id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02622v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02622v2 | DenseFormer: Enhancing Information Flow in Transformers via Depth Weighted Averaging | 2024-02-04T21:44:09 | 2024-03-21T10:57:40 | Matteo Pagliardini, Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Francois Fleuret, Martin Jaggi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The transformer architecture by Vaswani et al. (2017) is now ubiquitous
across application domains, from natural language processing to speech
processing and image understanding. We propose DenseFormer, a simple
modification to the standard architecture that improves the perplexity of the
model without increasing its size -- adding a few thousand parameters for
large-scale models in the 100B parameters range. Our approach relies on an
additional averaging step after each transformer block, which computes a
weighted average of current and past representations -- we refer to this
operation as Depth-Weighted-Average (DWA). The learned DWA weights exhibit
coherent patterns of information flow, revealing the strong and structured
reuse of activations from distant layers. Experiments demonstrate that
DenseFormer is more data efficient, reaching the same perplexity of much deeper
transformer models, and that for the same perplexity, these new models
outperform transformer baselines in terms of memory efficiency and inference
time. | [
-0.3495806157588959,
-0.6316201686859131,
0.5127052664756775,
0.33472758531570435,
-0.15983837842941284,
-0.06709490716457367,
0.014141053892672062,
-0.2705099582672119,
0.17491213977336884,
0.3951965272426605,
-0.049216050654649734,
-0.23279911279678345,
-1.0331039428710938,
-0.308885782957077,
-0.7879818081855774,
0.5343949794769287,
-0.14909560978412628,
-0.1302550584077835,
-0.24801310896873474,
-0.17384755611419678,
-0.3813890814781189,
-0.07599148899316788,
-0.7381585836410522,
-0.476728230714798,
0.6033469438552856,
0.46298232674598694,
1.104772686958313,
0.5411413311958313,
0.5900080800056458,
0.5050126910209656,
0.021746326237916946,
-0.2717469334602356,
-0.611298680305481,
0.2874108552932739,
0.20857033133506775,
-0.40377354621887207,
-0.79422527551651,
-0.26109999418258667,
0.8321490287780762,
1.1195714473724365,
-0.45508480072021484,
0.020432405173778534,
-0.1851145625114441,
0.985696017742157,
-0.6670306921005249,
0.03428208827972412,
-0.2819001078605652,
0.08777490258216858,
-0.004129454027861357,
-0.08754748851060867,
-0.258604496717453,
0.011888859793543816,
0.22777195274829865,
-0.598832905292511,
0.223423570394516,
-0.1481107622385025,
0.37656399607658386,
0.7587298154830933,
-0.10138440132141113,
-0.058573536574840546,
-0.9919403195381165,
0.6623607277870178,
-0.3507764935493469,
0.7023557424545288,
-0.1240195706486702,
0.6458508968353271,
0.13469627499580383,
-1.0134888887405396,
-0.6394839882850647,
0.16131138801574707,
-0.12966285645961761,
0.4276459217071533,
-0.894967794418335,
0.07701783627271652,
0.48790448904037476,
0.4991254508495331,
-0.4488104581832886,
0.03478460758924484,
-0.5649811625480652,
0.041360221803188324,
0.7257260680198669,
0.21271423995494843,
0.03973120450973511,
0.1075933650135994,
-0.10831565409898758,
-0.41680416464805603,
-0.05240757763385773,
0.1101292073726654,
0.2418939173221588,
-0.29304978251457214,
-0.2882749140262604,
0.39218997955322266,
-0.3228664696216583,
0.6751483082771301,
0.3981425166130066,
0.04385954514145851,
0.23939989507198334,
0.09095119684934616,
-0.5174791812896729,
0.26149964332580566,
0.5490019917488098,
0.07590443640947342,
0.046425849199295044,
-0.315118670463562,
-0.35493215918540955,
-0.2800343334674835,
0.663906991481781,
-1.2609342336654663,
-0.5248814225196838,
0.4437985420227051,
-0.6282685995101929,
-0.2656473219394684,
0.2655121684074402,
-0.5868380665779114,
-0.625901997089386,
-0.23243314027786255,
0.40843284130096436,
-0.2630297839641571,
-0.435373991727829,
0.5830334424972534,
-0.4613152742385864,
0.35664820671081543,
0.5421891212463379,
-0.7104405164718628,
0.6031551957130432,
0.6249045133590698,
0.893808126449585,
-0.2596232295036316,
-0.12862038612365723,
-0.3726363778114319,
0.1798432469367981,
-0.3629591464996338,
0.9612227082252502,
-0.6094143390655518,
-0.24448704719543457,
-0.5375487804412842,
-0.3469723165035248,
0.17667919397354126,
-0.7363878488540649,
0.4332117438316345,
-0.7664799094200134,
0.2401663362979889,
0.00020669483637902886,
-0.29016318917274475,
-0.23854991793632507,
-0.2141137719154358,
-1.1944252252578735,
0.9278079867362976,
0.3795909285545349,
-0.5298504829406738,
0.529640793800354,
-0.7322725653648376,
-0.3786551356315613,
0.07394779473543167,
0.07392621040344238,
-0.48678264021873474,
0.47022485733032227,
0.2568904161453247,
0.48226359486579895,
-0.21386553347110748,
0.29406020045280457,
-0.047292280942201614,
-0.831225574016571,
0.04396097734570503,
-0.5252114534378052,
0.41213494539260864,
0.26237308979034424,
-0.3055514097213745,
0.34291398525238037,
-0.9705213904380798,
-0.35756105184555054,
0.11241830140352249,
-0.2746588885784149,
-0.2493588775396347,
-0.1070331558585167,
-0.1210796907544136,
-0.04897993430495262,
0.08208952099084854,
-0.4430732727050781,
0.17167681455612183,
-0.3398646116256714,
0.21584950387477875,
0.5318188667297363,
-0.20190124213695526,
1.2041780948638916,
-0.30542412400245667,
0.43448859453201294,
0.4400492012500763,
0.37484264373779297,
-0.055240944027900696,
-0.3825313448905945,
-0.6744146347045898,
-0.5122506022453308,
0.17968067526817322,
0.28594672679901123,
-0.3228243589401245,
0.2751239836215973,
-0.596293568611145,
-0.8652048707008362,
-0.6384491324424744,
0.2790697515010834,
-0.20032663643360138,
0.46954309940338135,
0.5703619718551636,
-0.3790481388568878,
-0.5706714987754822,
-0.7809553146362305,
-0.20599819719791412,
0.19144585728645325,
-0.424961656332016,
0.17317435145378113,
0.045896876603364944,
-0.348660945892334,
0.6646322011947632,
-0.6283552050590515,
-0.06795331090688705,
-0.258646160364151,
0.16038759052753448,
0.6817182302474976,
0.4136054217815399,
0.3531867265701294,
-0.9759793281555176,
-0.28986597061157227,
-0.2677898108959198,
-0.573007345199585,
-0.023317428305745125,
-0.20050440728664398,
-0.22892522811889648,
-0.3085053563117981,
0.5334836840629578,
-0.7799689769744873,
0.23548762500286102,
0.6568632125854492,
-0.32666754722595215,
0.16865649819374084,
-0.07575444877147675,
-0.1070239469408989,
-0.8709706664085388,
-0.16107389330863953,
-0.20156095921993256,
-0.001393490587361157,
-0.6765283346176147,
-0.3499031364917755,
0.07724212110042572,
-0.1878145933151245,
-0.1310303658246994,
0.5021299123764038,
-0.4510245621204376,
-0.0539274737238884,
-0.3336208164691925,
0.01781192608177662,
0.1252836138010025,
0.24057403206825256,
-0.12308474630117416,
0.7228891849517822,
0.8266890048980713,
-0.543243408203125,
0.4506966471672058,
0.047741327434778214,
-0.38399526476860046,
0.5656369924545288,
-1.0595916509628296,
0.055462900549173355,
-0.6473482847213745,
0.47126802802085876,
-1.0160378217697144,
-0.17333993315696716,
-0.14458216726779938,
-0.16317765414714813,
0.2882395088672638,
-0.006487962324172258,
-0.16250483691692352,
-0.17188480496406555,
-0.3372582793235779,
0.6742880940437317,
0.641915500164032,
-0.4630255699157715,
1.5436100959777832,
0.27079296112060547,
0.047655194997787476,
-0.5048645734786987,
-0.8933733105659485,
0.2221931368112564,
-0.07415588200092316,
-1.0073472261428833,
0.6589498519897461,
-0.013909772969782352,
-0.4456995725631714,
0.07680635154247284,
-0.4094032645225525,
-0.2248840183019638,
0.14289182424545288,
0.43198633193969727,
-0.1501607447862625,
-0.5157529711723328,
0.06754042953252792,
0.19670243561267853,
-0.162140890955925,
0.12310703098773956,
-0.4281405508518219,
0.47959354519844055,
0.020878596231341362,
-0.3032488524913788,
-0.5112680196762085,
0.44556552171707153,
0.6747458577156067,
-0.0067663672380149364,
0.7817236185073853,
0.7841365933418274,
-0.19778887927532196,
-0.2197641283273697,
-0.7913615107536316,
-0.19769614934921265,
-0.5550968647003174,
0.44248130917549133,
-0.565025269985199,
-0.7925145030021667,
0.470236212015152,
-0.006580708548426628,
-0.025565950199961662,
0.4852258861064911,
0.2980741560459137,
-0.09496843814849854,
1.0844935178756714,
0.9260229468345642,
-0.13407617807388306,
0.7972754836082458,
-0.43773216009140015,
0.2996842861175537,
-0.5638127326965332,
-0.2496444433927536,
-0.09075848758220673,
-0.9310618042945862,
-0.3080529570579529,
-0.5832071900367737,
0.3602471649646759,
0.22605687379837036,
-0.21871782839298248,
0.1475539207458496,
-0.4697240889072418,
0.4577580988407135,
0.3246174454689026,
0.13964547216892242,
0.3552389144897461,
0.07809627056121826,
0.28138309717178345,
0.3052847981452942,
-0.9332303404808044,
-0.2717670500278473,
0.8743212223052979,
0.41983726620674133,
1.0044467449188232,
0.14288006722927094,
0.5274474024772644,
0.08545035868883133,
0.4055714011192322,
-0.985552191734314,
0.24548958241939545,
-0.2281520664691925,
-0.025704892352223396,
-0.4344825744628906,
-0.5364611148834229,
-0.8250669240951538,
0.13879220187664032,
0.03714459016919136,
-0.1400335729122162,
0.4203507602214813,
0.15016908943653107,
-0.4518004059791565,
0.42448535561561584,
-0.7945694923400879,
0.6716610789299011,
-0.10049811750650406,
-0.12111981958150864,
-0.42714831233024597,
-0.30167829990386963,
0.3233092427253723,
0.0011067584855481982,
-0.19918183982372284,
0.24322693049907684,
-0.3338070809841156,
0.8050085306167603,
-0.3591931164264679,
0.6461859941482544,
-0.38187578320503235,
-0.26681339740753174,
0.31146544218063354,
0.1340131014585495,
0.4378555119037628,
0.03883334621787071,
-0.30286574363708496,
0.2739788889884949,
-0.49967119097709656,
-0.6776180267333984,
-1.0777931213378906,
0.441616415977478,
-0.8276130557060242,
-0.5472763180732727,
0.07025180011987686,
-0.7645745873451233,
0.05845024064183235,
0.15488885343074799,
-0.07167789340019226,
0.578813910484314,
0.05389447882771492,
0.673134982585907,
0.90080326795578,
0.06978622078895569,
0.30491217970848083,
0.35835427045822144,
0.4144878685474396,
-0.2610366642475128,
0.4823059141635895,
0.09062212705612183,
0.014509916305541992,
0.7313603758811951,
0.29141318798065186,
-0.11196578294038773,
-0.8122377991676331,
-0.24065399169921875,
0.08769670128822327,
-0.6966345906257629,
-0.21114687621593475,
-1.1660255193710327,
-0.21294257044792175,
-0.1613054871559143,
-0.22354847192764282,
-0.5161910057067871,
-0.608735203742981,
0.020361147820949554,
-0.16889522969722748,
0.29847773909568787,
0.857009768486023,
0.3542414605617523,
0.674056351184845,
-0.5620926022529602,
0.46838220953941345,
0.629337728023529,
0.6944181323051453,
0.32630491256713867,
-0.6676934361457825,
-0.18386198580265045,
-0.3023214638233185,
-0.24781866371631622,
-0.5117063522338867,
-0.11857136338949203,
0.09147465229034424,
0.5948350429534912,
0.39973554015159607,
-0.2870122492313385,
0.9737458229064941,
-0.2861618399620056,
0.6385524868965149,
-0.015575728379189968,
-0.869460940361023,
0.15067072212696075,
0.06319394707679749,
0.765792965888977,
0.2822999656200409,
0.34879231452941895,
-0.3863919973373413,
-0.24468550086021423,
-0.6001322865486145,
-0.8213471174240112,
0.35079142451286316,
-0.050454556941986084,
0.43310293555259705,
0.46597376465797424,
0.31875079870224,
-0.047705382108688354,
-0.02587767317891121,
-0.3788648247718811,
-0.08344462513923645,
-0.7400763034820557,
-0.5094681978225708,
0.18741290271282196,
-0.4444504976272583,
0.08599947392940521,
-0.4325354993343353,
0.2881857752799988,
-0.19708308577537537,
0.3067307472229004,
0.3962477445602417,
-0.42355379462242126,
-0.20634952187538147,
0.16396889090538025,
0.5057021379470825,
0.7596753835678101,
0.08898606151342392,
0.422023743391037,
0.392722487449646,
-0.8427259922027588,
-0.11055359989404678,
0.155258908867836,
0.06250006705522537,
-0.1811143159866333,
0.5391696691513062,
0.9061064720153809,
0.582531750202179,
-0.5733205080032349,
0.5606667995452881,
-0.31744199991226196,
-0.41842734813690186,
-0.2714218497276306,
0.3169479966163635,
0.06495462357997894,
0.4859890937805176,
0.5963224768638611,
0.44043534994125366,
0.2671598196029663,
-0.11584300547838211,
0.2876977026462555,
0.2406831681728363,
-0.6321905851364136,
-0.3548831045627594,
0.5836774706840515,
-0.022746628150343895,
0.02123209275305271,
0.5652191042900085,
0.10570390522480011,
-0.18932859599590302,
0.3126241862773895,
0.2518267333507538,
0.9768826961517334,
-0.2938874363899231,
-0.0887179970741272,
0.3233053982257843,
0.2682191729545593,
-0.19792944192886353,
0.25858110189437866,
-0.3625086843967438,
-0.7365322113037109,
-0.5330759286880493,
-0.7357821464538574,
-0.20656810700893402,
-0.042110245674848557,
-0.382026344537735,
0.18533673882484436,
-0.6240426898002625,
0.19075989723205566,
-0.03514568880200386,
-0.1292131096124649,
-0.6785538792610168,
0.12945233285427094,
0.12922635674476624,
1.2983304262161255,
-0.5838043093681335,
0.5498069524765015,
0.5740939974784851,
-0.16528105735778809,
-0.9216912984848022,
-0.20821034908294678,
-0.26519283652305603,
-0.6059404015541077,
0.47988831996917725,
0.028213992714881897,
-0.42994391918182373,
-0.06524014472961426,
-0.4171029329299927,
-1.0058231353759766,
1.4172396659851074,
0.32443687319755554,
-0.5775727033615112,
0.01590099185705185,
-0.015833880752325058,
0.4980994462966919,
-0.447152316570282,
0.6848679780960083,
0.630010187625885,
0.7067722082138062,
0.35081958770751953,
-0.25890064239501953,
0.3731182813644409,
-0.46716538071632385,
-0.050734881311655045,
0.17753981053829193,
-0.510242223739624,
0.7977655529975891,
-0.23503832519054413,
-0.3248187005519867,
-0.16328181326389313,
0.9278488159179688,
-0.20386694371700287,
0.046411801129579544,
0.8305025696754456,
0.6081389784812927,
0.7298649549484253,
-0.033501677215099335,
1.0975481271743774,
-0.10988270491361618,
-0.24281059205532074,
0.9109249711036682,
-0.1419430822134018,
0.5683586597442627,
0.32423070073127747,
-0.04315601661801338,
0.9083205461502075,
-0.10664645582437515,
-0.2242598533630371,
0.12982037663459778,
0.004287194926291704,
0.015283549204468727,
-0.12531310319900513,
0.17627152800559998,
-0.030338646844029427,
0.7775664329528809,
0.05779028683900833,
-0.32071954011917114,
-0.19522356986999512,
-0.2553064525127411,
-0.11410024017095566,
-0.03401854261755943,
-0.2611352205276489,
0.9341767430305481,
-0.018285516649484634,
-0.40919023752212524,
0.6372091770172119,
-0.14428699016571045,
0.7937424778938293,
-0.5523490309715271,
-0.09099096804857254,
-0.27908265590667725,
0.16565440595149994,
-0.5747953653335571,
-0.7310671806335449,
0.48431864380836487,
-0.05639071762561798,
-0.5130342841148376,
-0.5076600313186646,
0.812882661819458,
-0.2357492595911026,
-0.5271922945976257,
0.31222009658813477,
0.44519785046577454,
-0.11458302289247513,
-0.5353153347969055,
-0.6061137318611145,
0.15067343413829803,
-0.599717378616333,
-0.5218320488929749,
-0.15426835417747498,
0.5465511679649353,
0.009426764212548733,
0.6355264186859131,
0.5475257635116577,
0.11960234493017197,
0.2824020981788635,
0.7470496892929077,
1.0563218593597412,
-0.7266849279403687,
-0.3191123306751251,
-0.6261857748031616,
0.6938847303390503,
-0.42209291458129883,
-0.10155756771564484,
0.6682286262512207,
0.6178135275840759,
0.5465499758720398,
0.09923455119132996,
0.4137466549873352,
0.07283658534288406,
0.09602738916873932,
-0.3206532895565033,
0.8363050222396851,
-0.54124915599823,
0.2664136588573456,
-0.1889067143201828,
-1.1353864669799805,
-0.2959885895252228,
0.24972377717494965,
-0.34720295667648315,
0.19825518131256104,
0.5918957591056824,
0.8060690760612488,
-0.5811291933059692,
0.1419907510280609,
0.32104015350341797,
0.5549950003623962,
0.40760520100593567,
0.45322927832603455,
0.724456787109375,
-0.7058252096176147,
0.6574308276176453,
-0.40144824981689453,
-0.5372999906539917,
0.08589979261159897,
-0.7306075692176819,
-0.6608639359474182,
-0.3381136953830719,
-0.173994243144989,
0.049052197486162186,
-0.47096049785614014,
0.4079122841358185,
0.9164015650749207,
-0.7910978198051453,
-0.2887747883796692,
-0.11935064196586609,
0.26974770426750183,
-0.4719829857349396,
-0.2641300559043884,
0.05692535638809204,
-0.2974661588668823,
-0.5217305421829224,
0.4551936388015747,
0.4594023823738098,
0.04428364709019661,
-0.3085377812385559,
-0.01814344711601734,
0.47283443808555603,
0.21303106844425201,
0.7550613284111023,
-0.2562899589538574,
-0.2809525728225708,
0.005661201663315296,
-0.01609772816300392,
-0.01957911066710949,
0.22197167575359344,
1.0040241479873657,
-0.9251747727394104,
0.4265083968639374,
0.7744388580322266,
0.737479031085968,
0.6219804883003235,
0.12213878333568573,
0.6582309603691101,
-0.5786269307136536,
0.30020028352737427,
0.3305378556251526,
0.3887970447540283,
0.42645812034606934,
-0.5659347772598267,
0.16770723462104797,
-0.07586175203323364,
-0.14842067658901215,
-0.5795953869819641,
0.1965099424123764,
-1.139845848083496,
-0.2671040892601013,
0.642437219619751,
0.5266945362091064,
-0.4453028440475464,
-0.03574679046869278,
-0.004865835886448622,
0.12969422340393066,
-0.40456917881965637,
0.8750400543212891,
0.2599036991596222,
-0.07855487614870071,
-0.4308627247810364,
-0.3882913589477539,
0.37453266978263855,
0.3775154948234558,
-0.6575854420661926,
-0.13731445372104645,
0.12141352146863937,
0.2879563570022583,
0.34593871235847473,
0.5342348217964172,
-0.34826046228408813,
0.3727628290653229,
0.13044233620166779,
-0.1800149530172348,
-0.2691965401172638,
-0.49977385997772217,
-0.45816513895988464,
0.4340778589248657,
-0.2891109585762024,
0.338420033454895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02619v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02619v7 | Increasing Trust in Language Models through the Reuse of Verified Circuits | 2024-02-04T21:33:18 | 2024-06-16T22:09:57 | Philip Quirke, Clement Neo, Fazl Barez | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Language Models (LMs) are increasingly used for a wide range of prediction
tasks, but their training can often neglect rare edge cases, reducing their
reliability. Here, we define a stringent standard of trustworthiness whereby
the task algorithm and circuit implementation must be verified, accounting for
edge cases, with no known failure modes. We show that a model can be trained to
meet this standard if built using mathematically and logically specified
frameworks. In this paper, we fully verify an auto-regressive transformer model
for n-digit integer addition. To exhibit the reusability of verified modules,
we insert the trained integer addition model into a larger untrained model and
train the combined model to perform both addition and subtraction. We find
extensive reuse of the addition circuits for both tasks, easing verification of
the more complex subtractor model. We discuss how inserting verified task
modules into LMs can leverage model reuse to improve verifiability and
trustworthiness of language models built using them. The reuse of verified
circuits reduces the effort to verify more complex composite models which we
believe to be a significant step towards safety of language models. | [
-0.2462559938430786,
-0.4090118408203125,
0.555327296257019,
0.08555329591035843,
0.0019466141238808632,
0.11483926326036453,
-0.02621796913444996,
-0.39836856722831726,
-0.34289154410362244,
0.663554310798645,
-0.18698033690452576,
-0.19438566267490387,
-0.7136515974998474,
-0.06462346762418747,
-0.9385013580322266,
0.7138173580169678,
-0.34432274103164673,
-0.09947533160448074,
-0.43299156427383423,
-0.17145484685897827,
-0.2355078011751175,
-0.7075826525688171,
-0.5173243284225464,
-0.8675439953804016,
0.23397816717624664,
0.08062040060758591,
0.9365456700325012,
0.4826885163784027,
0.5462912321090698,
0.42808371782302856,
0.05347128584980965,
0.2241600751876831,
-0.054322484880685806,
0.052139438688755035,
-0.3285844326019287,
-0.6473785638809204,
-0.6831823587417603,
0.0566890612244606,
0.5026466250419617,
0.43786299228668213,
-0.2996974289417267,
0.2205401510000229,
-0.18383030593395233,
0.24413378536701202,
-0.4710509479045868,
0.2326861172914505,
-0.7675718069076538,
-0.14717499911785126,
0.32045435905456543,
-0.08160988241434097,
-0.8417198061943054,
-0.6219252943992615,
-0.062399107962846756,
-0.3588632047176361,
-0.03217692673206329,
-0.050562236458063126,
0.9003481864929199,
0.21737737953662872,
-0.516539454460144,
-0.12092398852109909,
-0.8680189847946167,
0.7926667928695679,
-0.5589122176170349,
0.9159271121025085,
0.390970379114151,
0.25772008299827576,
-0.05086925998330116,
-1.0373693704605103,
-0.5942046642303467,
-0.50185227394104,
-0.2783966660499573,
-0.33945733308792114,
-0.3181338906288147,
0.03220473229885101,
0.4246963560581207,
0.42444005608558655,
-0.13021577894687653,
-0.09273829311132431,
-0.28480303287506104,
-0.5002580881118774,
0.45348337292671204,
0.06269823014736176,
0.5854734182357788,
0.03872263431549072,
-0.20080171525478363,
-0.07454333454370499,
-1.0110892057418823,
0.12441900372505188,
0.3315373659133911,
0.07009759545326233,
-0.021554799750447273,
0.5253116488456726,
-0.05522875860333443,
0.5090805292129517,
0.017719825729727745,
-0.20868951082229614,
0.30098679661750793,
-0.3016485571861267,
-0.2775862514972687,
-0.2846006751060486,
0.646382749080658,
0.2386016845703125,
0.7608386278152466,
-0.177467480301857,
-0.5153660774230957,
0.16051073372364044,
0.5672637224197388,
-0.5705289840698242,
-0.4242252707481384,
-0.018981799483299255,
-0.2980572581291199,
-0.415298193693161,
-0.22281698882579803,
0.13784943521022797,
0.02279168926179409,
-0.35227444767951965,
0.48741936683654785,
-0.6211047768592834,
-0.3705466389656067,
0.16433998942375183,
0.13786107301712036,
0.16564282774925232,
0.25231048464775085,
-0.7348256707191467,
0.42038771510124207,
0.9546324014663696,
0.6837394833564758,
0.19951948523521423,
-0.5462794899940491,
-0.45096316933631897,
-0.13034756481647491,
-0.4698357582092285,
0.5047670006752014,
-0.3741949200630188,
-0.28114834427833557,
0.1735277622938156,
0.3669466972351074,
-0.08802846074104309,
-0.38814494013786316,
0.6766415238380432,
-0.8020812273025513,
0.14411593973636627,
0.09898117184638977,
-0.5686776638031006,
-0.0937829241156578,
0.3609118163585663,
-0.6253403425216675,
1.136260747909546,
0.24024750292301178,
-0.48923802375793457,
0.17190007865428925,
-0.2590216100215912,
-0.7305501699447632,
-0.287971168756485,
-0.040234263986349106,
-0.5101273655891418,
0.34288033843040466,
0.1206471249461174,
0.22136354446411133,
-0.06913231313228607,
0.5364230275154114,
-0.2974563539028168,
-0.3909382224082947,
0.5016584396362305,
-0.6548888087272644,
0.9703919291496277,
-0.010969064198434353,
-0.2577509582042694,
0.010206407867372036,
-0.7268400192260742,
0.23187772929668427,
-0.2104445844888687,
-0.2645869255065918,
-0.2982037365436554,
-0.10698775202035904,
-0.12263175845146179,
0.2340313047170639,
0.24143730103969574,
-0.6885631084442139,
-0.20153656601905823,
-0.5082122683525085,
0.5233138203620911,
0.6505530476570129,
-0.04334823787212372,
0.37003055214881897,
-0.3804015517234802,
0.255280077457428,
-0.04005745053291321,
0.2575003206729889,
-0.2857084572315216,
-0.3665885031223297,
-1.0671182870864868,
0.06536093354225159,
0.36632123589515686,
0.5441859364509583,
-0.8305931091308594,
0.5786362290382385,
-0.23633979260921478,
-0.6899438500404358,
-0.29636529088020325,
0.07987795025110245,
0.30655282735824585,
0.4821397066116333,
0.3356953263282776,
-0.2432296723127365,
-0.3593769669532776,
-1.0048173666000366,
-0.2982670068740845,
-0.4003133177757263,
-0.13858990371227264,
0.053506333380937576,
0.5257534384727478,
-0.28868985176086426,
0.9438464045524597,
-0.18961289525032043,
0.3530218303203583,
-0.21740944683551788,
0.14399021863937378,
0.19322757422924042,
0.8103598356246948,
0.2452738881111145,
-0.5028520822525024,
-0.3820470869541168,
-0.04150913283228874,
-0.7320892810821533,
0.09842916578054428,
-0.19444942474365234,
0.20696981251239777,
0.2461007684469223,
0.5199344158172607,
-0.5910932421684265,
0.472871869802475,
0.555492103099823,
-0.10250455141067505,
0.3769438862800598,
-0.39747560024261475,
0.3051195442676544,
-0.8140107989311218,
-0.07854901999235153,
-0.08269597589969635,
-0.6992880702018738,
-0.586398720741272,
0.250842422246933,
0.32444947957992554,
0.0051368046551942825,
-0.26730769872665405,
0.38332125544548035,
-0.10185091942548752,
0.04611828178167343,
-0.4353378713130951,
-0.043066371232271194,
0.1884450912475586,
0.28163212537765503,
0.10416882485151291,
0.6137546896934509,
0.6877291202545166,
-0.5557782649993896,
0.33669930696487427,
-0.05146076902747154,
-0.6089746356010437,
0.5606865286827087,
-1.0030272006988525,
0.18923096358776093,
0.08606111258268356,
0.020306572318077087,
-0.9176167249679565,
0.2537253201007843,
0.03027937188744545,
-0.43937623500823975,
0.24648594856262207,
-0.15284296870231628,
-0.6783469915390015,
-0.14630265533924103,
0.22858011722564697,
0.3769385814666748,
0.6920163631439209,
-0.7205718755722046,
0.9341527223587036,
0.2842640280723572,
0.05122624710202217,
-0.48139727115631104,
-0.7547315955162048,
-0.07802323997020721,
0.15282857418060303,
-0.743610143661499,
0.214751735329628,
0.18272081017494202,
-0.30980217456817627,
-0.010813272558152676,
-0.3427392840385437,
-0.357050359249115,
0.4667731523513794,
0.3889769911766052,
0.35264384746551514,
-0.05391401797533035,
0.15755970776081085,
0.0903414860367775,
-0.5443572402000427,
0.42423948645591736,
-0.08131406456232071,
0.34256529808044434,
-0.14279966056346893,
-0.7835204005241394,
-0.6766819357872009,
0.3659054636955261,
0.8312499523162842,
-0.35964828729629517,
0.5055767893791199,
0.48185285925865173,
-0.7969815135002136,
-0.17316043376922607,
-0.7201223969459534,
-0.37807196378707886,
-0.56783527135849,
0.3973469138145447,
-0.4725821912288666,
-1.0795031785964966,
0.5306349396705627,
-0.06789854168891907,
0.3564251959323883,
0.4924226403236389,
0.5445857048034668,
0.062299106270074844,
0.8287436366081238,
0.8405016660690308,
-0.006759996060281992,
0.2287350594997406,
0.25435301661491394,
0.6555464863777161,
-0.5000486969947815,
-0.19585096836090088,
-0.5457773208618164,
0.07911791652441025,
-0.5395858287811279,
-0.5913244485855103,
-0.06843124330043793,
-0.1451023668050766,
-0.28813427686691284,
0.6574586629867554,
-0.3717420995235443,
0.5635120272636414,
0.5017285943031311,
0.1122945100069046,
0.6190420985221863,
-0.08129487186670303,
-0.10559623688459396,
0.05203285068273544,
-0.4471384584903717,
-0.6199367046356201,
0.9821294546127319,
0.8211660385131836,
0.9078685641288757,
-0.08345097303390503,
0.7901734709739685,
0.2182736098766327,
0.7111589312553406,
-0.6029061675071716,
0.5010513663291931,
-0.1963232010602951,
-0.8222386837005615,
-0.152375727891922,
-0.5143265724182129,
-0.2278473973274231,
-0.11754930764436722,
0.13882753252983093,
-0.8218395709991455,
0.26051491498947144,
0.3228432238101959,
-0.4531327188014984,
0.34122735261917114,
-0.6800641417503357,
0.6342507004737854,
-0.17974518239498138,
-0.19602593779563904,
-0.3923147916793823,
-0.22773952782154083,
0.47251561284065247,
0.1353072226047516,
0.15359073877334595,
0.16652315855026245,
0.29026150703430176,
0.5725330114364624,
-0.5855632424354553,
0.8258597254753113,
0.07836417108774185,
-0.3842056393623352,
0.5954649448394775,
0.47373610734939575,
0.8689447641372681,
0.12553706765174866,
0.09928565472364426,
0.06403475254774094,
0.058947257697582245,
0.1049969494342804,
-0.7679661512374878,
0.8956464529037476,
-0.8382716774940491,
-0.688279390335083,
-0.36593925952911377,
-0.47625303268432617,
-0.3402496576309204,
0.16968224942684174,
0.03525010123848915,
0.6004823446273804,
0.13793520629405975,
0.3779229521751404,
0.9052116870880127,
0.0780487209558487,
0.3339511454105377,
0.11671674251556396,
-0.24508652091026306,
-0.35266050696372986,
0.8503954410552979,
0.03694659844040871,
0.5810667276382446,
0.304931640625,
-0.13236279785633087,
-0.17889854311943054,
-0.3375161290168762,
-0.10748335719108582,
-0.05404997617006302,
-0.8518621325492859,
-0.07562823593616486,
-0.6503578424453735,
-0.596627950668335,
-0.1522277295589447,
-0.10261930525302887,
-0.9008543491363525,
-0.66343754529953,
0.128646582365036,
-0.41429322957992554,
0.3220921456813812,
0.5897114276885986,
-0.0596369169652462,
0.41747474670410156,
-0.8793727159500122,
0.1195710077881813,
0.4876118302345276,
0.8186250925064087,
0.03213426470756531,
-0.7558742165565491,
-0.37282487750053406,
-0.20027372241020203,
-0.014536713249981403,
-0.6273707151412964,
0.014412718825042248,
-0.11057828366756439,
0.7663124799728394,
-0.04802354797720909,
-0.35100609064102173,
0.3874189257621765,
-0.559122622013092,
0.5365480780601501,
0.1077290028333664,
-1.4073865413665771,
0.10130785405635834,
-0.08283736556768417,
0.05858224257826805,
0.5107023119926453,
0.3325282037258148,
-0.5078636407852173,
-0.4181133508682251,
-0.8215662837028503,
-0.5487779974937439,
0.26650485396385193,
0.2053530216217041,
0.28926098346710205,
0.15336959064006805,
0.4907447099685669,
-0.10871769487857819,
0.053737323731184006,
-0.9721731543540955,
-0.3759249746799469,
-0.47200846672058105,
-0.192242830991745,
0.20678648352622986,
-0.48996564745903015,
-0.14791148900985718,
-0.05524712800979614,
0.7742086052894592,
0.08109763264656067,
0.11792441457509995,
0.05715790390968323,
-0.29155686497688293,
0.08269523829221725,
0.36824050545692444,
0.2581608295440674,
0.691038191318512,
-0.09645280241966248,
0.41389745473861694,
0.265230655670166,
-0.3957739472389221,
0.4077800512313843,
-0.22241124510765076,
-0.12040933221578598,
0.1693858653306961,
0.39479559659957886,
0.4106346666812897,
0.29376021027565,
-0.38963237404823303,
0.20667853951454163,
-0.21043069660663605,
-0.2574901282787323,
-0.46173155307769775,
0.07069554179906845,
0.3439308702945709,
0.12020084261894226,
0.09471084177494049,
0.29464924335479736,
-0.04545431584119797,
-0.3220697045326233,
0.8616018295288086,
0.19268657267093658,
-0.7057381272315979,
-0.22718989849090576,
0.2157420963048935,
0.2603534758090973,
-0.5483499765396118,
0.6837401986122131,
-0.18437500298023224,
-0.6359707117080688,
0.4555162787437439,
0.5999235510826111,
0.8636394739151001,
-0.3538092076778412,
0.16859303414821625,
0.5299487709999084,
1.0963369607925415,
-0.27521252632141113,
0.1402323842048645,
0.22442442178726196,
-0.9582971334457397,
-0.5511907935142517,
-0.2212587594985962,
-0.5167570114135742,
-0.10699564963579178,
-0.6039605736732483,
0.18030104041099548,
-0.657717227935791,
-0.33010974526405334,
-0.3716025650501251,
-0.36676400899887085,
-0.5647603869438171,
0.40486666560173035,
0.01951482519507408,
1.0733609199523926,
-1.0180919170379639,
1.012364387512207,
0.31808891892433167,
0.052283380180597305,
-0.9549790620803833,
-0.4269101917743683,
-0.23311811685562134,
-0.8976588845252991,
0.6073276996612549,
-0.017608271911740303,
-0.32452577352523804,
-0.32258519530296326,
-0.20113436877727509,
-0.8799580931663513,
0.9328896403312683,
0.19287404417991638,
-0.6051104664802551,
0.19065983593463898,
0.09944111853837967,
0.4306063652038574,
-0.4193617105484009,
0.45287075638771057,
0.45556706190109253,
0.193006232380867,
0.09985150396823883,
-0.9623750448226929,
0.36520564556121826,
-0.2479981780052185,
-0.1504126340150833,
0.14136464893817902,
-0.3889930546283722,
1.133069634437561,
-0.14352235198020935,
-0.2891632914543152,
-0.011181329376995564,
0.7114227414131165,
0.3688947260379791,
-0.019844498485326767,
0.7613455653190613,
0.47972121834754944,
0.7523298263549805,
-0.16967348754405975,
0.809453547000885,
-0.5649567246437073,
0.5464529395103455,
1.4260417222976685,
-0.1871005743741989,
0.8038275837898254,
0.5175370573997498,
-0.11827623844146729,
0.7350701093673706,
0.20301584899425507,
-0.0131179578602314,
0.13767515122890472,
0.12506753206253052,
-0.011786052957177162,
-0.9218273758888245,
-0.13556529581546783,
-0.3437037765979767,
0.326576292514801,
0.21996478736400604,
-0.6011847257614136,
-0.2802993357181549,
-0.3368208706378937,
0.16642342507839203,
0.020105786621570587,
-0.04872020706534386,
0.19786927103996277,
0.2532711923122406,
-0.5844292640686035,
0.20029260218143463,
0.08596884459257126,
0.3821941912174225,
-0.4524628520011902,
0.07597565650939941,
-0.1531907469034195,
0.3758966624736786,
-0.31557250022888184,
-0.5851025581359863,
0.5285173654556274,
-0.08924960345029831,
-0.2600346803665161,
-0.36983656883239746,
0.8742530941963196,
-0.27633100748062134,
-0.9445029497146606,
0.13378775119781494,
0.6267217397689819,
-0.3879200518131256,
0.022754667326807976,
-0.3410457372665405,
0.1465955525636673,
0.09159262478351593,
-0.25055596232414246,
0.23327335715293884,
0.3269927501678467,
-0.037790533155202866,
0.9911048412322998,
0.6435946822166443,
-0.11980753391981125,
-0.08344320207834244,
0.2258419543504715,
0.8080493211746216,
-0.4833037555217743,
-0.3105398714542389,
-1.001827359199524,
0.7208567261695862,
-0.18098294734954834,
-0.086248978972435,
0.8301503658294678,
0.32139599323272705,
0.8202630281448364,
0.10640494525432587,
0.866916298866272,
0.16955821216106415,
0.25009337067604065,
-0.2651778757572174,
0.7942665219306946,
-0.23184354603290558,
0.38469794392585754,
0.09956496208906174,
-0.6004565954208374,
-0.32610324025154114,
0.785731315612793,
-0.2332497239112854,
0.2275446504354477,
0.8574655652046204,
0.8790292739868164,
-0.059764496982097626,
0.1991899013519287,
0.2603040039539337,
0.054893624037504196,
0.6105973124504089,
0.610467791557312,
0.9311733841896057,
-0.7059259414672852,
0.5127657055854797,
-0.574518620967865,
-0.38793545961380005,
0.2248232066631317,
-1.0310542583465576,
-1.0190261602401733,
-0.49674472212791443,
-0.6856479048728943,
-0.45580989122390747,
-0.2149055451154709,
0.7447295188903809,
0.5077027082443237,
-0.8292266130447388,
-0.32447364926338196,
-0.036443568766117096,
0.6143999099731445,
-0.26733800768852234,
-0.14827752113342285,
0.09135375916957855,
-0.2504778504371643,
-0.49563953280448914,
0.28890320658683777,
0.2889738380908966,
0.09620169550180435,
-0.5492997169494629,
0.1360112428665161,
0.0026101742405444384,
0.19005604088306427,
0.40615376830101013,
0.059716470539569855,
-0.617886483669281,
-0.7270718216896057,
0.33697575330734253,
-0.07682016491889954,
-0.1760343611240387,
0.965179979801178,
-0.7065622210502625,
0.24725288152694702,
0.595288097858429,
0.5563210844993591,
0.0732588991522789,
-0.24966883659362793,
1.0426878929138184,
-0.4042869806289673,
-0.34455716609954834,
-0.02666011080145836,
0.8074976205825806,
0.38912323117256165,
-0.21022114157676697,
0.25221550464630127,
0.051783494651317596,
-0.5650978088378906,
-1.0481945276260376,
0.510594367980957,
-0.6084160804748535,
0.21968215703964233,
0.8452837467193604,
-0.6241675615310669,
-0.21847450733184814,
-0.23466794192790985,
0.2582506537437439,
0.05905841663479805,
-0.1553441882133484,
0.8829107284545898,
0.835209310054779,
0.1328870803117752,
-0.30493736267089844,
-0.14357945322990417,
0.4441612660884857,
0.4305724799633026,
-0.7170491218566895,
0.3173716068267822,
-0.023774543777108192,
0.5742112994194031,
0.5769433379173279,
0.32519543170928955,
-0.32530689239501953,
0.3981736898422241,
0.19585020840168,
0.04411989077925682,
-0.45977312326431274,
-0.5623587965965271,
-0.13381606340408325,
0.2737126350402832,
0.25827494263648987,
-0.01292139571160078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02617v1 | Layer-Wise Analysis of Self-Supervised Acoustic Word Embeddings: A Study on Speech Emotion Recognition | 2024-02-04T21:24:54 | 2024-02-04T21:24:54 | Alexandra Saliba, Yuanchao Li, Ramon Sanabria, Catherine Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The efficacy of self-supervised speech models has been validated, yet the
optimal utilization of their representations remains challenging across diverse
tasks. In this study, we delve into Acoustic Word Embeddings (AWEs), a
fixed-length feature derived from continuous representations, to explore their
advantages in specific tasks. AWEs have previously shown utility in capturing
acoustic discriminability. In light of this, we propose measuring layer-wise
similarity between AWEs and word embeddings, aiming to further investigate the
inherent context within AWEs. Moreover, we evaluate the contribution of AWEs,
in comparison to other types of speech features, in the context of Speech
Emotion Recognition (SER). Through a comparative experiment and a layer-wise
accuracy analysis on two distinct corpora, IEMOCAP and ESD, we explore
differences between AWEs and raw self-supervised representations, as well as
the proper utilization of AWEs alone and in combination with word embeddings.
Our findings underscore the acoustic context conveyed by AWEs and showcase the
highly competitive SER accuracies by appropriately employing AWEs. | [
-0.4066862165927887,
-0.5090851783752441,
0.429970383644104,
0.3098333179950714,
-0.2055971473455429,
-0.021375952288508415,
-0.01172629464417696,
-0.5594547390937805,
0.5537781119346619,
0.35529330372810364,
-0.21520720422267914,
-0.6468349695205688,
-0.4905346632003784,
0.11383026093244553,
-0.5403382182121277,
0.5632534027099609,
-0.21824906766414642,
-0.215307354927063,
-0.5160358548164368,
-0.5448919534683228,
-0.15285003185272217,
-0.5803917646408081,
-0.5527698397636414,
-0.1420658379793167,
0.5212132334709167,
0.057129137217998505,
0.26986098289489746,
0.6471494436264038,
0.1296459585428238,
0.33924582600593567,
-0.06363087147474289,
0.04785079136490822,
-0.15884721279144287,
0.3422311544418335,
0.4060346186161041,
-0.07814006507396698,
-0.18839968740940094,
0.19657383859157562,
0.5092207789421082,
0.5140923261642456,
-0.31900113821029663,
-0.06542114913463593,
0.31920117139816284,
0.564251184463501,
-0.6585938930511475,
0.13487392663955688,
-0.24575799703598022,
0.7199099063873291,
-0.14164096117019653,
-0.13348810374736786,
0.00020328939717728645,
-0.14327922463417053,
0.6057913899421692,
-0.2882385849952698,
-0.028365327045321465,
0.07036534696817398,
0.16713397204875946,
0.29809167981147766,
-0.3737039864063263,
-0.6417044401168823,
-0.49975118041038513,
0.558032751083374,
-0.7070338726043701,
0.6627083420753479,
0.2430330216884613,
0.01653454266488552,
0.2758846580982208,
-0.5409497022628784,
-0.5125172138214111,
-0.285334974527359,
0.004010718781501055,
0.41511163115501404,
-0.4987971782684326,
0.43767836689949036,
0.04198914393782616,
0.607921838760376,
-0.3188210129737854,
0.3610570728778839,
0.0427674874663353,
-0.36337044835090637,
0.543903648853302,
-0.1567985564470291,
0.3076169192790985,
-0.08849228173494339,
-0.4520409107208252,
-0.24986279010772705,
-0.23788897693157196,
0.2841807007789612,
0.43395137786865234,
0.2879168391227722,
-0.38926926255226135,
0.42229822278022766,
0.07950379699468613,
0.15082374215126038,
-0.13723567128181458,
-0.14697377383708954,
0.47418412566185,
0.46153971552848816,
-0.17711135745048523,
0.5325469374656677,
0.7078661918640137,
0.11635283380746841,
0.12854240834712982,
-0.29646897315979004,
-0.32230472564697266,
0.07391630113124847,
0.3577679693698883,
-0.41248461604118347,
-0.011619370430707932,
0.4420051574707031,
-0.4289085566997528,
-0.1775854080915451,
-0.08742847293615341,
-0.5894428491592407,
-0.2762155830860138,
-0.2748339772224426,
0.45887428522109985,
-0.35353100299835205,
-0.28554803133010864,
0.09221361577510834,
-0.3014453947544098,
-0.03941689804196358,
-0.18815967440605164,
-0.7263897061347961,
0.4308740198612213,
0.5110811591148376,
1.0304831266403198,
-0.035228606313467026,
-0.23181912302970886,
-0.4516799747943878,
0.016785282641649246,
-0.4114328920841217,
0.5015797019004822,
-0.6324687600135803,
-0.7634431719779968,
0.25318825244903564,
-0.442518413066864,
-0.11782369017601013,
-0.4973546266555786,
0.684039831161499,
-0.15314514935016632,
0.19983185827732086,
-0.2609289288520813,
-1.016177773475647,
-0.1680160015821457,
-0.035172153264284134,
-0.5578782558441162,
1.0401443243026733,
0.002416830975562334,
-0.6968056559562683,
0.05875701457262039,
-0.5750568509101868,
-0.41439396142959595,
-0.12226548045873642,
-0.285942018032074,
-0.557745099067688,
0.5340180993080139,
0.05661774426698685,
0.6974553465843201,
0.27610135078430176,
-0.3222278952598572,
-0.5005107522010803,
-0.1615559458732605,
0.11091833561658859,
-0.3172833025455475,
0.22204044461250305,
0.2997415065765381,
-0.5387522578239441,
-0.2661019265651703,
-0.6911738514900208,
-0.09831161797046661,
-0.05903370678424835,
0.005763526540249586,
-0.740108847618103,
0.06925474107265472,
-0.19407065212726593,
-0.03139074519276619,
0.14204615354537964,
-0.8402537703514099,
-0.11775758862495422,
-0.15409141778945923,
0.4321642816066742,
0.6413799524307251,
-0.10383012145757675,
0.20549266040325165,
0.14795446395874023,
0.4900616407394409,
0.13570508360862732,
-0.1320682168006897,
-0.019400056451559067,
-0.17363137006759644,
-0.3982629179954529,
-0.5106765627861023,
0.3579157590866089,
0.403360515832901,
-0.3368423879146576,
0.5713456869125366,
0.20389775931835175,
-0.45954418182373047,
-0.8193827867507935,
-0.05305802449584007,
0.6046464443206787,
0.686849057674408,
0.5395118594169617,
-0.5190036296844482,
-0.40114402770996094,
-0.9849697947502136,
-0.16862742602825165,
-0.169580340385437,
-0.1218213438987732,
0.570050060749054,
0.12391111999750137,
-0.285945326089859,
0.8530455827713013,
-0.25577762722969055,
-0.5287173986434937,
0.16542482376098633,
0.6315380334854126,
-0.32739055156707764,
0.37881967425346375,
0.7764511108398438,
-0.5914829969406128,
-0.23121021687984467,
-0.17847131192684174,
-0.9649315476417542,
-0.4645982086658478,
0.0671972706913948,
0.2857569456100464,
0.17647084593772888,
0.4822469651699066,
-0.19219550490379333,
0.4085412323474884,
0.8009418249130249,
-0.15231189131736755,
0.5553882718086243,
-0.3752029538154602,
0.1464146077632904,
-0.452108770608902,
-0.28109538555145264,
0.35750895738601685,
-0.1447906643152237,
-0.7045238018035889,
-0.21760194003582,
0.04784347489476204,
-0.036074988543987274,
-0.3997441530227661,
0.21847480535507202,
-0.5935549139976501,
-0.44564032554626465,
-0.3381030261516571,
0.41844311356544495,
-0.046906936913728714,
0.3473874628543854,
0.18426479399204254,
0.6818408966064453,
0.8124493360519409,
-0.40136682987213135,
0.3330148160457611,
0.019292036071419716,
-0.30289897322654724,
0.7940114140510559,
-0.7256026864051819,
0.49603271484375,
0.014622194692492485,
0.19971440732479095,
-0.8447813987731934,
0.22015517950057983,
-0.30190330743789673,
-0.16679438948631287,
0.3331694006919861,
0.09543029218912125,
-0.2922094762325287,
-0.38576290011405945,
-0.2953502833843231,
0.2831774652004242,
0.6089395880699158,
-0.6092736124992371,
0.707149088382721,
0.7632305026054382,
-0.22392965853214264,
-0.3801176846027374,
-0.7041327357292175,
-0.01570890098810196,
-0.6448557376861572,
-0.442935049533844,
0.5755271315574646,
0.1512308269739151,
-0.06509000062942505,
0.14269091188907623,
-0.3441832661628723,
0.1993054300546646,
0.09358035773038864,
0.3627449572086334,
-0.2475283443927765,
-0.30985796451568604,
0.26740726828575134,
0.1268848180770874,
0.016345364972949028,
0.24319688975811005,
-0.2634567618370056,
0.20006191730499268,
-0.3897048532962799,
-0.4100162386894226,
-0.46693187952041626,
0.6116316914558411,
0.39585092663764954,
-0.3456443250179291,
0.5070925354957581,
0.7281278371810913,
-0.39417019486427307,
-0.3401590585708618,
-0.7336316108703613,
0.16834355890750885,
-0.49743136763572693,
0.10809806734323502,
-0.4883153736591339,
-1.2531068325042725,
0.9038746356964111,
-0.13151410222053528,
-0.23520077764987946,
0.5399900078773499,
0.1409463733434677,
-0.6234874725341797,
1.1864383220672607,
0.6397292017936707,
-0.5746408104896545,
0.3860591948032379,
-0.30238786339759827,
0.049678921699523926,
-1.1670397520065308,
-0.3001675307750702,
-0.5741554498672485,
-0.3744873106479645,
-0.6245962381362915,
-0.001932906568981707,
0.4652528762817383,
-0.18878747522830963,
0.00919006485491991,
0.1330558955669403,
-0.3816412091255188,
0.1879892498254776,
0.31177273392677307,
-0.07955694943666458,
-0.38754552602767944,
-0.03968608006834984,
-0.34886667132377625,
0.006409076973795891,
-0.5076892971992493,
-0.203663632273674,
0.5274141430854797,
0.5727609992027283,
0.540310263633728,
-0.20169900357723236,
1.0528720617294312,
0.562265157699585,
-0.2410566210746765,
-0.7278830409049988,
0.25448229908943176,
-0.3987194299697876,
0.029699647799134254,
-0.3241502046585083,
-0.4924842417240143,
-0.795030951499939,
0.10569072514772415,
0.04646968096494675,
-0.8478956818580627,
0.45898494124412537,
0.17015132308006287,
-0.41736698150634766,
0.3044109046459198,
-0.6931937336921692,
0.7423512935638428,
-0.3389917314052582,
-0.07599397003650665,
-0.19809742271900177,
-0.4105606973171234,
-0.24775323271751404,
0.1503153294324875,
0.311607301235199,
0.005643832962960005,
0.0015573165146633983,
0.9079956412315369,
-0.3068249225616455,
0.7400317788124084,
-0.43495383858680725,
-0.39250728487968445,
0.48754727840423584,
0.11103646457195282,
0.16649965941905975,
-0.40841445326805115,
-0.06848771125078201,
0.3435787558555603,
-0.08442360162734985,
-0.11415918171405792,
-0.7059169411659241,
0.8144592642784119,
-0.6994523406028748,
-0.5296328663825989,
-0.3653653562068939,
-0.2930178940296173,
-0.43008002638816833,
-0.10530191659927368,
-0.022382602095603943,
0.9617863297462463,
-0.25711914896965027,
0.3743194341659546,
0.731157660484314,
-0.16362693905830383,
0.40681445598602295,
0.19909457862377167,
0.018565669655799866,
-0.08308026939630508,
0.9663701057434082,
0.37753137946128845,
0.062018100172281265,
0.1832415610551834,
0.47265639901161194,
-0.7022229433059692,
-0.46778199076652527,
-0.05915940925478935,
0.040905971080064774,
-0.5477916598320007,
0.027456682175397873,
-0.606739342212677,
-0.2319481521844864,
-0.4546508193016052,
-0.20400342345237732,
-0.587388813495636,
-0.2848108410835266,
-0.4318287968635559,
-0.38614559173583984,
0.37091967463493347,
0.6090680956840515,
-0.5521591901779175,
-0.0545722134411335,
-0.7329098582267761,
0.3572116792201996,
0.6765748858451843,
0.49442484974861145,
0.017569316551089287,
-0.5674711465835571,
-0.2581676244735718,
0.04118572175502777,
-0.08668297529220581,
-0.885351836681366,
0.45188117027282715,
0.6989914774894714,
0.7010887265205383,
0.6670612096786499,
0.22185997664928436,
0.7760050892829895,
-0.5125182867050171,
0.8836441040039062,
0.0013196924701333046,
-1.2688097953796387,
0.5477917194366455,
-0.08253999054431915,
0.060947973281145096,
0.48415520787239075,
0.5801178812980652,
-0.6925732493400574,
-0.5386138558387756,
-0.7668061256408691,
-0.9272372722625732,
0.25796443223953247,
0.3552684187889099,
0.42345181107521057,
-0.09960345923900604,
0.30462244153022766,
0.02166406251490116,
0.2317439466714859,
-0.32859787344932556,
-0.39899885654449463,
-0.46395567059516907,
-0.3384726047515869,
0.03589276969432831,
-0.3477764129638672,
-0.10651054233312607,
0.020265832543373108,
0.32015368342399597,
0.007027535233646631,
0.493012398481369,
0.6274397969245911,
-0.005294872913509607,
0.02122049406170845,
0.17550508677959442,
0.31388038396835327,
-0.08958478271961212,
-0.35595768690109253,
0.4834316670894623,
0.27915504574775696,
-0.4121093451976776,
-0.1594480276107788,
0.1212511658668518,
0.47315943241119385,
-0.024395477026700974,
0.47435471415519714,
0.9458502531051636,
0.3858572542667389,
-0.46686869859695435,
0.46238234639167786,
0.05879918113350868,
0.01154494658112526,
-0.3355117738246918,
0.042985089123249054,
0.058639075607061386,
0.45349404215812683,
0.328012079000473,
-0.32978102564811707,
0.6774126887321472,
-0.739920973777771,
0.24563245475292206,
0.41647425293922424,
-0.6315882802009583,
-0.25206777453422546,
0.42161324620246887,
0.30098453164100647,
-0.3131338357925415,
0.5335765480995178,
-0.18540383875370026,
-0.8406164646148682,
0.5945699214935303,
0.5435786247253418,
1.2188829183578491,
-0.5758418440818787,
0.02884204126894474,
0.008835190907120705,
-0.11057596653699875,
0.13516409695148468,
0.2734944522380829,
-0.4248053729534149,
-0.722935140132904,
0.10236304253339767,
-0.5011380910873413,
-0.6380278468132019,
-0.07518725097179413,
-1.0187833309173584,
-0.22104722261428833,
-0.2010357826948166,
-0.030794264748692513,
0.0071606882847845554,
-0.21948930621147156,
-0.567308247089386,
0.40336155891418457,
0.7353106737136841,
0.7544416785240173,
-0.7856089472770691,
0.5576985478401184,
0.3700401484966278,
0.011207710951566696,
-0.8270921111106873,
-0.196449875831604,
0.2762955129146576,
-0.6813215613365173,
0.18702752888202667,
0.38607409596443176,
-0.6391780972480774,
-0.007184029556810856,
-0.32249242067337036,
-0.527793824672699,
1.1454108953475952,
0.19628430902957916,
-0.600725531578064,
0.28115350008010864,
0.10430672764778137,
0.9187395572662354,
-0.6975090503692627,
0.19760435819625854,
0.6232272386550903,
0.11849378794431686,
-0.1544647216796875,
-0.8038697838783264,
-0.285472571849823,
-0.3293581008911133,
0.06339661031961441,
-0.13996388018131256,
-0.49429357051849365,
0.3874753713607788,
0.10814005136489868,
-0.36070749163627625,
-0.21510079503059387,
0.9634128212928772,
0.24531866610050201,
0.489175945520401,
0.8613302707672119,
0.8806649446487427,
0.7723890542984009,
-0.10900920629501343,
1.2373387813568115,
-0.20996923744678497,
0.2709690034389496,
0.779912531375885,
-0.2679482698440552,
0.9279400706291199,
0.05341175198554993,
-0.2861955463886261,
0.6891486644744873,
0.5207290053367615,
0.12490151077508926,
0.76703941822052,
0.2675052285194397,
-0.2686404883861542,
-0.023022709414362907,
-0.295422226190567,
-0.6080700755119324,
0.7309110760688782,
0.49113449454307556,
-0.27696096897125244,
0.2072407603263855,
0.32215210795402527,
-0.14655768871307373,
-0.023718561977148056,
-0.3391202390193939,
0.875555694103241,
0.5225481390953064,
-0.0959462895989418,
0.2409873753786087,
-0.3583900034427643,
0.7553640604019165,
-0.5907766222953796,
0.16699950397014618,
-0.1431477814912796,
-0.3521204888820648,
-0.21340858936309814,
-0.8290212154388428,
0.21944200992584229,
0.21620671451091766,
0.2264736443758011,
-0.3631780445575714,
0.7206989526748657,
-0.6889975666999817,
-0.237989604473114,
0.6991382837295532,
0.1531776487827301,
0.17033866047859192,
-0.16761532425880432,
-0.6186978220939636,
0.17011605203151703,
-0.3005025386810303,
-0.37466832995414734,
0.17892925441265106,
0.7221369743347168,
0.44137856364250183,
0.5328063368797302,
0.18890361487865448,
0.22304140031337738,
0.052860911935567856,
0.457947313785553,
0.6036475896835327,
-0.582872748374939,
-0.8502114415168762,
-0.6834224462509155,
0.5022069215774536,
-0.004750214051455259,
-0.2779141366481781,
0.8562151193618774,
0.4047306180000305,
0.6301441192626953,
0.14391310513019562,
0.6445396542549133,
0.21090862154960632,
0.45952650904655457,
-0.6812160015106201,
0.5384221076965332,
-0.8575694561004639,
0.13518425822257996,
-0.6653700470924377,
-0.6891070604324341,
-0.02406599558889866,
0.881803572177887,
-0.22503291070461273,
-0.01077184360474348,
0.501605749130249,
0.3850405812263489,
-0.11903837323188782,
0.42808595299720764,
0.3880510926246643,
0.2456650584936142,
-0.013689895160496235,
0.19502221047878265,
0.8675046563148499,
-0.08370325714349747,
-0.011557732708752155,
-0.5485771894454956,
-0.1277225762605667,
-0.16801315546035767,
-0.9981483221054077,
-0.4617704749107361,
-0.8867586255073547,
-0.5929508209228516,
0.1424756944179535,
-0.057572197169065475,
0.8129611611366272,
0.5487570762634277,
-0.7285977005958557,
-0.20735099911689758,
0.27023494243621826,
-0.18003788590431213,
-0.3095126748085022,
-0.16678160429000854,
0.6079045534133911,
-0.14297014474868774,
-0.45071110129356384,
0.7021071314811707,
0.4669741094112396,
0.20851704478263855,
-0.3759486675262451,
-0.02521919272840023,
0.30178481340408325,
0.27228501439094543,
0.6706030368804932,
0.3701764941215515,
-0.6001349687576294,
-0.8180142641067505,
-0.251384973526001,
-0.019019249826669693,
0.060584306716918945,
0.7146201133728027,
-0.6994125843048096,
0.6687083840370178,
0.3137018382549286,
0.7193953394889832,
0.445233017206192,
-0.09023575484752655,
0.3260593116283417,
-1.0928345918655396,
-0.0056442078202962875,
0.32048913836479187,
0.7465397715568542,
0.4310458302497864,
-0.28300634026527405,
0.39624130725860596,
-0.09113561362028122,
-0.5286979079246521,
-0.8330352902412415,
-0.038974713534116745,
-1.1792781352996826,
0.08264493197202682,
0.9190858006477356,
-0.5287074446678162,
0.025990163907408714,
0.16163447499275208,
-0.03841916844248772,
0.42197367548942566,
-0.43489089608192444,
1.0148003101348877,
0.5768872499465942,
-0.4994191527366638,
-0.20764251053333282,
-0.21955667436122894,
0.4278333783149719,
0.37358570098876953,
-0.5840539336204529,
-0.20457488298416138,
0.37668007612228394,
-0.05155257135629654,
0.4986158609390259,
0.3279377222061157,
-0.04356370493769646,
-0.03354845196008682,
0.027602514252066612,
-0.009647829458117485,
-0.15593360364437103,
-0.27705147862434387,
-0.6617072224617004,
0.3305349051952362,
-0.24741283059120178,
-0.292059987783432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02611v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02611v2 | PuzzleBench: Can LLMs Solve Challenging First-Order Combinatorial Reasoning Problems? | 2024-02-04T20:56:09 | 2024-02-22T14:42:45 | Chinmay Mittal, Krishna Kartik, Mausam, Parag Singla | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent works show that the largest of the large language models (LLMs) can
solve many simple reasoning tasks expressed in natural language, without
any/much supervision. But, can they also solve challenging first-order
combinatorial reasoning problems, such as graph coloring, knapsack and
cryptarithmetic? To answer this question, we present PuzzleBench, a dataset of
31 such challenging problems along with a few solved instances for each
problem. These problems are all first order, i.e., they can be instantiated
with problem instances of varying sizes, and most of them are NP-hard,
requiring several reasoning steps to reach the solution. We first observe that
LLMs, even when aided by symbolic solvers, perform rather poorly on our
dataset. In response, we propose a new approach, Puzzle-LM, which combines LLMs
with both symbolic solvers and program interpreters, along with feedback from
solved examples, to achieve huge performance gains. Our extensive
experimentation and analyses offer new insights into the reasoning abilities
and limitations of present-day LLMs. | [
-0.28729182481765747,
-0.7212051749229431,
0.7948710322380066,
0.27674371004104614,
-0.35362860560417175,
0.3778027296066284,
-0.0751396045088768,
-0.5105425715446472,
0.044828273355960846,
0.6320924758911133,
-0.9612261056900024,
-0.3280562460422516,
-0.8075934648513794,
0.3382396399974823,
-0.3809947371482849,
0.55696040391922,
-0.011784764006733894,
0.18492458760738373,
-0.47365716099739075,
-0.14469633996486664,
-0.3294125497341156,
-0.7034685015678406,
-0.536993682384491,
-0.4573539197444916,
0.5500078797340393,
0.32233649492263794,
0.5921295881271362,
0.6133687496185303,
0.5752820372581482,
0.3785465359687805,
-0.2952018082141876,
0.38458582758903503,
-0.7293103933334351,
0.18585222959518433,
-0.2115989327430725,
-0.867703378200531,
-0.08500687032938004,
-0.21099933981895447,
0.20103755593299866,
0.8828907012939453,
-0.08083735406398773,
0.06520797312259674,
-0.318227618932724,
0.6895126104354858,
-0.3348545432090759,
0.4246029853820801,
-0.7377279996871948,
0.24829192459583282,
-0.3693358600139618,
-0.09962517768144608,
-0.36122840642929077,
-0.2286641001701355,
-0.1710314005613327,
-0.6229190230369568,
-0.16899259388446808,
0.27413511276245117,
0.4132838845252991,
0.5926001071929932,
-0.3324962556362152,
-0.4654091000556946,
-0.8426275253295898,
0.846798300743103,
-0.6083897352218628,
0.241898313164711,
0.22717781364917755,
0.3625441789627075,
-0.7247610688209534,
-0.6544400453567505,
-0.30992820858955383,
-0.03400880843400955,
0.022367464378476143,
-0.12169187515974045,
-0.48213815689086914,
-0.1938651204109192,
0.6308141946792603,
0.18240097165107727,
-0.51764976978302,
0.15793906152248383,
-0.3420257568359375,
-0.08037654310464859,
0.7520419359207153,
0.6848394870758057,
0.16055791079998016,
-0.009873912669718266,
-0.09480173140764236,
-0.1450008898973465,
-0.7202427983283997,
-0.0748380497097969,
0.26083478331565857,
0.12710030376911163,
0.34296098351478577,
0.6276177763938904,
-0.13102170825004578,
0.673878014087677,
-0.3175600469112396,
-0.07748551666736603,
-0.16000919044017792,
-0.22404028475284576,
-0.013767899014055729,
0.020671213045716286,
0.5837002992630005,
0.003895278787240386,
0.27974918484687805,
-0.13976189494132996,
-0.17182357609272003,
0.11131884157657623,
-0.0436878465116024,
-0.6495975852012634,
-0.560958743095398,
0.2601240575313568,
-0.13179749250411987,
-0.17818273603916168,
-0.11358467489480972,
-0.441103994846344,
-0.6696910858154297,
-0.3109246790409088,
0.4272860288619995,
-0.35502758622169495,
-0.08691160380840302,
0.2475837767124176,
-0.08332480490207672,
0.13625136017799377,
0.49553292989730835,
-0.5100172162055969,
0.47143521904945374,
1.0276474952697754,
0.6332317590713501,
-0.17809812724590302,
-0.11895491182804108,
-0.5330473184585571,
-0.02874702587723732,
-0.3573324382305145,
0.6312925815582275,
-0.474192351102829,
-0.44025275111198425,
-0.3978569209575653,
-0.18865667283535004,
0.16056689620018005,
-0.7888438701629639,
0.29231372475624084,
-0.4456652104854584,
-0.014668960124254227,
-0.4715806841850281,
-0.701381266117096,
0.13821803033351898,
0.3600914776325226,
-0.6841363310813904,
0.9211112260818481,
0.027621788904070854,
-0.6452367901802063,
-0.21353155374526978,
-0.3600519597530365,
-0.4480685293674469,
0.1723886877298355,
-0.3794403374195099,
-0.20249348878860474,
0.3342423737049103,
0.09070463478565216,
0.13560009002685547,
-0.36340370774269104,
0.06186011806130409,
-0.3133503198623657,
-0.4367169141769409,
0.33038052916526794,
-0.06849947571754456,
0.9067237377166748,
0.26900622248649597,
-0.28173187375068665,
0.16541150212287903,
-0.6056343913078308,
0.29123973846435547,
0.6956346035003662,
-0.1295493245124817,
-0.10901609063148499,
0.27467891573905945,
-0.3122883439064026,
0.2097519487142563,
0.36508452892303467,
-0.37495389580726624,
0.4174102544784546,
-0.20886200666427612,
0.5973142981529236,
0.9820467829704285,
-0.19632509350776672,
0.018091540783643723,
-0.24379216134548187,
0.7144434452056885,
-0.0001533011527499184,
-0.021665887907147408,
-0.10337884724140167,
-0.6094739437103271,
-0.8435949683189392,
-0.06280574202537537,
0.3412582576274872,
0.7981517910957336,
-0.7001718878746033,
0.09441010653972626,
-0.23734502494335175,
-0.42309147119522095,
0.01503237709403038,
0.21151040494441986,
0.2920394837856293,
0.0007896855240687728,
0.17716115713119507,
-0.06247217208147049,
-0.6612196564674377,
-0.7979169487953186,
-0.24774889647960663,
-0.14486820995807648,
-0.07751686125993729,
0.37367573380470276,
0.6009359955787659,
0.042534664273262024,
0.8319273591041565,
-0.7194036245346069,
0.08316300809383392,
-0.3367607891559601,
0.23417584598064423,
0.4078185260295868,
0.2116689682006836,
0.10076992958784103,
-0.5091093182563782,
-0.23743325471878052,
-0.02128438837826252,
-0.6381189227104187,
-0.2958953082561493,
0.0351010337471962,
-0.11031318455934525,
0.17073345184326172,
0.6983060240745544,
-0.6000706553459167,
0.08227243274450302,
0.3105268180370331,
-0.20582157373428345,
0.6628598570823669,
-0.21056407690048218,
-0.5363094806671143,
-0.7673746943473816,
-0.22878210246562958,
-0.2756071090698242,
-0.14975668489933014,
-0.5047515630722046,
0.11089577525854111,
-0.3450191915035248,
-0.2043783962726593,
-0.17566384375095367,
0.5169456601142883,
-0.47149309515953064,
-0.07459673285484314,
-0.1984492391347885,
0.06353961676359177,
-0.19458945095539093,
0.4663386046886444,
-0.23316296935081482,
0.41259250044822693,
0.28816160559654236,
-0.2318277209997177,
0.5738459825515747,
0.2176375389099121,
-0.4722503125667572,
0.45294442772865295,
-0.5371904969215393,
0.39062240719795227,
-0.20604300498962402,
0.16865652799606323,
-0.7574346661567688,
-0.17448964715003967,
0.33615991473197937,
-0.12930329144001007,
0.14419293403625488,
0.061655063182115555,
-0.8466736674308777,
-0.5298833250999451,
-0.04368317127227783,
0.3104270100593567,
0.30710574984550476,
-0.4523845911026001,
0.44674113392829895,
0.06058724224567413,
-0.2948232591152191,
-0.470240980386734,
-0.5907062888145447,
0.20904284715652466,
-0.09475794434547424,
-0.6185832619667053,
0.28447476029396057,
-0.49340492486953735,
-0.42603158950805664,
0.06423027068376541,
-0.5655090808868408,
-0.06548837572336197,
0.3544408082962036,
0.035873282700777054,
-0.07725253701210022,
-0.08303805440664291,
-0.05552615597844124,
-0.28510475158691406,
-0.18992231786251068,
0.36740848422050476,
-0.06042685732245445,
0.6402613520622253,
-0.23405417799949646,
-0.7078010439872742,
0.14394809305667877,
0.5646202564239502,
0.4302803575992584,
-0.3411804735660553,
0.43068137764930725,
0.1262877732515335,
-0.4069457948207855,
-0.4292421042919159,
-0.4643482267856598,
-0.14252789318561554,
-0.5165382623672485,
0.46028101444244385,
-0.5581859350204468,
-1.0222188234329224,
0.4727188050746918,
-0.2450876086950302,
0.01240387000143528,
-0.06821563839912415,
0.5674928426742554,
-0.1294662058353424,
1.278112530708313,
0.34746429324150085,
-0.15214493870735168,
0.15955275297164917,
-0.1069631353020668,
0.4867488145828247,
-0.28123748302459717,
-0.2358262687921524,
-0.4256839454174042,
-0.5272297859191895,
-0.5449822545051575,
-0.4640556871891022,
0.48211631178855896,
0.44838544726371765,
-0.2008187174797058,
0.13138934969902039,
-0.4733486771583557,
0.9457929134368896,
0.7029355764389038,
0.13595326244831085,
0.49490365386009216,
-0.07013964653015137,
-0.20565977692604065,
0.11412111669778824,
-0.7629083395004272,
-0.31354913115501404,
0.9167187809944153,
-0.11334235221147537,
0.6231801509857178,
0.1704283058643341,
0.9262638092041016,
-0.10090680420398712,
0.06982935965061188,
-0.7439410090446472,
0.867151141166687,
-0.14658881723880768,
-0.6826868057250977,
-0.13532474637031555,
-0.567304790019989,
-1.1957931518554688,
0.29487344622612,
0.014423529617488384,
-1.1008585691452026,
-0.1888907551765442,
-0.0614907369017601,
-0.019243191927671432,
0.2823117971420288,
-0.39046981930732727,
0.8925187587738037,
-0.6956495642662048,
-0.23974253237247467,
-0.10992364585399628,
-0.5571756958961487,
0.5287334322929382,
0.008540350012481213,
0.3866692781448364,
-0.17627884447574615,
0.15054407715797424,
0.5106210112571716,
-0.6209850907325745,
0.6033639311790466,
0.1495186686515808,
-0.03427070751786232,
0.16152189671993256,
0.575579822063446,
0.8152612447738647,
-0.1996157467365265,
-0.00711212819442153,
-0.09758178144693375,
0.27370908856391907,
-0.4772995114326477,
-0.7947587966918945,
0.5966327786445618,
-0.5023254156112671,
-1.0750031471252441,
-0.5254549980163574,
-0.913008451461792,
-0.2491869181394577,
0.34431424736976624,
-0.03612740337848663,
0.16021700203418732,
0.02759351208806038,
0.09237425774335861,
0.510412871837616,
0.15224097669124603,
0.18064835667610168,
0.25181907415390015,
-0.4319554269313812,
-0.2250172346830368,
1.1660090684890747,
0.19581344723701477,
0.09330349415540695,
0.10256402939558029,
0.2777625620365143,
0.05012478306889534,
-0.9536277651786804,
-0.16318796575069427,
0.1561572551727295,
-0.9903285503387451,
-0.06087108328938484,
-0.3730408251285553,
-0.19744975864887238,
0.31722015142440796,
-0.029589857906103134,
-0.1623435914516449,
-0.6278277039527893,
-0.03787638992071152,
0.1725553721189499,
0.22225213050842285,
0.8184565305709839,
-0.027945706620812416,
0.0937640517950058,
-0.6560353636741638,
0.364816278219223,
0.4799251854419708,
0.29507678747177124,
-0.24113593995571136,
0.26350077986717224,
0.026044929400086403,
-0.1178613156080246,
-0.26995691657066345,
-0.9754902720451355,
0.016703469678759575,
-0.3419428765773773,
0.6586282253265381,
0.25157469511032104,
0.05770247429609299,
0.5703648924827576,
-0.4022177755832672,
0.577972412109375,
-0.04221264272928238,
-0.837485671043396,
0.35670918226242065,
-0.41968828439712524,
0.3039645552635193,
0.40195807814598083,
0.28129392862319946,
-0.3261188864707947,
-0.3333585858345032,
-0.5558099746704102,
-0.7976468801498413,
0.8781001567840576,
0.4658149480819702,
-0.250649094581604,
0.05515860393643379,
0.3219110071659088,
-0.20057688653469086,
0.2557753026485443,
-0.7014171481132507,
-0.41617706418037415,
0.0033911445643752813,
-0.35996752977371216,
-0.052003052085638046,
-0.10968232899904251,
-0.38190609216690063,
-0.36347293853759766,
0.5463935732841492,
-0.12220177799463272,
0.14382609724998474,
-0.2265516072511673,
-0.20763878524303436,
-0.15272898972034454,
0.33004525303840637,
0.6655721664428711,
0.7841988205909729,
-0.13753867149353027,
0.15677370131015778,
0.19877244532108307,
0.07359544187784195,
0.07465442270040512,
0.2624072730541229,
-0.018989715725183487,
-0.23590154945850372,
0.38758233189582825,
0.5896661281585693,
0.23830384016036987,
-0.9638715386390686,
0.2175460308790207,
0.0667419359087944,
-0.2777649164199829,
-0.13895468413829803,
0.2433226853609085,
0.5163506269454956,
0.5204227566719055,
0.3919832110404968,
-0.3674227297306061,
-0.1367393434047699,
-0.4768012762069702,
-0.09931693226099014,
0.8506585359573364,
0.0616014264523983,
0.013783801347017288,
0.5079894065856934,
-0.09178558737039566,
-0.611247181892395,
0.7367566823959351,
-0.45044583082199097,
-0.9571592807769775,
0.9839152097702026,
0.5638250708580017,
0.5029187798500061,
0.12002351880073547,
0.04582713916897774,
0.10039260238409042,
0.6307896971702576,
-0.10611972212791443,
0.5879572629928589,
-0.0760326012969017,
-0.6274617910385132,
-0.4942036271095276,
-0.48976799845695496,
-1.0113433599472046,
0.2062448114156723,
-0.3738629221916199,
0.04960252344608307,
-0.6817106604576111,
0.2169744223356247,
0.02733793668448925,
0.13996011018753052,
-0.5082811713218689,
-0.23620347678661346,
0.3872848153114319,
0.7521997094154358,
-0.3570719361305237,
0.45777273178100586,
0.7694841623306274,
0.060370661318302155,
-0.5669872164726257,
-0.48908770084381104,
0.28645485639572144,
-0.6382238864898682,
0.7190167903900146,
0.24149461090564728,
-0.04942063242197037,
0.025714166462421417,
-0.7832244038581848,
-0.9259703159332275,
1.0528757572174072,
0.5514876246452332,
-0.6209927797317505,
0.05000074952840805,
0.6456812620162964,
0.44582849740982056,
-0.2781912386417389,
0.20018285512924194,
0.621197521686554,
0.8057730197906494,
0.13909339904785156,
-0.8453277349472046,
0.04495810344815254,
-0.32857784628868103,
-0.20814163982868195,
0.43886083364486694,
-0.6079205274581909,
0.9731573462486267,
-0.11221787333488464,
-0.22381804883480072,
0.2108628749847412,
0.39587804675102234,
0.6165332198143005,
0.41651663184165955,
0.6280421018600464,
0.7602930665016174,
0.8697624802589417,
-0.34480705857276917,
0.9497804045677185,
-0.2930367887020111,
0.22715385258197784,
1.184437870979309,
-0.45097559690475464,
0.5328628420829773,
0.5678221583366394,
-0.553268313407898,
0.5361096858978271,
0.581477701663971,
-0.15526294708251953,
0.14994171261787415,
0.8814442753791809,
-0.06265385448932648,
-0.7763134241104126,
0.03328455612063408,
-0.19216817617416382,
0.28120964765548706,
0.44349637627601624,
0.2627757787704468,
-0.5262496471405029,
-0.29772064089775085,
-0.12933817505836487,
-0.018480898812413216,
-0.17904947698116302,
0.5066587328910828,
0.2575773596763611,
-0.3802478015422821,
0.4806293845176697,
0.032910626381635666,
0.36741015315055847,
-0.64057457447052,
-0.12573367357254028,
-0.18883703649044037,
0.2521950602531433,
-0.09716513007879257,
-0.6591423749923706,
0.18611830472946167,
-0.17395958304405212,
-0.08914431184530258,
-0.1013396754860878,
0.6319503784179688,
-0.07846032083034515,
-0.7654600739479065,
0.13933292031288147,
0.844483494758606,
0.02294568158686161,
-0.0876302644610405,
-0.6724950075149536,
0.19944262504577637,
-0.1787790209054947,
-0.2815597355365753,
0.43355247378349304,
0.35583293437957764,
-0.23938840627670288,
1.0248616933822632,
0.6828429698944092,
-0.2062261700630188,
0.5337684154510498,
-0.3811187744140625,
0.9397249221801758,
-0.8236702680587769,
-0.30771225690841675,
-0.8412295579910278,
0.20334658026695251,
-0.07604995369911194,
-0.07594213634729385,
0.5468609929084778,
0.4945593476295471,
0.8765331506729126,
0.043703608214855194,
0.5087542533874512,
0.06548204272985458,
0.13510170578956604,
-0.406882107257843,
0.12787330150604248,
-0.574957013130188,
0.39580562710762024,
-0.10384321957826614,
-0.7592753767967224,
-0.3901105523109436,
0.5212617516517639,
-0.12538640201091766,
-0.1312122642993927,
0.7881110310554504,
0.7927608489990234,
-0.0711696669459343,
0.333283007144928,
0.02788016013801098,
0.4121330976486206,
0.336800217628479,
1.0577352046966553,
1.060942530632019,
-0.050075411796569824,
0.8176909685134888,
-0.6876128911972046,
0.15714843571186066,
-0.1826671063899994,
-1.0094654560089111,
-0.944855809211731,
-0.12294267117977142,
-0.27611345052719116,
-0.2093058079481125,
-0.04137680307030678,
0.99677973985672,
0.24721376597881317,
-0.6858792901039124,
-0.2418813407421112,
-0.3708213269710541,
0.6309347748756409,
-0.27959877252578735,
-0.21755288541316986,
0.21222175657749176,
-0.17828717827796936,
-0.7463107705116272,
0.7022797465324402,
0.27104949951171875,
-0.11102666705846786,
-0.32527562975883484,
-0.05596709996461868,
-0.027199748903512955,
0.29712486267089844,
0.6498574614524841,
0.310777485370636,
-0.814032256603241,
-0.21147726476192474,
0.0866755023598671,
0.12695983052253723,
0.05454587563872337,
1.046659231185913,
-0.6298143863677979,
0.366625040769577,
0.504172146320343,
0.6965292692184448,
0.807961106300354,
-0.24220630526542664,
0.18382638692855835,
-0.5772542357444763,
-0.054083649069070816,
0.25459617376327515,
0.49402815103530884,
-0.04790123924612999,
-0.04184863716363907,
0.6533374786376953,
0.17972876131534576,
-0.3049660921096802,
-1.1305882930755615,
0.5971408486366272,
-1.129031777381897,
-0.4951871633529663,
0.8472377061843872,
0.13079950213432312,
-0.19131650030612946,
-0.01437381375581026,
-0.13846375048160553,
-0.02084757201373577,
0.16672685742378235,
0.5941711664199829,
0.9739774465560913,
-0.5229755640029907,
-0.3244835138320923,
-0.46438491344451904,
0.0943780466914177,
0.8565991520881653,
-0.9707823395729065,
-0.021202832460403442,
0.5336950421333313,
0.2012154906988144,
0.22428372502326965,
0.44846758246421814,
0.08755579590797424,
0.22733072936534882,
-0.18767023086547852,
-0.42603734135627747,
-0.5435975790023804,
-0.2009699046611786,
-0.19346673786640167,
0.2993534207344055,
0.1195739135146141,
0.31906384229660034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14594v1 | Improving Assessment of Tutoring Practices using Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-02-04T20:42:30 | 2024-02-04T20:42:30 | Zifei FeiFei Han, Jionghao Lin, Ashish Gurung, Danielle R. Thomas, Eason Chen, Conrad Borchers, Shivang Gupta, Kenneth R. Koedinger | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR | One-on-one tutoring is an effective instructional method for enhancing
learning, yet its efficacy hinges on tutor competencies. Novice math tutors
often prioritize content-specific guidance, neglecting aspects such as
social-emotional learning. Social-emotional learning promotes equity and
inclusion and nurturing relationships with students, which is crucial for
holistic student development. Assessing the competencies of tutors accurately
and efficiently can drive the development of tailored tutor training programs.
However, evaluating novice tutor ability during real-time tutoring remains
challenging as it typically requires experts-in-the-loop. To address this
challenge, this preliminary study aims to harness Generative Pre-trained
Transformers (GPT), such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 models, to automatically assess
tutors' ability of using social-emotional tutoring strategies. Moreover, this
study also reports on the financial dimensions and considerations of employing
these models in real-time and at scale for automated assessment. The current
study examined four prompting strategies: two basic Zero-shot prompt
strategies, Tree of Thought prompt, and Retrieval-Augmented Generator (RAG)
based prompt. The results indicate that the RAG prompt demonstrated more
accurate performance (assessed by the level of hallucination and correctness in
the generated assessment texts) and lower financial costs than the other
strategies evaluated. These findings inform the development of personalized
tutor training interventions to enhance the the educational effectiveness of
tutored learning. | [
-0.5234817266464233,
-0.8765738010406494,
0.1480644792318344,
0.4152424931526184,
-0.09789494425058365,
0.46886736154556274,
-0.048951320350170135,
-0.060319945216178894,
-0.008104915730655193,
-0.035468459129333496,
-0.5956454873085022,
-0.20643796026706696,
-0.42160120606422424,
0.4481220245361328,
-0.2344353348016739,
0.7890905737876892,
-0.0048957448452711105,
0.1517433226108551,
-0.27303504943847656,
-0.015686001628637314,
-0.6767659783363342,
-0.46405264735221863,
-0.9567835330963135,
0.20838181674480438,
0.30544769763946533,
0.45704689621925354,
0.32295945286750793,
0.29044294357299805,
0.43034303188323975,
0.3573932945728302,
0.06319991499185562,
0.03956161066889763,
-0.29962944984436035,
0.11245720088481903,
0.035675276070833206,
-0.3190056085586548,
-0.4029674232006073,
0.36002984642982483,
0.3963201940059662,
0.4019997715950012,
-0.18642665445804596,
0.6020025014877319,
0.1582978516817093,
0.6392164826393127,
-0.8602582216262817,
-0.017938880249857903,
-0.5375454425811768,
0.4624022841453552,
0.12117569893598557,
-0.34317880868911743,
-0.47080719470977783,
-0.7761778831481934,
0.6789995431900024,
-0.6729579567909241,
0.6220725774765015,
-0.22763927280902863,
0.6597195267677307,
0.3901387155056,
-0.1330931931734085,
-0.4064481556415558,
-0.417712926864624,
0.6520563960075378,
-0.3661956787109375,
0.2019413858652115,
0.408107727766037,
0.7233472466468811,
0.4401199519634247,
-0.6812055110931396,
-0.29532870650291443,
-0.2919439375400543,
-0.15131577849388123,
0.4605421721935272,
-0.04283366724848747,
-0.09750686585903168,
0.49697861075401306,
0.09179351478815079,
-0.3342409133911133,
-0.09835579991340637,
-0.22215718030929565,
-0.2578081488609314,
0.3833911716938019,
0.07270068675279617,
0.1427733153104782,
-0.43564772605895996,
-0.23132041096687317,
-0.330126017332077,
-0.4405900835990906,
0.05214865133166313,
0.4979346990585327,
0.43298450112342834,
-0.08505775779485703,
0.43744906783103943,
0.0519983246922493,
0.4962233304977417,
0.45364245772361755,
0.05946960300207138,
0.07619200646877289,
-0.5471041798591614,
0.15702387690544128,
0.22293220460414886,
0.455468088388443,
0.1368516981601715,
0.5142542123794556,
-0.08360487967729568,
-0.07144694030284882,
-0.057660169899463654,
0.4755724370479584,
-0.7689625024795532,
0.05456417798995972,
-0.12937012314796448,
-0.11678000539541245,
-0.4398530423641205,
0.03019068017601967,
-1.2727097272872925,
-0.1417323797941208,
-0.49906936287879944,
0.7451347708702087,
-0.46025651693344116,
-0.20618069171905518,
-0.13431240618228912,
-0.019045982509851456,
0.33022549748420715,
0.22771616280078888,
-0.8444193601608276,
0.3681546151638031,
0.4846579134464264,
0.8933004140853882,
-0.03788072615861893,
-0.14904628694057465,
-0.7852104306221008,
-0.27895283699035645,
-0.17232391238212585,
0.674128532409668,
-0.3658839464187622,
-0.5264099836349487,
0.1432298868894577,
-0.25263822078704834,
-0.3945621848106384,
-0.47689399123191833,
0.1916268914937973,
-0.4246595501899719,
0.619775116443634,
-0.20179568231105804,
-0.36689141392707825,
0.05050713196396828,
0.38969677686691284,
-0.45338499546051025,
0.983776867389679,
0.7454556822776794,
-0.6087977886199951,
0.3902759253978729,
-0.8358613848686218,
-0.19474594295024872,
0.293329656124115,
0.05795283243060112,
-0.49342116713523865,
-0.055818624794483185,
0.43297848105430603,
0.4242159128189087,
-0.14648768305778503,
0.06539852917194366,
0.19860456883907318,
-0.6812880039215088,
-0.08083245158195496,
-0.6765679121017456,
0.5774831771850586,
-0.03356446325778961,
-0.6259285807609558,
0.007585467770695686,
-0.591299831867218,
0.21925409138202667,
0.1870550811290741,
0.08859311044216156,
-0.11727767437696457,
-0.44645005464553833,
-0.34930115938186646,
-0.1978268176317215,
0.15735630691051483,
-0.32350948452949524,
0.22206516563892365,
-0.4162123501300812,
0.07066678255796432,
0.9097129106521606,
0.2229485958814621,
0.29919061064720154,
-0.1395757645368576,
1.1582902669906616,
-0.3328275978565216,
0.2123328596353531,
-0.5549542903900146,
-0.15130938589572906,
-0.6577907800674438,
-0.3044261932373047,
0.4456084072589874,
0.7584608793258667,
-0.7955684065818787,
0.31004059314727783,
-0.11748969554901123,
-0.5620384216308594,
-0.7586293816566467,
-0.052126459777355194,
0.6486651301383972,
0.8136109113693237,
0.5717740058898926,
-0.043639373034238815,
-0.5227497816085815,
-0.26765432953834534,
-0.3126069903373718,
0.06553653627634048,
-0.10440065711736679,
0.4227204918861389,
0.23233024775981903,
-0.18248502910137177,
0.9769160747528076,
-0.37969404458999634,
-0.2122330516576767,
-0.02184654213488102,
0.39301708340644836,
-0.07762633264064789,
0.4608299434185028,
0.6906412839889526,
-0.6266801953315735,
-1.0551751852035522,
-0.16486111283302307,
-0.6008844375610352,
-0.17803855240345,
-0.2927657961845398,
-0.001063070958480239,
0.1602180302143097,
0.06920462101697922,
-0.3572402596473694,
0.6446012258529663,
0.030914606526494026,
-0.40454182028770447,
0.9160196185112,
-0.13328269124031067,
0.5250477194786072,
-0.6348481178283691,
-0.10219161957502365,
-0.0023220062721520662,
-0.03771798312664032,
-0.19076940417289734,
-0.10810096561908722,
0.050261978060007095,
-0.22864164412021637,
-0.42409297823905945,
0.6518042683601379,
-0.39943864941596985,
-0.2087416797876358,
0.329513281583786,
0.2975461781024933,
-0.18503566086292267,
0.5027275681495667,
-0.4546643793582916,
1.4570568799972534,
0.5170919895172119,
-0.3354220390319824,
0.2056470811367035,
0.143843874335289,
-0.20797637104988098,
0.934596598148346,
-0.8850917220115662,
0.4242042899131775,
0.03756381943821907,
-0.16548559069633484,
-1.0668139457702637,
0.12253329157829285,
0.07851997017860413,
-0.5447560548782349,
0.429620623588562,
-0.1956407129764557,
-0.2852843105792999,
-0.3321341574192047,
-0.4089702367782593,
0.3108084797859192,
0.6279723644256592,
-0.6566221117973328,
0.7396686673164368,
-0.29640477895736694,
-0.4233012795448303,
-0.5607489943504333,
0.20274987816810608,
-0.15165925025939941,
-0.2639755606651306,
-0.3422238230705261,
0.19610770046710968,
-0.043088942766189575,
-0.12848585844039917,
-0.03778761252760887,
-0.3230082094669342,
0.12647239863872528,
0.20972242951393127,
0.02612297423183918,
0.6526691317558289,
-0.16802960634231567,
-0.13464471697807312,
0.25812771916389465,
-0.3989224433898926,
0.10618308931589127,
0.05999602749943733,
0.5772355794906616,
-0.2890518605709076,
-0.4417610466480255,
-0.43038180470466614,
-0.11470542103052139,
0.3101661205291748,
-0.4460567235946655,
0.374092161655426,
0.8237473964691162,
-0.03249884024262428,
0.03266754001379013,
-0.5949733257293701,
-0.35882213711738586,
-0.5095883011817932,
0.2617054283618927,
-0.40635964274406433,
-0.7016322016716003,
0.4356124699115753,
-0.1874982714653015,
-0.06767130643129349,
0.2649376094341278,
0.16539934277534485,
-0.0339968316257,
1.2000303268432617,
0.20025140047073364,
0.18605740368366241,
0.6380204558372498,
-0.6162799596786499,
0.151971235871315,
-0.8876767158508301,
-0.0834789052605629,
-0.4550422132015228,
-0.04302233085036278,
-0.26566290855407715,
-0.17985641956329346,
0.4458672106266022,
0.020910056307911873,
-0.4699169099330902,
0.2598916292190552,
-0.8365141749382019,
0.6338887810707092,
0.40693241357803345,
0.09626971185207367,
-0.0010195259237661958,
0.14306135475635529,
-0.30001378059387207,
-0.23002879321575165,
-0.4623713791370392,
-0.5612000226974487,
1.175392985343933,
0.16579405963420868,
0.27603840827941895,
-0.13521254062652588,
0.6689012050628662,
0.2667240500450134,
0.8053482174873352,
-0.7712191939353943,
0.574069082736969,
0.21159687638282776,
-0.40114960074424744,
-0.4893064498901367,
-0.5496893525123596,
-0.8386462926864624,
0.200491264462471,
-0.25380513072013855,
-0.4801962971687317,
-0.18047840893268585,
0.05166322737932205,
-0.6668020486831665,
-0.03488432988524437,
-1.035017728805542,
0.8851611614227295,
-0.35958024859428406,
-0.42408525943756104,
-0.17010930180549622,
-0.4960249960422516,
-0.027178682386875153,
-0.4086284339427948,
-0.17998072504997253,
0.18817073106765747,
0.01171188335865736,
0.682720422744751,
-0.19720710813999176,
0.633294939994812,
-0.5710545778274536,
0.15284159779548645,
0.5141273736953735,
0.29339468479156494,
0.34546390175819397,
-0.05252300202846527,
-0.16060176491737366,
-0.16963808238506317,
0.24304181337356567,
-0.5333638191223145,
-1.0084210634231567,
0.3320416808128357,
-0.805194616317749,
-0.6987863779067993,
-0.28109216690063477,
-0.21179194748401642,
-0.5750711560249329,
-0.06718730926513672,
0.15983745455741882,
0.5713009238243103,
-0.19037535786628723,
0.02169329673051834,
0.49312564730644226,
-0.086564801633358,
0.280200332403183,
0.4998369514942169,
0.013420985080301762,
-0.5782803893089294,
1.1399673223495483,
0.2980336546897888,
0.34785017371177673,
0.004471810068935156,
0.4184768795967102,
-0.43348413705825806,
-0.05739155784249306,
-0.4052867889404297,
0.1945064663887024,
-0.5391038060188293,
-0.25663867592811584,
-0.4402795135974884,
-0.029739730060100555,
-0.6508469581604004,
-0.5571481585502625,
-0.12230955064296722,
-0.32680848240852356,
-0.45864978432655334,
-0.4521917700767517,
0.21860481798648834,
0.36091580986976624,
-0.050024762749671936,
0.4092429280281067,
-0.7750875353813171,
0.1737825870513916,
0.7625246644020081,
0.1960393190383911,
0.37328147888183594,
-0.5952011942863464,
0.011835692450404167,
-0.04013180360198021,
-0.3498496413230896,
-0.6935459971427917,
0.32329750061035156,
0.11542683839797974,
0.3932814300060272,
0.38845065236091614,
-0.06359975039958954,
0.9247801899909973,
-0.5145279765129089,
0.6300994157791138,
0.06536266952753067,
-0.9972503185272217,
0.5014508962631226,
-0.0872415229678154,
0.06186220794916153,
0.7328757047653198,
0.5517453551292419,
-0.14572124183177948,
0.05826505273580551,
-0.6313283443450928,
-0.5305823683738708,
0.49148765206336975,
-0.11100298911333084,
0.2866379916667938,
-0.06733071804046631,
0.6186206936836243,
0.11604668945074081,
0.16765938699245453,
-0.11257325112819672,
-0.16244082152843475,
-0.630524754524231,
-0.3813735544681549,
0.15093477070331573,
-0.19440902769565582,
0.10837523639202118,
-0.4738384783267975,
0.3756890594959259,
-0.2761918902397156,
0.2624524235725403,
0.18836496770381927,
0.21533527970314026,
-0.1573777198791504,
0.13608700037002563,
0.33772197365760803,
0.6058805584907532,
-0.19888803362846375,
-0.22685754299163818,
0.3488130569458008,
-0.7195946574211121,
0.3757673501968384,
0.23491805791854858,
-0.09483800828456879,
-0.07312232255935669,
0.45683783292770386,
0.5818681120872498,
0.3917359411716461,
-0.6589206457138062,
0.5309230089187622,
-0.20782649517059326,
-0.1400061994791031,
-0.32721203565597534,
0.18598830699920654,
-0.3584598898887634,
-0.04790519177913666,
0.5996404886245728,
0.01788441650569439,
-0.11569381505250931,
-0.2308296114206314,
0.15787017345428467,
0.3390417993068695,
-0.3896089196205139,
-0.4371795058250427,
0.27314522862434387,
0.24179372191429138,
-0.6189042329788208,
0.8314782381057739,
-0.40313631296157837,
-0.7102259993553162,
0.7595688104629517,
0.7102739214897156,
1.0757180452346802,
-0.42186838388442993,
0.6354130506515503,
0.6673399209976196,
0.05516461282968521,
0.25536370277404785,
0.0684274360537529,
-0.38681212067604065,
-0.4369771480560303,
-0.4524444043636322,
-0.3773709237575531,
-0.6260553598403931,
-0.43714168667793274,
-0.903374433517456,
0.2154708057641983,
-0.4936264157295227,
-0.14470942318439484,
-0.2362615317106247,
0.3168524503707886,
-0.7809066772460938,
0.07948180288076401,
-0.37137651443481445,
0.7853947877883911,
-0.5359210968017578,
0.1474008411169052,
0.641661524772644,
-0.5370277762413025,
-0.9451348781585693,
-0.20671944320201874,
-0.09612429141998291,
-0.7622584700584412,
0.8416839838027954,
0.22665004432201385,
0.00006441444566007704,
0.5317729115486145,
-0.5691008567810059,
-0.6455380320549011,
0.9978305697441101,
0.1920655518770218,
-0.35413143038749695,
-0.38775166869163513,
0.023188702762126923,
0.6483590602874756,
-0.25415340065956116,
0.5826719999313354,
0.4486958086490631,
0.4282683730125427,
0.2458195984363556,
-0.6753677725791931,
-0.11937875300645828,
-0.17227953672409058,
-0.20806193351745605,
0.05172165483236313,
-0.2910432517528534,
0.6293644905090332,
-0.37429261207580566,
-0.43082451820373535,
0.09297781437635422,
0.46320825815200806,
0.42138272523880005,
0.4710674285888672,
0.5636579394340515,
0.4576433002948761,
0.646385908126831,
-0.1366756111383438,
0.9518293738365173,
-0.33558619022369385,
0.32260921597480774,
0.8624745607376099,
-0.15497958660125732,
0.6246649622917175,
0.3872094750404358,
-0.5535438656806946,
0.48939210176467896,
0.4810582399368286,
-0.11663560569286346,
0.2658272683620453,
0.20182324945926666,
-0.4231882691383362,
-0.09120059013366699,
-0.08135619759559631,
-0.2464389055967331,
-0.026552408933639526,
0.3267512321472168,
0.1842697560787201,
-0.1924334317445755,
0.2873396575450897,
-0.06440258026123047,
0.24396434426307678,
-0.25721168518066406,
0.7610235214233398,
-0.18510666489601135,
-0.7309377193450928,
0.5337204933166504,
-0.5447009205818176,
0.5975763201713562,
-0.5572866201400757,
-0.2729508876800537,
-0.3987866938114166,
-0.05727151408791542,
-0.08547750115394592,
-0.35339561104774475,
-0.03333276882767677,
0.35161837935447693,
0.21621739864349365,
-0.25089940428733826,
0.5547163486480713,
-0.21842516958713531,
-0.42922481894493103,
0.0038917618803679943,
0.6910678744316101,
-0.10206714272499084,
0.005119158886373043,
-0.6729952692985535,
-0.372437059879303,
-0.17949098348617554,
-0.26190385222435,
0.41274017095565796,
0.5037187933921814,
0.19668954610824585,
0.7050923109054565,
0.7266388535499573,
0.10076431185007095,
0.11077829450368881,
0.2508869171142578,
0.5538418292999268,
-0.4988695979118347,
-0.04803115874528885,
-0.6366326212882996,
0.47192227840423584,
0.07387307286262512,
-0.35053181648254395,
1.0107381343841553,
0.3074873089790344,
0.7061656713485718,
-0.1022820994257927,
0.5023559927940369,
0.09471137821674347,
0.703029990196228,
-0.11810775846242905,
0.4495828449726105,
-0.2684333026409149,
-0.010883154347538948,
-0.5948167443275452,
-0.8986558318138123,
-0.06714770197868347,
0.8244677782058716,
-0.44199419021606445,
0.09592719376087189,
0.4344562590122223,
0.5251935124397278,
0.2189076840877533,
0.07586627453565598,
0.10582071542739868,
-0.27755412459373474,
0.41617193818092346,
0.12343313544988632,
1.023348093032837,
-0.43603530526161194,
0.3195803165435791,
-0.3894861042499542,
-0.30933329463005066,
0.01162861380726099,
-0.6116952300071716,
-0.9660505652427673,
-0.3083139955997467,
-0.4337213337421417,
-0.24198558926582336,
-0.005851189140230417,
1.0394408702850342,
0.4036274254322052,
-0.47932037711143494,
0.007934673689305782,
-0.07793638110160828,
-0.03554645925760269,
-0.3220698833465576,
-0.3246106803417206,
0.5961108803749084,
-0.7217528223991394,
-0.6392436027526855,
0.23452405631542206,
-0.03090548887848854,
0.41363325715065,
-0.5287731885910034,
0.04427773877978325,
0.11853616684675217,
0.14191091060638428,
0.7427924275398254,
0.13294380903244019,
-0.263830304145813,
-0.31850382685661316,
0.5801503658294678,
-0.053713906556367874,
-0.21582576632499695,
0.5766252875328064,
-1.1365824937820435,
0.6207943558692932,
0.3024032711982727,
0.865504801273346,
0.2656630277633667,
0.506669282913208,
0.3633593022823334,
-0.47153395414352417,
-0.14585624635219574,
0.4094866216182709,
0.002606532536447048,
0.2411521077156067,
-0.37028416991233826,
0.8263545632362366,
0.29435834288597107,
-0.5119038820266724,
-0.9094803333282471,
-0.2926720380783081,
-0.47026365995407104,
0.22844341397285461,
0.613498330116272,
-0.459766685962677,
0.05250484123826027,
0.09731742739677429,
-0.6465833187103271,
0.3159714639186859,
-0.1722656935453415,
1.0277624130249023,
0.61758953332901,
-0.023403163999319077,
-0.13962478935718536,
-0.37448230385780334,
0.4830872118473053,
0.7789406776428223,
-0.6919497847557068,
-0.1412191540002823,
0.3014810383319855,
-0.09370097517967224,
0.4760015904903412,
0.5055285096168518,
-0.06836534291505814,
0.4207223951816559,
-0.11930474638938904,
-0.2651464641094208,
-0.20304375886917114,
-0.3482801020145416,
-0.3468220829963684,
0.16655610501766205,
-0.46857818961143494,
-0.05162736400961876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02591v1 | On the performance of phonetic algorithms in microtext normalization | 2024-02-04T19:54:44 | 2024-02-04T19:54:44 | Yerai Doval, Manuel Vilares, Jesús Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL | User-generated content published on microblogging social networks constitutes
a priceless source of information. However, microtexts usually deviate from the
standard lexical and grammatical rules of the language, thus making its
processing by traditional intelligent systems very difficult. As an answer,
microtext normalization consists in transforming those non-standard microtexts
into standard well-written texts as a preprocessing step, allowing traditional
approaches to continue with their usual processing. Given the importance of
phonetic phenomena in non-standard text formation, an essential element of the
knowledge base of a normalizer would be the phonetic rules that encode these
phenomena, which can be found in the so-called phonetic algorithms.
