id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00707v1 | Non-Exchangeable Conformal Language Generation with Nearest Neighbors | 2024-02-01T16:04:04 | 2024-02-01T16:04:04 | Dennis Ulmer, Chrysoula Zerva, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Quantifying uncertainty in automatically generated text is important for
letting humans check potential hallucinations and making systems more reliable.
Conformal prediction is an attractive framework to provide predictions imbued
with statistical guarantees, however, its application to text generation is
challenging since any i.i.d. assumptions are not realistic. In this paper, we
bridge this gap by leveraging recent results on non-exchangeable conformal
prediction, which still ensures bounds on coverage. The result,
non-exchangeable conformal nucleus sampling, is a novel extension of the
conformal prediction framework to generation based on nearest neighbors. Our
method can be used post-hoc for an arbitrary model without extra training and
supplies token-level, calibrated prediction sets equipped with statistical
guarantees. Experiments in machine translation and language modeling show
encouraging results in generation quality. By also producing tighter prediction
sets with good coverage, we thus give a more theoretically principled way to
perform sampling with conformal guarantees. | [
-0.33368465304374695,
-0.4088776111602783,
0.7083070874214172,
-0.056135453283786774,
0.04214765504002571,
-0.36587396264076233,
-0.3212219774723053,
-0.6602932810783386,
0.2806502878665924,
0.38512322306632996,
-0.5589365363121033,
-0.3217277228832245,
-0.6055974364280701,
0.31487590074539185,
-0.3772798180580139,
0.7064458131790161,
0.15850183367729187,
-0.0661550760269165,
-0.347561240196228,
0.048506032675504684,
-0.037461671978235245,
-0.31333109736442566,
-0.16127099096775055,
-0.13981682062149048,
0.032342929393053055,
0.5104692578315735,
0.821320116519928,
0.47722506523132324,
0.12536665797233582,
0.30193036794662476,
-0.0725293755531311,
0.04256587475538254,
-0.39512550830841064,
0.11512371152639389,
0.10126437991857529,
-0.6538019776344299,
-0.3574782609939575,
-0.14797565340995789,
0.7794337868690491,
0.7297378778457642,
-0.17150093615055084,
-0.05680406093597412,
-0.3033847510814667,
0.9902361631393433,
-0.4267524778842926,
0.025358200073242188,
-1.036814570426941,
-0.011359105817973614,
-0.356158047914505,
0.19585829973220825,
-0.5943783521652222,
-0.7698146104812622,
0.11869045346975327,
-0.6477766633033752,
0.5481013655662537,
0.011642247438430786,
0.6721965670585632,
0.12031770497560501,
-0.1314222514629364,
-0.15709646046161652,
-0.6085468530654907,
0.8916674852371216,
-0.770793616771698,
0.4909224808216095,
0.9349299073219299,
0.4841308295726776,
-0.5259954929351807,
-0.6330059766769409,
-0.7453379034996033,
-0.34660956263542175,
0.15284204483032227,
0.026089562103152275,
-0.3756817579269409,
-0.10586971789598465,
-0.011839363723993301,
0.35978367924690247,
-0.5425955057144165,
-0.3349255621433258,
-0.6977944374084473,
-0.15578797459602356,
0.5185391902923584,
-0.11459584534168243,
0.19726070761680603,
-0.14322341978549957,
-0.058690182864665985,
-0.21836788952350616,
-0.7495639324188232,
-0.03968832269310951,
0.6779047846794128,
0.46619755029678345,
-0.22697119414806366,
0.6683091521263123,
-0.4667354226112366,
0.8856487274169922,
0.43999990820884705,
0.48979461193084717,
0.39293670654296875,
-0.28214898705482483,
-0.06748457252979279,
-0.02327839285135269,
0.8305255770683289,
0.26930686831474304,
0.3690127432346344,
-0.2686866819858551,
-0.24696311354637146,
-0.05833137407898903,
0.3288474977016449,
-0.6829962730407715,
-0.5608742237091064,
0.23011548817157745,
-0.5352922677993774,
-0.6184294819831848,
0.17080558836460114,
-1.0609396696090698,
0.09562376886606216,
0.03657057508826256,
-0.03682562708854675,
-0.6590651869773865,
-0.4860495626926422,
-0.15506528317928314,
-0.07419842481613159,
-0.21382366120815277,
-0.0167292021214962,
-1.0066206455230713,
0.07126107811927795,
0.23882868885993958,
0.838579535484314,
-0.14010605216026306,
-0.12093961983919144,
-0.2464597523212433,
0.25685444474220276,
-0.5895575881004333,
1.1165258884429932,
-0.8067401647567749,
-0.4439968764781952,
0.07270847260951996,
-0.2545279562473297,
0.21829183399677277,
-0.634604275226593,
0.01443399302661419,
-0.46324706077575684,
0.07944527268409729,
-0.04526349902153015,
-0.6251355409622192,
0.18106485903263092,
0.08060953766107559,
-0.8808805346488953,
0.8565201163291931,
0.6708369851112366,
-0.662563681602478,
0.29623332619667053,
-0.16633564233779907,
-0.30930158495903015,
-0.026911316439509392,
-0.1713201254606247,
-0.7858718037605286,
0.30125027894973755,
-0.02887490577995777,
0.15932705998420715,
-0.07150312513113022,
-0.013834815472364426,
-0.5623825192451477,
-0.121078722178936,
0.47968053817749023,
-0.03511165827512741,
0.14058849215507507,
0.33841848373413086,
-0.41606032848358154,
0.06549341976642609,
-0.7725921273231506,
0.5504922866821289,
-0.21460877358913422,
-0.07122692465782166,
-0.060861799865961075,
-0.27414992451667786,
0.1874360740184784,
0.1361987143754959,
0.2682340145111084,
-0.633563220500946,
-0.07647048681974411,
-0.7455097436904907,
0.6073872447013855,
0.8051514029502869,
0.07731674611568451,
0.9249212145805359,
-0.6851526498794556,
0.621256947517395,
0.006953870411962271,
-0.0543447807431221,
0.1271323561668396,
-0.6814064979553223,
-0.1506698876619339,
0.0412517786026001,
0.35547804832458496,
0.06472909450531006,
-0.8781108260154724,
0.32968658208847046,
-0.16758832335472107,
-0.8829489350318909,
-0.23547053337097168,
-0.08824684470891953,
0.42517992854118347,
0.23466119170188904,
0.36630570888519287,
0.39284276962280273,
-0.48289406299591064,
-0.8891765475273132,
-0.1083982065320015,
-0.4625784158706665,
-0.16067083179950714,
0.12851455807685852,
0.0748259499669075,
-0.37465980648994446,
1.0458471775054932,
-0.43041834235191345,
-0.17137394845485687,
-0.3418559432029724,
0.13895802199840546,
0.05586312338709831,
0.47460243105888367,
0.43922844529151917,
-0.8218860626220703,
-0.683749258518219,
0.004905776586383581,
-0.4845680296421051,
-0.16318058967590332,
-0.12579065561294556,
-0.2271679937839508,
0.5431212782859802,
0.6799278855323792,
-0.1748010516166687,
0.3317863643169403,
1.0322588682174683,
-0.010835864581167698,
0.3550609350204468,
-0.3111421465873718,
-0.1325598657131195,
-1.2271076440811157,
0.001751494244672358,
0.02738959528505802,
-0.2974169850349426,
-0.7640742659568787,
-0.30285152792930603,
0.1760787069797516,
0.15866026282310486,
-0.2177290916442871,
0.5922903418540955,
-0.3696031868457794,
-0.04649129882454872,
-0.6178564429283142,
0.13212774693965912,
-0.36564183235168457,
0.11469797790050507,
0.5679245591163635,
0.9109594225883484,
0.36415740847587585,
-0.6609843969345093,
-0.30040886998176575,
0.5117732882499695,
-0.23133507370948792,
0.5987200736999512,
-0.4136907160282135,
-0.039455920457839966,
-0.11671262234449387,
0.37677001953125,
-0.7470403909683228,
-0.17740926146507263,
-0.10941080749034882,
-0.7913258671760559,
0.17923827469348907,
0.21025332808494568,
-0.18998143076896667,
-0.12811286747455597,
-0.06649008393287659,
0.5950496196746826,
0.8447482585906982,
-0.4716627597808838,
0.17812874913215637,
0.5759760737419128,
-0.13310743868350983,
-0.226734921336174,
-0.6837289929389954,
-0.1660318672657013,
0.030439814552664757,
-0.5024259090423584,
0.12064385414123535,
-0.23840557038784027,
-0.13666492700576782,
-0.08441110700368881,
-0.11107480525970459,
-0.3590177893638611,
-0.30774739384651184,
0.35451510548591614,
0.16666607558727264,
-0.08385490626096725,
-0.10721789300441742,
0.2280554324388504,
-0.359231173992157,
-0.005879676900804043,
-0.4427158832550049,
0.2679429352283478,
-0.27401307225227356,
-0.07320120185613632,
-0.2588196098804474,
0.2536994516849518,
0.2729087769985199,
0.14266233146190643,
0.5221739411354065,
0.0483274981379509,
-0.5932828187942505,
-0.3178119659423828,
-0.35994842648506165,
-0.2416590005159378,
-0.4958505630493164,
0.18282809853553772,
-0.45226144790649414,
-0.6114400029182434,
0.3266555964946747,
0.045896243304014206,
-0.06097251921892166,
0.45113280415534973,
0.5387250781059265,
0.09950236231088638,
0.5983859896659851,
0.5859649777412415,
0.2825428545475006,
0.47515320777893066,
0.04164186120033264,
0.08537372946739197,
-0.8066251277923584,
-0.09141623228788376,
-0.5061445236206055,
-0.007163988891988993,
-0.7756035923957825,
-0.613142728805542,
0.30633461475372314,
0.1240537092089653,
0.2395758479833603,
0.5828253626823425,
-0.6259703040122986,
0.46558406949043274,
0.6390030980110168,
-0.04279113933444023,
0.22400426864624023,
-0.07077118754386902,
0.007884358055889606,
-0.2640281915664673,
-0.48835378885269165,
-0.525772750377655,
1.2180427312850952,
-0.0452873632311821,
0.5407071113586426,
0.009526721201837063,
0.8870585560798645,
0.12635135650634766,
0.6030716300010681,
-0.21706925332546234,
0.48044487833976746,
0.029969515278935432,
-0.4499102532863617,
-0.5342490077018738,
-0.7586553692817688,
-1.0134007930755615,
-0.16827292740345,
-0.2805805802345276,
-0.6566798090934753,
0.20356611907482147,
0.26232966780662537,
-0.02955133467912674,
0.5381085276603699,
-0.24204400181770325,
0.23828621208667755,
0.6296291351318359,
0.03455175459384918,
0.07330993562936783,
-0.6759851574897766,
0.29051098227500916,
-0.5308735966682434,
0.2550186812877655,
-0.012796679511666298,
0.27434903383255005,
0.29017481207847595,
-0.4809057116508484,
0.6057020425796509,
-0.12126662582159042,
-0.06602880358695984,
0.5725491642951965,
0.3833349049091339,
0.5598874092102051,
0.04266267642378807,
-0.5716232061386108,
0.499990314245224,
0.2966812551021576,
-0.4082699120044708,
-0.23500631749629974,
0.5740304589271545,
-0.7287288904190063,
-0.1014544740319252,
-0.39179566502571106,
-0.6061582565307617,
-0.31195956468582153,
0.29692837595939636,
0.9305676221847534,
0.0029092421755194664,
-0.3646482825279236,
-0.007927033118903637,
0.497670441865921,
-0.1620454490184784,
0.11596016585826874,
0.14849598705768585,
0.028510482981801033,
-0.7057483196258545,
1.0256106853485107,
-0.015327769331634045,
0.6958560943603516,
0.46326926350593567,
0.403737336397171,
-0.4978444576263428,
-0.6314354538917542,
-0.4767817258834839,
0.08353903144598007,
-0.3639570474624634,
-0.36511021852493286,
-0.6266522407531738,
-0.2087264060974121,
-0.7536954283714294,
-0.6320436596870422,
-0.48475709557533264,
-0.7162597179412842,
0.04253051057457924,
-0.14114782214164734,
0.303605854511261,
1.0783767700195312,
-0.6045340299606323,
0.29352331161499023,
-0.9996979832649231,
0.4110042154788971,
-0.13118630647659302,
0.2812459468841553,
-0.08922775089740753,
-0.23560231924057007,
-0.16834259033203125,
0.2958909273147583,
-0.2069130688905716,
-1.0019620656967163,
0.3489384353160858,
0.07000863552093506,
0.5056173205375671,
0.19504383206367493,
0.49285489320755005,
0.49901923537254333,
-0.6825476884841919,
0.7333370447158813,
0.26646482944488525,
-0.9608282446861267,
0.5991593599319458,
-0.4530658721923828,
0.18970957398414612,
0.8281219005584717,
-0.023620817810297012,
-0.4573312997817993,
-1.2346471548080444,
-1.0387581586837769,
-0.7902616262435913,
0.6268616914749146,
0.7018385529518127,
0.16185863316059113,
-0.43532758951187134,
0.6069688200950623,
0.212639719247818,
0.2439587563276291,
-0.8093940019607544,
-0.1706307977437973,
-0.39399614930152893,
-0.27761274576187134,
0.07593285292387009,
-0.05549832433462143,
0.2574440836906433,
0.19113689661026,
0.915642499923706,
-0.18597358465194702,
0.4416573643684387,
0.3093375861644745,
0.17897672951221466,
-0.7060076594352722,
0.022764498367905617,
0.9264385104179382,
0.5273590683937073,
-0.28621622920036316,
-0.017876282334327698,
0.1513451486825943,
-0.5052129030227661,
0.0827380046248436,
-0.24939292669296265,
-0.3106140196323395,
0.246717169880867,
-0.040829092264175415,
0.1777976006269455,
-0.164615660905838,
-0.7112814784049988,
0.5980217456817627,
-0.19697122275829315,
-0.48107853531837463,
-0.7111636400222778,
-0.08133035153150558,
0.0011934031499549747,
0.20982755720615387,
-0.016972072422504425,
0.16258861124515533,
-0.02385260909795761,
0.023216020315885544,
0.8257604837417603,
0.5658487677574158,
-0.6697356104850769,
-0.6365223526954651,
0.8298295736312866,
-0.11600328236818314,
-0.20757277309894562,
0.5507395267486572,
-0.39329057931900024,
-0.07860647141933441,
0.720832884311676,
0.8935941457748413,
0.8321200609207153,
-0.35643598437309265,
0.2921730875968933,
0.804230272769928,
0.3141418993473053,
-0.19270187616348267,
0.22348900139331818,
0.06161386892199516,
-0.5836567282676697,
0.1373748779296875,
-0.609443187713623,
-0.5879413485527039,
0.09450172632932663,
-0.8555062413215637,
0.172529935836792,
-0.41737011075019836,
-0.1306653916835785,
-0.3116298317909241,
-0.35559847950935364,
0.050759896636009216,
0.08486268669366837,
0.05125749856233597,
0.9223569631576538,
-0.8552097082138062,
0.9410187602043152,
0.5404075384140015,
-0.049098700284957886,
-0.5374161005020142,
0.4521220028400421,
-0.24120938777923584,
-0.5855827927589417,
0.5399436950683594,
0.1301630288362503,
-0.13645687699317932,
-0.24232551455497742,
-0.29024091362953186,
-1.0194274187088013,
0.8218730688095093,
0.25786417722702026,
-0.46942439675331116,
-0.054519832134246826,
0.3284849226474762,
0.4883072078227997,
-0.10403819382190704,
0.13081185519695282,
0.2009805142879486,
0.6707225441932678,
0.5105273723602295,
-0.5410448312759399,
0.20762456953525543,
-0.2609345018863678,
0.21368086338043213,
0.5743952989578247,
-0.5078014731407166,
0.8342443704605103,
-0.34979352355003357,
-0.19702088832855225,
0.6647869348526001,
1.2683149576187134,
0.592905580997467,
0.3275906443595886,
0.5966923832893372,
0.3432791531085968,
0.8549800515174866,
0.24683301150798798,
1.1086828708648682,
-0.6146425604820251,
0.15367025136947632,
1.206705093383789,
-0.2707269489765167,
0.9022074341773987,
0.5333102941513062,
-0.05705410987138748,
0.34281936287879944,
0.5972030758857727,
-0.0049414001405239105,
0.662704586982727,
0.3587777614593506,
-0.27899953722953796,
-0.2234419733285904,
0.20605315268039703,
-0.5802481770515442,
0.0820179134607315,
0.22440923750400543,
-0.17244519293308258,
-0.351308673620224,
-0.236954465508461,
-0.1873089224100113,
0.6261032223701477,
0.044640470296144485,
0.7231526970863342,
0.04293815419077873,
-0.6919314861297607,
0.4144876003265381,
0.049898870289325714,
0.6152143478393555,
-0.4361562728881836,
-0.15994952619075775,
0.008323879912495613,
0.09444265067577362,
-0.16653071343898773,
-0.6183695197105408,
0.6997768878936768,
-0.3138993978500366,
-0.3772696554660797,
-0.2528466284275055,
0.40800192952156067,
-0.53511643409729,
-0.5737565755844116,
-0.028877174481749535,
0.2629031538963318,
0.32809576392173767,
-0.008661167696118355,
-0.21531444787979126,
-0.5004264712333679,
0.1303139328956604,
-0.14657557010650635,
0.42450010776519775,
0.7239335775375366,
-0.15394970774650574,
0.3331626355648041,
0.8437188863754272,
0.5520741939544678,
0.23927611112594604,
-0.5151678323745728,
0.601606547832489,
-0.58050137758255,
-0.6621311902999878,
-0.6440414190292358,
-0.0005666324286721647,
0.2625514268875122,
-0.30798786878585815,
0.5040813088417053,
0.589124321937561,
0.7906079292297363,
-0.06393317878246307,
0.9449828267097473,
0.036307286471128464,
0.3981209397315979,
-0.4626576900482178,
0.7661404609680176,
-0.24179312586784363,
-0.20473039150238037,
-0.1758161187171936,
-1.0101631879806519,
-0.11346156150102615,
0.8943088054656982,
-0.12848058342933655,
0.10582645982503891,
0.8339151740074158,
0.6952953338623047,
0.07469920068979263,
0.4065277576446533,
0.6017197370529175,
0.07349035143852234,
0.3183422386646271,
0.6398105621337891,
0.6717599034309387,
-0.4454796016216278,
0.5073644518852234,
-0.39475318789482117,
-0.22511543333530426,
0.1224483922123909,
-0.9088147878646851,
-0.8234660029411316,
-0.9705231189727783,
-0.06327913701534271,
-0.8413528203964233,
-0.31157386302948,
0.7311453223228455,
0.6866157054901123,
-0.7261295914649963,
-0.18229307234287262,
-0.6264960169792175,
-0.06550641357898712,
-0.06121889874339104,
-0.2256198227405548,
0.14180326461791992,
-0.4763163626194,
-1.1551754474639893,
0.3282342553138733,
0.02037093974649906,
0.4619370102882385,
-0.05730946362018585,
-0.08303158730268478,
0.1594342440366745,
0.2904612720012665,
0.09367269277572632,
0.44655245542526245,
-0.38496556878089905,
-0.13137178122997284,
-0.010301515460014343,
-0.27522945404052734,
0.1317022144794464,
0.6603299975395203,
-0.7817868590354919,
0.30733922123908997,
0.5545473098754883,
0.5046759247779846,
0.37029609084129333,
-0.054982542991638184,
0.963128924369812,
-0.8114997148513794,
0.31224822998046875,
0.20225340127944946,
0.07894854247570038,
0.12477952241897583,
-0.6453585624694824,
0.3034747242927551,
-0.12121959775686264,
-0.6087272763252258,
-0.91566401720047,
0.7029080390930176,
-0.818077564239502,
-0.29927995800971985,
1.3386789560317993,
-0.03616427630186081,
-0.504883348941803,
-0.14590324461460114,
0.29887625575065613,
0.14383052289485931,
-0.5978121161460876,
1.0073184967041016,
0.6076608300209045,
-0.16223134100437164,
0.2919063866138458,
-0.5372002720832825,
0.7411941289901733,
0.5171505808830261,
-0.9775499105453491,
0.28976136445999146,
0.45151829719543457,
0.2086750715970993,
0.31708261370658875,
1.0305685997009277,
-0.3127208948135376,
0.2625580430030823,
-0.0491090752184391,
0.13564158976078033,
-0.07006926089525223,
-0.19963578879833221,
-0.23819920420646667,
-0.010437090881168842,
0.008084049448370934,
0.03585214540362358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01777v1 | On the Psychology of GPT-4: Moderately anxious, slightly masculine, honest, and humble | 2024-02-01T15:58:13 | 2024-02-01T15:58:13 | Adrita Barua, Gary Brase, Ke Dong, Pascal Hitzler, Eugene Vasserman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | We subject GPT-4 to a number of rigorous psychometric tests and analyze the
results. We find that, compared to the average human, GPT-4 tends to show more
honesty and humility, and less machiavellianism and narcissism. It sometimes
exhibits ambivalent sexism, leans slightly toward masculinity, is moderately
anxious but mostly not depressive (but not always). It shows human-average
numerical literacy and has cognitive reflection abilities that are above human
average for verbal tasks. | [
-0.6586143374443054,
-0.7599346041679382,
0.8062509298324585,
0.24991685152053833,
0.015469235368072987,
0.2481551319360733,
-0.20933948457241058,
-0.5482237339019775,
0.05029144138097763,
-0.5114784836769104,
-0.5849423408508301,
-0.33038702607154846,
-0.7184680104255676,
0.44809579849243164,
0.1674286276102066,
1.2476091384887695,
0.07461843639612198,
0.19087763130664825,
0.4799210727214813,
0.10861755162477493,
-0.4441709518432617,
-0.9357998371124268,
-0.6955068707466125,
-0.54923415184021,
0.4449193775653839,
0.05695272237062454,
1.0083982944488525,
0.05087696388363838,
0.5999828577041626,
0.3692739009857178,
0.23144082725048065,
-0.6687106490135193,
-0.6280348300933838,
0.018794622272253036,
-0.4212532639503479,
-0.512249767780304,
-0.8720244765281677,
0.7715963125228882,
0.2660425901412964,
0.29899436235427856,
-0.01573987677693367,
0.10637672990560532,
0.17249244451522827,
0.5005467534065247,
0.09933015704154968,
0.5094217658042908,
-0.028632521629333496,
0.10430396348237991,
-0.34179621934890747,
-0.05557756498456001,
0.13416048884391785,
-0.6229726672172546,
0.3540041744709015,
-0.9185597896575928,
0.577243447303772,
-0.005907667800784111,
0.8943035006523132,
-0.21996575593948364,
-0.6148840188980103,
-0.24138450622558594,
-0.43102678656578064,
0.859459400177002,
-0.1743587702512741,
0.3601740896701813,
0.8679715394973755,
0.02900475449860096,
0.21609747409820557,
-0.5806850790977478,
-0.3045884668827057,
-0.2929573357105255,
-0.2793068289756775,
0.3685922920703888,
-0.27921009063720703,
0.18171770870685577,
0.3434445858001709,
0.6405155062675476,
-0.8610721230506897,
-0.3243483304977417,
-0.40301868319511414,
-0.3475845456123352,
0.38946712017059326,
0.12105172127485275,
0.20539623498916626,
-0.02195410430431366,
-0.2186112105846405,
0.23086437582969666,
-0.16670848429203033,
0.25986248254776,
0.7474112510681152,
-0.06125621497631073,
0.040513310581445694,
0.24007205665111542,
-0.02375689335167408,
0.1575414091348648,
0.5459655523300171,
-0.15659834444522858,
0.5249436497688293,
-0.6694028973579407,
0.08269302546977997,
-0.24725747108459473,
0.49007314443588257,
0.6786849498748779,
0.32481297850608826,
-0.09722913056612015,
-0.3204750716686249,
0.4171472191810608,
0.6281053423881531,
-0.9272772073745728,
-0.4561833143234253,
-0.13238537311553955,
-0.5233620405197144,
-0.30770260095596313,
-0.0033253049477934837,
-0.6023678183555603,
0.08693231642246246,
-0.3534761965274811,
0.2638714015483856,
-0.5769147872924805,
-0.19612492620944977,
-0.2945137619972229,
-0.3240043520927429,
0.6190476417541504,
0.3246215581893921,
-1.2018579244613647,
0.7031683325767517,
0.5954806804656982,
0.9681470394134521,
-0.33269399404525757,
-0.15132208168506622,
0.06687405705451965,
-0.20476464927196503,
-0.5036633610725403,
0.6946994662284851,
-0.6242014169692993,
-0.5447775721549988,
-0.5473909974098206,
0.17119112610816956,
-0.10658445209264755,
-0.037362102419137955,
1.0097160339355469,
-0.1554679423570633,
0.48575112223625183,
-1.0277148485183716,
-0.08428294956684113,
-0.36360180377960205,
0.8301010727882385,
-0.3728373944759369,
1.075052261352539,
0.7170314788818359,
-0.814659059047699,
0.5204889178276062,
-0.6957135200500488,
0.042084451764822006,
-0.02538228966295719,
-0.5255677103996277,
-0.07086513936519623,
0.09737996011972427,
0.020116373896598816,
0.23091398179531097,
-0.18094687163829803,
-0.12835969030857086,
-0.4069676101207733,
-0.7342000007629395,
0.4534780979156494,
-0.3344942331314087,
0.3188576400279999,
0.25719374418258667,
-0.4796048104763031,
-0.25995340943336487,
-0.12717066705226898,
0.3957979083061218,
-0.07446607202291489,
-0.25131407380104065,
-0.0956277996301651,
-0.5429662466049194,
-0.17986297607421875,
0.29196226596832275,
0.5277054309844971,
-0.7157805562019348,
0.4160314202308655,
-0.20631667971611023,
0.329626202583313,
0.845318615436554,
0.2741033434867859,
0.4308384656906128,
-0.4438732862472534,
0.8826879858970642,
-0.13832001388072968,
0.3758339285850525,
0.6355559825897217,
-0.9793304800987244,
-0.20753571391105652,
-0.44995951652526855,
-0.05993063375353813,
0.6095834970474243,
-0.4765152037143707,
0.27623721957206726,
0.07597069442272186,
-0.47942253947257996,
-0.22958487272262573,
0.24457533657550812,
0.631619930267334,
0.5264392495155334,
0.014965538866817951,
-0.5821096301078796,
-0.1938633769750595,
-1.234966516494751,
-0.6186656951904297,
-0.14576837420463562,
-0.19257032871246338,
0.13784751296043396,
0.6198652386665344,
-0.26225823163986206,
0.4523908197879791,
-0.5679751038551331,
-0.41724514961242676,
-0.0687914714217186,
0.43726250529289246,
0.5516369938850403,
0.2097581923007965,
0.7614601254463196,
-0.7857033610343933,
-0.16691704094409943,
-0.15738871693611145,
-0.7802123427391052,
0.03466686233878136,
0.47537633776664734,
-0.20108604431152344,
-0.16143395006656647,
0.08336315304040909,
-0.7474370002746582,
0.3702623248100281,
0.12400922179222107,
-0.7378808259963989,
0.3964545428752899,
-0.3016771376132965,
0.5563596487045288,
-0.4026675820350647,
-0.18059083819389343,
0.04490209370851517,
0.020599650219082832,
-0.7407243847846985,
-0.1383609026670456,
-0.1403600126504898,
-0.084651418030262,
-0.03465363383293152,
0.07728590071201324,
-0.4842383563518524,
-0.3800453543663025,
0.16986943781375885,
0.10274676978588104,
0.014442665502429008,
0.6254472732543945,
0.000236518622841686,
0.908460795879364,
0.5638963580131531,
-0.4277302920818329,
0.38398444652557373,
0.2688598036766052,
0.32919058203697205,
0.9254343509674072,
-0.7187535166740417,
0.4956877827644348,
-0.16181227564811707,
0.16273625195026398,
-0.9262630343437195,
-0.6359624862670898,
0.09917885810136795,
-0.5256279110908508,
0.263914555311203,
0.27330416440963745,
-0.08325040340423584,
-0.48097705841064453,
-0.9451139569282532,
0.4357665181159973,
0.6286669969558716,
0.14033271372318268,
0.4730547070503235,
-0.08173949271440506,
-0.667579710483551,
-0.15033283829689026,
-0.7835264205932617,
-0.028639672324061394,
-0.3156370520591736,
-0.3321031332015991,
0.38996490836143494,
-0.3107593059539795,
-0.2796970009803772,
-0.21245479583740234,
-0.08674635738134384,
-0.40592679381370544,
-0.11662676930427551,
0.05402839183807373,
0.12897710502147675,
-0.13463108241558075,
-0.14009623229503632,
-0.22218090295791626,
-0.31330710649490356,
0.30079948902130127,
0.3036298155784607,
0.3180067241191864,
-1.2501144409179688,
-0.08885618299245834,
-0.6198465824127197,
0.31354087591171265,
0.4004555940628052,
0.11190903931856155,
0.04802142456173897,
0.8716103434562683,
-0.25796079635620117,
0.6074989438056946,
-0.09628794342279434,
-0.6003479957580566,
-0.43822354078292847,
0.3467184603214264,
-0.8774059414863586,
-0.4890536069869995,
0.7128576040267944,
0.36654040217399597,
-0.26855432987213135,
0.4354232847690582,
0.8546238541603088,
-0.256093293428421,
1.0557299852371216,
0.36728110909461975,
0.16151423752307892,
0.21991431713104248,
-0.07733981311321259,
0.2747635841369629,
-0.5610703229904175,
0.06296822428703308,
-0.36529454588890076,
-0.7340869903564453,
-1.1432839632034302,
-0.036037277430295944,
0.35503461956977844,
-0.4742904603481293,
-0.8169698715209961,
-0.3251538872718811,
-0.7383348345756531,
0.4248393774032593,
0.6432194709777832,
0.23359695076942444,
0.20980681478977203,
-0.644245445728302,
0.49119409918785095,
-0.6562888026237488,
0.0644925907254219,
-0.7959452867507935,
1.1750837564468384,
0.4879903197288513,
0.6479532718658447,
0.8118047714233398,
0.4734433591365814,
0.1754326969385147,
0.5877478122711182,
-0.6077561974525452,
0.41410183906555176,
0.16786721348762512,
-1.291187047958374,
-0.29835304617881775,
-0.3126436769962311,
-0.7556677460670471,
0.0985565334558487,
0.005487792193889618,
-0.8202275037765503,
0.16946718096733093,
0.17992420494556427,
-0.36499735713005066,
-0.2865144610404968,
-0.9384797811508179,
0.7138385772705078,
-0.28704363107681274,
-0.2503937780857086,
0.4764467775821686,
-0.9925037026405334,
0.9053373336791992,
-0.3475506007671356,
0.1489778459072113,
-0.12642373144626617,
-0.4259183406829834,
0.47926196455955505,
0.05143359303474426,
0.6264998316764832,
-0.35916587710380554,
0.0780869573354721,
0.08693263679742813,
0.2664729654788971,
0.34900546073913574,
0.27319321036338806,
-0.09502211958169937,
-0.023488426581025124,
-0.04783852398395538,
-0.6003497242927551,
-0.7579583525657654,
0.6687071323394775,
-1.2643215656280518,
-0.3276499807834625,
-1.03426992893219,
-0.5476870536804199,
-0.4789663553237915,
0.18424548208713531,
0.6556370854377747,
0.4520551860332489,
-0.4885779917240143,
-0.040683452039957047,
0.6861168742179871,
-0.09733675420284271,
0.4476919174194336,
0.19339218735694885,
-0.39362525939941406,
-0.4693319797515869,
0.5167453289031982,
0.18616168200969696,
0.4102611243724823,
-0.12716875970363617,
0.39806175231933594,
-0.6366620659828186,
-0.3075641691684723,
-0.2840707302093506,
0.29727664589881897,
-0.45013898611068726,
0.09378556162118912,
-0.4967096745967865,
0.07675975561141968,
-0.39945101737976074,
-0.2531571686267853,
-0.4308144748210907,
-0.3223903775215149,
-0.009471198543906212,
-0.5243974328041077,
0.41671234369277954,
0.7575754523277283,
0.26761966943740845,
0.22053055465221405,
-0.26034465432167053,
0.5406513214111328,
0.5571772456169128,
0.43227624893188477,
-0.8027247190475464,
-0.6796084046363831,
0.46040624380111694,
-0.2841750979423523,
-0.7927582263946533,
-0.80149906873703,
0.15619294345378876,
0.40490734577178955,
0.19653035700321198,
0.8039489388465881,
-0.08502034842967987,
0.5530953407287598,
-0.08624953776597977,
1.1330151557922363,
0.16338373720645905,
-0.9376648664474487,
0.011855273507535458,
-0.9120622277259827,
0.011954226531088352,
0.8321129083633423,
0.5016152858734131,
-0.027472788468003273,
-0.5331345200538635,
-0.8628442883491516,
-0.27064037322998047,
0.5871132612228394,
0.9332373142242432,
0.24406246840953827,
0.06265062093734741,
0.6647353172302246,
0.23485738039016724,
0.3537857234477997,
-1.2541592121124268,
-0.38778820633888245,
-0.9844182729721069,
-0.10874229669570923,
-0.3266170620918274,
-0.10120440274477005,
-0.3827165365219116,
-0.5836401581764221,
0.30178916454315186,
0.03374712914228439,
1.006714940071106,
0.2208566814661026,
0.33570224046707153,
0.21215856075286865,
0.5225023627281189,
0.8728896975517273,
0.6523323655128479,
-0.874387800693512,
0.5393403768539429,
0.25353291630744934,
-1.0441843271255493,
0.7472312450408936,
0.20003671944141388,
0.2539638876914978,
-0.05696181580424309,
0.4291071891784668,
0.2506198585033417,
-0.025259798392653465,
0.12597711384296417,
0.8749610185623169,
-0.3873562216758728,
-0.5228772163391113,
-0.38162437081336975,
0.09751133620738983,
0.08991576731204987,
0.24095933139324188,
0.27225229144096375,
-0.018463803455233574,
0.6279488205909729,
-1.1930534839630127,
0.04453947767615318,
0.12867514789104462,
-0.4589427411556244,
-0.9968337416648865,
0.631379246711731,
0.3744948208332062,
-0.3496687114238739,
0.5258535146713257,
-1.047706127166748,
-0.8129777312278748,
-0.012151481583714485,
0.5826802253723145,
0.712339460849762,
-0.27734270691871643,
0.1454344242811203,
0.24761554598808289,
0.5857385396957397,
-0.10583077371120453,
0.9184089303016663,
0.17873306572437286,
-0.7276155352592468,
0.022235296666622162,
-0.3801741600036621,
-0.4274473190307617,
-0.010956990532577038,
-0.7921706438064575,
-0.1207006573677063,
-0.560661256313324,
-0.965595543384552,
-0.43463823199272156,
0.4201687276363373,
-0.8462438583374023,
0.5750709772109985,
-0.14818382263183594,
0.28586599230766296,
-0.8670588731765747,
0.6641261577606201,
0.9116507172584534,
-0.42446091771125793,
-1.0701295137405396,
-0.05839390307664871,
0.28420689702033997,
-0.654840886592865,
0.9017816185951233,
0.3515152633190155,
-0.18870145082473755,
-0.11175543814897537,
-0.17930765450000763,
-0.7451744675636292,
1.2075756788253784,
0.5547105073928833,
-0.07713920623064041,
-0.2984430491924286,
-0.28223302960395813,
0.7650430798530579,
-0.025644216686487198,
0.5863171219825745,
1.012626051902771,
0.893047034740448,
-0.3249472677707672,
-0.9355964660644531,
0.060995686799287796,
-0.43451982736587524,
-0.072853222489357,
0.1739557832479477,
-0.7906721234321594,
1.234846830368042,
-0.09485869109630585,
0.06685076653957367,
-0.2107096016407013,
0.368495374917984,
0.43962618708610535,
0.5824235081672668,
0.4023016393184662,
0.3841572701931,
0.8991416692733765,
-0.3172900676727295,
1.312949776649475,
-0.11877463012933731,
0.26190829277038574,
0.6202080249786377,
-0.17996864020824432,
0.031495124101638794,
0.3641003370285034,
-0.379383385181427,
0.3283853828907013,
0.8533185124397278,
0.3631436824798584,
0.6245575547218323,
-0.04812559485435486,
-0.2945399284362793,
0.2436331808567047,
0.4237649440765381,
-0.34939688444137573,
0.7784973382949829,
0.09280351549386978,
-0.21860256791114807,
0.05510964244604111,
-0.1064487174153328,
0.31499168276786804,
-0.2709192633628845,
-0.3264314830303192,
0.22111742198467255,
0.25714489817619324,
-0.3859744668006897,
0.394052118062973,
-0.13893872499465942,
0.44989877939224243,
-0.47784894704818726,
0.1793729066848755,
-0.22041089832782745,
0.23302647471427917,
-0.16135667264461517,
-0.8845205903053284,
0.27675890922546387,
0.08080635219812393,
-0.26054146885871887,
-0.5771209001541138,
0.7421465516090393,
0.09063747525215149,
-0.11000651866197586,
0.04525642469525337,
0.52753084897995,
0.5924136638641357,
-0.3167935013771057,
-0.7687902450561523,
-0.227772057056427,
0.12964656949043274,
-0.8520950078964233,
0.3238777816295624,
0.7071414589881897,
-0.08144959807395935,
0.5646005272865295,
0.4287737309932709,
-0.026785917580127716,
-0.19246543943881989,
-0.1329360157251358,
0.464629203081131,
-1.0348554849624634,
-0.5886315107345581,
-0.8183081746101379,
0.06021307408809662,
-0.21248061954975128,
-0.7423401474952698,
0.8842189908027649,
0.4030286967754364,
0.1147163137793541,
-0.1337224692106247,
0.5417927503585815,
-0.06886821240186691,
0.5053873658180237,
-0.3741217255592346,
0.42983686923980713,
0.04750175029039383,
-0.111425019800663,
-0.6563006043434143,
-1.2678587436676025,
-0.04977666214108467,
0.9007390141487122,
-0.49831071496009827,
0.6574245095252991,
1.0430234670639038,
0.5618054866790771,
-0.05408572033047676,
0.3962714970111847,
0.3979281783103943,
0.30515795946121216,
0.3962319791316986,
0.5209441184997559,
0.8519184589385986,
0.012569182552397251,
0.2131599336862564,
-0.14923810958862305,
-0.5812321305274963,
0.2401740700006485,
-0.740986704826355,
-0.8999588489532471,
-0.2229270190000534,
-0.051720015704631805,
-0.11101912707090378,
-0.07212091237306595,
0.6749442219734192,
0.4550860524177551,
0.01868485100567341,
0.1915736198425293,
0.07154287397861481,
-0.43220654129981995,
-0.2786039113998413,
-0.2033844143152237,
0.19567421078681946,
0.006718950811773539,
-0.6356611847877502,
-0.05865369737148285,
0.24584262073040009,
0.35290294885635376,
-0.09759814292192459,
-0.14446869492530823,
0.3749071955680847,
0.21156729757785797,
0.458372563123703,
-0.2304891049861908,
-0.48394617438316345,
-0.7809735536575317,
0.11891824752092361,
-0.17063845694065094,
0.12216190248727798,
0.5294563174247742,
-0.32981076836586,
0.19808590412139893,
0.04529275372624397,
0.11866813153028488,
0.5015740394592285,
0.5670843720436096,
0.6910925507545471,
-0.6598097085952759,
0.2243344485759735,
0.6561530232429504,
0.1743893027305603,
0.2246788740158081,
-0.5622203946113586,
0.6570438146591187,
0.44929563999176025,
-0.9221742749214172,
-0.6591105461120605,
0.3170989453792572,
-1.1544411182403564,
0.21111120283603668,
0.9082813262939453,
-0.2753920257091522,
0.02768649347126484,
-0.5724158883094788,
-0.4422272741794586,
-0.10877461731433868,
-0.7820966839790344,
0.45255857706069946,
1.090816617012024,
-0.8555371761322021,
0.09155750274658203,
-1.212959885597229,
0.7612378597259521,
0.041951876133680344,
-0.8081305027008057,
-0.26954251527786255,
0.2457563281059265,
0.565532386302948,
0.02163059078156948,
0.9457443356513977,
-0.23533912003040314,
0.4133807420730591,
0.14372241497039795,
0.05874505639076233,
0.32224521040916443,
0.2574200928211212,
-0.035461876541376114,
0.32105115056037903,
0.24489204585552216,
-0.18664678931236267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00667v1 | Improving Weak-to-Strong Generalization with Scalable Oversight and Ensemble Learning | 2024-02-01T15:30:19 | 2024-02-01T15:30:19 | Jitao Sang, Yuhang Wang, Jing Zhang, Yanxu Zhu, Chao Kong, Junhong Ye, Shuyu Wei, Jinlin Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a follow-up study to OpenAI's recent superalignment work
on Weak-to-Strong Generalization (W2SG). Superalignment focuses on ensuring
that high-level AI systems remain consistent with human values and intentions
when dealing with complex, high-risk tasks. The W2SG framework has opened new
possibilities for empirical research in this evolving field. Our study
simulates two phases of superalignment under the W2SG framework: the
development of general superhuman models and the progression towards
superintelligence. In the first phase, based on human supervision, the quality
of weak supervision is enhanced through a combination of scalable oversight and
ensemble learning, reducing the capability gap between weak teachers and strong
students. In the second phase, an automatic alignment evaluator is employed as
the weak supervisor. By recursively updating this auto aligner, the
capabilities of the weak teacher models are synchronously enhanced, achieving
weak-to-strong supervision over stronger student models.We also provide an
initial validation of the proposed approach for the first phase. Using the SciQ
task as example, we explore ensemble learning for weak teacher models through
bagging and boosting. Scalable oversight is explored through two auxiliary
settings: human-AI interaction and AI-AI debate. Additionally, the paper
discusses the impact of improved weak supervision on enhancing weak-to-strong
generalization based on in-context learning. Experiment code and dataset will
be released at https://github.com/ADaM-BJTU/W2SG. | [
-0.05968443676829338,
-0.2752342224121094,
0.12944315373897552,
-0.09070463478565216,
0.15310272574424744,
-0.2801935374736786,
-0.3862612545490265,
-0.6469485759735107,
-0.07005483657121658,
0.12469473481178284,
-0.26105836033821106,
-0.11586863547563553,
-0.7358400821685791,
-0.1601962447166443,
-0.36572396755218506,
1.3822240829467773,
-0.07533058524131775,
0.3871564269065857,
-0.3847886621952057,
-0.2504456639289856,
-0.4885335862636566,
-0.2203187495470047,
-0.47695907950401306,
-0.5435337424278259,
0.19541636109352112,
0.6298123002052307,
0.9373784065246582,
0.6514821648597717,
0.6957908868789673,
0.2666538655757904,
-0.041946787387132645,
0.12446223199367523,
-0.7877008318901062,
0.09531375765800476,
-0.520896852016449,
-0.6351838707923889,
-0.5083297491073608,
0.03142290934920311,
0.7907497882843018,
0.7310004830360413,
-0.21361581981182098,
0.10233671218156815,
0.33913305401802063,
0.31959429383277893,
-0.7858029007911682,
0.2032584398984909,
-0.35952484607696533,
-0.09550343453884125,
-0.1126679927110672,
0.3985905349254608,
-0.1164129450917244,
0.15877701342105865,
0.2345585972070694,
-0.7521485090255737,
0.3691084682941437,
0.08977676182985306,
1.0366615056991577,
0.6194635629653931,
-0.34899935126304626,
0.205919086933136,
-0.7939415574073792,
0.9588808417320251,
-0.3205908238887787,
0.2385684847831726,
0.5056278109550476,
0.2838015854358673,
-0.14169791340827942,
-0.7455533146858215,
-0.37659624218940735,
0.08352312445640564,
-0.18893441557884216,
0.48743629455566406,
-0.10133752226829529,
0.17561298608779907,
0.23466946184635162,
0.4631801247596741,
-0.40862005949020386,
0.4539543688297272,
-0.40494632720947266,
-0.062356188893318176,
0.6828873157501221,
0.09492679685354233,
0.04749869555234909,
0.21992214024066925,
-0.4162611961364746,
-0.2924557626247406,
-0.5201614499092102,
-0.03231877461075783,
0.4092053472995758,
0.08779721707105637,
-0.1875419318675995,
0.3038545548915863,
-0.23748818039894104,
0.2529749870300293,
0.3527102470397949,
0.2191258817911148,
0.0798809751868248,
-0.5558934807777405,
-0.13412606716156006,
-0.16538091003894806,
0.5726157426834106,
0.42357897758483887,
0.058166638016700745,
-0.30896928906440735,
-0.2783084213733673,
0.12543131411075592,
0.3743239641189575,
-0.43201714754104614,
-0.30536743998527527,
0.17217698693275452,
-0.4140242338180542,
-0.3640545904636383,
0.20480263233184814,
-0.6344082951545715,
-0.26574552059173584,
-0.5313329100608826,
0.4199357032775879,
-0.2555597424507141,
-0.2767234444618225,
-0.3191872537136078,
-0.17791087925434113,
0.38631370663642883,
0.2651248574256897,
-1.2444835901260376,
0.2827504873275757,
0.8758770823478699,
0.6018137335777283,
-0.07610219717025757,
-0.6747899651527405,
-0.39029809832572937,
0.3805927634239197,
-0.46315568685531616,
0.4858832359313965,
-0.5716042518615723,
-0.13252881169319153,
-0.20634059607982635,
-0.04291336238384247,
-0.07937201112508774,
-0.48018860816955566,
0.5304449200630188,
-0.36328524351119995,
0.4377250671386719,
-0.026310721412301064,
-0.41255003213882446,
0.11958947777748108,
0.10943207144737244,
-0.17432387173175812,
1.024890422821045,
0.370431125164032,
-0.5778731107711792,
0.6426874399185181,
-0.4392283260822296,
-0.39356860518455505,
0.099859319627285,
-0.2883940041065216,
-0.7438996434211731,
0.08115236461162567,
0.41162019968032837,
0.28807711601257324,
-0.16303713619709015,
0.44690683484077454,
-0.2909681499004364,
-0.7207409143447876,
-0.5011503100395203,
-0.053141433745622635,
0.6312994360923767,
-0.09551924467086792,
-0.5299323797225952,
0.43163710832595825,
-0.3617333173751831,
-0.006731776054948568,
-0.0428214892745018,
-0.06105997413396835,
-0.4053167402744293,
0.11749591678380966,
-0.1471787691116333,
-0.12235520035028458,
0.13981813192367554,
-0.16718167066574097,
0.534805178642273,
-0.545513391494751,
0.436370849609375,
0.9065590500831604,
-0.11581229418516159,
0.7461241483688354,
-0.20444664359092712,
0.1801544725894928,
-0.1012926772236824,
0.21277429163455963,
-0.05342595651745796,
-0.38127973675727844,
-0.5831897258758545,
-0.14921286702156067,
0.5405159592628479,
0.6071415543556213,
-0.5976449251174927,
0.5502148866653442,
-0.15042638778686523,
-0.2889993488788605,
-0.4719555079936981,
0.32200032472610474,
0.8048787713050842,
0.38654348254203796,
0.7058632969856262,
-0.37250423431396484,
-0.6347541809082031,
-0.6875956654548645,
-0.2178468555212021,
-0.4619516432285309,
-0.23578061163425446,
0.033453695476055145,
0.6142128109931946,
-0.5813214182853699,
0.6152182817459106,
-0.2918413579463959,
-0.44132500886917114,
-0.09349577128887177,
0.24662785232067108,
-0.10303283482789993,
1.071230173110962,
0.32628369331359863,
-0.7868707180023193,
-0.025504281744360924,
-0.09237253665924072,
-0.9772027134895325,
0.2801796793937683,
-0.088189035654068,
-0.4373070299625397,
0.017732780426740646,
0.6990678906440735,
-0.8486342430114746,
0.3632314205169678,
0.20547045767307281,
-0.13777104020118713,
0.7455954551696777,
-0.04511510208249092,
-0.16921398043632507,
-1.0445468425750732,
0.07055361568927765,
0.11530625820159912,
0.07591501623392105,
-0.6122217774391174,
0.6188286542892456,
0.1958204060792923,
-0.11282508075237274,
-0.09793035686016083,
0.13770218193531036,
-0.31053370237350464,
-0.1594650149345398,
-0.049218080937862396,
-0.24603894352912903,
-0.34466302394866943,
0.6027830839157104,
-0.17697849869728088,
0.7200179100036621,
0.8471794128417969,
-0.49393430352211,
0.10550563782453537,
0.21832750737667084,
-0.07505428045988083,
0.7734590172767639,
-0.8799369931221008,
0.08719997107982635,
-0.21121744811534882,
0.5593341588973999,
-0.9577966332435608,
-0.719925045967102,
0.17937280237674713,
-0.32281211018562317,
0.6897485852241516,
-0.42050427198410034,
-0.36752068996429443,
-0.31341347098350525,
-0.25157690048217773,
0.5755882263183594,
0.28541338443756104,
-0.611640214920044,
0.32367637753486633,
0.29482412338256836,
-0.00203145993873477,
-0.5866277813911438,
-0.5846996903419495,
0.10858789086341858,
-0.17727604508399963,
-0.45980343222618103,
0.5109542012214661,
0.37602198123931885,
-0.29751381278038025,
-0.10264770686626434,
-0.3497116267681122,
0.10413109511137009,
0.08692049980163574,
0.2217801958322525,
0.4989582300186157,
-0.11665236204862595,
0.2627822756767273,
0.10582942515611649,
-0.3174731135368347,
-0.13264146447181702,
-0.7504122853279114,
0.07654893398284912,
-0.2758979797363281,
-0.3125916123390198,
-0.6318797469139099,
0.26376572251319885,
0.5564607381820679,
-0.23182833194732666,
0.7158628702163696,
0.9194687008857727,
-0.5721741914749146,
-0.0025577994529157877,
-0.2439773678779602,
-0.4463649392127991,
-0.40881186723709106,
0.3959660232067108,
0.0013056729221716523,
-0.8543411493301392,
0.2178208827972412,
0.04729997366666794,
0.3822876811027527,
0.4884468913078308,
0.3703692853450775,
-0.35540682077407837,
1.4923893213272095,
0.7618587613105774,
-0.5676145553588867,
0.5805045366287231,
-0.5515320301055908,
0.05651036277413368,
-0.850721538066864,
-0.19918489456176758,
-0.35079658031463623,
-0.6532012224197388,
-0.5784187316894531,
-0.19791671633720398,
0.42070499062538147,
0.5225915312767029,
-0.3852044939994812,
0.29772329330444336,
-0.449310302734375,
0.5607100129127502,
0.6189809441566467,
0.04164186120033264,
-0.160503089427948,
-0.052057020366191864,
0.12841485440731049,
0.176022008061409,
-0.7957130074501038,
-0.21167322993278503,
1.2341843843460083,
0.3381202220916748,
0.7937013506889343,
0.2038460522890091,
0.7258588075637817,
0.14248326420783997,
0.3866516053676605,
-0.5586128234863281,
0.39167580008506775,
-0.06272407621145248,
-0.3314829170703888,
-0.595402717590332,
-0.45568495988845825,
-0.8403884768486023,
0.503372311592102,
-0.3036710023880005,
-0.8466359972953796,
0.19875568151474,
0.46606215834617615,
-0.3679925799369812,
0.19412517547607422,
-0.9706330895423889,
0.7899607419967651,
-0.022250154986977577,
-0.7696613073348999,
-0.3609371781349182,
-0.994238555431366,
0.5975812673568726,
0.30507734417915344,
-0.15693198144435883,
0.43996742367744446,
0.02175477333366871,
0.632048487663269,
-0.5264776349067688,
0.9332237839698792,
-0.29020956158638,
-0.12140906602144241,
0.2643849551677704,
-0.3891131579875946,
0.9355258941650391,
0.25955772399902344,
0.08692531287670135,
0.3459671139717102,
-0.40340614318847656,
-0.7373754978179932,
-0.542302131652832,
0.6320108771324158,
-0.9375059604644775,
-0.6632757782936096,
-0.2146548330783844,
-0.7366893887519836,
-0.3259444236755371,
0.18671464920043945,
0.3530590832233429,
0.289926677942276,
0.10906579345464706,
0.18173719942569733,
0.6894596815109253,
0.5545260310173035,
0.28272536396980286,
0.17443642020225525,
0.2635013461112976,
-0.2820734977722168,
1.0195491313934326,
0.15857283771038055,
0.09644895792007446,
0.20507681369781494,
0.18779626488685608,
-0.24462012946605682,
-0.45522984862327576,
-0.7555416822433472,
0.03496323153376579,
-0.11988195776939392,
-0.28744596242904663,
-0.25077253580093384,
0.03983898088335991,
-0.889064371585846,
-0.20816604793071747,
-0.19146816432476044,
-0.5382562279701233,
-0.3115004599094391,
-0.12325987964868546,
-0.2430378496646881,
0.5946674346923828,
-0.17710644006729126,
0.1872897744178772,
-0.20228414237499237,
0.19884666800498962,
0.6009565591812134,
0.27470335364341736,
0.07644523680210114,
-0.5203897953033447,
-0.4377334415912628,
-0.0584222637116909,
-0.5678325891494751,
-0.2898142337799072,
-0.3405900299549103,
0.3088488280773163,
0.5277745723724365,
0.9479846358299255,
-0.03497098386287689,
0.808904767036438,
-0.10917762666940689,
0.7337856888771057,
0.3270898461341858,
-0.7420433759689331,
0.572252631187439,
-0.5071141719818115,
0.29338589310646057,
0.5426416993141174,
0.33042800426483154,
-0.13276715576648712,
-0.6401708722114563,
-0.7580718398094177,
-1.0333843231201172,
0.8274257183074951,
0.2853168547153473,
-0.04124268516898155,
0.2852582037448883,
0.42771172523498535,
-0.20432806015014648,
0.05016780272126198,
-0.40433892607688904,
0.03441455960273743,
-0.40446561574935913,
-0.25246232748031616,
-0.2912507951259613,
0.002677520737051964,
-0.3895680904388428,
-0.2608329653739929,
0.7371735572814941,
-0.3216010630130768,
0.12233912199735641,
0.11067374050617218,
-0.05173502489924431,
-0.30508357286453247,
0.25450724363327026,
0.5626226663589478,
0.46469566226005554,
0.160054549574852,
0.3122542202472687,
0.5705243349075317,
-0.44197556376457214,
0.01812366023659706,
0.15744517743587494,
-0.26830533146858215,
-0.67252516746521,
0.7994229793548584,
0.628678023815155,
0.3560250997543335,
-0.45594340562820435,
0.525066614151001,
0.3243441879749298,
-0.3844812512397766,
0.11582858115434647,
0.5064226984977722,
-0.3820949196815491,
0.43968093395233154,
0.4303407073020935,
0.39243850111961365,
0.010973043739795685,
-0.6018658876419067,
0.2662794291973114,
0.425387978553772,
-0.554454505443573,
-0.4386206865310669,
0.7626528143882751,
0.049146730452775955,
-0.1033720150589943,
0.5974303483963013,
-0.42914456129074097,
-0.4872893691062927,
0.7378851771354675,
0.6482473015785217,
0.5173915028572083,
-0.3657999336719513,
-0.09496735036373138,
0.32326439023017883,
0.24955521523952484,
-0.5814179182052612,
0.043392471969127655,
-0.3488820493221283,
-0.5083654522895813,
-0.26089176535606384,
-0.08869486302137375,
-0.5898637175559998,
0.02274627424776554,
-0.9517791867256165,
0.018494369462132454,
-0.537898063659668,
-0.06512082368135452,
-0.3941914141178131,
-0.014646158553659916,
-0.4136841893196106,
0.13583211600780487,
-0.14948254823684692,
0.40806880593299866,
-0.8518081903457642,
0.4615883529186249,
1.0620582103729248,
-0.2929810583591461,
-0.8747214078903198,
0.5887414813041687,
0.10810896754264832,
-0.709308385848999,
0.24001732468605042,
0.16242970526218414,
0.08124568313360214,
0.034883543848991394,
-0.9200806617736816,
-0.9408439993858337,
1.1600490808486938,
0.1765323281288147,
-0.590978741645813,
-0.09232936054468155,
-0.33216992020606995,
0.8083773255348206,
-0.0409441702067852,
0.26380428671836853,
0.6192034482955933,
0.30086204409599304,
-0.1451875865459442,
-0.6931465268135071,
-0.07366877794265747,
-0.27238771319389343,
0.00806894525885582,
0.394256055355072,
-1.1670048236846924,
0.7295820713043213,
-0.48859119415283203,
-0.215972900390625,
0.12794767320156097,
1.1106170415878296,
0.050628893077373505,
0.45360419154167175,
0.558335542678833,
1.1233525276184082,
0.852555513381958,
-0.03458954393863678,
0.6479494571685791,
-0.15729442238807678,
0.30667322874069214,
1.2282391786575317,
-0.23539941012859344,
0.653547465801239,
0.41942283511161804,
-0.25046828389167786,
0.5902434587478638,
0.40117427706718445,
-0.19985561072826385,
0.3271436095237732,
0.0516013465821743,
-0.06321246176958084,
-0.19527824223041534,
-0.23031571507453918,
-0.47680848836898804,
0.4702574610710144,
0.26099345088005066,
-0.10246353596448898,
-0.09236649423837662,
-0.09831275790929794,
-0.10088006407022476,
-0.14851875603199005,
-0.753063440322876,
0.6783638596534729,
-0.15334051847457886,
-1.0036240816116333,
0.40954941511154175,
0.06470789015293121,
0.5107166767120361,
-0.3983932137489319,
-0.04559009522199631,
-0.15871408581733704,
0.3092782497406006,
-0.46891987323760986,
-0.5997517704963684,
0.09604422748088837,
-0.024705369025468826,
-0.24315007030963898,
-0.21642480790615082,
0.798724353313446,
-0.4872472584247589,
-0.36703118681907654,
-0.04095268249511719,
0.1499483436346054,
0.07274258881807327,
0.3400583565235138,
-0.4320002496242523,
-0.3552585542201996,
-0.3593144118785858,
-0.05993048474192619,
0.5779904127120972,
0.13766224682331085,
-0.5010098218917847,
0.3500344455242157,
0.6058470606803894,
-0.20243918895721436,
-0.32951679825782776,
0.3142341375350952,
0.920714795589447,
-0.23043571412563324,
-0.7135816216468811,
-0.6255303025245667,
0.30744946002960205,
-0.030876094475388527,
-0.6125283241271973,
0.790065348148346,
0.4136820137500763,
1.0818029642105103,
0.345129132270813,
0.590128481388092,
-0.075831837952137,
0.017488569021224976,
-0.4270152747631073,
0.5600248575210571,
-0.5034034848213196,
0.08550793677568436,
-0.43018847703933716,
-0.6937314867973328,
-0.18217216432094574,
0.4290403425693512,
-0.32550525665283203,
0.08927847445011139,
0.3325088918209076,
0.9143372774124146,
-0.3135150074958801,
-0.0035568212624639273,
0.0741463303565979,
0.04220779240131378,
0.029157841578125954,
0.5876439213752747,
0.7966486811637878,
-0.5449017286300659,
0.5927395224571228,
0.03317953273653984,
-0.4516499936580658,
-0.3194367587566376,
-0.2833337187767029,
-0.7755318880081177,
-0.32045382261276245,
-0.2735317051410675,
-0.21808259189128876,
0.23596957325935364,
0.7211496829986572,
1.0514018535614014,
-0.8517571091651917,
0.02303151600062847,
-0.5516512989997864,
0.268478661775589,
-0.774155855178833,
-0.24435874819755554,
0.43447840213775635,
-0.6480964422225952,
-0.5787639617919922,
0.5036633014678955,
0.0405704602599144,
0.10097859054803848,
-0.25154849886894226,
-0.3859573304653168,
0.09603006392717361,
-0.22361375391483307,
0.22028376162052155,
0.4793340563774109,
-0.3398333787918091,
-0.37614521384239197,
-0.5027626752853394,
-0.05271562188863754,
-0.2732258439064026,
0.8152464628219604,
-0.4855605959892273,
0.21648870408535004,
0.2732233703136444,
0.5721309781074524,
0.2656058669090271,
0.3914487063884735,
0.45800429582595825,
-0.9335854649543762,
0.04505627602338791,
0.07368021458387375,
0.33962079882621765,
-0.06520437449216843,
-0.5477119088172913,
0.6694290637969971,
0.5242236852645874,
-0.6690187454223633,
-0.9789764285087585,
0.3085494041442871,
-0.4303785264492035,
-0.010168789885938168,
0.8988707065582275,
-0.2461862415075302,
0.1522350162267685,
-0.09973135590553284,
-0.0033374661579728127,
0.39609044790267944,
-0.3131875991821289,
1.0069687366485596,
0.5321433544158936,
-0.29035449028015137,
0.02671477198600769,
-0.15873591601848602,
0.3370797038078308,
1.0027271509170532,
-0.6384574174880981,
0.04022161662578583,
0.32665717601776123,
-0.08171054720878601,
0.17066025733947754,
0.20269271731376648,
0.15073813498020172,
0.6008013486862183,
0.13198386132717133,
-0.16617028415203094,
-0.02161998860538006,
-0.690194845199585,
-0.5239887833595276,
0.27759039402008057,
-0.3316740393638611,
-0.20706620812416077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00658v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00658v2 | Learning Planning-based Reasoning by Trajectories Collection and Process Reward Synthesizing | 2024-02-01T15:18:33 | 2024-04-15T06:36:24 | Fangkai Jiao, Chengwei Qin, Zhengyuan Liu, Nancy F. Chen, Shafiq Joty | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks through step-by-step rationale generation.
However, recent studies have raised concerns regarding the hallucination and
flaws in their reasoning process. Substantial efforts are being made to improve
the reliability and faithfulness of the generated rationales. Some approaches
model reasoning as planning, while others focus on annotating for process
supervision. Nevertheless, the planning-based search process often results in
high latency due to the frequent assessment of intermediate reasoning states
and the extensive exploration space. Additionally, supervising the reasoning
process with human annotation is costly and challenging to scale for LLM
training. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose a framework to
learn planning-based reasoning through Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) on
collected trajectories, which are ranked according to synthesized process
rewards. Our results on challenging logical reasoning benchmarks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our learning framework, showing that our 7B model can
surpass the strong counterparts like GPT-3.5-Turbo. | [
-0.27973803877830505,
-0.4453521966934204,
1.1157946586608887,
0.019751552492380142,
-0.26673445105552673,
-0.004986385349184275,
-0.07489124685525894,
-0.15289652347564697,
0.2922206521034241,
0.7694447636604309,
-0.9062941670417786,
-0.3858353793621063,
-0.45821768045425415,
-0.027319321408867836,
0.2012651562690735,
0.5454376339912415,
-0.21288862824440002,
-0.18274883925914764,
0.184004545211792,
0.3215726912021637,
-0.580618143081665,
-0.5969021916389465,
-0.7713302373886108,
-0.40483587980270386,
0.6363759636878967,
0.5233070850372314,
0.5445561408996582,
0.7738747000694275,
0.12732045352458954,
0.2167496383190155,
-0.24640434980392456,
0.49332693219184875,
-0.4558333158493042,
0.4516560435295105,
-0.40468230843544006,
-0.2911275327205658,
-0.3864942193031311,
0.042848724871873856,
0.21906986832618713,
0.8216174840927124,
-0.17934419214725494,
-0.08300497382879257,
-0.34097856283187866,
0.6313126087188721,
-0.6447945237159729,
0.43149852752685547,
-0.7928473353385925,
0.27069029211997986,
0.20300421118736267,
-0.40217870473861694,
-0.5199156999588013,
-0.45518791675567627,
0.2561994194984436,
-0.7879202365875244,
0.005819272715598345,
-0.10860955715179443,
0.35554197430610657,
0.4539898931980133,
-0.2949462831020355,
-0.4781953990459442,
-0.8010287880897522,
0.7277007699012756,
-0.4571568965911865,
0.11424828320741653,
0.37798961997032166,
0.5397158861160278,
-0.526455283164978,
-0.46386897563934326,
-0.38257837295532227,
-0.11530826985836029,
0.2966610789299011,
-0.11093238741159439,
0.43136465549468994,
0.10187576711177826,
0.5770586133003235,
0.02172517590224743,
-0.5460472106933594,
0.03832969069480896,
-0.19383400678634644,
-0.07936093211174011,
0.8423475623130798,
0.17440293729305267,
-0.15507838129997253,
-0.14458400011062622,
-0.2909383177757263,
-0.4594348967075348,
-0.6047820448875427,
0.12019273638725281,
0.29877427220344543,
0.3788364827632904,
0.3908761739730835,
0.4780727028846741,
-0.49686089158058167,
0.7260036468505859,
-0.010303671471774578,
-0.23111648857593536,
0.07992143929004669,
0.05562413111329079,
-0.2473869025707245,
0.1334971934556961,
0.5127432346343994,
0.2901665270328522,
0.2758720815181732,
-0.15651045739650726,
-0.2848972678184509,
0.1623905599117279,
0.31185677647590637,
-0.53107088804245,
-0.21441929042339325,
0.2603008449077606,
0.10091160237789154,
-0.3859725296497345,
-0.1882564127445221,
-0.645147979259491,
-0.32475775480270386,
-0.5248327255249023,
0.16950464248657227,
-0.4344480335712433,
-0.18666861951351166,
0.43250471353530884,
0.07152790576219559,
0.10150180757045746,
0.5625765919685364,
-0.979149341583252,
-0.2668178081512451,
0.7059124708175659,
0.5197972059249878,
-0.1484752893447876,
-0.3499699532985687,
-0.6285898685455322,
0.3105601370334625,
-0.48743242025375366,
0.9331392645835876,
-0.44578996300697327,
-0.616280734539032,
0.024342559278011322,
-0.3464581370353699,
-0.07441665232181549,
-0.5153628587722778,
0.9163534045219421,
-0.33157840371131897,
-0.008852066472172737,
-0.3490680754184723,
-0.41407087445259094,
-0.2825426757335663,
0.3749421536922455,
-0.4403722882270813,
0.9169803857803345,
0.05268693342804909,
-0.2665785551071167,
0.6718528270721436,
-0.5985968708992004,
-0.4601653814315796,
0.0590340830385685,
-0.22330717742443085,
-0.20328521728515625,
0.02164262719452381,
0.34745481610298157,
0.6370524168014526,
0.03743257746100426,
0.7893732786178589,
-0.20983494818210602,
-0.47082728147506714,
-0.019951919093728065,
-0.03319660201668739,
0.43798232078552246,
0.2894885540008545,
-0.5798274278640747,
0.4053559899330139,
-0.9610252976417542,
0.052051838487386703,
0.1966041475534439,
-0.4062384068965912,
-0.1062006726861,
0.36434751749038696,
-0.6890270113945007,
0.47580939531326294,
0.015174268744885921,
-0.19827358424663544,
0.5278833508491516,
-0.575627326965332,
0.3385763168334961,
0.9544363021850586,
0.1143481582403183,
0.5317003130912781,
-0.13284681737422943,
0.4442916810512543,
0.08159953355789185,
0.24550409615039825,
0.13200248777866364,
-0.23115171492099762,
-0.6631502509117126,
0.14560756087303162,
-0.42226099967956543,
0.305082231760025,
-0.8959084153175354,
0.5932876467704773,
-0.2608943283557892,
-0.4676797688007355,
0.16518984735012054,
-0.16255055367946625,
0.04786956310272217,
0.6047316789627075,
0.3869926333427429,
0.21916265785694122,
-0.5069189667701721,
-0.6849938631057739,
0.0779542401432991,
-0.4040451645851135,
0.06658580154180527,
0.20725283026695251,
0.25151684880256653,
-0.13916097581386566,
0.6130570769309998,
-0.6514695882797241,
-0.00935645867139101,
-0.6333122253417969,
0.06739633530378342,
0.239289328455925,
0.2425680309534073,
0.1490425169467926,
-0.6303585171699524,
-0.08453540503978729,
-0.23727449774742126,
-0.6227806210517883,
-0.14766466617584229,
-0.24247407913208008,
-0.6085473299026489,
0.26523056626319885,
0.10007565468549728,
-0.6688462495803833,
0.32564306259155273,
0.12872742116451263,
-0.31729191541671753,
0.4667849838733673,
-0.12724226713180542,
-0.07285571098327637,
-0.8091532588005066,
-0.09782399982213974,
-0.044344305992126465,
-0.06344515085220337,
-0.34145867824554443,
-0.14852431416511536,
-0.2565946877002716,
-0.1917031705379486,
-0.5111696720123291,
0.5356507301330566,
-0.30122920870780945,
-0.1382376104593277,
-0.3920018970966339,
0.10436445474624634,
-0.020901160314679146,
0.8832892775535583,
0.6825658679008484,
0.5444755554199219,
0.23025599122047424,
-0.8044273853302002,
0.2818042039871216,
0.2934565544128418,
-0.15421301126480103,
0.08516262471675873,
-0.1628963053226471,
0.05256938934326172,
-0.027705566957592964,
0.29402804374694824,
-0.4147043824195862,
-0.14958076179027557,
0.30667001008987427,
-0.09073520451784134,
0.16150647401809692,
-0.20508958399295807,
-0.31781813502311707,
-0.3765648305416107,
-0.21442514657974243,
-0.10820707678794861,
0.3612522482872009,
-0.6803191900253296,
0.5164288282394409,
0.44105264544487,
0.06733384728431702,
-0.674938976764679,
-0.1782057285308838,
-0.21136952936649323,
-0.17681901156902313,
-0.5538236498832703,
0.0644255205988884,
0.014821484684944153,
-0.11072138696908951,
-0.491300493478775,
-0.4235081672668457,
0.22486692667007446,
0.15209636092185974,
0.31185317039489746,
0.18313312530517578,
0.40589630603790283,
0.01753547228872776,
0.07190747559070587,
-0.2807714641094208,
0.32018306851387024,
-0.4767077565193176,
0.5790539383888245,
0.2871874272823334,
-0.2559468746185303,
-0.014423171058297157,
0.2303556650876999,
0.44486677646636963,
-0.05396696552634239,
0.30761516094207764,
0.0711817592382431,
-0.2781767249107361,
-0.5958631038665771,
-0.41140806674957275,
-0.21002820134162903,
-0.39822113513946533,
0.24031509459018707,
-0.5845198631286621,
-0.6313483715057373,
0.16310150921344757,
-0.276345431804657,
0.21320943534374237,
0.36659225821495056,
0.4777054488658905,
0.24420791864395142,
1.096789836883545,
0.2735835909843445,
0.2514001429080963,
0.2921428978443146,
-0.45398107171058655,
0.06896200031042099,
-0.526639461517334,
-0.5070651173591614,
-0.3086014688014984,
-0.27280277013778687,
-0.4422416388988495,
-0.5434780120849609,
0.2734281122684479,
0.022365586832165718,
-0.41629889607429504,
0.18519777059555054,
-0.7974869608879089,
0.38279134035110474,
0.7138437628746033,
0.04936099424958229,
0.260899156332016,
0.06918352842330933,
-0.44204404950141907,
0.0701739490032196,
-0.5866217017173767,
-0.7415898442268372,
0.9342963099479675,
0.07261635363101959,
0.6323153376579285,
-0.11795858293771744,
0.890603244304657,
-0.09415972232818604,
-0.10916486382484436,
-0.8176882266998291,
0.9813921451568604,
0.2454109936952591,
-0.3676612079143524,
-0.43722081184387207,
-0.6059575080871582,
-0.7825019359588623,
0.37926000356674194,
-0.18450528383255005,
-0.8914287090301514,
0.14518120884895325,
0.25820180773735046,
-0.20441962778568268,
0.3680124580860138,
-0.5304547548294067,
0.7321404814720154,
-0.5943700075149536,
-0.6817754507064819,
-0.24992398917675018,
-0.6914474964141846,
0.2439255267381668,
0.22451704740524292,
-0.010584728792309761,
-0.33626270294189453,
0.27838969230651855,
0.5389190316200256,
-0.4013229310512543,
0.4565208852291107,
-0.4773976802825928,
0.07687345892190933,
0.21232561767101288,
0.39405813813209534,
0.7421854138374329,
0.2058017998933792,
-0.20653079450130463,
-0.22996294498443604,
-0.19892926514148712,
-0.22755210101604462,
-0.6096016764640808,
0.6287781596183777,
-0.5973983407020569,
-0.774945080280304,
-0.6627908945083618,
-0.6190608739852905,
-0.5257937908172607,
0.0075904084369540215,
0.02681564725935459,
0.065709188580513,
0.07120246440172195,
-0.4275583028793335,
0.7483117580413818,
-0.2654595375061035,
0.4245298206806183,
0.1271701604127884,
-0.4152309000492096,
-0.2071835994720459,
0.652890145778656,
0.0166578721255064,
0.11219896376132965,
0.6206619739532471,
0.3768441379070282,
-0.4920365810394287,
-0.8129824995994568,
-0.4986576437950134,
0.18213649094104767,
-0.6974567174911499,
0.0267333947122097,
-0.5919197201728821,
-0.10140424966812134,
-0.21606478095054626,
-0.3603942394256592,
-0.37387871742248535,
-0.5880547165870667,
-0.03214293718338013,
-0.37930333614349365,
0.15109007060527802,
0.6455897092819214,
-0.0594172440469265,
0.09000507742166519,
-0.5250377655029297,
0.0045449272729456425,
0.252347856760025,
0.17824791371822357,
-0.02384517341852188,
-0.09820446372032166,
-0.11505358666181564,
0.06341230869293213,
-0.515937864780426,
-0.6758045554161072,
0.5696660876274109,
-0.5161939859390259,
0.6863999962806702,
0.25580695271492004,
0.07961513847112656,
0.6357704401016235,
-0.3207620680332184,
0.6037744879722595,
-0.09639833867549896,
-0.6147135496139526,
1.1053358316421509,
-0.5046771168708801,
0.19649045169353485,
0.5081208348274231,
0.48535555601119995,
-0.1192074567079544,
-0.09465499222278595,
-0.7718421220779419,
-0.9053906202316284,
0.7696928977966309,
0.0873253121972084,
-0.40319356322288513,
-0.11716370284557343,
0.614308774471283,
0.09600614011287689,
0.2968061864376068,
-0.831325113773346,
0.10883871465921402,
-0.10614611953496933,
0.02472282573580742,
0.02937958762049675,
-0.41981834173202515,
0.07628792524337769,
-0.12750078737735748,
0.945813775062561,
-0.21913477778434753,
0.07124783098697662,
0.15809382498264313,
-0.05223604291677475,
-0.050611332058906555,
0.2193816900253296,
0.6756378412246704,
0.8057456612586975,
-0.449273943901062,
0.06759706139564514,
-0.20896458625793457,
-0.13941971957683563,
0.33634835481643677,
0.05819183215498924,
-0.2355601042509079,
-0.2519282102584839,
0.07192344218492508,
0.9777047038078308,
-0.028918432071805,
-0.8629329800605774,
0.20585694909095764,
0.0686931237578392,
-0.35575613379478455,
-0.4448019564151764,
0.3444302976131439,
0.026004429906606674,
0.30206143856048584,
0.251582533121109,
-0.13322170078754425,
0.1546710729598999,
-0.2620510458946228,
-0.1367463320493698,
0.21624401211738586,
-0.18662700057029724,
-0.11234094947576523,
0.5793411731719971,
0.24761617183685303,
-0.18040437996387482,
0.5825778245925903,
-0.5128499865531921,
-0.5704963207244873,
0.2878674864768982,
0.21533644199371338,
0.7173725962638855,
-0.02792496420443058,
0.3031889498233795,
0.5655863285064697,
0.07655102014541626,
-0.5085902214050293,
0.4106397032737732,
-0.23717088997364044,
-0.6523489356040955,
-0.6377288699150085,
-0.7416234016418457,
-0.5859271287918091,
0.2026572972536087,
-0.2405017614364624,
0.4576529860496521,
-0.48732301592826843,
-0.05913162603974342,
-0.3772701621055603,
0.10332029312849045,
-0.3786100447177887,
0.27814212441444397,
0.06960746645927429,
0.5532850623130798,
-0.5940448045730591,
0.6452230215072632,
0.7539162635803223,
-0.4755982756614685,
-1.2294697761535645,
-0.12386764585971832,
-0.1551922708749771,
-0.6450969576835632,
0.8348264694213867,
0.1995377093553543,
-0.11947101354598999,
-0.21093212068080902,
-0.144139364361763,
-0.7137771248817444,
1.009371280670166,
0.5108226537704468,
-0.6681632399559021,
-0.49950727820396423,
0.07752025127410889,
0.362693727016449,
-0.3882838487625122,
0.0742507055401802,
0.3326486051082611,
0.3402901887893677,
0.7114112377166748,
-0.5945581197738647,
0.01669524610042572,
0.20513318479061127,
-0.07876963168382645,
0.3269999027252197,
-0.3556274473667145,
0.6329658031463623,
-0.30839619040489197,
-0.016235871240496635,
-0.31853750348091125,
0.2316443920135498,
0.8138038516044617,
0.2954115569591522,
0.5695125460624695,
0.6677824854850769,
0.5405005812644958,
-0.10644431412220001,
0.9483305215835571,
0.11196162551641464,
0.05428485944867134,
1.2095345258712769,
-0.619410514831543,
0.7963374257087708,
0.5648267865180969,
-0.008126923814415932,
0.41308072209358215,
0.8914677500724792,
0.4303776025772095,
0.5921377539634705,
0.38800811767578125,
-0.0936209112405777,
-0.5957500338554382,
0.13608534634113312,
0.029388099908828735,
0.4221299886703491,
0.3202610909938812,
-0.2391587346792221,
-0.15141332149505615,
-0.2913648188114166,
-0.0848693922162056,
0.23767675459384918,
-0.347951740026474,
0.7436321973800659,
-0.05531344190239906,
-1.0357850790023804,
0.40727606415748596,
-0.38041889667510986,
0.30450958013534546,
-0.49591949582099915,
-0.1535479873418808,
-0.2328438013792038,
0.25703269243240356,
0.05191003531217575,
-0.6828330755233765,
0.31277066469192505,
-0.2770726680755615,
-0.034466732293367386,
-0.5219731330871582,
0.5663000345230103,
-0.052777886390686035,
-0.4828422963619232,
0.496881902217865,
0.630292534828186,
0.11499760299921036,
-0.09312281012535095,
-0.3611173927783966,
-0.08646368980407715,
0.1937175840139389,
-0.5323692560195923,
0.3254672884941101,
0.43886300921440125,
-0.24424488842487335,
0.946645200252533,
0.6443648338317871,
0.41396188735961914,
-0.0424368754029274,
0.08853975683450699,
0.7019093632698059,
-0.7687132954597473,
-0.6673485636711121,
-0.7822080850601196,
0.3885156810283661,
-0.1910359412431717,
0.03013373725116253,
0.1891149878501892,
0.6160163879394531,
1.031954288482666,
-0.017177755013108253,
0.6059763431549072,
0.26793715357780457,
0.7352744340896606,
-0.772879421710968,
0.08015710115432739,
-0.2670081853866577,
0.531800389289856,
-0.11747168749570847,
-1.0740687847137451,
-0.2206835150718689,
0.9603039026260376,
-0.5460615754127502,
-0.05619201064109802,
0.6243069171905518,
0.5784241557121277,
0.08296343684196472,
-0.09547451138496399,
0.3463852107524872,
-0.3025652766227722,
0.48706382513046265,
1.064736008644104,
0.9288389682769775,
0.12577413022518158,
0.555892825126648,
-0.37120890617370605,
-0.144553542137146,
-0.1299598217010498,
-1.0498907566070557,
-0.8302019834518433,
-0.4479111433029175,
-0.20112581551074982,
-0.14158718287944794,
0.20628252625465393,
1.1895619630813599,
0.6866308450698853,
-0.3278534412384033,
-0.4198327362537384,
-0.3863447606563568,
0.26211658120155334,
-0.19480527937412262,
-0.1753542721271515,
0.18870756030082703,
-0.2813986837863922,
-0.667410671710968,
0.5315572023391724,
0.4182981848716736,
0.08222317695617676,
-0.2195313572883606,
-0.27932941913604736,
-0.3453490734100342,
-0.1744011640548706,
0.5529173016548157,
0.16157668828964233,
-0.7414014339447021,
-0.3649401068687439,
0.019571712240576744,
0.10530801862478256,
0.10446757823228836,
0.8824245929718018,
-0.8235546946525574,
0.330098032951355,
0.5597631931304932,
0.5521383285522461,
0.9652028679847717,
-0.1424696445465088,
0.7320060729980469,
-0.5046294331550598,
0.23423409461975098,
0.46730202436447144,
0.47803211212158203,
0.2500201165676117,
-0.3494115471839905,
0.9118404388427734,
0.2020348161458969,
-0.6989781856536865,
-0.71706622838974,
0.38470369577407837,
-1.1668117046356201,
-0.17558278143405914,
1.249466061592102,
0.025087174028158188,
-0.10612194240093231,
0.20592883229255676,
-0.2673385739326477,
0.3636155426502228,
-0.5818140506744385,
0.8829649686813354,
0.5486208200454712,
-0.5754429697990417,
-0.0908050537109375,
-0.4008413255214691,
0.4873664975166321,
0.28174418210983276,
-0.7303555607795715,
0.17717963457107544,
0.8975241780281067,
-0.015936128795146942,
0.1428544968366623,
0.665145754814148,
0.07229280471801758,
0.0577414445579052,
-0.21433362364768982,
0.101451575756073,
-0.30923032760620117,
-0.32718634605407715,
0.07237790524959564,
0.2066522091627121,
0.4554923474788666,
0.004010234493762255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00632v1 | Prosody in Cascade and Direct Speech-to-Text Translation: a case study on Korean Wh-Phrases | 2024-02-01T14:46:35 | 2024-02-01T14:46:35 | Giulio Zhou, Tsz Kin Lam, Alexandra Birch, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL | Speech-to-Text Translation (S2TT) has typically been addressed with cascade
systems, where speech recognition systems generate a transcription that is
subsequently passed to a translation model. While there has been a growing
interest in developing direct speech translation systems to avoid propagating
errors and losing non-verbal content, prior work in direct S2TT has struggled
to conclusively establish the advantages of integrating the acoustic signal
directly into the translation process. This work proposes using contrastive
evaluation to quantitatively measure the ability of direct S2TT systems to
disambiguate utterances where prosody plays a crucial role. Specifically, we
evaluated Korean-English translation systems on a test set containing
wh-phrases, for which prosodic features are necessary to produce translations
with the correct intent, whether it's a statement, a yes/no question, a
wh-question, and more. Our results clearly demonstrate the value of direct
translation systems over cascade translation models, with a notable 12.9%
improvement in overall accuracy in ambiguous cases, along with up to a 15.6%
increase in F1 scores for one of the major intent categories. To the best of
our knowledge, this work stands as the first to provide quantitative evidence
that direct S2TT models can effectively leverage prosody. The code for our
evaluation is openly accessible and freely available for review and
utilisation. | [
-0.004094849806278944,
-0.35598504543304443,
0.670922577381134,
0.7743664383888245,
-0.7115617394447327,
-0.06943400204181671,
-0.1501176655292511,
-0.22510872781276703,
0.013589803129434586,
0.19901451468467712,
-0.3166995644569397,
-0.5257719159126282,
-0.7195377945899963,
0.4362155795097351,
-0.3814171850681305,
1.0204342603683472,
-0.15495038032531738,
0.4094444811344147,
0.0823216438293457,
-0.1700649857521057,
-0.43983978033065796,
-0.16102172434329987,
-0.49849286675453186,
-0.21479842066764832,
0.2643260061740875,
0.20392027497291565,
0.899756133556366,
0.28177282214164734,
0.8964154720306396,
0.29434871673583984,
-0.37299588322639465,
-0.17240147292613983,
-0.10856770724058151,
0.3897992968559265,
-0.19669562578201294,
-0.20482632517814636,
-0.6383668780326843,
0.06452212482690811,
0.7461284399032593,
0.700353741645813,
0.11210876703262329,
0.11235446482896805,
0.42427611351013184,
0.5755290985107422,
-0.36721181869506836,
0.22865965962409973,
-0.17923510074615479,
0.046513598412275314,
-0.1910403072834015,
-0.20768970251083374,
-0.3179738223552704,
-0.5981960296630859,
0.3374086618423462,
-0.4236105978488922,
-0.15491026639938354,
-0.2184441238641739,
0.4816330075263977,
0.47021448612213135,
-0.7720222473144531,
-0.6081047058105469,
-0.7193912863731384,
0.7033075094223022,
-0.5439190864562988,
0.6280648708343506,
0.22837918996810913,
0.16284143924713135,
-0.14385439455509186,
-0.7430858016014099,
-0.5283329486846924,
-0.5143032670021057,
-0.2885648310184479,
0.7126983404159546,
-0.2920341491699219,
0.16525305807590485,
-0.13004596531391144,
0.45244428515434265,
-0.708854615688324,
-0.12224912643432617,
-0.0809592679142952,
-0.03253474831581116,
0.528915286064148,
-0.018559934571385384,
0.17554888129234314,
-0.5477836728096008,
-0.3467201888561249,
-0.01829933188855648,
-0.3605702519416809,
0.037354450672864914,
0.3361176550388336,
0.5227853059768677,
-0.18748188018798828,
0.6523188948631287,
-0.2122310847043991,
0.273356556892395,
0.24858088791370392,
-0.2447238266468048,
0.37406787276268005,
-0.7601833343505859,
0.01216658391058445,
0.2117677628993988,
0.8189553618431091,
0.31622886657714844,
0.2860022783279419,
-0.2935838997364044,
-0.2528862953186035,
-0.023394010961055756,
-0.0919695720076561,
-0.9344615340232849,
-0.054686497896909714,
0.374407559633255,
-0.441336452960968,
-0.3458652198314667,
-0.13247914612293243,
-0.3067835569381714,
-0.25285616517066956,
-0.3740772306919098,
0.28969258069992065,
-0.25658145546913147,
-0.6078115105628967,
-0.05833085998892784,
-0.1860712170600891,
0.012704402208328247,
0.06315146386623383,
-0.2785731256008148,
0.37665292620658875,
0.47933098673820496,
0.9978752136230469,
-0.24816112220287323,
-0.179285928606987,
-0.5344263315200806,
-0.07553097605705261,
-0.6645393371582031,
0.5937727093696594,
-0.3391568064689636,
-0.7386766076087952,
-0.021684594452381134,
-0.11616060882806778,
0.02612401731312275,
-0.9044715762138367,
0.7461583018302917,
-0.3758681118488312,
-0.23856860399246216,
-0.2471943348646164,
-0.3049224615097046,
0.34977462887763977,
-0.2927033603191376,
-0.4624028503894806,
0.8552374839782715,
0.12053296715021133,
-0.7165738940238953,
-0.13769428431987762,
-0.1522604376077652,
-0.7097793221473694,
-0.006098510231822729,
-0.12663348019123077,
-0.2157030552625656,
0.3198489844799042,
-0.3286968469619751,
0.17675702273845673,
-0.2379215657711029,
0.5978435277938843,
0.1585395187139511,
-0.5338259339332581,
0.3587692379951477,
-0.34733086824417114,
0.6644861102104187,
0.2479790598154068,
-0.4239733815193176,
-0.00837639532983303,
-0.4771304726600647,
-0.17600888013839722,
-0.08690378814935684,
-0.29218703508377075,
-0.42663145065307617,
-0.23271286487579346,
-0.07909341156482697,
0.2837509512901306,
0.13401921093463898,
-0.27620476484298706,
-0.13078546524047852,
-0.299482136964798,
0.22423753142356873,
0.4547862112522125,
0.008573830127716064,
0.6973179578781128,
0.3148252069950104,
0.430292010307312,
0.26510876417160034,
0.15066273510456085,
0.05174955353140831,
-0.7054482102394104,
-0.5072440505027771,
-0.17923328280448914,
0.5090709328651428,
0.8532915115356445,
-0.8691325187683105,
0.38412436842918396,
-0.2155587375164032,
-0.3490130305290222,
-0.7268210053443909,
-0.25041115283966064,
0.7406956553459167,
0.7922773957252502,
0.4921678602695465,
-0.0672789067029953,
-0.3543647825717926,
-0.9196356534957886,
-0.3443008065223694,
-0.2432532012462616,
-0.3845694363117218,
0.18966081738471985,
0.42837271094322205,
-0.02369890734553337,
0.6216986775398254,
-0.43089115619659424,
-0.23574399948120117,
-0.06359979510307312,
0.2544882893562317,
0.14240993559360504,
0.3441767394542694,
0.14292216300964355,
-0.7277886867523193,
-0.6749069094657898,
0.05798390507698059,
-0.6946967840194702,
-0.45947104692459106,
0.10664591938257217,
-0.17069867253303528,
-0.2319621592760086,
0.5387431383132935,
-0.807980477809906,
0.4011373221874237,
0.5778842568397522,
-0.2725762724876404,
0.7898271679878235,
-0.07400865852832794,
0.3498059809207916,
-1.0342931747436523,
0.2666710913181305,
0.021932421252131462,
-0.1802263706922531,
-0.8112164735794067,
0.004519973881542683,
0.15247304737567902,
-0.14541161060333252,
-0.42901724576950073,
0.3656792640686035,
-0.16359637677669525,
-0.30556225776672363,
-0.37326815724372864,
0.6067816019058228,
-0.16578985750675201,
0.1738882064819336,
0.19924335181713104,
1.0844110250473022,
0.15184812247753143,
-0.8818495869636536,
0.242711141705513,
0.4064940810203552,
-0.2726143002510071,
0.9028618335723877,
-0.7660370469093323,
0.06130414828658104,
-0.02643570303916931,
0.43488091230392456,
-1.221527099609375,
-0.0035899262875318527,
0.28041189908981323,
-0.6790617108345032,
0.22369569540023804,
-0.022724032402038574,
-0.2639161944389343,
0.019439205527305603,
-0.1266525685787201,
0.3442423343658447,
0.6767733693122864,
-0.11423569917678833,
0.10250052809715271,
0.13296163082122803,
-0.6910194158554077,
-0.48210397362709045,
-0.6355305314064026,
0.06571439653635025,
-0.10492036491632462,
-0.4179655611515045,
0.7250012755393982,
0.22810044884681702,
-0.4060834050178528,
0.004707663785666227,
-0.3772647976875305,
0.06112155318260193,
-0.16228915750980377,
-0.06959131360054016,
0.024827370420098305,
-0.09768775850534439,
0.16050729155540466,
0.2879789471626282,
-0.4421364665031433,
-0.0813177078962326,
-0.22789886593818665,
0.3993540108203888,
0.06068047508597374,
0.030752861872315407,
-0.8791968822479248,
0.32248711585998535,
0.27911531925201416,
-0.018032632768154144,
0.3904198408126831,
0.6781095266342163,
-0.11215779930353165,
0.19742298126220703,
-0.07061661779880524,
-0.3015165627002716,
-0.43400657176971436,
0.6659711599349976,
-0.6851131916046143,
-0.4684332609176636,
0.49805688858032227,
-0.5341373682022095,
-0.4378662705421448,
0.4116933345794678,
0.11862873286008835,
-0.4212893843650818,
1.1476075649261475,
0.04020674154162407,
0.27755120396614075,
0.45691049098968506,
0.04347936064004898,
0.32490044832229614,
-1.1409286260604858,
-0.1305336356163025,
-0.6892452239990234,
-0.37832650542259216,
-0.9880942702293396,
-0.5297432541847229,
0.4701352119445801,
0.4043305814266205,
-0.27090948820114136,
0.37523552775382996,
-0.08857143670320511,
0.12330209463834763,
0.258658230304718,
0.13424396514892578,
0.38945823907852173,
-0.15214958786964417,
-0.06672856956720352,
-0.49826836585998535,
-0.16457882523536682,
-0.5662234425544739,
0.7064727544784546,
0.19363562762737274,
0.29274314641952515,
0.30063948035240173,
0.612083375453949,
0.24513044953346252,
0.2315617948770523,
-0.9280918836593628,
0.6960716247558594,
-0.71830815076828,
0.11906322091817856,
-0.3238602578639984,
-0.5538545846939087,
-0.8031433820724487,
0.23905974626541138,
0.27150920033454895,
-0.2150993049144745,
0.179799884557724,
0.12123666703701019,
-0.17356787621974945,
-0.2969464957714081,
-0.4536919593811035,
0.6833983063697815,
-0.18544544279575348,
-0.3060525059700012,
-0.02571973390877247,
-0.6404497027397156,
0.21627917885780334,
0.02477921172976494,
0.08292030543088913,
0.08707144111394882,
-0.2965034544467926,
0.5894098877906799,
-0.2792207598686218,
0.6212823987007141,
-0.37351536750793457,
-0.4485359489917755,
0.3237107992172241,
0.45764338970184326,
0.8287248015403748,
-0.20764659345149994,
-0.06074172258377075,
0.18541507422924042,
-0.2615047097206116,
-0.047398485243320465,
-0.7345689535140991,
0.5821430683135986,
-0.5823414921760559,
-0.4586069881916046,
-0.2401740849018097,
-0.38880011439323425,
-0.2787858545780182,
0.02610614150762558,
0.23761719465255737,
0.2095620334148407,
-0.13207225501537323,
0.2031279057264328,
0.5785658359527588,
-0.18833155930042267,
0.22790612280368805,
0.48897862434387207,
-0.18485994637012482,
-0.5639066696166992,
1.0123497247695923,
0.24968355894088745,
0.4833107888698578,
0.3511965572834015,
0.4790051579475403,
-0.7133731245994568,
-0.6591542363166809,
-0.3733340799808502,
0.33353137969970703,
-0.7288613319396973,
-0.16104668378829956,
-0.33084774017333984,
-0.10677362233400345,
-0.6003187894821167,
0.10520260781049728,
-0.42565399408340454,
-0.6240009069442749,
-0.056733354926109314,
-0.1366509050130844,
0.03405241295695305,
0.6441851854324341,
0.013379930518567562,
0.41677799820899963,
-0.5777025818824768,
0.4477404057979584,
0.2865431606769562,
0.11313999444246292,
-0.32302600145339966,
-1.057082176208496,
0.0551445335149765,
-0.14458772540092468,
-0.27270203828811646,
-1.3643524646759033,
0.22930122911930084,
0.155976802110672,
0.31804531812667847,
0.0529664121568203,
0.22058802843093872,
0.8484411239624023,
-0.6680203080177307,
0.8471715450286865,
0.16700999438762665,
-1.2033025026321411,
0.7839018106460571,
-0.39007368683815,
0.4021942913532257,
0.599142849445343,
0.5777444243431091,
-0.671398937702179,
-0.5431607961654663,
-0.3395310044288635,
-0.8600229620933533,
0.4787406623363495,
0.5562390089035034,
-0.011785604059696198,
-0.10827437043190002,
0.4566322863101959,
-0.09698732197284698,
0.4488000273704529,
-0.3729957938194275,
-0.17962944507598877,
-0.05089931935071945,
-0.47873833775520325,
-0.09464729577302933,
-0.1505381315946579,
0.1527915894985199,
-0.05956749990582466,
0.4714384973049164,
0.11943341046571732,
0.24708542227745056,
0.35231879353523254,
-0.20674404501914978,
0.23714885115623474,
0.30551430583000183,
0.6235975623130798,
0.3375031352043152,
-0.32310691475868225,
0.3746591806411743,
0.05600294843316078,
-0.8913508653640747,
0.3763323724269867,
-0.0321190245449543,
-0.4635940194129944,
0.33523184061050415,
0.24498607218265533,
0.6144760251045227,
0.33798691630363464,
-0.26161086559295654,
0.6903759241104126,
0.231160506606102,
-0.15115103125572205,
0.09997870773077011,
-0.46714603900909424,
0.200396329164505,
0.31550154089927673,
0.16166716814041138,
0.22239603102207184,
0.49860137701034546,
-0.41145044565200806,
0.03619955852627754,
0.08091005682945251,
-0.6464691162109375,
-0.6314311027526855,
0.3998120427131653,
0.6140137314796448,
-0.4445711076259613,
0.5369895100593567,
-0.4229401648044586,
-0.44952282309532166,
0.49815741181373596,
0.7334785461425781,
1.1756715774536133,
-0.8395451307296753,
0.403141587972641,
0.512383222579956,
0.22906185686588287,
-0.1765059381723404,
0.3740123212337494,
-0.16353042423725128,
-0.36649420857429504,
-0.2752609848976135,
-0.529456615447998,
-0.3831404745578766,
0.07880070060491562,
-0.8271441459655762,
0.24125534296035767,
0.07998522371053696,
-0.4731152653694153,
-0.19454367458820343,
-0.2219891995191574,
-0.4810751676559448,
0.26586562395095825,
-0.13943998515605927,
0.5910231471061707,
-0.8804726004600525,
0.6594303846359253,
0.5850567817687988,
-0.4125427305698395,
-0.3404611349105835,
0.48256662487983704,
-0.2628379464149475,
-0.4110998213291168,
1.0891709327697754,
-0.05585267022252083,
-0.6035761833190918,
0.11939795315265656,
0.08780046552419662,
-0.7401968240737915,
1.0901830196380615,
0.4969974160194397,
-0.8159795999526978,
0.26209282875061035,
0.5373728275299072,
0.6747572422027588,
-0.09705293923616409,
0.2480747252702713,
0.8499268889427185,
0.37342873215675354,
0.09768274426460266,
-1.2719732522964478,
0.2040531188249588,
-0.044225774705410004,
0.12371161580085754,
-0.03428547456860542,
-0.5978706479072571,
0.7645921111106873,
-0.10303056985139847,
-0.39749088883399963,
0.053672827780246735,
0.5349798798561096,
0.2618120610713959,
0.43420645594596863,
0.40157079696655273,
0.11723455041646957,
0.7374147772789001,
-0.1038464605808258,
0.8842433094978333,
-0.22569209337234497,
0.06871116161346436,
1.1579570770263672,
-0.5346143841743469,
1.256171703338623,
0.6810855865478516,
-0.43293648958206177,
0.1496800035238266,
0.38125187158584595,
0.8242217302322388,
0.992880642414093,
0.3148877024650574,
-0.45589715242385864,
-0.05804593116044998,
-0.3615628182888031,
-0.46851837635040283,
0.4755779206752777,
0.13037027418613434,
-0.31556087732315063,
0.08554432541131973,
0.06921740621328354,
0.1561383455991745,
0.11444054543972015,
-0.16499103605747223,
0.8296306133270264,
0.3272281587123871,
-0.7508752346038818,
0.45391935110092163,
-0.007903681136667728,
0.4876463711261749,
-0.549571692943573,
0.051432691514492035,
-0.7599245309829712,
0.21085643768310547,
-0.2651249170303345,
-0.8633308410644531,
0.5457502603530884,
0.23330114781856537,
0.08907859027385712,
-0.2566257417201996,
0.5026895999908447,
-0.573845386505127,
-0.19655102491378784,
0.34022513031959534,
0.49329710006713867,
0.36243370175361633,
-0.24364431202411652,
-0.3656099736690521,
0.009185072965919971,
-0.10148582607507706,
-0.15889257192611694,
0.266345739364624,
0.42610546946525574,
-0.12555904686450958,
0.25214892625808716,
0.2140672653913498,
0.350625604391098,
-0.21204036474227905,
0.47750771045684814,
0.5956404209136963,
-0.5841225981712341,
-0.4846055209636688,
-0.8282615542411804,
0.6196163296699524,
-0.058969490230083466,
-0.3667535185813904,
0.8739431500434875,
0.5478495955467224,
0.7326138615608215,
-0.09675522893667221,
0.7996257543563843,
0.35513171553611755,
0.2125779390335083,
-0.4119153320789337,
0.37444430589675903,
-0.239203080534935,
0.09990022331476212,
-0.372832715511322,
-0.9748986959457397,
-0.11948950588703156,
0.6669052839279175,
-0.3630267083644867,
-0.23289845883846283,
0.9213584065437317,
0.6184386610984802,
0.04496375843882561,
0.08441223204135895,
0.2037922441959381,
0.18865694105625153,
0.022281985729932785,
0.17553645372390747,
0.9030360579490662,
-0.9225287437438965,
0.8868747353553772,
-0.10730204731225967,
-0.387061208486557,
-0.0871674120426178,
-0.638525664806366,
-0.27645647525787354,
-0.5142744183540344,
-0.6618205904960632,
-0.4782928228378296,
0.22071407735347748,
0.45585766434669495,
0.3045313358306885,
-0.7719972729682922,
-0.4050036370754242,
-0.17761781811714172,
-0.05743803456425667,
-0.4973815679550171,
-0.1199810653924942,
0.5668755173683167,
-0.3829558491706848,
-0.8983529210090637,
0.5956090688705444,
0.293215274810791,
0.1744517683982849,
-0.039984866976737976,
-0.43796035647392273,
0.18628597259521484,
0.11883877962827682,
0.7553800344467163,
-0.2290300577878952,
-0.5982750654220581,
-0.06221562996506691,
0.24946850538253784,
-0.2134181708097458,
-0.27843284606933594,
0.8790884613990784,
-0.4586276412010193,
0.2380506545305252,
0.7342904806137085,
0.2953561544418335,
0.3322575092315674,
0.13942363858222961,
0.4214427173137665,
-1.0328118801116943,
0.38382044434547424,
0.23887968063354492,
-0.07043395936489105,
0.39852744340896606,
-0.12526898086071014,
0.44076627492904663,
0.3641483187675476,
-0.5187374353408813,
-1.0013731718063354,
0.38442665338516235,
-0.686122715473175,
-0.05290599167346954,
1.3249695301055908,
-0.20505020022392273,
0.0770709365606308,
-0.17405487596988678,
-0.35842475295066833,
0.5461865067481995,
-0.23793508112430573,
0.4246280789375305,
0.47357097268104553,
-0.24552303552627563,
0.08937139809131622,
-0.7690002918243408,
0.7913432121276855,
0.4048880636692047,
-0.48524296283721924,
0.10979317128658295,
0.22096499800682068,
0.006301018875092268,
0.210068017244339,
0.888110876083374,
-0.16996540129184723,
0.15797804296016693,
0.37274056673049927,
-0.2840293049812317,
0.24468044936656952,
-0.30516815185546875,
-0.40609046816825867,
-0.12810207903385162,
-0.04103429242968559,
-0.610867440700531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00620v1 | Actor Identification in Discourse: A Challenge for LLMs? | 2024-02-01T14:30:39 | 2024-02-01T14:30:39 | Ana Barić, Sean Papay, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL | The identification of political actors who put forward claims in public
debate is a crucial step in the construction of discourse networks, which are
helpful to analyze societal debates. Actor identification is, however, rather
challenging: Often, the locally mentioned speaker of a claim is only a pronoun
("He proposed that [claim]"), so recovering the canonical actor name requires
discourse understanding. We compare a traditional pipeline of dedicated NLP
components (similar to those applied to the related task of coreference) with a
LLM, which appears a good match for this generation task. Evaluating on a
corpus of German actors in newspaper reports, we find surprisingly that the LLM
performs worse. Further analysis reveals that the LLM is very good at
identifying the right reference, but struggles to generate the correct
canonical form. This points to an underlying issue in LLMs with controlling
generated output. Indeed, a hybrid model combining the LLM with a classifier to
normalize its output substantially outperforms both initial models. | [
-0.2545919418334961,
-0.4205249845981598,
0.6666955947875977,
-0.2994559407234192,
-0.15908901393413544,
0.42863136529922485,
-0.31027549505233765,
-0.4782240092754364,
0.3438182473182678,
0.7613528370857239,
-0.29880839586257935,
-0.057880159467458725,
-0.7653677463531494,
0.16702744364738464,
-0.45910584926605225,
0.7979546785354614,
0.08684054017066956,
0.10769413411617279,
-0.3658009171485901,
-0.11260423064231873,
-0.049348652362823486,
-0.6251935958862305,
-0.8080673813819885,
-0.727923572063446,
0.7530266046524048,
0.24460722506046295,
0.6432068943977356,
0.4105059802532196,
0.4337465465068817,
0.4445211887359619,
-0.2922026813030243,
0.30404165387153625,
-0.3305831253528595,
0.11269669979810715,
-0.49090489745140076,
-0.4815797507762909,
-0.1772657036781311,
0.08366288989782333,
0.8893095850944519,
0.8319538831710815,
0.1820283830165863,
0.24901607632637024,
0.020705141127109528,
0.6994456648826599,
-0.6922139525413513,
0.01861911453306675,
-0.9339504241943359,
0.010547466576099396,
-0.47215309739112854,
-0.20466665923595428,
-0.3567180335521698,
-0.4495845437049866,
0.11882808804512024,
-0.33401787281036377,
0.4183864891529083,
-0.014662128873169422,
1.086940884590149,
-0.1695239096879959,
-0.6539771556854248,
-0.4220057427883148,
-1.1646397113800049,
0.5759835243225098,
-0.6136239171028137,
-0.33777284622192383,
0.08305812627077103,
0.17964011430740356,
-0.2549533247947693,
-0.5733360052108765,
-0.482257604598999,
-0.21505975723266602,
-0.17281214892864227,
0.050827112048864365,
-0.30321767926216125,
0.23698951303958893,
0.059175532311201096,
0.3835182785987854,
-0.21775507926940918,
0.3783893883228302,
-0.4500545263290405,
-0.4514187276363373,
0.612268328666687,
0.0032219882123172283,
-0.020098287612199783,
-0.6134058833122253,
-0.4523109495639801,
0.3029870092868805,
-0.7771770358085632,
-0.037884850054979324,
0.7135648131370544,
0.4274437129497528,
0.24573272466659546,
0.6083565354347229,
0.03287558630108833,
0.2960434854030609,
0.45000025629997253,
-0.18423685431480408,
-0.10245472192764282,
0.0649622455239296,
-0.2967853248119354,
0.24225308001041412,
0.6372578740119934,
0.11047420650720596,
0.23827245831489563,
-0.03824356570839882,
-0.04156973958015442,
0.09933546185493469,
0.25300532579421997,
-0.3604778051376343,
0.08490471541881561,
0.03141477704048157,
-0.31078997254371643,
-0.4334944188594818,
0.34937262535095215,
-0.3961626887321472,
-0.6967863440513611,
-0.3278766870498657,
0.1257561594247818,
0.04105767607688904,
-0.4643181562423706,
-0.46230003237724304,
0.006877729203552008,
0.4228072166442871,
0.41029092669487,
-0.6205953359603882,
0.38637688755989075,
0.8299841284751892,
0.4644812047481537,
-0.3932746946811676,
0.12158481776714325,
-0.5256682634353638,
0.27771684527397156,
-0.7203308343887329,
0.993138313293457,
-0.5934591293334961,
-0.32210975885391235,
0.22032895684242249,
0.14171229302883148,
-0.1962767094373703,
-0.9971919655799866,
0.5578038692474365,
-0.4957183003425598,
0.16038605570793152,
-0.5123043060302734,
-0.7999820113182068,
0.14900769293308258,
0.10599194467067719,
-0.6514581441879272,
0.7966464757919312,
-0.1111646294593811,
-0.7521803379058838,
0.2920130491256714,
-0.31184571981430054,
-0.27802008390426636,
0.3687133193016052,
-0.6231212615966797,
-0.18473273515701294,
0.4735080301761627,
-0.30000635981559753,
0.5698361396789551,
-0.3893032968044281,
0.6303430199623108,
-0.025731701403856277,
-0.09223226457834244,
0.4179643988609314,
-0.11924080550670624,
0.4981324076652527,
0.015991564840078354,
-0.02313501201570034,
0.13168251514434814,
-0.8746037483215332,
-0.5296962857246399,
0.1980918049812317,
-0.3659842610359192,
-0.13852103054523468,
0.22871463000774384,
-0.1872507631778717,
-0.13616669178009033,
-0.002419493393972516,
-0.5504558086395264,
-0.07558916509151459,
-0.20452415943145752,
0.3458448052406311,
1.0647715330123901,
0.011921417899429798,
0.6483465433120728,
-0.5340260863304138,
0.46960872411727905,
-0.08626583963632584,
-0.48621681332588196,
-0.09290636330842972,
-0.5088098645210266,
-0.8384988307952881,
-0.17425471544265747,
0.6499857902526855,
0.6887966990470886,
-0.7276372909545898,
0.13655933737754822,
-0.07595866173505783,
-0.357730895280838,
-0.2644316852092743,
-0.12002507597208023,
0.32874152064323425,
0.6105101108551025,
-0.1733037531375885,
-0.2477191984653473,
-0.7600312232971191,
-1.3213950395584106,
-0.6553300619125366,
-0.6592757105827332,
-0.3094205856323242,
0.5186669826507568,
0.39585959911346436,
0.25667721033096313,
0.865127682685852,
-0.13329452276229858,
-0.22508695721626282,
-0.3289494514465332,
0.3155544400215149,
0.21489785611629486,
0.2641478180885315,
0.25338461995124817,
-0.6665225625038147,
-0.23073315620422363,
-0.015427551232278347,
-0.5797907114028931,
-0.14892490208148956,
-0.34771978855133057,
0.06635326147079468,
0.10256928950548172,
0.4883841872215271,
-0.5833662152290344,
0.003428664058446884,
0.32893842458724976,
-0.16780900955200195,
0.7865325808525085,
0.012795316986739635,
-0.16070832312107086,
-1.1684479713439941,
0.25327104330062866,
0.019610581919550896,
-0.4141802191734314,
-0.6603866815567017,
-0.020237892866134644,
-0.3947432041168213,
-0.14257749915122986,
-0.7021085023880005,
0.32869917154312134,
-0.3570941388607025,
-0.026122186332941055,
-0.24985305964946747,
0.22268979251384735,
-0.3905666470527649,
0.2401590794324875,
0.017864292487502098,
0.4985427260398865,
0.3251825273036957,
-0.6067054271697998,
0.451413631439209,
-0.05047224089503288,
-0.4322583079338074,
0.8193333148956299,
-0.3522111177444458,
0.40004682540893555,
-0.4590066969394684,
0.4238625168800354,
-1.0687360763549805,
-0.5416387915611267,
0.3236961364746094,
-0.14451061189174652,
0.3905200660228729,
-0.3433511555194855,
-0.485232949256897,
-0.1658587008714676,
0.07978879660367966,
0.13493433594703674,
0.30790695548057556,
-0.3005964756011963,
0.8513195514678955,
0.5408446192741394,
-0.2260352373123169,
-0.4505455493927002,
-0.5334078073501587,
0.3975622355937958,
-0.5089331269264221,
-0.4569118916988373,
0.7554001808166504,
0.3684583604335785,
-0.34869858622550964,
-0.06814995408058167,
-0.19268763065338135,
-0.15083979070186615,
0.045360203832387924,
0.14198845624923706,
-0.02930321730673313,
-0.22711001336574554,
0.14702585339546204,
-0.06622364372015,
-0.3287336826324463,
0.24801941215991974,
0.2693026661872864,
0.04449893534183502,
0.012858033180236816,
-0.23861701786518097,
-0.4658717215061188,
0.7083120346069336,
0.26685014367103577,
0.20665225386619568,
0.23982176184654236,
0.26671484112739563,
-0.3977471590042114,
-0.07087137550115585,
-0.6232563853263855,
-0.0035655430983752012,
-0.4389675259590149,
0.17886000871658325,
-0.16472533345222473,
-0.842752993106842,
0.498050719499588,
-0.7429355978965759,
0.08491311967372894,
0.6686747074127197,
0.5572571158409119,
-0.2222364842891693,
0.5920099020004272,
0.3155965507030487,
0.035540059208869934,
0.10874279588460922,
-0.03963416442275047,
0.0715942308306694,
-0.5971298217773438,
-0.10450803488492966,
-0.7547556161880493,
-0.4686586558818817,
-0.6857305765151978,
-0.35877373814582825,
0.1745108813047409,
-0.08337974548339844,
0.08537757396697998,
0.3012734055519104,
-0.32835716009140015,
0.5992045998573303,
0.41408443450927734,
-0.18404267728328705,
0.39351338148117065,
-0.11655935645103455,
-0.16213510930538177,
-0.23359687626361847,
-0.5571281313896179,
-1.0012636184692383,
0.5154919624328613,
0.3431832790374756,
0.5118713974952698,
0.3118205666542053,
0.7943646907806396,
0.3013283610343933,
0.336892694234848,
-0.6096388697624207,
0.9341725707054138,
-0.10466431081295013,
-0.7749277353286743,
0.2689499855041504,
-0.21859456598758698,
-0.9772508144378662,
0.4696460962295532,
-0.3343575596809387,
-0.9144145846366882,
0.36198264360427856,
0.24535246193408966,
-0.4593125581741333,
0.4489753842353821,
-0.285197377204895,
0.5827212333679199,
-0.0060874479822814465,
-0.09901867061853409,
-0.13675899803638458,
-0.5709383487701416,
0.3518737256526947,
0.05907158926129341,
0.2140425145626068,
-0.45241639018058777,
0.0033906775061041117,
0.8493965864181519,
-0.31588828563690186,
1.1212894916534424,
-0.1404857635498047,
0.0339200533926487,
0.4777030944824219,
0.011110363528132439,
0.5438922047615051,
0.043511658906936646,
-0.033083196729421616,
-0.2160513699054718,
-0.10988694429397583,
-0.3714214265346527,
-0.3503190279006958,
0.5147182941436768,
-0.6362932324409485,
-1.0162250995635986,
-0.48766466975212097,
-0.07726804167032242,
-0.10705902427434921,
-0.10026226192712784,
0.44508931040763855,
0.2635353207588196,
-0.6741572022438049,
0.3453221619129181,
0.6444814205169678,
-0.05539413541555405,
0.5238178372383118,
0.3120405972003937,
0.00025302727590315044,
-0.3231050968170166,
0.8765586614608765,
0.25356194376945496,
0.18573226034641266,
0.30979305505752563,
0.3417903184890747,
-0.04103480279445648,
-0.3915267586708069,
-0.2965624928474426,
0.23895439505577087,
-0.6941560506820679,
-0.20233292877674103,
-0.3861505687236786,
-0.33053648471832275,
-0.0020248957443982363,
-0.07547015696763992,
-0.5141483545303345,
-0.503108561038971,
-0.5941342711448669,
-0.15454208850860596,
-0.22417250275611877,
0.7348441481590271,
-0.039219293743371964,
0.2462705671787262,
-0.2559210956096649,
0.20580989122390747,
0.4997747540473938,
-0.05081823468208313,
-0.21868614852428436,
-0.4400060474872589,
-0.05604216456413269,
-0.43545466661453247,
-0.7214311361312866,
-1.1877402067184448,
-0.11910916864871979,
0.2638457715511322,
0.5291890501976013,
0.6600268483161926,
0.28058481216430664,
0.44554322957992554,
-0.5230001211166382,
1.2247816324234009,
0.13158129155635834,
-0.7023968696594238,
0.4689222276210785,
-0.18505477905273438,
0.11537512391805649,
0.32671549916267395,
0.36952903866767883,
-0.32553157210350037,
-0.6251624226570129,
-0.8504326939582825,
-0.8846401572227478,
0.4161856770515442,
0.2847314774990082,
0.4916248917579651,
-0.2201426476240158,
0.2779309153556824,
0.15821392834186554,
0.22730691730976105,
-0.6597282886505127,
-0.15879593789577484,
0.2522570490837097,
0.4067351520061493,
-0.0014008033322170377,
-0.565226137638092,
-0.3963170349597931,
-0.09202004969120026,
0.5395691990852356,
-0.19469667971134186,
0.3419073522090912,
0.5534955859184265,
-0.09293512254953384,
-0.252617210149765,
0.4703123867511749,
0.7473024725914001,
0.6432552337646484,
0.12352001667022705,
0.4203834533691406,
0.08208920806646347,
0.12881140410900116,
0.16990278661251068,
-0.18250371515750885,
-0.19682851433753967,
0.49868276715278625,
0.5962942838668823,
0.7612903714179993,
0.3871176838874817,
-0.334597110748291,
0.4152723550796509,
0.21133168041706085,
-0.6795063018798828,
-0.6382881999015808,
-0.030107881873846054,
0.1674654632806778,
0.44153469800949097,
0.872868537902832,
0.22243991494178772,
-0.08188893646001816,
-0.6956720352172852,
-0.05156600847840309,
0.44819116592407227,
-0.15082639455795288,
-0.5220715999603271,
0.5152327418327332,
0.4548766613006592,
-0.7247729301452637,
0.17203845083713531,
-0.12233530730009079,
-0.5074616074562073,
0.6255443096160889,
0.4969637989997864,
0.9873096346855164,
-0.22221030294895172,
0.4733952283859253,
0.1764441579580307,
0.14495182037353516,
0.10835643112659454,
-0.07373026013374329,
0.06316354125738144,
-0.9641720652580261,
-0.634928822517395,
-0.19582070410251617,
-0.6251966953277588,
0.35441747307777405,
-0.6161705255508423,
0.10634950548410416,
-0.5920752286911011,
-0.5395456552505493,
0.22646202147006989,
0.16660161316394806,
-0.4625154435634613,
-0.31583720445632935,
0.5733472108840942,
0.5837615728378296,
-1.051855444908142,
0.7029417753219604,
0.6846364736557007,
0.13139882683753967,
-0.5002419948577881,
0.01891837827861309,
0.22036416828632355,
-0.3012530505657196,
0.535256564617157,
-0.019897326827049255,
-0.01883801259100437,
-0.15661349892616272,
-0.4346873164176941,
-0.6167916059494019,
0.8688808083534241,
0.8477533459663391,
-0.5460554361343384,
-0.3183439373970032,
0.2649388313293457,
0.45669469237327576,
-0.7656393051147461,
0.024602049961686134,
0.30453288555145264,
0.5707483887672424,
0.3346526026725769,
-0.8667662143707275,
0.047511328011751175,
0.11864286661148071,
0.25042420625686646,
0.03563755378127098,
-0.696324348449707,
0.6675254702568054,
-0.05828312411904335,
-0.4410024583339691,
0.0399981364607811,
0.9545181393623352,
0.2189732789993286,
0.30766111612319946,
0.6478352546691895,
0.13988055288791656,
0.960252046585083,
0.1148829534649849,
0.9146259427070618,
0.14820906519889832,
0.12473905086517334,
1.1859012842178345,
-0.33441418409347534,
0.7401983737945557,
0.6330051422119141,
-0.12704961001873016,
0.5082491636276245,
0.7218024134635925,
-0.018163789063692093,
0.2971448004245758,
0.4355991780757904,
-0.32380059361457825,
-0.45250403881073,
-0.1346312314271927,
-0.03191767632961273,
0.5321476459503174,
0.21662384271621704,
-0.5092876553535461,
-0.424997478723526,
-0.30145394802093506,
0.03569997847080231,
0.5460919737815857,
-0.2630128562450409,
0.8524748086929321,
0.26854953169822693,
-0.7660198211669922,
0.31960076093673706,
0.046101056039333344,
0.3215782046318054,
-0.26301002502441406,
0.11888186633586884,
-0.030718838796019554,
0.01630731113255024,
-0.35554835200309753,
-0.34640008211135864,
0.6145557165145874,
-0.07205623388290405,
-0.21498006582260132,
-0.1998509168624878,
0.8961938619613647,
-0.28835323452949524,
-0.3686692714691162,
0.19299492239952087,
0.5412929654121399,
0.3007809519767761,
0.17806322872638702,
-0.7111861109733582,
-0.05852533504366875,
-0.2522088289260864,
-0.3199262320995331,
0.2788621187210083,
0.1507040411233902,
-0.07713951915502548,
0.3312690854072571,
0.3650107681751251,
0.15409748256206512,
-0.007118007633835077,
-0.07979951798915863,
0.7032075524330139,
-0.4149969518184662,
-0.015317895449697971,
-0.884556770324707,
0.3990941643714905,
-0.1950952708721161,
-0.365085244178772,
0.5716710090637207,
0.5611518025398254,
0.7172764539718628,
-0.0884743481874466,
0.5527607798576355,
-0.012526068836450577,
0.7037224173545837,
-0.46479418873786926,
0.37277644872665405,
-0.14796258509159088,
0.16751837730407715,
-0.3035512864589691,
-0.7783392667770386,
-0.11230269074440002,
0.35873743891716003,
-0.11036578565835953,
-0.22595202922821045,
0.6949439644813538,
0.6323584318161011,
-0.01863330975174904,
-0.17943722009658813,
0.37578389048576355,
0.09976305812597275,
0.2206089049577713,
0.4237946569919586,
0.9587838649749756,
-0.24905429780483246,
0.4720381498336792,
-0.0616794116795063,
0.022923830896615982,
-0.2514718770980835,
-1.0998330116271973,
-0.8340849280357361,
-0.6322501301765442,
-0.6608228087425232,
-0.281442254781723,
0.01998046226799488,
0.8785173892974854,
0.7587363719940186,
-0.7189399600028992,
-0.4860871434211731,
0.0009783260757103562,
0.31036216020584106,
-0.25540637969970703,
-0.16970916092395782,
0.1124638020992279,
-0.18535476922988892,
-0.8888304233551025,
0.4823085367679596,
-0.015803517773747444,
-0.3748757839202881,
-0.3141786754131317,
0.07221224904060364,
-0.26739299297332764,
0.4895714521408081,
0.44398704171180725,
0.45547136664390564,
-1.1830586194992065,
-0.5055745840072632,
-0.39661267399787903,
-0.0067214746959507465,
0.19174964725971222,
1.2552317380905151,
-0.662824273109436,
0.29703035950660706,
0.2973186671733856,
0.7500391602516174,
0.5305547118186951,
0.06587786972522736,
0.7750718593597412,
-0.9405693411827087,
0.012679655104875565,
0.4509570002555847,
0.26080214977264404,
0.4344438910484314,
-0.37693002820014954,
0.3045400083065033,
0.5165101885795593,
-0.5511094331741333,
-0.9427722692489624,
0.6273236870765686,
-0.9825347661972046,
-0.22441940009593964,
1.1196080446243286,
0.022850433364510536,
-0.34220361709594727,
-0.11820900440216064,
-0.20739343762397766,
0.031245315447449684,
-0.3344901502132416,
0.41633811593055725,
0.8453445434570312,
-0.17138144373893738,
-0.3217688202857971,
-0.3933735489845276,
0.5107163190841675,
0.2519691586494446,
-0.20286263525485992,
-0.08505742996931076,
0.16563552618026733,
0.2237415611743927,
0.4381929337978363,
0.796481192111969,
-0.022059669718146324,
-0.04473080858588219,
-0.3328280448913574,
-0.17537261545658112,
0.4063030183315277,
-0.21155129373073578,
-0.1942657083272934,
0.5726476907730103,
0.22207865118980408,
-0.07198620587587357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01775v1 | Design and consensus content validity of the questionnaire for b-learning education: A 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic Delphi based Decision Support Tool | 2024-02-01T13:32:18 | 2024-02-01T13:32:18 | Rosana Montes, Cristina Zuheros, Jeovani M. Morales, Noe Zermeño, Jerónimo Duran, Francsico Herrera | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC | Classic Delphi and Fuzzy Delphi methods are used to test content validity of
data collection tools such as questionnaires. Fuzzy Delphi takes the opinion
issued by judges from a linguistic perspective reducing ambiguity in opinions
by using fuzzy numbers. We propose an extension named 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic
Delphi method to deal with scenarios in which judges show different expertise
degrees by using fuzzy multigranular semantics of the linguistic terms and to
obtain intermediate and final results expressed by 2-tuple linguistic values.
The key idea of our proposal is to validate the full questionnaire by means of
the evaluation of its parts, defining the validity of each item as a Decision
Making problem. Taking the opinion of experts, we measure the degree of
consensus, the degree of consistency, and the linguistic score of each item, in
order to detect those items that affect, positively or negatively, the quality
of the instrument. Considering the real need to evaluate a b-learning
educational experience with a consensual questionnaire, we present a Decision
Making model for questionnaire validation that solves it. Additionally, we
contribute to this consensus reaching problem by developing an online tool
under GPL v3 license. The software visualizes the collective valuations for
each iteration and assists to determine which parts of the questionnaire should
be modified to reach a consensual solution. | [
-0.7165065407752991,
-0.8827970623970032,
0.17723721265792847,
0.16521047055721283,
-0.5283676385879517,
0.3084884285926819,
-0.4326245188713074,
-0.3671407699584961,
-0.07788490504026413,
0.11349187046289444,
-0.3643823564052582,
-0.37370437383651733,
-0.7319570183753967,
-0.08573449403047562,
-0.22492530941963196,
0.7135769724845886,
0.3146575689315796,
0.273058146238327,
-0.1208421066403389,
0.07591734826564789,
-0.6272582411766052,
-0.26129791140556335,
-0.8015551567077637,
-0.3987184166908264,
0.2201758623123169,
1.07207453250885,
0.590362012386322,
-0.31590336561203003,
0.4663575291633606,
0.23609651625156403,
-0.19813062250614166,
0.372773677110672,
-0.4035012125968933,
0.16368621587753296,
-0.5590962171554565,
-0.41299256682395935,
-0.4943286180496216,
0.2787568271160126,
0.454555869102478,
0.6225599050521851,
-0.5322642922401428,
0.22742725908756256,
0.3265424966812134,
0.7350550293922424,
-0.47033101320266724,
0.06309475004673004,
-0.5462082028388977,
0.017774146050214767,
0.09022027254104614,
0.3400232791900635,
-0.39769691228866577,
-0.8225205540657043,
0.4809917211532593,
-0.3636513650417328,
0.12866279482841492,
-0.10282566398382187,
0.7415651679039001,
0.18723031878471375,
-0.270620733499527,
-0.11986114829778671,
-0.4803627133369446,
0.6635667681694031,
-0.7684707045555115,
0.7710787653923035,
0.6467238664627075,
0.5489442944526672,
-0.05684586986899376,
-0.39268508553504944,
-0.8369222283363342,
-0.17672257125377655,
-0.052323754876852036,
0.3142602741718292,
0.40499818325042725,
0.1454750895500183,
0.0693468227982521,
0.38711175322532654,
-0.534240186214447,
0.09360861778259277,
-0.8271626830101013,
-0.05458787828683853,
0.7336987257003784,
-0.1859637200832367,
-0.15447641909122467,
-0.11550187319517136,
-0.32395076751708984,
0.13076899945735931,
-0.49573957920074463,
-0.011531798169016838,
0.2777833938598633,
0.22170105576515198,
-0.2533881366252899,
0.6537020802497864,
-0.19520244002342224,
0.7737720608711243,
0.42844313383102417,
-0.02772034890949726,
0.44718196988105774,
-0.2670542895793915,
-0.22836865484714508,
-0.001985569018870592,
0.6532334685325623,
0.738875687122345,
0.4710540175437927,
0.030036738142371178,
-0.016576141119003296,
0.021059712395071983,
0.31123411655426025,
-0.5559876561164856,
-0.16413256525993347,
0.5338176488876343,
-0.3971244692802429,
-0.06483454257249832,
-0.003494845936074853,
-1.0349818468093872,
-0.45493271946907043,
-0.5802390575408936,
0.4713105857372284,
-0.7259767055511475,
-0.7034996747970581,
0.3055071532726288,
-0.2541711926460266,
0.33746835589408875,
0.4225199520587921,
-1.001875638961792,
0.3345319330692291,
0.783904492855072,
0.7627529501914978,
-0.3021877706050873,
-0.31460899114608765,
0.016193179413676262,
-0.12872087955474854,
-0.30736657977104187,
0.8030712604522705,
-0.5969519019126892,
-0.7291855812072754,
-0.02413984388113022,
-0.3528762459754944,
-0.025131918489933014,
-0.4202174246311188,
0.3301964998245239,
-0.28412064909935,
0.629055380821228,
-0.23725071549415588,
-0.8477458357810974,
-0.5596896409988403,
0.7419519424438477,
-0.5181986689567566,
0.865979790687561,
0.36017894744873047,
-0.47414082288742065,
0.8029069900512695,
-0.5540573596954346,
-0.23715873062610626,
0.2334441840648651,
-0.2095138281583786,
-0.25575175881385803,
-0.058329060673713684,
-0.3371073603630066,
0.27318844199180603,
-0.22501538693904877,
0.5345190167427063,
-0.34431952238082886,
-0.32987844944000244,
0.2982308566570282,
-0.30221617221832275,
0.6629467010498047,
0.136773020029068,
-0.3225350081920624,
-0.14345180988311768,
-0.7830777168273926,
0.2435029149055481,
-0.3965400159358978,
-0.4677916467189789,
-0.20386268198490143,
0.14015445113182068,
-0.20181059837341309,
0.38809889554977417,
0.3526790738105774,
-0.5924294590950012,
0.21820276975631714,
-0.4064539670944214,
-0.1301942616701126,
0.558223307132721,
0.2942380905151367,
0.3513113558292389,
-0.502958357334137,
0.26900017261505127,
0.16445107758045197,
0.49725693464279175,
0.5787366628646851,
-0.683649480342865,
-0.8592600226402283,
-0.029309017583727837,
0.42613187432289124,
0.5214264392852783,
-0.6167703866958618,
0.5019640326499939,
0.19972051680088043,
-0.9352068901062012,
-0.4835978150367737,
0.03884788230061531,
0.3971494138240814,
0.5170948505401611,
0.34272390604019165,
-0.19838157296180725,
-0.40092313289642334,
-0.74067622423172,
0.2246560901403427,
-0.4480780065059662,
0.17758066952228546,
0.05833740159869194,
0.4349043667316437,
0.12656989693641663,
0.7195879817008972,
-0.3824729025363922,
-0.255300909280777,
-0.40118733048439026,
-0.06824439764022827,
0.2878294885158539,
0.7020715475082397,
0.7121610641479492,
-0.844892144203186,
-0.35634028911590576,
-0.1649159938097,
-0.2967521548271179,
0.048110481351614,
0.2643577456474304,
-0.3298843502998352,
0.48436808586120605,
-0.2302989512681961,
-0.2705210745334625,
0.23292988538742065,
0.40299636125564575,
-0.4945206642150879,
0.6283751130104065,
-0.016893206164240837,
0.4769764840602875,
-0.9219397902488708,
0.06295739859342575,
0.08487492799758911,
0.10437028855085373,
-0.3449003994464874,
0.13764406740665436,
-0.02561524137854576,
0.08842182159423828,
-0.46187180280685425,
0.40310847759246826,
0.2578263580799103,
0.35238102078437805,
-0.10507198423147202,
0.6129360198974609,
0.13245323300361633,
0.43133294582366943,
0.31740716099739075,
0.4885161817073822,
0.6008310914039612,
-0.7209024429321289,
0.6457101106643677,
0.601155698299408,
-0.4050758481025696,
1.3110764026641846,
-0.6334362030029297,
-0.04615485668182373,
-0.04994463548064232,
-0.09867507964372635,
-1.1730575561523438,
-0.04050179943442345,
0.6434913277626038,
-0.7508937120437622,
0.2345835119485855,
-0.19733752310276031,
-0.21942844986915588,
-0.08021761476993561,
-0.27551180124282837,
0.09190527349710464,
0.29637598991394043,
-0.13464628159999847,
0.1685251146554947,
0.3818309009075165,
-0.17647358775138855,
-0.4888973534107208,
-0.7729976773262024,
-0.16812492907047272,
-0.011095575988292694,
-0.6241998076438904,
-0.004733797628432512,
-0.33614012598991394,
-0.3721254765987396,
-0.02562415599822998,
-0.182728111743927,
-0.41152840852737427,
0.1946980357170105,
0.0719652846455574,
0.416041761636734,
-0.038151875138282776,
0.25562727451324463,
0.2193969190120697,
0.0008730633999221027,
0.11811237037181854,
-0.17455048859119415,
0.5050808787345886,
-0.03669504076242447,
-0.4095152020454407,
-0.022194726392626762,
0.5161064267158508,
0.45771732926368713,
-0.5282301902770996,
0.4452027380466461,
0.21400171518325806,
-0.7492719292640686,
-0.23076072335243225,
-0.6674163341522217,
0.1096113845705986,
-0.4363281726837158,
0.03340468183159828,
-0.0314253494143486,
-0.683356761932373,
0.2407221496105194,
0.17471805214881897,
0.38530465960502625,
0.21519164741039276,
0.7536318302154541,
0.0388992615044117,
0.6580829620361328,
0.24129784107208252,
0.26256465911865234,
0.31462347507476807,
-0.5744728446006775,
0.09181246161460876,
-0.5843274593353271,
-1.1121115684509277,
-0.667085587978363,
-0.637829601764679,
-0.3600422143936157,
0.0169138852506876,
0.22076642513275146,
-0.2535835802555084,
-0.5093436241149902,
-0.044567566365003586,
-0.5356194376945496,
0.06801264733076096,
0.9334133863449097,
0.5138756632804871,
0.054508935660123825,
-0.1187971755862236,
-0.2605396807193756,
0.04181937500834465,
-0.1713048368692398,
-0.3272419273853302,
0.6746822595596313,
-0.07546945661306381,
0.6370731592178345,
0.5734796524047852,
0.7336621880531311,
0.5206661224365234,
-0.037795472890138626,
-1.1215800046920776,
0.6027411818504333,
-0.0501321405172348,
-0.9138234257698059,
-0.34691041707992554,
-0.11184796690940857,
-0.6086010336875916,
0.30290472507476807,
-0.4742938280105591,
-0.6077072620391846,
0.2388269007205963,
-0.13737356662750244,
-0.35397326946258545,
0.12562209367752075,
-0.7412077784538269,
0.9205025434494019,
-0.32944825291633606,
-0.41042613983154297,
-0.5186072587966919,
-0.5745446085929871,
0.12660035490989685,
-0.2120332270860672,
0.041515450924634933,
-0.14338615536689758,
-0.051239270716905594,
0.7191713452339172,
-0.2221517115831375,
0.6738232374191284,
-0.5411476492881775,
-0.04690084233880043,
0.595214307308197,
0.3339918553829193,
-0.2609008252620697,
0.1731216162443161,
-0.4752531051635742,
0.02547065168619156,
0.20749105513095856,
-0.21124722063541412,
-0.604766309261322,
0.47392353415489197,
-0.7384452819824219,
-0.7533423900604248,
-0.490401953458786,
-0.03199130296707153,
-0.5836385488510132,
0.40078964829444885,
0.07471014559268951,
0.5031328201293945,
-0.07258512079715729,
0.16587604582309723,
0.5525522232055664,
0.14265431463718414,
0.10447099804878235,
0.7482870221138,
-0.24147537350654602,
-0.4925799071788788,
0.7803593277931213,
0.2764027416706085,
0.2577202618122101,
0.18551987409591675,
0.336394339799881,
-0.5505632758140564,
-0.7830593585968018,
-0.44065380096435547,
0.013590252958238125,
-0.6527919769287109,
-0.33034616708755493,
-0.013383455574512482,
-0.24030108749866486,
-0.4570942223072052,
-0.13961800932884216,
0.14329120516777039,
-0.6668022871017456,
-0.05564950406551361,
-0.4650942385196686,
0.2428891956806183,
0.506385087966919,
-0.3777052164077759,
0.3016684949398041,
-0.8154869079589844,
0.22658301889896393,
0.22692672908306122,
0.7358747720718384,
-0.2487594336271286,
-0.7077866196632385,
-0.12037979066371918,
0.2814413905143738,
-0.4962952136993408,
-1.0428268909454346,
-0.19778497517108917,
0.3651770353317261,
0.7067422270774841,
0.4447307884693146,
0.017504682764410973,
0.31137198209762573,
-0.1297658085823059,
1.0946203470230103,
0.002183539094403386,
-0.8960081934928894,
0.7267221212387085,
-0.07829539477825165,
-0.14640434086322784,
0.9345006346702576,
0.48757365345954895,
-0.7246301174163818,
-0.5124322175979614,
-0.8171607255935669,
-0.49547943472862244,
0.4497451186180115,
-0.201945498585701,
-0.14561906456947327,
-0.19370658695697784,
0.39027440547943115,
0.2207266241312027,
0.44155213236808777,
-0.14586873352527618,
-0.25793352723121643,
-0.3684764504432678,
-0.1729188710451126,
0.18298162519931793,
-0.39422133564949036,
0.03422021120786667,
-0.12626954913139343,
0.8879669308662415,
0.13077819347381592,
-0.3299195468425751,
0.04026077315211296,
0.22716371715068817,
0.08941973000764847,
0.5283710956573486,
0.2664875090122223,
1.0384466648101807,
-0.171480193734169,
-0.044262029230594635,
0.21963123977184296,
-0.5385116338729858,
0.21851448714733124,
0.030679328367114067,
-0.22819922864437103,
-0.015068486332893372,
-0.10971200466156006,
0.06322190910577774,
0.26115918159484863,
-0.5300523042678833,
0.7763756513595581,
-0.09003660827875137,
-0.3232627213001251,
-0.3355640172958374,
0.29892614483833313,
-0.2871471345424652,
0.24917303025722504,
0.08802760392427444,
0.12038610130548477,
0.39671334624290466,
-0.23546186089515686,
0.43729040026664734,
0.15769319236278534,
-0.42005839943885803,
-0.042066484689712524,
0.43355345726013184,
0.47265273332595825,
-0.2360307276248932,
0.9041458964347839,
-0.31847429275512695,
-0.48294541239738464,
0.4032887816429138,
0.3457009792327881,
0.5239009261131287,
-0.4810791015625,
0.6670994162559509,
0.5634562373161316,
0.28603455424308777,
-0.16967710852622986,
0.960036039352417,
-0.06642303615808487,
-0.6479926705360413,
-0.31144770979881287,
-0.4507606029510498,
-0.9709681272506714,
-0.13145247101783752,
-0.6477208733558655,
0.6459243297576904,
-0.6526035070419312,
-0.17059792578220367,
-0.23601657152175903,
0.2191999852657318,
-0.40344318747520447,
0.8069700002670288,
0.2565372586250305,
1.2346111536026,
-0.6796349287033081,
0.4486810863018036,
1.0345302820205688,
-0.467293918132782,
-0.8941184282302856,
-0.5159487128257751,
0.1080084964632988,
-0.5105658173561096,
0.007579383905977011,
-0.02786938287317753,
-0.04657340794801712,
-0.28154996037483215,
-0.5476166605949402,
-0.5136723518371582,
0.6522641181945801,
0.10445801168680191,
-0.6420572996139526,
-0.042544007301330566,
0.11846500635147095,
0.4775950014591217,
0.3378559947013855,
0.14007052779197693,
0.5273768901824951,
0.7160062789916992,
0.5087365508079529,
-0.9765730500221252,
-0.12465890496969223,
-0.11047077178955078,
-0.7489041090011597,
0.2167626917362213,
-0.7864981889724731,
0.45977097749710083,
-0.2156485766172409,
0.05748186632990837,
-0.04431205615401268,
0.5709868669509888,
0.5553886890411377,
0.5119276642799377,
0.5608888864517212,
0.508177638053894,
0.9970592260360718,
-0.27234649658203125,
0.35279372334480286,
-0.43578389286994934,
0.6121591925621033,
0.9561328887939453,
-0.05264679715037346,
0.7979714274406433,
0.2837206721305847,
-0.31140804290771484,
0.4772873520851135,
0.9160192012786865,
-0.2085408717393875,
0.4367634952068329,
0.3301169276237488,
-0.3713088929653168,
-0.47292593121528625,
-0.19425439834594727,
-0.44224750995635986,
0.719028890132904,
0.6839667558670044,
0.1773545742034912,
-0.20138482749462128,
-0.25735658407211304,
0.05830158293247223,
0.11735115200281143,
-0.4962834119796753,
0.4961816966533661,
0.10506636649370193,
-0.9750581979751587,
0.24140743911266327,
-0.15306870639324188,
0.4126397669315338,
-0.6570167541503906,
-0.16179341077804565,
-0.2845805883407593,
0.14664852619171143,
-0.5782435536384583,
-1.2712059020996094,
0.4376864731311798,
-0.10438522696495056,
0.07188913226127625,
0.20694756507873535,
0.5472591519355774,
-0.6873836517333984,
-0.587981641292572,
-0.12765489518642426,
0.8154504299163818,
0.16551950573921204,
0.14436045289039612,
-0.5594006180763245,
-0.12561361491680145,
-0.2551429569721222,
0.1403350979089737,
-0.1406129151582718,
0.6212289929389954,
0.2968416213989258,
0.578506350517273,
0.17721198499202728,
0.3182958960533142,
-0.14211226999759674,
0.22480148077011108,
0.7159701585769653,
-0.21407155692577362,
-0.4606306552886963,
-0.626284658908844,
0.4196498990058899,
-0.1079486832022667,
-0.4225737750530243,
0.5060008764266968,
0.796204149723053,
1.1784553527832031,
0.28873902559280396,
0.9936232566833496,
-0.5795722603797913,
0.47890350222587585,
-0.4523316025733948,
0.8097296953201294,
-0.5875235199928284,
-0.17839327454566956,
-0.14401879906654358,
-0.6671310663223267,
-0.31105300784111023,
0.6752296090126038,
-0.10760573297739029,
0.08981820195913315,
0.6033933758735657,
0.44008249044418335,
0.06912552565336227,
0.37180110812187195,
0.28451448678970337,
-0.04744790494441986,
0.1351896971464157,
0.5773731470108032,
0.9763389825820923,
-0.006618674378842115,
0.542544424533844,
-0.3502420485019684,
-0.42983657121658325,
0.11321321874856949,
-0.5807266235351562,
-1.0276066064834595,
-0.7940324544906616,
-0.45151808857917786,
-0.5267391204833984,
0.04299468919634819,
1.2874910831451416,
0.362185537815094,
-0.7343782186508179,
-0.15903903543949127,
0.4738284945487976,
0.3813985288143158,
-0.28156691789627075,
-0.19101658463478088,
0.3156372606754303,
-0.22896763682365417,
-0.7095392942428589,
-0.03603227436542511,
-0.0687539279460907,
-0.07702390104532242,
-0.4068225026130676,
0.1058327928185463,
-0.22948218882083893,
-0.13531845808029175,
0.5516762137413025,
-0.09615902602672577,
-0.3801824748516083,
-0.7112137079238892,
0.024180516600608826,
0.09033066034317017,
-0.1117352545261383,
0.5854416489601135,
-0.5200838446617126,
0.5462026596069336,
0.7207273244857788,
0.40507256984710693,
-0.025132102891802788,
0.04970037564635277,
0.27509403228759766,
-0.37867656350135803,
-0.06326363235712051,
0.2563912570476532,
0.5305687785148621,
0.21657462418079376,
-0.10209063440561295,
0.5837861895561218,
0.2476707398891449,
-0.6018151640892029,
-0.21936871111392975,
0.3060399889945984,
-1.1729224920272827,
-0.029715847223997116,
1.3245747089385986,
-0.33783841133117676,
0.18788091838359833,
-0.34927356243133545,
-0.6768497824668884,
0.22190648317337036,
-0.5270591378211975,
1.1019673347473145,
0.8160794973373413,
-0.0373198427259922,
0.030316848307847977,
-0.06288391351699829,
0.2680567502975464,
0.022739121690392494,
-0.5131295919418335,
-0.25898081064224243,
0.6984150409698486,
0.3855232000350952,
-0.058692365884780884,
0.4556753635406494,
-0.25357767939567566,
0.6027095317840576,
-0.23533213138580322,
-0.22121872007846832,
-0.20648552477359772,
-0.30211618542671204,
-0.033268120139837265,
0.09261467307806015,
0.27386391162872314,
-0.45947393774986267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03471v1 | The Information of Large Language Model Geometry | 2024-02-01T12:50:43 | 2024-02-01T12:50:43 | Zhiquan Tan, Chenghai Li, Weiran Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | This paper investigates the information encoded in the embeddings of large
language models (LLMs). We conduct simulations to analyze the representation
entropy and discover a power law relationship with model sizes. Building upon
this observation, we propose a theory based on (conditional) entropy to
elucidate the scaling law phenomenon. Furthermore, we delve into the
auto-regressive structure of LLMs and examine the relationship between the last
token and previous context tokens using information theory and regression
techniques. Specifically, we establish a theoretical connection between the
information gain of new tokens and ridge regression. Additionally, we explore
the effectiveness of Lasso regression in selecting meaningful tokens, which
sometimes outperforms the closely related attention weights. Finally, we
conduct controlled experiments, and find that information is distributed across
tokens, rather than being concentrated in specific "meaningful" tokens alone. | [
0.006790459621697664,
-0.7522588968276978,
0.7958397269248962,
0.07390695810317993,
-0.028965068981051445,
-0.414912611246109,
-0.4553903043270111,
-0.27506139874458313,
0.4568433165550232,
0.563079833984375,
-0.28441303968429565,
-0.3934009075164795,
-0.8874585628509521,
-0.27547505497932434,
-0.5009161233901978,
0.6567503213882446,
0.06771082431077957,
0.2195582091808319,
-0.15807262063026428,
0.12750504910945892,
-0.272784024477005,
-0.8192027807235718,
-0.6760706305503845,
-0.03297550603747368,
0.5767768621444702,
-0.1299547255039215,
0.7263396978378296,
1.147304654121399,
0.6289571523666382,
0.3232249617576599,
-0.2370520979166031,
-0.32208308577537537,
-0.5737925171852112,
0.25878265500068665,
-0.006256570108234882,
-0.9251111745834351,
-0.32708218693733215,
-0.039400167763233185,
1.281200885772705,
0.721762478351593,
-0.17734003067016602,
0.19191192090511322,
0.13331562280654907,
0.48929908871650696,
-0.541926383972168,
0.5142132043838501,
-0.5697835683822632,
-0.007425681222230196,
-0.18568572402000427,
-0.27562281489372253,
-0.571047842502594,
-0.256552129983902,
-0.05984988436102867,
-0.6210033297538757,
-0.08910168707370758,
0.5600557327270508,
0.7054696679115295,
0.449130654335022,
-0.5635414123535156,
-0.3903142809867859,
-0.6435524821281433,
0.9245380759239197,
-0.7610942721366882,
0.6215490698814392,
0.4196801483631134,
0.08269339054822922,
-0.3139861822128296,
-0.5334333777427673,
-0.2015753537416458,
-0.32496199011802673,
-0.17827677726745605,
-0.4287864863872528,
-0.3237849175930023,
0.1863269805908203,
0.3933919370174408,
0.38260185718536377,
-0.44822725653648376,
0.23275695741176605,
-0.40549957752227783,
-0.26366594433784485,
0.5538740158081055,
0.13373978435993195,
0.4289548397064209,
-0.14464768767356873,
-0.19359126687049866,
-0.1044742614030838,
-0.8413606286048889,
-0.07899513095617294,
0.3476856052875519,
0.48252737522125244,
-0.17018543183803558,
0.7600391507148743,
0.2055734544992447,
0.7864046096801758,
-0.0025321426801383495,
-0.35997825860977173,
0.23746611177921295,
-0.21760690212249756,
-0.38464847207069397,
0.16226395964622498,
0.6915211081504822,
0.028984403237700462,
0.22598768770694733,
-0.2874891757965088,
-0.08807624131441116,
-0.5717011094093323,
0.03601181507110596,
-0.7307788729667664,
0.14761759340763092,
-0.04558899253606796,
-0.7528643608093262,
-0.0351179838180542,
0.24182787537574768,
-0.3244382441043854,
-0.5417003631591797,
-0.6154565215110779,
0.3234403431415558,
-0.21227620542049408,
-0.5231086611747742,
0.10364819318056107,
-0.22468285262584686,
0.36867403984069824,
0.23462152481079102,
-1.0262497663497925,
0.16119696199893951,
0.8932749629020691,
0.9199932217597961,
0.0910307988524437,
-0.17426453530788422,
-0.44486093521118164,
0.31959325075149536,
-0.16992036998271942,
0.23207326233386993,
-0.7130857110023499,
0.01971987821161747,
0.13139738142490387,
0.13698428869247437,
-0.09769551455974579,
-0.3128080666065216,
0.25397348403930664,
-0.6252442002296448,
0.03415794298052788,
-0.4025682806968689,
-0.8881327509880066,
-0.073591448366642,
0.022742019966244698,
-0.9199432134628296,
0.7455568313598633,
0.028033090755343437,
-0.888282835483551,
0.32009339332580566,
-0.38518014550209045,
-0.10003209859132767,
-0.038112226873636246,
-0.40732309222221375,
-0.07220110297203064,
0.43112215399742126,
-0.22801610827445984,
0.5947216153144836,
-0.5168377161026001,
0.33264243602752686,
-0.49030083417892456,
-0.09356299787759781,
0.2009653002023697,
-0.26347777247428894,
0.790944516658783,
0.26090362668037415,
-0.05737781524658203,
-0.05818087235093117,
-0.5045470595359802,
-0.13517309725284576,
0.23828522861003876,
-0.41878044605255127,
-0.6421552896499634,
-0.040503472089767456,
-0.1532507985830307,
-0.10163094103336334,
0.4463934898376465,
-0.571456253528595,
0.5319969654083252,
-0.09612350165843964,
0.41688257455825806,
0.6692653894424438,
-0.2118200659751892,
0.679213285446167,
0.016850758343935013,
0.4477878212928772,
-0.10376128554344177,
0.06890623271465302,
-0.022996678948402405,
-0.3560795187950134,
-0.5329563021659851,
-0.3333843946456909,
0.4165378212928772,
0.31695374846458435,
-0.21190829575061798,
0.3190801739692688,
-0.36399608850479126,
-0.023859554901719093,
-0.2883380353450775,
0.18743513524532318,
0.12939493358135223,
0.009041390381753445,
-0.11850692331790924,
0.05892204865813255,
-0.7345528602600098,
-0.9522073268890381,
-0.33466634154319763,
-0.33206799626350403,
-0.21968303620815277,
0.3714606463909149,
0.2622157633304596,
-0.046677302569150925,
0.8794124126434326,
-0.4851246178150177,
-0.12188616394996643,
-0.21533073484897614,
0.0031573143787682056,
0.3571426272392273,
0.4238848388195038,
0.8097078800201416,
-0.6485196352005005,
-0.07794548571109772,
-0.08186589181423187,
-0.6660358905792236,
0.07725483179092407,
0.12888988852500916,
0.06019464507699013,
0.037028711289167404,
0.9578807950019836,
-0.5543617606163025,
0.4053533673286438,
0.6245008111000061,
-0.4860215485095978,
0.23331844806671143,
-0.3939504325389862,
-0.17554044723510742,
-1.081259846687317,
-0.020795105025172234,
0.005346845369786024,
-0.15367759764194489,
-0.5560379028320312,
-0.1026708260178566,
0.0814160406589508,
0.13503612577915192,
-0.17787215113639832,
0.828050434589386,
-0.5883729457855225,
-0.2770655155181885,
-0.2553214728832245,
0.0051923757418990135,
-0.24642214179039001,
0.34722813963890076,
-0.1483154296875,
0.488976389169693,
0.6346456408500671,
-0.5266650319099426,
0.5074132084846497,
-0.2457176148891449,
-0.345829039812088,
0.2234591245651245,
-0.5780502557754517,
-0.16777996718883514,
-0.4799693822860718,
0.27716541290283203,
-1.0630009174346924,
-0.3954360783100128,
-0.2654266655445099,
-0.3037779927253723,
0.5071327686309814,
-0.27843576669692993,
-0.8655846118927002,
-0.2642367482185364,
-0.12196657061576843,
0.7273695468902588,
0.4330592453479767,
-0.46678099036216736,
0.6167804598808289,
0.8832122683525085,
-0.17685894668102264,
-0.4378291666507721,
-0.656559944152832,
0.00653971778228879,
-0.4836251139640808,
-0.6776619553565979,
0.07693243026733398,
0.12964707612991333,
-0.7052819728851318,
0.045456670224666595,
0.34908679127693176,
0.011892781592905521,
-0.040741145610809326,
0.2932577133178711,
0.011755919083952904,
-0.502545177936554,
0.6479169130325317,
-0.2896805703639984,
0.2197427600622177,
0.3270995318889618,
-0.563874363899231,
0.719230592250824,
-0.3388414978981018,
-0.18187592923641205,
-0.5236260890960693,
0.20429950952529907,
0.6433096528053284,
0.18739737570285797,
1.0136327743530273,
0.4178769886493683,
-0.47334009408950806,
0.05812666937708855,
-0.6133267283439636,
-0.14650940895080566,
-0.4678330421447754,
0.48783642053604126,
-0.25735628604888916,
-1.0176630020141602,
0.75259929895401,
0.03459887579083443,
-0.10429947078227997,
0.7294890880584717,
0.6424499750137329,
0.16633479297161102,
1.2366775274276733,
1.139310359954834,
-0.31776097416877747,
0.8740147948265076,
-0.24214304983615875,
0.30008605122566223,
-0.8997968435287476,
-0.3924684524536133,
-0.5332309603691101,
-0.367656409740448,
-0.6985704898834229,
-0.4806632101535797,
0.21804021298885345,
0.27795878052711487,
-0.7242493033409119,
0.19475629925727844,
-0.14089642465114594,
0.3911880850791931,
0.616895318031311,
-0.18905694782733917,
0.07396882772445679,
0.0598338358104229,
-0.06638355553150177,
0.1241845041513443,
-0.7981922626495361,
-0.23557107150554657,
1.004970908164978,
0.6826830506324768,
1.1344473361968994,
0.30355319380760193,
0.41334205865859985,
0.22845028340816498,
0.11647828668355942,
-0.9313092231750488,
0.2316170632839203,
-0.10272402316331863,
-0.4944259822368622,
-0.5101228356361389,
-0.628063440322876,
-1.0847737789154053,
-0.022184576839208603,
0.014572381041944027,
-1.0740221738815308,
0.37012404203414917,
-0.06511051952838898,
-0.23176158964633942,
0.6162065267562866,
-0.716886043548584,
0.3961552083492279,
-0.24472452700138092,
-0.12440483272075653,
-0.20514003932476044,
-0.5350836515426636,
0.20117084681987762,
-0.027313772588968277,
0.3253440856933594,
0.025238290429115295,
-0.09446847438812256,
1.0779566764831543,
-0.5730366706848145,
0.8685202598571777,
-0.13731415569782257,
-0.3003992736339569,
0.2839227020740509,
0.13560818135738373,
0.5759428143501282,
0.06226295977830887,
-0.17060284316539764,
0.12281744182109833,
0.2118217647075653,
-0.5004357099533081,
-0.8201457858085632,
0.6817123293876648,
-0.8586803078651428,
-0.8032625913619995,
-0.06298709660768509,
-0.8590367436408997,
-0.011908769607543945,
0.19614174962043762,
0.11573920398950577,
0.394050270318985,
0.18007098138332367,
0.5890418887138367,
0.5909422039985657,
-0.24476782977581024,
0.3816753923892975,
0.25004106760025024,
-0.5074028968811035,
-0.06134478375315666,
0.47874894738197327,
0.31055495142936707,
0.18765999376773834,
0.41636350750923157,
0.30201777815818787,
-0.2763653099536896,
-0.30614039301872253,
-0.15872591733932495,
0.7433469891548157,
-0.7259573340415955,
-0.2188860923051834,
-0.4142630100250244,
-0.48083776235580444,
-0.5237101316452026,
0.11742422729730606,
-0.33384400606155396,
-0.47692686319351196,
-0.26759156584739685,
-0.14107665419578552,
0.48619091510772705,
1.322839379310608,
-0.18594692647457123,
0.41498643159866333,
-0.3730272650718689,
-0.4484248459339142,
0.03975677490234375,
0.3113066554069519,
0.26849061250686646,
-0.7413509488105774,
-0.4603550434112549,
0.1806049793958664,
0.16792531311511993,
-0.5941591858863831,
0.409129798412323,
-0.08616570383310318,
0.6394057869911194,
0.6490144729614258,
-0.21477657556533813,
0.4009433090686798,
-0.41050204634666443,
0.662359893321991,
0.3527468740940094,
-0.8296042680740356,
0.21241731941699982,
-0.3533065617084503,
0.18308597803115845,
0.005033898167312145,
0.23324356973171234,
-0.5171083211898804,
-0.5321675539016724,
-0.7142019867897034,
-0.7594482898712158,
0.5244049429893494,
-0.1441027671098709,
0.4531223773956299,
0.09587519615888596,
0.8606983423233032,
-0.14136198163032532,
0.14918799698352814,
-0.7532448172569275,
-0.1300811916589737,
0.10962091386318207,
-0.3000507056713104,
0.17516472935676575,
-0.5229313373565674,
-0.01116097066551447,
-0.22829073667526245,
0.30671319365501404,
0.06427783519029617,
0.43201109766960144,
0.028702018782496452,
-0.020711999386548996,
-0.03900210186839104,
-0.04082537814974785,
0.661332368850708,
0.6794611811637878,
-0.16400828957557678,
0.39659544825553894,
0.06730222702026367,
-0.5156850218772888,
-0.05452745035290718,
-0.368359237909317,
0.30982527136802673,
-0.10735800862312317,
0.693304181098938,
1.0819722414016724,
0.015036201104521751,
-0.3919098675251007,
0.6014229655265808,
-0.19001518189907074,
-0.07780421525239944,
-0.37547433376312256,
0.0264651570469141,
-0.014751198701560497,
0.45453763008117676,
0.5925602912902832,
-0.47686484456062317,
0.03292912244796753,
-0.8259837031364441,
0.18271388113498688,
0.6503197550773621,
-0.45740315318107605,
-0.5179579257965088,
0.45509907603263855,
-0.21252357959747314,
-0.25833478569984436,
0.5762205123901367,
0.08087890595197678,
-0.4577201008796692,
0.8298726081848145,
0.6543176174163818,
0.502264678478241,
-0.39583513140678406,
0.023441636934876442,
0.5163518786430359,
0.30225804448127747,
-0.13235273957252502,
0.04631539434194565,
0.08144846558570862,
-0.5275112986564636,
-0.47608280181884766,
-0.7925993204116821,
0.08448804169893265,
0.22334159910678864,
-0.673592746257782,
0.24492235481739044,
-0.4717644453048706,
-0.32085132598876953,
-0.18216127157211304,
-0.06294479966163635,
-0.7763192057609558,
0.03957666456699371,
0.4249725639820099,
0.7827603816986084,
-0.9017237424850464,
0.8563527464866638,
0.32861921191215515,
-0.3324459195137024,
-1.060657262802124,
0.026652179658412933,
-0.022443218156695366,
-1.1565382480621338,
1.2226024866104126,
-0.013931498862802982,
-0.02392774447798729,
-0.03661796450614929,
-0.6443848013877869,
-1.8349905014038086,
1.0848642587661743,
0.6811601519584656,
-0.5704830288887024,
-0.3507000803947449,
0.015308540314435959,
0.5690158605575562,
-0.7071233987808228,
0.24106313288211823,
0.3405558168888092,
0.4562458395957947,
0.333385705947876,
-1.0282275676727295,
0.19976337254047394,
-0.013786446303129196,
0.05850004777312279,
0.4055708944797516,
-0.7629625797271729,
1.1689722537994385,
-0.23235364258289337,
-0.2310205101966858,
-0.06062301620841026,
0.5673209428787231,
-0.07449396699666977,
-0.2821124196052551,
0.4229985177516937,
0.4341937303543091,
1.0829308032989502,
0.10226930677890778,
1.3463225364685059,
-0.6159844398498535,
0.6520928144454956,
0.8172764778137207,
0.11537139862775803,
0.831993043422699,
0.5268018245697021,
-0.12809166312217712,
0.5171075463294983,
0.64042729139328,
0.10480733215808868,
0.49445638060569763,
0.5948334336280823,
0.13456584513187408,
-0.07105588912963867,
-0.3021683990955353,
-0.40268921852111816,
0.3579699695110321,
0.47821614146232605,
-0.8598645329475403,
-0.13588130474090576,
0.11974090337753296,
0.3500280976295471,
-0.6117547750473022,
-0.5903792977333069,
0.8593089580535889,
0.2957268953323364,
-0.28666675090789795,
0.6730325222015381,
0.048556286841630936,
0.29371553659439087,
-0.46549537777900696,
0.2327410727739334,
-0.10313775390386581,
0.1540113091468811,
-0.20074889063835144,
-0.6850592494010925,
0.2877911329269409,
-0.17967304587364197,
-0.33501988649368286,
-0.24519963562488556,
0.349933922290802,
-0.4656880795955658,
-0.5831579566001892,
0.3739807903766632,
0.23645034432411194,
0.2863462269306183,
0.07101551443338394,
-0.3934321105480194,
0.3418716490268707,
-0.09363283216953278,
-0.45701032876968384,
0.269214391708374,
0.7721300721168518,
-0.1491105854511261,
0.5743094086647034,
0.3490692973136902,
0.4155597984790802,
0.34474581480026245,
0.0151114696636796,
0.8204026818275452,
-0.7357794046401978,
-0.404559850692749,
-1.1301320791244507,
-0.01805161125957966,
-0.19604085385799408,
-0.01995340920984745,
0.8467505574226379,
0.5928821563720703,
0.4632306694984436,
0.3157121539115906,
0.697737991809845,
0.11814872175455093,
0.17443285882472992,
-0.7551969885826111,
0.6599476933479309,
-0.6821016073226929,
0.3414858877658844,
0.04334896430373192,
-1.0135403871536255,
-0.5185704827308655,
0.4869630038738251,
-0.6820683479309082,
-0.05029197037220001,
0.7464366555213928,
0.5677168369293213,
-0.16770614683628082,
-0.1489020735025406,
0.41837963461875916,
0.6087229251861572,
0.2156112790107727,
0.3895602524280548,
0.6060515642166138,
-0.2116275429725647,
0.2557159662246704,
0.40914833545684814,
-0.2710869610309601,
-0.47339293360710144,
-0.736474335193634,
-0.8098488450050354,
-0.9980461597442627,
-0.0777134895324707,
-0.5038194060325623,
-0.33186572790145874,
0.8872832655906677,
0.7833501100540161,
-0.5410890579223633,
-0.42208215594291687,
-0.028772743418812752,
0.17455273866653442,
0.4541904926300049,
-0.21066780388355255,
0.7300022840499878,
-0.5191145539283752,
-0.5583264827728271,
-0.006416643969714642,
0.4362626075744629,
0.1745181381702423,
-0.5840033888816833,
-0.022519096732139587,
0.1521560251712799,
0.4714423418045044,
0.583829402923584,
0.0697338730096817,
-0.7913362383842468,
-0.3560841381549835,
-0.08018162101507187,
-0.31621140241622925,
0.11776526272296906,
1.20065176486969,
-0.45201483368873596,
0.2555682957172394,
0.7216728925704956,
0.6266127824783325,
0.47719159722328186,
-0.20044218003749847,
0.8824334144592285,
-0.6213505864143372,
0.4507325291633606,
-0.025257404893636703,
0.7217618823051453,
0.3110702335834503,
-0.5959810614585876,
0.19349446892738342,
-0.014853600412607193,
-0.4781642556190491,
-0.9488634467124939,
0.3457140028476715,
-0.6365820169448853,
-0.3565004765987396,
1.6332218647003174,
-0.1012796089053154,
-0.805837869644165,
0.2797943949699402,
-0.000667109910864383,
0.08791632950305939,
-0.27822211384773254,
0.6393887400627136,
1.0979326963424683,
-0.09004195779561996,
-0.23728132247924805,
-0.565025269985199,
0.6056813597679138,
0.2486773282289505,
-0.43821436166763306,
0.22582605481147766,
0.29772570729255676,
0.29703450202941895,
0.3145144581794739,
0.33584678173065186,
-0.0770481750369072,
-0.3614678680896759,
-0.02699229307472706,
-0.11242068558931351,
0.2171735018491745,
-0.2849515378475189,
-0.3694291114807129,
0.12273398041725159,
0.14094965159893036,
0.24054838716983795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00559v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00559v4 | A Chain-of-Thought Is as Strong as Its Weakest Link: A Benchmark for Verifiers of Reasoning Chains | 2024-02-01T12:46:45 | 2024-05-21T09:55:07 | Alon Jacovi, Yonatan Bitton, Bernd Bohnet, Jonathan Herzig, Or Honovich, Michael Tseng, Michael Collins, Roee Aharoni, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompting language models to provide step-by-step answers (e.g.,
"Chain-of-Thought") is the prominent approach for complex reasoning tasks,
where more accurate reasoning chains typically improve downstream task
performance. Recent literature discusses automatic methods to verify reasoning
to evaluate and improve their correctness. However, no fine-grained step-level
datasets are available to enable thorough evaluation of such verification
methods, hindering progress in this direction. We introduce REVEAL: Reasoning
Verification Evaluation, a dataset to benchmark automatic verifiers of complex
Chain-of-Thought reasoning in open-domain question-answering settings. REVEAL
includes comprehensive labels for the relevance, attribution to evidence
passages, and logical correctness of each reasoning step in a language model's
answer, across a variety of datasets and state-of-the-art language models.
Evaluation on REVEAL shows that verifiers struggle at verifying reasoning
chains - in particular, verifying logical correctness and detecting
contradictions. Available at https://reveal-dataset.github.io/ . | [
-0.34050312638282776,
-0.7584859728813171,
0.6551818251609802,
-0.23490017652511597,
0.0029171714559197426,
0.3546532690525055,
-0.15870226919651031,
-0.4548441171646118,
-0.1880783885717392,
0.3820023238658905,
-0.6654638051986694,
-0.29381445050239563,
-0.5811726450920105,
0.11980286240577698,
-0.5640006065368652,
0.8778815865516663,
-0.41289854049682617,
-0.17933516204357147,
-0.26479214429855347,
-0.1148698702454567,
-0.3389758765697479,
-0.21200481057167053,
-0.29638245701789856,
-0.6008202433586121,
0.44383901357650757,
0.1389048844575882,
0.769656240940094,
0.6948432922363281,
0.585493266582489,
0.19109216332435608,
0.05681716278195381,
0.5230253338813782,
-0.6142231822013855,
0.2563186585903168,
-0.6544996500015259,
-0.4725229740142822,
-0.4260537624359131,
-0.06115615367889404,
0.4182617664337158,
0.8937715291976929,
-0.07467494904994965,
0.5500190258026123,
-0.3057955801486969,
0.8271608352661133,
-1.0727894306182861,
-0.011306012980639935,
-0.8066555857658386,
-0.20715177059173584,
-0.0511687733232975,
0.03936397656798363,
-0.5079975128173828,
-0.7081938982009888,
0.23451973497867584,
-0.32455262541770935,
-0.04759377986192703,
0.42556071281433105,
0.9989551901817322,
0.3035948574542999,
-0.45528557896614075,
-0.35731810331344604,
-0.923186719417572,
0.5503556132316589,
-0.4213956892490387,
0.32343345880508423,
0.33519700169563293,
0.770317792892456,
-0.1597977727651596,
-0.7951073050498962,
-0.6410656571388245,
-0.045020416378974915,
-0.05139864608645439,
0.05596078559756279,
-0.4546450972557068,
-0.09356167167425156,
0.5876139402389526,
0.7461182475090027,
-0.5985808968544006,
-0.32224926352500916,
-0.1607842743396759,
-0.14542342722415924,
0.6479533910751343,
0.16096898913383484,
0.3005169630050659,
0.2616632580757141,
-0.39943110942840576,
-0.24187740683555603,
-0.8109983801841736,
0.032285742461681366,
0.28493595123291016,
0.09480173140764236,
0.17587511241436005,
0.6553956270217896,
-0.6255688071250916,
0.7165545225143433,
0.09961544722318649,
0.2965450584888458,
0.24572032690048218,
-0.6072279810905457,
-0.3040594458580017,
-0.0425293929874897,
0.7669854760169983,
0.2302502989768982,
0.20682810246944427,
-0.11537624895572662,
-0.34687086939811707,
0.16858720779418945,
0.359853059053421,
-0.6689341068267822,
-0.46718597412109375,
0.3278086483478546,
-0.1800742745399475,
-0.11697616428136826,
0.12959152460098267,
-0.40957558155059814,
-0.40912944078445435,
-0.07817354798316956,
0.7618391513824463,
-0.11091047525405884,
-0.18983213603496552,
0.4408315420150757,
-0.20861555635929108,
0.06638776510953903,
0.38240015506744385,
-0.32019343972206116,
0.5979102253913879,
0.7626393437385559,
0.40416672825813293,
0.0416218638420105,
-0.28410857915878296,
-0.5099345445632935,
-0.09616944938898087,
-0.6048185229301453,
0.8070147633552551,
-0.5105776190757751,
0.37299609184265137,
0.08416550606489182,
0.06044713407754898,
-0.02425812929868698,
-0.47562330961227417,
0.7822144627571106,
-0.43066510558128357,
-0.011657066643238068,
-0.5928349494934082,
-0.6600563526153564,
-0.048719536513090134,
0.6583982110023499,
-0.809179961681366,
1.0627003908157349,
-0.10811122506856918,
-0.9326050877571106,
0.24557171761989594,
-0.21901243925094604,
-0.26917189359664917,
-0.05404675006866455,
-0.19834162294864655,
-0.24994896352291107,
0.02377558872103691,
0.3131725788116455,
0.2278362214565277,
-0.606563150882721,
0.17663736641407013,
-0.4290579855442047,
-0.44664090871810913,
0.39966389536857605,
-0.5289639830589294,
0.8478138446807861,
0.03849399834871292,
-0.5485134124755859,
-0.010755290277302265,
-0.867204487323761,
0.2369426190853119,
0.17222435772418976,
0.011154052801430225,
-0.4394879937171936,
-0.002774098189547658,
-0.8722020983695984,
0.2750667333602905,
0.10150939971208572,
-0.5912094712257385,
0.26702117919921875,
-0.31456688046455383,
0.2276831418275833,
0.6675453186035156,
0.07412192225456238,
-0.005475674755871296,
-0.40731847286224365,
0.36425551772117615,
0.07240255177021027,
0.2061515599489212,
-0.28978243470191956,
-0.424898236989975,
-0.9345192313194275,
0.12355324625968933,
0.40154775977134705,
0.5146421194076538,
-0.926971971988678,
0.3982342779636383,
-0.3242291510105133,
-0.6882720589637756,
-0.7102479934692383,
-0.04026269540190697,
0.8033761382102966,
0.5259235501289368,
0.3802538812160492,
-0.2424212098121643,
-0.41313865780830383,
-0.9604576230049133,
-0.6610599160194397,
-0.44446295499801636,
-0.14480358362197876,
0.0732920914888382,
0.9243961572647095,
-0.010825046338140965,
0.5826166868209839,
-0.5232527256011963,
0.5074698328971863,
-0.0203907061368227,
0.15290850400924683,
0.3061332404613495,
0.29117217659950256,
-0.16733916103839874,
-0.44647619128227234,
-0.132450133562088,
0.08527906239032745,
-0.8163315057754517,
0.12639561295509338,
0.0961448922753334,
-0.3716616630554199,
-0.46141886711120605,
0.12112051248550415,
-0.39179080724716187,
0.4789336919784546,
0.2933153510093689,
-0.4253690838813782,
0.8360716104507446,
-0.19211800396442413,
0.32502543926239014,
-0.4429609775543213,
0.20393039286136627,
-0.10468759387731552,
-0.32775232195854187,
-0.5613306760787964,
0.1511610448360443,
0.10654879361391068,
0.15889213979244232,
-0.03205133229494095,
0.32793128490448,
-0.4262546896934509,
0.06310253590345383,
0.04189014807343483,
0.2044898122549057,
0.10430458188056946,
0.46949926018714905,
-0.03681422770023346,
0.5786473155021667,
0.6838229894638062,
-0.5501242280006409,
0.3049481511116028,
0.2346220165491104,
-0.5714231729507446,
0.5056541562080383,
-0.5640974640846252,
0.4149370491504669,
0.01499437727034092,
0.39942026138305664,
-1.0581070184707642,
-0.20732520520687103,
0.2800019085407257,
-0.07530097663402557,
-0.06492210179567337,
-0.12080810964107513,
-0.7015872597694397,
-0.8408243656158447,
-0.2634936571121216,
0.43943870067596436,
0.39514821767807007,
-0.77613365650177,
0.42178577184677124,
0.26526591181755066,
0.22983524203300476,
-0.9047475457191467,
-0.5303125977516174,
-0.036968525499105453,
0.1838432252407074,
-0.4834553599357605,
0.03413303196430206,
-0.169222891330719,
-0.39407798647880554,
-0.27523425221443176,
-0.6302304267883301,
-0.19359314441680908,
0.03309239447116852,
0.16654397547245026,
0.0602886863052845,
-0.052218180149793625,
0.24880164861679077,
0.04618462920188904,
-0.0866503044962883,
0.5480878353118896,
-0.4738485813140869,
0.090208500623703,
-0.5905992984771729,
-0.614510715007782,
-0.16605770587921143,
0.006413180846720934,
0.5172877311706543,
-0.29559463262557983,
0.2672882378101349,
0.22318190336227417,
-0.5328266024589539,
-0.5234515070915222,
-0.596066415309906,
-0.18086302280426025,
-0.40875428915023804,
-0.1079014241695404,
-0.5091549754142761,
-0.6712708473205566,
0.5185206532478333,
-0.4765036106109619,
0.032856933772563934,
0.4460736811161041,
0.3023925721645355,
-0.010786890052258968,
1.0728763341903687,
0.1692674309015274,
0.18497855961322784,
-0.30901050567626953,
-0.15352368354797363,
0.41369515657424927,
-0.5967003107070923,
-0.21385082602500916,
-0.6098246574401855,
-0.09895910322666168,
-0.5560441613197327,
-0.4038141071796417,
0.11989472806453705,
0.23547899723052979,
-0.43923068046569824,
0.483071506023407,
-0.5208249688148499,
0.6797321438789368,
0.3132692575454712,
0.3836667537689209,
0.5187348127365112,
-0.2390175461769104,
-0.3095434904098511,
0.29773610830307007,
-0.6498684287071228,
-0.743136465549469,
0.9702697992324829,
0.38685792684555054,
0.7843546867370605,
-0.09172032028436661,
0.45544108748435974,
0.3212389349937439,
0.06784652918577194,
-0.46221864223480225,
0.6434335708618164,
0.11183064430952072,
-0.6494332551956177,
-0.2473771721124649,
-0.43108561635017395,
-0.5915194153785706,
0.0794643983244896,
-0.15022216737270355,
-0.6863446831703186,
0.1343313604593277,
0.24949201941490173,
-0.10159260779619217,
0.45049184560775757,
-0.2731313705444336,
0.8198212385177612,
-0.13677553832530975,
-0.4032079875469208,
-0.08351486176252365,
-0.7214400768280029,
0.5532110333442688,
0.09918034821748734,
0.054994165897369385,
0.0393592044711113,
0.28659796714782715,
0.6390464901924133,
-0.8674763441085815,
0.6453750729560852,
0.017985619604587555,
-0.36969849467277527,
0.5345489382743835,
0.28597402572631836,
0.9358199238777161,
-0.11984848976135254,
-0.06641293317079544,
0.05983177572488785,
-0.16893966495990753,
-0.2971612811088562,
-0.8042130470275879,
0.46271783113479614,
-0.3169032633304596,
-0.4819338023662567,
-0.20039626955986023,
-0.07654464244842529,
-0.4532105028629303,
0.2271774262189865,
0.15326878428459167,
0.46934884786605835,
-0.15204231441020966,
-0.10905484855175018,
1.0597052574157715,
0.1495732069015503,
-0.052346520125865936,
0.18387743830680847,
-0.13936744630336761,
-0.34276819229125977,
0.7833743691444397,
-0.047699738293886185,
0.4363515079021454,
0.4496893584728241,
0.36527538299560547,
-0.20023424923419952,
-0.48336511850357056,
-0.622002899646759,
0.033464498817920685,
-1.0670652389526367,
-0.17737391591072083,
-0.4502353370189667,
-0.13302363455295563,
0.2211472988128662,
0.22341960668563843,
-0.5801432728767395,
-0.6234950423240662,
0.5268519520759583,
-0.34302932024002075,
0.13755758106708527,
0.9132379293441772,
0.19751618802547455,
-0.34223589301109314,
-0.2501934766769409,
0.3541920483112335,
0.6481127738952637,
0.4735370874404907,
0.03920791670680046,
-0.13127656280994415,
-0.168507382273674,
0.194891557097435,
-0.1148332878947258,
-0.6586785316467285,
-0.29788637161254883,
-0.09052756428718567,
0.4436400830745697,
0.24438484013080597,
0.364608496427536,
0.7547900080680847,
-0.47814270853996277,
0.7556281685829163,
0.2202833592891693,
-1.1476538181304932,
0.9214447140693665,
-0.12717759609222412,
0.3807840347290039,
0.781791627407074,
0.45366716384887695,
-0.056938111782073975,
-0.689639151096344,
-0.6993991732597351,
-0.6823819279670715,
0.29966697096824646,
0.5521115064620972,
-0.4576011300086975,
-0.03287824988365173,
0.23507213592529297,
0.38447412848472595,
0.2998470366001129,
-0.5167651772499084,
-0.5196906328201294,
-0.2337464988231659,
-0.04837222397327423,
0.42583566904067993,
0.01725444570183754,
-0.2298016995191574,
-0.14779789745807648,
0.7042689323425293,
-0.23728474974632263,
0.2941538691520691,
0.3755101263523102,
-0.13269589841365814,
-0.3103512227535248,
0.3289734721183777,
0.2592909634113312,
1.0972654819488525,
-0.21159842610359192,
0.6497083306312561,
0.17184199392795563,
-0.2889864444732666,
0.3007810711860657,
-0.10163430124521255,
-0.3007546365261078,
0.09462759643793106,
0.5905638933181763,
0.7585754990577698,
0.05093778297305107,
-0.7155594825744629,
0.678176999092102,
-0.19618098437786102,
-0.2534455358982086,
-0.05813738703727722,
0.266385555267334,
-0.1763506680727005,
0.18016697466373444,
0.2506147623062134,
0.2850525677204132,
0.3523862957954407,
-0.6367780566215515,
0.1593673974275589,
0.06359833478927612,
-0.7061963677406311,
-0.46770331263542175,
0.5631672739982605,
-0.03622085601091385,
-0.11447291076183319,
0.5816170573234558,
-0.2255617082118988,
-0.6476117372512817,
0.46992993354797363,
0.26969313621520996,
0.9458101987838745,
0.0474918894469738,
0.16391143202781677,
0.5857266783714294,
0.5006086826324463,
-0.282084584236145,
0.5503473877906799,
-0.2787129282951355,
-0.4970075488090515,
-0.5017295479774475,
-0.15018495917320251,
-0.6662642955780029,
-0.03442941606044769,
-0.7801421880722046,
-0.06053392216563225,
-0.3698553144931793,
-0.09195335954427719,
0.03092334233224392,
0.11840889602899551,
-0.7906020879745483,
0.4176924526691437,
0.15920744836330414,
1.0737136602401733,
-0.8271707892417908,
0.7518430948257446,
0.4777621626853943,
-0.35591232776641846,
-0.8337900638580322,
0.12344180792570114,
-0.09746120870113373,
-0.5551405549049377,
0.6399467587471008,
0.30100780725479126,
-0.5988024473190308,
-0.3656409978866577,
-0.7742279171943665,
-0.6136393547058105,
1.0208765268325806,
0.305765837430954,
-0.797957718372345,
0.13653995096683502,
0.052156612277030945,
0.5094472765922546,
-0.40828049182891846,
0.640734851360321,
0.41954517364501953,
0.5442104339599609,
0.12923263013362885,
-1.0113643407821655,
0.5632047653198242,
-0.3799227774143219,
-0.22471891343593597,
0.2140660285949707,
-0.2596582770347595,
0.6466724276542664,
-0.40728363394737244,
-0.39212921261787415,
-0.1004365012049675,
0.5747625231742859,
0.30759528279304504,
0.35666269063949585,
0.6845952272415161,
0.5629317164421082,
1.2782008647918701,
-0.3059353530406952,
0.9958191514015198,
-0.04764479026198387,
0.17408128082752228,
1.379241943359375,
-0.4945695698261261,
1.0280871391296387,
0.24723704159259796,
-0.21559549868106842,
0.9289900660514832,
0.36145398020744324,
0.04736306890845299,
0.3974226415157318,
0.6625882983207703,
0.01506609097123146,
-0.569877028465271,
-0.009579486213624477,
-0.19829580187797546,
0.06624557822942734,
0.3451222777366638,
-0.21950389444828033,
-0.21636682748794556,
-0.27139195799827576,
-0.16425393521785736,
0.14629429578781128,
-0.3769729733467102,
0.6732589602470398,
-0.13114452362060547,
-0.9186404347419739,
0.8958924412727356,
-0.5252385139465332,
-0.017125986516475677,
-0.48474639654159546,
-0.20524299144744873,
0.0646076649427414,
0.36398592591285706,
-0.1510753333568573,
-1.0806996822357178,
0.03671383112668991,
0.15411125123500824,
-0.05436189845204353,
-0.16812661290168762,
0.915997326374054,
-0.21713170409202576,
-0.212528258562088,
0.39352360367774963,
0.6595237255096436,
0.09714764356613159,
-0.0683503970503807,
-0.7211980819702148,
-0.059416234493255615,
-0.16747567057609558,
-0.20903921127319336,
-0.1850232481956482,
0.6189460754394531,
-0.1977454125881195,
1.030242681503296,
0.41455844044685364,
-0.04856341704726219,
0.015000101178884506,
0.30308613181114197,
1.006911039352417,
-0.6341229677200317,
-0.17748205363750458,
-0.8186968564987183,
0.4917619526386261,
-0.32653313875198364,
-0.32547518610954285,
0.8594294786453247,
0.5526726245880127,
1.0587501525878906,
0.05171902850270271,
0.8323248028755188,
0.040777452290058136,
0.44177570939064026,
-0.44190657138824463,
0.4313683807849884,
-0.28354501724243164,
0.3486749827861786,
-0.3123636841773987,
-0.532238781452179,
-0.14588822424411774,
0.3368849754333496,
-0.30758991837501526,
-0.25122129917144775,
1.0367846488952637,
0.5195030570030212,
-0.10800501704216003,
0.39465105533599854,
0.060778260231018066,
0.39900654554367065,
0.06375957280397415,
0.6617977023124695,
1.19150710105896,
-0.9496574401855469,
0.5640903115272522,
-0.3961256146430969,
-0.2816317677497864,
0.13340142369270325,
-0.99778813123703,
-1.1190143823623657,
-0.4605913758277893,
-0.7313346266746521,
-0.541732132434845,
0.46288686990737915,
0.6411097645759583,
0.6713929176330566,
-0.8709931969642639,
-0.28254082798957825,
-0.5071998834609985,
0.29635968804359436,
-0.9325657486915588,
-0.08968092501163483,
0.40534093976020813,
-0.18901832401752472,
-0.13499808311462402,
0.5193737745285034,
0.2938927710056305,
-0.3338376581668854,
-0.39795804023742676,
-0.016898199915885925,
-0.29538848996162415,
0.2678445875644684,
0.39618825912475586,
0.18849977850914001,
-0.821545422077179,
-0.26290032267570496,
-0.16412974894046783,
-0.057648126035928726,
0.08432614058256149,
0.8538866639137268,
-0.88694828748703,
0.695480465888977,
0.7219915390014648,
0.5375361442565918,
0.4193571209907532,
0.032796118408441544,
0.7546510696411133,
-0.4469524621963501,
-0.6787647604942322,
0.2218877077102661,
0.4311547577381134,
0.035360343754291534,
-0.14572280645370483,
0.7140987515449524,
-0.08546634763479233,
-0.5400307178497314,
-0.9777411818504333,
0.37922152876853943,
-0.8504084944725037,
-0.11634545028209686,
0.6330097317695618,
-0.49172443151474,
-0.577862024307251,
-0.22920991480350494,
0.1601519137620926,
0.10299261659383774,
-0.14994202554225922,
0.6147579550743103,
0.6971769332885742,
0.08928362280130386,
0.1530068963766098,
-0.35180342197418213,
0.5064308047294617,
0.08537276834249496,
-0.9479237794876099,
0.7000253796577454,
0.29123860597610474,
0.12885335087776184,
0.33427953720092773,
0.4523221254348755,
-0.011485458351671696,
0.265444278717041,
0.14430804550647736,
-0.3654586374759674,
0.006044889334589243,
-0.5606063604354858,
-0.05678407475352287,
0.2641012966632843,
-0.00762034859508276,
-0.05000711604952812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00530v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00530v2 | Superfiltering: Weak-to-Strong Data Filtering for Fast Instruction-Tuning | 2024-02-01T11:57:53 | 2024-06-07T20:28:36 | Ming Li, Yong Zhang, Shwai He, Zhitao Li, Hongyu Zhao, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is critical to improve LLMs but usually suffers from
low-quality and redundant data. Data filtering for instruction tuning has
proved important in improving both the efficiency and performance of the tuning
process. But it also leads to extra cost and computation due to the involvement
of LLMs in this process. To reduce the filtering cost, we study Superfiltering:
Can we use a smaller and weaker model to select data for finetuning a larger
and stronger model? Despite the performance gap between weak and strong
language models, we find their highly consistent capability to perceive
instruction difficulty and data selection results. This enables us to use a
much smaller and more efficient model to filter the instruction data used to
train a larger language model. Not only does it largely speed up the data
filtering, but the filtered-data-finetuned LLM achieves even better performance
on standard benchmarks. Extensive experiments validate the efficacy and
efficiency of our approach. | [
-0.6163808107376099,
-0.7448098063468933,
0.46910303831100464,
-0.2631895840167999,
-0.4657495617866516,
-0.07341515272855759,
-0.21336780488491058,
-0.4532347023487091,
-0.2200031578540802,
0.7029439210891724,
-0.6855742931365967,
-0.2690431773662567,
-0.6478956937789917,
-0.08262141793966293,
-0.5066697597503662,
0.9972386956214905,
0.18971408903598785,
0.4915935695171356,
-0.2550937533378601,
0.14491704106330872,
-0.5020068287849426,
-0.26480916142463684,
-0.7387734055519104,
-0.7646293640136719,
0.21073347330093384,
0.7132349610328674,
0.9577044248580933,
0.9447756409645081,
0.6447885036468506,
0.28911009430885315,
-0.31310585141181946,
0.26984554529190063,
-0.7864951491355896,
0.2934962809085846,
-0.13921627402305603,
-0.8634490370750427,
-0.3620988428592682,
-0.05013926699757576,
0.5968164801597595,
0.6253674030303955,
-0.015355778858065605,
-0.0033298146445304155,
0.04821395128965378,
1.0317951440811157,
-0.5237576961517334,
-0.05130583420395851,
-0.6648167967796326,
0.046808402985334396,
-0.4111049771308899,
-0.09958687424659729,
-0.15705133974552155,
-0.4518931210041046,
-0.3776998817920685,
-0.2944275140762329,
0.527985155582428,
0.3008957505226135,
0.953696608543396,
0.480739951133728,
0.02839130349457264,
-0.1318499743938446,
-0.8251426219940186,
0.9442600607872009,
-0.7012405395507812,
0.9311724305152893,
0.6655226945877075,
0.01063231285661459,
-0.30811789631843567,
-0.4678344130516052,
-0.38753172755241394,
-0.18168571591377258,
0.03566588833928108,
0.037907619029283524,
0.08082687854766846,
0.2776111364364624,
0.274884432554245,
0.6637535095214844,
-0.4710584282875061,
0.2934029698371887,
-0.5147971510887146,
-0.12422286719083786,
0.648439347743988,
0.2725808918476105,
0.020949317142367363,
0.1005321815609932,
-0.12969206273555756,
0.03866368904709816,
-0.9787261486053467,
-0.33864685893058777,
0.5113877058029175,
0.39487457275390625,
0.38372933864593506,
0.17730925977230072,
-0.4197618067264557,
0.7884417176246643,
0.12665651738643646,
-0.14376729726791382,
-0.34730181097984314,
-0.36602216958999634,
-0.37475866079330444,
-0.22439895570278168,
0.22923845052719116,
0.148862823843956,
0.33380207419395447,
-0.09965641796588898,
-0.5216814279556274,
0.049906354397535324,
0.050519172102212906,
-0.9415194392204285,
-0.374470978975296,
-0.13538572192192078,
-0.5587723255157471,
-0.10061994940042496,
0.08031801134347916,
-0.6851406097412109,
-0.3811209499835968,
-0.5509217381477356,
0.2171383500099182,
-0.16248632967472076,
0.011219827458262444,
0.166776642203331,
0.08500759303569794,
0.1828327178955078,
0.08230221271514893,
-1.238139271736145,
0.5548597574234009,
0.7856950759887695,
0.5824364423751831,
-0.10133107006549835,
0.006015572231262922,
-0.7593163847923279,
-0.07432794570922852,
-0.5752261281013489,
0.9791945815086365,
-0.8488753437995911,
-0.463215172290802,
-0.3289746046066284,
-0.021856604143977165,
-0.060363709926605225,
-1.0992732048034668,
0.621260404586792,
-0.9459381699562073,
-0.2281707227230072,
0.01036834716796875,
-0.8374584913253784,
-0.04353124275803566,
-0.3009137213230133,
-0.8063017725944519,
1.1787883043289185,
0.19235171377658844,
-0.035164669156074524,
0.3169700801372528,
-0.07005862891674042,
-0.5806602239608765,
0.19522349536418915,
0.008294628001749516,
-0.6400049924850464,
0.4839291274547577,
0.2146143615245819,
0.5488300919532776,
-0.5633379817008972,
0.11446532607078552,
-0.3840453326702118,
-0.9054315090179443,
-0.1439315229654312,
-0.5796914100646973,
0.46808183193206787,
0.40979480743408203,
-0.19099701941013336,
-0.17499582469463348,
-0.6887865662574768,
0.16121982038021088,
-0.10630019009113312,
-0.5755451917648315,
-0.321510374546051,
0.3492204248905182,
-0.26381173729896545,
-0.14580096304416656,
-0.0529644750058651,
-0.36113330721855164,
0.08545351028442383,
-0.3966473937034607,
0.3436765968799591,
0.8148648738861084,
-0.038388241082429886,
0.3381102383136749,
-0.36923396587371826,
0.44100695848464966,
-0.2547909617424011,
0.314482718706131,
0.07137008011341095,
-0.4310716986656189,
-0.967958390712738,
-0.042810842394828796,
0.6012097001075745,
0.5367699861526489,
-0.7455995082855225,
0.22298339009284973,
0.11590223014354706,
-0.427610844373703,
-0.6697072386741638,
0.8272527456283569,
0.5702966451644897,
0.27391886711120605,
0.458932101726532,
-0.25011855363845825,
-0.46017318964004517,
-0.8159782886505127,
-0.15268626809120178,
-0.09698823094367981,
0.0669812262058258,
0.34842416644096375,
0.15719066560268402,
-0.08796625584363937,
0.45029622316360474,
-0.682365357875824,
-0.2572838068008423,
-0.41520172357559204,
-0.22649750113487244,
0.3692549169063568,
0.5653618574142456,
0.17516371607780457,
-0.8639838099479675,
-0.4060797691345215,
-0.13376225531101227,
-0.34080255031585693,
-0.31006500124931335,
0.0909283310174942,
-0.23881275951862335,
0.1922733634710312,
0.8401861786842346,
-0.3597771227359772,
0.413850337266922,
0.5296653509140015,
-0.21551410853862762,
0.4600732624530792,
-0.24845026433467865,
0.11667348444461823,
-0.47115179896354675,
-0.454925537109375,
0.03394700959324837,
-0.3857741057872772,
-0.6129631400108337,
0.24564552307128906,
0.18422849476337433,
0.07690653204917908,
-0.47473475337028503,
0.19959759712219238,
-0.3952293395996094,
0.19733355939388275,
-0.5455930233001709,
-0.16227412223815918,
0.1524551957845688,
0.24058152735233307,
-0.11685328930616379,
0.7546360492706299,
0.48824235796928406,
-0.813302755355835,
0.44512802362442017,
-0.055982545018196106,
-0.5176637768745422,
0.5269879698753357,
-0.5126683115959167,
0.15947143733501434,
-0.035742342472076416,
0.08100203424692154,
-0.9488131999969482,
-0.06337068229913712,
-0.09969156235456467,
0.026520652696490288,
0.5882583260536194,
-0.45730239152908325,
-0.5363298654556274,
-0.27191171050071716,
-0.22523508965969086,
0.0655396580696106,
0.4916563332080841,
-0.7630423903465271,
0.24211987853050232,
0.38242068886756897,
-0.23912785947322845,
-0.16562411189079285,
-0.7350081205368042,
-0.236007422208786,
-0.17418844997882843,
-0.3592531383037567,
0.4132850468158722,
-0.17829394340515137,
0.12287651002407074,
-0.0005891506443731487,
-0.5099071264266968,
-0.2773735225200653,
0.2567138969898224,
0.04280465468764305,
0.5220240950584412,
-0.4098890423774719,
0.23344404995441437,
0.16279959678649902,
-0.3739142119884491,
-0.12930457293987274,
-0.12997008860111237,
0.3436968922615051,
0.1253066211938858,
-0.2597426176071167,
-0.5789339542388916,
0.47469866275787354,
0.4242090582847595,
0.12106157839298248,
0.742726743221283,
0.5131691694259644,
-0.4280901551246643,
-0.4225003123283386,
-0.6046338081359863,
-0.5612621903419495,
-0.5564176440238953,
0.35331374406814575,
-0.23332205414772034,
-0.9272263050079346,
0.13514748215675354,
-0.0874115601181984,
0.025479217991232872,
0.1624119132757187,
0.3382379412651062,
-0.26151594519615173,
1.4513359069824219,
0.5515699982643127,
-0.24882923066616058,
0.8210537433624268,
-0.251176118850708,
0.2025497704744339,
-0.6708991527557373,
0.014776949770748615,
-0.7053439021110535,
-0.4594901502132416,
-0.5858054757118225,
-0.14536777138710022,
0.1385045349597931,
0.36610904335975647,
-0.056312963366508484,
0.07478170096874237,
-0.4014442563056946,
1.0366290807724,
0.7150403261184692,
0.34058940410614014,
0.24460139870643616,
0.04908101260662079,
0.07832566648721695,
-0.05057911202311516,
-0.7722944617271423,
-0.47502410411834717,
1.0192471742630005,
0.0775984674692154,
1.1563267707824707,
-0.19604438543319702,
0.46911489963531494,
0.192886620759964,
0.2500206530094147,
-0.6867756247520447,
0.7279621958732605,
-0.9392249584197998,
-0.8218785524368286,
-0.2238984853029251,
-0.5575990676879883,
-0.743809163570404,
0.27295076847076416,
-0.3381500244140625,
-0.4521997570991516,
0.1362430304288864,
0.3425113260746002,
-0.4585661292076111,
0.5388068556785583,
-1.161162257194519,
0.6003113389015198,
-0.157771036028862,
-0.5380111932754517,
-0.39205825328826904,
-0.3019461929798126,
0.24132196605205536,
-0.027083776891231537,
0.03877831995487213,
-0.22427932918071747,
0.17677441239356995,
0.784210205078125,
-0.5396889448165894,
0.7025056481361389,
-0.19805344939231873,
0.11034711450338364,
0.194284588098526,
0.06851957738399506,
0.5113027095794678,
0.014256376773118973,
-0.2513269782066345,
0.09633804857730865,
-0.160675048828125,
-0.3830166161060333,
-0.6135789155960083,
0.9825149178504944,
-0.7346424460411072,
-0.9499455690383911,
0.06981489062309265,
-0.46104615926742554,
-0.17718055844306946,
0.09872198104858398,
0.02295556478202343,
0.5488952994346619,
0.321982741355896,
0.46787363290786743,
1.024716854095459,
0.27234697341918945,
0.2682270407676697,
0.6361662745475769,
0.1226549968123436,
-0.08869591355323792,
1.3397204875946045,
0.5700539350509644,
0.27030304074287415,
0.30197757482528687,
0.34579718112945557,
-0.21950112283229828,
-0.9668264389038086,
-0.3446404039859772,
0.13679347932338715,
-0.5695658922195435,
-0.47479933500289917,
-0.009763460606336594,
-0.408860981464386,
-0.2129518985748291,
0.017213864251971245,
-0.5239427089691162,
-0.4429338872432709,
-0.42109599709510803,
-0.06395570933818817,
0.2996880114078522,
0.7344921827316284,
-0.039371244609355927,
0.46680381894111633,
-0.6801989674568176,
0.6300221681594849,
0.5398097634315491,
0.7896487712860107,
-0.2009841799736023,
-0.5928836464881897,
-0.5777835249900818,
-0.22639206051826477,
-0.39587563276290894,
-0.6089484691619873,
0.02175987884402275,
0.6200230717658997,
0.6469071507453918,
0.33604300022125244,
0.09061109274625778,
0.9875196218490601,
-0.518278181552887,
0.6207753419876099,
-0.40053898096084595,
-0.8708661794662476,
0.6097131967544556,
0.27148401737213135,
0.29079145193099976,
0.6828248500823975,
0.2845160961151123,
-0.13725250959396362,
-0.47519296407699585,
-0.3683684766292572,
-0.9444147348403931,
0.9747514128684998,
-0.016966737806797028,
0.26287543773651123,
0.22914399206638336,
0.7032124400138855,
0.15216825902462006,
-0.0716337263584137,
-0.17982318997383118,
-0.49051591753959656,
0.09417875856161118,
-0.20271727442741394,
-0.14012815058231354,
-0.3244483768939972,
0.13607539236545563,
-0.4016748070716858,
1.030874252319336,
0.10194292664527893,
0.2037050724029541,
-0.13406458497047424,
-0.1984262317419052,
-0.3688601851463318,
0.11668305844068527,
0.39216941595077515,
0.23925501108169556,
-0.10439709573984146,
0.21200810372829437,
0.3694382309913635,
-0.6658363342285156,
0.13180972635746002,
0.0040317317470908165,
-0.27261412143707275,
-0.25384026765823364,
0.29571443796157837,
0.951390266418457,
0.347800612449646,
-0.38073599338531494,
0.059453561902046204,
-0.06513012945652008,
-0.06021963804960251,
0.4678570032119751,
0.9625263810157776,
0.028225639835000038,
0.21835461258888245,
0.275481641292572,
-0.0331169068813324,
0.19612330198287964,
-0.3144928514957428,
0.2932175397872925,
0.31407350301742554,
-0.3592876195907593,
-0.10740954428911209,
0.6016393899917603,
0.14066822826862335,
-0.43304362893104553,
0.7085018157958984,
0.047372180968523026,
-0.3704252243041992,
0.6425415277481079,
0.6674616932868958,
0.5078028440475464,
-0.4484075903892517,
0.009081216529011726,
0.01806570217013359,
0.31845584511756897,
-0.1483456939458847,
0.3263922929763794,
-0.22397957742214203,
-0.5533828139305115,
-0.4124962091445923,
-0.667517900466919,
-0.5768229961395264,
0.3906812071800232,
-0.711419939994812,
0.1834261268377304,
-0.44000905752182007,
-0.1615501195192337,
0.07229115068912506,
0.4231621026992798,
-0.588392972946167,
0.5184302926063538,
0.2571626901626587,
0.9533412456512451,
-0.9854440689086914,
0.8617834448814392,
0.6314239501953125,
0.14442358911037445,
-0.844116747379303,
-0.10045748203992844,
-0.045895807445049286,
-0.8251746892929077,
0.39955800771713257,
-0.03818335756659508,
-0.26342037320137024,
0.17127321660518646,
-0.5256668329238892,
-0.8081185817718506,
0.8158409595489502,
0.6390093564987183,
-0.7644796967506409,
0.23042559623718262,
-0.04629573971033096,
0.4798765182495117,
-0.2946684658527374,
0.2580694854259491,
1.149655818939209,
0.43727630376815796,
0.09122082591056824,
-0.4077264666557312,
-0.10795973241329193,
-0.2049420028924942,
0.10011953860521317,
0.40569645166397095,
-0.9536662697792053,
0.667748749256134,
0.1383756548166275,
-0.20943480730056763,
-0.05520408973097801,
0.568220853805542,
0.1958293914794922,
0.3241162896156311,
0.5439972281455994,
0.4363614618778229,
0.7531111836433411,
-0.2998378872871399,
0.850208044052124,
-0.3551076352596283,
0.23861071467399597,
0.9589267373085022,
-0.33305108547210693,
0.9217105507850647,
0.4164288640022278,
-0.23629553616046906,
0.37921157479286194,
0.7228133678436279,
0.07350897789001465,
0.5685263872146606,
0.11539272964000702,
-0.19313162565231323,
-0.5330782532691956,
-0.08379103243350983,
-0.28482767939567566,
0.22463081777095795,
0.47002655267715454,
-0.15799953043460846,
-0.1500978320837021,
-0.11309611052274704,
-0.10707791149616241,
-0.15176990628242493,
-0.5955119132995605,
0.7518686652183533,
0.10726972669363022,
-0.6233093738555908,
0.7418030500411987,
0.04481589049100876,
0.4272156357765198,
-0.5182564854621887,
0.0037123290821909904,
-0.47984740138053894,
0.30763673782348633,
-0.34368664026260376,
-0.7096579670906067,
0.3524746894836426,
0.06218014657497406,
-0.3915485143661499,
-0.3637427091598511,
1.0799518823623657,
-0.39457452297210693,
-0.3574075698852539,
0.26563653349876404,
0.3904988169670105,
0.303123414516449,
0.17672327160835266,
-0.7213290333747864,
0.35251563787460327,
-0.02454105019569397,
-0.640848696231842,
0.3583977520465851,
0.04555744305253029,
-0.07372064888477325,
0.6726176738739014,
0.8686542510986328,
0.4500119388103485,
0.057209841907024384,
0.36212271451950073,
1.0480151176452637,
-0.6781047582626343,
-0.4724171757698059,
-0.9402775168418884,
0.08784276992082596,
0.17828184366226196,
-0.07564011216163635,
0.48711448907852173,
0.4889838993549347,
0.9353839159011841,
0.15129514038562775,
0.4346611797809601,
0.3247162699699402,
0.39799970388412476,
-0.8493077754974365,
0.731804609298706,
-0.546841561794281,
0.5439419150352478,
0.12330508977174759,
-1.0182585716247559,
-0.4832039475440979,
0.5283997058868408,
-0.2746192216873169,
0.16356739401817322,
0.45681220293045044,
1.2351288795471191,
-0.20756269991397858,
0.24168792366981506,
0.6525088548660278,
0.21227972209453583,
0.10059412568807602,
0.6859613060951233,
0.6955333948135376,
-0.5713117122650146,
0.6801218390464783,
-0.25798624753952026,
-0.17439641058444977,
-0.3981418013572693,
-0.6562785506248474,
-0.8530107140541077,
-0.18963967263698578,
-0.30398890376091003,
-0.02396586164832115,
0.18383648991584778,
0.5959790945053101,
1.3262608051300049,
-1.0467191934585571,
-0.2406863421201706,
-0.2439042180776596,
0.7040754556655884,
-0.3696635663509369,
-0.19058305025100708,
0.12322544306516647,
-0.4819774925708771,
-0.8425788283348083,
0.751625657081604,
0.15602247416973114,
0.058439336717128754,
-0.3203381299972534,
-0.19778014719486237,
0.037667784839868546,
0.5036764740943909,
0.28652074933052063,
0.11996554583311081,
-0.1967184841632843,
-0.3362121880054474,
-0.23464912176132202,
-0.10178495198488235,
-0.052513428032398224,
0.8056516647338867,
-0.7462915182113647,
0.36919960379600525,
0.4200637638568878,
0.6248066425323486,
0.5932625532150269,
-0.20392295718193054,
0.2961187958717346,
-0.7188020348548889,
-0.14552080631256104,
-0.012583659961819649,
0.2512105405330658,
0.22377540171146393,
-0.5211135149002075,
0.4084891676902771,
0.3483808934688568,
-0.7676165103912354,
-1.034736156463623,
0.198298379778862,
-0.20303161442279816,
-0.2514566481113434,
0.8766524791717529,
-0.031249118968844414,
-0.258284330368042,
-0.2707499563694,
-0.15254026651382446,
0.3013533353805542,
-0.2745712697505951,
0.7694237232208252,
0.8599137663841248,
-0.3143947720527649,
-0.14957045018672943,
-0.8614189624786377,
0.4774312376976013,
0.7249115705490112,
-0.5632097125053406,
0.03587762266397476,
0.33656996488571167,
0.1895063817501068,
-0.28241923451423645,
0.2779993712902069,
0.13946163654327393,
0.3785015642642975,
-0.07204094529151917,
-0.5787447690963745,
-0.14061647653579712,
-0.6332960724830627,
-0.41220393776893616,
0.28338778018951416,
-0.06320399791002274,
-0.05523507297039032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00518v1 | EE-Tuning: An Economical yet Scalable Solution for Tuning Early-Exit Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T11:39:04 | 2024-02-01T11:39:04 | Xuchen Pan, Yanxi Chen, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jingren Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | This work introduces EE-Tuning, a lightweight and economical solution to
training/tuning early-exit large language models (LLMs). In contrast to the
common approach of full-parameter pre-training, EE-Tuning augments any
pre-trained (and possibly fine-tuned) standard LLM with additional early-exit
layers that are tuned in a parameter-efficient manner, which requires
significantly less computational resources and training data. Our
implementation of EE-Tuning achieves outstanding training efficiency via
extensive performance optimizations, as well as scalability due to its full
compatibility with 3D parallelism. Results of systematic experiments validate
the efficacy of EE-Tuning, confirming that effective early-exit LLM inference
can be achieved with a limited training budget. In hope of making early-exit
LLMs accessible to the community, we release the source code of our
implementation of EE-Tuning at https://github.com/pan-x-c/EE-LLM. | [
-0.6183629035949707,
-0.8221254944801331,
0.7118956446647644,
0.27388980984687805,
-0.2310461848974228,
-0.10249785333871841,
-0.6591446995735168,
-0.2816586196422577,
0.02861512266099453,
0.3714315891265869,
-0.5865971446037292,
-0.4867100715637207,
-0.465073823928833,
-0.02371828630566597,
-0.34055063128471375,
0.4930034279823303,
0.1018841490149498,
0.05814161151647568,
0.06599219888448715,
0.17781059443950653,
0.1751057505607605,
-0.1107267439365387,
-1.2543988227844238,
-0.2042817771434784,
0.9666591286659241,
0.7434414625167847,
0.267257958650589,
1.1739106178283691,
0.12203169614076614,
0.24164801836013794,
-0.07576504349708557,
0.03943196311593056,
-0.7809103727340698,
-0.30252814292907715,
0.13075165450572968,
-0.4932510256767273,
-0.6344669461250305,
-0.02585447020828724,
0.4163701832294464,
0.8099809288978577,
-0.45315247774124146,
0.18878036737442017,
0.15208762884140015,
0.6807767748832703,
-0.7923902273178101,
0.07449006289243698,
-0.8379858732223511,
-0.13808992505073547,
-0.6714243292808533,
-0.27298474311828613,
-0.5139882564544678,
-0.2127668857574463,
-0.27452215552330017,
-0.8259320259094238,
0.03590771183371544,
0.3558766841888428,
0.8198369741439819,
0.240105539560318,
-0.18014013767242432,
0.11857279390096664,
-0.4367070198059082,
0.7871937155723572,
-0.6728506684303284,
0.6185294389724731,
0.16969941556453705,
0.22889907658100128,
0.006790482439100742,
-0.45576661825180054,
-0.5739112496376038,
0.01808510534465313,
0.33166196942329407,
0.0913478285074234,
-0.0006109554087743163,
0.28079357743263245,
0.14985831081867218,
0.43573102355003357,
-0.550113320350647,
0.7489522099494934,
0.03661072626709938,
0.00011213164543733001,
0.29213646054267883,
0.0769781768321991,
0.09975678473711014,
0.33683472871780396,
-0.13162828981876373,
-0.04562278464436531,
-1.024056077003479,
-0.19882643222808838,
0.6195081472396851,
0.5098393559455872,
-0.23034194111824036,
0.3507862985134125,
-0.2968374788761139,
0.8197111487388611,
0.11556767672300339,
0.0926838368177414,
0.11760605126619339,
0.005988137796521187,
-0.23882907629013062,
0.04130152240395546,
0.44916096329689026,
0.32224783301353455,
0.3766530454158783,
-0.23393982648849487,
-0.29621902108192444,
-0.1742267906665802,
-0.19339242577552795,
-0.8480574488639832,
-0.3045605421066284,
0.0901632010936737,
-0.4903874099254608,
-0.25472357869148254,
-0.287050724029541,
-0.741079568862915,
-0.04442876949906349,
-0.6210770010948181,
0.31826746463775635,
-0.33430835604667664,
-0.4046815037727356,
0.32154202461242676,
0.2603968381881714,
0.5036324858665466,
0.41913947463035583,
-0.9405498504638672,
0.2330377846956253,
0.5367121696472168,
0.8079060316085815,
-0.08180860430002213,
-0.47352534532546997,
-0.9552514553070068,
0.2301763892173767,
-0.218294158577919,
0.5896242260932922,
-0.5812796354293823,
-0.18404395878314972,
-0.09683062136173248,
0.0519707165658474,
0.14865513145923615,
-0.5062237977981567,
0.4951953589916229,
-0.6882508993148804,
-0.13648946583271027,
-0.028610099107027054,
-0.5022339820861816,
0.012919953092932701,
-0.06056921184062958,
-0.6415400505065918,
0.8451993465423584,
-0.15885645151138306,
-0.3455272614955902,
0.5192633867263794,
-0.6489142775535583,
-0.33464375138282776,
0.1445723921060562,
0.09392069280147552,
-0.3597767651081085,
0.4890648126602173,
0.4004984498023987,
0.47382140159606934,
-0.6424962878227234,
-0.3407217562198639,
-0.6253209114074707,
-0.5009010434150696,
-0.5923438668251038,
-0.07266994565725327,
0.5813786387443542,
0.43819549679756165,
-0.23510298132896423,
-0.19581526517868042,
-1.244746208190918,
0.3150049149990082,
0.21570557355880737,
-0.3762373924255371,
-0.384065717458725,
0.08464383333921432,
0.14587661623954773,
-0.19514986872673035,
0.5888735055923462,
-0.4474334120750427,
0.004044102504849434,
-0.43560683727264404,
0.096584752202034,
0.8761163949966431,
-0.4876161515712738,
0.42933863401412964,
0.06667914241552353,
0.5161834955215454,
0.01581401750445366,
0.04638676345348358,
-0.3498798906803131,
-0.30779266357421875,
-0.8951709270477295,
-0.5626128911972046,
0.3431910276412964,
0.4864337742328644,
-0.4981101155281067,
0.9002364873886108,
-0.12808452546596527,
-0.5044933557510376,
-0.380330890417099,
0.3275321424007416,
0.32561489939689636,
0.4843093454837799,
0.2467799037694931,
0.14999255537986755,
-0.6426782608032227,
-0.9929250478744507,
-0.49029862880706787,
-0.04043792188167572,
-0.23297739028930664,
0.28798988461494446,
0.2022310495376587,
-0.07030873745679855,
0.7047387361526489,
-0.410824179649353,
-0.006602188106626272,
-0.29743435978889465,
0.21829423308372498,
0.48964250087738037,
0.3221479654312134,
0.4123738408088684,
-0.3251650035381317,
-0.7080466151237488,
0.308024138212204,
-0.3680225610733032,
-0.5435982346534729,
0.13769188523292542,
-0.0913686603307724,
-0.01990385167300701,
0.8386660218238831,
-0.2560962438583374,
-0.0758940577507019,
0.7644108533859253,
-0.26191556453704834,
0.3144587576389313,
-0.18956829607486725,
0.09607945382595062,
-0.8770105242729187,
0.060211461037397385,
0.11351439356803894,
-0.4749343991279602,
-0.25023043155670166,
-0.08336304128170013,
0.2557648718357086,
-0.13571494817733765,
-0.6025177836418152,
0.4273911118507385,
-0.5946552157402039,
0.20369650423526764,
-0.2286449372768402,
0.1749778836965561,
-0.036824170500040054,
0.26494917273521423,
0.024690592661499977,
0.9468886852264404,
0.8285637497901917,
-0.8092728853225708,
0.009962372481822968,
-0.06357245147228241,
-0.45017263293266296,
0.3840222954750061,
-0.6601617336273193,
0.17875412106513977,
-0.21790219843387604,
-0.1901620477437973,
-0.3266501724720001,
-0.10595833510160446,
-0.20234182476997375,
-0.03719012811779976,
0.47484341263771057,
-0.20298165082931519,
-0.39299145340919495,
-0.18241527676582336,
-0.30639493465423584,
0.2792467474937439,
0.5320085287094116,
-0.9588114023208618,
0.38140198588371277,
0.2530996799468994,
-0.2380874752998352,
-0.1482764482498169,
-0.5185316205024719,
0.01803913339972496,
-0.3681568205356598,
-0.45883625745773315,
0.25090667605400085,
-0.0752183049917221,
-0.023641368374228477,
-0.015449291095137596,
0.1696685403585434,
0.022823192179203033,
0.09482579678297043,
-0.5259730219841003,
-0.1213746964931488,
-0.44062721729278564,
-0.19604989886283875,
0.19178630411624908,
-0.26130253076553345,
-0.021576207131147385,
-0.4563472270965576,
0.5090960264205933,
-0.30400294065475464,
-0.2761533558368683,
-0.044756606221199036,
0.3524523079395294,
0.5760202407836914,
-0.13836713135242462,
1.0919708013534546,
0.4540577828884125,
-0.32096487283706665,
-0.5455104112625122,
-0.7606847882270813,
-0.11402225494384766,
-0.515312135219574,
0.7324747443199158,
-0.46697551012039185,
-0.8609601855278015,
0.6076841950416565,
-0.5849800109863281,
-0.028630323708057404,
0.20168070495128632,
0.7070528864860535,
-0.33239489793777466,
1.195527195930481,
0.8956663012504578,
0.04003484547138214,
0.6345580816268921,
0.052017685025930405,
0.21448273956775665,
-0.8663334250450134,
0.0484100803732872,
-0.6022759079933167,
-0.2932058274745941,
-0.5245685577392578,
-0.047918420284986496,
0.6169354915618896,
0.4645281136035919,
-0.4076743721961975,
0.1767793893814087,
-0.18214668333530426,
1.0963160991668701,
0.3571784794330597,
0.144973024725914,
0.230264350771904,
-0.14954084157943726,
-0.06824637204408646,
-0.04432503506541252,
-0.8551169633865356,
-0.5037134289741516,
1.280580759048462,
0.26580023765563965,
0.8680921792984009,
0.044481270015239716,
0.8559156060218811,
-0.16417554020881653,
0.17869915068149567,
-0.43523842096328735,
0.5309709906578064,
-0.36290061473846436,
-0.2758042812347412,
-0.5303585529327393,
-0.5659083724021912,
-0.931136965751648,
0.16523298621177673,
-0.016569098457694054,
-0.883913516998291,
0.2192901223897934,
0.48052191734313965,
-0.2929290533065796,
0.5696561336517334,
-1.0052447319030762,
0.9651896357536316,
-0.35582128167152405,
-0.6113945245742798,
-0.29444923996925354,
-0.2851985692977905,
0.512435793876648,
-0.4378851652145386,
0.10100963711738586,
-0.1486775279045105,
-0.3709999620914459,
0.5309460163116455,
-0.45435091853141785,
0.6572450399398804,
-0.32398319244384766,
-0.18484698235988617,
-0.1571694016456604,
-0.060095131397247314,
0.7755031585693359,
0.30757179856300354,
-0.15885864198207855,
0.294053852558136,
-0.29962775111198425,
-0.49089154601097107,
-0.27549782395362854,
0.9268107414245605,
-0.8718551397323608,
-0.3261895477771759,
-0.05599075183272362,
-0.13174182176589966,
-0.4279380440711975,
0.4512466788291931,
0.41310495138168335,
0.2024887502193451,
-0.10822857171297073,
0.4240126311779022,
1.086634874343872,
-0.449364572763443,
0.4847390055656433,
0.7039399743080139,
-0.268652081489563,
-0.2160162627696991,
0.8360570669174194,
-0.226875901222229,
0.14135733246803284,
0.38665294647216797,
0.26101183891296387,
-0.5180656909942627,
-0.791272759437561,
-0.4110246002674103,
0.3077619969844818,
-0.40358608961105347,
-0.17764639854431152,
-0.31700634956359863,
-0.053874671459198,
-0.00306086428463459,
-0.24204182624816895,
-0.8732042908668518,
-0.1148262470960617,
-0.29312384128570557,
0.04577558860182762,
0.25560712814331055,
0.4878971576690674,
-0.17054034769535065,
0.4673731327056885,
-0.7475305199623108,
0.2605969309806824,
0.24777038395404816,
0.8869174122810364,
-0.10826795548200607,
-0.45134586095809937,
-0.7832276225090027,
-0.3304309546947479,
-0.16791556775569916,
-0.5166646838188171,
0.12247857451438904,
0.6428630948066711,
0.5822299122810364,
0.6399773955345154,
-0.2915637195110321,
0.6272969841957092,
-0.79816734790802,
0.6138396859169006,
0.4017927646636963,
-0.9812479019165039,
0.645372211933136,
-0.5510817766189575,
0.507797122001648,
0.8386649489402771,
0.15152180194854736,
-0.0072062197141349316,
-0.12715408205986023,
-0.015851285308599472,
-1.0124807357788086,
0.7446980476379395,
-0.059889793395996094,
-0.12773486971855164,
-0.04885464161634445,
0.344736784696579,
0.29918986558914185,
0.2748870849609375,
-0.7134512662887573,
-0.4895728826522827,
0.08541289716959,
0.00919722206890583,
-0.3758561313152313,
-0.3101315200328827,
0.05679291486740112,
-0.404883474111557,
0.760315477848053,
-0.29182058572769165,
-0.1019841805100441,
-0.3606710731983185,
-0.2532259225845337,
-0.4538528025150299,
0.08951831609010696,
0.27668121457099915,
0.6536461114883423,
-0.35134923458099365,
-0.09054265916347504,
0.2218235582113266,
-0.24885991215705872,
0.22620554268360138,
-0.00396316172555089,
-0.1408170759677887,
-0.2862551808357239,
0.031019791960716248,
0.8414905071258545,
0.5368440747261047,
-0.4464099109172821,
0.33157262206077576,
-0.13840623199939728,
-0.27653244137763977,
-0.25093185901641846,
0.03539155051112175,
0.254508912563324,
0.06934501230716705,
0.19430360198020935,
-0.2696487307548523,
-0.0009861383587121964,
-0.26788491010665894,
0.18868449330329895,
0.40345725417137146,
0.29696738719940186,
-0.19935515522956848,
1.0420536994934082,
0.5392366647720337,
-0.17384220659732819,
0.5953351855278015,
-0.266795814037323,
0.01683269627392292,
0.4198741316795349,
0.46569809317588806,
1.321615219116211,
-0.11361623555421829,
-0.24001795053482056,
0.28752222657203674,
0.6479642391204834,
-0.03323642909526825,
0.4097910225391388,
-0.001620716997422278,
-0.6431160569190979,
-0.9662464261054993,
-0.8981055021286011,
-0.41168898344039917,
0.3689591586589813,
-0.8025794625282288,
0.7736098170280457,
-0.25591593980789185,
0.2245798408985138,
-0.5235117673873901,
-0.29609397053718567,
-0.9980942010879517,
0.14106883108615875,
0.5091160535812378,
1.3348394632339478,
-0.6984284520149231,
0.9227012395858765,
0.7099225521087646,
0.1686083972454071,
-0.55487060546875,
-0.054784759879112244,
-0.022412171587347984,
-0.7628462314605713,
0.342311292886734,
-0.04177756607532501,
-0.36110618710517883,
0.5265642404556274,
-0.5223158001899719,
-0.8482586145401001,
0.9609442353248596,
0.8011578321456909,
-1.2443695068359375,
-0.06207987666130066,
0.07258167862892151,
0.28436073660850525,
-0.27145281434059143,
0.45867136120796204,
0.8277621269226074,
0.7366757988929749,
-0.18029722571372986,
-0.8819897770881653,
-0.3616558313369751,
-0.2687585651874542,
0.11130934953689575,
0.3391936719417572,
-0.8865076899528503,
0.7256800532341003,
0.031022636219859123,
-0.035510748624801636,
-0.13079933822155,
0.599607527256012,
0.15833760797977448,
0.08570677042007446,
0.9483928084373474,
0.9555699229240417,
0.6672335267066956,
-0.2469540685415268,
0.8589734435081482,
-0.9678515791893005,
0.23971688747406006,
0.8715270161628723,
-0.30212751030921936,
0.7154052257537842,
0.5480425953865051,
-0.12917432188987732,
0.08702535927295685,
0.7119284272193909,
0.391454815864563,
0.739901602268219,
0.16775137186050415,
-0.21777717769145966,
-0.6366062164306641,
0.4186730980873108,
-0.5322179794311523,
0.5668879747390747,
0.3495124578475952,
0.18291467428207397,
-0.2535887658596039,
-0.15882059931755066,
-0.1681080460548401,
-0.05635290592908859,
-0.643845796585083,
0.6667946577072144,
0.23412081599235535,
-0.20846328139305115,
0.561913251876831,
0.03403754532337189,
0.7656083703041077,
-0.9646108150482178,
0.19312182068824768,
-0.30338746309280396,
0.018172599375247955,
-0.17086076736450195,
-0.1253305822610855,
0.08551618456840515,
0.017329800873994827,
-0.14113155007362366,
-0.4324576258659363,
0.17243897914886475,
-0.42458900809288025,
-0.5548190474510193,
0.4846334159374237,
0.7773929834365845,
-0.04785069450736046,
0.03541511297225952,
-0.6437325477600098,
0.2702995836734772,
-0.19366715848445892,
-0.7826946973800659,
0.4224702715873718,
0.686265766620636,
0.5042492151260376,
0.507088303565979,
0.516838788986206,
0.6999478936195374,
0.2999548316001892,
0.15714512765407562,
0.8041654229164124,
-0.7023522853851318,
-0.8390933275222778,
-0.7663983106613159,
0.5980644822120667,
-0.04605302959680557,
-0.3450208604335785,
0.6734339594841003,
0.8460172414779663,
0.9313536286354065,
-0.06757944077253342,
0.7972438931465149,
0.12794038653373718,
0.59908127784729,
-0.957700252532959,
0.6630153656005859,
-0.8982844948768616,
0.61581951379776,
-0.1555170863866806,
-1.3927992582321167,
-0.11260222643613815,
0.35580822825431824,
-0.03124702349305153,
0.25732338428497314,
0.6777303218841553,
0.855449914932251,
-0.412323921918869,
-0.18733875453472137,
0.5783315300941467,
0.3390011489391327,
0.2648911774158478,
0.6854773163795471,
0.584394097328186,
-0.06368129700422287,
0.38304463028907776,
-0.13759742677211761,
-0.5613206028938293,
-0.1911211907863617,
-1.1784251928329468,
-0.7371340394020081,
-0.19935958087444305,
-0.3204312324523926,
0.08677849918603897,
0.053811974823474884,
0.7758952975273132,
0.914311945438385,
-0.9210615158081055,
-0.22149550914764404,
-0.38240689039230347,
-0.1494177132844925,
-0.14715637266635895,
-0.17706386744976044,
0.1025475561618805,
-0.6727535724639893,
-1.0621697902679443,
0.8326351642608643,
0.36279380321502686,
-0.38518065214157104,
-0.32378706336021423,
-0.21013528108596802,
0.1398693174123764,
0.22027765214443207,
0.5477646589279175,
0.353186696767807,
-0.39568012952804565,
-0.10576868802309036,
-0.16229557991027832,
0.13207568228244781,
0.03925352916121483,
0.8710589408874512,
-0.5588228106498718,
0.32986611127853394,
0.15584112703800201,
0.7480329275131226,
0.6916388273239136,
-0.3518843948841095,
0.836717963218689,
-0.7664562463760376,
0.4148695766925812,
0.035851649940013885,
0.47361811995506287,
-0.10072050988674164,
-0.16605244576931,
0.4122094213962555,
0.011026902124285698,
-0.5179375410079956,
-0.9330103993415833,
0.11034022271633148,
-0.6925055980682373,
0.1649879813194275,
0.7473292350769043,
0.1701963096857071,
-0.29812702536582947,
0.10456864535808563,
0.16001251339912415,
-0.062154993414878845,
-0.35715436935424805,
0.6732785701751709,
0.7098865509033203,
-0.05008217692375183,
-0.4546019434928894,
-0.43626466393470764,
0.35559263825416565,
0.45605531334877014,
-0.9345040917396545,
0.15146183967590332,
0.17566412687301636,
0.018988119438290596,
-0.4477919936180115,
0.40281838178634644,
0.014965039677917957,
0.21739104390144348,
0.03819071501493454,
0.2353380024433136,
-0.26963329315185547,
-0.3900081515312195,
-0.4211621880531311,
0.10968609899282455,
0.3998887240886688,
-0.1743421107530594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00913v1 | Institutional Platform for Secure Self-Service Large Language Model Exploration | 2024-02-01T10:58:10 | 2024-02-01T10:58:10 | V. K. Cody Bumgardner, Mitchell A. Klusty, W. Vaiden Logan, Samuel E. Armstrong, Caylin Hickey, Jeff Talbert | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper introduces a user-friendly platform developed by the University of
Kentucky Center for Applied AI, designed to make large, customized language
models (LLMs) more accessible. By capitalizing on recent advancements in
multi-LoRA inference, the system efficiently accommodates custom adapters for a
diverse range of users and projects. The paper outlines the system's
architecture and key features, encompassing dataset curation, model training,
secure inference, and text-based feature extraction.