In this work we experiment with a wide range of phonetic algorithms for the
English language. The aim of this study is to determine the best phonetic
algorithms within the context of candidate generation for microtext
normalization. In other words, we intend to find those algorithms that taking
as input non-standard terms to be normalized allow us to obtain as output the
smallest possible sets of normalization candidates which still contain the
corresponding target standard words. As it will be stated, the choice of the
phonetic algorithm will depend heavily on the capabilities of the candidate
selection mechanism which we usually find at the end of a microtext
normalization pipeline. The faster it can make the right choices among big
enough sets of candidates, the more we can sacrifice on the precision of the
phonetic algorithms in favour of coverage in order to increase the overall
performance of the normalization system.
KEYWORDS: microtext normalization; phonetic algorithm; fuzzy matching;
Twitter; texting | [
-0.33998990058898926,
-0.5092524290084839,
0.49476945400238037,
0.3348466455936432,
-0.49469253420829773,
-0.07815821468830109,
-0.659446120262146,
-0.35632196068763733,
0.5893335938453674,
0.19908110797405243,
-0.45624175667762756,
-0.5520932078361511,
-0.36612755060195923,
0.6064885854721069,
-0.19302301108837128,
0.5905857086181641,
0.15616369247436523,
0.004113736096769571,
0.2784264385700226,
-0.09200766682624817,
-0.41367030143737793,
-0.41179513931274414,
-0.8114300966262817,
-0.21887341141700745,
0.6282355785369873,
0.6309835314750671,
0.8153494596481323,
0.8258148431777954,
0.42446067929267883,
0.2916099429130554,
-0.41249561309814453,
-0.12305070459842682,
-0.43882450461387634,
0.11881285160779953,
-0.03482915088534355,
-0.42197757959365845,
0.07321308553218842,
0.05001983791589737,
0.711635172367096,
0.6460086703300476,
-0.13158559799194336,
0.27313292026519775,
0.08523409068584442,
0.5685746073722839,
-0.34977126121520996,
-0.06199900060892105,
-0.7464253306388855,
-0.07021448761224747,
-0.6767504811286926,
-0.43084967136383057,
-0.04117787256836891,
-0.5549871325492859,
-0.04674439877271652,
-0.5886968970298767,
0.36180639266967773,
0.09619997441768646,
0.7158414125442505,
-0.16494625806808472,
0.10318171232938766,
-0.8225412964820862,
-0.8879667520523071,
0.9087602496147156,
-0.5821261405944824,
0.5967139005661011,
0.0773945078253746,
0.44752398133277893,
-0.13672032952308655,
-0.46499598026275635,
-0.5688899755477905,
-0.04694051295518875,
0.12398054450750351,
-0.033216431736946106,
-0.1551540642976761,
0.3757930397987366,
0.05539218708872795,
0.361411452293396,
-0.31668534874916077,
0.3709176778793335,
-0.520929753780365,
-0.4395502805709839,
0.45491278171539307,
-0.17506422102451324,
0.4403250813484192,
-0.33148568868637085,
0.2197619527578354,
-0.28764617443084717,
-0.27753186225891113,
0.27369287610054016,
0.4103710353374481,
0.6917816400527954,
0.11236918717622757,
0.6083447337150574,
-0.3792157471179962,
0.28208690881729126,
-0.021732661873102188,
-0.46493884921073914,
0.054436638951301575,
-0.30917438864707947,
-0.20919476449489594,
0.2252279669046402,
0.7024390697479248,
0.3397650420665741,
0.65711510181427,
-0.2985842227935791,
-0.43529006838798523,
0.12831981480121613,
-0.032925769686698914,
-0.7124653458595276,
-0.01871487870812416,
0.17106612026691437,
-0.646687924861908,
-0.49788790941238403,
-0.10831039398908615,
-0.6655640602111816,
0.032530974596738815,
-0.41286271810531616,
0.4284401535987854,
-0.5623353123664856,
-0.04201839119195938,
0.010540178045630455,
-0.3807402551174164,
-0.027971141040325165,
0.10460437089204788,
-1.10239577293396,
0.4872010052204132,
0.6511139869689941,
0.6830581426620483,
0.29873451590538025,
-0.11073268204927444,
-0.14335894584655762,
-0.025828400626778603,
-0.5429790019989014,
0.7544084191322327,
-0.48037809133529663,
-0.17111265659332275,
0.21989737451076508,
-0.2847467064857483,
-0.1893734186887741,
-0.7607196569442749,
0.8257815837860107,
-0.5683549046516418,
-0.006063542794436216,
-0.29153838753700256,
-0.769682765007019,
-0.05366511642932892,
-0.09515412151813507,
-0.5225074887275696,
0.8096098303794861,
-0.3164339065551758,
-0.6770342588424683,
0.5164619088172913,
-0.6352816224098206,
-0.6759095788002014,
-0.016185887157917023,
-0.3147923946380615,
-0.06772913783788681,
0.3148309588432312,
0.1669185906648636,
0.6660076379776001,
-0.36474305391311646,
-0.16547439992427826,
0.10356707870960236,
-0.7180094122886658,
0.06336276978254318,
-0.25541427731513977,
0.9045220613479614,
0.25164803862571716,
-0.5115312933921814,
-0.2177978903055191,
-0.7051153182983398,
0.06323470920324326,
0.20179007947444916,
-0.4935605227947235,
-0.5622963309288025,
0.03428683057427406,
0.10736879706382751,
-0.16650164127349854,
0.043113600462675095,
-0.7752795219421387,
-0.22658446431159973,
-0.6572148203849792,
0.44975465536117554,
0.7309390306472778,
-0.1123572513461113,
0.7318406701087952,
-0.2914610803127289,
0.35214781761169434,
-0.2327427864074707,
0.09829266369342804,
0.15164467692375183,
-0.7724763751029968,
-0.36974722146987915,
-0.2644830048084259,
0.9485113024711609,
0.661841094493866,
-0.6034366488456726,
0.11457609385251999,
-0.27285170555114746,
-0.5750433206558228,
-0.858885645866394,
0.37337154150009155,
0.33964022994041443,
0.25708213448524475,
0.09426819533109665,
0.18221017718315125,
-0.5988941788673401,
-0.9603108763694763,
-0.4797174036502838,
-0.15298870205879211,
-0.20022717118263245,
0.3334570825099945,
-0.07968113571405411,
-0.4554465711116791,
0.5761837959289551,
-0.15079732239246368,
-0.33605751395225525,
-0.06325477361679077,
0.045831188559532166,
0.19462333619594574,
0.21270819008350372,
0.6526103019714355,
-0.7592487931251526,
-0.4730222821235657,
0.04446018859744072,
-0.5672626495361328,
-0.2517765760421753,
0.07527143508195877,
0.14404445886611938,
0.3307728171348572,
0.5382355451583862,
-0.3353566527366638,
0.28604739904403687,
0.5330694913864136,
0.07706176489591599,
0.3992631733417511,
-0.17767728865146637,
0.27125099301338196,
-0.8505082130432129,
-0.202985018491745,
0.032309889793395996,
-0.00008019839879125357,
-0.7740270495414734,
0.034657180309295654,
0.016221608966588974,
-0.03273748606443405,
-0.2012711465358734,
0.37977832555770874,
-0.40938064455986023,
0.1520172357559204,
0.02836362086236477,
0.412836492061615,
-0.43266844749450684,
0.16102729737758636,
-0.338733047246933,
0.8304720520973206,
0.3998713195323944,
-0.7429137229919434,
0.05495419353246689,
-0.11982565373182297,
-0.1506367176771164,
0.1805487722158432,
-0.4453905522823334,
0.13623760640621185,
-0.05212388187646866,
-0.24711383879184723,
-1.2758779525756836,
-0.14673742651939392,
0.025572333484888077,
-0.6424732804298401,
0.05168682709336281,
0.15250055491924286,
-0.8545277118682861,
-0.17284490168094635,
-0.45774656534194946,
0.3497255742549896,
0.7259584069252014,
-0.43679460883140564,
0.3067777156829834,
0.4054509401321411,
-0.15644370019435883,
-0.16187334060668945,
-0.4844748079776764,
0.18155482411384583,
-0.12389912456274033,
-0.8344348073005676,
0.3890641927719116,
0.21713599562644958,
-0.37672728300094604,
-0.08210008591413498,
0.03262774646282196,
-0.027709560468792915,
-0.07191534340381622,
-0.09535802900791168,
-0.20568349957466125,
-0.3893500864505768,
0.19056163728237152,
0.5528543591499329,
0.019076230004429817,
-0.13387635350227356,
-0.32866331934928894,
0.43189653754234314,
0.18108947575092316,
0.27120059728622437,
-0.6344396471977234,
0.3058197796344757,
0.35782480239868164,
0.03551018610596657,
0.6380485892295837,
0.5783289670944214,
-0.6504067182540894,
-0.13822834193706512,
-0.7798788547515869,
-0.21393762528896332,
-0.4895302355289459,
-0.11503425240516663,
-0.5926172137260437,
-0.9269529581069946,
0.6315340995788574,
0.009866531938314438,
-0.015935726463794708,
0.6360765695571899,
0.39069294929504395,
-0.29856979846954346,
0.8515400886535645,
0.525894820690155,
-0.10324231535196304,
0.3434268832206726,
0.08465559035539627,
0.21061493456363678,
-0.42863136529922485,
0.1501675397157669,
-0.8149953484535217,
-0.4142744243144989,
-1.180907130241394,
-0.28394490480422974,
0.204777330160141,
-0.06911062449216843,
0.360211044549942,
0.40706074237823486,
-0.6480069756507874,
0.434379518032074,
0.7572685480117798,
0.021484633907675743,
0.12919697165489197,
0.5450336337089539,
-0.5408609509468079,
-0.1889951527118683,
-0.6880611181259155,
-0.6754814386367798,
0.9367712736129761,
0.3222610056400299,
0.48246118426322937,
0.13406506180763245,
1.1592624187469482,
0.2577088177204132,
-0.08491609990596771,
-0.7295253872871399,
0.6899226307868958,
-0.6194108128547668,
-0.3358404338359833,
-0.7015314102172852,
-0.5528424978256226,
-1.0058163404464722,
-0.1420295685529709,
-0.33328941464424133,
-0.5810428857803345,
0.2639032006263733,
0.03982742130756378,
-0.3452869951725006,
0.2995350658893585,
-0.7085195779800415,
0.4168696105480194,
0.32118675112724304,
0.24308785796165466,
-0.24779289960861206,
-0.5527856945991516,
-0.10577386617660522,
-0.10676608234643936,
0.2629716396331787,
0.07890286296606064,
-0.07669536769390106,
1.157057762145996,
0.03256472572684288,
0.5741575956344604,
-0.3000020980834961,
0.12575079500675201,
0.29606232047080994,
0.15394309163093567,
0.055007513612508774,
-0.18141239881515503,
-0.11521191149950027,
0.2979179322719574,
0.2587454617023468,
-0.29732489585876465,
-0.3800661861896515,
0.41910165548324585,
-0.7031576037406921,
-0.3604232370853424,
0.047553304582834244,
-0.1424846351146698,
-0.010111275129020214,
0.5390840768814087,
0.6679390668869019,
0.4027571678161621,
-0.37781110405921936,
0.13852766156196594,
0.657530665397644,
-0.05955493450164795,
0.29008451104164124,
0.07738727331161499,
-0.08671080321073532,
-0.46816393733024597,
1.1056560277938843,
0.739777147769928,
-0.11196431517601013,
0.5576851963996887,
0.4782297909259796,
-0.22983506321907043,
-0.9139819741249084,
-0.4322828948497772,
0.38736245036125183,
-0.5644708275794983,
-0.11248011887073517,
-0.4204602539539337,
-0.1749783307313919,
-0.8283025622367859,
-0.18730942904949188,
-0.15286658704280853,
-0.6256924271583557,
-0.36749589443206787,
0.2012438327074051,
-0.048432327806949615,
0.6878724694252014,
-0.04432172328233719,
0.0505443811416626,
-0.6134771704673767,
0.4499761760234833,
0.3814631402492523,
0.21076549589633942,
-0.29043322801589966,
-0.3386978209018707,
-0.18527710437774658,
0.15226832032203674,
-0.05875154212117195,
-0.8136357665061951,
-0.23111841082572937,
0.17569588124752045,
0.4884834885597229,
0.611437976360321,
-0.04196680337190628,
0.6393846273422241,
-0.7338541150093079,
0.38154369592666626,
-0.15535640716552734,
-0.771106481552124,
0.45714613795280457,
-0.4658428728580475,
-0.0774022713303566,
0.7253870368003845,
0.20650002360343933,
-0.7854558825492859,
-0.6211507320404053,
-0.7168757915496826,
-0.4906054437160492,
0.3050452768802643,
0.6344998478889465,
0.1573820263147354,
-0.1883726269006729,
0.766102135181427,
-0.10035532712936401,
0.1716308891773224,
-0.04748395085334778,
-0.03692490607500076,
0.23376652598381042,
-0.35980963706970215,
-0.22562000155448914,
-0.5361401438713074,
0.07949855178594589,
-0.21603836119174957,
0.4489092230796814,
0.13609176874160767,
0.48476889729499817,
0.3797408938407898,
0.060553375631570816,
-0.13064274191856384,
0.36276644468307495,
0.8529778718948364,
0.3770199418067932,
-0.3770213723182678,
-0.04259997233748436,
0.10062909126281738,
-0.7055251598358154,
0.13198474049568176,
0.14666718244552612,
-0.40037909150123596,
0.33575761318206787,
0.319999098777771,
0.2918006479740143,
0.27038076519966125,
-0.6262001395225525,
0.39470627903938293,
-0.20423783361911774,
-0.41793292760849,
-0.2417495995759964,
0.0707753375172615,
0.049095720052719116,
0.053363554179668427,
0.2888341248035431,
0.32462525367736816,
0.5436010956764221,
-0.5625205636024475,
0.1554846316576004,
0.36623984575271606,
-0.18923497200012207,
-0.4883643686771393,
0.5098800659179688,
0.156194806098938,
-0.8429988026618958,
0.42625197768211365,
-0.3683488965034485,
-0.4257625937461853,
0.5476900935173035,
0.376900851726532,
0.973249614238739,
-0.43831679224967957,
0.11720684170722961,
0.13202860951423645,
0.554729700088501,
-0.14236293733119965,
0.2375650256872177,
0.04684289172291756,
-0.8979743719100952,
-0.054700471460819244,
-0.6235017776489258,
-0.40754058957099915,
-0.22446832060813904,
-0.42009520530700684,
0.3281105160713196,
-0.7487763166427612,
-0.2822447121143341,
0.26648271083831787,
-0.03703538700938225,
-0.6974183320999146,
0.453421950340271,
0.2585889399051666,
1.1004753112792969,
-0.6593354940414429,
0.44989290833473206,
0.8664318919181824,
0.07710308581590652,
-1.1042073965072632,
0.26112067699432373,
-0.001593124121427536,
-0.6230645179748535,
0.2576572299003601,
0.18784455955028534,
-0.2597801983356476,
-0.0503845289349556,
-0.14859789609909058,
-0.38042762875556946,
0.8973734974861145,
0.3920550048351288,
-0.4656509459018707,
-0.15977416932582855,
0.321277916431427,
0.8147927522659302,
-0.3219574987888336,
0.01529987994581461,
0.7867375016212463,
0.3921225666999817,
-0.10237579047679901,
-1.058004379272461,
0.11740347743034363,
-0.0768238753080368,
0.36344823241233826,
0.11760828644037247,
-0.6986128687858582,
0.9518938660621643,
0.06979401409626007,
-0.46168383955955505,
0.1147056594491005,
0.4583701193332672,
0.04353261739015579,
0.37427112460136414,
0.6845877170562744,
0.3462958037853241,
0.9037756323814392,
0.035508424043655396,
0.8651318550109863,
-0.22447653114795685,
0.08640468865633011,
0.3526177704334259,
0.045539092272520065,
0.9628762602806091,
0.5477869510650635,
-0.17301343381404877,
0.15387564897537231,
0.6909520030021667,
0.2775556445121765,
0.3746889531612396,
0.17168210446834564,
-0.10547657310962677,
0.21714361011981964,
0.15379303693771362,
0.06604325026273727,
0.5912989974021912,
0.00886498298496008,
-0.33025482296943665,
-0.04607940837740898,
0.07088813185691833,
0.06171651557087898,
0.2611818313598633,
-0.32666128873825073,
1.048507571220398,
-0.24537307024002075,
-0.507054328918457,
0.5823851823806763,
0.35812896490097046,
0.8283634781837463,
-0.16885869204998016,
0.05701145902276039,
-0.1552239954471588,
0.038293082267045975,
-0.17425666749477386,
-0.49531131982803345,
0.2739187479019165,
-0.2310725897550583,
-0.2615423798561096,
0.021121466532349586,
1.0779750347137451,
-0.09540118277072906,
-0.6801926493644714,
0.4812164306640625,
0.30025747418403625,
0.24433504045009613,
-0.2489236742258072,
-0.39081233739852905,
-0.11241771280765533,
0.07126863300800323,
0.09443170577287674,
0.12355174124240875,
0.863831639289856,
0.00439781928434968,
0.2527395784854889,
0.5262468457221985,
0.3990868031978607,
0.36391645669937134,
0.08406725525856018,
0.7492051720619202,
-0.6666099429130554,
-0.5961316823959351,
-0.7991556525230408,
-0.03620423004031181,
0.07622519135475159,
-0.23736247420310974,
0.7492071390151978,
0.5514482259750366,
0.8787028789520264,
0.03381607308983803,
0.5371770858764648,
0.15476281940937042,
0.8502200841903687,
-0.6320776343345642,
0.8157081007957458,
-0.4953799545764923,
0.10524882376194,
-0.5306326746940613,
-1.018050193786621,
-0.402649462223053,
0.500960648059845,
-0.1367601454257965,
-0.05328190699219704,
0.5881290435791016,
0.8569362163543701,
-0.16119876503944397,
0.2699155807495117,
0.3686563968658447,
-0.03629690781235695,
0.14562299847602844,
-0.08547740429639816,
0.3096376359462738,
-0.556602954864502,
0.6934980750083923,
-0.6620646119117737,
-0.5010240077972412,
-0.3427409529685974,
-0.4577013850212097,
-0.89753258228302,
-0.6110172271728516,
0.08691979944705963,
-0.09143178910017014,
0.17435269057750702,
0.9468072056770325,
0.4070676863193512,
-0.7247646450996399,
-0.5144332647323608,
0.07479006797075272,
0.18374235928058624,
-0.3401446044445038,
-0.2406078577041626,
0.18186549842357635,
-0.5764000415802002,
-0.6914514303207397,
0.18497006595134735,
0.1552736908197403,
0.04264282435178757,
0.18200160562992096,
0.10324278473854065,
-0.11880971491336823,
0.5925434827804565,
0.5776596665382385,
0.13760991394519806,
-0.4817681312561035,
-0.394790381193161,
0.23846684396266937,
-0.17462556064128876,
0.20786133408546448,
0.766326367855072,
-0.23774045705795288,
0.3236533999443054,
0.4660290479660034,
0.6583514213562012,
-0.03339330852031708,
-0.1497061401605606,
0.27008986473083496,
-0.7422935366630554,
0.19145384430885315,
0.2608678340911865,
0.1636686623096466,
0.23356924951076508,
-0.378562331199646,
0.36676421761512756,
0.30489981174468994,
-0.5511988997459412,
-0.7567072510719299,
-0.12690402567386627,
-0.7347443103790283,
-0.06234963983297348,
1.1508629322052002,
0.47249844670295715,
-0.4382694959640503,
0.04730188846588135,
-0.34921956062316895,
0.31212449073791504,
-0.5481168627738953,
0.7473198175430298,
0.7584004998207092,
-0.051642563194036484,
-0.018566608428955078,
-0.47535014152526855,
0.7443294525146484,
0.3896228075027466,
-0.04460303112864494,
-0.3524048924446106,
-0.09828096628189087,
0.4193747639656067,
0.6123746037483215,
0.9332505464553833,
0.053586624562740326,
0.232686385512352,
0.0029863875824958086,
-0.08762402832508087,
0.3555436134338379,
-0.3355703055858612,
-0.28816327452659607,
0.14600735902786255,
0.11754204332828522,
-0.37070906162261963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02572v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02572v1 | A Quantitative Discourse Analysis of Asian Workers in the US Historical Newspapers | 2024-02-04T17:32:52 | 2024-02-04T17:32:52 | Jaihyun Park, Ryan Cordell | cs.CL | cs.CL | Warning: This paper contains examples of offensive language targetting
marginalized population. The digitization of historical texts invites
researchers to explore the large-scale corpus of historical texts with
computational methods. In this study, we present computational text analysis on
a relatively understudied topic of how Asian workers are represented in
historical newspapers in the United States. We found that the word "coolie" was
semantically different in some States (e.g., Massachusetts, Rhode Island,
Wyoming, Oklahoma, and Arkansas) with the different discourses around coolie.
We also found that then-Confederate newspapers and then-Union newspapers formed
distinctive discourses by measuring over-represented words. Newspapers from
then-Confederate States associated coolie with slavery-related words. In
addition, we found Asians were perceived to be inferior to European immigrants
and subjected to the target of racism. This study contributes to supplementing
the qualitative analysis of racism in the United States with quantitative
discourse analysis. | [
-0.10590958595275879,
-0.739672064781189,
0.421099454164505,
0.08615872263908386,
-0.3613086938858032,
0.19935941696166992,
-0.092359259724617,
-0.4857969284057617,
0.6619584560394287,
0.2990860044956207,
-0.08943790197372437,
-0.40109649300575256,
-0.4384550154209137,
0.2972344756126404,
-0.2804986238479614,
0.9056098461151123,
-0.096794992685318,
-0.005756067577749491,
0.18576903641223907,
-0.4762412905693054,
-0.19679835438728333,
-0.7236469984054565,
-0.22469237446784973,
0.2373945116996765,
0.18505677580833435,
0.23830720782279968,
1.1195281744003296,
0.8063651919364929,
0.6194389462471008,
0.43248552083969116,
-0.10483510792255402,
-0.588800847530365,
-0.6524595022201538,
0.24915041029453278,
-0.26668819785118103,
-0.6537293195724487,
-0.1468154340982437,
0.29498225450515747,
0.3959718346595764,
0.7043161392211914,
0.2709076702594757,
0.45360201597213745,
-0.4172288179397583,
0.5670791864395142,
-0.9679695963859558,
-0.06159789860248566,
-0.700092613697052,
0.09521825611591339,
-0.6511508226394653,
-0.17093218863010406,
-0.3016599416732788,
-0.6456393003463745,
-0.3149036467075348,
-0.5507904291152954,
0.2774610221385956,
-0.2258192002773285,
1.0806292295455933,
0.06339104473590851,
-0.7324874997138977,
-0.21527723968029022,
-0.7644089460372925,
0.9349424242973328,
-0.6229079365730286,
0.09206744283437729,
0.3762768805027008,
0.07763219624757767,
0.033243220299482346,
-0.6289385557174683,
-0.6599323749542236,
-0.050463445484638214,
-0.5153775811195374,
0.37542083859443665,
-0.3686896562576294,
-0.21036286652088165,
0.46894925832748413,
0.5615643262863159,
-0.7410920858383179,
0.3233852982521057,
-0.732783854007721,
-0.2809649407863617,
0.6698251366615295,
0.5086356401443481,
0.6303939819335938,
-0.36325007677078247,
-0.2090742141008377,
0.07472114264965057,
-0.07195182889699936,
0.03543377295136452,
0.5051962733268738,
0.2612974941730499,
-0.17740264534950256,
0.5302255153656006,
-0.2037682831287384,
0.18131566047668457,
-0.2701167166233063,
-0.3138941824436188,
0.17616552114486694,
-0.23130680620670319,
-0.00332908658310771,
-0.2565263509750366,
0.8861156702041626,
0.5795913934707642,
0.43098023533821106,
-0.13451699912548065,
0.020886048674583435,
0.3062089681625366,
0.07299498468637466,
-0.7996734380722046,
-0.021047765389084816,
0.10675186663866043,
-0.7537257075309753,
0.09912460297346115,
-0.04773616045713425,
-0.9243049025535583,
-0.46711012721061707,
0.013158564455807209,
-0.4534125328063965,
0.013947459869086742,
-0.40022575855255127,
-0.535206139087677,
-0.7400916814804077,
0.2205749750137329,
-0.12867289781570435,
-0.7937659621238708,
0.16242261230945587,
0.6656166911125183,
0.7047528028488159,
-0.21957023441791534,
-0.11224646866321564,
0.15317651629447937,
0.27368465065956116,
-0.5620242357254028,
0.4101755917072296,
-0.706086277961731,
-0.6008052825927734,
0.26725366711616516,
-0.05581977590918541,
0.15030734241008759,
-0.5307478308677673,
0.7443869709968567,
-0.8076881170272827,
0.2990535497665405,
-0.25554323196411133,
-0.17407430708408356,
-0.10119665414094925,
-0.06681858003139496,
-0.8932926058769226,
0.9060488939285278,
0.45282649993896484,
-1.1186939477920532,
0.592735230922699,
-0.047125522047281265,
-0.47727200388908386,
0.2549453675746918,
-0.5717595219612122,
-0.42202794551849365,
0.24529576301574707,
-0.1389034241437912,
0.16398759186267853,
-0.10940080136060715,
0.19865018129348755,
-0.22114291787147522,
-0.675217866897583,
0.15701541304588318,
-0.05113384500145912,
1.5180529356002808,
0.2801132798194885,
-0.4619900584220886,
-0.17475979030132294,
-0.603302538394928,
-0.3123401701450348,
0.1912015676498413,
-0.043732721358537674,
-0.9799835681915283,
-0.41265228390693665,
-0.13728761672973633,
-0.183320090174675,
0.16755186021327972,
-0.8147011399269104,
0.0693463534116745,
-0.17782050371170044,
-0.0851496011018753,
0.37774860858917236,
0.03739287331700325,
0.5914740562438965,
-0.11905448883771896,
0.7298627495765686,
-0.15139995515346527,
-0.12730838358402252,
-0.2734840214252472,
-0.18274538218975067,
-0.473012775182724,
0.022445576265454292,
0.03285573795437813,
0.9868432283401489,
-0.8248479962348938,
-0.20327255129814148,
-0.46486449241638184,
-0.43996065855026245,
-0.11705181747674942,
-0.35099682211875916,
0.22028154134750366,
0.23951494693756104,
0.1432959884405136,
-0.15173786878585815,
-0.7776036858558655,
-1.0278894901275635,
-0.5487934947013855,
-0.6736099720001221,
-0.14602212607860565,
0.1291930079460144,
0.336931437253952,
0.11499449610710144,
0.9250999093055725,
-0.7253696322441101,
-0.17497843503952026,
0.4317232668399811,
0.541934072971344,
0.07179386168718338,
0.1590920388698578,
0.7569002509117126,
-0.8943959474563599,
-0.7087250351905823,
0.11994987726211548,
-0.779944121837616,
0.11271365731954575,
-0.2789761424064636,
-0.2575840651988983,
0.25572946667671204,
0.8123679161071777,
-0.3789818286895752,
0.7907697558403015,
0.29957273602485657,
-0.2367985099554062,
0.6196892857551575,
0.28934937715530396,
0.43284502625465393,
-1.1142046451568604,
0.21225197613239288,
0.019057469442486763,
0.28119292855262756,
-0.42840760946273804,
0.17704764008522034,
-0.043566927313804626,
-0.4636230170726776,
-0.39032164216041565,
0.40590885281562805,
-0.4152783751487732,
0.22194752097129822,
-0.157725989818573,
0.16063983738422394,
-0.294806569814682,
0.41868025064468384,
0.07255195081233978,
0.613531768321991,
0.03279701620340347,
-0.1781310737133026,
0.20941275358200073,
-0.08602359145879745,
0.05502039194107056,
0.6480892896652222,
-0.14536967873573303,
0.13904033601284027,
-0.48529157042503357,
0.2169100046157837,
-1.140689492225647,
0.018309203907847404,
0.031210878863930702,
-0.5163676738739014,
-0.14441128075122833,
0.11079899966716766,
-0.2587791383266449,
-0.6189094185829163,
-0.5079545974731445,
0.7446849942207336,
0.14473451673984528,
0.02549085207283497,
0.4182854890823364,
0.8526225686073303,
-0.33102765679359436,
-0.668708086013794,
-0.8174182772636414,
0.25326040387153625,
-0.6472733020782471,
-0.3296221196651459,
0.2915877103805542,
0.26594221591949463,
-0.8402084112167358,
0.05598701909184456,
0.3374512493610382,
-0.8864569067955017,
-0.02708101086318493,
0.14534161984920502,
0.39631685614585876,
-0.4908396005630493,
0.07738863676786423,
-0.08882137387990952,
0.06432345509529114,
0.38050296902656555,
0.39976030588150024,
0.012264719232916832,
0.2818354666233063,
0.4393354654312134,
-0.6931878328323364,
0.6625378131866455,
0.4738348126411438,
-0.1599060744047165,
0.6975405812263489,
0.70177161693573,
-0.32644569873809814,
0.304300993680954,
-0.35735467076301575,
-0.4040851891040802,
-0.4176579415798187,
0.47653642296791077,
-0.2393186092376709,
-1.0338704586029053,
0.6759517192840576,
0.0626666396856308,
0.3498975336551666,
0.5995107293128967,
0.2610933482646942,
-0.012096450664103031,
0.568992555141449,
0.612903892993927,
-0.4352463483810425,
0.4059390127658844,
0.008125153370201588,
0.1412036120891571,
-0.22110697627067566,
0.08224073052406311,
-1.1197115182876587,
-0.30746886134147644,
-1.1481391191482544,
-0.1208844855427742,
0.10940298438072205,
-0.16430582106113434,
-0.4411289691925049,
0.19054894149303436,
-0.36285677552223206,
0.5118733644485474,
0.047971710562705994,
-0.40084877610206604,
0.35249409079551697,
-0.15710556507110596,
0.262154757976532,
-0.5730245113372803,
-0.31611764430999756,
-0.6510159373283386,
0.6226174235343933,
0.19503852725028992,
0.5155348777770996,
0.27650412917137146,
0.5534077882766724,
0.436961829662323,
0.6329376697540283,
-0.6844647526741028,
0.5345827341079712,
-0.6390368938446045,
-0.7016872763633728,
-0.3699031174182892,
-0.5886639356613159,
-1.1761659383773804,
0.3548382818698883,
-0.0959850549697876,
-0.9044049978256226,
0.43466949462890625,
-0.03465374931693077,
-0.5484686493873596,
0.3465675413608551,
-0.49608856439590454,
0.5387669205665588,
-0.10857916623353958,
0.006012169644236565,
-0.17068606615066528,
-0.5162884593009949,
0.8146485090255737,
0.10878495126962662,
0.739324688911438,
-0.2216397225856781,
-0.31977683305740356,
0.7055464386940002,
-0.3384034335613251,
1.0005779266357422,
-0.010994118638336658,
-0.0910477265715599,
0.48172637820243835,
0.27005279064178467,
0.16107873618602753,
-0.2519787847995758,
-0.4336621165275574,
0.24575430154800415,
0.18583424389362335,
-0.5806539058685303,
-0.3572295904159546,
0.4566272497177124,
-0.6080820560455322,
-0.5538684129714966,
-0.40930795669555664,
-0.557682991027832,
0.19106003642082214,
0.3551751673221588,
0.3289467692375183,
0.23641444742679596,
-0.37800419330596924,
-0.13991370797157288,
0.1209675669670105,
0.08596665412187576,
0.6918789148330688,
0.29068630933761597,
-0.18134061992168427,
-0.16833411157131195,
0.8190097808837891,
0.39643409848213196,
-0.2968468964099884,
0.31205102801322937,
0.1195257306098938,
0.09907762706279755,
-0.04111797362565994,
-0.45817917585372925,
0.4170001149177551,
-0.5267201066017151,
-0.1138375774025917,
-0.5154212713241577,
0.16197684407234192,
-0.3623121678829193,
-0.3384864330291748,
-0.07501818239688873,
-0.3952133059501648,
-0.5928263664245605,
0.11478233337402344,
0.009491236880421638,
0.6989484429359436,
0.1309535950422287,
0.5450659394264221,
-0.5993003249168396,
0.4680262506008148,
0.34942206740379333,
0.14822104573249817,
0.09857744723558426,
-0.5243306756019592,
-0.4997631907463074,
-0.19840572774410248,
-0.15888291597366333,
-1.2990787029266357,
0.04170985147356987,
-0.33019012212753296,
0.5192210674285889,
0.3805733919143677,
0.4822487533092499,
0.5422006249427795,
-0.29823076725006104,
0.8908396363258362,
0.17656558752059937,
-0.8387410044670105,
0.2269214689731598,
-0.4412264823913574,
0.5394206643104553,
0.7155820727348328,
0.8952760696411133,
-0.5522239804267883,
-0.8814197182655334,
-0.6122229695320129,
-0.9138538837432861,
0.4111311137676239,
-0.12656815350055695,
0.6277967691421509,
-0.2537761926651001,
0.37522798776626587,
0.014003202319145203,
-0.19040556252002716,
-0.8746606707572937,
-0.4335346817970276,
0.029000291600823402,
0.039977721869945526,
0.6063454151153564,
-0.37132972478866577,
0.037247318774461746,
-0.0057998113334178925,
0.415067583322525,
0.028620470315217972,
-0.2209271639585495,
-0.1700412631034851,
-0.21585869789123535,
-0.2547188401222229,
0.36376532912254333,
0.2601167559623718,
1.2557286024093628,
-0.03406444564461708,
0.3177129030227661,
0.28387823700904846,
-0.6890512108802795,
-0.03360571339726448,
0.10954491049051285,
-0.3924867808818817,
0.5625901818275452,
0.49635669589042664,
0.6404967308044434,
0.007087049074470997,
-0.4121408760547638,
0.4944174289703369,
-0.1878824681043625,
0.2786361575126648,
-0.44914400577545166,
-0.34714406728744507,
-0.11740484088659286,
-0.002168599283322692,
0.8415377736091614,
-0.284961998462677,
0.4120488464832306,
-0.940782368183136,
-0.030498547479510307,
0.491292268037796,
-0.4094712734222412,
-0.1595035195350647,
0.5861039161682129,
0.25117164850234985,
-0.18132127821445465,
0.5822991132736206,
-0.39677274227142334,
-0.6840782761573792,
0.5882018804550171,
0.45462629199028015,
0.5095306634902954,
-0.42457860708236694,
0.4272654354572296,
0.7171381115913391,
0.5156494379043579,
0.6386612057685852,
0.17556744813919067,
0.06420698016881943,
-0.5865141749382019,
-0.3929603099822998,
-0.29267093539237976,
-0.04861719161272049,
-0.0607113353908062,
-0.9018074870109558,
0.11823111027479172,
-0.15726560354232788,
-0.5642071962356567,
0.2072536051273346,
0.018402405083179474,
-0.3494427502155304,
0.40631622076034546,
0.21160314977169037,
0.45285630226135254,
-1.170849084854126,
0.3548131585121155,
0.8286390900611877,
-0.3044731020927429,
-0.4802304804325104,
0.4644598364830017,
0.12867093086242676,
-0.4521041214466095,
0.6831494569778442,
-0.21751920878887177,
-0.10390608012676239,
-0.27222558856010437,
-0.3741563558578491,
-0.6763883233070374,
0.6998905539512634,
0.3177275061607361,
-0.3428694009780884,
0.1853644996881485,
0.3339266777038574,
0.7305864095687866,
0.05528952553868294,
0.30834507942199707,
0.7782825827598572,
0.1270565390586853,
-0.25221818685531616,
-0.9766414165496826,
0.23697568476200104,
-0.04637349396944046,
0.12152732908725739,
0.5318495035171509,
-0.9024665951728821,
0.9651376008987427,
-0.24722495675086975,
-0.8588845133781433,
0.0751279667019844,
1.055746078491211,
-0.0700402557849884,
0.5309319496154785,
0.4307480454444885,
0.3074907660484314,
0.8050891757011414,
0.10246871411800385,
0.9826233386993408,
0.13338230550289154,
0.09089136868715286,
1.063653588294983,
0.1134379431605339,
0.5722687840461731,
0.32682955265045166,
-0.5415764451026917,
0.7763171792030334,
0.2935764193534851,
0.3215351700782776,
0.04586947336792946,
0.40960225462913513,
-0.3349207639694214,
0.5109478831291199,
-0.5691758990287781,
-0.2257300168275833,
0.8798701763153076,
0.08996269851922989,
-0.20625509321689606,
-0.24506737291812897,
-0.017759472131729126,
0.7222805023193359,
0.6224387884140015,
-0.6517844200134277,
0.816204845905304,
-0.017425470054149628,
-0.35986897349357605,
0.34374529123306274,
0.00590013712644577,
0.5748826861381531,
-0.20995178818702698,
-0.017027640715241432,
-0.6175089478492737,
-0.3263133466243744,
-0.4233308434486389,
-0.7014179825782776,
0.623683750629425,
0.05640614777803421,
-0.2270604819059372,
0.28495916724205017,
0.5011383891105652,
-0.2943425178527832,
-0.3084307014942169,
-0.10439618676900864,
0.45795053243637085,
0.30493175983428955,
0.18076342344284058,
-0.4420805871486664,
0.36454176902770996,
0.11018288135528564,
-0.023380527272820473,
-0.045069679617881775,
0.8877058625221252,
-0.6956408023834229,
-0.011190482415258884,
0.31783080101013184,
-0.033053137362003326,
-0.05105319619178772,
-0.09631597250699997,
0.6707059144973755,
-0.9718625545501709,
-0.844431459903717,
-0.9239907264709473,
0.4091610014438629,
-0.39814522862434387,
-0.6467212438583374,
0.811112642288208,
0.8632738590240479,
0.6746468544006348,
0.1809416264295578,
0.718183696269989,
-0.09594136476516724,
0.7853636145591736,
-0.055935148149728775,
0.6390187740325928,
-0.31503212451934814,
-0.2768608629703522,
-0.5139264464378357,
-0.7806004881858826,
-0.30906930565834045,
0.1976800113916397,
-0.389865517616272,
0.07283062487840652,
0.7668824791908264,
0.47559186816215515,
0.19877739250659943,
0.340920627117157,
0.21074430644512177,
0.34354254603385925,
-0.13074734807014465,
-0.24251464009284973,
0.7941561937332153,
-0.12097945809364319,
0.6587333083152771,
-0.6205270886421204,
-0.3717106282711029,
0.017301339656114578,
-0.652478039264679,
-0.36378923058509827,
-0.7229093313217163,
-0.3148515224456787,
-0.28553566336631775,
-0.1277419626712799,
0.22160959243774414,
0.3699030876159668,
-0.7295069098472595,
-0.6890444755554199,
0.7788205742835999,
0.1683560460805893,
0.1546814888715744,
-0.36130353808403015,
0.7068517804145813,
0.048790350556373596,
-0.9294516444206238,
-0.17950280010700226,
0.12391173839569092,
0.04239527881145477,
-0.26623809337615967,
0.44661659002304077,
-0.19812916219234467,
-0.006810553837567568,
0.5304172039031982,
0.6468645334243774,
-0.47643423080444336,
0.050412435084581375,
-0.15653347969055176,
-0.4729897677898407,
-0.10769254714250565,
1.327695608139038,
-0.6739243268966675,
0.35814952850341797,
0.3099110424518585,
0.4985951781272888,
0.2992718815803528,
0.4302511215209961,
0.2654140591621399,
-0.6410349011421204,
0.6901007294654846,
0.7173109650611877,
0.011047134175896645,
0.36975908279418945,
-0.7195507884025574,
0.37541094422340393,
0.3326460123062134,
-0.4764808714389801,
-0.6349608898162842,
-0.11242639273405075,
-0.6632349491119385,
-0.5927470922470093,
0.8100330233573914,
-0.057363130152225494,
-0.28642070293426514,
-0.46476584672927856,
-0.15324272215366364,
0.45760223269462585,
-0.38136792182922363,
1.0002808570861816,
0.5459086894989014,
-0.2081134021282196,
-0.07328640669584274,
-0.5066255927085876,
0.4129122793674469,
0.3550887405872345,
-0.7814763188362122,
0.034786518663167953,
0.7484516501426697,
-0.2767135798931122,
0.40267854928970337,
1.110619068145752,
-0.024715151637792587,
0.314522385597229,
0.22584332525730133,
-0.0883944183588028,
0.6329895853996277,
0.32473471760749817,
0.10479895025491714,
0.29473692178726196,
-0.21221615374088287,
-0.13131478428840637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02564v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02564v2 | A Truly Joint Neural Architecture for Segmentation and Parsing | 2024-02-04T16:56:08 | 2024-03-02T16:33:32 | Danit Yshaayahu Levi, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Contemporary multilingual dependency parsers can parse a diverse set of
languages, but for Morphologically Rich Languages (MRLs), performance is
attested to be lower than other languages. The key challenge is that, due to
high morphological complexity and ambiguity of the space-delimited input
tokens, the linguistic units that act as nodes in the tree are not known in
advance. Pre-neural dependency parsers for MRLs subscribed to the joint
morpho-syntactic hypothesis, stating that morphological segmentation and
syntactic parsing should be solved jointly, rather than as a pipeline where
segmentation precedes parsing. However, neural state-of-the-art parsers to date
use a strict pipeline. In this paper we introduce a joint neural architecture
where a lattice-based representation preserving all morphological ambiguity of
the input is provided to an arc-factored model, which then solves the
morphological segmentation and syntactic parsing tasks at once. Our experiments
on Hebrew, a rich and highly ambiguous MRL, demonstrate state-of-the-art
performance on parsing, tagging and segmentation of the Hebrew section of UD,
using a single model. This proposed architecture is LLM-based and language
agnostic, providing a solid foundation for MRLs to obtain further performance
improvements and bridge the gap with other languages. | [
-0.28650903701782227,
-0.5854480862617493,
0.4665881097316742,
0.5664859414100647,
-0.3795539140701294,
0.13942813873291016,
0.04276576638221741,
-0.6270074248313904,
0.38315334916114807,
0.22633671760559082,
-0.30953532457351685,
-0.3928312361240387,
-0.5048785209655762,
0.09324179589748383,
0.042335815727710724,
0.34367483854293823,
0.13952571153640747,
0.4738975763320923,
-0.2278946042060852,
-0.4652126729488373,
-0.3398648500442505,
-0.46015915274620056,
-0.39155492186546326,
-0.45557457208633423,
0.7287682890892029,
-0.16399531066417694,
0.8903860449790955,
1.0989642143249512,
0.2972920536994934,
0.434905469417572,
-0.4763060212135315,
0.20335030555725098,
0.34081950783729553,
0.4297993779182434,
-0.356366902589798,
-0.5953299403190613,
-0.4334687888622284,
-0.5399885773658752,
0.6175954937934875,
0.8471075296401978,
-0.17446208000183105,
-0.15212684869766235,
-0.19375337660312653,
0.5168731212615967,
-0.7863246202468872,
0.10712248086929321,
-0.7984212636947632,
0.25319740176200867,
-0.42136451601982117,
-0.08575177192687988,
-0.39622992277145386,
0.1612180918455124,
-0.17770354449748993,
-0.2893815338611603,
-0.1725296527147293,
-0.16404873132705688,
0.8493800759315491,
0.4915561079978943,
0.04658046364784241,
0.1335761994123459,
-0.3765658438205719,
0.40604323148727417,
-0.5215739011764526,
0.7701022028923035,
0.3395760953426361,
0.035036951303482056,
0.005338509567081928,
-0.6924222707748413,
-0.21535608172416687,
-0.02695862576365471,
-0.15111947059631348,
-0.006016317754983902,
-0.03268994390964508,
0.04490752890706062,
-0.07430326193571091,
0.2927968502044678,
-0.6495620608329773,
0.3142305612564087,
-0.05537780374288559,
-0.28352367877960205,
0.15481042861938477,
0.19387197494506836,
0.7731374502182007,
-0.4817180335521698,
-0.31071069836616516,
0.0796741247177124,
-0.7058910727500916,
-0.040335722267627716,
0.22939471900463104,
0.45132821798324585,
-0.1515645831823349,
0.5878258943557739,
0.26593777537345886,
0.8266535401344299,
-0.25338730216026306,
0.12334644049406052,
0.13260886073112488,
-0.1591562181711197,
-0.20654736459255219,
0.14372822642326355,
0.8603399395942688,
-0.19106073677539825,
0.21993251144886017,
-0.16449175775051117,
-0.22526323795318604,
0.17193439602851868,
0.19299177825450897,
-0.4232066869735718,
-0.17275996506214142,
0.10485445708036423,
-0.4280098080635071,
0.14423777163028717,
-0.34118083119392395,
-0.6832013726234436,
-0.35213467478752136,
-0.3003074824810028,
0.11020296066999435,
-0.5804441571235657,
-0.4349726438522339,
0.21063090860843658,
0.21297316253185272,
0.17980214953422546,
0.18134446442127228,
-1.2019908428192139,
0.2974454462528229,
0.8177168369293213,
0.9092461466789246,
0.023525891825556755,
-0.46577349305152893,
-0.38713881373405457,
0.23656219244003296,
-0.33726006746292114,
0.9264273047447205,
-0.7995957732200623,
-0.07240168005228043,
-0.1522340029478073,
-0.26474273204803467,
-0.22359547019004822,
-0.7758817672729492,
0.1876494288444519,
-0.6415138840675354,
-0.2380124181509018,
-0.029441550374031067,
-0.2491881549358368,
0.07530955970287323,
0.5261043906211853,
-0.7346712946891785,
0.8098017573356628,
0.19654490053653717,
-0.7801900506019592,
0.2879123389720917,
-0.40862005949020386,
-0.5132970809936523,
0.34404778480529785,
-0.5583450198173523,
-0.17151083052158356,
0.19658894836902618,
0.3493060767650604,
0.2698507308959961,
-0.17407044768333435,
0.6584958434104919,
-0.12480093538761139,
-0.05486755818128586,
-0.008632714860141277,
-0.5148267149925232,
0.8405491709709167,
0.07634482532739639,
-0.17340219020843506,
0.4300209581851959,
-0.8116348385810852,
0.0731949433684349,
0.08443582057952881,
-0.3999297320842743,
-0.41471368074417114,
0.08282418549060822,
-0.10329917818307877,
0.2166871428489685,
0.28605422377586365,
-0.5213518142700195,
0.09893579035997391,
-0.7095162868499756,
0.4856339395046234,
0.7495350241661072,
-0.4541988968849182,
0.3151271641254425,
0.07007751613855362,
0.2159140557050705,
0.44409361481666565,
0.059288766235113144,
-0.3623848557472229,
-0.3786059319972992,
-0.8760982155799866,
-0.32058045268058777,
0.40824422240257263,
0.46411097049713135,
-0.5996937155723572,
0.5326002836227417,
-0.21451857686042786,
-0.03894750401377678,
-0.6567816138267517,
-0.10233215242624283,
0.3017562925815582,
0.14945431053638458,
0.45069530606269836,
-0.3463652431964874,
-0.47269999980926514,
-1.1530778408050537,
0.04508013650774956,
-0.25156256556510925,
0.24336224794387817,
-0.01652589440345764,
0.11026772856712341,
0.08112946152687073,
0.7935850620269775,
-0.11879752576351166,
-0.07356736809015274,
-0.47894588112831116,
-0.11318875849246979,
0.17932797968387604,
0.5836666822433472,
0.22984571754932404,
-0.764712929725647,
-0.4072577953338623,
0.33947351574897766,
-0.720088541507721,
0.09910858422517776,
0.08665943145751953,
-0.013093930669128895,
-0.07744751125574112,
0.4541000425815582,
-0.8644315600395203,
0.2939325273036957,
0.46170589327812195,
-0.38660547137260437,
0.30663928389549255,
-0.3551558256149292,
-0.3086194694042206,
-1.0946136713027954,
0.05758605897426605,
-0.2576380968093872,
-0.1843908429145813,
-0.5587239265441895,
0.1902662068605423,
0.2847974896430969,
-0.06972822546958923,
-0.6354169249534607,
0.5644211769104004,
-0.4544726312160492,
-0.380746454000473,
-0.1753217875957489,
-0.32501253485679626,
0.2027900665998459,
0.67347651720047,
0.045711781829595566,
0.7388010025024414,
0.8743208050727844,
-0.35034194588661194,
0.08681491762399673,
0.3195067048072815,
-0.18780650198459625,
0.2350015789270401,
-0.6286018490791321,
-0.2049194872379303,
-0.24496585130691528,
0.03229626640677452,
-0.4901334345340729,
-0.1491585075855255,
0.529263436794281,
-0.1936226785182953,
0.5434374213218689,
-0.4213111996650696,
-0.5188775062561035,
0.18392319977283478,
0.07842602580785751,
0.9791073203086853,
0.13293467462062836,
-0.5587413311004639,
1.0145695209503174,
0.31803226470947266,
-0.12281691282987595,
-0.7684221267700195,
-0.8055388927459717,
0.2046123445034027,
0.13841034471988678,
-1.0039325952529907,
0.506788432598114,
0.2694890797138214,
-0.32959696650505066,
0.2669141888618469,
-0.16775403916835785,
-0.3466079831123352,
0.054558731615543365,
0.13200289011001587,
0.2329898327589035,
-0.6065535545349121,
0.13789726793766022,
-0.1586434692144394,
-0.37932348251342773,
-0.08562981337308884,
-0.3234808146953583,
1.11466383934021,
-0.09397450089454651,
-0.717750608921051,
-0.447304368019104,
0.39479219913482666,
0.6356000900268555,
-0.8549269437789917,
0.6046302318572998,
0.28776344656944275,
-0.3163071274757385,
-0.19103886187076569,
-0.44283655285835266,
0.23858028650283813,
-0.4741944670677185,
0.4709923267364502,
-0.550408661365509,
-0.812970757484436,
0.6805368661880493,
-0.00683638034388423,
-0.23889042437076569,
0.4737248420715332,
0.47134336829185486,
0.2811228036880493,
0.8888516426086426,
0.2808055579662323,
-0.06167801842093468,
0.27784717082977295,
0.0010567166609689593,
0.17516878247261047,
-0.8639305233955383,
-0.401292622089386,
-0.506280779838562,
-0.19868868589401245,
-0.35597577691078186,
-0.48851147294044495,
0.03984615206718445,
0.014112459495663643,
0.03589978814125061,
0.11031679064035416,
-0.38801005482673645,
0.7388122081756592,
0.44329938292503357,
-0.09331148117780685,
-0.014694985002279282,
-0.06679654121398926,
-0.5538707971572876,
0.13356123864650726,
-0.7554901242256165,
-0.176337331533432,
0.3979083001613617,
0.2961565852165222,
0.6109746098518372,
-0.02671091817319393,
0.4699476957321167,
-0.1400027573108673,
-0.30792561173439026,
-0.916578471660614,
0.5768213868141174,
-0.4909866452217102,
-0.359905481338501,
0.010002223774790764,
-0.39257970452308655,
-1.0071992874145508,
0.7815796732902527,
-0.020003311336040497,
-0.7939757108688354,
0.21120403707027435,
-0.10131547600030899,
-0.3916627764701843,
0.668383002281189,
-0.48025205731391907,
0.8926965594291687,
-0.4561494290828705,
-0.5505780577659607,
-0.10582869499921799,
-0.758765459060669,
0.09743968397378922,
0.30117765069007874,
0.018199555575847626,
-0.241896390914917,
0.05631319433450699,
0.5064988136291504,
-0.267169326543808,
0.6816036105155945,
-0.0980365052819252,
0.09150896221399307,
0.1842370629310608,
0.3119317591190338,
0.23214992880821228,
0.12626199424266815,
-0.06134204566478729,
0.36190396547317505,
-0.2258194088935852,
-0.38562145829200745,
-0.5654319524765015,
0.573911726474762,
-0.7009226679801941,
-0.6543867588043213,
-0.45142272114753723,
-0.7567707300186157,
-0.22125910222530365,
0.31071737408638,
-0.13825449347496033,
0.6379422545433044,
-0.05701897665858269,
-0.12215310335159302,
0.5554496645927429,
-0.3052836060523987,
0.6292583346366882,
0.07523533701896667,
-0.27436935901641846,
-0.3838370144367218,
0.8267181515693665,
-0.1129433810710907,
-0.0015587384114041924,
0.4912714958190918,
0.23251238465309143,
-0.2981792390346527,
-0.9191974997520447,
-0.9072569608688354,
0.3316432237625122,
-0.6231638193130493,
-0.12758378684520721,
-0.758134126663208,
-0.5574004054069519,
-0.14697223901748657,
-0.026723887771368027,
-0.6977275609970093,
-0.32704275846481323,
-0.12357988953590393,
0.04265361279249191,
-0.21127137541770935,
0.9200343489646912,
-0.0810132622718811,
0.14335298538208008,
-1.0411373376846313,
0.35285457968711853,
0.11913846433162689,
0.5745897889137268,
0.09056184440851212,
0.0615500882267952,
-0.11846849322319031,
-0.09093408286571503,
-0.015096387825906277,
-0.5598950982093811,
0.3132820725440979,
-0.015591653995215893,
0.589854896068573,
0.23818077147006989,
-0.44663870334625244,
0.7055860161781311,
-0.7107661366462708,
0.5727030038833618,
0.379052072763443,
-0.8073291182518005,
0.22760629653930664,
-0.14846554398536682,
0.6017885208129883,
0.5090315341949463,
0.07573563605546951,
-0.5637919306755066,
-0.25809192657470703,
-0.3719128370285034,
-0.9274754524230957,
0.8837426900863647,
0.040912993252277374,
0.03624700754880905,
-0.14016912877559662,
0.13996097445487976,
0.22546735405921936,
-0.18404854834079742,
-0.7617952227592468,
-0.28908467292785645,
-0.1076163500547409,
-0.18823103606700897,
0.4369715750217438,
-0.3510913848876953,
0.06533459573984146,
-0.25065839290618896,
0.23196083307266235,
0.10916892439126968,
0.026353750377893448,
0.045552659779787064,
-0.18644003570079803,
-0.07412856817245483,
0.37275782227516174,
0.47171109914779663,
0.810429573059082,
0.13375911116600037,
0.6375906467437744,
-0.13114294409751892,
-0.37886422872543335,
0.29485639929771423,
-0.02716628648340702,
-0.17552457749843597,
-0.005465642549097538,
0.4781531095504761,
0.8673041462898254,
0.11140471696853638,
-0.4192691147327423,
0.32912030816078186,
-0.06298645585775375,
-0.013230566866695881,
0.03824925795197487,
-0.06506496667861938,
0.5304782390594482,
0.3890080749988556,
-0.05383029207587242,
0.7010752558708191,
-0.15118204057216644,
-0.3612312972545624,
0.37264537811279297,
0.4495903253555298,
-0.30488619208335876,
-0.505275309085846,
0.2796880900859833,
0.09414102882146835,
-0.4429316222667694,
0.5950416922569275,
-0.03722996637225151,
-0.7521528005599976,
0.49859094619750977,
0.6168398261070251,
0.71607905626297,
-0.36240822076797485,
0.1548566371202469,
0.22633804380893707,
0.10610402375459671,
0.09648731350898743,
0.24481350183486938,
-0.10651727765798569,
-0.8825532793998718,
-0.6641930341720581,
-1.0772382020950317,
0.08711931109428406,
0.04327470436692238,
-0.3877240717411041,
0.02709263004362583,
-0.5845382809638977,
0.14761002361774445,
0.006951306015253067,
-0.695166289806366,
-0.39221155643463135,
0.13327158987522125,
0.25621140003204346,
0.8712207078933716,
-0.4075135886669159,
0.9590930938720703,
0.6656422019004822,
-0.1275089532136917,
-0.7670169472694397,
-0.13934357464313507,
-0.2138940840959549,
-1.1551833152770996,
0.6871100664138794,
0.25450971722602844,
-0.1676236093044281,
-0.24499420821666718,
0.11980724334716797,
-0.8243863582611084,
0.5805055499076843,
0.471865713596344,
-0.5149356126785278,
-0.08966825902462006,
0.562217652797699,
0.4701043367385864,
-0.18905939161777496,
0.14180336892604828,
0.2785119414329529,
0.42019468545913696,
0.24493251740932465,
-0.7369225025177002,
-0.04362309351563454,
-0.3772532343864441,
-0.05194446071982384,
0.8551275134086609,
-0.47852665185928345,
0.9941197037696838,
0.2208103984594345,
-0.40490972995758057,
-0.07408829778432846,
0.5112089514732361,
0.062310878187417984,
0.05097705125808716,
0.5881589651107788,
1.0496686697006226,
0.499950110912323,
-0.002179903443902731,
0.8011196851730347,
-0.48193198442459106,
-0.14011988043785095,
1.1255548000335693,
-0.24751020967960358,
0.8089367151260376,
0.4874584674835205,
-0.1049422025680542,
0.2777838706970215,
0.570558488368988,
0.15605156123638153,
0.3695967197418213,
0.26984500885009766,
-0.4920847415924072,
-0.5188126564025879,
-0.6228427290916443,
-0.348536878824234,
0.7862792015075684,
0.3597317934036255,
-0.32869839668273926,
-0.6685121059417725,
-0.32759833335876465,
-0.13688872754573822,
0.004200797062367201,
-0.2653570771217346,
0.6942196488380432,
0.07019297778606415,
-0.6800411343574524,
0.3427085280418396,
0.09614523500204086,
0.5662881731987,
-0.8855522274971008,
-0.12188529223203659,
-0.19333991408348083,
-0.06659181416034698,
-0.2677631974220276,
-0.6809821128845215,
0.5697848200798035,
-0.27392300963401794,
-0.037727441638708115,
-0.2183356136083603,
0.7006093263626099,
-0.34376129508018494,
-0.3513024151325226,
0.6642203330993652,
0.9358370304107666,
-0.035996660590171814,
0.1531604379415512,
-0.6816088557243347,
0.28931087255477905,
-0.06832017004489899,
-0.11473984271287918,
0.5338759422302246,
0.37087684869766235,
0.060306742787361145,
0.592083752155304,
0.5282323360443115,
0.25674739480018616,
0.31298142671585083,
0.4313799738883972,
1.1431611776351929,
-0.6895455121994019,
-0.4610365927219391,
-1.261400818824768,
0.639142632484436,
0.24632138013839722,
-0.30263277888298035,
0.21011056005954742,
0.5303506851196289,
0.6019062399864197,
0.30557796359062195,
0.34287768602371216,
-0.17223580181598663,
-0.24531060457229614,
-0.6269340515136719,
0.6800867319107056,
-0.7771744132041931,
0.11640123277902603,
0.20034566521644592,
-1.1411420106887817,
-0.7757830023765564,
0.5623796582221985,
-0.0236646831035614,
-0.1388411968946457,
0.808999240398407,
0.6888803839683533,
-0.35450682044029236,
0.05514374002814293,
0.6345232725143433,
0.10152950137853622,
0.17221523821353912,
0.4108600318431854,
1.0968340635299683,
0.1416732668876648,
0.3601934015750885,
-0.276694118976593,
0.14584819972515106,
0.33532050251960754,
-0.465935617685318,
-0.6822156310081482,
-0.46321097016334534,
0.07547562569379807,
-0.07900377362966537,
0.1079832911491394,
0.9195176362991333,
0.6867151260375977,
-0.5621879696846008,
-0.31819871068000793,
-0.24067600071430206,
0.05871954560279846,
0.2015264928340912,
-0.17647090554237366,
0.378118634223938,
-0.6710191369056702,
-0.4778231978416443,
0.875061571598053,
0.9669685363769531,
-0.10741492360830307,
-0.3025451898574829,
0.033145785331726074,
-0.570227324962616,
-0.2541046738624573,
0.334857314825058,
0.08038533478975296,
-0.788174569606781,
-0.13359054923057556,
-0.1312587857246399,
-0.2066245973110199,
0.7611624598503113,
0.8580562472343445,
-0.5573914647102356,
0.4267135560512543,
0.5282849073410034,
1.1019587516784668,
0.29805445671081543,
-0.09911982715129852,
0.45567676424980164,
-0.6808605790138245,
0.23964060842990875,
0.43720096349716187,
0.7384888529777527,
0.4729105830192566,
-0.18675127625465393,
0.32506024837493896,
0.15491770207881927,
-0.2632080316543579,
-0.274578720331192,
0.6466769576072693,
-0.9987450242042542,
-0.5375751852989197,
0.663474440574646,
-0.35435187816619873,
-0.5066384077072144,
-0.32979848980903625,
-0.031285759061574936,
0.1986641138792038,
-0.17348334193229675,
0.35720160603523254,
0.614171028137207,
-0.06961067020893097,
-0.3207550048828125,
0.10611940920352936,
0.13928169012069702,
0.84928297996521,
-0.7327132225036621,
0.17135044932365417,
0.4149772822856903,
-0.05853170529007912,
0.4913760721683502,
0.4764266908168793,
-0.21976161003112793,
0.1736425757408142,
0.29099223017692566,
0.0643433928489685,
-0.2627931535243988,
-0.6445052027702332,
-0.34402361512184143,
0.5958381295204163,
0.24974325299263,
-0.06306558847427368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02563v2 | Synergy-of-Thoughts: Eliciting Efficient Reasoning in Hybrid Language Models | 2024-02-04T16:45:01 | 2024-05-23T14:20:53 | Yu Shang, Yu Li, Fengli Xu, Yong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive emergent abilities in a
wide range of tasks, but still face challenges in handling complex reasoning
problems. Previous works like chain-of-thought (CoT) and tree-of-thoughts (ToT)
have predominately focused on enhancing accuracy, but overlook the rapidly
increasing token cost, which could be particularly problematic for open-ended
real-world tasks with huge solution spaces. Motivated by the dual process
theory of human cognition, we propose "Synergy of Thoughts" (SoT) to unleash
the synergistic potential of hybrid LLMs for efficient reasoning. By default,
SoT uses smaller-scale language models to generate multiple low-cost reasoning
thoughts, which resembles the parallel intuitions produced by System 1. If
these intuitions exhibit conflicts, SoT will invoke the reflective reasoning of
scaled-up language models to emulate the intervention of System 2, which will
override the intuitive thoughts and rectify the reasoning process. This
framework is model-agnostic and training-free, which can be flexibly
implemented with various off-the-shelf LLMs. Experiments on six representative
reasoning tasks show that SoT substantially reduces the token cost by
38.3%-75.1%, and simultaneously achieves state-of-the-art reasoning accuracy
and solution diversity. Notably, the average token cost reduction on open-ended
tasks reaches up to 69.1%. Code repo with all prompts will be released upon
publication. | [
-0.2736319899559021,
-0.6743606925010681,
0.7532177567481995,
-0.10450519621372223,
-0.2842830717563629,
0.39436718821525574,
-0.39839962124824524,
-0.5598353743553162,
0.2850705683231354,
0.39084959030151367,
-0.6107286214828491,
-0.11176421493291855,
-0.33656731247901917,
-0.09056486934423447,
-0.3494279682636261,
0.7646438479423523,
-0.10305052250623703,
0.019551077857613564,
-0.009638075716793537,
-0.25129204988479614,
-0.07200821489095688,
-0.4830470085144043,
-0.5539958477020264,
-0.34914690256118774,
0.4376661479473114,
0.2426508516073227,
0.6859936118125916,
0.24317695200443268,
0.455093115568161,
0.24865207076072693,
-0.07669184356927872,
0.24587631225585938,
-0.4837932586669922,
0.20491991937160492,
-0.6109890341758728,
-0.5945982336997986,
-0.4224723279476166,
0.032863762229681015,
0.4925488531589508,
0.534349799156189,
-0.32040029764175415,
0.16290123760700226,
0.006406336557120085,
0.6224341988563538,
-0.7256348133087158,
-0.1286323368549347,
-0.9252489805221558,
-0.11576994508504868,
-0.14688488841056824,
-0.09141815453767776,
-0.27576544880867004,
-0.0972215011715889,
0.12705235183238983,
-0.5377879738807678,
-0.27385348081588745,
0.27333173155784607,
0.30488473176956177,
0.31755977869033813,
-0.07744215428829193,
-0.05950058251619339,
-0.7768263816833496,
0.7812407612800598,
-0.6222757697105408,
0.3817477524280548,
-0.12140512466430664,
0.21894921362400055,
-0.22257597744464874,
-0.5201402902603149,
-1.0371583700180054,
0.0245282594114542,
0.1501634567975998,
0.43428078293800354,
-0.39615851640701294,
0.17691102623939514,
0.4951359033584595,
0.5070313215255737,
-0.4390994608402252,
-0.01320957113057375,
0.025291893631219864,
0.027495210990309715,
0.578963577747345,
0.2702617645263672,
0.27241405844688416,
0.08197199553251266,
-0.5654953718185425,
0.0798984244465828,
-0.46207478642463684,
-0.11156652867794037,
0.31578901410102844,
0.129224956035614,
0.1117217168211937,
0.4921945333480835,
-0.21547432243824005,
0.5537706613540649,
-0.08462313562631607,
-0.1439143419265747,
-0.09755978733301163,
-0.7862627506256104,
-0.23868125677108765,
-0.22182947397232056,
0.8291535973548889,
0.24018380045890808,
0.07909710705280304,
-0.2549843192100525,
-0.4326654374599457,
0.6857433915138245,
0.1941426396369934,
-0.40010276436805725,
-0.22290949523448944,
0.15472131967544556,
-0.49328333139419556,
-0.19891327619552612,
-0.1835871785879135,
-0.48179003596305847,
-0.2477213442325592,
-0.37613645195961,
0.3494533896446228,
-0.3807424008846283,
-0.5700765252113342,
0.41028326749801636,
-0.2041502594947815,
-0.010247715748846531,
0.40714335441589355,
-0.6562186479568481,
0.5603978037834167,
0.6220327019691467,
0.4277110695838928,
-0.22371123731136322,
-0.30934369564056396,
-0.2678947150707245,
0.09659852832555771,
-0.08538734167814255,
0.8147444725036621,
-0.46272870898246765,
-0.16226890683174133,
-0.5574636459350586,
-0.6786543130874634,
-0.1688380390405655,
-0.5592511892318726,
0.4175333082675934,
-0.24869176745414734,
0.30300384759902954,
-0.4120854139328003,
-0.45831969380378723,
0.1078774631023407,
0.2939625084400177,
-0.5282257795333862,
1.0927971601486206,
0.014746501110494137,
-1.0631905794143677,
0.18870271742343903,
-0.805496096611023,
-0.4223213493824005,
0.2887904644012451,
-0.4385794401168823,
0.04564788192510605,
0.11038242280483246,
0.010915343649685383,
0.052429188042879105,
-0.8128836154937744,
0.24416930973529816,
-0.2494708150625229,
-0.1426505446434021,
0.06319676339626312,
-0.21881772577762604,
0.9301966428756714,
0.4960429072380066,
-0.535076379776001,
0.23344528675079346,
-0.4330509305000305,
0.07101583480834961,
0.3928622007369995,
-0.12034434825181961,
-0.44818729162216187,
-0.15233732759952545,
-0.35167521238327026,
0.30797621607780457,
0.22903479635715485,
-0.5817640423774719,
0.2081134021282196,
-0.4514967203140259,
0.4466404914855957,
0.5544822812080383,
-0.27449560165405273,
0.5234463214874268,
-0.34747153520584106,
0.4861743152141571,
0.05521271005272865,
0.23933953046798706,
-0.008255957625806332,
-0.4591071605682373,
-0.8796327710151672,
-0.2934955954551697,
0.0007394581334665418,
0.5093492269515991,
-0.976245641708374,
0.4781036376953125,
-0.05335346236824989,
-0.38408464193344116,
-0.6458697319030762,
0.09842432290315628,
0.5464988946914673,
0.44864794611930847,
0.15380719304084778,
-0.3135908246040344,
-0.45888814330101013,
-0.8355315923690796,
-0.5636878609657288,
-0.2701604962348938,
0.4051492214202881,
0.10408560931682587,
0.5491918921470642,
0.1172386109828949,
0.9771596789360046,
-0.3454988896846771,
0.22361382842063904,
-0.5786014199256897,
0.07627350091934204,
0.06596855074167252,
0.27433857321739197,
0.12755809724330902,
-0.6559935808181763,
-0.24861489236354828,
-0.06113913655281067,
-0.5362206101417542,
0.1031026691198349,
-0.138523131608963,
-0.3801955282688141,
0.12937910854816437,
0.16793350875377655,
-0.8923312425613403,
0.25125792622566223,
0.3824080526828766,
-0.238705575466156,
0.6865987777709961,
-0.3009698688983917,
-0.11186913400888443,
-1.2192051410675049,
0.1433579921722412,
-0.10148848593235016,
-0.12488701194524765,
-0.4956974983215332,
0.2923116087913513,
-0.11196339875459671,
-0.012076731771230698,
-0.15298239886760712,
0.5120778679847717,
-0.45196813344955444,
-0.047509144991636276,
-0.3774179518222809,
0.2120862603187561,
-0.005302694160491228,
0.49663132429122925,
0.1601584106683731,
0.7345402240753174,
0.4117545783519745,
-0.19033917784690857,
0.4581640958786011,
-0.03549903631210327,
-0.4705338180065155,
0.4538847506046295,
-0.1680281162261963,
0.3607550263404846,
-0.02851286344230175,
0.554807186126709,
-0.6549363136291504,
0.13161537051200867,
0.22073803842067719,
-0.06872504949569702,
-0.055532198399305344,
0.4331967830657959,
-0.9394593238830566,
-0.623869001865387,
-0.2566521465778351,
0.4505358636379242,
0.46776753664016724,
-0.6384400725364685,
0.6763788461685181,
0.6018878221511841,
-0.034056324511766434,
-0.6001416444778442,
-0.5174789428710938,
0.05143796280026436,
0.016057347878813744,
-0.491637259721756,
0.28281688690185547,
0.06222261115908623,
-0.513930082321167,
0.23133452236652374,
-0.30072155594825745,
0.3343300223350525,
0.16034561395645142,
-0.21110382676124573,
0.35393401980400085,
-0.036064665764570236,
0.2586567997932434,
0.01480921357870102,
-0.14985482394695282,
0.023724321275949478,
-1.0597854852676392,
0.39113131165504456,
-0.34577086567878723,
-0.526152491569519,
-0.18372519314289093,
0.446189820766449,
0.6195066571235657,
-0.4831313490867615,
0.48632901906967163,
0.20999178290367126,
-0.43844109773635864,
-0.5604571104049683,
-0.7420729994773865,
-0.4001942276954651,
-0.36645469069480896,
0.29880648851394653,
-0.5118801593780518,
-0.9427629709243774,
0.4579868018627167,
-0.2919280529022217,
0.10789695382118225,
0.1917879581451416,
0.7950690388679504,
-0.20432166755199432,
0.9248554110527039,
0.31651991605758667,
-0.008622508496046066,
0.36656641960144043,
-0.366575688123703,
0.7660511136054993,
-0.7329438328742981,
-0.21605855226516724,
-0.1153697595000267,
-0.5581315159797668,
-0.22867004573345184,
-0.8165923357009888,
0.32431283593177795,
0.14605385065078735,
0.06639079749584198,
0.3541466295719147,
-0.5793440937995911,
0.6283716559410095,
0.7126702666282654,
0.1369449347257614,
0.4919067919254303,
-0.32137420773506165,
-0.49281638860702515,
0.34270599484443665,
-1.1139142513275146,
-0.3869864046573639,
0.9069142937660217,
0.1379009336233139,
0.6164054870605469,
-0.07695447653532028,
0.7283542156219482,
-0.07102074474096298,
0.15462546050548553,
-0.5784267783164978,
0.9839136004447937,
-0.03716141730546951,
-0.6922623515129089,
-0.2957944869995117,
-0.47862595319747925,
-0.6811696290969849,
0.3576352298259735,
-0.34373340010643005,
-0.7976222038269043,
-0.1589416116476059,
0.23846623301506042,
-0.5960805416107178,
0.8037021160125732,
-0.5872319936752319,
0.7268875241279602,
-0.47014304995536804,
-0.46943050622940063,
-0.8470652103424072,
-0.7345085740089417,
0.558947741985321,
-0.049833033233881,
0.11750809848308563,
0.037096910178661346,
0.05594578757882118,
0.7281040549278259,
-0.49069926142692566,
0.5865721702575684,
0.07346197962760925,
-0.060881081968545914,
0.6581557393074036,
0.009641903452575207,
0.7046501636505127,
-0.44189152121543884,
0.1615598201751709,
-0.179316908121109,
-0.266742080450058,
-0.24957053363323212,
-0.8131118416786194,
0.6480247378349304,
-0.46177002787590027,
-0.7324080467224121,
-0.2599990963935852,
-0.9029054045677185,
-0.20037931203842163,
0.12866905331611633,
0.11595366895198822,
0.24500244855880737,
-0.04387862607836723,
-0.32497650384902954,
0.5188366174697876,
-0.009320955723524094,
0.10798610001802444,
0.2581299841403961,
-0.29870250821113586,
-0.3928503394126892,
0.8731594085693359,
0.018496207892894745,
0.5712974071502686,
0.27230632305145264,
0.23099403083324432,
-0.43991246819496155,
-0.399036705493927,
-0.2790956497192383,
0.27519482374191284,
-0.7317140102386475,
-0.1131097748875618,
-0.7878465056419373,
-0.0924011841416359,
-0.11622122675180435,
0.03411902114748955,
-0.422148197889328,
-0.8057570457458496,
0.22239147126674652,
-0.2128853052854538,
0.30150893330574036,
0.5683486461639404,
0.017270129173994064,
-0.1131264865398407,
-0.48978784680366516,
0.20116326212882996,
0.3688157796859741,
0.24881014227867126,
0.4385487735271454,
-0.16737069189548492,
-0.224472776055336,
-0.032899290323257446,
-0.40482857823371887,
-0.6488165855407715,
0.05517341569066048,
-0.36670100688934326,
0.6197102665901184,
0.1702716052532196,
0.14792457222938538,
0.5753029584884644,
-0.21412768959999084,
0.5494498014450073,
0.7741446495056152,
-0.9131909608840942,
0.5950924754142761,
-0.2849506437778473,
0.2950858473777771,
0.504000723361969,
0.06549724191427231,
-0.3135395646095276,
-0.7352063655853271,
-0.8982555270195007,
-0.599302351474762,
0.7210906147956848,
0.19591110944747925,
-0.29562023282051086,
-0.13799719512462616,
0.04084153100848198,
0.26596543192863464,
0.11408673971891403,
-0.503371000289917,
-0.028390608727931976,
0.11352871358394623,
-0.24946089088916779,
0.18545196950435638,
0.04998741298913956,
-0.13386784493923187,
-0.49446022510528564,
0.5182051658630371,
-0.1444130390882492,
0.1294107288122177,
0.022396370768547058,
0.011434471234679222,
-0.35025033354759216,
0.49936166405677795,
0.2941257059574127,
0.34371018409729004,
0.16594275832176208,
0.5624430179595947,
0.494172066450119,
0.05564721301198006,
0.16355828940868378,
-0.13372136652469635,
-0.08060963451862335,
-0.375212699174881,
0.08550117909908295,
0.8360674381256104,
0.27614620327949524,
-0.7720813155174255,
0.34195390343666077,
0.10505577176809311,
-0.25178176164627075,
0.10712184756994247,
0.20417965948581696,
0.5873258709907532,
0.504906952381134,
0.01260467804968357,
0.45447203516960144,
0.2633100748062134,
-0.8208691477775574,
-0.05451501905918121,
0.6723493337631226,
0.004343900829553604,
-0.40949422121047974,
0.5442149043083191,
0.5525604486465454,
-0.3180243670940399,
0.5001363754272461,
-0.4549151062965393,
-0.9174218773841858,
0.2477051019668579,
0.6296552419662476,
1.0556433200836182,
0.1770259290933609,
-0.09448036551475525,
0.09818319231271744,
0.07790887355804443,
-0.29632094502449036,
0.6986338496208191,
-0.4385230839252472,
-0.9817399382591248,
-0.5980693697929382,
-0.4482234716415405,
-0.45610252022743225,
-0.01884886622428894,
-0.34115225076675415,
0.09000588953495026,
-0.47871217131614685,
-0.4331486225128174,
-0.14647571742534637,
0.1225132867693901,
-0.41686955094337463,
-0.031789857894182205,
0.5374166369438171,
1.1613993644714355,
-0.6971872448921204,
1.014763593673706,
0.7285599112510681,
-0.24795344471931458,
-0.9914877414703369,
0.022084519267082214,
-0.04899708926677704,
-0.5817795991897583,
0.5900735855102539,
0.034104518592357635,
-0.7133866548538208,
0.17545905709266663,
-0.20189255475997925,
-0.6041632294654846,
1.026760220527649,
0.618709146976471,
-0.8176808953285217,
-0.20093019306659698,
-0.12872235476970673,
0.4591978192329407,
-0.4275986850261688,
0.30332669615745544,
0.7096166610717773,
0.3445734679698944,
0.10022427886724472,
-1.2487964630126953,
0.1854480504989624,
-0.3948333263397217,
-0.16129286587238312,
0.5310279726982117,
-0.852741539478302,
0.7295975685119629,
-0.6328341960906982,
-0.4613068997859955,
-0.039653174579143524,
0.4449797570705414,
0.43788230419158936,
0.20972216129302979,
0.7377766966819763,
0.9635056853294373,
0.9249144196510315,
0.07858408987522125,
1.0435932874679565,
-0.4553985595703125,
0.1298588514328003,
1.0068786144256592,
-0.6352962255477905,
0.7989416122436523,
0.713407576084137,
-0.26567697525024414,
0.5684787034988403,
0.10913389176130295,
0.39380326867103577,
0.36551955342292786,
0.2932727038860321,
-0.44001132249832153,
-0.602778434753418,
-0.22149981558322906,
-0.09477833658456802,
0.24183852970600128,
0.22614936530590057,
-0.03599902242422104,
-0.16197343170642853,
-0.08820417523384094,
-0.21397706866264343,
0.3345969319343567,
-0.03778199851512909,
0.7416753172874451,
0.3795856833457947,
-0.9119049906730652,
0.3537522256374359,
-0.3710676431655884,
0.7189047336578369,
-0.41047781705856323,
0.1916038542985916,
0.16534046828746796,
0.43919914960861206,
0.06924528628587723,
-0.7675971984863281,
0.19312487542629242,
0.10576221346855164,
-0.2196129858493805,
-0.6212328672409058,
0.8216188549995422,
-0.4904944896697998,
-0.41369950771331787,
0.7157641649246216,
0.8483896255493164,
0.04809608310461044,
0.01846957392990589,
-0.896156907081604,
0.028761258348822594,
-0.06911879032850266,
-0.07150297611951828,
0.29109513759613037,
0.40073779225349426,
-0.11334063857793808,
0.7088423371315002,
0.7233423590660095,
0.4156516492366791,
-0.22641229629516602,
0.24408701062202454,
1.092861294746399,
-0.6258491277694702,
-0.5904368758201599,
-0.9362044334411621,
0.26236626505851746,
-0.27871814370155334,
-0.08458513021469116,
0.4872239828109741,
0.5634381175041199,
0.8694843649864197,
0.23512014746665955,
0.9591427445411682,
0.051926981657743454,
0.6228719353675842,
-0.4110700488090515,
0.6234885454177856,
-0.6483711004257202,
0.23672384023666382,
-0.18863214552402496,
-0.84172123670578,
-0.053628500550985336,
0.5499451756477356,
-0.5553262829780579,
-0.13807588815689087,
0.979964017868042,
0.6534056663513184,
-0.09418746083974838,
0.6261634826660156,
0.1835557371377945,
-0.024022962898015976,
0.0031450686510652304,
1.0341616868972778,
1.308447003364563,
0.007666561286896467,
0.33770743012428284,
-0.2246231883764267,
-0.4055008292198181,
-0.08284930139780045,
-0.7103004455566406,
-0.7529027462005615,
-0.36423689126968384,
-0.19046537578105927,
-0.28842276334762573,
0.18545465171337128,
1.3482860326766968,
0.601101279258728,
-0.6197080016136169,
-0.457522988319397,
-0.4376191198825836,
-0.019653726369142532,
-0.2740848660469055,
-0.11996156722307205,
0.12304054200649261,
-0.3755071461200714,
-0.3582382798194885,
0.2539254128932953,
0.7062880396842957,
-0.1309720128774643,
-0.41500118374824524,
-0.26025113463401794,
-0.2740831673145294,
0.24479368329048157,
0.4657236635684967,
0.0534556582570076,
-1.0966248512268066,
-0.06808202713727951,
0.19944533705711365,
-0.23121853172779083,
-0.079512819647789,
1.049069881439209,
-0.8364166021347046,
0.6295456290245056,
0.540798544883728,
0.5048164129257202,
0.3436805307865143,
-0.0815507248044014,
0.6993937492370605,
-0.1561293601989746,
0.2269958108663559,
0.5975896120071411,
0.5235611796379089,
0.014446205459535122,
-0.1003589779138565,
0.36695295572280884,
0.387599378824234,
-0.21606534719467163,
-0.8547331690788269,
0.5282641649246216,
-0.8425317406654358,
-0.33643609285354614,
0.8942331075668335,
-0.09484600275754929,
-0.23644724488258362,
0.053491849452257156,
-0.20246854424476624,
0.28787127137184143,
-0.33244580030441284,
0.6623930335044861,
0.6157675981521606,
-0.31879153847694397,
-0.15196600556373596,
0.0739419013261795,
0.3394738733768463,
0.9796485900878906,
-0.8970748782157898,
0.43467703461647034,
0.1760580688714981,
-0.11086558550596237,
0.29288408160209656,
0.827796995639801,
0.08089267462491989,
0.31078657507896423,
0.30106672644615173,
0.1562853455543518,
0.07853277027606964,
-0.3595122694969177,
0.035394132137298584,
-0.1313427984714508,
0.13849681615829468,
0.02224516123533249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02559v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02559v1 | NavHint: Vision and Language Navigation Agent with a Hint Generator | 2024-02-04T16:23:16 | 2024-02-04T16:23:16 | Yue Zhang, Quan Guo, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing work on vision and language navigation mainly relies on
navigation-related losses to establish the connection between vision and
language modalities, neglecting aspects of helping the navigation agent build a
deep understanding of the visual environment. In our work, we provide indirect
supervision to the navigation agent through a hint generator that provides
detailed visual descriptions. The hint generator assists the navigation agent