We illustrate the establishment of a tenant-aware computational network using
agent-based methods, securely utilizing islands of isolated resources as a
unified system. The platform strives to deliver secure LLM services,
emphasizing process and data isolation, end-to-end encryption, and role-based
resource authentication. This contribution aligns with the overarching goal of
enabling simplified access to cutting-edge AI models and technology in support
of scientific discovery. | [
-0.3129466474056244,
-0.7552890777587891,
0.7006580233573914,
0.16522353887557983,
0.2739015519618988,
0.3468206524848938,
-0.2725468873977661,
-0.4156923294067383,
0.3044929504394531,
0.9290162920951843,
-0.1573084145784378,
-0.695018470287323,
-0.40617239475250244,
0.2139749675989151,
-0.34274381399154663,
0.5789782404899597,
0.10498782992362976,
0.0923367440700531,
-0.12658269703388214,
-0.03360738977789879,
-0.01862466149032116,
-0.6674435138702393,
-0.5783923268318176,
-0.42665427923202515,
0.4510985314846039,
0.4093564748764038,
0.6613671183586121,
0.8248189687728882,
0.7090766429901123,
0.5001880526542664,
0.21827439963817596,
-0.055496491491794586,
-0.21570006012916565,
0.3604435324668884,
-0.2711929678916931,
-0.40395522117614746,
-0.6025445461273193,
-0.1340216100215912,
0.6376477479934692,
0.5592869520187378,
-0.375728577375412,
0.192174032330513,
-0.2222304493188858,
0.43961116671562195,
-0.7493443489074707,
0.3524141311645508,
-0.6033074855804443,
-0.05159280449151993,
-0.35635340213775635,
0.2804620563983917,
-0.502179741859436,
0.1841680258512497,
0.017061855643987656,
-0.774052083492279,
-0.24874630570411682,
-0.03355288505554199,
0.23000451922416687,
0.176844522356987,
-0.4915848672389984,
-0.0712154433131218,
-0.6920610666275024,
0.6406024694442749,
-0.43057987093925476,
0.42443084716796875,
0.3899743854999542,
0.6129846572875977,
-0.45474356412887573,
-0.975897490978241,
-0.43542325496673584,
-0.4475163221359253,
-0.014215749688446522,
-0.19305716454982758,
-0.15387815237045288,
0.17744563519954681,
-0.021859481930732727,
0.05150316283106804,
-0.4720202684402466,
0.5601796507835388,
-0.2768249809741974,
-0.1994035542011261,
0.7440500259399414,
0.18053846061229706,
0.2832312285900116,
-0.12382803857326508,
-0.1438390165567398,
-0.033143702894449234,
-0.7176878452301025,
0.19103918969631195,
0.32569295167922974,
0.6850355267524719,
-0.1666923612356186,
0.6674085855484009,
-0.23766016960144043,
0.10870551317930222,
-0.329965740442276,
0.28035616874694824,
0.135141521692276,
-0.06509134918451309,
-0.401628315448761,
0.11815574765205383,
0.9312518239021301,
-0.38247618079185486,
-0.11867455393075943,
-0.28567180037498474,
-0.2598220407962799,
0.10358047485351562,
0.31034055352211,
-0.6203356385231018,
-0.22010061144828796,
0.28852495551109314,
-0.461154580116272,
-0.3736180365085602,
0.01443689875304699,
-0.6912875771522522,
-0.616631269454956,
-0.24866777658462524,
0.19554992020130157,
-0.015376737341284752,
-0.374416321516037,
-0.1226683109998703,
0.05823809280991554,
0.048474084585905075,
0.30492642521858215,
-1.0410354137420654,
0.7294037342071533,
0.8486193418502808,
0.8516331315040588,
-0.436321884393692,
-0.2862768769264221,
-0.5721842050552368,
0.2147386223077774,
-0.17973583936691284,
0.4015275835990906,
-0.6990885734558105,
-0.5265504717826843,
0.043554048985242844,
0.1961519420146942,
0.1282215714454651,
-0.27702152729034424,
0.35578015446662903,
-0.8608990907669067,
-0.15019769966602325,
-0.021988369524478912,
-0.5013452768325806,
0.00841251015663147,
0.18093188107013702,
-0.8552584648132324,
0.8581745624542236,
0.1373719424009323,
-0.5321601629257202,
-0.14381113648414612,
-1.2403815984725952,
0.07385668158531189,
0.3329433798789978,
-0.5063328742980957,
-0.2644769847393036,
-0.060714829713106155,
0.21873007714748383,
0.2504847049713135,
-0.01059635914862156,
0.4521804749965668,
-0.7615987658500671,
-0.1158071830868721,
0.3491705358028412,
-0.19988785684108734,
0.9039459228515625,
0.5602810978889465,
-0.34949636459350586,
0.2689673602581024,
-0.9195378422737122,
0.014334793202579021,
0.2620350122451782,
-0.2629539370536804,
-0.4784095585346222,
-0.18309904634952545,
0.1954652965068817,
-0.21341685950756073,
0.7763630151748657,
-0.603354275226593,
0.5031020641326904,
-0.11563427001237869,
0.737129271030426,
0.8926066160202026,
-0.4050537347793579,
0.5334606766700745,
0.37352412939071655,
0.6812294721603394,
0.01952560618519783,
0.20157663524150848,
-0.2889062762260437,
-0.09282077103853226,
-0.47238874435424805,
-0.6244075894355774,
0.19723673164844513,
0.5073011517524719,
-0.5422013401985168,
0.3928275406360626,
-0.07201281934976578,
-0.4833943247795105,
-0.6734805107116699,
0.2690613865852356,
0.16919450461864471,
0.2774670422077179,
0.21570010483264923,
-0.24833504855632782,
-0.4160066545009613,
-1.0798907279968262,
0.13015004992485046,
-0.11943306028842926,
0.03397559002041817,
0.34309977293014526,
0.6718294024467468,
-0.6648582816123962,
1.0336557626724243,
-0.25071224570274353,
-0.13411970436573029,
-0.17792962491512299,
-0.24388781189918518,
0.31698960065841675,
0.5050106048583984,
0.35623684525489807,
-0.8087106943130493,
-0.2578670084476471,
0.25082793831825256,
-1.2516216039657593,
-0.017404336482286453,
0.2759449779987335,
-0.21187153458595276,
-0.10984355211257935,
0.587698757648468,
-0.6609430313110352,
0.21289843320846558,
0.669369101524353,
-0.28437361121177673,
0.39450353384017944,
-0.3675898015499115,
-0.13643142580986023,
-1.1339002847671509,
0.23055948317050934,
-0.2160298079252243,
-0.37683308124542236,
-0.6425475478172302,
0.5644973516464233,
-0.175315260887146,
-0.32085224986076355,
-0.13459989428520203,
0.6836661100387573,
-0.3834308981895447,
-0.41059988737106323,
-0.4445825517177582,
0.3504108786582947,
0.134412482380867,
0.1605900675058365,
-0.029344743117690086,
0.8739153146743774,
0.799746036529541,
-0.28291428089141846,
0.4278680384159088,
0.5386249423027039,
-0.07948870956897736,
0.25183025002479553,
-0.6561530828475952,
0.4026409983634949,
0.2519345283508301,
0.2638023793697357,
-0.5714998841285706,
-0.3646462559700012,
0.13531190156936646,
-0.15019850432872772,
0.02900843881070614,
-0.10317310690879822,
-0.21600495278835297,
-0.273790180683136,
-0.165551096200943,
0.3319830596446991,
-0.019761834293603897,
-0.7651748061180115,
0.8192472457885742,
0.7689040303230286,
-0.32224178314208984,
-0.8063173890113831,
-0.63835209608078,
0.5557831525802612,
-0.2631901204586029,
-0.6239125728607178,
0.03164515644311905,
-0.08076318353414536,
-0.625853419303894,
-0.04315289482474327,
0.4161357581615448,
-0.304593026638031,
0.5504120588302612,
0.5352693796157837,
0.24661919474601746,
-0.4739683270454407,
0.12178591638803482,
-0.05021120607852936,
-0.051940467208623886,
0.33347848057746887,
-0.37517064809799194,
0.3894124925136566,
-0.5107992887496948,
-0.5581220984458923,
-0.46174752712249756,
0.520764172077179,
0.7495747804641724,
-0.291594535112381,
0.6582523584365845,
0.4661335349082947,
-0.434519499540329,
-0.21578042209148407,
-0.37025725841522217,
-0.3038965165615082,
-0.621012806892395,
0.2888681888580322,
-0.4927848279476166,
-1.251213788986206,
0.7862223386764526,
-0.10996232181787491,
0.12990382313728333,
0.3980446755886078,
0.5176647901535034,
-0.00826414953917265,
0.7702086567878723,
0.8387342691421509,
-0.3558763861656189,
0.405124306678772,
-0.246750146150589,
0.3635643422603607,
-0.8847815990447998,
-0.07145002484321594,
-0.8821152448654175,
-0.04232819378376007,
-0.9127749800682068,
-0.06274743378162384,
0.29385438561439514,
-0.18993854522705078,
-0.5949654579162598,
0.2959814965724945,
-0.5194531679153442,
0.2894226014614105,
0.8015866279602051,
-0.08674889802932739,
0.5209802389144897,
-0.01312264334410429,
-0.07228466123342514,
0.05222611129283905,
-0.469165563583374,
-0.797393262386322,
1.2122832536697388,
0.6162830591201782,
1.0533347129821777,
0.29854604601860046,
0.8991571664810181,
0.7717337012290955,
0.3285805583000183,
-0.3658016622066498,
0.48145541548728943,
-0.12239113450050354,
-0.7058814764022827,
-0.7142012715339661,
-0.5116803050041199,
-0.9799626469612122,
0.27764132618904114,
-0.1049867793917656,
-1.1562172174453735,
0.2586213946342468,
0.030538927763700485,
-0.2665014863014221,
0.213109090924263,
-0.7276518940925598,
0.7635769248008728,
-0.42567679286003113,
-0.22729040682315826,
-0.277278870344162,
-0.44065091013908386,
0.4570763409137726,
-0.1883469969034195,
0.3685911297798157,
0.044899389147758484,
0.08279269188642502,
0.4517524838447571,
-0.33280375599861145,
0.9296482801437378,
-0.1964443176984787,
0.0077911014668643475,
0.2992503345012665,
0.22056594491004944,
0.606559693813324,
0.28636434674263,
-0.2925221621990204,
0.33471062779426575,
-0.008167118765413761,
-0.22834424674510956,
-0.532036304473877,
0.9532163143157959,
-1.1655467748641968,
-0.7284908294677734,
-0.2138330638408661,
-0.48074766993522644,
0.0061683389358222485,
0.28904521465301514,
-0.3586677014827728,
0.17333905398845673,
-0.4073356091976166,
0.472925066947937,
0.4660611152648926,
-0.07800453901290894,
0.3813972771167755,
0.6391381621360779,
-0.46566277742385864,
-0.3604919910430908,
0.5941833257675171,
-0.0860653892159462,
-0.0020125522278249264,
0.3659587502479553,
0.3365989625453949,
-0.5301414728164673,
-0.529682457447052,
-0.38297542929649353,
0.018537160009145737,
-0.7674852609634399,
-0.05271489918231964,
-0.7387219667434692,
-0.3844098746776581,
-0.7341024875640869,
-0.17247925698757172,
-0.5182358622550964,
-0.5051382780075073,
-0.22816938161849976,
-0.2497628927230835,
0.3829653561115265,
0.8670085668563843,
-0.054522786289453506,
0.7006158232688904,
-0.5859476327896118,
0.1431816667318344,
0.14391063153743744,
0.2782774269580841,
-0.24569910764694214,
-0.37957334518432617,
-0.31472131609916687,
-0.17250388860702515,
-0.14272725582122803,
-0.5719135999679565,
0.31243976950645447,
0.10619208216667175,
0.715121328830719,
0.6050686240196228,
0.03239520266652107,
0.0635209009051323,
-0.2943505346775055,
0.8145623207092285,
0.006379527971148491,
-0.9864311218261719,
0.3763657808303833,
-0.49220097064971924,
0.12474922090768814,
0.6499441862106323,
0.16775749623775482,
-0.37602129578590393,
-0.33957940340042114,
-0.5796846151351929,
-0.581378698348999,
0.3911283016204834,
0.02673976495862007,
0.05200100317597389,
0.2678224444389343,
0.5488079190254211,
0.008817690424621105,
0.37094831466674805,
-1.064529299736023,
-0.20380137860774994,
-0.324048787355423,
-0.2330009490251541,
0.015646904706954956,
0.05900014191865921,
-0.4596903324127197,
0.24081963300704956,
0.7928257584571838,
-0.5370914936065674,
0.046041086316108704,
0.0938112884759903,
-0.015536378137767315,
0.09433429688215256,
0.42755335569381714,
0.3351849913597107,
0.6544913053512573,
0.06818318367004395,
0.3233848214149475,
0.1725224107503891,
-0.5581697225570679,
0.09747280925512314,
0.3367559015750885,
-0.26117122173309326,
-0.25286027789115906,
0.3094179034233093,
0.6367781758308411,
-0.019728325307369232,
-0.6473075151443481,
0.19463440775871277,
-0.249566912651062,
0.05073736608028412,
-0.6058743596076965,
0.27308133244514465,
0.118585966527462,
0.6416042447090149,
0.33983173966407776,
-0.377190500497818,
0.31465765833854675,
-0.3576684594154358,
0.1441090852022171,
0.5788515210151672,
-0.33417871594429016,
-0.23521482944488525,
0.5983534455299377,
0.24258777499198914,
-0.5082473158836365,
0.7073190212249756,
0.04403328150510788,
-0.24557003378868103,
0.6364423632621765,
0.46694236993789673,
0.9588059186935425,
-0.4467727243900299,
0.2485787570476532,
0.005455777049064636,
0.43739938735961914,
0.0847422331571579,
0.12677957117557526,
-0.048889629542827606,
-0.7285047173500061,
-0.1167234554886818,
-0.5787704586982727,
-0.6339719891548157,
0.393280029296875,
-0.4441770017147064,
0.144805446267128,
-0.5648083090782166,
-0.3440476655960083,
-0.12023264169692993,
0.08166443556547165,
-0.4836547374725342,
-0.1747412532567978,
0.17364665865898132,
1.1049418449401855,
-0.6597709655761719,
0.8782899379730225,
0.5339584946632385,
-0.103938989341259,
-0.6989265084266663,
-0.9073819518089294,
-0.015347952954471111,
-0.9575392007827759,
0.4603930711746216,
0.027951620519161224,
-0.23790206015110016,
-0.2197040468454361,
-0.6849191188812256,
-0.9281567931175232,
1.2237930297851562,
0.46188095211982727,
-0.8331742882728577,
-0.0860474556684494,
0.4060446619987488,
0.6379318833351135,
-0.7324764728546143,
0.2747946083545685,
0.4981578290462494,
0.5813864469528198,
-0.38596436381340027,
-0.6816088557243347,
-0.12431782484054565,
-0.19280393421649933,
-0.30122238397598267,
-0.17616257071495056,
-0.6059732437133789,
0.6162166595458984,
-0.09199563413858414,
0.26364263892173767,
0.06158046796917915,
0.8195375800132751,
0.3439761698246002,
0.48141831159591675,
0.5330542325973511,
0.31812581419944763,
0.9844003915786743,
0.23990535736083984,
0.7624734044075012,
-0.46619170904159546,
0.24057266116142273,
1.3621824979782104,
-0.5035686492919922,
0.8499809503555298,
0.5382885336875916,
0.0287260040640831,
0.5087575912475586,
0.5137609243392944,
-0.0625280812382698,
0.2959516942501068,
0.3196403980255127,
-0.4000990092754364,
-0.28844109177589417,
-0.42171919345855713,
-0.23634396493434906,
0.7499544024467468,
0.5549561381340027,
-0.4596107602119446,
-0.15341444313526154,
-0.15103337168693542,
-0.22470329701900482,
0.1662633717060089,
-0.20061007142066956,
0.653954803943634,
0.4390203058719635,
-0.3281632661819458,
-0.19749701023101807,
0.14016513526439667,
0.08094955235719681,
-0.7855910658836365,
0.05639467388391495,
-0.10968351364135742,
0.05732223764061928,
-0.15344414114952087,
-0.5638061165809631,
-0.034282997250556946,
0.021813467144966125,
-0.00022066970996093005,
-0.14534889161586761,
0.6749696731567383,
-0.22408777475357056,
-0.44660016894340515,
0.5449056029319763,
0.7296063303947449,
0.10048843175172806,
0.2608858048915863,
-0.7049129605293274,
0.20108003914356232,
-0.4309546649456024,
-0.532077968120575,
0.3246716856956482,
0.5327197909355164,
-0.38112083077430725,
1.0029741525650024,
0.7222237586975098,
0.1299850344657898,
-0.03504366800189018,
0.3088783025741577,
0.7942497134208679,
-0.4367092549800873,
-0.7928710579872131,
-0.7848591804504395,
0.06470821797847748,
-0.16272792220115662,
-0.15367335081100464,
0.5275129079818726,
0.5191754698753357,
0.4780091941356659,
0.21650570631027222,
1.0144941806793213,
0.19140993058681488,
0.1893630474805832,
-0.3557528257369995,
0.8358486294746399,
-0.239047110080719,
0.3159753084182739,
0.011226112954318523,
-0.7586587071418762,
-0.10199488699436188,
0.5351766347885132,
-0.22570174932479858,
-0.06742390990257263,
0.24200893938541412,
0.942818820476532,
-0.15585261583328247,
0.006139753386378288,
0.40060126781463623,
0.4942498505115509,
0.8489775061607361,
0.002435732400044799,
0.7647445797920227,
-0.051462315022945404,
0.21741706132888794,
0.02277623489499092,
-0.21008434891700745,
-0.1881672441959381,
-0.9219977855682373,
-0.8696134090423584,
-0.5396950244903564,
-0.04815312847495079,
-0.1766529530286789,
0.12688837945461273,
1.164495825767517,
0.8541802167892456,
-0.8175353407859802,
-0.43645939230918884,
0.006879711989313364,
0.08743823319673538,
0.16490161418914795,
-0.1946936994791031,
0.40201467275619507,
-0.16049189865589142,
-0.5330319404602051,
0.8763329982757568,
0.3946104943752289,
-0.1884293109178543,
-1.093062400817871,
-0.10266058892011642,
0.06275580823421478,
-0.018500415608286858,
0.22944650053977966,
0.49152955412864685,
-0.6149551272392273,
-0.22837300598621368,
0.21040649712085724,
-0.4247097671031952,
-0.0357070155441761,
0.7925199866294861,
-0.48662829399108887,
0.5090620517730713,
0.090554378926754,
1.1553962230682373,
0.3282659947872162,
-0.21871504187583923,
0.6382728815078735,
-0.3328219950199127,
0.10255011916160583,
0.03303930535912514,
0.6316680312156677,
0.4454694390296936,
-0.7737993597984314,
0.47053924202919006,
-0.013827994465827942,
-0.7971011996269226,
-0.800588071346283,
0.2329850196838379,
-1.0102511644363403,
-0.06587875634431839,
0.6229499578475952,
-0.41349104046821594,
-0.5185533761978149,
-0.17572443187236786,
0.1173488199710846,
0.03990737721323967,
-0.6516304612159729,
1.2120981216430664,
0.6473270058631897,
-0.03399674966931343,
-0.17279091477394104,
-0.5437145829200745,
0.23781102895736694,
0.04400802403688431,
-1.1183348894119263,
0.21831950545310974,
0.2955150306224823,
0.14212271571159363,
0.43717145919799805,
0.6717234253883362,
0.07198887318372726,
-0.010841776616871357,
-0.21243155002593994,
0.21740923821926117,
-0.2347113937139511,
-0.5884210467338562,
-0.49105513095855713,
0.14017853140830994,
0.167214497923851,
0.026287464424967766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01772v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01772v1 | Disentangling the Roles of Target-Side Transfer and Regularization in Multilingual Machine Translation | 2024-02-01T10:55:03 | 2024-02-01T10:55:03 | Yan Meng, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multilingual Machine Translation (MMT) benefits from knowledge transfer
across different language pairs. However, improvements in one-to-many
translation compared to many-to-one translation are only marginal and sometimes
even negligible. This performance discrepancy raises the question of to what
extent positive transfer plays a role on the target-side for one-to-many MT. In
this paper, we conduct a large-scale study that varies the auxiliary target
side languages along two dimensions, i.e., linguistic similarity and corpus
size, to show the dynamic impact of knowledge transfer on the main language
pairs. We show that linguistically similar auxiliary target languages exhibit
strong ability to transfer positive knowledge. With an increasing size of
similar target languages, the positive transfer is further enhanced to benefit
the main language pairs. Meanwhile, we find distant auxiliary target languages
can also unexpectedly benefit main language pairs, even with minimal positive
transfer ability. Apart from transfer, we show distant auxiliary target
languages can act as a regularizer to benefit translation performance by
enhancing the generalization and model inference calibration. | [
-0.5295641422271729,
-0.4157160520553589,
0.4259587824344635,
0.26255354285240173,
-0.2984275221824646,
-0.015413468703627586,
-0.5011364221572876,
-0.5580011606216431,
0.21397189795970917,
0.4670848250389099,
-0.3707554042339325,
-0.11766565591096878,
-1.0406060218811035,
0.34719014167785645,
-0.2628427743911743,
1.1492263078689575,
-0.10999323427677155,
-0.0917527824640274,
0.005704800132662058,
-0.3374328911304474,
-0.5016154646873474,
-0.6477289199829102,
-0.8194758892059326,
-0.03464733436703682,
0.9652791619300842,
0.3003945052623749,
0.8646729588508606,
0.6245535016059875,
0.7294346690177917,
0.2583644986152649,
0.42040160298347473,
-0.14775629341602325,
-0.5045254826545715,
0.14606723189353943,
-0.3292492628097534,
-0.7018168568611145,
-0.20823757350444794,
-0.024265455082058907,
0.9984737038612366,
0.6461881399154663,
0.4028278589248657,
0.18693315982818604,
0.09773825109004974,
0.8086125254631042,
-0.17542298138141632,
0.2009606510400772,
-0.4649094343185425,
-0.05265984311699867,
-0.2032732218503952,
-0.009710771031677723,
-0.3532344698905945,
-0.15325281023979187,
-0.024858525022864342,
-0.5768523812294006,
0.057157859206199646,
-0.11701687425374985,
0.8048956990242004,
0.571673572063446,
-0.9777811765670776,
-0.08608508855104446,
-0.7572802901268005,
0.8979750871658325,
-0.5554834604263306,
0.7668715119361877,
0.47308123111724854,
0.4607107937335968,
0.09831545501947403,
-0.1356566846370697,
-0.332329660654068,
-0.1179640144109726,
-0.41230109333992004,
0.1475570648908615,
-0.1516588181257248,
0.06468567997217178,
0.27293384075164795,
0.19398732483386993,
-0.39266860485076904,
0.24982181191444397,
-0.6931782364845276,
-0.2649344205856323,
0.4564031958580017,
-0.37752601504325867,
0.39045992493629456,
0.16364483535289764,
-0.46836215257644653,
-0.1258697211742401,
-0.48867160081863403,
-0.00014577119145542383,
0.18964414298534393,
0.5055726766586304,
-0.40266531705856323,
0.4941159784793854,
-0.01922878995537758,
0.6882256865501404,
-0.029774781316518784,
-0.28644636273384094,
0.0657455325126648,
-0.7613103985786438,
0.022750917822122574,
0.01218244805932045,
0.7732887268066406,
0.43534982204437256,
0.38999104499816895,
-0.43713846802711487,
-0.01849318854510784,
-0.149634450674057,
-0.13055765628814697,
-0.8387060761451721,
0.11474563181400299,
-0.2200019210577011,
-0.5094062089920044,
0.14711306989192963,
-0.0711330696940422,
-0.5391474962234497,
-0.08306466042995453,
-0.6166999340057373,
0.4881208539009094,
-0.36963024735450745,
-0.28770339488983154,
0.03239027410745621,
-0.13751763105392456,
0.17361557483673096,
0.20263230800628662,
-0.8576135635375977,
0.37838324904441833,
0.4868941307067871,
0.7816587090492249,
-0.3364729583263397,
-0.519644021987915,
-0.7492804527282715,
0.362027645111084,
-0.33059439063072205,
0.5111416578292847,
-0.3103765845298767,
-0.023781782016158104,
-0.14691023528575897,
-0.03922472894191742,
-0.45145541429519653,
-0.21581777930259705,
0.2908180058002472,
-0.44773802161216736,
0.31469812989234924,
-0.669124186038971,
-0.1393282413482666,
-0.4934099614620209,
0.22824934124946594,
-0.6163543462753296,
0.5395491719245911,
0.008199835196137428,
-0.493570476770401,
0.3515039086341858,
-0.36774742603302,
-0.8933349251747131,
-0.39694496989250183,
-0.12778452038764954,
-0.17265979945659637,
0.266096830368042,
0.06462714821100235,
0.5393432974815369,
-0.3219623267650604,
-0.09851136058568954,
0.0605599507689476,
-0.22775384783744812,
0.3590046763420105,
-0.641463577747345,
0.5868614315986633,
0.404087096452713,
-0.1768186092376709,
-0.04516662657260895,
-0.6278297305107117,
-0.4691537916660309,
-0.23903624713420868,
-0.5542027354240417,
-0.5900953412055969,
-0.39145591855049133,
-0.1822052150964737,
0.7156594395637512,
0.34203144907951355,
-0.45413830876350403,
0.5067997574806213,
-0.03597337752580643,
0.23353034257888794,
0.5035231113433838,
0.12276742607355118,
0.7312577366828918,
-0.3194768726825714,
0.580956220626831,
0.0927525982260704,
0.11392515897750854,
0.1271069049835205,
-0.581004798412323,
-0.8777515888214111,
-0.5844637751579285,
0.5492243766784668,
0.4762513339519501,
-0.944259762763977,
-0.0897795781493187,
-0.3534405529499054,
0.014165693894028664,
-0.8844804763793945,
0.285038024187088,
0.3671377897262573,
0.44294607639312744,
0.568199872970581,
-0.24470025300979614,
-0.31265684962272644,
-1.2816007137298584,
-0.2191970944404602,
0.06786699593067169,
0.08754219114780426,
-0.18260742723941803,
-0.0517776720225811,
-0.3472946286201477,
0.40715140104293823,
0.010727262124419212,
-0.6173316240310669,
-0.22048161923885345,
-0.1561833769083023,
0.302863210439682,
0.5477097630500793,
0.7637635469436646,
-0.8376728892326355,
-1.065543293952942,
0.5600942373275757,
-0.529961884021759,
-0.07046648114919662,
-0.5695667266845703,
-0.426665335893631,
0.08864989131689072,
0.446214497089386,
-0.5404770970344543,
0.09875273704528809,
0.9372125267982483,
-0.1940469890832901,
0.2610233426094055,
-0.3729676604270935,
0.562997579574585,
-1.1660265922546387,
0.13687878847122192,
-0.23629102110862732,
-0.2289244830608368,
-0.7860754132270813,
0.023980101570487022,
0.07742880284786224,
0.1390819251537323,
-0.37024566531181335,
0.3979613780975342,
-0.6214012503623962,
-0.1760023981332779,
-0.20413419604301453,
0.1702405959367752,
-0.004942407365888357,
0.4439326524734497,
-0.27560845017433167,
0.7054290771484375,
0.4921748638153076,
-0.632014274597168,
0.07132861763238907,
-0.0007709095370955765,
0.3823705017566681,
0.6212413311004639,
-0.32398054003715515,
0.04085309058427811,
0.06261356174945831,
0.028121404349803925,
-0.8880506157875061,
0.08531952649354935,
0.18651063740253448,
-0.5960670113563538,
0.8048526048660278,
-0.3704131245613098,
-0.6252580285072327,
0.004389866255223751,
-0.11945840716362,
0.4269103705883026,
0.536943256855011,
-0.14845608174800873,
0.3694436252117157,
0.05696212500333786,
-0.09541285783052444,
-0.32021334767341614,
-1.037793755531311,
0.17318810522556305,
-0.3819977045059204,
-0.5863558650016785,
0.1385328322649002,
-0.0058012730441987514,
-0.21722015738487244,
-0.1264687031507492,
-0.04457726702094078,
-0.15940184891223907,
0.18144673109054565,
0.12179312855005264,
0.08153902739286423,
-0.25600576400756836,
0.318430095911026,
0.34964480996131897,
-0.36737099289894104,
-0.14293572306632996,
-0.4208918511867523,
0.24279974400997162,
0.149352565407753,
-0.42293378710746765,
-0.4790320098400116,
0.49399393796920776,
0.6669426560401917,
-0.6916008591651917,
1.1324856281280518,
1.004400372505188,
-0.1808485984802246,
0.38324105739593506,
-0.7253202199935913,
-0.26644080877304077,
-0.37092113494873047,
0.3740459084510803,
-1.0201997756958008,
-0.7504563927650452,
0.4847334325313568,
0.29349207878112793,
0.13952098786830902,
0.7875882387161255,
0.42476367950439453,
0.2872936725616455,
1.177554965019226,
0.8625373244285583,
-0.39774131774902344,
0.5512590408325195,
-0.11985615640878677,
0.12824319303035736,
-0.7675415873527527,
0.09530296176671982,
-0.48908400535583496,
-0.4568602740764618,
-0.6583569049835205,
-0.554479718208313,
0.18864279985427856,
0.36901354789733887,
0.04797631874680519,
0.7143572568893433,
-0.22807444632053375,
0.13911937177181244,
0.727985680103302,
-0.2607605755329132,
0.6450687050819397,
0.19342628121376038,
-0.15573906898498535,
-0.28932467103004456,
-0.7411877512931824,
-0.30388954281806946,
0.9597898721694946,
0.4670092761516571,
0.4689384698867798,
0.42644003033638,
0.9077162742614746,
-0.02956715039908886,
0.3214356601238251,
-0.6136785745620728,
0.14019007980823517,
-0.40327030420303345,
-0.35161468386650085,
-0.21834343671798706,
-0.7026785612106323,
-1.0269322395324707,
0.4280628263950348,
-0.0914631187915802,
-0.3367941081523895,
0.05901329964399338,
-0.16590769588947296,
-0.01338123343884945,
0.21855701506137848,
-1.0661888122558594,
0.8115482926368713,
-0.2623007595539093,
-0.46947264671325684,
-0.3777562081813812,
-0.8244971036911011,
0.04380830004811287,
-0.2840043604373932,
0.482138454914093,
0.10971589386463165,
-0.126311793923378,
0.7238219976425171,
0.2743399143218994,
0.45250964164733887,
-0.025579331442713737,
-0.2467254251241684,
-0.034490931779146194,
0.5126807689666748,
0.4693634808063507,
-0.10899423807859421,
-0.21866856515407562,
0.3163525462150574,
-0.09613421559333801,
-0.6294289827346802,
-0.6191698312759399,
0.9025615453720093,
-0.7618376612663269,
-0.7637898921966553,
-0.06865351647138596,
-0.8469584584236145,
-0.1294013112783432,
0.6102745532989502,
0.25365278124809265,
0.030138075351715088,
0.26980483531951904,
0.18087494373321533,
0.4832982122898102,
-0.05856596678495407,
0.15169459581375122,
0.7188611626625061,
-0.3073253333568573,
-0.03308742120862007,
1.2134016752243042,
0.2967432737350464,
0.8169466257095337,
0.803849995136261,
0.12699419260025024,
-0.14117485284805298,
-0.530063807964325,
-0.7376853227615356,
0.5331286191940308,
-0.5121901631355286,
0.03495629131793976,
-0.7325320839881897,
0.09782909601926804,
-0.5979647636413574,
-0.2382413148880005,
-0.47871702909469604,
-0.6663213968276978,
-0.11421472579240799,
-0.12873278558254242,
0.1644711047410965,
0.7156543135643005,
-0.4839093089103699,
-0.04334423691034317,
-1.0145984888076782,
0.12199851125478745,
0.18394459784030914,
0.011573282070457935,
-0.2825431227684021,
-0.7020133137702942,
-0.5555235743522644,
0.21311672031879425,
-0.18382573127746582,
-0.8990763425827026,
0.22462408244609833,
0.1488291621208191,
0.7991654276847839,
0.4654048979282379,
-0.06830266863107681,
0.5244008898735046,
-0.47242075204849243,
0.3847317099571228,
0.3401711881160736,
-0.5768862366676331,
0.062304090708494186,
-0.3555653393268585,
0.3286483585834503,
0.5125359296798706,
0.5356522798538208,
-0.7632977962493896,
-0.5836926102638245,
-0.23867911100387573,
-0.3546285927295685,
0.5336509943008423,
0.39254117012023926,
-0.12129480391740799,
0.1835186630487442,
0.02388070710003376,
0.23110118508338928,
0.11342700570821762,
-0.6906445622444153,
-0.2608872056007385,
0.05988948419690132,
-0.10316627472639084,
-0.5123749375343323,
0.06051957979798317,
0.013531937263906002,
-0.03402107581496239,
0.42071035504341125,
-0.018236728385090828,
0.3270512819290161,
0.14601722359657288,
-0.19683082401752472,
-0.3214605152606964,
0.40103158354759216,
0.7801137566566467,
0.25973397493362427,
-0.04301416501402855,
0.4154506325721741,
0.2967051863670349,
-0.13744136691093445,
0.10423298925161362,
0.4065159857273102,
0.04815376177430153,
-0.2190827578306198,
0.5696922540664673,
0.5563113689422607,
0.1355152577161789,
-0.008886311203241348,
0.23812593519687653,
0.15500345826148987,
-0.06482905894517899,
0.49726244807243347,
-0.3912522792816162,
0.09883570671081543,
0.21845225989818573,
0.28490006923675537,
0.4584628641605377,
0.23055605590343475,
-0.6729676723480225,
0.17409202456474304,
0.2860593795776367,
-0.6965627074241638,
-0.7492385506629944,
0.5472880601882935,
0.13599951565265656,
-0.12949861586093903,
0.4140866994857788,
-0.22645685076713562,
-0.9352006912231445,
0.5988026261329651,
0.5414188504219055,
0.4936104714870453,
-0.39933425188064575,
-0.030784524977207184,
0.44228315353393555,
0.7147396802902222,
0.19596371054649353,
-0.30906450748443604,
-0.10460849106311798,
-0.33538103103637695,
-0.6461564898490906,
-0.4238450825214386,
0.07841264456510544,
-0.3112330734729767,
-0.6136133074760437,
0.20676890015602112,
0.2463136464357376,
0.04542913660407066,
-0.25818902254104614,
-0.04161448776721954,
-0.8992289900779724,
-0.21848608553409576,
0.17622680962085724,
0.38801324367523193,
-0.7147371768951416,
1.0750832557678223,
0.5826214551925659,
-0.664326548576355,
-0.5909678936004639,
-0.16415776312351227,
-0.10735706984996796,
-0.5494634509086609,
0.7874268889427185,
0.17964743077754974,
0.06422849744558334,
0.10862787812948227,
0.188137486577034,
-0.9866845607757568,
0.7710888981819153,
0.47967803478240967,
-0.7028433680534363,
-0.12241562455892563,
0.45586833357810974,
0.7033267021179199,
-0.19859008491039276,
-0.05941632017493248,
0.3812183439731598,
0.6377028226852417,
-0.1960870772600174,
-1.3856993913650513,
0.36906424164772034,
0.28297293186187744,
-0.21292002499103546,
0.5989723205566406,
-0.9415265321731567,
0.8874378204345703,
-0.24892255663871765,
-0.35831940174102783,
-0.19122949242591858,
0.25639989972114563,
-0.3788008987903595,
0.00856911949813366,
0.17129626870155334,
0.26067760586738586,
0.09247389435768127,
0.3192761540412903,
1.177187442779541,
-0.42925044894218445,
0.20793479681015015,
0.8658164739608765,
0.09953700751066208,
0.7705528736114502,
0.9144266247749329,
-0.2260456532239914,
0.07025137543678284,
0.32437166571617126,
0.18831822276115417,
0.5640631914138794,
0.11819395422935486,
-0.019738275557756424,
-0.1518520712852478,
-0.022834310308098793,
-0.6680603623390198,
0.12093763053417206,
0.2951035797595978,
-0.5249775648117065,
-0.3148534595966339,
0.33828017115592957,
0.12944495677947998,
0.09108609706163406,
-0.046394020318984985,
0.7372498512268066,
0.2956126630306244,
-0.852579653263092,
0.6681302785873413,
0.03125689551234245,
0.6425434947013855,
-0.572879433631897,
-0.18382491171360016,
-0.29225319623947144,
0.3539502024650574,
-0.13447205722332,
-0.45940306782722473,
0.5067897439002991,
-0.41641169786453247,
-0.3263886272907257,
-0.41662341356277466,
0.6893734335899353,
-0.7731653451919556,
-0.41529256105422974,
0.5928698182106018,
0.7256166338920593,
0.2569569945335388,
-0.3279600143432617,
-0.6363911628723145,
-0.05564909428358078,
0.47930407524108887,
0.05782713368535042,
0.7328157424926758,
0.5945116281509399,
-0.19933682680130005,
0.4329098165035248,
0.7910888195037842,
0.2830139398574829,
0.47423261404037476,
-0.04904612898826599,
0.6750605702400208,
-0.30391791462898254,
-0.20435164868831635,
-0.6889746785163879,
0.391745001077652,
0.22522173821926117,
-0.2060340791940689,
1.381635069847107,
0.5975185632705688,
0.8237432241439819,
-0.1552129089832306,
0.4530484080314636,
0.06349422037601471,
0.29926568269729614,
-0.4249647259712219,
0.7253693342208862,
-0.44932523369789124,
0.13258413970470428,
-0.037744250148534775,
-1.1866986751556396,
-0.3978499174118042,
0.3435966968536377,
-0.391070157289505,
-0.24946774542331696,
0.6652163863182068,
0.5010892748832703,
-0.16840077936649323,
-0.6447247862815857,
0.7387707233428955,
0.24021367728710175,
0.4423035681247711,
0.7063656449317932,
0.5170118808746338,
-0.6072654724121094,
0.8553916811943054,
-0.3935365378856659,
-0.4435863196849823,
-0.15300288796424866,
-0.5031115412712097,
-1.0005886554718018,
-0.6451606750488281,
-0.2928606867790222,
-0.0915774405002594,
0.09914957731962204,
0.6553385257720947,
0.6799428462982178,
-0.7101436257362366,
-0.2998393774032593,
0.13700439035892487,
0.21433153748512268,
-0.3654925525188446,
-0.21685561537742615,
0.2925874590873718,
-0.5179187059402466,
-0.6934028267860413,
0.399290531873703,
0.2490583062171936,
0.1525993049144745,
-0.1703932136297226,
-0.15914681553840637,
-0.46823975443840027,
-0.14184387028217316,
0.7835733294487,
0.21230891346931458,
-0.5273581147193909,
-0.19731391966342926,
0.07445156574249268,
-0.30691155791282654,
-0.03768468275666237,
0.7340338230133057,
-0.3426438570022583,
0.46858730912208557,
0.3508029878139496,
0.771025538444519,
0.48189133405685425,
-0.11598511785268784,
0.780826985836029,
-0.7375553846359253,
0.35831451416015625,
-0.2083592414855957,
0.15685787796974182,
0.4442054033279419,
-0.40371158719062805,
0.4864538609981537,
0.1637464463710785,
-0.44579795002937317,
-0.5608978867530823,
0.27930617332458496,
-0.7131943106651306,
-0.06724224984645844,
1.4350744485855103,
-0.17083130776882172,
0.053080543875694275,
-0.12914294004440308,
-0.40406179428100586,
0.607517421245575,
-0.36066195368766785,
0.3679075241088867,
0.7950444221496582,
0.047977905720472336,
-0.02478187344968319,
-0.7755308747291565,
0.4737304747104645,
0.4881499707698822,
-0.5949150919914246,
-0.40169399976730347,
0.24003192782402039,
0.23967154324054718,
0.41566309332847595,
0.2607211172580719,
0.006681941915303469,
0.0982612818479538,
0.039511386305093765,
-0.20588016510009766,
0.027523264288902283,
-0.26236867904663086,
-0.3517831861972809,
-0.2992079257965088,
0.24125516414642334,
-0.42699646949768066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00474v1 | SA-MDKIF: A Scalable and Adaptable Medical Domain Knowledge Injection Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T10:26:27 | 2024-02-01T10:26:27 | Tianhan Xu, Zhe Hu, Ling Chen, Bin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional
performance in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their
effective application in the medical domain is hampered by a lack of medical
domain knowledge. In this study, we present SA-MDKIF, a scalable and adaptable
framework that aims to inject medical knowledge into general-purpose LLMs
through instruction tuning, thereby enabling adaptability for various
downstream tasks. SA-MDKIF consists of two stages: skill training and skill
adaptation. In the first stage, we define 12 basic medical skills and use
AdaLoRA to train these skills based on uniformly formatted instructional
datasets that we have constructed. In the next stage, we train the skill router
using task-specific downstream data and use this router to integrate the
acquired skills with LLMs during inference. Experimental results on 9 different
medical tasks show that SA-MDKIF improves performance by 10-20% compared to the
original LLMs. Notably, this improvement is particularly pronounced for unseen
medical tasks, showing an improvement of up to 30%. | [
-0.20769114792346954,
-0.8324310779571533,
0.7628823518753052,
0.07536498457193375,
-0.29189568758010864,
-0.11660528182983398,
-0.19708400964736938,
-0.34562134742736816,
0.1813112497329712,
0.607112467288971,
-0.42688316106796265,
-0.5813745856285095,
-0.8489134311676025,
0.0006730405730195343,
-0.16995052993297577,
0.8555470108985901,
0.0632530003786087,
0.5160113573074341,
-0.3698667883872986,
-0.24693860113620758,
-0.33954980969429016,
-0.5844599008560181,
-0.8908000588417053,
-0.4813229739665985,
0.5813204050064087,
0.4777981638908386,
0.5169098973274231,
0.9996729493141174,
0.42866820096969604,
0.195506289601326,
0.14179009199142456,
0.37145814299583435,
-0.030742326751351357,
0.17744241654872894,
-0.44217634201049805,
-0.5393029451370239,
-0.5036050081253052,
-0.4028944671154022,
0.6220589876174927,
0.9239590764045715,
-0.4442819654941559,
-0.07883487641811371,
-0.14788798987865448,
1.060941457748413,
-0.5230822563171387,
0.15244348347187042,
-0.6767857670783997,
-0.09789756685495377,
-0.05816922336816788,
-0.2036726325750351,
-0.15694913268089294,
0.0009070795495063066,
0.09221357852220535,
-0.5664179921150208,
0.11014897376298904,
-0.23231446743011475,
0.64249187707901,
0.48402640223503113,
-0.7421227097511292,
-0.5890255570411682,
-0.4264100193977356,
0.33956682682037354,
-0.9517749547958374,
0.3758012652397156,
0.5487591624259949,
0.46052294969558716,
-0.3137485086917877,
-0.7666207551956177,
-0.5576678514480591,
-0.043929096311330795,
0.09984876215457916,
-0.21009059250354767,
0.46263009309768677,
0.4652288258075714,
-0.04216781258583069,
0.3709444999694824,
-0.5175434947013855,
0.39667659997940063,
-0.14646558463573456,
0.27468401193618774,
0.48359671235084534,
0.31075647473335266,
0.47963258624076843,
-0.04570656269788742,
-0.05504944548010826,
0.18483899533748627,
-0.8520127534866333,
-0.330750972032547,
-0.14809946715831757,
0.3881196677684784,
-0.2885819375514984,
0.5453243851661682,
-0.14374956488609314,
1.1511832475662231,
0.07307060807943344,
-0.7454151511192322,
0.2149561196565628,
-0.016293788328766823,
-0.6036195755004883,
-0.002587891649454832,
0.5253574252128601,
0.08387473970651627,
0.13128218054771423,
-0.009296518750488758,
0.1918935626745224,
-0.16673333942890167,
0.45974159240722656,
-0.8377425074577332,
-0.21321727335453033,
0.3292120695114136,
-0.3277822732925415,
-0.6263793706893921,
-0.31009864807128906,
-0.6807233691215515,
-0.7900332808494568,
-0.20564940571784973,
0.3367156684398651,
-0.48994389176368713,
-0.13659189641475677,
0.1676456332206726,
0.10532760620117188,
0.14834877848625183,
0.14590272307395935,
-1.162795066833496,
0.31336504220962524,
0.5256367921829224,
0.85916668176651,
-0.5066074132919312,
-0.20290620625019073,
-0.5543252825737,
0.44773632287979126,
-0.35314369201660156,
0.7310547232627869,
-0.596924364566803,
-0.3566879332065582,
0.11434329301118851,
-0.014206056483089924,
-0.39996033906936646,
-0.7756898999214172,
0.44028839468955994,
-0.570612907409668,
-0.18880891799926758,
-0.11358879506587982,
-0.6643068194389343,
-0.0616275891661644,
0.11857543140649796,
-0.43824782967567444,
0.7959489822387695,
0.4041110873222351,
-0.5062170624732971,
0.4270791709423065,
-0.985863983631134,
-1.0466344356536865,
0.11592746526002884,
-0.31050142645835876,
-0.16024945676326752,
-0.04838502034544945,
0.40679097175598145,
0.6537133455276489,
-0.44238415360450745,
0.30706140398979187,
-0.24057713150978088,
-0.2757163643836975,
0.22510451078414917,
-0.2982645332813263,
0.5550122857093811,
0.06368286162614822,
-0.2418718785047531,
0.07197476178407669,
-1.1599141359329224,
-0.020651262253522873,
0.010526925325393677,
-0.672602653503418,
-0.3325151205062866,
-0.16076673567295074,
0.012653655372560024,
0.3068799674510956,
-0.1961667686700821,
-0.16741690039634705,
0.29473328590393066,
-0.7469883561134338,
0.47859498858451843,
0.6382495164871216,
0.44678252935409546,
0.4517257809638977,
-0.22645264863967896,
0.649235188961029,
0.2897751033306122,
0.017519893124699593,
0.03678150847554207,
-0.5822020173072815,
-0.7488322854042053,
-0.6939176321029663,
0.2465677112340927,
0.5094633102416992,
-1.1593711376190186,
0.426652193069458,
-0.17280128598213196,
-0.46815332770347595,
-0.7123714685440063,
0.3574230670928955,
0.2442946434020996,
0.816969096660614,
0.40410053730010986,
0.10152844339609146,
-0.5398274660110474,
-0.7668534517288208,
-0.133609339594841,
0.030326412990689278,
-0.18028336763381958,
0.540633499622345,
0.29029080271720886,
-0.48711881041526794,
0.39689064025878906,
-0.687034547328949,
-0.5008236169815063,
-0.09136158972978592,
-0.19713351130485535,
0.287380576133728,
0.5321667790412903,
0.462937593460083,
-0.7651578187942505,
-0.5546436905860901,
0.20175650715827942,
-0.7224434018135071,
-0.08722080290317535,
-0.18428796529769897,
-0.15904860198497772,
0.2683885395526886,
0.3195083737373352,
-0.6343294382095337,
0.18268747627735138,
0.8188431859016418,
-0.5098483562469482,
0.5258123278617859,
-0.4951138496398926,
0.3673650920391083,
-1.290578842163086,
0.2229306548833847,
-0.2509444057941437,
-0.33317890763282776,
-0.7813959717750549,
0.15493355691432953,
0.2035876363515854,
-0.06542152911424637,
-0.3214506208896637,
0.5998131632804871,
-0.29723137617111206,
0.030009925365447998,
-0.47073987126350403,
-0.006927968468517065,
-0.024192512035369873,
0.4195548892021179,
-0.04030989110469818,
0.9340812563896179,
0.716058075428009,
-0.9158396124839783,
0.23254403471946716,
0.23232461512088776,
-0.415232390165329,
0.9375485181808472,
-0.483295738697052,
0.1819242238998413,
0.09009035676717758,
-0.10356258600950241,
-0.6803505420684814,
-0.460660457611084,
0.22295790910720825,
-0.2493746280670166,
0.4931541085243225,
-0.5055128335952759,
-0.34157484769821167,
-0.20785705745220184,
0.30422353744506836,
0.030975205823779106,
0.49061256647109985,
-0.7180070281028748,
0.8854655623435974,
0.4876149594783783,
-0.3214471638202667,
-0.5385270714759827,
-0.7010006308555603,
0.198350191116333,
-0.01213813666254282,
-0.36611708998680115,
0.30833014845848083,
-0.0210102591663599,
0.09982268512248993,
-0.13466402888298035,
-0.07411794364452362,
-0.4795028269290924,
0.022041957825422287,
0.4469899535179138,
0.27716732025146484,
-0.30612456798553467,
0.3824028968811035,
0.7256446480751038,
0.010670380666851997,
-0.07903473824262619,
-0.3526870310306549,
0.40184372663497925,
0.2973925471305847,
-0.6612517833709717,
-0.22075356543064117,
0.3327830135822296,
0.9447633028030396,
-0.14406158030033112,
1.2808810472488403,
0.3113292157649994,
-0.5080966353416443,
-0.24037988483905792,
-0.6064094305038452,
0.06888033449649811,
-0.4773517847061157,
0.5987176895141602,
-0.40864062309265137,
-0.7711322903633118,
0.06913752108812332,
-0.2934214174747467,
-0.05603604391217232,
0.467117041349411,
0.7010645866394043,
-0.2644200026988983,
1.007087230682373,
0.5788765549659729,
0.10760360211133957,
0.1982216238975525,
-0.1620764434337616,
-0.17180386185646057,
-0.8354572057723999,
-0.30314797163009644,
-0.304332435131073,
-0.10369834303855896,
0.08391815423965454,
-0.7527317404747009,
0.4564085006713867,
0.0992426872253418,
-0.2254643440246582,
-0.12476200610399246,
-0.21132521331310272,
0.3146854639053345,
0.1339309960603714,
0.36075839400291443,
0.3480955958366394,
-0.056011609733104706,
-0.28500208258628845,
0.029267169535160065,
-0.8937835693359375,
-0.2509092688560486,
1.3108185529708862,
0.13215522468090057,
0.603891134262085,
-0.059327442198991776,
0.40693846344947815,
0.22394539415836334,
0.5612735152244568,
-0.8598775863647461,
0.2803998589515686,
-0.4703473448753357,
-0.4051794409751892,
-0.15538038313388824,
-0.44615375995635986,
-0.594935953617096,
0.14019663631916046,
-0.42820215225219727,
-0.28754833340644836,
0.16506141424179077,
0.31384676694869995,
-0.14717282354831696,
0.453421413898468,
-0.8446702361106873,
0.660475492477417,
-0.12330932170152664,
0.10321564972400665,
-0.39590325951576233,
-0.437004953622818,
0.33387693762779236,
-0.4549403190612793,
0.2849210798740387,
-0.00023557945678476244,
-0.395229697227478,
0.5640741586685181,
-0.4512336552143097,
0.7480764985084534,
-0.4163162410259247,
-0.10374749451875687,
-0.20493842661380768,
-0.1930677741765976,
0.38725292682647705,
0.11842440813779831,
-0.16361655294895172,
0.10761576145887375,
0.254876971244812,
-0.41388601064682007,
-0.8750399351119995,
1.052590012550354,
-0.6156046986579895,
-0.5768909454345703,
-0.2958930730819702,
-0.7663335204124451,
-0.7508569359779358,
0.25851669907569885,
-0.0031030650716274977,
0.38638174533843994,
-0.24139975011348724,
0.1588907539844513,
0.8580484986305237,
-0.2422783523797989,
-0.027735305950045586,
0.6075267791748047,
-0.10070201754570007,
-0.5343000888824463,
0.6541382074356079,
-0.010454127565026283,
0.5193663239479065,
0.32344353199005127,
0.03725153207778931,
-0.13229727745056152,
-0.7114076018333435,
-0.9237880706787109,
0.39860495924949646,
-0.8423627018928528,
-0.32939720153808594,
-0.7989500761032104,
-0.280346542596817,
-0.4117766320705414,
-0.2163870930671692,
-0.30011966824531555,
-0.3913247585296631,
-0.4321511387825012,
0.02110685221850872,
0.5097054243087769,
0.8665157556533813,
0.16631731390953064,
0.19840949773788452,
-0.7555614113807678,
0.7154363989830017,
0.1752002239227295,
0.8053426146507263,
0.011496731080114841,
-0.6821088790893555,
-0.5050548911094666,
0.14184941351413727,
0.24287688732147217,
-0.8567275404930115,
0.10557252168655396,
0.527374804019928,
0.5808928608894348,
0.5290747284889221,
-0.13153067231178284,
0.8143087029457092,
-0.7610598802566528,
0.5734971165657043,
0.21744564175605774,
-0.5113751888275146,
0.4461430013179779,
-0.03163320571184158,
0.5276922583580017,
0.5141642093658447,
0.5435912013053894,
-0.5258753299713135,
-0.19210314750671387,
-0.16452747583389282,
-0.5146864652633667,
0.34672173857688904,
-0.2477840930223465,
-0.012437970377504826,
-0.006809778045862913,
0.8278152942657471,
0.11850550770759583,
0.09206841886043549,
0.02219417318701744,
-0.500449538230896,
0.12043152004480362,
-0.630133330821991,
-0.17822973430156708,
-0.3487449884414673,
-0.35265854001045227,
-0.40973296761512756,
0.7995810508728027,
-0.40005746483802795,
0.09700942039489746,
0.23710377514362335,
-0.3168998062610626,
0.03132728114724159,
0.09888787567615509,
0.4951946437358856,
0.7363675236701965,
0.22670641541481018,
0.005213834811002016,
0.3712310791015625,
-0.9993915557861328,
0.36596179008483887,
0.07781822979450226,
-0.08461397141218185,
-0.16287794709205627,
0.3203568458557129,
0.56526780128479,
0.35639646649360657,
-0.951988697052002,
0.3120196759700775,
0.049210403114557266,
-0.2360163778066635,
0.021599899977445602,
0.3744167387485504,
0.6272643804550171,
0.17354914546012878,
0.3095009922981262,
0.11309514939785004,
0.1429562121629715,
-0.2618959844112396,
0.18788698315620422,
0.16936282813549042,
-0.35601726174354553,
0.13993403315544128,
0.5340868830680847,
0.07163838297128677,
-0.3651881217956543,
0.30407050251960754,
0.22763203084468842,
-0.12334077060222626,
0.37356677651405334,
0.7774518132209778,
0.4826100468635559,
-0.37077993154525757,
0.09834271669387817,
0.21653802692890167,
-0.02077840268611908,
0.10939239710569382,
0.3441704213619232,
0.1197165697813034,
-0.5086955428123474,
-0.5144761800765991,
-0.766271710395813,
-0.19034738838672638,
0.052049990743398666,
-0.6846803426742554,
0.00841949600726366,
-0.6113442182540894,
-0.10437500476837158,
0.18059572577476501,
-0.22402696311473846,
-0.7460017204284668,
0.4749962389469147,
-0.3080955147743225,
1.0939418077468872,
-0.7827922105789185,
1.3046770095825195,
0.8827171921730042,
-0.2993050813674927,
-0.5609820485115051,
-0.0041695949621498585,
0.018359409645199776,
-0.8905284404754639,
0.4756810665130615,
-0.2767443358898163,
-0.059147268533706665,
0.09070027619600296,
-0.27162981033325195,
-0.7086820602416992,
1.1519265174865723,
0.48846834897994995,
-0.371589720249176,
-0.1668139100074768,
0.16869880259037018,
0.6653388142585754,
-0.6396123766899109,
-0.4443221092224121,
0.6558793783187866,
0.162799671292305,
0.19620159268379211,
-0.6764418482780457,
0.14905871450901031,
-0.174192413687706,
0.14478512108325958,
-0.021824508905410767,
-0.06920734792947769,
0.15620476007461548,
-0.47217756509780884,
0.05737851560115814,
0.16889715194702148,
0.4233776926994324,
0.3454352021217346,
-0.03185504674911499,
0.5719424486160278,
0.4169256091117859,
0.8956906795501709,
0.21108782291412354,
0.9849429726600647,
-0.38776353001594543,
-0.22554728388786316,
1.1496425867080688,
-0.21963238716125488,
0.9692396521568298,
0.7154642939567566,
-0.27544495463371277,
0.6475859880447388,
0.2316865175962448,
0.2529575228691101,
0.5872915387153625,
0.08840017765760422,
-0.5230140686035156,
-0.057054635137319565,
0.054904498159885406,
-0.4956429600715637,
0.3345387279987335,
0.7415697574615479,
-0.6177945137023926,
0.21284087002277374,
0.4670954942703247,
0.07158771902322769,
0.04627646505832672,
-0.3272154629230499,
0.9322112798690796,
0.16720500588417053,
-0.622678816318512,
0.6416465640068054,
0.1599915772676468,
0.5847123861312866,
-0.9589068293571472,
-0.3179958164691925,
-0.1067260131239891,
0.2674920856952667,
-0.2530081868171692,
-0.617767870426178,
0.29697832465171814,
-0.06154799461364746,
-0.3907824754714966,
0.20115290582180023,
0.954826831817627,
-0.49836426973342896,
-0.47931838035583496,
0.14259928464889526,
0.32827314734458923,
-0.012507106177508831,
-0.01877831295132637,
-0.6500552296638489,
-0.08964534103870392,
-0.14384378492832184,
-0.04858187213540077,
0.6882532238960266,
0.21778663992881775,
0.4031383991241455,
0.9854642748832703,
0.8999208807945251,
0.5660083889961243,
-0.008556462824344635,
0.24212834239006042,
0.9697693586349487,
-0.4127390384674072,
-0.41748446226119995,
-0.5462473630905151,
0.31733933091163635,
-0.07643837481737137,
-0.19249983131885529,
0.3793869912624359,
0.3114463984966278,
0.27869555354118347,
-0.23387472331523895,
0.7456238269805908,
-0.06693018972873688,
0.5596096515655518,
-0.6380950212478638,
1.2808403968811035,
-0.5265697240829468,
0.14111052453517914,
-0.037496935576200485,
-0.3671105206012726,
-0.39502906799316406,
0.499339759349823,
0.02706790529191494,
0.15372949838638306,
0.6814815402030945,
0.7588886022567749,
0.04769855737686157,
-0.12807497382164001,
0.6137598156929016,
0.3302527964115143,
0.29570242762565613,
0.502138078212738,
0.031742360442876816,
-0.27977481484413147,
0.4125428795814514,
-0.2724626064300537,
-0.3839189410209656,
-0.12147793918848038,
-0.6796118021011353,
-1.072786808013916,
-0.700873076915741,
-0.1325157731771469,
-0.3527066707611084,
0.373779296875,
0.8448994755744934,
0.9819539785385132,
-1.031498670578003,
0.036798879504203796,
0.06059059873223305,
-0.004322963301092386,
-0.5531166791915894,
-0.1849493533372879,
0.5374954342842102,
-0.34399300813674927,
-0.4001728594303131,
0.6959070563316345,
0.4415200650691986,
-0.0173750352114439,
-0.31494641304016113,
-0.23980972170829773,
-0.6538830399513245,
0.1196332797408104,
0.6835353374481201,
0.24327252805233002,
-0.5571261644363403,
-0.18388381600379944,
-0.08685342967510223,
-0.27981576323509216,
0.030342597514390945,
0.8286502957344055,
-0.6361627578735352,
0.5718743205070496,
0.03142824396491051,
1.12192702293396,
0.5022582411766052,
-0.28226006031036377,
0.7732675075531006,
-0.6141908168792725,
0.06390222907066345,
0.04681609570980072,
0.397507905960083,
0.37005776166915894,
-0.6601717472076416,
0.38995808362960815,
0.2598591148853302,
-0.3846917152404785,
-0.7861878275871277,
0.12374678999185562,
-0.7809631824493408,
-0.3627847135066986,
1.171836256980896,
-0.22332994639873505,
0.0366012267768383,
-0.36973488330841064,
-0.29108211398124695,
0.3493119180202484,
0.14430135488510132,
0.6738678216934204,
0.5862541794776917,
-0.11471612006425858,
-0.12960641086101532,
-0.6781444549560547,
0.6504249572753906,
0.2465110421180725,
-1.0966193675994873,
-0.09986014664173126,
0.16975650191307068,
0.7211655378341675,
-0.3663477301597595,
0.8930307626724243,
-0.35097870230674744,
0.4009900391101837,
-0.017832817509770393,
-0.22029660642147064,
-0.33888667821884155,
-0.32400766015052795,
-0.5107624530792236,
0.07034268975257874,
0.32830023765563965,
0.03369230777025223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00453v2 | Instruction Makes a Difference | 2024-02-01T09:43:30 | 2024-06-13T13:28:37 | Tosin Adewumi, Nudrat Habib, Lama Alkhaled, Elisa Barney | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce Instruction Document Visual Question Answering (iDocVQA) dataset
and Large Language Document (LLaDoc) model, for training Language-Vision (LV)
models for document analysis and predictions on document images, respectively.
Usually, deep neural networks for the DocVQA task are trained on datasets
lacking instructions. We show that using instruction-following datasets
improves performance. We compare performance across document-related datasets
using the recent state-of-the-art (SotA) Large Language and Vision Assistant
(LLaVA)1.5 as the base model. We also evaluate the performance of the derived
models for object hallucination using the Polling-based Object Probing
Evaluation (POPE) dataset. The results show that instruction-tuning performance
ranges from 11X to 32X of zero-shot performance and from 0.1% to 4.2% over
non-instruction (traditional task) finetuning. Despite the gains, these still
fall short of human performance (94.36%), implying there's much room for
improvement. | [
-0.07837353646755219,
-0.7465434074401855,
0.587445080280304,
-0.24609526991844177,
-0.17142769694328308,
-0.0772286206483841,
-0.2404290735721588,
-0.4139091670513153,
-0.3222479820251465,
0.6819291114807129,
-0.5781167149543762,
-0.8307090401649475,
-0.7261942028999329,
-0.023718740791082382,
-0.47399866580963135,
0.502750813961029,
0.06008270010352135,
0.42232227325439453,
-0.5724547505378723,
0.1576281487941742,
-0.6896881461143494,
-0.034205250442028046,
-0.787431001663208,
-0.18600960075855255,
0.3457646369934082,
0.6011814475059509,
0.3941355347633362,
1.0326542854309082,
0.7007758617401123,
0.3419915735721588,
0.2633047103881836,
0.4004374146461487,
-0.5161846876144409,
0.011696698144078255,
0.0444711335003376,
-0.6115932464599609,
-0.13499276340007782,
-0.033000774681568146,
0.5778625011444092,
0.6507446765899658,
0.0077022830955684185,
-0.16111858189105988,
0.07576672732830048,
0.8488579988479614,
-0.5158801078796387,
0.5144128799438477,
-0.48642849922180176,
0.10610794275999069,
0.0717739537358284,
-0.3182910084724426,
-0.48226794600486755,
-0.22209633886814117,
0.20652198791503906,
-0.7908456921577454,
0.5697197914123535,
-0.025203745812177658,
0.7290953993797302,
0.5168399214744568,
0.044995252043008804,
-0.5691537261009216,
-0.5098655819892883,
0.6575730443000793,
-0.6668455600738525,
0.6223824620246887,
0.4503333270549774,
0.057948999106884,
-0.1475091278553009,
-0.7238616347312927,
-0.4505375921726227,
-0.3332965672016144,
0.14008815586566925,
0.23497509956359863,
0.06572868674993515,
0.26356908679008484,
0.4167122542858124,
0.35537025332450867,
-0.4101429581642151,
0.43176865577697754,
-0.7242661714553833,
0.0922112911939621,
0.5404523611068726,
0.31875959038734436,
0.18159714341163635,
-0.04982453212141991,
-0.13209611177444458,
-0.531643807888031,
-0.5091355443000793,
0.23085471987724304,
0.32434821128845215,
0.013754933141171932,
0.13686610758304596,
0.47087639570236206,
-0.3552911579608917,
0.88138347864151,
0.15154290199279785,
-0.19895629584789276,
0.07845243811607361,
-0.039516959339380264,
-0.4319717288017273,
0.053159650415182114,
0.5575524568557739,
0.5635652542114258,
0.2618085443973541,
-0.3766843378543854,
-0.2060779482126236,
0.023820174857974052,
0.48939117789268494,
-0.8840874433517456,
-0.2793566882610321,
-0.029446447268128395,
-0.4426267147064209,
-0.21846774220466614,
0.13179317116737366,
-0.6735779047012329,
-0.7278157472610474,
-0.8039361238479614,
0.3548278510570526,
-0.607039213180542,
0.3919718861579895,
0.1943473517894745,
-0.16142617166042328,
0.6951777338981628,
0.7266227006912231,
-1.0372978448867798,
0.502039909362793,
0.9576636552810669,
0.6660903096199036,
-0.2767080068588257,
-0.3608986437320709,
-0.7854860424995422,
-0.33934563398361206,
-0.7849025726318359,
0.8998006582260132,
-0.7541951537132263,
-0.4006643295288086,
-0.01920742727816105,
0.2584231495857239,
-0.25444531440734863,
-0.7054222822189331,
0.3873124122619629,
-0.3814247250556946,
0.17990702390670776,
-0.2518569827079773,
-0.7747920155525208,
-0.3141789138317108,
0.07089374214410782,
-0.6368702054023743,
0.9930481314659119,
0.07115738838911057,
-0.34327831864356995,
0.3173667788505554,
-0.4562388062477112,
-0.4636893570423126,
-0.046727437525987625,
-0.5173628330230713,
-0.1470520794391632,
0.13934309780597687,
0.4315350353717804,
0.7211800217628479,
-0.28789272904396057,
-0.13734962046146393,
0.1238430067896843,
-0.97430020570755,
0.08665681630373001,
-0.49209776520729065,
0.4513710141181946,
-0.11161413788795471,
-0.5573814511299133,
-0.06744471192359924,
-0.9174128174781799,
-0.011359261348843575,
-0.09660937637090683,
-0.4579034745693207,
-0.09759023040533066,
0.1227995753288269,
-0.4005128741264343,
-0.09463874995708466,
-0.03441562131047249,
-0.4842389225959778,
0.40197551250457764,
-0.4744850695133209,
0.09334297478199005,
0.8939324021339417,
-0.08886272460222244,
0.5522756576538086,
-0.05071192979812622,
0.5471785664558411,
-0.10366318374872208,
0.12189701199531555,
-0.31451788544654846,
-0.4458478093147278,
-1.1142005920410156,
0.0810246542096138,
0.2326129823923111,
0.7288773059844971,
-0.9038518071174622,
-0.002079442609101534,
-0.19681432843208313,
-0.30580320954322815,
-0.7371995449066162,
0.24861395359039307,
0.7290849685668945,
0.8235023021697998,
0.20177283883094788,
-0.3910156488418579,
-0.3230641484260559,
-0.8714814186096191,
0.14944949746131897,
-0.06559435278177261,
-0.005887114908546209,
0.44089993834495544,
0.30906906723976135,
0.06086938455700874,
0.07455461472272873,
-0.4939640760421753,
-0.29980409145355225,
0.08320359140634537,
0.18036668002605438,
0.17098352313041687,
0.28507375717163086,
0.21937887370586395,
-0.709942638874054,
-0.37172895669937134,
0.09554623812437057,
-0.9536805152893066,
0.06816694885492325,
-0.24280016124248505,
-0.027666999027132988,
0.45714375376701355,
0.7963802218437195,
-0.3076011538505554,
0.7450980544090271,
0.2181083858013153,
-0.006147012580186129,
0.3014509081840515,
-0.43591153621673584,
0.515103816986084,
-0.7148637771606445,
-0.42497631907463074,
-0.09586671739816666,
0.06973937898874283,
-0.6799058318138123,
0.07774875313043594,
0.20787891745567322,
-0.1780688464641571,
-0.6350341439247131,
0.2575656771659851,
-0.5511149168014526,
-0.39300793409347534,
-0.3249413073062897,
0.14694377779960632,
0.3109809458255768,
0.66690993309021,
0.21938662230968475,
1.0874446630477905,
0.851622998714447,
-0.5754581093788147,
0.4379826486110687,
0.24643181264400482,
-0.6642789840698242,
0.2809367775917053,
-0.6760964393615723,
0.465305894613266,
-0.364158034324646,
-0.21755701303482056,
-0.9050953388214111,
-0.2626209855079651,
0.3348968029022217,
-0.2819211781024933,
0.7517687082290649,
0.0038708653301000595,
-0.40300285816192627,
-0.22744470834732056,
-0.4472503662109375,
-0.17469240725040436,
0.4467063546180725,
-0.5819957852363586,
0.4969640374183655,
-0.08492154628038406,
0.10250549018383026,
-0.8016592860221863,
-0.7277270555496216,
0.09875396639108658,
0.21166977286338806,
-0.5378563404083252,
0.3150211572647095,
-0.01750301942229271,
-0.21484212577342987,
-0.024889614433050156,
-0.014228513464331627,
-0.13251644372940063,
0.006261523813009262,
0.5348429083824158,
0.3743950128555298,
-0.36693689227104187,
0.5884861350059509,
-0.2325183004140854,
0.11681386828422546,
0.050423216074705124,
-0.21601171791553497,
0.3879256844520569,
-0.18353642523288727,
-0.3565884828567505,
-0.7138143181800842,
0.37478533387184143,
0.3267712891101837,
-0.32821598649024963,
0.6797724366188049,
0.3097529709339142,
-0.16560423374176025,
-0.17768804728984833,
-0.4763560891151428,
-0.20413319766521454,
-0.4902086555957794,
0.4745282828807831,
-0.39909204840660095,
-0.36810117959976196,
0.0331278070807457,
0.2733135521411896,
0.11847265064716339,
0.1738368272781372,
0.3243550658226013,
-0.5563530921936035,
0.5808098316192627,
0.5854868292808533,
0.27948930859565735,
0.6254141926765442,
-0.6729893088340759,
0.013057715259492397,
-0.8988326191902161,
-0.37105321884155273,
-0.23167186975479126,
-0.365363746881485,
-0.5213305950164795,
-0.7263922691345215,
0.1317778080701828,
-0.02913493476808071,
0.15597723424434662,
0.20160645246505737,
-0.8159849643707275,
0.6642460227012634,
0.8074666261672974,
0.3878721594810486,
0.05046515166759491,
0.19974471628665924,
0.23408032953739166,
-0.012181729078292847,
-0.7338278293609619,
-0.5695828199386597,
1.2731982469558716,
0.06435892730951309,
1.0843793153762817,
-0.4438928961753845,
0.7779433727264404,
0.3443315029144287,
-0.0901109129190445,
-1.0087324380874634,
0.6702640056610107,
-0.7397511005401611,
-0.05575020983815193,
-0.4761594235897064,
-0.13708443939685822,
-1.0254253149032593,
0.11043232679367065,
-0.15968024730682373,
-0.746451735496521,
0.46282345056533813,
-0.043094806373119354,
-0.18706096708774567,
0.19662298262119293,
-0.9647658467292786,
0.8255436420440674,
-0.4898107349872589,
-0.44022268056869507,
-0.10503847897052765,
-0.2828623652458191,
0.0002600642910692841,
0.2366216778755188,
-0.31141865253448486,
0.13257133960723877,
-0.03281290456652641,
0.7597370147705078,
-0.147640660405159,
0.8098932504653931,
-0.1526539921760559,
-0.13598178327083588,
0.3714290261268616,
-0.29849016666412354,
0.4966244101524353,
-0.27065160870552063,
-0.29710087180137634,
0.04973491653800011,
-0.17415057122707367,
-0.21927887201309204,
-1.001395583152771,
0.6849377155303955,
-0.7280793190002441,
-0.958666980266571,
-0.09198075532913208,
-0.65300452709198,
-0.0038202262949198484,
0.018530575558543205,
0.42113614082336426,
0.9162508249282837,
-0.14954757690429688,
0.5537123084068298,
1.2770721912384033,
-0.23329927027225494,
0.3856706917285919,
0.4217301905155182,
0.1993921548128128,
0.0976618230342865,
0.8633489608764648,
0.5007457137107849,
0.12379162013530731,
0.6821706891059875,
-0.041289955377578735,
-0.20467199385166168,
-0.6217207312583923,
-0.6449141502380371,
0.01890362799167633,
-1.1234290599822998,
0.030100317671895027,
-0.6644260287284851,
-0.2883864939212799,
-0.6060221791267395,
-0.08355577290058136,
-0.25612369179725647,
-0.1948208063840866,
-0.6147352457046509,
-0.10814210027456284,
0.2506018877029419,
0.7490434050559998,
0.33964625000953674,
0.19202977418899536,
-0.4915520250797272,
0.4895753562450409,
0.5552682280540466,
0.19732707738876343,
-0.01386044267565012,
-0.5878841876983643,
-0.2715393900871277,
-0.018954504281282425,
-0.23563066124916077,
-0.727479100227356,
0.03246413171291351,
0.3360229730606079,
0.5618817210197449,
0.3649916648864746,
-0.19931678473949432,
0.6597845554351807,
-0.7217687964439392,
0.5426266193389893,
-0.07082844525575638,
-0.5923767685890198,
0.6390336155891418,
0.0012642218498513103,
0.3695462644100189,
0.45525825023651123,
0.14389550685882568,
-0.36044543981552124,
-0.264423131942749,
-0.36009928584098816,
-0.44872939586639404,
0.9243152141571045,
0.0648607462644577,
0.13218927383422852,
0.18163873255252838,
0.4670371413230896,
0.17695391178131104,
0.12273222953081131,
-0.14026257395744324,
0.010809284634888172,
-0.18508051335811615,
-0.22633957862854004,
-0.057357292622327805,
-0.008907629176974297,
0.0435083843767643,
-0.30430176854133606,
0.4525993764400482,
-0.22720502316951752,
0.44491010904312134,
0.2136077731847763,
-0.07758451253175735,
0.0812261626124382,
0.13449279963970184,
0.6347493529319763,
0.7720734477043152,
-0.2220279574394226,
-0.061257753521203995,
0.16493436694145203,
-0.563942551612854,
-0.007692268118262291,
0.11128296703100204,
-0.1899101734161377,
-0.13534459471702576,
0.7608581781387329,
1.2593473196029663,
0.14669384062290192,
-0.6821507215499878,
0.47423502802848816,
-0.3112275004386902,
-0.46127164363861084,
-0.17161573469638824,
0.7768115401268005,
0.030366042628884315,
0.34924283623695374,
0.14535342156887054,
-0.11177556961774826,
0.29925912618637085,
-0.6756185293197632,
0.05964764207601547,
0.1500971019268036,
-0.38067322969436646,
0.17250719666481018,
0.44789832830429077,
0.01344030536711216,
-0.5033895969390869,
0.888349711894989,
0.03911681845784187,
-0.1735038459300995,
1.1460400819778442,
0.27192196249961853,
0.6019824147224426,
0.04762951657176018,
0.39903661608695984,
0.17300595343112946,
0.3900236487388611,
0.045757293701171875,
0.29771316051483154,
-0.28579947352409363,
-0.4492800533771515,
-0.16419729590415955,
-0.42655569314956665,
-0.32145655155181885,
0.19764107465744019,
-0.6910642981529236,
0.08447394520044327,
-0.5326166749000549,
0.3589416444301605,
0.17573027312755585,
0.2263331413269043,
-0.985872209072113,
0.5381357073783875,
0.12737713754177094,
0.834263801574707,
-0.45588207244873047,
0.9722816944122314,
0.5549362897872925,
-0.4085759222507477,
-0.7770069241523743,
0.0626489520072937,
-0.2450704127550125,
-0.922555148601532,
0.8009532690048218,
0.45951607823371887,
-0.19680087268352509,
-0.17645083367824554,
-0.5682236552238464,
-0.5272189974784851,
1.2313591241836548,
0.26858335733413696,
-0.8885056972503662,
-0.1788170337677002,
0.07283546030521393,
0.7120790481567383,
-0.5902294516563416,
0.027170326560735703,
0.5798109173774719,
0.2074100822210312,
0.10930711030960083,
-0.26800480484962463,
-0.29175373911857605,
-0.18241830170154572,
0.10577064752578735,
-0.014212535694241524,
-0.5445539951324463,
0.7591109871864319,
-0.2115507572889328,
-0.3421882390975952,
0.05116695538163185,
0.5458842515945435,
-0.19475163519382477,
0.5288165211677551,
0.32583022117614746,
0.5626095533370972,
0.9258804321289062,
-0.13188818097114563,
1.4511250257492065,
0.05259984731674194,
-0.34014081954956055,
1.449155330657959,
-0.05458221584558487,
0.8403812050819397,
0.3668059706687927,
0.035931605845689774,
0.3211071789264679,
0.5978611707687378,
-0.3485536575317383,
0.5325708985328674,
0.05524049326777458,
0.054274994879961014,
-0.15677256882190704,
-0.08469653874635696,
-0.2500443160533905,
0.7006886601448059,
0.3563467860221863,
-0.5981500148773193,
0.0923813134431839,
0.15704473853111267,
-0.3058321177959442,
0.18959303200244904,
-0.3855384886264801,
0.9122771620750427,
-0.053585074841976166,
-0.7925344705581665,
0.8306099772453308,
-0.21786190569400787,
0.23275388777256012,
-0.3472699820995331,
-0.5470910668373108,
-0.4036349654197693,
0.11770833283662796,
-0.06852572411298752,
-0.9602015614509583,
-0.06521888822317123,
0.05969221889972687,
-0.323400616645813,
-0.13325883448123932,
0.7916929125785828,
-0.2950098514556885,
-0.653898298740387,
0.134945347905159,
0.18562617897987366,
0.46906575560569763,
0.131943941116333,
-0.6812343597412109,
0.0036102712620049715,
0.013718479312956333,
-0.1137087270617485,
0.18517762422561646,
0.4449775815010071,
-0.10733337700366974,
0.5491681098937988,
0.45293354988098145,
-0.030228476971387863,
0.28451916575431824,
0.3061557114124298,
0.9412922263145447,
-0.34395235776901245,
0.0013007125817239285,
-0.5157126188278198,
0.2860266864299774,
-0.26895302534103394,
-0.3433949649333954,
0.481344610452652,
0.3958147466182709,
0.947806179523468,
-0.34559065103530884,
0.4088062047958374,
0.1903097927570343,
0.19994916021823883,
-1.0470455884933472,
0.46763524413108826,
-0.6442151069641113,
0.26922956109046936,
0.026073727756738663,
-0.8009890913963318,
-0.04845886677503586,
0.5202691555023193,
-0.5355421900749207,
-0.21968874335289001,
0.670760452747345,
1.1535074710845947,
-0.09212812036275864,
-0.1694437712430954,
0.6390221118927002,
0.0676627904176712,
0.1264825165271759,
0.6246601939201355,
0.8652951121330261,
-0.6684737205505371,
0.47887369990348816,
-0.4849577844142914,
-0.09539878368377686,
-0.21904416382312775,
-0.527730405330658,
-1.1656758785247803,
-0.47642970085144043,
-0.34275153279304504,
0.022206254303455353,
0.45371323823928833,
0.39121684432029724,
0.7155624032020569,
-0.6329106688499451,
-0.0858665332198143,
-0.17928040027618408,
0.03857988864183426,
-0.2863951623439789,
-0.17427490651607513,
0.6974747180938721,
-0.48579108715057373,
-0.9718515276908875,
0.6523708701133728,
0.39561164379119873,
-0.04308843985199928,
-0.1798626035451889,
-0.19548499584197998,
-0.19006693363189697,
0.1339314728975296,
0.42109036445617676,
0.1734934151172638,
-0.8368469476699829,
-0.09067968279123306,
0.3771864175796509,
-0.2609001398086548,
0.4658967852592468,
0.5986098647117615,
-0.6195191144943237,
0.9360407590866089,
0.479491263628006,
0.85512775182724,
0.5563936233520508,
-0.054758649319410324,
0.37688499689102173,
-0.6750734448432922,
0.2353689968585968,
0.10594252496957779,
0.2110716700553894,
0.5065401196479797,
-0.7631322741508484,
0.642159104347229,
-0.06090501695871353,
-0.5293866395950317,
-0.39137816429138184,
-0.07126084715127945,
-0.7492460608482361,
-0.407157838344574,
0.8327895998954773,
-0.31917765736579895,
-0.6557120084762573,
0.23317599296569824,
-0.4714159369468689,
0.32180535793304443,
-0.37944361567497253,
0.8166435956954956,
0.758750855922699,
-0.2703460454940796,
-0.5890390872955322,
-0.8226485252380371,
0.3776854872703552,
0.24455587565898895,
-0.9729633927345276,
-0.0702129453420639,
0.5988916158676147,
-0.018616577610373497,
0.023792650550603867,
0.553779125213623,
0.004667883738875389,
0.7472110390663147,
0.2809760570526123,
-0.04566033557057381,
-0.3381592631340027,
-0.6425237655639648,
-0.3156117796897888,
-0.016142485663294792,
-0.07476656138896942,
-0.6657568216323853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00446v1 | Improving Dialog Safety using Socially Aware Contrastive Learning | 2024-02-01T09:24:33 | 2024-02-01T09:24:33 | Souvik Das, Rohini K. Srihari | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art conversational AI systems raise concerns due to their
potential risks of generating unsafe, toxic, unethical, or dangerous content.
Previous works have developed datasets to teach conversational agents the
appropriate social paradigms to respond effectively to specifically designed
hazardous content. However, models trained on these adversarial datasets still
struggle to recognize subtle unsafe situations that appear naturally in
conversations or introduce an inappropriate response in a casual context. To
understand the extent of this problem, we study prosociality in both
adversarial and casual dialog contexts and audit the response quality of
general-purpose language models in terms of propensity to produce unsafe
content. We propose a dual-step fine-tuning process to address these issues
using a socially aware n-pair contrastive loss. Subsequently, we train a base
model that integrates prosocial behavior by leveraging datasets like Moral
Integrity Corpus (MIC) and ProsocialDialog. Experimental results on several
dialog datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in generating
socially appropriate responses. | [
-0.002874896861612797,
-0.95711350440979,
0.2430311143398285,
-0.10101818293333054,
-0.30005884170532227,
0.08352984488010406,
-0.04075394943356514,
-0.3751786947250366,
-0.14553935825824738,
0.3835873305797577,
-0.3332635760307312,
-0.29742905497550964,
-0.532802939414978,
-0.13159167766571045,
-0.10850448906421661,
1.3843859434127808,
0.5730465054512024,
0.16820673644542694,
-0.17558084428310394,
-0.4208730459213257,
-0.35157525539398193,
-0.5332876443862915,
-1.3178633451461792,
-0.11567188799381256,
0.5199228525161743,
0.39695531129837036,
1.0537874698638916,
0.2893702983856201,
0.37371641397476196,
0.36505115032196045,
-0.19751043617725372,
0.3199481666088104,
-0.927546501159668,
0.09991900622844696,
-0.20891739428043365,
-0.27460581064224243,
-0.4269111156463623,
0.04157239571213722,
0.26905548572540283,
0.5242940187454224,
-0.05727563425898552,
-0.09643589705228806,
0.5013585090637207,
0.5729343891143799,
-0.4536026418209076,
0.2347629964351654,
-0.5377047061920166,
-0.04876488074660301,
0.2838796079158783,
-0.40710511803627014,
-0.39306560158729553,
-0.7333387136459351,
0.4309805631637573,
-0.600337028503418,
0.13700348138809204,
-0.15478311479091644,
0.5079575181007385,
0.22542418539524078,
-0.5457634925842285,
-0.4120560884475708,
-0.5427336096763611,
0.5282258987426758,
-0.5300353765487671,
0.033596862107515335,
0.6193750500679016,
0.13571026921272278,
-0.0515255443751812,
-0.27950266003608704,
-0.37532544136047363,
-0.22990782558918,
-0.14280149340629578,
0.036995526403188705,
-0.06344950199127197,
0.28813764452934265,
-0.22706812620162964,
-0.09743750095367432,
-0.3307608664035797,
0.02490071952342987,
-0.31873926520347595,
-0.3048165440559387,
0.7787069082260132,
0.46338921785354614,
0.19339235126972198,
0.03798118978738785,
-0.06885473430156708,
-0.36825937032699585,
-0.5630161762237549,
0.18119263648986816,
0.5294038653373718,
0.393185555934906,
-0.42673954367637634,
-0.009654038585722446,
0.12165837734937668,
0.2350703328847885,
0.18536950647830963,
0.11749552190303802,
0.1561175435781479,
-0.6204801797866821,
-0.042931508272886276,
0.1239687129855156,
0.7780402898788452,
0.9540066719055176,
0.6425765752792358,
0.0063185859471559525,
0.12736542522907257,
0.23127003014087677,
0.44258540868759155,
-0.7874816060066223,
-0.36582958698272705,
0.0639224499464035,
-0.21199677884578705,
-1.0235686302185059,
-0.16727307438850403,
-0.5897154808044434,
-0.8550168871879578,
-0.3920512795448303,
0.3465802073478699,
-0.5657080411911011,
-0.30779510736465454,
0.027334388345479965,
0.1568739116191864,
0.08130845427513123,
0.44762513041496277,
-0.7206385731697083,
0.311249703168869,
0.4553816020488739,
0.5822250843048096,
0.38796210289001465,
0.13793963193893433,
-0.8876272439956665,
0.24351544678211212,
-0.42198461294174194,
0.34144511818885803,
-0.5882052183151245,
-0.5836933255195618,
0.20049458742141724,
0.11314927786588669,
0.12086495757102966,
-0.5440921187400818,
0.4494529068470001,
-0.3622579574584961,
0.00952955987304449,
-0.11071725189685822,
-0.13434919714927673,
-0.04679756239056587,
0.37639325857162476,
-0.06091572344303131,
0.4762902557849884,
-0.2571451961994171,
-0.9473598003387451,
0.024550653994083405,
-0.29648879170417786,
-0.7141456007957458,
-0.13539491593837738,
-0.15977340936660767,
-0.4985506236553192,
-0.05111101642251015,
-0.10234826803207397,
0.6405454277992249,
0.07117998600006104,
0.44482144713401794,
-0.48725631833076477,
-0.5209580659866333,
0.33689942955970764,
-0.617997407913208,
0.7493501305580139,
-0.0587138868868351,
-0.3207806944847107,
0.3659175634384155,
-0.6406547427177429,
-0.12175147235393524,
0.14772839844226837,
-0.1660173237323761,
-0.6661980152130127,
-0.039876360446214676,
-0.10062845051288605,
0.15287046134471893,
-0.04558594524860382,
-0.3028782308101654,
-0.5584360957145691,
-0.3264666795730591,
0.5002326965332031,
1.23405122756958,
-0.01357309054583311,
0.43220269680023193,
-0.36735209822654724,
0.122884601354599,
0.18560536205768585,
0.4518437385559082,
0.2011360377073288,
-0.22235813736915588,
-0.8590494990348816,
0.23652051389217377,
-0.1715402752161026,
0.7384659647941589,
-0.989077091217041,
0.4559250473976135,
0.10612178593873978,
-0.4596457779407501,
-0.3635917007923126,
-0.07859811931848526,
0.8782367706298828,
0.6823912262916565,
0.0730472132563591,
-0.3320208489894867,
-0.18249067664146423,
-0.7230868935585022,
-0.0928717628121376,
-0.43245112895965576,
-0.01130734570324421,
0.8289061188697815,
0.11158468574285507,
-0.21791785955429077,
0.397792786359787,
-0.39262035489082336,
-0.21176663041114807,
0.03997870534658432,
0.33841925859451294,
-0.288465678691864,
0.7798694968223572,
0.2885148525238037,
-0.8595289587974548,
-0.3604198694229126,
-0.16801440715789795,
-0.8695638179779053,
0.1354040801525116,
-0.1039266511797905,
-0.251584529876709,
0.12873993813991547,
0.6865807175636292,
-0.14927753806114197,
0.3244777023792267,
0.36823591589927673,
-0.4223170280456543,
0.3915356397628784,
-0.3497055768966675,
0.10824628919363022,
-1.1338180303573608,
-0.16666452586650848,
0.07827284932136536,
-0.23025913536548615,
-0.8513200879096985,
-0.2893311679363251,
-0.27289021015167236,
-0.1928548514842987,
-0.6656453013420105,
0.21418865025043488,
-0.06705159693956375,
0.24112339317798615,
0.018542639911174774,
0.21127688884735107,
-0.2060149908065796,
0.43189871311187744,
0.09493350237607956,
0.8929409980773926,
0.5904883742332458,
-0.8809881210327148,
0.06891710311174393,
0.3788258731365204,
0.011740862391889095,
0.8287904858589172,
-0.985528826713562,
0.5131469368934631,
-0.4990556240081787,
0.30072054266929626,
-0.8127179741859436,
-0.3594256639480591,
0.33841100335121155,
-0.5390028953552246,
0.2520076632499695,
-0.12570010125637054,
-0.12349942326545715,
0.3616654574871063,
-0.5778329372406006,
0.42485275864601135,
0.4363671839237213,
-0.22486291825771332,
0.15113456547260284,
0.5930803418159485,
-0.6080660223960876,
-0.49693596363067627,
-0.2989226281642914,
-0.04472969472408295,
-0.3537953794002533,
-0.7572866678237915,
-0.046153921633958817,
-0.2114514261484146,
-0.3563578724861145,
-0.29832369089126587,
-0.031109686940908432,
0.04077363386750221,
0.3930017352104187,
0.2989274263381958,
0.34498754143714905,
0.26256465911865234,
0.1574387103319168,
0.019279610365629196,
-0.3181411623954773,
0.285630464553833,
0.321831077337265,
0.5016766786575317,
-0.5023179054260254,
0.10539140552282333,
-0.5032267570495605,
0.282819926738739,
0.2986716628074646,
-0.02659003622829914,
0.8337616920471191,
0.6172221302986145,
-0.27197515964508057,
0.14824795722961426,
-0.18065722286701202,
-0.563025712966919,
-0.568307638168335,
0.26112088561058044,
0.1876661479473114,
-1.0565640926361084,
0.35751041769981384,
0.12221583724021912,
0.009618731215596199,
-0.15074147284030914,
0.22257527709007263,
-0.2661614716053009,
1.0495121479034424,
0.4666072130203247,
0.005125090479850769,
0.6553336381912231,
-0.13146811723709106,
0.37950393557548523,
-0.5391181707382202,
-0.2780328392982483,
-0.3650864362716675,
-0.003540558973327279,
-0.7762670516967773,
-0.45530030131340027,
0.8634681105613708,
-0.29038435220718384,
-0.5292202234268188,
0.05921965464949608,
-0.30126380920410156,
0.5962154269218445,
0.6678029298782349,
0.5405029058456421,
0.11442312598228455,
-0.19980835914611816,
0.15553952753543854,
0.0042390706948935986,
-0.38704654574394226,
-0.826574981212616,
0.8225986957550049,
0.2608188986778259,
0.8341636657714844,
0.2896437644958496,
0.7648256421089172,
0.2736843526363373,
0.20025596022605896,
-0.49423784017562866,
0.7215721011161804,
-0.2680695652961731,
-0.43349236249923706,
-0.39992645382881165,
-0.5720781087875366,
-0.9265037178993225,
-0.03129157796502113,
-0.35667940974235535,
-0.6654075384140015,
0.2289295643568039,
0.42963117361068726,
-0.7242735624313354,
-0.11767098307609558,
-0.6757633686065674,
0.6829922795295715,
0.03223950415849686,
-0.7391130328178406,
-0.4597553312778473,
-1.1657962799072266,
0.24736063182353973,
0.2165384590625763,
0.40525317192077637,
-0.2371322363615036,
0.36605748534202576,
0.4776117205619812,
-0.1214708611369133,
1.424635410308838,
-0.21588321030139923,
-0.08553192019462585,
0.3229522705078125,
0.40138518810272217,
0.6420249938964844,
0.4816608428955078,
0.051590077579021454,
0.05058030039072037,
-0.22711314260959625,
-0.3717207610607147,
-0.33462265133857727,
0.5021809935569763,
-0.8773209452629089,
-0.5325849652290344,
-0.18177998065948486,
-0.39840829372406006,
-0.4606682062149048,
-0.0526532381772995,
0.13231833279132843,
0.6889969110488892,
-0.5157729387283325,
0.37434789538383484,
1.060747742652893,
-0.6516579985618591,
0.18645399808883667,
0.5681520104408264,
0.6817320585250854,
-0.38018137216567993,
1.1808388233184814,
-0.2110079675912857,
0.487114280462265,
-0.010265538468956947,
0.2986542284488678,
-0.2630186080932617,
-0.4822678864002228,
-0.09375794231891632,
-0.035107627511024475,
-0.6563066840171814,
-0.3010338246822357,
-0.6405258774757385,
-0.14049014449119568,
-0.559610903263092,
-0.5026404857635498,
-0.155679851770401,
-0.11523640155792236,
-0.3804776668548584,
-0.2028149515390396,
0.22947226464748383,
0.521693766117096,
-0.26869943737983704,
0.12756335735321045,
-0.9807009100914001,
0.17911186814308167,
0.6909394264221191,
0.2700367569923401,
-0.2051517218351364,
-0.40763476490974426,
0.08621544390916824,
0.14965267479419708,
-0.26472875475883484,
-0.6188752055168152,
0.19722053408622742,
0.34220999479293823,
0.29095762968063354,
0.6146858334541321,
0.7264569997787476,
0.24303488433361053,
-0.48197996616363525,
0.5459353923797607,
0.20746906101703644,
-0.6241487860679626,
0.7443435192108154,
-0.7745782136917114,
-0.17198440432548523,
0.9202571511268616,
0.304546058177948,
-0.6506765484809875,
-0.4956147372722626,
-0.6820082664489746,
-0.9363603591918945,
0.6189836859703064,
0.3885001838207245,
0.5672773718833923,
-0.3258149027824402,
0.02590944804251194,
0.07907801121473312,
0.252689391374588,
-0.6153994798660278,
-0.0925058051943779,
-0.24018940329551697,
-0.31883177161216736,
-0.31616413593292236,
-0.2489013820886612,
-0.6032093167304993,
0.061244070529937744,
0.6457879543304443,
-0.40182849764823914,
0.047074299305677414,
0.07298240810632706,
0.026542503386735916,
0.052299614995718,
0.38357535004615784,
0.3760615885257721,
0.12190704047679901,
-0.33324286341667175,
0.30986058712005615,
0.031834572553634644,
-0.3909425139427185,
0.28677448630332947,
0.11962860822677612,
0.023647034540772438,
-0.5220509767532349,
0.15261462330818176,
0.5315836071968079,
0.3578539788722992,
-0.7211593985557556,
0.5602415800094604,
-0.2964779734611511,
0.05982318893074989,
-0.21525639295578003,
0.4318559467792511,
0.04586007818579674,
0.27879852056503296,
-0.2651160657405853,
0.08334452658891678,
0.4672270715236664,
-0.7317373752593994,
0.17733469605445862,
0.430451363325119,
-0.4135506749153137,
-0.2529561221599579,
0.5155738592147827,
0.9036144614219666,
-0.4129784405231476,
0.632311224937439,
-0.2903844714164734,
-0.24763040244579315,
0.6820573210716248,
0.2889426052570343,
0.8340104222297668,
-0.2529353201389313,
0.6124799847602844,
0.3517270088195801,
0.22546330094337463,
0.34751996397972107,
0.2152967005968094,
-0.15383818745613098,
-1.10519540309906,
0.18834847211837769,
-0.19196270406246185,
-0.6270331740379333,
0.05918765440583229,
-0.7335250377655029,
-0.2246624082326889,
-0.8279096484184265,
-0.1919160932302475,
0.05909891799092293,
-0.3078920543193817,
-0.44236883521080017,
0.21115659177303314,
0.04271627217531204,
0.24126431345939636,
-1.0157727003097534,
0.4341234564781189,
0.7462295293807983,
-0.23901595175266266,
-0.5141069889068604,
0.08469577878713608,
0.2966259717941284,
-0.958430826663971,
0.361270934343338,
0.38477644324302673,
-0.5159948468208313,
-0.2340676337480545,
-0.6494318246841431,
-0.38140928745269775,
0.816654622554779,
0.40329715609550476,
-0.4954453706741333,
0.1653873175382614,
0.16660355031490326,
0.6691464185714722,
-0.032544516026973724,
-0.0998171865940094,
0.5024835467338562,
-0.043341390788555145,
0.0053192912600934505,
-0.7155886292457581,
0.2750682234764099,
-0.43179821968078613,
0.06344224512577057,
0.06474676728248596,
-0.9586939811706543,
0.35022789239883423,
-0.37227094173431396,
-0.20528416335582733,
-0.1298224925994873,
0.2848118841648102,
0.284962922334671,
0.7266798615455627,
0.7651553750038147,
0.14164915680885315,
0.7473894953727722,
-0.0353066511452198,
0.7639738917350769,
-0.2161511927843094,
-0.15035082399845123,
1.242398977279663,
-0.333497554063797,
0.5444142818450928,
0.22188544273376465,
0.1999136358499527,
0.09481313079595566,
0.5540466904640198,
0.5288228392601013,
0.603385329246521,
0.14963601529598236,
-0.6107070446014404,
-0.537408709526062,
-0.6070531606674194,
-0.25076955556869507,
0.49452143907546997,
0.5707947611808777,
-0.3117334842681885,
0.13446058332920074,
-0.2967357337474823,
0.2624935209751129,
0.1584583967924118,
-0.14591184258460999,
1.086084246635437,
0.021040912717580795,
-0.3985239863395691,
0.3987239599227905,
-0.3492615520954132,
0.6767281889915466,
-0.2248964011669159,
-0.02978740818798542,
-0.46333152055740356,
0.26677778363227844,
-0.006846846546977758,
-0.6597653031349182,
0.459787517786026,
-0.015104584395885468,
0.268619567155838,
-0.07819043099880219,
0.8058112859725952,
-0.4163440465927124,
-0.17739032208919525,
0.21033325791358948,
0.16021330654621124,
0.15808932483196259,
0.14110581576824188,
-0.6480435729026794,
-0.16456320881843567,
-0.18473201990127563,
0.18491922318935394,
0.6303719878196716,
0.431941419839859,
0.003996357321739197,
0.6677572131156921,
0.5351095795631409,
-0.5312688946723938,
-0.42591604590415955,
0.27333611249923706,
1.0680395364761353,
-0.41206979751586914,
-0.6756181716918945,
-0.48806077241897583,
0.6859813332557678,
-0.3394002318382263,
-0.29205265641212463,
0.37839746475219727,
-0.06705166399478912,
0.6685353517532349,
0.2861382067203522,
0.6150829792022705,
0.2446163147687912,
0.11318238824605942,
-0.3728492856025696,
0.6665598750114441,
-0.19981567561626434,
0.2037225365638733,
-0.5243358612060547,
-0.38323479890823364,
-0.017353475093841553,
0.8138514757156372,
-0.10866676270961761,
-0.02411198988556862,
0.16278597712516785,
1.0560160875320435,
0.2985215485095978,
0.2508290708065033,
0.3719289004802704,
0.23589450120925903,
0.3397984504699707,
0.5679261684417725,
0.8477823138237,
-0.21483387053012848,
0.8117312788963318,
-0.24146853387355804,
-0.3809777796268463,
-0.1614968329668045,
-0.8621443510055542,
-1.0576081275939941,
-0.26014453172683716,
-0.4809219539165497,
-0.5573041439056396,
0.5990704298019409,
0.7638192176818848,
0.6714198589324951,
-0.5982521772384644,
0.037681300193071365,
-0.2731647789478302,
-0.07874522358179092,
0.042097993195056915,
-0.2764821946620941,
0.21927231550216675,
-0.33566126227378845,
-0.5114157795906067,
0.40761902928352356,
0.231525257229805,
0.3914157450199127,
0.07355422526597977,
-0.27514582872390747,
0.09868837893009186,
0.31053969264030457,
0.6600728631019592,
0.010067107155919075,
-0.1203545406460762,
-0.5831629633903503,
-0.28992244601249695,
-0.08467751741409302,
-0.16749179363250732,
0.5731704235076904,
-0.264519602060318,
0.3779282867908478,
0.23400110006332397,
0.5530992746353149,
-0.17290784418582916,
0.0016092803562059999,
0.7986524701118469,
-0.979361891746521,
0.15762686729431152,
0.4642440676689148,
0.05610581114888191,
0.5432116985321045,
-0.8089903593063354,
0.619933009147644,
0.09915381669998169,
-0.6125972867012024,
-0.6758345365524292,
0.37306469678878784,
-0.7481489777565002,
-0.23223012685775757,
1.1321738958358765,
-0.3313378393650055,
0.16459859907627106,
-0.45355162024497986,
-0.5005216598510742,
0.3907513916492462,
-0.7315042018890381,
1.012328028678894,
0.2981932461261749,
-0.15690335631370544,
-0.02829129621386528,
-0.2888631522655487,
0.6995309591293335,
0.5169702172279358,
-0.9621192812919617,
0.45751023292541504,
0.7342100143432617,
0.23359932005405426,
0.11244404315948486,
0.7899355292320251,
-0.0463845320045948,
0.46027901768684387,
0.12604321539402008,
-0.4087248742580414,
0.03011014498770237,
-0.3750014305114746,
-0.33846646547317505,
0.06254808604717255,
-0.1513410061597824,
-0.26824241876602173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00421v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00421v2 | From PARIS to LE-PARIS: Toward Patent Response Automation with Recommender Systems and Collaborative Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T08:37:13 | 2024-03-05T03:45:22 | Jung-Mei Chu, Hao-Cheng Lo, Jieh Hsiang, Chun-Chieh Cho | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | In patent prosecution, timely and effective responses to Office Actions (OAs)
are crucial for securing patents. However, past automation and artificial
intelligence research have largely overlooked this aspect. To bridge this gap,
our study introduces the Patent Office Action Response Intelligence System
(PARIS) and its advanced version, the Large Language Model (LLM) Enhanced PARIS
(LE-PARIS). These systems are designed to enhance the efficiency of patent
attorneys in handling OA responses through collaboration with AI. The systems'
key features include the construction of an OA Topics Database, development of
Response Templates, and implementation of Recommender Systems and LLM-based
Response Generation. To validate the effectiveness of the systems, we have
employed a multi-paradigm analysis using the USPTO Office Action database and
longitudinal data based on attorney interactions with our systems over six
years. Through five studies, we have examined the constructiveness of OA topics
(studies 1 and 2) using topic modeling and our proposed Delphi process, the
efficacy of our proposed hybrid LLM-based recommender system tailored for OA
responses (study 3), the quality of generated responses (study 4), and the
systems' practical value in real-world scenarios through user studies (study
5). The results indicate that both PARIS and LE-PARIS significantly achieve key
metrics and have a positive impact on attorney performance. | [
-0.31252771615982056,
-0.6800795793533325,
0.8688930869102478,
0.04297781363129616,
0.05494493991136551,
0.19699998199939728,
0.16939903795719147,
-0.6418325901031494,
0.5060790777206421,
0.5400306582450867,
-0.04430587217211723,
-0.2119991034269333,
-0.5000810623168945,
0.16479751467704773,
-0.32314544916152954,
0.4577164649963379,
-0.05475728586316109,
0.21786975860595703,
0.16053278744220734,
0.019216688349843025,
-0.42578697204589844,
-0.7292202115058899,
-0.6265552639961243,
-0.3639183044433594,
0.6217895150184631,
0.30960533022880554,
0.2100447416305542,
0.17654265463352203,
0.7955579161643982,
0.34558311104774475,
0.04361657425761223,
0.029187822714447975,
-0.19819214940071106,
-0.17241309583187103,
-0.1314658671617508,
-0.3209921717643738,
-0.9211509823799133,
0.06262387335300446,
0.02747173048555851,
0.6300277709960938,
-0.05458299443125725,
-0.18316145241260529,
-0.2759663462638855,
0.871595025062561,
-0.5751315355300903,
-0.10420442372560501,
-0.5963562726974487,
0.12827514111995697,
0.3936823904514313,
-0.15692652761936188,
-0.3439907133579254,
-0.060191597789525986,
0.531402051448822,
-0.517828106880188,
0.032151781022548676,
0.46924713253974915,
0.471350759267807,
-0.044418346136808395,
-0.18044643104076385,
-0.2997964024543762,
-0.9788304567337036,
0.5449743866920471,
-0.5960497856140137,
0.03412464261054993,
-0.015994474291801453,
0.23274487257003784,
-0.4837752878665924,
-0.780735194683075,
-0.720313549041748,
-0.45577284693717957,
0.13522951304912567,
0.24518311023712158,
-0.13626958429813385,
-0.17020989954471588,
0.12419269233942032,
0.20367014408111572,
-0.5523641705513,
0.1955263912677765,
-0.5674444437026978,
-0.08658580482006073,
0.7653164863586426,
-0.10569938272237778,
0.12807689607143402,
0.2166348397731781,
-0.2367403656244278,
-0.0651789978146553,
-0.6117303967475891,
-0.02935299463570118,
0.40336713194847107,
0.43997347354888916,
0.270902544260025,
0.8115922808647156,
-0.13506929576396942,
0.505322277545929,
0.008814234286546707,
0.23389866948127747,
0.12377243489027023,
-0.40963155031204224,
-0.2996703088283539,
0.14196428656578064,
0.8703559041023254,
0.2724078893661499,
0.27659401297569275,
-0.16680306196212769,
-0.29617246985435486,
-0.34416863322257996,
0.4313879907131195,
-0.6859115362167358,
-0.05260854214429855,
0.6435980200767517,
-0.559959888458252,
0.011267443187534809,
0.2788056433200836,
-0.6837592124938965,
-0.6866140961647034,
-0.6218372583389282,
0.3356987237930298,
-0.1683950275182724,
-0.14651021361351013,
0.21392342448234558,
-0.232421875,
0.1628776341676712,
0.5210673809051514,
-0.6428045630455017,
0.45700228214263916,
0.9228911995887756,
0.776501476764679,
-0.3134731948375702,
-0.20372290909290314,
-0.799545407295227,
-0.003495334880426526,
-0.22935806214809418,
0.9879996180534363,
-0.4499644935131073,
-0.663119912147522,
0.137818843126297,
-0.060556527227163315,
-0.2184286117553711,
-0.7362237572669983,
0.44352906942367554,
-0.7752788662910461,
0.15996010601520538,
-0.13545872271060944,
-0.34983110427856445,
0.08647315949201584,
0.31576937437057495,
-0.44270139932632446,
0.4133044183254242,
-0.20998814702033997,
-0.5721957087516785,
0.4888180196285248,
-1.057116150856018,
-0.37673237919807434,
-0.17567181587219238,
-0.27238765358924866,
-0.22883117198944092,
0.1927485316991806,
0.27203869819641113,
0.44172361493110657,
-0.3054735064506531,
0.11047320812940598,
-0.387527734041214,
-0.12650930881500244,
-0.037529509514570236,
0.18905256688594818,
0.5440002679824829,
0.31706589460372925,
-0.28847965598106384,
0.353542298078537,
-0.8881914615631104,
-0.4089522361755371,
0.3422999978065491,
-0.12076417356729507,
-0.18375815451145172,
-0.07725857943296432,
-0.07642792165279388,
0.27971863746643066,
0.3973900079727173,
-0.8677911758422852,
0.17256276309490204,
-0.6013991832733154,
0.4979812204837799,
0.7487456202507019,
-0.03426869958639145,
0.24540314078330994,
-0.29012832045555115,
0.32559555768966675,
-0.14775501191616058,
-0.04261643439531326,
-0.20360302925109863,
-0.5038476586341858,
-0.6307589411735535,
-0.18815335631370544,
-0.016919653862714767,
0.7870768308639526,
-0.2215108722448349,
0.6802133321762085,
-0.48054006695747375,
-0.31149935722351074,
-0.07882991433143616,
-0.06881566345691681,
-0.09398947656154633,
0.5418155789375305,
0.10383059829473495,
-0.6272553205490112,
-0.2598561644554138,
-0.8806236386299133,
-0.16734662652015686,
-0.28083598613739014,
-0.04586391896009445,
0.5793771147727966,
0.6811330318450928,
0.036381497979164124,
1.034281849861145,
-0.5268332362174988,
-0.16589048504829407,
-0.33243492245674133,
0.2654406428337097,
0.4349202513694763,
-0.018562335520982742,
0.7572640776634216,
-0.8013585805892944,
-0.4423365294933319,
0.2920766770839691,
-0.4426099956035614,
0.0008621959714218974,
0.30534857511520386,
0.0042617786675691605,
0.21472324430942535,
0.5008847117424011,
-0.2817419767379761,
0.6205874681472778,
-0.11298675090074539,
-0.29109612107276917,
0.3290199637413025,
-0.37176576256752014,
0.2565927505493164,
-1.1739060878753662,
0.42630940675735474,
-0.11368539184331894,
-0.044336140155792236,
-0.5717670321464539,
-0.2649700939655304,
-0.2951943576335907,
-0.529191792011261,
-0.6707695722579956,
0.7058053016662598,
0.03824078291654587,
-0.27311068773269653,
-0.46929147839546204,
0.21527698636054993,
-0.07553501427173615,
0.32342439889907837,
-0.0031342862639576197,
0.8856247067451477,
0.32042255997657776,
-0.6139847636222839,
0.5930516719818115,
0.24025575816631317,
0.0039606415666639805,
0.6883063316345215,
-0.8852508068084717,
0.3059273064136505,
-0.012092194519937038,
0.23354239761829376,
-1.0359647274017334,
-0.31467151641845703,
0.04000091552734375,
0.042212966829538345,
0.147365540266037,
0.14661329984664917,
-0.7013775110244751,
-0.8041918277740479,
-0.47296950221061707,
-0.04880808666348457,
0.20361033082008362,
-0.46789228916168213,
1.0352963209152222,
0.4319511353969574,
-0.5592038035392761,
-0.4737568795681,
-0.43522951006889343,
0.34233927726745605,
-0.2140703648328781,
-0.554162323474884,
0.1327083557844162,
-0.18387076258659363,
-0.482662171125412,
-0.06703638285398483,
0.2095320224761963,
-0.11743274331092834,
-0.023839371278882027,
0.2279905527830124,
0.07474067062139511,
0.053252480924129486,
-0.06915326416492462,
-0.37559381127357483,
-0.11470680683851242,
0.05636311322450638,
-0.3098125159740448,
0.7416270971298218,
0.04838023707270622,
-0.51744145154953,
-0.6820206642150879,
0.32633763551712036,
0.9569288492202759,
-0.22276437282562256,
0.4532042145729065,
0.20501330494880676,
-0.17757561802864075,
0.023361453786492348,
-0.37054377794265747,
-0.25834211707115173,
-0.46155357360839844,
0.12252094596624374,
-0.32730600237846375,
-0.6066391468048096,
0.5197196006774902,
-0.2782590687274933,
0.3315630555152893,
0.4113096296787262,
0.7287207245826721,
0.2831900119781494,
0.6959293484687805,
0.9672710299491882,
-0.4224722385406494,
0.5913081169128418,
-0.28983691334724426,
0.9712173342704773,
-0.650465726852417,
-0.1922178715467453,
-0.6254486441612244,
-0.30615803599357605,
-0.21774007380008698,
0.09229803085327148,
0.5390763282775879,
-0.24573741853237152,
-0.15246866643428802,
0.4538998305797577,
-0.38285690546035767,
0.15618565678596497,
0.7521026134490967,
-0.24340707063674927,
0.31787508726119995,
0.23883765935897827,
-0.228027805685997,
0.32764750719070435,
-0.5860303044319153,
-0.7515685558319092,
1.3734517097473145,
0.39014291763305664,
0.5556310415267944,
0.048055145889520645,
0.7254029512405396,
0.2578481435775757,
0.10784904658794403,
-0.9312270283699036,
0.7505027651786804,
-0.21300698816776276,
-0.11189408600330353,
-0.2290138602256775,
0.1410684585571289,
-0.8180685043334961,
-0.06349007785320282,
-0.007348611019551754,
-0.9269649982452393,
0.42926353216171265,
-0.08811285346746445,
-0.9788095355033875,
0.081499844789505,
-0.7811819911003113,
0.39763468503952026,
-0.34578660130500793,
-0.530370831489563,
-0.4695947766304016,
-0.38403090834617615,
-0.08341437578201294,
-0.4064996540546417,
0.11311488598585129,
-0.09602148830890656,
0.08582751452922821,
0.4710392653942108,
-0.6093050837516785,
0.7095551490783691,
0.12298177182674408,
-0.5213587880134583,
0.19396325945854187,
-0.09967737644910812,
0.6253790855407715,
-0.1787910908460617,
-0.43626537919044495,
-0.306317001581192,
-0.22655290365219116,
-0.03180617094039917,
-0.5234269499778748,
0.9644328951835632,
-0.5345348119735718,
-0.6753157377243042,
-0.45743682980537415,
-0.6542592644691467,
-0.23293301463127136,
0.447648286819458,
-0.03137349709868431,
0.266841858625412,
-0.3344690203666687,
-0.0250194501131773,
0.3087206184864044,
-0.28324517607688904,
0.6151542663574219,
0.8023514747619629,
-0.1661146879196167,
-0.6728943586349487,
0.8292241096496582,
0.18093830347061157,
-0.1083097904920578,
0.3635319769382477,
0.12779051065444946,
-0.31331339478492737,
-0.6593303084373474,
-0.14943280816078186,
0.27507004141807556,
-0.46008801460266113,
0.23659159243106842,
-0.8055353760719299,
-0.06909109652042389,
-0.7644813656806946,
-0.05353514477610588,
-0.22296710312366486,
-0.5020913481712341,
-0.05764506757259369,
0.15049119293689728,
0.18836259841918945,
0.7828029990196228,
0.11016683280467987,
-0.1869281828403473,
-0.6478149890899658,
0.3651546537876129,
0.5845673084259033,
0.18482139706611633,
-0.06660754233598709,
-0.33887648582458496,
0.02553967572748661,
-0.1960461288690567,
-0.5502873659133911,
-0.21086274087429047,
0.19996525347232819,
0.22262465953826904,
0.3498930335044861,
0.4084651470184326,
0.1520322561264038,
0.3059499263763428,
-0.9352215528488159,
0.8855732083320618,
-0.20900946855545044,
-0.48393842577934265,
0.8970271348953247,
-0.4436492919921875,
-0.15140020847320557,
0.24757780134677887,
0.22522421181201935,
0.04245968163013458,
-0.23185455799102783,
-0.5341537594795227,
-1.0929793119430542,
0.7377426028251648,
0.08490469306707382,
0.3142315447330475,
0.2674666941165924,
0.5472001433372498,
-0.22134214639663696,
0.4520491063594818,
-0.19926193356513977,
0.027899960055947304,
0.2741827368736267,
0.14134834706783295,
0.18275752663612366,
0.07790004462003708,
-0.617983341217041,
0.1810622662305832,
0.6798847913742065,
-0.0392206571996212,
0.26590609550476074,
0.43070176243782043,
0.41557347774505615,
-0.038310706615448,
0.2608923316001892,
0.7658260464668274,
0.8657015562057495,
-0.24373413622379303,
-0.21188360452651978,
-0.11783384531736374,
-0.31397315859794617,
-0.013788911513984203,
0.3428419530391693,
0.13431692123413086,
-0.3723869025707245,
0.4155884385108948,
0.3590485155582428,
-0.5545967817306519,
-0.847794234752655,
0.444823294878006,
-0.13190340995788574,
-0.20906434953212738,
-0.24253681302070618,
0.09942960739135742,
-0.40076112747192383,
0.3199869990348816,
0.41717129945755005,
-0.027263350784778595,
0.3288988173007965,
-0.7426308393478394,
0.26149699091911316,
0.4261346757411957,
-0.37459099292755127,
-0.14293044805526733,
0.584204375743866,
0.46213531494140625,
-0.3533046543598175,
-0.002175049390643835,
0.04655086249113083,
-0.5149511694908142,
0.8440088629722595,
0.334061861038208,
1.0004284381866455,
0.18336395919322968,
-0.126844584941864,
0.08659901469945908,
0.12012307345867157,
-0.1695907711982727,
0.306654691696167,
0.1329643726348877,
-0.5487097501754761,
-0.10956345498561859,
-0.19678938388824463,
-0.5392459034919739,
0.31749045848846436,
-0.23732639849185944,
0.2175167053937912,
-0.8347410559654236,
-0.25702306628227234,
-0.0361245833337307,
0.09486756473779678,
-0.4485534429550171,
-0.09060194343328476,
-0.13969016075134277,
1.0168814659118652,
-0.7102087736129761,
0.3835170269012451,
0.9424535632133484,
-0.35283055901527405,
-0.456190288066864,
0.2972419857978821,
0.0447547547519207,
-0.6437914371490479,
0.9795106053352356,
0.053035397082567215,
-0.5773568749427795,
-0.2511342167854309,
-0.2962721288204193,
-0.4674592614173889,
1.0654239654541016,
0.22783850133419037,
-0.6717365980148315,
0.5995883941650391,
0.2342817783355713,
0.8550772666931152,
-0.5371859669685364,
-0.04135385528206825,
0.6527102589607239,
0.11587998270988464,
0.26241418719291687,
-1.204379677772522,
-0.3082219362258911,
-0.42020317912101746,
0.03316201642155647,
-0.1365482211112976,
-0.7764976024627686,
0.5001419186592102,
-0.3320428431034088,
0.04985574260354042,
0.46367818117141724,
0.5758584141731262,
0.20401550829410553,
0.5489870309829712,
0.22309835255146027,
0.7171922922134399,
0.5305904746055603,
-0.05266144126653671,
1.2710094451904297,
-0.7100351452827454,
-0.04057621955871582,
0.99015212059021,
-0.9397366642951965,
1.2367491722106934,
0.5415814518928528,
-0.2008371353149414,
0.2684100568294525,
0.3940800428390503,
0.06746674329042435,
0.5023861527442932,
0.2807096540927887,
-0.3369651138782501,
0.050671111792325974,
-0.796302080154419,
-0.23436260223388672,
0.031068552285432816,
0.2596661150455475,
-0.37034133076667786,
-0.029741037636995316,
0.19591155648231506,
-0.27552521228790283,
0.207400843501091,
-0.14059586822986603,
0.8261513710021973,
0.06144770607352257,
-0.5327101349830627,
0.13342280685901642,
-0.10250753164291382,
0.18909704685211182,
-0.34447726607322693,
-0.09013570100069046,
-0.1317204236984253,
0.4314987361431122,
0.014263264834880829,
-0.6770411729812622,
0.10684723407030106,
0.13032349944114685,
-0.1988852322101593,
-0.166042298078537,
0.3834167420864105,
0.006281631998717785,
-0.4549649655818939,
0.49177587032318115,
0.3660733699798584,
-0.015008569695055485,
0.1420801728963852,
-0.6688820719718933,
-0.10495587438344955,
-0.5210002660751343,
-0.19243763387203217,
0.08606479316949844,
0.5210086703300476,
-0.1119174212217331,
0.7270166873931885,
0.6071074604988098,
0.2868203818798065,
-0.13758322596549988,
0.33358004689216614,
1.016446590423584,
-0.1280277818441391,
-0.4685151278972626,
-0.4819497764110565,
0.3019663691520691,
-0.2586592733860016,
-0.005967581644654274,
0.47082847356796265,
0.5897364020347595,
0.26111191511154175,
-0.06933637708425522,
0.8800333738327026,
-0.10105135291814804,
0.7767361998558044,
-0.4554779827594757,
0.31470370292663574,
-0.41310447454452515,
0.6894170045852661,
-0.37196770310401917,
-1.1211580038070679,
-0.6287797093391418,
0.442536324262619,
-0.6195128560066223,
0.04037249833345413,
0.46221160888671875,
0.9044210910797119,
-0.16130325198173523,
-0.3038288354873657,
0.1193314641714096,
0.16662347316741943,
0.9358531832695007,
0.3349393904209137,
0.5717673301696777,
-0.5613528490066528,
0.15821342170238495,
0.022587213665246964,
-0.20544792711734772,
-0.39278435707092285,
-0.9256883859634399,
-1.0157493352890015,
-0.2654256522655487,
-0.16920506954193115,
-0.13593846559524536,
-0.02897530421614647,
1.117774248123169,
0.5242384076118469,
-1.169554591178894,
-0.22863651812076569,
-0.4044906497001648,
-0.19623534381389618,
0.24248547852039337,
-0.17294877767562866,
0.6990018486976624,
-0.34284070134162903,
-0.9230727553367615,
0.649228572845459,
0.9126230478286743,
0.25173670053482056,
-0.22080744802951813,
0.034585222601890564,
-0.066172294318676,
0.2458217293024063,
0.5862715840339661,
0.5712271332740784,
-0.7010889053344727,
-0.23233526945114136,
0.1803673356771469,
-0.0068715945817530155,
-0.06694900244474411,
1.0195192098617554,
-0.5898132920265198,
0.72637540102005,
0.7397680878639221,
0.7469134330749512,
-0.21440483629703522,
-0.006259198300540447,
1.1842621564865112,
-0.32979926466941833,
0.35704532265663147,
0.1559189110994339,
0.642397403717041,
0.03149280324578285,
-0.19254399836063385,
0.6605770587921143,
0.11129847913980484,
-0.46456316113471985,
-0.45482414960861206,
0.17806409299373627,
-0.6729523539543152,
-0.14091260731220245,
0.8516165614128113,
-0.2578961253166199,
-0.11752995103597641,
-0.287777841091156,
-0.6113722920417786,
-0.28637945652008057,
-0.5701539516448975,
1.1509360074996948,
0.8616124391555786,
-0.5788671374320984,
0.23351536691188812,
-0.422223836183548,
0.1319160908460617,
0.2676147222518921,
-0.9728983640670776,
-0.10477565973997116,
0.41351747512817383,
-0.1658756583929062,
0.8524583578109741,
0.6635375022888184,
-0.07259300351142883,
0.22604776918888092,
-0.4557356834411621,
-0.22054295241832733,
-0.042952071875333786,
-0.7409037351608276,
-0.37290963530540466,
0.1308293640613556,
0.18941792845726013,
-0.05478311702609062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00414v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00414v1 | Prompt-Time Symbolic Knowledge Capture with Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T08:15:28 | 2024-02-01T08:15:28 | Tolga Çöplü, Arto Bendiken, Andrii Skomorokhov, Eduard Bateiko, Stephen Cobb, Joshua J. Bouw | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Augmenting large language models (LLMs) with user-specific knowledge is
crucial for real-world applications, such as personal AI assistants. However,
LLMs inherently lack mechanisms for prompt-driven knowledge capture. This paper
investigates utilizing the existing LLM capabilities to enable prompt-driven
knowledge capture, with a particular emphasis on knowledge graphs. We address
this challenge by focusing on prompt-to-triple (P2T) generation. We explore
three methods: zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting, and fine-tuning, and
then assess their performance via a specialized synthetic dataset. Our code and
datasets are publicly available at https://github.com/HaltiaAI/paper-PTSKC. | [
-0.19336004555225372,
-0.8582794666290283,
1.0579931735992432,
0.24236097931861877,
-0.07766115665435791,
0.08985063433647156,
-0.06074162572622299,
-0.2147480547428131,
-0.16100835800170898,
0.32451164722442627,
-0.5504710078239441,
-0.46254703402519226,
-0.5577400326728821,
0.4505666494369507,
-0.10004076361656189,
0.707223653793335,
-0.2889938950538635,
-0.50010085105896,
-0.014768092893064022,
0.19603925943374634,
-0.6830751895904541,
-0.5025312900543213,
-0.8658437132835388,
-0.2491002082824707,
0.798700213432312,
0.6809109449386597,
0.5203573107719421,
0.41704389452934265,
-0.10198633372783661,
0.09826574474573135,
0.1487666517496109,
0.5183522701263428,
-0.2985578179359436,
0.4316629469394684,
0.178320974111557,
-0.34924569725990295,
-0.32180890440940857,
-0.02764919400215149,
0.8977213501930237,
0.5558755397796631,
0.4119848608970642,
0.20884589850902557,
0.05602039024233818,
0.3702658414840698,
-0.4754725396633148,
0.617929220199585,
-0.38670533895492554,
0.08830265700817108,
-0.23929676413536072,
-0.267105370759964,
-0.5827764868736267,
-0.46453574299812317,
-0.04769798740744591,
-0.7861142754554749,
-0.1349250227212906,
0.08474965393543243,
0.4700072109699249,
0.24764998257160187,
-0.7902700901031494,
-0.09761632978916168,
-0.7436597347259521,
0.49265989661216736,
-0.7007882595062256,
0.20781078934669495,
0.5304055213928223,
0.6583690643310547,
-0.18503406643867493,
-0.9368709921836853,
-0.8214919567108154,
-0.40967193245887756,
-0.08404339849948883,
-0.021291645243763924,
-0.30338573455810547,
-0.1027166023850441,
0.6242693662643433,
-0.15169757604599,
-0.4315880537033081,
0.16628825664520264,
-0.3326745927333832,
-0.17152181267738342,
0.4566049873828888,
0.4737357199192047,
0.19157323241233826,
-0.2917482852935791,
-0.21159853041172028,
-0.10199552774429321,
-0.9135400056838989,
0.1277710199356079,
0.4300278127193451,
0.5351406931877136,
-0.09284324198961258,
0.9562978148460388,
-0.3137444257736206,
1.0020583868026733,
0.1268388330936432,
-0.12731973826885223,
-0.04595573619008064,
-0.5955057740211487,
0.09990265965461731,
-0.10037166625261307,
0.8934785723686218,
0.30817127227783203,
0.2714233994483948,
-0.12686635553836823,
-0.1365852802991867,
-0.19785523414611816,
-0.08478318899869919,
-0.7093652486801147,
-0.26726117730140686,
0.19027304649353027,
0.010506842285394669,
-0.30467936396598816,
-0.1021416187286377,
-0.5193836092948914,
-0.4994644224643707,
-0.4195089042186737,
0.213312566280365,
-0.5207791924476624,
-0.1591411978006363,
-0.056751593947410583,
-0.2728663384914398,
0.3912350535392761,
0.432571142911911,
-0.5736069679260254,
-0.009483834728598595,
0.5450983643531799,
1.0477724075317383,
-0.1642552763223648,
-0.3917652666568756,
-0.8513439893722534,
0.4975079596042633,
-0.41328996419906616,
0.7569175958633423,
-0.32391923666000366,
-0.2728521525859833,
0.09527449309825897,
-0.313370943069458,
0.06639858335256577,
-0.18133020401000977,
0.15355364978313446,
-0.6154154539108276,
0.40240776538848877,
-0.6378928422927856,
-0.5358509421348572,
-0.0026011455338448286,
0.40676310658454895,
-0.5113932490348816,
1.2206007242202759,
0.3912784457206726,
-0.7150465846061707,
0.34980258345603943,
-0.62889164686203,
-0.6385498642921448,
0.22327499091625214,
-0.20220521092414856,
-0.07867758721113205,
-0.25536948442459106,
0.4902079403400421,
0.7580428719520569,
-0.24284309148788452,
0.2566834092140198,
-0.3055325746536255,
-0.1554860919713974,
0.03900807723402977,
-0.24893219769001007,
0.7573477029800415,
0.21708017587661743,
-0.22181019186973572,
0.08147092163562775,
-0.6318278908729553,
-0.10697188228368759,
0.3496021628379822,
-0.3762228786945343,
-0.05601246654987335,
-0.21551647782325745,
-0.444740355014801,
0.5237147808074951,
0.3094162046909332,
-0.37461012601852417,
0.5973379015922546,
-0.14540140330791473,
0.5369063019752502,
0.6891170740127563,
0.3574105203151703,
0.28078004717826843,
-0.3116251230239868,
0.7104319930076599,
-0.09374292939901352,
-0.11678662896156311,
-0.38129040598869324,
-0.5876692533493042,
-0.4689381420612335,
-0.13854539394378662,
0.03092087060213089,
0.5744172930717468,
-1.2631118297576904,
0.40087345242500305,
-0.231719970703125,
-0.3392329514026642,
-0.1376483142375946,
0.09728748351335526,
0.3164161741733551,
0.7489220499992371,
0.2683512568473816,
0.16509373486042023,
-0.36776089668273926,
-0.6688429117202759,
-0.21030475199222565,
-0.525353729724884,
-0.3938572406768799,
0.5202279090881348,
0.24500347673892975,
0.08709651231765747,
1.1950517892837524,
-0.626531183719635,
-0.12532435357570648,
-0.4747164249420166,
0.30846208333969116,
0.11898749321699142,
0.20263467729091644,
0.5192484855651855,
-0.23665882647037506,
-0.5132626295089722,
-0.31141427159309387,
-0.9236031174659729,
-0.4115622341632843,
-0.16348062455654144,
-0.0189922247081995,
0.2198767066001892,
0.6251044273376465,
-0.8851156234741211,
0.18653972446918488,
0.31130415201187134,
-0.5476816892623901,
0.6627659201622009,
-0.05860789120197296,
0.25958991050720215,
-1.3286828994750977,
0.2296607941389084,
-0.08208949863910675,
-0.345249742269516,
-0.6683218479156494,
-0.1700756698846817,
0.119637630879879,
-0.36943718791007996,
-0.6031082272529602,
0.9680482149124146,
-0.6090465784072876,
-0.24654211103916168,
-0.182565376162529,
0.29313355684280396,
-0.1302558332681656,
0.6158861517906189,
0.048454344272613525,
0.7951978445053101,
0.3693356513977051,
-0.6548956632614136,
0.5611593127250671,
0.2827084958553314,
-0.04323511943221092,
0.5956431031227112,
-0.7046812772750854,
0.5473009943962097,
0.07354631274938583,
0.5260891318321228,
-1.0204113721847534,
-0.6013423800468445,
0.4915659725666046,
-0.47129949927330017,
0.2750796377658844,
-0.23232704401016235,
-1.0357446670532227,
-0.5772562623023987,
-0.35411614179611206,
0.4731411039829254,
0.5985569357872009,
-0.6587417721748352,
0.5601686835289001,
0.1505201905965805,
-0.30597984790802,
-0.20894119143486023,
-0.42529550194740295,
0.3249639570713043,
-0.10229375958442688,
-0.7577304840087891,
0.04285199195146561,
0.18557125329971313,
-0.09363460540771484,
-0.1919199675321579,
0.1779416799545288,
0.3985918164253235,
-0.11665437370538712,
0.183940127491951,
0.12083388864994049,
-0.08249998837709427,
0.07478084415197372,
0.2363622635602951,
-0.21165402233600616,
-0.023427380248904228,
-0.6726434230804443,
0.6007130742073059,
0.10102604329586029,
-0.3529116213321686,
-0.8867104649543762,
0.44749733805656433,
0.5462045073509216,
-0.12914742529392242,
0.5499894618988037,
0.5490046143531799,
-0.34557148814201355,
0.03148187696933746,
-0.50371253490448,
-0.3094903826713562,
-0.41534730792045593,
0.06628599017858505,
-0.4350460171699524,
-1.0820437669754028,
0.37561464309692383,
-0.0814429372549057,
0.19377487897872925,
0.32736438512802124,
0.7173209190368652,
-0.13772690296173096,
1.222529649734497,
0.32999974489212036,
0.011760125868022442,
0.4410380721092224,
-0.08572116494178772,
0.17993441224098206,
-0.6124515533447266,
-0.26214656233787537,
-0.5432423949241638,
-0.27115413546562195,
-0.149732768535614,
-0.40508490800857544,
0.674247145652771,
0.09637122601270676,
-0.49783310294151306,
0.23296725749969482,
-0.08934923261404037,
0.3852199912071228,
0.8600298762321472,
0.004521307535469532,
0.34698572754859924,
0.07177909463644028,
-0.005147578660398722,
0.13735760748386383,
-0.9148072600364685,
-0.46629437804222107,
1.0369137525558472,
0.2264687865972519,
0.48852571845054626,
0.06721312552690506,
0.5190911889076233,
0.2782858908176422,
-0.24614423513412476,
-0.8025729060173035,
0.6996528506278992,
0.12793698906898499,
-0.19124361872673035,
-0.4249325394630432,
-0.5745639204978943,
-0.835482120513916,
-0.3136840760707855,
0.023872634395956993,
-0.610670804977417,
-0.1911209374666214,
0.523091197013855,
-0.7952556610107422,
0.24072077870368958,
-0.8397075533866882,
0.6572252511978149,
-0.144051194190979,
-0.2220192402601242,
0.051305100321769714,
-0.8041574954986572,
0.5675780773162842,
-0.06686919182538986,
-0.3295549154281616,
-0.13497251272201538,
-0.054232802242040634,
0.6799017190933228,
-0.30705153942108154,
1.1633882522583008,
-0.552191436290741,
-0.05835660174489021,
0.4097960591316223,
0.4223412871360779,
0.8765208125114441,
0.06872504204511642,
0.20498430728912354,
0.0010922212386503816,
-0.13360874354839325,
-0.43870916962623596,
-0.684873104095459,
0.48520156741142273,
-0.7328222393989563,
-0.4388226270675659,
-0.2758825719356537,
-0.7356712222099304,
-0.6399131417274475,
0.13521437346935272,
0.13844476640224457,
0.37598997354507446,
0.11962462216615677,
-0.17572076618671417,
0.3243424892425537,
-0.3202155530452728,
0.3401513397693634,
0.5202677845954895,
-0.20038998126983643,
-0.27843669056892395,
0.7208295464515686,
0.14064398407936096,
0.2773965001106262,
0.3304329216480255,
0.2541560232639313,
-0.5615025758743286,
-0.30335164070129395,
-0.5065227746963501,
0.3315622806549072,
-0.4600749909877777,
-0.4822782874107361,
-0.7829346060752869,
-0.05895901843905449,
-0.8742505311965942,
-0.208061084151268,
-0.061561308801174164,
-0.7102386951446533,
-0.3664471507072449,
-0.2450770139694214,
0.7039434909820557,
0.7333239316940308,
-0.17224043607711792,
0.5789148211479187,
-0.9291971325874329,
0.48935726284980774,
0.6580145359039307,
-0.055682819336652756,
-0.19253547489643097,
-0.37838688492774963,
0.10883147269487381,
-0.19692379236221313,
-0.009774935431778431,
-1.0864509344100952,
0.23250848054885864,
-0.04012715071439743,
0.4058517515659332,
0.21313293278217316,
0.12259797751903534,
0.49564793705940247,
-0.32016482949256897,
1.2052043676376343,
0.2858196198940277,
-0.7108049988746643,
0.9143235087394714,
-0.5673931837081909,
0.6132693886756897,
0.27933502197265625,
0.3086661100387573,
-0.7879015207290649,
-0.42320600152015686,
-0.3892174959182739,
-0.750446617603302,
1.0254080295562744,
0.19803056120872498,
-0.1074693500995636,
-0.047466740012168884,
0.4329933822154999,
0.04045702517032623,
-0.00003771722913370468,
-0.29577744007110596,
0.08318087458610535,
-0.14875183999538422,
-0.3158443570137024,
0.029442062601447105,
-0.4444444477558136,
-0.15843161940574646,
-0.09226332604885101,
0.5056226253509521,
-0.3956112861633301,
0.2077818512916565,
0.017678668722510338,
0.005311416927725077,
0.04886402189731598,
-0.0043816822580993176,
0.4641130268573761,
0.38655632734298706,
0.13579308986663818,
0.3781147599220276,
0.07789904624223709,
-0.14417006075382233,
0.147605761885643,
0.19856172800064087,
-0.46812358498573303,
-0.2547546923160553,
0.40914294123649597,
0.8870893120765686,
0.04234736040234566,
-0.44199007749557495,
0.3309065103530884,
-0.07995492964982986,
-0.05540487915277481,
-0.21869544684886932,
0.04926033690571785,
-0.12604855000972748,
0.41697508096694946,
0.1846173256635666,
-0.2787691652774811,
-0.268937349319458,
-0.21400746703147888,
0.05388344079256058,
0.22138535976409912,
-0.02155889756977558,
-0.5748305320739746,
0.5906709432601929,
0.2469354122877121,
-0.3448580205440521,
0.9500448107719421,
-0.39147675037384033,
-0.43879878520965576,
0.29728055000305176,
0.6263596415519714,
0.79057377576828,
-0.18143190443515778,
0.304452121257782,
0.5788223147392273,
0.1538761705160141,
0.04108356684446335,
0.25233161449432373,
-0.45971977710723877,
-0.6436182856559753,
-0.49626556038856506,
-0.2372192144393921,
-0.25216957926750183,
0.033836573362350464,
-0.25081807374954224,
0.4799168109893799,
-0.4401352107524872,
-0.10195176303386688,
-0.36421748995780945,
0.06730467081069946,
-0.7409051060676575,
-0.41640692949295044,
0.10393130779266357,
0.9484822750091553,
-0.8370158672332764,
0.8377412557601929,
0.43797072768211365,
-0.4490189850330353,
-1.2551666498184204,
-0.06017614156007767,
0.3535199761390686,
-1.0668095350265503,
0.6501336693763733,
-0.11786773055791855,
0.02403131313621998,
0.29974794387817383,
-0.5583826303482056,
-0.492509126663208,
1.306221604347229,
0.6010299921035767,
-0.34281840920448303,
-0.4600496292114258,
0.36390194296836853,
0.27097710967063904,
-0.21266397833824158,
0.014161176048219204,
0.9529701471328735,
0.6684523224830627,
0.30429807305336,
-0.9188494086265564,
0.10579709708690643,
0.015661390498280525,
0.0359363779425621,
0.0397040918469429,
-0.36202940344810486,
0.6858217120170593,
-0.39055177569389343,
-0.2827252149581909,
-0.15264202654361725,
0.567367434501648,
0.7577055096626282,
0.2341858148574829,
0.4861333966255188,
0.4544863700866699,
0.7367636561393738,
0.07683179527521133,
1.1950926780700684,
-0.3346075713634491,
-0.031560543924570084,
1.1923130750656128,
-0.4440762996673584,
0.5581037402153015,
0.5264453291893005,
-0.056474391371011734,
-0.03669757395982742,
0.6517593264579773,
0.12167492508888245,
0.25443708896636963,
-0.2470858097076416,
-0.41256996989250183,
-0.3495357930660248,
-0.23886039853096008,
-0.32700690627098083,
0.2743569016456604,
0.2671250104904175,
-0.12664510309696198,
-0.32277294993400574,
0.014263898134231567,
0.27275967597961426,
-0.3313945233821869,
-0.15096886456012726,
1.0139323472976685,
0.14609278738498688,
-0.9697008728981018,
0.40739044547080994,
-0.08321353793144226,
0.2509417235851288,
-0.6637261509895325,
-0.1875431388616562,
-0.4451524317264557,
-0.22774721682071686,
0.08542680740356445,
-1.1230336427688599,
0.07725482434034348,
0.30749019980430603,
-0.01041066087782383,
-0.625572681427002,
0.8240745663642883,
-0.44526243209838867,
-0.28041666746139526,
0.023027578368782997,
0.8096058964729309,
0.17392687499523163,
-0.1952144056558609,
-0.2353878766298294,
-0.1663183569908142,
-0.04086444154381752,
-0.18640948832035065,
0.1512851119041443,
0.508643627166748,
-0.08146937936544418,
0.4829564094543457,
0.6825053095817566,
0.09838784486055374,
0.19940541684627533,
0.14215651154518127,
0.7554797530174255,
-0.5286117792129517,
-0.5296764373779297,
-0.8074679970741272,
0.4035351276397705,
0.015513455495238304,
-0.25641393661499023,
0.7536182999610901,
0.41545557975769043,
0.6012904644012451,
-0.13849122822284698,
0.8889800906181335,
-0.1683434545993805,
0.5533986687660217,
-0.7284715175628662,
0.5576668381690979,
-0.22091065347194672,
0.03766627237200737,
-0.019924623891711235,
-0.6867663860321045,
-0.4458508789539337,
0.16567178070545197,
-0.31647831201553345,
-0.07010334730148315,
0.4128655195236206,
0.8657172918319702,
0.020811421796679497,
-0.18049070239067078,
0.2916202247142792,
0.2746371626853943,
0.6516379117965698,
0.8584080338478088,
1.1295571327209473,
0.02865763008594513,
0.5951458811759949,
-0.1591721922159195,
-0.27653440833091736,
-0.1408262401819229,
-0.9878749847412109,
-0.8970380425453186,
-0.8315318822860718,
-0.22623752057552338,
-0.4727749824523926,
-0.0019891890697181225,
0.9387633800506592,
0.6353905200958252,
-0.5299313068389893,
0.0567663200199604,
-0.12603193521499634,
-0.009754127822816372,
-0.09626597166061401,
-0.17271532118320465,
0.46962833404541016,
-0.4529379904270172,
-0.5434889793395996,
0.5874958038330078,
0.15167532861232758,
0.25915199518203735,
-0.23348963260650635,
-0.18924616277217865,
0.1767929196357727,
-0.18198354542255402,
0.8936077952384949,
0.5047751069068909,
-0.5716372132301331,
-0.3582852780818939,
0.17661193013191223,
0.03733545169234276,
-0.18533308804035187,
1.3403358459472656,
-1.0617700815200806,
0.3578592836856842,
0.6388084292411804,
0.5904521942138672,
0.5884831547737122,
-0.06936711072921753,
0.8030784726142883,
-1.2601780891418457,
0.007136943284422159,
0.3775244951248169,
0.3406459093093872,
0.3068838119506836,
-0.3533676862716675,
0.3471231460571289,
0.3804839551448822,
-0.3475319743156433,
-0.7948671579360962,
0.3541589081287384,
-0.9820264577865601,
-0.040043994784355164,
1.5270453691482544,
-0.09818410128355026,
0.06137444078922272,
-0.18561550974845886,
-0.40584489703178406,
0.5831109881401062,
-0.5339751243591309,
0.5785693526268005,
0.5543137788772583,
-0.33155539631843567,
-0.1862560212612152,
-0.3811456263065338,
0.4167530834674835,
0.014381074346601963,
-0.9619552493095398,
0.34137168526649475,
0.913342297077179,
0.1367146521806717,
-0.1408625841140747,
0.9662800431251526,
-0.06565655767917633,
0.304983526468277,
-0.10768922418355942,
-0.16051551699638367,
-0.632013738155365,
-0.5521578788757324,
-0.383331298828125,
0.3484068512916565,
0.20839159190654755,
0.044521965086460114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00412v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00412v1 | Hidding the Ghostwriters: An Adversarial Evaluation of AI-Generated Student Essay Detection | 2024-02-01T08:11:56 | 2024-02-01T08:11:56 | Xinlin Peng, Ying Zhou, Ben He, Le Sun, Yingfei Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable capabilities in text
generation tasks. However, the utilization of these models carries inherent
risks, including but not limited to plagiarism, the dissemination of fake news,
and issues in educational exercises. Although several detectors have been
proposed to address these concerns, their effectiveness against adversarial
perturbations, specifically in the context of student essay writing, remains
largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by constructing
AIG-ASAP, an AI-generated student essay dataset, employing a range of text
perturbation methods that are expected to generate high-quality essays while
evading detection. Through empirical experiments, we assess the performance of
current AIGC detectors on the AIG-ASAP dataset. The results reveal that the
existing detectors can be easily circumvented using straightforward automatic
adversarial attacks. Specifically, we explore word substitution and sentence
substitution perturbation methods that effectively evade detection while
maintaining the quality of the generated essays. This highlights the urgent
need for more accurate and robust methods to detect AI-generated student essays
in the education domain. | [
-0.4407370388507843,
-1.0317509174346924,
0.655674159526825,
-0.23802512884140015,
0.025797393172979355,
0.30508843064308167,
-0.02081974223256111,
-0.20471759140491486,
0.07338197529315948,
0.48622772097587585,
-0.3648488521575928,
-0.5944183468818665,
-0.7542206048965454,
0.23708896338939667,
-0.8285831809043884,
0.9898708462715149,
-0.058473922312259674,
-0.03702129051089287,
-0.27384844422340393,
0.22276176512241364,
0.09316397458314896,
-0.48999637365341187,
-0.9216954708099365,
-0.0772014707326889,
0.47732099890708923,
0.22107119858264923,
0.4426327645778656,
0.6298015117645264,
0.32108616828918457,
0.2292180210351944,
0.13846731185913086,
0.04634011909365654,
-0.07017137855291367,
0.11821731925010681,
0.28327152132987976,
-0.24385903775691986,
-0.14038918912410736,
0.30073046684265137,
0.9234981536865234,
0.27781927585601807,
0.0886092334985733,
0.030776092782616615,
0.10271245986223221,
0.15752814710140228,
-0.6536054611206055,
-0.2912340462207794,
-0.8314259648323059,
0.06248242035508156,
-0.38661614060401917,
-0.06717240810394287,
-0.6164303421974182,
-0.17751836776733398,
-0.28951892256736755,
-0.2741788625717163,
0.2894541323184967,
-0.15343207120895386,
0.8530076742172241,
0.38569948077201843,
-0.24701856076717377,
-0.4168500304222107,
-0.4310586154460907,
0.547390878200531,
-0.6793370842933655,
-0.2466237097978592,
0.38364142179489136,
0.23274190723896027,
-0.4455614686012268,
-0.6315884590148926,
-0.8441944122314453,
-0.332023561000824,
-0.10850182175636292,
0.315090537071228,
-0.2270374298095703,
0.32878410816192627,
0.08290914446115494,
0.36486777663230896,
-0.7768164873123169,
0.15122230350971222,
0.02973267063498497,
-0.2810249328613281,
0.5963345170021057,
0.08485051244497299,
0.6174790263175964,
-0.2893730700016022,
-0.36436447501182556,
-0.1158534362912178,
-0.5582900643348694,
-0.08082104474306107,
1.1909348964691162,
-0.029982808977365494,
0.48818060755729675,
0.5006892085075378,
0.21353699266910553,
0.30721572041511536,
-0.026109647005796432,
0.06707105040550232,
-0.48702916502952576,
-0.09519921243190765,
0.008242879994213581,
0.05230877920985222,
0.8345346450805664,
-0.04091819375753403,
0.09828808903694153,
-0.19055888056755066,
-0.3066999018192291,
0.4560226798057556,
0.3662945628166199,
-0.49009817838668823,
-0.4058569371700287,
-0.03827901557087898,
-0.33683666586875916,
-0.6734849810600281,
0.17052525281906128,
-0.7655810713768005,
-0.39405643939971924,
0.07842102646827698,
0.5955215692520142,
-0.28427988290786743,
0.22480371594429016,
-0.24188224971294403,
-0.05566880479454994,
0.1571568250656128,
0.11960959434509277,
-0.4320169687271118,
0.2944484353065491,
0.5172811150550842,
0.49630603194236755,
-0.3810354173183441,
-0.48155099153518677,
-0.5574564337730408,
0.005399856250733137,
-0.3631277084350586,
0.9149584174156189,
-0.5239310264587402,
-0.5301018953323364,
-0.02567477710545063,
-0.1477748453617096,
-0.15750958025455475,
-0.2717641592025757,
0.7413436770439148,
-0.15774884819984436,
0.5374374389648438,
0.09290458261966705,
-0.6814414262771606,
-0.06838905066251755,
0.28808853030204773,
-0.38921478390693665,
0.9488816261291504,
-0.08616014569997787,
-0.692527711391449,
0.029236624017357826,
-0.3270002603530884,
-0.6272985339164734,
0.015116969123482704,
-0.3805631697177887,
-0.8178256154060364,
0.14675843715667725,
0.5000432133674622,
0.5408560037612915,
0.10454403609037399,
0.08749251067638397,
-0.11365779489278793,
-0.7463546395301819,
0.21146292984485626,
-0.9816010594367981,
0.6842559576034546,
0.04572773352265358,
-0.41966360807418823,
-0.04943998530507088,
-0.8077030777931213,
-0.1922609955072403,
0.28806477785110474,
-0.4608887732028961,
-0.32787686586380005,
-0.1378253549337387,
0.0488794706761837,
-0.09232021868228912,
0.10584130883216858,
-0.33691081404685974,
0.13415387272834778,
-0.21110035479068756,
0.11026471108198166,
1.0619444847106934,
0.23262396454811096,
0.09001397341489792,
-0.27145448327064514,
0.8344020843505859,
-0.3443920910358429,
-0.04021821916103363,
-0.680280327796936,
-0.36049965023994446,
-0.7759115695953369,
-0.37569233775138855,
0.1366545408964157,
0.4906015992164612,
-1.0064103603363037,
0.5127554535865784,
0.2445356547832489,
-0.2590751647949219,
-0.664643406867981,
-0.027785656973719597,
0.5779948830604553,
0.5184460282325745,
0.394231915473938,
0.18497905135154724,
-0.3827074468135834,
-0.6992858052253723,
-0.7832366824150085,
-0.30329957604408264,
-0.16251474618911743,
0.1597159057855606,
0.5258554816246033,
-0.13663621246814728,
0.43967410922050476,
-0.5011911392211914,
-0.2389373779296875,
-0.19183340668678284,
0.36191511154174805,
-0.4427536427974701,
0.5685936808586121,
0.6699010729789734,
-0.4316886365413666,
-0.7371184825897217,
-0.5285669565200806,
-0.6971893906593323,
-0.3376922905445099,
-0.5571719408035278,
0.09171338379383087,
0.38328874111175537,
0.6775861978530884,
-0.5846524834632874,
0.7787198424339294,
0.3991912007331848,
-0.4516259729862213,
0.8051789999008179,
0.024967264384031296,
0.37442418932914734,
-1.0638172626495361,
-0.02033255808055401,
0.0007239073165692389,
-0.26668581366539,
-0.45364299416542053,
0.3945339024066925,
-0.18532612919807434,
-0.21949118375778198,
-0.05420742928981781,
0.528193473815918,
-0.3687700629234314,
0.23385827243328094,
-0.6086353659629822,
-0.06650415062904358,
-0.01242645364254713,
0.2754564881324768,
-0.38643601536750793,
0.9867189526557922,
0.42605772614479065,
-0.16058717668056488,
0.10720867663621902,
0.09728579223155975,
-0.07909329980611801,
0.5322210788726807,
-0.5229189395904541,
0.34747856855392456,
-0.2103928029537201,
0.6073037981987,
-1.3546674251556396,
-0.346547394990921,
0.23719635605812073,
-0.8361284732818604,
0.3708392083644867,
-0.1521962285041809,
-0.4669111669063568,
-0.35708674788475037,
-0.5362207293510437,
-0.1060844212770462,
0.43632227182388306,
-0.8570189476013184,
0.7088925838470459,
0.06319442391395569,
-0.017015568912029266,
-0.6959143280982971,
-0.6072762608528137,
0.6524022817611694,
-0.3787704408168793,
-0.3678819239139557,
0.13295120000839233,
-0.07241134345531464,
-0.3566942811012268,
0.08407008647918701,
-0.04628652706742287,
0.22626031935214996,
0.41757267713546753,
0.26676997542381287,
0.3989224135875702,
-0.20847316086292267,
-0.06796715408563614,
0.12961123883724213,
-0.11544898897409439,
0.27393144369125366,
-0.43061336874961853,
0.37106040120124817,
0.2513068914413452,
-0.44864150881767273,
-0.6533779501914978,
0.535965085029602,
0.49694934487342834,
0.14436854422092438,
0.8223211765289307,
0.6925441026687622,
-0.5260342955589294,
-0.5759982466697693,
-0.6530219912528992,
-0.3061281144618988,
-0.5118288993835449,
0.21331378817558289,
-0.02339053712785244,
-0.5085965394973755,
0.3249168395996094,
0.2183028757572174,
0.0699012503027916,
0.37957248091697693,
0.13912653923034668,
-0.1269475221633911,
1.1310173273086548,
0.3619232773780823,
-0.2433585524559021,
0.42040643095970154,
0.0010395932476967573,
0.3529050052165985,
-0.6681643724441528,
0.10597137361764908,
-0.7163073420524597,
-0.1205286905169487,
-0.38271820545196533,
-0.13479360938072205,
0.3667313754558563,
-0.13172797858715057,
0.1290079951286316,
0.22200269997119904,
-0.5663777589797974,
0.7391898036003113,
0.49221840500831604,
-0.018475649878382683,
0.1758328229188919,
0.10283861309289932,
0.030079079791903496,
-0.03014053776860237,
-0.35197120904922485,
-0.9196743369102478,
1.4403196573257446,
0.15844649076461792,
0.5436947345733643,
-0.2892524003982544,
0.6784947514533997,
0.5905004739761353,
0.33748453855514526,
-0.49227795004844666,
0.9357268214225769,
-0.6173261404037476,
-0.2808089554309845,
-0.037376921623945236,
-0.26748886704444885,
-0.5980281829833984,
0.2741689682006836,
-0.283075213432312,
-0.614621639251709,
-0.33716896176338196,
0.1510685533285141,
-0.3458389937877655,
0.4990580976009369,
-0.60777348279953,
0.5542088150978088,
-0.026894306764006615,
-0.5248043537139893,
-0.035591427236795425,
-0.19105124473571777,
0.2885453999042511,
-0.011381381191313267,
-0.1380748599767685,
0.15916159749031067,
0.24184517562389374,
0.5913684368133545,
-0.1843360960483551,
0.4857480525970459,
-0.11312351375818253,
0.08248750865459442,
0.551811695098877,
0.21124282479286194,
0.7733570337295532,
0.17529839277267456,
-0.052411243319511414,
0.04974082112312317,
-0.5805603265762329,
-0.40518918633461,
-0.2824462056159973,
1.0202977657318115,
-0.5853337049484253,
-1.030522346496582,
-0.46631455421447754,
-0.4033617079257965,
-0.07483021169900894,
0.053560830652713776,
0.5817383527755737,
0.11705181002616882,
-0.19709771871566772,
0.13559430837631226,
0.6192205548286438,
-0.36498895287513733,
0.5816624164581299,
0.2767544090747833,
0.05147363245487213,
-0.2409486323595047,
0.966005802154541,
0.0884646326303482,
0.09437064826488495,
-0.14033745229244232,
0.12913358211517334,
-0.19843220710754395,
-0.7101831436157227,
-0.49867361783981323,
0.012032409198582172,
-0.744930624961853,
0.07416456192731857,
-0.9169976115226746,
-0.3071587085723877,
-0.7745198607444763,
-0.6117509007453918,
-0.0970507562160492,
-0.35455042123794556,
-0.6102935671806335,
-0.21809503436088562,
-0.10958258807659149,
0.49515026807785034,
0.22452907264232635,
0.4106893539428711,
-0.2533280849456787,
0.19411571323871613,
0.29774221777915955,
-0.11604676395654678,
0.018951980397105217,
-0.6321630477905273,
0.031359124928712845,
-0.21835628151893616,
-0.34500622749328613,
-0.6481609344482422,
0.3394106924533844,
-0.04083184152841568,
0.4933120906352997,
0.5051543116569519,
0.1076967641711235,
0.5086104869842529,
-0.2308347225189209,
1.1320897340774536,
-0.2708236575126648,
-0.8385162353515625,
0.45605018734931946,
-0.45006266236305237,
0.17004264891147614,
0.47606056928634644,
0.3075965940952301,
-0.1005706638097763,
-0.8465869426727295,
-0.7001288533210754,
-0.9184730052947998,
0.4638534188270569,
0.21121807396411896,
0.2142220139503479,
0.12548208236694336,
0.6791067123413086,
0.060964349657297134,
0.2814655005931854,
-0.7522551417350769,
-0.15849712491035461,
-0.12818175554275513,
-0.41268980503082275,
-0.10153340548276901,
-0.15811054408550262,
-0.05785262957215309,
0.06185675039887428,
0.8290953040122986,
-0.08311304450035095,
0.06374070793390274,
0.19950686395168304,
0.18747153878211975,
-0.03946232050657272,
-0.002371752867475152,
0.47827214002609253,
-0.10641314089298248,
0.2404504269361496,
0.3367314040660858,
0.003497580299153924,
-0.6207596659660339,
0.05786283686757088,
0.2797650694847107,
-0.4878869652748108,
0.04626236855983734,
0.5093470215797424,
0.4742487668991089,
-0.4559975266456604,
-0.7198383808135986,
0.5355175137519836,
-0.19935652613639832,
-0.09448844194412231,
-0.7433336973190308,
0.36997145414352417,
-0.3487390875816345,
-0.06219817325472832,
0.5751027464866638,
0.2016480267047882,
0.2442944198846817,
-0.5200668573379517,
0.2545369863510132,
0.7730165123939514,
-0.15958833694458008,
-0.33460962772369385,
1.0194518566131592,
-0.04855659604072571,
-0.31135112047195435,
0.5222938656806946,
-0.05330955609679222,
-0.769763171672821,
0.9026508927345276,
0.5103979110717773,
1.1738430261611938,
-0.45720207691192627,
0.16072730720043182,
0.20734179019927979,
0.5025201439857483,
-0.08241308480501175,
-0.16232602298259735,
0.1401696801185608,
-0.38749855756759644,
0.04693673923611641,
-0.5079569220542908,
-0.37288665771484375,
0.7699503302574158,
-0.31708958745002747,
0.269317626953125,
-0.6423284411430359,
0.11789533495903015,
0.016748376190662384,
-0.08628519624471664,
-0.2092578262090683,
0.2328948974609375,
0.2376294583082199,
0.3505035638809204,
-0.8212687373161316,
0.5865617990493774,
0.8414488434791565,
-0.15295560657978058,
-0.5513166189193726,
0.8933559656143188,
0.4058332145214081,
-0.4723968505859375,
0.03291526064276695,
0.34707653522491455,
-0.28454330563545227,
0.08117993921041489,
-0.7266939282417297,
-0.2999177575111389,
0.6515150666236877,
0.08264109492301941,
0.003313749795779586,
-0.05774172395467758,
0.16829551756381989,
0.7249172925949097,
-0.2102777659893036,
0.029750723391771317,
0.5017071962356567,
0.490749329328537,
-0.056740373373031616,
-0.09287538379430771,
-0.008209722116589546,
-0.20675086975097656,
-0.20703956484794617,
-0.1410481482744217,
-0.670509934425354,
1.030297040939331,
-0.008993669413030148,
-0.3737303614616394,
0.17002224922180176,
0.41589364409446716,
-0.04702010005712509,
0.46287885308265686,
0.26063302159309387,
0.5487202405929565,
0.45983362197875977,
-0.201811283826828,
0.932267427444458,
-0.1776541769504547,
-0.08863365650177002,
0.8764991164207458,
-0.18516013026237488,
0.50938481092453,
0.4061046838760376,
0.06674634665250778,
0.21345821022987366,
0.37066540122032166,
-0.3176652491092682,
0.054429791867733,
0.23867489397525787,
-0.6088896989822388,
-0.22026509046554565,
0.038016896694898605,
-0.026792090386152267,
0.6088875532150269,
0.3915655016899109,
-0.4258395731449127,
0.051989682018756866,
0.26235365867614746,
0.40035656094551086,
0.7274627089500427,
-0.249745711684227,
0.6556422114372253,
-0.17189756035804749,
-1.0398623943328857,
0.3779076337814331,
0.201722651720047,
0.7552812099456787,
-0.5259095430374146,
-0.19298119843006134,
-0.43959417939186096,
0.4038339853286743,
-0.12916357815265656,
-0.5351451635360718,
0.24432244896888733,
0.34748032689094543,
0.20983605086803436,
-0.19715994596481323,
0.9777166247367859,
-0.42710861563682556,
-0.4528658390045166,
0.10734663158655167,
-0.03566901385784149,
0.04373779892921448,
0.0167123693972826,
-0.4112406373023987,
-0.08157099038362503,
-0.05768588185310364,
-0.520536482334137,
0.48689913749694824,
0.061423398554325104,
0.18872782588005066,
0.4696630537509918,
0.7217799425125122,
0.11089412122964859,
0.030104808509349823,
-0.3954058289527893,
0.7175273895263672,
-0.23530012369155884,
-0.5003935098648071,
-0.923716127872467,
0.25078240036964417,
0.01905127242207527,
-0.22227352857589722,
1.281534194946289,
0.5449236035346985,
0.7589136958122253,
0.05254486948251724,
1.1963683366775513,
0.33499351143836975,
0.44435548782348633,
-0.5185965299606323,
0.9729747176170349,
-0.5679212212562561,
0.5283230543136597,
-0.4976614713668823,
-0.6402712464332581,
-0.36834320425987244,
0.6349958777427673,
-0.0992359146475792,
-0.08725853264331818,
0.5602948069572449,
0.580425500869751,
0.12909312546253204,
0.01595473848283291,
0.3856557011604309,
0.15962354838848114,
0.6434540152549744,
0.33268144726753235,
0.8195894360542297,
-0.6964277625083923,
0.6620132327079773,
-0.04176992177963257,
-0.06251915544271469,
-0.14214476943016052,
-0.6884128451347351,
-1.27799654006958,
-0.4243873357772827,
-0.4742429554462433,
-0.6184902787208557,
0.4503394663333893,
0.5515413284301758,
0.05690433084964752,
-0.7418977618217468,
0.18068595230579376,
-0.2903592586517334,
0.12754656374454498,
-0.037544526159763336,
-0.2920975089073181,
0.5672562718391418,
-0.04149240255355835,
-0.9937521815299988,
0.7736099362373352,
0.15459847450256348,
0.3858385980129242,
-0.6756131649017334,
0.31540173292160034,
-0.18636751174926758,
0.7197592258453369,
0.04894690960645676,
0.21259805560112,
-0.5513140559196472,
-0.4588261842727661,
-0.190381720662117,
-0.2906830906867981,
-0.2848638594150543,
0.6678113341331482,
-0.7375918030738831,
0.26485517621040344,
0.39447829127311707,
0.792597234249115,
-0.07885636389255524,
0.19212940335273743,
0.251720130443573,
-0.7925606369972229,
0.14422518014907837,
0.2955367863178253,
0.2266773134469986,
0.3630000948905945,
-0.8605000376701355,
0.37434467673301697,
0.5004112720489502,
-0.6662764549255371,
-1.1290026903152466,
-0.008744610473513603,
-0.21360377967357635,
-0.6818946003913879,
0.970493495464325,
-0.5192391872406006,
-0.07654634118080139,
-0.013955055736005306,
-0.19488142430782318,
0.16953392326831818,
-0.3108740448951721,
1.34732186794281,
0.9883133769035339,
0.05322946235537529,
0.06383288651704788,
-0.492779016494751,
0.6804283261299133,
0.4299081861972809,
-0.9959394335746765,
-0.09328816831111908,
0.5188341736793518,
0.08459324389696121,
0.05698779225349426,
0.34904277324676514,
0.027078716084361076,
0.23835720121860504,
0.3106449246406555,
-0.1251239776611328,
-0.24856048822402954,
-0.623101532459259,
-0.36643001437187195,
0.40095609426498413,
-0.395022988319397,
-0.20721139013767242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00402v1 | Investigating Bias Representations in Llama 2 Chat via Activation Steering | 2024-02-01T07:48:50 | 2024-02-01T07:48:50 | Dawn Lu, Nina Rimsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address the challenge of societal bias in Large Language Models (LLMs),
focusing on the Llama 2 7B Chat model. As LLMs are increasingly integrated into
decision-making processes with substantial societal impact, it becomes
imperative to ensure these models do not reinforce existing biases. Our
approach employs activation steering to probe for and mitigate biases related
to gender, race, and religion. This method manipulates model activations to
direct responses towards or away from biased outputs, utilizing steering
vectors derived from the StereoSet dataset and custom GPT4 generated gender
bias prompts. Our findings reveal inherent gender bias in Llama 2 7B Chat,
persisting even after Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). We
also observe a predictable negative correlation between bias and the model's
tendency to refuse responses. Significantly, our study uncovers that RLHF tends
to increase the similarity in the model's representation of different forms of
societal biases, which raises questions about the model's nuanced understanding
of different forms of bias. This work also provides valuable insights into
effective red-teaming strategies for LLMs using activation steering,
particularly emphasizing the importance of integrating a refusal vector. | [
-0.4033232033252716,
-0.6775279641151428,
0.36940276622772217,
0.491515576839447,
-0.15043507516384125,
0.36147525906562805,
-0.2643803060054779,
-0.6833466291427612,
0.23658356070518494,
0.39670103788375854,
-0.8605786561965942,
-0.19600674510002136,
-0.8402230739593506,
0.07668319344520569,
-0.3237195611000061,
0.931754469871521,
0.09356828778982162,
0.33114317059516907,
-0.01849553734064102,
-0.06876616925001144,
-0.8067710399627686,
-0.5393279790878296,
-0.6376270055770874,
-0.837603747844696,
0.5097659230232239,
0.3704516589641571,
0.6035842895507812,
0.41601383686065674,
0.14921778440475464,
0.21002568304538727,
-0.384902685880661,
0.024916209280490875,
-0.994842529296875,
0.34052592515945435,
-0.10811655223369598,
-0.6460253596305847,
-0.33421406149864197,
0.21756939589977264,
0.5033172965049744,
0.5870248079299927,
-0.12537460029125214,
0.2953731119632721,
0.2542528212070465,
0.4419516921043396,
-0.5192241668701172,
0.3702685534954071,
-0.9404839873313904,
-0.05213021859526634,
-0.11282411217689514,
-0.14240452647209167,
-0.42997103929519653,
-0.18704409897327423,
0.21796463429927826,
-0.49555277824401855,
0.09473341703414917,
0.0444113090634346,
0.49584463238716125,
0.39022520184516907,
-0.6137130856513977,
-0.4740404188632965,
-0.6508995890617371,
0.9402929544448853,
-0.32840126752853394,
0.16015127301216125,
0.532738983631134,
0.19902300834655762,
-0.423004150390625,
-0.08516749739646912,
-0.4818260073661804,
-0.15085288882255554,
0.1424579918384552,
-0.01223054714500904,
-0.14581963419914246,
-0.0402337983250618,
0.22293269634246826,
-0.30773356556892395,
0.007738168351352215,
0.4431989789009094,
-0.5571421384811401,
-0.23161053657531738,
0.605317234992981,
-0.014643535949289799,
0.2228401154279709,
-0.08577951043844223,
-0.424029678106308,
-0.11812049895524979,
-0.9897648692131042,
-0.1691848784685135,
0.6291617155075073,
0.1755933165550232,
-0.25364795327186584,
0.6840062141418457,
-0.11840414255857468,
0.22811652719974518,
0.4241439700126648,
-0.032251209020614624,
0.447539746761322,
0.06081870198249817,
-0.038512490689754486,
0.4707048535346985,
0.5282638669013977,
0.6219022274017334,
0.3166300058364868,
0.14228831231594086,
0.004339931067079306,
0.3750375211238861,
0.3404886722564697,
-0.47774723172187805,
0.29138433933258057,
0.1263691782951355,
-0.5247489809989929,
-0.579972505569458,
-0.26053503155708313,
-0.7972375750541687,
-0.7982083559036255,
-0.19933758676052094,
0.022007565945386887,
-0.019352803006768227,
-0.6130273342132568,
-0.20568598806858063,
-0.2532937526702881,
0.5739417672157288,
0.36679279804229736,
-1.0550209283828735,
0.010606286115944386,
0.7916311621665955,
0.5301613211631775,
-0.3150100111961365,
-0.1714712530374527,
-0.2552318274974823,
0.271533340215683,
-0.36900636553764343,
0.6058326959609985,
-0.7363207340240479,
-0.5596805214881897,
0.12660861015319824,
-0.2018977701663971,
0.234906867146492,
-0.7241442203521729,
0.4260806143283844,
-0.6949822306632996,
-0.003448921488597989,
-0.6642537117004395,
-0.1619010716676712,
-0.28260141611099243,
0.2684570550918579,
-0.5125696063041687,
1.1242945194244385,
-0.2806957960128784,
-0.8128414154052734,
0.6064971089363098,
-0.7739722728729248,
-0.14766986668109894,
-0.15036733448505402,
-0.49529922008514404,
-0.31002387404441833,
0.10755838453769684,
0.3369045555591583,
0.23398709297180176,
-0.2911095917224884,
0.3906116187572479,
-0.477743536233902,
-0.3299233317375183,
0.23748046159744263,
-0.46009984612464905,
0.679401695728302,
-0.17670418322086334,
-0.7860214710235596,
0.3598906993865967,
-0.30782350897789,
-0.5214091539382935,
0.22799402475357056,
-0.2575860023498535,
-0.39613720774650574,
0.2201986461877823,
-0.190264031291008,
0.20148396492004395,
0.025757480412721634,
-0.4001961946487427,
0.1195879802107811,
-0.3258005976676941,
0.3805849254131317,
1.1048420667648315,
-0.052430134266614914,
0.836327850818634,
-0.18619418144226074,
0.5430790185928345,
0.13922522962093353,
0.06602705270051956,
0.2487483024597168,
-0.7732006311416626,
-0.7531982064247131,
-0.10013137757778168,
-0.05129183456301689,
0.3815156817436218,
-0.7247289419174194,
0.06355483829975128,
-0.21209260821342468,
-0.2567659318447113,
-0.5571035146713257,
0.22091403603553772,
0.3975909352302551,
0.3675265908241272,
0.21716204285621643,
-0.4039752185344696,
-0.5509739518165588,
-1.1149259805679321,
-0.14152349531650543,
-0.5276842713356018,
-0.014528338797390461,
0.28596293926239014,
0.5339869856834412,
-0.4088485538959503,
0.9719569683074951,
-0.08361080288887024,
-0.2566888630390167,
-0.5776660442352295,
0.37367257475852966,
0.015074393711984158,
0.2567901611328125,
0.5312845706939697,
-0.8084580302238464,
-0.015227028168737888,
-0.18729566037654877,
-0.7182685136795044,
-0.5252361297607422,
-0.03580605983734131,
-0.3993352949619293,
0.25360211730003357,
0.4379437267780304,
-0.4400883615016937,
0.6353293657302856,
0.7999882102012634,
-0.4336206316947937,
0.43459367752075195,
0.33820676803588867,
0.08345648646354675,
-0.5830869674682617,
-0.2982510030269623,
0.03366848826408386,
-0.035439033061265945,
-0.5794460773468018,
-0.37077009677886963,
-0.05363447591662407,
0.3728335201740265,
-0.5456556081771851,
0.4853702187538147,
-0.5533806681632996,
-0.3956802189350128,
-0.41732946038246155,
0.008096535690128803,
-0.40580856800079346,
0.44841036200523376,
0.27803125977516174,
0.8382602334022522,
0.18381306529045105,
-0.6141717433929443,
0.029838435351848602,
0.45590969920158386,
-0.26121583580970764,
0.4108741283416748,
-0.6838058233261108,
0.28336337208747864,
-0.4482753276824951,
0.617218017578125,
-0.9895702600479126,
-0.21278205513954163,
0.6177706718444824,
-0.4708387553691864,
0.07208748906850815,
-0.3195401132106781,
-0.17629049718379974,
-0.25524792075157166,
-0.3233819901943207,
0.5673568844795227,
0.5252348780632019,
-0.5560581088066101,
0.6147114634513855,
0.7932261228561401,
-0.19804085791110992,
-0.7637175917625427,
-0.62623131275177,
-0.12836870551109314,
-0.3862248659133911,
-0.41876399517059326,
0.2255595475435257,
0.22020232677459717,
-0.3918379843235016,
-0.4417923092842102,
-0.08657462149858475,
0.30186158418655396,
0.030971335247159004,
0.6639571785926819,
0.3028661608695984,
0.2331031858921051,
0.0005917259259149432,
0.3752268850803375,
-0.016899341717362404,
0.3826218545436859,
-0.014082877896726131,
0.9456649422645569,
0.1968892514705658,
-0.597424328327179,
-0.3004223704338074,
0.20535126328468323,
0.5322500467300415,
0.06669801473617554,
0.7187920212745667,
0.5156456232070923,
-0.052189696580171585,
-0.0160254817456007,
-0.7707666158676147,
-0.5292881727218628,
-0.4860072731971741,
0.6043437123298645,
-0.027197036892175674,
-1.0922393798828125,
0.6091079711914062,
-0.08266191929578781,
0.1996425986289978,
0.19269981980323792,
1.1031347513198853,
-0.14572714269161224,
1.0246456861495972,
0.45054885745048523,
-0.35509949922561646,
0.6386149525642395,
-0.19594351947307587,
-0.14317545294761658,
-1.0093636512756348,
-0.5085901618003845,
-0.3469201624393463,
-0.6840090155601501,
-0.4799083471298218,
-0.7390346527099609,
0.429004967212677,
-0.09865064918994904,
-0.4735623002052307,
-0.16324150562286377,
-0.2980540096759796,
0.35052186250686646,
0.48047977685928345,
0.17916293442249298,
0.10642553120851517,
0.20088091492652893,
-0.03503314033150673,
-0.13541719317436218,
-0.6510111689567566,
-0.47325289249420166,
1.1411670446395874,
0.6957582831382751,
0.8158606886863708,
0.05588844418525696,
0.5468429923057556,
0.4640205502510071,
0.7485840320587158,
-0.5515550971031189,
0.6112722158432007,
0.5998241305351257,
-0.8010804653167725,
-0.19751305878162384,
-0.25760185718536377,
-0.9744264483451843,
0.38168641924858093,
-0.2612631916999817,
-0.7519803047180176,
0.35250920057296753,
0.2035752236843109,
0.18288373947143555,
0.1312894970178604,
-0.5858317613601685,
0.3133883476257324,
-0.1278311163187027,
-0.4749396741390228,
-0.44367077946662903,
-0.5609861016273499,
0.6142898797988892,
0.18531858921051025,
0.4457276463508606,
-0.3788370192050934,
-0.03224041685461998,
0.9353194236755371,
0.07459849864244461,
1.4814850091934204,
-0.2618737816810608,
-0.3999299705028534,
0.22394657135009766,
0.21209855377674103,
0.5560404658317566,
0.12449342757463455,
-0.161495640873909,
0.5188397169113159,
-0.6286128163337708,
-0.33831194043159485,
-0.2931050658226013,
0.5506981015205383,
-1.0688703060150146,
-0.804166316986084,
-0.43441256880760193,
-0.5768160223960876,
-0.17427338659763336,
-0.18079116940498352,
-0.04507609084248543,
0.012688952498137951,
-0.20380255579948425,
-0.16210177540779114,
0.5975087881088257,
-0.3944406509399414,
0.27478256821632385,
0.29271814227104187,
-0.39906343817710876,
-0.18937858939170837,
0.38732317090034485,
-0.2498353272676468,
0.6056793928146362,
-0.10444824397563934,
-0.04046177491545677,
-0.40043342113494873,
-0.3271743357181549,
-0.5095458626747131,
0.29843655228614807,
-0.7285184264183044,
-0.05754951387643814,
-0.4637429416179657,
-0.02286321483552456,
-0.2819094657897949,
0.02947002835571766,
-0.35929277539253235,
-0.2401253581047058,
-0.3632621765136719,
-0.4255872368812561,
0.3234691619873047,
1.1084835529327393,
-0.02393547259271145,
0.4994327425956726,
-0.26231300830841064,
0.24649983644485474,
0.3126012682914734,
-0.012584615498781204,
0.2952827215194702,
-0.6026248931884766,
0.2522168755531311,
0.2905275225639343,
-0.4919736981391907,
-1.3286570310592651,
0.39327865839004517,
-0.23057234287261963,
0.674557626247406,
0.3594551682472229,
-0.12494099885225296,
0.450604110956192,
-0.4133443236351013,
0.8708616495132446,
0.2504901885986328,
-0.8283529877662659,
0.5043115615844727,
-0.47700244188308716,
0.1636875569820404,
0.24453966319561005,
0.47190409898757935,
-0.3926912844181061,
-0.5610644817352295,
-0.4054243266582489,
-0.8307627439498901,
0.7058292627334595,
0.19924956560134888,
0.32981419563293457,
-0.08960189670324326,
0.33467698097229004,
0.06063340976834297,
0.3380604684352875,
-0.8972633481025696,
-0.45531827211380005,
-0.05317523702979088,
0.08355188369750977,
0.22887909412384033,
-0.7068383693695068,
-0.2522587776184082,
-0.14505186676979065,
0.6932846903800964,
-0.13621218502521515,
0.40854060649871826,
0.025872766971588135,
-0.2449376881122589,
-0.19463586807250977,
0.2827589511871338,
0.5857083201408386,
0.5594033598899841,
0.03467005118727684,
-0.06031244248151779,
0.4806385636329651,
-0.5642507076263428,
0.26481232047080994,
-0.41532912850379944,
-0.34557315707206726,
-0.17661376297473907,
0.2844361662864685,
0.8219173550605774,
0.37230026721954346,
-0.4321861267089844,
0.29676008224487305,
0.10868227481842041,
-0.2003960907459259,
-0.10585277527570724,
-0.04745365306735039,
0.08516471832990646,
0.4137195646762848,
0.5623465180397034,
-0.04331250116229057,
0.014574946835637093,
-0.5301291942596436,
-0.20786181092262268,
0.5546307563781738,
-0.616655707359314,
-0.23863209784030914,
0.7167561054229736,
0.5390807390213013,
-0.08206193894147873,
0.5910458564758301,
-0.1492246836423874,
-0.9915660619735718,
0.5538594126701355,
0.535949170589447,
0.6394505500793457,
-0.12552091479301453,
0.41270148754119873,
0.3222622871398926,
0.42149582505226135,
-0.03292958810925484,
0.11893860995769501,
-0.07865957915782928,
-1.0375138521194458,
-0.6127411723136902,
-0.4584241211414337,
-0.446562796831131,
-0.1517227441072464,
-0.6238661408424377,
0.21692828834056854,
-0.3266516625881195,
-0.4723929464817047,
-0.36261576414108276,
-0.3018582761287689,
-0.6184035539627075,
-0.40493205189704895,
0.49074384570121765,
0.7289193868637085,
-0.9912551641464233,
0.6127082705497742,
0.5075072050094604,
-0.1946522295475006,
-0.6542205810546875,
-0.07927703857421875,
0.5141028165817261,
-1.2195268869400024,
1.2771329879760742,
0.23665468394756317,
-0.1743205487728119,
-0.27742716670036316,
-0.756118893623352,
-0.8073357939720154,
1.1088088750839233,
0.32936641573905945,
-0.5834232568740845,
0.08514966070652008,
0.2802436053752899,
0.21992841362953186,
-0.4010423719882965,
0.593014121055603,
0.8420751690864563,
0.5207865238189697,
0.18893447518348694,
-1.2035094499588013,
0.05140978842973709,
0.05498634651303291,
0.21386371552944183,
-0.13660649955272675,
-0.6471839547157288,
0.46139615774154663,
-0.1751318722963333,
-0.05804281309247017,
-0.3026471436023712,
0.906440019607544,
0.7187939882278442,
0.11595535278320312,
0.7865089774131775,
0.20446212589740753,
0.649845540523529,
-0.11531055718660355,
0.9386608004570007,
0.07695063948631287,
0.024081550538539886,
0.983501672744751,
-0.5474965572357178,
0.6934323310852051,
0.8650317192077637,
-0.10303767770528793,
0.6641502976417542,
0.45267966389656067,
0.4333086609840393,
0.3916701376438141,
0.4604836702346802,
-0.30816102027893066,
-0.18345144391059875,
-0.3064805567264557,
-0.39158472418785095,
0.5293483734130859,
0.6235183477401733,
-0.33504483103752136,
-0.14851868152618408,
-0.07039031386375427,
0.12808659672737122,
-0.08980690687894821,
-0.3901337683200836,
0.8310508728027344,
0.08910783380270004,
-0.7718028426170349,
0.3561224937438965,
-0.11813618242740631,
1.0399445295333862,
-0.603300154209137,
-0.15858347713947296,
-0.15799522399902344,
-0.0630464255809784,
-0.08288212865591049,
-0.7158860564231873,
0.089412160217762,
0.04424140229821205,
-0.30982881784439087,
-0.37464189529418945,
0.6885975003242493,
-0.41377249360084534,
-0.25515833497047424,
0.6228517889976501,
0.375246524810791,
-0.09531869739294052,
0.0761200413107872,
-0.6841068267822266,
0.6511194705963135,
0.2742752134799957,
-0.3364400565624237,
0.46752431988716125,
0.059813596308231354,
-0.3775673508644104,
0.9768506288528442,
0.7696877717971802,
0.15645378828048706,
0.31639668345451355,
0.23907363414764404,
0.9415955543518066,
-0.4211091101169586,
-0.4580968916416168,
-0.899164080619812,
0.31093066930770874,
-0.19502754509449005,
-0.07631707936525345,
0.5967011451721191,
0.1344967782497406,
0.7619438767433167,
0.05827464535832405,
0.8656319379806519,
0.09484267234802246,
0.33450108766555786,
-0.3832736611366272,
0.7569392919540405,
-0.09857285767793655,
0.5119026303291321,
-0.21207265555858612,
-0.9172162413597107,
0.11241772770881653,
0.7465206980705261,
-0.6530947089195251,
0.036617621779441833,
0.1938430368900299,
0.9147216081619263,
0.21717694401741028,
0.18163257837295532,
-0.06257902085781097,
0.40908506512641907,
0.5891852974891663,
0.4492490291595459,
1.310693383216858,
-0.044000010937452316,
0.5063963532447815,
0.14711900055408478,
-0.3719913363456726,
-0.23402805626392365,
-0.8706037402153015,
-1.0696332454681396,
-0.28321489691734314,
-0.18387822806835175,
-0.47474387288093567,
0.14253860712051392,
1.2254081964492798,
0.6940575242042542,
-0.6032981872558594,
-0.43475693464279175,
0.20866528153419495,
0.4166887700557709,
-0.004109494853764772,
-0.22410555183887482,
0.0060046156868338585,
-0.21796809136867523,
-0.6855689883232117,
0.18386045098304749,
0.1949177235364914,
-0.08140216022729874,
-0.5434694290161133,
-0.295559823513031,
-0.2009672224521637,
-0.22529561817646027,
0.5927753448486328,
0.20428551733493805,
-0.8914408683776855,
-0.3464343547821045,
-0.27919188141822815,
0.10266758501529694,
-0.033829692751169205,
0.7525495290756226,
-1.012467622756958,
0.12423542141914368,
0.2820684313774109,
0.5114969611167908,
0.5083344578742981,
-0.0328369066119194,
0.9756012558937073,
-0.6116312146186829,
0.4112256169319153,
0.1667683869600296,
0.14220501482486725,
0.32492923736572266,
-0.12518373131752014,
0.3886474370956421,
0.09859169274568558,
-0.5056979060173035,
-0.7982726693153381,
0.2193291187286377,
-0.8964247107505798,
0.044000137597322464,
1.6544780731201172,
0.3770444989204407,
-0.28708910942077637,
-0.2826170027256012,
-0.6268970370292664,
0.2450258880853653,
-0.753954291343689,
0.7986181974411011,
0.5880006551742554,
0.014452180825173855,
-0.09953420609235764,
-0.6776428818702698,
0.5158668160438538,
0.6447591781616211,
-0.5159187316894531,
0.13800758123397827,
0.5293410420417786,
0.35461288690567017,
0.04167766124010086,
0.7001528739929199,
-0.08241970837116241,
0.2271781861782074,
-0.346720427274704,
0.12297875434160233,
0.12693801522254944,
-0.11574217677116394,
-0.273348867893219,
-0.03985390067100525,
0.03555566817522049,
0.02020777203142643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00396v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00396v2 | Efficient Exploration for LLMs | 2024-02-01T07:32:24 | 2024-06-04T18:35:09 | Vikranth Dwaracherla, Seyed Mohammad Asghari, Botao Hao, Benjamin Van Roy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME, stat.ML | We present evidence of substantial benefit from efficient exploration in
gathering human feedback to improve large language models. In our experiments,
an agent sequentially generates queries while fitting a reward model to the
feedback received. Our best-performing agent generates queries using double
Thompson sampling, with uncertainty represented by an epistemic neural network.
Our results demonstrate that efficient exploration enables high levels of
performance with far fewer queries. Further, both uncertainty estimation and
the choice of exploration scheme play critical roles. | [
-0.056227944791316986,
-0.6339070200920105,
0.9549869894981384,
0.15636292099952698,
0.13533662259578705,
0.2611162066459656,
-0.5303313732147217,
-0.5120537281036377,
0.22549918293952942,
0.2509143650531769,
-0.6045404672622681,
-0.46723809838294983,
-0.6993729472160339,
-0.09575759619474411,
-0.15103507041931152,
0.4092314839363098,
-0.005900512915104628,
-0.06602922827005386,
0.0685487911105156,
0.13355088233947754,
0.05805471912026405,
-0.537752091884613,
-1.1683039665222168,
-0.41479048132896423,
0.8347553610801697,
0.34629011154174805,
0.7180560231208801,
0.548359215259552,
0.5199455618858337,
0.3772391974925995,
-0.33709657192230225,
0.5218710899353027,
-0.7663546800613403,
0.5877078175544739,
-0.16829515993595123,
-1.0137969255447388,
-0.06625144183635712,
-0.0692039430141449,
0.5708997249603271,
0.6943721771240234,
-0.6331048607826233,
-0.050684571266174316,
-0.06553590297698975,
0.5682022571563721,
-0.6989011168479919,
0.22802455723285675,
-0.4134795367717743,
0.28709253668785095,
-0.15898917615413666,
-0.5575671195983887,
-0.33135849237442017,
-0.423441618680954,
0.6296458840370178,
-0.9090608358383179,
-0.11896943300962448,
0.02356136217713356,
0.5458544492721558,
0.22773419320583344,
-0.4707478880882263,
-0.49145036935806274,
-0.8716306686401367,
1.0832716226577759,
-0.26366886496543884,
0.35219481587409973,
0.4246487021446228,
0.49882587790489197,
-0.3440449833869934,
-0.9041051268577576,
-0.2148640900850296,
-0.4362793564796448,
0.08002170920372009,
0.10828070342540741,
-0.29678064584732056,
0.3176094591617584,
0.16731633245944977,
0.17570672929286957,
-0.1409580409526825,
0.42291194200515747,
-0.2175438106060028,
-0.363302081823349,
0.94551020860672,
0.35024911165237427,
0.1893058568239212,
0.1084928885102272,
-0.3200492858886719,
-0.32024064660072327,
-0.8312737345695496,
0.46405455470085144,
0.4990573227405548,
0.21263732016086578,
0.3706766366958618,
0.808711588382721,
-0.3499203324317932,
0.8080317974090576,
-0.3616049587726593,
-0.009439508430659771,
-0.21040092408657074,
-0.28677576780319214,
-0.04450760409235954,
-0.3137454390525818,
0.6337486505508423,
0.31326404213905334,
0.15818549692630768,
-0.42028161883354187,
-0.716762900352478,
-0.1453789621591568,
0.28493908047676086,
-0.5980987548828125,
-0.1784340739250183,
0.3946266770362854,
-0.23136872053146362,
-0.28978201746940613,
0.06061916798353195,
-0.6943608522415161,
-0.5479546785354614,
-0.23534750938415527,
0.39453715085983276,
-0.3045896291732788,
-0.3443172872066498,
0.2488144487142563,
-0.5105407238006592,
0.04462653771042824,
0.6828747391700745,
-0.8153808116912842,
0.3375316262245178,
0.5789290070533752,
0.6913032531738281,
-0.2762186527252197,
-0.23817245662212372,
-0.6213549375534058,
0.07341496646404266,
-0.5063759088516235,
0.920166015625,
-0.5068855881690979,
-0.45486000180244446,
0.19068732857704163,
-0.25483375787734985,
0.06143542379140854,
-0.7390760779380798,
0.5294072031974792,
-0.9696036577224731,
0.20426154136657715,
-0.4702843129634857,
-0.7302951812744141,
-0.3384217619895935,
0.36769720911979675,
-0.7474159598350525,
1.3084397315979004,
0.29453733563423157,
-0.3280884325504303,
0.29395079612731934,
-1.07696533203125,
0.08887505531311035,
0.09239423274993896,
0.048043958842754364,
0.13087837398052216,
0.31067946553230286,
0.3785554766654968,
0.27607446908950806,
-0.3108282685279846,
0.13700562715530396,
0.040114421397447586,
-0.570008397102356,
0.6138396859169006,
-0.2384166568517685,
0.5300506949424744,
0.44144394993782043,
-0.4542235732078552,
0.13107451796531677,
-0.4237293004989624,
0.30527904629707336,
0.2367839813232422,
-0.6942538022994995,
-0.34698808193206787,
0.3429744839668274,
-0.1022866815328598,
-0.21039825677871704,
0.2674448788166046,
-0.4266182780265808,
0.32621699571609497,
-0.49520570039749146,
0.27960845828056335,
0.9217955470085144,
0.16260410845279694,
0.5802602171897888,
-0.4654591381549835,
0.963199257850647,
-0.17363548278808594,
-0.12254423648118973,
-0.21281035244464874,
-0.3380190134048462,
-0.8280789852142334,
-0.22467480599880219,
0.48135751485824585,
0.541192352771759,
-0.7248321175575256,
0.2792418897151947,
-0.16306790709495544,
-0.3642573058605194,
-0.7193877100944519,
0.1469220370054245,
0.0936359092593193,
-0.20710965991020203,
0.10833791643381119,
-0.10701139271259308,
-0.45339903235435486,
-0.7454235553741455,
-0.39456209540367126,
-0.2535780370235443,
-0.3158666491508484,
0.666725218296051,
0.03694832697510719,
-0.43183594942092896,
0.9021819233894348,
-0.48626410961151123,
0.11677570641040802,
-0.3102369010448456,
0.0010339382570236921,
0.155270516872406,
0.0993046835064888,
0.1402047872543335,
-0.6567392945289612,
-0.4109119176864624,
-0.19518303871154785,
-0.7725781798362732,
-0.05070728063583374,
-0.20984628796577454,
-0.4277086853981018,
0.08704884350299835,
0.3086621165275574,
-0.8474345803260803,
0.2787149250507355,
0.26373910903930664,
-0.17906524240970612,
-0.02934243343770504,
-0.1635863184928894,
0.0037067679222673178,
-0.6383050680160522,
-0.1640266329050064,
-0.0482180193066597,
-0.5065746903419495,
-0.4470503032207489,
0.4023933708667755,
-0.032277800142765045,
0.31232383847236633,
-0.3136267066001892,
0.44036611914634705,
-0.8652377724647522,
-0.11803412437438965,
-0.3250827193260193,
0.5567260980606079,
-0.19964000582695007,
0.45683562755584717,
-0.04181627184152603,
0.7751694917678833,
0.6628075242042542,
-0.8270205855369568,
0.6899101734161377,
-0.2254323959350586,
-0.3532702326774597,
0.09296946972608566,
-0.6489008665084839,
0.4137488901615143,
-0.12644344568252563,
0.007503274362534285,
-1.1449415683746338,
-0.10867293179035187,
0.11273612082004547,
-0.45893779397010803,
0.4137701392173767,
0.12945720553398132,
-0.5054344534873962,
-0.385722279548645,
-0.6858364343643188,
-0.05626975744962692,
0.4932195246219635,
-0.7892884016036987,
0.42376625537872314,
0.616923987865448,
-0.19602352380752563,
-0.7375770211219788,
-0.5581881999969482,
0.17544211447238922,
-0.1411120891571045,
-0.7080417275428772,
0.12333682924509048,
0.0069576650857925415,
-0.46919772028923035,
0.016404403373599052,
-0.035289738327264786,
0.27223438024520874,
0.3890380263328552,
-0.059865161776542664,
0.031323257833719254,
-0.06574708968400955,
0.28498750925064087,
0.039104267954826355,
0.10325096547603607,
0.3311674892902374,
-0.41694509983062744,
0.6829342246055603,
0.00994801428169012,
-0.3099769949913025,
-0.5239822864532471,
0.3781590461730957,
0.16436512768268585,
0.14850234985351562,
0.36877551674842834,
0.30994775891304016,
-0.3040502071380615,
-0.31443750858306885,
-0.49847346544265747,
-0.4099566340446472,
-0.5069136023521423,
0.5307517051696777,
-0.31169363856315613,
-1.0833685398101807,
0.5399600863456726,
-0.21403512358665466,
0.18004557490348816,
0.5300639867782593,
0.6420605778694153,
-0.2841741740703583,
1.0281530618667603,
0.7181966304779053,
0.0585377998650074,
0.4029146432876587,
-0.5522069334983826,
-0.1381281316280365,
-0.6825822591781616,
-0.38191282749176025,
-0.3552916347980499,
-0.6289125680923462,
-0.5967474579811096,
-0.5651955008506775,
0.4388168156147003,
0.026805967092514038,
0.13468597829341888,
-0.010566888377070427,
-0.5239675045013428,
0.4696500599384308,
1.0897084474563599,
0.26367247104644775,
0.25061795115470886,
0.12772920727729797,
-0.2563495635986328,
-0.158283531665802,
-0.8201412558555603,
-0.5776212215423584,
1.5613367557525635,
0.37244608998298645,
0.9853740930557251,
0.5347352623939514,
0.9196797609329224,
0.17312699556350708,
0.24792592227458954,
-0.9675557017326355,
0.49531224370002747,
0.737086296081543,
-0.6988535523414612,
-0.7629666924476624,
-0.5246772170066833,
-1.3188387155532837,
0.3691771924495697,
-0.1528577357530594,
-0.8508851528167725,
0.08378428965806961,
0.07971985638141632,
-0.7590639591217041,
0.27884000539779663,
-0.7108020186424255,
0.1736997812986374,
-0.2586020231246948,
-0.5352743864059448,
-0.3441019654273987,
-0.6841580867767334,
0.2071763426065445,
0.05420453101396561,
-0.2948278784751892,
0.22072850167751312,
-0.4844415485858917,
0.8086463212966919,
-0.2893187403678894,
0.6356627941131592,
-0.5634137392044067,
-0.09401929378509521,
0.6241910457611084,
0.18825843930244446,
0.9077010750770569,
0.21571125090122223,
-0.059869930148124695,
-0.4081692397594452,
-0.27228277921676636,
-0.29491832852363586,
-0.8330090641975403,
0.42221200466156006,
-0.901117742061615,
-0.8742731809616089,
-0.5208301544189453,
-0.7366354465484619,
-0.2735680341720581,
-0.1544453203678131,
0.1659134030342102,
-0.08492323011159897,
-0.0997258797287941,
0.1167944148182869,
0.7833969593048096,
-0.26012617349624634,
0.5773528814315796,
0.5752776861190796,
-0.318448007106781,
-0.05879700556397438,
0.39781033992767334,
0.28177836537361145,
0.08918200433254242,
0.5992780327796936,
0.13768047094345093,
-0.6716675162315369,
-0.6652673482894897,
-0.4653894007205963,
0.09238730370998383,
-0.4665820002555847,
-0.21374450623989105,
-0.916643500328064,
-0.1065119057893753,
-0.1660102754831314,
0.1382354348897934,
-0.3767181634902954,
-0.6872165203094482,
-0.14505085349082947,
-0.40998774766921997,
0.3578559160232544,
1.031723141670227,
-0.37682363390922546,
0.6946088075637817,
-0.7934055328369141,
-0.05526309832930565,
0.6563511490821838,
0.13126610219478607,
0.002730680163949728,
-0.43162643909454346,
-0.3132376968860626,
0.2625229060649872,
-0.432718962430954,
-0.9163761138916016,
0.4031192362308502,
-0.002324761124327779,
1.1201177835464478,
0.4715018570423126,
-0.15019375085830688,
0.4245903193950653,
-0.12049401551485062,
0.9339640140533447,
-0.18874773383140564,
-0.6143016219139099,
0.5999128222465515,
-0.32396382093429565,
0.06849116832017899,
0.45282796025276184,
0.6410761475563049,
-0.49174201488494873,
-0.2826405465602875,
-0.6374431848526001,
-0.9388017654418945,
0.9138368368148804,
0.19067098200321198,
0.010115200653672218,
0.2002211958169937,
0.5283544063568115,
-0.14338450133800507,
0.22030161321163177,
-0.5779181718826294,
-0.05900397524237633,
0.3438745141029358,
0.16200678050518036,
-0.09957219660282135,
-0.578410267829895,
-0.55295330286026,
-0.1361503154039383,
0.6601893901824951,
-0.01557920966297388,
0.7516269683837891,
0.24791072309017181,
-0.2743030786514282,
-0.35634294152259827,
0.15187470614910126,
0.6246373653411865,
0.7011772990226746,
-0.39938899874687195,
0.24897071719169617,
0.19371579587459564,
-0.24516722559928894,
0.19789893925189972,
0.23519906401634216,
-0.026425350457429886,
-0.05098484456539154,
0.1957850456237793,
0.6919918060302734,
-0.14563532173633575,
-0.9814348220825195,
0.43211162090301514,
-0.2956676781177521,
-0.1250831037759781,
-0.4740230441093445,
0.3305044174194336,
0.31633251905441284,
0.5529963970184326,
0.5528148412704468,
-0.0842369943857193,
0.38714033365249634,
-0.5300835967063904,
0.0006034293910488486,
0.39784494042396545,
-0.3081345558166504,
-0.14626652002334595,
0.4914315640926361,
-0.030273757874965668,
-0.5703904032707214,
0.8125738501548767,
-0.4138350784778595,
-0.5475749373435974,
0.5868884325027466,
0.36766448616981506,
0.615205705165863,
-0.2985324561595917,
0.12949854135513306,
0.20537646114826202,
0.50625079870224,
-0.2326313853263855,
0.6561903357505798,
-0.2671518325805664,
-0.7393719553947449,
-0.5925844311714172,
-0.3385874032974243,
-0.717643141746521,
-0.3082484006881714,
-0.6334012150764465,
0.11844105273485184,
-0.0627921000123024,
-0.3123679459095001,
-0.2963646352291107,
0.1701536476612091,
-0.7676172256469727,
-0.030329514294862747,
0.013084865175187588,
0.9847487807273865,
-0.31156519055366516,
0.6825504302978516,
0.77540123462677,
-0.03814825415611267,
-1.035181999206543,
-0.3742513358592987,
0.09552548825740814,
-1.1176774501800537,
0.6465760469436646,
0.0445997454226017,
-0.2361135631799698,
-0.05343581736087799,
-0.7380772829055786,
-1.1838219165802002,
1.4055601358413696,
0.25877583026885986,
-0.6007252335548401,
-0.07148060947656631,
-0.11032651364803314,
0.6249071955680847,
-0.24053281545639038,
0.6096103191375732,
0.5874472856521606,
0.46488043665885925,
0.10099443793296814,
-0.4793606996536255,
-0.09952768683433533,
-0.2924947142601013,
0.16355392336845398,
0.23266233503818512,
-0.5647010207176208,
0.6576218008995056,
-0.405642569065094,
-0.3669266700744629,
0.19559238851070404,
0.8205674886703491,
0.5553738474845886,
0.3791060745716095,
0.6918861865997314,
0.5217523574829102,
1.2390217781066895,
-0.24296681582927704,
1.4912970066070557,
-0.32287755608558655,
0.3755955696105957,
0.8314781785011292,
-0.09518419951200485,
0.7129881381988525,
0.5266714096069336,
-0.41823962330818176,
0.23060375452041626,
1.1305724382400513,
0.41748401522636414,
0.6147209405899048,
0.7063877582550049,
-0.42530104517936707,
-0.22628021240234375,
-0.12553109228610992,
-0.2804202735424042,
0.5121411085128784,
0.5455771088600159,
-0.2635035812854767,
-0.018054809421300888,
-0.3869188129901886,
0.04596426337957382,
0.004591905977576971,
-0.13840654492378235,
0.7853105068206787,
0.02444407157599926,
-1.0674502849578857,
0.26107099652290344,
0.24550583958625793,
0.8846495151519775,
-0.5948798656463623,
0.07688821107149124,
-0.38746345043182373,
-0.06024670973420143,
0.025142427533864975,
-0.5788580179214478,
-0.021927667781710625,
-0.23630379140377045,
0.2258187085390091,
-0.1733652651309967,
0.6469132304191589,
-0.4912119507789612,
-0.23188789188861847,
0.4361828565597534,
0.930014967918396,
0.3056512475013733,
-0.16108618676662445,
-0.35120439529418945,
-0.2688579857349396,
-0.03327799588441849,
-0.9843785166740417,
0.13812310993671417,
0.6981711983680725,
0.225433349609375,
0.7955256104469299,
0.6795830130577087,
0.316689670085907,
0.3642680048942566,
-0.12348360568284988,
0.9198626279830933,
-0.9590162038803101,
-0.4470510482788086,
-0.8814452886581421,
0.3838890790939331,
-0.23008471727371216,
-0.07425054907798767,
0.681177020072937,
0.6440297365188599,
0.5931276082992554,
0.21540793776512146,
0.8429393768310547,
0.28939399123191833,
0.6794213652610779,
-0.6383495926856995,
0.4895556569099426,
-0.5049011707305908,
0.555268406867981,
0.13149186968803406,
-0.9337923526763916,
-0.22934797406196594,
0.6334333419799805,
-0.027037618681788445,
0.027065949514508247,
0.5711320638656616,
1.0296708345413208,
0.2037161886692047,
0.14782799780368805,
0.22754475474357605,
0.010090314783155918,
0.4250006675720215,
0.7674176096916199,
1.5745561122894287,
-0.16933070123195648,
0.2546146810054779,
-0.27494099736213684,
-0.313284695148468,
-0.20693932473659515,
-0.5884600877761841,
-0.5343104004859924,
-0.1628851294517517,
0.10241798311471939,
-0.2570733428001404,
0.046534355729818344,
1.3315048217773438,
0.8170570135116577,
-0.49374276399612427,
-0.5793837904930115,
0.11313123255968094,
0.22406339645385742,
-0.21127060055732727,
-0.21400000154972076,
0.2890276312828064,
-0.6582545042037964,
-1.1091257333755493,
0.7281269431114197,
0.19445040822029114,
-0.0055239382199943066,
-0.4503322243690491,
-0.2623285949230194,
-0.2682057321071625,
0.11729156970977783,
0.5701944828033447,
0.1364823281764984,
-0.48234081268310547,
-0.11833271384239197,
0.5371494889259338,
-0.25482186675071716,
-0.05808430537581444,
0.9260573983192444,
-0.7065150737762451,
0.6022812724113464,
0.3489133417606354,
1.0736709833145142,
0.9213006496429443,
-0.28171926736831665,
0.751728355884552,
-0.598267138004303,
0.10989309102296829,
0.4293597340583801,
0.3400513827800751,
0.23409846425056458,
-0.6778557896614075,
1.013507604598999,
-0.0435861311852932,
-0.6455946564674377,
-0.8618882894515991,
0.01584630459547043,
-1.0278844833374023,
0.037551674991846085,
1.3611699342727661,
-0.14292339980602264,
-0.1639518141746521,
0.12759968638420105,
-0.1771325170993805,
-0.011009748093783855,
-0.6604206562042236,
0.8110103011131287,
0.83719801902771,
-0.5350320339202881,
-0.05939539149403572,
-0.6641383767127991,
0.3588070273399353,
0.5640751719474792,
-0.618155837059021,
-0.4088091254234314,
0.29315266013145447,
-0.05327518656849861,
0.20784051716327667,
0.9837608337402344,
0.014922753907740116,
0.2245003879070282,
-0.18082411587238312,
0.00986274890601635,
0.10010278970003128,
-0.33544838428497314,
-0.38854092359542847,
0.3497050106525421,
0.5559942722320557,
-0.21570985019207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01771v1 | BlackMamba: Mixture of Experts for State-Space Models | 2024-02-01T07:15:58 | 2024-02-01T07:15:58 | Quentin Anthony, Yury Tokpanov, Paolo Glorioso, Beren Millidge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG | State-space models (SSMs) have recently demonstrated competitive performance
to transformers at large-scale language modeling benchmarks while achieving
linear time and memory complexity as a function of sequence length. Mamba, a
recently released SSM model, shows impressive performance in both language
modeling and long sequence processing tasks. Simultaneously, mixture-of-expert
(MoE) models have shown remarkable performance while significantly reducing the
compute and latency costs of inference at the expense of a larger memory
footprint. In this paper, we present BlackMamba, a novel architecture that
combines the Mamba SSM with MoE to obtain the benefits of both. We demonstrate
that BlackMamba performs competitively against both Mamba and transformer
baselines, and outperforms in inference and training FLOPs. We fully train and
open-source 340M/1.5B and 630M/2.8B BlackMamba models on 300B tokens of a
custom dataset. We show that BlackMamba inherits and combines both of the
benefits of SSM and MoE architectures, combining linear-complexity generation
from SSM with cheap and fast inference from MoE. We release all weights,
checkpoints, and inference code open-source. Inference code at:
https://github.com/Zyphra/BlackMamba | [
-0.5183231830596924,
-0.6767264008522034,
0.5470066666603088,
0.1712997853755951,
-0.2418070137500763,
0.45280683040618896,
-0.27634721994400024,
-0.4115583002567291,
0.5013803839683533,
0.44613027572631836,
-0.12857380509376526,
-0.1756386011838913,
-0.672367513179779,
-0.41133421659469604,
-0.3034425377845764,
0.453368216753006,
0.04213693365454674,
-0.01394503004848957,
-0.292767196893692,
-0.24586617946624756,
-0.5773378610610962,
-0.4907534420490265,
-0.18825533986091614,
-0.38316673040390015,
0.25606465339660645,
0.19657985866069794,
0.8130098581314087,
0.5391251444816589,
0.009068344719707966,
0.3285883963108063,
-0.2555837631225586,
0.5951834321022034,
-0.39961880445480347,
0.1886567771434784,
-0.29927384853363037,
-0.5675467848777771,
-0.48146286606788635,
-0.22218520939350128,
0.4157988131046295,
0.6600866317749023,
-0.5364834070205688,
0.038119494915008545,
-0.23051300644874573,
0.43270787596702576,
-1.0603885650634766,
0.1850370615720749,
-0.768992006778717,
-0.013677641749382019,
-0.19154223799705505,
-0.014111295342445374,
-0.6273024082183838,
-0.13009724020957947,
-0.14695854485034943,
-0.5002859234809875,
-0.039896927773952484,
0.18971748650074005,
0.8434349894523621,
0.6434991955757141,
-0.42743682861328125,
-0.0268086027354002,
-1.1252738237380981,
0.9164401292800903,
-0.7529994249343872,
0.23656684160232544,
0.0887506902217865,
0.7810811400413513,
-0.29988375306129456,
-0.30229267477989197,
-0.6235367655754089,
0.2871333956718445,
0.20356550812721252,
0.2803921401500702,
-0.15000009536743164,
-0.11059171706438065,
-0.2802860140800476,
0.5498946309089661,
-0.2755378782749176,
0.2009853720664978,
-0.7497475743293762,
-0.10023240000009537,
0.6968626379966736,
0.2508314251899719,
-0.03310937061905861,
-0.18934519588947296,
-0.4423312544822693,
0.056155916303396225,
-0.45517393946647644,
-0.1923414021730423,
0.2505185902118683,
0.2037697434425354,
-0.13272301852703094,
0.580887496471405,
-0.05931425094604492,
0.7773226499557495,
0.01965952292084694,
-0.1245909035205841,
0.13804666697978973,
0.04694763571023941,
-0.3106871545314789,
-0.06278684735298157,
0.8469266891479492,
0.06434798985719681,
0.00036251716664992273,
-0.39285627007484436,
-0.20607344806194305,
0.1378992199897766,
0.6880752444267273,
-0.5782424807548523,
-0.34395331144332886,
0.2018774300813675,
-0.36885568499565125,
0.023926658555865288,
0.08881261199712753,
-0.9499374628067017,
-0.4255128800868988,
-0.3890431225299835,
0.662990391254425,
-0.45675134658813477,
-0.6922560930252075,
0.21349629759788513,
-0.10505146533250809,
0.024553971365094185,
0.3021610677242279,
-0.6686148643493652,
0.4191075563430786,
0.8373085856437683,
0.9194796681404114,
-0.27579694986343384,
-0.00014324868971016258,
-0.17946071922779083,
0.31992489099502563,
-0.5003468990325928,
0.5702465176582336,
-0.7323857545852661,
-0.6801676154136658,
-0.4279465973377228,
-0.5416121482849121,
-0.1868738830089569,
-0.6240533590316772,
0.13947437703609467,
-0.553170382976532,
-0.012295106425881386,
0.19260290265083313,
-0.7551586627960205,
-0.3692599833011627,
-0.2322520911693573,
-0.5341017842292786,
1.422208547592163,
0.275091290473938,
-0.2616308033466339,
0.4471106231212616,
-0.5855520963668823,
-0.4706631302833557,
0.241451233625412,
-0.2097947597503662,
-0.3656551241874695,
0.30524933338165283,
0.10794777423143387,
0.7186118364334106,
-0.2048969268798828,
0.41770920157432556,
-0.5825595259666443,
-0.4324871301651001,
0.15502172708511353,
0.12205937504768372,
0.5330426096916199,
0.617284893989563,
-0.3380376100540161,
0.038550376892089844,
-1.070650577545166,
-0.31441470980644226,
0.2978646457195282,
-0.2629619836807251,
-0.5639142394065857,
0.3816549777984619,
-0.42295464873313904,
0.3690169155597687,
0.21024921536445618,
-0.43512827157974243,
0.03722415491938591,
-0.1398652195930481,
0.4685312509536743,
0.673207700252533,
-0.01853691227734089,
0.701762318611145,
-0.06509652733802795,
0.6768018007278442,
0.3412277400493622,
-0.10207998752593994,
-0.31359270215034485,
-0.7206514477729797,
-0.9321900606155396,
-0.737574577331543,
0.31508293747901917,
0.4007512032985687,
-0.8210546970367432,
0.8006153702735901,
-0.21772027015686035,
-0.8953478336334229,
-1.0988938808441162,
0.10619350522756577,
0.16456590592861176,
0.506659746170044,
0.6717580556869507,
-0.3312239944934845,
-0.46770957112312317,
-1.0844846963882446,
0.14173384010791779,
0.05349376052618027,
0.031883157789707184,
0.48375779390335083,
0.31814780831336975,
-0.11143531650304794,
1.0639077425003052,
-0.5687532424926758,
0.23053286969661713,
-0.23713117837905884,
-0.11132732778787613,
0.17174923419952393,
0.43913236260414124,
0.6694003939628601,
-0.37934041023254395,
-0.05272294580936432,
-0.020470941439270973,
-0.677226722240448,
0.026100503280758858,
0.03480907902121544,
-0.3446347415447235,
0.00942583754658699,
0.21275289356708527,
-0.6948110461235046,
0.13541722297668457,
0.6286735534667969,
-0.017338920384645462,
0.3133540153503418,
-0.29769980907440186,
-0.15529760718345642,
-1.393891453742981,
0.005611715838313103,
0.03930876776576042,
-0.15619172155857086,
-0.48409631848335266,
0.47042736411094666,
0.1344699114561081,
-0.21502266824245453,
-0.3514876365661621,
0.6839461326599121,
-0.41465115547180176,
-0.3106105327606201,
-0.4042728841304779,
0.05085337907075882,
-0.12089025974273682,
0.6816606521606445,
-0.21859797835350037,
0.8510222434997559,
0.4954390823841095,
-0.7203415036201477,
0.05487844720482826,
0.04233751818537712,
-0.6630136966705322,
0.3627925217151642,
-0.4695334732532501,
0.195126011967659,
0.03614693880081177,
0.27242931723594666,
-1.1022170782089233,
-0.1256328970193863,
0.1680438071489334,
-0.3406580686569214,
0.31252261996269226,
-0.3027462959289551,
-0.5679382681846619,
-0.5087229013442993,
0.2670096158981323,
0.1825401782989502,
0.8063135147094727,
-0.34466472268104553,
0.9790925979614258,
0.713522732257843,
-0.2311929166316986,
-0.6425402760505676,
-0.9104613065719604,
0.17069591581821442,
0.04658515751361847,
-0.4814285933971405,
0.014463693834841251,
0.21733316779136658,
-0.12451937794685364,
-0.06295201927423477,
-0.23672635853290558,
-0.06296480447053909,
0.4535839557647705,
0.4622262120246887,
0.38623297214508057,
-0.4723007082939148,
-0.2794716954231262,
0.5730354189872742,
-0.158005490899086,
-0.07283113151788712,
-0.41041380167007446,
0.6668106913566589,
0.04360716789960861,
-0.33132579922676086,
-0.13206623494625092,
0.2273789644241333,
0.42066365480422974,
-0.47912362217903137,
1.1609779596328735,
0.2723146378993988,
-0.22163215279579163,
-0.49300912022590637,
-0.568038821220398,
0.2101745754480362,
-0.4454506039619446,
0.15906672179698944,
-0.4130804240703583,
-0.8020164966583252,
0.40915945172309875,
-0.061376653611660004,
0.318392276763916,
0.3632235527038574,
0.9114685654640198,
0.03829869255423546,
0.7808071970939636,
0.23046420514583588,
-0.19761840999126434,
0.20463013648986816,
-0.2062133252620697,
0.34038597345352173,
-0.4817070960998535,
-0.40428251028060913,
-0.5354108810424805,
-0.6817289590835571,
-0.17900140583515167,
-0.8414822220802307,
0.028260597959160805,
-0.027851849794387817,
-0.09265539050102234,
0.39466404914855957,
-0.3197212219238281,
0.49266743659973145,
0.5436004400253296,
0.2857329845428467,
0.12059315294027328,
-0.07877634465694427,
-0.42390692234039307,
0.1258208006620407,
-0.9525242447853088,
-0.5057554244995117,
1.1015360355377197,
0.2828187942504883,
0.8716803193092346,
0.08057330548763275,
0.6339957118034363,
0.13805682957172394,
0.18904225528240204,
-0.6612260937690735,
0.8255265355110168,
-0.1253288835287094,
-0.7949705719947815,
0.10451063513755798,
-0.6127042770385742,
-0.7386461496353149,
0.6114905476570129,
-0.23347562551498413,
-0.45477697253227234,
0.26694440841674805,
0.1640617996454239,
-0.40101972222328186,
0.57213294506073,
-0.8189487457275391,
0.3328496813774109,
-0.001750598894432187,
-0.1408081352710724,
-0.7029523253440857,
-0.6551055908203125,
0.5731121897697449,
-0.1890125721693039,
0.12381622940301895,
-0.3011743128299713,
-0.23835258185863495,
0.5111594796180725,
-0.3555295169353485,
0.6738796830177307,
-0.4342688024044037,
0.07390978932380676,
0.23070234060287476,
0.31069934368133545,
0.04683850333094597,
-0.26868125796318054,
-0.33622485399246216,
0.41867223381996155,
-0.663754403591156,
-0.7429583072662354,
-0.4371510148048401,
0.6732293367385864,
-1.0383576154708862,
-0.48675641417503357,
-0.08003660291433334,
-0.7542034387588501,
-0.3493579030036926,
0.17974159121513367,
-0.21208743751049042,
0.311085969209671,
0.08269844949245453,
0.42601537704467773,
0.5740105509757996,
-0.21112899482250214,
0.25768110156059265,
0.47603029012680054,
-0.16090764105319977,
-0.45877936482429504,
0.8475576043128967,
0.08644481003284454,
0.2594955861568451,
0.37338513135910034,
-0.06094029173254967,
-0.015997866168618202,
-0.7233176231384277,
-0.6452925801277161,
0.06730331480503082,
-0.5613475441932678,
-0.1314866691827774,
-0.7647891044616699,
-0.22537922859191895,
0.029135996475815773,
-0.2384670227766037,
-0.7430245280265808,
-0.7717206478118896,
-0.07026489078998566,
-0.23935863375663757,
0.05270473659038544,
0.727024495601654,
0.19011478126049042,
0.4640815258026123,
-0.6769829988479614,
0.3782975673675537,
0.08773791044950485,
0.19485916197299957,
0.4367466866970062,
-0.37625133991241455,
-0.580638587474823,
-0.08592399209737778,
-0.4485463500022888,
-0.6059797406196594,
0.13461259007453918,
-0.04824679717421532,
0.8434484601020813,
0.6114324927330017,
-0.056208156049251556,
0.8677470088005066,
-0.4931771457195282,
0.8496467471122742,
0.06215633079409599,
-0.8556752800941467,
0.30229154229164124,
-0.1445646584033966,
0.12310611456632614,
0.3321031928062439,
0.418954998254776,
-0.05930888280272484,
-0.9706694483757019,
-0.4737154245376587,
-0.7029639482498169,
0.7482117414474487,
0.17453782260417938,
-0.07866626232862473,
0.1140376478433609,
0.3316483497619629,
0.44847315549850464,
0.290825754404068,
-0.1468776911497116,
-0.43622255325317383,
-0.41998666524887085,
-0.36862343549728394,
-0.30962079763412476,
-0.04571931064128876,
-0.18067090213298798,
-0.13973857462406158,
0.5276573300361633,
0.010159647092223167,
0.23704788088798523,
-0.29656562209129333,
-0.572106659412384,
-0.12288302183151245,
0.2746850550174713,
0.6109477877616882,
0.8913246989250183,
-0.033168282359838486,
-0.04909997060894966,
0.187567800283432,
-0.04455467686057091,
0.3542573153972626,
0.3017270863056183,
-0.27820220589637756,
0.0755777657032013,
0.030478239059448242,
1.0696570873260498,
0.7700405716896057,
-0.3776611387729645,
0.13723070919513702,
0.2536690831184387,
-0.2854461073875427,
0.22044244408607483,
0.7492799758911133,
0.4112533628940582,
0.4015295207500458,
0.7209344506263733,
0.43419426679611206,
-0.13166551291942596,
-0.1706133633852005,
-0.019810188561677933,
0.1478494256734848,
0.06777215749025345,
-0.3232378661632538,
1.1067676544189453,
0.3790362775325775,
-0.17905041575431824,
0.28151318430900574,
0.022868279367685318,
-0.2594842314720154,
0.5510742664337158,
0.22340643405914307,
0.5314710736274719,
-0.5046237111091614,
-0.038280460983514786,
0.12658162415027618,
0.1670142561197281,
0.05350086838006973,
0.2100289911031723,
-0.3681037724018097,
-0.6107469797134399,
-0.5250179767608643,
-0.7495743632316589,
-0.7930901050567627,
-0.1949647068977356,
-0.7664521336555481,
0.13179118931293488,
-0.63083815574646,
-0.15559762716293335,
0.049700766801834106,
-0.02094610407948494,
-0.2379543036222458,
0.03766675293445587,
0.3996042311191559,
1.195882797241211,
-0.5282406806945801,
0.8437402248382568,
0.7311883568763733,
-0.026241013780236244,
-0.5297397375106812,
-0.3668437600135803,
0.1001211404800415,
-0.8481563329696655,
0.23586295545101166,
0.10663671791553497,
-0.09288167953491211,
-0.2553887367248535,
-0.24964484572410583,
-0.5145934224128723,
1.1219807863235474,
0.5839001536369324,
-0.7023901343345642,
-0.09215833991765976,
-0.06666677445173264,
0.49950456619262695,
-0.2042471170425415,
0.11597799509763718,
0.4956197440624237,
0.34305718541145325,
0.09370377659797668,
-0.6202027797698975,
-0.1866125613451004,
-0.16281035542488098,
-0.05094996839761734,
0.626375675201416,
-0.9468308687210083,
0.7104556560516357,
-0.12177471071481705,
-0.058044929057359695,
0.1724250316619873,
1.3258165121078491,
0.5927863121032715,
0.1718306690454483,
0.6072556972503662,
0.7753347158432007,
0.8833886384963989,
-0.15089669823646545,
0.9605467915534973,
-0.4912031888961792,
0.23722147941589355,
1.0185062885284424,
-0.48851901292800903,
0.9198542833328247,
0.08984880894422531,
-0.34675538539886475,
0.7668680548667908,
0.637420654296875,
-0.10582131892442703,
0.3981349766254425,
-0.16421706974506378,
-0.11673677712678909,
-0.4356227517127991,
0.5720928907394409,
-0.3722911775112152,
0.254789799451828,
0.4144337475299835,
-0.04352707043290138,
-0.14584915339946747,
-0.26192140579223633,
0.047513023018836975,
0.033836375921964645,
-0.2894144058227539,
0.675441563129425,
0.2846955358982086,
-0.7584328055381775,
0.3454190790653229,
0.11156036704778671,
0.7070781588554382,
-0.7028779983520508,
0.33566224575042725,
-0.278022825717926,
0.3167412281036377,
-0.014869427308440208,
-0.8218545913696289,
0.2827324867248535,
-0.1904384046792984,
-0.18507638573646545,
0.015104593709111214,
0.6567996144294739,
-0.5730957984924316,
-0.44448548555374146,
0.4832116365432739,
0.41186991333961487,
-0.01878872513771057,
0.1441616714000702,
-0.5737953186035156,
-0.3123183250427246,
-0.5311839580535889,
-0.10262510925531387,
0.3352680802345276,
0.25092071294784546,
0.14003083109855652,
0.8305399417877197,
0.5376842021942139,
0.21241030097007751,
0.5657022595405579,
-0.12155210226774216,
0.735554039478302,
-0.5941529273986816,
-0.8644956350326538,
-0.6082510948181152,
0.4240207076072693,
-0.013925787061452866,
-0.11705837398767471,
0.6856531500816345,
0.7707704305648804,
0.5586021542549133,
-0.12501108646392822,
0.6059967279434204,
0.060521792620420456,
0.4853825271129608,
-0.48078078031539917,
0.825263261795044,
-0.8000223636627197,
-0.10325558483600616,
-0.030259994789958,
-0.839694082736969,
0.06477873027324677,
0.11952648311853409,
-0.16109786927700043,
0.11122063547372818,
0.24824629724025726,
0.7390320301055908,
-0.3885561525821686,
-0.01144515722990036,
0.33544406294822693,
0.3132762908935547,
0.24163314700126648,
0.6780810952186584,
0.769231379032135,
-0.11919794231653214,
0.6952931880950928,
-0.12512801587581635,
-0.05046992376446724,
-0.6266931891441345,
-0.4951252043247223,
-0.8093964457511902,
-0.4436560869216919,
0.0279361754655838,
-0.2008432149887085,
-0.15578755736351013,
0.8668210506439209,
1.1870440244674683,
-0.8019888997077942,
-0.1697760671377182,
0.4812532067298889,
0.13481760025024414,
-0.23353980481624603,
-0.20504887402057648,
-0.11034289747476578,
-0.2036186307668686,
-0.8730175495147705,
0.8102781772613525,
0.6744941473007202,
-0.17878666520118713,
-0.4904506206512451,
-0.3839167654514313,
-0.18682989478111267,
0.4330144226551056,
0.5942429900169373,
0.13631486892700195,
-0.7241252064704895,
0.2584701180458069,
-0.2474825382232666,
-0.18860219419002533,
0.3370150029659271,
0.8553798794746399,
-0.6926668882369995,
0.5451955795288086,
0.47328752279281616,
1.1364179849624634,
0.6453050374984741,
-0.04792681336402893,
0.8483244180679321,
-0.7794676423072815,
0.4210715889930725,
0.06680078059434891,
0.7884815335273743,
0.22808390855789185,
-0.09151550382375717,
0.5310379266738892,
0.2261039763689041,
-0.2987005114555359,
-0.7779843807220459,
-0.13241073489189148,
-1.0749808549880981,
-0.6084911823272705,
0.8363568186759949,
-0.09136757254600525,
-0.1936461180448532,
-0.027628082782030106,
-0.021042989566922188,
0.2670544385910034,
-0.6772946119308472,
0.7815818786621094,
0.9900968074798584,
0.2863938808441162,
-0.27467241883277893,
-0.3955082893371582,
-0.32445237040519714,
0.5040348172187805,
-0.7421342730522156,
-0.3806110918521881,
0.25438934564590454,
0.10230200737714767,
0.25219765305519104,
0.10715048760175705,
-0.03309264034032822,
0.3949469327926636,
0.04254448041319847,
0.2193402349948883,
-0.5105067491531372,
-0.4115598499774933,
-0.2694936990737915,
0.3460577428340912,
-0.25605103373527527,
-0.17167149484157562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00385v1 | Computational Morphology and Lexicography Modeling of Modern Standard Arabic Nominals | 2024-02-01T07:05:45 | 2024-02-01T07:05:45 | Christian Khairallah, Reham Marzouk, Salam Khalifa, Mayar Nassar, Nizar Habash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) nominals present many morphological and lexical
modeling challenges that have not been consistently addressed previously. This
paper attempts to define the space of such challenges, and leverage a recently
proposed morphological framework to build a comprehensive and extensible model
for MSA nominals. Our model design addresses the nominals' intricate
morphotactics, as well as their paradigmatic irregularities. Our implementation
showcases enhanced accuracy and consistency compared to a commonly used MSA
morphological analyzer and generator. We make our models publicly available. | [
-0.448978990316391,
-0.9442784786224365,
0.5088425278663635,
0.09053494781255722,
-0.32873985171318054,
0.07298218458890915,
0.26263129711151123,
-0.7306486964225769,
0.5273786783218384,
0.45891451835632324,
-0.43797609210014343,
-0.6543920636177063,
-0.4283038079738617,
0.3497599959373474,
-0.2765568494796753,
0.5851677060127258,
-0.2381577044725418,
-0.2210659682750702,
0.041027240455150604,
-0.26491639018058777,
-0.4900740385055542,
-0.9361095428466797,
-0.31724438071250916,
0.3050186038017273,
0.37111151218414307,
0.3359610140323639,
1.4089748859405518,
0.7930235266685486,
0.4111436903476715,
0.3514542281627655,
-0.5425092577934265,
0.5280895829200745,
0.21498022973537445,
0.15408417582511902,
-0.16350071132183075,
0.07787501066923141,
-0.5699754357337952,
-0.26665911078453064,
0.9450753927230835,
0.8753398656845093,
-0.30402159690856934,
0.20044396817684174,
-0.4218626618385315,
0.5344484448432922,
-0.7429777383804321,
0.11452069878578186,
-0.5233481526374817,
-0.053984981030225754,
-0.6862289309501648,
0.04245668277144432,
-0.11158856004476547,
-0.3030027151107788,
0.04384097084403038,
-0.257318377494812,
0.10010416060686111,
-0.37857359647750854,
1.1326824426651,
-0.10779985785484314,
-0.6242918372154236,
-0.54276043176651,
-0.866674542427063,
0.4345594048500061,
-0.5040105581283569,
0.4332983195781708,
0.05219893530011177,
0.6085636019706726,
-0.1174430325627327,
-0.8742354512214661,
-0.3647388815879822,
-0.5990346670150757,
0.12467354536056519,
-0.2040293961763382,
-0.16999013721942902,
0.02249048464000225,
-0.06566232442855835,
0.7030541300773621,
-0.3966231048107147,
0.03863244503736496,
-0.41990071535110474,
-0.2724889814853668,
0.2841958999633789,
0.34152451157569885,
0.55796879529953,
-0.27598726749420166,
-0.17291758954524994,
0.5304228067398071,
-0.9720507264137268,
-0.006951407063752413,
0.48711827397346497,
0.5102031826972961,
-0.27105897665023804,
0.7848820090293884,
-0.04146268963813782,
0.5939300656318665,
-0.43413838744163513,
-0.009049315005540848,
0.28092458844184875,
-0.3848317265510559,
-0.08861736953258514,
-0.06795603781938553,
0.255961149930954,
-0.052265066653490067,
0.049668654799461365,
0.11403153836727142,
-0.4462270438671112,
0.04540933668613434,
0.4569622874259949,
-0.7346175312995911,
-0.10284613072872162,
0.1619640737771988,
-0.328241765499115,
-0.10924376547336578,
-0.14880363643169403,
-0.6154472231864929,
-0.31804993748664856,
-0.6537830829620361,
0.28358566761016846,
-0.6165776252746582,
-0.18488362431526184,
0.11201385408639908,
0.13956423103809357,
-0.2157282680273056,
0.3177584707736969,
-0.7694250345230103,
0.33525708317756653,
0.503693699836731,
1.0631835460662842,
-0.041237980127334595,
0.20904682576656342,
0.18084166944026947,
0.18842358887195587,
-0.5832153558731079,
0.8684542775154114,
-0.8946990966796875,
-0.557643711566925,
0.38130486011505127,
-0.306928813457489,
0.034516360610723495,
-0.6579588055610657,
0.7508811354637146,
-0.4852314591407776,
-0.26109033823013306,
0.2732478380203247,
-0.3865585923194885,
-0.21861882507801056,
0.3077749013900757,
-0.7994289994239807,
0.824636697769165,
0.46254292130470276,
-0.5908753275871277,
-0.12171637266874313,
-0.664762556552887,
0.04966730624437332,
0.0895177349448204,
-0.37711670994758606,
-0.16412027180194855,
0.2733047306537628,
-0.011281609535217285,
0.042288217693567276,
-0.22661922872066498,
0.5020349621772766,
0.07117124646902084,
-0.07550395280122757,
0.2502443492412567,
-0.2955116033554077,
0.6607586145401001,
0.6009490489959717,
0.22254985570907593,
0.4768088459968567,
-1.0877825021743774,
-0.3070041537284851,
0.03886488825082779,
0.052332498133182526,
-0.22713029384613037,
0.21728909015655518,
0.3621442914009094,
0.23724891245365143,
0.45753732323646545,
-0.25793638825416565,
0.544155478477478,
-0.404433012008667,
0.323853999376297,
0.6202118396759033,
0.13649879395961761,
0.2614174485206604,
-0.32701462507247925,
0.4897977411746979,
0.2883491814136505,
0.15850327908992767,
-0.13614438474178314,
-0.5113202929496765,
-0.5562841296195984,
-0.9219121336936951,
0.39607134461402893,
0.2531479001045227,
-0.5659701228141785,
0.35509803891181946,
-0.2708445191383362,
-0.9655168652534485,
-0.2843553125858307,
-0.3540937006473541,
0.11511662602424622,
0.30046504735946655,
0.2744997441768646,
-0.48518553376197815,
-0.643488347530365,
-1.3075802326202393,
-0.06297440826892853,
-0.0435650609433651,
0.054037585854530334,
0.008166266605257988,
0.5598164200782776,
-0.4597387909889221,
1.0357797145843506,
-0.31479576230049133,
-0.25746336579322815,
-0.0750192180275917,
0.4349159300327301,
0.25912293791770935,
0.6186292767524719,
0.9593289494514465,
-0.7314621210098267,
-0.35900717973709106,
-0.012804066762328148,
-0.3583395183086395,
-0.2224320024251938,
-0.025933032855391502,
0.05853452906012535,
0.31879547238349915,
0.40271323919296265,
-0.7670443654060364,
0.4785948097705841,
0.4310874938964844,
-0.4807014763355255,
1.1826493740081787,
0.003961100243031979,
-0.07097449898719788,
-1.0756479501724243,
0.04144287109375,
-0.21814216673374176,
-0.18733984231948853,
-0.8434935808181763,
0.7275243997573853,
0.09499496221542358,
-0.2623737156391144,
-0.6241740584373474,
0.5630318522453308,
-0.29137104749679565,
0.16726696491241455,
-0.1422445923089981,
-0.22815704345703125,
-0.2650018334388733,
0.24024005234241486,
0.04811253026127815,
1.0944823026657104,
0.47158578038215637,
-0.8041870594024658,
-0.05126118287444115,
0.1444711685180664,
-0.3650733530521393,
0.2880857586860657,
-0.6338093280792236,
0.14837895333766937,
-0.10901220887899399,
-0.06573067605495453,
-0.7448303699493408,
-0.23986990749835968,
0.28166791796684265,
-0.2349565476179123,
0.3965916335582733,
-0.21851733326911926,
-0.7536175847053528,
0.2125142514705658,
-0.22900231182575226,
0.67686927318573,
0.3738429844379425,
-0.20662163197994232,
0.9403451681137085,
0.45282959938049316,
-0.5543572902679443,
-0.22063091397285461,
-0.048715777695178986,
0.33744823932647705,
-0.02474766969680786,
-0.6972922086715698,
0.8426855802536011,
0.06862981617450714,
-0.44204673171043396,
-0.21279634535312653,
-0.00571953970938921,
-0.45470139384269714,
0.011023231782019138,
0.28322213888168335,
0.3912394642829895,
-0.32479581236839294,
0.0005425531999208033,
0.13813316822052002,
0.023883285000920296,
-0.22629277408123016,
0.15049852430820465,
0.8650301098823547,
-0.11670045554637909,
-0.36402276158332825,
-0.6292505860328674,
0.6682782173156738,
0.6989015340805054,
-0.3583306074142456,
0.9396045207977295,
0.23416204750537872,
-0.75649094581604,
0.363044798374176,
-0.23345176875591278,
0.28336167335510254,
-0.5107885599136353,
0.45688098669052124,
-0.8574671149253845,
-0.6294668912887573,
0.735535204410553,
-0.04234496131539345,
0.24983522295951843,
0.5700068473815918,
0.6815517544746399,
0.1568436175584793,
1.228350043296814,
0.7672576904296875,
0.2854767441749573,
0.27797022461891174,
0.1198498085141182,
0.14155438542366028,
-0.47058090567588806,
-0.3251025974750519,
-0.9554221630096436,
0.09120747447013855,
-0.6598731279373169,
-0.4812305271625519,
0.36401963233947754,
0.12679871916770935,
-0.45578786730766296,
0.25385582447052,
-0.19513274729251862,
0.23614493012428284,
0.37176230549812317,
-0.4239112138748169,
0.014900203794240952,
0.25125595927238464,
-0.37388572096824646,
-0.32151299715042114,
-0.186075359582901,
-1.2397531270980835,
0.4910341203212738,
0.5349348783493042,
0.3583543598651886,
0.6020679473876953,
0.3220981955528259,
0.4024011194705963,
0.21796700358390808,
-0.7982717752456665,
0.29009363055229187,
-0.03816775977611542,
-0.7307695746421814,
0.1498350203037262,
-0.17127078771591187,
-0.7383325099945068,
0.20947866141796112,
-0.040689557790756226,
-0.8814706206321716,
0.32732945680618286,
0.03605567663908005,
-0.25231853127479553,
0.2935604751110077,
-0.3526756465435028,
0.7834847569465637,
0.44328054785728455,
0.15502139925956726,
-0.020064935088157654,
-0.5335367918014526,
0.27779486775398254,
-0.18534928560256958,
0.42808160185813904,
-0.21496744453907013,
-0.2817819118499756,
0.5716225504875183,
-0.603424072265625,
0.8088060617446899,
0.053560156375169754,
-0.39554303884506226,
0.5147077441215515,
0.651001513004303,
0.2678361237049103,
-0.16510991752147675,
-0.1220516562461853,
0.30028077960014343,
0.4102284014225006,
-0.6944003105163574,
-0.349787175655365,
0.2621186673641205,
-0.803966760635376,
-0.4559231996536255,
-0.6990129947662354,
-0.536492109298706,
-0.40397658944129944,
-0.005865734536200762,
-0.062468450516462326,
0.7968909740447998,
-0.6145846247673035,
-0.20295345783233643,
0.005652588326483965,
-0.1046462208032608,
0.19885815680027008,
0.39974847435951233,
-0.33818987011909485,
-0.41609102487564087,
0.7112764120101929,
0.41237887740135193,
0.05519253760576248,
0.059705235064029694,
-0.21144884824752808,
-0.23700329661369324,
-1.0142443180084229,
-0.6608343720436096,
0.1184515655040741,
-0.6753477454185486,
-0.26013389229774475,
-0.42004650831222534,
-0.5555731654167175,
-0.6652613282203674,
-0.02233041822910309,
-0.47867757081985474,
-0.6943359375,
-0.3736308515071869,
-0.020415127277374268,
0.16944444179534912,
1.0042420625686646,
0.012361306697130203,
0.46573230624198914,
-1.1837055683135986,
0.35156911611557007,
-0.008639691397547722,
0.04344351962208748,
-0.22840850055217743,
-0.8075355291366577,
-0.02903089113533497,
-0.01956639066338539,
-0.5909194350242615,
-1.232946515083313,
0.5881944894790649,
0.3499600887298584,
0.17893631756305695,
0.7507393956184387,
-0.2606739103794098,
0.7163184285163879,
-1.0027074813842773,
1.1045887470245361,
-0.10129690170288086,
-1.10188627243042,
0.32918256521224976,
-0.4141062796115875,
0.1392141580581665,
0.33308905363082886,
0.5822792649269104,
-0.7586493492126465,
-0.22281843423843384,
-0.4352400004863739,
-0.9542978405952454,
0.28835970163345337,
0.5126315355300903,
0.4924575984477997,
-0.3624492287635803,
0.5272814631462097,
0.36932283639907837,
0.08723414689302444,
-0.20375199615955353,
-0.45186129212379456,
0.025523874908685684,
-0.44532883167266846,
0.12481758743524551,
-0.9075108170509338,
-0.06259088218212128,
-0.14689789712429047,
0.5805354118347168,
0.03226946294307709,
0.2529154121875763,
0.007097073830664158,
-0.18470098078250885,
0.25472280383110046,
0.38292375206947327,
1.0017430782318115,
0.8849890828132629,
-0.15378935635089874,
0.41389626264572144,
-0.021143799647688866,
-0.6562254428863525,
0.3146178424358368,
0.002000948181375861,
-0.48559656739234924,
0.46029195189476013,
0.27187833189964294,
0.4815507233142853,
0.02196517400443554,
-0.7255697846412659,
0.10199101269245148,
0.27949902415275574,
-0.15432271361351013,
-0.6433651447296143,
-0.3436567485332489,
0.07857899367809296,
-0.12721827626228333,
0.29330602288246155,
0.3138258457183838,
0.2968045473098755,
-0.7888497114181519,
0.14083532989025116,
0.3019911050796509,
-0.41009265184402466,
-0.6198055148124695,
0.06619461625814438,
-0.16739521920681,
-0.474476158618927,
0.3792175054550171,
-0.2385895997285843,
-0.6216025948524475,
0.6736629605293274,
0.7555767893791199,
0.39431726932525635,
-0.5241931080818176,
0.31961894035339355,
0.2682811915874481,
0.1705055832862854,
0.3891383707523346,
0.5514403581619263,
0.3289957046508789,
-0.5825013518333435,
0.035301707684993744,
-0.871541440486908,
-0.4772951900959015,
-0.042597249150276184,
-0.3662010133266449,
0.2604401409626007,
-0.5793358683586121,
-0.14835163950920105,
0.18564411997795105,
-0.24920052289962769,
-0.24120503664016724,
0.1725359559059143,
0.26848775148391724,
1.316382884979248,
-0.5160831212997437,
0.6392204761505127,
0.8857623338699341,
-0.6435710787773132,
-0.4219999313354492,
-0.4804595112800598,
0.24213668704032898,
-0.5219122767448425,
0.503568172454834,
0.32170888781547546,
-0.40548622608184814,
-0.3015415668487549,
-0.3797800838947296,
-1.1603139638900757,
0.5964774489402771,
0.41753503680229187,
-0.22043949365615845,
-0.18159912526607513,
0.4945829510688782,
0.5395237803459167,
-0.43049144744873047,
0.19727462530136108,
0.52783203125,
0.36073800921440125,
0.16697384417057037,
-0.8556997179985046,
-0.06555850803852081,
-0.3635009527206421,
0.17721880972385406,
0.24206525087356567,
-0.23099057376384735,
1.1439567804336548,
0.27515482902526855,
-0.7870760560035706,
0.7211170196533203,
0.9579566121101379,
0.2900477945804596,
0.0318843349814415,
0.21272774040699005,
0.45348185300827026,
0.7535416483879089,
0.04317498952150345,
0.8335496187210083,
-0.33627036213874817,
0.0377349779009819,
0.9965940713882446,
-0.30740898847579956,
0.8517677783966064,
0.47830072045326233,
-0.3952568471431732,
0.7489357590675354,
1.0605140924453735,
0.2835127115249634,
0.18400706350803375,
0.28043678402900696,
-0.6219213008880615,
-0.09893586486577988,
-0.588936448097229,
-0.6737284064292908,
0.5590552091598511,
0.6321927309036255,
-0.16737094521522522,
-0.3554241955280304,
-0.31272780895233154,
0.003986187744885683,
0.3005909323692322,
-0.5837588310241699,
0.46903422474861145,
-0.11582136899232864,
-0.28380587697029114,
0.6162356734275818,
0.6187723875045776,
0.42621728777885437,
-0.6398661732673645,
-0.2209625542163849,
-0.0724337100982666,
-0.09047869592905045,
-0.027152495458722115,
-0.30266156792640686,
0.7738215327262878,
0.09124196320772171,
0.08904141187667847,
0.17921653389930725,
0.4948207139968872,
-0.20709921419620514,
-0.6165419220924377,
-0.23507925868034363,
0.5702588558197021,
0.3287351131439209,
-0.3713042736053467,
-0.49819415807724,
-0.034532297402620316,
-0.45996546745300293,
0.22417837381362915,
0.17853568494319916,
0.2733207643032074,
-0.4971470236778259,
0.534899890422821,
0.4911781847476959,
0.11298534274101257,
0.23594599962234497,
0.16902931034564972,
0.6879897713661194,
-0.9967378973960876,
-0.4714723527431488,
-0.8679165244102478,
0.36576953530311584,
0.13879673182964325,
-0.14161062240600586,
0.3478468060493469,
0.6514586806297302,
0.354279488325119,
-0.2890684902667999,
0.22189052402973175,
0.020863844081759453,
0.32413527369499207,
-0.6296418309211731,
0.7393612265586853,
-0.5458168387413025,
-0.11457043141126633,
0.11543385684490204,
-0.8811939358711243,
-0.45510903000831604,
0.3189786672592163,
0.3572494089603424,
0.055914029479026794,
0.7189517617225647,
0.7869269251823425,
-0.1957254260778427,
0.10492946207523346,
0.2949373126029968,
0.04288972541689873,
0.40918898582458496,
0.07014209032058716,
1.0032658576965332,
0.003179065650328994,
0.02105776034295559,
-0.2635691463947296,
-0.034924060106277466,
-0.24432925879955292,
-0.7791868448257446,
-0.6422064900398254,
-0.7832027077674866,
-0.22021371126174927,
-0.16890151798725128,
-0.04890234395861626,
1.3745392560958862,
0.6321377754211426,
-0.9904300570487976,
-0.2622397840023041,
-0.01205119676887989,
0.04091036319732666,
-0.08195863664150238,
-0.2044915407896042,
0.6092386841773987,
-0.5885627269744873,
-0.8657610416412354,
0.2939838469028473,
0.26290807127952576,
0.6517688035964966,
-0.17334909737110138,
0.38222670555114746,
-0.3024071753025055,
0.6643026471138,
0.6799477934837341,
0.1995079070329666,
-0.7593358755111694,
-0.36834388971328735,
-0.26727235317230225,
-0.3894464373588562,
0.34438055753707886,
0.8440606594085693,
-0.4854992926120758,
0.15893986821174622,
0.23665931820869446,
0.4924105703830719,
-0.1007329449057579,
-0.14751268923282623,
0.5249969959259033,
-0.8534562587738037,
0.22571739554405212,
0.20177869498729706,
0.597180187702179,
0.24326255917549133,
-0.07792496681213379,
0.42721858620643616,
0.19968898594379425,
0.033217769116163254,
-0.8710104823112488,
0.8256189227104187,
-0.9778741002082825,
-0.40922439098358154,
0.7109919786453247,
-0.10120958089828491,
-0.22873562574386597,
-0.4535929560661316,
-0.747840404510498,
0.39294159412384033,
-0.17315855622291565,
0.8339805603027344,
0.8203277587890625,
0.1074168011546135,
-0.0035095633938908577,
-0.2967243492603302,
0.5878186821937561,
0.3214173913002014,
-0.7409818768501282,
-0.06166725605726242,
0.6988082528114319,
0.007505145855247974,
0.541767954826355,
0.5040988326072693,
-0.474640816450119,
0.341937392950058,
0.05896898731589317,
0.1371949166059494,
-0.2636004686355591,
-0.6667512059211731,
-0.4482251703739166,
0.5347217321395874,
0.35484442114830017,
0.11602336168289185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00371v1 | What Does the Bot Say? Opportunities and Risks of Large Language Models in Social Media Bot Detection | 2024-02-01T06:21:19 | 2024-02-01T06:21:19 | Shangbin Feng, Herun Wan, Ningnan Wang, Zhaoxuan Tan, Minnan Luo, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media bot detection has always been an arms race between advancements
in machine learning bot detectors and adversarial bot strategies to evade
detection. In this work, we bring the arms race to the next level by
investigating the opportunities and risks of state-of-the-art large language
models (LLMs) in social bot detection. To investigate the opportunities, we
design novel LLM-based bot detectors by proposing a
mixture-of-heterogeneous-experts framework to divide and conquer diverse user
information modalities. To illuminate the risks, we explore the possibility of
LLM-guided manipulation of user textual and structured information to evade
detection. Extensive experiments with three LLMs on two datasets demonstrate
that instruction tuning on merely 1,000 annotated examples produces specialized
LLMs that outperform state-of-the-art baselines by up to 9.1% on both datasets,
while LLM-guided manipulation strategies could significantly bring down the
performance of existing bot detectors by up to 29.6% and harm the calibration
and reliability of bot detection systems. | [
-0.3863513171672821,
-1.2346656322479248,
0.5747226476669312,
-0.2726176381111145,
-0.356174111366272,
0.5321208238601685,
-0.3832778334617615,
-0.46211278438568115,
0.17206107079982758,
0.6791231632232666,
-0.4934398829936981,
-0.4689615070819855,
-0.9177066683769226,
-0.15313337743282318,
-0.46682676672935486,
0.8304858803749084,
0.2597404420375824,
-0.03204220160841942,
0.13650520145893097,
0.13915790617465973,
-0.7050393223762512,
-0.5156546831130981,
-0.5516685843467712,
0.1636689454317093,
0.8002219796180725,
0.5024807453155518,
0.7925902009010315,
0.3923557996749878,
0.5364190936088562,
0.3691171407699585,
-0.15123571455478668,
0.3104500472545624,
-0.6105489134788513,
0.21992240846157074,
-0.07327963411808014,
-0.734254002571106,
-0.3416138291358948,
-0.007140708155930042,
0.4769396185874939,
0.5451816916465759,
0.05573533847928047,
0.13243183493614197,
-0.10234467685222626,
0.5214123725891113,
-0.6502824425697327,
-0.03639015555381775,
-1.0219426155090332,
-0.28718262910842896,
-0.4558952748775482,
-0.46512216329574585,
-0.46366822719573975,
-0.049815692007541656,
-0.12194804847240448,
-0.22214780747890472,
0.027942275628447533,
0.09582767635583878,
0.46054771542549133,
0.2060721218585968,
-0.16081351041793823,
-0.09785608947277069,
-0.7707372307777405,
0.6054601073265076,
-0.6332637667655945,
0.042110100388526917,
0.44735872745513916,
0.6929495930671692,
-0.3078637421131134,
-0.402463436126709,
-0.800773561000824,
-0.06268148869276047,
0.2815498411655426,
-0.1218549907207489,
-0.4156351089477539,
-0.0875585600733757,
0.10212366282939911,
0.07315071672201157,
-0.5081353783607483,
0.46596911549568176,
-0.4787004888057709,
-0.2128857970237732,
0.8571499586105347,
-0.052945952862501144,
0.40241092443466187,
-0.15510807931423187,
-0.28184035420417786,
0.021522533148527145,
-0.6246732473373413,
-0.3085331618785858,
0.8688677549362183,
0.3712855279445648,
-0.005552683491259813,
0.7610876560211182,
-0.05060814693570137,
0.566523015499115,
-0.04750850424170494,
0.14819787442684174,
0.046617425978183746,
0.0633876845240593,
0.0434366911649704,
-0.1353801041841507,
0.9018425345420837,
0.5388156175613403,
0.5050390958786011,
-0.15894639492034912,
-0.25108057260513306,
0.000792770879343152,
0.17430128157138824,
-0.3112007677555084,
-0.20884478092193604,
0.12760360538959503,
-0.32236066460609436,
-0.5358824133872986,
0.1610899716615677,
-0.7202223539352417,
-0.8747637271881104,
-0.03563953563570976,
0.47336989641189575,
-0.25842148065567017,
-0.37521639466285706,
0.1827337145805359,
-0.2773211896419525,
0.14640024304389954,
0.45238104462623596,
-0.4080221652984619,
0.09784790128469467,
0.9150325655937195,
0.6622277498245239,
-0.13533379137516022,
-0.12812979519367218,
-0.885859489440918,
0.053115230053663254,
-0.39886903762817383,
0.7791264057159424,
-0.5771788358688354,
-0.4013029932975769,
0.25920233130455017,
0.02383004128932953,
0.16913935542106628,
-0.46196460723876953,
0.21794980764389038,
-0.6703344583511353,
0.0895741805434227,
-0.21481795608997345,
-0.5671906471252441,
-0.2565895915031433,
0.1669035255908966,
-0.6030600070953369,
0.7473087906837463,
0.013210523873567581,
-0.588135302066803,
0.167865589261055,
-0.5390538573265076,
-0.7464005351066589,
0.5144284963607788,
-0.008833489380776882,
-0.07829704880714417,
0.15706010162830353,
0.1398414671421051,
0.711881160736084,
-0.27290570735931396,
0.12409812211990356,
-0.7002229690551758,
-0.21853388845920563,
0.6296294927597046,
-0.7140630483627319,
0.6786088347434998,
0.20137983560562134,
-0.26744621992111206,
0.21961447596549988,
-0.3411807119846344,
-0.40707287192344666,
0.37300798296928406,
-0.13108228147029877,
-0.24545547366142273,
0.1377132683992386,
0.1731104999780655,
0.18195314705371857,
0.29206931591033936,
-0.5357881188392639,
-0.02935686893761158,
-0.042728241533041,
0.5387980937957764,
1.1667054891586304,
-0.03978663310408592,
0.45020344853401184,
-0.3412700891494751,
0.6412804126739502,
-0.18734776973724365,
0.16918879747390747,
-0.1850748360157013,
-0.6498586535453796,
-0.516392707824707,
-0.3807317018508911,
0.24105820059776306,
0.4750617444515228,
-0.7685844898223877,
0.675938069820404,
-0.1469459980726242,
-0.4524393677711487,
-0.5792833566665649,
0.3619306981563568,
-0.07065410166978836,
0.32363802194595337,
0.06803227216005325,
0.03346244990825653,
-0.2852236032485962,
-0.7754049301147461,
-0.6338289976119995,
-0.2787551283836365,
-0.17486430704593658,
0.19728875160217285,
0.2745104730129242,
-0.2649385929107666,
0.7489737272262573,
-0.49125421047210693,
-0.20671655237674713,
-0.5604795217514038,
-0.11753612756729126,
-0.0651775375008583,
0.1293070763349533,
0.39176687598228455,
-1.0468204021453857,
-0.6342089772224426,
-0.028904544189572334,
-0.5338714122772217,
-0.22716723382472992,
-0.03894151374697685,
-0.003292457200586796,
0.37071043252944946,
0.7403204441070557,
-0.7267580628395081,
0.609234094619751,
0.34559786319732666,
0.0803254246711731,
0.32858720421791077,
0.05641613528132439,
-0.030874021351337433,
-1.2024400234222412,
-0.3181953728199005,
0.16805261373519897,
-0.6133549809455872,
-0.6178911328315735,
-0.009594965726137161,
-0.19312453269958496,
-0.13194359838962555,
-0.5421446561813354,
0.5531126260757446,
-0.2150573432445526,
0.26981428265571594,
-0.5794469118118286,
0.23607765138149261,
-0.36554574966430664,
0.2400977909564972,
-0.24028345942497253,
0.3935903012752533,
0.5785579681396484,
-0.4083707332611084,
0.5546653270721436,
-0.2529993951320648,
-0.3712168037891388,
0.48580700159072876,
-0.6411415934562683,
0.20869608223438263,
-0.10449378192424774,
0.5074763894081116,
-1.3229892253875732,
-0.4667736887931824,
0.5235692858695984,
-0.7252465486526489,
0.32170039415359497,
-0.06630267947912216,
-1.1475907564163208,
-0.4571104943752289,
-0.5239595770835876,
0.06341210752725601,
0.5722230672836304,
-0.3166407346725464,
0.7902405261993408,
0.8137616515159607,
-0.1544482558965683,
-0.41039878129959106,
-0.596486508846283,
0.33639833331108093,
-0.31242552399635315,
-0.6707770228385925,
-0.023581435903906822,
0.08871818333864212,
-0.3199583888053894,
0.05625380948185921,
-0.0031360893044620752,
0.20984536409378052,
0.44334733486175537,
0.35340219736099243,
0.2714214622974396,
-0.035447344183921814,
0.20648767054080963,
-0.15684372186660767,
0.02016288787126541,
0.0700802281498909,
0.1857702136039734,
1.1175073385238647,
-0.02612459845840931,
-0.6766023635864258,
-0.7683029770851135,
0.398811399936676,
0.5133810639381409,
-0.05706283450126648,
0.7780793905258179,
0.7677600383758545,
-0.5717830061912537,
-0.24534988403320312,
-0.7199477553367615,
-0.1822396218776703,
-0.5619254112243652,
0.5430582761764526,
0.15277962386608124,
-0.8706854581832886,
0.4269537329673767,
-0.08451900631189346,
0.05845414847135544,
0.319688618183136,
0.7119871377944946,
-0.34631749987602234,
1.0032520294189453,
0.6317988634109497,
-0.38583704829216003,
0.6529494524002075,
-0.07579134404659271,
0.510550320148468,
-0.40620362758636475,
0.016819220036268234,
-0.19819383323192596,
-0.437812864780426,
-0.7553974390029907,
-0.6282983422279358,
0.35087570548057556,
-0.21881036460399628,
-0.18489694595336914,
0.30130505561828613,
-0.08444266766309738,
0.5216667652130127,
0.5210133194923401,
0.24438026547431946,
0.15520219504833221,
0.08779758960008621,
0.6811035871505737,
0.43807336688041687,
-0.5473283529281616,
-0.5667657852172852,
1.2976932525634766,
0.4798562824726105,
0.9920560121536255,
0.11704698950052261,
0.37847018241882324,
0.808315098285675,
0.23199599981307983,
-0.8075932264328003,
0.6899912357330322,
-0.07620707899332047,
-0.7675232291221619,
-0.3881082236766815,
-0.21994523704051971,
-0.8308098316192627,
0.17018941044807434,
-0.18063846230506897,
-0.7451922297477722,
-0.2719874083995819,
0.059204746037721634,
-0.044985733926296234,
0.7336126565933228,
-0.5788105130195618,
0.5323804020881653,
-0.3809104561805725,
-0.18606889247894287,
-0.38686904311180115,
-0.6972354054450989,
0.2729279398918152,
-0.21259412169456482,
0.36402592062950134,
-0.19299164414405823,
-0.03120030090212822,
0.36878785490989685,
-0.20536203682422638,
1.2323486804962158,
-0.08498265594244003,
-0.09698372334241867,
0.35253968834877014,
0.015032787807285786,
0.588284432888031,
0.01976965367794037,
0.046673163771629333,
0.313242644071579,
-0.5208855271339417,
-0.41883841156959534,
-0.2854078710079193,
0.48835548758506775,
-0.43655455112457275,
-0.8875554203987122,
-0.2609192430973053,
-0.6887277364730835,
-0.05250384286046028,
0.13767877221107483,
0.27426591515541077,
0.005291064735502005,
-0.2159835398197174,
0.34510496258735657,
0.5225335359573364,
-0.4271182715892792,
0.16038137674331665,
0.39916449785232544,
-0.12412501126527786,
-0.13701239228248596,
1.000685453414917,
0.08394323289394379,
0.4244121313095093,
0.3043709695339203,
0.20936931669712067,
-0.3280487656593323,
-0.45851680636405945,
-0.2389184534549713,
0.17032474279403687,
-0.6965279579162598,
-0.22338373959064484,
-0.7736583352088928,
-0.23929616808891296,
-0.5656081438064575,
-0.2582205533981323,
-0.27612727880477905,
-0.09599627554416656,
-0.3374192714691162,
-0.0032929929438978434,
0.545929491519928,
0.6450411081314087,
-0.08671598881483078,
0.7429169416427612,
-0.5553380250930786,
0.3625113368034363,
0.13692675530910492,
0.13980071246623993,
-0.007494334597140551,
-0.5042412281036377,
-0.10479261726140976,
0.2608626186847687,
-0.22015248239040375,
-0.917039155960083,
0.334599107503891,
-0.20218425989151,
0.5691990852355957,
0.4630056917667389,
0.19922876358032227,
0.3572129011154175,
-0.4642767012119293,
0.5374099016189575,
0.1465277373790741,
-0.630547285079956,
0.40265074372291565,
-0.4864186644554138,
-0.13817156851291656,
0.2795037627220154,
0.3094119131565094,
-0.736725389957428,
-0.6148818135261536,
-0.3627033829689026,
-0.8962809443473816,
0.5931697487831116,
-0.09596211463212967,
0.47241005301475525,
0.011847385205328465,
-0.002394729293882847,
0.04737311229109764,
0.3165525794029236,
-0.7270572781562805,
-0.21020972728729248,
0.31714269518852234,
-0.1498631238937378,
-0.16562402248382568,
-0.06546049565076828,
-0.3030841648578644,
-0.012604747898876667,
0.3753975033760071,
0.04112096130847931,
0.127442866563797,
-0.38302984833717346,
-0.37795063853263855,
-0.19111260771751404,
0.04660315811634064,
0.18891869485378265,
0.3434734046459198,
0.057436253875494,
-0.040582023561000824,
-0.009233145043253899,
-0.08824307471513748,
-0.278916597366333,
0.08400045335292816,
-0.04138777777552605,
-0.028207071125507355,
0.4743902087211609,
0.5967972874641418,
-0.057139065116643906,
-0.8405507206916809,
0.6402873992919922,
0.09235376864671707,
-0.16441377997398376,
-0.38454198837280273,
0.18292656540870667,
0.2262657880783081,
0.24110335111618042,
0.6214542984962463,
0.032192543148994446,
-0.010123507119715214,
-0.6916881203651428,
0.04674305021762848,
0.642802357673645,
-0.2861734628677368,
-0.4315294027328491,
0.42343974113464355,
0.08765491843223572,
-0.7033625841140747,
0.0851128026843071,
-0.0043797483667731285,
-0.8482601046562195,
0.5943465232849121,
0.25070586800575256,
0.8662293553352356,
-0.17622697353363037,
0.32135671377182007,
-0.3523294925689697,
0.5169565081596375,
0.03963238373398781,
0.1843971610069275,
0.13834238052368164,
-0.7805054187774658,
-0.22142159938812256,
-0.2108727991580963,
-0.43108779191970825,
0.2950865626335144,
-0.33024898171424866,
0.5075896382331848,
-0.605607807636261,
-0.09196700155735016,
0.3484199047088623,
-0.3236050307750702,
-0.6889867186546326,
-0.41551733016967773,
0.44838398694992065,
0.7485812306404114,
-0.7858653664588928,
0.4180280566215515,
0.4855600893497467,
-0.12461192905902863,
-0.3152872323989868,
0.26518866419792175,
0.35384827852249146,
-0.8991585373878479,
0.4030519425868988,
0.3455308675765991,
-0.18443457782268524,
-0.24973896145820618,
-1.083019733428955,
-0.41343045234680176,
0.5245360136032104,
0.36096441745758057,
-0.5342516303062439,
0.1661594659090042,
0.24253779649734497,
0.5264826416969299,
-0.17853733897209167,
-0.1929522156715393,
0.253264456987381,
0.47540318965911865,
-0.08175770938396454,
-0.6273453831672668,
-0.054394256323575974,
0.001061303191818297,
-0.10324794799089432,
-0.018517786636948586,
-0.7812784910202026,
0.8307011127471924,
-0.0695711001753807,
-0.35028478503227234,
-0.009157751686871052,
0.3891834020614624,
0.0238233283162117,
0.2947060465812683,
0.7085386514663696,
0.2460263967514038,
0.6350801587104797,
0.1021052747964859,
1.0568890571594238,
-0.20821206271648407,
0.05311000719666481,
0.8901730179786682,
-0.5684076547622681,
0.7670832872390747,
0.19479726254940033,
0.025015443563461304,
0.32207608222961426,
0.8369976878166199,
-0.1450439989566803,
0.14107505977153778,
0.3658040165901184,
-0.3636591136455536,
-0.46523794531822205,
-0.1179017648100853,
-0.33008643984794617,
0.5538600087165833,
0.6292464733123779,
-0.26249372959136963,
-0.15827026963233948,
0.07288588583469391,
0.10255797207355499,
0.302680104970932,
-0.17199677228927612,
0.5639250874519348,
-0.06527736037969589,
-0.32796841859817505,
0.2974226474761963,
0.01995065063238144,
0.9265379905700684,
-0.4486740231513977,
0.06783389300107956,
0.11653853952884674,
0.19526949524879456,
-0.04976051673293114,
-0.903865396976471,
0.039018820971250534,
0.1255611628293991,
0.14890888333320618,
-0.11001898348331451,
0.9554890990257263,
-0.3472222089767456,
-0.5634948015213013,
0.5068399906158447,
0.572370707988739,
0.09094344824552536,
-0.38079941272735596,
-0.6602425575256348,
0.003252039197832346,
-0.2696700096130371,
-0.21249175071716309,
0.35360071063041687,
0.5337128043174744,
-0.08313930034637451,
0.9594164490699768,
0.9765244126319885,
0.10998647660017014,
0.14411696791648865,
0.04407032951712608,
1.1616941690444946,
-0.45073819160461426,
-0.1985291838645935,
-1.0859999656677246,
0.24288232624530792,
-0.35287579894065857,
-0.041811563074588776,
0.8411653637886047,
0.3813871145248413,
1.0410653352737427,
0.06024717912077904,
1.0118598937988281,
-0.06527356058359146,
0.6139881610870361,
-0.2130056470632553,
0.8771956562995911,
-0.7054004073143005,
0.45092007517814636,
-0.3071746826171875,
-0.6160663962364197,
-0.28337547183036804,
0.3040068745613098,
-0.3960815370082855,
-0.0041172076016664505,
0.234650120139122,
0.7807043790817261,
0.16578130424022675,
-0.1181621253490448,
0.3508816361427307,
0.16311869025230408,
0.610274612903595,
0.2361212819814682,
1.0551906824111938,
-0.03546885401010513,
0.50449538230896,
-0.0036850927863270044,
-0.2155933827161789,
-0.6361443400382996,
-0.48622429370880127,
-1.1143765449523926,
-0.33844438195228577,
-0.20322062075138092,
-0.4928049147129059,
0.004839251283556223,
0.829594075679779,
0.5044835805892944,
-0.5834500193595886,
-0.08807391673326492,
0.15988333523273468,
0.5181048512458801,
0.095883309841156,
-0.24823011457920074,
0.11371254175901413,
-0.18277700245380402,
-0.8342719078063965,
0.22385236620903015,
0.2631830871105194,
-0.03442687541246414,
-0.41957223415374756,
0.0994950383901596,
-0.4104916751384735,
0.07008586823940277,
0.610325038433075,
0.30887356400489807,
-0.8756165504455566,
-0.2568691074848175,
0.1313037872314453,
-0.14594216644763947,
-0.10380160063505173,
0.43261852860450745,
-0.28656744956970215,
0.5410235524177551,
0.5717473030090332,
0.931747555732727,
0.11134842783212662,
-0.06316020339727402,
0.6680593490600586,
-0.5316929817199707,
0.23543080687522888,
0.3367995321750641,
0.39604809880256653,
0.3301737308502197,
-0.49611783027648926,
0.3227245509624481,
0.3154852092266083,
-0.3031557500362396,
-1.1237456798553467,
0.3126298189163208,
-1.0091347694396973,
-0.634726345539093,
1.4559077024459839,
0.12787923216819763,
-0.28589364886283875,
-0.1608172059059143,
-0.20723317563533783,
0.2801068127155304,
-0.513524055480957,
0.8560501933097839,
0.8438599109649658,
0.32780662178993225,
0.05935456231236458,
-0.7144961357116699,
0.1541014015674591,
0.06769357621669769,
-0.4700664281845093,
0.13327094912528992,
0.4049644470214844,
0.28848105669021606,
0.045459918677806854,
0.5167835354804993,
-0.06356540322303772,
0.2727932333946228,
-0.3091576099395752,
-0.009472973644733429,
0.08803846687078476,
-0.1997886598110199,
-0.3015630543231964,
-0.14389513432979584,
-0.27101030945777893,
-0.4407508075237274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00367v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00367v2 | Don't Hallucinate, Abstain: Identifying LLM Knowledge Gaps via Multi-LLM Collaboration | 2024-02-01T06:11:49 | 2024-07-01T01:34:09 | Shangbin Feng, Weijia Shi, Yike Wang, Wenxuan Ding, Vidhisha Balachandran, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite efforts to expand the knowledge of large language models (LLMs),
knowledge gaps -- missing or outdated information in LLMs -- might always
persist given the evolving nature of knowledge. In this work, we study
approaches to identify LLM knowledge gaps and abstain from answering questions
when knowledge gaps are present. We first adapt existing approaches to model
calibration or adaptation through fine-tuning/prompting and analyze their
ability to abstain from generating low-confidence outputs. Motivated by their
failures in self-reflection and over-reliance on held-out sets, we propose two
novel approaches that are based on model collaboration, i.e., LLMs probing
other LLMs for knowledge gaps, either cooperatively or competitively. Extensive
experiments with three LLMs on four QA tasks featuring diverse knowledge
domains demonstrate that both cooperative and competitive approaches to
unveiling LLM knowledge gaps achieve up to 19.3% improvements on abstain
accuracy against the strongest baseline. Further analysis reveals that our
proposed mechanisms could help identify failure cases in retrieval augmentation
and pinpoint knowledge gaps in multi-hop reasoning. | [
-0.6321365833282471,
-0.8722572922706604,
0.9644632339477539,
-0.0494636669754982,
0.1420266330242157,
0.41948285698890686,
-0.1583145409822464,
-0.442169189453125,
0.10194762796163559,
0.6122869849205017,
-0.6957417130470276,
-0.39038288593292236,
-0.48555925488471985,
-0.010151918046176434,
0.0005840354133397341,
0.4487643837928772,
-0.19195428490638733,
0.001729912357404828,
-0.7291163206100464,
-0.1917588859796524,
-0.8916072249412537,
-0.45204758644104004,
-0.13517679274082184,
-0.47015076875686646,
0.5387064814567566,
0.6442956328392029,
0.3822939395904541,
0.36474180221557617,
0.4340188205242157,
0.23735804855823517,
0.03912176564335823,
0.6921603083610535,
-0.5031605958938599,
0.22110827267169952,
-0.131612628698349,
-0.4399326741695404,
-0.4079221785068512,
-0.06499838083982468,
0.3860589861869812,
0.917959451675415,
0.02034485898911953,
0.052566200494766235,
0.3426703214645386,
0.7875345945358276,
-0.907163143157959,
0.17027541995048523,
-0.9207616448402405,
-0.08191536366939545,
-0.11466258764266968,
-0.23044900596141815,
-0.5113678574562073,
-0.14878879487514496,
-0.004097294993698597,
-0.5952886343002319,
0.2059657722711563,
-0.15396073460578918,
0.5970026254653931,
0.5865468382835388,
-0.2425350397825241,
-0.2667553126811981,
-0.6343786120414734,
0.8368080854415894,
-0.6194125413894653,
0.584138035774231,
0.5981799364089966,
0.10513309389352798,
-0.3347339332103729,
-0.23562507331371307,
-0.48350071907043457,
-0.1476621925830841,
-0.003649385878816247,
0.2268022745847702,
-0.0043621547520160675,
-0.030639784410595894,
-0.021663762629032135,
0.11385739594697952,
-0.3327581584453583,
0.0776909589767456,
-0.26760271191596985,
-0.08286844193935394,
0.38741159439086914,
0.008096321485936642,
0.2060425877571106,
0.2572104036808014,
-0.3624935746192932,
0.13849498331546783,
-1.1095994710922241,
-0.18808351457118988,
-0.017944350838661194,
0.20004592835903168,
0.11698313802480698,
0.7579860687255859,
-0.08084269613027573,
0.5684386491775513,
-0.012136771343648434,
0.16971571743488312,
0.12480956315994263,
-0.36145755648612976,
-0.17997317016124725,
-0.25679296255111694,
0.6150968670845032,
0.13606710731983185,
0.16554181277751923,
-0.3638819754123688,
-0.12272154539823532,
-0.15035924315452576,
0.11781572550535202,
-0.22721602022647858,
-0.23515118658542633,
0.25139889121055603,
-0.14694786071777344,
0.06030769646167755,
0.02013792097568512,
-0.7310426235198975,
-0.6171349287033081,
-0.22749063372612,
0.7851760983467102,
-0.1893080174922943,
-0.33725377917289734,
-0.059662386775016785,
-0.09750384092330933,
0.1238393634557724,
0.2893359363079071,
-0.7308947443962097,
0.3570479452610016,
0.6292833089828491,
0.7921807765960693,
-0.1787588894367218,
-0.5286954641342163,
-0.5270022749900818,
0.4689691662788391,
-0.421941339969635,
0.5447328090667725,
-0.33079060912132263,
-0.2944410741329193,
-0.21863748133182526,
0.01121077686548233,
-0.23887938261032104,
-0.8530599474906921,
0.12697535753250122,
-0.5930452942848206,
0.02691015973687172,
-0.6365430355072021,
-0.7637040615081787,
-0.30977514386177063,
0.38171321153640747,
-0.6842036843299866,
0.5361708998680115,
0.016757747158408165,
-0.5941689610481262,
0.09944382309913635,
-0.4693332314491272,
-0.12288615852594376,
-0.0021186734084039927,
-0.4100755751132965,
-0.10731114447116852,
0.12903229892253876,
0.3924776315689087,
0.23237915337085724,
-0.18583247065544128,
0.2293396294116974,
-0.43915265798568726,
-0.2364623248577118,
0.2978152930736542,
-0.30777645111083984,
0.63712477684021,
-0.03092256188392639,
-0.13425058126449585,
0.17783817648887634,
-0.5012146830558777,
0.02578006125986576,
0.0016721535939723253,
-0.06846537441015244,
-0.501902163028717,
0.1257016956806183,
-0.6452754139900208,
0.2838517129421234,
0.29045477509498596,
-0.24057495594024658,
0.13601349294185638,
-0.3204033374786377,
0.08490042388439178,
0.7364709377288818,
0.16876177489757538,
0.2634502947330475,
-0.7844882607460022,
0.5629178881645203,
0.10145238041877747,
0.09623278677463531,
-0.07260239124298096,
-0.4266222417354584,
-1.0123369693756104,
-0.12992098927497864,
0.04935424029827118,
0.49260756373405457,
-0.978910505771637,
0.6318955421447754,
-0.05893022567033768,
-0.4222625195980072,
-0.6898736357688904,
0.4219623804092407,
0.34961333870887756,
0.5875205397605896,
0.5593883991241455,
-0.26399505138397217,
-0.5025509595870972,
-0.5205307006835938,
-0.2181374579668045,
-0.32592758536338806,
-0.03524944931268692,
0.20680846273899078,
0.4238124191761017,
-0.04488448426127434,
0.8484019041061401,
-0.36929720640182495,
-0.2899000346660614,
-0.15373890101909637,
-0.14750109612941742,
0.13496676087379456,
0.49537789821624756,
0.1113600954413414,
-0.5319478511810303,
-0.3896408677101135,
-0.13688009977340698,
-0.9329754710197449,
-0.09059077501296997,
-0.07226009666919708,
-0.1464100033044815,
0.05434860661625862,
0.5733726024627686,
-0.5166283845901489,
0.2481703758239746,
0.6708574295043945,
-0.17723166942596436,
0.44133445620536804,
0.014123385772109032,
0.07533659785985947,
-0.9510456919670105,
-0.09174976497888565,
-0.22302985191345215,
-0.07282387465238571,
-0.6964086294174194,
0.16477663815021515,
0.01906541921198368,
0.45310840010643005,
-0.17876531183719635,
0.699837327003479,
-0.6613979339599609,
0.023104194551706314,
-0.1445455253124237,
0.46553122997283936,
0.25791212916374207,
0.4177927076816559,
0.258714497089386,
0.6093717813491821,
0.45254430174827576,
-0.6945886611938477,
0.0746762752532959,
0.5742197632789612,
-0.15179282426834106,
0.1096593588590622,
-0.4187874495983124,
0.3574109673500061,
0.13999724388122559,
-0.14093856513500214,
-0.8808796405792236,
-0.14935065805912018,
0.45712295174598694,
-0.4856041669845581,
0.04259578138589859,
-0.23011747002601624,
-0.28773513436317444,
-0.10756929218769073,
-0.2690487504005432,
0.40620332956314087,
0.20625370740890503,
-0.6479043960571289,
0.5064898729324341,
0.4325498938560486,
-0.19056975841522217,
-0.7483800053596497,
-0.6653531193733215,
-0.14983393251895905,
-0.10597137361764908,
-0.7299970388412476,
0.16310779750347137,
-0.2398783266544342,
-0.6091077923774719,
-0.03811877593398094,
-0.3250417411327362,
-0.21745114028453827,
0.29669246077537537,
0.3085687458515167,
0.3997451364994049,
-0.13107915222644806,
0.3120003342628479,
-0.03471582010388374,
0.14506930112838745,
0.08544795960187912,
-0.16926437616348267,
0.5406912565231323,
0.06913505494594574,
-0.8964294791221619,
-0.2866085469722748,
0.32082822918891907,
0.4668375253677368,
-0.23000569641590118,
0.8026278018951416,
0.2955872714519501,
-0.42558151483535767,
-0.15701140463352203,
-0.9710976481437683,
-0.511610746383667,
-0.4772929251194,
0.09643243253231049,
-0.3897882103919983,
-1.0260869264602661,
0.5947611927986145,
-0.11933568865060806,
0.0005441407556645572,
0.21578440070152283,
0.46746590733528137,
0.15399743616580963,
0.5745241641998291,
0.872126579284668,
0.015471440739929676,
0.16479668021202087,
0.03575555235147476,
0.21817119419574738,
-0.8763667345046997,
-0.380706787109375,
-0.4583331048488617,
0.110153429210186,
-0.35803303122520447,
-0.6127809286117554,
0.49541279673576355,
0.48168280720710754,
0.10701252520084381,
0.140384241938591,
-0.14275911450386047,
0.5473880767822266,
0.36114147305488586,
0.039747484028339386,
0.6560908555984497,
-0.2307969331741333,
-0.101004958152771,
-0.08098289370536804,
-0.7196010947227478,
-0.2207678109407425,
0.9871521592140198,
0.25240159034729004,
0.6182889342308044,
0.19573558866977692,
0.8131142258644104,
0.041496653109788895,
0.05132080614566803,
-0.8339340090751648,
0.33729562163352966,
0.2351953238248825,
-0.4785095155239105,
-0.5734212398529053,
-0.6588888168334961,
-0.6482958197593689,
0.3931128680706024,
-0.0967676118016243,
-0.7124971151351929,
0.32093214988708496,
-0.10021078586578369,
-0.4170210361480713,
0.2440456598997116,
-0.623785674571991,
0.727619469165802,
-0.11510638892650604,
-0.45386192202568054,
-0.11813481152057648,
-0.5050652027130127,
0.5784227252006531,
-0.5853597521781921,
0.435649037361145,
-0.19248348474502563,
-0.011558669619262218,
0.5396130681037903,
-0.2783416211605072,
0.8815348744392395,
0.026191867887973785,
-0.37733712792396545,
0.30389469861984253,
0.3051879107952118,
0.5929363965988159,
0.04451019689440727,
-0.18563421070575714,
0.162145733833313,
-0.07756094634532928,
-0.3286122977733612,
-0.4996681809425354,
0.5185702443122864,
-0.6596165299415588,
-0.6933350563049316,
-0.1618027687072754,
-0.7422094941139221,
-0.7697573900222778,
0.22135189175605774,
0.05675406754016876,
-0.11027585715055466,
-0.3089394271373749,
-0.07624541223049164,
0.7002959251403809,
-0.28283268213272095,
0.45352545380592346,
0.5763314366340637,
-0.11922125518321991,
-0.43261978030204773,
0.7489392161369324,
0.048615094274282455,
0.5874022841453552,
0.264364093542099,
0.014542062766849995,
-0.4668947756290436,
-0.7342709302902222,
-0.09710824489593506,
0.3491070568561554,
-0.7349238395690918,
-0.0572737418115139,
-0.628535270690918,
-0.33084285259246826,
-0.6757283210754395,
-0.042017485946416855,
-0.3883332908153534,
-0.2684582769870758,
-0.25369951128959656,
0.038976069539785385,
0.11467985808849335,
0.8216626644134521,
-0.28117913007736206,
0.041118476539850235,
-1.05424964427948,
0.19156116247177124,
0.3397808372974396,
0.1107001006603241,
0.09807540476322174,
-0.5033252835273743,
-0.13359488546848297,
-0.008227579295635223,
-0.31769827008247375,
-0.9227098822593689,
0.49182137846946716,
-0.06444582343101501,
0.8605241179466248,
0.21165792644023895,
0.2942109704017639,
0.9043428301811218,
-0.20628854632377625,
0.5565210580825806,
0.23946581780910492,
-1.149771809577942,
0.3812673091888428,
-0.25633326172828674,
0.10918305814266205,
0.5539142489433289,
0.36003485321998596,
-0.6779012084007263,
-0.6088432669639587,
-0.3268700838088989,
-0.944748044013977,
0.4670010507106781,
0.14157631993293762,
-0.16110388934612274,
0.1786395013332367,
0.3180226981639862,
0.25298479199409485,
0.3353620171546936,
-0.7822976112365723,
-0.10693946480751038,
0.18645690381526947,
-0.048157673329114914,
0.07343346625566483,
-0.06708011776208878,
-0.44811132550239563,
-0.24594368040561676,
0.6922524571418762,
-0.20965003967285156,
-0.08023571968078613,
0.2538803517818451,
-0.43225914239883423,
-0.24107562005519867,
0.3506263792514801,
0.4051075279712677,
1.1679304838180542,
0.055831000208854675,
0.3930806517601013,
0.3347092270851135,
-0.18804730474948883,
-0.030643831938505173,
-0.07635363191366196,
-0.12889371812343597,
-0.08006133884191513,
0.44904017448425293,
0.37363937497138977,
-0.2668345868587494,
-0.5691198110580444,
0.41680479049682617,
0.13911405205726624,
-0.21361330151557922,
-0.22841550409793854,
0.01567208766937256,
0.2719879448413849,
0.3755306601524353,
0.21315675973892212,
-0.08045285940170288,
-0.23001107573509216,
-0.502281129360199,
0.44976627826690674,
0.5662508010864258,
-0.5595331788063049,
-0.07889830321073532,
0.4901026487350464,
0.09261220693588257,
0.05104898288846016,
0.5026746988296509,
-0.16462618112564087,
-0.2518065869808197,
0.5555711388587952,
0.4004226624965668,
0.7206824421882629,
-0.27206775546073914,
0.3112621605396271,
0.051368460059165955,
0.4357158839702606,
-0.28209224343299866,
0.27302709221839905,
0.10091186314821243,
-1.0596293210983276,
-0.6255863904953003,
-0.2275211662054062,
-0.5354517102241516,
0.37011510133743286,
-0.6890965104103088,
0.1504911631345749,
-0.3643626868724823,
0.19492195546627045,
-0.1544182002544403,
0.08394423127174377,
-0.3051675260066986,
-0.2944008708000183,
-0.033061809837818146,
0.658301055431366,
-0.8194272518157959,
0.8155142664909363,
0.31661784648895264,
-0.5138421058654785,
-0.696247398853302,
0.34518542885780334,
0.3144162893295288,
-0.7644630074501038,
0.194929838180542,
0.11997903138399124,
-0.18890294432640076,
0.09972258657217026,
-0.5453135371208191,
-0.705564022064209,
1.0661022663116455,
0.32585400342941284,
-0.8667023181915283,
0.1438591182231903,
0.042910292744636536,
0.16441240906715393,
-0.22018128633499146,
0.10241463780403137,
0.41442257165908813,
0.6309928297996521,
0.2715541422367096,
-1.0277403593063354,
0.20456573367118835,
0.08413620293140411,
-0.43381747603416443,
0.07148445397615433,
-0.6901568174362183,
0.7561770081520081,
-0.4436052441596985,
-0.03500756993889809,
0.22781170904636383,
0.4203703999519348,
0.6220508217811584,
0.48064377903938293,
0.6740350127220154,
0.3034299612045288,
1.1054953336715698,
0.017321208491921425,
0.2848588228225708,
-0.15958094596862793,
0.2275865077972412,
1.332410216331482,
-0.6416888236999512,
0.7418559789657593,
0.723934531211853,
0.10473860055208206,
0.1943739354610443,
0.48245367407798767,
-0.20739108324050903,
0.4095762372016907,
0.13671573996543884,
-0.5057056546211243,
-0.6918195486068726,
-0.22471041977405548,
-0.41973552107810974,
0.3588429093360901,
0.5123826861381531,
-0.03760123625397682,
-0.17613084614276886,
-0.16449695825576782,
-0.0026312819682061672,
0.04079950600862503,
-0.09732931852340698,
0.815796971321106,
0.24497753381729126,
-0.9165536761283875,
0.6086745262145996,
-0.3028930723667145,
0.42545175552368164,
-0.28618761897087097,
-0.19823472201824188,
-0.32199159264564514,
0.16312241554260254,
-0.17400866746902466,
-0.52731853723526,
0.21886633336544037,
-0.28738605976104736,
-0.15013116598129272,
0.023163454607129097,
0.7605224847793579,
-0.6134177446365356,
-0.266787588596344,
0.5961718559265137,
1.3695461750030518,
0.22475410997867584,
-0.23008334636688232,
-0.4715951979160309,
0.05217374116182327,
-0.007411876227706671,
0.14264407753944397,
0.2172117382287979,
0.3930809497833252,
-0.01205607783049345,
0.7666659355163574,
0.5105245113372803,
0.1372838020324707,
0.059841278940439224,
0.23279669880867004,
1.0004432201385498,
-0.654260516166687,
0.019747385755181313,
-1.061140537261963,
0.2559501826763153,
0.0449250154197216,
0.09232425689697266,
0.8627639412879944,
0.41385626792907715,
0.9426212906837463,
0.15788054466247559,
1.0181031227111816,
0.1160653829574585,
0.4997543394565582,
-0.7300693392753601,
0.7357259392738342,
-0.6777887344360352,
0.7792604565620422,
-0.2920569181442261,
-0.6882662177085876,
-0.319903165102005,
0.3725571930408478,
-0.12104125320911407,
0.07432343065738678,
0.7621057033538818,
0.9084122776985168,
0.20634528994560242,
-0.1479712277650833,
0.5143373012542725,
0.18937666714191437,
0.270536869764328,
0.6838634014129639,
1.1774994134902954,
-0.11079563945531845,
0.5817965865135193,
-0.18938690423965454,
-0.19177214801311493,
-0.062485210597515106,
-0.641499400138855,
-1.0429790019989014,
-0.47103822231292725,
-0.32632386684417725,
-0.35253825783729553,
0.1970548927783966,
0.7334397435188293,
0.6980026364326477,
-0.8592906594276428,
-0.2746831178665161,
-0.2119167298078537,
0.7174702286720276,
-0.34793034195899963,
-0.1465766578912735,
0.23024407029151917,
-0.5255099534988403,
-0.536880373954773,
0.9474034309387207,
0.15789063274860382,
0.13946844637393951,
-0.43717044591903687,
-0.1673722118139267,
-0.21922758221626282,
0.033172618597745895,
0.29477015137672424,
0.2953694462776184,
-0.7684401869773865,
-0.2611948847770691,
0.3708842098712921,
0.28601300716400146,
0.07547963410615921,
0.6427960991859436,
-0.6490792632102966,
0.3189825117588043,
0.6289828419685364,
0.6788667440414429,
0.25547006726264954,
0.08996831625699997,
0.6652814745903015,
-0.9464099407196045,
-0.0007215613732114434,
0.23680825531482697,
0.13091211020946503,
0.2550223171710968,
-0.24220861494541168,
0.5758633017539978,
0.4139147102832794,
-0.6564883589744568,
-0.8410005569458008,
0.36626631021499634,
-0.7029743194580078,
-0.5598032474517822,
1.1478177309036255,
-0.2973339855670929,
-0.01818769983947277,
-0.6527266502380371,
0.2211746871471405,
0.30763009190559387,
-0.043590791523456573,
1.0586951971054077,
1.002614140510559,
-0.2379240244626999,
-0.2828397750854492,
-0.68400639295578,
0.39705973863601685,
0.4927792251110077,
-0.8987460732460022,
0.34192192554473877,
0.6249051094055176,
0.3145381212234497,
0.3635075092315674,
0.749496579170227,
-0.15039341151714325,
-0.017104683443903923,
-0.03489698842167854,
0.13337229192256927,
-0.07616697251796722,
-0.5916744470596313,
-0.34828442335128784,
0.14602789282798767,
0.31148993968963623,
-0.26247546076774597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00345v1 | IndiVec: An Exploration of Leveraging Large Language Models for Media Bias Detection with Fine-Grained Bias Indicators | 2024-02-01T05:20:07 | 2024-02-01T05:20:07 | Luyang Lin, Lingzhi Wang, Xiaoyan Zhao, Jing Li, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study focuses on media bias detection, crucial in today's era of
influential social media platforms shaping individual attitudes and opinions.