in developing a global understanding of the visual environment. It directs the
agent's attention toward related navigation details, including the relevant
sub-instruction, potential challenges in recognition and ambiguities in
grounding, and the targeted viewpoint description. To train the hint generator,
we construct a synthetic dataset based on landmarks in the instructions and
visible and distinctive objects in the visual environment. We evaluate our
method on the R2R and R4R datasets and achieve state-of-the-art on several
metrics. The experimental results demonstrate that generating hints not only
enhances the navigation performance but also helps improve the interpretability
of the agent's actions. | [
-0.2323872447013855,
-0.5601661801338196,
0.6280216574668884,
0.07402606308460236,
-0.34424638748168945,
-0.09982197731733322,
-0.1720675528049469,
-0.3525485098361969,
0.03269828483462334,
0.39872461557388306,
-0.8420332074165344,
-0.49911364912986755,
-0.10371781140565872,
-0.1153956726193428,
-0.14835679531097412,
0.9032350778579712,
0.17346246540546417,
-0.11422013491392136,
-0.05411951243877411,
0.008567810989916325,
-0.9507186412811279,
-0.09253662079572678,
-0.8105459213256836,
-0.28356051445007324,
0.6203237175941467,
0.6293273568153381,
0.5713111162185669,
0.6071569919586182,
0.619787871837616,
0.30891484022140503,
0.2451632022857666,
0.20540985465049744,
-0.4487696886062622,
0.5064248442649841,
-0.4563620388507843,
-0.5476301312446594,
-0.42632946372032166,
-0.27249762415885925,
0.5292722582817078,
0.34543290734291077,
0.10161051899194717,
0.14882275462150574,
-0.13785898685455322,
0.7781944274902344,
-0.6846538186073303,
0.6255815029144287,
-0.4067594110965729,
0.12342043966054916,
-0.2657483220100403,
-0.5585644245147705,
-0.12514005601406097,
-0.2939983308315277,
0.3273925483226776,
-0.9980322122573853,
0.3750571608543396,
0.1825595200061798,
0.7388498187065125,
0.7371516227722168,
-0.41437458992004395,
-0.2712588310241699,
-0.7423923015594482,
0.7720898389816284,
-0.10520854592323303,
0.4432893395423889,
0.025751784443855286,
0.8453068733215332,
-0.1252869963645935,
-0.6021972298622131,
-0.3377430737018585,
-0.14105652272701263,
0.11345469206571579,
0.5916382670402527,
0.08289240300655365,
0.08331391215324402,
0.22793683409690857,
-0.011458808556199074,
-0.48280730843544006,
-0.41357818245887756,
-0.4576427638530731,
-0.3945625126361847,
0.5193577408790588,
0.08243954926729202,
0.22330708801746368,
-0.26911985874176025,
-0.5917297601699829,
-0.39828118681907654,
-0.9770157337188721,
0.13916999101638794,
0.08638627082109451,
0.4020410180091858,
0.07409188151359558,
0.44949081540107727,
-0.6174203753471375,
0.9891380071640015,
0.06011846661567688,
-0.3371872901916504,
0.19766190648078918,
-0.6308150291442871,
-0.020714744925498962,
0.37206968665122986,
0.44655895233154297,
0.8131735920906067,
0.6053507924079895,
-0.05598624050617218,
-0.40615031123161316,
-0.23560020327568054,
0.391574889421463,
-0.39425912499427795,
-0.5489766597747803,
-0.09595023095607758,
-0.2797130048274994,
-0.33500126004219055,
0.0726674273610115,
-0.6537747383117676,
-0.6048615574836731,
-0.24076557159423828,
0.30071768164634705,
-0.524761974811554,
-0.5050275921821594,
-0.11031308025121689,
-0.514676570892334,
0.9501478672027588,
0.6149625182151794,
-0.49937161803245544,
-0.20044872164726257,
0.28718170523643494,
0.639788806438446,
0.0024742395617067814,
-0.2888704240322113,
-0.7711847424507141,
0.4417782127857208,
-0.22037702798843384,
0.8061197996139526,
-0.4602430462837219,
-0.5556591153144836,
0.14241959154605865,
-0.011669986881315708,
-0.02922322414815426,
-0.2398502677679062,
0.3131728172302246,
-0.38827815651893616,
-0.013197744265198708,
-0.4519210755825043,
-0.06443898379802704,
-0.5805191993713379,
0.4310622215270996,
-0.607068657875061,
0.7747258543968201,
0.1152079701423645,
-0.5787712335586548,
0.4732866585254669,
-0.5549207925796509,
-0.5735834836959839,
0.6212978363037109,
-0.4024769961833954,
-0.18672910332679749,
0.17057478427886963,
0.46800389885902405,
0.18839162588119507,
0.027626780793070793,
-0.19739556312561035,
0.455329030752182,
-0.36167335510253906,
-0.040530167520046234,
-0.2850322425365448,
0.5267977714538574,
-0.06486015766859055,
-0.6084997057914734,
0.03986840695142746,
-0.5375785827636719,
0.13183623552322388,
0.13640297949314117,
-0.5134787559509277,
-0.40227457880973816,
0.008129158057272434,
0.11926113069057465,
0.05927865952253342,
0.49007686972618103,
-0.2281363308429718,
0.31081274151802063,
-0.4494568407535553,
-0.17035777866840363,
0.5750302076339722,
0.5239689350128174,
0.47408780455589294,
0.02591538615524769,
0.9655844569206238,
-0.10874159634113312,
0.28855204582214355,
-0.3931126892566681,
-0.9492875337600708,
-1.053383231163025,
0.16802144050598145,
0.038523782044649124,
0.6442791819572449,
-1.4756780862808228,
0.007140063215047121,
-0.6074118614196777,
-0.2575973868370056,
-0.33757174015045166,
0.006328888703137636,
0.9495302438735962,
0.5644712448120117,
0.2836528420448303,
-0.10921575874090195,
-0.5490414500236511,
-0.7167230248451233,
-0.20739643275737762,
-0.19465577602386475,
0.18551862239837646,
0.25899001955986023,
0.43566325306892395,
-0.0007458620821125805,
1.0282063484191895,
-0.26500776410102844,
-0.3471779525279999,
-0.4576774537563324,
-0.1913587898015976,
-0.25944986939430237,
0.4790554940700531,
0.42713460326194763,
-1.0116616487503052,
-0.39795413613319397,
0.25384044647216797,
-0.8063434362411499,
0.002818711567670107,
-0.22850631177425385,
-0.1892963945865631,
0.04405290260910988,
0.713228166103363,
-0.523218035697937,
0.5931935906410217,
0.14282500743865967,
-0.3507939279079437,
0.5303995609283447,
-0.2981123924255371,
0.07710769027471542,
-0.9676766395568848,
-0.21066251397132874,
-0.012140758335590363,
-0.2831818759441376,
-0.6043598055839539,
0.19250959157943726,
-0.0385163314640522,
0.10387808829545975,
-0.41087713837623596,
0.6071836948394775,
-0.7355260252952576,
-0.13097001612186432,
-0.1256377100944519,
0.3390917181968689,
-0.03791309893131256,
0.48223257064819336,
0.35993409156799316,
0.7140588164329529,
0.7300955057144165,
-0.7227329015731812,
0.7074962258338928,
0.27897894382476807,
-0.12710770964622498,
0.9397570490837097,
-0.5682349801063538,
0.12679526209831238,
-0.1642356812953949,
0.0646011009812355,
-0.8544052243232727,
-0.4046626091003418,
0.49845194816589355,
-0.6260736584663391,
0.3118784725666046,
-0.5969935059547424,
-0.26126211881637573,
-0.23116867244243622,
-0.1349865198135376,
0.44440072774887085,
0.6622697710990906,
-0.5833471417427063,
0.6738454103469849,
0.014617265202105045,
-0.07472552359104156,
-0.6528890132904053,
-0.5504952669143677,
0.17231401801109314,
-0.2537047863006592,
-0.4151804745197296,
0.0471157468855381,
0.22658079862594604,
-0.2527511715888977,
-0.05292344093322754,
-0.2251545637845993,
0.33480456471443176,
-0.2806573212146759,
0.6363120079040527,
0.12314345687627792,
-0.12652869522571564,
0.2098950743675232,
-0.1295287162065506,
-0.42316734790802,
0.2946777045726776,
-0.6133613586425781,
0.16471368074417114,
-0.3436639904975891,
-0.40350645780563354,
-0.25058987736701965,
-0.061959125101566315,
0.21990838646888733,
-0.6311765909194946,
0.06343109905719757,
0.5525758862495422,
-0.043317761272192,
-0.3216000199317932,
-0.37714362144470215,
-0.14216431975364685,
-0.5626729726791382,
0.3596184253692627,
-0.7571674585342407,
-0.11880762875080109,
0.29539886116981506,
-0.3198809027671814,
-0.10210403800010681,
0.3027234375476837,
0.34430021047592163,
-0.013817096129059792,
0.9192501902580261,
0.748583197593689,
0.11618656665086746,
0.594743549823761,
-0.5277903079986572,
0.14992325007915497,
-0.809653639793396,
-0.7573395371437073,
-0.07437219470739365,
-0.21865026652812958,
-0.5367161631584167,
-0.6991801857948303,
0.5836656093597412,
-0.23195144534111023,
0.11740939319133759,
0.16810378432273865,
-0.7502768635749817,
0.6433113813400269,
0.9821986556053162,
-0.11501079797744751,
0.2083672434091568,
0.12479174137115479,
-0.22441378235816956,
0.0959305465221405,
-0.9214256405830383,
-0.3077901303768158,
0.9165025353431702,
-0.07732542604207993,
0.788159191608429,
-0.02246597222983837,
0.8494922518730164,
0.10138377547264099,
-0.22525155544281006,
-0.799892008304596,
0.7087075114250183,
0.6630474925041199,
-0.3727819621562958,
-0.1821831613779068,
-0.24185708165168762,
-0.8769939541816711,
0.05317794159054756,
-0.04044578596949577,
-0.4903319478034973,
0.17026066780090332,
0.284737229347229,
-0.1950138956308365,
-0.10339967161417007,
-0.7451128363609314,
0.8656007647514343,
-0.2762182652950287,
-0.14538274705410004,
0.02741062641143799,
-0.9749549031257629,
0.2906983494758606,
0.35227447748184204,
-0.033215515315532684,
0.34418144822120667,
-0.05267505347728729,
0.5428944826126099,
-0.33948057889938354,
0.6386816501617432,
-0.5526190400123596,
-0.14320670068264008,
0.47005993127822876,
0.19453705847263336,
0.3996046185493469,
0.1291678547859192,
0.356681227684021,
-0.16327185928821564,
-0.38241979479789734,
-0.241973876953125,
-0.5216726660728455,
0.7459065318107605,
-0.40194448828697205,
-0.4675297737121582,
-0.49464085698127747,
-0.6457527875900269,
-0.0728582963347435,
0.25406524538993835,
0.4296596646308899,
0.6199020743370056,
-0.10520189255475998,
-0.1882672905921936,
0.7677779793739319,
-0.32134678959846497,
0.29831168055534363,
0.43400245904922485,
-0.2048313170671463,
-0.022274013608694077,
1.259732723236084,
-0.15541017055511475,
0.13655658066272736,
0.41785192489624023,
-0.11279407143592834,
-0.4453248977661133,
-0.6493172645568848,
-0.6067661643028259,
-0.0027929069474339485,
-1.1061948537826538,
-0.23608264327049255,
0.07744963467121124,
-0.2198375016450882,
0.04218865558505058,
-0.2936996519565582,
-0.23673227429389954,
-0.4787294864654541,
0.24501146376132965,
-0.16745837032794952,
0.6056939363479614,
1.1769837141036987,
-0.2006048560142517,
0.218740776181221,
-0.44510188698768616,
0.2425685077905655,
0.4934091567993164,
-0.08489809185266495,
-0.15940281748771667,
-0.1448204070329666,
-0.3994489908218384,
0.034063585102558136,
0.08630333095788956,
-0.7373380661010742,
0.040718287229537964,
0.20464281737804413,
0.5584800243377686,
0.5526196956634521,
-0.1423315405845642,
0.48401591181755066,
-0.45013466477394104,
0.9379483461380005,
0.12079020589590073,
-0.44921475648880005,
1.1286900043487549,
-0.43463432788848877,
0.8439728617668152,
0.3769181966781616,
-0.17015329003334045,
-0.3219291567802429,
-0.7328279614448547,
-0.45083457231521606,
-0.6525651216506958,
0.49727559089660645,
0.47743669152259827,
-0.28849923610687256,
0.1587217152118683,
0.5614559650421143,
-0.2982136309146881,
0.13872548937797546,
-0.3861222267150879,
-0.35077062249183655,
-0.42186814546585083,
-0.27925097942352295,
-0.04941537603735924,
0.05359787866473198,
-0.11088107526302338,
-0.16920039057731628,
0.6069439649581909,
-0.19135689735412598,
0.18224161863327026,
0.35852834582328796,
-0.4304521083831787,
0.11291232705116272,
-0.09060876816511154,
0.5248353481292725,
0.6148287653923035,
-0.23632797598838806,
0.2774437963962555,
-0.11478009074926376,
-0.8027927279472351,
-0.000056622808187967166,
0.013605094514787197,
-0.4998879134654999,
0.1987791508436203,
0.5722294449806213,
0.5776576399803162,
0.03469598665833473,
-0.575503408908844,
0.5085318684577942,
-0.17999626696109772,
0.02423691935837269,
-0.4132806360721588,
0.47383227944374084,
0.05124863609671593,
0.3796345293521881,
0.2891656160354614,
0.27470001578330994,
0.2622853219509125,
-0.233870267868042,
-0.10292316973209381,
0.5016006827354431,
-0.6706974506378174,
-0.3687281608581543,
0.7469677329063416,
0.49348488450050354,
-0.373390793800354,
0.7209376096725464,
-0.48724690079689026,
-0.673308253288269,
0.6822153925895691,
0.14086242020130157,
0.8308684825897217,
-0.22267943620681763,
0.29132792353630066,
0.3823135197162628,
0.4475574195384979,
0.21590827405452728,
0.4854975938796997,
-0.3445470631122589,
-0.48597511649131775,
-0.27457529306411743,
-0.4927399158477783,
-0.2575637698173523,
-0.3282260596752167,
-0.7216250896453857,
-0.08654451370239258,
-0.13815675675868988,
-0.0018576873699203134,
-0.32688045501708984,
0.024222353473305702,
-1.0173505544662476,
0.2576383948326111,
0.2504669725894928,
0.6973572969436646,
-0.4353780150413513,
0.8280884027481079,
1.0929827690124512,
-0.7659212946891785,
-0.6738618016242981,
0.23073424398899078,
0.11484542489051819,
-0.9026179313659668,
0.8554683327674866,
0.2142477184534073,
-0.7701739072799683,
0.24234271049499512,
-0.429875910282135,
-0.7403824329376221,
1.3223809003829956,
0.02177034690976143,
-0.3979600667953491,
-0.11630106717348099,
0.036599233746528625,
0.36035165190696716,
-0.3348422646522522,
0.019384389743208885,
0.6537092328071594,
0.6905161738395691,
0.11854973435401917,
-0.8115308284759521,
0.21912871301174164,
-0.3510708510875702,
0.19746898114681244,
0.017665604129433632,
-0.4148198962211609,
0.4662516713142395,
-0.6510695815086365,
-0.27160006761550903,
0.1585281938314438,
0.38645219802856445,
0.09405707567930222,
0.16841337084770203,
0.45364636182785034,
0.323183536529541,
0.5585514307022095,
-0.28760290145874023,
1.312585473060608,
-0.39205023646354675,
-0.0002513279323466122,
1.1610698699951172,
0.08923711627721786,
0.4380883276462555,
0.5696782469749451,
0.45664727687835693,
0.6716231107711792,
0.3139820396900177,
0.20272645354270935,
0.9075090885162354,
-0.021653098985552788,
-0.26953989267349243,
-0.32126450538635254,
-0.16089287400245667,
-0.39913660287857056,
0.47733116149902344,
0.5775715708732605,
-0.10065615922212601,
-0.4231603741645813,
0.11916444450616837,
-0.29257461428642273,
-0.19213959574699402,
-0.507803201675415,
0.8717865347862244,
0.015069108456373215,
-0.7784615159034729,
0.5171377658843994,
-0.22033417224884033,
0.24186283349990845,
-0.613983690738678,
-0.38730180263519287,
-0.22800087928771973,
0.36290067434310913,
-0.10781572014093399,
-0.8044189214706421,
-0.24947042763233185,
-0.17711637914180756,
0.22498202323913574,
-0.25717222690582275,
0.9485021829605103,
-0.505791962146759,
-0.3351210653781891,
-0.052745286375284195,
0.7465446591377258,
0.23991084098815918,
-0.2818186283111572,
-0.5683062672615051,
-0.09777627885341644,
0.2570662498474121,
-0.3191234767436981,
-0.1408139020204544,
0.6082115173339844,
0.03478464111685753,
0.8870120048522949,
0.34282591938972473,
0.16271346807479858,
0.3215816020965576,
0.1561017632484436,
0.6751206517219543,
-0.8163869380950928,
-0.48946595191955566,
-0.5239229798316956,
0.5446488857269287,
-0.28059646487236023,
-0.33474797010421753,
1.2357895374298096,
0.4892980456352234,
0.6652032732963562,
-0.23704181611537933,
1.0256931781768799,
-0.029510434716939926,
-0.08256649971008301,
-0.7470209002494812,
0.6126149892807007,
-0.4530304968357086,
0.06252313405275345,
0.08392773568630219,
-1.053381323814392,
-0.07732776552438736,
0.8901915550231934,
-0.25444328784942627,
0.13189473748207092,
0.725209653377533,
0.9955060482025146,
-0.12923234701156616,
-0.4695548713207245,
0.13713324069976807,
-0.03280120715498924,
0.38403335213661194,
0.7812398672103882,
1.0001602172851562,
-0.452804297208786,
0.8560609817504883,
-0.20461110770702362,
-0.009694766253232956,
-0.3431803584098816,
-0.5698425769805908,
-1.009358525276184,
-0.673274576663971,
-0.4194115996360779,
-0.18694552779197693,
0.3614344596862793,
0.2592456340789795,
0.8094078302383423,
-0.2554026246070862,
0.04256897047162056,
-0.35908839106559753,
0.28184211254119873,
-0.3772736191749573,
-0.24022895097732544,
0.35348573327064514,
-0.419220894575119,
-0.6238332390785217,
0.7356350421905518,
0.4552241563796997,
0.2293083518743515,
-0.6268892288208008,
-0.44600552320480347,
0.07990682125091553,
-0.1585434526205063,
0.4770528972148895,
0.3414042890071869,
-0.7467644810676575,
-0.3623839020729065,
-0.11102766543626785,
0.17631149291992188,
-0.04943031817674637,
0.6971772909164429,
-1.0918605327606201,
0.929246723651886,
0.3238811492919922,
0.1214173287153244,
0.5562955141067505,
0.20298145711421967,
0.8214389681816101,
-1.1758345365524292,
0.36223340034484863,
0.04108758643269539,
0.27818480134010315,
0.671262800693512,
-0.24538083374500275,
0.6251786351203918,
-0.11750616133213043,
-0.32292667031288147,
-0.4037320613861084,
0.4622562825679779,
-1.1182364225387573,
0.13054895401000977,
1.3222804069519043,
-0.05333167314529419,
-0.5202874541282654,
-0.1484077125787735,
-0.6130135655403137,
0.12969738245010376,
-0.4423227906227112,
0.35493937134742737,
0.1706937849521637,
0.07201886177062988,
-0.05926748365163803,
-0.8742537498474121,
0.9987972974777222,
0.023392271250486374,
-0.5935409665107727,
-0.14426091313362122,
0.6324614882469177,
0.28015801310539246,
0.3195928931236267,
0.564070463180542,
0.28679442405700684,
0.678683340549469,
0.2601572871208191,
0.2147330939769745,
-0.1825518012046814,
-0.5902085900306702,
-0.260177344083786,
-0.18329951167106628,
0.09355312585830688,
-0.611836850643158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02558v1 | Enhancing Robustness in Biomedical NLI Models: A Probing Approach for Clinical Trials | 2024-02-04T16:18:01 | 2024-02-04T16:18:01 | Ata Mustafa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models have revolutionized various fields and industries, such
as Conversational AI, Content Generation, Information Retrieval, Business
Intelligence, and Medical, to name a few. One major application in the field of
medical is to analyze and investigate clinical trials for entailment
tasks.However, It has been observed that Large Language Models are susceptible
to shortcut learning, factual inconsistency, and performance degradation with
little variation in context. Adversarial and robust testing is performed to
ensure the integrity of models output. But, ambiguity still persists. In order
to ensure the integrity of the reasoning performed and investigate the model
has correct syntactic and semantic understanding probing is used. Here, I used
mnestic probing to investigate the Sci-five model, trained on clinical trial. I
investigated the model for feature learnt with respect to natural logic. To
achieve the target, I trained task specific probes. Used these probes to
investigate the final layers of trained model. Then, fine tuned the trained
model using iterative null projection. The results shows that model accuracy
improved. During experimentation, I observed that size of the probe has affect
on the fine tuning process. | [
-0.018876226618885994,
-0.9560253620147705,
0.6370115876197815,
0.11351331323385239,
-0.04996085911989212,
-0.220050647854805,
-0.12618428468704224,
-0.5464034676551819,
0.16876015067100525,
0.5681376457214355,
-0.3326679766178131,
-0.6060957312583923,
-0.6200721263885498,
0.32814979553222656,
-0.20463347434997559,
1.0105341672897339,
0.2364390790462494,
0.4251912534236908,
-0.3181666433811188,
-0.6027449369430542,
-0.40735092759132385,
-0.4491434097290039,
-0.7653336524963379,
-0.3043588697910309,
0.5529559254646301,
-0.02625557780265808,
0.6512446403503418,
0.7220106720924377,
0.933999240398407,
0.35680264234542847,
-0.340316504240036,
0.1526498645544052,
-0.519100546836853,
0.24165840446949005,
-0.40707388520240784,
-0.8572372198104858,
-0.48159074783325195,
-0.08279754966497421,
0.4763968586921692,
1.1186443567276,
-0.10817565768957138,
0.002380834659561515,
-0.02393590472638607,
0.4248635768890381,
-0.5205145478248596,
-0.1254015415906906,
-0.8301886916160583,
-0.11882171779870987,
0.07856512069702148,
-0.30837780237197876,
-0.5079429149627686,
-0.2661793529987335,
0.15534605085849762,
-0.6076711416244507,
0.4420565664768219,
-0.024748267605900764,
0.9389073252677917,
0.4679860472679138,
-0.6412723064422607,
-0.3385847210884094,
-0.5815799832344055,
0.929122805595398,
-0.9425297975540161,
0.3579973578453064,
0.40803277492523193,
0.15586140751838684,
-0.3372591435909271,
-0.9541167616844177,
-0.2016037106513977,
-0.6120736002922058,
-0.07591930031776428,
0.12407010048627853,
-0.0459088496863842,
0.23878413438796997,
0.4620155096054077,
0.17071035504341125,
-0.6496788263320923,
0.21383129060268402,
-0.3369162976741791,
-0.3965736925601959,
0.5791829824447632,
0.36349648237228394,
0.25887295603752136,
-0.1484970599412918,
-0.217087060213089,
-0.08361240476369858,
-0.6967872381210327,
0.03428715839982033,
0.06536497175693512,
0.37119120359420776,
0.16570325195789337,
0.6449544429779053,
-0.10198062658309937,
0.5620131492614746,
-0.05878373980522156,
-0.10500574111938477,
0.2071121633052826,
-0.7255270481109619,
-0.14877840876579285,
-0.09055893868207932,
0.7105571627616882,
0.26702436804771423,
-0.02978382259607315,
-0.11246202141046524,
-0.009505110792815685,
0.3857511579990387,
0.6580455899238586,
-0.9705221056938171,
-0.24804893136024475,
0.570685088634491,
-0.6550027132034302,
-0.5753034949302673,
-0.3649671673774719,
-0.6231763362884521,
-0.25931814312934875,
-0.07324672490358353,
0.5901871919631958,
-0.8729791641235352,
-0.0622672513127327,
0.4194772243499756,
-0.13099981844425201,
0.07764394581317902,
0.15152902901172638,
-0.7264722585678101,
0.2573167681694031,
0.6973701119422913,
0.713683009147644,
0.0513499416410923,
-0.12852858006954193,
-0.6377808451652527,
0.08669965714216232,
-0.3560875952243805,
0.4826451241970062,
-0.3603966236114502,
-0.5064017176628113,
-0.27623844146728516,
-0.12750546634197235,
-0.3865986168384552,
-0.6417641639709473,
0.7083544731140137,
-0.3038060963153839,
0.23501372337341309,
-0.11627070605754852,
-0.7414689660072327,
-0.013007399626076221,
0.6055564880371094,
-0.46767836809158325,
0.5731616616249084,
-0.11603642255067825,
-0.8714497685432434,
0.46014416217803955,
-0.932755708694458,
-0.43428876996040344,
-0.05450786277651787,
-0.23101721704006195,
-0.7259049415588379,
0.358161062002182,
0.32177263498306274,
0.28632715344429016,
0.04698982089757919,
0.3437685966491699,
-0.6801437735557556,
-0.26601147651672363,
0.5007631182670593,
-0.19163091480731964,
0.7976552248001099,
0.11149094998836517,
-0.3721693158149719,
0.36489424109458923,
-0.896853506565094,
0.1381194144487381,
0.16095396876335144,
-0.04634290188550949,
-0.5352028608322144,
0.004665744956582785,
-0.04418691620230675,
-0.14469920098781586,
-0.014155363664031029,
-0.6866002678871155,
0.04195264354348183,
-0.9119967818260193,
0.44429129362106323,
0.3104144334793091,
0.21841886639595032,
0.1745944321155548,
-0.26341602206230164,
0.27836787700653076,
0.04460311681032181,
0.4988187849521637,
-0.07702933996915817,
-0.4569179117679596,
-0.5712391138076782,
-0.35827767848968506,
0.7819339632987976,
0.5065057277679443,
-0.6681003570556641,
0.34128108620643616,
-0.07908544689416885,
-0.49406298995018005,
-0.6258081197738647,
-0.11335314810276031,
0.2432498186826706,
0.6756895780563354,
0.43183740973472595,
-0.3548029065132141,
-0.3346848487854004,
-0.9493098258972168,
-0.26857367157936096,
-0.13386718928813934,
-0.26944226026535034,
0.3433856964111328,
0.8941665291786194,
-0.4635310471057892,
0.547557532787323,
-0.47105059027671814,
-0.3231216371059418,
-0.116203673183918,
0.28014376759529114,
0.3063966929912567,
0.6044021248817444,
0.6170722246170044,
-0.9912198185920715,
-0.03735676035284996,
0.021525651216506958,
-0.7746150493621826,
0.0191021841019392,
-0.09029727429151535,
-0.13143426179885864,
-0.17864179611206055,
0.4901813268661499,
-0.6168801188468933,
0.5139476656913757,
0.35077226161956787,
-0.3743218779563904,
0.43246227502822876,
-0.33783912658691406,
0.06728382408618927,
-1.040797472000122,
0.48524317145347595,
-0.14147894084453583,
-0.17702019214630127,
-0.7695814371109009,
0.38732725381851196,
0.20636068284511566,
0.02516883984208107,
-0.1391650140285492,
0.27684250473976135,
-0.2958444058895111,
0.29939696192741394,
-0.3930624723434448,
-0.14649897813796997,
0.10049627721309662,
0.05265774950385094,
-0.13740473985671997,
0.5832720398902893,
0.49230045080184937,
-0.6223041415214539,
-0.1356160044670105,
0.34948188066482544,
-0.09348363429307938,
0.3358750641345978,
-1.1096596717834473,
0.03525952249765396,
-0.02330215461552143,
-0.041328806430101395,
-0.7314104437828064,
-0.2191619575023651,
-0.056741468608379364,
-0.8072977662086487,
0.25972747802734375,
-0.015109507367014885,
-0.29120099544525146,
-0.013267721980810165,
-0.26037830114364624,
0.3417374789714813,
0.3482625484466553,
-0.2525659203529358,
0.6322621703147888,
0.21533794701099396,
-0.04690917953848839,
-0.5492238402366638,
-0.41880571842193604,
-0.044489435851573944,
-0.3416847288608551,
-0.5786241292953491,
0.25271838903427124,
-0.04980900511145592,
-0.28389668464660645,
-0.15232829749584198,
0.005240517668426037,
-0.10487870126962662,
0.39564183354377747,
0.1386185586452484,
0.40871700644493103,
-0.4330998361110687,
0.0299267265945673,
0.10096201300621033,
-0.06489116698503494,
0.29054149985313416,
-0.0033020011615008116,
0.25998249650001526,
0.037789616733789444,
-0.5424323081970215,
-0.37685084342956543,
0.6075552105903625,
0.780155599117279,
-0.4220236539840698,
0.7491112947463989,
0.6870959997177124,
-0.5987419486045837,
-0.018816469237208366,
-0.4383224844932556,
-0.6372946500778198,
-0.4806678891181946,
0.47957268357276917,
-0.2540033161640167,
-0.978000283241272,
0.5913870334625244,
-0.2835712134838104,
-0.17644087970256805,
0.39662739634513855,
0.5559731125831604,
-0.0848202332854271,
1.4812923669815063,
0.8158479928970337,
0.18097993731498718,
0.029776131734251976,
-0.10915450751781464,
0.3557310998439789,
-0.7345755696296692,
-0.07798931747674942,
-0.7388583421707153,
-0.12598101794719696,
-0.5560857653617859,
-0.18070347607135773,
0.8550853729248047,
-0.07642564177513123,
0.17039255797863007,
-0.052526719868183136,
-0.32908129692077637,
0.1923927217721939,
0.4685736894607544,
0.3520716726779938,
0.14618615806102753,
-0.24704937636852264,
-0.417766809463501,
-0.26551154255867004,
-0.7995205521583557,
-0.4385150074958801,
1.2129042148590088,
0.5523931384086609,
0.668860137462616,
0.07991544902324677,
0.47849658131599426,
-0.2300122082233429,
0.213070347905159,
-0.7342878580093384,
0.25934651494026184,
0.027268726378679276,
-0.693674623966217,
-0.15730203688144684,
-0.5784639716148376,
-1.049977421760559,
0.1436014026403427,
-0.2988297641277313,
-0.6219708323478699,
0.37566816806793213,
0.20190176367759705,
-0.7009575366973877,
0.06129719316959381,
-0.5566434264183044,
0.8814370632171631,
-0.19741599261760712,
-0.5166338682174683,
-0.14699126780033112,
-0.8753358125686646,
0.1896842122077942,
0.05459040403366089,
-0.126835435628891,
0.13181014358997345,
0.07050906121730804,
0.47175562381744385,
-0.19490402936935425,
0.9383752942085266,
0.06512326002120972,
0.19021396338939667,
-0.1774122416973114,
0.13665635883808136,
0.3404061496257782,
0.26181837916374207,
-0.08771641552448273,
0.05486748367547989,
0.31744107604026794,
-0.6148507595062256,
-0.6702918410301208,
0.4592125415802002,
-0.43371981382369995,
-0.47286415100097656,
-0.37560486793518066,
-0.7217885851860046,
-0.5235073566436768,
0.1684129685163498,
0.3534434139728546,
0.5748194456100464,
-0.26129207015037537,
0.4334820508956909,
0.9891538619995117,
-0.3352660834789276,
-0.09874801337718964,
0.3389109969139099,
0.021891789510846138,
-0.17932043969631195,
0.5276651978492737,
-0.2609883248806,
0.5195701718330383,
0.2784617245197296,
0.25510573387145996,
-0.3436723053455353,
-1.2259920835494995,
-0.07106220722198486,
0.37987256050109863,
-0.4401034116744995,
-0.15009194612503052,
-0.744263231754303,
-0.2341967225074768,
-0.7209318280220032,
0.06964221596717834,
-0.5531738996505737,
-0.1918562352657318,
-0.21973495185375214,
0.11168287694454193,
0.21959945559501648,
0.454450786113739,
0.0738290473818779,
0.017167702317237854,
-0.8277400135993958,
0.22281967103481293,
-0.013607949018478394,
0.13179218769073486,
-0.3881826400756836,
-0.41867825388908386,
-0.09366493672132492,
0.16046859323978424,
-0.19519342482089996,
-0.7388165593147278,
0.5381664633750916,
0.2627216577529907,
0.5420531034469604,
0.4746101200580597,
-0.022811127826571465,
0.6035434603691101,
-0.3606049418449402,
0.5978590250015259,
-0.11210763454437256,
-0.7615815997123718,
0.9077499508857727,
-0.5454463958740234,
0.30037298798561096,
0.7454493641853333,
0.5222389101982117,
-0.1185726672410965,
-0.5302274823188782,
-0.637420654296875,
-0.8940073847770691,
0.11630752682685852,
0.2497742474079132,
-0.006891194265335798,
0.1428898125886917,
0.6266197562217712,
0.17830410599708557,
0.13317681849002838,
-0.42733535170555115,
0.11680448800325394,
0.032327644526958466,
-0.4055047035217285,
0.0609000064432621,
-0.14257508516311646,
-0.6453423500061035,
-0.2896771728992462,
0.5506432056427002,
-0.5986937880516052,
0.27159473299980164,
0.49230247735977173,
-0.03269502520561218,
0.34961241483688354,
0.20848028361797333,
0.7306445240974426,
0.7007696032524109,
-0.42733457684516907,
0.08175316452980042,
0.30771496891975403,
-0.7485194206237793,
-0.21409521996974945,
0.12029766291379929,
-0.1670982837677002,
-0.08969799429178238,
0.5939690470695496,
0.706125020980835,
0.10581455379724503,
-0.7833661437034607,
0.5197717547416687,
-0.27836206555366516,
-0.3253481090068817,
-0.06874305754899979,
0.15539924800395966,
-0.11125057190656662,
0.31749916076660156,
-0.03843902796506882,
0.26347631216049194,
0.5937454700469971,
-0.42726024985313416,
0.297771155834198,
0.5589256286621094,
-0.5962207913398743,
-0.14787383377552032,
0.8826190233230591,
-0.017844779416918755,
0.03410737216472626,
0.7045933604240417,
0.08726629614830017,
-0.6261738538742065,
0.695390522480011,
0.6960762143135071,
0.39023175835609436,
-0.2429676353931427,
0.010907944291830063,
0.37437909841537476,
0.4461069405078888,
0.07198352366685867,
0.3678644299507141,
0.1741505116224289,
-0.7528972625732422,
-0.40830373764038086,
-0.33523526787757874,
-0.5120360851287842,
0.1867503523826599,
-0.8535494208335876,
0.030199291184544563,
-0.4669402241706848,
-0.4096572697162628,
0.24843727052211761,
0.03635019063949585,
-0.31998759508132935,
0.3929600119590759,
-0.1932135820388794,
0.9375685453414917,
-0.79157555103302,
0.8426925539970398,
0.647290050983429,
-0.2376253455877304,
-0.7548876404762268,
-0.13735058903694153,
-0.016020148992538452,
-0.5243616104125977,
0.5099301934242249,
0.09156020730733871,
0.0681358352303505,
-0.31577736139297485,
-0.6015825271606445,
-0.7768816351890564,
0.8346368074417114,
0.2933092415332794,
-0.27322277426719666,
0.09031778573989868,
0.0860251858830452,
0.8619282841682434,
-0.2622411251068115,
0.2521214783191681,
0.4030197262763977,
0.14990641176700592,
0.03186152130365372,
-0.9438266754150391,
0.1338452696800232,
-0.5391154885292053,
-0.07256340235471725,
0.07640295475721359,
-0.22674135863780975,
0.5934969186782837,
-0.4133979380130768,
0.055522508919239044,
0.4942567050457001,
0.5516123175621033,
0.413878470659256,
0.5742864608764648,
0.5511432886123657,
0.3914452791213989,
0.9323395490646362,
-0.2199486941099167,
1.1542096138000488,
-0.19604794681072235,
0.3017752766609192,
0.9092593789100647,
-0.5758874416351318,
0.8011986017227173,
0.705049991607666,
0.13963398337364197,
0.016465941444039345,
0.5587038397789001,
-0.14834801852703094,
0.41716885566711426,
0.16097202897071838,
-0.12637859582901,
-0.2126004695892334,
-0.31109222769737244,
-0.3930725157260895,
0.6418578028678894,
0.646595299243927,
-0.4892645478248596,
0.058666110038757324,
0.1776430904865265,
0.004174017813056707,
0.12131106853485107,
-0.014121119864284992,
0.6760630011558533,
-0.007863757200539112,
-0.5446909070014954,
0.4341367483139038,
-0.002771790837869048,
0.5157039165496826,
-0.8771819472312927,
-0.03653179109096527,
-0.09058333933353424,
0.5511842966079712,
0.07443824410438538,
-0.2880260646343231,
0.45947766304016113,
-0.2747204601764679,
0.08345267176628113,
0.19994120299816132,
0.9094104766845703,
-0.2019180804491043,
-0.5462726354598999,
0.34199047088623047,
0.3463723659515381,
-0.08088383078575134,
0.03613462299108505,
-0.7751514911651611,
0.16594180464744568,
-0.09673392027616501,
-0.09273006021976471,
0.30385270714759827,
0.277580589056015,
-0.0313076488673687,
0.7202772498130798,
0.7358685731887817,
0.30420204997062683,
-0.08393189311027527,
0.11454695463180542,
0.7303415536880493,
-0.5458360910415649,
-0.2781067490577698,
-0.7404218912124634,
0.4160614311695099,
-0.3703194856643677,
-0.4892277419567108,
0.7381632924079895,
0.4914426803588867,
0.45322301983833313,
0.05884623900055885,
0.41384270787239075,
0.3042352795600891,
0.6399465799331665,
-0.7097567319869995,
0.9426863789558411,
-0.5206606388092041,
0.042761798948049545,
0.038363147526979446,
-0.35287511348724365,
-0.7792132496833801,
0.5516224503517151,
-0.14917929470539093,
0.08476293832063675,
0.8698021173477173,
1.042127251625061,
-0.09005574136972427,
0.31517016887664795,
0.3967708945274353,
0.5715892910957336,
0.4727259874343872,
0.5354467630386353,
0.6492300033569336,
-0.6170066595077515,
0.046221017837524414,
-0.3922792375087738,
-0.313323438167572,
-0.04761936515569687,
-0.7161358594894409,
-1.0084137916564941,
-0.33562079071998596,
-0.43715086579322815,
-0.5424612164497375,
0.21234028041362762,
0.7098691463470459,
0.778435230255127,
-0.9615423083305359,
0.05438739061355591,
0.061474308371543884,
-0.1804477721452713,
-0.41664624214172363,
-0.1546643227338791,
0.46527913212776184,
-0.3275783956050873,
-0.6129079461097717,
0.6157995462417603,
0.3294879198074341,
-0.0719083920121193,
-0.060375507920980453,
0.35912826657295227,
-0.29275742173194885,
0.12942233681678772,
0.4477154612541199,
0.1046350970864296,
-0.3980928063392639,
-0.25636011362075806,
0.3370203971862793,
-0.19019222259521484,
-0.12733560800552368,
0.8414071202278137,
-0.5834658741950989,
0.41119205951690674,
0.33581358194351196,
0.9224205613136292,
0.25624173879623413,
-0.2455301284790039,
0.7836882472038269,
-0.46813416481018066,
0.0881139263510704,
0.53984135389328,
0.31802815198898315,
0.3640519678592682,
-0.6074716448783875,
0.62241530418396,
0.13444700837135315,
-0.7084689140319824,
-1.0246399641036987,
0.11689916253089905,
-1.0416823625564575,
-0.3342134356498718,
0.8423213362693787,
-0.06035451591014862,
-0.4245136082172394,
-0.220703586935997,
-0.15485483407974243,
0.2434847056865692,
0.19561973214149475,
1.0254747867584229,
0.48106300830841064,
-0.271139919757843,
0.3548933267593384,
-0.8327047228813171,
0.4949842691421509,
0.9892762899398804,
-0.8369577527046204,
-0.396366685628891,
0.1926245093345642,
0.38042062520980835,
0.318132609128952,
0.3448665738105774,
-0.4218756854534149,
0.4044426679611206,
0.028193574398756027,
-0.23534858226776123,
0.152759850025177,
-0.1865343600511551,
-0.5369874238967896,
0.3485276699066162,
0.011513303965330124,
-0.3785330057144165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02555v1 | Generalizable Entity Grounding via Assistance of Large Language Model | 2024-02-04T16:06:05 | 2024-02-04T16:06:05 | Lu Qi, Yi-Wen Chen, Lehan Yang, Tiancheng Shen, Xiangtai Li, Weidong Guo, Yu Xu, Ming-Hsuan Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this work, we propose a novel approach to densely ground visual entities
from a long caption. We leverage a large multimodal model (LMM) to extract
semantic nouns, a class-agnostic segmentation model to generate entity-level
segmentation, and the proposed multi-modal feature fusion module to associate
each semantic noun with its corresponding segmentation mask. Additionally, we
introduce a strategy of encoding entity segmentation masks into a colormap,
enabling the preservation of fine-grained predictions from features of
high-resolution masks. This approach allows us to extract visual features from
low-resolution images using the CLIP vision encoder in the LMM, which is more
computationally efficient than existing approaches that use an additional
encoder for high-resolution images. Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate
the superiority of our method, outperforming state-of-the-art techniques on
three tasks, including panoptic narrative grounding, referring expression
segmentation, and panoptic segmentation. | [
-0.7081279754638672,
-0.8835287690162659,
0.6567936539649963,
0.04620783403515816,
-0.664181113243103,
-0.14798037707805634,
-0.47100281715393066,
-0.5963698029518127,
0.38600221276283264,
0.7561271786689758,
-0.3200598657131195,
-0.7625438570976257,
-0.5968562960624695,
-0.11293976753950119,
-0.2769109308719635,
0.6492176055908203,
0.06152873858809471,
-0.08688785135746002,
-0.4824269711971283,
-0.26357296109199524,
-0.5830742120742798,
-0.43794679641723633,
-0.27850353717803955,
-0.024997631087899208,
0.39356938004493713,
0.38215890526771545,
0.7623138427734375,
0.9430168271064758,
0.5732752680778503,
0.2863810062408447,
0.07385636121034622,
0.39127248525619507,
-0.15296918153762817,
0.04531709477305412,
-0.42296797037124634,
-0.24761582911014557,
-0.30858007073402405,
-0.02317430078983307,
0.7769218683242798,
0.7877699136734009,
0.053606290370225906,
0.006761034019291401,
-0.2803211510181427,
0.3845524787902832,
-0.879925012588501,
0.4271787703037262,
-0.7323492169380188,
-0.08235801011323929,
-0.06678951531648636,
-0.24662809073925018,
-0.3982786238193512,
0.28405144810676575,
0.11568524688482285,
-0.6946023106575012,
0.2993868887424469,
0.23613837361335754,
1.4864509105682373,
0.33498615026474,
-0.28075215220451355,
0.09509983658790588,
-0.6077532768249512,
0.8388923406600952,
-0.3036746084690094,
0.5226158499717712,
0.14536039531230927,
0.4278642535209656,
0.20653390884399414,
-0.6284152865409851,
-0.6823532581329346,
-0.15319231152534485,
0.00011228312359889969,
0.04396316409111023,
0.054137878119945526,
0.2597440183162689,
0.48360922932624817,
0.4737629294395447,
-0.08530431240797043,
0.040318746119737625,
-0.37928342819213867,
-0.1897452175617218,
0.366493284702301,
-0.08007248491048813,
0.6645669341087341,
-0.49461138248443604,
-0.7594283819198608,
-0.0949968695640564,
-0.5562281608581543,
-0.04276396334171295,
-0.08823460340499878,
0.1388687640428543,
-0.03382069617509842,
0.8243917226791382,
-0.29188093543052673,
0.6697861552238464,
-0.056617822498083115,
-0.39248090982437134,
0.13907429575920105,
-0.06247374787926674,
-0.4205775260925293,
-0.0449698306620121,
0.6630688309669495,
0.8941402435302734,
0.2990991473197937,
-0.41814136505126953,
-0.17504791915416718,
0.4603036642074585,
0.16413387656211853,
-0.9750546813011169,
-0.1500149518251419,
0.05206599086523056,
-0.3921065032482147,
0.11217669397592545,
0.2547011971473694,
-1.1449253559112549,
-0.29041001200675964,
-0.6789584159851074,
0.31446224451065063,
-0.4455822706222534,
-0.09410181641578674,
0.09553214907646179,
-0.1820383369922638,
0.41738361120224,
0.489917516708374,
-0.8085553050041199,
0.2538350224494934,
0.4742342531681061,
0.9299505352973938,
-0.3588169813156128,
-0.18423037230968475,
-0.49039313197135925,
0.6678901314735413,
-0.1777738630771637,
0.7574266791343689,
-0.7411755323410034,
0.0964895561337471,
0.033486295491456985,
0.3118731677532196,
0.12496128678321838,
-0.5988017916679382,
0.4832659959793091,
-0.7641541957855225,
-0.12742415070533752,
-0.07896442711353302,
-0.3306567966938019,
-0.4534089267253876,
0.5097364187240601,
-0.8223966360092163,
0.5176666975021362,
0.025876739993691444,
-0.7780162692070007,
0.5286745429039001,
-0.5313892364501953,
-0.26559001207351685,
-0.03374529257416725,
-0.4548850357532501,
-0.36741578578948975,
0.052983369678258896,
0.8114321827888489,
0.6810443997383118,
-0.4165472984313965,
0.47970840334892273,
-0.3245799243450165,
-0.1349303275346756,
-0.12925675511360168,
0.013425180688500404,
0.44424018263816833,
-0.09100454300642014,
-0.35098350048065186,
0.3198091983795166,
-0.8788694739341736,
-0.24909691512584686,
0.30851972103118896,
-0.1907653510570526,
-0.547446072101593,
0.06519752740859985,
0.10275261849164963,
0.34497758746147156,
-0.059454601258039474,
-0.5012157559394836,
0.18624253571033478,
-0.11251424252986908,
0.4660950005054474,
0.409483939409256,
0.20231236517429352,
0.7753869295120239,
0.12519150972366333,
0.27788782119750977,
0.4109545052051544,
-0.25049853324890137,
-0.8542163372039795,
-0.29532647132873535,
-0.9258092045783997,
-0.7552447319030762,
0.3080853521823883,
0.43881499767303467,
-0.9648251533508301,
0.49368709325790405,
-0.6200894117355347,
-0.22926270961761475,
-0.15230612456798553,
0.00854093674570322,
0.05670112371444702,
0.6763731241226196,
0.7071188688278198,
-0.503915011882782,
-0.3915628492832184,
-1.3534945249557495,
0.41289472579956055,
0.14136949181556702,
-0.2031887322664261,
0.3531953692436218,
0.5834348201751709,
-0.4364270865917206,
1.1352336406707764,
-0.749504566192627,
-0.5868454575538635,
-0.038014281541109085,
-0.13125993311405182,
-0.07147753238677979,
0.7873433232307434,
0.5820499062538147,
-0.970875084400177,
0.16088318824768066,
-0.010738100856542587,
-0.9344929456710815,
0.22096554934978485,
-0.17584754526615143,
-0.28527334332466125,
-0.19174177944660187,
0.7140693068504333,
-1.02742338180542,
0.21696361899375916,
0.2459660917520523,
-0.23520423471927643,
0.263739675283432,
-0.07318173348903656,
0.19114777445793152,
-0.972743034362793,
-0.003879668889567256,
0.19577082991600037,
-0.38863566517829895,
-0.39914435148239136,
0.5450611710548401,
0.24879583716392517,
-0.4938977062702179,
-0.3092554807662964,
0.3134589195251465,
-0.8862930536270142,
-0.20213447511196136,
-0.20397354662418365,
0.18431685864925385,
0.29173627495765686,
0.6998027563095093,
0.3857821524143219,
0.43852582573890686,
0.8943179845809937,
-0.607020378112793,
0.5225120782852173,
0.2151050865650177,
-0.3892992436885834,
0.6054947376251221,
-0.5785312652587891,
-0.060488153249025345,
-0.6026999950408936,
0.3355132043361664,
-0.7581928372383118,
-0.6283751130104065,
0.2745739221572876,
0.018859704956412315,
0.35918930172920227,
-0.36068370938301086,
-0.508036196231842,
-0.10307034105062485,
-0.1744980663061142,
0.6159942150115967,
0.28616970777511597,
-0.49684545397758484,
0.9295918345451355,
0.5650931596755981,
-0.04888296499848366,
-0.2861892580986023,
-0.6462643146514893,
0.31352779269218445,
-0.45208311080932617,
-0.8219761252403259,
0.5765547156333923,
0.25234338641166687,
-0.17919860780239105,
-0.0965714082121849,
0.06306534260511398,
-0.18651054799556732,
-0.05789985880255699,
0.5056590437889099,
0.31416982412338257,
-0.4710036814212799,
0.2530386447906494,
0.013889572583138943,
-0.019677873700857162,
0.07235104590654373,
-0.29624396562576294,
0.6060616970062256,
-0.0569184273481369,
-0.3103470802307129,
-0.2660238742828369,
0.6410731673240662,
0.751288652420044,
-0.7095996737480164,
0.5513202548027039,
0.5565826892852783,
-0.8450760245323181,
-0.04853503033518791,
-0.7438141703605652,
0.020551957190036774,
-0.3694019615650177,
0.4361817240715027,
-0.40514519810676575,
-0.8390018343925476,
0.5766622424125671,
-0.33011549711227417,
-0.1824449598789215,
0.5734078884124756,
0.2889014184474945,
0.1629362553358078,
0.788837194442749,
0.7997774481773376,
0.012673649936914444,
0.38386818766593933,
-0.46006903052330017,
-0.04860113188624382,
-0.896583080291748,
-0.33189138770103455,
-0.13636617362499237,
-0.270306795835495,
-0.11812741309404373,
-0.9577392935752869,
0.24772419035434723,
0.5321199893951416,
0.07591843605041504,
0.04504372924566269,
-0.4168013036251068,
0.7677218317985535,
0.5055525302886963,
0.34146788716316223,
0.18580208718776703,
0.1850205659866333,
-0.015052195638418198,
-0.09376440942287445,
-0.26126202940940857,
-0.40234649181365967,
0.6290296316146851,
0.6105470061302185,
0.5154665112495422,
-0.0785183310508728,
0.538097620010376,
0.07375973463058472,
0.03389132395386696,
-1.002638816833496,
0.6495548486709595,
0.05818973481655121,
-0.5325374007225037,
-0.44578126072883606,
-0.10712940245866776,
-0.6675595045089722,
0.6786940097808838,
-0.3843730688095093,
-0.6787059903144836,
0.26815125346183777,
-0.10743220150470734,
-0.3465798795223236,
0.31700801849365234,
-0.7079592943191528,
0.9274937510490417,
0.07825720310211182,
-0.30301809310913086,
0.053965698927640915,
-0.6929888129234314,
0.47139596939086914,
0.047332730144262314,
0.21341140568256378,
-0.3166692554950714,
-0.28251853585243225,
0.7395012974739075,
-0.09867731481790543,
0.7215114831924438,
-0.4063970446586609,
-0.18170854449272156,
0.3824738562107086,
-0.22135291993618011,
0.3044050633907318,
0.22797837853431702,
0.44064363837242126,
0.3549957573413849,
-0.5123463273048401,
-0.403580904006958,
-0.6427397131919861,
0.559898316860199,
-0.5627189874649048,
-0.6472035050392151,
-0.1125251054763794,
-0.39434829354286194,
-0.16335877776145935,
0.4276180565357208,
0.12837694585323334,
0.4463127553462982,
-0.02011364884674549,
0.207790806889534,
0.6573336124420166,
-0.15529681742191315,
0.5445795655250549,
-0.06142691895365715,
-0.14676116406917572,
-0.7602362036705017,
0.888328492641449,
0.01804511621594429,
0.022204123437404633,
0.4725044369697571,
0.007162831723690033,
-0.06327018141746521,
-0.7271010875701904,
-0.7698949575424194,
0.2938898205757141,
-0.9045842289924622,
-0.47818177938461304,
-0.8842747807502747,
0.04458222538232803,
-0.2168424427509308,
-0.30557337403297424,
-0.3213910460472107,
-0.18927110731601715,
-0.3066321909427643,
-0.15425433218479156,
-0.08726496249437332,
0.19541938602924347,
0.34533289074897766,
0.2854735255241394,
-0.7590077519416809,
0.9285578727722168,
0.5816167593002319,
0.15317200124263763,
-0.11920809000730515,
-0.1767110973596573,
-0.08448681980371475,
-0.16043899953365326,
-0.08712884038686752,
-0.8246515393257141,
0.24063906073570251,
0.2961091995239258,
0.44245606660842896,
0.6702908277511597,
-0.05100217089056969,
1.0067801475524902,
-0.8059932589530945,
0.9268844127655029,
0.5313576459884644,
-0.9407036304473877,
0.7356151342391968,
-0.42740049958229065,
0.28594648838043213,
0.26478034257888794,
0.15068726241588593,
-0.30665770173072815,
-0.30798137187957764,
-0.4673507511615753,
-1.306169867515564,
0.511728048324585,
-0.0005465855356305838,
0.22321966290473938,
-0.2583296298980713,
0.323921263217926,
-0.03046792931854725,
0.13107624650001526,
-0.8445321917533875,
-0.07349000871181488,
-0.34074273705482483,
0.12142704427242279,
-0.14358490705490112,
-0.5147615671157837,
-0.29580190777778625,
-0.1892452985048294,
0.2219153344631195,
-0.3784776031970978,
0.11694725602865219,
0.34953102469444275,
-0.6744144558906555,
0.01990998350083828,
0.27442535758018494,
0.7088626623153687,
0.7255887389183044,
-0.09127382189035416,
0.5509642958641052,
0.0882892981171608,
-0.2980230748653412,
0.08682092279195786,
0.14751403033733368,
-0.2533913254737854,
0.08886664360761642,
0.5281961560249329,
0.81175297498703,
0.4417714774608612,
-0.6630690693855286,
0.7836098670959473,
0.33179306983947754,
-0.03656907007098198,
-0.25320038199424744,
-0.14433994889259338,
0.0022017506416887045,
0.3450387418270111,
0.45268845558166504,
-0.021387815475463867,
0.13143669068813324,
-0.5516090989112854,
0.34463828802108765,
0.37035277485847473,
-0.20259587466716766,
-0.3012685179710388,
0.6689573526382446,
0.29150477051734924,
0.3137684166431427,
0.4229958653450012,
-0.03783236816525459,
-0.5229672789573669,
0.5598960518836975,
0.5078840255737305,
0.6188380122184753,
0.02414233796298504,
0.04765385389328003,
0.4664900600910187,
0.3688255846500397,
-0.14336499571800232,
-0.15470246970653534,
-0.08375786244869232,
-0.736649215221405,
-0.5658837556838989,
-0.7445874214172363,
-0.1797170490026474,
0.11681199073791504,
-0.5322955250740051,
0.3768770098686218,
-0.7079861164093018,
0.002026759088039398,
0.20632462203502655,
-0.46549734473228455,
-0.6727537512779236,
0.5355799794197083,
0.6085245013237,
0.7026055455207825,
-0.7541862726211548,
0.5957096815109253,
0.9961661100387573,
-0.5990263819694519,
-0.4882739782333374,
-0.11571401357650757,
-0.49162405729293823,
-0.6399548649787903,
0.8318251967430115,
0.6670601963996887,
0.03386181220412254,
-0.17536474764347076,
-0.6927963495254517,
-0.859870433807373,
1.1311227083206177,
0.5857017636299133,
-0.548531174659729,
-0.42992979288101196,
0.07314436882734299,
0.1537652313709259,
-0.6901189684867859,
-0.012436705641448498,
0.35249263048171997,
0.43235400319099426,
0.10167700797319412,
-0.588432252407074,
0.18858467042446136,
-0.015407568775117397,
0.28826236724853516,
0.16910582780838013,
-0.5855880975723267,
0.8381158113479614,
-0.20561763644218445,
-0.5540238618850708,
-0.20925548672676086,
1.084548830986023,
0.0429178886115551,
0.21022839844226837,
0.7809889316558838,
0.8290802836418152,
0.6586176753044128,
-0.14672958850860596,
0.6635205149650574,
-0.08240970969200134,
0.4165402948856354,
0.8965310454368591,
-0.11094285547733307,
0.6367086172103882,
0.7499374151229858,
0.3909878134727478,
0.44866126775741577,
0.3600281774997711,
-0.35792624950408936,
0.6123865246772766,
0.36560988426208496,
-0.1342877447605133,
-0.6320404410362244,
-0.364764541387558,
-0.20933549106121063,
0.7353341579437256,
0.27057960629463196,
-0.45797914266586304,
-0.45029205083847046,
0.40483924746513367,
-0.11316388100385666,
0.01652154140174389,
-0.7078042030334473,
0.6654818654060364,
-0.06504116952419281,
-0.4576767385005951,
0.5508195161819458,
0.279048889875412,
0.6480513215065002,
-0.26795631647109985,
-0.3873847723007202,
0.22787150740623474,
-0.09517096728086472,
-0.130630761384964,
-0.5669107437133789,
0.1121162623167038,
-0.17589065432548523,
-0.35159939527511597,
-0.07655932009220123,
0.9249598383903503,
-0.6394384503364563,
-0.3653799295425415,
0.2031310498714447,
0.2517561912536621,
0.05923043563961983,
-0.5168770551681519,
-0.21032440662384033,
0.2155044972896576,
-0.33742648363113403,
-0.057754892855882645,
0.06911451369524002,
0.6449231505393982,
-0.28283748030662537,
0.3771761655807495,
0.6864392757415771,
-0.08589396625757217,
0.11035887151956558,
0.08768240362405777,
1.1863707304000854,
-1.0496916770935059,
-0.6453360915184021,
-0.8177282214164734,
0.7093520760536194,
-0.26184317469596863,
-0.10761281847953796,
0.31040942668914795,
0.5495347380638123,
0.749839723110199,
-0.42872822284698486,
0.4247453212738037,
0.11630097031593323,
-0.006963604129850864,
-0.9364632368087769,
0.4958856701850891,
-0.43611764907836914,
-0.16348427534103394,
-0.4039960503578186,
-1.3372318744659424,
-0.641118049621582,
0.4666377902030945,
-0.02562107890844345,
-0.3218194246292114,
0.710801362991333,
0.26191475987434387,
-0.3543926179409027,
-0.4281192123889923,
0.527904748916626,
-0.11583811044692993,
0.5059288740158081,
0.37211984395980835,
0.7789249420166016,
-0.28394225239753723,
0.42575979232788086,
-0.4175456464290619,
-0.21606816351413727,
-0.14142775535583496,
-0.7605316638946533,
-1.1207482814788818,
-0.45394089818000793,
-0.4835032522678375,
-0.09344527125358582,
-0.3062179386615753,
0.7186276316642761,
0.8858867287635803,
-0.7079758048057556,
0.3079669177532196,
0.20413121581077576,
-0.011337636038661003,
0.19223904609680176,
-0.21993616223335266,
0.5754637122154236,
-0.26800525188446045,
-0.8700243830680847,
0.2978711724281311,
0.5632933378219604,
0.08653458207845688,
-0.21131764352321625,
0.18282243609428406,
-0.06386712193489075,
-0.16115257143974304,
0.8273374438285828,
-0.011631595902144909,
-1.0000406503677368,
-0.6877458095550537,
-0.2835526168346405,
-0.047252822667360306,
0.2844243049621582,
0.8005089163780212,
-0.7243039011955261,
0.3423929810523987,
0.1401478797197342,
0.8967497944831848,
0.406146377325058,
0.24141532182693481,
0.27916720509529114,
-0.8201913237571716,
0.48511403799057007,
0.2555161714553833,
0.7894550561904907,
0.5256710052490234,
-0.1696024090051651,
0.303902268409729,
0.40061676502227783,
-0.0958089679479599,
-0.6810608506202698,
0.36610206961631775,
-1.5158487558364868,
-0.08283912390470505,
1.238619089126587,
-0.3103741705417633,
-0.475754052400589,
0.17253102362155914,
-0.3705618977546692,
0.09577374905347824,
-0.34722191095352173,
0.521782636642456,
0.7616020441055298,
0.39756107330322266,
-0.5708604454994202,
-0.3494114279747009,
0.1059761717915535,
0.08825039863586426,
-0.9445334076881409,
0.041267793625593185,
0.909783124923706,
0.2417566180229187,
0.8971194624900818,
0.1897081881761551,
-0.23961803317070007,
0.24623391032218933,
-0.004050505347549915,
0.3580363988876343,
-0.25165998935699463,
-0.6986373066902161,
-0.21694737672805786,
0.7554731965065002,
-0.23067595064640045,
-0.49098333716392517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02549v1 | Are Large Language Models Table-based Fact-Checkers? | 2024-02-04T15:52:59 | 2024-02-04T15:52:59 | Hangwen Zhang, Qingyi Si, Peng Fu, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Table-based Fact Verification (TFV) aims to extract the entailment relation
between statements and structured tables. Existing TFV methods based on
small-scaled models suffer from insufficient labeled data and weak zero-shot
ability. Recently, the appearance of Large Language Models (LLMs) has gained
lots of attraction in research fields. They have shown powerful zero-shot and
in-context learning abilities on several NLP tasks, but their potential on TFV
is still unknown. In this work, we implement a preliminary study about whether
LLMs are table-based fact-checkers. In detail, we design diverse prompts to
explore how the in-context learning can help LLMs in TFV, i.e., zero-shot and
few-shot TFV capability. Besides, we carefully design and construct TFV
instructions to study the performance gain brought by the instruction tuning of
LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate that LLMs can achieve acceptable results
on zero-shot and few-shot TFV with prompt engineering, while instruction-tuning
can stimulate the TFV capability significantly. We also make some valuable
findings about the format of zero-shot prompts and the number of in-context
examples. Finally, we analyze some possible directions to promote the accuracy
of TFV via LLMs, which is beneficial to further research of table reasoning. | [
-0.10874812304973602,
-1.1135047674179077,
0.8867776989936829,
-0.09138999879360199,
-0.287690132856369,
-0.023863617330789566,
-0.22571668028831482,
-0.2717224359512329,
-0.1323489099740982,
0.6540882587432861,
-0.3221389055252075,
-0.7194181084632874,
-0.5710731148719788,
0.2060498148202896,
-0.5167158246040344,
0.7591248154640198,
-0.18313054740428925,
-0.1678658425807953,
-0.3179556131362915,
0.016748575493693352,
-0.6400600671768188,
-0.28580501675605774,
-0.44491681456565857,
-0.4942466616630554,
0.37749406695365906,
0.8856829404830933,
0.47450125217437744,
1.0052202939987183,
0.2976931929588318,
0.2698105573654175,
-0.1340334117412567,
0.1648244708776474,
-0.44342732429504395,
0.08892862498760223,
-0.14655017852783203,
-0.5346642136573792,
-0.1976393312215805,
-0.1475473940372467,
0.7186390161514282,
0.28119561076164246,
-0.127659410238266,
0.29576054215431213,
-0.16367074847221375,
0.5280287265777588,
-0.4618770480155945,
0.57737135887146,
-0.6263281106948853,
0.23811765015125275,
-0.2126532793045044,
-0.1989038586616516,
-0.6866683959960938,
-0.3256150186061859,
-0.07456648349761963,
-0.06710102409124374,
0.20400844514369965,
0.40507927536964417,
0.9705812335014343,
0.33381426334381104,
-0.8230109810829163,
-0.2906588912010193,
-0.8976518511772156,
0.670845627784729,
-0.8936274647712708,
0.6097425818443298,
0.18185947835445404,
0.4243168532848358,
-0.44618093967437744,
-0.44183704257011414,
-0.9320974349975586,
-0.48363569378852844,
-0.2833438217639923,
-0.3641946017742157,
0.04091498628258705,
0.002096378244459629,
0.7427427768707275,
0.23063644766807556,
-0.5607013702392578,
0.35365718603134155,
0.0020551218185573816,
-0.11178130656480789,
0.43204599618911743,
0.28143224120140076,
0.3527546525001526,
-0.18147261440753937,
-0.23993435502052307,
0.04297441989183426,
-1.0755281448364258,
0.11177332699298859,
-0.3526766300201416,
0.22361359000205994,
-0.33281564712524414,
0.8589789867401123,
-0.2985723614692688,
1.1709667444229126,
-0.15787504613399506,
-0.6499348878860474,
0.007427761796861887,
-0.19137558341026306,
-0.4250808358192444,
0.18334221839904785,
0.6963520050048828,
0.2426045835018158,
0.17897829413414001,
-0.3883053660392761,
-0.3228154182434082,
-0.1491546630859375,
-0.12886729836463928,
-0.9180087447166443,
0.24860779941082,
0.28758078813552856,
-0.20356926321983337,
-0.2953617572784424,
-0.10599733889102936,
-0.6005970239639282,
-0.3690842390060425,
-0.30845963954925537,
0.7545933723449707,
-0.24837978184223175,
-0.02401902712881565,
-0.008606577292084694,
0.024816865101456642,
0.664577841758728,
0.49572503566741943,
-0.7088649868965149,
-0.08935898542404175,
0.9077274203300476,
0.8650910258293152,
-0.16007587313652039,
-0.0084761381149292,
-0.9047359824180603,
0.2704983949661255,
-0.5317764282226562,
0.8046747446060181,
-0.502131998538971,
-0.1873975396156311,
0.2681153416633606,
-0.0755462646484375,
0.21740645170211792,
-0.3792671859264374,
0.5121203064918518,
-0.6445633172988892,
0.05724867060780525,
-0.7035592198371887,
-0.7074925303459167,
-0.14111462235450745,
0.8589871525764465,
-0.6178593635559082,
0.7199853658676147,
-0.1044778823852539,
-0.5298910737037659,
0.7142072319984436,
-0.6445136070251465,
-0.582426130771637,
0.10040857642889023,
-0.4393429160118103,
-0.47863373160362244,
-0.1329771727323532,
0.23403982818126678,
0.6613485217094421,
-0.42807716131210327,
0.39750853180885315,
-0.31903138756752014,
-0.537412166595459,
0.4157956540584564,
-0.1387999951839447,
0.4893758296966553,
-0.05599217861890793,
-0.4180300831794739,
0.259965717792511,
-0.7832391262054443,
-0.06225433573126793,
0.020045947283506393,
-0.5361824631690979,
0.14034977555274963,
0.11459808796644211,
-0.36539384722709656,
0.33636072278022766,
-0.2427653819322586,
-0.8270151615142822,
0.22069989144802094,
-0.28181180357933044,
0.47768843173980713,
0.3207791745662689,
0.2522814869880676,
0.25235211849212646,
-0.389252632856369,
0.26708588004112244,
0.16558563709259033,
-0.2833876609802246,
-0.19726984202861786,
-0.30023476481437683,
-1.0286650657653809,
-0.17876498401165009,
0.5118419528007507,
0.630631148815155,
-1.1805392503738403,
0.4265555739402771,
-0.14537954330444336,
-0.3213537931442261,
0.18464604020118713,
-0.17466102540493011,
0.23923230171203613,
1.0583266019821167,
0.3420986533164978,
0.29026004672050476,
-0.4207163453102112,
-0.8360189199447632,
-0.1013176366686821,
-0.14099441468715668,
-0.08946242928504944,
0.3779284954071045,
0.7097891569137573,
0.2321702390909195,
0.9394243955612183,
-0.3300773799419403,
-0.30852916836738586,
-0.33560681343078613,
-0.02195867709815502,
0.38547420501708984,
0.184865802526474,
0.4540407955646515,
-0.3044775426387787,
-0.4666617214679718,
-0.13573893904685974,
-0.9440656304359436,
-0.009507237933576107,
-0.004134591668844223,
0.17027613520622253,
0.47076305747032166,
0.5598166584968567,
-0.6698252558708191,
0.32527956366539,
0.1370914727449417,
-0.3835269808769226,
0.3033013939857483,
-0.17075546085834503,
0.248433917760849,
-0.7294239401817322,
-0.08100192993879318,
0.23380248248577118,
-0.3898591995239258,
-0.7384105324745178,
0.09115628898143768,
0.22192992269992828,
-0.10874190181493759,
-0.609346866607666,
0.5066950917243958,
-0.4341130256652832,
-0.11306259781122208,
-0.2724621593952179,
0.018787937238812447,
-0.10547392815351486,
0.42533376812934875,
0.16162247955799103,
0.6550758481025696,
0.5885343551635742,
-0.7681020498275757,
0.24070614576339722,
0.1659833937883377,
-0.7267782688140869,
0.4687146246433258,
-0.7414570450782776,
0.089244045317173,
-0.2516448199748993,
0.3583446741104126,
-1.0130008459091187,
-0.24669285118579865,
0.167602077126503,
-0.04099050909280777,
0.5264900326728821,
-0.10726337134838104,
-0.7169656157493591,
-0.23060409724712372,
-0.17365647852420807,
-0.1440536379814148,
0.4487530589103699,
-0.7484499216079712,
0.7168555855751038,
0.34367579221725464,
0.2836343050003052,
-0.8749474287033081,
-0.6362593173980713,
0.15228570997714996,
-0.04742969200015068,
-0.6740692257881165,
0.050788406282663345,
0.26697179675102234,
-0.47013771533966064,
-0.25860631465911865,
-0.30234673619270325,
0.13494841754436493,
-0.03816593438386917,
0.27976423501968384,
0.2788962125778198,
-0.41492265462875366,
0.42914485931396484,
-0.19142571091651917,
0.1941623091697693,
0.13788552582263947,
-0.12210642546415329,
0.3337230086326599,
-0.36812323331832886,
-0.22916579246520996,
-0.17213183641433716,
0.024165188893675804,
0.32432126998901367,
-0.25739821791648865,
0.9476287961006165,
0.5396572351455688,
-0.373948872089386,
-0.48383453488349915,
-0.9750222563743591,
-0.2747114896774292,
-0.43309471011161804,
0.2670360207557678,
-0.2639073133468628,
-1.3431345224380493,
0.5721110105514526,
-0.08047234266996384,
0.12432660907506943,
0.48748403787612915,
0.6399689316749573,
-0.13471680879592896,
0.5281071066856384,
0.4628029763698578,
0.20038414001464844,
0.2019733339548111,
-0.17687608301639557,
0.09355125576257706,
-0.3570578396320343,
-0.513150155544281,
-0.8530222177505493,
-0.31337231397628784,
-0.45643335580825806,
-0.41818249225616455,
0.4708615839481354,
-0.29018309712409973,
-0.5549324154853821,
-0.026525788009166718,
-0.1713036298751831,
0.7965306639671326,
0.23587507009506226,
0.22984422743320465,
0.3691388666629791,
-0.09265304356813431,
-0.10593836009502411,
0.10303254425525665,
-0.7408086657524109,
-0.4107491970062256,
0.839198112487793,
0.3376670479774475,
0.7180415987968445,
0.2027880847454071,
0.48955824971199036,
0.37402579188346863,
0.35753950476646423,
-0.9846464395523071,
0.6806886196136475,
-0.08408841490745544,
-0.5539684891700745,
-0.6377092599868774,
-0.6432148814201355,
-0.4263843595981598,
0.2205064296722412,
-0.5498718023300171,
-0.6301425695419312,
0.07952306419610977,
0.21239548921585083,
-0.22331620752811432,
0.4230022728443146,
-0.6294533014297485,
0.9374759197235107,
-0.20881111919879913,
-0.5116266012191772,
0.05859203264117241,
-0.38654565811157227,
0.620661199092865,
0.06649891287088394,
0.09994639456272125,
-0.049815330654382706,
-0.03715458884835243,
0.5133911371231079,
-0.525592029094696,
0.7888162732124329,
-0.205011248588562,
-0.27760469913482666,
0.38858187198638916,
0.3602016568183899,
0.7162953019142151,
0.2155149281024933,
-0.23935337364673615,
0.30205100774765015,
-0.17058992385864258,
0.057169944047927856,
-0.5971423983573914,
0.7214432954788208,
-0.6079077124595642,
-0.9172912240028381,
-0.48566579818725586,
-0.4480476379394531,
-0.3454999327659607,
0.23287054896354675,
-0.12247611582279205,
0.5496965050697327,
-0.17946757376194,
0.6466796398162842,
0.9198575019836426,
-0.09141427278518677,
0.6346073746681213,
1.0982991456985474,
-0.1587304323911667,
0.04920056462287903,
0.6989575028419495,
0.23713618516921997,
-0.13596025109291077,
1.0469828844070435,
0.3524876534938812,
-0.3313169777393341,
-0.6251387000083923,
-0.7357200980186462,
0.19626271724700928,
-0.6061960458755493,
-0.4306422472000122,
-0.4964697062969208,
-0.10836251825094223,
0.08839458227157593,
0.03389391675591469,
-0.1272105723619461,
-0.40008544921875,
-0.10173726081848145,
-0.09178219735622406,
0.39469295740127563,
0.714697539806366,
0.2452264279127121,
0.1967983841896057,
-0.7921805381774902,
0.22190682590007782,
0.40982285141944885,
0.53592449426651,
0.03298850730061531,
-0.5840297341346741,
-0.08175975829362869,
-0.18996992707252502,
0.006169704720377922,
-0.858770489692688,
0.0886041522026062,
0.14513519406318665,
0.42774441838264465,
0.3013577461242676,
-0.003798842430114746,
0.21696561574935913,
-0.6574432253837585,
0.864191472530365,
-0.16898895800113678,
-1.0125950574874878,
0.27738040685653687,
-0.25448888540267944,
0.3129291534423828,
0.2605200409889221,
0.11931073665618896,
-0.4878336787223816,
-0.19576193392276764,
-0.21804998815059662,
-0.32272854447364807,
0.9210599660873413,
-0.07194945961236954,
-0.14672531187534332,
0.03917236998677254,
0.6185263395309448,
-0.055761486291885376,
0.21687394380569458,
-0.6998785734176636,
-0.1896485537290573,
-0.14744403958320618,
0.061738140881061554,
-0.032792747020721436,
-0.5604211688041687,
-0.05973188951611519,
-0.00005037874143454246,
0.5562403798103333,
-0.14011059701442719,
-0.03754710033535957,
-0.022195540368556976,
-0.10369006544351578,
-0.3619769215583801,
0.7192620635032654,
0.8008952736854553,
0.7738442420959473,
-0.3921531140804291,
0.22939589619636536,
0.4146251380443573,
-0.020608309656381607,
0.2823329567909241,
-0.2868770658969879,
-0.5178142786026001,
0.043808359652757645,
0.4032534956932068,
0.9121273756027222,
0.12337782979011536,
-0.37495288252830505,
0.5435109734535217,
-0.013034089468419552,
-0.3182613253593445,
-0.11274740099906921,
0.3600342273712158,
0.06809030473232269,
0.251033216714859,
0.10202619433403015,
-0.329007625579834,
-0.0688590332865715,
-0.6395591497421265,
0.17735770344734192,
0.5914196372032166,
-0.146482914686203,
0.09986352920532227,
0.5360072255134583,
0.05466246232390404,
-0.5471594333648682,
0.6747472882270813,
-0.1875724196434021,
-0.3054826259613037,
0.7062296271324158,
0.6796485185623169,
0.4923478364944458,
-0.061243485659360886,
0.31785139441490173,
0.5244934558868408,
0.47225821018218994,
-0.3310966491699219,
0.315030574798584,
-0.15062786638736725,
-0.7481080293655396,
-0.7032735347747803,
-0.49750787019729614,
-0.6790290474891663,
0.5401018857955933,
-0.12410682439804077,
0.4950956702232361,
-0.5007253289222717,
0.04831830412149429,
0.1161857545375824,
-0.08408130705356598,
-0.6345944404602051,
0.27600207924842834,
0.10924916714429855,
0.9892165660858154,
-0.7791261672973633,
0.788735032081604,
0.4411159157752991,
-0.26523905992507935,
-1.037541151046753,
0.019405260682106018,
0.07994142919778824,
-0.6802446842193604,
0.7685641050338745,
0.04130702465772629,
0.019986161962151527,
-0.32224419713020325,
-0.7916309833526611,
-0.9092203378677368,
1.0142788887023926,
0.5631715655326843,
-0.7079792618751526,
-0.04552195221185684,
0.4141214191913605,
0.5953088402748108,
-0.26967698335647583,
0.27815505862236023,
0.5686091184616089,
0.566349983215332,
0.677113950252533,
-0.7826717495918274,
0.31150054931640625,
0.23671120405197144,
-0.15996795892715454,
0.17220132052898407,
-0.4932914972305298,
0.7049174904823303,
-0.2555210292339325,
0.0046148113906383514,
-0.5231419205665588,
0.807762086391449,
0.33278888463974,
0.19855746626853943,
0.5319299697875977,
0.3469453454017639,
0.40884366631507874,
-0.24464218318462372,
0.8824083805084229,
-0.1959642916917801,
0.1617688089609146,
1.1146528720855713,
-0.5511990189552307,
0.868553876876831,
0.31175291538238525,
-0.031725894659757614,
0.5672770142555237,
0.300748735666275,
-0.35781240463256836,
0.08387213945388794,
0.18100731074810028,
-0.04748797416687012,
-0.470313161611557,
-0.28183022141456604,
-0.22376658022403717,
0.7451928853988647,
0.5423709750175476,
-0.3628619313240051,
-0.49429014325141907,
-0.24139992892742157,
-0.030083490535616875,
-0.2211027443408966,
-0.40973570942878723,
0.8175886273384094,
0.07569625228643417,
-0.7169546484947205,
0.5653965473175049,
0.1683257520198822,
0.403906911611557,
-0.511535108089447,
-0.39198583364486694,
-0.029015423730015755,
0.06418159604072571,
-0.2574140429496765,
-0.961631178855896,
0.0985449030995369,
0.08437424898147583,
0.029919179156422615,
-0.03769603744149208,
0.9475614428520203,
-0.6056139469146729,
-0.2468554973602295,
-0.38136741518974304,
0.6272883415222168,
0.06090224161744118,
0.025121258571743965,
-0.2177644520998001,
0.10207601636648178,
0.03219560906291008,
-0.1112949401140213,
0.2542073428630829,
0.4543169140815735,
-0.07544252276420593,
0.603054940700531,
0.34368449449539185,
-0.0851067304611206,
-0.40766456723213196,
0.0942910835146904,
0.5591427087783813,
-0.5664047598838806,
-0.4179013669490814,
-1.1691515445709229,
0.22013437747955322,
0.0314670167863369,
0.12566711008548737,
0.7955775856971741,
0.5429710149765015,
0.7276653051376343,
-0.3254316449165344,
0.44968751072883606,
-0.022144323214888573,
0.415923148393631,
-0.7283775210380554,
0.773008406162262,
-0.4921201765537262,
0.28002721071243286,
0.0022597704082727432,
-0.7728032469749451,
-0.607754647731781,
0.4381440579891205,
-0.4235641062259674,
0.021367086097598076,
0.6112520098686218,
0.8400919437408447,
0.04302716255187988,
0.16947676241397858,
0.4611961841583252,
0.35013020038604736,
0.42574307322502136,
0.4166545569896698,
0.6531262993812561,
-0.11510203033685684,
0.550786554813385,
-0.13899502158164978,
-0.11515620350837708,
-0.3691485524177551,
-1.2408490180969238,
-1.262622594833374,
-0.3130902349948883,
-0.3272029757499695,
-0.42945989966392517,
-0.06408698111772537,
0.9403033256530762,
0.4133991301059723,
-0.8546180725097656,
-0.1932726949453354,
0.10537151247262955,
0.5054212808609009,
0.06326137483119965,
-0.17048203945159912,
0.5816172957420349,
-0.15233564376831055,
-0.20058384537696838,
0.35341688990592957,
0.35430023074150085,
0.027247169986367226,
-0.15215235948562622,
0.21239018440246582,
-0.24310049414634705,
0.08924498409032822,
0.8406151533126831,
0.34080904722213745,
-0.6150427460670471,
-0.5402494072914124,
-0.0414651595056057,
-0.1142200157046318,
0.21368908882141113,
0.8862916827201843,
-0.7171119451522827,
0.22278454899787903,
0.6636718511581421,
0.5386359095573425,
0.7077172994613647,
-0.12354564666748047,
0.40735092759132385,
-0.9423160552978516,
-0.035514287650585175,
-0.02246062085032463,
0.5569667220115662,
0.3652835190296173,
-0.3860343098640442,
0.34036511182785034,
-0.0898747593164444,
-0.6480894088745117,
-0.8802387118339539,
0.16990840435028076,
-0.9244139194488525,
0.05443426966667175,
1.2866028547286987,
0.04898925498127937,
-0.460562527179718,
-0.03533436730504036,
0.012505045160651207,
0.39656707644462585,
-0.4601069688796997,
0.9824360609054565,
0.7834163904190063,
-0.14783701300621033,
-0.27705082297325134,
-0.4490603804588318,
0.6699404120445251,
0.02951449528336525,
-0.9128605723381042,
0.061185888946056366,
0.5195047855377197,
0.4104926586151123,
0.07859893143177032,
0.22102512419223785,
0.06523963063955307,
0.20563387870788574,
-0.13377854228019714,
-0.07943525910377502,
-0.5709303617477417,
-0.3207218647003174,
-0.2823249101638794,
0.5337710976600647,
0.18584193289279938,
0.09950581938028336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02548v1 | "What's my model inside of?": Exploring the role of environments for grounded natural language understanding | 2024-02-04T15:52:46 | 2024-02-04T15:52:46 | Ronen Tamari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI | In contrast to classical cognitive science which studied brains in isolation,
ecological approaches focused on the role of the body and environment in
shaping cognition. Similarly, in this thesis we adopt an ecological approach to
grounded natural language understanding (NLU) research. Grounded language
understanding studies language understanding systems situated in the context of
events, actions and precepts in naturalistic/simulated virtual environments.
Where classic research tends to focus on designing new models and optimization
methods while treating environments as given, we explore the potential of
environment design for improving data collection and model development. We
developed novel training and annotation approaches for procedural text
understanding based on text-based game environments. We also drew upon embodied
cognitive linguistics literature to propose a roadmap for grounded NLP
research, and to inform the development of a new benchmark for measuring the
progress of large language models on challenging commonsense reasoning tasks.
We leveraged the richer supervision provided by text-based game environments to
develop Breakpoint Transformers, a novel approach to modeling intermediate
semantic information in long narrative or procedural texts. Finally, we
integrated theories on the role of environments in collective human
intelligence to propose a design for AI-augmented "social thinking
environments" for knowledge workers like scientists. | [
-0.5240042209625244,
-1.0503191947937012,
0.7988206744194031,
0.14829376339912415,
-0.02874644286930561,
0.18038734793663025,
-0.40946054458618164,
-0.49805766344070435,
-0.02925943210721016,
0.6194810271263123,
-0.655754804611206,
-0.5244244933128357,
-0.21366214752197266,
0.214013010263443,
0.018743978813290596,
0.4719275236129761,
0.39437219500541687,
0.015613819472491741,
-0.5902655720710754,
-0.2720899283885956,
-0.6071568727493286,
-0.6522122025489807,
-0.5628036856651306,
-0.5494181513786316,
0.19258633255958557,
0.34001392126083374,
0.6772639751434326,
0.5695175528526306,
0.3829893171787262,
0.35613372921943665,
-0.5325931310653687,
-0.09165963530540466,
-0.3353145122528076,
0.0966605618596077,
-0.3106388747692108,
-0.4478428065776825,
0.08307104557752609,
-0.12976187467575073,
0.5086825489997864,
0.8160972595214844,
-0.01084327232092619,
0.07806556671857834,
0.08924775570631027,
0.3837730288505554,
-0.38212817907333374,
0.5794926881790161,
-0.2755182981491089,
0.27404555678367615,
0.31807491183280945,
0.010936844162642956,
-0.4628784656524658,
-0.03243890404701233,
0.11589796096086502,
-0.9654171466827393,
-0.009678075090050697,
0.15855833888053894,
0.6383342742919922,
0.33615610003471375,
-0.4182487726211548,
-0.4395318031311035,
-0.5198045969009399,
0.8701415657997131,
-0.8647280335426331,
0.46287065744400024,
0.55880206823349,
0.005886064376682043,
-0.3001565635204315,
-0.44344133138656616,
-0.6802656054496765,
-0.13626860082149506,
-0.2767769396305084,
0.44883185625076294,
-0.15316174924373627,
0.14012044668197632,
0.1739230453968048,
0.18493413925170898,
-0.3188461661338806,
0.2474210411310196,
-0.4030407667160034,
0.26541316509246826,
0.5752841830253601,
0.08638070523738861,
0.6056311726570129,
-0.4144536554813385,
-0.056367985904216766,
-0.10299424827098846,
-0.2706568241119385,
0.3357120454311371,
0.178781658411026,
0.32391026616096497,
-0.14829708635807037,
0.5349526405334473,
-0.12154771387577057,
0.7638600468635559,
-0.26235899329185486,
-0.016858840361237526,
-0.15135367214679718,
-0.3004368543624878,
-0.3061966896057129,
0.08680892735719681,
0.3610508143901825,
0.4476107656955719,
0.2685526907444,
-0.1894243061542511,
-0.025744784623384476,
0.2669222056865692,
0.5676448345184326,
-0.31950199604034424,
-0.17590948939323425,
0.2462063878774643,
-0.6285917162895203,
-0.6264569759368896,
-0.17385517060756683,
-0.8229561448097229,
-0.460921972990036,
-0.9798665642738342,
0.01860266737639904,
-0.5538893342018127,
-0.7688179016113281,
0.17877410352230072,
-0.3074240982532501,
0.3660678565502167,
0.14454743266105652,
-0.939538300037384,
0.7352510690689087,
1.0303891897201538,
0.8531942963600159,
0.13451023399829865,
-0.28919681906700134,
0.004882358014583588,
0.13594914972782135,
-0.311786413192749,
0.6629838943481445,
-0.5269871354103088,
-0.5593518018722534,
0.09183592349290848,
-0.12949393689632416,
0.07009903341531754,
-0.325120210647583,
0.5674185752868652,
-0.3029945194721222,
0.5234328508377075,
-0.3746321201324463,
-0.44781798124313354,
-0.6304206252098083,
0.4903758466243744,
-0.48005855083465576,
1.1195217370986938,
-0.24417033791542053,
-0.7800262570381165,
0.28690725564956665,
-1.052939772605896,
-0.40537554025650024,
0.11562683433294296,
-0.13737142086029053,
0.16115045547485352,
0.3601883053779602,
0.21177339553833008,
0.066024050116539,
-0.032122593373060226,
0.4074781537055969,
-0.24332614243030548,
-0.42853793501853943,
0.21800260245800018,
-0.14866872131824493,
0.9858073592185974,
0.08692455291748047,
-0.37837985157966614,
0.12481224536895752,
-0.6395792365074158,
0.2537277638912201,
0.19554363191127777,
-0.26412233710289,
-0.7495751976966858,
0.45274925231933594,
0.22429142892360687,
0.2535102367401123,
-0.0963614210486412,
-0.318327397108078,
0.14738547801971436,
-0.5100162625312805,
0.7497750520706177,
0.5921820998191833,
-0.02829921804368496,
0.6930790543556213,
-0.1818556785583496,
0.15300780534744263,
-0.34846943616867065,
-0.11581139266490936,
-0.3917469382286072,
-0.5165607929229736,
-0.623723030090332,
-0.02973335050046444,
-0.1866445094347,
0.3979940116405487,
-0.5632144212722778,
0.5955905914306641,
-0.14692601561546326,
-0.3411675989627838,
-0.4198910892009735,
-0.17614628374576569,
0.36759597063064575,
0.5147354006767273,
0.38475826382637024,
-0.12758587300777435,
-0.5154146552085876,
-0.6718512773513794,
-0.20925839245319366,
-0.4746286869049072,
-0.0637778639793396,
0.406998872756958,
0.7069023847579956,
-0.3115646541118622,
1.3468292951583862,
-0.5054420232772827,
-0.08244702219963074,
-0.17042769491672516,
0.19132587313652039,
0.2749841809272766,
0.6254682540893555,
0.45752251148223877,
-0.7332183718681335,
0.14384949207305908,
0.10581935197114944,
-1.1853022575378418,
-0.06659678369760513,
0.009590299800038338,
-0.16007812321186066,
-0.285928338766098,
0.6390939950942993,
-0.6417862772941589,
0.38114699721336365,
0.4626511037349701,
-0.5760433673858643,
0.35479027032852173,
-0.37866440415382385,
0.21856342256069183,
-0.9495312571525574,
-0.018743805587291718,
0.021767200902104378,
0.08974482119083405,
-0.7652531266212463,
0.3732031285762787,
-0.2552391290664673,
-0.36361122131347656,
-0.1054406687617302,
0.5917147994041443,
-0.633865475654602,
-0.029609762132167816,
-0.31090107560157776,
0.30711230635643005,
0.10335669666528702,
0.3898376226425171,
0.440698504447937,
0.4228179156780243,
0.400597482919693,
-0.6007265448570251,
-0.042477525770664215,
0.4381972849369049,
-0.2873739004135132,
0.6614920496940613,
-0.6466426253318787,
0.31747114658355713,
-0.5646074414253235,
0.1501069962978363,
-0.7434610724449158,
-0.30242347717285156,
0.037694357335567474,
-0.40037187933921814,
-0.0926659107208252,
-0.2604721784591675,
-0.5277047157287598,
-0.16305308043956757,
0.13172881305217743,
0.1216859444975853,
0.5301973819732666,
-0.5344606637954712,
0.6609306931495667,
0.6466376781463623,
-0.14444085955619812,
-0.10289982706308365,
-0.8700941205024719,
0.16755297780036926,
-0.4635169506072998,
-0.6894250512123108,
0.12347971647977829,
0.003579729935154319,
-1.2146662473678589,
0.039294399321079254,
-0.04253125563263893,
-0.3572847545146942,
0.44708696007728577,
0.43591219186782837,
-0.0892280712723732,
-0.6044158339500427,
0.2636057734489441,
0.043040066957473755,
-0.1338433176279068,
0.45707857608795166,
-0.35942772030830383,
0.15328171849250793,
-0.15838833153247833,
-0.05426754057407379,
-0.02195705845952034,
0.5741599798202515,
0.5424448251724243,
-0.15391474962234497,
0.965561032295227,
0.0071913315914571285,
-0.7098488211631775,
-0.2346677929162979,
-0.3492070734500885,
-0.25121110677719116,
-0.4505253732204437,
0.1753450483083725,
-0.24978089332580566,
-0.7287978529930115,
0.39588141441345215,
-0.015391985885798931,
0.25786757469177246,
0.19422467052936554,
0.3716319501399994,
-0.325085312128067,
0.5283859372138977,
0.8154471516609192,
0.16379041969776154,
0.47235307097435,
-0.11857983469963074,
0.2520934045314789,
-0.7765046954154968,
-0.10231909155845642,
-0.38374796509742737,
-0.018595144152641296,
-0.18151187896728516,
-0.5723534226417542,
-0.019645316526293755,
0.16292844712734222,
-0.3838939070701599,
0.17089636623859406,
-0.5310530066490173,
0.6682243347167969,
0.45381879806518555,
0.0007950004655867815,
0.3501063287258148,
-0.2363896518945694,
-0.1820131540298462,
-0.3513985276222229,
-0.6200714111328125,
-1.110693097114563,
0.6315590143203735,
0.4392715394496918,
0.24829864501953125,
0.1879836469888687,
0.4919969439506531,
0.172654926776886,
0.39231041073799133,
-0.48776400089263916,
0.3897228240966797,
0.4608317017555237,
-0.7098479270935059,
-0.34477299451828003,
-0.06955615431070328,
-0.7885159254074097,
0.6717869639396667,
-0.24971145391464233,
-0.8049386143684387,
0.0021770072635263205,
-0.17688307166099548,
-0.26148733496665955,
0.22969065606594086,
-0.7292817831039429,
0.8208116888999939,
-0.23195844888687134,
-0.36635053157806396,
-0.23491345345973969,
-0.6565106511116028,
0.4913093149662018,
0.3262762725353241,
0.8303248882293701,
-0.09560315310955048,
0.19447998702526093,
0.4548434615135193,
0.06303641945123672,
0.9678962230682373,
-0.08503685891628265,
-0.13552770018577576,
0.30893439054489136,
0.18054798245429993,
0.05562480911612511,
0.3947741985321045,
-0.13906198740005493,
0.28710007667541504,
0.10972613096237183,
-0.262958288192749,
-0.47496119141578674,
0.631486177444458,
-0.6736022233963013,
-0.3951733708381653,
-0.5727589726448059,
-0.3808663487434387,
-0.07438583672046661,
0.20698411762714386,
0.058904483914375305,
0.29153621196746826,
-0.5566660761833191,
0.34654638171195984,
0.7563445568084717,
-0.4789576530456543,
0.37664300203323364,
0.6031831502914429,
-0.1878259927034378,
-0.12467034161090851,
0.5492669939994812,
-0.16582715511322021,
0.19569997489452362,
0.25271308422088623,
0.30274638533592224,
-0.2873097360134125,
-0.30356478691101074,
-0.08378095924854279,
-0.008252471685409546,
-0.9636573791503906,
0.2085413783788681,
-0.7517235279083252,
-0.13170310854911804,
-0.3194224238395691,
-0.629896879196167,
-0.15960006415843964,
0.09726952761411667,
-0.5200961828231812,
-0.48335686326026917,
0.36134111881256104,
1.0564838647842407,
-0.17704112827777863,
0.3753546476364136,
-0.5468907952308655,
0.28907281160354614,
0.022563545033335686,
0.20416823029518127,
0.14317284524440765,
-0.11712673306465149,
-0.10173863172531128,
0.21850080788135529,
-0.0215277262032032,
-0.9067589044570923,
0.5768603086471558,
-0.06012629345059395,
0.6771183013916016,
0.13610640168190002,
-0.19301681220531464,
0.6316362023353577,
-0.515140950679779,
0.9251057505607605,
-0.13822613656520844,
-1.0063471794128418,
0.6473428606987,
-0.638159453868866,
0.3758802115917206,
0.6665671467781067,
0.003314126282930374,
-0.8293907046318054,
-0.4322032034397125,
-0.7951011657714844,
-0.7814738750457764,
0.4262438416481018,
0.40277954936027527,
0.17837533354759216,
-0.019234057515859604,
0.26468825340270996,
0.07161049544811249,
0.13004516065120697,
-0.8836256265640259,
0.028950873762369156,
-0.19314926862716675,
-0.23658080399036407,
-0.33847612142562866,
-0.04836783930659294,
-0.20323707163333893,
-0.3502587378025055,
0.2752896845340729,
-0.3666503429412842,
0.20712031424045563,
0.18242065608501434,
-0.24078214168548584,
0.06949476897716522,
0.19502152502536774,
0.5261005759239197,
0.6175659894943237,
-0.0005447600269690156,
0.30974647402763367,
0.278496652841568,
-0.3568532168865204,
0.004465989302843809,
-0.30812332034111023,
-0.1165165901184082,
-0.15203315019607544,
0.6294293403625488,
0.39146527647972107,
0.8461921811103821,
-0.722402036190033,
-0.1096486747264862,
-0.16857294738292694,
-0.16150720417499542,
-0.4942176043987274,
0.03922485560178757,
0.38259878754615784,
0.1808667629957199,
0.23086704313755035,
-0.03431619703769684,
0.14360743761062622,
-0.7501552104949951,
0.24309508502483368,
0.1282152682542801,
-0.5638229846954346,
-0.3004327714443207,
0.610822319984436,
0.18899011611938477,
-0.500734269618988,
0.8848103880882263,
0.08337780833244324,
-0.38890764117240906,
0.9902231097221375,
0.5524007678031921,
0.7637683749198914,
0.33690303564071655,
0.17124970257282257,
0.5078169703483582,
0.5812498927116394,
-0.14570049941539764,
0.1035628616809845,
-0.1161952093243599,
-0.8503811955451965,
-0.356925904750824,
-0.4917076528072357,
-0.46998247504234314,
0.012916186824440956,
-0.5449132323265076,
0.17235369980335236,
-0.572319507598877,
0.06411615759134293,
-0.03940464183688164,
-0.14504562318325043,
-0.5530074834823608,
0.32487982511520386,
0.3130567669868469,
0.6424663662910461,
-0.9276213049888611,
0.4431341886520386,
0.5918779969215393,
-0.48937416076660156,
-0.42606887221336365,
-0.00830579362809658,
0.24886378645896912,
-0.2765560448169708,
0.6302906274795532,
0.27514010667800903,
-0.012977690435945988,
0.09825443476438522,
-0.8469623923301697,
-1.0376408100128174,
0.8184636831283569,
-0.06323902308940887,
-0.059710793197155,
0.11364267021417618,
-0.30180537700653076,
0.7701164484024048,
-0.3706938922405243,
0.26903703808784485,
0.7005370855331421,
0.640910804271698,
-0.34381866455078125,
-0.364853173494339,
-0.13706369698047638,
-0.4479227364063263,
-0.1722424477338791,
-0.04533974453806877,
-0.5534245371818542,
0.6990939378738403,
-0.007116121239960194,
-0.2085808515548706,
-0.014296367764472961,
0.7080787420272827,
0.47890520095825195,
0.41464364528656006,
0.1797276735305786,
0.5622507333755493,
0.6202247142791748,
-0.25262650847435,
1.01762855052948,
0.06949099898338318,
0.26409438252449036,
0.9910627007484436,
-0.21801210939884186,
0.6060466766357422,
0.558622419834137,
0.12812204658985138,
0.5269385576248169,
0.6812762022018433,
0.2714160084724426,
0.4519291818141937,
0.5568351149559021,
-0.22294864058494568,
-0.04186813160777092,
-0.1753777265548706,
-0.1527576446533203,
0.4400619566440582,
0.681409478187561,
-0.08138320595026016,
-0.06403422355651855,
0.07427093386650085,
-0.09862000495195389,
0.6797806620597839,
-0.024688277393579483,
0.9882739186286926,
0.19690746068954468,
-0.637668251991272,
-0.020079104229807854,
0.038323938846588135,
0.47397908568382263,
-0.34299129247665405,
-0.26581570506095886,
-0.14021892845630646,
0.010788286104798317,
-0.034530870616436005,
-0.8969177603721619,
0.4481339454650879,
-0.029353490099310875,
-0.08929315954446793,
-0.6870750188827515,
0.6659660339355469,
-0.1634766161441803,
-0.4348379075527191,
0.33452048897743225,
0.41282644867897034,
0.11495599150657654,
0.09059939533472061,
-0.5937766432762146,
0.2045687437057495,
-0.31158551573753357,
-0.23152245581150055,
-0.006943829823285341,
0.7273082733154297,
0.0553559809923172,
0.6182024478912354,
0.8564233183860779,
-0.2753414809703827,
-0.021345453336834908,
-0.10599535703659058,
0.678215503692627,
-1.0005196332931519,
-0.675862193107605,
-0.7259718775749207,
0.6873325705528259,
-0.35781610012054443,
-0.6821511387825012,
0.6931765675544739,
0.4230865240097046,
0.5026313662528992,
-0.18335866928100586,
0.8042890429496765,
-0.16796216368675232,
0.13817229866981506,
-0.6670392155647278,
0.6868841052055359,
-0.23309454321861267,
-0.1467827409505844,
-0.46540695428848267,
-0.8542611002922058,
-0.3588517904281616,
0.9422575235366821,
-0.26072075963020325,
-0.1917409896850586,
0.6057494282722473,
0.2277805507183075,
-0.06467878073453903,
0.328698992729187,
0.2338036447763443,
0.12636204063892365,
0.5045150518417358,
0.22729258239269257,
1.0618257522583008,
-0.04519619047641754,
-0.2634720206260681,
-0.20925329625606537,
-0.06992807239294052,
0.10644691437482834,
-0.894037127494812,
-1.0263323783874512,
-0.5290855169296265,
-0.20411871373653412,
-0.16982349753379822,
-0.11451511830091476,
0.9318890571594238,
0.6088300347328186,
-0.5150694251060486,
-0.5035041570663452,
-0.5615953207015991,
0.1758836805820465,
-0.304953008890152,
-0.33181139826774597,
0.05491327866911888,
-0.39085716009140015,
-0.6394248604774475,
0.8243387341499329,
0.505534827709198,
-0.04222492873668671,
-0.38866937160491943,
0.003804207779467106,
-0.4734068214893341,
0.2527066171169281,
0.5698093175888062,
0.356650173664093,
-0.9578889012336731,
-0.3771135210990906,
0.26900777220726013,
-0.09037452191114426,
0.02604569122195244,
0.856442928314209,
-0.7629449963569641,
0.5681963562965393,
0.34232959151268005,
0.594287633895874,
0.286050021648407,
-0.03562568873167038,
0.9622840881347656,
-0.42613065242767334,
0.5270736813545227,
0.4872342348098755,
0.2401057332754135,
0.3896150290966034,
-0.5121160745620728,
0.7706636786460876,
0.17962905764579773,
-0.3688206970691681,
-0.8648093342781067,
-0.05680810660123825,
-0.7538484930992126,
-0.4469572901725769,
1.0873773097991943,
0.12151840329170227,
-0.4712204039096832,
-0.3292100727558136,
-0.48877692222595215,
0.02074394002556801,
-0.07540640980005264,
0.7754249572753906,
1.1820859909057617,
0.25674939155578613,
-0.41194450855255127,
-0.9784389734268188,
0.4250691831111908,
0.27142301201820374,
-0.9923561215400696,
0.043940674513578415,
0.5602496266365051,
0.02449101023375988,
0.32252025604248047,
0.47817906737327576,
0.14318016171455383,
-0.04257756471633911,
0.26263976097106934,
0.15411140024662018,
0.1602901667356491,
0.02032502554357052,
-0.3753022849559784,
-0.03438638523221016,
-0.11304306983947754,
0.1354902982711792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02547v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02547v2 | Integration of cognitive tasks into artificial general intelligence test for large models | 2024-02-04T15:50:42 | 2024-03-06T02:46:40 | Youzhi Qu, Chen Wei, Penghui Du, Wenxin Che, Chi Zhang, Wanli Ouyang, Yatao Bian, Feiyang Xu, Bin Hu, Kai Du, Haiyan Wu, Jia Liu, Quanying Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | During the evolution of large models, performance evaluation is necessarily
performed to assess their capabilities and ensure safety before practical
application. However, current model evaluations mainly rely on specific tasks
and datasets, lacking a united framework for assessing the multidimensional
intelligence of large models. In this perspective, we advocate for a
comprehensive framework of cognitive science-inspired artificial general
intelligence (AGI) tests, aimed at fulfilling the testing needs of large models
with enhanced capabilities. The cognitive science-inspired AGI tests encompass
the full spectrum of intelligence facets, including crystallized intelligence,
fluid intelligence, social intelligence, and embodied intelligence. To assess
the multidimensional intelligence of large models, the AGI tests consist of a
battery of well-designed cognitive tests adopted from human intelligence tests,
and then naturally encapsulates into an immersive virtual community. We propose
increasing the complexity of AGI testing tasks commensurate with advancements
in large models and emphasizing the necessity for the interpretation of test
results to avoid false negatives and false positives. We believe that cognitive
science-inspired AGI tests will effectively guide the targeted improvement of
large models in specific dimensions of intelligence and accelerate the
integration of large models into human society. | [
-0.4971396028995514,
-1.101672887802124,
0.8718602657318115,
0.14891348779201508,
0.2013566792011261,
0.06614529341459274,
-0.2242950052022934,
-0.7757001519203186,
0.18607598543167114,
0.24898678064346313,
-0.7180403470993042,
-0.10174299776554108,
-0.3538323938846588,
-0.26460325717926025,
-0.4696894586086273,
0.7003160119056702,
0.020931845530867577,
-0.030859841033816338,
-0.7869457006454468,
-0.021134955808520317,
-0.5707424879074097,
-0.574748158454895,
-0.3567401170730591,
-0.4020347595214844,
0.46000346541404724,
-0.04298819601535797,
0.6848717927932739,
0.3947330713272095,
0.4567878842353821,
0.3833480477333069,
0.11430872976779938,
0.15632957220077515,
-0.2689063549041748,
-0.36216843128204346,
-0.3740427494049072,
-0.1577896773815155,
-0.7511312961578369,
0.43152526021003723,
0.373924195766449,
0.7281057834625244,
-0.25560110807418823,
0.33471789956092834,
-0.024037860333919525,
0.2061356157064438,
-0.8352664709091187,
0.4681573212146759,
-0.3603423237800598,
-0.14406466484069824,
0.05574624985456467,
0.12530215084552765,
-0.2850375175476074,
-0.17864951491355896,
0.10992967337369919,
-0.7769768238067627,
0.09945939481258392,
-0.013600099831819534,
0.38992050290107727,
0.193708136677742,
-0.6331422328948975,
-0.28983479738235474,
-1.011214017868042,
1.0213663578033447,
-0.33501964807510376,
0.24185332655906677,
0.07797852158546448,
0.5159180164337158,
-0.11012809723615646,
-0.4514467716217041,
-0.930172860622406,
-0.6753383874893188,
0.2039736807346344,
0.39947375655174255,
-0.15673835575580597,
0.16938342154026031,
0.19952388107776642,
0.1721455156803131,
-0.7361502051353455,
0.04748763144016266,
-0.402093768119812,
0.13617198169231415,
1.117104172706604,
0.4505476951599121,
0.412022203207016,
0.4011533856391907,
0.15524058043956757,
-0.2779235541820526,
-0.0903901681303978,
0.22413374483585358,
0.17737016081809998,
0.19661346077919006,
0.06318746507167816,
0.6817362904548645,
-0.5991237759590149,
0.5603011846542358,
-0.05755437910556793,
0.10433747619390488,
0.39307886362075806,
-0.6250275373458862,
-0.12160193920135498,
-0.03312195464968681,
0.4741591811180115,
0.17115181684494019,
0.6249287128448486,
-0.43901968002319336,
0.0030574665870517492,
0.8034561276435852,
0.6822965145111084,
-0.691819965839386,
0.11534354090690613,
0.36316704750061035,
-0.23564399778842926,
-0.349597692489624,
0.2806924283504486,
-0.6522992849349976,
-0.2508366107940674,
-0.7770536541938782,
0.5866121053695679,
-0.5232175588607788,
-0.20009128749370575,
0.32644110918045044,
-0.24872516095638275,
0.4369600713253021,
0.29159241914749146,
-0.7961525321006775,
0.35368314385414124,
1.2026312351226807,
0.48769599199295044,
-0.21933245658874512,
-0.38425469398498535,
-0.4384317100048065,
0.19589956104755402,
-0.3832702040672302,
0.6051951050758362,
-0.8800753355026245,
-0.36095672845840454,
-0.25192487239837646,
-0.17514313757419586,
-0.2886406183242798,
-0.30534839630126953,
0.23857031762599945,
-0.5311984419822693,
0.11513475328683853,
-0.3326042890548706,
-0.35154393315315247,
-0.5329736471176147,
0.5624986290931702,
-0.35603275895118713,
0.6680852770805359,
0.1488148421049118,
-0.08193381875753403,
0.13418929278850555,
-1.4207004308700562,
-0.48823150992393494,
0.15327781438827515,
-0.29696786403656006,
-0.02665279246866703,
0.341995507478714,
0.12431111931800842,
0.22654792666435242,
-0.6636613607406616,
0.45485660433769226,
-0.7244769930839539,
-0.4135773479938507,
0.2490123063325882,
-0.3112338185310364,
0.648909330368042,
-0.008938838727772236,
-0.4964657425880432,
0.33725979924201965,
-0.5423766374588013,
0.7301576137542725,
0.07344216108322144,
0.08010366559028625,
-0.2830350399017334,
0.12591853737831116,
-0.12142393738031387,
0.03121943771839142,
0.2184278666973114,
-0.5499139428138733,
0.14356419444084167,
-0.17309366166591644,
0.7602124810218811,
0.7329339385032654,
0.06493163108825684,
0.50499427318573,
-0.29664289951324463,
0.39142438769340515,
-0.28624600172042847,
0.834286630153656,
0.3550753593444824,
-0.6737335920333862,
-0.3045331537723541,
-0.43092629313468933,
0.22831957042217255,
0.8826625347137451,
-0.38522377610206604,
0.7954679131507874,
-0.5829252004623413,
-1.0094947814941406,
-0.17821817100048065,
-0.12593571841716766,
0.11140810698270798,
0.2530217170715332,
0.31884852051734924,
-0.45083919167518616,
0.09481334686279297,
-0.8398886322975159,
0.023180896416306496,
-0.12481264024972916,
-0.3210274577140808,
0.4231495261192322,
0.9450645446777344,
-0.617340087890625,
0.8196882605552673,
-0.4678000807762146,
-0.026564311236143112,
0.09655071049928665,
0.08350786566734314,
0.14918528497219086,
0.5182085037231445,
0.6417620182037354,
-1.020838737487793,
0.11126711219549179,
0.1875879466533661,
-0.9575716257095337,
0.13138329982757568,
0.12286311388015747,
-0.15813486278057098,
-0.4761567711830139,
0.2276395708322525,
-1.0677424669265747,
0.5904760956764221,
0.3393786549568176,
-0.4585171937942505,
0.7539701461791992,
-0.2892273962497711,
0.43983975052833557,
-0.4080314338207245,
0.2815020978450775,
-0.12481104582548141,
0.4283674955368042,
-0.5385581851005554,
0.5161281824111938,
0.01066400296986103,
-0.14467762410640717,
-0.16465993225574493,
0.4843626916408539,
-0.1396651268005371,
-0.1087610274553299,
-0.1547911912202835,
-0.12629671394824982,
0.01912701688706875,
0.2956467866897583,
-0.4687660038471222,
0.7248837947845459,
0.6323971748352051,
-0.8363468647003174,
0.5655685067176819,
0.14747147262096405,
-0.188807412981987,
0.5317813754081726,
-0.9517338275909424,
0.27444639801979065,
-0.24427786469459534,
0.18062511086463928,
-0.8183422684669495,
-0.3415127992630005,
0.08911930024623871,
-0.3689846396446228,
-0.08350491523742676,
0.6295446753501892,
-0.29925066232681274,
-0.6517614722251892,
-0.1780073493719101,
0.5791664123535156,
0.5690320134162903,
-0.3787347078323364,
1.4963793754577637,
0.16331236064434052,
0.03486108034849167,
-0.30792656540870667,
-0.5582609176635742,
-0.0456274077296257,
-0.18906819820404053,
-0.9775026440620422,
0.43278101086616516,
-0.6003870368003845,
-0.5014608502388,
0.015914704650640488,
0.13001225888729095,
-0.16765551269054413,
0.24326904118061066,
0.4050142765045166,
0.46989983320236206,
-0.3153623342514038,
-0.060402221977710724,
-0.09893915057182312,
0.05244239792227745,
0.2547498643398285,
-0.39923837780952454,
0.48213890194892883,
-0.3277979791164398,
-0.7563742995262146,
-0.3860315680503845,
0.6396450996398926,
1.0533041954040527,
-0.8493098616600037,
0.4502052366733551,
0.45441561937332153,
-0.2445516288280487,
0.12861600518226624,
-0.7939416170120239,
-0.009535272605717182,
-0.461079478263855,
0.5612086653709412,
-0.40837886929512024,
-0.8235831260681152,
0.5567452311515808,
-0.22107218205928802,
-0.012692193500697613,
0.4891265630722046,
0.3262086510658264,
0.033987659960985184,
1.4371980428695679,
0.5102435350418091,
-0.24517996609210968,
0.3021036684513092,
-0.3331327736377716,
0.3439348042011261,
-0.7813138961791992,
-0.1134660616517067,
-0.3877021074295044,
-0.3047959506511688,
-0.24099288880825043,
-0.44383561611175537,
0.27882033586502075,
-0.41827407479286194,
-0.6666388511657715,
-0.3174915909767151,
-0.6534581780433655,
0.6266145706176758,
0.5484669208526611,
0.22571977972984314,
-0.05346234142780304,
-0.16954854130744934,
0.20253898203372955,
0.4344397783279419,
-0.28377044200897217,
-0.24433299899101257,
1.0495941638946533,
-0.08418283611536026,
0.29812562465667725,
0.03224525973200798,
0.17704080045223236,
0.46989426016807556,
0.3999534547328949,
-0.764081597328186,
0.6081556081771851,
-0.19680869579315186,
-0.5354095101356506,
-0.4271432161331177,
-0.3620052933692932,
-0.9264732599258423,
0.11806243658065796,
-0.329915851354599,
-0.699004590511322,
0.1297854781150818,
-0.2991791367530823,
-0.6671866178512573,
-0.023753216490149498,
-0.9233341217041016,
0.8778579235076904,
-0.6131368279457092,
-0.01805870793759823,
-0.8040822744369507,
-0.16753754019737244,
0.5649241209030151,
-0.19389595091342926,
0.33775973320007324,
0.04304475337266922,
0.1075591966509819,
0.5075538158416748,
0.09723980724811554,
0.7220566272735596,
-0.21996138989925385,
0.4321274161338806,
0.466373473405838,
-0.1919533908367157,
0.261168897151947,
-0.004399325232952833,
-0.1430589258670807,
0.23579296469688416,
-0.08193950355052948,
-0.5773729681968689,
-0.8875723481178284,
0.6965426802635193,
-0.9136471748352051,
-0.7335898280143738,
-0.3154675364494324,
-0.6763770580291748,
-0.24033111333847046,
0.023180052638053894,
-0.33122676610946655,
0.28356263041496277,
-0.4842354357242584,
-0.04650164023041725,
0.6319975256919861,
0.10234513878822327,
0.22111552953720093,
0.2720950245857239,
-0.03988077864050865,
-0.30398035049438477,
0.7125871777534485,
-0.036449261009693146,
0.1098831295967102,
-0.21719850599765778,
0.08704368025064468,
-0.18045111000537872,
-0.6163480281829834,
-0.13784091174602509,
0.21179090440273285,
-0.3802635669708252,
0.2615065276622772,
-0.4112391173839569,
-0.2569579780101776,
-0.5543692111968994,
-0.2837746739387512,
-0.28757917881011963,
0.07287649065256119,
-0.12454409152269363,
0.12048304826021194,
0.07339169085025787,
0.8603023290634155,
0.11878474056720734,
0.09011530131101608,
-0.5609604120254517,
0.5446319580078125,
0.696399986743927,
0.12282677739858627,
0.37753430008888245,
-0.1692877858877182,
0.17924076318740845,
0.21371665596961975,
-0.4081825017929077,
-0.3552406430244446,
0.006726346909999847,
0.32209911942481995,
0.7470046877861023,
0.5312605500221252,
-0.15857788920402527,
0.8986034989356995,
-0.6337538361549377,
0.7962585687637329,
0.2758241295814514,
-0.9968549609184265,
0.4357810318470001,
-0.26869142055511475,
0.28954875469207764,
0.4583399295806885,
0.261243999004364,
-0.20168812572956085,
-0.06125643476843834,
-0.6016266942024231,
-0.6008135676383972,
0.26935696601867676,
-0.007942864671349525,
0.3516959249973297,
-0.012996927835047245,
0.8372997045516968,
-0.1535463184118271,
0.024517280980944633,
-0.2736358642578125,
0.31958943605422974,
-0.03672211617231369,
-0.2969335913658142,
-0.3650040924549103,
0.16460826992988586,
-0.25347214937210083,
-0.46382561326026917,
0.5562644600868225,
-0.38631734251976013,
0.27880486845970154,
0.2115395963191986,
0.25389963388442993,
-0.02333066612482071,
0.08969449251890182,
0.3805902600288391,
0.7806762456893921,
0.13842254877090454,
-0.3538438379764557,
0.4375247657299042,
-0.582842230796814,
0.21614430844783783,
0.09649772942066193,
-0.1534232497215271,
-0.7206757664680481,
0.3858794867992401,
0.41397562623023987,
-0.11726024001836777,
-0.7965472340583801,
0.49416598677635193,
-0.13095155358314514,
-0.24992279708385468,
-0.7916476130485535,
0.6732043027877808,
0.07424748688936234,
0.63384610414505,
0.5415639877319336,
0.23800316452980042,
0.22196833789348602,
-0.9395932555198669,
0.15040947496891022,
0.8127317428588867,
-0.23634615540504456,
-0.3665361702442169,
0.6390507817268372,
-0.13802702724933624,
-0.31509116291999817,
1.0649230480194092,
-0.3363490104675293,
-0.4216783046722412,
0.8051148056983948,
0.1089121401309967,
0.5646095275878906,
-0.5099955797195435,
0.179714173078537,
0.2498280555009842,
0.5075796246528625,
-0.12830214202404022,
0.25993311405181885,
0.16314713656902313,
-0.5499778389930725,
-0.8676779270172119,
-0.4797213077545166,
-0.31141045689582825,
0.13457216322422028,
-0.49794092774391174,
0.08511880785226822,
-0.5478572845458984,
-0.1090429276227951,
0.17755211889743805,
-0.024158654734492302,
-0.8215795159339905,
0.7051159143447876,
0.4726444482803345,
0.7586615085601807,
-0.7487046122550964,
0.5388982892036438,
0.6462908983230591,
-0.16715969145298004,
-0.49837133288383484,
-0.17936396598815918,
-0.12647315859794617,
-0.7294055223464966,
0.4602365493774414,
0.4688626825809479,
0.007878895848989487,
-0.15396732091903687,
-0.7610409259796143,
-1.149609088897705,
1.32042396068573,
0.19588515162467957,
-0.2650407552719116,
-0.21674096584320068,
0.2390514612197876,
0.6430061459541321,
-0.781115710735321,
0.5632116198539734,
0.5655878782272339,
0.8131677508354187,
0.10624289512634277,
-0.8359323740005493,
0.05726839601993561,
-0.38825514912605286,
0.06428682804107666,
-0.06626936048269272,
-0.6878889799118042,
0.9070013761520386,
-0.21995916962623596,
-0.025218673050403595,
0.15569692850112915,
0.8226848840713501,
0.31785017251968384,
0.6389053463935852,
0.8483379483222961,
0.5221157670021057,
0.9791509509086609,
0.00313403457403183,
1.3697916269302368,
-0.05015796422958374,
-0.01876184716820717,
0.802642822265625,
-0.6350924968719482,
0.7008522748947144,
0.14482899010181427,
0.10944826155900955,
0.503926694393158,
0.3494569659233093,
-0.28170713782310486,
0.42881718277931213,
0.5367023348808289,
-0.21708537638187408,
-0.46830934286117554,
-0.2537331283092499,
-0.12842528522014618,
0.8627921938896179,
0.39485642313957214,
0.13539011776447296,
-0.002227145479992032,
0.18292760848999023,
-0.46793320775032043,
0.02269808016717434,
-0.48982128500938416,
0.3674995005130768,
-0.30549177527427673,
-0.8099057078361511,
0.22897425293922424,
-0.1419139802455902,
0.5070719122886658,
-0.8490742444992065,
-0.028468791395425797,
0.304384708404541,
0.3626548647880554,
0.08882032334804535,
-0.572691023349762,
0.37320154905319214,
-0.2510351836681366,
-0.2552441656589508,
0.3155606687068939,
0.5101536512374878,
0.060933589935302734,
-0.5662397742271423,
0.6569095849990845,
0.5634881854057312,
-0.04830733314156532,
-0.6665542125701904,
-0.808699369430542,
-0.0781177431344986,
-0.11278947442770004,
-0.3392360508441925,
0.36466601490974426,
0.23077140748500824,
-0.3632594048976898,
0.6306934356689453,
1.0443428754806519,
-0.34356483817100525,
-0.2638401687145233,
-0.05437791720032692,
0.8128361105918884,
-0.797044038772583,
-0.5895159244537354,
-0.7971969842910767,
0.5313364863395691,
-0.22461450099945068,
-0.2543181777000427,
0.29798176884651184,
0.4219106137752533,
0.44646552205085754,
-0.12290214747190475,
1.0473541021347046,
-0.19247519969940186,
-0.02344874106347561,
-0.15707924962043762,
0.7707850337028503,
-0.5663445591926575,
-0.3921141028404236,
-0.130410835146904,
-1.086536169052124,
-0.14604738354682922,
0.2809534966945648,
-0.5993471741676331,
0.23005561530590057,
0.602192759513855,
0.490817129611969,
-0.3036540150642395,
0.34818965196609497,
0.35623109340667725,
0.19267767667770386,
0.41670435667037964,
0.8204976916313171,
0.8895646929740906,
-0.24876737594604492,
0.37623053789138794,
0.00535255903378129,
-0.7564822435379028,
0.1624482423067093,
-0.517961323261261,
-0.8205577731132507,
-0.4158323109149933,
-0.5208702683448792,
0.01529023703187704,
-0.12577657401561737,
0.40626564621925354,
0.7345811724662781,
-0.7110111713409424,
-0.032126445323228836,
0.009794889949262142,
-0.4312551021575928,
-0.552435040473938,
-0.2878285050392151,
0.2423071712255478,
-0.029360419139266014,
-0.5944547057151794,
0.6193679571151733,
0.23427864909172058,
-0.15253984928131104,
-0.25658684968948364,
0.02194391004741192,
-0.1096191555261612,
0.4769940972328186,
0.6442249417304993,
-0.0625523179769516,
-0.6478379368782043,
-0.653887927532196,
0.2506556510925293,
0.16486357152462006,
-0.27833303809165955,
0.48923999071121216,
-0.6855124235153198,
0.17047490179538727,
0.15750910341739655,
0.6655369997024536,
0.29658225178718567,
-0.03013300709426403,
0.3744703531265259,
-0.004682416561990976,
-0.04264534264802933,
0.1823817789554596,
0.20138682425022125,
0.008912358433008194,
-0.7021010518074036,
0.7992634177207947,
0.14821922779083252,
-0.6678685545921326,
-0.6513513326644897,
0.18974611163139343,
-1.2121148109436035,
-0.2620900571346283,
0.6503443717956543,
-0.09832900762557983,
-0.6559208035469055,
0.10101726651191711,
0.05148003622889519,
0.1578873246908188,
-0.04466378688812256,
1.0728827714920044,
0.7712813019752502,
-0.25410833954811096,
0.297512024641037,
-0.7874364852905273,
-0.24941624701023102,
0.45500996708869934,
-0.9149973392486572,
0.061452388763427734,
0.41441473364830017,
0.10924895107746124,
0.796481728553772,
0.14601139724254608,
-0.09774573892354965,
0.4262276589870453,
-0.01460195705294609,
0.34734615683555603,
-0.1870443969964981,
-0.16219855844974518,
-0.17208212614059448,
0.44053640961647034,
-0.4831516444683075,
-0.037592433393001556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02541v1 | Knowledge Generation for Zero-shot Knowledge-based VQA | 2024-02-04T15:41:35 | 2024-02-04T15:41:35 | Rui Cao, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Previous solutions to knowledge-based visual question answering~(K-VQA)
retrieve knowledge from external knowledge bases and use supervised learning to
train the K-VQA model. Recently pre-trained LLMs have been used as both a
knowledge source and a zero-shot QA model for K-VQA and demonstrated promising
results. However, these recent methods do not explicitly show the knowledge
needed to answer the questions and thus lack interpretability. Inspired by
recent work on knowledge generation from LLMs for text-based QA, in this work
we propose and test a similar knowledge-generation-based K-VQA method, which
first generates knowledge from an LLM and then incorporates the generated
knowledge for K-VQA in a zero-shot manner. We evaluate our method on two K-VQA
benchmarks and found that our method performs better than previous zero-shot
K-VQA methods and our generated knowledge is generally relevant and helpful. | [
-0.31879234313964844,
-0.8528417348861694,
1.076273798942566,
-0.22935256361961365,
-0.3909647464752197,
0.05371348559856415,
0.2404939979314804,
-0.4092763662338257,
0.13707084953784943,
0.6481932401657104,
-0.6821747422218323,
-0.5132439136505127,
-0.30054792761802673,
0.1041114404797554,
-0.30269643664360046,
0.48510223627090454,
-0.14954917132854462,
0.22924482822418213,
-0.8493759632110596,
0.002879659179598093,
-0.6880426406860352,
-0.32419106364250183,
-0.23039191961288452,
-0.22609682381153107,
0.49488234519958496,
0.6589010953903198,
0.22194942831993103,
0.30650410056114197,
0.3770987391471863,
0.15933912992477417,
0.1425442397594452,
0.16391313076019287,
-0.45889371633529663,
0.13043193519115448,
0.030270420014858246,
-0.6866231560707092,
-0.020987965166568756,
-0.27920612692832947,
0.32091444730758667,
0.2557121217250824,
0.11302322894334793,
0.5057888627052307,
-0.4013422429561615,
0.4303933382034302,
-0.995753824710846,
0.04290376976132393,
-0.9927840828895569,
0.1168120801448822,
0.10692492872476578,
-0.5263087749481201,
-0.3181215524673462,
-0.43024155497550964,
0.1427546590566635,
-0.761000394821167,
0.10213842988014221,
-0.20759932696819305,
1.0220423936843872,
0.3813217580318451,
-0.701031506061554,
-0.06067176163196564,
-0.8029405474662781,
0.6275399327278137,
-0.5645012259483337,
0.33276432752609253,
0.0627165213227272,
0.7960379123687744,
0.013807698152959347,
-0.7841593027114868,
-0.9864822030067444,
-0.2166975885629654,
0.4282861351966858,
0.5459486246109009,
-0.06330869346857071,
-0.1547432541847229,
0.29935380816459656,
0.13565389811992645,
-0.5570268034934998,
-0.2328115999698639,
-0.46478724479675293,
-0.06175251305103302,
0.5137880444526672,
0.06913226842880249,
0.10242511332035065,
-0.3594934344291687,
-0.5824025869369507,
-0.06319892406463623,
-0.9961607456207275,
0.34616002440452576,
-0.043186087161302567,
-0.08189123868942261,
0.3944174647331238,
0.9033566117286682,
-0.8975303769111633,
0.7176046371459961,
0.00043284252751618624,
-0.26656460762023926,
0.20211666822433472,
-0.3622206449508667,
-0.4199727773666382,
-0.15471197664737701,
0.44264546036720276,
0.5783840417861938,
0.481823205947876,
0.02577582746744156,
0.1087448000907898,
-0.03961616009473801,
0.24218302965164185,
-0.916337788105011,
-0.11160386353731155,
0.0810418650507927,
-0.08621262013912201,
-0.5587745904922485,
-0.15448710322380066,
-0.424217164516449,
-0.0869961529970169,
-0.186666801571846,
0.9753265976905823,
-0.3182695209980011,
-0.15487971901893616,
-0.006136341951787472,
-0.3177109956741333,
0.8764815330505371,
0.48615941405296326,
-0.2720182240009308,
-0.16710178554058075,
0.10889139771461487,
0.2835335433483124,
-0.009489666670560837,
-0.025553377345204353,
-0.6734774112701416,
0.16302256286144257,
-0.501018226146698,
0.9399392008781433,
-0.03706570714712143,
-0.12305973470211029,
0.2290109246969223,
-0.21410693228244781,
0.20626847445964813,
-0.5054806470870972,
0.025498466566205025,
-0.9306336045265198,
0.3524782955646515,
-0.6909178495407104,
-0.6433864831924438,
-0.3197959363460541,
0.5954985618591309,
-0.14552980661392212,
0.8947272896766663,
0.3547384440898895,
-0.5162705779075623,
0.738241970539093,
-0.28566795587539673,
0.007293897680938244,
0.3666730523109436,
-0.5513023734092712,
-0.3521568477153778,
-0.11877842247486115,
0.5493164658546448,
0.5187150239944458,
-0.025996215641498566,
0.039173632860183716,
-0.32568877935409546,
-0.35119879245758057,
0.18272359669208527,
-0.18828172981739044,
0.5595061779022217,
-0.06903911381959915,
-0.31744858622550964,
-0.14274954795837402,
-0.7899532914161682,
0.4373916983604431,
0.3993756175041199,
-0.14730657637119293,
-0.2688935399055481,
-0.20157605409622192,
-0.559320867061615,
0.42756110429763794,
0.25376221537590027,
-0.7110983729362488,
0.09117026627063751,
-0.2698493003845215,
-0.04220879077911377,
0.5150116086006165,
0.6511258482933044,
0.26045140624046326,
-0.28870564699172974,
0.7595185041427612,
0.35414987802505493,
0.2613099217414856,
-0.23431378602981567,
-0.62177574634552,
-0.9677419066429138,
0.028659120202064514,
0.1298222839832306,
0.6927689909934998,
-1.733948826789856,
-0.20502464473247528,
0.055931929498910904,
-0.544586181640625,
-0.19778302311897278,
0.18991902470588684,
0.484582781791687,
0.8654133081436157,
0.48717793822288513,
-0.30632030963897705,
-0.28765374422073364,
-0.7598316669464111,
-0.15302978456020355,
-0.3826756775379181,
-0.03042345680296421,
0.6190328001976013,
0.5806324481964111,
0.16026820242404938,
1.0117859840393066,
-0.6998560428619385,
0.04040025547146797,
-0.0753219872713089,
0.009722673334181309,
-0.12428800761699677,
-0.035634707659482956,
0.6025376915931702,
-0.5203965902328491,
-0.4306217432022095,
-0.224811390042305,
-1.13670814037323,
-0.09396235644817352,
-0.039191458374261856,
-0.3923254907131195,
0.21037347614765167,
0.49284711480140686,
-0.47766149044036865,
0.6130672097206116,
0.14398826658725739,
-0.2705143392086029,
0.8647975921630859,
0.18661324679851532,
0.29574689269065857,
-1.1726844310760498,
-0.10892058908939362,
-0.13093867897987366,
-0.4298279583454132,
-0.5929635167121887,
0.04219655320048332,
0.10389870405197144,
-0.0908011719584465,
-0.8930748105049133,
0.6828796863555908,
-0.4846857190132141,
-0.0368986539542675,
-0.17446129024028778,
0.21016506850719452,
0.04400743171572685,
0.6431966423988342,
0.2789587676525116,
0.6381696462631226,
0.5318662524223328,
-0.6383703351020813,
0.40858614444732666,
0.3388909697532654,
-0.32721036672592163,
0.6877971887588501,
-0.5825831294059753,
0.10758122056722641,
-0.3496042788028717,
-0.3039741516113281,
-0.9540727734565735,
-0.19044920802116394,
0.3637888729572296,
-0.6407524347305298,
-0.0030353786423802376,
-0.06416448950767517,
-0.24566921591758728,
-0.515718400478363,
-0.3230449855327606,
0.45079267024993896,
0.7147653698921204,
-0.5330826044082642,
0.3636849820613861,
-0.1166156679391861,
-0.11817459762096405,
-0.7173154354095459,
-0.4931551218032837,
-0.15722984075546265,
-0.10026572644710541,
-0.6306520104408264,
0.06323917210102081,
-0.0034116788301616907,
-0.11266718804836273,
0.12554340064525604,
-0.13921357691287994,
-0.25624701380729675,
-0.07969029247760773,
0.18235604465007782,
0.31322184205055237,
-0.46076783537864685,
0.15854105353355408,
0.08214946836233139,
0.17051076889038086,
0.1625046283006668,
-0.22003434598445892,
0.15393060445785522,
0.2336660623550415,
-0.5275843739509583,
-0.2388588935136795,
0.31005579233169556,
0.3787000775337219,
-0.22233478724956512,
0.6598617434501648,
0.4002620279788971,
-0.17450933158397675,
-0.3977903127670288,
-0.6882345080375671,
-0.15134666860103607,
-0.40762045979499817,
0.21938064694404602,
-0.21865156292915344,
-1.013529896736145,
0.23941458761692047,
-0.18600274622440338,
-0.031720176339149475,
0.3923492431640625,
0.6447888612747192,
-0.47732099890708923,
0.6254209280014038,
0.8715503811836243,
0.3941919207572937,
0.477386474609375,
-0.28729715943336487,
-0.09585558623075485,
-0.3592151403427124,
-0.36097437143325806,
-0.24598829448223114,
0.03159547969698906,
-0.186643585562706,
-0.48273029923439026,
0.6775033473968506,
0.3388558030128479,
-0.34260094165802,
0.17091616988182068,
-0.33881035447120667,
0.41341689229011536,
0.9373348951339722,
0.25133222341537476,
0.5321557521820068,
0.10030446946620941,
-0.07343970239162445,
0.0737110897898674,
-0.9201614260673523,
-0.1858961284160614,
1.4589329957962036,
-0.09088882058858871,
0.37881380319595337,
-0.11253965646028519,
0.7603066563606262,
-0.07079464942216873,
0.219713494181633,
-0.7942028045654297,
0.5663840174674988,
0.344317227602005,
-0.38094308972358704,
-0.4333646893501282,
-0.5379849076271057,
-0.5361571907997131,
-0.0835799053311348,
-0.34665560722351074,
-0.39466315507888794,
0.06965940445661545,
0.2007480412721634,
-0.4067334532737732,
0.045549165457487106,
-0.6193490624427795,
0.7383270263671875,
-0.28420791029930115,
-0.10031682252883911,
0.2910121977329254,
-0.5105118155479431,
0.7918535470962524,
-0.08733561635017395,
-0.34021297097206116,
0.1676371991634369,
0.13427840173244476,
0.5922908782958984,
-0.48792892694473267,
0.54716557264328,
-0.48790743947029114,
-0.15496677160263062,
0.6679026484489441,
-0.03247934952378273,
0.234461709856987,
0.20139329135417938,
0.39982151985168457,
0.02073477767407894,
0.18625488877296448,
-0.5351623296737671,
-0.7634230256080627,
0.16279244422912598,
-0.6837798953056335,
-0.6549768447875977,
-0.21999502182006836,
-0.4765159785747528,
-0.5040969252586365,
0.26219287514686584,
0.3674958050251007,
0.3324117660522461,
-0.02066187560558319,
0.28694239258766174,
0.8404408693313599,
-0.46728816628456116,
0.2139727771282196,
0.7494192123413086,
-0.4595019519329071,
-0.4925929009914398,
0.8137156963348389,
0.25766026973724365,
0.47346231341362,
0.5722562670707703,
-0.10196928679943085,
-0.2659149169921875,
-0.511589765548706,
-0.732147753238678,
0.10661652684211731,
-0.5148060321807861,
-0.46458378434181213,
-0.25213849544525146,
-0.651136577129364,
-0.28023356199264526,
-0.0692291408777237,
-0.12143590301275253,
-0.40023937821388245,
-0.09022398293018341,
-0.04053587093949318,
0.4364789128303528,
0.4666711091995239,
0.21959318220615387,
0.24747121334075928,
-0.7615475058555603,
0.7066188454627991,
1.063138723373413,
0.10834629833698273,
-0.29742345213890076,
-0.3489115238189697,
-0.16190053522586823,
0.054853059351444244,
-0.5109138488769531,
-1.0876909494400024,
-0.00019049178808927536,
0.05641568452119827,
0.4549638628959656,
0.22857536375522614,
0.11271308362483978,
0.48630058765411377,
-0.4313295781612396,
1.1017347574234009,
0.23234975337982178,
-0.6257376074790955,
0.6753570437431335,
-0.36139121651649475,
0.6511710286140442,
0.5445401072502136,
0.3225035071372986,
-0.19010327756404877,
-0.42437636852264404,
-0.6376276016235352,
-0.5428679585456848,
0.23482288420200348,
0.3911198377609253,
0.06213840842247009,
0.0649019181728363,
0.5916960835456848,
0.0835995152592659,
0.5151139497756958,
-0.6284566521644592,
-0.2847479581832886,
-0.2730429172515869,
-0.025870688259601593,
0.18183542788028717,
-0.3912724256515503,
-0.003456223290413618,
-0.1249786913394928,
0.723644495010376,
-0.3911612927913666,
0.3702564239501953,
0.5332412123680115,
-0.19600535929203033,
-0.14841069281101227,
0.13030202686786652,
0.45562949776649475,
0.7987422347068787,
-0.17719897627830505,
-0.0557858869433403,
0.3412568271160126,
-0.32876163721084595,
0.16757944226264954,
-0.302965372800827,
-0.8501557111740112,
0.02426966279745102,
0.24976810812950134,
0.6206333637237549,
-0.18673132359981537,
-0.7581290602684021,
0.8218552470207214,
-0.15012601017951965,
-0.8793267011642456,
-0.30423954129219055,
0.2821386456489563,
0.11959564685821533,
0.5649970769882202,
0.31552574038505554,
-0.17993704974651337,
-0.1389147937297821,
-0.425260454416275,
0.35158073902130127,
0.6118436455726624,
-0.32134100794792175,
0.1471187174320221,
0.6367611289024353,
0.07767914235591888,
-0.04930311068892479,
0.4364881217479706,
-0.1510799080133438,
-0.3546661138534546,
0.633308470249176,
0.20645447075366974,
0.6305458545684814,
0.13330458104610443,
0.740079402923584,
0.38048839569091797,
0.19132114946842194,
0.30629828572273254,
0.9603863954544067,
-0.4389740824699402,
-0.8108128905296326,
-0.6863702535629272,
-0.49722006916999817,
-0.652053952217102,
0.35421374440193176,
-0.6508151888847351,
0.21394330263137817,
-0.18550461530685425,
0.08484385162591934,
-0.3116130232810974,
0.024698531255126,
-0.8593582510948181,
0.45966920256614685,
0.18629109859466553,
0.9487852454185486,
-0.6800468564033508,
0.579436719417572,
0.687410831451416,
-0.5991734266281128,
-1.0046836137771606,
0.16120803356170654,
-0.28223100304603577,
-0.9968725442886353,
0.638242244720459,
-0.19184792041778564,
-0.022885750979185104,
0.0965864509344101,
-0.8465600609779358,
-0.719780445098877,
1.624772071838379,
0.5020281076431274,
-0.31351786851882935,
0.1261424869298935,
0.3921121060848236,
0.45687100291252136,
-0.07255654036998749,
0.11946891248226166,
0.01863354817032814,
0.18215395510196686,
0.5975618958473206,
-0.5572570562362671,
-0.04216178506612778,
-0.26003238558769226,
0.033464811742305756,
-0.07404591888189316,
-0.4761052131652832,
0.38123175501823425,
-0.21377868950366974,
-0.1534498631954193,
0.17334869503974915,
0.8266287446022034,
0.5005858540534973,
0.5042679309844971,
0.3307345509529114,
0.6462163329124451,
0.5095142126083374,
0.13974778354167938,
0.6684024930000305,
-0.16912589967250824,
0.10985994338989258,
1.132602334022522,
-0.31262388825416565,
1.0517523288726807,
0.6547285914421082,
0.1048903614282608,
0.5892443656921387,
0.2677837610244751,
0.02830241620540619,
0.5240994691848755,
0.20523019134998322,
-0.3612474501132965,
-0.6270099878311157,
-0.09351109713315964,
-0.40211835503578186,
0.5923864841461182,
-0.28124773502349854,
-0.21151186525821686,
-0.40434250235557556,
-0.09028273075819016,
-0.3504040539264679,
-0.08248617500066757,
-0.4394761919975281,
1.0393673181533813,
0.11321781575679779,
-0.7271817922592163,
0.61039799451828,
-0.2876043915748596,
0.2901794910430908,
-0.4976540505886078,
-0.309469610452652,
-0.27176162600517273,
-0.2125578224658966,
0.03443073108792305,
-0.930577278137207,
-0.02340667136013508,
0.23866766691207886,
-0.25511714816093445,
-0.11425811797380447,
1.1708892583847046,
-0.48906001448631287,
-0.610348105430603,
-0.04929574951529503,
1.3012672662734985,
0.08309996128082275,
-0.34221479296684265,
-0.16944779455661774,
-0.78321772813797,
0.023596785962581635,
-0.18609505891799927,
0.2819201946258545,
0.5766962766647339,
0.01374070718884468,
0.5807732343673706,
0.5646671652793884,
-0.08138178288936615,
0.3481060564517975,
-0.10228095948696136,
0.8067288994789124,
-0.6201364398002625,
-0.12985216081142426,
-0.5173355340957642,
0.6493817567825317,
-0.020524634048342705,
-0.28645336627960205,
0.7350000739097595,
0.2900175154209137,
0.9587914347648621,
-0.3620361387729645,
0.900000810623169,
0.06602194160223007,
0.4231990575790405,
-0.6974456906318665,
0.7651544809341431,
-0.7317039966583252,
-0.24461528658866882,
-0.3189954161643982,
-0.7490297555923462,
-0.24906054139137268,
0.19734004139900208,
-0.23773619532585144,
-0.13895493745803833,
0.610367476940155,
0.8185526728630066,
0.24375475943088531,
-0.24188221991062164,
0.69014573097229,
0.037591688334941864,
0.0067772832699120045,
0.9290322065353394,
1.1336311101913452,
-0.637657880783081,
0.8872132897377014,
-0.47854509949684143,
-0.07040344923734665,
0.04853103309869766,
-0.8969466090202332,
-0.9789313077926636,
-0.5085309743881226,
-0.3092106282711029,
-0.054449956864118576,
0.022156735882163048,
0.12540987133979797,
0.5527191758155823,
-0.4182162880897522,
0.33054304122924805,
-0.21483680605888367,
0.1226842924952507,
-0.1146765798330307,
-0.24492007493972778,
0.10529141128063202,
-0.18437521159648895,
-0.17445647716522217,
0.2914733588695526,
0.16238723695278168,
-0.014754925854504108,
-0.3000076711177826,
0.006042141001671553,
-0.06595160067081451,
0.18753473460674286,
0.8228370547294617,
0.41151610016822815,
-0.39617934823036194,
-0.5471129417419434,
0.42556026577949524,
0.10163823515176773,
0.03534850478172302,
0.3432904779911041,
-1.3022704124450684,
0.417336106300354,
0.627356767654419,
0.7488734722137451,
0.5930657386779785,
0.11012507975101471,
0.6485876441001892,
-0.8138570785522461,
-0.4208185374736786,
0.13375359773635864,
0.049569398164749146,
0.06482090055942535,
-0.31423258781433105,
0.23754073679447174,
0.4621472954750061,
-0.48233866691589355,
-0.6169578433036804,
0.2952564060688019,
-1.1552073955535889,
-0.06886707246303558,
1.1207228899002075,
-0.03611947223544121,
-0.3226497769355774,
0.07040028274059296,
-0.2480621337890625,
0.4003470540046692,
-0.0330657958984375,
0.6739500761032104,
0.3530285060405731,
-0.07531668245792389,
-0.5221359133720398,
-0.7028863430023193,
0.4066062271595001,
0.3630495071411133,
-1.1204509735107422,
-0.47941339015960693,
0.5036810636520386,
0.5645235180854797,
0.01116169337183237,
0.9122561812400818,
-0.010132145136594772,
0.7174137234687805,
-0.0017521340632811189,
0.3196909725666046,
-0.4053958058357239,
-0.43470898270606995,
-0.06621771305799484,
0.3593759536743164,
0.08667997270822525,
-0.3844897150993347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02522v1 | Absolute convergence and error thresholds in non-active adaptive sampling | 2024-02-04T15:10:34 | 2024-02-04T15:10:34 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Jesús Vilares Ferro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Non-active adaptive sampling is a way of building machine learning models
from a training data base which are supposed to dynamically and automatically
derive guaranteed sample size. In this context and regardless of the strategy
used in both scheduling and generating of weak predictors, a proposal for
calculating absolute convergence and error thresholds is described. We not only
make it possible to establish when the quality of the model no longer
increases, but also supplies a proximity condition to estimate in absolute
terms how close it is to achieving such a goal, thus supporting decision making
for fine-tuning learning parameters in model selection. The technique proves
its correctness and completeness with respect to our working hypotheses, in
addition to strengthening the robustness of the sampling scheme. Tests meet our
expectations and illustrate the proposal in the domain of natural language
processing, taking the generation of part-of-speech taggers as case study. | [
-0.3029208481311798,
-0.7083081007003784,
0.2945181131362915,
0.05208703875541687,
-0.05276256427168846,
-0.14959672093391418,
-0.2294507622718811,
-0.5194977521896362,
0.025229360908269882,
0.32363417744636536,
-0.4536219835281372,
-0.11332857608795166,
-0.34134089946746826,
0.01782875694334507,
-0.584729790687561,
0.7583422064781189,
-0.17887265980243683,
-0.24222074449062347,
-0.23674623668193817,
-0.36079081892967224,
-0.644928514957428,
-0.22973866760730743,
-0.45020437240600586,
0.21618810296058655,
0.2617112696170807,
0.4349210560321808,
0.26922768354415894,
0.8968759775161743,
0.30819401144981384,
0.2389654517173767,
0.14397922158241272,
0.10940311849117279,
-0.14445026218891144,
0.46250179409980774,
-0.00867657084017992,
-0.714664101600647,
-0.5249486565589905,
0.12112453579902649,
1.1533139944076538,
0.8994197845458984,
-0.17958328127861023,
0.14123855531215668,
0.12811727821826935,
0.5418618321418762,
-0.8784456253051758,
-0.02806059457361698,
-0.8789443373680115,
0.03908415511250496,
0.05784643068909645,
-0.15369963645935059,
-0.4624544382095337,
-0.28082138299942017,
-0.042654093354940414,
-0.4056035876274109,
0.8180946707725525,
-0.10634762048721313,
0.7995256185531616,
0.424554705619812,
-0.11279208213090897,
-0.10719750821590424,
-0.7443445920944214,
1.213918924331665,
-0.5416937470436096,
0.22091743350028992,
0.612126350402832,
0.30440735816955566,
-0.12066642194986343,
-0.43610331416130066,
-0.4303257465362549,
-0.30862540006637573,
0.4449501633644104,
0.07002555578947067,
-0.389920175075531,
0.06549829989671707,
0.5122377872467041,
0.25021442770957947,
-0.11966250836849213,
0.11115913838148117,
-0.4114983379840851,
-0.008617493323981762,
0.3712257146835327,
-0.06938155740499496,
-0.20965182781219482,
0.22132116556167603,
-0.07969039678573608,
0.00983054656535387,
-0.2478804886341095,
-0.15554475784301758,
0.41619452834129333,
0.6871122121810913,
-0.30171674489974976,
0.43806472420692444,
-0.33815085887908936,
1.062421441078186,
0.27465665340423584,
0.03347610682249069,
0.3215911090373993,
-0.40501344203948975,
-0.24020175635814667,
-0.07567775249481201,
0.3659050762653351,
0.19953016936779022,
0.17082227766513824,
-0.014132264070212841,
-0.5638334155082703,
0.13046322762966156,
0.6135733723640442,
-0.3186360001564026,
-0.3017723262310028,
0.23380734026432037,
-0.3090653121471405,
-0.3436787724494934,
0.012819995172321796,
-0.9823662042617798,
0.03563643619418144,
-0.23716969788074493,
0.33844926953315735,
-0.05894703418016434,
-0.22246435284614563,
-0.40954598784446716,
-0.10076131671667099,
-0.15094904601573944,
0.016561223194003105,
-0.5260314345359802,
0.2890591621398926,
-0.14670009911060333,
0.9105290174484253,
-0.26354193687438965,
-0.06327491253614426,
-0.6856582164764404,
-0.09876994043588638,
-0.47735345363616943,
0.9624291658401489,
-0.27991336584091187,
-0.45495519042015076,
-0.07056203484535217,
-0.07883163541555405,
-0.2621549069881439,
-0.7473227381706238,
0.8366230130195618,
-0.335355281829834,
-0.07320639491081238,
-0.12056339532136917,
-0.48683667182922363,
0.09786201268434525,
0.1761205941438675,
-0.5720992684364319,
1.0611282587051392,
0.28193578124046326,
-0.38906148076057434,
0.6023271679878235,
-0.9115521311759949,
-0.5048717856407166,
-0.07052776962518692,
0.31502363085746765,
-0.888195276260376,
0.09091416746377945,
-0.04666592925786972,
0.27902406454086304,
0.017819447442889214,
-0.12019409239292145,
-0.5513078570365906,
-0.18254265189170837,
0.16636857390403748,
-0.4674363136291504,
0.5546263456344604,
0.22012130916118622,
-0.6350495219230652,
0.1845659464597702,
-0.7699435353279114,
0.3553468883037567,
0.12839627265930176,
-0.46083712577819824,
-0.1200212761759758,
0.18899542093276978,
-0.19512346386909485,
0.033840328454971313,
0.017094498500227928,
-0.38086575269699097,
0.05295379459857941,
-0.2392469048500061,
0.48567840456962585,
0.7021812200546265,
0.16573764383792877,
0.4612603783607483,
-0.7248914837837219,
0.5236899852752686,
-0.2567286491394043,
0.11125829070806503,
-0.18145665526390076,
-0.3858444094657898,
-0.8492862582206726,
-0.41150617599487305,
0.7629954218864441,
0.6303778290748596,
-0.6507146954536438,
1.0283291339874268,
-0.08214207738637924,
-0.5554199814796448,
-0.2427937239408493,
0.3691316843032837,
0.3587886095046997,
0.6666842699050903,
0.39479923248291016,
-0.4853362739086151,
-0.8193131685256958,
-0.408028781414032,
0.285873144865036,
-0.4131290316581726,
0.011284290812909603,
0.19240562617778778,
0.4678345024585724,
0.10388302057981491,
1.018555760383606,
-0.09420068562030792,
-0.3217502534389496,
-0.19263646006584167,
0.02224840596318245,
0.27605023980140686,
0.424099862575531,
0.5843405723571777,
-0.8831799030303955,
-0.6065932512283325,
-0.5915272235870361,
-0.5672410726547241,
-0.40827903151512146,
0.06823123246431351,
-0.13275407254695892,
0.2651609778404236,
0.3453994393348694,
-0.34480878710746765,
0.3100227117538452,
0.5447103381156921,
0.15422691404819489,
0.6186040043830872,
-0.11132551729679108,
-0.27721378207206726,
-0.8117297291755676,
0.28583118319511414,
0.33716005086898804,
-0.1501779556274414,
-0.6614247560501099,
0.03476056829094887,
-0.12463726103305817,
0.1821514517068863,
-0.15521416068077087,
0.6155004501342773,
-0.5152852535247803,
-0.013124765828251839,
-0.771902859210968,
0.08184243738651276,
-0.275748074054718,
0.17570194602012634,
0.062095850706100464,
0.6223987936973572,
0.7216225266456604,
-0.9178801774978638,
0.36852800846099854,
-0.04628545790910721,
-0.019171342253684998,
0.8282296657562256,
-0.5094740390777588,
0.022067394107580185,
-0.09803257882595062,
0.3786987066268921,
-1.0503400564193726,
-0.3676117956638336,
0.19021634757518768,
-0.777982234954834,
0.3488008975982666,
-0.3851129710674286,
-0.08464673906564713,
-0.4822010099887848,
-0.16257929801940918,
0.3378642201423645,
0.7650521993637085,
-0.21318411827087402,
0.24545033276081085,
0.6285423040390015,
0.20289906859397888,
-0.5277080535888672,
-0.5241959095001221,
-0.24227049946784973,
-0.24900095164775848,
-0.06369246542453766,
0.045105136930942535,
0.07217924296855927,
-0.2855668067932129,
0.02564949542284012,
-0.03545026481151581,
-0.16456246376037598,
0.2100965827703476,
0.25584179162979126,
0.3083599805831909,
-0.16986675560474396,
-0.03998541459441185,
-0.19841814041137695,
-0.0034548931289464235,
-0.17996090650558472,
-0.6448573470115662,
0.2665833830833435,
0.45241713523864746,
-0.5863332748413086,
-0.1374310851097107,
0.06577888876199722,
0.3692891001701355,
-0.04191245883703232,
0.5600280165672302,
0.3892296552658081,
-0.6988571286201477,
-0.436369389295578,
-0.4204692244529724,
-0.13302069902420044,
-0.38532328605651855,
0.21818718314170837,
-0.12945781648159027,
-0.176913321018219,
0.6210476756095886,
0.515389084815979,
0.45949310064315796,
0.6432079076766968,
0.7447972893714905,
0.009283509105443954,
0.7543666362762451,
0.7451804876327515,
-0.02136138826608658,
0.7327701449394226,
0.010732915252447128,
0.09528856724500656,
-0.5705960392951965,
0.11035393178462982,
-0.7257817983627319,
-0.31478151679039,
-0.27714163064956665,
-0.5807835459709167,
0.31566476821899414,
0.1716797649860382,
0.054154880344867706,
0.21081450581550598,
-0.44921690225601196,
0.22712525725364685,
0.907002329826355,
-0.11272262781858444,
-0.22606003284454346,
0.14228719472885132,
-0.19302533566951752,
0.0344436839222908,
-0.8032047748565674,
-0.2940012812614441,
1.1179072856903076,
0.06453758478164673,
0.45028573274612427,
0.05598285049200058,
0.26853886246681213,
0.654617965221405,
0.23634260892868042,
-1.0025814771652222,
0.367625892162323,
0.0823054313659668,
-0.9459182620048523,
-0.325118750333786,
-0.6481630802154541,
-0.9425337314605713,
-0.24882511794567108,
-0.22842857241630554,
-0.5150244235992432,
0.31144285202026367,
0.4225636124610901,
-0.4952743947505951,
0.6446271538734436,
-0.6649070978164673,
0.43450453877449036,
0.013097928836941719,
-0.4111132323741913,
0.3164791166782379,
-0.6873682141304016,
-0.008927667513489723,
-0.498793363571167,
-0.00647386722266674,
-0.27660760283470154,
-0.14071214199066162,
1.0004698038101196,
0.026319436728954315,
0.9738476276397705,
-0.8362060189247131,
0.355090469121933,
0.8809192776679993,
-0.024340370669960976,
0.4066251814365387,
-0.47372445464134216,
-0.40726831555366516,
-0.124690942466259,
-0.1740701049566269,
-0.952416718006134,
-0.13792411983013153,
0.30995532870292664,
-0.5571073293685913,
-0.0648776963353157,
-0.48389843106269836,
-0.49697017669677734,
-0.5079627633094788,
0.4864508807659149,
0.031021248549222946,
0.26484522223472595,
0.0730842798948288,
0.29893290996551514,
0.7598966360092163,
0.08861486613750458,
0.41606441140174866,
0.5764349699020386,
0.4851367175579071,
-0.21621271967887878,
0.9771403074264526,
0.3628932237625122,
0.47941526770591736,
0.215693861246109,
-0.15112048387527466,
-0.4270325005054474,
-1.0221742391586304,
-0.5757536888122559,
0.018182411789894104,
-0.5519214868545532,
-0.33306607604026794,
-0.5021522641181946,
-0.2537696361541748,
-0.40879783034324646,
-0.031682100147008896,
-0.27624696493148804,
-0.15956023335456848,
-0.24424563348293304,
-0.0334162674844265,
0.1305353194475174,
0.30136746168136597,
-0.3598906695842743,
0.15733937919139862,
-0.7492798566818237,
0.0714501142501831,
-0.09004964679479599,
0.3077375292778015,
0.014165561646223068,
-0.9940506815910339,
-0.40793123841285706,
0.10511735081672668,
-0.4568823277950287,
-0.6143392324447632,
0.08668546378612518,
0.6113089323043823,
0.9556677341461182,
0.2746254801750183,
0.5227341055870056,
0.38574060797691345,
-0.26533350348472595,
0.6706252694129944,
-0.0896674171090126,
-0.5656613707542419,
0.4870884120464325,
-0.4728485643863678,
0.27114152908325195,
0.7051279544830322,
0.3575650453567505,
-0.11954253911972046,
-0.35423991084098816,
-0.6655101776123047,
-0.9154075384140015,
0.4283851385116577,
0.29238733649253845,
0.304136723279953,
0.015807662159204483,
0.5864842534065247,
-0.1781422644853592,
0.0062579866498708725,
-0.499493271112442,
-0.06377597898244858,
-0.08842574059963226,
-0.33603912591934204,
0.04271247237920761,
-0.11596771329641342,
-0.27650177478790283,
-0.008344696834683418,
0.8950608968734741,
-0.48746585845947266,
0.8101205825805664,
0.03678131476044655,
0.2503018081188202,
-0.6568785905838013,
0.03649135306477547,
0.5188217163085938,
0.8883739709854126,
-0.3863423764705658,
0.005349999293684959,
0.4674956500530243,
-0.5786803364753723,
0.27335548400878906,
0.22979512810707092,
-0.11982441693544388,
-0.11106318980455399,
0.47141915559768677,
0.6724302172660828,
-0.33501940965652466,
-0.8768807053565979,
0.40919968485832214,
-0.006055172067135572,
-0.3026769161224365,
-0.396696537733078,
0.22839972376823425,
-0.5855719447135925,
-0.09642703831195831,
0.626264750957489,
0.4412824511528015,
-0.19278183579444885,
-0.36853429675102234,
0.7259315848350525,
0.4985722005367279,
-0.9271433353424072,
-0.33225083351135254,
0.781467080116272,
0.1881752759218216,
0.016145942732691765,
0.5413740277290344,
-0.43444401025772095,
-0.3301140069961548,
0.6993630528450012,
0.6236555576324463,
0.6602423787117004,
-0.22986505925655365,
-0.2464396357536316,
0.5637336373329163,
0.19681967794895172,
-0.194277822971344,
0.002078292891383171,
-0.13389018177986145,
-0.8246560096740723,
-0.4569772779941559,
-0.8548830151557922,
-0.5657012462615967,
-0.10658533126115799,
-0.7764182686805725,
0.5036813020706177,
-0.5815941095352173,
-0.43435853719711304,
0.0026196050457656384,
0.054219067096710205,
0.07129672169685364,
0.5199465751647949,
0.09036137163639069,
0.8232913613319397,
-1.0127054452896118,
0.9950906038284302,
0.8449571132659912,
0.061836473643779755,
-0.4006754755973816,
0.2664963901042938,
-0.07014533132314682,
-0.6719863414764404,
-0.14605170488357544,
-0.10903074592351913,
0.06089423596858978,
-0.11988601088523865,
-0.2863566279411316,
-0.7471149563789368,
0.6882976293563843,
0.23191112279891968,
-0.34592294692993164,
-0.2542628049850464,
-0.43966323137283325,
0.43285125494003296,
0.03332310914993286,
0.019511528313159943,
0.45799216628074646,
0.24105985462665558,
0.46232661604881287,
-1.0699869394302368,
0.0349106602370739,
-0.4950389564037323,
-0.40668055415153503,
0.6370200514793396,
-0.41921502351760864,
0.7269946336746216,
-0.1608695089817047,
-0.023588627576828003,
0.37965115904808044,
0.715038537979126,
0.3205547630786896,
0.22194695472717285,
0.8859724402427673,
0.439328134059906,
0.8430601954460144,
-0.16886179149150848,
0.9354202747344971,
-0.4382316768169403,
0.31064680218696594,
0.7997324466705322,
-0.20285511016845703,
0.764463484287262,
0.17929677665233612,
-0.4718794822692871,
-0.004176186863332987,
0.859961211681366,
-0.4206637144088745,
0.39288511872291565,
0.09776291996240616,
-0.3628755807876587,
-0.07246661931276321,
-0.2472330927848816,
-0.27581679821014404,
0.19879136979579926,
0.23445694148540497,
-0.47779637575149536,
-0.05456966906785965,
-0.08247660845518112,
-0.14577050507068634,
0.04473327845335007,
-0.38197338581085205,
0.46393853425979614,
-0.017668617889285088,
-0.6630831956863403,
0.6878458261489868,
0.1826447993516922,
0.7371445894241333,
-0.5962201952934265,
0.0008475789800286293,
0.20367830991744995,
0.26844844222068787,
-0.187130406498909,
-0.5634414553642273,
0.5317912697792053,
0.04043357074260712,
-0.40277373790740967,
0.08357290178537369,
0.7225685119628906,
-0.028924262151122093,
-0.5958964824676514,
0.0543610155582428,
0.29422903060913086,
0.12883394956588745,
0.027640333399176598,
-0.7868745923042297,
-0.1692662090063095,
0.051938023418188095,
0.15213972330093384,
0.19911427795886993,
0.050181977450847626,
-0.2511304020881653,
0.3959001898765564,
0.6152133345603943,
0.2675504982471466,
0.44314444065093994,
-0.3534281849861145,
0.44139036536216736,
-0.39884141087532043,
-0.5381127595901489,
-0.6861658692359924,
0.2375665307044983,
0.15963342785835266,
-0.17221370339393616,
0.8520175814628601,
0.4627344310283661,
0.7193838357925415,
0.4025084674358368,
1.0602754354476929,
-0.5865777134895325,
0.7752891778945923,
-0.3417491614818573,
0.3708536922931671,
-0.5522469878196716,
-0.09385527670383453,
-0.06293942779302597,
-1.1464176177978516,
-0.38866403698921204,
0.5496498346328735,
-0.4039275050163269,
0.525516152381897,
0.25363877415657043,
0.5054782032966614,
-0.29156002402305603,
-0.150785893201828,
0.22253097593784332,
0.016754871234297752,
0.1545720100402832,
0.32919004559516907,
0.42452341318130493,
-0.2451838105916977,
0.41178590059280396,
-0.3205345571041107,
-0.5361049771308899,
-0.10336091369390488,
-0.5943583250045776,
-0.5927470922470093,
-0.5551483631134033,
-0.3458307385444641,
-0.7915098071098328,
-0.08425876498222351,
0.9916372895240784,
0.9564897418022156,
-1.0068285465240479,
-0.2062486708164215,
-0.06009184941649437,
-0.08145192265510559,
-0.34952735900878906,
-0.19482320547103882,
0.17725679278373718,
-0.40556374192237854,
-0.8855623006820679,
0.3749626874923706,
-0.18495073914527893,
0.25482407212257385,
-0.24252523481845856,
0.09666557610034943,
-0.17107874155044556,
0.2737021744251251,
0.15977159142494202,
0.7296941876411438,
-0.10073373466730118,
-0.03800008445978165,
-0.2057134360074997,
0.12680591642856598,
0.2911962866783142,
0.5084982514381409,
-0.6097007989883423,
0.6235514283180237,
0.2905553877353668,
0.5199569463729858,
0.1286746859550476,
0.1567164957523346,
0.3052721619606018,
-0.8609166741371155,
0.36750778555870056,
0.45935335755348206,
0.12428135424852371,
0.33057382702827454,
0.040723767131567,
0.30606523156166077,
0.6098147630691528,
-0.5271317362785339,
-1.335679292678833,
0.1576727032661438,
-0.858278214931488,
-0.03841845318675041,
1.1242542266845703,
-0.21453166007995605,
-0.44495609402656555,
-0.4987020790576935,
0.18397486209869385,
0.3798268437385559,
-0.2965424954891205,
0.8146691918373108,
0.46082717180252075,
-0.37091654539108276,
0.1382431834936142,
-1.0046167373657227,
0.263072669506073,
0.36173903942108154,
-0.5232129693031311,
-0.06704380363225937,
0.2604534924030304,
0.39196544885635376,
0.2578161656856537,
0.6844797730445862,
-0.013528169132769108,
0.41928863525390625,
0.2703379690647125,
0.023854238912463188,
0.24571476876735687,
-0.29112765192985535,
-0.2834091782569885,
0.31790071725845337,
0.46457138657569885,
-0.34175118803977966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02516v1 | Adaptive scheduling for adaptive sampling in POS taggers construction | 2024-02-04T15:02:17 | 2024-02-04T15:02:17 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Jesús Vilares Ferro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce an adaptive scheduling for adaptive sampling as a novel way of
machine learning in the construction of part-of-speech taggers. The goal is to
speed up the training on large data sets, without significant loss of
performance with regard to an optimal configuration. In contrast to previous
methods using a random, fixed or regularly rising spacing between the
instances, ours analyzes the shape of the learning curve geometrically in
conjunction with a functional model to increase or decrease it at any time. The
algorithm proves to be formally correct regarding our working hypotheses.
Namely, given a case, the following one is the nearest ensuring a net gain of
learning ability from the former, it being possible to modulate the level of
requirement for this condition. We also improve the robustness of sampling by
paying greater attention to those regions of the training data base subject to
a temporary inflation in performance, thus preventing the learning from
stopping prematurely.
The proposal has been evaluated on the basis of its reliability to identify
the convergence of models, corroborating our expectations. While a concrete
halting condition is used for testing, users can choose any condition
whatsoever to suit their own specific needs. | [
-0.3720575273036957,
-0.6231682896614075,
0.23308193683624268,
0.3335776925086975,
-0.30294090509414673,
0.07320509105920792,
-0.06984823197126389,
-0.38052621483802795,
0.35693374276161194,
0.45825743675231934,
-0.4582325220108032,
-0.13791914284229279,
-0.5062469244003296,
-0.3198288381099701,
-0.16015850007534027,
0.9874573349952698,
0.09677531570196152,
-0.234494149684906,
-0.16553659737110138,
0.0014135431265458465,
-0.699522078037262,
-0.4225984215736389,
-0.9014292359352112,
-0.006660336162894964,
0.4490196406841278,
0.3077222406864166,
0.34113219380378723,
1.2350367307662964,
0.35833799839019775,
0.23417077958583832,
-0.12789711356163025,
-0.06446991115808487,
-0.08617373555898666,
0.2674037516117096,
-0.2938717305660248,
-0.24219706654548645,
-0.6046074628829956,
-0.11151920258998871,
0.978905439376831,
0.9859753847122192,
-0.8557287454605103,
0.31946995854377747,
-0.0903942808508873,
0.3558174669742584,
-0.6500604748725891,
0.12385588884353638,
-1.02510404586792,
-0.031190870329737663,
-0.32478341460227966,
-0.4829751253128052,
-0.4235967993736267,
-0.2001999169588089,
0.23439569771289825,
-0.7432544231414795,
0.5884665250778198,
0.035447027534246445,
0.6419233679771423,
0.6067404747009277,
0.10296114534139633,
-0.1783858835697174,
-0.7719551920890808,
0.7725825905799866,
-0.502466082572937,
0.2660136818885803,
0.48311322927474976,
0.4767639636993408,
-0.1615050882101059,
-0.7147690653800964,
-0.30987900495529175,
-0.11237781494855881,
0.3088115155696869,
0.29759466648101807,
0.07720301300287247,
-0.06001000106334686,
0.6785004734992981,
0.03229895234107971,
-0.6552022695541382,
0.2596277892589569,
-0.4993240237236023,
-0.09608740359544754,
0.5563989877700806,
-0.021066728979349136,
-0.23393858969211578,
0.19439543783664703,
-0.5051246285438538,
0.026273254305124283,
-0.3198293149471283,
0.20057059824466705,
0.6123042702674866,
0.5200538039207458,
0.21974964439868927,
0.3540092706680298,
-0.3934701979160309,
1.0677640438079834,
-0.04158028960227966,
-0.32764601707458496,
0.44491007924079895,
0.26915571093559265,
-0.3476196527481079,
0.1636117696762085,
0.229567751288414,
0.11537408828735352,
0.1643947958946228,
0.07116077840328217,
-0.5379256010055542,
0.17423106729984283,
0.5563132762908936,
-0.37572601437568665,
-0.45430415868759155,
-0.009566613472998142,
-0.3353882133960724,
-0.09676852077245712,
-0.06633105874061584,
-0.9026238918304443,
-0.26976674795150757,
-0.2573500871658325,
0.28568994998931885,
-0.4172641336917877,
-0.3428526818752289,
0.26221296191215515,
-0.3879351317882538,
0.03402126953005791,
0.033379800617694855,
-0.8265984654426575,
0.11715758591890335,
0.5063949823379517,
0.698390781879425,
0.015521264635026455,
-0.3960131108760834,
-0.9599825739860535,
0.13263052701950073,
-0.23102129995822906,
1.1749780178070068,
-0.7003040313720703,
-0.40544092655181885,
0.015976639464497566,
-0.18439526855945587,
-0.5037187933921814,
-0.8202860355377197,
0.5933056473731995,
-0.4201160669326782,
0.061709899455308914,
0.1395425647497177,
-0.6064666509628296,
0.20009365677833557,
0.058037374168634415,
-0.44248634576797485,
1.2275593280792236,
0.4591137766838074,
-0.6647254824638367,
0.5600406527519226,
-0.829248309135437,
-0.49143192172050476,
0.2759266197681427,
0.18964484333992004,
-0.7076908946037292,
-0.045736104249954224,
-0.029459862038493156,
0.4489601254463196,
0.28483352065086365,
-0.03542992100119591,
-0.3091076910495758,
-0.24598760902881622,
0.05905996635556221,
0.2287703901529312,
0.5897952914237976,
0.5525891780853271,
-0.23334315419197083,
0.15625576674938202,
-0.7293927073478699,
-0.17187482118606567,
0.244726300239563,
-0.5001213550567627,
-0.14344817399978638,
0.7783805131912231,
-0.1537746638059616,
-0.05578997731208801,
-0.16322393715381622,
-0.4262535572052002,
0.3703401982784271,
-0.45310452580451965,
0.4345109760761261,
1.0485563278198242,
0.2217927873134613,
0.46186432242393494,
-0.8192778825759888,
0.8434327244758606,
-0.37802332639694214,
0.2415509670972824,
-0.2736591398715973,
-0.3884657323360443,
-0.6328135132789612,
-0.6367539167404175,
0.4946196675300598,
0.6999815702438354,
-0.9767595529556274,
0.5678331851959229,
-0.07372482120990753,
-0.5656669735908508,
-0.3028322756290436,
0.01533716544508934,
0.32510295510292053,
0.5196630358695984,
0.3038546144962311,
-0.5913828015327454,
-0.82884681224823,
-0.3033652901649475,
-0.1380791813135147,
-0.09332742542028427,
-0.4585929811000824,
0.022013364359736443,
0.09017873555421829,
0.26935064792633057,
0.945159375667572,
-0.5025061368942261,
-0.29844993352890015,
0.07155938446521759,
0.13601502776145935,
0.3295283913612366,
0.6020056009292603,
1.049397587776184,
-0.6678179502487183,
-0.3791801333427429,
-0.6052094101905823,
-0.10512068122625351,
-0.19642534852027893,
-0.23299407958984375,
0.006592303514480591,
0.3625657856464386,
0.5579769611358643,
-0.12279647588729858,
0.3557332456111908,
0.4337185323238373,
-0.34527748823165894,
0.5600621104240417,
0.0358409658074379,
-0.4756128191947937,
-0.7807097434997559,
-0.090218685567379,
0.0614975206553936,
-0.3099323511123657,
-0.4220743477344513,
-0.1623014658689499,
-0.507588267326355,
-0.1497373878955841,
-0.45111650228500366,
0.3380139470100403,
-0.2783603370189667,
-0.13924427330493927,
-0.44479963183403015,
0.05875434726476669,
-0.389322966337204,
0.5166740417480469,
0.11622633039951324,
0.34495988488197327,
0.8134578466415405,
-0.9156308770179749,
0.2610880434513092,
-0.07755445688962936,
-0.4200993478298187,
0.8008748888969421,
-0.4862090051174164,
0.1174517497420311,
-0.23199976980686188,
0.4077991545200348,
-0.8611863255500793,
-0.2194344848394394,
0.5459409952163696,
-0.8179869651794434,
0.41903653740882874,
-0.41023287177085876,
-0.2967178225517273,
-0.336402952671051,
-0.09201624244451523,
0.22093625366687775,
0.7988495826721191,
-0.429031640291214,
0.587353527545929,
0.7677974104881287,
-0.2420215755701065,
-0.2559770941734314,
-0.22370478510856628,
-0.6712005734443665,
-0.3275059461593628,
-0.2353644222021103,
0.46450790762901306,
-0.12976913154125214,
0.04852480813860893,
0.1520765721797943,
-0.266917884349823,
-0.23374392092227936,
0.40679776668548584,
0.16173715889453888,
0.29310229420661926,
-0.1377006620168686,
0.2575227618217468,
-0.18621978163719177,
-0.2915130853652954,
-0.05172975733876228,
-0.8020097017288208,
0.531769871711731,
0.6280650496482849,
-0.2212768793106079,
-0.18477338552474976,
0.22365134954452515,
0.22050856053829193,
-0.41054555773735046,
0.6958879232406616,
0.8067104816436768,
-0.8078430891036987,
-0.502555251121521,
-0.3255477249622345,
0.17091909050941467,
-0.42884790897369385,
0.21871261298656464,
-0.5168953537940979,
-0.7349370718002319,
0.4351370632648468,
0.12095112353563309,
0.44676557183265686,
0.5837580561637878,
0.5019297003746033,
-0.36175739765167236,
0.8216099739074707,
0.7195708155632019,
0.014864460565149784,
1.1691174507141113,
0.014697571285068989,
0.06556744128465652,
-0.5496925711631775,
-0.12531687319278717,
-0.7952508330345154,
-0.24494220316410065,
-0.48580533266067505,
-0.4100850224494934,
0.1530630737543106,
0.14172738790512085,
-0.2349315583705902,
-0.05946510285139084,
-1.0835464000701904,
0.452441930770874,
0.7376701831817627,
-0.09766228497028351,
-0.3581504821777344,
0.12326433509588242,
-0.03371579572558403,
0.23635588586330414,
-0.8976271152496338,
-0.25506606698036194,
0.83610999584198,
0.08901234716176987,
0.5325863361358643,
-0.1270359456539154,
0.32310953736305237,
0.4249216914176941,
0.3094753324985504,
-0.6974292993545532,
0.2903476059436798,
-0.11796185374259949,
-0.5909581780433655,
-0.28677037358283997,
-0.3587407171726227,
-1.1643990278244019,
-0.01649186573922634,
-0.18996526300907135,
-0.8733617067337036,
-0.0627768337726593,
0.5979880690574646,
-0.5027698278427124,
0.6187881827354431,
-0.798397421836853,
0.6121676564216614,
-0.06607023626565933,
0.11675026267766953,
-0.0213130172342062,
-0.6757837533950806,
-0.16181622445583344,
0.08577019721269608,
0.0766773372888565,
-0.5304940342903137,
0.0490555502474308,
1.2333837747573853,
-0.07095936685800552,
0.7505360245704651,
-0.9909465312957764,
0.32909220457077026,
0.5226299166679382,
-0.16274602711200714,
0.23702572286128998,
-0.17739331722259521,
-0.12368506193161011,
-0.17566804587841034,
0.15229007601737976,
-1.0821369886398315,
-0.37464797496795654,
0.2512557804584503,
-0.5368941426277161,
-0.286742240190506,
-0.7920787334442139,
-0.527466893196106,
-0.33700838685035706,
0.04132362827658653,
0.09589336812496185,
0.30187323689460754,
0.07533453404903412,
0.05933162942528725,
0.5468389987945557,
-0.06618337333202362,
0.5272654294967651,
0.49068811535835266,
-0.05880816653370857,
-0.31077516078948975,
1.133675456047058,
0.3161503076553345,
0.13525278866291046,
0.3617994785308838,
0.11727564036846161,
-0.2574954926967621,
-0.899150013923645,
-0.24316102266311646,
0.0948059931397438,
-0.2906286418437958,
-0.4508727192878723,
-0.29512807726860046,
-0.25359755754470825,
-0.6825612187385559,
-0.12800854444503784,
-0.17659185826778412,
-0.5033541917800903,
-0.20674535632133484,
0.1410108059644699,
0.41932326555252075,
0.44625604152679443,
0.08428837358951569,
0.7424066066741943,
-0.6948686242103577,
0.17813080549240112,
0.1013716533780098,
0.7265259623527527,
-0.28728678822517395,
-0.9478256702423096,
-0.23779603838920593,
-0.13604453206062317,
-0.5591545701026917,
-0.6355096697807312,
0.017258109524846077,
0.3957396149635315,
0.9862366914749146,
0.34861186146736145,
0.14932112395763397,
0.4435144066810608,
-0.5580404996871948,
0.4868457615375519,
-0.13311642408370972,
-0.7394732236862183,
0.53493732213974,
-0.49882742762565613,
0.19019047915935516,
0.24584463238716125,
0.4704975187778473,
-0.5299879908561707,
-0.13034288585186005,
-0.8033460378646851,
-0.8972944021224976,
0.6743956208229065,
-0.04339225962758064,
-0.02743089385330677,
0.1194448471069336,
0.6413569450378418,
-0.12690645456314087,
0.03383722901344299,
-0.190712571144104,
0.020622974261641502,
-0.3317636549472809,
-0.13695907592773438,
-0.17199042439460754,
-0.40344661474227905,
-0.04369443282485008,
-0.2039238065481186,
0.7671275734901428,
-0.3262215852737427,
0.5649800300598145,
0.08352572470903397,
0.12165804952383041,
-0.012750227935612202,
-0.018327191472053528,
0.6311878561973572,
1.0824919939041138,
-0.4316372275352478,
-0.1652335524559021,
0.28049683570861816,
-0.39060142636299133,
-0.16597484052181244,
0.6033527851104736,
-0.06747476011514664,
0.056682273745536804,
0.12370754033327103,
0.8120997548103333,
-0.015256695449352264,
-0.7701095342636108,
0.1631138026714325,
0.024102119728922844,
-0.34201520681381226,
-0.5886729955673218,
0.20550279319286346,
-0.17374977469444275,
0.3175123929977417,
0.4716825783252716,
0.2563176453113556,
-0.24620792269706726,
-0.22587263584136963,
0.27394673228263855,
0.2810852527618408,
-0.27917560935020447,
-0.311572402715683,
0.5657489895820618,
0.1166226714849472,
-0.7289832830429077,
0.49306347966194153,
-0.5476375818252563,
-0.5576603412628174,
0.599946916103363,
0.58144211769104,
0.5839767456054688,
-0.8349564075469971,
-0.10332032293081284,
0.43612274527549744,
0.3201710283756256,
0.19481481611728668,
0.3520446717739105,
0.030072826892137527,
-0.7190829515457153,
-0.42714089155197144,
-0.9951236844062805,
-0.44597581028938293,
-0.025524314492940903,
-0.7570824027061462,
0.28280550241470337,
-0.6932500600814819,
-0.1241445392370224,
0.25367113947868347,
-0.12282268702983856,
-0.3924476206302643,
0.37332361936569214,
0.09642622619867325,
0.955692708492279,
-0.8446491360664368,
0.9778075814247131,
1.092266321182251,
0.09899868071079254,
-0.5636258721351624,
-0.13244383037090302,
-0.11466265469789505,
-0.6495272517204285,
-0.43296465277671814,
-0.031207477673888206,
0.210389643907547,
0.2240113615989685,
-0.2284725457429886,
-0.787070631980896,
0.8531485199928284,
0.33796122670173645,
-0.3497157692909241,
-0.17467449605464935,
-0.3403896689414978,
0.4120713472366333,
-0.32660141587257385,
-0.1832870990037918,
0.6292811036109924,
0.11362168192863464,
0.2943035364151001,
-0.9904174208641052,
-0.1737847775220871,
-0.2526542842388153,
0.029677337035536766,
0.5689817070960999,
-0.45321086049079895,
0.6007847785949707,
0.16899888217449188,
-0.3831949532032013,
0.1664995551109314,
0.6079819798469543,
0.3531329035758972,
0.5433686971664429,
1.1983163356781006,
0.5637428164482117,
1.0355726480484009,
-0.31301185488700867,
0.8830451369285583,
-0.09714407473802567,
0.4202585816383362,
1.2228236198425293,
-0.18238255381584167,
0.8645195364952087,
0.3916841745376587,
-0.38503941893577576,
0.13968265056610107,
1.0685783624649048,
-0.14832252264022827,
0.45943570137023926,
0.5311144590377808,
-0.20127618312835693,
-0.16091154515743256,
-0.32800933718681335,
-0.45362094044685364,
0.5738927721977234,
0.3516803979873657,
-0.08607625961303711,
-0.0015819533728063107,
0.10458679497241974,
-0.10136057436466217,
0.16226276755332947,
-0.3484717011451721,
0.6129007935523987,
-0.33455079793930054,
-0.8306018114089966,
0.4458150267601013,
0.07269620895385742,
0.6409969925880432,
-0.7332251071929932,
0.043377649039030075,
0.12556485831737518,
0.2227979451417923,
-0.1812252253293991,
-0.368543803691864,
0.6666939854621887,
-0.1784818023443222,
-0.48229798674583435,
-0.40179213881492615,
0.613572359085083,
-0.2614092230796814,
-0.4169667363166809,
0.032573338598012924,
0.1847347766160965,
0.14396344125270844,
-0.1058332622051239,
-0.644721269607544,
0.051539696753025055,
-0.09719134867191315,
0.08046071231365204,
0.27832844853401184,
0.17640677094459534,
-0.005101778078824282,
0.3437575101852417,
0.7609984278678894,
0.17415834963321686,
0.5510018467903137,
-0.15622928738594055,
0.8495697975158691,
-0.39972561597824097,
-0.6741687655448914,
-0.49063754081726074,
0.5060851573944092,
0.19899602234363556,
-0.15853652358055115,
0.42718175053596497,
0.6863487958908081,
1.4238433837890625,
0.13985374569892883,
0.6907299160957336,
-0.36217001080513,
1.0124214887619019,
-0.60976243019104,
0.5048928260803223,
-0.4459855258464813,
0.04988854005932808,
-0.10874250531196594,
-0.950248122215271,
-0.4470720589160919,
0.6857593059539795,
-0.1747463196516037,
-0.04814979434013367,
0.5838859677314758,
0.5645564198493958,
-0.14033614099025726,
-0.17724379897117615,
0.00025812609237618744,
-0.20935650169849396,
0.34109005331993103,
0.5466829538345337,
0.9122732877731323,
0.08923543244600296,
0.5894542336463928,
-0.4117085635662079,
-0.637495756149292,
-0.12585625052452087,
-0.8285784721374512,
-0.5041854381561279,
-0.7028326392173767,
-0.4096418619155884,
-0.3487873375415802,
-0.048773959279060364,
0.8320202827453613,
0.9199721813201904,
-0.6246291995048523,
-0.20575276017189026,
0.2729143500328064,
0.11522907763719559,
-0.5915862321853638,
-0.26227420568466187,
0.22524423897266388,
-0.5161178112030029,
-0.8410010933876038,
0.265007346868515,
0.05008619278669357,
-0.10823946446180344,
0.2578912377357483,
0.12524491548538208,
-0.5802417993545532,
0.01098686084151268,
0.3043031096458435,
0.5367910861968994,
-0.32459962368011475,
-0.36741289496421814,
-0.22136126458644867,
0.28822067379951477,
0.25952690839767456,
1.114899754524231,
-0.7457234859466553,
0.7154814600944519,
0.47879675030708313,
0.7949945330619812,
0.6415349841117859,
0.031438373029232025,
0.02244952693581581,
-1.0457733869552612,
0.5965291857719421,
0.5054154396057129,
0.4203101098537445,
0.11764764785766602,
-0.037800393998622894,
0.48990824818611145,
0.6998745799064636,
-0.6510080695152283,
-1.0938949584960938,
0.2807101607322693,
-1.0899349451065063,
-0.0077173770405352116,
0.7413507103919983,
-0.28426215052604675,
-0.24168403446674347,
-0.21688097715377808,
-0.04704182595014572,
0.4743184745311737,
-0.18589001893997192,
0.8589807748794556,
0.3553975224494934,
-0.3503963351249695,
0.24836091697216034,
-0.6703860759735107,
0.3485717475414276,
0.37710434198379517,
-0.6992727518081665,
-0.4103839099407196,
0.3394632339477539,
0.5068200826644897,
0.18094241619110107,
0.9474741816520691,
0.32189008593559265,
0.4954385459423065,
0.011921039782464504,
0.11511701345443726,
-0.05040443688631058,
-0.45468810200691223,
-0.30247706174850464,
0.15481479465961456,
0.22972887754440308,
-0.9067397713661194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02515v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02515v1 | Modeling of learning curves with applications to pos tagging | 2024-02-04T15:00:52 | 2024-02-04T15:00:52 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Francisco J. Ribadas Pena | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | An algorithm to estimate the evolution of learning curves on the whole of a
training data base, based on the results obtained from a portion and using a
functional strategy, is introduced. We approximate iteratively the sought value
at the desired time, independently of the learning technique used and once a
point in the process, called prediction level, has been passed. The proposal
proves to be formally correct with respect to our working hypotheses and
includes a reliable proximity condition. This allows the user to fix a
convergence threshold with respect to the accuracy finally achievable, which
extends the concept of stopping criterion and seems to be effective even in the
presence of distorting observations.
Our aim is to evaluate the training effort, supporting decision making in
order to reduce the need for both human and computational resources during the
learning process. The proposal is of interest in at least three operational
procedures. The first is the anticipation of accuracy gain, with the purpose of
measuring how much work is needed to achieve a certain degree of performance.
The second relates the comparison of efficiency between systems at training
time, with the objective of completing this task only for the one that best
suits our requirements. The prediction of accuracy is also a valuable item of
information for customizing systems, since we can estimate in advance the
impact of settings on both the performance and the development costs. Using the
generation of part-of-speech taggers as an example application, the
experimental results are consistent with our expectations. | [
-0.2824443280696869,
-0.816684365272522,
0.3222874104976654,
-0.09947174042463303,
-0.10160906612873077,
-0.07917127013206482,
-0.11762426048517227,
-0.34602826833724976,
0.173321932554245,
0.03780470788478851,
-0.5370140671730042,
-0.483222633600235,
-0.41555848717689514,
-0.29920053482055664,
-0.29511895775794983,
0.8617139458656311,
0.03768451139330864,
0.06521814316511154,
-0.033754218369722366,
0.3153434097766876,
-0.550480306148529,
-0.4719788134098053,
-0.8723490238189697,
-0.1896931678056717,
0.6386347413063049,
0.3282003104686737,
0.17842569947242737,
1.0174988508224487,
0.4910779297351837,
0.23507049679756165,
-0.23598334193229675,
-0.12905816733837128,
-0.29393523931503296,
0.13930442929267883,
-0.18250003457069397,
-0.6259618401527405,
-0.5849967002868652,
-0.045837465673685074,
0.7933623194694519,
0.7964069247245789,
-0.4597548544406891,
0.197317436337471,
0.009827387519180775,
0.45529383420944214,
-0.42349034547805786,
0.28688064217567444,
-0.4014601707458496,
0.027896160259842873,
-0.2303098738193512,
-0.3695640563964844,
-0.5024241805076599,
-0.3780645728111267,
0.5398324728012085,
-0.596366822719574,
0.28527170419692993,
-0.2166958600282669,
0.8926361799240112,
0.13695938885211945,
0.15226148068904877,
-0.50947105884552,
-0.8466045260429382,
0.8260250687599182,
-0.7081538438796997,
0.25117358565330505,
0.4959374964237213,
0.45804136991500854,
-0.2245148867368698,
-0.5805795788764954,
-0.04931773990392685,
-0.4260369837284088,
0.1927763670682907,
0.01161294523626566,
0.09100698679685593,
0.240752175450325,
0.7981948256492615,
0.16277636587619781,
-0.3345457911491394,
0.21027804911136627,
-0.647718608379364,
0.136703759431839,
0.8511418104171753,
0.0815512165427208,
-0.12410634011030197,
0.06141006574034691,
-0.3931407332420349,
0.16137239336967468,
-0.3797057271003723,
0.38414448499679565,
0.6256230473518372,
0.6267583966255188,
-0.08622357994318008,
0.5435344576835632,
-0.3867020010948181,
0.8501935005187988,
-0.04238712415099144,
-0.7087223529815674,
0.5584025382995605,
0.2572121024131775,
-0.08694759011268616,
-0.25921520590782166,
0.34054118394851685,
0.18867570161819458,
0.404958039522171,
0.042646750807762146,
-0.30142560601234436,
0.009029015898704529,
0.38458386063575745,
-0.3779890239238739,
-0.28920289874076843,
-0.09861909598112106,
-0.40581366419792175,
-0.22683745622634888,
0.043247416615486145,
-0.9588469862937927,
-0.351033091545105,
-0.4527902901172638,
0.37820881605148315,
-0.8813647627830505,
-0.3538721799850464,
0.05203111469745636,
-0.16057346761226654,
0.16584700345993042,
0.1644940972328186,
-0.8905170559883118,
0.04297633096575737,
0.6026929616928101,
1.1128230094909668,
-0.015307498164474964,
-0.3799501359462738,
-0.46429136395454407,
0.005931058898568153,
-0.14365817606449127,
0.718925952911377,
-0.7689963579177856,
-0.566398561000824,
0.042627010494470596,
-0.4575682282447815,
-0.29578548669815063,
-0.3006923794746399,
0.6825420260429382,
-0.294237345457077,
-0.22888725996017456,
-0.08302353322505951,
-0.9655247926712036,
-0.05889388173818588,
0.13383221626281738,
-0.4297206997871399,
1.075777292251587,
0.23130390048027039,
-0.6931504011154175,
0.6445558667182922,
-1.106407880783081,
-0.561454176902771,
0.158939927816391,
0.12703564763069153,
-0.5680145621299744,
0.1314248889684677,
-0.37805601954460144,
0.45115697383880615,
0.03587856516242027,
-0.04398199915885925,
-0.2750241756439209,
-0.23307301104068756,
0.070734903216362,
0.08771748840808868,
0.5100176930427551,
0.3743216097354889,
-0.23915137350559235,
0.1429765224456787,
-0.6862389445304871,
0.02238667570054531,
0.11903731524944305,
-0.5370080471038818,
-0.43027761578559875,
0.6523213982582092,
-0.5967435836791992,
-0.0374123714864254,
-0.003798095043748617,
-0.5428197383880615,
0.501085102558136,
-0.3135719299316406,
0.4901263117790222,
0.5188254714012146,
0.2129986733198166,
0.5268139839172363,
-0.3920655846595764,
0.6840509176254272,
-0.29505687952041626,
0.5063183903694153,
-0.31806379556655884,
-0.602121114730835,
-0.580781102180481,
-0.4225095212459564,
0.6530236601829529,
0.4844956696033478,
-0.6629533171653748,
0.4503665268421173,
-0.126578226685524,
-0.7932279706001282,
-0.11254897713661194,
-0.2028745859861374,
0.4185652434825897,
0.7517545819282532,
0.2425643652677536,
-0.39754900336265564,
-0.3679802715778351,
-0.27832338213920593,
-0.14078322052955627,
-0.3059629797935486,
-0.2961864173412323,
-0.05997716262936592,
0.3680107891559601,
0.19552017748355865,
0.9371929168701172,
-0.49401459097862244,
-0.10311868041753769,
0.051332443952560425,
0.48130103945732117,
-0.14244459569454193,
0.6662530899047852,
0.59129399061203,
-0.8025018572807312,
-0.471425861120224,
-0.19627107679843903,
-0.5116748213768005,
0.025762120261788368,
0.04452051967382431,
0.07337646186351776,
0.24494509398937225,
0.19995293021202087,
-0.14456616342067719,
0.752210259437561,
0.16452628374099731,
-0.20991133153438568,
0.7693041563034058,
-0.11154989898204803,
-0.03159599006175995,
-0.5930719971656799,
0.04948170483112335,
0.6856224536895752,
0.0755968764424324,
-0.9760947227478027,
-0.12060760706663132,
-0.2650323510169983,
-0.01735183410346508,
-0.2817402780056,
0.2937803566455841,
-0.3278728127479553,
-0.23614807426929474,
-0.07203461974859238,
0.1693233847618103,
-0.4520361125469208,
0.518430769443512,
0.16486705839633942,
0.4602629840373993,
0.8326752185821533,
-0.6811007857322693,
0.1466541886329651,
0.0369805209338665,
-0.29585322737693787,
0.8527638912200928,
-0.2618107497692108,
-0.09008356928825378,
-0.0612642876803875,
-0.20172010362148285,
-0.8048904538154602,
-0.11376754194498062,
0.40823403000831604,
-0.9589840769767761,
0.45674648880958557,
-0.4613957703113556,
-0.12263950705528259,
-0.5277749300003052,
-0.06989547610282898,
-0.09639967232942581,
0.7112724184989929,
-0.11503951251506805,
0.5990325212478638,
0.5085079669952393,
-0.1018415242433548,
-0.5457813739776611,
-0.3492300808429718,
-0.5114597678184509,
-0.48349708318710327,
-0.2529211938381195,
0.16848671436309814,
0.005735418293625116,
0.04892183095216751,
-0.21406495571136475,
-0.137166827917099,
-0.13247738778591156,
0.16814680397510529,
0.24102318286895752,
0.401079386472702,
-0.1558472216129303,
0.4496575891971588,
-0.1529640108346939,
-0.1854955106973648,
0.10857244580984116,
-0.5991664528846741,
0.41551122069358826,
0.10550505667924881,
-0.17572849988937378,
-0.5275275111198425,
-0.05286393314599991,
0.14671209454536438,
-0.4573439657688141,
0.7116126418113708,
0.437822163105011,
-0.6685209274291992,
-0.4373927414417267,
-0.26195797324180603,
0.11887579411268234,
-0.47204917669296265,
0.2244170755147934,
-0.7440744042396545,
-0.3569573163986206,
0.6465652585029602,
-0.3287741243839264,
0.24790571630001068,
0.2781345546245575,
0.3103175163269043,
-0.44933634996414185,
1.0583480596542358,
0.9205830097198486,
0.2847754955291748,
1.0922267436981201,
-0.48657187819480896,
0.3400076925754547,
-0.580947756767273,
-0.5701025724411011,
-0.8095078468322754,
-0.3448179364204407,
-0.6144094467163086,
-0.3347152769565582,
0.12173890322446823,
0.4425906836986542,
-0.29361966252326965,
0.2122667282819748,
-0.6557681560516357,
0.3860492408275604,
0.6365050077438354,
0.1392652541399002,
0.02059894986450672,
0.3228154480457306,
-0.12932395935058594,
-0.001360349589958787,
-0.8539173007011414,
-0.49295860528945923,
0.9627901315689087,
0.5168744325637817,
0.8000619411468506,
-0.37011319398880005,
0.6058327555656433,
0.5461840629577637,
0.604296088218689,
-0.9863126277923584,
0.35032278299331665,
-0.09042444080114365,
-0.43939515948295593,
-0.7041349411010742,
-0.6205559372901917,
-0.7100469470024109,
-0.12755441665649414,
-0.10702897608280182,
-1.0915381908416748,
0.04319922626018524,
0.5154163837432861,
-0.29226261377334595,
0.6489014625549316,
-0.7697336673736572,
0.7811349630355835,
-0.46309494972229004,
-0.3273449242115021,
0.05571462959051132,
-0.8230544328689575,
-0.17751650512218475,
-0.05096609517931938,
-0.054467763751745224,
-0.36203423142433167,
-0.05229558050632477,
1.2284680604934692,
-0.2720454931259155,
0.7198606133460999,
-0.885888397693634,
0.08515232801437378,
0.6552403569221497,
-0.16191120445728302,
0.12879204750061035,
-0.6206355094909668,
-0.5560736656188965,
0.08209531009197235,
0.14376918971538544,
-0.6619641780853271,
-0.49503427743911743,
0.3256126642227173,
-0.5564514398574829,
-0.1664128452539444,
-0.3912498950958252,
-0.3630404770374298,
-0.29765787720680237,
0.26530978083610535,
0.20710442960262299,
0.3900192975997925,
0.08573279529809952,
-0.18083366751670837,
0.548688530921936,
-0.0037419230211526155,
0.26117077469825745,
0.393545925617218,
-0.16248944401741028,
-0.2489892691373825,
1.1196142435073853,
0.40309828519821167,
0.37752920389175415,
0.2987379729747772,
0.26085370779037476,
-0.3851064443588257,
-0.9079128503799438,
-0.25060126185417175,
0.33734434843063354,
-0.6641879677772522,
-0.4315612018108368,
0.025457177311182022,
-0.21068747341632843,
-0.17280064523220062,
-0.3158580958843231,
0.00801191758364439,
-0.2488260120153427,
-0.33462440967559814,
-0.1781349629163742,
0.28348323702812195,
0.7970311641693115,
-0.11731091141700745,
0.8431618213653564,
-0.4301837980747223,
-0.26636311411857605,
-0.27148231863975525,
0.7285758256912231,
-0.19015958905220032,
-0.600770115852356,
-0.4062023460865021,
0.2640596926212311,
-0.4913039207458496,
-0.9714999794960022,
0.2809354364871979,
0.2686784863471985,
0.8512133955955505,
0.5253376960754395,
-0.08484452962875366,
0.5739337801933289,
-0.2303328812122345,
0.5265462398529053,
0.27547234296798706,
-1.031754732131958,
0.7589033246040344,
-0.4070564806461334,
-0.2001480758190155,
0.41911956667900085,
0.9493014812469482,
-0.3120003342628479,
0.035132814198732376,
-0.5479083061218262,
-0.596027135848999,
0.7948174476623535,
-0.10091721266508102,
-0.1743624061346054,
0.29198771715164185,
1.0771698951721191,
0.0009569298708811402,
0.12828439474105835,
-0.3727042078971863,
-0.11888647079467773,
-0.017054706811904907,
-0.3647564649581909,
-0.008892189711332321,
-0.16270016133785248,
0.2686886489391327,
-0.1980878859758377,
0.6949805617332458,
-0.20808613300323486,
0.35657528042793274,
0.010570191778242588,
0.10354657471179962,
-0.25206127762794495,
-0.1611173003911972,
0.48099321126937866,
1.116016149520874,
-0.25051409006118774,
-0.22665296494960785,
0.18497858941555023,
-0.3363604247570038,
0.07769717276096344,
0.12980468571186066,
-0.2682513892650604,
-0.10472235828638077,
0.0724644586443901,
0.7523330450057983,
-0.08722317963838577,
-0.7132644057273865,
0.271173357963562,
0.23664502799510956,
-0.255845844745636,
-0.2705298066139221,
0.14563174545764923,
-0.2263670116662979,
0.3211902678012848,
0.36982688307762146,
-0.0364370234310627,
0.024438006803393364,
-0.21402598917484283,
0.3854515552520752,
0.3068699240684509,
-0.4641517996788025,
-0.28061145544052124,
0.33418968319892883,
0.3017643094062805,
-0.9220126867294312,
0.41995349526405334,
-0.41632288694381714,
-0.5571555495262146,
0.6650176644325256,
0.3671087622642517,
0.5744905471801758,
-0.8820275664329529,
0.32787925004959106,
0.6667791604995728,
0.21730796992778778,
-0.008121945895254612,
0.12190544605255127,
-0.05180075764656067,
-0.37157630920410156,
-0.3688648045063019,
-0.994310200214386,
-0.3298672139644623,
0.011701530776917934,
-0.8855103850364685,
0.6144930720329285,
-0.4177659749984741,
-0.5701974630355835,
0.3698318898677826,
0.04224047064781189,
-0.33799856901168823,
0.4152470529079437,
0.40544870495796204,
1.169327974319458,
-0.8383559584617615,
0.9129873514175415,
0.7593182325363159,
-0.5183058381080627,
-0.6534687876701355,
-0.1592920571565628,
-0.2534199357032776,
-0.5242027640342712,
0.0944209024310112,
0.08552227914333344,
-0.13251334428787231,
0.10248980671167374,
-0.22725987434387207,
-0.7284477353096008,
1.0226389169692993,
0.15375380218029022,
-0.7217110991477966,
-0.5829161405563354,
0.16699130833148956,
0.5793771743774414,
-0.4590432345867157,
0.063264861702919,
1.0466262102127075,
0.18950244784355164,
0.38224658370018005,
-0.8904020190238953,
-0.3007376492023468,
0.009486067108809948,
-0.039404548704624176,
0.5485184192657471,
-0.2381834089756012,
0.835885226726532,
-0.30730998516082764,
-0.34181511402130127,
0.22621802985668182,
0.4252810478210449,
0.07730568200349808,
0.46599745750427246,
0.6334855556488037,
0.5073530673980713,
0.8581008315086365,
-0.34784871339797974,
0.7988640069961548,
-0.15577419102191925,
0.7663331627845764,
1.0089346170425415,
-0.038887787610292435,
0.8844187259674072,
0.18329329788684845,
-0.36461368203163147,
0.41453951597213745,
0.9101945161819458,
-0.25895583629608154,
0.37345054745674133,
0.5826560258865356,
-0.1529291272163391,
0.14855259656906128,
0.09864707291126251,
-0.14548039436340332,
0.27354785799980164,
0.5720382928848267,
-0.5175566673278809,
0.02613219805061817,
0.13591185212135315,
-0.030963711440563202,
-0.015905337408185005,
-0.5353142023086548,
0.759095311164856,
-0.2834312915802002,
-0.6628217101097107,
0.4616391062736511,
0.21831583976745605,
0.49337759613990784,
-0.897126317024231,
-0.0899740681052208,
0.09795823693275452,
0.15128129720687866,
-0.28024283051490784,
-0.700506329536438,
0.35606130957603455,
0.11442205309867859,
-0.010670243762433529,
-0.2219696342945099,
0.8067683577537537,
-0.44354352355003357,
-0.30578649044036865,
0.24700938165187836,
0.35766109824180603,
0.32168084383010864,
0.2690749168395996,
-0.7268838286399841,
0.1016298234462738,
0.16332313418388367,
-0.03836304321885109,
0.015378262847661972,
0.15268035233020782,
0.13002321124076843,
0.6477152705192566,
0.33663347363471985,
0.11056016385555267,
0.5481849908828735,
-0.3500133454799652,
0.7178990840911865,
-0.4654202461242676,
-0.6663973331451416,
-0.6360914707183838,
0.7058488726615906,
0.014650776982307434,
-0.2531833350658417,
0.48492783308029175,
0.545720636844635,
1.257509708404541,
0.18227516114711761,
0.9656780362129211,
-0.37297409772872925,
0.6510162353515625,
-0.45282310247421265,
0.470223993062973,
-0.4329441785812378,
-0.02590973861515522,
-0.1078144907951355,
-0.798460066318512,
-0.24329254031181335,
0.8291111588478088,
-0.8700734376907349,
0.2742863893508911,
0.4200688600540161,
0.5145750641822815,
0.04861696437001228,
0.18871557712554932,
0.27003759145736694,
-0.2240733504295349,
0.2723938822746277,
0.34184402227401733,
0.9697086811065674,
-0.031240077689290047,
0.36729878187179565,
-0.6091811656951904,
-0.753727912902832,
-0.20873360335826874,
-0.7770158648490906,
-0.7077277898788452,
-0.6689959168434143,
-0.33012109994888306,
-0.2613147795200348,
-0.000013634125934913754,
0.6005741357803345,
0.9621798992156982,
-0.575536847114563,
-0.4444611370563507,
-0.05584007874131203,
-0.05238032341003418,
-0.3109520971775055,
-0.18763256072998047,
0.1762121170759201,
-0.5587729811668396,
-0.6146339178085327,
-0.04857464134693146,
0.002401535166427493,
0.12295743823051453,
-0.2536165714263916,
-0.2574886977672577,
-0.4828878939151764,
0.10611505806446075,
0.3901631236076355,
0.652437150478363,
-0.47790518403053284,
-0.24845413863658905,
-0.1362459510564804,
0.28091883659362793,
0.28061190247535706,
1.0247414112091064,
-0.47626230120658875,
0.6782291531562805,
0.4070298969745636,
0.45516908168792725,
0.7525768280029297,
0.2949194312095642,
0.08420473337173462,
-0.6987587213516235,
-0.03862015902996063,
0.30968165397644043,
0.15638472139835358,
0.2776867151260376,
-0.02067761868238449,
0.6237154603004456,
0.3573060631752014,
-0.500365138053894,
-0.9332683086395264,
0.23640355467796326,
-0.7058199048042297,
0.10869599878787994,
0.7346001863479614,
-0.6762374639511108,
-0.36095166206359863,
0.08979634195566177,
-0.03484680876135826,
0.5443350076675415,
-0.3196626305580139,
0.7911040782928467,
0.4497857689857483,
-0.5663658380508423,
0.1741124540567398,
-0.6127960085868835,
0.6378688812255859,
0.049820445477962494,
-0.9001376628875732,
-0.05698573589324951,
0.4563436210155487,
0.4115750789642334,
0.4915236234664917,
0.3738507926464081,
0.10525143891572952,
0.154819056391716,
0.12940934300422668,
0.16082513332366943,
0.012996222823858261,
-0.6389918327331543,
-0.4252469837665558,
0.17700152099132538,
0.2332976907491684,
-0.5811909437179565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02513v1 | Early stopping by correlating online indicators in neural networks | 2024-02-04T14:57:20 | 2024-02-04T14:57:20 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Yerai Doval Mosquera, Francisco J. Ribadas Pena, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE | In order to minimize the generalization error in neural networks, a novel
technique to identify overfitting phenomena when training the learner is
formally introduced. This enables support of a reliable and trustworthy early
stopping condition, thus improving the predictive power of that type of
modeling. Our proposal exploits the correlation over time in a collection of
online indicators, namely characteristic functions for indicating if a set of
hypotheses are met, associated with a range of independent stopping conditions
built from a canary judgment to evaluate the presence of overfitting. That way,
we provide a formal basis for decision making in terms of interrupting the
learning process.