In contrast to prior work that primarily relies on training specific models
tailored to particular datasets, resulting in limited adaptability and subpar
performance on out-of-domain data, we introduce a general bias detection
framework, IndiVec, built upon large language models. IndiVec begins by
constructing a fine-grained media bias database, leveraging the robust
instruction-following capabilities of large language models and vector database
techniques. When confronted with new input for bias detection, our framework
automatically selects the most relevant indicator from the vector database and
employs majority voting to determine the input's bias label. IndiVec excels
compared to previous methods due to its adaptability (demonstrating consistent
performance across diverse datasets from various sources) and explainability
(providing explicit top-k indicators to interpret bias predictions).
Experimental results on four political bias datasets highlight IndiVec's
significant superiority over baselines. Furthermore, additional experiments and
analysis provide profound insights into the framework's effectiveness. | [
-0.7819926738739014,
-0.723977267742157,
0.4066303074359894,
0.2656189799308777,
-0.029194219037890434,
-0.04639345034956932,
-0.6519417762756348,
-0.042679768055677414,
0.10373476892709732,
0.21944589912891388,
-0.6209803819656372,
-0.6966267824172974,
-0.7524470686912537,
-0.35222992300987244,
-0.63435959815979,
1.0641050338745117,
0.2206786572933197,
0.29982689023017883,
0.009364469908177853,
-0.46639496088027954,
-0.3063879907131195,
-0.1419958472251892,
-0.3250886797904968,
-0.4339975416660309,
0.18219442665576935,
0.6262094378471375,
0.5431362390518188,
0.46322643756866455,
0.24332481622695923,
0.11315254122018814,
-0.07449286431074142,
0.17029134929180145,
-0.6707083582878113,
-0.11749961227178574,
-0.5182237029075623,
-0.30588197708129883,
-0.0034551939461380243,
0.11357168853282928,
0.5521424412727356,
0.4312448501586914,
0.28508326411247253,
0.3681860566139221,
0.25495249032974243,
0.9249773621559143,
-1.0237336158752441,
-0.015623645856976509,
-0.9504330158233643,
0.047804541885852814,
-0.3938405513763428,
-0.42992037534713745,
-0.5687800645828247,
-0.5001717805862427,
-0.23015673458576202,
-0.13950645923614502,
0.2410615086555481,
-0.3809206783771515,
0.4872409403324127,
0.11146733909845352,
-0.5207789540290833,
-0.5414441227912903,
-0.9099791646003723,
0.7466115355491638,
-0.46153393387794495,
0.45428577065467834,
0.44740840792655945,
0.1642298549413681,
-0.18005512654781342,
-0.4178031086921692,
-0.5792508721351624,
0.1418401002883911,
0.38692763447761536,
0.18659727275371552,
-0.10365182161331177,
-0.11999807506799698,
0.08005204796791077,
0.3729310929775238,
-0.27453798055648804,
0.2943175733089447,
-0.16938486695289612,
0.0482962466776371,
0.37108126282691956,
-0.09263190627098083,
0.19968341290950775,
-0.12531468272209167,
-0.09575919806957245,
0.18289563059806824,
-0.8641223907470703,
0.017043033614754677,
0.6719030737876892,
0.3735661804676056,
-0.14623156189918518,
0.5668778419494629,
-0.3078534007072449,
0.4273633658885956,
0.39505574107170105,
0.2155546396970749,
-0.08000536262989044,
0.008624439127743244,
-0.16852392256259918,
0.11188986152410507,
0.7567126154899597,
0.5117259621620178,
0.36868128180503845,
0.2503989338874817,
-0.1345646232366562,
0.4616507887840271,
0.003054141765460372,
-0.8503642678260803,
-0.249757319688797,
0.15570197999477386,
-0.8978611826896667,
-0.3079957067966461,
0.156046062707901,
-1.0289571285247803,
-0.9538360834121704,
-0.4467427432537079,
0.140652135014534,
-0.1325242668390274,
-0.46138930320739746,
-0.1784529834985733,
0.19780178368091583,
0.34799012541770935,
0.1590929478406906,
-0.825849175453186,
0.13638584315776825,
0.7494803667068481,
0.802006721496582,
-0.3701566457748413,
0.08075518906116486,
-0.7229270935058594,
-0.35285255312919617,
-0.47845718264579773,
0.9627910256385803,
-0.9780269861221313,
-0.09519573301076889,
0.5983696579933167,
0.08643069118261337,
0.4085756838321686,
-0.5992189645767212,
0.7222619652748108,
-0.45680826902389526,
0.11461351811885834,
-0.43611544370651245,
-0.6212992072105408,
0.08983482420444489,
0.20754599571228027,
-0.6940905451774597,
0.9415483474731445,
0.1458209604024887,
-1.0592784881591797,
0.811377227306366,
-0.6185661554336548,
-0.40570810437202454,
-0.242782324552536,
-0.30638182163238525,
-0.1985446810722351,
0.09940281510353088,
0.4897116422653198,
0.5992636680603027,
-0.33339956402778625,
0.2246706783771515,
-0.5585758090019226,
-0.29808565974235535,
0.3354038596153259,
-0.5112990140914917,
0.8789384961128235,
0.31009626388549805,
-0.3933216333389282,
0.204143226146698,
-0.7198381423950195,
-0.3427824378013611,
-0.1892261803150177,
-0.4811035096645355,
-0.5818084478378296,
0.1894247680902481,
0.19269061088562012,
0.26182821393013,
-0.18836826086044312,
-0.595565140247345,
0.10213199257850647,
0.1852821260690689,
0.40817901492118835,
0.8371167778968811,
0.1082882359623909,
0.8606008887290955,
0.16432739794254303,
0.3031831979751587,
-0.02546432428061962,
0.10160955041646957,
-0.0901440680027008,
-0.1959543079137802,
-0.7000214457511902,
-0.12253699451684952,
0.3389395475387573,
0.27533194422721863,
-0.5427108407020569,
0.352631151676178,
-0.05361057445406914,
-0.21083539724349976,
-0.45178765058517456,
0.23368015885353088,
-0.07132314145565033,
0.13298079371452332,
0.2522956430912018,
-0.18792682886123657,
-0.5438959002494812,
-0.7603787779808044,
-0.6632010340690613,
-0.030811507254838943,
-0.06660474836826324,
0.07700294256210327,
0.37266966700553894,
-0.3180875778198242,
0.7540127635002136,
-0.02507689967751503,
-0.4871738851070404,
-0.24097315967082977,
0.18341679871082306,
0.2628091871738434,
0.2031492441892624,
0.24172130227088928,
-0.5857731699943542,
-0.5664336085319519,
0.1819632649421692,
-0.7063973546028137,
-0.32876473665237427,
-0.3161449134349823,
-0.06991793215274811,
0.019081760197877884,
0.7237818837165833,
-0.20495863258838654,
0.4747030735015869,
0.6919865012168884,
-0.40192022919654846,
0.2971004247665405,
0.2681080102920532,
0.21588562428951263,
-0.7704644799232483,
-0.17214824259281158,
0.5542309880256653,
-0.1824331134557724,
-0.5202198624610901,
-0.4782140254974365,
0.17953453958034515,
0.37501847743988037,
-0.3342025876045227,
0.3963870406150818,
-0.31716302037239075,
-0.014733645133674145,
-0.39357447624206543,
-0.011793812736868858,
-0.09503882378339767,
0.14590266346931458,
-0.10935048758983612,
0.6065391898155212,
0.18079757690429688,
-0.5107676982879639,
-0.06730177253484726,
-0.1313924491405487,
-0.8563618659973145,
0.7745931148529053,
-0.22043520212173462,
0.1263277679681778,
-0.3741794526576996,
0.20216017961502075,
-1.0135409832000732,
-0.2808847725391388,
0.010834919288754463,
-0.5348559021949768,
0.24376067519187927,
-0.4383319616317749,
-0.26771897077560425,
-0.10746804624795914,
-0.30411675572395325,
0.16492654383182526,
0.12411560118198395,
-0.8926540017127991,
0.7638384103775024,
0.8453259468078613,
0.06274925917387009,
-0.677653968334198,
-0.5664860606193542,
-0.261452317237854,
-0.28277337551116943,
-0.3265741765499115,
0.0779305249452591,
0.26946184039115906,
-0.3518279194831848,
-0.07861050963401794,
0.0036575717385858297,
-0.0016069060657173395,
-0.2955249845981598,
0.30173447728157043,
0.04243914410471916,
-0.06939443945884705,
0.29556137323379517,
0.17588990926742554,
0.20239634811878204,
0.14665356278419495,
-0.24618148803710938,
0.6869009733200073,
-0.12875047326087952,
-0.2896865904331207,
-0.49718713760375977,
0.24619604647159576,
0.6828930974006653,
-0.2542206943035126,
0.4322247803211212,
0.8876489400863647,
-0.4290967881679535,
-0.5476438999176025,
-0.8045714497566223,
-0.3128439486026764,
-0.4106247127056122,
0.45038706064224243,
0.040757302194833755,
-0.6812223792076111,
0.7119614481925964,
-0.1373634785413742,
0.03543676808476448,
0.3862004578113556,
1.0158871412277222,
0.30021196603775024,
1.1422538757324219,
0.6095422506332397,
-0.5025158524513245,
0.7925391793251038,
-0.21736876666545868,
0.23129422962665558,
-0.7021695971488953,
0.002480862196534872,
-0.46244102716445923,
-0.28185293078422546,
-0.649745762348175,
-0.30332663655281067,
-0.0030160078313201666,
-0.26581981778144836,
-0.5169410109519958,
-0.03847598657011986,
-0.8044016361236572,
0.7033915519714355,
0.3612631559371948,
-0.10100146383047104,
0.31404271721839905,
0.1010827049612999,
0.18929001688957214,
-0.15673048794269562,
-0.4647703766822815,
-0.4424887001514435,
1.1422532796859741,
0.6733735203742981,
1.1686804294586182,
-0.21234679222106934,
0.1413184404373169,
0.7498313188552856,
0.9291026592254639,
-0.7893697619438171,
0.1513347178697586,
-0.24914272129535675,
-0.8842609524726868,
0.04242970421910286,
-0.21605032682418823,
-0.4036513864994049,
0.24101415276527405,
-0.40200141072273254,
-0.6582043766975403,
0.6498464941978455,
0.049953643232584,
-0.23291976749897003,
0.6287034749984741,
-0.7069351673126221,
0.738024890422821,
-0.0557500459253788,
-0.6924117207527161,
-0.20940570533275604,
-0.22222250699996948,
0.48300209641456604,
0.3762339949607849,
0.26471713185310364,
-0.29676544666290283,
0.24772335588932037,
0.6976205706596375,
0.10328137874603271,
0.7589371800422668,
-0.393899142742157,
0.0041959770023822784,
0.40034595131874084,
0.14345026016235352,
0.5746285319328308,
0.20762385427951813,
-0.030880067497491837,
0.06928981095552444,
-0.22879281640052795,
0.08009449392557144,
-0.22644446790218353,
0.9949061870574951,
-0.6719298958778381,
0.027671627700328827,
-0.1911994218826294,
-0.43335771560668945,
-0.17824847996234894,
0.008365022949874401,
0.3318300247192383,
0.3852825164794922,
-0.618781566619873,
0.5153506398200989,
0.775714635848999,
-0.2606155276298523,
0.23276983201503754,
0.3741176426410675,
-0.24475860595703125,
-0.28773704171180725,
0.7258859872817993,
0.1741899847984314,
0.023497475311160088,
0.25973033905029297,
0.22499369084835052,
-0.1757902204990387,
-0.31348365545272827,
-0.39813682436943054,
-0.03121650405228138,
-0.8667272329330444,
-0.38869696855545044,
-0.7375717759132385,
-0.029561014845967293,
-0.10319498926401138,
-0.16739633679389954,
-0.7659397125244141,
-0.09526283293962479,
-0.17169927060604095,
-0.07763277739286423,
0.16080808639526367,
0.8365434408187866,
-0.1464240401983261,
0.4456019401550293,
-0.03636845946311951,
0.2488226294517517,
0.3077141046524048,
0.6069278717041016,
-0.03462092950940132,
-0.5599085092544556,
-0.17614597082138062,
-0.13654935359954834,
-0.3114403486251831,
-0.8831613659858704,
0.3207412660121918,
0.05812492594122887,
0.02562638372182846,
0.9795542359352112,
0.05619078874588013,
0.14875128865242004,
-0.3092138469219208,
0.40847599506378174,
-0.011021033860743046,
-0.8817350268363953,
0.2876388430595398,
-0.5073075294494629,
0.2957189977169037,
0.8054474592208862,
0.42963412404060364,
-0.48459017276763916,
-0.2365277111530304,
-0.28395137190818787,
-0.6259337663650513,
0.42146238684654236,
-0.07247687876224518,
0.1454833596944809,
-0.08017943054437637,
0.02253398671746254,
0.14139842987060547,
0.010346904397010803,
-0.8101927042007446,
-0.1404939889907837,
-0.2768154740333557,
-0.35139673948287964,
0.37329864501953125,
-0.3964567482471466,
-0.20631664991378784,
-0.3074682950973511,
0.7507925629615784,
-0.31245964765548706,
0.07456017285585403,
0.03155007213354111,
-0.09650580585002899,
-0.2818458080291748,
0.37405893206596375,
0.3236771523952484,
0.7164644598960876,
-0.2622758746147156,
0.004682393744587898,
-0.028230948373675346,
-0.41595274209976196,
-0.1721397191286087,
0.034734487533569336,
-0.3459126949310303,
0.12072546780109406,
0.10243287682533264,
0.4795461595058441,
-0.27075812220573425,
-0.4910104274749756,
0.6881822347640991,
-0.14921502768993378,
0.07334551960229874,
-0.5392575263977051,
-0.35859301686286926,
0.10660089552402496,
0.14785411953926086,
0.49339941143989563,
-0.0290035642683506,
0.3480062484741211,
-0.7212504148483276,
0.13131718337535858,
0.8007730841636658,
-1.0117372274398804,
-0.2780400514602661,
0.5776656270027161,
0.3382677137851715,
0.10305079817771912,
0.1771400421857834,
-0.14308103919029236,
-0.4008393883705139,
0.628759503364563,
0.3380785286426544,
0.8530726432800293,
-0.2875363826751709,
0.24465994536876678,
0.30624592304229736,
0.5894497632980347,
-0.13668185472488403,
-0.07663261145353317,
0.1366586685180664,
-0.9724522233009338,
-0.4723753333091736,
-0.30255892872810364,
-0.15124547481536865,
0.580714762210846,
-0.6920313239097595,
0.42563045024871826,
-0.770586371421814,
-0.3635556101799011,
0.4056547284126282,
-0.13102956116199493,
-0.9081281423568726,
-0.04634299874305725,
0.3037469983100891,
0.9056442975997925,
-1.2021169662475586,
0.6435811519622803,
0.5404914021492004,
0.02982904575765133,
-0.5295677781105042,
0.1417047381401062,
0.47026965022087097,
-0.596875786781311,
0.2694624066352844,
0.3192955255508423,
0.010093054734170437,
-0.3941466212272644,
-0.8718543648719788,
-0.38085857033729553,
0.6833032369613647,
0.1905425637960434,
-0.40454959869384766,
0.37115544080734253,
-0.09196757525205612,
0.3285388648509979,
-0.8736729025840759,
0.45907917618751526,
1.0205605030059814,
0.37859025597572327,
-0.3411560356616974,
-0.3618967533111572,
-0.19569522142410278,
-0.1613566130399704,
-0.09757498651742935,
0.2540396749973297,
-0.5773907899856567,
0.7785921692848206,
0.13323909044265747,
-0.20481126010417938,
-0.45551228523254395,
0.7840021252632141,
-0.1894398033618927,
0.3867502510547638,
0.5289958119392395,
0.25991326570510864,
0.5758123397827148,
-0.17957109212875366,
0.8572104573249817,
-0.38072025775909424,
0.2990393340587616,
1.2287997007369995,
-0.3049604892730713,
0.5701779723167419,
0.43284130096435547,
0.005098853725939989,
0.6596705913543701,
0.49772846698760986,
0.13810132443904877,
0.46596869826316833,
0.04887320101261139,
-0.5306286811828613,
-0.21057963371276855,
-0.58481764793396,
-0.19296197593212128,
0.5168101787567139,
0.7828992605209351,
-0.6062663793563843,
-0.17772410809993744,
0.11530850827693939,
0.3046068251132965,
0.5216624736785889,
-0.7099218964576721,
0.5449139475822449,
-0.031126823276281357,
-0.680907130241394,
0.2544165253639221,
-0.050191812217235565,
0.9715403318405151,
-0.4574418365955353,
0.014116100035607815,
-0.3742533028125763,
0.6245030164718628,
-0.47708189487457275,
-0.8907572031021118,
0.017727229744195938,
0.13801191747188568,
-0.25650498270988464,
0.19636772572994232,
1.0091450214385986,
-0.48414623737335205,
-0.39442238211631775,
0.33972489833831787,
0.38579684495925903,
-0.358264297246933,
-0.22430667281150818,
-0.35484910011291504,
0.6384525299072266,
0.12344150990247726,
-0.16720204055309296,
0.26066410541534424,
0.6094912886619568,
-0.10008759051561356,
0.5699660778045654,
0.5248741507530212,
0.020576706156134605,
-0.14010925590991974,
0.301787793636322,
0.9865596890449524,
-0.20173925161361694,
-0.2558723986148834,
-0.7718483805656433,
0.30283454060554504,
-0.3062361776828766,
-0.3868241608142853,
0.7666157484054565,
0.48945102095603943,
1.0580061674118042,
-0.14978384971618652,
1.1624196767807007,
-0.17939907312393188,
0.5663456320762634,
-0.3496060371398926,
0.7204908728599548,
-0.11851616948843002,
0.07934876531362534,
-0.34765782952308655,
-0.9704201221466064,
-0.26199761033058167,
0.7376270890235901,
-0.38323739171028137,
-0.003606986254453659,
0.41619694232940674,
0.9765651226043701,
-0.26430460810661316,
0.17598536610603333,
-0.16327181458473206,
0.2954389452934265,
0.43638911843299866,
0.17628905177116394,
0.8970154523849487,
-0.10626905411481857,
0.3270750045776367,
-0.30296778678894043,
-0.45824646949768066,
-0.23588211834430695,
-0.754109799861908,
-1.2830853462219238,
-0.4962667226791382,
-0.19853274524211884,
-0.8413188457489014,
0.019966410472989082,
1.372279167175293,
0.7198008298873901,
-1.1575876474380493,
-0.2404497116804123,
0.08339112251996994,
0.3747160732746124,
-0.050268448889255524,
-0.33058029413223267,
0.40280139446258545,
-0.2444518655538559,
-0.8050864338874817,
0.015735259279608727,
0.3060184717178345,
-0.41087669134140015,
-0.6008395552635193,
0.12232129275798798,
-0.4263967275619507,
0.17623105645179749,
0.7703248858451843,
0.5205998420715332,
-0.38435110449790955,
-0.31058186292648315,
-0.22654250264167786,
0.03096921369433403,
0.04454765096306801,
1.277529239654541,
-0.6158077716827393,
0.6006080508232117,
0.5315536856651306,
0.7105391621589661,
0.44136738777160645,
0.20611578226089478,
0.31606242060661316,
-0.6221242547035217,
0.34505993127822876,
0.21439607441425323,
0.34979385137557983,
0.7258595824241638,
-0.18633872270584106,
0.46819502115249634,
-0.12603934109210968,
-0.7488752603530884,
-0.7242000699043274,
0.09403261542320251,
-0.7292798757553101,
-0.20576751232147217,
1.500802755355835,
0.46412670612335205,
-0.13142521679401398,
-0.21373626589775085,
-0.11150001734495163,
0.02104511857032776,
-0.6954151391983032,
0.8831281065940857,
0.6816701889038086,
0.25814542174339294,
-0.0992349162697792,
-0.8631389737129211,
0.5602519512176514,
0.09651154279708862,
-0.5545631051063538,
0.276731938123703,
0.5413277745246887,
0.3117585778236389,
-0.05682912841439247,
0.745606005191803,
-0.24727404117584229,
-0.030839331448078156,
-0.3289593756198883,
0.18549828231334686,
0.36941391229629517,
-0.40270546078681946,
-0.3674340844154358,
0.012881939299404621,
0.08044381439685822,
-0.01620134711265564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00322v1 | Bias in Opinion Summarisation from Pre-training to Adaptation: A Case Study in Political Bias | 2024-02-01T04:15:59 | 2024-02-01T04:15:59 | Nannan Huang, Haytham Fayek, Xiuzhen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Opinion summarisation aims to summarise the salient information and opinions
presented in documents such as product reviews, discussion forums, and social
media texts into short summaries that enable users to effectively understand
the opinions therein. Generating biased summaries has the risk of potentially
swaying public opinion. Previous studies focused on studying bias in opinion
summarisation using extractive models, but limited research has paid attention
to abstractive summarisation models. In this study, using political bias as a
case study, we first establish a methodology to quantify bias in abstractive
models, then trace it from the pre-trained models to the task of summarising
social media opinions using different models and adaptation methods. We find
that most models exhibit intrinsic bias. Using a social media text
summarisation dataset and contrasting various adaptation methods, we find that
tuning a smaller number of parameters is less biased compared to standard
fine-tuning; however, the diversity of topics in training data used for
fine-tuning is critical. | [
-0.5751180052757263,
-0.3500218987464905,
0.3483693301677704,
-0.03726603463292122,
-0.558017909526825,
0.05156644061207771,
-0.12664857506752014,
-0.2239420861005783,
0.4797748923301697,
0.3503701388835907,
-0.5705872774124146,
-0.2823507785797119,
-0.8364803194999695,
-0.07223720848560333,
-0.31544238328933716,
1.5584828853607178,
0.21448934078216553,
0.20853041112422943,
-0.03211609646677971,
-0.4606667160987854,
-0.20677967369556427,
-0.8403100371360779,
-0.1806337982416153,
-0.39354416728019714,
0.18597379326820374,
0.3585008978843689,
0.525393545627594,
0.1079091876745224,
0.23962713778018951,
0.15798373520374298,
-0.2245158553123474,
0.10341714322566986,
-0.8548415303230286,
-0.4147503674030304,
-0.44910353422164917,
-0.6952813267707825,
-0.4171527922153473,
0.2571614980697632,
0.36500003933906555,
0.5457430481910706,
0.2333734631538391,
0.39323678612709045,
0.2790481448173523,
1.2820672988891602,
-0.8591545820236206,
-0.11825591325759888,
-0.901951014995575,
0.037143900990486145,
0.1320798248052597,
-0.3198060393333435,
-0.16292189061641693,
-0.6211884617805481,
0.30574551224708557,
-0.5526425242424011,
0.5682641267776489,
-0.278704971075058,
0.6931867003440857,
0.08888848125934601,
-0.4883531630039215,
-0.5673538446426392,
-0.9060477614402771,
0.7585740089416504,
-0.76014643907547,
-0.11383076757192612,
0.1315055936574936,
0.16748861968517303,
0.41639333963394165,
-0.3700713813304901,
-0.370012491941452,
0.43507057428359985,
-0.004261197056621313,
0.4301934242248535,
0.08136211335659027,
-0.06817809492349625,
0.19855476915836334,
0.23959563672542572,
-0.026714380830526352,
-0.22842435538768768,
-0.7004580497741699,
0.03535567224025726,
0.7830151915550232,
-0.10807197540998459,
-0.15461421012878418,
-0.45122402906417847,
-0.07861197739839554,
-0.05316191911697388,
-0.7381577491760254,
-0.03347838297486305,
0.8651772737503052,
0.41617676615715027,
-0.3407873809337616,
0.4521535634994507,
-0.46741342544555664,
0.4416041076183319,
0.49019280076026917,
0.13824890553951263,
0.21857379376888275,
-0.5186401605606079,
0.004746121354401112,
0.3596785366535187,
0.6424986720085144,
0.8062894940376282,
0.7591913938522339,
0.44804632663726807,
-0.044429343193769455,
0.23813588917255402,
0.36527255177497864,
-0.7543085813522339,
-0.13917648792266846,
0.22199979424476624,
-0.9394224882125854,
-0.6442774534225464,
0.24250176548957825,
-0.9046803116798401,
-0.5876070857048035,
-0.3264559507369995,
0.2729308009147644,
-0.04762163758277893,
-0.3882595896720886,
0.04339856281876564,
-0.3768337070941925,
0.26252293586730957,
0.4998140335083008,
-0.8864739537239075,
0.21556353569030762,
0.642447292804718,
0.898192822933197,
-0.25727543234825134,
-0.02491169609129429,
-0.08121120184659958,
-0.05145684629678726,
-0.2595587372779846,
1.0811247825622559,
-0.343265175819397,
-0.4363144040107727,
0.014093558304011822,
-0.035115160048007965,
0.1243380755186081,
-0.5599868893623352,
0.2627803385257721,
-0.32478511333465576,
0.3799285888671875,
-0.6070392727851868,
-0.3239803612232208,
-0.09710945188999176,
0.030450263991951942,
-0.48206087946891785,
0.6129274964332581,
-0.0021558552980422974,
-1.1897192001342773,
0.794830322265625,
-0.7103963494300842,
-0.7154605388641357,
-0.6921045184135437,
-0.14844517409801483,
-0.37115922570228577,
0.46370238065719604,
0.6043612360954285,
0.3539848029613495,
0.04994332790374756,
0.11271782219409943,
-0.45576605200767517,
-0.2044614553451538,
0.1487257331609726,
-0.04388263449072838,
0.7875739336013794,
0.04482138156890869,
-0.1941511332988739,
0.2072303742170334,
-0.5211077928543091,
-0.4977288246154785,
-0.16742448508739471,
-0.04279729723930359,
-0.6711238026618958,
0.18308956921100616,
0.023298759013414383,
0.48865726590156555,
-0.1002071350812912,
-0.21566279232501984,
0.004297810606658459,
-0.37470343708992004,
0.49277156591415405,
1.0603872537612915,
0.3715507686138153,
0.8392745852470398,
-0.39514297246932983,
0.27887246012687683,
0.23137784004211426,
0.04562528431415558,
-0.05165128782391548,
-0.048532482236623764,
-0.5404449105262756,
0.215096116065979,
0.5365138053894043,
0.36387112736701965,
-0.5378445982933044,
0.1431809365749359,
-0.4067714512348175,
-0.3249829411506653,
-0.6243287920951843,
0.09694793075323105,
0.08878938108682632,
0.3220095932483673,
-0.030740661546587944,
-0.38791123032569885,
-0.429627001285553,
-0.9986333847045898,
-0.8201339840888977,
-0.4546622633934021,
-0.1494826078414917,
0.2577507495880127,
0.8472980856895447,
0.07994949817657471,
0.8812940120697021,
-0.41401535272598267,
-0.2642304003238678,
-0.3479703366756439,
0.42342865467071533,
0.10659690946340561,
0.17418749630451202,
0.6711498498916626,
-0.7006920576095581,
-0.288169264793396,
-0.1971687376499176,
-0.5266703367233276,
-0.22811925411224365,
-0.422523558139801,
-0.2654672861099243,
0.15078000724315643,
0.20867924392223358,
-0.39638233184814453,
0.4030917286872864,
0.38279348611831665,
-0.13039706647396088,
0.5072425007820129,
0.2046390175819397,
0.20868761837482452,
-1.3308736085891724,
-0.08733434975147247,
0.21015867590904236,
-0.501990020275116,
-0.4242056608200073,
-0.288932740688324,
-0.14243437349796295,
0.2605392336845398,
-0.5344021916389465,
0.20778024196624756,
-0.5267019271850586,
-0.16136100888252258,
-0.6175200343132019,
0.012274268083274364,
0.029616881161928177,
0.25420570373535156,
0.21082061529159546,
0.4626977741718292,
0.1751352846622467,
-0.5485915541648865,
-0.19289521872997284,
0.16786602139472961,
-0.504612147808075,
0.6304690837860107,
-0.6314131021499634,
0.19374635815620422,
-0.34195759892463684,
0.12431152164936066,
-0.9092980027198792,
-0.20055922865867615,
0.06860329210758209,
-0.46470001339912415,
-0.0558803416788578,
-0.2967492341995239,
-0.11398237198591232,
-0.03518624231219292,
-0.6411528587341309,
0.16295838356018066,
0.46848273277282715,
-0.30505332350730896,
0.6643276810646057,
0.7249846458435059,
-0.342689573764801,
-0.4307532012462616,
-0.5130936503410339,
-0.3840295672416687,
-0.3881581723690033,
-0.07815476506948471,
0.3309759497642517,
0.17596584558486938,
-0.4648430049419403,
0.04883524402976036,
-0.40009433031082153,
0.18684832751750946,
-0.162567600607872,
0.18177586793899536,
-0.09131886065006256,
-0.09237773716449738,
-0.18077313899993896,
0.27292922139167786,
0.14576280117034912,
0.29861128330230713,
0.1376904994249344,
0.33578136563301086,
0.05625751614570618,
-0.22371795773506165,
-0.16413384675979614,
0.36992332339286804,
0.685498058795929,
0.10393191874027252,
0.568479597568512,
0.17009367048740387,
-0.26147133111953735,
-0.2687884569168091,
-0.4744790196418762,
-0.4292277693748474,
-0.36885350942611694,
0.5200775265693665,
0.1808890402317047,
-0.554180383682251,
0.5770361423492432,
-0.21669158339500427,
0.27305516600608826,
0.49888262152671814,
0.7481006383895874,
-0.1262802928686142,
0.9324089884757996,
0.6992884874343872,
-0.4736272096633911,
0.6430202722549438,
-0.13385601341724396,
0.04862163960933685,
-0.4626690447330475,
0.23385563492774963,
-0.42254769802093506,
-0.40416356921195984,
-0.4906251132488251,
0.01081080548465252,
0.1596626490354538,
-0.15946631133556366,
0.1962970644235611,
-0.2414969950914383,
-0.42829519510269165,
0.6334185600280762,
0.41134318709373474,
0.3376237750053406,
0.020052112638950348,
0.17564831674098969,
0.47884610295295715,
0.07694976776838303,
-0.6483795642852783,
-0.5503097772598267,
1.229401707649231,
0.1218481957912445,
0.5512160062789917,
-0.18450649082660675,
0.4499201774597168,
0.6025928854942322,
0.6193643808364868,
-0.5944799780845642,
0.23670798540115356,
-0.09302514046430588,
-0.7008893489837646,
-0.1706421971321106,
-0.2935952842235565,
-0.3176867961883545,
0.29843461513519287,
-0.5354076623916626,
-0.2552413046360016,
0.44117334485054016,
0.265109658241272,
-0.40764033794403076,
0.188237264752388,
-0.6836386322975159,
0.595333993434906,
-0.13468454778194427,
-0.2545291483402252,
-0.28665539622306824,
-0.658897340297699,
0.5319374799728394,
-0.2169659435749054,
0.38323038816452026,
-0.08958449214696884,
0.34927690029144287,
1.1623740196228027,
-0.26689791679382324,
0.9777857065200806,
-0.36624547839164734,
0.3298359215259552,
0.14509226381778717,
-0.427532821893692,
0.32414498925209045,
-0.06768748909235,
-0.056291986256837845,
0.13446439802646637,
0.013237367384135723,
-0.5319934487342834,
-0.47193366289138794,
0.36319777369499207,
-1.1124074459075928,
-0.6688341498374939,
-0.45482271909713745,
-0.4972105920314789,
-0.107220359146595,
0.14294813573360443,
0.4038776457309723,
0.236812561750412,
-0.4818451404571533,
0.24048998951911926,
0.5688586831092834,
-0.09870754182338715,
0.33532440662384033,
0.32955414056777954,
-0.13332104682922363,
-0.27608442306518555,
0.48704785108566284,
0.5511303544044495,
0.33450865745544434,
0.14675742387771606,
0.36684101819992065,
0.047444991767406464,
-0.5285925269126892,
-0.1485152393579483,
-0.027789272367954254,
-0.7745212912559509,
0.005283928010612726,
-0.6012663841247559,
-0.1627579778432846,
-0.48821672797203064,
-0.2822389006614685,
-0.4097706079483032,
-0.7065298557281494,
-0.28357452154159546,
-0.42713040113449097,
0.35575389862060547,
0.8421992063522339,
0.030272560194134712,
0.6554683446884155,
-0.22402030229568481,
0.6428528428077698,
0.32952144742012024,
0.11251150071620941,
-0.1234501302242279,
-0.692245364189148,
-0.3405151963233948,
0.10027971118688583,
-0.4192398488521576,
-1.2958790063858032,
0.3166802227497101,
0.28947901725769043,
0.20709577202796936,
0.6171422004699707,
0.28660687804222107,
0.5883822441101074,
-0.34083959460258484,
0.7923793792724609,
0.040710482746362686,
-0.7282863259315491,
0.7756913900375366,
-0.4446081817150116,
0.5247964262962341,
0.9199474453926086,
0.5877450108528137,
0.0033747253473848104,
-0.39769402146339417,
-0.5284659266471863,
-0.9701187014579773,
0.6354745626449585,
0.043389659374952316,
0.23870156705379486,
0.2464817315340042,
0.3697667121887207,
0.457058846950531,
0.418470174074173,
-0.7268545627593994,
-0.1619817614555359,
-0.5578576922416687,
-0.032782260328531265,
-0.1214028000831604,
-0.43154680728912354,
-0.23990373313426971,
-0.4066169857978821,
0.7431289553642273,
-0.12232400476932526,
-0.02189900539815426,
0.10678890347480774,
-0.4681718051433563,
0.1062459722161293,
0.20413832366466522,
0.6500321626663208,
1.0305384397506714,
-0.32290929555892944,
-0.012850699946284294,
0.18341900408267975,
-0.4115457534790039,
-0.01711762510240078,
-0.03940396383404732,
-0.4322183132171631,
0.36787649989128113,
0.26290780305862427,
0.6727054119110107,
-0.07690703868865967,
-0.18339213728904724,
0.6698368191719055,
-0.1714581400156021,
-0.3590129017829895,
-0.18876244127750397,
-0.19939753413200378,
0.05096488073468208,
-0.09769277274608612,
0.40220287442207336,
0.3496064245700836,
0.2855586111545563,
-0.7838271260261536,
-0.024672430008649826,
0.436827152967453,
-0.3910731077194214,
-0.5668696165084839,
0.6193670630455017,
0.2920154631137848,
-0.07195688784122467,
-0.1168123111128807,
0.1624203473329544,
-0.3853311538696289,
0.4377164840698242,
0.23867551982402802,
1.009670376777649,
-0.12620879709720612,
0.2460423856973648,
0.13993918895721436,
0.5683145523071289,
-0.09986655414104462,
0.2488047480583191,
-0.0010119088692590594,
-0.629548966884613,
-0.252534419298172,
-0.4170128405094147,
-0.46377167105674744,
0.008321372792124748,
-0.9056660532951355,
0.284085214138031,
-0.5550211071968079,
-0.35847723484039307,
0.22215715050697327,
-0.18673282861709595,
-0.4663979709148407,
0.16849029064178467,
-0.10343848168849945,
0.7225012183189392,
-1.4842935800552368,
0.46014639735221863,
0.7007034420967102,
-0.14631296694278717,
-0.27143552899360657,
0.2112552523612976,
0.09755662083625793,
-0.4359974265098572,
0.2915889024734497,
0.13534440100193024,
-0.039688821882009506,
-0.5303354263305664,
-0.5829712152481079,
-0.36038345098495483,
0.5399880409240723,
0.37878867983818054,
-0.5069624781608582,
0.013188997283577919,
0.1594526171684265,
0.47971320152282715,
-0.6314321756362915,
0.27487146854400635,
0.4970393478870392,
0.0242751594632864,
-0.35596781969070435,
-0.4645359516143799,
0.006238219793885946,
-0.3438218832015991,
-0.09622927010059357,
-0.14738723635673523,
-0.657747209072113,
0.703003466129303,
0.026144441217184067,
0.024744490161538124,
-0.7092181444168091,
0.6699943542480469,
0.038071513175964355,
0.3831435739994049,
0.47666576504707336,
-0.04725012928247452,
0.5780267715454102,
-0.07996135950088501,
0.9320842027664185,
-0.560945451259613,
0.05880401283502579,
1.3595393896102905,
-0.4207197427749634,
0.6813438534736633,
0.7436544299125671,
0.165007084608078,
0.45211225748062134,
0.6484521627426147,
0.26749566197395325,
0.8686094880104065,
0.12116264551877975,
-0.009673981927335262,
0.10837991535663605,
0.12624284625053406,
-0.4858396053314209,
0.12522584199905396,
0.4243047535419464,
-0.6345894932746887,
-0.047015611082315445,
-0.1256856918334961,
-0.06601500511169434,
0.14155086874961853,
-0.6949196457862854,
1.0926395654678345,
0.14509062469005585,
-0.700006902217865,
0.12807069718837738,
-0.2719973027706146,
0.7689183354377747,
-0.39130163192749023,
0.15917561948299408,
-0.3672633469104767,
0.05529414862394333,
-0.4186345338821411,
-0.5414573550224304,
0.4956457316875458,
0.14567923545837402,
-0.5265068411827087,
-0.17929105460643768,
0.8466352224349976,
-0.013400396332144737,
-0.6191468238830566,
-0.03681958466768265,
0.6789181232452393,
-0.05798523873090744,
-0.21605928242206573,
-0.5269080996513367,
0.00971705187112093,
0.025035090744495392,
-0.5048756003379822,
0.47431445121765137,
0.44222167134284973,
-0.014033815823495388,
0.1958935707807541,
0.5161023139953613,
0.37279069423675537,
-0.09579100459814072,
0.08524294197559357,
1.0378996133804321,
-0.4850256145000458,
-0.8078686594963074,
-1.1433552503585815,
0.4646308720111847,
-0.40648403763771057,
-0.3583877682685852,
0.8302743434906006,
0.5353753566741943,
0.8789629340171814,
-0.25483381748199463,
1.2380092144012451,
0.23921532928943634,
0.4388144612312317,
-0.5562549829483032,
1.0814476013183594,
-0.29768937826156616,
0.07866941392421722,
-0.5317831635475159,
-0.8892024159431458,
0.04825824871659279,
0.6638748645782471,
-0.6971185803413391,
0.043882451951503754,
0.42003706097602844,
0.7245197892189026,
-0.15543004870414734,
0.1756412237882614,
-0.1560075879096985,
0.28656622767448425,
-0.1478276550769806,
0.15123768150806427,
0.7511297464370728,
-0.20925727486610413,
0.22091035544872284,
-0.19861996173858643,
-0.2928030490875244,
-0.27311426401138306,
-0.9969377517700195,
-1.2976895570755005,
-0.319294273853302,
-0.40043267607688904,
-0.5728304982185364,
0.39198780059814453,
0.9139388203620911,
0.8315659165382385,
-0.9850739240646362,
-0.22948728501796722,
0.11912885308265686,
0.2735026478767395,
-0.11860199272632599,
-0.206813782453537,
0.4198726713657379,
0.15159523487091064,
-0.41498225927352905,
-0.4500913619995117,
0.046441927552223206,
-0.18699944019317627,
-0.12371297180652618,
0.2248973548412323,
-0.13600046932697296,
0.32415804266929626,
0.7510842084884644,
0.21822601556777954,
-0.3655688166618347,
-0.2674982249736786,
-0.39480212330818176,
0.26843297481536865,
0.24802888929843903,
0.9761055111885071,
-0.5365700721740723,
0.31744128465652466,
0.4749610126018524,
0.41758155822753906,
0.6379051208496094,
0.3783555328845978,
0.8721536993980408,
-0.7222608327865601,
0.17476041615009308,
-0.02324674464762211,
0.253201425075531,
0.4503566026687622,
-0.21096855401992798,
0.18790416419506073,
0.06586962938308716,
-0.37707099318504333,
-0.8423495292663574,
0.17976270616054535,
-0.8249598741531372,
-0.4244222939014435,
1.201385498046875,
0.1997590810060501,
-0.29587721824645996,
-0.07254840433597565,
-0.3547501266002655,
0.2881694734096527,
-0.4065830707550049,
1.313727855682373,
0.735197901725769,
0.007794490549713373,
-0.12841854989528656,
-0.5582916736602783,
0.5651042461395264,
0.12295382469892502,
-0.8184662461280823,
0.2221890091896057,
0.3794429898262024,
0.4371950924396515,
-0.040812283754348755,
0.8781575560569763,
-0.04340061545372009,
0.3066158592700958,
-0.1818438023328781,
-0.03120603784918785,
0.21565459668636322,
-0.13185520470142365,
-0.5836718678474426,
0.3593160808086395,
-0.06629995256662369,
0.0114722466096282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01769v1 | Redefining "Hallucination" in LLMs: Towards a psychology-informed framework for mitigating misinformation | 2024-02-01T03:01:11 | 2024-02-01T03:01:11 | Elijah Berberette, Jack Hutchins, Amir Sadovnik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have become incredibly popular,
with ChatGPT for example being used by over a billion users. While these models
exhibit remarkable language understanding and logical prowess, a notable
challenge surfaces in the form of "hallucinations." This phenomenon results in
LLMs outputting misinformation in a confident manner, which can lead to
devastating consequences with such a large user base. However, we question the
appropriateness of the term "hallucination" in LLMs, proposing a psychological
taxonomy based on cognitive biases and other psychological phenomena. Our
approach offers a more fine-grained understanding of this phenomenon, allowing
for targeted solutions. By leveraging insights from how humans internally
resolve similar challenges, we aim to develop strategies to mitigate LLM
hallucinations. This interdisciplinary approach seeks to move beyond
conventional terminology, providing a nuanced understanding and actionable
pathways for improvement in LLM reliability. | [
-0.510437548160553,
-0.8958994746208191,
0.6801625490188599,
0.4468368887901306,
-0.14388665556907654,
0.08862191438674927,
-0.47294241189956665,
-0.6262320876121521,
0.4905979633331299,
0.4973560869693756,
-0.7990379333496094,
-0.31378716230392456,
-0.7285337448120117,
0.129669189453125,
-0.3916861414909363,
0.76412433385849,
0.13435322046279907,
0.16364635527133942,
-0.4335595369338989,
0.19276827573776245,
-0.7711676359176636,
-0.7965255379676819,
-0.5204896330833435,
-0.5599737167358398,
0.6441931128501892,
0.22405961155891418,
0.8135607838630676,
0.2826201319694519,
0.6316342353820801,
0.14653617143630981,
-0.03461898863315582,
0.19407765567302704,
-0.8156359791755676,
0.28268253803253174,
-0.0036802920512855053,
-0.5496131181716919,
-0.15218514204025269,
-0.1394730806350708,
0.28174862265586853,
1.074963927268982,
-0.5002928972244263,
-0.21292705833911896,
0.2937065660953522,
0.7507628798484802,
-0.6817340850830078,
-0.027598435059189796,
-0.8485611081123352,
0.4119025468826294,
0.02374265156686306,
-0.5212400555610657,
-0.5040942430496216,
-0.43629297614097595,
0.07008355855941772,
-0.4027723968029022,
0.1610986441373825,
-0.00011544249719008803,
0.5146167874336243,
0.44013622403144836,
-0.21233446896076202,
-0.5641995668411255,
-1.0137299299240112,
0.5730766654014587,
-0.4591832160949707,
0.6698432564735413,
0.6328538060188293,
0.2638148069381714,
-0.23235942423343658,
-0.4437173902988434,
-0.38458433747291565,
-0.32942330837249756,
-0.10295788943767548,
-0.11701254546642303,
-0.12403038144111633,
-0.08707321435213089,
0.3249952495098114,
0.07749765366315842,
-0.6185542345046997,
0.07351585477590561,
-0.49746108055114746,
-0.49214714765548706,
0.5854984521865845,
0.2899242341518402,
0.301067590713501,
0.06472403556108475,
-0.22600029408931732,
0.42960125207901,
-0.7830902338027954,
-0.6771960854530334,
0.27418017387390137,
0.2523764669895172,
0.31368234753608704,
0.5513277649879456,
-0.08381456136703491,
0.1212913990020752,
0.04597654566168785,
-0.07655686140060425,
0.2352578341960907,
0.21062549948692322,
-0.24386325478553772,
0.4616212844848633,
0.5078960657119751,
0.5613986849784851,
0.4074711501598358,
-0.6917996406555176,
-0.17385318875312805,
0.462517648935318,
0.7324854731559753,
-0.7116912007331848,
-0.2047473043203354,
0.39392977952957153,
-0.49113184213638306,
-0.2265416830778122,
-0.023172054439783096,
-0.8482521772384644,
-1.0453248023986816,
-0.4874292016029358,
0.4284364879131317,
-0.5359900593757629,
-0.44439175724983215,
0.32904621958732605,
0.08038849383592606,
-0.010394137352705002,
0.30006271600723267,
-0.888047456741333,
0.3476451337337494,
0.7761258482933044,
0.874729335308075,
-0.32623860239982605,
-0.5410135984420776,
-0.08575311303138733,
0.21355363726615906,
-0.3312596082687378,
0.8381566405296326,
-0.31928008794784546,
-0.6066994071006775,
0.17598433792591095,
-0.06639856845140457,
0.027360429987311363,
-0.777896523475647,
0.41592937707901,
-0.2710130214691162,
0.24613834917545319,
-0.43348759412765503,
-0.505081832408905,
-0.21942083537578583,
0.3197971284389496,
-0.41304823756217957,
0.8033804893493652,
-0.19446811079978943,
-0.6476454138755798,
0.30578699707984924,
-0.3452771306037903,
-0.3640194535255432,
0.10449341684579849,
-0.31528332829475403,
-0.11792460829019547,
0.41671988368034363,
-0.053268346935510635,
0.3115001618862152,
-0.2739045321941376,
0.4745716452598572,
-0.17336885631084442,
-0.5888994932174683,
0.5116221308708191,
-0.4877298176288605,
0.32077524065971375,
0.2431793510913849,
-0.4126395285129547,
0.12020904570817947,
-0.6407452821731567,
-0.24842804670333862,
-0.027805062010884285,
0.011467604897916317,
-0.359320729970932,
0.15188099443912506,
-0.11576272547245026,
0.006159135140478611,
0.2218727022409439,
-0.12118103355169296,
-0.0013690810883417726,
-0.35726678371429443,
0.1929306834936142,
0.8567209243774414,
-0.001281946199014783,
0.35686635971069336,
-0.5328843593597412,
0.3405108153820038,
0.09375036507844925,
0.40008145570755005,
0.11652112752199173,
-0.3101995587348938,
-0.5682205557823181,
-0.21633635461330414,
-0.35514315962791443,
0.5678613185882568,
-0.4534663259983063,
0.5198360085487366,
-0.1427706480026245,
-0.5733181834220886,
-0.34788891673088074,
0.10485675185918808,
0.05549383908510208,
0.4942222237586975,
0.2803770899772644,
-0.3047710955142975,
-0.8234149813652039,
-0.922843873500824,
-0.35977548360824585,
-0.2866162061691284,
0.01806286722421646,
0.08212941884994507,
0.5172900557518005,
-0.8198197484016418,
0.6690201163291931,
-0.37673965096473694,
-0.637012779712677,
-0.2247762680053711,
0.2866227626800537,
-0.023419342935085297,
0.18269723653793335,
0.055195558816194534,
-0.6354228258132935,
0.0034659975208342075,
-0.09791190177202225,
-1.0582270622253418,
-0.15988636016845703,
-0.47063055634498596,
-0.03760544955730438,
0.3986939489841461,
0.5916435718536377,
-0.8311136364936829,
0.4525832533836365,
0.14519241452217102,
-0.29599735140800476,
0.9222103357315063,
-0.03147287294268608,
0.07935991138219833,
-0.8518894910812378,
-0.23820173740386963,
-0.035577110946178436,
0.2894308269023895,
-0.6161264777183533,
-0.20245999097824097,
-0.29842430353164673,
0.26768752932548523,
-0.3109678626060486,
0.2666186988353729,
-0.3759061098098755,
-0.029742583632469177,
-0.4571102559566498,
0.3553965985774994,
-0.40036365389823914,
0.2270214706659317,
0.07465583831071854,
0.5848551988601685,
0.6463302969932556,
-0.6705226898193359,
0.4636610448360443,
0.1657334566116333,
-0.2758430242538452,
0.6008542776107788,
-0.2960091829299927,
-0.03081856109201908,
-0.4241871237754822,
0.29484593868255615,
-0.7863481640815735,
-0.39286136627197266,
0.46760621666908264,
-0.47637733817100525,
-0.14940036833286285,
0.30926313996315,
-0.6968430280685425,
-0.22622019052505493,
-0.28990438580513,
0.3121940791606903,
0.37183743715286255,
-0.5333194732666016,
0.5738058686256409,
0.3402136564254761,
0.11020860821008682,
-0.42780959606170654,
-0.945001482963562,
0.42395147681236267,
-0.5115842819213867,
-0.5767027139663696,
0.200397327542305,
-0.16880135238170624,
-0.5714239478111267,
-0.25560057163238525,
-0.24863018095493317,
0.19783733785152435,
0.15549364686012268,
0.46803316473960876,
0.24490633606910706,
-0.08568491786718369,
0.5946111083030701,
-0.47526296973228455,
-0.05435504764318466,
0.5434427261352539,
-0.06466089189052582,
0.9010719656944275,
-0.05859144777059555,
-0.5589339733123779,
-0.4827004671096802,
0.3813820481300354,
0.4297119975090027,
0.3013575077056885,
0.9155035614967346,
0.5847814083099365,
-0.8020573258399963,
-0.33303001523017883,
-0.7899804711341858,
-0.7575154304504395,
-0.40832340717315674,
0.4087594151496887,
-0.3581455945968628,
-0.7921350002288818,
0.658065676689148,
-0.11007540673017502,
-0.28293266892433167,
0.12946100533008575,
0.718018114566803,
-0.1800675094127655,
0.9464102387428284,
0.7291863560676575,
0.004660553764551878,
0.16630661487579346,
0.09732431918382645,
0.5649685859680176,
-0.6011180877685547,
-0.6366659998893738,
-0.27153414487838745,
-0.2290174961090088,
-0.5890870690345764,
-0.29308006167411804,
0.10890518128871918,
0.06567090004682541,
-0.18415194749832153,
-0.1488686203956604,
-0.6286674737930298,
0.4080723822116852,
0.1802651584148407,
0.15393634140491486,
0.4218381345272064,
0.22833004593849182,
0.1932724565267563,
-0.39470282196998596,
-0.4508235454559326,
-0.7948395013809204,
0.9593233466148376,
0.4660990834236145,
1.0985701084136963,
0.17456093430519104,
0.7375194430351257,
0.4335193336009979,
0.3131175935268402,
-0.8873872756958008,
0.682664692401886,
0.47522225975990295,
-0.6039108633995056,
-0.21485364437103271,
-0.3492419719696045,
-0.8874232769012451,
0.37729859352111816,
-0.24876824021339417,
-1.4067919254302979,
0.13430999219417572,
-0.05777013301849365,
-0.14421935379505157,
0.3395070731639862,
-0.4657549560070038,
0.5283622145652771,
-0.39585328102111816,
-0.33268141746520996,
-0.47580990195274353,
-0.4275248646736145,
0.5964810848236084,
-0.2558467388153076,
0.298086553812027,
-0.0623503215610981,
-0.015376368537545204,
0.6639947891235352,
-0.13763177394866943,
1.2142810821533203,
0.1151440292596817,
-0.46149808168411255,
0.039479341357946396,
0.3649147152900696,
0.4631507694721222,
-0.043062690645456314,
0.07321358472108841,
0.1823134571313858,
-0.08069393783807755,
-0.09808459132909775,
-0.7165630459785461,
0.6982325315475464,
-0.782942533493042,
-0.7209423184394836,
-0.4773370027542114,
-0.6645680069923401,
-0.45178982615470886,
-0.12469393759965897,
0.3456668555736542,
-0.05937466025352478,
-0.3700375556945801,
0.1359216868877411,
0.9375060200691223,
-0.22484427690505981,
0.025158438831567764,
0.255401074886322,
-0.7051730751991272,
-0.17840160429477692,
0.985785961151123,
0.13199147582054138,
0.0696246549487114,
0.008617938496172428,
-0.050266630947589874,
-0.2978419363498688,
-0.5471389889717102,
0.3295879065990448,
0.4976915121078491,
-1.0626672506332397,
0.1730176955461502,
-0.7610077857971191,
-0.5124832987785339,
-0.40361350774765015,
-0.25086045265197754,
-0.2734020948410034,
-0.09578323364257812,
-0.5217233896255493,
-0.24524371325969696,
0.23016628623008728,
0.7823727130889893,
-0.1295660436153412,
0.4388602674007416,
-0.45783960819244385,
0.3382616341114044,
0.021745407953858376,
0.5072457194328308,
0.16807568073272705,
-0.49927598237991333,
-0.22086292505264282,
-0.059927985072135925,
-0.3822193443775177,
-0.9677596688270569,
0.43268731236457825,
-0.2571529448032379,
0.7566457986831665,
0.5395618677139282,
-0.11128193885087967,
0.759069561958313,
-0.2112034112215042,
0.8218691945075989,
0.3952785134315491,
-0.7808321118354797,
0.5425651669502258,
-0.086000956594944,
-0.0803605169057846,
0.43165361881256104,
0.5777568221092224,
-1.0059744119644165,
-0.4898279309272766,
-0.579842209815979,
-0.9991794228553772,
0.24549825489521027,
0.09686854481697083,
0.1332150250673294,
-0.22801685333251953,
0.23419825732707977,
0.43203723430633545,
0.1974826604127884,
-0.9493680596351624,
-0.03472999855875969,
-0.07736602425575256,
-0.12104780972003937,
-0.061741698533296585,
-0.4961032271385193,
-0.3718279004096985,
-0.13224734365940094,
0.9002491235733032,
-0.03222543001174927,
0.27904680371284485,
0.14898857474327087,
-0.500967264175415,
-0.25629565119743347,
0.11338010430335999,
0.6192877292633057,
1.0161243677139282,
-0.25496286153793335,
0.3028566241264343,
0.13786423206329346,
-0.5974429845809937,
-0.009180898778140545,
-0.20688465237617493,
0.017086826264858246,
-0.07149380445480347,
0.40047088265419006,
0.670414388179779,
0.12648673355579376,
-0.7629457712173462,
0.1954517960548401,
0.06361372768878937,
-0.35547366738319397,
-0.5047097206115723,
-0.06366432458162308,
0.1627303510904312,
0.3439633846282959,
0.589436411857605,
-0.10225421190261841,
0.10852792859077454,
-0.7202444076538086,
0.2497267723083496,
0.4235173463821411,
-0.4206046164035797,
-0.13499781489372253,
0.5830480456352234,
0.003005376085639,
-0.4122636616230011,
0.5824944376945496,
-0.012232999317348003,
-0.2944628596305847,
0.4737672209739685,
0.6050445437431335,
1.07465660572052,
-0.1128644198179245,
0.23455365002155304,
0.21605591475963593,
0.6997925043106079,
-0.4093727171421051,
0.23331761360168457,
0.24036242067813873,
-0.9292569756507874,
-0.20202000439167023,
-0.5050427913665771,
-0.3023128807544708,
0.3085554242134094,
-0.5234346985816956,
0.25417450070381165,
-0.4353179633617401,
-0.28988367319107056,
-0.2718675136566162,
-0.28095752000808716,
-0.35575369000434875,
0.06461364030838013,
0.531399130821228,
0.8636503219604492,
-0.874986469745636,
0.5401830673217773,
0.41625866293907166,
-0.42972859740257263,
-0.20788824558258057,
0.41259291768074036,
0.24272048473358154,
-0.6631403565406799,
0.6138138175010681,
0.3615776598453522,
-0.2735867500305176,
-0.29278895258903503,
-0.5264396071434021,
-0.648247241973877,
1.116854190826416,
0.18115465342998505,
-0.6439160704612732,
0.04692208394408226,
0.47034943103790283,
0.5610883235931396,
-0.5570363402366638,
0.08272040635347366,
0.7929152846336365,
0.6218141317367554,
0.14588968455791473,
-0.704058825969696,
0.12837380170822144,
0.14954189956188202,
0.08157709240913391,
-0.10674698650836945,
-0.4283948242664337,
0.4282015860080719,
-0.285727858543396,
-0.29586538672447205,
-0.051966410130262375,
0.5955127477645874,
0.4778202474117279,
0.40402302145957947,
0.4324500262737274,
0.30305907130241394,
1.1750411987304688,
-0.1298319697380066,
0.6856340169906616,
-0.09352654963731766,
0.08237507939338684,
1.2245802879333496,
-0.41670000553131104,
0.6724053025245667,
0.9443986415863037,
-0.02374783158302307,
0.20845194160938263,
0.8300339579582214,
0.020978758111596107,
0.46457070112228394,
0.5805245637893677,
-0.23057921230793,
-0.28306642174720764,
-0.20127683877944946,
-0.4385441541671753,
0.3038926124572754,
0.7579044699668884,
-0.3080667555332184,
-0.18118472397327423,
0.2530496418476105,
-0.11479249596595764,
0.2654300928115845,
-0.16382873058319092,
0.7029865384101868,
0.2279428243637085,
-0.4736688435077667,
0.679969310760498,
-0.40200600028038025,
0.7967384457588196,
-0.3477418124675751,
0.2177778035402298,
-0.38677483797073364,
0.11797580868005753,
-0.46955978870391846,
-0.6176015138626099,
0.5469448566436768,
-0.19549892842769623,
-0.24137555062770844,
-0.18816833198070526,
0.7972405552864075,
-0.34801897406578064,
-0.5156990885734558,
0.5198109149932861,
0.7717147469520569,
0.471320778131485,
-0.29112690687179565,
-0.38922151923179626,
0.5430174469947815,
-0.015498524531722069,
-0.0034837136045098305,
0.25921517610549927,
0.607636570930481,
-0.09037952870130539,
1.062801480293274,
0.3001696467399597,
0.3550112545490265,
0.06944765150547028,
0.4095116853713989,
0.6879590749740601,
-0.8381233811378479,
-0.2663695514202118,
-1.1086012125015259,
0.30371832847595215,
-0.01641407050192356,
-0.0995582565665245,
0.6745852828025818,
0.5148932933807373,
0.739898681640625,
-0.05621303617954254,
0.943831741809845,
0.23079514503479004,
0.20616509020328522,
-0.4166637361049652,
0.917685329914093,
-0.5728321671485901,
0.7551870942115784,
-0.20864589512348175,
-1.1523851156234741,
-0.5139958262443542,
0.6630972027778625,
-0.40915971994400024,
0.020685294643044472,
0.8188193440437317,
1.0715709924697876,
0.079425148665905,
0.4208393096923828,
0.4740491807460785,
0.5031930804252625,
0.17655028402805328,
0.4695252478122711,
1.3657264709472656,
-0.059616029262542725,
0.5432507395744324,
-0.1826312392950058,
-0.10470690578222275,
-0.47344186902046204,
-0.732394278049469,
-0.9894022345542908,
-0.634594202041626,
-0.4465680718421936,
-0.35499700903892517,
0.17455603182315826,
1.014668345451355,
0.41465115547180176,
-0.5430945158004761,
-0.3964217007160187,
-0.15888939797878265,
0.27075910568237305,
-0.015452245250344276,
-0.26363322138786316,
0.04993410408496857,
-0.6807368993759155,
-0.3202296793460846,
0.06460176408290863,
0.36718064546585083,
0.09226637333631516,
-0.7317689657211304,
-0.22335471212863922,
0.11890561133623123,
0.2159397006034851,
0.7183496952056885,
-0.022437874227762222,
-1.0987064838409424,
-0.2348347008228302,
-0.11300951987504959,
-0.22961603105068207,
0.08577046543359756,
0.82352215051651,
-0.7710332274436951,
0.22489506006240845,
0.11529465019702911,
0.6102786064147949,
0.054884172976017,
-0.2942058742046356,
0.5128745436668396,
-0.3676014840602875,
0.03862840682268143,
0.26430150866508484,
0.2845255136489868,
0.4609180986881256,
-0.642261266708374,
0.6192994713783264,
0.36904627084732056,
-0.3151107728481293,
-1.1621785163879395,
0.24478761851787567,
-0.7458257079124451,
-0.6605669856071472,
1.2166081666946411,
0.5548414587974548,
-0.1684272140264511,
-0.14314498007297516,
-0.4666496813297272,
0.11186627298593521,
-0.19819562137126923,
1.6643702983856201,
1.020126461982727,
-0.15814900398254395,
-0.3026424050331116,
-0.6909133195877075,
0.6182514429092407,
0.4433057904243469,
-0.9228246808052063,
0.46651017665863037,
0.5469574332237244,
0.032515041530132294,
0.3316997289657593,
0.5456024408340454,
-0.13316945731639862,
0.1662052571773529,
-0.062096934765577316,
0.3163905739784241,
0.3346095085144043,
-0.4536251723766327,
-0.22508195042610168,
0.17920956015586853,
0.026833103969693184,
0.16637824475765228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01767v1 | HiQA: A Hierarchical Contextual Augmentation RAG for Massive Documents QA | 2024-02-01T02:24:15 | 2024-02-01T02:24:15 | Xinyue Chen, Pengyu Gao, Jiangjiang Song, Xiaoyang Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As language model agents leveraging external tools rapidly evolve,
significant progress has been made in question-answering(QA) methodologies
utilizing supplementary documents and the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
approach. This advancement has improved the response quality of language models
and alleviates the appearance of hallucination. However, these methods exhibit
limited retrieval accuracy when faced with massive indistinguishable documents,
presenting notable challenges in their practical application. In response to
these emerging challenges, we present HiQA, an advanced framework for
multi-document question-answering (MDQA) that integrates cascading metadata
into content as well as a multi-route retrieval mechanism. We also release a
benchmark called MasQA to evaluate and research in MDQA. Finally, HiQA
demonstrates the state-of-the-art performance in multi-document environments. | [
-0.6441642642021179,
-1.049914836883545,
0.5471121072769165,
-0.110527902841568,
0.15191929042339325,
0.44871631264686584,
0.3376713693141937,
-0.5736588835716248,
0.30503422021865845,
0.6448979377746582,
-0.5581144094467163,
-0.24252423644065857,
-0.44922953844070435,
0.05032388120889664,
-0.35723626613616943,
0.8127201795578003,
0.16080059111118317,
-0.019344855099916458,
-0.5100958347320557,
-0.44177529215812683,
-0.596287727355957,
-0.628035306930542,
-0.5234155654907227,
-0.17486286163330078,
0.4984646439552307,
0.2118067443370819,
0.9619114995002747,
0.5044118762016296,
0.5154199004173279,
0.3219219446182251,
-0.1612388640642166,
0.5263801217079163,
-0.12089785933494568,
0.5624316334724426,
-0.2700945734977722,
-0.11227894574403763,
-0.7730175256729126,
-0.15405914187431335,
0.8392918705940247,
0.6547970771789551,
0.03283783420920372,
0.1844538301229477,
-0.07892440259456635,
0.3709014356136322,
-0.8970350623130798,
-0.1602124273777008,
-0.4859025776386261,
-0.17671982944011688,
0.03454197570681572,
-0.5702513456344604,
-0.1611165702342987,
-0.1123749241232872,
0.1896926909685135,
-0.8744962215423584,
0.05306609719991684,
0.02477119117975235,
0.9120505452156067,
0.40424883365631104,
-0.7156774997711182,
-0.6121276021003723,
-0.5938929915428162,
0.4525720775127411,
-0.6544657349586487,
0.38702794909477234,
0.33453038334846497,
0.3666137754917145,
-0.13001509010791779,
-0.9544411301612854,
-0.7702290415763855,
-0.1707875281572342,
0.028237000107765198,
0.25513702630996704,
0.20762895047664642,
-0.002414894523099065,
0.24364110827445984,
0.34836292266845703,
-0.6048374772071838,
-0.09654918313026428,
-0.13676200807094574,
-0.15727388858795166,
0.22807429730892181,
0.1330491453409195,
0.4439132809638977,
-0.4253756105899811,
-0.3671041429042816,
-0.16420109570026398,
-0.3584226965904236,
-0.08823675662279129,
0.23549754917621613,
0.10953575372695923,
0.2239805907011032,
0.4958212673664093,
-0.37768450379371643,
0.5180317163467407,
0.021020911633968353,
-0.3115009665489197,
0.3231416642665863,
-0.3578857481479645,
-0.2384481430053711,
-0.3210656940937042,
0.31418970227241516,
-0.00653430912643671,
-0.5389190912246704,
-0.1312514990568161,
-0.1626015305519104,
-0.4552338719367981,
0.4966621994972229,
-0.6449311971664429,
0.10729320347309113,
0.39931628108024597,
-0.195816770195961,
-0.11710970103740692,
0.025242675095796585,
-0.8759151101112366,
-0.6902328729629517,
-0.3390241265296936,
0.9241659045219421,
-0.13966946303844452,
-0.12120909988880157,
-0.14987243711948395,
-0.3326066732406616,
0.4138750731945038,
0.5509852766990662,
-0.5554734468460083,
0.13900862634181976,
0.7302638292312622,
0.45579224824905396,
0.015876520425081253,
-0.46799489855766296,
-0.8429316878318787,
0.2754957377910614,
-0.4739926755428314,
0.8620094656944275,
-0.5591108202934265,
-0.2756314277648926,
-0.008755389600992203,
-0.04372809827327728,
0.03897187486290932,
-0.6394657492637634,
0.9344485402107239,
-1.0019809007644653,
0.5957780480384827,
-0.42968040704727173,
-0.2384452372789383,
-0.16608242690563202,
0.6108922362327576,
-0.8122654557228088,
1.4330635070800781,
0.46961790323257446,
-0.8057581186294556,
0.19319158792495728,
-0.6316183805465698,
-0.24829165637493134,
0.38391703367233276,
-0.03683929517865181,
-0.14631608128547668,
-0.24773143231868744,
0.354232519865036,
0.19902357459068298,
-0.420764297246933,
0.22867926955223083,
-0.06574290990829468,
-0.4345366954803467,
0.0938628539443016,
-0.42679163813591003,
0.5796337723731995,
0.1997113674879074,
-0.17688710987567902,
0.2617461085319519,
-0.7440748810768127,
-0.023263761773705482,
-0.12545903027057648,
-0.7237398624420166,
-0.5556740760803223,
-0.2586973309516907,
0.14447538554668427,
0.6115520596504211,
0.41821038722991943,
-0.3196973204612732,
0.23856700956821442,
-0.3986586332321167,
0.07758039981126785,
0.47454386949539185,
0.24550877511501312,
0.529793918132782,
-0.5129319429397583,
0.6003778576850891,
0.01784353144466877,
0.11693243682384491,
-0.4365459680557251,
-0.38873714208602905,
-0.6245663166046143,
-0.22999633848667145,
0.37481242418289185,
0.3562646210193634,
-1.1357382535934448,
0.2472100704908371,
-0.27485767006874084,
-0.29270651936531067,
-0.7444313764572144,
-0.037005990743637085,
0.34804829955101013,
0.6436576247215271,
0.5979383587837219,
-0.3311347961425781,
-0.5903916954994202,
-0.7832516431808472,
0.051825150847435,
-0.2654561698436737,
-0.19680409133434296,
0.4227197766304016,
0.5587466955184937,
-0.4390592575073242,
0.8506107926368713,
-0.3305240273475647,
-0.213556706905365,
0.03659817948937416,
0.43050703406333923,
-0.09495601058006287,
0.4507684111595154,
0.215715229511261,
-1.165710210800171,
-0.26931071281433105,
0.022219829261302948,
-0.808698296546936,
-0.05896832048892975,
-0.2589627504348755,
-0.3903335630893707,
0.31459251046180725,
0.5664964914321899,
-0.7092335224151611,
0.0020641291048377752,
0.5245869755744934,
-0.1859482079744339,
0.7371233701705933,
-0.3489948511123657,
0.5597713589668274,
-1.5320533514022827,
0.2361634224653244,
-0.3146499991416931,
-0.02097066305577755,
-0.6839451193809509,
0.7944108247756958,
0.34738844633102417,
-0.12331999093294144,
-0.2835412323474884,
0.7833830714225769,
-0.5188340544700623,
-0.24308903515338898,
-0.46256154775619507,
0.3232648968696594,
0.3989475667476654,
0.4907488524913788,
-0.28300780057907104,
1.055861234664917,
0.4709632098674774,
-0.4937240779399872,
0.28183236718177795,
0.43625548481941223,
-0.0063457791693508625,
0.8589306473731995,
-0.5024495124816895,
0.205263152718544,
-0.5066521167755127,
0.4482877254486084,
-0.9540253281593323,
-0.49187275767326355,
0.03690521419048309,
-0.6044448018074036,
0.2790306508541107,
-0.05584336444735527,
-0.731755256652832,
-0.32926487922668457,
-0.3294622302055359,
0.39842960238456726,
0.29931408166885376,
-0.6794178485870361,
1.004103660583496,
0.5946480631828308,
-0.3256520926952362,
-0.9574028849601746,
-0.2359541654586792,
0.4958629310131073,
-0.08672953397035599,
-0.5594700574874878,
0.311818391084671,
-0.2963680624961853,
-0.02792394906282425,
-0.13298730552196503,
-0.2657039761543274,
-0.4366631805896759,
0.17455588281154633,
0.13608524203300476,
0.29434460401535034,
-0.3375660181045532,
0.3086920380592346,
0.3477715253829956,
0.1667148321866989,
0.013680539093911648,
-0.2332218885421753,
0.38617271184921265,
0.062928706407547,
-0.2446679174900055,
-0.006843957118690014,
0.7074325084686279,
0.9500331878662109,
-0.657666027545929,
0.7540094256401062,
0.7052664160728455,
-0.5440951585769653,
0.0025746722240000963,
-0.7381982803344727,
0.020299706608057022,
-0.4765418767929077,
0.3203207552433014,
-0.8147357702255249,
-0.8878254294395447,
0.48192542791366577,
-0.042118679732084274,
0.0910269096493721,
0.5648400187492371,
0.5527763366699219,
-0.18692803382873535,
0.9569576382637024,
0.5030036568641663,
0.1257013976573944,
0.040268510580062866,
-0.024040628224611282,
-0.04351207613945007,
-1.1752222776412964,
-0.24712848663330078,
-0.9515326023101807,
0.15543478727340698,
-0.5684160590171814,
-0.6322584748268127,
0.7788264155387878,
0.15756559371948242,
-0.07092952728271484,
0.20843522250652313,
-0.17708463966846466,
0.36079075932502747,
0.5611944198608398,
-0.09659800678491592,
0.5731770396232605,
-0.32592496275901794,
-0.18818442523479462,
0.3035176396369934,
-0.571731686592102,
-0.4685615301132202,
0.6505700945854187,
0.4537847340106964,
0.7076456546783447,
0.3422034978866577,
0.3835124373435974,
0.21874761581420898,
0.2775527834892273,
-0.7372127175331116,
0.3725019693374634,
0.378451406955719,
-0.9101502895355225,
-0.6852939128875732,
-0.346751868724823,
-0.9196867942810059,
0.8847219347953796,
-0.4779442548751831,
-0.4808332324028015,
0.296468049287796,
-0.27667638659477234,
-0.3340437114238739,
0.005657327361404896,
-0.35822793841362,
0.7536265850067139,
0.2789495289325714,
-0.37334370613098145,
0.05357702821493149,
-0.8267160058021545,
0.277957558631897,
-0.41974425315856934,
0.24739815294742584,
0.09361616522073746,
-0.2812262773513794,
0.5320732593536377,
-0.07766278833150864,
0.23820944130420685,
0.046807318925857544,
-0.41368284821510315,
0.17189447581768036,
0.021333778277039528,
0.4127645194530487,
0.012242765165865421,
-0.1738288253545761,
-0.3072599172592163,
0.5693612694740295,
-0.5169749855995178,
-0.7838545441627502,
0.6868025064468384,
-0.4690518379211426,
-0.588482141494751,
-0.3938908278942108,
-1.0313442945480347,
-0.621198832988739,
0.3733149468898773,
-0.08516217023134232,
0.8363254070281982,
-0.10295218229293823,
0.4221486449241638,
0.7163673639297485,
-0.3242923617362976,
0.34713348746299744,
0.5053915977478027,
0.08234590291976929,
-0.25314706563949585,
0.6238892674446106,
0.05558919534087181,
0.15493325889110565,
0.5944026112556458,
0.13466404378414154,
-0.6261866688728333,
-0.5011879205703735,
-0.709681510925293,
0.11547677218914032,
-0.9374415278434753,
-0.0777214765548706,
-1.0859581232070923,
-0.26042768359184265,
-0.7168571949005127,
-0.07132253050804138,
0.04956771060824394,
-0.41769081354141235,
-0.015007932670414448,
0.18839658796787262,
-0.3138878345489502,
0.5789026021957397,
0.267876535654068,
-0.03886699676513672,
-1.1692090034484863,
0.6971622705459595,
0.47400012612342834,
0.06955130398273468,
0.11295761913061142,
-0.6799762845039368,
-0.4325321316719055,
-0.0927986353635788,
-0.3445591926574707,
-0.9141407608985901,
0.31576114892959595,
0.035846561193466187,
0.6943680047988892,
-0.07711281627416611,
0.2716602087020874,
0.5969676971435547,
-0.39334791898727417,
0.6973308324813843,
-0.2817972004413605,
-0.7534940838813782,
0.25822576880455017,
-0.5744430422782898,
0.665787935256958,
0.6402009725570679,
0.5389297604560852,
-0.6163837909698486,
-0.5403052568435669,
-0.5212995409965515,
-0.8204197287559509,
0.3514460325241089,
0.028223088011145592,
0.30188271403312683,
0.17225585877895355,
0.23028932511806488,
0.022097652778029442,
0.34977924823760986,
-0.2966171205043793,
0.005321237724274397,
0.025526072829961777,
-0.03911400958895683,
0.16438013315200806,
-0.2163667231798172,
-0.1957649290561676,
-0.045978955924510956,
0.6571963429450989,
-0.5941414833068848,
-0.09248735755681992,
0.3377957344055176,
-0.24200931191444397,
-0.1125812754034996,
0.6795781850814819,
0.29283520579338074,
1.0118942260742188,
-0.26765021681785583,
0.11817820370197296,
0.20333248376846313,
-0.50722336769104,
0.13241329789161682,
0.18491674959659576,
-0.3386683464050293,
-0.023080576211214066,
0.31084969639778137,
0.2663731276988983,
0.04315653443336487,
-0.7902993559837341,
0.47669389843940735,
-0.08202333748340607,
-0.28542500734329224,
0.0022816844284534454,
-0.26949068903923035,
-0.06007095053792,
0.18456223607063293,
0.766917884349823,
-0.1910509318113327,
0.7230895757675171,
-0.9525119066238403,
0.2961304485797882,
0.47603753209114075,
-0.3431413769721985,
0.23089003562927246,
0.594278872013092,
0.1581564098596573,
-0.061158549040555954,
0.17137783765792847,
-0.17016448080539703,
-0.4469841420650482,
0.5269838571548462,
0.3516295552253723,
0.6824144124984741,
-0.046469829976558685,
0.4312213361263275,
0.2986140251159668,
0.3118141293525696,
0.13888977468013763,
0.24229823052883148,
-0.2068546861410141,
-0.4922659695148468,
-0.5013724565505981,
-0.7750435471534729,
-0.745313286781311,
0.05012224614620209,
-0.7784517407417297,
-0.30668142437934875,
-0.0653480514883995,
0.04541905224323273,
0.13576549291610718,
0.28356146812438965,
-0.274893581867218,
0.4719223380088806,
-0.19022376835346222,
0.8451560735702515,
-0.30577540397644043,
0.9033203125,
0.8768185377120972,
-0.5655341148376465,
-0.7440707087516785,
0.44431301951408386,
-0.13942478597164154,
-0.20781561732292175,
0.3383537530899048,
-0.047895416617393494,
-0.17084172368049622,
0.05164197459816933,
-0.20782531797885895,
-0.8744044899940491,
1.095369577407837,
0.061460256576538086,
0.16142131388187408,
-0.3503841161727905,
-0.059563565999269485,
0.7432153224945068,
-0.13430391252040863,
0.34410563111305237,
0.6443158388137817,
0.42039236426353455,
0.5175061225891113,
-0.9336978793144226,
0.15805315971374512,
-0.2658100128173828,
0.014637399464845657,
0.14706562459468842,
-0.32881566882133484,
0.75832599401474,
0.04867412522435188,
-0.2619762718677521,
0.4056820869445801,
0.641329824924469,
0.21098650991916656,
0.42693591117858887,
0.311736136674881,
0.4876324236392975,
0.8755742907524109,
0.0038173880893737078,
1.0954177379608154,
-0.12354257702827454,
0.12346151471138,
1.3267358541488647,
-0.2913297116756439,
0.9459719657897949,
0.3644343912601471,
0.18490725755691528,
0.504845142364502,
0.5227189064025879,
0.43060699105262756,
0.10112347453832626,
-0.1417870670557022,
-0.4443594813346863,
0.008880521170794964,
-0.4805857837200165,
-0.43694281578063965,
0.40563100576400757,
0.26604458689689636,
0.14659617841243744,
-0.2944261431694031,
0.027618195861577988,
-0.1887594610452652,
0.19309407472610474,
-0.2786834239959717,
0.9343067407608032,
-0.275841623544693,
-0.8334764242172241,
0.5228581428527832,
0.2800123989582062,
0.5401071906089783,
-0.3578127920627594,
-0.14608091115951538,
-0.3668140172958374,
-0.3397170901298523,
-0.14349722862243652,
-0.7441374659538269,
0.331621378660202,
-0.29305219650268555,
-0.18975421786308289,
0.02866063266992569,
0.8039560317993164,
-0.47585394978523254,
0.09960917383432388,
0.04327775910496712,
0.9859780073165894,
-0.13315589725971222,
-0.263611763715744,
-0.7430064678192139,
-0.2562491297721863,
-0.7431789040565491,
-0.050012875348329544,
0.41212087869644165,
0.5214560627937317,
-0.14736407995224,
0.5933020710945129,
0.7007648348808289,
-0.2587994933128357,
0.11423161625862122,
0.26180481910705566,
0.9725662469863892,
-0.3432827591896057,
-0.7028840780258179,
-0.1973336637020111,
0.5275123715400696,
-0.15988577902317047,
-0.2571086883544922,
0.8995488286018372,
0.5408416390419006,
0.6597371697425842,
-0.03932124003767967,
0.48422136902809143,
0.03421471640467644,
0.6888279914855957,
-0.5820637941360474,
0.678013801574707,
-0.9174107313156128,
0.15181565284729004,
-0.4661344587802887,
-1.0178035497665405,
-0.0838194265961647,
-0.004564669448882341,
0.09365642070770264,
-0.01080198772251606,
0.9474616646766663,
1.0638463497161865,
0.018426548689603806,
-0.2905803620815277,
0.5826462507247925,
-0.026817714795470238,
0.23523932695388794,
0.2767215967178345,
1.043270230293274,
-0.6711914539337158,
0.42687612771987915,
0.18723511695861816,
-0.21044324338436127,
-0.01691899448633194,
-0.5073754191398621,
-0.6552290320396423,
-1.0270841121673584,
-0.02377919852733612,
-0.5142183899879456,
0.140254408121109,
0.7368362545967102,
0.8954192996025085,
-0.467713326215744,
0.02748670056462288,
0.47224879264831543,
0.17710955440998077,
-0.1828937977552414,
-0.2642587423324585,
0.30785828828811646,
-0.3348284065723419,
-0.9030457139015198,
0.5393636226654053,
0.5009732842445374,
0.039066728204488754,
-0.49901852011680603,
-0.06375158578157425,
-0.5768611431121826,
0.5290955901145935,
0.8313446640968323,
0.3720690608024597,
-0.49074745178222656,
-0.07163035869598389,
0.050983112305402756,
-0.5594286918640137,
0.15659461915493011,
0.6656919121742249,
-0.6936549544334412,
0.5100542306900024,
0.7827196717262268,
1.2863030433654785,
0.31780558824539185,
0.4588097333908081,
0.30010271072387695,
-0.8240973353385925,
-0.1966417133808136,
0.30676883459091187,
0.02139345370233059,
0.2786276042461395,
-0.4234115481376648,
0.35948559641838074,
-0.01965288817882538,
-0.5784966349601746,
-0.7767186164855957,
0.1180950477719307,
-1.0390403270721436,
-0.48648974299430847,
1.0190073251724243,
0.1027119979262352,
-0.13263893127441406,
-0.47503015398979187,
-0.5293036103248596,
0.03523318096995354,
-0.15912529826164246,
0.6781830191612244,
0.6160813570022583,
0.23489443957805634,
-0.34043657779693604,
-0.8421000838279724,
0.3976280987262726,
0.37186121940612793,
-1.4555234909057617,
-0.27390944957733154,
0.922568678855896,
-0.09683703631162643,
0.42256495356559753,
0.8858669996261597,
-0.2422657310962677,
0.5547928810119629,
0.011658267118036747,
-0.16662074625492096,
0.06989923119544983,
-0.718567430973053,
-0.46015340089797974,
0.7728986740112305,
0.1792641282081604,
0.04847855493426323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00271v1 | A Crucial Parameter for Rank-Frequency Relation in Natural Languages | 2024-02-01T01:45:46 | 2024-02-01T01:45:46 | Chenchen Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL | $f \propto r^{-\alpha} \cdot (r+\gamma)^{-\beta}$ has been empirically shown
more precise than a na\"ive power law $f\propto r^{-\alpha}$ to model the
rank-frequency ($r$-$f$) relation of words in natural languages. This work
shows that the only crucial parameter in the formulation is $\gamma$, which
depicts the resistance to vocabulary growth on a corpus. A method of parameter
estimation by searching an optimal $\gamma$ is proposed, where a ``zeroth
word'' is introduced technically for the calculation. The formulation and
parameters are further discussed with several case studies. | [
-0.8260982632637024,
-0.9912332892417908,
0.7159717679023743,
0.05677581951022148,
-0.45044898986816406,
-0.5521713495254517,
-0.3516596555709839,
-0.29968905448913574,
0.3906974494457245,
0.2756091058254242,
-0.3825508654117584,
-0.19192110002040863,
-0.6049381494522095,
0.08286316692829132,
-0.5474648475646973,
0.5969513654708862,
0.5556722283363342,
0.06935674697160721,
0.07621648907661438,
-0.3206925690174103,
-0.4512704908847809,
-0.6397077441215515,
-0.4123005270957947,
-0.40238893032073975,
0.9036847949028015,
0.40090513229370117,
0.9351391196250916,
0.4283875524997711,
0.577505350112915,
0.24006326496601105,
-0.20826876163482666,
-0.2627755403518677,
-0.29785776138305664,
0.5252798199653625,
0.07652322947978973,
-0.4897587299346924,
-0.3687897026538849,
0.08596815168857574,
0.878576934337616,
0.8193554282188416,
-0.0855422243475914,
-0.016059668734669685,
-0.4260255694389343,
0.8881175518035889,
-0.3589397072792053,
0.27720120549201965,
-0.44798436760902405,
-0.24850869178771973,
-0.576381504535675,
-0.6146336793899536,
-0.2568633556365967,
-0.514600932598114,
-0.0700591653585434,
-0.774966299533844,
0.2342901974916458,
0.24324114620685577,
1.445984125137329,
0.16583068668842316,
-0.2340383529663086,
-0.2995821535587311,
-0.7278940081596375,
0.7901647686958313,
-0.47041741013526917,
0.6914072632789612,
0.7173888683319092,
0.31969037652015686,
-0.3392225205898285,
-0.5337159633636475,
-0.3702949285507202,
-0.688258171081543,
0.0904717892408371,
-0.14176325500011444,
0.3000788688659668,
0.22943148016929626,
0.17295192182064056,
0.4709690511226654,
-0.18211859464645386,
-0.3498119115829468,
-0.5721027255058289,
0.11338508129119873,
0.7272162437438965,
-0.21017205715179443,
0.5061940550804138,
-0.27369794249534607,
-0.18449921905994415,
-0.061210788786411285,
-0.7167169451713562,
-0.2393295019865036,
0.2662973701953888,
0.551451563835144,
0.14911574125289917,
0.25607794523239136,
0.22825835645198822,
0.9865697026252747,
0.10830333828926086,
-0.01172388345003128,
-0.09682978689670563,
-0.3617064654827118,
0.13009318709373474,
-0.022697418928146362,
0.2559536099433899,
0.12656204402446747,
0.7220516204833984,
-0.4070483446121216,
-0.006469393614679575,
-0.0387435108423233,
0.4725186824798584,
-0.7295656800270081,
-0.02088669314980507,
-0.24184028804302216,
0.05486802011728287,
-0.15779441595077515,
0.32675230503082275,
-0.7548491358757019,
0.027401907369494438,
-0.2217443585395813,
0.7172620296478271,
-0.5625095963478088,
-0.32131072878837585,
-0.12642908096313477,
-0.057834405452013016,
0.354089617729187,
-0.14735454320907593,
-1.1031991243362427,
0.6503199338912964,
0.7765960693359375,
0.8670040965080261,
0.15152579545974731,
0.025096777826547623,
-0.48500362038612366,
-0.24615009129047394,
-0.46062174439430237,
0.5583301782608032,
-0.6623982191085815,
-0.5068512558937073,
-0.21429133415222168,
-0.25054803490638733,
-0.15658551454544067,
-0.13483254611492157,
0.8803508281707764,
-0.9090527892112732,
-0.026967644691467285,
-0.23718462884426117,
-0.7826534509658813,
-0.40661802887916565,
-0.05051550269126892,
-0.6500919461250305,
1.2936702966690063,
0.2600495219230652,
-0.5404235124588013,
0.6358458995819092,
-0.58875572681427,
-0.3643013834953308,
0.2197478711605072,
-0.17385753989219666,
-0.31151190400123596,
0.323280394077301,
-0.18666140735149384,
0.18982432782649994,
-0.413146048784256,
0.35337868332862854,
-0.4985727369785309,
-0.44667303562164307,
0.46966949105262756,
-0.24635134637355804,
0.6263796091079712,
0.18466006219387054,
-0.034654635936021805,
-0.13323181867599487,
-0.6932665109634399,
0.16676601767539978,
0.09574760496616364,
-0.1494559496641159,
-0.7800517678260803,
0.14069896936416626,
-0.14649978280067444,
-0.06552653759717941,
0.18022039532661438,
-0.5956917405128479,
0.06871400028467178,
-0.6699324250221252,
0.37076568603515625,
0.4379313290119171,
0.1759060025215149,
0.39463385939598083,
-0.42396077513694763,
0.647826611995697,
-0.5931475758552551,
0.2504059672355652,
0.36081662774086,
-0.5745964050292969,
-0.49778369069099426,
-0.2555447220802307,
0.8103634715080261,
0.0520188994705677,
0.06028683856129646,
0.39451903104782104,
-0.4580029547214508,
-0.6524493098258972,
-0.34146901965141296,
-0.12326424568891525,
0.20411916077136993,
0.39598560333251953,
0.29932984709739685,
-0.07212299853563309,
-0.2811240255832672,
-0.5928773880004883,
-0.22068296372890472,
-0.35093486309051514,
0.23517771065235138,
0.2683292329311371,
0.29245176911354065,
0.20006532967090607,
1.1395821571350098,
-0.5255639553070068,
-0.2309815138578415,
-0.17411914467811584,
0.20946264266967773,
0.4765244424343109,
0.2166118323802948,
1.0234829187393188,
-0.9554197192192078,
-0.5033933520317078,
-0.29842236638069153,
-0.2636597454547882,
-0.3586101233959198,
0.6510187983512878,
-0.09290391951799393,
0.10427790880203247,
0.7378231883049011,
-0.037652138620615005,
0.1249023899435997,
0.7603987455368042,
-0.3248189389705658,
0.1453636884689331,
-0.4435950219631195,
-0.13474038243293762,
-0.9195707440376282,
0.5021132826805115,
0.30395904183387756,
-0.083778016269207,
-0.9102709293365479,
0.662337601184845,
-0.0036653776187449694,
-0.01096800435334444,
-0.10627782344818115,
0.8730941414833069,
-0.3251294195652008,
-0.06867552548646927,
-0.04131855443120003,
0.35619956254959106,
-0.20181667804718018,
0.3837198317050934,
-0.06107485666871071,
0.9834110140800476,
0.5125218033790588,
-0.9767708778381348,
0.1815384179353714,
0.06026158109307289,
0.03272130712866783,
0.3568515181541443,
-0.5958616137504578,
-0.21461297571659088,
-0.24280132353305817,
-0.26417645812034607,
-1.0073800086975098,
0.024240484461188316,
-0.17762155830860138,
-0.5446391701698303,
0.29116466641426086,
-0.3666611313819885,
-0.36146798729896545,
-0.08096995204687119,
-0.3629944920539856,
0.5283488631248474,
0.4982510209083557,
-0.15152615308761597,
0.4427115321159363,
0.6048100590705872,
-0.3016146421432495,
-0.3986513614654541,
-0.4494022727012634,
-0.1770910769701004,
-0.33840617537498474,
-0.7285469770431519,
0.5995316505432129,
-0.14645934104919434,
-0.4212184548377991,
-0.08778690546751022,
-0.1577240228652954,
-0.3232491612434387,
0.19283388555049896,
0.36393389105796814,
0.12408260256052017,
-0.2918246388435364,
0.25380149483680725,
-0.17586369812488556,
-0.4860740900039673,
0.15326224267482758,
0.1833122819662094,
0.6705480813980103,
-0.29831162095069885,
0.08658269047737122,
0.252612829208374,
0.17566122114658356,
0.7728670239448547,
-0.1888876110315323,
0.4889972507953644,
0.2066686451435089,
-0.25453731417655945,
-0.09764665365219116,
-0.4248642325401306,
-0.313924103975296,
-0.5098954439163208,
0.0980076864361763,
-0.3970455825328827,
-0.35498547554016113,
0.5100591778755188,
0.27992862462997437,
-0.26391950249671936,
0.6337297558784485,
0.353298544883728,
0.23181480169296265,
0.9355480074882507,
0.6471743583679199,
0.11405230313539505,
0.7108352780342102,
0.07598032802343369,
0.27342280745506287,
-0.7758233547210693,
-0.22547610104084015,
-0.7952704429626465,
-0.07498840987682343,
-0.7313874959945679,
-0.05760499835014343,
0.6872522234916687,
0.10249406099319458,
-0.16349248588085175,
0.32974016666412354,
-0.27193620800971985,
0.13423390686511993,
0.6782492995262146,
-0.2525309920310974,
0.22800445556640625,
-0.03929357975721359,
-0.35210978984832764,
-0.3157947063446045,
-0.4641963541507721,
-0.029643142595887184,
0.876013457775116,
0.1796211302280426,
0.48295658826828003,
0.39980238676071167,
0.7531610131263733,
0.267422616481781,
0.5202507972717285,
-1.169528603553772,
0.5314686894416809,
-0.2997412383556366,
-0.9791626930236816,
-0.7261335849761963,
-0.1286289542913437,
-1.1710478067398071,
0.42204922437667847,
-0.01914309896528721,
-0.47904038429260254,
0.20030589401721954,
-0.21515260636806488,
-0.12395033240318298,
-0.2669845223426819,
-0.33092814683914185,
0.5760921835899353,
-0.16429780423641205,
0.009965755045413971,
-0.3029767870903015,
-0.5441208481788635,
0.03316350281238556,
-0.0759037509560585,
0.39102819561958313,
-0.6376998424530029,
-0.1950705498456955,
0.7842456102371216,
-0.8264946341514587,
0.02549159899353981,
-0.18169784545898438,
0.06546607613563538,
0.07798703014850616,
0.1837271898984909,
0.13902908563613892,
0.1664130538702011,
-0.637305736541748,
0.041354987770318985,
0.17506857216358185,
-0.4386154115200043,
-0.37604662775993347,
0.6564568877220154,
-0.639705240726471,
-0.4426387846469879,
-0.6817119717597961,
-0.4016331434249878,
-0.33302053809165955,
0.3645087480545044,
0.46089985966682434,
0.5870093107223511,
-0.33265626430511475,
0.4488399624824524,
0.5888147354125977,
0.11335296928882599,
0.5987696647644043,
0.7093104720115662,
-0.448690801858902,
-0.33712515234947205,
0.8283454775810242,
0.7766739130020142,
0.20033514499664307,
0.41798779368400574,
0.48505041003227234,
-0.33389854431152344,
-0.44455766677856445,
-0.24948127567768097,
0.5427162647247314,
-0.35312288999557495,
-0.05618910491466522,
-0.2592167854309082,
-0.46678662300109863,
0.2715620696544647,
-0.29931607842445374,
-0.09889883548021317,
-0.39267319440841675,
-0.08434103429317474,
0.0763193815946579,
1.0163757801055908,
0.38459569215774536,
-0.0789559930562973,
0.13008743524551392,
-0.450890451669693,
0.6324136257171631,
0.42057064175605774,
0.49168360233306885,
-0.2174290120601654,
-0.8601239919662476,
0.04052251577377319,
-0.10775645822286606,
0.17903585731983185,
-1.2213557958602905,
0.7274436950683594,
0.8257952928543091,
0.7186653017997742,
0.14649127423763275,
0.32379111647605896,
0.5043690800666809,
-0.2035122960805893,
0.5948479771614075,
-0.23369526863098145,
-1.0466642379760742,
0.4350181818008423,
-0.5309609770774841,
0.036610282957553864,
0.780541181564331,
0.22488197684288025,
-0.624089777469635,
-0.8921682834625244,
-0.8123905062675476,
-1.2059886455535889,
0.768101692199707,
0.30266696214675903,
0.43739989399909973,
-0.02248738892376423,
0.6340726613998413,
-0.2275063544511795,
0.04995863512158394,
-0.4248995780944824,
-0.6719099879264832,
-0.10938625782728195,
0.029504064470529556,
0.028902702033519745,
-0.3424282670021057,
0.14104096591472626,
-0.4921513497829437,
0.826652467250824,
-0.02173362672328949,
0.21527083218097687,
0.031929511576890945,
-0.1663699746131897,
-0.21747839450836182,
0.19111774861812592,
0.8673558831214905,
0.8097275495529175,
-0.6867104172706604,
0.04175461083650589,
0.10923831909894943,
-0.7124215960502625,
0.09615559130907059,
0.17088764905929565,
-0.33380964398384094,
0.36223772168159485,
0.02605648897588253,
0.3673761188983917,
0.6250287890434265,
-0.2906509041786194,
0.6063941121101379,
-0.052515435963869095,
-0.30553677678108215,
-0.5781632661819458,
0.29759901762008667,
0.009778323583304882,
-0.4739892780780792,
0.823738694190979,
-0.3553444445133209,
-0.02342340722680092,
-0.41799354553222656,
0.6148359775543213,
0.3866647779941559,
-0.7411523461341858,
-0.2967328429222107,
0.7804486751556396,
0.14006848633289337,
-0.2862914204597473,
0.41313114762306213,
-0.22215701639652252,
-0.3133801817893982,
0.775368332862854,
0.377945214509964,
0.6996910572052002,
-0.3550610840320587,
0.3316662907600403,
0.4664376378059387,
0.10058815777301788,
-0.05467691645026207,
0.5901548266410828,
0.13987554609775543,
-0.5256014466285706,
-0.2763906419277191,
-0.9645885229110718,
-0.37378397583961487,
-0.06853202730417252,
-0.9781220555305481,
0.2951434254646301,
-0.6186810731887817,
-0.45450901985168457,
0.454081267118454,
0.4440041780471802,
-0.2018028050661087,
0.18276578187942505,
-0.04213738441467285,
0.7623958587646484,
-0.6891199946403503,
0.9940630197525024,
0.36226528882980347,
-0.6515671610832214,
-0.9161943197250366,
0.04629649594426155,
-0.36545228958129883,
-0.8140084147453308,
0.9024259448051453,
-0.17867617309093475,
-0.35227149724960327,
0.08055946230888367,
-0.1385864019393921,
-1.336518406867981,
0.8464281558990479,
0.568726122379303,
-0.17587049305438995,
0.22528177499771118,
-0.3228042721748352,
0.8139023184776306,
-0.12952882051467896,
0.12830427289009094,
0.4113263189792633,
1.0441428422927856,
-0.004715559538453817,
-0.8226202726364136,
0.15693464875221252,
-0.2835753858089447,
0.07772812247276306,
0.8991222977638245,
-0.6323179602622986,
1.0608384609222412,
0.04469316080212593,
-0.15546105802059174,
0.10004784911870956,
0.66521817445755,
-0.15427851676940918,
-0.17703086137771606,
0.31191110610961914,
0.0923306867480278,
0.5477651357650757,
-0.14295144379138947,
0.9706608653068542,
-1.1080213785171509,
0.6796417832374573,
0.3091420531272888,
0.0715196430683136,
0.8885043263435364,
0.3499390482902527,
-0.2627628445625305,
0.45437854528427124,
0.3091750741004944,
0.007092027924954891,
0.4848051965236664,
0.21775931119918823,
-0.27938374876976013,
-0.12209944427013397,
-0.061189670115709305,
-0.5146530866622925,
0.408356636762619,
0.6274961233139038,
-0.3681738078594208,
-0.3770688474178314,
-0.45423492789268494,
0.5017855763435364,
0.22927886247634888,
-0.3623218536376953,
0.6767448782920837,
0.254881352186203,
-0.7851069569587708,
1.0486234426498413,
0.3366508483886719,
0.4255684018135071,
-0.9512506723403931,
0.16636042296886444,
-0.19138024747371674,
-0.07933954149484634,
-0.20063629746437073,
-0.4566943943500519,
0.3546195924282074,
-0.3364422023296356,
-0.059053968638181686,
0.16039547324180603,
0.3179865777492523,
-0.4503594636917114,
-0.5002475380897522,
0.40781891345977783,
0.17537331581115723,
0.035518061369657516,
0.08473943918943405,
-0.5419193506240845,
-0.24803827702999115,
-0.5848335027694702,
-0.43108072876930237,
0.1104334145784378,
-0.01675049401819706,
-0.06151542812585831,
0.5238233804702759,
0.42267340421676636,
0.40572550892829895,
0.24450956284999847,
-0.06705204397439957,
0.3889566659927368,
-0.5823137760162354,
-0.7260538935661316,
-0.6329416632652283,
-0.24033574759960175,
0.07502566277980804,
-0.4848601818084717,
0.48062485456466675,
0.24074894189834595,
0.16462035477161407,
0.15726609528064728,
0.5319473147392273,
-0.3455051779747009,
0.3130515217781067,
-0.4845454692840576,
0.7935448884963989,
-0.671881914138794,
-0.08440488576889038,
-0.24746419489383698,
-1.2026851177215576,
-0.661054253578186,
0.6172868013381958,
-0.3755693733692169,
0.3062901496887207,
0.9377707839012146,
0.9906532168388367,
-0.013182035647332668,
-0.08816540986299515,
0.6089301705360413,
0.15906459093093872,
0.0693717747926712,
-0.04358789697289467,
0.0011804725509136915,
-0.39388951659202576,
0.3886357545852661,
-0.02740049734711647,
0.05258738622069359,
-0.6923408508300781,
-0.9227036833763123,
-0.2305213063955307,
-0.8248649835586548,
-0.15300732851028442,
-0.299608439207077,
0.3250412344932556,
0.8818275928497314,
0.8110286593437195,
-0.6635989546775818,
-0.2560173571109772,
-0.3431927561759949,
0.1550385057926178,
-0.5896835327148438,
-0.2195810079574585,
0.35027164220809937,
-0.3802761137485504,
-0.5851872563362122,
0.30251628160476685,
0.17925304174423218,
-0.10254199802875519,
-0.5166485905647278,
-0.20577885210514069,
-0.2647342383861542,
0.8700810074806213,
0.23728272318840027,
0.7526887655258179,
-0.7731647491455078,
-0.5058245062828064,
-0.2241458147764206,
-0.22315211594104767,
0.15075460076332092,
0.718049168586731,
-0.6160893440246582,
0.4375772178173065,
0.5715510249137878,
0.113213911652565,
0.48552384972572327,
0.26963114738464355,
0.8383103013038635,
-1.1078647375106812,
0.2117566615343094,
0.3032079041004181,
0.16154015064239502,
0.019533302634954453,
-0.1649404913187027,
0.5093217492103577,
0.1864892840385437,
-0.3820643424987793,
-0.6578578352928162,
0.4420917332172394,
-1.1325570344924927,
-0.13189424574375153,
1.156240701675415,
0.27719444036483765,
-0.35178032517433167,
-0.2045329511165619,
-0.08662786334753036,
0.014663755893707275,
-0.5743625164031982,
0.6008126139640808,
0.8441867828369141,
0.004413971211761236,
-0.1691192388534546,
-0.7044511437416077,
0.7449391484260559,
0.5669512748718262,
-0.2351246029138565,
-0.16861574351787567,
0.26981714367866516,
0.28383228182792664,
0.15717566013336182,
0.5436912178993225,
-0.32573941349983215,
0.11514276266098022,
0.009951547719538212,
-0.25411972403526306,
-0.22245275974273682,
-0.4030037522315979,
-0.24222028255462646,
0.587583601474762,
0.6944944262504578,
-0.04930088296532631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00263v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00263v3 | Does DetectGPT Fully Utilize Perturbation? Bridge Selective Perturbation to Fine-tuned Contrastive Learning Detector would be Better | 2024-02-01T01:23:07 | 2024-02-24T13:46:21 | Shengchao Liu, Xiaoming Liu, Yichen Wang, Zehua Cheng, Chengzhengxu Li, Zhaohan Zhang, Yu Lan, Chao Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The burgeoning generative capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
raised growing concerns about abuse, demanding automatic machine-generated text
detectors. DetectGPT, a zero-shot metric-based detector, first introduces
perturbation and shows great performance improvement. However, in DetectGPT,
random perturbation strategy could introduce noise, and logit regression
depends on threshold, harming the generalizability and applicability of
individual or small-batch inputs. Hence, we propose a novel fine-tuned
detector, Pecola, bridging metric-based and fine-tuned detectors by contrastive
learning on selective perturbation. Selective strategy retains important tokens
during perturbation and weights for multi-pair contrastive learning. The
experiments show that Pecola outperforms the state-of-the-art by 1.20% in
accuracy on average on four public datasets. And we further analyze the
effectiveness, robustness, and generalization of the method. | [
-0.31634166836738586,
-0.927510678768158,
0.5511884689331055,
0.13192139565944672,
-0.44512104988098145,
0.049995578825473785,
-0.21702267229557037,
-0.19679154455661774,
-0.08398911356925964,
0.3262996971607208,
-0.23050382733345032,
-0.7242157459259033,
-0.8070363402366638,
0.009081627242267132,
-0.26096928119659424,
1.1286038160324097,
0.07171427458524704,
0.032237835228443146,
0.3663889467716217,
0.10569915920495987,
-0.11137852072715759,
-0.4809280037879944,
-0.8947039842605591,
-0.3437439501285553,
0.6498056054115295,
0.4475693106651306,
0.2528713643550873,
0.2817726135253906,
0.43513670563697815,
0.21838420629501343,
-0.21149992942810059,
0.07752317190170288,
-0.5494740605354309,
0.2072438895702362,
0.0692083090543747,
-0.5110304355621338,
-0.2855033278465271,
0.007175059523433447,
0.7588228583335876,
0.34931010007858276,
-0.024616079404950142,
-0.023505685850977898,
0.3250349760055542,
0.411356657743454,
-0.7646860480308533,
0.005167587194591761,
-0.9980433583259583,
-0.017806177958846092,
-0.4478539824485779,
-0.24463123083114624,
-0.45603981614112854,
0.243343785405159,
-0.16498610377311707,
-0.3389776945114136,
0.39413967728614807,
-0.2530576288700104,
0.7737558484077454,
0.4760200083255768,
-0.2789587080478668,
0.026569537818431854,
-0.7079115509986877,
0.9647762775421143,
-0.4445853531360626,
0.3297903537750244,
0.4274059534072876,
0.2552050054073334,
-0.14324843883514404,
-0.8175013661384583,
-0.40820232033729553,
-0.3246804177761078,
-0.022365767508745193,
0.28960782289505005,
-0.1774568110704422,
-0.012343824841082096,
0.2858012914657593,
0.5835462212562561,
-0.6173136830329895,
0.4121442437171936,
0.12104323506355286,
-0.385118693113327,
0.32943812012672424,
0.08857350796461105,
0.059584587812423706,
0.16214711964130402,
-0.4250924587249756,
-0.045028895139694214,
-0.8340863585472107,
-0.17467926442623138,
0.7729394435882568,
0.36897897720336914,
-0.22492094337940216,
0.16667364537715912,
-0.2680588960647583,
0.7888699769973755,
0.0861116573214531,
0.30583456158638,
0.28014084696769714,
-0.38370829820632935,
-0.29097095131874084,
-0.09176364541053772,
1.0684731006622314,
-0.14976766705513,
0.26996132731437683,
-0.08183882385492325,
-0.2324676215648651,
0.2979859709739685,
-0.303384006023407,
-0.9454659223556519,
-0.881134569644928,
-0.07324878126382828,
-0.1615029275417328,
-0.6344143152236938,
-0.02185528539121151,
-0.755286455154419,
-0.26970624923706055,
0.08612065762281418,
0.20261339843273163,
-0.365075021982193,
-0.2043229043483734,
0.48147106170654297,
0.12928541004657745,
0.2022632658481598,
0.28614574670791626,
-1.0320407152175903,
0.20766791701316833,
0.39085620641708374,
0.6669585108757019,
-0.1885126531124115,
-0.27595025300979614,
-0.8922610878944397,
-0.21386221051216125,
-0.09999074041843414,
1.193185806274414,
-0.7715165019035339,
-0.31711545586586,
-0.3207826316356659,
-0.04158872365951538,
0.01342372503131628,
-0.583888828754425,
0.7974559664726257,
-0.3282473087310791,
0.22150036692619324,
-0.12456558644771576,
-0.279673308134079,
0.30596545338630676,
0.34515467286109924,
-0.5308118462562561,
0.7709389328956604,
-0.06629174202680588,
-0.9571868777275085,
0.6240532994270325,
-0.34337887167930603,
-0.46320995688438416,
0.11884503811597824,
-0.28087374567985535,
-0.911578893661499,
-0.1064034029841423,
0.5747730135917664,
0.4131025969982147,
0.08695056289434433,
0.038173165172338486,
-0.3410296142101288,
-0.7002080082893372,
0.07674818485975266,
-0.8438342809677124,
0.6202600598335266,
0.04116233065724373,
-0.38653096556663513,
0.3218933641910553,
-0.856646716594696,
-0.423306405544281,
0.2517985999584198,
-0.7401553392410278,
-0.24234002828598022,
0.12905381619930267,
0.06173049658536911,
-0.15550346672534943,
0.081995889544487,
-0.7424785494804382,
-0.05329596623778343,
-0.3019188642501831,
0.48150181770324707,
0.7960279583930969,
0.08852174878120422,
0.20111922919750214,
-0.299791544675827,
0.35115501284599304,
0.02268396131694317,
0.02616056799888611,
-0.44461187720298767,
-0.41383084654808044,
-0.605674684047699,
-0.6050354838371277,
0.5050111413002014,
0.40889865159988403,
-0.4743973910808563,
0.4472353458404541,
0.1583438217639923,
-0.3572530746459961,
-0.3013644218444824,
0.06382080912590027,
0.42125532031059265,
0.5052065849304199,
0.547698974609375,
-0.15376541018486023,
-0.3675117492675781,
-0.7024800777435303,
-0.36584383249282837,
0.039354369044303894,
-0.20020043849945068,
0.2774712145328522,
0.3626887798309326,
0.007849560119211674,
0.28188204765319824,
-0.505636990070343,
-0.32768353819847107,
0.03212333098053932,
0.06380608677864075,
0.17119140923023224,
0.5053893327713013,
0.5921376943588257,
-0.863179087638855,
-0.9478006362915039,
0.040269844233989716,
-0.43731489777565,
-0.23268911242485046,
0.06999765336513519,
0.15177960693836212,
-0.08451726287603378,
0.5707389116287231,
-0.09501668065786362,
0.15745653212070465,
0.6775514483451843,
-0.3089311718940735,
0.7366823554039001,
0.07717902958393097,
-0.02445036917924881,
-0.8408896923065186,
0.10585907101631165,
0.17310304939746857,
-0.4363853335380554,
-0.44023221731185913,
0.009027814492583275,
-0.011936530470848083,
0.009232756681740284,
-0.378509521484375,
0.38896510004997253,
-0.27400219440460205,
0.14949826896190643,
-0.28565067052841187,
0.15513524413108826,
-0.25170326232910156,
0.3135751485824585,
0.007270404137670994,
0.8069350719451904,
0.7003159523010254,
-0.5628977417945862,
0.27325084805488586,
0.024409005418419838,
-0.19673307240009308,
0.6986499428749084,
-0.590686023235321,
0.34535953402519226,
-0.09936299175024033,
0.2982446551322937,
-1.1909010410308838,
-0.06414949893951416,
0.2799040377140045,
-0.7734174728393555,
0.43497270345687866,
-0.23787274956703186,
-0.45404720306396484,
0.05200479179620743,
-0.367255300283432,
0.23785659670829773,
0.255035936832428,
-0.6707073450088501,
0.24909263849258423,
0.22836914658546448,
0.15770724415779114,
-0.6096866726875305,
-0.621563732624054,
-0.032196398824453354,
-0.13039614260196686,
-0.2211669236421585,
0.3788057863712311,
-0.19221194088459015,
0.03863910585641861,
0.03407875448465347,
-0.3963051438331604,
0.24538543820381165,
0.30581551790237427,
-0.0630284771323204,
0.0831780806183815,
-0.13475902378559113,
0.18207113444805145,
-0.09268254786729813,
-0.3819124400615692,
-0.3262597918510437,
-0.44832491874694824,
1.0380668640136719,
-0.18322165310382843,
-0.3070122003555298,
-0.5117348432540894,
0.007715963292866945,
0.3385995924472809,
-0.455621600151062,
0.2973100543022156,
1.0554524660110474,
-0.24507755041122437,
-0.2620176374912262,
-0.4780482053756714,
-0.3638395667076111,
-0.5202694535255432,
0.5263585448265076,
-0.649206817150116,
-1.100204586982727,
0.3773135840892792,
-0.03165705129504204,
-0.04252643883228302,
0.2367268204689026,
0.6126192212104797,
-0.08302336931228638,
0.9982658624649048,
0.4181702435016632,
-0.26395750045776367,
0.7794540524482727,
-0.07999991625547409,
0.11983353644609451,
-0.9022591710090637,
-0.03179405629634857,
-0.6540955305099487,
-0.451465904712677,
-0.7643823623657227,
0.009667966514825821,
0.13207979500293732,
0.041769981384277344,
-0.45991843938827515,
0.22956715524196625,
-0.6959453225135803,
0.5317906737327576,
0.46286383271217346,
0.42908892035484314,
0.4859745502471924,
0.37272462248802185,
-0.40680408477783203,
-0.15338937938213348,
-0.49660518765449524,
-0.330562025308609,
1.3200364112854004,
0.12900379300117493,
0.8845345973968506,
-0.09510285407304764,
0.8034926056861877,
-0.0365053229033947,
0.19523507356643677,
-0.7145587801933289,
0.45828521251678467,
-0.7064482569694519,
-0.40442541241645813,
-0.08554504066705704,
-0.504335343837738,
-1.0857232809066772,
0.2948343753814697,
-0.42748168110847473,
-0.7806736826896667,
0.09961894154548645,
0.28984323143959045,
-0.18762409687042236,
0.5993629097938538,
-0.5149734616279602,
0.6863116025924683,
-0.10463418811559677,
-0.6043132543563843,
-0.1394653022289276,
-0.16746824979782104,
0.11485064029693604,
-0.08041293919086456,
-0.34721750020980835,
-0.09742116183042526,
-0.0014441126259043813,
0.32354536652565,
0.24893859028816223,
0.8898154497146606,
-0.08970045298337936,
0.040894169360399246,
0.04900157079100609,
0.32852014899253845,
0.5759319067001343,
0.10472026467323303,
-0.08030761033296585,
0.08824823051691055,
-0.32546621561050415,
-0.7710000872612,
-0.42108577489852905,
0.9124738574028015,
-0.4570807218551636,
-0.6931817531585693,
-0.2570372223854065,
-0.39527884125709534,
-0.2901417911052704,
0.3251233994960785,
0.5754674673080444,
0.09061172604560852,
-0.051871925592422485,
0.4018140733242035,
0.7819331884384155,
-0.19300878047943115,
0.2553039789199829,
0.6724133491516113,
-0.06183338910341263,
-0.34077000617980957,
0.9122309684753418,
-0.16545574367046356,
0.23371285200119019,
0.6337001919746399,
0.3588780462741852,
0.03358124569058418,
-0.8487175107002258,
-0.062282901257276535,
0.34383222460746765,
-0.29040324687957764,
-0.0057630036026239395,
-0.40770965814590454,
-0.09064126014709473,
-0.09875140339136124,
-0.04643658176064491,
-0.30661237239837646,
0.035002920776605606,
-0.29260432720184326,
-0.21024560928344727,
-0.0415785126388073,
0.30271115899086,
0.09002122282981873,
0.45300260186195374,
-0.39799371361732483,
0.14345766603946686,
0.46614861488342285,
0.5564097762107849,
-0.4121702313423157,
-0.4608582556247711,
0.12881307303905487,
-0.25631818175315857,
-0.2855844795703888,
-0.7052602767944336,
0.1770031750202179,
-0.005919899325817823,
0.5648646354675293,
0.527694046497345,
0.02118997648358345,
0.3418964445590973,
-0.21849283576011658,
0.5372086763381958,
0.11639014631509781,
-0.6877526044845581,
0.6073216199874878,
-0.5204123854637146,
0.3786352872848511,
0.397654265165329,
0.36524081230163574,
-0.2639070153236389,
-0.3051552474498749,
-0.5014853477478027,
-0.5673152208328247,
0.4792900085449219,
0.0339292511343956,
0.14665114879608154,
0.1557876616716385,
0.34819284081459045,
-0.0016868964303284883,
0.10401717573404312,
-0.8390317559242249,
0.013776022009551525,
0.10174289345741272,
-0.13773158192634583,
-0.16377583146095276,
-0.27193644642829895,
-0.005791937932372093,
0.001048763981088996,
0.46884801983833313,
-0.13852059841156006,
0.21949410438537598,
0.2870442569255829,
0.007083862088620663,
-0.11009054630994797,
0.12141014635562897,
0.16735687851905823,
0.2481575459241867,
-0.27513742446899414,
0.30917447805404663,
-0.0067954519763588905,
-0.619046151638031,
-0.06036839634180069,
0.2417212426662445,
-0.5789403319358826,
-0.1738256812095642,
0.2012423872947693,
0.9100341796875,
0.08998363465070724,
-0.27422091364860535,
0.37062227725982666,
-0.09967700392007828,
-0.3263176381587982,
-0.04477277025580406,
0.15410538017749786,
-0.20641854405403137,
0.28215694427490234,
0.08725132793188095,
0.19450964033603668,
0.04904920235276222,
-0.3033360242843628,
0.38668912649154663,
0.6928289532661438,
-0.6026991009712219,
-0.4700208008289337,
0.840566098690033,
0.22328579425811768,
-0.2939707636833191,
0.4178888499736786,
-0.2836780846118927,
-0.6216037273406982,
0.40158286690711975,
0.6896613240242004,
0.7496904730796814,
-0.39441776275634766,
0.08918888866901398,
0.43386077880859375,
0.4074220061302185,
0.19583886861801147,
0.19528599083423615,
-0.37149176001548767,
-1.2055507898330688,
-0.4256914556026459,
-0.5589345097541809,
-0.2555501163005829,
0.6735208034515381,
-0.27676665782928467,
0.4712934195995331,
-0.7231016755104065,
-0.165477454662323,
0.09302930533885956,
0.24649369716644287,
-0.4737473130226135,
0.0446002259850502,
0.1708189994096756,
0.6094768643379211,
-1.0071080923080444,
0.9278093576431274,
0.845192015171051,
-0.462813138961792,
-0.5575093030929565,
0.447419136762619,
0.011894718743860722,
-0.735405445098877,
0.40979817509651184,
0.13952569663524628,
-0.2213464230298996,
0.24109846353530884,
-0.6806601285934448,
-0.36863619089126587,
0.7979108691215515,
0.5632476210594177,
-0.7128188014030457,
0.18517085909843445,
-0.3390796184539795,
0.4163064956665039,
0.008398414589464664,
0.03347932919859886,
0.7423287630081177,
0.40337130427360535,
-0.008551073260605335,
-0.7015613317489624,
-0.014697695150971413,
-0.07705733180046082,
-0.30122119188308716,
0.38983216881752014,
-0.8539761900901794,
0.8479931354522705,
0.02332131378352642,
-0.3680779039859772,
-0.09358986467123032,
0.13163231313228607,
0.3509594798088074,
0.2072877585887909,
0.45984676480293274,
0.7876595258712769,
0.6336098313331604,
-0.24523675441741943,
0.8600296974182129,
-0.22739337384700775,
0.47526803612709045,
1.1870430707931519,
-0.16067826747894287,
0.7453905940055847,
0.3899492621421814,
-0.516579806804657,
0.2678961157798767,
0.6879793405532837,
-0.33955323696136475,
0.4333406984806061,
0.1804952472448349,
-0.5873996019363403,
-0.4879191517829895,
0.1399536430835724,
-0.05814223736524582,
0.4203624129295349,
0.4880819022655487,
-0.35512545704841614,
-0.3248143196105957,
-0.24981984496116638,
0.11121074855327606,
0.31343400478363037,
-0.276646226644516,
0.4069220721721649,
0.0666588693857193,
-0.45235389471054077,
0.5550427436828613,
-0.04997425153851509,
1.1422038078308105,
-0.5142616033554077,
0.0049390411004424095,
-0.3908730149269104,
0.4717322587966919,
-0.47405368089675903,
-0.6367363929748535,
-0.07968776673078537,
-0.14784985780715942,
0.11447915434837341,
0.14769138395786285,
1.016474723815918,
-0.4255883991718292,
-0.20677891373634338,
0.47043371200561523,
0.21710214018821716,
-0.11405862867832184,
-0.3176492154598236,
-0.5246158838272095,
-0.11372684687376022,
0.18419580161571503,
-0.2175195962190628,
0.5180750489234924,
0.12161052227020264,
0.1685667186975479,
0.4353998005390167,
0.8795323967933655,
0.4182545244693756,
0.03960305452346802,
0.24069970846176147,
0.841353714466095,
-0.18713106215000153,
-0.30144697427749634,
-1.0136420726776123,
0.31564053893089294,
-0.030740341171622276,
-0.20306938886642456,
0.6279696226119995,
0.45528921484947205,
1.1460427045822144,
0.11254537850618362,
0.740971565246582,
0.3907219469547272,
0.30200573801994324,
-0.5195394158363342,
0.5371336340904236,
-0.44290050864219666,
0.37469935417175293,
-0.1948980838060379,
-1.0432701110839844,
-0.921048641204834,
0.6617143750190735,
-0.5383654832839966,
-0.0377216599881649,
0.6743081212043762,
0.8301140666007996,
-0.2375372350215912,
-0.30381259322166443,
0.6270663142204285,
0.3059508502483368,
0.5736607313156128,
0.6951826214790344,
0.6098427772521973,
-0.42217519879341125,
0.7878662347793579,
-0.1789446920156479,
-0.3706784248352051,
-0.039385780692100525,
-0.7186263203620911,
-0.919078528881073,
-0.4683080017566681,
-0.33633896708488464,
-0.23618312180042267,
0.2716033458709717,
0.25908100605010986,
0.6628629565238953,
-1.0096420049667358,
0.09164060652256012,
-0.4950461983680725,
0.05105731636285782,
-0.06006719172000885,
-0.23669232428073883,
0.4292389154434204,
-0.6138567328453064,
-1.1428229808807373,
0.43752506375312805,
0.4451792538166046,
-0.05809016898274422,
-0.2384411096572876,
0.0325695239007473,
-0.16695894300937653,
-0.18103499710559845,
0.4976683557033539,
0.26425546407699585,
-0.2399839162826538,
-0.13950657844543457,
-0.0925145223736763,
-0.0021113120019435883,
0.19805291295051575,
0.8145790696144104,
-0.8079409599304199,
0.6235634684562683,
0.6970480680465698,
0.6962724328041077,
0.9862111806869507,
-0.10912203043699265,
0.22589290142059326,
-0.7864125967025757,
0.377645879983902,
0.2942615747451782,
0.5205876231193542,
0.3265506625175476,
-0.37049591541290283,
0.4770995080471039,
0.6012808084487915,
-0.6926722526550293,
-0.7181936502456665,
0.6616814136505127,
-0.5113683342933655,
-0.2901582717895508,
1.053582787513733,
-0.2809807360172272,
0.031082823872566223,
-0.06108706444501877,
-0.17930151522159576,
0.18071582913398743,
-0.568202793598175,
0.6628236770629883,
0.6426296234130859,
-0.11731458455324173,
-0.3406769037246704,
-0.24341920018196106,
0.3054073452949524,
0.615160346031189,
-0.45142510533332825,
-0.20688766241073608,
0.35453200340270996,
0.545935869216919,
-0.009886978194117546,
0.6328519582748413,
-0.4370090365409851,
0.16130071878433228,
0.15825006365776062,
-0.29799598455429077,
-0.24856127798557281,
-0.3294398784637451,
-0.5054828524589539,
0.24425585567951202,
0.23456834256649017,
-0.5082694292068481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00253v2 | A Survey on Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-01T00:33:21 | 2024-05-06T01:10:01 | Hanchao Liu, Wenyuan Xue, Yifei Chen, Dapeng Chen, Xiutian Zhao, Ke Wang, Liping Hou, Rongjun Li, Wei Peng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent development of Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) has attracted
growing attention within the AI landscape for its practical implementation
potential. However, ``hallucination'', or more specifically, the misalignment
between factual visual content and corresponding textual generation, poses a
significant challenge of utilizing LVLMs. In this comprehensive survey, we
dissect LVLM-related hallucinations in an attempt to establish an overview and
facilitate future mitigation. Our scrutiny starts with a clarification of the
concept of hallucinations in LVLMs, presenting a variety of hallucination
symptoms and highlighting the unique challenges inherent in LVLM
hallucinations. Subsequently, we outline the benchmarks and methodologies
tailored specifically for evaluating hallucinations unique to LVLMs.
Additionally, we delve into an investigation of the root causes of these
hallucinations, encompassing insights from the training data and model
components. We also critically review existing methods for mitigating
hallucinations. The open questions and future directions pertaining to
hallucinations within LVLMs are discussed to conclude this survey. | [
-0.43561050295829773,
-0.9074495434761047,
0.7329555749893188,
-0.02560609206557274,
-0.055652908980846405,
-0.22854873538017273,
-0.2597370743751526,
-0.7755596041679382,
0.28458303213119507,
0.8560495376586914,
-0.5693977475166321,
-0.3235834836959839,
-0.4950391352176666,
0.052364058792591095,
-0.588250994682312,
0.6176468729972839,
0.03920036554336548,
0.1740720272064209,
-0.30233198404312134,
-0.12285369634628296,
-0.867233157157898,
-0.8285373449325562,
-0.48022985458374023,
-0.1924121379852295,
0.6354342103004456,
-0.06021684780716896,
0.5943015813827515,
0.10904069989919662,
0.7359553575515747,
0.2400207668542862,
0.06898266822099686,
0.41480574011802673,
-0.7279349565505981,
0.4374254643917084,
0.09039968997240067,
-0.2109733521938324,
-0.17461688816547394,
-0.3317539691925049,
0.6589012145996094,
0.9882981777191162,
-0.2437436729669571,
-0.0802108496427536,
0.033465493470430374,
0.860132098197937,
-0.8676943778991699,
-0.08517474681138992,
-0.6907537579536438,
0.5208555459976196,
-0.04574991762638092,
-0.16384580731391907,
-0.6197550296783447,
-0.1256430745124817,
0.2510603070259094,
-0.22924944758415222,
0.3284573554992676,
0.26459288597106934,
0.46525973081588745,
0.8053809404373169,
-0.25108402967453003,
-0.4621789753437042,
-1.0300744771957397,
0.8290053606033325,
-0.40721553564071655,
0.7362285852432251,
0.30889734625816345,
0.33931219577789307,
0.025811797007918358,
-0.629779577255249,
-0.5483954548835754,
-0.44776034355163574,
-0.028568798676133156,
-0.024906206876039505,
-0.07169322669506073,
-0.09201622754335403,
0.44539129734039307,
0.2216048389673233,
-0.7861066460609436,
0.22944894433021545,
-0.5749070644378662,
-0.3233100175857544,
0.6525775790214539,
0.47916263341903687,
0.2187238484621048,
-0.03794967755675316,
-0.11459603905677795,
0.04821089282631874,
-0.725169837474823,
-0.3177221119403839,
0.19032426178455353,
0.10477356612682343,
0.3762395679950714,
0.8327742218971252,
0.0006383017753250897,
0.8121595978736877,
-0.3953407108783722,
0.08130916953086853,
0.23284249007701874,
-0.25204333662986755,
-0.30809617042541504,
0.15817776322364807,
0.5062925815582275,
0.6585279107093811,
0.3954419493675232,
-0.2686038017272949,
-0.4317919909954071,
0.1104789525270462,
0.7128859162330627,
-0.5878176093101501,
-0.27964988350868225,
0.48054254055023193,
-0.6557909250259399,
-0.27814337611198425,
-0.04662091284990311,
-0.7630662322044373,
-1.1046448945999146,
-0.4451114237308502,
0.35048505663871765,
-0.33386462926864624,
-0.2858949303627014,
0.12549638748168945,
-0.18835005164146423,
0.4424503743648529,
0.42231127619743347,
-0.7330111265182495,
0.09483823925256729,
0.5624123811721802,
0.6676940321922302,
-0.39661043882369995,
-0.5778514742851257,
-0.572803795337677,
-0.12330397218465805,
-0.4616357982158661,
0.62287837266922,
-0.33502066135406494,
-0.2405037134885788,
0.4470345973968506,
-0.06957367062568665,
0.0030774802435189486,
-0.8226411938667297,
0.29462751746177673,
-0.09736964106559753,
0.0717218667268753,
-0.44988974928855896,
-0.36773940920829773,
-0.22600866854190826,
0.28401678800582886,
-0.744537353515625,
0.7286404371261597,
-0.17448675632476807,
-0.7505611777305603,
0.3576413691043854,
-0.20760934054851532,
-0.2277662605047226,
0.13371576368808746,
-0.49795031547546387,
-0.433185875415802,
0.4126977026462555,
0.07908714562654495,
0.6337534189224243,
-0.1068200021982193,
0.3556375503540039,
0.01061225775629282,
-0.5434540510177612,
0.3618931472301483,
-0.3895019292831421,
0.5034371018409729,
0.0041445158421993256,
-0.39595502614974976,
0.42501017451286316,
-0.7182813286781311,
-0.2529180347919464,
0.2793389558792114,
0.3518790304660797,
-0.39817386865615845,
0.3948917090892792,
0.09817526489496231,
-0.13363958895206451,
0.06010976433753967,
0.036930881440639496,
0.16120025515556335,
-0.2817051410675049,
0.11600199341773987,
0.7612578868865967,
0.09499669820070267,
0.21831320226192474,
-0.17052395641803741,
0.20976854860782623,
0.05224914476275444,
0.43993622064590454,
0.008396800607442856,
-0.3185489773750305,
-0.9985809922218323,
0.045043956488370895,
-0.3508093059062958,
0.3301243782043457,
-0.9184035658836365,
0.21723417937755585,
0.01303160935640335,
-0.41724705696105957,
-0.350869745016098,
-0.1383110135793686,
0.36741387844085693,
0.44854241609573364,
0.3722520172595978,
-0.15636855363845825,
-0.5269023776054382,
-0.9487890005111694,
-0.001840768731199205,
-0.09105236083269119,
0.2854454219341278,
0.2304856777191162,
0.7554413080215454,
-0.468842089176178,
0.4976132810115814,
-0.4527059495449066,
-0.5078722238540649,
-0.2610233724117279,
-0.0281734149903059,
-0.3651609420776367,
0.21883158385753632,
0.595185399055481,
-0.983729362487793,
-0.08130645751953125,
-0.03558400645852089,
-0.9004369378089905,
0.1928388923406601,
-0.32526975870132446,
0.26261210441589355,
0.6447446942329407,
0.6958053708076477,
-0.6112393736839294,
0.6586366891860962,
0.4228328764438629,
-0.2902933657169342,
0.9228008985519409,
-0.10317381471395493,
0.12169557064771652,
-0.6285577416419983,
-0.0181579627096653,
-0.22003880143165588,
0.18424761295318604,
-0.72806715965271,
0.21174420416355133,
-0.30994153022766113,
0.10293687880039215,
-0.43315961956977844,
0.23488762974739075,
-0.4895652234554291,
-0.3799069821834564,
-0.09434295445680618,
0.2443174570798874,
-0.3436548411846161,
0.2534833252429962,
0.23021073639392853,
0.3983665108680725,
0.7416161298751831,
-0.5513136982917786,
0.7987028360366821,
0.19632625579833984,
-0.5339679718017578,
0.16031602025032043,
-0.3923533856868744,
0.03783413767814636,
-0.4591180086135864,
0.03672581538558006,
-0.7924994826316833,
-0.41464900970458984,
0.5266565084457397,
-0.2194853276014328,
0.05315973982214928,
0.29587045311927795,
-0.4453427195549011,
-0.35365021228790283,
-0.36913153529167175,
0.5037477016448975,
0.5097291469573975,
-0.5086466670036316,
0.4124397933483124,
0.2547476589679718,
0.2047301083803177,
-0.683495819568634,
-0.6975026726722717,
0.33624228835105896,
-0.21377865970134735,
-0.4771781861782074,
0.02366734854876995,
-0.14626562595367432,
-0.6291107535362244,
-0.14746420085430145,
0.16508670151233673,
0.2533811926841736,
-0.024895932525396347,
0.25624990463256836,
0.1744617521762848,
-0.1666124016046524,
0.13867411017417908,
-0.5616700053215027,
0.2357783317565918,
0.3597531020641327,
-0.07635053992271423,
0.8569267392158508,
-0.09562884271144867,
-0.7261629700660706,
-0.20967523753643036,
0.46139541268348694,
0.5477244257926941,
-0.32003700733184814,
0.7191406488418579,
0.6172151565551758,
-0.5991290211677551,
-0.40261295437812805,
-0.7269389629364014,
-0.3765847384929657,
-0.3316733241081238,
0.7005885243415833,
-0.31640905141830444,
-0.6078747510910034,
0.5311633348464966,
0.2541499435901642,
-0.11542584002017975,
0.36357489228248596,
0.7810326218605042,
-0.06253720074892044,
0.9872531890869141,
0.6267886757850647,
0.16665218770503998,
0.23598231375217438,
-0.2706603407859802,
0.4060816466808319,
-0.5791294574737549,
-0.6501451134681702,
-0.33163896203041077,
-0.14435480535030365,
-0.505470871925354,
-0.48483747243881226,
0.16697609424591064,
-0.3913557827472687,
0.06907597184181213,
-0.18172630667686462,
-0.6669535040855408,
0.4146465063095093,
0.33790966868400574,
-0.08494459092617035,
0.06298850476741791,
0.0946379229426384,
0.22815009951591492,
-0.1581895351409912,
-0.6115503311157227,
-0.3244163990020752,
0.7483797669410706,
0.29699844121932983,
0.7852276563644409,
0.04929076135158539,
0.6639949679374695,
0.2547392249107361,
-0.211774080991745,
-0.8548157215118408,
0.654723584651947,
0.031037988141179085,
-0.34511125087738037,
-0.6071376204490662,
-0.28810757398605347,
-0.7658270597457886,
0.25000685453414917,
-0.3425242602825165,
-1.0936181545257568,
0.16255098581314087,
0.15615373849868774,
-0.19376973807811737,
0.29772481322288513,
-0.3902241289615631,
0.9230962991714478,
-0.38888034224510193,
-0.3474326431751251,
-0.29746970534324646,
-0.6494988203048706,
0.7102242112159729,
-0.0813874900341034,
0.04729599505662918,
0.2879398763179779,
0.40189337730407715,
0.42658767104148865,
-0.20100536942481995,
0.9661486148834229,
-0.15010666847229004,
-0.4647286534309387,
0.2574365437030792,
0.03567234054207802,
0.4166645109653473,
-0.3411172330379486,
0.37008917331695557,
0.20477689802646637,
-0.054895348846912384,
-0.10519324988126755,
-0.5184644460678101,
0.6174665093421936,
-0.5656311511993408,
-0.6411981582641602,
-0.6233659982681274,
-0.5956621170043945,
-0.21688081324100494,
-0.02450970932841301,
0.41895592212677,
0.3994253873825073,
-0.346607506275177,
0.29948726296424866,
0.8969347476959229,
-0.5191622376441956,
0.4153723120689392,
-0.08820819109678268,
-0.8474234938621521,
-0.11728964000940323,
1.2332810163497925,
0.20877277851104736,
0.2570361793041229,
0.1248721107840538,
-0.13582876324653625,
-0.20954987406730652,
-0.863955020904541,
-0.2715449929237366,
0.2254815548658371,
-0.8662537932395935,
0.2566097378730774,
-0.5062732696533203,
-0.6015477776527405,
-0.5279392600059509,
-0.031509146094322205,
-0.35738253593444824,
-0.12158088386058807,
-0.3691539764404297,
0.11471296846866608,
-0.025335678830742836,
0.9641677737236023,
0.3792046308517456,
-0.08142899721860886,
-0.5699740648269653,
0.5558128356933594,
0.1706409603357315,
0.1537863314151764,
0.31779012084007263,
-0.23878909647464752,
-0.23268301784992218,
-0.1285773664712906,
0.08296096324920654,
-0.6927797198295593,
0.48162850737571716,
-0.21175932884216309,
0.5573610067367554,
0.5984445214271545,
0.09361762553453445,
0.7796960473060608,
-0.5902712941169739,
1.153938889503479,
0.3601450026035309,
-0.5446556806564331,
0.4698520004749298,
0.09041892737150192,
0.03717222437262535,
0.19542068243026733,
0.2858177423477173,
-0.6484588980674744,
-0.5856561064720154,
-0.22516034543514252,
-0.7144855856895447,
0.197936549782753,
0.3355597257614136,
0.028768151998519897,
0.13652542233467102,
0.20558691024780273,
0.26055508852005005,
0.08763881027698517,
-0.786774754524231,
-0.07755828648805618,
-0.17437024414539337,
-0.017458265647292137,
-0.08949312567710876,
-0.4309013783931732,
-0.2511523962020874,
-0.32110780477523804,
0.44169339537620544,
0.0022699078544974327,
0.025612710043787956,
0.20989775657653809,
-0.3732993006706238,
-0.09583282470703125,
-0.185622900724411,
0.9394747614860535,
0.9855149388313293,
-0.22961418330669403,
0.15014512836933136,
0.10914824903011322,
-0.5675534605979919,
-0.2842039465904236,
-0.3382900357246399,
-0.29197752475738525,
0.09209278225898743,
0.6626991033554077,
1.1348814964294434,
-0.24931426346302032,
-1.0400160551071167,
0.5180244445800781,
-0.14839059114456177,
-0.29356083273887634,
-0.8016747832298279,
0.11716870963573456,
-0.24754297733306885,
0.4245743751525879,
0.37581267952919006,
-0.012445124797523022,
0.17261379957199097,
-0.7313863039016724,
-0.06183408573269844,
0.6645222306251526,
-0.44603675603866577,
-0.11390167474746704,
0.5799449682235718,
-0.06742598116397858,
-0.38419219851493835,
0.8388828039169312,
0.10652264207601547,
-0.574184000492096,
0.654973566532135,
0.36027365922927856,
1.0121510028839111,
-0.027198240160942078,
0.0486828088760376,
0.1548745185136795,
0.5991104245185852,
-0.13670001924037933,
0.32338616251945496,
0.09027601033449173,
-0.7475097179412842,
-0.18139860033988953,
-0.6818944811820984,
-0.37259820103645325,
0.3086630702018738,
-0.6058409810066223,
0.4046350419521332,
-0.18186037242412567,
0.019785212352871895,
-0.10621444135904312,
-0.3735053241252899,
-0.5197911262512207,
0.24986673891544342,
0.6542034149169922,
0.5334110856056213,
-0.770838737487793,
0.6402908563613892,
0.41531693935394287,
-0.5291511416435242,
-0.2262481451034546,
0.3403087556362152,
-0.08623775839805603,
-0.6084893345832825,
0.5609033107757568,
0.28136584162712097,
-0.29712817072868347,
-0.22564710676670074,
-0.6461573243141174,
-0.3611586391925812,
0.898634135723114,
-0.1663084179162979,
-0.666161298751831,
-0.29272422194480896,
0.5082663297653198,
0.5787160396575928,
-0.3578450381755829,
-0.2868020534515381,
0.7567319273948669,
0.47858309745788574,
0.09685134142637253,
-0.6822491884231567,
0.02869296446442604,
0.062089163810014725,
0.02037479169666767,
0.06114257872104645,
-0.6929290294647217,
0.6373178958892822,
-0.2934959828853607,
-0.05244394764304161,
0.21287475526332855,
0.39626458287239075,
0.3172754645347595,
0.5384836792945862,
0.4981774687767029,
0.39771920442581177,
0.806951105594635,
-0.03080185130238533,
0.909001350402832,
-0.06636393070220947,
0.010727032087743282,
1.0156021118164062,
-0.4828816056251526,
0.734688937664032,
0.9238088130950928,
0.14290860295295715,
0.00418475829064846,
0.4625692367553711,
-0.27267366647720337,
0.45967721939086914,
0.3680342137813568,
-0.063710518181324,
-0.24428178369998932,
-0.045353226363658905,
-0.5954199433326721,
0.5319775342941284,
0.36893123388290405,
-0.2476191222667694,
0.17219425737857819,
0.3589686453342438,
-0.6417799592018127,
-0.07934709638357162,
-0.37423819303512573,
0.7656456232070923,
0.02028818055987358,
-0.7792702913284302,
0.6805424690246582,
-0.43006953597068787,
0.2932487726211548,
-0.37425339221954346,
-0.2821463644504547,
-0.2585826814174652,
0.10591192543506622,
-0.19511857628822327,
-0.6019951701164246,
0.4439692199230194,
-0.04813400283455849,
-0.2002428025007248,
-0.24488654732704163,
0.7810090184211731,
-0.361908882856369,
-0.4194932281970978,
0.34677863121032715,
0.525518000125885,
0.496608704328537,
-0.3040069341659546,
-0.17336787283420563,
0.6537416577339172,
0.1340845227241516,
-0.13718242943286896,
0.12694475054740906,
0.5506052374839783,
-0.18959762156009674,
0.6736454367637634,
0.308342844247818,
0.18913303315639496,
0.27299097180366516,
0.5195808410644531,
0.7148050665855408,
-1.0047388076782227,
-0.09722820669412613,
-0.9693990349769592,
0.5589874386787415,
-0.08245690166950226,
-0.2978050708770752,
0.536600649356842,
0.583313524723053,
0.7982746958732605,
-0.4754948616027832,
0.7687450051307678,
0.08016450703144073,
0.13850054144859314,
-0.829409122467041,
1.0167770385742188,
-0.9409897923469543,
0.22794866561889648,
-0.2736685574054718,
-1.2318415641784668,
-0.47915586829185486,
0.6364879608154297,
-0.10131050646305084,
-0.2732170522212982,
0.8599408268928528,
0.8084778189659119,
0.11203078925609589,
-0.06746338307857513,
0.7133758068084717,
0.4699569344520569,
0.11033798009157181,
0.4679390490055084,
1.454679012298584,
-0.12108469009399414,
0.41524872183799744,
-0.13091999292373657,
0.1454405039548874,
-0.6280714273452759,
-0.6742579340934753,
-0.958490252494812,
-0.9448990821838379,
-0.36378300189971924,
-0.21335089206695557,
0.12207198888063431,
0.5477911233901978,
0.2874069809913635,
-0.7532302141189575,
-0.13707618415355682,
-0.13893695175647736,
0.13075396418571472,
0.0002685191575437784,
-0.19117523729801178,
0.33095529675483704,
-0.3961390554904938,
-0.6778379082679749,
0.14056670665740967,
0.3032967448234558,
0.19245079159736633,
-0.9269635081291199,
-0.15022306144237518,
0.1889525055885315,
-0.15964044630527496,
0.8703658580780029,
0.06258480995893478,
-1.2688884735107422,
-0.552765429019928,
0.1722681224346161,
-0.15124011039733887,
-0.08527913689613342,
0.7842118740081787,
-0.6372480988502502,
0.458538681268692,
0.3908863067626953,
0.5417720079421997,
0.4090349078178406,
-0.31488466262817383,
0.27025720477104187,
-0.5728021860122681,
0.32909759879112244,
0.48974764347076416,
0.3758183419704437,
0.3612428903579712,
-0.2876366376876831,
0.4314516484737396,
0.29574301838874817,
-0.4136202931404114,
-1.2572925090789795,
0.37902674078941345,
-1.1164162158966064,
-0.5403472781181335,
1.1759382486343384,
0.5188409686088562,
-0.15803764760494232,
0.08292794972658157,
-0.5741271376609802,
0.018046071752905846,
0.3683442771434784,
1.134377121925354,
0.9666945338249207,
-0.17842867970466614,
-0.276781290769577,
-0.7474127411842346,
0.590604841709137,
0.34971338510513306,
-0.701677143573761,
0.4131002724170685,
0.9995099902153015,
-0.3469981551170349,
0.24971149861812592,
0.3908854126930237,
0.21396149694919586,
0.19170337915420532,
0.2163776010274887,
0.2902207374572754,
0.21757560968399048,
-0.7112686038017273,
-0.32896581292152405,
0.23301495611667633,
-0.013849539682269096,
0.03131531551480293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00251v1 | Efficient Non-Parametric Uncertainty Quantification for Black-Box Large Language Models and Decision Planning | 2024-02-01T00:23:31 | 2024-02-01T00:23:31 | Yao-Hung Hubert Tsai, Walter Talbott, Jian Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Step-by-step decision planning with large language models (LLMs) is gaining
attention in AI agent development. This paper focuses on decision planning with
uncertainty estimation to address the hallucination problem in language models.
Existing approaches are either white-box or computationally demanding, limiting
use of black-box proprietary LLMs within budgets. The paper's first
contribution is a non-parametric uncertainty quantification method for LLMs,
efficiently estimating point-wise dependencies between input-decision on the
fly with a single inference, without access to token logits. This estimator
informs the statistical interpretation of decision trustworthiness. The second
contribution outlines a systematic design for a decision-making agent,
generating actions like ``turn on the bathroom light'' based on user prompts
such as ``take a bath''. Users will be asked to provide preferences when more
than one action has high estimated point-wise dependencies. In conclusion, our
uncertainty estimation and decision-making agent design offer a cost-efficient
approach for AI agent development. | [
-0.19019462168216705,
-0.6056767702102661,
1.0932507514953613,
0.20246320962905884,
0.1100020483136177,
-0.1653032749891281,
-0.09025000780820847,
-0.3746432960033417,
0.25799837708473206,
0.49077922105789185,
-0.3275378942489624,
-0.40083032846450806,
-0.4487699270248413,
-0.026940034702420235,
-0.052183136343955994,
0.25542324781417847,
-0.12817278504371643,
0.056642286479473114,
-0.1262240707874298,
0.013148794881999493,
-0.3162122070789337,
-0.061305444687604904,
-0.8070449829101562,
-0.29778510332107544,
0.39868223667144775,
0.2344001978635788,
1.0876349210739136,
0.23292486369609833,
0.0827302411198616,
0.26055607199668884,
0.11793102324008942,
0.33264514803886414,
0.019144251942634583,
0.2637213468551636,
-0.20980259776115417,
-0.3693859875202179,
-0.6228840947151184,
-0.22348462045192719,
0.10239450633525848,
0.5152455568313599,
-0.08785172551870346,
0.13786521553993225,
-0.1961115300655365,
0.5380160212516785,
-0.8839897513389587,
0.5215005874633789,
-0.5238389372825623,
0.20371587574481964,
0.5542568564414978,
-0.222123920917511,
-0.577581524848938,
-0.15582706034183502,
0.041595056653022766,
-0.4679281413555145,
-0.07196047902107239,
0.03713330626487732,
0.37702322006225586,
0.7464156746864319,
-0.15334764122962952,
-0.3632545471191406,
-1.0139882564544678,
0.9780851602554321,
-0.6909834742546082,
0.7732025384902954,
0.8558706641197205,
0.1317788064479828,
-0.3832434117794037,
-0.5955564975738525,
-0.5052929520606995,
-0.5027972459793091,
-0.05565940588712692,
-0.27628058195114136,
0.043103449046611786,
0.29101741313934326,
0.1391952484846115,
-0.24531245231628418,
-0.5050429105758667,
-0.10955508798360825,
-0.04734373837709427,
-0.2949824035167694,
0.7846634387969971,
-0.019120115786790848,
0.06023202836513519,
-0.15232203900814056,
-0.17149151861667633,
-0.00717078847810626,
-0.2601645886898041,
-0.1517111361026764,
0.22057214379310608,
0.33556050062179565,
0.009467413648962975,
0.5888819098472595,
-0.1981911063194275,
0.4608111083507538,
0.0427272692322731,
-0.46092697978019714,
-0.07750003039836884,
-0.2668130099773407,
-0.36485451459884644,
0.0973730981349945,
0.7402177453041077,
0.1636406034231186,
0.3573564291000366,
-0.347808301448822,
-0.4397130608558655,
0.03858041390776634,
0.4229224622249603,
-0.7201237678527832,
-0.10617854446172714,
0.6900983452796936,
-0.27332407236099243,
-0.2830854058265686,
-0.2765178978443146,
-1.0349202156066895,
-0.6010892987251282,
-0.2827725112438202,
0.4540615379810333,
-0.438449889421463,
-0.21850167214870453,
0.06369854509830475,
0.09988719969987869,
0.4088577330112457,
0.4280429780483246,
-0.7510452270507812,
0.2243114411830902,
0.358857661485672,
0.6903427243232727,
-0.013524300418794155,
-0.36885321140289307,
-0.40238073468208313,
0.3488781154155731,
-0.8014350533485413,
0.5327885746955872,
-0.5353389382362366,
-0.4238920509815216,
-0.044343601912260056,
-0.4799391031265259,
0.09744027256965637,
-0.3644101023674011,
0.2722187340259552,
-0.38018035888671875,
-0.29489895701408386,
-0.02194724977016449,
-0.3289478123188019,
-0.1943081021308899,
0.3073577582836151,
-0.6943864822387695,
0.7714499831199646,
0.2829225957393646,
-0.43235015869140625,
0.5259540677070618,
-0.5507654547691345,
-0.503443717956543,
0.15511195361614227,
-0.34311988949775696,
-0.4135458469390869,
0.22632266581058502,
0.4064529538154602,
0.4145186245441437,
-0.20578734576702118,
0.3843262493610382,
-0.2456376552581787,
-0.2941662073135376,
0.17980150878429413,
-0.39005112648010254,
0.6539000272750854,
0.2336065024137497,
-0.5936064124107361,
0.4568599462509155,
-0.7543420195579529,
0.12115428596735,
0.0201265886425972,
-0.05684490129351616,
-0.05721070244908333,
0.3220829367637634,
-0.19612586498260498,
0.17450125515460968,
0.48796936869621277,
0.07942745834589005,
-0.077835313975811,
-0.06047891080379486,
0.37999486923217773,
0.8018588423728943,
0.09269212931394577,
0.5599140524864197,
-0.3143092095851898,
0.6848852038383484,
-0.32516786456108093,
0.4979017674922943,
0.3733278512954712,
-0.4349864423274994,
-0.7204312086105347,
-0.19020669162273407,
0.04964609444141388,
0.4610353708267212,
-0.7578806281089783,
0.507183313369751,
0.20344918966293335,
-0.3892199993133545,
-0.2562091648578644,
-0.08388718217611313,
0.10414595156908035,
0.07134774327278137,
0.32928594946861267,
0.3041512668132782,
-0.2765553891658783,
-0.49018368124961853,
0.14145588874816895,
-0.7159228324890137,
0.05522892251610756,
0.21380920708179474,
0.6085661053657532,
-0.3335753381252289,
0.6809679865837097,
-0.32983165979385376,
-0.09891437739133835,
-0.2947692573070526,
0.1093086302280426,
-0.3372213542461395,
0.16773048043251038,
0.31913575530052185,
-0.7778854966163635,
-0.22993981838226318,
-0.1434517204761505,
-0.6896448135375977,
0.19074878096580505,
-0.4183017313480377,
-0.1945323795080185,
0.49488934874534607,
0.4647427797317505,
-0.9683115482330322,
0.7058997750282288,
0.3927639424800873,
-0.20955432951450348,
0.6296104788780212,
-0.36653581261634827,
0.07444377988576889,
-0.9836010932922363,
-0.12011891603469849,
0.0870848298072815,
-0.036489326506853104,
-0.7324903607368469,
0.2547905743122101,
-0.03804880008101463,
0.02598283626139164,
-0.3891567885875702,
0.7221360206604004,
-0.5403124094009399,
-0.3224501609802246,
-0.25207000970840454,
-0.05534509941935539,
-0.13810697197914124,
0.7456236481666565,
0.2668136954307556,
0.8669119477272034,
0.5827282667160034,
-0.6659612655639648,
0.11058817058801651,
0.08589337021112442,
-0.23166567087173462,
0.4248535633087158,
-0.47718799114227295,
0.23461568355560303,
0.025288110598921776,
0.06330631673336029,
-0.6875486969947815,
-0.09793473780155182,
0.6377447247505188,
-0.5238803029060364,
0.14237907528877258,
0.06488630920648575,
-0.40451285243034363,
0.008214064873754978,
-0.28674623370170593,
0.3694346249103546,
0.30617180466651917,
-0.2680814266204834,
0.7759515047073364,
0.4091821312904358,
-0.06046149507164955,
-0.567046582698822,
-0.5236013531684875,
0.168288454413414,
-0.21723301708698273,
-0.4431001842021942,
-0.00753858732059598,
-0.07656201720237732,
-0.6873793005943298,
-0.13289645314216614,
-0.35094743967056274,
-0.2786312401294708,
0.035430267453193665,
0.3253994882106781,
0.13203983008861542,
0.038814034312963486,
-0.001015248941257596,
0.014069588854908943,
-0.14188514649868011,
0.2642551064491272,
-0.29885587096214294,
0.6033080816268921,
0.0810626894235611,
-0.519356369972229,
-0.3891647160053253,
0.27169498801231384,
0.6852771043777466,
-0.2292528599500656,
0.5338503122329712,
0.2336752563714981,
-0.6579501628875732,
-0.7528424263000488,
-0.4030149281024933,
-0.2574983537197113,
-0.45420098304748535,
0.2548023462295532,
-0.4548434019088745,
-0.32569342851638794,
0.5386597514152527,
0.12916627526283264,
-0.010063813999295235,
0.09076975286006927,
0.5304035544395447,
0.15258517861366272,
0.92372727394104,
0.5776745676994324,
0.13418902456760406,
0.19248922169208527,
-0.10580119490623474,
0.48139432072639465,
-0.2663278579711914,
-0.15777705609798431,
-0.5067612528800964,
-0.20940649509429932,
-0.5949601531028748,
-0.8679304718971252,
0.2991710603237152,
-0.29889360070228577,
-0.09126432240009308,
0.004349320661276579,
-0.3193127512931824,
0.11336599290370941,
0.5657906532287598,
0.04655483737587929,
0.22116638720035553,
-0.16771142184734344,
0.17615681886672974,
0.33905065059661865,
-0.2898947596549988,
-0.5713736414909363,
1.0493407249450684,
0.24243760108947754,
0.9558106660842896,
0.007702893111854792,
0.8468051552772522,
0.18618853390216827,
-0.2946976125240326,
-1.034674882888794,
0.6352546215057373,
0.5675625801086426,
-0.4702717363834381,
-1.0295497179031372,
-0.39453962445259094,
-0.8555805683135986,
0.1782359480857849,
-0.00643982645124197,
-0.8044025897979736,
0.4744262993335724,
-0.12403921037912369,
-0.46674057841300964,
0.37125980854034424,
-0.4883808493614197,
0.4398403763771057,
-0.2873366177082062,
-0.23001104593276978,
-0.1614052653312683,
-0.45417168736457825,
0.0680113211274147,
-0.27999159693717957,
0.07666190713644028,
-0.019886042922735214,
-0.28529658913612366,
0.5396639108657837,
-0.4207712411880493,
0.5813502669334412,
-0.33852195739746094,
-0.11631994694471359,
0.41154226660728455,
0.38155022263526917,
0.8907978534698486,
0.27927687764167786,
-0.41897696256637573,
0.08210204541683197,
-0.014882903546094894,
-0.42167678475379944,
-0.6980499625205994,
0.4098309874534607,
-0.6480334401130676,
-0.6386113166809082,
-0.5859324336051941,
-0.9752727150917053,
-0.5534597039222717,
0.1983291655778885,
0.048612967133522034,
0.00194397266022861,
-0.05556196719408035,
-0.32894980907440186,
0.5746389627456665,
-0.3642368018627167,
0.6795002818107605,
0.2713858485221863,
-0.09178684651851654,
-0.2691158354282379,
0.7737176418304443,
0.19384659826755524,
0.16493283212184906,
0.42427968978881836,
0.10945994406938553,
-0.37518393993377686,
-1.0497933626174927,
-0.32277512550354004,
0.2486717849969864,
-0.4423905909061432,
-0.0041616507805883884,
-0.28152650594711304,
-0.3921370804309845,
-0.7199163436889648,
-0.46131566166877747,
-0.34484341740608215,
-0.22661438584327698,
-0.24354399740695953,
-0.2999476194381714,
0.2329639494419098,
0.775749921798706,
-0.0868038535118103,
0.08982912451028824,
-0.20257101953029633,
0.47356098890304565,
0.16822393238544464,
0.37777718901634216,
0.09340603649616241,
-0.11300856620073318,
-0.1958136111497879,
-0.04042010381817818,
-0.1170261800289154,
-0.9673588871955872,
0.6899809241294861,
-0.28880929946899414,
0.5499232411384583,
0.5066908001899719,
0.651701807975769,
0.4962306618690491,
-0.1286325454711914,
0.625022828578949,
-0.1656060516834259,
-0.7748511433601379,
0.44714802503585815,
-0.07917066663503647,
0.03404814004898071,
0.7070703506469727,
0.24822907149791718,
-0.1140088364481926,
-0.4869331419467926,
-0.6444460153579712,
-0.7388516664505005,
0.5791926980018616,
0.27351242303848267,
-0.155502587556839,
0.21432048082351685,
0.20856772363185883,
0.09774895012378693,
0.32918640971183777,
-0.6339341998100281,
-0.26939383149147034,
0.025171304121613503,
-0.052261460572481155,
-0.20404917001724243,
-0.31117045879364014,
-0.017620055004954338,
-0.2258938103914261,
0.692859411239624,
-0.20556248724460602,
0.3891972303390503,
0.025807306170463562,
-0.2001388520002365,
-0.22218748927116394,
0.1951598823070526,
0.6649705171585083,
1.064089298248291,
-0.41499510407447815,
0.2878822684288025,
0.28214460611343384,
-0.28250575065612793,
0.3818504512310028,
0.04157550632953644,
-0.34536319971084595,
0.02769857831299305,
0.2950281500816345,
0.6709467172622681,
-0.08511308580636978,
-0.5677874088287354,
0.24960364401340485,
-0.016894711181521416,
-0.3189599812030792,
-0.6572166681289673,
-0.004957885947078466,
-0.11995648592710495,
0.6195608973503113,
0.06739513576030731,
-0.08523799479007721,
0.19114035367965698,
-0.24821116030216217,
0.3369728922843933,
0.4610307514667511,
-0.4846351146697998,
0.007521327119320631,
0.5335724949836731,
-0.030471067875623703,
-0.5028497576713562,
0.4720120131969452,
-0.6628623604774475,
-0.007627492304891348,
0.5991027355194092,
0.3986819386482239,
1.2422024011611938,
-0.2839588224887848,
0.7776383757591248,
0.12754647433757782,
0.5050704479217529,
-0.017368866130709648,
0.5438713431358337,
0.0007158810622058809,
-0.7458223700523376,
-0.29565054178237915,
-0.6918787956237793,
-0.555156946182251,
0.20874646306037903,
-0.3453633785247803,
0.35681942105293274,
-0.711889922618866,
-0.08930595219135284,
-0.28713124990463257,
0.11862919479608536,
-0.39886021614074707,
0.1681104153394699,
-0.022295204922556877,
0.6234921813011169,
-0.6064638495445251,
0.7514948844909668,
0.5298629999160767,
-0.4317694902420044,
-0.9071319699287415,
0.4587697386741638,
-0.20695267617702484,
-0.995616614818573,
0.12168662995100021,
-0.20337285101413727,
-0.3512183427810669,
-0.25845035910606384,
-0.4176332652568817,
-0.8125900626182556,
1.0696791410446167,
0.4924634099006653,
-0.28358131647109985,
-0.4215574562549591,
0.43127769231796265,
0.3002236485481262,
-0.015607764013111591,
0.16801418364048004,
0.6763249635696411,
0.7785248756408691,
0.4007796347141266,
-0.5177024006843567,
0.35351306200027466,
0.18580006062984467,
-0.011376350186765194,
0.4876573383808136,
-0.49208390712738037,
0.7566700577735901,
-0.5013997554779053,
-0.053799837827682495,
0.047258034348487854,
0.642501711845398,
0.36405280232429504,
0.5452650785446167,
0.47768235206604004,
0.40469810366630554,
0.8624956011772156,
0.3013812005519867,
0.7607972025871277,
-0.5250775814056396,
0.16919822990894318,
0.9947739243507385,
-0.19756531715393066,
0.7482703924179077,
0.6659356951713562,
-0.26887449622154236,
0.06063937768340111,
0.8399392366409302,
0.05837623402476311,
0.40870359539985657,
0.24550479650497437,
-0.2466927021741867,
-0.1593935638666153,
0.04103134199976921,
-0.04480525106191635,
0.3213431239128113,
0.33908581733703613,
-0.2574426829814911,
-0.08316494524478912,
-0.2723948657512665,
0.25938645005226135,
-0.34004902839660645,
-0.07928173243999481,
0.6898422241210938,
0.20132139325141907,
-0.7780568599700928,
0.46090859174728394,
-0.0611492358148098,
0.15490399301052094,
-0.3636292815208435,
0.11055777966976166,
-0.25710445642471313,
-0.0737883448600769,
-0.1400824934244156,
-0.5040060877799988,
0.15440329909324646,
-0.3099433481693268,
0.09368204325437546,
-0.11866743117570877,
0.47394344210624695,
-0.15311883389949799,
-0.8082064390182495,
0.4134780466556549,
0.6186864972114563,
0.2739010751247406,
-0.389583945274353,
-0.5392675399780273,
-0.0916568860411644,
-0.06186499819159508,
-0.2505200207233429,
0.21915754675865173,
0.5626546740531921,
-0.2387629747390747,
0.7097806930541992,
0.20260988175868988,
0.37036269903182983,
0.05649638548493385,
-0.07615948468446732,
0.24296128749847412,
-0.6335493326187134,
-0.3243599534034729,
-0.8619998097419739,
0.3267126679420471,
0.418716698884964,
-0.14800046384334564,
0.328316867351532,
0.3266095221042633,
0.5863165259361267,
0.1210915669798851,
0.891755998134613,
0.10549253970384598,
-0.26639050245285034,
-0.4813450276851654,
0.6216464042663574,
-0.4175184667110443,
0.2230788618326187,
-0.330020934343338,
-1.035197377204895,
-0.31382477283477783,
0.8867533206939697,
-0.2201654613018036,
0.19094480574131012,
0.8097137212753296,
1.1225671768188477,
0.23457157611846924,
-0.09007814526557922,
0.5923029184341431,
0.055804572999477386,
0.3177666664123535,
0.5190844535827637,
0.7534472346305847,
-0.07392071932554245,
0.44975191354751587,
-0.5157917737960815,
-0.2300175428390503,
-0.12200985103845596,
-0.6356915235519409,
-0.7493963241577148,
-0.7921885251998901,
-0.38756316900253296,
-0.23003612458705902,
-0.20805948972702026,
0.9458902478218079,
0.717124879360199,
-0.8581017255783081,
-0.5832302570343018,
-0.11454001814126968,
0.5899682641029358,
-0.397053062915802,
-0.152510404586792,
0.4804958999156952,
-0.5280108451843262,
-0.793578565120697,
0.3396773338317871,
0.1888727992773056,
0.08890050649642944,
-0.6320282220840454,
-0.501508891582489,
-0.21177376806735992,
0.5308594107627869,
0.5446057319641113,
0.1011592298746109,
-0.9153448939323425,
-0.4773474335670471,
-0.0028613009490072727,
-0.018617304041981697,
0.1167987510561943,
0.5035460591316223,
-0.35360944271087646,
0.27983924746513367,
0.3379819393157959,
0.4349568784236908,
0.5153093338012695,
-0.28656116127967834,
0.5558356046676636,
-0.392013818025589,
0.1614992916584015,
0.3925330340862274,
0.2581261396408081,
-0.013721328228712082,
-0.5083264708518982,
0.5520268678665161,
-0.14121995866298676,
-0.6558456420898438,
-0.791292667388916,
0.2348426878452301,
-0.919689416885376,
-0.48803889751434326,
1.4064595699310303,
0.22258822619915009,
-0.2699272632598877,
-0.1909637600183487,
-0.18371182680130005,
0.30110326409339905,
-0.6588674783706665,
0.8983684182167053,
0.6527551412582397,
-0.5393356084823608,
-0.32316040992736816,
-0.6206379532814026,
0.645038366317749,
0.15425856411457062,
-0.8342310190200806,
0.06389331072568893,
0.6811583638191223,
-0.2046646624803543,
0.21139295399188995,
0.5937258005142212,
0.24623611569404602,
-0.0453827828168869,
0.32375669479370117,
0.18068717420101166,
0.13786950707435608,
-0.7751085758209229,
-0.07268832623958588,
0.37308964133262634,
0.5090304613113403,
-0.4350802004337311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00235v1 | Exploring the limits of decoder-only models trained on public speech recognition corpora | 2024-01-31T23:29:42 | 2024-01-31T23:29:42 | Ankit Gupta, George Saon, Brian Kingsbury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The emergence of industrial-scale speech recognition (ASR) models such as
Whisper and USM, trained on 1M hours of weakly labelled and 12M hours of audio
only proprietary data respectively, has led to a stronger need for large scale
public ASR corpora and competitive open source pipelines. Unlike the said
models, large language models are typically based on Transformer decoders, and
it remains unclear if decoder-only models trained on public data alone can
deliver competitive performance. In this work, we investigate factors such as
choice of training datasets and modeling components necessary for obtaining the
best performance using public English ASR corpora alone. Our Decoder-Only
Transformer for ASR (DOTA) model comprehensively outperforms the
encoder-decoder open source replication of Whisper (OWSM) on nearly all English
ASR benchmarks and outperforms Whisper large-v3 on 7 out of 15 test sets. We
release our codebase and model checkpoints under permissive license. | [
-0.2269195318222046,
-0.06474708020687103,
0.3499223589897156,
0.32549938559532166,
-0.10766924172639847,
-0.08161299675703049,
-0.4128774106502533,
-0.6920854449272156,
-0.30694904923439026,
0.6144079566001892,
-0.27795806527137756,
-0.5378819704055786,
-0.7381315231323242,
0.5280574560165405,
-0.6289710402488708,
0.6900274157524109,
0.2287922203540802,
0.17508861422538757,
-0.14615938067436218,
-0.17141953110694885,
-0.12394703179597855,
-0.7993949055671692,
-0.36722373962402344,
-0.19108334183692932,
0.1959502249956131,
0.3884214758872986,
0.4821205139160156,
0.6663225293159485,
0.34569495916366577,
0.256995290517807,
-0.43575236201286316,
-0.11606297641992569,
-0.5783165693283081,
-0.1475597769021988,
-0.089783675968647,
-0.35742494463920593,
-0.2189411222934723,
-0.058491867035627365,
0.7724570035934448,
0.6322890520095825,
-0.2002544403076172,
0.4271710515022278,
0.009320421144366264,
0.29552674293518066,
-0.7277123332023621,
0.3874395191669464,
-0.9314252734184265,
-0.13652198016643524,
-0.3009292185306549,
0.21055282652378082,
-0.630824863910675,
-0.32982635498046875,
0.3106355667114258,
-0.5408677458763123,
0.34844475984573364,
-0.12682415544986725,
0.9451649785041809,
0.25096598267555237,
-0.228794664144516,
-0.38394251465797424,
-1.0753065347671509,
0.6827046275138855,
-0.4638831913471222,
0.7537373900413513,
0.15277567505836487,
0.5195417404174805,
0.37245747447013855,
-0.7213675379753113,
-0.33715465664863586,
0.04612704738974571,
0.13952717185020447,
0.021874966099858284,
-0.7953915596008301,
-0.019761933013796806,
0.14871594309806824,
0.2872636020183563,
-0.4158701002597809,
0.31135863065719604,
-0.9052342176437378,
0.028129635378718376,
0.47722578048706055,
0.05375971272587776,
-0.03255348652601242,
-0.03632119297981262,
-0.45993924140930176,
-0.24716033041477203,
-0.8095258474349976,
0.23030270636081696,
0.15497000515460968,
0.6062189936637878,
-0.02014661394059658,
0.5258714556694031,
-0.05738180875778198,
0.2199331820011139,
-0.061943184584379196,
0.0635630190372467,
0.2972504794597626,
0.1765836924314499,
-0.2459767609834671,
0.32344919443130493,
0.9396088719367981,
-0.0951068326830864,
0.08676230162382126,
-0.40790271759033203,
-0.35180097818374634,
0.44397884607315063,
0.1270865947008133,
-0.8135851621627808,
0.022197498008608818,
0.1533750742673874,
-0.3511793911457062,
-0.19713692367076874,
-0.060252655297517776,
-0.644854724407196,
-0.2007664144039154,
-0.4063933491706848,
0.5242604613304138,
-0.16476832330226898,
-0.5752411484718323,
0.45687225461006165,
-0.23653635382652283,
0.2383636236190796,
-0.11090273410081863,
-0.6951964497566223,
0.60494464635849,
0.8566985130310059,
0.7465129494667053,
-0.13979431986808777,
-0.38146451115608215,
-0.5264452695846558,
0.010408328846096992,
-0.45518478751182556,
0.7575423121452332,
-0.5743589401245117,
-0.6535161733627319,
0.15244337916374207,
-0.024799427017569542,
-0.33238157629966736,
-0.8100064992904663,
0.8820905685424805,
-0.7305837273597717,
-0.14584685862064362,
-0.10687089711427689,
-0.5362372994422913,
0.021638182923197746,
-0.24610210955142975,
-0.7044143676757812,
0.4882020652294159,
-0.2583863437175751,
-0.6714788675308228,
0.24524201452732086,
-0.8555284738540649,
-0.3016587793827057,
-0.02684328518807888,
-0.22047822177410126,
-0.46664169430732727,
0.3081323802471161,
0.19745977222919464,
0.3925590515136719,
-0.38184088468551636,
0.12422589212656021,
0.08309408277273178,
-0.5250228047370911,
0.2602071166038513,
-0.5894766449928284,
0.7704350352287292,
0.31055641174316406,
-0.31339573860168457,
0.20180776715278625,
-1.0375310182571411,
-0.24876035749912262,
0.08249900490045547,
-0.5239298939704895,
0.009205394424498081,
0.09598808735609055,
0.2957669198513031,
0.04704001173377037,
-0.040787745267152786,
-0.9402011036872864,
-0.3576869070529938,
-0.497405469417572,
0.565367579460144,
0.6926841139793396,
-0.4577699601650238,
0.2720368504524231,
-0.1401776373386383,
0.5023441314697266,
-0.10581884533166885,
0.12005525082349777,
0.07029900699853897,
-0.4780520796775818,
-0.5942095518112183,
-0.6707085967063904,
0.5295814871788025,
0.3192600607872009,
-0.18237869441509247,
0.2627545893192291,
-0.7100883722305298,
-0.498624324798584,
-1.2239844799041748,
-0.2852434515953064,
0.5089987516403198,
0.3561670482158661,
0.40268126130104065,
0.14101992547512054,
-0.8037189245223999,
-0.9224891662597656,
-0.03877180442214012,
-0.011637190356850624,
-0.5531722903251648,
0.2511918246746063,
0.26480022072792053,
-0.3591063916683197,
1.0441105365753174,
-0.47506028413772583,
-0.3821951746940613,
-0.42790669202804565,
0.012632029131054878,
0.17735634744167328,
-0.08239476382732391,
0.12350553274154663,
-0.7627655863761902,
-0.4224312901496887,
-0.013296003453433514,
-0.47648850083351135,
-0.11712118238210678,
0.366698294878006,
0.3581272065639496,
0.2446332424879074,
0.36441904306411743,
-0.4295613467693329,
0.31262609362602234,
1.0675075054168701,
-0.18498580157756805,
0.6358186602592468,
-0.20180027186870575,
-0.13079294562339783,
-0.7332609295845032,
0.34606510400772095,
-0.16080555319786072,
-0.23964369297027588,
-0.7024603486061096,
0.07408946752548218,
0.1566964089870453,
-0.8361490368843079,
-0.5431239008903503,
0.24500668048858643,
-0.5294867753982544,
-0.22196874022483826,
-0.2854798436164856,
-0.016380442306399345,
-0.13584499061107635,
0.34503844380378723,
0.565673291683197,
0.8982853293418884,
0.8120492100715637,
-0.7230412364006042,
-0.06822417676448822,
0.5288211703300476,
-0.5275116562843323,
0.05450541526079178,
-0.9122235178947449,
0.2815326154232025,
-0.021110819652676582,
-0.021635008975863457,
-0.5152168869972229,
0.005143876653164625,
-0.3351101279258728,
-0.43988531827926636,
0.26991358399391174,
-0.16017964482307434,
-0.3176969885826111,
-0.4056601822376251,
0.08092335611581802,
-0.05705615505576134,
0.8123626112937927,
-1.0157102346420288,
0.7501948475837708,
0.5636271834373474,
0.059134747833013535,
-0.29903697967529297,
-0.6363828778266907,
-0.0768720880150795,
-0.058900125324726105,
-0.8070287108421326,
0.1863059103488922,
-0.0294998437166214,
-0.09408639371395111,
-0.2786746323108673,
-0.22305269539356232,
-0.19064904749393463,
-0.13406625390052795,
0.466984361410141,
0.15689809620380402,
-0.4924634099006653,
-0.23647984862327576,
-0.3488202691078186,
-0.39052626490592957,
0.1435708999633789,
0.013328741304576397,
0.2833077311515808,
-0.19898976385593414,
-0.3563868999481201,
-0.601387619972229,
0.398242712020874,
0.6541157960891724,
-0.49735110998153687,
0.725494384765625,
0.16729053854942322,
-0.03956611827015877,
-0.4434864819049835,
-0.5075832605361938,
0.0012286516139283776,
-0.4972873330116272,
0.22959108650684357,
-0.6115759611129761,
-0.8602219820022583,
0.3713398277759552,
0.03872647136449814,
-0.012136719189584255,
0.31612512469291687,
0.33226004242897034,
0.3492397964000702,
0.9468721151351929,
0.6996375918388367,
-0.3623199462890625,
0.06965048611164093,
-0.19963939487934113,
0.10490257292985916,
-0.695939838886261,
-0.19423973560333252,
-0.7532954216003418,
0.18137606978416443,
-0.5399441123008728,
-0.5191043019294739,
0.5518757700920105,
-0.228097066283226,
-0.0613228976726532,
0.476071298122406,
-0.6720953583717346,
0.4843612313270569,
0.48900526762008667,
0.019186770543456078,
0.5277601480484009,
0.07296334207057953,
0.20295511186122894,
0.17430417239665985,
-0.5660761594772339,
-0.5473064184188843,
1.243963599205017,
0.7193688154220581,
0.7041581869125366,
0.054022498428821564,
0.41991081833839417,
-0.15877260267734528,
-0.06091241165995598,
-0.6091940999031067,
0.41663122177124023,
-0.458956778049469,
-0.7241212725639343,
-0.4100835919380188,
-0.4314476549625397,
-1.0888363122940063,
0.2995743751525879,
-0.03708479180932045,
-0.25497373938560486,
0.4193773567676544,
-0.10801595449447632,
-0.18685446679592133,
0.34773382544517517,
-0.6580744981765747,
0.7253665924072266,
0.32942232489585876,
0.22730326652526855,
0.03217552974820137,
-0.40741902589797974,
-0.001412472571246326,
-0.06478946655988693,
0.1872292011976242,
0.021825894713401794,
0.010189859196543694,
0.5719515681266785,
-0.23503805696964264,
0.6351106762886047,
-0.1701623648405075,
0.002890408504754305,
0.2836647629737854,
-0.2161170095205307,
0.5109423995018005,
-0.3008558452129364,
-0.14874954521656036,
0.7231412529945374,
-0.021449536085128784,
-0.219089075922966,
-0.11327584087848663,
0.37387800216674805,
-1.1844894886016846,
-0.46785202622413635,
-0.27413296699523926,
0.014083502814173698,
-0.3568717837333679,
-0.04445507004857063,
0.6528316140174866,
0.6914359331130981,
-0.3716959059238434,
0.5463977456092834,
0.943488597869873,
0.05757805332541466,
0.28589051961898804,
0.9604700803756714,
-0.014940885826945305,
-0.3289574682712555,
0.9702087044715881,
0.07041747868061066,
0.20652511715888977,
0.5461660623550415,
0.4154636859893799,
-0.44054871797561646,
-0.7265196442604065,
-0.28633570671081543,
0.09624826908111572,
-0.44068533182144165,
-0.17952536046504974,
-0.859632670879364,
-0.4707515239715576,
-0.45025208592414856,
0.09403262287378311,
-0.7714301347732544,
-0.07370162010192871,
-0.41548439860343933,
-0.1417957991361618,
0.24207307398319244,
0.9646857380867004,
-0.23656128346920013,
-0.12029539048671722,
-0.6860437393188477,
0.3280870020389557,
0.47294825315475464,
0.49578946828842163,
-0.03142673894762993,
-0.5874198079109192,
-0.1111648827791214,
-0.07392430305480957,
-0.04528871551156044,
-0.6645075082778931,
0.25828948616981506,
0.15674836933612823,
0.44749587774276733,
0.38722163438796997,
0.1747799664735794,
0.443552702665329,
-0.918422281742096,
0.6745031476020813,
0.10883232206106186,
-0.9622434377670288,
0.2419928014278412,
-0.4886839687824249,
0.3209242522716522,
0.3690808117389679,
0.4155491292476654,
-0.28836581110954285,
-0.46734756231307983,
-0.44185471534729004,
-0.6294592022895813,
0.7866381406784058,
0.42182812094688416,
0.059786297380924225,
0.108756884932518,
-0.22063226997852325,
0.1573084145784378,
0.07234657555818558,
-0.4271150231361389,
-0.1834404170513153,
-0.41567158699035645,
-0.12315869331359863,
-0.22976772487163544,
-0.2586783766746521,
-0.06466425210237503,
0.03386585786938667,
0.6190345883369446,
0.18731559813022614,
0.2117718905210495,
0.13584420084953308,
-0.06421452015638351,
-0.022977381944656372,
0.5257289409637451,
0.3647910952568054,
0.5796900391578674,
-0.22963647544384003,
-0.10482732206583023,
0.06646348536014557,
-0.603759229183197,
0.038832779973745346,
0.3491576015949249,
-0.14895670115947723,
0.3403055965900421,
0.05963780730962753,
0.9224420785903931,
0.4417963922023773,
-0.8320807814598083,
0.7653709650039673,
-0.11157741397619247,
-0.24444113671779633,
-0.373770534992218,
-0.14622892439365387,
0.28252846002578735,
0.2928158640861511,
0.5263670086860657,
0.024079496040940285,
0.23868303000926971,
-0.3607027232646942,
0.05183252692222595,
0.17413432896137238,
-0.29178881645202637,
-0.5795281529426575,
0.8492002487182617,
0.2473309338092804,
-0.2644050121307373,
0.4511442184448242,
-0.025608481839299202,
-0.516744077205658,
0.256237268447876,
0.6305364370346069,
0.8315614461898804,
-0.3797289729118347,
-0.03179561719298363,
0.30236583948135376,
0.1214422732591629,
-0.4095911979675293,
0.044063568115234375,
0.05657299607992172,
-0.4285960793495178,
-0.2960822284221649,
-0.818200945854187,
-0.537746787071228,
0.315036803483963,
-0.9661740660667419,
0.5613464117050171,
-0.21980924904346466,
0.01013513095676899,
0.011715314351022243,
-0.19997747242450714,
-0.7488297820091248,
0.16069220006465912,
0.4459860920906067,
1.1528170108795166,
-0.8102594017982483,
0.6677950024604797,
0.2573363482952118,
-0.3202376067638397,
-0.984245240688324,
-0.17684395611286163,
-0.11412252485752106,
-0.6887684464454651,
0.5928062796592712,
0.0692744180560112,
-0.3752957284450531,
-0.028202593326568604,
-0.34956246614456177,
-0.9619103074073792,
0.885600745677948,
0.5047414898872375,
-0.8290359377861023,
-0.3389062285423279,
0.1867634505033493,
0.5655178427696228,
-0.17890141904354095,
0.03932717815041542,
0.5068780183792114,
-0.015585051849484444,
0.2342820167541504,
-1.3126460313796997,
-0.2774622440338135,
-0.021760035306215286,
0.11964905261993408,
0.020370157435536385,
-0.6562391519546509,
0.6607785820960999,
0.09629343450069427,
-0.5556724071502686,
0.02018989622592926,
0.6486201882362366,
0.3375956416130066,
0.17889998853206635,
0.3475106358528137,
0.3827657401561737,
0.49070581793785095,
0.11011989414691925,
0.954836368560791,
-0.11408431828022003,
0.06946831196546555,
1.1171833276748657,
-0.28459402918815613,
1.450482726097107,
-0.07896893471479416,
-0.2859804034233093,
0.4053688645362854,
0.0829596072435379,
-0.1804012954235077,
0.626560628414154,
0.07936303317546844,
-0.24889709055423737,
-0.13357774913311005,
-0.03731813654303551,
-0.3531945049762726,
0.816724419593811,
-0.0013781094457954168,
-0.2427627295255661,
-0.03269994631409645,
0.21010763943195343,
-0.024508601054549217,
0.36067861318588257,
-0.478379487991333,
0.9812602400779724,
0.004464935045689344,
-0.1987966150045395,
0.6765580773353577,
-0.10824745893478394,
0.9459041953086853,
-0.7845432162284851,
0.43796464800834656,
0.13107503950595856,
0.2123107761144638,
-0.07699394226074219,
-0.32668039202690125,
0.33108142018318176,
0.49347350001335144,
-0.46176931262016296,
-0.2337636798620224,
0.48600292205810547,
-0.28981688618659973,
-0.5511456727981567,
0.5861083269119263,
0.022563813254237175,
0.3249824047088623,
-0.39112144708633423,
-0.18336418271064758,
0.5166343450546265,
-0.23774674534797668,
-0.03948401287198067,
0.2878350615501404,
0.40292349457740784,
0.5193533301353455,
0.5478077530860901,
0.5275079011917114,
0.3188152313232422,
0.28484949469566345,
0.15559887886047363,
0.9151816368103027,
-0.37751203775405884,
-0.6234040856361389,
-0.39948657155036926,
0.5361446738243103,
0.07413823157548904,
-0.14388339221477509,
0.7710099220275879,
0.9002863764762878,
0.77133709192276,
-0.19834837317466736,
0.756527841091156,
0.4488430619239807,
1.0994740724563599,
-0.34577134251594543,
0.8663927912712097,
-0.20687128603458405,
0.061510827392339706,
-0.03546009212732315,
-0.5386834740638733,
0.1922473907470703,
0.3034929931163788,
-0.335207998752594,
-0.5164332985877991,
0.38616743683815,
0.775534987449646,
-0.11926782131195068,
0.3673935830593109,
0.7135036587715149,
0.30198436975479126,
0.25294846296310425,
0.6499451398849487,
0.8340984582901001,
-0.5238713026046753,
1.1483403444290161,
0.10650156438350677,
-0.12313798815011978,
0.013081206008791924,
-0.5227556824684143,
-0.9754975438117981,
-0.7007321715354919,
-0.19505080580711365,
-0.2690146863460541,
0.052572403103113174,
0.8304727673530579,
0.8519081473350525,
-0.8910531997680664,
-0.46173831820487976,
0.06278593838214874,
-0.3585232198238373,
-0.09128578752279282,
-0.135997474193573,
0.42837101221084595,
-0.10346490144729614,
-0.7387212514877319,
0.8917754888534546,
-0.04050170257687569,
-0.19642405211925507,
-0.25753775238990784,
-0.010846740566194057,
0.3368181586265564,
0.2704624831676483,
0.495134562253952,
0.3293912708759308,
-0.6122450232505798,
0.01528029702603817,
0.13851812481880188,
-0.06252755224704742,
0.32351627945899963,
0.8242945075035095,
-0.6357712745666504,
0.47109419107437134,
0.1920638233423233,
0.5391631126403809,
0.6012970805168152,
-0.07125116139650345,
0.7395347952842712,
-0.6173357367515564,
0.12915876507759094,
0.43898463249206543,
0.0979127511382103,
0.4659549593925476,
-0.0391695462167263,
0.2752310633659363,
-0.08597491681575775,
-0.6308280825614929,
-1.001768946647644,
0.05523418262600899,
-0.5456522703170776,
-0.3192642331123352,
1.405134916305542,
-0.1195259615778923,
-0.26206907629966736,
-0.09036236256361008,
0.0547538585960865,
0.24718032777309418,
-0.547199547290802,
0.5428162217140198,
0.3103726804256439,
0.18151292204856873,
0.0944255143404007,
-0.34884920716285706,
0.6737256646156311,
-0.284366637468338,
-0.4330170750617981,
0.27763310074806213,
0.26329633593559265,
0.5852993726730347,
0.32686835527420044,
0.6646667122840881,
-0.22394104301929474,
0.19877563416957855,
0.40165820717811584,
0.0011902025435119867,
-0.3205875754356384,
-0.5168279409408569,
-0.8721169233322144,
0.491344690322876,
0.1834578961133957,
-0.47652626037597656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00234v1 | Are Generative AI systems Capable of Supporting Information Needs of Patients? | 2024-01-31T23:24:37 | 2024-01-31T23:24:37 | Shreya Rajagopal, Subhashis Hazarika, Sookyung Kim, Yan-ming Chiou, Jae Ho Sohn, Hari Subramonyam, Shiwali Mohan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Patients managing a complex illness such as cancer face a complex information
challenge where they not only must learn about their illness but also how to
manage it. Close interaction with healthcare experts (radiologists,
oncologists) can improve patient learning and thereby, their disease outcome.
However, this approach is resource intensive and takes expert time away from
other critical tasks. Given the recent advancements in Generative AI models
aimed at improving the healthcare system, our work investigates whether and how
generative visual question answering systems can responsibly support patient
information needs in the context of radiology imaging data. We conducted a
formative need-finding study in which participants discussed chest computed
tomography (CT) scans and associated radiology reports of a fictitious close
relative with a cardiothoracic radiologist. Using thematic analysis of the
conversation between participants and medical experts, we identified commonly
occurring themes across interactions, including clarifying medical terminology,
locating the problems mentioned in the report in the scanned image,
understanding disease prognosis, discussing the next diagnostic steps, and
comparing treatment options. Based on these themes, we evaluated two
state-of-the-art generative visual language models against the radiologist's
responses. Our results reveal variability in the quality of responses generated
by the models across various themes. We highlight the importance of
patient-facing generative AI systems to accommodate a diverse range of
conversational themes, catering to the real-world informational needs of
patients. | [
-0.34198305010795593,
-0.739341139793396,
0.8800336122512817,
-0.06312502920627594,
-0.37226617336273193,
-0.12323130667209625,
0.11892182379961014,
-0.4955277740955353,
0.1610446721315384,
0.6515450477600098,
-0.5056555867195129,
-0.3389468193054199,
-0.6877394914627075,
0.1411515772342682,
-0.27947285771369934,
0.7472606301307678,
-0.04472219571471214,
0.4107193946838379,
-0.7278542518615723,
-0.02661464735865593,
-0.6710532307624817,
-0.0859670490026474,
-0.957531213760376,
-0.23409046232700348,
0.5368929505348206,
0.2742234766483307,
1.111072301864624,
0.4911373257637024,
0.9459618926048279,
0.28767532110214233,
0.17929503321647644,
0.1415606588125229,
-0.25734519958496094,
0.7769652009010315,
0.18436086177825928,
-0.4133428633213043,
-0.1710679829120636,
-0.46219223737716675,
-0.08901405334472656,
0.5729485154151917,
-0.23400582373142242,
-0.20031730830669403,
-0.07345807552337646,
0.5626530647277832,
-0.31588631868362427,
0.2782136797904968,
-0.07744728773832321,
0.5567658543586731,
0.12883521616458893,
-0.5880841016769409,
-0.22568561136722565,
-0.2815721333026886,
0.4445987939834595,
-0.9523531198501587,
0.2647310793399811,
-0.2574297785758972,
0.9584916234016418,
0.520034909248352,
-0.1850489377975464,
-0.4631260335445404,
-0.8759391903877258,
0.07498297095298767,
-0.33011266589164734,
0.028371043503284454,
0.5876857042312622,
0.6003618836402893,
-0.07170568406581879,
-0.6706606149673462,
-0.2844127416610718,
0.09453464299440384,
-0.29831045866012573,
0.6219407916069031,
-0.40745246410369873,
0.33063265681266785,
0.1983080506324768,
0.4010884463787079,
-0.7306283116340637,
-0.04810766503214836,
-0.41774553060531616,
-0.09501059353351593,
0.43792447447776794,
0.5240603089332581,
0.7871658802032471,
-0.2774101197719574,
-0.2406388819217682,
0.04210781306028366,
-0.37063559889793396,
-0.31478214263916016,
-0.34482067823410034,
-0.17179743945598602,
-0.27722713351249695,
0.5776528716087341,
-0.09139398485422134,
0.7569002509117126,
-0.06013450399041176,
0.04227006062865257,
-0.013080154545605183,
-0.2775033712387085,
-0.34430935978889465,
-0.20462438464164734,
0.6760461926460266,
0.3102598786354065,
0.05367949232459068,
-0.04583853483200073,
0.04136713594198227,
-0.008021366782486439,
0.46022385358810425,
-0.5050390362739563,
-0.422588050365448,
0.5285665988922119,
-0.6427602767944336,
-0.04029466584324837,
0.03275642916560173,
-0.664513349533081,
-0.6950060129165649,
-0.3022666275501251,
0.20729604363441467,
-0.727516770362854,
-0.4309268295764923,
0.04998113214969635,
-0.37604543566703796,
0.18618935346603394,
0.7670958638191223,
-0.5291321277618408,
-0.21582962572574615,
0.26857325434684753,
0.5691117644309998,
0.4136030972003937,
0.21811091899871826,
-0.4805125594139099,
0.292226642370224,
-0.2108829766511917,
0.9583582878112793,
-0.5817826390266418,
-0.6156376600265503,
-0.0275005791336298,
-0.27613726258277893,
-0.2493964284658432,
-0.6071640849113464,
0.1198250874876976,
-0.6460925936698914,
0.3024798333644867,
-0.40798771381378174,
-0.24148160219192505,
0.1340017318725586,
0.38006630539894104,
-0.6583799719810486,
0.3214222490787506,
0.28360557556152344,
-0.7361906170845032,
0.23610515892505646,
-0.5255607962608337,
-0.2582610249519348,
0.7536699771881104,
-0.8491716980934143,
-0.3715258240699768,
0.23196223378181458,
0.31583172082901,
0.5882799625396729,
-0.5364258289337158,
0.2591171860694885,
-0.09488329291343689,
-0.14574021100997925,
0.40210792422294617,
-0.228695809841156,
0.3953237533569336,
0.5784572958946228,
0.0747903510928154,
0.1282401829957962,
-0.4419301152229309,
0.04666083678603172,
0.2131427377462387,
-0.2824482321739197,
-0.22232799232006073,
0.03474742919206619,
-0.039037544280290604,
0.040379155427217484,
-0.08397877961397171,
-0.3038010001182556,
0.17207379639148712,
-0.049080949276685715,
0.20796555280685425,
0.5972478985786438,
0.2928045094013214,
-0.16099241375923157,
-0.5185196399688721,
1.0021696090698242,
0.26917311549186707,
0.26500144600868225,
-0.3970892131328583,
-0.7560368180274963,
-0.7093353867530823,
-0.3602839410305023,
-0.04649492725729942,
0.4693242311477661,
-1.237130045890808,
-0.15485236048698425,
-0.3551771342754364,
-0.1304764747619629,
-0.6425526738166809,
-0.3099353313446045,
0.5468783974647522,
0.7266947031021118,
0.27967727184295654,
-0.43212994933128357,
-0.41799718141555786,
-0.7740347385406494,
0.3543950617313385,
-0.46047884225845337,
-0.2494085431098938,
0.7182866930961609,
-0.04848860204219818,
-0.12291479855775833,
0.6156606674194336,
-0.5678461194038391,
-0.3174367845058441,
-0.3194859027862549,
0.31842145323753357,
-0.17236638069152832,
0.0657888799905777,
0.41010862588882446,
-1.0810790061950684,
-0.26750457286834717,
0.36173784732818604,
-1.4136348962783813,
0.08879007399082184,
-0.2908901274204254,
0.08432911336421967,
-0.2256753295660019,
0.3936861455440521,
-0.3943374752998352,
0.6669462323188782,
0.25980886816978455,
-0.2950651943683624,
0.05626772716641426,
-0.5289040803909302,
0.30609676241874695,
-1.1610970497131348,
0.09560569375753403,
-0.03376490995287895,
-0.2307940423488617,
-0.6774821877479553,
-0.024615420028567314,
-0.32243669033050537,
-0.4759533405303955,
-0.042610470205545425,
0.07594915479421616,
-0.3902854025363922,
-0.0634443610906601,
-0.049329888075590134,
-0.15440917015075684,
0.025636298581957817,
0.03757614269852638,
0.30349841713905334,
0.587613046169281,
0.7922750115394592,
-0.48232269287109375,
0.3585035502910614,
0.49803557991981506,
-0.30221131443977356,
0.8859298229217529,
-0.7090815901756287,
0.12742942571640015,
-0.6606809496879578,
-0.06227806583046913,
-0.8724128603935242,
-0.570734977722168,
0.42100098729133606,
-0.5791322588920593,
0.2587525248527527,
-0.18599814176559448,
-0.32899099588394165,
-0.4200788140296936,
0.41106438636779785,
0.41926613450050354,
0.3575918972492218,
0.020120691508054733,
0.7882434725761414,
0.25003576278686523,
-0.4132912755012512,
-0.27454328536987305,
-0.8039107918739319,
0.42288464307785034,
-0.058067142963409424,
-0.6587012410163879,
0.011072964407503605,
0.03169240429997444,
-0.25666922330856323,
0.22997403144836426,
0.4593392312526703,
-0.27977272868156433,
0.12702608108520508,
0.41686907410621643,
0.2349652200937271,
-0.34045010805130005,
0.4863665699958801,
-0.3250357508659363,
-0.17566874623298645,
0.029741156846284866,
-0.19725479185581207,
0.53700852394104,
-0.05099828541278839,
-0.6291000247001648,
-0.6290256381034851,
0.7313123345375061,
0.6697752475738525,
-0.3010169565677643,
0.48879578709602356,
0.5021085143089294,
-0.3842829763889313,
0.3933632969856262,
-0.5511156916618347,
-0.09384243190288544,
-0.35606229305267334,
0.23235757648944855,
-0.39374297857284546,
-0.7241033315658569,
0.5352743864059448,
0.3525366485118866,
-0.3799833357334137,
0.4167628586292267,
0.5851943492889404,
-0.5316283702850342,
0.9725852012634277,
0.4290158152580261,
0.1611327826976776,
0.08731037378311157,
-0.24320082366466522,
0.12072568386793137,
-0.5679758191108704,
-0.6681954264640808,
-0.22489596903324127,
-0.06658748537302017,
-0.5231806039810181,
-0.24792490899562836,
1.0508204698562622,
-0.3117116391658783,
0.1753934621810913,
-0.150770366191864,
-0.6814852356910706,
-0.07021285593509674,
0.376704603433609,
0.7001726627349854,
0.14295148849487305,
0.1734059751033783,
0.17276570200920105,
0.04266642406582832,
-0.9437562227249146,
-0.21812663972377777,
0.8209227919578552,
0.13688117265701294,
1.0046731233596802,
0.14843177795410156,
0.34768587350845337,
0.3375600278377533,
0.17735350131988525,
-0.6256184577941895,
0.2873113453388214,
-0.13675525784492493,
-0.3172242045402527,
-0.24683500826358795,
-0.28910136222839355,
-1.125964879989624,
-0.14171642065048218,
-0.25108397006988525,
-0.2467029094696045,
0.39028704166412354,
0.2934267818927765,
-0.6077446937561035,
0.0891856774687767,
-0.4441620111465454,
0.793838381767273,
-0.31020715832710266,
-0.11693722754716873,
-0.19597859680652618,
-0.944852352142334,
-0.09490334242582321,
0.2708209156990051,
0.02179170586168766,
0.17410758137702942,
0.23393145203590393,
0.4883074164390564,
-0.5204578638076782,
0.8661316633224487,
-0.06910353899002075,
0.2126057893037796,
0.4042809307575226,
0.02435861900448799,
-0.08090897649526596,
0.10823091119527817,
0.12260068953037262,
-0.1601393073797226,
0.18895605206489563,
-0.5466094613075256,
-0.7447584271430969,
0.4075727164745331,
-0.9620447754859924,
-0.8819633722305298,
-0.44700106978416443,
-0.4272521734237671,
-0.22542451322078705,
0.07484632730484009,
0.41664087772369385,
0.4688636362552643,
-0.03619539737701416,
0.17779071629047394,
0.8240245580673218,
-0.2735487222671509,
0.005951256025582552,
0.16618643701076508,
0.28565260767936707,
0.018691806122660637,
0.7046682238578796,
-0.10690277814865112,
0.161198228597641,
0.6069114208221436,
0.2700527608394623,
0.3269116282463074,
-0.611132800579071,
-0.6470377445220947,
0.0992586612701416,
-0.7959228157997131,
-0.3215303421020508,
-0.787575900554657,
-0.43293800950050354,
-0.18434123694896698,
-0.15126030147075653,
0.11022904515266418,
0.046857766807079315,
-0.7520195245742798,
0.009026476182043552,
0.4352076053619385,
0.7660084366798401,
0.284332275390625,
-0.024600818753242493,
-0.8956940770149231,
0.25775712728500366,
0.5089491605758667,
0.1266590654850006,
-0.07119515538215637,
-0.21053706109523773,
-0.09053599089384079,
-0.013626612722873688,
-0.20224729180335999,
-0.9647444486618042,
0.22337360680103302,
0.14590103924274445,
0.5345809459686279,
0.4235859513282776,
-0.06270340085029602,
0.6149814128875732,
0.09740200638771057,
0.6544591188430786,
0.31946930289268494,
-0.3746291697025299,
0.8753871321678162,
-0.44002336263656616,
0.4932081997394562,
0.5021119117736816,
0.4625775218009949,
-0.777448296546936,
-0.3398585617542267,
-0.4911946952342987,
-0.4505138099193573,
0.5279566645622253,
0.23079441487789154,
0.20515194535255432,
-0.14717282354831696,
0.5303285121917725,
-0.12285953015089035,
0.07026713341474533,
-0.34195834398269653,
0.01851068250834942,
-0.5192056894302368,
-0.36692696809768677,
0.27954503893852234,
-0.30966031551361084,
-0.4071754813194275,
0.2924096882343292,
0.06886957585811615,
-0.32385846972465515,
0.6588524580001831,
0.5490990877151489,
0.19266550242900848,
-0.19244743883609772,
0.29758313298225403,
0.3050733804702759,
0.6105448007583618,
0.11711917072534561,
0.11330460011959076,
-0.2646203339099884,
-0.3413347899913788,
-0.144090935587883,
-0.05639065057039261,
-0.21551521122455597,
-0.1651272177696228,
0.46851080656051636,
0.905180811882019,
-0.25618478655815125,
-0.710060715675354,
0.6725900769233704,
-0.258291095495224,
-0.025861337780952454,
-0.29520106315612793,
0.2290239930152893,
-0.01642167940735817,
0.18782061338424683,
0.223059743642807,
0.2456560730934143,
0.22243499755859375,
-0.5013455152511597,
0.15897835791110992,
0.47911888360977173,
-0.8758042454719543,
-0.24665911495685577,
0.6186254024505615,
0.1134641170501709,
-0.22667720913887024,
1.0856008529663086,
0.3160838782787323,
-0.20437484979629517,
0.9792143702507019,
0.3072236180305481,
0.5398722290992737,
-0.2716776728630066,
0.6046127676963806,
0.1366613656282425,
0.06483480334281921,
0.2352704405784607,
0.5948988795280457,
-0.07629207521677017,
-0.6238104104995728,
0.06300440430641174,
0.03414647653698921,
-0.2744123935699463,
0.10105633735656738,
-0.9553368091583252,
0.07121209800243378,
-0.4633680582046509,
-0.24208591878414154,
0.10626929253339767,
-0.6061171293258667,
-0.8733440041542053,
0.722179651260376,
0.23965907096862793,
0.4531075060367584,
-0.7237737774848938,
0.4860405921936035,
0.82155841588974,
-0.8509860634803772,
-0.7795895934104919,
-0.01798049919307232,
-0.10838671773672104,
-1.0473506450653076,
0.6357805728912354,
-0.1278163641691208,
0.14893639087677002,
-0.28782954812049866,
-0.30260664224624634,
-0.7925440073013306,
1.1103872060775757,
0.17409497499465942,
0.02031051740050316,
-0.11195642501115799,
0.18878944218158722,
1.1118714809417725,
-0.5360488295555115,
0.5329645872116089,
-0.1042943075299263,
0.25612789392471313,
0.609782874584198,
-0.5945560336112976,
0.07920883595943451,
-0.5420548319816589,
0.13557235896587372,
-0.09053801000118256,
-0.5914164781570435,
0.5446373820304871,
-0.47179651260375977,
-0.41457095742225647,
0.1586705446243286,
0.5459231734275818,
-0.1810011863708496,
0.4225611388683319,
0.36078959703445435,
0.463586688041687,
0.6965270042419434,
-0.1950712352991104,
1.557891845703125,
-0.1399655044078827,
-0.2323324829339981,
0.5328751802444458,
0.16932445764541626,
0.469662070274353,
0.3793582618236542,
-0.0816105380654335,
0.4990059435367584,
0.6266542673110962,
-0.05200773850083351,
0.2739052176475525,
-0.03131873905658722,
-0.331790030002594,
-0.5548504590988159,
-0.5614848136901855,
-0.6316331624984741,
0.3550141155719757,
0.6507874131202698,
-0.5327314138412476,
0.00947960652410984,
0.2906114161014557,
-0.292831689119339,
-0.07640350610017776,
-0.078523188829422,
1.0765306949615479,
-0.017335431650280952,
-0.8094984292984009,
0.4548977017402649,
-0.3018368184566498,
-0.09150243550539017,
-0.5606473088264465,
-0.05101540684700012,
-0.31874048709869385,
-0.2183648645877838,
-0.3967439830303192,
-0.8740836977958679,
0.3298952579498291,
-0.11129110306501389,
-0.3058365285396576,
-0.05581926554441452,
0.4338425099849701,
-0.3369849622249603,
-0.6510051488876343,
-0.030933720991015434,
0.5054744482040405,
0.21121686697006226,
0.18331827223300934,
-0.5340233445167542,
0.05994966998696327,
0.022873081266880035,
0.15530207753181458,
0.26240310072898865,
0.03340817615389824,
-0.23135817050933838,
0.9105959534645081,
0.2040289342403412,
0.06392180919647217,
-0.3334009647369385,
0.1700415164232254,
0.9131562113761902,
-0.22371919453144073,
-0.32874324917793274,
-0.26205694675445557,
0.32331982254981995,
0.042358387261629105,
-0.3937666714191437,
0.2371140569448471,
0.19702298939228058,
0.514744222164154,
-0.10398868471384048,
1.0463225841522217,
-0.00972210243344307,
0.15996472537517548,
-0.6575382351875305,
0.6254662871360779,
-0.8048507571220398,
0.4074999690055847,
0.031888168305158615,
-0.15415401756763458,
-0.47120413184165955,
0.4614690840244293,
-0.37554728984832764,
0.19169268012046814,
0.46615421772003174,
0.5528967976570129,
0.13863147795200348,
0.26969727873802185,
0.39397671818733215,
0.19438987970352173,
0.4879937469959259,
0.8229060173034668,
0.8530483245849609,
-0.20933230221271515,
0.5707992911338806,
-0.0708908960223198,
-0.24618738889694214,
-0.27234166860580444,
-0.2538410425186157,
-0.5810880661010742,
-0.7447534203529358,
-0.6115767955780029,
-0.2204607129096985,
0.3576803207397461,
0.5883190035820007,
0.6490037441253662,
-0.48148515820503235,
0.09723944962024689,
-0.005459279287606478,
-0.15997010469436646,
0.013707377947866917,
-0.19245368242263794,
0.5626523494720459,
-0.09939596056938171,
-0.2828437387943268,
0.004117220640182495,
0.6338660717010498,
0.30232325196266174,
-0.12210885435342789,
0.14952610433101654,
0.28737619519233704,
-0.25903186202049255,
0.19614997506141663,
0.4369296729564667,
-0.7029473185539246,
-0.053499408066272736,
0.06028323993086815,
-0.48159563541412354,
0.4539005160331726,
0.9192227721214294,
-0.7442583441734314,
1.1089398860931396,
0.3709363043308258,
0.8047906756401062,
0.4906465709209442,
0.11324109882116318,
0.49137887358665466,
-0.21541917324066162,
-0.15955013036727905,
0.4700026214122772,
0.1650465875864029,
0.5021445751190186,
-0.8710200190544128,
0.06958064436912537,
0.27975940704345703,
-0.2466879040002823,
-0.1619817018508911,
0.2535996735095978,
-0.8732579946517944,
-0.20679378509521484,
0.76630038022995,
-0.4748631715774536,
0.016727769747376442,
-0.3438344895839691,
-0.17801617085933685,
-0.06240372732281685,
-0.10919922590255737,
0.8180409073829651,
0.4089677929878235,
-0.62000572681427,
-0.650324285030365,
-0.20851050317287445,
0.36337044835090637,
0.5377905368804932,
-1.0481021404266357,
-0.43491265177726746,
0.5415875911712646,
0.05594561994075775,
-0.004044938366860151,
0.9800859689712524,
-0.15193791687488556,
0.7000563144683838,
-0.22706829011440277,
-0.18357311189174652,
-0.2272535115480423,
-0.21667829155921936,
-0.08061117678880692,
0.43279728293418884,
0.1750323623418808,
-0.18842805922031403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15514v2 | Large Scale Generative AI Text Applied to Sports and Music | 2024-01-31T22:47:01 | 2024-02-28T00:03:57 | Aaron Baughman, Stephen Hammer, Rahul Agarwal, Gozde Akay, Eduardo Morales, Tony Johnson, Leonid Karlinsky, Rogerio Feris | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address the problem of scaling up the production of media content,
including commentary and personalized news stories, for large-scale sports and
music events worldwide. Our approach relies on generative AI models to
transform a large volume of multimodal data (e.g., videos, articles, real-time
scoring feeds, statistics, and fact sheets) into coherent and fluent text.
Based on this approach, we introduce, for the first time, an AI commentary
system, which was deployed to produce automated narrations for highlight
packages at the 2023 US Open, Wimbledon, and Masters tournaments. In the same
vein, our solution was extended to create personalized content for ESPN Fantasy
Football and stories about music artists for the Grammy awards. These
applications were built using a common software architecture achieved a 15x
speed improvement with an average Rouge-L of 82.00 and perplexity of 6.6. Our
work was successfully deployed at the aforementioned events, supporting 90
million fans around the world with 8 billion page views, continuously pushing
the bounds on what is possible at the intersection of sports, entertainment,
and AI. | [
-0.5318282246589661,
-0.6347832083702087,
0.3067372143268585,
0.6998713612556458,
-0.3301468789577484,
0.14912046492099762,
-0.5175939202308655,
-0.6410605311393738,
0.5085579752922058,
0.04623621702194214,
-0.804654598236084,
-0.5019841194152832,
-0.4639130234718323,
0.21747362613677979,
-0.4947282075881958,
1.3239351511001587,
0.07575304061174393,
0.04397375136613846,
-0.2231294959783554,
-0.3739410638809204,
-0.3684275150299072,
-0.19729278981685638,
-0.6691119074821472,
-0.02897227369248867,
0.33643266558647156,
0.251414030790329,
0.6492366194725037,
0.5797370076179504,
0.7533510327339172,
0.28821802139282227,
-0.02493547648191452,
0.44117334485054016,
-0.4547552168369293,
0.38305413722991943,
-0.17180806398391724,
-0.11346907913684845,
-0.6144969463348389,
0.012053391896188259,
0.692053496837616,
0.4570704698562622,
0.10960030555725098,
0.326053649187088,
-0.16193604469299316,
0.6128995418548584,
-0.3077341914176941,
0.3646523952484131,
-0.2837575674057007,
0.35433825850486755,
-0.17806920409202576,
-0.6920260190963745,
-0.2881348431110382,
-0.13003212213516235,
-0.042618248611688614,
-1.070941686630249,
0.15058264136314392,
0.0900321677327156,
0.7160895466804504,
0.42848077416419983,
-0.20245496928691864,
-0.22612504661083221,
-1.3344550132751465,
0.6757432818412781,
-0.24796970188617706,
0.22075912356376648,
0.12464188784360886,
0.4328610897064209,
0.04877210408449173,
-0.4096873104572296,
-0.6183903217315674,
-0.28521600365638733,
0.32472896575927734,
0.46111825108528137,
-0.26466259360313416,
0.049163784831762314,
0.23607571423053741,
0.38258683681488037,
-0.6935123205184937,
0.02428382635116577,
-0.31283092498779297,
0.1938646137714386,
1.3380134105682373,
0.2889331877231598,
0.4911169707775116,
0.3052857220172882,
0.07859347015619278,
-0.0039701699279248714,
-0.47032034397125244,
-0.13920815289020538,
0.36215606331825256,
0.00043640407966449857,
-0.1410394310951233,
0.5709278583526611,
-0.599877119064331,
0.41842174530029297,
0.06730218231678009,
-0.3934828042984009,
0.23872795701026917,
-0.5093182325363159,
0.03250199556350708,
0.20366263389587402,
0.9397410750389099,
0.607952892780304,
0.2080315202474594,
-0.48305949568748474,
0.05843740701675415,
-0.1311848759651184,
0.28342005610466003,
-0.6410477757453918,
-0.24785968661308289,
0.376105397939682,
-0.5415859818458557,
-0.1412304937839508,
0.20730657875537872,
-0.8700546026229858,
-0.5287542343139648,
-0.6698944568634033,
0.34139999747276306,
-0.1945832520723343,
-0.008580955676734447,
0.06545282155275345,
-0.3794478178024292,
0.1823536604642868,
0.6124079823493958,
-0.693371593952179,
-0.24504122138023376,
0.5404272675514221,
0.6973914504051208,
-0.0990099310874939,
-0.2832212448120117,
-0.8391892313957214,
0.5327203869819641,
-0.2653743624687195,
0.837672770023346,
-0.3745855689048767,
-0.3420160412788391,
0.20988813042640686,
-0.3612360954284668,
0.4197551906108856,
-0.5327816009521484,
0.5997489094734192,
-0.5842916965484619,
-0.22254644334316254,
-0.017121508717536926,
-0.45512455701828003,
0.12985077500343323,
0.264553427696228,
-0.736728847026825,
0.4970628619194031,
-0.0723656713962555,
-0.7113655209541321,
0.5429391860961914,
-0.9753536581993103,
-0.8682951331138611,
0.20064136385917664,
-0.15458393096923828,
-0.547272264957428,
0.1419323831796646,
0.4741058945655823,
0.19087928533554077,
-0.22277173399925232,
0.21230140328407288,
-0.23084908723831177,
-0.5800283551216125,
0.09968251734972,
-0.5124346613883972,
0.3941502869129181,
0.2017301768064499,
-0.5861567854881287,
0.40407758951187134,
-1.0130400657653809,
-0.2937675416469574,
-0.06836630403995514,
-0.5820394158363342,
0.22202931344509125,
0.17633962631225586,
0.3801270127296448,
0.12955109775066376,
-0.0014781348872929811,
-0.4252655506134033,
0.48081326484680176,
-0.15739458799362183,
0.5378744006156921,
0.6874375343322754,
-0.16115440428256989,
0.5829573273658752,
-0.11052810400724411,
0.7634676694869995,
-0.0063826581463217735,
0.34735918045043945,
-0.4202090799808502,
-0.411525160074234,
-0.4038030505180359,
-0.1764359325170517,
0.13230210542678833,
0.4398936331272125,
-0.6634050011634827,
0.4532163143157959,
-0.7203739881515503,
-0.27964675426483154,
-0.47132521867752075,
0.3961683213710785,
0.031227143481373787,
0.19958530366420746,
0.24444374442100525,
-0.053921300917863846,
-0.5795193314552307,
-0.7939268350601196,
-0.0693117305636406,
-0.023543208837509155,
-0.10965828597545624,
0.4158324599266052,
0.273032009601593,
0.03689257428050041,
0.6833100318908691,
-0.4544925391674042,
-0.6264742612838745,
-0.14449167251586914,
0.4721222221851349,
-0.019376296550035477,
0.5486814975738525,
0.5691361427307129,
-1.0687350034713745,
-0.8060424327850342,
0.143790140748024,
-0.9937538504600525,
-0.003483909647911787,
-0.4379878044128418,
-0.2082858830690384,
-0.060164984315633774,
0.6449294090270996,
-0.6312289834022522,
0.3203358054161072,
0.6514492034912109,
-0.45452842116355896,
0.5957627296447754,
-0.12483061850070953,
0.49112468957901,
-0.8351687788963318,
-0.024318773299455643,
0.17724701762199402,
-0.07266449928283691,
-0.41499918699264526,
-0.0994068831205368,
-0.5827990174293518,
-0.06889443844556808,
-0.13749517500400543,
0.33473441004753113,
-0.31959885358810425,
-0.22116875648498535,
-0.390048086643219,
0.055571746081113815,
0.09354445338249207,
0.3194540739059448,
0.11365996301174164,
1.036880373954773,
0.3874756097793579,
-0.501732587814331,
0.686590850353241,
0.3512340486049652,
-0.5824851393699646,
0.8678314685821533,
-0.4988183379173279,
-0.11878848820924759,
-0.3625739812850952,
0.7040979862213135,
-0.7816683650016785,
-0.40836256742477417,
0.11211767047643661,
-0.6086846590042114,
0.2619301974773407,
0.18064752221107483,
-0.633269727230072,
-0.4900702238082886,
-0.13674288988113403,
0.5341140627861023,
0.4713904559612274,
-0.4744059145450592,
0.6519019603729248,
0.5080941915512085,
-0.37702295184135437,
-0.0683068037033081,
-0.4198225736618042,
0.5104323029518127,
-0.19885094463825226,
-0.6427202820777893,
0.4069788455963135,
-0.3585549294948578,
-0.2839178740978241,
-0.02462729997932911,
0.1321692317724228,
-0.05333700776100159,
0.15040145814418793,
0.3125097155570984,
0.04097980633378029,
-0.537761390209198,
0.23084233701229095,
0.02965296246111393,
0.16192558407783508,
-0.10101476311683655,
-0.7613648772239685,
0.4119511842727661,
0.056747179478406906,
-0.0921638011932373,
-1.1445027589797974,
0.7140117287635803,
0.7046080231666565,
-0.2938965857028961,
0.7497478127479553,
0.8351749181747437,
0.160597562789917,
-0.16755996644496918,
-0.28035831451416016,
0.03454292565584183,
-0.41020330786705017,
0.507672131061554,
-0.26038023829460144,
-0.8379104137420654,
0.26759061217308044,
0.10188644379377365,
0.17138749361038208,
0.7850189208984375,
0.5210655927658081,
-0.5173411965370178,
1.731755256652832,
0.46555396914482117,
-0.5354946851730347,
0.5482754111289978,
-0.3242492973804474,
-0.01188651192933321,
-0.683379054069519,
-0.35867294669151306,
-0.663409948348999,
-0.7630686163902283,
-0.4580444097518921,
-0.23102392256259918,
0.5059300065040588,
-0.0581994503736496,
-0.4465850293636322,
0.04249493405222893,
-0.5350580811500549,
0.5886640548706055,
0.9086865186691284,
0.016221174970269203,
0.4671075940132141,
-0.21629004180431366,
0.6299758553504944,
-0.022957641631364822,
-0.6335507035255432,
0.029430357739329338,
1.0220884084701538,
0.20726755261421204,
0.7084787487983704,
0.3242052495479584,
0.42471587657928467,
0.7616345882415771,
0.7782262563705444,
-0.7718963027000427,
0.17828162014484406,
-0.23862674832344055,
-0.6711276173591614,
-0.6754604578018188,
-0.26675519347190857,
-0.5315118432044983,
-0.2521688640117645,
-0.3669326603412628,
-0.4395361840724945,
-0.20531800389289856,
0.18595542013645172,
-0.4735562205314636,
0.3484760522842407,
-0.2949392795562744,
0.38003209233283997,
-0.2221960872411728,
-0.3123430609703064,
-0.0030284638050943613,
-0.43376287817955017,
0.36984214186668396,
-0.011602717451751232,
0.38814809918403625,
-0.009144379757344723,
0.11132355034351349,
0.7318780422210693,
-0.3812650740146637,
0.6184592843055725,
-0.03982199355959892,
-0.1902814507484436,
0.38141903281211853,
-0.12846939265727997,
0.45041632652282715,
0.29721951484680176,
0.1749238222837448,
-0.015486626885831356,
-0.49465781450271606,
-0.41832104325294495,
-0.5859768390655518,
0.5033360719680786,
-0.989788293838501,
-0.7185724973678589,
0.000257494073593989,
-0.6727856993675232,
-0.3553828001022339,
0.027034487575292587,
0.23320272564888,
0.41640913486480713,
-0.18676431477069855,
0.5481114387512207,
0.6453367471694946,
-0.09389186650514603,
0.4966751039028168,
0.1424885392189026,
0.1074964627623558,
-0.7074819803237915,
0.8452893495559692,
-0.1767800748348236,
-0.22411541640758514,
0.5537143349647522,
-0.009558881632983685,
-0.3008289337158203,
-0.9970612525939941,
-0.8441641330718994,
0.07779780775308609,
-0.40688958764076233,
-0.3456208109855652,
-0.5361904501914978,
-0.011613204143941402,
-0.5441405773162842,
-0.23607835173606873,
-0.2389366179704666,
-0.30368995666503906,
-0.3690953552722931,
-0.2291598618030548,
0.266276091337204,
0.8541354537010193,
0.031470928341150284,
0.6184051632881165,
-1.0829213857650757,
0.17303748428821564,
0.15198534727096558,
0.4493531584739685,
-0.11635028570890427,
-0.6118350625038147,
-0.5847570896148682,
-0.22651536762714386,
-0.42662397027015686,
-0.5434430241584778,
0.4103259742259979,
0.48425042629241943,
0.4231470823287964,
0.8385104537010193,
-0.21980905532836914,
0.6580895781517029,
-0.7137011885643005,
1.0078543424606323,
0.31409236788749695,
-0.8434015512466431,
0.7312775254249573,
-0.8309743404388428,
0.3067076802253723,
0.6733216643333435,
0.3346503973007202,
-0.3678915500640869,
-0.39616724848747253,
-0.6298713684082031,
-0.6240540146827698,
0.7834921479225159,
0.19073140621185303,
0.39209988713264465,
0.007032173220068216,
0.3505438566207886,
0.08596988767385483,
0.45993903279304504,
-0.4901828169822693,
-0.3002234399318695,
-0.3335074186325073,
-0.3119141757488251,
-0.703302264213562,
-0.05275055393576622,
-0.31887462735176086,
-0.26177775859832764,
0.5798834562301636,
-0.32031726837158203,
-0.015322007238864899,
0.10784156620502472,
0.17435012757778168,
-0.11140652000904083,
0.014943400397896767,
0.9571346640586853,
0.6148959398269653,
-0.10870996862649918,
-0.2931917905807495,
-0.22415995597839355,
-0.38447102904319763,
0.06442225724458694,
0.22801566123962402,
-0.5048226714134216,
0.0622200146317482,
0.6455926299095154,
0.8516069054603577,
0.1627681851387024,
-0.9776386022567749,
0.3583545982837677,
0.08063609153032303,
-0.5406206846237183,
-0.3344757854938507,
-0.1672278493642807,
0.12003253400325775,
0.24657562375068665,
0.44422200322151184,
0.10500778257846832,
0.367917537689209,
-0.7792021036148071,
0.32444074749946594,
0.3971826732158661,
-0.6190281510353088,
-0.4628683924674988,
1.392285704612732,
0.5725688934326172,
-0.22170378267765045,
0.5627707839012146,
-0.08491393178701401,
-0.5575798749923706,
0.7119789719581604,
0.40328124165534973,
0.8213244676589966,
0.08917033672332764,
0.5212098360061646,
0.32902076840400696,
-0.19356927275657654,
-0.01927049644291401,
-0.019477182999253273,
-0.24434715509414673,
-0.4704554080963135,
-0.6005525588989258,
-0.8357120752334595,
-0.16270890831947327,
0.05965084582567215,
-0.4714205861091614,
-0.16388443112373352,
-0.39967191219329834,
-0.11663129180669785,
0.464273065328598,
0.01948416978120804,
-0.5485605597496033,
0.36658546328544617,
0.4550071656703949,
0.9121026992797852,
-0.984769344329834,
0.44347408413887024,
0.9744589328765869,
-1.011056900024414,
-0.8203465938568115,
0.11614292114973068,
0.050504185259342194,
-0.34745821356773376,
1.0549713373184204,
-0.22242052853107452,
0.2967788577079773,
-0.008095228113234043,
-0.6632004976272583,
-0.5461318492889404,
1.0189627408981323,
-0.09652774780988693,
-0.4889848232269287,
-0.056250493973493576,
0.2543371319770813,
0.6278615593910217,
-0.5124713778495789,
0.12818537652492523,
0.4190676510334015,
0.5709537267684937,
0.6127749681472778,
-0.9137597680091858,
-0.6777632832527161,
-0.15999847650527954,
-0.10434237867593765,
0.1329403966665268,
-1.1133166551589966,
0.7138835787773132,
0.018593288958072662,
0.2298547625541687,
0.16834069788455963,
1.069204330444336,
0.10900720953941345,
0.3386772871017456,
0.2619702219963074,
0.43290919065475464,
0.6596215963363647,
-0.1653508096933365,
1.242023229598999,
-0.1404992938041687,
0.15176284313201904,
1.0369133949279785,
-0.22436702251434326,
0.5924037098884583,
0.16116175055503845,
-0.37885841727256775,
0.1864914745092392,
0.3543483316898346,
-0.3076397478580475,
0.4188920855522156,
0.3529719114303589,
-0.5655930042266846,
-0.3007137179374695,
-0.36297690868377686,
-0.22366930544376373,
0.8384892344474792,
0.021170787513256073,
-0.5093555450439453,
-0.04793423041701317,
0.3774353563785553,
-0.07571840286254883,
0.2986936867237091,
-0.5905555486679077,
1.0518962144851685,
-0.3117023706436157,
-0.9058070182800293,
-0.13246679306030273,
0.02058475650846958,
0.677378237247467,
-0.3331555128097534,
-0.09960757941007614,
-0.40718916058540344,
0.2991388142108917,
-0.053475040942430496,
-0.7090740203857422,
0.17859958112239838,
0.03678825497627258,
-0.4841066002845764,
-0.2233843207359314,
0.2150992751121521,
-0.3709987998008728,
-0.5891184210777283,
0.027103722095489502,
0.15726065635681152,
0.07175084948539734,
-0.33778780698776245,
-0.38284775614738464,
0.43880271911621094,
-0.030322223901748657,
-0.1459503173828125,
0.3083811104297638,
0.43291059136390686,
-0.08642296493053436,
0.5961751341819763,
0.6085205674171448,
0.3801341950893402,
0.2057063728570938,
0.39950406551361084,
0.7576131224632263,
-0.5104809403419495,
-0.7408832907676697,
-0.6180076003074646,
0.3955542743206024,
-0.3023681938648224,
-0.3457680344581604,
0.7480873465538025,
0.9792178869247437,
0.7368849515914917,
-0.32325735688209534,
0.996611475944519,
0.0794481411576271,
0.16792218387126923,
-0.38859960436820984,
0.8555099964141846,
-0.6275033354759216,
-0.04645970091223717,
-0.12270628660917282,
-0.9105533361434937,
-0.5875695943832397,
0.09601796418428421,
0.0865032896399498,
0.013893443159759045,
0.15295906364917755,
0.16206203401088715,
0.16031098365783691,
0.23981231451034546,
0.2601482570171356,
0.14726413786411285,
0.5910990238189697,
0.3635990023612976,
0.7125266194343567,
-0.3944292366504669,
0.8765276670455933,
-0.09928715974092484,
-0.38938555121421814,
-0.5306664109230042,
-0.6302002668380737,
-0.8140087723731995,
-0.5993709564208984,
-0.5491902828216553,
-0.4838320314884186,
0.15084658563137054,
0.7495864033699036,
0.8239439725875854,
-0.9217355251312256,
0.04295716807246208,
-0.00965089164674282,
-0.20741970837116241,
-0.22643668949604034,
-0.26835501194000244,
0.5653067231178284,
-0.29682043194770813,
-1.2003257274627686,
0.2928793430328369,
0.525884747505188,
-0.26689213514328003,
-0.3572218716144562,
0.024386044591665268,
0.05384301766753197,
0.012749300338327885,
0.8302161693572998,
0.6426671147346497,
-0.5026562213897705,
-0.5253615379333496,
-0.11721581965684891,
0.04984235018491745,
0.28055378794670105,
0.841314971446991,
-0.5178225636482239,
0.30455923080444336,
0.49499744176864624,
0.8152949810028076,
0.43497201800346375,
0.4272269308567047,
0.6683238744735718,
-0.5096230506896973,
0.10185210406780243,
0.43930289149284363,
-0.09207365661859512,
0.026382816955447197,
-0.4419426918029785,
0.33562302589416504,
0.4061471223831177,
-0.5901207327842712,
-0.5404418706893921,
-0.07224531471729279,
-1.1585489511489868,
-0.08907478302717209,
1.1651190519332886,
0.08441480994224548,
-0.062282104045152664,
-0.07049989700317383,
-0.21679812669754028,
0.044161535799503326,
-0.23801380395889282,
1.0247610807418823,
0.7984136343002319,
-0.4759015440940857,
-0.04444931074976921,
-0.6056708693504333,
0.8161052465438843,
0.0367482490837574,
-0.792231559753418,
-0.17648226022720337,
0.7981205582618713,
0.07672160863876343,
0.33012229204177856,
0.6351509094238281,
-0.047349970787763596,
0.5240801572799683,
0.326562762260437,
-0.08024854212999344,
-0.15771056711673737,
-0.6159842014312744,
-0.1079748198390007,
0.3843749165534973,
-0.17733179032802582,
-0.23645074665546417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00179v1 | De-identification is not always enough | 2024-01-31T21:14:01 | 2024-01-31T21:14:01 | Atiquer Rahman Sarkar, Yao-Shun Chuang, Noman Mohammed, Xiaoqian Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | For sharing privacy-sensitive data, de-identification is commonly regarded as
adequate for safeguarding privacy. Synthetic data is also being considered as a
privacy-preserving alternative. Recent successes with numerical and tabular
data generative models and the breakthroughs in large generative language
models raise the question of whether synthetically generated clinical notes
could be a viable alternative to real notes for research purposes. In this
work, we demonstrated that (i) de-identification of real clinical notes does
not protect records against a membership inference attack, (ii) proposed a
novel approach to generate synthetic clinical notes using the current
state-of-the-art large language models, (iii) evaluated the performance of the
synthetically generated notes in a clinical domain task, and (iv) proposed a
way to mount a membership inference attack where the target model is trained
with synthetic data. We observed that when synthetically generated notes
closely match the performance of real data, they also exhibit similar privacy
concerns to the real data. Whether other approaches to synthetically generated
clinical notes could offer better trade-offs and become a better alternative to
sensitive real notes warrants further investigation. | [
-0.0333997942507267,
-0.9878219962120056,
0.7029373049736023,
-0.0329725444316864,
-0.14853112399578094,
0.16857029497623444,
0.03051777184009552,
-0.7788102030754089,
0.43250176310539246,
0.4688572883605957,
-0.4955233633518219,
-0.709814727306366,
-0.320789635181427,
0.11748445779085159,
-0.6426120400428772,
1.0101516246795654,
0.2980349063873291,
0.14188739657402039,
-0.22787506878376007,
-0.10376390814781189,
0.0261557474732399,
-0.917230486869812,
-0.5682867169380188,
0.145416721701622,
0.8742524981498718,
-0.20092147588729858,
0.49715036153793335,
0.8515641093254089,
0.7084462642669678,
0.3109945058822632,
-0.07421974092721939,
0.2319115251302719,
-0.3796617090702057,
0.15073776245117188,
-0.13826167583465576,
-0.603259265422821,
-0.9475480914115906,
0.3332987129688263,
0.5672646164894104,
0.5088353157043457,
-0.033153388649225235,
0.05323440209031105,
-0.458047479391098,
0.6242197751998901,
-0.47298935055732727,
-0.038284219801425934,
-0.6415929198265076,
0.17329643666744232,
-0.3051166534423828,
-0.11234340816736221,
-0.5137584209442139,
-0.47536930441856384,
0.22122058272361755,
-0.6649186015129089,
0.8411794304847717,
-0.1297147572040558,
0.8451109528541565,
-0.3860204219818115,
-0.1478014588356018,
-0.39875528216362,
-1.038763403892517,
0.3498363196849823,
-0.7906865477561951,
0.22758658230304718,
0.6634656190872192,
0.5789945125579834,
-0.22352281212806702,
-0.8305238485336304,
-0.6108359098434448,
-0.5110868215560913,
-0.14979591965675354,
0.24807308614253998,
0.29456228017807007,
0.2160930037498474,
0.4772503972053528,
0.5479737520217896,
-0.49817317724227905,
0.11994302272796631,
-0.6384598612785339,
-0.20485080778598785,
0.9858205318450928,
0.31239965558052063,
0.308136522769928,
-0.13023130595684052,
-0.43911656737327576,
-0.16401955485343933,
-0.8689892292022705,
-0.3918393850326538,
0.3211502134799957,
0.46631619334220886,
-0.24094617366790771,
0.5873393416404724,
0.018776720389723778,
0.3975695073604584,
-0.1232479065656662,
-0.4205566644668579,
0.06673302501440048,
-0.08382865786552429,
-0.27962708473205566,
0.39531922340393066,
0.9547926783561707,
0.3946918845176697,
0.05675981938838959,
-0.4111766517162323,
0.1635356992483139,
0.3568366467952728,
0.47416871786117554,
-0.7593674063682556,
-0.6176332235336304,
0.4322504997253418,
-0.5018048286437988,
-0.5617400407791138,
0.28775468468666077,
-0.8101204037666321,
-0.4657241702079773,
-0.35389813780784607,
0.28211286664009094,
-0.37024492025375366,
-0.1799122542142868,
-0.14580172300338745,
-0.29378217458724976,
-0.2182837277650833,
0.43569713830947876,
-0.8658722639083862,
0.3599962890148163,
0.8032892346382141,
0.6909334063529968,
-0.14930446445941925,
-0.02348320372402668,
-0.1625145673751831,
0.5408916473388672,
-0.508378267288208,
0.41091206669807434,
-0.4442020654678345,
-0.8686907887458801,
-0.10607647150754929,
0.12315905839204788,
-0.2743772268295288,
-0.6682776212692261,
0.3364672064781189,
-0.44641751050949097,
0.2668164074420929,
-0.40987637639045715,
-0.5145184993743896,
0.06838994473218918,
0.2253832221031189,
-0.7398825883865356,
0.37934809923171997,
0.39920705556869507,
-0.6746877431869507,
0.4325525462627411,
-0.22573526203632355,
-0.4428253769874573,
0.054431308060884476,
-0.363520085811615,
-0.6833003163337708,
0.09689459204673767,
-0.24060355126857758,
0.178219735622406,
-0.08487329632043839,
0.1072976216673851,
-0.4935641586780548,
-0.2037448287010193,
0.7799974083900452,
-0.3796021044254303,
0.6411520838737488,
0.34272652864456177,
-0.018875503912568092,
-0.39630189538002014,
-0.9848082065582275,
-0.07311058044433594,
0.09871528297662735,
-0.1909506469964981,
-0.43625351786613464,
-0.2447241246700287,
-0.03520883247256279,
0.01187130343168974,
-0.05594531074166298,
-0.7543267011642456,
0.1964460164308548,
-0.557296097278595,
0.4153788685798645,
0.5961743593215942,
0.36636653542518616,
0.26853010058403015,
-0.6998374462127686,
0.701579213142395,
0.1420605182647705,
0.15183812379837036,
0.0816851481795311,
-0.35321563482284546,
-0.2573640048503876,
-0.8819265961647034,
0.8713882565498352,
0.4605279564857483,
0.07065179944038391,
0.17742018401622772,
-0.2152368277311325,
-0.6425758004188538,
-0.4385848641395569,
-0.24820667505264282,
0.7586880922317505,
0.47287148237228394,
0.42754608392715454,
-0.28644677996635437,
-0.6203410029411316,
-0.9859846234321594,
-0.47803521156311035,
-0.13353735208511353,
-0.1427878737449646,
0.5069568753242493,
0.3415862023830414,
-0.17894123494625092,
0.6964120864868164,
-0.5249596834182739,
-0.3421609103679657,
-0.14317728579044342,
-0.11391887813806534,
-0.2655593156814575,
0.8419400453567505,
0.5893626809120178,
-0.6232895851135254,
-0.4848921298980713,
-0.13454942405223846,
-0.7366501092910767,
0.17453278601169586,
-0.4550327956676483,
-0.1411246657371521,
-0.06845609098672867,
0.244541198015213,
-1.0857104063034058,
0.7465284466743469,
0.10417427122592926,
0.18262311816215515,
0.18582302331924438,
-0.5947471857070923,
0.12427400797605515,
-1.0679476261138916,
0.16706980764865875,
-0.19446392357349396,
-0.3104267120361328,
-0.8042690753936768,
0.12393961101770401,
0.021832268685102463,
-0.4117004871368408,
-0.25530287623405457,
0.43554285168647766,
-0.31055712699890137,
0.35584840178489685,
-0.039085257798433304,
-0.011388782411813736,
0.1838456243276596,
0.1555120199918747,
0.09031891077756882,
0.3269229829311371,
0.3525846302509308,
-0.5597038269042969,
-0.1360912173986435,
0.6327025890350342,
0.03746766224503517,
0.5367684364318848,
-0.5414614081382751,
0.465833455324173,
-0.17864716053009033,
0.33058515191078186,
-0.7636439800262451,
-0.5753490924835205,
0.3974340260028839,
-0.7190165519714355,
0.596981942653656,
-0.2657138705253601,
-0.19720381498336792,
-0.22722937166690826,
-0.3825148642063141,
0.23354551196098328,
0.6725290417671204,
-0.245200976729393,
0.3991474509239197,
0.529800534248352,
-0.08819545805454254,
-0.3587205708026886,
-0.9091049432754517,
0.13615958392620087,
-0.5101991891860962,
-0.13309219479560852,
0.7200478911399841,
0.24400363862514496,
-0.39711689949035645,
-0.05636698380112648,
-0.2895558178424835,
-0.2561865448951721,
0.08356515318155289,
0.5714158415794373,
0.3452480733394623,
0.014111463911831379,
0.08074329048395157,
0.16406306624412537,
-0.17348922789096832,
0.23778051137924194,
0.16017518937587738,
-0.02428765967488289,
0.6218918561935425,
-0.2799002230167389,
-0.8721718788146973,
0.7480021119117737,
0.6441670060157776,
-0.08160571753978729,
0.8257418870925903,
-0.007704222109168768,
-0.5136468410491943,
-0.5704069137573242,
-0.4057345688343048,
-0.24172160029411316,
-0.4598393440246582,
-0.033621206879615784,
-0.16529935598373413,
-0.4626026153564453,
0.5798333287239075,
-0.04473506659269333,
0.11662961542606354,
0.18567906320095062,
0.3730244040489197,
-0.4244690537452698,
0.9702771902084351,
0.07007389515638351,
0.1995728760957718,
0.07609415799379349,
-0.3167186379432678,
0.6136850714683533,
-0.6997191905975342,
-0.38669341802597046,
-0.695489227771759,
-0.21374690532684326,
-0.7279981374740601,
-0.1908641904592514,
0.4801975190639496,
-0.17745070159435272,
0.040640104562044144,
0.44177624583244324,
-0.5515328645706177,
0.23658497631549835,
0.3659941852092743,
0.44513097405433655,
0.18802998960018158,
0.017087077721953392,
0.34818387031555176,
-0.14123447239398956,
-0.40146011114120483,
-0.652640700340271,
1.332328200340271,
0.13088952004909515,
0.827711820602417,
0.04558596760034561,
0.9356744289398193,
0.4508584141731262,
0.5156327486038208,
-0.16857799887657166,
0.6293348670005798,
-0.014999170787632465,
-0.8081300854682922,
-0.09032852947711945,
-0.5011383295059204,
-0.9637571573257446,
0.27705562114715576,
-0.27417775988578796,
-0.7644301652908325,
0.3316064476966858,
0.5181267857551575,
-0.5370268225669861,
0.04124263674020767,
-0.7467525005340576,
0.7825999855995178,
-0.007443623151630163,
-0.45461463928222656,
-0.09029553830623627,
-0.6027460694313049,
0.412478506565094,
-0.2590354382991791,
0.16429494321346283,
0.037106502801179886,
0.252766489982605,
0.705076277256012,
-0.8365630507469177,
1.003065586090088,
-0.31844562292099,
-0.07883501797914505,
0.4325215518474579,
0.42061907052993774,
0.5215710997581482,
0.34256166219711304,
0.021543731912970543,
-0.10511837899684906,
0.3516688942909241,
-0.10503091663122177,
-0.768566370010376,
0.8855339884757996,
-0.4347914755344391,
-0.8097770810127258,
-0.46454039216041565,
-0.366085946559906,
-0.29412367939949036,
0.005829982925206423,
0.206496000289917,
0.7869051098823547,
-0.3463061451911926,
0.03061620332300663,
0.2948938012123108,
-0.19495609402656555,
0.1890868991613388,
0.5494768619537354,
0.35186704993247986,
-0.6962593793869019,
1.0278979539871216,
0.3331088125705719,
0.3182202875614166,
0.24848850071430206,
0.2787194848060608,
-0.46002665162086487,
-0.5467832684516907,
-0.2403218150138855,
0.5196409225463867,
-0.3850778341293335,
0.12133434414863586,
-0.8879187107086182,
-0.18054696917533875,
-0.5312252640724182,
-0.17524689435958862,
-0.2769436836242676,
-0.8520922660827637,
-0.2032669633626938,
-0.4345114529132843,
0.4046597480773926,
0.27817147970199585,
-0.17556311190128326,
0.07721143215894699,
-1.0449198484420776,
0.6776340007781982,
0.1467866152524948,
-0.01561747957020998,
0.0023900552187114954,
-0.26102927327156067,
0.07132894545793533,
0.27906733751296997,
-0.18121396005153656,
-0.8566477298736572,
0.5313513875007629,
0.1505078822374344,
0.42436525225639343,
0.2853280007839203,
0.4043303430080414,
0.7450923323631287,
-0.41087964177131653,
0.5824676156044006,
-0.06297745555639267,
-0.5636299848556519,
0.4730525016784668,
-0.5590565204620361,
-0.3383728563785553,
0.863409161567688,
0.3752680718898773,
-0.06838825345039368,
-0.5945953130722046,
-1.1604915857315063,
-0.6484730839729309,
0.5440400242805481,
0.29773813486099243,
0.2997496426105499,
-0.24068960547447205,
0.46802476048469543,
0.1211254745721817,
0.4263785183429718,
-0.6463858485221863,
-0.055191900581121445,
0.03350362181663513,
-0.24049267172813416,
0.30119502544403076,
-0.14516647160053253,
-0.47348731756210327,
-0.19356857240200043,
0.25320443511009216,
0.24600179493427277,
0.24640299379825592,
0.6744568347930908,
0.1727284938097,
0.12071583420038223,
-0.0749237984418869,
0.5656880140304565,
0.5974220633506775,
-0.3012501299381256,
0.27360406517982483,
-0.07823337614536285,
-0.7238825559616089,
0.08467091619968414,
-0.01944316364824772,
-0.5847811698913574,
0.024854162707924843,
0.36100438237190247,
0.4471840560436249,
-0.19432367384433746,
-0.7140834331512451,
0.45461222529411316,
0.048086754977703094,
-0.484236478805542,
-0.6318798661231995,
0.35590365529060364,
0.1296999454498291,
-0.30962660908699036,
-0.29967647790908813,
-0.061581723392009735,
0.044858988374471664,
-0.7898695468902588,
0.2221095860004425,
0.5792623162269592,
-0.42869263887405396,
-0.6610702872276306,
1.0047030448913574,
-0.025850772857666016,
-0.6216751337051392,
0.6599463224411011,
0.1943838894367218,
-0.20146812498569489,
0.7841140627861023,
0.7466859221458435,
0.8954867720603943,
-0.43611669540405273,
0.2657807469367981,
0.44336196780204773,
0.000004259206434653606,
0.17032112181186676,
0.27880945801734924,
-0.32706379890441895,
-0.23526450991630554,
0.16036683320999146,
-0.2960103750228882,
-0.392233282327652,
0.2976381480693817,
-0.641206681728363,
-0.02193060889840126,
-0.8502535223960876,
-0.42249056696891785,
0.21233943104743958,
-0.40860673785209656,
-0.12260423600673676,
0.5205209255218506,
-0.15987567603588104,
0.5395203828811646,
-0.7040773630142212,
0.8265040516853333,
0.15755365788936615,
-0.3352039158344269,
-0.6376894116401672,
-0.1182292029261589,
0.0919298306107521,
-0.09127938747406006,
0.30045345425605774,
0.17708541452884674,
0.28350332379341125,
-0.41241455078125,
0.011657393537461758,
-0.41317909955978394,
0.7974674701690674,
0.1529112160205841,
-0.5949228405952454,
-0.186497300863266,
0.6229379773139954,
0.9876668453216553,
-0.1447141170501709,
-0.07735910266637802,
0.3232155442237854,
0.2141186147928238,
0.04772747680544853,
-0.5312365293502808,
0.24829617142677307,
-0.1561928242444992,
-0.21600596606731415,
0.15574398636817932,
-0.6164824962615967,
0.9831261038780212,
-0.17007260024547577,
-0.47452038526535034,
0.11698948591947556,
0.3630833923816681,
0.3683319091796875,
0.5804593563079834,
0.26534533500671387,
0.603912353515625,
0.9044044017791748,
0.1108226627111435,
1.1871399879455566,
-0.15559640526771545,
0.07179886102676392,
1.0910289287567139,
-0.8950203061103821,
0.35740265250205994,
0.1621433049440384,
-0.22605806589126587,
0.3114418089389801,
0.18952186405658722,
-0.16090938448905945,
0.579627513885498,
0.46349164843559265,
-0.6187902092933655,
-0.09700614959001541,
0.14619450271129608,
-0.5050423741340637,
0.17857006192207336,
0.4266853928565979,
-0.8253802061080933,
0.14066480100154877,
-0.3199383318424225,
0.17889849841594696,
0.17749841511249542,
0.336580365896225,
0.9732492566108704,
0.3798901438713074,
-0.5706097483634949,
0.6503612995147705,
-0.01539231650531292,
-0.2505602240562439,
-0.7075080871582031,
-0.2618916630744934,
-0.07773035019636154,
0.34727317094802856,
-0.22722668945789337,
0.09618076682090759,
0.4459603428840637,
0.14723770320415497,
-0.017615143209695816,
-0.07098381221294403,
0.3730414807796478,
-0.41504645347595215,
-0.5171226263046265,
-0.23252178728580475,
0.21645358204841614,
-0.07133551687002182,
0.15861919522285461,
-0.3502235412597656,
-0.3037223517894745,
-0.2108326256275177,
-0.22617416083812714,
0.7120611667633057,
0.3260638415813446,
-0.347608357667923,
0.5031388998031616,
0.9009450078010559,
0.4797733724117279,
-0.22889530658721924,
0.12161093205213547,
0.6425216794013977,
-0.62481290102005,
-0.6648500561714172,
-0.9020429849624634,
0.18892446160316467,
-0.4009994566440582,
-0.42498037219047546,
0.9821000099182129,
0.8516736030578613,
0.5080353021621704,
-0.3376186490058899,
0.8662607669830322,
0.08086206018924713,
1.048230528831482,
-0.5196376442909241,
0.7760319113731384,
-0.23878075182437897,
0.14238248765468597,
-0.474170446395874,
-0.6039938926696777,
-0.43736761808395386,
0.3788498640060425,
0.050046272575855255,
-0.2576289474964142,
0.7837461829185486,
1.1556727886199951,
-0.09210042655467987,
0.20455405116081238,
-0.012183653190732002,
0.09026382863521576,
0.6333178281784058,
0.43149176239967346,
0.8023521304130554,
-0.4832437038421631,
-0.0027423014398664236,
-0.4782559275627136,
-0.0033617084845900536,
0.1807977855205536,
-0.6674184799194336,
-1.1000937223434448,
-0.34243589639663696,
-0.4526119828224182,
-0.5101224780082703,
-0.008784959092736244,
0.6597399115562439,
0.6310074925422668,
-0.8476470708847046,
0.16798779368400574,
-0.24496938288211823,
-0.3601957857608795,
-0.3141881227493286,
-0.1061648279428482,
0.8133238554000854,
0.3163168132305145,
-0.643193244934082,
0.6384941935539246,
0.18043763935565948,
0.5717599987983704,
-0.047827258706092834,
0.3175215721130371,
0.2247086763381958,
0.3330298364162445,
0.1616276055574417,
0.47990620136260986,
-0.5690345168113708,
-0.168391153216362,
-0.2218756377696991,
-0.18436643481254578,
0.08276914060115814,
1.1043813228607178,
-0.6774628162384033,
0.4516637623310089,
0.5435658097267151,
0.49028971791267395,
0.616291344165802,
0.6092263460159302,
0.5840943455696106,
-0.4024025499820709,
0.3242296576499939,
0.4918990135192871,
0.05723700299859047,
0.16022366285324097,
-0.6578637361526489,
0.46651121973991394,
0.3317444622516632,
-0.2760172486305237,
-1.2794235944747925,
-0.0007630950422026217,
-1.2009174823760986,
-0.05502709001302719,
0.7182657718658447,
-0.39128705859184265,
-0.4665990173816681,
-0.21251647174358368,
-0.3188338279724121,
-0.03024914301931858,
-0.09182227402925491,
1.1680322885513306,
0.02031462825834751,
0.047778621315956116,
0.260191947221756,
-0.4375644624233246,
0.8444642424583435,
0.0701538473367691,
-0.855735719203949,
0.5551790595054626,
0.6247000694274902,
0.005929820705205202,
0.22127024829387665,
0.8334540724754333,
-0.659046471118927,
0.2739366888999939,
0.15241371095180511,
-0.5026684403419495,
-0.18648414313793182,
-0.514820396900177,
-0.030669214203953743,
0.336129754781723,
-0.21350009739398956,
-0.23292052745819092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00160v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00160v2 | Emergency Department Decision Support using Clinical Pseudo-notes | 2024-01-31T20:31:56 | 2024-04-29T21:37:34 | Simon A. Lee, Sujay Jain, Alex Chen, Kyoka Ono, Jennifer Fang, Akos Rudas, Jeffrey N. Chiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the Multiple Embedding Model for EHR (MEME), an
approach that serializes multimodal EHR tabular data into text using
pseudo-notes, mimicking clinical text generation. This conversion not only
preserves better representations of categorical data and learns contexts but
also enables the effective employment of pretrained foundation models for rich
feature representation. To address potential issues with context length, our
framework encodes embeddings for each EHR modality separately. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of MEME by applying it to several decision support tasks
within the Emergency Department across multiple hospital systems. Our findings
indicate that MEME outperforms traditional machine learning, EHR-specific
foundation models, and general LLMs, highlighting its potential as a general
and extendible EHR representation strategy. | [
-0.1278807371854782,
-0.7882872223854065,
1.2271524667739868,
-0.02168368548154831,
-0.2698926329612732,
-0.16398651897907257,
0.08495791256427765,
-0.3404437303543091,
0.7387165427207947,
0.32434380054473877,
-0.18515127897262573,
-0.5137363076210022,
-0.37986108660697937,
0.1933096945285797,
-0.12635111808776855,
1.1746413707733154,
-0.280185729265213,
0.3243589997291565,
-0.23995952308177948,
-0.23585978150367737,
-0.4208165407180786,
-0.88458651304245,
-0.36781981587409973,
-0.3230135142803192,
0.4476495683193207,
0.7217769026756287,
0.39491310715675354,
0.3375220000743866,
0.6903294920921326,
0.2282598614692688,
0.5235781073570251,
-0.016678281128406525,
-0.019542140886187553,
0.018414439633488655,
0.18562299013137817,
-0.3763924539089203,
-0.964773416519165,
-0.4612710177898407,
0.629795491695404,
0.3033606708049774,
-0.690421462059021,
-0.04654666408896446,
-0.10704712569713593,
0.44373127818107605,
-0.49861934781074524,
-0.11139196902513504,
-0.3048063814640045,
0.23605260252952576,
-0.059163738042116165,
-0.45473241806030273,
-0.5166877508163452,
-0.11994408816099167,
0.7523304224014282,
-0.43882128596305847,
0.1296510547399521,
0.3046099841594696,
0.42992904782295227,
-0.017624247819185257,
-0.555172324180603,
-0.3390483558177948,
-0.8569536209106445,
0.6978420615196228,
-0.3946911692619324,
0.609259843826294,
0.31687256693840027,
0.4854106605052948,
0.21230216324329376,
-0.916966438293457,
-0.5571753978729248,
0.12711696326732635,
-0.14799347519874573,
0.12948137521743774,
0.011452722363173962,
0.4296613931655884,
0.012320100329816341,
0.12099873274564743,
-0.48663565516471863,
-0.17542056739330292,
-0.26486897468566895,
-0.029292261227965355,
0.27434632182121277,
0.4111119508743286,
0.301791787147522,
-0.44247931241989136,
-0.44504842162132263,
-0.27925175428390503,
-0.5373207926750183,
-0.19375833868980408,
-0.34103190898895264,
-0.128029927611351,
-0.05167867988348007,
0.5176378488540649,
0.29934176802635193,
0.3482276499271393,
0.033269837498664856,
-0.39864856004714966,
0.4798578917980194,
-0.0457012914121151,
-0.5075637102127075,
0.6743939518928528,
0.5706223845481873,
0.601094663143158,
-0.2329101711511612,
-0.13651879131793976,
-0.27748972177505493,
0.07902487367391586,
0.7244834899902344,
-0.5714398622512817,
-0.4923021197319031,
0.25232431292533875,
-0.8577826023101807,
-0.018078306689858437,
-0.022513313218951225,
-1.0948859453201294,
-0.17909950017929077,
-0.32003211975097656,
0.34922125935554504,
-0.4956449270248413,
-0.1423444151878357,
0.07453315705060959,
0.007475390564650297,
-0.012577579356729984,
0.6007252931594849,
-0.5820565819740295,
0.5042761564254761,
0.03788779675960541,
0.8252286314964294,
0.40648481249809265,
0.03771611303091049,
-0.21281379461288452,
0.280642032623291,
-0.27294623851776123,
0.903025209903717,
-0.6977735161781311,
-0.6624447107315063,
-0.050488315522670746,
0.06813618540763855,
-0.22914646565914154,
-0.48287197947502136,
0.8117767572402954,
-0.3632412254810333,
-0.03232687711715698,
-0.2500815987586975,
-0.5548716187477112,
-0.3033575117588043,
0.2857193946838379,
-0.6798403263092041,
0.557246208190918,
0.3229753375053406,
-0.5482997298240662,
0.5615688562393188,
-0.6918806433677673,
-0.4540102779865265,
-0.032624393701553345,
-0.5653203725814819,
-1.0768017768859863,
0.24899253249168396,
0.17133069038391113,
0.7464607357978821,
-0.17204837501049042,
0.2030792236328125,
-0.345705509185791,
-0.012562437914311886,
-0.15387147665023804,
0.01981714926660061,
-0.18190957605838776,
0.3469371199607849,
-0.025025367736816406,
-0.02620025910437107,
-0.710612952709198,
0.03646182268857956,
0.1379549652338028,
-0.5205416083335876,
-0.5726813673973083,
0.26596084237098694,
0.6138692498207092,
0.5203199982643127,
-0.15883561968803406,
-0.3798295855522156,
-0.061335910111665726,
0.21091867983341217,
0.40803825855255127,
0.3524167537689209,
0.17729780077934265,
0.3779270052909851,
-0.7988081574440002,
0.44486045837402344,
0.279933899641037,
-0.04729738086462021,
-0.49114856123924255,
-0.44161269068717957,
-0.4007208049297333,
-0.4130920469760895,
0.07736725360155106,
0.7735781073570251,
-0.5828279256820679,
0.47013673186302185,
-0.2741298973560333,
-0.07854191958904266,
-0.645931601524353,
-0.21013082563877106,
0.2414051592350006,
0.6473677754402161,
0.9368872046470642,
-0.16755957901477814,
-0.8744310736656189,
-1.0795230865478516,
0.16593943536281586,
-0.20303744077682495,
0.05468098819255829,
0.4965032637119293,
0.43269339203834534,
-0.6397347450256348,
0.7437404990196228,
-0.09807092696428299,
-0.6643931269645691,
-0.5307439565658569,
0.1457861065864563,
0.015577868558466434,
0.5992774367332458,
0.6450861692428589,
-0.617742121219635,
-0.26468440890312195,
-0.08937693387269974,
-0.9289574027061462,
0.19510570168495178,
-0.38975828886032104,
0.2905775308609009,
-0.2963710129261017,
0.30512821674346924,
-0.18640972673892975,
0.5628914833068848,
0.21946901082992554,
-0.24017253518104553,
0.2628924548625946,
-0.6893222332000732,
0.5734239816665649,
-1.2097594738006592,
-0.09267034381628036,
0.097307488322258,
-0.6306410431861877,
-0.8368719220161438,
-0.47645723819732666,
0.4932357966899872,
-0.1939590573310852,
-0.15336193144321442,
0.1716805100440979,
-0.5969936847686768,
0.20969052612781525,
0.15219567716121674,
-0.13242778182029724,
0.09051115065813065,
0.12108659744262695,
0.30650433897972107,
0.25500914454460144,
0.43070870637893677,
-0.5856659412384033,
-0.02927229553461075,
0.5502504706382751,
-0.26555848121643066,
0.9148349165916443,
-0.7135931253433228,
0.18790225684642792,
-0.345004141330719,
0.547882616519928,
-0.6697757244110107,
-0.35121452808380127,
-0.1412082016468048,
0.15006977319717407,
0.6985984444618225,
-0.24275372922420502,
-0.541314423084259,
-0.5784711241722107,
-0.46444711089134216,
0.2990933358669281,
0.4695264995098114,
-0.1514350026845932,
0.7961025834083557,
0.6234211921691895,
-0.34133556485176086,
-0.28371185064315796,
-0.9197091460227966,
0.19986854493618011,
-0.3307132422924042,
-0.4226568937301636,
0.6170538663864136,
0.14775198698043823,
-0.1639339178800583,
0.13367269933223724,
0.10165627300739288,
-0.08474855124950409,
-0.09289660304784775,
0.25294229388237,
0.28573742508888245,
-0.6065003871917725,
0.3628208637237549,
0.4301271140575409,
0.10528183728456497,
-0.04920543357729912,
-0.13448430597782135,
0.3180249333381653,
-0.06656759977340698,
-0.6315240859985352,
-0.6096544861793518,
0.8844003081321716,
0.8094576001167297,
0.14129731059074402,
0.730094850063324,
0.016424518078565598,
-0.9770374298095703,
-0.20711174607276917,
-0.679273247718811,
-0.3427658677101135,
-0.356594443321228,
0.4084632098674774,
-0.30400943756103516,
-0.6563243865966797,
0.45148965716362,
-0.2943176031112671,
0.1353435069322586,
0.29955822229385376,
0.4971776008605957,
-0.3355381488800049,
1.037892460823059,
0.5144478678703308,
0.0486467219889164,
0.3287700414657593,
-0.21695765852928162,
0.4935983717441559,
-0.958453357219696,
-0.543671190738678,
-0.274580180644989,
-0.4011005163192749,
-0.25964072346687317,
-0.5118226408958435,
0.893219530582428,
0.18045927584171295,
0.20996008813381195,
0.03176266327500343,
-0.44300878047943115,
0.08182810992002487,
-0.12839631736278534,
0.5706557631492615,
-0.14973221719264984,
0.011201996356248856,
-0.3422127664089203,
-0.19885636866092682,
-0.7690611481666565,
-0.8845556378364563,
1.2233905792236328,
0.5561305284500122,
0.7319705486297607,
0.18323367834091187,
0.8939661383628845,
0.4732562303543091,
0.4767104387283325,
-0.3309389650821686,
0.04115370661020279,
-0.02113635651767254,
-0.6458887457847595,
-0.1535719484090805,
-0.04057379812002182,
-0.5837122797966003,
0.17213378846645355,
-0.6273206472396851,
-0.629957377910614,
0.38883495330810547,
0.4120185077190399,
-0.6933907270431519,
0.45961621403694153,
-0.8946123123168945,
0.7756637930870056,
-0.2109479457139969,
-0.07714258879423141,
-0.4656897485256195,
-0.6603297591209412,
-0.14954568445682526,
-0.23097138106822968,
0.35229751467704773,
0.2847957909107208,
0.05726121366024017,
0.9100213646888733,
-0.6595868468284607,
0.5772268772125244,
-0.06342383474111557,
0.3506787419319153,
0.5862466096878052,
-0.01997874490916729,
0.623085081577301,
0.2159540057182312,
-0.04195433855056763,
-0.1191316545009613,
0.029072457924485207,
-0.33806419372558594,
-0.37489014863967896,
0.7341054677963257,
-0.5697464942932129,
-0.3023713231086731,
-0.30720099806785583,
0.009706869721412659,
-0.3176959455013275,
0.0989251360297203,
0.1910080760717392,
1.0244224071502686,
-0.33784568309783936,
0.23359771072864532,
0.7354066967964172,
-0.16859962046146393,
0.4206464886665344,
0.27057570219039917,
0.19149702787399292,
-0.36187490820884705,
0.5640102624893188,
0.4040451943874359,
-0.32482269406318665,
0.7341404557228088,
0.05059152841567993,
-0.708711564540863,
-0.405219167470932,
-0.619354784488678,
0.1863144487142563,
-0.9649479389190674,
-0.0775812417268753,
-1.3313584327697754,
0.07160050421953201,
-0.250346302986145,
-0.5874045491218567,
-0.14093917608261108,
-0.31993603706359863,
-0.4480828046798706,
-0.6259232759475708,
0.5019325613975525,
0.9985790252685547,
0.012469643726944923,
0.38320809602737427,
-1.0948266983032227,
0.11237230151891708,
0.15739960968494415,
0.257526695728302,
0.1302291452884674,
-0.19977684319019318,
-0.18818406760692596,
-0.38242968916893005,
-0.4722538888454437,
-1.3015230894088745,
0.10136809200048447,
0.26622283458709717,
0.6960116624832153,
0.7178238034248352,
0.00917671900242567,
0.8034676909446716,
-1.13123619556427,
0.6077414751052856,
0.66570645570755,
-0.6333184838294983,
0.6291353702545166,
-0.21820305287837982,
-0.2685321569442749,
0.7113716006278992,
0.3411167562007904,
-0.2573324143886566,
0.1789158135652542,
-0.9223506450653076,
-0.8311229348182678,
0.49864962697029114,
-0.06245480477809906,
0.07397577166557312,
-0.300937682390213,
0.30695798993110657,
-0.09056972712278366,
0.284214049577713,
-0.46166878938674927,
-0.5768375396728516,
-0.39256229996681213,
-0.489055335521698,
-0.09604733437299728,
-0.7315477132797241,
0.10406898707151413,
-0.06438329815864563,
0.07659465819597244,
0.13314110040664673,
0.6484300494194031,
0.7867357134819031,
-0.2610131502151489,
-0.32681965827941895,
0.7304649949073792,
0.6046922206878662,
0.688798189163208,
-0.2571086585521698,
0.5518370270729065,
0.4584800601005554,
-0.43091028928756714,
0.15914613008499146,
0.011993595398962498,
0.2945701777935028,
0.33090096712112427,
0.29086926579475403,
0.7700141668319702,
0.4977763891220093,
-0.5111365914344788,
0.4830004572868347,
0.06619003415107727,
0.024715255945920944,
-0.2506515383720398,
-0.37228772044181824,
-0.13911639153957367,
-0.07565250992774963,
0.19746793806552887,
0.04994276538491249,
0.5184468030929565,
-0.5059046149253845,
0.9392664432525635,
-0.053344275802373886,
-0.6290220618247986,
-0.646404504776001,
0.7763780355453491,
0.17580170929431915,
-0.07970590889453888,
0.2041158676147461,
0.11872971057891846,
-0.5829010009765625,
0.5457971692085266,
0.9142809510231018,
0.7175549864768982,
-0.5930652022361755,
0.19998736679553986,
0.3877788782119751,
0.2966885268688202,
-0.2903395891189575,
0.6280917525291443,
0.034594565629959106,
-0.2521994709968567,
0.11084957420825958,
-0.3378269672393799,
-0.3476168215274811,
0.12134098261594772,
-0.6864662766456604,
0.6223593950271606,
-0.9385685324668884,
-0.4152412712574005,
-0.2667103409767151,
-0.6288989186286926,
-0.9221417903900146,
0.6182457208633423,
0.301794171333313,
0.5609223246574402,
-0.7815113067626953,
0.6156553626060486,
1.4175149202346802,
-0.23069924116134644,
-0.8750079870223999,
-0.1800040602684021,
0.14605315029621124,
-0.4439426362514496,
0.0861966535449028,
0.26445066928863525,
0.22033271193504333,
-0.3399070203304291,
0.08714234083890915,
-0.5185205340385437,
1.0214346647262573,
-0.1145271584391594,
-1.0828068256378174,
-0.16365286707878113,
-0.03801409900188446,
0.6177811622619629,
-0.6133723855018616,
0.6856662631034851,
0.34408366680145264,
0.20659008622169495,
-0.49352896213531494,
-0.8383544683456421,
0.16281622648239136,
-0.14971786737442017,
-0.35579174757003784,
0.4216363728046417,
-0.45103350281715393,
0.8126770257949829,
-0.48925721645355225,
-0.07344882190227509,
-0.5936848521232605,
0.35459470748901367,
0.20776201784610748,
0.6381135582923889,
0.49065446853637695,
0.7779306173324585,
0.8486754894256592,
0.08049774169921875,
1.3437730073928833,
-0.09652096778154373,
0.2940511405467987,
0.922921895980835,
-0.4414809048175812,
0.7750003933906555,
0.5007981657981873,
-0.028444455936551094,
0.9040675759315491,
0.5702621936798096,
0.31251123547554016,
0.8656230568885803,
-0.11961376667022705,
-0.28091466426849365,
-0.23624710738658905,
-0.009580760262906551,
-0.5535423159599304,
-0.06781324744224548,
0.6722139716148376,
-0.7764436602592468,
-0.3121916651725769,
0.018510587513446808,
0.08492010086774826,
-0.2690679728984833,
-0.25857746601104736,
0.7764602899551392,
0.5257682204246521,
-0.22510996460914612,
0.24297437071800232,
0.13843518495559692,
0.11316689848899841,
-0.4952438473701477,
-0.43310022354125977,
0.3842131793498993,
0.2827311158180237,
-0.4203903079032898,
-0.42170363664627075,
0.19570201635360718,
-0.08918643742799759,
-0.45371606945991516,
-0.1745733618736267,
0.6236046552658081,
-0.2808123528957367,
-0.38041409850120544,
0.32646578550338745,
0.515688955783844,
-0.12489433586597443,
0.35243305563926697,
-0.7106578350067139,
-0.37335729598999023,
-0.21586790680885315,
-0.2035910189151764,
0.32796546816825867,
0.6995714902877808,
-0.3066997826099396,
0.3766239881515503,
0.46426355838775635,
0.10636387020349503,
0.136038675904274,
0.2043500393629074,
0.8250324726104736,
-0.5330075621604919,
-1.0654276609420776,
-0.8751113414764404,
0.5969821810722351,
0.01928221993148327,
-0.3464454114437103,
0.22963519394397736,
0.25734347105026245,
0.36791083216667175,
-0.1431126445531845,
1.0200307369232178,
-0.09379985183477402,
0.5877085328102112,
-0.631788432598114,
0.5829853415489197,
-0.6586403250694275,
0.21080933511257172,
-0.6368253827095032,
-0.6598791480064392,
-0.3576437830924988,
0.8178430199623108,
-0.2679336965084076,
-0.12772513926029205,
0.9908508658409119,
0.18533898890018463,
-0.2815769910812378,
0.14296701550483704,
0.37584057450294495,
-0.014603633433580399,
0.39000436663627625,
0.6501867771148682,
0.8577622771263123,
-0.3895954191684723,
0.047201499342918396,
-0.2771705090999603,
-0.3954170048236847,
-0.5019293427467346,
-0.786888062953949,
-0.9652166962623596,
-0.38892146944999695,
-0.33699244260787964,
-0.09122740477323532,
-0.26795023679733276,
1.270412802696228,
0.9061145782470703,
-1.1265571117401123,
0.23381714522838593,
0.2505543529987335,
-0.05706024169921875,
0.2033507227897644,
-0.11417338997125626,
0.5559910535812378,
0.050661876797676086,
0.004437965340912342,
0.3498915433883667,
0.566376805305481,
0.31199702620506287,
0.20094262063503265,
0.012352287769317627,
-0.18072718381881714,
0.061402179300785065,
0.5208921432495117,
-0.1336359828710556,
-0.5735387802124023,
-0.23907242715358734,
-0.03996456041932106,
-0.07652033120393753,
0.2855248749256134,
1.2166284322738647,
-0.6183474063873291,
0.6350410580635071,
0.3108120262622833,
0.758500337600708,
0.11431647092103958,
-0.0957711711525917,
0.37977227568626404,
-0.4845309555530548,
0.023097705096006393,
0.3831312954425812,
0.9967517852783203,
0.4232068359851837,
-0.6029713153839111,
0.04580742120742798,
0.09826116263866425,
-0.45794230699539185,
-0.7601857781410217,
-0.2516312897205353,
-0.622437059879303,
-0.025939343497157097,
0.7034291625022888,
-0.2278982251882553,
0.09345483779907227,
-0.6312557458877563,
-0.12417137622833252,
-0.07101818919181824,
-0.7387651205062866,
0.7425631880760193,
0.4864289462566376,
-0.35987046360969543,
-0.23721204698085785,
-0.6672002077102661,
0.4909338653087616,
0.4308023154735565,
-0.8741390705108643,
-0.5183229446411133,
0.4359762966632843,
0.26452189683914185,
0.5082369446754456,
0.9325115084648132,
-0.27840426564216614,
0.4108963906764984,
-0.3548581898212433,
-0.03323642164468765,
0.4362688958644867,
-0.8027107119560242,
-0.31346482038497925,
0.16324032843112946,
-0.09065789729356766,
-0.22566519677639008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00159v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00159v2 | Dolma: an Open Corpus of Three Trillion Tokens for Language Model Pretraining Research | 2024-01-31T20:29:50 | 2024-06-06T18:46:40 | Luca Soldaini, Rodney Kinney, Akshita Bhagia, Dustin Schwenk, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Ben Bogin, Khyathi Chandu, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Valentin Hofmann, Ananya Harsh Jha, Sachin Kumar, Li Lucy, Xinxi Lyu, Nathan Lambert, Ian Magnusson, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Abhilasha Ravichander, Kyle Richardson, Zejiang Shen, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Oyvind Tafjord, Pete Walsh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Iz Beltagy, Dirk Groeneveld, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information about pretraining corpora used to train the current
best-performing language models is seldom discussed: commercial models rarely
detail their data, and even open models are often released without accompanying
training data or recipes to reproduce them. As a result, it is challenging to
conduct and advance scientific research on language modeling, such as
understanding how training data impacts model capabilities and limitations. To
facilitate scientific research on language model pretraining, we curate and
release Dolma, a three-trillion-token English corpus, built from a diverse
mixture of web content, scientific papers, code, public-domain books, social
media, and encyclopedic materials. We extensively document Dolma, including its
design principles, details about its construction, and a summary of its
contents. We present analyses and experimental results on intermediate states
of Dolma to share what we have learned about important data curation practices.
Finally, we open-source our data curation toolkit to enable reproduction of our
work as well as support further research in large-scale data curation. | [
-0.10098578035831451,
-0.7976166009902954,
0.3231542408466339,
0.06500275433063507,
-0.06997691094875336,
0.054019466042518616,
-0.3926306366920471,
-0.34967970848083496,
0.1839609444141388,
0.5040706992149353,
0.0012605360243469477,
-0.27692997455596924,
-0.4976312518119812,
0.04111786186695099,
-0.6026294827461243,
1.3390883207321167,
-0.16255880892276764,
0.4733046591281891,
-0.33018139004707336,
0.22651994228363037,
0.10735489428043365,
-0.8417767286300659,
-0.3635329008102417,
0.053660422563552856,
0.7913799285888672,
0.43975868821144104,
0.49018922448158264,
0.47304850816726685,
0.5132319927215576,
0.1313094049692154,
-0.013753034174442291,
-0.17175453901290894,
-0.8805380463600159,
-0.006379867438226938,
0.12451700866222382,
-0.7685521245002747,
-0.8091619610786438,
0.4569860100746155,
0.9571605920791626,
0.9330681562423706,
-0.10288907587528229,
0.48347577452659607,
-0.12613514065742493,
0.4709028899669647,
-0.7220174670219421,
0.268393337726593,
-0.6426619291305542,
-0.09388966113328934,
-0.9938347339630127,
0.10125917196273804,
-0.4734656512737274,
-0.41091814637184143,
-0.15172673761844635,
-0.7042174935340881,
0.4896504878997803,
0.3435429632663727,
0.6033605337142944,
0.17237892746925354,
-0.22707818448543549,
-0.16785749793052673,
-0.7696871161460876,
0.713823139667511,
-0.6022120118141174,
0.5351129770278931,
0.767583966255188,
0.15460561215877533,
-0.0851210281252861,
-1.0234888792037964,
-1.0193021297454834,
-0.3692167401313782,
-0.121355339884758,
-0.34879305958747864,
-0.33394914865493774,
-0.19833925366401672,
0.056366030126810074,
0.563642144203186,
-0.6955670118331909,
0.14490589499473572,
-0.8269495964050293,
0.03046167455613613,
0.42332884669303894,
-0.03454092517495155,
0.28049132227897644,
0.1872687190771103,
-0.13893765211105347,
-0.27822017669677734,
-1.1248588562011719,
-0.2548959255218506,
0.6815049648284912,
0.19500064849853516,
-0.0737379863858223,
0.6579915285110474,
0.08088693022727966,
0.6503106355667114,
-0.16410568356513977,
0.3840029537677765,
0.6031850576400757,
-0.29957306385040283,
-0.2167094200849533,
0.09605124592781067,
0.8455449342727661,
-0.08880314975976944,
-0.013745873235166073,
-0.38598328828811646,
-0.16476936638355255,
0.06614255160093307,
0.6443495750427246,
-0.6679148077964783,
-0.29659977555274963,
0.1048731654882431,
-0.34496623277664185,
-0.41921278834342957,
0.026148490607738495,
-0.6619961261749268,
0.04354539513587952,
-0.3777654469013214,
0.10544665157794952,
-0.15841303765773773,
-0.5913639068603516,
0.07515666633844376,
0.10818374902009964,
-0.09363402426242828,
-0.005359293892979622,
-1.0745463371276855,
0.3270476758480072,
0.7249296307563782,
0.7993032336235046,
-0.19453218579292297,
-0.5554644465446472,
-0.5595644116401672,
0.09489765018224716,
-0.6508543491363525,
0.4778413772583008,
-0.5663832426071167,
-0.3550305962562561,
-0.09538803994655609,
0.19609896838665009,
-0.10145564377307892,
-0.4856853783130646,
0.4683387577533722,
-0.8532605171203613,
0.17586533725261688,
0.06633755564689636,
-0.3293691873550415,
0.04623778909444809,
0.08848477154970169,
-1.0020592212677002,
1.1410918235778809,
0.2418307363986969,
-0.8604778051376343,
0.31112533807754517,
-0.8885631561279297,
-0.14354433119297028,
0.3551044166088104,
-0.07269023358821869,
-0.1419050246477127,
0.2915324568748474,
-0.12071163952350616,
0.4666864573955536,
-0.36108872294425964,
0.7746932506561279,
-0.4891955554485321,
-0.14244291186332703,
0.33707723021507263,
-0.17798390984535217,
0.761329174041748,
0.6374155879020691,
0.00027411713381297886,
0.19720028340816498,
-0.7315647006034851,
-0.3330353796482086,
0.39390742778778076,
-0.12496877461671829,
-0.4187851548194885,
-0.3015792965888977,
0.17930316925048828,
-0.11100487411022186,
0.41969025135040283,
-0.8224570751190186,
0.2173120379447937,
-0.20663097500801086,
0.4200317859649658,
0.4030284285545349,
-0.7209028601646423,
0.5539028644561768,
-0.36462298035621643,
0.6681122183799744,
0.3470117449760437,
0.06772914528846741,
-0.2728736698627472,
-0.17071691155433655,
-0.7556394338607788,
-0.19693347811698914,
0.6211079955101013,
0.0953207015991211,
-0.3931310772895813,
0.23281067609786987,
-0.2755698263645172,
-0.9125266075134277,
-1.0715491771697998,
0.05625620856881142,
0.4136209487915039,
0.6020786762237549,
0.3201606273651123,
-0.25200483202934265,
-0.7182955741882324,
-0.7126559019088745,
0.18154381215572357,
-0.2361880987882614,
-0.05703980475664139,
-0.03792112320661545,
0.70707768201828,
-0.108576700091362,
0.9723562598228455,
-0.6638140082359314,
-0.061480890959501266,
-0.056478843092918396,
0.10014430433511734,
0.0891164094209671,
0.5403189659118652,
0.6240876913070679,
-0.6230217218399048,
-0.22199450433254242,
-0.08130253106355667,
-0.7022731304168701,
0.2839638888835907,
0.4493919610977173,
-0.3121723234653473,
0.18799643218517303,
0.42955055832862854,
-0.646159291267395,
0.22620761394500732,
0.7909651398658752,
-0.20492935180664062,
0.5263994932174683,
-0.18396073579788208,
-0.03567078709602356,
-0.8882690668106079,
0.7488778829574585,
-0.44373223185539246,
-0.13111995160579681,
-0.8635923862457275,
0.04643848165869713,
0.20706185698509216,
-0.316911518573761,
-0.46114876866340637,
0.7975509762763977,
-0.17933715879917145,
0.1646871119737625,
0.013247082009911537,
0.01653670147061348,
-0.03206874430179596,
0.25197845697402954,
0.20647038519382477,
0.7390310764312744,
0.6741238236427307,
-0.5315307974815369,
0.03814217075705528,
0.4439096450805664,
-0.5379560589790344,
0.18138571083545685,
-0.7807205319404602,
0.4153749942779541,
-0.2773090898990631,
0.4704889953136444,
-0.7195318937301636,
-0.41811618208885193,
0.35443931818008423,
-0.3165501654148102,
0.35150593519210815,
0.11660595238208771,
-0.5410549640655518,
-0.30295509099960327,
-0.13668707013130188,
0.4884980320930481,
0.4875325560569763,
-0.5636813044548035,
-0.08351034671068192,
0.9040631055831909,
-0.48641595244407654,
-0.4818195104598999,
-0.47992539405822754,
-0.05037165433168411,
-0.05733005329966545,
-0.538857638835907,
0.42909538745880127,
-0.2963712811470032,
-0.41707542538642883,
0.09327869117259979,
0.07808862626552582,
-0.19519028067588806,
0.1052003875374794,
0.10529139637947083,
0.5056741833686829,
-0.2911648452281952,
0.1792985498905182,
-0.2481490969657898,
0.032083380967378616,
0.06258401274681091,
-0.20304469764232635,
0.6412166357040405,
-0.2553812861442566,
-0.27984246611595154,
0.1130872592329979,
0.20094315707683563,
0.33588969707489014,
-0.22470170259475708,
0.930813729763031,
0.501220166683197,
-0.22167249023914337,
-0.14902843534946442,
-0.47730186581611633,
0.012541180476546288,
-0.3597180247306824,
0.1113688051700592,
-0.1408683806657791,
-1.0559298992156982,
0.08470694720745087,
0.22250515222549438,
0.26376381516456604,
0.3234928250312805,
0.5998727083206177,
-0.028524255380034447,
0.6240621209144592,
0.6075459122657776,
0.08550418168306351,
0.32740867137908936,
-0.2886795699596405,
0.49397948384284973,
-0.6834572553634644,
-0.5264591574668884,
-0.8811278939247131,
-0.03388388082385063,
-0.12370476871728897,
-0.6793185472488403,
0.13066178560256958,
0.27616286277770996,
-0.23918132483959198,
0.19460327923297882,
-0.2112516164779663,
0.3204866647720337,
0.7095043063163757,
-0.17239966988563538,
0.27195826172828674,
-0.110559843480587,
0.05172284319996834,
0.1988212764263153,
-0.5536162853240967,
-0.8237761855125427,
1.4501712322235107,
0.28851214051246643,
0.66634202003479,
-0.04248261824250221,
0.6034494638442993,
0.07424917817115784,
0.47430190443992615,
-0.39772915840148926,
0.3159783184528351,
-0.010575863532721996,
-0.967130184173584,
-0.2983812689781189,
-0.3247053325176239,
-1.2959996461868286,
-0.16387762129306793,
0.11260286718606949,
-0.21702149510383606,
-0.1789703369140625,
0.38410863280296326,
-0.07414018362760544,
0.11827511340379715,
-0.6036720275878906,
0.8463653326034546,
-0.314043790102005,
-0.11875878274440765,
-0.23008371889591217,
-0.6724421381950378,
0.4234911799430847,
-0.6357688307762146,
0.4240168333053589,
-0.126437246799469,
0.06780201196670532,
0.9051973819732666,
-0.4145466685295105,
0.8106275200843811,
-0.013329115696251392,
-0.15609732270240784,
0.2793099880218506,
0.04995265230536461,
0.21524371206760406,
-0.15226401388645172,
-0.16686344146728516,
0.7249302268028259,
0.19838880002498627,
-0.42552217841148376,
-0.2928491234779358,
0.6053470969200134,
-0.9386780261993408,
-0.4410671293735504,
-0.3731870651245117,
-0.35866111516952515,
-0.17370690405368805,
0.29559069871902466,
-0.022285128012299538,
0.10416246205568314,
-0.6511461734771729,
0.4753704071044922,
0.3506292700767517,
-0.023227617144584656,
0.4366375207901001,
0.5579145550727844,
-0.43723389506340027,
-0.18325255811214447,
1.059043288230896,
0.11621961742639542,
-0.07552304118871689,
0.2304556965827942,
0.17302651703357697,
-0.30482709407806396,
-0.6120567917823792,
-0.3599195182323456,
0.29812943935394287,
-0.4685724377632141,
0.010950271040201187,
-0.7232775092124939,
-0.3180128335952759,
-0.7775439023971558,
-0.0019376652780920267,
-0.3719632625579834,
-0.5183237791061401,
-0.4760369658470154,
-0.286687433719635,
0.3956761062145233,
1.0821830034255981,
-0.1088448166847229,
0.44744765758514404,
-0.8665686249732971,
0.3377378284931183,
0.029639801010489464,
0.5534369349479675,
0.03534281998872757,
-0.3130982518196106,
-0.48247411847114563,
0.15901774168014526,
-0.2108372300863266,
-0.4538198709487915,
0.5650457143783569,
-0.02242232859134674,
0.8151378035545349,
0.13707834482192993,
-0.03465072810649872,
0.5111803412437439,
-0.5452632308006287,
0.9746416807174683,
0.29816192388534546,
-0.713843584060669,
0.45861655473709106,
-0.43911224603652954,
-0.00813877210021019,
0.5312715172767639,
0.8949001431465149,
-0.3294766843318939,
-0.14490154385566711,
-0.8820046186447144,
-0.7374672293663025,
1.0725560188293457,
0.13291729986667633,
0.21170774102210999,
-0.3404551148414612,
-0.1313517689704895,
0.46071699261665344,
0.608751118183136,
-0.6766651272773743,
-0.09162028878927231,
-0.35959842801094055,
-0.2501817047595978,
-0.44172346591949463,
-0.2914559245109558,
-0.3463151156902313,
-0.11191361397504807,
0.7307908535003662,
0.00985671766102314,
-0.11257051676511765,
-0.13922542333602905,
-0.29520851373672485,
-0.01892014406621456,
0.1506243646144867,
0.3014429211616516,
0.609523594379425,
-0.07942143827676773,
0.31594401597976685,
-0.1468813568353653,
-0.8895607590675354,
-0.027380332350730896,
0.10129828751087189,
-0.19015009701251984,
-0.06511729210615158,
0.13052508234977722,
1.0440146923065186,
0.1935378611087799,
-0.9392920732498169,
0.4488593339920044,
-0.09401869773864746,
-0.18832623958587646,
-0.481921911239624,
-0.03827495500445366,
0.0919664204120636,
-0.21501201391220093,
0.1253986656665802,
-0.02026359923183918,
-0.18981215357780457,
-0.3689756691455841,
0.08968669176101685,
0.08863579481840134,
-0.1806834191083908,
-0.6522567868232727,
0.7340806126594543,
0.239766463637352,
-0.2604425549507141,
0.8335003852844238,
-0.005493141245096922,
0.08308210968971252,
0.26188933849334717,
0.6703860759735107,
0.5959287285804749,
-0.13128627836704254,
0.27791255712509155,
0.3419662117958069,
-0.027646290138363838,
-0.31806468963623047,
0.3781314194202423,
-0.12474742531776428,
-0.5920003652572632,
-0.3288196921348572,
-1.1490062475204468,
-0.2954193949699402,
0.32452303171157837,
-0.4864017963409424,
0.4385007917881012,
-0.30884554982185364,
-0.0938597023487091,
-0.004013833124190569,
-0.1888362318277359,
-0.9355292916297913,
-0.020931340754032135,
0.38893967866897583,
0.7103943824768066,
-0.7578590512275696,
1.0407646894454956,
0.6334991455078125,
-0.5830230116844177,
-0.6176922917366028,
-0.3501615822315216,
-0.07610299438238144,
-0.9681754112243652,
1.174656867980957,
0.08614147454500198,
0.07553114742040634,
0.16595397889614105,
-0.6843819618225098,
-1.1445162296295166,
0.7929064631462097,
0.6544395685195923,
-0.738589346408844,
-0.3044596314430237,
0.07656717300415039,
0.5462138652801514,
-0.41522228717803955,
0.2721192240715027,
0.6294814348220825,
0.40990862250328064,
0.17029832303524017,
-1.0486489534378052,
-0.23744933307170868,
-0.6100607514381409,
-0.2994721531867981,
0.10946834832429886,
-0.5748506188392639,
0.9487634301185608,
-0.07063613831996918,
-0.021792367100715637,
-0.07087166607379913,
0.42197805643081665,
0.4125382900238037,
0.18912740051746368,
0.44228899478912354,
0.6906492114067078,
1.0440880060195923,
0.14202488958835602,
0.920266330242157,
-0.3766433894634247,
-0.10188978165388107,
1.1595044136047363,
-0.44992002844810486,
1.0584183931350708,
0.6249952912330627,
-0.24541300535202026,
0.3787820637226105,
0.6313419342041016,
0.06116419658064842,
0.31386950612068176,
0.48602744936943054,
-0.3599570393562317,
0.15906459093093872,
-0.4176410734653473,
-0.34164804220199585,
0.6737353801727295,
0.3948712944984436,
-0.33402907848358154,
-0.05330158770084381,
-0.036915019154548645,
0.41312143206596375,
-0.17877164483070374,
-0.08395208418369293,
0.49989914894104004,
0.03203190118074417,
-0.9208521246910095,
0.4699690341949463,
-0.32498684525489807,
0.32985565066337585,
-0.6905218958854675,
0.012566827237606049,
-0.08755744248628616,
-0.05819493904709816,
-0.21043379604816437,
-0.5578461289405823,
0.4390209913253784,
0.40578773617744446,
-0.0610528364777565,
-0.5631478428840637,
0.3465873897075653,
-0.5410476922988892,
-0.42261284589767456,
0.12713521718978882,
0.5415499806404114,
0.7027809619903564,
0.2881452739238739,
-0.21497218310832977,
0.3788068890571594,
-0.32326239347457886,
-0.5611855983734131,
0.5916380882263184,
0.29311898350715637,
-0.052106134593486786,
0.28955960273742676,
1.0657058954238892,
0.4342330992221832,
0.2483835369348526,
0.09223392605781555,
0.9980855584144592,
-0.5502294898033142,
-0.2765806317329407,
-0.7121245265007019,
0.5175032615661621,
-0.02549607865512371,
-0.49745631217956543,
0.6868802905082703,
0.7165400385856628,
1.3351432085037231,
-0.15910600125789642,
0.8728365898132324,
-0.2939661145210266,
0.536828875541687,
-0.4327334463596344,
0.9155163168907166,
-0.4360916018486023,
-0.0863182470202446,
0.05337582901120186,
-0.7613932490348816,
-0.4479653239250183,
0.39062362909317017,
-0.250463604927063,
-0.30346977710723877,
0.620451807975769,
0.8578969836235046,
-0.11063363403081894,
0.18967896699905396,
0.2708033621311188,
0.34321948885917664,
0.22689053416252136,
-0.03579819202423096,
0.8104820847511292,
0.023866597563028336,
0.4470411539077759,
-0.1137835755944252,
-0.20785778760910034,
-0.2092190831899643,
-0.9039128422737122,
-0.9238757491111755,
-1.0086007118225098,
0.026549356058239937,
-0.02843356877565384,
-0.244064599275589,
0.811016857624054,
0.9504538178443909,
-0.7028994560241699,
-0.31772831082344055,
-0.039248641580343246,
-0.26484134793281555,
0.21333520114421844,
-0.08682791143655777,
0.3278696835041046,
-0.6804675459861755,
-0.755154550075531,
0.6298477649688721,
-0.09262257814407349,
0.05953243002295494,
-0.47389668226242065,
-0.09755155444145203,
-0.11830559372901917,
-0.19153711199760437,
0.42484575510025024,
0.19784940779209137,
-0.4533805847167969,
0.19885298609733582,
0.1360337734222412,
-0.028954453766345978,
-0.025876974686980247,
1.0186207294464111,
-0.7181234955787659,
0.6162863969802856,
0.4272228181362152,
0.53873610496521,
0.6031773686408997,
-0.45455366373062134,
0.942492663860321,
-0.7908117771148682,
0.4180561304092407,
0.4395509362220764,
0.38037657737731934,
0.3007674515247345,
-0.20053799450397491,
0.681441068649292,
-0.02736232988536358,
-0.669410765171051,
-1.293816089630127,
-0.08164072036743164,
-0.7729512453079224,
-0.18767867982387543,
0.934887170791626,
-0.40234023332595825,
-0.41257745027542114,
-0.1179959625005722,
-0.13875886797904968,
0.5228381752967834,
-0.23978100717067719,
0.6518744230270386,
0.7083890438079834,
0.1499057114124298,
0.19185777008533478,
-0.7627004981040955,
0.5857582092285156,
0.15906672179698944,
-0.8370686769485474,
0.28985685110092163,
0.4903109073638916,
0.12433977425098419,
0.19410526752471924,
0.971925675868988,
-0.386417031288147,
-0.11758337169885635,
0.2544638216495514,
0.22863662242889404,
-0.2220868617296219,
-0.6171530485153198,
-0.38542303442955017,
0.23394310474395752,
0.3374846875667572,
-0.04159824177622795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00157v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00157v3 | Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning: Progresses and Challenges | 2024-01-31T20:26:32 | 2024-04-05T04:06:51 | Janice Ahn, Rishu Verma, Renze Lou, Di Liu, Rui Zhang, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for assessing the fundamental
cognitive capabilities of human intelligence. In recent times, there has been a
notable surge in the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) geared towards
the automated resolution of mathematical problems. However, the landscape of
mathematical problem types is vast and varied, with LLM-oriented techniques
undergoing evaluation across diverse datasets and settings. This diversity
makes it challenging to discern the true advancements and obstacles within this
burgeoning field. This survey endeavors to address four pivotal dimensions: i)
a comprehensive exploration of the various mathematical problems and their
corresponding datasets that have been investigated; ii) an examination of the
spectrum of LLM-oriented techniques that have been proposed for mathematical
problem-solving; iii) an overview of factors and concerns affecting LLMs in
solving math; and iv) an elucidation of the persisting challenges within this
domain. To the best of our knowledge, this survey stands as one of the first
extensive examinations of the landscape of LLMs in the realm of mathematics,
providing a holistic perspective on the current state, accomplishments, and
future challenges in this rapidly evolving field. | [
-0.5133904814720154,
-1.052340030670166,
0.9263854026794434,
0.4095728397369385,
0.1367831975221634,
0.28997552394866943,
-0.4461825489997864,
-0.3673362135887146,
-0.14664775133132935,
0.6521809101104736,
-0.5406685471534729,
-0.3815194070339203,
-0.7582114934921265,
0.0856538861989975,
-0.2560894191265106,
0.5118424892425537,
-0.14563724398612976,
0.14182323217391968,
-0.5756382942199707,
-0.07865491509437561,
-0.41576963663101196,
-0.9086989760398865,
-0.637515664100647,
-0.31210216879844666,
0.3492189943790436,
0.21376582980155945,
0.7307657599449158,
0.18179410696029663,
0.8452054262161255,
0.43315818905830383,
-0.21528179943561554,
0.0892038568854332,
-0.27416351437568665,
0.4596129357814789,
-0.1332930624485016,
-0.5335726737976074,
-0.2552725672721863,
-0.10378272831439972,
0.7880825996398926,
1.3679897785186768,
0.006558200344443321,
0.1655997931957245,
-0.17767904698848724,
0.7523725032806396,
-0.3522070050239563,
0.403652548789978,
-0.5504137277603149,
-0.06289632618427277,
-0.5197898745536804,
0.20356979966163635,
-0.23121196031570435,
-0.330659955739975,
0.3453924357891083,
-0.4471510052680969,
-0.1444758176803589,
-0.09437089413404465,
0.40091273188591003,
0.18412314355373383,
-0.740935742855072,
-0.5258911848068237,
-1.0377113819122314,
1.0602962970733643,
-0.5757132768630981,
0.38015031814575195,
0.34988823533058167,
0.37456873059272766,
-0.3061107397079468,
-0.5260458588600159,
-0.3803691864013672,
-0.09303200244903564,
0.4362689256668091,
-0.11423120647668839,
-0.22954894602298737,
-0.3211507201194763,
0.49416017532348633,
0.39338934421539307,
-0.47918596863746643,
0.3229793608188629,
-0.23701469600200653,
-0.22257091104984283,
0.9136378169059753,
0.5926167368888855,
0.24973753094673157,
0.008037588559091091,
0.21539172530174255,
0.1905994862318039,
-0.7987650632858276,
0.01570385880768299,
0.2736462950706482,
-0.0118837496265769,
0.07509956508874893,
0.6927095055580139,
-0.008010373450815678,
0.7505797147750854,
-0.45157140493392944,
-0.21886137127876282,
0.013894341886043549,
-0.29608723521232605,
0.04614011570811272,
-0.46610313653945923,
0.5890331864356995,
-0.09989145398139954,
0.5127333402633667,
0.3894253969192505,
-0.23458252847194672,
0.14030815660953522,
-0.22285950183868408,
-0.41317984461784363,
0.005745186470448971,
0.22443443536758423,
-0.18275056779384613,
-0.07035841792821884,
-0.29507410526275635,
-0.6120923161506653,
-0.41475623846054077,
-0.7838172912597656,
0.01968747191131115,
-0.28988924622535706,
-0.31287071108818054,
0.31311073899269104,
0.40574827790260315,
0.26544901728630066,
0.5976415276527405,
-0.7625505328178406,
0.17750084400177002,
1.0520814657211304,
0.5091738104820251,
-0.08705594390630722,
0.019677268341183662,
-0.07790669798851013,
-0.07701928913593292,
-0.4183890223503113,
0.9194175601005554,
-0.7491414546966553,
-0.4983999729156494,
0.327425479888916,
-0.27454060316085815,
0.023977812379598618,
-0.6648651361465454,
0.6592510938644409,
-0.5033589601516724,
0.165703684091568,
-0.4455735981464386,
-0.6091935038566589,
-0.22001396119594574,
0.6123220920562744,
-0.5588709712028503,
0.850170373916626,
0.13072779774665833,
-0.39952173829078674,
-0.23910854756832123,
-0.6768901944160461,
-0.33262574672698975,
0.13988550007343292,
-0.3638535141944885,
-0.2565544545650482,
0.324798583984375,
0.2059183418750763,
0.3294205963611603,
-0.8067998290061951,
0.404735267162323,
-0.4064432382583618,
0.06537297368049622,
0.6093962788581848,
-0.580132782459259,
0.9787949323654175,
0.26413851976394653,
0.05190953239798546,
0.005944959353655577,
-0.7699651122093201,
0.0434439443051815,
0.4696441888809204,
-0.017238330096006393,
-0.25294890999794006,
0.21054396033287048,
-0.17960447072982788,
0.25613734126091003,
0.4633387625217438,
-0.2904241383075714,
0.3494662046432495,
-0.24097631871700287,
0.6343891024589539,
0.7077516913414001,
-0.023998146876692772,
0.25943276286125183,
-0.17545050382614136,
0.6082174777984619,
-0.02386506274342537,
0.20454657077789307,
-0.27318939566612244,
-0.6745967268943787,
-0.538425862789154,
-0.1788666546344757,
0.29295602440834045,
0.6125292778015137,
-0.5521689653396606,
0.18003807961940765,
-0.26025980710983276,
-0.5139734745025635,
-0.06932907551527023,
0.22356842458248138,
0.18525908887386322,
0.19851543009281158,
0.0024946527555584908,
0.2963418662548065,
-0.2834881544113159,
-0.8421918749809265,
-0.1353282779455185,
-0.0005762640503235161,
0.026841366663575172,
0.4866354167461395,
0.6181832551956177,
-0.20950442552566528,
0.814821720123291,
-0.6603097915649414,
-0.25176310539245605,
-0.23384271562099457,
-0.01308654434978962,
0.24646246433258057,
0.25923529267311096,
0.4304737150669098,
-0.7521111369132996,
-0.44436654448509216,
-0.03872077539563179,
-0.9387403130531311,
-0.33142903447151184,
0.1846078485250473,
-0.03410862013697624,
0.07430118322372437,
0.44173672795295715,
-0.7151392698287964,
0.2609920799732208,
0.5259391069412231,
-0.2111714780330658,
0.669023871421814,
-0.05310956388711929,
-0.10321278870105743,
-0.7433239221572876,
-0.07851748913526535,
0.23634690046310425,
0.26124417781829834,
-0.4468783438205719,
0.03880374878644943,
-0.2773974537849426,
-0.2592731714248657,
-0.0665653645992279,
0.5949310064315796,
-0.5312197804450989,
-0.24417422711849213,
0.02284124679863453,
0.40316179394721985,
-0.18223027884960175,
0.1868428885936737,
-0.05664658546447754,
0.3643819987773895,
0.7489609718322754,
-0.5482558608055115,
0.6968476176261902,
0.15387950837612152,
-0.34951159358024597,
0.6221758723258972,
-0.6313463449478149,
0.105861134827137,
-0.24857789278030396,
0.21661405265331268,
-0.9389664530754089,
-0.17756308615207672,
0.11189054697751999,
-0.4635542333126068,
0.12319251149892807,
0.10992641001939774,
-0.6423797607421875,
-0.49050167202949524,
0.10771297663450241,
0.7999076843261719,
0.4997008442878723,
-0.2190551906824112,
0.6473197937011719,
0.46074575185775757,
-0.5193603038787842,
-0.34859877824783325,
-0.4141619801521301,
0.1925056129693985,
-0.19101177155971527,
-0.8867022395133972,
0.03198749199509621,
-0.1370493471622467,
-1.0222641229629517,
-0.14129595458507538,
-0.04511154815554619,
-0.08837756514549255,
0.09669573605060577,
-0.12769053876399994,
0.4757174551486969,
-0.30395644903182983,
0.07129504531621933,
-0.1547294557094574,
-0.2994225025177002,
0.5366764664649963,
-0.3884919583797455,
0.5052785873413086,
-0.2260684221982956,
-0.668292224407196,
-0.2029990702867508,
0.5759090781211853,
0.5896738767623901,
-0.6042143106460571,
0.5130268335342407,
0.10568536072969437,
-0.6279728412628174,
-0.25352299213409424,
-0.6069842576980591,
0.08285653591156006,
-0.40796399116516113,
0.3649660348892212,
-0.5124334692955017,
-0.9984000325202942,
0.6508992314338684,
-0.2845100462436676,
0.11341474950313568,
0.530322790145874,
0.8202199935913086,
0.030062235891819,
1.214707851409912,
0.24857838451862335,
0.08646006137132645,
0.18091242015361786,
-0.2918001711368561,
0.39909377694129944,
-0.8595306873321533,
-0.42003634572029114,
-0.833420991897583,
-0.12316587567329407,
-0.3036951720714569,
-0.5205137133598328,
0.5424448847770691,
-0.051415782421827316,
-0.2862158715724945,
-0.16961249709129333,
-0.2779954969882965,
0.4273836016654968,
0.11797742545604706,
-0.32025963068008423,
0.3708542585372925,
-0.08853953331708908,
-0.16897991299629211,
-0.30077406764030457,
-0.4427867531776428,
-0.6134264469146729,
1.0804818868637085,
0.48991167545318604,
0.6906810402870178,
0.4215185344219208,
0.30693888664245605,
-0.14343680441379547,
0.311808317899704,
-0.8911214470863342,
0.726350724697113,
-0.09151102602481842,
-0.7634901404380798,
-0.572819709777832,
-0.6651681661605835,
-1.021771788597107,
0.37037068605422974,
-0.07640881836414337,
-0.8568674325942993,
-0.13291889429092407,
-0.02267083153128624,
-0.20024415850639343,
0.4047790765762329,
-0.34240129590034485,
0.5758439898490906,
-0.6031057834625244,
-0.29967787861824036,
-0.25394394993782043,
-0.45435330271720886,
0.6551236510276794,
-0.3397069573402405,
0.5886400938034058,
-0.3407471477985382,
0.04455172270536423,
0.5196426510810852,
-0.24001789093017578,
0.5642505288124084,
0.034202199429273605,
-0.5687015652656555,
0.423430472612381,
0.29673299193382263,
0.27146631479263306,
0.1937345564365387,
-0.019087158143520355,
0.14473406970500946,
0.19940167665481567,
-0.405725359916687,
-0.7200461030006409,
0.6751251816749573,
-0.6779717803001404,
-0.9309295415878296,
-0.6339493989944458,
-0.7732961773872375,
-0.5526190400123596,
0.008676751516759396,
-0.11254315823316574,
0.6426747441291809,
-0.08120668679475784,
0.2337365597486496,
0.9172388911247253,
-0.4263937473297119,
0.30925750732421875,
0.31952714920043945,
-0.6712805032730103,
-0.2928086221218109,
0.8000397086143494,
0.3297143876552582,
0.2621690630912781,
0.31508010625839233,
0.19757317006587982,
-0.5176069140434265,
-0.7691076397895813,
-0.112923264503479,
0.5473508238792419,
-0.8599240779876709,
-0.017775746062397957,
-0.34913989901542664,
-0.3858296871185303,
-0.3734400272369385,
0.062064219266176224,
-0.28536707162857056,
-0.3183762729167938,
-0.24517512321472168,
0.41208285093307495,
0.2222277969121933,
0.8544338345527649,
0.14202961325645447,
0.055831775069236755,
-0.733502984046936,
0.28397127985954285,
0.40789198875427246,
0.2526874244213104,
0.11528581380844116,
-0.3696008622646332,
0.017286064103245735,
0.09586537629365921,
-0.2330165058374405,
-0.5304577350616455,
0.16390416026115417,
-0.20221605896949768,
0.7319743037223816,
0.4503564238548279,
-0.09532493352890015,
0.4929375946521759,
-0.4830700159072876,
0.8224993944168091,
0.19014161825180054,
-0.9757132530212402,
0.2735995650291443,
-0.4987894594669342,
0.18703331053256989,
0.06644478440284729,
0.5123587250709534,
-0.4445192515850067,
-0.055793195962905884,
-0.42705124616622925,
-0.5877285599708557,
0.144384503364563,
0.13408520817756653,
0.08024049550294876,
-0.07078476250171661,
0.48450401425361633,
-0.17637987434864044,
-0.025410523638129234,
-0.36824196577072144,
-0.09952987730503082,
0.19460850954055786,
-0.19826889038085938,
-0.28420156240463257,
-0.19743576645851135,
-0.0747918039560318,
-0.4341355264186859,
0.41849514842033386,
0.015896454453468323,
0.09858258068561554,
-0.1464100182056427,
-0.11285735666751862,
-0.019031105563044548,
0.3296591341495514,
0.8556127548217773,
1.0378570556640625,
0.228056862950325,
0.03565702214837074,
0.18987728655338287,
-0.2359839677810669,
0.1647341400384903,
0.07907135784626007,
0.11083819717168808,
-0.22244253754615784,
0.4425513744354248,
0.527293860912323,
0.2005942016839981,
-0.7805591821670532,
0.33178946375846863,
0.08267546445131302,
-0.5076305866241455,
-0.7285074591636658,
-0.21161937713623047,
0.3010205030441284,
0.24837733805179596,
0.5182912945747375,
-0.1590147167444229,
-0.11299271136522293,
-0.6438453197479248,
-0.27049940824508667,
0.6468027830123901,
-0.0033833228517323732,
-0.3629898428916931,
0.44700902700424194,
-0.008924029767513275,
-0.4365473687648773,
0.8410724997520447,
-0.053467605262994766,
-0.7167009711265564,
0.6797642111778259,
0.5715270638465881,
0.5351804494857788,
-0.16790276765823364,
-0.05484773591160774,
0.18895719945430756,
0.22456641495227814,
0.0063149030320346355,
0.236765518784523,
0.24864569306373596,
-0.7894079089164734,
-0.6172358393669128,
-0.5744251012802124,
-0.5016387104988098,
0.15196017920970917,
-0.4275969862937927,
0.11672824621200562,
-0.4662904441356659,
-0.17198152840137482,
0.1909550130367279,
0.12449192255735397,
-0.5870637893676758,
0.003117036074399948,
0.3608505129814148,
0.7345196604728699,
-0.6109540462493896,
0.5798348188400269,
0.803774356842041,
-0.14688405394554138,
-0.4916044771671295,
-0.311190664768219,
0.17783860862255096,
-0.8231594562530518,
0.7390795946121216,
-0.1872357279062271,
-0.0471692755818367,
-0.01470020692795515,
-0.6167370676994324,
-0.9791020154953003,
0.7223723530769348,
0.3275522291660309,
-0.5291582942008972,
-0.10100355744361877,
0.4249120056629181,
0.537574052810669,
-0.4100020229816437,
0.09529437124729156,
0.6448872685432434,
0.6774384379386902,
0.27788156270980835,
-0.9125595688819885,
-0.3299686908721924,
-0.20952726900577545,
0.27689793705940247,
0.39867883920669556,
-0.590244710445404,
1.1771036386489868,
-0.05679459124803543,
0.040603503584861755,
0.20937025547027588,
0.5546231269836426,
0.6090689897537231,
0.3596118688583374,
0.383526474237442,
0.6146584749221802,
0.6396304368972778,
-0.35717764496803284,
0.827510416507721,
-0.11917160451412201,
0.4260134994983673,
0.7033803462982178,
-0.7196552157402039,
0.6073126792907715,
0.2974931001663208,
-0.5434434413909912,
0.43951156735420227,
0.5591080188751221,
0.05579375475645065,
-0.23072387278079987,
0.7654277086257935,
-0.5593728423118591,
-0.6101104021072388,
-0.020804109051823616,
-0.4992528259754181,
0.5782373547554016,
0.9610285758972168,
0.021116508170962334,
-0.38270169496536255,
-0.023513076826930046,
-0.0848134309053421,
0.44485902786254883,
-0.6203221082687378,
0.521358847618103,
0.2801857590675354,
-0.6194478273391724,
0.20679058134555817,
0.06302042305469513,
0.3146347999572754,
-0.6023136973381042,
-0.16859018802642822,
-0.09403588622808456,
0.24519449472427368,
-0.11459732800722122,
-1.0053648948669434,
0.39352285861968994,
0.011084330268204212,
0.004714972339570522,
-0.16130591928958893,
0.4864422678947449,
-0.18461886048316956,
-0.7791362404823303,
0.035171281546354294,
0.8160202503204346,
0.19468483328819275,
-0.024118497967720032,
-0.6534683704376221,
0.501774251461029,
-0.18197959661483765,
-0.12295462936162949,
0.3626188039779663,
0.8139525651931763,
-0.4307399094104767,
0.9573303461074829,
0.769304633140564,
0.004557560198009014,
0.16035202145576477,
0.21800577640533447,
0.7298808693885803,
-0.918091893196106,
-0.23242434859275818,
-0.841099739074707,
0.24435633420944214,
0.09618570655584335,
-0.31199368834495544,
0.7038847208023071,
0.4366428554058075,
0.511931836605072,
0.020393691956996918,
0.8275026082992554,
0.1529824435710907,
0.5364569425582886,
-0.5410749912261963,
0.24353523552417755,
-0.2512149512767792,
0.5001586675643921,
-0.35284292697906494,
-0.987338662147522,
-0.6402420401573181,
0.6440378427505493,
-0.6803538799285889,
0.17457418143749237,
0.6884286999702454,
0.31715381145477295,
0.11594774574041367,
0.08640741556882858,
0.3497152626514435,
0.12951378524303436,
0.36349302530288696,
0.7424103021621704,
1.313373327255249,
0.03207821771502495,
0.44456809759140015,
-0.06678249686956406,
-0.14275559782981873,
-0.07026790827512741,
-0.7363112568855286,
-0.9205653667449951,
-0.5315395593643188,
-0.458147794008255,
-0.22654537856578827,
-0.5615015625953674,
0.867611289024353,
0.30760663747787476,
-0.7350097298622131,
-0.4843836724758148,
0.1133253425359726,
0.29655224084854126,
0.009257013909518719,
-0.20999537408351898,
0.20897769927978516,
-0.297410249710083,
-0.7118531465530396,
0.030848002061247826,
0.42812585830688477,
-0.020858928561210632,
-0.6519758701324463,
0.09713347256183624,
-0.055721037089824677,
0.22991162538528442,
0.9910354018211365,
0.36088845133781433,
-0.889438807964325,
-0.23205623030662537,
0.20751164853572845,
-0.04155636206269264,
-0.1144791841506958,
1.0021295547485352,
-0.38951051235198975,
0.09686948359012604,
0.3337944447994232,
1.004590630531311,
0.39150622487068176,
-0.3414333760738373,
0.33457276225090027,
-0.1303623616695404,
-0.04045095667243004,
0.42987021803855896,
0.5514501333236694,
0.204619362950325,
-0.09854826331138611,
0.3475641906261444,
0.33323386311531067,
-0.5935500860214233,
-0.9535481929779053,
0.5541967749595642,
-0.9716145396232605,
-0.27474310994148254,
1.0034170150756836,
0.06649007648229599,
-0.11788687109947205,
-0.18470317125320435,
-0.12878213822841644,
-0.14619122445583344,
0.1307584047317505,
0.4725162386894226,
1.1115009784698486,
-0.3540935218334198,
-0.35860589146614075,
-0.6867518424987793,
0.07408331334590912,
0.397590696811676,
-0.9247782826423645,
0.04035118594765663,
0.7637713551521301,
0.22962740063667297,
0.19471846520900726,
0.3443645238876343,
-0.45414289832115173,
-0.00588738638907671,
-0.21642090380191803,
-0.3108770251274109,
0.134557843208313,
-0.2547455430030823,
-0.48947709798812866,
0.3463757634162903,
0.22350727021694183,
0.3962539732456207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00149v1 | The Impact of Language Adapters in Cross-Lingual Transfer for NLU | 2024-01-31T20:07:43 | 2024-01-31T20:07:43 | Jenny Kunz, Oskar Holmström | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modular deep learning has been proposed for the efficient adaption of
pre-trained models to new tasks, domains and languages. In particular,
combining language adapters with task adapters has shown potential where no
supervised data exists for a language. In this paper, we explore the role of
language adapters in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer for natural language
understanding (NLU) benchmarks. We study the effect of including a
target-language adapter in detailed ablation studies with two multilingual
models and three multilingual datasets. Our results show that the effect of
target-language adapters is highly inconsistent across tasks, languages and
models. Retaining the source-language adapter instead often leads to an
equivalent, and sometimes to a better, performance. Removing the language
adapter after training has only a weak negative effect, indicating that the
language adapters do not have a strong impact on the predictions. | [
-0.35960808396339417,
-0.482806921005249,
0.27553728222846985,
0.15310503542423248,
-0.1815251111984253,
-0.12069795280694962,
-0.4563564956188202,
-0.659196138381958,
-0.10820954293012619,
0.33934885263442993,
-0.1748490184545517,
0.026037245988845825,
-0.6709468364715576,
0.29578897356987,
-0.06489640474319458,
0.8653554916381836,
-0.17271322011947632,
-0.05029463768005371,
-0.08093107491731644,
-0.3640012741088867,
-0.7935132384300232,
-0.254630446434021,
-0.6552037000656128,
-0.5222998261451721,
0.496237576007843,
0.4180000126361847,
0.5702541470527649,
0.3463110029697418,
0.24718372523784637,
0.3203898072242737,
0.12741893529891968,
-0.3766619563102722,
-0.4128507375717163,
-0.11366340517997742,
-0.589898943901062,
-0.6967083215713501,
-0.36036649346351624,
-0.45375752449035645,
0.8565719723701477,
0.8454189300537109,
-0.02459242381155491,
-0.09453140199184418,
-0.09921328723430634,
0.7640185356140137,
-0.7311896085739136,
0.17644426226615906,
-0.8223811388015747,
0.18728573620319366,
0.1001686379313469,
0.013210315257310867,
-0.5796511173248291,
0.0592084564268589,
0.19142122566699982,
-0.5976025462150574,
0.1733846664428711,
-0.21381138265132904,
0.6707565188407898,
0.32362663745880127,
-0.43170323967933655,
-0.13158589601516724,
-0.744076132774353,
0.869572103023529,
-0.8547694087028503,
0.5392829775810242,
-0.07548359781503677,
0.36292627453804016,
0.08815482258796692,
-0.035146743059158325,
-0.6141467690467834,
0.2799489200115204,
-0.5768123269081116,
0.1605643630027771,
-0.4839884638786316,
0.08826908469200134,
-0.006298423279076815,
0.35373619198799133,
-0.5732280015945435,
0.4155428409576416,
-0.4616641402244568,
-0.0700497105717659,
0.5553281307220459,
-0.05603773519396782,
0.49488258361816406,
-0.07152178883552551,
-0.10854709893465042,
0.1645066738128662,
-0.558296263217926,
0.15885192155838013,
0.1466348022222519,
0.5889350771903992,
-0.2644973397254944,
0.38133177161216736,
-0.21128076314926147,
1.079554796218872,
0.2565557658672333,
0.13042724132537842,
0.2903054356575012,
-0.5118517875671387,
-0.39535096287727356,
0.33843106031417847,
0.7461791634559631,
0.06006593629717827,
0.40918901562690735,
-0.49034473299980164,
0.13104349374771118,
-0.11447670310735703,
0.2814406156539917,
-0.9385242462158203,
-0.1014712005853653,
-0.05920976772904396,
-0.12422339618206024,
0.14749309420585632,
-0.15566568076610565,
-0.5632659792900085,
0.03483207896351814,
-0.25469252467155457,
0.4501342475414276,
-0.403414785861969,
-0.42658519744873047,
0.28937116265296936,
-0.1709134876728058,
0.43817126750946045,
0.11767764389514923,
-1.1896687746047974,
0.25287118554115295,
0.43691930174827576,
0.5570372939109802,
-0.2540013790130615,
-0.5653972029685974,
-0.5273491144180298,
0.16790050268173218,
-0.43097585439682007,
0.7694339156150818,
-0.5622994899749756,
-0.19110657274723053,
0.03469199687242508,
0.3938642740249634,
-0.6341646909713745,
-0.6529037356376648,
0.2398902326822281,
-0.3450620770454407,
0.2532323896884918,
-0.2767341434955597,
-0.35055842995643616,
-0.4853726029396057,
0.18091803789138794,
-0.5484783053398132,
0.6232314705848694,
0.09875552356243134,
-0.13276544213294983,
0.5057304501533508,
-0.6181522011756897,
-0.7624828219413757,
0.02344256266951561,
0.07033492624759674,
-0.062448352575302124,
0.3942074477672577,
0.26682722568511963,
0.4750288426876068,
0.04226262867450714,
0.2714259624481201,
-0.1190975233912468,
-0.4836232662200928,
0.11129486560821533,
-0.3936484456062317,
0.6556325554847717,
-0.08945437520742416,
-0.4188041090965271,
0.002511546015739441,
-0.8128690123558044,
-0.3855818808078766,
-0.0077986023388803005,
-0.5325595736503601,
-0.43920111656188965,
-0.22964924573898315,
0.13121740520000458,
0.4701186418533325,
-0.1301323026418686,
-0.6239071488380432,
0.06636492908000946,
-0.27814850211143494,
-0.002799931913614273,
0.5298505425453186,
-0.40159404277801514,
0.9708905816078186,
-0.21097292006015778,
0.5621883869171143,
0.17556366324424744,
-0.28911665081977844,
-0.3738185465335846,
-0.2603268027305603,
-0.9100385308265686,
-0.12739524245262146,
0.22647438943386078,
0.47616806626319885,
-0.976041316986084,
0.1877141147851944,
-0.46633002161979675,
-0.5407114028930664,
-0.7317410707473755,
0.39994335174560547,
0.4424993693828583,
0.5828161239624023,
0.3807857632637024,
-0.23698754608631134,
-0.499551922082901,
-0.9228901267051697,
-0.6025198698043823,
-0.08211705088615417,
-0.023072853684425354,
0.32211703062057495,
0.10712138563394547,
-0.13980762660503387,
0.7037909030914307,
-0.0892147570848465,
-0.4027844965457916,
-0.6346970796585083,
-0.06567728519439697,
0.3447180986404419,
0.49299344420433044,
0.8902876377105713,
-0.46217605471611023,
-0.8353721499443054,
0.5049646496772766,
-0.7671800255775452,
-0.004695107229053974,
-0.3932356834411621,
-0.020468687638640404,
0.4391154646873474,
0.3106565773487091,
-0.3679579198360443,
0.16553448140621185,
0.9027099013328552,
-0.2968425750732422,
0.38659289479255676,
-0.1969165951013565,
0.0846465528011322,
-0.8741135597229004,
0.23839765787124634,
0.010045826435089111,
-0.03543335199356079,
-1.3122516870498657,
-0.17728732526302338,
0.2008182853460312,
0.04321454465389252,
-0.8637531399726868,
0.9670756459236145,
-0.2856254577636719,
-0.06313609331846237,
-0.3551033139228821,
-0.017369547858834267,
0.16375502943992615,
0.4694019854068756,
0.24317191541194916,
0.642555296421051,
0.6637192368507385,
-0.5354012846946716,
-0.1311522126197815,
0.24680759012699127,
-0.12811295688152313,
0.731412410736084,
-0.5244075059890747,
0.02209954708814621,
-0.18559309840202332,
0.08208359032869339,
-0.9504783749580383,
0.1533338576555252,
0.22679874300956726,
-0.25191977620124817,
0.5276682376861572,
-0.33723247051239014,
-0.08711660653352737,
0.1107666939496994,
-0.09880270808935165,
0.7498216032981873,
0.32364293932914734,
-0.516240119934082,
0.8730586171150208,
0.026889730244874954,
0.018692027777433395,
-0.663252055644989,
-1.0851646661758423,
0.03325482830405235,
-0.14474926888942719,
-0.32238954305648804,
0.1533995419740677,
-0.13529786467552185,
-0.03795721381902695,
0.1904258280992508,
-0.26933524012565613,
-0.20426739752292633,
0.06229545176029205,
0.15244516730308533,
0.36113595962524414,
-0.5001162886619568,
-0.12813739478588104,
0.05819232761859894,
-0.18731515109539032,
0.02645760588347912,
-0.1768495887517929,
0.336925745010376,
-0.08414433151483536,
-0.2824822664260864,
-0.3671572208404541,
0.12550346553325653,
0.5594807267189026,
0.05125490576028824,
0.8631063103675842,
0.7885589599609375,
-0.11698881536722183,
0.06946542114019394,
-0.4972597658634186,
0.12390909343957901,
-0.4867970943450928,
0.44452714920043945,
-0.4861934185028076,
-0.8592650890350342,
0.4643477201461792,
0.25625234842300415,
0.19512900710105896,
0.4081616997718811,
0.4969744384288788,
0.2805587649345398,
0.47886157035827637,
0.7023882865905762,
-0.2816631495952606,
0.6532230973243713,
-0.00266505335457623,
0.36987605690956116,
-1.049454689025879,
-0.057777535170316696,
-0.41373905539512634,
-0.45455899834632874,
-0.40368834137916565,
-0.3725748062133789,
-0.3770394027233124,
0.07279569655656815,
0.09375309199094772,
0.7439566254615784,
-0.04144740477204323,
0.4239303171634674,
0.1644010841846466,
-0.34338662028312683,
0.2878895699977875,
-0.028774719685316086,
0.04946637898683548,
0.009934951551258564,
-0.995682954788208,
0.12978868186473846,
0.9910337924957275,
-0.012785876169800758,
0.5498251914978027,
0.23656922578811646,
0.4769228994846344,
-0.2509547472000122,
0.22946856915950775,
-0.8843585252761841,
0.30266374349594116,
-0.4684424102306366,
-0.6445221304893494,
-0.20896582305431366,
-0.4392273724079132,
-1.0514181852340698,
0.5352324843406677,
-0.09256899356842041,
-0.6849076747894287,
0.6427901983261108,
-0.021318361163139343,
-0.16435889899730682,
0.445522665977478,
-0.7361148595809937,
1.0375854969024658,
-0.14757956564426422,
-0.3854246735572815,
-0.16334380209445953,
-0.21148701012134552,
0.193082794547081,
-0.33921852707862854,
0.5071057677268982,
-0.15086524188518524,
0.13679485023021698,
0.619356095790863,
0.1532197743654251,
0.7113134264945984,
-0.18047043681144714,
-0.027431868016719818,
-0.0491357259452343,
0.2874862849712372,
0.248139888048172,
-0.12002278119325638,
-0.4105208218097687,
0.5032011270523071,
-0.3671145439147949,
-0.7908913493156433,
-0.5664190053939819,
0.7082475423812866,
-0.8091148734092712,
-0.6783073544502258,
-0.22816546261310577,
-1.0151913166046143,
-0.09591954201459885,
0.450717568397522,
-0.15752798318862915,
0.384915292263031,
-0.22022788226604462,
0.19064389169216156,
0.27673012018203735,
-0.24183142185211182,
0.7516012191772461,
0.9544658660888672,
-0.168110191822052,
-0.06740130484104156,
1.1384817361831665,
0.06689774245023727,
0.7253027558326721,
0.5479992032051086,
0.15222902595996857,
0.08314583450555801,
-0.8219554424285889,
-0.8190014958381653,
0.338016539812088,
-0.662020742893219,
0.19210046529769897,
-0.5872613787651062,
-0.21479898691177368,
-0.40540775656700134,
-0.5813167691230774,
-0.3851724863052368,
-0.3021632730960846,
-0.2836126983165741,
-0.16084906458854675,
0.1379099190235138,
0.6068955063819885,
-0.15560422837734222,
0.2965201437473297,
-0.8721156120300293,
0.34105467796325684,
0.4152147173881531,
0.3004598915576935,
-0.02474900893867016,
-0.6400309801101685,
-0.5503228306770325,
-0.09735298156738281,
0.20083266496658325,
-0.3798885643482208,
0.268063485622406,
0.5488191246986389,
0.8722744584083557,
0.41282910108566284,
-0.11807610094547272,
0.920362114906311,
-0.6222814917564392,
0.559601902961731,
0.13823305070400238,
-0.8823176622390747,
0.15248170495033264,
-0.260738343000412,
0.9647245407104492,
0.831352949142456,
0.3291325271129608,
-0.6891733407974243,
-0.3068169951438904,
-0.09683885425329208,
-0.7662132382392883,
0.9995892643928528,
-0.05563482642173767,
0.33974260091781616,
0.0658547431230545,
0.16478204727172852,
0.37476757168769836,
-0.036078065633773804,
-0.7501742839813232,
-0.3498173952102661,
-0.17900210618972778,
0.1317582130432129,
-0.4557831585407257,
0.013514346443116665,
0.22720132768154144,
-0.3336321711540222,
0.5535009503364563,
-0.3797896206378937,
-0.049131639301776886,
0.05384993553161621,
-0.5836847424507141,
-0.42544853687286377,
0.5344228744506836,
0.5089258551597595,
0.6396934390068054,
-0.18875393271446228,
0.002837568987160921,
0.49907252192497253,
-0.3330211639404297,
0.02867911010980606,
0.15602444112300873,
-0.23511694371700287,
0.2632700204849243,
0.49082720279693604,
0.9901500344276428,
0.6158198714256287,
-0.5847049355506897,
0.15894359350204468,
-0.22073546051979065,
-0.29028892517089844,
0.1402527242898941,
0.03461511805653572,
0.1398690789937973,
-0.07885179668664932,
0.2557528018951416,
0.46331122517585754,
0.0017727607628330588,
-0.7364674210548401,
0.17055252194404602,
0.5378997325897217,
-0.8717525005340576,
-0.6242793798446655,
0.33193016052246094,
0.11305384337902069,
-0.298302561044693,
0.37512627243995667,
0.11418028175830841,
-0.4672737419605255,
0.44790366291999817,
0.7615906596183777,
0.7650399208068848,
-0.5826758146286011,
0.018087686970829964,
0.41367143392562866,
0.39231976866722107,
0.27754247188568115,
-0.16398870944976807,
-0.05694211646914482,
-0.8586475253105164,
-0.751311182975769,
-0.569386899471283,
-0.27736014127731323,
-0.21772384643554688,
-0.7583332657814026,
0.24715006351470947,
-0.011975382454693317,
0.4204722046852112,
0.009237374179065228,
-0.2857836186885834,
-0.9928499460220337,
0.02430117130279541,
0.3285841941833496,
0.7780176997184753,
-1.079157829284668,
1.1893328428268433,
0.6464386582374573,
0.05248195305466652,
-0.5760995745658875,
-0.18189562857151031,
0.0033426997251808643,
-0.8732722401618958,
0.3770279288291931,
0.1925133764743805,
0.145356222987175,
-0.11600246280431747,
0.6193951964378357,
-0.7835572361946106,
0.9053840041160583,
0.4394780099391937,
-0.6901111602783203,
-0.07105658948421478,
0.6120617389678955,
0.505192220211029,
-0.32873645424842834,
0.46271440386772156,
0.6743982434272766,
0.5299081206321716,
0.11951536685228348,
-1.1341228485107422,
0.324483186006546,
-0.2207433432340622,
-0.18227452039718628,
0.24025613069534302,
-0.3187917470932007,
0.8413304090499878,
0.0590716190636158,
-0.13661955296993256,
-0.32396262884140015,
0.36061859130859375,
-0.08817513287067413,
0.13263100385665894,
0.526591956615448,
0.5591795444488525,
0.1539040058851242,
0.19415012001991272,
0.9327921867370605,
-0.22709570825099945,
0.09248362481594086,
1.0942734479904175,
-0.28634530305862427,
0.9220871925354004,
0.6462437510490417,
-0.08095972239971161,
0.5592078566551208,
0.07584968209266663,
0.05788254365324974,
0.4718683958053589,
-0.1283591091632843,
-0.15095990896224976,
-0.089485302567482,
-0.20531241595745087,
-0.3698406517505646,
0.3331838548183441,
0.2949647903442383,
-0.13514482975006104,
-0.48490628600120544,
0.07187986373901367,
0.03153643757104874,
-0.17122673988342285,
-0.2002931386232376,
0.9905802011489868,
0.055235106498003006,
-0.8009387850761414,
0.7013394832611084,
-0.44118887186050415,
0.9597973227500916,
-0.5309301018714905,
0.1524808406829834,
-0.28100407123565674,
0.3404353857040405,
-0.44552361965179443,
-0.6516134142875671,
0.8343825340270996,
-0.291581392288208,
-0.1633836179971695,
-0.23403608798980713,
0.7613660097122192,
-0.5794532895088196,
-0.6667517423629761,
0.8427917957305908,
0.7064327001571655,
-0.0186749380081892,
0.030286896973848343,
-0.5665748715400696,
-0.08912868797779083,
0.10152565687894821,
-0.17433898150920868,
0.8567208051681519,
0.3616357147693634,
0.26815128326416016,
0.2534680962562561,
0.8453367352485657,
0.014870013110339642,
0.16192303597927094,
-0.024890290573239326,
0.7839066982269287,
-0.5020123720169067,
0.021030163392424583,
-0.9620461463928223,
0.6816133856773376,
0.26932409405708313,
-0.1023128479719162,
0.9549382925033569,
0.6057254076004028,
1.0507972240447998,
0.008704336360096931,
0.8232054114341736,
-0.06668886542320251,
-0.16161082684993744,
-0.24379754066467285,
0.8012300729751587,
-0.722618043422699,
0.17630568146705627,
-0.15152901411056519,
-0.9972938299179077,
-0.4574955403804779,
0.17722256481647491,
-0.40172168612480164,
-0.37142759561538696,
0.602543830871582,
0.5007508993148804,
-0.26255130767822266,
-0.3043450713157654,
0.7293000817298889,
0.13101188838481903,
0.47487667202949524,
0.6283521056175232,
0.3160021901130676,
-0.5856046080589294,
0.7722980380058289,
-0.5810836553573608,
0.03203121945261955,
-0.2714773416519165,
-0.7967909574508667,
-1.1507755517959595,
-0.28411251306533813,
-0.30028802156448364,
0.06533437967300415,
0.1630295217037201,
0.45709747076034546,
0.6220598816871643,
-1.0797665119171143,
-0.5774102807044983,
-0.055641576647758484,
0.36768412590026855,
-0.2881356179714203,
-0.2843635380268097,
0.12272823601961136,
-0.4851224422454834,
-0.8701899647712708,
0.6720923781394958,
0.48516571521759033,
-0.2749561369419098,
0.040406592190265656,
-0.09539441019296646,
-0.39873582124710083,
0.05597348511219025,
0.6181249022483826,
0.5527015328407288,
-0.8094841837882996,
-0.29331839084625244,
0.20539793372154236,
0.22970539331436157,
0.3451564311981201,
0.73359215259552,
-1.0487985610961914,
0.7209693789482117,
0.49403631687164307,
0.8758801817893982,
0.39289751648902893,
-0.33039242029190063,
0.9514893889427185,
-0.48711976408958435,
0.3822706341743469,
-0.19749997556209564,
0.5284309387207031,
0.3654155731201172,
-0.20159299671649933,
0.38460874557495117,
-0.03452384099364281,
-0.3714280128479004,
-0.643186092376709,
-0.01835533417761326,
-0.8705382943153381,
-0.47018617391586304,
1.0650957822799683,
-0.2967497408390045,
-0.33038046956062317,
-0.4152401089668274,
0.03606624901294708,
0.19810830056667328,
-0.2801748216152191,
0.4436458647251129,
0.6144534349441528,
-0.09394653886556625,
-0.3398018479347229,
-0.6118772625923157,
0.15254054963588715,
0.7401049137115479,
-0.63759446144104,
-0.000012637946383620147,
0.04168661683797836,
0.4749426543712616,
0.26532137393951416,
0.41468071937561035,
0.22436529397964478,
0.36737680435180664,
-0.09378968179225922,
0.12644296884536743,
-0.03858008608222008,
-0.07052673399448395,
-0.9270172119140625,
-0.08384499698877335,
0.058163609355688095,
0.019374260678887367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00898v1 | An Early Categorization of Prompt Injection Attacks on Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T19:52:00 | 2024-01-31T19:52:00 | Sippo Rossi, Alisia Marianne Michel, Raghava Rao Mukkamala, Jason Bennett Thatcher | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models and AI chatbots have been at the forefront of
democratizing artificial intelligence. However, the releases of ChatGPT and
other similar tools have been followed by growing concerns regarding the
difficulty of controlling large language models and their outputs. Currently,
we are witnessing a cat-and-mouse game where users attempt to misuse the models
with a novel attack called prompt injections. In contrast, the developers
attempt to discover the vulnerabilities and block the attacks simultaneously.
In this paper, we provide an overview of these emergent threats and present a
categorization of prompt injections, which can guide future research on prompt
injections and act as a checklist of vulnerabilities in the development of LLM
interfaces. Moreover, based on previous literature and our own empirical
research, we discuss the implications of prompt injections to LLM end users,
developers, and researchers. | [
-0.34069064259529114,
-1.2884495258331299,
0.5966632962226868,
0.10069390386343002,
0.14446081221103668,
0.17176233232021332,
0.09612070024013519,
-0.522925615310669,
-0.2942948043346405,
0.7811912298202515,
-0.45989227294921875,
-0.2809363901615143,
-0.7198319435119629,
0.06915857642889023,
-0.5201806426048279,
0.7891473174095154,
0.10063012689352036,
-0.11212596297264099,
-0.16406984627246857,
0.3577481806278229,
-0.7056792974472046,
-0.8132584095001221,
-0.8900432586669922,
-0.08371593803167343,
0.7654769420623779,
0.028563888743519783,
0.8978033065795898,
0.27948108315467834,
0.6566385626792908,
0.41001996397972107,
-0.10741215944290161,
-0.2669358551502228,
-0.0909174233675003,
0.17563451826572418,
0.016584305092692375,
-0.6792864799499512,
-0.19292792677879333,
0.02624063566327095,
0.14117781817913055,
0.5560193061828613,
0.017749277874827385,
-0.08143683522939682,
-0.09301415830850601,
0.18108659982681274,
-0.3926725387573242,
-0.10674944519996643,
-0.5973025560379028,
0.21100853383541107,
-0.45960626006126404,
-0.30833330750465393,
-0.7611969709396362,
-0.22395841777324677,
0.038223862648010254,
-0.2752237915992737,
-0.23206187784671783,
0.34056875109672546,
0.55030357837677,
0.19806651771068573,
-0.47036051750183105,
-0.49735361337661743,
-0.4431537687778473,
0.41711410880088806,
-0.5145226120948792,
0.004363656044006348,
0.060511138290166855,
0.7562313079833984,
-0.9614747762680054,
-0.5304535031318665,
-0.5253809094429016,
-0.3837589621543884,
-0.15028239786624908,
-0.32505229115486145,
-0.6776427626609802,
0.39986786246299744,
0.36215877532958984,
0.036007110029459,
-0.6845910549163818,
0.6166130900382996,
-0.17167368531227112,
-0.26015540957450867,
0.4870396852493286,
0.37960824370384216,
1.032629370689392,
-0.21017473936080933,
-0.5665978193283081,
0.38517406582832336,
-0.9606476426124573,
0.12918323278427124,
0.6414546966552734,
0.36295652389526367,
-0.19138093292713165,
0.6983765959739685,
-0.02451416477560997,
0.8097879886627197,
-0.05693738907575607,
0.016745921224355698,
-0.2887345850467682,
-0.23809894919395447,
-0.06635478883981705,
-0.16074992716312408,
1.0360703468322754,
0.22807151079177856,
0.3118084967136383,
0.08568788319826126,
-0.3067127466201782,
-0.3451840877532959,
0.05908828601241112,
-0.5391106605529785,
-0.17851094901561737,
0.4252825975418091,
-0.2440609484910965,
-0.4282027781009674,
-0.2108703851699829,
-0.6748586893081665,
-0.8673165440559387,
0.14998815953731537,
0.2889210283756256,
-0.06292489171028137,
-0.19510482251644135,
-0.004014717414975166,
0.006975602358579636,
0.25390681624412537,
0.4611658751964569,
-0.6021217703819275,
0.08170609921216965,
0.9421625137329102,
0.6963260173797607,
-0.31585031747817993,
-0.13853459060192108,
-0.55189448595047,
-0.09741997718811035,
-0.08116389811038971,
0.9277223944664001,
-0.5151138305664062,
-0.6962751150131226,
0.28434357047080994,
-0.039648864418268204,
0.33399298787117004,
-0.43059760332107544,
0.16309991478919983,
-0.5982617735862732,
0.4074486792087555,
0.12220794707536697,
-0.36024361848831177,
0.028682919219136238,
0.2725619971752167,
-0.35224416851997375,
0.6574334502220154,
-0.02466784231364727,
-0.6524648070335388,
0.06393179297447205,
-0.48898962140083313,
-0.21342769265174866,
0.39803192019462585,
-0.19764402508735657,
0.073504738509655,
-0.11675822734832764,
-0.027162862941622734,
0.6397695541381836,
-0.3165094554424286,
0.43374210596084595,
-0.18448801338672638,
-0.0451471172273159,
0.5915846824645996,
-0.45872458815574646,
1.0744993686676025,
0.25743699073791504,
0.01186266541481018,
0.34214311838150024,
-0.5573150515556335,
-0.17431014776229858,
-0.1223863735795021,
-0.12094065546989441,
-0.19378948211669922,
-0.00788333360105753,
-0.2198139876127243,
0.28492113947868347,
0.30891403555870056,
-0.17466042935848236,
0.3044945001602173,
-0.3494412899017334,
0.7184341549873352,
0.8955841064453125,
0.4381037652492523,
0.3571251630783081,
-0.13907906413078308,
0.7839211225509644,
0.18951711058616638,
0.6110388040542603,
-0.6289957165718079,
-0.8315272331237793,
-0.41041868925094604,
-0.43235763907432556,
0.10973252356052399,
0.941379964351654,
-0.9074522256851196,
0.4979914724826813,
0.27876797318458557,
-0.8034019470214844,
-0.19133247435092926,
-0.03625193610787392,
0.29791074991226196,
0.22242775559425354,
0.1541789174079895,
0.1694672405719757,
-0.20559866726398468,
-0.926412045955658,
-0.27756834030151367,
-0.4586527943611145,
-0.31084102392196655,
0.3192231059074402,
0.31196802854537964,
-0.32545000314712524,
0.8411819338798523,
-0.3656350076198578,
0.1490529626607895,
-0.22005756199359894,
0.09567765146493912,
0.40482425689697266,
0.6192840337753296,
0.38116416335105896,
-0.4290916621685028,
-0.3832567632198334,
0.1322150081396103,
-0.5867440700531006,
-0.35390710830688477,
-0.37416505813598633,
-0.14301203191280365,
-0.19782570004463196,
0.7890332341194153,
-0.8926083445549011,
0.33671608567237854,
0.22525472939014435,
-0.24108274281024933,
0.5783953666687012,
0.026788130402565002,
-0.032104410231113434,
-0.8931604623794556,
-0.10893231630325317,
-0.07099638879299164,
0.0023915427736938,
-1.0471653938293457,
0.29999035596847534,
-0.0802110880613327,
-0.286876916885376,
-1.0316336154937744,
0.9222230315208435,
-0.2718616724014282,
0.09861424565315247,
-0.08589526265859604,
-0.03944776952266693,
-0.09294431656599045,
0.08979857712984085,
-0.35139036178588867,
1.0933489799499512,
0.6964305639266968,
-0.6372196078300476,
0.4811302423477173,
0.13984864950180054,
-0.21715866029262543,
0.2826458513736725,
-0.9266574382781982,
0.15839959681034088,
0.11542481929063797,
0.3434995710849762,
-1.0946623086929321,
-0.30288437008857727,
0.6241396069526672,
-0.6059029698371887,
0.44049376249313354,
0.027493126690387726,
-0.48787200450897217,
-0.35171234607696533,
-0.22344845533370972,
0.22032423317432404,
0.5916728377342224,
-0.47479960322380066,
0.40913712978363037,
0.283588707447052,
-0.26929736137390137,
-0.7031833529472351,
-0.45769229531288147,
0.30820244550704956,
-0.3969324827194214,
-0.6851558685302734,
-0.1318582147359848,
-0.037453655153512955,
-0.4732554256916046,
-0.42756175994873047,
0.4698890149593353,
-0.09087682515382767,
0.5670263767242432,
0.29481807351112366,
0.2965517044067383,
-0.047625280916690826,
-0.09701074659824371,
-0.1802331656217575,
-0.2524363100528717,
0.17044392228126526,
0.3054811656475067,
0.6226766109466553,
0.3082202672958374,
-0.6906803846359253,
-0.558110773563385,
0.4583261013031006,
0.34024664759635925,
-0.011853567324578762,
0.5121026635169983,
0.1476532369852066,
-0.15567556023597717,
0.06579603254795074,
-0.6251082420349121,
-0.21277238428592682,
-0.5470503568649292,
0.42952415347099304,
-0.286720871925354,
-0.936967134475708,
0.6823157072067261,
-0.12062299996614456,
0.18773365020751953,
0.25346896052360535,
0.42550480365753174,
0.010642263107001781,
1.197168231010437,
0.5021678805351257,
0.0944535881280899,
0.5308441519737244,
0.36982548236846924,
0.357117235660553,
-0.45399853587150574,
-0.33924978971481323,
-0.8067907691001892,
0.1104826107621193,
-0.7470548152923584,
-0.4368424713611603,
0.19527380168437958,
0.08724086731672287,
-0.31625258922576904,
0.2477661371231079,
-0.4148942232131958,
0.5862932801246643,
0.4945635199546814,
-0.27743759751319885,
0.10153932869434357,
-0.3759695589542389,
0.10747277736663818,
0.24608644843101501,
-0.6211602687835693,
-0.6165194511413574,
0.8526039123535156,
0.4654481112957001,
0.9088723063468933,
0.08683698624372482,
0.46839502453804016,
0.5175478458404541,
0.14509794116020203,
-0.8389915823936462,
0.8118069171905518,
0.165723517537117,
-0.5342189073562622,
-0.1090141087770462,
-0.1795101910829544,
-1.2081470489501953,
-0.01673702523112297,
-0.0801515206694603,
-0.7767531275749207,
0.14203129708766937,
-0.04162421450018883,
-0.5525863766670227,
0.10951536148786545,
-1.023476004600525,
0.7960175275802612,
-0.31001660227775574,
-0.1382356435060501,
0.2568212151527405,
-0.7122530341148376,
0.6537976264953613,
-0.09779738634824753,
0.28317195177078247,
-0.2489713579416275,
-0.1794186532497406,
0.23164516687393188,
-0.33051714301109314,
1.0818201303482056,
0.01382722333073616,
-0.3151801824569702,
0.46743151545524597,
0.2651207745075226,
0.44375836849212646,
0.07461746037006378,
0.2392420619726181,
0.3830004036426544,
-0.12232539057731628,
-0.4216901361942291,
-0.43251463770866394,
0.4630931615829468,
-0.609572172164917,
-1.1930010318756104,
-0.5283932685852051,
-0.2656185030937195,
0.016712866723537445,
0.11042939126491547,
0.1533326804637909,
0.26290246844291687,
-0.2358090877532959,
-0.32256922125816345,
0.7662282586097717,
-0.952427327632904,
0.5496676564216614,
0.41294050216674805,
-0.4334827661514282,
-0.14671587944030762,
0.8558560609817505,
-0.1315889209508896,
0.5646301507949829,
0.32059112191200256,
-0.056306734681129456,
-0.04961114376783371,
-0.8057058453559875,
-0.41675519943237305,
0.03679840266704559,
-0.534829318523407,
-0.4572046101093292,
-0.5989394187927246,
-0.3391016125679016,
-0.34268221259117126,
-0.22388403117656708,
0.0661245658993721,
-0.12378564476966858,
-0.384286493062973,
0.14071406424045563,
0.41128742694854736,
0.7419173121452332,
0.20301225781440735,
0.7804283499717712,
-0.885100781917572,
-0.034345775842666626,
0.3476299047470093,
0.05379587784409523,
-0.14162570238113403,
-0.12955957651138306,
0.16249746084213257,
-0.27666452527046204,
-0.18574179708957672,
-1.0202006101608276,
0.19805307686328888,
-0.19398543238639832,
0.6195603013038635,
0.6256290078163147,
-0.06925900280475616,
0.2533113658428192,
-0.8155542612075806,
1.1995443105697632,
0.41689547896385193,
-0.63663649559021,
0.583041787147522,
-0.28387078642845154,
0.2818850576877594,
0.1266544759273529,
0.39880335330963135,
-0.8205603361129761,
-0.5158988237380981,
-0.3973929286003113,
-0.7601535320281982,
0.45438870787620544,
-0.051665473729372025,
0.4471779465675354,
-0.4690417945384979,
0.11731273680925369,
0.3158802092075348,
0.2564047574996948,
-0.4004034996032715,
-0.17990201711654663,
0.23475202918052673,
0.11039133369922638,
0.18360619246959686,
-0.41885000467300415,
-0.029213812202215195,
0.12596380710601807,
0.33802834153175354,
0.19817565381526947,
0.1482180505990982,
-0.1885235458612442,
-0.08082739263772964,
0.15847477316856384,
0.4397066831588745,
0.5399305820465088,
0.2843964099884033,
0.24208761751651764,
0.3550315201282501,
-0.17676183581352234,
-0.2589617073535919,
0.268658846616745,
-0.04662363976240158,
-0.32334816455841064,
-0.16451239585876465,
0.5173719525337219,
0.6859391927719116,
0.0214716587215662,
-0.9428389072418213,
0.5866420865058899,
0.016425350680947304,
0.35791945457458496,
-0.42896369099617004,
0.3114457428455353,
-0.358252614736557,
0.3200879991054535,
0.2354012280702591,
0.04469290003180504,
0.1786476969718933,
-0.49498021602630615,
0.06223496049642563,
0.7277973890304565,
-0.3460708260536194,
-0.347780704498291,
0.31769394874572754,
0.28846901655197144,
-0.662982702255249,
0.3087291121482849,
0.053915731608867645,
-0.5015676617622375,
0.6745692491531372,
0.22723443806171417,
0.8832508325576782,
-0.6065962910652161,
0.12357649207115173,
0.3186914622783661,
0.42411544919013977,
0.20981086790561676,
0.050818830728530884,
0.28899458050727844,
-0.561453104019165,
-0.3471277356147766,
-0.2738194167613983,
-0.43769827485084534,
0.08393587917089462,
-0.14474761486053467,
0.556205153465271,
-0.5613470673561096,
-0.2798391580581665,
0.112623430788517,
-0.38513004779815674,
-0.5500986576080322,
-0.46386608481407166,
0.04894464462995529,
1.0123988389968872,
-0.5910798907279968,
0.39766329526901245,
0.4523738622665405,
-0.30528002977371216,
-0.26633748412132263,
-0.30933070182800293,
0.17287757992744446,
-1.0081801414489746,
0.7422970533370972,
0.14105872809886932,
0.3947613835334778,
-0.056854043155908585,
-0.6897655129432678,
-0.5553434491157532,
0.5428794026374817,
0.08721360564231873,
-0.392560213804245,
-0.13277402520179749,
0.273229718208313,
0.31592556834220886,
-0.30032768845558167,
0.5392126441001892,
0.5158225297927856,
0.5005077719688416,
-0.10502311587333679,
-0.7921599745750427,
0.07064460217952728,
-0.020837463438510895,
0.08354833722114563,
0.214000403881073,
-0.40833771228790283,
0.8380129933357239,
-0.15197792649269104,
-0.48313429951667786,
0.16346871852874756,
0.4874606430530548,
0.06296942383050919,
0.12463457137346268,
0.32582446932792664,
0.012667966075241566,
0.5354058146476746,
-0.09386569261550903,
1.1060584783554077,
-0.03217408433556557,
-0.3723546862602234,
0.8948861360549927,
-0.28680160641670227,
0.654938280582428,
0.6468958258628845,
-0.4443415701389313,
0.08979382365942001,
0.9286806583404541,
-0.01119354646652937,
0.16307786107063293,
0.5795122981071472,
-0.4061015844345093,
-0.019356491044163704,
-0.33257555961608887,
-0.5523748993873596,
0.16351722180843353,
0.6707075834274292,
0.06937433779239655,
-0.2423616200685501,
0.3392705023288727,
0.3332144320011139,
-0.181284561753273,
-0.2252117395401001,
0.9581915736198425,
0.014513145200908184,
-0.3384835124015808,
0.3068365454673767,
-0.15608812868595123,
0.7819774746894836,
-0.5526200532913208,
-0.03351627662777901,
-0.3372223675251007,
-0.38269901275634766,
-0.03180380165576935,
-0.9611908793449402,
-0.09555020183324814,
0.01660826802253723,
0.15430620312690735,
-0.07024137675762177,
0.6101369857788086,
-0.2213543951511383,
-0.08224772661924362,
0.04717814177274704,
0.6952304840087891,
0.26008322834968567,
-0.05885399132966995,
-0.7283172607421875,
0.19285538792610168,
-0.13710564374923706,
-0.3597792387008667,
0.4549606442451477,
0.5381357669830322,
-0.2548811137676239,
0.9720139503479004,
0.73650723695755,
-0.06640373915433884,
0.3544401526451111,
-0.2533392608165741,
0.7987146377563477,
-0.4703105390071869,
-0.09777259081602097,
-1.1975034475326538,
0.4683646559715271,
-0.0038262964226305485,
-0.17547525465488434,
0.8124309182167053,
0.23083026707172394,
0.3166826367378235,
0.09763942658901215,
0.6396571397781372,
-0.05283157154917717,
0.3175748288631439,
-0.428079217672348,
0.6227143406867981,
-0.2506674826145172,
0.465070515871048,
-0.19136984646320343,
-0.6364827752113342,
-0.3673062026500702,
-0.11781208962202072,
-0.18877434730529785,
-0.08918028324842453,
0.49477076530456543,
0.9119400978088379,
0.2879939377307892,
-0.2735884189605713,
0.4596075713634491,
0.3778056502342224,
0.5966443419456482,
0.5768492817878723,
1.3159325122833252,
0.02216959185898304,
0.33646926283836365,
-0.04715793952345848,
-0.35251858830451965,
-0.37516433000564575,
-0.9047755599021912,
-1.1960022449493408,
-0.46308282017707825,
-0.19488951563835144,
-0.42933622002601624,
0.06270594149827957,
0.7844800353050232,
0.21536025404930115,
-0.8138380646705627,
-0.060332391411066055,
-0.01161170843988657,
0.5104482173919678,
0.2879868447780609,
-0.25352585315704346,
0.13840943574905396,
-0.39472371339797974,
-0.651814341545105,
0.35756272077560425,
0.31237903237342834,
0.4480851888656616,
-0.731122612953186,
0.25222888588905334,
-0.16531167924404144,
0.17556658387184143,
0.5090194940567017,
0.5596978068351746,
-0.9764940142631531,
-0.43174365162849426,
-0.003998292610049248,
-0.2543371021747589,
-0.13138841092586517,
0.7586867809295654,
-0.6538913249969482,
0.2807181775569916,
0.5691584348678589,
0.9440799951553345,
-0.46368199586868286,
-0.3326559066772461,
0.7197162508964539,
-0.5256500244140625,
0.3950407803058624,
0.08924530446529388,
0.21057520806789398,
0.16481710970401764,
-0.7158295512199402,
0.369154155254364,
-0.04830169305205345,
-0.40960001945495605,
-1.1491236686706543,
0.7343490123748779,
-0.939434826374054,
-0.22479383647441864,
1.0711143016815186,
-0.15435007214546204,
-0.389376699924469,
-0.31511613726615906,
-0.5337457656860352,
-0.08284152299165726,
-0.47061383724212646,
0.6785295009613037,
0.8334493637084961,
0.006080762017518282,
-0.24430254101753235,
-1.0170387029647827,
0.6135467290878296,
0.027730613946914673,
-1.053830623626709,
0.061138447374105453,
0.5025860667228699,
-0.24433177709579468,
0.0839044526219368,
0.40491077303886414,
-0.08776379376649857,
0.23821382224559784,
-0.16914179921150208,
0.19097457826137543,
0.0323113352060318,
-0.21763412654399872,
-0.2927871346473694,
0.22645419836044312,
0.17830996215343475,
0.13617262244224548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00143v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00143v1 | Making a Long Story Short in Conversation Modeling | 2024-01-31T19:48:58 | 2024-01-31T19:48:58 | Yufei Tao, Tiernan Mines, Ameeta Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Conversation systems accommodate diverse users with unique personalities and
distinct writing styles. Within the domain of multi-turn dialogue modeling,
this work studies the impact of varied utterance lengths on the quality of
subsequent responses generated by conversation models. Using GPT-3 as the base
model, multiple dialogue datasets, and several metrics, we conduct a thorough
exploration of this aspect of conversational models. Our analysis sheds light
on the complex relationship between utterance lengths and the quality of
follow-up responses generated by dialogue systems. Empirical findings suggests
that, for certain types of conversations, utterance lengths can be reduced by
up to 72% without any noticeable difference in the quality of follow-up
responses. | [
-0.4843744933605194,
-0.6835784912109375,
1.073115348815918,
0.12834344804286957,
-0.3143887221813202,
0.08413009345531464,
-0.10463818907737732,
-0.847676157951355,
0.1967654824256897,
0.7410441040992737,
-0.5144978165626526,
-0.20303325355052948,
-0.45287078619003296,
0.023009156808257103,
-0.4185446798801422,
1.2384731769561768,
0.28131479024887085,
-0.23363372683525085,
0.08440383523702621,
-0.2774890959262848,
-0.771508514881134,
-0.7021640539169312,
-0.627329409122467,
-0.21822728216648102,
0.6005333065986633,
0.37827572226524353,
1.244397759437561,
0.19984106719493866,
0.4111883342266083,
0.15860497951507568,
-0.1250709742307663,
-0.1094667837023735,
-0.7831315398216248,
0.3070051372051239,
0.27168700098991394,
-0.4506475031375885,
-0.3943640887737274,
-0.11283131688833237,
0.6623966693878174,
0.8058277368545532,
-0.13981106877326965,
-0.05474484711885452,
0.21948513388633728,
0.5720526576042175,
-0.0778021588921547,
-0.05466831102967262,
-0.1643173098564148,
-0.2193259447813034,
-0.1577063798904419,
-0.04509001597762108,
-0.3734714984893799,
-0.3298706114292145,
0.7725134491920471,
-0.33039188385009766,
0.2659420073032379,
-0.043228596448898315,
0.7218176126480103,
-0.3152868449687958,
-0.4090866446495056,
-0.45780131220817566,
-1.1073248386383057,
0.7288413047790527,
-1.1126189231872559,
0.11093100160360336,
0.06808628141880035,
0.29700759053230286,
0.07169743627309799,
-0.37940025329589844,
-0.6809126734733582,
-0.5346111059188843,
-0.4791903495788574,
0.06367988884449005,
0.03492862731218338,
0.28079596161842346,
0.31523188948631287,
0.2780257761478424,
-0.5175700783729553,
0.007125891279429197,
-0.7292037606239319,
0.15349926054477692,
0.5377374887466431,
0.7312747836112976,
0.1060090959072113,
-0.271605521440506,
0.003653228748589754,
0.07608140259981155,
-0.7287517189979553,
0.11017047613859177,
0.7941431403160095,
0.35141417384147644,
-0.12210626900196075,
0.6931284070014954,
-0.31197354197502136,
0.720678985118866,
-0.0726206973195076,
-0.3251434564590454,
-0.11946029216051102,
-0.6738304495811462,
-0.06290435791015625,
-0.317399799823761,
0.8550610542297363,
0.5817806720733643,
0.2629353702068329,
-0.022822821512818336,
-0.05123459920287132,
-0.02394368313252926,
0.05301447957754135,
-1.0173132419586182,
-0.03516697883605957,
0.2305370569229126,
-0.527679979801178,
-0.11578183621168137,
0.06300853937864304,
-0.6599330306053162,
-0.11956360936164856,
-0.4092229902744293,
0.11484009027481079,
-0.551319420337677,
-0.026411687955260277,
0.3175985813140869,
0.009374253451824188,
0.23697012662887573,
0.3902522325515747,
-0.7574836015701294,
0.5674274563789368,
0.5922942757606506,
1.173279881477356,
-0.2760677933692932,
-0.21377216279506683,
-0.29077014327049255,
0.024694664403796196,
-0.3258938491344452,
0.5706601142883301,
-0.739678144454956,
-1.1126506328582764,
-0.25406864285469055,
-0.1016228124499321,
0.15236353874206543,
-0.2293948531150818,
0.4764712154865265,
-0.3815141022205353,
0.5587099194526672,
-0.1615530252456665,
-0.4680348336696625,
-0.14835049211978912,
-0.07664424180984497,
-0.5360698699951172,
0.29870450496673584,
0.14613203704357147,
-0.5750883221626282,
0.19673769176006317,
-0.6397365927696228,
-0.6725836396217346,
0.02019667439162731,
0.00018697476480156183,
-0.4167185425758362,
0.32693344354629517,
0.048283521085977554,
0.3536032736301422,
-0.29797786474227905,
0.13515526056289673,
-0.45815446972846985,
-0.429342120885849,
0.3852761685848236,
-0.529517650604248,
0.3941037058830261,
0.15912854671478271,
-0.053818248212337494,
0.08630386739969254,
-0.8049653172492981,
-0.018658455461263657,
-0.16746672987937927,
-0.4178537130355835,
-0.07377520948648453,
0.0910709872841835,
-0.0506073422729969,
0.29336318373680115,
-0.26690229773521423,
-0.7629167437553406,
0.14222322404384613,
-0.3279350697994232,
0.4109826982021332,
0.5549460649490356,
0.24742722511291504,
0.3094783127307892,
-0.6712219715118408,
0.5512996315956116,
-0.1128482073545456,
0.2050231695175171,
-0.565070390701294,
-0.670257031917572,
-0.8351123332977295,
-0.07552852481603622,
0.005727002862840891,
0.4574960768222809,
-0.5512676239013672,
-0.02827392891049385,
-0.4506872296333313,
-0.38763782382011414,
-0.3401716947555542,
-0.18084238469600677,
0.3801957070827484,
0.2754974961280823,
0.3035476803779602,
-0.4461365342140198,
-0.14802873134613037,
-0.9567272067070007,
-0.4046120345592499,
-0.4653032124042511,
-0.43127554655075073,
0.3581405282020569,
0.409056156873703,
0.0776253193616867,
1.224352478981018,
-0.6462706923484802,
-0.02053217962384224,
-0.2955303192138672,
0.23459811508655548,
0.25810015201568604,
0.29441460967063904,
0.5736759901046753,
-0.33906322717666626,
-0.6415351629257202,
-0.23269586265087128,
-0.2990320324897766,
0.16200321912765503,
-0.3672611117362976,
0.197967529296875,
-0.06929490715265274,
-0.029869891703128815,
-1.0091397762298584,
0.6518683433532715,
0.4955039918422699,
-0.18480713665485382,
1.0142358541488647,
0.041065678000450134,
0.45741626620292664,
-1.0014785528182983,
-0.24256113171577454,
-0.16571949422359467,
-0.04332306981086731,
-0.9532356858253479,
-0.47576960921287537,
-0.3567391633987427,
-0.41719532012939453,
-0.48069363832473755,
0.41375675797462463,
-0.46069228649139404,
-0.24015149474143982,
-0.20395058393478394,
-0.03698944300413132,
0.27523428201675415,
0.3980397582054138,
0.14259962737560272,
0.8807026147842407,
0.15734171867370605,
-0.7193966507911682,
0.39741021394729614,
0.4629930257797241,
-0.4767237901687622,
0.8487918376922607,
-1.10515558719635,
0.4873436987400055,
0.08115243911743164,
0.4690917730331421,
-1.106170415878296,
-0.38427144289016724,
-0.008597031235694885,
-0.6416815519332886,
-0.06771668046712875,
-0.25305745005607605,
-0.44467321038246155,
-0.6374989151954651,
0.027925042435526848,
0.15476031601428986,
0.46368107199668884,
-0.21149279177188873,
0.46400025486946106,
-0.272659033536911,
-0.8826433420181274,
-0.014780537225306034,
-0.7735638618469238,
0.2504918575286865,
-0.36574697494506836,
-1.0433077812194824,
0.19400447607040405,
-0.2857475280761719,
-0.15619099140167236,
-0.42649737000465393,
0.25843876600265503,
-0.008210454136133194,
-0.15997052192687988,
0.16050603985786438,
0.08048596978187561,
-0.19506286084651947,
0.28211215138435364,
-0.20438545942306519,
0.20256829261779785,
0.03816547989845276,
0.11297532916069031,
0.6181598901748657,
-0.3226906359195709,
-0.5692806243896484,
-0.759480893611908,
0.945728063583374,
0.8199244141578674,
0.040249843150377274,
0.8535673022270203,
0.2373916059732437,
0.10878442227840424,
0.5480337142944336,
-0.45901238918304443,
-0.34614086151123047,
-0.46658068895339966,
0.4150482416152954,
-0.7217094898223877,
-0.8426956534385681,
0.7975026369094849,
0.47276121377944946,
-0.009204579517245293,
0.2597641944885254,
0.414401113986969,
0.012901611626148224,
1.3556255102157593,
0.7122803330421448,
0.040269773453474045,
0.5231627821922302,
0.2460804134607315,
0.6126908659934998,
-0.7461970448493958,
-0.1561487466096878,
-0.4921524226665497,
0.034794166684150696,
-0.4967194199562073,
-0.03671031817793846,
0.1740065962076187,
-0.07281544804573059,
-0.1323547661304474,
0.27012526988983154,
-0.2758503556251526,
0.3994627594947815,
0.37505748867988586,
0.13714976608753204,
0.34038299322128296,
-0.4945399761199951,
0.5135180354118347,
-0.046253595501184464,
-0.3662005066871643,
-0.5781282782554626,
0.8484287261962891,
0.46488651633262634,
0.8823618292808533,
0.4614720046520233,
0.6277147531509399,
0.18582738935947418,
0.07307006418704987,
-0.8056454062461853,
0.2927708923816681,
0.3414769470691681,
-0.4822395443916321,
-0.6916676759719849,
-0.48752543330192566,
-0.8762858510017395,
0.1811441034078598,
0.1952829211950302,
-0.8318390250205994,
-0.012142516672611237,
-0.05746389552950859,
-0.9008379578590393,
0.1510544717311859,
-0.7088037729263306,
0.3726097345352173,
-0.299118310213089,
-0.033501703292131424,
-0.10642508417367935,
-0.829723060131073,
0.42429521679878235,
-0.038920219987630844,
0.02385224588215351,
-0.29041367769241333,
0.4200774133205414,
0.8717474341392517,
-0.6319149136543274,
0.6701319217681885,
0.04010693356394768,
-0.06457486748695374,
0.5823348164558411,
0.2023955136537552,
0.5827588438987732,
0.24642013013362885,
0.2825617492198944,
-0.1241808533668518,
0.09454841166734695,
-0.48225289583206177,
-0.5579759478569031,
0.5238314867019653,
-0.7054651975631714,
-0.711816668510437,
-0.08463476598262787,
-0.4192425012588501,
-0.483672171831131,
-0.011698239482939243,
0.29285240173339844,
0.516140878200531,
-0.4065030813217163,
0.13616639375686646,
0.383884459733963,
-0.28978827595710754,
0.562838613986969,
0.4602155089378357,
-0.13123825192451477,
-0.2867453098297119,
0.45556405186653137,
0.16742302477359772,
0.8998208045959473,
-0.09521321207284927,
0.08668453991413116,
-0.32038450241088867,
-0.5486984848976135,
-0.3323577642440796,
0.2899990975856781,
-0.6873119473457336,
0.05180914327502251,
-0.818945586681366,
-0.061498697847127914,
-0.6053736209869385,
-0.1833268702030182,
-0.3798051178455353,
-0.3858684003353119,
-0.481322318315506,
-0.20989622175693512,
0.398547887802124,
1.1678879261016846,
0.1837601661682129,
0.9946678280830383,
-1.0561996698379517,
0.27817925810813904,
0.5658331513404846,
0.4176904559135437,
0.032744914293289185,
-0.721777081489563,
-0.1420602798461914,
0.25992730259895325,
-0.32505151629447937,
-1.0042766332626343,
0.4310046136379242,
0.30844002962112427,
0.31152063608169556,
0.2472800761461258,
-0.32619550824165344,
0.5754640102386475,
-0.520686149597168,
1.3074642419815063,
0.8125705122947693,
-0.8077995777130127,
0.5054479241371155,
-0.7144696116447449,
0.8155670762062073,
0.38582149147987366,
0.2645282745361328,
-0.9872080087661743,
-0.2836131155490875,
-0.6535389423370361,
-0.7446102499961853,
0.38695091009140015,
0.428070992231369,
0.5298917889595032,
-0.017922135069966316,
0.05729960277676582,
0.36944231390953064,
0.14102792739868164,
-0.4218524396419525,
-0.0736895203590393,
-0.23538681864738464,
0.2502579391002655,
-0.12787990272045135,
-0.6013792157173157,
-0.1263161450624466,
0.128304585814476,
0.3876780867576599,
-0.10511398315429688,
0.4758131802082062,
-0.06462370604276657,
-0.06202763691544533,
0.4112188518047333,
0.7009649872779846,
0.9286488890647888,
0.9038378596305847,
-0.3033978343009949,
-0.37405192852020264,
0.1755712628364563,
-0.2311875969171524,
0.025368407368659973,
-0.051738470792770386,
0.19328142702579498,
0.36365723609924316,
0.2538711130619049,
1.0503259897232056,
-0.1380133032798767,
-0.14768631756305695,
0.4261775612831116,
-0.16581609845161438,
-0.10072783380746841,
0.009823312982916832,
-0.3381144106388092,
0.1381186544895172,
-0.0023748839739710093,
0.43011295795440674,
0.05033201351761818,
0.3786028325557709,
-0.6525884866714478,
0.2778034210205078,
0.034253112971782684,
-0.5591439008712769,
-0.46575671434402466,
0.2675589919090271,
0.5617062449455261,
-0.37148022651672363,
0.7177174687385559,
0.25767281651496887,
-0.4418271481990814,
0.5395715832710266,
0.32636597752571106,
0.6889058351516724,
-0.27151885628700256,
0.35391175746917725,
0.14378531277179718,
-0.12593956291675568,
-0.03179236873984337,
-0.21221287548542023,
0.034152109175920486,
-0.4167912006378174,
-0.5609421730041504,
-0.4478202164173126,
-0.6891803741455078,
0.2399388998746872,
-0.8522867560386658,
0.10233936458826065,
-0.2317853569984436,
-0.4393808841705322,
0.039722587913274765,
-0.17121581733226776,
-0.7878341674804688,
0.19369734823703766,
0.05450735241174698,
0.2863982021808624,
-0.6438584923744202,
0.30507993698120117,
-0.16877833008766174,
-0.456522136926651,
-0.6454357504844666,
-0.10203254222869873,
-0.07504500448703766,
-0.34048521518707275,
0.46628114581108093,
0.42266136407852173,
-0.42186692357063293,
-0.30361777544021606,
-0.39708417654037476,
-0.9404425024986267,
0.6683140397071838,
-0.002629280788823962,
-0.7660194635391235,
-0.20782016217708588,
0.46362489461898804,
0.7764400243759155,
-0.5481641888618469,
0.6050265431404114,
0.9746714234352112,
0.18719328939914703,
0.055202893912792206,
-1.4174742698669434,
-0.20737269520759583,
0.17320425808429718,
0.23986127972602844,
0.08005721867084503,
-0.8266533613204956,
0.8964989185333252,
-0.5018349885940552,
-0.3038047254085541,
0.6239588856697083,
0.6650427579879761,
0.1396029144525528,
-0.07376086711883545,
0.2481156885623932,
0.31486207246780396,
0.41915345191955566,
-0.15299981832504272,
1.1272013187408447,
-0.12275062501430511,
0.3472505807876587,
1.4145283699035645,
-0.30044659972190857,
0.5755499005317688,
0.3513646423816681,
-0.2829873561859131,
0.6062878370285034,
0.7170839309692383,
0.21353363990783691,
0.5082584619522095,
0.4008210301399231,
-0.30458304286003113,
-0.11378699541091919,
0.1373547613620758,
-0.6365174055099487,
0.3520013988018036,
0.425289511680603,
-0.2343643456697464,
0.08119755983352661,
0.16405396163463593,
0.26065438985824585,
-0.2418477088212967,
0.028958121314644814,
0.7441111207008362,
0.24521496891975403,
-0.829549252986908,
0.43069663643836975,
-0.3362017273902893,
0.6384627223014832,
-0.3406916856765747,
0.048541780561208725,
-0.44745978713035583,
-0.030842214822769165,
-0.03325802832841873,
-1.094049096107483,
0.26610931754112244,
-0.24219927191734314,
-0.41433185338974,
0.025124305859208107,
0.4219246804714203,
-0.3982160687446594,
-0.14317795634269714,
0.16987018287181854,
0.602588415145874,
0.21424275636672974,
-0.06376819312572479,
-0.4917329251766205,
0.04614916443824768,
0.003000396303832531,
-0.47365105152130127,
0.13337036967277527,
0.19774304330348969,
0.13901732861995697,
0.75468510389328,
0.660915195941925,
-0.21637272834777832,
0.02273455448448658,
0.3093678653240204,
0.7797108888626099,
-0.7187286615371704,
-0.6581668257713318,
-0.7670802474021912,
0.5023529529571533,
-0.27385565638542175,
-0.37670594453811646,
0.49554529786109924,
0.41901353001594543,
0.5404893755912781,
-0.05849840119481087,
1.1195228099822998,
0.2211737185716629,
1.0090938806533813,
-0.4568537771701813,
0.4476809501647949,
0.008684356696903706,
0.2973688244819641,
-0.2793603837490082,
-0.9646873474121094,
-0.07095792889595032,
0.1373412311077118,
-0.4766175448894501,
0.2230994999408722,
0.7106301784515381,
0.5107050538063049,
0.0755007341504097,
0.24096807837486267,
0.5353055000305176,
-0.019234612584114075,
0.7982664108276367,
0.44577282667160034,
1.1573230028152466,
-0.21519798040390015,
0.8504325747489929,
0.06401713937520981,
0.0681910514831543,
-0.3545263111591339,
-0.4562442898750305,
-0.9297456741333008,
-0.4155077338218689,
-0.006648615933954716,
-0.47840189933776855,
0.18475927412509918,
0.018560903146862984,
0.779546856880188,
-0.6724158525466919,
-0.20515160262584686,
0.14244845509529114,
-0.129566490650177,
0.21472318470478058,
-0.32368603348731995,
0.07597166299819946,
-0.1155051663517952,
-0.4981045424938202,
0.18344752490520477,
0.2938043177127838,
0.550856351852417,
-0.059928297996520996,
-0.2315724790096283,
0.06340843439102173,
0.48848259449005127,
0.6918889284133911,
0.30537402629852295,
-0.964111328125,
-0.7960041761398315,
0.10851558297872543,
-0.08739365637302399,
0.34343183040618896,
1.014892816543579,
-0.5511608719825745,
0.337228387594223,
0.3686602711677551,
0.24948197603225708,
0.7829701900482178,
0.16564232110977173,
0.9529099464416504,
-0.6626277565956116,
-0.19968900084495544,
0.4231241047382355,
0.17878969013690948,
0.5642105937004089,
-0.5027309060096741,
0.26367324590682983,
0.11372571438550949,
-0.7310079336166382,
-0.5810583233833313,
0.5575569272041321,
-0.8805850148200989,
-0.11716239899396896,
1.2684322595596313,
-0.3212200105190277,
0.28584256768226624,
-0.2600324749946594,
-0.4333431124687195,
-0.01175273023545742,
-0.6195175051689148,
0.4378361403942108,
1.0918716192245483,
-0.7244889140129089,
-0.3043043613433838,
-0.4403150975704193,
0.5260645747184753,
0.4391082227230072,
-0.7837290167808533,
0.08781471848487854,
0.7063406705856323,
0.4506698250770569,
0.4720854163169861,
0.706847608089447,
0.08032496273517609,
0.13860109448432922,
0.11775679886341095,
-0.3029051423072815,
0.3186430335044861,
-0.44349515438079834,
0.0030598645098507404,
0.21415245532989502,
0.008662969805300236,
-0.024942869320511818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00126v1 | Common Sense Reasoning for Deep Fake Detection | 2024-01-31T19:11:58 | 2024-01-31T19:11:58 | Yue Zhang, Ben Colman, Ali Shahriyari, Gaurav Bharaj | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | State-of-the-art approaches rely on image-based features extracted via neural
networks for the deepfake detection binary classification. While these
approaches trained in the supervised sense extract likely fake features, they
may fall short in representing unnatural `non-physical' semantic facial
attributes -- blurry hairlines, double eyebrows, rigid eye pupils, or unnatural
skin shading. However, such facial attributes are generally easily perceived by
humans via common sense reasoning. Furthermore, image-based feature extraction
methods that provide visual explanation via saliency maps can be hard to be
interpreted by humans. To address these challenges, we propose the use of
common sense reasoning to model deepfake detection, and extend it to the
Deepfake Detection VQA (DD-VQA) task with the aim to model human intuition in
explaining the reason behind labeling an image as either real or fake. To this
end, we introduce a new dataset that provides answers to the questions related
to the authenticity of an image, along with its corresponding explanations. We
also propose a Vision and Language Transformer-based framework for the DD-VQA
task, incorporating text and image aware feature alignment formulations.
Finally, we evaluate our method on both the performance of deepfake detection
and the quality of the generated explanations. We hope that this task inspires
researchers to explore new avenues for enhancing language-based
interpretability and cross-modality applications in the realm of deepfake
detection. | [
-0.6446869969367981,
-0.9113016128540039,
0.7891928553581238,
-0.09663642197847366,
-0.34862440824508667,
-0.022283563390374184,
0.19379599392414093,
-0.7244832515716553,
0.06275323033332825,
0.5935499668121338,
-0.6633702516555786,
-0.34802594780921936,
-0.4439094364643097,
-0.0037369190249592066,
-0.4054916501045227,
0.5066879391670227,
-0.02626993879675865,
-0.05159071460366249,
-0.10715614259243011,
-0.07128216326236725,
-0.39485964179039,
-0.6194640398025513,
-0.5200693011283875,
-0.19538693130016327,
0.2955203950405121,
0.3062570095062256,
0.8448079228401184,
0.3356708884239197,
0.16255006194114685,
0.3074299097061157,
0.10148249566555023,
0.3076801002025604,
-0.2389458417892456,
-0.2866390347480774,
-0.3334500193595886,
-0.07013442367315292,
-0.3811551332473755,
0.09525349736213684,
0.16484327614307404,
0.49229028820991516,
0.22629956901073456,
-0.27310270071029663,
-0.41863691806793213,
0.45235127210617065,
-0.5703712105751038,
-0.17515063285827637,
-0.565336287021637,
-0.052387408912181854,
-0.053121622651815414,
0.20293733477592468,
-0.11613425612449646,
-0.13686232268810272,
0.10078506916761398,
-0.8159129619598389,
0.5573634505271912,
-0.19629153609275818,
1.1036947965621948,
0.3062325417995453,
-0.4043180048465729,
-0.011172564700245857,
-0.554399311542511,
0.7360509634017944,
-0.4608583450317383,
0.5363287329673767,
0.1920633167028427,
0.5450509786605835,
-0.1707477569580078,
-0.7802759408950806,
-1.3815616369247437,
-0.07466470450162888,
-0.20787934958934784,
0.06266504526138306,
-0.32229721546173096,
-0.011864217929542065,
0.11783132702112198,
0.5279740691184998,
-0.5282062888145447,
0.016060594469308853,
0.006478641647845507,
-0.4713018834590912,
0.7802034020423889,
-0.002787049161270261,
0.4420553743839264,
-0.001709809061139822,
-0.6247618794441223,
-0.04024290293455124,
-0.42592835426330566,
0.09160219877958298,
0.2284749150276184,
-0.0633452981710434,
-0.06698211282491684,
0.2612161636352539,
-0.6493088006973267,
0.5216058492660522,
0.21571841835975647,
0.22181092202663422,
0.25545641779899597,
-0.35332754254341125,
-0.407512903213501,
-0.1306859701871872,
0.5025557279586792,
0.6369239091873169,
0.7594976425170898,
-0.05205586925148964,
-0.24520191550254822,
0.352324903011322,
0.24758362770080566,
-0.6237972974777222,
-0.19217976927757263,
0.15081800520420074,
-0.3508169949054718,
-0.6014012098312378,
0.16410163044929504,
-0.6538790464401245,
-0.37686577439308167,
-0.6917291283607483,
0.6316521167755127,
-0.4743807911872864,
-0.6943511366844177,
0.3645262122154236,
-0.2109687775373459,
0.2867407202720642,
0.7847208380699158,
-0.43132174015045166,
0.3855631947517395,
0.8254641890525818,
0.5763339996337891,
-0.11932898312807083,
-0.2254120260477066,
-0.45993566513061523,
-0.20993643999099731,
-0.18839967250823975,
0.8801071047782898,
-0.29662254452705383,
0.06953351199626923,
-0.15567953884601593,
0.38169464468955994,
0.2039211243391037,
-0.4629216492176056,
0.5043336749076843,
-0.572546124458313,
0.09506735950708389,
-0.4144758880138397,
-0.3591870367527008,
-0.49483340978622437,
0.25608378648757935,
-0.7526894807815552,
0.819632351398468,
0.017681298777461052,
-0.24465793371200562,
0.8218739032745361,
-0.5283288359642029,
-0.6626867651939392,
0.2217327356338501,
-0.1494826227426529,
-0.26377105712890625,
0.24091708660125732,
0.39423078298568726,
0.6918099522590637,
0.021021341904997826,
0.3845498263835907,
-0.3905426561832428,
-0.5830012559890747,
0.5022371411323547,
-0.9227614998817444,
0.9394133687019348,
0.26915910840034485,
-0.7055044770240784,
-0.27366769313812256,
-0.6974208950996399,
-0.12419730424880981,
0.13726887106895447,
-0.015585023909807205,
-0.2674074172973633,
-0.3037484586238861,
0.19102929532527924,
0.09631914645433426,
0.05468255281448364,
-0.5114514827728271,
-0.031500522047281265,
-0.4011152386665344,
0.1305375099182129,
0.6119567155838013,
0.07659107446670532,
0.3873652219772339,
-0.036099180579185486,
0.06491312384605408,
0.4458417594432831,
0.305429607629776,
-0.11630740016698837,
-0.5578952431678772,
-0.5130402445793152,
-0.6185042858123779,
0.11067444086074829,
0.46033838391304016,
-0.8127723336219788,
0.36886322498321533,
-0.17151693999767303,
-0.10653828829526901,
-0.4430762529373169,
0.0684957280755043,
0.43924176692962646,
0.6694703698158264,
0.6099790930747986,
-0.4784521758556366,
-0.24685661494731903,
-1.0757657289505005,
-0.5692270398139954,
0.186182901263237,
0.030489729717373848,
0.12665554881095886,
0.7103269696235657,
-0.23298272490501404,
0.913133978843689,
-0.265863299369812,
-0.10407336056232452,
0.1289324313402176,
0.3266254663467407,
-0.04565826430916786,
0.4681614935398102,
0.5661877393722534,
-1.3507980108261108,
-0.14825069904327393,
-0.1039242148399353,
-0.5804720520973206,
-0.13708560168743134,
-0.2639753520488739,
0.046887099742889404,
0.5727220773696899,
0.43953636288642883,
-0.7365262508392334,
0.8860781788825989,
0.2159365713596344,
-0.5069251656532288,
0.7226462364196777,
0.40481245517730713,
0.5356496572494507,
-0.6115325689315796,
0.09216317534446716,
0.21171095967292786,
-0.38401561975479126,
-0.6743980646133423,
0.09921718388795853,
-0.3185259997844696,
0.03470444306731224,
-0.6624846458435059,
0.8660026788711548,
-0.18287162482738495,
-0.12293975055217743,
-0.2801371216773987,
-0.23987528681755066,
0.41440051794052124,
0.32585257291793823,
0.3102889060974121,
0.611623227596283,
0.3627159297466278,
-0.43622732162475586,
0.4657391309738159,
-0.06809716671705246,
-0.29523342847824097,
0.8668272495269775,
-0.605507493019104,
0.22943860292434692,
-0.01715136133134365,
0.23119820654392242,
-1.169443130493164,
-0.6415510177612305,
0.5449391007423401,
-0.7694399952888489,
0.18004514276981354,
-0.3773539960384369,
-0.6116061806678772,
-0.20998218655586243,
0.165947824716568,
0.286160409450531,
0.32171720266342163,
-0.8732126355171204,
0.641060471534729,
-0.055050190538167953,
0.48637640476226807,
-0.7262750864028931,
-0.7383267879486084,
0.12893535196781158,
0.019244270399212837,
-0.9370108246803284,
0.4265528917312622,
0.08054229617118835,
-0.43327391147613525,
0.14257606863975525,
-0.3933711647987366,
-0.5167558789253235,
0.5063580274581909,
0.4366535246372223,
0.14423616230487823,
-0.21429942548274994,
-0.026342464610934258,
0.1231115385890007,
-0.25496408343315125,
0.07810062915086746,
0.1252872496843338,
0.19199958443641663,
-0.42676666378974915,
-0.4542914628982544,
-0.6536607146263123,
0.5006341338157654,
0.8585230112075806,
0.04757966846227646,
0.5353386998176575,
0.7476996779441833,
-0.5724654793739319,
-0.18236614763736725,
-0.6324133276939392,
-0.4013229310512543,
-0.48743143677711487,
0.025640131905674934,
-0.49973264336586,
-0.9251827001571655,
0.3737122714519501,
-0.39612334966659546,
-0.3621193766593933,
0.28652656078338623,
0.5333648920059204,
-0.33665889501571655,
1.0597625970840454,
0.2596578299999237,
0.18513983488082886,
0.04082995653152466,
-0.0323956273496151,
0.1746262013912201,
-0.0868915244936943,
-0.24320873618125916,
-0.05153615027666092,
-0.3017556667327881,
-0.07129470258951187,
-0.5947852730751038,
-0.05052094906568527,
0.17779581248760223,
-0.3760634958744049,
0.07132405042648315,
-0.6965524554252625,
0.6872710585594177,
0.6547672152519226,
0.3614293336868286,
0.2698822617530823,
0.2576903700828552,
-0.058106206357479095,
-0.08504701405763626,
-0.16036604344844818,
-0.4775952994823456,
0.4364356994628906,
0.35097578167915344,
0.3093997836112976,
0.13407637178897858,
0.5073114633560181,
0.37438395619392395,
0.14073395729064941,
-0.9168459177017212,
0.5901249647140503,
-0.2320156842470169,
-1.0612505674362183,
-0.31903982162475586,
-0.099976547062397,
-0.4538607597351074,
-0.025363614782691002,
-0.40409642457962036,
-0.4937398135662079,
0.4444907009601593,
0.32179757952690125,
-0.3176257312297821,
0.05380697920918465,
-0.8410977125167847,
0.9486589431762695,
-0.38448455929756165,
-0.3348752558231354,
-0.247453972697258,
-0.5755822658538818,
0.6126808524131775,
0.015106582082808018,
0.21359314024448395,
0.01765807718038559,
0.15429826080799103,
0.3508356809616089,
-0.4351581931114197,
1.2682358026504517,
-0.4317694306373596,
0.13899989426136017,
0.2884790897369385,
0.35353371500968933,
0.14258010685443878,
0.1349647045135498,
0.15500466525554657,
0.6157364249229431,
-0.18461236357688904,
-0.4884547293186188,
-0.839192271232605,
0.5197193622589111,
-0.4821572005748749,
-0.6110237836837769,
-0.3801547884941101,
-0.19234396517276764,
-0.08978910744190216,
0.22558948397636414,
0.29030975699424744,
0.0966906026005745,
-0.22223378717899323,
0.037709370255470276,
0.7368155121803284,
-0.24631668627262115,
0.2912849485874176,
0.3055448532104492,
-0.012267063371837139,
-0.35896405577659607,
0.7622686624526978,
-0.09104243665933609,
0.10315373539924622,
0.025296982377767563,
0.1094759851694107,
-0.1929709017276764,
-0.3947998285293579,
-0.4493371844291687,
-0.004515385255217552,
-0.7571818828582764,
0.02449912764132023,
-0.30180853605270386,
-0.18026071786880493,
-0.3430366516113281,
-0.4754011631011963,
-0.36866191029548645,
-0.4223596155643463,
-0.3157874345779419,
0.08469431847333908,
0.641842246055603,
0.3195759952068329,
-0.40074631571769714,
0.36513277888298035,
-0.45188868045806885,
0.9544883966445923,
0.6839649677276611,
0.45998451113700867,
-0.11530544608831406,
-0.5212326645851135,
-0.005188455805182457,
0.09482386708259583,
-0.030753418803215027,
-0.8656207323074341,
0.26648974418640137,
-0.07183723151683807,
0.6111990213394165,
0.4750590920448303,
-0.052424199879169464,
0.5960737466812134,
-0.16128389537334442,
0.7281126379966736,
0.26356959342956543,
-1.2301064729690552,
0.5401285290718079,
-0.1607351303100586,
-0.021366925910115242,
0.5582813620567322,
0.6264901757240295,
-0.2833974063396454,
0.03737657517194748,
-0.6988245248794556,
-0.516390323638916,
0.21563836932182312,
0.2353190779685974,
0.19528867304325104,
0.04827661067247391,
0.41140103340148926,
0.1870177835226059,
0.13466928899288177,
-0.793749213218689,
-0.15025188028812408,
-0.6816316843032837,
-0.12220202386379242,
0.31435245275497437,
0.0027561262249946594,
-0.3310752213001251,
-0.5257232189178467,
0.3157126009464264,
-0.4095878601074219,
0.27563372254371643,
0.42549628019332886,
-0.21476496756076813,
-0.028419407084584236,
0.07699088007211685,
0.6264463067054749,
0.3797351121902466,
0.008091002702713013,
0.3027656078338623,
0.007652726490050554,
-0.45515894889831543,
0.054122284054756165,
0.07551778852939606,
-0.1150234192609787,
0.12179636210203171,
0.41707050800323486,
0.5145560503005981,
0.12536382675170898,
-0.43921366333961487,
0.8623521327972412,
-0.015014749020338058,
-0.5226713418960571,
-0.38078808784484863,
0.1597786396741867,
0.05979301780462265,
0.35168763995170593,
0.5702908635139465,
0.40698784589767456,
0.3353101909160614,
-0.5775346159934998,
0.6692593693733215,
0.3787662088871002,
-0.30793458223342896,
-0.394758403301239,
0.28690558671951294,
0.1872624009847641,
-0.15011337399482727,
0.4482423961162567,
-0.14572305977344513,
-0.9191900491714478,
0.6640923619270325,
0.1066361516714096,
0.6972144842147827,
-0.1039387583732605,
0.3438011109828949,
0.16341833770275116,
0.43082693219184875,
-0.04373821243643761,
0.393606573343277,
-0.011039431206882,
-1.1644797325134277,
-0.5903690457344055,
-0.4056885242462158,
-0.17449884116649628,
0.49090874195098877,
-0.2934299409389496,
0.26814302802085876,
-0.698552668094635,
0.12026871740818024,
0.3308100998401642,
-0.19080917537212372,
-0.9045584201812744,
0.7813988924026489,
0.52891606092453,
0.8357737064361572,
-1.0941554307937622,
0.5535646080970764,
0.5276768803596497,
-0.5744844675064087,
-0.7736182808876038,
0.0002993372909259051,
0.3981875479221344,
-1.0129566192626953,
0.9125982522964478,
0.2601141035556793,
-0.18580704927444458,
-0.14203575253486633,
-1.1351799964904785,
-0.5157192945480347,
0.7708303332328796,
0.30067116022109985,
-0.5857113599777222,
0.21159277856349945,
0.14435186982154846,
0.41381117701530457,
-0.3419106900691986,
-0.06565210968255997,
0.577136754989624,
0.7693449258804321,
0.3834211528301239,
-0.5878024101257324,
0.4796068072319031,
-0.035305436700582504,
-0.38876014947891235,
-0.12519894540309906,
-0.3556695282459259,
0.6890348196029663,
-0.14526477456092834,
-0.24113424122333527,
-0.17522050440311432,
0.4827677309513092,
0.38589420914649963,
0.9388526678085327,
0.6929242014884949,
0.9072446823120117,
0.5185992121696472,
-0.0769524946808815,
0.901199996471405,
0.26638394594192505,
0.05451562628149986,
1.0716493129730225,
-0.13911236822605133,
0.5003047585487366,
0.44776397943496704,
0.08384349197149277,
0.6988863945007324,
0.45120683312416077,
-0.3517324924468994,
0.5120121836662292,
-0.09319153428077698,
-0.38863223791122437,
-0.7881219387054443,
0.13670513033866882,
-0.014260314404964447,
0.7695083022117615,
0.3858790993690491,
-0.37023377418518066,
-0.20729196071624756,
-0.12434545904397964,
0.026149583980441093,
0.1643156111240387,
-0.23539970815181732,
0.5800182223320007,
0.1297266185283661,
-0.3800848126411438,
0.6663532853126526,
-0.2696429491043091,
0.6763207316398621,
0.23842933773994446,
-0.47953686118125916,
-0.21497221291065216,
-0.08542581647634506,
-0.4030452370643616,
-1.0533661842346191,
0.4754100739955902,
-0.03799610957503319,
-0.2738672196865082,
-0.050497867166996,
1.0712589025497437,
0.09120973944664001,
-0.29026105999946594,
0.05509619414806366,
0.5218005180358887,
0.20403790473937988,
-0.4882093369960785,
-0.9638862013816833,
-0.028648942708969116,
-0.18979260325431824,
-0.3135455548763275,
0.16638322174549103,
0.8284157514572144,
-0.12468595057725906,
0.4092940390110016,
0.9800081849098206,
-0.1378953605890274,
-0.08102917671203613,
0.020776575431227684,
0.6779035925865173,
-0.6086263060569763,
-0.1907953917980194,
-0.7140931487083435,
0.9118174910545349,
-0.3958755135536194,
-0.36662137508392334,
0.4160023331642151,
0.1533154547214508,
0.7250164747238159,
-0.20216432213783264,
0.7969368696212769,
0.11554982513189316,
0.45956259965896606,
-0.49674075841903687,
0.8146945238113403,
-0.815449059009552,
0.02972588688135147,
-0.2724611163139343,
-0.5561532974243164,
-0.3348657488822937,
0.7210010886192322,
-0.190450057387352,
0.017455056309700012,
0.45142266154289246,
0.9076338410377502,
-0.45517319440841675,
-0.07613000273704529,
0.5754066705703735,
0.06503506004810333,
0.09253951162099838,
0.3478851914405823,
0.8024921417236328,
-0.4740731418132782,
0.3811219334602356,
-0.22919142246246338,
-0.1495419293642044,
-0.39341676235198975,
-1.0676099061965942,
-0.7498812079429626,
-0.6417059898376465,
-0.5291668772697449,
-0.46539297699928284,
-0.10515636950731277,
0.3653525710105896,
0.8719194531440735,
-0.7266903519630432,
0.5743632912635803,
-0.38690879940986633,
0.23806828260421753,
-0.2502325773239136,
-0.3944317400455475,
0.03054983913898468,
0.16646094620227814,
-0.47474977374076843,
0.33060675859451294,
0.07880938053131104,
0.3519051969051361,
-0.15644530951976776,
-0.15463297069072723,
-0.1176295354962349,
0.2212442308664322,
0.5254050493240356,
0.48922181129455566,
-1.0771610736846924,
-0.5904381275177002,
0.01074986718595028,
0.003253993345424533,
-0.15800924599170685,
0.6470463275909424,
-1.1972341537475586,
0.3471538722515106,
0.29776817560195923,
0.5980516076087952,
0.39964503049850464,
0.0013949485728517175,
0.5612010359764099,
-0.6973711252212524,
0.08438015729188919,
0.2579651176929474,
0.07575169205665588,
0.3553617596626282,
-0.6297745108604431,
0.4510065019130707,
0.7765869498252869,
-0.2500770390033722,
-0.9751554727554321,
0.47883036732673645,
-1.323362112045288,
-0.6905779838562012,
0.8547729849815369,
-0.11002921313047409,
-0.3369162976741791,
-0.5453245639801025,
-0.06670795381069183,
0.3433801531791687,
-0.3312278687953949,
0.6975575089454651,
0.5367634892463684,
0.040495600551366806,
-0.651830792427063,
-0.41432034969329834,
0.7149606943130493,
0.33370205760002136,
-0.580380380153656,
0.02217157743871212,
0.7609657645225525,
0.4749038815498352,
0.33273670077323914,
0.3720996677875519,
0.030328312888741493,
0.8778350353240967,
0.02227960154414177,
0.15731288492679596,
-0.2585933208465576,
-0.4175325334072113,
-0.4189106225967407,
0.04043770581483841,
-0.4350593388080597,
-0.02533070743083954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00123v1 | Comparing Template-based and Template-free Language Model Probing | 2024-01-31T19:07:37 | 2024-01-31T19:07:37 | Sagi Shaier, Kevin Bennett, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The differences between cloze-task language model (LM) probing with 1)
expert-made templates and 2) naturally-occurring text have often been
overlooked. Here, we evaluate 16 different LMs on 10 probing English datasets
-- 4 template-based and 6 template-free -- in general and biomedical domains to
answer the following research questions: (RQ1) Do model rankings differ between
the two approaches? (RQ2) Do models' absolute scores differ between the two
approaches? (RQ3) Do the answers to RQ1 and RQ2 differ between general and
domain-specific models? Our findings are: 1) Template-free and template-based
approaches often rank models differently, except for the top domain-specific
models. 2) Scores decrease by up to 42% Acc@1 when comparing parallel
template-free and template-based prompts. 3) Perplexity is negatively
correlated with accuracy in the template-free approach, but,
counter-intuitively, they are positively correlated for template-based probing.
4) Models tend to predict the same answers frequently across prompts for
template-based probing, which is less common when employing template-free
techniques. | [
-0.39075967669487,
-0.8801896572113037,
0.6985440254211426,
0.15529221296310425,
-0.20931243896484375,
-0.22380121052265167,
-0.19899490475654602,
-0.6447907090187073,
0.1522597074508667,
0.3692854046821594,
-0.2357175201177597,
-0.5070853233337402,
-0.6619204878807068,
0.4209832549095154,
-0.39939650893211365,
0.5988364219665527,
0.021906696259975433,
0.39292412996292114,
-0.6748402714729309,
-0.3800741732120514,
-0.4684296250343323,
-0.4279373288154602,
-0.6977783441543579,
-0.24468685686588287,
0.626552402973175,
-0.0028007421642541885,
0.3729840815067291,
0.6976951360702515,
0.5143065452575684,
0.22734464704990387,
-0.32439908385276794,
-0.05146777629852295,
-0.25031501054763794,
0.16247980296611786,
-0.4696950614452362,
-0.5219836831092834,
-0.5565274357795715,
0.23937998712062836,
0.14559924602508545,
0.7936911582946777,
0.20320367813110352,
0.30684754252433777,
0.20104610919952393,
0.5486477613449097,
-0.6348894834518433,
0.03808937221765518,
-0.4358741044998169,
-0.3385455012321472,
-0.2205430567264557,
-0.05340469256043434,
-0.5002593994140625,
-0.23091253638267517,
0.5460406541824341,
-0.4269031882286072,
0.5389314889907837,
0.12797923386096954,
0.604391872882843,
-0.12100888043642044,
-0.8027653098106384,
-0.5320111513137817,
-0.5154465436935425,
0.8887134790420532,
-0.7101109027862549,
0.4128454327583313,
0.18950685858726501,
-0.061294905841350555,
0.12383948266506195,
-0.7074726819992065,
-0.37647712230682373,
-0.5204470157623291,
-0.13602609932422638,
0.13278210163116455,
-0.26088860630989075,
0.045089248567819595,
0.20621903240680695,
0.26751768589019775,
-0.9579524397850037,
0.2455725073814392,
-0.545659065246582,
-0.30109116435050964,
0.5029696822166443,
0.2776761054992676,
0.0811598002910614,
-0.2457253634929657,
-0.4645887017250061,
-0.17987236380577087,
-0.9233294725418091,
0.33420687913894653,
0.06922409683465958,
0.359381765127182,
-0.10177094489336014,
0.4834226369857788,
0.006635930389165878,
1.0171630382537842,
0.08820503950119019,
-0.05664370581507683,
-0.02098008058965206,
-0.24225662648677826,
-0.37627166509628296,
-0.15815939009189606,
0.8189393877983093,
0.5010668039321899,
0.26552388072013855,
-0.15549336373806,
-0.09889999777078629,
-0.05292605981230736,
0.1458146721124649,
-0.5295876264572144,
-0.061715833842754364,
0.5820448398590088,
-0.5199270844459534,
-0.1942591369152069,
0.04605767875909805,
-0.6054263114929199,
-0.43212559819221497,
-0.18141084909439087,
0.4148208200931549,
-0.3019034266471863,
-0.08280334621667862,
0.21172016859054565,
-0.16743481159210205,
0.398917555809021,
0.46638017892837524,
-0.5252243280410767,
0.41059401631355286,
0.597525417804718,
0.7742276191711426,
-0.6836525201797485,
-0.12553074955940247,
-0.32381170988082886,
-0.20378246903419495,
-0.4257683753967285,
1.1011486053466797,
-0.43860340118408203,
-0.666778564453125,
-0.12337043136358261,
-0.049244947731494904,
-0.45069655776023865,
-0.8867628574371338,
0.25440704822540283,
-0.2764891982078552,
0.761904239654541,
-0.5743092894554138,
-0.9594247937202454,
-0.3744804561138153,
0.2040291577577591,
-0.6703463792800903,
0.943936824798584,
0.1426016241312027,
-0.9222226142883301,
0.18562008440494537,
-0.5332458019256592,
-0.06371892988681793,
0.02648329548537731,
-0.3744262456893921,
0.11729614436626434,
0.06357310712337494,
0.20525185763835907,
0.4651309549808502,
-0.7515758872032166,
0.18600113689899445,
-0.26971009373664856,
-0.43907901644706726,
0.32405439019203186,
-0.08656438440084457,
0.8328524827957153,
0.18279492855072021,
-0.4924042820930481,
0.07356306165456772,
-0.5345694422721863,
0.33161991834640503,
0.2996075749397278,
-0.11632394045591354,
-0.4766666293144226,
0.020409023389220238,
-0.09848489612340927,
0.10624741017818451,
0.07035104930400848,
-0.7378809452056885,
0.26460686326026917,
-0.45901334285736084,
0.11988811939954758,
0.4064899981021881,
0.12292696535587311,
0.2622058391571045,
-0.8099341988563538,
0.5494186878204346,
0.1501755714416504,
-0.1837596744298935,
-0.045276254415512085,
-0.7445856928825378,
-0.640077531337738,
-0.30122876167297363,
0.2801438868045807,
0.8041790723800659,
-0.24143199622631073,
0.024164538830518723,
-0.19289104640483856,
-0.7215760350227356,
-0.7278956770896912,
-0.20358456671237946,
0.5976758599281311,
0.8237441778182983,
0.6143730282783508,
-0.5222199559211731,
-0.17827963829040527,
-0.9585041403770447,
-0.6196786761283875,
-0.024144846946001053,
-0.22370173037052155,
0.5600151419639587,
0.5752893686294556,
0.23106814920902252,
0.9020562171936035,
-0.47592371702194214,
-0.06579416990280151,
-0.5062371492385864,
0.064638152718544,
0.30697232484817505,
0.34039512276649475,
0.870339572429657,
-0.5586098432540894,
-0.8594766855239868,
-0.260512113571167,
-0.5930598378181458,
-0.20262877643108368,
0.13356631994247437,
0.6030036807060242,
0.18860594928264618,
0.4238031208515167,
-0.7468113899230957,
0.43298059701919556,
0.39185595512390137,
-0.12538132071495056,
0.6929970979690552,
0.019300494343042374,
0.4310779571533203,
-1.0456668138504028,
0.3561917245388031,
0.06551727652549744,
-0.11082416772842407,
-1.1311845779418945,
0.2700369656085968,
0.3532664477825165,
0.012366400100290775,
-0.7225462198257446,
1.084119439125061,
-0.4737791419029236,
0.05659998953342438,
-0.2577386200428009,
0.14521478116512299,
0.21670126914978027,
0.23478135466575623,
0.003924631979316473,
1.0184166431427002,
0.702940821647644,
-0.6987205743789673,
0.02439921721816063,
0.02551105059683323,
-0.5993780493736267,
0.14357978105545044,
-1.0756964683532715,
0.5112418532371521,
-0.1099637821316719,
0.08267505466938019,
-0.9931187033653259,
0.19600512087345123,
0.13845376670360565,
-0.5714958310127258,
0.24320852756500244,
-0.09649989753961563,
-0.2940506935119629,
-0.12217427790164948,
-0.5238515734672546,
0.5214818120002747,
0.561759889125824,
-0.016263777390122414,
0.08595329523086548,
-0.004662742838263512,
-0.3405971825122833,
-0.6566622257232666,
-0.34930527210235596,
-0.17836804687976837,
-0.24804984033107758,
-0.45525288581848145,
0.21987447142601013,
-0.17380516231060028,
-0.5352683067321777,
-0.20402134954929352,
-0.3929958641529083,
0.023453528061509132,
0.06850463896989822,
-0.036920398473739624,
0.033953458070755005,
-0.5749437808990479,
-0.11328356713056564,
-0.19295960664749146,
0.21612659096717834,
0.033953707665205,
-0.23778454959392548,
0.6097177863121033,
0.009446859359741211,
-0.4337015748023987,
-0.34860068559646606,
0.6700491309165955,
0.6857929229736328,
-0.574320912361145,
0.6118981838226318,
0.12672516703605652,
-0.25942301750183105,
0.13946589827537537,
-0.7626118659973145,
-0.15165188908576965,
-0.4936700165271759,
0.1621173769235611,
-0.2736654579639435,
-0.9487413763999939,
0.6348481774330139,
0.336824893951416,
-0.026320721954107285,
0.48546087741851807,
0.6307967305183411,
-0.2488260716199875,
0.9057037234306335,
0.489197313785553,
0.057352859526872635,
0.058881111443042755,
-0.0722983330488205,
0.14284822344779968,
-0.7865354418754578,
0.0019587548449635506,
-0.8345352411270142,
-0.01874660514295101,
-0.5925415754318237,
-0.4636615216732025,
0.5384513735771179,
-0.010898757725954056,
-0.01618237979710102,
0.23722223937511444,
-0.4155784845352173,
0.2148026078939438,
0.5173364877700806,
-0.0900975689291954,
0.12489791214466095,
-0.09073466807603836,
-0.5428211092948914,
-0.08108025789260864,
-0.7338225841522217,
-0.6113946437835693,
1.3193604946136475,
0.13186369836330414,
0.3762229084968567,
-0.017368733882904053,
0.5498970150947571,
0.07588382810354233,
0.33540183305740356,
-0.6440175771713257,
0.6298075318336487,
-0.16372282803058624,
-0.8443508148193359,
-0.18881221115589142,
-0.25069162249565125,
-1.2061690092086792,
0.36654430627822876,
-0.03306717798113823,
-1.1440682411193848,
0.23163217306137085,
0.2712429463863373,
-0.16843627393245697,
0.34828343987464905,
-0.4695011079311371,
0.6270396113395691,
-0.15001744031906128,
-0.37634986639022827,
0.045300621539354324,
-0.5067105293273926,
0.15018606185913086,
0.13032740354537964,
0.310475617647171,
0.009006310254335403,
0.11308176815509796,
0.7953739166259766,
0.023872533813118935,
0.7765083312988281,
-0.09038335084915161,
-0.15327489376068115,
0.519154965877533,
0.4657113254070282,
0.24190156161785126,
-0.006950845941901207,
-0.1442493349313736,
0.010082460939884186,
0.25770246982574463,
-0.6123713850975037,
-0.5087239146232605,
0.564538836479187,
-0.5943245887756348,
-1.0732501745224,
-0.5088503360748291,
-0.5962676405906677,
-0.29859602451324463,
0.2625500559806824,
0.615225076675415,
0.7916338443756104,
-0.16737298667430878,
0.2526521384716034,
0.8271037340164185,
-0.3709757924079895,
0.04472379758954048,
0.8029772639274597,
-0.01950303465127945,
-0.12932254374027252,
0.501483142375946,
0.03518030047416687,
0.44956690073013306,
0.7287834882736206,
0.30678632855415344,
-0.2256840467453003,
-0.6544442772865295,
-0.21986182034015656,
0.5165836811065674,
-0.5998991131782532,
-0.03813482075929642,
-0.6833400726318359,
-0.01999548450112343,
-0.8847586512565613,
-0.11489932239055634,
-0.4210681915283203,
-0.40457165241241455,
-0.13340695202350616,
-0.13839954137802124,
0.23765063285827637,
0.6714334487915039,
0.23572252690792084,
-0.1621752679347992,
-0.8476012349128723,
-0.07669350504875183,
0.05192594975233078,
0.0011929571628570557,
-0.03302893415093422,
-0.29838404059410095,
0.034408457577228546,
0.13224728405475616,
-0.23272313177585602,
-1.406773328781128,
0.33104658126831055,
-0.000038036610931158066,
0.6170094013214111,
0.2930058538913727,
-0.17148348689079285,
0.5074264407157898,
-0.43551012873649597,
1.0489403009414673,
-0.06761624664068222,
-0.8354604840278625,
0.3873014748096466,
-0.6080846190452576,
0.3349273204803467,
0.33717989921569824,
0.7209396362304688,
-0.676429271697998,
-0.6909370422363281,
-0.44260138273239136,
-0.8821937441825867,
0.29052308201789856,
0.08061210811138153,
-0.14853085577487946,
-0.32596907019615173,
0.6098783016204834,
0.41358479857444763,
0.23843608796596527,
-0.5563181638717651,
-0.45598354935646057,
-0.018164413049817085,
-0.08024833351373672,
-0.24951496720314026,
-0.15991224348545074,
-0.2183779776096344,
-0.2085805982351303,
0.017301861196756363,
-0.033061083406209946,
0.7128819227218628,
0.6403580904006958,
-0.190926656126976,
0.1308899074792862,
0.4111829698085785,
0.9410311579704285,
0.5867720246315002,
-0.5019358396530151,
0.11045482754707336,
0.21061590313911438,
-0.47452396154403687,
0.19163136184215546,
-0.24491965770721436,
-0.2301209568977356,
0.12923261523246765,
0.7687386870384216,
0.6787658929824829,
0.1140994131565094,
-0.6002452373504639,
0.45454978942871094,
0.0939921885728836,
-0.5305666923522949,
0.016524823382496834,
0.23888598382472992,
0.35110989212989807,
-0.048271652311086655,
0.2532884180545807,
-0.21832779049873352,
0.16541311144828796,
-0.2989571988582611,
0.07814060896635056,
0.35758745670318604,
-0.3852429687976837,
-0.4001140296459198,
0.6808163523674011,
0.0588151216506958,
-0.3890210688114166,
0.5487125515937805,
-0.057581827044487,
-0.2973632514476776,
0.8744104504585266,
0.6683440804481506,
0.5253485441207886,
-0.4001796841621399,
0.01927756331861019,
0.3766585886478424,
0.1807110756635666,
0.05022010952234268,
0.5558075308799744,
0.14688576757907867,
-0.5798247456550598,
-0.04502555727958679,
-0.1103871762752533,
-0.5498899221420288,
0.6425961256027222,
-1.252204418182373,
-0.03658492863178253,
-0.15297560393810272,
-0.15099367499351501,
-0.13458579778671265,
0.16587911546230316,
-1.0298733711242676,
0.412469744682312,
-0.2867852747440338,
1.3814213275909424,
-0.6121867895126343,
0.7954394817352295,
1.1724107265472412,
-0.1765512079000473,
-0.6845044493675232,
-0.017616085708141327,
0.19452372193336487,
-0.4420398473739624,
0.39555904269218445,
0.34258201718330383,
-0.0914057195186615,
0.09325577318668365,
-0.36358121037483215,
-1.0861667394638062,
1.306230068206787,
0.11560879647731781,
-0.36377865076065063,
-0.147975891828537,
0.12496842443943024,
0.6959046721458435,
-0.34654733538627625,
0.4201264977455139,
0.17181752622127533,
0.19429288804531097,
-0.5568286776542664,
-1.3183174133300781,
0.045527633279561996,
-0.2514343857765198,
-0.35335269570350647,
0.09041743725538254,
-0.6115493774414062,
1.049715518951416,
-0.0954277515411377,
-0.37781649827957153,
0.4142620861530304,
0.3904796242713928,
0.322156697511673,
0.5502126216888428,
0.42628949880599976,
0.24303148686885834,
0.6250179409980774,
0.06242286041378975,
1.2516133785247803,
-0.48285332322120667,
0.4830712080001831,
0.7764143943786621,
-0.6572850346565247,
0.7434864044189453,
0.4618397355079651,
-0.09037403762340546,
0.31267163157463074,
0.5815979838371277,
0.0635455772280693,
0.5504130721092224,
0.31523454189300537,
0.004530239384621382,
-0.0631987452507019,
0.23391786217689514,
-0.4836612045764923,
0.3809502124786377,
0.5692993402481079,
-0.10493007302284241,
-0.34009823203086853,
-0.06283624470233917,
0.1524129956960678,
0.008017272688448429,
-0.06746794283390045,
0.5740663409233093,
0.17070384323596954,
-0.8320118188858032,
0.7041410207748413,
0.2833520770072937,
0.4485490322113037,
-0.7000414133071899,
0.45788663625717163,
-0.635123074054718,
-0.03322594240307808,
0.25945934653282166,
-0.5422789454460144,
0.060913145542144775,
0.2007129043340683,
-0.06308306008577347,
-0.14234907925128937,
0.7184560298919678,
-0.1310058981180191,
-0.11010584235191345,
0.45011571049690247,
1.2067201137542725,
0.258322536945343,
0.15693888068199158,
-0.6316684484481812,
-0.2675090432167053,
-0.1334153711795807,
-0.5324050784111023,
0.6555280685424805,
-0.027192234992980957,
-0.23713991045951843,
0.8363751769065857,
0.333846777677536,
0.08930013328790665,
0.01639508455991745,
-0.3545728921890259,
0.6543393135070801,
-0.687819242477417,
-0.14517325162887573,
-0.5755168199539185,
0.40058040618896484,
0.07198820263147354,
-0.5069025754928589,
0.6315537095069885,
0.538698136806488,
0.8139330744743347,
-0.31411051750183105,
0.6960299015045166,
0.10887588560581207,
0.9327315092086792,
-0.6856701374053955,
0.5875231623649597,
-0.7505975961685181,
0.06648985296487808,
-0.20363213121891022,
-0.7312153577804565,
-0.2798216938972473,
0.5535488724708557,
-0.2856079339981079,
0.053238075226545334,
1.1884119510650635,
0.9325369000434875,
-0.28405919671058655,
-0.17658627033233643,
0.26034078001976013,
0.228582501411438,
0.39727723598480225,
0.4975179135799408,
0.6310347318649292,
-0.15629084408283234,
-0.008450793102383614,
-0.14109928905963898,
-0.10265743732452393,
-0.07582153379917145,
-0.9353801012039185,
-0.9748371839523315,
-0.6957708597183228,
-0.19467668235301971,
-0.13291649520397186,
0.24164187908172607,
0.9665993452072144,
0.294647753238678,
-1.0143699645996094,
-0.42975348234176636,
0.33804792165756226,
-0.12694449722766876,
-0.37084442377090454,
-0.19143854081630707,
0.5709472894668579,
-0.10256503522396088,
-0.7436794638633728,
0.8364625573158264,
0.21526724100112915,
0.10206039994955063,
0.1088244840502739,
0.39738228917121887,
-0.03466368839144707,
0.5060813426971436,
0.3282633125782013,
0.26220592856407166,
-0.9122681021690369,
-0.4147661328315735,
0.7082186937332153,
-0.4694497883319855,
0.13934479653835297,
1.1698192358016968,
-0.6810296177864075,
0.23655283451080322,
0.6402614712715149,
0.30704280734062195,
0.10612301528453827,
-0.018520662561058998,
0.7705299854278564,
-0.5653666853904724,
0.04551839828491211,
0.32260075211524963,
0.3498922884464264,
0.29544931650161743,
-0.2091500163078308,
0.19257429242134094,
0.32119888067245483,
-0.5565149784088135,
-0.8961084485054016,
0.5442683696746826,
-1.1923518180847168,
-0.4541129171848297,
1.254823088645935,
-0.34199202060699463,
0.02557777613401413,
-0.30186623334884644,
-0.005178485997021198,
0.06946754455566406,
0.05685367062687874,
0.7245370149612427,
0.7848770618438721,
-0.28033238649368286,
0.1607820987701416,
-0.7447252869606018,
0.4470750093460083,
0.7235985994338989,
-0.36770427227020264,
-0.28111761808395386,
0.1413397192955017,
0.7695987820625305,
0.032757069915533066,
0.9281865954399109,
-0.18309003114700317,
0.4892768859863281,
-0.3139255940914154,
-0.12083478271961212,
-0.2354656308889389,
-0.17696043848991394,
-0.32784292101860046,
0.32451343536376953,
0.08031745254993439,
0.024285757914185524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18070v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18070v2 | Do Language Models Exhibit the Same Cognitive Biases in Problem Solving as Human Learners? | 2024-01-31T18:48:20 | 2024-06-17T15:08:05 | Andreas Opedal, Alessandro Stolfo, Haruki Shirakami, Ying Jiao, Ryan Cotterell, Bernhard Schölkopf, Abulhair Saparov, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | There is increasing interest in employing large language models (LLMs) as
cognitive models. For such purposes, it is central to understand which
properties of human cognition are well-modeled by LLMs, and which are not. In
this work, we study the biases of LLMs in relation to those known in children
when solving arithmetic word problems. Surveying the learning science
literature, we posit that the problem-solving process can be split into three
distinct steps: text comprehension, solution planning and solution execution.
We construct tests for each one in order to understand whether current LLMs
display the same cognitive biases as children in these steps. We generate a
novel set of word problems for each of these tests, using a neuro-symbolic
approach that enables fine-grained control over the problem features. We find
evidence that LLMs, with and without instruction-tuning, exhibit human-like
biases in both the text-comprehension and the solution-planning steps of the
solving process, but not in the final step, in which the arithmetic expressions
are executed to obtain the answer. | [
-0.3382144272327423,
-0.9047995209693909,
0.9263201355934143,
0.2548832297325134,
0.07658514380455017,
0.09309378266334534,
-0.33727651834487915,
-0.4315371513366699,
-0.028970368206501007,
0.6310473084449768,
-1.0154316425323486,
0.04776256904006004,
-0.7752726078033447,
0.16967791318893433,
-0.11293717473745346,
0.6310587525367737,
-0.1884673535823822,
0.5535483956336975,
-0.5530807375907898,
0.1288185715675354,
-0.4362933337688446,
-0.5869261026382446,
-0.6780388355255127,
-0.7976050972938538,
0.33887332677841187,
0.47349369525909424,
0.7565796971321106,
0.6982758045196533,
0.39701953530311584,
0.2768612504005432,
-0.22116050124168396,
-0.148763045668602,
-0.21260511875152588,
0.06053603067994118,
-0.31499531865119934,
-0.7812222838401794,
-0.05584849789738655,
0.2983780801296234,
0.20410816371440887,
1.227568507194519,
-0.16864833235740662,
0.14568071067333221,
0.10882271081209183,
0.9446645379066467,
-0.5423861742019653,
0.32060155272483826,
-0.6209421157836914,
0.07303757965564728,
-0.0024714551400393248,
0.17468596994876862,
-0.4633410573005676,
-0.14915888011455536,
0.16488343477249146,
-0.7586394548416138,
0.499489426612854,
0.0661541298031807,
0.5615654587745667,
0.423071950674057,
-0.4395591914653778,
-0.7222192287445068,
-0.5267179608345032,
1.0786529779434204,
-0.6661898493766785,
0.03424909710884094,
0.6334219574928284,
-0.19950419664382935,
-0.3263961970806122,
0.10995128750801086,
-0.8419010043144226,
-0.2276497632265091,
-0.12950864434242249,
-0.22419339418411255,
0.055270008742809296,
0.05673005059361458,
0.5763748288154602,
-0.14852437376976013,
-0.5308420062065125,
0.14240653812885284,
-0.5872443914413452,
-0.27480730414390564,
0.6488811373710632,
0.3541005253791809,
0.29755258560180664,
-0.2334980070590973,
-0.08858192712068558,
-0.1338043212890625,
-0.6797890067100525,
-0.03271092101931572,
0.31422555446624756,
0.1904541701078415,
0.050330083817243576,
0.7034544348716736,
-0.09797387570142746,
0.6363778710365295,
-0.061102960258722305,
-0.0522405207157135,
0.21987569332122803,
0.0907524824142456,
-0.02465774305164814,
0.15625306963920593,
0.5908148288726807,
0.10875701904296875,
1.0682357549667358,
0.0661267414689064,
-0.3853292465209961,
0.6043649315834045,
0.19660699367523193,
-0.46583291888237,
-0.06000284478068352,
-0.0800776407122612,
-0.14961355924606323,
-0.35109448432922363,
-0.36953479051589966,
-0.47190916538238525,
-0.3828343152999878,
-0.4572432041168213,
0.577945351600647,
-0.37502652406692505,
0.06606225669384003,
0.39038345217704773,
-0.04294748231768608,
0.030372006818652153,
0.021926086395978928,
-1.1749335527420044,
0.4705480635166168,
0.8163761496543884,
0.4055041968822479,
-0.16035643219947815,
-0.26959332823753357,
-0.31965866684913635,
-0.0795833095908165,
-0.5658324360847473,
0.7071062326431274,
-0.8074637055397034,
-0.4699513614177704,
0.00984993390738964,
-0.16681921482086182,
-0.11499052494764328,
-0.8248928785324097,
0.45042574405670166,
-0.5524415373802185,
0.21234513819217682,
-0.6320256590843201,
-0.5211259126663208,
-0.01841229759156704,
0.10814561694860458,
-0.6397663354873657,
0.7899542450904846,
-0.09041133522987366,
-0.7492291331291199,
0.24599188566207886,
-0.5446153283119202,
-0.3770657777786255,
-0.3034617602825165,
-0.3868710994720459,
-0.11307434737682343,
0.5078737139701843,
0.41487711668014526,
0.15907634794712067,
-0.4560932517051697,
0.023127371445298195,
-0.23367363214492798,
-0.3358415365219116,
0.44781485199928284,
-0.49809780716896057,
0.8196812272071838,
-0.11898261308670044,
-0.5279687643051147,
-0.09284254908561707,
-0.6010359525680542,
0.08768504858016968,
0.47201889753341675,
-0.2328604906797409,
-0.42273685336112976,
0.28700318932533264,
-0.40282437205314636,
0.4470990300178528,
0.4325830936431885,
-0.6564725637435913,
0.18148674070835114,
-0.23743310570716858,
0.43589988350868225,
0.8874520659446716,
-0.05860478803515434,
0.3305983543395996,
-0.4938679337501526,
0.45968642830848694,
0.0925503596663475,
0.05239645764231682,
-0.09407132863998413,
-0.5704636573791504,
-1.0795350074768066,
0.34587782621383667,
-0.10456204414367676,
0.4816993176937103,
-0.7435427308082581,
-0.02454545721411705,
-0.15144604444503784,
-0.14037980139255524,
-0.21414026618003845,
0.09672107547521591,
0.6736668944358826,
0.45268920063972473,
0.22761951386928558,
-0.20858614146709442,
-0.10104288905858994,
-1.1037155389785767,
-0.47206366062164307,
-0.1508849561214447,
-0.24800509214401245,
0.49460768699645996,
0.5247344374656677,
0.12735886871814728,
0.7516797184944153,
-0.7501220107078552,
-0.19560754299163818,
0.17993979156017303,
0.2689506411552429,
0.05459471419453621,
0.20042753219604492,
0.22777555882930756,
-0.622785747051239,
-0.194920614361763,
-0.33864203095436096,
-0.7065272331237793,
-0.47887489199638367,
0.08808701485395432,
0.11030514538288116,
0.46719929575920105,
0.5578984022140503,
-0.769105851650238,
0.3061005175113678,
0.4659391939640045,
-0.5687509179115295,
0.76680588722229,
-0.17887482047080994,
-0.33038148283958435,
-0.48132649064064026,
-0.4205476939678192,
0.2673597037792206,
0.20198744535446167,
-0.41301825642585754,
0.09133603423833847,
0.12146535515785217,
0.27954214811325073,
-0.2685449421405792,
0.23791883885860443,
-0.5410155057907104,
-0.18861116468906403,
-0.27998825907707214,
0.31012392044067383,
0.1059080958366394,
0.5198209881782532,
0.169131338596344,
0.7519806623458862,
0.3456677198410034,
-0.5273893475532532,
0.15865403413772583,
-0.33631524443626404,
-0.27096280455589294,
0.40653783082962036,
-0.8622114062309265,
0.3921179473400116,
-0.32449066638946533,
0.012224801816046238,
-0.7148731350898743,
0.022745968773961067,
0.005489205475896597,
-0.36109036207199097,
0.14128319919109344,
0.12508726119995117,
-0.641762912273407,
-0.4102255403995514,
-0.08079855144023895,
0.5131213665008545,
0.5986865758895874,
-0.21968913078308105,
0.36637964844703674,
0.2808355689048767,
-0.27792251110076904,
-0.4122816026210785,
-0.663223385810852,
-0.2162366807460785,
-0.006467195227742195,
-0.5358357429504395,
0.2643786668777466,
-0.21816937625408173,
-0.548303484916687,
0.08843439072370529,
-0.37508970499038696,
-0.14141418039798737,
-0.22075501084327698,
0.14434607326984406,
0.4488266110420227,
-0.060859255492687225,
0.23574630916118622,
-0.1382404863834381,
-0.11795380711555481,
0.5752946734428406,
-0.22335456311702728,
0.6768194437026978,
0.057309187948703766,
-0.4419766068458557,
0.019360458478331566,
0.28519171476364136,
0.6026946902275085,
-0.2545161843299866,
0.5992244482040405,
0.0005109031335450709,
-0.49793457984924316,
-0.2565559446811676,
-0.5496438145637512,
-0.5365109443664551,
-0.47473013401031494,
0.45991596579551697,
-0.3537161648273468,
-0.7626768946647644,
0.39728763699531555,
0.2762237787246704,
0.04588071256875992,
0.25024282932281494,
0.6803741455078125,
-0.3237764835357666,
1.2604864835739136,
0.4798506796360016,
0.032631244510412216,
0.16528482735157013,
-0.17964595556259155,
-0.01876148208975792,
-0.9476479291915894,
-0.2632695436477661,
-0.5785195231437683,
-0.40523675084114075,
-0.4877330958843231,
-0.549869954586029,
0.32118749618530273,
-0.020734278485178947,
-0.5939565300941467,
-0.06767049431800842,
-0.6157020330429077,
0.8197647333145142,
0.3130016326904297,
-0.046767912805080414,
0.3237360119819641,
0.10659383982419968,
-0.43508780002593994,
-0.3024837374687195,
-0.7118890285491943,
-0.5620754361152649,
1.2169978618621826,
-0.005549182649701834,
0.7262427806854248,
-0.13789315521717072,
0.5319541096687317,
-0.028558416292071342,
0.507661759853363,
-0.7592459321022034,
0.690916121006012,
-0.08045849204063416,
-1.0424106121063232,
-0.4700564444065094,
-0.5426524877548218,
-1.1029164791107178,
0.48797667026519775,
-0.2154954969882965,
-1.086110234260559,
0.015526964329183102,
-0.11243940144777298,
-0.0027389023452997208,
0.20664621889591217,
-0.6887291073799133,
0.47158652544021606,
-0.2915121018886566,
-0.3092796206474304,
-0.5858464241027832,
-0.3187139630317688,
0.3591359853744507,
-0.19415447115898132,
0.6008825898170471,
-0.20631185173988342,
-0.08712070435285568,
0.8804094791412354,
-0.3749057948589325,
0.8082216382026672,
0.017795829102396965,
-0.2507719099521637,
0.33817049860954285,
0.32874828577041626,
0.43317991495132446,
-0.1314665526151657,
-0.022462967783212662,
-0.09068644046783447,
-0.047929756343364716,
-0.6930136680603027,
-0.6992655396461487,
0.8282817006111145,
-0.8683822154998779,
-0.9941478967666626,
-0.8050389289855957,
-0.7893534302711487,
-0.3596203625202179,
0.2931143641471863,
-0.036560021340847015,
0.3755970001220703,
0.08291701227426529,
-0.21742191910743713,
0.9496097564697266,
-0.12435201555490494,
0.623299241065979,
0.7599527835845947,
-0.4246593713760376,
0.03537219390273094,
0.7776296138763428,
0.29453107714653015,
0.6101587414741516,
0.02571806311607361,
0.3459620773792267,
-0.036031659692525864,
-0.434287965297699,
-0.2702062427997589,
0.48431476950645447,
-0.6056661605834961,
0.283065527677536,
-0.20649085938930511,
-0.14569444954395294,
0.09678420424461365,
-0.1418222337961197,
-0.27402257919311523,
-0.38315436244010925,
-0.21572059392929077,
0.08163181692361832,
0.10967520624399185,
1.0373152494430542,
0.3140886425971985,
0.06114250794053078,
-0.49191319942474365,
0.5021884441375732,
0.556735634803772,
0.22682584822177887,
0.26162728667259216,
-0.4048163592815399,
-0.1700877994298935,
0.35088542103767395,
-0.480760782957077,
-0.918587863445282,
0.1730366200208664,
0.009577427059412003,
0.22801952064037323,
0.26537826657295227,
-0.07196781039237976,
0.3087664544582367,
-0.587536096572876,
0.849409818649292,
0.0259931031614542,
-0.8678659200668335,
0.17924149334430695,
-0.2232702374458313,
0.45240864157676697,
0.21357202529907227,
0.4506910741329193,
-0.45679962635040283,
-0.14117297530174255,
-0.4972623884677887,
-0.48051291704177856,
0.7783631682395935,
0.04795188456773758,
0.331647664308548,
-0.23316901922225952,
0.4303540885448456,
-0.17377333343029022,
-0.061545178294181824,
-0.5849331021308899,
-0.3509216904640198,
0.1106916218996048,
0.04653526842594147,
-0.11527066677808762,
-0.16437746584415436,
-0.06813402473926544,
-0.19436782598495483,
0.6169158816337585,
-0.11395706236362457,
-0.12797461450099945,
0.17955312132835388,
-0.2209600806236267,
-0.4327954351902008,
0.29702407121658325,
0.5265328884124756,
0.6322832107543945,
0.09102542698383331,
0.04533540457487106,
0.13872841000556946,
-0.5692998170852661,
0.29045259952545166,
-0.19592173397541046,
-0.2459389567375183,
-0.253720760345459,
0.5717184543609619,
0.5402465462684631,
0.30294206738471985,
-0.8166388869285583,
0.32234811782836914,
-0.04393528401851654,
-0.3821420669555664,
-0.35869669914245605,
0.28278836607933044,
0.4728151261806488,
0.10423968732357025,
0.6047409772872925,
-0.06371573358774185,
-0.09231357276439667,
-0.6495867967605591,
-0.25018924474716187,
0.4956369400024414,
-0.4165218472480774,
-0.27667468786239624,
0.39373981952667236,
-0.06601747870445251,
-0.7336589694023132,
0.9782874584197998,
-0.32191967964172363,
-0.676224410533905,
0.8594180345535278,
0.7847768664360046,
0.6361011862754822,
-0.019992325454950333,
0.24291017651557922,
0.036586787551641464,
0.5238798260688782,
0.09831777215003967,
0.4990580976009369,
0.1826913058757782,
-1.060666799545288,
-0.7736886143684387,
-0.5701913237571716,
-0.22414696216583252,
0.1184132769703865,
-0.6948924660682678,
-0.0028171748854219913,
-0.41357773542404175,
-0.17430847883224487,
0.28188806772232056,
0.0058768680319190025,
-0.6525989174842834,
0.35523444414138794,
0.37594524025917053,
0.6948246955871582,
-0.7381903529167175,
0.6223083734512329,
0.8691051006317139,
-0.16142910718917847,
-0.9029601216316223,
0.065423883497715,
0.05648273229598999,
-0.8555202484130859,
0.7910794019699097,
0.08759839832782745,
-0.08388363569974899,
-0.17835663259029388,
-0.5223386883735657,
-0.9631810188293457,
0.6862161159515381,
0.34895244240760803,
-0.622390627861023,
-0.31316980719566345,
0.4264701306819916,
0.5424355268478394,
-0.31214308738708496,
0.17850451171398163,
0.8071615695953369,
0.5060576796531677,
-0.004817479755729437,
-1.0381170511245728,
0.004955427721142769,
-0.09752412885427475,
-0.031312018632888794,
0.31938251852989197,
-0.6184552907943726,
0.9778791666030884,
-0.42071840167045593,
0.033619869500398636,
-0.4770020842552185,
0.3438204228878021,
0.6006563901901245,
0.3689301609992981,
0.5274074077606201,
0.7010825276374817,
0.4703148901462555,
-0.04595734179019928,
1.0044114589691162,
-0.2608276903629303,
0.23169724643230438,
0.8264020085334778,
-0.2003938853740692,
0.6284661889076233,
0.7005395889282227,
-0.4703975021839142,
0.5265142917633057,
0.3712722957134247,
0.4669763743877411,
0.23823317885398865,
0.5649505853652954,
-0.13916154205799103,
-0.29798099398612976,
-0.015230879187583923,
0.042635079473257065,
0.3220025300979614,
0.806030809879303,
-0.18387863039970398,
-0.09762095659971237,
-0.2902144491672516,
0.2936245799064636,
0.3132467567920685,
-0.541702926158905,
0.4644051492214203,
0.44689667224884033,
-0.8939367532730103,
0.6515880823135376,
0.10843823105096817,
0.734082818031311,
-0.3638918995857239,
0.16826054453849792,
-0.009951148182153702,
-0.0291480403393507,
-0.17380480468273163,
-0.8645948171615601,
0.20097438991069794,
0.015763655304908752,
-0.5294916033744812,
0.0230797678232193,
0.43632712960243225,
-0.2035229653120041,
-0.8320164084434509,
0.1254984736442566,
0.5175060629844666,
0.01788933202624321,
-0.10944242030382156,
-0.5456024408340454,
0.08944106847047806,
0.07811626046895981,
-0.4688754379749298,
0.37574973702430725,
0.39890891313552856,
-0.5861055254936218,
0.9770368337631226,
0.6595986485481262,
0.20407356321811676,
0.40331411361694336,
0.122830830514431,
0.6550981998443604,
-0.7714977860450745,
-0.16993732750415802,
-0.9727157354354858,
0.06787652522325516,
0.035157959908246994,
-0.29099076986312866,
0.4053446054458618,
0.28517207503318787,
0.8316149115562439,
-0.05750015750527382,
0.7341665625572205,
0.4171411395072937,
0.11320677399635315,
-0.458484023809433,
0.38743144273757935,
-0.2233123779296875,
0.3574674427509308,
-0.24306078255176544,
-1.2662291526794434,
-0.13024979829788208,
0.7357183694839478,
-0.6870936155319214,
0.3231015205383301,
0.9799754023551941,
0.7160193920135498,
0.15416161715984344,
0.2373962253332138,
0.12498217076063156,
0.22802384197711945,
0.20130546391010284,
0.9582873582839966,
0.71165531873703,
-0.0942109152674675,
0.1901552677154541,
-0.31549981236457825,
-0.355385959148407,
-0.049204498529434204,
-0.666195809841156,
-0.8730738162994385,
-0.36211347579956055,
-0.17463302612304688,
-0.02083408832550049,
0.08341877162456512,
0.9383554458618164,
0.3604937493801117,
-0.5527215003967285,
-0.18595537543296814,
-0.18129979074001312,
0.2887459993362427,
-0.014516322873532772,
-0.2295709252357483,
0.26120951771736145,
-0.4057699143886566,
-0.694075882434845,
0.057710565626621246,
0.12377774715423584,
-0.15607254207134247,
-0.6028013229370117,
0.055095870047807693,
0.17199338972568512,
0.6658365726470947,
0.39981305599212646,
-0.012753992341458797,
-0.8089704513549805,
-0.3678750693798065,
0.18814367055892944,
-0.2400641143321991,
-0.06909443438053131,
0.9789361357688904,
-0.9565131068229675,
0.4162033498287201,
0.23732398450374603,
0.1992497742176056,
0.7073391675949097,
-0.2753840684890747,
0.36659377813339233,
-0.3832162618637085,
0.12059678882360458,
0.31976592540740967,
0.35384663939476013,
0.3201614022254944,
-0.09977678954601288,
0.17937137186527252,
0.1377287358045578,
-0.5535818934440613,
-0.5816104412078857,
0.5064789056777954,
-0.4398610591888428,
-0.39570075273513794,
0.9486237168312073,
0.3066362142562866,
-0.32527464628219604,
0.07917885482311249,
-0.14608757197856903,
0.06682546436786652,
-0.1743553876876831,
1.0268256664276123,
1.153415322303772,
-0.23684585094451904,
-0.02227598987519741,
-0.7267681956291199,
0.1727004498243332,
0.878768265247345,
-0.21377289295196533,
0.04207479581236839,
0.46078747510910034,
0.3228197991847992,
0.29818373918533325,
0.33234354853630066,
-0.2684440314769745,
0.11390435695648193,
-0.015431903302669525,
0.09725306928157806,
0.11189624667167664,
-0.14985691010951996,
-0.214756041765213,
-0.15558035671710968,
0.2690931260585785,
0.2675313651561737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18059v1 | RAPTOR: Recursive Abstractive Processing for Tree-Organized Retrieval | 2024-01-31T18:30:21 | 2024-01-31T18:30:21 | Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh Khanna, Anna Goldie, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented language models can better adapt to changes in world
state and incorporate long-tail knowledge. However, most existing methods
retrieve only short contiguous chunks from a retrieval corpus, limiting
holistic understanding of the overall document context. We introduce the novel
approach of recursively embedding, clustering, and summarizing chunks of text,
constructing a tree with differing levels of summarization from the bottom up.
At inference time, our RAPTOR model retrieves from this tree, integrating
information across lengthy documents at different levels of abstraction.
Controlled experiments show that retrieval with recursive summaries offers
significant improvements over traditional retrieval-augmented LMs on several
tasks. On question-answering tasks that involve complex, multi-step reasoning,
we show state-of-the-art results; for example, by coupling RAPTOR retrieval
with the use of GPT-4, we can improve the best performance on the QuALITY
benchmark by 20% in absolute accuracy. | [
-0.3904757499694824,
-0.8263790011405945,
0.6254738569259644,
-0.10610072314739227,
-0.21280668675899506,
0.7964012026786804,
0.28055790066719055,
-0.8041788339614868,
0.39875537157058716,
0.11518772691488266,
-0.09921290725469589,
-0.5047327280044556,
-0.78480464220047,
0.23944734036922455,
-0.7667908668518066,
0.9734521508216858,
-0.0463852733373642,
-0.5845319032669067,
-0.0017644049366936088,
0.021160854026675224,
-0.21272370219230652,
-0.6078572273254395,
-0.6013586521148682,
-0.4614562690258026,
0.5113837122917175,
0.11688487976789474,
0.7128915786743164,
0.7389464378356934,
0.4992660880088806,
0.2861326038837433,
-0.39853039383888245,
0.14543412625789642,
-0.28628358244895935,
0.49303072690963745,
-0.34657344222068787,
-0.36399081349372864,
-0.3604680597782135,
-0.2460334151983261,
0.6810266971588135,
0.5389798283576965,
-0.22846457362174988,
-0.06737504154443741,
-0.22631825506687164,
0.4975379407405853,
-0.8388591408729553,
0.1381184309720993,
-0.5205935835838318,
0.26332300901412964,
0.056602321565151215,
-0.5149978995323181,
-0.5574718117713928,
-0.2591380774974823,
0.09225580841302872,
-0.5382547378540039,
0.31863853335380554,
-0.054654572159051895,
0.4899704158306122,
0.20957793295383453,
-0.3236890137195587,
-0.4245707094669342,
-0.7522222995758057,
0.6764568090438843,
-0.3935890197753906,
0.3913017213344574,
0.29847195744514465,
0.3254798352718353,
0.026652928441762924,
-1.0946885347366333,
-0.21153569221496582,
0.0561370849609375,
-0.2440458983182907,
0.28555795550346375,
-0.5699072480201721,
0.08371900022029877,
0.21610380709171295,
0.6085488796234131,
-0.21351364254951477,
-0.3455786108970642,
-0.345293790102005,
-0.014264382421970367,
0.3146786093711853,
-0.0562165193259716,
0.41033005714416504,
-0.2216733694076538,
-0.052847716957330704,
-0.11849218606948853,
-0.42148715257644653,
0.1520160585641861,
-0.02753354422748089,
0.2741221487522125,
0.3671286702156067,
0.5121762156486511,
0.01955074444413185,
0.7953358888626099,
0.31244224309921265,
-0.18223226070404053,
0.16138394176959991,
-0.5293740034103394,
-0.01683846302330494,
0.05238276720046997,
0.34640204906463623,
0.13951270282268524,
-0.04611204192042351,
-0.39935851097106934,
-0.47562873363494873,
-0.03467162325978279,
0.3440130352973938,
-0.9054257869720459,
-0.023730579763650894,
0.348962664604187,
-0.3080262243747711,
-0.2930930554866791,
-0.047225434333086014,
-0.4721396565437317,
0.05327139422297478,
-0.05092867463827133,
0.24605342745780945,
-0.5996394753456116,
-0.2636420726776123,
0.0405830480158329,
-0.308108389377594,
0.1720351129770279,
0.3302765488624573,
-0.9950595498085022,
0.8173598051071167,
0.7816977500915527,
1.398990273475647,
-0.18304844200611115,
0.019767887890338898,
-0.9875132441520691,
0.1815473735332489,
-0.40252628922462463,
1.0062644481658936,
-0.9879981875419617,
-0.6005566716194153,
-0.23137757182121277,
-0.09179399907588959,
-0.053376324474811554,
-0.4124309718608856,
0.46453532576560974,
-0.8637556433677673,
0.07344959676265717,
-0.01859445683658123,
-0.4750654101371765,
-0.21992164850234985,
0.46966832876205444,
-0.6101047396659851,
1.2221723794937134,
0.29901033639907837,
-1.025856852531433,
-0.12377627938985825,
-0.7864058017730713,
-0.5381147861480713,
-0.006696101278066635,
-0.1648353487253189,
-0.051401618868112564,
0.08685015887022018,
0.4377899169921875,
0.16183006763458252,
0.11692879348993301,
-0.06541463732719421,
0.350320428609848,
-0.6079293489456177,
-0.15105949342250824,
0.20611795783042908,
0.39962470531463623,
0.28474634885787964,
0.07845467329025269,
0.1408587545156479,
-0.43314796686172485,
-0.09033335745334625,
-0.06146950274705887,
-0.35067328810691833,
-0.5976639986038208,
0.17658084630966187,
-0.24109987914562225,
0.12558546662330627,
0.15924187004566193,
-0.7808089852333069,
0.3546203374862671,
-0.6412400007247925,
0.6261003613471985,
0.28690946102142334,
0.1813855916261673,
0.5177919864654541,
-0.3745027482509613,
0.72261643409729,
0.16689462959766388,
-0.24775533378124237,
-0.718264102935791,
-0.23144470155239105,
-0.2390846461057663,
-0.03177247568964958,
0.2908543646335602,
0.4545743465423584,
-0.6665098667144775,
0.08468611538410187,
-0.28270527720451355,
-0.22653044760227203,
-0.4274478554725647,
-0.3167034387588501,
0.37415534257888794,
0.4998926818370819,
0.49601486325263977,
-0.36009669303894043,
-0.6209022402763367,
-0.707068145275116,
-0.12499001622200012,
-0.007644832134246826,
-0.014349727891385555,
0.09766300022602081,
0.6433722972869873,
-0.08998019993305206,
0.9334065914154053,
-0.595003604888916,
-0.0363057479262352,
-0.3244830369949341,
0.4242737889289856,
0.3186274766921997,
0.34300366044044495,
0.4619303047657013,
-0.9572969079017639,
-0.33881253004074097,
0.2766513526439667,
-0.3773702085018158,
0.11745703965425491,
0.1982329785823822,
0.14069980382919312,
-0.05907706171274185,
0.6790177226066589,
-0.747032880783081,
0.2526131570339203,
0.3246192932128906,
-0.13695630431175232,
0.3230672776699066,
-0.2831687331199646,
0.13141803443431854,
-1.263949990272522,
0.09653211385011673,
-0.2576606571674347,
-0.5913745760917664,
-0.5286691188812256,
0.3706406354904175,
-0.07340606302022934,
0.07945016771554947,
-0.11361894011497498,
0.21797585487365723,
-0.5351632833480835,
-0.6951739192008972,
-0.5361830592155457,
0.48184478282928467,
0.12056584656238556,
0.12196022272109985,
0.05346892029047012,
1.0491303205490112,
0.28617194294929504,
-0.510153591632843,
0.10263682156801224,
0.3854275345802307,
-0.11821335554122925,
0.25870588421821594,
-0.8454587459564209,
0.3054390251636505,
-0.5051962733268738,
0.4267498850822449,
-0.9501726627349854,
-0.1215292289853096,
0.00374251464381814,
-0.6869615316390991,
0.2705855369567871,
-0.4999365210533142,
-0.5193105936050415,
-0.06722959131002426,
-0.4048810303211212,
0.512134850025177,
0.3587455153465271,
-0.3789742588996887,
0.9966201186180115,
0.41153600811958313,
-0.3637365698814392,
-0.8542323112487793,
-0.4732065796852112,
0.1124032512307167,
0.2042333334684372,
-0.3560585379600525,
0.9411492347717285,
0.05348607152700424,
-0.37079912424087524,
0.15196913480758667,
-0.1855093389749527,
0.018428780138492584,
-0.01765763759613037,
0.11968521028757095,
-0.06173751875758171,
-0.07469123601913452,
0.27539440989494324,
0.21646761894226074,
-0.24518081545829773,
-0.05743309110403061,
-0.22898723185062408,
0.4462054669857025,
-0.29903846979141235,
-0.08246103674173355,
0.07686158269643784,
0.5934430360794067,
0.628521203994751,
-0.5203056335449219,
0.42802655696868896,
0.23676881194114685,
-0.4519893229007721,
0.13759078085422516,
-0.22546789050102234,
-0.1849401295185089,
-0.36632829904556274,
0.3006907105445862,
-0.6757768392562866,
-1.0017616748809814,
0.4739340543746948,
-0.10922352969646454,
0.46762311458587646,
0.37702012062072754,
0.17303113639354706,
-0.07489384710788727,
1.3097859621047974,
0.635869026184082,
-0.05881191045045853,
0.4383973777294159,
-0.4409046471118927,
0.18592801690101624,
-1.005385398864746,
-0.18421418964862823,
-0.5428712368011475,
-0.2521849274635315,
-0.536657989025116,
-0.3617599904537201,
0.1975473314523697,
0.1675165891647339,
-0.14340521395206451,
0.2213653177022934,
-0.7674875855445862,
0.7042111158370972,
0.40536952018737793,
-0.11760519444942474,
0.8407038450241089,
0.00908955279737711,
-0.32496747374534607,
0.201211079955101,
-0.4716891050338745,
-0.4075756371021271,
0.6633449196815491,
0.20243990421295166,
0.5086553692817688,
0.24437011778354645,
0.8234738111495972,
0.4184556305408478,
0.4865579307079315,
-0.9873848557472229,
0.2049637883901596,
-0.05300140753388405,
-0.4243994951248169,
-0.1098095178604126,
-0.18234899640083313,
-1.0077645778656006,
0.669132649898529,
0.05834738537669182,
-0.8570425510406494,
-0.026082957163453102,
-0.025251125916838646,
-0.484941691160202,
0.32716628909111023,
-0.49654096364974976,
0.2865865230560303,
0.0882246270775795,
-0.06688808649778366,
-0.18982379138469696,
-0.6521298289299011,
0.36891084909439087,
-0.06182757392525673,
0.28488001227378845,
0.18058684468269348,
-0.2517932057380676,
0.7420350313186646,
-0.3304220139980316,
0.49951425194740295,
-0.06692113727331161,
0.10080041736364365,
0.21808408200740814,
0.2800770103931427,
0.6751503944396973,
-0.25199493765830994,
-0.09180273860692978,
-0.3769626319408417,
0.6244660019874573,
-0.32595810294151306,
-0.9101464748382568,
0.7302771806716919,
-0.855006217956543,
-0.6428185701370239,
-0.9155932664871216,
-0.6832057237625122,
-0.13314802944660187,
0.31787005066871643,
0.08193323016166687,
0.38039109110832214,
0.035534221678972244,
0.3004117012023926,
0.4012548625469208,
0.11191234737634659,
0.5011999011039734,
0.5266369581222534,
-0.701455295085907,
-0.22098533809185028,
0.4409390091896057,
0.16382288932800293,
0.0951162800192833,
0.784430205821991,
0.12636849284172058,
-0.3982616364955902,
-0.8008803129196167,
-0.10074666142463684,
0.09569676220417023,
-0.715614914894104,
-0.22457286715507507,
-0.9925624132156372,
-0.4817976653575897,
-0.010201357305049896,
-0.07696261256933212,
-0.2636653780937195,
-0.4217449724674225,
0.027565069496631622,
-0.5674599409103394,
0.43200603127479553,
1.0511705875396729,
-0.06991646438837051,
0.2894667387008667,
-0.8635197877883911,
0.37090304493904114,
0.06432311236858368,
0.30167239904403687,
0.20090745389461517,
-0.6341516971588135,
-0.13834510743618011,
-0.11732738465070724,
-0.4062720835208893,
-0.7684985995292664,
0.4229317009449005,
0.12930768728256226,
0.2128797322511673,
0.040249302983284,
0.04252179339528084,
0.7011906504631042,
-0.5228161811828613,
0.4636760950088501,
0.04144744947552681,
-0.8025010824203491,
0.6728940010070801,
-0.20441299676895142,
0.4602634012699127,
0.4003033936023712,
0.4295494258403778,
-0.6655340194702148,
-0.2742694020271301,
-0.5172094702720642,
-0.8299384117126465,
0.5928288102149963,
0.4330170154571533,
0.024659879505634308,
-0.1873914748430252,
0.5475717782974243,
-0.04847333952784538,
-0.049247417598962784,
-0.40733006596565247,
-0.08409201353788376,
-0.30430203676223755,
0.006528813391923904,
0.04387690871953964,
-0.35758906602859497,
0.012638193555176258,
-0.2879357933998108,
0.37560519576072693,
-0.12904123961925507,
0.20268599689006805,
0.4225867986679077,
-0.21905475854873657,
-0.13037283718585968,
0.48000767827033997,
0.46235018968582153,
0.9746986031532288,
-0.6235484480857849,
0.5707622170448303,
0.06268982589244843,
-0.5854277014732361,
0.24262598156929016,
0.2672158479690552,
-0.3063369691371918,
0.2045566737651825,
0.3532507121562958,
0.21352022886276245,
0.4871739447116852,
-0.48456451296806335,
0.2147291600704193,
-0.1965680718421936,
-0.13973169028759003,
-0.3556576371192932,
-0.09325811266899109,
0.28771623969078064,
0.24797016382217407,
0.841286838054657,
-0.07036111503839493,
0.35019373893737793,
-0.57732093334198,
0.44274836778640747,
0.26432356238365173,
-0.218553826212883,
-0.4049793481826782,
0.31424352526664734,
0.06141795590519905,
-0.40219828486442566,
0.5041152238845825,
0.033045701682567596,
-0.3390868306159973,
0.41857534646987915,
0.8176448941230774,
0.5725306272506714,
-0.26983779668807983,
0.22274647653102875,
0.5675826668739319,
0.10178536176681519,
-0.10613466799259186,
0.367279976606369,
-0.4204942286014557,
-0.8095967769622803,
-0.9363398551940918,
-0.6793898344039917,
-0.5356022715568542,
-0.022467734292149544,
-0.6995707154273987,
-0.47766074538230896,
-0.5491783022880554,
-0.15785297751426697,
0.275940865278244,
0.0064486851915717125,
-0.07634691148996353,
0.04317767545580864,
-0.3500146269798279,
1.0639792680740356,
-0.388295978307724,
0.6544275283813477,
0.5312745571136475,
-0.6507626175880432,
-0.5597930550575256,
-0.23260705173015594,
-0.2592523396015167,
-0.5914613008499146,
0.775504469871521,
0.17740391194820404,
-0.6524290442466736,
0.4564380645751953,
-0.4237412214279175,
-1.0921677350997925,
1.125072956085205,
0.0832856222987175,
-0.5876545906066895,
-0.3110399544239044,
-0.3343810439109802,
0.6256945729255676,
-0.4751370847225189,
0.5148470401763916,
0.7584874629974365,
0.251708060503006,
0.519594669342041,
-0.5513089299201965,
-0.06717544049024582,
-0.45260584354400635,
0.003535935888066888,
0.5693322420120239,
-0.21044938266277313,
0.7974249720573425,
-0.3146789073944092,
-0.5555686950683594,
0.0025430943351238966,
0.6088270545005798,
0.28629979491233826,
0.13866150379180908,
0.36949676275253296,
0.5311076045036316,
0.7690161466598511,
-0.07725149393081665,
1.3525128364562988,
-0.5790602564811707,
0.22780132293701172,
1.2965539693832397,
0.07615770399570465,
1.0937031507492065,
0.4301421344280243,
-0.18543526530265808,
0.834141194820404,
0.5850279331207275,
0.436994343996048,
0.36639198660850525,
-0.03744741529226303,
-0.48156529664993286,
-0.049410317093133926,
-0.3397529423236847,
-0.30507639050483704,
0.27674970030784607,
0.413540780544281,
-0.49871936440467834,
-0.5652596354484558,
-0.23960772156715393,
-0.14610956609249115,
0.14810194075107574,
-0.37604284286499023,
0.7873194813728333,
0.10975626856088638,
-0.8418041467666626,
0.4412524700164795,
0.15400229394435883,
0.5001934766769409,
-0.3761616349220276,
-0.3109581172466278,
-0.28756973147392273,
0.03323318436741829,
-0.509405255317688,
-0.9671269655227661,
0.6206373572349548,
0.12171037495136261,
-0.3524339497089386,
-0.25255918502807617,
0.7291305661201477,
-0.23897109925746918,
-0.43124812841415405,
0.40100041031837463,
0.6644282937049866,
0.2488897442817688,
-0.17313668131828308,
-0.48269543051719666,
0.00493277283385396,
-0.4385185241699219,
-0.11091124266386032,
0.19649013876914978,
0.19168999791145325,
-0.057675499469041824,
0.7314953207969666,
0.7387030124664307,
-0.01855216547846794,
-0.1861969530582428,
0.26998260617256165,
0.8820151686668396,
-0.913619339466095,
-0.5573019981384277,
-0.7342965602874756,
0.17334392666816711,
-0.011612042784690857,
0.2371838390827179,
0.5532670021057129,
0.6420392394065857,
0.7378239035606384,
0.30990511178970337,
0.9170903563499451,
-0.08460702002048492,
0.7631811499595642,
-0.293946236371994,
0.295685738325119,
-0.2880961000919342,
0.18752522766590118,
-0.1639648973941803,
-0.8646166324615479,
-0.3338797688484192,
0.6361492872238159,
-0.42073628306388855,
0.10626675933599472,
0.7257363796234131,
0.4741385877132416,
-0.26941564679145813,
-0.031216029077768326,
0.31530627608299255,
0.275845468044281,
0.5184171795845032,
0.5311827659606934,
0.8962007164955139,
-0.4674359858036041,
0.6194448471069336,
0.002194396685808897,
-0.06742864847183228,
-0.10031353682279587,
-0.5809835195541382,
-0.541652500629425,
-0.6437883377075195,
0.07652613520622253,
-0.19705480337142944,
0.22474344074726105,
0.7433784604072571,
0.5266493558883667,
-0.7193548679351807,
-0.023060861974954605,
-0.294654905796051,
0.2927089333534241,
-0.1922220140695572,
-0.24486523866653442,
0.45620298385620117,
-0.3948885500431061,
-0.6531899571418762,
0.4545111358165741,
0.6023319959640503,
0.16205067932605743,
-0.15474769473075867,
0.03614910691976547,
-0.4921122193336487,
-0.10406914353370667,
0.9871580600738525,
0.44385334849357605,
-0.7491755485534668,
-0.5032229423522949,
0.1211857795715332,
0.15163689851760864,
0.4688135087490082,
0.9366393685340881,
-1.0257025957107544,
0.5699608325958252,
0.4487003684043884,
0.6940040588378906,
0.9704676270484924,
0.5268594026565552,
0.5571012496948242,
-0.7522481083869934,
-0.14774064719676971,
0.5148748159408569,
0.3862071633338928,
0.42689910531044006,
-0.19119849801063538,
0.590099036693573,
-0.14114585518836975,
-0.27886006236076355,
-0.5606316924095154,
0.24332238733768463,
-0.7358245849609375,
-0.32030192017555237,
0.7084043025970459,
-0.10979609936475754,
-0.22715918719768524,
-0.37502413988113403,
-0.3297893702983856,
0.20911383628845215,
-0.49025091528892517,
0.6706941723823547,
0.6901353597640991,
-0.4215922951698303,
-0.7433391213417053,
-0.2283412516117096,
0.36056068539619446,
-0.05439060926437378,
-0.8548241257667542,
-0.06425396353006363,
0.4050408899784088,
0.3934449553489685,
0.7177008986473083,
0.7757117748260498,
-0.3059972822666168,
0.30264925956726074,
-0.04114362597465515,
-0.20893847942352295,
-0.2684699296951294,
-0.2722737789154053,
-0.11509204655885696,
0.519049882888794,
0.1920054405927658,
-0.05022791773080826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18058v1 | LongAlign: A Recipe for Long Context Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T18:29:39 | 2024-01-31T18:29:39 | Yushi Bai, Xin Lv, Jiajie Zhang, Yuze He, Ji Qi, Lei Hou, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Extending large language models to effectively handle long contexts requires
instruction fine-tuning on input sequences of similar length. To address this,
we present LongAlign -- a recipe of the instruction data, training, and
evaluation for long context alignment. First, we construct a long
instruction-following dataset using Self-Instruct. To ensure the data
diversity, it covers a broad range of tasks from various long context sources.
Second, we adopt the packing and sorted batching strategies to speed up
supervised fine-tuning on data with varied length distributions. Additionally,
we develop a loss weighting method to balance the contribution to the loss
across different sequences during packing training. Third, we introduce the
LongBench-Chat benchmark for evaluating instruction-following capabilities on
queries of 10k-100k in length. Experiments show that LongAlign outperforms
existing recipes for LLMs in long context tasks by up to 30\%, while also
maintaining their proficiency in handling short, generic tasks. The code, data,
and long-aligned models are open-sourced at https://github.com/THUDM/LongAlign. | [
-0.09681714326143265,
-0.6254040002822876,
0.5451382994651794,
0.31519943475723267,
-0.044644687324762344,
-0.25850018858909607,
-0.6667336821556091,
-0.28368109464645386,
0.13656583428382874,
0.6980870366096497,
-0.6975225210189819,
-0.7655033469200134,
-0.40429773926734924,
-0.08865352720022202,
-0.5479209423065186,
0.9285199046134949,
-0.2762684226036072,
-0.024418048560619354,
-0.3323335349559784,
-0.270746648311615,
-0.814214825630188,
-0.3091540038585663,
-0.5536853671073914,
-0.14072561264038086,
0.7343804240226746,
0.6063103079795837,
0.5974889397621155,
1.1108168363571167,
0.3004077076911926,
0.25746041536331177,
0.20620837807655334,
0.025074299424886703,
-0.737554669380188,
0.3966563642024994,
-0.34061428904533386,
-0.23529976606369019,
-0.4994260370731354,
-0.24322421848773956,
0.7848758101463318,
0.7513677477836609,
-0.2685750424861908,
0.16381646692752838,
0.37890172004699707,
0.926240086555481,
-0.6044666171073914,
0.0886395126581192,
-0.14214320480823517,
-0.16926100850105286,
-0.5869451761245728,
-0.015409549698233604,
-0.4873293340206146,
-0.1411019265651703,
-0.08368473500013351,
-0.5907794237136841,
-0.10985725373029709,
0.22172315418720245,
0.2956927716732025,
0.5216614007949829,
-0.6161924004554749,
-0.47335419058799744,
-0.6037814021110535,
0.8534283638000488,
-0.6314702033996582,
0.5954228043556213,
0.4199533760547638,
0.4148646593093872,
-0.5189818739891052,
-0.6639177799224854,
-0.2218109369277954,
0.09493474662303925,
0.067874014377594,
0.04623007774353027,
0.3052111268043518,
0.09780523180961609,
0.17975689470767975,
0.25703486800193787,
-0.8478443622589111,
0.694736123085022,
-0.38479503989219666,
0.16160428524017334,
0.5887486338615417,
0.06621377170085907,
0.10315869748592377,
0.2066381871700287,
-0.5099531412124634,
-0.053297363221645355,
-0.9472782015800476,
0.08424703031778336,
0.307885080575943,
0.46636155247688293,
-0.27145108580589294,
0.5704726576805115,
-0.40484654903411865,
1.0227668285369873,
0.19906999170780182,
-0.0905604287981987,
0.043764352798461914,
-0.11960568279027939,
-0.2700856626033783,
0.6155813336372375,
0.6655741333961487,
0.6085618138313293,
0.14996662735939026,
-0.05397692695260048,
-0.22440572082996368,
-0.36763229966163635,
0.10323034226894379,
-0.8624226450920105,
-0.07945610582828522,
0.06519733369350433,
-0.18890845775604248,
0.0675937607884407,
-0.17669101059436798,
-0.6752409338951111,
-0.2616882622241974,
-0.6345654129981995,
0.2617552876472473,
-0.25164178013801575,
0.19432732462882996,
0.3814760148525238,
0.2310234159231186,
0.49101853370666504,
0.21573051810264587,
-1.0846775770187378,
0.36932095885276794,
1.2618471384048462,
0.6781082153320312,
-0.48518264293670654,
-0.3985360860824585,
-0.7628520727157593,
0.34913235902786255,
-0.26982489228248596,
0.39965325593948364,
-0.6119397878646851,
-0.16787618398666382,
0.214928537607193,
0.41267240047454834,
0.028756629675626755,
-0.38168394565582275,
0.5466621518135071,
-0.34504207968711853,
0.4659891724586487,
-0.16240163147449493,
-1.0971633195877075,
0.11784340441226959,
0.24515005946159363,
-0.6833662390708923,
0.9816078543663025,
0.05127887800335884,
-0.3090793490409851,
0.3406550884246826,
-0.5321671962738037,
-0.8253672122955322,
-0.06870277225971222,
-0.15297625958919525,
-0.3173969089984894,
-0.14389626681804657,
0.24820321798324585,
0.5910247564315796,
-0.23201321065425873,
0.28996261954307556,
-0.42689642310142517,
-0.6017649173736572,
0.03238232061266899,
-0.3974796533584595,
0.6491498351097107,
0.026969507336616516,
-0.38452255725860596,
0.2568030059337616,
-0.5536304712295532,
0.017210114747285843,
0.04257800430059433,
-0.3743692636489868,
-0.47973254323005676,
0.1425076127052307,
-0.23643216490745544,
-0.03031107597053051,
0.23126576840877533,
-0.18784648180007935,
0.5919688940048218,
-0.31264472007751465,
0.4907877743244171,
0.7958040833473206,
-0.31221574544906616,
0.6387759447097778,
-0.11489768326282501,
0.42287057638168335,
-0.15178875625133514,
0.15639813244342804,
-0.28220614790916443,
-0.13348940014839172,
-0.6646650433540344,
-0.11429279297590256,
0.2898189127445221,
0.4521196484565735,
-0.4040811061859131,
0.6542032361030579,
-0.6991748809814453,
-0.07090144604444504,
-0.5104520916938782,
0.4875544011592865,
0.475786954164505,
0.5609428286552429,
0.5266525745391846,
-0.35051220655441284,
-0.3408176302909851,
-0.8325415849685669,
-0.019699998199939728,
0.4578036963939667,
0.026220520958304405,
0.024636629968881607,
0.34317126870155334,
-0.16272523999214172,
0.7247177958488464,
-0.5384325981140137,
-0.24207623302936554,
0.013107440434396267,
0.015785150229930878,
0.20880386233329773,
0.736496090888977,
0.26267683506011963,
-0.36950528621673584,
-0.4838932752609253,
-0.09177171438932419,
-0.6153632998466492,
0.11029917001724243,
-0.07158307731151581,
-0.5140720009803772,
0.4551393389701843,
0.9560012221336365,
-0.6951774954795837,
0.28357812762260437,
0.6928273439407349,
-0.12839753925800323,
0.409496933221817,
0.09359988570213318,
0.06312986463308334,
-1.3695032596588135,
-0.1754673719406128,
-0.0029429954010993242,
-0.4251095652580261,
-0.3215457499027252,
0.011492337100207806,
0.3921256363391876,
-0.15920889377593994,
-0.3939741551876068,
0.6649965643882751,
-0.6240858435630798,
0.024659018963575363,
-0.16475337743759155,
-0.006855607032775879,
0.05669182166457176,
0.42509013414382935,
-0.06593267619609833,
0.8461724519729614,
0.5625188946723938,
-0.5224516987800598,
0.5331767797470093,
-0.10228926688432693,
-0.6993156671524048,
0.6091023683547974,
-0.506354033946991,
0.2612517178058624,
0.021568771451711655,
0.5030930638313293,
-0.7832720875740051,
-0.4636652171611786,
0.33255699276924133,
-0.01452269684523344,
0.7713205218315125,
-0.5891269445419312,
-0.49165746569633484,
-0.40813034772872925,
-0.15924769639968872,
0.707602858543396,
0.3926638662815094,
-0.744067370891571,
0.1272265613079071,
0.026461707428097725,
-0.1838022619485855,
-0.755583643913269,
-0.571486234664917,
0.04916362091898918,
-0.45636287331581116,
-0.4886975884437561,
0.5698923468589783,
-0.12154136598110199,
0.09133079648017883,
-0.15608759224414825,
-0.24337638914585114,
-0.04721478000283241,
-0.07504184544086456,
0.27201342582702637,
-0.1852787882089615,
-0.5357224345207214,
0.46461325883865356,
0.16033057868480682,
-0.05851392075419426,
0.11321219801902771,
-0.5467848181724548,
0.6114490032196045,
0.0022512779105454683,
-0.6838005781173706,
-0.44860273599624634,
0.42256495356559753,
0.43891844153404236,
-0.21535484492778778,
0.716421365737915,
0.5075626969337463,
-0.3195802867412567,
-0.32928577065467834,
-0.5074684619903564,
-0.08784737437963486,
-0.5064586997032166,
0.41560909152030945,
-0.08059487491846085,
-0.8494158983230591,
0.2689597010612488,
-0.05055283382534981,
0.13921551406383514,
0.1972421109676361,
0.26691219210624695,
-0.3571902811527252,
0.9613034725189209,
0.6905499696731567,
-0.40806344151496887,
0.42385154962539673,
0.011876260861754417,
0.22210539877414703,
-0.6263531446456909,
0.02644926682114601,
-0.221889466047287,
-0.6472000479698181,
-0.43076828122138977,
-0.5568193793296814,
0.05630456656217575,
0.1367696225643158,
-0.3908053934574127,
0.32085493206977844,
-0.46713536977767944,
0.8653676509857178,
0.5748093128204346,
-0.014809574000537395,
-0.09157256782054901,
-0.20706965029239655,
0.3508589565753937,
0.1081775575876236,
-0.48699402809143066,
-0.2651163637638092,
0.8799846768379211,
0.33257609605789185,
1.18952214717865,
0.13884837925434113,
1.086943507194519,
0.006622911896556616,
0.12482088059186935,
-1.0981210470199585,
0.5463663339614868,
-0.28399622440338135,
-0.48651206493377686,
-0.5391861796379089,
-0.36014723777770996,
-1.147030234336853,
-0.497658908367157,
0.12679670751094818,
-0.48713019490242004,
-0.2934798002243042,
0.19006909430027008,
-0.35557618737220764,
-0.011548737995326519,
-0.6754541993141174,
1.2398452758789062,
-0.8108856678009033,
-0.4113233983516693,
-0.10860276967287064,
-0.7971006035804749,
0.2470073401927948,
0.11204399913549423,
-0.018687568604946136,
-0.054493729025125504,
0.15233968198299408,
0.8172557353973389,
-0.2130432277917862,
1.0373040437698364,
-0.04756227135658264,
-0.3334793448448181,
0.08163388818502426,
0.006281688343733549,
0.437420517206192,
-0.12942306697368622,
-0.01005823165178299,
-0.2630276083946228,
-0.0020557325333356857,
-0.474223792552948,
-0.7730827927589417,
1.0559618473052979,
-0.3757930099964142,
-0.708629846572876,
-0.23697376251220703,
-0.5879763960838318,
-0.04553383216261864,
0.5171193480491638,
0.11659963428974152,
0.5440464615821838,
-0.2254732847213745,
0.4564998149871826,
0.6899323463439941,
-0.10684981197118759,
0.3687745928764343,
0.16460691392421722,
-0.24187088012695312,
-0.19973739981651306,
0.7260425686836243,
0.09861975163221359,
0.2733546793460846,
0.5807159543037415,
0.08271793276071548,
-0.20250920951366425,
-0.28623083233833313,
-0.6241046190261841,
0.03663059324026108,
-0.7537940144538879,
-0.43126508593559265,
0.034204572439193726,
-0.23575539886951447,
-0.5010332465171814,
-0.2894250154495239,
-0.5956063270568848,
-0.30342209339141846,
-0.2827657461166382,
0.1369968056678772,
0.274417906999588,
0.6372756361961365,
0.4630984961986542,
0.45756837725639343,
-0.711126446723938,
-0.12855523824691772,
0.31531092524528503,
0.6830257177352905,
-0.14092595875263214,
-0.4276833236217499,
-0.4832065999507904,
0.19762980937957764,
-0.28335514664649963,
-0.567246675491333,
0.09888389706611633,
0.2945926785469055,
0.2819754183292389,
0.47362014651298523,
0.15114544332027435,
1.0810325145721436,
-0.6364637613296509,
0.6259333491325378,
0.2683946192264557,
-0.6886681318283081,
0.43725618720054626,
-0.2925216555595398,
0.672042191028595,
0.6878833770751953,
0.5001944899559021,
-0.5932241082191467,
-0.003617786569520831,
0.0133269764482975,
-1.0224952697753906,
0.3984149992465973,
-0.20548921823501587,
0.12453519552946091,
-0.17655041813850403,
0.4357263445854187,
0.23324500024318695,
-0.10628340393304825,
-0.6090303659439087,
-0.035617757588624954,
-0.014001842588186264,
-0.7606873512268066,
-0.1911371797323227,
-0.15257170796394348,
-0.48896080255508423,
-0.20097455382347107,
0.5124867558479309,
-0.19719983637332916,
0.07750209420919418,
-0.23486077785491943,
-0.34673652052879333,
0.025414159521460533,
0.3404894769191742,
0.8524962663650513,
0.8520106077194214,
-0.10547783970832825,
0.0910482406616211,
0.08222805708646774,
0.03009418211877346,
-0.10855499655008316,
0.25999918580055237,
0.3116673231124878,
-0.38207852840423584,
0.3898662328720093,
0.6894378066062927,
0.5953142642974854,
-0.4898686110973358,
0.5364282727241516,
-0.04751944914460182,
-0.005257273092865944,
-0.421728253364563,
0.09040385484695435,
0.38610556721687317,
0.18702878057956696,
-0.031735848635435104,
-0.5697435140609741,
0.05268210545182228,
-0.4997967779636383,
0.18836535513401031,
0.3754386603832245,
-0.41002145409584045,
-0.10962893813848495,
0.2957814931869507,
0.22603924572467804,
-0.3019007444381714,
1.0913106203079224,
-0.12676115334033966,
-0.27576032280921936,
0.5130673050880432,
0.7763839364051819,
0.5578665733337402,
-0.20953525602817535,
-0.27816975116729736,
0.251853883266449,
-0.1118948757648468,
-0.44785410165786743,
-0.16318155825138092,
-0.15870140492916107,
-0.2008267641067505,
-0.6667912602424622,
-0.4797099828720093,
-0.10817716270685196,
0.2052660435438156,
-0.8655074238777161,
0.5516493320465088,
-0.21928194165229797,
0.02237907610833645,
-0.09136567264795303,
-0.19687789678573608,
-0.7153822183609009,
-0.030407292768359184,
0.354051411151886,
0.8656481504440308,
-0.6257786154747009,
1.000996470451355,
0.4365806579589844,
0.02363402582705021,
-0.5636419057846069,
-0.000034907170629594475,
0.17939966917037964,
-0.9266546964645386,
0.6049200892448425,
0.6805323362350464,
-0.1000494584441185,
-0.247871533036232,
-0.7085191607475281,
-0.9676450490951538,
1.039806842803955,
0.2277260720729828,
-1.082688570022583,
-0.24044689536094666,
0.19393190741539001,
0.2809525728225708,
-0.42777183651924133,
-0.39613643288612366,
0.4873344302177429,
0.28263381123542786,
0.07587838172912598,
-0.8842471241950989,
0.041422635316848755,
-0.01011245884001255,
-0.39626917243003845,
0.6799303293228149,
-0.3806804120540619,
0.31840384006500244,
-0.010587029159069061,
-0.1909879744052887,
0.2222561091184616,
0.825995922088623,
-0.03678014129400253,
0.43408456444740295,
0.395214319229126,
0.8038532137870789,
0.5286781787872314,
0.0054546743631362915,
0.6392000317573547,
-0.5320460796356201,
0.1650063693523407,
1.7616381645202637,
-0.31782564520835876,
0.8771877884864807,
0.4280213713645935,
0.21490661799907684,
0.3894180357456207,
0.7048481702804565,
0.13009271025657654,
0.4329673945903778,
0.3418635427951813,
-0.016673026606440544,
-0.10954833030700684,
0.12677910923957825,
-0.37728145718574524,
0.44530361890792847,
0.4441763162612915,
-0.3789671063423157,
-0.15765541791915894,
-0.15146741271018982,
0.24649293720722198,
-0.05454098433256149,
-0.2525430917739868,
0.7509078979492188,
0.3165034055709839,
-1.0378118753433228,
0.9001129865646362,
-0.17615915834903717,
0.5867970585823059,
-0.4375819265842438,
-0.08150264620780945,
-0.2458113133907318,
0.24580791592597961,
-0.11865951120853424,
-1.166594386100769,
0.07130159437656403,
-0.21030981838703156,
-0.13791285455226898,
-0.43057286739349365,
0.29412952065467834,
-0.7676964998245239,
-0.38539919257164,
0.1405465304851532,
0.08243892341852188,
0.11950430274009705,
0.22850929200649261,
-0.5950585007667542,
0.055191900581121445,
-0.26394978165626526,
-0.2024179846048355,
0.5501973628997803,
0.388076514005661,
-0.2879568934440613,
0.6261857748031616,
0.26428934931755066,
-0.23909763991832733,
0.047575756907463074,
0.2884296774864197,
0.6257738471031189,
-0.7541072964668274,
-0.2534826099872589,
-0.9107905030250549,
0.43359169363975525,
-0.08331131935119629,
-0.36464211344718933,
0.5565724968910217,
0.7766560912132263,
0.9530704617500305,
-0.014522148296236992,
0.15565693378448486,
0.20614735782146454,
0.17510297894477844,
-0.877488911151886,
0.44462427496910095,
-0.5941540598869324,
0.09015273302793503,
0.2588121294975281,
-1.06967031955719,
-0.3492641746997833,
0.3160706162452698,
-0.3956453204154968,
0.01743318699300289,
0.47245413064956665,
0.8843573331832886,
-0.5979441404342651,
-0.2517910301685333,
0.003959955647587776,
-0.01625135913491249,
0.32838448882102966,
0.6129468679428101,
0.6364827156066895,
-0.09165377169847488,
0.289929062128067,
-0.3535243570804596,
-0.043540772050619125,
-0.3696966767311096,
-1.1082260608673096,
-0.7829993367195129,
-0.6223524808883667,
-0.2074185162782669,
-0.19232071936130524,
0.3444647490978241,
1.1493698358535767,
0.9913903474807739,
-0.5543166399002075,
-0.45480331778526306,
0.20679371058940887,
0.00018672729493118823,
-0.32530292868614197,
-0.19661173224449158,
0.5047482252120972,
-0.4735468924045563,
-0.6349176168441772,
0.6570038795471191,
0.14048077166080475,
0.21525125205516815,
0.08155230432748795,
-0.16521935164928436,
-0.013106022030115128,
-0.27538371086120605,
0.6920993328094482,
0.5891334414482117,
-0.7217252850532532,
-0.47461453080177307,
0.08460935205221176,
-0.19568611681461334,
0.12603922188282013,
0.6185542345046997,
-0.3978360891342163,
0.448889821767807,
0.25993865728378296,
0.6765784025192261,
0.45191413164138794,
0.18405698239803314,
0.7159712314605713,
-1.0342261791229248,
-0.02941078506410122,
0.16528165340423584,
0.33732476830482483,
0.4253917932510376,
-0.33368155360221863,
0.43573707342147827,
-0.5754695534706116,
-0.9532188773155212,
-0.8718555569648743,
0.23463791608810425,
-1.2201452255249023,
-0.18797698616981506,
1.1344462633132935,
-0.06729479134082794,
-0.42742615938186646,
0.3737570345401764,
0.01693740114569664,
0.44105395674705505,
-0.3406493365764618,
0.7460359930992126,
0.7011208534240723,
-0.09812997281551361,
-0.039492618292570114,
-0.5970415472984314,
0.4706920385360718,
0.4609573483467102,
-0.7548233866691589,
0.4059622585773468,
0.5690956115722656,
0.42938879132270813,
-0.11763712763786316,
0.2524948716163635,
0.1341957151889801,
0.16902458667755127,
-0.6616089344024658,
0.00831769872456789,
0.05719336122274399,
-0.5374916195869446,
-0.3174562156200409,
-0.3252609074115753,
0.15369254350662231,
-0.15182644128799438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18046v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18046v2 | Multipath parsing in the brain | 2024-01-31T18:07:12 | 2024-06-06T13:40:47 | Berta Franzluebbers, Donald Dunagan, Miloš Stanojević, Jan Buys, John T. Hale | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans understand sentences word-by-word, in the order that they hear them.
This incrementality entails resolving temporary ambiguities about syntactic
relationships. We investigate how humans process these syntactic ambiguities by
correlating predictions from incremental generative dependency parsers with
timecourse data from people undergoing functional neuroimaging while listening
to an audiobook. In particular, we compare competing hypotheses regarding the
number of developing syntactic analyses in play during word-by-word
comprehension: one vs more than one. This comparison involves evaluating
syntactic surprisal from a state-of-the-art dependency parser with LLM-adapted
encodings against an existing fMRI dataset. In both English and Chinese data,
we find evidence for multipath parsing. Brain regions associated with this
multipath effect include bilateral superior temporal gyrus. | [
-0.328585684299469,
-0.7327283024787903,
1.0033444166183472,
0.6627082228660583,
-0.007358359172940254,
-0.12876708805561066,
-0.04141305759549141,
-0.8050938844680786,
0.29316607117652893,
0.15468789637088776,
-0.8608521223068237,
-0.24952733516693115,
-0.5462069511413574,
0.11804523319005966,
0.00500634266063571,
0.434129923582077,
0.14901423454284668,
0.3057941496372223,
-0.2413615733385086,
-0.5552499890327454,
-0.6276144981384277,
-0.7959328889846802,
-0.608081042766571,
-0.6384875178337097,
0.7690614461898804,
0.0027742984239012003,
0.8949622511863708,
0.42446428537368774,
0.23424552381038666,
0.2966136932373047,
-0.2420283555984497,
-0.3667548596858978,
0.4850628972053528,
0.261287659406662,
-0.02438565343618393,
-0.4193252623081207,
-0.3013977110385895,
-0.1566861867904663,
0.5123266577720642,
0.8933464288711548,
-0.33649301528930664,
-0.17125700414180756,
-0.11208270490169525,
0.6279870867729187,
-0.4783978760242462,
-0.20242327451705933,
-0.07363957166671753,
0.20277139544487,
-0.43582022190093994,
-0.4406884014606476,
-0.5264557600021362,
0.07194944471120834,
0.3641478717327118,
-0.35576289892196655,
0.21240320801734924,
-0.0922541692852974,
0.7595955729484558,
0.2613678276538849,
-0.5677327513694763,
-0.30181658267974854,
-0.3825334310531616,
0.3881601393222809,
-0.5080751180648804,
0.7113585472106934,
0.3618384003639221,
0.15111000835895538,
-0.26326435804367065,
-0.539847731590271,
-0.5723721385002136,
-0.30824363231658936,
-0.5111563205718994,
0.18780755996704102,
-0.034328218549489975,
0.10971366614103317,
0.41086962819099426,
0.17837496101856232,
-0.6441179513931274,
-0.16536124050617218,
-0.39115574955940247,
-0.30018383264541626,
0.1257476508617401,
0.274657666683197,
0.5803958177566528,
-0.4984814524650574,
-0.41632750630378723,
-0.02281164564192295,
-0.2755265533924103,
0.20113138854503632,
0.5451374650001526,
0.06312163919210434,
-0.1519315391778946,
0.4779820144176483,
0.09175454825162888,
0.8883960843086243,
-0.37791574001312256,
-0.042773883789777756,
0.48207321763038635,
-0.5478978157043457,
0.0032615158706903458,
0.16894368827342987,
0.7004535794258118,
0.09440143406391144,
0.16989772021770477,
-0.3125534951686859,
0.14596502482891083,
0.41925275325775146,
0.2081831395626068,
-0.2843277156352997,
-0.07029943913221359,
0.3765375316143036,
-0.4977702498435974,
0.27231091260910034,
-0.22650566697120667,
-0.7037015557289124,
-0.554265022277832,
-0.45114073157310486,
0.29638150334358215,
-0.8600835204124451,
-0.04861664026975632,
0.4978538751602173,
-0.38689759373664856,
0.12317562848329544,
0.14775946736335754,
-0.8745923042297363,
0.26990875601768494,
0.19384095072746277,
1.134877324104309,
0.23142926394939423,
-0.8775480389595032,
-0.4789413511753082,
0.3470590114593506,
0.02435940131545067,
1.1954282522201538,
-0.380703330039978,
-0.11442790180444717,
-0.46854719519615173,
-0.022462043911218643,
-0.30899348855018616,
-0.3454076051712036,
0.5785117745399475,
-0.21449267864227295,
0.180063858628273,
-0.33946388959884644,
-0.07535863667726517,
-0.3711925745010376,
0.026024091988801956,
-0.6813175678253174,
0.3169904053211212,
0.03261321783065796,
-0.9042261838912964,
0.41977381706237793,
-0.6574567556381226,
-0.7317698001861572,
-0.2663441002368927,
-0.3206650912761688,
0.13670839369297028,
0.18764881789684296,
0.3537827730178833,
0.300845205783844,
-0.07610969245433807,
0.3759101629257202,
-0.1387256681919098,
-0.21544326841831207,
0.28555700182914734,
-0.6026869416236877,
1.0876818895339966,
0.020516611635684967,
-0.012315194122493267,
0.18208099901676178,
-0.6416365504264832,
-0.2273683398962021,
-0.020724857226014137,
-0.4451502561569214,
-0.594575047492981,
0.2761933505535126,
0.04912431165575981,
0.5492103099822998,
0.010109826922416687,
-0.5923680663108826,
-0.014760884456336498,
-0.39638495445251465,
0.5887897610664368,
0.6448272466659546,
0.15405115485191345,
0.07272215187549591,
-0.5150130987167358,
0.3143879175186157,
0.511517345905304,
0.0865136906504631,
-0.5261285901069641,
-0.4509328305721283,
-0.636436939239502,
-0.011274892836809158,
-0.007617660332471132,
0.504692792892456,
-0.3637255132198334,
0.04684724286198616,
-0.22821244597434998,
-0.12660562992095947,
-0.6292082071304321,
-0.23247073590755463,
0.19563549757003784,
0.2489883005619049,
0.696994960308075,
-0.32093727588653564,
-0.2878103256225586,
-0.9171578288078308,
-0.46988359093666077,
0.012368704192340374,
-0.1500348597764969,
0.2362854927778244,
-0.006605332717299461,
-0.3001292645931244,
0.5863537788391113,
-0.4144585132598877,
-0.5649639368057251,
-0.1127810925245285,
0.3425145745277405,
0.16977977752685547,
0.2948824167251587,
0.44179385900497437,
-0.4878336191177368,
-0.14439788460731506,
-0.21504180133342743,
-0.767238199710846,
0.01471604872494936,
-0.628838062286377,
-0.21954207122325897,
0.1390320509672165,
0.7168410420417786,
-0.7444918751716614,
0.1581333875656128,
0.575103759765625,
-0.8650214672088623,
0.3057217299938202,
-0.3765692710876465,
0.12634974718093872,
-0.8601076602935791,
-0.1255660355091095,
0.0837281122803688,
0.08007579296827316,
-0.4245243966579437,
-0.2735219895839691,
-0.11422959715127945,
0.35726889967918396,
-0.1868489384651184,
0.3320600390434265,
-0.6351379156112671,
-0.36619797348976135,
0.2705181837081909,
0.17240779101848602,
0.25576716661453247,
0.5600892901420593,
0.06487113982439041,
0.5362571477890015,
0.4062175154685974,
-0.29078376293182373,
0.08276749402284622,
0.327914297580719,
-0.35501807928085327,
0.29573652148246765,
-0.596614420413971,
0.1266455501317978,
-0.4289374351501465,
0.19658085703849792,
-1.0294958353042603,
-0.19261568784713745,
0.282219260931015,
-0.3732168972492218,
0.18367591500282288,
0.009645115584135056,
-0.590562105178833,
0.09113571792840958,
-0.028520988300442696,
0.562323808670044,
0.0706670954823494,
-0.4411237835884094,
0.7594272494316101,
0.26081815361976624,
0.057545438408851624,
-0.407168984413147,
-1.050261378288269,
0.026379063725471497,
-0.10971365869045258,
-0.8476887345314026,
0.36229407787323,
0.007722012232989073,
-0.38364461064338684,
-0.0821947380900383,
-0.029204076156020164,
-0.008117995224893093,
0.03150727599859238,
0.3670312464237213,
0.04835158959031105,
-0.15792015194892883,
0.11808204650878906,
0.09030197560787201,
-0.09756021946668625,
0.3477042019367218,
0.10996098071336746,
0.7114420533180237,
0.13536392152309418,
-0.33290207386016846,
-0.33102813363075256,
0.5377204418182373,
0.6650272011756897,
-0.11911797523498535,
0.6696517467498779,
0.36417531967163086,
-0.16033527255058289,
0.2829899489879608,
-0.2961784601211548,
0.13233967125415802,
-0.4383452236652374,
0.07983636111021042,
-0.6722263097763062,
-0.5703957080841064,
0.546164870262146,
0.27580124139785767,
-0.20329008996486664,
0.19819983839988708,
0.3224264681339264,
-0.015728985890746117,
0.8201713562011719,
0.40615150332450867,
0.2761249840259552,
0.32394132018089294,
0.13866807520389557,
-0.03900456428527832,
-1.035733699798584,
-0.2753923833370209,
-0.2616172730922699,
-0.2890767753124237,
-0.5278629064559937,
-0.1408858746290207,
0.29999053478240967,
-0.14121317863464355,
0.034301165491342545,
0.30525076389312744,
-0.32669928669929504,
0.5820211172103882,
0.3340473771095276,
0.30637985467910767,
0.34441840648651123,
-0.1820933073759079,
-0.4234035611152649,
-0.09844573587179184,
-0.4320583939552307,
-0.1475643664598465,
0.8186305165290833,
0.3342874050140381,
0.4514639675617218,
0.31966114044189453,
0.3054572343826294,
0.1140671819448471,
0.1745484173297882,
-1.0133670568466187,
0.34993547201156616,
-0.4397996962070465,
-0.5001862049102783,
-0.15780189633369446,
-0.12196565419435501,
-0.8937525153160095,
0.6406734585762024,
-0.0495888777077198,
-0.7951196432113647,
0.37134042382240295,
-0.0738571360707283,
-0.6701540350914001,
-0.035563137382268906,
-0.9601925611495972,
1.0501946210861206,
-0.3106306791305542,
-0.268280029296875,
-0.3314054012298584,
-1.0134063959121704,
0.4590654969215393,
0.240155890583992,
0.326372891664505,
-0.06541585922241211,
0.2162182331085205,
0.6531216502189636,
0.18894341588020325,
0.44977742433547974,
-0.19329534471035004,
0.09346957504749298,
-0.0370059534907341,
0.1750454157590866,
-0.3026803731918335,
0.05831519886851311,
-0.1174258291721344,
0.46885812282562256,
0.16317561268806458,
-0.25118693709373474,
-0.35943326354026794,
0.6684744954109192,
-0.6893447041511536,
-0.6134625673294067,
-0.8396526575088501,
-0.7428643107414246,
-0.3266853392124176,
0.09731671959161758,
0.45768657326698303,
0.5183689594268799,
0.03792371600866318,
-0.2245570570230484,
0.12712839245796204,
-0.3771224021911621,
0.6265084147453308,
0.323787122964859,
-0.061792727559804916,
-0.3618064820766449,
0.3499463200569153,
0.26020607352256775,
0.21352428197860718,
0.4530887007713318,
0.23457248508930206,
-0.37405717372894287,
-0.4289168119430542,
-0.23915696144104004,
0.5361750721931458,
-0.7729129791259766,
0.20595993101596832,
-0.9453274011611938,
-0.07333690673112869,
-0.2077896147966385,
-0.07992629706859589,
0.07209201157093048,
-0.16055820882320404,
0.029369277879595757,
0.05396916717290878,
0.16716359555721283,
0.7676409482955933,
-0.07568220049142838,
0.29803645610809326,
-1.0167125463485718,
0.45843467116355896,
0.05042785406112671,
0.2923567295074463,
0.09449054300785065,
-0.1895080804824829,
-0.13528312742710114,
-0.07371576875448227,
-0.3347505033016205,
-1.0345155000686646,
0.13248911499977112,
0.06493699550628662,
0.32627570629119873,
0.10962316393852234,
-0.3896104097366333,
0.9667474031448364,
-0.7589675784111023,
0.5842558741569519,
0.23457686603069305,
-1.0569603443145752,
0.49976906180381775,
-0.3271379768848419,
0.7208948731422424,
0.426716685295105,
0.29001879692077637,
-1.0159168243408203,
-0.39164504408836365,
-0.36648061871528625,
-0.8899577260017395,
0.818293571472168,
-0.13957397639751434,
-0.0569317601621151,
-0.16531166434288025,
0.2597050368785858,
0.23055896162986755,
-0.24342013895511627,
-0.7333177924156189,
-0.22885996103286743,
-0.17979158461093903,
0.10960271209478378,
-0.33673325181007385,
-0.2484353631734848,
0.01532743964344263,
-0.3298034369945526,
-0.08273380249738693,
0.15438809990882874,
0.4607377052307129,
0.4530531167984009,
-0.08691190928220749,
-0.23187270760536194,
0.3801434636116028,
0.6825140714645386,
0.6267493963241577,
-0.29787081480026245,
0.38227272033691406,
-0.07424194365739822,
-0.5853335857391357,
0.3702186346054077,
-0.01714756339788437,
0.21742522716522217,
0.27065619826316833,
0.714504063129425,
0.6786459684371948,
-0.05823126807808876,
-0.4021129906177521,
0.4120713472366333,
-0.3963761329650879,
-0.09196505695581436,
-0.4820283353328705,
0.010463472455739975,
0.43235233426094055,
0.40939000248908997,
-0.11617109179496765,
0.5818598866462708,
0.2949683368206024,
-0.496580570936203,
0.29727479815483093,
0.1843433529138565,
0.008678287267684937,
-0.49551069736480713,
0.5868483781814575,
-0.24874478578567505,
-0.2283802330493927,
0.7362890243530273,
0.0652131587266922,
-0.16598764061927795,
0.3489941954612732,
0.49850741028785706,
0.9500523209571838,
-0.06533149629831314,
0.029621116816997528,
0.3503549098968506,
0.19240932166576385,
-0.09520234167575836,
0.3758321702480316,
-0.04931630194187164,
-0.8648729920387268,
-0.6302674412727356,
-0.7924620509147644,
-0.17618586122989655,
0.1442861557006836,
-0.5920817255973816,
0.3043905794620514,
-0.4209381639957428,
-0.3192780315876007,
0.544684886932373,
-0.598902702331543,
-0.5573055148124695,
-0.04564613848924637,
0.13921046257019043,
0.814382791519165,
-0.8578068017959595,
1.064299464225769,
0.9044141173362732,
-0.5406872034072876,
-0.7275665402412415,
0.754540205001831,
-0.14040151238441467,
-0.4413314163684845,
0.5676291584968567,
0.4785347282886505,
-0.3530077040195465,
-0.01566498912870884,
-0.011811774224042892,
-0.7396275401115417,
1.0125008821487427,
0.49431198835372925,
-0.420974463224411,
-0.314615935087204,
-0.03887569159269333,
0.6279847025871277,
-0.07784855365753174,
0.21510931849479675,
0.6049401760101318,
0.4322117567062378,
-0.047672975808382034,
-0.5500858426094055,
0.23655250668525696,
-0.08472220599651337,
0.03496585413813591,
0.5922908782958984,
-0.5811226963996887,
0.9819381833076477,
-0.2803135812282562,
-0.4478023946285248,
-0.227042555809021,
0.23180721700191498,
0.21444031596183777,
0.29919150471687317,
0.5091398358345032,
0.6133625507354736,
0.3073084056377411,
0.06994853913784027,
0.9813218712806702,
-0.20385006070137024,
-0.07788911461830139,
1.1966155767440796,
-0.05852344632148743,
0.6220653057098389,
0.8902394771575928,
-0.3391232490539551,
0.7272855639457703,
0.5709573030471802,
0.24813403189182281,
0.48787355422973633,
0.07348036766052246,
-0.27022314071655273,
-0.17283649742603302,
-0.08107493072748184,
-0.05538858473300934,
0.6681667566299438,
0.3682706356048584,
-0.09321284294128418,
-0.4108186960220337,
0.07036181539297104,
-0.017955932766199112,
-0.0782194584608078,
0.1664086878299713,
0.586703896522522,
0.28300169110298157,
-0.8757771849632263,
0.3686368465423584,
-0.10118710994720459,
0.6373691558837891,
-0.6551501154899597,
-0.03996160253882408,
-0.17646509408950806,
0.1574886590242386,
-0.276784747838974,
-0.9552174210548401,
0.6784626841545105,
-0.4275858998298645,
-0.2600094676017761,
-0.25325241684913635,
0.22992084920406342,
-0.27621743083000183,
-0.015649881213903427,
1.0596263408660889,
0.5829665064811707,
0.05342935770750046,
0.0951770544052124,
-0.6376524567604065,
-0.12256927043199539,
-0.16094696521759033,
-0.4411913752555847,
0.4428480267524719,
0.6124687194824219,
0.020922493189573288,
0.5705816149711609,
0.6272304058074951,
0.2029607594013214,
0.1737976223230362,
0.3202146887779236,
0.6536642909049988,
-0.9662984609603882,
-0.5199304819107056,
-1.2208702564239502,
0.5550774931907654,
0.37046682834625244,
-0.3827948272228241,
0.3739965856075287,
0.07227572053670883,
0.9027359485626221,
0.057288408279418945,
0.5550910234451294,
-0.20879480242729187,
0.15675511956214905,
-0.7469390630722046,
0.43427303433418274,
-0.6708844900131226,
0.32189637422561646,
-0.08917485177516937,
-0.7281301617622375,
-0.4395321309566498,
0.6032116413116455,
-0.2385512739419937,
-0.18722978234291077,
1.2283304929733276,
0.5564942955970764,
-0.20658418536186218,
0.08080314844846725,
0.27677014470100403,
0.16151851415634155,
0.08626031875610352,
0.8248516321182251,
0.8784217834472656,
-0.26595979928970337,
0.16278304159641266,
-0.3430166244506836,
-0.059771567583084106,
0.4672926664352417,
-0.690187931060791,
-0.5836378931999207,
-0.6197342872619629,
0.023932861164212227,
-0.34156253933906555,
-0.025151023641228676,
0.8511098623275757,
0.22461920976638794,
-0.5672150254249573,
-0.47551432251930237,
-0.28606346249580383,
0.2076888084411621,
-0.23052407801151276,
-0.2502763271331787,
0.26124635338783264,
-0.4954851567745209,
-0.34467020630836487,
0.4201495349407196,
0.4905364215373993,
0.094117172062397,
-0.16620373725891113,
0.09996454417705536,
-0.6970294117927551,
-0.10828546434640884,
0.5374361872673035,
-0.13265958428382874,
-0.8004801273345947,
-0.45800891518592834,
0.048171576112508774,
-0.08721596002578735,
0.4452851712703705,
1.0343742370605469,
-0.7455252408981323,
0.3692052960395813,
0.5932270288467407,
0.18637776374816895,
0.12722782790660858,
-0.08522877842187881,
0.5087729692459106,
-0.537565290927887,
0.2696414291858673,
-0.004576585255563259,
0.4729909598827362,
0.3057711124420166,
-0.5986369252204895,
0.4035199284553528,
0.3353085517883301,
-0.5677319765090942,
-0.4310276210308075,
0.3568543493747711,
-0.9573771953582764,
-0.5276392698287964,
1.016501545906067,
-0.045940231531858444,
-0.0602598637342453,
-0.37117674946784973,
-0.14264222979545593,
0.3011728823184967,
-0.1778959184885025,
0.5684701800346375,
1.0744458436965942,
-0.7716984748840332,
-0.13419996201992035,
-0.7464354038238525,
0.35792937874794006,
0.3930026888847351,
-0.5604806542396545,
0.2781526446342468,
0.6866452097892761,
0.2230609953403473,
0.48486724495887756,
1.0417381525039673,
-0.06858368217945099,
0.23585914075374603,
0.15435530245304108,
-0.1306615024805069,
0.28603440523147583,
-0.5221265554428101,
-0.44621583819389343,
0.1687716692686081,
-0.034624550491571426,
-0.26759073138237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18045v1 | SpeechComposer: Unifying Multiple Speech Tasks with Prompt Composition | 2024-01-31T18:06:29 | 2024-01-31T18:06:29 | Yihan Wu, Soumi Maiti, Yifan Peng, Wangyou Zhang, Chenda Li, Yuyue Wang, Xihua Wang, Shinji Watanabe, Ruihua Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent advancements in language models have significantly enhanced
performance in multiple speech-related tasks. Existing speech language models
typically utilize task-dependent prompt tokens to unify various speech tasks in
a single model. However, this design omits the intrinsic connections between
different speech tasks, which can potentially boost the performance of each
task. In this work, we propose a novel decoder-only speech language model,
SpeechComposer, that can unify common speech tasks by composing a fixed set of
prompt tokens. Built upon four primary tasks -- speech synthesis, speech
recognition, speech language modeling, and text language modeling --
SpeechComposer can easily extend to more speech tasks via compositions of
well-designed prompt tokens, like voice conversion and speech enhancement. The
unification of prompt tokens also makes it possible for knowledge sharing among
different speech tasks in a more structured manner. Experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed SpeechComposer can improve the performance of
both primary tasks and composite tasks, showing the effectiveness of the shared
prompt tokens. Remarkably, the unified decoder-only model achieves a comparable
and even better performance than the baselines which are expert models designed
for single tasks. | [
-0.06603946536779404,
-0.4572553336620331,
0.31720829010009766,
0.3732704222202301,
-0.38397759199142456,
0.08363223075866699,
-0.18151172995567322,
-0.16261722147464752,
0.29490506649017334,
0.6207093596458435,
-0.5911022424697876,
-0.37896865606307983,
-0.49461498856544495,
0.2200329452753067,
-0.2681988477706909,
0.8231980204582214,
0.3958980143070221,
0.06277081370353699,
-0.3642483055591583,
-0.12882868945598602,
-1.235743761062622,
-0.6079676151275635,
-0.6550176739692688,
-0.3891119360923767,
0.534527063369751,
0.5094728469848633,
0.18323677778244019,
0.5151156783103943,
0.21985384821891785,
0.39861544966697693,
-0.10535796731710434,
0.04245827719569206,
-0.2151048183441162,
0.4520159363746643,
-0.1590297669172287,
-0.33014896512031555,
-0.36182519793510437,
-0.33512556552886963,
0.668347954750061,
0.8420706987380981,
-0.10618209838867188,
0.12530620396137238,
0.3677017092704773,
0.13232143223285675,
-0.5780523419380188,
0.2745521366596222,
-0.4718118906021118,
-0.21751976013183594,
-0.08373433351516724,
-0.08451317250728607,
-0.5338705778121948,
0.04478304460644722,
0.012485080398619175,
-0.5079350471496582,
0.18981638550758362,
-0.2298983484506607,
0.052877459675073624,
0.4373648762702942,
-0.40912777185440063,
0.03407326713204384,
-0.7838956117630005,
0.7727698683738708,
-0.49197718501091003,
0.3841921389102936,
-0.14719675481319427,
0.4000129997730255,
0.13205306231975555,
-0.9167978763580322,
-0.47835150361061096,
-0.149322047829628,
-0.07197850197553635,
0.13275860249996185,
-0.526079535484314,
0.19681857526302338,
0.05696995556354523,
0.024099627509713173,
-0.461520254611969,
0.042878661304712296,
-0.3130643665790558,
-0.45543721318244934,
0.14469334483146667,
0.30341199040412903,
0.6144177317619324,
-0.2960432767868042,
-0.5102329850196838,
-0.017315270379185677,
-0.4336507022380829,
0.4160526990890503,
-0.00989231001585722,
0.8410112261772156,
-0.022396879270672798,
0.5423504710197449,
-0.1924351006746292,
0.7002397775650024,
0.014151245355606079,
-0.22784315049648285,
0.09327235072851181,
-0.5137205719947815,
-0.04422346502542496,
0.4029019773006439,
0.6504821181297302,
0.08712784945964813,
-0.30645087361335754,
-0.390768438577652,
-0.12401881814002991,
0.3174653947353363,
0.14373566210269928,
-0.6549266576766968,
-0.21723224222660065,
0.1358167827129364,
-0.4014793932437897,
0.014805684797465801,
-0.008793540298938751,
-0.3175031244754791,
-0.3918953537940979,
-0.46398410201072693,
0.5107102990150452,
-0.32125502824783325,
-0.3814862370491028,
0.10010567307472229,
-0.4353421926498413,
-0.09743092954158783,
0.04839495196938515,
-0.7523640990257263,
0.493275910615921,
0.9161884784698486,
0.7920467257499695,
-0.5195048451423645,
-0.5523059964179993,
-1.071703553199768,
0.27137401700019836,
0.0485215000808239,
0.8759995698928833,
-0.6360543370246887,
-0.6359614133834839,
-0.23908939957618713,
-0.056215181946754456,
-0.30003002285957336,
-0.42264464497566223,
0.8588064908981323,
-0.19413018226623535,
0.04603038355708122,
-0.4303536117076874,
-0.6900383830070496,
-0.1260971873998642,
-0.042566463351249695,
-0.9854400753974915,
0.727863073348999,
-0.32711148262023926,
-0.7128580808639526,
0.0879555195569992,
-0.960949182510376,
-0.5688012838363647,
0.5462908148765564,
-0.1618027687072754,
0.17142890393733978,
0.16305497288703918,
0.35369426012039185,
0.3187117278575897,
-0.2658928334712982,
0.4725986421108246,
0.3448261320590973,
-0.48737984895706177,
0.33696043491363525,
-0.5336933135986328,
0.7532363533973694,
0.11195781826972961,
-0.13688330352306366,
0.5527252554893494,
-0.8160156011581421,
-0.052429988980293274,
-0.34248870611190796,
-0.4242410957813263,
-0.17961086332798004,
-0.11688755452632904,
0.28329506516456604,
0.07968674600124359,
0.4522509276866913,
-0.7275928258895874,
0.004631666000932455,
-0.23411284387111664,
0.5053749680519104,
0.47125229239463806,
-0.11418087780475616,
0.5957010984420776,
-0.5541304349899292,
0.7119060754776001,
0.1357675939798355,
-0.16906754672527313,
-0.5971108078956604,
-0.6614444851875305,
-0.5413685441017151,
-0.7399380207061768,
0.15983755886554718,
0.6793391704559326,
-0.5927309393882751,
0.4216160178184509,
-0.35633185505867004,
-0.41494789719581604,
-0.644845724105835,
-0.12654510140419006,
0.4479120671749115,
0.7512465119361877,
0.3033779561519623,
-0.07209736853837967,
-0.7018642425537109,
-0.7620077729225159,
-0.5145195126533508,
-0.0075197117403149605,
-0.16384166479110718,
-0.15041427314281464,
-0.0220826156437397,
0.02826731838285923,
1.150886058807373,
-0.3305110037326813,
-0.44766169786453247,
-0.6242172122001648,
0.10299401730298996,
0.40049782395362854,
0.7012168765068054,
0.12665855884552002,
-0.7445328235626221,
-0.325544148683548,
-0.19721725583076477,
-0.11848911643028259,
-0.3145788609981537,
0.03227536752820015,
0.30198392271995544,
-0.0028078481554985046,
0.5078854560852051,
-0.6807368397712708,
0.1004566103219986,
0.5373607873916626,
-0.32130739092826843,
0.548058807849884,
-0.23026026785373688,
0.07854508608579636,
-1.254827618598938,
0.3370017111301422,
-0.4050728976726532,
-0.06263930350542068,
-1.086479663848877,
-0.12351638823747635,
-0.16604343056678772,
-0.6456010341644287,
-0.5694463849067688,
0.6232454776763916,
-0.19184599816799164,
-0.012296219356358051,
-0.5436825752258301,
-0.0902625173330307,
0.07812229543924332,
0.482790470123291,
-0.03360552340745926,
0.8853498697280884,
0.9096435904502869,
-0.6018038988113403,
0.531840980052948,
0.34706684947013855,
-0.16311535239219666,
0.49528706073760986,
-1.0639398097991943,
0.2931522727012634,
-0.2487720251083374,
0.14601971209049225,
-1.3586797714233398,
-0.2533552944660187,
0.13554929196834564,
-0.47015342116355896,
-0.0778028592467308,
-0.07025296241044998,
-0.3520773947238922,
-0.1395842581987381,
0.1679951548576355,
0.43278300762176514,
0.32455670833587646,
-0.5186746716499329,
0.9485903382301331,
0.38029125332832336,
-0.6936571598052979,
-0.3478240370750427,
-0.7294199466705322,
0.20887650549411774,
-0.10333824157714844,
-0.6260713338851929,
0.6113302111625671,
-0.1713874638080597,
0.09109151363372803,
0.030532674863934517,
-0.2202160805463791,
-0.19828954339027405,
-0.21663902699947357,
0.4521600902080536,
0.20885398983955383,
-0.009955771267414093,
0.3334990441799164,
0.08834809064865112,
-0.4035823941230774,
-0.2013327032327652,
-0.41120168566703796,
0.5801896452903748,
0.09900666773319244,
-0.3312646746635437,
-0.7339587211608887,
1.0409362316131592,
0.682961642742157,
-0.6569100022315979,
0.470320463180542,
0.43204444646835327,
-0.2520330250263214,
-0.07174622267484665,
-0.5864249467849731,
-0.21855376660823822,
-0.4646745026111603,
0.3064330220222473,
-0.768892228603363,
-1.225638508796692,
0.6016809344291687,
-0.016830909997224808,
0.2200760394334793,
0.08534746617078781,
0.3447819650173187,
0.2883732318878174,
1.0664247274398804,
0.6788620352745056,
-0.17803242802619934,
0.4726845920085907,
0.22166544198989868,
0.19025945663452148,
-0.5661832094192505,
-0.3924293518066406,
-0.7894487380981445,
-0.19213484227657318,
-0.24327263236045837,
-0.42222708463668823,
0.483773797750473,
-0.3180488348007202,
-0.11553317308425903,
0.4292495846748352,
-0.6872259974479675,
0.5755870938301086,
0.9607590436935425,
0.05479329079389572,
0.36099255084991455,
0.08024520426988602,
-0.09416753798723221,
0.02883935160934925,
-0.7942097187042236,
-0.45859310030937195,
0.6679532527923584,
-0.06615942716598511,
0.3525642156600952,
-0.15991829335689545,
0.7713178396224976,
0.034645020961761475,
-0.4439898133277893,
-0.6772962212562561,
0.6815851330757141,
-0.5512492656707764,
-0.4078562557697296,
-0.3320056200027466,
-0.4686441719532013,
-0.9407223463058472,
0.44022366404533386,
0.0852782279253006,
-0.626366376876831,
0.09200628101825714,
0.0703747346997261,
-0.4039037525653839,
0.004884554538875818,
-0.644765317440033,
0.9382287263870239,
0.11814438551664352,
0.17164014279842377,
-0.24154436588287354,
-0.5094752311706543,
0.04784925654530525,
0.11917704343795776,
0.1313701868057251,
-0.07174865901470184,
-0.07643645256757736,
0.8967311978340149,
-0.20835115015506744,
0.9711458086967468,
-0.2964843511581421,
0.12840911746025085,
0.3588462173938751,
-0.06884162873029709,
0.3820345103740692,
-0.1697443574666977,
-0.25472477078437805,
-0.12062148749828339,
0.03943273797631264,
-0.2397773563861847,
-0.5315618515014648,
0.6361775398254395,
-0.6051159501075745,
-0.6501597166061401,
0.029349785298109055,
-0.7721534967422485,
-0.21014663577079773,
0.562308669090271,
0.18700124323368073,
0.904306173324585,
-0.3204842805862427,
0.14572301506996155,
0.2934153079986572,
0.07297620177268982,
0.6414309740066528,
0.40010932087898254,
0.18990552425384521,
-0.7329524159431458,
0.9011093974113464,
-0.1536032259464264,
0.06881847977638245,
0.5662492513656616,
0.2576174736022949,
-0.4841974973678589,
-0.309577077627182,
-0.09365994483232498,
-0.05107415094971657,
-0.7444142699241638,
-0.0024228207767009735,
-0.7858699560165405,
0.06118170917034149,
-0.7251230478286743,
0.05573589354753494,
-0.3278767764568329,
-0.5007184147834778,
-0.5264686942100525,
0.026321394369006157,
0.13874632120132446,
0.45870786905288696,
-0.2164895385503769,
0.44286638498306274,
-0.9598252773284912,
0.6718363165855408,
0.731351912021637,
0.05253683775663376,
-0.1201353371143341,
-0.4097386598587036,
0.015531887300312519,
0.08091798424720764,
-0.07209831476211548,
-0.7545844316482544,
0.24469734728336334,
0.15544240176677704,
0.7284621000289917,
0.21254862844944,
0.1821352243423462,
0.6153395175933838,
-0.6266088485717773,
0.8705011606216431,
0.6326234936714172,
-1.198736548423767,
0.2850227952003479,
-0.27096956968307495,
0.7328159809112549,
0.6345533132553101,
-0.12172576040029526,
-0.7225320935249329,
-0.27842599153518677,
-0.1679643988609314,
-0.6778313517570496,
0.8132450580596924,
0.12020877003669739,
0.33804360032081604,
-0.004986128769814968,
-0.08676689863204956,
0.25129234790802,
0.18801157176494598,
-0.4655499756336212,
-0.2972612977027893,
-0.3654427230358124,
-0.16174131631851196,
-0.14242427051067352,
-0.1852666586637497,
-0.11926525831222534,
-0.3491799533367157,
0.3753964602947235,
-0.07488343119621277,
0.29542335867881775,
0.12210621684789658,
0.0051943459548056126,
0.1663784682750702,
0.7038001418113708,
0.4925425052642822,
0.49436715245246887,
0.2243722379207611,
0.3674794137477875,
-0.1578414887189865,
-0.33943137526512146,
0.33009445667266846,
0.38188111782073975,
-0.14020086824893951,
0.321184366941452,
0.2926159203052521,
1.0594335794448853,
0.6448935270309448,
-0.597748339176178,
0.43657153844833374,
-0.09858797490596771,
0.06917353719472885,
0.10196773707866669,
0.13476161658763885,
0.4440861940383911,
0.21395832300186157,
0.5827106237411499,
0.3790738880634308,
0.29190969467163086,
-0.3384833037853241,
0.36604902148246765,
0.2599388360977173,
-0.3038707375526428,
-0.3603360056877136,
0.851101279258728,
0.4865995943546295,
-0.5136626958847046,
0.29967963695526123,
-0.040908198803663254,
-0.4711296260356903,
0.5095596313476562,
0.8361895680427551,
0.9675338268280029,
-0.6235314607620239,
0.2843005657196045,
0.15006327629089355,
-0.05623438581824303,
-0.08224587142467499,
0.47613900899887085,
-0.32135745882987976,
-0.4376353919506073,
-0.6902628540992737,
-0.38479456305503845,
-0.37130168080329895,
-0.22895845770835876,
-0.6388608813285828,
0.21156667172908783,
0.12171969562768936,
-0.21753595769405365,
0.12046171724796295,
-0.2378726303577423,
-0.4576878547668457,
0.011450651101768017,
0.04321388527750969,
0.6664537191390991,
-0.640866756439209,
0.7022245526313782,
1.0025126934051514,
-0.16566647589206696,
-1.1120519638061523,
-0.3108373284339905,
-0.18360963463783264,
-0.3711414933204651,
0.5585342049598694,
0.36788704991340637,
-0.245716392993927,
0.3008323311805725,
-0.0262258630245924,
-0.7263774871826172,
0.8844259977340698,
0.598761260509491,
-0.6824500560760498,
-0.13254296779632568,
0.4826107323169708,
0.16396638751029968,
-0.48636797070503235,
-0.07028453797101974,
0.4125085771083832,
0.3532775044441223,
0.43358418345451355,
-1.1623121500015259,
0.14018481969833374,
-0.21140941977500916,
0.0636325553059578,
-0.053803421556949615,
-0.17636877298355103,
1.0665761232376099,
-0.07220559567213058,
-0.49897491931915283,
0.25855961441993713,
0.6519405245780945,
0.48299553990364075,
0.2101460099220276,
0.6485188603401184,
0.259791761636734,
0.8497208952903748,
0.20793502032756805,
0.6699674725532532,
-0.37945881485939026,
-0.08317433297634125,
1.2914901971817017,
-0.2696903645992279,
0.6567379832267761,
0.3977724015712738,
0.15730074048042297,
0.2027217298746109,
-0.20289137959480286,
0.14335688948631287,
0.774616003036499,
0.007336112670600414,
-0.7127760648727417,
-0.5327954888343811,
-0.5261315703392029,
-0.11982817947864532,
0.7203187942504883,
-0.14865900576114655,
0.07842060178518295,
-0.33014675974845886,
0.4411429166793823,
-0.15653491020202637,
0.08766180276870728,
-0.39773210883140564,
0.9526074528694153,
-0.040690407156944275,
-0.9156020283699036,
0.31637832522392273,
-0.06158225238323212,
0.7028329372406006,
-0.5247117877006531,
0.033874791115522385,
0.0578998439013958,
0.13613972067832947,
-0.022954847663640976,
-0.4280669093132019,
0.21281717717647552,
0.009320203214883804,
-0.36538374423980713,
-0.24506767094135284,
0.9813798069953918,
-0.6918240189552307,
-0.513749361038208,
0.10015831142663956,
0.5320487022399902,
-0.0667143315076828,
-0.4480559527873993,
-0.3920973241329193,
0.40032336115837097,
-0.058867018669843674,
0.25922420620918274,
-0.044425755739212036,
0.2993710935115814,
0.2918079197406769,
0.5767014622688293,
0.7253243923187256,
0.0966239869594574,
0.2437036782503128,
0.30182716250419617,
0.8538418412208557,
-0.6385793089866638,
-1.0159416198730469,
-0.6929643154144287,
0.7357417941093445,
0.03401980921626091,
-0.16228154301643372,
0.771211564540863,
0.5707932114601135,
0.3011312484741211,
-0.3031240999698639,
0.9604705572128296,
0.13193391263484955,
0.85772705078125,
-0.1465207189321518,
0.6469319462776184,
-0.25679445266723633,
-0.03806321322917938,
-0.27216455340385437,
-0.7873871326446533,
-0.35181471705436707,
0.17246250808238983,
0.21224746108055115,
-0.2541946768760681,
0.504139244556427,
0.7661362886428833,
0.09006386995315552,
0.27460944652557373,
0.45045244693756104,
-0.23062650859355927,
0.38956934213638306,
0.47478801012039185,
0.814418613910675,
-0.16672897338867188,
0.8009843230247498,
-0.16263677179813385,
-0.1358838826417923,
0.0021900017745792866,
-0.7357112765312195,
-0.8284769654273987,
-0.877386212348938,
-0.3254481256008148,
0.2553184926509857,
-0.026281526312232018,
0.7447462677955627,
0.7817831039428711,
-0.7602854371070862,
-0.27888548374176025,
-0.19152434170246124,
-0.07817012071609497,
-0.4323868453502655,
-0.21859051287174225,
0.23584970831871033,
-0.4759036898612976,
-0.7481697201728821,
0.9271035194396973,
0.2485664039850235,
-0.20292921364307404,
0.12617848813533783,
0.06625690311193466,
0.32073715329170227,
0.11166428029537201,
0.5135301947593689,
0.1779845803976059,
-0.8206642270088196,
-0.10024476796388626,
0.1495588719844818,
0.08296843618154526,
-0.09170959889888763,
1.2346303462982178,
-0.9025538563728333,
0.5071613192558289,
0.6208487749099731,
0.6270095109939575,
0.17946702241897583,
0.02512972801923752,
0.6025630235671997,
-0.8839672803878784,
0.17419463396072388,
0.3316247761249542,
0.35267868638038635,
0.3222304582595825,
-0.11834420263767242,
-0.17714622616767883,
-0.023002654314041138,
-0.5004022717475891,
-0.7171325087547302,
0.3063824474811554,
-1.3507452011108398,
-0.3510397672653198,
0.8737316727638245,
-0.0972946360707283,
0.009204494766891003,
-0.26226991415023804,
-0.4706535041332245,
0.5398312211036682,
-0.6476995348930359,
0.4102136790752411,
0.48952987790107727,
-0.07861269265413284,
-0.3236314058303833,
-0.057940445840358734,
0.26315024495124817,
0.41526517271995544,
-0.6249191761016846,
0.3150070607662201,
0.5720441937446594,
0.3752027153968811,
0.20096854865550995,
0.6740018725395203,
0.038057535886764526,
0.43810856342315674,
0.03742130473256111,
0.18903812766075134,
-0.5696583986282349,
-0.3879321813583374,
-0.5169311761856079,
0.5779152512550354,
-0.26946163177490234,
-0.5988057255744934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18040v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18040v2 | Enhancing End-to-End Multi-Task Dialogue Systems: A Study on Intrinsic Motivation Reinforcement Learning Algorithms for Improved Training and Adaptability | 2024-01-31T18:03:39 | 2024-03-25T23:03:58 | Navin Kamuni, Hardik Shah, Sathishkumar Chintala, Naveen Kunchakuri, Sujatha Alla Old Dominion | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | End-to-end multi-task dialogue systems are usually designed with separate
modules for the dialogue pipeline. Among these, the policy module is essential
for deciding what to do in response to user input. This policy is trained by
reinforcement learning algorithms by taking advantage of an environment in
which an agent receives feedback in the form of a reward signal. The current
dialogue systems, however, only provide meagre and simplistic rewards.
Investigating intrinsic motivation reinforcement learning algorithms is the
goal of this study. Through this, the agent can quickly accelerate training and
improve its capacity to judge the quality of its actions by teaching it an
internal incentive system. In particular, we adapt techniques for random
network distillation and curiosity-driven reinforcement learning to measure the
frequency of state visits and encourage exploration by using semantic
similarity between utterances. Experimental results on MultiWOZ, a
heterogeneous dataset, show that intrinsic motivation-based debate systems
outperform policies that depend on extrinsic incentives. By adopting random
network distillation, for example, which is trained using semantic similarity
between user-system dialogues, an astounding average success rate of 73% is
achieved. This is a significant improvement over the baseline Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO), which has an average success rate of 60%. In addition,
performance indicators such as booking rates and completion rates show a 10%
rise over the baseline. Furthermore, these intrinsic incentive models help
improve the system's policy's resilience in an increasing amount of domains.