As opposed to previous approaches focused on a single criterion, we take
advantage of subsidiarities between independent assessments, thus seeking both
a wider operating range and greater diagnostic reliability. With a view to
illustrating the effectiveness of the halting condition described, we choose to
work in the sphere of natural language processing, an operational continuum
increasingly based on machine learning. As a case study, we focus on parser
generation, one of the most demanding and complex tasks in the domain. The
selection of cross-validation as a canary function enables an actual comparison
with the most representative early stopping conditions based on overfitting
identification, pointing to a promising start toward an optimal bias and
variance control. | [
-0.7537557482719421,
-0.966960072517395,
0.6288003921508789,
0.35095497965812683,
-0.034049615263938904,
-0.0414910651743412,
-0.21911466121673584,
-0.5526231527328491,
0.23008158802986145,
0.1689326912164688,
-0.23107856512069702,
-0.07095453143119812,
-0.6635252237319946,
-0.014784461818635464,
-0.5624991059303284,
0.9619700312614441,
0.030910339206457138,
0.015305408276617527,
-0.24345563352108002,
0.06533687561750412,
-0.4428103268146515,
-0.5725420713424683,
-1.4784066677093506,
-0.40217113494873047,
0.5386698246002197,
-0.2319551259279251,
0.5117271542549133,
0.656610906124115,
0.33577537536621094,
0.3666784465312958,
-0.3454934060573578,
0.08979380875825882,
-0.2565290331840515,
0.22592976689338684,
-0.004611447919160128,
-0.4702501595020294,
-0.2630039155483246,
-0.07874801009893417,
0.3611922860145569,
1.066567301750183,
-0.08826079219579697,
-0.11357160657644272,
0.29694345593452454,
0.6316894292831421,
-0.8410256505012512,
0.52266925573349,
-0.3256693482398987,
0.2945418357849121,
-0.14860369265079498,
-0.28815898299217224,
-0.2581946551799774,
-0.4387162923812866,
0.3051806688308716,
-0.4969935715198517,
0.24185819923877716,
-0.22757574915885925,
0.8481903076171875,
0.394479364156723,
-0.055766526609659195,
-0.19987782835960388,
-0.734078586101532,
0.895718514919281,
-0.38856789469718933,
0.5256935954093933,
0.8700559139251709,
0.5618674159049988,
-0.12194463610649109,
-0.7342612147331238,
-0.16788968443870544,
-0.22927963733673096,
-0.028917131945490837,
0.18510016798973083,
-0.4015025496482849,
-0.10925654321908951,
0.14567819237709045,
-0.002952709561213851,
-0.3208616077899933,
0.130072683095932,
-0.6644670367240906,
-0.45564931631088257,
0.4417242109775543,
-0.04899619147181511,
0.12023728340864182,
0.21718816459178925,
-0.29654914140701294,
0.1449303925037384,
-0.5577776432037354,
0.36178943514823914,
0.506047785282135,
0.3332195281982422,
0.10608729720115662,
0.1571493297815323,
-0.3991667330265045,
0.7190596461296082,
0.13512040674686432,
0.13527093827724457,
0.043963722884655,
-0.035410549491643906,
-0.45048731565475464,
0.2902137041091919,
0.7300307750701904,
0.18471761047840118,
0.6617135405540466,
-0.23067504167556763,
-0.14814002811908722,
0.037862617522478104,
0.129755437374115,
-0.5855127573013306,
-0.18738512694835663,
0.47061610221862793,
-0.4921905994415283,
-0.5194442272186279,
-0.06444784253835678,
-0.5813130140304565,
-0.13840551674365997,
-0.5890287160873413,
0.10317983478307724,
-0.38031724095344543,
-0.09947372227907181,
0.019266609102487564,
0.0619053915143013,
-0.29349449276924133,
0.11312512308359146,
-0.6106986403465271,
0.49870145320892334,
0.5038658380508423,
1.1024532318115234,
-0.01341701578348875,
-0.30663901567459106,
-1.077054738998413,
-0.20062817633152008,
-0.26360833644866943,
0.4052882492542267,
-0.2406245768070221,
0.01276087760925293,
0.21989020705223083,
-0.07137463986873627,
-0.06327736377716064,
-0.3587360680103302,
0.5078241229057312,
-0.6841206550598145,
0.13903704285621643,
-0.16297489404678345,
-0.588347315788269,
-0.164947971701622,
0.44652271270751953,
-0.8985654711723328,
0.9415430426597595,
-0.08028185367584229,
-0.6953808069229126,
0.7791631817817688,
-0.6905781030654907,
-0.44692984223365784,
-0.30533069372177124,
-0.041012026369571686,
-0.6856165528297424,
0.024876095354557037,
0.14713384211063385,
0.5415946245193481,
-0.2560149133205414,
0.43830451369285583,
-0.3593282103538513,
0.09319587051868439,
0.38729190826416016,
-0.28667476773262024,
0.7739645838737488,
0.2756913900375366,
-0.0901903510093689,
0.132435142993927,
-1.1798127889633179,
0.20873570442199707,
-0.15460100769996643,
-0.4713954031467438,
-0.5312350988388062,
0.28823456168174744,
-0.20583240687847137,
0.26413488388061523,
0.023431774228811264,
-0.6061387062072754,
-0.28613030910491943,
-0.288594126701355,
0.5369164347648621,
0.45249125361442566,
0.11457134038209915,
-0.04816999286413193,
-0.43294984102249146,
0.38759368658065796,
-0.07395327091217041,
0.39389580488204956,
-0.09838677942752838,
-0.8252156376838684,
-1.1085785627365112,
-0.1747526377439499,
0.4390772581100464,
0.4225544333457947,
-0.5108692049980164,
0.6743090748786926,
0.14748142659664154,
-0.05667969956994057,
-0.1597115397453308,
0.2386084794998169,
0.7026243805885315,
0.43651333451271057,
0.6694313287734985,
-0.3185622990131378,
-0.8876297473907471,
-0.4822758138179779,
-0.0553894117474556,
-0.2833579480648041,
0.03670695051550865,
-0.03654221072793007,
0.31326234340667725,
0.1830304116010666,
1.1742165088653564,
-0.1528426706790924,
-0.3433690369129181,
-0.21796678006649017,
0.288345068693161,
0.1731778085231781,
0.43814921379089355,
0.6550310254096985,
-0.5740479230880737,
-0.5754953026771545,
0.05692457780241966,
-0.8405497670173645,
-0.163605734705925,
-0.29287540912628174,
-0.08314419537782669,
0.026046771556138992,
0.9360501766204834,
-0.31050819158554077,
0.44454821944236755,
0.21228162944316864,
-0.28097569942474365,
0.38702523708343506,
-0.21462023258209229,
-0.08928927034139633,
-0.22195804119110107,
0.14591731131076813,
0.21244925260543823,
-0.25606435537338257,
-0.6337917447090149,
-0.12990957498550415,
-0.24283431470394135,
0.07432958483695984,
-0.60159832239151,
0.25137653946876526,
-0.14321072399616241,
0.0012396177044138312,
-0.012442988343536854,
-0.14713315665721893,
0.16992510855197906,
0.37336161732673645,
0.02366187609732151,
0.30274367332458496,
0.4321571886539459,
-0.7851016521453857,
0.19459094107151031,
0.08537080883979797,
-0.06252627074718475,
0.5729087591171265,
-1.0347334146499634,
-0.07196230441331863,
-0.07532666623592377,
-0.17452548444271088,
-0.6587044596672058,
-0.0937216579914093,
0.42205390334129333,
-0.4932158589363098,
0.26878297328948975,
-0.41572412848472595,
-0.013183907605707645,
-0.1562107503414154,
-0.006080618128180504,
0.19045734405517578,
0.3651231825351715,
-0.4160003066062927,
0.2798430323600769,
0.0046165320090949535,
0.021626370027661324,
-0.35844114422798157,
-0.8519687056541443,
-0.20873567461967468,
-0.1143806055188179,
-0.6302562952041626,
0.07332324236631393,
0.40392836928367615,
-0.28639382123947144,
-0.026186931878328323,
0.21491709351539612,
-0.4336898922920227,
0.2283702939748764,
0.040931977331638336,
0.08615840971469879,
-0.17967233061790466,
0.10154309868812561,
0.19653834402561188,
-0.4815673828125,
0.21188192069530487,
-0.4542526304721832,
0.5745633840560913,
0.026583898812532425,
-0.32627633213996887,
-0.40360867977142334,
0.18361754715442657,
0.38890132308006287,
-0.349197655916214,
0.8564292788505554,
0.6632896661758423,
-0.4267846941947937,
-0.13424314558506012,
-0.3093011975288391,
0.1445365846157074,
-0.4031946063041687,
0.1411820650100708,
-0.25846636295318604,
-0.24641844630241394,
0.7082945704460144,
0.18378400802612305,
-0.2392115592956543,
0.5249702334403992,
0.4414960443973541,
0.02745612896978855,
0.870384931564331,
0.5247079133987427,
0.01380903273820877,
0.5430354475975037,
-0.3003441393375397,
0.07979734241962433,
-0.6024258136749268,
-0.28638017177581787,
-0.48937323689460754,
-0.11481606215238571,
-0.22939421236515045,
-0.2190425992012024,
0.32832202315330505,
0.3821113407611847,
-0.31077444553375244,
-0.023607192561030388,
-0.4177331328392029,
0.4991206228733063,
0.46517401933670044,
0.16471081972122192,
0.1300514191389084,
-0.008176075294613838,
-0.3686079978942871,
0.036698292940855026,
-0.7765950560569763,
-0.0034945374354720116,
1.1279809474945068,
0.35107702016830444,
0.5054450035095215,
-0.17093993723392487,
0.6209290623664856,
0.6025685667991638,
0.07370848953723907,
-0.8538971543312073,
0.05224107578396797,
-0.052553437650203705,
-0.4659898281097412,
-0.38518446683883667,
-0.5634959936141968,
-1.1544944047927856,
0.0332719050347805,
-0.20165076851844788,
-0.7762594819068909,
0.40397366881370544,
0.46551796793937683,
-0.6316670775413513,
0.1461598426103592,
-0.46764546632766724,
0.8059266209602356,
-0.5986254811286926,
-0.5052260756492615,
0.07197292149066925,
-0.5619731545448303,
0.3846578001976013,
-0.1217971220612526,
0.2078368216753006,
0.15368147194385529,
0.09196839481592178,
0.8189830183982849,
-0.6508609056472778,
1.2025458812713623,
-0.36686497926712036,
0.4066884517669678,
0.4950906038284302,
0.06138927862048149,
0.515278160572052,
-0.4745737612247467,
-0.22365368902683258,
0.1841920167207718,
-0.07132051885128021,
-0.24303820729255676,
-0.4398684799671173,
0.4284784197807312,
-0.7698081135749817,
0.37958279252052307,
-0.5413805246353149,
0.07416432350873947,
-0.1488194763660431,
0.3457661271095276,
0.4330938756465912,
0.5106675624847412,
-0.3539944589138031,
0.15322503447532654,
0.4509907364845276,
-0.19677579402923584,
0.6549564003944397,
0.07469425350427628,
-0.5314990878105164,
-0.7017737627029419,
1.238904356956482,
0.3651682734489441,
0.39017453789711,
0.00007852782437112182,
0.700446605682373,
-0.2922600209712982,
-0.668574869632721,
-0.2344723641872406,
-0.3174966871738434,
-0.8559497594833374,
-0.07711519300937653,
-0.409433513879776,
-0.3786645829677582,
-0.010958906263113022,
-0.11471785604953766,
-0.3208097517490387,
-0.3749103844165802,
-0.38159075379371643,
0.18446214497089386,
0.0365949422121048,
0.746970534324646,
-0.11292529106140137,
0.5963960886001587,
-0.8373641967773438,
0.006554573308676481,
0.24957692623138428,
0.36124441027641296,
0.24396973848342896,
-0.11602707207202911,
-0.5054996609687805,
-0.26324033737182617,
-0.45289140939712524,
-0.5238733291625977,
0.37372469902038574,
0.7552066445350647,
0.9606136083602905,
0.8674712777137756,
0.05912522226572037,
0.32005739212036133,
-0.08227869123220444,
0.3438663184642792,
0.5895450115203857,
-1.0624310970306396,
0.48670998215675354,
-0.16740740835666656,
0.03583333641290665,
0.3380979597568512,
0.7329102754592896,
-0.49417710304260254,
-0.3890342116355896,
-0.5785252451896667,
-0.9115403890609741,
0.1380954086780548,
0.5839817523956299,
-0.4824688732624054,
-0.16835126280784607,
0.14591369032859802,
0.0863196924328804,
0.24388352036476135,
-0.2732793092727661,
-0.02163989655673504,
-0.48032981157302856,
0.021487608551979065,
0.08819524943828583,
-0.08071579784154892,
-0.27900800108909607,
-0.2606032192707062,
0.5001475214958191,
-0.4330002963542938,
0.02870113030076027,
0.19566833972930908,
-0.3359954357147217,
-0.18777666985988617,
-0.010441186837852001,
0.48022744059562683,
0.8612928986549377,
-0.15540991723537445,
0.1074637621641159,
-0.03624655678868294,
-0.14798332750797272,
-0.04870864748954773,
-0.005235825665295124,
-0.4628291428089142,
-0.05821350961923599,
0.6881358623504639,
0.7661774754524231,
0.2515241205692291,
-0.15212690830230713,
0.2925149202346802,
-0.08305108547210693,
0.13028499484062195,
-0.44519495964050293,
0.09584774076938629,
-0.3070395290851593,
0.15533281862735748,
0.24028241634368896,
0.3438524007797241,
0.1704019457101822,
-0.29616373777389526,
0.4946345388889313,
0.2752194404602051,
-0.597911536693573,
-0.30033278465270996,
0.555820882320404,
0.43580684065818787,
-0.3629583418369293,
0.3875570595264435,
-0.4294953942298889,
-0.7653661370277405,
1.0109870433807373,
0.3376065790653229,
1.096410870552063,
0.12076429277658463,
0.04780327156186104,
0.474821001291275,
0.2754255533218384,
-0.08300986140966415,
0.33715754747390747,
-0.13257722556591034,
-0.8104249835014343,
-0.6798745393753052,
-0.938583254814148,
-0.20043042302131653,
0.012608760967850685,
-1.0144107341766357,
0.2241699993610382,
-0.9976452589035034,
-0.5922490954399109,
0.2396748811006546,
-0.35024237632751465,
-0.7496145367622375,
0.4979639947414398,
0.27028077840805054,
0.4765392243862152,
-1.0741708278656006,
0.6276400685310364,
0.3610348105430603,
-0.6412815451622009,
-0.21459005773067474,
-0.2489461451768875,
0.11101774126291275,
-0.6684783697128296,
0.742018461227417,
0.24810132384300232,
0.04431787505745888,
-0.24017013609409332,
-0.30140677094459534,
-0.6607233881950378,
0.5857966542243958,
0.11798937618732452,
-0.7021552920341492,
-0.004782866220921278,
0.10553712397813797,
0.6741048693656921,
-0.33482304215431213,
0.48539331555366516,
0.9987260103225708,
0.5382118821144104,
0.12298078089952469,
-0.8957592844963074,
-0.000763173564337194,
-0.18702562153339386,
-0.14682640135288239,
0.381037175655365,
-0.5032956600189209,
1.0432485342025757,
0.026548609137535095,
0.12273850291967392,
0.09502675384283066,
0.3549564778804779,
-0.13444185256958008,
0.3728818893432617,
0.696768581867218,
0.7393561601638794,
0.7684243321418762,
-0.21583238244056702,
0.9878292083740234,
-0.3257962465286255,
0.61635822057724,
1.1075538396835327,
0.26016929745674133,
0.745642364025116,
0.49923646450042725,
-0.4691314101219177,
0.11086361855268478,
0.6094266772270203,
-0.10563401132822037,
0.46230557560920715,
0.20990510284900665,
-0.08793101459741592,
-0.6749218106269836,
-0.046906884759664536,
-0.5010431408882141,
0.4775225818157196,
0.32417595386505127,
-0.6923388242721558,
-0.42866697907447815,
-0.038957878947257996,
-0.0806308463215828,
-0.19388878345489502,
-0.19828860461711884,
0.4813287854194641,
0.06378617882728577,
-0.6343051791191101,
0.666033923625946,
-0.19748297333717346,
0.32871609926223755,
-0.6343019604682922,
0.02182035706937313,
0.131697416305542,
0.2733146548271179,
-0.4574524164199829,
-0.5040517449378967,
0.6070480346679688,
-0.2708503305912018,
-0.2931082844734192,
-0.22717376053333282,
0.7023066282272339,
-0.20823164284229279,
-0.7924720048904419,
0.6945579648017883,
0.5862773656845093,
0.1813952475786209,
-0.06064165383577347,
-0.6054106950759888,
0.3512569069862366,
-0.1708105355501175,
-0.22161974012851715,
0.2851736843585968,
0.2160937339067459,
-0.02404036745429039,
0.619284451007843,
1.1669777631759644,
0.4306640923023224,
0.40852051973342896,
0.1395445019006729,
0.5824141502380371,
-0.4089452028274536,
-0.901986300945282,
-0.827800989151001,
0.5923483967781067,
-0.14098452031612396,
-0.6934353113174438,
0.3577135503292084,
0.275594562292099,
0.8194243907928467,
0.3434774875640869,
1.0132371187210083,
-0.25376999378204346,
0.32389748096466064,
-0.7944833040237427,
0.8661962747573853,
-0.5040588974952698,
0.2633247375488281,
0.07030440121889114,
-0.6506633758544922,
-0.3819161057472229,
0.6682493090629578,
-0.37586382031440735,
0.0387246236205101,
0.656900942325592,
0.17873600125312805,
-0.3561016619205475,
-0.03150608390569687,
0.500547468662262,
0.11587440222501755,
0.5878757238388062,
0.3212088346481323,
0.9546067714691162,
-0.2550590932369232,
0.49593061208724976,
-0.5606347918510437,
-0.2612362205982208,
-0.33890706300735474,
-1.0365184545516968,
-1.1331552267074585,
-0.1248953714966774,
-0.361491858959198,
-0.5289642214775085,
0.08978190273046494,
0.8890383839607239,
0.8804506063461304,
-1.1984564065933228,
-0.020921887829899788,
-0.4613902270793915,
-0.08517425507307053,
-0.38076314330101013,
-0.1311766356229782,
0.3111661672592163,
-0.8745406866073608,
-0.32502782344818115,
0.3875153064727783,
0.02065892145037651,
-0.04030651971697807,
-0.6641583442687988,
-0.3381272852420807,
-0.2925700545310974,
-0.025987325236201286,
0.6371282339096069,
0.7969551682472229,
-0.4938478469848633,
-0.26626724004745483,
-0.34844815731048584,
0.2582471966743469,
0.0771254152059555,
1.0010430812835693,
-0.8148276805877686,
0.7584282159805298,
0.623619019985199,
0.7414605021476746,
0.6391466856002808,
-0.23869356513023376,
0.6426537036895752,
-0.6460002064704895,
0.21893830597400665,
0.21242330968379974,
0.570814847946167,
0.2600295841693878,
-0.3499646484851837,
0.40894898772239685,
0.4600858986377716,
-0.4473057687282562,
-0.6047786474227905,
0.13341200351715088,
-0.5608394742012024,
0.1631474792957306,
0.6533481478691101,
-0.6285228729248047,
-0.12472297996282578,
-0.5596233606338501,
0.2356298416852951,
0.37994521856307983,
-0.4485817551612854,
0.8787573575973511,
0.7565006017684937,
-0.4997729957103729,
0.15499137341976166,
-0.4890128970146179,
0.424897164106369,
0.4535977840423584,
-0.7840591669082642,
-0.5513179898262024,
0.21885034441947937,
0.12448572367429733,
0.5333423614501953,
0.14518515765666962,
0.3297193944454193,
0.3945346176624298,
0.08033957332372665,
-0.16246384382247925,
-0.4132227599620819,
-0.7914635539054871,
-0.30358532071113586,
0.39642414450645447,
-0.060968995094299316,
-0.5423169136047363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02503v1 | GeReA: Question-Aware Prompt Captions for Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering | 2024-02-04T14:28:23 | 2024-02-04T14:28:23 | Ziyu Ma, Shutao Li, Bin Sun, Jianfei Cai, Zuxiang Long, Fuyan Ma | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Knowledge-based visual question answering (VQA) requires world knowledge
beyond the image for accurate answer. Recently, instead of extra knowledge
bases, a large language model (LLM) like GPT-3 is activated as an implicit
knowledge engine to jointly acquire and reason the necessary knowledge for
answering by converting images into textual information (e.g., captions and
answer candidates). However, such conversion may introduce irrelevant
information, which causes the LLM to misinterpret images and ignore visual
details crucial for accurate knowledge. We argue that multimodal large language
model (MLLM) is a better implicit knowledge engine than the LLM for its
superior capability of visual understanding. Despite this, how to activate the
capacity of MLLM as the implicit knowledge engine has not been explored yet.
Therefore, we propose GeReA, a generate-reason framework that prompts a MLLM
like InstructBLIP with question relevant vision and language information to
generate knowledge-relevant descriptions and reasons those descriptions for
knowledge-based VQA. Specifically, the question-relevant image regions and
question-specific manual prompts are encoded in the MLLM to generate the
knowledge relevant descriptions, referred to as question-aware prompt captions.
After that, the question-aware prompt captions, image-question pair, and
similar samples are sent into the multi-modal reasoning model to learn a joint
knowledge-image-question representation for answer prediction. GeReA unlocks
the use of MLLM as the implicit knowledge engine, surpassing all previous
state-of-the-art methods on OK-VQA and A-OKVQA datasets, with test accuracies
of 66.5% and 63.3% respectively. Our code will be released at
https://github.com/Upper9527/GeReA. | [
-0.6424573063850403,
-0.8813275098800659,
0.9440714120864868,
-0.15065433084964752,
-0.14791923761367798,
-0.30573976039886475,
0.1020088717341423,
-0.49914678931236267,
-0.38824349641799927,
0.4038775563240051,
-0.7271052002906799,
-0.28015437722206116,
-0.3085904121398926,
0.010804402641952038,
-0.1619013547897339,
0.8115856647491455,
-0.11108466237783432,
0.174429789185524,
-0.7906376719474792,
-0.14224350452423096,
-0.5382492542266846,
-0.3891236484050751,
-0.6533956527709961,
0.023678092285990715,
0.6009417772293091,
0.37866851687431335,
0.4324313700199127,
0.17849451303482056,
0.2803480923175812,
0.29326698184013367,
0.16077770292758942,
0.40171927213668823,
-0.22774280607700348,
0.24078820645809174,
-0.04389918968081474,
-0.39756786823272705,
-0.06427980959415436,
-0.20554041862487793,
0.3016340434551239,
0.1497407853603363,
0.08508644253015518,
0.27331116795539856,
0.09023690223693848,
0.37837204337120056,
-0.5570244193077087,
0.2832344174385071,
-0.7120490670204163,
-0.04895992949604988,
0.15550924837589264,
-0.3928309679031372,
-0.3473069965839386,
-0.27333196997642517,
0.12224212288856506,
-1.047486662864685,
0.3336023688316345,
0.32347601652145386,
1.0646287202835083,
0.4135861396789551,
-0.38345736265182495,
-0.2771804928779602,
-0.35949593782424927,
0.510017454624176,
-0.37282589077949524,
0.07313758134841919,
0.1272755265235901,
0.827632486820221,
0.06111670285463333,
-0.7573839426040649,
-0.9001082181930542,
-0.10597731173038483,
-0.04536227136850357,
0.38343313336372375,
-0.33784300088882446,
0.14908728003501892,
0.4452774226665497,
0.2527950406074524,
-0.7314218282699585,
-0.3153553009033203,
-0.3376012444496155,
-0.4328145980834961,
0.1859375685453415,
0.09761055558919907,
0.6437284350395203,
-0.2993992567062378,
-0.5209314227104187,
0.021903473883867264,
-0.5879901051521301,
0.37241172790527344,
0.0598413310945034,
-0.13524813950061798,
0.05900879576802254,
0.6590880751609802,
-0.32322290539741516,
0.7927181720733643,
-0.04395255073904991,
0.09123202413320541,
0.07678145915269852,
-0.1923360973596573,
-0.4209986925125122,
-0.22519955039024353,
0.5954138040542603,
0.7080133557319641,
0.43039488792419434,
0.06716151535511017,
-0.004949985072016716,
0.28747111558914185,
-0.01717565394937992,
-0.909148097038269,
-0.16660307347774506,
0.2511914372444153,
-0.10794860869646072,
-0.16944965720176697,
0.06546729803085327,
-0.7787336111068726,
-0.4329465925693512,
-0.30343273282051086,
0.5578175187110901,
-0.41595458984375,
0.05288839340209961,
0.13027049601078033,
-0.2293766885995865,
0.48230302333831787,
0.9028163552284241,
-0.5399999022483826,
-0.18064910173416138,
0.2679584324359894,
0.374385267496109,
0.2339549958705902,
-0.3026164770126343,
-1.0524109601974487,
0.23236650228500366,
-0.23055434226989746,
0.7935073375701904,
-0.4853323698043823,
-0.1609227955341339,
0.08811013400554657,
0.25590014457702637,
-0.046207625418901443,
-0.24403585493564606,
0.3974372446537018,
-0.7473569512367249,
0.7330909967422485,
-0.6635258793830872,
-0.4807376563549042,
-0.6642752885818481,
0.4583669900894165,
-0.5941382050514221,
0.6716135740280151,
-0.1359720081090927,
-0.7983927130699158,
0.35750243067741394,
-0.6063290238380432,
-0.22123898565769196,
0.13651596009731293,
-0.5012590885162354,
-0.00003986064621130936,
-0.07153403013944626,
0.9536563754081726,
0.5199781656265259,
-0.4241602420806885,
0.32468244433403015,
-0.17970126867294312,
-0.20612451434135437,
0.2536047697067261,
-0.6286328434944153,
0.5136507749557495,
0.09815289825201035,
-0.30916428565979004,
0.207843616604805,
-0.40920141339302063,
0.2067921757698059,
0.22620795667171478,
-0.12558095157146454,
-0.12635627388954163,
-0.22900044918060303,
-0.21018348634243011,
0.3538966178894043,
0.2137448489665985,
-0.4585573673248291,
-0.045955486595630646,
0.0015291885938495398,
0.2793906331062317,
0.7718315720558167,
0.22857342660427094,
0.3831655979156494,
-0.17043793201446533,
0.8919461965560913,
0.1905117928981781,
0.40553906559944153,
-0.448497474193573,
-0.7914369106292725,
-0.7808208465576172,
-0.10946884006261826,
-0.009993820451200008,
0.7026414275169373,
-1.4579335451126099,
-0.48427870869636536,
0.05303632840514183,
-0.2604539096355438,
-0.6035781502723694,
0.06348016858100891,
0.4307933449745178,
0.9752790331840515,
0.5680907964706421,
0.1997808963060379,
-0.35301658511161804,
-0.9162235856056213,
0.022641275078058243,
-0.3020501732826233,
-0.005244822707027197,
0.5645666718482971,
0.4669542610645294,
-0.0550861619412899,
0.7699999213218689,
-0.48865413665771484,
-0.14492309093475342,
-0.20574460923671722,
0.07270532846450806,
0.13065116107463837,
0.2255275696516037,
0.6116728782653809,
-1.0203946828842163,
-0.2606452703475952,
0.2368020862340927,
-1.180675983428955,
-0.06191755831241608,
-0.05022681504487991,
-0.25960445404052734,
0.26099592447280884,
0.5062770247459412,
-0.7165778279304504,
0.19491416215896606,
0.5368809103965759,
-0.4147881269454956,
0.6770815849304199,
-0.20511440932750702,
0.37600475549697876,
-1.0230709314346313,
0.18250572681427002,
0.06503184884786606,
-0.24069608747959137,
-0.3385747969150543,
0.2556096315383911,
0.10874493420124054,
-0.30569472908973694,
-0.5178197026252747,
0.8226393461227417,
-0.5342611074447632,
0.07694105803966522,
0.13292339444160461,
0.050284892320632935,
0.36344292759895325,
0.6879054307937622,
-0.00503658689558506,
1.006301999092102,
0.8188146352767944,
-0.48126134276390076,
0.46305301785469055,
0.2851400375366211,
-0.4030783772468567,
0.5715522170066833,
-0.883807897567749,
0.0178934708237648,
-0.5967323184013367,
-0.014146211557090282,
-1.1026116609573364,
-0.6095426678657532,
0.3350246548652649,
-0.4565761685371399,
0.16026881337165833,
-0.2724529802799225,
-0.33939677476882935,
-0.5268224477767944,
0.06038372591137886,
0.23829686641693115,
0.5438147187232971,
-0.462275892496109,
0.8682899475097656,
0.11062374711036682,
-0.4248241186141968,
-0.7515816688537598,
-0.6148406267166138,
-0.1430848240852356,
-0.14403106272220612,
-0.751710057258606,
-0.15644444525241852,
-0.3333251476287842,
-0.09291193634271622,
0.21903559565544128,
0.06337816268205643,
0.012225164100527763,
-0.07610586285591125,
0.3073664605617523,
0.6178314089775085,
-0.24410507082939148,
0.305909663438797,
0.12727397680282593,
-0.08688709139823914,
0.22031483054161072,
-0.3207596242427826,
0.25127947330474854,
-0.4395669996738434,
-0.5077865123748779,
-0.13754718005657196,
0.5739193558692932,
0.8214753270149231,
-0.446254163980484,
0.2934992015361786,
0.7691702246665955,
-0.19897623360157013,
-0.07643471658229828,
-0.5999583601951599,
-0.09110414981842041,
-0.4033546447753906,
0.355884313583374,
-0.36642155051231384,
-1.1753722429275513,
0.4763997793197632,
0.1804923713207245,
-0.01301204040646553,
0.3415606617927551,
0.46359169483184814,
-0.3965584337711334,
1.0449286699295044,
0.37988489866256714,
0.11885492503643036,
0.14604532718658447,
-0.09581641107797623,
-0.26687806844711304,
-0.6328933835029602,
-0.27795469760894775,
-0.19806213676929474,
-0.024404285475611687,
-0.03350924700498581,
-0.6249591112136841,
0.6387730836868286,
0.15189491212368011,
-0.3294265568256378,
-0.29249173402786255,
-0.5482210516929626,
0.5341652035713196,
0.6571215987205505,
0.06704837828874588,
0.3580029606819153,
0.0789928063750267,
-0.26425546407699585,
-0.0598793625831604,
-0.7801430225372314,
-0.328133225440979,
0.8492521047592163,
0.09185363352298737,
0.5981523990631104,
-0.10846051573753357,
0.158201664686203,
0.16839760541915894,
0.29285261034965515,
-0.5461165904998779,
0.633797824382782,
0.21341997385025024,
-0.6653249263763428,
-0.3666142523288727,
-0.31395575404167175,
-0.4427691102027893,
0.3716946840286255,
-0.19487197697162628,
-0.32233861088752747,
0.0381576269865036,
0.43087559938430786,
-0.37929612398147583,
0.15172061324119568,
-0.7028518319129944,
0.9853600263595581,
-0.31419721245765686,
-0.30353227257728577,
0.18999610841274261,
-0.6663649678230286,
0.42504948377609253,
0.26835060119628906,
0.07140571624040604,
0.05206281319260597,
0.0738850012421608,
0.32129567861557007,
-0.27929702401161194,
0.7097457647323608,
-0.5822523832321167,
-0.08607560396194458,
0.45178714394569397,
-0.010523234494030476,
0.47410091757774353,
0.21544967591762543,
0.3577561676502228,
-0.23098325729370117,
-0.19550761580467224,
-0.2625085413455963,
-0.9005027413368225,
0.39921095967292786,
-0.49849066138267517,
-0.8352060317993164,
-0.1057514175772667,
-0.5536073446273804,
-0.3838372826576233,
0.07190559804439545,
0.5974706411361694,
0.7361933588981628,
0.0426679365336895,
0.031215161085128784,
0.9874017238616943,
-0.4214160144329071,
0.2805821895599365,
0.3539826571941376,
-0.6374692916870117,
-0.5082191824913025,
0.8117770552635193,
-0.11298523098230362,
0.2286260426044464,
0.3910580575466156,
-0.03966297581791878,
-0.4441269338130951,
-0.2539695203304291,
-0.9824486374855042,
0.03476184606552124,
-0.9671627879142761,
-0.2602689862251282,
-0.7029560208320618,
-0.07825250923633575,
0.0774451196193695,
-0.20370014011859894,
0.3084360361099243,
-0.15376468002796173,
-0.15398070216178894,
-0.11769387125968933,
0.45441383123397827,
0.3558950424194336,
0.21363131701946259,
-0.11403647810220718,
-0.6481399536132812,
0.5913204550743103,
1.1013606786727905,
-0.1363304704427719,
-0.013056633993983269,
-0.3307306170463562,
0.055402301251888275,
0.17998194694519043,
-0.07661028206348419,
-0.8906532526016235,
0.03958464413881302,
0.06856083124876022,
0.6300811171531677,
0.280912846326828,
-0.08150749653577805,
0.6366613507270813,
-0.5099997520446777,
0.842823326587677,
0.32826554775238037,
-0.716850996017456,
0.7589468955993652,
-0.4903270900249481,
0.5288428068161011,
0.47680044174194336,
0.22019413113594055,
-0.501743495464325,
-0.46167126297950745,
-0.41404175758361816,
-0.5890675783157349,
0.28156086802482605,
0.006982698105275631,
0.14576607942581177,
0.05680681765079498,
-0.07402503490447998,
0.14952759444713593,
0.3910296559333801,
-0.6920319199562073,
-0.014004964381456375,
-0.3018568158149719,
-0.043978650122880936,
0.12164061516523361,
-0.2774316668510437,
-0.2712555229663849,
-0.3496462404727936,
0.7213705778121948,
-0.5723356604576111,
0.3502483367919922,
0.545451819896698,
-0.2592269480228424,
0.011209453456103802,
0.44680213928222656,
0.5209506750106812,
0.6919366717338562,
0.12432350218296051,
0.0379180870950222,
0.12771306931972504,
-0.22160525619983673,
0.02191418968141079,
0.2907480299472809,
-0.406381756067276,
0.13238123059272766,
0.25157782435417175,
1.039219856262207,
-0.03595399484038353,
-0.7478539347648621,
0.658556342124939,
-0.23327334225177765,
-0.3837425708770752,
-0.16270895302295685,
0.08718527853488922,
0.16207484900951385,
0.42769506573677063,
0.4409151077270508,
0.40130168199539185,
0.181099072098732,
-0.3488837778568268,
0.10625028610229492,
0.45549726486206055,
-0.5301439762115479,
-0.051564715802669525,
1.0353795289993286,
0.22390230000019073,
0.5286754369735718,
0.48983490467071533,
-0.09930243343114853,
-0.5520498752593994,
0.6233358979225159,
0.1778050810098648,
0.66709965467453,
0.13775897026062012,
0.6789613366127014,
0.3638753294944763,
0.33139753341674805,
0.19258278608322144,
0.7375035881996155,
-0.15184976160526276,
-0.813003659248352,
-0.6842050552368164,
-0.3838992416858673,
-0.29670023918151855,
0.11265303939580917,
-0.6766601204872131,
-0.11305364966392517,
-0.2962568402290344,
0.049111127853393555,
-0.20742729306221008,
-0.4290938973426819,
-0.9640703201293945,
0.3543027639389038,
0.32395151257514954,
0.8888490200042725,
-0.7696086168289185,
0.6103827357292175,
0.9221441149711609,
-0.6241729259490967,
-1.0313520431518555,
-0.13446636497974396,
-0.15304312109947205,
-0.8756381273269653,
0.46374180912971497,
0.34714922308921814,
-0.04842176288366318,
0.13466934859752655,
-0.980003833770752,
-0.3960492014884949,
1.2288163900375366,
0.683981716632843,
-0.5088129043579102,
-0.1140306293964386,
-0.19447170197963715,
0.2410922348499298,
-0.23089368641376495,
0.1266842484474182,
-0.10971016436815262,
0.7500684857368469,
0.3368504047393799,
-0.47619253396987915,
0.13965755701065063,
-0.6169621348381042,
0.04188687726855278,
-0.01042878907173872,
-0.23837162554264069,
0.7352163195610046,
-0.6852310299873352,
-0.3266659677028656,
0.1177225187420845,
0.7280828356742859,
0.4477863907814026,
0.39181628823280334,
0.4599992334842682,
0.5747338533401489,
0.9616642594337463,
-0.20535172522068024,
1.3495045900344849,
0.020396990701556206,
0.1396588683128357,
1.1211682558059692,
-0.04597143828868866,
0.5814727544784546,
0.6447082161903381,
0.15750408172607422,
0.5433511734008789,
0.33462005853652954,
0.02410707250237465,
0.5062902569770813,
-0.20419150590896606,
-0.30524104833602905,
-0.7142643928527832,
-0.16767698526382446,
-0.5492091774940491,
0.15282495319843292,
0.08413774520158768,
-0.3627893924713135,
-0.22624105215072632,
0.28668516874313354,
-0.13557565212249756,
0.008364773355424404,
-0.464093953371048,
0.7165049314498901,
-0.02873879112303257,
-0.7174307703971863,
0.5265234112739563,
-0.5329386591911316,
0.25150617957115173,
-0.6946869492530823,
-0.27308496832847595,
-0.140029639005661,
-0.26860663294792175,
0.029645562171936035,
-1.0688360929489136,
-0.34337395429611206,
0.09891016036272049,
-0.45790237188339233,
0.012830531224608421,
0.8624511361122131,
-0.6488466858863831,
-0.6074424982070923,
-0.035380590707063675,
0.9595276713371277,
-0.1499866247177124,
-0.3251465857028961,
-0.5796175003051758,
-0.31378939747810364,
0.22386105358600616,
-0.23063728213310242,
-0.023331169039011,
0.8301647305488586,
-0.030447736382484436,
0.8015541434288025,
0.673210620880127,
-0.19136612117290497,
0.021175919100642204,
0.19767135381698608,
0.9366251230239868,
-0.26039743423461914,
-0.5428354144096375,
-0.586361289024353,
1.0486091375350952,
-0.19351138174533844,
-0.2925717532634735,
0.6477911472320557,
0.11331037431955338,
0.6031010746955872,
-0.45645415782928467,
1.145463228225708,
-0.1706252545118332,
0.15992935001850128,
-0.8750907182693481,
0.6283800601959229,
-0.8495113849639893,
-0.14100486040115356,
-0.33155351877212524,
-0.7601442933082581,
-0.14540666341781616,
0.2786329388618469,
-0.36151036620140076,
-0.11793182790279388,
0.6087945103645325,
0.8949909210205078,
0.07026980072259903,
0.16982193291187286,
0.49599167704582214,
0.03846428170800209,
0.12370031327009201,
0.7977501749992371,
1.167909860610962,
-0.3245087265968323,
0.6935217976570129,
0.08519921451807022,
-0.07799877971410751,
-0.012328511103987694,
-0.7939344644546509,
-0.7920822501182556,
-0.769595205783844,
-0.06566937267780304,
-0.15474994480609894,
0.09573125839233398,
0.36999017000198364,
0.45374345779418945,
-0.6592546701431274,
0.404010534286499,
-0.1463417112827301,
-0.054847296327352524,
-0.22914254665374756,
-0.266975075006485,
0.20338508486747742,
-0.3170466721057892,
-0.5335981845855713,
0.13124290108680725,
0.3265056014060974,
0.18956510722637177,
-0.24025672674179077,
-0.28071507811546326,
0.1778382509946823,
-0.21559463441371918,
0.6896724700927734,
0.3075573742389679,
-0.8139098286628723,
-0.4566586911678314,
0.18162809312343597,
-0.12449812889099121,
-0.12637507915496826,
0.5212185978889465,
-0.8754491209983826,
0.7401586174964905,
0.4167857766151428,
0.7704141139984131,
0.2630608081817627,
0.14185920357704163,
0.7044618129730225,
-0.5466387867927551,
0.02719452977180481,
0.18920062482357025,
0.5933590531349182,
0.38435131311416626,
-0.3999195992946625,
0.4743212163448334,
0.14379394054412842,
-0.5667191743850708,
-0.3394826352596283,
0.36498069763183594,
-1.1004884243011475,
-0.2857299745082855,
1.2127121686935425,
-0.11473046243190765,
-0.3043692708015442,
0.08291161805391312,
-0.7547692656517029,
-0.00015184321091510355,
-0.3584056496620178,
0.30244144797325134,
0.739533543586731,
0.23000873625278473,
-0.5478339195251465,
-0.8627617955207825,
0.5153738260269165,
0.41586217284202576,
-1.024367332458496,
-0.08051776885986328,
1.021207332611084,
0.05608510971069336,
0.0639057382941246,
0.5300153493881226,
-0.04077702388167381,
0.7648426294326782,
-0.25111040472984314,
0.14801087975502014,
-0.5734794735908508,
-0.5944745540618896,
-0.10052294284105301,
0.41825366020202637,
-0.051126886159181595,
-0.32937660813331604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05123v1 | A Survey on Data Selection for LLM Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-04T13:32:01 | 2024-02-04T13:32:01 | Jiahao Wang, Bolin Zhang, Qianlong Du, Jiajun Zhang, Dianhui Chu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is a vital step of training large language models (LLM),
so how to enhance the effect of instruction tuning has received increased
attention. Existing works indicate that the quality of the dataset is more
crucial than the quantity during instruction tuning of LLM. Therefore, recently
a lot of studies focus on exploring the methods of selecting high-quality
subset from instruction datasets, aiming to reduce training costs and enhance
the instruction-following capabilities of LLMs. This paper presents a
comprehensive survey on data selection for LLM instruction tuning. Firstly, we
introduce the wildly used instruction datasets. Then, we propose a new taxonomy
of the data selection methods and provide a detailed introduction of recent
advances,and the evaluation strategies and results of data selection methods
are also elaborated in detail. Finally, we emphasize the open challenges and
present new frontiers of this task. | [
-0.5963245034217834,
-0.6616259813308716,
0.32553550601005554,
-0.20621663331985474,
-0.28193533420562744,
0.1395624577999115,
-0.4339269995689392,
-0.1466296911239624,
-0.06981159001588821,
0.7021409273147583,
-0.695996105670929,
-0.7938417792320251,
-0.5512035489082336,
0.015883460640907288,
-0.37469393014907837,
0.8461013436317444,
-0.028393203392624855,
0.3776121735572815,
-0.38799160718917847,
0.12428458780050278,
-0.5538829565048218,
-0.299638032913208,
-0.6025255918502808,
-0.21434129774570465,
0.3077000379562378,
0.6831592321395874,
0.33536115288734436,
1.0698963403701782,
0.6603862047195435,
0.23363511264324188,
-0.07643390446901321,
0.5774462819099426,
-0.6380147337913513,
0.30823397636413574,
0.20467118918895721,
-0.7345203161239624,
-0.36823636293411255,
0.14693795144557953,
0.8383216857910156,
0.8078940510749817,
-0.04476567730307579,
0.41198259592056274,
0.020886672660708427,
0.8908429741859436,
-0.8096805214881897,
0.05695012956857681,
-0.6388956308364868,
0.10244472324848175,
-0.4757465124130249,
-0.20160147547721863,
-0.5414761304855347,
-0.7748420238494873,
-0.12051858752965927,
-0.3445124328136444,
0.40399569272994995,
0.32488706707954407,
0.40481653809547424,
0.33663636445999146,
-0.3588772714138031,
-0.33623963594436646,
-0.7736730575561523,
0.9277135133743286,
-0.6163582801818848,
0.6428031325340271,
0.5259345173835754,
0.2236071228981018,
-0.116867795586586,
-0.32951679825782776,
0.04731271415948868,
-0.17958304286003113,
0.30673474073410034,
0.10445788502693176,
0.09080158174037933,
0.12074970453977585,
0.31122055649757385,
0.7156559228897095,
-0.5306108593940735,
0.5283309817314148,
-0.3277433514595032,
-0.07300762087106705,
0.7024927139282227,
0.34011557698249817,
-0.04656403139233589,
0.29109179973602295,
-0.019728118553757668,
-0.3062257766723633,
-1.0902527570724487,
-0.16395805776119232,
0.6104657053947449,
0.10342379659414291,
0.08518875390291214,
0.3991625905036926,
-0.3215767741203308,
1.236534833908081,
-0.1489635854959488,
-0.14677028357982635,
0.10430273413658142,
-0.2806772291660309,
-0.11755000799894333,
-0.04354587197303772,
0.48557940125465393,
0.35883674025535583,
0.28882333636283875,
-0.17040951550006866,
-0.29805248975753784,
-0.4282108247280121,
0.047777097672224045,
-0.6058658361434937,
-0.15374056994915009,
-0.006112013012170792,
-0.31933629512786865,
-0.04547895863652229,
0.14923886954784393,
-0.9822598099708557,
-0.13976402580738068,
-0.5778533816337585,
-0.2295122891664505,
-0.19251561164855957,
0.029027191922068596,
0.11595664918422699,
0.17697201669216156,
0.40014874935150146,
0.2331598997116089,
-1.278343915939331,
0.22712445259094238,
0.7807338237762451,
0.5361239910125732,
-0.43432867527008057,
-0.20707081258296967,
-0.648168683052063,
-0.10286454856395721,
-0.7358922958374023,
0.9188475608825684,
-0.9418017268180847,
-0.5912613868713379,
0.1503121703863144,
-0.08451281487941742,
-0.2037838101387024,
-0.7530747056007385,
0.471487432718277,
-0.7634835839271545,
0.055096425116062164,
-0.30861812829971313,
-0.8270493149757385,
-0.08997146040201187,
-0.03602134436368942,
-0.851439356803894,
1.0549921989440918,
0.23881040513515472,
-0.4992453455924988,
0.4754768908023834,
-0.11407510191202164,
-0.5343917012214661,
-0.10648146271705627,
-0.0848127007484436,
-0.5331243872642517,
0.3071233630180359,
0.4064957797527313,
0.4577717185020447,
-0.4817918837070465,
0.019060038030147552,
-0.15642715990543365,
-0.659870982170105,
0.14201602339744568,
-0.5103664994239807,
0.4612114429473877,
0.2558974623680115,
-0.0015698058996349573,
-0.12859037518501282,
-0.7238573431968689,
0.2963586747646332,
-0.23718129098415375,
-0.5457972288131714,
-0.16698741912841797,
0.17575405538082123,
-0.3993085026741028,
-0.12552744150161743,
0.10615383833646774,
-0.2624705731868744,
0.3971932828426361,
-0.3504787087440491,
0.11364611238241196,
0.8714186549186707,
0.17318783700466156,
0.3024457097053528,
-0.3673311471939087,
0.8082401752471924,
-0.30154553055763245,
0.33983302116394043,
-0.012137165293097496,
-0.2589440643787384,
-0.8993772864341736,
-0.04570199176669121,
0.678546667098999,
0.48499083518981934,
-0.6926604509353638,
0.5619882345199585,
-0.09990483522415161,
-0.4654902219772339,
-0.9669739603996277,
0.37734052538871765,
0.43112796545028687,
0.2713841497898102,
0.2697851359844208,
0.18805399537086487,
-0.5206215977668762,
-0.7060562372207642,
0.01807452365756035,
0.11469555646181107,
0.13058435916900635,
0.46322792768478394,
0.072687529027462,
0.20300719141960144,
0.6314826607704163,
-0.7381845116615295,
0.24015089869499207,
-0.3971993625164032,
-0.24359983205795288,
0.25715547800064087,
0.21425974369049072,
0.3983316421508789,
-0.3648058772087097,
-0.43557965755462646,
-0.06420708447694778,
-0.38511669635772705,
-0.0887480154633522,
0.041260071098804474,
-0.28464195132255554,
0.23863619565963745,
0.5504890084266663,
-0.18904554843902588,
0.08212791383266449,
0.6326594948768616,
0.1265931874513626,
0.3024853467941284,
-0.12791284918785095,
0.30298879742622375,
-0.836258590221405,
-0.2310618907213211,
0.02863270975649357,
-0.07370640337467194,
-0.4099583923816681,
-0.07107452303171158,
0.26289406418800354,
0.17993707954883575,
-0.31265515089035034,
0.296056866645813,
-0.8118672370910645,
-0.130567729473114,
-0.22921276092529297,
-0.040374141186475754,
-0.28224366903305054,
0.21101096272468567,
-0.060007642954587936,
0.8850945830345154,
0.8216229677200317,
-0.7386799454689026,
0.6684473156929016,
0.3513090908527374,
-0.8817524909973145,
0.09802675247192383,
-0.3091566860675812,
0.40180718898773193,
-0.1382959485054016,
-0.0529230535030365,
-0.7833424210548401,
-0.13759568333625793,
0.08262689411640167,
-0.03445569798350334,
0.6684920191764832,
-0.39691659808158875,
-0.5583205223083496,
-0.32955658435821533,
-0.2843873202800751,
0.08248195052146912,
0.5690396428108215,
-0.6195122599601746,
-0.10865222662687302,
0.3285773694515228,
-0.12071080505847931,
-0.5949448347091675,
-0.3879609704017639,
-0.24367578327655792,
-0.2135067731142044,
-0.1472945511341095,
0.12327777594327927,
-0.11834966391324997,
-0.16666212677955627,
-0.3216644525527954,
-0.2922566533088684,
0.1920533925294876,
0.0473628006875515,
-0.18881317973136902,
0.5440543293952942,
-0.32063403725624084,
0.09704958647489548,
0.2193460613489151,
-0.15848807990550995,
-0.0023470388259738684,
-0.0779983177781105,
0.5149187445640564,
0.3875467777252197,
-0.5683329701423645,
-0.2310248762369156,
0.13379250466823578,
-0.013179116882383823,
-0.39949584007263184,
0.37223389744758606,
0.4109351634979248,
0.150798961520195,
-0.5438849925994873,
-0.647151529788971,
-0.2840188443660736,
-0.4652687609195709,
0.5143631100654602,
0.15007615089416504,
-0.8310503363609314,
0.02721637859940529,
-0.2839156985282898,
0.19405436515808105,
-0.012608669698238373,
0.464114248752594,
-0.0846291035413742,
0.9682690501213074,
0.44871342182159424,
-0.49739304184913635,
0.7141947746276855,
-0.30287644267082214,
0.008578894659876823,
-0.9031545519828796,
-0.07953318953514099,
-0.7529261112213135,
-0.36092472076416016,
-0.692120373249054,
-0.28155234456062317,
0.33451882004737854,
-0.16404207050800323,
0.07473944872617722,
-0.10078609734773636,
-0.5410306453704834,
0.7701555490493774,
0.5230649709701538,
0.1650429666042328,
0.16805841028690338,
0.20350834727287292,
0.3246230185031891,
0.10821932554244995,
-0.5271289348602295,
-0.48341432213783264,
1.3252787590026855,
0.12645193934440613,
1.0558196306228638,
-0.19094586372375488,
0.6065292954444885,
0.04384347051382065,
0.041064370423555374,
-0.7757963538169861,
0.6705910563468933,
-0.49799153208732605,
-0.5354670882225037,
-0.34328407049179077,
-0.5966103076934814,
-1.0370023250579834,
-0.047828562557697296,
-0.08551914244890213,
-0.5338340997695923,
-0.14087232947349548,
0.11696653813123703,
-0.2444080412387848,
0.26318228244781494,
-0.5401797890663147,
0.46302151679992676,
-0.2819175124168396,
-0.048474229872226715,
-0.19780558347702026,
-0.4475961923599243,
0.23597249388694763,
0.0423179529607296,
-0.049293119460344315,
-0.1420232653617859,
-0.04165802150964737,
0.8764644265174866,
-0.09853927046060562,
0.5730463266372681,
-0.2050030678510666,
-0.24578671157360077,
0.2645086646080017,
-0.17120003700256348,
0.4891326129436493,
-0.0015351424226537347,
-0.29329273104667664,
0.01594274677336216,
-0.16857996582984924,
-0.16339802742004395,
-0.5820995569229126,
0.7291829586029053,
-0.6899794340133667,
-0.6364147663116455,
0.043160248547792435,
-0.43833011388778687,
-0.7095050811767578,
-0.0845484584569931,
0.28203698992729187,
0.5598934292793274,
-0.07158621400594711,
0.4041464626789093,
1.110046625137329,
-0.1432064026594162,
0.375331312417984,
0.34352222084999084,
-0.04245574399828911,
-0.4900329113006592,
1.1658958196640015,
0.3314321041107178,
0.4789540469646454,
0.4824841022491455,
-0.028403645381331444,
-0.20924092829227448,
-1.0449485778808594,
-0.46535971760749817,
0.05261779576539993,
-0.5670086145401001,
-0.45306557416915894,
-0.11807836592197418,
-0.38880684971809387,
-0.25011304020881653,
0.10861611366271973,
-0.3777802884578705,
-0.37503156065940857,
-0.4889346659183502,
-0.15573936700820923,
0.4030952751636505,
0.682930588722229,
0.32349127531051636,
0.4230066239833832,
-0.6704689860343933,
0.29756513237953186,
0.20962922275066376,
0.5875995755195618,
-0.13946159183979034,
-0.5115964412689209,
-0.48009854555130005,
0.09513438493013382,
-0.3476025462150574,
-0.5454356670379639,
0.20918864011764526,
0.3334731161594391,
0.9019945859909058,
0.4142170250415802,
-0.05184933915734291,
0.5287491679191589,
-0.44572940468788147,
0.4865342080593109,
-0.31432920694351196,
-0.40970930457115173,
0.7904607057571411,
-0.04156329110264778,
0.08781775087118149,
0.6213486790657043,
0.45806431770324707,
-0.3501613736152649,
-0.1274699717760086,
-0.27234265208244324,
-0.7342252731323242,
0.9874809384346008,
-0.06088286638259888,
0.17922547459602356,
0.27011701464653015,
0.45642486214637756,
0.36866113543510437,
0.14896658062934875,
-0.004722220823168755,
-0.6053681373596191,
0.22869305312633514,
-0.26013562083244324,
-0.11545702069997787,
-0.12443692237138748,
0.006930506322532892,
-0.3479691445827484,
0.7197102308273315,
-0.0971059575676918,
0.1344783753156662,
-0.5539815425872803,
-0.012909909710288048,
-0.1853783130645752,
0.23466713726520538,
0.25873512029647827,
0.6897329092025757,
-0.16984640061855316,
-0.3688366115093231,
0.2516311705112457,
-0.6660473942756653,
0.1323331743478775,
-0.07125760614871979,
-0.30892249941825867,
-0.12987814843654633,
0.5264807939529419,
1.1181024312973022,
0.24739979207515717,
-0.45890048146247864,
0.2361297458410263,
0.006779847200959921,
-0.2719201147556305,
0.00581713579595089,
0.8192709684371948,
-0.09942440688610077,
-0.012210836634039879,
0.07323471456766129,
-0.3611595332622528,
0.016083531081676483,
-0.2851014733314514,
0.004341415595263243,
0.517503023147583,
-0.16142310202121735,
-0.09467677772045135,
0.10944783687591553,
0.07396145910024643,
-0.21935272216796875,
1.1264698505401611,
-0.07373640686273575,
0.07248635590076447,
0.6363129019737244,
0.5228646397590637,
0.5740929841995239,
-0.41671743988990784,
0.14724107086658478,
0.2788303792476654,
0.18886065483093262,
-0.14514599740505219,
0.44806212186813354,
0.09539663791656494,
-0.5653551816940308,
-0.5308027863502502,
-0.5774412155151367,
-0.5916247963905334,
0.4598377048969269,
-0.9866715669631958,
0.4402599334716797,
-0.3703958988189697,
0.07782312482595444,
-0.34953629970550537,
0.25989508628845215,
-0.5558779835700989,
0.24464762210845947,
0.19401110708713531,
0.9881935715675354,
-0.586455762386322,
0.8861625790596008,
0.5894261598587036,
0.11747003346681595,
-0.4658721089363098,
0.10174009203910828,
-0.0017301456537097692,
-0.9633297324180603,
0.3440779447555542,
-0.22898083925247192,
0.031674426048994064,
0.24806644022464752,
-0.7511336207389832,
-0.9045883417129517,
0.9882492423057556,
0.5345834493637085,
-0.731791079044342,
-0.0681171640753746,
0.19337274134159088,
0.25261175632476807,
-0.28523412346839905,
0.2808806598186493,
1.0230481624603271,
0.3991445302963257,
0.3487449884414673,
-0.4266732335090637,
-0.3784334063529968,
-0.06985481083393097,
0.03453344479203224,
0.3642098009586334,
-0.8777470588684082,
0.6275830864906311,
0.03317651152610779,
-0.05148961767554283,
-0.01756596378982067,
0.5298482179641724,
0.208635613322258,
0.09389512240886688,
0.3053362965583801,
0.23736661672592163,
0.76531982421875,
-0.14276309311389923,
0.7438341379165649,
-0.32164010405540466,
0.21047192811965942,
0.9853120446205139,
-0.28923338651657104,
0.763422429561615,
0.21086131036281586,
-0.460902601480484,
0.01932060904800892,
1.085229516029358,
-0.47481247782707214,
0.5603022575378418,
0.3729013502597809,
-0.16185390949249268,
-0.40776726603507996,
0.029649514704942703,
-0.49310004711151123,
0.6343048810958862,
0.49095237255096436,
-0.21124368906021118,
-0.19719582796096802,
-0.1263737976551056,
-0.162458136677742,
-0.30934256315231323,
-0.3458735942840576,
1.0745173692703247,
-0.12303589284420013,
-0.634212076663971,
0.7698469758033752,
-0.15282240509986877,
0.39407792687416077,
-0.599664568901062,
-0.19698385894298553,
-0.4420035779476166,
-0.1202736422419548,
-0.1588500738143921,
-0.8346170783042908,
-0.07587776333093643,
0.031091393902897835,
-0.08137037605047226,
-0.3190470337867737,
0.47862139344215393,
-0.3244323432445526,
-0.42919865250587463,
-0.06414894759654999,
0.4779073894023895,
0.2350684553384781,
0.1662004590034485,
-0.42089489102363586,
0.2790817320346832,
0.21663548052310944,
-0.47413304448127747,
0.44144877791404724,
0.3867674469947815,
0.21390347182750702,
0.671575129032135,
0.48967424035072327,
0.5927886962890625,
0.09743593633174896,
0.18919283151626587,
0.9772775173187256,
-0.7262169718742371,
-0.10263580083847046,
-0.7094382643699646,
0.2462553232908249,
-0.07304543256759644,
-0.4795632064342499,
0.6818940043449402,
0.7512845396995544,
1.0710476636886597,
-0.04118482396006584,
0.957410991191864,
0.3223702609539032,
0.7163069248199463,
-1.094575047492981,
0.49750468134880066,
-0.2484242469072342,
0.4213241636753082,
0.010115723125636578,
-1.0372799634933472,
-0.05477631092071533,
0.33091121912002563,
-0.48211145401000977,
0.28581202030181885,
0.5284953713417053,
0.9518101811408997,
-0.18899741768836975,
0.32629844546318054,
0.3562614619731903,
-0.1557505875825882,
-0.0376584418118,
0.4644657373428345,
0.9683198928833008,
-0.186825230717659,
0.3854060471057892,
-0.28808164596557617,
-0.20129342377185822,
-0.33976152539253235,
-0.6440336108207703,
-0.975650429725647,
-0.5535346865653992,
-0.2478577345609665,
0.15849539637565613,
0.07124807685613632,
1.0007127523422241,
0.7989495992660522,
-0.9030105471611023,
-0.3157462179660797,
0.2657262980937958,
0.2898712456226349,
-0.2720537483692169,
-0.03417915850877762,
0.47985637187957764,
-0.6611602902412415,
-0.8394905924797058,
0.652410626411438,
0.009663321077823639,
-0.04300326108932495,
-0.14656749367713928,
0.03447837755084038,
-0.029746409505605698,
-0.08187089115381241,
0.3547055125236511,
0.08393574506044388,
-0.2852720022201538,
0.08456896990537643,
0.14224843680858612,
-0.07467559725046158,
0.2666393220424652,
0.9442882537841797,
-0.3645705282688141,
0.32532909512519836,
0.38496556878089905,
0.8454436659812927,
0.5091341733932495,
-0.19298654794692993,
0.42254185676574707,
-0.8782643675804138,
-0.17153339087963104,
0.24567535519599915,
0.19592837989330292,
0.1895524561405182,
-0.43243494629859924,
0.5146416425704956,
-0.09337195008993149,
-0.6920192241668701,
-0.7643833756446838,
0.13338787853717804,
-0.5001647472381592,
-0.11706328392028809,
1.2642922401428223,
0.09308003634214401,
-0.22472470998764038,
0.07744582742452621,
-0.23612526059150696,
0.23709338903427124,
-0.27136558294296265,
0.7077463269233704,
0.8782685399055481,
-0.39035043120384216,
-0.3709816038608551,
-0.9768769145011902,
0.603432834148407,
0.19771717488765717,
-1.0034772157669067,
0.37609463930130005,
0.629093587398529,
-0.023296451196074486,
-0.5983378291130066,
0.02366751618683338,
0.04150431975722313,
0.10130634903907776,
-0.2439957559108734,
-0.17272301018238068,
-0.13811634480953217,
-0.4624846279621124,
-0.3304865062236786,
-0.13211485743522644,
0.4250170588493347,
-0.3077866733074188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09674v1 | Navigating the Peril of Generated Alternative Facts: A ChatGPT-4 Fabricated Omega Variant Case as a Cautionary Tale in Medical Misinformation | 2024-02-04T13:21:19 | 2024-02-04T13:21:19 | Malik Sallam, Jan Egger, Rainer Roehrig, Behrus Puladi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG | In an era where artificial intelligence (AI) intertwines with medical
research, the delineation of truth becomes increasingly complex. This study
ostensibly examines a purported novel SARS-CoV-2 variant, dubbed the Omega
variant, showcasing 31 unique mutations in the S gene region. However, the real
undercurrent of this narrative is a demonstration of the ease with which AI,
specifically ChatGPT-4, can fabricate convincing yet entirely fictional
scientific data. The so-called Omega variant was identified in a fully
vaccinated, previously infected 35-year-old male presenting with severe
COVID-19 symptoms. Through a detailed, albeit artificial, genomic analysis and
contact tracing, this study mirrors the rigorous methodology of genuine case
reports, thereby setting the stage for a compelling but entirely constructed
narrative. The entire case study was generated by ChatGPT-4, a large language
model by OpenAI. The fabricated Omega variant features an ensemble of
mutations, including N501Y and E484K, known for enhancing ACE2 receptor
affinity, alongside L452R and P681H, ostensibly indicative of immune evasion.
This variant's contrived interaction dynamics - severe symptoms in a vaccinated
individual versus mild ones in unvaccinated contacts - were designed to mimic
real-world complexities, including suggestions of antibody-dependent
enhancement (ADE). While the Omega variant is a product of AI-generated
fiction, the implications of this exercise are real and profound. The ease with
which AI can generate believable but false scientific information, as
illustrated in this case, raises significant concerns about the potential for
misinformation in medicine. This study, therefore, serves as a cautionary tale,
emphasizing the necessity for critical evaluation of sources, especially in an
age where AI tools like ChatGPT are becoming increasingly sophisticated and
widespread in their use. | [
-0.21051934361457825,
-0.6403449773788452,
0.5457808971405029,
-0.4546026885509491,
-0.114085853099823,
0.28820499777793884,
0.06636679172515869,
-0.6425365805625916,
0.20641973614692688,
0.08146306127309799,
-0.5244346261024475,
0.11226287484169006,
-0.6791582107543945,
0.06533423066139221,
-0.1459256112575531,
1.241381049156189,
0.10600626468658447,
0.07834887504577637,
-0.05677613243460655,
-0.1503455489873886,
0.07870814949274063,
-0.42632415890693665,
-0.7073330283164978,
-0.49569082260131836,
0.5017611384391785,
0.483860582113266,
0.9324823021888733,
0.3633631765842438,
0.5399699211120605,
0.10712611675262451,
0.30411896109580994,
0.011483078822493553,
-0.6841036081314087,
0.02555350959300995,
0.11339082568883896,
-0.6357216238975525,
-0.3996044099330902,
0.47977522015571594,
0.16671337187290192,
0.15936484932899475,
-0.21075482666492462,
-0.062587209045887,
-0.2899666130542755,
0.2883908450603485,
-0.4661492705345154,
-0.22737334668636322,
-0.4246559143066406,
0.24408526718616486,
-0.5811411738395691,
-0.21174629032611847,
-0.1409892588853836,
0.0021561244502663612,
0.39410871267318726,
-0.7359185814857483,
0.46304160356521606,
0.1290845423936844,
0.9439919590950012,
0.26994818449020386,
-0.41753411293029785,
-0.5560784339904785,
-0.8067891597747803,
0.4092654883861542,
-0.6211574077606201,
-0.023191459476947784,
0.3944871127605438,
0.5561124086380005,
-0.22575630247592926,
-0.9023599028587341,
-0.6558336615562439,
-0.4858514368534088,
0.19030971825122833,
0.4114050269126892,
-0.36165690422058105,
-0.08676429837942123,
0.18297545611858368,
0.4943166971206665,
-0.5770995020866394,
-0.20719541609287262,
-0.8329226970672607,
-0.44248974323272705,
0.6599462032318115,
-0.08401688933372498,
0.7407538294792175,
-0.11564632505178452,
-0.39641693234443665,
0.08817866444587708,
-0.9391864538192749,
-0.003055628389120102,
0.28523167967796326,
-0.17200729250907898,
-0.40946006774902344,
0.6308907866477966,
0.007330871652811766,
0.09671939164400101,
0.43763604760169983,
-0.00036331123556010425,
0.11523236334323883,
-0.3519965708255768,
-0.11094696819782257,
0.6180717349052429,
0.7431963086128235,
0.24068260192871094,
0.06392162293195724,
0.0553610734641552,
0.21904321014881134,
0.06657511740922928,
0.6221975088119507,
-0.6483299732208252,
-0.3881532847881317,
0.3505288064479828,
-0.20850734412670135,
-0.3547280728816986,
-0.08528950810432434,
-0.5532793402671814,
-0.34955766797065735,
0.1809925138950348,
0.27959054708480835,
-0.650122880935669,
-0.04625220224261284,
-0.14108394086360931,
-0.43239614367485046,
0.4472934901714325,
0.383533775806427,
-0.42310139536857605,
0.0220266692340374,
0.5231210589408875,
0.7284743189811707,
0.009682318195700645,
0.15939763188362122,
-0.3646742105484009,
0.3188343942165375,
-0.4595159888267517,
0.8766732811927795,
-0.8391484618186951,
-0.27565717697143555,
-0.19387656450271606,
-0.5986593961715698,
0.11584317684173584,
-0.2983925938606262,
0.6142385601997375,
-0.4752975404262543,
0.06060820072889328,
-0.3117765784263611,
-0.19115093350410461,
-0.1582433134317398,
0.12847845256328583,
-0.438014417886734,
0.5260311961174011,
0.0034504220820963383,
-0.8009144067764282,
0.1757708191871643,
-0.6170781850814819,
-0.3007301688194275,
0.4288753867149353,
-0.6379404067993164,
-0.5237111449241638,
0.023829294368624687,
-0.08675924688577652,
-0.209339439868927,
-0.5394178628921509,
0.18720942735671997,
-0.3596161901950836,
-0.030564524233341217,
0.25107133388519287,
-0.46407127380371094,
0.5574507117271423,
0.4054142236709595,
-0.3596365451812744,
-0.2748156189918518,
-0.6147292256355286,
-0.17304763197898865,
0.024332815781235695,
-0.25978368520736694,
-0.19532757997512817,
-0.24021220207214355,
-0.45605403184890747,
0.16902011632919312,
0.17634530365467072,
-0.686799168586731,
0.11723514646291733,
-0.2664015591144562,
0.34868356585502625,
0.3290272057056427,
0.402965784072876,
0.22745893895626068,
-0.8714514374732971,
0.7653190493583679,
0.11220866441726685,
0.5176920890808105,
-0.009846676141023636,
-0.9142977595329285,
-0.7798365950584412,
-0.15856492519378662,
-0.04117289558053017,
0.5848514437675476,
-0.7122173309326172,
-0.3298730254173279,
0.13055823743343353,
-0.7547008991241455,
-0.6570691466331482,
-0.2950803339481354,
0.45290619134902954,
0.562526524066925,
0.34902673959732056,
-0.32160013914108276,
-0.5809723734855652,
-1.1330636739730835,
-0.6977748870849609,
-0.19338151812553406,
0.09234944730997086,
0.3095340430736542,
0.5308904647827148,
-0.4356440603733063,
0.6641587615013123,
-0.46372413635253906,
-0.18085427582263947,
-0.009848551824688911,
0.5075016021728516,
-0.07434198260307312,
0.5628118515014648,
0.4143580198287964,
-0.826042890548706,
-0.2727305591106415,
0.10610313713550568,
-0.7925181984901428,
0.22138574719429016,
-0.3121054470539093,
0.053282178938388824,
-0.07522881031036377,
0.4394020736217499,
-0.5815826654434204,
0.6935476064682007,
0.23808303475379944,
0.025254426524043083,
0.7787876129150391,
-0.41075611114501953,
0.1674349159002304,
-0.8139529824256897,
0.2694544196128845,
0.07973237335681915,
0.14523325860500336,
-0.7933579683303833,
0.1705300211906433,
-0.1295192539691925,
0.062495894730091095,
-0.28093767166137695,
0.09802045673131943,
-0.2749349772930145,
0.264020174741745,
-0.017756732180714607,
-0.32244694232940674,
-0.21266774833202362,
0.09972483664751053,
-0.4889370799064636,
0.7881424427032471,
0.2450994849205017,
-0.3401690423488617,
0.3680780529975891,
0.30329760909080505,
-0.16158747673034668,
0.531865656375885,
-0.5802777409553528,
0.14730463922023773,
-0.2074955254793167,
0.47809937596321106,
-0.6047606468200684,
-0.5982288718223572,
0.699021577835083,
-0.5893491506576538,
0.04594928398728371,
-0.05321125686168671,
-0.006444799248129129,
-0.19879107177257538,
-0.20900490880012512,
0.560411810874939,
0.5777813196182251,
-0.12275679409503937,
0.4986017346382141,
0.49913665652275085,
-0.407265305519104,
-0.5282204747200012,
-0.7775689363479614,
0.41537198424339294,
-0.08144821226596832,
-0.345069944858551,
0.4543711245059967,
-0.383515864610672,
-0.4880327880382538,
-0.024105925112962723,
-0.45336800813674927,
-0.44283634424209595,
-0.14380204677581787,
0.254544734954834,
0.014448807574808598,
-0.29829728603363037,
-0.0808568000793457,
0.12057910859584808,
0.09519748389720917,
-0.10213442891836166,
0.2564221918582916,
0.11307918280363083,
-0.28936567902565,
-0.5144835114479065,
-0.41683924198150635,
0.5532951951026917,
0.6454680562019348,
-0.12055511027574539,
0.11282813549041748,
0.32496288418769836,
-0.44438400864601135,
0.12649288773536682,
-0.26761144399642944,
-0.15885533392429352,
-0.38860276341438293,
0.21836528182029724,
-0.36310410499572754,
-0.45463383197784424,
0.31989753246307373,
-0.0321667306125164,
-0.06033426150679588,
0.656831681728363,
0.2967100143432617,
-0.2053670883178711,
0.7337698340415955,
0.4309656023979187,
0.30977192521095276,
0.1450204998254776,
-0.11674236506223679,
0.547531008720398,
-0.7703050374984741,
-0.4931056797504425,
-0.3043113350868225,
-0.09495929628610611,
-0.7187643647193909,
-0.5362321138381958,
0.9430084824562073,
-0.27432766556739807,
-0.35735023021698,
-0.3722818195819855,
-0.17305625975131989,
0.3298894166946411,
0.7219963669776917,
0.25315386056900024,
0.3119470477104187,
-0.17337608337402344,
-0.20094053447246552,
0.08663340657949448,
-1.3365647792816162,
-0.30336591601371765,
1.1679257154464722,
0.18949595093727112,
0.588607907295227,
0.1568174958229065,
0.3862682580947876,
0.48000726103782654,
0.2969203591346741,
-0.44423630833625793,
0.09552069008350372,
-0.13202309608459473,
-0.6921640038490295,
0.05630921199917793,
-0.04163414239883423,
-0.9081084132194519,
-0.23794464766979218,
-0.4031721353530884,
-0.3349604904651642,
0.41707995533943176,
0.3151867091655731,
-0.6301501989364624,
-0.09201077371835709,
-0.8154934644699097,
0.34996503591537476,
-0.3828088641166687,
-0.33610934019088745,
-0.4115448296070099,
-0.8545910716056824,
0.5399507284164429,
-0.2939547896385193,
0.24200481176376343,
0.25574415922164917,
0.10966380685567856,
0.3757981061935425,
-0.7865554094314575,
0.8998574614524841,
0.4290340542793274,
-0.14281082153320312,
0.22848361730575562,
-0.013340028002858162,
0.40134912729263306,
0.448963463306427,
-0.12075095623731613,
0.3721298277378082,
-0.10323261469602585,
-0.533538281917572,
-0.33063805103302,
0.6540438532829285,
-0.8664891719818115,
-0.9947752356529236,
-0.9873728156089783,
-0.322482168674469,
0.09144403785467148,
0.1723143309354782,
0.5644166469573975,
0.6084725260734558,
-0.30133485794067383,
-0.2157953828573227,
0.526441752910614,
-0.5165818333625793,
0.04243611544370651,
0.5346041917800903,
0.5850129127502441,
-0.43454432487487793,
0.6609742641448975,
0.3075295686721802,
0.21016091108322144,
0.22884461283683777,
0.22451600432395935,
-0.031112397089600563,
-0.4715842604637146,
-0.40776121616363525,
0.38926199078559875,
-0.3450744152069092,
-0.05243521183729172,
-0.339074969291687,
-0.5423716306686401,
-0.29604098200798035,
-0.15467028319835663,
-0.5052058100700378,
-0.0805908590555191,
-0.04779969900846481,
0.06628090143203735,
0.4338552951812744,
0.9760736227035522,
-0.2469281703233719,
-0.1453752964735031,
-0.6200128793716431,
0.3808145523071289,
0.262759804725647,
0.3315262198448181,
-0.38884416222572327,
-0.3018138110637665,
-0.19068099558353424,
0.7916478514671326,
-0.3842277526855469,
-0.8139221668243408,
0.128008633852005,
0.3864274024963379,
0.505355954170227,
0.5412594676017761,
0.3922220468521118,
0.7730998396873474,
-0.45697247982025146,
0.823316752910614,
0.2116093933582306,
-0.6092336773872375,
0.5369741916656494,
-0.4671863913536072,
0.3010595440864563,
0.11945346742868423,
0.5736678242683411,
-0.621279776096344,
-0.8020898103713989,
-1.051247000694275,
-0.7731041312217712,
0.5022935271263123,
0.377354234457016,
-0.18897920846939087,
0.06400419771671295,
0.5738962888717651,
0.4645457863807678,
-0.040282055735588074,
-0.27285683155059814,
-0.49959081411361694,
-0.33222496509552,
-0.05974002555012703,
-0.1449604630470276,
-0.33002203702926636,
-0.5803645849227905,
-0.029847092926502228,
0.7457312345504761,
-0.04754820466041565,
0.3966085612773895,
0.7122527360916138,
0.02630060724914074,
-0.0733434334397316,
0.09325523674488068,
0.8637557625770569,
0.6588011384010315,
-0.01941252127289772,
0.4343336820602417,
-0.2758899927139282,
-0.7844061851501465,
0.005858519114553928,
0.14308087527751923,
-0.20886321365833282,
-0.13118857145309448,
0.46072933077812195,
0.7001851201057434,
-0.015559826977550983,
-0.7655820846557617,
0.3975692391395569,
-0.08214100450277328,
0.00849941372871399,
-0.5550815463066101,
0.24388530850410461,
-0.27772581577301025,
0.4570706784725189,
0.58565354347229,
0.7178512811660767,
0.31407472491264343,
-0.6899963021278381,
0.33541980385780334,
0.489374041557312,
-0.17667904496192932,
-0.6395971775054932,
0.6809549331665039,
0.26752179861068726,
-0.19145265221595764,
0.5909330248832703,
-0.020330972969532013,
-0.31765878200531006,
0.7453339695930481,
0.4148777425289154,
0.5123082399368286,
-0.42560267448425293,
0.45254290103912354,
0.34443187713623047,
0.34765225648880005,
0.10546350479125977,
-0.02525380253791809,
0.24812069535255432,
-0.7134037613868713,
-0.1492738127708435,
-0.052692580968141556,
-0.3318624198436737,
0.48529052734375,
-0.35399821400642395,
0.0017976931994780898,
-0.40074679255485535,
-0.07459706813097,
0.327303946018219,
-0.10237777978181839,
-0.34373217821121216,
0.21943366527557373,
0.1937008798122406,
0.6629367470741272,
-0.7853400111198425,
0.7064085006713867,
0.8293854594230652,
-0.5207603573799133,
-0.49352124333381653,
0.46121397614479065,
0.22017250955104828,
-0.9749250411987305,
0.4253401756286621,
-0.15241679549217224,
0.07077807188034058,
-0.1969480812549591,
-0.4817785322666168,
-0.9514555931091309,
0.9665202498435974,
0.6014271378517151,
-0.32604673504829407,
0.24821683764457703,
0.1539122313261032,
0.6447314023971558,
-0.32162606716156006,
0.28543105721473694,
0.461492657661438,
0.4169835150241852,
0.33828896284103394,
-0.756686270236969,
0.10877546668052673,
-0.5947744846343994,
-0.22016076743602753,
-0.23759447038173676,
-0.9043183326721191,
0.7101378440856934,
-0.783369779586792,
-0.18840040266513824,
-0.06766761839389801,
0.23420433700084686,
0.09143853187561035,
0.5807738304138184,
-0.032832708209753036,
0.46606189012527466,
1.0061545372009277,
0.19923174381256104,
1.3656686544418335,
-0.25421375036239624,
-0.16457419097423553,
0.918683648109436,
0.000623106665443629,
0.49753984808921814,
0.6472598910331726,
0.061502743512392044,
0.364378422498703,
0.6405685544013977,
0.08820217102766037,
0.37933778762817383,
-0.019341686740517616,
-0.45630982518196106,
-0.2174437940120697,
-0.09440765529870987,
-0.5673131346702576,
0.6925563216209412,
0.42823198437690735,
-0.07273082435131073,
-0.19776612520217896,
-0.17100587487220764,
0.24999919533729553,
-0.2917880713939667,
0.05422903224825859,
0.6930404901504517,
0.04655058681964874,
-0.8956321477890015,
0.6758872866630554,
-0.13271564245224,
0.20648452639579773,
-0.6112669706344604,
-0.27076828479766846,
-0.1944231539964676,
-0.005059217102825642,
-0.15518257021903992,
-0.42611756920814514,
0.30598828196525574,
-0.06273666769266129,
-0.31073707342147827,
0.0646284893155098,
0.5396767854690552,
-0.2767550051212311,
-0.26804104447364807,
-0.3797243535518646,
0.41185101866722107,
0.157356858253479,
0.11536112427711487,
-0.638212263584137,
0.1438039094209671,
0.2712160050868988,
0.12165012210607529,
0.20186805725097656,
0.23916226625442505,
-0.187151238322258,
0.8124791979789734,
0.6259120106697083,
0.18456295132637024,
-0.08820313960313797,
-0.5687834620475769,
0.589527428150177,
-0.4467324912548065,
-0.5230691432952881,
-0.8774772882461548,
0.224157452583313,
-0.17278741300106049,
-0.3475695848464966,
0.688919186592102,
0.7256069779396057,
0.370793879032135,
-0.10321956872940063,
1.3961607217788696,
-0.2314777821302414,
0.01659293659031391,
-0.2773643136024475,
1.0797088146209717,
-0.31486397981643677,
0.3196762502193451,
0.2421478033065796,
0.07627150416374207,
-0.18438753485679626,
0.2909087836742401,
-0.3125406801700592,
0.042666204273700714,
0.7238871455192566,
0.6575039625167847,
0.13935086131095886,
0.19878150522708893,
-0.058019008487463,
0.94516921043396,
0.4613398313522339,
0.46468085050582886,
0.6963869333267212,
-0.48522987961769104,
0.40842074155807495,
-0.03542981669306755,
-0.6496706008911133,
-0.6247119903564453,
-0.7177281379699707,
-0.36749953031539917,
-0.6866903901100159,
-0.6065914630889893,
-0.2771514356136322,
0.6154217720031738,
0.7139580845832825,
0.5552533268928528,
-0.46024078130722046,
0.17703425884246826,
-0.17321358621120453,
0.04926501214504242,
-0.2950055003166199,
-0.10475274920463562,
0.20014797151088715,
-0.14430800080299377,
-0.46662279963493347,
0.3994310200214386,
0.35155004262924194,
0.23344436287879944,
0.25440213084220886,
-0.13751262426376343,
-0.22686181962490082,
0.38944363594055176,
0.354669988155365,
0.6401371359825134,
-0.6907200217247009,
-0.32030951976776123,
-0.4482237696647644,
-0.0949474424123764,
0.2959323227405548,
0.6927812695503235,
-0.7087340950965881,
0.6616861820220947,
0.12030810117721558,
0.541976273059845,
0.45049145817756653,
-0.21079587936401367,
1.2072019577026367,
-0.3862309753894806,
-0.18360012769699097,
0.2532244026660919,
0.12691320478916168,
0.17242693901062012,
-0.6085373759269714,
0.21253426373004913,
0.4705859422683716,
-0.3115972876548767,
-0.6387899518013,
0.5510326623916626,
-1.0829435586929321,
-0.28486138582229614,
1.1678870916366577,
0.07302803546190262,
-0.1766376942396164,
-0.2636461555957794,
-0.48185500502586365,
0.4745274484157562,
-0.67037034034729,
1.2524830102920532,
0.5372099876403809,
-0.6758068799972534,
0.036460865288972855,
-0.7559067010879517,
0.994570791721344,
0.1698998063802719,
-0.6055678129196167,
-0.3907339572906494,
0.36475491523742676,
0.2375398725271225,
-0.0029561673291027546,
0.6113644242286682,
-0.07924222201108932,
0.6821607947349548,
0.2350005805492401,
-0.001596747781150043,
-0.0834193080663681,
0.11108586192131042,
-0.0642043724656105,
0.08619848638772964,
0.01736915111541748,
-0.12784481048583984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02479v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02479v2 | BRAIn: Bayesian Reward-conditioned Amortized Inference for natural language generation from feedback | 2024-02-04T13:16:29 | 2024-06-10T10:18:46 | Gaurav Pandey, Yatin Nandwani, Tahira Naseem, Mayank Mishra, Guangxuan Xu, Dinesh Raghu, Sachindra Joshi, Asim Munawar, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Distribution matching methods for language model alignment such as Generation
with Distributional Control (GDC) and Distributional Policy Gradient (DPG) have
not received the same level of attention in reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF) as contrastive methods such as Sequence Likelihood Calibration
(SLiC), Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and its variants. We identify high
variance of the gradient estimate as the primary reason for the lack of success
of these methods and propose a self-normalized baseline to reduce the variance.