This implies that they could be useful in scaling up to settings that cover a
wider range of domains. | [
-0.39815303683280945,
-0.4075961112976074,
0.5201421976089478,
0.14068737626075745,
-0.07081823796033859,
0.17776648700237274,
-0.42941975593566895,
-0.06864248216152191,
0.20056624710559845,
0.2027064561843872,
-0.8208976984024048,
-0.025569193065166473,
-0.49642807245254517,
0.1632212996482849,
0.08639587461948395,
1.0181812047958374,
-0.015279041603207588,
-0.022545745596289635,
-0.13337697088718414,
-0.1593988686800003,
-0.4752858281135559,
-0.7024490237236023,
-0.8220235109329224,
-0.5408427715301514,
0.42957398295402527,
0.3382706642150879,
0.04925968497991562,
-0.12752152979373932,
0.08236553519964218,
0.35681331157684326,
-0.24600815773010254,
0.2041960507631302,
-0.7458965182304382,
0.3146495819091797,
-0.31513720750808716,
-0.5670263171195984,
0.18741212785243988,
-0.15672442317008972,
0.4933323264122009,
0.29991415143013,
-0.5274815559387207,
-0.2092580795288086,
0.2847980558872223,
0.6297231316566467,
-0.5650834441184998,
0.3135398030281067,
-0.6758714914321899,
0.10163448005914688,
0.2677442729473114,
-0.6306299567222595,
-0.41517314314842224,
-0.3655054569244385,
0.45154064893722534,
-0.5339323282241821,
-0.3126092553138733,
0.13052359223365784,
0.6250578761100769,
0.24002842605113983,
-0.43663290143013,
-0.4845510721206665,
-0.6388207077980042,
0.9093576669692993,
-0.5514187812805176,
-0.07590068876743317,
0.08513517677783966,
0.29035401344299316,
-0.47452059388160706,
-0.36368846893310547,
-0.4943685829639435,
-0.6089988350868225,
0.2486691176891327,
0.30395185947418213,
-0.29026326537132263,
0.2732856273651123,
0.2250204235315323,
0.255379319190979,
-0.24425387382507324,
0.14373968541622162,
-0.028183262795209885,
-0.18020272254943848,
0.11314330995082855,
0.2290056049823761,
-0.005843071732670069,
0.1928880363702774,
-0.4179946780204773,
-0.30031445622444153,
-0.5878413319587708,
0.8143847584724426,
0.47878748178482056,
0.15222300589084625,
0.3184308409690857,
0.3676934242248535,
-0.8353554606437683,
0.43175503611564636,
0.13302236795425415,
-0.13325896859169006,
0.11613212525844574,
-0.34143775701522827,
0.09046661108732224,
0.2509233355522156,
0.4980703592300415,
0.2723643183708191,
0.13822662830352783,
-0.12745031714439392,
-0.33109772205352783,
0.06587331742048264,
0.2796825170516968,
-0.7383278012275696,
0.018910052254796028,
0.07151128351688385,
-0.41539111733436584,
-0.25628355145454407,
-0.19142533838748932,
-0.20627270638942719,
-0.12727509438991547,
-0.6709750890731812,
0.5191521644592285,
-0.47882723808288574,
-0.3207058906555176,
0.1120828166604042,
-0.5282362699508667,
0.13384032249450684,
0.6139106750488281,
-0.8645094633102417,
0.3275183439254761,
0.5526670217514038,
0.9064390063285828,
-0.07246064394712448,
-0.2798597514629364,
-0.5454811453819275,
0.02344316802918911,
-0.2054002285003662,
0.8268949389457703,
-0.6166803240776062,
-0.24445784091949463,
-0.06352227181196213,
-0.08162853121757507,
-0.10267163813114166,
-0.5207907557487488,
0.48738306760787964,
-0.4119550883769989,
0.20926719903945923,
-0.29886797070503235,
-0.39059388637542725,
-0.36188751459121704,
0.6452929377555847,
-0.2519497871398926,
0.6281597018241882,
0.291856974363327,
-0.1686965525150299,
0.3387942314147949,
-0.9303157329559326,
-0.21458584070205688,
-0.25626155734062195,
0.04195849969983101,
-0.07278899848461151,
0.31865203380584717,
0.09051062911748886,
0.1381538063287735,
-0.41521650552749634,
0.4174826145172119,
-0.32122963666915894,
-0.3330323100090027,
0.32989993691444397,
-0.6759936809539795,
0.5946175456047058,
0.1641000360250473,
-0.4692510664463043,
0.3777800500392914,
-0.3455078601837158,
0.07841264456510544,
-0.06894969195127487,
-0.3365802764892578,
-0.3082221746444702,
0.13658420741558075,
-0.3385957181453705,
0.4571090340614319,
0.03978632017970085,
-0.6976805329322815,
0.20491181313991547,
-0.35618874430656433,
0.6027899980545044,
1.0726993083953857,
0.19576752185821533,
0.1415654718875885,
-0.4621011018753052,
0.3975164294242859,
0.181329146027565,
0.26701998710632324,
-0.3691410422325134,
-0.4134947657585144,
-0.5638113617897034,
-0.17582468688488007,
0.0686659961938858,
0.5504441857337952,
-0.828246533870697,
0.32860514521598816,
-0.24313464760780334,
-0.22079238295555115,
-0.18611210584640503,
-0.13538575172424316,
0.48744750022888184,
0.45753052830696106,
0.12557847797870636,
-0.6945918202400208,
-0.03631345182657242,
-0.6083994507789612,
-0.03012491948902607,
-0.2753031849861145,
0.10219714790582657,
0.5803539156913757,
0.4943660497665405,
0.1442396193742752,
0.9578292369842529,
-0.33708447217941284,
-0.34166961908340454,
-0.176646426320076,
0.3223387598991394,
0.3291035294532776,
0.37522533535957336,
0.5340556502342224,
-0.6543291211128235,
-0.6646555066108704,
0.15043200552463531,
-0.5849043726921082,
0.1373746246099472,
-0.19827502965927124,
-0.05585726350545883,
-0.08684651553630829,
-0.011569700203835964,
-0.395021915435791,
0.3301604390144348,
0.11974005401134491,
-0.18177886307239532,
0.8060338497161865,
-0.2491457462310791,
0.36069977283477783,
-0.5437313318252563,
-0.2554413676261902,
0.09188605099916458,
-0.22032488882541656,
-0.6617090702056885,
-0.22489620745182037,
-0.44995516538619995,
-0.013877280056476593,
-0.4844074249267578,
0.10789338499307632,
-0.2572988271713257,
0.04727065935730934,
-0.582561731338501,
-0.08997581154108047,
-0.1643301248550415,
1.183885931968689,
0.10913392901420593,
0.8181288838386536,
0.7323784232139587,
-0.8474153280258179,
0.72519451379776,
0.1923343986272812,
-0.33636829257011414,
0.9334597587585449,
-0.6768335700035095,
0.13226218521595,
-0.07332894206047058,
0.49421226978302,
-0.867647647857666,
0.11157051473855972,
0.31823208928108215,
-0.4063718616962433,
0.09449206292629242,
-0.04488174617290497,
-0.12004819512367249,
-0.007949653081595898,
-0.42612722516059875,
-0.009725674986839294,
0.34002605080604553,
-0.6836395263671875,
0.5261746048927307,
0.31738972663879395,
-0.3200322985649109,
-0.7329469919204712,
-0.0004336980346124619,
0.21388773620128632,
-0.3382173180580139,
-0.3182487487792969,
0.31752094626426697,
-0.12382031977176666,
-0.06834612041711807,
0.10827632248401642,
-0.22513777017593384,
0.057130441069602966,
0.3065737783908844,
0.16218245029449463,
0.0745433047413826,
-0.04770253226161003,
-0.004547316115349531,
0.25546663999557495,
-0.17940418422222137,
0.2571103274822235,
-0.8427625298500061,
0.6081357002258301,
-0.3336593806743622,
-0.3259146809577942,
-0.7206058502197266,
0.37395259737968445,
0.34584328532218933,
0.001687446841970086,
0.7195454835891724,
0.41507354378700256,
-0.09280425310134888,
-0.10111650079488754,
-0.2845921516418457,
-0.442213773727417,
-0.4818888008594513,
0.3697372376918793,
-0.5764763951301575,
-1.074605107307434,
0.2637220025062561,
-0.6881831288337708,
0.31950682401657104,
0.2928079664707184,
0.7163670063018799,
-0.10028529912233353,
0.8986794352531433,
0.43683990836143494,
-0.11196190863847733,
0.7720261812210083,
-0.032512929290533066,
0.048594824969768524,
-0.9005036354064941,
-0.38222387433052063,
-0.5400646924972534,
-0.3968508541584015,
-0.222816601395607,
-0.114578016102314,
0.46678784489631653,
0.05429200828075409,
-0.13190951943397522,
0.33691829442977905,
-0.5906994342803955,
0.3531767427921295,
0.8744122982025146,
0.12981334328651428,
0.10439950227737427,
0.19191014766693115,
-0.18673908710479736,
0.14801499247550964,
-0.5622750520706177,
-0.2448144257068634,
1.0727317333221436,
0.20601892471313477,
0.6098031997680664,
0.4618857502937317,
0.6558104753494263,
0.587130606174469,
0.3052460551261902,
-0.7301693558692932,
0.27545198798179626,
0.20381338894367218,
-0.19066372513771057,
-0.6693048477172852,
-0.6657676696777344,
-0.6550413966178894,
0.47400346398353577,
-0.02101004309952259,
-0.9950389266014099,
0.4849458932876587,
0.09603503346443176,
-0.29977652430534363,
0.14782904088497162,
-0.7352524995803833,
0.5456382632255554,
-0.32619333267211914,
-0.32575955986976624,
-0.6011027693748474,
-0.5288709998130798,
0.16274002194404602,
0.04591476544737816,
-0.2807924449443817,
-0.30953139066696167,
0.28235113620758057,
0.6954373717308044,
-0.365230530500412,
0.6742455959320068,
-0.5352885723114014,
0.02634391002357006,
0.4455612301826477,
-0.20310662686824799,
0.679450511932373,
0.06396444141864777,
0.0948200449347496,
-0.03159603103995323,
-0.06016254052519798,
-0.18047559261322021,
-0.865027904510498,
0.5800406336784363,
-0.753568708896637,
-0.6100242137908936,
-0.3232240080833435,
-0.3705163598060608,
-0.38767102360725403,
-0.13271427154541016,
-0.052923478186130524,
0.6842906475067139,
-0.24243253469467163,
0.45368966460227966,
0.8626334071159363,
-0.14060422778129578,
0.40935012698173523,
0.5443384647369385,
0.2062879204750061,
-0.24400824308395386,
1.348904013633728,
-0.2118193805217743,
0.4352056086063385,
0.5929222106933594,
0.25153008103370667,
-0.5594293475151062,
-0.4488823413848877,
-0.4626849293708801,
-0.28691229224205017,
-0.5933685898780823,
-0.14958442747592926,
-0.617177426815033,
0.06948226690292358,
-0.27213039994239807,
0.11675428599119186,
-0.06365002691745758,
-0.6504498720169067,
-0.2222546637058258,
0.10321860015392303,
0.28649789094924927,
0.44821494817733765,
-0.13999974727630615,
0.518018901348114,
-0.3701211214065552,
0.08531291037797928,
0.4323202669620514,
0.19586943089962006,
0.09213661402463913,
-0.7052552700042725,
-0.30559325218200684,
0.1032436415553093,
-0.6671627759933472,
-0.8184283971786499,
0.20293118059635162,
0.438485711812973,
0.8468188047409058,
0.6194429993629456,
0.17283132672309875,
0.41695713996887207,
-0.3225855529308319,
0.5713456869125366,
0.6127755045890808,
-0.8178080916404724,
0.4504431188106537,
-0.10878220945596695,
0.057154081761837006,
0.7154039144515991,
0.3518452048301697,
-0.6170067191123962,
-0.16980090737342834,
-0.2896285951137543,
-0.6901277899742126,
1.0814508199691772,
0.022884776815772057,
0.13216502964496613,
0.1922224462032318,
0.1842809021472931,
0.07072607427835464,
0.43631991744041443,
-0.6550371646881104,
-0.17043136060237885,
-0.3230171501636505,
-0.15747423470020294,
0.06620779633522034,
-0.08679790794849396,
-0.4095073640346527,
0.005441423039883375,
0.8581636548042297,
-0.5419662594795227,
0.4635559618473053,
0.15875989198684692,
-0.08449456095695496,
0.2026221603155136,
0.6285853385925293,
0.7403571009635925,
0.4002261757850647,
-0.2052556425333023,
-0.24767433106899261,
0.11490710824728012,
-0.08911100029945374,
0.5312820076942444,
-0.0656827762722969,
0.10921626538038254,
-0.14098212122917175,
-0.4389702081680298,
1.2935924530029297,
-0.012559800408780575,
-0.8871067762374878,
0.4629327058792114,
-0.3404546082019806,
-0.37528225779533386,
-0.253424733877182,
0.32667276263237,
-0.3014397621154785,
0.3333357274532318,
0.4522022604942322,
0.09246084839105606,
0.40403708815574646,
-0.7300882339477539,
0.10404311865568161,
0.582513689994812,
-0.724438488483429,
-0.1048818975687027,
0.19416451454162598,
0.2604919672012329,
-0.33778679370880127,
0.5755987763404846,
-0.39368224143981934,
-0.6337338089942932,
0.517421305179596,
0.4983443021774292,
0.9085727334022522,
-0.1511078178882599,
0.35444268584251404,
0.19259050488471985,
0.33992844820022583,
-0.13475801050662994,
0.0009483438916504383,
-0.5467220544815063,
-0.6298883557319641,
-0.4944683015346527,
-0.34546226263046265,
-0.7766913771629333,
-0.13258926570415497,
-0.5751395225524902,
-0.052626606076955795,
-0.2627595365047455,
-0.22437790036201477,
-0.331546813249588,
-0.08215047419071198,
-0.4330323338508606,
-0.07131495326757431,
0.03580478951334953,
0.5618840456008911,
-0.6044213771820068,
0.4643685817718506,
0.5415764451026917,
-0.14944256842136383,
-0.5744786262512207,
-0.2920719385147095,
0.09002772718667984,
-0.5518576502799988,
0.5087052583694458,
0.2606842517852783,
-0.1834425926208496,
0.009044774807989597,
-0.3461073040962219,
-0.7434213161468506,
0.9876984357833862,
0.12462472915649414,
-0.5814087986946106,
-0.09082262217998505,
-0.045772455632686615,
0.4099711775779724,
-0.5667631030082703,
0.8017187714576721,
0.3914785087108612,
0.22585488855838776,
0.06045423448085785,
-0.9489325881004333,
-0.11030422896146774,
-0.2830846905708313,
-0.15385420620441437,
0.24235643446445465,
-0.6744152307510376,
0.566493570804596,
-0.10937543958425522,
0.05428524687886238,
-0.1381797194480896,
0.6566978693008423,
0.384731650352478,
0.4166390895843506,
0.8819302916526794,
0.44949036836624146,
0.6211928725242615,
-0.37382882833480835,
0.8567578196525574,
-0.300027459859848,
0.38043835759162903,
0.9149988293647766,
-0.4670674502849579,
0.5321856141090393,
0.43220630288124084,
-0.15079836547374725,
0.7080181837081909,
0.569811999797821,
0.25869208574295044,
0.8360185027122498,
0.4450724422931671,
-0.4748588502407074,
-0.15714195370674133,
-0.5780936479568481,
-0.16017045080661774,
0.15108856558799744,
0.5989893674850464,
0.0710357278585434,
-0.2421383112668991,
0.36798158288002014,
-0.38745248317718506,
-0.23021940886974335,
-0.24610529839992523,
1.0606400966644287,
0.11324401944875717,
-0.8820410370826721,
0.3575419783592224,
-0.017910286784172058,
0.7122434973716736,
-0.8843985795974731,
-0.11319893598556519,
0.10475911945104599,
0.1121901273727417,
0.08183489739894867,
-0.5278587341308594,
-0.12884105741977692,
-0.19495922327041626,
-0.09303011000156403,
-0.47633638978004456,
0.5392321944236755,
-0.3491354286670685,
0.27368107438087463,
0.14239074289798737,
0.3966122567653656,
0.16164174675941467,
-0.25812697410583496,
-0.8909133672714233,
-0.29628047347068787,
0.2099742740392685,
-0.4056423306465149,
0.561140775680542,
0.5032352805137634,
-0.012655303813517094,
0.750925600528717,
0.9644753932952881,
-0.02088513784110546,
-0.03522872179746628,
0.08068744838237762,
1.0710591077804565,
-0.48531967401504517,
-0.8686559200286865,
-0.5340287685394287,
0.253256231546402,
-0.2909185588359833,
-0.4122626781463623,
0.4502963721752167,
0.27400416135787964,
0.8304803371429443,
0.2021491676568985,
0.6734375357627869,
-0.12988559901714325,
0.23783671855926514,
-0.4811022877693176,
0.1150118038058281,
-0.4673789143562317,
0.14407968521118164,
0.004815029911696911,
-0.9376739859580994,
0.5139009952545166,
0.4100707173347473,
-0.09761113673448563,
-0.10933588445186615,
0.676496148109436,
0.5384975671768188,
0.32136088609695435,
0.2033587396144867,
0.21178129315376282,
-0.2274215966463089,
0.5743095874786377,
0.9069122076034546,
1.3332329988479614,
0.22121232748031616,
0.54362952709198,
-0.2363758385181427,
-0.5689684748649597,
-0.259208083152771,
-0.3962033689022064,
-0.6305555701255798,
-0.5502976775169373,
-0.16980576515197754,
-0.23656593263149261,
0.29654547572135925,
1.041962742805481,
0.6144505739212036,
-0.6813745498657227,
-0.2644747197628021,
-0.11911266297101974,
0.011324796825647354,
-0.7519832849502563,
-0.25948193669319153,
0.05700179561972618,
-0.6474865078926086,
-0.6857950091362,
0.5676375031471252,
0.6457222104072571,
-0.3615541458129883,
-0.27336376905441284,
-0.36519956588745117,
-0.06390134245157242,
0.025230886414647102,
0.6251155138015747,
0.5163549184799194,
-0.6778951287269592,
-0.10083165764808655,
0.04220573604106903,
0.062376923859119415,
0.10229012370109558,
1.1454133987426758,
-0.8146859407424927,
0.40370920300483704,
0.3459544777870178,
0.7955809235572815,
0.3133375644683838,
0.07960014790296555,
0.45046088099479675,
-0.3910187780857086,
0.05597155541181564,
0.3635893166065216,
0.38465121388435364,
-0.04527191072702408,
-0.2990851402282715,
0.3204658627510071,
0.2858084440231323,
-0.7272436022758484,
-0.8153803944587708,
0.27427998185157776,
-0.9120426177978516,
-0.24360299110412598,
0.8896387815475464,
-0.4660455286502838,
-0.21369220316410065,
-0.45841535925865173,
-0.3507768511772156,
0.04700518399477005,
-0.8057252764701843,
0.7866369485855103,
0.6678891181945801,
-0.37326696515083313,
-0.036704037338495255,
-0.2772146165370941,
0.35036641359329224,
0.8157550096511841,
-0.8180474042892456,
-0.1633692979812622,
0.39586204290390015,
0.1062593162059784,
0.25449031591415405,
0.7940492033958435,
0.21309752762317657,
0.32040584087371826,
-0.22825632989406586,
-0.11663226038217545,
-0.13490568101406097,
-0.5397887825965881,
-0.49168819189071655,
0.1479765921831131,
-0.017505083233118057,
-0.16550058126449585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18034v1 | Paramanu: A Family of Novel Efficient Indic Generative Foundation Language Models | 2024-01-31T17:58:10 | 2024-01-31T17:58:10 | Mitodru Niyogi, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present Gyan AI Paramanu ("atom"), a family of novel language models for
Indian languages. It is a collection of auto-regressive monolingual, bilingual,
and multilingual Indic language models pretrained from scratch on a single GPU
for 10 Indian languages (Assamese, Bangla, Hindi, Konkani, Maithili, Marathi,
Odia, Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu) across 5 scripts (Bangla, Devanagari, Odia,
Tamil, Telugu) of varying sizes ranging from 13.29M to 367.5M.The models are
pretrained with a context size of 1024 on a single GPU. The models are very
efficient, small, fast, and powerful. We have also developed an efficient most
advanced Indic tokenizer that can even tokenize unseen languages. In order to
avoid the "curse of multi-linguality" in our multilingual mParamanu model, we
pretrained on comparable corpora by typological grouping using the same script.
We performed human evaluation of our pretrained models for open end text
generation on grammar, coherence, creativity, and factuality metrics for
Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit. Our Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit models
outperformed GPT-3.5-Turbo (ChatGPT), Bloom 7B, LLaMa-2 7B, OPT 6.7B, GPT-J 6B,
GPTNeo 1.3B, GPT2-XL large language models (LLMs) by a large margin despite
being smaller in size by 66 to 20 times compared to standard 7B LLMs. To run
inference on our pretrained models, CPU is enough, and GPU is not needed. We
also instruction-tuned our pretrained Bangla, Hindi, Marathi, Tamil, and Telugu
models on 23k instructions in respective languages. Our pretrained and
instruction-tuned models which are first of its kind, most powerful efficient
small generative language models ever developed for Indic languages, and the
various results lead to the conclusion that high quality generative language
models are possible without high amount of compute power and humongous number
of parameters. We plan to release our models at https://www.bharatgpts.com. | [
-0.3894352912902832,
-0.6992400884628296,
0.015006236732006073,
0.2433767169713974,
-0.4806695282459259,
0.049721624702215195,
-0.6135250926017761,
-0.283513605594635,
-0.047954343259334564,
0.2516406774520874,
-0.19522878527641296,
-0.33840858936309814,
-0.42936259508132935,
0.41437867283821106,
-0.32854947447776794,
0.783352255821228,
0.1275598555803299,
-0.05949567258358002,
-0.25815725326538086,
-0.346138596534729,
-0.3340661823749542,
-0.33119451999664307,
-0.5805274844169617,
-0.3059101700782776,
0.18176567554473877,
0.25658726692199707,
0.716370165348053,
0.6406701803207397,
0.36253976821899414,
0.36249133944511414,
0.09765729308128357,
0.10363087058067322,
-0.10788366198539734,
-0.21680906414985657,
-0.03173351660370827,
-0.46190041303634644,
-0.20289932191371918,
-0.187405526638031,
0.7580152153968811,
0.6438822746276855,
-0.28967800736427307,
0.10770620405673981,
0.08709969371557236,
0.4965875744819641,
-0.6794901490211487,
0.346862256526947,
-0.43185487389564514,
-0.21774901449680328,
-0.4350697994232178,
0.004406399093568325,
-0.5605741739273071,
-0.41743093729019165,
-0.28669431805610657,
-0.6432796120643616,
0.02742893435060978,
-0.053986020386219025,
0.850106418132782,
0.3320443034172058,
-0.3034178614616394,
-0.2350500077009201,
-0.930864691734314,
0.6831722855567932,
-0.9274703860282898,
0.36467817425727844,
0.3546726703643799,
0.40147730708122253,
0.028212895616889,
-0.5728736519813538,
-0.5944167375564575,
-0.4113636314868927,
-0.053910110145807266,
0.12250404804944992,
-0.003068514633923769,
0.14646479487419128,
0.0015466655604541302,
0.5973636507987976,
-0.7343717217445374,
0.10247169435024261,
-0.341537743806839,
0.1959998458623886,
0.5243808031082153,
0.22016045451164246,
0.5629539489746094,
-0.2451820820569992,
-0.3792945146560669,
0.03578343987464905,
-0.8188948035240173,
0.06948836147785187,
0.5937233567237854,
0.43946847319602966,
-0.32234203815460205,
0.3842127025127411,
-0.27779850363731384,
1.1625803709030151,
-0.08397788554430008,
-0.2824138104915619,
-0.022434702143073082,
-0.551523745059967,
-0.3226250410079956,
-0.09150344133377075,
1.2084691524505615,
-0.1339121162891388,
0.24274025857448578,
-0.19034616649150848,
0.0026175391394644976,
0.2920858860015869,
0.04248083382844925,
-0.7289617657661438,
-0.12119455635547638,
-0.10901360213756561,
-0.4328919053077698,
-0.20056362450122833,
-0.32376670837402344,
-0.7909106016159058,
-0.13235019147396088,
-0.38556694984436035,
0.22459234297275543,
-0.7898784875869751,
-0.7621625661849976,
-0.09911012649536133,
0.23963779211044312,
0.3396988809108734,
0.18511360883712769,
-1.3055592775344849,
0.19455385208129883,
0.409807413816452,
0.6175677180290222,
-0.051020096987485886,
-0.5439016819000244,
0.1024613082408905,
0.09238260239362717,
-0.5984358191490173,
0.7919639348983765,
-0.9255961775779724,
-0.41575607657432556,
-0.02275829389691353,
-0.44971030950546265,
-0.47052788734436035,
-0.5976410508155823,
0.4254917800426483,
-0.354208379983902,
-0.018407879397273064,
-0.11549769341945648,
-0.47290563583374023,
-0.2760980725288391,
0.10905040800571442,
-0.5802279114723206,
0.8219493627548218,
0.3278875946998596,
-0.7469140887260437,
0.30646488070487976,
-0.5500601530075073,
-0.4691369831562042,
0.5128335952758789,
-0.47341930866241455,
-0.12196537107229233,
0.21388466656208038,
0.21311423182487488,
0.2987886667251587,
-0.8292217254638672,
0.48373907804489136,
-0.028834059834480286,
-0.48010382056236267,
-0.04834505915641785,
-0.3163820207118988,
0.8314337134361267,
0.419185072183609,
-0.21063798666000366,
0.35974428057670593,
-0.9309654831886292,
-0.13811932504177094,
0.10911106318235397,
-0.45911920070648193,
-0.386743426322937,
-0.22537459433078766,
0.06417742371559143,
0.23751944303512573,
0.19474168121814728,
-0.4817941188812256,
-0.004754862282425165,
-0.3706809878349304,
0.6180476546287537,
0.62515789270401,
-0.31374743580818176,
0.40999916195869446,
0.004267469979822636,
0.9286347031593323,
0.04376521334052086,
0.2003432810306549,
-0.26639699935913086,
-0.5619115829467773,
-0.8223059773445129,
-0.355871319770813,
0.33644288778305054,
0.5109855532646179,
-0.8299788236618042,
0.2080269157886505,
-0.26125192642211914,
-0.5971401929855347,
-0.6181319952011108,
0.29504895210266113,
0.695178747177124,
0.49821293354034424,
0.1233057901263237,
0.06521300226449966,
-0.3814825713634491,
-1.1903090476989746,
-0.41901227831840515,
-0.25503626465797424,
0.3168153166770935,
-0.01722325198352337,
0.3334456980228424,
-0.32913854718208313,
0.8487606048583984,
0.027620768174529076,
0.1322823017835617,
-0.6091216802597046,
0.15839119255542755,
0.027798578143119812,
0.40149807929992676,
0.44382455945014954,
-0.8437650799751282,
-0.7169061303138733,
0.2675350606441498,
-1.0705211162567139,
0.22934329509735107,
0.052334219217300415,
-0.05324402078986168,
0.4154433310031891,
0.5764369368553162,
-0.869030237197876,
0.26099374890327454,
0.5785285830497742,
-0.21788287162780762,
0.5375184416770935,
-0.2641846835613251,
0.03567033261060715,
-1.4202910661697388,
0.14215187728405,
0.06367482244968414,
-0.1929493099451065,
-0.604189932346344,
0.5108789801597595,
0.14934062957763672,
-0.4625404477119446,
-0.4454542100429535,
0.5658760666847229,
-0.4950769245624542,
0.2576446235179901,
-0.2230280637741089,
-0.13807742297649384,
-0.4114106297492981,
0.7343587875366211,
-0.13952967524528503,
1.1066306829452515,
0.5768871903419495,
-0.7879040241241455,
0.2977498471736908,
0.2854967415332794,
-0.5012152791023254,
0.3469606339931488,
-0.5911023616790771,
0.014224107377231121,
-0.23441466689109802,
0.08288808166980743,
-0.9128918647766113,
-0.32990163564682007,
0.3663753569126129,
-0.3174566626548767,
0.46476641297340393,
-0.01940472237765789,
-0.505064070224762,
-0.30629944801330566,
0.01984640583395958,
0.553882896900177,
0.5347731113433838,
-0.5121520757675171,
0.7875857353210449,
0.2992991805076599,
-0.2368565797805786,
-0.5541509985923767,
-0.6139724254608154,
0.07426897436380386,
-0.3337298631668091,
-0.4114128053188324,
-0.09574335813522339,
-0.23248402774333954,
-0.19285592436790466,
0.13455060124397278,
0.19878102838993073,
-0.025965193286538124,
-0.14310325682163239,
0.2958972156047821,
0.2797539234161377,
-0.3161609470844269,
-0.035845816135406494,
0.18405888974666595,
-0.20567332208156586,
-0.12790438532829285,
-0.16710616648197174,
0.7614250183105469,
-0.5325388312339783,
-0.05925554409623146,
-0.6268619298934937,
0.31994378566741943,
0.5734696388244629,
-0.5646058917045593,
0.7925198078155518,
0.6689191460609436,
-0.47780346870422363,
0.07984765619039536,
-0.44332611560821533,
0.32878100872039795,
-0.4359554350376129,
0.2906985580921173,
-0.769801676273346,
-0.8489543199539185,
0.42711859941482544,
-0.10846614092588425,
-0.06677594035863876,
0.7480664849281311,
0.7368992567062378,
0.5233381390571594,
0.8982387781143188,
0.7681195139884949,
-0.2083994597196579,
0.383556991815567,
-0.35230013728141785,
0.3408985137939453,
-0.7508987188339233,
-0.17619460821151733,
-0.3508838713169098,
0.19283440709114075,
-0.6769497990608215,
-0.23761622607707977,
0.06983137130737305,
0.2952934503555298,
0.037786636501550674,
0.5207251310348511,
-0.468593567609787,
0.4922313690185547,
0.5792394280433655,
-0.1947745680809021,
0.24006877839565277,
0.05030534788966179,
-0.21998819708824158,
0.12999670207500458,
-0.8319377899169922,
-0.5266612768173218,
1.4289718866348267,
-0.032433897256851196,
0.7341551184654236,
-0.03289661183953285,
0.694249153137207,
-0.11219935864210129,
0.47159531712532043,
-0.3759740889072418,
0.6287451982498169,
-0.09551245719194412,
-0.7240208983421326,
-0.17672033607959747,
-0.4639226496219635,
-0.6920279264450073,
0.32349318265914917,
0.09241461753845215,
-0.48163750767707825,
0.22867736220359802,
0.10735483467578888,
-0.5270302295684814,
0.4013981521129608,
-0.9455823302268982,
1.0811768770217896,
-0.006050722673535347,
-0.28476622700691223,
-0.314143568277359,
-0.5951268672943115,
0.8476771116256714,
-0.10489632189273834,
0.185708686709404,
-0.16873136162757874,
-0.001933000748977065,
0.6078190207481384,
-0.44000184535980225,
0.589812695980072,
-0.06658666580915451,
0.08745649456977844,
0.600376307964325,
-0.08182725310325623,
0.27820271253585815,
0.20381969213485718,
-0.017258863896131516,
0.2694249451160431,
-0.1685238629579544,
-0.5502279996871948,
-0.4977005124092102,
0.8900509476661682,
-0.9572787880897522,
-0.4900129437446594,
-0.5067008137702942,
-0.5842412114143372,
-0.04260392487049103,
0.31950366497039795,
0.5652631521224976,
0.5741600394248962,
-0.2522068917751312,
0.040011197328567505,
0.4732951521873474,
-0.2835526168346405,
0.7951771020889282,
0.3051253855228424,
-0.19930511713027954,
-0.5254136323928833,
1.2436846494674683,
-0.03496364504098892,
0.21157687902450562,
0.49851858615875244,
0.22548936307430267,
-0.3574601709842682,
-0.6760671734809875,
-0.935944676399231,
0.35127782821655273,
-0.5713031888008118,
-0.20387792587280273,
-0.6619126200675964,
-0.24004359543323517,
-0.549058735370636,
0.14775075018405914,
-0.45580628514289856,
-0.3292135000228882,
-0.09493415057659149,
0.01210728008300066,
0.09916408360004425,
0.9528424143791199,
0.1415412724018097,
0.353527694940567,
-0.5236883759498596,
0.37878262996673584,
0.3446585237979889,
0.2953086793422699,
-0.09132222831249237,
-0.3370915353298187,
-0.313614159822464,
-0.11734342575073242,
-0.08480176329612732,
-0.5487765669822693,
0.3742038607597351,
0.4302458167076111,
0.4487428665161133,
0.4930517375469208,
-0.19894061982631683,
0.5599564909934998,
-0.4909916818141937,
0.5712196230888367,
0.15972702205181122,
-0.7529641389846802,
0.4814954400062561,
-0.4871980845928192,
0.37950509786605835,
0.7633358836174011,
0.5790277123451233,
-0.39790579676628113,
-0.3616706132888794,
-0.45189693570137024,
-0.72353196144104,
0.7202962040901184,
0.19816803932189941,
0.11062770336866379,
-0.2470322996377945,
0.4951777458190918,
0.319155216217041,
0.34451255202293396,
-0.6327978372573853,
-0.32903343439102173,
-0.27815955877304077,
-0.3665482699871063,
-0.4276629090309143,
-0.3955901265144348,
0.09837996959686279,
-0.5197482109069824,
0.6668075919151306,
-0.04743792116641998,
0.2401229441165924,
-0.0381239578127861,
-0.34369567036628723,
-0.08990085870027542,
0.26884275674819946,
0.75730961561203,
1.003045678138733,
-0.08646444231271744,
-0.06693929433822632,
-0.037246935069561005,
-0.4214964807033539,
0.28745830059051514,
0.3401894271373749,
-0.2817235291004181,
0.028457265347242355,
0.2809552848339081,
1.1733291149139404,
0.12398798763751984,
-0.7428812384605408,
0.22599941492080688,
-0.33844029903411865,
0.22004547715187073,
-0.5008130073547363,
-0.06453559547662735,
0.2688164710998535,
-0.07714532315731049,
0.08323898166418076,
0.17441903054714203,
0.03806078061461449,
-0.355663537979126,
-0.14494676887989044,
0.24642691016197205,
-0.06936158239841461,
-0.42514264583587646,
1.0270349979400635,
0.33230021595954895,
-0.32871195673942566,
0.7559645175933838,
-0.4532175362110138,
-0.2114628702402115,
0.3924422860145569,
0.7841722369194031,
0.979397177696228,
-0.7282357811927795,
0.17230117321014404,
0.5291357040405273,
0.4166102707386017,
-0.07422058284282684,
0.12235055863857269,
-0.11061933636665344,
-0.5031328797340393,
-0.3319898843765259,
-1.0608566999435425,
-0.3192666471004486,
0.2451070100069046,
-0.4238746464252472,
0.13078393042087555,
-0.6246217489242554,
0.024577701464295387,
-0.0902213528752327,
-0.004663220141083002,
-0.5482754707336426,
0.22490468621253967,
0.06887630373239517,
0.8194789886474609,
-1.0313230752944946,
1.138236165046692,
0.8021050095558167,
-0.6839647889137268,
-0.8628202676773071,
-0.26646751165390015,
-0.2890796959400177,
-0.5659449100494385,
0.42878246307373047,
0.25496023893356323,
-0.07115258276462555,
0.3046775162220001,
-0.061732809990644455,
-0.8108914494514465,
0.9247183799743652,
0.752526581287384,
-0.6367975473403931,
-0.12249457091093063,
0.32564985752105713,
0.48638787865638733,
-0.2748788297176361,
0.32986605167388916,
0.7195895314216614,
0.26192718744277954,
-0.22451117634773254,
-0.6630687713623047,
0.01690864749252796,
-0.7850679159164429,
0.5199804902076721,
0.38338494300842285,
-0.8330832123756409,
1.1949971914291382,
-0.027850084006786346,
-0.14903567731380463,
0.30408602952957153,
0.9033615589141846,
0.19638633728027344,
-0.06683976203203201,
0.3423835337162018,
1.0227431058883667,
0.4864535927772522,
0.07574612647294998,
1.5063681602478027,
-0.6808118224143982,
0.0878237783908844,
0.8247179985046387,
0.02494220621883869,
0.7581843137741089,
0.1751035451889038,
-0.18984507024288177,
0.48920318484306335,
0.6539506316184998,
0.3676404654979706,
0.28059640526771545,
0.009013407863676548,
-0.5390594601631165,
-0.37994104623794556,
-0.15242166817188263,
-0.5394008159637451,
0.46535634994506836,
0.21269112825393677,
0.01890517584979534,
-0.17998208105564117,
0.265686959028244,
0.03793836757540703,
0.24184033274650574,
-0.16438119113445282,
0.425901859998703,
0.0972229465842247,
-0.8087555170059204,
0.931313157081604,
0.33608508110046387,
0.805016040802002,
-0.8705089688301086,
0.12944060564041138,
-0.5159968137741089,
0.3496852219104767,
0.02487749606370926,
-0.005070737563073635,
0.257373183965683,
-0.07581134140491486,
0.08144065737724304,
0.06949752569198608,
0.6763661503791809,
-0.6388387680053711,
-0.7660498023033142,
0.2709473967552185,
0.19954948127269745,
0.057237111032009125,
-0.2299092561006546,
-0.5664689540863037,
0.23949500918388367,
-0.22605720162391663,
-0.1695241779088974,
0.3690907061100006,
0.11454080045223236,
-0.1638445258140564,
0.6583051085472107,
0.4549117684364319,
-0.06672610342502594,
0.4555869996547699,
0.051502443850040436,
0.6676139831542969,
-0.5963491797447205,
-0.5115264058113098,
-0.8915483355522156,
0.2363336682319641,
0.18333695828914642,
-0.5935105085372925,
0.9720605611801147,
0.8887332677841187,
1.0503804683685303,
-0.28906846046447754,
0.9023839235305786,
-0.027275381609797478,
0.20386455953121185,
-0.30838367342948914,
0.7989798188209534,
-0.4777698218822479,
-0.24155165255069733,
-0.03970884531736374,
-0.9633313417434692,
-0.22469736635684967,
0.3189791738986969,
-0.06547028571367264,
0.1639167070388794,
0.6473715901374817,
0.6224661469459534,
-0.05735157057642937,
0.04335620626807213,
0.28963059186935425,
-0.015344539657235146,
0.2086426019668579,
0.8790259957313538,
0.857965350151062,
-0.6090835928916931,
0.65557461977005,
-0.49593132734298706,
-0.32227811217308044,
-0.10370831936597824,
-0.37180519104003906,
-1.0393435955047607,
-0.6709929704666138,
-0.32260191440582275,
0.13191810250282288,
0.07895002514123917,
0.9441790580749512,
0.6718102693557739,
-0.7436917424201965,
-0.5769034028053284,
-0.5292806625366211,
-0.13075903058052063,
-0.06071702390909195,
-0.1724216639995575,
0.3504057228565216,
-0.5154836773872375,
-1.0122724771499634,
0.6939151287078857,
0.4233511686325073,
-0.09551513940095901,
-0.34628137946128845,
-0.2582513988018036,
-0.6028338670730591,
0.0810704305768013,
0.5935887098312378,
0.5895833373069763,
-0.7835621237754822,
0.26981350779533386,
-0.4296913146972656,
-0.23220562934875488,
0.1152532696723938,
0.8761734366416931,
-0.7046232223510742,
0.47931596636772156,
0.5178254246711731,
0.7203930020332336,
0.2875244915485382,
-0.11303544789552689,
0.4714515805244446,
-0.5078427791595459,
0.587118923664093,
0.10010804235935211,
0.2609182298183441,
0.533372700214386,
-0.21659784018993378,
0.44004201889038086,
0.41020527482032776,
-0.32234540581703186,
-0.8192850351333618,
0.18329493701457977,
-0.6635735630989075,
-0.2764616310596466,
1.048151969909668,
-0.07107038050889969,
-0.5084824562072754,
0.23545008897781372,
0.07953586429357529,
0.5510714054107666,
-0.10364925116300583,
0.49952027201652527,
0.6179215312004089,
0.015027797780930996,
-0.22493885457515717,
-0.5849859714508057,
0.5387856960296631,
0.40576544404029846,
-0.971390426158905,
0.022690344601869583,
0.11944060772657394,
0.2764134705066681,
0.12205078452825546,
0.844635546207428,
-0.21629352867603302,
0.2094276398420334,
0.20127330720424652,
0.25026339292526245,
-0.32694804668426514,
-0.7207028269767761,
-0.6501742601394653,
0.009338973090052605,
0.2248033881187439,
-0.3086845874786377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18028v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18028v2 | Evaluating the Capabilities of LLMs for Supporting Anticipatory Impact Assessment | 2024-01-31T17:43:04 | 2024-05-20T23:34:39 | Mowafak Allaham, Nicholas Diakopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Gaining insight into the potential negative impacts of emerging Artificial
Intelligence (AI) technologies in society is a challenge for implementing
anticipatory governance approaches. One approach to produce such insight is to
use Large Language Models (LLMs) to support and guide experts in the process of
ideating and exploring the range of undesirable consequences of emerging
technologies. However, performance evaluations of LLMs for such tasks are still
needed, including examining the general quality of generated impacts but also
the range of types of impacts produced and resulting biases. In this paper, we
demonstrate the potential for generating high-quality and diverse impacts of AI
in society by fine-tuning completion models (GPT-3 and Mistral-7B) on a diverse
sample of articles from news media and comparing those outputs to the impacts
generated by instruction-based (GPT-4 and Mistral-7B-Instruct) models. We
examine the generated impacts for coherence, structure, relevance, and
plausibility and find that the generated impacts using Mistral-7B, a small
open-source model fine-tuned on impacts from the news media, tend to be
qualitatively on par with impacts generated using a more capable and larger
scale model such as GPT-4. Moreover, we find that impacts produced by
instruction-based models had gaps in the production of certain categories of
impacts in comparison to fine-tuned models. This research highlights a
potential bias in the range of impacts generated by state-of-the-art LLMs and
the potential of aligning smaller LLMs on news media as a scalable alternative
to generate high quality and more diverse impacts in support of anticipatory
governance approaches. | [
-0.5356394052505493,
-0.7834959626197815,
0.6722277998924255,
-0.23988638818264008,
-0.12324263155460358,
-0.04942094162106514,
-0.23992300033569336,
-0.5686523914337158,
0.1090567335486412,
0.5341501235961914,
-0.2974056899547577,
-0.1866062581539154,
-0.9280896186828613,
-0.1176711767911911,
-0.6939743757247925,
1.141297459602356,
0.007330076303333044,
-0.005375225562602282,
0.0472310334444046,
0.25776973366737366,
-0.5376217365264893,
-0.20298731327056885,
-0.328731894493103,
-0.2876134514808655,
0.2454051375389099,
0.21060426533222198,
0.8789175748825073,
0.41201648116111755,
0.5478346347808838,
0.27216002345085144,
-0.26270297169685364,
0.19048471748828888,
-0.5824756026268005,
-0.5454426407814026,
-0.3574884831905365,
-0.25928494334220886,
-0.22923873364925385,
0.5079033970832825,
0.6558559536933899,
0.3526003658771515,
-0.1307687908411026,
0.45574426651000977,
0.4729289710521698,
0.3647415339946747,
-0.7003558278083801,
0.22072312235832214,
-0.7571806907653809,
-0.24745935201644897,
0.033872056752443314,
-0.13119158148765564,
-0.0880117267370224,
-0.5051612257957458,
0.3111092448234558,
-0.32954075932502747,
-0.22691278159618378,
-0.2869468629360199,
0.7875065207481384,
0.5923517346382141,
-0.38452398777008057,
-0.5507047176361084,
-0.8538830876350403,
0.716016948223114,
-0.9456631541252136,
0.23393946886062622,
0.23569712042808533,
0.23322822153568268,
-0.22375327348709106,
-0.5941633582115173,
-0.6809993982315063,
-0.12361003458499908,
0.10829995572566986,
0.14292512834072113,
-0.2397293746471405,
0.2981887459754944,
0.07207551598548889,
0.23349928855895996,
-0.1131698489189148,
0.23139436542987823,
-0.6287667155265808,
0.01926420070230961,
0.5161900520324707,
0.2670018970966339,
0.15439371764659882,
-0.3275419771671295,
-0.13339176774024963,
0.23435458540916443,
-0.7691654562950134,
0.20329906046390533,
0.5574560761451721,
0.37643635272979736,
-0.19066981971263885,
0.5662972927093506,
-0.14432524144649506,
0.5606667399406433,
-0.01372258085757494,
-0.06144426390528679,
-0.056356076151132584,
-0.525391697883606,
-0.161795973777771,
-0.13002139329910278,
0.7191374897956848,
0.2413335144519806,
0.27519479393959045,
0.019003553315997124,
-0.16383305191993713,
0.12727434933185577,
0.4358416199684143,
-0.7931011915206909,
-0.007161119487136602,
0.12777894735336304,
-0.44647541642189026,
-0.3147117495536804,
0.27273455262184143,
-0.5337753295898438,
-0.5373952984809875,
-0.6765574812889099,
0.7490523457527161,
-0.1236424520611763,
-0.2299555540084839,
0.0959249809384346,
0.025126323103904724,
0.17487645149230957,
0.6321906447410583,
-0.566705584526062,
0.06424951553344727,
0.7065760493278503,
0.8495649099349976,
-0.054832544177770615,
-0.061547499150037766,
-0.4611265957355499,
0.12345654517412186,
-0.3794383108615875,
0.7698700428009033,
-0.6204352378845215,
-0.4597495198249817,
0.01934135891497135,
-0.2561233639717102,
0.06276506185531616,
-0.6701807975769043,
0.36536839604377747,
-0.3841024935245514,
-0.056014809757471085,
-0.25364795327186584,
-0.43961095809936523,
-0.3685019612312317,
0.2686498761177063,
-0.7419540286064148,
0.7363267540931702,
0.15786908566951752,
-0.5664176344871521,
0.4447603225708008,
-0.6341227889060974,
-0.44731152057647705,
0.01802673749625683,
-0.46169358491897583,
-0.2180064469575882,
0.09687468409538269,
0.13337914645671844,
0.2878403961658478,
-0.4928259551525116,
0.7085744142532349,
-0.04569527506828308,
-0.5824803113937378,
-0.09170080721378326,
-0.7757693529129028,
0.5809199213981628,
0.016278652474284172,
-0.7779316902160645,
0.3341747522354126,
-0.7736997604370117,
0.05273972079157829,
-0.48051905632019043,
-0.6023648977279663,
-0.0630156472325325,
0.18942250311374664,
-0.051228489726781845,
0.2572982609272003,
0.3270558714866638,
-0.33587926626205444,
0.03424893692135811,
-0.176126629114151,
0.6209303736686707,
0.9777597188949585,
0.03933984041213989,
0.21983350813388824,
-0.39116066694259644,
0.5012335181236267,
-0.09886328130960464,
0.4140099585056305,
-0.18835610151290894,
-0.4699532091617584,
-0.5718793272972107,
-0.2718386948108673,
0.37901338934898376,
0.46780022978782654,
-0.7962849140167236,
0.28048259019851685,
-0.2922067940235138,
-0.6385175585746765,
-0.7094966769218445,
0.06267493963241577,
0.20900720357894897,
0.41300004720687866,
0.2471301406621933,
-0.2551475763320923,
-0.5493927597999573,
-0.8858461380004883,
-0.3365470767021179,
-0.37832218408584595,
0.1298019289970398,
0.41806235909461975,
0.574993908405304,
-0.2705543637275696,
1.117077112197876,
0.072611004114151,
-0.2682378590106964,
-0.1042822077870369,
0.18783169984817505,
0.29767414927482605,
0.28388944268226624,
0.29343536496162415,
-0.7786829471588135,
-0.20485849678516388,
-0.1279391646385193,
-0.6425092816352844,
-0.16991062462329865,
-0.16663484275341034,
0.06532824784517288,
-0.03567097708582878,
0.10978757590055466,
-0.7415053844451904,
0.6589946150779724,
0.5535836815834045,
-0.21896624565124512,
0.6009588241577148,
0.07716193050146103,
0.4984357953071594,
-0.754227340221405,
0.12823212146759033,
-0.009374917484819889,
0.013459300622344017,
-0.646477222442627,
-0.09802524745464325,
-0.09147072583436966,
0.09003565460443497,
-0.7903856635093689,
0.6568161249160767,
-0.28168028593063354,
-0.09101978689432144,
-0.3597208857536316,
-0.04493003711104393,
-0.13813510537147522,
-0.06222515180706978,
-0.12489713728427887,
0.898973286151886,
0.11252002418041229,
-0.5023313760757446,
-0.11307942867279053,
-0.007248202338814735,
-0.669162392616272,
0.07020015269517899,
-0.7170963287353516,
-0.24489177763462067,
-0.0007422412745654583,
0.2566651403903961,
-0.579899251461029,
-0.1964019387960434,
0.030326522886753082,
-0.3298639953136444,
0.036759380251169205,
-0.03128654509782791,
-0.5828838348388672,
-0.29863664507865906,
-0.4294489920139313,
0.3112371861934662,
0.46757152676582336,
-0.3842414915561676,
0.6985424757003784,
0.56801438331604,
-0.11722507327795029,
-0.43498706817626953,
-0.5678672194480896,
0.2707290053367615,
-0.23598463833332062,
-0.552014946937561,
0.041682127863168716,
0.08860788494348526,
-0.37383297085762024,
0.129587322473526,
0.13402879238128662,
0.31257903575897217,
0.16698656976222992,
0.34226083755493164,
0.19010809063911438,
-0.091934934258461,
-0.23732614517211914,
0.11324357986450195,
0.14365944266319275,
-0.04707064479589462,
-0.010058252140879631,
0.4209939241409302,
-0.019395384937524796,
-0.4169166088104248,
-0.5810045003890991,
0.14230455458164215,
0.6621751189231873,
-0.28713637590408325,
0.6578875780105591,
0.6079390048980713,
-0.48507875204086304,
-0.010957898572087288,
-0.7132691144943237,
-0.2544586956501007,
-0.47326940298080444,
0.5402806401252747,
0.07190840691328049,
-1.000693678855896,
0.6142058372497559,
-0.07392926514148712,
0.17764662206172943,
0.5907166600227356,
0.7026747465133667,
0.34914910793304443,
1.0132644176483154,
0.5746519565582275,
-0.21796461939811707,
0.7125968337059021,
-0.4337611198425293,
0.1536002904176712,
-0.7220863699913025,
-0.1504369080066681,
-0.2799483835697174,
-0.08502700924873352,
-0.5446733832359314,
-0.44973933696746826,
0.5712863802909851,
0.12110266089439392,
-0.40885311365127563,
-0.07804533839225769,
-0.3824412524700165,
0.3874105215072632,
0.8136497139930725,
-0.007784200832247734,
0.3361852765083313,
-0.10391298681497574,
0.44955867528915405,
0.2050577700138092,
-0.5505275130271912,
-0.9957590103149414,
1.1742862462997437,
0.43743348121643066,
0.8969609141349792,
0.15420973300933838,
0.5220934748649597,
0.6482726335525513,
0.648997962474823,
-0.6906619668006897,
0.3051280677318573,
-0.32916077971458435,
-0.4964767098426819,
-0.2723599076271057,
-0.43685269355773926,
-0.6906867623329163,
0.0002032237680396065,
-0.43315425515174866,
-0.7789916396141052,
0.09198995679616928,
-0.06876686215400696,
-0.6327788829803467,
0.3597032129764557,
-0.6535719633102417,
0.535656213760376,
-0.1975761204957962,
-0.29385074973106384,
-0.44054707884788513,
-0.2855002284049988,
0.3393816351890564,
-0.18111565709114075,
0.513800859451294,
-0.09550173580646515,
0.106101855635643,
0.8436298966407776,
-0.2784133553504944,
1.2211060523986816,
-0.3234923183917999,
-0.3586694300174713,
0.8419444561004639,
-0.20836405456066132,
0.4725407660007477,
0.010183034464716911,
-0.22111976146697998,
0.4803631603717804,
-0.09332378208637238,
-0.030537763610482216,
-0.4918838143348694,
0.6773952841758728,
-1.214646577835083,
-1.0424480438232422,
-0.07293011993169785,
-0.6994495391845703,
-0.052870430052280426,
0.35278773307800293,
0.051879387348890305,
0.34361398220062256,
-0.1929382085800171,
-0.025166640058159828,
0.2674906849861145,
-0.1659218817949295,
0.4217173755168915,
0.7030724883079529,
0.0347440131008625,
-0.4179101586341858,
0.9486021399497986,
0.6800010204315186,
0.06015260890126228,
-0.09383208304643631,
0.12350074201822281,
-0.09285615384578705,
-0.7699960470199585,
-0.6409433484077454,
-0.07158820331096649,
-0.5043407678604126,
-0.29462021589279175,
-0.5044494271278381,
-0.4344794452190399,
-0.4336836636066437,
0.019725976511836052,
-0.16373950242996216,
-0.2862817347049713,
-0.4897509515285492,
0.05831122398376465,
-0.028126563876867294,
1.3396445512771606,
-0.13097679615020752,
0.4424141049385071,
-0.9211769700050354,
0.14162804186344147,
0.19470401108264923,
0.31120195984840393,
0.23689042031764984,
-0.5621798038482666,
-0.6538224816322327,
0.23519761860370636,
-0.6978073716163635,
-0.6378886699676514,
0.12524014711380005,
0.08652681112289429,
0.681312620639801,
0.32952702045440674,
-0.040603816509246826,
0.5643376708030701,
-0.7136232852935791,
1.0203752517700195,
-0.03149305656552315,
-0.8733371496200562,
0.5681302547454834,
-0.5699341297149658,
0.25593987107276917,
0.43443650007247925,
0.25699517130851746,
-0.05061504244804382,
-0.5330373048782349,
-0.4628968834877014,
-0.9206648468971252,
0.5432192087173462,
0.13454239070415497,
0.2607543170452118,
-0.2413555383682251,
0.4355757534503937,
0.20636793971061707,
0.322825163602829,
-0.41518181562423706,
0.20581692457199097,
-0.10572652518749237,
-0.2763817608356476,
0.08078384399414062,
-0.3715323209762573,
0.025797788053750992,
-0.0007652965723536909,
0.7739993929862976,
0.15441246330738068,
-0.14373795688152313,
0.05502425879240036,
0.1068931296467781,
-0.2290075570344925,
0.2978453040122986,
0.4843619763851166,
0.5750064849853516,
-0.04219713434576988,
-0.1136101707816124,
-0.06473688781261444,
-0.53168123960495,
0.07660409063100815,
0.22143247723579407,
-0.5566843152046204,
-0.27429431676864624,
0.4921009838581085,
0.597654402256012,
-0.09475597739219666,
-0.7892055511474609,
0.41002070903778076,
0.13746583461761475,
-0.11908041685819626,
-0.20229147374629974,
0.2262626439332962,
-0.1057157889008522,
0.6401419043540955,
0.5640663504600525,
0.08715736865997314,
0.46607741713523865,
-0.6294994354248047,
0.2907606363296509,
0.600166380405426,
-0.38982105255126953,
-0.3051857650279999,
0.7464733123779297,
0.30342650413513184,
-0.10138147324323654,
0.35761672258377075,
-0.006918191444128752,
-0.41214805841445923,
0.8727142810821533,
0.31371816992759705,
0.6627192497253418,
-0.14655081927776337,
0.025771334767341614,
0.27805712819099426,
0.5632043480873108,
-0.3267652690410614,
0.3641561269760132,
0.31687524914741516,
-0.6070383191108704,
-0.6197012662887573,
-0.6277781128883362,
-0.34044894576072693,
0.19952337443828583,
-0.5480942130088806,
0.4011254608631134,
-0.45205143094062805,
-0.5285988450050354,
-0.09662516415119171,
0.06772655993700027,
-0.6436830759048462,
0.19215165078639984,
0.14352113008499146,
0.7240408062934875,
-0.8197906613349915,
0.5130903720855713,
0.6634705066680908,
-0.4776148498058319,
-0.7771008014678955,
0.1922936886548996,
0.1830180585384369,
-0.7206928133964539,
0.5245682001113892,
0.27409350872039795,
-0.13225680589675903,
-0.058103207498788834,
-0.38064077496528625,
-0.9689542651176453,
0.9724268913269043,
0.5372983813285828,
-0.6890080571174622,
-0.2515324652194977,
0.38503918051719666,
0.5739089250564575,
-0.33826854825019836,
0.4901328384876251,
0.6090348958969116,
0.5584096312522888,
-0.21517126262187958,
-1.3682310581207275,
-0.00848550908267498,
-0.11061353981494904,
-0.011889207176864147,
0.22881391644477844,
-0.732059895992279,
0.8467364311218262,
-0.2912614643573761,
-0.23009151220321655,
0.06642242521047592,
0.5920313596725464,
0.05027294531464577,
0.24897336959838867,
0.37620019912719727,
0.5240622758865356,
0.47155439853668213,
0.21863500773906708,
1.050903081893921,
-0.5733024477958679,
0.32394346594810486,
1.0469751358032227,
0.20061630010604858,
0.9264920949935913,
0.38187775015830994,
-0.23904965817928314,
0.3414466381072998,
0.6633167266845703,
0.09309281408786774,
0.4845876395702362,
0.3773193061351776,
-0.17012034356594086,
0.04206571355462074,
-0.609329104423523,
-0.196711927652359,
0.4987281858921051,
0.5397459864616394,
-0.43507444858551025,
-0.14604465663433075,
0.056344471871852875,
0.008494360372424126,
0.10562245547771454,
-0.7779348492622375,
0.7125648260116577,
0.06192071735858917,
-0.7053050994873047,
0.3628036677837372,
-0.05869598686695099,
0.923776388168335,
-0.16682325303554535,
-0.29081472754478455,
0.16003477573394775,
0.01717117801308632,
-0.358931303024292,
-0.9424747824668884,
0.36126574873924255,
0.15748311579227448,
-0.34430691599845886,
0.39898309111595154,
0.43107202649116516,
-0.40770673751831055,
-0.6126773357391357,
0.36566436290740967,
0.7225010395050049,
-0.0910276398062706,
-0.030983557924628258,
-0.4196966588497162,
0.24622592329978943,
-0.018910208716988564,
-0.34184858202934265,
0.2059599906206131,
0.3149177134037018,
-0.3311443030834198,
0.39431148767471313,
0.36109280586242676,
0.2457267791032791,
-0.014454711228609085,
0.20110200345516205,
0.9079466462135315,
-0.371287077665329,
-0.3402579128742218,
-1.0277466773986816,
0.43557190895080566,
0.35084933042526245,
-0.21121110022068024,
0.5717720985412598,
0.5197114944458008,
0.7650394439697266,
0.3486807644367218,
1.207768201828003,
-0.0896596759557724,
0.3023425042629242,
-0.42286962270736694,
0.7238443493843079,
-0.48924821615219116,
0.5006600618362427,
-0.3176295757293701,
-0.775446355342865,
-0.006106494925916195,
0.24029502272605896,
-0.6352141499519348,
0.25836867094039917,
-0.06307996064424515,
0.6024010181427002,
-0.03692226484417915,
0.09546522051095963,
0.251788854598999,
0.3038583993911743,
0.6069964170455933,
0.33697813749313354,
0.8831822872161865,
-0.24286256730556488,
0.5543274879455566,
0.14840368926525116,
-0.4846987724304199,
0.1296701282262802,
-0.672367513179779,
-0.9031599760055542,
-0.4423379600048065,
0.05121874436736107,
-0.20081056654453278,
0.3467816710472107,
0.8041169047355652,
0.5414702892303467,
-0.5708838105201721,
-0.054809242486953735,
0.09071797877550125,
-0.0606941357254982,
0.3367442190647125,
-0.3042463958263397,
0.5533021092414856,
-0.17915678024291992,
-0.7215461134910583,
0.07856104522943497,
0.1629498302936554,
0.035301849246025085,
-0.5496233701705933,
-0.0779598280787468,
-0.0564112514257431,
0.3883751928806305,
0.7661996483802795,
-0.04488161951303482,
-0.9672473073005676,
-0.5574848055839539,
-0.2595295011997223,
0.06907135993242264,
-0.194778174161911,
0.5997925400733948,
-0.9463937282562256,
0.14933663606643677,
0.31044140458106995,
0.7680118083953857,
0.02191881276667118,
0.027046097442507744,
0.47680529952049255,
-0.24945157766342163,
-0.10179802030324936,
0.06119810417294502,
0.17470690608024597,
0.2683035433292389,
-0.5311397910118103,
0.5920820832252502,
-0.16733218729496002,
-0.7132006883621216,
-0.7148653864860535,
0.15097014605998993,
-0.4067825675010681,
-0.2803780734539032,
1.3349547386169434,
-0.11141262948513031,
-0.05129758641123772,
-0.04709158092737198,
-0.2680952250957489,
0.3770737648010254,
-0.5422487258911133,
1.1625186204910278,
0.6256875991821289,
-0.29303526878356934,
-0.1538337916135788,
-0.6742449998855591,
0.3271781802177429,
0.1373296082019806,
-0.7692621946334839,
-0.0162873025983572,
0.5105339884757996,
0.09353233873844147,
0.10873681306838989,
0.6860647201538086,
-0.19366878271102905,
0.2915257513523102,
-0.2069348394870758,
0.03306197747588158,
-0.11697303503751755,
-0.2828851342201233,
-0.2661682665348053,
-0.02825971134006977,
0.09730805456638336,
0.2728509306907654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18018v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18018v4 | On Prompt-Driven Safeguarding for Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T17:28:24 | 2024-06-03T06:52:58 | Chujie Zheng, Fan Yin, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Kai-Wei Chang, Minlie Huang, Nanyun Peng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prepending model inputs with safety prompts is a common practice for
safeguarding large language models (LLMs) against queries with harmful intents.
However, the underlying working mechanisms of safety prompts have not been
unraveled yet, restricting the possibility of automatically optimizing them to
improve LLM safety. In this work, we investigate how LLMs' behavior (i.e.,
complying with or refusing user queries) is affected by safety prompts from the
perspective of model representation. We find that in the representation space,
the input queries are typically moved by safety prompts in a "higher-refusal"
direction, in which models become more prone to refusing to provide assistance,
even when the queries are harmless. On the other hand, LLMs are naturally
capable of distinguishing harmful and harmless queries without safety prompts.
Inspired by these findings, we propose a method for safety prompt optimization,
namely DRO (Directed Representation Optimization). Treating a safety prompt as
continuous, trainable embeddings, DRO learns to move the queries'
representations along or opposite the refusal direction, depending on their
harmfulness. Experiments with eight LLMs on out-of-domain and jailbreak
benchmarks demonstrate that DRO remarkably improves the safeguarding
performance of human-crafted safety prompts, without compromising the models'
general performance. | [
-0.09113168716430664,
-0.7402408719062805,
0.8821825385093689,
0.10007137060165405,
-0.27249816060066223,
0.09308436512947083,
0.011296771466732025,
-0.2168492078781128,
-0.1774817854166031,
0.6921036243438721,
-0.7060337066650391,
-0.5691536664962769,
-0.36615192890167236,
0.2332390397787094,
-0.010435286909341812,
0.6276293396949768,
0.06207948178052902,
-0.20534701645374298,
-0.29275792837142944,
0.20879822969436646,
-0.8743998408317566,
-0.7238110899925232,
-0.9843030571937561,
0.029626790434122086,
0.8325852751731873,
0.19229896366596222,
0.7420198917388916,
0.9386422634124756,
0.165248841047287,
0.3123534619808197,
-0.28070199489593506,
0.09477918595075607,
-0.36841830611228943,
0.7055119276046753,
-0.26451417803764343,
-0.5114386677742004,
-0.23359060287475586,
-0.10273084044456482,
0.5008202791213989,
0.3763054609298706,
-0.2234923541545868,
-0.4828004240989685,
0.09886810928583145,
0.5165908336639404,
-0.7824829816818237,
0.10784850269556046,
-0.46362215280532837,
0.06422112882137299,
0.08306753635406494,
-0.26542961597442627,
-0.9710701704025269,
-0.37012526392936707,
-0.10842358320951462,
-0.5219826698303223,
-0.19310729205608368,
0.2013254165649414,
0.588988184928894,
0.21761846542358398,
-0.45302432775497437,
-0.15225881338119507,
-0.2545854151248932,
0.8347291350364685,
-0.528491199016571,
0.1896110326051712,
0.5015736222267151,
0.27277782559394836,
-0.827187716960907,
-0.2849911153316498,
-0.3802463412284851,
-0.45159292221069336,
-0.2021609991788864,
-0.2691614031791687,
-0.16554301977157593,
0.4594314992427826,
0.5787091255187988,
-0.47751033306121826,
-0.44835302233695984,
0.6059693694114685,
0.03995967283844948,
-0.4617011845111847,
0.8324499726295471,
0.2944420576095581,
0.4971359074115753,
-0.23829735815525055,
-0.5839192867279053,
-0.6752197742462158,
-1.144264578819275,
0.2903387248516083,
0.2824866771697998,
0.36680519580841064,
0.08134162425994873,
0.17140108346939087,
-0.02959335595369339,
0.5872076153755188,
0.0023299073800444603,
-0.219267338514328,
-0.16092164814472198,
-0.009218375198543072,
-0.02616441622376442,
0.004210733808577061,
1.0281850099563599,
0.5407615303993225,
0.4529801607131958,
0.020094623789191246,
-0.6446685194969177,
-0.2175932228565216,
0.23255403339862823,
-0.7960513830184937,
0.01709640398621559,
0.17132145166397095,
-0.3176332712173462,
-0.5834805965423584,
-0.06851032376289368,
-0.8753886818885803,
-0.7106944918632507,
-0.11091984808444977,
0.19673706591129303,
-0.29946595430374146,
-0.1303209364414215,
0.0025753858499228954,
0.09470077604055405,
-0.13182887434959412,
0.18346422910690308,
-0.8789690732955933,
-0.06092296540737152,
0.5999311804771423,
0.632204532623291,
-0.0296233631670475,
0.0031822961755096912,
-0.91645747423172,
0.32711267471313477,
-0.6355616450309753,
0.43407025933265686,
-0.7136253714561462,
-0.7384064197540283,
0.2202182412147522,
0.09387629479169846,
-0.2563612461090088,
-0.42843490839004517,
0.7003167867660522,
-0.9528855085372925,
0.0791991651058197,
-0.5993287563323975,
-0.19499890506267548,
-0.22428931295871735,
0.11502423882484436,
-0.46577125787734985,
0.46145549416542053,
-0.27614831924438477,
-0.6042435765266418,
0.3456593453884125,
-0.44169655442237854,
-0.4891766905784607,
-0.15065349638462067,
-0.41930264234542847,
-0.3394068479537964,
-0.018648715689778328,
0.3125512897968292,
0.5349726676940918,
-0.020599480718374252,
0.3402025103569031,
-0.3659701943397522,
-0.22606563568115234,
0.41447439789772034,
-0.4251129925251007,
0.8419032096862793,
0.3099108338356018,
-0.08650865405797958,
0.5426287651062012,
-0.45378270745277405,
-0.14921383559703827,
0.3598092794418335,
-0.2648038864135742,
-0.7288367748260498,
0.15660379827022552,
-0.46128642559051514,
0.39670610427856445,
0.059516046196222305,
-0.5093860626220703,
0.1257549524307251,
-0.3970903158187866,
0.4905315041542053,
1.2495580911636353,
0.10793621838092804,
0.43814948201179504,
-0.2258959859609604,
0.7823647260665894,
0.12423811852931976,
0.315502792596817,
-0.3515293300151825,
-0.21961432695388794,
-0.27486464381217957,
-0.36286062002182007,
-0.022080503404140472,
0.5946252346038818,
-0.6908098459243774,
0.5117087364196777,
0.12863010168075562,
0.04112299531698227,
-0.03127548471093178,
-0.12849467992782593,
0.5698134899139404,
0.695522665977478,
0.08576636761426926,
0.08487764000892639,
-0.2645716071128845,
-0.8368332982063293,
-0.0797840803861618,
-0.49190670251846313,
0.08608650416135788,
0.20865903794765472,
0.14672382175922394,
-0.15091779828071594,
0.8009795546531677,
-0.43680238723754883,
0.06216329336166382,
-0.054174091666936874,
-0.15992018580436707,
0.05679115280508995,
0.6192610859870911,
0.8789930939674377,
-0.8201467394828796,
-0.3967663049697876,
-0.32086360454559326,
-0.9345834255218506,
-0.16235308349132538,
-0.26986587047576904,
-0.22246943414211273,
0.42590057849884033,
0.8278372287750244,
-0.8334593176841736,
0.2604719400405884,
0.09992464631795883,
-0.3670905828475952,
0.5381972193717957,
-0.23681730031967163,
0.10678375512361526,
-0.9124796390533447,
-0.16142818331718445,
-0.24848201870918274,
-0.3171217739582062,
-0.5493102669715881,
0.34790781140327454,
0.3078652620315552,
-0.3970966637134552,
-0.4752817749977112,
0.47761523723602295,
-0.47391068935394287,
0.4141121506690979,
-0.2847662568092346,
0.045844778418540955,
0.020320696756243706,
0.18211035430431366,
0.15037979185581207,
0.9708869457244873,
1.0094727277755737,
-0.8497474193572998,
0.0030153857078403234,
0.21301652491092682,
0.1152893453836441,
0.360018253326416,
-0.8824071288108826,
0.48356321454048157,
-0.30457860231399536,
0.16951557993888855,
-0.8538893461227417,
-0.2554880678653717,
0.34829646348953247,
-0.08559098839759827,
0.6363306045532227,
-0.5395320057868958,
-0.5519500374794006,
-0.3201233446598053,
-0.5272663831710815,
0.2867431938648224,
0.659224271774292,
-0.5610561966896057,
0.4209029972553253,
0.4070081412792206,
-0.366131067276001,
-0.8309682011604309,
-0.4209609031677246,
0.07401737570762634,
-0.6101191639900208,
-0.7060570120811462,
0.18548990786075592,
-0.05061221122741699,
-0.29264816641807556,
-0.38449740409851074,
-0.10654428601264954,
0.16653233766555786,
0.36621466279029846,
0.35184577107429504,
0.4595479965209961,
0.17959745228290558,
0.19029660522937775,
0.3165154457092285,
-0.21037156879901886,
0.41550594568252563,
0.06964435428380966,
0.5017758011817932,
0.3342786729335785,
-0.38786232471466064,
-0.5135797262191772,
0.5822184681892395,
0.464599072933197,
-0.20069199800491333,
0.8936903476715088,
-0.1457306146621704,
-0.21709483861923218,
-0.3548344671726227,
-0.24490652978420258,
-0.632656455039978,
-0.6529108881950378,
0.21079306304454803,
-0.3606758415699005,
-0.9145453572273254,
0.5452459454536438,
0.1118210181593895,
0.2504911720752716,
0.13650257885456085,
0.15889310836791992,
-0.04743511974811554,
1.3782175779342651,
0.6107292771339417,
-0.09879913926124573,
0.5431254506111145,
0.32716166973114014,
0.16027042269706726,
-0.3711085617542267,
-0.3026729226112366,
-0.5877254605293274,
-0.0015291766030713916,
-0.6793509721755981,
-0.24103491008281708,
0.3832847774028778,
0.27151060104370117,
-0.30147573351860046,
0.42313745617866516,
-0.5099572539329529,
0.5172500014305115,
0.292074590921402,
0.10770657658576965,
0.084989033639431,
0.10798224806785583,
-0.3557516932487488,
-0.050764452666044235,
-0.7156775593757629,
-0.678490400314331,
0.5874544978141785,
0.5424453020095825,
1.0979652404785156,
0.12841910123825073,
1.000866413116455,
0.2493351846933365,
-0.08883284777402878,
-0.576404333114624,
1.0203274488449097,
0.2588832676410675,
-0.49684906005859375,
-0.12866784632205963,
-0.6890623569488525,
-1.014380931854248,
0.28998878598213196,
-0.06876280903816223,
-0.809699535369873,
0.4086230993270874,
0.16703210771083832,
-0.5595332384109497,
0.09196772426366806,
-0.7625401616096497,
0.5584371089935303,
-0.2445058822631836,
-0.4603690505027771,
-0.3338674306869507,
-0.6694128513336182,
0.2063477635383606,
-0.0369376502931118,
0.23465532064437866,
-0.10915665328502655,
-0.05384080111980438,
0.8039180040359497,
-0.28833186626434326,
1.0265822410583496,
-0.5274216532707214,
-0.27324798703193665,
0.3071833848953247,
0.527573823928833,
0.9058887958526611,
0.25449496507644653,
-0.20557907223701477,
-0.19765153527259827,
0.060850128531455994,
-0.17775020003318787,
-0.4406503140926361,
0.8746529221534729,
-0.2750513255596161,
-1.1843013763427734,
-0.5971505045890808,
-0.5743069052696228,
-0.2491099238395691,
0.40789708495140076,
0.14117556810379028,
0.23932889103889465,
0.06912972778081894,
-0.05217188596725464,
1.0197269916534424,
-0.6026122570037842,
0.8194330334663391,
0.5423051118850708,
-0.1931886225938797,
0.031589142978191376,
0.4580787122249603,
0.017118122428655624,
0.29472196102142334,
0.19603082537651062,
0.2416858971118927,
-0.5924241542816162,
-0.7303737998008728,
-0.5086022615432739,
0.22664335370063782,
-0.9232045412063599,
-0.36774635314941406,
-0.5717711448669434,
0.04065157473087311,
-0.3273053765296936,
-0.08213913440704346,
-0.04912368953227997,
-0.27096426486968994,
-0.41200897097587585,
-0.4320286214351654,
0.49982208013534546,
0.5133047699928284,
-0.08741769939661026,
0.0873834565281868,
-0.8605997562408447,
-0.11287499964237213,
0.23384325206279755,
0.17878232896327972,
0.06173279508948326,
-0.452644407749176,
0.2779780328273773,
-0.17279550433158875,
-0.12135431170463562,
-0.7271420955657959,
0.2818286120891571,
-0.18221288919448853,
0.7095507979393005,
0.6634956002235413,
0.7973348498344421,
0.2619214653968811,
-0.5723099112510681,
0.44757652282714844,
0.2560063600540161,
-0.41926661133766174,
0.6778507232666016,
-0.5920283794403076,
-0.19268755614757538,
0.5454813838005066,
0.4654231667518616,
-0.3306334316730499,
-0.10145741701126099,
-0.05508255213499069,
-0.8043943643569946,
0.6925016641616821,
-0.08752764761447906,
0.6654131412506104,
-0.3447464406490326,
0.36634787917137146,
-0.012170246802270412,
0.025337375700473785,
-0.6286172866821289,
-0.003987891599535942,
0.19891446828842163,
-0.0009587365784682333,
0.40906229615211487,
-0.6585114002227783,
-0.4647374153137207,
0.25967490673065186,
0.39613860845565796,
-0.0330890491604805,
0.15087252855300903,
0.04718692600727081,
0.03813357651233673,
-0.121894970536232,
0.47417768836021423,
0.5392709970474243,
0.4106515944004059,
-0.052170731127262115,
0.1049366369843483,
-0.15337294340133667,
-0.1960795521736145,
0.36783838272094727,
0.28029292821884155,
-0.5195092558860779,
-0.33639153838157654,
0.34333059191703796,
0.6448712944984436,
-0.13236209750175476,
-0.7628246545791626,
0.37646710872650146,
-0.18022431433200836,
0.2078281044960022,
-0.00840582326054573,
0.5562971234321594,
-0.28416410088539124,
0.008468177169561386,
0.2976776659488678,
-0.0664089173078537,
0.022401733323931694,
-0.4800357222557068,
0.20735161006450653,
0.562591552734375,
-0.29774218797683716,
-0.22457319498062134,
0.8044958710670471,
0.25797662138938904,
-0.29245540499687195,
0.5457519888877869,
-0.10928653925657272,
-0.5299243927001953,
0.4503902196884155,
0.5401949286460876,
0.8790006637573242,
-0.35241177678108215,
0.18623502552509308,
0.53044593334198,
0.2810954749584198,
-0.12278657406568527,
0.24990905821323395,
0.033174410462379456,
-0.5465155839920044,
-0.2405499666929245,
-0.44522392749786377,
-0.16356141865253448,
-0.12583859264850616,
-0.5499374866485596,
0.07641378045082092,
-0.8548164963722229,
-0.28320589661598206,
-0.41756558418273926,
-0.4766586720943451,
-0.20344175398349762,
0.030128641054034233,
-0.021747326478362083,
0.9065462946891785,
-0.620875895023346,
0.5547896027565002,
0.4979330599308014,
-0.37586596608161926,
-0.8700388669967651,
0.10386066138744354,
0.04466604068875313,
-0.6371924877166748,
0.4177466332912445,
0.3711632490158081,
-0.1718617081642151,
-0.15740619599819183,
-0.5711455345153809,
-0.6171797513961792,
0.7731177806854248,
0.6838454604148865,
-1.0316948890686035,
-0.0960441455245018,
-0.023919930681586266,
0.24411863088607788,
-0.146849125623703,
-0.2130862921476364,
0.3884361684322357,
0.27972161769866943,
-0.11942467093467712,
-0.6735464930534363,
0.6630481481552124,
0.10556492954492569,
0.04618101567029953,
0.101239874958992,
-0.44045141339302063,
0.5522839426994324,
-0.48751646280288696,
-0.6340338587760925,
0.08490657806396484,
0.3855591416358948,
0.6775569319725037,
0.2838241755962372,
0.7635486125946045,
0.2440938651561737,
0.7663328647613525,
-0.17777866125106812,
1.425711989402771,
0.10637816786766052,
-0.06577792763710022,
0.7686030864715576,
-0.4167879819869995,
0.5873910784721375,
0.5702205300331116,
0.016738800331950188,
0.4538695514202118,
0.7334028482437134,
0.3874247074127197,
0.9439284205436707,
0.08890842646360397,
-0.46860471367836,
-0.3993241488933563,
-0.28300246596336365,
-0.3181705176830292,
0.023120082914829254,
0.2588551938533783,
-0.5122858285903931,
-0.08315467834472656,
0.11382774263620377,
0.2738422453403473,
0.3180389702320099,
-0.22182852029800415,
0.9011828899383545,
0.31860804557800293,
-0.7498086094856262,
0.8696393966674805,
0.03780020773410797,
0.41425976157188416,
-0.6059315204620361,
0.03428656607866287,
-0.3085311949253082,
-0.06472316384315491,
0.0427241176366806,
-0.8392674922943115,
0.1625228375196457,
-0.054559241980314255,
-0.10275372117757797,
-0.35222575068473816,
0.8204549551010132,
-0.14171744883060455,
-0.04915326461195946,
0.6317670345306396,
0.008999321609735489,
-0.06691408902406693,
0.014395104721188545,
-0.6208429336547852,
0.08814502507448196,
-0.059261515736579895,
-0.3596764802932739,
0.6219066381454468,
0.34538161754608154,
-0.5649880170822144,
0.8412926197052002,
0.7403137683868408,
-0.27026239037513733,
-0.12697574496269226,
0.2964572012424469,
1.0823948383331299,
-0.5705955624580383,
-0.7423961758613586,
-1.0672125816345215,
0.39972051978111267,
0.008476085029542446,
0.24420377612113953,
0.6524103879928589,
0.006931430660188198,
0.4854874610900879,
-0.1305801272392273,
0.715553343296051,
-0.01874522678554058,
0.18186381459236145,
-0.8148301839828491,
0.9311902523040771,
-0.2287246584892273,
0.42330387234687805,
-0.2158960998058319,
-0.6818889379501343,
-0.2856617569923401,
0.5906513929367065,
-0.43422478437423706,
0.18215295672416687,
0.30566728115081787,
1.1257880926132202,
0.2287992388010025,
-0.2528722286224365,
0.45999711751937866,
-0.09821069240570068,
0.5741450786590576,
0.44131341576576233,
1.03218412399292,
0.026720527559518814,
0.40588024258613586,
-0.2197088599205017,
-0.24469028413295746,
-0.1402360498905182,
-1.0933326482772827,
-1.1069775819778442,
-0.3181491792201996,
-0.21298353374004364,
-0.40809935331344604,
0.3057394027709961,
0.9368770122528076,
0.9442360997200012,
-0.9037957787513733,
0.11077733337879181,
-0.18395811319351196,
0.33511102199554443,
-0.018119342625141144,
-0.21486523747444153,
0.4127711057662964,
-0.33805450797080994,
-0.5312321186065674,
0.9660829901695251,
0.12003379315137863,
0.23840220272541046,
-0.16206558048725128,
-0.18599660694599152,
0.054829444736242294,
0.17986030876636505,
0.5390851497650146,
0.29974013566970825,
-0.46220117807388306,
-0.5157895684242249,
0.0723455622792244,
-0.22399915754795074,
-0.11642686277627945,
0.6297122836112976,
-0.524777352809906,
0.5430182218551636,
0.6369325518608093,
0.5916334986686707,
-0.05280481278896332,
0.12582196295261383,
0.8088133335113525,
-0.9947410225868225,
0.29584264755249023,
0.37172043323516846,
0.4547535479068756,
0.422380268573761,
-0.859892725944519,
0.25189208984375,
-0.0018820480909198523,
-0.5281336307525635,
-0.9520800113677979,
0.5645256042480469,
-0.7003980278968811,
-0.2953415811061859,
0.9964497089385986,
-0.38503211736679077,
-0.14635279774665833,
-0.12863823771476746,
-0.3067891001701355,
-0.01974184811115265,
-0.836493730545044,
0.8326832056045532,
0.44673219323158264,
-0.011878159828484058,
-0.4345894455909729,
-0.4542083144187927,
0.6577871441841125,
0.4821597635746002,
-0.5204107761383057,
0.5121120810508728,
0.6453824043273926,
0.2852931022644043,
0.13193053007125854,
0.24688151478767395,
-0.28291282057762146,
0.28589650988578796,
-0.2779442071914673,
-0.3045039176940918,
-0.3632839322090149,
-0.49608051776885986,
-0.5894494652748108,
0.07872902601957321,
0.33856505155563354,
-0.30018150806427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18001v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18001v1 | Desiderata for the Context Use of Question Answering Systems | 2024-01-31T17:02:31 | 2024-01-31T17:02:31 | Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior work has uncovered a set of common problems in state-of-the-art
context-based question answering (QA) systems: a lack of attention to the
context when the latter conflicts with a model's parametric knowledge, little
robustness to noise, and a lack of consistency with their answers. However,
most prior work focus on one or two of those problems in isolation, which makes
it difficult to see trends across them. We aim to close this gap, by first
outlining a set of -- previously discussed as well as novel -- desiderata for
QA models. We then survey relevant analysis and methods papers to provide an
overview of the state of the field. The second part of our work presents
experiments where we evaluate 15 QA systems on 5 datasets according to all
desiderata at once. We find many novel trends, including (1) systems that are
less susceptible to noise are not necessarily more consistent with their
answers when given irrelevant context; (2) most systems that are more
susceptible to noise are more likely to correctly answer according to a context
that conflicts with their parametric knowledge; and (3) the combination of
conflicting knowledge and noise can reduce system performance by up to 96%. As
such, our desiderata help increase our understanding of how these models work
and reveal potential avenues for improvements. | [
-0.6350155472755432,
-0.8185542225837708,
0.9914054870605469,
0.030572764575481415,
-0.272350937128067,
-0.23534761369228363,
0.36530864238739014,
-0.623389482498169,
0.06226426362991333,
0.3432197868824005,
-0.5445067882537842,
-0.13326920568943024,
-0.353400319814682,
0.22647985816001892,
-0.5214071869850159,
0.6440805196762085,
-0.03881793096661568,
0.018867213279008865,
-0.4358973801136017,
-0.4168931841850281,
-0.9870409369468689,
-0.6035469174385071,
-0.5298052430152893,
0.14777734875679016,
0.45221230387687683,
0.23328761756420135,
0.48552656173706055,
-0.0230870321393013,
0.41056618094444275,
0.18826080858707428,
-0.44395682215690613,
-0.012164643965661526,
-0.2167867124080658,
0.3858204185962677,
-0.2332572340965271,
-0.31133586168289185,
-0.1773235946893692,
-0.22634455561637878,
0.6321901679039001,
0.6843806505203247,
-0.08793044090270996,
0.5093346238136292,
-0.020144283771514893,
0.6187715530395508,
-0.8592527508735657,
-0.010987939313054085,
-0.4228799045085907,
-0.24099768698215485,
0.11556725203990936,
-0.24972385168075562,
-0.21140693128108978,
-0.48270153999328613,
0.25600114464759827,
-0.5117049813270569,
-0.2729257643222809,
-0.37226396799087524,
0.5532252192497253,
0.5007603764533997,
-0.7292894124984741,
-0.13573861122131348,
-0.962792694568634,
0.6743203401565552,
-0.7056817412376404,
0.2916796803474426,
0.27563026547431946,
0.5887554883956909,
-0.15199311077594757,
-0.6950970888137817,
-0.36911842226982117,
0.46979016065597534,
-0.08479589968919754,
-0.07219379395246506,
-0.32248950004577637,
-0.26072853803634644,
0.46310365200042725,
0.17128998041152954,
-0.25022417306900024,
-0.2723577916622162,
-0.44888508319854736,
0.01334631722420454,
0.42508548498153687,
0.32013052701950073,
0.2740546464920044,
0.103923000395298,
-0.4307173490524292,
0.18116961419582367,
-0.7665850520133972,
0.4972643554210663,
-0.21598966419696808,
-0.11967623233795166,
0.3270013928413391,
0.03820422664284706,
-0.4269593358039856,
0.9015739560127258,
0.15058963000774384,
0.10785353928804398,
-0.03691078722476959,
-0.3637116253376007,
-0.34979724884033203,
-0.5734961628913879,
0.2261446714401245,
0.3589704930782318,
-0.11759375035762787,
-0.17812709510326385,
-0.3069192171096802,
-0.23439495265483856,
0.31704655289649963,
-0.720737636089325,
0.005775008350610733,
0.38440316915512085,
-0.4745253324508667,
-0.14346587657928467,
-0.17150281369686127,
-0.7388064861297607,
-0.26462414860725403,
-0.4580242931842804,
0.675967812538147,
-0.12796396017074585,
-0.4284681975841522,
0.005255252122879028,
-0.3482970893383026,
0.2777813971042633,
0.5773056745529175,
-0.6829832792282104,
0.3924328684806824,
0.45174649357795715,
0.49591153860092163,
0.133366197347641,
0.0942310318350792,
-0.3736056089401245,
-0.1091962531208992,
-0.4613747298717499,
0.9610399603843689,
-0.6165341734886169,
-0.2458379715681076,
0.059595655649900436,
0.1438935250043869,
-0.2684505879878998,
-0.5582787990570068,
0.38068893551826477,
-1.0891735553741455,
0.3930639922618866,
-0.8833496570587158,
-0.5715580582618713,
-0.5109389424324036,
0.23731687664985657,
-0.6442166566848755,
0.8191141486167908,
0.4350295960903168,
-0.9087369441986084,
0.4180913269519806,
-0.6966989040374756,
-0.1415892094373703,
-0.22445206344127655,
-0.090122289955616,
0.004131397232413292,
0.31261155009269714,
0.10970091819763184,
0.04882753640413284,
-0.438035786151886,
0.21756161749362946,
-0.10238774120807648,
-0.6845079660415649,
0.39832162857055664,
-0.25463324785232544,
0.9830023646354675,
0.45647746324539185,
-0.24406088888645172,
-0.1540748029947281,
-0.512259304523468,
0.18656177818775177,
-0.2324354499578476,
-0.18097235262393951,
-0.7621840238571167,
0.0017236425774171948,
0.008767422288656235,
0.4218504726886749,
0.2454078048467636,
-0.5672382712364197,
-0.018991457298398018,
-0.22480565309524536,
0.7616362571716309,
0.4109886884689331,
0.41611039638519287,
0.2520776093006134,
-0.5373994708061218,
0.6752511262893677,
0.3558262586593628,
0.3437332808971405,
-0.12006457895040512,
-0.46964505314826965,
-0.409895658493042,
0.02211344800889492,
0.3233886659145355,
0.39868438243865967,
-0.6006693840026855,
-0.2491401731967926,
0.05422409996390343,
-0.2848193049430847,
-0.11380335688591003,
-0.16363145411014557,
0.31780317425727844,
0.7395142912864685,
0.44518476724624634,
-0.2055523693561554,
-0.46704378724098206,
-0.9887763857841492,
-0.19708533585071564,
-0.23482617735862732,
-0.016113445162773132,
0.3366512060165405,
0.3982793688774109,
-0.18426579236984253,
1.222313642501831,
-0.44898465275764465,
0.15775124728679657,
0.11810444295406342,
-0.1970331370830536,
0.08191514015197754,
0.320944607257843,
0.7742327451705933,
-1.1332178115844727,
-0.3115274906158447,
-0.5714155435562134,
-0.6013539433479309,
-0.10435228049755096,
0.32361260056495667,
-0.13354215025901794,
0.1155286505818367,
0.4096936285495758,
-0.3871569335460663,
0.4675086438655853,
0.2842179834842682,
-0.4013679623603821,
0.30207037925720215,
0.19318987429141998,
0.46331408619880676,
-1.3004958629608154,
0.45971518754959106,
-0.13673189282417297,
0.019296271726489067,
-0.9401376247406006,
0.07259566336870193,
0.1155761107802391,
-0.09131570160388947,
-0.5764105319976807,
0.5479142069816589,
-0.1524774432182312,
0.00763150118291378,
-0.22479629516601562,
0.09854153543710709,
0.2330460250377655,
0.5516201257705688,
-0.03612777218222618,
0.9315259456634521,
0.3331015706062317,
-0.8811884522438049,
-0.08718828111886978,
0.43518003821372986,
-0.17988407611846924,
0.6004054546356201,
-0.841282308101654,
0.12137670814990997,
-0.18463844060897827,
0.20205141603946686,
-1.0430190563201904,
-0.10158173739910126,
0.31470656394958496,
-0.2666853368282318,
-0.028841061517596245,
0.010443011298775673,
-0.1843855232000351,
-0.3548336327075958,
-0.027189549058675766,
0.8158018589019775,
0.5199202299118042,
-0.25581833720207214,
0.31483280658721924,
0.7367302179336548,
-0.051131561398506165,
-0.6568224430084229,
-0.3905205726623535,
-0.12886130809783936,
-0.46890872716903687,
-0.4600667953491211,
0.1772637516260147,
-0.12240548431873322,
-0.4722282588481903,
-0.11045725643634796,
-0.42092612385749817,
-0.8268425464630127,
0.5037948489189148,
0.16897951066493988,
-0.20681479573249817,
-0.2892839014530182,
0.5196600556373596,
0.1839059591293335,
0.007775259204208851,
0.2088533192873001,
-0.2903253436088562,
0.19279463589191437,
-0.048306819051504135,
-0.2336808294057846,
-0.6875629425048828,
0.6484487056732178,
0.7528277039527893,
-0.23192676901817322,
0.49072399735450745,
0.06730090081691742,
-0.5545997619628906,
0.2130303829908371,
-0.47361844778060913,
-0.4081045687198639,
-0.3927038908004761,
0.14736808836460114,
-0.4303686320781708,
-0.91152024269104,
0.7789177298545837,
-0.01812233217060566,
0.20567025244235992,
0.40460917353630066,
0.10441839694976807,
-0.25263524055480957,
1.0103439092636108,
0.8099296689033508,
0.18635553121566772,
0.5688548684120178,
0.12071806937456131,
0.07953564077615738,
-0.9032217264175415,
0.02143622376024723,
-0.732806921005249,
-0.2641356587409973,
-0.4734959602355957,
-0.05090342089533806,
0.3831882178783417,
0.2624262273311615,
-0.3662136495113373,
0.38670647144317627,
-0.5689617395401001,
0.20546706020832062,
0.636118471622467,
0.07755427807569504,
0.4410373568534851,
-0.25057539343833923,
0.24142776429653168,
0.15309670567512512,
-0.8297447562217712,
-0.6774436831474304,
1.0506123304367065,
0.37168505787849426,
0.6159539222717285,
0.2353145331144333,
0.5784730315208435,
0.17627595365047455,
0.34477779269218445,
-0.37871405482292175,
0.35439664125442505,
0.1607338935136795,
-0.9825782775878906,
-0.6039882302284241,
-0.2089381068944931,
-0.9056846499443054,
0.2745175063610077,
0.15887495875358582,
-0.7875139117240906,
0.7537105083465576,
0.2305842787027359,
-0.6894273161888123,
0.19769158959388733,
-0.5839161276817322,
0.8587506413459778,
0.35019659996032715,
-0.30696719884872437,
0.07351876050233841,
-0.6582403779029846,
0.31967252492904663,
-0.10361668467521667,
0.0757451057434082,
-0.07164251059293747,
0.05252685397863388,
0.8362764716148376,
-0.24375088512897491,
0.9504631161689758,
-0.4733186662197113,
-0.5823715329170227,
0.7562285661697388,
-0.052039291709661484,
0.2766787111759186,
0.2402752935886383,
0.009459909051656723,
-0.05406097322702408,
1.2359706163406372,
-0.4980672597885132,
-0.7258835434913635,
0.354520708322525,
-0.4189310073852539,
-0.8684425354003906,
-0.2800329625606537,
-0.4814067482948303,
-0.46814364194869995,
0.2381298691034317,
0.009806922636926174,
0.7106758952140808,
-0.32999634742736816,
0.30318304896354675,
0.9152687191963196,
-0.03268646448850632,
0.3461560904979706,
0.6704604029655457,
-0.0002545293536968529,
-0.1961430162191391,
0.3646887242794037,
0.2103608101606369,
0.054379407316446304,
0.4525814950466156,
-0.12162569910287857,
-0.512827455997467,
-0.3749332129955292,
-0.5623009204864502,
-0.1486593633890152,
-0.6614097356796265,
-0.3025074005126953,
-0.677613377571106,
0.0032618611585348845,
-0.345497727394104,
0.29520705342292786,
0.08832510560750961,
-0.6422057151794434,
-0.08706343919038773,
0.3554356098175049,
0.04849657043814659,
0.7969421744346619,
0.25656139850616455,
0.029985550791025162,
-0.8668062686920166,
0.19453363120555878,
0.8146287202835083,
0.31214627623558044,
0.009631113149225712,
-0.45185115933418274,
-0.2079569548368454,
0.3219107389450073,
-0.4121597409248352,
-1.393297553062439,
0.0287169236689806,
-0.07245942205190659,
0.6499159336090088,
0.18193519115447998,
0.4424557685852051,
0.44280728697776794,
-0.1918308436870575,
0.7432466745376587,
-0.3189331293106079,
-0.8562719821929932,
0.6454734802246094,
-0.48711293935775757,
0.35511401295661926,
0.7844370007514954,
0.26949676871299744,
-0.7604565620422363,
-0.38846156001091003,
-0.6273304224014282,
-0.5448353290557861,
0.5270840525627136,
0.07278724759817123,
0.1732582151889801,
-0.08825552463531494,
0.688316822052002,
0.012498878873884678,
0.5595197677612305,
-0.3790607452392578,
-0.1342420130968094,
0.010432876646518707,
-0.12264315783977509,
0.18637095391750336,
-0.5402595400810242,
-0.4597609341144562,
-0.019775930792093277,
0.4022841155529022,
-0.17739693820476532,
0.3420943021774292,
0.4192686676979065,
-0.09584460407495499,
-0.19644206762313843,
0.5389440655708313,
0.8683411478996277,
1.2796114683151245,
-0.22285090386867523,
0.046078793704509735,
0.36708754301071167,
-0.2794818878173828,
0.5394743084907532,
-0.20071391761302948,
-0.738510012626648,
-0.042115457355976105,
-0.04532288387417793,
0.32830896973609924,
0.30524930357933044,
-0.7001646757125854,
0.3910331726074219,
-0.2469724714756012,
-0.1594376564025879,
-0.4038819968700409,
0.0518655925989151,
0.036531854420900345,
0.41911134123802185,
0.5259463787078857,
0.09716657549142838,
0.5467278361320496,
-0.5302079319953918,
0.23531155288219452,
0.5519034266471863,
-0.6977651119232178,
-0.3523033559322357,
0.6086477041244507,
0.4243565499782562,
-0.18413400650024414,
0.15646609663963318,
0.16917990148067474,
-0.36364683508872986,
0.9270792007446289,
0.4464816749095917,
0.7563539147377014,
-0.061482034623622894,
0.3879794180393219,
0.26203158497810364,
0.04017254710197449,
0.09964195638895035,
0.5370727777481079,
-0.28634002804756165,
-0.430388480424881,
-0.26480764150619507,
-0.4610326290130615,
-0.5380951762199402,
0.34256938099861145,
-0.9286680221557617,
-0.16433027386665344,
-0.17979450523853302,
-0.4057283103466034,
-0.25346311926841736,
0.14812016487121582,
-0.4634864032268524,
0.3335573077201843,
-0.3200102746486664,
1.0504274368286133,
-0.9365909695625305,
0.4539361596107483,
1.0407137870788574,
-0.5066030025482178,
-0.5730971693992615,
0.27859365940093994,
-0.367416650056839,
-0.17465373873710632,
0.7097123861312866,
0.0706205815076828,
-0.017408080399036407,
0.020098479464650154,
-0.4024465084075928,
-1.2466555833816528,
1.2065093517303467,
0.22436875104904175,
-0.2921835482120514,
-0.013176031410694122,
-0.21469521522521973,
0.6659889817237854,
-0.4345238506793976,
0.12600040435791016,
0.5218152403831482,
0.4901445209980011,
-0.007992259226739407,
-0.843811571598053,
0.33083483576774597,
-0.1769380420446396,
0.09456727653741837,
0.16800250113010406,
-0.8270198106765747,
0.7273429036140442,
-0.1345115453004837,
-0.5786906480789185,
0.27908816933631897,
0.3908883035182953,
0.06936413794755936,
0.6753275990486145,
0.5113638043403625,
0.2598567008972168,
0.7058148980140686,
-0.08507970720529556,
0.5201212167739868,
-0.379108190536499,
0.15049804747104645,
1.0218032598495483,
-0.2191632091999054,
0.8908716440200806,
0.6757124662399292,
-0.2268281728029251,
0.673256516456604,
0.904226541519165,
0.4565483033657074,
0.5196877717971802,
0.047823868691921234,
-0.21525441110134125,
-0.39407309889793396,
0.0345255583524704,
-0.6277549862861633,
0.2606602609157562,
0.041489552706480026,
-0.28946444392204285,
-0.37519630789756775,
0.08334790915250778,
-0.3419501781463623,
-0.012082596309483051,
-0.10328087210655212,
0.9428457021713257,
-0.0982050970196724,
-0.8155330419540405,
0.6775627732276917,
-0.33833011984825134,
0.19328424334526062,
-0.12539073824882507,
-0.1355823129415512,
-0.6052828431129456,
-0.1666874885559082,
0.05617658421397209,
-0.5614089965820312,
0.4358380436897278,
-0.13826361298561096,
-0.5593329071998596,
-0.02840227447450161,
0.6118922829627991,
-0.1667252629995346,
-0.09634917974472046,
-0.003916935529559851,
0.8550265431404114,
0.040634479373693466,
-0.17615218460559845,
-0.4676136076450348,
-0.25557848811149597,
-0.11105698347091675,
-0.10476236045360565,
0.3587263822555542,
0.6029689311981201,
-0.2473595291376114,
0.7387577295303345,
0.2741544842720032,
-0.36570581793785095,
-0.2641104459762573,
-0.198988139629364,
1.0544663667678833,
-0.707091212272644,
-0.4832559823989868,
-0.2789529263973236,
0.3704371452331543,
-0.038683630526065826,
-0.43374696373939514,
0.5324134230613708,
0.21952101588249207,
0.537558913230896,
0.022135861217975616,
0.6364454627037048,
-0.09169268608093262,
0.7276564240455627,
-0.35325080156326294,
0.5959365367889404,
-0.7328740954399109,
0.35350704193115234,
-0.15997320413589478,
-0.8266004323959351,
0.027818910777568817,
0.18176813423633575,
-0.30929532647132874,
0.1383257657289505,
0.6623841524124146,
0.5962549448013306,
0.04911177605390549,
0.079875148832798,
0.42235228419303894,
-0.04407057166099548,
0.15615426003932953,
0.6169082522392273,
1.0708067417144775,
-0.794301450252533,
0.5361413359642029,
-0.08849301934242249,
-0.23177441954612732,
-0.4046894609928131,
-0.5244077444076538,
-0.5776309370994568,
-0.9213510751724243,
-0.352099746465683,
-0.15897133946418762,
0.28956425189971924,
0.19659186899662018,
0.7014607787132263,
-1.0280840396881104,
0.14590011537075043,
-0.06142442300915718,
0.38941362500190735,
-0.5435188412666321,
-0.21002469956874847,
0.2823336720466614,
-0.5169634222984314,
-0.7024080157279968,
0.14826056361198425,
0.01823999732732773,
0.16402144730091095,
-0.13893556594848633,
0.30101436376571655,
-0.18027736246585846,
0.4097750186920166,
0.5188687443733215,
0.6084609031677246,
-0.5555841326713562,
-0.4077671766281128,
0.28512105345726013,
-0.17335419356822968,
-0.033348556607961655,
0.7763323783874512,
-0.9361063241958618,
0.12466724216938019,
0.7886959314346313,
0.5058133006095886,
0.1137406975030899,
0.45103874802589417,
0.6377203464508057,
-0.20563481748104095,
-0.18738575279712677,
0.2844559848308563,
0.17242290079593658,
-0.022642483934760094,
-0.28266480565071106,
0.39164644479751587,
0.030156729742884636,
-0.7647737860679626,
-0.945030927658081,
0.4327411353588104,
-0.5484504699707031,
-0.5598835945129395,
0.9866176247596741,
-0.12786363065242767,
-0.14489293098449707,
-0.5296288728713989,
-0.18812091648578644,
-0.07014846801757812,
-0.20716014504432678,
0.997590184211731,
0.5980545282363892,
-0.2590242922306061,
-0.08015695214271545,
-0.5791521668434143,
0.8805641531944275,
0.5815523862838745,
-0.7326952219009399,
0.08204738795757294,
0.7158171534538269,
0.6040415167808533,
0.28856438398361206,
0.852899432182312,
-0.21378155052661896,
0.6044946908950806,
-0.16945703327655792,
-0.4039665162563324,
0.23821163177490234,
-0.4113183319568634,
-0.386724591255188,
0.500253438949585,
0.19913671910762787,
-0.3366519808769226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17979v1 | Entity Linking in the Job Market Domain | 2024-01-31T16:34:10 | 2024-01-31T16:34:10 | Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Natural Language Processing, entity linking (EL) has centered around
Wikipedia, but yet remains underexplored for the job market domain.
Disambiguating skill mentions can help us get insight into the current labor
market demands. In this work, we are the first to explore EL in this domain,
specifically targeting the linkage of occupational skills to the ESCO taxonomy
(le Vrang et al., 2014). Previous efforts linked coarse-grained (full)
sentences to a corresponding ESCO skill. In this work, we link more
fine-grained span-level mentions of skills. We tune two high-performing neural
EL models, a bi-encoder (Wu et al., 2020) and an autoregressive model (Cao et
al., 2021), on a synthetically generated mention--skill pair dataset and
evaluate them on a human-annotated skill-linking benchmark. Our findings reveal
that both models are capable of linking implicit mentions of skills to their
correct taxonomy counterparts. Empirically, BLINK outperforms GENRE in strict
evaluation, but GENRE performs better in loose evaluation (accuracy@$k$). | [
-0.2701670527458191,
-0.5123231410980225,
0.48126673698425293,
0.174069344997406,
-0.009204280562698841,
-0.14727219939231873,
-0.36907288432121277,
-1.2461105585098267,
0.3745363652706146,
0.3182123601436615,
-0.39027559757232666,
-0.5212514400482178,
-0.43536821007728577,
0.3562217056751251,
-0.6249565482139587,
1.285966396331787,
0.39384976029396057,
-0.504262387752533,
-0.6577671766281128,
0.008987457491457462,
-0.12481838464736938,
-0.18456873297691345,
-1.0631674528121948,
-0.13235348463058472,
0.9413638710975647,
0.064212366938591,
0.7105270028114319,
0.8022026419639587,
0.36009395122528076,
0.30110958218574524,
0.13022175431251526,
0.17252784967422485,
-0.2792400121688843,
0.3259607255458832,
-0.32863351702690125,
-0.3679654598236084,
-0.7233156561851501,
-0.03400903567671776,
0.34479469060897827,
1.0280498266220093,
-0.03110150620341301,
0.4478161334991455,
0.024334611371159554,
0.603855550289154,
-0.5657947659492493,
0.4074609577655792,
-1.1784074306488037,
-0.5435715317726135,
-0.5354076623916626,
-0.013526314869523048,
-0.4106881618499756,
-0.10990258306264877,
0.18201826512813568,
-0.7903660535812378,
0.5415713787078857,
0.29533272981643677,
1.161797285079956,
0.4406549632549286,
-0.523016631603241,
-0.3639284670352936,
-0.5659136176109314,
0.3182847499847412,
-0.27235278487205505,
0.48369845747947693,
0.610876739025116,
0.051556024700403214,
0.40990057587623596,
-0.5108689665794373,
-0.4740596413612366,
-0.22280870378017426,
-0.060784563422203064,
-0.019339535385370255,
-0.10840966552495956,
0.25174614787101746,
0.21402452886104584,
0.36555156111717224,
-0.24524813890457153,
0.2530698776245117,
-0.7526405453681946,
0.06127225607633591,
0.7396538853645325,
0.1594628542661667,
0.21462757885456085,
-0.09418003261089325,
-0.33068370819091797,
0.14153967797756195,
-0.8375201225280762,
-0.12660343945026398,
0.7767693400382996,
0.17879733443260193,
0.1493808925151825,
0.7686656713485718,
-0.3200473189353943,
0.7577710151672363,
0.10293225198984146,
0.09385234117507935,
0.1556658297777176,
-0.33386367559432983,
0.04762623831629753,
0.08309361338615417,
0.6476624011993408,
0.4359109699726105,
0.342105895280838,
-0.5955891609191895,
-0.21092994511127472,
-0.00872821919620037,
0.7015313506126404,
-0.1434345692396164,
-0.1841038465499878,
-0.11918073892593384,
-0.11897077411413193,
-0.1235276609659195,
-0.02469571679830551,
-0.42243799567222595,
-0.25904813408851624,
-0.16736255586147308,
0.5271509885787964,
-0.2284695953130722,
0.04790554940700531,
-0.09327666461467743,
-0.01886717975139618,
-0.07857389748096466,
-0.07187875360250473,
-1.0903187990188599,
0.3976341784000397,
0.8486558794975281,
0.7597182393074036,
0.06645714491605759,
-0.3518006205558777,
-0.20563668012619019,
0.44106578826904297,
-0.08153361827135086,
0.9822672009468079,
-0.5550862550735474,
0.007896901108324528,
0.2818272113800049,
0.13463972508907318,
-0.2369140386581421,
-0.5610083341598511,
0.3754764497280121,
-0.8065301179885864,
-0.26982781291007996,
-0.1866835504770279,
-0.3506612181663513,
-0.08008112758398056,
0.043403882533311844,
-0.9189521074295044,
1.420018196105957,
0.18597641587257385,
-0.71571946144104,
0.7843328714370728,
-0.6289460062980652,
-0.526018500328064,
-0.0688871219754219,
-0.008921905420720577,
-0.23291318118572235,
-0.08379165828227997,
-0.3014177978038788,
0.4617164433002472,
-0.3626672923564911,
0.1692093014717102,
-0.3602656126022339,
-0.4792546331882477,
0.21432213485240936,
-0.216546431183815,
0.4308503568172455,
-0.04489327594637871,
-0.29416540265083313,
-0.24840684235095978,
-0.5735636353492737,
-0.5480706095695496,
-0.11967993527650833,
-0.2916621267795563,
-0.6806720495223999,
-0.09880079329013824,
-0.14416654407978058,
0.3714304268360138,
0.23040439188480377,
-0.3812132775783539,
0.05268042907118797,
-0.6102944612503052,
0.058856334537267685,
0.5286043882369995,
-0.021136367693543434,
0.4665404260158539,
-0.16166459023952484,
0.19352401793003082,
-0.05781039595603943,
-0.046893130987882614,
0.06694061309099197,
-0.5242927074432373,
-0.945033848285675,
0.047768160700798035,
0.3333970010280609,
0.28456562757492065,
-0.7575539946556091,
0.43230992555618286,
-0.33101630210876465,
-0.609304666519165,
-1.0490177869796753,
0.027681635692715645,
0.46102088689804077,
0.6870461702346802,
0.6935722231864929,
-0.22372528910636902,
-0.4813794791698456,
-1.1950958967208862,
-0.6054566502571106,
-0.13873867690563202,
-0.2758195698261261,
0.30679216980934143,
0.5044164061546326,
0.0008507630554959178,
0.6934850215911865,
-0.4868660271167755,
-0.5215533971786499,
0.13428986072540283,
0.21422608196735382,
0.09835861623287201,
0.13391819596290588,
0.5126897096633911,
-0.6016584634780884,
-0.7473481297492981,
-0.08541011810302734,
-0.4798814654350281,
-0.14011144638061523,
-0.0918477401137352,
-0.16851958632469177,
0.19705389440059662,
0.4631860852241516,
-0.668269693851471,
0.3616597652435303,
0.27754896879196167,
-0.5041082501411438,
0.49984073638916016,
-0.1260334551334381,
0.07974058389663696,
-0.8694301247596741,
0.28971096873283386,
0.5383355617523193,
0.009273911826312542,
-0.4253983199596405,
-0.3826780617237091,
-0.31014975905418396,
0.053290896117687225,
-0.2609842121601105,
0.655235767364502,
-0.657810389995575,
-0.5320630073547363,
-0.129608616232872,
0.2528251111507416,
-0.019442472606897354,
0.45558783411979675,
0.12800903618335724,
0.864957869052887,
0.6628298759460449,
-0.6911093592643738,
0.29578569531440735,
0.2816926836967468,
-0.27251407504081726,
0.6307210326194763,
-0.7541148662567139,
0.12983563542366028,
-0.1731845587491989,
0.03842533007264137,
-0.609900951385498,
-0.12111683934926987,
-0.09000299125909805,
-0.1873037964105606,
0.20259422063827515,
-0.11476288735866547,
-0.664574384689331,
-0.3729698061943054,
-0.2913447320461273,
0.27940985560417175,
0.3030947148799896,
-0.1417360007762909,
0.22218194603919983,
0.45461758971214294,
-0.26747459173202515,
-0.6120104789733887,
-0.6484479308128357,
-0.020720908418297768,
-0.08757832646369934,
-0.49401822686195374,
0.8570443987846375,
0.23391959071159363,
-0.03962089121341705,
0.2832767367362976,
-0.2716856002807617,
-0.33287250995635986,
0.19367659091949463,
0.28658512234687805,
0.5851605534553528,
-0.2423168271780014,
0.3298221528530121,
0.08706042915582657,
-0.2473994940519333,
0.25710850954055786,
-0.11713892966508865,
0.04674726352095604,
0.07685169577598572,
-0.3608655035495758,
-0.05798689275979996,
0.06462635099887848,
0.3758847117424011,
-0.16019326448440552,
1.2485781908035278,
0.7500633001327515,
-0.4175966680049896,
-0.14657296240329742,
-0.7345897555351257,
-0.12238118052482605,
-0.4520910084247589,
0.40510594844818115,
-0.18567946553230286,
-0.7627854347229004,
0.2825070023536682,
-0.0683872401714325,
-0.14708757400512695,
0.7932141423225403,
0.19118040800094604,
-0.3212012052536011,
0.4264603853225708,
0.8215797543525696,
-0.011111622676253319,
0.22955003380775452,
-0.13189414143562317,
0.3343963921070099,
-1.2313233613967896,
-0.5220078229904175,
-0.5806300640106201,
-0.4105381667613983,
-0.3188173770904541,
-0.4281201958656311,
0.3263363242149353,
0.027841618284583092,
-0.19354219734668732,
0.8429206013679504,
-0.43325328826904297,
0.3593652844429016,
0.5912835597991943,
0.0909692570567131,
0.3675119876861572,
-0.19523872435092926,
0.016072990372776985,
0.10753630846738815,
-0.5395721197128296,
-0.5614514946937561,
1.0701483488082886,
0.3409721851348877,
0.44863060116767883,
-0.09970341622829437,
0.486847460269928,
0.2780430018901825,
0.2565506398677826,
-0.6061640381813049,
0.5204108357429504,
-0.2874792814254761,
-0.6807231307029724,
-0.5503875017166138,
0.018441936001181602,
-0.7494918704032898,
-0.047672197222709656,
-0.6275985240936279,
-0.6858347058296204,
0.09921932965517044,
0.20331060886383057,
-0.30769795179367065,
0.3139810860157013,
-0.5049048066139221,
0.9483523368835449,
0.04405573010444641,
-0.5902668237686157,
-0.2189321219921112,
-0.5276331901550293,
-0.0024548072833567858,
-0.16427330672740936,
0.16201739013195038,
-0.3859972655773163,
-0.32710132002830505,
0.6173595786094666,
-0.18039654195308685,
0.9449021220207214,
0.16664184629917145,
-0.15745678544044495,
0.26732614636421204,
-0.05300531163811684,
0.4102086126804352,
-0.010607643984258175,
-0.4811870753765106,
0.41562172770500183,
-0.2857024669647217,
-0.19741396605968475,
-0.3211458921432495,
0.7804347276687622,
-0.41506248712539673,
-0.3224116265773773,
-0.18583714962005615,
-0.3097107410430908,
-0.540597140789032,
0.08282019942998886,
0.29420626163482666,
0.2999116778373718,
-0.20798587799072266,
0.2667289674282074,
0.7140945196151733,
0.1749206781387329,
0.16514496505260468,
0.4592835009098053,
0.4503144323825836,
0.09323954582214355,
0.6644352078437805,
0.20391257107257843,
0.10608533024787903,
0.3326667249202728,
-0.698477566242218,
-0.47876644134521484,
-0.11991479247808456,
-0.05552823469042778,
0.41551485657691956,
-0.5635381937026978,
-0.39438876509666443,
-0.7211626172065735,
-0.24546301364898682,
-0.28545039892196655,
-0.4357661306858063,
-0.3221578299999237,
0.01903657056391239,
-0.004372388124465942,
-0.27062731981277466,
0.4843793213367462,
0.5865823030471802,
0.18799078464508057,
-0.1580228954553604,
-0.5591036081314087,
0.27268290519714355,
0.3849208950996399,
0.7878897190093994,
0.22088859975337982,
-0.019550424069166183,
-0.7885839939117432,
0.04695964604616165,
0.015059806406497955,
-0.9287778735160828,
-0.01014762558043003,
0.4528235197067261,
0.5701281428337097,
0.25494033098220825,
0.01887504942715168,
0.5849701762199402,
-0.6555740237236023,
0.7356535792350769,
0.19388771057128906,
-0.7599142789840698,
0.4602280855178833,
-0.33770355582237244,
-0.15765520930290222,
0.7234039306640625,
0.8463150858879089,
-0.6897422075271606,
-0.5469498634338379,
-0.618043839931488,
-1.2014832496643066,
0.6056700348854065,
0.2923048734664917,
0.17902261018753052,
-0.6426010727882385,
0.19470010697841644,
0.16177254915237427,
0.45004695653915405,
-0.6463072896003723,
-0.40269413590431213,
0.3079756796360016,
-0.3551816940307617,
0.25355294346809387,
-0.3603476881980896,
0.05456096678972244,
-0.22118903696537018,
0.6582686901092529,
0.03445329889655113,
0.3659207224845886,
0.09677568823099136,
-0.36229121685028076,
-0.14821164309978485,
0.20716425776481628,
0.13441221415996552,
0.4973159432411194,
0.01636003889143467,
0.20949490368366241,
0.31650105118751526,
-0.3358130156993866,
-0.2551082968711853,
-0.040476806461811066,
-0.026889797300100327,
0.2174767255783081,
0.3184957802295685,
0.8335632085800171,
0.859991729259491,
-0.539824903011322,
0.5798353552818298,
0.7560855746269226,
-0.2003387212753296,
-0.3226031959056854,
0.2969624996185303,
0.3150988519191742,
0.2873687446117401,
0.5324520468711853,
0.07505274564027786,
0.3169139623641968,
-0.6675791144371033,
0.20364497601985931,
0.2162484973669052,
-0.5594285130500793,
-0.547814130783081,
1.0749778747558594,
0.5642350912094116,
-0.0720079317688942,
0.686982274055481,
-0.17064432799816132,
-0.23398908972740173,
0.6228373646736145,
0.5808916687965393,
0.9269928932189941,
0.14948388934135437,
0.09351211041212082,
0.5851479768753052,
0.1877315640449524,
-0.1323249638080597,
-0.17697183787822723,
-0.143775075674057,
-0.5136361122131348,
-0.3467217981815338,
-0.6337000131607056,
-0.19006212055683136,
-0.21850480139255524,
-0.7409083247184753,
0.32533252239227295,
0.0460505485534668,
-0.2292262762784958,
0.20789743959903717,
-0.26309874653816223,
-1.1521507501602173,
0.4068642854690552,
0.3467700183391571,
0.7739632725715637,
-0.9954107999801636,
0.8447765707969666,
0.8293543457984924,
-0.9964337944984436,
-0.5660638213157654,
0.0769406408071518,
-0.21840862929821014,
-0.5012862682342529,
0.9345340132713318,
0.11170181632041931,
-0.2301582396030426,
0.32854163646698,
-0.10241389274597168,
-0.698951005935669,
1.4570302963256836,
0.2260531336069107,
-0.4110855162143707,
-0.6565758585929871,
0.03823722153902054,
0.5921692848205566,
-0.4171378016471863,
0.42034244537353516,
0.35380831360816956,
0.27649402618408203,
-0.22467099130153656,
-1.4017257690429688,
-0.018513571470975876,
-0.17962034046649933,
0.12178592383861542,
0.28421470522880554,
-0.5934737324714661,
0.5595069527626038,
-0.15007756650447845,
-0.32613712549209595,
-0.2569258213043213,
0.716041624546051,
-0.04178985580801964,
0.5159946084022522,
0.6073480248451233,
0.46231260895729065,
0.7364229559898376,
-0.08692429214715958,
0.6136654019355774,
-0.6352870464324951,
0.452058881521225,
1.091562032699585,
-0.3670505881309509,
1.1176375150680542,
0.31445449590682983,
-0.3397047221660614,
1.0986560583114624,
0.42056968808174133,
-0.2895434498786926,
0.2816832661628723,
-0.012238644994795322,
-0.330620139837265,
-0.16231532394886017,
-0.3197023272514343,
-0.20053346455097198,
0.30416104197502136,
0.18910306692123413,
-0.4981151223182678,
-0.19300168752670288,
-0.18628190457820892,
-0.11258194595575333,
0.2265077531337738,
-0.5126885175704956,
0.8412677049636841,
0.14831435680389404,
-0.5584399104118347,
0.11587508022785187,
-0.14664188027381897,
0.910014808177948,
-0.5158955454826355,
-0.3138459026813507,
0.08358866721391678,
-0.549679696559906,
-0.439369261264801,
-1.0226320028305054,
0.6963518261909485,
0.17692269384860992,
-0.3795861303806305,
-0.18337853252887726,
0.8741754293441772,
-0.8176782727241516,
0.021697184070944786,
0.2545147240161896,
0.214302197098732,
0.14328306913375854,
-0.13343565165996552,
-0.5660294890403748,
-0.26152029633522034,
-0.47888973355293274,
-0.02142716944217682,
0.3030785322189331,
0.5408657193183899,
0.13132284581661224,
0.6439521312713623,
0.5327654480934143,
0.11737202107906342,
0.09185541421175003,
-0.028524238616228104,
0.6537490487098694,
-0.805160403251648,
-0.45369160175323486,
-0.43541622161865234,
0.8057062029838562,
-0.38093361258506775,
-0.5148325562477112,
0.5468716025352478,
0.7467058300971985,
1.2628532648086548,
-0.374622106552124,
0.4477972686290741,
-0.15679608285427094,
0.33083346486091614,
-0.46334347128868103,
0.7501329183578491,
-0.5856900811195374,
0.2216315120458603,
-0.24308711290359497,
-1.178942084312439,
0.27345871925354004,
0.32630401849746704,
-0.382649302482605,
0.10675639659166336,
0.9520222544670105,
0.7751332521438599,
-0.17056173086166382,
-0.5439568758010864,
0.2866734564304352,
0.062231168150901794,
-0.6069540977478027,
0.4945724606513977,
0.25870004296302795,
-0.4812448024749756,
0.579820454120636,
-0.3496653735637665,
0.33761754631996155,
-0.48490041494369507,
-0.7634093761444092,
-0.6901652812957764,
-0.9531406164169312,
-0.7756748199462891,
-0.2325802892446518,
0.08580312877893448,
0.8164545893669128,
0.5148722529411316,
-0.3513559103012085,
-0.09479207545518875,
0.2712581157684326,
0.020937226712703705,
-0.47161632776260376,
-0.24737444519996643,
0.19686205685138702,
-0.33970531821250916,
-0.7646239995956421,
0.4104684293270111,
0.585964560508728,
-0.37644365429878235,
-0.21792441606521606,
0.21904270350933075,
-0.330145001411438,
0.07256224751472473,
0.5576900839805603,
0.19658222794532776,
-0.7039528489112854,
-0.336929053068161,
-0.04775594174861908,
-0.4097897410392761,
-0.3440094590187073,
0.4912026822566986,
-0.647765576839447,
0.3475443720817566,
0.19003117084503174,
0.6755983829498291,
0.3594694435596466,
0.0041684540919959545,
0.3945921063423157,
-0.8963505029678345,
-0.0017459267983213067,
0.1802586317062378,
0.235590398311615,
0.1899941861629486,
-0.6719256639480591,
0.8019218444824219,
0.2330307960510254,
-0.3546731173992157,
-0.6212211847305298,
0.11586588621139526,
-0.8161184191703796,
0.025982823222875595,
1.0572409629821777,
0.14655427634716034,
-0.3368174135684967,
-0.3280660808086395,
0.19343629479408264,
0.48341014981269836,
-0.20628580451011658,
0.9827494025230408,
0.5041709542274475,
-0.016044292598962784,
0.09314636886119843,
-0.6907710433006287,
0.5928339958190918,
-0.08472324907779694,
-0.5751648545265198,
-0.1720820516347885,
0.38105785846710205,
0.35823723673820496,
0.0998028889298439,
0.8420145511627197,
0.1077679842710495,
0.5021113157272339,
0.3955114483833313,
0.2839551568031311,
-0.2634983956813812,
-0.5425660014152527,
0.1238061785697937,
0.01553760189563036,
0.4374731481075287,
-0.048340726643800735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17974v1 | GUMsley: Evaluating Entity Salience in Summarization for 12 English Genres | 2024-01-31T16:30:50 | 2024-01-31T16:30:50 | Jessica Lin, Amir Zeldes | cs.CL | cs.CL | As NLP models become increasingly capable of understanding documents in terms
of coherent entities rather than strings, obtaining the most salient entities
for each document is not only an important end task in itself but also vital
for Information Retrieval (IR) and other downstream applications such as
controllable summarization. In this paper, we present and evaluate GUMsley, the
first entity salience dataset covering all named and non-named salient entities
for 12 genres of English text, aligned with entity types, Wikification links
and full coreference resolution annotations. We promote a strict definition of
salience using human summaries and demonstrate high inter-annotator agreement
for salience based on whether a source entity is mentioned in the summary. Our
evaluation shows poor performance by pre-trained SOTA summarization models and
zero-shot LLM prompting in capturing salient entities in generated summaries.
We also show that predicting or providing salient entities to several model
architectures enhances performance and helps derive higher-quality summaries by
alleviating the entity hallucination problem in existing abstractive
summarization. | [
-0.37075382471084595,
-0.28528472781181335,
0.4515223801136017,
0.3209854066371918,
-0.3081444203853607,
-0.14958705008029938,
-0.33176037669181824,
-0.8803781270980835,
0.7030783891677856,
0.15929122269153595,
-0.3661348819732666,
-0.6566506624221802,
-0.675827145576477,
0.5351884961128235,
-0.655292272567749,
1.2476400136947632,
0.2366713136434555,
-0.02451893873512745,
-0.24936094880104065,
-0.16268952190876007,
-0.2977910339832306,
-0.23459501564502716,
-0.24193410575389862,
0.0175964143127203,
0.8227528929710388,
0.37364912033081055,
0.428751140832901,
0.4587414562702179,
0.8384113311767578,
0.25172168016433716,
-0.1896767020225525,
-0.12986691296100616,
-0.5258380770683289,
0.4233205318450928,
-0.5495637655258179,
-0.24822409451007843,
-0.6486513614654541,
-0.16802915930747986,
0.39359572529792786,
0.9080953598022461,
0.14437802135944366,
0.4382208287715912,
-0.05036186799407005,
0.5405020713806152,
-0.6589570045471191,
0.25918298959732056,
-0.5959264636039734,
-0.02600788325071335,
-0.5629892945289612,
-0.3087535798549652,
-0.28537461161613464,
-0.34299689531326294,
0.39812469482421875,
-0.5958949327468872,
0.31875357031822205,
0.4034709930419922,
1.2617825269699097,
0.3903980255126953,
-0.234137162566185,
-0.4348524212837219,
-0.452817440032959,
0.6048930883407593,
-0.4482594430446625,
0.2850058674812317,
0.09202057868242264,
0.09847139567136765,
0.2539741098880768,
-0.6300961375236511,
-0.1610744446516037,
-0.23946601152420044,
-0.1736326962709427,
0.3711196780204773,
-0.362472802400589,
0.048030782490968704,
0.10050159692764282,
0.5878506898880005,
-0.5842553973197937,
0.15863220393657684,
-0.44548818469047546,
0.06126372888684273,
0.5239694118499756,
-0.053374193608760834,
0.11874258518218994,
-0.4292527139186859,
-0.4538981020450592,
0.30262622237205505,
-0.44646313786506653,
0.05946796014904976,
0.33803102374076843,
0.028189819306135178,
0.3534933924674988,
0.6622360944747925,
-0.11290189623832703,
0.4137308895587921,
0.1295957714319229,
-0.2719002664089203,
-0.09604226797819138,
-0.29355916380882263,
-0.1900494545698166,
0.47237884998321533,
0.4226495325565338,
0.3694491982460022,
0.20507535338401794,
-0.43428927659988403,
-0.27225109934806824,
0.11704152077436447,
0.13297270238399506,
-0.7593618631362915,
-0.30075979232788086,
0.3515685498714447,
-0.4445604383945465,
-0.13877111673355103,
0.14715278148651123,
-0.6583911776542664,
-0.2314021736383438,
-0.14572638273239136,
-0.19146457314491272,
-0.9402023553848267,
-0.286411315202713,
0.03248676657676697,
-0.3421061933040619,
0.0028362891171127558,
0.26291799545288086,
-1.0758453607559204,
0.376452773809433,
0.6373763680458069,
0.7672072649002075,
-0.4005174934864044,
-0.4218527376651764,
-0.13947366178035736,
0.3709697425365448,
-0.17512795329093933,
1.4220027923583984,
-0.44152066111564636,
-0.45346689224243164,
-0.6027016639709473,
-0.21603308618068695,
0.21829615533351898,
-0.5972680449485779,
0.5469292402267456,
-0.2740999758243561,
-0.01230978686362505,
-0.26940980553627014,
-0.5395107269287109,
-0.3472915291786194,
-0.1321219801902771,
-0.773648202419281,
0.8485886454582214,
0.3101246953010559,
-0.8414571285247803,
0.6104943156242371,
-0.6545806527137756,
-0.618779718875885,
0.293022483587265,
-0.015224558301270008,
-0.28966909646987915,
0.4193270206451416,
-0.10649163275957108,
0.5714850425720215,
-0.1711816042661667,
0.43547946214675903,
-0.03802787885069847,
-0.3861883282661438,
0.22434327006340027,
-0.05849834531545639,
0.42995885014533997,
-0.06945181638002396,
-0.28094497323036194,
0.2588106691837311,
-0.7076941132545471,
-0.2702791094779968,
-0.015614045783877373,
-0.031513940542936325,
-0.8323323130607605,
-0.35250723361968994,
0.11944182217121124,
-0.11413706094026566,
0.07903234660625458,
-0.03522106260061264,
0.0007653600187040865,
-0.32825958728790283,
-0.16947320103645325,
0.5973334312438965,
0.3018510341644287,
0.3118778169155121,
-0.2429233342409134,
0.6157183647155762,
0.10458620637655258,
-0.2901633679866791,
-0.3418286144733429,
-0.40617555379867554,
-0.48141616582870483,
-0.58890700340271,
0.6630607843399048,
0.25875768065452576,
-0.355676531791687,
0.4913106858730316,
-0.5085647702217102,
-0.54728764295578,
-0.5140073895454407,
-0.20849841833114624,
0.5912578105926514,
0.6379750967025757,
0.4680476188659668,
-0.5472143292427063,
-0.6047440767288208,
-0.9665948152542114,
-0.42538225650787354,
-0.19052812457084656,
-0.16661189496517181,
0.13012143969535828,
0.5040624737739563,
0.14853110909461975,
0.7991169691085815,
-0.315781831741333,
-0.28020045161247253,
-0.23210573196411133,
0.298218697309494,
-0.03423801809549332,
0.17230314016342163,
0.7837830781936646,
-0.5874091386795044,
-0.16591213643550873,
-0.36800581216812134,
-0.786145806312561,
-0.3716681897640228,
0.012082015164196491,
-0.184193953871727,
0.18697217106819153,
-0.1338619589805603,
-0.7689568996429443,
0.2554508149623871,
0.25751787424087524,
-0.449336975812912,
0.7199755907058716,
0.37420085072517395,
0.2660925090312958,
-0.7785773277282715,
0.49936291575431824,
0.1377331167459488,
-0.23228895664215088,
-0.3173261880874634,
-0.004781072493642569,
0.08377543836832047,
0.005560443736612797,
-0.255807489156723,
0.36220988631248474,
-0.9097943305969238,
-0.47744497656822205,
0.045964743942022324,
0.4795691668987274,
0.25876620411872864,
0.24742746353149414,
0.2219611555337906,
0.7675133347511292,
0.38787731528282166,
-0.9020839333534241,
0.3606756329536438,
0.09345239400863647,
-0.2105425000190735,
0.9126954078674316,
-0.5087379217147827,
-0.3602093756198883,
-0.564016580581665,
-0.004463075194507837,
-0.6414037942886353,
-0.45544132590293884,
-0.02257971651852131,
-0.43274885416030884,
0.30630260705947876,
0.01012909971177578,
-0.16100282967090607,
0.1342223584651947,
-0.4617854654788971,
0.0575895830988884,
0.10912905633449554,
-0.08775364607572556,
0.5469036102294922,
0.4834688901901245,
-0.39571723341941833,
-0.7162895202636719,
-0.6003454327583313,
0.14957338571548462,
-0.3852801024913788,
-0.4167191684246063,
0.5051826238632202,
0.17219769954681396,
-0.46767565608024597,
0.38815635442733765,
-0.4203234612941742,
0.1464592069387436,
0.5188848972320557,
0.34057557582855225,
0.33530089259147644,
-0.2817332148551941,
0.20417220890522003,
0.07371178269386292,
-0.3825269639492035,
-0.02219868078827858,
-0.37618669867515564,
0.24444927275180817,
-0.21607044339179993,
-0.08529184013605118,
0.038956914097070694,
0.38918444514274597,
0.1953359693288803,
-0.48746612668037415,
0.513042688369751,
0.33227887749671936,
-0.4052475690841675,
0.11839801073074341,
-0.37317943572998047,
-0.17838530242443085,
-0.23896409571170807,
0.5141914486885071,
-0.4453873634338379,
-0.44158193469047546,
0.38280734419822693,
0.043384402990341187,
0.2048947960138321,
0.6330312490463257,
0.24690820276737213,
-0.13988171517848969,
0.3523079752922058,
0.47921615839004517,
0.08146847784519196,
0.43744558095932007,
-0.26083412766456604,
0.1357252448797226,
-0.5919039249420166,
-0.3359699845314026,
-0.5303641557693481,
-0.3452150225639343,
-0.3514571189880371,
0.07517920434474945,
0.48229631781578064,
0.2453322410583496,
0.4774143695831299,
0.5053955316543579,
-0.44245558977127075,
0.5914730429649353,
0.3896524906158447,
-0.20345838367938995,
0.6862367987632751,
-0.0652390867471695,
0.17633546888828278,
-0.2347395122051239,
-0.3957116901874542,
-0.7358604669570923,
0.6676739454269409,
0.1996399164199829,
0.6912631392478943,
0.6694181561470032,
0.7566447257995605,
0.10274405777454376,
0.38626712560653687,
-1.0691362619400024,
0.6843531727790833,
0.00020672813116107136,
-0.3555196523666382,
-0.41077521443367004,
-0.2507689595222473,
-1.004008412361145,
0.09071890264749527,
-0.24864979088306427,
-0.5529751181602478,
0.22474566102027893,
0.16304278373718262,
-0.5656739473342896,
-0.06675420701503754,
-0.641524612903595,
0.6728931069374084,
-0.21843791007995605,
-0.3147525489330292,
-0.16420190036296844,
-0.5618475079536438,
0.6865109205245972,
0.25189897418022156,
-0.13400796055793762,
-0.5232470035552979,
-0.27166619896888733,
0.5696782469749451,
0.02362997829914093,
0.20921602845191956,
0.00728247594088316,
-0.02538098767399788,
-0.028269032016396523,
0.2729286253452301,
0.020442383363842964,
0.2701231837272644,
-0.08871330320835114,
0.32631850242614746,
-0.04274698346853256,
-0.4298226237297058,
-0.5388811230659485,
0.6200155019760132,
-0.3338223695755005,
-0.6301788091659546,
-0.6440469622612,
-0.3956470787525177,
0.02611393854022026,
0.4192408621311188,
0.4830337464809418,
0.45428577065467834,
-0.2663957476615906,
0.16964948177337646,
0.9449357986450195,
0.3398267328739166,
0.5800026059150696,
0.48347213864326477,
-0.21590286493301392,
0.010097826831042767,
0.7426287531852722,
0.41119298338890076,
-0.004611121024936438,
0.5193989276885986,
-0.2842787802219391,
-0.28266310691833496,
-0.600787878036499,
-0.36305609345436096,
0.1577385812997818,
-0.7105939388275146,
-0.49591702222824097,
-0.902569591999054,
-0.009855365380644798,
-0.5703573822975159,
-0.1854064166545868,
-0.253828763961792,
-0.7932867407798767,
-0.33729228377342224,
-0.38237884640693665,
0.4141900837421417,
0.5124949812889099,
0.2655569016933441,
-0.23354128003120422,
-0.637230634689331,
0.19321492314338684,
-0.06210358440876007,
0.39400625228881836,
-0.16967378556728363,
-0.4193061292171478,
-0.3143024444580078,
-0.7568756341934204,
-0.21257922053337097,
-1.3220189809799194,
0.4395388662815094,
0.24016854166984558,
0.48918455839157104,
0.5199119448661804,
0.09627640247344971,
0.6298509240150452,
-0.19889035820960999,
0.7997192144393921,
0.06886792927980423,
-0.9225549697875977,
0.6236989498138428,
-0.07483004778623581,
0.1522945612668991,
0.5684405565261841,
0.7740755677223206,
-0.4772142767906189,
-0.48570942878723145,
-0.7760013341903687,
-1.2367552518844604,
0.3770958185195923,
0.15345796942710876,
-0.3583199083805084,
-0.07885397970676422,
0.08902665227651596,
0.27441585063934326,
0.3486875593662262,
-0.4761364758014679,
-0.3711460530757904,
-0.3422899544239044,
-0.3905436396598816,
0.2292253077030182,
-0.5250025391578674,
0.03337860852479935,
0.238833487033844,
0.9628539085388184,
0.02511155605316162,
0.04986770078539848,
0.3229777216911316,
-0.5621827244758606,
0.13067276775836945,
0.5294030904769897,
0.5626876354217529,
0.8699129223823547,
-0.321658730506897,
0.4164058268070221,
0.070904441177845,
-0.5304020047187805,
0.042255427688360214,
0.37273263931274414,
-0.31987425684928894,
0.5662014484405518,
0.5004284977912903,
0.6598510146141052,
0.8493349552154541,
-0.6867063045501709,
0.3402591943740845,
-0.07840976864099503,
0.33944058418273926,
-0.4219135642051697,
0.23122172057628632,
-0.10044651478528976,
0.10470788180828094,
0.44625478982925415,
0.2450435310602188,
0.7564196586608887,
-0.5117458701133728,
0.047276027500629425,
0.19894370436668396,
-0.15633517503738403,
-0.4705446660518646,
0.6416360139846802,
0.13588733971118927,
0.07808385044336319,
0.05921058729290962,
-0.3574671447277069,
-0.042434997856616974,
0.19778947532176971,
0.32127073407173157,
0.8047212958335876,
-0.3016050159931183,
-0.04221171513199806,
0.20839835703372955,
0.17879854142665863,
0.14656192064285278,
0.04904026538133621,
0.0060348547995090485,
-0.3702307343482971,
-0.08037587255239487,
-0.47604283690452576,
-0.5161083340644836,
-0.28211233019828796,
-0.8873568773269653,
0.46840590238571167,
-0.38394439220428467,
-0.3596849739551544,
0.4840881824493408,
-0.036788418889045715,
-0.3451958894729614,
0.07434447854757309,
-0.19789081811904907,
0.8832764029502869,
-0.46956270933151245,
0.32404330372810364,
0.9592958688735962,
-0.8940239548683167,
-0.6361638903617859,
0.17318230867385864,
0.03815338388085365,
-0.25322097539901733,
0.4502377510070801,
0.15692076086997986,
-0.227120503783226,
0.3161177933216095,
-0.33690953254699707,
-0.9266159534454346,
1.4715533256530762,
0.5158639550209045,
-0.378579705953598,
-0.3543987572193146,
-0.5002997517585754,
0.3975960314273834,
-0.15111756324768066,
0.7617737650871277,
0.6286296844482422,
0.3610743284225464,
0.03372221812605858,
-0.7228076457977295,
-0.013942809775471687,
-0.37450864911079407,
0.3110019266605377,
-0.14366169273853302,
-0.6794431209564209,
0.6958944797515869,
-0.24677473306655884,
-0.6393525004386902,
-0.3084433674812317,
1.188522458076477,
0.608171820640564,
0.27419599890708923,
0.27008822560310364,
0.1795930564403534,
1.183506727218628,
-0.30973413586616516,
1.1083475351333618,
-0.5662537217140198,
0.18988706171512604,
1.0642368793487549,
-0.2711290419101715,
0.3767387866973877,
0.430109441280365,
-0.06051389500498772,
0.4771524667739868,
0.6862472295761108,
0.005918443668633699,
0.4780919551849365,
0.01959557645022869,
-0.31485047936439514,
0.3128938674926758,
-0.6089172959327698,
-0.3372606337070465,
0.41716766357421875,
0.2330949306488037,
-0.273230642080307,
-0.1915445476770401,
-0.09378217905759811,
0.3736409544944763,
0.19406744837760925,
-0.40224364399909973,
0.7601317763328552,
0.10473491251468658,
-0.8075748085975647,
0.2664055824279785,
0.29210546612739563,
0.7352420091629028,
-0.5482888221740723,
0.005067336838692427,
-0.4735444188117981,
-0.23025812208652496,
-0.451969176530838,
-0.6970399618148804,
0.4288789927959442,
0.25241559743881226,
-0.5982089042663574,
-0.1687241494655609,
0.7601865530014038,
-0.35054799914360046,
-0.21535901725292206,
0.16331665217876434,
0.1810676008462906,
0.6403674483299255,
-0.03647247701883316,
-0.2320612072944641,
-0.3484068512916565,
-0.402759313583374,
-0.37075135111808777,
0.1509903520345688,
0.7794733643531799,
-0.09859676659107208,
0.4682023823261261,
0.3359573483467102,
0.41613924503326416,
-0.03857288882136345,
0.07741804420948029,
0.7901965379714966,
-0.8256463408470154,
-0.47407519817352295,
-0.8474112749099731,
0.55755215883255,
-0.2507537305355072,
-0.3547680079936981,
0.979203999042511,
0.715083122253418,
0.7644290924072266,
-0.20632074773311615,
0.6795979142189026,
-0.16734158992767334,
0.5881703495979309,
-0.7460405826568604,
0.5147947072982788,
-0.11276275664567947,
0.4559890329837799,
-0.36128056049346924,
-0.7901982665061951,
-0.17555715143680573,
0.4447765648365021,
-0.224436953663826,
0.03326050192117691,
0.9373204112052917,
0.5023537278175354,
-0.11168897897005081,
0.08009731769561768,
0.44761431217193604,
0.17557178437709808,
-0.07699736207723618,
0.4010979235172272,
0.5144844651222229,
-0.1482572704553604,
0.28955546021461487,
-0.16646341979503632,
-0.1737069934606552,
-0.40937021374702454,
-0.7729702591896057,
-0.727877140045166,
-0.4766009449958801,
-0.20055653154850006,
-0.41129371523857117,
0.1342291384935379,
1.1235588788986206,
0.40092283487319946,
-1.052067756652832,
0.08914903551340103,
0.41261857748031616,
0.30101364850997925,
-0.36676737666130066,
-0.2782280147075653,
0.27603915333747864,
-0.2651422619819641,
-0.9078384637832642,
0.14074915647506714,
0.7376364469528198,
0.20241524279117584,
-0.4554304778575897,
0.28867045044898987,
-0.12692250311374664,
-0.15406915545463562,
0.4704335331916809,
0.19460688531398773,
-0.7355669140815735,
-0.046240370720624924,
0.2848910391330719,
-0.30681002140045166,
0.005183721426874399,
0.881398618221283,
-0.4607972800731659,
-0.06556456536054611,
0.14892706274986267,
0.4581319987773895,
0.3049495220184326,
0.3025972843170166,
0.1711861938238144,
-0.9288283586502075,
0.24449923634529114,
0.39195966720581055,
0.531379759311676,
0.4023354649543762,
-0.6875864863395691,
0.6512932181358337,
0.46042534708976746,
-0.21490027010440826,
-0.6692124009132385,
0.055283114314079285,
-0.7051473259925842,
-0.14193302392959595,
0.8402771949768066,
-0.5321775674819946,
-0.36517590284347534,
-0.2647840976715088,
-0.07267341762781143,
0.3198113441467285,
-0.6299492716789246,
0.8820855617523193,
0.625045657157898,
-0.26098352670669556,
-0.42617911100387573,
-0.3817842900753021,
0.5665635466575623,
0.4615921676158905,
-1.0001462697982788,
-0.04991540312767029,
0.7385799288749695,
0.12018665671348572,
0.3286096453666687,
0.6267886757850647,
0.015247760340571404,
0.17624154686927795,
-0.08491963148117065,
0.4705324172973633,
-0.24781584739685059,
-0.6081443428993225,
-0.2316306233406067,
0.169573113322258,
0.08657766878604889,
0.2574721872806549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08795v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08795v1 | Ontologia para monitorar a deficiência mental em seus déficts no processamento da informação por declínio cognitivo e evitar agressões psicológicas e físicas em ambientes educacionais com ajuda da I.A* | 2024-01-31T16:15:41 | 2024-01-31T16:15:41 | Bruna Araújo de Castro Oliveira | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The intention of this article is to propose the use of artificial
intelligence to detect through analysis by UFO ontology the emergence of verbal
and physical aggression related to psychosocial deficiencies and their
provoking agents, in an attempt to prevent catastrophic consequences within
school environments. | [
-0.5470452308654785,
-1.1149814128875732,
0.6788424253463745,
0.1283060610294342,
0.33722129464149475,
0.19196833670139313,
0.28813594579696655,
-0.5687824487686157,
0.3543044626712799,
0.34448736906051636,
-0.9412865042686462,
-0.27785730361938477,
-0.6465522050857544,
0.16299277544021606,
-0.390036404132843,
0.6257382035255432,
0.2645176649093628,
0.14369399845600128,
-0.21920406818389893,
0.1756685972213745,
-0.33004340529441833,
-0.5528638362884521,
-1.140491008758545,
0.004145107232034206,
0.22735320031642914,
0.33638161420822144,
0.5665271878242493,
0.16843155026435852,
0.8211641907691956,
0.6295264363288879,
0.11973148584365845,
-0.07180840522050858,
-0.35819557309150696,
-0.052626218646764755,
-0.7427189946174622,
-0.4267139732837677,
-0.44641146063804626,
0.10332842916250229,
0.5946305394172668,
0.3645184338092804,
-0.07011991739273071,
0.23639467358589172,
-0.28316327929496765,
0.5224637389183044,
-0.2083798348903656,
0.26070091128349304,
-0.11552193015813828,
0.30664587020874023,
-0.04408537596464157,
-0.059109922498464584,
0.029652860015630722,
-0.16109402477741241,
-0.04151148721575737,
-0.7593938112258911,
-0.10457976162433624,
0.07260922342538834,
0.852768063545227,
0.6986985206604004,
-0.1739402413368225,
-0.40915384888648987,
-0.824963390827179,
0.6981821060180664,
-0.4085683226585388,
0.49388882517814636,
0.7623184323310852,
0.13777291774749756,
-0.40406695008277893,
-0.6836621165275574,
-0.9019700884819031,
-0.2607577443122864,
0.11347801238298416,
0.11767582595348358,
-0.43631401658058167,
-0.043141625821590424,
0.34372270107269287,
-0.3690219819545746,
-0.2435522824525833,
0.16803230345249176,
-0.5258081555366516,
-0.45511284470558167,
0.7950994372367859,
0.5599477887153625,
0.8215850591659546,
0.01966431550681591,
-0.13697421550750732,
0.07991728186607361,
-0.26341646909713745,
0.30007609724998474,
0.6538718342781067,
0.19931116700172424,
-0.34789586067199707,
0.5351719856262207,
-0.09590103477239609,
0.553626537322998,
0.1390525847673416,
-0.13772936165332794,
-0.14333093166351318,
-0.3458404541015625,
-0.12184539437294006,
0.005740767810493708,
0.9063683152198792,
0.4436347484588623,
-0.011186541989445686,
0.036780521273612976,
-0.15451325476169586,
0.7459588050842285,
0.690101146697998,
-0.5030512809753418,
0.13725364208221436,
0.3232255280017853,
-0.22540883719921112,
-0.726296067237854,
0.18289515376091003,
-1.0840342044830322,
-0.292141318321228,
-0.2885309159755707,
0.27469050884246826,
-0.5313904285430908,
-0.23792687058448792,
-0.019641326740384102,
-0.015479235909879208,
0.01170672383159399,
0.2469542920589447,
-0.554124653339386,
0.47636887431144714,
0.42442843317985535,
0.5124972462654114,
0.396064817905426,
-0.36712646484375,
-0.15684394538402557,
-0.01045901607722044,
-0.38035154342651367,
0.986249566078186,
-0.5984486937522888,
-0.2465842366218567,
-0.20153695344924927,
-0.02740558609366417,
0.15584732592105865,
-0.3276294469833374,
0.7402597665786743,
-0.20412124693393707,
0.2726210057735443,
-0.09116269648075104,
-0.23179315030574799,
-0.5578810572624207,
0.23951688408851624,
-0.3724370002746582,
1.2842620611190796,
0.43220219016075134,
-0.3076172173023224,
0.18351386487483978,
-0.8077321648597717,
-0.23259128630161285,
0.39400580525398254,
-0.42980700731277466,
-0.420089989900589,
-0.29171761870384216,
-0.452304869890213,
0.4677928388118744,
-0.17153146862983704,
0.36685463786125183,
-0.16378672420978546,
-0.11181318014860153,
0.363227516412735,
-0.013767832890152931,
1.0064023733139038,
0.215909942984581,
-0.6142972707748413,
0.32069098949432373,
-0.7960008978843689,
-0.0971817672252655,
0.48594212532043457,
-0.057538144290447235,
-0.6247395277023315,
0.5183447599411011,
-0.25351497530937195,
0.469252347946167,
0.3911683261394501,
-0.7711303234100342,
0.06272048503160477,
-0.31738558411598206,
0.07241528481245041,
0.8019869327545166,
0.14935611188411713,
-0.02539967931807041,
-0.4640999436378479,
0.42608147859573364,
-0.09027905762195587,
0.5038602352142334,
0.24977362155914307,
-0.35477346181869507,
-0.36161893606185913,
-0.06148811802268028,
-0.5833274722099304,
0.8159421682357788,
-0.5870897173881531,
0.7030971646308899,
-0.06717081367969513,
-0.5030189752578735,
-0.12772917747497559,
0.25001221895217896,
0.7969629764556885,
0.5236403346061707,
0.21624256670475006,
-0.31658458709716797,
-0.9400037527084351,
-0.19068412482738495,
-0.05993365868926048,
-0.30125030875205994,
0.024931035935878754,
0.4719425439834595,
0.8187999725341797,
-0.321816623210907,
0.6536446213722229,
-0.267329603433609,
-0.7824128866195679,
0.02306586503982544,
-0.12467944622039795,
-0.35016709566116333,
0.30708637833595276,
0.9411797523498535,
-1.1558520793914795,
-0.53090500831604,
0.08442794531583786,
-1.5494389533996582,
-0.21706120669841766,
0.17022663354873657,
-0.17551028728485107,
0.023994941264390945,
0.9713488221168518,
-0.29368895292282104,
0.6700286865234375,
0.3269617557525635,
-1.194494605064392,
0.48867249488830566,
-0.06047796830534935,
0.22628210484981537,
-0.7187759876251221,
-0.10631459951400757,
0.43731629848480225,
-0.04489750787615776,
-0.9022927284240723,
0.12824012339115143,
-0.4616912603378296,
0.025154493749141693,
-0.7383051514625549,
0.3428352177143097,
-0.007631528191268444,
0.41133105754852295,
-0.24683989584445953,
0.3393281102180481,
-0.19158940017223358,
0.516605019569397,
-0.11846133321523666,
0.4886525869369507,
0.6638016104698181,
-0.6553435921669006,
0.7944009900093079,
0.5553969144821167,
-0.03254077583551407,
0.8635485172271729,
-0.6282501220703125,
-0.050224993377923965,
-0.297461599111557,
-0.19039292633533478,
-0.7382193207740784,
-0.25430846214294434,
0.7890735864639282,
-0.7242376208305359,
-0.0324290432035923,
0.609506368637085,
-0.1383892297744751,
-0.5377979874610901,
-0.3469213843345642,
-0.1178247407078743,
0.2712152302265167,
-0.25130897760391235,
0.8929763436317444,
0.7270874977111816,
-0.026027066633105278,
-0.356037974357605,
-0.5541065335273743,
0.2019956111907959,
-0.2999724745750427,
-0.4034688174724579,
0.0993259847164154,
-0.06789229810237885,
-1.0594942569732666,
0.2600516974925995,
0.10591264814138412,
-0.1602674424648285,
0.3625384271144867,
0.6757614612579346,
0.5075969099998474,
-0.29291704297065735,
-0.17781658470630646,
0.02098754607141018,
0.2410440295934677,
0.805311381816864,
0.10681745409965515,
0.5682269930839539,
-0.14128510653972626,
-0.0029657927807420492,
-1.077215313911438,
0.4069715142250061,
0.5640615820884705,
0.07325432449579239,
0.9683131575584412,
-0.0639081746339798,
-0.4036611020565033,
0.04662501811981201,
-0.1282222419977188,
-0.13029052317142487,
-0.6024190783500671,
0.3026047945022583,
-0.32586705684661865,
-0.19854991137981415,
0.4429437518119812,
-0.23061132431030273,
-0.42818254232406616,
0.5579527020454407,
0.4019775986671448,
-0.30772867798805237,
0.9242566823959351,
0.4923337996006012,
-0.1826804131269455,
0.7771696448326111,
-0.6229367852210999,
-0.048573654145002365,
-0.4723266661167145,
-0.9755207896232605,
-0.6192145943641663,
-0.12950697541236877,
-0.3904801309108734,
-0.10629087686538696,
0.1419830620288849,
-0.520825207233429,
-0.6172471642494202,
0.18269599974155426,
-0.7762041091918945,
0.364268034696579,
0.33717018365859985,
0.16690035164356232,
-0.04442567750811577,
-0.1696271449327469,
0.02555185556411743,
0.14103534817695618,
-0.527326762676239,
-0.7049371004104614,
0.9351094961166382,
0.08220315724611282,
0.462233304977417,
0.4616149365901947,
0.12954896688461304,
0.6217331886291504,
0.3451344668865204,
-0.7834284901618958,
0.9564414024353027,
0.0369337722659111,
-0.7248104214668274,
-0.5930373668670654,
-0.05147537961602211,
-1.0717692375183105,
0.08292228728532791,
-0.4834924340248108,
-0.9517272710800171,
0.4945984184741974,
-0.18112725019454956,
-0.38194987177848816,
0.1838477998971939,
-0.576667845249176,
0.7816986441612244,
-0.2747081220149994,
-0.6230629682540894,
-0.2733144462108612,
-0.5828313231468201,
0.097402423620224,
-0.4163864552974701,
0.3743200898170471,
-0.4535963535308838,
-0.22798413038253784,
0.8949941992759705,
-0.49232369661331177,
1.2211358547210693,
-0.24998098611831665,
-0.21027284860610962,
0.744063675403595,
-0.1891103982925415,
0.11634661257266998,
-0.35177162289619446,
0.10426310449838638,
0.2679365575313568,
-0.0005616120179183781,
-0.2995227575302124,
-0.46219828724861145,
0.6514190435409546,
-1.3641258478164673,
-0.5427646040916443,
-0.7396989464759827,
-0.3408566117286682,
0.08928989619016647,
0.5768648386001587,
0.286618709564209,
0.21514959633350372,
-0.4892975986003876,
-0.2517707943916321,
0.3976268172264099,
0.17340576648712158,
0.341257780790329,
1.0993486642837524,
-0.2589459717273712,
-0.1381891369819641,
0.9447525143623352,
0.3070405125617981,
-0.0530049130320549,
0.06327855587005615,
0.3758195638656616,
-0.21403911709785461,
-0.27908408641815186,
0.22158241271972656,
0.24639318883419037,
-0.40395694971084595,
-0.3368682265281677,
-0.5552949905395508,
-0.08240914344787598,
-0.8335441946983337,
-0.20750325918197632,
-0.3546985387802124,
0.16836512088775635,
-0.19632992148399353,
-0.0881018340587616,
0.3288997709751129,
1.0473096370697021,
-0.1166306808590889,
0.6539850234985352,
-0.3952813446521759,
0.5184263586997986,
0.14255398511886597,
0.20230476558208466,
-0.24798455834388733,
-0.3952105641365051,
-0.2169249951839447,
0.13173776865005493,
-0.6677448153495789,
-0.8837646842002869,
0.5626325011253357,
0.21790200471878052,
0.6134706139564514,
0.9957358241081238,
0.15170669555664062,
0.18221613764762878,
-0.10075091570615768,
0.5546804070472717,
-0.005648791324347258,
-0.8476434946060181,
1.0201293230056763,
-0.5184661149978638,
-0.0592966191470623,
0.339610755443573,
1.2824746370315552,
-0.12825700640678406,
-0.6360089182853699,
-0.9741100668907166,
-0.5333305597305298,
0.9947354197502136,
-0.015250018797814846,
-0.009175821207463741,
-0.0732678696513176,
0.2869025468826294,
-0.3313016891479492,
-0.06268921494483948,
-0.45123690366744995,
-0.4596037268638611,
-0.268265038728714,
-0.06781083345413208,
0.047463204711675644,
-0.08279362320899963,
-0.44702622294425964,
-0.5086609721183777,
0.6983810663223267,
0.18151433765888214,
0.165397047996521,
0.34096184372901917,
0.2428712397813797,
-0.5032750368118286,
-0.23669157922267914,
0.5486201643943787,
0.4771808683872223,
0.10923123359680176,
0.2861422896385193,
0.08058927208185196,
-0.9967164993286133,
0.3973233103752136,
-0.23311908543109894,
-0.20654378831386566,
-0.2587053179740906,
0.3369652330875397,
0.718191385269165,
0.15802885591983795,
-1.0790836811065674,
0.6316628456115723,
-0.07945245504379272,
-0.403241366147995,
-0.89177006483078,
0.2519017159938812,
-0.6300946474075317,
0.43485841155052185,
0.40518078207969666,
0.18636702001094818,
0.22523872554302216,
-0.7213488817214966,
0.19866228103637695,
0.3486781716346741,
-0.33874911069869995,
-0.6595525145530701,
0.7842121124267578,
-0.04578644037246704,
-0.854961097240448,
0.5494703650474548,
-0.5795760154724121,
-0.6916738152503967,
0.8457388281822205,
0.7171748280525208,
0.5401290655136108,
-0.9776173233985901,
0.46509894728660583,
0.34723177552223206,
0.44630661606788635,
0.08668871223926544,
0.7387194037437439,
0.2606232464313507,
-1.1736575365066528,
-0.1630304455757141,
-0.3220209777355194,
-0.48925915360450745,
0.2894306480884552,
-0.6754834055900574,
0.2724708616733551,
-1.0290846824645996,
-0.2813597619533539,
0.2700969874858856,
-0.12707772850990295,
-0.4104408323764801,
0.6465660333633423,
0.1405215710401535,
0.368575781583786,
-1.38408625125885,
0.5477883219718933,
1.0040295124053955,
-0.46568426489830017,
-0.7611309885978699,
-0.14063458144664764,
0.2762715518474579,
-0.6979451775550842,
0.830187201499939,
-0.18732509016990662,
-0.5118719935417175,
0.14398109912872314,
-0.6123361587524414,
-1.112767219543457,
0.5113372206687927,
0.044146597385406494,
-0.21148636937141418,
0.0995892882347107,
0.1852085143327713,
1.0187582969665527,
-0.1376853585243225,
0.056816838681697845,
0.834800124168396,
0.7960620522499084,
-0.117261603474617,
-0.405629426240921,
0.19078071415424347,
-0.4440358579158783,
-0.33006733655929565,
0.31554022431373596,
-0.998545229434967,
0.4209851622581482,
-0.2921260893344879,
-0.39120572805404663,
-0.3007971942424774,
0.763701319694519,
-0.2818830907344818,
0.7996014356613159,
0.07815676927566528,
0.5174242258071899,
0.5364573001861572,
-0.04402480646967888,
0.9274170994758606,
-0.2905157506465912,
-0.17858612537384033,
0.7715456485748291,
-0.08879370987415314,
0.6553015112876892,
0.47686466574668884,
-0.6312816143035889,
0.8473525047302246,
0.37723249197006226,
-0.38081562519073486,
0.40857017040252686,
-0.1423605978488922,
-0.6657830476760864,
0.1735237091779709,
-0.7481832504272461,
0.26040151715278625,
1.0242118835449219,
0.8210541009902954,
0.0172877199947834,
0.25187477469444275,
0.5663849711418152,
0.021532976999878883,
0.778472900390625,
-0.801912248134613,
0.8492547869682312,
-0.2828513979911804,
-0.7616857290267944,
0.29497402906417847,
-0.21525956690311432,
0.5773593783378601,
-0.600400447845459,
0.11937814950942993,
0.010177074931561947,
0.13163046538829803,
-0.44838643074035645,
-0.6819239854812622,
0.8450706601142883,
0.01920759491622448,
0.1292707324028015,
-0.14413894712924957,
0.8360419869422913,
0.22622425854206085,
-0.6638126373291016,
0.706115186214447,
0.3660717308521271,
0.39075610041618347,
0.22668689489364624,
-0.7820068001747131,
-0.07045146077871323,
-0.09787996113300323,
-0.3772682845592499,
0.42693790793418884,
0.33697509765625,
-0.36976203322410583,
0.7748966217041016,
0.5537031888961792,
0.4359114170074463,
0.12971116602420807,
-0.4032529592514038,
0.9619265198707581,
-0.5646907091140747,
-0.42079877853393555,
-0.9533637166023254,
0.09309985488653183,
-0.010136577300727367,
-0.15590977668762207,
0.8583072423934937,
0.6043697595596313,
0.885063648223877,
0.0491458997130394,
0.6878687143325806,
-0.4645453989505768,
0.27332186698913574,
0.17876586318016052,
0.42227911949157715,
-0.4253326654434204,
-0.15884184837341309,
-0.28935518860816956,
-0.535045325756073,
-0.07751915603876114,
0.7432821989059448,
-0.5970180630683899,
-0.0781199261546135,
0.6763213276863098,
0.6244022250175476,
0.3335423767566681,
-0.10552509129047394,
0.49280303716659546,
0.3663457930088043,
-0.03592316433787346,
0.12524981796741486,
0.7583369612693787,
-0.3262871503829956,
0.2872709631919861,
-0.5217422842979431,
-0.38517138361930847,
-0.12107712775468826,
-0.416798859834671,
-0.9472699165344238,
-0.5754461884498596,
-0.453485369682312,
-0.3505105972290039,
0.09130066633224487,
0.6766496300697327,
-0.047350820153951645,
-0.7822884321212769,
-0.18173831701278687,
-0.23130176961421967,
0.10322605073451996,
-0.32586413621902466,
-0.3407890200614929,
0.1611861288547516,
-0.042462512850761414,
-1.0770684480667114,
0.4342353045940399,
0.11942911893129349,
0.4882351756095886,
-0.4901096820831299,
0.053292326629161835,
-0.5390228033065796,
0.456166535615921,
0.4476836621761322,
0.6394448280334473,
-0.38892847299575806,
-0.282612144947052,
-0.13686755299568176,
-0.24846667051315308,
-0.15190571546554565,
0.3015150725841522,
-0.7679945826530457,
0.08665923774242401,
0.40745919942855835,
0.1826714277267456,
-0.1881304830312729,
-0.12621639668941498,
0.0912269875407219,
-0.6400488615036011,
0.5987175703048706,
0.3373122215270996,
0.04068358615040779,
-0.09342731535434723,
-0.9010688066482544,
0.7228417992591858,
0.45898252725601196,
-0.5467075109481812,
-0.8971788883209229,
-0.005688813515007496,
-0.6534386873245239,
-0.35427889227867126,
0.6834754347801208,
-0.22398610413074493,
-0.4810059666633606,
-0.3172534108161926,
-0.5092061758041382,
0.39175528287887573,
-0.28364601731300354,
1.0918997526168823,
0.4043676555156708,
-0.44838660955429077,
0.2167358100414276,
-0.41312411427497864,
0.5195006132125854,
0.3091789484024048,
-0.8743065595626831,
-0.567099392414093,
0.3076404333114624,
0.046492744237184525,
0.525816798210144,
0.5760276913642883,
0.22556979954242706,
0.32185661792755127,
0.5028200149536133,
0.30110421776771545,
-0.00829229224473238,
-0.4626789689064026,
0.05122648924589157,
0.1460229456424713,
-0.4780203104019165,
-0.1406210958957672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17922v1 | [Lions: 1] and [Tigers: 2] and [Bears: 3], Oh My! Literary Coreference Annotation with LLMs | 2024-01-31T15:35:21 | 2024-01-31T15:35:21 | Rebecca M. M. Hicke, David Mimno | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coreference annotation and resolution is a vital component of computational
literary studies. However, it has previously been difficult to build high
quality systems for fiction. Coreference requires complicated structured
outputs, and literary text involves subtle inferences and highly varied
language. New language-model-based seq2seq systems present the opportunity to
solve both these problems by learning to directly generate a copy of an input
sentence with markdown-like annotations. We create, evaluate, and release
several trained models for coreference, as well as a workflow for training new
models. | [
-0.19755563139915466,
-0.5696365237236023,
0.6806032061576843,
0.05367239564657211,
-0.3814964294433594,
-0.03028973378241062,
-0.21508900821208954,
-0.6814780235290527,
0.32986709475517273,
1.0058199167251587,
-0.5076650381088257,
-0.39483270049095154,
-0.4210207164287567,
0.30667105317115784,
-0.2810090184211731,
0.9977063536643982,
0.11403663456439972,
0.12249883264303207,
-0.2145284116268158,
-0.18685466051101685,
-0.07312590628862381,
-0.9192950129508972,
-0.40909722447395325,
-0.6531413197517395,
0.48109838366508484,
0.3199363052845001,
0.8996078968048096,
0.5710371136665344,
0.7065633535385132,
0.1241459846496582,
-0.17305830121040344,
0.18560291826725006,
-0.22034034132957458,
0.5912023782730103,
-0.4309360980987549,
-0.42143067717552185,
-0.17710871994495392,
0.2214890867471695,
0.3305952847003937,
0.6555387377738953,
0.4471622109413147,
0.23573759198188782,
-0.18257151544094086,
0.6360903382301331,
-0.7495981454849243,
-0.03429350256919861,
-0.6493602991104126,
0.0849313735961914,
-0.21226708590984344,
-0.06954677402973175,
-0.6378128528594971,
-0.6067633628845215,
-0.22530627250671387,
-0.5861548781394958,
0.1891474425792694,
0.176534503698349,
0.8663413524627686,
0.2943882942199707,
-0.5774725079536438,
-0.5507174134254456,
-0.4534599184989929,
0.6589582562446594,
-0.6291325092315674,
-0.11950353533029556,
0.6208246350288391,
0.15029561519622803,
0.08483407646417618,
-0.6895815134048462,
-0.645585834980011,
-0.29116469621658325,
-0.13763296604156494,
0.0023748748935759068,
0.15953786671161652,
0.04024892300367355,
0.29981520771980286,
0.45193877816200256,
-0.275302916765213,
0.14496007561683655,
-0.18617881834506989,
-0.17112740874290466,
0.8189088106155396,
0.08085481077432632,
0.3496987819671631,
-0.46310150623321533,
-0.08093378692865372,
0.38261476159095764,
-0.835313081741333,
-0.07592479139566422,
0.1292780339717865,
0.34588345885276794,
0.29363909363746643,
0.7701948285102844,
0.02876930870115757,
0.47730228304862976,
0.2036391645669937,
-0.14943091571331024,
0.17846465110778809,
-0.1544099599123001,
-0.04778424650430679,
-0.03348042443394661,
0.5409350991249084,
0.5454064011573792,
0.30805644392967224,
-0.1829850822687149,
-0.3339696228504181,
0.16903793811798096,
-0.005021587945520878,
-0.5666191577911377,
-0.2443811595439911,
0.027384202927350998,
-0.4292905628681183,
-0.4360372722148895,
-0.3050177991390228,
-0.020623141899704933,
-0.8094793558120728,
-0.5731416940689087,
0.45806998014450073,
-0.4618438482284546,
-0.15016157925128937,
-0.10648660361766815,
-0.2152017056941986,
0.284371554851532,
0.44258859753608704,
-0.9446699023246765,
0.13627086579799652,
0.5063878893852234,
0.6775732040405273,
-0.12787142395973206,
-0.25773993134498596,
-0.40077123045921326,
0.18886852264404297,
-0.44773435592651367,
0.9250046014785767,
-0.5260685682296753,
-0.4229479432106018,
-0.08386071026325226,
0.036340367048978806,
0.1762857437133789,
-0.5670427083969116,
0.8524211645126343,
-0.3993271291255951,
-0.08497971296310425,
-0.3147163987159729,
-0.7512093782424927,
-0.25720182061195374,
0.21092893183231354,
-0.7503834366798401,
1.4333922863006592,
0.030367352068424225,
-0.6643430590629578,
-0.3049754202365875,
-0.36276134848594666,
-0.4562511444091797,
0.22612233459949493,
-0.21958453953266144,
0.015566139481961727,
0.2609090805053711,
0.05245189368724823,
0.7785319089889526,
-0.5249621272087097,
0.13100756704807281,
-0.22997944056987762,
-0.3876922130584717,
0.45748257637023926,
0.46088099479675293,
0.7192392945289612,
0.39165887236595154,
-0.07758443057537079,
0.05130447819828987,
-0.5545350909233093,
-0.07294690608978271,
0.18658679723739624,
-0.0735657662153244,
-0.37650367617607117,
-0.1865428239107132,
0.2681010663509369,
0.018697718158364296,
0.3979274034500122,
-0.46840858459472656,
0.2603398561477661,
-0.01678392104804516,
0.756566047668457,
0.23149564862251282,
0.1841694414615631,
0.47841882705688477,
-0.6059974431991577,
0.4426921010017395,
-0.2642260193824768,
-0.23962631821632385,
-0.48168542981147766,
-0.23387272655963898,
-0.7153443694114685,
-0.3222212493419647,
0.22300830483436584,
0.6905462145805359,
-0.7350557446479797,
0.4555349051952362,
0.21326109766960144,
-0.8229694366455078,
-0.056810565292835236,
-0.05158533155918121,
0.2678898572921753,
0.2996433973312378,
0.1632670760154724,
0.05942215770483017,
-0.7089427709579468,
-0.9498581886291504,
-0.20672424137592316,
-0.31906452775001526,
0.02888842485845089,
0.23631615936756134,
0.6581525802612305,
-0.10726950317621231,
0.7520449161529541,
-0.40855932235717773,
-0.33805954456329346,
-0.4282880425453186,
0.23699703812599182,
0.22698451578617096,
0.5396407246589661,
0.6390978097915649,
-0.4794674515724182,
-0.1025775596499443,
-0.29679614305496216,
-0.7813930511474609,
-0.5172606706619263,
-0.16678071022033691,
-0.33042821288108826,
-0.050000861287117004,
0.7499796152114868,
-0.29542458057403564,
-0.029156794771552086,
0.45248618721961975,
-0.414657324552536,
1.0974206924438477,
0.274175763130188,
0.2384108155965805,
-1.2034859657287598,
0.02160281129181385,
-0.23101353645324707,
-0.326909601688385,
-0.3588985800743103,
0.10672792792320251,
0.2493651658296585,
-0.11893551796674728,
-0.26275208592414856,
0.48974961042404175,
-0.5384474992752075,
0.12971806526184082,
-0.33252766728401184,
0.3054160177707672,
0.23564429581165314,
0.3387501835823059,
0.21747486293315887,
0.6423776149749756,
0.3045330345630646,
-0.6363382339477539,
0.3853009343147278,
0.5129674077033997,
-0.20186571776866913,
0.7147243022918701,
-0.4157511591911316,
0.25537148118019104,
-0.07246935367584229,
0.22615958750247955,
-0.8919656276702881,
-0.2931550145149231,
-0.12775039672851562,
-0.6465670466423035,
0.05655904859304428,
-0.09588290750980377,
-0.5348369479179382,
-0.011808863840997219,
-0.20673905313014984,
0.4125206768512726,
0.42417898774147034,
-0.510964035987854,
0.6096237897872925,
0.4962329864501953,
-0.3555642068386078,
-0.558015763759613,
-1.0227744579315186,
0.24750570952892303,
0.11568793654441833,
-0.3936232924461365,
0.43707019090652466,
0.03925371170043945,
-0.34802305698394775,
0.12456909567117691,
0.3312523066997528,
-0.25574976205825806,
0.1446562111377716,
0.5873995423316956,
0.2760201394557953,
-0.15329831838607788,
0.44491448998451233,
0.25286275148391724,
-0.07912802696228027,
-0.09516286104917526,
-0.01608176901936531,
0.16316241025924683,
-0.18980391323566437,
-0.3330957889556885,
-0.23935702443122864,
0.5629767775535583,
0.5196019411087036,
-0.3460606634616852,
0.2391895353794098,
0.26379987597465515,
-0.6862967014312744,
-0.18760114908218384,
-0.906336784362793,
-0.18595726788043976,
-0.36996859312057495,
0.335220068693161,
-0.5926635265350342,
-1.385988473892212,
0.35334208607673645,
-0.19861456751823425,
0.09879548847675323,
0.639515221118927,
0.7449096441268921,
-0.30637845396995544,
0.412835031747818,
0.4558596611022949,
0.26748034358024597,
0.43725451827049255,
0.049517784267663956,
-0.028607208281755447,
-1.0027433633804321,
0.02606278844177723,
-0.7628973126411438,
-0.3013327717781067,
0.0025766349863260984,
-0.6439770460128784,
0.060445964336395264,
0.6160224080085754,
-0.4649946987628937,
0.517868161201477,
-0.47958502173423767,
0.7776899933815002,
0.6226069331169128,
-0.008935501798987389,
0.5800448656082153,
-0.11878173053264618,
-0.4474274814128876,
-0.46922004222869873,
-0.05895271897315979,
-0.9800289273262024,
0.7666071057319641,
0.19481085240840912,
0.7978071570396423,
0.2918814718723297,
0.7580167651176453,
0.6530699133872986,
0.33205586671829224,
-0.8104134202003479,
0.6184309124946594,
-0.2046797126531601,
-0.8037183880805969,
-0.19028784334659576,
0.1178504079580307,
-0.5063997507095337,
0.12429122626781464,
-0.42512673139572144,
-0.8514012098312378,
0.016548944637179375,
-0.0585159994661808,
-0.5879823565483093,
0.2768622040748596,
-0.419589102268219,
0.5230860114097595,
-0.131943941116333,
-0.3116436004638672,
0.03179296478629112,
-0.5555604696273804,
0.4095543324947357,
0.04425287991762161,
0.04872153326869011,
-0.6870852708816528,
-0.12633392214775085,
0.7730255126953125,
-0.12886205315589905,
0.9936296343803406,
0.2840355932712555,
0.2584022283554077,
0.6011978387832642,
0.7257188558578491,
0.3810347616672516,
0.03250797837972641,
-0.3818497657775879,
-0.15331608057022095,
0.43851301074028015,
-0.20510753989219666,
-0.5063704252243042,
0.5045469999313354,
-0.7346880435943604,
-0.2848580479621887,
-0.5562324523925781,
-0.5131945013999939,
-0.15476679801940918,
0.1173323392868042,
0.25041985511779785,
0.31943780183792114,
-0.2442287802696228,
0.16677021980285645,
0.3865080177783966,
0.010303338058292866,
0.4909897744655609,
0.5730850100517273,
-0.46455714106559753,
-0.8582667708396912,
0.40366601943969727,
0.0677085891366005,
0.09745121747255325,
0.3688782751560211,
-0.19312618672847748,
-0.42045673727989197,
-0.5836873650550842,
-0.3266858756542206,
0.6513384580612183,
-1.0655250549316406,
-0.32234781980514526,
-0.6454974412918091,
-0.4231329560279846,
-0.5135778188705444,
-0.5568601489067078,
-0.21984580159187317,
-0.8777360916137695,
-0.4600929021835327,
-0.30311447381973267,
0.3718026280403137,
0.9947015643119812,
-0.15225239098072052,
0.33516862988471985,
-0.9094411730766296,
-0.10207003355026245,
0.07104334235191345,
-0.0007947320700623095,
-0.3905904293060303,
-0.6810048222541809,
-0.38470250368118286,
-0.5066065192222595,
-0.36256882548332214,
-1.2254830598831177,
0.2817700505256653,
0.3036175072193146,
0.3498002290725708,
0.18203791975975037,
0.4037448763847351,
0.2096087783575058,
-0.31438207626342773,
1.2198580503463745,
0.2631392776966095,
-1.143686294555664,
0.5811067819595337,
-0.3146754205226898,
0.21446891129016876,
0.7635602355003357,
0.31325405836105347,
-0.8793737292289734,
-0.32522648572921753,
-0.42004308104515076,
-0.48526889085769653,
0.33822792768478394,
0.20572231709957123,
0.11954577267169952,
-0.20091865956783295,
0.784636378288269,
0.16235776245594025,
0.14216069877147675,
-0.7566980123519897,
-0.08170169591903687,
0.08633296191692352,
-0.3357360363006592,
-0.16365252435207367,
-0.801226019859314,
-0.017669333145022392,
-0.1209132969379425,
0.8505076766014099,
-0.40599748492240906,
0.08782774955034256,
0.3852156698703766,
-0.5279879570007324,
0.020578447729349136,
0.32101958990097046,
0.3239065706729889,
0.42836400866508484,
-0.10207686573266983,
0.5179495811462402,
0.10990533232688904,
-0.4609067738056183,
0.20325294137001038,
-0.14986515045166016,
-0.5032222270965576,
0.09261491894721985,
0.482991099357605,
0.514847993850708,
0.1717963069677353,
-0.8089629411697388,
0.3057156503200531,
0.19600093364715576,
-0.34321051836013794,
-0.6590330004692078,
-0.03669697791337967,
0.35529911518096924,
0.5749368667602539,
0.4542994499206543,
-0.034158915281295776,
0.2566693425178528,
-0.14493148028850555,
0.2555917799472809,
0.23274478316307068,
-0.49016621708869934,
-0.22275157272815704,
0.5578478574752808,
0.49017101526260376,
-0.23338854312896729,
0.38813671469688416,
-0.3219941258430481,
-0.7876737713813782,
0.4517601728439331,
0.660030722618103,
0.9825742840766907,
0.11113841831684113,
0.2280251830816269,
0.7114616632461548,
0.48373764753341675,
-0.06783425807952881,
0.4160667359828949,
-0.05451216548681259,
-0.9507651329040527,
-0.507564902305603,
-0.700709342956543,
-0.9082025289535522,
0.022550711408257484,
-0.6381528973579407,
0.34824293851852417,
-0.6121039986610413,
-0.3339598774909973,
0.004090939648449421,
0.06676684319972992,
-0.2370530515909195,
0.21007710695266724,
0.5461505651473999,
0.7545360922813416,
-0.8819169998168945,
0.8279013633728027,
1.1494464874267578,
-0.6420228481292725,
-0.6024423241615295,
-0.483268678188324,
0.14840063452720642,
-0.5115467309951782,
0.6951755285263062,
0.24367254972457886,
-0.05138648673892021,
0.26188474893569946,
-0.6840893030166626,
-0.8440949320793152,
1.1920729875564575,
0.4351526200771332,
-0.30162423849105835,
-0.03259341046214104,
-0.0646682009100914,
0.3382601737976074,
-0.6753602623939514,
0.5619553327560425,
0.5876222252845764,
0.1773746907711029,
0.26342150568962097,
-0.8822551369667053,
0.1618272364139557,
-0.41406315565109253,
0.13208846747875214,
0.017739826813340187,
-0.46808329224586487,
0.8768068552017212,
-0.31566646695137024,
-0.16053129732608795,
0.28670167922973633,
0.8596609234809875,
0.36006030440330505,
0.11323955655097961,
0.36450380086898804,
0.6988056898117065,
0.943195641040802,
-0.24854998290538788,
0.6190145611763,
-0.3063235878944397,
0.4407498240470886,
1.5974338054656982,
-0.44009867310523987,
1.0383602380752563,
0.47228437662124634,
-0.13183264434337616,
0.39065253734588623,
1.0141481161117554,
0.026904918253421783,
0.021746736019849777,
0.19300270080566406,
-0.39599862694740295,
-0.6447577476501465,
-0.5271629095077515,
-0.34256798028945923,
0.02630183845758438,
0.4589710235595703,
-0.5748328566551208,
-0.029153401032090187,
0.03916509449481964,
0.1561715453863144,
0.5132402181625366,
-0.12714534997940063,
0.6931580901145935,
0.23848271369934082,
-0.6229318380355835,
0.2667877972126007,
0.10901495069265366,
0.6704463362693787,
-0.3512970209121704,
0.15481750667095184,
-0.22403939068317413,
0.05978187918663025,
-0.329627126455307,
-0.7341578006744385,
0.4007590711116791,
-0.013333430513739586,
-0.5786640644073486,
0.00839082058519125,
0.8095512390136719,
-0.3823080360889435,
-0.48431119322776794,
0.09148833155632019,
0.5042023658752441,
0.3667490482330322,
-0.39426788687705994,
-0.5385713577270508,
0.07451201975345612,
-0.0873989388346672,
-0.1895470768213272,
-0.11143369972705841,
0.46181002259254456,
0.006028249394148588,
0.5488516092300415,
0.39184796810150146,
0.036680590361356735,
0.016515545547008514,
0.03042615018785,
0.5512638092041016,
-1.1234421730041504,
-0.42261767387390137,
-0.5937699675559998,
0.2750943601131439,
0.0021884122397750616,
-0.4353605806827545,
0.6124403476715088,
0.4340149760246277,
0.4045391380786896,
-0.14272725582122803,
1.056775689125061,
-0.14016452431678772,
0.8022356629371643,
-0.4248238503932953,
0.46919116377830505,
-0.41791588068008423,
0.10792531818151474,
-0.058723244816064835,
-0.7798299789428711,
-0.5963082313537598,
0.6133943796157837,
-0.3032081425189972,
-0.2904490530490875,
1.013541340827942,
0.8737144470214844,
0.4422464668750763,
0.34391915798187256,
0.5021696090698242,
0.08729824423789978,
0.10755540430545807,
0.5659056305885315,
1.0890817642211914,
-0.3566896319389343,
0.2243627905845642,
-0.3926357924938202,
-0.16824397444725037,
-0.48795226216316223,
-0.9889796376228333,
-1.0161043405532837,
-0.862310528755188,
-0.6631189584732056,
-0.7435476183891296,
-0.035517022013664246,
1.3118373155593872,
0.4438968896865845,
-0.8391541838645935,
-0.2412034422159195,
0.423690527677536,
-0.01850072480738163,
-0.18011340498924255,
-0.17049680650234222,
0.2797960042953491,
-0.5517521500587463,
-0.6149318218231201,
0.03926362469792366,
0.2767239809036255,
0.17068882286548615,
-0.26665768027305603,
-0.05136289447546005,
-0.3546498119831085,
0.27872973680496216,
0.6381136178970337,
0.032481081783771515,
-0.894980251789093,
-0.2129303216934204,
-0.07935315370559692,
-0.6009191870689392,
-0.22591722011566162,
1.1163907051086426,
-0.5528977513313293,
0.3079390525817871,
0.5507993698120117,
0.7937101721763611,
0.49346593022346497,
-0.067689448595047,
0.35535579919815063,
-0.44750985503196716,
0.1597951352596283,
0.6053107976913452,
0.502501368522644,
0.5383517146110535,
-0.43319618701934814,
0.7766493558883667,
0.47398045659065247,
-0.7147307395935059,
-0.7317032814025879,
0.3977915048599243,
-1.0916849374771118,
-0.2568167448043823,
1.3008636236190796,
-0.22202181816101074,
-0.32635316252708435,
-0.09502013027667999,
-0.6817291975021362,
0.17119787633419037,
-0.15753857791423798,
0.1834689825773239,
0.9033109545707703,
-0.3073154091835022,
-0.42420777678489685,
-0.325486958026886,
0.4459037780761719,
0.5196844935417175,
-0.48381128907203674,
-0.09789088368415833,
0.7794064879417419,
0.2083899974822998,
0.30823320150375366,
0.6210885047912598,
-0.1501964032649994,
0.13932432234287262,
0.003364522010087967,
0.6991823315620422,
-0.16458208858966827,
-0.002678622491657734,
-0.21884529292583466,
0.3127061128616333,
0.46961262822151184,
0.041069090366363525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17919v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17919v3 | LOCOST: State-Space Models for Long Document Abstractive Summarization | 2024-01-31T15:33:37 | 2024-03-25T12:52:42 | Florian Le Bronnec, Song Duong, Mathieu Ravaut, Alexandre Allauzen, Nancy F. Chen, Vincent Guigue, Alberto Lumbreras, Laure Soulier, Patrick Gallinari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | State-space models are a low-complexity alternative to transformers for
encoding long sequences and capturing long-term dependencies. We propose
LOCOST: an encoder-decoder architecture based on state-space models for
conditional text generation with long context inputs. With a computational
complexity of $O(L \log L)$, this architecture can handle significantly longer
sequences than state-of-the-art models that are based on sparse attention
patterns. We evaluate our model on a series of long document abstractive
summarization tasks. The model reaches a performance level that is 93-96%
comparable to the top-performing sparse transformers of the same size while
saving up to 50% memory during training and up to 87% during inference.
Additionally, LOCOST effectively handles input texts exceeding 600K tokens at
inference time, setting new state-of-the-art results on full-book summarization
and opening new perspectives for long input processing. | [
-0.10639157891273499,
-0.40263450145721436,
0.7631717324256897,
0.31071457266807556,
-0.49408650398254395,
-0.4380570948123932,
-0.1889333426952362,
-0.2944754660129547,
0.422365665435791,
0.2984810471534729,
-0.4740617275238037,
-0.4252152442932129,
-0.6114948987960815,
0.280322402715683,
-0.8728308081626892,
1.2452510595321655,
0.0215537678450346,
-0.3483901917934418,
-0.4664115905761719,
0.03884235396981239,
-0.4198054075241089,
-0.510516345500946,
-0.5129978060722351,
-0.007470608688890934,
0.5014161467552185,
-0.20240075886249542,
0.46640515327453613,
0.5754227042198181,
0.36459335684776306,
0.3359319269657135,
-0.26562273502349854,
0.15159720182418823,
-0.48877716064453125,
0.33751121163368225,
-0.20928089320659637,
-0.2903860807418823,
-0.9378442764282227,
-0.48032116889953613,
0.6773748397827148,
0.47753894329071045,
-0.047525983303785324,
-0.05010164901614189,
0.1486925631761551,
0.7320320010185242,
-0.811443030834198,
0.3189399242401123,
-0.048122379928827286,
-0.09435396641492844,
0.2910408675670624,
0.026047367602586746,
-0.5701009035110474,
-0.2622818648815155,
-0.10134518891572952,
-0.6005023717880249,
0.23902685940265656,
-0.1661788523197174,
0.7541881799697876,
0.545511782169342,
-0.7383067011833191,
-0.34476175904273987,
-0.8757159113883972,
0.4196692407131195,
-0.6768182516098022,
0.6061745285987854,
0.40759024024009705,
0.15579885244369507,
-0.17453232407569885,
-1.0719325542449951,
-0.47215181589126587,
-0.03168056905269623,
-0.3892458379268646,
0.5214772820472717,
-0.12767262756824493,
0.25147902965545654,
0.2145511507987976,
0.35035261511802673,
-0.6940885186195374,
-0.32722869515419006,
-0.5750353932380676,
-0.08035779744386673,
0.4911656379699707,
0.5168340802192688,
-0.0652998760342598,
-0.44374221563339233,
-0.39397159218788147,
0.1083524227142334,
-0.5153530240058899,
0.0651283785700798,
0.2191450148820877,
0.0037704927381128073,
-0.23050248622894287,
0.611863911151886,
-0.3256780207157135,
0.7869610786437988,
0.2800978422164917,
0.0681443065404892,
-0.27096471190452576,
-0.46336129307746887,
-0.31728482246398926,
0.03866365924477577,
0.8899304866790771,
0.26968008279800415,
-0.32082322239875793,
-0.22328664362430573,
-0.5486770868301392,
0.14127571880817413,
0.30660611391067505,
-1.1778628826141357,
-0.07333068549633026,
0.3708915710449219,
-0.3823290169239044,
0.010675054043531418,
-0.013476655818521976,
-0.871851921081543,
-0.5060481429100037,
-0.22002899646759033,
0.36394596099853516,
-0.6566106081008911,
0.17852692306041718,
0.5403873920440674,
-0.3327866196632385,
0.23579943180084229,
0.41428110003471375,
-0.9092935919761658,
0.5389325618743896,
0.882727324962616,
1.1300915479660034,
-0.4415648281574249,
0.002976209856569767,
-0.49692773818969727,
0.14750798046588898,
-0.2200276255607605,
0.7026039361953735,
-0.2174178659915924,
-0.5756362676620483,
0.0003965010109823197,
0.10615606606006622,
0.05089541897177696,
0.009584255516529083,
0.5683088302612305,
-0.7310807108879089,
0.12860846519470215,
-0.03173286095261574,
-0.6752687692642212,
0.026422441005706787,
0.36985865235328674,
-0.933090329170227,
0.9837142825126648,
0.17156152427196503,
-0.7075888514518738,
0.32223084568977356,
-0.693343460559845,
-0.870770275592804,
-0.17130392789840698,
0.01800406165421009,
-0.4530695378780365,
-0.05268824100494385,
0.19182108342647552,
0.4714171886444092,
-0.08905256539583206,
0.39677831530570984,
0.04563683643937111,
-0.3595300614833832,
-0.030254801735281944,
-0.33102717995643616,
0.3247952461242676,
0.25588124990463257,
-0.11718655377626419,
0.21922187507152557,
-1.0118114948272705,
-0.5113829970359802,
-0.1939898133277893,
-0.7207438945770264,
-0.5935659408569336,
0.3564969003200531,
-0.07161334156990051,
0.18074168264865875,
0.6233667135238647,
-0.583518922328949,
0.3100171685218811,
-0.6398471593856812,
0.6518818736076355,
0.49630317091941833,
0.028752848505973816,
0.8398788571357727,
-0.10713789612054825,
0.633446455001831,
0.15298593044281006,
-0.003728769486770034,
-0.8254566788673401,
-0.08485976606607437,
-0.9524916410446167,
-0.49694129824638367,
0.26976972818374634,
0.36990785598754883,
-0.7925507426261902,
0.6943080425262451,
-0.835740864276886,
-0.15350261330604553,
-0.05572722479701042,
-0.3729274868965149,
0.21087391674518585,
0.4568583071231842,
0.30634573101997375,
-0.08211924880743027,
-0.694462239742279,
-0.9500415325164795,
0.0000179214130184846,
0.08763985335826874,
-0.15734706819057465,
-0.22796854376792908,
0.8963857293128967,
-0.19494588673114777,
1.1595741510391235,
-0.4910891354084015,
0.009470853954553604,
-0.3839428424835205,
0.0008014378254301846,
0.4895119369029999,
0.3099239468574524,
0.2854333519935608,
-0.7471674680709839,
-0.2780328691005707,
-0.02665315568447113,
-0.6501497030258179,
0.40495482087135315,
-0.161185160279274,
-0.12570782005786896,
0.30153053998947144,
0.7217505574226379,
-1.1312094926834106,
0.7596669793128967,
0.6404598355293274,
-0.6164510250091553,
0.1503199189901352,
-0.43258222937583923,
0.08954809606075287,
-1.4899396896362305,
0.1824459284543991,
-0.2646064758300781,
-0.5668027997016907,
-0.47794878482818604,
0.02764086425304413,
0.4399840533733368,
-0.5461629629135132,
-0.35595643520355225,
0.6925204396247864,
-0.6601425409317017,
-0.09801624715328217,
-0.2808435559272766,
-0.040161777287721634,
0.19456762075424194,
0.7140123844146729,
0.2976553738117218,
0.708483874797821,
0.08756829053163528,
-0.8717315196990967,
0.12668322026729584,
0.17244499921798706,
-0.42143645882606506,
0.18785947561264038,
-0.7710396647453308,
0.11118590831756592,
-0.4257907271385193,
0.7571121454238892,
-1.0127285718917847,
-0.3709771931171417,
0.03484325110912323,
-0.29509425163269043,
0.2616417407989502,
-0.24004089832305908,
-0.3999665379524231,
-0.3452863395214081,
-0.24727481603622437,
0.5615624785423279,
0.6845560073852539,
-0.42356428503990173,
1.029020071029663,
0.09414923191070557,
-0.2122415453195572,
-0.6041837930679321,
-0.531778872013092,
-0.017558421939611435,
0.0011057802475988865,
-0.5975599884986877,
0.22727617621421814,
0.2803662121295929,
0.17781463265419006,
0.10163634270429611,
-0.14142365753650665,
0.011010206304490566,
-0.2834213972091675,
0.56291264295578,
0.20911456644535065,
-0.294394314289093,
0.12065580487251282,
0.3672218918800354,
-0.13685521483421326,
0.04404940456151962,
-0.596470296382904,
0.559173047542572,
-0.1742871105670929,
-0.14875425398349762,
-0.03880231827497482,
0.5492457151412964,
0.775877833366394,
-0.36503535509109497,
0.5511665940284729,
0.0741928219795227,
-0.4007210433483124,
-0.3353988528251648,
0.07890100032091141,
0.036518555134534836,
-0.5150560140609741,
0.7994034290313721,
-0.26457980275154114,
-0.7990710139274597,
0.5406863689422607,
0.10319937765598297,
0.3428877592086792,
0.5902124047279358,
0.6613630056381226,
-0.08868467062711716,
0.7640222311019897,
0.7877237200737,
-0.15981681644916534,
0.3525565266609192,
-0.3353792726993561,
0.36650222539901733,
-0.6040036082267761,
-0.19763901829719543,
-0.2209235578775406,
-0.30208486318588257,
-0.2662089169025421,
-0.7029348015785217,
0.4495227336883545,
-0.2709205150604248,
-0.13226418197155,
0.40305349230766296,
-0.4475928843021393,
0.5387662649154663,
0.17898915708065033,
0.04788261279463768,
0.14743515849113464,
-0.3506316542625427,
0.2363174855709076,
0.30951330065727234,
-0.8157178163528442,
-0.2301175445318222,
0.8623408675193787,
0.23487618565559387,
1.134326457977295,
0.09919341653585434,
0.7653154730796814,
0.35245445370674133,
0.15674042701721191,
-1.23306405544281,
0.6944990754127502,
-0.20047158002853394,
-0.5352580547332764,
-0.6584639549255371,
0.03373314440250397,
-1.2148139476776123,
0.23393391072750092,
-0.08025463670492172,
-0.3188023567199707,
0.437518447637558,
0.2988051772117615,
-0.5906518697738647,
0.20011396706104279,
-0.30330130457878113,
0.5934659242630005,
-0.008730798028409481,
-0.3197495639324188,
-0.07149965316057205,
-0.6375343203544617,
0.5557222962379456,
0.03888814151287079,
0.057422611862421036,
0.4486488997936249,
-0.3154887557029724,
0.6902536153793335,
-0.6302726864814758,
0.8666841983795166,
0.17054571211338043,
-0.2575937807559967,
0.4014134109020233,
0.21075278520584106,
0.8022506237030029,
0.04793693125247955,
-0.09582257270812988,
-0.1313725858926773,
-0.059847794473171234,
-0.11370719969272614,
-0.7861573696136475,
0.48534873127937317,
-0.4871428310871124,
-0.32587388157844543,
-0.5417951941490173,
-0.5866068005561829,
0.021579507738351822,
0.3137335181236267,
0.5566365718841553,
0.6580061912536621,
-0.38712504506111145,
0.2433796525001526,
0.8463818430900574,
-0.08705418556928635,
0.5714550018310547,
0.25869905948638916,
-0.14898048341274261,
-0.4513082504272461,
0.721449077129364,
-0.21251307427883148,
-0.033991578966379166,
0.759387731552124,
-0.1493951827287674,
-0.4167616069316864,
-0.15495552122592926,
-0.42269763350486755,
0.16127519309520721,
-0.9058294892311096,
-0.25344473123550415,
-0.8677284717559814,
-0.38628315925598145,
-0.4454670250415802,
-0.2653316557407379,
-0.6031334400177002,
-0.5831500291824341,
-0.3137645423412323,
-0.1428571343421936,
0.18886595964431763,
0.8299776911735535,
0.15267165005207062,
0.3171228766441345,
-0.8540704846382141,
0.6148000359535217,
0.29412558674812317,
0.2900255024433136,
-0.049634870141744614,
-0.636955976486206,
-0.731743574142456,
-0.3025232255458832,
-0.1219785138964653,
-0.8417069315910339,
0.5899302959442139,
0.03590264916419983,
0.020246848464012146,
0.3156391680240631,
0.03679662570357323,
0.6011262536048889,
-0.8562111854553223,
0.8779944777488708,
0.310371994972229,
-0.8059386014938354,
0.33606719970703125,
-0.5739400386810303,
0.6126224398612976,
0.36902332305908203,
0.31906312704086304,
-0.5421521663665771,
-0.44036218523979187,
-0.31850504875183105,
-1.0403004884719849,
0.6192591190338135,
0.09496814012527466,
0.11439613252878189,
-0.19299277663230896,
0.32656532526016235,
0.1413370966911316,
-0.025987934321165085,
-0.6494635343551636,
0.07878227531909943,
-0.44982093572616577,
-0.32890191674232483,
-0.27189531922340393,
-0.44456642866134644,
0.08628102391958237,
-0.19362236559391022,
0.4111206829547882,
0.11245789378881454,
0.5239061117172241,
0.36977919936180115,
-0.22924508154392242,
0.20815332233905792,
0.5179028511047363,
0.930518388748169,
0.5156752467155457,
-0.13590678572654724,
0.1829344630241394,
0.13864974677562714,
-0.5444956421852112,
0.26062247157096863,
0.00008559085108572617,
-0.29321444034576416,
0.2976413667201996,
0.3774115741252899,
0.9349111914634705,
0.4658508002758026,
-0.4405142366886139,
0.7859211564064026,
-0.17146742343902588,
-0.44363588094711304,
-0.5228913426399231,
-0.025675781071186066,
0.23726336658000946,
-0.022735711187124252,
0.09134950488805771,
-0.05792234092950821,
0.5198938250541687,
-0.24380283057689667,
0.19587194919586182,
0.04660726338624954,
-0.3345150649547577,
-0.5812556743621826,
1.0216064453125,
0.48322755098342896,
-0.13592450320720673,
0.5397634506225586,
-0.1206253170967102,
-0.3713461458683014,
0.8186704516410828,
0.6103761196136475,
1.0170083045959473,
0.04157271236181259,
-0.18403556942939758,
0.6177933216094971,
0.23638169467449188,
-0.2576712965965271,
0.111524797976017,
-0.30628854036331177,
-0.24579527974128723,
-0.7490336894989014,
-0.882723331451416,
-0.15791434049606323,
0.22558237612247467,
-0.778481125831604,
0.4652281403541565,
-0.3059518039226532,
-0.21399877965450287,
-0.3708854019641876,
-0.6645447611808777,
-0.423238605260849,
0.1849086731672287,
0.1655304729938507,
1.027994155883789,
-0.7538335919380188,
0.8365156054496765,
0.6313368082046509,
-0.06530601531267166,
-0.4439454972743988,
-0.2621413767337799,
-0.40521374344825745,
-0.22255770862102509,
0.8157070875167847,
-0.05523601546883583,
-0.3978913128376007,
-0.1954166293144226,
-0.35359078645706177,
-0.9409295916557312,
1.0491764545440674,
0.1745494306087494,
-0.8067325353622437,
-0.4523336589336395,
-0.054194364696741104,
0.6205256581306458,
-0.05051804333925247,
-0.0769716426730156,
0.49380043148994446,
0.24378728866577148,
-0.08306477218866348,
-0.6164146661758423,
-0.002833978272974491,
-0.3649079203605652,
-0.06175548955798149,
0.7259719967842102,
-0.6743367314338684,
1.1050031185150146,
-0.1619364470243454,
-0.36853358149528503,
0.38555908203125,
1.1737985610961914,
0.0930624008178711,
0.33726751804351807,
0.4006221294403076,
0.48864084482192993,
0.34545835852622986,
0.1651352345943451,
1.302474856376648,
-0.46689993143081665,
0.35097160935401917,
1.1759734153747559,
-0.029437405988574028,
0.8019179701805115,
0.3414175808429718,
-0.03649815917015076,
0.5831417441368103,
0.44458505511283875,
0.22855758666992188,
0.6857083439826965,
-0.011818503960967064,
-0.230362206697464,
-0.28975483775138855,
0.6370061039924622,
-0.16136500239372253,
0.3096795678138733,
0.4486938714981079,
-0.40170663595199585,
-0.3188318908214569,
0.013327434659004211,
-0.003535452065989375,
-0.09892097860574722,
-0.4627143144607544,
0.7031047344207764,
0.17783863842487335,
-0.956940233707428,
0.42832469940185547,
0.3055437505245209,
0.7481960654258728,
-0.7288331985473633,
-0.1862708330154419,
-0.46727636456489563,
0.17898043990135193,
-0.15487098693847656,
-0.6134212613105774,
0.10916467756032944,
0.17945700883865356,
-0.5326809883117676,
-0.2258964329957962,
0.7570307850837708,
-0.5214345455169678,
-0.5366795659065247,
-0.005156315863132477,
-0.0023222421295940876,
0.12397310137748718,
0.2131611406803131,
-0.0027275527827441692,
-0.36708101630210876,
-0.280692458152771,
-0.4994332790374756,
0.29380807280540466,
0.497546523809433,
-0.3367915451526642,
0.6092243194580078,
0.3717486560344696,
0.017302168533205986,
0.28544342517852783,
-0.16181780397891998,
0.8960228562355042,
-0.8667611479759216,
-1.186404824256897,
-0.9105615019798279,
0.6687331199645996,
0.09268616884946823,
-0.20397117733955383,
0.566416323184967,
0.9900039434432983,
0.2841901183128357,
-0.39820989966392517,
0.8908665180206299,
-0.23591646552085876,
0.18252436816692352,
-0.681151270866394,
0.7543728351593018,
-0.5574867129325867,
-0.03662460297346115,
0.12789730727672577,
-0.646134614944458,
0.012372166849672794,
0.2989689111709595,
-0.3091050386428833,
-0.038173858076334,
0.8533867001533508,
0.5485103726387024,
-0.28252488374710083,
-0.1562214195728302,
0.4097413420677185,
0.055205218493938446,
0.3508748710155487,
0.8690636157989502,
1.0582901239395142,
-0.5251010060310364,
0.6284809708595276,
0.006728098727762699,
0.09878064692020416,
-0.25984418392181396,
-0.8889046907424927,
-0.9865865707397461,
-0.7413250803947449,
0.16647601127624512,
-0.3373613953590393,
0.11665181815624237,
0.5316124558448792,
0.5756243467330933,
-0.5522539615631104,
-0.11818233132362366,
-0.006664242595434189,
-0.020396636798977852,
0.20463916659355164,
-0.17686696350574493,
0.6753525733947754,
-0.22184370458126068,
-0.8803275227546692,
0.42308294773101807,
0.47066178917884827,
-0.06854601949453354,
-0.07365494966506958,
-0.2579371929168701,
0.2689986526966095,
0.25179606676101685,
1.1175819635391235,
0.4607287049293518,
-0.4883519411087036,
-0.15859584510326385,
0.05385599657893181,
-0.4204965829849243,
-0.012040761299431324,
1.0515552759170532,
-0.8555168509483337,
0.29626214504241943,
0.6796777844429016,
0.5654215812683105,
0.8581005334854126,
0.24472397565841675,
0.6206337213516235,
-0.6451375484466553,
0.5772911906242371,
0.39996835589408875,
0.5168546438217163,
-0.1212003231048584,
-0.4997386634349823,
0.3437653183937073,
-0.21291442215442657,
-0.5495789051055908,
-0.5909081697463989,
0.04187312722206116,
-1.2282689809799194,
-0.33218124508857727,
1.3281025886535645,
0.025317996740341187,
-0.588440477848053,
0.11523231118917465,
-0.06315112113952637,
0.3388136029243469,
-0.48308733105659485,
0.6124984622001648,
0.5604987144470215,
-0.18249645829200745,
0.025123190134763718,
-0.32390812039375305,
0.5395433306694031,
0.10867380350828171,
-0.8724982738494873,
0.13438351452350616,
0.8237180709838867,
0.23151139914989471,
0.11864696443080902,
0.8491398692131042,
-0.13996686041355133,
0.6670249700546265,
0.19393466413021088,
0.2332693189382553,
-0.27425408363342285,
-0.4610917866230011,
-0.5166661739349365,
0.14446619153022766,
-0.33478379249572754,
-0.20266523957252502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17911v1 | SNNLP: Energy-Efficient Natural Language Processing Using Spiking Neural Networks | 2024-01-31T15:16:25 | 2024-01-31T15:16:25 | R. Alexander Knipper, Kaniz Mishty, Mehdi Sadi, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As spiking neural networks receive more attention, we look toward
applications of this computing paradigm in fields other than computer vision
and signal processing. One major field, underexplored in the neuromorphic
setting, is Natural Language Processing (NLP), where most state-of-the-art
solutions still heavily rely on resource-consuming and power-hungry traditional
deep learning architectures. Therefore, it is compelling to design NLP models
for neuromorphic architectures due to their low energy requirements, with the
additional benefit of a more human-brain-like operating model for processing
information. However, one of the biggest issues with bringing NLP to the
neuromorphic setting is in properly encoding text into a spike train so that it
can be seamlessly handled by both current and future SNN architectures. In this
paper, we compare various methods of encoding text as spikes and assess each
method's performance in an associated SNN on a downstream NLP task, namely,
sentiment analysis. Furthermore, we go on to propose a new method of encoding
text as spikes that outperforms a widely-used rate-coding technique, Poisson
rate-coding, by around 13\% on our benchmark NLP tasks. Subsequently, we
demonstrate the energy efficiency of SNNs implemented in hardware for the
sentiment analysis task compared to traditional deep neural networks, observing
an energy efficiency increase of more than 32x during inference and 60x during
training while incurring the expected energy-performance tradeoff. | [
-0.08548597246408463,
-0.5715382695198059,
0.25574713945388794,
0.5141796469688416,
-0.26170632243156433,
0.05136984959244728,
-0.46464112401008606,
-0.341423898935318,
0.6597410440444946,
0.07416152954101562,
-0.2530403435230255,
-0.20397475361824036,
-0.643064558506012,
0.07702420651912689,
-0.31022265553474426,
1.093605399131775,
0.3418903052806854,
0.10256211459636688,
-0.24439822137355804,
0.1560465544462204,
0.1812991052865982,
-0.5839634537696838,
-0.9388113021850586,
-0.49382010102272034,
0.6047627925872803,
-0.16943278908729553,
0.5534960031509399,
0.6141172647476196,
0.5785154104232788,
0.1423899531364441,
-0.4468744993209839,
0.09298018366098404,
-0.22812527418136597,
0.2280733734369278,
0.08043397217988968,
-0.07884997129440308,
-0.41127046942710876,
-0.3095877766609192,
0.5033514499664307,
0.48307567834854126,
-0.4078841209411621,
0.050393473356962204,
-0.06909793615341187,
0.7232668995857239,
-0.7178842425346375,
-0.0893513485789299,
-0.7963411211967468,
0.634601354598999,
-0.2002156376838684,
-0.4599156677722931,
-0.474222868680954,
-0.302070289850235,
0.046653732657432556,
-0.1990385353565216,
0.26609790325164795,
-0.04162823036313057,
0.7321366667747498,
0.2878986895084381,
-0.021343277767300606,
-0.323299765586853,
-0.31396928429603577,
0.5245276093482971,
-0.9687861800193787,
0.24236463010311127,
0.24996590614318848,
-0.09502770751714706,
-0.08037831634283066,
-0.6812641620635986,
-0.5759398937225342,
-0.15004342794418335,
0.18409620225429535,
0.2895980179309845,
-0.38924527168273926,
0.18892401456832886,
0.3167574405670166,
0.645851194858551,
-0.42607173323631287,
0.1662565916776657,
0.032965537160634995,
-0.01822013035416603,
0.6681861877441406,
0.03194315358996391,
0.1307183802127838,
-0.5344431400299072,
-0.4754185676574707,
0.21892611682415009,
-0.26792073249816895,
-0.01749323308467865,
0.5340386033058167,
0.5684630870819092,
0.256845623254776,
0.45083513855934143,
-0.0642571896314621,
0.5598111748695374,
0.08503975719213486,
0.2488035410642624,
0.38347533345222473,
-0.10125941783189774,
-0.3403955399990082,
0.446037620306015,
0.9580707550048828,
0.6814215779304504,
0.05623657628893852,
-0.41591739654541016,
-0.14435724914073944,
0.10300091654062271,
0.6092721819877625,
-1.001485824584961,
-0.2767044007778168,
0.19745269417762756,
-0.6090806722640991,
-0.41626062989234924,
-0.7213101983070374,
-0.9417589902877808,
-0.714083194732666,
0.07611660659313202,
0.3652207851409912,
-0.6413843035697937,
-0.6785478591918945,
0.6805978417396545,
-0.37604087591171265,
-0.2732311189174652,
0.03159958869218826,
-1.364284634590149,
0.420101135969162,
0.6835780739784241,
1.249983310699463,
-0.25243017077445984,
-0.21960771083831787,
-0.300576388835907,
-0.4183698296546936,
-0.10092046856880188,
0.6668694615364075,
-0.3342002332210541,
-0.04628309980034828,
0.11384821683168411,
-0.5916209816932678,
-0.13466861844062805,
-0.22066360712051392,
0.4928017258644104,
-0.3213651180267334,
-0.27109193801879883,
0.011037503369152546,
-0.6384365558624268,
0.01979472115635872,
0.20693469047546387,
-0.6693189144134521,
1.339889645576477,
-0.3847290277481079,
-1.0062096118927002,
0.25337788462638855,
-0.688450813293457,
-0.7656465172767639,
0.02633940428495407,
-0.09066043794155121,
-0.3089647591114044,
0.5867099761962891,
0.008754540234804153,
0.773675262928009,
-0.3437146246433258,
0.2564188539981842,
0.2785157859325409,
-0.19532254338264465,
0.12119697034358978,
-0.6993405818939209,
0.7312198877334595,
0.18721038103103638,
-0.6670824885368347,
0.012703439220786095,
-0.7998549938201904,
-0.24581781029701233,
0.20434120297431946,
-0.4874582290649414,
-0.12635380029678345,
0.28033584356307983,
-0.014758740551769733,
0.05408826097846031,
0.2831445038318634,
-0.8368945121765137,
0.12736603617668152,
-0.6169674396514893,
0.5227058529853821,
0.6920180916786194,
-0.16829146444797516,
0.6122216582298279,
0.029930666089057922,
0.16647636890411377,
-0.027967533096671104,
-0.04802151769399643,
0.020992068573832512,
-0.6207947731018066,
-0.9435749650001526,
0.18208341300487518,
0.00047851793351583183,
0.2979816198348999,
-0.9130904078483582,
0.5545805096626282,
-0.24581559002399445,
-0.7573640942573547,
-0.560452938079834,
-0.17004388570785522,
0.09796493500471115,
0.6338865160942078,
0.5338184237480164,
-0.2593314051628113,
-0.3727920651435852,
-0.7369560599327087,
-0.716357946395874,
0.24632330238819122,
0.027697458863258362,
0.2151843011379242,
0.19466140866279602,
0.17146874964237213,
0.6726415753364563,
-0.19816528260707855,
0.29116517305374146,
-0.5386391282081604,
0.28710535168647766,
0.483148992061615,
0.5539629459381104,
0.4025743901729584,
-0.5666236281394958,
-0.30831870436668396,
0.0326014943420887,
-0.5865803360939026,
0.15166594088077545,
-0.2927650213241577,
0.0204559825360775,
0.14434269070625305,
0.2616629898548126,
-0.8687902688980103,
0.7425599098205566,
0.34608131647109985,
-0.08941679447889328,
0.6659759283065796,
-0.2391301691532135,
0.012161361053586006,
-0.776382565498352,
-0.13291223347187042,
0.27009519934654236,
0.1323341429233551,
-1.1447575092315674,
-0.1922031193971634,
0.10150086134672165,
-0.20521685481071472,
-0.43069547414779663,
0.02213309332728386,
-0.3740607798099518,
0.0201590433716774,
-0.35450416803359985,
-0.05565493926405907,
-0.008330599404871464,
0.6012671589851379,
0.27761411666870117,
0.6086791753768921,
0.8351978659629822,
-0.696202278137207,
0.3394887447357178,
-0.2617133557796478,
-0.30142295360565186,
0.2888752222061157,
-0.3938692808151245,
0.33469152450561523,
-0.2915686070919037,
0.06085679680109024,
-0.4428917169570923,
0.17014087736606598,
0.1293526589870453,
-0.5351619720458984,
0.2763993740081787,
0.08445528894662857,
-0.7564939260482788,
-0.057573139667510986,
-0.26127317547798157,
0.25099194049835205,
0.34826773405075073,
-0.6847589612007141,
0.8134173154830933,
0.3251267075538635,
0.2763022780418396,
-0.559732973575592,
-1.0263313055038452,
0.2944489121437073,
-0.16045162081718445,
-0.4761117994785309,
0.4482167959213257,
0.015483462251722813,
0.30764731764793396,
-0.07735887169837952,
-0.3904261291027069,
0.13567551970481873,
0.0725356936454773,
0.10202604532241821,
-0.020551275461912155,
-0.29473453760147095,
0.47978875041007996,
-0.1396028995513916,
-0.1959548145532608,
0.2689344882965088,
-0.2587284445762634,
0.927933394908905,
-0.17159508168697357,
-0.05967528000473976,
-0.703438937664032,
0.3980523943901062,
0.3105755150318146,
-0.14829565584659576,
0.8931822180747986,
0.5373996496200562,
-0.7234089374542236,
-0.3448048532009125,
-0.3297174870967865,
-0.15963216125965118,
-0.4482094943523407,
0.39111578464508057,
-0.23407825827598572,
-0.7326135635375977,
-0.06752999871969223,
-0.20167143642902374,
0.16026851534843445,
0.3026057779788971,
0.4853627383708954,
-0.17954182624816895,
1.016243815422058,
0.465592622756958,
-0.10870809108018875,
0.699862539768219,
-0.07049711793661118,
0.7393739819526672,
-0.8815925717353821,
-0.0014558186521753669,
-0.449269562959671,
-0.5517342686653137,
-0.34100526571273804,
-0.4582405686378479,
-0.04755034297704697,
-0.1521274298429489,
-0.19324855506420135,
0.46381160616874695,
-1.0071465969085693,
0.31813862919807434,
0.4109354019165039,
-0.02577052265405655,
-0.1738152652978897,
0.4368724524974823,
0.07320661842823029,
-0.3504635989665985,
-1.193969964981079,
-0.1592606008052826,
0.8361325263977051,
0.41068035364151,
0.43593499064445496,
-0.3449753224849701,
0.6281177997589111,
0.09028089046478271,
0.1143822893500328,
-1.0547635555267334,
0.6621875166893005,
-0.5676180124282837,
-0.38863545656204224,
0.22107376158237457,
-0.6625396013259888,
-0.6417558789253235,
0.06621713936328888,
-0.5262982249259949,
-1.0031678676605225,
-0.01612160913646221,
0.09387337416410446,
-0.47923076152801514,
1.0175918340682983,
-0.577531635761261,
0.7634278535842896,
-0.3927125930786133,
-0.40971288084983826,
-0.25835713744163513,
-0.3864305317401886,
-0.09672515094280243,
0.592901885509491,
-0.23465633392333984,
-0.13585180044174194,
0.2887428104877472,
0.9509109854698181,
-0.2560194134712219,
0.6611407995223999,
-0.3448106646537781,
0.12628965079784393,
0.018498895689845085,
-0.0890304446220398,
0.3792297840118408,
-0.00454223807901144,
-0.6718083620071411,
0.4902682900428772,
-0.4851563274860382,
-0.24203908443450928,
-0.8019860982894897,
0.6208979487419128,
-0.5140969157218933,
-0.3021264374256134,
-0.8112848997116089,
-0.47440457344055176,
-0.00007193429337348789,
0.13814033567905426,
0.5097488164901733,
0.5520258545875549,
0.13057301938533783,
0.15721845626831055,
0.6594945788383484,
-0.16664646565914154,
0.631757915019989,
-0.21385590732097626,
-0.19323115050792694,
-0.24128197133541107,
1.1570624113082886,
0.24178454279899597,
0.19229760766029358,
0.25094154477119446,
0.2988244891166687,
-0.08619058132171631,
-0.8407254219055176,
-0.534796416759491,
-0.04815569147467613,
-0.4902505874633789,
-0.38859090209007263,
-0.764977753162384,
-0.5794316530227661,
-0.3527739644050598,
-0.27344799041748047,
-0.6901271343231201,
-0.2672625482082367,
-0.44604966044425964,
-0.21381719410419464,
0.6920270919799805,
0.44433820247650146,
-0.13106557726860046,
0.5704807043075562,
-0.41830021142959595,
0.45291009545326233,
0.10423322767019272,
0.3998115360736847,
0.235830619931221,
-0.1803409606218338,
-0.29831254482269287,
-0.13924525678157806,
0.1653994619846344,
-0.8977473378181458,
0.45058760046958923,
0.2810869812965393,
0.24057182669639587,
0.2672726809978485,
-0.16508261859416962,
0.7069770097732544,
-0.7019535899162292,
0.9299175143241882,
0.7730862498283386,
-0.9626704454421997,
0.5299442410469055,
0.1569974422454834,
0.300686240196228,
0.6481110453605652,
0.49753859639167786,
-0.7890013456344604,
0.13496915996074677,
-0.6485770344734192,
-1.1036312580108643,
0.5795376896858215,
0.32836759090423584,
0.3541293144226074,
-0.326927125453949,
0.5329701900482178,
0.0783233493566513,
0.5229072570800781,
-0.6416903138160706,
-0.4788670837879181,
-0.563819169998169,
-0.18948809802532196,
0.034954339265823364,
-0.2440502792596817,
0.1723507046699524,
-0.3334091007709503,
0.6137044429779053,
-0.024168087169528008,
0.5030129551887512,
0.25550028681755066,
-0.041786231100559235,
0.3403332531452179,
0.04593545198440552,
0.24470633268356323,
-0.042775802314281464,
-0.3948245644569397,
0.5934599041938782,
0.2583502531051636,
-0.7934022545814514,
-0.06205272674560547,
-0.12014596164226532,
-0.1989203691482544,
0.3244349956512451,
-0.09074174612760544,
1.2020539045333862,
0.13880927860736847,
-0.2767300605773926,
0.37511587142944336,
-0.4285220503807068,
-0.02649102918803692,
0.007984088733792305,
0.07806842029094696,
0.28941893577575684,
0.024403907358646393,
0.25662848353385925,
0.7462352514266968,
0.20095175504684448,
-0.3408285975456238,
-0.07044494152069092,
0.08222746849060059,
-0.514974057674408,
-0.27625954151153564,
0.26333072781562805,
0.19203411042690277,
-0.925969123840332,
0.6195780634880066,
-0.5891343355178833,
-0.5541872978210449,
0.39984220266342163,
0.8343926668167114,
1.0502349138259888,
0.16617968678474426,
0.10781213641166687,
0.5105236768722534,
0.3622099757194519,
0.031045451760292053,
0.3151153028011322,
-0.3867478668689728,
-0.8500311374664307,
-0.4824972152709961,
-1.0089709758758545,
-0.09834425896406174,
-0.018579645082354546,
-0.6975547075271606,
-0.2232416570186615,
-0.997054398059845,
-0.49510788917541504,
0.08389529585838318,
-0.20711150765419006,
-0.4518822133541107,
0.39675018191337585,
0.36300748586654663,
1.2677356004714966,
-0.6848462224006653,
0.5793125629425049,
0.5947141051292419,
-0.08236604928970337,
-0.44240644574165344,
-0.02446654625236988,
-0.23006246984004974,
-0.3973146975040436,
0.46756285429000854,
0.4302261471748352,
-0.5154069066047668,
0.06753029674291611,
-0.4338272213935852,
-0.6018286943435669,
0.7065696716308594,
0.29075321555137634,
-0.4955701529979706,
0.08916526287794113,
0.08924566954374313,
0.5999656319618225,
-0.3438781499862671,
0.24515970051288605,
0.8833293318748474,
0.11458364874124527,
-0.2409970760345459,
-0.4123663604259491,
-0.059876032173633575,
-0.8601303696632385,
0.010496913455426693,
0.11931534111499786,
-0.49998795986175537,
0.6982734799385071,
0.49390164017677307,
-0.3776112496852875,
-0.24360966682434082,
0.8831207752227783,
0.2685312032699585,
0.37802696228027344,
0.5100191235542297,
0.8212962746620178,
0.8339782357215881,
-0.15133343636989594,
0.931503415107727,
-0.34569498896598816,
0.19076840579509735,
0.7514646649360657,
-0.1973395198583603,
1.0572856664657593,
0.822088897228241,
-0.11602966487407684,
0.37499064207077026,
0.42023903131484985,
0.23420313000679016,
0.38901591300964355,
0.47003841400146484,
-0.6062734127044678,
-0.21556632220745087,
-0.2702167332172394,
-0.27650001645088196,
0.21128949522972107,
0.4469262361526489,
-0.1135919839143753,
-0.02625337429344654,
-0.005576238967478275,
0.23686158657073975,
0.08971688151359558,
-0.5581973791122437,
0.5488916039466858,
0.11061681061983109,
-0.2849779725074768,
0.2062956988811493,
-0.18086396157741547,
1.4173109531402588,
-0.645568311214447,
0.28688257932662964,
-0.08619894832372665,
-0.09452390670776367,
-0.5297181606292725,
-0.6517719626426697,
0.42393141984939575,
0.4055292308330536,
-0.34067782759666443,
-0.6024345755577087,
0.9590247273445129,
0.1077403575181961,
-0.5527825355529785,
0.29136595129966736,
-0.1115969568490982,
0.4191043972969055,
-0.08671248704195023,
-0.7066088914871216,
0.02695354074239731,
-0.12583616375923157,
-0.3100283741950989,
0.2327432781457901,
0.2924785614013672,
0.6432445049285889,
0.44653522968292236,
0.8204079270362854,
0.8138718605041504,
0.4416808485984802,
0.3054722845554352,
0.770810067653656,
-0.8166643977165222,
-0.657939612865448,
-0.8492276072502136,
0.596225380897522,
-0.5430691838264465,
-0.7143014669418335,
0.8946716785430908,
0.5524510741233826,
0.33134087920188904,
0.16857866942882538,
0.6748632192611694,
-0.2394571304321289,
0.16049616038799286,
-0.532127320766449,
1.0634580850601196,
-0.5183053612709045,
-0.10588772594928741,
-0.057042401283979416,
-0.611649751663208,
-0.575646698474884,
0.9517534375190735,
-0.3466338813304901,
-0.1769908219575882,
0.7694907784461975,
0.614119827747345,
0.037355393171310425,
0.4334344267845154,
0.0023134518414735794,
0.129354327917099,
0.17806433141231537,
0.5037835836410522,
0.7638053894042969,
-0.5248942971229553,
0.15216991305351257,
-0.5855185985565186,
0.009029136970639229,
-0.2642917335033417,
-1.1671913862228394,
-0.7575063109397888,
-0.321559339761734,
-0.3445354700088501,
-0.3231659531593323,
-0.03757297620177269,
0.875821053981781,
0.611311137676239,
-0.6326570510864258,
-0.21409089863300323,
-0.5936248898506165,
-0.049621693789958954,
-0.4051109552383423,
-0.18401767313480377,
0.5161466002464294,
-0.47437015175819397,
-0.5954200029373169,
0.7056195735931396,
0.8148267269134521,
-0.41109147667884827,
-0.20775580406188965,
0.0899350568652153,
-0.5593665242195129,
0.042951442301273346,
0.5427074432373047,
0.08230657130479813,
-0.12770169973373413,
-0.16756479442119598,
0.15304377675056458,
-0.08167175948619843,
0.5171312093734741,
0.9044294357299805,
-0.5779880285263062,
0.6235671639442444,
0.8089298009872437,
1.060981035232544,
0.7717717885971069,
-0.35962820053100586,
0.2834823429584503,
-0.7293744683265686,
0.14607293903827667,
0.6590818762779236,
0.32130706310272217,
0.5205118060112,
-0.37457960844039917,
0.019432073459029198,
0.12235500663518906,
-0.6203640103340149,
-0.8041277527809143,
0.199113667011261,
-0.9432454705238342,
-0.029668742790818214,
0.9400466084480286,
0.015228457748889923,
-0.7902506589889526,
0.126058429479599,
-0.16342207789421082,
0.4297839403152466,
-0.42643865942955017,
0.7914119958877563,
0.34783849120140076,
-0.42208507657051086,
-0.22145859897136688,
-0.695135772228241,
0.79544597864151,
0.8772662878036499,
-0.6500647664070129,
0.024291280657052994,
0.003458669176325202,
-0.1656743437051773,
0.5019831657409668,
0.5710575580596924,
0.40597355365753174,
0.26109230518341064,
0.49839580059051514,
0.2944718897342682,
0.15645816922187805,
-0.32159316539764404,
-0.6742374300956726,
0.42108967900276184,
-0.3493756651878357,
-0.24377022683620453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17902v1 | Revisiting speech segmentation and lexicon learning with better features | 2024-01-31T15:06:34 | 2024-01-31T15:06:34 | Herman Kamper, Benjamin van Niekerk | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We revisit a self-supervised method that segments unlabelled speech into
word-like segments. We start from the two-stage duration-penalised dynamic
programming method that performs zero-resource segmentation without learning an
explicit lexicon. In the first acoustic unit discovery stage, we replace
contrastive predictive coding features with HuBERT. After word segmentation in
the second stage, we get an acoustic word embedding for each segment by
averaging HuBERT features. These embeddings are clustered using K-means to get
a lexicon. The result is good full-coverage segmentation with a lexicon that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ZeroSpeech benchmarks. | [
-0.6056665778160095,
-0.5094063878059387,
0.4709191918373108,
-0.026691682636737823,
-0.406910240650177,
0.4297582805156708,
-0.1645534783601761,
-0.5707923173904419,
0.7331375479698181,
0.5050652623176575,
-0.6729247570037842,
-0.38745418190956116,
-0.37187430262565613,
0.033988360315561295,
-0.5129918456077576,
0.6916379332542419,
0.2464054822921753,
0.05431932210922241,
-0.23648975789546967,
-0.4198639690876007,
-0.33487668633461,
-0.4864380955696106,
-0.43094971776008606,
-0.41220226883888245,
0.4775722324848175,
0.6277998685836792,
0.4747571647167206,
0.9077413082122803,
-0.0652436763048172,
0.2715185284614563,
-0.3862598240375519,
0.0856708213686943,
-0.2192542850971222,
0.16390791535377502,
0.03629497438669205,
-0.017696678638458252,
-0.00528935668990016,
0.19684216380119324,
0.6098989844322205,
0.9125493764877319,
-0.40778815746307373,
-0.15168143808841705,
0.006431888323277235,
0.2639792263507843,
-0.632347047328949,
0.04668545722961426,
-0.6620597839355469,
0.026790054515004158,
-0.16126851737499237,
-0.09763171523809433,
-0.12387330830097198,
-0.07381698489189148,
0.17959478497505188,
-0.45566219091415405,
0.30800992250442505,
-0.22788573801517487,
0.848848819732666,
0.20440587401390076,
-0.12532739341259003,
-0.3581043481826782,
-0.7044106125831604,
1.0498408079147339,
-0.40086138248443604,
0.693625807762146,
0.3120195269584656,
0.11759956926107407,
0.13807009160518646,
-0.8202309012413025,
-0.4128974974155426,
-0.41682198643684387,
0.13696885108947754,
-0.04052364453673363,
0.028841398656368256,
0.09194125980138779,
-0.026533210650086403,
0.4099876284599304,
-0.12129653245210648,
0.3329073488712311,
-0.5537777543067932,
-0.4699665307998657,
0.7614413499832153,
-0.25237342715263367,
-0.07653214037418365,
-0.2428773194551468,
-0.4343358278274536,
-0.28948724269866943,
-0.34520792961120605,
-0.09549686312675476,
0.29785051941871643,
0.35713687539100647,
-0.11832387000322342,
0.25157564878463745,
-0.2729969322681427,
0.39642682671546936,
-0.22792339324951172,
-0.3987920880317688,
0.6646528840065002,
-0.10540788620710373,
0.04683496803045273,
0.6003491878509521,
0.4388003945350647,
-0.1329961121082306,
0.46551787853240967,
-0.10933537781238556,
-0.14842183887958527,
0.10944533348083496,
0.1453324556350708,
-0.42026716470718384,
-0.491810142993927,
0.16289162635803223,
-0.14285825192928314,
-0.2738710343837738,
-0.18527019023895264,
-0.5932522416114807,
-0.03906663507223129,
-0.5670827031135559,
0.27481716871261597,
-0.5526776909828186,
-0.2782936692237854,
0.01049074623733759,
-0.11385077983140945,
0.34792235493659973,
0.21544213593006134,
-0.942233681678772,
0.48036569356918335,
0.6784442663192749,
1.045194387435913,
-0.1494637280702591,
-0.14161095023155212,
-0.3796272873878479,
0.012082341127097607,
-0.5383703112602234,
0.9610402584075928,
-0.5704094171524048,
-0.7089105844497681,
-0.0953277125954628,
-0.07428878545761108,
0.15307599306106567,
-0.6117345690727234,
0.200073704123497,
-0.1743295043706894,
0.24210314452648163,
-0.09588323533535004,
-0.6626119613647461,
-0.224066361784935,
0.11942794173955917,
-0.25465866923332214,
0.9864237904548645,
0.28391823172569275,
-0.4483984112739563,
0.45069029927253723,
-0.5157444477081299,
-0.472543865442276,
0.015422288328409195,
-0.30286020040512085,
-0.4445872902870178,
0.11995580792427063,
0.2489829659461975,
0.20084986090660095,
0.2978183925151825,
-0.024903861805796623,
-0.49155300855636597,
-0.1882733702659607,
0.17588743567466736,
-0.25172480940818787,
0.43162253499031067,
0.3406324088573456,
-0.1812169998884201,
0.19472616910934448,
-1.086655616760254,
0.08226451277732849,
0.013685936108231544,
-0.12033851444721222,
-0.17724724113941193,
0.21352197229862213,
-0.11361487954854965,
0.02516382373869419,
0.1216297373175621,
-0.9391037821769714,
-0.006293852347880602,
-0.5582291483879089,
0.4436928629875183,
0.5592330694198608,
0.11947497725486755,
0.4479960799217224,
0.11248954385519028,
0.32100722193717957,
-0.27542877197265625,
0.1890190988779068,
-0.12074607610702515,
-0.28450807929039,
-0.779765784740448,
-0.38791072368621826,
0.5630934238433838,
0.4837934970855713,
-0.5334123373031616,
0.3922518789768219,
0.17797930538654327,
-0.36949488520622253,
-0.45647838711738586,
0.0607445128262043,
0.35468652844429016,
0.5456976294517517,
0.6096429228782654,
-0.37940672039985657,
-0.5066191554069519,
-1.006514310836792,
0.21438126266002655,
-0.270350843667984,
-0.2524743378162384,
0.3985936939716339,
0.1770741194486618,
-0.12563112378120422,
0.7005868554115295,
-0.8129099011421204,
-0.36689212918281555,
-0.442437082529068,
0.19702941179275513,
0.09036426246166229,
0.41166409850120544,
0.2645436227321625,
-0.48168930411338806,
-0.2789984941482544,
-0.20882324874401093,
-0.3241611123085022,
-0.375017911195755,
0.006383745931088924,
0.1736203283071518,
0.2874845266342163,
0.8994096517562866,
0.021546868607401848,
0.2715500295162201,
0.417229026556015,
-0.03758621960878372,
0.391045480966568,
-0.16592475771903992,
-0.22607621550559998,
-0.9199552536010742,
-0.3100138008594513,
-0.2969338297843933,
-0.17385584115982056,
-0.5325412750244141,
-0.22603438794612885,
-0.09642244875431061,
-0.2383517622947693,
-0.5493183135986328,
0.37082135677337646,
-0.5886865854263306,
-0.254499226808548,
-0.5776169300079346,
0.3503842055797577,
-0.08947542309761047,
0.4518599212169647,
0.14820636808872223,
0.6376171708106995,
0.6238889098167419,
-0.568365752696991,
0.36734986305236816,
0.21057109534740448,
-0.49133023619651794,
0.2703517973423004,
-0.46867451071739197,
0.19622689485549927,
-0.11000552028417587,
-0.09278104454278946,
-1.026463270187378,
-0.05988418683409691,
0.03667832911014557,
-0.5396202206611633,
0.5825058817863464,
0.09930833429098129,
-0.11784595251083374,
-0.3355836570262909,
-0.32346466183662415,
0.30121055245399475,
0.46353474259376526,
-0.4200369417667389,
0.07108701765537262,
0.7840885519981384,
-0.07694918662309647,
-0.27277761697769165,
-0.6592863202095032,
0.10390083491802216,
-0.03570620343089104,
-0.3612091839313507,
0.6620132327079773,
0.33673280477523804,
-0.14975473284721375,
0.037842605262994766,
-0.1892077773809433,
-0.07720576226711273,
0.07732071727514267,
0.1608285903930664,
-0.13491038978099823,
0.03259967640042305,
0.2370862364768982,
-0.09787674993276596,
-0.22078008949756622,
-0.1768144965171814,
-0.22368676960468292,
0.7517097592353821,
0.19085857272148132,
-0.1543482393026352,
-0.3639940321445465,
0.330816388130188,
0.09640494734048843,
-0.3386523425579071,
0.32952508330345154,
0.6794290542602539,
-0.26838067173957825,
-0.33257830142974854,
-0.4901614785194397,
-0.29060280323028564,
-0.45641931891441345,
0.492895245552063,
-0.2350638061761856,
-1.219458818435669,
0.23431022465229034,
-0.05837787687778473,
-0.008209616877138615,
0.4663175046443939,
0.2028864026069641,
-0.21539254486560822,
0.760847270488739,
0.7886573672294617,
-0.12870104610919952,
0.43300729990005493,
-0.36329251527786255,
0.17241425812244415,
-0.9515344500541687,
-0.5371843576431274,
-0.5511131286621094,
-0.3778114914894104,
-0.7360240817070007,
-0.49531856179237366,
0.2612556219100952,
0.26497751474380493,
0.154266819357872,
0.4058583080768585,
-0.6271321177482605,
0.23844099044799805,
0.7163808345794678,
-0.13435141742229462,
-0.2783114016056061,
0.17806890606880188,
-0.4015960097312927,
-0.003928725607693195,
-0.5882956385612488,
0.008395155891776085,
0.7329378724098206,
0.3636142909526825,
0.6529694199562073,
-0.2658967077732086,
1.0756298303604126,
0.38472235202789307,
-0.03790096566081047,
-0.9765453338623047,
0.5409577488899231,
-0.13213834166526794,
-0.43522000312805176,
-0.7040202021598816,
-0.3549993634223938,
-1.0225027799606323,
0.30788537859916687,
-0.184530109167099,
-0.8315449953079224,
0.31713563203811646,
0.11332666873931885,
-0.624459445476532,
0.32570216059684753,
-0.41425299644470215,
0.48139750957489014,
-0.2139042615890503,
-0.05160021036863327,
-0.5504823923110962,
-0.30195462703704834,
0.01735071651637554,
-0.03245652839541435,
0.3158906400203705,
-0.5634892582893372,
-0.1185428574681282,
1.011487364768982,
-0.44356998801231384,
0.5120046138763428,
-0.3973389267921448,
0.023118408396840096,
0.5985077619552612,
0.013499447144567966,
-0.16735795140266418,
0.08856956660747528,
0.16416959464550018,
0.3739240765571594,
0.09381649643182755,
-0.32561931014060974,
-0.3596712350845337,
0.717742919921875,
-0.5264400839805603,
-0.45097675919532776,
-0.5291210412979126,
-0.11021292954683304,
-0.525836706161499,
-0.02972169779241085,
0.08957359939813614,
0.6330238580703735,
-0.28510865569114685,
0.33171358704566956,
0.46444395184516907,
-0.37268713116645813,
0.8145191669464111,
0.5017167329788208,
-0.15037469565868378,
-0.8285195231437683,
0.8434399962425232,
0.2928905487060547,
0.06151171773672104,
0.3343521058559418,
0.46711739897727966,
-0.5068531036376953,
-0.6566066145896912,
-0.21968582272529602,
0.3368849456310272,
-0.22391466796398163,
-0.12721456587314606,
-0.5490418076515198,
-0.5959069132804871,
-0.577472448348999,
-0.06939529627561569,
-0.6943557262420654,
-0.4939410090446472,
-0.4400333762168884,
-0.16999469697475433,
0.14111198484897614,
0.6996700763702393,
-0.6235827803611755,
0.548019289970398,
-0.6285573244094849,
0.326354056596756,
0.5051270723342896,
0.1747097373008728,
-0.07827827334403992,
-0.7234748005867004,
-0.4010080397129059,
-0.2881178855895996,
-0.513180136680603,
-0.7681984305381775,
0.5141110420227051,
0.5002174377441406,
0.5353469848632812,
0.6366870999336243,
-0.25779616832733154,
0.4961490333080292,
-0.7070483565330505,
0.7650727033615112,
0.36487284302711487,
-0.8619757890701294,
0.6691980361938477,
0.05528085306286812,
0.5179924368858337,
0.5093110203742981,
0.3160400092601776,
-0.752765417098999,
-0.01736854389309883,
-0.7482761144638062,
-0.9962018132209778,
0.7933599948883057,
0.16853798925876617,
0.12490640580654144,
-0.25569042563438416,
0.32990196347236633,
-0.09171611815690994,
0.2452256828546524,
-0.20031586289405823,
-0.24644801020622253,
-0.211046040058136,
0.2709309458732605,
-0.13754241168498993,
-0.9156413674354553,
0.058787520974874496,
-0.34900739789009094,
0.7753722667694092,
-0.05479080229997635,
0.19180020689964294,
0.2936665415763855,
0.2525234520435333,
0.08402847498655319,
0.381952166557312,
0.5624202489852905,
0.5523269176483154,
-0.2934671938419342,
-0.01578466221690178,
0.40081918239593506,
-0.3388563096523285,
0.225007563829422,
0.14498461782932281,
-0.05807787925004959,
0.21914441883563995,
0.6466127038002014,
0.8888841271400452,
0.5746688842773438,
-0.2359047383069992,
0.4218759536743164,
0.24421030282974243,
-0.6582458019256592,
-0.5182033777236938,
0.1721496433019638,
0.05922766774892807,
0.10166380554437637,
0.20384293794631958,
-0.38126108050346375,
0.21853064000606537,
-0.5098130106925964,
0.650459349155426,
0.28358885645866394,
-0.6362098455429077,
-0.1668657809495926,
0.3947388529777527,
0.21334625780582428,
-0.2501394748687744,
0.5824000239372253,
-0.2925446331501007,
-0.5165628790855408,
0.5208776593208313,
0.42656639218330383,
0.9369949102401733,
-0.6648427844047546,
0.4144625961780548,
0.4014073312282562,
0.08384986221790314,
0.15664198994636536,
0.6520376801490784,
-0.5327563881874084,
-0.7638417482376099,
-0.6150978207588196,
-1.059167742729187,
-0.43675434589385986,
0.253650039434433,
-0.737709641456604,
0.17813652753829956,
-0.6027922034263611,
-0.023099776357412338,
0.1797179877758026,
-0.0062553770840168,
-0.24983066320419312,
0.31848323345184326,
0.6066180467605591,
0.795504093170166,
-0.4790007472038269,
1.052193284034729,
0.4002491235733032,
0.1852456033229828,
-0.9765190482139587,
-0.22592270374298096,
-0.007909303531050682,
-0.9155339598655701,
0.18712247908115387,
0.365496963262558,
-0.0794934630393982,
-0.14895325899124146,
-0.3846745491027832,
-1.389129877090454,
0.8693904280662537,
0.09248881787061691,
-0.9468551874160767,
0.011147520504891872,
0.08273983746767044,
0.26954397559165955,
-0.16385702788829803,
-0.1343870609998703,
0.6295485496520996,
0.2552095949649811,
0.3950444161891937,
-0.8452532291412354,
-0.6470487117767334,
0.43028101325035095,
0.030002888292074203,
0.40587592124938965,
-0.5564373135566711,
0.6612407565116882,
-0.22270764410495758,
-0.3477810025215149,
-0.05254150554537773,
1.0297327041625977,
-0.10416398197412491,
0.36298736929893494,
0.8378636837005615,
0.9377675652503967,
0.7502538561820984,
-0.10560431331396103,
0.6010643243789673,
-0.3096091151237488,
0.434050589799881,
1.2486679553985596,
-0.15877650678157806,
0.81296706199646,
0.22350813448429108,
-0.44529473781585693,
0.7233250141143799,
0.6526963114738464,
-0.11788134276866913,
0.8134906888008118,
0.4292091429233551,
-0.37374547123908997,
-0.4037017822265625,
-0.34340280294418335,
-0.27994468808174133,
1.2230241298675537,
0.3704131543636322,
-0.19120022654533386,
-0.4695962369441986,
0.15919910371303558,
0.07205019891262054,
0.0679248794913292,
-0.5694629549980164,
0.9452942609786987,
0.3621985912322998,
-0.2500527501106262,
0.6915656328201294,
0.15461735427379608,
0.6326029300689697,
-0.7347206473350525,
-0.008774652145802975,
-0.14517834782600403,
-0.08683371543884277,
-0.15554498136043549,
-0.7172375917434692,
0.4682783782482147,
-0.249540314078331,
0.16472190618515015,
-0.0889991968870163,
0.631771981716156,
-0.512438952922821,
-0.44804060459136963,
0.4228403866291046,
0.3010973334312439,
0.35028186440467834,
-0.10547346621751785,
-0.59847491979599,
-0.030109375715255737,
0.24539710581302643,
0.031345438212156296,
0.18140022456645966,
0.2566051185131073,
0.1702171117067337,
0.4053715765476227,
0.43911293148994446,
0.32502880692481995,
-0.10862181335687637,
0.4971802532672882,
0.7538328766822815,
-0.7195937037467957,
-0.7938278913497925,
-0.7784510254859924,
-0.01598908193409443,
-0.1942751109600067,
-0.27701303362846375,
0.5169466137886047,
0.5711905360221863,
1.1569191217422485,
0.25746047496795654,
0.36033955216407776,
0.14306378364562988,
0.8077762722969055,
-0.5483526587486267,
0.48593834042549133,
-0.7057299613952637,
-0.07513990253210068,
-0.1751120537519455,
-0.8179985284805298,
-0.15270403027534485,
0.5743600726127625,
-0.06692633032798767,
-0.049176640808582306,
0.5660682916641235,
0.6623427271842957,
0.0804808959364891,
-0.1130807027220726,
0.7257270216941833,
-0.07793793827295303,
0.23063088953495026,
0.10819698125123978,
0.6810957193374634,
0.1285373717546463,
0.43232372403144836,
-0.849105954170227,
-0.3681328594684601,
0.033033587038517,
-0.6566930413246155,
-0.5388723611831665,
-0.5903866291046143,
-0.47886922955513,
-0.25587406754493713,
-0.004034603480249643,
0.781143307685852,
0.9602750539779663,
-0.9631866812705994,
-0.31020045280456543,
0.1687917709350586,
-0.01306145265698433,
-0.07959829270839691,
-0.26211458444595337,
0.40446025133132935,
-0.5636023879051208,
-0.5709501504898071,
0.8741145133972168,
0.5461174249649048,
-0.14483240246772766,
-0.41502276062965393,
0.10932348668575287,
-0.22804269194602966,
0.1559601128101349,
0.5541874766349792,
0.45870116353034973,
-0.4252232015132904,
-0.422692209482193,
-0.34774041175842285,
0.3454628586769104,
0.2023083120584488,
0.9035314321517944,
-0.9645143747329712,
0.38116973638534546,
0.12402603775262833,
0.4856673777103424,
0.6744213104248047,
-0.11946963518857956,
0.08071544021368027,
-0.821596622467041,
0.28109070658683777,
0.43659648299217224,
0.44980573654174805,
0.453949511051178,
-0.1234997808933258,
0.45888739824295044,
0.5503067970275879,
-0.5149121880531311,
-0.6126771569252014,
0.3449534773826599,
-0.8996064066886902,
-0.5304844975471497,
1.0375816822052002,
0.15443862974643707,
-0.4051106870174408,
-0.052983108907938004,
0.022604115307331085,
0.37657761573791504,
-0.35384854674339294,
0.783756673336029,
0.3480648398399353,
-0.5714884996414185,
-0.13369187712669373,
-0.058070871978998184,
0.6547444462776184,
0.305213987827301,
-0.3886943459510803,
-0.26594704389572144,
0.5229274034500122,
0.4650891423225403,
0.44690564274787903,
0.5930575132369995,
-0.2811320424079895,
-0.000310053612338379,
0.11901377886533737,
0.27996304631233215,
-0.2830195724964142,
-0.7967906594276428,
-0.31415215134620667,
0.3177633285522461,
0.19770970940589905,
-0.7679998278617859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17897v1 | Employing Label Models on ChatGPT Answers Improves Legal Text Entailment Performance | 2024-01-31T15:04:01 | 2024-01-31T15:04:01 | Chau Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The objective of legal text entailment is to ascertain whether the assertions
in a legal query logically follow from the information provided in one or
multiple legal articles. ChatGPT, a large language model, is robust in many
natural language processing tasks, including legal text entailment: when we set
the temperature = 0 (the ChatGPT answers are deterministic) and prompt the
model, it achieves 70.64% accuracy on COLIEE 2022 dataset, which outperforms
the previous SOTA of 67.89%. On the other hand, if the temperature is larger
than zero, ChatGPT answers are not deterministic, leading to inconsistent
answers and fluctuating results. We propose to leverage label models (a
fundamental component of weak supervision techniques) to integrate the
provisional answers by ChatGPT into consolidated labels. By that way, we treat
ChatGPT provisional answers as noisy predictions which can be consolidated by
label models. The experimental results demonstrate that this approach can
attain an accuracy of 76.15%, marking a significant improvement of 8.26% over
the prior state-of-the-art benchmark. Additionally, we perform an analysis of
the instances where ChatGPT produces incorrect answers, then we classify the
errors, offering insights that could guide potential enhancements for future
research endeavors. | [
-0.11666803807020187,
-0.9784760475158691,
0.5714123249053955,
0.15974800288677216,
-0.36587467789649963,
-0.13397686183452606,
-0.0972343161702156,
-0.6917603611946106,
-0.08254829049110413,
0.7466673254966736,
-0.034791287034749985,
-0.5804133415222168,
-0.8679742217063904,
-0.23004965484142303,
-0.4274807870388031,
1.3902761936187744,
-0.055708177387714386,
-0.12071604281663895,
-0.3639894127845764,
-0.06897641718387604,
-0.33403313159942627,
-0.5899184346199036,
-0.729224681854248,
-0.3693617582321167,
0.3881770372390747,
0.19270315766334534,
0.8405933380126953,
0.651438295841217,
0.7851953506469727,
0.17479120194911957,
-0.30710986256599426,
0.08605120331048965,
-0.4749041497707367,
0.1785268634557724,
0.015603164210915565,
-0.49869972467422485,
-0.6423742771148682,
0.13955162465572357,
0.20842485129833221,
0.42970725893974304,
-0.4790923297405243,
0.040796998888254166,
0.11219178140163422,
0.49903562664985657,
-0.636651873588562,
0.4770777225494385,
-0.6408175826072693,
-0.089152492582798,
-0.08975397795438766,
-0.27595430612564087,
-0.6882525086402893,
-0.662269115447998,
0.33335086703300476,
-0.5998589396476746,
0.3756926655769348,
0.07732031494379044,
1.1254853010177612,
0.6060339212417603,
-0.7001630067825317,
-0.5808162689208984,
-0.6679157614707947,
0.1823277771472931,
-1.0988460779190063,
0.5016645789146423,
0.5076606273651123,
0.1286146640777588,
-0.2505185306072235,
-0.9757731556892395,
-0.3792472183704376,
-0.44292131066322327,
-0.2251434624195099,
0.6098135709762573,
-0.2091388702392578,
0.3714475929737091,
0.45930609107017517,
0.029313942417502403,
-0.5590665936470032,
0.1114087849855423,
-0.1824195384979248,
-0.2608576714992523,
0.5533602237701416,
-0.0253817830234766,
0.24118617177009583,
0.13471168279647827,
-0.1544722318649292,
-0.05752861127257347,
-0.6532131433486938,
0.2981938421726227,
0.34845930337905884,
0.20995204150676727,
0.08554106205701828,
0.8319824934005737,
-0.16460461914539337,
0.8237040638923645,
0.0832933634519577,
-0.031578391790390015,
-0.03877587616443634,
-0.29246222972869873,
-0.17511200904846191,
0.4313506782054901,
0.8974472880363464,
0.3455996513366699,
0.2100798785686493,
-0.3239245116710663,
-0.0978301465511322,
-0.08861333131790161,
0.06439859420061111,
-1.1798094511032104,
-0.5689203143119812,
0.28353002667427063,
-0.10598089545965195,
-0.15413591265678406,
0.15793628990650177,
-0.6940314769744873,
-0.6641095876693726,
-0.5506542921066284,
0.2815772593021393,
-0.4975920617580414,
-0.02541279047727585,
0.3875974118709564,
-0.32608503103256226,
0.3544219732284546,
0.35253578424453735,
-0.6964808106422424,
0.4251289367675781,
0.8820058107376099,
0.5393461585044861,
0.23807621002197266,
0.3064565360546112,
-0.6176822781562805,
0.24520602822303772,
-0.23571708798408508,
0.9371874332427979,
-0.900914192199707,
-0.17053858935832977,
-0.13840022683143616,
-0.12037085741758347,
-0.3074396252632141,
-0.5212603211402893,
0.912893533706665,
-0.7270591259002686,
0.1526409089565277,
-0.09742636233568192,
-0.9228173494338989,
-0.25033921003341675,
0.3770907521247864,
-0.5011401176452637,
1.0194790363311768,
-0.47191718220710754,
-0.996273398399353,
0.5777466297149658,
-0.6550257205963135,
-0.35101455450057983,
0.02689087763428688,
0.05002642050385475,
-0.8219214677810669,
-0.2761037349700928,
0.3246208727359772,
0.2705453038215637,
-0.29918110370635986,
0.6306063532829285,
-0.20434971153736115,
-0.16291052103042603,
0.5121716260910034,
-0.5671725273132324,
0.7404868006706238,
0.1152198314666748,
-0.3642231523990631,
0.002462818520143628,
-0.47117504477500916,
0.06626398116350174,
-0.16217991709709167,
-0.6024284362792969,
-0.29654863476753235,
0.19571705162525177,
-0.31132251024246216,
-0.047925613820552826,
0.20599499344825745,
-0.5934231877326965,
0.09417583048343658,
-0.3346051573753357,
0.1701013594865799,
0.4371853470802307,
0.2653082609176636,
0.33659669756889343,
-0.24618184566497803,
0.556276261806488,
0.01621542125940323,
-0.10933495312929153,
0.06125633046030998,
-1.0951533317565918,
-0.7868476510047913,
-0.21028509736061096,
0.7016470432281494,
0.8370629549026489,
-0.6013121604919434,
0.08625362813472748,
-0.3788157105445862,
-0.7962803840637207,
-0.6234863996505737,
-0.0017042869003489614,
0.5186080932617188,
0.5317927598953247,
0.3356928527355194,
-0.06109941378235817,
-0.3950604200363159,
-0.8683177828788757,
-0.618263840675354,
-0.4924857020378113,
-0.1472894549369812,
0.25727578997612,
0.5433706641197205,
-0.08784961700439453,
1.0939522981643677,
-0.6278538703918457,
0.04438308626413345,
0.09881103038787842,
0.589805006980896,
0.43622028827667236,
0.22786784172058105,
0.2547858953475952,
-1.078245759010315,
-0.7102814316749573,
0.353943407535553,
-0.7837730050086975,
-0.32584914565086365,
-0.024975307285785675,
-0.12460102885961533,
-0.040800340473651886,
0.4299975037574768,
-0.5689253807067871,
0.4480609893798828,
0.1693020761013031,
-0.5498644709587097,
0.6874940395355225,
-0.22840569913387299,
0.25913262367248535,
-0.7573919296264648,
-0.251401424407959,
0.23312394320964813,
-0.2632254362106323,
-0.7880052328109741,
0.08602694422006607,
0.21495983004570007,
0.038423728197813034,
-0.5848761200904846,
0.17654696106910706,
-0.23119737207889557,
0.4813114106655121,
-0.267459899187088,
0.044190797954797745,
-0.04444383829832077,
0.2590177357196808,
0.015181920491158962,
0.7583250403404236,
0.5826231837272644,
-0.7311285138130188,
0.4261552691459656,
0.13398586213588715,
-0.02659299038350582,
0.47377854585647583,
-0.8329954147338867,
0.13690437376499176,
-0.3707091510295868,
0.25713494420051575,
-0.9148860573768616,
-0.4611921012401581,
0.44526028633117676,
-0.37482595443725586,
0.4498365521430969,
-0.5216256976127625,
-0.7202175259590149,
-0.23583436012268066,
0.1668168157339096,
0.030197104439139366,
0.6577353477478027,
-0.20997127890586853,
0.6135965585708618,
0.548058032989502,
-0.14785942435264587,
-0.39540019631385803,
-0.5521094799041748,
0.07919759303331375,
-0.4118468761444092,
-0.5569918155670166,
0.16692300140857697,
0.03858098015189171,
-0.32850381731987,
0.11986319720745087,
-0.1449480652809143,
-0.4998844265937805,
-0.11699779331684113,
0.1406586915254593,
0.030967310070991516,
-0.3508837819099426,
0.4349404573440552,
-0.17731571197509766,
0.1541885882616043,
0.23236101865768433,
-0.1699538677930832,
0.3091910183429718,
-0.399768590927124,
-0.3372027277946472,
-0.2542104125022888,
-0.015418102033436298,
0.41036897897720337,
-0.37363317608833313,
0.8146235346794128,
0.4542737305164337,
-0.2955363690853119,
0.0776090919971466,
-0.5911081433296204,
-0.21127764880657196,
-0.4454177916049957,
0.14341840147972107,
-0.26683831214904785,
-0.7706125378608704,
0.5575620532035828,
0.1463555246591568,
0.19278502464294434,
0.2596665620803833,
0.3906879127025604,
-0.2636297643184662,
0.6935004591941833,
0.4691127836704254,
0.2701624631881714,
0.30704617500305176,
0.2430044263601303,
0.42338645458221436,
-0.3972124457359314,
-0.4211263656616211,
-0.6318573951721191,
0.15534450113773346,
-1.000672459602356,
-0.5252013206481934,
0.41403210163116455,
-0.048686422407627106,
-0.12212321907281876,
0.5397614240646362,
-0.5330336689949036,
0.6430915594100952,
0.6585630178451538,
0.46493032574653625,
0.3393551707267761,
-0.24154481291770935,
0.10019445419311523,
-0.056141797453165054,
-0.8290696740150452,
-0.6683759689331055,
0.9297739863395691,
0.38398101925849915,
0.7876546382904053,
0.29705578088760376,
0.623328447341919,
0.16046276688575745,
0.5725718140602112,
-0.8914937376976013,
0.5938435792922974,
-0.13075736165046692,
-0.715965211391449,
-0.41510939598083496,
-0.4334909915924072,
-0.9908472895622253,
0.4602033793926239,
-0.11649700999259949,
-0.8239513039588928,
0.0982411801815033,
0.17720752954483032,
-0.0547470822930336,
0.2372213751077652,
-0.8403171896934509,
0.7973586320877075,
0.00039445486618205905,
-0.6719889044761658,
0.3855270445346832,
-0.4682430326938629,
0.4800398051738739,
-0.3785015344619751,
0.16905684769153595,
-0.31581196188926697,
0.09990192949771881,
1.1277101039886475,
-0.4849388301372528,
1.1007168292999268,
0.036256857216358185,
-0.42967745661735535,
0.9141577482223511,
-0.15394505858421326,
0.7735611796379089,
-0.040584906935691833,
-0.16016706824302673,
-0.28869131207466125,
0.22913524508476257,
-0.21663066744804382,
-0.74774569272995,
0.18774986267089844,
-0.2664324939250946,
-0.6558687686920166,
-0.39308175444602966,
-0.5968133807182312,
-0.15697439014911652,
0.12271109223365784,
0.3625209927558899,
0.41213691234588623,
0.03806405887007713,
0.40118208527565,
0.9924152493476868,
-0.14452122151851654,
0.18561947345733643,
0.9195589423179626,
0.0895487442612648,
0.10048071295022964,
0.7871086597442627,
0.3824867308139801,
0.09572546184062958,
0.37369734048843384,
0.384777694940567,
-0.653860330581665,
-0.3332674205303192,
-0.0426202192902565,
0.1840110719203949,
-0.9289610981941223,
-0.32422617077827454,
-0.8926981687545776,
-0.28265616297721863,
-0.5879608988761902,
0.1743733435869217,
-0.33337321877479553,
-0.26276522874832153,
0.07077043503522873,
-0.13947860896587372,
0.5098027586936951,
0.541388988494873,
0.19664227962493896,
0.4366356432437897,
-0.8571953773498535,
0.3303076922893524,
0.3881506323814392,
0.43193504214286804,
-0.5588585734367371,
-0.789115309715271,
0.02244185283780098,
0.4277924597263336,
-0.49483534693717957,
-1.2050875425338745,
0.23966330289840698,
0.2691233158111572,
0.5952322483062744,
0.18682214617729187,
0.4168769419193268,
0.7438528537750244,
-0.6214785575866699,
0.4386395215988159,
0.007755066733807325,
-0.781683623790741,
0.7791089415550232,
-0.6692032217979431,
0.2696320116519928,
0.4209452271461487,
0.38773998618125916,
-0.48583054542541504,
-1.1010183095932007,
-0.6439673900604248,
-0.9112448692321777,
0.3307853937149048,
0.5538495779037476,
-0.0462799146771431,
0.12542571127414703,
0.2466210275888443,
-0.09454047679901123,
-0.02325422875583172,
-0.8767554759979248,
0.055044837296009064,
0.18984270095825195,
-0.051729071885347366,
0.20376324653625488,
-0.2604541480541229,
-0.07047861814498901,
-0.21448157727718353,
0.9037883281707764,
-0.02180970087647438,
0.29843321442604065,
0.0782083123922348,
0.13950705528259277,
0.31760188937187195,
0.7253393530845642,
0.37074989080429077,
0.6127884984016418,
-0.44445177912712097,
0.25082457065582275,
0.21885623037815094,
-0.5866029858589172,
0.22312195599079132,
0.2725668251514435,
-0.3143133521080017,
0.23204056918621063,
0.33665376901626587,
0.709843635559082,
0.04202921316027641,
-0.510610818862915,
0.3888894021511078,
0.008988614194095135,
-0.39757686853408813,
-0.07531770318746567,
0.07835499197244644,
0.11516011506319046,
-0.010111373849213123,
0.07658129930496216,
0.016428176313638687,
0.5030554533004761,
-0.35868099331855774,
0.4670993983745575,
0.15835240483283997,
-0.6566435098648071,
0.1188194528222084,
0.9965885877609253,
-0.15615443885326385,
-0.06199854612350464,
0.5280426740646362,
-0.0687936320900917,
-0.5083457231521606,
1.0516482591629028,
0.5899562835693359,
0.5746245384216309,
0.041388850659132004,
0.3786827623844147,
0.37720659375190735,
0.48773014545440674,
-0.40122103691101074,
-0.044300928711891174,
0.1968114823102951,
-0.6765937209129333,
-0.5230284929275513,
-0.5646412968635559,
-0.7710511684417725,
-0.29205721616744995,
-0.7321770191192627,
0.06654168665409088,
0.03495579957962036,
-0.35227516293525696,
0.18254797160625458,
-0.47789129614830017,
-0.7026087641716003,
0.3101446032524109,
-0.14371727406978607,
0.6227890849113464,
-0.8909059166908264,
0.7612107992172241,
0.7533487677574158,
-0.47143253684043884,
-0.916273295879364,
0.09501219540834427,
-0.12070781737565994,
-0.32349932193756104,
0.5490890145301819,
0.15483921766281128,
-0.09738963097333908,
-0.07816724479198456,
-0.7713375091552734,
-0.5339114665985107,
0.682776927947998,
0.3784092962741852,
-0.6012076139450073,
0.3510190546512604,
0.5025665163993835,
0.7951111197471619,
0.16875198483467102,
0.32639041543006897,
0.841509997844696,
0.5360602736473083,
0.45559144020080566,
-1.0475972890853882,
0.11666912585496902,
-0.2166745364665985,
-0.43055441975593567,
0.24922023713588715,
-0.3383693993091583,
0.3503223955631256,
-0.1759769320487976,
-0.37268495559692383,
-0.40944617986679077,
0.6308999061584473,
0.24819768965244293,
0.5423091650009155,
0.14863073825836182,
0.5655640363693237,
1.2325313091278076,
-0.540946900844574,
1.2220208644866943,
-0.17744113504886627,
0.3646722137928009,
1.4406706094741821,
-0.18863318860530853,
0.8586079478263855,
0.391935259103775,
-0.19864393770694733,
0.1301756650209427,
0.7741410136222839,
-0.028717797249555588,
0.4468631446361542,
0.21365752816200256,
-0.4186622202396393,
-0.36231687664985657,
-0.41449692845344543,
-0.38479533791542053,
0.4971029460430145,
0.3684994578361511,
-0.1982494592666626,
-0.13001388311386108,
-0.08816279470920563,
0.2102087438106537,
0.0640784353017807,
-0.15054404735565186,
1.0025526285171509,
0.03903821483254433,
-0.9114927649497986,
0.3638260066509247,
-0.07102609425783157,
0.4301547706127167,
-0.38632339239120483,
-0.02643793448805809,
-0.24903835356235504,
0.18231774866580963,
-0.12856855988502502,
-1.1392221450805664,
0.314052939414978,
0.22373473644256592,
0.11951397359371185,
-0.3614118993282318,
0.8393969535827637,
-0.4973120391368866,
-0.6710536479949951,
-0.10867226123809814,
0.33252960443496704,
0.3562192916870117,
-0.13467736542224884,
-0.48307880759239197,
-0.4752105474472046,
-0.10454527288675308,
-0.11372318863868713,
-0.09157619625329971,
0.7692464590072632,
0.054028090089559555,
0.779365062713623,
0.544046938419342,
-0.11627652496099472,
0.45769956707954407,
-0.07228967547416687,
0.937155544757843,
-0.28252390027046204,
-0.5320860743522644,
-0.992243766784668,
0.5596557855606079,
-0.21339987218379974,
-0.04530642181634903,
0.7903713583946228,
0.7943487167358398,
0.6145955920219421,
-0.017952414229512215,
0.7043718099594116,
-0.09032437950372696,
0.26530906558036804,
-0.8404568433761597,
0.7037468552589417,
-0.2213440239429474,
0.33781933784484863,
-0.2364647090435028,
-0.9223746061325073,
-0.4460134506225586,
0.27776139974594116,
-0.7821768522262573,
-0.2545793652534485,
0.601579487323761,
0.9295911192893982,
-0.17885026335716248,
0.1402207314968109,
0.3796127438545227,
0.013057672418653965,
0.7014281153678894,
0.38701605796813965,
0.7471951246261597,
-0.5648412704467773,
0.8335614204406738,
-0.22004613280296326,
0.01942933350801468,
0.005072999745607376,
-0.8561089634895325,
-0.8471407890319824,
-0.17115449905395508,
-0.8536081910133362,
-0.48923367261886597,
0.29608362913131714,
0.4406301975250244,
0.6207154989242554,
-0.9716127514839172,
-0.0149642089381814,
-0.15625382959842682,
-0.1629360467195511,
-0.12573577463626862,
-0.2722280025482178,
0.3565373420715332,
-0.5631596446037292,
-0.6716834902763367,
0.0983293205499649,
-0.004062128718942404,
0.3183795213699341,
0.6686680912971497,
-0.14183291792869568,
-0.1641029566526413,
0.27990031242370605,
0.41960805654525757,
0.14640605449676514,
-0.6345536112785339,
-0.11805595457553864,
-0.24542753398418427,
-0.3458602726459503,
0.18804992735385895,
0.6749556660652161,
-0.29227644205093384,
0.6704842448234558,
0.5698508024215698,
0.6897085905075073,
0.7037556171417236,
0.32178211212158203,
0.546784520149231,
-0.659073531627655,
0.1677410751581192,
0.36627286672592163,
0.3116595447063446,
0.0822368636727333,
-0.35620468854904175,
0.7483939528465271,
-0.0110250823199749,
-0.6380752921104431,
-0.45219168066978455,
0.11642742156982422,
-0.9468238949775696,
-0.2408439815044403,
1.2977274656295776,
-0.40594378113746643,
-0.2304287552833557,
-0.32790300250053406,
-0.3417423367500305,
0.4893113970756531,
-0.44245457649230957,
0.6647699475288391,
0.8996233344078064,
-0.032349418848752975,
-0.3480771481990814,
-1.1248176097869873,
0.38154497742652893,
0.3066904544830322,
-0.944973349571228,
0.1170431450009346,
0.4291759431362152,
0.22229352593421936,
0.008412651717662811,
0.6025659441947937,
0.0018183570355176926,
0.19470936059951782,
0.2392672896385193,
-0.11852779239416122,
0.15709242224693298,
0.007028978783637285,
0.20395009219646454,
0.2754429876804352,
-0.030003679916262627,
-0.20313097536563873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01766v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01766v2 | LLM Voting: Human Choices and AI Collective Decision Making | 2024-01-31T14:52:02 | 2024-05-15T14:50:37 | Joshua C. Yang, Damian Dailisan, Marcin Korecki, Carina I. Hausladen, Dirk Helbing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC, 68T05, 91B14, 91C20, I.2.7; J.4; K.4.1 | This paper investigates the voting behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, their biases, and how they align with human
voting patterns. Our methodology involved using a dataset from a human voting
experiment to establish a baseline for human preferences and a corresponding
experiment with LLM agents. We observed that the methods used for voting input
and the presentation of choices influence LLM voting behavior. We discovered
that varying the persona can reduce some of these biases and enhance alignment
with human choices. While the Chain-of-Thought approach did not improve
prediction accuracy, it has potential for AI explainability in the voting
process. We also identified a trade-off between preference diversity and
alignment accuracy in LLMs, influenced by different temperature settings. Our
findings indicate that LLMs may lead to less diverse collective outcomes and
biased assumptions when used in voting scenarios, emphasizing the importance of
cautious integration of LLMs into democratic processes. | [
-0.5306338667869568,
-0.46272212266921997,
0.8623916506767273,
0.0056633357889950275,
-0.3353719115257263,
0.5180238485336304,
-0.18736004829406738,
-0.368143230676651,
0.1930343061685562,
0.5717072486877441,
-0.509726881980896,
-0.46955904364585876,
-0.4708814024925232,
0.1402754932641983,
-0.03159447759389877,
0.8804186582565308,
-0.002515760250389576,
0.3257250189781189,
-0.44193384051322937,
-0.14325721561908722,
-0.2261267453432083,
-0.8562056422233582,
-0.595804750919342,
-1.0512348413467407,
0.7266860604286194,
0.5744863152503967,
1.03290593624115,
0.7865707278251648,
0.26949408650398254,
0.344367116689682,
0.23284423351287842,
0.08687363564968109,
-0.5964806079864502,
0.024257265031337738,
-0.2538397014141083,
-0.8218042254447937,
-0.3300655484199524,
0.48828089237213135,
0.47698238492012024,
0.2487177848815918,
-0.25083431601524353,
0.07023400813341141,
0.006976386997848749,
0.7645484209060669,
-0.3709837794303894,
0.10586008429527283,
-0.8028310537338257,
-0.1447717398405075,
-0.4440380930900574,
-0.10167671740055084,
-0.13793042302131653,
-0.48501965403556824,
0.05914091318845749,
-0.016489654779434204,
0.1071968525648117,
0.17183010280132294,
0.559249758720398,
0.42631420493125916,
-0.4817233681678772,
-0.3212698698043823,
-0.5916407704353333,
0.8552653193473816,
-0.8120483160018921,
0.17046433687210083,
0.5074945092201233,
-0.09183281660079956,
-0.19300399720668793,
-0.3432476818561554,
-0.7944281101226807,
-0.10601376742124557,
0.23366768658161163,
0.14834894239902496,
0.11041401326656342,
0.20583267509937286,
-0.1616857349872589,
0.016536200419068336,
-0.4567824900150299,
0.5602288842201233,
-0.20019464194774628,
-0.05592498928308487,
0.8182126879692078,
0.42962440848350525,
0.17923517525196075,
-0.10281065106391907,
-0.20344561338424683,
-0.02077440172433853,
-0.761017382144928,
-0.042813774198293686,
0.7435566186904907,
0.3105776906013489,
-0.06886854767799377,
0.666068971157074,
-0.027722910046577454,
0.7626637816429138,
0.18831808865070343,
0.07851988822221756,
0.05014660209417343,
-0.3106779456138611,
-0.2615802586078644,
-0.11635097116231918,
0.8458264470100403,
0.5786461234092712,
0.29200175404548645,
0.04879147931933403,
-0.12613847851753235,
0.29318979382514954,
0.05361897498369217,
-0.48629000782966614,
-0.1834271252155304,
0.28592607378959656,
-0.44213107228279114,
-0.4730263948440552,
0.3765938878059387,
-0.5546773672103882,
-0.5917462706565857,
-0.8242122530937195,
0.22189143300056458,
0.17601928114891052,
-0.04965386912226677,
-0.08346115797758102,
-0.2526424825191498,
0.444112092256546,
0.6257256269454956,
-0.9409512877464294,
0.24663011729717255,
1.0245288610458374,
0.7116905450820923,
-0.5700023174285889,
-0.380272775888443,
-0.09632010012865067,
-0.00608861492946744,
-0.5793260335922241,
0.8085563778877258,
-0.8613729476928711,
-0.23409642279148102,
-0.2498973160982132,
-0.3945922255516052,
0.053324051201343536,
-0.6844481825828552,
0.03070514090359211,
-0.8522212505340576,
0.39368000626564026,
-0.5795154571533203,
-0.6446825861930847,
-0.21075554192066193,
0.3001500964164734,
-0.6859603524208069,
0.7063256502151489,
-0.28760308027267456,
-0.38759908080101013,
0.619931161403656,
-0.6187911033630371,
-0.18537019193172455,
-0.08619765937328339,
-0.5117474794387817,
-0.24030601978302002,
-0.11938611418008804,
0.10040895640850067,
0.6402115821838379,
-0.32570669054985046,
0.209095761179924,
-0.5008405447006226,
-0.4234420359134674,
0.577305793762207,
-0.34574946761131287,
0.8190045356750488,
0.08454239368438721,
-0.3616485893726349,
0.47037383913993835,
-0.10928449034690857,
-0.2276739925146103,
0.0905737653374672,
-0.549660861492157,
-0.10930483788251877,
0.40471023321151733,
-0.1283814013004303,
0.1850891262292862,
0.2536623775959015,
-0.2544265389442444,
0.6057291030883789,
-0.142495796084404,
0.5270570516586304,
1.3449242115020752,
-0.14031676948070526,
0.7740990519523621,
-0.49051013588905334,
0.4454776644706726,
0.0485386997461319,
0.0706930011510849,
0.6057822108268738,
-0.9723450541496277,
-0.5971354246139526,
0.038189422339200974,
0.19490209221839905,
0.7193713188171387,
-0.5109975934028625,
0.19926218688488007,
0.00978122092783451,
-0.5237322449684143,
-0.2745172083377838,
0.32231366634368896,
-0.059671178460121155,
0.0737810805439949,
-0.22023116052150726,
-0.17743106186389923,
-0.558200478553772,
-0.7379345297813416,
-0.05192536115646362,
-0.766697883605957,
0.11967194825410843,
0.25631028413772583,
0.5602558255195618,
-0.45654964447021484,
1.0975061655044556,
-0.32890382409095764,
0.0077588483691215515,
-0.24397948384284973,
0.033572904765605927,
0.3804883658885956,
0.1437409222126007,
0.2611054480075836,
-0.6235839128494263,
-0.07376585900783539,
0.0436195433139801,
-0.4786427319049835,
0.04507303610444069,
0.05069967731833458,
-0.04729871824383736,
0.5171197056770325,
0.24195228517055511,
-0.4923970401287079,
0.31269705295562744,
0.7483016848564148,
-0.1961224228143692,
0.40241119265556335,
0.05817727744579315,
0.19995813071727753,
-0.9064323902130127,
-0.4823121726512909,
0.024469805881381035,
-0.23825639486312866,
-0.4814196228981018,
-0.0884464830160141,
-0.2629787027835846,
0.2867165505886078,
-0.423235148191452,
0.5500375628471375,
-0.3665451109409332,
-0.36566486954689026,
-0.28587645292282104,
-0.02168603613972664,
-0.25904154777526855,
0.39944925904273987,
0.08153461664915085,
0.9622003436088562,
0.21603453159332275,
-0.5910928249359131,
0.6025667190551758,
0.11303089559078217,
-0.390179306268692,
0.34296807646751404,
-0.5010242462158203,
0.7449080348014832,
-0.14834833145141602,
0.3270268738269806,
-1.0988328456878662,
-0.3207431435585022,
0.32253414392471313,
-0.44674602150917053,
-0.05072006583213806,
0.06339371204376221,
-0.5586649775505066,
-0.1353544443845749,
-0.26618489623069763,
0.32070475816726685,
0.33505937457084656,
-0.3758573830127716,
0.520755410194397,
0.7699256539344788,
-0.030616123229265213,
-0.4690572917461395,
-0.5514177083969116,
0.25684136152267456,
-0.4675098657608032,
-0.5549354553222656,
0.31934472918510437,
-0.042419977486133575,
-0.7036060690879822,
-0.20426003634929657,
0.3103136718273163,
0.10479960590600967,
-0.17402344942092896,
0.2750200927257538,
0.5701166391372681,
-0.035787202417850494,
0.04736597463488579,
-0.35944679379463196,
0.07296588271856308,
-0.10864635556936264,
-0.16363884508609772,
0.722980260848999,
-0.2469170242547989,
-0.4454609453678131,
-0.28405556082725525,
0.2905339300632477,
0.6228252649307251,
0.03380803018808365,
0.5310501456260681,
0.39295628666877747,
-0.320446640253067,
0.11039116978645325,
-0.8055620789527893,
-0.2942892611026764,
-0.47725704312324524,
0.43168750405311584,
-0.04898901283740997,
-1.1523956060409546,
0.7257559895515442,
0.09635540097951889,
0.19060102105140686,
0.14701084792613983,
1.274126648902893,
-0.4320763051509857,
1.2306681871414185,
0.20659440755844116,
-0.6541344523429871,
0.4207620620727539,
0.1785961091518402,
-0.09910210222005844,
-0.6225842833518982,
-0.19265149533748627,
-0.6031197905540466,
-0.7529892921447754,
-0.821324348449707,
-0.8092920184135437,
0.3421056568622589,
-0.1859315037727356,
-0.6800075173377991,
-0.1376531720161438,
-0.39723485708236694,
0.634540855884552,
0.7190011143684387,
0.16905483603477478,
0.1129620373249054,
-0.11676718294620514,
0.08700163662433624,
0.04390595108270645,
-0.5617396235466003,
-0.7579914331436157,
1.0060157775878906,
0.12539270520210266,
0.7882968187332153,
0.25171831250190735,
0.8909053802490234,
0.41406965255737305,
0.4357369840145111,
-0.7356617450714111,
0.5794247388839722,
-0.08218029141426086,
-0.6998934149742126,
-0.650104820728302,
-0.17206372320652008,
-0.9950693845748901,
0.28486841917037964,
-0.04923882707953453,
-0.7241588234901428,
0.15130098164081573,
0.03582433983683586,
-0.20258352160453796,
0.4958138167858124,
-0.3310208320617676,
0.4993850290775299,
-0.4010821580886841,
-0.20303432643413544,
-0.44522202014923096,
-0.7024573087692261,
0.31438374519348145,
0.09581577777862549,
0.12488426268100739,
-0.23260873556137085,
-0.38702529668807983,
0.9640810489654541,
-0.23367443680763245,
1.2273080348968506,
0.06978768855333328,
-0.07633534073829651,
0.223377987742424,
-0.16773775219917297,
0.7148302793502808,
-0.0140744149684906,
-0.5545421838760376,
0.5193514823913574,
-0.3538771867752075,
-0.25379160046577454,
-0.4944406747817993,
0.6469677686691284,
-1.3626409769058228,
-1.0102888345718384,
-0.6037865281105042,
-0.44089123606681824,
-0.14846070110797882,
-0.23303790390491486,
0.27817264199256897,
0.046978481113910675,
-0.22094322741031647,
-0.03324282914400101,
0.1911529302597046,
0.20210355520248413,
0.449198454618454,
0.2820793092250824,
-0.43607285618782043,
-0.5114697217941284,
0.689981997013092,
0.16256020963191986,
0.3499791622161865,
0.19054025411605835,
0.3066861927509308,
-0.45222896337509155,
-0.5487276315689087,
-0.5417864918708801,
0.2556803524494171,
-0.7058923244476318,
-0.018782198429107666,
-0.07617172598838806,
0.08943759649991989,
-0.31627142429351807,
-0.16485029458999634,
-0.14826494455337524,
-0.2506832778453827,
-0.7837786674499512,
-0.2422240674495697,
0.17360642552375793,
1.1943227052688599,
-0.008137708529829979,
0.17651331424713135,
-0.3838137984275818,
0.1371556669473648,
0.5925259590148926,
0.22807925939559937,
-0.1368459314107895,
-0.2847593426704407,
0.1027006208896637,
-0.06639042496681213,
-0.335809588432312,
-1.2061711549758911,
0.05983635038137436,
-0.07555166631937027,
0.5792351961135864,
0.531201183795929,
-0.11980049312114716,
0.6543887853622437,
-0.2831234037876129,
1.0890899896621704,
0.04934855177998543,
-0.9444552063941956,
0.3614124059677124,
-0.38221466541290283,
0.2796505093574524,
0.5499581098556519,
0.05316485837101936,
-0.47941353917121887,
-0.39796265959739685,
-0.28846901655197144,
-0.44613170623779297,
0.6391794085502625,
-0.04311255365610123,
0.22750315070152283,
0.09220239520072937,
0.31091418862342834,
0.09334731847047806,
0.19331218302249908,
-0.6420338749885559,
-0.3330605924129486,
-0.020481426268815994,
0.08575915545225143,
-0.2346731573343277,
-0.10840614140033722,
-0.2565591633319855,
-0.3549934923648834,
0.4841320514678955,
-0.19933590292930603,
0.1881408393383026,
0.015814686194062233,
0.35289305448532104,
-0.3801325261592865,
0.19199363887310028,
0.9280487298965454,
0.9241330027580261,
-0.040997181087732315,
-0.08414904028177261,
0.31864139437675476,
-0.11810264736413956,
0.43622204661369324,
-0.4973355531692505,
-0.11978180706501007,
-0.2883158326148987,
0.2979557514190674,
0.8557947874069214,
-0.19717730581760406,
-0.17116031050682068,
0.10501016676425934,
-0.07855665683746338,
-0.2577481269836426,
-0.26787465810775757,
0.2222440540790558,
0.42454665899276733,
0.3518970012664795,
0.2409133017063141,
0.3537324368953705,
-0.06224827468395233,
-0.8155063986778259,
-0.04960624873638153,
0.8465035557746887,
-0.25996747612953186,
-0.3347935974597931,
0.4518749415874481,
0.4025704264640808,
-0.5656012296676636,
0.75075364112854,
-0.09803304076194763,
-0.8731303811073303,
0.7276935577392578,
0.33916977047920227,
0.6415697336196899,
-0.45470917224884033,
0.19677500426769257,
-0.019017362967133522,
0.46112900972366333,
-0.11864844709634781,
0.1741037666797638,
0.12452564388513565,
-1.3473410606384277,
-0.48367080092430115,
-0.26141437888145447,
-0.846204936504364,
-0.053326014429330826,
-0.4366443157196045,
0.30337902903556824,
-0.5192629098892212,
-0.4808526337146759,
-0.23204970359802246,
0.19368265569210052,
-0.740043580532074,
0.07775761932134628,
0.4594460427761078,
0.3916723132133484,
-0.8694648742675781,
0.7710033655166626,
0.8340356349945068,
-0.05405392125248909,
-0.8841157555580139,
0.031164804473519325,
0.49435892701148987,
-1.125228762626648,
0.4730492830276489,
-0.0679309219121933,
-0.07098934054374695,
-0.19159077107906342,
-0.7839339971542358,
-0.9403842687606812,
1.0419193506240845,
0.44900965690612793,
-0.6779868006706238,
0.03509172052145004,
0.25762757658958435,
0.2676047384738922,
-0.4575508236885071,
0.1886863112449646,
0.7832602262496948,
0.7992470860481262,
0.16908906400203705,
-0.8479898571968079,
-0.12087303400039673,
0.08236290514469147,
-0.2137339562177658,
0.13585761189460754,
-0.9594306945800781,
0.8718940615653992,
-0.4227374792098999,
0.046364154666662216,
-0.11529286205768585,
0.7665289044380188,
0.7420457601547241,
0.45842066407203674,
0.6815275549888611,
0.40008094906806946,
1.09025239944458,
-0.06782068312168121,
1.1035493612289429,
0.14842209219932556,
0.044962964951992035,
0.8230167031288147,
-0.8863536715507507,
0.7990790605545044,
0.75218266248703,
-0.5954746007919312,
0.6171272993087769,
0.958125114440918,
0.09687010943889618,
0.23707272112369537,
0.33666256070137024,
-0.25929710268974304,
-0.6246703863143921,
0.11742568016052246,
-0.05024217441678047,
0.7573181390762329,
0.231065571308136,
0.007541413884609938,
0.30536913871765137,
-0.2980324923992157,
0.051261551678180695,
-0.16156332194805145,
-0.3450034558773041,
0.9727723598480225,
0.2040194869041443,
-0.9587967991828918,
-0.03357289731502533,
-0.030467871576547623,
0.7268595099449158,
-0.2421962320804596,
-0.0030683157965540886,
0.05172664299607277,
-0.02008085697889328,
-0.3539632558822632,
-1.183369755744934,
0.0291990227997303,
-0.07025676220655441,
-0.4803929030895233,
-0.1616722047328949,
0.5055833458900452,
-0.16890105605125427,
-0.49254682660102844,
0.15139412879943848,
0.6761481165885925,
0.18027199804782867,
0.050861287862062454,
-0.8103204369544983,
0.3033684194087982,
0.23613031208515167,
-0.48149779438972473,
0.44821301102638245,
-0.02913091704249382,
-0.34005600214004517,
0.5596615672111511,
0.8835663795471191,
0.30532190203666687,
-0.24205009639263153,
0.3211568593978882,
0.7303623557090759,
-0.5892556309700012,
-0.38460013270378113,
-1.3310374021530151,
0.3270309567451477,
-0.041915345937013626,
-0.21613167226314545,
0.36110907793045044,
0.379670113325119,
0.5980129241943359,
0.15098461508750916,
0.9785568714141846,
0.298348069190979,
0.15246081352233887,
-0.6118280291557312,
0.7184572815895081,
-0.1740128993988037,
0.3133259117603302,
-0.17672833800315857,
-0.9751377701759338,
-0.2327960878610611,
0.5367873311042786,
-0.4731515347957611,
0.25906795263290405,
0.32636573910713196,
0.867611825466156,
0.37094220519065857,
0.06070806086063385,
0.2811134159564972,
0.03681269288063049,
0.3972114324569702,
0.35968583822250366,
1.1559048891067505,
0.0849219262599945,
0.24914653599262238,
0.09531431645154953,
-0.1754746288061142,
-0.1565694361925125,
-0.910412073135376,
-0.8219828009605408,
-0.6339520215988159,
-0.3913729786872864,
-0.034860916435718536,
-0.12798945605754852,
1.3409684896469116,
0.841585099697113,
-0.7218596935272217,
-0.671825647354126,
0.20096378028392792,
0.5029957294464111,
0.058188751339912415,
-0.22715963423252106,
0.11115633696317673,
-0.002542018424719572,
-0.7989480495452881,
0.1322159469127655,
0.3025493621826172,
-0.07219044119119644,
-0.3631077706813812,
-0.5603267550468445,
-0.14333049952983856,
0.3455304503440857,
0.40274471044540405,
-0.03487706929445267,
-1.2722288370132446,
-0.39275798201560974,
-0.09086290746927261,
-0.16038939356803894,
0.32068726420402527,
0.8653881549835205,
-0.730566680431366,
0.1970205008983612,
0.6687160730361938,
0.2503626048564911,
0.2754375636577606,
0.33603957295417786,
0.8254364728927612,
-0.4305901825428009,
-0.13330692052841187,
0.2993670701980591,
0.3243228495121002,
0.3043719232082367,
-0.3082127273082733,
0.3877266049385071,
0.07643934339284897,
-1.1110126972198486,
-0.4382660388946533,
0.14400941133499146,
-0.9285504817962646,
-0.09137975424528122,
1.2219243049621582,
0.388863205909729,
-0.072178415954113,
-0.1808318942785263,
-0.4131765365600586,
0.18255957961082458,
-0.6324411630630493,
0.6634523868560791,
0.9661438465118408,
-0.6312673687934875,
-0.21783703565597534,
-0.43449971079826355,
0.3401818871498108,
0.2702949047088623,
-0.7724016904830933,
-0.11401648074388504,
0.5717557668685913,
0.1414550095796585,
-0.053118038922548294,
0.8833644390106201,
0.13756977021694183,
0.22945739328861237,
-0.6063292026519775,
-0.10965459048748016,
0.22510693967342377,
0.024302685633301735,
-0.4159506857395172,
0.12023938447237015,
0.33600616455078125,
0.021487129852175713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17882v2 | I Think, Therefore I am: Benchmarking Awareness of Large Language Models Using AwareBench | 2024-01-31T14:41:23 | 2024-02-16T09:47:38 | Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Yuli Lin, Siyuan Wu, Yao Wan, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do large language models (LLMs) exhibit any forms of awareness similar to
humans? In this paper, we introduce AwareBench, a benchmark designed to
evaluate awareness in LLMs. Drawing from theories in psychology and philosophy,
we define awareness in LLMs as the ability to understand themselves as AI
models and to exhibit social intelligence. Subsequently, we categorize
awareness in LLMs into five dimensions, including capability, mission, emotion,
culture, and perspective. Based on this taxonomy, we create a dataset called
AwareEval, which contains binary, multiple-choice, and open-ended questions to
assess LLMs' understandings of specific awareness dimensions. Our experiments,
conducted on 13 LLMs, reveal that the majority of them struggle to fully
recognize their capabilities and missions while demonstrating decent social
intelligence. We conclude by connecting awareness of LLMs with AI alignment and
safety, emphasizing its significance to the trustworthy and ethical development
of LLMs. Our dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/HowieHwong/Awareness-in-LLM. | [
-0.3683062493801117,
-0.6613442301750183,
0.6143640279769897,
0.236331969499588,
0.1275545060634613,
0.18674379587173462,
-0.4937557280063629,
-0.7945473194122314,
0.16873860359191895,
0.19531577825546265,
-0.23053885996341705,
-0.4615248739719391,
-0.5035576820373535,
-0.0043862988241016865,
-0.5082917809486389,
0.5200813412666321,
0.11994417756795883,
0.07548479735851288,
-0.33428695797920227,
-0.39613816142082214,
-0.22264866530895233,
-0.5593335032463074,
-0.5412489175796509,
-0.4714892506599426,
0.5249161124229431,
0.30767354369163513,
0.45550522208213806,
0.6763957142829895,
0.6184733510017395,
0.2909325659275055,
0.047966670244932175,
-0.18422271311283112,
-0.6203669309616089,
0.14205577969551086,
-0.26818379759788513,
-0.4430164694786072,
-0.5989688038825989,
0.1730262041091919,
0.836918830871582,
0.8081282377243042,
0.03807654231786728,
0.5280085206031799,
0.07375685125589371,
0.5714097619056702,
-0.7312580943107605,
0.11610136926174164,
-0.7633229494094849,
-0.13882561028003693,
-0.13395161926746368,
0.49957406520843506,
-0.2634284198284149,
-0.3782188594341278,
0.19699476659297943,
-0.3505555987358093,
-0.14318150281906128,
0.4107867479324341,
0.5222327709197998,
0.5173166394233704,
-0.4178656041622162,
-0.06150849163532257,
-0.5851858258247375,
0.6874229907989502,
-0.5942754745483398,
0.5617483854293823,
0.3465045988559723,
0.41431981325149536,
0.005414342042058706,
-0.5585290193557739,
-0.7604988217353821,
-0.06527356803417206,
0.059488777071237564,
0.13747650384902954,
-0.24533537030220032,
-0.06753979623317719,
0.5039862394332886,
0.22282379865646362,
-0.6356112957000732,
0.16017211973667145,
-0.07805469632148743,
-0.3501926362514496,
0.798260509967804,
0.10590675473213196,
0.1467624306678772,
0.035828445106744766,
-0.40245717763900757,
0.008868526667356491,
-0.5329549908638,
0.11403165012598038,
0.15121392905712128,
-0.02334718033671379,
-0.2694565951824188,
0.46774888038635254,
-0.24500007927417755,
0.6150012612342834,
-0.34469711780548096,
-0.0732206255197525,
0.45888569951057434,
-0.09892772883176804,
-0.20626577734947205,
0.07319886982440948,
0.5773201584815979,
0.43407535552978516,
0.8261141180992126,
0.0348198264837265,
-0.10314103960990906,
0.1796310544013977,
0.5142764449119568,
-0.6591777205467224,
-0.0032398062758147717,
0.17938005924224854,
-0.43745991587638855,
-0.07005786895751953,
-0.20696473121643066,
-0.4494881331920624,
-0.9516425728797913,
-0.1774860918521881,
0.42061084508895874,
-0.35358870029449463,
-0.40239426493644714,
-0.019558599218726158,
-0.04101948067545891,
0.5204242467880249,
0.2874683737754822,
-0.7681342959403992,
0.4487532079219818,
0.867453396320343,
0.513058066368103,
0.06410916149616241,
-0.41736072301864624,
-0.2844090163707733,
0.12578648328781128,
-0.5034931302070618,
0.7584899663925171,
-0.4715689718723297,
-0.4697509706020355,
-0.12131000310182571,
-0.2771732211112976,
-0.1257944256067276,
-0.5493658781051636,
0.5407211184501648,
-0.38326016068458557,
-0.3472945988178253,
-0.5527986288070679,
-0.7672522068023682,
-0.2124672383069992,
0.6783876419067383,
-0.4251617193222046,
1.0850999355316162,
0.023485280573368073,
-0.672753632068634,
0.3603266179561615,
-0.38881704211235046,
-0.3309994041919708,
0.11919398605823517,
-0.4430483281612396,
-0.07345515489578247,
0.038152627646923065,
-0.1852416843175888,
0.5150929689407349,
-0.4062501788139343,
0.07185477018356323,
-0.6713942289352417,
-0.2032918483018875,
0.4523180425167084,
-0.18033020198345184,
0.6262851357460022,
0.09428557753562927,
-0.3395458161830902,
0.2947472929954529,
-0.696092963218689,
0.2455296367406845,
0.04495823755860329,
-0.37986817955970764,
-0.5159899592399597,
0.11871087551116943,
-0.2771512567996979,
0.24637964367866516,
0.6031460762023926,
-0.44400614500045776,
-0.1721472442150116,
-0.307824045419693,
0.17752724885940552,
1.0436241626739502,
-0.08145944029092789,
0.18952696025371552,
-0.28793004155158997,
0.24190764129161835,
-0.21935702860355377,
0.17844805121421814,
0.3377150893211365,
-0.2009975016117096,
-0.990480363368988,
-0.26138418912887573,
0.046694349497556686,
0.46219658851623535,
-0.029705103486776352,
0.6178335547447205,
-0.46762815117836,
-0.6606304049491882,
-0.4666880965232849,
0.3523942232131958,
0.5095456838607788,
0.5401895046234131,
-0.015831248834729195,
-0.4185941517353058,
-0.45379331707954407,
-1.1993283033370972,
-0.5651669502258301,
-0.6183269619941711,
0.03471170365810394,
0.49899882078170776,
0.5229626297950745,
-0.1907033622264862,
0.6938779354095459,
-0.1912245750427246,
-0.020483175292611122,
-0.3381511867046356,
-0.04115016758441925,
-0.04720988869667053,
0.37940043210983276,
0.5329968929290771,
-0.5390217900276184,
-0.6672953963279724,
0.023893287405371666,
-1.011906623840332,
0.00010756677511380985,
0.2731653153896332,
-0.14747969806194305,
0.05035432428121567,
0.8770415782928467,
-0.41872119903564453,
0.21256832778453827,
0.40211018919944763,
-0.2214725762605667,
0.2873898148536682,
-0.10226171463727951,
-0.09785256534814835,
-1.1450128555297852,
0.2965092957019806,
0.005448936950415373,
-0.29551374912261963,
-0.5665261149406433,
-0.15075841546058655,
0.3757552206516266,
0.1663968861103058,
-0.2584519684314728,
0.7641012072563171,
-0.6036056280136108,
-0.5531588196754456,
-0.09845761209726334,
0.4015938639640808,
-0.2874498665332794,
0.27966514229774475,
-0.12589968740940094,
0.6550008058547974,
0.7597815990447998,
-0.39654847979545593,
0.32271528244018555,
0.023639319464564323,
-0.8854752779006958,
0.853649914264679,
-0.5736661553382874,
0.15470260381698608,
-0.11729519069194794,
0.12788531184196472,
-0.8455746173858643,
-0.45011278986930847,
-0.06513956934213638,
-0.4360262453556061,
0.0793386697769165,
0.3198270797729492,
-0.6443163156509399,
-0.47917619347572327,
-0.18599200248718262,
0.18185296654701233,
0.5538919568061829,
-0.22946305572986603,
0.8754696249961853,
0.6128780841827393,
-0.09223894774913788,
-0.5420807600021362,
-0.5439553260803223,
-0.005083637777715921,
-0.28228017687797546,
-0.461200088262558,
-0.10287151485681534,
-0.29034852981567383,
-0.8292694091796875,
-0.15230897068977356,
-0.2402111142873764,
0.19020476937294006,
0.5430014133453369,
0.5152296423912048,
0.02979855053126812,
-0.028072796761989594,
0.29049789905548096,
-0.5589961409568787,
-0.004567370750010014,
0.32711824774742126,
-0.05938544124364853,
0.531470537185669,
-0.6294541358947754,
-0.6684635281562805,
-0.24535351991653442,
0.10409332811832428,
0.5710629820823669,
-0.470591276884079,
0.6749724745750427,
0.5663972496986389,
-0.5760157108306885,
-0.18669825792312622,
-0.8475711941719055,
-0.13553273677825928,
-0.4426324665546417,
0.47107386589050293,
-0.32273948192596436,
-0.9685293436050415,
0.7494766712188721,
-0.1793196201324463,
0.10934443771839142,
0.32565099000930786,
0.7425677180290222,
-0.12229924649000168,
1.094215989112854,
0.9210078120231628,
-0.669925332069397,
0.4820472002029419,
0.017273899167776108,
0.3274155855178833,
-0.9479650855064392,
-0.04267532005906105,
-0.6294060945510864,
-0.6422291398048401,
-0.4094923138618469,
-0.4494638741016388,
0.5948262214660645,
-0.07084861397743225,
-0.7243906855583191,
0.018916349858045578,
-0.05284180864691734,
0.5712299346923828,
0.44205111265182495,
-0.1197444424033165,
0.1566447615623474,
-0.42884284257888794,
-0.07234067469835281,
0.10913636535406113,
-0.501939058303833,
-0.6966901421546936,
1.027143120765686,
0.4896276295185089,
0.8008659482002258,
0.2944047152996063,
0.5316283106803894,
0.19887329638004303,
0.6374650001525879,
-0.671092689037323,
0.8064149022102356,
0.17331154644489288,
-0.924715518951416,
-0.2712419927120209,
-0.243256613612175,
-0.5979092121124268,
0.1483870893716812,
-0.2591661512851715,
-1.1084449291229248,
0.0671730563044548,
-0.001813685754314065,
-0.2856617271900177,
0.1389007568359375,
-0.7713304758071899,
1.033277153968811,
-0.47707226872444153,
-0.2917918860912323,
-0.6025471091270447,
-0.967498779296875,
0.2989038825035095,
-0.1556522697210312,
0.351042240858078,
-0.6278274655342102,
-0.07617685198783875,
0.6717572212219238,
0.1022806391119957,
1.0828505754470825,
0.10910765081644058,
0.099232979118824,
0.19792236387729645,
0.06822336465120316,
0.39334341883659363,
-0.12708327174186707,
-0.30492836236953735,
-0.03551502898335457,
-0.31378501653671265,
-0.38095465302467346,
-0.3322528600692749,
0.8376772999763489,
-0.9895647764205933,
-0.7451307773590088,
-0.3119319677352905,
-0.606557309627533,
-0.5112960338592529,
0.5493312478065491,
-0.2727872133255005,
0.10537288337945938,
-0.6214878559112549,
0.2800055742263794,
0.829573929309845,
0.0312179084867239,
0.2223893254995346,
0.8806943893432617,
-0.2723943889141083,
0.06639619171619415,
0.6731905341148376,
0.17036867141723633,
0.4382821023464203,
0.312394380569458,
0.12910665571689606,
-0.19567172229290009,
-0.4362785518169403,
-0.18364304304122925,
0.23523804545402527,
-1.0949639081954956,
-0.005398258566856384,
-0.8336015343666077,
-0.272904634475708,
-0.44281747937202454,
-0.11880964785814285,
-0.4284454882144928,
-0.23085831105709076,
0.09737227112054825,
-0.29540830850601196,
0.37564343214035034,
0.7783063054084778,
-0.03173929825425148,
0.0750206783413887,
-0.4845426678657532,
0.15284432470798492,
0.4231643080711365,
0.6649139523506165,
0.16710534691810608,
-0.31363680958747864,
-0.34578266739845276,
-0.10895295441150665,
0.011002696119248867,
-0.48621079325675964,
0.06132175028324127,
0.1897250860929489,
1.0436735153198242,
0.6471418738365173,
0.19769561290740967,
0.432852566242218,
-0.2175271064043045,
0.5000186562538147,
-0.2893778085708618,
-1.0555858612060547,
0.2984773814678192,
-0.2394074648618698,
0.23064374923706055,
0.8081778287887573,
0.42413800954818726,
-0.60268634557724,
-0.5455588102340698,
-0.6603386998176575,
-0.5276658535003662,
0.39252138137817383,
-0.16175028681755066,
0.029434898868203163,
-0.08293938636779785,
0.15988726913928986,
-0.30048930644989014,
0.2719472050666809,
-0.6362990140914917,
-0.14067894220352173,
0.016345249488949776,
-0.3396701514720917,
-0.4336167871952057,
-0.2838280498981476,
-0.2541278600692749,
-0.05662614479660988,
0.7023225426673889,
-0.21405985951423645,
-0.1106078252196312,
0.04018332064151764,
-0.14761509001255035,
-0.03214787319302559,
0.29573068022727966,
0.34180089831352234,
0.6487953662872314,
-0.2118896245956421,
0.5958356261253357,
0.4381053149700165,
-0.34232601523399353,
-0.14734479784965515,
-0.09331481158733368,
0.268705815076828,
-0.6883620619773865,
0.5045783519744873,
0.4414074420928955,
0.1822725087404251,
-1.0643984079360962,
0.4301562011241913,
-0.262587308883667,
-0.03437282517552376,
-0.4865972697734833,
0.20900382101535797,
0.6319440007209778,
0.44971197843551636,
-0.010414188727736473,
-0.021051352843642235,
-0.034796975553035736,
-0.6855432987213135,
-0.12557685375213623,
0.7096547484397888,
-0.5596963167190552,
-0.1627313494682312,
0.5063620805740356,
0.3017963469028473,
-0.20028376579284668,
0.5931875705718994,
-0.059782348573207855,
-0.6627200841903687,
0.5970445871353149,
0.3362843096256256,
0.8763296008110046,
-0.11004284024238586,
-0.35150620341300964,
0.3327297270298004,
0.7191249132156372,
0.004466874524950981,
0.3963943421840668,
-0.04257628694176674,
-1.2246428728103638,
0.055510539561510086,
-0.6117117404937744,
-0.606214702129364,
-0.1386200487613678,
-0.5006725788116455,
-0.08322031050920486,
-0.6864057183265686,
-0.20276722311973572,
0.2752666771411896,
0.16726048290729523,
-0.6634026169776917,
0.0019204639829695225,
0.12552237510681152,
1.1219910383224487,
-0.8041204810142517,
0.8900120854377747,
0.8832011222839355,
-0.01423177681863308,
-0.9682055115699768,
0.053916361182928085,
0.360530823469162,
-1.1333396434783936,
0.4216954708099365,
0.4133470058441162,
-0.3696464002132416,
0.1124453991651535,
-0.49299392104148865,
-0.9186828136444092,
1.0260050296783447,
0.1638294756412506,
-0.3500094413757324,
0.5714623928070068,
0.007937031798064709,
0.7474743127822876,
-0.4492442011833191,
0.010176340118050575,
0.7729212045669556,
0.7051125168800354,
-0.4347139894962311,
-0.8715129494667053,
-0.12108009308576584,
-0.5988837480545044,
-0.0590607225894928,
0.07278241217136383,
-0.9835808873176575,
0.6323137879371643,
-0.2425059825181961,
-0.29396766424179077,
-0.10459597408771515,
0.4897335469722748,
0.05692250654101372,
0.2283158153295517,
0.6800135970115662,
0.5562034845352173,
0.9457719326019287,
0.04391235113143921,
1.0618292093276978,
-0.586371123790741,
-0.02238970622420311,
0.9796602129936218,
-0.9042238593101501,
0.9316544532775879,
0.32352033257484436,
-0.07059615105390549,
0.2976984679698944,
0.5219966769218445,
0.29355764389038086,
-0.012877251952886581,
0.3179348409175873,
-0.3568979501724243,
-0.6149396896362305,
-0.4179689586162567,
-0.20069201290607452,
0.5002008676528931,
0.5490809679031372,
-0.2263215333223343,
-0.017717724665999413,
-0.23514166474342346,
-0.06781116127967834,
0.3422645032405853,
-0.3131868243217468,
1.0539108514785767,
0.023884469643235207,
-0.48700234293937683,
0.5529617071151733,
-0.13174299895763397,
0.4245508015155792,
-0.661604642868042,
0.4909963309764862,
-0.06377334892749786,
0.47870147228240967,
-0.02477107383310795,
-0.874299168586731,
0.22295670211315155,
0.11913201212882996,
-0.30289340019226074,
-0.16797709465026855,
0.748302161693573,
-0.2300003319978714,
-0.44390907883644104,
0.46962830424308777,
0.8042069673538208,
0.32170334458351135,
0.046122048050165176,
-0.5870509147644043,
0.2950949966907501,
-0.00029246139456517994,
-0.23768331110477448,
0.5101004838943481,
0.46466997265815735,
-0.3788203001022339,
1.014706015586853,
0.3654480576515198,
-0.12217046320438385,
0.005776807200163603,
0.33802852034568787,
0.6691390872001648,
-0.6427769660949707,
-0.22789567708969116,
-0.886305570602417,
0.09973227232694626,
-0.2784680426120758,
-0.283573180437088,
0.9828132390975952,
0.7447238564491272,
0.8443043828010559,
0.12161896377801895,
0.9822165966033936,
-0.0894448310136795,
0.8184015154838562,
0.02227313444018364,
0.9067938923835754,
-0.5140789151191711,
0.23283344507217407,
-0.20157510042190552,
-0.7929624915122986,
-0.14499075710773468,
0.7598275542259216,
-0.5618337392807007,
0.18127226829528809,
0.320137619972229,
0.912233293056488,
0.11686971783638,
0.15345917642116547,
0.4301512837409973,
0.5053422451019287,
0.20229887962341309,
0.3900706171989441,
0.891952395439148,
0.1520153433084488,
0.1596667617559433,
-0.28295284509658813,
-0.3666558265686035,
-0.21657195687294006,
-0.9221778512001038,
-1.0490782260894775,
-0.4988490343093872,
-0.07057817280292511,
-0.03128812462091446,
-0.0018367321463301778,
1.0599966049194336,
0.6896932125091553,
-0.47816359996795654,
-0.5183030366897583,
0.10037139803171158,
0.2841787338256836,
-0.2759610116481781,
-0.17678126692771912,
0.10985998809337616,
-0.19421067833900452,
-0.4411409795284271,
0.302973210811615,
0.36285462975502014,
0.1724570393562317,
-0.4918319582939148,
0.02574283815920353,
-0.2727047801017761,
0.2140820175409317,
0.567230224609375,
0.24611692130565643,
-0.5270677804946899,
-0.704374372959137,
0.08032616227865219,
-0.34576207399368286,
-0.20855043828487396,
0.6793652176856995,
-0.5786761045455933,
0.4562523365020752,
0.4757828116416931,
0.5768163800239563,
0.30233705043792725,
-0.01201076339930296,
0.47681924700737,
-0.6107627749443054,
0.03611017018556595,
0.17777852714061737,
0.5023229718208313,
0.4403318166732788,
-0.10521819442510605,
0.5275477170944214,
-0.17154164612293243,
-0.7121781706809998,
-0.7474321126937866,
0.2672847807407379,
-0.9990296363830566,
-0.10278698056936264,
0.906778872013092,
-0.06542756408452988,
-0.26254570484161377,
-0.16453638672828674,
0.011575442738831043,
0.13146157562732697,
-0.29140007495880127,
0.8252919912338257,
0.7631182074546814,
-0.09516537189483643,
-0.04516192525625229,
-0.7883028984069824,
0.3543269634246826,
0.4306562840938568,
-0.9305727481842041,
0.5179533958435059,
0.483727365732193,
0.3994951844215393,
0.2697877883911133,
0.755679726600647,
0.02780482918024063,
0.1089325025677681,
0.017847809940576553,
0.3159194886684418,
0.35274621844291687,
-0.12838199734687805,
-0.08684851229190826,
-0.1296725869178772,
0.47199878096580505,
0.3221956789493561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17858v1 | Probing Language Models' Gesture Understanding for Enhanced Human-AI Interaction | 2024-01-31T14:19:03 | 2024-01-31T14:19:03 | Philipp Wicke | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has affected various disciplines
that got beyond mere text generation. Going beyond their textual nature, this
project proposal aims to investigate the interaction between LLMs and
non-verbal communication, specifically focusing on gestures. The proposal sets
out a plan to examine the proficiency of LLMs in deciphering both explicit and
implicit non-verbal cues within textual prompts and their ability to associate
these gestures with various contextual factors. The research proposes to test
established psycholinguistic study designs to construct a comprehensive dataset
that pairs textual prompts with detailed gesture descriptions, encompassing
diverse regional variations, and semantic labels. To assess LLMs' comprehension
of gestures, experiments are planned, evaluating their ability to simulate
human behaviour in order to replicate psycholinguistic experiments. These
experiments consider cultural dimensions and measure the agreement between
LLM-identified gestures and the dataset, shedding light on the models'
contextual interpretation of non-verbal cues (e.g. gestures). | [
-0.2609637677669525,
-1.0598998069763184,
0.5890211462974548,
0.24813473224639893,
-0.1977081000804901,
-0.005778395105153322,
-0.21826735138893127,
-0.8228190541267395,
0.42953553795814514,
0.4196394383907318,
-0.763512134552002,
-0.46645820140838623,
-0.6794724464416504,
0.21728600561618805,
-0.557541012763977,
0.5816861391067505,
-0.035125888884067535,
0.3133167028427124,
-0.26025450229644775,
-0.010811376385390759,
-0.1433701515197754,
-0.5334472060203552,
-0.7966601252555847,
-0.6391914486885071,
0.5179055333137512,
0.4004300832748413,
0.6334547400474548,
0.20820805430412292,
0.31833821535110474,
0.2932480573654175,
-0.17052166163921356,
0.10004955530166626,
-0.27319276332855225,
-0.08318204432725906,
0.11376756429672241,
-0.4747511148452759,
-0.5803534984588623,
0.3709244430065155,
0.5499954223632812,
0.8723752498626709,
0.2723644971847534,
0.11798085272312164,
0.16725343465805054,
0.14331470429897308,
-0.21985028684139252,
0.11208952218294144,
0.0016640141839161515,
0.06255930662155151,
-0.21033875644207,
-0.24264487624168396,
-0.4080897867679596,
-0.09898737818002701,
-0.04247334226965904,
-0.30359527468681335,
-0.0032683962490409613,
0.10870341956615448,
0.5520889759063721,
0.16803400218486786,
-0.7142601013183594,
-0.18274952471256256,
-0.6217538118362427,
0.561481237411499,
-0.7572677135467529,
0.45811137557029724,
0.7433769106864929,
-0.09370662271976471,
-0.24982184171676636,
-0.5766831040382385,
-0.7944233417510986,
-0.698734700679779,
-0.1150924563407898,
-0.05369902402162552,
0.09707089513540268,
0.11672207713127136,
0.2521042227745056,
-0.018772436305880547,
-0.6922916173934937,
0.37290915846824646,
-0.03499677777290344,
-0.08246830850839615,
0.9491140842437744,
0.34363076090812683,
0.6243896484375,
-0.37349167466163635,
-0.3144182562828064,
-0.056672267615795135,
-0.6876206994056702,
0.1755855828523636,
0.29172730445861816,
0.4556773900985718,
-0.6639853119850159,
0.6773016452789307,
-0.08368181437253952,
0.8611104488372803,
0.031016884371638298,
-0.084444060921669,
0.17403672635555267,
-0.6122696995735168,
-0.3585546910762787,
-0.09427052736282349,
0.6865163445472717,
0.5339617729187012,
0.5541996359825134,
-0.024558404460549355,
0.031682856380939484,
-0.18325158953666687,
-0.08859337866306305,
-0.5185567140579224,
-0.08670000731945038,
0.31001606583595276,
-0.6756592392921448,
-0.2464621663093567,
-0.09109726548194885,
-0.5794965028762817,
-0.6854361891746521,
-0.5190352201461792,
0.1798238903284073,
-0.29384878277778625,
-0.6981906294822693,
-0.03485310450196266,
-0.19940225780010223,
0.72027587890625,
0.3526849150657654,
-1.0151718854904175,
0.0017844289541244507,
0.7757990956306458,
0.7779006958007812,
-0.011328856460750103,
-0.5647784471511841,
-0.21142373979091644,
0.20667555928230286,
-0.4136972725391388,
0.6452847123146057,
-0.8324786424636841,
-0.8304039239883423,
-0.09419889748096466,
-0.13312020897865295,
-0.1602243036031723,
-0.3483835756778717,
0.5507277250289917,
-0.20583854615688324,
0.3289203643798828,
-0.26512181758880615,
-0.5377686619758606,
-0.12969237565994263,
0.4022791385650635,
-0.5061467289924622,
1.0167815685272217,
-0.18380215764045715,
-0.5511162281036377,
0.3857392966747284,
-1.062698483467102,
-0.6014882326126099,
0.29912105202674866,
-0.41744863986968994,
-0.004368313588202,
0.1951899528503418,
0.09257049858570099,
0.6284165382385254,
-0.2234860062599182,
0.31249773502349854,
-0.26387450098991394,
-0.34946754574775696,
0.5136456489562988,
-0.6284101009368896,
0.7636635303497314,
-0.09563245624303818,
-0.31698766350746155,
0.44341158866882324,
-0.40123507380485535,
-0.12484153360128403,
0.24470262229442596,
-0.19897572696208954,
-0.4045400023460388,
0.07697165757417679,
0.24251407384872437,
0.08661283552646637,
0.413649320602417,
-0.4169156849384308,
0.3925338387489319,
-0.39965301752090454,
0.5252037644386292,
0.5138583183288574,
-0.028884967789053917,
0.6437479853630066,
-0.2516421675682068,
0.5982418656349182,
-0.3558937609195709,
0.19245947897434235,
-0.10801868140697479,
-0.5259366035461426,
-0.5390658974647522,
-0.25377827882766724,
-0.04872855916619301,
0.35831066966056824,
-0.6403334140777588,
0.2716948986053467,
-0.20942552387714386,
-0.3433690369129181,
-0.32424691319465637,
-0.00488360645249486,
0.3986881375312805,
0.4218067228794098,
-0.1248723566532135,
-0.05667641758918762,
-0.4099687933921814,
-0.7161144614219666,
-0.31143805384635925,
-0.5103994011878967,
-0.23710906505584717,
0.4120389223098755,
0.4235266149044037,
-0.06545654684305191,
0.8855103254318237,
-0.012095976620912552,
-0.0019209060119464993,
-0.4673841893672943,
0.5520233511924744,
-0.09721311926841736,
0.0667150616645813,
0.6399105787277222,
-1.0195081233978271,
-0.20672015845775604,
-0.27192866802215576,
-0.7060804963111877,
-0.12806379795074463,
-0.03616079315543175,
0.11428318172693253,
0.35773906111717224,
0.7947418689727783,
-0.6267440915107727,
0.39639583230018616,
0.6831651329994202,
-0.7413092851638794,
0.43943169713020325,
-0.043653454631567,
0.3954208493232727,
-1.1056638956069946,
-0.02365664578974247,
-0.06929712742567062,
-0.0232981126755476,
-0.9332627654075623,
0.004210690502077341,
0.06272943317890167,
-0.08457266539335251,
-0.7527247071266174,
1.0208982229232788,
-0.5626578330993652,
-0.2287854105234146,
-0.504460334777832,
0.35715481638908386,
-0.2571350932121277,
0.16634264588356018,
0.5638067722320557,
0.833483874797821,
0.5364806652069092,
-0.5909431576728821,
-0.0070836544036865234,
0.23474960029125214,
-0.27585387229919434,
0.8104411363601685,
-0.5378905534744263,
0.26338598132133484,
-0.049616627395153046,
0.13665629923343658,
-1.264277696609497,
-0.44442102313041687,
0.24625469744205475,
-1.0101957321166992,
0.11271101236343384,
0.06966135650873184,
-0.4854900538921356,
-0.17880484461784363,
-0.32252904772758484,
0.28895145654678345,
0.2512851655483246,
-0.5115206241607666,
0.9346182346343994,
0.31859055161476135,
-0.27037352323532104,
-0.4262126684188843,
-0.7146305441856384,
0.5411423444747925,
-0.5354527235031128,
-0.7666857838630676,
-0.05636435002088547,
-0.010280455462634563,
-0.5339212417602539,
-0.5819979310035706,
0.4167233109474182,
0.21946574747562408,
0.38775017857551575,
0.33222225308418274,
0.39139610528945923,
-0.0898531824350357,
-0.07106814533472061,
0.032208219170570374,
-0.00928686186671257,
0.3486168384552002,
0.10830868035554886,
0.7272223830223083,
0.1644216626882553,
-0.5720757842063904,
-0.8105261325836182,
0.25004515051841736,
0.7163622975349426,
-0.19754654169082642,
0.5886847972869873,
0.5150895118713379,
-0.33165308833122253,
0.3313266634941101,
-0.11957548558712006,
-0.45965710282325745,
-0.5081747770309448,
0.4063635468482971,
-0.5272431969642639,
-0.8269317150115967,
0.36959192156791687,
-0.22217528522014618,
0.09701887518167496,
-0.1574706882238388,
0.7043090462684631,
-0.3463588058948517,
1.0930129289627075,
0.603256344795227,
-0.36158373951911926,
0.5688779354095459,
-0.11648151278495789,
0.33126652240753174,
-0.8680980801582336,
-0.376865416765213,
-0.5345442891120911,
-0.6322075724601746,
-0.3982710540294647,
-0.6658821702003479,
0.17078571021556854,
-0.11945204436779022,
-0.06787997484207153,
0.02309778891503811,
0.13192278146743774,
0.2970433533191681,
0.41796404123306274,
-0.16023944318294525,
0.2667192816734314,
-0.1664983183145523,
-0.07335781306028366,
0.15930120646953583,
-0.2595829963684082,
-0.7707040309906006,
0.7864959239959717,
0.34618163108825684,
0.644331693649292,
0.32128670811653137,
0.533909261226654,
0.2876951992511749,
0.207743838429451,
-0.8874855637550354,
0.8501593470573425,
0.15777812898159027,
-0.4538593292236328,
-0.5477559566497803,
-0.022202448919415474,
-1.1105244159698486,
0.1238449215888977,
-0.2822832763195038,
-0.9428313970565796,
0.00030272756703197956,
0.10446616262197495,
-0.02964598312973976,
0.13864190876483917,
-0.5076219439506531,
0.5045356154441833,
-0.465781569480896,
-0.19867436587810516,
-0.24334466457366943,
-0.6327256560325623,
0.2749217450618744,
0.17298650741577148,
0.3312130570411682,
-0.13494066894054413,
-0.14225976169109344,
0.6439499258995056,
0.077255018055439,
1.4157514572143555,
-0.33001500368118286,
-0.5246204733848572,
-0.03595568612217903,
0.37191328406333923,
0.2931192219257355,
-0.12454553693532944,
-0.16925576329231262,
0.34662726521492004,
-0.24750442802906036,
-0.3061251938343048,
-0.5459707975387573,
0.4955681562423706,
-0.6889452934265137,
-0.4068605601787567,
-0.2707504630088806,
-0.819024920463562,
-0.34732577204704285,
-0.13291046023368835,
-0.0337403304874897,
0.3456617295742035,
-0.5016377568244934,
-0.21406744420528412,
0.39431625604629517,
-0.14744898676872253,
0.5607692003250122,
0.9094371795654297,
-0.2918942868709564,
0.19579565525054932,
0.5550515651702881,
-0.47555023431777954,
0.2946431338787079,
0.4730663597583771,
0.18058449029922485,
-0.6989338994026184,
-0.6362873315811157,
-0.5315902829170227,
0.3324670195579529,
-0.3537604808807373,
0.27090102434158325,
-0.09766249358654022,
-0.0447516106069088,
-0.6967530250549316,
-0.17398691177368164,
0.220321923494339,
-0.2889178693294525,
-0.3211805820465088,
-0.48347511887550354,
0.5838420987129211,
0.9146190881729126,
-0.13046950101852417,
0.4071274995803833,
-0.5780612230300903,
0.2760043442249298,
-0.1983901709318161,
-0.11736859381198883,
0.0628875121474266,
-0.6174815893173218,
0.18730391561985016,
0.01726311817765236,
0.04749230667948723,
-0.823465883731842,
0.3799290359020233,
0.12335261702537537,
0.4513101577758789,
0.682483971118927,
-0.10678285360336304,
0.5374769568443298,
-0.35551533102989197,
1.164509892463684,
0.049239665269851685,
-0.8604628443717957,
0.5153217911720276,
-0.6993255615234375,
0.31420403718948364,
0.16070213913917542,
0.425559937953949,
-0.837863564491272,
-0.6049961447715759,
-0.44291141629219055,
-0.6853205561637878,
0.6489130854606628,
0.05149676650762558,
0.3946191370487213,
0.033207397907972336,
0.6525359749794006,
-0.13288019597530365,
-0.03707380220293999,
-0.5501288175582886,
-0.21266363561153412,
0.44025611877441406,
-0.3768724501132965,
-0.4763759672641754,
-0.09910474717617035,
-0.020994743332266808,
-0.1179519072175026,
0.16017156839370728,
-0.10121452063322067,
0.09574147313833237,
-0.12318336218595505,
-0.12883274257183075,
0.08429785072803497,
0.10857638716697693,
0.7706692218780518,
0.5244662761688232,
0.2733454406261444,
0.20899759232997894,
0.14556187391281128,
-0.5136439204216003,
0.09097974747419357,
-0.205471009016037,
-0.0988171398639679,
-0.3252570331096649,
0.7217692136764526,
0.7909340262413025,
0.09211726486682892,
-0.7516461610794067,
0.19579161703586578,
-0.27994146943092346,
-0.22816909849643707,
-0.35531744360923767,
-0.024613702669739723,
0.3828757107257843,
0.344899982213974,
0.20581883192062378,
-0.4447871744632721,
0.1721530556678772,
-0.5876734256744385,
0.1662469059228897,
0.662202775478363,
-0.25627240538597107,
-0.41028517484664917,
0.4499594271183014,
0.42554575204849243,
-0.7812454700469971,
0.8687147498130798,
-0.008170985616743565,
-0.34576377272605896,
0.6623170375823975,
0.44251468777656555,
0.6674404144287109,
-0.38061702251434326,
0.4125450551509857,
0.1840115785598755,
0.1944144368171692,
0.29559338092803955,
0.5558558702468872,
-0.3752938508987427,
-0.765796422958374,
-0.34725216031074524,
-0.31495511531829834,
-0.5549880266189575,
0.007735677994787693,
-0.6351977586746216,
0.4028209447860718,
-0.03562124818563461,
-0.1418457329273224,
-0.2062830626964569,
-0.11958623677492142,
-0.36325398087501526,
0.14352060854434967,
0.44879260659217834,
0.7989000678062439,
-1.2713590860366821,
0.9326858520507812,
0.8528510928153992,
-0.23801299929618835,
-0.7397430539131165,
0.2691485583782196,
0.3029167354106903,
-1.1913626194000244,
0.7497466206550598,
0.03351486101746559,
-0.40689632296562195,
-0.035478536039590836,
-0.4527829587459564,
-0.6456128358840942,
1.0191820859909058,
0.3823421001434326,
-0.3518717586994171,
-0.03422500193119049,
0.5028243064880371,
0.5424556732177734,
-0.032941751182079315,
0.4590975344181061,
0.9001545310020447,
0.7194548845291138,
0.18025550246238708,
-1.2166748046875,
-0.032617006450891495,
-0.21388781070709229,
-0.20670194923877716,
0.393056184053421,
-0.6258522272109985,
0.5740985870361328,
-0.3397211730480194,
-0.05057954043149948,
0.4124075174331665,
0.8362205028533936,
0.4294004440307617,
0.584790050983429,
0.3932977616786957,
0.20541322231292725,
0.8352389335632324,
-0.004766944330185652,
1.1178038120269775,
-0.24612149596214294,
-0.10531631112098694,
1.0276051759719849,
-0.49186742305755615,
1.113858938217163,
0.7411655187606812,
-0.08496087044477463,
0.4037145674228668,
0.9037747979164124,
0.31936323642730713,
0.12572813034057617,
0.3344319760799408,
-0.3951174318790436,
-0.03551657497882843,
-0.3358970582485199,
0.05987710878252983,
0.8296511173248291,
0.5285019278526306,
-0.23206540942192078,
-0.0802524983882904,
0.4062612056732178,
0.1690683662891388,
0.15572868287563324,
-0.3398330509662628,
0.8285818696022034,
0.14850641787052155,
-0.5041274428367615,
0.31095507740974426,
0.1448703110218048,
0.833484411239624,
-0.6070351004600525,
0.11887793987989426,
-0.2416382133960724,
-0.10921723395586014,
-0.11002284288406372,
-1.0266975164413452,
0.2128596305847168,
-0.046380020678043365,
0.09656409919261932,
-0.38797664642333984,
0.6608614325523376,
-0.2881419360637665,
-0.46576493978500366,
0.5766428709030151,
0.6811468601226807,
0.7327438592910767,
0.18707400560379028,
-0.6566973328590393,
0.1930699199438095,
-0.17655828595161438,
-0.17217710614204407,
0.4807826280593872,
0.1841432750225067,
-0.3079686760902405,
0.5352317094802856,
0.26597362756729126,
0.05800290405750275,
-0.06978435069322586,
0.5304585695266724,
0.2602030038833618,
-0.7357093691825867,
-0.25037282705307007,
-0.9355831742286682,
0.25630009174346924,
0.13591575622558594,
-0.2564152181148529,
0.7836438417434692,
0.21991945803165436,
0.6806685924530029,
0.0822424367070198,
0.6194984316825867,
-0.045508190989494324,
0.17630596458911896,
-0.6773449778556824,
0.7153312563896179,
-0.5154417753219604,
-0.17358742654323578,
-0.13530784845352173,
-0.5016700029373169,
-0.13046418130397797,
0.7996607422828674,
-0.47211527824401855,
0.3616306781768799,
0.25973787903785706,
0.771113932132721,
0.07923296093940735,
0.3728325366973877,
0.5087748765945435,
0.14856664836406708,
0.2881495952606201,
0.4698222577571869,
1.0998409986495972,
0.17304055392742157,
-0.038225941359996796,
0.1828615516424179,
-0.3234056532382965,
-0.022313078865408897,
-0.9987062811851501,
-1.1282896995544434,
-0.7737923264503479,
-0.24437707662582397,
0.19082991778850555,
-0.21558618545532227,
0.8282822370529175,
0.6951099038124084,
-0.4170113801956177,
-0.7326182723045349,
0.17249014973640442,
-0.2225879430770874,
-0.0586654394865036,
-0.261962354183197,
0.29839256405830383,
0.02374565601348877,
-1.207700252532959,
0.7178598046302795,
0.12555429339408875,
0.39365947246551514,
-0.4166634976863861,
-0.32256439328193665,
-0.1534767895936966,
0.28559747338294983,
0.8555927872657776,
0.16347736120224,
-0.784864068031311,
-0.30099689960479736,
0.2163139134645462,
0.37589791417121887,
-0.28174421191215515,
1.0124298334121704,
-0.6066544055938721,
-0.049976661801338196,
0.5078893303871155,
0.34039434790611267,
0.16644948720932007,
0.1657189130783081,
0.6484152674674988,
-0.8012772798538208,
0.3537498116493225,
0.03573629632592201,
0.2734038233757019,
0.4112343192100525,
-0.4023948013782501,
0.21188388764858246,
-0.22608864307403564,
-0.302455872297287,
-0.7533528208732605,
0.43286818265914917,
-0.8820133209228516,
-0.3437972664833069,
1.2256033420562744,
0.17541097104549408,
-0.03371228277683258,
-0.22845956683158875,
-0.4206852316856384,
0.11320802569389343,
-0.26162147521972656,
0.6750679016113281,
0.7755860090255737,
-0.8146770000457764,
-0.2930007874965668,
-0.3069594204425812,
0.34093567728996277,
0.46262967586517334,
-0.8332233428955078,
0.24148090183734894,
0.5806160569190979,
0.19054020941257477,
-0.03940394148230553,
0.8942211270332336,
-0.06692331284284592,
0.09163517504930496,
-0.47104594111442566,
0.023462878540158272,
0.07201419770717621,
-0.32239916920661926,
-0.7076084613800049,
-0.15822766721248627,
0.497692346572876,
-0.11147470027208328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03366v1 | Uncertainty-Aware Explainable Recommendation with Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T14:06:26 | 2024-01-31T14:06:26 | Yicui Peng, Hao Chen, Chingsheng Lin, Guo Huang, Jinrong Hu, Hui Guo, Bin Kong, Shu Hu, Xi Wu, Xin Wang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Providing explanations within the recommendation system would boost user
satisfaction and foster trust, especially by elaborating on the reasons for
selecting recommended items tailored to the user. The predominant approach in
this domain revolves around generating text-based explanations, with a notable
emphasis on applying large language models (LLMs). However, refining LLMs for
explainable recommendations proves impractical due to time constraints and
computing resource limitations. As an alternative, the current approach
involves training the prompt rather than the LLM. In this study, we developed a
model that utilizes the ID vectors of user and item inputs as prompts for
GPT-2. We employed a joint training mechanism within a multi-task learning
framework to optimize both the recommendation task and explanation task. This
strategy enables a more effective exploration of users' interests, improving
recommendation effectiveness and user satisfaction. Through the experiments,
our method achieving 1.59 DIV, 0.57 USR and 0.41 FCR on the Yelp, TripAdvisor
and Amazon dataset respectively, demonstrates superior performance over four
SOTA methods in terms of explainability evaluation metric. In addition, we
identified that the proposed model is able to ensure stable textual quality on
the three public datasets. | [
-0.23957929015159607,
-0.6721209287643433,
1.0867531299591064,
0.0786491334438324,
-0.3283500373363495,
-0.2796429395675659,
-0.3699522316455841,
-0.40157434344291687,
-0.2274325042963028,
0.12482890486717224,
-0.8998448252677917,
-0.3535453975200653,
-0.5632351636886597,
-0.09054578840732574,
0.008119734935462475,
1.405325174331665,
-0.2971551716327667,
0.017710408195853233,
-0.17558400332927704,
-0.0032214971724897623,
-0.6778793334960938,
-0.2690216898918152,
-0.9767289757728577,
-0.44852128624916077,
0.6157607436180115,
0.5560135245323181,
0.777505099773407,
0.41897642612457275,
0.22292549908161163,
0.12888741493225098,
0.050302255898714066,
0.3010898530483246,
-0.45121100544929504,
0.20777718722820282,
-0.5298643112182617,
-0.3972340226173401,
-0.239317387342453,
-0.29416900873184204,
0.18566899001598358,
0.5071274042129517,
-0.262517511844635,
0.04153492674231529,
0.22889764606952667,
0.625947892665863,
-0.31713420152664185,
0.26681581139564514,
-0.3759191632270813,
-0.18639595806598663,
0.0572587214410305,
-0.06802037358283997,
-0.17052550613880157,
-0.26790398359298706,
0.6582769155502319,
-1.0875296592712402,
0.16951005160808563,
0.3531276285648346,
0.7095200419425964,
0.17047612369060516,
-0.276584267616272,
-0.5066486597061157,
-0.8509811162948608,
0.6747608184814453,
-0.4190300703048706,
0.47987982630729675,
0.6546423435211182,
0.4732646346092224,
-0.17250069975852966,
-0.48297277092933655,
-0.48645147681236267,
-0.0682743564248085,
-0.0874265804886818,
0.08850018680095673,
-0.1888662725687027,
-0.11455606669187546,
0.035084646195173264,
0.10002709925174713,
-0.8925623893737793,
0.1583082377910614,
0.14413194358348846,
-0.2540501356124878,
0.3352338671684265,
-0.057057805359363556,
-0.0038121354300528765,
0.01156550832092762,
-0.5493435263633728,
0.08539308607578278,
-0.6332285404205322,
0.28966137766838074,
0.383084774017334,
0.27660781145095825,
-0.017242755740880966,
0.49951428174972534,
-0.2151186168193817,
0.4705575704574585,
0.1780969202518463,
-0.1666562557220459,
-0.029118819162249565,
-0.4005591869354248,
-0.06966547667980194,
-0.24471060931682587,
0.83158940076828,
0.5410990715026855,
0.17834849655628204,
-0.2970580756664276,
-0.20524002611637115,
-0.18711885809898376,
0.07274790108203888,
-0.7507176399230957,
-0.012407473288476467,
0.5171744227409363,
-0.4833674430847168,
0.04350372031331062,
0.077348493039608,
-0.7626050114631653,
-0.6298372745513916,
-0.36218374967575073,
0.660302460193634,
-0.5957596898078918,
-0.288268119096756,
0.2102964073419571,
-0.006034717429429293,
-0.3323114812374115,
0.4815756380558014,
-0.9821390509605408,
0.04855765402317047,
0.4680895209312439,
0.6476422548294067,
-0.19801023602485657,
-0.3160860538482666,
-0.40811967849731445,
0.19020143151283264,
-0.06168321892619133,
0.7648544907569885,
-0.4577740430831909,
-0.25848326086997986,
0.14376647770404816,
-0.02245481126010418,
0.19201628863811493,
-0.19379465281963348,
0.5729612708091736,
-0.5767292380332947,
0.4258503317832947,
-0.6720419526100159,
-0.5153778195381165,
-0.6103598475456238,
0.1489112675189972,
-0.2827340364456177,
0.9557762145996094,
0.2362256944179535,
-0.496642142534256,
0.6780667901039124,
-0.7970942854881287,
-0.26237356662750244,
0.05185166746377945,
0.0028929051477462053,
-0.2990173399448395,
-0.09573032706975937,
0.7183910608291626,
0.654435932636261,
-0.5322496891021729,
0.6155468821525574,
-0.3175753057003021,
-0.47637516260147095,
0.2272203415632248,
-0.529497504234314,
0.33548998832702637,
0.2971271276473999,
-0.2956361770629883,
0.42549562454223633,
-0.43050044775009155,
-0.22153300046920776,
0.1964772641658783,
-0.15255820751190186,
-0.23696590960025787,
-0.027354519814252853,
0.0768890231847763,
0.05297105386853218,
0.3597983419895172,
-0.042861487716436386,
0.052430130541324615,
-0.3891459107398987,
0.5414943099021912,
0.7809790372848511,
0.1588704138994217,
0.40621325373649597,
-0.3639144003391266,
0.642246663570404,
0.015721827745437622,
0.07240226864814758,
-0.28611552715301514,
-0.38702934980392456,
-0.44449952244758606,
-0.04628405347466469,
0.025450898334383965,
0.32763051986694336,
-0.8763059973716736,
0.33974766731262207,
-0.25442028045654297,
-0.37014392018318176,
-0.26006895303726196,
0.1122983992099762,
0.33104628324508667,
0.3405367434024811,
0.4074263274669647,
0.05220238119363785,
-0.35493454337120056,
-0.5636746883392334,
-0.35578399896621704,
-0.2964443266391754,
-0.32665228843688965,
0.4478166997432709,
0.34350547194480896,
-0.26346415281295776,
0.9158113598823547,
-0.40733271837234497,
-0.10936879366636276,
-0.3458959460258484,
0.21265727281570435,
0.3315112888813019,
0.07716096937656403,
0.3570607006549835,
-0.6752150654792786,
-0.4156409800052643,
-0.11808501183986664,
-0.48384666442871094,
0.1389983743429184,
-0.35183003544807434,
-0.03874991461634636,
-0.056924838572740555,
0.08127492666244507,
-0.5103139281272888,
0.11725282669067383,
0.3608165383338928,
-0.45066505670547485,
0.5572086572647095,
-0.5385646224021912,
0.22584520280361176,
-1.2452445030212402,
-0.26393556594848633,
0.4171903133392334,
-0.2967424988746643,
-0.3624865412712097,
-0.15955369174480438,
-0.09707148373126984,
-0.07225203514099121,
-0.07805398851633072,
0.5118287205696106,
-0.31187668442726135,
0.05022434517741203,
-0.24992148578166962,
0.19995100796222687,
0.08241856843233109,
0.658542811870575,
-0.05084622651338577,
0.84246826171875,
0.7668248414993286,
-0.60240638256073,
0.21582017838954926,
0.1381048709154129,
-0.4220953583717346,
0.752006471157074,
-0.8506307601928711,
0.09274878352880478,
-0.18533442914485931,
0.4603542685508728,
-1.2588250637054443,
-0.3263709843158722,
0.3577774167060852,
-0.16118861734867096,
0.059928420931100845,
-0.22207476198673248,
-0.307451993227005,
-0.33749720454216003,
-0.23526927828788757,
0.2765921652317047,
0.2737399935722351,
-0.7745650410652161,
0.5042239427566528,
0.010722609236836433,
-0.365570604801178,
-0.6157558560371399,
-0.23820938169956207,
-0.12184074521064758,
-0.519931435585022,
-0.48114943504333496,
0.4113660752773285,
-0.3144264221191406,
-0.05058622732758522,
-0.05016462132334709,
-0.26977264881134033,
-0.02556539699435234,
0.12322184443473816,
0.5675632953643799,
0.3471226990222931,
0.028266286477446556,
0.5822417736053467,
0.013860180974006653,
-0.24872799217700958,
0.0463341660797596,
-0.6786317825317383,
0.43012985587120056,
-0.20942218601703644,
-0.3255878686904907,
-0.6717696785926819,
0.31304240226745605,
0.44075697660446167,
-0.10859278589487076,
0.7008951902389526,
1.0897676944732666,
-0.27102598547935486,
-0.1441439986228943,
-0.4281763732433319,
-0.3593326807022095,
-0.4434293508529663,
0.4562506675720215,
-0.5390365719795227,
-1.1633875370025635,
0.42983385920524597,
-0.10272518545389175,
-0.1337881237268448,
0.4278991222381592,
0.6934412121772766,
-0.18319404125213623,
0.8825893402099609,
0.5524303317070007,
-0.04863962158560753,
0.4559118449687958,
-0.0022053145803511143,
0.3731978237628937,
-0.4848490357398987,
-0.2612675726413727,
-0.3841935396194458,
-0.1211027055978775,
-0.26304370164871216,
-0.3691733777523041,
0.3618759512901306,
0.2400497943162918,
-0.21427789330482483,
0.21886707842350006,
-0.46298590302467346,
0.36347323656082153,
0.7865604758262634,
0.37871310114860535,
0.1869741827249527,
0.11618111282587051,
-0.04617011547088623,
0.04637089744210243,
-0.553878128528595,
-0.40692630410194397,
1.0734630823135376,
0.563200056552887,
0.7878393530845642,
0.14956888556480408,
0.23591835796833038,
0.34862425923347473,
-0.23428480327129364,
-0.8617509007453918,
0.18421043455600739,
0.050073448568582535,
-0.506024956703186,
-0.5988146066665649,
-0.3318486511707306,
-0.7588691711425781,
-0.07196585088968277,
-0.34712859988212585,
-0.9184672236442566,
0.09602953493595123,
0.2285299152135849,
-0.7184258699417114,
-0.055879075080156326,
-0.720565915107727,
0.7537484765052795,
-0.2874360978603363,
-0.34270086884498596,
-0.2959486246109009,
-0.579472541809082,
-0.01949204131960869,
-0.20818838477134705,
0.28925132751464844,
-0.09172359853982925,
0.16357561945915222,
0.833989679813385,
-0.39759954810142517,
0.5017225742340088,
-0.40962010622024536,
-0.07684818655252457,
0.18185105919837952,
0.05184631794691086,
0.9640730023384094,
0.3733573257923126,
-0.1870829313993454,
0.1351993829011917,
-0.21526795625686646,
-0.05513850972056389,
-0.7880458831787109,
0.7039411664009094,
-0.7701964378356934,
-0.5940170288085938,
-0.08415617793798447,
-0.8044245839118958,
-0.4753296375274658,
0.051485512405633926,
0.34250032901763916,
0.3671155869960785,
0.1456397920846939,
0.011929286643862724,
0.701585054397583,
-0.2530606687068939,
0.3166123628616333,
0.49415698647499084,
-0.19515393674373627,
-0.27825120091438293,
0.9813092350959778,
0.04622292518615723,
-0.09270699322223663,
0.42812660336494446,
0.4371374845504761,
-0.7096712589263916,
-0.785121500492096,
-0.45990052819252014,
0.04187549650669098,
-0.48832324147224426,
0.12020505964756012,
-0.5793390870094299,
0.3390299081802368,
-0.26028892397880554,
-0.17629285156726837,
-0.02429712750017643,
-0.3835395276546478,
-0.2651837468147278,
-0.29995661973953247,
0.650484561920166,
0.798917293548584,
0.12815873324871063,
0.7161499857902527,
-0.3756033778190613,
0.4066985547542572,
0.49173253774642944,
0.627482533454895,
-0.06288915127515793,
-0.6490513682365417,
-0.4636101722717285,
0.14183716475963593,
-0.004559709690511227,
-0.8536030054092407,
0.07388196885585785,
0.06080169975757599,
0.5616622567176819,
0.7176534533500671,
0.16608993709087372,
0.6023092269897461,
-0.16091784834861755,
0.9010543823242188,
0.22567690908908844,
-0.8177735805511475,
0.6357926726341248,
-0.6103311777114868,
0.31258833408355713,
0.5147478580474854,
0.6334148645401001,
-0.3891005218029022,
-0.14403580129146576,
-0.3050471246242523,
-1.0264214277267456,
0.8287044167518616,
0.05089602991938591,
-0.15256649255752563,
0.34065642952919006,
0.4213463366031647,
0.6276512145996094,
0.199101522564888,
-0.7045802474021912,
-0.27322840690612793,
-0.07852693647146225,
-0.3131179213523865,
-0.37172508239746094,
-0.7344017624855042,
-0.14243808388710022,
0.15861406922340393,
0.9440854787826538,
-0.07638239860534668,
0.28727585077285767,
0.031062228605151176,
0.02730751596391201,
-0.216335266828537,
0.5127901434898376,
0.6163974404335022,
0.9981514811515808,
-0.31276828050613403,
0.013931157998740673,
-0.034676458686590195,
-0.2223511040210724,
0.1306651383638382,
0.3653610944747925,
0.045691825449466705,
-0.15147119760513306,
0.06639878451824188,
1.0520113706588745,
-0.15758267045021057,
-0.4618242681026459,
0.4807240664958954,
-0.20467281341552734,
-0.1885138750076294,
-0.1619793176651001,
-0.05603048577904701,
0.1704549640417099,
0.3864651620388031,
0.3908044397830963,
0.1992160677909851,
0.2807713747024536,
-0.3362691402435303,
-0.055203963071107864,
0.2711862027645111,
-0.728011429309845,
-0.16632963716983795,
0.6388120055198669,
0.12416169792413712,
-0.132424995303154,
0.33983558416366577,
-0.23236650228500366,
-0.2906973361968994,
0.10135141015052795,
0.48999086022377014,
0.744094729423523,
-0.03278423473238945,
0.468642920255661,
0.20043131709098816,
0.2502060532569885,
-0.29091545939445496,
0.2185782492160797,
-0.10595619678497314,
-0.6786074042320251,
-0.34816399216651917,
-0.4174576699733734,
-0.5113571286201477,
0.1459299921989441,
-0.6995985507965088,
0.08170434087514877,
-0.25790661573410034,
-0.12938961386680603,
0.08574233949184418,
-0.22636926174163818,
-0.7625147104263306,
0.2484942376613617,
-0.24828164279460907,
0.4206790328025818,
-0.8696804642677307,
0.5860102772712708,
0.7555783987045288,
-0.43309688568115234,
-1.1646071672439575,
0.1759716272354126,
0.1677631139755249,
-0.8743769526481628,
0.12631893157958984,
0.1403270959854126,
-0.0629894956946373,
-0.22927142679691315,
-0.2121378481388092,
-0.5743046402931213,
1.0874207019805908,
0.47902706265449524,
-0.6383021473884583,
0.06124082952737808,
-0.11983293294906616,
0.5425901412963867,
-0.2762790322303772,
0.5195852518081665,
0.30118298530578613,
0.5715526342391968,
0.11836222559213638,
-0.7609481811523438,
0.2102397233247757,
0.07184521853923798,
0.08867239952087402,
-0.04047475755214691,
-0.3336763381958008,
0.5515445470809937,
-0.4469391703605652,
0.0362260676920414,
-0.09587924927473068,
0.5695974230766296,
0.2837280333042145,
0.5001886487007141,
0.7556940913200378,
0.36592480540275574,
0.9879555702209473,
-0.17373739182949066,
1.0970685482025146,
-0.08245015144348145,
0.3272585868835449,
1.4373259544372559,
-0.0839722529053688,
0.6460110545158386,
0.5677204132080078,
-0.30378323793411255,
0.6319937109947205,
1.098126769065857,
0.04901367053389549,
0.6123276352882385,
-0.05655515193939209,
-0.0470619723200798,
-0.3066844642162323,
-0.37612247467041016,
-0.338508665561676,
0.14856038987636566,
0.30231404304504395,
-0.4527462422847748,
-0.08695190399885178,
0.33861401677131653,
-0.02736726962029934,
-0.12793923914432526,
-0.25448548793792725,
0.8201242089271545,
-0.1322895735502243,
-0.7969032526016235,
0.3409382998943329,
0.06196051836013794,
0.5418220162391663,
-0.7115556597709656,
-0.025692777708172798,
0.025544730946421623,
0.02545863576233387,
-0.10896531492471695,
-0.7769081592559814,
-0.18752187490463257,
-0.02291197143495083,
-0.6545576453208923,
-0.43684035539627075,
0.5845469832420349,
-0.5390037298202515,
-0.37495726346969604,
0.13249018788337708,
0.4704795479774475,
0.24744898080825806,
-0.38118329644203186,
-0.6846608519554138,
-0.28441062569618225,
0.1432599127292633,
-0.28784915804862976,
0.19441640377044678,
0.5851739048957825,
-0.10196793079376221,
0.9225386381149292,
0.6576882600784302,
-0.09466880559921265,
-0.5265417098999023,
0.14919331669807434,
0.5141292214393616,
-0.21314483880996704,
-0.6644505858421326,
-0.7511529922485352,
0.5117009878158569,
0.24300003051757812,
-0.2671687602996826,
0.6690320372581482,
0.19146758317947388,
0.5999847650527954,
-0.20858174562454224,
0.9283031225204468,
0.1387617588043213,
0.5890613794326782,
-0.4850344955921173,
0.43696898221969604,
-0.5310637950897217,
0.6818681955337524,
-0.1998729705810547,
-0.9796204566955566,
0.0412137396633625,
0.46030232310295105,
-0.35507023334503174,
0.34010791778564453,
0.9105744361877441,
0.6629040241241455,
0.08366506546735764,
0.1239318698644638,
0.08417446911334991,
0.14237649738788605,
0.2087767869234085,
0.5887476801872253,
0.6266264915466309,
-0.21607926487922668,
0.7655477523803711,
-0.043275587260723114,
-0.19769276678562164,
-0.3790791630744934,
-0.8072047829627991,
-0.7746961712837219,
-0.5973702669143677,
-0.35791289806365967,
-0.3819088041782379,
0.34366375207901,
1.0880941152572632,
0.8355588912963867,
-0.8354542851448059,
-0.05150749161839485,
-0.1718428134918213,
0.2892760634422302,
-0.6514753699302673,
-0.21170730888843536,
0.5536903142929077,
-0.09368433058261871,
-0.4893300235271454,
0.4712265133857727,
0.19403284788131714,
0.0887887254357338,
-0.21579568088054657,
-0.30429959297180176,
0.11897268891334534,
-0.18665803968906403,
0.2852989137172699,
-0.10161226987838745,
-0.901469886302948,
-0.4182915687561035,
-0.09192809462547302,
0.1337539553642273,
-0.24095042049884796,
0.6434417366981506,
-0.4905831813812256,
0.7217121720314026,
0.2606920897960663,
0.5430876612663269,
0.4887983500957489,
0.08607564121484756,
0.9204708933830261,
-0.6360483169555664,
-0.15596874058246613,
-0.13729573786258698,
0.4309629499912262,
0.13547085225582123,
-0.758680522441864,
0.4429893493652344,
-0.07296356558799744,
-0.7904889583587646,
-0.33838340640068054,
0.13906700909137726,
-1.2441356182098389,
-0.2946144640445709,
1.3452130556106567,
-0.5742632150650024,
0.29523470997810364,
-0.3964449465274811,
-0.39982202649116516,
0.22720769047737122,
-0.8626921772956848,
0.8013393878936768,
0.9644792675971985,
-0.04349333420395851,
-0.10858829319477081,
-0.37658122181892395,
0.48664918541908264,
0.3640921711921692,
-0.679614245891571,
0.2478940784931183,
0.4754999876022339,
0.32348501682281494,
-0.17111483216285706,
0.4945453405380249,
0.3437228798866272,
0.341217041015625,
-0.27500683069229126,
-0.14055809378623962,
-0.3312593102455139,
-0.49459704756736755,
-0.4212955832481384,
0.2645375430583954,
0.41132652759552,
-0.05927399545907974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17839v1 | Global-Liar: Factuality of LLMs over Time and Geographic Regions | 2024-01-31T13:57:24 | 2024-01-31T13:57:24 | Shujaat Mirza, Bruno Coelho, Yuyuan Cui, Christina Pöpper, Damon McCoy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The increasing reliance on AI-driven solutions, particularly Large Language
Models (LLMs) like the GPT series, for information retrieval highlights the
critical need for their factuality and fairness, especially amidst the rampant
spread of misinformation and disinformation online. Our study evaluates the
factual accuracy, stability, and biases in widely adopted GPT models, including
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, contributing to reliability and integrity of AI-mediated
information dissemination.
We introduce 'Global-Liar,' a dataset uniquely balanced in terms of
geographic and temporal representation, facilitating a more nuanced evaluation
of LLM biases. Our analysis reveals that newer iterations of GPT models do not
always equate to improved performance. Notably, the GPT-4 version from March
demonstrates higher factual accuracy than its subsequent June release.
Furthermore, a concerning bias is observed, privileging statements from the
Global North over the Global South, thus potentially exacerbating existing
informational inequities. Regions such as Africa and the Middle East are at a
disadvantage, with much lower factual accuracy. The performance fluctuations
over time suggest that model updates may not consistently benefit all regions
equally.
Our study also offers insights into the impact of various LLM configuration
settings, such as binary decision forcing, model re-runs and temperature, on
model's factuality. Models constrained to binary (true/false) choices exhibit
reduced factuality compared to those allowing an 'unclear' option. Single
inference at a low temperature setting matches the reliability of majority
voting across various configurations. The insights gained highlight the need
for culturally diverse and geographically inclusive model training and
evaluation. This approach is key to achieving global equity in technology,
distributing AI benefits fairly worldwide. | [
-0.0013454529689624906,
-0.6447060704231262,
0.878122866153717,
0.09119583666324615,
-0.0035775876604020596,
0.2371390461921692,
-0.04958471283316612,
-0.6099332571029663,
-0.13932153582572937,
0.13941487669944763,
-0.301758736371994,
-0.4539742171764374,
-0.7626858353614807,
-0.02576649747788906,
-0.3941936790943146,
1.1403342485427856,
0.05541718751192093,
0.029249975457787514,
-0.1681928038597107,
-0.26609480381011963,
-0.2506144344806671,
-0.8819118738174438,
-0.32365882396698,
-0.5029338002204895,
0.330003947019577,
0.06846296787261963,
1.2259362936019897,
0.6269364953041077,
0.5901808142662048,
0.3234095573425293,
-0.10232805460691452,
0.04609354957938194,
-0.5025908946990967,
-0.05956258252263069,
-0.23630167543888092,
-0.658232569694519,
-0.3788520097732544,
0.24327406287193298,
0.6471452713012695,
0.48938941955566406,
-0.28688129782676697,
0.3012674152851105,
-0.050927843898534775,
0.4825451672077179,
-0.47899723052978516,
0.18552616238594055,
-0.7669817805290222,
-0.09285003691911697,
-0.07929643988609314,
0.13657423853874207,
-0.19738683104515076,
-0.8218182325363159,
0.47473064064979553,
-0.3100874423980713,
0.660213828086853,
0.011056488379836082,
0.9527537822723389,
0.38938769698143005,
-0.7140820622444153,
-0.5313241481781006,
-1.1307973861694336,
0.7349297404289246,
-0.619351863861084,
0.20220842957496643,
0.1658838391304016,
0.3884362578392029,
0.06487885862588882,
-0.7119259834289551,
-0.46474146842956543,
-0.4557657837867737,
-0.025347359478473663,
0.12407239526510239,
-0.10289505869150162,
-0.13124483823776245,
0.28406253457069397,
0.33814966678619385,
-0.5736755132675171,
-0.027969632297754288,
-0.4537971317768097,
-0.5137479305267334,
0.5182836055755615,
0.07395830005407333,
0.406332790851593,
-0.07396747916936874,
-0.3437292277812958,
0.44755974411964417,
-1.0800284147262573,
-0.21281927824020386,
0.6234858632087708,
0.3687421381473541,
-0.37124887108802795,
0.542743980884552,
-0.027002671733498573,
0.42462435364723206,
-0.29076749086380005,
-0.5079160928726196,
-0.040701232850551605,
-0.49187028408050537,
-0.0788484662771225,
0.06054740771651268,
0.4071711599826813,
0.2994096279144287,
0.013364671729505062,
-0.3491522967815399,
-0.12998159229755402,
0.35440048575401306,
0.017581306397914886,
-0.701777458190918,
-0.05285250395536423,
0.013576737605035305,
-0.32366910576820374,
-0.00545935845002532,
0.3526074290275574,
-0.5445824861526489,
-0.38829106092453003,
-0.5438529253005981,
0.20685622096061707,
-0.0670861154794693,
-0.13152197003364563,
-0.13180619478225708,
0.09183405339717865,
0.1864490807056427,
0.36450448632240295,
-0.640917956829071,
0.203631192445755,
0.7269331812858582,
1.0867761373519897,
-0.07825993746519089,
-0.11883020401000977,
-0.0483868271112442,
0.1331292688846588,
-0.2788262665271759,
0.6050004363059998,
-0.5826277136802673,
-0.22974883019924164,
-0.07372256368398666,
-0.04352708160877228,
0.09554491937160492,
-0.4825875461101532,
0.5579096674919128,
-0.6773203611373901,
0.440561443567276,
-0.8164777755737305,
-0.21603937447071075,
-0.26847994327545166,
0.2756263017654419,
-0.6964501738548279,
0.8054840564727783,
-0.10947025567293167,
-0.7202789783477783,
0.35068997740745544,
-0.586591362953186,
-0.07611177116632462,
-0.28770655393600464,
-0.35429877042770386,
-0.3071223497390747,
-0.02282879315316677,
0.3709891736507416,
0.12702076137065887,
-0.40256166458129883,
0.6918495893478394,
-0.2868851125240326,
-0.6848886609077454,
0.0754174217581749,
-0.9987843632698059,
0.8494247794151306,
0.08406224101781845,
-0.6995547413825989,
-0.16741736233234406,
-0.4836176335811615,
-0.24823109805583954,
0.20581762492656708,
-0.2927408218383789,
0.009037872776389122,
0.06197679787874222,
-0.4598069489002228,
0.17638468742370605,
0.28215155005455017,
-0.6026638150215149,
0.25206342339515686,
-0.2637414038181305,
0.31126025319099426,
0.970099151134491,
-0.13577014207839966,
0.36772552132606506,
-0.5981676578521729,
0.5831731557846069,
-0.060839615762233734,
0.25812819600105286,
0.19337160885334015,
-0.5901709198951721,
-0.6814962029457092,
-0.13769154250621796,
0.32547783851623535,
0.9214165806770325,
-0.6711520552635193,
-0.04363546893000603,
-0.5881490111351013,
-0.4930538535118103,
-0.500170886516571,
-0.19720707833766937,
0.22350525856018066,
0.49553123116493225,
0.09293815493583679,
0.11264488101005554,
-0.3154808282852173,
-0.9952693581581116,
-0.21010352671146393,
-0.3808003067970276,
-0.022827615961432457,
0.35582613945007324,
0.6321064233779907,
-0.1938984990119934,
1.1657061576843262,
-0.22299250960350037,
-0.011526127345860004,
-0.02789323218166828,
0.16003641486167908,
0.41866859793663025,
-0.09091740846633911,
0.6042829155921936,
-0.9308493137359619,
-0.2903476059436798,
-0.1519547402858734,
-0.8918340802192688,
0.004542077425867319,
-0.06680691242218018,
0.22502954304218292,
0.6368104815483093,
-0.08603877574205399,
-0.5740700960159302,
0.6143864989280701,
0.7473894953727722,
-0.395863801240921,
0.7715036273002625,
-0.1592913419008255,
0.32834410667419434,
-0.6572375297546387,
0.1414380967617035,
0.009977426379919052,
-0.26060032844543457,
-0.27729862928390503,
0.021365981549024582,
-0.21149992942810059,
0.051836613565683365,
-0.41450563073158264,
0.6733207702636719,
-0.42457467317581177,
-0.39188218116760254,
-0.0557282529771328,
0.31800466775894165,
-0.16766127943992615,
0.10550464689731598,
-0.45017141103744507,
1.1811304092407227,
0.23947028815746307,
-0.4506053030490875,
0.6074706315994263,
0.03035435453057289,
-0.4211984872817993,
0.31831473112106323,
-0.6739725470542908,
0.16407892107963562,
-0.26151934266090393,
0.38561880588531494,
-0.6986609101295471,
-0.16076482832431793,
0.24988357722759247,
-0.43126222491264343,
0.07287414371967316,
-0.34398820996284485,
-0.5622122287750244,
-0.21823349595069885,
0.03602205589413643,
0.25450217723846436,
0.4250151216983795,
-0.623231053352356,
0.5205429792404175,
0.27414509654045105,
-0.4384683072566986,
-1.0167559385299683,
-0.6709256172180176,
0.2696041762828827,
-0.19010838866233826,
-0.7560091614723206,
0.16304346919059753,
-0.02713266760110855,
-0.5793588161468506,
0.19478721916675568,
-0.3167364299297333,
0.1830073893070221,
0.011350023560225964,
0.12026330828666687,
0.4184539318084717,
-0.11955330520868301,
0.04008667543530464,
-0.5522989630699158,
-0.12997572124004364,
0.17340239882469177,
-0.3453648090362549,
0.32248905301094055,
-0.5217623710632324,
-0.6837573647499084,
-0.27738094329833984,
0.19944027066230774,
0.44328737258911133,
0.024133900180459023,
0.908580482006073,
0.6572958827018738,
-0.29764676094055176,
0.23190347850322723,
-0.6808116436004639,
-0.11944247037172318,
-0.43665167689323425,
0.3935040831565857,
-0.06380586326122284,
-0.860510528087616,
0.7411656379699707,
0.10332638025283813,
0.09820257872343063,
0.40677472949028015,
0.4814451038837433,
0.15717825293540955,
0.8604159355163574,
0.7356032133102417,
-0.5056178569793701,
0.0851190835237503,
-0.17467615008354187,
0.49282827973365784,
-0.3281654715538025,
-0.34671100974082947,
-0.5364483594894409,
-0.3020663559436798,
-0.8797456622123718,
-0.4265955984592438,
0.6095930337905884,
-0.27210766077041626,
-0.7121015191078186,
-0.7181767225265503,
-0.20742973685264587,
0.7340524196624756,
0.6419008374214172,
0.12106896936893463,
0.46293288469314575,
0.2898246645927429,
-0.22741764783859253,
-0.42973560094833374,
-0.6648011207580566,
-0.7833097577095032,
1.2190247774124146,
0.33362191915512085,
0.8648080825805664,
0.5524933338165283,
0.12519700825214386,
0.5130658149719238,
0.6469371318817139,
-0.44871291518211365,
0.3412356972694397,
-0.1864526867866516,
-0.8126853704452515,
-0.15354977548122406,
-0.49079370498657227,
-0.5363754034042358,
0.08952056616544724,
-0.004259186331182718,
-0.632243812084198,
-0.13789261877536774,
0.081722691655159,
-0.22732949256896973,
0.7045058012008667,
-0.45897096395492554,
0.437307745218277,
-0.4641367197036743,
-0.3167174458503723,
-0.11370386183261871,
-0.754283607006073,
0.5556582808494568,
0.009716939181089401,
0.215749129652977,
-0.35942503809928894,
-0.12610489130020142,
0.3166680932044983,
-0.24127274751663208,
1.0764826536178589,
-0.28902924060821533,
-0.05579652264714241,
0.2693893015384674,
0.04781873896718025,
0.5982566475868225,
0.21961435675621033,
-0.33593323826789856,
0.5273027420043945,
-0.3362615406513214,
-0.49705779552459717,
-0.6051750183105469,
0.6767290830612183,
-1.1896843910217285,
-0.8155537843704224,
-0.9110630750656128,
-0.5016138553619385,
-0.027137484401464462,
0.10617660731077194,
0.2872261106967926,
0.6466202139854431,
-0.23239414393901825,
0.0040411576628685,
0.7277560234069824,
-0.2612726390361786,
0.12062083184719086,
0.41528406739234924,
-0.25885623693466187,
-0.30946412682533264,
0.8205606341362,
0.38650351762771606,
0.40843379497528076,
0.12202001363039017,
0.15300439298152924,
-0.5118381977081299,
-0.4832402169704437,
-0.2070811241865158,
0.5290356874465942,
-0.9535138607025146,
-0.0517285130918026,
-0.27004382014274597,
-0.464011549949646,
-0.22839118540287018,
-0.02253427542746067,
-0.2211889922618866,
-0.2733195424079895,
-0.05858360975980759,
-0.2101699411869049,
0.2367778867483139,
1.058579444885254,
-0.23385533690452576,
0.4286191761493683,
-0.48349112272262573,
0.3844568133354187,
0.21470215916633606,
0.32328134775161743,
-0.2929341495037079,
-0.6632358431816101,
-0.10148444026708603,
0.27799537777900696,
-0.3213183581829071,
-0.7809566855430603,
0.22991228103637695,
0.08670832216739655,
0.708543062210083,
0.01483907550573349,
0.04635065793991089,
0.5868726372718811,
-0.4462580978870392,
1.0658622980117798,
-0.23451505601406097,
-0.8775769472122192,
0.396390438079834,
-0.49234238266944885,
0.3269706070423126,
0.13920505344867706,
0.6916850805282593,
-0.5907807350158691,
-0.4519820213317871,
-0.6772084832191467,
-0.8818084597587585,
0.5060485601425171,
-0.061134979128837585,
0.14188842475414276,
0.30166831612586975,
0.5895583629608154,
0.189170241355896,
0.29798606038093567,
-1.0253146886825562,
-0.5772711038589478,
-0.10452031344175339,
-0.08947459608316422,
0.044353265315294266,
-0.4980694651603699,
-0.29426807165145874,
0.034900419414043427,
0.8888494372367859,
-0.32514238357543945,
0.5450656414031982,
0.35145634412765503,
-0.09425874799489975,
0.1575397551059723,
0.3009498417377472,
0.6079415082931519,
1.3578346967697144,
-0.16088920831680298,
-0.06435956060886383,
0.08235330879688263,
-0.4750533998012543,
0.32973113656044006,
0.08082462847232819,
-0.7300040125846863,
0.20187044143676758,
0.40267518162727356,
0.6937223076820374,
-0.1314481496810913,
-0.18272365629673004,
0.42838141322135925,
-0.2805474102497101,
0.05446310341358185,
-0.5362415313720703,
-0.13421978056430817,
-0.08045859634876251,
0.39356833696365356,
0.481709748506546,
0.3753184378147125,
-0.00572536326944828,
-0.5714714527130127,
0.018793849274516106,
0.5180711150169373,
-0.08469879627227783,
-0.3560905158519745,
0.7989736199378967,
0.06903622299432755,
0.11695937812328339,
1.0111541748046875,
-0.31684085726737976,
-0.7636080384254456,
0.614016056060791,
0.5254740118980408,
0.48575037717819214,
-0.16797639429569244,
0.4661833345890045,
0.2337162345647812,
0.8090874552726746,
-0.1545434147119522,
0.3330851197242737,
0.4637641906738281,
-0.7053591012954712,
-0.5220509171485901,
-0.3710622489452362,
-0.5650485754013062,
0.17783169448375702,
-0.33076244592666626,
-0.027529869228601456,
-0.45911020040512085,
-0.4664989411830902,
-0.7267892956733704,
0.3348919153213501,
-0.8440828323364258,
0.1607663929462433,
0.3732546865940094,
0.6746829152107239,
-0.9321418404579163,
0.4969048500061035,
0.4480149745941162,
-0.09520459920167923,
-0.5199787616729736,
0.30087870359420776,
0.5683720707893372,
-0.8504326343536377,
0.5034793019294739,
0.14687393605709076,
-0.1516929268836975,
-0.3843871057033539,
-0.731541633605957,
-1.3389344215393066,
1.2526514530181885,
0.8601915836334229,
-0.4064003527164459,
-0.19818316400051117,
0.47082534432411194,
0.40742477774620056,
-0.15930727124214172,
0.35927990078926086,
0.6675310134887695,
0.46841683983802795,
0.17162340879440308,
-1.117549180984497,
0.05479889363050461,
0.157231867313385,
0.05363099277019501,
-0.12896813452243805,
-0.995183527469635,
0.7516775727272034,
-0.5782985091209412,
-0.4218580722808838,
0.048408206552267075,
0.7179413437843323,
0.4503368139266968,
0.16891780495643616,
0.22943253815174103,
0.34215405583381653,
1.2097347974777222,
-0.5380616188049316,
1.1426372528076172,
-0.1838054656982422,
0.33678901195526123,
1.0966061353683472,
-0.3552215099334717,
0.4471278488636017,
0.012491164728999138,
-0.3518068492412567,
0.49912285804748535,
0.5923668146133423,
0.014178470708429813,
0.38896411657333374,
-0.02501673810184002,
-0.40173831582069397,
-0.0005810509901493788,
-0.20787617564201355,
-0.43361297249794006,
0.3912944197654724,
0.3952307403087616,
0.023267313838005066,
-0.35734856128692627,
-0.31855303049087524,
0.33694469928741455,
-0.027129020541906357,
-0.30614960193634033,
0.23876693844795227,
0.02645297907292843,
-0.4589676856994629,
0.2385173738002777,
0.07391224801540375,
0.6974223256111145,
-0.5767951011657715,
0.1288750171661377,
-0.5059534311294556,
0.08878565579652786,
-0.13655564188957214,
-0.6366310119628906,
0.4162234365940094,
0.13216224312782288,
-0.35268670320510864,
0.07724981755018234,
0.5736903548240662,
-0.2684510052204132,
-0.7375853061676025,
0.19219136238098145,
0.6051608920097351,
0.02238963358104229,
0.05335626378655434,
-0.9031674861907959,
0.25555330514907837,
0.1330263614654541,
-0.12242096662521362,
-0.00963517650961876,
0.42448994517326355,
-0.18211594223976135,
1.0115312337875366,
0.5335111618041992,
0.47819945216178894,
0.18584701418876648,
-0.023165903985500336,
0.5030945539474487,
-0.6530128717422485,
-0.4305967390537262,
-1.0077221393585205,
0.36247628927230835,
-0.0644700825214386,
0.11141545325517654,
0.7423107028007507,
0.3827522397041321,
0.7797364592552185,
0.39071908593177795,
1.2590099573135376,
0.08033573627471924,
0.5845540761947632,
-0.7075064182281494,
0.6174582242965698,
-0.2418278008699417,
0.5430195331573486,
0.16614970564842224,
-1.030704379081726,
-0.2520017623901367,
0.33631885051727295,
-0.6236749887466431,
0.4248281717300415,
0.5366078615188599,
0.6272991895675659,
0.008787672035396099,
0.148798868060112,
0.07520857453346252,
0.5715540051460266,
0.6774648427963257,
0.27568477392196655,
0.8730725049972534,
-0.33159497380256653,
0.46011772751808167,
-0.0875069797039032,
-0.15519985556602478,
-0.10841375589370728,
-1.0741558074951172,
-0.4096211791038513,
-0.14374354481697083,
-0.21265572309494019,
-0.42543601989746094,
0.30328568816185,
0.7954281568527222,
0.5425133109092712,
-0.6033662557601929,
-0.05121491849422455,
0.6010898351669312,
0.3382185101509094,
0.2311684638261795,
-0.22462475299835205,
0.5192060470581055,
-0.048126280307769775,
-0.5832501649856567,
0.06132057309150696,
0.14507503807544708,
0.23582425713539124,
-0.3808111846446991,
-0.017542360350489616,
0.06130842864513397,
-0.0317765474319458,
0.470622181892395,
0.18059620261192322,
-1.0182188749313354,
-0.4699331521987915,
-0.17976105213165283,
-0.12044664472341537,
0.09305977821350098,
0.5006732940673828,
-0.7784803509712219,
0.20265567302703857,
0.07172508537769318,
0.5686789751052856,
0.09693413972854614,
0.21935898065567017,
0.6937841773033142,
-0.7561517953872681,
0.15363876521587372,
0.2622734606266022,
0.3330862820148468,
0.6627214550971985,
-0.4142269492149353,
0.5718295574188232,
0.5729914903640747,
-1.0493298768997192,
-0.5865516066551208,
0.13288596272468567,
-0.3450224995613098,
-0.08255032449960709,
1.169313907623291,
-0.09754393994808197,
-0.08138219267129898,
-0.2833792269229889,
0.04582350701093674,
0.1389058530330658,
-0.33044323325157166,
0.953709602355957,
0.9500433206558228,
-0.10345292091369629,
0.2430066466331482,
-1.0943639278411865,
0.36713001132011414,
0.10458764433860779,
-0.5960911512374878,
-0.02657070942223072,
0.7430180311203003,
0.537508487701416,
0.12708114087581635,
0.7278833389282227,
-0.11650269478559494,
0.037137605249881744,
-0.10707267373800278,
-0.2953090965747833,
0.15009695291519165,
-0.6160305142402649,
-0.29275643825531006,
0.042708009481430054,
0.0561942532658577,
0.2840610444545746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01765v1 | LLMs Simulate Big Five Personality Traits: Further Evidence | 2024-01-31T13:45:25 | 2024-01-31T13:45:25 | Aleksandra Sorokovikova, Natalia Fedorova, Sharwin Rezagholi, Ivan P. Yamshchikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; J.4; I.2.1 | An empirical investigation into the simulation of the Big Five personality
traits by large language models (LLMs), namely Llama2, GPT4, and Mixtral, is
presented. We analyze the personality traits simulated by these models and
their stability. This contributes to the broader understanding of the
capabilities of LLMs to simulate personality traits and the respective
implications for personalized human-computer interaction. | [
-0.6316787600517273,
-0.7190846800804138,
0.8842812180519104,
0.470611572265625,
0.12052971869707108,
0.09247787296772003,
-0.26929768919944763,
-0.46861547231674194,
0.4235715866088867,
0.7096410989761353,
-0.6180670857429504,
-0.4093700349330902,
-0.4655855596065521,
0.24558041989803314,
-0.38822227716445923,
0.802745521068573,
0.15441668033599854,
0.24002091586589813,
-0.2604927718639374,
-0.10972679406404495,
-0.4064975678920746,
-1.1739102602005005,
-0.6287092566490173,
-0.5979182720184326,
0.6960127949714661,
0.5059782862663269,
0.6540610194206238,
0.03720885515213013,
0.5094429850578308,
0.3359817564487457,
-0.14289119839668274,
-0.07247713953256607,
-0.6592930555343628,
0.21339958906173706,
-0.0022600064985454082,
-0.5428565144538879,
-0.6443136930465698,
0.2899942100048065,
0.7317511439323425,
0.6042956113815308,
-0.3850060701370239,
0.12763351202011108,
-0.1301332265138626,
0.3332090973854065,
-0.05508051812648773,
-0.047210924327373505,
-0.2874918580055237,
-0.22460868954658508,
-0.0354745052754879,
0.015292261727154255,
-0.42874255776405334,
-0.4174860715866089,
0.1141752228140831,
-0.2009873390197754,
0.0955483466386795,
0.1291874498128891,
0.7317783832550049,
0.08257663249969482,
-0.656682014465332,
-0.17643089592456818,
-1.055891990661621,
0.8724753260612488,
-0.8408164381980896,
0.036789897829294205,
0.5664108395576477,
0.5377238988876343,
-0.3877332806587219,
-0.49439552426338196,
-0.9305568337440491,
-0.2933768033981323,
-0.06182066351175308,
0.1251513957977295,
0.21163812279701233,
0.2717382311820984,
0.3551436960697174,
0.39616578817367554,
-0.23747576773166656,
0.37781110405921936,
-0.43404972553253174,
-0.02212623506784439,
0.9204105734825134,
0.47606945037841797,
0.2578856647014618,
0.3034569025039673,
-0.022001665085554123,
-0.21159909665584564,
-0.946581244468689,
-0.16522905230522156,
0.6671493649482727,
-0.2969580888748169,
-0.14007706940174103,
0.712726891040802,
-0.072153739631176,
0.2733350098133087,
0.2131788581609726,
-0.6852410435676575,
0.29410746693611145,
-0.2658940553665161,
-0.23208793997764587,
0.08176006376743317,
0.5322583317756653,
0.5347874164581299,
0.5107575058937073,
-0.005237538367509842,
-0.011017406359314919,
0.22207462787628174,
0.18335531651973724,
-0.9447396397590637,
-0.23127463459968567,
0.67552649974823,
-0.6820946931838989,
-0.4116794764995575,
-0.23004919290542603,
-0.545016348361969,
-0.5450108051300049,
-0.2263331562280655,
0.016109835356473923,
-0.5341044664382935,
-0.34383562207221985,
-0.11774786561727524,
-0.22259022295475006,
0.494679719209671,
0.4067307710647583,
-1.1291199922561646,
0.6317011713981628,
0.6095213294029236,
0.4768576920032501,
-0.2911805510520935,
-0.5581777691841125,
-0.19070672988891602,
0.025397973135113716,
-0.255528062582016,
0.5231044292449951,
-0.8138431310653687,
-0.6861786842346191,
-0.03927658125758171,
-0.1336458921432495,
0.352151483297348,
-0.5874817371368408,
0.42325469851493835,
-0.4947041869163513,
0.18379999697208405,
-0.8045468330383301,
-0.6936721801757812,
-0.09223198145627975,
0.4295462369918823,
-0.5115044713020325,
0.8648632168769836,
0.10673010349273682,
-0.6436194181442261,
0.4052307605743408,
-0.6230224967002869,
-0.19597779214382172,
-0.3149451017379761,
-0.29734528064727783,
-0.4942631423473358,
0.07171253114938736,
-0.12945005297660828,
0.7183189988136292,
-0.20710642635822296,
0.05059295520186424,
-0.8778703212738037,
-0.6233484148979187,
0.7099730372428894,
0.1618184894323349,
0.6213686466217041,
0.03471207246184349,
-0.054369524121284485,
0.22760894894599915,
-0.7929784059524536,
-0.23687559366226196,
0.31921204924583435,
-0.47293582558631897,
-0.14398694038391113,
0.3121575713157654,
-0.009119898080825806,
0.3257195055484772,
0.1927405148744583,
-0.710430920124054,
0.5999276041984558,
0.09298694878816605,
0.3154158592224121,
0.6976519823074341,
0.12436776608228683,
0.23905391991138458,
-0.4629696309566498,
0.5938332676887512,
0.16925199329853058,
-0.11890069395303726,
0.08101294189691544,
-0.6354689002037048,
-0.7873403429985046,
-0.4677519202232361,
0.11462859064340591,
0.4477403163909912,
-0.1603311151266098,
0.3888978362083435,
-0.14168909192085266,
-0.46285074949264526,
-0.27695584297180176,
0.24593785405158997,
0.2990381717681885,
-0.22423934936523438,
0.06464549154043198,
-0.30495911836624146,
-0.6810075640678406,
-0.8339371681213379,
-0.1582999974489212,
-0.18153436481952667,
-0.24048438668251038,
0.2497175931930542,
0.5891216397285461,
-0.5449272394180298,
0.9199404120445251,
-0.24131666123867035,
0.18908949196338654,
-0.5119595527648926,
0.11788376420736313,
-0.05507607385516167,
0.11292761564254761,
1.0464199781417847,
-0.5204569101333618,
-0.19759930670261383,
-0.263645201921463,
-0.5776961445808411,
-0.3026164472103119,
0.14054900407791138,
0.2469063699245453,
0.03824947774410248,
0.3408982455730438,
-0.6080235838890076,
0.2702564299106598,
0.830962061882019,
-0.4046313464641571,
1.0223231315612793,
-0.15553833544254303,
0.01208321750164032,
-0.9606133699417114,
0.0792834684252739,
0.03250966966152191,
-0.12130637466907501,
-0.701590895652771,
-0.14169193804264069,
-0.1009196788072586,
0.09720753878355026,
-0.03925778344273567,
0.6172415018081665,
-0.3940359354019165,
-0.5827749371528625,
-0.2355940043926239,
-0.02695505879819393,
-0.14603300392627716,
0.21414168179035187,
0.05836529657244682,
1.004062533378601,
0.261980801820755,
-0.6474742889404297,
0.4925423562526703,
0.2585081458091736,
-0.138464093208313,
0.7624000310897827,
-0.7556852698326111,
0.2535420060157776,
-0.21571087837219238,
0.4057205617427826,
-1.1721893548965454,
-0.7425300478935242,
-0.2560601234436035,
-0.3628690242767334,
0.00952125433832407,
0.013115623034536839,
-0.7375977635383606,
-0.3572237491607666,
-0.5459845662117004,
-0.03955564275383949,
0.81282639503479,
-0.4616907835006714,
0.6930376887321472,
0.3343782126903534,
-0.39987319707870483,
-0.05549237132072449,
-0.5804629921913147,
0.1234472319483757,
-0.6454182863235474,
-0.46496620774269104,
0.29109880328178406,
-0.4621328115463257,
-0.7906162142753601,
-0.4422624111175537,
0.5045299530029297,
0.12707175314426422,
0.14517351984977722,
0.3466447591781616,
0.25322940945625305,
-0.10004682093858719,
-0.2914869785308838,
0.11469363421201706,
0.32916468381881714,
0.24603919684886932,
0.12930209934711456,
0.6053062081336975,
-0.25445643067359924,
-0.3244880139827728,
-0.479175865650177,
0.15189619362354279,
0.8068975210189819,
0.08526787906885147,
0.8441767692565918,
0.5684284567832947,
0.0023602237924933434,
-0.018667178228497505,
-0.7409674525260925,
-0.3341771960258484,
-0.5241627097129822,
0.2545308470726013,
-0.4282458424568176,
-1.083411455154419,
0.9694892168045044,
-0.17283332347869873,
0.16886340081691742,
-0.05396997556090355,
1.0631294250488281,
-0.2627767324447632,
1.224104642868042,
0.6976304650306702,
-0.05395132675766945,
0.3444010317325592,
0.13815651834011078,
0.11844509094953537,
-0.9711760878562927,
-0.20986177027225494,
-0.27119195461273193,
-0.5918841361999512,
-0.7219770550727844,
-0.2917992174625397,
0.3288111984729767,
-0.3485226631164551,
-0.5435338020324707,
-0.20045720040798187,
-0.016711939126253128,
0.3896540403366089,
0.4682946801185608,
-0.12021565437316895,
0.1807035356760025,
-0.05773596093058586,
-0.3636936545372009,
-0.04071294143795967,
-0.16954657435417175,
-0.7428934574127197,
1.16696035861969,
0.5874463319778442,
0.9464684724807739,
0.4866596758365631,
0.6129400134086609,
0.13244237005710602,
0.5039697289466858,
-0.43809404969215393,
0.7487145066261292,
0.04190477356314659,
-0.7979440093040466,
-0.386065810918808,
-0.30088210105895996,
-0.702935516834259,
0.06581257283687592,
-0.26484471559524536,
-1.105989933013916,
0.15718621015548706,
0.420184850692749,
-0.19169765710830688,
0.06700793653726578,
-0.7964784502983093,
0.44554707407951355,
-0.25064605474472046,
-0.17510290443897247,
-0.28677898645401,
-0.6401528716087341,
0.7540677189826965,
0.03063836134970188,
0.018350781872868538,
-0.22981072962284088,
0.027144605293869972,
0.46671509742736816,
-0.39687901735305786,
1.1286122798919678,
0.056608859449625015,
-0.18501587212085724,
0.053052861243486404,
0.30338338017463684,
0.549416720867157,
-0.05337381735444069,
-0.3033928871154785,
0.18444906175136566,
0.23815856873989105,
-0.5484954118728638,
-0.633755087852478,
0.8776333332061768,
-1.186476707458496,
-0.46254733204841614,
-0.3048669397830963,
-0.2265586405992508,
-0.41856247186660767,
0.016300631687045097,
-0.0955202504992485,
-0.003905647434294224,
-0.6560993194580078,
0.10263224691152573,
0.5673389434814453,
-0.3267347812652588,
0.4212285578250885,
0.3878979980945587,
-0.69564288854599,
-0.5070664882659912,
0.5781617164611816,
-0.05128258839249611,
0.4233832359313965,
-0.04514995589852333,
0.34273868799209595,
-0.09497804939746857,
-0.4913332164287567,
-0.09893450886011124,
0.3570224642753601,
-0.5778290033340454,
0.41286104917526245,
-0.27330419421195984,
-0.11312899738550186,
-0.43386921286582947,
-0.08420879393815994,
-0.16431619226932526,
-0.17977377772331238,
0.133922278881073,
-0.15317289531230927,
0.43917369842529297,
1.1499617099761963,
0.4121484160423279,
0.6982490420341492,
-0.5056995749473572,
-0.010332735255360603,
0.46770933270454407,
0.4517671465873718,
-0.1288956105709076,
-0.42765817046165466,
0.1675235778093338,
-0.17307424545288086,
-0.4001629054546356,
-0.8695938587188721,
0.3619547486305237,
0.03944091871380806,
0.46895262598991394,
0.8862306475639343,
-0.5238075852394104,
0.3370313346385956,
-0.3697502315044403,
0.9105427265167236,
0.03803887590765953,
-0.7645713686943054,
0.11095770448446274,
-0.6307312250137329,
0.04631124809384346,
0.2806926965713501,
0.44196999073028564,
-0.6736481785774231,
-0.17894703149795532,
-0.6067312359809875,
-0.27735039591789246,
0.487112432718277,
0.37535086274147034,
0.16501131653785706,
0.027505293488502502,
0.6155139207839966,
0.05030166730284691,
0.42440950870513916,
-0.5197360515594482,
-0.15654298663139343,
-0.1348990499973297,
-0.3856752812862396,
-0.12405864894390106,
-0.8224018812179565,
-0.14489173889160156,
-0.2909850478172302,
0.32628872990608215,
-0.12830184400081635,
0.3434057831764221,
-0.09281861782073975,
0.31681740283966064,
0.2577480673789978,
0.04411724582314491,
0.9540296196937561,
0.5848435163497925,
-0.29348093271255493,
0.2136329561471939,
0.5074521899223328,
-0.6913539171218872,
0.26202431321144104,
-0.4229844808578491,
0.1559467911720276,
-0.3178299367427826,
0.2618570923805237,
0.6828758120536804,
0.2404123693704605,
-0.7932673692703247,
0.4201650023460388,
-0.25756126642227173,
-0.2959496080875397,
-0.7887969017028809,
0.23589903116226196,
0.4249732196331024,
0.14675308763980865,
0.07961876690387726,
-0.4517066180706024,
-0.13548989593982697,
-0.9104766249656677,
-0.16691213846206665,
0.34331050515174866,
0.139377623796463,
-0.7278968095779419,
0.5410385131835938,
0.31635358929634094,
-0.23476029932498932,
0.5109357237815857,
-0.19856804609298706,
-0.5330562591552734,
0.5973441004753113,
0.6776608228683472,
0.5392060875892639,
-0.49616798758506775,
-0.115449458360672,
0.007122321520000696,
0.08544883131980896,
-0.07785548269748688,
0.5878550410270691,
0.31653526425361633,
-0.9964107275009155,
-0.42033612728118896,
-0.6653225421905518,
-0.8665249943733215,
0.14690178632736206,
-0.15589158236980438,
0.36849191784858704,
-0.8601089119911194,
-0.39956364035606384,
-0.03822396695613861,
0.08512023091316223,
-0.6137802004814148,
0.16948987543582916,
0.4783746004104614,
0.5904475450515747,
-0.7553341388702393,
1.0865085124969482,
0.9251824617385864,
-0.21382389962673187,
-0.6997765898704529,
0.07024858146905899,
0.20212867856025696,
-0.8706153631210327,
0.991768479347229,
-0.015418983064591885,
-0.11434542387723923,
-0.0630912333726883,
-0.7103261351585388,
-0.9200814366340637,
1.2340880632400513,
0.41581687331199646,
-0.3276202976703644,
-0.1850126087665558,
0.16546154022216797,
0.5917227268218994,
-0.42195209860801697,
0.49116766452789307,
0.9359238147735596,
0.6303902864456177,
0.2403687834739685,
-1.0751821994781494,
-0.0711580142378807,
-0.27073290944099426,
0.29102832078933716,
-0.1067085862159729,
-1.0732661485671997,
0.7774296998977661,
-0.309335321187973,
0.23579014837741852,
0.1107209175825119,
0.7656934261322021,
0.6651607751846313,
-0.07456929236650467,
0.25562217831611633,
0.6457886695861816,
0.862669050693512,
0.17252850532531738,
1.1887785196304321,
-0.5765239000320435,
0.28910523653030396,
0.7015480399131775,
-0.767265796661377,
0.7796216607093811,
0.42479828000068665,
-0.4414035379886627,
0.7841780185699463,
0.7344043254852295,
-0.12655845284461975,
0.19326667487621307,
0.20070426166057587,
-0.2815925180912018,
-0.10006000101566315,
0.3479672372341156,
-0.04236479476094246,
0.7547715306282043,
0.5495400428771973,
-0.3056848645210266,
0.29326745867729187,
-0.3258369266986847,
0.3344370126724243,
-0.3531322181224823,
-0.1931639015674591,
0.49870795011520386,
0.11422280222177505,
-0.5396558046340942,
0.3285907804965973,
0.21987284719944,
0.6315166354179382,
-0.4419756829738617,
-0.007389997597783804,
-0.2695538103580475,
0.2382938265800476,
-0.14841777086257935,
-0.8296201825141907,
0.13457632064819336,
-0.04122108221054077,
-0.04505322873592377,
-0.07621484249830246,
0.7252382636070251,
-0.1851043850183487,
-0.32791367173194885,
0.13718663156032562,
0.13747437298297882,
0.3614274263381958,
0.04343460500240326,
-0.21603098511695862,
0.21729972958564758,
-0.4724077582359314,
-0.4878007173538208,
0.6976062059402466,
0.4315687417984009,
-0.18186289072036743,
0.8195916414260864,
0.7075639367103577,
0.15215110778808594,
0.17202365398406982,
0.03067679889500141,
0.8316892981529236,
-0.9385485053062439,
-0.5030656456947327,
-1.071271300315857,
0.16653840243816376,
-0.44286251068115234,
-0.3625021278858185,
0.9274646043777466,
0.35158443450927734,
0.470241516828537,
-0.1383255273103714,
0.878021240234375,
0.07401525229215622,
0.4189998209476471,
-0.49565279483795166,
0.7684018611907959,
-0.19658952951431274,
0.18056224286556244,
-0.3224506080150604,
-0.9461607933044434,
-0.04513222724199295,
0.34935659170150757,
-0.521760106086731,
0.46740958094596863,
0.580384373664856,
0.49720290303230286,
0.0963733047246933,
0.00963415578007698,
0.5088754296302795,
0.5917127728462219,
0.30645298957824707,
0.2292085587978363,
0.7234595417976379,
0.26335474848747253,
-0.05443857982754707,
-0.07318279147148132,
-0.18392780423164368,
-0.6449357867240906,
-0.8636159300804138,
-1.362425446510315,
-0.20883625745773315,
0.13485313951969147,
-0.3697797358036041,
-0.11045193672180176,
0.7718596458435059,
0.6343721747398376,
-0.537545919418335,
-0.3484030067920685,
0.1886034905910492,
-0.013518639840185642,
0.00529451435431838,
-0.14739453792572021,
-0.09238145500421524,
0.04244055598974228,
-0.4911305010318756,
0.10040605813264847,
0.2699028551578522,
0.3145286738872528,
-0.7663273811340332,
-0.18188732862472534,
0.23633205890655518,
0.49923592805862427,
0.8642603158950806,
0.20078210532665253,
-0.8327861428260803,
-0.6238101720809937,
0.06085989996790886,
-0.13843947649002075,
0.10206838697195053,
0.718596339225769,
-0.4753914177417755,
-0.11631545424461365,
0.38515809178352356,
0.3379787504673004,
0.500617504119873,
0.29687514901161194,
0.7279244065284729,
-0.7059227824211121,
0.214837908744812,
-0.0590621680021286,
0.531177282333374,
0.32899296283721924,
-0.31932705640792847,
0.2614569067955017,
0.2596340477466583,
-0.7921262383460999,
-0.5507568717002869,
0.33487626910209656,
-1.1420586109161377,
0.06863240152597427,
1.5087289810180664,
-0.14190848171710968,
-0.23821520805358887,
-0.009392591193318367,
-0.3942467272281647,
-0.27770036458969116,
-0.18906989693641663,
1.0027896165847778,
1.0514997243881226,
-0.45799267292022705,
-0.3025180399417877,
-0.7462650537490845,
0.3730204701423645,
0.23464402556419373,
-0.8486741185188293,
-0.060165535658597946,
0.5454064011573792,
0.6828427314758301,
-0.04767487943172455,
0.6776782274246216,
0.030714187771081924,
0.07493209838867188,
0.061629265546798706,
0.48111218214035034,
0.17291979491710663,
-0.04329261556267738,
-0.19698002934455872,
-0.015313730575144291,
0.5120730400085449,
0.4888535439968109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17827v1 | Neural Machine Translation for Malayalam Paraphrase Generation | 2024-01-31T13:40:00 | 2024-01-31T13:40:00 | Christeena Varghese, Sergey Koshelev, Ivan P. Yamshchikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.7.0; I.2.7 | This study explores four methods of generating paraphrases in Malayalam,
utilizing resources available for English paraphrasing and pre-trained Neural
Machine Translation (NMT) models. We evaluate the resulting paraphrases using
both automated metrics, such as BLEU, METEOR, and cosine similarity, as well as
human annotation. Our findings suggest that automated evaluation measures may
not be fully appropriate for Malayalam, as they do not consistently align with
human judgment. This discrepancy underscores the need for more nuanced
paraphrase evaluation approaches especially for highly agglutinative languages. | [
-0.13518154621124268,
-0.6211254596710205,
0.6226491928100586,
0.5252679586410522,
-0.7319103479385376,
-0.15681257843971252,
-0.023887552320957184,
-0.08295007795095444,
0.20526152849197388,
0.5236781239509583,
-0.2934025526046753,
-0.19573377072811127,
-0.4928255081176758,
0.5825749039649963,
-0.49843525886535645,
0.6968874931335449,
-0.09176311641931534,
0.2872934937477112,
-0.18511971831321716,
0.11643946170806885,
-0.6170228123664856,
-0.49121806025505066,
-0.706551730632782,
-0.42983001470565796,
0.15776695311069489,
0.45966610312461853,
0.6921387910842896,
0.7957309484481812,
0.9670364260673523,
0.3544963300228119,
0.22581960260868073,
0.14754076302051544,
0.24850790202617645,
0.41498467326164246,
-0.45492613315582275,
-0.33818140625953674,
-0.343106746673584,
-0.08109518140554428,
0.5305290222167969,
0.5378260016441345,
0.218446746468544,
0.4137910306453705,
0.04467407241463661,
0.4529019892215729,
-0.5266851186752319,
0.14389975368976593,
-0.5818689465522766,
0.3345886468887329,
-0.09078845381736755,
-0.5222792625427246,
-0.2180982083082199,
-0.684203028678894,
0.04914861172437668,
-0.16600395739078522,
0.15066589415073395,
0.11187740415334702,
0.7348589301109314,
0.34541964530944824,
-0.5075404644012451,
-0.6284657120704651,
-0.4118577837944031,
0.9173631072044373,
-0.6530997157096863,
-0.007524739019572735,
0.6060066819190979,
0.7022223472595215,
0.21688096225261688,
-1.0254696607589722,
-0.46881240606307983,
-0.4273153841495514,
-0.02664969488978386,
0.0973428264260292,
0.11232280731201172,
0.06089723855257034,
-0.1300431191921234,
0.5249554514884949,
-0.39590752124786377,
-0.23134176433086395,
-0.5535165667533875,
-0.33659517765045166,
0.5735256671905518,
0.4233970642089844,
0.35434654355049133,
-0.9383180737495422,
-0.5095728635787964,
-0.13060873746871948,
-0.24018330872058868,
-0.26927363872528076,
0.4163638651371002,
0.17244195938110352,
0.26951703429222107,
0.9271579384803772,
-0.26911717653274536,
0.7577740550041199,
0.12331485003232956,
0.04833157733082771,
0.2202489674091339,
-0.7940260767936707,
-0.28615275025367737,
0.05867556110024452,
0.9517045021057129,
0.9124056100845337,
0.4660070836544037,
-0.19025734066963196,
-0.4218558371067047,
0.08413319289684296,
0.48661771416664124,
-0.6742019653320312,
0.012365373782813549,
0.015322880819439888,
-0.5339359641075134,
-0.5594229102134705,
-0.04226340726017952,
-1.0784406661987305,
-0.43425023555755615,
-0.5502869486808777,
0.6063358783721924,
-0.6728630661964417,
-0.07672697305679321,
-0.05942823737859726,
-0.5290039777755737,
0.3853195011615753,
0.05447123944759369,
-0.7854114770889282,
0.42251622676849365,
0.47877416014671326,
1.1704416275024414,
-0.22869500517845154,
-0.6645553112030029,
-0.2790835201740265,
-0.26254624128341675,
-0.4479537606239319,
0.4958172142505646,
-0.2925475835800171,
-0.15957902371883392,
-0.25674018263816833,
-0.30691996216773987,
-0.4034758508205414,
-0.6465481519699097,
0.39075854420661926,
-0.14290429651737213,
0.111605204641819,
-0.08772572875022888,
-0.3773224353790283,
-0.38026750087738037,
-0.007244971115142107,
-0.3018834590911865,
0.6323038935661316,
0.2933967113494873,
-0.5768677592277527,
0.07379881292581558,
-0.5612472295761108,
-0.508316695690155,
-0.1329854279756546,
-0.11145223677158356,
-0.19899001717567444,
0.4899160861968994,
0.24183981120586395,
0.7303770780563354,
-0.6629495024681091,
0.33675193786621094,
0.19947980344295502,
-0.07006822526454926,
0.29640883207321167,
-0.47866091132164,
0.7701051235198975,
0.8143229484558105,
-0.619375467300415,
0.1044052466750145,
-0.686182975769043,
0.06130674108862877,
0.01781068742275238,
0.08860255777835846,
-0.2191004753112793,
-0.4745851159095764,
0.39655497670173645,
0.7885040640830994,
0.42088842391967773,
-0.34481266140937805,
-0.41276830434799194,
-0.33113986253738403,
0.4860013723373413,
0.6879041194915771,
0.5291762351989746,
0.44145190715789795,
-0.48772385716438293,
0.9874100685119629,
-0.05515919253230095,
0.05814386159181595,
0.100877545773983,
-0.4211978018283844,
-0.5367310643196106,
-0.04929487407207489,
0.14905504882335663,
0.579893171787262,
-0.8067526817321777,
0.1441573053598404,
-0.321997731924057,
-0.576285719871521,
-0.6847921013832092,
0.3845759928226471,
0.7053270936012268,
0.6342525482177734,
0.5838741660118103,
-0.32551559805870056,
-0.7412927746772766,
-1.052188515663147,
-0.4454399049282074,
0.29792386293411255,
0.15237309038639069,
-0.02658233419060707,
0.6292901635169983,
0.1299564242362976,
0.6974513530731201,
-0.08479111641645432,
-0.09661324322223663,
-0.308437317609787,
0.031409408897161484,
-0.05773928388953209,
0.3533961772918701,
0.5558321475982666,
-0.9113765954971313,
-0.7774680256843567,
0.2532276511192322,
-1.216958999633789,
-0.1756380945444107,
-0.07825005799531937,
0.06321021914482117,
0.020343292504549026,
0.6535120606422424,
-0.8054183721542358,
0.3783305287361145,
0.2173686921596527,
-0.34743040800094604,
0.5215884447097778,
-0.24066686630249023,
0.5468259453773499,
-1.7499432563781738,
0.12901818752288818,
-0.26231539249420166,
-0.3314121663570404,
-0.3943226635456085,
0.39823251962661743,
0.15481433272361755,
-0.13389061391353607,
-0.7109417915344238,
0.5517725348472595,
-0.5025780200958252,
-0.04366540536284447,
-0.4112192392349243,
0.16394981741905212,
-0.09420891106128693,
0.10299678891897202,
-0.14604675769805908,
0.8080707788467407,
0.336791068315506,
-0.5793229341506958,
0.6742019057273865,
0.19852633774280548,
-0.18212124705314636,
0.7564798593521118,
-0.498829185962677,
0.11182907223701477,
-0.05921827629208565,
-0.09166238456964493,
-0.8795720934867859,
-0.4418921172618866,
0.1909944862127304,
-0.7149872779846191,
0.07269158214330673,
0.051312707364559174,
-0.2996128797531128,
-0.10013257712125778,
-0.3966626822948456,
0.26900649070739746,
0.7509718537330627,
-0.064895398914814,
0.21065753698349,
0.03282562270760536,
-0.35951000452041626,
-0.5639697313308716,
-0.8719736933708191,
0.5469287633895874,
-0.6672040820121765,
-0.39046648144721985,
-0.1277305781841278,
0.3715061545372009,
-0.5087687969207764,
-0.17542974650859833,
-0.04895949363708496,
-0.14397217333316803,
0.0035942604299634695,
0.1983199566602707,
-0.30062317848205566,
-0.3226519227027893,
-0.12727637588977814,
0.006340351887047291,
-0.04027455300092697,
0.2582249641418457,
-0.6556739807128906,
0.886468768119812,
-0.2277182787656784,
-0.02884037420153618,
-0.5852804780006409,
0.3097131550312042,
0.7108309268951416,
-0.33128541707992554,
0.31887876987457275,
0.7162696123123169,
-0.48514556884765625,
0.4359111189842224,
-0.3790540099143982,
-0.17751361429691315,
-0.42693057656288147,
0.44738587737083435,
-0.6823694109916687,
-0.00561686884611845,
0.41259998083114624,
0.1626734584569931,
-0.3035644590854645,
0.734433114528656,
0.8348332643508911,
-0.01748810149729252,
0.632797360420227,
0.04119478538632393,
0.41393619775772095,
0.09304656833410263,
-0.2239532619714737,
-0.13241955637931824,
-0.7013230323791504,
-0.17192088067531586,
-0.5325921773910522,
-0.33703547716140747,
-0.5107871890068054,
-0.4382014870643616,
-0.17939355969429016,
0.08155982196331024,
0.09479478746652603,
0.6836875081062317,
-0.3735779821872711,
0.3886243999004364,
0.6031228303909302,
-0.014210417866706848,
0.10734593868255615,
0.10876618325710297,
-0.31579259037971497,
-0.20038610696792603,
-0.32810699939727783,
-0.7284690737724304,
1.3118579387664795,
-0.12033803015947342,
0.20368912816047668,
0.14427267014980316,
1.026547908782959,
0.2755405306816101,
-0.06148960068821907,
-0.49794259667396545,
0.6487810015678406,
0.024649538099765778,
-0.7020728588104248,
-0.3917938470840454,
-0.46841204166412354,
-1.1482326984405518,
0.26823127269744873,
0.10312304645776749,
-0.5870645642280579,
-0.13589805364608765,
-0.04306195303797722,
-0.09104937314987183,
-0.03898889571428299,
-0.8290245532989502,
0.9024266004562378,
-0.09668958187103271,
-0.12153057754039764,
-0.21841299533843994,
-0.7935594916343689,
0.21603266894817352,
-0.36280250549316406,
-0.03487474471330643,
0.16192306578159332,
-0.177033469080925,
0.629182755947113,
-0.587844967842102,
0.34063199162483215,
-0.26327311992645264,
0.4711040258407593,
0.36534377932548523,
0.2055361419916153,
-0.0577411875128746,
-0.03695854917168617,
-0.2545188367366791,
-0.16990776360034943,
-0.23685573041439056,
-0.7185762524604797,
-0.5553712248802185,
0.6719356775283813,
-0.6541312336921692,
-0.44914141297340393,
-0.5144241452217102,
-0.7323055267333984,
-0.02132461778819561,
0.40273764729499817,
0.7972354888916016,
0.12206928431987762,
0.1839333027601242,
0.2599884271621704,
0.021944183856248856,
0.03513643518090248,
0.5925360321998596,
-0.2519904673099518,
-0.3804110884666443,
-0.8901348114013672,
1.0584189891815186,
0.1344531625509262,
0.43405741453170776,
0.39120152592658997,
0.31371673941612244,
-0.49648794531822205,
-0.6427863836288452,
-0.4913458526134491,
0.13459335267543793,
-1.0145213603973389,
-0.2201680988073349,
-0.6499568819999695,
-0.10805581510066986,
-0.6647751927375793,
-0.22059416770935059,
-0.15973444283008575,
-0.8606055974960327,
0.09522087126970291,
-0.1553492695093155,
0.44350171089172363,
0.8535266518592834,
0.035667743533849716,
0.45468202233314514,
-0.5649632811546326,
0.44140684604644775,
0.12086677551269531,
-0.2433152198791504,
-0.08721057325601578,
-0.6730931997299194,
-0.17891259491443634,
0.09876787662506104,
-0.5475806593894958,
-1.009835958480835,
0.7061052322387695,
0.3267037868499756,
0.3016915023326874,
-0.0702044665813446,
-0.28431180119514465,
0.5789822936058044,
-0.6256573796272278,
0.7251377701759338,
0.30303487181663513,
-0.870545506477356,
0.620694637298584,
-0.3604463040828705,
0.2622169256210327,
0.7131967544555664,
0.6232441663742065,
-0.26122239232063293,
-0.3645181953907013,
-0.6325294971466064,
-0.9779731035232544,
0.2950485050678253,
0.5634334087371826,
0.26710638403892517,
-0.2760489284992218,
0.40274959802627563,
0.1843050718307495,
0.44887277483940125,
-0.3913270831108093,
-0.18474581837654114,
-0.3840988278388977,
-0.6135433912277222,
-0.6323287487030029,
0.06381046026945114,
0.42355817556381226,
-0.27391722798347473,
0.242683544754982,
0.2527051568031311,
0.12893708050251007,
0.29624611139297485,
-0.6725211143493652,
0.014900256879627705,
0.042382899671792984,
0.8755577802658081,
0.9123364686965942,
-0.38736963272094727,
0.1778206080198288,
0.2593795955181122,
-0.8252555727958679,
0.5497960448265076,
0.07631103694438934,
-0.19223903119564056,
0.30435869097709656,
0.2995918095111847,
0.6960716247558594,
0.05883108451962471,
-0.24611099064350128,
0.3694542944431305,
-0.14416755735874176,
-0.1354999989271164,
-0.4492930769920349,
-0.2388191521167755,
0.1775776445865631,
0.05107612535357475,
0.23837675154209137,
0.34892094135284424,
0.26385319232940674,
-0.3538972735404968,
0.4022659659385681,
0.013772279024124146,
-0.38415098190307617,
-0.3027791678905487,
0.7865208983421326,
0.04006589949131012,
-0.8520421385765076,
0.6837823987007141,
-0.04722852632403374,
-0.2267359048128128,
0.5082675218582153,
0.546190083026886,
1.225739598274231,
-0.5604473948478699,
0.06497642397880554,
0.10958818346261978,
0.41598784923553467,
-0.06501033157110214,
0.4307129383087158,
-0.008957830257713795,
-0.013570721261203289,
-0.5447438359260559,
-1.1391568183898926,
-0.27543359994888306,
0.143480122089386,
-0.6417583227157593,
0.36697864532470703,
-0.4100343585014343,
-0.36019042134284973,
0.24776071310043335,
-0.12970413267612457,
-0.7235471606254578,
0.390095978975296,
-0.25531911849975586,
0.6237495541572571,
-0.7930901646614075,
0.5770748853683472,
1.1288888454437256,
-0.940178632736206,
-0.5235029458999634,
0.09912314265966415,
-0.21527419984340668,
-0.5263429880142212,
0.7804957628250122,
0.28686797618865967,
0.011460132896900177,
0.3432890474796295,
0.11680557578802109,
-0.5357862710952759,
1.094438910484314,
0.5253610014915466,
0.14092285931110382,
-0.32389986515045166,
0.45670247077941895,
0.6020509004592896,
-0.2103510946035385,
0.37013471126556396,
0.3859148621559143,
0.4882882237434387,
-0.41081422567367554,
-1.182610273361206,
0.12306798249483109,
-0.32142412662506104,
0.11259443312883377,
-0.04585500806570053,
-0.3060206174850464,
1.060199499130249,
0.19967234134674072,
0.31616565585136414,
0.0963711142539978,
0.5520235896110535,
-0.0065257735550403595,
0.4719074070453644,
0.16513791680335999,
0.4111554026603699,
0.3311554491519928,
0.3867917060852051,
1.4326515197753906,
-0.2601241171360016,
0.2548676133155823,
0.8077393770217896,
0.11500929296016693,
0.5477356314659119,
0.8006191253662109,
0.03074655681848526,
-0.08923033624887466,
0.6983577013015747,
0.37697887420654297,
0.40775731205940247,
0.32110801339149475,
0.0031749499030411243,
-0.10929787158966064,
0.13555659353733063,
-0.2603404223918915,
0.7001665234565735,
0.23719263076782227,
-0.6957645416259766,
-0.4634092450141907,
0.2384084314107895,
-0.1159052848815918,
0.4369857609272003,
-0.32292434573173523,
0.6396579146385193,
0.6078477501869202,
-1.0293116569519043,
1.0318400859832764,
0.19663117825984955,
0.38487082719802856,
-0.2701857388019562,
-0.05007670819759369,
-0.3491935431957245,
0.29073601961135864,
-0.126930370926857,
-0.5327261090278625,
0.6471620798110962,
0.0010037748143076897,
0.08092004805803299,
-0.279883474111557,
0.6506046652793884,
-0.11758056282997131,
-0.3495483696460724,
0.20372234284877777,
0.6681386232376099,
0.6513943076133728,
-0.4109053611755371,
-0.6170130372047424,
-0.5270297527313232,
-0.000017475738786743023,
-0.2992466986179352,
0.3124394714832306,
0.44632288813591003,
-0.4192045032978058,
0.6591314673423767,
0.4621826410293579,
0.20783154666423798,
0.5395746827125549,
-0.298493891954422,
0.09412931650876999,
-0.849246084690094,
-0.40168190002441406,
-1.3282119035720825,
0.19600628316402435,
-0.26426810026168823,
-0.6083182096481323,
1.2546392679214478,
0.5894380211830139,
0.4727284908294678,
-0.6087141633033752,
0.862086832523346,
0.004317574203014374,
-0.0022972077131271362,
-0.5455787181854248,
0.7297883033752441,
-0.36594340205192566,
-0.39643287658691406,
-0.4131909906864166,
-1.4138879776000977,
-0.16941939294338226,
0.7721214890480042,
-0.1746087521314621,
0.09916149824857712,
1.1426334381103516,
0.5795208811759949,
-0.40697145462036133,
-0.23504473268985748,
0.5458431243896484,
-0.00644355732947588,
0.014395556412637234,
0.36395734548568726,
0.8872956037521362,
-0.7051917314529419,
0.5842275023460388,
-0.4213361144065857,
0.03284727409482002,
-0.38491499423980713,
-0.7507577538490295,
-0.8773453831672668,
-0.7979407906532288,
-0.10167326778173447,
-0.5761595964431763,
0.25271472334861755,
1.1114932298660278,
0.2735893726348877,
-0.7376198768615723,
-0.4967685341835022,
-0.44558683037757874,
-0.18904823064804077,
-0.28027746081352234,
-0.21435239911079407,
0.5186032652854919,
-0.775850236415863,
-0.8402451276779175,
0.245881587266922,
0.2270749807357788,
0.05727966129779816,
-0.19942879676818848,
-0.0981087014079094,
-0.5244500637054443,
0.19671139121055603,
0.399499773979187,
-0.15819750726222992,
-0.5593340992927551,
-0.12251976132392883,
0.16716653108596802,
-0.3491552174091339,
-0.08825600147247314,
0.5129712820053101,
-0.3176792860031128,
0.27359846234321594,
0.7590889930725098,
0.8290451765060425,
0.3601493835449219,
-0.008857411332428455,
0.8171321749687195,
-0.8413848280906677,
0.24654100835323334,
0.3858080506324768,
0.2749902009963989,
0.6218570470809937,
0.024646060541272163,
0.4353545904159546,
0.3305470049381256,
-0.5470144152641296,
-0.8652151823043823,
0.22022610902786255,
-0.6028274297714233,
0.1203232929110527,
1.3358993530273438,
-0.1501879245042801,
-0.4381823241710663,
-0.3351376950740814,
-0.30760592222213745,
0.45111915469169617,
0.10543414950370789,
0.6540365219116211,
0.830912172794342,
0.15154989063739777,
0.1094505563378334,
-0.8291416168212891,
0.5367473363876343,
0.5778571963310242,
-0.43453216552734375,
-0.2845463156700134,
0.12988920509815216,
0.3257262706756592,
0.2070261687040329,
0.49127906560897827,
-0.15802262723445892,
0.6358823180198669,
0.3471693992614746,
0.23348161578178406,
-0.16384020447731018,
-0.11112694442272186,
-0.5193370580673218,
-0.06208273768424988,
0.318718284368515,
-0.42743217945098877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17824v1 | A Survey of Pre-trained Language Models for Processing Scientific Text | 2024-01-31T13:35:07 | 2024-01-31T13:35:07 | Xanh Ho, Anh Khoa Duong Nguyen, An Tuan Dao, Junfeng Jiang, Yuki Chida, Kaito Sugimoto, Huy Quoc To, Florian Boudin, Akiko Aizawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The number of Language Models (LMs) dedicated to processing scientific text
is on the rise. Keeping pace with the rapid growth of scientific LMs (SciLMs)
has become a daunting task for researchers. To date, no comprehensive surveys
on SciLMs have been undertaken, leaving this issue unaddressed. Given the
constant stream of new SciLMs, appraising the state-of-the-art and how they
compare to each other remain largely unknown. This work fills that gap and
provides a comprehensive review of SciLMs, including an extensive analysis of
their effectiveness across different domains, tasks and datasets, and a
discussion on the challenges that lie ahead. | [
-0.24630744755268097,
-0.31256917119026184,
0.6191868185997009,
0.3325595259666443,
-0.13852211833000183,
0.4425543248653412,
-0.29301923513412476,
-0.6845255494117737,
0.04857810214161873,
0.5323519706726074,
-0.41488903760910034,
-0.44747304916381836,
-0.854263186454773,
0.5883457064628601,
-0.6755710244178772,
1.0869582891464233,
0.032146189361810684,
0.32508373260498047,
-0.5626335740089417,
0.1261407881975174,
0.10811305046081543,
-0.5970376133918762,
-0.2803872227668762,
-0.3565431237220764,
0.6088714599609375,
-0.06974812597036362,
0.4848668575286865,
0.3265083134174347,
0.8462857604026794,
0.2918424606323242,
-0.43075883388519287,
0.27955517172813416,
-0.51578289270401,
0.5501020550727844,
-0.09127387404441833,
-0.21356268227100372,
-0.5116526484489441,
0.14182159304618835,
0.8723231554031372,
1.0910418033599854,
0.15062452852725983,
0.2358717918395996,
-0.04182023927569389,
0.40369337797164917,
-0.3801771104335785,
-0.018091004341840744,
-0.5752453207969666,
0.0774708017706871,
-0.4017332196235657,
-0.1893402487039566,
-0.6878601908683777,
-0.2551562190055847,
0.4227847456932068,
-0.4640868008136749,
0.3597465455532074,
0.20807689428329468,
0.49443620443344116,
0.06338158249855042,
-0.3513810336589813,
-0.3374541401863098,
-0.7388514876365662,
1.0478962659835815,
-0.6491944193840027,
0.5665223002433777,
0.2817022204399109,
-0.06068778783082962,
-0.24094675481319427,
-1.1332144737243652,
-0.19296154379844666,
-0.5329585671424866,
-0.11109049618244171,
-0.08569718897342682,
-0.1929994821548462,
-0.08856894820928574,
0.1307937651872635,
0.22575785219669342,
-0.7992092370986938,
0.20897068083286285,
-0.7706919312477112,
0.005929992534220219,
0.6415848135948181,
0.2007090300321579,
0.14621272683143616,
0.02027265913784504,
-0.1383461207151413,
-0.0059729767963290215,
-0.7167160511016846,
-0.2480437010526657,
-0.09753193706274033,
0.09425733983516693,
0.4076135456562042,
0.5564523339271545,
-0.14085401594638824,
1.0406315326690674,
-0.5091903209686279,
0.04356447607278824,
0.057544808834791183,
-0.6644379496574402,
-0.28740304708480835,
-0.0881834626197815,
1.1152098178863525,
0.13073945045471191,
0.11683366447687149,
-0.07280027121305466,
-0.06713429093360901,
-0.02288028411567211,
0.2900727391242981,
-0.8089840412139893,
-0.26038268208503723,
0.06973878294229507,
-0.3968318998813629,
-0.23152227699756622,
-0.2740018367767334,
-0.5696044564247131,
-0.3636475205421448,
-0.20836366713047028,
-0.18724316358566284,
-0.11546193063259125,
-0.23841950297355652,
0.21162332594394684,
0.06100055202841759,
-0.3840934932231903,
0.46371063590049744,
-0.5861368775367737,
0.3233019709587097,
0.6607984900474548,
1.1002147197723389,
-0.25736483931541443,
-0.32255929708480835,
0.05486713722348213,
-0.11240007728338242,
-0.4211258292198181,
1.0396223068237305,
-0.6267305612564087,
-0.5326071381568909,
-0.21859624981880188,
-0.18968528509140015,
-0.16316114366054535,
-0.30361253023147583,
0.6050754189491272,
-0.6535868048667908,
0.4121989607810974,
-0.16523493826389313,
-0.6324186325073242,
0.06554282456636429,
0.1883234828710556,
-0.6011202931404114,
1.090544581413269,
0.04207289218902588,
-1.0386463403701782,
0.26648569107055664,
-0.7267302870750427,
-0.18937551975250244,
0.30203545093536377,
-0.02352617308497429,
-0.14893397688865662,
0.13880328834056854,
0.028377775102853775,
0.6587250828742981,
-0.42436569929122925,
0.38381555676460266,
-0.18778687715530396,
-0.2448590248823166,
0.437430202960968,
-0.07978149503469467,
0.4923105537891388,
0.7771834135055542,
0.26425901055336,
0.4518758952617645,
-0.6968395709991455,
0.26800721883773804,
-0.0934210866689682,
-0.14237447082996368,
-0.5775505900382996,
0.4034484326839447,
0.12615062296390533,
0.13608194887638092,
0.3702702522277832,
-0.5864670276641846,
0.4600704312324524,
-0.4067457318305969,
0.7093397974967957,
0.26511815190315247,
-0.389376163482666,
0.3562946915626526,
0.008476360701024532,
0.5620140433311462,
-0.29869580268859863,
0.19144809246063232,
-0.4905114471912384,
-0.4110187292098999,
-0.43163344264030457,
-0.28634101152420044,
0.20876742899417877,
0.1943642944097519,
-0.46816906332969666,
0.07824650406837463,
-0.1852308064699173,
-0.9955522418022156,
-0.7454057931900024,
0.007306311745196581,
0.30837491154670715,
0.3179720938205719,
0.5078041553497314,
-0.10163039714097977,
-0.6892076134681702,
-0.599943220615387,
-0.4585621953010559,
-0.1400548219680786,
0.020603077486157417,
0.04623914510011673,
0.4203035831451416,
-0.24020330607891083,
0.9748416543006897,
-0.4202114939689636,
0.09774568676948547,
-0.2261570543050766,
0.29193106293678284,
0.23436766862869263,
0.22004427015781403,
0.4153903126716614,
-0.8005055785179138,
-0.5263867378234863,
0.09234943985939026,
-0.8272193074226379,
-0.1830959916114807,
0.36254629492759705,
0.34251323342323303,
0.1685851365327835,
0.6713250279426575,
-0.611980676651001,
0.1818515807390213,
0.6304032206535339,
-0.36982962489128113,
0.6094194054603577,
-0.22649270296096802,
0.29473039507865906,
-0.6470317244529724,
0.2730259895324707,
0.019162902608513832,
-0.2085535079240799,
-1.0345772504806519,
0.03460099920630455,
0.10329741984605789,
0.00012248831626493484,
-0.5785380005836487,
0.5652021169662476,
-0.6901257038116455,
-0.12426279485225677,
-0.4788375496864319,
0.14007756114006042,
-0.09521719068288803,
-0.27326253056526184,
0.4970216751098633,
0.5367627143859863,
0.6270754337310791,
-0.6664280891418457,
0.2757583558559418,
0.16489377617835999,
-0.5564992427825928,
0.0010176649084314704,
-0.8158063292503357,
0.042454492300748825,
-0.3828902244567871,
0.4044225811958313,
-0.741260290145874,
-0.059711698442697525,
0.008743169717490673,
-0.3832400143146515,
0.15796372294425964,
0.2373737245798111,
-0.2144424319267273,
-0.596156120300293,
-0.15395580232143402,
0.47939953207969666,
0.43718016147613525,
-0.10245215147733688,
0.2535276412963867,
0.35157647728919983,
-0.6474629044532776,
-0.8488959670066833,
-0.31193095445632935,
0.21673789620399475,
0.10456765443086624,
-0.42060911655426025,
0.19414423406124115,
-0.10456652194261551,
-0.5275023579597473,
0.040969766676425934,
-0.14592240750789642,
-0.014519158750772476,
0.057198937982320786,
0.06654386967420578,
0.38648512959480286,
-0.20207267999649048,
0.026381516829133034,
-0.23775051534175873,
0.12231875211000443,
0.12954716384410858,
-0.16270898282527924,
0.6135544776916504,
-0.08416212350130081,
-0.219166100025177,
0.059304509311914444,
0.3458232581615448,
0.5520937442779541,
-0.2918172776699066,
0.5755437016487122,
0.2957097589969635,
-0.2703125774860382,
0.03365745022892952,
-0.3979528546333313,
-0.13604938983917236,
-0.4373129904270172,
0.7205280661582947,
-0.2052583545446396,
-1.0177456140518188,
0.11996003240346909,
0.048315711319446564,
0.34206196665763855,
0.4596228301525116,
0.4592588245868683,
-0.25189298391342163,
1.3079686164855957,
0.6390355825424194,
0.12201923877000809,
0.27046945691108704,
0.03651948645710945,
0.42060479521751404,
-0.5995350480079651,
-0.542143702507019,
-1.0213302373886108,
0.14156445860862732,
-0.3426029086112976,
-0.39606669545173645,
0.15075989067554474,
0.07343778014183044,
-0.1252448707818985,
0.2454734593629837,
-0.7242208123207092,
0.4072275459766388,
0.19122420251369476,
-0.5845218300819397,
0.37621504068374634,
-0.00958915427327156,
0.11205171793699265,
-0.09379880875349045,
-0.8947255611419678,
-0.8755669593811035,
0.9252893924713135,
0.4492509663105011,
0.8578348755836487,
-0.43820226192474365,
0.45530611276626587,
0.14393296837806702,
0.7733602523803711,
-0.5350202918052673,
0.6161059737205505,
-0.33505532145500183,
-0.5832020044326782,
-0.3778800964355469,
-0.5175230503082275,
-1.08830726146698,
0.5670706033706665,
-0.1908254772424698,
-0.43227407336235046,
-0.12781476974487305,
0.075578972697258,
-0.16716571152210236,
0.2766551375389099,
-0.28336602449417114,
0.6270725131034851,
-0.4655208885669708,
-0.1884174644947052,
-0.18083010613918304,
-0.6121842265129089,
0.4036933481693268,
-0.31417176127433777,
0.5640414953231812,
-0.27638500928878784,
0.038138497620821,
1.1225236654281616,
-0.10799925774335861,
0.485736608505249,
-0.0638647973537445,
-0.16723260283470154,
0.206063374876976,
0.023836668580770493,
0.0477689653635025,
-0.17753110826015472,
-0.127296581864357,
0.2096823900938034,
0.6016750335693359,
-0.27232691645622253,
-0.185379758477211,
0.7047766447067261,
-0.5409210920333862,
-0.5056847929954529,
-1.0635792016983032,
-0.5903992056846619,
-0.20931652188301086,
0.2490704208612442,
0.25664040446281433,
0.032660529017448425,
-0.4434129297733307,
0.1401011198759079,
0.6019541621208191,
-0.1691005527973175,
0.42189279198646545,
0.7783967852592468,
-0.6095580458641052,
-0.07181631773710251,
0.5839331150054932,
0.044580455869436264,
0.18984854221343994,
0.10613033920526505,
-0.17225860059261322,
-0.4119665324687958,
-0.8578754663467407,
-0.12924052774906158,
0.30532488226890564,
-0.524450421333313,
-0.15240409970283508,
-1.0144026279449463,
-0.38017207384109497,
-0.7339708209037781,
0.07135405391454697,
-0.34752193093299866,
-0.285338819026947,
-0.4582875669002533,
0.07980333268642426,
0.3752504289150238,
1.3625565767288208,
0.37501391768455505,
0.29382580518722534,
-0.9070267081260681,
-0.01215842179954052,
-0.13682793080806732,
0.22516261041164398,
-0.10250962525606155,
-0.4800824820995331,
-0.32587411999702454,
0.047021396458148956,
0.05685624107718468,
-0.6886147260665894,
0.8365949988365173,
0.3079543709754944,
0.5890896320343018,
0.2821304202079773,
-0.14436136186122894,
0.48117733001708984,
-0.7276683449745178,
1.0452063083648682,
0.26089051365852356,
-0.6849545836448669,
0.4743715822696686,
-0.017930205911397934,
0.06702892482280731,
0.35847318172454834,
0.9918206930160522,
-0.797077476978302,
-0.4401664733886719,
-0.39215171337127686,
-0.8035664558410645,
0.5583218932151794,
-0.10990706086158752,
-0.07362052798271179,
-0.020370690152049065,
0.19550533592700958,
0.19395290315151215,
0.3137361705303192,
-0.6401638388633728,
0.0408911369740963,
-0.15161824226379395,
-0.2796037793159485,
-0.4914308488368988,
-0.32024118304252625,
-0.07128933072090149,
-0.28626492619514465,
0.5846747159957886,
-0.047906406223773956,
-0.01734359934926033,
0.11107582598924637,
-0.2758162319660187,
0.043952059000730515,
0.3503698706626892,
0.7514806985855103,
0.7779244780540466,
-0.21883556246757507,
0.3539595305919647,
0.006872767116874456,
-0.8212699294090271,
0.08165360987186432,
0.04432633891701698,
-0.23300893604755402,
0.21219392120838165,
0.6201039552688599,
0.8568273782730103,
0.24036748707294464,
-0.866081714630127,
0.19692867994308472,
-0.14576171338558197,
-0.24320493638515472,
-0.06714790314435959,
-0.021251361817121506,
0.034220725297927856,
-0.07096222043037415,
0.4623330235481262,
0.14842452108860016,
0.1463407725095749,
-0.3873659372329712,
-0.11000724881887436,
0.4811830520629883,
-0.25057607889175415,
-0.478091299533844,
0.5893646478652954,
0.06521784514188766,
-0.2335185706615448,
0.4452487528324127,
0.05483812466263771,
-0.6790646910667419,
0.3889213800430298,
0.663813591003418,
0.3897203207015991,
-0.39510679244995117,
0.1484619677066803,
0.2594957649707794,
0.29168808460235596,
-0.4051976203918457,
0.39694544672966003,
0.07020387053489685,
-0.5370188355445862,
-0.7963014245033264,
-0.9908560514450073,
-0.5000191926956177,
0.1135297641158104,
-0.5284116864204407,
0.1558370292186737,
-0.23453480005264282,
-0.35491594672203064,
0.0942426323890686,
0.047069963067770004,
-0.6014894843101501,
0.2608660161495209,
0.04646509885787964,
1.1240320205688477,
-0.8747153282165527,
0.8831061124801636,
0.9644951820373535,
-0.16332484781742096,
-0.3563423156738281,
-0.7275233268737793,
-0.32408028841018677,
-0.42740491032600403,
1.013352870941162,
-0.1333121955394745,
-0.10246872901916504,
0.008924456313252449,
-0.5876010656356812,
-1.1468000411987305,
0.6747323274612427,
0.07132306694984436,
-0.8596199154853821,
-0.20087556540966034,
0.13923941552639008,
0.9243113398551941,
-0.3306887745857239,
0.5503942370414734,
0.6389827728271484,
0.523759663105011,
-0.07917963713407516,
-1.1411972045898438,
-0.3958277404308319,
-0.4170503616333008,
-0.19867543876171112,
-0.004375534597784281,
-0.31358546018600464,
1.0741136074066162,
0.015681859105825424,
-0.2190885692834854,
0.21011076867580414,
0.7098182439804077,
0.48625192046165466,
0.554039716720581,
0.29375797510147095,
0.08342982083559036,
0.913335919380188,
-0.1874527633190155,
0.8565995693206787,
-0.3757392466068268,
0.25356075167655945,
0.8687484264373779,
-0.7635131478309631,
0.8075281381607056,
0.4952152669429779,
-0.5085774660110474,
0.3161620497703552,
0.8723984956741333,
-0.016550378873944283,
0.2940274775028229,
0.45421352982521057,
-0.3722727596759796,
-0.1596790850162506,
-0.29922619462013245,
-0.6531728506088257,
0.2217089682817459,
0.6071890592575073,
-0.4874170422554016,
-0.12166133522987366,
0.21969470381736755,
-0.08019808679819107,
0.1704484075307846,
-0.5257448554039001,
0.5486005544662476,
0.20329804718494415,
-0.8021581172943115,
0.45914191007614136,
0.05770273506641388,
0.8413906097412109,
-0.9291369915008545,
0.19638356566429138,
-0.06566345691680908,
-0.1458413004875183,
-0.35303643345832825,
-0.8180895447731018,
0.22253403067588806,
0.4730771481990814,
-0.29444438219070435,
-0.6904507279396057,
0.9973565340042114,
-0.6051076054573059,
-0.42386043071746826,
0.21755830943584442,
0.5307162404060364,
0.6631671190261841,
0.20167818665504456,
-0.2619858682155609,
0.35099509358406067,
-0.1250658482313156,
-0.5049096941947937,
0.25485852360725403,
-0.000226689619012177,
-0.2820228338241577,
0.8074256777763367,
0.6340436339378357,
0.5493502616882324,
0.4035431742668152,
0.17360171675682068,
0.7105388641357422,
-0.7577475309371948,
-0.2402186393737793,
-0.6622545719146729,
0.22552257776260376,
-0.21874049305915833,
-0.19451162219047546,
0.9544771909713745,
0.5181819796562195,
0.7715440392494202,
-0.24994297325611115,
0.9266268014907837,
0.08285894989967346,
0.7686091065406799,
-0.3135262727737427,
0.9161173105239868,
-0.2908340096473694,
0.19328655302524567,
-0.20644545555114746,
-0.9613772034645081,
-0.5266886949539185,
0.6686277389526367,
-0.19907814264297485,
-0.020410915836691856,
0.8010294437408447,
0.4818612039089203,
0.17439702153205872,
0.3684898614883423,
0.19691485166549683,
0.2698448896408081,
0.33216407895088196,
0.21113257110118866,
1.3094772100448608,
-0.05100679025053978,
0.11692427098751068,
0.13344094157218933,
-0.034290701150894165,
-0.0050700027495622635,
-1.0890482664108276,
-0.7043132781982422,
-0.5956038236618042,
-0.3124968409538269,
0.05410046875476837,
0.007089178077876568,
0.7924121022224426,
0.8218942880630493,
-0.9192734956741333,
-0.26236391067504883,
0.1738690733909607,
-0.1851075440645218,
0.009994794614613056,
-0.0939464345574379,
0.3181678056716919,
-0.3925630450248718,
-0.7981278896331787,
0.8493697047233582,
0.20206686854362488,
0.006172566674649715,
-0.514700710773468,
-0.02766876481473446,
-0.205076202750206,
0.19351951777935028,
0.7440032362937927,
0.45929113030433655,
-0.6214538216590881,
0.11520978063344955,
0.4195650815963745,
-0.30409616231918335,
-0.3296459913253784,
1.0554449558258057,
-0.8514084219932556,
0.32121798396110535,
0.6795686483383179,
0.4348371922969818,
0.496357798576355,
-0.3596498370170593,
0.33408260345458984,
-0.6391398906707764,
0.010185114108026028,
0.6719536185264587,
0.3285336196422577,
0.4528358280658722,
0.021066777408123016,
0.5240534543991089,
0.13556712865829468,
-0.8038161396980286,
-1.5673749446868896,
-0.02131526730954647,
-0.8101577162742615,
-0.4837344288825989,
0.8035476803779602,
-0.10564031451940536,
-0.07790035009384155,
-0.15634435415267944,
-0.09910155087709427,
0.05974472314119339,
0.14572758972644806,
0.34006252884864807,
0.8676317930221558,
-0.3013845384120941,
-0.011456253938376904,
-0.3676636517047882,
0.6616076231002808,
0.5897319316864014,
-0.7648012638092041,
0.09582025557756424,
0.4970904290676117,
0.25502637028694153,
0.3065526485443115,
0.8303516507148743,
-0.07129159569740295,
-0.05807659402489662,
-0.409821480512619,
0.20161721110343933,
-0.24627383053302765,
-0.6191931962966919,
-0.4602424204349518,
0.3385145366191864,
0.23754695057868958,
0.5775721669197083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17809v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17809v3 | SWEA: Updating Factual Knowledge in Large Language Models via Subject Word Embedding Altering | 2024-01-31T13:08:45 | 2024-04-23T01:08:44 | Xiaopeng Li, Shasha Li, Shezheng Song, Huijun Liu, Bin Ji, Xi Wang, Jun Ma, Jie Yu, Xiaodong Liu, Jing Wang, Weimin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The general capabilities of large language models (LLMs) make them the
infrastructure for various AI applications, but updating their inner knowledge
requires significant resources. Recent model editing is a promising technique
for efficiently updating a small amount of knowledge of LLMs and has attracted
much attention. In particular, local editing methods, which directly update
model parameters, are more suitable for updating a small amount of knowledge.
Local editing methods update weights by computing least squares closed-form
solutions and identify edited knowledge by vector-level matching in inference,
which achieve promising results. However, these methods still require a lot of
time and resources to complete the computation. Moreover, vector-level matching
lacks reliability, and such updates disrupt the original organization of the
model's parameters. To address these issues, we propose an detachable and
expandable Subject Word Embedding Altering (SWEA) framework, which finds the
editing embeddings through token-level matching and adds them to the subject
word embeddings in Transformer input. To get these editing embeddings, we
propose optimizing then suppressing fusion method, which first optimizes
learnable embedding vectors for the editing target and then suppresses the
Knowledge Embedding Dimensions (KEDs) to obtain final editing embeddings. We
thus propose SWEA$\oplus$OS method for editing factual knowledge in LLMs. We
demonstrate the overall state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of SWEA$\oplus$OS
on the \textsc{CounterFact} and zsRE datasets. To further validate the
reasoning ability of SWEA$\oplus$OS in editing knowledge, we evaluate it on the
more complex \textsc{RippleEdits} benchmark. The results demonstrate that
SWEA$\oplus$OS possesses SOTA reasoning ability. | [
-0.16597743332386017,
-1.0775402784347534,
0.6793115139007568,
-0.09556037187576294,
-0.09383953362703323,
0.10889489948749542,
-0.39988231658935547,
-0.5185486674308777,
0.060944028198719025,
0.6891372799873352,
-0.5330973863601685,
-0.5929088592529297,
-0.515899121761322,
0.08572698384523392,
-0.2029186487197876,
0.6427742838859558,
-0.25911784172058105,
0.06444302946329117,
-0.3975718021392822,
-0.5238180160522461,
-0.629787802696228,
-0.24968285858631134,
-0.39858800172805786,
-0.011015119031071663,
0.267025887966156,
0.3877348005771637,
0.7032198905944824,
0.6358832120895386,
0.5119163990020752,
0.45523127913475037,
-0.6243118643760681,
0.3382669687271118,
-0.48967400193214417,
0.43378275632858276,
-0.6905382871627808,
-0.7187871932983398,
-0.688910186290741,
-0.3206739127635956,
0.7618876099586487,
0.4880950450897217,
0.08097614347934723,
0.27328431606292725,
-0.22559994459152222,
0.49928799271583557,
-0.673223614692688,
-0.07777780294418335,
-0.9541416764259338,
-0.09723574668169022,
-0.1939343810081482,
0.0029747444204986095,
-0.37350693345069885,
-0.16993489861488342,
0.2500643730163574,
-0.39094749093055725,
0.20557178556919098,
0.08890949189662933,
0.77401202917099,
0.4278075397014618,
-0.09038626402616501,
-0.0388353057205677,
-0.8363916277885437,
0.8099608421325684,
-0.9583905339241028,
0.5698416829109192,
0.19874486327171326,
-0.030399955809116364,
-0.2196422666311264,
-0.5656899809837341,
-0.5085732936859131,
-0.12217621505260468,
0.07242359966039658,
-0.021206289529800415,
-0.40601539611816406,
0.21276286244392395,
0.4990874230861664,
0.23053354024887085,
-0.2788366675376892,
0.23733553290367126,
-0.4006938934326172,
-0.09366535395383835,
0.703217089176178,
0.10492610931396484,
0.5431509613990784,
-0.041545502841472626,
-0.15975254774093628,
0.10419782996177673,
-1.0197986364364624,
-0.2904970347881317,
0.06602445989847183,
0.1664399355649948,
0.18035218119621277,
0.9017032384872437,
-0.11547696590423584,
0.6336444020271301,
0.007278026081621647,
-0.18449875712394714,
0.15564361214637756,
-0.10354049503803253,
-0.4791746735572815,
-0.09498155862092972,
0.2641907036304474,
0.1143626719713211,
-0.3982200026512146,
-0.034559883177280426,
-0.31032466888427734,
-0.15760503709316254,
0.1347254067659378,
-0.6631889343261719,
0.38608667254447937,
0.3747108280658722,
-0.35176992416381836,
-0.18260599672794342,
-0.049042489379644394,
-0.6452658176422119,
-0.542985200881958,
-0.42274466156959534,
0.575766384601593,
-0.5957475900650024,
0.038274262100458145,
0.06657285988330841,
-0.15567539632320404,
0.1571127027273178,
0.38710343837738037,
-0.4230167865753174,
-0.1176367849111557,
0.6232138276100159,
0.6133781671524048,
0.2291579395532608,
-0.5120120644569397,
-0.41051191091537476,
0.28910326957702637,
-0.2079702466726303,
0.6775679588317871,
-0.732979953289032,
-0.4741898775100708,
-0.034949786961078644,
-0.12136563658714294,
0.15609657764434814,
-0.35046836733818054,
0.3303251564502716,
-0.7274811267852783,
0.23436886072158813,
-0.5436096787452698,
-0.9144531488418579,
-0.24142350256443024,
0.06242967024445534,
-0.49590495228767395,
0.978541374206543,
-0.02437554858624935,
-0.650870680809021,
0.27819037437438965,
-0.8233615159988403,
-0.49995866417884827,
-0.18639099597930908,
0.2761668860912323,
-0.2734513580799103,
0.3104807436466217,
0.3801850378513336,
0.3078046143054962,
-0.02064930833876133,
0.32263487577438354,
-0.3122284412384033,
-0.31776779890060425,
0.15863841772079468,
-0.21763886511325836,
0.4434358477592468,
-0.05387091636657715,
-0.31752437353134155,
0.5945879817008972,
-0.8034125566482544,
-0.36239272356033325,
-0.02967142127454281,
-0.08068566769361496,
-0.6025232076644897,
0.0994800329208374,
-0.48453015089035034,
0.19877856969833374,
0.3454081416130066,
-0.7847748398780823,
0.46759942173957825,
-0.5758908987045288,
0.4139230251312256,
0.9548999667167664,
0.18577802181243896,
0.5506490468978882,
-0.1496671736240387,
0.3244877755641937,
-0.018533742055296898,
0.23336516320705414,
0.03579059615731239,
-0.3762856125831604,
-0.8212296366691589,
-0.36652159690856934,
0.44950148463249207,
0.5174542665481567,
-0.7669854760169983,
0.3508863151073456,
-0.2618112564086914,
-0.8212134838104248,
-0.9045186042785645,
0.2906489372253418,
0.08173665404319763,
0.40715503692626953,
0.6368343234062195,
0.2737036943435669,
-0.6981999278068542,
-0.8360497951507568,
-0.5467104315757751,
0.22245417535305023,
0.014970052987337112,
0.12410753220319748,
0.42401009798049927,
-0.4466443955898285,
1.146562933921814,
-0.688033938407898,
-0.38507163524627686,
-0.31221041083335876,
0.08541346341371536,
-0.033959101885557175,
0.27291080355644226,
0.3736037611961365,
-0.46086961030960083,
-0.12018357962369919,
0.0097995949909091,
-0.6997212171554565,
-0.16669465601444244,
-0.2057064175605774,
-0.19391793012619019,
0.13037002086639404,
0.4438622295856476,
-0.6369494795799255,
0.5174677968025208,
0.4629081189632416,
-0.5335250496864319,
0.42003652453422546,
-0.4293528199195862,
0.14552344381809235,
-0.8873175978660583,
-0.14465290307998657,
0.000008066594091360457,
-0.25608178973197937,
-0.6350677013397217,
0.41033539175987244,
0.05033152177929878,
-0.22018000483512878,
-0.6140820384025574,
0.6250349283218384,
-0.5882214903831482,
-0.2083754688501358,
-0.3340330719947815,
0.6298693418502808,
-0.0032504817936569452,
0.47548139095306396,
-0.007763812784105539,
0.5798873901367188,
0.5526763200759888,
-0.5169199705123901,
0.14695432782173157,
0.4029499292373657,
-0.3091808259487152,
0.36993515491485596,
-0.624622642993927,
0.23077058792114258,
-0.36566781997680664,
0.23313114047050476,
-0.552020788192749,
0.2299910932779312,
0.021980341523885727,
0.07432162016630173,
0.19137834012508392,
0.07866343855857849,
-0.21638651192188263,
-0.007491980213671923,
-0.4052619934082031,
0.1033351719379425,
0.3199864327907562,
-0.6321612596511841,
1.1167219877243042,
0.36612117290496826,
-0.34486106038093567,
-0.6777064800262451,
-0.6424615979194641,
0.10581231117248535,
0.14186611771583557,
-0.6550769805908203,
0.5278359651565552,
0.08545194566249847,
-0.5121172070503235,
0.41481685638427734,
-0.0906316488981247,
0.2130349576473236,
-0.04284387826919556,
0.11435934901237488,
0.4881814420223236,
-0.3019844591617584,
0.10925988107919693,
0.6056906580924988,
-0.032728563994169235,
-0.2424086034297943,
0.13192133605480194,
0.23445133864879608,
-0.0300286952406168,
-0.4721638560295105,
-0.38209688663482666,
0.0672522708773613,
0.6284646391868591,
-0.5220142602920532,
0.7864837050437927,
0.5341532826423645,
-0.5401695370674133,
-0.2265545129776001,
-0.6467119455337524,
-0.15925586223602295,
-0.4964154362678528,
0.6994447708129883,
-0.48513317108154297,
-0.9748135805130005,
0.5104048252105713,
-0.22234675288200378,
0.48857495188713074,
0.5242485404014587,
0.41543224453926086,
-0.03519501909613609,
0.9010785818099976,
0.42915773391723633,
-0.055596932768821716,
0.41904082894325256,
-0.1982712596654892,
0.18076854944229126,
-1.1028194427490234,
0.04877760261297226,
-0.4575361907482147,
-0.5403257012367249,
-0.44389739632606506,
-0.8494423031806946,
0.19748246669769287,
-0.1376722753047943,
-0.08132947981357574,
0.26476237177848816,
-0.24692586064338684,
0.4409855902194977,
0.3523039221763611,
0.21705177426338196,
0.2544970214366913,
-0.4377009868621826,
0.14672206342220306,
-0.30195972323417664,
-0.4293435513973236,
-0.25086718797683716,
0.7521395087242126,
0.4301891028881073,
0.6124202609062195,
0.2881444990634918,
0.4092642068862915,
0.4034413695335388,
0.43983039259910583,
-0.6508316993713379,
0.7750723958015442,
-0.27246665954589844,
-0.40373605489730835,
-0.5066995620727539,
-0.22963689267635345,
-0.5024522542953491,
0.5714005827903748,
-0.5264983177185059,
-0.6004831194877625,
0.3329885005950928,
0.026870839297771454,
0.017407381907105446,
0.9385704398155212,
-0.44694072008132935,
0.4568723440170288,
-0.04233085364103317,
-0.3020188510417938,
-0.6456469893455505,
-0.36629414558410645,
0.1698681265115738,
0.10729337483644485,
0.30025652050971985,
0.002656811149790883,
-0.11223924905061722,
0.6565316915512085,
-0.5479050278663635,
0.9692511558532715,
-0.42953434586524963,
-0.3501242697238922,
0.1811981052160263,
0.23770879209041595,
0.8559697270393372,
-0.03815843537449837,
-0.2845918536186218,
0.2627970278263092,
-0.12585018575191498,
-0.27781692147254944,
-0.9275356531143188,
0.6139455437660217,
-0.6682588458061218,
-0.8572454452514648,
-0.2228045016527176,
-0.5654205083847046,
-0.5517286062240601,
0.24816207587718964,
-0.009159163571894169,
0.6728447675704956,
-0.33545148372650146,
0.24288444221019745,
0.616400420665741,
-0.42909926176071167,
0.151388481259346,
0.5763734579086304,
-0.324079304933548,
-0.3159084916114807,
0.975824236869812,
0.24396243691444397,
0.18392504751682281,
0.5548734664916992,
0.4629327356815338,
-0.21844550967216492,
-0.4718606770038605,
-0.301609605550766,
0.3492080569267273,
-0.7833883762359619,
-0.17297013103961945,
-0.5792315602302551,
-0.07222828269004822,
-0.32890406250953674,
-0.4671069383621216,
-0.3716975450515747,
-0.29436060786247253,
-0.13737761974334717,
-0.2551981806755066,
0.3792051374912262,
0.883487343788147,
-0.0037545578088611364,
0.1539197862148285,
-0.8610813617706299,
0.36656880378723145,
0.1758902221918106,
0.20841392874717712,
0.0032866066321730614,
-0.660477340221405,
-0.08710462599992752,
0.20233340561389923,
0.06469731032848358,
-0.97453773021698,
0.09023868292570114,
0.11309057474136353,
0.5106186270713806,
0.24181291460990906,
-0.015495089814066887,
0.8663058280944824,
-0.3061622083187103,
0.8940293192863464,
-0.2551402151584625,
-1.5121928453445435,
0.7333236932754517,
-0.0018624585354700685,
0.2597682476043701,
0.3550910949707031,
-0.13153937458992004,
-0.601842999458313,
-0.8292608261108398,
-0.6605803370475769,
-0.6117517352104187,
0.5767151713371277,
-0.14943385124206543,
0.29821881651878357,
0.2921956181526184,
0.48374882340431213,
0.171824648976326,
0.09383565187454224,
-0.17967084050178528,
-0.23052482306957245,
0.06253551691770554,
-0.14408105611801147,
0.3691686689853668,
-0.6659089922904968,
0.10093435645103455,
-0.5632401704788208,
1.2976007461547852,
0.07924799621105194,
0.03912923112511635,
0.26913344860076904,
-0.5218448638916016,
0.007618121802806854,
0.5421977639198303,
0.84584641456604,
0.837397575378418,
-0.21420973539352417,
-0.12904542684555054,
0.8082152605056763,
-0.453025758266449,
-0.16649530827999115,
-0.29622992873191833,
-0.4611293375492096,
0.11589625477790833,
0.49865153431892395,
1.2228590250015259,
0.6768140196800232,
-0.693221926689148,
0.3427101969718933,
0.12730084359645844,
-0.2713794708251953,
0.2293538898229599,
0.04220988228917122,
-0.012320374138653278,
0.14043352007865906,
0.1106390655040741,
0.4202854335308075,
-0.14590515196323395,
-0.4185234308242798,
0.04599399492144585,
0.16415609419345856,
-0.4113451838493347,
-0.35260987281799316,
0.47685858607292175,
0.20121878385543823,
-0.28929001092910767,
0.3834587335586548,
-0.013605879619717598,
-0.5162218809127808,
0.12038413435220718,
0.638189435005188,
0.7445353269577026,
-0.4067254960536957,
0.21901358664035797,
0.30521470308303833,
0.4542572498321533,
0.1546677201986313,
0.3100668787956238,
0.21298693120479584,
-0.9686209559440613,
-0.6257995367050171,
-0.323725163936615,
-0.5915756821632385,
0.09055449813604355,
-0.5963742136955261,
0.48054057359695435,
-0.5313413143157959,
0.0481908805668354,
-0.22680340707302094,
-0.13420988619327545,
-0.6957809329032898,
0.24069646000862122,
-0.1403922438621521,
1.0328795909881592,
-0.6312249302864075,
0.7008452415466309,
0.8151915073394775,
-0.16100676357746124,
-0.6732326745986938,
-0.09894780069589615,
-0.024298949167132378,
-0.6453688740730286,
0.22742782533168793,
-0.36589035391807556,
-0.20773190259933472,
-0.08473167568445206,
-0.39193740487098694,
-0.9469971656799316,
0.9920987486839294,
0.4040158689022064,
-0.621494710445404,
0.015786923468112946,
-0.059048399329185486,
0.5023360848426819,
0.03967289999127388,
0.054931994527578354,
0.5570037961006165,
0.6945577263832092,
0.04967223480343819,
-0.2844592034816742,
0.27534598112106323,
0.08165659755468369,
-0.003378515597432852,
0.1100550964474678,
-0.47534799575805664,
0.49521031975746155,
-0.36120909452438354,
-0.13853825628757477,
-0.09341668337583542,
1.167250394821167,
0.14142069220542908,
-0.014807149767875671,
0.5582697987556458,
0.6021138429641724,
1.050529956817627,
0.025171270594000816,
0.6478176712989807,
-0.24102677404880524,
0.38223955035209656,
1.3352755308151245,
-0.6729910373687744,
1.1226738691329956,
0.37051406502723694,
-0.15104983747005463,
0.7061805725097656,
0.06379517167806625,
-0.23455572128295898,
0.26740559935569763,
-0.08903109282255173,
-0.1891673505306244,
-0.0946178138256073,
0.14675018191337585,
-0.19546250998973846,
0.7463293075561523,
0.3417096734046936,
-0.1960541158914566,
-0.16175822913646698,
0.29454851150512695,
0.21298713982105255,
0.08248498290777206,
-0.19323885440826416,
0.7689130306243896,
-0.14138029515743256,
-0.3235611915588379,
0.0004725663166027516,
0.471081405878067,
0.6887445449829102,
-0.63909512758255,
0.0066938684321939945,
-0.08074657618999481,
0.0030293806921690702,
-0.16464322805404663,
-0.7103817462921143,
0.39931583404541016,
0.14369937777519226,
-0.0731692835688591,
-0.012895531952381134,
1.1560392379760742,
-0.4809536635875702,
-0.5742456912994385,
0.2068115919828415,
0.5230829119682312,
-0.23961283266544342,
0.11551062017679214,
-0.6566030383110046,
0.25218430161476135,
0.053586509078741074,
-0.4816546142101288,
0.17348387837409973,
0.2836489677429199,
-0.0005470162141136825,
0.6834644675254822,
0.8266491889953613,
0.506973922252655,
-0.2141762226819992,
0.19624114036560059,
0.631794273853302,
-0.731896162033081,
-0.5037307143211365,
-0.8671647906303406,
0.5475975275039673,
-0.22976213693618774,
-0.2794507145881653,
0.7238385081291199,
0.26389840245246887,
0.4360578656196594,
-0.12105032801628113,
0.8192125558853149,
-0.13035044074058533,
0.3086431920528412,
-0.6288214921951294,
0.6474140882492065,
-0.5095096230506897,
0.19534651935100555,
-0.36667105555534363,
-0.8747259378433228,
-0.2673378884792328,
0.36851394176483154,
-0.5586356520652771,
-0.32747882604599,
0.5458189845085144,
0.8634920716285706,
0.17900097370147705,
0.3718281686306,
0.45843592286109924,
0.7786402702331543,
0.3601696789264679,
-0.08271971344947815,
0.6482628583908081,
-0.4406420588493347,
-0.08303125202655792,
-0.4145883321762085,
-0.16972042620182037,
-0.12049464136362076,
-0.8072235584259033,
-0.7409940361976624,
-0.5538524985313416,
-0.5118187665939331,
-0.1380302757024765,
0.03397578001022339,
1.0178248882293701,
0.3004322946071625,
-0.6948494911193848,
0.2812800407409668,
0.30369439721107483,
0.5643858313560486,
-0.5910096168518066,
-0.21855266392230988,
0.6069130897521973,
-0.07488397508859634,
-0.6759399771690369,
0.7789490818977356,
0.4006770849227905,
-0.3029197156429291,
-0.4088744819164276,
0.16836388409137726,
-0.317066490650177,
0.43339094519615173,
0.9008858799934387,
0.18420842289924622,
-0.7868589758872986,
-0.6566392183303833,
-0.0797138661146164,
0.08564866334199905,
-0.2355072796344757,
0.725230872631073,
-0.5559865236282349,
0.4195570945739746,
0.6767019033432007,
0.7877972722053528,
0.28589239716529846,
0.09713667631149292,
0.5830115079879761,
-0.9183946251869202,
0.17116467654705048,
0.03614717349410057,
0.7412489652633667,
0.30654481053352356,
-0.48489272594451904,
0.22003218531608582,
0.20368582010269165,
-0.44137218594551086,
-0.9332180619239807,
-0.03381889685988426,
-0.8799811005592346,
-0.45597025752067566,
1.206218957901001,
-0.023333091288805008,
-0.5064409375190735,
0.0671849325299263,
-0.5202149152755737,
0.3692939579486847,
-0.020276810973882675,
0.5319841504096985,
0.6091227531433105,
0.13304643332958221,
0.06472315639257431,
-0.14918984472751617,
0.23430438339710236,
0.4718066155910492,
-0.8573663830757141,
0.24933050572872162,
0.4434792995452881,
0.44049954414367676,
0.014310752041637897,
0.2561190128326416,
-0.052972666919231415,
0.15434037148952484,
-0.0628914162516594,
0.32413896918296814,
-0.3201342523097992,
-0.10760430246591568,
-0.22399747371673584,
0.07981392741203308,
0.05487663671374321,
-0.03626209497451782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17755v1 | CauESC: A Causal Aware Model for Emotional Support Conversation | 2024-01-31T11:30:24 | 2024-01-31T11:30:24 | Wei Chen, Hengxu Lin, Qun Zhang, Xiaojin Zhang, Xiang Bai, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Emotional Support Conversation aims at reducing the seeker's emotional
distress through supportive response. Existing approaches have two limitations:
(1) They ignore the emotion causes of the distress, which is important for
fine-grained emotion understanding; (2) They focus on the seeker's own mental
state rather than the emotional dynamics during interaction between speakers.