We further generalize the target distribution in DPG, GDC and DPO by using
Bayes' rule to define the reward-conditioned posterior. The resulting approach,
referred to as BRAIn - Bayesian Reward-conditioned Amortized Inference acts as
a bridge between distribution matching methods and DPO and significantly
outperforms prior art in summarization and Antropic HH tasks. | [
-0.3054125905036926,
-0.7616536617279053,
0.42593222856521606,
0.35257408022880554,
0.03899918869137764,
-0.07740176469087601,
-0.2115723192691803,
0.01128031313419342,
0.13668422400951385,
0.6040536165237427,
-0.7960777282714844,
-0.5216678380966187,
-0.3448721468448639,
-0.2740543782711029,
0.13712182641029358,
1.1119095087051392,
0.1367470622062683,
-0.0591864250600338,
-0.23875731229782104,
0.04839969053864479,
-0.19415511190891266,
-0.36653050780296326,
-0.7169908285140991,
-0.5925295948982239,
0.5706086754798889,
0.19637969136238098,
0.7318564653396606,
0.7318138480186462,
0.5455285310745239,
0.18589143455028534,
-0.004243646282702684,
-0.07843583822250366,
-0.2193586379289627,
-0.054415248334407806,
-0.23889242112636566,
-0.4566764533519745,
-0.33911120891571045,
-0.02505769394338131,
0.5154727697372437,
0.8256409764289856,
-0.7202395796775818,
-0.2181508094072342,
-0.08438409119844437,
1.0431522130966187,
-1.1721861362457275,
0.16528202593326569,
-0.2818245589733124,
0.09337363392114639,
0.08450185507535934,
-0.15604297816753387,
-0.3859333097934723,
-0.654367208480835,
0.2506154179573059,
-0.5009443759918213,
0.42009758949279785,
0.06918109208345413,
0.5619317293167114,
0.528433084487915,
-0.36427488923072815,
-0.3165571987628937,
-0.6801204085350037,
0.8480781316757202,
-0.9319248199462891,
0.030782189220190048,
0.6706850528717041,
0.0824657529592514,
-0.2541833519935608,
-0.3215171992778778,
-0.4927199184894562,
-0.36682987213134766,
-0.05519796907901764,
0.2435026317834854,
-0.11414218693971634,
0.5062224864959717,
0.16439630091190338,
0.4808628559112549,
-0.45678654313087463,
0.25095391273498535,
-0.10827451944351196,
-0.19168183207511902,
0.7736445069313049,
0.21291740238666534,
0.163373202085495,
-0.17749947309494019,
-0.31674283742904663,
-0.38296258449554443,
-0.6959165930747986,
0.08438830822706223,
0.6847087740898132,
0.05341203510761261,
-0.09401345252990723,
0.5462711453437805,
-0.28250816464424133,
0.8046286702156067,
0.08466525375843048,
-0.029450783506035805,
0.24156184494495392,
-0.2104209065437317,
-0.1920803189277649,
0.05628173425793648,
0.8072969317436218,
0.5574280023574829,
0.242169588804245,
-0.1273016631603241,
-0.22834160923957825,
0.36573946475982666,
0.23722825944423676,
-0.5390147566795349,
-0.27282243967056274,
0.1523413211107254,
-0.38069820404052734,
-0.26230287551879883,
-0.19224491715431213,
-0.9126362800598145,
-0.3434629440307617,
-0.18569782376289368,
0.28442877531051636,
-0.33168673515319824,
-0.17502719163894653,
0.15818306803703308,
-0.40800154209136963,
0.24182085692882538,
-0.03376944363117218,
-1.6480498313903809,
0.4310115575790405,
0.47708389163017273,
0.5421357750892639,
-0.3878950774669647,
-0.20358188450336456,
-0.3584379255771637,
0.28282395005226135,
-0.5478418469429016,
0.8243829011917114,
-0.24931463599205017,
-0.18583111464977264,
0.22247962653636932,
-0.38047340512275696,
-0.11041814088821411,
-0.7026036977767944,
0.49765750765800476,
-0.26148754358291626,
0.46595048904418945,
-0.22284115850925446,
-0.5038796663284302,
-0.04925970360636711,
-0.015358821488916874,
-0.43575578927993774,
0.7005090713500977,
0.4347822964191437,
-0.8965211510658264,
0.4409330487251282,
-0.5833176374435425,
-0.5153830647468567,
-0.11082114279270172,
-0.08166106790304184,
-0.2423163205385208,
0.10470955818891525,
0.25780174136161804,
0.2673519551753998,
-0.24304376542568207,
0.3557559847831726,
-0.48147493600845337,
-0.2403034120798111,
0.007948569022119045,
-0.3995715379714966,
0.5487003922462463,
0.24399298429489136,
-0.4949251413345337,
0.23547840118408203,
-0.8059644103050232,
-0.15681618452072144,
-0.0425700806081295,
-0.3628068268299103,
-0.4600713551044464,
0.4407590627670288,
0.02062026411294937,
0.021220682188868523,
0.13525007665157318,
-0.35097771883010864,
0.20221148431301117,
-0.6999655961990356,
0.5574521422386169,
0.6504272222518921,
0.10812953114509583,
0.7677209377288818,
-0.2953749895095825,
0.5480645298957825,
0.12053856253623962,
-0.1932140737771988,
0.07289660722017288,
-0.15291889011859894,
-0.4252646267414093,
-0.4211752116680145,
0.1705533266067505,
0.7170873880386353,
-0.5332198739051819,
0.5425911545753479,
-0.08446219563484192,
-0.2700403034687042,
-0.6987261176109314,
-0.2036738246679306,
0.4785577058792114,
0.6452669501304626,
0.3477906882762909,
-0.22974848747253418,
-0.2959476411342621,
-1.2460906505584717,
0.00439320458099246,
-0.19742371141910553,
-0.30458277463912964,
0.2752479016780853,
0.126367449760437,
-0.2869868576526642,
0.8927267789840698,
-0.6476427912712097,
-0.05311267077922821,
-0.05734698474407196,
0.6630873084068298,
0.22401009500026703,
0.5425218939781189,
0.428833544254303,
-0.36495497822761536,
-0.21571224927902222,
-0.17793431878089905,
-0.465220183134079,
-0.3554740846157074,
0.040843866765499115,
-0.1570318341255188,
0.27851808071136475,
0.29140332341194153,
-0.4873778522014618,
0.41499441862106323,
0.5343170762062073,
-0.30753615498542786,
0.2869327664375305,
-0.48636090755462646,
0.3385586738586426,
-0.8510460257530212,
-0.02480597421526909,
0.22523663938045502,
0.021648306399583817,
-0.3491320013999939,
-0.21261999011039734,
0.03905373066663742,
0.08133874833583832,
-0.08200191706418991,
0.36976033449172974,
-0.3010440468788147,
-0.07644625753164291,
-0.4736211597919464,
0.11083731055259705,
-0.26050442457199097,
0.6547796726226807,
0.27717721462249756,
0.7029516696929932,
0.4892289340496063,
-0.7433990836143494,
0.3615869879722595,
0.1426660120487213,
-0.15941612422466278,
0.7958869338035583,
-0.7144761085510254,
-0.26442599296569824,
-0.44661444425582886,
0.17467881739139557,
-0.947869598865509,
-0.22159023582935333,
0.29750052094459534,
-0.4074660837650299,
0.2101648598909378,
0.20436261594295502,
-0.12411895394325256,
-0.24400287866592407,
-0.3370455801486969,
0.32709836959838867,
0.6624546647071838,
-0.477036714553833,
0.11181752383708954,
0.29604220390319824,
-0.27030107378959656,
-0.756527841091156,
-0.9062421917915344,
-0.29266977310180664,
-0.24926237761974335,
-0.36290839314460754,
0.6861916780471802,
-0.13003085553646088,
-0.3420112431049347,
-0.008006126619875431,
-0.026615506038069725,
-0.07885663956403732,
0.0026256192941218615,
0.06100110709667206,
0.21049529314041138,
-0.12337426841259003,
0.08438016474246979,
0.30397409200668335,
-0.018608970567584038,
0.312504380941391,
0.04420766606926918,
0.25530922412872314,
0.28842002153396606,
-0.25434938073158264,
-0.17902930080890656,
0.4893362522125244,
0.20534290373325348,
-0.007937861606478691,
0.5474917888641357,
0.4824632406234741,
-0.336405873298645,
-0.12956464290618896,
-0.5125758647918701,
-0.2808573544025421,
-0.3673674464225769,
0.30201759934425354,
-0.04016401618719101,
-0.7911394834518433,
0.32223135232925415,
0.2231757938861847,
-0.1038563922047615,
0.4037502706050873,
0.7980757355690002,
-0.009202583692967892,
1.23026442527771,
0.5826942324638367,
-0.2761155962944031,
0.6655411720275879,
0.02547835372388363,
-0.021488124504685402,
-0.8196126222610474,
0.053011566400527954,
-0.42933109402656555,
-0.2572071850299835,
-0.7363203167915344,
0.010837257839739323,
-0.010693422518670559,
0.17572279274463654,
-0.2990312874317169,
0.01389852911233902,
-0.4990543723106384,
0.21420106291770935,
0.9476349949836731,
0.09813280403614044,
0.05510513484477997,
-0.055382873862981796,
-0.23340323567390442,
-0.11941667646169662,
-0.6690200567245483,
-0.1789531409740448,
0.9043275713920593,
0.173113614320755,
0.9531422853469849,
-0.07514265179634094,
0.7091889977455139,
0.36731112003326416,
0.4053635001182556,
-0.6056749820709229,
0.20916453003883362,
0.16163161396980286,
-0.503390371799469,
-0.35151180624961853,
-0.6878228187561035,
-1.1540606021881104,
0.24421203136444092,
-0.11623714864253998,
-0.9397419095039368,
0.36443743109703064,
0.37893691658973694,
-0.42770370841026306,
-0.18482977151870728,
-0.8177183270454407,
0.9500560164451599,
0.1295267641544342,
-0.34434881806373596,
-0.3768140971660614,
-0.6792958974838257,
0.556723415851593,
0.3960534930229187,
0.15927807986736298,
-0.3403703272342682,
-0.0046167150139808655,
0.6510524153709412,
-0.30838578939437866,
0.4029247462749481,
-0.3126482367515564,
-0.06671535968780518,
0.08977549523115158,
-0.18229568004608154,
0.2679736614227295,
0.13460959494113922,
0.0668925940990448,
-0.43312162160873413,
-0.07569033652544022,
-0.5203643441200256,
-0.7071285843849182,
0.5977822542190552,
-0.6776852011680603,
-0.5180637240409851,
-0.4105283319950104,
-0.7683628797531128,
-0.3106919229030609,
-0.07122910022735596,
0.4862997233867645,
0.1014484316110611,
-0.31563153862953186,
0.0027307230047881603,
0.641445517539978,
-0.2813382148742676,
0.6220576167106628,
0.36787691712379456,
-0.007822788320481777,
-0.9042680263519287,
0.7161585092544556,
-0.35860612988471985,
0.33936914801597595,
0.5851204991340637,
0.0978570207953453,
-0.4171306788921356,
-0.44008156657218933,
-0.23521113395690918,
0.2906867265701294,
-0.5035455226898193,
0.029490888118743896,
-0.20557595789432526,
-0.08882685750722885,
-0.6586294174194336,
-0.22672820091247559,
-0.2133522629737854,
-0.0879717469215393,
-0.23162733018398285,
-0.03662625327706337,
0.012846430763602257,
0.6572924256324768,
-0.35085588693618774,
0.46890291571617126,
-0.48004135489463806,
0.4344811737537384,
0.4162045121192932,
0.4266144037246704,
-0.21634532511234283,
-0.36117327213287354,
-0.1969185769557953,
0.3189128637313843,
-0.3174304664134979,
-1.1506705284118652,
0.5961111187934875,
0.023943856358528137,
0.6971104145050049,
0.2669975757598877,
-0.01570659503340721,
0.34377533197402954,
-0.29996076226234436,
0.5210415720939636,
0.34169092774391174,
-0.6647930145263672,
0.6867182850837708,
-0.4940292239189148,
0.3284514546394348,
0.48511406779289246,
0.30839526653289795,
-0.49714645743370056,
-0.1123962476849556,
-0.6847048401832581,
-0.9155726432800293,
0.6443113684654236,
0.08669731765985489,
-0.016103237867355347,
-0.34725889563560486,
0.32327690720558167,
-0.2482811063528061,
0.422364741563797,
-0.6960042715072632,
-0.29059308767318726,
-0.04272601753473282,
-0.4740157723426819,
-0.27948009967803955,
-0.17169874906539917,
-0.24108217656612396,
-0.13383810222148895,
0.6728291511535645,
-0.3304492235183716,
0.3738594651222229,
0.30021044611930847,
0.026263969019055367,
-0.1910271793603897,
0.3541604280471802,
0.7506630420684814,
0.5395850539207458,
-0.5126891136169434,
-0.035172492265701294,
-0.18601632118225098,
-0.29908499121665955,
0.18895737826824188,
0.21483086049556732,
-0.2770240902900696,
-0.2848993241786957,
0.05483946204185486,
1.0332825183868408,
0.16332091391086578,
-0.6677255034446716,
0.4524501860141754,
0.024640345945954323,
-0.3839656710624695,
-0.03400755301117897,
0.16565372049808502,
0.2231246829032898,
0.1012970507144928,
0.1872698962688446,
-0.11502604931592941,
0.2630108892917633,
-0.39600563049316406,
0.11525894701480865,
0.5494325160980225,
-0.5043066740036011,
0.011244609020650387,
0.6287517547607422,
-0.10157912969589233,
-0.39076051115989685,
0.7483970522880554,
-0.2851329743862152,
-0.05354301258921623,
0.5294579267501831,
0.6641799807548523,
0.8589749932289124,
-0.23256035149097443,
0.4285928010940552,
0.38344892859458923,
0.20337609946727753,
-0.2712101936340332,
0.3013141453266144,
-0.31301775574684143,
-0.7895323038101196,
-0.5692722201347351,
-0.4203159809112549,
-0.5634740591049194,
-0.09182066470384598,
-0.8927863240242004,
-0.08193108439445496,
-0.35878100991249084,
-0.10562155395746231,
0.012434674426913261,
-0.30261513590812683,
-0.3209284245967865,
0.26791292428970337,
0.18423041701316833,
0.4841447174549103,
-0.9885408282279968,
0.6292670369148254,
0.6018834114074707,
-0.6588637828826904,
-0.5651724934577942,
-0.024056175723671913,
-0.35888585448265076,
-0.6556801795959473,
0.4406929612159729,
-0.20696912705898285,
0.1708325892686844,
0.25626909732818604,
-0.568825900554657,
-0.7396482229232788,
0.9456298351287842,
0.46982306241989136,
-0.2850859463214874,
-0.0523180216550827,
-0.17765194177627563,
0.5377939939498901,
-0.2440561205148697,
0.4092124104499817,
0.835625410079956,
0.2446969449520111,
0.15548771619796753,
-0.6057521104812622,
-0.1649990975856781,
-0.15359671413898468,
0.19131402671337128,
0.4287390410900116,
-0.3675113022327423,
0.5376474857330322,
-0.19025260210037231,
0.058849263936281204,
-0.17812612652778625,
0.7471491694450378,
0.7669798731803894,
0.2591747045516968,
0.3466203808784485,
0.9638217091560364,
0.521906852722168,
-0.08001376688480377,
1.0171151161193848,
-0.15122023224830627,
0.4223553240299225,
0.8356835842132568,
-0.08972187340259552,
0.8869742155075073,
0.796626627445221,
-0.461998850107193,
0.7284163236618042,
0.8799628615379333,
0.1054031103849411,
0.9977436661720276,
0.7154216170310974,
-0.2153341919183731,
0.08098641037940979,
0.046889759600162506,
-0.27422648668289185,
-0.08866605907678604,
0.3779836595058441,
-0.3479345440864563,
-0.1739787459373474,
-0.0030301909428089857,
-0.1757461428642273,
0.25616201758384705,
-0.3206484615802765,
0.8772355318069458,
-0.0334419310092926,
-1.19382643699646,
0.5604206919670105,
-0.08325468003749847,
0.9089862704277039,
-0.44784650206565857,
0.03789149224758148,
-0.4530037045478821,
0.18817688524723053,
-0.10078037530183792,
-0.41833773255348206,
0.3614938259124756,
-0.40898245573043823,
-0.42567014694213867,
-0.13144396245479584,
0.4259676933288574,
-0.5765424966812134,
-0.07651983946561813,
0.14697562158107758,
0.24267283082008362,
-0.141450434923172,
-0.06118304654955864,
-0.5525587797164917,
-0.45683950185775757,
-0.12590615451335907,
-0.5034457445144653,
0.49317681789398193,
0.2899358868598938,
0.23296815156936646,
0.7666497230529785,
0.3269805610179901,
0.28572389483451843,
0.09552175551652908,
0.05209053307771683,
0.27106449007987976,
-0.8109085559844971,
-0.6113104224205017,
-0.877285897731781,
0.4156001806259155,
0.00968633871525526,
-0.38177186250686646,
0.30511584877967834,
0.3354436159133911,
0.6031416058540344,
-0.3015296459197998,
0.7277519106864929,
0.027593975886702538,
0.2894943654537201,
-0.5479069948196411,
0.3892098069190979,
-0.43545421957969666,
0.026272892951965332,
-0.22927965223789215,
-1.0533429384231567,
-0.188736692070961,
0.7814049124717712,
-0.2817235589027405,
0.1498870849609375,
1.0030443668365479,
0.8357894420623779,
0.1996525228023529,
-0.2099418193101883,
0.19237735867500305,
-0.23955808579921722,
-0.021785583347082138,
0.7997748255729675,
0.6736000776290894,
-0.09895564615726471,
0.22860360145568848,
-0.2828252613544464,
-0.3347835838794708,
-0.005397908389568329,
-0.9432145953178406,
-0.5356646776199341,
-0.46725180745124817,
-0.5694222450256348,
-0.33119577169418335,
0.14407283067703247,
0.9013799428939819,
0.7330895066261292,
-0.8265920281410217,
-0.3902460038661957,
-0.7775527238845825,
0.28808706998825073,
-0.52726149559021,
-0.2820248603820801,
0.20600372552871704,
-0.5542550086975098,
-0.8016443252563477,
0.2318018078804016,
0.44245070219039917,
0.11667857319116592,
-0.43729203939437866,
-0.1823982447385788,
-0.2569664716720581,
0.03612890467047691,
0.22670163214206696,
0.3678760528564453,
-0.7673138380050659,
-0.08720307797193527,
-0.11944656819105148,
-0.5183959007263184,
0.1216830238699913,
0.7811370491981506,
-0.6201662421226501,
0.14189213514328003,
0.9073037505149841,
0.7380557656288147,
0.5227128267288208,
0.10685434937477112,
0.9205837845802307,
-0.6872671246528625,
0.07709315419197083,
0.25932544469833374,
0.31627050042152405,
0.21345806121826172,
-0.1690005362033844,
0.4713779389858246,
0.3873234987258911,
-0.863983154296875,
-0.5410264134407043,
0.3750070333480835,
-0.9693886041641235,
-0.07585020363330841,
1.1618268489837646,
-0.06498339027166367,
-0.38868165016174316,
0.25831204652786255,
-0.23811356723308563,
0.278420090675354,
-0.37240898609161377,
0.9121888875961304,
0.8119038343429565,
-0.19686251878738403,
-0.3286583423614502,
-0.3461485207080841,
0.718971312046051,
0.7151768207550049,
-0.9917487502098083,
0.12876375019550323,
0.7567066550254822,
0.08781685680150986,
-0.060066550970077515,
0.9268682599067688,
0.16271905601024628,
0.36159253120422363,
0.054091691970825195,
0.47824475169181824,
0.4993131160736084,
0.14280687272548676,
-0.476461261510849,
0.08530239015817642,
0.15658065676689148,
-0.2782701253890991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02456v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02456v2 | tnGPS: Discovering Unknown Tensor Network Structure Search Algorithms via Large Language Models (LLMs) | 2024-02-04T12:06:13 | 2024-06-01T15:54:54 | Junhua Zeng, Chao Li, Zhun Sun, Qibin Zhao, Guoxu Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Tensor networks are efficient for extremely high-dimensional representation,
but their model selection, known as tensor network structure search (TN-SS), is
a challenging problem. Although several works have targeted TN-SS, most
existing algorithms are manually crafted heuristics with poor performance,
suffering from the curse of dimensionality and local convergence. In this work,
we jump out of the box, studying how to harness large language models (LLMs) to
automatically discover new TN-SS algorithms, replacing the involvement of human
experts. By observing how human experts innovate in research, we model their
common workflow and propose an automatic algorithm discovery framework called
tnGPS. The proposed framework is an elaborate prompting pipeline that instruct
LLMs to generate new TN-SS algorithms through iterative refinement and
enhancement. The experimental results demonstrate that the algorithms
discovered by tnGPS exhibit superior performance in benchmarks compared to the
current state-of-the-art methods. | [
-0.5741927623748779,
-0.47739341855049133,
0.6731173992156982,
-0.07271356880664825,
-0.25212913751602173,
0.30528724193573,
-0.17176181077957153,
-0.08029981702566147,
0.5238978862762451,
0.31931373476982117,
-0.6187626719474792,
-0.5060077905654907,
-0.8885811567306519,
0.328561395406723,
-0.18516874313354492,
0.2148303985595703,
-0.17466247081756592,
0.19444043934345245,
0.44706347584724426,
0.12219057232141495,
-0.2939455807209015,
0.09649515897035599,
-1.1137274503707886,
-0.268682062625885,
0.5107390284538269,
0.2710232138633728,
0.36866244673728943,
0.9777565598487854,
0.413434237241745,
0.4865950345993042,
-0.4431571662425995,
0.614704966545105,
-0.3411892056465149,
0.29286983609199524,
-0.08141320198774338,
-0.4561956524848938,
-0.2005268782377243,
-0.3197469413280487,
0.8983246088027954,
0.64986252784729,
-0.041383322328329086,
0.3152971863746643,
-0.09211312234401703,
0.7918956279754639,
-0.48916321992874146,
0.19564364850521088,
-0.49831289052963257,
0.3872513473033905,
-0.5481509566307068,
-0.6703082323074341,
-0.3377961814403534,
-0.18543021380901337,
0.14398398995399475,
-0.3523382246494293,
0.7154472470283508,
0.08586858958005905,
0.3242732882499695,
0.24583615362644196,
-0.38531380891799927,
-0.19086173176765442,
-0.40342116355895996,
0.34235090017318726,
-0.632574200630188,
0.5150618553161621,
0.05642891302704811,
0.4211658239364624,
-0.8378143906593323,
-0.7385543584823608,
-0.270955353975296,
-0.3141840100288391,
-0.06994438171386719,
-0.4922526180744171,
-0.08483313024044037,
0.1879178285598755,
0.20719201862812042,
0.36671873927116394,
-0.6293757557868958,
0.3344886898994446,
-0.48246461153030396,
-0.20755766332149506,
0.41149869561195374,
0.2592513859272003,
0.32238972187042236,
-0.16995836794376373,
-0.052148908376693726,
-0.014634386636316776,
-0.814626157283783,
-0.2166360467672348,
0.30616530776023865,
0.5692599415779114,
0.011483941227197647,
0.7177455425262451,
-0.4504821300506592,
0.7204020619392395,
-0.19377021491527557,
0.4131309986114502,
0.1684369295835495,
-0.009791480377316475,
-0.1819227933883667,
0.025825297459959984,
0.8022240996360779,
-0.28048184514045715,
0.05932210013270378,
-0.5429962873458862,
-0.4236149191856384,
-0.1904095709323883,
0.18294952809810638,
-0.6640885472297668,
-0.2526940703392029,
0.10580997914075851,
-0.5744504928588867,
-0.3394339978694916,
-0.13948996365070343,
-0.58670973777771,
-0.7383165955543518,
-0.3360091745853424,
0.3873943090438843,
-0.24089735746383667,
-0.6477276682853699,
0.029900260269641876,
-0.5101417899131775,
-0.18465717136859894,
0.06353826075792313,
-0.764442503452301,
-0.0717637836933136,
0.7230101227760315,
1.0453405380249023,
-0.1476307362318039,
-0.3388937711715698,
-0.8585305213928223,
-0.12519985437393188,
-0.6241146326065063,
0.8203154802322388,
-0.5462062358856201,
-0.26179927587509155,
-0.20173390209674835,
-0.022426793351769447,
-0.00006844103336334229,
-0.35879209637641907,
0.4991266429424286,
-0.6529873013496399,
0.07155675441026688,
-0.5408538579940796,
-0.5555785298347473,
-0.04464177414774895,
0.21254654228687286,
-0.7607514262199402,
0.9493324756622314,
0.08597245067358017,
-0.8836162686347961,
0.20255854725837708,
-1.3163046836853027,
-0.00471058115363121,
0.289845734834671,
-0.23411443829536438,
-0.4182858169078827,
0.5322830677032471,
0.4054863452911377,
0.7169289588928223,
-0.5520314574241638,
0.32523348927497864,
-0.3695550262928009,
-0.7738034725189209,
-0.2078031748533249,
-0.20593520998954773,
1.0479544401168823,
0.34934869408607483,
-0.541612982749939,
0.2968330681324005,
-0.5175158977508545,
0.13385573029518127,
0.29296231269836426,
-0.1235695481300354,
-0.22691041231155396,
-0.15830926597118378,
-0.482042521238327,
-0.10336464643478394,
-0.02799103409051895,
-0.4163120985031128,
0.37132683396339417,
-0.19401371479034424,
0.7682758569717407,
0.9238625764846802,
-0.1279754936695099,
0.49581602215766907,
0.04248330369591713,
0.5393418669700623,
-0.1602059304714203,
-0.00961983110755682,
-0.17836487293243408,
-0.27952516078948975,
-0.5905042290687561,
-0.25149673223495483,
0.29711270332336426,
-0.02956138364970684,
-0.7605395317077637,
0.13539659976959229,
-0.3906267285346985,
-0.5916212797164917,
-0.47228771448135376,
0.055094532668590546,
0.18636976182460785,
0.44739508628845215,
0.14129643142223358,
-0.31324058771133423,
-0.8125422596931458,
-0.7861680388450623,
-0.2441190630197525,
-0.08077412843704224,
-0.028777360916137695,
0.21100032329559326,
0.24099913239479065,
-0.36130544543266296,
0.6649382710456848,
-0.4748172163963318,
-0.12171025574207306,
-0.024937553331255913,
0.1983293890953064,
0.09307766705751419,
0.2997838258743286,
0.30104929208755493,
-0.5578920841217041,
-0.11017557233572006,
-0.19653670489788055,
-0.9106364846229553,
0.15009087324142456,
0.3699548840522766,
-0.05072014406323433,
0.006210976280272007,
0.9691429138183594,
-0.5995221734046936,
0.19603358209133148,
0.3016431927680969,
-0.28313255310058594,
0.5404329895973206,
-0.16760823130607605,
-0.05192723125219345,
-1.1835850477218628,
0.2415197342634201,
0.29426559805870056,
0.12852591276168823,
-0.383165180683136,
0.43789350986480713,
-0.02994615025818348,
-0.21187040209770203,
-0.17682470381259918,
0.6978838443756104,
-0.9812301993370056,
-0.45263123512268066,
-0.12125938385725021,
-0.05609576776623726,
-0.31900614500045776,
0.565271258354187,
0.0464969165623188,
0.7739459276199341,
0.7978848218917847,
-0.7031100392341614,
0.4632912278175354,
0.15458737313747406,
-0.39349111914634705,
0.1922883838415146,
-0.4172796607017517,
0.22503937780857086,
-0.3778144121170044,
0.19835485517978668,
-1.048448920249939,
-0.20147131383419037,
0.09437411278486252,
-0.5090079307556152,
0.3328186571598053,
-0.8078284859657288,
-0.49498823285102844,
-0.5672111511230469,
-0.039549022912979126,
0.3616495728492737,
-0.005105400457978249,
-0.8217517137527466,
0.7082274556159973,
0.5943945646286011,
-0.013376390561461449,
-0.7056424617767334,
-0.21670657396316528,
0.5740000605583191,
-0.12351945787668228,
-0.6709363460540771,
0.26746129989624023,
0.15654337406158447,
0.0373624823987484,
-0.14783646166324615,
-0.1602289080619812,
0.03900536522269249,
0.27070391178131104,
0.11198338866233826,
0.05372137576341629,
-0.5254254341125488,
0.08099668473005295,
-0.17289382219314575,
-0.24542655050754547,
0.11994696408510208,
-0.8075946569442749,
0.8012571930885315,
-0.5225547552108765,
-0.27217379212379456,
-0.3410781919956207,
0.03652511537075043,
0.561622142791748,
-0.5584170818328857,
0.10718809813261032,
1.0687657594680786,
-0.45020291209220886,
-0.28523004055023193,
-0.7741986513137817,
-0.4279518127441406,
-0.6046704649925232,
0.6446983218193054,
-0.32847848534584045,
-0.9957109093666077,
0.4757055640220642,
-0.38240811228752136,
-0.05560048297047615,
0.24695444107055664,
0.45469576120376587,
0.27957114577293396,
1.021474003791809,
0.7530333399772644,
-0.0422852523624897,
0.44853344559669495,
-0.5450229048728943,
0.2984829246997833,
-0.9206722378730774,
-0.28312239050865173,
-0.6552730202674866,
-0.5041713118553162,
-0.8549647331237793,
-0.24917472898960114,
0.6381721496582031,
-0.23394954204559326,
-0.4052116870880127,
0.5260236263275146,
-0.7806107401847839,
0.7075778245925903,
0.6266976594924927,
0.038640446960926056,
0.2011624425649643,
0.3224218785762787,
-0.6290457248687744,
0.33977943658828735,
-0.9142447113990784,
-0.1434081643819809,
1.1142363548278809,
0.3421243727207184,
0.33476412296295166,
0.1304078847169876,
0.9522201418876648,
0.26001349091529846,
0.3350703716278076,
-0.7016443610191345,
0.7257658839225769,
-0.08600198477506638,
-0.4081438481807709,
-0.584518551826477,
-0.8725579380989075,
-1.087659478187561,
-0.016073958948254585,
-0.23149453103542328,
-0.7114546298980713,
0.16948813199996948,
0.07996668666601181,
-0.31851089000701904,
0.7748187184333801,
-0.6759108304977417,
0.5524527430534363,
-0.0915883406996727,
-0.24367497861385345,
-0.10247018933296204,
-0.34898436069488525,
0.3022644519805908,
0.33935120701789856,
-0.13639023900032043,
0.07440098375082016,
0.15232163667678833,
0.596214234828949,
-0.40574511885643005,
0.5662686228752136,
-0.4105716943740845,
0.0299659613519907,
0.0772905945777893,
0.4463801085948944,
0.7487289309501648,
0.1387106031179428,
-0.21107743680477142,
0.07782404869794846,
-0.5145047903060913,
-0.22156141698360443,
-0.5254533290863037,
0.9421201348304749,
-0.5636216402053833,
-0.62420654296875,
-0.13360023498535156,
-0.28537487983703613,
-0.2525665760040283,
0.6775546073913574,
0.2918635606765747,
0.6118174195289612,
0.0027970033697783947,
0.09956103563308716,
0.7771405577659607,
0.09077508002519608,
0.6365299820899963,
0.4168987572193146,
0.03809273988008499,
-0.322631299495697,
0.872879683971405,
0.06150729954242706,
-0.46600162982940674,
0.3984823524951935,
0.3142732083797455,
-0.4781121611595154,
-1.0441930294036865,
-0.7914006114006042,
0.18544365465641022,
-0.45252540707588196,
-0.2846841514110565,
-0.5027743577957153,
-0.28143802285194397,
-0.30796703696250916,
0.12536533176898956,
-0.4831659495830536,
-0.3139082193374634,
-0.1766538769006729,
-0.2304133027791977,
0.30253756046295166,
0.7880299091339111,
-0.03185126185417175,
0.22794301807880402,
-0.7066963315010071,
0.21220791339874268,
0.0830991193652153,
1.0617402791976929,
0.2886291742324829,
-0.2136916071176529,
-0.17999404668807983,
-0.007824054919183254,
-0.027291322126984596,
-0.45139968395233154,
0.2512913942337036,
-0.29711058735847473,
0.6150569319725037,
0.40363121032714844,
-0.17418791353702545,
0.5931991338729858,
-0.3307427763938904,
0.2317512184381485,
0.06657174229621887,
-0.6360290050506592,
0.011112380772829056,
-0.5229350328445435,
0.142037034034729,
0.23806989192962646,
0.292587012052536,
-0.5834380388259888,
0.12963689863681793,
-0.478643000125885,
-0.6329349875450134,
0.5956881642341614,
0.23350244760513306,
-0.07269494235515594,
0.09065178036689758,
0.5773268342018127,
-0.16771529614925385,
0.032551415264606476,
-0.2703063189983368,
-0.24043795466423035,
0.05800481140613556,
-0.09000994265079498,
0.15446096658706665,
-0.11492732912302017,
-0.15317746996879578,
0.05661211907863617,
0.5163166522979736,
-0.29532182216644287,
0.45008957386016846,
0.3098120093345642,
0.04536299407482147,
-0.4499315321445465,
-0.03545717895030975,
0.37854939699172974,
0.7017655372619629,
-0.08314274251461029,
0.17219945788383484,
0.03935569152235985,
-0.3608020842075348,
-0.0014208091888576746,
0.23607130348682404,
-0.0973958894610405,
0.0919620618224144,
0.16091972589492798,
0.9910299777984619,
-0.10150429606437683,
-0.5006382465362549,
0.21826517581939697,
-0.40735650062561035,
-0.22887660562992096,
-0.6366516351699829,
0.2526513934135437,
0.21548809111118317,
0.496677041053772,
0.5897303223609924,
0.2987682521343231,
0.11248661577701569,
-0.21148847043514252,
0.2329932600259781,
0.6865798234939575,
-0.27824628353118896,
-0.09876443445682526,
0.49082112312316895,
0.10814663022756577,
-0.7162243127822876,
0.7295409440994263,
-0.3890729248523712,
-0.5365394949913025,
0.5318995118141174,
0.08309882134199142,
1.1239663362503052,
-0.13473403453826904,
0.3883354663848877,
0.3566778898239136,
0.30407044291496277,
-0.4898691773414612,
0.09041047841310501,
0.005999099463224411,
-0.6496269702911377,
-0.6028567552566528,
-0.2245294451713562,
-0.11630845069885254,
0.32712632417678833,
-0.324323445558548,
0.7018150687217712,
-0.5219448804855347,
-0.13577152788639069,
0.1554568111896515,
0.21041803061962128,
-0.6894412636756897,
0.07274440675973892,
0.3136289417743683,
0.9951061606407166,
-0.45890510082244873,
0.4458884596824646,
0.6744143962860107,
-0.049681004136800766,
-0.8325501084327698,
-0.2898271381855011,
0.15966761112213135,
-1.000888466835022,
0.5543915033340454,
0.09389740973711014,
-0.11295318603515625,
0.3328496515750885,
-0.5105807781219482,
-1.0468043088912964,
1.2274718284606934,
0.5231128931045532,
-0.33974671363830566,
-0.5255522727966309,
0.13465063273906708,
0.5354470014572144,
-0.36580443382263184,
0.6158257126808167,
0.19977273046970367,
0.3355170488357544,
0.1854269653558731,
-0.7949425578117371,
0.27579861879348755,
-0.5167317390441895,
0.051180388778448105,
0.5777204036712646,
-0.5210286378860474,
0.6602738499641418,
-0.556507408618927,
-0.018874919041991234,
-0.08219434320926666,
0.5482820868492126,
0.48390018939971924,
0.2581578493118286,
0.5366312861442566,
0.542326807975769,
0.7806156277656555,
0.12108245491981506,
0.7256177067756653,
-0.1236971914768219,
0.02248251624405384,
0.7978112101554871,
0.21476611495018005,
0.5869433879852295,
0.27215877175331116,
0.10218893736600876,
0.278530091047287,
0.8516417741775513,
-0.2443438619375229,
0.12477592378854752,
0.5117555856704712,
-0.05638439580798149,
-0.3829392194747925,
0.15929144620895386,
-0.14140000939369202,
0.5723332762718201,
0.37195655703544617,
-0.577409029006958,
-0.4394746720790863,
-0.4772964417934418,
-0.03299672156572342,
-0.34293970465660095,
-0.44489550590515137,
0.48816239833831787,
0.0018790496978908777,
-0.7703127264976501,
0.8810394406318665,
0.38252517580986023,
0.45017221570014954,
-0.45108547806739807,
-0.08096493780612946,
-0.3336097002029419,
-0.03578487038612366,
-0.1453140377998352,
-0.4111613929271698,
0.1890217661857605,
-0.2499835044145584,
0.09269481152296066,
0.1015804260969162,
0.5655048489570618,
-0.18276970088481903,
-0.34314605593681335,
0.10352636873722076,
0.544180154800415,
-0.08541129529476166,
-0.2191322296857834,
-0.5133081078529358,
-0.01448480598628521,
0.027892138808965683,
-0.24040339887142181,
0.28010475635528564,
0.5798425674438477,
-0.32381418347358704,
1.1332803964614868,
0.8130066394805908,
0.1518300622701645,
0.07918724417686462,
-0.15892384946346283,
0.8781066536903381,
-0.5903483033180237,
-0.5605422854423523,
-0.8171408176422119,
0.14210081100463867,
-0.16591386497020721,
-0.32042834162712097,
0.39684945344924927,
0.5605831742286682,
0.8060991764068604,
0.07659153640270233,
0.7239254713058472,
0.1814781129360199,
0.38111189007759094,
-0.49953097105026245,
0.8037686347961426,
-0.5346338152885437,
0.6318385601043701,
-0.1809512972831726,
-0.8688018918037415,
-0.406364381313324,
0.31769153475761414,
-0.11121029406785965,
0.035501789301633835,
0.5228577852249146,
1.2219650745391846,
-0.3432396352291107,
0.3959549069404602,
-0.18200400471687317,
0.293950617313385,
0.47172072529792786,
0.13479559123516083,
0.5359787344932556,
-0.22850273549556732,
0.5291624069213867,
-0.10154768824577332,
-0.09255647659301758,
-0.25255900621414185,
-1.1790205240249634,
-0.9631578922271729,
-0.8977122902870178,
-0.1518283188343048,
-0.35376793146133423,
0.1496334820985794,
1.235615611076355,
0.7838371992111206,
-0.565311074256897,
-0.20134763419628143,
-0.6230335831642151,
0.2977273166179657,
-0.12809695303440094,
-0.14543397724628448,
0.7628750205039978,
-0.3535803556442261,
-0.6202849745750427,
0.7165191769599915,
0.11186236143112183,
0.045582134276628494,
-0.5569271445274353,
-0.032173145562410355,
0.20283104479312897,
-0.3394656479358673,
0.19418008625507355,
0.45009538531303406,
-0.360435426235199,
0.16973541676998138,
0.32988351583480835,
0.17082451283931732,
-0.15498057007789612,
1.2966972589492798,
-0.7457239627838135,
0.4522521495819092,
0.7123978734016418,
0.8327586650848389,
0.48819032311439514,
-0.5270878076553345,
0.8405480980873108,
-0.6649268269538879,
-0.09289712458848953,
0.25033971667289734,
0.717369019985199,
0.44326597452163696,
-0.3058011531829834,
0.7120205760002136,
0.2377896010875702,
-0.3042373061180115,
-1.170930027961731,
0.2082701474428177,
-0.47656166553497314,
-0.15753981471061707,
0.9978463649749756,
0.08365729451179504,
-0.20382574200630188,
-0.12146668136119843,
-0.10034941881895065,
0.2983221709728241,
-0.22724561393260956,
1.2551237344741821,
0.31072819232940674,
0.034215208142995834,
-0.24380838871002197,
-0.2622116804122925,
0.8051350116729736,
0.33424457907676697,
-0.139055997133255,
0.16513539850711823,
0.015110719949007034,
0.40626171231269836,
0.06030075624585152,
0.45539000630378723,
-0.2251051515340805,
0.07773768156766891,
-0.2715340852737427,
-0.08848796784877777,
-0.859513521194458,
-0.3168994188308716,
-0.007699423469603062,
0.2076374739408493,
-0.014682769775390625,
0.20273767411708832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02449v1 | Surfing the modeling of PoS taggers in low-resource scenarios | 2024-02-04T11:38:12 | 2024-02-04T11:38:12 | Manuel Vilares Ferro, Víctor M. Darriba Bilbao, Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Jorge Graña Gil | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68, 68T50 | The recent trend towards the application of deep structured techniques has
revealed the limits of huge models in natural language processing. This has
reawakened the interest in traditional machine learning algorithms, which have
proved still to be competitive in certain contexts, in particular low-resource
settings. In parallel, model selection has become an essential task to boost
performance at reasonable cost, even more so when we talk about processes
involving domains where the training and/or computational resources are scarce.
Against this backdrop, we evaluate the early estimation of learning curves as a
practical mechanism for selecting the most appropriate model in scenarios
characterized by the use of non-deep learners in resource-lean settings. On the
basis of a formal approximation model previously evaluated under conditions of
wide availability of training and validation resources, we study the
reliability of such an approach in a different and much more demanding
operationalenvironment. Using as case study the generation of PoS taggers for
Galician, a language belonging to the Western Ibero-Romance group, the
experimental results are consistent with our expectations. | [
-0.3748738467693329,
-0.6805151700973511,
0.6600579023361206,
-0.03530755266547203,
-0.17788800597190857,
-0.020315414294600487,
-0.33862265944480896,
-0.56423419713974,
-0.06644588708877563,
0.27056998014450073,
-0.6376457810401917,
-0.2948019802570343,
-0.4519452154636383,
0.08256492763757706,
-0.018999500200152397,
1.2808157205581665,
-0.10109864175319672,
-0.09861543029546738,
0.026870539411902428,
0.0811431035399437,
-0.5339469909667969,
-0.3346681296825409,
-0.6443708539009094,
-0.2433832734823227,
0.4255702495574951,
0.25431305170059204,
0.6239435076713562,
0.6422041058540344,
0.5101277828216553,
0.274867445230484,
-0.22165913879871368,
0.014007707126438618,
-0.5774086117744446,
0.1722896546125412,
-0.3645472824573517,
-0.4165801405906677,
-0.3780893385410309,
0.17418216168880463,
0.6168325543403625,
0.9690337777137756,
-0.22906112670898438,
0.30186668038368225,
0.09645478427410126,
0.3819795250892639,
-0.7952153086662292,
0.10678648948669434,
-0.9756473898887634,
0.07597976177930832,
-0.08337298780679703,
0.18781377375125885,
-0.47328972816467285,
-0.2091408520936966,
0.5265781879425049,
-0.5489889979362488,
0.44063901901245117,
-0.049949683248996735,
0.9926599264144897,
0.33666330575942993,
0.05216405168175697,
-0.3752315938472748,
-1.0023175477981567,
1.0883066654205322,
-0.4589706361293793,
0.2775680124759674,
0.6724225282669067,
0.46465739607810974,
-0.26607152819633484,
-0.7312286496162415,
-0.20333538949489594,
-0.563833475112915,
-0.13400860130786896,
-0.12601442635059357,
-0.013688781298696995,
0.05546199902892113,
0.40784910321235657,
0.16476193070411682,
-0.21484339237213135,
0.5195712447166443,
-0.4877243936061859,
0.0014694674173370004,
0.6185658574104309,
0.19218429923057556,
-0.19889883697032928,
-0.260307252407074,
-0.5641418695449829,
0.09373758733272552,
-0.3826456069946289,
0.2732747197151184,
0.5666399002075195,
0.7569037079811096,
-0.16904820501804352,
0.45328447222709656,
-0.27781400084495544,
0.7945147752761841,
-0.04704168066382408,
-0.7010499238967896,
0.2037123292684555,
-0.1769617795944214,
-0.4311304986476898,
-0.24345020949840546,
0.8203359842300415,
-0.1400238424539566,
0.31610050797462463,
-0.036909665912389755,
-0.5826705098152161,
0.1161622479557991,
0.2639259994029999,
-0.5051680207252502,
-0.15994635224342346,
-0.0903121754527092,
-0.44154128432273865,
-0.04819664731621742,
-0.1979055255651474,
-0.8204646110534668,
-0.2844976782798767,
-0.18228796124458313,
0.06210387870669365,
-0.5991367697715759,
-0.24211755394935608,
0.017438417300581932,
0.03946666792035103,
0.0780637338757515,
0.20362375676631927,
-0.6835508942604065,
0.12684108316898346,
0.4998853802680969,
0.9456115961074829,
0.1347997486591339,
-0.22137270867824554,
-0.5081043839454651,
-0.07653753459453583,
-0.24536611139774323,
0.6674823760986328,
-0.8184288740158081,
-0.5018442869186401,
-0.17513111233711243,
-0.1834423542022705,
-0.23965522646903992,
-0.5635968446731567,
1.0472471714019775,
-0.34833604097366333,
-0.05038754269480705,
-0.03206208348274231,
-0.2892146408557892,
0.25157999992370605,
0.025624725967645645,
-0.7359320521354675,
1.1417436599731445,
0.5237554907798767,
-0.8171519637107849,
0.6207290291786194,
-0.49638405442237854,
-0.5888362526893616,
0.1004442572593689,
0.017049118876457214,
-0.49863433837890625,
0.3627913296222687,
-0.2671939730644226,
0.6685183644294739,
-0.493156373500824,
0.2572261691093445,
-0.53008633852005,
-0.2909007966518402,
0.15199199318885803,
-0.4523644745349884,
0.5868111848831177,
0.5925864577293396,
-0.05283840745687485,
-0.27246227860450745,
-0.771452784538269,
-0.06189528480172157,
0.3018236458301544,
-0.611981213092804,
-0.4325506091117859,
0.3881852626800537,
-0.1702197641134262,
0.23867695033550262,
-0.027739932760596275,
-0.3641993999481201,
0.19158950448036194,
-0.32475408911705017,
0.6058779358863831,
0.5193278193473816,
0.07699242979288101,
0.6542658805847168,
-0.19787012040615082,
0.7812494039535522,
-0.3863597810268402,
0.4346960186958313,
-0.19576159119606018,
-0.38576382398605347,
-0.5455924272537231,
-0.7378206253051758,
0.31971582770347595,
0.48972126841545105,
-0.8939333558082581,
0.1852371245622635,
-0.23672078549861908,
-0.7914084792137146,
-0.63654625415802,
0.17124593257904053,
0.6854710578918457,
0.6371368169784546,
0.21485145390033722,
-0.20449529588222504,
-0.5054197907447815,
-0.7851982712745667,
-0.1594257354736328,
-0.3598472774028778,
-0.37766820192337036,
0.4143829345703125,
0.3565964996814728,
-0.10694276541471481,
0.9069345593452454,
-0.23974080383777618,
-0.15715602040290833,
-0.3080696761608124,
0.08170218020677567,
0.27407246828079224,
0.41058358550071716,
0.7325716614723206,
-0.7396830916404724,
-0.43335220217704773,
-0.18440625071525574,
-0.39820966124534607,
-0.07550019025802612,
0.10158095508813858,
0.04536274075508118,
0.4126526415348053,
0.17712010443210602,
-0.421345978975296,
0.31650254130363464,
0.6451929807662964,
-0.10544121265411377,
0.48155394196510315,
-0.16148719191551208,
-0.2854423522949219,
-0.48098835349082947,
0.18428218364715576,
0.5354958176612854,
-0.049315061420202255,
-0.579095721244812,
-0.2469712495803833,
-0.45513924956321716,
-0.22337956726551056,
-0.617805004119873,
0.4332379400730133,
-0.3601819574832916,
-0.19902248680591583,
0.1681176871061325,
0.05887022241950035,
-0.0788491815328598,
0.45207077264785767,
0.23842927813529968,
0.49214908480644226,
0.540302574634552,
-0.6862370371818542,
-0.11122073233127594,
-0.026499629020690918,
-0.5211629867553711,
0.637467086315155,
-0.4684438705444336,
0.009359301999211311,
-0.21305914223194122,
-0.03888014331459999,
-0.9165874719619751,
-0.31324928998947144,
0.21461212635040283,
-0.39323732256889343,
0.29147079586982727,
-0.6874625086784363,
-0.37835240364074707,
-0.4148107171058655,
0.05968233570456505,
0.08338810503482819,
0.7362223267555237,
-0.22653289139270782,
0.6511435508728027,
0.6104063391685486,
0.01983310654759407,
-0.4120178520679474,
-0.34991294145584106,
-0.5057161450386047,
-0.3497784435749054,
-0.3503163754940033,
-0.08490196615457535,
0.32819095253944397,
-0.18167385458946228,
-0.014596635475754738,
-0.12365847080945969,
-0.20985226333141327,
0.5240150690078735,
0.2884135842323303,
0.388631135225296,
-0.3104541003704071,
0.06781283020973206,
-0.3511294722557068,
-0.16284601390361786,
-0.16373887658119202,
-0.40797489881515503,
0.509278416633606,
-0.2286974936723709,
-0.1366243213415146,
-0.41335639357566833,
0.030949993059039116,
0.4857890009880066,
-0.5666643977165222,
1.0280636548995972,
0.43177253007888794,
-0.3614192306995392,
-0.5394453406333923,
-0.32197117805480957,
0.1471543163061142,
-0.4512706398963928,
0.3219802975654602,
-0.3613297641277313,
-0.6151519417762756,
0.4322756230831146,
-0.20931194722652435,
-0.021167641505599022,
0.44769877195358276,
0.21685126423835754,
-0.30809837579727173,
0.807434618473053,
0.8255701065063477,
0.1480909287929535,
0.6408301591873169,
-0.28884992003440857,
0.39390820264816284,
-0.5380105972290039,
-0.39835622906684875,
-0.8058156967163086,
-0.2674601078033447,
-0.9026204943656921,
-0.42303627729415894,
0.36576923727989197,
0.40293240547180176,
-0.17195181548595428,
0.27521124482154846,
-0.31597980856895447,
0.4824047088623047,
0.5634118914604187,
-0.09062667936086655,
-0.007574041374027729,
0.18012665212154388,
-0.1357339471578598,
-0.011669131927192211,
-1.0764559507369995,
-0.8218069076538086,
0.6072908639907837,
0.4867604374885559,
0.8685832619667053,
-0.35062283277511597,
0.44053786993026733,
0.13421951234340668,
0.49254128336906433,
-0.8121881484985352,
0.41434210538864136,
-0.33985477685928345,
-0.5646230578422546,
-0.5234345197677612,
-0.5513747930526733,
-1.0264722108840942,
0.07053763419389725,
-0.43983033299446106,
-0.6851609349250793,
0.06010453775525093,
0.36510467529296875,
-0.6538248658180237,
0.5383012294769287,
-0.9775028228759766,
0.9889301657676697,
-0.38234013319015503,
-0.4435305893421173,
0.21175722777843475,
-0.6371756196022034,
0.12201718986034393,
-0.18128719925880432,
0.3212900161743164,
-0.4603133797645569,
-0.1514347642660141,
0.6564522981643677,
-0.29900890588760376,
0.9128202795982361,
-0.5401297807693481,
-0.07893328368663788,
0.8045779466629028,
0.1440332978963852,
0.5448355078697205,
-0.23735164105892181,
-0.36258530616760254,
0.2054819017648697,
-0.15221969783306122,
-0.43874332308769226,
-0.3238053023815155,
0.4747178852558136,
-0.755316436290741,
-0.2116049975156784,
-0.21683649718761444,
-0.0493604801595211,
-0.29591622948646545,
0.06539345532655716,
0.3163076341152191,
0.08543990552425385,
-0.10140431672334671,
-0.10445190966129303,
0.45769214630126953,
-0.32755276560783386,
0.44483035802841187,
0.6080714464187622,
0.08755654841661453,
-0.17825506627559662,
0.8745838403701782,
0.3335234820842743,
0.4512481987476349,
0.19380225241184235,
0.12605181336402893,
-0.025887953117489815,
-0.7341514825820923,
-0.17247076332569122,
0.275593101978302,
-0.47687631845474243,
-0.3622892498970032,
-0.496083527803421,
-0.1190820187330246,
-0.03537711501121521,
-0.34372183680534363,
-0.5865997076034546,
-0.11899930983781815,
-0.31718263030052185,
-0.2070322483778,
0.12601728737354279,
0.6634334921836853,
0.13943657279014587,
0.5365087985992432,
-0.6416887640953064,
0.032181501388549805,
0.010826433077454567,
0.6287320256233215,
0.02117144875228405,
-0.3920007050037384,
-0.35798972845077515,
-0.0711744874715805,
-0.10564173012971878,
-0.7984760999679565,
0.3083347678184509,
0.16896621882915497,
0.7029432654380798,
0.21856434643268585,
0.06800694763660431,
0.3691149353981018,
-0.49031323194503784,
0.4211828410625458,
0.08766158670186996,
-0.7343779802322388,
0.7579740285873413,
-0.39610591530799866,
0.038897544145584106,
0.6720345616340637,
0.9354748725891113,
-0.2960819900035858,
-0.24372030794620514,
-0.7063393592834473,
-1.0578813552856445,
0.8234078288078308,
0.11182314157485962,
0.020289676263928413,
-0.09368957579135895,
0.6362259984016418,
0.29878586530685425,
0.2668745219707489,
-0.5715503692626953,
0.08701317757368088,
0.03789848834276199,
-0.028093356639146805,
-0.13342414796352386,
-0.3215484023094177,
0.45739707350730896,
0.11624272912740707,
0.6686447262763977,
-0.17631377279758453,
0.022871796041727066,
0.027136916294693947,
0.0012682992964982986,
-0.24512386322021484,
0.1888590157032013,
0.04756254702806473,
0.7141684293746948,
-0.22450701892375946,
0.03168289363384247,
0.166831836104393,
-0.268737256526947,
0.01765640825033188,
0.0360945500433445,
-0.37840819358825684,
0.10110467672348022,
0.4158007800579071,
1.1573153734207153,
0.3037116825580597,
-1.0348697900772095,
0.38379570841789246,
0.10172264277935028,
0.10123555362224579,
-0.23948609828948975,
0.2625742256641388,
-0.3699341416358948,
0.32331761717796326,
0.20027531683444977,
0.17152516543865204,
-0.1054493710398674,
-0.4992903769016266,
0.017670122906565666,
0.4357891380786896,
-0.48985210061073303,
-0.4271292984485626,
0.4311106503009796,
0.3783924877643585,
-0.4908578395843506,
0.698307991027832,
-0.516582190990448,
-0.5031506419181824,
0.3698369860649109,
0.17751552164554596,
0.736301839351654,
-0.36358651518821716,
0.3337280750274658,
0.5401741862297058,
0.5077131390571594,
-0.20547783374786377,
0.012734204530715942,
0.11155807971954346,
-0.46121910214424133,
-0.6551911234855652,
-1.2326765060424805,
-0.12310945987701416,
0.34601029753685,
-0.6626561880111694,
0.49558964371681213,
-0.6295836567878723,
-0.5831612944602966,
-0.0210318174213171,
0.1042945608496666,
-0.9431104063987732,
0.30463677644729614,
0.5634502172470093,
0.791026771068573,
-1.161497712135315,
0.7435174584388733,
0.6605209112167358,
-0.28547969460487366,
-0.6681071519851685,
-0.23433344066143036,
-0.3398025631904602,
-0.678246796131134,
0.5134939551353455,
-0.021213741973042488,
-0.20334431529045105,
-0.24311932921409607,
-0.46177855134010315,
-0.9432562589645386,
0.8360114097595215,
0.5676172375679016,
-0.7791781425476074,
-0.281523197889328,
-0.03834104537963867,
0.795295238494873,
-0.24257676303386688,
0.08885955065488815,
0.7862740159034729,
0.1781557947397232,
0.29025667905807495,
-1.2846641540527344,
-0.23759877681732178,
0.14934536814689636,
0.0522729828953743,
0.4499240219593048,
-0.5625218749046326,
1.0911881923675537,
-0.42773884534835815,
-0.5873907804489136,
0.02489934302866459,
0.5061593055725098,
0.25829169154167175,
0.2771912217140198,
0.6383529305458069,
0.48975053429603577,
0.9323631525039673,
0.03393024578690529,
1.3280755281448364,
-0.11179620772600174,
0.508831799030304,
1.2489242553710938,
-0.4679431617259979,
0.9637642502784729,
0.2541497051715851,
-0.39963048696517944,
0.4501968324184418,
0.7994993925094604,
-0.25144845247268677,
0.595282256603241,
0.17527653276920319,
-0.0831829160451889,
-0.2644367814064026,
-0.3307941257953644,
-0.005823314189910889,
0.545168936252594,
0.32546111941337585,
-0.3961184322834015,
-0.18504884839057922,
-0.1263733059167862,
0.11483301222324371,
0.12564031779766083,
-0.592544674873352,
0.6594788432121277,
-0.07518815994262695,
-0.8663654327392578,
0.6319751143455505,
0.30392876267433167,
0.5237522721290588,
-0.7370510697364807,
0.1744481325149536,
-0.11891939491033554,
0.22644637525081635,
-0.058616336435079575,
-0.6602567434310913,
0.18615314364433289,
0.38453173637390137,
-0.2761666774749756,
-0.2549266219139099,
0.8958401083946228,
-0.1694744974374771,
-0.5671496391296387,
0.45638033747673035,
0.5849595665931702,
0.16507911682128906,
0.20735406875610352,
-0.4675426185131073,
-0.033081769943237305,
-0.1421087682247162,
-0.008341781795024872,
0.25369325280189514,
0.5838621258735657,
-0.11654079705476761,
0.6081869006156921,
0.5667752027511597,
0.12429541349411011,
0.2940196394920349,
-0.3278053104877472,
0.7859479188919067,
-0.3133682608604431,
-0.5521420240402222,
-0.8953233957290649,
0.48779454827308655,
0.24140717089176178,
-0.266111820936203,
0.6705443263053894,
0.4708750545978546,
1.3247318267822266,
0.0916232243180275,
0.9080256223678589,
-0.2206955999135971,
0.4776221811771393,
-0.5709425210952759,
0.4682643413543701,
-0.34086695313453674,
0.10217925161123276,
-0.10170669108629227,
-0.9202216267585754,
0.09454473108053207,
0.7564177513122559,
-0.7248857617378235,
0.11004465818405151,
0.4409998059272766,
0.36061033606529236,
-0.10083388537168503,
-0.1118987575173378,
0.24052715301513672,
0.10275863111019135,
-0.04402473568916321,
0.6912622451782227,
1.1116716861724854,
0.06339593976736069,
0.394296258687973,
-0.37232595682144165,
-0.2816527783870697,
-0.18142913281917572,
-0.9611210227012634,
-0.9690390825271606,
-0.38984161615371704,
-0.15745842456817627,
-0.4085044264793396,
-0.1545664221048355,
0.8806096315383911,
0.7480016946792603,
-0.5980479121208191,
-0.17615044116973877,
0.24859103560447693,
0.16821739077568054,
0.0617280937731266,
-0.13554587960243225,
0.026319323107600212,
-0.5087358355522156,
-0.6170605421066284,
0.19553007185459137,
0.16350328922271729,
0.20687496662139893,
-0.21609647572040558,
-0.22612306475639343,
-0.22004248201847076,
0.07483603805303574,
0.38918647170066833,
0.4270828366279602,
-0.45289507508277893,
-0.00034676145878620446,
-0.09251220524311066,
-0.11745341867208481,
0.07814116775989532,
0.9445266723632812,
-1.0478440523147583,
0.14055705070495605,
0.3377688229084015,
0.585917055606842,
0.37306123971939087,
-0.10276251286268234,
0.1295037567615509,
-0.876131534576416,
0.35258960723876953,
0.4792163670063019,
0.3602786064147949,
0.5596595406532288,
0.12565860152244568,
0.6786971688270569,
0.42360541224479675,
-0.25190189480781555,
-1.1001955270767212,
0.21382354199886322,
-0.46231788396835327,
-0.18877077102661133,
1.1370400190353394,
-0.41202792525291443,
-0.48801544308662415,
0.037010785192251205,
0.03694181516766548,
0.22105877101421356,
-0.3334800601005554,
0.5881332755088806,
0.4769659638404846,
-0.07237941771745682,
0.23975583910942078,
-0.7422510981559753,
0.628087043762207,
0.1119171753525734,
-0.5432237982749939,
0.006324215792119503,
0.4745368957519531,
0.2082153707742691,
0.275751531124115,
0.5670660734176636,
0.3147593140602112,
-0.23364947736263275,
0.0568118616938591,
-0.149262934923172,
0.14202572405338287,
-0.6456146836280823,
-0.14495591819286346,
0.30156296491622925,
0.2380412518978119,
0.013631582260131836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02447v1 | Breaking MLPerf Training: A Case Study on Optimizing BERT | 2024-02-04T11:12:17 | 2024-02-04T11:12:17 | Yongdeok Kim, Jaehyung Ahn, Myeongwoo Kim, Changin Choi, Heejae Kim, Narankhuu Tuvshinjargal, Seungwon Lee, Yanzi Zhang, Yuan Pei, Xiongzhan Linghu, Jingkun Ma, Lin Chen, Yuehua Dai, Sungjoo Yoo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Speeding up the large-scale distributed training is challenging in that it
requires improving various components of training including load balancing,
communication, optimizers, etc. We present novel approaches for fast
large-scale training of BERT model which individually ameliorates each
component thereby leading to a new level of BERT training performance. Load
balancing is imperative in distributed BERT training since its training
datasets are characterized by samples with various lengths. Communication cost,
which is proportional to the scale of distributed training, needs to be hidden
by useful computation. In addition, the optimizers, e.g., ADAM, LAMB, etc.,
need to be carefully re-evaluated in the context of large-scale distributed
training. We propose two new ideas, (1) local presorting based on dataset
stratification for load balancing and (2) bucket-wise gradient clipping before
allreduce which allows us to benefit from the overlap of gradient computation
and synchronization as well as the fast training of gradient clipping before
allreduce. We also re-evaluate existing optimizers via hyperparameter
optimization and utilize ADAM, which also contributes to fast training via
larger batches than existing methods. Our proposed methods, all combined, give
the fastest MLPerf BERT training of 25.1 (22.3) seconds on 1,024 NVIDIA A100
GPUs, which is 1.33x (1.13x) and 1.57x faster than the other top two (one)
submissions to MLPerf v1.1 (v2.0). Our implementation and evaluation results
are available at MLPerf v1.1~v2.1. | [
-0.7831659913063049,
-0.9414930939674377,
0.15429602563381195,
0.6588097214698792,
-0.21732203662395477,
0.05671946704387665,
-0.2956196367740631,
-0.5703823566436768,
0.17684127390384674,
0.30806225538253784,
-0.9230878353118896,
0.17828848958015442,
-0.7845829129219055,
0.0229499451816082,
-0.48663532733917236,
0.9745744466781616,
-0.024759305641055107,
0.3698408305644989,
-0.3713300824165344,
-0.20228980481624603,
-0.2068483531475067,
-0.6037139296531677,
-0.8385025262832642,
-0.4934220612049103,
0.774161696434021,
0.38197338581085205,
0.6763267517089844,
0.6074049472808838,
1.0393677949905396,
0.3785012364387512,
-0.160776749253273,
-0.003022867487743497,
-0.7454620003700256,
0.3397669792175293,
0.14081470668315887,
-0.16186560690402985,
-0.35601070523262024,
-0.3251281976699829,
0.9788125157356262,
0.7192692160606384,
-0.3494444787502289,
0.2451470047235489,
0.03747028112411499,
0.8848398327827454,
-0.7425484657287598,
-0.11993817239999771,
-0.541246771812439,
0.2838536202907562,
-0.2339843362569809,
0.07790958881378174,
-0.2646602392196655,
-0.2020851969718933,
0.3208642601966858,
-0.3488074839115143,
0.5668706297874451,
-0.09464962035417557,
0.9296575784683228,
0.45423609018325806,
-0.037383999675512314,
0.06980358064174652,
-0.8340922594070435,
0.9449354410171509,
-0.4598163664340973,
0.4899232089519501,
0.06205461546778679,
0.47743353247642517,
-0.08375908434391022,
-0.8630815744400024,
-0.369645357131958,
0.13758492469787598,
0.25136199593544006,
-0.06789613515138626,
0.11215639859437943,
-0.0668620765209198,
0.3759738504886627,
0.39989084005355835,
-0.3753542900085449,
0.3230563700199127,
-0.11520728468894958,
0.18774071335792542,
0.6895660758018494,
-0.061333443969488144,
-0.2557413578033447,
0.29491209983825684,
-0.7888503074645996,
-0.5303892493247986,
-0.3528588116168976,
0.1148366630077362,
0.31143373250961304,
0.39778366684913635,
0.13356749713420868,
-0.04286600649356842,
0.18080928921699524,
0.7239571213722229,
0.06513888388872147,
-0.027874881401658058,
0.529356062412262,
0.059019140899181366,
-0.2800566554069519,
0.14792220294475555,
0.42698410153388977,
0.2635742425918579,
0.1557745337486267,
0.04471883922815323,
-0.36179739236831665,
-0.6218833327293396,
0.270088255405426,
-1.1184120178222656,
-0.15635083615779877,
0.2999081611633301,
-0.6662421226501465,
-0.41200950741767883,
-0.12492837756872177,
-0.7485240697860718,
-0.4093802869319916,
-0.3925859034061432,
0.6055326461791992,
-0.2658423185348511,
-0.2872292697429657,
-0.14460518956184387,
-0.1804588884115219,
0.37825807929039,
0.43534055352211,
-1.0893365144729614,
0.19656798243522644,
0.9636210203170776,
0.6683834195137024,
-0.07329529523849487,
-0.46666663885116577,
-0.6801959872245789,
-0.2666551172733307,
-0.1301496922969818,
0.4670603275299072,
-0.2930164337158203,
-0.11213430762290955,
0.10240016877651215,
-0.027372440323233604,
-0.1638634204864502,
-0.6218475699424744,
0.5204609036445618,
-0.4955459535121918,
-0.057222817093133926,
-0.6211236119270325,
-0.6748998165130615,
0.1053471639752388,
0.1964157372713089,
-0.5728078484535217,
1.1569037437438965,
-0.1674812287092209,
-1.0026687383651733,
0.48218148946762085,
-0.4890531897544861,
-0.7455064058303833,
-0.07346539199352264,
0.17465724050998688,
-0.6825267672538757,
-0.16864387691020966,
0.4144345819950104,
0.6113376617431641,
-0.053708285093307495,
0.005442968104034662,
-0.4057794213294983,
-0.5949878096580505,
-0.3109840452671051,
-0.13952428102493286,
0.8941187262535095,
0.22125814855098724,
-0.4646792411804199,
0.02048243209719658,
-0.49911388754844666,
0.2691502571105957,
0.37617045640945435,
-0.28474393486976624,
0.051169853657484055,
0.20706941187381744,
0.27088794112205505,
-0.19391027092933655,
0.297643780708313,
-0.46315711736679077,
0.248721644282341,
-0.2446591854095459,
0.2511198818683624,
0.9877564311027527,
-0.1821708083152771,
0.26331764459609985,
-0.3137047588825226,
0.06304875761270523,
-0.42740654945373535,
0.8356992602348328,
-0.14549729228019714,
-0.1853843480348587,
-0.7268205285072327,
-0.6483916640281677,
0.4737715423107147,
0.41571542620658875,
-0.7078779935836792,
0.46739962697029114,
0.03647307679057121,
-0.5040845274925232,
-0.6018934845924377,
0.199025496840477,
0.23140528798103333,
0.40984857082366943,
0.3863278925418854,
-0.20907072722911835,
-0.6756897568702698,
-0.8800275325775146,
-0.04317406564950943,
0.3387463092803955,
-0.03971249982714653,
0.24820758402347565,
0.3930377960205078,
-0.15941981971263885,
0.6947037577629089,
-0.3282393217086792,
-0.2871090769767761,
-0.26992884278297424,
0.20690548419952393,
0.463833212852478,
0.6608136296272278,
0.7958842515945435,
-0.7064042687416077,
-0.46816471219062805,
-0.44799157977104187,
-0.5691729187965393,
0.1190594807267189,
-0.12336086481809616,
-0.33866316080093384,
0.05120415985584259,
0.37161779403686523,
-0.5231791138648987,
0.12113010138273239,
0.39684298634529114,
0.04100051894783974,
0.44549795985221863,
-0.49099552631378174,
-0.012333955615758896,
-0.45264771580696106,
-0.2488640695810318,
-0.16724370419979095,
-0.29121047258377075,
-0.3788178265094757,
0.4302602708339691,
-0.06988583505153656,
-0.12596572935581207,
-0.5437448620796204,
0.06027984619140625,
-0.3311845660209656,
-0.22234076261520386,
-0.349915474653244,
-0.20284977555274963,
-0.28533437848091125,
0.40242481231689453,
-0.30174151062965393,
0.5345224738121033,
0.8009570837020874,
-0.39737188816070557,
0.5502467155456543,
0.5180166959762573,
-0.3141428828239441,
0.3334478437900543,
-0.7945445775985718,
0.09664376080036163,
-0.4299349784851074,
0.5619925260543823,
-0.4984203577041626,
0.17978940904140472,
0.07182984799146652,
-0.1262596994638443,
0.47069743275642395,
-0.031244562938809395,
-0.7853769063949585,
-0.47241491079330444,
-0.35131382942199707,
0.2210673987865448,
0.5854306817054749,
-1.0301322937011719,
0.5898979306221008,
0.033011049032211304,
0.148405984044075,
-0.9090224504470825,
-0.4683196544647217,
-0.16587992012500763,
0.09215202927589417,
-0.7668920159339905,
0.34801894426345825,
-0.09020854532718658,
-0.23199360072612762,
-0.3252520263195038,
-0.29659998416900635,
-0.21736498177051544,
0.21230679750442505,
0.09811174124479294,
0.08020685613155365,
0.1169130727648735,
0.1614040732383728,
-0.269430011510849,
0.11373856663703918,
-0.10382887721061707,
-0.14277197420597076,
0.523783266544342,
-0.17426124215126038,
-0.31628158688545227,
-0.3524036407470703,
0.5494625568389893,
0.5674524307250977,
-0.39449283480644226,
1.154973030090332,
1.2231849431991577,
-0.16239172220230103,
-0.4478726089000702,
-0.5884485840797424,
-0.41103118658065796,
-0.5240699052810669,
0.3634577691555023,
-0.061493802815675735,
-0.6466566324234009,
0.35341739654541016,
-0.1295844316482544,
0.49872252345085144,
0.22941787540912628,
0.6169978976249695,
-0.5589063167572021,
0.774982750415802,
0.843839168548584,
-0.2907680869102478,
0.9338770508766174,
-0.400009423494339,
0.2612611949443817,
-0.2532459795475006,
0.07131551206111908,
-0.3894389867782593,
-0.8343600630760193,
-0.4730687737464905,
-0.4981536567211151,
0.3133682310581207,
0.2040555328130722,
-0.5382258296012878,
0.08462968468666077,
-0.6041728854179382,
0.5802759528160095,
0.7557344436645508,
0.276601642370224,
-0.25411808490753174,
0.21930718421936035,
-0.050498005002737045,
0.1483640819787979,
-0.9125398397445679,
0.28207364678382874,
1.0680898427963257,
0.43067285418510437,
0.6498594284057617,
-0.3667140007019043,
0.7643018364906311,
0.5399717092514038,
0.2153296023607254,
-0.4545106887817383,
0.5006942749023438,
-0.25498488545417786,
-0.7705382704734802,
-0.4447491466999054,
-0.6117014288902283,
-0.7208593487739563,
0.5167064070701599,
-0.6077489256858826,
-0.3350968360900879,
0.030872361734509468,
0.23351342976093292,
0.007824784144759178,
0.6494045257568359,
-0.8555214405059814,
0.7058366537094116,
-0.41487836837768555,
-0.4745914041996002,
-0.4341866970062256,
-0.8648989200592041,
0.04480557516217232,
0.017541853711009026,
0.08707528561353683,
-0.22634105384349823,
0.5403697490692139,
0.6418808698654175,
-0.8202546834945679,
0.48381495475769043,
-0.8123639225959778,
0.004420673940330744,
0.1545666754245758,
-0.41693276166915894,
0.7704054117202759,
-0.2168097048997879,
0.04951845854520798,
0.37433528900146484,
-0.11999145895242691,
-0.8726551532745361,
-0.43567049503326416,
0.6033269166946411,
-0.8510174751281738,
-0.2708840072154999,
-0.3209196925163269,
-0.4304473102092743,
-0.12452992796897888,
0.006673833820968866,
0.19154570996761322,
0.23073945939540863,
-0.093904048204422,
0.3265526294708252,
0.8639429807662964,
-0.039919737726449966,
0.8009523749351501,
0.2661615014076233,
0.05764935538172722,
-0.3515416383743286,
0.6953609585762024,
0.015653766691684723,
0.11395811289548874,
0.3672710657119751,
-0.12473306804895401,
0.02664947509765625,
-0.3040944039821625,
-0.14715668559074402,
0.1593170166015625,
-0.5464927554130554,
-0.056189414113759995,
-0.42593932151794434,
-0.13163544237613678,
-0.09035396575927734,
-0.32421886920928955,
-0.7359495759010315,
-0.3061562478542328,
0.044755786657333374,
0.13049964606761932,
0.2502730190753937,
0.2829257845878601,
-0.14220118522644043,
0.6845298409461975,
-0.7364322543144226,
0.07830965518951416,
0.35087117552757263,
0.5050583481788635,
0.5164141654968262,
0.041240036487579346,
-0.3832983374595642,
-0.048217806965112686,
-0.2901865839958191,
-0.21527086198329926,
0.004647788126021624,
0.36044391989707947,
0.5869863033294678,
0.5956238508224487,
0.18785513937473297,
0.7567933201789856,
-0.768735408782959,
0.27173033356666565,
0.45706260204315186,
-0.7706149816513062,
0.3511630892753601,
-0.12696950137615204,
0.03733856976032257,
0.49403858184814453,
0.37098029255867004,
-0.2324148565530777,
-0.15982647240161896,
-0.522544801235199,
-1.1659364700317383,
0.598281979560852,
0.4015200436115265,
0.019440986216068268,
0.3426971733570099,
0.27049151062965393,
0.2501668334007263,
0.20511075854301453,
-0.32622018456459045,
-0.4406912326812744,
-0.06712935864925385,
-0.0390707328915596,
-0.0699680894613266,
-0.2557864189147949,
-0.3739135265350342,
-0.791435956954956,
0.7181397080421448,
0.23473306000232697,
0.5343983173370361,
0.26477211713790894,
-0.09154869616031647,
-0.1557779312133789,
-0.13536851108074188,
0.4185519516468048,
0.7337796092033386,
-0.6767786145210266,
-0.17471843957901,
0.14329129457473755,
-0.45920151472091675,
0.013899140059947968,
0.46742895245552063,
-0.015095840208232403,
0.15409758687019348,
0.6004034280776978,
0.7503470182418823,
0.16430030763149261,
-0.548149824142456,
0.6448572874069214,
-0.14127255976200104,
-0.5965443253517151,
-0.3850390613079071,
0.03162023052573204,
-0.02619391679763794,
0.6636235117912292,
0.5468307137489319,
0.20052692294120789,
-0.3933691382408142,
-0.10310105234384537,
0.5049241781234741,
0.467790812253952,
0.03412872552871704,
-0.02650255337357521,
0.6204725503921509,
0.4981901943683624,
-0.10595083981752396,
0.8827326893806458,
-0.01271766982972622,
-0.4858648180961609,
0.5845577120780945,
0.20985670387744904,
0.7724502682685852,
-0.27091437578201294,
0.01572517491877079,
0.3062516450881958,
0.33295226097106934,
-0.3588612377643585,
0.18330319225788116,
-0.4667258560657501,
-0.810581624507904,
-0.61913001537323,
-0.7104564905166626,
-0.5957151055335999,
-0.21759209036827087,
-0.7707629203796387,
-0.011238480918109417,
-0.8538160920143127,
-0.3766912817955017,
0.14112256467342377,
0.014178569428622723,
-0.9456467628479004,
0.05646654963493347,
0.34936168789863586,
0.976981520652771,
-0.6605931520462036,
0.6685605645179749,
0.5854336023330688,
0.03882856294512749,
-0.28491196036338806,
-0.032214779406785965,
-0.37612229585647583,
-0.9409414529800415,
0.766620397567749,
0.10220684856176376,
0.23152177035808563,
-0.06137389689683914,
-0.7976211309432983,
-0.8321167826652527,
0.9342439770698547,
0.29394015669822693,
-0.8989880681037903,
0.006495639681816101,
-0.09165121614933014,
0.19407859444618225,
-0.014989318326115608,
0.3968496024608612,
0.5525194406509399,
0.5395528674125671,
0.2653186023235321,
-0.9356603026390076,
-0.23254039883613586,
0.035516273230314255,
-0.07947802543640137,
0.39725762605667114,
-0.912713885307312,
0.8959781527519226,
-0.2816286087036133,
0.284499853849411,
-0.1888890564441681,
0.5115224719047546,
0.06711860746145248,
0.13363707065582275,
0.8929692506790161,
1.029017686843872,
0.7678709626197815,
-0.11805310100317001,
0.7494416236877441,
-0.15716873109340668,
0.7785248756408691,
1.0447026491165161,
-0.44225889444351196,
0.8049591779708862,
0.4761017858982086,
-0.3766164183616638,
0.2558195888996124,
0.6558936834335327,
-0.5106369256973267,
0.7895767092704773,
0.287197470664978,
-0.32643142342567444,
-0.383585661649704,
0.11907973885536194,
-0.5612107515335083,
0.19249244034290314,
-0.19272251427173615,
-0.39506199955940247,
-0.5945780277252197,
0.4113978445529938,
0.02927233837544918,
-0.5221276879310608,
-0.4731115996837616,
0.40281978249549866,
-0.1796485334634781,
-0.12782366573810577,
1.0301055908203125,
-0.0927228182554245,
0.8224897980690002,
-0.5921968221664429,
0.057670142501592636,
-0.305988609790802,
0.6726852655410767,
-0.1642095297574997,
-0.3869380056858063,
0.026734793558716774,
0.022392911836504936,
-0.30777934193611145,
-0.8791038990020752,
0.7152047157287598,
-0.043029382824897766,
-0.5565569400787354,
0.49525129795074463,
0.321819543838501,
0.09243857115507126,
-0.2167508900165558,
-0.7613929510116577,
0.15955635905265808,
0.03266165778040886,
-0.2979981005191803,
0.4320189654827118,
0.2252056896686554,
0.32088062167167664,
0.7715403437614441,
0.6638731360435486,
-0.1637246310710907,
0.17541199922561646,
0.22033903002738953,
0.9663461446762085,
-0.4816007614135742,
-0.3970835208892822,
-0.6699835062026978,
0.22781133651733398,
-0.0913829430937767,
-0.08893638104200363,
0.5006444454193115,
0.31832852959632874,
1.070664882659912,
-0.012497740797698498,
0.286452054977417,
-0.19819943606853485,
0.44191646575927734,
-0.06423456966876984,
0.8237688541412354,
-0.6222130060195923,
-0.11242428421974182,
-0.2594369351863861,
-1.0444918870925903,
-0.023983145132660866,
0.4993509352207184,
-0.009553635492920876,
-0.02379234880208969,
0.5281636118888855,
0.19264543056488037,
0.2243974804878235,
0.1310667097568512,
-0.07484836876392365,
0.1873321533203125,
0.28842899203300476,
0.412544310092926,
0.6032207608222961,
-0.35252639651298523,
0.5732786059379578,
-0.5795109272003174,
-0.35648593306541443,
-0.35667684674263,
-0.7926326394081116,
-0.9240810871124268,
-0.2556714117527008,
-0.17987580597400665,
0.08864995092153549,
0.1984081268310547,
0.9796759486198425,
0.9728369116783142,
-0.6458469033241272,
-0.06212906166911125,
-0.05630015581846237,
0.02286355383694172,
-0.7726650238037109,
-0.20603473484516144,
0.4157167375087738,
-0.5802692770957947,
-0.6449049711227417,
0.1588345468044281,
-0.1781204491853714,
-0.07628839462995529,
-0.057174261659383774,
0.11181207746267319,
-0.24740833044052124,
-0.27977627515792847,
0.624066174030304,
0.10363911092281342,
-0.31976449489593506,
-0.2639840245246887,
-0.3568854033946991,
0.26767605543136597,
0.0933370292186737,
0.9103900194168091,
-0.6555045247077942,
0.38966572284698486,
0.4693063199520111,
1.0053889751434326,
0.9551195502281189,
0.2382238358259201,
0.34535592794418335,
-1.0006139278411865,
0.4815402925014496,
0.3452375829219818,
0.30001306533813477,
0.18408085405826569,
-0.2931002974510193,
0.37904092669487,
0.36107441782951355,
-0.8008660674095154,
-0.913479208946228,
-0.1240936741232872,
-0.7339685559272766,
-0.3862208425998688,
0.47878360748291016,
-0.21202591061592102,
-0.15058328211307526,
0.48633256554603577,
0.08215217292308807,
0.1357506364583969,
-0.21577948331832886,
0.7222397327423096,
0.7570776343345642,
-0.30376136302948,
-0.2236487716436386,
-0.6854062080383301,
0.4452674984931946,
0.7502491474151611,
-0.41532406210899353,
0.1568519026041031,
0.17489463090896606,
0.182790145277977,
-0.14468763768672943,
0.37821200489997864,
0.2199532687664032,
-0.12228323519229889,
-0.006591289769858122,
0.4357818067073822,
-0.2653965950012207,
-0.3630612790584564,
-0.08685494214296341,
0.15336132049560547,
-0.3115423321723938,
-0.6719291806221008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02446v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02446v3 | LQER: Low-Rank Quantization Error Reconstruction for LLMs | 2024-02-04T10:59:52 | 2024-05-30T09:49:47 | Cheng Zhang, Jianyi Cheng, George A. Constantinides, Yiren Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Post-training quantization of Large Language Models (LLMs) is challenging. In
this work, we introduce Low-rank Quantization Error Reduction (LQER), which
combines quantization and low-rank approximation to recover the model
capability. LQER leverages an activation-induced scale matrix to drive the
singular value distribution of quantization error towards a desirable
distribution, which enables nearly-lossless W4A8 quantization on various LLMs
and downstream tasks without the need for knowledge distillation, grid search,
or gradient-base iterative optimization. Unlike existing methods, the
computation pattern of LQER eliminates the need for specialized Scatter and
Gather processes to collect high-precision weights from irregular memory
locations. Our W4A8 LLMs achieve near-lossless performance on six popular
downstream tasks, while using 1.36$\times$ fewer hardware resources than the
leading state-of-the-art method. We open-source our framework at
https://github.com/ChengZhang-98/lqer | [
0.021902818232774734,
-0.34347468614578247,
0.48881927132606506,
-0.07659203559160233,
-0.11421756446361542,
0.25020644068717957,
-0.26281043887138367,
0.12223349511623383,
-0.000861244392581284,
0.3746095597743988,
-0.38653504848480225,
-0.42679563164711,
-0.6011350154876709,
-0.0890878438949585,
-0.29479941725730896,
0.7389503121376038,
0.014932614751160145,
0.15286046266555786,
0.010580317117273808,
-0.053758855909109116,
0.01188108790665865,
-0.5445973873138428,
-0.9157729744911194,
0.009690473787486553,
0.7140910029411316,
0.2960018217563629,
0.35446643829345703,
0.3834550082683563,
0.3690913915634155,
0.25424960255622864,
-0.14050649106502533,
-0.01785646751523018,
-1.0268136262893677,
-0.046143002808094025,
0.2791465222835541,
-0.5393256545066833,
-0.9242156147956848,
-0.29191410541534424,
1.0266025066375732,
0.6382281184196472,
-0.16312304139137268,
0.1879245936870575,
0.0556306466460228,
0.8545925617218018,
-0.9176064133644104,
0.18047170341014862,
-0.46576371788978577,
0.004378954414278269,
-0.14941681921482086,
-0.05985826253890991,
-0.42283353209495544,
-0.43378934264183044,
-0.38453754782676697,
-0.5352417826652527,
0.018223127350211143,
0.024257319048047066,
0.5632418394088745,
0.5548433661460876,
-0.4823063611984253,
0.4013642966747284,
-0.9060754776000977,
1.026748776435852,
-1.0302802324295044,
0.4382062554359436,
0.2753120958805084,
0.2600497603416443,
-0.1419060081243515,
-0.8905928134918213,
-0.5968713164329529,
0.3347703814506531,
0.07280431687831879,
0.04206721857190132,
-0.4311027228832245,
0.40243905782699585,
0.35731494426727295,
0.6788247227668762,
-0.4325311779975891,
0.17105349898338318,
-0.5132023096084595,
-0.34300583600997925,
0.38381752371788025,
-0.010579412803053856,
-0.095302514731884,
0.05546500161290169,
0.1304609626531601,
-0.17546166479587555,
-0.9292733669281006,
0.28592249751091003,
0.057776328176259995,
0.11956855654716492,
0.056733548641204834,
0.26030465960502625,
-0.39403244853019714,
0.5065599679946899,
0.0476454421877861,
-0.45391198992729187,
0.1781959980726242,
-0.18801961839199066,
-0.30980435013771057,
-0.02961880713701248,
0.8120371103286743,
0.18890012800693512,
-0.16571226716041565,
-0.17099520564079285,
-0.46187564730644226,
-0.11968402564525604,
-0.03508381545543671,
-1.140673041343689,
-0.20017530024051666,
0.22418734431266785,
-0.5074491500854492,
-0.1291399896144867,
-0.39338812232017517,
-0.384893000125885,
-0.34973233938217163,
0.006278814747929573,
0.547818124294281,
-0.1677744835615158,
-0.12242920696735382,
-0.07305242866277695,
0.1254744827747345,
0.4393044710159302,
0.3935297131538391,
-0.5968142151832581,
0.194838747382164,
0.42244359850883484,
0.6283389329910278,
-0.06355292350053787,
0.034088924527168274,
-0.9512520432472229,
0.14491619169712067,
-0.3914843797683716,
0.5032784938812256,
0.03745907545089722,
-0.12377592921257019,
-0.17914512753486633,
0.023327676579356194,
0.0008524834993295372,
-0.454175740480423,
0.5095584988594055,
-0.7421174645423889,
-0.03379737213253975,
-0.05344110727310181,
-0.4856996536254883,
-0.09994915127754211,
0.20560923218727112,
-0.8112471699714661,
1.018754482269287,
0.34293806552886963,
-0.6293853521347046,
0.12564881145954132,
-0.4238399565219879,
-0.0048833866603672504,
0.1307474970817566,
0.002488074591383338,
-0.6169423460960388,
0.36480432748794556,
0.13453827798366547,
0.2887977957725525,
-0.335359126329422,
0.0328165628015995,
-0.2646130919456482,
-0.7689846754074097,
-0.04778202250599861,
-0.5007699728012085,
0.48206669092178345,
-0.19251714646816254,
-0.4568352699279785,
0.33641642332077026,
-1.0700478553771973,
0.28710252046585083,
0.10113641619682312,
-0.5138600468635559,
-0.38085734844207764,
0.11670663207769394,
-0.09422580152750015,
0.1280527263879776,
0.4436732828617096,
-0.4652414619922638,
0.23207111656665802,
-0.43033942580223083,
0.6136038303375244,
0.5914615988731384,
-0.15606851875782013,
0.6955530643463135,
-0.05047953128814697,
0.6077960133552551,
-0.10142946988344193,
0.17771536111831665,
0.2155955731868744,
-0.09575527161359787,
-0.9578498005867004,
-0.5355104804039001,
0.5098418593406677,
0.4946473240852356,
-0.9543258547782898,
0.30857372283935547,
-0.8430026769638062,
-0.3889206647872925,
-0.792526125907898,
0.15274788439273834,
0.5155946016311646,
0.07304917275905609,
0.2735541760921478,
-0.08751504868268967,
-0.4963463544845581,
-0.9243713617324829,
0.02261636219918728,
0.026162533089518547,
-0.33466532826423645,
-0.14072829484939575,
0.14171379804611206,
-0.32631009817123413,
0.7298097014427185,
-0.32316648960113525,
-0.4277355968952179,
-0.19690977036952972,
-0.08459310233592987,
0.2285594791173935,
0.5598548650741577,
0.16286014020442963,
-0.41947367787361145,
-0.293490469455719,
-0.0944126769900322,
-0.4830693006515503,
0.13573946058750153,
0.27428409457206726,
-0.2177043855190277,
0.291873037815094,
0.7532175183296204,
-0.47725728154182434,
0.4226081669330597,
0.9551279544830322,
-0.0028005284257233143,
0.10941699147224426,
-0.10993830114603043,
0.2486327588558197,
-1.0953434705734253,
-0.004191532731056213,
-0.2936738431453705,
-0.3688465356826782,
-0.6140220165252686,
-0.09553839266300201,
0.11525294929742813,
0.05341680347919464,
-0.35301926732063293,
0.35893476009368896,
-0.48752087354660034,
-0.22459767758846283,
-0.2562330663204193,
-0.014905928634107113,
0.1127145066857338,
0.628045380115509,
-0.2916020452976227,
0.9049953818321228,
0.32300254702568054,
-0.3322100341320038,
0.08992385864257812,
0.009347517974674702,
-0.18756188452243805,
0.4295395314693451,
-0.5493326187133789,
0.1823534369468689,
-0.2822120487689972,
0.29929521679878235,
-0.9903812408447266,
-0.08870334923267365,
0.17908215522766113,
-0.42990005016326904,
0.17670682072639465,
-0.49938783049583435,
-0.4902524948120117,
-0.07052724063396454,
-0.5934349894523621,
0.7018834352493286,
0.8221828937530518,
-0.3382720351219177,
0.7799748182296753,
0.31492936611175537,
-0.14758656919002533,
-0.49093905091285706,
-0.5799934267997742,
-0.14448685944080353,
-0.1451909989118576,
-0.15582183003425598,
0.17039142549037933,
-0.09198074787855148,
-0.07845107465982437,
-0.26065367460250854,
-0.09407557547092438,
-0.06855130195617676,
0.0378984697163105,
0.19672508537769318,
-0.016054105013608932,
-0.3872232735157013,
0.011522497981786728,
0.1868969351053238,
-0.0671847015619278,
0.015680568292737007,
-0.16887471079826355,
0.40226852893829346,
-0.16240625083446503,
-0.24089689552783966,
-0.405050665140152,
0.08531845360994339,
0.6588638424873352,
-0.15133629739284515,
0.796596348285675,
0.6071594953536987,
-0.6241158843040466,
-0.21825401484966278,
-0.3181120753288269,
-0.1434554159641266,
-0.4717491865158081,
0.5188581347465515,
-0.3598966598510742,
-1.089003086090088,
0.21872712671756744,
-0.10397382080554962,
0.08611638098955154,
0.3422240912914276,
0.3359878659248352,
-0.22439107298851013,
1.0445454120635986,
0.5589291453361511,
-0.22672291100025177,
0.3966926634311676,
-0.41249004006385803,
0.5512822270393372,
-0.8552502393722534,
0.25829052925109863,
-0.26817426085472107,
-0.45632460713386536,
-0.5377042293548584,
-0.6097732186317444,
0.6300313472747803,
0.34768229722976685,
-0.38979318737983704,
-0.10357069969177246,
-0.2855597138404846,
0.3222240209579468,
0.6513129472732544,
-0.0107954703271389,
0.5140131115913391,
0.1788169890642166,
0.5618515610694885,
-0.3588162958621979,
-0.8476250171661377,
-0.23718193173408508,
0.9344502091407776,
0.2595963478088379,
0.6298108696937561,
0.14130911231040955,
0.9841495752334595,
0.07639439404010773,
0.46491938829421997,
-1.197601318359375,
0.5316538214683533,
-0.15401485562324524,
0.09435448795557022,
-0.6514862775802612,
-0.7778904438018799,
-0.8818378448486328,
0.4466792941093445,
-0.18767483532428741,
-0.45895951986312866,
0.02783828228712082,
0.4279933273792267,
-0.5677875280380249,
0.5043017268180847,
-0.393286794424057,
0.7516233921051025,
0.15769065916538239,
-0.30054110288619995,
-0.11768671125173569,
-0.3761599659919739,
0.6921401619911194,
-0.19206418097019196,
0.5552682280540466,
0.02176930196583271,
-0.04823695123195648,
0.8817999362945557,
-0.5612189769744873,
0.7784616351127625,
-0.3121868669986725,
-0.5523167252540588,
0.03509123995900154,
0.09824584424495697,
0.79178386926651,
-0.2580290138721466,
0.06568701565265656,
0.04169519618153572,
0.18862663209438324,
-0.47819820046424866,
-0.618116021156311,
0.6982499361038208,
-0.6933618783950806,
-0.34618860483169556,
-0.2964613139629364,
-0.5846856236457825,
-0.3367379605770111,
0.22576427459716797,
0.09948887676000595,
0.3515385687351227,
-0.04651831462979317,
0.40270063281059265,
0.6341837048530579,
-0.024231981486082077,
0.5341457724571228,
0.3647536635398865,
-0.008451000787317753,
-0.7619426846504211,
1.124691367149353,
0.1180214062333107,
0.23443488776683807,
0.47872474789619446,
-0.08646266162395477,
-0.12835469841957092,
-0.9521705508232117,
-0.3336346447467804,
0.300685316324234,
-0.6534874439239502,
-0.6095858216285706,
-0.4762522578239441,
-0.29826024174690247,
-0.16774921119213104,
0.022160915657877922,
-0.7753786444664001,
-0.5720202326774597,
-0.16452552378177643,
0.11331666260957718,
0.34664833545684814,
0.40192845463752747,
0.10056816041469574,
0.76047682762146,
-1.0733966827392578,
0.19122740626335144,
0.25658372044563293,
0.18009606003761292,
0.007958326488733292,
-0.7159157395362854,
-0.65499347448349,
0.09086338430643082,
-0.05397501960396767,
-0.3033635914325714,
0.4710904061794281,
0.37310540676116943,
0.09423303604125977,
0.20993559062480927,
0.277103453874588,
0.7542336583137512,
-0.47236010432243347,
0.6442457437515259,
0.05671800673007965,
-1.0943286418914795,
0.24478007853031158,
-0.12236277759075165,
0.39943429827690125,
0.6044372320175171,
0.08302959054708481,
-0.3211699426174164,
-0.44116705656051636,
-0.4187118411064148,
-1.2025541067123413,
0.5546489953994751,
0.2899056077003479,
-0.13267876207828522,
0.3695511221885681,
0.4977673888206482,
-0.3540378510951996,
0.29149654507637024,
-1.013558030128479,
-0.3154684007167816,
0.1084962785243988,
-0.3940042555332184,
-0.22852782905101776,
-0.36444467306137085,
-0.13969223201274872,
-0.1832345426082611,
0.8149827718734741,
-0.4324350953102112,
0.11253581196069717,
-0.10246578603982925,
-0.44403982162475586,
-0.3116509020328522,
0.41287052631378174,
0.47091296315193176,
0.4972474277019501,
-0.27328383922576904,
0.4090920686721802,
0.21538469195365906,
-0.3563624620437622,
0.23288913071155548,
0.1643608659505844,
-0.2657073438167572,
-0.1047777608036995,
0.2673429846763611,
0.842418909072876,
0.7092669010162354,
-0.6599940657615662,
0.6684192419052124,
-0.2270844280719757,
-0.2014150619506836,
-0.4406963288784027,
-0.1497729867696762,
0.16305556893348694,
0.3905889093875885,
0.5914268493652344,
-0.11941966414451599,
0.3843190371990204,
-0.053994398564100266,
-0.02205539494752884,
0.43667998909950256,
-0.14912669360637665,
-0.42500269412994385,
0.6564480662345886,
0.034645356237888336,
0.10653244704008102,
0.3446044623851776,
-0.41926756501197815,
-0.36772167682647705,
0.2106255739927292,
0.21034175157546997,
0.5925676822662354,
-0.21821607649326324,
-0.07950284332036972,
0.5813025236129761,
0.2249743938446045,
-0.29162129759788513,
0.2330460548400879,
0.03959845006465912,
-0.6106804013252258,
-0.8750872015953064,
-0.7132880091667175,
-0.3951497972011566,
0.3326018750667572,
-0.7104079127311707,
0.13893014192581177,
-0.45009514689445496,
0.017981478944420815,
-0.4345487356185913,
-0.20239049196243286,
-0.34500962495803833,
0.099645234644413,
0.08508075773715973,
0.367612361907959,
-0.33109384775161743,
0.9539784789085388,
0.40282875299453735,
-0.17975202202796936,
-0.8368017077445984,
-0.012338737957179546,
-0.3163699805736542,
-0.7558438777923584,
0.6294955015182495,
-0.10940807312726974,
-0.22521711885929108,
0.7555465698242188,
-0.4539337456226349,
-1.0836259126663208,
1.3605035543441772,
0.4908701181411743,
-0.8325872421264648,
-0.3093366324901581,
0.024216141551733017,
0.30242061614990234,
0.1159779354929924,
0.281904399394989,
0.6853109002113342,
0.2498420774936676,
-0.004834298510104418,
-1.0146583318710327,
0.21528521180152893,
0.05895327031612396,
0.27593329548835754,
0.3994704484939575,
-0.53407883644104,
0.8204317092895508,
-0.056736793369054794,
-0.13821665942668915,
0.04341404512524605,
0.7777252793312073,
0.5540665984153748,
-0.03706757724285126,
0.5970931649208069,
0.484341025352478,
0.6041914820671082,
-0.0007705648895353079,
0.6988146305084229,
-0.3811608850955963,
0.5474120378494263,
0.8268031477928162,
-0.07765381038188934,
1.1983155012130737,
0.7694550156593323,
-0.39973562955856323,
0.28130385279655457,
0.3669077455997467,
0.412911057472229,
0.5807939767837524,
0.3841477632522583,
-0.40728509426116943,
-0.18117491900920868,
0.24350950121879578,
-0.24117116630077362,
0.27003130316734314,
0.28733503818511963,
-0.01634773053228855,
-0.1690332293510437,
0.010403704829514027,
0.12488662451505661,
-0.3520590364933014,
-0.6745463013648987,
0.7243611812591553,
0.14887136220932007,
-0.2533368766307831,
1.2920173406600952,
-0.0012802615528926253,
0.988793134689331,
-0.42678552865982056,
-0.17523810267448425,
-0.4497588872909546,
0.4560159146785736,
-0.19221711158752441,
-0.028165306895971298,
0.1209176629781723,
-0.36755889654159546,
-0.3246612250804901,
-0.24993400275707245,
0.6279548406600952,
-0.6319125890731812,
-0.4374820590019226,
0.1815420687198639,
0.6380063891410828,
0.07912257313728333,
-0.30885669589042664,
-0.24971647560596466,
0.41583123803138733,
0.03048798255622387,
-0.5024740695953369,
0.5665682554244995,
0.3934786915779114,
-0.13313592970371246,
0.5202506184577942,
0.4208248555660248,
0.15041182935237885,
0.152345672249794,
0.10362911969423294,
0.8288061022758484,
-0.6950635313987732,
-0.23226673901081085,
-0.46213337779045105,
0.6871787905693054,
0.1737108826637268,
0.1955776810646057,
0.3829877972602844,
0.5471336245536804,
0.7472617030143738,
-0.28808528184890747,
0.9065120220184326,
0.09119285643100739,
0.5512877106666565,
-0.6169681549072266,
0.7802877426147461,
-0.6662423610687256,
0.3200586140155792,
0.08606505393981934,
-0.907149612903595,
-0.38243207335472107,
0.6413396000862122,
-0.16303396224975586,
-0.09834007918834686,
0.6565081477165222,
0.8851644396781921,
-0.038801781833171844,
-0.6571407914161682,
0.713036298751831,
0.3409113883972168,
0.24279603362083435,
0.8009815216064453,
0.777364194393158,
-1.0176208019256592,
0.7983863353729248,
-0.1879151314496994,
-0.3967905044555664,
-0.2703320384025574,
-0.6597337126731873,
-0.5683727860450745,
-0.462820827960968,
-0.4390494227409363,
-0.5649786591529846,
-0.08936240524053574,
0.8406710028648376,
0.6317723393440247,
-0.8139840364456177,
-0.20874887704849243,
-0.09880237281322479,
0.10510437935590744,
-0.06819014251232147,
-0.2775987386703491,
0.3997313678264618,
-0.31043654680252075,
-1.0520724058151245,
0.5013097524642944,
0.09896265715360641,
0.028104186058044434,
-0.27681177854537964,
-0.3678222596645355,
0.3668934106826782,
-0.18870919942855835,
0.8272684812545776,
0.374085932970047,
-0.6112083196640015,
-0.14166255295276642,
-0.1163705587387085,
-0.291115939617157,
0.1758543699979782,
0.8230521082878113,
-0.7829963564872742,
-0.053803008049726486,
0.29417362809181213,
0.7284510731697083,
0.5177085995674133,
-0.27837854623794556,
0.5471425652503967,
-0.7716897130012512,
0.29024365544319153,
0.31309109926223755,
0.46700480580329895,
0.31050750613212585,
-0.2789667248725891,
0.3041938543319702,
0.3560523986816406,
-0.47216805815696716,
-1.1779614686965942,
0.08323278278112411,
-1.1108723878860474,
0.11187107861042023,
1.154633641242981,
-0.15937365591526031,
-0.3703860342502594,
0.19966432452201843,
-0.17535953223705292,
0.1867547482252121,
-0.37022385001182556,
0.4975099563598633,
0.33930185437202454,
0.09244753420352936,
-0.8561277985572815,
-0.48288238048553467,
0.8394289612770081,
0.29389336705207825,
-0.8172228932380676,
-0.04152936115860939,
0.6792757511138916,
0.3968542814254761,
-0.13723136484622955,
0.9644930362701416,
0.000018493334209779277,
0.27428311109542847,
-0.15830902755260468,
0.7224300503730774,
0.14751428365707397,
0.17880530655384064,
-0.46010521054267883,
0.18182912468910217,
0.5346518158912659,
-0.18685123324394226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02420v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02420v2 | Factuality of Large Language Models in the Year 2024 | 2024-02-04T09:36:31 | 2024-02-09T06:36:41 | Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Muhammad Arslan Manzoor, Fei Liu, Georgi Georgiev, Rocktim Jyoti Das, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs), especially when instruction-tuned for chat,
have become part of our daily lives, freeing people from the process of
searching, extracting, and integrating information from multiple sources by
offering a straightforward answer to a variety of questions in a single place.
Unfortunately, in many cases, LLM responses are factually incorrect, which
limits their applicability in real-world scenarios. As a result, research on
evaluating and improving the factuality of LLMs has attracted a lot of research
attention recently. In this survey, we critically analyze existing work with
the aim to identify the major challenges and their associated causes, pointing
out to potential solutions for improving the factuality of LLMs, and analyzing
the obstacles to automated factuality evaluation for open-ended text
generation. We further offer an outlook on where future research should go. | [
-0.23964393138885498,
-0.9843806624412537,
0.8925439715385437,
0.07048513740301132,
-0.014405505731701851,
0.006921621970832348,
-0.4711584746837616,
-0.6284080743789673,
-0.09826133400201797,
0.6895608305931091,
-0.5146508812904358,
-0.28453025221824646,
-0.714565098285675,
0.2935523986816406,
-0.41773274540901184,
0.9008296728134155,
-0.0628095418214798,
-0.09043432027101517,
-0.5699784159660339,
-0.2814375162124634,
-0.6381885409355164,
-0.7277166843414307,
-0.443062961101532,
-0.043899036943912506,
0.5853369832038879,
0.41593649983406067,
0.674655556678772,
0.5227794647216797,
0.6745457649230957,
0.46043452620506287,
0.006593423895537853,
0.3184002935886383,
-0.6757990121841431,
0.063588947057724,
-0.10267824679613113,
-0.5067211389541626,
-0.49727514386177063,
0.1419978141784668,
0.9056654572486877,
0.8559359908103943,
0.019391875714063644,
0.19184510409832,
-0.10744228214025497,
0.5821936130523682,
-0.3963979184627533,
0.27609339356422424,
-0.6834883689880371,
-0.03945501893758774,
-0.22422228753566742,
-0.17190420627593994,
-0.5548346638679504,
-0.7202129364013672,
0.2716098129749298,
-0.2010805308818817,
0.12489371001720428,
0.2831398546695709,
0.8403011560440063,
0.23690100014209747,
-0.612506091594696,
-0.7249147891998291,
-1.0256376266479492,
0.9120857119560242,
-1.1056443452835083,
0.5629533529281616,
0.17284412682056427,
0.28345319628715515,
-0.40995463728904724,
-0.589335560798645,
-0.5546255707740784,
-0.3947274088859558,
0.1328587383031845,
-0.20487640798091888,
-0.10229653120040894,
-0.11234937608242035,
0.1935279816389084,
0.2821956276893616,
-0.3394782543182373,
0.2801884710788727,
-0.3904826045036316,
-0.28991690278053284,
0.7257148027420044,
0.3872319161891937,
0.34792783856391907,
0.02526182495057583,
-0.19766511023044586,
0.323922723531723,
-0.776955783367157,
-0.266108900308609,
0.48899033665657043,
0.20942360162734985,
-0.08656678348779678,
0.7568181157112122,
-0.08650041371583939,
0.5068629384040833,
-0.15981647372245789,
-0.4199489951133728,
0.08455221354961395,
-0.46648117899894714,
-0.16255129873752594,
-0.11703146994113922,
0.7128821611404419,
0.4135611951351166,
0.17567987740039825,
-0.08278103172779083,
-0.11420824378728867,
-0.08892979472875595,
0.09619233012199402,
-0.8524309992790222,
0.07067631930112839,
0.48993822932243347,
-0.12757016718387604,
-0.26963379979133606,
-0.16551770269870758,
-0.7597581744194031,
-0.4835311770439148,
-0.31442922353744507,
0.15727749466896057,
-0.2034645676612854,
-0.21990059316158295,
0.24112941324710846,
0.32316726446151733,
0.1844257116317749,
0.7676538228988647,
-0.7557913661003113,
0.13803459703922272,
0.7285535335540771,
0.617978036403656,
-0.175519660115242,
0.046047259122133255,
-0.34352564811706543,
-0.05489325895905495,
-0.578883707523346,
0.8054603934288025,
-0.36073899269104004,
-0.3212134838104248,
0.14198018610477448,
0.06707809865474701,
-0.15829698741436005,
-0.5539928674697876,
0.7034453749656677,
-0.5386552214622498,
0.5622740387916565,
-0.5220411419868469,
-0.7598022818565369,
-0.021332796663045883,
0.6528986096382141,
-0.6527215838432312,
0.6900202035903931,
-0.3182106912136078,
-0.8624736070632935,
0.035862065851688385,
-0.5028003454208374,
-0.05620114877820015,
0.04590826854109764,
-0.21796517074108124,
-0.4396940767765045,
0.06707519292831421,
-0.10583193600177765,
0.3255985379219055,
-0.4558336138725281,
0.7715440988540649,
-0.3254799246788025,
-0.1656060516834259,
0.5887104272842407,
-0.9131385684013367,
0.6980763077735901,
0.13031677901744843,
-0.25451815128326416,
0.07328200340270996,
-0.8970566391944885,
-0.1639500856399536,
0.15401379764080048,
-0.6167109608650208,
0.11260180920362473,
0.30736082792282104,
-0.2208915650844574,
0.2665521502494812,
0.4677140712738037,
-0.8036365509033203,
0.0899021178483963,
-0.4933631718158722,
0.34480926394462585,
0.7313675880432129,
-0.08957508206367493,
0.24487555027008057,
-0.38015511631965637,
0.4580524265766144,
-0.082558773458004,
0.14319594204425812,
-0.18744170665740967,
-0.5694342255592346,
-0.9208677411079407,
-0.216826394200325,
0.31894025206565857,
0.6300714015960693,
-0.5168071985244751,
0.4411605894565582,
-0.3102065920829773,
-0.5115423798561096,
-0.19796529412269592,
0.04104243591427803,
0.16025441884994507,
0.6328108310699463,
-0.07203840464353561,
-0.019386867061257362,
-0.6984653472900391,
-0.8722716569900513,
-0.15578168630599976,
-0.3104628622531891,
0.3051612377166748,
0.319513738155365,
0.5679733753204346,
-0.3975602090358734,
1.0068519115447998,
-0.37915554642677307,
0.16219648718833923,
-0.23148156702518463,
0.02869790978729725,
0.046420469880104065,
0.27852872014045715,
0.2578384578227997,
-0.7845954298973083,
-0.17494149506092072,
-0.14211294054985046,
-0.9071524143218994,
0.038922399282455444,
0.09641780704259872,
0.2840031683444977,
0.6652653813362122,
0.5380953550338745,
-0.8716369271278381,
0.2735059857368469,
0.7567762136459351,
-0.19894953072071075,
0.8621230125427246,
-0.3368346691131592,
0.3011871576309204,
-0.8254226446151733,
0.07399610430002213,
-0.08306478708982468,
-0.12886397540569305,
-0.5819391012191772,
-0.043408170342445374,
-0.059361573308706284,
-0.13193409144878387,
-0.3316532075405121,
0.5551615357398987,
-0.4691590368747711,
-0.013821604661643505,
-0.31866970658302307,
0.39767423272132874,
-0.26288899779319763,
0.1176498681306839,
-0.3945103883743286,
0.7165965437889099,
0.1674002856016159,
-0.508505642414093,
0.691646933555603,
0.21834395825862885,
-0.6364338994026184,
0.18469028174877167,
-0.6005825400352478,
0.12062142044305801,
-0.22767707705497742,
0.7109410762786865,
-1.0345112085342407,
-0.5784091949462891,
0.2928643524646759,
-0.4547221064567566,
0.256193608045578,
0.11368944495916367,
-0.6226280331611633,
-0.4515567421913147,
-0.19648189842700958,
0.23496834933757782,
0.48047560453414917,
-0.4297318756580353,
0.47304782271385193,
0.1855257749557495,
-0.29262781143188477,
-0.7434543371200562,
-0.4203817844390869,
0.5334031581878662,
-0.1104281023144722,
-0.8915468454360962,
-0.2547956705093384,
-0.3325798511505127,
-0.6272478103637695,
-0.03562835976481438,
0.0024422563146799803,
0.12187117338180542,
0.13954167068004608,
0.034200143069028854,
0.5121604204177856,
-0.3689977824687958,
0.20959767699241638,
-0.4535942077636719,
0.12067874521017075,
0.3108333945274353,
-0.1898668259382248,
0.43957436084747314,
-0.23913663625717163,
-0.52252197265625,
-0.2643919885158539,
0.06047683209180832,
0.5527066588401794,
-0.31485551595687866,
0.8974823951721191,
0.3340294361114502,
-0.2629969120025635,
-0.09573163837194443,
-0.9371768236160278,
0.02656378410756588,
-0.5052591562271118,
0.48627468943595886,
0.11084163933992386,
-1.3542007207870483,
0.37039849162101746,
-0.16794046759605408,
0.3611631393432617,
0.25765135884284973,
0.8239337801933289,
-0.07124986499547958,
0.9951015114784241,
0.6054209470748901,
0.35619255900382996,
0.035868089646101,
0.24374882876873016,
0.6588404178619385,
-0.482613742351532,
-0.4877573847770691,
-0.6761949062347412,
0.0385524220764637,
-0.9239989519119263,
-0.51595538854599,
0.3705936074256897,
-0.4006606340408325,
0.08143813163042068,
-0.08406545221805573,
0.06043630465865135,
0.2892950177192688,
0.16983959078788757,
-0.21251429617404938,
0.3634885251522064,
-0.265490859746933,
-0.04171699658036232,
-0.112091064453125,
-0.579779326915741,
-0.8742198944091797,
1.0962438583374023,
0.5656386017799377,
0.5043623447418213,
0.17557929456233978,
0.4438638389110565,
0.08476702868938446,
0.31168028712272644,
-0.8048170208930969,
0.6972700953483582,
0.05918649584054947,
-1.0521700382232666,
-0.4876193702220917,
-0.5735560059547424,
-0.7337179780006409,
0.1740604043006897,
-0.34587788581848145,
-0.6925315260887146,
-0.039273928850889206,
0.3343849778175354,
-0.157136008143425,
0.45583269000053406,
-0.5441144704818726,
0.6634740829467773,
-0.2767477333545685,
-0.41316497325897217,
0.019132070243358612,
-0.7146648168563843,
0.8302102088928223,
-0.4048374891281128,
0.7444419860839844,
-0.42490270733833313,
-0.020711950957775116,
0.528511106967926,
-0.4783795475959778,
0.975766122341156,
-0.00447466503828764,
-0.7359373569488525,
0.4199868142604828,
-0.17896248400211334,
0.6355537176132202,
-0.11717601120471954,
0.0003373720101080835,
-0.06621640920639038,
0.04657986760139465,
-0.34148940443992615,
-0.5763834714889526,
0.7830950021743774,
-0.5367810726165771,
-0.8741629123687744,
-0.46261268854141235,
-0.6304304003715515,
-0.5666749477386475,
-0.013561269268393517,
0.1255044788122177,
0.7704822421073914,
-0.4998404383659363,
0.2748715281486511,
1.0690075159072876,
-0.608481764793396,
0.3709036707878113,
0.5526758432388306,
-0.5441083312034607,
-0.2849595546722412,
1.0975862741470337,
0.2994462549686432,
0.21626020967960358,
0.16563928127288818,
0.2501817047595978,
-0.2472483366727829,
-0.6478029489517212,
-0.5655907988548279,
0.515661895275116,
-0.7239727973937988,
0.11735980212688446,
-0.7430732846260071,
-0.16862502694129944,
-0.5571228265762329,
0.15262094140052795,
-0.5786830186843872,
-0.2658042907714844,
-0.3327138423919678,
-0.02087133377790451,
0.010544762015342712,
0.9622067213058472,
-0.0023934899363666773,
0.06309128552675247,
-1.0435189008712769,
0.16626214981079102,
0.2807387709617615,
0.31287264823913574,
-0.005822479724884033,
-0.8073877096176147,
-0.35458022356033325,
-0.010217626579105854,
-0.19545254111289978,
-0.4308638870716095,
0.21225765347480774,
-0.056133121252059937,
0.3235107362270355,
0.27742302417755127,
0.00922363717108965,
0.3290598392486572,
-0.9512219429016113,
0.8416528105735779,
0.12526071071624756,
-0.7190065979957581,
0.2043081820011139,
-0.4393092393875122,
0.1593993753194809,
0.2287348508834839,
0.5792011618614197,
-0.6341537833213806,
-0.2914116382598877,
-0.5855013132095337,
-0.6856720447540283,
0.5652629137039185,
0.19418592751026154,
0.4032647907733917,
0.060503892600536346,
0.228434756398201,
0.1505563110113144,
0.24606435000896454,
-0.47883108258247375,
-0.061533838510513306,
0.11214568465948105,
-0.37010762095451355,
-0.07143279165029526,
-0.5403080582618713,
0.020680388435721397,
-0.14534036815166473,
0.7254394292831421,
-0.07339370995759964,
0.2487829029560089,
-0.13527588546276093,
0.24024654924869537,
-0.38833510875701904,
0.5898689031600952,
0.8218324780464172,
1.116777777671814,
-0.28515997529029846,
0.06229016184806824,
0.34956616163253784,
-0.3024969696998596,
0.1303006410598755,
-0.08995092660188675,
-0.14700238406658173,
-0.05776647850871086,
0.6071067452430725,
0.7990185022354126,
0.38139477372169495,
-1.0724045038223267,
0.6299316883087158,
-0.01084202155470848,
-0.21971483528614044,
-0.5535088777542114,
0.09738373756408691,
0.369917094707489,
0.20197413861751556,
0.2564694881439209,
-0.05657263472676277,
-0.09187640249729156,
-0.9268785715103149,
-0.1605924665927887,
0.47523728013038635,
-0.3084242045879364,
-0.4369395673274994,
0.4704446792602539,
0.3191373348236084,
-0.21777337789535522,
0.4506657123565674,
0.05847721919417381,
-0.5549201369285583,
0.48706161975860596,
0.589667797088623,
0.6172288656234741,
-0.06129883602261543,
0.01493410486727953,
0.31914591789245605,
0.5777150988578796,
-0.16689588129520416,
0.15196765959262848,
0.4874691069126129,
-0.8970909118652344,
-0.7226178646087646,
-0.6580973267555237,
-0.7921384572982788,
0.35766929388046265,
-0.20508931577205658,
0.3600877821445465,
-0.46973490715026855,
-0.046466097235679626,
-0.15596313774585724,
0.014482356607913971,
-0.41365718841552734,
0.5232303142547607,
0.3311719000339508,
0.8119131326675415,
-0.6172537207603455,
0.7114675045013428,
0.6242402195930481,
-0.1732115000486374,
-0.5414085984230042,
-0.09097874909639359,
0.23169764876365662,
-0.6279341578483582,
0.5845571756362915,
-0.0014393916353583336,
-0.25646519660949707,
-0.19169266521930695,
-1.2968759536743164,
-0.9283506870269775,
0.8257920742034912,
0.47782179713249207,
-0.7338099479675293,
-0.46399369835853577,
0.3250209093093872,
0.5617717504501343,
-0.2086285650730133,
0.0769745334982872,
0.6498437523841858,
0.6407930254936218,
0.2048327624797821,
-0.9185820817947388,
-0.15657849609851837,
-0.020815391093492508,
-0.04893859475851059,
0.08260024338960648,
-0.8383252620697021,
0.7745017409324646,
-0.1654857099056244,
-0.35393980145454407,
0.15312868356704712,
0.8906700015068054,
0.2798839807510376,
0.3147513270378113,
0.4025513529777527,
0.3709135055541992,
0.7904195189476013,
-0.07263894379138947,
0.8822991847991943,
-0.001618137233890593,
0.22779063880443573,
1.0224766731262207,
-0.48711058497428894,
0.7430099248886108,
0.18155595660209656,
-0.27776795625686646,
0.28562629222869873,
0.4116145074367523,
-0.008497929200530052,
-0.1494019478559494,
0.07781078666448593,
-0.44698283076286316,
-0.3298901617527008,
-0.04590515047311783,
-0.231787770986557,
0.5373505353927612,
0.4885510206222534,
-0.03239106759428978,
-0.19240160286426544,
-0.030201774090528488,
0.4058964252471924,
0.28136518597602844,
0.07430769503116608,
0.5969788432121277,
0.011078830808401108,
-0.6132401823997498,
0.4725874066352844,
0.23416857421398163,
0.724808394908905,
-0.5184261202812195,
-0.09415741264820099,
-0.248299703001976,
-0.022962963208556175,
-0.21272501349449158,
-0.5501688718795776,
0.2694885730743408,
0.4441252052783966,
-0.055751003324985504,
0.09834054112434387,
0.729248046875,
-0.381265252828598,
-0.4454382658004761,
0.014502054080367088,
0.4312616288661957,
0.25050678849220276,
0.2528231143951416,
-0.4211586117744446,
0.690731942653656,
0.11483053863048553,
-0.159463569521904,
0.2580035626888275,
0.7936105132102966,
0.10320070385932922,
0.9167583584785461,
0.45975515246391296,
0.12913334369659424,
0.32476940751075745,
-0.3086714446544647,
0.7652091979980469,
-0.694645345211029,
0.0013575699413195252,
-0.7801707983016968,
0.37110984325408936,
0.010287064127624035,
-0.2954041361808777,
1.0483568906784058,
0.4884505569934845,
0.601510763168335,
0.06988272815942764,
0.9963659048080444,
-0.03698010370135307,
0.8322235345840454,
-0.566795825958252,
0.6432956457138062,
-0.3791631758213043,
0.4155588448047638,
-0.11486201733350754,
-0.920470118522644,
-0.14314043521881104,
0.024249913170933723,
-0.407640278339386,
0.1400998830795288,
0.6658483147621155,
0.6141843199729919,
0.13499489426612854,
0.29565468430519104,
0.5233468413352966,
0.4938446581363678,
0.48821014165878296,
0.18403825163841248,
1.0788023471832275,
-0.3165173828601837,
0.5657402276992798,
-0.021235203370451927,
-0.16481494903564453,
-0.5442033410072327,
-1.0480937957763672,
-0.7477737069129944,
-0.4955362379550934,
-0.3989807069301605,
-0.31236258149147034,
0.06347227841615677,
1.0430606603622437,
0.15037716925144196,
-0.9028053879737854,
-0.2841586470603943,
0.1720779985189438,
0.06652147322893143,
0.6670451164245605,
-0.14636807143688202,
0.2113145887851715,
-0.4543466567993164,
-0.8588401079177856,
0.47917166352272034,
0.31630656123161316,
-0.01666337251663208,
-0.4274771809577942,
0.0555124394595623,
-0.30670973658561707,
0.5604397058486938,
0.8648713827133179,
0.42547282576560974,
-0.7427175045013428,
-0.6757281422615051,
-0.14641638100147247,
-0.25305768847465515,
-0.014066942036151886,
0.6269442439079285,
-0.35763511061668396,
0.3466499447822571,
0.3176913261413574,
0.8444483280181885,
0.07112081348896027,
-0.07870261371135712,
0.5784456133842468,
-0.3820929229259491,
-0.14482201635837555,
0.18640469014644623,
0.2659744918346405,
0.6837552189826965,
-0.06387393176555634,
0.3052002787590027,
0.5206049084663391,
-0.8691760897636414,
-1.0307259559631348,
0.2225305587053299,
-0.8103493452072144,
-0.12288665026426315,
1.2622181177139282,
-0.06529708951711655,
-0.3945583999156952,
-0.22835424542427063,
-0.20640742778778076,
0.23570945858955383,
0.03444821387529373,
0.6452926397323608,
1.0577967166900635,
-0.0884808674454689,
0.007586379535496235,
-0.95865398645401,
0.34355106949806213,
0.20408466458320618,
-0.9990200400352478,
0.35255134105682373,
0.9658635258674622,
0.40553686022758484,
-0.015696724876761436,
0.463684618473053,
-0.19279737770557404,
0.06912212073802948,
-0.07284693419933319,
-0.007028606720268726,
0.19255013763904572,
-0.4408245086669922,
-0.18668116629123688,
0.09827359765768051,
0.4270121157169342,
0.2821996212005615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02416v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02416v4 | Aligner: Efficient Alignment by Learning to Correct | 2024-02-04T09:24:51 | 2024-06-24T18:55:16 | Jiaming Ji, Boyuan Chen, Hantao Lou, Donghai Hong, Borong Zhang, Xuehai Pan, Juntao Dai, Tianyi Qiu, Yaodong Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the rapid development of large language models (LLMs) and ever-evolving
practical requirements, finding an efficient and effective alignment method has
never been more critical. However, the tension between the complexity of
current alignment methods and the need for rapid iteration in deployment
scenarios necessitates the development of a model-agnostic alignment approach
that can operate under these constraints. In this paper, we introduce Aligner,
a novel and simple alignment paradigm that learns the correctional residuals
between preferred and dispreferred answers using a small model. Designed as a
model-agnostic, plug-and-play module, Aligner can be directly applied to
various open-source and API-based models with only one-off training, making it
suitable for rapid iteration. Notably, Aligner can be applied to any powerful,
large-scale upstream models. Moreover, it can even iteratively bootstrap the
upstream models using corrected responses as synthetic human preference data,
breaking through the model's performance ceiling. Our experiments demonstrate
performance improvements by deploying the same Aligner model across 11
different LLMs, evaluated on the 3H dimensions (helpfulness, harmlessness, and
honesty). Specifically, Aligner-7B has achieved an average improvement of 68.9%
in helpfulness and 23.8% in harmlessness across the tested LLMs while also
effectively reducing hallucination. In the Alpaca-Eval leaderboard, stacking
Aligner-2B on GPT-4 Turbo improved its LC Win Rate from 55.0% to 58.3%,
surpassing GPT-4 Omni's 57.5% Win Rate (community report). | [
-0.18476749956607819,
-0.3769923448562622,
0.6366258263587952,
-0.21722373366355896,
-0.0103580541908741,
0.2374304085969925,
-0.1598752737045288,
-0.2630881071090698,
-0.000588360009714961,
0.1608559787273407,
-0.5135390758514404,
-0.20023873448371887,
-0.5070735812187195,
-0.14275531470775604,
-0.3027156889438629,
0.8649252653121948,
-0.010403532534837723,
0.22158367931842804,
-0.04954596608877182,
-0.4445289671421051,
-0.6677217483520508,
-0.08919862657785416,
-0.5690686702728271,
-0.4905425012111664,
0.7705552577972412,
0.43092334270477295,
0.8850176930427551,
1.1677837371826172,
0.6816927194595337,
0.3161657750606537,
0.12309194356203079,
-0.03881903737783432,
-0.5920121073722839,
-0.08726584911346436,
-0.46825477480888367,
-0.538701057434082,
-0.25901708006858826,
-0.10617110133171082,
0.48618337512016296,
0.38851311802864075,
-0.6367921829223633,
0.34938111901283264,
-0.03364928811788559,
0.7740572690963745,
-0.7403926849365234,
-0.20363759994506836,
-0.8574944734573364,
-0.3149711489677429,
-0.16985508799552917,
0.35748520493507385,
-0.4403817355632782,
-0.515028715133667,
0.050226639956235886,
-0.7027487754821777,
0.07417337596416473,
0.09628801047801971,
1.0001516342163086,
0.6527179479598999,
-0.22981499135494232,
-0.2712192237377167,
-0.7436398267745972,
0.7956615090370178,
-0.6913541555404663,
0.6302703022956848,
-0.1499212384223938,
0.6971456408500671,
0.07702620327472687,
-0.5184273719787598,
-0.6950546503067017,
0.07650481164455414,
-0.12316050380468369,
0.0758112370967865,
-0.2538563907146454,
-0.15902045369148254,
-0.010575976222753525,
0.31727170944213867,
-0.4908791482448578,
0.5760661363601685,
-0.24313876032829285,
-0.24370887875556946,
0.4157334864139557,
0.1394726186990738,
0.18345145881175995,
0.12176897376775742,
-0.44447800517082214,
-0.21525587141513824,
-0.6466420888900757,
0.13274256885051727,
0.3550240695476532,
0.45448410511016846,
0.1157151460647583,
0.5946567058563232,
0.21384519338607788,
0.8211658596992493,
0.5330901741981506,
-0.2711521089076996,
0.10446756333112717,
-0.009813115932047367,
-0.058202438056468964,
0.14094312489032745,
0.6448656320571899,
0.3476966321468353,
-0.3626820147037506,
-0.18187016248703003,
-0.5097446441650391,
0.4628712236881256,
0.45882847905158997,
-0.4322561025619507,
-0.25210097432136536,
0.21520867943763733,
-0.21759706735610962,
-0.17290359735488892,
-0.03245032951235771,
-0.5115904808044434,
-0.6953061819076538,
-0.6926853060722351,
0.5996043682098389,
-0.46707838773727417,
0.006217224523425102,
0.007766721770167351,
-0.08333117514848709,
0.7963334918022156,
0.46197500824928284,
-0.9473565816879272,
0.3054620027542114,
0.9085418581962585,
0.8497896790504456,
-0.2847118675708771,
-0.07456234097480774,
-0.6271280646324158,
0.029628746211528778,
-0.2983510196208954,
0.7606340050697327,
-0.31382137537002563,
0.13911135494709015,
-0.16885234415531158,
-0.04144442081451416,
-0.15311305224895477,
-0.5128279328346252,
0.5488954782485962,
-0.682236909866333,
0.21245765686035156,
-0.1914890706539154,
-0.6928175091743469,
-0.08303286135196686,
0.1921258270740509,
-0.7736532688140869,
0.8116248250007629,
0.22901034355163574,
-0.4690617024898529,
0.44703492522239685,
-0.5247223377227783,
0.053232088685035706,
0.036759622395038605,
-0.10102332383394241,
-0.6402390599250793,
-0.01315003540366888,
0.0820888802409172,
-0.01878691092133522,
-0.0009740723762661219,
0.23323465883731842,
-0.2959560453891754,
-0.5491777062416077,
0.04918566346168518,
-0.14606107771396637,
0.45782139897346497,
0.2742345333099365,
-0.2585919499397278,
0.28314289450645447,
-0.7700155377388,
-0.10900198668241501,
0.10594616085290909,
-0.2462216168642044,
-0.24249719083309174,
0.04677120968699455,
-0.22115282714366913,
0.12779714167118073,
0.35231998562812805,
-0.6791509389877319,
0.33304157853126526,
-0.3762513995170593,
0.313669353723526,
0.9847832918167114,
-0.4263959527015686,
0.9229510426521301,
-0.47518250346183777,
0.4916761815547943,
-0.20728234946727753,
0.1130978912115097,
0.02094392105937004,
-0.04703247919678688,
-0.8781378269195557,
-0.5509186387062073,
0.5948013067245483,
0.7113694548606873,
-0.557320773601532,
0.5691743493080139,
-0.4649374783039093,
-0.5889987349510193,
-1.080917477607727,
0.41009268164634705,
0.4116514325141907,
0.8299551606178284,
0.4584181606769562,
-0.07051067054271698,
-0.509739875793457,
-0.9237286448478699,
-0.3440564274787903,
-0.18677599728107452,
-0.016560012474656105,
-0.13449519872665405,
0.19849449396133423,
-0.27193623781204224,
0.9822610020637512,
-0.569176197052002,
-0.39560621976852417,
-0.09064800292253494,
-0.09802032262086868,
0.30099958181381226,
0.4408196210861206,
0.3914167284965515,
-0.5012170672416687,
-0.41231217980384827,
0.10783431679010391,
-0.502221941947937,
0.008056418038904667,
-0.14598201215267181,
-0.3308255076408386,
0.1483817994594574,
0.25883448123931885,
-0.40443506836891174,
0.09393033385276794,
0.5559765696525574,
-0.015120253898203373,
0.32214269042015076,
-0.08869017660617828,
-0.27212706208229065,
-0.9076232314109802,
0.24251489341259003,
-0.0038272675592452288,
-0.3499879837036133,
-0.661924421787262,
0.07023774087429047,
0.38618022203445435,
0.20215342938899994,
-0.34610676765441895,
0.5272789001464844,
-0.33600813150405884,
0.17717167735099792,
-0.09391605108976364,
0.2726336419582367,
-0.16070570051670074,
0.361581951379776,
-0.05348564311861992,
0.7521237134933472,
0.1845303326845169,
-0.32703346014022827,
0.1140160858631134,
0.5025349855422974,
-0.21653762459754944,
0.5131644010543823,
-0.5900946259498596,
0.257947713136673,
-0.2512664198875427,
0.01643134467303753,
-1.009041428565979,
-0.3456827700138092,
0.2409171313047409,
-0.25689584016799927,
0.3606499433517456,
-0.10117247700691223,
0.027795938774943352,
-0.4772191047668457,
-0.34187349677085876,
0.25395113229751587,
0.5777174830436707,
-0.7857475876808167,
0.782571017742157,
0.2762138843536377,
-0.0184992216527462,
-1.0376553535461426,
-0.34309500455856323,
-0.24250058829784393,
-0.28838518261909485,
-0.35088038444519043,
0.2822516858577728,
0.026120107620954514,
-0.2580205500125885,
-0.13971467316150665,
-0.45344820618629456,
0.07709518074989319,
0.1533641368150711,
0.05825525149703026,
0.6897159814834595,
-0.19909602403640747,
0.18639340996742249,
-0.053532157093286514,
-0.1821388602256775,
-0.2916739284992218,
-0.2370378077030182,
0.33655619621276855,
-0.3421440124511719,
-0.5142560005187988,
-0.3676726520061493,
0.014267940074205399,
0.5774893760681152,
-0.1930418163537979,
0.7117370367050171,
0.3142833113670349,
-0.21238774061203003,
-0.0357629656791687,
-0.8148210644721985,
-0.020846668630838394,
-0.49240589141845703,
0.17542190849781036,
-0.1894083470106125,
-0.9212089776992798,
0.6360302567481995,
0.07333487272262573,
0.2985008656978607,
0.34697139263153076,
0.33350926637649536,
0.007115618325769901,
1.1745525598526,
0.6998106837272644,
-0.30723732709884644,
0.5285054445266724,
0.09556420892477036,
0.4559861719608307,
-0.7981594204902649,
-0.12049642205238342,
-0.4357689619064331,
-0.5004430413246155,
-0.4486423134803772,
-0.15951403975486755,
0.21484611928462982,
0.1795371174812317,
-0.5897696614265442,
0.4697651267051697,
-0.7037197351455688,
0.6578050851821899,
0.42145097255706787,
0.2667791545391083,
0.2424246370792389,
-0.40790268778800964,
-0.0004923493252135813,
0.06309900432825089,
-0.6440734267234802,
-0.6404377222061157,
0.9598338007926941,
0.4303838908672333,
0.895721435546875,
0.33321434259414673,
0.8160068988800049,
0.08167865872383118,
0.6674720048904419,
-1.059273600578308,
0.15953804552555084,
-0.03710941970348358,
-0.3867003321647644,
-0.3027608394622803,
-0.198891744017601,
-0.7177737951278687,
0.30853337049484253,
-0.2092883139848709,
-0.731746256351471,
0.2848285734653473,
0.4586986303329468,
-0.8028164505958557,
0.2709757387638092,
-0.7415667176246643,
0.8721086382865906,
-0.36077889800071716,
-0.5162067413330078,
0.2019134908914566,
-1.0032601356506348,
0.4713393747806549,
-0.4039529263973236,
0.16959068179130554,
-0.11200804263353348,
-0.15484271943569183,
0.43969041109085083,
-0.4869549870491028,
0.4851142168045044,
-0.27527064085006714,
-0.2576741874217987,
0.08758256584405899,
0.007350401487201452,
0.523056149482727,
-0.27638521790504456,
-0.10904580354690552,
-0.025743843987584114,
-0.21512946486473083,
-0.23238426446914673,
-0.7652090787887573,
0.6608486771583557,
-0.7914612889289856,
-0.6352989673614502,
-0.36906689405441284,
-0.5199688673019409,
-0.14121823012828827,
0.4052234888076782,
0.0011433386243879795,
0.15005391836166382,
-0.20977187156677246,
0.03133033215999603,
0.6987621188163757,
0.08641966432332993,
0.2981967031955719,
0.6493855714797974,
-0.290287584066391,
-0.5271403193473816,
0.8231325745582581,
-0.07449018210172653,
0.282241553068161,
0.41898438334465027,
0.1464611440896988,
-0.6656852960586548,
-0.3651264011859894,
-0.5971581339836121,
0.3952529728412628,
-0.7232918739318848,
-0.5731065273284912,
-0.5240267515182495,
-0.04746965691447258,
-0.1833890825510025,
-0.40341028571128845,
-0.5464274883270264,
-0.43523716926574707,
-0.003466809866949916,
-0.19969718158245087,
0.12030782550573349,
0.6461332440376282,
-0.11784371733665466,
0.6109619736671448,
-0.6551780104637146,
0.17983247339725494,
0.3543996810913086,
0.4515850841999054,
-0.0954374447464943,
-0.5598613619804382,
-0.09867115318775177,
0.08671547472476959,
-0.6145959496498108,
-0.5630708336830139,
0.26618248224258423,
0.176534965634346,
0.6638213992118835,
0.538682222366333,
-0.07731851190328598,
0.9263845682144165,
-0.5215687155723572,
0.6128675937652588,
0.3563297986984253,
-1.0716580152511597,
0.3320441246032715,
-0.3715977370738983,
0.2867484986782074,
0.925047755241394,
0.33109259605407715,
-0.43955197930336,
-0.3581629991531372,
-0.31288841366767883,
-0.7853847146034241,
0.5937244296073914,
-0.11365550011396408,
-0.1584603190422058,
0.13390880823135376,
0.4433291256427765,
0.2539423704147339,
0.06047602742910385,
-0.7846895456314087,
-0.10890951007604599,
-0.16910016536712646,
-0.6299103498458862,
-0.11308210343122482,
0.05729076638817787,
-0.16643959283828735,
-0.30136480927467346,
0.8548375964164734,
-0.3867187201976776,
0.14685478806495667,
-0.08444558084011078,
-0.3911086320877075,
-0.11790228635072708,
0.3633181154727936,
0.4956795573234558,
0.6600966453552246,
-0.22850936651229858,
0.1144571453332901,
0.1970931738615036,
-0.14116127789020538,
0.430633544921875,
0.11280126124620438,
-0.1655760258436203,
-0.2715621888637543,
0.06599780917167664,
0.6251626014709473,
0.1693948209285736,
-0.4735962152481079,
0.6688683032989502,
-0.11256685107946396,
-0.010935825295746326,
-0.21284137666225433,
-0.015759164467453957,
0.12834595143795013,
0.2095152586698532,
0.13143128156661987,
0.450810968875885,
0.05006743595004082,
-0.2217382937669754,
0.28521794080734253,
0.5242811441421509,
-0.7299386262893677,
-0.2332219034433365,
0.9129619598388672,
0.027616791427135468,
-0.20842348039150238,
0.7223687171936035,
-0.12453419715166092,
-0.5092127323150635,
0.24244529008865356,
0.6015535593032837,
0.7266271114349365,
-0.5646091103553772,
0.00886188168078661,
0.3966566026210785,
0.09157469123601913,
-0.4667509198188782,
-0.04712275043129921,
0.1356183886528015,
-0.9825354218482971,
-0.49083220958709717,
-0.6735400557518005,
-0.340596079826355,
-0.12877999246120453,
-0.9501239061355591,
0.5172038078308105,
-0.3675832748413086,
-0.10245644301176071,
0.07222403585910797,
-0.414320170879364,
-0.48955556750297546,
-0.21064427495002747,
0.2502172887325287,
0.9284539222717285,
-0.8125409483909607,
0.6183599233627319,
0.6898964643478394,
-0.3508507311344147,
-1.1228584051132202,
-0.27915090322494507,
0.3840896189212799,
-0.9797776937484741,
0.18411250412464142,
0.31034329533576965,
-0.2728334069252014,
0.03437485173344612,
-0.6014135479927063,
-0.9478792548179626,
1.2566804885864258,
0.5739452838897705,
-0.8722507953643799,
-0.10458234697580338,
-0.06743841618299484,
0.4569648206233978,
-0.26562702655792236,
0.2642325460910797,
0.7867990732192993,
0.2933448851108551,
0.1641247570514679,
-0.8513333201408386,
0.08192501217126846,
-0.20929555594921112,
0.07102444767951965,
0.48686808347702026,
-0.7635244131088257,
0.6248754858970642,
-0.22599481046199799,
-0.2269091010093689,
0.35968017578125,
0.5894740223884583,
0.2842046022415161,
-0.044149816036224365,
0.6334641575813293,
0.8432236313819885,
1.1089298725128174,
-0.21896007657051086,
0.8273383378982544,
-0.35904961824417114,
0.3951384723186493,
1.4140688180923462,
-0.49294912815093994,
0.8983368277549744,
0.6233875155448914,
0.13027222454547882,
0.8778977990150452,
0.3758831322193146,
-0.01850225403904915,
0.6391286849975586,
0.18549317121505737,
-0.15594249963760376,
-0.32287704944610596,
-0.008691203780472279,
-0.10091165453195572,
0.5317351222038269,
-0.007490554824471474,
-0.1538928896188736,
-0.2171747386455536,
-0.06824669241905212,
0.02444644086062908,
0.2733112871646881,
-0.2687987983226776,
0.993575930595398,
-0.10518485307693481,
-0.8527845740318298,
0.46977004408836365,
-0.1785995215177536,
0.596260666847229,
-0.6809711456298828,
-0.11631864309310913,
-0.11800623685121536,
0.7425147891044617,
-0.18935157358646393,
-0.4924336373806,
0.2343585193157196,
-0.14082132279872894,
-0.2364596724510193,
-0.17775210738182068,
0.6766061782836914,
-0.48556196689605713,
-0.2766467034816742,
0.10291028022766113,
0.26837867498397827,
-0.39797186851501465,
0.1882026642560959,
-0.5921767354011536,
0.11078233271837234,
-0.02729296311736107,
0.15027064085006714,
0.2332828938961029,
0.045252423733472824,
-0.04471119865775108,
0.8161569833755493,
0.45990467071533203,
-0.10543280094861984,
-0.050629399716854095,
-0.09609954804182053,
0.9507032632827759,
-0.40807411074638367,
-0.3147929608821869,
-0.8508092761039734,
0.7626819014549255,
-0.19539877772331238,
-0.03612051159143448,
0.7384001612663269,
0.7408407330513,
0.8283621668815613,
-0.0017942716367542744,
0.7538886666297913,
-0.03642040491104126,
0.6304870247840881,
-0.30943405628204346,
0.5679539442062378,
-0.34824419021606445,
0.45004379749298096,
-0.04287605732679367,
-0.912510871887207,
-0.3838733434677124,
0.7100159525871277,
-0.3735024333000183,
-0.40684935450553894,
0.4524032771587372,
0.8825924396514893,
-0.11562662571668625,
-0.07297316193580627,
-0.012254921719431877,
-0.05865311622619629,
0.42542821168899536,
0.4261183440685272,
1.1169586181640625,
-0.507851243019104,
0.348414808511734,
-0.14047524333000183,
-0.34859713912010193,
0.04295465722680092,
-0.8050210475921631,
-0.37898388504981995,
-0.2616826295852661,
-0.24237504601478577,
-0.36952388286590576,
-0.029097888618707657,
1.206381916999817,
0.4504324197769165,
-0.8938234448432922,
-0.23939937353134155,
0.007351410575211048,
0.21638958156108856,
-0.3901837468147278,
-0.22721995413303375,
0.13693103194236755,
-0.47452861070632935,
-0.5080504417419434,
0.25179094076156616,
0.06378951668739319,
-0.0058546834625303745,
0.0420680046081543,
-0.14797431230545044,
-0.14394842088222504,
0.11102264374494553,
0.19505731761455536,
0.46875831484794617,
-0.8541337251663208,
-0.596194863319397,
0.314111590385437,
-0.0718267634510994,
0.32738274335861206,
0.5577672719955444,
-0.7083820104598999,
0.5229136347770691,
0.18285316228866577,
0.7635130286216736,
0.10832525044679642,
0.44789111614227295,
0.7706767320632935,
-0.5617823600769043,
-0.1982014775276184,
0.20261767506599426,
0.4965309202671051,
0.38673460483551025,
-0.39498135447502136,
0.41774624586105347,
-0.09740041196346283,
-0.761313259601593,
-0.8093129396438599,
0.13636139035224915,
-1.0421596765518188,
0.027307741343975067,
0.9095388650894165,
-0.05409691855311394,
-0.3615284264087677,
0.08173993974924088,
-0.34191346168518066,
0.29127684235572815,
-0.4675835072994232,
0.8699111342430115,
0.4868636727333069,
-0.11602576822042465,
-0.029325317591428757,
0.017262471839785576,
0.3406023383140564,
0.3595110774040222,
-0.44243189692497253,
0.10397813469171524,
0.6417330503463745,
0.5537746548652649,
0.35729241371154785,
0.4225393533706665,
-0.1460946500301361,
0.18251489102840424,
-0.24003154039382935,
0.2089296579360962,
0.1533331423997879,
-0.13889363408088684,
-0.7805956602096558,
-0.00921916589140892,
0.2255794107913971,
-0.08793450146913528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02408v1 | GLaPE: Gold Label-agnostic Prompt Evaluation and Optimization for Large Language Model | 2024-02-04T08:57:54 | 2024-02-04T08:57:54 | Xuanchang Zhang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the rapid progress of large language models (LLMs), their task
performance remains sensitive to prompt design. Recent studies have explored
leveraging the LLM itself as an optimizer to identify optimal prompts that
maximize task accuracy. However, when evaluating prompts, such approaches
heavily rely on elusive manually annotated gold labels to calculate task
accuracy for each candidate prompt, which hinders the widespread implementation
and generality. To overcome the limitation, this work proposes a gold
label-agnostic prompt evaluation (GLaPE) to alleviate dependence on gold
labels. Motivated by the observed correlation between self-consistency and the
accuracy of the answer, we adopt self-consistency as the initial evaluation
score. Subsequently, we refine the scores of prompts producing identical
answers to be mutually consistent. Experimental results show that GLaPE
provides reliable evaluations uniform with accuracy, even in the absence of
gold labels. Moreover, on six popular reasoning tasks, our GLaPE-based prompt
optimization yields effective prompts comparable to accuracy-based ones. The
code is publicly available at https://github.com/thunderous77/GLaPE. | [
-0.027203815057873726,
-0.7855386137962341,
0.7254576683044434,
0.6547250747680664,
-0.015251214616000652,
-0.028169089928269386,
-0.35944050550460815,
-0.1911017745733261,
0.08657350391149521,
0.17070378363132477,
-0.7708853483200073,
-0.3800729215145111,
-0.4921068549156189,
0.3856894373893738,
0.047206856310367584,
0.8998786807060242,
0.014102011919021606,
-0.4572947323322296,
-0.2873983085155487,
-0.15894564986228943,
-0.6143454909324646,
-0.3539832532405853,
-0.4878377914428711,
-0.4691695272922516,
0.6029461026191711,
0.2215851992368698,
0.7389284372329712,
0.589855968952179,
-0.04872647672891617,
0.2738116383552551,
-0.12706534564495087,
0.6211766004562378,
-0.14233337342739105,
0.24113138020038605,
-0.3281181752681732,
-0.0803486630320549,
-0.40285253524780273,
0.016857344657182693,
0.5620313286781311,
0.3193599283695221,
0.013807669281959534,
0.4066160321235657,
0.3517792224884033,
0.5710799098014832,
-0.8964937925338745,
0.26402705907821655,
-0.5952491164207458,
-0.007288350258022547,
0.014799864962697029,
-0.4205438792705536,
-0.654975414276123,
-0.41308102011680603,
-0.09152036160230637,
-0.7181770205497742,
-0.09413076937198639,
0.08646965771913528,
0.8032149076461792,
0.36490434408187866,
-0.03697105497121811,
-0.5973110198974609,
-0.48655781149864197,
0.9351996779441833,
-0.519049882888794,
0.20487628877162933,
0.5031337738037109,
0.16069431602954865,
-0.2843417823314667,
-0.5397182106971741,
-0.41419142484664917,
-0.7085229158401489,
-0.11985582858324051,
0.11864424496889114,
-0.3953254818916321,
0.05770109221339226,
0.14491897821426392,
0.31476104259490967,
-0.8432514667510986,
0.2886907160282135,
0.1891188621520996,
-0.38567808270454407,
0.4687018394470215,
0.11378618329763412,
0.39666667580604553,
0.05143602937459946,
-0.280929297208786,
0.2139645367860794,
-0.4844399392604828,
0.2317044883966446,
0.36410361528396606,
0.581128716468811,
-0.044501058757305145,
0.5473331809043884,
-0.17078277468681335,
1.1178420782089233,
0.3469585180282593,
-0.34103474020957947,
0.5834327936172485,
-0.3156753182411194,
-0.14972257614135742,
-0.04860232025384903,
1.0387762784957886,
0.2302304059267044,
0.41096749901771545,
-0.2916160225868225,
-0.13279026746749878,
0.31219857931137085,
0.0684063583612442,
-0.7235924601554871,
-0.07708235830068588,
0.391585111618042,
-0.1594173014163971,
-0.01595529541373253,
-0.3323824107646942,
-0.48818439245224,
-0.41587033867836,
-0.35322636365890503,
0.5674459338188171,
-0.09749727696180344,
0.19059062004089355,
0.30333516001701355,
0.33648788928985596,
-0.29480990767478943,
0.6225546598434448,
-1.1773310899734497,
0.0505412295460701,
0.7370300889015198,
0.977044939994812,
-0.10922334343194962,
-0.3283365070819855,
-1.298435091972351,
0.01164708286523819,
-0.2722376585006714,
0.7728568315505981,
-0.6855419278144836,
-0.41876354813575745,
-0.25809863209724426,
0.001105672330595553,
-0.3022731840610504,
-0.37430307269096375,
0.942478597164154,
-0.3051711916923523,
0.3276943564414978,
-0.32378992438316345,
-0.680113673210144,
0.0031520905904471874,
0.48992735147476196,
-0.5902668237686157,
0.9650525450706482,
0.07036814093589783,
-0.5762594938278198,
0.19092914462089539,
-0.7490520477294922,
-0.032108720391988754,
0.3642113506793976,
-0.20246917009353638,
-0.20518909394741058,
-0.008431773632764816,
0.34299907088279724,
0.05927928909659386,
-0.34199127554893494,
0.23696546256542206,
-0.1289290338754654,
-0.4945983588695526,
0.06503662467002869,
-0.47244447469711304,
0.8560934662818909,
0.23930376768112183,
-0.37219712138175964,
0.2833213210105896,
-0.4246756136417389,
0.2638489007949829,
-0.0869932621717453,
-0.49448516964912415,
-0.24909353256225586,
-0.20677870512008667,
-0.349702388048172,
0.024138497188687325,
0.6144233345985413,
-0.6115251779556274,
0.4672445058822632,
-0.2535632252693176,
0.06548944860696793,
0.8515221476554871,
-0.18764449656009674,
0.3473733961582184,
-0.2040516883134842,
0.6717302799224854,
-0.5390434265136719,
0.39345723390579224,
-0.22999583184719086,
-0.7483486533164978,
-0.32546573877334595,
-0.4590310752391815,
0.43274611234664917,
0.9193726181983948,
-0.36457914113998413,
0.7673903107643127,
0.08191148191690445,
-0.4630831778049469,
-0.7280571460723877,
0.594270646572113,
0.3437062203884125,
0.8416696786880493,
0.48648136854171753,
-0.05624432861804962,
-0.21190676093101501,
-0.9913032650947571,
-0.45988020300865173,
-0.3490711748600006,
0.0172014981508255,
0.29478299617767334,
0.18287506699562073,
-0.5383601784706116,
1.1831570863723755,
-0.3048497140407562,
-0.26084136962890625,
-0.17782644927501678,
0.09772207587957382,
0.7272580862045288,
0.4691845178604126,
0.6442552804946899,
-0.4510189890861511,
-0.6885040402412415,
0.06643839925527573,
-0.620621383190155,
-0.7192980051040649,
-0.28265297412872314,
-0.05274277180433273,
0.34704524278640747,
0.2412869930267334,
-0.6905648708343506,
0.053314439952373505,
0.7795590758323669,
-0.5178878903388977,
0.8806634545326233,
-0.49616554379463196,
0.13203147053718567,
-0.4778880178928375,
0.31415921449661255,
0.2135186344385147,
-0.0895947739481926,
-0.6214909553527832,
-0.15386900305747986,
0.34977835416793823,
0.14511846005916595,
-0.15753565728664398,
1.1640995740890503,
-0.3616088926792145,
0.2447134405374527,
-0.3309461176395416,
0.015085704624652863,
0.3670026361942291,
0.29964131116867065,
-0.17273390293121338,
1.1065810918807983,
0.47769421339035034,
-0.3858247697353363,
0.3216114640235901,
0.2534318268299103,
-0.44233840703964233,
0.4101025462150574,
-0.9252154231071472,
0.20979899168014526,
-0.15857622027397156,
0.20242758095264435,
-1.0475631952285767,
0.17437702417373657,
0.7139827609062195,
-0.30954229831695557,
0.19906571507453918,
-0.32198503613471985,
-0.6098193526268005,
-0.33878234028816223,
-0.18815650045871735,
0.38635262846946716,
0.5082864165306091,
-0.6256166696548462,
0.6099106073379517,
0.03108077496290207,
-0.4610666334629059,
-0.9124717116355896,
-0.4117598235607147,
0.14034073054790497,
-0.2754213213920593,
-0.41271284222602844,
0.05039479583501816,
-0.5837068557739258,
-0.14894919097423553,
-0.3501186966896057,
-0.08999880403280258,
0.26234322786331177,
0.15715545415878296,
0.08109065145254135,
0.3260149359703064,
0.10093846917152405,
0.30979540944099426,
-0.17246975004673004,
-0.36326974630355835,
-0.02833094261586666,
-0.3013029396533966,
0.6359759569168091,
-0.48085111379623413,
-0.3763510286808014,
-0.5208926200866699,
0.23935309052467346,
0.3401148319244385,
-0.30631396174430847,
0.37619948387145996,
0.41251859068870544,
-0.03606110066175461,
-0.2607733905315399,
-0.5992259383201599,
0.22481709718704224,
-0.5660509467124939,
0.11226844042539597,
-0.32111021876335144,
-0.8935754895210266,
0.4700522720813751,
0.14310376346111298,
0.29816341400146484,
0.3214753568172455,
0.6316754817962646,
0.24681921303272247,
0.945532500743866,
0.3256848156452179,
-0.09983646124601364,
0.29779618978500366,
0.17956072092056274,
-0.0024035621900111437,
-0.6385924220085144,
-0.18536876142024994,
-0.5548518896102905,
-0.09147552400827408,
-0.10772902518510818,
-0.37091532349586487,
0.28793373703956604,
0.16413848102092743,
-0.24149180948734283,
-0.12245114147663116,
-0.5856836438179016,
0.6619176268577576,
0.5473368763923645,
-0.07192293554544449,
0.37083300948143005,
0.0009458773420192301,
-0.11635009199380875,
-0.11433608084917068,
-0.6201969385147095,
-0.7660813927650452,
0.7075157165527344,
0.36656540632247925,
0.7902069687843323,
-0.211652472615242,
0.5509047508239746,
0.6161201596260071,
0.234264075756073,
-0.7243764400482178,
0.4946305751800537,
-0.09206070750951767,
-0.29932740330696106,
-0.2130695879459381,
-0.46206995844841003,
-1.1422172784805298,
0.263548880815506,
-0.07315613329410553,
-1.1146451234817505,
0.024338850751519203,
0.4599460959434509,
-0.5643168091773987,
-0.20653584599494934,
-0.8016608357429504,
1.1586437225341797,
-0.4727324843406677,
-0.3650287985801697,
0.2993762195110321,
-0.42864271998405457,
0.11836609989404678,
-0.22965198755264282,
0.28296342492103577,
-0.2886214554309845,
-0.18770653009414673,
0.4040558934211731,
-0.29858940839767456,
0.8611165285110474,
-0.1816297322511673,
-0.48273414373397827,
0.44048452377319336,
0.0632040798664093,
0.5962859988212585,
0.09806125611066818,
-0.2773205041885376,
-0.06572379171848297,
-0.412935346364975,
-0.3100399971008301,
-0.8454811573028564,
0.6959810853004456,
-0.6115278005599976,
-0.6030364632606506,
-0.28038522601127625,
-0.8355879783630371,
-0.27537816762924194,
0.06529320031404495,
0.19686800241470337,
0.555210530757904,
0.1974300742149353,
-0.30955782532691956,
0.5192938446998596,
-0.35070517659187317,
0.44301164150238037,
0.4455786645412445,
-0.3633013665676117,
-0.38793233036994934,
0.8331484794616699,
0.08887118101119995,
0.24111607670783997,
0.060678210109472275,
0.47903376817703247,
-0.6790256500244141,
-0.32720646262168884,
-0.7174917459487915,
0.3498333990573883,
-0.7925239205360413,
-0.09937407076358795,
-0.5900664925575256,
0.017484541982412338,
-0.12508642673492432,
-0.2450615018606186,
-0.2619989514350891,
-0.3801751732826233,
-0.29872944951057434,
0.1315268874168396,
0.35067468881607056,
0.30933958292007446,
-0.34385794401168823,
0.20462895929813385,
-0.7356958389282227,
0.2883493900299072,
0.5044399499893188,
0.25156229734420776,
-0.10942962765693665,
-0.6412690281867981,
-0.06748456507921219,
0.07178861647844315,
-0.1735936552286148,
-0.7330098152160645,
0.2341897189617157,
0.43415090441703796,
0.8670073747634888,
0.14705109596252441,
0.17786070704460144,
0.46201643347740173,
-0.5352836847305298,
0.6388142108917236,
0.24210475385189056,
-1.0364160537719727,
0.7722216248512268,
-0.3277242183685303,
0.6875247359275818,
0.739962100982666,
0.2104753851890564,
-0.4192558526992798,
-0.38259896636009216,
-0.6115676760673523,
-0.9653161764144897,
0.30350160598754883,
0.1712915450334549,
-0.00046164385275915265,
-0.10888879001140594,
0.24249334633350372,
0.4501193165779114,
0.27293601632118225,
-0.652039110660553,
-0.32194197177886963,
-0.005464490968734026,
-0.10127633064985275,
-0.2706853747367859,
-0.36172783374786377,
-0.1712181717157364,
0.01769893988966942,
0.6518898010253906,
-0.4043211340904236,
0.0056127277202904224,
0.044816676527261734,
-0.09207209944725037,
-0.044949378818273544,
0.5370139479637146,
0.6682666540145874,
0.7778628468513489,
-0.19535405933856964,
0.042730219662189484,
0.08946840465068817,
-0.44625845551490784,
0.29895487427711487,
0.13378703594207764,
-0.5722151398658752,
0.28300684690475464,
0.2115316092967987,
0.6877231001853943,
-0.17092297971248627,
-0.7149676084518433,
0.4594227969646454,
-0.0726325735449791,
-0.011705168522894382,
-0.11032765358686447,
0.21199092268943787,
-0.07748039066791534,
0.3975503146648407,
0.5100499987602234,
-0.0478208102285862,
0.18452152609825134,
-0.34360596537590027,
0.09157523512840271,
0.4980139434337616,
-0.06644593179225922,
-0.07893100380897522,
0.6637657284736633,
0.05012880265712738,
-0.49803999066352844,
0.47844672203063965,
-0.3943094313144684,
-0.41143956780433655,
0.36463335156440735,
0.5510567426681519,
0.9506624937057495,
-0.38965654373168945,
0.5331557989120483,
0.3462212383747101,
0.35158008337020874,
-0.147068053483963,
0.3861842155456543,
-0.06931586563587189,
-0.5492818355560303,
-0.8003180623054504,
-0.7340817451477051,
-0.6476744413375854,
0.06614094227552414,
-0.460877001285553,
0.1953839212656021,
-0.3821093440055847,
-0.28753477334976196,
-0.3285260796546936,
0.10921542346477509,
-0.27141478657722473,
0.24663572013378143,
0.23244912922382355,
0.9757239818572998,
-0.8719098567962646,
0.584625780582428,
0.6208798885345459,
0.13229234516620636,
-0.6300747394561768,
-0.29664045572280884,
-0.14234505593776703,
-0.7925436496734619,
0.49894633889198303,
0.4919493496417999,
-0.15831854939460754,
-0.04459759593009949,
-0.40382710099220276,
-0.6982405185699463,
0.7519708871841431,
0.8177483677864075,
-0.6186003088951111,
0.19797387719154358,
-0.022330742329359055,
0.4295286238193512,
-0.3344777524471283,
0.3574698865413666,
0.5176403522491455,
0.7424602508544922,
0.17963053286075592,
-1.299918532371521,
-0.054903868585824966,
-0.4777146875858307,
-0.15515372157096863,
-0.09226150065660477,
-0.5868818759918213,
0.6301738023757935,
-0.1434859335422516,
-0.13808821141719818,
0.2851705253124237,
0.5854371786117554,
0.9903253316879272,
0.19759707152843475,
0.6321011185646057,
0.44441014528274536,
1.1750385761260986,
-0.023308316245675087,
0.9784630537033081,
-0.2225688248872757,
0.46579569578170776,
1.2085546255111694,
-0.18763573467731476,
0.39352700114250183,
0.4730154573917389,
0.08476828783750534,
0.4610432982444763,
0.5474007725715637,
-0.15663902461528778,
0.600259006023407,
0.28700560331344604,
-0.4187065660953522,
-0.5113343000411987,
-0.26055029034614563,
-0.5247196555137634,
0.23908792436122894,
0.2744417190551758,
-0.21447241306304932,
-0.5139621496200562,
-0.23732268810272217,
0.16859182715415955,
0.04384199529886246,
-0.6046664714813232,
0.22069905698299408,
-0.1437455415725708,
-0.6426276564598083,
0.8525545001029968,
-0.23166735470294952,
0.656568706035614,
-0.9186789989471436,
0.1257583200931549,
-0.1048356369137764,
0.17700964212417603,
-0.15650038421154022,
-0.7689239978790283,
-0.03951900079846382,
0.004857798106968403,
-0.188605397939682,
-0.3472701609134674,
0.7144917845726013,
-0.3881089687347412,
-0.4954335689544678,
0.13765181601047516,
0.48029986023902893,
0.018379012122750282,
0.030124284327030182,
-0.9408984184265137,
0.39189475774765015,
-0.06326986849308014,
-0.544297993183136,
0.251262903213501,
0.41468164324760437,
0.05871162191033363,
0.8643466234207153,
0.4751477837562561,
0.1388506144285202,
-0.14211495220661163,
0.04296010360121727,
0.7276387214660645,
-0.1977674812078476,
-0.7701555490493774,
-1.138741374015808,
0.72691410779953,
0.029117152094841003,
-0.5202312469482422,
0.8512423038482666,
0.5508783459663391,
0.20382905006408691,
-0.1630915105342865,
0.8826695680618286,
0.2232816070318222,
0.4406932592391968,
-0.6016815304756165,
0.39808937907218933,
-0.5467690229415894,
0.23529435694217682,
-0.5910062193870544,
-1.1371538639068604,
-0.4153134524822235,
0.932065486907959,
-0.35084229707717896,
-0.01783582754433155,
0.42042776942253113,
0.7062097191810608,
0.12116948515176773,
0.027587102726101875,
0.1404213011264801,
-0.05497392266988754,
0.3088501989841461,
0.7204351425170898,
0.8313978910446167,
-0.1625135838985443,
0.32983192801475525,
0.07167313992977142,
-0.4688471555709839,
-0.18096500635147095,
-1.36571204662323,
-0.8494366407394409,
-0.30378207564353943,
-0.5353652834892273,
-0.3968501091003418,
0.16317884624004364,
1.081984519958496,
0.29172128438949585,
-0.6674242615699768,
-0.26251742243766785,
0.11680804193019867,
-0.07170907407999039,
-0.15393179655075073,
-0.1663832664489746,
0.44268038868904114,
-0.6779777407646179,
-0.7067645788192749,
0.639878511428833,
0.43265658617019653,
0.09952912479639053,
-0.030604742467403412,
-0.327432781457901,
0.0031738383695483208,
-0.021772485226392746,
0.5164281725883484,
0.7098405957221985,
-0.6757403016090393,
-0.4224099814891815,
-0.026796193793416023,
-0.11937311291694641,
-0.04566388577222824,
0.3374245762825012,
-0.848943293094635,
0.49019935727119446,
0.30250000953674316,
0.7232591509819031,
-0.012406942434608936,
0.42633941769599915,
0.5703632235527039,
-0.6065718531608582,
0.061810292303562164,
0.27138033509254456,
0.3461371958255768,
0.33253055810928345,
-0.3866521120071411,
0.6097632646560669,
0.08319305628538132,
-0.8504343032836914,
-0.8530262112617493,
0.32917317748069763,
-1.1840406656265259,
-0.12604203820228577,
1.4721143245697021,
-0.35773083567619324,
-0.23426483571529388,
-0.09414070844650269,
-0.452761173248291,
-0.27514389157295227,
-0.5405367016792297,
0.8733070492744446,
0.5602114200592041,
-0.2278704047203064,
-0.24423587322235107,
-0.4488574266433716,
0.3527759909629822,
0.5511436462402344,
-0.6118523478507996,
0.26397544145584106,
0.6553305387496948,
0.13688284158706665,
0.39111328125,
0.8752472996711731,
0.2448740303516388,
0.3710050880908966,
-0.3292819857597351,
-0.08278831094503403,
-0.3221798837184906,
-0.4579504430294037,
-0.2982123792171478,
0.3671359121799469,
0.15172532200813293,
-0.06824032217264175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02392v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02392v2 | DeLLMa: A Framework for Decision Making Under Uncertainty with Large Language Models | 2024-02-04T08:11:45 | 2024-06-09T05:04:13 | Ollie Liu, Deqing Fu, Dani Yogatama, Willie Neiswanger | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The potential of large language models (LLMs) as decision support tools is
increasingly being explored in fields such as business, engineering, and
medicine, which often face challenging tasks of decision-making under
uncertainty. In this paper, we show that directly prompting LLMs on these types
of decision-making problems can yield poor results, especially as the problem
complexity increases. To aid in these tasks, we propose DeLLMa (Decision-making
Large Language Model assistant), a framework designed to enhance
decision-making accuracy in uncertain environments. DeLLMa involves a
multi-step scaffolding procedure, drawing upon principles from decision theory
and utility theory, to provide a rational and human-auditable decision-making
process. We validate our framework on multiple realistic decision-making
environments, demonstrating that DeLLMa can consistently enhance the
decision-making performance of leading language models, and achieve up to a 40%
increase in accuracy over competing methods. | [
-0.14290310442447662,
-1.0153050422668457,
1.1676831245422363,
0.29756176471710205,
0.0800255760550499,
0.045702699571847916,
-0.4614644944667816,
-0.21111170947551727,
-0.01634901389479637,
0.2389402538537979,
-0.398594468832016,
-0.48851248621940613,
-0.8788741230964661,
0.07817231863737106,
-0.2943651080131531,
0.2886156141757965,
-0.14956791698932648,
0.468037486076355,
-0.26161831617355347,
0.16193179786205292,
-0.37904834747314453,
-0.5203219652175903,
-1.1474533081054688,
-0.2792661488056183,
0.4202156066894531,
0.5275575518608093,
0.92978435754776,
0.08272051811218262,
0.3987896144390106,
0.3625105023384094,
-0.30039650201797485,
0.25307324528694153,
-0.008564760908484459,
0.2318529337644577,
-0.3240063488483429,
-0.8099620342254639,
-0.5400550365447998,
-0.17120254039764404,
0.6030569076538086,
0.5980677604675293,
-0.46032068133354187,
0.12818792462348938,
-0.08745469897985458,
0.8727526664733887,
-0.6616231203079224,
0.2736937999725342,
-0.7632848620414734,
0.17054174840450287,
0.24382270872592926,
0.29961878061294556,
-0.2557784616947174,
-0.3715948760509491,
0.29550087451934814,
-0.41760411858558655,
-0.27066075801849365,
0.19998107850551605,
0.43205201625823975,
0.3892437815666199,
-0.28286880254745483,
-0.2110813409090042,
-0.869245707988739,
0.6640971899032593,
-0.7039189338684082,
0.3136000335216522,
0.5970041155815125,
0.5236821174621582,
-0.43146735429763794,
-0.3195827305316925,
-0.5475728511810303,
-0.1786588728427887,
0.3179479241371155,
-0.0489848293364048,
-0.08973697572946548,
0.13941846787929535,
0.26761743426322937,
-0.10199486464262009,
-0.05656738951802254,
0.30955076217651367,
-0.3910301625728607,
-0.1337728351354599,
0.6624807119369507,
0.1785433292388916,
0.12959074974060059,
0.04594900459051132,
-0.0008315296727232635,
-0.18545784056186676,
-0.8491682410240173,
-0.22917279601097107,
0.21549202501773834,
0.4745667278766632,
0.2640330195426941,
0.6870648264884949,
-0.3232760727405548,
0.8827426433563232,
-0.23428528010845184,
-0.32373544573783875,
-0.06735482811927795,
0.09972120821475983,
-0.5868590474128723,
0.11449666321277618,
0.4654178023338318,
0.16238535940647125,
0.16587194800376892,
0.1692197620868683,
-0.24751132726669312,
0.27464380860328674,
0.14829963445663452,
-0.5776435136795044,
0.007679554633796215,
0.49911776185035706,
-0.2250252366065979,
-0.2691172957420349,
-0.006938132923096418,
-0.7889858484268188,
-0.588489294052124,
-0.4987524151802063,
0.6903887391090393,
-0.20703867077827454,
-0.27088117599487305,
0.35533201694488525,
0.1477675586938858,
-0.044810209423303604,
0.7863620519638062,
-0.5264038443565369,
0.28573375940322876,
0.438910573720932,
0.7660660147666931,
-0.21482650935649872,
-0.11909130960702896,
-0.5139738917350769,
0.2302444726228714,
-0.9108583331108093,
0.6617247462272644,
-0.6738245487213135,
-0.6447214484214783,
0.10082629323005676,
-0.35944676399230957,
0.05913884565234184,
-0.6383129954338074,
0.6925690770149231,
-0.12799452245235443,
0.10138383507728577,
-0.13343147933483124,
-0.38912466168403625,
-0.4503147006034851,
0.42432576417922974,
-0.542946457862854,
0.9357649683952332,
-0.04861576110124588,
-0.27020132541656494,
0.6128911972045898,
-0.6747019290924072,
-0.17082448303699493,
-0.27030420303344727,
-0.41871151328086853,
-0.49151864647865295,
0.4183581471443176,
0.20750080049037933,
0.6733095645904541,
-0.44628840684890747,
0.4175364673137665,
-0.5751460790634155,
-0.1144140437245369,
0.34629055857658386,
-0.4849504232406616,
0.36150500178337097,
0.3697553277015686,
-0.2393147051334381,
0.29442399740219116,
-0.7147550582885742,
-0.011154926382005215,
-0.019195927307009697,
-0.48750734329223633,
-0.1980346441268921,
0.5552451014518738,
-0.08361513167619705,
0.4934278130531311,
0.21757330000400543,
-0.22862298786640167,
0.20432880520820618,
-0.03923778235912323,
0.25629863142967224,
0.9511715769767761,
-0.3859921097755432,
0.3457556962966919,
-0.2592085599899292,
0.5307825207710266,
0.16244344413280487,
0.055018749088048935,
0.09969630092382431,
-0.6494954824447632,
-1.0689880847930908,
-0.01712544448673725,
0.29264122247695923,
0.5827905535697937,
-0.5804359316825867,
0.31439700722694397,
0.04025967791676521,
-0.4711877405643463,
-0.3669951856136322,
-0.024045199155807495,
-0.03771165385842323,
0.3564218580722809,
0.32845431566238403,
0.24544113874435425,
-0.49823465943336487,
-0.858634352684021,
-0.37093159556388855,
-0.4170757830142975,
0.06892403215169907,
0.1649094969034195,
0.2811621129512787,
-0.3961128294467926,
0.9460374712944031,
-0.49312976002693176,
-0.3477257192134857,
-0.26800382137298584,
0.018535632640123367,
0.41695502400398254,
0.42658814787864685,
0.08922266215085983,
-0.8562183976173401,
-0.1403401643037796,
0.2018853724002838,
-0.4821282923221588,
0.023923290893435478,
-0.2174503654241562,
0.04318632930517197,
0.4421830177307129,
0.4547879099845886,
-0.697290301322937,
0.46029508113861084,
0.6211109161376953,
-0.22968652844429016,
0.7591516375541687,
-0.6031350493431091,
0.19734074175357819,
-1.201270341873169,
-0.06041461601853371,
0.1917785406112671,
-0.24386757612228394,
-0.426164448261261,
-0.07229984551668167,
0.04154166951775551,
-0.09101054072380066,
-0.3050743341445923,
0.38665953278541565,
-0.4038591682910919,
-0.18112649023532867,
-0.20275577902793884,
0.10230086743831635,
-0.45459455251693726,
0.09480750560760498,
0.3232569992542267,
0.9173985123634338,
0.78753662109375,
-0.6847663521766663,
0.11664655059576035,
0.027649886906147003,
-0.7672622203826904,
0.6075902581214905,
-0.4375196397304535,
-0.18928582966327667,
-0.12319980561733246,
0.20765385031700134,
-0.6675236821174622,
-0.32557520270347595,
0.032083701342344284,
-0.16546446084976196,
0.2556062936782837,
0.11409048736095428,
-0.5475136637687683,
-0.4203408360481262,
0.05612147971987724,
-0.0029239205177873373,
0.3823438584804535,
-0.26490870118141174,
0.9070035815238953,
0.5161897540092468,
-0.4379991292953491,
-0.43238353729248047,
-0.5542449355125427,
0.26491206884384155,
-0.3504742980003357,
-0.48653656244277954,
0.18969014286994934,
-0.24817311763763428,
-0.7645959854125977,
-0.45144355297088623,
-0.3096320331096649,
-0.20907366275787354,
0.34955456852912903,
0.4205265939235687,
0.37690335512161255,
0.038956232368946075,
0.2955595850944519,
0.1626572161912918,
-0.18029481172561646,
0.2081911563873291,
-0.38397106528282166,
0.1813802421092987,
-0.11421215534210205,
-0.5979779958724976,
-0.34023866057395935,
0.23023512959480286,
0.7322041988372803,
0.14718516170978546,
0.5177035927772522,
0.18633519113063812,
-0.8047151565551758,
-0.25704118609428406,
-0.7184202671051025,
0.023086830973625183,
-0.47372516989707947,
0.4199625551700592,
-0.3998023569583893,
-0.8194828629493713,
0.27409812808036804,
-0.5203039050102234,
0.05226101353764534,
0.3963083326816559,
0.7608709335327148,
-0.02697691135108471,
1.4340163469314575,
0.6483072638511658,
-0.16068817675113678,
0.2883763909339905,
0.16238468885421753,
0.18720687925815582,
-0.4283953309059143,
-0.2714470326900482,
-0.8975354433059692,
-0.28538262844085693,
-0.28866636753082275,
-0.7481129169464111,
0.5962023735046387,
0.03986227512359619,
-0.18189851939678192,
-0.04296311363577843,
-0.27906233072280884,
0.3547271490097046,
0.3628799617290497,
0.13533389568328857,
0.3560258448123932,
-0.04975389689207077,
-0.28535494208335876,
0.10785619914531708,
-0.9483504295349121,
-0.7038717269897461,
0.826520562171936,
0.32083359360694885,
0.9199455380439758,
0.08951767534017563,
0.4884583055973053,
0.20174789428710938,
0.21823875606060028,
-0.7770972847938538,
0.42267370223999023,
0.2634629011154175,
-0.6668705940246582,
-0.4207056164741516,
-0.44747668504714966,
-0.7050999402999878,
0.3627163767814636,
-0.7406153678894043,
-1.010036587715149,
0.28162986040115356,
0.1985466629266739,
-0.6374455690383911,
0.35223615169525146,
-0.7629616856575012,
0.5812389850616455,
-0.2991127669811249,
-0.1660269945859909,
-0.5966745018959045,
-0.25619497895240784,
0.2502513527870178,
-0.5485061407089233,
0.6000475883483887,
-0.33862191438674927,
-0.3554457426071167,
0.5297325253486633,
-0.3805673122406006,
0.7801366448402405,
-0.02964322455227375,
-0.2908777594566345,
0.27393966913223267,
0.3812117874622345,
0.772883951663971,
0.19569480419158936,
-0.6506332755088806,
0.040217552334070206,
0.09093811362981796,
-0.12203855812549591,
-0.47966644167900085,
0.6552165746688843,
-0.575463056564331,
-0.9444215297698975,
-0.5495989918708801,
-0.46066662669181824,
-0.5785493850708008,
0.13147729635238647,
0.19189570844173431,
0.045191917568445206,
-0.27392327785491943,
-0.1237645074725151,
0.6396943926811218,
-0.2577087879180908,
0.4227384924888611,
0.2540537714958191,
-0.5779705047607422,
-0.250499427318573,
0.6427171230316162,
0.3027801811695099,
0.14764773845672607,
0.19325989484786987,
0.25045332312583923,
-0.40696725249290466,
-0.9304488301277161,
-0.3054715394973755,
-0.18155142664909363,
-0.635057806968689,
-0.1775646209716797,
-0.35482439398765564,
0.02329329028725624,
-0.1205434575676918,
-0.12179932743310928,
-0.19173692166805267,
-0.599159836769104,
-0.2852264940738678,
-0.25145071744918823,
0.20969198644161224,
0.845874547958374,
-0.04938282445073128,
0.2639063894748688,
-0.6997273564338684,
0.03301272168755531,
0.47078728675842285,
0.2991759181022644,
-0.2576289474964142,
-0.07144715636968613,
-0.21658000349998474,
0.10288316756486893,
0.024857785552740097,
-0.7803784608840942,
0.2997119128704071,
0.06583092361688614,
0.5437663793563843,
0.4016788601875305,
-0.03422485664486885,
0.6812512278556824,
-0.45135581493377686,
0.6868994832038879,
0.2215784639120102,
-0.9864161014556885,
0.733927309513092,
-0.359617680311203,
0.30774781107902527,
0.5092379450798035,
0.15790154039859772,
-0.39870956540107727,
-0.22739291191101074,
-0.5137479901313782,
-0.7892422676086426,
0.615231454372406,
0.10265939682722092,
0.08411473780870438,
0.17175151407718658,
0.21657338738441467,
-0.008274003863334656,
0.2504003047943115,
-0.4091799855232239,
0.012146412394940853,
0.42359963059425354,
0.06066026911139488,
-0.23357290029525757,
-0.26522865891456604,
-0.23195290565490723,
-0.3048999607563019,
0.9373285174369812,
-0.34991323947906494,
0.11856779456138611,
0.3436906337738037,
-0.09271401911973953,
-0.25663626194000244,
0.30222272872924805,
0.5685617923736572,
1.1099385023117065,
0.08146858215332031,
-0.03538314253091812,
0.7561994791030884,
-0.026707377284765244,
0.1298367977142334,
0.007584431208670139,
0.05418642610311508,
-0.08725045621395111,
-0.05100875720381737,
0.467465877532959,
0.10059773921966553,
-0.8526255488395691,
0.27209433913230896,
-0.09964828938245773,
-0.09981153160333633,
-0.4563843607902527,
0.2709381878376007,
0.18790465593338013,
0.31845206022262573,
0.5370404720306396,
0.11884021759033203,
0.1313265711069107,
-0.354261577129364,
0.02462361566722393,
0.3346289098262787,
-0.42684394121170044,
0.1991831213235855,
0.4387623369693756,
0.10966703295707703,
-0.4411585330963135,
0.3431943655014038,
0.1682135909795761,
-0.42598578333854675,
0.6512717604637146,
0.5112465620040894,
0.7459227442741394,
-0.42301520705223083,
0.2979751527309418,
0.2603134214878082,
0.34280338883399963,
-0.5102768540382385,
0.32274654507637024,
0.019539151340723038,
-0.7208321690559387,
-0.46060264110565186,
-0.7035921216011047,
-0.7540271878242493,
-0.12692891061306,
-0.44588473439216614,
0.4788243770599365,
-0.8410238027572632,
-0.4047752320766449,
-0.2632153034210205,
-0.2782517075538635,
-0.538849413394928,
0.5489696264266968,
0.10220763832330704,
1.2976372241973877,
-0.4046563506126404,
0.7821105122566223,
0.7450714111328125,
0.11692775785923004,
-0.7598755359649658,
0.010261508636176586,
0.1977940797805786,
-0.6882470846176147,
0.3332430124282837,
0.14936278760433197,
-0.35298725962638855,
-0.3224477469921112,
-0.5270800590515137,
-0.8957957625389099,
0.9539110660552979,
0.5370702147483826,
-0.8579996228218079,
0.11687017977237701,
-0.0640111193060875,
0.2930313050746918,
-0.39790821075439453,
0.07267299294471741,
0.7800189256668091,
0.7518332600593567,
0.01622864231467247,
-0.7564855217933655,
-0.0439392514526844,
0.0436084009706974,
0.11791235953569412,
0.21774138510227203,
-0.5140225291252136,
0.6489688158035278,
-0.4494728744029999,
0.019682906568050385,
0.17759038507938385,
0.7306972742080688,
0.4419914484024048,
0.11840201169252396,
0.6820258498191833,
0.41119226813316345,
1.0300116539001465,
-0.3033125102519989,
0.8416628837585449,
-0.1697784960269928,
0.23541121184825897,
1.0258604288101196,
-0.19841258227825165,
1.0956649780273438,
0.536372721195221,
-0.3687467575073242,
0.6287162899971008,
1.0373520851135254,
0.3445691168308258,
-0.014623316004872322,
0.20333704352378845,
-0.4109663665294647,
-0.8410672545433044,
0.09421144425868988,
-0.3141084611415863,
0.44195064902305603,
0.8862661123275757,
-0.3792889416217804,
0.02094728872179985,
-0.35876864194869995,
0.19743311405181885,
-0.008750797249376774,
-0.44967642426490784,
0.6584345698356628,
0.23868942260742188,
-0.7831829786300659,
0.16912856698036194,
0.08405724167823792,
0.30216550827026367,
-0.652390718460083,
0.05882299691438675,
0.20842285454273224,
0.09404811263084412,
-0.22475935518741608,
-0.7910312414169312,
0.41294196248054504,
-0.09185854345560074,
-0.060907941311597824,
-0.004148927051573992,
0.6651588082313538,
-0.35051459074020386,
-0.9940606951713562,
0.2179003208875656,
0.6606603860855103,
-0.03772597387433052,
-0.2957875728607178,
-0.8996813297271729,
0.19494415819644928,
-0.2447870671749115,
-0.13042671978473663,
0.20936280488967896,
0.3533186912536621,
-0.1545756757259369,
0.9103382229804993,
0.6324231624603271,
0.20495204627513885,
-0.3821221888065338,
-0.12706837058067322,
0.5272592902183533,
-0.4143384099006653,
-0.5572546124458313,
-0.8967618346214294,
0.31509268283843994,
-0.22586679458618164,
-0.20582622289657593,
0.529541552066803,
0.37736865878105164,
0.5220851898193359,
0.1575390100479126,
1.0246739387512207,
0.11085262894630432,
0.07365009188652039,
-0.7483348250389099,
0.7053592801094055,
-0.6023035049438477,
0.33243295550346375,
-0.3386944830417633,
-1.204588770866394,
-0.6441118121147156,
0.8870494365692139,
-0.3717191219329834,
0.14316225051879883,
0.44092175364494324,
0.8670161962509155,
0.1047036424279213,
0.09949824959039688,
0.5277627110481262,
0.3963385820388794,
0.13953986763954163,
0.5075591206550598,
0.8379270434379578,
0.0662522092461586,
0.4483770728111267,
0.11978445947170258,
-0.27175799012184143,
-0.13757005333900452,
-1.110206961631775,
-0.7470824718475342,
-0.5500854849815369,
-0.21258406341075897,
-0.2970886528491974,
0.019176628440618515,
1.285982608795166,
0.9602528214454651,
-0.7397769689559937,
-0.3983165919780731,
-0.16739781200885773,
0.5653526186943054,
-0.2974367141723633,
-0.05961914733052254,
0.17229485511779785,
-0.4987471103668213,
-0.9191934466362,
0.6380200386047363,
0.5996389389038086,
0.24529871344566345,
-0.35945194959640503,
-0.26759248971939087,
-0.12965993583202362,
0.41156795620918274,
0.5981974005699158,
-0.030047107487916946,
-0.6852587461471558,
-0.2733405828475952,
-0.4411434531211853,
0.07037633657455444,
-0.03544754162430763,
0.7748602032661438,
-0.7311479449272156,
0.6464250683784485,
0.38354483246803284,
0.7487378120422363,
0.35245373845100403,
-0.4008621871471405,
1.0833743810653687,
-0.20817817747592926,
-0.0631694570183754,
0.03967848792672157,
0.8122345805168152,
0.29223334789276123,
-0.3189592957496643,
0.5727260112762451,
-0.0392615832388401,
-0.46932414174079895,
-0.4617929756641388,
0.2923933267593384,
-0.6725918054580688,
-0.6441694498062134,
1.2944978475570679,
-0.01079539954662323,
-0.2138342708349228,
-0.13750773668289185,
-0.6350880265235901,
-0.04825432598590851,
-0.5216031074523926,
1.110809087753296,
1.126623272895813,
0.015061501413583755,
0.019249340519309044,
-0.33738604187965393,
0.6949609518051147,
0.7057777643203735,
-1.086855411529541,
0.09971677511930466,
0.6831192374229431,
0.02388782612979412,
0.12220638245344162,
0.32983624935150146,
0.0632774755358696,
0.3577119708061218,
-0.2906218469142914,
-0.43494850397109985,
0.18240708112716675,
-0.5573971271514893,
-0.5378633737564087,
0.11839782446622849,
0.47469720244407654,
0.1509203165769577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02389v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02389v2 | KICGPT: Large Language Model with Knowledge in Context for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-02-04T08:01:07 | 2024-02-23T09:01:44 | Yanbin Wei, Qiushi Huang, James T. Kwok, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) is crucial for addressing knowledge graph
incompleteness and supporting downstream applications. Many models have been
proposed for KGC. They can be categorized into two main classes: triple-based
and text-based approaches. Triple-based methods struggle with long-tail
entities due to limited structural information and imbalanced entity
distributions. Text-based methods alleviate this issue but require costly
training for language models and specific finetuning for knowledge graphs,
which limits their efficiency. To alleviate these limitations, in this paper,
we propose KICGPT, a framework that integrates a large language model (LLM) and
a triple-based KGC retriever. It alleviates the long-tail problem without
incurring additional training overhead. KICGPT uses an in-context learning
strategy called Knowledge Prompt, which encodes structural knowledge into
demonstrations to guide the LLM. Empirical results on benchmark datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of KICGPT with smaller training overhead and no
finetuning. | [
-0.3202434480190277,
-0.7194680571556091,
0.733910858631134,
0.12810659408569336,
-0.14955002069473267,
0.1489780843257904,
-0.25389206409454346,
-0.2702789306640625,
-0.007831376045942307,
0.5284618139266968,
-0.29863056540489197,
-0.5580938458442688,
-0.7154932022094727,
-0.12475452572107315,
-0.08683468401432037,
1.0223870277404785,
-0.3873652219772339,
-0.07864603400230408,
-0.23849605023860931,
-0.11675544083118439,
-0.6643035411834717,
-0.3495749235153198,
-0.8278482556343079,
-0.7329856753349304,
0.5557560324668884,
0.6051158905029297,
0.5431185364723206,
0.5440861582756042,
-0.008609375916421413,
0.08779653906822205,
-0.11459888517856598,
0.007775431033223867,
-0.43436580896377563,
-0.041198454797267914,
0.10488060861825943,
-0.3255906105041504,
-0.3025800287723541,
-0.12530617415905,
0.7495630979537964,
0.9779269099235535,
-0.13783274590969086,
-0.14769667387008667,
0.3100815713405609,
0.7882111072540283,
-0.6175481677055359,
0.7317795753479004,
-0.4325944483280182,
0.05586777999997139,
0.05105678737163544,
0.06972003728151321,
-0.39214852452278137,
-0.3558545708656311,
0.26577407121658325,
-0.3839240074157715,
-0.028160028159618378,
-0.055955417454242706,
0.34474241733551025,
0.08661794662475586,
-1.1163791418075562,
-0.4144378900527954,
-0.4719039499759674,
0.31500738859176636,
-0.5510908365249634,
0.6201659440994263,
0.6307233572006226,
0.4587171971797943,
-0.1748388260602951,
-0.7907085418701172,
-0.6684959530830383,
-0.6487561464309692,
-0.26771631836891174,
0.12748005986213684,
0.3477793037891388,
0.2116193026304245,
0.3822314143180847,
0.0002907276211772114,
-0.32874438166618347,
-0.10631771385669708,
-0.22743017971515656,
-0.2498757243156433,
0.07527559250593185,
-0.0018579853931441903,
0.3589304983615875,
-0.4168747067451477,
-0.3501225411891937,
0.015242069959640503,
-0.7636075019836426,
0.004886704962700605,
0.3096903860569,
0.3674416244029999,
0.011971060186624527,
0.7358196973800659,
-0.5689008235931396,
0.9357073307037354,
-0.31389120221138,
-0.2888337969779968,
0.10737118870019913,
-0.06820854544639587,
0.09998077899217606,
0.28008347749710083,
0.7337456345558167,
0.22768846154212952,
0.15129724144935608,
-0.4604383111000061,
-0.013798106461763382,
-0.2149248719215393,
0.021985601633787155,
-0.838284432888031,
-0.36233702301979065,
-0.08825245499610901,
-0.2199014127254486,
-0.17763754725456238,
-0.22387340664863586,
-0.5843504667282104,
-0.21811197698116302,
-0.38117581605911255,
0.39122188091278076,
-0.6316763162612915,
-0.26105403900146484,
-0.09749829024076462,
-0.15669412910938263,
0.13498958945274353,
0.2198086380958557,
-0.8152871131896973,
0.08493412286043167,
0.5671083331108093,
0.9463791251182556,
-0.09254959970712662,
-0.2729305624961853,
-0.48211270570755005,
0.595380425453186,
-0.08750846236944199,
0.6211810111999512,
-0.4630446135997772,
-0.2747509479522705,
-0.16716153919696808,
-0.1328825056552887,
-0.1317095309495926,
-0.09589867293834686,
0.5503169298171997,
-0.9359153509140015,
0.0019052078714594245,
-0.4281207025051117,
-0.7218689918518066,
-0.345820814371109,
0.5875315070152283,
-0.6693742275238037,
1.1200029850006104,
0.3091636002063751,
-0.9906745553016663,
0.4632379114627838,
-0.8503727912902832,
-0.6451619863510132,
0.31855520606040955,
-0.10987013578414917,
-0.06627527624368668,
-0.5054037570953369,
0.2459242194890976,
0.6156930923461914,
-0.21499404311180115,
0.4262630343437195,
-0.41137465834617615,
-0.07564971596002579,
-0.254818856716156,
-0.2529394328594208,
0.519302487373352,
0.25891149044036865,
-0.32543569803237915,
-0.3706522285938263,
-0.8762683272361755,
0.21430836617946625,
0.09377618879079819,
-0.6622714996337891,
-0.49595168232917786,
0.023909326642751694,
-0.21606600284576416,
0.26150259375572205,
0.2816779613494873,
-0.44712549448013306,
0.5358644723892212,
-0.28599652647972107,
0.6982471942901611,
0.48318400979042053,
-0.03600681200623512,
0.46897706389427185,
0.0992288663983345,
0.5065997838973999,
-0.24962639808654785,
-0.2449294477701187,
0.0010519040515646338,
-0.4030362665653229,
-0.6006715297698975,
-0.191165030002594,
0.3016205430030823,
0.638239324092865,
-1.0700342655181885,
0.18620558083057404,
-0.5388307571411133,
-0.513181209564209,
0.07177107036113739,
0.035944532603025436,
0.3413526117801666,
0.7892181277275085,
0.25745734572410583,
-0.03519555553793907,
-0.2716176211833954,
-0.7826361656188965,
-0.1737033873796463,
-0.12150928378105164,
0.0064358776435256,
0.5429251194000244,
0.5117339491844177,
-0.14015910029411316,
1.2746953964233398,
-0.8030202388763428,
-0.16669143736362457,
-0.44694459438323975,
0.22893983125686646,
0.10752450674772263,
0.271484911441803,
0.2352989763021469,
-1.0103721618652344,
-0.8580327033996582,
0.24393035471439362,
-0.7044975161552429,
-0.07450486719608307,
0.3846273720264435,
-0.10562906414270401,
0.1406565010547638,
0.542309582233429,
-0.8052948713302612,
0.2979241907596588,
0.46883857250213623,
-0.18714188039302826,
0.46528249979019165,
-0.07639431953430176,
0.2128356397151947,
-1.358878254890442,
0.27356159687042236,
-0.3883587718009949,
-0.3920497000217438,
-0.6092730164527893,
0.0003671579761430621,
0.42042818665504456,
-0.33545422554016113,
-0.16077710688114166,
0.7317914962768555,
-0.31513503193855286,
0.0656745657324791,
-0.20299206674098969,
0.32774391770362854,
-0.07660447061061859,
0.698731541633606,
0.07005402445793152,
0.5559034943580627,
0.3042351007461548,
-0.622895359992981,
0.46846598386764526,
0.20725485682487488,
-0.4255709946155548,
0.519991397857666,
-0.455368310213089,
0.2313741147518158,
-0.19641071557998657,
0.5823225378990173,
-0.8122109770774841,
-0.5671465992927551,
0.39131125807762146,
-0.2622527480125427,
0.3266063332557678,
-0.6744092702865601,
-0.5710391998291016,
-0.6214962601661682,
0.23859158158302307,
0.6099362969398499,
0.3885310888290405,
-0.6718103289604187,
0.8323080539703369,
0.0966775119304657,
-0.18084357678890228,
-0.7923559546470642,
-0.3871780335903168,
0.09977653622627258,
-0.11371146142482758,
-0.6607567071914673,
0.07667822390794754,
-0.038059037178754807,
0.3623347580432892,
0.05352119728922844,
-0.17035801708698273,
-0.05571021884679794,
-0.0038911167066544294,
0.11206452548503876,
0.001573986024595797,
-0.030137188732624054,
0.2767169177532196,
-0.18098674714565277,
-0.17365291714668274,
-0.16133354604244232,
-0.8437919020652771,
0.8170673251152039,
0.03659411892294884,
-0.4972262382507324,
-0.20008675754070282,
0.30010607838630676,
0.5709965229034424,
-0.13703703880310059,
0.8981252312660217,
0.4871121644973755,
-0.23693527281284332,
-0.03508911654353142,
-0.6998812556266785,
0.06282100081443787,
-0.39136171340942383,
0.5749757289886475,
-0.3751979172229767,
-1.1228045225143433,
0.5761418342590332,
-0.19946816563606262,
-0.33196792006492615,
0.32362642884254456,
0.27808237075805664,
0.2274310290813446,
1.1150349378585815,
0.5617217421531677,
-0.3716776669025421,
0.395504891872406,
-0.12621693313121796,
0.47338002920150757,
-0.681857168674469,
-0.40662452578544617,
-0.61663818359375,
0.09552060812711716,
-0.24605678021907806,
-0.08435982465744019,
0.5166615843772888,
0.6530991196632385,
-0.46374616026878357,
0.40966174006462097,
-0.204338937997818,
0.6775544285774231,
0.6254878044128418,
0.17429523169994354,
0.36967965960502625,
-0.022135447710752487,
-0.47889864444732666,
0.3708178400993347,
-0.9547939300537109,
-0.2708044946193695,
0.9989768266677856,
0.09775485843420029,
0.5402306914329529,
0.15752063691616058,
0.46374833583831787,
0.049002423882484436,
0.3818947672843933,
-0.9627063274383545,
0.4214441478252411,
0.08720922470092773,
-0.4052780270576477,
-0.2709810435771942,
-0.9042372703552246,
-0.6052834987640381,
-0.040453631430864334,
0.1199977844953537,
-0.8716427087783813,
-0.32777920365333557,
0.3078508973121643,
-0.11159805208444595,
0.47040221095085144,
-0.8175355195999146,
1.0315141677856445,
0.00739325862377882,
-0.018574558198451996,
-0.011879928410053253,
-0.6856454610824585,
0.45573997497558594,
-0.20286978781223297,
0.08715572208166122,
0.021887769922614098,
0.2167692929506302,
0.7006997466087341,
-0.5244486331939697,
0.8516415953636169,
-0.414036363363266,
-0.1699046641588211,
0.3044455051422119,
0.1437866985797882,
1.2569856643676758,
0.044736482203006744,
0.13122551143169403,
-0.195712149143219,
-0.05737770348787308,
-0.4108077585697174,
-0.7764790058135986,
0.6009032130241394,
-0.6588666439056396,
-0.32471227645874023,
0.08395850658416748,
-0.6713550686836243,
-0.40187785029411316,
0.5827021598815918,
0.16062070429325104,
0.6050310134887695,
-0.02961558848619461,
0.2294391691684723,
0.48755356669425964,
-0.13902691006660461,
0.23408962786197662,
0.46246859431266785,
-0.09657005220651627,
-0.5590168833732605,
0.8083181381225586,
0.2871644198894501,
0.5587714314460754,
0.4325457215309143,
0.1819772869348526,
-0.38313111662864685,
-0.41919082403182983,
-0.3747066855430603,
0.0026363690849393606,
-1.0670912265777588,
-0.2635413408279419,
-1.1601454019546509,
-0.2714400589466095,
-0.5883738994598389,
-0.1578250676393509,
-0.23247240483760834,
-0.27540743350982666,
0.1311805546283722,
0.025981778278946877,
0.48557814955711365,
0.6309790015220642,
0.2010677009820938,
0.6686084866523743,
-0.8443456888198853,
0.3486696779727936,
0.5827003717422485,
0.6210291385650635,
0.31347498297691345,
-0.06549867987632751,
-0.4319271743297577,
0.18440626561641693,
-0.15205134451389313,
-0.7296074032783508,
0.12353140115737915,
-0.11200039088726044,
0.4410076439380646,
0.17779938876628876,
0.031591080129146576,
0.5116901397705078,
-0.5104182362556458,
0.7663292288780212,
0.3135223686695099,
-0.7811402082443237,
0.413036972284317,
-0.5173314809799194,
0.4936769902706146,
0.4548068046569824,
0.49944350123405457,
-1.0499883890151978,
-0.20114605128765106,
-0.4423202872276306,
-0.9711875915527344,
0.8417625427246094,
0.1281280368566513,
-0.08945287019014359,
-0.2851261794567108,
0.4864569902420044,
-0.13412883877754211,
0.17758338153362274,
-0.9423047304153442,
0.03094479627907276,
-0.17770427465438843,
-0.410453736782074,
0.04754925146698952,
-0.4368644952774048,
-0.11252514272928238,
0.0717608705163002,
0.9149243831634521,
-0.5123847126960754,
0.12351836264133453,
0.08168747276067734,
-0.27185535430908203,
0.31138432025909424,
0.2988409399986267,
0.2549215257167816,
0.44985902309417725,
-0.07059686630964279,
0.13890303671360016,
0.2961120903491974,
-0.5626142621040344,
0.1023416668176651,
0.1814187616109848,
-0.2379244714975357,
-0.49434202909469604,
0.4064917266368866,
0.9036548733711243,
0.1835043877363205,
-0.4413280785083771,
0.6506505608558655,
0.20358696579933167,
-0.10874082893133163,
-0.3471911549568176,
-0.07446014136075974,
0.21658717095851898,
0.3352062702178955,
0.3531596064567566,
0.005279976408928633,
-0.0023105936124920845,
-0.1588447391986847,
0.04692712053656578,
0.474795937538147,
-0.4758591949939728,
0.12491154670715332,
0.5720728039741516,
-0.05642635002732277,
-0.033506251871585846,
0.9342336058616638,
-0.30913227796554565,
-0.8972114324569702,
0.6723303198814392,
0.5185272097587585,
0.6089697480201721,
0.15937617421150208,
0.21573452651500702,
0.3901071846485138,
0.08601173758506775,
-0.48389649391174316,
-0.06352268904447556,
-0.3854219317436218,
-0.7844828367233276,
-0.7473608255386353,
-0.5817396640777588,
-0.06196874380111694,
-0.1096516028046608,
-0.4215395152568817,
0.38636139035224915,
-0.1346602588891983,
0.0804225355386734,
-0.23845583200454712,
0.04681303724646568,
-0.6533178687095642,
-0.1806829422712326,
-0.027310142293572426,
1.010499358177185,
-0.7124632596969604,
1.0520929098129272,
0.38516736030578613,
-0.3340349793434143,
-1.2699655294418335,
-0.06250043958425522,
-0.205082967877388,
-0.8561754822731018,
0.9524950981140137,
0.2708091139793396,
-0.07852000743150711,
0.31725871562957764,
-0.5361633896827698,
-0.97200608253479,
1.264391541481018,
0.32479262351989746,
-0.22040610015392303,
-0.10875063389539719,
0.2610666751861572,
0.1406993716955185,
-0.30430981516838074,
0.09415361285209656,
0.5296297073364258,
0.6614944934844971,
0.4760468304157257,
-0.9049449563026428,
0.008631340228021145,
0.1303934007883072,
0.024157879874110222,
0.5822939872741699,
-0.65108323097229,
0.4243200719356537,
-0.0964168906211853,
-0.14315856993198395,
0.01191466860473156,
0.4469962418079376,
0.2541798949241638,
0.15857726335525513,
0.6388385891914368,
0.7534360885620117,
0.710491418838501,
0.08134904503822327,
1.0358588695526123,
-0.27100202441215515,
0.6242519021034241,
1.1930233240127563,
-0.3086830675601959,
0.49951615929603577,
0.24629415571689606,
-0.14807383716106415,
0.21806208789348602,
0.48002713918685913,
0.22556206583976746,
0.5573471784591675,
0.016426729038357735,
-0.4829714298248291,
-0.25185880064964294,
-0.11188211292028427,
-0.40273359417915344,
0.3047564923763275,
0.15772712230682373,
-0.20524181425571442,
-0.3876044452190399,
0.16844600439071655,
0.3379144072532654,
-0.439785361289978,
-0.37305718660354614,
0.731082022190094,
0.0018120311433449388,
-0.8691875338554382,
0.39440396428108215,
-0.07017534226179123,
0.3693782091140747,
-0.9633769989013672,
-0.12246231734752655,
-0.14102844893932343,
0.009804162196815014,
-0.00896487757563591,
-0.7025344371795654,
-0.10269258171319962,
-0.3557613492012024,
-0.37509939074516296,
-0.13959357142448425,
0.8478286266326904,
-0.7665212154388428,
-0.36995428800582886,
0.3436707854270935,
0.27858975529670715,
-0.005515474360436201,
-0.23475883901119232,
-0.279662162065506,
-0.4790023863315582,
0.09925182163715363,
-0.3128942847251892,
0.20771555602550507,
0.6179642677307129,
-0.21974462270736694,
0.8941341042518616,
0.4997224807739258,
-0.12308237701654434,
-0.10629497468471527,
0.18018311262130737,
0.8812593817710876,
-0.5170872807502747,
-0.5731781125068665,
-0.8163561224937439,
0.27728551626205444,
-0.07527786493301392,
0.19681350886821747,
0.5443471670150757,
0.5171374082565308,
0.7275301814079285,
0.04578293114900589,
0.9084778428077698,
-0.4823431074619293,
0.37079906463623047,
-0.7887129187583923,
0.9014399647712708,