To address these issues, we propose a novel framework CauESC, which firstly
recognizes the emotion causes of the distress, as well as the emotion effects
triggered by the causes, and then understands each strategy of verbal grooming
independently and integrates them skillfully. Experimental results on the
benchmark dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and show the
benefits of emotion understanding from cause to effect and
independent-integrated strategy modeling. | [
-0.3465527892112732,
-0.8207982182502747,
0.5391893982887268,
0.64013671875,
0.011684763245284557,
-0.2149132341146469,
0.056068938225507736,
-0.5947331786155701,
0.7015935182571411,
0.42446619272232056,
-0.982917308807373,
-0.07341789454221725,
-0.4910542070865631,
0.11409512907266617,
-0.45694783329963684,
0.8764590620994568,
0.142502099275589,
0.2344377487897873,
-0.058352019637823105,
-0.24715816974639893,
-0.7209324240684509,
-0.3652777671813965,
-1.304314374923706,
-0.100217804312706,
0.5558004379272461,
0.6080231070518494,
0.342073529958725,
0.23636074364185333,
0.44203072786331177,
0.34054580330848694,
-0.21506835520267487,
0.23395366966724396,
-0.6039161682128906,
0.34053221344947815,
-0.17388316988945007,
-0.4660583734512329,
-0.4563215672969818,
-0.15645277500152588,
0.32470041513442993,
0.48327207565307617,
-0.7877027988433838,
-0.10759337991476059,
0.3331463634967804,
0.5365822911262512,
-0.887635350227356,
-0.0827481746673584,
-0.5521368980407715,
0.1577446460723877,
0.07660505175590515,
-0.24234998226165771,
-0.6071217060089111,
-0.16313374042510986,
0.1331835240125656,
-0.5694859623908997,
0.12296299636363983,
-0.3122115433216095,
0.35805681347846985,
0.21514004468917847,
-0.9038769602775574,
-0.4164181053638458,
-0.8757939338684082,
0.5138666033744812,
-0.46320968866348267,
0.29837310314178467,
0.5566442608833313,
0.21727044880390167,
-0.05422447249293327,
-0.47261545062065125,
-0.19437254965305328,
0.22620759904384613,
-0.1400989294052124,
0.3911904990673065,
-0.5066454410552979,
0.3749696910381317,
0.26393699645996094,
0.01220071129500866,
-0.3008500337600708,
0.0030564418993890285,
-0.26032721996307373,
-0.018900185823440552,
0.5474702715873718,
0.3541974425315857,
0.2938370704650879,
-0.0043030790984630585,
-0.4813516438007355,
0.3181231915950775,
-0.47515612840652466,
0.3078083395957947,
-0.11700920015573502,
0.3501754701137543,
-0.12881335616111755,
0.16978931427001953,
-0.06623005867004395,
0.36418861150741577,
0.3976302146911621,
0.1300661861896515,
-0.4597509205341339,
0.13449929654598236,
-0.41860172152519226,
0.5232746601104736,
0.24111522734165192,
0.364748477935791,
0.025691842660307884,
-0.05790698528289795,
0.31030309200286865,
0.2944132089614868,
0.4034799039363861,
-0.9667474627494812,
0.2767181992530823,
0.28176259994506836,
-0.584692656993866,
-0.03934744372963905,
-0.059584520757198334,
-0.7670682072639465,
-0.779071033000946,
-0.505089282989502,
-0.05769342556595802,
-0.1638748198747635,
-0.3865275979042053,
0.101082444190979,
0.14000152051448822,
0.22133088111877441,
0.4573376476764679,
-0.7091894149780273,
0.818977415561676,
0.3115249574184418,
0.7387751340866089,
0.1603769212961197,
0.26434430480003357,
-0.9047909379005432,
0.11007032543420792,
-0.013877077959477901,
0.8165732026100159,
-0.51581209897995,
-0.6693746447563171,
0.08810709416866302,
0.12667834758758545,
-0.11803045868873596,
-0.1499689817428589,
1.0271811485290527,
-0.19331727921962738,
-0.18067164719104767,
-0.7544160485267639,
-0.3591795563697815,
-0.2921297550201416,
0.10064023733139038,
-0.46902844309806824,
0.7322238683700562,
-0.25738492608070374,
-0.7698705196380615,
0.1474243849515915,
-0.46032869815826416,
-0.4593668580055237,
0.057426098734140396,
-0.1062113493680954,
0.03460152447223663,
0.3178504705429077,
0.23434117436408997,
0.4012027680873871,
-0.4777461886405945,
0.6661092638969421,
-0.48521554470062256,
-0.1211269274353981,
0.013145082630217075,
-0.26746195554733276,
0.42427176237106323,
0.3473014533519745,
-0.4838577210903168,
0.16039378941059113,
-0.7122825384140015,
-0.17786894738674164,
-0.04329177737236023,
0.19334711134433746,
-0.7233705520629883,
0.49673593044281006,
-0.09716633707284927,
0.42781326174736023,
-0.38221275806427,
-0.48809105157852173,
-0.23275114595890045,
-0.3876792788505554,
0.214281365275383,
0.7650442719459534,
0.2774352729320526,
0.4379458427429199,
0.011825768277049065,
0.6838583946228027,
0.0031235371716320515,
0.4315362870693207,
-0.105637326836586,
-0.18277977406978607,
-0.8589746952056885,
-0.3139297068119049,
-0.4984930455684662,
0.5846707224845886,
-0.516613781452179,
0.06871787458658218,
0.5411383509635925,
-0.5031165480613708,
-0.3152986168861389,
-0.25784677267074585,
0.525862991809845,
0.7955401539802551,
0.4081282913684845,
-0.1678961217403412,
-0.7352175116539001,
-0.858892023563385,
-0.33503207564353943,
-0.3048395812511444,
0.4598299562931061,
0.3821866512298584,
-0.021712971851229668,
0.014683731831610203,
0.8748747110366821,
-0.3051778972148895,
-0.19487792253494263,
-0.09923094511032104,
0.301717072725296,
-0.31614232063293457,
0.42655470967292786,
0.5867863893508911,
-0.6942359209060669,
-0.2808767855167389,
-0.23958085477352142,
-0.8310123085975647,
-0.43531686067581177,
-0.3151772618293762,
-0.38352376222610474,
-0.06037908419966698,
0.6296983361244202,
-0.3828567862510681,
0.9459506273269653,
0.37887412309646606,
-0.5758429169654846,
0.270577609539032,
-0.024803005158901215,
0.5344448089599609,
-0.8790816068649292,
-0.007578991819173098,
0.5117090940475464,
0.02739471197128296,
-0.7842691540718079,
-0.45635902881622314,
-0.12841609120368958,
-0.23907269537448883,
-0.4927928149700165,
0.37366944551467896,
-0.32073861360549927,
0.2935890853404999,
-0.18555042147636414,
0.2523828446865082,
0.04247458279132843,
0.4094323217868805,
0.20138008892536163,
0.32674527168273926,
0.5129175186157227,
-0.6824856400489807,
0.07928340137004852,
0.5189999938011169,
0.15241184830665588,
1.3255270719528198,
-0.8613021969795227,
-0.053828563541173935,
-0.27219367027282715,
0.4389796853065491,
-0.9324450492858887,
0.04207618907094002,
0.2217942476272583,
-0.16184890270233154,
0.1650487631559372,
-0.0026456923224031925,
0.19065216183662415,
-0.3201342821121216,
0.09885679185390472,
0.4003993570804596,
-0.09913812577724457,
-0.5479641556739807,
0.8955028653144836,
0.3056771159172058,
-0.4276362359523773,
-0.5371006727218628,
-0.6568017601966858,
0.10888152569532394,
-0.4554172456264496,
-0.762555718421936,
0.18818403780460358,
-0.38452842831611633,
-0.347309947013855,
-0.4456123411655426,
-0.15240192413330078,
0.03792572021484375,
0.2667215168476105,
0.5748358368873596,
-0.06721844524145126,
0.06975116580724716,
0.4913323223590851,
0.2650192081928253,
-0.12072498351335526,
0.3368295133113861,
0.12318442016839981,
0.26832252740859985,
-0.23831528425216675,
-0.643248975276947,
-0.7110161185264587,
1.0710153579711914,
0.3619794249534607,
-0.4377521276473999,
0.8594061732292175,
0.45853191614151,
-0.5578171014785767,
-0.10591758042573929,
-0.8057868480682373,
-0.5046110153198242,
-0.42631351947784424,
0.29151228070259094,
-0.1275884360074997,
-0.8327629566192627,
0.7879499793052673,
-0.36514168977737427,
-0.31406089663505554,
0.14655448496341705,
0.356917142868042,
0.07337961345911026,
1.4882123470306396,
0.8084624409675598,
-0.06150737777352333,
0.469833105802536,
0.2297663390636444,
0.47443774342536926,
-0.6080102920532227,
-0.3811416029930115,
-0.8485639095306396,
-0.26187869906425476,
-0.310045450925827,
0.17486535012722015,
0.1557868868112564,
0.29994478821754456,
-0.46983635425567627,
0.04152799770236015,
-0.5372163653373718,
-0.01509191282093525,
0.09089252352714539,
0.3313640058040619,
0.07927531749010086,
-0.1985292285680771,
-0.08354859054088593,
-0.3539503514766693,
-0.68575119972229,
-0.21917325258255005,
0.12596729397773743,
0.4072988033294678,
0.745254635810852,
0.23628804087638855,
0.4863429367542267,
0.09489022940397263,
0.32357677817344666,
-0.785226047039032,
0.6146465539932251,
0.26907896995544434,
-0.5717528462409973,
0.24749381840229034,
-0.34974759817123413,
-0.9297886490821838,
0.15611274540424347,
-0.226473867893219,
-1.267830729484558,
0.7471158504486084,
0.09076882153749466,
-0.3400043249130249,
0.022254426032304764,
-0.8757190108299255,
0.5674615502357483,
-0.299586683511734,
-0.6343948245048523,
-0.4366415739059448,
-0.7646745443344116,
0.32829779386520386,
0.13542988896369934,
0.47350817918777466,
0.006963704712688923,
0.4159967005252838,
1.0698964595794678,
-0.6884920597076416,
1.0944331884384155,
-0.38663628697395325,
0.07663299888372421,
0.5953035354614258,
0.316133588552475,
0.7207643389701843,
0.008052296936511993,
-0.12423291802406311,
-0.5764529705047607,
-0.019482292234897614,
-0.2790277302265167,
-0.7852045893669128,
0.7060064673423767,
-0.5336323976516724,
-0.7316805720329285,
-0.19861061871051788,
-0.32649603486061096,
-0.4823092222213745,
-0.053179722279310226,
-0.22086016833782196,
0.49087095260620117,
-0.5045233964920044,
0.06710978597402573,
0.5830103754997253,
-0.19035087525844574,
0.4328366219997406,
0.7606729865074158,
0.08809717744588852,
-0.21899206936359406,
0.157967671751976,
-0.11901076883077621,
-0.00894195307046175,
-0.1887557953596115,
0.28048551082611084,
-0.07826357334852219,
0.11103028059005737,
0.3039482831954956,
0.3441995680332184,
-0.892368733882904,
-0.4431629180908203,
-0.8068650960922241,
0.08905597776174545,
-0.37016934156417847,
-0.40878456830978394,
-0.3797752261161804,
0.006032305769622326,
-0.4606644809246063,
-0.5195579528808594,
0.689230740070343,
0.6389409303665161,
-0.24604007601737976,
0.690447986125946,
-0.8716127276420593,
-0.06525269895792007,
0.3505065441131592,
0.12188542634248734,
0.3100838363170624,
-0.17173373699188232,
-0.3334093987941742,
0.0854693204164505,
-0.45824021100997925,
-1.2349272966384888,
0.49212491512298584,
0.18552325665950775,
0.5497035980224609,
0.8270137310028076,
0.33233413100242615,
1.039158582687378,
-0.042436644434928894,
0.8423275351524353,
0.5661231279373169,
-1.2923765182495117,
0.9666168689727783,
-0.3178733289241791,
-0.08142196387052536,
0.5627003312110901,
0.3709407150745392,
-0.8069139122962952,
-0.030641980469226837,
-0.8035023212432861,
-0.8046952486038208,
0.9040079712867737,
0.1121888980269432,
-0.1943470686674118,
-0.41710910201072693,
0.44111353158950806,
-0.4234582185745239,
-0.03552914410829544,
-0.5910674929618835,
-0.17674003541469574,
0.10402017831802368,
-0.10310886800289154,
0.2974757254123688,
-0.5594549179077148,
-0.38648995757102966,
-0.07188722491264343,
0.807210385799408,
-0.08550760895013809,
0.4122910499572754,
0.5365293025970459,
0.15760821104049683,
-0.6185612082481384,
0.2348266839981079,
0.5814719796180725,
0.1958611011505127,
0.032721154391765594,
0.017421944066882133,
0.3798694610595703,
-0.19128136336803436,
-0.0919899195432663,
0.036541346460580826,
0.48905548453330994,
-0.29629233479499817,
0.11785703897476196,
0.7886838912963867,
0.46091368794441223,
-0.3109002411365509,
0.5409550666809082,
-0.2434999793767929,
-0.12591296434402466,
0.06895773112773895,
-0.22550927102565765,
0.13061034679412842,
0.5860978364944458,
0.18218517303466797,
0.18638819456100464,
0.5497889518737793,
-0.26125621795654297,
0.21515925228595734,
0.398909330368042,
-1.0287667512893677,
-0.25302284955978394,
0.577339231967926,
0.49105972051620483,
-0.2010677307844162,
0.455360472202301,
0.12729431688785553,
-0.608585000038147,
0.6326761245727539,
0.676570475101471,
0.7773568034172058,
-0.833344578742981,
0.3638937771320343,
0.487568199634552,
0.10695290565490723,
-0.14537706971168518,
0.28970059752464294,
-0.25370705127716064,
-0.5995720028877258,
-0.32186806201934814,
-0.09380263090133667,
-0.35221731662750244,
-0.49411123991012573,
-1.2415953874588013,
0.31346675753593445,
-0.20921176671981812,
-0.2870066165924072,
-0.3426508903503418,
-0.20951443910598755,
-0.6844573020935059,
0.3102661967277527,
0.11343565583229065,
1.0380761623382568,
-1.2206059694290161,
0.32986778020858765,
0.37016531825065613,
-0.4148730933666229,
-1.4246971607208252,
-0.5850353837013245,
0.39193955063819885,
-0.7172849178314209,
0.6484554409980774,
0.0969567820429802,
-0.6176134943962097,
-0.22924277186393738,
-0.7002434730529785,
-0.6293253302574158,
1.0527969598770142,
0.46785590052604675,
-0.43538329005241394,
0.138591468334198,
-0.26080459356307983,
0.45934945344924927,
-0.4036692976951599,
0.6330739259719849,
0.5393213033676147,
0.490901917219162,
0.43128907680511475,
-0.7646401524543762,
0.1733051985502243,
-0.5229039788246155,
-0.04638407751917839,
0.04054088518023491,
-0.8218112587928772,
0.38417860865592957,
0.037514619529247284,
-0.42823004722595215,
0.09361933171749115,
0.5577079653739929,
0.17605328559875488,
0.6014735102653503,
0.5316677689552307,
0.3568101227283478,
0.9184815287590027,
-0.1142755076289177,
0.8235015869140625,
-0.12722916901111603,
0.22817037999629974,
1.1881293058395386,
-0.4566190838813782,
0.5289437174797058,
0.5711963772773743,
0.1434955894947052,
0.5588927865028381,
0.5780553817749023,
0.6413920521736145,
0.3448931574821472,
0.18786519765853882,
-0.5541222095489502,
-0.427598237991333,
-0.8609492182731628,
-0.36083662509918213,
0.6114035844802856,
0.659415602684021,
-0.40245407819747925,
-0.3180880844593048,
0.29623526334762573,
0.3373859226703644,
0.29372671246528625,
-0.4365212917327881,
0.7741328477859497,
0.35138022899627686,
-0.71237713098526,
0.24313434958457947,
-0.07171878963708878,
0.3355197012424469,
-0.7987494468688965,
-0.043452080339193344,
-0.42418959736824036,
0.1323523223400116,
-0.5826354622840881,
-0.2766939401626587,
0.501003623008728,
0.008861582726240158,
-0.05616094917058945,
-0.14506195485591888,
1.1265846490859985,
-0.2976778447628021,
-0.22014231979846954,
0.766821026802063,
0.5646576285362244,
-0.16794170439243317,
-0.11968619376420975,
-0.589036762714386,
0.10271596908569336,
-0.3030003309249878,
-0.2898106873035431,
0.2819405198097229,
0.697356641292572,
-0.027300594374537468,
0.6048698425292969,
0.3408602476119995,
-0.15639594197273254,
-0.45448729395866394,
0.3211539685726166,
0.8479889035224915,
-0.47492730617523193,
-0.7309421300888062,
-0.5757886171340942,
0.7812530994415283,
-0.1850113868713379,
-0.03464306518435478,
0.4643899202346802,
-0.14179755747318268,
-0.03442191332578659,
0.3211815357208252,
0.4594166874885559,
0.12437503784894943,
0.2893187403678894,
-0.23921354115009308,
0.3458743095397949,
-0.4738801419734955,
0.14760662615299225,
-0.7007594704627991,
-0.5047457218170166,
-0.3882826268672943,
0.7898697257041931,
-0.37370216846466064,
0.1363372802734375,
0.644080400466919,
0.871429979801178,
0.31410661339759827,
0.812068521976471,
0.1038263738155365,
0.29367807507514954,
0.5294886827468872,
0.6206857562065125,
1.0430198907852173,
-0.1615535467863083,
0.35909122228622437,
-0.04979008436203003,
-0.4388364255428314,
-0.04117989540100098,
-1.017673373222351,
-0.5716103911399841,
-0.5710626244544983,
-0.3368321657180786,
-0.4593140482902527,
0.0014877832727506757,
0.9458662867546082,
0.8044123649597168,
-0.50836580991745,
-0.17074687778949738,
-0.36532363295555115,
-0.03783220052719116,
-0.3756495714187622,
-0.23667092621326447,
0.13678477704524994,
-0.12137475609779358,
-0.07162650674581528,
0.38654884696006775,
0.29641082882881165,
-0.2645267844200134,
0.08971311151981354,
-0.14035101234912872,
-0.40860989689826965,
0.4413830041885376,
0.6742355227470398,
0.4546153247356415,
-0.4629586935043335,
-0.39455145597457886,
0.0537387952208519,
0.12381744384765625,
-0.01634310558438301,
1.1537739038467407,
-0.7594096660614014,
0.6125002503395081,
-0.07937642186880112,
0.5674905776977539,
0.4438548684120178,
-0.03469718620181084,
0.5489687919616699,
-0.6152236461639404,
0.20881803333759308,
0.06820826232433319,
0.5788195729255676,
0.18951694667339325,
-0.9411442875862122,
0.403886079788208,
0.14469599723815918,
-0.5990169644355774,
-0.5588382482528687,
0.3982413411140442,
-1.333975911140442,
-0.001179709448479116,
0.9529955983161926,
-0.349080353975296,
0.12660615146160126,
0.03797672688961029,
-0.7305238246917725,
0.576747477054596,
-0.4921046793460846,
0.5100133419036865,
0.4957267940044403,
-0.34155571460723877,
-0.33780908584594727,
-0.08900038152933121,
0.3157395124435425,
0.6748045086860657,
-0.8893468976020813,
0.21861054003238678,
0.5822352170944214,
-0.2593497633934021,
-0.1079854890704155,
0.6741348505020142,
0.053856611251831055,
0.09084537625312805,
-0.22320885956287384,
0.0950261726975441,
0.3011569678783417,
-0.308480441570282,
-0.252778023481369,
0.11020594090223312,
-0.031598709523677826,
0.2716984450817108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17716v1 | Enhancing Large Language Model with Decomposed Reasoning for Emotion Cause Pair Extraction | 2024-01-31T10:20:01 | 2024-01-31T10:20:01 | Jialiang Wu, Yi Shen, Ziheng Zhang, Longjun Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction (ECPE) involves extracting clause pairs
representing emotions and their causes in a document. Existing methods tend to
overfit spurious correlations, such as positional bias in existing benchmark
datasets, rather than capturing semantic features. Inspired by recent work, we
explore leveraging large language model (LLM) to address ECPE task without
additional training. Despite strong capabilities, LLMs suffer from
uncontrollable outputs, resulting in mediocre performance. To address this, we
introduce chain-of-thought to mimic human cognitive process and propose the
Decomposed Emotion-Cause Chain (DECC) framework. Combining inducing inference
and logical pruning, DECC guides LLMs to tackle ECPE task. We further enhance
the framework by incorporating in-context learning. Experiment results
demonstrate the strength of DECC compared to state-of-the-art supervised
fine-tuning methods. Finally, we analyze the effectiveness of each component
and the robustness of the method in various scenarios, including different LLM
bases, rebalanced datasets, and multi-pair extraction. | [
-0.4851219952106476,
-0.8730003237724304,
0.6405497789382935,
-0.16358855366706848,
-0.37589356303215027,
-0.07428597658872604,
-0.5125846862792969,
-0.5593752861022949,
0.20962409675121307,
0.5534530282020569,
-0.7301246523857117,
-0.5355036854743958,
-0.5006113648414612,
0.13659368455410004,
-0.44017493724823,
0.8633994460105896,
0.10830727219581604,
-0.3242180347442627,
-0.23164549469947815,
0.0005877108196727931,
-0.1581519991159439,
-0.6935680508613586,
-0.8751910924911499,
-0.25255298614501953,
0.4293501377105713,
0.6177131533622742,
0.14276596903800964,
0.042517006397247314,
0.2621897757053375,
0.3199189305305481,
-0.0234798863530159,
0.41468504071235657,
-0.5543566942214966,
0.2250683307647705,
-0.14333605766296387,
-0.46361979842185974,
-0.65519118309021,
-0.12196772545576096,
0.278567910194397,
0.4627104103565216,
-0.36512112617492676,
-0.06519527733325958,
-0.01868583634495735,
0.9217044711112976,
-0.7367377281188965,
0.11892770975828171,
-0.8378955721855164,
-0.17601771652698517,
0.006113482639193535,
-0.17886924743652344,
-0.5824915170669556,
-0.12253277003765106,
0.05578006058931351,
-0.29887163639068604,
0.0033487596083432436,
0.115875244140625,
0.49465271830558777,
0.3151923418045044,
-0.7281158566474915,
-0.2530319094657898,
-0.43000495433807373,
0.6997724771499634,
-0.9215565323829651,
0.3402721583843231,
0.3683834969997406,
-0.355169415473938,
-0.3320938050746918,
-0.49526697397232056,
-0.6256108283996582,
0.11413338035345078,
0.10679583996534348,
0.2762294411659241,
-0.13636742532253265,
0.2316598892211914,
0.4596650302410126,
0.3687199056148529,
-0.37803149223327637,
0.21685755252838135,
-0.08533265441656113,
0.12079460918903351,
0.7325981855392456,
0.17136217653751373,
0.5575417876243591,
-0.03470436856150627,
-0.3574132025241852,
-0.07386507838964462,
-0.8456627726554871,
0.05912419408559799,
0.42805081605911255,
0.10132233053445816,
-0.2368943989276886,
0.30541756749153137,
-0.007060526870191097,
0.45401686429977417,
0.037370555102825165,
0.18574225902557373,
0.1930229365825653,
0.056834783405065536,
-0.29871413111686707,
0.21542276442050934,
0.812824547290802,
0.43337252736091614,
0.22230497002601624,
-0.05566127970814705,
-0.17958062887191772,
0.32969117164611816,
0.2955150306224823,
-0.9407474398612976,
-0.23918595910072327,
0.530796229839325,
-0.4084707200527191,
-0.32230618596076965,
-0.07963872700929642,
-1.251082420349121,
-0.41814205050468445,
-0.48489126563072205,
0.03215187042951584,
-0.43798646330833435,
-0.5833154320716858,
0.19335409998893738,
0.02507464587688446,
0.1517239362001419,
0.17617471516132355,
-0.9860484600067139,
0.4084976315498352,
0.9421910643577576,
0.47108757495880127,
-0.1090216413140297,
-0.009850550442934036,
-0.6781162619590759,
-0.17746251821517944,
-0.31445416808128357,
0.6835789084434509,
-0.5783474445343018,
-0.046303898096084595,
0.24653390049934387,
0.11710365116596222,
0.08070271462202072,
-0.44537943601608276,
0.9588070511817932,
-0.38195857405662537,
0.2437242716550827,
-0.262561559677124,
-0.7228806018829346,
-0.1478951871395111,
0.28956082463264465,
-0.6254360675811768,
0.9482956528663635,
-0.17860929667949677,
-0.9397690296173096,
0.10722370445728302,
-0.5164651274681091,
-0.5918182134628296,
-0.08467122912406921,
-0.08669988811016083,
-0.27739328145980835,
0.33999282121658325,
0.3644978404045105,
0.571805477142334,
-0.6016803979873657,
0.2605380713939667,
-0.5153571367263794,
-0.021682240068912506,
0.16229870915412903,
-0.18148644268512726,
0.6781476736068726,
0.016594193875789642,
-0.37041711807250977,
0.10293038934469223,
-0.9835758805274963,
-0.12057552486658096,
0.11758311837911606,
-0.1866988092660904,
-0.7860448360443115,
0.2356632649898529,
-0.1361810564994812,
0.7243906259536743,
0.025174781680107117,
-0.5196651220321655,
0.029368169605731964,
-0.6733723878860474,
0.6315036416053772,
0.8143368363380432,
0.1997748166322708,
0.3674424886703491,
0.2219453752040863,
0.46816933155059814,
0.10528484731912613,
-0.14311306178569794,
-0.2020469754934311,
-0.11365053057670593,
-0.7224040627479553,
-0.26057925820350647,
-0.1492973417043686,
0.27668002247810364,
-0.6819758415222168,
0.589843213558197,
0.05914252996444702,
-0.12221688032150269,
-0.4045100510120392,
0.22077295184135437,
0.3505817651748657,
0.7403900027275085,
0.3479003310203552,
-0.15911468863487244,
-0.6042596697807312,
-0.7367957234382629,
-0.15007305145263672,
-0.11380024999380112,
-0.13555163145065308,
0.15792763233184814,
0.4068898856639862,
-0.09910066425800323,
0.46145132184028625,
-0.5342459082603455,
0.007223318796604872,
-0.24462643265724182,
0.3543418049812317,
0.07792365550994873,
0.25730597972869873,
0.15657174587249756,
-0.6798173189163208,
0.04668189585208893,
-0.16410773992538452,
-0.6528768539428711,
-0.3424660563468933,
-0.22681112587451935,
-0.4352656304836273,
0.4866045415401459,
0.5904580354690552,
-0.5319522619247437,
0.30879727005958557,
0.6630986928939819,
-0.5169137716293335,
0.5444842576980591,
-0.28592202067375183,
0.17071887850761414,
-1.1430857181549072,
0.033733759075403214,
0.3245214521884918,
-0.05573960766196251,
-0.5146533250808716,
0.027877768501639366,
0.171064093708992,
-0.02536243572831154,
-0.35937973856925964,
0.1255894899368286,
-0.4377310574054718,
0.018757924437522888,
-0.2519499659538269,
0.4030396640300751,
0.18705083429813385,
0.5974137783050537,
0.15256531536579132,
0.06348609924316406,
0.4551156759262085,
-0.35782065987586975,
0.47876620292663574,
0.23132352530956268,
-0.3256571292877197,
0.8333806395530701,
-0.44562408328056335,
0.2553841769695282,
-0.22644078731536865,
0.28818848729133606,
-0.8126671314239502,
-0.14928090572357178,
0.0014263889752328396,
0.01927918754518032,
0.35033294558525085,
-0.02334398217499256,
-0.6734322905540466,
-0.3431440591812134,
-0.31967446208000183,
0.27472689747810364,
0.6101821660995483,
-0.8367724418640137,
0.6092202663421631,
0.3092850148677826,
-0.065480537712574,
-0.14334428310394287,
-0.5274075269699097,
0.14537307620048523,
-0.6551289558410645,
-0.6126834154129028,
0.38638946413993835,
-0.011657646857202053,
-0.3571752905845642,
-0.33681049942970276,
-0.20424038171768188,
0.01966819167137146,
0.1722276210784912,
0.40819108486175537,
0.2022865116596222,
0.076300248503685,
0.5280277132987976,
-0.010241671465337276,
-0.020211156457662582,
0.6109659671783447,
0.12808358669281006,
0.5491490364074707,
-0.2313208132982254,
-0.1602250337600708,
-0.25255605578422546,
0.5055452585220337,
0.8499882817268372,
-0.4820125102996826,
0.5942332148551941,
0.3467811942100525,
-0.4492199420928955,
-0.5622557401657104,
-0.5158324241638184,
-0.45736539363861084,
-0.40013086795806885,
0.36548057198524475,
-0.20082992315292358,
-0.6708035469055176,
0.5341417789459229,
-0.6086921691894531,
-0.2478625476360321,
0.1701083779335022,
0.650196373462677,
-0.10051444172859192,
0.8454154133796692,
0.4670090675354004,
-0.25497373938560486,
0.5424831509590149,
-0.18243229389190674,
0.3481242060661316,
-1.0719481706619263,
-0.24121513962745667,
-0.332206130027771,
-0.29931405186653137,
-0.4410702884197235,
-0.09529446810483932,
0.21456149220466614,
0.22099298238754272,
-0.32622864842414856,
0.15752668678760529,
-0.32513365149497986,
0.3005741238594055,
0.3685555160045624,
0.48309335112571716,
0.23218201100826263,
-0.19835899770259857,
0.015482635237276554,
0.06391572207212448,
-0.5594558119773865,
-0.23935188353061676,
0.8318803310394287,
0.2397501915693283,
0.622454822063446,
-0.06869436055421829,
0.6748455762863159,
-0.057389553636312485,
0.08048482239246368,
-0.7254687547683716,
0.5730841755867004,
-0.1434134542942047,
-0.34222865104675293,
-0.0828956812620163,
-0.3700703978538513,
-0.8801324963569641,
0.20965822041034698,
-0.38405531644821167,
-1.0780707597732544,
0.18008087575435638,
0.09016115963459015,
-0.09943380206823349,
0.3628663122653961,
-0.5401455760002136,
0.9247730374336243,
-0.36457571387290955,
-0.5388394594192505,
-0.6344931721687317,
-0.6872536540031433,
0.6679079532623291,
-0.20642919838428497,
0.37266984581947327,
-0.03302357345819473,
0.17993420362472534,
0.6671017408370972,
-0.6786748170852661,
0.9171041250228882,
0.13631579279899597,
-0.47813189029693604,
0.4010002017021179,
0.1311715543270111,
0.8722839951515198,
-0.19624343514442444,
-0.28014466166496277,
0.0021367985755205154,
-0.3200927674770355,
-0.1334112137556076,
-0.6846551299095154,
0.8256633877754211,
-0.4119512736797333,
-0.5012126564979553,
0.07196588069200516,
-0.3831895589828491,
-0.25617507100105286,
-0.10492032766342163,
0.08426771312952042,
0.579866886138916,
-0.03901050239801407,
0.1976107656955719,
0.43573564291000366,
-0.3936457931995392,
0.6566420197486877,
0.40237343311309814,
0.024099431931972504,
-0.4462132751941681,
0.5749685168266296,
-0.4271850883960724,
0.34866467118263245,
0.35379791259765625,
0.3489191234111786,
-0.23335574567317963,
-0.07918877899646759,
-0.0009687509154900908,
0.2050340175628662,
-0.6344020962715149,
-0.17277762293815613,
-0.5244263410568237,
0.24489769339561462,
-0.13051806390285492,
-0.14083604514598846,
-0.48252981901168823,
0.008215459063649178,
-0.1141723245382309,
-0.37383079528808594,
0.49937912821769714,
0.2985284626483917,
0.003988977055996656,
-0.05970803648233414,
-0.7976541519165039,
0.4595252275466919,
0.26904982328414917,
0.188728466629982,
0.1751391589641571,
-0.3741810917854309,
-0.14822699129581451,
-0.0019442131742835045,
-0.25118693709373474,
-1.0575000047683716,
0.6556309461593628,
0.12470687180757523,
0.22042310237884521,
0.6149553656578064,
0.5998222827911377,
0.6398431062698364,
-0.2829200327396393,
0.675317108631134,
0.34010985493659973,
-1.1909953355789185,
0.7754724025726318,
-0.22730498015880585,
-0.03314151242375374,
0.3160375952720642,
0.3594740033149719,
-0.5257404446601868,
-0.4083157777786255,
-0.9062345623970032,
-1.1869618892669678,
0.5114527940750122,
0.08620363473892212,
-0.16665753722190857,
-0.3522433340549469,
0.3302046060562134,
-0.1812078058719635,
0.08666961640119553,
-0.5226029753684998,
-0.06148744001984596,
0.2364945262670517,
-0.32232534885406494,
0.07238438725471497,
-0.401967316865921,
-0.05268247425556183,
-0.1995520144701004,
0.6329851150512695,
-0.1306920200586319,
-0.10061473399400711,
0.3568783700466156,
-0.09866545349359512,
-0.4216087758541107,
0.4255436062812805,
0.3982583284378052,
0.2798977494239807,
-0.2293769270181656,
0.40608280897140503,
0.2816646099090576,
0.11875680834054947,
-0.01869708113372326,
-0.18680278956890106,
0.31544777750968933,
-0.4809523820877075,
0.5258304476737976,
0.7182399034500122,
0.4288511574268341,
-0.9231160879135132,
0.590298056602478,
0.09333524852991104,
-0.1017654612660408,
-0.24139511585235596,
-0.19770947098731995,
0.29980719089508057,
0.4033578634262085,
0.1329624056816101,
-0.19366469979286194,
0.2110610157251358,
-0.7005714774131775,
0.20562787353992462,
0.4458523690700531,
-0.2164962887763977,
-0.6106898784637451,
0.48924845457077026,
0.5561614632606506,
-0.20312045514583588,
0.8495920896530151,
-0.10049433261156082,
-0.8945057988166809,
0.8354933261871338,
0.6633213758468628,
0.9859557747840881,
-0.19327278435230255,
0.054821379482746124,
0.4782048761844635,
0.22543373703956604,
-0.24942119419574738,
0.21398842334747314,
-0.12486377358436584,
-0.8454837203025818,
-0.6741616725921631,
-0.26578187942504883,
-0.3490360379219055,
0.26385006308555603,
-0.7968406677246094,
0.439686119556427,
-0.13207343220710754,
0.20364537835121155,
-0.45650598406791687,
-0.1539987027645111,
-0.7075763940811157,
0.19838964939117432,
0.5743522047996521,
0.6179726123809814,
-1.1499196290969849,
0.8791455626487732,
0.6701721549034119,
-0.38302209973335266,
-0.9041950702667236,
-0.017411965876817703,
0.02541370876133442,
-0.49319684505462646,
0.7790890336036682,
0.2700155973434448,
0.030671782791614532,
-0.05328177660703659,
-0.4351741373538971,
-0.35298267006874084,
0.862341582775116,
0.3412471413612366,
-0.9242169260978699,
0.2317344844341278,
-0.1349387764930725,
0.6898343563079834,
-0.5287557244300842,
0.35971006751060486,
0.6276430487632751,
0.33367136120796204,
-0.019393078982830048,
-0.48795628547668457,
0.5114295482635498,
-0.15736135840415955,
-0.3222416937351227,
0.39970842003822327,
-0.6590592861175537,
0.5224096775054932,
-0.23060575127601624,
-0.1482611447572708,
-0.4973706305027008,
0.208428755402565,
0.2965419292449951,
0.3221302628517151,
0.7836433053016663,
0.8520984053611755,
0.8892753720283508,
0.2574499249458313,
1.0122268199920654,
-0.5137200951576233,
0.3405649960041046,
1.2664384841918945,
-0.49132809042930603,
1.0754976272583008,
0.6376404762268066,
-0.12836304306983948,
0.7421622276306152,
0.5157811641693115,
0.3304494619369507,
0.41152501106262207,
0.3289963901042938,
-0.37018078565597534,
-0.6236879825592041,
0.0516226552426815,
-0.04845795780420303,
0.5040476322174072,
0.5880972146987915,
-0.5577173233032227,
-0.1307915896177292,
-0.26860666275024414,
0.05271759629249573,
0.062432363629341125,
-0.37029287219047546,
0.779297411441803,
0.4100699722766876,
-0.5997439026832581,
0.49336177110671997,
-0.4571722149848938,
0.642437756061554,
-0.18999642133712769,
-0.17722398042678833,
-0.34609290957450867,
0.11860477924346924,
-0.378525972366333,
-0.39184409379959106,
0.23769941926002502,
0.11626727133989334,
-0.009643958881497383,
-0.16883395612239838,
0.8717464208602905,
-0.7303771376609802,
-0.4305565059185028,
0.5564182996749878,
0.365888386964798,
0.058581288903951645,
-0.38015517592430115,
-0.4198628067970276,
0.10141166299581528,
-0.06813616305589676,
-0.5393648743629456,
0.3333856463432312,
0.9353837966918945,
0.1146867498755455,
0.5563469529151917,
0.6403416395187378,
0.04726198688149452,
-0.4779675006866455,
0.19732211530208588,
0.8635968565940857,
-0.8523761630058289,
-0.26757705211639404,
-1.2954905033111572,
0.8209614157676697,
-0.27786701917648315,
-0.162440687417984,
0.3254990875720978,
0.2835317552089691,
0.4066244661808014,
0.0490882433950901,
0.5368762612342834,
0.0036194075364619493,
0.10815471410751343,
-0.5382663607597351,
0.44342702627182007,
-0.5927904844284058,
0.32922860980033875,
-0.6229398250579834,
-0.8467031717300415,
-0.19064681231975555,
0.42008116841316223,
-0.3417931795120239,
-0.29126647114753723,
0.9726181626319885,
0.681542158126831,
0.11883276700973511,
0.10584444552659988,
0.41044503450393677,
0.4709956645965576,
0.40216320753097534,
1.0923317670822144,
0.7806289196014404,
-0.29115813970565796,
0.407881498336792,
-0.26545631885528564,
-0.3416629731655121,
-0.22615554928779602,
-1.3586314916610718,
-0.9602746367454529,
-0.6087183356285095,
-0.7251925468444824,
-0.30307289958000183,
-0.15484821796417236,
1.1736676692962646,
0.5384291410446167,
-0.602225661277771,
0.19354122877120972,
-0.5290807485580444,
0.1863064467906952,
-0.16049358248710632,
-0.23345094919204712,
0.5041705369949341,
-0.4014117121696472,
-0.66790372133255,
0.38025137782096863,
0.2759600281715393,
-0.36663463711738586,
0.02023107372224331,
-0.005917268805205822,
-0.048503898084163666,
-0.010770699940621853,
0.8736764192581177,
0.15468940138816833,
-0.7301478981971741,
-0.3940839469432831,
-0.45018869638442993,
0.13973021507263184,
0.04552626237273216,
0.863696813583374,
-0.6126629114151001,
0.43443763256073,
0.595906138420105,
0.6038908958435059,
0.4280203580856323,
0.1726170927286148,
0.8143523931503296,
-0.7267420291900635,
0.036853764206171036,
-0.038546107709407806,
0.7885820865631104,
0.24391725659370422,
-0.4249764680862427,
0.5626032948493958,
0.08089058101177216,
-0.6934270262718201,
-0.6522632241249084,
0.3250052034854889,
-1.1610373258590698,
-0.3364884555339813,
1.314712643623352,
-0.35440513491630554,
-0.18366198241710663,
0.2829168438911438,
-0.3189304769039154,
0.4297100305557251,
-0.5074155926704407,
0.9848273396492004,
0.6522937417030334,
-0.1792861521244049,
-0.3921496272087097,
-0.2067692130804062,
0.19936683773994446,
0.45433950424194336,
-1.2648195028305054,
0.47469478845596313,
0.6046896576881409,
0.09472180157899857,
-0.12523268163204193,
0.2321772426366806,
-0.07147319614887238,
-0.18595820665359497,
-0.04163492098450661,
0.632206380367279,
0.08176588267087936,
0.03564593195915222,
-0.4185129404067993,
0.23581087589263916,
-0.14145474135875702,
0.028457239270210266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17703v1 | WSC+: Enhancing The Winograd Schema Challenge Using Tree-of-Experts | 2024-01-31T09:49:22 | 2024-01-31T09:49:22 | Pardis Sadat Zahraei, Ali Emami | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7; K.4.1 | The Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC) serves as a prominent benchmark for
evaluating machine understanding. While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at
answering WSC questions, their ability to generate such questions remains less
explored. In this work, we propose Tree-of-Experts (ToE), a novel prompting
method which enhances the generation of WSC instances (50% valid cases vs. 10%
in recent methods). Using this approach, we introduce WSC+, a novel dataset
comprising 3,026 LLM-generated sentences. Notably, we extend the WSC framework
by incorporating new 'ambiguous' and 'offensive' categories, providing a deeper
insight into model overconfidence and bias. Our analysis reveals nuances in
generation-evaluation consistency, suggesting that LLMs may not always
outperform in evaluating their own generated questions when compared to those
crafted by other models. On WSC+, GPT-4, the top-performing LLM, achieves an
accuracy of 68.7%, significantly below the human benchmark of 95.1%. | [
-0.49037158489227295,
-0.5636118054389954,
0.7744241952896118,
-0.1540643870830536,
-0.10711074620485306,
0.5887430310249329,
-0.30151715874671936,
-0.7352211475372314,
-0.17224889993667603,
0.22071576118469238,
-0.6925650238990784,
-0.559475302696228,
-0.6399884819984436,
0.16471129655838013,
-0.21915385127067566,
0.9420974254608154,
0.14605319499969482,
-0.22688321769237518,
-0.41264089941978455,
-0.10787373781204224,
-0.5502892136573792,
-0.3677009046077728,
-0.23808299005031586,
-0.037291284650564194,
0.37842100858688354,
0.7383359670639038,
0.850062906742096,
0.40933629870414734,
0.4677174389362335,
0.2791997194290161,
-0.3780688941478729,
0.28076308965682983,
-0.37263163924217224,
0.44031238555908203,
-0.2722643315792084,
-0.28206667304039,
-0.5457556843757629,
-0.01693841814994812,
0.2073354721069336,
0.8558138608932495,
-0.47741007804870605,
0.25540992617607117,
-0.009414642117917538,
0.5838292241096497,
-0.6272158026695251,
0.2496052384376526,
-1.143894076347351,
-0.08454195410013199,
-0.3093445897102356,
-0.1589641124010086,
-0.6456310749053955,
-0.37595006823539734,
0.31949669122695923,
-0.7574987411499023,
0.34256741404533386,
0.2619512379169464,
0.7180118560791016,
0.21915318071842194,
-0.5028600692749023,
-0.3354852795600891,
-0.2977144420146942,
0.6439613103866577,
-0.6137990951538086,
0.22485511004924774,
0.2020101249217987,
0.42915546894073486,
-0.4024439752101898,
-0.3367452621459961,
-0.44808924198150635,
-0.35061338543891907,
-0.02207993157207966,
0.20586822926998138,
-0.48384666442871094,
0.03662332519888878,
0.5554664731025696,
0.259736567735672,
-0.5693884491920471,
0.15129488706588745,
-0.21200793981552124,
-0.18827098608016968,
0.5746566653251648,
0.34737545251846313,
-0.12620194256305695,
-0.2784494459629059,
-0.06014293432235718,
-0.14339159429073334,
-0.7675374150276184,
0.11751106381416321,
0.469412237405777,
0.12426485866308212,
0.42909565567970276,
0.5450423955917358,
-0.43951424956321716,
0.8441744446754456,
0.18691225349903107,
0.07531996071338654,
0.31649917364120483,
-0.18872180581092834,
-0.0637061595916748,
0.1442411094903946,
0.44894054532051086,
0.3395133316516876,
0.2465057224035263,
0.030635954812169075,
0.034415073692798615,
0.33721259236335754,
0.12549714744091034,
-0.6308180093765259,
-0.19343878328800201,
0.24864596128463745,
-0.3873501121997833,
-0.7422217130661011,
0.04079529270529747,
-0.5785319805145264,
-0.44138792157173157,
-0.16355076432228088,
-0.01768222451210022,
-0.45452743768692017,
-0.4414328336715698,
0.4318297207355499,
-0.3479629158973694,
0.20822028815746307,
0.39159175753593445,
-0.5856282711029053,
0.3414841294288635,
0.6703489422798157,
0.2465645968914032,
-0.06533937156200409,
-0.27755579352378845,
-0.6786277890205383,
0.15704116225242615,
-0.5644044876098633,
0.9351597428321838,
-0.8862233757972717,
-0.2902330458164215,
-0.35290324687957764,
-0.09488444775342941,
0.13600946962833405,
-0.27821165323257446,
0.47853878140449524,
-0.2762874662876129,
0.6767626404762268,
-0.510165810585022,
-0.41949301958084106,
-0.04298187792301178,
0.4146515727043152,
-0.26898837089538574,
1.4897011518478394,
0.3985300362110138,
-1.1442376375198364,
0.5491955876350403,
-0.7591847777366638,
-0.23957432806491852,
0.46695372462272644,
-0.2946242392063141,
-0.05883806198835373,
0.27340632677078247,
0.4232500493526459,
0.3999691307544708,
-0.43078556656837463,
0.7941021919250488,
-0.39218956232070923,
-0.18116959929466248,
0.08249673247337341,
-0.48562395572662354,
0.8109387755393982,
0.200072780251503,
-0.37307482957839966,
0.3046271502971649,
-0.8249324560165405,
0.19779381155967712,
0.3643949329853058,
-0.08660797774791718,
-0.5494834184646606,
0.11129672825336456,
-0.4695962965488434,
0.34552136063575745,
0.10007742792367935,
-0.8984522223472595,
0.43068450689315796,
-0.24401186406612396,
0.4605770707130432,
0.7724210619926453,
0.003940317779779434,
0.017538519576191902,
-0.14877398312091827,
0.603340208530426,
-0.1895066201686859,
0.25506773591041565,
-0.3731750249862671,
-0.6377441883087158,
-0.5115097165107727,
0.006633071694523096,
0.18156254291534424,
0.573662281036377,
-0.7716822028160095,
0.4725717008113861,
-0.30372053384780884,
-0.8204739689826965,
-0.6985340714454651,
-0.18351812660694122,
0.40846213698387146,
0.7468563914299011,
0.4353196322917938,
-0.22868089377880096,
-0.4431171715259552,
-0.8539388179779053,
-0.022580033168196678,
-0.44566109776496887,
-0.17621994018554688,
0.5686089992523193,
0.34660547971725464,
0.13136501610279083,
1.0788137912750244,
-0.6384119987487793,
0.2601794898509979,
-0.31190937757492065,
0.07219058275222778,
0.06694178283214569,
0.4064095914363861,
0.34394899010658264,
-0.34103161096572876,
-0.4501194953918457,
-0.05001545324921608,
-0.6288917064666748,
-0.03994981199502945,
-0.04682962968945503,
-0.13857971131801605,
0.13052819669246674,
0.5548936128616333,
-0.8492480516433716,
0.13748614490032196,
0.4952925145626068,
-0.6645336747169495,
0.841403603553772,
-0.26560530066490173,
0.08742627501487732,
-1.0232151746749878,
0.12571750581264496,
-0.3095170259475708,
-0.2741583585739136,
-0.25571319460868835,
0.2816489636898041,
0.08413705974817276,
-0.1510593593120575,
-0.4167129695415497,
0.07098633050918579,
-0.5547194480895996,
-0.022265851497650146,
0.25564101338386536,
0.2803950011730194,
0.06266200542449951,
0.3954498767852783,
0.04357371851801872,
0.5251097679138184,
0.8554407358169556,
-0.3036430776119232,
0.284358412027359,
0.33455905318260193,
-0.5758201479911804,
0.7649227380752563,
-0.6889744997024536,
0.27844446897506714,
-0.29110410809516907,
0.31531769037246704,
-1.0666507482528687,
-0.3326985836029053,
0.06796446442604065,
-0.2705364227294922,
0.45738714933395386,
-0.14180591702461243,
-0.49566835165023804,
-0.8573670983314514,
-0.40328729152679443,
0.3085375130176544,
0.5741824507713318,
-0.4979659914970398,
0.333502858877182,
0.29569512605667114,
-0.3387273848056793,
-0.7424789667129517,
-0.2446475774049759,
0.37028977274894714,
-0.17113882303237915,
-0.6897652745246887,
0.45773667097091675,
-0.17812329530715942,
-0.18498685956001282,
-0.04434611648321152,
-0.1429004818201065,
0.48233553767204285,
0.30017608404159546,
0.04300853610038757,
0.3139131963253021,
-0.4487393796443939,
0.09205101430416107,
0.3430849313735962,
-0.1588202267885208,
0.12387891858816147,
-0.26207777857780457,
0.4105552136898041,
-0.44473332166671753,
-0.6091939210891724,
-0.3272393047809601,
0.4974335730075836,
0.5532855987548828,
-0.45257994532585144,
0.2665878236293793,
0.19039386510849,
-0.08243747055530548,
0.1598374843597412,
-0.6658483147621155,
-0.2185887098312378,
-0.517646312713623,
0.5460121035575867,
-0.5145374536514282,
-1.0364242792129517,
0.2039985954761505,
-0.08350459486246109,
0.20474040508270264,
0.5083274245262146,
0.23100923001766205,
-0.22860923409461975,
1.46415114402771,
0.48716408014297485,
-0.13135790824890137,
0.08874524384737015,
0.17616306245326996,
-0.11709796637296677,
-0.6579136252403259,
-0.3676224648952484,
-0.7712827324867249,
-0.0727108046412468,
-0.5178711414337158,
-0.2998078465461731,
0.05275862291455269,
0.015198583714663982,
-0.2792808711528778,
0.5045644044876099,
-0.7826513051986694,
0.6065182685852051,
0.3101675808429718,
-0.03403028845787048,
0.3797328472137451,
-0.09170195460319519,
-0.1293274462223053,
-0.12575383484363556,
-1.003577709197998,
-0.35236167907714844,
0.8859663009643555,
0.4864080250263214,
0.5907731056213379,
-0.06561841070652008,
0.4896651804447174,
0.1830349713563919,
0.4644952118396759,
-0.6230059862136841,
0.605918824672699,
0.14860346913337708,
-0.6283791661262512,
-0.374038428068161,
-0.4058386981487274,
-0.9874939322471619,
0.23249711096286774,
-0.32003313302993774,
-0.6970397233963013,
0.1593412160873413,
0.16718769073486328,
-0.30416417121887207,
0.19153635203838348,
-0.3903779983520508,
0.8153133392333984,
-0.3718624413013458,
-0.03148907423019409,
-0.05417589470744133,
-0.7511659264564514,
0.26098138093948364,
0.14084263145923615,
0.28031638264656067,
-0.24811145663261414,
-0.02976750023663044,
0.714320719242096,
-0.2526959180831909,
0.5832101106643677,
-0.4933299124240875,
-0.34232693910598755,
0.42908039689064026,
0.3710668683052063,
0.8557000756263733,
-0.17350728809833527,
-0.22994807362556458,
-0.06193464249372482,
-0.08162324130535126,
-0.32638657093048096,
-0.42366963624954224,
0.3529936969280243,
-0.24121738970279694,
-0.8238312602043152,
-0.4040091037750244,
-0.6102743744850159,
-0.4586978554725647,
0.2799398601055145,
0.15473710000514984,
0.39548349380493164,
-0.35794931650161743,
0.335135281085968,
0.6431649923324585,
-0.2667420208454132,
0.14693589508533478,
0.6343734264373779,
-0.23930558562278748,
-0.14719635248184204,
0.8856388926506042,
-0.1850443333387375,
0.29758602380752563,
-0.04553966969251633,
0.4271898567676544,
-0.23515164852142334,
-0.7418308258056641,
-0.7458824515342712,
0.018725764006376266,
-0.5692046284675598,
-0.5058012008666992,
-0.7050248980522156,
0.08574441075325012,
-0.17896628379821777,
-0.0020601567812263966,
-0.29993218183517456,
-0.5442225933074951,
0.09509158134460449,
-0.5095641613006592,
0.5384390950202942,
0.9354243278503418,
0.32072940468788147,
0.26098525524139404,
-0.6342422962188721,
-0.10669943690299988,
0.20156918466091156,
0.33986392617225647,
-0.02848050929605961,
-0.5270128846168518,
0.19283005595207214,
-0.11856764554977417,
-0.33385369181632996,
-0.9942354559898376,
-0.06110810115933418,
0.19076402485370636,
0.7015805244445801,
0.4593411684036255,
0.16176824271678925,
0.7790003418922424,
-0.49064359068870544,
0.7619480490684509,
0.09915655106306076,
-1.120130181312561,
0.4991033971309662,
-0.6442228555679321,
0.23346760869026184,
0.7745864391326904,
0.29286062717437744,
-0.5374042987823486,
-0.9903967380523682,
-0.9769028425216675,
-0.8160157799720764,
0.741081178188324,
0.22523461282253265,
0.12123141437768936,
-0.20789384841918945,
0.22732143104076385,
0.39909863471984863,
0.19140954315662384,
-0.40934091806411743,
-0.00984827522188425,
-0.16356037557125092,
-0.3065771758556366,
0.22703756392002106,
-0.3439390957355499,
0.051211271435022354,
-0.17666977643966675,
0.43042078614234924,
-0.28034892678260803,
-0.09053505957126617,
0.053686004132032394,
-0.04630472511053085,
-0.18291990458965302,
0.4834868311882019,
0.4689878821372986,
0.7443121671676636,
-0.20346182584762573,
0.06181181222200394,
0.5381630659103394,
-0.19161657989025116,
-0.09660662710666656,
-0.18223312497138977,
-0.1248580664396286,
-0.0049960920587182045,
0.5246750712394714,
0.7104160785675049,
0.2168821096420288,
-0.6885870099067688,
0.5410075187683105,
-0.10798489302396774,
-0.5652082562446594,
0.10976268351078033,
0.14349795877933502,
0.2638199031352997,
-0.0683014765381813,
0.6010017991065979,
0.26475369930267334,
0.037104930728673935,
-0.39966145157814026,
0.26412543654441833,
0.6146756410598755,
-0.3896770179271698,
-0.12604378163814545,
0.4916892349720001,
0.18989160656929016,
-0.09663461893796921,
0.4668056070804596,
-0.41220366954803467,
-0.7482837438583374,
0.6893424391746521,
0.5500720739364624,
0.37374112010002136,
-0.35050517320632935,
0.38704776763916016,
0.3732273578643799,
0.46396762132644653,
-0.08964274823665619,
0.6278356313705444,
-0.20069152116775513,
-0.4593593180179596,
-0.5276405215263367,
-0.20323924720287323,
-0.5160192847251892,
0.028800318017601967,
-1.062211513519287,
0.2262202799320221,
-0.0893804207444191,
0.039852119982242584,
-0.11241912096738815,
-0.1314784288406372,
-0.7527322173118591,
0.03233471140265465,
0.05051889643073082,
1.27764892578125,
-0.8708363175392151,
0.84065181016922,
0.3994598686695099,
-0.022109339013695717,
-0.8006951808929443,
-0.1915176659822464,
-0.2515535056591034,
-0.6284231543540955,
0.18078432977199554,
0.25846242904663086,
-0.09694014489650726,
0.014362053945660591,
-0.6491678357124329,
-0.9100720286369324,
1.0391099452972412,
0.40943607687950134,
-0.8784189224243164,
-0.03201138973236084,
-0.10138550400733948,
0.6336860060691833,
-0.5915446877479553,
0.4640248417854309,
0.7936197519302368,
0.6052637696266174,
0.027324195951223373,
-0.8361341953277588,
0.36056068539619446,
-0.2409876585006714,
-0.26693710684776306,
0.17222726345062256,
-0.26086995005607605,
0.7132717370986938,
-0.5499581098556519,
-0.2021448016166687,
-0.10378534346818924,
0.5722024440765381,
0.5186086893081665,
0.23872970044612885,
0.8847543001174927,
0.22761674225330353,
1.3063039779663086,
0.06524535268545151,
0.9522290229797363,
-0.14143528044223785,
0.2129821926355362,
1.368093729019165,
-0.4348185956478119,
0.8297134637832642,
0.4003865420818329,
-0.2881903350353241,
0.7651647925376892,
0.8917818069458008,
-0.11300564557313919,
0.2942057251930237,
0.2770533263683319,
0.07126429677009583,
-0.5041026473045349,
-0.07279006391763687,
-0.7381558418273926,
0.5721104741096497,
0.5190465450286865,
-0.013301054947078228,
-0.3350931406021118,
-0.028645332902669907,
0.14824363589286804,
0.07299350947141647,
-0.1357743740081787,
0.8857241272926331,
-0.3338029682636261,
-0.8498887419700623,
0.4837688207626343,
-0.1404515951871872,
0.6536083221435547,
-0.5500363707542419,
-0.050980180501937866,
-0.18837624788284302,
-0.2192928045988083,
-0.2580692768096924,
-0.9694810509681702,
0.20284411311149597,
0.3227497935295105,
0.002499170368537307,
-0.06974721699953079,
0.5780443549156189,
-0.5318699479103088,
-0.666910707950592,
0.2680460810661316,
0.6173498630523682,
0.3405669629573822,
-0.21116097271442413,
-0.6940306425094604,
-0.158396914601326,
0.16046546399593353,
-0.2961871027946472,
0.2428271621465683,
0.5863560438156128,
-0.36613205075263977,
0.6203779578208923,
0.8021758198738098,
-0.01673222705721855,
-0.24198774993419647,
0.0009442081209272146,
1.0916818380355835,
-0.6037177443504333,
-0.33572742342948914,
-0.845857560634613,
0.5035197138786316,
-0.329112708568573,
-0.2758035659790039,
0.7203428745269775,
0.5521283149719238,
0.816296398639679,
0.053935449570417404,
0.9317018985748291,
-0.3265376091003418,
0.5279455184936523,
-0.2885792553424835,
0.7026997804641724,
-0.4739079773426056,
0.14046284556388855,
-0.6815447211265564,
-0.7850521802902222,
-0.049004338681697845,
0.39015722274780273,
-0.17705470323562622,
-0.17693114280700684,
0.7263497710227966,
0.6975616812705994,
-0.0641276091337204,
0.238740012049675,
0.1365976333618164,
0.1065010204911232,
0.41145312786102295,
0.847234845161438,
1.1184521913528442,
-0.12679354846477509,
0.9146210551261902,
-0.20589737594127655,
-0.3917663097381592,
-0.05317056551575661,
-1.3010157346725464,
-0.7317236065864563,
-0.3695290684700012,
-0.23859627544879913,
-0.3462541401386261,
-0.08104986697435379,
0.899104654788971,
0.5957440137863159,
-0.9330258965492249,
0.0920582264661789,
-0.20804964005947113,
0.09632956236600876,
-0.3144913613796234,
-0.13574449717998505,
0.5399424433708191,
-0.2557358145713806,
-0.31658241152763367,
0.7199237942695618,
0.09991022944450378,
-0.10853025317192078,
-0.23278020322322845,
-0.20891261100769043,
0.3043319582939148,
0.03663774952292442,
0.6479941606521606,
-0.057049017399549484,
-0.6851897239685059,
-0.5305196642875671,
0.36476582288742065,
-0.02742360718548298,
0.048373617231845856,
0.9282715320587158,
-0.9040794968605042,
0.45880043506622314,
0.35066232085227966,
0.46187087893486023,
0.3272756040096283,
0.25608086585998535,
0.45087096095085144,
-0.6276635527610779,
0.10257113724946976,
0.34564560651779175,
0.32597842812538147,
0.3615313470363617,
-0.5645990967750549,
0.3824111223220825,
0.16430582106113434,
-0.2762227952480316,
-1.0773066282272339,
0.28382861614227295,
-0.8010079264640808,
-0.36222752928733826,
0.923034131526947,
-0.1443244367837906,
0.040096912533044815,
-0.441484659910202,
-0.643007755279541,
-0.11309847235679626,
-0.5808881521224976,
0.7694131731987,
0.8490264415740967,
-0.13046379387378693,
0.061797045171260834,
-0.30707690119743347,
0.5540289878845215,
0.6451235413551331,
-0.9244614243507385,
0.6005932688713074,
0.5407249927520752,
0.25772976875305176,
-0.008610576391220093,
0.5328099131584167,
-0.08369861543178558,
0.409327894449234,
0.052166808396577835,
0.021799828857183456,
-0.6328969597816467,
-0.5362350344657898,
-0.043145786970853806,
0.34556716680526733,
0.23549392819404602,
0.059137098491191864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17692v1 | Mitigating the Problem of Strong Priors in LMs with Context Extrapolation | 2024-01-31T09:28:06 | 2024-01-31T09:28:06 | Raymond Douglas, Andis Draguns, Tomáš Gavenčiak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have become important tools in a variety of
applications, from data processing to the creation of instruction-following
assistants. But despite their advantages, LMs have certain idiosyncratic
limitations such as the problem of `strong priors', where a model learns to
output typical continuations in response to certain, usually local, portions of
the input regardless of any earlier instructions. For example, prompt injection
attacks can induce models to ignore explicit directives. In some cases, larger
models have been shown to be more susceptible to these problems than similar
smaller models, an example of the phenomenon of `inverse scaling'. We develop a
new technique for mitigating the problem of strong priors: we take the original
set of instructions, produce a weakened version of the original prompt that is
even more susceptible to the strong priors problem, and then extrapolate the
continuation away from the weakened prompt. This lets us infer how the model
would continue a hypothetical strengthened set of instructions. Our technique
conceptualises LMs as mixture models which combine a family of data generation
processes, reinforcing the desired elements of the mixture. Our approach works
at inference time, removing any need for retraining. We apply it to eleven
models including GPT-2, GPT-3, Llama 2, and Mistral on four tasks, and find
improvements in 41/44. Across all 44 combinations the median increase in
proportion of tasks completed is 40%. | [
-0.2828562259674072,
-0.8357675075531006,
0.7619597911834717,
0.07195700705051422,
-0.171118825674057,
-0.3847018778324127,
-0.36788642406463623,
-0.0546894446015358,
-0.05320913717150688,
0.9336997866630554,
-0.4697907865047455,
-0.18262602388858795,
-0.4964524209499359,
-0.1454419195652008,
-0.3428826630115509,
1.0422905683517456,
-0.08067557215690613,
0.09918297082185745,
-0.2024540901184082,
0.043490469455718994,
-0.6555154323577881,
-0.6574214696884155,
-0.6829810738563538,
-0.5466077923774719,
0.22675693035125732,
0.35282620787620544,
0.7304048538208008,
0.4747690260410309,
0.46608880162239075,
0.2381802350282669,
-0.1677503138780594,
0.08080443739891052,
-0.5221942663192749,
0.4860614836215973,
-0.16348110139369965,
-0.601600706577301,
-0.30771324038505554,
-0.28868362307548523,
0.8370977640151978,
0.8860524892807007,
-0.20171912014484406,
-0.1404704600572586,
0.3704703748226166,
0.6761457920074463,
-0.6380681395530701,
-0.10280358046293259,
-0.680519700050354,
-0.058795928955078125,
0.13830585777759552,
-0.2975892722606659,
-0.5537395477294922,
-0.028890127316117287,
0.05724867805838585,
-0.4424925148487091,
0.1160879135131836,
-0.3029199540615082,
0.5034382939338684,
0.2225242555141449,
-0.4160556495189667,
0.07955072820186615,
-1.0631121397018433,
0.9097232222557068,
-0.8486762642860413,
0.18883219361305237,
0.49486929178237915,
0.2815110683441162,
-0.5251168012619019,
-0.7703521251678467,
-0.44612517952919006,
-0.33123543858528137,
-0.005752557422965765,
0.027621980756521225,
-0.10836758464574814,
0.01543017104268074,
0.43469277024269104,
0.2580346167087555,
-0.34048938751220703,
0.22893019020557404,
-0.21738195419311523,
-0.10078126937150955,
0.3002551198005676,
0.30611830949783325,
0.0686165913939476,
0.26010069251060486,
-0.4653697907924652,
-0.17708434164524078,
-1.2108522653579712,
-0.09325918555259705,
0.20358097553253174,
0.4238910377025604,
0.04638633131980896,
0.5470409393310547,
-0.1508849710226059,
0.8495896458625793,
0.15774111449718475,
-0.05430080369114876,
0.09270484745502472,
-0.4321574568748474,
-0.14200830459594727,
-0.3317663073539734,
0.37687447667121887,
0.2897787392139435,
0.25192248821258545,
0.18876846134662628,
-0.40634816884994507,
-0.1868300437927246,
0.09489695727825165,
-0.8876954913139343,
-0.32280635833740234,
0.10936057567596436,
-0.22874559462070465,
-0.034773580729961395,
-0.038965530693531036,
-0.4184199571609497,
-0.5805789232254028,
-0.40828239917755127,
0.5556946992874146,
-0.2633163332939148,
-0.31436046957969666,
-0.16634799540042877,
0.11897450685501099,
0.11186527460813522,
0.31869351863861084,
-0.6997663974761963,
0.48440316319465637,
0.5430594086647034,
0.8896757960319519,
-0.04819784313440323,
-0.18821056187152863,
-0.7172116041183472,
0.28795263171195984,
-0.3393273651599884,
0.696126401424408,
-0.6436784267425537,
-0.6567108631134033,
-0.2622861862182617,
-0.022204909473657608,
0.1367068737745285,
-0.6465507745742798,
0.6040627956390381,
-0.31220564246177673,
0.2685917317867279,
-0.11083820462226868,
-0.7124032378196716,
-0.042591728270053864,
0.09165455400943756,
-0.5788998603820801,
0.9687283635139465,
0.1364990621805191,
-0.5329753160476685,
0.04970606043934822,
-0.2739624083042145,
-0.5282503962516785,
-0.26832905411720276,
-0.10852395743131638,
-0.3416721224784851,
0.40934574604034424,
0.40490537881851196,
0.5240339636802673,
-0.32717418670654297,
0.272400826215744,
-0.35227319598197937,
-0.37230369448661804,
0.062195952981710434,
-0.484009325504303,
0.48740386962890625,
0.11663024127483368,
-0.18331976234912872,
0.2750222980976105,
-0.5324763655662537,
0.12468495219945908,
0.047604870051145554,
-0.04819819703698158,
-0.5982506275177002,
0.007435342762619257,
-0.34242552518844604,
0.29982125759124756,
0.07965350151062012,
-0.03858909383416176,
0.3149243891239166,
-0.5284948348999023,
0.20722946524620056,
0.7913578152656555,
0.2696482837200165,
0.6193484663963318,
-0.3611244559288025,
0.5345335602760315,
0.19869433343410492,
-0.03572855517268181,
-0.5741927027702332,
-0.544571578502655,
-0.6052805781364441,
-0.3229497969150543,
0.03244335949420929,
0.6093597412109375,
-0.7784010767936707,
0.5298945307731628,
-0.25308725237846375,
-0.45719581842422485,
-0.07908979058265686,
0.3111658990383148,
0.2475026249885559,
0.662636935710907,
0.45015040040016174,
-0.25597649812698364,
-0.49206334352493286,
-0.9329718351364136,
-0.24678577482700348,
-0.07092612981796265,
-0.25932765007019043,
0.03151577338576317,
0.352420449256897,
-0.09680101275444031,
1.0356993675231934,
-0.6736066937446594,
-0.16844108700752258,
-0.22743603587150574,
-0.04741160571575165,
0.43424054980278015,
0.7937906980514526,
0.22401805222034454,
-0.8910496234893799,
-0.3983527421951294,
-0.24124401807785034,
-0.4710366427898407,
-0.33610817790031433,
-0.3155249357223511,
0.07976055145263672,
-0.026085853576660156,
0.6439467072486877,
-0.4513920545578003,
0.15679599344730377,
0.3749750256538391,
-0.22412090003490448,
0.622713029384613,
-0.41306912899017334,
-0.23319150507450104,
-1.0667550563812256,
-0.06083473935723305,
0.11291836202144623,
-0.3623373508453369,
-0.8458490371704102,
0.37887775897979736,
0.11902555823326111,
-0.17011409997940063,
-0.4090469479560852,
0.6331777572631836,
-0.5757448077201843,
0.18846407532691956,
-0.47814661264419556,
-0.25185003876686096,
-0.011952490545809269,
0.4835858941078186,
0.28280165791511536,
0.5867769122123718,
0.6881881952285767,
-0.6531568169593811,
0.27303019165992737,
-0.36251315474510193,
0.031830333173274994,
0.545939564704895,
-0.7694692015647888,
0.19674621522426605,
-0.14509129524230957,
0.5148711204528809,
-1.0507817268371582,
0.15859395265579224,
0.17049540579319,
-0.04852829501032829,
0.46959537267684937,
-0.36673468351364136,
-0.40008512139320374,
-0.26785513758659363,
-0.4449065625667572,
0.16046875715255737,
0.5543509721755981,
-0.35584330558776855,
0.7092297077178955,
0.09480776637792587,
-0.3040637969970703,
-0.4116871654987335,
-0.48367613554000854,
0.020715931430459023,
-0.49103131890296936,
-0.3600354790687561,
0.2972499132156372,
-0.1635432243347168,
-0.3597235679626465,
-0.06941752880811691,
-0.11896581202745438,
-0.25466713309288025,
0.21070367097854614,
0.08883046358823776,
0.2231055647134781,
-0.31207504868507385,
-0.04213455691933632,
0.4005196988582611,
-0.12391737103462219,
-0.055447209626436234,
-0.4086754322052002,
0.5169780850410461,
0.05994458869099617,
-0.39774811267852783,
-0.31792595982551575,
0.5314726829528809,
0.530045211315155,
0.022314446046948433,
0.8097574710845947,
0.4837188720703125,
-0.5692064166069031,
-0.11414481699466705,
-0.4606226086616516,
-0.5527395606040955,
-0.4959796965122223,
0.4448581039905548,
-0.5271772742271423,
-0.4006728529930115,
0.6137805581092834,
-0.13589715957641602,
0.040221020579338074,
0.39921656250953674,
0.5795847177505493,
0.14932416379451752,
1.1149226427078247,
0.5550164580345154,
-0.07519081979990005,
0.6922521591186523,
-0.10787245631217957,
-0.07921811938285828,
-0.8787640929222107,
0.27475520968437195,
-0.22181573510169983,
-0.08173621445894241,
-0.2808503210544586,
-0.38302090764045715,
0.4823581278324127,
0.46740487217903137,
-0.023026879876852036,
0.3801667094230652,
-0.1918639987707138,
0.6221904158592224,
0.5649420619010925,
0.276344358921051,
0.28683850169181824,
0.10606195032596588,
-0.10900747030973434,
-0.07528532296419144,
-0.6680263876914978,
-0.4253137409687042,
1.3330721855163574,
0.35251155495643616,
0.8429729342460632,
0.26698195934295654,
0.7405386567115784,
0.20757745206356049,
0.5060523152351379,
-0.5729374289512634,
0.4950443208217621,
0.04338564723730087,
-0.37800830602645874,
-0.2670266926288605,
-0.6665651202201843,
-0.818080484867096,
0.4732688367366791,
-0.16684949398040771,
-0.7407712340354919,
0.0013739746063947678,
0.31560689210891724,
-0.49900582432746887,
0.2203332483768463,
-1.0018569231033325,
0.602053701877594,
0.10438257455825806,
-0.7067403793334961,
-0.1498461812734604,
-0.6777552366256714,
0.30224838852882385,
-0.23120054602622986,
0.16272622346878052,
0.23464316129684448,
-0.1391587257385254,
0.42644408345222473,
-0.6415079236030579,
1.083031177520752,
-0.3607947528362274,
-0.5203813314437866,
0.34385690093040466,
0.17995969951152802,
0.9838405847549438,
-0.036243192851543427,
0.15452663600444794,
-0.31442791223526,
-0.03823784366250038,
-0.4466024935245514,
-0.8999837636947632,
0.8293377161026001,
-0.3751378357410431,
-0.8702506422996521,
0.024663308635354042,
-0.5846182107925415,
-0.26935073733329773,
0.21904928982257843,
0.32355615496635437,
0.5675224661827087,
-0.06666089594364166,
0.02521633170545101,
0.6412156224250793,
-0.012430188246071339,
0.21072503924369812,
0.4712274372577667,
-0.27862560749053955,
-0.1802869439125061,
0.873365581035614,
0.22220265865325928,
0.5807338356971741,
0.3246402144432068,
0.4721194803714752,
-0.3446120619773865,
-0.6767674684524536,
-0.3866811692714691,
0.07994208484888077,
-0.7898990511894226,
-0.1630949079990387,
-0.4437488615512848,
0.004845278803259134,
-0.4596666693687439,
0.020548207685351372,
-0.2643214464187622,
-0.6580568552017212,
-0.2722906172275543,
0.12133047729730606,
0.014222906902432442,
0.6129220128059387,
0.009745101444423199,
0.49706587195396423,
-0.6330104470252991,
0.13381655514240265,
0.24269558489322662,
0.1043640598654747,
0.007310556247830391,
-0.785709023475647,
-0.1583518087863922,
0.10655263066291809,
-0.3691929578781128,
-1.0121397972106934,
0.3871714770793915,
0.24652515351772308,
0.5470974445343018,
0.4289691746234894,
0.016462910920381546,
0.6218532919883728,
-0.601128339767456,
0.7584430575370789,
0.1087431088089943,
-0.720401406288147,
0.5113745331764221,
-0.39694297313690186,
0.45376670360565186,
0.24054177105426788,
0.30713698267936707,
-0.3684713542461395,
-0.6332455277442932,
-0.6111938953399658,
-1.1292556524276733,
0.14872635900974274,
0.27573832869529724,
0.24017879366874695,
0.1173664778470993,
0.4729059040546417,
0.08756133168935776,
0.018257364630699158,
-0.6035162806510925,
-0.3235571086406708,
-0.019572896882891655,
-0.2035507708787918,
-0.22140689194202423,
-0.3207854628562927,
-0.07167799025774002,
-0.21502523124217987,
0.7018991112709045,
-0.05627705901861191,
0.08160484582185745,
0.21545866131782532,
-0.2962853014469147,
0.060577791184186935,
0.25673311948776245,
0.819922149181366,
0.6512078642845154,
-0.05827975645661354,
0.3684004545211792,
0.27907049655914307,
-0.45642200112342834,
0.12790100276470184,
0.2049117237329483,
-0.1874845176935196,
-0.16062621772289276,
0.42075851559638977,
0.5682944059371948,
0.04171783849596977,
-0.5708063840866089,
0.3641119599342346,
0.11902828514575958,
0.390670508146286,
-0.30413123965263367,
0.10589196532964706,
-0.09759259223937988,
0.1220223605632782,
0.7101341485977173,
0.15103895962238312,
0.135397806763649,
-0.4654322862625122,
0.35409849882125854,
0.31049206852912903,
-0.343534916639328,
-0.3589650094509125,
0.3608970046043396,
0.18006308376789093,
-0.05244048684835434,
0.1624058336019516,
-0.030631879344582558,
-0.5646421909332275,
0.662899374961853,
0.9724352955818176,
0.6179324984550476,
-0.4318155348300934,
-0.31780529022216797,
0.3507392108440399,
0.37035253643989563,
-0.4499834179878235,
0.12535174190998077,
-0.055088333785533905,
-0.7645439505577087,
-0.5130895972251892,
-0.05867595970630646,
-0.3835708796977997,
0.22602006793022156,
-0.6204781532287598,
0.2821520268917084,
-0.45331597328186035,
-0.25445106625556946,
-0.3714343309402466,
-0.12024145573377609,
-0.4416401982307434,
0.12118718773126602,
0.10021799057722092,
0.681014895439148,
-0.9878559112548828,
0.8937002420425415,
0.5681270360946655,
-0.2114732414484024,
-0.6065248847007751,
0.0898885577917099,
-0.02223086729645729,
-0.5116930603981018,
0.4211302101612091,
0.07214563339948654,
-0.09967850148677826,
0.11183695495128632,
-0.3427359461784363,
-0.8147670030593872,
0.652060866355896,
0.5015414357185364,
-0.6916001439094543,
-0.0655495896935463,
-0.2944396734237671,
0.4447620213031769,
-0.2781413793563843,
0.2955477833747864,
0.509031355381012,
0.31887108087539673,
-0.2354571372270584,
-0.8391536474227905,
0.30402687191963196,
-0.2021452933549881,
-0.0612223856151104,
0.3069818913936615,
-0.14674082398414612,
0.7891382575035095,
-0.3528200089931488,
-0.162639781832695,
0.330239862203598,
0.6679540872573853,
0.2585444748401642,
-0.06468291580677032,
0.5863215923309326,
0.4699232280254364,
0.8024992942810059,
0.13226652145385742,
1.2084498405456543,
-0.14078041911125183,
0.3339194357395172,
1.6013950109481812,
-0.40442922711372375,
0.8115959763526917,
0.6706582307815552,
-0.15682876110076904,
0.4408468008041382,
0.40696457028388977,
0.2147279530763626,
0.5491723418235779,
0.26421868801116943,
-0.2929786145687103,
-0.17915979027748108,
-0.0029635385144501925,
-0.7081413865089417,
0.06900043040513992,
0.5707184076309204,
-0.4917111396789551,
-0.20286202430725098,
0.07602197676897049,
0.11938989907503128,
0.20124337077140808,
-0.40927234292030334,
0.6104928851127625,
0.10607661306858063,
-0.6638603806495667,
0.6829586625099182,
-0.001719023217447102,
0.6122385859489441,
-0.7301071286201477,
-0.12298878282308578,
-0.32911282777786255,
0.301351398229599,
-0.007249388378113508,
-0.6925685405731201,
0.26418423652648926,
-0.1987740844488144,
-0.20351757109165192,
-0.06898579746484756,
0.7680296897888184,
-0.6392748355865479,
-0.5641650557518005,
0.03144698217511177,
0.5353673696517944,
0.010456427000463009,
-0.32857227325439453,
-0.39047515392303467,
-0.21163979172706604,
-0.1516590714454651,
-0.48539820313453674,
0.2597731649875641,
0.3472123146057129,
-0.3014303147792816,
0.7268136143684387,
0.5800665616989136,
0.3631769120693207,
-0.055682580918073654,
0.08631394058465958,
1.0196765661239624,
-0.4839920699596405,
-0.603650689125061,
-1.174499750137329,
0.21899500489234924,
-0.08267870545387268,
-0.1875365972518921,
0.8705165982246399,
0.4564282298088074,
0.5958822965621948,
0.11179960519075394,
0.5795325636863708,
0.39112091064453125,
0.30109909176826477,
-0.7642577886581421,
0.32373636960983276,
-0.3511804938316345,
0.5732851624488831,
-0.40304335951805115,
-1.0444477796554565,
-0.47326844930648804,
0.4031513035297394,
-0.4339624345302582,
0.08692040294408798,
0.5578370690345764,
0.8270478248596191,
-0.13958494365215302,
-0.1882634162902832,
0.3072713613510132,
0.2658866047859192,
0.30169764161109924,
0.5685046315193176,
0.9607540965080261,
-0.08869269490242004,
0.30211761593818665,
-0.25705966353416443,
-0.36039790511131287,
-0.006387511268258095,
-0.9205541610717773,
-0.7502508759498596,
-0.47960802912712097,
-0.14420409500598907,
-0.40115416049957275,
-0.03678005561232567,
0.9654908180236816,
0.7773658633232117,
-0.7640013098716736,
-0.07305128127336502,
-0.1437874287366867,
0.24219782650470734,
-0.49049344658851624,
-0.22625534236431122,
0.2827034294605255,
-0.17056049406528473,
-0.5776218771934509,
0.5389365553855896,
-0.12393690645694733,
0.395095556974411,
-0.38030314445495605,
-0.038706324994564056,
0.06346424669027328,
0.11759129911661148,
0.5829648375511169,
0.22032734751701355,
-0.5541382431983948,
-0.2313014715909958,
-0.2860177755355835,
0.06681922823190689,
-0.0425213947892189,
1.1488494873046875,
-0.9386280179023743,
0.3637677729129791,
0.41860395669937134,
0.4521782696247101,
0.4746849834918976,
-0.03713199868798256,
0.9928862452507019,
-1.0269067287445068,
0.3639950454235077,
0.26498496532440186,
0.6018635630607605,
0.4643526077270508,
-0.42158374190330505,
0.40577784180641174,
0.23392540216445923,
-0.20672327280044556,
-0.9991987347602844,
0.6337804198265076,
-0.596023440361023,
-0.6012426614761353,
1.2216557264328003,
-0.22926096618175507,
0.00859734695404768,
-0.02966487593948841,
-0.3172454833984375,
0.050159890204668045,
-0.4265790581703186,
0.3538970649242401,
0.5844721794128418,
0.08449194580316544,
0.002494558459147811,
-0.37129464745521545,
0.23056696355342865,
0.7871463298797607,
-0.5282742977142334,
0.24407239258289337,
0.5220465064048767,
0.2660142481327057,
0.03011041320860386,
0.5770506858825684,
0.028114138171076775,
0.025332335382699966,
-0.1735759824514389,
-0.31114089488983154,
-0.06290752440690994,
-0.48279789090156555,
-0.7787379026412964,
0.12643127143383026,
0.12274500727653503,
0.09933856129646301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17686v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17686v2 | Deductive Beam Search: Decoding Deducible Rationale for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-01-31T09:16:35 | 2024-02-04T13:18:34 | Tinghui Zhu, Kai Zhang, Jian Xie, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements have significantly augmented the reasoning capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs) through various methodologies, especially
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. However, previous methods fail to address
reasoning errors in intermediate steps, leading to accumulative errors. In this
paper, we propose Deductive Beam Search (DBS), which seamlessly integrates CoT
and deductive reasoning with step-wise beam search for LLMs. Our approach
deploys a verifier, verifying the deducibility of a reasoning step and its
premises, thus alleviating the error accumulation. Furthermore, we introduce a
scalable and labor-free data construction method to amplify our model's
verification capabilities. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach
significantly enhances the base performance of LLMs of various scales (7B, 13B,
70B, and ChatGPT) across 8 reasoning datasets from 3 diverse reasoning genres,
including arithmetic, commonsense, and symbolic. Moreover, our analysis proves
DBS's capability of detecting diverse and subtle reasoning errors and
robustness on different model scales. | [
-0.2120334953069687,
-1.1585465669631958,
1.073175072669983,
0.16538682579994202,
-0.2310020476579666,
0.2662445306777954,
0.09143251180648804,
-0.18202923238277435,
-0.000795152795035392,
0.5063888430595398,
-0.43317028880119324,
-0.5112564563751221,
-0.6013138890266418,
0.09493953734636307,
-0.5949512720108032,
0.1463378369808197,
-0.2510419487953186,
-0.04774581640958786,
0.01267513819038868,
0.12006733566522598,
-0.5843502283096313,
-0.3672082722187042,
-0.4941220283508301,
-0.3319408595561981,
0.29892951250076294,
0.1213151067495346,
0.6698351502418518,
0.6646023988723755,
0.5261527299880981,
0.21919269859790802,
-0.45014968514442444,
0.8086817860603333,
-0.31190580129623413,
0.27663275599479675,
-0.6488770842552185,
-0.2583572566509247,
-0.5534584522247314,
-0.2837720513343811,
0.45531782507896423,
0.6787881255149841,
-0.18790467083454132,
-0.10340185463428497,
-0.24444951117038727,
0.7753814458847046,
-0.8175712823867798,
0.29064467549324036,
-0.9972973465919495,
-0.1380237340927124,
-0.05860104411840439,
-0.23318755626678467,
-0.7781904339790344,
-0.4123884439468384,
-0.2829497754573822,
-0.2011757344007492,
-0.08358702808618546,
0.06494797766208649,
0.5777455568313599,
0.46752938628196716,
-0.6102722883224487,
-0.44867056608200073,
-0.8741117715835571,
0.720650315284729,
-0.729898989200592,
0.6299557089805603,
0.5435165762901306,
0.27047625184059143,
-0.49435847997665405,
-0.5778716206550598,
-0.5487156510353088,
-0.161473348736763,
-0.19626159965991974,
-0.191944882273674,
-0.20091256499290466,
0.25202977657318115,
0.3931041359901428,
0.40911054611206055,
-0.639773428440094,
-0.1358555257320404,
-0.040162649005651474,
0.10137277841567993,
0.5764135122299194,
0.29251861572265625,
-0.009714377112686634,
-0.11095604300498962,
-0.22344784438610077,
0.01149848010390997,
-0.8310962319374084,
-0.04888947680592537,
-0.18047362565994263,
0.17258065938949585,
0.17009377479553223,
0.5278708338737488,
-0.5888491868972778,
0.9253954887390137,
0.2092025727033615,
0.08142654597759247,
-0.027470240369439125,
-0.5359548926353455,
-0.30583521723747253,
0.19835439324378967,
0.4749864339828491,
0.0531185083091259,
-0.07751057296991348,
-0.023839090019464493,
-0.23987844586372375,
0.14949160814285278,
0.11900914460420609,
-0.7417222261428833,
-0.15170706808567047,
0.4569833278656006,
-0.37990468740463257,
-0.2508820593357086,
-0.34948059916496277,
-0.32141372561454773,
-0.5535306334495544,
-0.2882136106491089,
0.10110526531934738,
-0.5835582613945007,
-0.23177969455718994,
0.5825007557868958,
0.01988465152680874,
0.13772380352020264,
0.3092619478702545,
-0.7104610204696655,
-0.08108983188867569,
0.7479653358459473,
0.6290343999862671,
0.4901876747608185,
-0.13085195422172546,
-0.6582545638084412,
0.21296432614326477,
-0.7595488429069519,
0.7761052250862122,
-0.6477405428886414,
-0.1394636631011963,
-0.05971239134669304,
-0.268113911151886,
-0.16265389323234558,
-0.3233368694782257,
0.5911591649055481,
-0.8240996599197388,
-0.37894120812416077,
-0.44558650255203247,
-0.7399511933326721,
-0.1483154147863388,
0.6173803210258484,
-0.6169727444648743,
0.886115312576294,
-0.013685205951333046,
-0.7753247618675232,
0.36640283465385437,
-0.3316628336906433,
-0.5019601583480835,
0.13818393647670746,
-0.4350356161594391,
-0.05324634909629822,
0.3163742125034332,
0.3885309398174286,
0.4347432553768158,
-0.538755476474762,
0.5573910474777222,
-0.707327127456665,
-0.5154623985290527,
0.30368638038635254,
-0.4276285171508789,
0.997969388961792,
0.21078717708587646,
-0.4509459435939789,
-0.3387945890426636,
-0.9534674882888794,
0.06522125750780106,
0.1904834508895874,
-0.35480624437332153,
-0.48027467727661133,
0.47948122024536133,
-0.7076736092567444,
0.1307384967803955,
0.1195329874753952,
-0.4609265625476837,
0.2891756594181061,
-0.4622787833213806,
0.5034224987030029,
0.5122085213661194,
-0.09401250630617142,
0.14499899744987488,
-0.018815243616700172,
0.33456435799598694,
0.1859341412782669,
-0.0035192917566746473,
-0.16333085298538208,
-0.09388717263936996,
-0.4716452360153198,
-0.4082975387573242,
-0.029304267838597298,
0.5170007944107056,
-0.9054408073425293,
0.6396600008010864,
-0.1481110155582428,
-0.5874384641647339,
-0.2638643682003021,
0.10256606340408325,
0.373189240694046,
0.5676089525222778,
0.43283215165138245,
0.2103443592786789,
-0.7437549829483032,
-0.5033057928085327,
-0.13471508026123047,
-0.2695850729942322,
0.10611855983734131,
0.10012546926736832,
0.5073545575141907,
-0.4624498784542084,
0.9309433102607727,
-0.44266360998153687,
0.004368498455733061,
-0.3642878830432892,
-0.04108240082859993,
0.5525115132331848,
0.3218061327934265,
0.11877094209194183,
-0.6114307641983032,
-0.06277266144752502,
0.031149163842201233,
-0.9774394631385803,
0.05989581346511841,
-0.23260854184627533,
-0.2140444666147232,
0.1287311464548111,
0.5106230974197388,
-0.7104208469390869,
0.554160475730896,
0.3133549988269806,
-0.5018828511238098,
0.4363270401954651,
-0.3347312808036804,
0.10519686341285706,
-0.6224066019058228,
-0.020436041057109833,
-0.2533152103424072,
-0.13905802369117737,
-0.22531011700630188,
0.08255355805158615,
0.12718789279460907,
0.3590526878833771,
-0.037859294563531876,
0.28545352816581726,
-0.3308407962322235,
0.10391300171613693,
-0.32454997301101685,
0.5172203183174133,
0.32581961154937744,
0.21270473301410675,
0.12395550310611725,
0.3338015377521515,
0.6654598116874695,
-0.6452757716178894,
0.6942017078399658,
0.3794000744819641,
-0.4101291298866272,
0.5848650932312012,
-0.6759852766990662,
0.10240068286657333,
-0.29207396507263184,
0.6632169485092163,
-1.073091983795166,
-0.006912116426974535,
0.010648897849023342,
-0.13445600867271423,
-0.04078647866845131,
-0.15032733976840973,
-0.6338648200035095,
-0.5348929762840271,
-0.2806442081928253,
0.538973331451416,
0.1917494237422943,
-0.8369981646537781,
0.6465968489646912,
0.23723094165325165,
0.20845893025398254,
-0.7537809610366821,
-0.5889597535133362,
-0.09862972050905228,
-0.03358862176537514,
-0.7533541917800903,
0.23695039749145508,
0.11297295987606049,
-0.40908563137054443,
-0.13786113262176514,
-0.3388885259628296,
-0.07778627425432205,
0.23548507690429688,
-0.16531628370285034,
0.44503486156463623,
-0.09795352071523666,
0.18256783485412598,
0.28693485260009766,
-0.048708852380514145,
0.2872970998287201,
-0.40333977341651917,
0.49697989225387573,
-0.3802781105041504,
-0.6491255164146423,
0.11011998355388641,
0.14203229546546936,
0.7197033166885376,
-0.30877524614334106,
0.6457411646842957,
0.23645706474781036,
-0.46343544125556946,
-0.5646652579307556,
-0.6940640807151794,
-0.14361408352851868,
-0.4384777843952179,
0.27825260162353516,
-0.6079061031341553,
-0.7140649557113647,
0.520166277885437,
-0.15435144305229187,
-0.14665551483631134,
0.09525421261787415,
0.5755253434181213,
0.1364208161830902,
1.2252634763717651,
0.03688594698905945,
0.2963090240955353,
-0.05020751431584358,
-0.28157520294189453,
0.7472875714302063,
-0.7348425388336182,
-0.22699542343616486,
-0.4678241014480591,
-0.20132628083229065,
-0.48599421977996826,
-0.6001412868499756,
0.21364888548851013,
0.29560190439224243,
-0.3826042711734772,
0.3636416792869568,
-0.5150248408317566,
0.719423770904541,
0.2976042330265045,
0.22764131426811218,
0.6228822469711304,
-0.3589909076690674,
-0.11762433499097824,
0.26785925030708313,
-0.4890986680984497,
-0.38456133008003235,
0.7913652658462524,
0.21490441262722015,
0.968895435333252,
0.025370903313159943,
0.6808185577392578,
0.11544833332300186,
-0.17927834391593933,
-0.6127259731292725,
0.6526094675064087,
-0.19775454699993134,
-0.9919431209564209,
-0.3267722725868225,
-0.6678352952003479,
-0.5594772100448608,
0.3506791591644287,
0.24268068373203278,
-0.7411527633666992,
0.33811289072036743,
0.35021018981933594,
-0.18660131096839905,
0.44814494252204895,
-0.10927443206310272,
0.7766770124435425,
-0.36887556314468384,
-0.3926254212856293,
-0.6633308529853821,
-0.42684125900268555,
0.6224536895751953,
0.004695654381066561,
0.4534476399421692,
-0.19664625823497772,
0.35623839497566223,
0.35198938846588135,
-0.4686540365219116,
0.4972001612186432,
-0.21774178743362427,
-0.281090646982193,
0.46810945868492126,
0.5967499017715454,
0.8949543237686157,
0.22629283368587494,
-0.02671622298657894,
-0.01726142130792141,
0.027407780289649963,
-0.3025945723056793,
-0.5899618864059448,
0.6360302567481995,
-0.1247846782207489,
-0.7152063250541687,
-0.18258978426456451,
-0.550963819026947,
-0.2780478298664093,
0.20525631308555603,
-0.039564765989780426,
0.4798445403575897,
0.003130100667476654,
0.3869943618774414,
0.8657456040382385,
0.06744265556335449,
0.17853234708309174,
0.41319170594215393,
-0.4353986084461212,
-0.21347016096115112,
0.5395459532737732,
-0.09472489356994629,
0.08992952853441238,
0.5982968211174011,
0.12627708911895752,
-0.47625285387039185,
-0.6077629327774048,
-0.43741151690483093,
0.21618139743804932,
-0.8977354168891907,
-0.31818851828575134,
-0.4724019765853882,
-0.1438654065132141,
-0.15276983380317688,
-0.27804672718048096,
-0.5801492929458618,
-0.48647648096084595,
0.29562583565711975,
-0.3787475824356079,
0.31102117896080017,
0.44310131669044495,
-0.16235144436359406,
-0.2154616117477417,
-0.7573662400245667,
0.2943914830684662,
0.2175445258617401,
0.3962133228778839,
0.08732102066278458,
-0.4103478491306305,
-0.37280628085136414,
0.21965983510017395,
-0.2831181287765503,
-0.6414646506309509,
0.18915770947933197,
-0.3359772562980652,
0.5117961168289185,
0.27691152691841125,
0.267127126455307,
0.6207605004310608,
-0.27047473192214966,
0.4408774673938751,
0.061726294457912445,
-1.2186094522476196,
0.8145857453346252,
-0.24315164983272552,
0.08672359585762024,
0.43265628814697266,
0.24516069889068604,
-0.13763488829135895,
-0.4947819113731384,
-0.4436441659927368,
-0.8991871476173401,
0.5990478992462158,
0.13268131017684937,
-0.28360503911972046,
-0.39358624815940857,
0.06526656448841095,
-0.23677363991737366,
-0.09997464716434479,
-0.5196802616119385,
-0.04023505374789238,
-0.05356389656662941,
-0.11509431898593903,
0.5146337151527405,
-0.31076711416244507,
-0.10969704389572144,
-0.23052434623241425,
0.8002303242683411,
-0.19062013924121857,
-0.18207360804080963,
0.3709550201892853,
-0.08730485290288925,
-0.05416024103760719,
0.3274800777435303,
0.20355334877967834,
0.8143192529678345,
-0.4766418933868408,
0.46608710289001465,
0.22803276777267456,
-0.06602112948894501,
0.2899937033653259,
0.09858379513025284,
-0.08476700633764267,
0.18159179389476776,
0.3293518126010895,
0.6136022210121155,
0.135258287191391,
-0.9697235226631165,
0.3551257252693176,
-0.013646026141941547,
-0.14082898199558258,
-0.2167486697435379,
-0.11279895156621933,
0.23949290812015533,
0.48392656445503235,
0.17627163231372833,
-0.12134689092636108,
0.22486504912376404,
-0.32977017760276794,
0.07595644891262054,
0.5628136992454529,
-0.014844422228634357,
-0.06988438218832016,
0.7178792953491211,
0.20647360384464264,
0.15224158763885498,
0.6983841061592102,
-0.46324509382247925,
-0.3415130376815796,
0.44774508476257324,
0.4894930124282837,
0.9843149781227112,
0.003147409064695239,
0.1888149529695511,
0.4488005042076111,
0.32424116134643555,
-0.3595898449420929,
0.21865808963775635,
-0.2371661216020584,
-0.8820949196815491,
-0.7702789902687073,
-0.47087088227272034,
-0.49625301361083984,
-0.07618555426597595,
-0.34051913022994995,
0.3575088381767273,
-0.5396178364753723,
0.06473281234502792,
-0.08443976938724518,
-0.20853206515312195,
-0.43925756216049194,
0.18790695071220398,
0.5950325727462769,
0.9471036791801453,
-0.5160917639732361,
0.8644436597824097,
0.4399898648262024,
-0.4363901615142822,
-0.8934553861618042,
-0.33517202734947205,
-0.022671859711408615,
-0.7563672661781311,
0.971847653388977,
0.15636008977890015,
-0.5784971117973328,
-0.30364900827407837,
-0.23290817439556122,
-1.0511177778244019,
1.2692903280258179,
0.40340328216552734,
-0.7784382700920105,
-0.33848804235458374,
0.055601201951503754,
0.28530898690223694,
-0.36605730652809143,
0.4264470040798187,
0.8840476870536804,
0.40409576892852783,
0.4760728180408478,
-0.8228042125701904,
0.43247511982917786,
0.16169895231723785,
0.1311064064502716,
0.20990817248821259,
-0.23261386156082153,
0.8322771787643433,
-0.23311366140842438,
-0.09955378621816635,
-0.26433199644088745,
0.36324238777160645,
0.7791481614112854,
0.5242774486541748,
0.40042200684547424,
0.6540206074714661,
1.0012449026107788,
0.01971624419093132,
0.8814708590507507,
-0.38179609179496765,
0.5053858160972595,
1.0171889066696167,
-0.6757789850234985,
0.666286051273346,
0.342780739068985,
-0.33195236325263977,
0.7448716163635254,
0.21926867961883545,
0.20014774799346924,
0.47973570227622986,
0.34732645750045776,
-0.13643792271614075,
-0.615565299987793,
0.11775238811969757,
-0.23728670179843903,
0.4819343388080597,
0.5362947583198547,
-0.38582301139831543,
-0.4218343198299408,
-0.22411949932575226,
0.14686518907546997,
0.1948378086090088,
-0.22589582204818726,
0.35106217861175537,
0.02218942902982235,
-0.659803032875061,
1.1046903133392334,
-0.10351069271564484,
0.26701951026916504,
-0.450986385345459,
-0.049963656812906265,
-0.32207173109054565,
0.8093289732933044,
-0.24313639104366302,
-0.6164458394050598,
0.5765828490257263,
-0.02738099917769432,
-0.10892648994922638,
-0.26554983854293823,
0.7431789636611938,
-0.1958424299955368,
-0.4540967643260956,
0.5267542600631714,
0.5748804211616516,
-0.19520394504070282,
-0.1843651831150055,
-0.48197564482688904,
0.3511180579662323,
0.12907026708126068,
-0.43833887577056885,
-0.06641802191734314,
0.7514805197715759,
0.040213365107774734,
0.8155670762062073,
0.3852822184562683,
0.012574195861816406,
-0.1880023330450058,
0.0010666287271305919,
0.946201503276825,
-0.8136282563209534,
-0.257615327835083,
-1.1799460649490356,
0.4654737710952759,
-0.13861483335494995,
0.11854322999715805,
0.5748260021209717,
0.4765852093696594,
0.8349635004997253,
0.008179604075849056,
0.6363018751144409,
-0.22453679144382477,
0.5813860297203064,
-0.7326314449310303,
0.26126015186309814,
-0.29070425033569336,
0.7262919545173645,
-0.19070054590702057,
-0.6961262822151184,
-0.33141660690307617,
0.8411105275154114,
-0.44773972034454346,
-0.22668828070163727,
0.9937068223953247,
0.8735908269882202,
0.0036866762675344944,
0.23667626082897186,
0.25907453894615173,
0.378927618265152,
0.6302089095115662,
0.8287856578826904,
1.001541018486023,
-0.32171547412872314,
0.6776634454727173,
-0.09077027440071106,
-0.32920846343040466,
-0.22260349988937378,
-0.953855037689209,
-0.8855777382850647,
-0.3085566759109497,
-0.4687710702419281,
-0.5559180974960327,
-0.1192709356546402,
0.8042513728141785,
0.44189247488975525,
-0.5674852132797241,
-0.1830214112997055,
-0.6767354607582092,
0.489215612411499,
-0.45583710074424744,
-0.1915276050567627,
0.29265469312667847,
-0.5191032290458679,
-0.4311017394065857,
0.7793556451797485,
0.3652545213699341,
-0.44931089878082275,
-0.21247334778308868,
-0.1175997257232666,
-0.35691022872924805,
0.512252151966095,
0.724807620048523,
-0.03713328018784523,
-0.7947461009025574,
-0.1653914749622345,
0.05989398807287216,
-0.12363994866609573,
-0.22592851519584656,
0.783486545085907,
-1.0521429777145386,
0.40106815099716187,
0.6502364873886108,
0.6254346966743469,
0.5816368460655212,
-0.20326818525791168,
0.3569665849208832,
-0.434561163187027,
-0.013927473686635494,
0.291098415851593,
0.7526746988296509,
0.11844445019960403,
-0.28143996000289917,
0.7595851421356201,
0.2903827428817749,
-0.6096889972686768,
-1.0144941806793213,
0.5357820391654968,
-1.030746579170227,
-0.41732728481292725,
0.9380890727043152,
-0.2844035029411316,
-0.05713750049471855,
-0.03359974920749664,
-0.2314429134130478,
-0.017184918746352196,
-0.05061019957065582,
0.92275071144104,
0.7774491310119629,
-0.22926141321659088,
0.14081008732318878,
0.05437256395816803,
0.24737626314163208,
0.37538260221481323,
-0.6322926878929138,
0.6952001452445984,
0.7423144578933716,
-0.12542185187339783,
0.28297245502471924,
0.6202521324157715,
-0.183705672621727,
0.32062774896621704,
0.29307886958122253,
-0.4672856330871582,
-0.2435527741909027,
-0.1731625646352768,
0.037782713770866394,
0.09443660825490952,
0.16604748368263245,
-0.0840904712677002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17671v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17671v1 | Contextual Feature Extraction Hierarchies Converge in Large Language Models and the Brain | 2024-01-31T08:48:35 | 2024-01-31T08:48:35 | Gavin Mischler, Yinghao Aaron Li, Stephan Bickel, Ashesh D. Mehta, Nima Mesgarani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC | Recent advancements in artificial intelligence have sparked interest in the
parallels between large language models (LLMs) and human neural processing,
particularly in language comprehension. While prior research has established
similarities in the representation of LLMs and the brain, the underlying
computational principles that cause this convergence, especially in the context
of evolving LLMs, remain elusive. Here, we examined a diverse selection of
high-performance LLMs with similar parameter sizes to investigate the factors
contributing to their alignment with the brain's language processing
mechanisms. We find that as LLMs achieve higher performance on benchmark tasks,
they not only become more brain-like as measured by higher performance when
predicting neural responses from LLM embeddings, but also their hierarchical
feature extraction pathways map more closely onto the brain's while using fewer
layers to do the same encoding. We also compare the feature extraction pathways
of the LLMs to each other and identify new ways in which high-performing models
have converged toward similar hierarchical processing mechanisms. Finally, we
show the importance of contextual information in improving model performance
and brain similarity. Our findings reveal the converging aspects of language
processing in the brain and LLMs and offer new directions for developing models
that align more closely with human cognitive processing. | [
-0.567986011505127,
-0.7769385576248169,
0.835693359375,
0.10197806358337402,
0.014982049353420734,
0.03665672615170479,
-0.6301981806755066,
-0.6343572735786438,
0.06568948179483414,
0.5294921398162842,
-0.48355451226234436,
-0.33111828565597534,
-0.6915099620819092,
0.0015270852018147707,
-0.3043922781944275,
0.7459532618522644,
0.18142534792423248,
-0.09398990124464035,
-0.6611416935920715,
-0.29260551929473877,
-0.6089577078819275,
-0.5866676568984985,
-0.35705995559692383,
-0.7763437032699585,
0.6063485741615295,
0.10217946022748947,
0.6570274829864502,
0.9956427216529846,
0.37839066982269287,
0.259257048368454,
-0.16000258922576904,
-0.08994758874177933,
-0.24351917207241058,
0.3485504686832428,
-0.17994675040245056,
-0.48095351457595825,
-0.451423704624176,
-0.216182678937912,
0.6886352300643921,
1.0210918188095093,
-0.1166311651468277,
0.0392046719789505,
0.45786985754966736,
0.4531591832637787,
-0.8056399822235107,
0.00995972566306591,
-0.7018790245056152,
-0.19741618633270264,
-0.19305212795734406,
-0.38568127155303955,
-0.3017292618751526,
-0.01739588752388954,
0.42741328477859497,
-0.3362829089164734,
0.07194408029317856,
0.04341639205813408,
0.6928325891494751,
0.2704978287220001,
-0.25570061802864075,
-0.23094704747200012,
-0.4466800391674042,
0.7830949425697327,
-0.6867637038230896,
0.5539231300354004,
0.19760185480117798,
0.001052380888722837,
-0.10440382361412048,
-0.6404996514320374,
-0.4347546696662903,
-0.08295758813619614,
-0.16007032990455627,
-0.2586574852466583,
-0.10469401627779007,
-0.15227612853050232,
0.3649837374687195,
-0.07165559381246567,
-0.5441842675209045,
0.5656449794769287,
-0.042473435401916504,
-0.17096523940563202,
0.31518155336380005,
0.17191804945468903,
0.21355998516082764,
-0.2936716079711914,
-0.3369807302951813,
-0.15503808856010437,
-0.8639598488807678,
0.16998372972011566,
-0.17114987969398499,
0.31825241446495056,
-0.07617830485105515,
0.2997409999370575,
-0.009688416495919228,
0.7732859253883362,
-0.2157370150089264,
-0.22445476055145264,
0.22303406894207,
-0.049949027597904205,
-0.17620885372161865,
0.01318700984120369,
0.6682166457176208,
0.21451272070407867,
0.43772271275520325,
-0.2716710567474365,
-0.3126286566257477,
-0.26139917969703674,
0.19246000051498413,
-0.6161609292030334,
0.011918578296899796,
0.06263380497694016,
-0.4401361644268036,
0.03953258693218231,
-0.19037699699401855,
-0.6067806482315063,
-0.4758543372154236,
-0.575370192527771,
0.225408136844635,
-0.3327324688434601,
-0.16601507365703583,
-0.12787257134914398,
-0.11886545270681381,
0.5760414600372314,
0.3037647306919098,
-1.168912649154663,
0.427716463804245,
1.0033549070358276,
0.8132729530334473,
-0.5545380711555481,
-0.5574204325675964,
-0.3977981209754944,
0.16229872405529022,
-0.293339341878891,
0.7709424495697021,
-0.724794328212738,
0.18451891839504242,
0.035035476088523865,
-0.0818021148443222,
-0.09816030412912369,
-0.8667278289794922,
0.19092895090579987,
-0.8842602968215942,
-0.0009277178323827684,
-0.6145278215408325,
-0.3670618236064911,
-0.21659056842327118,
0.14504653215408325,
-0.6648709774017334,
0.7979701161384583,
-0.1311768889427185,
-0.7691956758499146,
0.44112828373908997,
-0.4563307464122772,
-0.5026198625564575,
0.19743163883686066,
-0.5791153907775879,
-0.025991475209593773,
0.32327601313591003,
0.2270822823047638,
0.6429061889648438,
-0.6899974942207336,
0.13125047087669373,
-0.4954620897769928,
-0.5289504528045654,
0.39731621742248535,
-0.24559196829795837,
0.8137418627738953,
0.04465453699231148,
-0.30095145106315613,
0.10316012054681778,
-0.4341721534729004,
0.03748087212443352,
0.07785157114267349,
-0.3771944046020508,
-0.39623159170150757,
0.31271883845329285,
-0.08618113398551941,
0.3515945374965668,
0.47130388021469116,
-0.1932792216539383,
-0.045716263353824615,
-0.2207525670528412,
0.8794664740562439,
0.5883859992027283,
-0.16995318233966827,
0.4845544695854187,
-0.22183336317539215,
0.21430984139442444,
0.07365072518587112,
-0.3659643232822418,
-0.2466134876012802,
-0.22491145133972168,
-0.4232558012008667,
-0.3779492676258087,
0.20477412641048431,
0.5142791867256165,
-0.12814514338970184,
0.6519197225570679,
-0.6899091601371765,
-0.010394267737865448,
-0.43525320291519165,
0.1854182481765747,
0.2295098602771759,
0.4992721974849701,
0.34002482891082764,
-0.39547401666641235,
-0.45355167984962463,
-1.130755066871643,
-0.16114677488803864,
0.03805152699351311,
-0.2766192555427551,
0.3581297993659973,
0.25577041506767273,
-0.14794056117534637,
1.1545915603637695,
-0.42928025126457214,
-0.010739592835307121,
-0.103352390229702,
-0.028557797893881798,
0.13476118445396423,
0.32695847749710083,
0.48435506224632263,
-0.5374153852462769,
-0.09129402786493301,
0.2744399905204773,
-0.8960612416267395,
-0.1879052221775055,
0.13692891597747803,
0.044004179537296295,
0.21189723908901215,
0.7438064217567444,
-0.6578351259231567,
0.03959925100207329,
0.44244125485420227,
0.011580496095120907,
0.15906864404678345,
-0.12366203963756561,
-0.010379433631896973,
-1.0218652486801147,
0.28542420268058777,
-0.13882653415203094,
-0.07681434601545334,
-0.45525676012039185,
0.1123451367020607,
0.1461210995912552,
0.18866322934627533,
-0.19951318204402924,
0.4036619961261749,
-0.6967161893844604,
-0.6930604577064514,
-0.4281744062900543,
0.4781597852706909,
-0.04817427694797516,
0.6857959628105164,
0.05242214724421501,
0.6555908918380737,
0.7556871175765991,
-0.5031219720840454,
0.10405133664608002,
0.06197579205036163,
-0.3224911391735077,
0.36062175035476685,
-0.6682539582252502,
0.14687080681324005,
-0.24342255294322968,
0.08181077241897583,
-1.0533753633499146,
-0.29596802592277527,
-0.3721618354320526,
-0.2952926754951477,
0.44135305285453796,
0.17840486764907837,
-0.45432284474372864,
-0.045924458652734756,
-0.07150713354349136,
0.5041081309318542,
0.8113054037094116,
-0.4715486466884613,
0.5818509459495544,
0.4762312173843384,
-0.3940354287624359,
-0.600908100605011,
-0.7294036149978638,
0.1455041915178299,
-0.4072939157485962,
-0.588087797164917,
0.548115611076355,
0.17802667617797852,
-0.16000276803970337,
-0.1622350811958313,
-0.01930474117398262,
0.04324634373188019,
0.21966809034347534,
0.16395828127861023,
0.1534399688243866,
-0.4281562566757202,
-0.04121001809835434,
-0.030502337962388992,
0.2524415850639343,
0.29564329981803894,
-0.2350126951932907,
0.8141834735870361,
0.044223424047231674,
-0.08937665820121765,
-0.16968661546707153,
0.23542331159114838,
0.8039705157279968,
-0.27165356278419495,
0.7267956733703613,
0.3377920985221863,
-0.5711439847946167,
-0.10509557276964188,
-0.6650239825248718,
-0.41226986050605774,
-0.4305596351623535,
0.6604390144348145,
-0.5528586506843567,
-1.1598782539367676,
0.776314377784729,
-0.0875268206000328,
-0.02365747094154358,
0.3128262758255005,
0.7066141963005066,
-0.1352473497390747,
1.0741209983825684,
0.5725066065788269,
-0.22203989326953888,
0.5322985649108887,
0.06885498017072678,
-0.005997648928314447,
-1.2462058067321777,
-0.23774924874305725,
-0.4471062123775482,
-0.43560871481895447,
-0.6089888215065002,
-0.17786157131195068,
0.15855377912521362,
0.26765188574790955,
-0.13722269237041473,
0.37847840785980225,
-0.2018427848815918,
0.47449997067451477,
0.3033279776573181,
-0.01980837807059288,
0.054267775267362595,
0.2852881848812103,
-0.37828609347343445,
-0.04220708832144737,
-0.7058224081993103,
-0.4590492844581604,
0.799479603767395,
0.43346452713012695,
0.5838530659675598,
-0.08657479286193848,
0.449961394071579,
0.04639820754528046,
0.20282700657844543,
-0.6483709812164307,
0.6261489391326904,
-0.20262092351913452,
-0.33051344752311707,
-0.2367139458656311,
-0.12389234453439713,
-1.0554965734481812,
0.3908526301383972,
-0.21756131947040558,
-1.0467830896377563,
0.3529873788356781,
-0.20474281907081604,
-0.46089038252830505,
-0.02975970320403576,
-0.5432867407798767,
0.8266317844390869,
-0.05210992693901062,
-0.5225700736045837,
-0.2500034272670746,
-0.7565212845802307,
0.2797645032405853,
-0.24723799526691437,
0.09946246445178986,
-0.10791900008916855,
-0.3821401298046112,
0.5374546647071838,
0.08384383469820023,
0.7775161266326904,
0.1600838005542755,
-0.25406479835510254,
-0.11881639063358307,
0.045735325664281845,
0.023908061906695366,
-0.22835808992385864,
-0.01927386038005352,
0.3663555681705475,
-0.0524393655359745,
-0.3498570919036865,
-0.6024315357208252,
1.0439138412475586,
-0.8036253452301025,
-0.8648392558097839,
-0.12183351814746857,
-0.8505048155784607,
-0.21363423764705658,
0.20341172814369202,
0.2726818025112152,
0.3387233018875122,
-0.07452379912137985,
0.4572749733924866,
0.6358081102371216,
-0.04183701425790787,
0.7678746581077576,
0.06211816146969795,
-0.09138620644807816,
-0.3957306444644928,
0.5823636054992676,
0.1634248048067093,
0.25059711933135986,
0.41170504689216614,
-0.09413463622331619,
-0.25694775581359863,
-0.6860543489456177,
-0.23803335428237915,
0.23995408415794373,
-0.7654886841773987,
-0.016194799914956093,
-0.587935745716095,
-0.36719629168510437,
-0.4666482210159302,
-0.06693346053361893,
-0.06639302521944046,
-0.10235972702503204,
-0.15445855259895325,
0.2229955494403839,
0.02448616363108158,
0.7025970816612244,
0.1884443461894989,
0.2286340296268463,
-0.6404908299446106,
0.06075059995055199,
0.34248533844947815,
0.1832343339920044,
0.352597177028656,
-0.49972477555274963,
-0.40255704522132874,
-0.01706753857433796,
-0.2612687945365906,
-0.8170941472053528,
0.25331252813339233,
0.18643169105052948,
0.6219858527183533,
0.3007388710975647,
-0.4499748945236206,
0.7181572914123535,
-0.6011350750923157,
0.6149657964706421,
0.02138926088809967,
-0.7337770462036133,
0.19095347821712494,
-0.26981648802757263,
0.5917936563491821,
0.3473130464553833,
0.38607874512672424,
-0.49842482805252075,
-0.16033828258514404,
-0.17462417483329773,
-0.7058059573173523,
0.7109546065330505,
0.1148364245891571,
-0.014613276347517967,
-0.03912566602230072,
0.6130933165550232,
0.02904234640300274,
0.12735773622989655,
-0.6565771698951721,
0.1201452985405922,
0.2781112790107727,
-0.14452995359897614,
-0.0906057059764862,
-0.058786313980817795,
-0.2739848792552948,
-0.14124943315982819,
-0.14236702024936676,
-0.29661157727241516,
0.3076002299785614,
0.12751765549182892,
-0.17273372411727905,
-0.20248524844646454,
0.11610272526741028,
0.6717374324798584,
0.8106168508529663,
-0.0363975390791893,
0.2977294921875,
0.3553164005279541,
-0.31070268154144287,
-0.1467442363500595,
-0.0037337723188102245,
-0.05593777075409889,
-0.5054413080215454,
0.925633430480957,
0.9596160054206848,
0.2593570053577423,
-0.6751939058303833,
0.4089369773864746,
-0.015615098178386688,
-0.06773609668016434,
-0.12122881412506104,
0.3164796531200409,
0.38418886065483093,
0.522510826587677,
0.44286248087882996,
0.2059052288532257,
0.10630794614553452,
-0.7368574142456055,
0.22769100964069366,
0.7098742127418518,
-0.05806441605091095,
-0.33267292380332947,
0.478232204914093,
-0.17944128811359406,
-0.4776143431663513,
0.7554234862327576,
0.3835696280002594,
-0.4974493980407715,
0.6103875637054443,
0.6717991232872009,
1.007608413696289,
0.05633556470274925,
-0.4458780884742737,
0.2266075611114502,
0.007763169705867767,
-0.057322222739458084,
0.02975826896727085,
-0.33050572872161865,
-0.8166557550430298,
-0.6195768713951111,
-0.7775415778160095,
0.01993805170059204,
0.03279871493577957,
-0.7309166789054871,
0.18214622139930725,
-0.3916977047920227,
-0.18997357785701752,
0.03778707981109619,
-0.15758726000785828,
-0.7189818620681763,
0.1730300635099411,
0.5374391674995422,
0.7144808173179626,
-0.6254573464393616,
1.1299580335617065,
0.6483221650123596,
-0.08394826203584671,
-0.5501628518104553,
0.46869605779647827,
-0.25928613543510437,
-0.7771071195602417,
0.7192051410675049,
0.3725777268409729,
-0.11265800893306732,
0.09265325963497162,
-0.46042200922966003,
-1.1318951845169067,
1.2651700973510742,
0.690604031085968,
-0.664476752281189,
-0.30458715558052063,
0.13623373210430145,
0.669651210308075,
-0.8596567511558533,
0.29096511006355286,
1.0001269578933716,
0.1416201889514923,
0.13609124720096588,
-0.8605598211288452,
0.32704418897628784,
-0.06797707825899124,
0.2334308624267578,
0.2639554440975189,
-0.39521360397338867,
0.7762181162834167,
-0.15490323305130005,
-0.15557624399662018,
-0.026553984731435776,
0.5395424365997314,
0.635428249835968,
-0.03211843967437744,
0.37043631076812744,
0.5428285598754883,
0.5920950174331665,
-0.10486400872468948,
0.885869562625885,
-0.3639068305492401,
0.0103612020611763,
0.950272262096405,
-0.3944566249847412,
1.28787362575531,
0.5590429306030273,
0.0633089542388916,
0.7330556511878967,
0.7482474446296692,
0.2827824354171753,
0.5294886231422424,
0.031740352511405945,
0.10581152886152267,
-0.2804032862186432,
0.0008061799453571439,
-0.11247476935386658,
0.5700839757919312,
0.43835949897766113,
-0.3325871229171753,
-0.030094947665929794,
-0.05691075697541237,
-0.3008846044540405,
-0.10046624392271042,
-0.18763770163059235,
0.9167875647544861,
0.19835549592971802,
-1.0746121406555176,
0.7855343222618103,
-0.1868717074394226,
0.7037933468818665,
-0.3462119400501251,
0.0788285881280899,
-0.17006815969944,
-0.11322745680809021,
-0.1251702755689621,
-0.9153900742530823,
0.22734461724758148,
-0.1977551430463791,
-0.3842277228832245,
-0.12916627526283264,
0.49904945492744446,
-0.5283197164535522,
0.21192802488803864,
0.7245917320251465,
0.4943196773529053,
0.1014632135629654,
0.07335998117923737,
-0.6332953572273254,
0.3920767903327942,
-0.2484508901834488,
-0.30336594581604004,
0.49106985330581665,
0.4095454216003418,
-0.3118870258331299,
0.49131736159324646,
0.4877164363861084,
0.21613265573978424,
0.13719488680362701,
0.09796746075153351,
0.7960326671600342,
-0.8365312814712524,
-0.3768109381198883,
-1.2080508470535278,
0.23556455969810486,
-0.13362184166908264,
-0.20946691930294037,
0.39619162678718567,
0.3055065870285034,
0.7603248953819275,
0.09095324575901031,
0.3858160376548767,
0.11147178709506989,
0.18248191475868225,
-0.5557594299316406,
0.6656873226165771,
-0.7213799953460693,
0.3440467417240143,
-0.11365238577127457,
-1.3598504066467285,
-0.2938230633735657,
0.4061311185359955,
-0.33283451199531555,
0.30623191595077515,
0.8938028812408447,
0.6700239181518555,
-0.047814350575208664,
-0.19989652931690216,
0.4242537021636963,
0.2987322211265564,
0.18521389365196228,
0.6949558258056641,
0.6385611295700073,
-0.15499849617481232,
0.20744609832763672,
0.10785786807537079,
-0.20801782608032227,
-0.18553777039051056,
-0.9506666660308838,
-0.781561017036438,
-0.6016022562980652,
-0.07937983423471451,
-0.005900398828089237,
-0.187049001455307,
0.8574499487876892,
0.917143702507019,
-0.670335054397583,
-0.4953998625278473,
-0.18877758085727692,
0.034624844789505005,
-0.13107450306415558,
-0.23359958827495575,
0.34556207060813904,
-0.3905125558376312,
-0.7029154896736145,
0.25586092472076416,
0.5886384844779968,
-0.23142607510089874,
-0.4057404398918152,
-0.18541264533996582,
-0.09955532103776932,
0.13419455289840698,
0.6178702712059021,
0.13393916189670563,
-1.0647250413894653,
-0.2560020983219147,
0.18179769814014435,
-0.5133284330368042,
0.2838872969150543,
0.838215708732605,
-0.9258931875228882,
0.040809471160173416,
0.7742251753807068,
0.9481830596923828,
0.31599584221839905,
-0.16395752131938934,
0.6940973401069641,
-0.6443719267845154,
0.039460279047489166,
0.12331585586071014,
0.44174790382385254,
0.523938775062561,
-0.2866824269294739,
0.1646255999803543,
0.02873365767300129,
-0.709585964679718,
-0.8060621023178101,
0.2834436595439911,
-0.9231045246124268,
-0.45191293954849243,
0.9016919732093811,
0.11920840293169022,
-0.48732656240463257,
0.13750460743904114,
0.03173275291919708,
0.1726560741662979,
-0.004503811243921518,
0.7301362156867981,
0.9495868682861328,
-0.3454325497150421,
-0.41519787907600403,
-0.510818600654602,
0.44188210368156433,
0.637224018573761,
-0.6421803832054138,
0.2403581291437149,
0.41072654724121094,
0.35141682624816895,
0.29606977105140686,
0.37872207164764404,
-0.08927201479673386,
0.3045230507850647,
-0.3177379071712494,
0.029887262731790543,
0.45177048444747925,
-0.5395300984382629,
-0.5527112483978271,
0.5348863005638123,
0.2680201828479767,
0.1544135957956314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17658v1 | Document Structure in Long Document Transformers | 2024-01-31T08:28:06 | 2024-01-31T08:28:06 | Jan Buchmann, Max Eichler, Jan-Micha Bodensohn, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long documents often exhibit structure with hierarchically organized elements
of different functions, such as section headers and paragraphs. Despite the
omnipresence of document structure, its role in natural language processing
(NLP) remains opaque. Do long-document Transformer models acquire an internal
representation of document structure during pre-training? How can structural
information be communicated to a model after pre-training, and how does it
influence downstream performance? To answer these questions, we develop a novel
suite of probing tasks to assess structure-awareness of long-document
Transformers, propose general-purpose structure infusion methods, and evaluate
the effects of structure infusion on QASPER and Evidence Inference, two
challenging long-document NLP tasks. Results on LED and LongT5 suggest that
they acquire implicit understanding of document structure during pre-training,
which can be further enhanced by structure infusion, leading to improved
end-task performance. To foster research on the role of document structure in
NLP modeling, we make our data and code publicly available. | [
-0.21435263752937317,
-0.5315543413162231,
0.5439122319221497,
0.17208650708198547,
-0.1813843697309494,
0.00583078246563673,
-0.12598347663879395,
-0.8648318648338318,
0.13469845056533813,
0.44590532779693604,
-0.3321475386619568,
-0.19532033801078796,
-0.7400558590888977,
0.13593387603759766,
-0.6134067177772522,
1.1575355529785156,
-0.15977567434310913,
0.00363327469676733,
-0.41680678725242615,
0.18295742571353912,
-0.11216707527637482,
-0.6521393656730652,
-0.5545473694801331,
-0.6108665466308594,
0.3861026465892792,
-0.008129109628498554,
0.6585413813591003,
0.5023759007453918,
0.47652682662010193,
0.3733372092247009,
-0.2575874626636505,
-0.2991607189178467,
-0.22779187560081482,
0.19820022583007812,
-0.11660808324813843,
-0.8080170154571533,
-0.6044541597366333,
-0.04986982047557831,
1.0103435516357422,
0.8627066016197205,
0.09764576703310013,
0.05654512345790863,
0.42964649200439453,
0.6937106847763062,
-0.40806716680526733,
0.498649537563324,
-0.2692001461982727,
-0.005188259296119213,
-0.41441333293914795,
-0.0467735230922699,
-0.47105497121810913,
0.009579740464687347,
0.3396656811237335,
-0.33501991629600525,
0.6284083127975464,
-0.03313867002725601,
0.8010554909706116,
0.274448424577713,
-0.49354052543640137,
-0.5208750367164612,
-0.799345850944519,
0.3114840090274811,
-0.4144173860549927,
0.5110393166542053,
0.5842884182929993,
0.15671412646770477,
-0.22806307673454285,
-0.9759070873260498,
-0.39599883556365967,
-0.3081335723400116,
-0.5307492017745972,
0.2620622515678406,
0.05173003673553467,
0.41560009121894836,
0.22041913866996765,
0.655867338180542,
-0.6114805936813354,
0.26790204644203186,
-0.4613885283470154,
-0.1424476057291031,
0.317237913608551,
-0.31351426243782043,
0.1038464605808258,
-0.20957395434379578,
-0.4487767517566681,
-0.31899771094322205,
-0.376024067401886,
0.10954832285642624,
0.5589351654052734,
0.032825276255607605,
-0.1616637408733368,
0.6126605272293091,
-0.09180305898189545,
0.4207187592983246,
0.06939207762479782,
0.06654787063598633,
0.21773691475391388,
-0.32499974966049194,
-0.4454309940338135,
0.3590834438800812,
0.5209839344024658,
-0.08048906177282333,
0.10562030225992203,
-0.19116084277629852,
-0.2464527189731598,
0.05188479274511337,
0.588854193687439,
-0.8220292329788208,
-0.07321152091026306,
0.4275161623954773,
-0.43095117807388306,
-0.18771560490131378,
0.07923749834299088,
-0.350831538438797,
-0.2116485834121704,
-0.3440714180469513,
0.379949152469635,
-0.38688817620277405,
-0.08858562260866165,
0.3372964859008789,
-0.5689893960952759,
0.5352693200111389,
0.25120681524276733,
-1.010979175567627,
0.5169877409934998,
0.6179471611976624,
0.6386154890060425,
-0.16670235991477966,
-0.34695741534233093,
-0.25621476769447327,
0.2749559283256531,
-0.13620346784591675,
1.0571540594100952,
-0.36667388677597046,
-0.3965626358985901,
0.10928618162870407,
0.17649328708648682,
-0.11534656584262848,
-0.44525209069252014,
0.9858378767967224,
-0.46289610862731934,
0.5723901987075806,
0.08090469241142273,
-0.6297083497047424,
0.05941108241677284,
0.3584710359573364,
-0.7363559007644653,
1.049137830734253,
0.36557796597480774,
-0.7393357157707214,
0.33738434314727783,
-0.7443421483039856,
-0.49265992641448975,
0.08999363332986832,
-0.3108312487602234,
-0.4447467029094696,
0.21956709027290344,
0.3395458459854126,
0.5144829750061035,
-0.06065971404314041,
0.0424376055598259,
0.08968368172645569,
-0.40235477685928345,
0.12793877720832825,
-0.3401224613189697,
0.5674854516983032,
-0.34232479333877563,
-0.18593895435333252,
0.2468811273574829,
-0.7593302130699158,
-0.23372507095336914,
0.004329727962613106,
-0.4106983244419098,
-0.2323368787765503,
0.019135857000947,
-0.03523711487650871,
0.027457699179649353,
0.12137843668460846,
-0.533035397529602,
0.35502907633781433,
-0.6495230197906494,
0.2696293294429779,
0.4964296817779541,
0.053109217435121536,
0.8577889204025269,
-0.10710699111223221,
0.405413419008255,
0.07278933376073837,
0.3544321358203888,
-0.3810306489467621,
-0.41576477885246277,
-0.7818236351013184,
-0.15005864202976227,
0.013246527872979641,
0.061488695442676544,
-0.323562890291214,
0.3796321153640747,
-0.29137498140335083,
-0.4303617477416992,
-0.381621390581131,
-0.06348133832216263,
0.4638793468475342,
0.7863273620605469,
0.5625428557395935,
-0.3102806806564331,
-0.28949081897735596,
-1.111634612083435,
-0.12477413564920425,
-0.193124458193779,
-0.319620817899704,
-0.26665109395980835,
0.6790997982025146,
-0.18267767131328583,
0.7061176300048828,
-0.5854849815368652,
-0.3951294422149658,
-0.4069652557373047,
0.532162070274353,
0.29152601957321167,
0.4247022569179535,
0.4609721899032593,
-0.724700391292572,
-0.29798510670661926,
-0.25415581464767456,
-0.4335370361804962,
0.1515686959028244,
-0.31218111515045166,
-0.15184138715267181,
0.13439542055130005,
0.7560551166534424,
-0.8820778131484985,
0.4673343002796173,
0.3034166693687439,
-0.2515770196914673,
0.5107577443122864,
-0.3585170805454254,
-0.12355832010507584,
-1.0069665908813477,
-0.09976892173290253,
-0.16470816731452942,
-0.17313991487026215,
-0.8065302968025208,
0.010523313656449318,
0.4738768935203552,
-0.1459277868270874,
-0.27650219202041626,
0.35425540804862976,
-0.6672617793083191,
-0.28682979941368103,
-0.37511634826660156,
-0.08974950760602951,
0.36509156227111816,
0.625851035118103,
0.22048155963420868,
0.5001912713050842,
0.4042871594429016,
-0.4370712637901306,
-0.12135802954435349,
0.307525634765625,
-0.5605393052101135,
0.4537743926048279,
-0.779938817024231,
0.27696505188941956,
-0.515525758266449,
0.6189717650413513,
-0.9279679656028748,
-0.28158846497535706,
0.1005295142531395,
-0.3855222463607788,
0.820881724357605,
-0.3663599491119385,
-0.5253527164459229,
-0.27888521552085876,
-0.23430216312408447,
0.049801308661699295,
0.17412367463111877,
-0.16380666196346283,
0.6506060361862183,
0.06422015279531479,
-0.036293234676122665,
-0.396895170211792,
-0.5770717263221741,
-0.041383080184459686,
0.028976012021303177,
-0.7315064668655396,
0.875542938709259,
-0.011939414776861668,
-0.035494957119226456,
-0.19132140278816223,
-0.41271862387657166,
-0.28107699751853943,
0.10875142365694046,
0.5928501486778259,
0.05733606219291687,
-0.29639092087745667,
0.41639330983161926,
0.10577939450740814,
0.007922732271254063,
0.4177877902984619,
-0.26081565022468567,
0.49775898456573486,
-0.10323316603899002,
-0.3369494676589966,
-0.3594610393047333,
0.44196707010269165,
0.5547026991844177,
-0.5478276014328003,
0.8276607990264893,
0.5296680927276611,
-0.27444374561309814,
-0.3386254906654358,
-0.5141392946243286,
-0.09983711689710617,
-0.47848832607269287,
0.48678791522979736,
-0.3285200595855713,
-0.6010559797286987,
0.40299513936042786,
0.12587450444698334,
0.09509003907442093,
0.6431102156639099,
0.324453204870224,
-0.5520309805870056,
0.7096924781799316,
1.0325392484664917,
-0.03221771493554115,
0.5935242772102356,
-0.2819291651248932,
0.011245222762227058,
-0.7243194580078125,
-0.33768099546432495,
-0.8577262163162231,
-0.326461523771286,
-0.26241615414619446,
-0.5469292402267456,
0.25975412130355835,
0.2350788712501526,
-0.11622727662324905,
0.17547327280044556,
-0.4175717532634735,
0.4602023661136627,
0.28803735971450806,
0.023035665974020958,
0.24389813840389252,
-0.19937971234321594,
0.25896450877189636,
0.24070072174072266,
-0.2903766334056854,
-0.4003598988056183,
0.7962895035743713,
0.63523268699646,
0.6287057399749756,
-0.24979622662067413,
0.6681625843048096,
-0.004378542769700289,
0.2882542312145233,
-0.9115468263626099,
0.19737188518047333,
0.18640772998332977,
-0.5289633870124817,
-0.39854738116264343,
0.11339736729860306,
-0.9159435629844666,
0.015662534162402153,
-0.04013960435986519,
-0.38154366612434387,
0.3371769189834595,
-0.05314403027296066,
-0.09840255975723267,
-0.0944443792104721,
-0.8670431971549988,
0.7805666327476501,
-0.28216007351875305,
0.07625991106033325,
-0.05320629104971886,
-0.8077149391174316,
0.07887236028909683,
-0.13161908090114594,
-0.1310204714536667,
0.3358035683631897,
0.11033537983894348,
0.7755239009857178,
-0.19197723269462585,
0.7643557190895081,
0.032916110008955,
-0.249479278922081,
0.13797684013843536,
-0.2673318386077881,
0.6036925911903381,
-0.04191911220550537,
-0.1950165033340454,
0.15952995419502258,
-0.16587410867214203,
-0.27586424350738525,
-1.0030382871627808,
0.13310906291007996,
-0.6556176543235779,
-0.667783260345459,
-0.3986755311489105,
-0.42804276943206787,
-0.12153593450784683,
0.39268621802330017,
0.39216557145118713,
0.4969119429588318,
-0.10544122010469437,
0.5723776817321777,
0.7594223022460938,
0.1627335399389267,
0.42641472816467285,
0.3275665044784546,
0.15324585139751434,
0.17012502253055573,
0.13244926929473877,
0.05223546177148819,
0.3266279995441437,
0.843635082244873,
0.22380222380161285,
-0.3290931284427643,
-0.8575748205184937,
-0.14652256667613983,
0.24444398283958435,
-0.8496546745300293,
0.10898185521364212,
-0.7359452247619629,
-0.5292050838470459,
-0.39418354630470276,
-0.19451428949832916,
-0.4545044004917145,
-0.32277658581733704,
-0.25701919198036194,
-0.36080458760261536,
-0.09008094668388367,
0.8030869960784912,
0.5352662205696106,
0.4178195893764496,
-0.761596143245697,
0.44429880380630493,
0.19403110444545746,
0.4783933162689209,
-0.2583647668361664,
-0.4755747318267822,
-0.5264567136764526,
-0.07792102545499802,
-0.18586665391921997,
-0.7793581485748291,
0.0838174968957901,
0.19394361972808838,
0.6625316739082336,
0.4185609221458435,
-0.10396858304738998,
0.6005417108535767,
-0.5758742690086365,
0.6426829099655151,
-0.09207826107740402,
-0.6439154148101807,
0.5563963651657104,
-0.14687718451023102,
0.47537192702293396,
0.43897730112075806,
0.5838141441345215,
-0.1280035376548767,
-0.5971440672874451,
-0.37494659423828125,
-0.7194902896881104,
0.5039935111999512,
0.4415903091430664,
0.021077647805213928,
0.03662325441837311,
0.40016549825668335,
-0.004023430868983269,
0.14558765292167664,
-0.8065676689147949,
-0.017156017944216728,
-0.449257493019104,
0.02493615448474884,
-0.13594955205917358,
-0.4101810157299042,
-0.18627148866653442,
-0.10063481330871582,
0.06428799778223038,
-0.14632299542427063,
0.34425997734069824,
0.4905916452407837,
-0.36984461545944214,
0.21198594570159912,
0.5246226191520691,
0.4373975992202759,
0.48551926016807556,
-0.569320797920227,
0.19802716374397278,
-0.20870853960514069,
-0.7173619866371155,
-0.11690923571586609,
0.22983454167842865,
0.15927058458328247,
-0.12757965922355652,
0.7239415049552917,
0.6832630038261414,
0.46695631742477417,
-0.1594502478837967,
0.3516620397567749,
-0.22420747578144073,
-0.37931373715400696,
-0.42295438051223755,
-0.016001930460333824,
0.20050714910030365,
0.2931753396987915,
0.4040038585662842,
-0.20638123154640198,
0.1167994812130928,
-0.8146399855613708,
-0.004023530054837465,
0.3473401665687561,
-0.41695600748062134,
-0.33371564745903015,
0.38031718134880066,
0.07066258788108826,
-0.20312555134296417,
0.8371769785881042,
0.1497562974691391,
-0.4560611844062805,
0.5438920855522156,
0.6841071248054504,
1.0022143125534058,
-0.05420178547501564,
0.13098110258579254,
0.04110737144947052,
0.4925136864185333,
-0.14651450514793396,
0.04440015181899071,
-0.38928717374801636,
-0.5497296452522278,
-0.4530876576900482,
-0.9144633412361145,
-0.2540380656719208,
0.05332062765955925,
-0.6540277004241943,
0.16517697274684906,
-0.06841225922107697,
-0.0117258345708251,
0.12088523060083389,
0.01799597218632698,
-0.6211957335472107,
0.27219027280807495,
0.28389331698417664,
0.9683272838592529,
-0.5366711020469666,
1.044480562210083,
0.34981009364128113,
-0.5008034706115723,
-0.5602270364761353,
0.15135852992534637,
-0.3371706008911133,
-0.34973588585853577,
0.9050760865211487,
0.3536212146282196,
-0.2677936553955078,
-0.13612544536590576,
-0.36893704533576965,
-0.923794686794281,
1.009334683418274,
0.2732003629207611,
-0.19712837040424347,
-0.7077770829200745,
0.3907279968261719,
0.7611761689186096,
-0.07711661607027054,
0.3649164140224457,
0.14354835450649261,
0.47236284613609314,
-0.1627022624015808,
-0.7366055250167847,
-0.2200772613286972,
-0.28916820883750916,
-0.2973361313343048,
0.3733706772327423,
-0.2580687701702118,
0.8537271022796631,
0.2667929232120514,
-0.41732972860336304,
-0.3587154746055603,
0.8368723392486572,
-0.22634179890155792,
-0.0022983672097325325,
0.504642903804779,
0.3084339499473572,
0.7219876050949097,
0.05626608803868294,
1.2734240293502808,
-0.1916748732328415,
-0.20681887865066528,
1.2884206771850586,
-0.13941873610019684,
0.7416245937347412,
0.39653125405311584,
0.0032969978637993336,
0.6615695357322693,
0.2876497507095337,
-0.04186093062162399,
0.2074098438024521,
0.18941368162631989,
0.08635344356298447,
0.1706189215183258,
-0.06817015260457993,
-0.40397536754608154,
0.6858820915222168,
0.42384853959083557,
-0.43768131732940674,
-0.2845351994037628,
-0.2572782337665558,
-0.08915352821350098,
-0.19141826033592224,
-0.2886801064014435,
0.6086505055427551,
0.16636866331100464,
-0.7620619535446167,
0.3436315655708313,
-0.017556749284267426,
0.49803245067596436,
-1.0741534233093262,
0.016426585614681244,
-0.26054832339286804,
0.12754911184310913,
-0.2555640637874603,
-0.9082407355308533,
0.573594331741333,
-0.19141219556331635,
-0.46827492117881775,
-0.8580251336097717,
0.8295267820358276,
-0.31244978308677673,
-0.23361161351203918,
0.3239266872406006,
0.2516462802886963,
-0.07819294184446335,
-0.6116380095481873,
-0.2489238679409027,
-0.21252316236495972,
-0.4190256893634796,
-0.5783189535140991,
0.68624347448349,
0.20720256865024567,
-0.3153385818004608,
0.34353047609329224,
0.6540378928184509,
-0.031923919916152954,
0.06969839334487915,
0.3642118573188782,
0.9326356053352356,
-0.5282105803489685,
-0.6188454627990723,
-0.6898953318595886,
0.6100813746452332,
-0.24831920862197876,
-0.3145051598548889,
0.7330508232116699,
0.694746732711792,
0.9174228310585022,
-0.04608536511659622,
0.23559023439884186,
0.4009450376033783,
0.0877947136759758,
-0.6061927676200867,
1.0579432249069214,
-0.36018314957618713,
-0.20132485032081604,
-0.2008689045906067,
-0.9170475602149963,
-0.187117800116539,
0.1817072033882141,
-0.08612003177404404,
-0.3395768702030182,
0.9991841912269592,
0.569223165512085,
-0.024364793673157692,
0.036679644137620926,
0.03064686432480812,
0.2192596197128296,
0.5880056023597717,
0.28164181113243103,
0.6410343647003174,
-0.34500792622566223,
0.586907684803009,
-0.3210153579711914,
-0.014129135757684708,
0.05378630757331848,
-0.781434178352356,
-1.018262267112732,
-0.7978783249855042,
-0.020414330065250397,
-0.013697294518351555,
-0.1875835806131363,
0.441099613904953,
0.4851667284965515,
-0.2650611102581024,
-0.2853064239025116,
-0.16645805537700653,
0.14828480780124664,
-0.06536782532930374,
-0.18239739537239075,
0.7183472514152527,
-0.41605809330940247,
-0.6911463141441345,
0.7668601870536804,
0.43628308176994324,
0.246781125664711,
-0.13202665746212006,
0.3374307453632355,
-0.17341315746307373,
-0.009232129901647568,
0.7642754912376404,
0.13633693754673004,
-0.22113215923309326,
-0.09633160382509232,
0.0406302884221077,
-0.2778679430484772,
0.29222601652145386,
0.8985510468482971,
-0.7058934569358826,
0.35391631722450256,
0.6758558750152588,
0.494261234998703,
0.8264617919921875,
-0.08049273490905762,
0.7412285804748535,
-0.9808918833732605,
0.22953377664089203,
0.3856325149536133,
0.46782055497169495,
0.14599716663360596,
-0.512927770614624,
0.3372191786766052,
-0.26360177993774414,
-0.48801180720329285,
-0.8037521243095398,
0.26246821880340576,
-0.9059410095214844,
-0.34474989771842957,
0.8581981658935547,
0.026569273322820663,
-0.3614763915538788,
-0.3122711181640625,
-0.14008615911006927,
0.5461512207984924,
-0.10619812458753586,
0.5639613270759583,
0.7903739809989929,
-0.09657343477010727,
-0.10944896936416626,
-0.5668577551841736,
0.8054376244544983,
0.21418975293636322,
-1.0350075960159302,
-0.10720089077949524,
0.196628600358963,
-0.09097875654697418,
0.44708019495010376,
0.6400496363639832,
-0.26550549268722534,
-0.14499343931674957,
-0.10633797943592072,
-0.1054454892873764,
-0.188528910279274,
-0.5450790524482727,
-0.30708545446395874,
0.3473639190196991,
-0.14799925684928894,
0.014515841379761696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17633v1 | Navigating the OverKill in Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T07:26:47 | 2024-01-31T07:26:47 | Chenyu Shi, Xiao Wang, Qiming Ge, Songyang Gao, Xianjun Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Xun Zhao, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models are meticulously aligned to be both helpful and
harmless. However, recent research points to a potential overkill which means
models may refuse to answer benign queries. In this paper, we investigate the
factors for overkill by exploring how models handle and determine the safety of
queries. Our findings reveal the presence of shortcuts within models, leading
to an over-attention of harmful words like 'kill' and prompts emphasizing
safety will exacerbate overkill. Based on these insights, we introduce
Self-Contrastive Decoding (Self-CD), a training-free and model-agnostic
strategy, to alleviate this phenomenon. We first extract such over-attention by
amplifying the difference in the model's output distributions when responding
to system prompts that either include or omit an emphasis on safety. Then we
determine the final next-token predictions by downplaying the over-attention
from the model via contrastive decoding. Empirical results indicate that our
method has achieved an average reduction of the refusal rate by 20\% while
having almost no impact on safety. | [
-0.36616355180740356,
-0.8778197765350342,
0.7837127447128296,
0.0588567852973938,
-0.2166968435049057,
-0.21507903933525085,
0.0003995026636403054,
-0.3673444390296936,
-0.11930741369724274,
0.7593570351600647,
-0.4732499122619629,
-0.3304503560066223,
-0.5104466080665588,
0.01964721828699112,
-0.7005665898323059,
1.09934663772583,
0.15232200920581818,
-0.32707279920578003,
-0.17698052525520325,
-0.07130777835845947,
-0.40483012795448303,
-0.845473051071167,
-1.1193822622299194,
-0.02783280797302723,
0.8083369135856628,
0.09023700654506683,
0.9310258626937866,
0.7676018476486206,
0.29835429787635803,
0.3067805767059326,
-0.38855817914009094,
-0.2044098675251007,
-0.8080494999885559,
0.08849916607141495,
-0.4541667401790619,
-0.4682694375514984,
-0.3803517818450928,
-0.010958175174891949,
0.3721887767314911,
0.6846747994422913,
-0.08580482006072998,
0.10414636135101318,
0.24043862521648407,
0.6487501859664917,
-1.1223998069763184,
-0.00563953397795558,
-0.6514981389045715,
-0.2012680023908615,
-0.2257005125284195,
-0.18806859850883484,
-0.6658093929290771,
-0.10094591975212097,
-0.025369318202137947,
-0.48255401849746704,
-0.09318072348833084,
-0.09830625355243683,
0.40646275877952576,
0.35977885127067566,
-0.4943150281906128,
-0.36868366599082947,
-0.505660891532898,
0.9560366868972778,
-0.5881743431091309,
0.15599429607391357,
0.8922267556190491,
0.2953604757785797,
-0.16282227635383606,
-0.30791565775871277,
-0.3532821834087372,
-0.07275814563035965,
-0.2104327380657196,
0.03890029340982437,
-0.5338998436927795,
0.37744462490081787,
0.29931727051734924,
0.06340291351079941,
-0.5668327212333679,
0.2129712998867035,
-0.5528566837310791,
-0.03019626811146736,
0.4862525165081024,
0.42450150847435,
0.4261815845966339,
-0.2671438455581665,
-0.24208343029022217,
0.141757532954216,
-0.7328657507896423,
-0.23634354770183563,
0.19433808326721191,
0.22576391696929932,
-0.006144572980701923,
0.4592808187007904,
-0.3770870864391327,
0.726414680480957,
0.10633926093578339,
0.23369963467121124,
0.031355686485767365,
-0.36426112055778503,
-0.37461888790130615,
0.03452492877840996,
0.8089582324028015,
0.6749716997146606,
0.5318486094474792,
-0.16537350416183472,
-0.146439790725708,
0.042797647416591644,
0.5066079497337341,
-0.8031336665153503,
-0.2456609159708023,
0.6159965395927429,
-0.5922147631645203,
-0.4402807056903839,
-0.8132325410842896,
-0.6632005572319031,
-0.09808285534381866,
-0.016057364642620087,
0.6134811043739319,
-0.49335938692092896,
-0.2371886670589447,
0.39297592639923096,
0.051725633442401886,
0.09010966122150421,
0.21329757571220398,
-0.8373393416404724,
0.22808165848255157,
0.5296478867530823,
0.9895930886268616,
-0.02372707799077034,
-0.24105700850486755,
-0.7433359622955322,
0.3820835053920746,
-0.4744839370250702,
0.5829604864120483,
-0.30408135056495667,
-0.8076185584068298,
-0.07141690701246262,
0.03754879906773567,
-0.20632736384868622,
-0.4659130275249481,
0.5591311454772949,
-0.6274664402008057,
0.17645244300365448,
-0.627087414264679,
-0.5823771357536316,
-0.3368910253047943,
0.4556894600391388,
-0.536552906036377,
0.5888630747795105,
-0.26981261372566223,
-0.9719051718711853,
0.2421802580356598,
-0.5613975524902344,
-0.7790937423706055,
-0.09916502982378006,
0.06287400424480438,
-0.23998701572418213,
-0.056015387177467346,
0.07950512319803238,
0.5388209819793701,
-0.15434734523296356,
0.03573900833725929,
-0.3563690483570099,
-0.2299565225839615,
0.06155116856098175,
-0.40923774242401123,
0.9776280522346497,
0.5504058003425598,
-0.2277408242225647,
0.051120076328516006,
-0.8570233583450317,
0.077573761343956,
0.20395569503307343,
-0.42513948678970337,
-0.7488039135932922,
-0.10440053045749664,
0.023224882781505585,
0.4519587457180023,
-0.005177140235900879,
-0.549554169178009,
-0.20473937690258026,
-0.5784416794776917,
0.5040791630744934,
0.6402124762535095,
-0.10505037009716034,
0.35936498641967773,
-0.35064902901649475,
0.6887913346290588,
-0.08925924450159073,
0.35821688175201416,
-0.37652817368507385,
-0.2196781486272812,
-0.6562855839729309,
-0.08843418210744858,
0.08878488093614578,
0.37069573998451233,
-0.6930593848228455,
0.3966870605945587,
-0.03398779779672623,
-0.43843644857406616,
-0.5542187094688416,
0.046040624380111694,
0.8825392127037048,
0.45607784390449524,
0.5040326714515686,
-0.13446898758411407,
-0.3220985233783722,
-0.8375914692878723,
-0.1747373789548874,
-0.17881014943122864,
0.06213138997554779,
0.003611847525462508,
0.5203101634979248,
-0.21622799336910248,
0.7529271841049194,
-0.5390371680259705,
-0.5770719051361084,
-0.36042436957359314,
0.1161583736538887,
-0.16607654094696045,
0.5857993960380554,
0.7683634757995605,
-0.6932485699653625,
-0.47328996658325195,
-0.18665653467178345,
-0.59248948097229,
0.1518833190202713,
-0.35696160793304443,
-0.02126179449260235,
0.3432177007198334,
1.0290991067886353,
-0.6561610698699951,
0.32852503657341003,
0.2903714179992676,
-0.10454860329627991,
0.3618960678577423,
-0.32250338792800903,
-0.05988306552171707,
-0.8837096691131592,
0.4824264347553253,
-0.16736596822738647,
-0.012713773176074028,
-0.7284047603607178,
0.4055319130420685,
0.17169015109539032,
-0.15889383852481842,
-0.5258627533912659,
0.7202466130256653,
-0.5585495233535767,
0.19668078422546387,
-0.5356432795524597,
-0.0791756808757782,
0.14070352911949158,
0.34324878454208374,
-0.021905647590756416,
0.7710109353065491,
0.555998682975769,
-0.6292672753334045,
0.09412939101457596,
0.2010282725095749,
-0.27521783113479614,
0.4683545231819153,
-0.9420287013053894,
-0.04226161912083626,
-0.4203048646450043,
0.18819989264011383,
-1.0281590223312378,
-0.1249159425497055,
0.3396477699279785,
-0.38855859637260437,
0.3172456920146942,
-0.42596638202667236,
-0.4382690489292145,
-0.3944387137889862,
-0.2326798290014267,
0.8388975262641907,
0.44583386182785034,
-0.36897972226142883,
0.5227253437042236,
0.4060923755168915,
-0.08322747051715851,
-0.45171937346458435,
-0.9396565556526184,
0.08332240581512451,
-0.33360376954078674,
-0.3316603899002075,
-0.05348484218120575,
-0.18937160074710846,
-0.12974929809570312,
-0.201547309756279,
0.12979939579963684,
-0.09355442970991135,
0.432908296585083,
0.24633902311325073,
-0.09058814495801926,
0.09093782305717468,
0.18044187128543854,
-0.2067125290632248,
-0.39779651165008545,
0.4512546956539154,
0.07565290480852127,
0.518410861492157,
0.28656792640686035,
-0.47763702273368835,
-0.27110064029693604,
0.618388295173645,
0.7815068364143372,
-0.5291001796722412,
0.7745120525360107,
0.2519366145133972,
-0.17982380092144012,
0.15515828132629395,
-0.7226048707962036,
-0.13212080299854279,
-0.5272639393806458,
0.4613591730594635,
-0.3087695837020874,
-0.4845042824745178,
0.6976729035377502,
0.2458791732788086,
-0.0699758529663086,
0.1948997676372528,
0.308274507522583,
0.04627782478928566,
1.2916287183761597,
0.5989966988563538,
-0.30279627442359924,
0.35481542348861694,
-0.2447449266910553,
0.06980111449956894,
-0.5672187805175781,
-0.17583495378494263,
-0.6579926609992981,
0.2014940232038498,
-0.34925881028175354,
-0.4190499186515808,
0.4957038462162018,
-0.13504576683044434,
-0.16625332832336426,
0.2696925103664398,
-0.3691426217556,
0.7752668857574463,
0.42461901903152466,
-0.007408441044390202,
0.10033032298088074,
-0.266994833946228,
0.05638551712036133,
0.021727213636040688,
-0.8106721043586731,
0.042202383279800415,
0.9676012396812439,
0.46274805068969727,
1.1479586362838745,
-0.05523441731929779,
0.5527043342590332,
-0.025117652490735054,
-0.3085954487323761,
-0.8111864924430847,
0.5297904014587402,
-0.18240909278392792,
-1.0568476915359497,
-0.47343748807907104,
-0.49082350730895996,
-1.0681506395339966,
0.2501324713230133,
0.0639365166425705,
-0.5488024353981018,
0.19833356142044067,
0.40571606159210205,
-0.8631511330604553,
0.17820604145526886,
-0.6639065742492676,
1.0686147212982178,
-0.3759877681732178,
-0.23555061221122742,
-0.5034028887748718,
-0.8191163539886475,
0.30742210149765015,
-0.10348913073539734,
0.4853439927101135,
0.10759536921977997,
0.24675506353378296,
0.5617005228996277,
-0.10458973795175552,
1.0608296394348145,
0.10012335330247879,
-0.27741509675979614,
0.1739949882030487,
0.527197539806366,
0.5454612374305725,
-0.5781280994415283,
-0.2991284728050232,
0.035110488533973694,
0.0671946108341217,
-0.57341068983078,
-0.3431418240070343,
0.6584804058074951,
-0.36843040585517883,
-0.5483337044715881,
-0.40118879079818726,
-0.2687987983226776,
0.10459095984697342,
0.4569132626056671,
0.5342745184898376,
0.6877890825271606,
-0.06859157979488373,
0.15529178082942963,
0.7621867656707764,
-0.522662878036499,
0.5086873769760132,
0.5363038182258606,
-0.1570345014333725,
-0.10650861263275146,
1.0215970277786255,
0.38819047808647156,
0.7827004194259644,
0.18620753288269043,
-0.015132907778024673,
-0.5137099623680115,
-0.6905063986778259,
-0.5731592774391174,
0.23525157570838928,
-1.003258466720581,
-0.21594850718975067,
-1.136824607849121,
-0.19877088069915771,
-0.3289162516593933,
-0.1800236999988556,
-0.570541262626648,
-0.077618308365345,
-0.40395936369895935,
-0.15847720205783844,
0.25486162304878235,
0.683890700340271,
-0.12230543047189713,
0.22841037809848785,
-0.8402832746505737,
0.1563817411661148,
0.3832562267780304,
0.32785850763320923,
0.35655200481414795,
-0.4577847719192505,
-0.4447330832481384,
-0.22032678127288818,
-0.18322128057479858,
-0.7726371884346008,
0.48132044076919556,
0.0037082908675074577,
0.7501766681671143,
0.5048052668571472,
0.6394879221916199,
0.433695524930954,
-0.44368162751197815,
0.5581087470054626,
0.20134951174259186,
-0.9553796052932739,
0.5360633730888367,
-0.6270020604133606,
0.742347240447998,
0.6473037600517273,
0.7627711892127991,
-0.6411735415458679,
-0.5792846083641052,
-0.2874489724636078,
-1.068975567817688,
0.6433016061782837,
0.2246427983045578,
0.4304406940937042,
-0.5478603839874268,
0.12773345410823822,
-0.0995435044169426,
0.11098317056894302,
-0.7287483215332031,
-0.22605669498443604,
-0.18548505008220673,
0.06592513620853424,
-0.010634065605700016,
-0.7807648777961731,
-0.18411803245544434,
0.05373682454228401,
0.5492974519729614,
-0.2768857479095459,
-0.07866741716861725,
-0.061792824417352676,
-0.08653494715690613,
-0.32730406522750854,
0.48231935501098633,
0.47914060950279236,
0.6347044706344604,
-0.26118001341819763,
0.12121988087892532,
0.23794066905975342,
-0.05405372753739357,
-0.06926186382770538,
-0.10194329172372818,
-0.3093852698802948,
-0.17967253923416138,
0.19635938107967377,
0.45711979269981384,
0.3509756326675415,
-0.6497125625610352,
0.5051224827766418,
0.04579782113432884,
0.11263618618249893,
-0.005400739144533873,
0.052619822323322296,
0.05418787896633148,
-0.1384270042181015,
0.12799885869026184,
-0.21057476103305817,
0.6512199640274048,
-0.6803399324417114,
0.023005452007055283,
0.7084819078445435,
-0.33093374967575073,
-0.0856572762131691,
0.7183592319488525,
0.34971415996551514,
0.07899811118841171,
0.31355804204940796,
-0.08404003083705902,
-0.7222373485565186,
0.6192497611045837,
0.48023363947868347,
0.7851163148880005,
-0.2566518187522888,
0.20087310671806335,
0.4205929636955261,
0.31044676899909973,
-0.0924193263053894,
0.22186456620693207,
0.06936756521463394,
-0.31300103664398193,
-0.38237759470939636,
-0.49082693457603455,
-0.14989632368087769,
0.34396374225616455,
-0.8609954714775085,
0.05074866861104965,
-0.5414916276931763,
-0.0806582123041153,
0.07711046189069748,
-0.4256547689437866,
-0.25461089611053467,
0.57782381772995,
0.037389125674963,
0.7702912092208862,
-0.659821093082428,
0.8896968364715576,
0.3235023617744446,
-0.5609712600708008,
-0.5675404667854309,
0.10986490547657013,
0.006551091559231281,
-0.758759081363678,
0.6089954972267151,
0.29832541942596436,
-0.36083105206489563,
-0.0846489742398262,
-0.3501085638999939,
-0.9885823130607605,
0.4429703652858734,
0.2488674372434616,
-0.6135730147361755,
-0.292520672082901,
-0.05308963358402252,
0.5580148100852966,
0.16269561648368835,
0.20377571880817413,
0.5060794353485107,
0.2871648967266083,
0.06797906011343002,
-1.141906499862671,
0.29731112718582153,
0.03401631489396095,
-0.08209199458360672,
0.2362259030342102,
-0.7122262716293335,
0.9495348334312439,
-0.4321102797985077,
-0.4559909403324127,
0.19209665060043335,
0.12436611950397491,
-0.22513854503631592,
0.16846370697021484,
0.6791388392448425,
0.3625977635383606,
0.2179495394229889,
0.44508352875709534,
1.2096750736236572,
-0.26624584197998047,
0.48021000623703003,
1.1718357801437378,
-0.042565908282995224,
0.8905885815620422,
0.4637203514575958,
0.029563529416918755,
-0.10166503489017487,
0.345634788274765,
0.1516837328672409,
0.8068080544471741,
0.16911044716835022,
0.04960055649280548,
-0.7493841648101807,
-0.03306928277015686,
-0.5969969034194946,
0.4899134635925293,
0.45985350012779236,
-0.5126633048057556,
-0.6485688090324402,
0.19533050060272217,
0.12453848123550415,
0.1296623796224594,
-0.34640127420425415,
0.8560562133789062,
0.21967411041259766,
-0.6453550457954407,
1.0842890739440918,
-0.10666844248771667,
0.6796080470085144,
-0.45774373412132263,
0.21959668397903442,
-0.12618042528629303,
0.1616358906030655,
0.009995302185416222,
-0.9407733082771301,
0.5192493796348572,
-0.30448010563850403,
-0.39307668805122375,
-0.22101520001888275,
0.5460444092750549,
-0.43847885727882385,
-0.3632506728172302,
0.8650583624839783,
0.2541681230068207,
0.23021939396858215,
-0.38595834374427795,
-0.7938987612724304,
0.08926694095134735,
-0.026600755751132965,
-0.08748868852853775,
0.5815661549568176,
0.4326479136943817,
0.07325960695743561,
1.2274563312530518,
0.5162547826766968,
-0.10912982374429703,
-0.06714378297328949,
-0.2636459767818451,
0.9907176494598389,
-0.5736334323883057,
-0.9356253147125244,
-0.921463131904602,
0.268893837928772,
0.2742403745651245,
-0.11324749141931534,
0.7881193161010742,
0.24693553149700165,
0.9586969017982483,
-0.016384588554501534,
0.6900980472564697,
0.33375734090805054,
0.7340487241744995,
-0.6739073991775513,
1.1918625831604004,
-0.9118770956993103,
0.2841589152812958,
-0.2775306701660156,
-0.32761067152023315,
-0.19680675864219666,
0.45219773054122925,
-0.6354501843452454,
0.2806534469127655,
0.368721067905426,
0.829238772392273,
-0.1376003623008728,
-0.27614670991897583,
0.7723758220672607,
0.40065309405326843,
0.21616585552692413,
0.5609403252601624,
0.7468429207801819,
-0.14890561997890472,
0.9936950206756592,
-0.18008464574813843,
0.07808361947536469,
-0.5979772806167603,
-0.7610684037208557,
-1.1703007221221924,
-0.35450828075408936,
-0.2386292964220047,
-0.4514979422092438,
0.4965934455394745,
0.6286406517028809,
0.89757239818573,
-0.8420571684837341,
-0.060387227684259415,
0.03672158345580101,
0.01979852095246315,
0.2029149830341339,
-0.12980613112449646,
0.42102673649787903,
-0.4978422522544861,
-0.47794753313064575,
0.34897372126579285,
0.12124292552471161,
0.33933672308921814,
-0.3568898141384125,
0.17586649954319,
-0.16778798401355743,
0.06404879689216614,
0.5048843026161194,
0.6101983785629272,
-0.7298821806907654,
-0.2418212592601776,
-0.20893317461013794,
-0.4415203034877777,
-0.1841108798980713,
0.6114115118980408,
-0.6198156476020813,
0.568817675113678,
0.3197963237762451,
0.5995538234710693,
0.08343260735273361,
0.003095759777352214,
0.8912419080734253,
-0.6646353006362915,
0.1306338906288147,
0.10091053694486618,
0.21751239895820618,
0.38917437195777893,
-0.8038644194602966,
0.2060822695493698,
-0.15944106876850128,
-0.6759418845176697,
-0.797800600528717,
0.3604782819747925,
-0.6653040051460266,
-0.8026869893074036,
1.3318811655044556,
-0.35963553190231323,
-0.27545371651649475,
-0.5505321025848389,
-0.4548938572406769,
-0.022266732528805733,
-0.42733168601989746,
1.019998550415039,
0.47034791111946106,
0.26414456963539124,
-0.1368376910686493,
-0.4542176425457001,
0.8525473475456238,
0.8961184024810791,
-0.5870208740234375,
0.4814690053462982,
0.6353634595870972,
0.48648494482040405,
0.3757396340370178,
0.6899370551109314,
0.05275443568825722,
0.5759070515632629,
-0.0830039456486702,
-0.12319624423980713,
0.022012703120708466,
-0.49210894107818604,
-0.558122456073761,
0.2773807644844055,
0.1011863723397255,
-0.42173001170158386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17632v1 | What Do Self-Supervised Speech and Speaker Models Learn? New Findings From a Cross Model Layer-Wise Analysis | 2024-01-31T07:23:22 | 2024-01-31T07:23:22 | Takanori Ashihara, Marc Delcroix, Takafumi Moriya, Kohei Matsuura, Taichi Asami, Yusuke Ijima | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-supervised learning (SSL) has attracted increased attention for learning
meaningful speech representations. Speech SSL models, such as WavLM, employ
masked prediction training to encode general-purpose representations. In
contrast, speaker SSL models, exemplified by DINO-based models, adopt
utterance-level training objectives primarily for speaker representation.
Understanding how these models represent information is essential for refining
model efficiency and effectiveness. Unlike the various analyses of speech SSL,
there has been limited investigation into what information speaker SSL captures
and how its representation differs from speech SSL or other fully-supervised
speaker models. This paper addresses these fundamental questions. We explore
the capacity to capture various speech properties by applying SUPERB evaluation
probing tasks to speech and speaker SSL models. We also examine which layers
are predominantly utilized for each task to identify differences in how speech
is represented. Furthermore, we conduct direct comparisons to measure the
similarities between layers within and across models. Our analysis unveils that
1) the capacity to represent content information is somewhat unrelated to
enhanced speaker representation, 2) specific layers of speech SSL models would
be partly specialized in capturing linguistic information, and 3) speaker SSL
models tend to disregard linguistic information but exhibit more sophisticated
speaker representation. | [
-0.380567729473114,
-0.5257749557495117,
0.4454077482223511,
-0.14542455971240997,
0.12259669601917267,
0.025557035580277443,
0.09895160049200058,
-0.6355701088905334,
0.022799916565418243,
0.7040371894836426,
-0.42543095350265503,
-0.13026627898216248,
-0.355541467666626,
-0.16271494328975677,
-0.5347946286201477,
0.8889204263687134,
0.6506500244140625,
0.16981664299964905,
-0.36672744154930115,
0.21690554916858673,
-0.24484702944755554,
-0.8056520819664001,
-0.41488468647003174,
-0.6066997051239014,
0.26607078313827515,
0.1429993361234665,
0.39272841811180115,
0.7671664357185364,
0.09388382732868195,
0.32449719309806824,
-0.03962508589029312,
-0.1657710075378418,
-0.5286880731582642,
0.01622847653925419,
-0.39362433552742004,
-0.05545845627784729,
-0.20559066534042358,
0.4556248188018799,
0.735293447971344,
0.8649340867996216,
-0.06346116960048676,
0.4374539852142334,
0.2913539707660675,
0.32190585136413574,
-0.591427743434906,
0.27982717752456665,
-0.8280054926872253,
0.22932930290699005,
-0.2916436493396759,
-0.3929886519908905,
-0.6346082091331482,
0.3762663006782532,
0.30314603447914124,
-0.1243424117565155,
0.28050342202186584,
-0.1846446692943573,
0.4571475088596344,
0.05548202246427536,
-0.5936557054519653,
-0.11490067094564438,
-0.9633719325065613,
0.8159229159355164,
-0.6798141598701477,
0.65410977602005,
0.5389862060546875,
0.45159122347831726,
0.2196740359067917,
-0.6071015000343323,
-0.22038288414478302,
-0.4020858108997345,
-0.006833688355982304,
0.2262219786643982,
-0.16761912405490875,
0.09700175374746323,
0.20991668105125427,
0.40543511509895325,
-0.2739448547363281,
0.3050249218940735,
-0.5481440424919128,
-0.48143094778060913,
0.9042543172836304,
-0.014545862562954426,
0.13723251223564148,
-0.4989757537841797,
-0.5548771619796753,
-0.21345064043998718,
-0.3047938644886017,
0.23269519209861755,
0.40974161028862,
0.48930448293685913,
-0.05065835267305374,
0.4436253309249878,
-0.12296385318040848,
0.6440847516059875,
0.147500142455101,
-0.17887379229068756,
0.08475381135940552,
-0.1294127255678177,
-0.2727903127670288,
0.32348066568374634,
0.7592963576316833,
-0.1856081634759903,
0.2756817042827606,
-0.2807985842227936,
-0.1883382797241211,
-0.4453508257865906,
0.3816350996494293,
-0.3838123083114624,
-0.4026696979999542,
0.17961762845516205,
-0.6080489754676819,
-0.07796815037727356,
0.07997086644172668,
-0.3374761939048767,
-0.2180597484111786,
-0.46600255370140076,
0.5731055736541748,
-0.3265021741390228,
-0.5870442986488342,
-0.20644210278987885,
-0.2694965600967407,
0.3066532015800476,
0.1549292355775833,
-1.0292009115219116,
0.6124922037124634,
0.610974133014679,
0.49984273314476013,
-0.19923363626003265,
-0.363231360912323,
-0.6394492983818054,
0.2182125747203827,
-0.46157148480415344,
0.3910572826862335,
-0.6685802936553955,
-0.265785813331604,
-0.12452343106269836,
-0.2445782870054245,
-0.3679956793785095,
-0.37372130155563354,
0.29393520951271057,
-0.3650227189064026,
0.20608365535736084,
-0.24492892622947693,
-0.8846036195755005,
-0.12371973693370819,
-0.20193906128406525,
-0.695881724357605,
0.7526770830154419,
-0.062434881925582886,
-0.8066856861114502,
0.07890290021896362,
-0.22437918186187744,
-0.12501291930675507,
0.1790972203016281,
-0.37806689739227295,
-0.21697655320167542,
0.2836199402809143,
0.04844967648386955,
0.8791808485984802,
0.08142410963773727,
-0.15055452287197113,
-0.29582679271698,
-0.17689503729343414,
0.3814186751842499,
-0.4031728208065033,
0.6064263582229614,
0.2780882716178894,
-0.2442142516374588,
0.022960998117923737,
-1.0069199800491333,
0.05061553418636322,
0.24453169107437134,
-0.23369614779949188,
-0.2669260799884796,
0.01440405286848545,
-0.027210280299186707,
0.15234966576099396,
0.24745330214500427,
-0.7817800641059875,
-0.43397724628448486,
-0.2042468786239624,
0.6360924243927002,
0.6773594617843628,
-0.041116707026958466,
0.2967180907726288,
0.12904539704322815,
0.35305720567703247,
-0.12073727697134018,
0.05891165882349014,
-0.18147948384284973,
-0.36773160099983215,
-0.39471569657325745,
-0.03442976251244545,
0.5372949838638306,
0.40796855092048645,
-0.1861966848373413,
0.15294241905212402,
0.07629098743200302,
-0.5616167187690735,
-0.7650359272956848,
0.21343721449375153,
0.6658648252487183,
0.6028731465339661,
0.45193830132484436,
-0.3209055960178375,
-0.3129962980747223,
-1.0424120426177979,
-0.23400680720806122,
-0.34306252002716064,
0.09854438900947571,
0.33825552463531494,
0.32177630066871643,
0.2890135645866394,
0.8587650656700134,
0.14610455930233002,
-0.3151113986968994,
-0.46316397190093994,
0.08613010495901108,
-0.10133948177099228,
0.5970228910446167,
0.6057336926460266,
-0.7852541208267212,
-0.3261551856994629,
0.010195599868893623,
-0.6577050089836121,
-0.01105929259210825,
-0.2626029849052429,
0.21388137340545654,
-0.14344415068626404,
0.4783417582511902,
-0.4818616211414337,
0.38756272196769714,
0.580547571182251,
-0.1235460489988327,
0.48342615365982056,
-0.30068761110305786,
-0.036956146359443665,
-0.37098681926727295,
-0.2550697326660156,
0.042224351316690445,
-0.38089433312416077,
-0.9706024527549744,
0.013792237266898155,
0.1925748735666275,
-0.22790436446666718,
-0.4714718461036682,
0.45983126759529114,
-0.6772214770317078,
-0.6881256103515625,
-0.3490361273288727,
0.29691413044929504,
0.06464505940675735,
0.4801819920539856,
0.24426649510860443,
0.5968592166900635,
0.7418398261070251,
-0.4483206570148468,
0.2929670214653015,
-0.06964094191789627,
-0.24139229953289032,
0.3706028163433075,
-0.7986354231834412,
0.48898816108703613,
0.07613404840230942,
0.020809683948755264,
-1.0914437770843506,
-0.25932013988494873,
0.0024006953462958336,
-0.44528406858444214,
0.595005989074707,
-0.2844234108924866,
-0.09413498640060425,
-0.2892248332500458,
0.01996004767715931,
0.28056639432907104,
0.47204914689064026,
-0.6107271909713745,
0.7960184812545776,
0.6919572949409485,
-0.08414364606142044,
-0.4962211549282074,
-0.9654605388641357,
-0.01444393303245306,
-0.04244903102517128,
-0.38686272501945496,
0.5301364064216614,
0.20611757040023804,
-0.0897362008690834,
0.010982728563249111,
-0.2566583752632141,
-0.11216574162244797,
0.05330337956547737,
0.31295740604400635,
-0.1270495504140854,
-0.2856844961643219,
0.30229631066322327,
-0.2876754105091095,
0.021404368802905083,
0.31029340624809265,
-0.25296908617019653,
0.5714055895805359,
-0.10968425869941711,
-0.6724818348884583,
-0.8831397294998169,
0.5752446055412292,
0.0841025561094284,
-0.5690456032752991,
0.48241010308265686,
0.6151950359344482,
-0.07537853717803955,
-0.21972109377384186,
-0.8549346923828125,
-0.1465684324502945,
-0.39544305205345154,
0.3541364073753357,
-0.7461762428283691,
-0.8169485926628113,
0.6823430061340332,
0.5359955430030823,
-0.1346861571073532,
0.6472212076187134,
0.3332011103630066,
-0.30606114864349365,
1.0545893907546997,
0.6694309711456299,
-0.07956893742084503,
0.35142970085144043,
-0.237457275390625,
-0.10233941674232483,
-0.9202625155448914,
-0.3907628357410431,
-0.530096709728241,
0.16861063241958618,
-0.4846707284450531,
-0.25650718808174133,
-0.10076795518398285,
0.036292705684900284,
-0.01693916693329811,
0.2828320860862732,
-0.4978416860103607,
0.30345359444618225,
0.8237017393112183,
0.059665173292160034,
0.028936320915818214,
-0.0005645022029057145,
0.020781012251973152,
-0.06668169796466827,
-0.7081501483917236,
-0.34927937388420105,
0.9411516189575195,
0.72744220495224,
0.7719348073005676,
-0.2895968556404114,
0.9051966071128845,
0.4741784632205963,
-0.6467998623847961,
-0.4677797555923462,
0.5577574968338013,
-0.07336889952421188,
-0.5606713891029358,
-0.3568640649318695,
-0.5036100745201111,
-0.7669916749000549,
0.41653215885162354,
-0.005586477927863598,
-0.7406851053237915,
0.3579109311103821,
0.18483038246631622,
-0.2701815664768219,
0.32390087842941284,
-0.6353143453598022,
0.847842276096344,
-0.28959181904792786,
-0.08145415782928467,
-0.4697514474391937,
-0.5425006151199341,
0.0647914856672287,
-0.0034296310041099787,
-0.007543927989900112,
-0.0860491394996643,
0.38660427927970886,
0.8900291323661804,
0.05137038230895996,
0.9605172276496887,
-0.28821080923080444,
-0.1738986074924469,
0.4403446912765503,
0.1893942803144455,
-0.06726142019033432,
-0.2048613280057907,
-0.2157244235277176,
0.3738851249217987,
0.1576455533504486,
-0.48615762591362,
-0.45465072989463806,
0.6050071716308594,
-0.8919420838356018,
-0.8275653719902039,
-0.1499069780111313,
-0.24831213057041168,
-0.22444136440753937,
-0.06237422674894333,
-0.009474528953433037,
0.8971490263938904,
-0.17435185611248016,
0.3240323066711426,
0.5668107867240906,
-0.18948602676391602,
0.38649308681488037,
0.3857804536819458,
-0.10097875446081161,
0.07581160217523575,
0.955755352973938,
0.4771648049354553,
0.6226291060447693,
0.39313799142837524,
0.1764920949935913,
-0.4280734658241272,
-0.7058118581771851,
-0.2474314272403717,
0.1639297753572464,
-1.0267730951309204,
0.22277891635894775,
-0.8076209425926208,
-0.804606556892395,
-0.8096598982810974,
0.5040989518165588,
-0.4439757764339447,
-0.5951308608055115,
-0.40911924839019775,
-0.2909906208515167,
-0.14477777481079102,
0.8736576437950134,
-0.3780052363872528,
0.18513964116573334,
-0.3972562551498413,
0.25792986154556274,
0.9342504143714905,
-0.028375692665576935,
0.1835351139307022,
-0.7716198563575745,
-0.17773501574993134,
0.030784159898757935,
-0.10903846472501755,
-1.0801628828048706,
0.2157866656780243,
0.608259916305542,
1.105709195137024,
0.333584189414978,
-0.12656442821025848,
0.6891911029815674,
-0.38441669940948486,
1.0808862447738647,
-0.10748890042304993,
-1.1520450115203857,
0.8908697962760925,
-0.1542268842458725,
0.1773490458726883,
0.24539443850517273,
0.31611448526382446,
-0.3072674870491028,
-0.5351189374923706,
-0.7821048498153687,
-0.2869742214679718,
0.7799308896064758,
0.1973385363817215,
0.5542633533477783,
0.05557286739349365,
0.2901722490787506,
0.24016925692558289,
-0.039374131709337234,
-0.8425313830375671,
-0.030052734538912773,
-0.7189810872077942,
0.06525211036205292,
-0.06784102320671082,
-0.4835985600948334,
-0.04697725921869278,
-0.08622875809669495,
0.3711724877357483,
-0.04661302641034126,
0.29080286622047424,
0.4577995538711548,
-0.08580399304628372,
0.15499483048915863,
0.3019278049468994,
0.07401033490896225,
0.5270288586616516,
-0.29009729623794556,
0.4571605324745178,
0.11385669559240341,
-0.0008902464178390801,
-0.273346871137619,
-0.0671771690249443,
0.3057994246482849,
-0.0204685777425766,
0.8615290522575378,
0.9987934827804565,
0.036709558218717575,
-0.42102012038230896,
0.5781765580177307,
0.20003820955753326,
-0.0759488120675087,
-0.22985659539699554,
0.3602895736694336,
-0.01431322656571865,
0.4701673090457916,
0.5129619836807251,
-0.13381949067115784,
0.4645485281944275,
-0.9052915573120117,
0.20893126726150513,
0.5664833784103394,
-0.6689683198928833,
-0.43149733543395996,
0.7157996892929077,
0.08127005398273468,
-0.30624422430992126,
0.5257635712623596,
-0.051434047520160675,
-0.4918287694454193,
0.519544243812561,
0.661790132522583,
0.7085456252098083,
-0.6615704894065857,
0.4428439140319824,
0.02523171529173851,
-0.08331090211868286,
0.3476448059082031,
0.04111285135149956,
-0.7445903420448303,
-0.6408848166465759,
-0.4479331374168396,
-0.504106342792511,
-0.4241572618484497,
0.06851989775896072,
-0.9534819722175598,
-0.25512465834617615,
-0.38067254424095154,
-0.12134315818548203,
0.2608979344367981,
-0.03107631579041481,
-0.7045375108718872,
0.34257450699806213,
0.5765334963798523,
0.6952220797538757,
-0.8812032341957092,
1.0380421876907349,
0.23163871467113495,
-0.2799833416938782,
-0.9918338060379028,
-0.2053472101688385,
0.0024183134082704782,
-0.7882922887802124,
0.9097142815589905,
0.25386136770248413,
-0.33485785126686096,
0.03837556764483452,
-0.4585464596748352,
-0.8130638003349304,
0.724756121635437,
0.46669718623161316,
-0.471622496843338,
-0.006933156866580248,
0.35653769969940186,
0.6100258231163025,
-0.7547215819358826,
0.42977985739707947,
0.3639289140701294,
-0.024347150698304176,
-0.004250338301062584,
-1.1417065858840942,
-0.28265106678009033,
-0.25360357761383057,
0.12559542059898376,
-0.576168954372406,
-0.42881259322166443,
0.9415720105171204,
-0.00046210974687710404,
-0.44393783807754517,
-0.19211873412132263,
0.8432568311691284,
0.03467749431729317,
0.1785237342119217,
0.5914726853370667,
0.14158613979816437,
0.7206522226333618,
0.05765165016055107,
1.146552562713623,
-0.21620719134807587,
0.2921961843967438,
1.3670873641967773,
-0.1475353091955185,
0.9088568091392517,
0.13121020793914795,
-0.05504485219717026,
0.3784131109714508,
0.6788347959518433,
-0.22123079001903534,
0.6770024299621582,
-0.0763077437877655,
0.22722390294075012,
-0.7829116582870483,
-0.25812387466430664,
-0.5609716176986694,
0.9407709240913391,
0.10713138431310654,
-0.39778074622154236,
0.019221890717744827,
0.32568860054016113,
-0.6102299690246582,
0.060084450989961624,
-0.4345944821834564,
0.8556260466575623,
0.26900526881217957,
-0.34735387563705444,
0.411482036113739,
-0.2987235486507416,
0.058919861912727356,
-0.4255746304988861,
0.1066632941365242,
0.11847273260354996,
-0.04921581223607063,
-0.2372649610042572,
-0.9235842823982239,
0.09771593660116196,
-0.295561820268631,
-0.10091788321733475,
-0.3460249602794647,
1.000272274017334,
-0.4185447692871094,
-0.21925799548625946,
0.7489423751831055,
0.6076797246932983,
0.45249828696250916,
-0.10625801235437393,
-0.7232468724250793,
-0.019851477816700935,
-0.0689791664481163,
-0.274659126996994,
0.23110730946063995,
0.3210287094116211,
0.3218386471271515,
0.7452870011329651,
0.3577912449836731,
0.395406574010849,
0.4252675771713257,
0.4984661340713501,
0.5038614869117737,
-0.7313123941421509,
-0.5218268632888794,
-0.741145133972168,
0.3588273823261261,
-0.32938307523727417,
-0.13733793795108795,
0.9244105815887451,
0.36508700251579285,
1.011484980583191,
-0.013472374528646469,
0.585391104221344,
0.3462366759777069,
0.7136839628219604,
-0.6672147512435913,
0.3096097409725189,
-0.524864912033081,
0.14486707746982574,
-0.22545771300792694,
-0.7879199981689453,
0.31896138191223145,
0.5886024236679077,
-0.39452359080314636,
0.1608201116323471,
0.15956944227218628,
0.3973812162876129,
-0.3501126170158386,
0.3115706443786621,
0.5728684663772583,
0.16173066198825836,
0.2475375384092331,
0.28642737865448,
1.2165292501449585,
-0.22851185500621796,
0.3906717002391815,
-0.49948564171791077,
0.14961428940296173,
-0.0783105120062828,
-0.4437732696533203,
-1.1480369567871094,
-0.8591538667678833,
-0.45091331005096436,
0.0769408568739891,
-0.04821157455444336,
0.5803279876708984,
1.3006376028060913,
-0.7739912271499634,
-0.31848466396331787,
0.29592275619506836,
-0.18707680702209473,
-0.3251752257347107,
-0.20666241645812988,
0.4147212505340576,
-0.4060916304588318,
-0.4916793406009674,
0.880770206451416,
0.29646044969558716,
0.055188294500112534,
-0.7222553491592407,
0.08186716586351395,
0.18344157934188843,
0.20467720925807953,
0.4218600392341614,
0.2946467399597168,
-0.9752674698829651,
-0.34859558939933777,
-0.3017015755176544,
-0.2566881477832794,
0.18052250146865845,
0.5238227844238281,
-0.8605436682701111,
0.5553696155548096,
0.460559606552124,
0.6439271569252014,
0.8305783867835999,
-0.028828909620642662,
0.4063793122768402,
-0.8686630129814148,
-0.01991979032754898,
0.11680532991886139,
0.30647894740104675,
0.4638536274433136,
-0.2886119782924652,
0.26866400241851807,
-0.10706433653831482,
-0.5442220568656921,
-0.7557922601699829,
0.3330196440219879,
-1.0816702842712402,
-0.36909613013267517,
0.933074951171875,
-0.2911212146282196,
-0.19821520149707794,
-0.05167683959007263,
-0.015403136610984802,
0.24138756096363068,
-0.1443503350019455,
0.5783716440200806,
0.5580308437347412,
-0.3549029231071472,
-0.50538569688797,
-0.681598961353302,
0.34669163823127747,
0.46910086274147034,
-0.3503471314907074,
-0.07116854935884476,
0.20058691501617432,
0.27595239877700806,
0.4169224500656128,
0.6127857565879822,
-0.11043250560760498,
0.22383099794387817,
-0.0280439630150795,
-0.2840504050254822,
-0.2668745815753937,
-0.5179511904716492,
-0.4506705403327942,
0.6213617920875549,
-0.1584080457687378,
-0.2597423195838928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17623v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17623v2 | Neighboring Perturbations of Knowledge Editing on Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T06:49:36 | 2024-05-27T03:52:43 | Jun-Yu Ma, Zhen-Hua Ling, Ningyu Zhang, Jia-Chen Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their exceptional capabilities, large language models (LLMs) are
prone to generating unintended text due to false or outdated knowledge. Given
the resource-intensive nature of retraining LLMs, there has been a notable
increase in the development of knowledge editing. However, current approaches
and evaluations rarely explore the perturbation of editing on neighboring
knowledge. This paper studies whether updating new knowledge to LLMs perturbs
the neighboring knowledge encapsulated within them. Specifically, we seek to
figure out whether appending a new answer into an answer list to a factual
question leads to catastrophic forgetting of original correct answers in this
list, as well as unintentional inclusion of incorrect answers. A metric of
additivity is introduced and a benchmark dubbed as Perturbation Evaluation of
Appending Knowledge (PEAK) is constructed to evaluate the degree of
perturbation to neighboring knowledge when appending new knowledge. Besides, a
plug-and-play framework termed Appending via Preservation and Prevention (APP)
is proposed to mitigate the neighboring perturbation by maintaining the
integrity of the answer list. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of APP
coupling with four editing methods on four LLMs. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/mjy1111/PEAK. | [
-0.40142303705215454,
-1.0487756729125977,
0.581044614315033,
-0.12395428121089935,
0.16883745789527893,
0.08859943598508835,
-0.2971422076225281,
-0.3136923611164093,
0.004832047503441572,
0.7513049840927124,
-0.3219330310821533,
-0.5212820172309875,
-0.4393174946308136,
-0.22985538840293884,
-0.2625752091407776,
1.1044965982437134,
-0.005235301796346903,
-0.2717409133911133,
-0.7599167823791504,
-0.32403993606567383,
-0.7804111242294312,
-0.9709919095039368,
-0.4392377734184265,
-0.34475237131118774,
0.42988139390945435,
0.7153528928756714,
0.8214125633239746,
0.7234712839126587,
0.3317469656467438,
0.31529003381729126,
-0.4139552712440491,
0.06998417526483536,
-0.6808733940124512,
0.2505035698413849,
-0.3150355815887451,
-0.7287826538085938,
-0.59874427318573,
-0.16773149371147156,
0.9175717830657959,
0.7695919871330261,
0.051374103873968124,
0.3829669654369354,
0.048440124839544296,
0.6173630952835083,
-0.6534567475318909,
-0.27243778109550476,
-1.0484015941619873,
-0.17649754881858826,
-0.11971335113048553,
-0.206412672996521,
-0.25706422328948975,
-0.42794060707092285,
0.06757863610982895,
-0.195797398686409,
0.1747771054506302,
-0.20507340133190155,
0.6492058038711548,
0.3370990455150604,
-0.006019994616508484,
-0.14028629660606384,
-0.651283323764801,
0.5955104231834412,
-0.7207902073860168,
0.3127862215042114,
0.3171159327030182,
-0.09827939420938492,
-0.45792844891548157,
-0.28313907980918884,
-0.7225059866905212,
-0.14069566130638123,
0.14615878462791443,
-0.052436713129282,
-0.19382795691490173,
-0.06764122098684311,
0.4250592291355133,
0.4116911292076111,
-0.18147572875022888,
0.28390949964523315,
-0.16415157914161682,
-0.20641782879829407,
0.5192171335220337,
0.37953439354896545,
0.3679124414920807,
-0.03305119276046753,
-0.27339717745780945,
-0.02866099216043949,
-1.2069083452224731,
0.1879805475473404,
0.5646826028823853,
0.09989681094884872,
0.12318569421768188,
0.7186141014099121,
0.02032482624053955,
0.5728811025619507,
0.1585017442703247,
-0.05925050005316734,
0.15581613779067993,
-0.4848311245441437,
0.07491113990545273,
-0.029160095378756523,
0.5736730098724365,
0.6009407639503479,
0.2688045799732208,
0.00769567908719182,
-0.16673262417316437,
-0.21650123596191406,
0.053511928766965866,
-0.47409364581108093,
-0.3959946036338806,
0.09816388040781021,
-0.22762876749038696,
-0.33344265818595886,
-0.37493371963500977,
-0.3262677788734436,
-0.6013139486312866,
-0.061049964278936386,
0.5908611416816711,
-0.545176088809967,
0.007592061068862677,
-0.011340465396642685,
0.06268146634101868,
-0.3034711182117462,
0.3503517806529999,
-0.7190943956375122,
0.31332823634147644,
0.6097010970115662,
0.6450830101966858,
0.19327273964881897,
-0.766699492931366,
-0.6276905536651611,
0.2887842357158661,
-0.3683195412158966,
0.906245231628418,
-0.5462900996208191,
-0.46978136897087097,
-0.06883563846349716,
-0.1655159443616867,
-0.010583028197288513,
-0.7297701239585876,
0.25899064540863037,
-0.763118326663971,
0.046244435012340546,
-0.5410682559013367,
-0.7311490774154663,
-0.23437723517417908,
0.4609221816062927,
-0.46720924973487854,
0.8694761991500854,
-0.032765138894319534,
-0.9465658068656921,
0.11305104941129684,
-0.3630478084087372,
-0.49258697032928467,
-0.3314579129219055,
0.10038290917873383,
-0.4965061843395233,
0.1909039467573166,
0.2500097453594208,
0.27376648783683777,
0.03187170624732971,
0.08757498860359192,
-0.41978368163108826,
-0.418386310338974,
0.5273112058639526,
-0.2844406068325043,
0.6030001044273376,
-0.22635842859745026,
0.2546100914478302,
0.29692405462265015,
-0.6589888334274292,
-0.3306671679019928,
-0.04686493054032326,
-0.48302769660949707,
-0.7098923921585083,
-0.06434530019760132,
-0.6270402669906616,
0.12219976633787155,
0.4093591570854187,
-0.5734388828277588,
0.42052286863327026,
-0.18595407903194427,
0.043021392077207565,
1.0541822910308838,
0.6571587324142456,
0.3008307218551636,
-0.7796648144721985,
0.531156063079834,
0.01949484832584858,
0.15464720129966736,
-0.23087438941001892,
-0.4105248749256134,
-0.5404826998710632,
0.2697122395038605,
0.12730495631694794,
0.5913015007972717,
-0.6034130454063416,
0.09322457015514374,
-0.39735302329063416,
-0.5083556771278381,
-0.18389640748500824,
0.33508777618408203,
0.33247891068458557,
0.7078953981399536,
0.4119948148727417,
-0.09019381552934647,
-0.5864037871360779,
-0.6264063715934753,
-0.40302804112434387,
-0.28864529728889465,
0.1305484175682068,
0.3700841963291168,
0.36048710346221924,
-0.2899565100669861,
0.9345666170120239,
-0.5551325678825378,
-0.2918239235877991,
0.07608238607645035,
-0.36028575897216797,
0.3511027693748474,
0.3808666467666626,
0.5935824513435364,
-0.3144795000553131,
-0.44740384817123413,
-0.16838142275810242,
-0.5188635587692261,
-0.22795869410037994,
-0.052632689476013184,
-0.04546424746513367,
-0.038431551307439804,
0.4634539484977722,
-0.35881346464157104,
0.17547591030597687,
0.67863529920578,
-0.11017812043428421,
1.1264599561691284,
-0.28506985306739807,
0.1623278111219406,
-1.032435417175293,
-0.1250818371772766,
-0.35109326243400574,
-0.038872621953487396,
-0.6726620197296143,
0.09475629776716232,
-0.03871706500649452,
0.29848429560661316,
-0.3397710621356964,
0.46041667461395264,
-0.2520957291126251,
-0.054012689739465714,
-0.14896762371063232,
0.29737088084220886,
-0.14204873144626617,
0.1900547444820404,
-0.07870910316705704,
0.8222730755805969,
0.27430111169815063,
-0.7113852500915527,
0.4982934296131134,
0.5576488971710205,
-0.1338234692811966,
0.36760464310646057,
-0.3090365529060364,
0.3071897625923157,
-0.12875574827194214,
0.05339433625340462,
-0.7633336782455444,
0.06688796728849411,
-0.08682914823293686,
-0.6172873377799988,
0.2095640003681183,
-0.35345953702926636,
-0.46028754115104675,
-0.1412048041820526,
-0.7729628086090088,
0.34789741039276123,
0.08098875731229782,
-0.5183379650115967,
0.1645662784576416,
0.4842395782470703,
-0.2905891239643097,
-0.6263643503189087,
-0.67870032787323,
0.14990848302841187,
-0.23142310976982117,
-0.6443918347358704,
0.24729493260383606,
-0.22370858490467072,
-0.4506586492061615,
0.38749998807907104,
-0.007107662037014961,
0.1840471774339676,
0.03320259973406792,
0.02673484943807125,
0.31423816084861755,
-0.10720638930797577,
0.3403642773628235,
0.134543314576149,
-0.006090265233069658,
0.08819238096475601,
-0.1361791342496872,
0.4175257384777069,
0.04133830964565277,
-0.357259064912796,
-0.18770459294319153,
0.07293317466974258,
0.6950653195381165,
-0.2745398283004761,
0.8288699984550476,
0.26908060908317566,
-0.42905569076538086,
0.10562141984701157,
-0.8933842182159424,
-0.13058409094810486,
-0.4953146278858185,
0.6809264421463013,
-0.6597532033920288,
-1.0564476251602173,
0.890704333782196,
0.08833302557468414,
0.08685903996229172,
0.3935030996799469,
0.4321363866329193,
-0.0016657216474413872,
0.6175738573074341,
0.5686529874801636,
-0.2740453779697418,
0.4825282394886017,
-0.09992468357086182,
0.01762973703444004,
-1.3429359197616577,
-0.00039325180114246905,
-0.39776837825775146,
-0.113844133913517,
-0.40816107392311096,
-0.4736795723438263,
0.5059446096420288,
0.19684648513793945,
-0.2339053750038147,
0.26019829511642456,
-0.17828339338302612,
0.5049052238464355,
0.3465210497379303,
0.11192166060209274,
0.546290934085846,
-0.01105518825352192,
-0.305923730134964,
-0.15431064367294312,
-1.0202786922454834,
-0.3917829096317291,
1.3351398706436157,
0.3230332136154175,
0.7518259882926941,
0.2830997705459595,
0.6750146746635437,
0.2603762447834015,
0.3105621635913849,
-0.560834527015686,
0.5141642689704895,
-0.21556121110916138,
-0.4461061656475067,
-0.42236512899398804,
-0.4875850975513458,
-0.48128408193588257,
0.022993387654423714,
-0.3775217831134796,
-1.0213255882263184,
0.17442458868026733,
0.3688346743583679,
-0.5208677649497986,
0.7601951360702515,
-0.5623037815093994,
0.6343082785606384,
-0.028670283034443855,
-0.7126145362854004,
-0.31171301007270813,
-0.3048717677593231,
0.3506046533584595,
-0.1163988932967186,
0.46600937843322754,
0.07077711075544357,
0.04040321335196495,
0.6524761319160461,
-0.4301213026046753,
0.6475532650947571,
-0.22714532911777496,
-0.3039191961288452,
0.467081755399704,
0.4153152108192444,
0.7706735730171204,
0.1907568722963333,
-0.2852303981781006,
-0.04475550726056099,
0.06468825042247772,
-0.26639360189437866,
-0.6755003333091736,
1.050687313079834,
-0.7015117406845093,
-0.8076745271682739,
-0.09604798257350922,
-0.6239573955535889,
-0.5132144689559937,
0.08240927755832672,
0.24656006693840027,
0.5590529441833496,
0.14008471369743347,
0.0884854719042778,
0.8165392875671387,
-0.5279137492179871,
0.2129843682050705,
0.4938996434211731,
-0.3949390947818756,
-0.4916178286075592,
0.9356080293655396,
0.4799669682979584,
0.48379620909690857,
0.34438228607177734,
0.3827681541442871,
-0.11685946583747864,
-0.8225226998329163,
-0.28549450635910034,
0.29729411005973816,
-0.7817660570144653,
-0.1352420449256897,
-0.6755629181861877,
-0.18048527836799622,
-0.3558522164821625,
-0.17801716923713684,
-0.4120369255542755,
-0.3193383514881134,
-0.027805091813206673,
-0.03484632819890976,
0.45309749245643616,
0.8726040124893188,
-0.32447776198387146,
0.033255625516176224,
-0.9931985139846802,
-0.10210540890693665,
0.3187324106693268,
0.5633296966552734,
0.3587573766708374,
-0.6540678143501282,
-0.5180616974830627,
0.054373372346162796,
-0.10352516174316406,
-0.8755462765693665,
-0.2770829498767853,
-0.006242536008358002,
0.5577945113182068,
0.23459821939468384,
0.16568729281425476,
0.9267621636390686,
-0.5609018206596375,
0.7410035133361816,
-0.04318036139011383,
-0.8538525104522705,
0.37679198384284973,
-0.45478323101997375,
0.6839795112609863,
0.5426439046859741,
0.16823552548885345,
-0.8894791603088379,
-0.5620055198669434,
-0.4649643898010254,
-0.6333793997764587,
0.44603174924850464,
-0.33747419714927673,
0.426168292760849,
0.11330185830593109,
0.6791987419128418,
0.06547689437866211,
0.1616828590631485,
-0.4890308380126953,
-0.20021168887615204,
0.20081155002117157,
0.27690747380256653,
0.03082873858511448,
-0.8530305027961731,
0.15149235725402832,
-0.360305517911911,
0.8769525289535522,
0.22721850872039795,
0.009035021997988224,
0.23904331028461456,
-0.21645134687423706,
-0.33224940299987793,
0.21695289015769958,
0.6050744652748108,
0.5992016792297363,
-0.11595681309700012,
0.15793445706367493,
0.7058345079421997,
-0.48086100816726685,
0.04176108539104462,
-0.26708322763442993,
-0.29341429471969604,
-0.30467888712882996,
0.6472746729850769,
0.4763568043708801,
0.08884800225496292,
-0.4880356192588806,
0.3078056573867798,
-0.03414219990372658,
-0.06924284249544144,
-0.3102729916572571,
0.03754431754350662,
0.05571288987994194,
0.10064823180437088,
0.2808469533920288,
0.25764191150665283,
-0.08854024112224579,
-0.6346784830093384,
0.28573688864707947,
0.44246119260787964,
-0.40651124715805054,
-0.4603729844093323,
0.4886834919452667,
-0.18436495959758759,
-0.3635217845439911,
0.3872162997722626,
-0.07653104513883591,
-1.0580122470855713,
0.13669906556606293,
0.49282121658325195,
0.4711357355117798,
-0.5193909406661987,
-0.2935975193977356,
0.3881014585494995,
0.5794537663459778,
0.525277316570282,
0.04236917570233345,
-0.011365145444869995,
-1.05439293384552,
-0.6204131245613098,
-0.4179688096046448,
-0.4135932922363281,
0.46938005089759827,
-0.2488521933555603,
0.21465949714183807,
-0.5473543405532837,
-0.15017719566822052,
-0.365368127822876,
-0.0027812356129288673,
-0.27284958958625793,
0.095577172935009,
-0.2300785779953003,
0.5619673132896423,
-0.8002216219902039,
0.6689698100090027,
0.955620527267456,
-0.2367253452539444,
-0.7164660096168518,
0.2983434796333313,
0.03533962368965149,
-0.3206453323364258,
0.03207753226161003,
-0.22409768402576447,
-0.21978817880153656,
-0.15101279318332672,
-0.2979041039943695,
-0.9933069348335266,
0.5185868740081787,
0.3059100806713104,
-0.49130937457084656,
0.18404731154441833,
0.034656647592782974,
0.4949387311935425,
0.03712301328778267,
-0.03853764757514,
0.5639758110046387,
0.29144540429115295,
0.032577645033597946,
-1.010706901550293,
0.22396081686019897,
-0.1863619089126587,
-0.19783638417720795,
0.07987501472234726,
-0.6557780504226685,
0.874737560749054,
-0.5026696920394897,
0.11587981134653091,
0.08453352004289627,
0.17029744386672974,
-0.04414798319339752,
-0.12095115333795547,
0.4143594205379486,
0.6756649017333984,
0.6348215341567993,
0.23110951483249664,
0.8053621053695679,
-0.2033400982618332,
0.24663718044757843,
1.5347635746002197,
-0.19474373757839203,
0.7938432097434998,
0.48445528745651245,
-0.3607146143913269,
0.5123423337936401,
0.4120335578918457,
0.11938042938709259,
0.18796811997890472,
0.2519725561141968,
-0.37043318152427673,
-0.020930122584104538,
-0.052421294152736664,
-0.4669303297996521,
0.44990620017051697,
0.366324245929718,
-0.026130815967917442,
-0.054824262857437134,
0.006907347589731216,
0.4315156936645508,
0.4208019971847534,
-0.21072830259799957,
0.8987293243408203,
-0.23431117832660675,
-0.6082804799079895,
0.6258311867713928,
-0.03193255513906479,
0.4020450711250305,
-0.15881787240505219,
-0.015278797596693039,
-0.22801101207733154,
0.2895362973213196,
-0.43763411045074463,
-0.9361100792884827,
0.5079602003097534,
0.024886002764105797,
-0.4274129867553711,
0.19004854559898376,
0.6672654151916504,
-0.44095614552497864,
-0.1860446035861969,
0.37741196155548096,
0.3059402406215668,
-0.19380654394626617,
-0.10777076333761215,
-0.26742514967918396,
0.11648351699113846,
0.16986338794231415,
-0.19687898457050323,
0.37475597858428955,
0.3437696397304535,
-0.0718669667840004,
0.6183285713195801,
0.7739378213882446,
0.35320305824279785,
0.18007171154022217,
-0.029023706912994385,
1.1860578060150146,
-0.3256721496582031,
-0.3265059292316437,
-1.0004777908325195,
0.40767228603363037,
-0.023789098486304283,
-0.07844952493906021,
1.031007170677185,
0.6164560914039612,
0.8313221335411072,
0.08650059998035431,
0.8454890251159668,
0.163062185049057,
0.5697810053825378,
-0.477194607257843,
0.8251179456710815,
-0.3909434974193573,
0.7535236477851868,
-0.6489051580429077,
-1.15971040725708,
-0.46510177850723267,
0.18389961123466492,
-0.756022036075592,
-0.22317209839820862,
0.584655225276947,
0.6559842824935913,
0.2375102937221527,
-0.18255935609340668,
0.36950400471687317,
0.6423715949058533,
0.21950937807559967,
0.5751969814300537,
0.9999409317970276,
-0.30617645382881165,
0.45791906118392944,
-0.5245715379714966,
-0.3937312960624695,
-0.033847760409116745,
-0.7090763449668884,
-0.8595201373100281,
-0.49361541867256165,
-0.3505665361881256,
-0.39625731110572815,
0.3549095392227173,
0.6806185245513916,
0.21089650690555573,
-0.7712028622627258,
-0.2654709815979004,
0.16032856702804565,
0.5022256374359131,
-0.10105035454034805,
-0.1894809603691101,
0.4096677899360657,
-0.16317589581012726,
-0.298165500164032,
0.4118417799472809,
0.1714649200439453,
-0.11711734533309937,
-0.1502012014389038,
0.10180345922708511,
-0.4653473496437073,
-0.07382380217313766,
0.5275318026542664,
0.12150992453098297,
-0.25574731826782227,
-0.6469056010246277,
-0.09007121622562408,
0.45195066928863525,
-0.016626963391900063,
0.4841586947441101,
-0.8374693393707275,
0.6555726528167725,
0.38850343227386475,
0.5900058150291443,
0.3359662592411041,
0.15496240556240082,
0.5721412301063538,
-0.8308987617492676,
0.07238592952489853,
0.05965558812022209,
0.3342185616493225,
0.5048486590385437,
-0.5035173892974854,
0.0776994526386261,
0.30474624037742615,
-0.7012255787849426,
-0.8477166295051575,
0.28042784333229065,
-0.09558562189340591,
-0.0629119873046875,
0.9771577715873718,
-0.2367788553237915,
-0.1167360246181488,
0.012334953062236309,
-0.180572971701622,
0.21475574374198914,
-0.1420498937368393,
0.7830376625061035,
0.9141769409179688,
-0.12629662454128265,
0.001842416706494987,
-0.2619287073612213,
0.4050019383430481,
0.37143492698669434,
-0.4344455599784851,
0.251604825258255,
0.7107807993888855,
0.5505219101905823,
0.05915606766939163,
0.4196487069129944,
-0.08536823838949203,
0.3713412582874298,
0.054525427520275116,
-0.10090368241071701,
-0.27410486340522766,
-0.2805625796318054,
-0.41029322147369385,
0.1694188416004181,
0.5858545899391174,
-0.026893779635429382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17602v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17602v1 | Assertion Detection Large Language Model In-context Learning LoRA Fine-tuning | 2024-01-31T05:11:00 | 2024-01-31T05:11:00 | Yuelyu Ji, Zeshui Yu, Yanshan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we aim to address the task of assertion detection when
extracting medical concepts from clinical notes, a key process in clinical
natural language processing (NLP). Assertion detection in clinical NLP usually
involves identifying assertion types for medical concepts in the clinical text,
namely certainty (whether the medical concept is positive, negated, possible,
or hypothetical), temporality (whether the medical concept is for present or
the past history), and experiencer (whether the medical concept is described
for the patient or a family member). These assertion types are essential for
healthcare professionals to quickly and clearly understand the context of
medical conditions from unstructured clinical texts, directly influencing the
quality and outcomes of patient care. Although widely used, traditional
methods, particularly rule-based NLP systems and machine learning or deep
learning models, demand intensive manual efforts to create patterns and tend to
overlook less common assertion types, leading to an incomplete understanding of
the context. To address this challenge, our research introduces a novel
methodology that utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) pre-trained on a vast
array of medical data for assertion detection. We enhanced the current method
with advanced reasoning techniques, including Tree of Thought (ToT), Chain of
Thought (CoT), and Self-Consistency (SC), and refine it further with Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) fine-tuning. We first evaluated the model on the i2b2 2010
assertion dataset. Our method achieved a micro-averaged F-1 of 0.89, with 0.11
improvements over the previous works. To further assess the generalizability of
our approach, we extended our evaluation to a local dataset that focused on
sleep concept extraction. Our approach achieved an F-1 of 0.74, which is 0.31
higher than the previous method. | [
-0.01111172791570425,
-1.1055511236190796,
0.9264931082725525,
0.20533083379268646,
-0.25369325280189514,
-0.10642100125551224,
-0.3455980122089386,
-0.7186560034751892,
0.2149890661239624,
0.4465501606464386,
-0.396055668592453,
-0.691973865032196,
-0.70057612657547,
0.09510787576436996,
-0.24306821823120117,
0.8525097966194153,
-0.2613760530948639,
-0.048299167305231094,
-0.158025860786438,
-0.044996071606874466,
-0.6123055219650269,
-0.283886581659317,
-0.70736163854599,
-0.334077388048172,
0.21656589210033417,
0.4317688047885895,
0.25480255484580994,
0.41998186707496643,
0.6448788046836853,
0.2523576319217682,
-0.14600269496440887,
0.37668776512145996,
-0.08665990084409714,
0.19096755981445312,
-0.1213688850402832,
-0.46095967292785645,
-0.6528909206390381,
-0.255592942237854,
0.6042189002037048,
0.5556111931800842,
-0.18553507328033447,
0.34676995873451233,
-0.033302370458841324,
0.5388836860656738,
-0.7338426113128662,
0.11442393064498901,
-0.7317140102386475,
0.21356941759586334,
-0.17296259105205536,
-0.24101682007312775,
-0.488878458738327,
-0.3576172888278961,
0.2395009845495224,
-0.25525963306427,
0.11833584308624268,
-0.10476228594779968,
1.1431220769882202,
0.5834267735481262,
-0.4006047546863556,
-0.47037723660469055,
-0.5515201687812805,
0.6080113649368286,
-1.0999025106430054,
0.1865161508321762,
0.5573956966400146,
0.26404985785484314,
-0.13711602985858917,
-0.6765761375427246,
-0.7176172137260437,
-0.3763708174228668,
-0.18081635236740112,
0.07068534940481186,
-0.22829534113407135,
0.06649164110422134,
0.26032817363739014,
0.41657009720802307,
-0.5093132853507996,
0.5535788536071777,
-0.04500479996204376,
-0.2110743671655655,
0.45809879899024963,
0.08309906721115112,
0.3255246579647064,
-0.38261494040489197,
-0.352217435836792,
0.3349047005176544,
-0.7035074830055237,
0.048255596309900284,
-0.40886834263801575,
0.13513071835041046,
-0.31829360127449036,
0.5530092716217041,
-0.40719127655029297,
0.629833459854126,
0.18285374343395233,
-0.5429779887199402,
0.30762773752212524,
-0.280699759721756,
-0.4217115640640259,
0.3312540352344513,
0.8066251873970032,
0.20285451412200928,
-0.23156994581222534,
-0.07584185153245926,
-0.19986771047115326,
0.32903429865837097,
0.012365457601845264,
-0.7399510741233826,
0.15982463955879211,
0.5916633605957031,
-0.5992397665977478,
-0.41029253602027893,
-0.2218329906463623,
-0.622636616230011,
-0.5722920894622803,
-0.36815547943115234,
0.5342300534248352,
-0.575864851474762,
-0.1689079850912094,
0.3667459785938263,
0.2190384715795517,
0.4639456272125244,
0.42991939187049866,
-0.6390512585639954,
0.1499471217393875,
0.6548861861228943,
0.7163915634155273,
-0.40207943320274353,
0.0954262986779213,
-0.6210014224052429,
0.07817396521568298,
-0.397935152053833,
0.8390200734138489,
-0.3050277531147003,
-0.168148934841156,
-0.05906428396701813,
0.1726834774017334,
-0.2544640004634857,
-0.6673510074615479,
0.963519275188446,
-0.1579125076532364,
0.18607497215270996,
-0.031092291697859764,
-0.8630725741386414,
0.00847279466688633,
0.4891206920146942,
-0.3112148344516754,
0.7215091586112976,
0.1961337924003601,
-0.5650654435157776,
0.38865697383880615,
-0.828758716583252,
-0.44548192620277405,
0.03864303231239319,
-0.47789859771728516,
-0.7115678787231445,
0.30230581760406494,
0.37431225180625916,
0.6133823990821838,
-0.4213906228542328,
0.4177451431751251,
-0.19633597135543823,
-0.07252518087625504,
0.4698539078235626,
-0.2702469527721405,
0.7185536026954651,
0.34030547738075256,
-0.505720317363739,
0.09634829312562943,
-0.8219936490058899,
0.20595508813858032,
0.2583896219730377,
-0.15144068002700806,
-0.3290601074695587,
0.07774046808481216,
-0.40062010288238525,
0.23279595375061035,
0.23730485141277313,
-0.710474967956543,
0.3357926905155182,
-0.4279443323612213,
0.3595368564128876,
0.4783306121826172,
0.32283446192741394,
-0.194255992770195,
-0.32222458720207214,
0.49739590287208557,
0.05040246620774269,
0.08158461004495621,
-0.21217744052410126,
-0.3019762635231018,
-0.8231044411659241,
-0.4550720155239105,
0.3763298988342285,
0.541045606136322,
-0.505443811416626,
0.8640792965888977,
-0.38499537110328674,
-0.17253167927265167,
-0.6329416632652283,
0.01899433322250843,
0.5588531494140625,
0.9326804280281067,
0.48318466544151306,
-0.04799790680408478,
-0.5597890019416809,
-0.8219925761222839,
-0.15140840411186218,
-0.04623020812869072,
0.12613226473331451,
0.030485592782497406,
0.6013819575309753,
-0.590804398059845,
0.8401668667793274,
-0.7131729125976562,
-0.531175434589386,
-0.1724122315645218,
0.13840247690677643,
0.2724246084690094,
0.5248367190361023,
0.45173490047454834,
-0.558894157409668,
-0.35280588269233704,
0.14105628430843353,
-1.011175274848938,
-0.07726982980966568,
-0.19260193407535553,
0.21663139760494232,
0.35164520144462585,
0.7211225628852844,
-0.4398157596588135,
0.5744460225105286,
0.39876246452331543,
-0.5936045050621033,
0.5588467121124268,
-0.24478453397750854,
-0.04981321096420288,
-1.1951104402542114,
-0.07866431772708893,
-0.04775542393326759,
-0.18083472549915314,
-0.41714024543762207,
0.22027242183685303,
0.08935271948575974,
0.2304009050130844,
-0.1457156538963318,
0.4645165205001831,
-0.23674912750720978,
0.2695121467113495,
-0.24137353897094727,
0.01748676784336567,
0.04523181915283203,
0.2112489938735962,
0.05793195962905884,
0.4201870262622833,
0.5390307903289795,
-0.6053841710090637,
-0.23098857700824738,
0.3647284507751465,
-0.6506120562553406,
0.6187610030174255,
-0.6796271204948425,
0.13922925293445587,
0.053004514425992966,
0.24484331905841827,
-1.012711524963379,
-0.2740045487880707,
-0.024256736040115356,
-0.5000123977661133,
0.27175334095954895,
-0.15597224235534668,
-0.4367114305496216,
-0.35230162739753723,
0.11848053336143494,
0.11246667057275772,
0.3788374364376068,
-0.5277889966964722,
0.556966245174408,
0.28577721118927,
-0.21848897635936737,
-0.5825418829917908,
-0.6315186619758606,
-0.014928251504898071,
-0.22350628674030304,
-0.3907105028629303,
0.417558878660202,
0.0570882111787796,
-0.3828819990158081,
-0.23629671335220337,
-0.3095611035823822,
-0.21857936680316925,
0.25193795561790466,
0.23516899347305298,
0.5245962142944336,
-0.5579543709754944,
0.2901478707790375,
0.3996388018131256,
-0.06713983416557312,
0.15177412331104279,
-0.16082517802715302,
0.4862358570098877,
-0.2847234308719635,
-0.5162877440452576,
-0.8351756930351257,
0.1778203397989273,
0.5274152755737305,
-0.2743186950683594,
0.6706364750862122,
0.7624960541725159,
-0.6587818264961243,
-0.19785483181476593,
-0.7199730277061462,
-0.05302845314145088,
-0.4232099950313568,
0.34153369069099426,
-0.2916773557662964,
-0.8669584393501282,
0.4858311712741852,
-0.241119384765625,
-0.046592190861701965,
0.6124668717384338,
0.5806844830513,
-0.2758391201496124,
0.8982939720153809,
0.46943750977516174,
-0.019764378666877747,
0.21643000841140747,
-0.2902407944202423,
0.24778562784194946,
-0.9685887694358826,
0.0418875627219677,
-0.5995306372642517,
-0.19917678833007812,
-0.44845032691955566,
-0.47552457451820374,
0.4452366828918457,
0.1904086470603943,
-0.16865962743759155,
-0.13675393164157867,
-0.5410669445991516,
0.4109140634536743,
-0.07549020648002625,
0.4156055748462677,
0.463432639837265,
-0.13831563293933868,
-0.1354513019323349,
0.04424196854233742,
-0.25597184896469116,
-0.40051865577697754,
1.1127640008926392,
0.4468763768672943,
0.30008184909820557,
0.28719615936279297,
0.8636247515678406,
0.4238830506801605,
0.535452127456665,
-1.0228601694107056,
0.4848259389400482,
-0.23660869896411896,
-0.3527192771434784,
-0.22123610973358154,
-0.36449000239372253,
-1.0707783699035645,
0.19277328252792358,
-0.39266180992126465,
-1.0644465684890747,
0.13033007085323334,
0.08526603132486343,
-0.822467029094696,
0.1545722335577011,
-0.6537593007087708,
0.7970960736274719,
-0.31300508975982666,
-0.06347793340682983,
-0.22252137959003448,
-0.58339524269104,
0.46907588839530945,
-0.22014875710010529,
0.04248642921447754,
-0.16971474885940552,
0.12320748716592789,
0.6390893459320068,
-0.33694925904273987,
0.8922346234321594,
-0.17692454159259796,
-0.45066022872924805,
0.34778282046318054,
0.022318774834275246,
0.6165233254432678,
0.09651589393615723,
-0.04520333185791969,
0.10460332781076431,
0.13766075670719147,
-0.3358956575393677,
-0.4828137159347534,
0.44461631774902344,
-0.5548484921455383,
-0.4905385673046112,
-0.3399434983730316,
-0.35579657554626465,
-0.5001710057258606,
0.29670003056526184,
0.3558911085128784,
0.4180544912815094,
-0.3688412606716156,
0.31958404183387756,
0.8603456020355225,
-0.4516356289386749,
0.246747687458992,
0.7512839436531067,
-0.3491533696651459,
-0.15592466294765472,
0.7345237135887146,
-0.12863145768642426,
0.3454703390598297,
0.5720009207725525,
0.6763615608215332,
-0.2736847400665283,
-0.9577417969703674,
0.013463035225868225,
0.28732171654701233,
-0.5566680431365967,
-0.21935772895812988,
-0.6452089548110962,
-0.14565123617649078,
-0.507295548915863,
-0.060927946120500565,
-0.2929931879043579,
-0.42085790634155273,
-0.03600636497139931,
-0.16798852384090424,
0.2165503352880478,
0.4087624251842499,
0.26578620076179504,
0.4163263142108917,
-0.7183337211608887,
0.6424860954284668,
0.07324061542749405,
0.1290382295846939,
-0.23135870695114136,
-0.7025675773620605,
-0.013323095627129078,
-0.06431152671575546,
-0.31146737933158875,
-0.5501390099525452,
0.3927421569824219,
0.08822707086801529,
0.4374469816684723,
0.8206357955932617,
0.08164265751838684,
0.6840664744377136,
-0.24578142166137695,
0.5719558596611023,
0.29634997248649597,
-0.9548211693763733,
0.8040629029273987,
-0.35101985931396484,
0.047960806638002396,
0.5861569046974182,
0.17828120291233063,
-0.40625306963920593,
-0.1499641239643097,
-0.7549487948417664,
-0.6137056350708008,
0.22237937152385712,
-0.10683565586805344,
-0.39557957649230957,
-0.03855212405323982,
0.6031857132911682,
0.11269407719373703,
0.04646247997879982,
-0.661846935749054,
-0.08734619617462158,
0.24899519979953766,
-0.45844486355781555,
-0.15034238994121552,
-0.17912693321704865,
-0.33795657753944397,
-0.5058750510215759,
0.3473625183105469,
-0.5229120850563049,
0.37769708037376404,
0.5348768830299377,
-0.24682265520095825,
-0.06978955119848251,
0.5573082566261292,
0.7932483553886414,
0.8184812068939209,
-0.34503230452537537,
0.044095516204833984,
0.21812696754932404,
-0.4452320337295532,
0.04793772101402283,
0.1783437281847,
-0.3229186534881592,
0.08055043965578079,
0.4471573829650879,
0.80128413438797,
0.042780276387929916,
-0.7380356788635254,
0.596548855304718,
0.04866843298077583,
-0.08787122368812561,
-0.5553444027900696,
0.05644633248448372,
-0.05092695355415344,
0.14910610020160675,
0.07875803858041763,
0.10194899886846542,
0.06817571073770523,
-0.5387083888053894,
0.23216868937015533,
0.5662272572517395,
-0.5457000732421875,
-0.2703261375427246,
0.42786291241645813,
-0.20940522849559784,
-0.19724321365356445,
0.3505770266056061,
-0.18203437328338623,
-0.35553839802742004,
0.7303941249847412,
0.8354479670524597,
0.9666197896003723,
-0.20878660678863525,
0.2115040272474289,
0.3879716396331787,
0.12308869510889053,
-0.09552861005067825,
0.3847343623638153,
0.20576386153697968,
-0.9105221629142761,
-0.5930787324905396,
-0.5477375388145447,
-0.29388418793678284,
0.4651210308074951,
-0.820314884185791,
0.15853707492351532,
-0.4455736577510834,
-0.18182770907878876,
0.20961783826351166,
0.08088205009698868,
-0.5293692946434021,
0.26345616579055786,
0.24915790557861328,
0.7496041655540466,
-0.6919490694999695,
1.0347565412521362,
0.43198785185813904,
-0.31296199560165405,
-0.7826806902885437,
0.2577848732471466,
0.17058958113193512,
-0.9147346615791321,
0.5488865971565247,
0.19972454011440277,
-0.16488873958587646,
-0.24312196671962738,
-0.6659547090530396,
-0.642536461353302,
1.0434651374816895,
0.26144078373908997,
-0.4961974322795868,
-0.10546188801527023,
-0.07416606694459915,
0.6924211978912354,
-0.6197691559791565,
-0.07985905557870865,
0.7153441905975342,
0.36475518345832825,
-0.09879354387521744,
-0.9981635212898254,
0.3061154782772064,
0.11996699124574661,
-0.4827965497970581,
0.19162888824939728,
-0.4495518207550049,
0.661710798740387,
-0.5434367060661316,
-0.03594254329800606,
0.2024218589067459,
0.5893668532371521,
0.3849966526031494,
0.5244706273078918,
0.5423317551612854,
0.5945268273353577,
1.2779654264450073,
-0.02097056619822979,
1.1695054769515991,
-0.10537412762641907,
0.2832172214984894,
1.4776986837387085,
-0.3765353262424469,
1.0022540092468262,
0.437523752450943,
-0.05713875964283943,
0.7354598641395569,
0.43524277210235596,
0.2108386904001236,
0.242044135928154,
0.024410083889961243,
-0.20894604921340942,
-0.26105281710624695,
-0.2118283063173294,
-0.46574893593788147,
0.7319090366363525,
0.9986885190010071,
-0.5652472972869873,
-0.00014245013881009072,
-0.10694662481546402,
0.1966625303030014,
-0.13930745422840118,
-0.28959017992019653,
0.9426286816596985,
0.10508796572685242,
-0.9254762530326843,
0.9765844941139221,
-0.22158187627792358,
0.4570755064487457,
-0.7422761917114258,
-0.022865237668156624,
-0.014396429061889648,
0.5227161049842834,
-0.24786396324634552,
-0.416480153799057,
0.05937955901026726,
-0.07816385477781296,
-0.02990647219121456,
0.028124315664172173,
0.7507667541503906,
-0.26809704303741455,
-0.45198848843574524,
0.1053902879357338,
0.6565988659858704,
-0.0033503659069538116,
-0.00013061116624157876,
-0.694476306438446,
-0.16795097291469574,
0.16599254310131073,
0.02803325094282627,
0.3693279027938843,
0.5786333084106445,
-0.10135343670845032,
0.6651113629341125,
0.6049498319625854,
0.299312025308609,
-0.27969804406166077,
0.09408587962388992,
0.5389044284820557,
-0.6380423903465271,
-0.5706306099891663,
-0.9107572436332703,
0.1547468900680542,
-0.20055770874023438,
-0.37563157081604004,
0.5954195261001587,
0.3425062596797943,
0.33078327775001526,
0.11973860114812851,
0.7460665702819824,
0.062136780470609665,
0.8131287097930908,
-0.7997466921806335,
0.604917585849762,
-0.5369623303413391,
0.2602814733982086,
-0.47869548201560974,
-0.26208147406578064,
-0.37122416496276855,
0.7015487551689148,
-0.3849550187587738,
-0.4373093545436859,
1.0174833536148071,
0.4289277493953705,
0.06320100277662277,
0.05612177029252052,
0.1050691232085228,
0.612199068069458,
0.4271160662174225,
0.6005728244781494,
0.7971571087837219,
-0.3152419626712799,
0.004828078206628561,
-0.03398868069052696,
-0.2650895416736603,
-0.34343221783638,
-0.9455084204673767,
-0.7319057583808899,
-0.38456299901008606,
-0.6561833024024963,
-0.761888325214386,
-0.258335679769516,
1.1208416223526,
0.5538195967674255,
-1.024407982826233,
0.08793196827173233,
-0.0018316010246053338,
0.18482057750225067,
-0.6223199367523193,
-0.20308303833007812,
0.814204752445221,
-0.4801630973815918,
-0.22919504344463348,
0.5516330599784851,
0.2743000388145447,
0.054431378841400146,
0.06081492081284523,
0.027424374595284462,
-0.2583197355270386,
0.06371653825044632,
0.7462831139564514,
0.39132019877433777,
-0.7883961796760559,
-0.2791368067264557,
-0.09485717862844467,
-0.07062193751335144,
0.3388702869415283,
0.8232554793357849,
-0.7313134670257568,
0.3748953342437744,
0.07706322520971298,
0.8530640006065369,
0.279308557510376,
-0.010206736624240875,
0.23740796744823456,
-0.5451676249504089,
0.0846080556511879,
0.3671160638332367,
0.7012148499488831,
0.10424527525901794,
-0.446210116147995,
0.615700900554657,
0.18588511645793915,
-0.48541438579559326,
-1.0495096445083618,
0.27872800827026367,
-1.1983751058578491,
-0.39510872960090637,
1.0425676107406616,
-0.14655137062072754,
-0.16211913526058197,
-0.2392152100801468,
-0.20118963718414307,
0.062004268169403076,
-0.12633159756660461,
1.0224045515060425,
0.4091939926147461,
-0.3836837708950043,
0.14977188408374786,
-0.7156386375427246,
0.6389591097831726,
0.45739057660102844,
-0.9775331020355225,
0.04068807139992714,
0.29119357466697693,
0.35585522651672363,
0.3975656032562256,
0.7350857853889465,
-0.23713849484920502,
0.2069031447172165,
-0.42708227038383484,
-0.12054470926523209,
0.271379679441452,
-0.0033428918104618788,
-0.37748369574546814,
0.14162813127040863,
-0.03450653702020645,
-0.2767796814441681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17600v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17600v1 | Good at captioning, bad at counting: Benchmarking GPT-4V on Earth observation data | 2024-01-31T04:57:12 | 2024-01-31T04:57:12 | Chenhui Zhang, Sherrie Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Large Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance
on complex tasks involving visual input with natural language instructions.
However, it remains unclear to what extent capabilities on natural images
transfer to Earth observation (EO) data, which are predominantly satellite and
aerial images less common in VLM training data. In this work, we propose a
comprehensive benchmark to gauge the progress of VLMs toward being useful tools
for EO data by assessing their abilities on scene understanding, localization
and counting, and change detection tasks. Motivated by real-world applications,
our benchmark includes scenarios like urban monitoring, disaster relief, land
use, and conservation. We discover that, although state-of-the-art VLMs like
GPT-4V possess extensive world knowledge that leads to strong performance on
open-ended tasks like location understanding and image captioning, their poor
spatial reasoning limits usefulness on object localization and counting tasks.
Our benchmark will be made publicly available at https://vleo.danielz.ch/ and
on Hugging Face at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mit-ei/vleo-benchmark-datasets-65b789b0466555489cce0d70
for easy model evaluation. | [
-0.48545628786087036,
-0.23944710195064545,
0.7201428413391113,
0.0029453043825924397,
-0.5935197472572327,
-0.19286860525608063,
0.014758416451513767,
-0.7479491829872131,
-0.5972520112991333,
0.4474451243877411,
-0.2631128132343292,
-0.5792324542999268,
-0.6068497896194458,
0.3449869453907013,
-0.333415687084198,
0.7605129480361938,
-0.23112891614437103,
-0.10786283016204834,
-0.549568772315979,
-0.4130916893482208,
-0.3795672357082367,
-0.40055543184280396,
-0.1739133596420288,
-0.06356851756572723,
0.33871057629585266,
0.1950950175523758,
0.47576916217803955,
0.6461999416351318,
0.5806442499160767,
0.2994798719882965,
0.08427511900663376,
0.3667958974838257,
-0.44978082180023193,
-0.30391937494277954,
0.04766783490777016,
-0.39056360721588135,
-0.10914428532123566,
0.17806962132453918,
0.8149903416633606,
0.25824591517448425,
-0.18579024076461792,
0.18013477325439453,
-0.2595852017402649,
0.587855339050293,
-0.4574556052684784,
0.5642468333244324,
-0.7294847369194031,
0.15281155705451965,
-0.20416468381881714,
0.18966837227344513,
-0.08449818938970566,
-0.22208698093891144,
0.35828933119773865,
-0.8715274333953857,
0.4407382309436798,
0.26944640278816223,
1.0971391201019287,
0.4883062541484833,
-0.2582179605960846,
0.20023582875728607,
-0.37885454297065735,
1.048575758934021,
-0.6916179060935974,
0.49134695529937744,
0.500798225402832,
0.5782952904701233,
0.12219246476888657,
-0.654486358165741,
-0.6111539602279663,
-0.26939308643341064,
0.08307933062314987,
0.3429330289363861,
-0.2805522382259369,
-0.38747891783714294,
0.38355135917663574,
0.31956717371940613,
-0.5432310700416565,
-0.006303913425654173,
-0.4958336651325226,
-0.2445109784603119,
0.4512998163700104,
-0.010626887902617455,
0.07792859524488449,
-0.18962232768535614,
-0.475441575050354,
-0.06199182569980621,
-0.773316502571106,
0.023720132187008858,
0.34856948256492615,
0.10895082354545593,
-0.5636522173881531,
0.4019638001918793,
-0.4094502031803131,
1.1827492713928223,
-0.5576733946800232,
0.208754763007164,
0.49483513832092285,
-0.5554627180099487,
-0.4029340147972107,
-0.40805572271347046,
0.3670324385166168,
0.803533673286438,
0.3942601978778839,
-0.24556604027748108,
-0.07922035455703735,
0.20177236199378967,
0.3153635561466217,
-0.8643434047698975,
-0.33555883169174194,
-0.11038140952587128,
-0.18026159703731537,
-0.13726499676704407,
0.3301481306552887,
-0.7065337896347046,
-0.2926999032497406,
-0.649957001209259,
0.21176664531230927,
-0.28957006335258484,
0.031215576454997063,
0.11909400671720505,
-0.20377179980278015,
0.5975055694580078,
0.6506429314613342,
-0.4138909578323364,
0.4039188623428345,
0.8329591751098633,
0.9957822561264038,
-0.09946677088737488,
-0.5057826042175293,
-0.8787975311279297,
-0.17769908905029297,
-0.3148951232433319,
0.8644033670425415,
-0.33633100986480713,
-0.08623693883419037,
-0.09248494356870651,
0.3390060067176819,
-0.04703552648425102,
-0.6972916722297668,
0.6681259274482727,
-0.26245543360710144,
-0.03719251602888107,
-0.48418161273002625,
-0.25550684332847595,
-0.3215693533420563,
0.4801170229911804,
-0.8788511753082275,
1.127014398574829,
0.08698298782110214,
-0.4833676517009735,
0.719871997833252,
-0.27222132682800293,
-0.36073294281959534,
0.17077398300170898,
-0.25295290350914,
-0.6604555249214172,
0.26398196816444397,
0.4766961634159088,
0.3103320598602295,
-0.4860381484031677,
0.10460153967142105,
-0.18053370714187622,
-0.2956225275993347,
0.09209480881690979,
-0.27030712366104126,
0.20291227102279663,
0.3198234438896179,
-0.291587769985199,
-0.06729543209075928,
-0.7342731952667236,
-0.10881637781858444,
0.1845148205757141,
-0.11170776188373566,
-0.24385283887386322,
0.24519065022468567,
0.0663648396730423,
0.12941116094589233,
-0.015504319220781326,
-0.5541871190071106,
0.1763622909784317,
-0.03451108932495117,
0.5255597829818726,
0.5729603171348572,
-0.24252639710903168,
0.09654408693313599,
-0.36390653252601624,
0.1993597149848938,
0.0888548195362091,
0.24555395543575287,
-0.2948324680328369,
-0.9194619059562683,
-0.30355143547058105,
-0.263229638338089,
-0.1549660712480545,
0.3368067741394043,
-1.0611529350280762,
0.04905432462692261,
-0.6636537313461304,
-0.5014590620994568,
-0.27340373396873474,
0.10821252316236496,
0.3599652051925659,
0.5938370227813721,
0.5109425187110901,
-0.42389950156211853,
-0.3970235288143158,
-0.7573036551475525,
-0.438527375459671,
-0.07336681336164474,
-0.23056721687316895,
0.45853111147880554,
0.6119108200073242,
0.0938631147146225,
0.7283525466918945,
-0.33712154626846313,
-0.13412824273109436,
0.1382748931646347,
0.23145142197608948,
0.0706319659948349,
0.10115651786327362,
0.8199104070663452,
-1.1012113094329834,
-0.46157628297805786,
0.33184704184532166,
-0.906476616859436,
-0.09333749860525131,
0.2626003921031952,
0.22905924916267395,
0.30599790811538696,
0.2515067756175995,
-0.538154125213623,
0.5600557327270508,
0.5836973190307617,
-0.2529524564743042,
0.3476416766643524,
-0.2915428876876831,
0.45358091592788696,
-0.4039200246334076,
0.006341714411973953,
0.0896589532494545,
-0.40663617849349976,
-0.6229517459869385,
0.0766870528459549,
0.09803834557533264,
-0.11303596943616867,
-0.6154285073280334,
0.3779585361480713,
-0.7977247834205627,
-0.565765917301178,
0.06928520649671555,
0.0743226483464241,
-0.13734139502048492,
0.2530924379825592,
0.13800743222236633,
0.6092162132263184,
0.7058183550834656,
-0.39427655935287476,
0.4047342538833618,
0.2601272761821747,
-0.6018881797790527,
0.8484392166137695,
-0.5476749539375305,
0.4330584704875946,
-0.13481931388378143,
0.15681658685207367,
-0.77130526304245,
-0.1770736426115036,
0.10168594866991043,
-0.25601667165756226,
-0.027423180639743805,
-0.5608742237091064,
-0.5576230883598328,
-0.5734395384788513,
-0.39041274785995483,
0.2650723159313202,
0.5744518637657166,
-0.652775764465332,
0.486375093460083,
0.030075931921601295,
-0.09279914200305939,
-0.18921609222888947,
-0.675418496131897,
0.3717246949672699,
-0.21876110136508942,
-0.41761791706085205,
0.37940916419029236,
0.05302039906382561,
-0.12576310336589813,
0.13200151920318604,
-0.2997472584247589,
-0.047628335654735565,
-0.11615004390478134,
0.31981804966926575,
0.22857165336608887,
-0.020663782954216003,
-0.1837308555841446,
-0.5587560534477234,
-0.09126289933919907,
0.031681109219789505,
-0.4293440878391266,
0.23343440890312195,
-0.49185147881507874,
-0.30907517671585083,
-0.21010424196720123,
-0.04305403679609299,
0.9455643892288208,
-0.3698478043079376,
0.5541132688522339,
0.5400946736335754,
-0.5585394501686096,
-0.03396822139620781,
-0.5012741088867188,
0.14926555752754211,
-0.3407845199108124,
0.3464305102825165,
-0.4319424331188202,
-0.48172903060913086,
0.40372195839881897,
0.08862348645925522,
0.12145374715328217,
0.2871611714363098,
0.1836889237165451,
0.0873260572552681,
0.5500274896621704,
0.21402113139629364,
-0.4323605000972748,
0.45745226740837097,
-0.23942124843597412,
-0.011535163968801498,
-0.7284349799156189,
-0.0326383039355278,
-0.40052029490470886,
-0.08274056017398834,
-0.5336394309997559,
-1.0145742893218994,
0.14817996323108673,
-0.2207232117652893,
-0.2842836380004883,
0.28411754965782166,
-0.4220752418041229,
0.4029752314090729,
0.3518267273902893,
0.08685436099767685,
0.3930761218070984,
0.16140833497047424,
0.4260885715484619,
-0.17597539722919464,
-0.45320212841033936,
-0.41692689061164856,
1.0875307321548462,
0.07422738522291183,
0.5737634897232056,
0.1391693651676178,
0.45900365710258484,
0.4763793349266052,
0.5377419590950012,
-0.4452421963214874,
0.48406678438186646,
-0.24043378233909607,
-0.08412929624319077,
-0.3608992397785187,
-0.4827951192855835,
-0.7575727701187134,
0.4617003798484802,
0.10037434846162796,
-0.5519079566001892,
-0.001780824619345367,
0.223405659198761,
0.04217198118567467,
0.34769436717033386,
-0.6480856537818909,
0.9986479878425598,
-0.3248908817768097,
-0.4193347990512848,
-0.02676798216998577,
-0.6813981533050537,
-0.0653122141957283,
0.11570180952548981,
0.3801427185535431,
-0.22207523882389069,
-0.09628371894359589,
0.29276955127716064,
-0.3259523808956146,
0.7126563191413879,
-0.5068802833557129,
0.03715398162603378,
0.5652792453765869,
-0.34521958231925964,
0.6833032965660095,
-0.16719980537891388,
0.011183525435626507,
0.6004871129989624,
-0.11965220421552658,
-0.47653335332870483,
-0.29090046882629395,
0.6760550737380981,
-0.8827272653579712,
-0.15423475205898285,
-0.496734082698822,
-0.24268272519111633,
-0.07126379013061523,
0.06806030869483948,
0.2635522484779358,
0.5409974455833435,
-0.3194904029369354,
0.22021502256393433,
0.2536933422088623,
-0.1134125366806984,
0.24924662709236145,
0.6878508925437927,
-0.2532585561275482,
-0.3180735111236572,
1.1309853792190552,
0.33431100845336914,
0.3332354724407196,
0.27177831530570984,
0.2195907086133957,
-0.38124462962150574,
-0.8388268947601318,
-0.7464120388031006,
0.12015128135681152,
-0.6569114923477173,
-0.2062353938817978,
-0.37484681606292725,
0.07341314852237701,
-0.037675611674785614,
-0.010275385342538357,
-0.27355676889419556,
0.2272777557373047,
0.03926337510347366,
-0.30725234746932983,
0.37221628427505493,
0.7230305075645447,
0.23746351897716522,
-0.1736014187335968,
-0.758773684501648,
0.6359430551528931,
0.41325536370277405,
0.3840673863887787,
-0.35899215936660767,
-0.6220988631248474,
-0.21763572096824646,
-0.19307611882686615,
-0.11259356886148453,
-0.487131267786026,
0.5034107565879822,
0.22566595673561096,
0.5895959734916687,
0.03746322914958,
-0.11687390506267548,
0.6523502469062805,
-0.5930745005607605,
0.8631882071495056,
0.008474882692098618,
-0.8424310088157654,
0.45444759726524353,
-0.3838968276977539,
0.5278841257095337,
0.43516993522644043,
-0.06632363796234131,
-0.2921217679977417,
-0.2889983654022217,
-0.4341104030609131,
-0.6346781253814697,
0.4892105758190155,
0.27843615412712097,
-0.10556967556476593,
0.13589932024478912,
0.10155970603227615,
0.09801862388849258,
0.5067296624183655,
-0.5331060290336609,
0.13200652599334717,
-0.5701562166213989,
-0.033447328954935074,
-0.19032879173755646,
0.11328637599945068,
-0.20458956062793732,
-0.2634267508983612,
0.19957011938095093,
-0.4196016192436218,
0.115655317902565,
0.5545679926872253,
-0.3553060293197632,
-0.01622859016060829,
0.10650774836540222,
0.6596212983131409,
0.5929903388023376,
-0.1730109602212906,
0.20707906782627106,
0.24995115399360657,
-0.636559784412384,
-0.22722025215625763,
0.5711318850517273,
-0.18808841705322266,
-0.08311693370342255,
0.5126456022262573,
0.8746178150177002,
0.27929413318634033,
-0.5230591297149658,
0.5365578532218933,
-0.020957281813025475,
-0.31466054916381836,
-0.23754841089248657,
-0.24667568504810333,
-0.000551809964235872,
-0.08225476741790771,
0.44408711791038513,
0.0759960412979126,
0.1807630956172943,
-0.5273065567016602,
0.046033844351768494,
0.08144591748714447,
-0.2489071935415268,
-0.7117360234260559,
0.754644513130188,
0.3261800706386566,
-0.07798323780298233,
0.6270928978919983,
-0.2723117768764496,
-0.5989295840263367,
1.0426064729690552,
0.20534756779670715,
0.6747407913208008,
0.009188261814415455,
0.01998152583837509,
0.5354294180870056,
0.5850396752357483,
-0.1583978533744812,
0.39857983589172363,
-0.1105160042643547,
-0.7822731733322144,
-0.3928494453430176,
-0.22788822650909424,
-0.5476598143577576,
0.052909478545188904,
-0.7583415508270264,
0.0645514577627182,
-0.29242971539497375,
0.17100000381469727,
-0.04037373885512352,
-0.26963555812835693,
-1.3746483325958252,
0.2619588375091553,
0.37512215971946716,
0.6276304125785828,
-1.0663557052612305,
0.5285267233848572,
1.0108548402786255,
-0.14019492268562317,
-0.37005603313446045,
-0.1827700436115265,
0.2773732542991638,
-0.7451499104499817,
0.4106115400791168,
0.7582138776779175,
-0.18667440116405487,
-0.018056616187095642,
-0.8184725642204285,
-0.6366344094276428,
1.21470308303833,
0.05362803488969803,
-0.9721486568450928,
0.582823634147644,
0.018299628049135208,
0.6495334506034851,
-0.12532468140125275,
0.10807672888040543,
0.5339414477348328,
0.7610524892807007,
-0.10101430118083954,
-0.9549187421798706,
-0.002731726272031665,
-0.1463472694158554,
0.07556205242872238,
0.22041551768779755,
-0.7872584462165833,
0.722907543182373,
-0.37968671321868896,
-0.27993398904800415,
0.251697301864624,
0.41934260725975037,
0.017229076474905014,
0.6877891421318054,
0.8103448748588562,
0.8570472598075867,
0.5775564312934875,
-0.4680473506450653,
1.4601211547851562,
-0.0014167733024805784,
0.40796712040901184,
1.0759472846984863,
-0.7028242945671082,
0.7631933689117432,
0.46735283732414246,
-0.569957971572876,
0.1561514139175415,
0.3239787220954895,
-0.3996471166610718,
0.8105491399765015,
0.3136075437068939,
-0.1845957189798355,
-0.1457126885652542,
0.05786760896444321,
-0.18253833055496216,
0.3535374402999878,
0.005413845181465149,
0.1294766664505005,
-0.16386261582374573,
0.06261017173528671,
-0.32547423243522644,
0.0942489504814148,
-0.14454396069049835,
0.5905531048774719,
-0.020128775388002396,
-0.841918408870697,
0.3671816289424896,
-0.4370412230491638,
0.3757122755050659,
-0.4905983805656433,
-0.5005335211753845,
-0.18129779398441315,
-0.015522199682891369,
-0.16664977371692657,
-0.8201204538345337,
0.18102574348449707,
0.2527543604373932,
-0.15661029517650604,
-0.10985356569290161,
0.3804715573787689,
-0.15080705285072327,
-0.4434499442577362,
0.2805502414703369,
0.4362708330154419,
0.42928650975227356,
-0.34066158533096313,
-0.3139422535896301,
0.19658857583999634,
0.08893155306577682,
-0.19214984774589539,
0.15266413986682892,
0.3846617341041565,
-0.341858446598053,
0.5968954563140869,
0.8250131607055664,
0.0516398549079895,
0.19723094999790192,
0.46088895201683044,
0.7495815753936768,
-0.8082223534584045,
-0.3639477491378784,
-0.6850907206535339,
0.5214099287986755,
-0.3891218900680542,
-0.40322789549827576,
0.661933422088623,
0.712046205997467,
0.8759409189224243,
-0.28977298736572266,
0.9328145384788513,
-0.16447539627552032,
0.2998959720134735,
-0.5961229205131531,
0.1832769215106964,
-0.4505775570869446,
0.05873674154281616,
-0.0997261255979538,
-0.9557815194129944,
-0.2734556198120117,
0.491156667470932,
-0.4397985637187958,
-0.13553781807422638,
0.45225173234939575,
0.4288954734802246,
0.03664475306868553,
-0.12853889167308807,
0.5512650609016418,
0.2144845724105835,
0.5441994667053223,
0.4645116329193115,
1.0183842182159424,
-0.448004812002182,
0.5174415707588196,
-0.05911934748291969,
-0.22981134057044983,
0.02629777044057846,
-1.3039084672927856,
-0.6702804565429688,
-0.3593519330024719,
-0.3494565188884735,
0.40692955255508423,
0.12931933999061584,
0.21486172080039978,
0.753359317779541,
-0.6409508585929871,
0.3024895191192627,
-0.3204915225505829,
0.007359005510807037,
-0.46992355585098267,
-0.17909221351146698,
0.2556748688220978,
0.3095140755176544,
-0.8709942698478699,
0.37231165170669556,
0.38846489787101746,
0.12319982796907425,
-0.03136632218956947,
-0.11010923236608505,
0.20210009813308716,
-0.33963510394096375,
0.653597354888916,
0.4719419777393341,
-1.0565576553344727,
-0.633529007434845,
-0.14195850491523743,
0.17850692570209503,
0.09265811741352081,
0.5571788549423218,
-0.7429253458976746,
0.8669097423553467,
0.325134813785553,
0.6198854446411133,
0.879322350025177,
0.3523204028606415,
0.45344820618629456,
-0.5680457353591919,
0.1349354386329651,
-0.034977544099092484,
0.5278459191322327,
0.8168718218803406,
-0.03720049932599068,
0.9253312349319458,
0.4272661805152893,
-0.6365938782691956,
-0.7287487983703613,
-0.0033429760951548815,
-1.0415630340576172,
0.2758840024471283,
0.893247127532959,
-0.46258774399757385,
0.021031085401773453,
-0.17158038914203644,
-0.2398962378501892,
-0.20983248949050903,
-0.26920026540756226,
0.4685531556606293,
0.7724964618682861,
0.015190298669040203,
-0.38100504875183105,
-1.0637351274490356,
0.17811311781406403,
0.2146081179380417,
-1.1809879541397095,
0.07688318192958832,
0.8190105557441711,
0.516194760799408,
0.07901631295681,
0.3998626172542572,
-0.16521097719669342,
0.32094302773475647,
0.01166736800223589,
0.15383465588092804,
-0.31905755400657654,
-0.36085745692253113,
-0.305010586977005,
-0.24856333434581757,
0.006691095419228077,
-0.5258862972259521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17597v1 | SPECTRUM: Speaker-Enhanced Pre-Training for Long Dialogue Summarization | 2024-01-31T04:50:00 | 2024-01-31T04:50:00 | Sangwoo Cho, Kaiqiang Song, Chao Zhao, Xiaoyang Wang, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-turn dialogues are characterized by their extended length and the
presence of turn-taking conversations. Traditional language models often
overlook the distinct features of these dialogues by treating them as regular
text. In this paper, we propose a speaker-enhanced pre-training method for long
dialogue summarization, which leverages the inherent structure of multiple-turn
dialogues. To support our study, we curate a diverse dataset that includes
transcripts from real-world scenarios, movie or TV show transcripts, and
dialogues generated by a Large Language Model. We then perform a pre-training,
which encompasses the detection of speaker changes, and masked utterance
generation. Experimental results of fine-tuned models demonstrate that our
model achieves state-of-the-art performance on downstream benchmarks with long
context, surpassing baseline models and highlighting the effectiveness of our
approach. Our findings highlight the importance of curating pre-training
datasets that exhibit diversity and variations in length distribution to ensure
effective alignment with downstream datasets. | [
-0.7992454171180725,
-0.4381478726863861,
0.34973663091659546,
-0.045647889375686646,
-0.5464674830436707,
0.4119122624397278,
-0.4204465448856354,
-0.24433831870555878,
0.7271544933319092,
0.9554467797279358,
-0.8756617307662964,
-0.20311938226222992,
-0.589545726776123,
0.04599492996931076,
-0.39457929134368896,
1.260847568511963,
0.5578492283821106,
0.017368970438838005,
0.1771182417869568,
-0.052963465452194214,
-0.2389267385005951,
-0.46079015731811523,
-0.1136208027601242,
-0.15997935831546783,
0.37893179059028625,
0.3433454632759094,
0.7057011723518372,
0.15167176723480225,
0.03623228892683983,
0.3062788248062134,
0.016537662595510483,
0.43894150853157043,
-0.7314590215682983,
0.21223647892475128,
0.19637799263000488,
-0.016197197139263153,
-0.7183011174201965,
-0.0026903480757027864,
0.8732810616493225,
0.9034087061882019,
-0.027437420561909676,
0.05137048661708832,
0.09769745171070099,
0.6401757597923279,
-0.7445201277732849,
0.07211526483297348,
-0.33469948172569275,
-0.01754770427942276,
-0.3249571621417999,
-0.3004148006439209,
-0.5238993763923645,
-0.28669530153274536,
0.2894218862056732,
-0.6619707942008972,
0.130098357796669,
-0.272724986076355,
0.5607237219810486,
0.122066430747509,
-0.522587239742279,
-0.11473440378904343,
-1.0411865711212158,
0.54349684715271,
-0.8277133703231812,
0.32754459977149963,
0.2757902145385742,
0.5212037563323975,
-0.0010236173402518034,
-0.7795510292053223,
-0.6812618374824524,
-0.13637028634548187,
-0.13231384754180908,
0.39892101287841797,
0.27423983812332153,
0.3957144320011139,
0.22836163640022278,
0.43368569016456604,
-0.28825807571411133,
0.018096519634127617,
-0.30718860030174255,
-0.18268908560276031,
0.5436524748802185,
0.13861355185508728,
-0.09585293382406235,
-0.14207331836223602,
0.015711257234215736,
-0.2989085614681244,
-0.5313277840614319,
-0.027989666908979416,
0.7257261872291565,
0.44780951738357544,
-0.18331165611743927,
0.3441917300224304,
-0.4697282016277313,
0.6976341605186462,
0.031640514731407166,
-0.1163959875702858,
0.3655976355075836,
-0.6578823924064636,
0.00597103638574481,
0.16395996510982513,
0.5328696370124817,
0.32652246952056885,
0.4976162910461426,
0.18270105123519897,
0.0641040951013565,
-0.24562910199165344,
0.07072313874959946,
-0.955458402633667,
-0.34223029017448425,
0.17369943857192993,
-0.3288916349411011,
-0.027851678431034088,
0.07022076100111008,
-0.9743613004684448,
-0.27354660630226135,
-0.5486844778060913,
0.20449139177799225,
-0.35303565859794617,
-0.4900439977645874,
0.2081107497215271,
-0.08704087138175964,
0.2797048091888428,
0.15774989128112793,
-0.9938618540763855,
0.4237261414527893,
0.6076146364212036,
0.4938089847564697,
0.08280695229768753,
-0.24937091767787933,
-0.8498418927192688,
0.2493889033794403,
-0.3315007984638214,
0.6282363533973694,
-0.7693352699279785,
-0.5304985642433167,
0.11163230985403061,
-0.2365371584892273,
0.09348959475755692,
-0.16638274490833282,
0.2889612317085266,
-0.27916190028190613,
0.3594948351383209,
-0.06296353042125702,
-0.36882343888282776,
0.23856523633003235,
-0.10201433300971985,
-0.3298335671424866,
0.759906530380249,
0.08109352737665176,
-0.6624549627304077,
0.4031628966331482,
-0.7184882164001465,
-0.6245937943458557,
0.06863997131586075,
-0.2158389538526535,
-0.592162549495697,
0.05162311717867851,
0.6960667371749878,
0.37216001749038696,
0.31706753373146057,
0.24943935871124268,
-0.07550173252820969,
-0.38057833909988403,
0.2229021191596985,
-0.2569200396537781,
0.32592591643333435,
0.18133854866027832,
-0.10440342873334885,
0.3235052525997162,
-0.8749763369560242,
-0.10849309712648392,
-0.22846545279026031,
0.14449261128902435,
-0.12575562298297882,
0.005440924316644669,
-0.06780441105365753,
0.010922344401478767,
-0.13647088408470154,
-0.5392011404037476,
0.048013605177402496,
-0.6439811587333679,
0.25030431151390076,
0.6984779834747314,
0.1274709552526474,
0.4406680464744568,
-0.2044794261455536,
0.5093735456466675,
0.028444793075323105,
0.15912188589572906,
-0.9231908917427063,
-0.16977815330028534,
-0.7977590560913086,
-0.6475462317466736,
0.20411130785942078,
0.4076117277145386,
-0.8291876316070557,
0.6492161154747009,
-0.72482830286026,
-0.433369904756546,
-0.40693381428718567,
-0.047946177423000336,
0.4755115211009979,
0.3231015205383301,
0.5328402519226074,
-0.6118019819259644,
-0.6600374579429626,
-0.7733526825904846,
-0.34051674604415894,
0.24505876004695892,
-0.26781097054481506,
0.2718983292579651,
0.3442803621292114,
-0.17725181579589844,
1.2801110744476318,
-0.6672627329826355,
-0.17972508072853088,
-0.6152336001396179,
0.26247572898864746,
0.19922460615634918,
0.3839925229549408,
0.3069644272327423,
-0.5664671063423157,
-0.302700012922287,
-0.3942374587059021,
-0.33533942699432373,
0.030911676585674286,
-0.26883459091186523,
-0.026197370141744614,
-0.21279168128967285,
0.5941187739372253,
-0.4677286446094513,
0.3734419643878937,
0.4047512114048004,
-0.0392104871571064,
0.5265445113182068,
-0.19022317230701447,
0.1930556744337082,
-1.2946690320968628,
-0.18180277943611145,
-0.3048085868358612,
-0.44032546877861023,
-0.9670810103416443,
-0.43119198083877563,
-0.1219181939959526,
-0.5594714879989624,
-0.3242340087890625,
0.22535958886146545,
-0.4554559886455536,
-0.39723989367485046,
-0.25432324409484863,
0.19030524790287018,
-0.03407037630677223,
0.6511853337287903,
0.37305572628974915,
0.642629861831665,
0.2365245670080185,
-0.7620310187339783,
0.31667661666870117,
0.39770805835723877,
-0.6883196830749512,
0.3711901903152466,
-0.48263612389564514,
0.28394219279289246,
-0.2407837212085724,
0.8137298822402954,
-1.0836198329925537,
-0.3705124258995056,
-0.17935027182102203,
-0.48030173778533936,
0.5886234641075134,
-0.18283383548259735,
-0.1416361778974533,
-0.22125186026096344,
-0.27938780188560486,
0.4750446379184723,
0.4783829152584076,
-0.3910130560398102,
0.7784782648086548,
0.3610647916793823,
-0.6698423027992249,
-0.6032038927078247,
-0.3315580189228058,
0.30674585700035095,
-0.14382238686084747,
-0.6538290977478027,
0.32675617933273315,
-0.06302300095558167,
0.1576409637928009,
-0.7336534261703491,
0.10858154296875,
0.08532203733921051,
-0.029084190726280212,
0.12980689108371735,
-0.015685519203543663,
-0.13013997673988342,
0.08556316047906876,
0.16910213232040405,
-0.2952927052974701,
-0.18109208345413208,
-0.09900043904781342,
0.8317180871963501,
0.15070252120494843,
-0.3125993311405182,
-0.4266080856323242,
0.7143964767456055,
0.426140159368515,
-0.6688101291656494,
0.3767824172973633,
0.5126270651817322,
0.17545907199382782,
-0.02785937860608101,
-0.58699631690979,
-0.515591025352478,
-0.48912885785102844,
0.7902247309684753,
-0.2714627683162689,
-0.8717770576477051,
0.5035678148269653,
-0.2536318898200989,
0.13218995928764343,
-0.009774057194590569,
0.49396225810050964,
-0.09355388581752777,
0.949190616607666,
0.5899667143821716,
0.02445381134748459,
0.8577383160591125,
-0.17481209337711334,
0.4913046658039093,
-0.8331209421157837,
-0.04999052360653877,
-0.37201523780822754,
-0.04456159099936485,
-0.38832148909568787,
-0.3133913576602936,
0.44300228357315063,
-0.29258963465690613,
-0.2017010897397995,
0.15790876746177673,
-0.16699478030204773,
0.6241181492805481,
0.32671013474464417,
0.045597270131111145,
0.167971670627594,
-0.2653540372848511,
0.3648607134819031,
-0.10332763195037842,
-0.3312469720840454,
-0.19088071584701538,
1.195333480834961,
0.43368494510650635,
0.6534796357154846,
0.021240798756480217,
0.9133895039558411,
0.15137307345867157,
0.13909120857715607,
-0.5066550374031067,
0.48162734508514404,
-0.017936937510967255,
-0.27659812569618225,
-0.6342812776565552,
-0.3229164779186249,
-0.8671003580093384,
0.25497037172317505,
-0.2006201446056366,
-0.3130263686180115,
0.149967759847641,
0.09463221579790115,
-0.527386486530304,
-0.033317457884550095,
-0.6351553797721863,
0.5847984552383423,
-0.27199241518974304,
0.1420239806175232,
-0.28588196635246277,
-0.9250022172927856,
0.3137851655483246,
-0.034045878797769547,
0.37926116585731506,
0.07435508817434311,
0.38026365637779236,
0.7845556735992432,
-0.5288479924201965,
0.8065530061721802,
-0.3603147864341736,
0.15630702674388885,
0.13232415914535522,
-0.19436036050319672,
0.43698394298553467,
0.16698294878005981,
0.45690762996673584,
-0.14828144013881683,
-0.29483267664909363,
-0.5679304003715515,
-0.4462611973285675,
0.11305596679449081,
-0.8197459578514099,
-0.4799460768699646,
-0.16775722801685333,
-0.35494881868362427,
-0.6007276177406311,
0.08051054179668427,
0.4095076024532318,
0.7557834982872009,
-0.3878082036972046,
0.18673810362815857,
0.8727132081985474,
-0.3325900733470917,
0.5375444889068604,
0.44266095757484436,
-0.2798014283180237,
-0.4851491451263428,
0.7456439733505249,
0.03938041627407074,
0.6841899752616882,
0.2135227918624878,
0.057750627398490906,
-0.1731697916984558,
-0.7122488021850586,
-0.3156469762325287,
0.0688856914639473,
-0.6288037896156311,
0.06753329932689667,
-0.8209637999534607,
-0.2970133423805237,
-0.8387373685836792,
-0.02489466220140457,
-0.5939106345176697,
-0.46201077103614807,
0.2244059294462204,
-0.42525067925453186,
0.19649061560630798,
0.45844101905822754,
0.10846136510372162,
0.7212328910827637,
-0.8089361786842346,
0.5214093923568726,
0.7275838851928711,
0.26594558358192444,
-0.24845759570598602,
-0.6942901015281677,
-0.49169278144836426,
0.12073312699794769,
-0.16987325251102448,
-0.7455525994300842,
0.4490542709827423,
0.6453912854194641,
0.510942280292511,
0.39841145277023315,
0.05046332627534866,
0.631525456905365,
-0.38359734416007996,
1.0011616945266724,
0.4141847789287567,
-0.9415945410728455,
0.7687892913818359,
-0.576222836971283,
0.7175804376602173,
0.7006170749664307,
0.13506457209587097,
-0.44123876094818115,
-0.5171613693237305,
-0.31470686197280884,
-0.834971010684967,
0.6263720989227295,
0.319813996553421,
0.4468209147453308,
0.061156805604696274,
-0.08749981969594955,
0.11581765860319138,
0.29600420594215393,
-0.6459473371505737,
-0.16043195128440857,
-0.8871906399726868,
-0.03880160301923752,
-0.6675458550453186,
-0.40073561668395996,
-0.18605776131153107,
-0.22031474113464355,
0.5851274132728577,
-0.2521865665912628,
0.03548550233244896,
0.20381511747837067,
-0.43430909514427185,
0.3597588539123535,
0.5033833384513855,
0.9417563080787659,
0.7407031059265137,
-0.5001394748687744,
-0.1432206630706787,
0.16882146894931793,
-0.6319933533668518,
-0.07777734100818634,
0.10788556933403015,
0.39216822385787964,
0.10460963845252991,
0.5887085795402527,
0.9218252301216125,
0.26934614777565,
-0.44925034046173096,
0.5915741324424744,
-0.1747635155916214,
-0.08001042157411575,
-0.5488685369491577,
-0.22245103120803833,
-0.035162873566150665,
-0.18015097081661224,
0.45254939794540405,
-0.14914503693580627,
0.22836296260356903,
-0.6081555485725403,
0.17165066301822662,
-0.037773795425891876,
-0.3398692011833191,
-0.1986049860715866,
0.017906563356518745,
0.6914383769035339,
-0.27983358502388,
0.7925238609313965,
0.03431566804647446,
-0.6260544657707214,
0.34791818261146545,
0.2580585777759552,
0.9079005122184753,
-0.5267648100852966,
0.05763552710413933,
0.17911982536315918,
0.10490899533033371,
0.3352656662464142,
-0.030286576598882675,
-0.4580732583999634,
-0.6823923587799072,
-0.7352091670036316,
-0.49764877557754517,
-0.43863359093666077,
0.08916298300027847,
-0.7400296926498413,
0.27934345602989197,
-0.22732439637184143,
-0.1405499130487442,
0.04157387092709541,
-0.2248886674642563,
-0.34417229890823364,
0.06841013580560684,
0.36463209986686707,
0.5213918089866638,
-1.0734692811965942,
0.9017350673675537,
-0.053466517478227615,
-0.20242492854595184,
-0.49416205286979675,
-0.15218685567378998,
-0.27895689010620117,
-0.43521878123283386,
0.4827497601509094,
0.29514893889427185,
-0.34887170791625977,
-0.13879425823688507,
-0.22922897338867188,
-0.6311770081520081,
0.7307302355766296,
0.25981438159942627,
-0.7243403196334839,
-0.05499458685517311,
0.384963721036911,
0.44803863763809204,
-0.7150640487670898,
0.6152515411376953,
0.6701591610908508,
0.2070980668067932,
0.1847151815891266,
-1.0992947816848755,
-0.5040051937103271,
-0.18885739147663116,
-0.09116298705339432,
0.44530683755874634,
-0.4586086571216583,
0.7517871260643005,
-0.0009888897184282541,
0.05091431736946106,
-0.16680669784545898,
0.8724218010902405,
0.028746793046593666,
0.25773894786834717,
0.6405370235443115,
0.302775502204895,
0.567166805267334,
-0.021971160545945168,
0.9537084102630615,
-0.29913896322250366,
-0.015676196664571762,
1.5881378650665283,
-0.4017803966999054,
0.5524542331695557,
0.2616105079650879,
-0.030275873839855194,
0.5927039980888367,
0.49378788471221924,
0.3050175905227661,
0.7857304811477661,
0.2697508633136749,
-0.3065023422241211,
-0.5502592325210571,
0.13924704492092133,
-0.6416646838188171,
0.5791551470756531,
0.5032008290290833,
-0.20563694834709167,
-0.08593309670686722,
0.3342870771884918,
-0.08829983323812485,
0.28629520535469055,
-0.2722150385379791,
1.1308234930038452,
0.1465931534767151,
-0.8001128435134888,
0.4061887264251709,
-0.510214626789093,
0.7053893804550171,
-0.9292717576026917,
0.09070634096860886,
-0.38337242603302,
0.10563873499631882,
-0.20764268934726715,
-0.42918774485588074,
0.17101119458675385,
-0.17974118888378143,
-0.07580377161502838,
-0.38724634051322937,
0.28698503971099854,
-0.4632778465747833,
-0.3066641092300415,
0.14306068420410156,
0.2614705264568329,
0.1478651612997055,
0.007974923588335514,
-0.15388265252113342,
-0.18742308020591736,
0.016800524666905403,
-0.20238305628299713,
0.4185592830181122,
0.13252311944961548,
-0.015468784607946873,
0.4069157838821411,
0.6439246535301208,
-0.055449891835451126,
0.12986095249652863,
0.6056150794029236,
0.9691231846809387,
-0.5120355486869812,
-0.9743579626083374,
-0.6233025193214417,
0.6325138211250305,
-0.5122645497322083,
-0.31918391585350037,
0.52235347032547,
0.7820479869842529,
0.6587134599685669,
-0.02618362568318844,
0.6390750408172607,
0.569505512714386,
0.8501620292663574,
-0.5746155977249146,
0.4893318712711334,
0.09144577383995056,
0.30561545491218567,
-0.4594896733760834,
-1.0792921781539917,
0.21685311198234558,
0.35035669803619385,
-0.3242453336715698,
0.2089734524488449,
0.4090060889720917,
0.7930862903594971,
-0.12548689544200897,
0.1877378225326538,
0.23849250376224518,
0.117918461561203,
0.6697715520858765,
0.49103182554244995,
0.9876577854156494,
-0.1261921525001526,
0.5027074813842773,
0.06309935450553894,
-0.3610117435455322,
-0.2646656036376953,
-0.9089595675468445,
-1.1589754819869995,
-0.5998777151107788,
-0.26274359226226807,
-0.13826784491539001,
-0.006661418359726667,
0.6425526738166809,
1.127695083618164,
-0.6449389457702637,
-0.29948270320892334,
0.2199140042066574,
-0.308045893907547,
-0.051891643553972244,
-0.1255953460931778,
0.19252994656562805,
-0.27442169189453125,
-0.5476723909378052,
0.6993149518966675,
0.3296898305416107,
0.09275282174348831,
-0.13158713281154633,
-0.14344970881938934,
-0.12459500879049301,
0.38647356629371643,
0.5996323227882385,
0.18886326253414154,
-0.38309240341186523,
-0.4337158501148224,
-0.3510775566101074,
0.3000066578388214,
0.1289370357990265,
1.0732545852661133,
-0.8859425187110901,
0.7731960415840149,
0.31749117374420166,
0.3553093373775482,
1.1637141704559326,
0.035734228789806366,
1.0119900703430176,
-1.0874983072280884,
0.4376256465911865,
0.4664362967014313,
0.1687392145395279,
0.3142431974411011,
-0.11107294261455536,
0.10654152929782867,
-0.2353597730398178,
-0.40751394629478455,
-0.9080201387405396,
0.5934139490127563,
-1.0732542276382446,
-0.23521393537521362,
0.6655594110488892,
-0.1960735321044922,
0.305660605430603,
-0.2984669804573059,
-0.2126455157995224,
0.4090074598789215,
-0.38653719425201416,
0.48873865604400635,
0.6318804621696472,
-0.005450201686471701,
-0.332314670085907,
-0.1117047667503357,
0.7896901369094849,
0.5224909782409668,
-0.90896075963974,
0.21048547327518463,
0.3936533033847809,
-0.003056867513805628,
0.3396354913711548,
0.7757052779197693,
-0.059389591217041016,
0.21044373512268066,
-0.2601793706417084,
-0.11135388165712357,
-0.32905134558677673,
-0.33338069915771484,
-0.27005162835121155,
0.04779482260346413,
-0.18878421187400818,
-0.036145128309726715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17588v1 | Local and Global Contexts for Conversation | 2024-01-31T04:19:22 | 2024-01-31T04:19:22 | Zuoquan Lin, Xinyi Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The context in conversation is the dialog history crucial for multi-turn
dialogue. Learning from the relevant contexts in dialog history for grounded
conversation is a challenging problem. Local context is the most neighbor and
more sensitive to the subsequent response, and global context is relevant to a
whole conversation far beyond neighboring utterances. Currently, pretrained
transformer models for conversation challenge capturing the correlation and
connection between local and global contexts. We introduce a local and global
conversation model (LGCM) for general-purpose conversation in open domain. It
is a local-global hierarchical transformer model that excels at accurately
discerning and assimilating the relevant contexts necessary for generating
responses. It employs a local encoder to grasp the local context at the level
of individual utterances and a global encoder to understand the broader context
at the dialogue level. The seamless fusion of these locally and globally
contextualized encodings ensures a comprehensive comprehension of the
conversation. Experiments on popular datasets show that LGCM outperforms the
existing conversation models on the performance of automatic metrics with
significant margins. | [
-0.4266262650489807,
-1.1283975839614868,
0.5434646606445312,
-0.1965407431125641,
-0.11540601402521133,
-0.02790006250143051,
-0.30198362469673157,
-0.6424975991249084,
-0.03054424189031124,
0.6091660261154175,
-0.5646052956581116,
-0.4303235113620758,
-0.2606390416622162,
-0.171333447098732,
-0.1615234911441803,
1.1256592273712158,
-0.07685519754886627,
0.1957106590270996,
-0.5821322202682495,
-0.33925604820251465,
-0.7429079413414001,
-0.8773760795593262,
-0.6397713422775269,
-0.5025897026062012,
0.02882557176053524,
0.36037999391555786,
0.6915629506111145,
-0.03984352573752403,
0.23317183554172516,
0.3522655665874481,
-0.3544810116291046,
0.04360402747988701,
-0.7945952415466309,
0.19689448177814484,
-0.15704236924648285,
-0.4211399257183075,
-0.4187619388103485,
-0.1347353756427765,
0.532435417175293,
0.5992127656936646,
-0.08800293505191803,
-0.0388789139688015,
0.11032598465681076,
0.13771285116672516,
-0.33919090032577515,
0.210307776927948,
-0.8482016324996948,
0.17089605331420898,
0.39160776138305664,
-0.24622982740402222,
-0.28108638525009155,
-0.2933962643146515,
0.4544215202331543,
-0.1802022010087967,
0.48281270265579224,
-0.26567983627319336,
0.6429535746574402,
-0.1162090003490448,
-0.839381754398346,
-0.33576127886772156,
-1.1939736604690552,
0.514146089553833,
-0.38772276043891907,
0.24376150965690613,
0.21639889478683472,
0.577068567276001,
-0.17900623381137848,
-0.8046094179153442,
-0.4008837640285492,
-0.026653310284018517,
-0.38765817880630493,
0.18573737144470215,
-0.24998845160007477,
0.06737205386161804,
-0.1478596180677414,
0.8323559761047363,
-0.2552088797092438,
-0.17876970767974854,
-0.37851133942604065,
-0.060571134090423584,
0.10683697462081909,
0.5264375805854797,
0.20234394073486328,
-0.1341763138771057,
-0.46873530745506287,
0.2846839129924774,
-0.6383480429649353,
0.3157390058040619,
-0.04970033839344978,
0.38549262285232544,
-0.36999043822288513,
-0.03875582665205002,
-0.28067854046821594,
0.7117259502410889,
0.24610701203346252,
-0.3547898530960083,
-0.2565772235393524,
-0.7371538877487183,
-0.339927077293396,
-0.09473196417093277,
0.5621249079704285,
0.46303731203079224,
0.24476689100265503,
-0.22776101529598236,
0.4154343903064728,
-0.13444451987743378,
0.3456738591194153,
-0.9209581613540649,
0.2051226794719696,
0.13151170313358307,
-0.33359912037849426,
-0.10787197947502136,
0.09545857459306717,
-0.7743418216705322,
-0.1553615778684616,
-0.556198239326477,
0.10441427677869797,
0.12799377739429474,
-0.12548644840717316,
-0.10282760113477707,
0.3886110782623291,
0.5860618352890015,
0.27003559470176697,
-0.8761158585548401,
0.3820885121822357,
0.4882810711860657,
0.8372378945350647,
-0.0879894345998764,
0.10510095208883286,
-0.39836591482162476,
0.1398485153913498,
-0.07256729900836945,
0.5409587025642395,
-0.5891942977905273,
-0.7251521944999695,
0.2673626244068146,
0.34334349632263184,
-0.11806028336286545,
-0.41847673058509827,
0.6213213801383972,
-0.36993902921676636,
0.6651750206947327,
-0.11873561143875122,
-0.22916384041309357,
-0.09507858008146286,
0.3468114137649536,
-0.3966420590877533,
0.7533509135246277,
0.13713273406028748,
-0.86351478099823,
0.20323285460472107,
-0.5469273924827576,
-0.49344637989997864,
0.023765534162521362,
-0.3284204602241516,
-0.20651735365390778,
0.176275372505188,
0.5949357151985168,
0.5204905867576599,
-0.37083110213279724,
0.7611221671104431,
0.0013415194116532803,
-0.5097164511680603,
0.009344165213406086,
-0.5106644034385681,
0.4069344103336334,
0.06597334891557693,
-0.29589077830314636,
0.4446690082550049,
-0.4053960144519806,
-0.10479763895273209,
0.13786077499389648,
-0.16171708703041077,
-0.04536155238747597,
0.04925338178873062,
-0.3019859790802002,
0.28225645422935486,
-0.04489909112453461,
-0.43276867270469666,
0.16033415496349335,
-0.34785938262939453,
0.8769774436950684,
0.31558865308761597,
0.27463865280151367,
0.8791205883026123,
-0.20459173619747162,
0.29525327682495117,
0.29540562629699707,
0.1547936052083969,
-0.6424980163574219,
-0.4721297025680542,
-0.8168332576751709,
-0.047352079302072525,
-0.10663597285747528,
0.6654236316680908,
-0.45865336060523987,
0.4306585490703583,
-0.6366447806358337,
-0.3986699879169464,
-0.35760781168937683,
-0.31544604897499084,
0.04355078190565109,
0.7144161462783813,
0.20009581744670868,
-0.16534361243247986,
-0.3299970030784607,
-0.7708239555358887,
-0.10205237567424774,
0.052265483886003494,
-0.28750181198120117,
0.7044364213943481,
0.35054707527160645,
-0.3975573778152466,
1.5178020000457764,
-0.3819963335990906,
-0.45221564173698425,
-0.33649778366088867,
0.09933462738990784,
0.24934934079647064,
0.28192266821861267,
0.2981168031692505,
-0.8033021092414856,
-0.5771883726119995,
0.21552646160125732,
-0.7448306679725647,
0.3022909164428711,
-0.32396334409713745,
-0.24583099782466888,
0.0273597352206707,
0.5707502961158752,
-0.74155592918396,
0.6400529742240906,
0.49864017963409424,
-0.09468340873718262,
0.12761743366718292,
-0.11277681589126587,
0.47332194447517395,
-1.31276535987854,
-0.030493270605802536,
-0.2337416559457779,
-0.3040415644645691,
-1.0756113529205322,
-0.13213227689266205,
-0.12904992699623108,
-0.502762496471405,
-0.6811295747756958,
0.6013086438179016,
-0.3948470950126648,
0.13804270327091217,
0.07997823506593704,
0.28583428263664246,
-0.1189635768532753,
0.7196555733680725,
0.33960238099098206,
1.0049412250518799,
0.5385242700576782,
-0.5993706583976746,
0.22064310312271118,
0.5332176089286804,
-0.6470487713813782,
0.7319409847259521,
-0.6877429485321045,
0.4560832977294922,
-0.18387126922607422,
0.7215650677680969,
-0.9834912419319153,
-0.2910698354244232,
0.1454467922449112,
-0.20906993746757507,
0.19704250991344452,
-0.16146384179592133,
-0.006471019703894854,
-0.29626691341400146,
0.15180912613868713,
0.4517291188240051,
0.3629268407821655,
-0.7100876569747925,
0.8990772366523743,
0.3400668203830719,
-0.3037639260292053,
-0.13714544475078583,
-0.37858378887176514,
0.012964858673512936,
-0.3916044235229492,
-0.982177734375,
0.42259180545806885,
-0.10737654566764832,
-0.10807677358388901,
-0.6017060875892639,
-0.2157559096813202,
-0.07372827082872391,
-0.19544735550880432,
0.4242721199989319,
-0.04283851385116577,
-0.23669449985027313,
-0.19087249040603638,
-0.31159839034080505,
-0.1629411280155182,
0.20459158718585968,
-0.10502991825342178,
0.554854154586792,
-0.2951856553554535,
-0.45557868480682373,
-0.26866206526756287,
0.6600533723831177,
0.6316218376159668,
-0.05949489399790764,
0.8311024904251099,
0.5857746601104736,
-0.2567938566207886,
0.2121305763721466,
-0.437542200088501,
-0.31608104705810547,
-0.4651615619659424,
0.42575109004974365,
-0.42606380581855774,
-1.2970353364944458,
0.8132709860801697,
-0.2914358377456665,
-0.17865604162216187,
-0.08846930414438248,
0.6368794441223145,
0.24787233769893646,
1.0200207233428955,
0.6277437806129456,
-0.388602077960968,
0.4096704423427582,
0.06510968506336212,
0.7818654775619507,
-0.7269118428230286,
-0.272797554731369,
-0.4432750344276428,
-0.09576016664505005,
-0.3024611473083496,
-0.5573170781135559,
0.43125638365745544,
0.24275821447372437,
-0.2895319163799286,
0.05662288889288902,
-0.32820966839790344,
0.7486347556114197,
0.48354271054267883,
-0.08033689111471176,
0.3761392831802368,
0.07803202420473099,
-0.04563906416296959,
-0.4113715887069702,
-0.5381955504417419,
-0.6605666279792786,
0.39423373341560364,
0.44837141036987305,
0.6483995914459229,
0.03497420251369476,
0.2922907769680023,
-0.09671392291784286,
0.3323465585708618,
-0.7404792904853821,
0.3883648216724396,
0.4889069199562073,
-0.5472179055213928,
-0.03627204895019531,
-0.46960335969924927,
-1.042854905128479,
0.4825630784034729,
-0.015559704042971134,
-1.2892262935638428,
-0.2635319232940674,
-0.037160638719797134,
-0.26529085636138916,
0.5106984972953796,
-0.5023670792579651,
1.084756851196289,
0.05201073735952377,
-0.057920653373003006,
0.17974019050598145,
-0.8190732598304749,
0.4142765998840332,
0.1913675218820572,
0.3666313588619232,
0.08965674787759781,
0.8091493248939514,
0.17481662333011627,
-0.06282076984643936,
1.0503126382827759,
-0.00829392671585083,
-0.3851744532585144,
0.5467287302017212,
0.09712142497301102,
0.4845603108406067,
0.18863260746002197,
0.4263918399810791,
0.4329708218574524,
-0.2839209735393524,
0.030239827930927277,
-0.4270656406879425,
0.5897403955459595,
-0.8069477677345276,
-0.7963244915008545,
-0.1471395194530487,
-0.32596561312675476,
-0.4007924795150757,
-0.11186833679676056,
0.4741893708705902,
0.5374532341957092,
-0.8508060574531555,
0.36956217885017395,
0.578566312789917,
-0.30148011445999146,
0.22903397679328918,
0.38153669238090515,
-0.19776953756809235,
-0.4302669167518616,
0.49331793189048767,
-0.3919665217399597,
0.5368099212646484,
0.5014498233795166,
0.0952175036072731,
-0.06379145383834839,
0.04352397844195366,
-0.17726613581180573,
-0.1444227695465088,
-1.1621304750442505,
-0.28719446063041687,
-0.6815109848976135,
-0.4521900415420532,
-0.42492371797561646,
-0.3523084819316864,
0.03608381003141403,
0.1777958869934082,
-0.253155380487442,
-0.1472594141960144,
0.038133248686790466,
0.7356859445571899,
0.2539423108100891,
0.555301308631897,
-0.8808793425559998,
0.31805357336997986,
0.6176267862319946,
0.09170019626617432,
0.019339406862854958,
-0.5918291211128235,
-0.1826082468032837,
0.3202478885650635,
-0.5041546821594238,
-0.8439569473266602,
0.36359381675720215,
0.19251969456672668,
0.6283392310142517,
0.3859666883945465,
0.002105011371895671,
0.7378656268119812,
-0.7270639538764954,
1.1879183053970337,
-0.021347476169466972,
-1.0750657320022583,
0.6739816665649414,
-0.47029009461402893,
0.759864330291748,
0.4110228419303894,
0.4289613962173462,
-0.9008057713508606,
-0.40138161182403564,
-0.44965726137161255,
-0.9326775074005127,
0.7564628720283508,
0.09522801637649536,
0.5564336776733398,
-0.16042429208755493,
0.22893770039081573,
0.050299134105443954,
-0.009059932082891464,
-0.8898789286613464,
-0.1285439133644104,
-0.16341622173786163,
0.2008592039346695,
-0.17277027666568756,
-0.2473091334104538,
-0.4312836229801178,
-0.4483414888381958,
0.25653913617134094,
-0.4321959614753723,
0.7147354483604431,
0.2045380175113678,
-0.1132984608411789,
-0.19086474180221558,
0.5630673766136169,
0.7890624403953552,
0.6857288479804993,
-0.0834912583231926,
-0.015553710050880909,
0.6338868141174316,
-0.21124112606048584,
-0.06214865669608116,
-0.525039792060852,
0.015146005898714066,
-0.011625624261796474,
0.22407160699367523,
1.159288763999939,
0.7285885214805603,
-0.08426537364721298,
0.542842447757721,
-0.4013313055038452,
-0.10089055448770523,
-0.22227101027965546,
-0.16694006323814392,
0.25325489044189453,
0.08174441009759903,
0.35160917043685913,
-0.03891807049512863,
-0.04760083928704262,
-0.6902577877044678,
0.013385428115725517,
0.41811466217041016,
-0.4979144036769867,
-0.23342496156692505,
0.6564815640449524,
0.49127328395843506,
-0.3430924117565155,
0.6026114821434021,
0.20707708597183228,
-0.829037070274353,
0.37210530042648315,
0.8761839866638184,
0.7950554490089417,
-0.11533589661121368,
0.15294526517391205,
0.5314513444900513,
-0.12115870416164398,
0.2737215459346771,
-0.17408929765224457,
-0.5398297905921936,
-0.7627937197685242,
-0.38284236192703247,
-0.45636147260665894,
-0.8062009215354919,
0.20103418827056885,
-0.8785650134086609,
0.007668696343898773,
0.029045134782791138,
-0.10886266082525253,
-0.5161241888999939,
-0.22904984652996063,
-0.7967903017997742,
0.05411870405077934,
0.1229439526796341,
0.5016615986824036,
-0.746357262134552,
0.6150407195091248,
0.2632964551448822,
-0.04031651094555855,
-0.2983814477920532,
0.015199288725852966,
-0.10245279967784882,
-0.6263819336891174,
0.47739654779434204,
0.5471320748329163,
-0.3215264081954956,
-0.2931601405143738,
-0.5547749996185303,
-0.8430966734886169,
1.1650694608688354,
0.26482120156288147,
-0.384176105260849,
-0.03642742335796356,
0.38294363021850586,
0.43671998381614685,
-0.5907790660858154,
0.5542553663253784,
0.6201292872428894,
0.12523487210273743,
0.36751502752304077,
-1.1265619993209839,
-0.10172149538993835,
0.029941502958536148,
0.15281040966510773,
0.3147291839122772,
-0.7181128859519958,
0.7615624070167542,
0.06010056287050247,
-0.5099855661392212,
0.15844938158988953,
0.8891564011573792,
-0.06004641205072403,
0.004382945131510496,
0.12563137710094452,
0.09667322784662247,
0.5970845222473145,
-0.5131452679634094,
0.8303344249725342,
-0.466348797082901,
0.2518302798271179,
1.254589557647705,
-0.3712567687034607,
0.7707325220108032,
0.1597323715686798,
0.07553212344646454,
0.4813084602355957,
0.4413059651851654,
0.5371150374412537,
0.45609042048454285,
0.06679597496986389,
-0.6108070015907288,
-0.2207709699869156,
0.035854075103998184,
-0.580284833908081,
0.5598174333572388,
0.38329368829727173,
0.06984267383813858,
-0.3085169792175293,
0.019440995529294014,
0.1811486929655075,
0.012142873369157314,
-0.27602970600128174,
1.1374231576919556,
0.039760034531354904,
-0.9282029271125793,
0.4279843270778656,
-0.07152360677719116,
0.7075130343437195,
-0.6545845866203308,
0.14384464919567108,
-0.5167098641395569,
0.38761335611343384,
-0.023012004792690277,
-0.44386687874794006,
0.5565078258514404,
-0.1455494463443756,
-0.19884775578975677,
-0.34918835759162903,
0.8019962310791016,
-0.7236234545707703,
0.014879990369081497,
0.28962165117263794,
0.3987862467765808,
0.09163559228181839,
-0.1401934176683426,
-0.26260659098625183,
0.06946267932653427,
-0.11771883070468903,
-0.044135212898254395,
0.40973228216171265,
0.6507627367973328,
-0.1551063358783722,
0.4073593020439148,
0.4574941098690033,
-0.5310475826263428,
-0.1863722801208496,
0.2992255985736847,
0.7300499081611633,
-0.7417001724243164,
-0.7385112643241882,
-0.5376584529876709,
0.7054925560951233,
-0.04651053249835968,
-0.3735799789428711,
0.6589781045913696,
0.14340054988861084,
0.7420550584793091,
-0.053459540009498596,
0.5275413393974304,
0.2975551187992096,
0.2014068365097046,
-0.4813157916069031,
0.6080893278121948,
-0.019922669976949692,
-0.13856753706932068,
-0.15188005566596985,
-0.9823939204216003,
-0.11926865577697754,
1.0163819789886475,
-0.341780424118042,
0.16000498831272125,
0.5789294838905334,
0.5046743750572205,
-0.15718643367290497,
0.6115724444389343,
0.4733864963054657,
-0.05025968328118324,
0.4975060820579529,
0.7200514078140259,
1.0147860050201416,
-0.39962711930274963,
0.574404239654541,
0.20148178935050964,
-0.09215942770242691,
0.03701441362500191,
-1.0436476469039917,
-1.1054197549819946,
-0.49626588821411133,
-0.14518912136554718,
-0.16374365985393524,
-0.28012731671333313,
0.6577386260032654,
0.9391722083091736,
-0.8655323386192322,
-0.3164138197898865,
-0.13637188076972961,
-0.09520338475704193,
0.132851704955101,
-0.3102947175502777,
-0.11717311292886734,
-0.4039997160434723,
-0.7648090124130249,
0.6830540299415588,
0.1686086505651474,
0.13666342198848724,
-0.19757674634456635,
-0.21330925822257996,
0.016787702217698097,
0.08691209554672241,
0.7675095200538635,
0.17284801602363586,
-0.8562418818473816,
-0.5451076030731201,
-0.1520114541053772,
-0.13117235898971558,
0.5968220233917236,
1.2186620235443115,
-0.893113911151886,
0.47938135266304016,
0.07096347212791443,
0.5176618099212646,
0.7855556011199951,
0.1346602439880371,
0.9219110608100891,
-1.1411892175674438,
0.2933913767337799,
0.04408380016684532,
0.3365660607814789,
0.5701211094856262,
-0.39918720722198486,
0.4503744840621948,
0.01896529458463192,
-0.8459752798080444,
-0.5296326279640198,
0.3983144760131836,
-0.6215421557426453,
-0.1002555638551712,
0.9558441042900085,
-0.1462240219116211,
0.18687674403190613,
-0.12371272593736649,
-0.5260007381439209,
0.19074296951293945,
-0.09090817719697952,
0.37459325790405273,
0.788753867149353,
0.12040852010250092,
-0.05582418665289879,
-0.591107189655304,
0.4982675015926361,
0.22959096729755402,
-0.9043437242507935,
0.1044614240527153,
0.4534423351287842,
0.07215458899736404,
0.3196626603603363,
0.8608995079994202,
0.09078332781791687,
-0.13074372708797455,
-0.08356071263551712,
-0.2797781825065613,
0.4308359622955322,
-0.523446798324585,
-0.40943819284439087,
0.3248782455921173,
-0.4313454329967499,
0.023851361125707626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17585v1 | Propagation and Pitfalls: Reasoning-based Assessment of Knowledge Editing through Counterfactual Tasks | 2024-01-31T04:12:59 | 2024-01-31T04:12:59 | Wenyue Hua, Jiang Guo, Mingwen Dong, Henghui Zhu, Patrick Ng, Zhiguo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME | Current approaches of knowledge editing struggle to effectively propagate
updates to interconnected facts. In this work, we delve into the barriers that
hinder the appropriate propagation of updated knowledge within these models for
accurate reasoning. To support our analysis, we introduce a novel
reasoning-based benchmark -- ReCoE (Reasoning-based Counterfactual Editing
dataset) -- which covers six common reasoning schemes in real world. We conduct
a thorough analysis of existing knowledge editing techniques, including input
augmentation, finetuning, and locate-and-edit. We found that all model editing
methods show notably low performance on this dataset, especially in certain
reasoning schemes. Our analysis over the chain-of-thought generation of edited
models further uncover key reasons behind the inadequacy of existing knowledge
editing methods from a reasoning standpoint, involving aspects on fact-wise
editing, fact recall ability, and coherence in generation. We will make our
benchmark publicly available. | [
-0.513918936252594,
-1.1021987199783325,
0.6116838455200195,
-0.276403546333313,
-0.03860222548246384,
0.08522239327430725,
0.20085076987743378,
-0.64548659324646,
-0.15455198287963867,
0.4223346412181854,
-0.75677889585495,
-0.30764240026474,
-0.5630139112472534,
0.1446656882762909,
-0.452566921710968,
0.7008534073829651,
-0.2661151587963104,
-0.2537343502044678,
-0.5659134387969971,
-0.3379729390144348,
-0.8792093992233276,
-0.35802653431892395,
-0.2665084898471832,
-0.38008084893226624,
0.2476290762424469,
0.5488364100456238,
0.8189708590507507,
0.3879438042640686,
0.3261602520942688,
0.2904192805290222,
-0.34605321288108826,
0.4484570026397705,
-0.43808820843696594,
-0.0021981908939778805,
-0.840789794921875,
-0.38986819982528687,
-0.5242171883583069,
0.06766609102487564,
0.44872167706489563,
0.7868115305900574,
-0.04134690761566162,
0.17982785403728485,
-0.24174942076206207,
0.6478845477104187,
-0.8495354056358337,
-0.3115662634372711,
-0.7644674181938171,
0.00021382319391705096,
-0.11904053390026093,
0.22982122004032135,
-0.4121547341346741,
-0.4811049997806549,
0.31595873832702637,
-0.8300831913948059,
0.37427908182144165,
0.05483188480138779,
0.5047243237495422,
0.31489869952201843,
-0.2962293326854706,
-0.1891687512397766,
-0.49466344714164734,
0.6288596987724304,
-0.5678426623344421,
0.5948598980903625,
0.056585345417261124,
0.20041054487228394,
-0.31481102108955383,
-0.6713408827781677,
-0.6887651085853577,
0.08238556981086731,
0.030151136219501495,
0.020258737727999687,
-0.5954196453094482,
0.04414501413702965,
0.6042028069496155,
0.10494506359100342,
-0.33717209100723267,
-0.1932554394006729,
-0.2949792444705963,
-0.10460752248764038,
0.6898375153541565,
-0.021891528740525246,
0.11113511770963669,
-0.0883687287569046,
-0.2748029828071594,
-0.14304617047309875,
-0.9455345273017883,
-0.28129106760025024,
0.2833947539329529,
-0.2084745466709137,
0.1344229131937027,
0.5945128202438354,
-0.4252162575721741,
0.8547225594520569,
0.13853582739830017,
0.23003540933132172,
0.13711239397525787,
-0.437066912651062,
-0.47587403655052185,
-0.0040686349384486675,
0.4122615158557892,
0.636530339717865,
0.24035166203975677,
-0.0010658798273652792,
0.033022623509168625,
0.23831741511821747,
0.4881580173969269,
-0.3253771662712097,
-0.17237481474876404,
0.19190368056297302,
-0.23334912955760956,
-0.4602159857749939,
-0.22198951244354248,
-0.7424905300140381,
-0.3532187044620514,
-0.07227092981338501,
0.6487525701522827,
-0.42707276344299316,
-0.026752332225441933,
0.10744814574718475,
-0.31635090708732605,
-0.3883112072944641,
0.8273894190788269,
-0.28743261098861694,
0.18581628799438477,
0.600733757019043,
0.5954498648643494,
0.05004088953137398,
-0.3614419102668762,
-0.14535404741764069,
-0.06352321058511734,
-0.5179341435432434,
1.005948781967163,
-0.5347644686698914,
-0.5271925330162048,
-0.17106293141841888,
-0.10425672680139542,
-0.19252005219459534,
-0.5822916030883789,
0.5954903364181519,
-0.5565527081489563,
0.12006783485412598,
-0.6014971137046814,
-0.8615195155143738,
-0.520850419998169,
0.2919725775718689,
-0.6037161350250244,
0.7448908090591431,
0.1319042146205902,
-0.956957221031189,
0.4060590863227844,
-0.6275663375854492,
-0.45697715878486633,
-0.36115506291389465,
0.07233038544654846,
-0.3527073264122009,
0.004087203182280064,
0.23785918951034546,
0.09272199124097824,
-0.2890221178531647,
0.45195624232292175,
-0.31916651129722595,
-0.3874915838241577,
0.4175778031349182,
-0.5439221858978271,
0.7338801622390747,
0.27847567200660706,
-0.4532317817211151,
-0.09232630580663681,
-0.8647348880767822,
-0.16544614732265472,
-0.20662900805473328,
0.17777450382709503,
-0.3421795964241028,
0.020032204687595367,
-0.5626559257507324,
0.2872328758239746,
-0.07651534676551819,
-0.6979600191116333,
0.39191922545433044,
-0.06560012698173523,
0.22473156452178955,
0.5783490538597107,
0.49920016527175903,
0.09710852056741714,
-0.7418222427368164,
0.30114230513572693,
0.156953826546669,
0.43518686294555664,
0.04912981018424034,
-0.5963453650474548,
-0.42224904894828796,
0.3509529232978821,
0.3476276099681854,
0.7912746667861938,
-0.9857105612754822,
-0.10392148792743683,
-0.04230828955769539,
-0.9362145066261292,
-0.5766883492469788,
0.14365121722221375,
0.6513795256614685,
1.1583669185638428,
0.6358546614646912,
-0.10803502053022385,
-0.44153186678886414,
-0.911837637424469,
-0.7321584820747375,
-0.16759462654590607,
0.35399582982063293,
0.01899193599820137,
0.6499596238136292,
-0.2593311369419098,
0.6818305253982544,
-0.541615903377533,
0.36095988750457764,
0.10131946206092834,
0.48861536383628845,
-0.07531588524580002,
0.7217358350753784,
0.4026851952075958,
-0.6092850565910339,
-0.09907086938619614,
-0.15887151658535004,
-0.799370527267456,
-0.390460729598999,
-0.2868885099887848,
-0.2205914705991745,
0.252211332321167,
0.5352340340614319,
-0.7267910242080688,
0.7476276159286499,
0.2738420069217682,
-0.32495859265327454,
0.8369607925415039,
-0.14536909759044647,
0.7125318050384521,
-0.4521370530128479,
0.12560853362083435,
-0.04829845577478409,
-0.05629195645451546,
-0.7371861934661865,
0.20835445821285248,
0.013315417803823948,
0.21349596977233887,
-0.4943118989467621,
0.399676114320755,
-0.0861850455403328,
0.06264595687389374,
0.080863356590271,
0.24695666134357452,
0.22798320651054382,
0.35486677289009094,
0.055274758487939835,
0.6133041381835938,
0.15848292410373688,
-0.505829393863678,
0.3703117370605469,
0.40786293148994446,
-0.5604560375213623,
0.9778726100921631,
-0.5842598676681519,
0.20446835458278656,
-0.021304545924067497,
0.0669974610209465,
-0.8843904733657837,
0.08000092953443527,
0.3785960078239441,
-0.2645737826824188,
-0.025626247748732567,
-0.06309372931718826,
-0.3685385286808014,
-0.08906982094049454,
-0.21457964181900024,
0.5221785306930542,
0.25822725892066956,
-0.5018752217292786,
0.23667067289352417,
-0.03647730126976967,
-0.012826750986278057,
-0.7499513626098633,
-0.8861486911773682,
-0.01306134182959795,
-0.13616856932640076,
-0.7024291753768921,
0.2467719465494156,
-0.18567484617233276,
-0.6618489027023315,
0.24022983014583588,
-0.24669353663921356,
0.05222546309232712,
0.13002529740333557,
0.012324691750109196,
0.18378722667694092,
0.14235319197177887,
0.23268777132034302,
0.4916335344314575,
0.09820663183927536,
0.11465515941381454,
0.03273665904998779,
-0.3855096101760864,
0.322620153427124,
-0.6048738956451416,
-0.3863339126110077,
0.09983605146408081,
0.6112072467803955,
-0.024306263774633408,
0.4578739106655121,
0.0036519141867756844,
-0.4310024380683899,
-0.17165076732635498,
-0.9464499354362488,
0.15003728866577148,
-0.3565867245197296,
0.28211289644241333,
-0.547878623008728,
-0.42917975783348083,
0.4367722272872925,
-0.4189847409725189,
0.2880966365337372,
0.6452596187591553,
-0.07895488291978836,
-0.20206379890441895,
0.5782278180122375,
0.03162062540650368,
0.6129529476165771,
0.17828798294067383,
-0.2133224606513977,
-0.1773633509874344,
-0.7939149141311646,
-0.1365794837474823,
-0.41304269433021545,
-0.05041022598743439,
-0.6572061777114868,
-0.6642338037490845,
0.16023260354995728,
0.31222760677337646,
-0.3933209776878357,
0.3236876428127289,
-0.3660581409931183,
0.1982603222131729,
0.6008105278015137,
0.25326666235923767,
0.6345410943031311,
-0.32790860533714294,
-0.05107131227850914,
-0.05583685636520386,
-0.9527836441993713,
-0.2974194884300232,
0.9573686122894287,
0.17010250687599182,
0.6052748560905457,
0.05534769222140312,
0.3203558921813965,
0.6880756616592407,
0.4326319694519043,
-0.14373022317886353,
0.41190972924232483,
-0.11325767636299133,
-0.643273115158081,
-0.4628365933895111,
-0.4466635286808014,
-0.3178427815437317,
0.303464412689209,
-0.49472975730895996,
-0.5447807312011719,
0.8014129400253296,
0.5135536789894104,
-0.14339007437229156,
0.6202901601791382,
-0.8390267491340637,
1.0108314752578735,
0.06818220019340515,
-0.6612077355384827,
-0.41252008080482483,
-0.44182664155960083,
0.5112122893333435,
-0.19219085574150085,
0.5063724517822266,
0.3071134090423584,
0.25671738386154175,
0.6878856420516968,
-0.6296883821487427,
0.5635144114494324,
-0.33914628624916077,
-0.048332925885915756,
0.7392174005508423,
0.49326518177986145,
0.8428441286087036,
-0.03115769475698471,
-0.276344358921051,
0.27208057045936584,
0.14085108041763306,
-0.2554433345794678,
-0.8981322050094604,
0.40905463695526123,
-0.4875169098377228,
-0.758646547794342,
-0.26513993740081787,
-0.3916378617286682,
-0.54410719871521,
0.11448825150728226,
0.4529642164707184,
0.6312005519866943,
-0.40101638436317444,
-0.07759483903646469,
0.7131260633468628,
-0.25384607911109924,
0.025254150852560997,
0.35965585708618164,
0.07355226576328278,
-0.547771155834198,
0.6529589295387268,
0.5590393543243408,
0.6238324046134949,
0.26992812752723694,
0.11630899459123611,
-0.15050174295902252,
-0.5948482751846313,
-0.6020289659500122,
-0.06069531664252281,
-0.8891972303390503,
-0.044218260794878006,
-0.5036619901657104,
0.030155951157212257,
-0.34223413467407227,
-0.3641963005065918,
-0.4502599239349365,
-0.5780137181282043,
0.06076931580901146,
-0.23622362315654755,
0.3641607165336609,
0.9689252376556396,
-0.4227295517921448,
0.08049946278333664,
-0.48535796999931335,
0.4453868269920349,
0.4822709262371063,
0.4206734895706177,
0.2273237109184265,
-0.5463505387306213,
-0.12201114743947983,
0.26388978958129883,
-0.24851955473423004,
-1.030167818069458,
-0.14200139045715332,
-0.335506796836853,
0.5266224145889282,
-0.006391457282006741,
0.1535828560590744,
0.856598436832428,
-0.4155925512313843,
0.5628275871276855,
0.0143611254170537,
-1.133614182472229,
0.6692435145378113,
-0.1602449119091034,
0.4340866804122925,
0.5979934334754944,
0.2774643898010254,
-0.6012736558914185,
-0.3359234631061554,
-0.8899980187416077,
-0.2706248462200165,
0.48026469349861145,
0.12841510772705078,
-0.43053850531578064,
-0.04620080441236496,
0.4549717903137207,
0.3096899390220642,
0.35233744978904724,
-0.27997153997421265,
-0.15368835628032684,
-0.474232941865921,
0.25157058238983154,
0.17814458906650543,
-0.46293577551841736,
-0.06535238772630692,
-0.29054516553878784,
0.8814592361450195,
0.17786777019500732,
-0.10741132497787476,
0.8956116437911987,
-0.3934956192970276,
-0.39927780628204346,
0.47783705592155457,
0.9680926203727722,
0.9162523746490479,
-0.4350445568561554,
0.04714316502213478,
0.5724573135375977,
-0.3916623890399933,
0.1790313869714737,
0.040194764733314514,
-0.4938623905181885,
0.00782763585448265,
0.7003160715103149,
0.7747296094894409,
0.48734647035598755,
-0.5129290819168091,
0.2608528733253479,
0.1224852129817009,
-0.5254318118095398,
0.15815116465091705,
0.11482247710227966,
0.0721304789185524,
0.21703746914863586,
0.06168023496866226,
0.5914504528045654,
0.2199384570121765,
-0.4915699362754822,
0.15154844522476196,
0.02577621303498745,
-0.2685511112213135,
-0.23152177035808563,
0.6144932508468628,
0.28040847182273865,
-0.17127546668052673,
0.6535263657569885,
-0.2301778644323349,
-0.25904014706611633,
0.3957647681236267,
0.17052428424358368,
0.689818263053894,
-0.2482512891292572,
0.25157707929611206,
0.4227754771709442,
0.49194037914276123,
-0.010631976649165154,
0.2045823335647583,
0.037107810378074646,
-0.8936008214950562,
-0.5880777835845947,
0.13681666553020477,
-0.8246393203735352,
0.13012833893299103,
-0.4505726397037506,
0.055919043719768524,
-0.25708866119384766,
-0.08545573800802231,
0.15265753865242004,
-0.062248386442661285,
-0.6328495144844055,
0.5072346329689026,
-0.39338570833206177,
1.3277572393417358,
-0.8556563854217529,
0.4736459255218506,
0.6263510584831238,
-0.16754060983657837,
-0.27183520793914795,
-0.2538875341415405,
0.11202758550643921,
-0.2888721227645874,
0.3862987160682678,
-0.30041706562042236,
-0.22985883057117462,
-0.30644699931144714,
-0.3686518967151642,
-0.6913607120513916,
0.8605753183364868,
0.3933887779712677,
-0.9305540323257446,
0.04778565466403961,
-0.0296020470559597,
0.39382144808769226,
-0.11200451850891113,
0.15009477734565735,
0.5277367830276489,
0.5985886454582214,
0.1241701990365982,
-0.8895895481109619,
0.2503630220890045,
-0.11091596633195877,
-0.2982622981071472,
-0.02190408855676651,
-0.5386030077934265,
0.7887061834335327,
-0.2579323649406433,
-0.08745405822992325,
-0.04690781608223915,
0.22581903636455536,
0.23029792308807373,
0.6250582337379456,
0.5989235639572144,
0.8339736461639404,
0.6521356105804443,
0.03768093138933182,
0.8953946232795715,
0.013171683996915817,
0.09937909245491028,
1.4069757461547852,
-0.12051219493150711,
0.6893056035041809,
0.2873077988624573,
-0.14148250222206116,
0.7695342302322388,
0.32843032479286194,
-0.04621922969818115,
0.3795345425605774,
0.11918721348047256,
-0.1232137605547905,
-0.21165122091770172,
-0.0576535202562809,
-0.3796517252922058,
0.33016419410705566,
0.2822394371032715,
-0.08874425292015076,
-0.08168575912714005,
-0.10571353137493134,
0.16299982368946075,
0.35640910267829895,
-0.3092167377471924,
0.5162220001220703,
-0.1822754442691803,
-1.0462449789047241,
0.3906886577606201,
-0.12332690507173538,
0.26836958527565,
-0.18303312361240387,
-0.5395573377609253,
-0.20135727524757385,
-0.09506241977214813,
-0.1836978644132614,
-0.9560179114341736,
0.5461553335189819,
0.038287192583084106,
-0.07456880062818527,
-0.11714831739664078,
0.9068158268928528,
-0.14558841288089752,
-0.34707653522491455,
0.10669767111539841,
0.7320427298545837,
-0.0959540382027626,
-0.0016685669543221593,
-0.7442430257797241,
0.1753910481929779,
0.02758754976093769,
-0.31087300181388855,
-0.18167506158351898,
0.5468230843544006,
-0.33865514397621155,
0.586885392665863,
0.4691702723503113,
0.11031129956245422,
-0.2607642412185669,
0.04349549859762192,
0.5423732995986938,
-0.8322578072547913,
-0.34174641966819763,
-0.6271089911460876,
0.48936766386032104,
-0.12978777289390564,
-0.3797076940536499,
0.6484559178352356,
0.1830807626247406,
0.9917390942573547,
-0.051710110157728195,
0.8375360369682312,
0.10602624714374542,
0.7083321213722229,
-0.44630497694015503,
0.5610681772232056,
-0.33334967494010925,
0.0593874417245388,
-0.7538023591041565,
-0.5451529026031494,
-0.14914445579051971,
0.24180737137794495,
-0.5164940357208252,
-0.03550637513399124,
0.6452155709266663,
0.6164042353630066,
0.1281031221151352,
0.3416355848312378,
0.40633538365364075,
0.5380440950393677,
0.04333724081516266,
0.41187262535095215,
0.869877815246582,
-0.7313847541809082,
0.16235670447349548,
-0.7432950735092163,
-0.08307279646396637,
-0.1070137470960617,
-1.0685065984725952,
-0.6650911569595337,
-0.34963977336883545,
-0.6513439416885376,
-0.17999525368213654,
0.6292650699615479,
0.5003701448440552,
0.4814632534980774,
-0.6475881934165955,
0.12670540809631348,
-0.5619283318519592,
0.6658715605735779,
-0.619934618473053,
-0.18053586781024933,
0.38481763005256653,
0.24695390462875366,
-0.3864481449127197,
0.309717059135437,
-0.0253470279276371,
-0.0462329275906086,
0.02210947498679161,
0.22611749172210693,
-0.6533382534980774,
0.25283920764923096,
0.5975021719932556,
0.43716275691986084,
-0.6571497917175293,
-0.6286203861236572,
-0.24629543721675873,
0.3774479031562805,
-0.1810331642627716,
0.5129143595695496,
-0.9676506519317627,
0.8693938851356506,
0.572604775428772,
0.48809853196144104,
0.273343563079834,
0.2498432844877243,
0.5711928606033325,
-0.3954780697822571,
-0.2197917103767395,
-0.18810546398162842,
0.2465905249118805,
0.4104001820087433,
-0.44715866446495056,
0.6831946969032288,
0.7166195511817932,
-0.5232298374176025,
-0.8742610216140747,
0.1214485764503479,
-0.6304910778999329,
-0.5605310201644897,
0.6540467739105225,
-0.19135622680187225,
-0.08640936762094498,
-0.31727364659309387,
-0.18532465398311615,
0.42498311400413513,
-0.0030293967574834824,
0.8178309202194214,
0.7354446649551392,
-0.5070430636405945,
-0.09735530614852905,
-0.5774447321891785,
0.5489796996116638,
0.4400540292263031,
-0.8001548647880554,
0.2178984135389328,
0.7252283096313477,
0.41369447112083435,
0.23465709388256073,
0.319145530462265,
-0.03173965960741043,
0.8561393022537231,
0.5400512218475342,
0.02846129797399044,
-0.40309298038482666,
-0.24904178082942963,
-0.12489630281925201,
0.06080159917473793,
0.022547053173184395,
0.04124761372804642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17574v1 | Scavenging Hyena: Distilling Transformers into Long Convolution Models | 2024-01-31T03:39:07 | 2024-01-31T03:39:07 | Tokiniaina Raharison Ralambomihanta, Shahrad Mohammadzadeh, Mohammad Sami Nur Islam, Wassim Jabbour, Laurence Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs), epitomized by
architectures like GPT-4, has reshaped the landscape of natural language
processing. This paper introduces a pioneering approach to address the
efficiency concerns associated with LLM pre-training, proposing the use of
knowledge distillation for cross-architecture transfer. Leveraging insights
from the efficient Hyena mechanism, our method replaces attention heads in
transformer models by Hyena, offering a cost-effective alternative to
traditional pre-training while confronting the challenge of processing long
contextual information, inherent in quadratic attention mechanisms. Unlike
conventional compression-focused methods, our technique not only enhances
inference speed but also surpasses pre-training in terms of both accuracy and
efficiency. In the era of evolving LLMs, our work contributes to the pursuit of
sustainable AI solutions, striking a balance between computational power and
environmental impact. | [
-0.43592485785484314,
-0.5077861547470093,
0.5282600522041321,
0.2340409904718399,
-0.3734934628009796,
0.2191893309354782,
-0.2955233156681061,
-0.5021163821220398,
0.14204257726669312,
0.3819819390773773,
-0.41654086112976074,
0.11086522787809372,
-0.839499294757843,
0.07396066188812256,
-0.4232521057128906,
0.7966451644897461,
0.1796136051416397,
-0.39014601707458496,
-0.13435082137584686,
-0.20575912296772003,
-0.09465803951025009,
-0.603990375995636,
-0.5801453590393066,
-0.5966712236404419,
0.7021031975746155,
0.026224574074149132,
0.6718166470527649,
0.8067288994789124,
0.3377132713794708,
0.3466888964176178,
-0.08429654687643051,
-0.1495521515607834,
-0.6894282698631287,
0.08703573793172836,
-0.41400232911109924,
-0.34330543875694275,
-0.09848231077194214,
0.15966308116912842,
0.3361169397830963,
0.44641244411468506,
-0.25562238693237305,
0.43939027190208435,
0.4127003848552704,
0.9028769731521606,
-0.8630235195159912,
0.23949383199214935,
-0.9142729043960571,
-0.020103653892874718,
-0.2530724108219147,
-0.3787632882595062,
-0.24044713377952576,
-0.3684244453907013,
0.47499600052833557,
-0.568304717540741,
0.1280122697353363,
-0.12484556436538696,
0.8611333966255188,
0.9144110083580017,
0.09939251840114594,
-0.24338451027870178,
-0.8786086440086365,
0.9119837880134583,
-0.530043363571167,
0.4438510835170746,
0.40235164761543274,
0.46040472388267517,
-0.11892546713352203,
-1.2598021030426025,
-0.7149896025657654,
-0.032157570123672485,
-0.0892709270119667,
-0.1379004269838333,
-0.7038947939872742,
-0.19019220769405365,
0.24733895063400269,
0.42046910524368286,
-0.2555687129497528,
0.08437973260879517,
-0.6710823178291321,
-0.0028770805802196264,
0.3828253149986267,
-0.27938053011894226,
-0.04770917445421219,
0.13907800614833832,
-0.5267835855484009,
-0.07356392592191696,
-0.8078584671020508,
0.023344771936535835,
0.14332981407642365,
0.0360998697578907,
0.20925560593605042,
0.5220160484313965,
-0.007314852438867092,
0.5317725539207458,
0.2771379351615906,
-0.1257559210062027,
0.17638736963272095,
-0.2856605648994446,
-0.5398279428482056,
0.21779340505599976,
0.5583385229110718,
-0.001509445603005588,
0.2000109851360321,
-0.15438318252563477,
0.04764441400766373,
-0.01583455316722393,
0.6543168425559998,
-1.0759882926940918,
-0.40988409519195557,
0.0385466031730175,
-0.5201852321624756,
-0.21581728756427765,
-0.481689453125,
-1.015324592590332,
-0.2584521770477295,
-0.5795639157295227,
0.25721409916877747,
-0.178436279296875,
-0.1620536744594574,
0.30607011914253235,
-0.37955695390701294,
0.43336987495422363,
0.07606254518032074,
-1.1441558599472046,
0.14983722567558289,
0.5578756928443909,
0.8322568535804749,
-0.11046956479549408,
-0.26984813809394836,
-0.5191707015037537,
0.2723641097545624,
0.18444998562335968,
0.64081209897995,
-0.43211647868156433,
-0.17103414237499237,
-0.1337130069732666,
-0.07571810483932495,
0.19616249203681946,
-0.6493240594863892,
0.5869940519332886,
-0.5160784125328064,
-0.17047390341758728,
-0.27504655718803406,
-0.20740902423858643,
-0.2759033143520355,
0.2629683315753937,
-0.8633279204368591,
1.11391282081604,
0.19472065567970276,
-0.9090616106987,
0.2583804726600647,
-0.48027050495147705,
-0.5632590651512146,
0.08033686131238937,
-0.029576072469353676,
-0.3418613076210022,
0.05954425781965256,
0.33914700150489807,
0.5815183520317078,
-0.5266405344009399,
0.19313836097717285,
-0.3134264647960663,
-0.12598028779029846,
-0.36476242542266846,
-0.368375301361084,
0.7644302248954773,
0.36228400468826294,
-0.4938772916793823,
-0.04775834083557129,
-0.7575627565383911,
-0.4151075482368469,
0.1433587670326233,
-0.6126943826675415,
-0.7626643180847168,
0.06386052072048187,
-0.46469759941101074,
0.3482493460178375,
0.3858325779438019,
-0.3797156512737274,
0.2941232919692993,
-0.027871113270521164,
0.7482345700263977,
0.8263517618179321,
-0.324057012796402,
0.6130084991455078,
-0.20918355882167816,
0.3328417241573334,
-0.10139407962560654,
0.17031921446323395,
0.007427598815411329,
-0.1682664304971695,
-0.9280190467834473,
-0.41227784752845764,
-0.15965645015239716,
0.3454549312591553,
-1.08279287815094,
0.3796602487564087,
-0.3558511435985565,
-0.8098983764648438,
-0.6805755496025085,
0.2217811495065689,
0.051801472902297974,
0.5456739068031311,
0.5910110473632812,
0.06714694201946259,
-0.7068465948104858,
-0.9434556365013123,
-0.3159448504447937,
-0.034819819033145905,
0.06403065472841263,
0.02359524928033352,
0.33924469351768494,
-0.2856009006500244,
1.0516092777252197,
-0.445910781621933,
-0.18305617570877075,
-0.4701434373855591,
0.17760451138019562,
0.11626236140727997,
0.38074666261672974,
0.8058266043663025,
-0.6603860855102539,
-0.3458932638168335,
-0.224437415599823,
-0.6958245635032654,
-0.10308665782213211,
-0.03325151279568672,
-0.31165215373039246,
-0.14742130041122437,
0.7118796706199646,
-0.8655651807785034,
0.38173723220825195,
0.7437904477119446,
0.15622921288013458,
0.4914352297782898,
-0.13811975717544556,
-0.029701663181185722,
-1.0853886604309082,
0.2680984437465668,
0.19168876111507416,
-0.06693952530622482,
-0.6147242784500122,
-0.19950932264328003,
-0.12532173097133636,
0.07433631271123886,
-0.6289843320846558,
0.5015449523925781,
-0.7428048849105835,
0.05100363492965698,
-0.379985511302948,
-0.07183990627527237,
0.011537937447428703,
0.6819430589675903,
0.07147050648927689,
0.6524395942687988,
0.38665708899497986,
-0.824356734752655,
0.4566420316696167,
0.16291862726211548,
-0.3045406639575958,
0.37884071469306946,
-0.6324748396873474,
0.3273177146911621,
-0.18050970137119293,
0.4102693498134613,
-0.5419739484786987,
0.40011945366859436,
0.24671237170696259,
0.012461764737963676,
0.3218802511692047,
-0.11234601587057114,
-0.2367461770772934,
-0.5122873187065125,
-0.2866014838218689,
0.5780670046806335,
0.7123619318008423,
-0.959830641746521,
0.9339877367019653,
0.4615781307220459,
-0.27972692251205444,
-0.6698228716850281,
-0.6793327927589417,
0.1296677142381668,
-0.5154337286949158,
-0.45000967383384705,
0.3635903596878052,
0.04684961587190628,
-0.3026144504547119,
-0.11620841175317764,
-0.21122096478939056,
0.0031075470615178347,
0.11356387287378311,
-0.06611970067024231,
-0.06648930162191391,
-0.14280907809734344,
0.01500049140304327,
-0.053666286170482635,
0.00809409748762846,
0.054232142865657806,
-0.5441093444824219,
0.7031646370887756,
0.21764564514160156,
0.10228551924228668,
-0.6418895125389099,
0.08420021086931229,
0.916587233543396,
-0.5271530151367188,
0.5501517653465271,
0.4862861931324005,
-0.3615114092826843,
-0.23990361392498016,
-0.5966207385063171,
-0.22367864847183228,
-0.5396776795387268,
0.4072420001029968,
-0.4438539445400238,
-0.8177089095115662,
0.1272992193698883,
-0.45399636030197144,
0.1646927297115326,
0.3553251326084137,
0.6068708300590515,
0.10102606564760208,
0.424972265958786,
0.9519588947296143,
-0.5221326947212219,
0.7694140672683716,
-0.3535160720348358,
0.4834008812904358,
-0.7724645733833313,
-0.13602636754512787,
-0.9608609080314636,
-0.3991234600543976,
-0.378371000289917,
-0.5646350383758545,
0.04554961249232292,
0.04729939624667168,
-0.19041447341442108,
0.6211700439453125,
-0.5583036541938782,
0.4275892376899719,
0.6103153824806213,
-0.10665670782327652,
0.34561800956726074,
0.048351071774959564,
0.29280251264572144,
0.12511199712753296,
-0.68705153465271,
-0.5511111617088318,
0.9360321760177612,
0.4581696093082428,
1.0114620923995972,
-0.21043790876865387,
0.6445626020431519,
0.2626774311065674,
0.4355654716491699,
-0.8312115669250488,
0.39638230204582214,
-0.15543615818023682,
-0.3199763596057892,
-0.48566070199012756,
-0.21785859763622284,
-0.9454001784324646,
0.5136691927909851,
0.04057652875781059,
-0.6265386939048767,
0.27068647742271423,
0.07442726939916611,
-0.4859689474105835,
0.5622502565383911,
-0.4401960074901581,
0.8070549964904785,
-0.21578848361968994,
-0.5434435606002808,
-0.46928760409355164,
-0.6102062463760376,
0.46198272705078125,
-0.21326829493045807,
0.04410373792052269,
-0.113975889980793,
0.1605805605649948,
0.6072492003440857,
-0.27170780301094055,
0.7155154943466187,
-0.22676658630371094,
-0.3245365619659424,
0.3691135048866272,
-0.025893064215779305,
0.6789340376853943,
-0.3229343593120575,
-0.14191663265228271,
0.241566464304924,
-0.20270992815494537,
-0.43815508484840393,
-0.6553189754486084,
0.3288350999355316,
-0.658110499382019,
-0.7983142137527466,
-0.4593256711959839,
-0.35354405641555786,
0.09605081379413605,
0.15090720355510712,
0.15742036700248718,
0.0015877928817644715,
-0.3359992802143097,
0.3222831189632416,
0.5703303217887878,
-0.05484505370259285,
0.6776933073997498,
0.30312204360961914,
0.10786837339401245,
-0.020928356796503067,
0.6673715114593506,
0.13358895480632782,
0.28564563393592834,
0.31033381819725037,
0.2579145133495331,
-0.38956645131111145,
-0.7547125220298767,
-0.3369818329811096,
0.11403033137321472,
-0.5642209649085999,
-0.15105801820755005,
-0.9695847630500793,
-0.18641836941242218,
-0.26926106214523315,
-0.11492744088172913,
-0.4970204830169678,
-0.05902061611413956,
-0.5649577975273132,
-0.17336274683475494,
0.13027244806289673,
0.6926175951957703,
-0.10905736684799194,
0.4497394561767578,
-1.0685368776321411,
0.4788954555988312,
0.6039956212043762,
-0.025192534551024437,
0.15797817707061768,
-0.5147663950920105,
-0.35961514711380005,
0.11714708060026169,
-0.3038669526576996,
-0.572866678237915,
0.5976489782333374,
0.31147101521492004,
0.7512500286102295,
0.21255865693092346,
0.11280322819948196,
0.6910386681556702,
-0.474310040473938,
0.6778233051300049,
0.2369745820760727,
-0.9410298466682434,
0.27523091435432434,
0.06388284265995026,
0.28577396273612976,
0.5956927537918091,
0.5609642863273621,
-0.43097391724586487,
-0.26075083017349243,
-0.2837792932987213,
-0.8736814856529236,
0.5136857628822327,
0.16846215724945068,
0.1433086097240448,
0.12663152813911438,
0.24396800994873047,
0.39046841859817505,
0.15899094939231873,
-0.46508103609085083,
0.11808238178491592,
-0.45317578315734863,
-0.041603606194257736,
-0.16902977228164673,
-0.28809550404548645,
-0.0162965077906847,
-0.6116547584533691,
0.8574726581573486,
-0.2075011432170868,
-0.21879535913467407,
0.13502533733844757,
-0.5014798641204834,
0.35279616713523865,
0.25314992666244507,
0.307012140750885,
0.4750368893146515,
-0.04080568999052048,
0.40262091159820557,
0.09015681594610214,
-0.6588159203529358,
0.4360107481479645,
0.06559102982282639,
0.16238680481910706,
-0.30491283535957336,
0.10079436004161835,
0.7434384822845459,
0.11949042975902557,
-0.2603207528591156,
0.23842063546180725,
-0.32753604650497437,
-0.09157216548919678,
-0.1579597145318985,
-0.0797978863120079,
0.2995156943798065,
0.49587464332580566,
0.5178811550140381,
0.08313696086406708,
0.12776552140712738,
-0.6230326890945435,
0.34808507561683655,
0.12120234966278076,
-0.2234545201063156,
-0.35610270500183105,
0.47049736976623535,
0.573229193687439,
-0.1553039401769638,
0.7893689274787903,
-0.08914167433977127,
-0.43761560320854187,
0.40468284487724304,
0.4696536064147949,
1.1992385387420654,
-0.31546080112457275,
-0.05943048372864723,
0.29449087381362915,
0.3127977252006531,
-0.3248710632324219,
-0.14444789290428162,
-0.44733285903930664,
-0.711090087890625,
-0.3841514587402344,
-1.0408849716186523,
-0.055732373148202896,
0.23819388449192047,
-0.5931592583656311,
0.14607496559619904,
-0.27535054087638855,
-0.16985969245433807,
0.11871811747550964,
-0.2642373740673065,
-0.7707976698875427,
-0.20200863480567932,
0.2027837485074997,
0.9132373332977295,
-0.7585156559944153,
1.2803311347961426,
0.27449831366539,
-0.4177045226097107,
-0.6099327206611633,
0.09236470609903336,
-0.3194257616996765,
-0.7637550234794617,
0.6900984644889832,
0.18550746142864227,
-0.400162011384964,
0.23526667058467865,
-0.647066056728363,
-0.9443620443344116,
1.219018816947937,
0.6536405682563782,
-1.0301612615585327,
-0.30975544452667236,
0.14883139729499817,
0.49173763394355774,
-0.0885675922036171,
-0.17004847526550293,
1.324567437171936,
0.5774309039115906,
0.1402030736207962,
-0.9568522572517395,
0.15127432346343994,
-0.27343490719795227,
-0.03584740683436394,
0.03101891651749611,
-0.725951075553894,
0.7454578876495361,
-0.19740308821201324,
-0.37582695484161377,
-0.004954264499247074,
0.8079555630683899,
0.16637495160102844,
-0.0798361748456955,
0.5459021329879761,
0.9002094864845276,
0.7402889728546143,
0.040544163435697556,
0.8808913230895996,
-0.28002968430519104,
0.14074385166168213,
1.1290338039398193,
-0.4618491232395172,
0.6086686849594116,
1.0044031143188477,
-0.2096489667892456,
0.3877416253089905,
0.526573121547699,
0.11066359281539917,
0.8440065383911133,
0.6751171946525574,
-0.2770061790943146,
-0.06460490822792053,
-0.05325322225689888,
-0.23247511684894562,
0.7326345443725586,
0.22605273127555847,
-0.21609506011009216,
-0.4886179566383362,
0.08146507292985916,
0.11266188323497772,
-0.1696942150592804,
-0.34026822447776794,
0.8687953352928162,
0.39401504397392273,
-0.8972093462944031,
0.8140215873718262,
-0.42872917652130127,
1.0347734689712524,
-0.5231295824050903,
-0.10397695749998093,
-0.12797123193740845,
0.42321348190307617,
-0.08018692582845688,
-0.48475465178489685,
0.5245716571807861,
-0.05546033754944801,
-0.28393426537513733,
-0.4705314338207245,
0.6965252757072449,
-0.5202552080154419,
-0.19858276844024658,
0.6501203179359436,
0.5566356778144836,
0.1331082135438919,
-0.4681709408760071,
-0.5167336463928223,
0.019688306376338005,
0.039565734565258026,
-0.429444283246994,
0.2427365481853485,
0.441484272480011,
-0.01723354496061802,
0.6146760582923889,
0.7930346727371216,
-0.053502634167671204,
0.28706276416778564,
0.0056197200901806355,
1.1310030221939087,
-0.6624821424484253,
-0.5550883412361145,
-1.1828622817993164,
0.30392536520957947,
-0.030033916234970093,
-0.08470548689365387,
0.43476951122283936,
0.549389123916626,
0.7677759528160095,
0.028153372928500175,
1.142398476600647,
0.06109258159995079,
0.08452585339546204,
-0.3427950441837311,
1.034364104270935,
-0.3664192855358124,
0.035731587558984756,
-0.015086108818650246,
-1.1352065801620483,
0.13680632412433624,
0.3558848202228546,
-0.07012256234884262,
-0.1997338980436325,
0.7682655453681946,
0.4894025921821594,
-0.20260848104953766,
0.036276381462812424,
0.125509575009346,
0.22508054971694946,
0.7342206239700317,
0.6006118655204773,
0.9139673113822937,
-0.09775360673666,
0.5776563882827759,
-0.2857925295829773,
-0.27129343152046204,
-0.13741742074489594,
-1.061009168624878,
-0.7901569604873657,
-0.5451269745826721,
-0.043539952486753464,
-0.15181227028369904,
0.08551954478025436,
0.7037002444267273,
0.7215550541877747,
-0.3751404583454132,
-0.18534162640571594,
0.047974176704883575,
-0.17836342751979828,
-0.29659202694892883,
-0.10441912710666656,
0.5569201707839966,
-0.343292236328125,
-0.7735517024993896,
0.4392755627632141,
0.42349934577941895,
0.2159949690103531,
-0.5554618835449219,
-0.047861479222774506,
-0.3317825496196747,
0.15915627777576447,
0.8162673711776733,
0.46189016103744507,
-0.4072381556034088,
-0.32830706238746643,
-0.11739988625049591,
-0.2714936435222626,
0.2446945160627365,
1.0358625650405884,
-1.0309593677520752,
0.12803757190704346,
0.7166692018508911,
0.9857354760169983,
1.0177021026611328,
-0.08345075696706772,
0.7458239793777466,
-0.37835344672203064,
0.4330267012119293,
0.3336537182331085,
0.5654135942459106,
0.4259650707244873,
-0.21958410739898682,
0.4218069314956665,
0.2031962275505066,
-0.5228710770606995,
-0.6447097063064575,
0.06217808648943901,
-0.9105507135391235,
-0.25912031531333923,
1.151942253112793,
-0.3231092095375061,
-0.6734582781791687,
-0.334011971950531,
-0.2960716187953949,
0.6113317012786865,
-0.34450075030326843,
1.021250605583191,
0.5500103235244751,
0.10326956957578659,
-0.11217567324638367,
-0.2226535975933075,
0.7811420559883118,
0.19362092018127441,
-1.0619382858276367,
0.36258840560913086,
0.241248220205307,
0.31250569224357605,
0.23531611263751984,
0.6730310916900635,
-0.0044415113516151905,
-0.10406967252492905,
-0.11220245063304901,
0.3625650703907013,
-0.09035469591617584,
-0.4810658395290375,
-0.23968380689620972,
0.16638563573360443,
-0.18270163238048553,
-0.36725181341171265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17536v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17536v2 | PipeNet: Question Answering with Semantic Pruning over Knowledge Graphs | 2024-01-31T01:37:33 | 2024-05-17T01:06:46 | Ying Su, Jipeng Zhang, Yangqiu Song, Tong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is well acknowledged that incorporating explicit knowledge graphs (KGs)
can benefit question answering. Existing approaches typically follow a
grounding-reasoning pipeline in which entity nodes are first grounded for the
query (question and candidate answers), and then a reasoning module reasons
over the matched multi-hop subgraph for answer prediction. Although the
pipeline largely alleviates the issue of extracting essential information from
giant KGs, efficiency is still an open challenge when scaling up hops in
grounding the subgraphs. In this paper, we target at finding semantically
related entity nodes in the subgraph to improve the efficiency of graph
reasoning with KG. We propose a grounding-pruning-reasoning pipeline to prune
noisy nodes, remarkably reducing the computation cost and memory usage while
also obtaining decent subgraph representation. In detail, the pruning module
first scores concept nodes based on the dependency distance between matched
spans and then prunes the nodes according to score ranks. To facilitate the
evaluation of pruned subgraphs, we also propose a graph attention network (GAT)
based module to reason with the subgraph data. Experimental results on
CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. | [
-0.5909441113471985,
-0.7943671941757202,
0.6884341239929199,
-0.2775057554244995,
-0.4584212005138397,
-0.10508127510547638,
0.23619385063648224,
-0.04760122299194336,
0.3947499990463257,
0.5842238068580627,
-0.7025288939476013,
-0.6372185945510864,
-0.5791666507720947,
-0.07673469930887222,
-0.27126047015190125,
0.7454931139945984,
0.07330641150474548,
-0.3730647563934326,
-0.43339258432388306,
-0.11948864161968231,
-0.6572201251983643,
-0.03510656580328941,
-0.8313837051391602,
-0.1699209362268448,
0.9985741376876831,
0.4612022638320923,
0.603602409362793,
0.7243073582649231,
0.3830703794956207,
0.2585597336292267,
-0.32857024669647217,
0.3590221107006073,
-0.6338119506835938,
0.39748501777648926,
-0.3348769545555115,
-0.3268207013607025,
-0.10786007344722748,
-0.33498191833496094,
0.5388756990432739,
0.7885686159133911,
0.2199406772851944,
0.3527173399925232,
-0.2628183364868164,
0.6474214792251587,
-0.6726441383361816,
0.3675861656665802,
-0.7630072832107544,
0.09270407259464264,
0.03447237238287926,
-0.36529210209846497,
-0.21828126907348633,
-0.12044839560985565,
0.0036259256303310394,
-0.8804358839988708,
0.12639424204826355,
0.2438683956861496,
0.9268020391464233,
0.6607988476753235,
-0.3960859477519989,
0.0015608075773343444,
-0.21623581647872925,
0.39307284355163574,
-0.42300093173980713,
0.5889014005661011,
0.3641414940357208,
0.304981529712677,
-0.10207666456699371,
-1.0457262992858887,
-0.3115212321281433,
0.22989945113658905,
-0.3155755400657654,
0.45051270723342896,
-0.11490301787853241,
0.2953792214393616,
0.23603412508964539,
0.150974303483963,
-0.526006817817688,
-0.3284916877746582,
-0.5475179553031921,
-0.5097290277481079,
0.22579887509346008,
0.04542624577879906,
0.2505221664905548,
-0.24842774868011475,
-0.08396785706281662,
0.03831827640533447,
-0.5321046710014343,
-0.10024704784154892,
0.47946587204933167,
0.048317283391952515,
0.8095436692237854,
0.6526877880096436,
-0.6153751015663147,
0.8517338633537292,
-0.21633468568325043,
-0.04529959708452225,
-0.0566764697432518,
-0.15090499818325043,
-0.2795260548591614,
0.007924042642116547,
0.350383460521698,
0.4884611666202545,
0.44825035333633423,
-0.6434945464134216,
0.29201561212539673,
0.048836980015039444,
0.38641685247421265,
-0.8773594498634338,
-0.5504307150840759,
0.49469074606895447,
-0.37171122431755066,
-0.0837845727801323,
-0.14860358834266663,
-0.3233968913555145,
-0.24211344122886658,
-0.20430231094360352,
0.25956201553344727,
-0.5650368332862854,
-0.49875205755233765,
0.035504382103681564,
-0.6324097514152527,
0.22738322615623474,
0.2685111165046692,
-0.1937073916196823,
0.3037722706794739,
0.9111886620521545,
0.712245523929596,
0.3356528580188751,
-0.11833304166793823,
-0.7085034251213074,
0.16719211637973785,
-0.338279128074646,
0.6117479801177979,
-0.45612967014312744,
0.06313241273164749,
-0.5377252697944641,
0.12547262012958527,
-0.20272196829319,
-0.39853164553642273,
0.7121447324752808,
-0.8676536083221436,
-0.0010487120598554611,
-0.27385058999061584,
-0.7430888414382935,
-0.48603707551956177,
0.48790591955184937,
-0.4787174165248871,
0.7647541761398315,
0.06426776945590973,
-1.4448492527008057,
0.20803074538707733,
-0.4834204614162445,
-0.36353421211242676,
0.12036939710378647,
0.22400741279125214,
-0.39164209365844727,
-0.22866034507751465,
0.3734933137893677,
0.494473397731781,
-0.21508492529392242,
0.2959771454334259,
-0.22754912078380585,
-0.3263401985168457,
-0.2769519090652466,
0.09009039402008057,
0.7431575059890747,
0.43497923016548157,
0.1464899778366089,
0.141869455575943,
-0.42194002866744995,
0.49283304810523987,
-0.0694013461470604,
0.0742451399564743,
-0.3531339466571808,
-0.0583062618970871,
-0.7348157167434692,
0.07423000037670135,
-0.28657999634742737,
-0.666586697101593,
-0.16420455276966095,
-0.5498347878456116,
0.7194023132324219,
0.5240878462791443,
0.3665001094341278,
0.3095688223838806,
-0.30518239736557007,
0.5437334179878235,
0.2717955410480499,
-0.1359214335680008,
-0.07510334253311157,
-0.6486437916755676,
-0.717014729976654,
-0.1514505296945572,
0.5016331672668457,
0.5302852988243103,
-0.908694863319397,
0.015416115522384644,
-0.5641488432884216,
-0.5402219891548157,
-0.6424917578697205,
-0.06623079627752304,
0.25778278708457947,
1.060124158859253,
0.4435691833496094,
-0.34375858306884766,
-0.37729233503341675,
-0.8965250849723816,
-0.2794717252254486,
-0.33545053005218506,
-0.12333682924509048,
0.5304194688796997,
0.3019854426383972,
0.26595237851142883,
1.3736331462860107,
-0.7257176637649536,
-0.15565486252307892,
-0.01569780334830284,
-0.06472533196210861,
0.24584569036960602,
0.22678826749324799,
0.14152489602565765,
-1.019572377204895,
-0.3094867467880249,
-0.02072686143219471,
-0.5285325050354004,
-0.12228154391050339,
0.3659910559654236,
-0.41075944900512695,
-0.4671861231327057,
0.437552809715271,
-0.8772919178009033,
0.2894187271595001,
0.10838338732719421,
-0.21283504366874695,
0.497272253036499,
0.17555926740169525,
-0.02686420828104019,
-0.8326030969619751,
0.1509944349527359,
-0.3332352638244629,
-0.34906452894210815,
-0.3940647840499878,
0.2259647250175476,
-0.1579325795173645,
-0.3851374089717865,
-0.4022678732872009,
0.41382259130477905,
-0.3675101101398468,
-0.2026459127664566,
0.13628192245960236,
0.3152918517589569,
0.30094316601753235,
0.5686626434326172,
0.18949250876903534,
0.5299871563911438,
0.5090491771697998,
-0.5559359788894653,
0.6672521829605103,
0.14438463747501373,
-0.07493681460618973,
0.24841979146003723,
-0.7696009874343872,
0.33149173855781555,
-0.639618992805481,
0.2740590572357178,
-1.0500478744506836,
-0.12942641973495483,
0.37977755069732666,
-0.6934937834739685,
0.052448589354753494,
-0.8058212399482727,
-0.2010773867368698,
-0.43388086557388306,
-0.05806797370314598,
0.15945641696453094,
0.3616970181465149,
-0.11622009426355362,
0.5158045887947083,
0.3526412546634674,
-0.06600253283977509,
-0.6863594651222229,
-0.5110411047935486,
-0.1343097686767578,
-0.42203807830810547,
-1.1077312231063843,
0.05501934885978699,
0.32917720079421997,
-0.05054040625691414,
0.6273142099380493,
-0.4210689663887024,
-0.2906321883201599,
0.30152997374534607,
0.026534754782915115,
-0.2987639307975769,
-0.1491064578294754,
0.5463943481445312,
0.04602309688925743,
-0.4307147264480591,
0.13288743793964386,
-1.0433751344680786,
0.3793746531009674,
0.0919485092163086,
-0.28483909368515015,
0.03386635333299637,
0.33944445848464966,
0.48496687412261963,
-0.40457046031951904,
0.7170494198799133,
0.6157179474830627,
-0.2836015224456787,
-0.04916835203766823,
-0.2919047474861145,
-0.30556654930114746,
-0.3237093985080719,
0.47722476720809937,
-0.7140284776687622,
-0.9768003225326538,
0.29623088240623474,
-0.31729230284690857,
-0.19667789340019226,
0.30270954966545105,
0.19474250078201294,
-0.0738772451877594,
0.7151561975479126,
0.01731877401471138,
0.15093819797039032,
-0.06772789359092712,
-0.39175885915756226,
0.5399834513664246,
-0.8311354517936707,
-0.0013743871822953224,
-0.5233861207962036,
-0.2815553843975067,
-0.35606682300567627,
-0.4696938991546631,
0.4923124313354492,
0.35844168066978455,
-0.23566658794879913,
0.40212482213974,
-0.779509425163269,
0.5148018598556519,
0.6399869918823242,
0.06751926988363266,
0.11902226507663727,
-0.2019558846950531,
-0.40140384435653687,
0.1453111171722412,
-1.1522231101989746,
-0.13363684713840485,
0.6848248243331909,
0.2877163589000702,
0.3299107849597931,
0.08264510333538055,
0.5853421688079834,
-0.29682424664497375,
0.07194662094116211,
-0.9204936623573303,
0.5387466549873352,
0.07306307554244995,
-0.6110092401504517,
-0.6762149930000305,
-0.8938786387443542,
-0.8313744068145752,
0.3034398853778839,
0.19017253816127777,
-0.6274695992469788,
-0.25093451142311096,
0.10032506287097931,
-0.025832444429397583,
0.43892958760261536,
-1.035395622253418,
0.9915526509284973,
0.37396591901779175,
-0.3225444555282593,
0.019065670669078827,
-0.9319865107536316,
0.24938863515853882,
0.5449101328849792,
0.12345606088638306,
-0.16356156766414642,
0.15604093670845032,
0.7445136904716492,
-0.7409765720367432,
0.44081270694732666,
-0.5187771320343018,
0.2765338122844696,
0.6701835989952087,
0.07157817482948303,
0.5587769746780396,
0.058202069252729416,
-0.03622768446803093,
-0.2364654839038849,
-0.011040210723876953,
-0.4342070519924164,
-0.969745397567749,
0.6217631101608276,
-0.581188440322876,
-0.8132035732269287,
0.08508473634719849,
-0.49313896894454956,
-0.4048071503639221,
0.3617764711380005,
0.025944359600543976,
0.5752977132797241,
0.3426741659641266,
0.33624139428138733,
0.7781286835670471,
0.1552816480398178,
0.04072559252381325,
-0.14839300513267517,
-0.04880837723612785,
-0.333608478307724,
0.8579317331314087,
0.576509952545166,
0.200148805975914,
0.7322114109992981,
0.4619937837123871,
-0.5134692788124084,
-0.5773856043815613,
-0.4368801414966583,
0.03712058439850807,
-0.8187798261642456,
-0.42140141129493713,
-1.099115252494812,
-0.26650264859199524,
-0.6421975493431091,
0.30482447147369385,
-0.07705467939376831,
-0.609201192855835,
0.17752017080783844,
-0.3751491606235504,
0.5573872327804565,
0.07262692600488663,
0.2454579472541809,
-0.007070033811032772,
-0.6456605792045593,
0.29826217889785767,
0.7650226354598999,
0.3949269950389862,
0.11835290491580963,
-0.20400302112102509,
0.12177019566297531,
-0.11526878923177719,
-0.09854577481746674,
-0.9102354049682617,
0.06395681947469711,
-0.03743530809879303,
0.4001215994358063,
-0.020345810800790787,
0.5522992014884949,
0.7961350679397583,
-0.307236909866333,
0.3974539637565613,
0.08499637246131897,
-0.616619884967804,
0.5549405217170715,
-0.3718012273311615,
0.2527458369731903,
0.3983480930328369,
0.5081385970115662,
-0.7963829040527344,
-0.46220770478248596,
-0.8973773717880249,
-0.9314585328102112,
0.554055392742157,
0.4853265881538391,
-0.18385912477970123,
-0.23638157546520233,
0.3829409182071686,
-0.33699217438697815,
0.23172591626644135,
-0.3103121519088745,
-0.20127643644809723,
-0.49052953720092773,
-0.2501400113105774,
0.4061310887336731,
-0.11361956596374512,
-0.17133362591266632,
-0.19625255465507507,
0.7873522639274597,
-0.4512883424758911,
0.14234381914138794,
0.5610476136207581,
-0.1023605689406395,
0.25478851795196533,
0.27883198857307434,
-0.17393165826797485,
0.6973507404327393,
-0.020008567720651627,
0.5054598450660706,
0.2840670347213745,
-0.40321823954582214,
-0.010661518201231956,
-0.16064481437206268,
-0.3649485111236572,
-0.03571965545415878,
0.3063175678253174,
0.8008263111114502,
-0.18937812745571136,
-0.3567288815975189,
0.43307697772979736,
0.0021835705265402794,
-0.19461268186569214,
-0.05437628552317619,
0.19795900583267212,
0.7313559651374817,
-0.1381588876247406,
0.08432084321975708,
0.022562071681022644,
0.17054420709609985,
-0.29244399070739746,
0.2682129442691803,
0.2583090364933014,
-0.6763184666633606,
0.2265436202287674,
0.4801126718521118,
0.20183876156806946,
-0.3331853449344635,
0.7989570498466492,
-0.2641710340976715,
-0.7695868611335754,
0.8572064638137817,
0.22503608465194702,
0.6042826175689697,
0.3799912631511688,
0.3043920695781708,
0.5298469066619873,
0.27691254019737244,
0.5386180877685547,
-0.15817123651504517,
-0.26092061400413513,
-0.890519380569458,
-0.8125471472740173,
-0.542610228061676,
-0.22759298980236053,
-0.2012530267238617,
-0.26640161871910095,
0.2741246521472931,
-0.3286101818084717,
0.15702328085899353,
-0.06372302770614624,
0.19554053246974945,
-0.37805357575416565,
0.6301190853118896,
-0.23007886111736298,
0.9593989253044128,
-0.5714550018310547,
0.7248983979225159,
0.8603172898292542,
-0.3791373372077942,
-1.362478256225586,
-0.1998942792415619,
-0.31843069195747375,
-0.6242976784706116,
0.6634039282798767,
0.2760428786277771,
-0.24172355234622955,
0.5804542303085327,
-0.2609003484249115,
-0.6475499272346497,
1.2917338609695435,
0.36294448375701904,
-0.17354552447795868,
0.04520740732550621,
-0.12271739542484283,
0.25256234407424927,
-0.110269695520401,
0.6824391484260559,
0.35709381103515625,
0.5534241199493408,
0.5550590753555298,
-0.6093482375144958,
-0.0074190981686115265,
-0.35287201404571533,
-0.24225658178329468,
0.513573944568634,
-0.788374662399292,
0.5454577803611755,
-0.024427462369203568,
-0.33390510082244873,
-0.3492603600025177,
0.4913825988769531,
0.19629603624343872,
0.3987506031990051,
0.860443115234375,
1.106367826461792,
0.9340376853942871,
-0.18969455361366272,
0.8532121777534485,
-0.17770542204380035,
0.411395400762558,
0.8205742835998535,
-0.05958610773086548,
0.15637943148612976,
0.539106011390686,
-0.1331324279308319,
0.30619552731513977,
0.6903226971626282,
0.6426683068275452,
0.47961747646331787,
0.5394818186759949,
-0.008168415166437626,
-0.5386514067649841,
-0.3558632731437683,
-0.24890966713428497,
0.2121364176273346,
0.06325730681419373,
0.012388204224407673,
-0.35839128494262695,
-0.31091710925102234,
0.19023603200912476,
-0.04907146096229553,
-0.3328654170036316,
0.8052249550819397,
-0.02951926551759243,
-0.9347901940345764,
0.2406945377588272,
-0.09518741071224213,
-0.007875570096075535,
-0.5765469670295715,
-0.13239076733589172,
-0.1531316041946411,
-0.21060679852962494,
-0.2862090766429901,
-0.8224338889122009,
0.6583300232887268,
-0.29635894298553467,
-0.21625134348869324,
-0.29820001125335693,
1.21109938621521,
-0.15702807903289795,
-0.21077784895896912,
0.3558371067047119,
0.5027367472648621,
0.3848150372505188,
-0.25144678354263306,
-0.44933435320854187,
-0.43712300062179565,
-0.12052929401397705,
-0.20778696238994598,
0.12044279277324677,
0.8372483849525452,
-0.09094929695129395,
0.9238758683204651,
0.6922745704650879,
0.06396903842687607,
0.16544461250305176,
0.0689578726887703,
1.0811692476272583,
-0.3375869393348694,
-0.6348833441734314,
-0.2728402316570282,
0.458629310131073,
-0.3777807056903839,
-0.2997578978538513,
0.4516035318374634,
0.4530147910118103,
0.7963741421699524,
0.14541535079479218,
0.53351891040802,
-0.373201847076416,
0.7254928350448608,
-0.5282319188117981,
0.5020133852958679,
-0.3005332946777344,
0.07174406945705414,
-0.15387842059135437,
-0.8542130589485168,
-0.17620496451854706,
0.521708071231842,
-0.5033721327781677,
-0.1450217217206955,
0.8726941347122192,
0.9256049990653992,
-0.19642136991024017,
0.06759878247976303,
0.359061598777771,
0.2664244771003723,
0.09740442782640457,
0.5895350575447083,
0.6993657946586609,
-0.2952503263950348,
0.876210629940033,
-0.36924824118614197,
0.05470164120197296,
0.30559852719306946,
-0.8865776658058167,
-0.5468183755874634,
-0.37817972898483276,
-0.47059231996536255,
-0.2928968071937561,
0.25432178378105164,
0.22990289330482483,
0.8161792755126953,
-0.5042594075202942,
0.38554736971855164,
-0.5652915239334106,
0.6527011394500732,
-0.2777847647666931,
-0.33898183703422546,
0.543834388256073,
-0.380074679851532,
-0.3579157292842865,
0.1297820806503296,
0.2184377759695053,
-0.6114359498023987,
-0.12018650770187378,
0.02837400510907173,
-0.3969285190105438,
-0.336725652217865,
0.27879461646080017,
0.030211690813302994,
-0.4106772243976593,
-0.8275689482688904,
0.1916584074497223,
0.4764583110809326,
-0.1745873987674713,
0.8360005617141724,
-1.0575520992279053,
0.3374693989753723,
0.8055853247642517,
0.938663899898529,
0.772831380367279,
0.33913275599479675,
0.31483396887779236,
-1.0248076915740967,
0.2520291805267334,
0.5699185729026794,
0.16042554378509521,
0.2618287205696106,
-0.3685734272003174,
0.7654503583908081,
0.6004416346549988,
-0.4356005787849426,
-0.40126657485961914,
0.4685283899307251,
-0.6596502065658569,
-0.35010042786598206,
1.1041594743728638,
-0.6028584837913513,
-0.45218756794929504,
-0.5414304733276367,
-0.2460220903158188,
0.36136478185653687,
0.01494494080543518,
0.11952469497919083,
0.9140397310256958,
-0.00009384576696902514,
-0.4967685341835022,
-0.3606192469596863,
0.11423317342996597,
0.6223182082176208,
-0.5127872228622437,
-0.04326950013637543,
0.3778510093688965,
0.45083221793174744,
0.24400201439857483,
0.8052980899810791,
0.11997593194246292,
0.12890061736106873,
0.2331971377134323,
-0.42856350541114807,
-0.48489582538604736,
-0.46870094537734985,
0.49517762660980225,
0.6848694682121277,
-0.03733934462070465,
-0.25863784551620483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17514v2 | How Useful is Continued Pre-Training for Generative Unsupervised Domain Adaptation? | 2024-01-31T00:15:34 | 2024-04-01T20:40:40 | Rheeya Uppaal, Yixuan Li, Junjie Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in scale have enabled the emergence of powerful
generative language models, and the ability to fine-tune these models on
various tasks by casting them into prompts or instructions. In this landscape,
the problem of Unsupervised Domain Adaptation (UDA), or the problem of
leveraging knowledge from a labeled source domain to an unlabeled target
domain, has been left behind, with recent UDA methods still addressing
discriminative classification. In particular, two popular UDA approaches,
involving Continued Pre-Training (CPT) and learning domain invariant
representations, have been under-explored in the generative setting, signaling
a gap. In this work, we evaluate the utility of CPT for generative UDA. We
first perform an empirical evaluation to measure the trade-offs between CPT and
strong methods promoting domain invariance. We further evaluate how well the
benefits of CPT extend to different architectures, tuning methods and data
regimes. We then motivate the use of CPT by studying to what degree it benefits
classification performance on the target domain. Finally, we attempt to
understand the mechanism behind which CPT improves classification performance
on the unlabeled target domain. Our findings suggest that a implicitly learns
the downstream task while predicting masked words informative to that task. Our
work connects the body of UDA research with that of instruction tuning,
enabling an initial step towards a wider applicability of modern language
models. | [
-0.40649616718292236,
-0.3021323084831238,
0.5060812830924988,
0.1734965294599533,
-0.4954667389392853,
0.26291319727897644,
-0.3443503975868225,
-0.22739598155021667,
-0.33525747060775757,
0.43196025490760803,
-0.4609002470970154,
-0.2423444241285324,
-0.6805319786071777,
-0.07887457311153412,
-0.23683549463748932,
0.9772908687591553,
-0.11783900856971741,
-0.0782838761806488,
-0.33229318261146545,
0.09312571585178375,
-0.9716578125953674,
-0.8929715752601624,
-0.7467238903045654,
-0.4633660912513733,
0.3268929719924927,
0.19973811507225037,
0.20393924415111542,
0.35326093435287476,
0.22912101447582245,
0.22404658794403076,
0.37652429938316345,
-0.0610182024538517,
-0.6674973964691162,
-0.02820928581058979,
-0.1803615391254425,
-0.5252191424369812,
-0.26340416073799133,
0.32550808787345886,
0.6987181305885315,
1.1093966960906982,
-0.15557339787483215,
-0.04175605997443199,
0.6563275456428528,
0.8964995741844177,
-0.7802777290344238,
0.3279089033603668,
-0.65836101770401,
0.05045565962791443,
-0.45401281118392944,
-0.30467721819877625,
-0.5928343534469604,
-0.09896984696388245,
0.38576099276542664,
-0.8961769938468933,
0.27237746119499207,
-0.19790183007717133,
0.675229549407959,
0.3506879210472107,
-0.16715754568576813,
-0.012945244088768959,
-0.9355134963989258,
0.851314902305603,
-0.10386868566274643,
0.6848994493484497,
0.388916939496994,
0.0720147043466568,
-0.2712584137916565,
-0.8989924788475037,
-0.4973391890525818,
-0.13900715112686157,
0.05148797854781151,
0.5606157779693604,
-0.4114411771297455,
0.02371310628950596,
0.14405861496925354,
0.2086963802576065,
-0.390418142080307,
0.3859575092792511,
-0.2804619371891022,
-0.05877017602324486,
0.20477044582366943,
-0.289303183555603,
0.20302894711494446,
0.4688337445259094,
-0.5233104228973389,
-0.17811492085456848,
-1.0462193489074707,
0.05092250928282738,
0.13650847971439362,
0.08189847320318222,
-0.026898667216300964,
0.2300415337085724,
0.014280078932642937,
0.8797971606254578,
0.22330477833747864,
0.2806514799594879,
0.004022170323878527,
0.05371127277612686,
-0.23105484247207642,
-0.1507950872182846,
0.2231633961200714,
0.13779360055923462,
0.6366029977798462,
-0.20383931696414948,
-0.05678851529955864,
0.16059233248233795,
0.6543793082237244,
-0.7199800610542297,
-0.7219048738479614,
-0.2927604913711548,
-0.26833266019821167,
0.10471737384796143,
0.13789600133895874,
-0.6904492974281311,
-0.12965638935565948,
-0.5774263739585876,
0.4066413342952728,
-0.21417301893234253,
-0.2777867019176483,
0.2042432725429535,
0.007844599895179272,
0.15005911886692047,
0.6004785895347595,
-1.0737462043762207,
0.0990544781088829,
0.5576707124710083,
0.6256465911865234,
-0.4602489769458771,
-0.34588196873664856,
-0.36748000979423523,
0.0323462076485157,
-0.5708802938461304,
0.8874380588531494,
-0.6287694573402405,
-0.49783405661582947,
0.04337570443749428,
0.16751205921173096,
-0.5976616144180298,
-0.6334409713745117,
0.24539300799369812,
-0.9617127776145935,
0.19941593706607819,
-0.16591474413871765,
-0.46689772605895996,
-0.15413720905780792,
-0.10810098797082901,
-0.5351677536964417,
0.7188106179237366,
0.4845430254936218,
-0.3860621750354767,
0.841790497303009,
-0.5469151735305786,
-0.38596636056900024,
0.36759278178215027,
0.06037793308496475,
-0.3811280131340027,
0.27828484773635864,
0.20496869087219238,
0.5259756445884705,
0.02915952168405056,
-0.1823813021183014,
-0.1132223829627037,
-0.2654823064804077,
0.19288508594036102,
-0.5521348118782043,
0.4810687005519867,
0.07683464884757996,
-0.24019798636436462,
-0.21123676002025604,
-0.4650138020515442,
-0.14621281623840332,
-0.023170271888375282,
-0.4944598078727722,
-0.47090643644332886,
-0.043979350477457047,
-0.2823074460029602,
-0.06657364964485168,
-0.07025913894176483,
-0.22347506880760193,
0.14614179730415344,
-0.11191089451313019,
0.016474008560180664,
1.1347631216049194,
-0.07255737483501434,
0.3978859484195709,
-0.11330296844244003,
0.7167667150497437,
0.002595872851088643,
0.007344379555433989,
0.025960560888051987,
-0.472698837518692,
-0.6914485096931458,
-0.4655405879020691,
0.6349299550056458,
0.30467796325683594,
-0.9137515425682068,
0.4202343821525574,
-0.2410178929567337,
-0.13579948246479034,
-0.19918940961360931,
0.2411210983991623,
0.44142502546310425,
0.34454619884490967,
0.40489861369132996,
-0.8900346755981445,
-0.5764701962471008,
-0.17587190866470337,
-0.06424089521169662,
-0.03223956748843193,
-0.2392043173313141,
-0.003065939527004957,
0.34861597418785095,
-0.21991746127605438,
0.8738209009170532,
-0.5432182550430298,
-0.2823333144187927,
-0.3301752507686615,
0.18018728494644165,
-0.08944962918758392,
0.4301218092441559,
0.6837998032569885,
-0.6674790978431702,
-0.726887583732605,
0.08440760523080826,
-0.6545730233192444,
-0.006745385006070137,
-0.35883668065071106,
-0.13084818422794342,
-0.00551216397434473,
0.32233038544654846,
-0.5103242993354797,
0.33174002170562744,
0.6727135181427002,
-0.01297300960868597,
0.4892269968986511,
-0.3674609959125519,
0.041255511343479156,
-0.780799388885498,
-0.15341001749038696,
-0.21283775568008423,
-0.2291807234287262,
-0.7268346548080444,
-0.22830818593502045,
-0.07800943404436111,
-0.06085339933633804,
-0.17388728260993958,
0.2559898793697357,
-0.6933379769325256,
0.030278975144028664,
-0.5409976243972778,
-0.08754446357488632,
-0.11416244506835938,
0.4059049189090729,
0.3289598226547241,
1.1366370916366577,
0.7175514101982117,
-1.0103594064712524,
-0.006201455369591713,
0.1822289228439331,
-0.3725282549858093,
0.5809028744697571,
-0.31640538573265076,
0.4509434700012207,
0.008465143851935863,
0.1818576157093048,
-0.4900689721107483,
-0.001980101689696312,
0.12619858980178833,
-0.3638955056667328,
0.8498513698577881,
-0.15448448061943054,
-0.09683579951524734,
-0.2719317078590393,
-0.11855881661176682,
0.5083374381065369,
0.7553597092628479,
-1.053917407989502,
0.41809388995170593,
0.2862311899662018,
0.05619646608829498,
-0.3642359972000122,
-0.09985503554344177,
-0.054673824459314346,
-0.15078051388263702,
-0.11270815134048462,
0.540791928768158,
-0.06806997954845428,
0.1446707397699356,
-0.0513402596116066,
-0.3065383732318878,
0.08836077898740768,
0.24626289308071136,
0.2655458152294159,
0.07415564358234406,
-0.3321150243282318,
0.060702212154865265,
0.04735305905342102,
-0.25842252373695374,
-0.004267455078661442,
-0.6308596730232239,
0.5280215740203857,
0.06807774305343628,
-0.18993091583251953,
-0.354377418756485,
0.13870328664779663,
0.25993624329566956,
-0.10300981998443604,
0.8308010101318359,
0.4472861886024475,
-0.25227656960487366,
-0.47267594933509827,
-0.1765994429588318,
-0.106537826359272,
-0.43085920810699463,
0.22295822203159332,
-0.4534088969230652,
-0.9701359868049622,
0.0908738374710083,
-0.6484318971633911,
-0.35705846548080444,
0.4626065194606781,
0.2715344727039337,
-0.2958019971847534,
0.6436576247215271,
1.1844093799591064,
0.03942745923995972,
0.6573373675346375,
-0.33507469296455383,
0.19345921277999878,
-0.9759846925735474,
-0.26614099740982056,
-0.322754830121994,
0.1734890192747116,
-0.4096170961856842,
-0.3201260268688202,
0.17947989702224731,
0.5613661408424377,
0.13912147283554077,
0.48488810658454895,
-0.2859017550945282,
0.43001216650009155,
0.4757789075374603,
0.16028007864952087,
0.06036347523331642,
0.11538242548704147,
0.36344122886657715,
-0.015813760459423065,
-0.7979647517204285,
-0.14172574877738953,
1.229754090309143,
0.1764453947544098,
0.8214236497879028,
-0.17377969622612,
0.3855658769607544,
0.5549430251121521,
0.7698730826377869,
-0.6270395517349243,
0.2657625079154968,
-0.47087496519088745,
-0.14048907160758972,
-0.28044936060905457,
-0.146139457821846,
-1.1917626857757568,
0.16292047500610352,
-0.05989733710885048,
-0.49940019845962524,
0.4769052565097809,
0.35024017095565796,
-0.39408382773399353,
0.08681777864694595,
-0.8312830328941345,
0.939024806022644,
-0.06797309964895248,
-0.158656045794487,
-0.22711898386478424,
-0.3554813265800476,
0.053947675973176956,
-0.6955991983413696,
-0.23772473633289337,
0.25975272059440613,
0.256492555141449,
0.9973546862602234,
-0.16729862987995148,
1.1562470197677612,
-0.09197895228862762,
-0.10812235623598099,
0.12237823009490967,
-0.39137718081474304,
0.25985464453697205,
-0.09657889604568481,
0.4674551784992218,
0.3745751678943634,
-0.10110146552324295,
-0.430960088968277,
-0.7054620385169983,
0.41963469982147217,
-0.805205225944519,
-0.8639058470726013,
-0.512189507484436,
-0.2076660841703415,
-0.45536547899246216,
0.2607974112033844,
0.42170509696006775,
0.3514663577079773,
-0.3270896375179291,
0.31314218044281006,
0.9505586624145508,
-0.017335109412670135,
0.19918787479400635,
0.32613134384155273,
0.217328742146492,
-0.10966752469539642,
0.866234540939331,
-0.14951521158218384,
0.37775924801826477,
0.6318394541740417,
0.128414124250412,
-0.3042413890361786,
-0.8379487991333008,
-0.442874550819397,
0.029829388484358788,
-0.725065290927887,
-0.2798800766468048,
-0.4576819837093353,
-0.19570109248161316,
-0.3900666832923889,
-0.25891488790512085,
-0.17991040647029877,
-0.07934735715389252,
-0.666348934173584,
-0.2109469622373581,
0.09948935359716415,
0.7506939768791199,
-0.13510921597480774,
0.4748905301094055,
-0.6272989511489868,
0.24341008067131042,
0.7244189381599426,
0.21009817719459534,
-0.22807972133159637,
-0.6950841546058655,
-0.35163888335227966,
-0.08022613823413849,
-0.22727689146995544,
-0.7117831110954285,
0.11422547698020935,
0.5619266033172607,
0.7558935880661011,
0.2817492187023163,
-0.005991917569190264,
0.6337314248085022,
-0.5065567493438721,
0.6450204253196716,
0.2446945160627365,
-0.8687520027160645,
0.37986794114112854,
0.018247554078698158,
0.3876767158508301,
0.403408944606781,
0.6404104232788086,
-0.23154565691947937,
0.026499269530177116,
-0.15514785051345825,
-0.45743265748023987,
0.664997935295105,
0.05822831019759178,
0.4395659565925598,
0.16940830647945404,
0.42753687500953674,
0.41175130009651184,
0.17298728227615356,
-0.48932188749313354,
0.03582350164651871,
-0.5868247151374817,
0.17099039256572723,
-0.33085548877716064,
-0.4390728175640106,
-0.05176476761698723,
-0.33136212825775146,
0.5629649758338928,
-0.2755744457244873,
0.3204457461833954,
-0.21079328656196594,
-0.3634370267391205,
0.06485088169574738,
0.2579495310783386,
0.45942890644073486,
0.7937002778053284,
-0.1268339902162552,
0.024654604494571686,
0.10441847145557404,
-0.8936609625816345,
0.03159793093800545,
0.18355625867843628,
-0.028408797457814217,
-0.2879651188850403,
0.5538188815116882,
0.9776334166526794,
0.03181522339582443,
-0.32917532324790955,
0.5121392011642456,
-0.057130854576826096,
-0.11228413134813309,
-0.17916066944599152,
-0.05761946365237236,
-0.39691686630249023,
0.05164360627532005,
0.1991088092327118,
0.21295307576656342,
-0.25433221459388733,
-0.6694084405899048,
0.35211655497550964,
0.3450416624546051,
-0.4438561201095581,
-0.5373892784118652,
0.5098444819450378,
0.18533603847026825,
0.033387910574674606,
0.7253363132476807,
-0.01685967668890953,
-0.6636613607406616,
0.27653056383132935,
0.7581434845924377,
1.1070306301116943,
-0.44677725434303284,
0.301593154668808,
-0.03383499011397362,
0.2872924208641052,
-0.08038035780191422,
-0.17211386561393738,
-0.4446195960044861,
-0.997559666633606,
-0.5087015628814697,
-0.7803203463554382,
-0.12224721163511276,
0.07292898744344711,
-0.7109131813049316,
-0.1853112131357193,
-0.3744383752346039,
-0.04671669006347656,
-0.18168628215789795,
-0.38782501220703125,
-0.9051669836044312,
0.35371702909469604,
-0.15061432123184204,
0.5910180807113647,
-0.8444679975509644,
0.9898862838745117,
0.6594731211662292,
-0.27753907442092896,
-0.6120074391365051,
0.3862588703632355,
-0.4730660617351532,
-0.7764328718185425,
0.8768892288208008,
0.13948661088943481,
-0.40839335322380066,
0.19211438298225403,
-0.3026925325393677,
-0.6171067357063293,
0.8822824358940125,
0.3803609311580658,
-0.5095934271812439,
0.24547326564788818,
-0.060630448162555695,
0.723164975643158,
-0.5527825355529785,
-0.31899112462997437,
0.7607993483543396,
0.09061040729284286,
0.06312955915927887,
-0.6129096150398254,
0.10168717056512833,
0.027353232726454735,
0.20270025730133057,
0.07155374437570572,
-0.1926753669977188,
0.5181118249893188,
-0.42418763041496277,
-0.5565925240516663,
0.010409419424831867,
0.753031849861145,
-0.02864496409893036,
0.19722479581832886,
0.6727975606918335,
0.4632148742675781,
0.4758487939834595,
-0.29318860173225403,
1.0168064832687378,
0.07446540147066116,
0.1900337040424347,
0.8761190176010132,
-0.2960124611854553,
0.6496791839599609,
0.22292616963386536,
-0.4173370599746704,
0.6632639169692993,
0.7814127802848816,
0.11893175542354584,
1.061103343963623,
0.262590229511261,
-0.50845867395401,
-0.45104461908340454,
-0.03816225379705429,
-0.6374134421348572,
0.4663420021533966,
0.4478462338447571,
-0.10912346839904785,
-0.05552741512656212,
0.3980816900730133,
-0.16282090544700623,
0.10360012948513031,
-0.2728470265865326,
0.8827347159385681,
0.2148459404706955,
-0.6346897482872009,
0.6180850267410278,
-0.3933712840080261,
0.44619306921958923,
-0.6326480507850647,
-0.25373777747154236,
-0.2011445313692093,
0.353510320186615,
0.0273275189101696,
-0.5207991003990173,
-0.0016442586202174425,
-0.08047331124544144,
-0.17706334590911865,
-0.5493543148040771,
0.6247883439064026,
-0.2602676749229431,
-0.08524449169635773,
0.3445625603199005,
0.28250420093536377,
0.08694757521152496,
-0.31002089381217957,
-0.5011627674102783,
-0.03690456226468086,
-0.11073356121778488,
-0.15254510939121246,
0.6080843210220337,
0.3632414937019348,
-0.10867203772068024,
0.4089583158493042,
0.8496649265289307,
0.03748434782028198,
0.09464860707521439,
0.34852322936058044,
1.1189196109771729,
-0.3640688955783844,
-0.30817127227783203,
-0.4191346764564514,
0.2603866159915924,
0.2590693235397339,
-0.27867546677589417,
0.7111334800720215,
0.3072437644004822,
1.3829478025436401,
-0.4293022155761719,
0.7757441997528076,
0.16832460463047028,
0.18832270801067352,
-1.0503101348876953,
0.5328505039215088,
-0.4846135973930359,
0.25767284631729126,
0.06991110742092133,
-0.9843581318855286,
-0.26655134558677673,
0.23394985496997833,
-0.23017363250255585,
0.3489536941051483,
0.9230995774269104,
0.4020533859729767,
0.0056365132331848145,
-0.16924907267093658,
0.5820788145065308,
-0.18993006646633148,
0.1979750394821167,
0.4530971646308899,
0.9524036645889282,
0.06595908850431442,
0.1780366450548172,
-0.15451191365718842,
-0.5853070020675659,
0.09487173706293106,
-0.7069897055625916,
-1.0583796501159668,
-0.6924529671669006,
-0.3899826109409332,
-0.15475592017173767,
0.3723130226135254,
0.3527364134788513,
0.8636195659637451,
-0.9072728753089905,
-0.004055597819387913,
-0.1966644674539566,
-0.15923438966274261,
-0.6521695256233215,
-0.141463965177536,
0.6365851163864136,
-0.4554855525493622,
-0.6079868078231812,
0.5581035017967224,
0.36758968234062195,
0.16863347589969635,
-0.0009808901231735945,
0.010968497954308987,
0.16269813477993011,
-0.20877766609191895,
0.9592856764793396,
0.6224570274353027,
-0.38315558433532715,
-0.34885579347610474,
-0.0887230858206749,
0.3316134810447693,
0.0070113674737513065,
1.2136015892028809,
-0.8287378549575806,
0.6394771337509155,
0.23885267972946167,
0.9583070278167725,
0.5161310434341431,
0.03916012495756149,
0.8610883951187134,
-0.7347885966300964,
-0.1059083417057991,
0.050336968153715134,
0.20662885904312134,
0.36308324337005615,
-0.4248240292072296,
0.3222099840641022,
0.5208437442779541,
-0.42594191431999207,
-0.5667814016342163,
0.3404023051261902,
-0.8929038047790527,
-0.277852863073349,
0.9224323034286499,
-0.4891391098499298,
0.1297343522310257,
-0.5221114754676819,
0.04559716582298279,
0.1888466775417328,
-0.03571409732103348,
0.7657685279846191,
0.44182318449020386,
-0.2555484473705292,
-0.31680601835250854,
-0.33770304918289185,
0.9224215149879456,
0.40510115027427673,
-1.0431208610534668,
0.07531969249248505,
0.15215453505516052,
0.20926807820796967,
0.05025826767086983,
0.8337450623512268,
0.010368434712290764,
0.33787667751312256,
-0.07485297322273254,
-0.12037406116724014,
0.11488837748765945,
-0.7744206786155701,
-0.47211337089538574,
-0.09890251606702805,
0.2964448928833008,
-0.6186869740486145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17511v1 | Linguistically Communicating Uncertainty in Patient-Facing Risk Prediction Models | 2024-01-31T00:08:44 | 2024-01-31T00:08:44 | Adarsa Sivaprasad, Ehud Reiter | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper addresses the unique challenges associated with uncertainty
quantification in AI models when applied to patient-facing contexts within
healthcare. Unlike traditional eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)
methods tailored for model developers or domain experts, additional
considerations of communicating in natural language, its presentation and
evaluating understandability are necessary. We identify the challenges in
communication model performance, confidence, reasoning and unknown knowns using
natural language in the context of risk prediction. We propose a design aimed
at addressing these challenges, focusing on the specific application of
in-vitro fertilisation outcome prediction. | [
0.01687740348279476,
-0.6469203233718872,
0.7342480421066284,
0.4048055112361908,
-0.04084206372499466,
0.1627051830291748,
0.18955761194229126,
-0.9408795237541199,
-0.2153654247522354,
0.13486933708190918,
-0.7449259757995605,
-0.15749865770339966,
-0.6299619674682617,
0.0581953302025795,
-0.163814514875412,
0.5529710054397583,
-0.358131468296051,
0.3851716220378876,
-0.5306877493858337,
0.22652952373027802,
-0.4809361398220062,
-0.7315466403961182,
-0.6656384468078613,
-0.5069981813430786,
0.07192090898752213,
0.4220578670501709,
1.087201476097107,
0.48208338022232056,
0.8509871363639832,
0.26579800248146057,
-0.17869947850704193,
-0.4318697154521942,
0.0794249027967453,
0.13339048624038696,
0.05386674776673317,
-0.5544509291648865,
-0.15430867671966553,
-0.1968676894903183,
0.7136369347572327,
1.2164127826690674,
-0.24005351960659027,
-0.04023945704102516,
-0.2769324481487274,
0.40261730551719666,
-0.4202713668346405,
0.27055734395980835,
-0.36109012365341187,
0.4388272166252136,
-0.01351548358798027,
0.02172011323273182,
-0.38391974568367004,
-0.09621141105890274,
0.6876603960990906,
-0.6494477987289429,
-0.15302592515945435,
0.1502627283334732,
0.7606847286224365,
0.5190616250038147,
-0.341234028339386,
-0.7358739376068115,
-1.22046959400177,
0.5687766075134277,
-0.6529890894889832,
0.4680648744106293,
0.5596519708633423,
0.5073745846748352,
-0.18261748552322388,
-0.7180442214012146,
-0.4851229786872864,
-0.05186498537659645,
-0.2626298666000366,
-0.30150511860847473,
-0.2530820667743683,
0.44128933548927307,
-0.031716953963041306,
0.49100440740585327,
-0.23238499462604523,
0.18449585139751434,
-0.24986661970615387,
-0.20561620593070984,
0.7210052609443665,
0.10306087136268616,
0.17721031606197357,
-0.11347812414169312,
-0.3881160616874695,
0.10611771047115326,
-0.27240628004074097,
0.26283130049705505,
0.15882569551467896,
0.2322872430086136,
-0.4298023581504822,
0.4357447326183319,
-0.2834576964378357,
0.4536673426628113,
-0.03922377899289131,
0.048174288123846054,
0.2337951362133026,
-0.19601629674434662,
-0.34509968757629395,
0.003052080748602748,
0.6746920943260193,
0.058824680745601654,
0.003470388939604163,
-0.04322794824838638,
0.02905021421611309,
0.08029539883136749,
0.4645276963710785,
-0.6717121601104736,
-0.16356472671031952,
0.6875398755073547,
-0.13670551776885986,
-0.5899648070335388,
-0.18155226111412048,
-0.9184110164642334,
-0.46649765968322754,
0.19208545982837677,
0.5967002511024475,
-0.46439746022224426,
-0.13159607350826263,
0.20313571393489838,
0.11484289914369583,
-0.014285450801253319,
0.26973092555999756,
-0.8031343221664429,
0.3378065526485443,
0.3989451825618744,
0.3879126310348511,
0.16432525217533112,
0.1142822876572609,
-0.052012935280799866,
0.07176512479782104,
-0.5508677363395691,
0.5000653266906738,
-0.32107236981391907,
-0.5320249199867249,
0.0412292554974556,
-0.26642507314682007,
-0.052041586488485336,
-0.21541950106620789,
0.7224917411804199,
0.11269639432430267,
0.21107512712478638,
-0.05856310576200485,
-0.6456674337387085,
0.0067684827372431755,
0.049896180629730225,
-0.5718851685523987,
0.4800015985965729,
0.42890676856040955,
-0.8352487683296204,
0.5646088123321533,
-0.6644303798675537,
-0.6352889537811279,
0.42598140239715576,
-0.3854341208934784,
-0.7932928800582886,
0.1030469611287117,
0.07151728123426437,
0.42500802874565125,
-0.13409392535686493,
0.44568392634391785,
-0.03502051532268524,
-0.008299080654978752,
0.7542848587036133,
-0.49532172083854675,
0.3161880671977997,
0.28938817977905273,
-0.4941660165786743,
0.1695771962404251,
-0.6855220794677734,
0.22278858721256256,
-0.09910713136196136,
0.0745607316493988,
0.013663584366440773,
0.07042285054922104,
-0.12028929591178894,
0.3700416386127472,
-0.013744357973337173,
-0.26024022698402405,
-0.2923429012298584,
-0.6746794581413269,
0.5798466801643372,
0.3780243396759033,
0.14399443566799164,
0.6110764741897583,
-0.29858216643333435,
0.6093909740447998,
0.054702337831258774,
0.5645820498466492,
0.19203054904937744,
-0.7807762622833252,
-0.47311440110206604,
0.0857735127210617,
0.19862134754657745,
0.649728536605835,
-0.7757498025894165,
-0.46272262930870056,
-0.17182980477809906,
-0.5558836460113525,
-0.8180147409439087,
-0.21244019269943237,
0.5131098628044128,
0.7233195900917053,
0.0358058325946331,
0.11207550764083862,
-0.5877686738967896,
-0.8321940898895264,
-0.08324333280324936,
-0.8905602693557739,
0.1222987025976181,
0.5305226445198059,
0.536217451095581,
-0.2902282476425171,
0.6130610108375549,
-0.3888477385044098,
-0.04097314551472664,
-0.3272216320037842,
0.6024180054664612,
0.10819967836141586,
0.8095700144767761,
0.22958599030971527,
-1.2814613580703735,
-0.3170904815196991,
0.3215034008026123,
-0.8732360601425171,
0.31956303119659424,
-0.33182910084724426,
-0.09353987127542496,
0.2090231329202652,
0.12376894801855087,
-0.748911440372467,
0.8015711903572083,
0.5665490627288818,
-0.1838655322790146,
0.5705858469009399,
-0.33441150188446045,
0.2622738182544708,
-0.817950427532196,
-0.21218006312847137,
0.11755687743425369,
-0.09658918529748917,
-1.2482094764709473,
0.24206817150115967,
-0.15065059065818787,
-0.17950618267059326,
-0.710441529750824,
0.64720219373703,
-0.2684273421764374,
0.1623041033744812,
0.029731841757893562,
-0.42817988991737366,
-0.0038347544614225626,
0.023362167179584503,
0.24968034029006958,
0.9350717067718506,
0.6633090972900391,
-0.531672477722168,
0.06977220624685287,
0.6444258689880371,
-0.1772143393754959,
0.6827481985092163,
-0.803038477897644,
-0.2510839104652405,
0.012550442479550838,
-0.09547120332717896,
-0.5776975750923157,
-0.7899690270423889,
0.4201977550983429,
-1.0016288757324219,
0.4857744872570038,
0.09218478947877884,
0.10187988728284836,
-0.7722074389457703,
0.20089103281497955,
0.4250590205192566,
0.26021143794059753,
0.19053299725055695,
0.5996387004852295,
0.2942253351211548,
-0.26631954312324524,
-0.567651093006134,
-1.0464591979980469,
0.2726163864135742,
-0.27445197105407715,
-0.7264497876167297,
0.4127465486526489,
-0.12660542130470276,
-0.5862827897071838,
-0.1568535715341568,
-0.037456586956977844,
-0.5481288433074951,
0.48989641666412354,
0.657387912273407,
0.12236850708723068,
-0.07584214210510254,
0.5900560617446899,
-0.07219654321670532,
-0.23776566982269287,
0.4072311818599701,
-0.14724458754062653,
0.019590014591813087,
-0.14902278780937195,
-0.46098247170448303,
-0.7728581428527832,
0.8444873690605164,
0.296808123588562,
0.07445953041315079,
1.0211631059646606,
0.5270751118659973,
-1.0923556089401245,
0.09267465770244598,
-0.20113646984100342,
-0.10681632906198502,
-0.3902493715286255,
0.21281355619430542,
-0.27576857805252075,
-0.5679994225502014,
0.5663478970527649,
0.0006358717218972743,
-0.2347937524318695,
0.5122126936912537,
0.48417991399765015,
-0.5358286499977112,
1.20383620262146,
1.100859522819519,
0.17496664822101593,
-0.17663578689098358,
-0.12069649249315262,
0.4373309314250946,
-0.12827923893928528,
-0.5050410628318787,
-0.6082338094711304,
0.19488193094730377,
-0.5877513885498047,
-0.5656247138977051,
0.5264968276023865,
-0.1378345489501953,
-0.14123278856277466,
0.07438003271818161,
-0.5410900712013245,
-0.33569684624671936,
0.4582012891769409,
0.2323599010705948,
0.3117969036102295,
-0.3202199935913086,
-0.009733175858855247,
-0.133848637342453,
-0.7289941906929016,
-0.5780414342880249,
0.5334215760231018,
0.8746297359466553,
0.7973983287811279,
0.12010154128074646,
0.5086896419525146,
0.1501268446445465,
0.28958967328071594,
-0.5924307703971863,
-0.09982931613922119,
0.3707188069820404,
-0.9399425387382507,
-0.6046773195266724,
-0.6083997488021851,
-0.6332265138626099,
-0.3298717737197876,
-0.6932520866394043,
-0.9263803362846375,
0.35049426555633545,
0.07093849778175354,
-0.9235238432884216,
0.2539733052253723,
-0.6660898327827454,
0.9290361404418945,
-0.23414193093776703,
0.04345553368330002,
0.3261895477771759,
-1.0511789321899414,
-0.03166668117046356,
-0.24367135763168335,
0.5826433897018433,
0.08403446525335312,
-0.02085389383137226,
0.36802998185157776,
-0.3771149814128876,
0.8020039796829224,
0.4100567102432251,
0.04405185207724571,
0.2553248405456543,
-0.1208462044596672,
0.41624996066093445,
0.4050893187522888,
-0.43526017665863037,
0.047695860266685486,
0.25002139806747437,
-0.5127204656600952,
-0.3667028248310089,
0.1521015465259552,
-0.8211219310760498,
-0.5868874192237854,
-0.6150802373886108,
-0.6052292585372925,
-0.487703800201416,
-0.04064691811800003,
0.6535636186599731,
0.2953712046146393,
-0.22415682673454285,
-0.3599536716938019,
0.699728786945343,
-0.471582293510437,
0.1196962520480156,
0.025775793939828873,
-0.002947450615465641,
-0.1442164033651352,
0.6403894424438477,
-0.16274280846118927,
0.6783654093742371,
0.4386121928691864,
0.18341901898384094,
-0.19079181551933289,
-0.7435530424118042,
-0.46820327639579773,
-0.0036405916325747967,
-0.8183721303939819,
-0.12028256058692932,
-0.7287362813949585,
-0.6669586896896362,
-0.5557308197021484,
-0.38036733865737915,
-0.26731956005096436,
-0.1826857626438141,
-0.6373807191848755,
-0.47880154848098755,
0.19969359040260315,
1.0449594259262085,
0.06119811162352562,
0.7174919247627258,
-0.580954909324646,
0.10658645629882812,
0.0860370546579361,
0.46927520632743835,
-0.5606867671012878,
-0.15426534414291382,
-0.2161504477262497,
0.357937753200531,
0.08068176358938217,
-1.2028902769088745,
0.6622698903083801,
0.23486165702342987,
0.678871214389801,
0.28905510902404785,
0.30320796370506287,
0.5406762957572937,
-0.17294970154762268,
0.7253513336181641,
0.012230155989527702,
-1.0843814611434937,
0.6021639108657837,
-0.09204801172018051,
-0.025268614292144775,
0.5621210336685181,
0.7472358345985413,
-0.362692266702652,
-0.28239771723747253,
-0.9569534063339233,
-0.7578650116920471,
0.2540838420391083,
0.610130786895752,
-0.009708770550787449,
-0.016293486580252647,
0.5489939451217651,
0.10689312219619751,
0.5215411186218262,
-0.6596288084983826,
-0.35297903418540955,
0.19519957900047302,
-0.19698123633861542,
-0.024109266698360443,
-0.41888877749443054,
-0.20384162664413452,
-0.222427099943161,
0.6420374512672424,
-0.11922594159841537,
0.5865723490715027,
0.41840848326683044,
0.04467388987541199,
-0.45910337567329407,
0.31123220920562744,
0.7185922265052795,
0.7937051057815552,
-0.28857824206352234,
-0.03081340715289116,
0.2599877119064331,
-0.3762100338935852,
0.14748971164226532,
0.3868072032928467,
-0.026926202699542046,
0.1252979338169098,
0.562458872795105,
0.9100275635719299,
0.35815757513046265,
-0.5462682843208313,
0.5019891858100891,
-0.24229696393013,
-0.25021401047706604,
-0.7138856649398804,
-0.5675569772720337,
0.061424728482961655,
0.03847131133079529,
0.4826781451702118,
0.3787357211112976,
0.3222317397594452,
-0.5094241499900818,
0.5432047247886658,
0.24375444650650024,
-1.099779486656189,
-0.13398467004299164,
0.9850912094116211,
0.1769871860742569,
-0.349496990442276,
0.5289806723594666,
-0.19314809143543243,
-0.4844280779361725,
0.868489682674408,
0.3278878331184387,
0.6257417798042297,
-0.2672754228115082,
0.6014071702957153,
0.1215624138712883,
0.3082292377948761,
0.23043735325336456,
0.5009124875068665,
0.5263290405273438,
-0.6391847729682922,
-0.5016000270843506,
-0.3726140260696411,
-0.8981766104698181,
-0.35421663522720337,
-0.6154965162277222,
-0.016422316431999207,
-0.43176019191741943,
-0.5253728032112122,
0.32520216703414917,
0.00978821236640215,
-0.6132919788360596,
0.6173621416091919,
0.3974342346191406,
0.8512091040611267,
-0.8984608054161072,
0.4729171395301819,
0.7610974311828613,
-0.398354172706604,
-1.088629126548767,
-0.2896464169025421,
0.09010342508554459,
-0.5140076279640198,
0.3779991865158081,
0.0604233480989933,
0.3027249574661255,
-0.4431777000427246,
-0.2829499840736389,
-0.7231045961380005,
0.898734986782074,
0.267721563577652,
0.03800511732697487,
-0.2119193822145462,
0.7933837175369263,
0.6344377398490906,
-0.46220874786376953,
0.18891771137714386,
0.33005180954933167,
0.4666363298892975,
0.2582612931728363,
-1.0786890983581543,
-0.15931443870067596,
-0.16081003844738007,
-0.05125516280531883,
0.01565038599073887,
-0.02492513135075569,
0.9992063045501709,
-0.570023775100708,
-0.4784800112247467,
0.35115644335746765,
0.7987120747566223,
-0.3071292042732239,
0.6663582921028137,
0.20722553133964539,
0.28860774636268616,
0.8655800819396973,
-0.34248125553131104,
1.3036863803863525,
-0.09251603484153748,
0.07186979800462723,
0.8112245202064514,
-0.11856281012296677,
0.7120084762573242,
0.5054369568824768,
-0.34318211674690247,
0.2982388436794281,
0.6901159286499023,
0.5818806290626526,
0.08493542671203613,
0.2555036246776581,
-0.5124269723892212,
-0.17609240114688873,
-0.5108466148376465,
-0.45605066418647766,
0.42196986079216003,
0.8053101301193237,
-0.2269892543554306,
0.18238690495491028,
0.2563532590866089,
-0.26008668541908264,
0.16160666942596436,
-0.20427769422531128,
0.6790895462036133,
0.20518648624420166,
-0.35904744267463684,
0.22515223920345306,
-0.1679440438747406,
0.32353368401527405,
-0.2812601327896118,
-0.22472834587097168,
0.271220862865448,
0.19141826033592224,
-0.08127043396234512,
-0.9803637862205505,
0.586818516254425,
-0.5443585515022278,
-0.15666645765304565,
-0.14242345094680786,
0.6559988856315613,
-0.30861520767211914,
-0.9463109970092773,
0.07363936305046082,
0.5679327845573425,
0.04948653653264046,
-0.21133309602737427,
-0.7384130954742432,
0.029825495555996895,
-0.11905045062303543,
0.2256927341222763,
0.08346447348594666,
0.6664776802062988,
-0.3860551714897156,
1.5121525526046753,
0.29323285818099976,
0.17437055706977844,
-0.06614731252193451,
-0.25424349308013916,
0.6544857025146484,
-0.41814637184143066,
-0.43630361557006836,
-0.5518671274185181,
0.49158376455307007,
0.12576326727867126,
-0.4049646258354187,
0.18344968557357788,
-0.08018563687801361,
0.4227648377418518,
0.005079795140773058,
0.7837786078453064,
0.13614630699157715,
0.5265224575996399,
-0.08709261566400528,
0.675206184387207,
-0.1367134302854538,
0.17829352617263794,
-0.4862522482872009,
0.206943079829216,
-0.4140286147594452,
0.5676678419113159,
-0.2011854499578476,
-0.0449785478413105,
0.5029951930046082,
0.1834854930639267,
0.5582932829856873,
0.24371983110904694,
0.45423179864883423,
0.19419531524181366,
0.1480918824672699,
0.7056339383125305,
0.6342019438743591,
-0.5975432395935059,
0.35235595703125,
-1.0996547937393188,
-0.1559961438179016,
-0.17792187631130219,
-0.973342776298523,
-0.5583721399307251,
-0.725349485874176,
-0.41982996463775635,
-0.16713228821754456,
0.3262104392051697,
0.671146810054779,
0.8919593691825867,
-0.9145225286483765,
0.1099909171462059,
-0.003265323583036661,
0.36857879161834717,
-0.267424613237381,
-0.1863141655921936,
-0.034478213638067245,
-0.06293167173862457,
-0.47127440571784973,
-0.13628984987735748,
0.2621537744998932,
0.546194851398468,
-0.2174905389547348,
-0.035175733268260956,
-0.26080355048179626,
0.22412441670894623,
0.19126875698566437,
0.3860354721546173,
-0.51271653175354,
-0.42375338077545166,
-0.10523908585309982,
-0.2889276444911957,
0.07423894852399826,
0.135196253657341,
-0.6545255184173584,
0.36265403032302856,
0.12850478291511536,
0.793953001499176,
0.0704711526632309,
0.11909926682710648,
1.1873142719268799,
-0.47250524163246155,
0.17451909184455872,
0.6508846879005432,
0.2799363434314728,
0.5510072708129883,
-1.2447314262390137,
0.502871572971344,
-0.07565420120954514,
-0.4904179573059082,
-0.6377137899398804,
0.35213038325309753,
-0.7158793210983276,
-0.13631951808929443,
0.7605623602867126,
-0.3731384873390198,
-0.23334099352359772,
-0.3718230128288269,
0.06237873062491417,
0.24539996683597565,
-0.06714975833892822,
0.40823426842689514,
0.6357622742652893,
-0.06984035670757294,
-0.30008602142333984,
-1.2195545434951782,
0.9037858843803406,
0.517127513885498,
-0.9015418887138367,
-0.2046828716993332,
0.018872953951358795,
-0.15986086428165436,
0.19954383373260498,
0.3733510673046112,
0.010935315862298012,
0.3105708956718445,
0.06972937285900116,
0.0618673637509346,
0.25602972507476807,
-0.2793258726596832,
-0.21697652339935303,
-0.084751196205616,
0.252290815114975,
-0.08931131660938263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17505v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17505v3 | Arrows of Time for Large Language Models | 2024-01-30T23:46:35 | 2024-06-03T17:35:04 | Vassilis Papadopoulos, Jérémie Wenger, Clément Hongler | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We study the probabilistic modeling performed by Autoregressive Large
Language Models (LLMs) through the angle of time directionality, addressing a
question first raised in (Shannon, 1951). For large enough models, we
empirically find a time asymmetry in their ability to learn natural language: a
difference in the average log-perplexity when trying to predict the next token
versus when trying to predict the previous one. This difference is at the same
time subtle and very consistent across various modalities (language, model
size, training time, ...). Theoretically, this is surprising: from an
information-theoretic point of view, there should be no such difference. We
provide a theoretical framework to explain how such an asymmetry can appear
from sparsity and computational complexity considerations, and outline a number
of perspectives opened by our results. | [
-0.03904849290847778,
-0.8328683972358704,
0.6851109266281128,
0.30609506368637085,
-0.3571542799472809,
0.39360037446022034,
0.1296965777873993,
-0.6533153653144836,
0.06783338636159897,
0.03837350755929947,
-0.6787800192832947,
-0.31149032711982727,
-0.7819250226020813,
0.08080348372459412,
-0.7320098876953125,
0.7114630937576294,
-0.12013261020183563,
0.18182316422462463,
0.2095223069190979,
-0.11976511776447296,
0.01201311033219099,
-0.3464619815349579,
-1.019069790840149,
-0.3256281614303589,
0.6910199522972107,
0.1057669147849083,
0.9997236728668213,
1.0111517906188965,
0.5874010920524597,
0.2420797199010849,
0.15330922603607178,
-0.46068549156188965,
-0.17662052810192108,
0.31188148260116577,
-0.033512454479932785,
-0.5201718807220459,
-0.10244406759738922,
0.19703081250190735,
1.0584821701049805,
1.090836763381958,
-0.12229626625776291,
0.05290192365646362,
0.05067061260342598,
0.9337254166603088,
-0.3240463137626648,
0.04821232333779335,
-0.6021848917007446,
0.18539844453334808,
-0.31639009714126587,
-0.4409467875957489,
-0.01915031298995018,
-0.24833430349826813,
0.28569164872169495,
-0.5064507126808167,
0.2559538781642914,
0.35624709725379944,
0.8875513672828674,
0.05694117397069931,
-0.4438541829586029,
-0.45667803287506104,
-1.053175687789917,
1.0960376262664795,
-0.7899101972579956,
0.5042334198951721,
0.33632683753967285,
0.5715349912643433,
-0.24988628923892975,
-0.600542426109314,
-0.40505504608154297,
-0.33590206503868103,
0.35661154985427856,
-0.3974485993385315,
-0.25852546095848083,
-0.04194306954741478,
0.37216195464134216,
0.06322263181209564,
-0.7288286089897156,
0.35390499234199524,
-0.20175103843212128,
0.15748290717601776,
0.8563756942749023,
0.23666277527809143,
0.17881131172180176,
0.051081880927085876,
-0.37649810314178467,
0.19430392980575562,
-1.024289608001709,
0.120385080575943,
0.8963149189949036,
0.19167016446590424,
-0.07893620431423187,
0.6808323264122009,
-0.08756275475025177,
0.8039281368255615,
0.17730200290679932,
-0.03836227208375931,
-0.15571331977844238,
-0.2611050605773926,
-0.0888703241944313,
-0.04307194799184799,
0.7525998950004578,
-0.01313443947583437,
0.23834958672523499,
-0.17453081905841827,
-0.2977920472621918,
-0.2870943248271942,
-0.1883297711610794,
-0.6098469495773315,
-0.14286136627197266,
0.23707546293735504,
-0.4039474129676819,
-0.21837671101093292,
-0.09338122606277466,
-0.470968633890152,
-0.5125367641448975,
-0.4729287028312683,
0.22503452003002167,
-0.48743554949760437,
-0.35428208112716675,
0.0681619718670845,
0.1522606611251831,
0.5064613819122314,
0.26408621668815613,
-0.5866376161575317,
0.15745984017848969,
0.900705099105835,
0.8494221568107605,
-0.16903634369373322,
-0.44722703099250793,
-0.4882573187351227,
0.009160531684756279,
-0.483584463596344,
0.5980075001716614,
-0.9147680401802063,
-0.2640140652656555,
0.08893397450447083,
-0.09299435466527939,
-0.043362151831388474,
-0.27376917004585266,
-0.0038739449810236692,
-0.6579440236091614,
0.041206568479537964,
-0.15062877535820007,
-0.5165379643440247,
-0.1651362031698227,
0.009122861549258232,
-0.4679112136363983,
0.5235027074813843,
-0.22903931140899658,
-0.7325173020362854,
0.45262375473976135,
-0.26157963275909424,
-0.4499121904373169,
-0.06423187255859375,
-0.46550264954566956,
-0.3632398843765259,
0.1892186999320984,
-0.28024759888648987,
0.43545499444007874,
-0.3285687267780304,
0.5029169321060181,
-0.5151296854019165,
-0.10683812201023102,
0.8596612215042114,
-0.6068468689918518,
1.1715558767318726,
0.5232846140861511,
-0.41207176446914673,
-0.06605681777000427,
-0.8965520262718201,
-0.27184250950813293,
0.12650904059410095,
-0.4456474781036377,
-0.31061965227127075,
0.5828048586845398,
-0.2749412953853607,
0.24131092429161072,
0.17824052274227142,
-0.5260358452796936,
0.3230663239955902,
-0.3001808822154999,
0.471170037984848,
0.8465784192085266,
-0.2739427983760834,
0.49229246377944946,
-0.2087719589471817,
0.5682070851325989,
0.18776163458824158,
0.14126144349575043,
0.2672247886657715,
-0.3937510848045349,
-0.7544378042221069,
-0.13534647226333618,
0.13706980645656586,
0.32863789796829224,
-0.6581814289093018,
0.192193403840065,
-0.1325768083333969,
-0.19977490603923798,
-0.4232451915740967,
0.30301812291145325,
0.4959741532802582,
0.0880257710814476,
-0.023339927196502686,
-0.3285476565361023,
-0.5972984433174133,
-0.635030210018158,
-0.5374573469161987,
-0.46642863750457764,
-0.10464084148406982,
0.12133707106113434,
0.4231949746608734,
-0.011375992558896542,
0.7828715443611145,
-0.19312673807144165,
0.1378975361585617,
-0.2923106551170349,
0.6108062267303467,
0.24552269279956818,
0.3923355042934418,
0.3877865970134735,
-0.6307754516601562,
-0.5125414133071899,
-0.10690581053495407,
-0.8402597904205322,
0.009983825497329235,
-0.02144527994096279,
0.16798365116119385,
0.6782171130180359,
0.8643143177032471,
-0.6323890089988708,
0.4581267833709717,
0.4290810227394104,
-0.5830931663513184,
0.6079950332641602,
0.00837779138237238,
-0.20646758377552032,
-0.8321729302406311,
-0.005333693698048592,
0.018586289137601852,
0.0007827231311239302,
-0.5965703129768372,
-0.18000651895999908,
-0.3616880774497986,
0.024868160486221313,
-0.3537723124027252,
0.7553470134735107,
-0.7591472864151001,
-0.3624153733253479,
-0.16115568578243256,
0.15908867120742798,
-0.20250388979911804,
0.2839328944683075,
0.06636986136436462,
0.2946617901325226,
0.6468740701675415,
-0.7994701862335205,
0.26177066564559937,
-0.5447083115577698,
-0.3286581337451935,
0.6630361676216125,
-0.6777382493019104,
-0.001163431559689343,
-0.3770861327648163,
0.015931300818920135,
-1.2104625701904297,
-0.11725898832082748,
0.05842863395810127,
-0.8513858318328857,
0.676354169845581,
-0.23037907481193542,
-0.23322907090187073,
-0.2816586196422577,
-0.3462692201137543,
0.6287498474121094,
0.4314698278903961,
-0.3573494255542755,
0.6234935522079468,
0.20873302221298218,
-0.22831815481185913,
-1.088297963142395,
-0.4448435604572296,
-0.11894091963768005,
-0.14779411256313324,
-0.47070300579071045,
-0.14027568697929382,
-0.046937596052885056,
-0.9598336219787598,
0.1317603886127472,
0.03815670683979988,
-0.010799244977533817,
0.21120567619800568,
0.1857583224773407,
0.22206860780715942,
-0.39430445432662964,
0.22252798080444336,
-0.3515934348106384,
-0.06505919992923737,
0.22587279975414276,
-0.4878361225128174,
0.5607483983039856,
-0.10543395578861237,
-0.7568370699882507,
-0.453461229801178,
0.20673951506614685,
0.4431401789188385,
0.10593216866254807,
0.8133695721626282,
0.400575190782547,
-0.2505313754081726,
0.16607604920864105,
-0.7411410808563232,
0.006004055961966515,
-0.42109227180480957,
0.4369388222694397,
-0.32392463088035583,
-0.548325777053833,
0.7883537411689758,
0.6388384103775024,
0.34403079748153687,
0.47454169392585754,
0.26266494393348694,
-0.38449156284332275,
1.1786624193191528,
0.5697668194770813,
-0.18133516609668732,
0.7773323059082031,
-0.29107242822647095,
0.3855472505092621,
-0.6168452501296997,
-0.3255269229412079,
-0.6548102498054504,
-0.44747138023376465,
-0.6274995803833008,
-0.26558294892311096,
-0.160938560962677,
0.17949585616588593,
-0.4884639084339142,
-0.04430210962891579,
0.012542910873889923,
0.30870410799980164,
0.4982546865940094,
-0.40889817476272583,
0.40262600779533386,
0.1595413088798523,
0.016697341576218605,
0.06847919523715973,
-0.660453736782074,
-0.29260876774787903,
1.164031744003296,
0.5556214451789856,
1.1373084783554077,
0.13435353338718414,
0.5500139594078064,
-0.0591813363134861,
-0.005961129441857338,
-0.8339192271232605,
0.6750736236572266,
0.017990896478295326,
-0.6962867379188538,
-0.6712044477462769,
-0.40754425525665283,
-1.4710912704467773,
-0.17404110729694366,
-0.08555929362773895,
-0.6268202066421509,
0.15012110769748688,
0.2638010084629059,
-0.14669834077358246,
0.5075170397758484,
-0.39533793926239014,
0.5273802280426025,
-0.4231690764427185,
-0.463846892118454,
-0.19487392902374268,
-0.7708832025527954,
-0.07049622386693954,
0.22554464638233185,
0.22177831828594208,
-0.3311375081539154,
-0.11023762822151184,
0.9127237796783447,
-0.2795071005821228,
0.83342045545578,
-0.28807011246681213,
0.006910332478582859,
0.7859647274017334,
0.48063579201698303,
0.6705849170684814,
-0.07715946435928345,
0.201273575425148,
0.20371560752391815,
-0.13969966769218445,
-0.5270804166793823,
-0.4764883816242218,
0.6571111679077148,
-0.8986474871635437,
-0.7200824618339539,
-0.6565729975700378,
-0.5821834206581116,
-0.007373124826699495,
-0.05717657133936882,
0.37933585047721863,
0.6896345615386963,
-0.12886878848075867,
0.2120305895805359,
0.6549537777900696,
-0.24466539919376373,
0.843975305557251,
0.8704606294631958,
-0.4083232283592224,
0.12259317189455032,
0.8156536221504211,
0.6495056748390198,
0.485400527715683,
0.48001646995544434,
0.13040758669376373,
-0.443401962518692,
-0.7446616888046265,
-0.09606213867664337,
0.6193568110466003,
-0.6648837327957153,
0.11606321483850479,
-0.4501538872718811,
-0.4928741455078125,
-0.47460252046585083,
-0.27112337946891785,
-0.4398627281188965,
-0.6564387679100037,
-0.3719501495361328,
-0.06304256618022919,
0.3487410247325897,
1.108901858329773,
0.07076037675142288,
0.1738511174917221,
-0.4322376251220703,
-0.1749802976846695,
0.4127536416053772,
0.2716882526874542,
0.1086995080113411,
-0.8386315107345581,
-0.10130688548088074,
0.005671619903296232,
-0.2376369833946228,
-0.7078648209571838,
0.3812197744846344,
0.07558658719062805,
0.5930811762809753,
0.6227380037307739,
-0.2803286910057068,
0.42607173323631287,
-0.508459746837616,
0.709613025188446,
0.328492671251297,
-0.7276556491851807,
0.1679142713546753,
-0.5609521269798279,
0.4347837269306183,
0.06725914031267166,
0.7688822150230408,
-0.4348924458026886,
-0.5040550231933594,
-0.9432801008224487,
-0.8194239139556885,
0.2865411043167114,
-0.009045584127306938,
-0.20926932990550995,
0.16111384332180023,
0.265661358833313,
0.22327162325382233,
0.3158442974090576,
-0.7731559872627258,
-0.1560826450586319,
-0.04977673292160034,
-0.2942913770675659,
-0.29301080107688904,
-0.5570470094680786,
-0.01329689472913742,
-0.11001994460821152,
0.5451655983924866,
0.01838330738246441,
0.5613951086997986,
-0.06049424037337303,
-0.1319016069173813,
-0.2729121744632721,
0.36582130193710327,
0.5803560018539429,
1.1837072372436523,
-0.17057104408740997,
0.5134046673774719,
-0.06493311375379562,
-0.38130423426628113,
0.1951654851436615,
0.047354359179735184,
-0.006711198017001152,
0.12795321643352509,
0.7038813829421997,
0.8499521613121033,
0.08583051711320877,
-0.3384177088737488,
0.40815621614456177,
0.1987845003604889,
-0.09067674726247787,
-0.6229414939880371,
-0.23790448904037476,
0.02303590252995491,
0.42932581901550293,
0.6589558124542236,
-0.32092612981796265,
0.014066394418478012,
-0.7631542682647705,
-0.23368704319000244,
0.9194183349609375,
-0.2795695960521698,
-0.7197527289390564,
0.40979379415512085,
0.13329623639583588,
-0.6920220255851746,
0.5669238567352295,
-0.31735748052597046,
-0.19281095266342163,
0.7847909331321716,
0.39814329147338867,
1.161885142326355,
-0.41666093468666077,
0.05626147240400314,
0.25063684582710266,
0.1861768662929535,
-0.12964609265327454,
0.27216586470603943,
0.15172919631004333,
-0.5796883702278137,
-0.35864269733428955,
-0.7486715316772461,
-0.10361825674772263,
0.16529370844364166,
-0.44167080521583557,
0.23073779046535492,
-0.5914989113807678,
-0.21237099170684814,
-0.007597654592245817,
0.046358559280633926,
-0.6065609455108643,
-0.08191362768411636,
0.025075921788811684,
0.6497551798820496,
-0.8606990575790405,
0.7609111666679382,
0.52885502576828,
-0.1963278353214264,
-0.7414780855178833,
-0.08669830113649368,
0.09119793772697449,
-0.947212278842926,
0.9670844674110413,
0.0705055370926857,
-0.5537503361701965,
-0.21892660856246948,
-0.8585318326950073,
-1.0754085779190063,
1.0333867073059082,
0.16874352097511292,
-0.8342952132225037,
-0.35482916235923767,
0.09032249450683594,
0.6479607820510864,
-0.48029813170433044,
-0.03402262553572655,
0.5205311179161072,
0.024509849026799202,
0.3165600001811981,
-0.7387577295303345,
-0.17529842257499695,
0.12442713230848312,
0.08742697536945343,
0.23956948518753052,
-0.39768388867378235,
1.1258975267410278,
-0.48364999890327454,
-0.4925811290740967,
-0.06836632639169693,
0.7258710265159607,
0.09103422611951828,
0.44211259484291077,
0.26159557700157166,
0.10584761947393417,
0.5208298563957214,
0.029777411371469498,
1.1365900039672852,
-0.5191841721534729,
0.25028470158576965,
0.9546718001365662,
-0.1654069423675537,
0.8748030066490173,
0.8317205309867859,
-0.4942832887172699,
0.4666910469532013,
0.48430800437927246,
0.4318385720252991,
0.20686794817447662,
0.18574126064777374,
-0.28217506408691406,
-0.2734676003456116,
0.14403025805950165,
-0.3127833306789398,
0.10856067389249802,
0.3428318500518799,
-0.3926358222961426,
-0.031296517699956894,
-0.25827717781066895,
0.3719869554042816,
-0.12690991163253784,
-0.42932379245758057,
0.5164028406143188,
0.3633618652820587,
-0.6925395131111145,
0.5727866888046265,
-0.13474281132221222,
0.4549390971660614,
-0.676063597202301,
0.14004597067832947,
-0.11233846843242645,
0.35227033495903015,
-0.12318947911262512,
-1.0577737092971802,
0.34192416071891785,
-0.142902210354805,
0.04346179589629173,
-0.03385433182120323,
0.5330337285995483,
-0.39961060881614685,
-0.7379452586174011,
0.39263588190078735,
0.36869341135025024,
0.16241055727005005,
0.3622586727142334,
-0.7999911308288574,
0.0961446538567543,
-0.1218348890542984,
-0.4399590790271759,
0.30327340960502625,
0.5955962538719177,
0.006801338866353035,
1.27569580078125,
0.22436676919460297,
0.19773206114768982,
0.5268888473510742,
-0.2390054613351822,
0.3869452476501465,
-0.6574790477752686,
-0.23484274744987488,
-1.3007279634475708,
0.2294996976852417,
0.17255103588104248,
-0.19202174246311188,
0.926175057888031,
0.31272587180137634,
0.7353888750076294,
0.060665570199489594,
0.5505170822143555,
0.0021970670204609632,
0.5780120491981506,
-0.8616036772727966,
0.3860824704170227,
-0.5092668533325195,
0.4964851438999176,
0.0026060326490551233,
-0.8638968467712402,
-0.21025502681732178,
0.7638267278671265,
-0.6451270580291748,
0.1125275269150734,
0.9152572154998779,
0.6358721256256104,
0.2695438265800476,
-0.233989879488945,
0.11655675619840622,
0.4607272148132324,
0.3349408209323883,
0.590599775314331,
0.9701223373413086,
-0.05652179569005966,
0.47038978338241577,
0.10286968946456909,
-0.1037662923336029,
-0.43501466512680054,
-0.9394786953926086,
-1.0194199085235596,
-0.7410794496536255,
-0.460506796836853,
-0.4640887975692749,
0.2923324704170227,
1.0579547882080078,
0.30995744466781616,
-0.6650190949440002,
-0.7893296480178833,
-0.2445591539144516,
0.2526775002479553,
-0.028559017926454544,
-0.17559240758419037,
0.21091067790985107,
-0.3711990714073181,
-0.43183207511901855,
-0.052729275077581406,
0.30086731910705566,
0.5281484127044678,
-0.6288126111030579,
-0.18301306664943695,
-0.5531589388847351,
0.3176669478416443,
0.5226441025733948,
0.7312665581703186,
-0.6554638743400574,
-0.3676515221595764,
0.0488852933049202,
-0.14913496375083923,
0.08500760048627853,
0.8812326788902283,
-0.39239323139190674,
0.46254366636276245,
0.5023713111877441,
0.31857576966285706,
0.336578905582428,
-0.27022436261177063,
0.7069041132926941,
-0.6127522587776184,
0.33653774857521057,
0.1492334008216858,
0.29705581068992615,
0.45006728172302246,
-0.20349524915218353,
0.4325898587703705,
0.3921654522418976,
-0.5389374494552612,
-0.9075930118560791,
0.6730735301971436,
-0.5940095782279968,
-0.2585580348968506,
1.5230190753936768,
-0.17450521886348724,
-0.34572941064834595,
-0.2965160608291626,
0.1856636106967926,
0.24197673797607422,
-0.14288528263568878,
0.7386278510093689,
1.000799536705017,
-0.3866764307022095,
0.1468653529882431,
-0.5835603475570679,
0.6447031497955322,
0.2716546356678009,
-0.37235260009765625,
0.0798334926366806,
0.37365180253982544,
0.6022568345069885,
0.09810414165258408,
0.6486839652061462,
-0.12630486488342285,
0.01638013683259487,
0.03677656501531601,
-0.3162853419780731,
0.07200706005096436,
-0.7458428144454956,
-0.6694032549858093,
-0.1605846881866455,
0.7432078123092651,
-0.15476839244365692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01763v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01763v2 | When Large Language Models Meet Vector Databases: A Survey | 2024-01-30T23:35:28 | 2024-02-06T01:25:18 | Zhi Jing, Yongye Su, Yikun Han, Bo Yuan, Haiyun Xu, Chunjiang Liu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This survey explores the synergistic potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) and Vector Databases (VecDBs), a burgeoning but rapidly evolving
research area. With the proliferation of LLMs comes a host of challenges,
including hallucinations, outdated knowledge, prohibitive commercial
application costs, and memory issues. VecDBs emerge as a compelling solution to
these issues by offering an efficient means to store, retrieve, and manage the
high-dimensional vector representations intrinsic to LLM operations. Through
this nuanced review, we delineate the foundational principles of LLMs and
VecDBs and critically analyze their integration's impact on enhancing LLM
functionalities. This discourse extends into a discussion on the speculative
future developments in this domain, aiming to catalyze further research into
optimizing the confluence of LLMs and VecDBs for advanced data handling and
knowledge extraction capabilities. | [
-0.6805159449577332,
-0.6840094327926636,
0.7867149710655212,
0.12341727316379547,
0.05518854036927223,
0.5089642405509949,
-0.36476972699165344,
-0.6284076571464539,
0.3206346035003662,
0.7088988423347473,
-0.3104170560836792,
-0.48949283361434937,
-0.6213815808296204,
-0.06595586985349655,
-0.7387582063674927,
0.46197426319122314,
0.024195270612835884,
0.0835626944899559,
-0.6438437700271606,
-0.16276313364505768,
-0.6046448945999146,
-1.1283332109451294,
-0.1671205759048462,
-0.06497833877801895,
0.5931162238121033,
0.2871135473251343,
0.8123838901519775,
0.6863371729850769,
0.6206686496734619,
0.30697721242904663,
-0.14649631083011627,
0.1444893479347229,
-0.7724168300628662,
0.5434747338294983,
-0.17834784090518951,
-0.4545465409755707,
-0.43933728337287903,
-0.177608922123909,
0.6216456294059753,
0.8813278079032898,
-0.1849822849035263,
-0.08247290551662445,
-0.15485134720802307,
0.4542933404445648,
-0.6782314777374268,
-0.06284956634044647,
-0.38815808296203613,
-0.06845729053020477,
-0.5159952044487,
-0.0956844687461853,
-0.10747715830802917,
-0.25315678119659424,
0.23196615278720856,
-0.11985297501087189,
-0.16371102631092072,
0.12426989525556564,
0.5962507724761963,
0.08900153636932373,
-0.47794613242149353,
-0.27410367131233215,
-1.0600154399871826,
0.9020613431930542,
-0.2581525444984436,
0.7314519882202148,
0.07987932860851288,
0.34842172265052795,
-0.5493811964988708,
-0.7176777124404907,
-0.7067353129386902,
0.08564717322587967,
0.20816197991371155,
-0.03558824956417084,
-0.3784966468811035,
-0.12477856874465942,
0.19690166413784027,
0.6467226147651672,
-0.37299418449401855,
0.5266715288162231,
-0.3906340003013611,
-0.023024456575512886,
0.5359782576560974,
0.4841594696044922,
0.27437734603881836,
-0.2858743965625763,
-0.544600248336792,
0.12201521545648575,
-0.9330158829689026,
-0.110345758497715,
0.19507744908332825,
-0.01191018894314766,
0.06262970715761185,
0.8252260088920593,
-0.021793918684124947,
0.8488113880157471,
-0.47941160202026367,
0.2100328505039215,
0.10785574465990067,
-0.5352491140365601,
-0.12645944952964783,
-0.3645298480987549,
0.7583110928535461,
0.09904271364212036,
0.19073282182216644,
-0.342387318611145,
-0.30274105072021484,
-0.03076520748436451,
0.2685897946357727,
-0.554747998714447,
-0.08287817984819412,
0.328061044216156,
-0.5117840766906738,
-0.14518508315086365,
0.009111412800848484,
-0.7725740671157837,
-0.5219936370849609,
-0.7539304494857788,
0.05870812386274338,
-0.41234755516052246,
-0.44902077317237854,
0.28516221046447754,
-0.07767971605062485,
0.5378988981246948,
0.2956622838973999,
-0.845669686794281,
0.4272204339504242,
1.2069898843765259,
0.7006963491439819,
-0.598321795463562,
0.05514125898480415,
-0.2530425190925598,
0.26910290122032166,
-0.25726422667503357,
0.859016478061676,
-0.7303799986839294,
-0.7945473790168762,
0.26932260394096375,
-0.08454109728336334,
0.39360105991363525,
-0.6745643019676208,
0.477641761302948,
-0.6302582025527954,
-0.2365962266921997,
-0.7021877765655518,
-0.6748692393302917,
0.010061323642730713,
0.20915807783603668,
-0.7743357419967651,
0.9263405799865723,
0.08933936804533005,
-0.7045485973358154,
0.21684452891349792,
0.10296142101287842,
-0.4676937460899353,
0.20507636666297913,
-0.5810748338699341,
-0.16083410382270813,
0.34059515595436096,
-0.01483884546905756,
0.742479145526886,
-0.8985312581062317,
0.14664757251739502,
-0.5538609027862549,
-0.09301203489303589,
0.5100731253623962,
-0.27310270071029663,
0.7003754377365112,
0.27054667472839355,
0.5048288702964783,
-0.1056685745716095,
-0.8230382800102234,
-0.1254969984292984,
0.05232207477092743,
-0.42385727167129517,
-0.663642168045044,
0.2332167625427246,
-0.13524657487869263,
0.1482672244310379,
0.5158368349075317,
-0.3807942271232605,
0.30492642521858215,
-0.16149426996707916,
0.4706287384033203,
0.6297487616539001,
-0.22509264945983887,
0.43960073590278625,
-0.18298093974590302,
0.6377546191215515,
0.05550520122051239,
0.020080160349607468,
-0.004698774311691523,
-0.1089434027671814,
-0.6090649366378784,
-0.4168267250061035,
0.20993386209011078,
0.36903566122055054,
-0.8531169891357422,
0.47748956084251404,
-0.33757147192955017,
-0.6210761070251465,
-0.24415907263755798,
0.25403934717178345,
-0.17961803078651428,
0.06377391517162323,
0.1604367345571518,
-0.33593887090682983,
-0.6624107956886292,
-0.7827426791191101,
-0.05681315064430237,
-0.15452198684215546,
0.11576483398675919,
0.4101502299308777,
0.25923484563827515,
-0.31196102499961853,
1.039860486984253,
-0.5410301685333252,
-0.18897877633571625,
-0.5284344553947449,
-0.32827022671699524,
0.23974920809268951,
0.2582792043685913,
0.6663951277732849,
-0.6604048013687134,
-0.18838375806808472,
0.14314839243888855,
-0.8958982825279236,
0.02014024183154106,
0.2742217183113098,
-0.14045961201190948,
0.054033588618040085,
0.8094672560691833,
-0.9342793226242065,
0.018973251804709435,
0.7311276793479919,
-0.05345958471298218,
0.6191918253898621,
-0.29152703285217285,
-0.11969169974327087,
-0.9532824158668518,
-0.25013136863708496,
-0.22786088287830353,
-0.13273519277572632,
-0.6131433248519897,
-0.26189857721328735,
0.07589167356491089,
0.15930680930614471,
-0.1733536422252655,
0.3973516523838043,
-0.727115273475647,
-0.37524688243865967,
-0.14048296213150024,
0.17354559898376465,
-0.13780102133750916,
-0.014697618782520294,
-0.1525673121213913,
0.6471744775772095,
0.973641574382782,
-0.6689020395278931,
0.7379947900772095,
0.32824134826660156,
-0.40550991892814636,
0.6509422659873962,
-0.5089012980461121,
-0.026771480217576027,
-0.24373872578144073,
0.09201204031705856,
-0.9666253328323364,
-0.11075568199157715,
0.024814119562506676,
-0.31953296065330505,
0.48454245924949646,
0.09800716489553452,
-0.6499869227409363,
-0.5291058421134949,
-0.27006277441978455,
0.37343236804008484,
0.5422382354736328,
-0.623035192489624,
0.8671584129333496,
1.005642294883728,
-0.3373311460018158,
-0.7265117168426514,
-0.42871251702308655,
0.2782127559185028,
-0.13883168995380402,
-0.6693167090415955,
0.03621114417910576,
0.29919105768203735,
-0.44734206795692444,
0.09625735133886337,
-0.031406089663505554,
0.064083531498909,
-0.04504377767443657,
0.054042112082242966,
0.5255504250526428,
-0.2105187475681305,
0.31386086344718933,
-0.18554642796516418,
-0.054998721927404404,
0.3068562150001526,
-0.5230711698532104,
0.598223865032196,
0.11830747872591019,
-0.1865665465593338,
0.24979755282402039,
0.34819209575653076,
0.5363057255744934,
-0.5169849395751953,
0.8324551582336426,
0.45784351229667664,
-0.23636873066425323,
-0.41698455810546875,
-0.7074729800224304,
0.0597764328122139,
-0.4875938594341278,
0.580689549446106,
-0.41380012035369873,
-1.0720851421356201,
0.5409225225448608,
-0.3643814027309418,
-0.007357352878898382,
0.2032880187034607,
0.9128978848457336,
-0.3503052890300751,
0.5447596907615662,
0.8101054430007935,
-0.2548243999481201,
0.45417332649230957,
-0.28186726570129395,
0.3772335648536682,
-0.7575005292892456,
-0.32633811235427856,
-0.6774745583534241,
-0.21187026798725128,
-0.5468364953994751,
-0.6818849444389343,
0.1522291749715805,
-0.038404881954193115,
0.17030034959316254,
0.2551577687263489,
-0.14769817888736725,
0.34486114978790283,
0.37173324823379517,
-0.40611594915390015,
0.2577476501464844,
0.09651844948530197,
0.038472890853881836,
-0.07268355041742325,
-0.7754957675933838,
-0.41777610778808594,
1.2488974332809448,
0.45685625076293945,
1.0933663845062256,
0.27061697840690613,
0.5787385702133179,
-0.023127295076847076,
0.09845220297574997,
-0.6913518905639648,
0.7348175048828125,
-0.4399815499782562,
-0.4343664050102234,
-0.23484209179878235,
-0.29374805092811584,
-0.9218162894248962,
0.3552038371562958,
-0.3430948555469513,
-0.5885779857635498,
0.4502740800380707,
-0.08817600458860397,
-0.10731128603219986,
0.3766143321990967,
-0.4576619565486908,
0.6622737050056458,
-0.36458608508110046,
-0.5491841435432434,
-0.4539158344268799,
-0.43752703070640564,
0.5314487814903259,
-0.21722137928009033,
0.2814025282859802,
-0.023188799619674683,
-0.10733219236135483,
0.6266658902168274,
-0.33189040422439575,
0.4884568452835083,
0.16696062684059143,
-0.4988388121128082,
0.33518192172050476,
0.2117714136838913,
0.3859267830848694,
-0.13079619407653809,
0.14915595948696136,
0.47401154041290283,
0.13032840192317963,
-0.03257545083761215,
-0.41256552934646606,
0.9078192114830017,
-0.7942219376564026,
-0.6288979649543762,
-0.4343360364437103,
-0.6451001167297363,
-0.2759121358394623,
0.052605144679546356,
-0.25878196954727173,
0.40592432022094727,
-0.3684857189655304,
0.43830862641334534,
0.9036635160446167,
-0.5474047660827637,
0.14639978110790253,
0.4033896028995514,
-0.475296288728714,
-0.1098460927605629,
1.093434453010559,
0.16142123937606812,
0.39342212677001953,
0.38103893399238586,
-0.15750771760940552,
-0.3795730471611023,
-0.7020746469497681,
0.2412121444940567,
0.5604115128517151,
-0.8862482309341431,
-0.23947948217391968,
-0.8709257245063782,
-0.19553431868553162,
-0.3580048382282257,
-0.002986639505252242,
-0.3662196695804596,
-0.4232974648475647,
-0.38390424847602844,
-0.0762283056974411,
0.5088063478469849,
0.9263914227485657,
-0.2853555679321289,
0.08379905670881271,
-0.7565892338752747,
0.47382456064224243,
0.12347199022769928,
0.3623833954334259,
-0.05741302669048309,
-0.11530672013759613,
-0.23417764902114868,
-0.4272932708263397,
-0.031603164970874786,
-0.5519030094146729,
0.3010868430137634,
-0.2905789315700531,
0.6048054695129395,
0.2513841986656189,
-0.0868072584271431,
0.39270931482315063,
-0.5984715223312378,
0.5522022843360901,
0.0999932512640953,
-0.6058419942855835,
-0.08433011174201965,
-0.21241885423660278,
-0.1481858342885971,
0.019171634688973427,
0.551730215549469,
-0.7197853326797485,
-0.44748371839523315,
-0.28337663412094116,
-0.853114902973175,
0.49880897998809814,
-0.035055164247751236,
0.29118087887763977,
0.021277841180562973,
0.09841334074735641,
0.09086636453866959,
0.25009819865226746,
-0.1309765875339508,
-0.3636952340602875,
0.332882285118103,
-0.19037894904613495,
-0.09233085066080093,
-0.5943335890769958,
0.005513838026672602,
-0.21062369644641876,
0.22698494791984558,
0.3051895201206207,
0.20239868760108948,
-0.3277122378349304,
0.057041168212890625,
0.17180003225803375,
0.1715395748615265,
0.17208348214626312,
0.6743996143341064,
0.031776946038007736,
0.18715912103652954,
0.025583816692233086,
-0.5147920846939087,
0.11658267676830292,
-0.0624295249581337,
0.05278922989964485,
-0.0751492902636528,
0.19157645106315613,
0.5031412243843079,
0.10167475789785385,
-0.795238733291626,
0.39496639370918274,
-0.10488098114728928,
-0.034296900033950806,
-0.5084536075592041,
0.035782694816589355,
0.4742843210697174,
0.45296016335487366,
0.10894744098186493,
-0.1281435489654541,
-0.07629057765007019,
-0.4981570541858673,
0.1376880407333374,
0.7541670799255371,
-0.051776591688394547,
-0.258157342672348,
0.6481536626815796,
0.13608774542808533,
-0.05428693816065788,
0.4028909504413605,
0.254003643989563,
-0.42371654510498047,
0.4376561939716339,
0.14057078957557678,
0.707688570022583,
-0.12885910272598267,
-0.15253464877605438,
-0.030896279960870743,
0.2734842598438263,
-0.03089853748679161,
0.3736306130886078,
0.14294686913490295,
-0.9178954362869263,
-0.37278687953948975,
-0.6879854798316956,
-0.39127713441848755,
-0.10067921876907349,
-0.34782424569129944,
0.5787988901138306,
-0.3555401563644409,
-0.19963504374027252,
0.05488753318786621,
-0.11978572607040405,
-0.7565008997917175,
-0.20414923131465912,
0.2928508520126343,
0.8080947399139404,
-0.4017481207847595,
1.0565117597579956,
0.3906770348548889,
-0.3396850526332855,
-0.5093712210655212,
-0.42308542132377625,
-0.024655016139149666,
-0.8501304984092712,
0.9356294870376587,
-0.40085479617118835,
-0.04794541373848915,
0.03553100675344467,
-0.5164351463317871,
-1.053935170173645,
0.8661021590232849,
0.3255913257598877,
-0.6823756098747253,
-0.022203484550118446,
0.29908615350723267,
0.5206132531166077,
-0.15772074460983276,
-0.14445701241493225,
0.9455643892288208,
0.336189866065979,
0.2057316154241562,
-0.5223559141159058,
-0.11804037541151047,
0.18793469667434692,
0.14198487997055054,
0.23807524144649506,
-0.5267565846443176,
1.0993322134017944,
-0.11541517078876495,
-0.35355156660079956,
-0.014186499640345573,
1.05974280834198,
0.006131176371127367,
-0.3411969244480133,
0.20071575045585632,
0.4670153856277466,
0.6813676357269287,
-0.20401796698570251,
1.261993169784546,
-0.3406103551387787,
0.14446771144866943,
0.8035500049591064,
-0.6399536728858948,
0.8079746961593628,
0.6815458536148071,
-0.39027830958366394,
0.18297143280506134,
0.21836496889591217,
-0.06483378261327744,
0.1844269186258316,
0.3708561956882477,
-0.268201619386673,
-0.3980461061000824,
-0.10671874135732651,
-0.2789500653743744,
0.4076313376426697,
0.7514711618423462,
0.08920019119977951,
-0.1709875464439392,
-0.031462449580430984,
-0.12855158746242523,
0.17697276175022125,
-0.09442422538995743,
0.6400493383407593,
0.364359587430954,
-0.3001202642917633,
0.4916161596775055,
-0.10060541331768036,
0.5415331721305847,
-0.5722786784172058,
0.04794057086110115,
-0.06016753241419792,
0.28344547748565674,
-0.008414828218519688,
-0.994026780128479,
0.12144627422094345,
-0.1353776752948761,
-0.056305523961782455,
-0.2871825098991394,
0.7547140121459961,
-0.6131635904312134,
-0.32666724920272827,
0.47944188117980957,
0.8519378900527954,
-0.030245985835790634,
0.4450851380825043,
-0.2944176495075226,
0.7358112335205078,
-0.3404904007911682,
-0.10258680582046509,
0.28720951080322266,
0.97794109582901,
0.10753694921731949,
0.9062846899032593,
0.5688619613647461,
0.4658619463443756,
0.19549678266048431,
0.03406147286295891,
1.0480705499649048,
-0.8110430836677551,
-0.2670701742172241,
-0.6916466951370239,
0.1359112709760666,
-0.07912205904722214,
0.12462706118822098,
0.8358964920043945,
0.5275061130523682,
0.8694045543670654,
0.06532688438892365,
1.030090093612671,
-0.14876125752925873,
0.7222395539283752,
-0.5366689562797546,
0.6040443778038025,
-0.4189801812171936,
0.5391666889190674,
-0.20468707382678986,
-1.007216453552246,
-0.25180158019065857,
0.29806753993034363,
-0.4032779037952423,
-0.08887045085430145,
0.6048393249511719,
0.7076138257980347,
0.009321178309619427,
0.010628016665577888,
0.4149995446205139,
0.3859332501888275,
0.6454539895057678,
0.5558491945266724,
1.28542959690094,
-0.10640960931777954,
0.25419020652770996,
0.15848129987716675,
0.052029505372047424,
-0.22674328088760376,
-0.633877694606781,
-0.9947232604026794,
-0.5429016947746277,
-0.21524553000926971,
-0.16320466995239258,
-0.18048784136772156,
0.7044287323951721,
0.10337582975625992,
-0.6096758246421814,
-0.6355936527252197,
0.28130847215652466,
0.33931803703308105,
0.230689138174057,
-0.13987235724925995,
0.28452134132385254,
-0.37727683782577515,
-0.7812556624412537,
0.1805369257926941,
0.4247477948665619,
0.19809329509735107,
-0.780475378036499,
-0.11625050008296967,
-0.10971144586801529,
0.03597044199705124,
0.7557506561279297,
0.39036545157432556,
-0.44942358136177063,
-0.18390756845474243,
0.1482544094324112,
-0.3783020079135895,
-0.1716761589050293,
1.061867117881775,
-0.9623181223869324,
0.3215482532978058,
0.7416397333145142,
1.0855741500854492,
0.3049100339412689,
-0.2786283493041992,
0.9579370617866516,
-0.44152122735977173,
0.14636608958244324,
0.02679777331650257,
0.4371703565120697,
0.24213171005249023,
-0.08002155274152756,
0.26197350025177,
0.21755458414554596,
-0.4634602963924408,
-1.113472580909729,
0.2617383897304535,
-1.0161727666854858,
-0.33526408672332764,
1.0489641427993774,
0.27790459990501404,
-0.13374333083629608,
-0.2904292643070221,
-0.04145566374063492,
-0.11688698083162308,
0.07490884512662888,
0.4396197199821472,
0.8914059400558472,
0.21029742062091827,
-0.0866614505648613,
-0.7735165357589722,
0.48277807235717773,
0.15401962399482727,
-0.6780295372009277,
0.4987141489982605,
0.6608014106750488,
-0.09954103082418442,
-0.1611434817314148,
0.42375218868255615,
-0.21884524822235107,
-0.019653992727398872,
-0.26088660955429077,
0.09246400743722916,
-0.017976848408579826,
-0.3832801580429077,
-0.3051351010799408,
0.22852788865566254,
0.04953700676560402,
0.15648095309734344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17498v2 | Improving QA Model Performance with Cartographic Inoculation | 2024-01-30T23:08:26 | 2024-02-01T20:43:02 | Allen Chen, Okan Tanrikulu | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | QA models are faced with complex and open-ended contextual reasoning
problems, but can often learn well-performing solution heuristics by exploiting
dataset-specific patterns in their training data. These patterns, or "dataset
artifacts", reduce the model's ability to generalize to real-world QA problems.
Utilizing an ElectraSmallDiscriminator model trained for QA, we analyze the
impacts and incidence of dataset artifacts using an adversarial challenge set
designed to confuse models reliant on artifacts for prediction. Extending
existing work on methods for mitigating artifact impacts, we propose
cartographic inoculation, a novel method that fine-tunes models on an optimized
subset of the challenge data to reduce model reliance on dataset artifacts. We
show that by selectively fine-tuning a model on ambiguous adversarial examples
from a challenge set, significant performance improvements can be made on the
full challenge dataset with minimal loss of model generalizability to other
challenging environments and QA datasets. | [
-0.3195962905883789,
-0.5762174129486084,
0.46662798523902893,
-0.3294591009616852,
-0.3730570375919342,
0.10640742629766464,
0.02396995574235916,
-0.5000032782554626,
-0.1974756270647049,
0.8566988110542297,
-0.609736442565918,
-0.5198320150375366,
-0.46060818433761597,
-0.19740194082260132,
-0.2812165915966034,
1.0012950897216797,
0.02203209511935711,
0.2623603343963623,
-0.598408043384552,
-0.31394845247268677,
-0.804148256778717,
-0.7437337040901184,
-0.4385359287261963,
-0.5459110140800476,
-0.08891008049249649,
0.5943605303764343,
0.9891911745071411,
0.5854403376579285,
0.7463934421539307,
0.17644447088241577,
-0.18664562702178955,
0.6800094842910767,
-0.6383090019226074,
0.15961450338363647,
0.05883309617638588,
-0.7060472369194031,
-0.04903066158294678,
0.05070095509290695,
0.31068432331085205,
0.6965067982673645,
-0.09794800728559494,
0.4750998616218567,
0.05629422143101692,
0.37318629026412964,
-0.7857952117919922,
0.1140589639544487,
-0.5002395510673523,
-0.005504150874912739,
-0.16969579458236694,
-0.2729291021823883,
-0.5405446887016296,
-0.46968451142311096,
0.38530588150024414,
-1.225839376449585,
0.3590177297592163,
-0.0033860565163195133,
0.9566364288330078,
0.523736834526062,
-0.2347192019224167,
-0.2199060320854187,
-0.9112246036529541,
0.6529215574264526,
-0.7163452506065369,
-0.06697520613670349,
0.5001764297485352,
0.37117522954940796,
-0.41010287404060364,
-0.73903888463974,
-0.2864958345890045,
-0.09352601319551468,
0.04448515549302101,
-0.11793332546949387,
-0.2106129229068756,
0.040857717394828796,
0.5569264888763428,
0.13713157176971436,
-0.41739675402641296,
0.05121500417590141,
-0.44305577874183655,
0.08439705520868301,
0.5762741565704346,
0.4251134693622589,
0.3700024485588074,
0.17118635773658752,
-0.24345763027668,
-0.23729939758777618,
-0.8631356358528137,
0.16618309915065765,
0.28456488251686096,
0.3147984743118286,
0.28556859493255615,
0.43703994154930115,
-0.17998239398002625,
0.6462640762329102,
0.2821666896343231,
0.16119122505187988,
0.10195407271385193,
-0.07285095006227493,
-0.19417642056941986,
-0.22756342589855194,
-0.016604475677013397,
0.30630773305892944,
0.19416791200637817,
-0.34060734510421753,
-0.2846863567829132,
0.26005902886390686,
0.6019415855407715,
-0.6892003417015076,
-0.6944762468338013,
0.24798022210597992,
-0.23065543174743652,
-0.35321107506752014,
0.0384029783308506,
-0.477556049823761,
-0.5944028496742249,
-0.5346075296401978,
0.685768187046051,
-0.5773696303367615,
0.21472841501235962,
0.23469994962215424,
-0.16335776448249817,
-0.011615772731602192,
0.5947766900062561,
-0.48329418897628784,
0.22288848459720612,
0.6753937602043152,
0.7462798953056335,
0.021312007680535316,
-0.08927374333143234,
-0.5256981253623962,
0.2791692018508911,
-0.4564599096775055,
0.8860292434692383,
-0.7637290954589844,
-0.3694038689136505,
0.001468347618356347,
-0.15990924835205078,
0.06277015060186386,
-0.9445327520370483,
0.5655402541160583,
-0.642323911190033,
0.10080506652593613,
-0.37695425748825073,
-0.6155425906181335,
-0.5803791880607605,
0.3273423910140991,
-0.9034678936004639,
1.1389859914779663,
0.3117970824241638,
-0.2854742109775543,
0.723822832107544,
-0.5711881518363953,
-0.2912434935569763,
0.29105857014656067,
0.06023859977722168,
-0.8034915924072266,
0.08182540535926819,
0.5481187701225281,
-0.010995029471814632,
-0.3245631754398346,
-0.007798569276928902,
-0.33698365092277527,
-0.5986008048057556,
-0.006751940585672855,
0.09877406805753708,
0.7569755911827087,
0.04439239948987961,
-0.41887062788009644,
0.19413048028945923,
-0.8150457739830017,
0.1434779316186905,
0.037910737097263336,
-0.06943349540233612,
-0.6336511373519897,
0.11564755439758301,
-0.01180262677371502,
0.1825864166021347,
-0.0972195491194725,
-0.26746854186058044,
0.4440394639968872,
-0.26769140362739563,
0.2657603323459625,
0.6900164484977722,
0.1884099543094635,
0.5487249493598938,
-0.6522694826126099,
0.6659905910491943,
0.08869663625955582,
0.6545345783233643,
0.07576843351125717,
-0.7556561231613159,
-0.7270848155021667,
-0.4461670517921448,
0.07496622204780579,
0.40084949135780334,
-1.028460144996643,
-0.08690845966339111,
-0.22704385221004486,
-0.7026984095573425,
-0.5380499362945557,
-0.048309531062841415,
0.36917218565940857,
0.5242087841033936,
0.46076446771621704,
-0.5517792105674744,
-0.44166284799575806,
-0.5808756947517395,
0.02247033827006817,
-0.09303765743970871,
-0.12788434326648712,
0.2179541140794754,
0.6304282546043396,
0.1005856841802597,
0.758912980556488,
-0.5252858996391296,
-0.43356558680534363,
0.11937718838453293,
0.3305172920227051,
0.1347144991159439,
0.6761038899421692,
0.6508969664573669,
-0.7893479466438293,
-0.059330232441425323,
-0.18968670070171356,
-0.6734049916267395,
-0.0202603992074728,
-0.11650116741657257,
-0.2500506341457367,
-0.20158927142620087,
0.29655927419662476,
-0.6479275226593018,
0.6279540061950684,
0.1618761271238327,
-0.5790635347366333,
0.5312734842300415,
-0.23365500569343567,
0.427509605884552,
-0.5598609447479248,
-0.1454128921031952,
-0.20821742713451385,
0.057358402758836746,
-1.0369678735733032,
0.6077763438224792,
0.1286860704421997,
-0.3927041292190552,
-0.3927977681159973,
0.16047599911689758,
-0.3283092677593231,
0.03547244146466255,
-0.06198166310787201,
0.06543119251728058,
0.45215490460395813,
0.4559224247932434,
-0.24621877074241638,
0.6096251606941223,
0.27155208587646484,
-0.6554442644119263,
0.3308192193508148,
0.6515936255455017,
-0.4057028293609619,
0.7540068626403809,
-0.5451542735099792,
0.4670533239841461,
-0.1741437166929245,
0.30194541811943054,
-0.8478325009346008,
0.09556549787521362,
0.3172047436237335,
-0.036839116364717484,
0.22320589423179626,
-0.1641741245985031,
-0.5771425366401672,
-0.2621808350086212,
-0.39181044697761536,
0.846249520778656,
0.23420709371566772,
-0.9202645421028137,
0.5746706128120422,
0.12712332606315613,
0.5768069624900818,
-0.2645145654678345,
-0.6557289361953735,
-0.06973622739315033,
-0.5493990182876587,
-0.7049356698989868,
0.39176055788993835,
-0.09076093137264252,
-0.13261336088180542,
-0.19502541422843933,
0.17971166968345642,
-0.18356291949748993,
0.289273738861084,
0.30841657519340515,
0.3832385838031769,
-0.2009858340024948,
0.29889723658561707,
-0.32273074984550476,
0.0861864909529686,
0.0023464621044695377,
-0.5109473466873169,
0.33786579966545105,
0.19988983869552612,
-0.6560418605804443,
-0.49759647250175476,
0.28185564279556274,
0.7225045561790466,
-0.38320571184158325,
0.49191442131996155,
0.29621821641921997,
-0.6091408729553223,
-0.24863074719905853,
-0.5540441870689392,
-0.3944857716560364,
-0.4162499010562897,
0.43777143955230713,
-0.33471250534057617,
-0.28137537837028503,
0.8434520363807678,
-0.08141850680112839,
0.12898433208465576,
0.13358832895755768,
0.19992007315158844,
0.012488638050854206,
1.199617862701416,
0.4187740087509155,
-0.1001553162932396,
0.49608978629112244,
-0.610808253288269,
0.14042803645133972,
-0.8416599631309509,
-0.2673700749874115,
-0.5022697448730469,
-0.41981253027915955,
-0.28879162669181824,
-0.6960228085517883,
0.4923931956291199,
-0.0010372452670708299,
-0.30339303612709045,
-0.04104044288396835,
-0.8366048336029053,
0.35671117901802063,
0.7602097988128662,
0.7995554208755493,
0.36659935116767883,
-0.12020609527826309,
0.4675458073616028,
-0.13555151224136353,
-0.9710690975189209,
-0.545551061630249,
1.3986949920654297,
0.03731148689985275,
0.5810997486114502,
0.11471959203481674,
0.22869591414928436,
0.2703417241573334,
0.30287641286849976,
-0.42734211683273315,
0.183010533452034,
-0.266643762588501,
-0.4525412321090698,
-0.30969443917274475,
-0.071938157081604,
-0.8845732808113098,
0.07904202491044998,
-0.4220007359981537,
-0.5989079475402832,
0.6050601601600647,
0.22139693796634674,
-0.6162867546081543,
0.33050525188446045,
-0.5551320314407349,
0.7584839463233948,
0.07015185803174973,
-0.0663905069231987,
-0.22845208644866943,
-0.2999716103076935,
0.19236241281032562,
0.02827499248087406,
0.07260268181562424,
0.07381484657526016,
0.21313504874706268,
0.5011533498764038,
-0.5272493362426758,
0.7765589952468872,
-0.16281810402870178,
0.08612570911645889,
0.38317763805389404,
0.1524818390607834,
1.0336469411849976,
-0.08238726109266281,
-0.034623775631189346,
0.14017418026924133,
-0.00779381999745965,
-0.7031189799308777,
-0.8698008060455322,
0.23019158840179443,
-0.8065540790557861,
-0.6461416482925415,
0.010798816569149494,
-0.8303308486938477,
-0.17831335961818695,
-0.3336082100868225,
0.4933474361896515,
0.6971768736839294,
-0.14288818836212158,
-0.05197305977344513,
0.9576781988143921,
0.10511577129364014,
0.04113133251667023,
0.3626479506492615,
0.13175520300865173,
-0.16059242188930511,
0.7551788687705994,
0.3023800849914551,
0.47991248965263367,
-0.009585214778780937,
-0.20050190389156342,
0.03931427747011185,
-0.8845335841178894,
-0.602154552936554,
-0.23229195177555084,
-0.9257732629776001,
-0.4052125811576843,
-0.10502885282039642,
0.09438568353652954,
-0.16359342634677887,
-0.23984265327453613,
-0.11484949290752411,
-0.40818387269973755,
-0.7274007797241211,
0.12880216538906097,
0.456356942653656,
0.7922267317771912,
0.29868626594543457,
0.38764286041259766,
-0.3743336498737335,
0.1789637804031372,
0.24372883141040802,
0.097557432949543,
-0.10145724564790726,
-0.8043572902679443,
-0.4957190454006195,
0.10825572907924652,
-0.4689507484436035,
-0.9214991331100464,
0.2828763723373413,
0.24530091881752014,
0.5288493633270264,
0.3389035165309906,
0.12748698890209198,
0.9745383262634277,
-0.15965819358825684,
0.7095309495925903,
-0.35769250988960266,
-0.8409106731414795,
0.6723817586898804,
-0.23215289413928986,
0.4884621500968933,
0.42558377981185913,
-0.06365735083818436,
-0.1622607707977295,
-0.8169922828674316,
-0.5993307828903198,
-0.8623849749565125,
0.5320166945457458,
0.26173606514930725,
-0.2121158242225647,
0.17534539103507996,
0.7723164558410645,
-0.03904720023274422,
0.0035739168524742126,
-0.29147934913635254,
-0.0463126078248024,
-0.14090827107429504,
-0.0814896747469902,
0.020476585254073143,
-0.16730797290802002,
-0.5324171185493469,
-0.3113665282726288,
0.7738346457481384,
-0.2536885142326355,
-0.23052969574928284,
0.2777343690395355,
-0.4358777701854706,
-0.2982969582080841,
-0.2232559621334076,
0.6735454797744751,
0.7771996855735779,
-0.07383909076452255,
-0.1456386148929596,
0.45012009143829346,
-0.625036895275116,
0.2052331119775772,
0.022928817197680473,
-0.6381361484527588,
-0.025449758395552635,
0.3314380943775177,
0.607056200504303,
0.16287732124328613,
-0.5572057366371155,
0.34098654985427856,
-0.038178782910108566,
0.008371615782380104,
-0.15235567092895508,
-0.16992488503456116,
-0.5042840838432312,
0.7322381138801575,
0.47699397802352905,
0.07814811915159225,
0.4409705102443695,
-0.2341965138912201,
0.28990063071250916,
0.6524346470832825,
-0.44587287306785583,
-0.07362422347068787,
0.7581216096878052,
-0.07254205644130707,
-0.18344931304454803,
0.8752182722091675,
-0.010894048027694225,
-0.5237838625907898,
1.1609523296356201,
0.44654232263565063,
0.7001350522041321,
-0.3151857852935791,
0.2602523863315582,
0.39558470249176025,
0.5705827474594116,
-0.14530345797538757,
0.2413831353187561,
0.3187331557273865,
-0.5837039947509766,
-0.19582915306091309,
0.009241428226232529,
-0.4634138345718384,
0.131963312625885,
-0.8711884617805481,
0.34750896692276,
-0.3808213472366333,
-0.2544076442718506,
-0.38669559359550476,
0.016178466379642487,
-0.7615614533424377,
0.38913843035697937,
0.01010352373123169,
0.5751367807388306,
-0.9677738547325134,
0.5527774691581726,
0.7752315998077393,
-0.5109641551971436,
-0.6993471384048462,
-0.10565319657325745,
-0.1448533684015274,
-0.4455489218235016,
0.506263017654419,
-0.07577764242887497,
0.154057577252388,
-0.2245786190032959,
-0.5161622762680054,
-0.9988972544670105,
1.2027167081832886,
0.5935260653495789,
-0.2855099141597748,
0.14502908289432526,
0.09100694209337234,
0.5584879517555237,
-0.5578731894493103,
0.25249022245407104,
0.6266852021217346,
0.37311187386512756,
-0.20718543231487274,
-0.6512753963470459,
0.27213191986083984,
-0.1985519975423813,
0.2314181625843048,
0.23139332234859467,
-0.40411680936813354,
0.9110071659088135,
-0.3146907091140747,
-0.25467732548713684,
0.14234372973442078,
0.5383086800575256,
0.3550417721271515,
0.35927265882492065,
0.5639083981513977,
0.8401099443435669,
1.0780302286148071,
-0.3173738121986389,
0.8802807331085205,
-0.2655603289604187,
0.37053146958351135,
1.2172584533691406,
0.008074057288467884,
0.49459773302078247,
0.5559424757957458,
0.11630246043205261,
0.4363105893135071,
0.9560033679008484,
-0.38967078924179077,
0.6273411512374878,
0.3277702033519745,
-0.3135393261909485,
-0.24481181800365448,
-0.34304699301719666,
-0.494088351726532,
0.5528679490089417,
0.319752961397171,
-0.09544703364372253,
-0.12075580656528473,
0.3086356222629547,
-0.20703604817390442,
0.2867124080657959,
-0.40262892842292786,
0.622082531452179,
-0.411360502243042,
-0.4994336664676666,
0.6872291564941406,
-0.5022560358047485,
0.2744634747505188,
-0.19791929423809052,
-0.37461671233177185,
-0.20479269325733185,
0.0986594408750534,
-0.21266359090805054,
-0.28563836216926575,
0.09518617391586304,
-0.5768278241157532,
-0.35423702001571655,
0.1532888263463974,
0.27033624053001404,
-0.409994512796402,
-0.4266904890537262,
0.08142998069524765,
0.26809456944465637,
-0.09330754727125168,
-0.2119019478559494,
-0.34567660093307495,
-0.2697921693325043,
-0.2329653650522232,
-0.20823970437049866,
0.1156715601682663,
0.5298607349395752,
-0.3457667827606201,
0.8278166651725769,
0.5643286108970642,
0.08440455794334412,
-0.03579699248075485,
0.13392889499664307,
1.041821837425232,
-0.2710433900356293,
-0.510626494884491,
-0.5603782534599304,
0.4709649980068207,
-0.024930395185947418,
-0.5734198093414307,
0.41146230697631836,
0.5200258493423462,
0.9310019612312317,
-0.003043163800612092,
0.5442652106285095,
0.5225686430931091,
0.12390226125717163,
-0.4919978678226471,
0.7069225311279297,
-0.5271309018135071,
0.4334189295768738,
-0.23188839852809906,
-0.4109160900115967,
-0.4506407678127289,
0.24297736585140228,
-0.3211691975593567,
-0.16487988829612732,
0.5401784777641296,
0.7750030159950256,
0.04611022770404816,
0.10188832134008408,
0.31167325377464294,
-0.04433802515268326,
0.3722509443759918,
0.8351527452468872,
0.8537780046463013,
-0.5707533955574036,
0.6382056474685669,
-0.7351319193840027,
-0.3115278482437134,
-0.271431028842926,
-0.549137532711029,
-0.8183575868606567,
-0.700484573841095,
-0.433471143245697,
-0.5701137185096741,
0.43988388776779175,
0.5597654581069946,
0.8443074226379395,
-0.9214848875999451,
-0.07392622530460358,
0.07789511233568192,
0.12858939170837402,
-0.5619426369667053,
-0.2002754509449005,
0.4416484832763672,
-0.32070571184158325,
-0.67424076795578,
0.10484964400529861,
0.1553150713443756,
0.06945651024580002,
-0.11398927122354507,
0.18736442923545837,
-0.1620025336742401,
0.11231043934822083,
0.3692670464515686,
0.07093808799982071,
-0.6774811744689941,
-0.6171813011169434,
-0.2020479291677475,
-0.0664999708533287,
0.30824702978134155,
0.9347598552703857,
-0.8034805059432983,
0.7894734144210815,
0.11733172088861465,
0.43746429681777954,
0.504371166229248,
-0.02722794935107231,
0.7878671884536743,
-0.6049066185951233,
0.3883592486381531,
0.4834718108177185,
0.25413575768470764,
0.2827097475528717,
-0.939639687538147,
0.6591957211494446,
0.06985940784215927,
-0.6023199558258057,
-0.9567601680755615,
0.35948580503463745,
-0.4136716425418854,
-0.35918647050857544,
0.7000218629837036,
-0.40078407526016235,
-0.035806261003017426,
-0.4113944172859192,
-0.1552077829837799,
0.4543149769306183,
-0.1481027454137802,
1.3362163305282593,
0.707992434501648,
-0.11462190747261047,
-0.03143560513854027,
-0.5742669105529785,
0.6602327823638916,
0.7020700573921204,
-0.9051015973091125,
-0.10896981507539749,
0.5875543355941772,
0.001445415779016912,
0.16419963538646698,
0.10966406017541885,
0.040408190339803696,
0.8009127378463745,
-0.1052747592329979,
0.18943633139133453,
-0.0797245055437088,
-0.13604430854320526,
-0.5007180571556091,
0.4668061137199402,
0.10591642558574677,
-0.4026505649089813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17477v1 | Detecting mental disorder on social media: a ChatGPT-augmented explainable approach | 2024-01-30T22:22:55 | 2024-01-30T22:22:55 | Loris Belcastro, Riccardo Cantini, Fabrizio Marozzo, Domenico Talia, Paolo Trunfio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI | In the digital era, the prevalence of depressive symptoms expressed on social
media has raised serious concerns, necessitating advanced methodologies for
timely detection. This paper addresses the challenge of interpretable
depression detection by proposing a novel methodology that effectively combines
Large Language Models (LLMs) with eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) and
conversational agents like ChatGPT. In our methodology, explanations are
achieved by integrating BERTweet, a Twitter-specific variant of BERT, into a
novel self-explanatory model, namely BERT-XDD, capable of providing both
classification and explanations via masked attention. The interpretability is
further enhanced using ChatGPT to transform technical explanations into
human-readable commentaries. By introducing an effective and modular approach
for interpretable depression detection, our methodology can contribute to the
development of socially responsible digital platforms, fostering early
intervention and support for mental health challenges under the guidance of
qualified healthcare professionals. | [
-0.43700987100601196,
-1.1009211540222168,
0.8644497394561768,
0.6010315418243408,
-0.3837994635105133,
0.19739577174186707,
-0.23957566916942596,
-0.4060393273830414,
0.601996898651123,
-0.14022035896778107,
-1.3436578512191772,
-0.4797610342502594,
-0.8580719232559204,
-0.15848317742347717,
-0.6345201730728149,
1.113115906715393,
0.0028435036074370146,
-0.010796933434903622,
0.2629908621311188,
0.3705374300479889,
-0.3060925006866455,
-0.40305665135383606,
-1.2977648973464966,
-0.17646043002605438,
0.46993130445480347,
0.21051831543445587,
0.8599491119384766,
-0.10630951076745987,
0.6837659478187561,
0.1517251878976822,
-0.13496023416519165,
0.1878216564655304,
-0.6418076753616333,
-0.17258712649345398,
-0.1886456161737442,
-0.18197967112064362,
-0.6872904300689697,
-0.34549039602279663,
0.060980431735515594,
0.37830862402915955,
-0.06354852020740509,
-0.03695026785135269,
0.292728066444397,
0.3379473388195038,
-0.0725923627614975,
0.3995818495750427,
-0.2930856943130493,
0.23772358894348145,
0.03466908261179924,
-0.21232864260673523,
-0.02772696688771248,
-0.28862929344177246,
-0.13213029503822327,
-0.4183584451675415,
0.44425275921821594,
-0.6926223635673523,
0.6425924301147461,
0.46372175216674805,
-0.1928212195634842,
-0.4425637423992157,
-0.7989910840988159,
0.4132087528705597,
-0.6863101720809937,
0.07764145731925964,
0.5100148916244507,
0.5739246606826782,
-0.09600689262151718,
-0.45572972297668457,
-0.6794208884239197,
0.4190376102924347,
0.043544650077819824,
0.16450850665569305,
-0.2985825538635254,
-0.06497116386890411,
0.10143209993839264,
0.4473169147968292,
-0.747501015663147,
-0.06957461684942245,
-0.015207234770059586,
-0.017815297469496727,
0.7565433382987976,
-0.009863847866654396,
0.61723792552948,
-0.43542906641960144,
-0.07570353150367737,
0.5029696822166443,
-0.028585854917764664,
-0.06564581394195557,
-0.07077109068632126,
0.15695251524448395,
-0.5053879618644714,
0.4146098494529724,
0.11829584836959839,
0.17110830545425415,
0.19323672354221344,
0.07545654475688934,
-0.18026301264762878,
0.11261478811502457,
-0.20909743010997772,
0.21677595376968384,
0.6158644556999207,
0.5506246089935303,
0.271487832069397,
0.05179029330611229,
-0.19868654012680054,
0.2905157506465912,
0.21511374413967133,
-0.5620288848876953,
-0.720578670501709,
0.520314633846283,
-0.7879253029823303,
-0.2737537622451782,
-0.39023709297180176,
-0.8468528389930725,
-0.9832540154457092,
-0.16466814279556274,
0.4692625403404236,
-0.6923161745071411,
-0.7806582450866699,
0.06627443432807922,
-0.17068342864513397,
0.09456168860197067,
0.4572063982486725,
-0.8621571660041809,
0.11364560574293137,
0.7509062886238098,
1.2182979583740234,
-0.058495309203863144,
0.4188476502895355,
-0.0617588646709919,
0.1762603223323822,
-0.1678714007139206,
1.0419813394546509,
-0.16671858727931976,
-0.18380166590213776,
0.09226195514202118,
0.11200568079948425,
0.12091442197561264,
0.0009761365945450962,
0.659445583820343,
-0.15304537117481232,
-0.007088874001055956,
-0.26010411977767944,
-0.41558292508125305,
-0.021279390901327133,
0.3029477894306183,
-0.48644375801086426,
0.7551568150520325,
0.3723144829273224,
-1.0370347499847412,
0.2175222635269165,
-1.0134285688400269,
-0.2987828552722931,
0.35902684926986694,
0.06663595885038376,
-0.19806315004825592,
0.05296346917748451,
0.6175297498703003,
0.907913863658905,
0.02490966022014618,
0.3660522699356079,
-0.7513523101806641,
-0.3730100691318512,
0.3254096508026123,
-0.5290044546127319,
1.008020043373108,
0.24217376112937927,
-0.4154514670372009,
-0.02027001976966858,
-0.7571998238563538,
-0.16884316504001617,
0.3275373578071594,
-0.007259773556143045,
-0.21912696957588196,
0.3222346007823944,
0.180314302444458,
0.04094166308641434,
0.19150309264659882,
-0.3923282325267792,
-0.3073875606060028,
-0.15146970748901367,
0.7949743270874023,
0.9358706474304199,
0.10476905107498169,
-0.10505585372447968,
-0.14903101325035095,
0.5651296377182007,
-0.07841939479112625,
0.444633424282074,
-0.0887378379702568,
-0.6636372804641724,
-0.22480905055999756,
-1.010272741317749,
-0.12920989096164703,
0.6045674681663513,
-0.6350183486938477,
0.5745431184768677,
-0.2559940814971924,
-0.31856638193130493,
-0.6775302886962891,
-0.058169178664684296,
-0.06162307411432266,
0.32577449083328247,
0.217400923371315,
-0.04302329570055008,
-0.5625954270362854,
-0.746873676776886,
-0.18793100118637085,
-0.10356598347425461,
-0.0761488825082779,
0.15155276656150818,
0.10939261317253113,
-0.657741129398346,
0.7575429081916809,
-0.3407119810581207,
-0.24726244807243347,
-0.4892862141132355,
0.30747270584106445,
0.2384800910949707,
0.06098082289099693,
0.30671191215515137,
-0.7836390137672424,
-0.6116490364074707,
0.01186266727745533,
-0.9072459936141968,
-0.3427943289279938,
-0.3843494951725006,
0.04164483770728111,
-0.1720564216375351,
0.21274206042289734,
-0.7257229685783386,
0.5593278408050537,
0.44132402539253235,
-0.396194726228714,
0.37668076157569885,
0.038938410580158234,
0.05341983214020729,
-0.9179256558418274,
-0.286722332239151,
0.25431326031684875,
-0.6976543068885803,
-0.4156184196472168,
-0.28888630867004395,
-0.20839157700538635,
-0.4616009294986725,
-0.030110176652669907,
0.24347823858261108,
-0.20511609315872192,
0.0971730500459671,
-0.2759469151496887,
0.483614057302475,
-0.12800168991088867,
0.0998530462384224,
-0.2723916471004486,
0.3945799171924591,
0.7119284272193909,
-0.12089452147483826,
0.3326966464519501,
0.28942781686782837,
-0.3524164855480194,
0.8103313446044922,
-0.546631395816803,
-0.24546270072460175,
-0.3506602346897125,
0.3265953063964844,
-1.446921467781067,
-0.3327406644821167,
0.6979361772537231,
-0.6688957810401917,
0.0857197493314743,
0.0557013675570488,
-0.54988032579422,
-0.39849331974983215,
-0.22402876615524292,
0.281265527009964,
0.36183637380599976,
-0.6120237708091736,
0.38618505001068115,
0.21604207158088684,
-0.4608759582042694,
-0.020177656784653664,
-0.735377311706543,
0.33214035630226135,
-0.5054729580879211,
-0.8481061458587646,
0.5144169926643372,
-0.06596867740154266,
-0.3550432026386261,
0.21456347405910492,
-0.02269781194627285,
-0.30660948157310486,
0.2343216985464096,
0.19392050802707672,
0.11183642596006393,
-0.1619616001844406,
0.35768356919288635,
0.16335883736610413,
-0.13336312770843506,
0.33857831358909607,
0.27020058035850525,
0.5806750059127808,
0.16651733219623566,
-0.24194283783435822,
-0.8962945938110352,
0.7237049341201782,
0.37355712056159973,
0.3737221360206604,
0.6886672973632812,
0.899712860584259,
-0.5241815447807312,
-0.36731287837028503,
-0.1671946495771408,
-0.2752039134502411,
-0.4440819025039673,
-0.018055932596325874,
-0.2713288366794586,
-0.5974528193473816,
0.718221127986908,
-0.006551910191774368,
-0.34694722294807434,
0.12626637518405914,
0.6910720467567444,
-0.30609679222106934,
1.590428352355957,
0.6582759618759155,
-0.11993408203125,
0.6717211604118347,
-0.05925079435110092,
0.856381893157959,
-0.3610096275806427,
0.1729595810174942,
0.04244965314865112,
-0.10645328462123871,
-0.6756600141525269,
-0.2391880601644516,
0.2602415978908539,
-0.04660126939415932,
-0.13086241483688354,
0.055946461856365204,
-0.6313052773475647,
0.2515694797039032,
0.1813661754131317,
0.7390594482421875,
0.27517953515052795,
-0.1049741879105568,
0.47623929381370544,
-0.25348782539367676,
-0.48011019825935364,
-0.5582844018936157,
0.6639694571495056,
0.42542150616645813,
0.8371546268463135,
0.16990584135055542,
0.7668223977088928,
1.041265845298767,
0.43425703048706055,
-0.8159828782081604,
0.32058185338974,
-0.1466352343559265,
-0.8151184916496277,
-0.18784262239933014,
-0.2655538022518158,
-0.729830265045166,
-0.11364991217851639,
0.026293842121958733,
-1.0966880321502686,
0.15017372369766235,
0.1300811916589737,
-0.46559128165245056,
0.16854819655418396,
-0.9807253479957581,
0.8729562163352966,
-0.4082017242908478,
0.06647322326898575,
-0.4985294044017792,
-0.5261411666870117,
0.668539822101593,
-0.2963220775127411,
0.591008722782135,
-0.4267647862434387,
0.2269781529903412,
0.5489606857299805,
-0.3065767288208008,
1.2236101627349854,
-0.2710442841053009,
-0.3571690618991852,
0.09099122136831284,
-0.16505636274814606,
0.19966340065002441,
0.29936841130256653,
0.06725087016820908,
-0.05059395357966423,
0.3729498088359833,
-0.6863608360290527,
-0.8501684069633484,
0.6749138832092285,
-0.9102070927619934,
-0.5499034523963928,
-0.11416012048721313,
-0.6363550424575806,
-0.15660177171230316,
0.0639820471405983,
-0.025818416848778725,
0.27136632800102234,
-0.26317286491394043,
-0.32799434661865234,
0.6735588908195496,
-0.3422861099243164,
0.27549099922180176,
0.2214530110359192,
-0.39748141169548035,
-0.19014056026935577,
0.9768408536911011,
0.057530879974365234,
-0.08464556187391281,
0.17069648206233978,
0.13213011622428894,
-0.13198347389698029,
-0.24547132849693298,
0.17040875554084778,
0.4450836479663849,
-0.9055068492889404,
0.11803002655506134,
-0.6336458921432495,
-0.15119539201259613,
-0.5851510167121887,
-0.31467968225479126,
-0.25837498903274536,
-0.6145510673522949,
-0.41788622736930847,
-0.17364585399627686,
0.45433270931243896,
0.6537112593650818,
-0.5747981667518616,
0.7348647117614746,
-0.6391775012016296,
0.9190845489501953,
0.1794889122247696,
0.5501608848571777,
0.05847417935729027,
-0.18312200903892517,
-0.1319427192211151,
0.37186893820762634,
-0.2698851227760315,
-1.1713918447494507,
0.4121614992618561,
0.1865684539079666,
0.32692891359329224,
1.0807379484176636,
0.34433484077453613,
0.8007705211639404,
0.05668077617883682,
0.5429409146308899,
0.20534159243106842,
-0.9501616954803467,
0.8110711574554443,
-0.5587307810783386,
-0.13755840063095093,
0.16850997507572174,
0.8906972408294678,
-0.7920763492584229,
-0.331082284450531,
-0.631552517414093,
-0.7954232692718506,
0.6074196100234985,
0.19559626281261444,
0.2758478820323944,
-0.4177072048187256,
0.31739771366119385,
0.24887143075466156,
-0.2688237726688385,
-0.7840389609336853,
-0.06316245347261429,
-0.30662739276885986,
-0.3759084939956665,
-0.2040243297815323,
-0.40277135372161865,
-0.2439199686050415,
-0.19287467002868652,
0.7331454753875732,
0.13195809721946716,
0.8961893320083618,
0.40467920899391174,
-0.09833820164203644,
-0.08822796493768692,
-0.02833210863173008,
0.13527797162532806,
0.81208735704422,
-0.6084057092666626,
0.1938338279724121,
-0.4867312014102936,
-0.050471287220716476,
-0.07027790695428848,
0.49791935086250305,
0.07782416045665741,
0.3171982169151306,
0.37745219469070435,
0.5725335478782654,
0.04061727598309517,
-0.727161169052124,
0.5404285192489624,
-0.2634574770927429,
-0.1731068640947342,
-0.5738093256950378,
-0.06022655591368675,
0.25452515482902527,
0.7344034314155579,
0.3304019272327423,
-0.5219439268112183,
0.1956956535577774,
-0.7065175175666809,
0.15075983107089996,
0.5285282135009766,
-0.700803279876709,
-0.6330674290657043,
0.5674059987068176,
0.07868202030658722,
-0.7198361754417419,
0.30672577023506165,
-0.3155437707901001,
-0.4461314082145691,
0.42879369854927063,
0.420576810836792,
0.9302211403846741,
-0.1695864200592041,
0.913366973400116,
-0.18017305433750153,
0.25100722908973694,
0.07225915044546127,
0.6587314009666443,
-0.2416616529226303,
-0.8000075221061707,
-0.37864160537719727,
-0.1411314308643341,
-0.34340548515319824,
0.32080718874931335,
-0.6669378876686096,
0.28247949481010437,
-0.5764158368110657,
-0.3543248176574707,
0.6215558648109436,
-0.3057571351528168,
-0.3479384779930115,
0.20233353972434998,
0.5073214173316956,
0.7262008786201477,
-0.9992551803588867,
0.46346211433410645,
0.5634957551956177,
-0.21229086816310883,
-0.2942264974117279,
0.4234541058540344,
0.19949395954608917,
-1.0363060235977173,
0.23067840933799744,
0.3392959237098694,
0.16588431596755981,
0.15446694195270538,
-0.5996717214584351,
-0.5107772350311279,
0.7319372892379761,
0.256279319524765,
-0.11541913449764252,
0.023188959807157516,
0.1338769793510437,
0.7245667576789856,
-0.12728053331375122,
0.31871455907821655,
0.614181399345398,
0.5799951553344727,
-0.1282837837934494,
-0.6190023422241211,
0.04225160554051399,
-0.3419167697429657,
-0.20392417907714844,
0.15228095650672913,
-0.2852746546268463,
0.33123379945755005,
-0.057109128683805466,
-0.6641739010810852,
-0.27197912335395813,
0.21669058501720428,
-0.10450537502765656,
0.5027080774307251,
0.4009798765182495,
0.4865318834781647,
0.944728434085846,
0.21174654364585876,
1.0873682498931885,
-0.22056260704994202,
0.5647143721580505,
0.8378521203994751,
-0.04718755558133125,
0.4869244694709778,
0.3252551257610321,
-0.25502991676330566,
0.49017074704170227,
1.0935285091400146,
0.09836795181035995,
0.6545117497444153,
-0.025547074154019356,
-0.6876118779182434,
-0.47459766268730164,
-0.20274201035499573,
-0.17605391144752502,
0.028089649975299835,
0.6167394518852234,
-0.4706959128379822,
-0.7005083560943604,
0.34765833616256714,
0.12420974671840668,
-0.08533736318349838,
-0.35691776871681213,
0.5552675724029541,
0.24866965413093567,
-0.16791661083698273,
0.7028265595436096,
-0.10394401848316193,
0.43046247959136963,
-0.21237997710704803,
0.08816196024417877,
-0.13930639624595642,
0.5617589950561523,
-0.29996806383132935,
-0.8755160570144653,
0.6946712136268616,
0.11160397529602051,
-0.3846895396709442,
-0.38398778438568115,
0.9576749205589294,
-0.07382747530937195,
-0.791290283203125,
0.5583071112632751,
0.7609730958938599,
0.43111705780029297,
-0.5416424870491028,
-1.0183184146881104,
-0.19471532106399536,
-0.08856786042451859,
-0.10575763136148453,
0.2757515013217926,
0.9526097774505615,
-0.23498429358005524,
0.9758633971214294,
0.4019932150840759,
0.0003418158448766917,
-0.1781284362077713,
0.04516670107841492,
0.8509917259216309,
-0.5391040444374084,
-0.5561926960945129,
-0.9918166995048523,
0.46988844871520996,
-0.10513737052679062,
0.2183215171098709,
0.5072182416915894,
-0.030845146626234055,
0.18385794758796692,
0.030165081843733788,
1.097741723060608,
-0.5764318108558655,
0.889294445514679,
0.010591985657811165,
0.6549737453460693,
-0.46325504779815674,
0.11695092171430588,
-0.2996785342693329,
-0.6016601920127869,
-0.3722383379936218,
0.7317585349082947,
-0.5130100250244141,
-0.21668586134910583,
0.5821799635887146,
0.7672604918479919,
-0.1689540147781372,
0.12701712548732758,
0.2009088099002838,
0.5103561878204346,
0.5266382694244385,
0.3787264823913574,
1.0131226778030396,
0.05455387756228447,
0.6772943735122681,
-0.3350643813610077,
-0.5011827349662781,
-0.27102190256118774,
-0.7806851267814636,
-1.1263597011566162,
-0.4449689984321594,
-0.557307243347168,
-0.2133491486310959,
0.3170834481716156,
0.6813775897026062,
0.45133697986602783,
-0.6031132936477661,
0.2795242667198181,
-0.09650970995426178,
0.4910673499107361,
-0.40320348739624023,
-0.392356812953949,
0.463527113199234,
-0.26887163519859314,
-0.3833174705505371,
-0.03651454299688339,
0.12932123243808746,
-0.21686355769634247,
-0.28942736983299255,
0.2900512218475342,
-0.1726532131433487,
0.10229315608739853,
0.8467106223106384,
0.014249530620872974,
-0.6564570069313049,
-0.2686610221862793,
-0.24026429653167725,
0.16475442051887512,
0.2710898518562317,
0.6459230780601501,
-0.4618963897228241,
0.29671886563301086,
0.43892398476600647,
0.5629135966300964,
0.4730878174304962,
0.22541025280952454,
0.49445995688438416,
-0.21464791893959045,
-0.29834452271461487,
0.036195654422044754,
0.14005164802074432,
0.5239195823669434,
-0.7946993708610535,
0.4576700031757355,
0.21310636401176453,
-0.5052182674407959,
-0.7739086151123047,
-0.05832932889461517,
-1.124098300933838,
-0.46043747663497925,
0.8321610689163208,
-0.5573930144309998,
-0.1819860190153122,
-0.5282533764839172,
-0.45437154173851013,
0.4096268117427826,
-0.49693232774734497,
1.6014821529388428,
0.7022349238395691,
-0.3716218173503876,
-0.5664609670639038,
-0.7019253969192505,
0.30790385603904724,
0.0648004487156868,
-0.64940345287323,
0.23881933093070984,
0.20354460179805756,
0.06271453201770782,
-0.214314803481102,
0.8463630080223083,
0.04463151469826698,
0.2462429255247116,
-0.3141440153121948,
0.05489635467529297,
0.4012017250061035,
0.3584499657154083,
-0.2907775938510895,
-0.1325637847185135,
-0.32764095067977905,
-0.07975608855485916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00075v1 | D-Nikud: Enhancing Hebrew Diacritization with LSTM and Pretrained Models | 2024-01-30T22:07:12 | 2024-01-30T22:07:12 | Adi Rosenthal, Nadav Shaked | cs.CL | cs.CL | D-Nikud, a novel approach to Hebrew diacritization that integrates the
strengths of LSTM networks and BERT-based (transformer) pre-trained model.
Inspired by the methodologies employed in Nakdimon, we integrate it with the
TavBERT pre-trained model, our system incorporates advanced architectural
choices and diverse training data. Our experiments showcase state-of-the-art
results on several benchmark datasets, with a particular emphasis on modern
texts and more specified diacritization like gender. | [
-0.6251564025878906,
-0.9277864694595337,
0.11306952685117722,
-0.17525556683540344,
-0.5439960360527039,
0.4981268346309662,
-0.1521390825510025,
-0.18119099736213684,
0.17808999121189117,
0.41927701234817505,
-0.5128499865531921,
-0.9118161201477051,
-0.8103693723678589,
0.2613748610019684,
-0.6894741654396057,
1.1630713939666748,
-0.07813811302185059,
0.481033593416214,
0.386534184217453,
0.20639052987098694,
-0.35163360834121704,
-0.3323019742965698,
-0.3025099039077759,
-0.21886199712753296,
0.777085542678833,
0.397665411233902,
0.8414551019668579,
0.49504223465919495,
0.7910245060920715,
0.291888564825058,
-0.10829230397939682,
-0.08482637256383896,
-0.4852675199508667,
0.34053584933280945,
-0.007662557531148195,
-0.3525940775871277,
-0.9580639004707336,
0.006763944867998362,
0.6640152335166931,
0.8098497986793518,
0.06050970405340195,
0.2623627483844757,
-0.22547340393066406,
0.9210259318351746,
-0.6115912199020386,
-0.2549521327018738,
-0.2354518622159958,
0.4025857150554657,
-0.5079924464225769,
-0.07915840297937393,
-0.28287091851234436,
-0.9580107927322388,
0.3710300028324127,
-0.46647322177886963,
0.5309139490127563,
-0.01877657324075699,
0.5681509375572205,
0.3943546712398529,
-0.42969533801078796,
-0.0901939645409584,
-1.1752318143844604,
0.7688272595405579,
-0.6656508445739746,
0.60826176404953,
0.798932671546936,
0.20520450174808502,
0.06551377475261688,
-0.9312983155250549,
-0.5352146029472351,
-0.21436819434165955,
0.09402620792388916,
0.2560475766658783,
0.05740410462021828,
0.23483358323574066,
0.18597622215747833,
0.6094730496406555,
-0.5529959797859192,
0.5550186038017273,
-0.5591805577278137,
0.17154757678508759,
0.5193887948989868,
0.17943671345710754,
0.40679463744163513,
0.1775905042886734,
-0.5301635265350342,
-0.10437287390232086,
-0.5311000347137451,
-0.14328894019126892,
0.5373325943946838,
0.1658240258693695,
-0.2146444171667099,
0.5990376472473145,
0.02271054871380329,
1.03681218624115,
0.1697579026222229,
-0.0711798295378685,
0.1609295904636383,
-0.33557429909706116,
-0.4237302243709564,
0.192315012216568,
0.4910075068473816,
0.1690649539232254,
0.49840715527534485,
-0.16448795795440674,
-0.15281103551387787,
-0.014343135058879852,
0.8546225428581238,
-1.030470609664917,
-0.5352191925048828,
0.08661019057035446,
-0.5216304659843445,
-0.5990706086158752,
0.055422842502593994,
-1.026414155960083,
-0.2421775758266449,
-0.3489810526371002,
0.4503943920135498,
-0.5945234298706055,
-0.36905860900878906,
0.1854732483625412,
-0.12681125104427338,
0.2205662876367569,
0.6330628395080566,
-1.1013708114624023,
0.5910805463790894,
0.6185622811317444,
0.8139553070068359,
-0.3663352429866791,
-0.26433172821998596,
0.012548306956887245,
-0.04866746813058853,
-0.7167167663574219,
0.5089117288589478,
-0.42737212777137756,
-0.3640613853931427,
-0.09006056189537048,
-0.44317111372947693,
-0.03812731057405472,
-0.34954336285591125,
0.4968246519565582,
-1.061752438545227,
-0.02859334647655487,
-0.05611187219619751,
-0.7416845560073853,
-0.3821026682853699,
0.16688376665115356,
-0.8637224435806274,
1.1406769752502441,
0.5360500812530518,
-1.0946824550628662,
0.763285756111145,
-0.4581345319747925,
-0.3770609200000763,
0.5015530586242676,
-0.1542949229478836,
-0.6839940547943115,
0.2901018261909485,
0.1897134780883789,
0.5044727921485901,
-0.30038878321647644,
0.5642896890640259,
-0.00844581052660942,
-0.5223276615142822,
0.18534661829471588,
-0.4560603201389313,
0.6400395631790161,
0.14601416885852814,
-0.3141692280769348,
0.14720939099788666,
-0.783206045627594,
-0.052601296454668045,
0.23748807609081268,
-0.437153160572052,
-0.5392612814903259,
-0.12061680108308792,
0.003486107336357236,
-0.25758078694343567,
0.0952499657869339,
-0.7038384079933167,
0.29787176847457886,
-0.5996248126029968,
-0.035895053297281265,
0.7205007076263428,
-0.249874547123909,
0.6232354640960693,
-0.45257702469825745,
0.8049085140228271,
-0.03291147202253342,
0.34454041719436646,
0.25878003239631653,
-0.3544382154941559,
-0.7087522745132446,
-0.5566428899765015,
0.5821887850761414,
0.27104124426841736,
-0.7689157128334045,
0.6091317534446716,
-0.5489799976348877,
-0.6638234853744507,
-0.6490098237991333,
-0.0951104387640953,
0.40444010496139526,
0.4367796778678894,
0.433275043964386,
-0.6580409407615662,
-0.3047640323638916,
-0.8543756008148193,
0.2689601182937622,
0.18871547281742096,
0.5183778405189514,
-0.3070254623889923,
0.5374941229820251,
0.11880801618099213,
1.0670928955078125,
-0.35841163992881775,
-0.31335097551345825,
-0.7229543328285217,
0.052787333726882935,
0.3686215877532959,
0.46664029359817505,
0.8220688700675964,
-1.0843260288238525,
-1.053366780281067,
0.009983636438846588,
-0.3039715588092804,
-0.030207309871912003,
0.33840373158454895,
0.06746601313352585,
-0.32649803161621094,
0.4202113449573517,
-0.2655394673347473,
1.2009907960891724,
0.4276273548603058,
-0.13531626760959625,
0.9236142635345459,
-0.20109301805496216,
0.5060291886329651,
-1.0251038074493408,
0.0021775297354906797,
-0.4182952344417572,
-0.3700835108757019,
-1.3490289449691772,
-0.22911815345287323,
0.07698230445384979,
0.11400039494037628,
-0.6461227536201477,
0.5041300654411316,
-0.20143017172813416,
-0.1431688666343689,
-0.4603224992752075,
0.049204982817173004,
-0.08793415129184723,
0.19925498962402344,
-0.1331116110086441,
1.0694111585617065,
0.633131206035614,
-0.9105262756347656,
0.782745897769928,
0.9331498742103577,
-0.6452094316482544,
0.551129937171936,
-0.6916773915290833,
-0.016642117872834206,
-0.3975156247615814,
0.1301468461751938,
-0.9397165179252625,
-0.12386789172887802,
0.319291889667511,
-0.4090712070465088,
0.7082791328430176,
-0.514621913433075,
-0.4892343282699585,
-0.5940403342247009,
-0.5665634274482727,
1.1159831285476685,
0.4482080638408661,
-0.45536014437675476,
0.32232993841171265,
0.026839695870876312,
-0.2537873685359955,
-0.8419585227966309,
-0.7441196441650391,
0.13137148320674896,
-0.3966984748840332,
-0.12707525491714478,
0.7546398639678955,
-0.13677126169204712,
-0.2598456144332886,
-0.07937060296535492,
0.11849728226661682,
-0.4978339970111847,
0.2336813509464264,
0.012300168164074421,
0.2563611567020416,
-0.15757744014263153,
-0.01613471284508705,
0.025747248902916908,
-0.18461892008781433,
-0.4454505741596222,
0.08391788601875305,
1.1505722999572754,
0.39838355779647827,
-0.5316674113273621,
-0.9686163663864136,
0.30985549092292786,
0.5043073296546936,
-0.42856669425964355,
0.6372572779655457,
1.0624818801879883,
-0.2327083945274353,
-0.3222361207008362,
-0.4617551863193512,
-0.3176690638065338,
-0.48483678698539734,
0.6353373527526855,
-0.2804253399372101,
-0.6629434823989868,
0.3385264277458191,
-0.13522067666053772,
-0.032451316714286804,
0.13930565118789673,
0.8333101272583008,
-0.19304083287715912,
0.6515339612960815,
0.566088855266571,
-0.15722505748271942,
0.7788806557655334,
-0.1717248409986496,
0.12724646925926208,
-1.008117914199829,
-0.15007604658603668,
-0.45303407311439514,
-0.7073348760604858,
-0.5226156115531921,
-0.4247249364852905,
0.32430627942085266,
0.1255151778459549,
-0.4398432970046997,
0.38528695702552795,
-0.45831432938575745,
0.2972770929336548,
0.9193068146705627,
0.0734514594078064,
0.12186409533023834,
-0.07792529463768005,
-0.22207754850387573,
-0.3762684166431427,
-0.7379899024963379,
-0.3108329474925995,
1.3660272359848022,
0.22789429128170013,
0.8700027465820312,
0.2569493353366852,
0.9186242818832397,
0.8121196031570435,
0.42741724848747253,
-0.8174226880073547,
0.36074796319007874,
-0.21222443878650665,
-0.8769004940986633,
-0.22562357783317566,
-0.16746145486831665,
-1.3116258382797241,
0.01881571114063263,
-0.12290801852941513,
-0.7614099383354187,
0.10081988573074341,
-0.12546131014823914,
-0.623974621295929,
0.59392911195755,
-0.1739935278892517,
0.5272499322891235,
-0.2741401493549347,
0.0389106348156929,
-0.22400148212909698,
-0.7111238241195679,
0.32376664876937866,
-0.36521533131599426,
0.19005218148231506,
-0.3719293773174286,
0.23625217378139496,
0.9296180605888367,
-0.4511964023113251,
1.1093528270721436,
-0.21085911989212036,
-0.20095621049404144,
-0.07532338798046112,
0.3650079071521759,
0.07780668884515762,
-0.02111552096903324,
0.06972361356019974,
-0.039775945246219635,
-0.1560487598180771,
-0.1088084727525711,
-0.4260226786136627,
0.46614521741867065,
-0.9697390794754028,
-0.5452931523323059,
-0.5339882969856262,
-0.6153755187988281,
0.0036587833892554045,
0.32529929280281067,
0.1471823900938034,
0.8020256757736206,
-0.5833415389060974,
-0.07776284217834473,
0.7439568638801575,
-0.35896191000938416,
0.5230398774147034,
0.29400625824928284,
-0.5943124294281006,
-0.9720288515090942,
0.23815137147903442,
-0.04295597970485687,
0.38860559463500977,
0.3902732729911804,
0.16195251047611237,
-0.20677316188812256,
-1.0244865417480469,
-0.6274399161338806,
0.1782669723033905,
-0.7924748659133911,
-0.4669072926044464,
-0.4606100916862488,
-0.576023519039154,
-0.3112316429615021,
-0.2608567476272583,
-0.6154172420501709,
-0.3904530107975006,
-0.46397483348846436,
-0.2166668325662613,
0.689874529838562,
1.1542855501174927,
0.12141638994216919,
0.8015098571777344,
-0.9079647064208984,
0.5984020233154297,
0.019381215795874596,
0.32373666763305664,
0.08098993450403214,
-0.7410226464271545,
-0.41165173053741455,
-0.08604700863361359,
-0.23913061618804932,
-1.0105472803115845,
0.446128785610199,
0.2989010810852051,
0.49377068877220154,
0.5034885406494141,
0.22960777580738068,
0.5749053359031677,
-0.9384791851043701,
0.6880357265472412,
0.35495251417160034,
-0.8044257164001465,
0.6217174530029297,
-0.277249813079834,
-0.01221680548042059,
0.7024847269058228,
0.5612707138061523,
-0.4067768454551697,
-0.20592659711837769,
-0.21523134410381317,
-0.7198532223701477,
0.816804051399231,
0.19714374840259552,
0.3178176283836365,
-0.1420036107301712,
0.5399893522262573,
0.7059282064437866,
0.37050238251686096,
-0.6896085143089294,
-0.48505690693855286,
-0.016784487292170525,
-0.4622768461704254,
0.03804353252053261,
-0.5268131494522095,
-0.1919921189546585,
-0.7230263948440552,
0.4323442280292511,
0.4518442153930664,
0.1988859325647354,
0.3144572973251343,
-0.4767802655696869,
0.24505017697811127,
0.10687652975320816,
0.7114766836166382,
0.7595911026000977,
-0.27810388803482056,
0.24534723162651062,
0.08910731971263885,
-1.1261670589447021,
0.575448215007782,
-0.06113797053694725,
-0.49465930461883545,
-0.0668945387005806,
0.3418888449668884,
0.8156977891921997,
0.24917654693126678,
-0.019830826669931412,
0.6058383584022522,
-0.0702505111694336,
-0.40632206201553345,
-0.33800041675567627,
-0.06767063587903976,
-0.3525775969028473,
0.3545979857444763,
0.34530970454216003,
-0.05209408327937126,
-0.17855773866176605,
0.0693521499633789,
0.2993202209472656,
0.13386228680610657,
-0.3899398446083069,
-0.6947541832923889,
0.6713860630989075,
0.18925577402114868,
-0.5210621356964111,
0.7130053639411926,
-0.035803087055683136,
-0.8749604225158691,
0.3509693145751953,
0.6191189289093018,
0.859084963798523,
-0.7335137724876404,
0.47973692417144775,
0.3079899549484253,
0.2749210298061371,
0.09256501495838165,
0.4528242349624634,
-0.2984273135662079,
-0.9607415199279785,
-0.42331135272979736,
-0.9254807233810425,
-0.10685253888368607,
-0.14763258397579193,
-1.0545463562011719,
0.3166675865650177,
-0.7144389152526855,
-0.8087974190711975,
-0.1585221141576767,
-0.11359306424856186,
-1.0397238731384277,
0.3553502559661865,
0.09047886729240417,
0.70283043384552,
-0.6330116987228394,
1.0071643590927124,
0.5988782048225403,
-0.23544436693191528,
-0.012790929526090622,
-0.01583792455494404,
-0.2494218796491623,
-0.9460936784744263,
1.015275478363037,
0.026684554293751717,
-0.07383307069540024,
0.5863931775093079,
0.11945059150457382,
-1.0237823724746704,
1.2106305360794067,
-0.02812928706407547,
-0.6352465748786926,
0.08945862203836441,
0.36806684732437134,
0.35849910974502563,
0.04936067387461662,
0.12208890914916992,
0.7571448683738708,
0.6015366911888123,
-0.32420626282691956,
-1.1119384765625,
-0.24010708928108215,
0.020823152735829353,
0.16948865354061127,
0.5038719177246094,
-0.2909051179885864,
0.6665993928909302,
-0.20792746543884277,
-0.2659638524055481,
0.2267618179321289,
0.48349058628082275,
-0.231673002243042,
0.0940273329615593,
0.28723856806755066,
0.9193433523178101,
0.455867737531662,
-0.03091629408299923,
0.8329195380210876,
-0.18924029171466827,
0.2266172468662262,
0.9758689403533936,
-0.35520151257514954,
0.4837026596069336,
0.4107154309749603,
-0.5451876521110535,
0.39488470554351807,
0.7599049806594849,
-0.07581127434968948,
0.9066250920295715,
0.5077587962150574,
-0.5268341898918152,
0.07114574313163757,
-0.18090669810771942,
-0.383362352848053,
0.8026670217514038,
0.1649710237979889,
-0.2254866659641266,
-0.2916601598262787,
0.3338663876056671,
-0.04970071464776993,
0.208745539188385,
-0.388696551322937,
0.9300231337547302,
0.06568856537342072,
-0.08452196419239044,
0.5668966174125671,
0.13807068765163422,
0.6753010153770447,
-0.6105877161026001,
0.3015844523906708,
-0.03931096941232681,
0.1812821924686432,
0.10569982975721359,
-0.47260013222694397,
0.3486398160457611,
-0.0331956222653389,
-0.03986785560846329,
-0.26178622245788574,
0.7122036218643188,
-0.31684693694114685,
-0.6190919876098633,
0.36647143959999084,
0.8444045186042786,
-0.05864882469177246,
0.34096992015838623,
-0.5158888697624207,
0.07973587512969971,
-0.22169962525367737,
-0.24456247687339783,
0.2301960438489914,
0.18511083722114563,
0.09079013764858246,
0.43436864018440247,
0.5078141093254089,
0.4648595452308655,
0.16627264022827148,
0.7977100014686584,
0.9564246535301208,
-0.7436968684196472,
-0.34259355068206787,
-1.2140170335769653,
0.35035720467567444,
0.06955675780773163,
-0.2217598408460617,
0.7450111508369446,
0.4517626166343689,
0.7600656151771545,
-0.2253444790840149,
0.658585250377655,
0.06853358447551727,
0.4615052342414856,
-0.4321801960468292,
1.024986982345581,
-0.1698407083749771,
-0.2501347064971924,
-0.3371848165988922,
-1.1782748699188232,
-0.7876977920532227,
0.6129364967346191,
-0.2587081789970398,
0.2993062138557434,
0.6404921412467957,
0.3908197581768036,
-0.2716040015220642,
0.04709726572036743,
0.6007247567176819,
-0.015318593941628933,
0.20882871747016907,
0.08253178745508194,
1.2037811279296875,
-0.23913808166980743,
-0.13397514820098877,
-0.48371070623397827,
-0.37199780344963074,
-0.17539845407009125,
-0.7277617454528809,
-1.3277848958969116,
-0.6940051317214966,
-0.36469197273254395,
0.12907592952251434,
0.0044098058715462685,
1.0460578203201294,
0.6996898055076599,
-0.5550165176391602,
0.01506109070032835,
-0.05681653320789337,
-0.2678885757923126,
-0.057097177952528,
-0.12201891094446182,
0.5644105076789856,
-0.28231796622276306,
-0.8911358714103699,
0.6511774063110352,
0.24321681261062622,
0.5874791741371155,
-0.22332531213760376,
0.12194318324327469,
-0.12769344449043274,
-0.0981222614645958,
0.278149276971817,
-0.3815612196922302,
-0.5627473592758179,
-0.18051777780056,
-0.3832005560398102,
0.20948950946331024,
0.2634228765964508,
0.9087377190589905,
-0.4664320647716522,
0.5087772607803345,
0.2152402251958847,
0.6115991473197937,
0.8123065233230591,
0.26321345567703247,
0.6157052516937256,
-0.8405693173408508,
0.38053664565086365,
0.6482301354408264,
0.1555803120136261,
0.33476710319519043,
-0.08367998898029327,
0.06588225811719894,
0.10843028873205185,
-0.532899022102356,
-0.7521237134933472,
0.6349225640296936,
-0.7510654330253601,
-0.0509781651198864,
0.7881760001182556,
-0.2853439152240753,
-0.027278002351522446,
-0.469032883644104,
-0.011155832558870316,
0.45425236225128174,
0.043327294290065765,
0.86782306432724,
0.6002088785171509,
0.39604848623275757,
0.010679363273084164,
-0.8635313510894775,
0.8423373103141785,
0.29087671637535095,
-0.4530910551548004,
0.20221109688282013,
0.11897162348031998,
0.45643702149391174,
-0.2930092215538025,
0.772441565990448,
-0.22029848396778107,
0.2735047936439514,
-0.13655312359333038,
0.29214727878570557,
-0.18326117098331451,
-0.6531718373298645,
-0.18950395286083221,
-0.21731258928775787,
0.0678565725684166,
-0.3254459798336029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17464v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17464v2 | Efficient Tool Use with Chain-of-Abstraction Reasoning | 2024-01-30T21:53:30 | 2024-02-26T20:26:40 | Silin Gao, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Ping Yu, Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Ramakanth Pasunuru, Olga Golovneva, Koustuv Sinha, Asli Celikyilmaz, Antoine Bosselut, Tianlu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | To achieve faithful reasoning that aligns with human expectations, large
language models (LLMs) need to ground their reasoning to real-world knowledge
(e.g., web facts, math and physical rules). Tools help LLMs access this
external knowledge, but there remains challenges for fine-tuning LLM agents
(e.g., Toolformer) to invoke tools in multi-step reasoning problems, where
inter-connected tool calls require holistic and efficient tool usage planning.
In this work, we propose a new method for LLMs to better leverage tools in
multi-step reasoning. Our method, Chain-of-Abstraction (CoA), trains LLMs to
first decode reasoning chains with abstract placeholders, and then call domain
tools to reify each reasoning chain by filling in specific knowledge. This
planning with abstract chains enables LLMs to learn more general reasoning
strategies, which are robust to shifts of domain knowledge (e.g., math results)
relevant to different reasoning questions. It also allows LLMs to perform
decoding and calling of external tools in parallel, which avoids the inference
delay caused by waiting for tool responses. In mathematical reasoning and Wiki
QA domains, we show that our method consistently outperforms previous
chain-of-thought and tool-augmented baselines on both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution test sets, with an average ~6% absolute QA accuracy
improvement. LLM agents trained with our method also show more efficient tool
use, with inference speed being on average ~1.4x faster than baseline
tool-augmented LLMs. | [
-0.5674755573272705,
-0.669792652130127,
0.6696339845657349,
0.24064527451992035,
-0.28540539741516113,
0.374074250459671,
0.027897531166672707,
-0.5325837135314941,
-0.08919452130794525,
0.40056392550468445,
-0.48290714621543884,
-0.5585715770721436,
-0.3706321120262146,
0.060957420617341995,
-0.2708127200603485,
0.5275689363479614,
-0.23077692091464996,
-0.060984667390584946,
-0.3588714003562927,
-0.10166749358177185,
-0.2076123058795929,
-0.5149766206741333,
-0.6787382364273071,
-0.6319916248321533,
0.644577145576477,
0.2295452505350113,
0.8573926091194153,
0.5768976807594299,
0.47742486000061035,
0.3154403567314148,
0.04460686072707176,
0.6530492305755615,
-0.1671002209186554,
0.07906270027160645,
-0.33110561966896057,
-0.38646742701530457,
-0.7364789247512817,
-0.15316855907440186,
0.19304119050502777,
0.6924160718917847,
-0.22520601749420166,
0.22903035581111908,
-0.07637182623147964,
0.44235578179359436,
-0.949055552482605,
0.1259562224149704,
-0.6994920969009399,
-0.10218111425638199,
0.04024108871817589,
-0.3939947783946991,
-0.5819438695907593,
-0.1941203773021698,
-0.024619510397315025,
-0.8327254056930542,
-0.23589102923870087,
-0.03985733166337013,
0.5961952805519104,
0.18800833821296692,
-0.2865164577960968,
-0.28170955181121826,
-0.6714802980422974,
0.8313645720481873,
-0.6295484304428101,
0.6091475486755371,
0.4982782006263733,
0.19990861415863037,
-0.4092022478580475,
-0.790056586265564,
-0.5612313151359558,
-0.1031750813126564,
0.0304896030575037,
-0.0162174254655838,
-0.027934854850172997,
0.14104413986206055,
0.5151823163032532,
0.16969458758831024,
-0.21756762266159058,
0.12739643454551697,
-0.05660498887300491,
-0.2883443534374237,
0.6619824767112732,
0.12870900332927704,
0.058849185705184937,
0.43601852655410767,
-0.33645468950271606,
-0.261229932308197,
-0.7933740019798279,
-0.11189740896224976,
0.17131038010120392,
0.06277888268232346,
0.20080362260341644,
0.4401246905326843,
-0.10153312981128693,
0.864535391330719,
-0.054282914847135544,
-0.5930234789848328,
0.31949493288993835,
-0.4161643981933594,
-0.3056776523590088,
-0.13709022104740143,
0.4818432331085205,
0.07716580480337143,
0.34896206855773926,
-0.09208514541387558,
-0.3288109004497528,
0.010845623910427094,
0.2051151841878891,
-0.7775231599807739,
-0.12661786377429962,
0.34208035469055176,
0.010207151062786579,
-0.01649489253759384,
-0.12187417596578598,
-0.2416551411151886,
-0.22231106460094452,
-0.3962560296058655,
0.4377861022949219,
-0.38210001587867737,
-0.12392659485340118,
0.35929495096206665,
-0.2351519763469696,
0.1393263041973114,
0.5330590605735779,
-0.2996012270450592,
0.4990520477294922,
0.5714651942253113,
0.9847448468208313,
-0.04031748324632645,
-0.31038230657577515,
-0.9409701228141785,
0.35256969928741455,
-0.4660956859588623,
0.8983014225959778,
-0.4014807641506195,
-0.21388201415538788,
0.004716342315077782,
-0.13057062029838562,
0.18059556186199188,
-0.48994210362434387,
0.2024948000907898,
-0.7846665382385254,
-0.1353941261768341,
-0.25533783435821533,
-0.3093646764755249,
-0.2311035543680191,
0.36650580167770386,
-0.7522507905960083,
1.109883427619934,
-0.017202842980623245,
-0.5756823420524597,
0.35670924186706543,
-0.6862435936927795,
-0.5557714104652405,
-0.2228613793849945,
-0.040642205625772476,
-0.22203776240348816,
-0.19489319622516632,
0.4822702407836914,
0.47794386744499207,
-0.32186320424079895,
0.03806282952427864,
-0.39461231231689453,
-0.4623106122016907,
0.044373542070388794,
-0.23965223133563995,
0.7783263325691223,
0.13921621441841125,
-0.20622675120830536,
0.19262023270130157,
-0.6637831926345825,
0.16249839961528778,
-0.033982571214437485,
-0.35446834564208984,
-0.6051285862922668,
0.03716759383678436,
-0.4320329427719116,
0.5899026989936829,
0.09635487198829651,
-0.3472526967525482,
0.37865763902664185,
-0.5896826386451721,
0.17819540202617645,
0.8563112616539001,
0.0741799920797348,
0.4195167124271393,
-0.20757541060447693,
0.4727513790130615,
0.2538098692893982,
0.022915909066796303,
-0.15157540142536163,
-0.28620243072509766,
-0.8108161091804504,
-0.23942752182483673,
0.3780979514122009,
0.5048728585243225,
-1.0261437892913818,
0.7381992340087891,
-0.02065129391849041,
-0.41326096653938293,
-0.4172315001487732,
0.16626963019371033,
0.3905514180660248,
0.13884656131267548,
0.4147837460041046,
-0.38795775175094604,
-0.28011512756347656,
-0.5953246355056763,
-0.2213308960199356,
-0.08743932843208313,
-0.11405652016401291,
-0.062046363949775696,
0.6254799962043762,
-0.042215291410684586,
0.7275010943412781,
-0.464139848947525,
-0.05913063511252403,
-0.2741270661354065,
0.09899288415908813,
0.0048593622632324696,
0.13199588656425476,
-0.007789236959069967,
-0.5646824836730957,
-0.3863634467124939,
0.05066022276878357,
-0.6998459100723267,
-0.08923274278640747,
-0.3692418038845062,
-0.4962116777896881,
0.07837152481079102,
0.44556888937950134,
-0.4343912899494171,
0.3529019057750702,
0.3560307025909424,
-0.20393326878547668,
0.6308039426803589,
-0.15731289982795715,
-0.28812429308891296,
-0.8002099394798279,
0.0013182322727516294,
0.0101991081610322,
-0.45293280482292175,
-0.4563988149166107,
0.14750106632709503,
0.03096195124089718,
0.2800822854042053,
-0.5988339185714722,
0.6844375133514404,
-0.8383899927139282,
-0.16466648876667023,
-0.28110772371292114,
0.3168642520904541,
0.07921028137207031,
0.6657589673995972,
0.020221732556819916,
0.9872542023658752,
0.571488082408905,
-0.8761350512504578,
0.14617380499839783,
0.14403197169303894,
-0.2697561979293823,
0.38461485505104065,
-0.5009664297103882,
0.4130001962184906,
0.12608793377876282,
0.4665120840072632,
-0.5368265509605408,
0.23212628066539764,
0.15290458500385284,
0.08407166600227356,
-0.16499817371368408,
-0.004172234330326319,
-0.9496248364448547,
-0.30519017577171326,
-0.43029817938804626,
0.3351106345653534,
0.3149296045303345,
-0.6818780303001404,
0.913388729095459,
0.29059499502182007,
0.15371625125408173,
-0.8255337476730347,
-0.47133898735046387,
-0.14791902899742126,
-0.09581580758094788,
-0.5595380663871765,
0.3274683654308319,
-0.12340614944696426,
-0.40125545859336853,
-0.19850409030914307,
-0.5494655966758728,
-0.1252554953098297,
0.10152639448642731,
0.05863213539123535,
0.12334366142749786,
0.10781559348106384,
0.3160880506038666,
0.3178703784942627,
-0.17281904816627502,
0.24155555665493011,
-0.41576504707336426,
0.7522643208503723,
-0.05963478609919548,
-0.6867998242378235,
-0.32397332787513733,
0.15956644713878632,
0.6096760034561157,
-0.3474045395851135,
0.6211854219436646,
0.4212687909603119,
-0.25656694173812866,
-0.39859554171562195,
-0.587104082107544,
-0.3770639896392822,
-0.5007362365722656,
0.18792659044265747,
-0.6642473936080933,
-0.4545554518699646,
0.37252387404441833,
-0.6466823816299438,
0.504592776298523,
0.07406815141439438,
0.5041803121566772,
0.15043649077415466,
1.056435227394104,
0.359148770570755,
-0.020364580675959587,
0.3081184923648834,
-0.6870707273483276,
0.21676713228225708,
-0.9372496008872986,
-0.05997273325920105,
-0.24772565066814423,
-0.24801070988178253,
-0.01909460313618183,
-0.7385526299476624,
0.41554927825927734,
0.3389871120452881,
-0.24000857770442963,
0.2042257934808731,
-0.20604805648326874,
0.5956136584281921,
0.47467899322509766,
0.10911896079778671,
0.7618569731712341,
0.14877797663211823,
-0.46594709157943726,
0.42216211557388306,
-0.7914106249809265,
-0.5065128803253174,
1.008336067199707,
0.26498016715049744,
0.7594782710075378,
-0.10458258539438248,
0.680174708366394,
0.07168828696012497,
0.15206214785575867,
-0.8896781206130981,
0.726699948310852,
0.1652560532093048,
-0.25239259004592896,
-0.277893602848053,
-0.15485261380672455,
-0.7765297889709473,
0.5671690702438354,
0.06414681673049927,
-0.4861386716365814,
0.2355819046497345,
0.2031264305114746,
-0.17816637456417084,
0.5082415342330933,
-0.38088279962539673,
0.40648695826530457,
-0.1988144814968109,
-0.35386180877685547,
-0.3849385976791382,
-0.581897497177124,
0.2669641673564911,
-0.11558157950639725,
0.29392582178115845,
-0.0881589725613594,
-0.1828005611896515,
0.4964672327041626,
-0.6582823395729065,
0.7726030945777893,
-0.055812399834394455,
-0.4900561273097992,
0.4539966583251953,
0.23882248997688293,
0.9717095494270325,
-0.05529966950416565,
-0.19766759872436523,
0.22339408099651337,
-0.1260068714618683,
-0.4020664691925049,
-0.8708850145339966,
0.4038662314414978,
-0.5910939574241638,
-0.5434866547584534,
-0.487922728061676,
-0.7968840599060059,
-0.3740718364715576,
0.16147322952747345,
-0.1773330271244049,
0.5145635008811951,
0.15205729007720947,
-0.20570909976959229,
0.5121794939041138,
0.13527101278305054,
0.4367590546607971,
0.38101717829704285,
-0.14839570224285126,
-0.1623992621898651,
0.7242358326911926,
0.004373345524072647,
0.7275959253311157,
0.3520769774913788,
0.1183733269572258,
-0.38625913858413696,
-0.45841944217681885,
-0.33912771940231323,
0.2604151964187622,
-0.9274848103523254,
-0.29167255759239197,
-0.6706032752990723,
-0.24149678647518158,
0.1502285897731781,
-0.1315712034702301,
-0.17096860706806183,
-0.4638358950614929,
0.1648688018321991,
-0.06550871580839157,
0.4132935702800751,
0.3379049003124237,
-0.04714974761009216,
0.2717333436012268,
-0.5507372617721558,
0.3853437304496765,
0.24299630522727966,
0.16520071029663086,
0.24479888379573822,
-0.13441291451454163,
-0.3237248361110687,
0.01806851662695408,
-0.5004594922065735,
-0.6014876961708069,
0.0730074867606163,
0.05498368293046951,
0.5023695230484009,
0.27903982996940613,
0.1630517691373825,
1.0672892332077026,
-0.4408089220523834,
0.4012976288795471,
0.08195269107818604,
-0.9165416955947876,
0.43639418482780457,
0.0230014119297266,
0.45340943336486816,
0.339458703994751,
0.5657000541687012,
-0.2518830895423889,
-0.6914454102516174,
-0.5033116340637207,
-0.8932574987411499,
0.5100654363632202,
0.26428672671318054,
-0.2582933306694031,
0.009155994281172752,
0.07901693880558014,
0.17305177450180054,
0.22161227464675903,
-0.47646018862724304,
-0.1863430142402649,
0.15339592099189758,
0.07454226911067963,
0.2954462468624115,
0.10667848587036133,
-0.24784253537654877,
-0.36943984031677246,
0.7265172004699707,
-0.42447975277900696,
0.12088378518819809,
0.1386488676071167,
-0.33771228790283203,
0.004203103948384523,
0.3145718276500702,
0.2025631070137024,
1.1935224533081055,
0.11650210618972778,
0.43016406893730164,
0.4655706286430359,
-0.4626990854740143,
0.29857900738716125,
-0.14274588227272034,
0.020985672250390053,
-0.12764133512973785,
0.4070846438407898,
0.4766007363796234,
0.0999886766076088,
-0.82561194896698,
0.17471331357955933,
0.2357635498046875,
-0.2204560786485672,
-0.2577713131904602,
0.12051868438720703,
0.2781859040260315,
0.2429817020893097,
0.04128746688365936,
0.19349539279937744,
0.17772895097732544,
-0.5016162395477295,
0.180075004696846,
0.3591555058956146,
-0.0397053137421608,
-0.13721401989459991,
0.16728758811950684,
0.25109705328941345,
-0.25628021359443665,
0.6248947978019714,
-0.36211761832237244,
-0.2892214059829712,
0.3132469356060028,
0.6988337635993958,
0.7064875364303589,
-0.015074962750077248,
0.16080081462860107,
0.11130606383085251,
0.15812601149082184,
-0.300352543592453,
0.44723591208457947,
-0.09059876203536987,
-0.8691378831863403,
-0.823832631111145,
-0.5203030705451965,
-0.23162442445755005,
0.04463080316781998,
-0.36947327852249146,
0.2553582787513733,
-0.5021374821662903,
-0.08848871290683746,
-0.18834391236305237,
-0.03424219414591789,
-0.7162593603134155,
-0.08917535841464996,
-0.2752435505390167,
1.2027884721755981,
-0.5000993013381958,
0.9443586468696594,
0.6565099358558655,
-0.38376694917678833,
-0.8686668872833252,
0.12128232419490814,
0.06912466883659363,
-0.7844292521476746,
0.5883450508117676,
0.055429548025131226,
-0.7205035090446472,
0.14025446772575378,
-0.3158717155456543,
-0.7725183367729187,
1.1915010213851929,
0.3291533291339874,
-0.7147648930549622,
-0.03949689865112305,
-0.12382389605045319,
0.3837543725967407,
-0.3723350167274475,
0.3775349259376526,
0.5900223851203918,
0.4941668212413788,
0.3691786825656891,
-0.9128180742263794,
0.2446858137845993,
-0.12295980751514435,
-0.04065357893705368,
0.49452677369117737,
-0.378375768661499,
0.6700024604797363,
-0.2918103039264679,
-0.23028625547885895,
-0.18721163272857666,
0.5452042818069458,
0.8339985609054565,
0.21869373321533203,
0.9152567982673645,
0.5845057368278503,
0.8277363777160645,
0.19491545855998993,
1.0127307176589966,
-0.17562997341156006,
0.01512044109404087,
1.0873945951461792,
-0.3697669506072998,
0.9424006342887878,
0.4938385486602783,
-0.22323821485042572,
0.9444328546524048,
0.4538990557193756,
0.24844416975975037,
0.36423614621162415,
0.36243319511413574,
-0.4288555681705475,
-0.5815846920013428,
-0.04001890867948532,
-0.13640664517879486,
0.21826709806919098,
0.33863067626953125,
0.033547960221767426,
-0.29606395959854126,
-0.0838032066822052,
0.1093970239162445,
-0.04199305176734924,
-0.2595362961292267,
0.7759940028190613,
0.22680196166038513,
-0.5585317015647888,
0.698104202747345,
-0.04108842462301254,
0.4785945415496826,
-0.6713911294937134,
-0.33111491799354553,
0.07407601922750473,
0.28846976161003113,
-0.20147427916526794,
-0.7010741233825684,
0.1581185907125473,
-0.1765160858631134,
0.030899664387106895,
-0.15540099143981934,
0.7325198650360107,
-0.289061963558197,
-0.5298348665237427,
0.4622679352760315,
0.7832239270210266,
0.20509138703346252,
-0.3370419442653656,
-0.6993969082832336,
-0.09469021111726761,
-0.37810957431793213,
-0.09586154669523239,
0.28838929533958435,
0.5172961950302124,
-0.5225369334220886,
0.9445528388023376,
0.8993957042694092,
0.15299808979034424,
-0.0655115619301796,
0.4336254596710205,
1.1105554103851318,
-0.6215643286705017,
-0.5205577611923218,
-0.931084930896759,
0.6481093168258667,
-0.2784707546234131,
-0.005054769106209278,
0.6126895546913147,
0.5594915747642517,
0.994115948677063,
0.09521356225013733,
0.7489426732063293,
0.053588107228279114,
0.17882147431373596,
-0.6506364941596985,
0.24422802031040192,
-0.5422040224075317,
0.4920744299888611,
-0.20046810805797577,
-0.9052228331565857,
-0.21511809527873993,
0.7245291471481323,
-0.15950044989585876,
0.04351305589079857,
1.0825601816177368,
0.6617169976234436,
-0.26344484090805054,
-0.2688317596912384,
0.09991515427827835,
-0.004098602570593357,
0.484573632478714,
0.501623272895813,
0.7674378156661987,
-0.2725948989391327,
0.5213536620140076,
-0.33939510583877563,
-0.14188092947006226,
0.11972494423389435,
-0.83991539478302,
-1.077075719833374,
-0.3518526554107666,
-0.28175053000450134,
-0.25631624460220337,
0.1227809265255928,
1.0611145496368408,
0.7129847407341003,
-0.4564456045627594,
-0.5948225855827332,
-0.21661017835140228,
0.3890249729156494,
-0.8069350719451904,
-0.1679295152425766,
0.2721460461616516,
-0.48869141936302185,
-0.47711917757987976,
0.35260969400405884,
0.3878309726715088,
-0.28057724237442017,
-0.560918927192688,
-0.2324226200580597,
-0.4699392318725586,
0.08688563108444214,
0.9894490242004395,
-0.06951146572828293,
-0.9800338745117188,
-0.1878967583179474,
0.0059984526596963406,
0.26054102182388306,
0.11129201203584671,
1.0254870653152466,
-0.9956381916999817,
0.369399756193161,
0.44101378321647644,
0.4050893187522888,
0.5471991300582886,
0.09614929556846619,
0.8058429956436157,
-0.8384267091751099,
0.19581231474876404,
0.18091608583927155,
0.23442064225673676,
-0.001607253449037671,
-0.24891480803489685,
0.7049911618232727,
-0.018122661858797073,
-0.29054495692253113,
-0.7678900361061096,
0.39754635095596313,
-0.8668532371520996,
-0.3666544258594513,
1.0585013628005981,
-0.16673633456230164,
-0.05875980854034424,
-0.5086191892623901,
-0.3060113787651062,
0.13194341957569122,
-0.5662999749183655,
0.6280655860900879,
0.6308596730232239,
-0.3824174404144287,
-0.13974492251873016,
-0.3184047043323517,
0.38768306374549866,
0.02184823527932167,
-1.16103994846344,
0.10726306587457657,
0.31463807821273804,
0.18543994426727295,
0.36134713888168335,
0.7957944273948669,
-0.11717388778924942,
0.22751551866531372,
-0.12056125700473785,
-0.023107733577489853,
-0.3343653678894043,
-0.6474143266677856,
0.017768053337931633,
0.04390912503004074,
0.151511549949646,
-0.07224513590335846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17461v1 | Synthetic Dialogue Dataset Generation using LLM Agents | 2024-01-30T21:49:30 | 2024-01-30T21:49:30 | Yelaman Abdullin, Diego Molla-Aliod, Bahadorreza Ofoghi, John Yearwood, Qingyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Linear programming (LP) problems are pervasive in real-life applications.
However, despite their apparent simplicity, an untrained user may find it
difficult to determine the linear model of their specific problem. We envisage
the creation of a goal-oriented conversational agent that will engage in
conversation with the user to elicit all information required so that a
subsequent agent can generate the linear model. In this paper, we present an
approach for the generation of sample dialogues that can be used to develop and
train such a conversational agent. Using prompt engineering, we develop two
agents that "talk" to each other, one acting as the conversational agent, and
the other acting as the user. Using a set of text descriptions of linear
problems from NL4Opt available to the user only, the agent and the user engage
in conversation until the agent has retrieved all key information from the
original problem description. We also propose an extrinsic evaluation of the
dialogues by assessing how well the summaries generated by the dialogues match
the original problem descriptions. We conduct human and automatic evaluations,
including an evaluation approach that uses GPT-4 to mimic the human evaluation
metrics. The evaluation results show an overall good quality of the dialogues,
though research is still needed to improve the quality of the GPT-4 evaluation
metrics. The resulting dialogues, including the human annotations of a subset,
are available to the research community. The conversational agent used for the
generation of the dialogues can be used as a baseline. | [
-0.2891329526901245,
-0.546759843826294,
0.7730043530464172,
0.06196332350373268,
0.06362256407737732,
0.30697351694107056,
-0.12561216950416565,
-0.2587219774723053,
0.3111686408519745,
0.5281032919883728,
-1.0898919105529785,
-0.37932413816452026,
0.14315107464790344,
0.41378024220466614,
-0.026199625805020332,
1.121116042137146,
0.09438013285398483,
0.058376360684633255,
-0.22123730182647705,
0.09332147240638733,
-0.7450299859046936,
-0.44289690256118774,
-0.8144970536231995,
-0.4466531276702881,
0.2783523499965668,
0.25066617131233215,
0.7495542764663696,
0.35586240887641907,
0.03153029829263687,
0.4090867042541504,
0.24132905900478363,
0.4656483232975006,
-0.6936642527580261,
0.46361806988716125,
-0.03958030045032501,
-0.23163245618343353,
-0.29333606362342834,
0.1365734338760376,
0.32308271527290344,
0.5303685665130615,
0.048281800001859665,
0.1711328774690628,
0.1442795842885971,
0.18133053183555603,
0.026095496490597725,
0.40875378251075745,
-0.6773523092269897,
0.28615352511405945,
0.41954511404037476,
-0.5819050073623657,
-0.2616966962814331,
-0.5364571213722229,
0.17404523491859436,
-0.9178284406661987,
0.10512293130159378,
-0.0075170197524130344,
0.6768966913223267,
0.3613486588001251,
-0.1912686675786972,
-0.8700913190841675,
-0.8791415691375732,
0.832087516784668,
-0.9255899786949158,
-0.06058012694120407,
0.16115199029445648,
0.42898136377334595,
-0.5259901285171509,
-0.6188129782676697,
-0.5950629711151123,
-0.5720400214195251,
0.026462329551577568,
0.31645217537879944,
0.1528344452381134,
0.27459070086479187,
0.4146495461463928,
-0.04240480437874794,
-0.692950427532196,
-0.1381559818983078,
-0.43955713510513306,
-0.41292792558670044,
0.8129622340202332,
0.529415488243103,
0.20580647885799408,
-0.3251320421695709,
-0.3470670282840729,
0.1569969803094864,
-0.4844924211502075,
-0.10114739835262299,
0.6680049896240234,
0.542195737361908,
0.09880375862121582,
0.5844749808311462,
-0.14028263092041016,
0.6588236689567566,
-0.1450439691543579,
-0.3509412109851837,
0.2930002212524414,
-0.7496095299720764,
0.03707337751984596,
-0.14572927355766296,
0.8125032186508179,
0.611791729927063,
0.3379681408405304,
0.046198099851608276,
-0.5093667507171631,
-0.056000374257564545,
0.21134646236896515,
-0.7251833081245422,
-0.2000172883272171,
0.29802846908569336,
-0.2721986174583435,
-0.4401399493217468,
-0.22161681950092316,
-0.6522940993309021,
-0.38251030445098877,
-0.7998853921890259,
0.25540342926979065,
-0.3166833817958832,
-0.022409042343497276,
-0.2715699374675751,
0.05638843774795532,
0.3028818666934967,
0.33160150051116943,
-0.5896820425987244,
0.3437769412994385,
0.5207374691963196,
0.6459518671035767,
-0.02664223127067089,
-0.02845050022006035,
-0.5176692008972168,
-0.08406857401132584,
-0.2092941403388977,
0.6001209020614624,
-0.4638770818710327,
-0.6862815022468567,
0.14193034172058105,
-0.39455172419548035,
-0.017973264679312706,
-0.49786078929901123,
0.5119754672050476,
-0.11130036413669586,
0.38352257013320923,
-0.24393314123153687,
-0.5713431239128113,
0.30635830760002136,
0.5976340770721436,
-0.3500966727733612,
0.9946644902229309,
0.16815146803855896,
-0.4494059085845947,
-0.144972026348114,
-0.7697420120239258,
0.14444641768932343,
0.3010023832321167,
-0.6015469431877136,
-0.1741468906402588,
-0.32659250497817993,
0.16261398792266846,
0.2138042002916336,
-0.35614678263664246,
0.22707605361938477,
0.051190294325351715,
-0.23942820727825165,
0.5815586447715759,
-0.25767603516578674,
0.4230780601501465,
0.40677061676979065,
-0.02829970046877861,
0.16249851882457733,
-0.8145709037780762,
0.4096396863460541,
0.054494455456733704,
-0.25362735986709595,
0.16037698090076447,
0.00364889157935977,
-0.20062176883220673,
0.2269803136587143,
0.23012259602546692,
-0.5484097003936768,
0.31724095344543457,
-0.5295566916465759,
0.3763132095336914,
0.8966770768165588,
0.4478442370891571,
0.24889445304870605,
-0.5364426970481873,
0.8718354105949402,
-0.4147999584674835,
0.1811802238225937,
-0.382072776556015,
-0.6500636339187622,
-0.8678433895111084,
0.10297392308712006,
-0.06612967699766159,
0.8141727447509766,
-1.1563727855682373,
0.23832012712955475,
0.021192818880081177,
-0.18742255866527557,
-0.32182610034942627,
0.2848895788192749,
0.5110047459602356,
0.6861380338668823,
0.024223383516073227,
-0.021754778921604156,
-0.7429868578910828,
-0.8711068034172058,
0.17642444372177124,
-0.4401123523712158,
-0.30484136939048767,
0.7406759858131409,
0.22412684559822083,
-0.1891588717699051,
1.4281153678894043,
-0.6407108306884766,
-0.1283453404903412,
-0.5937983393669128,
0.27190321683883667,
0.3918773829936981,
0.38203197717666626,
0.3803110420703888,
-0.4327014684677124,
-0.4168854355812073,
-0.2544242739677429,
-0.8686777949333191,
-0.48075738549232483,
-0.5014464855194092,
-0.15548285841941833,
-0.07605722546577454,
0.4515358507633209,
-0.6356481909751892,
0.20778416097164154,
0.3176629841327667,
0.005910204257816076,
0.8199890851974487,
-0.20236167311668396,
-0.14081218838691711,
-1.3699722290039062,
-0.025570323690772057,
-0.08506107330322266,
-0.3757404088973999,
-0.7826898694038391,
-0.3676650822162628,
-0.725491464138031,
-0.7455840110778809,
-0.34872493147850037,
0.5428534150123596,
-0.3477822542190552,
-0.23411698639392853,
-0.12780289351940155,
0.3938431739807129,
-0.10988373309373856,
0.7970679998397827,
-0.09695583581924438,
0.7851001024246216,
0.08356451243162155,
-0.4053252935409546,
0.7589482665061951,
0.4663666784763336,
-0.059985578060150146,
0.40417689085006714,
-0.8416926860809326,
0.6884853839874268,
-0.08059319108724594,
0.34884485602378845,
-0.8871415257453918,
-0.05542682483792305,
0.5997477173805237,
-0.553282618522644,
-0.07009577751159668,
-0.20843781530857086,
-0.3274071216583252,
-0.33076635003089905,
-0.2610485851764679,
0.09579384326934814,
0.4676845371723175,
-0.12725485861301422,
0.4003692865371704,
0.16067670285701752,
-0.5700192451477051,
-0.4168300926685333,
-0.013569319620728493,
0.17606990039348602,
-0.0092861857265234,
-0.7584483027458191,
-0.021933330222964287,
-0.39708390831947327,
-0.2928791046142578,
-0.10084022581577301,
0.04814556613564491,
0.008573083207011223,
-0.19362297654151917,
0.2323884516954422,
0.29751986265182495,
-0.05578760802745819,
0.17613959312438965,
-0.2639610469341278,
-0.2806582748889923,
0.17904052138328552,
-0.3621405363082886,
0.622622013092041,
-0.18788199126720428,
-0.330789715051651,
-0.5024185180664062,
0.48992088437080383,
0.006493434775620699,
0.0770033672451973,
0.16342249512672424,
0.36646145582199097,
-0.0796845555305481,
-0.511119544506073,
-0.2813316285610199,
-0.36859798431396484,
-0.5345394611358643,
0.2477746456861496,
-0.48998311161994934,
-0.4629603922367096,
0.4416147470474243,
-0.2114037424325943,
0.2484009861946106,
-0.15894003212451935,
0.6331968307495117,
-0.20383736491203308,
0.8132656216621399,
0.3337095379829407,
0.16512009501457214,
0.31352871656417847,
-0.4923538863658905,
0.20197851955890656,
-0.492502361536026,
-0.24350190162658691,
-0.3677782714366913,
-0.29476094245910645,
-0.339961975812912,
-0.5307319164276123,
0.5084035396575928,
-0.30996638536453247,
-0.03670886904001236,
0.2901301980018616,
-0.46787187457084656,
0.5836370587348938,
0.4970340430736542,
0.025319967418909073,
0.1700800210237503,
-0.1448841691017151,
-0.23048561811447144,
-0.11093271523714066,
-0.5049490928649902,
-0.7431886196136475,
1.0520297288894653,
0.2673775255680084,
0.6921731233596802,
-0.031311996281147,
0.8898732662200928,
0.5240474343299866,
0.048637740314006805,
-0.7767004370689392,
0.8794277310371399,
0.5215031504631042,
-0.3031250834465027,
-0.34525853395462036,
-0.6779894232749939,
-0.9779362678527832,
-0.0440947599709034,
-0.2174597531557083,
-0.7933266758918762,
-0.14690710604190826,
0.3247380256652832,
-0.4188674986362457,
-0.27899760007858276,
-0.70137619972229,
0.8445490598678589,
-0.34557828307151794,
-0.15649692714214325,
0.09395970404148102,
-0.6883807182312012,
0.29988107085227966,
-0.022821824997663498,
0.06545086205005646,
-0.25873658061027527,
0.2830201983451843,
0.4893846809864044,
-0.8019640445709229,
0.9735420942306519,
-0.4548211991786957,
-0.13005198538303375,
0.6033781170845032,
0.06923885643482208,
0.567876398563385,
0.3035297393798828,
-0.13156870007514954,
-0.37499114871025085,
-0.058202654123306274,
-0.16702236235141754,
-0.8813879489898682,
0.4244590997695923,
-0.9123476147651672,
-0.5863199830055237,
-0.25774481892585754,
-0.8096315264701843,
-0.3299463093280792,
-0.07281135022640228,
0.025590328499674797,
0.6215574741363525,
-0.30748650431632996,
-0.40441980957984924,
0.3205168843269348,
-0.568112850189209,
0.33184584975242615,
0.43859535455703735,
-0.22519196569919586,
-0.34646278619766235,
1.126465082168579,
-0.2552512288093567,
0.5048213005065918,
0.16127200424671173,
0.11895757913589478,
-0.3394295871257782,
-0.42717456817626953,
-0.4036078155040741,
0.1888878345489502,
-0.6733285188674927,
-0.2478131651878357,
-0.2696412205696106,
-0.5120285153388977,
-0.2752736508846283,
-0.0626809224486351,
-0.22842606902122498,
-0.4501020610332489,
-0.22043560445308685,
0.025436265394091606,
0.10072457045316696,
0.8755584359169006,
0.015704445540905,
0.2758505046367645,
-0.7273999452590942,
0.2941665053367615,
0.3827594220638275,
-0.23555268347263336,
-0.4708724021911621,
-0.3407537341117859,
-0.06543233245611191,
0.3051284849643707,
-0.5930902361869812,
-0.9413332343101501,
0.7079570293426514,
0.278860867023468,
0.7006911039352417,
0.2134658545255661,
0.26221635937690735,
0.3950243592262268,
-0.4906689524650574,
0.7574576139450073,
0.1285017728805542,
-0.7474634051322937,
0.7748717665672302,
-0.4053710699081421,
-0.0035940806847065687,
0.532152533531189,
0.11123543232679367,
-0.5570228695869446,
-0.41195788979530334,
-0.35142603516578674,
-0.6268014907836914,
0.7959484457969666,
0.7265024781227112,
0.23278723657131195,
0.09658954292535782,
0.4229919910430908,
0.08317284286022186,
0.21187807619571686,
-0.7261467576026917,
-0.07044531404972076,
-0.38108405470848083,
-0.40990450978279114,
0.048630502074956894,
-0.1511753350496292,
-0.21317405998706818,
0.23762871325016022,
0.5864936113357544,
-0.3903747797012329,
0.44345706701278687,
0.18568864464759827,
-0.00041131681064143777,
0.24942535161972046,
0.30731046199798584,
0.6739851832389832,
0.5777899622917175,
-0.4041830897331238,
-0.20224888622760773,
0.01634964905679226,
-0.25682333111763,
0.3349073529243469,
0.1684173345565796,
-0.3114732503890991,
0.17938083410263062,
0.13439784944057465,
0.8721444606781006,
-0.04162636771798134,
-0.9185507893562317,
0.30638453364372253,
-0.18390803039073944,
-0.15973562002182007,
-0.7306870818138123,
0.06442907452583313,
0.030305294319987297,
0.2784629762172699,
0.24914124608039856,
-0.10971590131521225,
0.22943150997161865,
-0.550635576248169,
0.18374550342559814,
0.46167901158332825,
-0.07631397247314453,
-0.33595746755599976,
0.40874627232551575,
0.7235126495361328,
-0.847305417060852,
0.8489282727241516,
-0.5937581062316895,
-0.5469716787338257,
0.6863336563110352,
0.6004733443260193,
0.7218726873397827,
-0.14098946750164032,
0.5462682247161865,
0.4082166254520416,
0.1386750489473343,
0.3473053276538849,
0.3726763427257538,
-0.051450908184051514,
-1.0511921644210815,
-0.5074747204780579,
-0.5401214957237244,
-0.834665060043335,
0.3396041691303253,
-0.3279133141040802,
0.21308815479278564,
-0.4208120107650757,
-0.18847587704658508,
-0.11256486922502518,
0.2373710423707962,
-0.5935912132263184,
-0.14644619822502136,
0.33032217621803284,
0.43791764974594116,
-0.7827709317207336,
0.6402208209037781,
0.4333186745643616,
-0.49907925724983215,
-0.9666251540184021,
-0.15234312415122986,
0.17327044904232025,
-0.8557000756263733,
0.8101711273193359,
0.19315886497497559,
0.0995204970240593,
-0.03207181394100189,
-0.5170961618423462,
-0.6915810704231262,
1.0954598188400269,
0.45812511444091797,
-0.42013734579086304,
-0.20220708847045898,
0.6001521944999695,
0.5271120667457581,
-0.64907306432724,
0.4539163112640381,
0.3942168653011322,
0.2183835506439209,
0.41548213362693787,
-1.0030412673950195,
-0.006243429612368345,
-0.5617201924324036,
0.1608898937702179,
-0.21200262010097504,
-0.31759098172187805,
0.7114002108573914,
-0.1978403776884079,
-0.14659497141838074,
0.4044155776500702,
0.5107399821281433,
0.5312724113464355,
0.33300185203552246,
0.6035884618759155,
0.039732784032821655,
0.8042401671409607,
0.05174868553876877,
0.9132837653160095,
-0.4334876537322998,
0.1966003030538559,
1.418851375579834,
-0.5638094544410706,
0.2527690529823303,
0.23385876417160034,
-0.12530086934566498,
0.19610515236854553,
0.5151622891426086,
-0.024912279099225998,
0.22556093335151672,
0.7128534913063049,
-0.44796475768089294,
-0.12127098441123962,
-0.2638133466243744,
-0.13371630012989044,
0.3464113175868988,
0.46467500925064087,
-0.23212972283363342,
-0.3349255919456482,
-0.058913834393024445,
-0.13317301869392395,
0.08542022854089737,
-0.012502994388341904,
0.8098326325416565,
0.10724332928657532,
-0.743120551109314,
0.5815130472183228,
-0.17292071878910065,
0.16606682538986206,
-0.6264111399650574,
-0.38735678791999817,
-0.4695347249507904,
0.06506574898958206,
-0.08674792945384979,
-0.6031596660614014,
0.10867480933666229,
0.07286574691534042,
0.07567878812551498,
-0.5387073159217834,
0.6226083636283875,
-0.5149850249290466,
-0.4710114896297455,
-0.09890381991863251,
0.6369284987449646,
0.6711727976799011,
0.33867013454437256,
-0.8565270900726318,
0.11568702757358551,
0.3455975353717804,
-0.13247829675674438,
0.05770805850625038,
0.34826117753982544,
0.052225131541490555,
0.8525748252868652,
0.7659820914268494,
0.06885067373514175,
-0.0036488885525614023,
0.2713426649570465,
1.0552505254745483,
-0.44845038652420044,
-0.31634092330932617,
-0.51857590675354,
0.406290739774704,
-0.3049966096878052,
-0.23850476741790771,
0.5541627407073975,
0.6448795795440674,
0.3888101875782013,
-0.0874907523393631,
1.1079102754592896,
0.10705702006816864,
0.6731711626052856,
-0.7163422703742981,
0.23717378079891205,
0.0303630493581295,
0.6884147524833679,
-0.24701626598834991,
-1.140244483947754,
0.31016871333122253,
0.7502930164337158,
0.017460983246564865,
0.06722503155469894,
0.39851081371307373,
1.0869181156158447,
0.1607869416475296,
0.000010517155715206172,
0.32403087615966797,
0.2125149816274643,
0.8174781799316406,
0.7958530187606812,
1.2178562879562378,
-0.09622909873723984,
0.8983146548271179,
-0.024535812437534332,
-0.1619725376367569,
0.03263836354017258,
-0.8097062706947327,
-1.00017249584198,
-0.4779396951198578,
-0.097404845058918,
-0.3846396207809448,
0.13832417130470276,
1.3511701822280884,
0.6324230432510376,
-0.6100996732711792,
-0.40739738941192627,
-0.1548265665769577,
-0.06605244427919388,
0.23814299702644348,
-0.2420760840177536,
-0.001529822824522853,
-0.7432834506034851,
-0.8956854939460754,
0.7524791359901428,
-0.005388598423451185,
0.10791771113872528,
-0.45807212591171265,
-0.4274553954601288,
0.25341320037841797,
0.25840216875076294,
0.3554772734642029,
0.5270668864250183,
-0.4539921283721924,
-0.3406890630722046,
0.07420317083597183,
0.061216454952955246,
0.0008903300040401518,
0.9801512360572815,
-0.8868575692176819,
0.5008834600448608,
0.2320271134376526,
0.5019631385803223,
0.5525981187820435,
0.29592981934547424,
1.078852653503418,
-1.1478291749954224,
0.23799651861190796,
0.5212366580963135,
0.12789934873580933,
0.3905875086784363,
-0.2671794593334198,
0.533156156539917,
0.22785435616970062,
-0.728821873664856,
-0.7753978371620178,
0.5193336606025696,
-1.1364829540252686,
0.14105097949504852,
1.2892929315567017,
-0.19613872468471527,
0.2841903865337372,
-0.33408159017562866,
-0.7451508045196533,
0.06606148928403854,
-0.6842007040977478,
0.5176476836204529,
0.30101582407951355,
-0.5474024415016174,
-0.1742658019065857,
-0.7188958525657654,
0.613609790802002,
0.08276347815990448,
-0.9649760723114014,
-0.14189554750919342,
0.6635710597038269,
0.06315966695547104,
0.20706336200237274,
0.9522700309753418,
0.39205309748649597,
-0.22286400198936462,
0.03213382884860039,
0.16836252808570862,
-0.25148287415504456,
0.02135709673166275,
0.1278475821018219,
-0.0472441166639328,
0.0760497897863388,
-0.22689051926136017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17435v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17435v3 | Can Large Language Models Replace Economic Choice Prediction Labs? | 2024-01-30T20:49:47 | 2024-03-07T16:47:00 | Eilam Shapira, Omer Madmon, Roi Reichart, Moshe Tennenholtz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.HC | Economic choice prediction is an essential challenging task, often
constrained by the difficulties in acquiring human choice data. Indeed,
experimental economics studies had focused mostly on simple choice settings.
The AI community has recently contributed to that effort in two ways:
considering whether LLMs can substitute for humans in the above-mentioned
simple choice prediction settings, and the study through ML lens of more
elaborated but still rigorous experimental economics settings, employing
incomplete information, repetitive play, and natural language communication,
notably language-based persuasion games. This leaves us with a major
inspiration: can LLMs be used to fully simulate the economic environment and
generate data for efficient human choice prediction, substituting for the
elaborated economic lab studies? We pioneer the study of this subject,
demonstrating its feasibility. In particular, we show that a model trained
solely on LLM-generated data can effectively predict human behavior in a
language-based persuasion game, and can even outperform models trained on
actual human data. | [
-0.23642349243164062,
-0.8496469855308533,
0.8827563524246216,
0.10647482424974442,
0.08664797246456146,
0.04247802868485451,
-0.5735849738121033,
-0.6792455315589905,
0.1748635470867157,
0.7421607375144958,
-0.5065813660621643,
-0.11841312795877457,
-0.2576567828655243,
0.24945670366287231,
-0.2202010154724121,
0.6056252717971802,
0.15079334378242493,
0.5380030870437622,
-0.4801761507987976,
0.07066967338323593,
-0.04762784391641617,
-0.5503066778182983,
-1.1402056217193604,
-0.9170856475830078,
0.594921886920929,
0.24832822382450104,
0.7597972750663757,
0.6137545704841614,
0.1794721484184265,
0.39074990153312683,
0.01846921816468239,
0.005550071597099304,
-0.479261577129364,
-0.1373717039823532,
-0.08408361673355103,
-0.666833758354187,
-0.2238566279411316,
0.4244403541088104,
0.40683069825172424,
0.7967402935028076,
-0.42139357328414917,
0.006803110707551241,
0.14295411109924316,
0.7488589882850647,
-0.12654195725917816,
0.31665438413619995,
-0.9412143230438232,
0.11926192790269852,
0.03729620948433876,
-0.20932511985301971,
-0.7965487837791443,
-0.1510068029165268,
0.06936377286911011,
-0.5561649203300476,
-0.008283913135528564,
0.5124639868736267,
0.5504571795463562,
0.12301822751760483,
-0.5327146053314209,
-0.2693769335746765,
-0.9845824837684631,
0.8704526424407959,
-0.47643494606018066,
0.25200799107551575,
0.44344010949134827,
0.25333577394485474,
-0.5700170397758484,
-0.44473233819007874,
-0.5027530789375305,
-0.48564982414245605,
0.016732221469283104,
0.28493061661720276,
-0.3850423991680145,
0.30256372690200806,
0.3374744951725006,
-0.0837990790605545,
-0.0898771807551384,
0.36696165800094604,
-0.5570050477981567,
0.023655975237488747,
0.7340925335884094,
0.2840953469276428,
0.35814225673675537,
-0.06879013031721115,
-0.3420581817626953,
-0.19127188622951508,
-0.9247503280639648,
0.18641681969165802,
0.5581203699111938,
0.3084242641925812,
0.1702241450548172,
0.7232664227485657,
-0.192985400557518,
0.6091840267181396,
0.031184665858745575,
-0.15271605551242828,
0.00519403675571084,
0.1790257692337036,
-0.4967428147792816,
0.09106750786304474,
0.7403702139854431,
0.3746793270111084,
0.37782594561576843,
0.018369654193520546,
-0.34575915336608887,
-0.08404981344938278,
0.07763057202100754,
-0.36789658665657043,
-0.23885998129844666,
0.17903003096580505,
-0.5049983859062195,
-0.43546298146247864,
-0.3604331612586975,
-0.8975928425788879,
-0.659772515296936,
-0.43401649594306946,
0.3510548174381256,
-0.01929904706776142,
0.044809162616729736,
0.21461844444274902,
-0.18977247178554535,
0.20604948699474335,
0.391200989484787,
-0.7732048034667969,
0.4487668573856354,
0.482944130897522,
0.6981728672981262,
-0.15955382585525513,
-0.4243954122066498,
-0.5065998435020447,
0.1939859390258789,
-0.531982958316803,
0.800199031829834,
-0.5434801578521729,
-0.5623988509178162,
-0.0375027172267437,
-0.33943089842796326,
0.26612046360969543,
-0.7688345909118652,
0.0030410466715693474,
-0.6160480380058289,
0.22890117764472961,
-0.19269272685050964,
-0.8163124918937683,
0.14889441430568695,
0.39366254210472107,
-0.8909893035888672,
0.6530742049217224,
-0.11333037912845612,
-0.4825894236564636,
0.4136234521865845,
-0.7092528939247131,
-0.41364020109176636,
-0.04190904274582863,
-0.08657573908567429,
-0.4343632757663727,
-0.032807253301143646,
-0.057448334991931915,
0.21607421338558197,
-0.3335268795490265,
0.5513189435005188,
-0.6033923029899597,
-0.37053894996643066,
0.783997118473053,
-0.7328116297721863,
0.859055757522583,
0.017693495377898216,
-0.3572288155555725,
-0.1681780070066452,
-0.5931203365325928,
-0.24992236495018005,
0.1533309817314148,
-0.5823202729225159,
-0.19072045385837555,
0.4169514775276184,
-0.021850015968084335,
0.12255977094173431,
0.2165125012397766,
-0.5519909262657166,
0.13858407735824585,
-0.34216728806495667,
0.3951716721057892,
1.158475399017334,
-0.2833556830883026,
0.6533897519111633,
-0.5133581757545471,
0.7016734480857849,
-0.5211297273635864,
0.04218573123216629,
0.3242485523223877,
-0.6364588141441345,
-0.6714738607406616,
-0.2716512084007263,
0.33414214849472046,
0.5633012652397156,
-0.589381992816925,
-0.0534403994679451,
0.145481675863266,
-0.3499375879764557,
-0.2591629922389984,
-0.012943941168487072,
-0.07297966629266739,
0.505164384841919,
0.19702968001365662,
0.2464444637298584,
-1.05076265335083,
-0.802043080329895,
-0.5022100806236267,
-0.3734820783138275,
-0.11701832711696625,
0.5868871808052063,
0.2855272889137268,
-0.16650378704071045,
1.1472762823104858,
-0.3713776469230652,
-0.20513541996479034,
-0.6704775094985962,
0.01524187158793211,
0.35261961817741394,
0.18856929242610931,
0.3433581590652466,
-0.6037015318870544,
-0.33457279205322266,
-0.16571277379989624,
-0.368385910987854,
-0.09804141521453857,
-0.27565476298332214,
0.012262574397027493,
0.2521505355834961,
0.3373148441314697,
-0.5011653304100037,
0.3022572696208954,
0.5281485915184021,
-0.23058916628360748,
0.7509152889251709,
-0.5096552968025208,
-0.013900122605264187,
-0.777441143989563,
-0.19694919884204865,
0.13348081707954407,
-0.22500069439411163,
-0.5895505547523499,
-0.3772164285182953,
-0.11647871881723404,
-0.011862048879265785,
-0.5848376750946045,
1.0072522163391113,
-0.2466726452112198,
-0.2590174674987793,
-0.3364666998386383,
-0.0072465273551642895,
-0.16620370745658875,
0.14289386570453644,
0.330639123916626,
0.9326106309890747,
0.48860594630241394,
-0.6270829439163208,
0.306903213262558,
0.20656608045101166,
-0.630888819694519,
0.19860459864139557,
-0.6170880794525146,
-0.15261422097682953,
-0.2127699851989746,
0.6249784827232361,
-0.7997469305992126,
-0.524877667427063,
0.05147799476981163,
-0.22242692112922668,
-0.1232050284743309,
0.05847804620862007,
-0.43807005882263184,
-0.3290194571018219,
-0.09202345460653305,
-0.057616427540779114,
0.9753254652023315,
-0.5703079700469971,
0.5632590055465698,
0.32940128445625305,
-0.2887403070926666,
-0.44928818941116333,
-0.7695275545120239,
0.23964433372020721,
-0.4084259569644928,
-0.2327427864074707,
-0.03437531366944313,
-0.22247985005378723,
-0.6342372894287109,
-0.2501390874385834,
0.41753238439559937,
0.1506776511669159,
0.29364025592803955,
0.0013119950890541077,
0.7670566439628601,
0.07999216020107269,
0.22312474250793457,
-0.15942247211933136,
-0.1231660395860672,
0.3587539792060852,
-0.22755862772464752,
0.3619310259819031,
0.2591868042945862,
-0.34948891401290894,
-0.1397850215435028,
0.08997882157564163,
0.4323294460773468,
0.10509943217039108,
0.5598562955856323,
-0.041991040110588074,
-0.3674375116825104,
-0.2199484407901764,
-0.6653018593788147,
-0.04483012482523918,
-0.5594724416732788,
0.43611088395118713,
0.07668380439281464,
-0.859131395816803,
0.2773888409137726,
-0.22249436378479004,
0.011423141695559025,
0.3556782305240631,
0.6073639392852783,
-0.5307391285896301,
1.462613582611084,
0.5463857054710388,
-0.16877049207687378,
0.46996641159057617,
0.040963269770145416,
0.174659863114357,
-0.4632768929004669,
-0.1496846228837967,
-0.34326833486557007,
-0.494466632604599,
-0.4380994439125061,
-0.22001633048057556,
0.543211042881012,
-0.2568323016166687,
-0.39642462134361267,
-0.2909187972545624,
0.06211896240711212,
0.8656544089317322,
0.6640034914016724,
0.2736203968524933,
0.16865743696689606,
0.23431254923343658,
0.05148446932435036,
-0.054045166820287704,
-0.5538033843040466,
-0.7722625732421875,
1.3463504314422607,
0.10088802129030228,
0.638431966304779,
-0.20289762318134308,
0.7977472543716431,
0.38561856746673584,
0.7886513471603394,
-0.8368339538574219,
0.713155210018158,
-0.07985961437225342,
-0.5615877509117126,
-0.47582384943962097,
-0.5499359369277954,
-1.1045504808425903,
0.1429232805967331,
-0.39668038487434387,
-0.8800121545791626,
-0.09551520645618439,
0.2668773829936981,
-0.5081690549850464,
0.6516956686973572,
-0.5165632367134094,
0.6081188321113586,
-0.4738655686378479,
-0.37461310625076294,
-0.3893948197364807,
-0.16327624022960663,
0.2895279824733734,
-0.13547448813915253,
0.632908046245575,
-0.12325469404459,
0.0813235491514206,
0.9322885870933533,
-0.17881429195404053,
0.9767724275588989,
0.01869644597172737,
0.010495358146727085,
0.2998073101043701,
0.06519945710897446,
0.6237876415252686,
0.09529188275337219,
-0.5184680223464966,
-0.24448300898075104,
-0.45117905735969543,
-0.39281636476516724,
-0.49738338589668274,
0.6075068116188049,
-0.8092389106750488,
-0.9610638618469238,
-0.35842418670654297,
-0.6890900731086731,
-0.5444124937057495,
0.01138639822602272,
0.06938522309064865,
0.13516686856746674,
-0.593851625919342,
-0.039940301328897476,
0.5269287824630737,
-0.22120968997478485,
0.3710014820098877,
0.3622177541255951,
-0.24392439424991608,
-0.4650653004646301,
0.7940196990966797,
-0.048062246292829514,
0.16063304245471954,
0.20575520396232605,
0.584125816822052,
-0.5197950601577759,
-0.29330116510391235,
-0.32851260900497437,
0.18136447668075562,
-0.5767595767974854,
-0.09958761185407639,
-0.4540746510028839,
0.08130936324596405,
-0.056081030517816544,
-0.5735898017883301,
-0.21943384408950806,
-0.07195065170526505,
-0.5336721539497375,
-0.5041651725769043,
0.20279616117477417,
1.1716411113739014,
-0.2537758946418762,
0.11872295290231705,
-0.5676607489585876,
0.04945345222949982,
0.6013541221618652,
0.39797359704971313,
0.12858499586582184,
-0.033393338322639465,
-0.08045454323291779,
0.43062809109687805,
0.00044483327656053007,
-0.7770230174064636,
0.5993236303329468,
-0.1521027684211731,
0.47312453389167786,
0.3746042847633362,
-0.04908110201358795,
0.6360620260238647,
-0.607153058052063,
0.8756803274154663,
0.3199162185192108,
-0.7914757132530212,
0.20353811979293823,
-0.21803104877471924,
-0.053172845393419266,
0.36119696497917175,
0.1812991201877594,
-0.48558011651039124,
-0.37985843420028687,
-0.7321287989616394,
-0.5924902558326721,
0.8032786846160889,
-0.01262398436665535,
0.1702757328748703,
-0.08653292804956436,
0.1354341208934784,
0.42773282527923584,
0.2642081379890442,
-0.8606729507446289,
-0.21453949809074402,
0.23643217980861664,
0.015272046439349651,
-0.4923062026500702,
-0.23606841266155243,
-0.03992391377687454,
-0.2448393553495407,
0.7333885431289673,
0.14125320315361023,
0.061051711440086365,
-0.05460342764854431,
0.22828823328018188,
-0.38830816745758057,
0.40873879194259644,
0.2693263590335846,
0.6083804965019226,
-0.11196182668209076,
0.17959794402122498,
0.29437077045440674,
0.11055454611778259,
0.46913641691207886,
-0.02526923269033432,
-0.353839635848999,
-0.187715545296669,
-0.09332803636789322,
0.6655723452568054,
0.1324780434370041,
-1.3332183361053467,
0.19935812056064606,
-0.04395812377333641,
-0.4753251075744629,
-0.7353285551071167,
0.04878677427768707,
0.276188462972641,
0.5905389189720154,
0.3961948752403259,
0.05357441306114197,
0.19399139285087585,
-0.8548462986946106,
0.11617020517587662,
0.6820672154426575,
-0.27955254912376404,
-0.0715610459446907,
0.9592932462692261,
0.2533114552497864,
-0.4926345646381378,
0.7775141000747681,
-0.2204405814409256,
-0.4745922386646271,
1.0116605758666992,
0.7982205748558044,
0.5856394171714783,
0.11392837017774582,
0.4894968867301941,
0.1508549451828003,
0.15289632976055145,
-0.6190229654312134,
0.1836877465248108,
0.432742178440094,
-0.887701153755188,
-0.4482879936695099,
-0.4805009067058563,
-0.7992090582847595,
0.3977869749069214,
-0.3667025864124298,
0.20976689457893372,
-0.4139833450317383,
-0.060737244784832,
-0.20122140645980835,
-0.05324356630444527,
-0.8100788593292236,
0.25682950019836426,
0.5672040581703186,
0.8304767608642578,
-0.8382026553153992,
0.700246274471283,
0.9383789300918579,
-0.05147390440106392,
-0.5691366791725159,
-0.3114456534385681,
-0.09883099794387817,
-0.7102877497673035,
0.5778131484985352,
-0.005887052044272423,
-0.16277390718460083,
-0.07842368632555008,
-0.9375152587890625,
-0.8466509580612183,
1.0753693580627441,
0.42067670822143555,
-0.49446365237236023,
0.06278472393751144,
0.19902436435222626,
0.37739187479019165,
-0.6295462250709534,
0.2941902279853821,
0.6574782729148865,
0.8037887215614319,
-0.005865194369107485,
-0.6176088452339172,
-0.3023219704627991,
-0.0017125001177191734,
-0.13565266132354736,
0.006191687658429146,
-0.5492437481880188,
0.9291995763778687,
-0.4368296265602112,
-0.050914425402879715,
0.18670335412025452,
0.7593607902526855,
0.5364077091217041,
0.5501312017440796,
0.7351923584938049,
0.10958981513977051,
0.9918020367622375,
0.13620388507843018,
1.0809988975524902,
-0.32417359948158264,
0.4217827618122101,
0.8847978711128235,
-0.8225586414337158,
0.9849079251289368,
0.496427446603775,
-0.48078930377960205,
0.31087633967399597,
0.7641939520835876,
-0.003985933028161526,
0.26168903708457947,
0.3644114136695862,
-0.21400806307792664,
-0.7602294683456421,
0.061856068670749664,
0.0670282393693924,
0.46497097611427307,
0.44833239912986755,
-0.07756340503692627,
0.006303456146270037,
-0.03770779073238373,
0.006475694011896849,
0.08578523248434067,
-0.45046016573905945,
0.6286145448684692,
-0.03968222439289093,
-0.6050582528114319,
0.015374301932752132,
0.057359836995601654,
0.6713470816612244,
-0.6175090670585632,
-0.11746527999639511,
-0.19476750493049622,
0.0778716430068016,
0.11742962896823883,
-0.6746627688407898,
-0.12296947836875916,
-0.03888850286602974,
0.04077264294028282,
-0.5536018013954163,
0.7773740291595459,
-0.5234507322311401,
-0.6904043555259705,
0.16455166041851044,
0.7611186504364014,
0.08823366463184357,
0.055342625826597214,
-0.49696075916290283,
-0.39493435621261597,
0.20520298182964325,
-0.5095811486244202,
0.7345448136329651,
0.14582398533821106,
0.26258769631385803,
0.8943575620651245,
0.6870732307434082,
0.1962309181690216,
-0.2568046450614929,
-0.14969637989997864,
0.5108513832092285,
-0.8377735018730164,
-0.6235571503639221,
-1.012674331665039,
0.092680923640728,
-0.18256333470344543,
0.07928197830915451,
0.4056651294231415,
0.6662373542785645,
0.8263640999794006,
-0.295771062374115,
1.371859073638916,
0.3301028907299042,
0.2582361698150635,
-0.6679872870445251,
0.6952869296073914,
-0.5414013266563416,
0.19592896103858948,
0.012759119272232056,
-0.7868737578392029,
-0.13977019488811493,
0.3759699761867523,
-0.38121679425239563,
0.044231392443180084,
0.5096492171287537,
0.6171349883079529,
0.016906779259443283,
0.08594410866498947,
0.49536001682281494,
0.2994193136692047,
0.13349604606628418,
0.38977527618408203,
1.0790284872055054,
0.3916410207748413,
0.6784808039665222,
-0.1602596938610077,
-0.24654905498027802,
-0.34679239988327026,
-0.8542407751083374,
-0.893248975276947,
-0.3411354422569275,
-0.15881504118442535,
-0.3189746141433716,
0.05600345879793167,
1.3849427700042725,
0.09918641299009323,
-0.4243657886981964,
-0.8146889805793762,
0.05500712990760803,
0.2741982340812683,
-0.27080532908439636,
-0.1918063759803772,
0.11197726428508759,
-0.16713392734527588,
-0.9988051652908325,
0.5811907649040222,
0.2578999698162079,
0.2775885760784149,
-0.4585072696208954,
-0.2145286202430725,
-0.02478903718292713,
0.5746157169342041,
0.5981152057647705,
0.276322603225708,
-0.8094027638435364,
-0.23218736052513123,
0.12408594787120819,
-0.05953812599182129,
0.18716487288475037,
1.0595234632492065,
-0.9264379143714905,
0.2674860954284668,
0.18541918694972992,
0.46249300241470337,
0.11699848622083664,
-0.16540615260601044,
0.8858782649040222,
-0.237577885389328,
0.10867223143577576,
0.11506545543670654,
0.8142282962799072,
0.1472439467906952,
-0.22256863117218018,
0.40836286544799805,
-0.0026545231230556965,
-0.44810524582862854,
-0.5595589876174927,
0.3078256845474243,
-0.6180152893066406,
-0.3544591963291168,
1.4430980682373047,
0.13987775146961212,
-0.566225528717041,
-0.08779501914978027,
-0.4438159763813019,
0.06841406971216202,
-0.6029908657073975,
1.033694863319397,
0.819196879863739,
-0.268724262714386,
-0.06071210652589798,
-0.6808663606643677,
0.3536420464515686,
0.3684501051902771,
-0.6951330304145813,
0.1268632858991623,
0.6156013607978821,
0.16501669585704803,
-0.2215234488248825,
0.9270129799842834,
0.3392127752304077,
0.1984959840774536,
-0.16168060898780823,
0.14334909617900848,
0.02224644087255001,
0.027826059609651566,
-0.1953561156988144,
0.15165668725967407,
0.3286186158657074,
0.27652856707572937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00070v1 | EvoMerge: Neuroevolution for Large Language Models | 2024-01-30T19:37:21 | 2024-01-30T19:37:21 | Yushu Jiang | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Extensive fine-tuning on Large Language Models does not always yield better
results. Oftentimes, models tend to get better at imitating one form of data
without gaining greater reasoning ability and may even end up losing some
intelligence. Here I introduce EvoMerge, a systematic approach to large
language model training and merging. Leveraging model merging for weight
crossover and fine-tuning for weight mutation, EvoMerge establishes an
evolutionary process aimed at pushing models beyond the limits of conventional
fine-tuning. | [
-0.6568741202354431,
-0.9757043123245239,
0.35204407572746277,
-0.2769741714000702,
0.0697355717420578,
0.1462138295173645,
-0.581336498260498,
-0.6657541990280151,
0.2467542290687561,
0.4783637523651123,
-0.6560224294662476,
-0.12057346850633621,
-0.4914247393608093,
-0.11855900287628174,
-0.5850204825401306,
1.090654969215393,
0.08082616329193115,
0.305683970451355,
-0.12689927220344543,
-0.26641958951950073,
-0.25388073921203613,
-0.34950971603393555,
-1.1284961700439453,
-0.9482468962669373,
0.38675397634506226,
0.3778286874294281,
0.5656091570854187,
0.3552810251712799,
0.3015066087245941,
0.27385053038597107,
-0.24730435013771057,
0.32324129343032837,
-0.6834734678268433,
0.22477024793624878,
-0.3607974350452423,
-0.5517069697380066,
-0.6152494549751282,
-0.18717330694198608,
0.1900683492422104,
0.8721073865890503,
-0.47595739364624023,
0.11394628137350082,
0.09534761309623718,
0.5508038997650146,
-0.41195178031921387,
-0.46167051792144775,
-0.46778422594070435,
0.04508247599005699,
-0.14382486045360565,
-0.2863215208053589,
-0.36480817198753357,
-0.52346271276474,
0.09590370953083038,
-0.4478067457675934,
0.26783788204193115,
0.3318307101726532,
0.8265088796615601,
0.1770557463169098,
-0.2781996726989746,
-0.26411744952201843,
-0.9099717140197754,
0.7562201619148254,
-1.0112944841384888,
0.24186134338378906,
0.4460603892803192,
0.2559313476085663,
-0.3138119876384735,
-0.8167012333869934,
-0.5743948221206665,
-0.4099527895450592,
0.1652580201625824,
-0.3012407124042511,
-0.362207293510437,
0.4037662446498871,
0.4875493049621582,
0.3112439215183258,
-0.6967619061470032,
0.5134653449058533,
-0.4139115810394287,
-0.0013071303255856037,
0.6886777877807617,
0.11531022191047668,
0.7473598122596741,
0.37530386447906494,
0.2174256592988968,
-0.3908225893974304,
-0.7422091364860535,
-0.06991218775510788,
0.7416963577270508,
0.15858499705791473,
0.07257276028394699,
0.5675925016403198,
-0.1923055648803711,
0.7117690443992615,
0.4092688262462616,
0.41698309779167175,
0.2845931053161621,
-0.07454393059015274,
-0.47074469923973083,
0.5036090612411499,
0.5631322860717773,
0.2452915757894516,
0.2954927384853363,
-0.060933053493499756,
-0.1753309816122055,
-0.36505013704299927,
0.24889984726905823,
-0.8585419058799744,
-0.3479282259941101,
0.5017821192741394,
-0.46860623359680176,
-0.21832385659217834,
-0.4951705038547516,
-1.0695286989212036,
-0.27263039350509644,
-0.5304319262504578,
0.5738314986228943,
-0.7542470097541809,
-0.37522581219673157,
0.383830189704895,
-0.3668789565563202,
-0.0013726468896493316,
0.461701899766922,
-1.2675237655639648,
0.39356306195259094,
0.7344502806663513,
0.9191128015518188,
0.08094373345375061,
-0.5321927070617676,
-0.6905514001846313,
-0.1757039725780487,
-0.4650660753250122,
0.7614822387695312,
-0.45052385330200195,
-0.11108525842428207,
0.07258310168981552,
0.04798399657011032,
0.08967986702919006,
-0.3945062458515167,
0.5104036331176758,
-0.49097442626953125,
0.12203775346279144,
0.05369485542178154,
-0.7278933525085449,
-0.5140386819839478,
0.1339040845632553,
-0.7322593331336975,
0.8837139010429382,
0.2705208361148834,
-0.35468462109565735,
0.7560123801231384,
-0.6001871228218079,
-0.48750942945480347,
0.3021896481513977,
0.32376301288604736,
-0.338113397359848,
0.23455023765563965,
0.14333193004131317,
0.36602893471717834,
-0.625729501247406,
0.2766304314136505,
-0.5475773215293884,
0.06501263380050659,
-0.2434563785791397,
0.0972689613699913,
0.840244710445404,
0.35768425464630127,
-0.3198378086090088,
0.3531402051448822,
-0.6645424962043762,
0.1870989054441452,
0.06680392473936081,
-0.04284389317035675,
-0.7612658143043518,
0.026213986799120903,
0.2928101718425751,
0.11285727471113205,
0.18837375938892365,
-0.5256147384643555,
0.5843326449394226,
-0.5850111842155457,
1.1219508647918701,
0.3964671790599823,
-0.21374361217021942,
0.923842191696167,
-0.4257446825504303,
0.5992395281791687,
-0.5772497057914734,
0.17269267141819,
0.20537544786930084,
-0.3686739206314087,
-0.8292719125747681,
0.11233533918857574,
0.29369115829467773,
0.21410541236400604,
-0.5517995953559875,
0.6000516414642334,
-0.29113247990608215,
-0.8002007603645325,
-0.3335477113723755,
0.19185009598731995,
-0.014349591918289661,
0.09411465376615524,
0.4430445432662964,
0.12321247160434723,
-0.44562047719955444,
-1.0481687784194946,
-0.3031271696090698,
0.21484847366809845,
0.017575116828083992,
-0.22297963500022888,
0.7121594548225403,
-0.14505481719970703,
0.4663241505622864,
0.03350453823804855,
0.0439152717590332,
-0.5903187990188599,
0.5965183973312378,
0.25691041350364685,
0.8486144542694092,
0.7968058586120605,
-0.6373082399368286,
-0.18643704056739807,
0.5097827315330505,
-0.37508007884025574,
-0.07650189846754074,
-0.25642457604408264,
-0.09787879884243011,
-0.24521170556545258,
0.8906466364860535,
-0.635839581489563,
0.03583631291985512,
0.7397912740707397,
-0.2633354663848877,
0.3560197651386261,
-0.3845629096031189,
0.30565789341926575,
-0.9354564547538757,
0.0845019668340683,
-0.19103875756263733,
-0.23443739116191864,
-0.8532407283782959,
0.3325890302658081,
0.12735532224178314,
-0.043241459876298904,
-0.13892874121665955,
0.4276466965675354,
-0.5979939699172974,
0.08343753963708878,
-0.2790404260158539,
-0.2131618708372116,
-0.31883272528648376,
0.02406431920826435,
-0.4635205566883087,
0.4784029722213745,
0.5209141969680786,
-0.6768890619277954,
0.7955295443534851,
0.20245203375816345,
-0.27641716599464417,
0.6088968515396118,
-0.6840147972106934,
0.20639532804489136,
-0.1243542805314064,
0.0367450974881649,
-0.850311279296875,
-0.49865883588790894,
-0.45966118574142456,
-0.44266045093536377,
0.6507585644721985,
-0.22491036355495453,
-0.390899658203125,
-0.623718798160553,
-0.1743999719619751,
0.5174427032470703,
0.7333680391311646,
-0.8067783117294312,
0.9167317748069763,
0.1065298467874527,
-0.2541174292564392,
-0.19434180855751038,
-0.8278628587722778,
0.2716168463230133,
-0.4289371371269226,
-0.728476345539093,
0.3962734341621399,
-0.10396798700094223,
-0.1925107091665268,
-0.01477878075093031,
0.3876011073589325,
0.11291993409395218,
-0.18499848246574402,
-0.1820424497127533,
-0.24600109457969666,
-0.17943918704986572,
0.4579102098941803,
0.30304062366485596,
0.25764304399490356,
-0.1761537492275238,
-0.43449199199676514,
1.1889477968215942,
0.1276959478855133,
-0.279750257730484,
-0.08439264446496964,
0.3294939696788788,
0.8574174046516418,
-0.2794599235057831,
0.4944398105144501,
0.5166020393371582,
-0.4088955521583557,
-0.6906308531761169,
-0.5995011329650879,
-0.38608595728874207,
-0.48431146144866943,
0.6783661842346191,
-0.22929765284061432,
-1.0439385175704956,
0.5115910172462463,
-0.3914312422275543,
0.34725072979927063,
0.5810645222663879,
0.5394451022148132,
0.11350153386592865,
1.3694007396697998,
0.9388228058815002,
0.17928490042686462,
0.5480121374130249,
-0.0965791866183281,
0.3258247673511505,
-0.7506076097488403,
-0.19799059629440308,
-0.6072626113891602,
-0.734389066696167,
-0.5708989500999451,
-0.08953236043453217,
-0.07786163687705994,
0.17961090803146362,
-0.35258346796035767,
0.5641894340515137,
-0.6693576574325562,
0.3320847153663635,
0.5764768719673157,
0.07646553218364716,
0.09091509133577347,
0.26794445514678955,
0.08202781528234482,
-0.07235733419656754,
-0.9151406288146973,
0.004518401343375444,
0.9866505861282349,
0.09256653487682343,
0.9188445210456848,
-0.043497513979673386,
0.6595239043235779,
0.07526003569364548,
0.06240587309002876,
-0.8880684971809387,
0.377305269241333,
-0.2293538898229599,
-0.4773414433002472,
-0.42905595898628235,
-0.5177762508392334,
-1.1297078132629395,
-0.20547620952129364,
-0.40260788798332214,
-0.8768750429153442,
0.4295603036880493,
0.07453873008489609,
-0.41440853476524353,
0.5135405659675598,
-0.4838251769542694,
0.49010321497917175,
-0.3958631753921509,
-0.3409450650215149,
-0.8422303199768066,
-0.2569539248943329,
0.6316577792167664,
-0.22055968642234802,
0.17658667266368866,
-0.03304960951209068,
0.1670314222574234,
0.7593137621879578,
-0.4807496964931488,
0.33851414918899536,
0.3493689298629761,
-0.040196746587753296,
-0.08505813777446747,
0.5252833366394043,
0.7174842953681946,
-0.44575753808021545,
-0.009427418000996113,
-0.005853432230651379,
-0.2919584810733795,
-0.2865811288356781,
-0.5834177732467651,
0.7808056473731995,
-0.5010119676589966,
-0.3148060739040375,
-0.024776078760623932,
-0.5994925498962402,
-0.16480609774589539,
0.2007277011871338,
0.6245700716972351,
0.5444933176040649,
-0.12677304446697235,
0.1856110543012619,
0.795931875705719,
-0.42074471712112427,
0.5861924886703491,
0.24577908217906952,
-0.4404720366001129,
-0.6117578744888306,
0.5483219623565674,
0.2332034558057785,
0.5012742877006531,
0.13105088472366333,
0.11714055389165878,
-0.16582010686397552,
-0.6152195334434509,
-0.25824251770973206,
0.11430332064628601,
-0.6670365333557129,
-0.022108977660536766,
-0.7875927686691284,
-0.20690906047821045,
-0.4514896273612976,
-0.49948832392692566,
-0.5209273099899292,
-0.40087851881980896,
0.08971968293190002,
-0.027664661407470703,
0.8703789710998535,
0.9367649555206299,
-0.39874300360679626,
0.44870269298553467,
-0.7059057950973511,
0.006230705883353949,
0.48123684525489807,
0.21264462172985077,
0.03051437810063362,
-0.8218583464622498,
-0.18738652765750885,
-0.11001448333263397,
0.03457854688167572,
-0.8083760738372803,
0.7517715096473694,
0.5314223766326904,
0.7373385429382324,
0.3264874815940857,
-0.405373215675354,
0.7685585021972656,
-0.47398892045021057,
0.6790950894355774,
0.5977357029914856,
-1.0056262016296387,
0.7387102246284485,
-0.48079296946525574,
0.28125685453414917,
0.45919740200042725,
0.3334449231624603,
-0.6423215866088867,
-0.2449968457221985,
-0.7806531190872192,
-1.2333089113235474,
0.4137081205844879,
0.048262231051921844,
0.189841628074646,
0.3861202299594879,
0.3323464095592499,
0.1418469399213791,
0.17275875806808472,
-0.2380938082933426,
0.1288727968931198,
0.08432231843471527,
-0.1855614185333252,
-0.2585650384426117,
0.11760792136192322,
-0.30018556118011475,
-0.7194536328315735,
0.5814396142959595,
-0.139295756816864,
0.0049261171370744705,
-0.04841088503599167,
-0.21825845539569855,
-0.38189536333084106,
0.1554678976535797,
0.6846138834953308,
0.6341002583503723,
-0.020238444209098816,
0.0995531976222992,
0.42686957120895386,
-0.5723158121109009,
0.21417273581027985,
0.11978895962238312,
-0.04170410335063934,
-0.21339990198612213,
0.5169026851654053,
0.7329780459403992,
0.12605832517147064,
-0.7340309023857117,
0.1974894404411316,
-0.014699622988700867,
-0.6030102968215942,
-0.03212625905871391,
0.26177096366882324,
0.10568568855524063,
0.38985738158226013,
0.2953944504261017,
0.19625066220760345,
0.2885013818740845,
-0.5692960619926453,
0.3711920380592346,
0.3737572133541107,
-0.23148654401302338,
-0.3217048943042755,
0.795301079750061,
0.24995927512645721,
-0.3529919683933258,
0.9525423645973206,
-0.21410706639289856,
-0.5278698205947876,
0.9559304714202881,
0.38965094089508057,
1.1758546829223633,
-0.5825152397155762,
0.0760316252708435,
0.8725353479385376,
0.6104686260223389,
-0.6100634336471558,
0.04845389723777771,
0.1981354057788849,
-0.6139563918113708,
-0.9678546786308289,
-0.8250147700309753,
-0.10812268406152725,
0.3291788399219513,
-0.5963661074638367,
0.5173225998878479,
-0.6400185227394104,
-0.2429334670305252,
0.17236477136611938,
-0.40924227237701416,
-0.5284569263458252,
0.04598149657249451,
0.2692736089229584,
0.9370147585868835,
-0.8172445893287659,
0.6758416295051575,
1.0292158126831055,
-0.3246346116065979,
-0.7563480734825134,
-0.3359466791152954,
-0.07888138294219971,
-0.7329065203666687,
1.0409373044967651,
0.011262376792728901,
0.2183571308851242,
0.4520348310470581,
-0.9500340223312378,
-1.0249419212341309,
0.8738250732421875,
0.3808411657810211,
-1.0218650102615356,
-0.07642635703086853,
-0.2573222815990448,
0.4117768704891205,
-0.2610926032066345,
0.3843097984790802,
0.7831973433494568,
0.558561384677887,
-0.01463336031883955,
-1.2235705852508545,
0.06986590474843979,
-0.4142617881298065,
-0.1815592497587204,
0.7328286170959473,
-0.3968336284160614,
1.126483678817749,
-0.2735159993171692,
-0.026041623204946518,
0.02346215955913067,
0.4264867901802063,
-0.2559937834739685,
-0.008264387026429176,
0.5660948753356934,
0.9646673202514648,
0.8480166792869568,
-0.0716748908162117,
0.8970935344696045,
-0.21040305495262146,
0.6251646876335144,
0.9976516962051392,
-0.15712983906269073,
0.6485506296157837,
0.4217245280742645,
-0.14199677109718323,
0.20198002457618713,
0.8167115449905396,
-0.21070942282676697,
0.26001787185668945,
0.14329074323177338,
0.08647818863391876,
-0.5400041341781616,
0.0287061408162117,
-0.267509400844574,
0.40247124433517456,
0.46897706389427185,
-0.307936429977417,
-0.507328987121582,
0.4100210666656494,
0.05257313326001167,
-0.131345734000206,
-0.596854031085968,
0.6693985462188721,
-0.01918937638401985,
-0.7683680057525635,
0.698392927646637,
-0.3968118727207184,
0.7987498044967651,
-0.6188415884971619,
-0.19974058866500854,
-0.06869128346443176,
0.18666338920593262,
-0.3187149465084076,
-0.6719120144844055,
0.11753823608160019,
-0.4409542381763458,
0.05325367674231529,
-0.17556384205818176,
0.6620103120803833,
-0.5273271799087524,
-0.23413702845573425,
0.5709511637687683,
0.3138273060321808,
0.08158289641141891,
0.014624150469899178,
-0.6404010057449341,
-0.3526839017868042,
-0.00116166181396693,
-0.3669331669807434,
0.36297619342803955,
0.26838982105255127,
0.30557867884635925,
0.7644399404525757,
0.7662191390991211,
0.4760458469390869,
0.09006944298744202,
0.13787846267223358,
0.6333030462265015,
-0.4915446639060974,
-0.7018140554428101,
-1.0763870477676392,
0.35903990268707275,
-0.3749689757823944,
-0.631623387336731,
0.5969994068145752,
0.32813963294029236,
0.5442755818367004,
0.1355111300945282,
0.7505410313606262,
-0.42149031162261963,
0.013633138500154018,
-0.7060927152633667,
0.8128432035446167,
-0.9311622977256775,
-0.3525347411632538,
-0.0164576955139637,
-1.0602959394454956,
-0.16404542326927185,
0.4636484682559967,
-0.33100682497024536,
0.15479272603988647,
0.8981106877326965,
0.6702746152877808,
-0.23162899911403656,
0.020932676270604134,
0.6267814636230469,
0.3772636353969574,
0.2771771550178528,
0.7637885212898254,
0.9732949733734131,
-0.10924170911312103,
0.33353668451309204,
-0.07144276797771454,
-0.3428201973438263,
-0.519346296787262,
-0.6514453291893005,
-0.9369732141494751,
-0.6136692762374878,
-0.2814861536026001,
-0.3720299005508423,
0.1029437780380249,
1.0794447660446167,
1.0294861793518066,
-0.7440810799598694,
-0.09673583507537842,
-0.667248547077179,
-0.378615140914917,
-0.4617559611797333,
-0.18703946471214294,
0.1114383265376091,
-0.6276951432228088,
-1.0399255752563477,
0.2256399691104889,
0.3180231750011444,
0.15139693021774292,
-0.3390697240829468,
0.11994684487581253,
-0.014174330979585648,
0.12330905348062515,
0.44146424531936646,
0.42076486349105835,
-0.29057589173316956,
-0.06701519340276718,
-0.08469897508621216,
-0.0014178637648001313,
-0.08600202947854996,
1.0203346014022827,
-0.3870824873447418,
0.5888879895210266,
0.9030566811561584,
0.6458739042282104,
0.6083717346191406,
-0.4429033100605011,
1.033119559288025,
-0.11474031209945679,
0.3382520079612732,
0.38789743185043335,
0.6178992390632629,
0.2286527305841446,
-0.5556573867797852,
0.5891355276107788,
-0.1369307041168213,
-0.9379310607910156,
-0.7992950677871704,
0.3367202579975128,
-0.8239649534225464,
-0.42535150051116943,
1.2179762125015259,
0.39733102917671204,
-0.40482383966445923,
-0.15035811066627502,
-0.09873612970113754,
0.2372049242258072,
-0.388435423374176,
0.4749819040298462,
0.7701741456985474,
-0.21607153117656708,
-0.36797139048576355,
-1.1180071830749512,
0.6330586671829224,
0.6131505966186523,
-0.9335180521011353,
0.2076759785413742,
0.24657322466373444,
0.19575722515583038,
0.28968292474746704,
-0.09080325812101364,
0.20609261095523834,
0.4678427278995514,
0.2521286606788635,
0.6058437824249268,
0.178305983543396,
-0.007392984814941883,
-0.6432656645774841,
0.06580785661935806,
0.08445442467927933,
0.4745158851146698
] |
Subsets and Splits