-0.3686204254627228,
0.08218421041965485,
-0.28051114082336426,
-1.01820707321167,
-0.30371686816215515,
0.2417147159576416,
-0.3724535405635834,
0.3778402507305145,
0.838854193687439,
0.7297954559326172,
-0.28369778394699097,
0.15772604942321777,
0.1618102639913559,
0.31391727924346924,
0.36421090364456177,
0.666526198387146,
0.7473578453063965,
-0.09967312216758728,
0.8018001317977905,
-0.19393694400787354,
-0.2588423192501068,
-0.05589736998081207,
-1.1599507331848145,
-0.8426408767700195,
-0.6408621668815613,
-0.011722534894943237,
-0.4713513255119324,
-0.1405385434627533,
0.8916248679161072,
0.7305165529251099,
-0.32754093408584595,
0.16041719913482666,
-0.14451275765895844,
0.192946657538414,
-0.012804357334971428,
-0.2545863389968872,
0.7084749937057495,
-0.4254398047924042,
-0.29089951515197754,
0.2472398579120636,
0.017367415130138397,
0.13370636105537415,
0.0397343710064888,
-0.21206939220428467,
-0.05195439234375954,
-0.5939148664474487,
0.7559092044830322,
0.2444891482591629,
-0.4307134747505188,
-0.5802733302116394,
-0.21286427974700928,
0.04446473345160484,
-0.1503540575504303,
0.9998837113380432,
-0.8956200480461121,
0.36927342414855957,
0.3947277367115021,
0.7376993298530579,
0.7205954194068909,
-0.28289446234703064,
0.6698557138442993,
-0.8807864785194397,
0.11324455589056015,
0.01408386416733265,
0.32592102885246277,
0.21866923570632935,
-0.49574044346809387,
0.5935963988304138,
0.36240389943122864,
-0.6219620704650879,
-0.4773099422454834,
0.4229336678981781,
-0.9222529530525208,
-0.15494681894779205,
1.2847821712493896,
-0.08057150989770889,
-0.08574482053518295,
-0.18745717406272888,
-0.2808975875377655,
0.5166078805923462,
-0.2887900173664093,
0.5017330050468445,
1.0224237442016602,
0.17588889598846436,
-0.06195802614092827,
-1.0570731163024902,
0.37851065397262573,
0.13027173280715942,
-0.5575013756752014,
0.32865801453590393,
0.5181941390037537,
0.526900053024292,
-0.08118363469839096,
0.7797370553016663,
0.04034147784113884,
-0.09667714685201645,
-0.2366858869791031,
0.2663959562778473,
-0.15937821567058563,
-0.3630824387073517,
0.17948094010353088,
0.4263957142829895,
0.11195891350507736,
0.4193664491176605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02388v1 | Solution-oriented Agent-based Models Generation with Verifier-assisted Iterative In-context Learning | 2024-02-04T07:59:06 | 2024-02-04T07:59:06 | Tong Niu, Weihao Zhang, Rong Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | Agent-based models (ABMs) stand as an essential paradigm for proposing and
validating hypothetical solutions or policies aimed at addressing challenges
posed by complex systems and achieving various objectives. This process demands
labor-intensive endeavors and multidisciplinary expertise. Large language
models (LLMs) encapsulating cross-domain knowledge and programming proficiency
could potentially alleviate the difficulty of this process. However, LLMs excel
in handling sequential information, making it challenging for analyzing the
intricate interactions and nonlinear dynamics inherent in ABMs. Additionally,
due to the lack of self-evaluation capability of LLMs, relying solely on LLMs
is insufficient to effectively accomplish this process. In this paper, we
present SAGE, a general solution-oriented ABM generation framework designed for
automatic modeling and generating solutions for targeted problems. Unlike
approaches reliant on expert handcrafting or resource-intensive neural network
training, SAGE establishes a verifier-assisted iterative in-context learning
process employing large language models (LLMs) to leverages their inherent
cross-domain knowledge for tackling intricate demands from diverse domain
scenarios. In SAGE, we introduce an semi-structured conceptual representation
expliciting the intricate structures of ABMs and an objective representation to
guide LLMs in modeling scenarios and proposing hypothetical solutions through
in-context learning. To ensure the model executability and solution
feasibility, SAGE devises a two-level verifier with chain-of-thought prompting
tailored to the complex interactions and non-linear dynamics of ABMs, driving
the iterative generation optimization. Moreover, we construct an evaluation
dataset of solution-oriented ABMs from open sources.It contains practical
models across various domains. | [
-0.45969852805137634,
-0.8408854007720947,
0.6236270666122437,
-0.037940092384815216,
-0.10304758697748184,
0.1291843056678772,
-0.2754606306552887,
-0.15256890654563904,
-0.12278081476688385,
0.7274295091629028,
-0.6397040486335754,
-0.43955013155937195,
-0.2619045674800873,
0.01597677171230316,
-0.15397721529006958,
1.065263271331787,
-0.22650878131389618,
0.1814367175102234,
-0.354059100151062,
0.1620713770389557,
-0.6359216570854187,
-0.31717178225517273,
-0.7491151690483093,
-0.7857862114906311,
0.0026016670744866133,
0.47562551498413086,
0.5836053490638733,
0.6164854764938354,
0.08583174645900726,
0.41941744089126587,
0.1311926245689392,
0.13475103676319122,
-0.30042171478271484,
0.37129831314086914,
-0.4920310378074646,
-0.15279261767864227,
-0.2849549651145935,
-0.24531956017017365,
0.6264737844467163,
0.5203536152839661,
-0.29158586263656616,
0.39508336782455444,
0.041811518371105194,
0.31575116515159607,
-0.576166570186615,
0.2795768082141876,
-0.922781229019165,
-0.06150078773498535,
0.20097169280052185,
-0.17441534996032715,
-0.3014872074127197,
0.025923576205968857,
0.10385420173406601,
-0.5771347284317017,
0.11053401231765747,
-0.035133056342601776,
0.8381388187408447,
0.24634575843811035,
-0.41122254729270935,
-0.49573367834091187,
-0.6924914121627808,
0.8943663239479065,
-0.7059617638587952,
0.13469059765338898,
0.2409556359052658,
0.6910558342933655,
-0.5129640102386475,
-0.5947984457015991,
-0.6479901075363159,
-0.2036275863647461,
0.08513815701007843,
-0.10845805704593658,
0.060964588075876236,
-0.11763639003038406,
0.025184081867337227,
0.14338043332099915,
-0.5222569704055786,
0.027996333315968513,
0.024500494822859764,
-0.10304887592792511,
0.5986205339431763,
0.48434939980506897,
0.021393317729234695,
-0.09775957465171814,
-0.5312284231185913,
0.11300396919250488,
-0.7766578197479248,
0.005526209715753794,
-0.009407867677509785,
0.5033689141273499,
0.11326798796653748,
0.41438013315200806,
-0.22353750467300415,
0.6780558228492737,
0.06506642699241638,
-0.379764586687088,
0.18804533779621124,
-0.1469428539276123,
-0.3229958117008209,
-0.1314893513917923,
0.5657404065132141,
-0.04674128070473671,
-0.09124875068664551,
-0.169546440243721,
-0.5435242652893066,
-0.05442645028233528,
0.361684113740921,
-0.8313907384872437,
0.34880656003952026,
0.3463386595249176,
-0.23871126770973206,
-0.12518051266670227,
-0.38678860664367676,
-0.6090470552444458,
-0.41012313961982727,
-0.6841886043548584,
0.6458271145820618,
-0.3642699718475342,
-0.361802875995636,
0.14587999880313873,
0.1137942299246788,
0.6222773790359497,
0.3858022093772888,
-0.48222553730010986,
0.33357590436935425,
0.8349330425262451,
0.6417673230171204,
0.039478980004787445,
-0.4585172235965729,
-0.5789363980293274,
0.40164029598236084,
-0.30146825313568115,
0.7211151719093323,
-0.5874276161193848,
-0.5490666627883911,
0.09714430570602417,
-0.04341992363333702,
0.09603042900562286,
-0.4554618299007416,
0.26674336194992065,
-0.6336663365364075,
-0.015383239835500717,
-0.2598400413990021,
-0.6589604616165161,
-0.22100672125816345,
0.540752649307251,
-0.26478493213653564,
0.8429670929908752,
0.1606842279434204,
-0.266785591840744,
0.2994840145111084,
-0.6241163611412048,
-0.21438142657279968,
0.44843295216560364,
-0.5087525844573975,
-0.5956265926361084,
-0.12096195667982101,
-0.12059109658002853,
0.518335223197937,
-0.8113463521003723,
0.6374334096908569,
-0.18564772605895996,
-0.0433705672621727,
0.08153916150331497,
-0.046027228236198425,
0.5614251494407654,
0.5057039260864258,
-0.4797174334526062,
0.09312959015369415,
-0.7887039184570312,
0.3911859691143036,
0.32385748624801636,
-0.24608854949474335,
-0.21092185378074646,
0.0698571503162384,
-0.1311732977628708,
0.2885515093803406,
0.3388018310070038,
-0.35807740688323975,
0.14707040786743164,
0.014256334863603115,
0.17578166723251343,
0.6836546063423157,
0.2369672805070877,
0.3972555100917816,
-0.48101288080215454,
0.5662907958030701,
-0.10424739122390747,
-0.031953126192092896,
-0.3768954575061798,
-0.19236594438552856,
-0.7049798369407654,
-0.29564282298088074,
-0.05877295508980751,
0.46777597069740295,
-1.0681228637695312,
0.4211142659187317,
-0.24701949954032898,
-0.6546885371208191,
-0.06487200409173965,
0.35142016410827637,
0.7533494830131531,
0.690644383430481,
0.16227558255195618,
-0.27016428112983704,
-0.16155093908309937,
-0.6069470643997192,
-0.22006867825984955,
-0.2014053612947464,
0.06025215983390808,
0.24690143764019012,
0.7304748296737671,
-0.4628528356552124,
1.1984450817108154,
-0.2751829922199249,
-0.2673206329345703,
-0.3636136054992676,
0.15906822681427002,
-0.01744607463479042,
0.4507000744342804,
0.5264908075332642,
-0.7573399543762207,
-0.3361717760562897,
0.2115156650543213,
-0.9012572765350342,
-0.26220306754112244,
-0.14280082285404205,
-0.15200954675674438,
0.22870750725269318,
0.205533966422081,
-0.2841024696826935,
0.39212772250175476,
0.09508458524942398,
-0.3167961835861206,
0.5651431083679199,
-0.42875567078590393,
-0.07304283231496811,
-1.0502991676330566,
0.13097599148750305,
0.2436293065547943,
-0.31488269567489624,
-0.7777448892593384,
0.2657242715358734,
-0.06893077492713928,
-0.25482407212257385,
-0.2830387353897095,
0.8959461450576782,
-0.6686115860939026,
-0.24497532844543457,
-0.62843257188797,
0.018957171589136124,
0.059616293758153915,
0.6231149435043335,
0.3632379174232483,
0.6171137690544128,
0.6522023677825928,
-0.7080671787261963,
0.3472018837928772,
0.26913654804229736,
-0.16866503655910492,
0.7156919836997986,
-0.6012588739395142,
0.08539396524429321,
-0.1427043378353119,
0.02118721604347229,
-0.5402783155441284,
-0.25102078914642334,
0.21680228412151337,
-0.2073317915201187,
0.3860180675983429,
-0.16204527020454407,
-0.5013695955276489,
-0.13696375489234924,
-0.007474818266928196,
0.20011603832244873,
0.3188517987728119,
-0.5931352376937866,
0.9387546181678772,
0.504012942314148,
-0.3460557460784912,
-0.6143628358840942,
-0.4406864643096924,
0.15957172214984894,
-0.15437065064907074,
-0.6868636012077332,
0.0581672377884388,
-0.08817395567893982,
-0.4065208435058594,
-0.0196883212774992,
-0.04138656333088875,
-0.009822011925280094,
0.20705516636371613,
0.18566468358039856,
0.19085267186164856,
-0.0864650309085846,
0.1754184067249298,
0.20592902600765228,
-0.22871696949005127,
0.053891073912382126,
-0.404339998960495,
0.37517595291137695,
-0.5060227513313293,
-0.6208593249320984,
0.035735681653022766,
0.48171332478523254,
0.411950945854187,
-0.4311853051185608,
0.5512563586235046,
0.1285005658864975,
-0.501763105392456,
-0.7833621501922607,
-0.4355030953884125,
0.012739263474941254,
-0.5037039518356323,
0.3853048086166382,
-0.5546891689300537,
-0.6668794751167297,
0.8084328770637512,
-0.5565610527992249,
0.25173887610435486,
0.11755301058292389,
0.8843905329704285,
0.45659393072128296,
0.7095336318016052,
0.564890444278717,
0.046075478196144104,
0.4974574148654938,
-0.4393225908279419,
0.1074800118803978,
-0.47928738594055176,
-0.3206557035446167,
-0.5203487873077393,
0.1815139502286911,
-0.19548025727272034,
-0.22030234336853027,
0.6207485795021057,
-0.21565985679626465,
-0.6659848690032959,
0.12951017916202545,
-0.3986085057258606,
0.48736703395843506,
0.30233514308929443,
-0.22579798102378845,
0.2779519259929657,
-0.017308413982391357,
-0.1713583916425705,
0.2887153625488281,
-0.6599169969558716,
-0.8672640919685364,
0.9411710500717163,
0.48084577918052673,
0.8090118765830994,
0.20279718935489655,
0.6088197231292725,
0.3375296890735626,
0.5455535054206848,
-0.7816873788833618,
0.6355254650115967,
0.41407421231269836,
-0.6206334233283997,
-0.36970046162605286,
-0.43201714754104614,
-0.7556437849998474,
0.36912983655929565,
-0.20170104503631592,
-0.6561775803565979,
0.12623390555381775,
0.06370457261800766,
-0.1301800161600113,
0.09742550551891327,
-0.5539832711219788,
0.8272830843925476,
-0.4739605486392975,
-0.7204336524009705,
0.02308085188269615,
-0.6507439017295837,
0.31361764669418335,
-0.3481397032737732,
0.42176583409309387,
0.20165884494781494,
-0.08253753185272217,
0.17917758226394653,
-0.9356032609939575,
0.7743995189666748,
-0.4301345646381378,
-0.3912598788738251,
0.5867169499397278,
0.10644351691007614,
0.563399076461792,
0.06847135722637177,
-0.24937114119529724,
-0.06150954216718674,
-0.23424650728702545,
-0.2134617269039154,
-0.5703720450401306,
0.6961842179298401,
-0.7737988829612732,
-0.7770983576774597,
-0.39913010597229004,
-0.40362125635147095,
-0.24475587904453278,
0.2965664863586426,
0.029828669503331184,
0.5549318790435791,
-0.05808389559388161,
-0.1555129885673523,
0.6054285764694214,
-0.044938910752534866,
0.29220321774482727,
0.9065768122673035,
-0.4330109655857086,
-0.421487957239151,
0.9745655655860901,
0.1100865975022316,
0.2091313898563385,
-0.039618685841560364,
0.03844210505485535,
-0.18366281688213348,
-0.5607162714004517,
-0.7097994685173035,
0.1878456473350525,
-0.8854249119758606,
-0.4176607131958008,
-0.1913342922925949,
-0.3611781597137451,
-0.18310344219207764,
-0.3767290711402893,
-0.3828805983066559,
0.08481556177139282,
-0.12209650129079819,
0.1295200139284134,
0.34634336829185486,
0.7563802599906921,
0.014730152674019337,
0.483721524477005,
-0.6450818181037903,
0.27701762318611145,
0.24857300519943237,
0.42652177810668945,
-0.03860566392540932,
-0.4282287061214447,
-0.6113750338554382,
0.04013242572546005,
-0.5474429130554199,
-0.8457746505737305,
0.49828898906707764,
0.2698403298854828,
0.843982994556427,
0.3339659571647644,
0.031159162521362305,
0.5386645197868347,
-0.5617667436599731,
0.7917051911354065,
-0.10162831842899323,
-1.0960122346878052,
0.43523555994033813,
-0.38557857275009155,
0.043990567326545715,
0.5343063473701477,
0.07265222817659378,
-0.16821767389774323,
-0.3482154309749603,
-0.34169116616249084,
-0.8859620094299316,
0.6872550249099731,
0.0007331166416406631,
-0.03865952044725418,
0.07339386641979218,
0.7181332111358643,
0.3298346698284149,
0.33211514353752136,
-0.6914116740226746,
-0.36321452260017395,
-0.3310018479824066,
-0.004116293508559465,
-0.02736663818359375,
-0.0022780082654207945,
-0.18123824894428253,
0.11699938774108887,
1.1177619695663452,
-0.42757442593574524,
0.05524076893925667,
0.14037631452083588,
-0.19517692923545837,
-0.32170477509498596,
0.2700754404067993,
0.40231093764305115,
0.5990163683891296,
0.11105076968669891,
-0.09133391082286835,
0.09561028331518173,
-0.1681096851825714,
0.49567708373069763,
0.1700506955385208,
-0.24495829641819,
-0.043008942157030106,
0.04393521696329117,
0.8000587821006775,
-0.1126093789935112,
-0.7403579950332642,
0.511247456073761,
-0.07357743382453918,
-0.2305237203836441,
-0.70918869972229,
0.23848365247249603,
-0.08197115361690521,
0.4490870535373688,
0.5915789604187012,
-0.25860434770584106,
0.13010495901107788,
-0.41980698704719543,
0.09494785964488983,
0.7372531890869141,
0.09532471746206284,
-0.08217489719390869,
0.45829886198043823,
0.11997897922992706,
-0.38056468963623047,
0.09836039692163467,
-0.5178302526473999,
-0.49862760305404663,
0.6527082324028015,
0.7038283944129944,
0.991762638092041,
-0.24206729233264923,
0.17107850313186646,
0.21296949684619904,
0.07785379886627197,
-0.11362456530332565,
0.3054462969303131,
-0.3885488212108612,
-0.6344044208526611,
-0.3762938678264618,
-0.6139127612113953,
-0.7222812175750732,
0.23870694637298584,
-0.519597053527832,
0.3961668610572815,
-0.4706125855445862,
-0.20108279585838318,
-0.2715020775794983,
0.16843445599079132,
-0.5367987751960754,
0.27423739433288574,
0.0960896909236908,
0.8464732766151428,
-0.7842655181884766,
0.7243914604187012,
0.9592543840408325,
-0.35849466919898987,
-0.7998224496841431,
-0.04415200278162956,
0.009276234544813633,
-0.5409422516822815,
0.41506078839302063,
-0.0005239234887994826,
-0.44161632657051086,
-0.03712312504649162,
-0.7389666438102722,
-0.7917375564575195,
1.3827612400054932,
0.6106943488121033,
-0.20560643076896667,
0.10210882872343063,
0.2684813141822815,
0.5889025926589966,
-0.6870319247245789,
0.22314518690109253,
0.2814149260520935,
0.33608344197273254,
0.39296624064445496,
-0.7711694836616516,
0.014548431150615215,
-0.5168651342391968,
0.2960451543331146,
0.006342687178403139,
-0.7056647539138794,
0.8096822500228882,
-0.04092821851372719,
-0.16694945096969604,
0.09017375856637955,
0.688666045665741,
0.6480445861816406,
0.5217506885528564,
0.43283960223197937,
0.377224326133728,
0.6077006459236145,
0.30295005440711975,
0.7997159361839294,
-0.4818650484085083,
0.3670137822628021,
1.1619409322738647,
-0.7441630959510803,
0.5368266105651855,
0.31949153542518616,
0.3046075403690338,
0.6781899929046631,
0.4957577884197235,
0.0850202888250351,
0.4505011737346649,
0.4000605642795563,
-0.40470656752586365,
-0.478648841381073,
-0.0482744425535202,
-0.37281861901283264,
0.4891568720340729,
0.5242337584495544,
-0.18274065852165222,
-0.5802263617515564,
0.1093699187040329,
0.06145118921995163,
0.3480609655380249,
-0.5928458571434021,
0.8517824411392212,
-0.051276568323373795,
-0.8493807315826416,
0.6326860189437866,
0.15923093259334564,
0.31989458203315735,
-0.8534707427024841,
-0.09675893187522888,
-0.0642661303281784,
0.2664038836956024,
0.1294950693845749,
-0.5748128890991211,
0.2055809497833252,
0.3472980856895447,
-0.13104571402072906,
-0.2914579510688782,
1.0041389465332031,
-0.35760727524757385,
-0.41566404700279236,
0.3431515693664551,
0.8080759644508362,
0.053581614047288895,
0.3463549315929413,
-0.6065876483917236,
-0.08222176134586334,
-0.2930898368358612,
-0.6107096672058105,
0.3818836510181427,
0.7732937335968018,
-0.16707539558410645,
1.0145759582519531,
0.36759310960769653,
0.017176253721117973,
-0.184242382645607,
-0.24461250007152557,
1.0362589359283447,
-0.4364274740219116,
-0.5212339758872986,
-0.6939181685447693,
0.3977591097354889,
0.06865881383419037,
-0.00930334348231554,
0.6773160696029663,
0.45580407977104187,
0.7841886281967163,
0.07075223326683044,
1.175508975982666,
0.18205325305461884,
0.47107115387916565,
-0.4740649163722992,
0.7302365303039551,
-0.7342689633369446,
0.5191998481750488,
-0.24727573990821838,
-0.6287323832511902,
-0.16071000695228577,
0.540203869342804,
-0.4195181429386139,
0.33845508098602295,
0.14970280230045319,
0.714259922504425,
0.15460388362407684,
-0.02027524821460247,
0.29004746675491333,
-0.07959895581007004,
0.5013752579689026,
0.5347073674201965,
0.822980523109436,
-0.031186142936348915,
0.18353916704654694,
0.17306473851203918,
-0.34944528341293335,
-0.0688171461224556,
-1.0132490396499634,
-0.8372710347175598,
-0.6519495844841003,
-0.20974773168563843,
-0.2277265042066574,
-0.049667950719594955,
1.2264105081558228,
0.4220443367958069,
-0.5381144881248474,
-0.4954482316970825,
-0.26735320687294006,
0.17265111207962036,
0.013405556790530682,
-0.19257868826389313,
0.0005927131860516965,
-0.5983355045318604,
-0.5107110738754272,
0.2701984941959381,
-0.01868809014558792,
-0.010288743302226067,
-0.5402128100395203,
-0.46367520093917847,
0.1607474684715271,
0.2738165259361267,
0.3202652335166931,
0.5840957760810852,
-0.5091966390609741,
-0.16402898728847504,
-0.22796960175037384,
-0.16185279190540314,
-0.12968812882900238,
0.5881236791610718,
-1.0367302894592285,
0.5047162175178528,
0.1272743046283722,
0.8824315667152405,
0.2657039165496826,
-0.12832480669021606,
0.6178156733512878,
-0.6745825409889221,
-0.11494849622249603,
-0.015204382129013538,
0.5336210131645203,
0.35000988841056824,
-0.3021196722984314,
0.3512571454048157,
0.016591615974903107,
-0.7457244992256165,
-0.8798806071281433,
0.37989693880081177,
-0.6866750717163086,
-0.33452579379081726,
1.28573477268219,
-0.27555277943611145,
-0.43934962153434753,
-0.20852455496788025,
-0.21873512864112854,
0.2756202220916748,
-0.4130242168903351,
0.585235595703125,
0.42085278034210205,
-0.07847771793603897,
0.10074294358491898,
-0.2893508970737457,
0.3232724964618683,
0.20847268402576447,
-0.8770561814308167,
0.15121088922023773,
0.6673381328582764,
0.40081584453582764,
0.27661317586898804,
0.47902947664260864,
0.16628675162792206,
0.20996829867362976,
-0.08050891011953354,
0.36770036816596985,
-0.39693960547447205,
-0.37008392810821533,
-0.5150743126869202,
0.24833865463733673,
0.26263299584388733,
0.025889769196510315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02380v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02380v3 | Evaluating Large Language Models in Analysing Classroom Dialogue | 2024-02-04T07:39:06 | 2024-02-23T02:19:09 | Yun Long, Haifeng Luo, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | This study explores the application of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4, in the analysis of classroom dialogue, a crucial research
task for both teaching diagnosis and quality improvement. Recognizing the
knowledge-intensive and labor-intensive nature of traditional qualitative
methods in educational research, this study investigates the potential of LLM
to streamline and enhance the analysis process. The study involves datasets
from a middle school, encompassing classroom dialogues across mathematics and
Chinese classes. These dialogues were manually coded by educational experts and
then analyzed using a customised GPT-4 model. This study focuses on comparing
manual annotations with the outputs of GPT-4 to evaluate its efficacy in
analyzing educational dialogues. Time efficiency, inter-coder agreement, and
inter-coder reliability between human coders and GPT-4 are evaluated. Results
indicate substantial time savings with GPT-4, and a high degree of consistency
in coding between the model and human coders, with some discrepancies in
specific codes. These findings highlight the strong potential of LLM in
teaching evaluation and facilitation. | [
-0.25980985164642334,
-0.9192740321159363,
0.6602494120597839,
0.04586394876241684,
-0.26853978633880615,
0.23652812838554382,
-0.4800357222557068,
-0.3338831067085266,
-0.3170556128025055,
0.19217026233673096,
-0.13795362412929535,
-0.45925575494766235,
-0.5053874850273132,
0.21361783146858215,
-0.5911583304405212,
0.8345147371292114,
0.025800423696637154,
0.5700153112411499,
-0.04055686295032501,
0.07418376952409744,
-0.41349858045578003,
-0.9140486121177673,
-0.9030493497848511,
-0.29538199305534363,
0.3109931945800781,
0.1693337857723236,
0.7110171914100647,
0.22094155848026276,
0.4036896228790283,
0.4199591279029846,
-0.058032941073179245,
-0.14400972425937653,
-0.49268800020217896,
-0.22767360508441925,
-0.03504672646522522,
-0.27051299810409546,
-0.4184951186180115,
0.20643207430839539,
0.8975571990013123,
0.6472492814064026,
-0.31837180256843567,
0.12072207033634186,
0.3400780260562897,
0.33185791969299316,
-0.13671626150608063,
0.5718590021133423,
-0.33092057704925537,
0.08293014764785767,
-0.10890914499759674,
-0.076092429459095,
-0.24028456211090088,
-0.6601053476333618,
0.43075430393218994,
-0.25846076011657715,
0.05083029344677925,
-0.42148515582084656,
0.5944733023643494,
-0.18402844667434692,
-0.17455023527145386,
-0.47451505064964294,
-0.6388756632804871,
0.7834368348121643,
-1.1824824810028076,
0.29719871282577515,
0.3361084759235382,
0.3230551779270172,
-0.08527634292840958,
-0.7170209884643555,
-0.6789406538009644,
-0.2655602991580963,
-0.03657441586256027,
0.1172344908118248,
-0.005003936588764191,
0.19754359126091003,
0.2675500512123108,
0.526552677154541,
-0.37334108352661133,
0.2179267853498459,
-0.49906420707702637,
-0.23942509293556213,
0.5000596046447754,
0.3760983645915985,
0.49493053555488586,
-0.13998137414455414,
-0.03840675950050354,
0.27695056796073914,
-0.594480037689209,
-0.0518496111035347,
0.4121154844760895,
0.14316746592521667,
-0.05359591916203499,
0.18855775892734528,
0.004979359917342663,
0.8469891548156738,
-0.26685819029808044,
-0.4133364260196686,
-0.04098286107182503,
-0.5274822115898132,
-0.16534262895584106,
-0.07644195109605789,
0.8898571729660034,
0.5250844359397888,
0.36301174759864807,
0.009373832494020462,
-0.2894667387008667,
0.19431743025779724,
-0.11015089601278305,
-1.0551785230636597,
-0.4465097188949585,
-0.148311048746109,
-0.2375711053609848,
-0.1704941689968109,
-0.2987007796764374,
-0.7405108213424683,
0.013921630568802357,
-0.5749959349632263,
0.43773430585861206,
-0.24484692513942719,
-0.20724165439605713,
0.1961495578289032,
0.2776276767253876,
0.3069446384906769,
0.5447852611541748,
-0.8690943717956543,
0.2888418436050415,
0.6054853200912476,
0.9908933639526367,
-0.07369990646839142,
-0.061940547078847885,
-0.33284810185432434,
-0.0499187670648098,
-0.48294883966445923,
0.4356308579444885,
-0.806089460849762,
-0.6852030158042908,
0.24766512215137482,
-0.13038015365600586,
-0.09547869861125946,
-0.4971093237400055,
0.475833535194397,
-0.3047778606414795,
0.6147984266281128,
-0.198896586894989,
-0.6177869439125061,
-0.15882864594459534,
0.48841091990470886,
-0.6879230737686157,
0.8839090466499329,
0.4537458121776581,
-0.48304882645606995,
-0.03289264068007469,
-0.5957241654396057,
-0.053790852427482605,
0.2754654586315155,
-0.5933436751365662,
-0.43179604411125183,
-0.158315047621727,
0.2033158540725708,
0.532751202583313,
-0.501380443572998,
0.6282719373703003,
-0.023171473294496536,
-0.7737548351287842,
0.3527776896953583,
-0.57090824842453,
0.6736007332801819,
0.09248019009828568,
-0.49265626072883606,
0.07330743968486786,
-0.39477166533470154,
0.09182567149400711,
0.1834152638912201,
-0.5011496543884277,
-0.15228690207004547,
-0.19295503199100494,
-0.19127900898456573,
0.1449032425880432,
0.18428854644298553,
-0.47353678941726685,
0.39113688468933105,
-0.29571306705474854,
0.6093126535415649,
0.6708163022994995,
0.03549326956272125,
0.14658045768737793,
-0.27626845240592957,
0.703391969203949,
-0.08928938955068588,
0.24628116190433502,
-0.28101488947868347,
-0.5874310731887817,
-0.7724819779396057,
0.07690951973199844,
0.3184988796710968,
0.18254141509532928,
-1.0181981325149536,
-0.11292742192745209,
-0.21103501319885254,
-0.2949123680591583,
-0.4689556062221527,
0.1981256902217865,
0.5843331217765808,
0.2823444902896881,
0.15749512612819672,
-0.5488635301589966,
-0.423454225063324,
-0.6443942785263062,
-0.12039926648139954,
-0.23440493643283844,
-0.023142779245972633,
0.2000935822725296,
0.34584566950798035,
-0.20592591166496277,
0.7763423323631287,
-0.27494508028030396,
-0.08487191796302795,
-0.41824254393577576,
-0.02671540156006813,
0.1674821972846985,
0.27839529514312744,
0.5300605297088623,
-0.37807196378707886,
-0.6066064834594727,
-0.1715431809425354,
-0.688211977481842,
-0.16915367543697357,
0.05937020108103752,
-0.03241182118654251,
0.233176589012146,
0.16624155640602112,
-0.4220692813396454,
0.4359091520309448,
0.6408186554908752,
-0.13933730125427246,
0.6922153234481812,
0.021982984617352486,
0.33739709854125977,
-0.7438759207725525,
-0.2570124566555023,
0.10363315045833588,
0.027357470244169235,
-0.7162469625473022,
-0.11930608004331589,
-0.037387166172266006,
-0.2894042432308197,
-0.3390837013721466,
0.2886103093624115,
-0.4982439875602722,
-0.0951727107167244,
-0.1258649080991745,
0.5140450596809387,
-0.22099745273590088,
0.5436832308769226,
-0.003042419906705618,
0.9435694217681885,
0.12845958769321442,
-0.14245788753032684,
0.2621717154979706,
0.17653803527355194,
-0.6179996132850647,
0.22920255362987518,
-0.6786249876022339,
0.3721994459629059,
0.3042285144329071,
0.3654012382030487,
-0.9558672308921814,
-0.13464771211147308,
0.19870510697364807,
-0.28668642044067383,
0.35265985131263733,
-0.28361624479293823,
-0.660626232624054,
-0.4199430048465729,
-0.39903348684310913,
0.4600057303905487,
0.5148712992668152,
-0.48638466000556946,
0.27501800656318665,
0.23216812312602997,
-0.5418862700462341,
-0.30922362208366394,
-0.0848938524723053,
0.260463684797287,
-0.14875838160514832,
-0.5018815398216248,
-0.16734682023525238,
-0.22517456114292145,
-0.26956769824028015,
-0.17157961428165436,
-0.15727724134922028,
-0.22957909107208252,
0.07127909362316132,
0.03906381502747536,
0.6365801095962524,
-0.41782844066619873,
0.01664377935230732,
-0.06338922679424286,
-0.05795587971806526,
0.30638009309768677,
-0.06285621970891953,
0.5678446292877197,
-0.2769739627838135,
-0.31780850887298584,
-0.5084006190299988,
0.16246454417705536,
0.4486057460308075,
-0.08575591444969177,
0.4206271171569824,
0.484121710062027,
-0.14172694087028503,
-0.1435358226299286,
-0.6293372511863708,
-0.26186445355415344,
-0.5089311599731445,
0.36112740635871887,
-0.16200394928455353,
-1.1857279539108276,
0.17325876653194427,
-0.05427901819348335,
0.08778649568557739,
-0.019104287028312683,
0.6645947098731995,
0.23517568409442902,
0.9291806817054749,
0.38904401659965515,
-0.3685286343097687,
0.6127703785896301,
-0.41590234637260437,
0.4843181073665619,
-0.8060435056686401,
-0.0276313666254282,
-0.3595314025878906,
0.11180995404720306,
-0.2799077033996582,
-0.5647764801979065,
0.4357594847679138,
-0.15802551805973053,
-0.34462475776672363,
-0.13543343544006348,
-0.5405824780464172,
0.6260554194450378,
0.13448485732078552,
-0.10419148951768875,
0.41413360834121704,
-0.14116406440734863,
0.05678272619843483,
-0.15975603461265564,
-0.7362691164016724,
-0.9061838984489441,
1.0404247045516968,
0.37752896547317505,
0.48926886916160583,
0.3695079982280731,
0.5156049132347107,
-0.12958182394504547,
0.7333548665046692,
-0.7826361060142517,
0.7501357793807983,
0.03884904086589813,
-0.61668461561203,
-0.5138049125671387,
-0.46511244773864746,
-0.9497911930084229,
0.5781630873680115,
0.09567094594240189,
-0.6733899116516113,
-0.4356382489204407,
-0.12517638504505157,
-0.3801218271255493,
0.3539386987686157,
-0.835195004940033,
0.8344292640686035,
-0.19024598598480225,
-0.38950586318969727,
-0.023107299581170082,
-0.398466557264328,
0.6583212614059448,
-0.47520631551742554,
0.3551136255264282,
-0.10147169977426529,
0.39724069833755493,
1.0510900020599365,
-0.33231931924819946,
1.028232216835022,
-0.18393109738826752,
-0.4241524040699005,
0.5954969525337219,
0.011580994352698326,
0.20064637064933777,
-0.03390355408191681,
-0.037314318120479584,
0.2341090887784958,
0.16540490090847015,
-0.3495796024799347,
-0.8214849233627319,
0.7947182655334473,
-1.0027679204940796,
-0.9478392004966736,
-0.44725728034973145,
-0.4847511351108551,
-0.2771821916103363,
-0.03496113419532776,
-0.23508213460445404,
0.6991668343544006,
0.02894754149019718,
0.060679979622364044,
0.43936464190483093,
-0.41598430275917053,
0.6412853002548218,
0.7448502779006958,
-0.3479171693325043,
-0.1925273835659027,
0.7836247682571411,
0.5189008116722107,
0.44261282682418823,
-0.12241826951503754,
0.4044819474220276,
-0.21207180619239807,
-0.6010465025901794,
-0.358038067817688,
0.34071967005729675,
-0.8134668469429016,
-0.1269916594028473,
-0.451099157333374,
-0.43658605217933655,
-0.352104514837265,
-0.04135614633560181,
-0.1061183288693428,
-0.20826373994350433,
-0.06037847697734833,
-0.2134282886981964,
0.1824195384979248,
0.9834645390510559,
0.25775521993637085,
0.5483790636062622,
-0.9117968082427979,
-0.07816562056541443,
0.5002047419548035,
0.31260502338409424,
0.355278342962265,
-0.62715744972229,
-0.5023605823516846,
0.032154008746147156,
-0.5169663429260254,
-0.7216725945472717,
0.35314518213272095,
0.009851046837866306,
0.4959532916545868,
0.23470322787761688,
-0.1711960732936859,
0.6804848909378052,
-0.6120806336402893,
1.206794261932373,
0.2808237075805664,
-1.1723601818084717,
0.2003207951784134,
-0.4656732380390167,
0.37031400203704834,
0.11637677997350693,
0.27255433797836304,
-0.5151083469390869,
-0.4659161865711212,
-0.48420363664627075,
-0.6198720335960388,
0.6552038788795471,
0.2217780351638794,
0.2216537892818451,
0.060204870998859406,
0.3014712929725647,
0.024254975840449333,
0.18935856223106384,
-0.6288648843765259,
0.04960362985730171,
-0.24397720396518707,
-0.2522321045398712,
-0.27449455857276917,
-0.5568475127220154,
-0.2160605937242508,
-0.33497267961502075,
0.40893906354904175,
0.03380756080150604,
0.2238416224718094,
-0.12976720929145813,
0.0033384892158210278,
-0.007506730034947395,
0.6291943192481995,
0.4812854826450348,
0.949903666973114,
0.10324007272720337,
0.005369378719478846,
0.3116401731967926,
-0.6776286363601685,
0.21957533061504364,
0.04804036766290665,
0.23283879458904266,
0.12070903182029724,
0.4936208128929138,
0.5628594756126404,
0.6466142535209656,
-0.48975837230682373,
0.7104188799858093,
-0.13394665718078613,
-0.10267171263694763,
-0.45333194732666016,
0.13983137905597687,
0.10919307917356491,
0.25482693314552307,
0.2339039146900177,
-0.749089241027832,
0.2961975038051605,
-0.7511712312698364,
0.09430407732725143,
0.1540919840335846,
-0.11689341068267822,
-0.4851277768611908,
0.32107916474342346,
0.3981213867664337,
-0.34877750277519226,
0.7399706840515137,
0.09162352234125137,
-0.697207510471344,
0.4370296597480774,
0.6778501272201538,
0.6396927833557129,
-0.5384156703948975,
0.24736866354942322,
0.3339984118938446,
0.24275915324687958,
-0.08081676810979843,
0.11823207139968872,
0.020449530333280563,
-0.6880828738212585,
-0.7975876927375793,
-0.4815901219844818,
-0.7428399920463562,
0.32024043798446655,
-0.6188669800758362,
0.014963584020733833,
-0.4019090235233307,
-0.17928603291511536,
-0.01219445001333952,
0.29419630765914917,
-0.5098715424537659,
0.07577482610940933,
0.09429090470075607,
0.43608519434928894,
-0.7154176831245422,
1.0757473707199097,
0.5703964829444885,
-0.3629048466682434,
-1.2632197141647339,
-0.2115519642829895,
0.16172094643115997,
-0.7037578821182251,
0.7254355549812317,
0.1727527678012848,
-0.08308658748865128,
0.04198971763253212,
-0.6443490386009216,
-0.6461107730865479,
1.0658272504806519,
0.10654463618993759,
-0.9289847016334534,
-0.07928375899791718,
0.11275208741426468,
0.7152456641197205,
-0.339457243680954,
0.519292414188385,
0.9356353282928467,
0.40812671184539795,
0.0867304652929306,
-1.1829191446304321,
-0.035483263432979584,
-0.20613443851470947,
0.13756246864795685,
0.2608276605606079,
-0.6219208836555481,
0.7836268544197083,
-0.07732070237398148,
-0.2481820285320282,
0.20448647439479828,
0.3515598773956299,
0.3484066426753998,
0.4131956100463867,
0.1986757218837738,
0.20785675942897797,
0.5183024406433105,
-0.2644500434398651,
0.89019775390625,
-0.34189045429229736,
0.5351521372795105,
1.0599342584609985,
-0.35339003801345825,
0.6095283627510071,
0.28938621282577515,
-0.5635606050491333,
0.3387569189071655,
0.5318328142166138,
0.01736176386475563,
0.011003664694726467,
0.47245457768440247,
-0.5515273809432983,
-0.010883847251534462,
0.1952970027923584,
-0.4110017716884613,
0.17398610711097717,
0.6153790354728699,
0.022158073261380196,
-0.20782878994941711,
-0.11562535166740417,
0.3080650866031647,
0.06446539610624313,
-0.3762917220592499,
0.7255679368972778,
0.2616945803165436,
-0.4587666988372803,
0.7112006545066833,
-0.18152710795402527,
0.47315073013305664,
-0.3335639238357544,
-0.2705875039100647,
-0.32378655672073364,
0.031189922243356705,
-0.2662144899368286,
-0.6947343945503235,
-0.10058223456144333,
0.09501717239618301,
0.3474021852016449,
-0.01507343165576458,
0.38998618721961975,
-0.8225783705711365,
-0.335470050573349,
0.05023253336548805,
0.41618186235427856,
0.3592621982097626,
0.39146745204925537,
-0.5567324161529541,
0.4659695625305176,
0.13377715647220612,
-0.21580401062965393,
0.4393875002861023,
0.6437052488327026,
-0.09850744158029556,
0.5000190138816833,
0.5967810750007629,
-0.07130303233861923,
-0.02305866777896881,
0.4326492249965668,
1.1312611103057861,
-0.6956875324249268,
-0.08515863865613937,
-0.8256118893623352,
0.4587056636810303,
-0.01428707130253315,
-0.10622074455022812,
0.931418776512146,
0.4957633912563324,
0.8183680176734924,
-0.030976779758930206,
1.027682900428772,
0.4714323878288269,
0.4341065585613251,
-0.6189298033714294,
0.5251660346984863,
0.15610003471374512,
0.524541437625885,
-0.638126015663147,
-1.0325990915298462,
-0.22192203998565674,
0.789947509765625,
-0.7371301054954529,
0.1969113051891327,
0.8502699732780457,
0.5136701464653015,
0.15439271926879883,
0.330595999956131,
0.6670223474502563,
0.2712213099002838,
0.7637791633605957,
0.5495474934577942,
1.3301870822906494,
-0.25152572989463806,
0.3826192319393158,
-0.05688842013478279,
-0.34344911575317383,
-0.2417851835489273,
-0.47508978843688965,
-1.2472683191299438,
-0.42624029517173767,
-0.3446124196052551,
-0.2533133327960968,
0.12774400413036346,
0.7867892980575562,
0.30137842893600464,
-0.3967196047306061,
-0.4913744330406189,
0.471446692943573,
-0.13499361276626587,
0.3933210074901581,
-0.20535743236541748,
0.3628198504447937,
-0.3809897303581238,
-0.9130968451499939,
0.221025750041008,
0.1253381222486496,
0.2108008861541748,
-0.46408119797706604,
-0.09292155504226685,
0.14804157614707947,
0.23010657727718353,
0.8885141611099243,
-0.1692301630973816,
-0.810274600982666,
-0.4596012234687805,
-0.24635061621665955,
-0.08748231083154678,
-0.030823931097984314,
0.9675295352935791,
-0.4156067669391632,
0.6526945233345032,
-0.09577314555644989,
0.6263990998268127,
0.48066607117652893,
-0.09112277626991272,
0.6148372888565063,
-0.18943771719932556,
0.04941483959555626,
0.28664955496788025,
0.34560248255729675,
0.45856568217277527,
-0.09663956612348557,
0.6891797780990601,
0.1377757489681244,
-0.8364763259887695,
-0.8173342347145081,
-0.013734264299273491,
-0.7847679853439331,
-0.10692238807678223,
1.2826288938522339,
-0.5924952030181885,
-0.01089252158999443,
-0.2745915949344635,
-0.5211223363876343,
0.21750394999980927,
-0.36712947487831116,
0.849866509437561,
1.0565011501312256,
-0.002720977645367384,
-0.2598499059677124,
-0.9137258529663086,
0.4257720410823822,
0.15990369021892548,
-0.6584451794624329,
-0.2070865035057068,
0.6446737051010132,
0.4333500564098358,
-0.025468379259109497,
0.7503443956375122,
-0.4811117351055145,
0.12076450139284134,
-0.23920151591300964,
-0.06481745839118958,
0.11421443521976471,
0.056326184421777725,
-0.4313908517360687,
0.0837184339761734,
0.22910386323928833,
0.09305983036756516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02379v1 | Rethinking the Evaluation of Pre-trained Text-and-Layout Models from an Entity-Centric Perspective | 2024-02-04T07:33:45 | 2024-02-04T07:33:45 | Chong Zhang, Yixi Zhao, Chenshu Yuan, Yi Tu, Ya Guo, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently developed pre-trained text-and-layout models (PTLMs) have shown
remarkable success in multiple information extraction tasks on visually-rich
documents. However, the prevailing evaluation pipeline may not be sufficiently
robust for assessing the information extraction ability of PTLMs, due to
inadequate annotations within the benchmarks. Therefore, we claim the necessary
standards for an ideal benchmark to evaluate the information extraction ability
of PTLMs. We then introduce EC-FUNSD, an entity-centric benckmark designed for
the evaluation of semantic entity recognition and entity linking on
visually-rich documents. This dataset contains diverse formats of document
layouts and annotations of semantic-driven entities and their relations.
Moreover, this dataset disentangles the falsely coupled annotation of segment
and entity that arises from the block-level annotation of FUNSD. Experiment
results demonstrate that state-of-the-art PTLMs exhibit overfitting tendencies
on the prevailing benchmarks, as their performance sharply decrease when the
dataset bias is removed. | [
-0.7659795880317688,
-0.6730477809906006,
0.6488779783248901,
-0.13715042173862457,
-0.7133166790008545,
-0.0950070172548294,
-0.24491757154464722,
-0.6847215294837952,
0.21070747077465057,
0.6143402457237244,
-0.4485316276550293,
-0.6730916500091553,
-0.4674428403377533,
0.20709006488323212,
-0.5461806058883667,
1.0643967390060425,
-0.16109725832939148,
-0.04750186204910278,
-0.39500582218170166,
-0.1487150341272354,
-0.14072030782699585,
-0.3234550654888153,
-0.13855938613414764,
0.0265443567186594,
0.5270838737487793,
-0.05114992335438728,
0.4353679418563843,
0.9038910269737244,
0.6440355777740479,
0.21587859094142914,
0.15254193544387817,
0.1591549962759018,
-0.1894572228193283,
0.1396757811307907,
-0.35386398434638977,
-0.25523000955581665,
-0.4489276111125946,
0.1370045244693756,
0.466917484998703,
0.7758051156997681,
0.1647750437259674,
0.10649595409631729,
0.05846047401428223,
0.3309208154678345,
-0.9349860548973083,
0.059146590530872345,
-0.6472091674804688,
-0.03404110297560692,
-0.4627770781517029,
-0.2474479228258133,
-0.4835556149482727,
-0.31250232458114624,
0.5736244320869446,
-0.9943349957466125,
0.1436045616865158,
0.4408002197742462,
1.0733656883239746,
0.3527122437953949,
-0.23196972906589508,
-0.3663533926010132,
-0.4736047387123108,
0.8193187713623047,
-0.3171132504940033,
0.8166694045066833,
0.2769855856895447,
0.14831668138504028,
0.10990848392248154,
-0.8431076407432556,
-0.5296001434326172,
0.0060717142187058926,
-0.06784176081418991,
0.10487333685159683,
-0.005662234500050545,
-0.06464257091283798,
0.46917983889579773,
0.20167961716651917,
-0.35728830099105835,
0.0721234455704689,
-0.027425492182374,
-0.05440879240632057,
0.5934234261512756,
-0.10865680128335953,
0.3382301330566406,
-0.3828512728214264,
-0.7457899451255798,
-0.24035605788230896,
-0.576723039150238,
-0.18347099423408508,
0.3855687975883484,
0.09553946554660797,
0.07973459362983704,
0.5093446373939514,
0.016325920820236206,
0.5797615647315979,
0.04619774594902992,
0.08057092130184174,
0.4187995195388794,
-0.2086719423532486,
-0.49643442034721375,
0.3617118299007416,
0.5142647624015808,
0.33466482162475586,
0.398303359746933,
-0.4173440635204315,
-0.2161981761455536,
0.09196408838033676,
0.7794227004051208,
-0.8688535094261169,
-0.2306896597146988,
0.1990930587053299,
-0.5023976564407349,
-0.1119418665766716,
0.3127768337726593,
-0.9293195605278015,
-0.2546978294849396,
-0.5315341353416443,
0.46039703488349915,
-0.6488155126571655,
-0.20175401866436005,
-0.02613263577222824,
-0.30747365951538086,
0.20779003202915192,
0.5247681140899658,
-0.5750188827514648,
0.11104869842529297,
0.8878021836280823,
0.4301036298274994,
-0.4241756796836853,
-0.3642445206642151,
-0.24685701727867126,
0.3128657639026642,
-0.3197172284126282,
0.9517461657524109,
-0.6657705903053284,
-0.43284109234809875,
-0.07076326757669449,
0.012884542346000671,
-0.12416382879018784,
-0.43503400683403015,
0.8783494234085083,
-0.5410076975822449,
0.11515137553215027,
-0.5353850722312927,
-0.6803284883499146,
-0.04802769795060158,
0.44283348321914673,
-0.9082693457603455,
0.9873759150505066,
0.23613165318965912,
-1.2650922536849976,
1.1495048999786377,
-0.47053807973861694,
-0.3836289942264557,
0.11771326512098312,
-0.38071101903915405,
-0.46946462988853455,
0.2069617658853531,
0.05336663872003555,
0.19363652169704437,
-0.16156943142414093,
0.12053156644105911,
-0.621658980846405,
-0.30973634123802185,
0.24486283957958221,
-0.3612409830093384,
0.5499771237373352,
0.07009830325841904,
-0.3856629431247711,
0.024889051914215088,
-1.1793196201324463,
0.2795512080192566,
-0.0212742667645216,
-0.27966228127479553,
-1.0948656797409058,
-0.05700085684657097,
0.042235102504491806,
0.2780067026615143,
0.11860530823469162,
-0.768365740776062,
-0.04107850417494774,
-0.24056781828403473,
0.017678065225481987,
0.5674635767936707,
-0.09470017999410629,
0.3505297601222992,
0.047818057239055634,
0.09644927829504013,
0.02666148543357849,
0.07024145126342773,
-0.2944400906562805,
0.049453478306531906,
-0.7272107601165771,
-0.7673388123512268,
0.41744616627693176,
0.08951707184314728,
-0.8162152767181396,
0.6998010277748108,
-0.5557878613471985,
-0.5549918413162231,
-0.28413674235343933,
-0.1298266053199768,
0.3672894537448883,
0.7475828528404236,
0.5776347517967224,
-0.8604763150215149,
-0.5604469776153564,
-0.8557208180427551,
-0.3231419324874878,
-0.03989522531628609,
-0.08101948350667953,
0.12606953084468842,
0.5391384363174438,
0.06279589980840683,
0.9298422336578369,
0.013845338486135006,
-0.14024005830287933,
-0.11848662793636322,
0.12428729236125946,
-0.37929388880729675,
0.5071805715560913,
0.46836739778518677,
-0.9523967504501343,
-0.15759041905403137,
-0.11951328068971634,
-0.6864014267921448,
-0.01553074736148119,
0.04191701114177704,
-0.3998959958553314,
0.09630169719457626,
0.0994679182767868,
-0.8158082365989685,
0.8052460551261902,
0.05298842862248421,
-0.40138867497444153,
0.6293236613273621,
-0.03907165676355362,
0.11981503665447235,
-0.6217280626296997,
0.24388425052165985,
0.14486093819141388,
-0.03733990713953972,
-0.34134599566459656,
-0.13419444859027863,
0.45058104395866394,
0.12826398015022278,
-0.3868366777896881,
0.5632432699203491,
-0.6780109405517578,
-0.6381446123123169,
-0.025407740846276283,
0.3535082936286926,
0.6707169413566589,
0.3911978304386139,
0.3941363990306854,
0.21458156406879425,
0.21462339162826538,
-0.4010346531867981,
-0.06553136557340622,
0.31077903509140015,
-0.46602609753608704,
1.2375208139419556,
-0.3867231607437134,
-0.058970093727111816,
-0.15345148742198944,
0.3251694440841675,
-0.7290891408920288,
-0.10239589959383011,
0.10706445574760437,
0.1755981743335724,
0.6048850417137146,
0.09193380922079086,
-0.5976801514625549,
-0.27084872126579285,
-0.5311585068702698,
0.335014671087265,
-0.09013856202363968,
-0.6893309354782104,
0.6850923895835876,
0.2702803611755371,
0.14245016872882843,
-0.4065919816493988,
-0.5393475294113159,
-0.22793225944042206,
-0.3711191713809967,
-0.5081928968429565,
0.7434970736503601,
0.2961171865463257,
-0.21694445610046387,
0.2239057421684265,
-0.45063841342926025,
-0.07237505167722702,
0.1866709291934967,
0.3862179219722748,
0.49914976954460144,
-0.10634654015302658,
0.14301790297031403,
-0.03551969304680824,
-0.15199622511863708,
0.092961385846138,
-0.3251667618751526,
0.3914710283279419,
0.05208169296383858,
-0.74771648645401,
-0.2886534631252289,
0.2599577307701111,
0.2674385905265808,
-0.660740852355957,
0.5092529058456421,
0.5391549468040466,
-0.5159234404563904,
-0.1148897036910057,
-0.5540977120399475,
0.08267860114574432,
-0.3235662281513214,
0.5445429086685181,
-0.43678727746009827,
-0.4161471724510193,
0.13136985898017883,
-0.11908698827028275,
0.3401874005794525,
0.5463874936103821,
0.1430964320898056,
-0.13839475810527802,
0.6605368852615356,
0.7025688886642456,
0.5833942890167236,
0.48618659377098083,
-0.23194508254528046,
0.09502392262220383,
-1.0792988538742065,
-0.5219963192939758,
-0.7744816541671753,
-0.22581960260868073,
-0.4358845055103302,
-0.11052806675434113,
-0.03179444000124931,
0.28185662627220154,
-0.259299635887146,
0.5017496347427368,
-0.49012476205825806,
0.10184523463249207,
0.3564221262931824,
-0.007814663462340832,
0.2437300831079483,
-0.010579238645732403,
-0.2514704167842865,
-0.28630417585372925,
-0.3578053116798401,
-0.7940617203712463,
1.1479240655899048,
0.37560129165649414,
0.6349027156829834,
-0.2167307287454605,
0.7642332911491394,
-0.013847440481185913,
0.6359224319458008,
-0.46207618713378906,
0.36824876070022583,
-0.099260613322258,
-0.6067144274711609,
-0.40062543749809265,
-0.24928615987300873,
-0.7431294322013855,
0.341875284910202,
-0.1326516568660736,
-0.9293369054794312,
0.49184751510620117,
-0.25240397453308105,
-0.25500521063804626,
0.1544249951839447,
-0.8211473226547241,
1.0580980777740479,
-0.5864478945732117,
-0.5759639739990234,
0.08280052989721298,
-0.4051896333694458,
0.007150342687964439,
-0.258768767118454,
0.1755651831626892,
-0.06953974813222885,
-0.21791665256023407,
0.8124126195907593,
-0.3904530107975006,
0.295415997505188,
-0.13481539487838745,
-0.1569226235151291,
0.22365783154964447,
0.09764768183231354,
0.30463409423828125,
-0.09269271790981293,
-0.2097722887992859,
0.2051258087158203,
0.18241174519062042,
-0.23980876803398132,
-0.6131654977798462,
0.5278496146202087,
-0.5280681848526001,
-0.3104060888290405,
-0.27752402424812317,
-0.16674433648586273,
-0.2541322410106659,
0.4435492157936096,
0.3278498947620392,
0.6622021198272705,
-0.2741227149963379,
0.33254683017730713,
0.6480256915092468,
-0.0493648461997509,
0.6269241571426392,
0.2877073884010315,
-0.09751950949430466,
-0.3226175010204315,
0.7453203797340393,
0.3111899495124817,
0.051221542060375214,
0.28811153769493103,
-0.48911747336387634,
-0.5928238034248352,
-0.4272291958332062,
-0.5550647974014282,
0.12017319351434708,
-0.8537195324897766,
0.09378185868263245,
-0.8058758974075317,
-0.17226558923721313,
0.0426408126950264,
-0.11861806362867355,
-0.5838090777397156,
-0.29579830169677734,
-0.22105439007282257,
-0.10223574936389923,
-0.4000048339366913,
0.4067465662956238,
0.40147313475608826,
-0.08244257420301437,
-0.43080347776412964,
0.07837288826704025,
0.10332158207893372,
0.6117322444915771,
-0.05169933661818504,
-0.1342257857322693,
-0.13849063217639923,
-0.3690532445907593,
-0.3154313266277313,
-0.9176185727119446,
0.058584634214639664,
-0.08427318185567856,
0.9096654653549194,
0.43844252824783325,
0.0245298333466053,
0.5261280536651611,
-0.4329773485660553,
0.5064091086387634,
0.1564469337463379,
-0.7286665439605713,
0.48281440138816833,
0.1345292180776596,
-0.09186004102230072,
0.6738738417625427,
0.4902658462524414,
0.07802006602287292,
-0.07631215453147888,
-0.9455999732017517,
-0.8381633162498474,
0.4837600588798523,
0.2138301581144333,
-0.21099162101745605,
-0.10473883897066116,
0.14705443382263184,
0.4144046902656555,
0.5274839997291565,
-0.532776415348053,
-0.018787840381264687,
-0.5635470151901245,
-0.3879314661026001,
0.32899174094200134,
-0.3063738942146301,
0.11053608357906342,
0.17256741225719452,
0.5920778512954712,
0.0008856286876834929,
-0.0024595230352133512,
0.45296594500541687,
-0.438296377658844,
-0.016989385709166527,
0.4751797914505005,
0.12034127861261368,
0.9355295896530151,
-0.22050127387046814,
0.44559067487716675,
-0.14153169095516205,
-0.49627038836479187,
-0.17649632692337036,
0.6236734986305237,
-0.2298700362443924,
0.18120941519737244,
0.5501506924629211,
0.765239417552948,
0.5049028992652893,
-0.6139095425605774,
0.5235469937324524,
-0.21530397236347198,
0.18887926638126373,
-0.006517152767628431,
0.11164360493421555,
-0.38256338238716125,
0.03102618083357811,
0.3587740361690521,
-0.13294371962547302,
0.19815239310264587,
-0.37946024537086487,
0.4345949590206146,
0.6066411733627319,
-0.6302270293235779,
-0.42804214358329773,
0.5459290742874146,
0.32144197821617126,
-0.11690817773342133,
0.14264941215515137,
-0.08023800700902939,
-0.4486660361289978,
0.48869675397872925,
0.27812907099723816,
0.8041489720344543,
0.10767769068479538,
0.1426587998867035,
0.2467738687992096,
0.2820785939693451,
0.21521560847759247,
-0.01565057411789894,
-0.3631148636341095,
-0.3147846758365631,
-0.10183074325323105,
-0.845829427242279,
-0.18917831778526306,
0.00827766116708517,
-0.7275311946868896,
0.5523766875267029,
-0.4337071180343628,
-0.2208581268787384,
0.319366991519928,
0.4034684896469116,
-1.0263288021087646,
0.5539142489433289,
0.1717299073934555,
1.1285392045974731,
-0.3721753656864166,
0.7902670502662659,
0.7815026044845581,
-0.44422635436058044,
-0.5961469411849976,
0.03067273274064064,
-0.31129640340805054,
-0.31642448902130127,
0.4977321922779083,
0.5293160080909729,
0.28028687834739685,
-0.005113624501973391,
-0.23068679869174957,
-0.6909129023551941,
1.2182728052139282,
0.2651044428348541,
-0.6153061389923096,
-0.18805624544620514,
0.029880903661251068,
0.5872543454170227,
-0.5862125754356384,
0.4509870707988739,
0.5668261051177979,
0.4448382556438446,
-0.2159709632396698,
-0.7630043029785156,
0.05539289489388466,
-0.22106824815273285,
-0.022526197135448456,
0.20724394917488098,
-0.3856830298900604,
0.8136141896247864,
0.1971026062965393,
-0.3640937805175781,
-0.07376193255186081,
0.388187974691391,
0.4210508465766907,
0.42160898447036743,
0.754099428653717,
0.7736523747444153,
0.6375544667243958,
-0.2645600140094757,
1.0122833251953125,
-0.15853962302207947,
0.2839251458644867,
1.215202808380127,
-0.5918017029762268,
0.7308089733123779,
0.6777307987213135,
0.03742794692516327,
0.6166449189186096,
0.565481960773468,
-0.011051060631871223,
0.6993293762207031,
0.0626598671078682,
0.2029556930065155,
-0.23461896181106567,
-0.3113275468349457,
-0.5127615332603455,
0.35740649700164795,
0.36567404866218567,
-0.5933614373207092,
-0.5454481244087219,
-0.3112465441226959,
-0.1491939276456833,
-0.0677563026547432,
-0.1230681762099266,
0.5820647478103638,
0.08832962810993195,
-0.6367867588996887,
-0.013912105932831764,
-0.038115087896585464,
0.3329528570175171,
-0.3644505739212036,
0.00011831857409561053,
0.05862636864185333,
-0.09063759446144104,
-0.173212930560112,
-0.6950351595878601,
0.15835422277450562,
0.05454760044813156,
0.0016422112239524722,
-0.062337588518857956,
1.0587915182113647,
-0.27613306045532227,
-0.27941569685935974,
0.3314521014690399,
0.526084840297699,
-0.008610461838543415,
-0.06666954606771469,
-0.48457109928131104,
0.3751221299171448,
-0.3047274053096771,
-0.48397722840309143,
0.3009895086288452,
0.8341867923736572,
-0.19859883189201355,
0.3265116512775421,
0.5950426459312439,
0.0021365995053201914,
0.07329804450273514,
0.11509015411138535,
0.8170639872550964,
-0.4965996742248535,
-0.8360384106636047,
-0.8689801096916199,
0.551134467124939,
-0.4885585606098175,
-0.35712793469429016,
0.6519950032234192,
0.6714568734169006,
1.01273512840271,
0.31717461347579956,
0.7115921378135681,
-0.03274096921086311,
0.2990585267543793,
-0.44649356603622437,
0.607666015625,
-0.5331966876983643,
0.30520009994506836,
-0.6323672533035278,
-1.2955358028411865,
0.05308086797595024,
0.43327009677886963,
-0.6371003985404968,
0.19645386934280396,
0.7669817209243774,
0.13488440215587616,
-0.2460106909275055,
0.49184247851371765,
0.22122274339199066,
-0.2296660989522934,
0.31190040707588196,
0.404384046792984,
0.9344463348388672,
-0.19390195608139038,
0.5188103914260864,
-0.4591676890850067,
-0.07786943018436432,
-0.2038315087556839,
-1.0178375244140625,
-1.0007370710372925,
-0.5236218571662903,
-0.44194117188453674,
-0.12781654298305511,
-0.04552748054265976,
0.6008517742156982,
0.7585394382476807,
-0.4206381142139435,
0.568892776966095,
-0.005706931930035353,
0.0692838802933693,
0.18491101264953613,
-0.18158681690692902,
0.7344359159469604,
-0.07576676458120346,
-0.5318775773048401,
-0.2135171741247177,
0.5767281651496887,
0.1817624866962433,
-0.4556746780872345,
0.13062752783298492,
0.004836567677557468,
-0.049367427825927734,
0.275805801153183,
0.01973176933825016,
-0.6345080137252808,
-0.5174842476844788,
-0.1899137794971466,
-0.48288944363594055,
0.05798107013106346,
0.6363237500190735,
-0.7621400356292725,
0.4361104965209961,
0.08621219545602798,
0.8285576701164246,
0.27832210063934326,
0.2084357589483261,
0.06373235583305359,
-0.6326111555099487,
0.21519845724105835,
-0.0076131680980324745,
0.474785715341568,
0.5632200837135315,
-0.19546188414096832,
0.5729511976242065,
0.16961023211479187,
-0.07714807987213135,
-0.9243344068527222,
-0.048504091799259186,
-0.9080889225006104,
-0.10020169615745544,
0.7617393136024475,
-0.5560478568077087,
-0.6522809267044067,
-0.05751151591539383,
-0.1756477802991867,
0.41628801822662354,
-0.15188124775886536,
0.7472111582756042,
0.7976823449134827,
0.030198154971003532,
0.0427844412624836,
-0.32185104489326477,
0.44557076692581177,
0.3941175043582916,
-1.151345133781433,
-0.07845403254032135,
0.5881284475326538,
0.13078570365905762,
0.5250073075294495,
0.4351327121257782,
-0.25563934445381165,
0.3097943663597107,
0.056930024176836014,
0.0739884302020073,
-0.15186896920204163,
-0.5473324656486511,
0.06854772567749023,
0.36785852909088135,
-0.12318764626979828,
-0.15842591226100922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02370v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02370v2 | AutoTimes: Autoregressive Time Series Forecasters via Large Language Models | 2024-02-04T06:59:21 | 2024-05-23T01:58:28 | Yong Liu, Guo Qin, Xiangdong Huang, Jianmin Wang, Mingsheng Long | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Foundation models of time series have not been fully developed due to the
limited availability of time series corpora and the underexploration of
scalable pre-training. Based on the similar sequential formulation of time
series and natural language, increasing research demonstrates the feasibility
of leveraging large language models (LLM) for time series. Nevertheless, the
inherent autoregressive property and decoder-only architecture of LLMs have not
been fully considered, resulting in insufficient utilization of LLM abilities.
To further exploit the general-purpose token transition and multi-step
generation ability of large language models, we propose AutoTimes to repurpose
LLMs as autoregressive time series forecasters, which independently projects
time series segments into the embedding space and autoregressively generates
future predictions with arbitrary lengths. Compatible with any decoder-only
LLMs, the consequent forecaster exhibits the flexibility of the lookback length
and scalability of the LLM size. Further, we formulate time series as prompts,
extending the context for prediction beyond the lookback window, termed
in-context forecasting. By adopting textual timestamps as position embeddings,
AutoTimes integrates multimodality for multivariate scenarios. Empirically,
AutoTimes achieves state-of-the-art with 0.1% trainable parameters and over 5
times training/inference speedup compared to advanced LLM-based forecasters. | [
-0.18977628648281097,
-0.4393358528614044,
0.40992847084999084,
0.4722497761249542,
-0.28028348088264465,
0.22828033566474915,
0.021415214985609055,
-0.4651072025299072,
0.16426204144954681,
0.24608176946640015,
-0.5793974995613098,
-0.021145043894648552,
-0.6076372861862183,
-0.05566977337002754,
-0.7884015440940857,
0.7626598477363586,
-0.23104992508888245,
-0.08817487955093384,
0.19751106202602386,
0.10399262607097626,
-0.22657819092273712,
-0.5577937364578247,
-0.4473990201950073,
-0.18467748165130615,
0.31258538365364075,
0.08390630781650543,
0.7650678157806396,
0.9299831986427307,
0.05740412697196007,
0.3077162504196167,
0.4479290843009949,
-0.005663486197590828,
-0.03933067247271538,
0.3742606043815613,
0.21631748974323273,
-0.025600716471672058,
-0.3971976041793823,
-0.07094330340623856,
0.7658936381340027,
0.6145633459091187,
-0.3343627452850342,
0.2506488561630249,
-0.095953568816185,
0.36698204278945923,
-0.5698664784431458,
0.5714104175567627,
-0.43386295437812805,
0.315759539604187,
0.08491048216819763,
-0.14290748536586761,
-0.2662156820297241,
-0.2523578405380249,
0.1684010624885559,
-0.25250282883644104,
0.1872790902853012,
0.363086462020874,
0.34612375497817993,
0.5458376407623291,
-0.47822174429893494,
0.08645054697990417,
-0.9741072058677673,
0.8431367874145508,
-0.9705620408058167,
0.583358645439148,
-0.036489132791757584,
0.6185587048530579,
-0.005219044163823128,
-0.5981259942054749,
-0.36532139778137207,
-0.11789678037166595,
0.0015296457568183541,
-0.005193590652197599,
-0.09333161264657974,
-0.36512449383735657,
0.20857831835746765,
0.4213739037513733,
-0.6437279582023621,
0.1501431167125702,
0.24314983189105988,
0.03857363760471344,
0.48675546050071716,
0.5753098130226135,
-0.1647452414035797,
0.031086215749382973,
-0.4396800398826599,
-0.021842246875166893,
-0.4117405414581299,
-0.16125139594078064,
0.10136103630065918,
0.27136191725730896,
-0.0499911904335022,
0.3258170187473297,
-0.042114246636629105,
0.5283381938934326,
0.1348130702972412,
-0.10845328122377396,
0.10785560309886932,
-0.23129604756832123,
-0.5543975234031677,
-0.061382438987493515,
0.8093631267547607,
0.035726599395275116,
-0.015581061132252216,
-0.28536584973335266,
-0.16582617163658142,
-0.22471855580806732,
-0.15303091704845428,
-1.0661661624908447,
-0.27651917934417725,
0.02525017224252224,
-0.4112555980682373,
-0.16300025582313538,
-0.23172585666179657,
-0.9238073825836182,
-0.08102448284626007,
-0.5152274966239929,
0.1749044507741928,
-0.3243785500526428,
-0.2075813114643097,
0.048379283398389816,
0.057279475033283234,
0.27990418672561646,
0.3381589651107788,
-0.9264872670173645,
0.26274633407592773,
0.280148446559906,
0.7039167881011963,
-0.02158207818865776,
-0.38563966751098633,
-0.5556012392044067,
0.42577484250068665,
-0.32531842589378357,
0.5767576098442078,
-0.39633259177207947,
-0.5504745841026306,
-0.06645138561725616,
0.2546391487121582,
-0.08365779370069504,
-0.01351092103868723,
-0.354108989238739,
-0.6258103847503662,
0.24038846790790558,
0.2474387288093567,
-0.44541221857070923,
-0.009049147367477417,
0.17578619718551636,
-0.48758748173713684,
0.772429347038269,
0.0394313670694828,
-0.3302066922187805,
0.4108907878398895,
-0.41818860173225403,
-0.6298390030860901,
-0.33747047185897827,
-0.021101539954543114,
-0.24967016279697418,
-0.2507507801055908,
0.6734980940818787,
0.6589105725288391,
-0.5337069630622864,
0.5845645666122437,
-0.4439958930015564,
0.23533420264720917,
0.02383306622505188,
-0.9960340261459351,
0.48126956820487976,
0.40853938460350037,
-0.49080923199653625,
-0.10720253735780716,
-0.6582298874855042,
-0.07258608192205429,
0.029241502285003662,
0.07256043702363968,
-0.23489044606685638,
0.17294920980930328,
0.24533222615718842,
0.2717097997665405,
0.3459841012954712,
-0.3877846598625183,
0.322479248046875,
-0.4371729791164398,
0.6749565005302429,
0.6730859875679016,
-0.1410820633172989,
0.49498143792152405,
-0.05081978067755699,
0.8118637204170227,
0.14955545961856842,
0.3789646327495575,
-0.6575651168823242,
-0.04957089573144913,
-0.6140024065971375,
-0.32840803265571594,
-0.06652693450450897,
0.4975453019142151,
-0.6743407249450684,
0.3801988363265991,
-0.3587411642074585,
-0.681109607219696,
0.20551474392414093,
0.0774548277258873,
0.22032643854618073,
0.26281026005744934,
0.3675588071346283,
-0.10649428516626358,
-0.546554684638977,
-0.6782942414283752,
-0.2766970098018646,
-0.08636833727359772,
0.16646315157413483,
0.00946558266878128,
0.4405737519264221,
-0.2574749290943146,
0.9990642666816711,
-0.5570083856582642,
0.1486690789461136,
-0.04364898428320885,
0.3477360010147095,
0.2073926031589508,
0.3548785448074341,
0.5391461849212646,
-0.549381673336029,
-0.3987481892108917,
-0.4608730673789978,
-0.5710031390190125,
0.09224972873926163,
0.046035390347242355,
0.2611982524394989,
0.38203495740890503,
0.8622687458992004,
-0.273817241191864,
0.3036510944366455,
0.7106484770774841,
-0.5084188580513,
0.432437539100647,
-0.10726551711559296,
-0.1403973549604416,
-1.3825609683990479,
0.00521111860871315,
-0.06774678826332092,
-0.42568233609199524,
-0.0961698666214943,
-0.5255078077316284,
-0.16212281584739685,
-0.397433876991272,
-0.2909144163131714,
1.0457744598388672,
-0.638476550579071,
-0.3355550169944763,
-0.11778630316257477,
-0.35757049918174744,
0.15684518218040466,
0.023018287494778633,
0.061981894075870514,
0.6945774555206299,
0.34358951449394226,
-0.7479614615440369,
0.3989615738391876,
0.06584857404232025,
-0.40111273527145386,
0.20081721246242523,
-0.4836445748806,
-0.2246200144290924,
-0.047987379133701324,
0.6122961044311523,
-0.8173409104347229,
-0.07847113162279129,
-0.05063670501112938,
-0.1253538578748703,
0.5294349193572998,
-0.17175441980361938,
-0.5118622779846191,
-0.4796696603298187,
0.051660776138305664,
0.526645839214325,
0.4011077284812927,
-0.6829157471656799,
0.8329569101333618,
0.28144970536231995,
-0.3157102167606354,
-0.7372481226921082,
-0.7808224558830261,
0.26340949535369873,
-0.1999567449092865,
-0.28891390562057495,
0.280836284160614,
-0.32386189699172974,
-0.21327082812786102,
0.01598416082561016,
0.2224431037902832,
0.008418969810009003,
0.02958962693810463,
0.15972883999347687,
0.4176676869392395,
-0.23556305468082428,
0.08938057720661163,
-0.12413358688354492,
-0.2341441512107849,
0.04745231941342354,
-0.7451218962669373,
0.5131308436393738,
-0.24770788848400116,
-0.32431578636169434,
-0.10425253957509995,
0.3281154930591583,
0.8235494494438171,
-0.25138577818870544,
0.6522576808929443,
0.6238948702812195,
-0.2657761871814728,
-0.16587868332862854,
-0.6699771881103516,
-0.10440652072429657,
-0.4423224925994873,
0.3768851161003113,
-0.08711877465248108,
-0.8409294486045837,
0.4314638674259186,
0.05236802622675896,
0.24055950343608856,
0.43724769353866577,
0.5641117691993713,
0.22905220091342926,
1.1496644020080566,
0.5972850918769836,
-0.5440718531608582,
0.7159611582756042,
-0.3841451108455658,
0.24484147131443024,
-0.6802679896354675,
-0.11883421987295151,
-0.1588984876871109,
-0.0941111370921135,
-0.26037412881851196,
-0.3242141306400299,
0.265636682510376,
-0.34486550092697144,
-0.7647531032562256,
0.4933951795101166,
-0.22424481809139252,
0.1513197422027588,
0.2845152020454407,
-0.46485579013824463,
0.17548875510692596,
-0.03750081732869148,
0.11284283548593521,
0.04475851356983185,
-0.8099353909492493,
-0.1875103861093521,
0.9804446697235107,
0.45898333191871643,
1.1336524486541748,
-0.18970704078674316,
0.2974948287010193,
0.3543784022331238,
0.5252212285995483,
-0.7528930902481079,
0.2866709232330322,
-0.42916974425315857,
-0.4376402497291565,
-0.3828253746032715,
-0.16370199620723724,
-0.5900508165359497,
-0.09179794043302536,
0.1553664207458496,
-0.32905635237693787,
0.5799345970153809,
0.1829541176557541,
-0.4778367877006531,
0.4702085852622986,
-0.3639966547489166,
0.8498373627662659,
-0.30095550417900085,
-0.2541065812110901,
-0.06827937811613083,
-0.585867166519165,
0.10284976661205292,
0.0061129238456487656,
0.3598227798938751,
-0.19772326946258545,
-0.1691751331090927,
0.44597986340522766,
-0.5274620056152344,
1.0263456106185913,
-0.16275250911712646,
-0.1951436698436737,
0.09198775142431259,
0.28509944677352905,
0.4056069254875183,
0.18552374839782715,
-0.02904571406543255,
0.06502368301153183,
0.09633473306894302,
-0.20533518493175507,
-0.5234633088111877,
0.8493609428405762,
-0.6258608102798462,
-0.3249051570892334,
-0.6170372366905212,
-0.4942812919616699,
-0.39643922448158264,
0.021154774352908134,
0.1644904464483261,
0.9425030946731567,
-0.4688029885292053,
-0.011176800355315208,
0.2831975817680359,
0.10980977863073349,
1.1208593845367432,
0.7424068450927734,
-0.4051416516304016,
-0.6573935151100159,
0.6987616419792175,
0.00006724824197590351,
0.12200263142585754,
0.5795939564704895,
0.13539338111877441,
-0.6391007304191589,
-0.21900074183940887,
-0.517962634563446,
0.17964665591716766,
-0.556916356086731,
-0.31333351135253906,
-0.6411167979240417,
-0.2786884307861328,
-0.6184729337692261,
-0.2501012980937958,
-0.5333417654037476,
-0.45158126950263977,
-0.4035305976867676,
0.07756700366735458,
0.3891731798648834,
0.6220203638076782,
-0.12467554956674576,
0.3748760521411896,
-0.9017804861068726,
0.17575706541538239,
0.6102122068405151,
0.33996260166168213,
0.18138878047466278,
-0.6078815460205078,
-0.4585402309894562,
-0.2939002513885498,
-0.17108556628227234,
-0.39389947056770325,
1.1443613767623901,
0.17108865082263947,
0.2578589916229248,
0.4353312849998474,
-0.1276918202638626,
0.7941347360610962,
-0.7994928359985352,
0.721133291721344,
0.1760573387145996,
-0.9808770418167114,
0.2939000725746155,
-0.33935925364494324,
0.39615297317504883,
0.06904274970293045,
0.2511182427406311,
-0.5808100700378418,
-0.3182583153247833,
-0.3981966972351074,
-1.0054291486740112,
0.47486552596092224,
-0.282090425491333,
0.108344167470932,
-0.3491596579551697,
0.19911548495292664,
0.26916801929473877,
0.5690880417823792,
-0.4933989346027374,
-0.17681877315044403,
-0.8353680968284607,
-0.15726017951965332,
-0.6805341243743896,
-0.2757887542247772,
0.16587470471858978,
-0.04420384019613266,
0.5705490112304688,
-0.2528766989707947,
0.3050623834133148,
0.32016825675964355,
0.009814336895942688,
-0.17945072054862976,
0.27995505928993225,
0.2539706528186798,
0.6327733397483826,
-0.14175261557102203,
-0.16985984146595,
0.08241179585456848,
-0.04472314566373825,
0.3363616466522217,
0.589424192905426,
-0.06148555502295494,
-0.003415037179365754,
0.1864796280860901,
0.8304778933525085,
0.4401729702949524,
-0.314639151096344,
0.23652558028697968,
-0.012402440421283245,
0.2177979052066803,
-1.1671216487884521,
-0.29631853103637695,
-0.12558555603027344,
0.5306844711303711,
0.5206628441810608,
-0.10133194178342819,
0.028807206079363823,
-0.5942879319190979,
-0.02253752388060093,
0.49078306555747986,
-0.2798352837562561,
-0.33013734221458435,
1.1601182222366333,
0.15462082624435425,
-0.07238322496414185,
0.4779420495033264,
0.10945728421211243,
-0.30911579728126526,
0.8682254552841187,
0.7023236751556396,
1.2191702127456665,
-0.630447506904602,
-0.09769728034734726,
0.2474527359008789,
0.12532088160514832,
-0.4376920163631439,
0.03488735482096672,
0.21265535056591034,
-0.591240406036377,
-0.7098954916000366,
-0.8136730790138245,
-0.3679017424583435,
0.22095133364200592,
-0.4767472743988037,
0.15529748797416687,
-0.5725522637367249,
-0.3111007511615753,
-0.2420913279056549,
-0.23928947746753693,
-0.74306321144104,
0.4898914694786072,
0.2775953412055969,
1.0814810991287231,
-0.8263312578201294,
0.7718410491943359,
0.44904670119285583,
-0.08833206444978714,
-0.5578756928443909,
0.06562149524688721,
-0.08077765256166458,
-0.7093839049339294,
0.8843635320663452,
0.1584264039993286,
-0.2529546916484833,
0.20598241686820984,
-0.4495372772216797,
-1.1700774431228638,
1.3139170408248901,
0.2134363353252411,
-0.6011411547660828,
-0.5329170227050781,
-0.19238941371440887,
0.3703868091106415,
-0.803202211856842,
0.16363589465618134,
0.2270977944135666,
0.4339900612831116,
-0.03720651939511299,
-0.8221113085746765,
0.012799771502614021,
-0.13385429978370667,
0.2134857475757599,
0.48898181319236755,
-0.787594735622406,
0.8747966289520264,
-0.031984806060791016,
0.03951147571206093,
0.3220924437046051,
0.9595531821250916,
-0.3298289477825165,
0.33328574895858765,
0.5758357644081116,
0.38386866450309753,
0.14427971839904785,
0.10252498835325241,
1.046547532081604,
-0.7200989723205566,
0.12727715075016022,
1.1103696823120117,
-0.31843653321266174,
0.7589908242225647,
0.28517255187034607,
-0.17586922645568848,
0.8427584171295166,
0.402871698141098,
-0.14711731672286987,
0.5145242214202881,
-0.31029996275901794,
-0.18711841106414795,
-0.5649016499519348,
0.1387864649295807,
-0.3373083770275116,
0.445584774017334,
0.5637094378471375,
-0.4848233759403229,
-0.17718137800693512,
0.1367490440607071,
-0.002386008622124791,
-0.1771903932094574,
-0.30397945642471313,
0.3843262791633606,
0.3303740322589874,
-0.592877984046936,
0.2271711230278015,
-0.1897672712802887,
0.5139207243919373,
-0.7885726690292358,
0.14158685505390167,
-0.04720892012119293,
0.1718578040599823,
0.24440789222717285,
-0.36779388785362244,
0.4296093285083771,
-0.2897191643714905,
-0.3372379541397095,
-0.48476263880729675,
0.3326733112335205,
-0.5324971675872803,
-0.6606044173240662,
0.42883560061454773,
0.5112414956092834,
-0.2156897336244583,
0.09753420948982239,
-0.534415066242218,
-0.4516567587852478,
-0.35022982954978943,
-0.4052659869194031,
0.22547118365764618,
0.3462789058685303,
0.03226039186120033,
1.0669853687286377,
0.5793561339378357,
0.04233807697892189,
-0.06910984218120575,
0.042314544320106506,
0.7181735634803772,
-0.981054425239563,
-0.5909665822982788,
-0.8778057098388672,
0.16962072253227234,
0.35312944650650024,
0.011995979584753513,
0.7149645686149597,
0.6308309435844421,
0.3065595328807831,
-0.1459500938653946,
0.881962776184082,
0.16264759004116058,
0.7352138757705688,
-0.5523106455802917,
0.4947816729545593,
-0.6140152812004089,
0.28030452132225037,
-0.11172512918710709,
-0.9102436900138855,
-0.06960983574390411,
0.06451919674873352,
-0.4552809000015259,
0.056870196014642715,
0.6002726554870605,
0.20996156334877014,
-0.04804474115371704,
-0.04985139146447182,
0.14679624140262604,
0.405598908662796,
0.420476496219635,
0.41080591082572937,
0.6163275837898254,
-0.2517911195755005,
0.7270070910453796,
-0.1955360472202301,
-0.10309141874313354,
-0.3867741525173187,
-1.2569289207458496,
-0.8014987707138062,
-0.48869600892066956,
-0.18639881908893585,
-0.17882202565670013,
0.1218353882431984,
0.9853783249855042,
0.5119558572769165,
-0.7432053685188293,
-0.42485061287879944,
0.02109004184603691,
-0.4463234543800354,
0.008906463161110878,
-0.31575706601142883,
0.42685070633888245,
-0.33306267857551575,
-0.8788387179374695,
0.7042765617370605,
0.23495031893253326,
0.45727744698524475,
-0.8225749135017395,
0.18576449155807495,
0.2857855558395386,
0.015173227526247501,
0.71153724193573,
0.5335861444473267,
-0.5498161911964417,
-0.06434936821460724,
0.18901459872722626,
0.03796866163611412,
-0.13447749614715576,
0.8488505482673645,
-1.1214534044265747,
0.3204715847969055,
0.3150913417339325,
0.3630559742450714,
0.5985627174377441,
-0.09035690128803253,
1.0541740655899048,
-0.36320921778678894,
0.25117576122283936,
0.23970811069011688,
0.7267168164253235,
0.3855409324169159,
-0.20814336836338043,
0.14751467108726501,
0.2163248062133789,
-0.6924523711204529,
-0.5342025756835938,
0.27386632561683655,
-0.43672701716423035,
-0.196487158536911,
1.0459747314453125,
0.06242923066020012,
-0.10905073583126068,
-0.2652614712715149,
0.3160519301891327,
0.33223584294319153,
-0.466126024723053,
0.7847262024879456,
0.500497043132782,
-0.06542174518108368,
-0.06083676964044571,
-0.4699997007846832,
0.40369465947151184,
0.10379690676927567,
-0.4930206537246704,
0.3417239487171173,
0.46577998995780945,
0.3542577922344208,
-0.05785081535577774,
0.5393675565719604,
-0.16868992149829865,
-0.09000539779663086,
-0.16382598876953125,
-0.0980449914932251,
-0.39410296082496643,
-0.485525906085968,
-0.3038889765739441,
-0.2738693952560425,
-0.059858497232198715,
0.0314035564661026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02369v1 | M$^3$Face: A Unified Multi-Modal Multilingual Framework for Human Face Generation and Editing | 2024-02-04T06:56:23 | 2024-02-04T06:56:23 | Mohammadreza Mofayezi, Reza Alipour, Mohammad Ali Kakavand, Ehsaneddin Asgari | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | Human face generation and editing represent an essential task in the era of
computer vision and the digital world. Recent studies have shown remarkable
progress in multi-modal face generation and editing, for instance, using face
segmentation to guide image generation. However, it may be challenging for some
users to create these conditioning modalities manually. Thus, we introduce
M3Face, a unified multi-modal multilingual framework for controllable face
generation and editing. This framework enables users to utilize only text input
to generate controlling modalities automatically, for instance, semantic
segmentation or facial landmarks, and subsequently generate face images. We
conduct extensive qualitative and quantitative experiments to showcase our
frameworks face generation and editing capabilities. Additionally, we propose
the M3CelebA Dataset, a large-scale multi-modal and multilingual face dataset
containing high-quality images, semantic segmentations, facial landmarks, and
different captions for each image in multiple languages. The code and the
dataset will be released upon publication. | [
-0.5605481863021851,
-0.6782581210136414,
0.36735185980796814,
0.5696436166763306,
-0.006302621681243181,
-0.09318385273218155,
0.020150844007730484,
-0.5092371106147766,
-0.016141146421432495,
0.6252909898757935,
-0.9168429970741272,
-0.48232483863830566,
-0.23078930377960205,
0.22669759392738342,
0.1689058542251587,
0.8043800592422485,
-0.007526226341724396,
0.3144568204879761,
-0.20737573504447937,
-0.26161783933639526,
-0.5532224178314209,
-0.5112687349319458,
-0.6268603205680847,
0.07172142714262009,
0.7272573709487915,
0.326676607131958,
0.9295563697814941,
0.3681122362613678,
0.2924402058124542,
0.33244025707244873,
0.15663757920265198,
0.5424127578735352,
-0.09132082015275955,
-0.03609869256615639,
-0.4015873670578003,
0.031805116683244705,
-0.48162543773651123,
-0.03946653753519058,
0.5204156637191772,
0.8217759132385254,
0.08405453711748123,
0.01231202483177185,
-0.22434432804584503,
0.8073716163635254,
-0.45497921109199524,
-0.06452915817499161,
-0.5247946381568909,
-0.09192828088998795,
-0.44460898637771606,
0.03445973992347717,
-0.1142856553196907,
-0.20648761093616486,
-0.4049351215362549,
-0.5770888924598694,
0.024850258603692055,
0.09765996783971786,
0.5494682192802429,
0.0446745790541172,
-0.5669220089912415,
-0.10402560234069824,
-0.37220412492752075,
0.41341346502304077,
-0.23182985186576843,
0.6124944686889648,
0.07146703451871872,
0.4788946807384491,
-0.20521418750286102,
-0.5414814949035645,
-0.8098358511924744,
-0.025832217186689377,
-0.034290067851543427,
0.0024507814086973667,
-0.11455747485160828,
0.11526641994714737,
0.12598690390586853,
0.07973784953355789,
-0.5426365733146667,
-0.10552166402339935,
-0.3028622269630432,
-0.4646639823913574,
0.6661059856414795,
0.0642385333776474,
0.613885760307312,
-0.49122828245162964,
-0.3290593922138214,
-0.08042745292186737,
-0.8853058218955994,
0.07008909434080124,
0.5203270316123962,
0.12801648676395416,
0.040061067789793015,
0.700803816318512,
-0.45171743631362915,
0.8080204725265503,
-0.04215587303042412,
-0.5124536156654358,
0.23876981437206268,
-0.10990873724222183,
-0.5180677771568298,
-0.3611496686935425,
0.7664977312088013,
0.649603009223938,
0.09774906933307648,
-0.19152328372001648,
-0.12108640372753143,
-0.06764337420463562,
0.07236514985561371,
-1.0992960929870605,
-0.06668049097061157,
0.2176257073879242,
-0.28639858961105347,
-0.605038583278656,
0.19261835515499115,
-0.6643534898757935,
-0.39124414324760437,
-0.5672764778137207,
0.36941567063331604,
-0.31031695008277893,
-0.1362672746181488,
0.005508479196578264,
0.08717760443687439,
-0.21514999866485596,
0.655036449432373,
-0.7641879320144653,
-0.06210058927536011,
0.016514893621206284,
0.441327303647995,
-0.039729297161102295,
-0.5904600620269775,
-0.33293822407722473,
0.2851056456565857,
-0.3176724314689636,
0.5534855127334595,
-0.30203747749328613,
-0.37410351634025574,
-0.08767473697662354,
0.21954114735126495,
-0.04510069638490677,
-0.6304813027381897,
0.21993885934352875,
-0.5987225770950317,
0.4075027108192444,
-0.18888230621814728,
0.07943077385425568,
-0.10699430108070374,
0.004605050664395094,
-0.7974264621734619,
0.6490585207939148,
0.26264452934265137,
-0.4402356743812561,
0.3458707630634308,
-0.765745997428894,
-0.4282962679862976,
-0.06207675486803055,
-0.3742179870605469,
-0.3953009247779846,
0.030981672927737236,
0.3972074091434479,
0.5742506980895996,
-0.1118261069059372,
0.49375322461128235,
-0.1109108179807663,
0.30560049414634705,
0.3573262691497803,
-0.2144758403301239,
0.9135092496871948,
0.26650628447532654,
-0.5185288190841675,
0.27719560265541077,
-0.7435112595558167,
0.004230601247400045,
0.08960096538066864,
-0.3637917935848236,
0.28326839208602905,
-0.1295631229877472,
0.744026243686676,
0.8193901777267456,
0.06643351167440414,
-0.6573448777198792,
0.17857111990451813,
0.36823758482933044,
0.2700830399990082,
0.6782323122024536,
0.09427191317081451,
0.17959311604499817,
-0.30492717027664185,
0.2803269922733307,
0.4632749855518341,
0.09706256538629532,
-0.5106862187385559,
-0.5084612965583801,
-0.46372684836387634,
-0.4312936067581177,
0.0679640993475914,
0.6397232413291931,
-1.113068699836731,
0.05417770892381668,
-0.11915062367916107,
-0.20234526693820953,
-0.23120710253715515,
0.5180751085281372,
0.5766547322273254,
0.49400269985198975,
0.320772647857666,
-0.07235101610422134,
-0.46902894973754883,
-1.3693236112594604,
-0.22576917707920074,
0.17321304976940155,
-0.3590691387653351,
0.4586038291454315,
0.25348374247550964,
-0.5527327656745911,
0.8898376822471619,
-0.11648087948560715,
-0.4957466721534729,
-0.24767030775547028,
0.17375265061855316,
-0.40154850482940674,
0.9195797443389893,
0.698617696762085,
-1.0975114107131958,
-0.16327154636383057,
-0.05003790557384491,
-0.8173210620880127,
-0.33503836393356323,
-0.4668814241886139,
-0.47314387559890747,
0.4540048837661743,
0.6028446555137634,
-0.5714522004127502,
0.04425154626369476,
0.7539379596710205,
-0.3111864924430847,
0.5376794338226318,
0.04868768900632858,
0.365016371011734,
-1.2114300727844238,
0.409188449382782,
-0.07747410982847214,
-0.6214678287506104,
-0.5256459712982178,
0.12595456838607788,
0.3016722798347473,
-0.5593367218971252,
-0.6780687570571899,
0.5855498313903809,
-0.42382538318634033,
-0.02476528286933899,
-0.023104779422283173,
0.0315716452896595,
0.23003514111042023,
0.7389837503433228,
-0.02398395538330078,
0.8053498864173889,
0.319938987493515,
-0.4280460774898529,
0.2534295320510864,
0.3170151114463806,
-0.3128518760204315,
1.152632236480713,
-0.4445746839046478,
0.06530092656612396,
-0.12928226590156555,
0.305606484413147,
-0.5575819611549377,
-0.9266729950904846,
0.16059084236621857,
-0.30995485186576843,
0.22168613970279694,
0.2657727301120758,
-0.4429653286933899,
-0.19362285733222961,
-0.09360891580581665,
0.20202919840812683,
0.09884233772754669,
-0.6689977645874023,
0.6657862067222595,
0.34108513593673706,
-0.326191246509552,
-0.2445056289434433,
-0.6765848994255066,
0.42616239190101624,
-0.03507385030388832,
-0.9291996359825134,
0.7146618962287903,
-0.35492923855781555,
-0.2559898793697357,
-0.17361484467983246,
0.3010273873806,
-0.06798062473535538,
-0.08823215961456299,
0.41313421726226807,
0.2535666823387146,
0.040899742394685745,
-0.14835095405578613,
0.3210165500640869,
-0.101340152323246,
-0.1534430831670761,
0.06551431864500046,
-0.0038869839627295732,
-0.032718829810619354,
-0.34573233127593994,
-0.7140156626701355,
0.6424160599708557,
0.799464762210846,
-0.31382879614830017,
0.28330278396606445,
0.7590644955635071,
-0.45819544792175293,
0.1212989091873169,
-0.5973945260047913,
0.18007829785346985,
-0.4404384195804596,
0.32239338755607605,
-0.7688307166099548,
-1.067012906074524,
0.391358882188797,
-0.2699830234050751,
0.13169023394584656,
0.4733898639678955,
0.8269433379173279,
-0.007638667244464159,
1.4009499549865723,
0.6638970375061035,
0.2237878441810608,
0.27661100029945374,
0.2413218766450882,
-0.1973026543855667,
-0.814064085483551,
-0.39124947786331177,
-0.09761461615562439,
-0.39338865876197815,
-0.6275658011436462,
-0.4043632447719574,
0.48864248394966125,
0.26866310834884644,
0.003713739337399602,
0.14506544172763824,
-0.31518492102622986,
0.548889696598053,
0.4257187843322754,
0.31849783658981323,
0.2236693650484085,
-0.23854663968086243,
-0.1517065316438675,
-0.2697852551937103,
-0.2423742264509201,
-0.48885852098464966,
0.7311740517616272,
-0.021878227591514587,
0.49236613512039185,
0.5473002791404724,
0.29554933309555054,
0.25062498450279236,
0.5356807708740234,
-0.45861881971359253,
0.3896009922027588,
0.02597222849726677,
-0.9312931895256042,
-0.07774901390075684,
-0.3959702253341675,
-0.5241602659225464,
0.455639123916626,
-0.4151657521724701,
-0.6166703104972839,
0.3601328730583191,
0.3073846101760864,
-0.45406702160835266,
0.32596221566200256,
-0.6458219885826111,
1.048850655555725,
-0.11505304276943207,
-0.5021004676818848,
0.16288115084171295,
-0.8777152299880981,
0.5977749824523926,
-0.23164010047912598,
0.45896849036216736,
-0.3202894926071167,
-0.05822785571217537,
0.4011874794960022,
-0.24250783026218414,
0.7498975396156311,
-0.4994748830795288,
0.02549939602613449,
0.06163385882973671,
0.46821144223213196,
0.04362372308969498,
0.39310765266418457,
0.24420252442359924,
0.17682349681854248,
-0.01708463951945305,
-0.3832165002822876,
-0.5332390069961548,
0.5750537514686584,
-0.5549274682998657,
-0.3365505635738373,
0.07461632788181305,
-0.49067139625549316,
-0.4280470311641693,
0.4423356056213379,
0.1540043205022812,
0.7048028707504272,
-0.7011842727661133,
0.1961965262889862,
0.33370664715766907,
-0.25987040996551514,
0.5215087532997131,
0.14633511006832123,
-0.7122318148612976,
-0.72102952003479,
0.8003811240196228,
-0.1931883990764618,
0.31794628500938416,
0.29163944721221924,
-0.037284232676029205,
0.036039043217897415,
-0.07501497864723206,
-1.404874324798584,
-0.03457776829600334,
-0.46867743134498596,
-0.41140294075012207,
-0.6217232346534729,
0.15772759914398193,
-0.38927704095840454,
-0.5255836844444275,
-0.27106228470802307,
-0.543948769569397,
0.05795183405280113,
0.2928396463394165,
0.01058176439255476,
0.9016852974891663,
-0.4378800094127655,
0.46295616030693054,
-0.5653344988822937,
0.8257499933242798,
0.6760820150375366,
0.25845158100128174,
-0.6077390313148499,
0.16304509341716766,
-0.11898668110370636,
0.1762578785419464,
-0.4441860020160675,
-0.8249061703681946,
0.2878290116786957,
0.40642833709716797,
0.2035048007965088,
0.391631543636322,
-0.5052397847175598,
0.5883181691169739,
-0.7834908962249756,
0.6766912937164307,
0.3479309678077698,
-1.114639163017273,
0.3878059983253479,
-0.5005589127540588,
0.4608508348464966,
0.6160484552383423,
0.10366459935903549,
-0.9231517910957336,
-0.12986625730991364,
-0.47306209802627563,
-0.395186185836792,
0.7119226455688477,
0.21291324496269226,
0.24895183742046356,
0.17918159067630768,
0.20395654439926147,
0.1570178121328354,
0.4577907919883728,
-0.5526082515716553,
-0.16003571450710297,
-0.578773558139801,
-0.1314750611782074,
0.02982303686439991,
-0.15343841910362244,
-0.40498483180999756,
-0.09436702728271484,
0.5741232633590698,
-0.4913533329963684,
0.19084449112415314,
0.21113285422325134,
-0.44784480333328247,
-0.08979209512472153,
0.05186671391129494,
1.0257935523986816,
0.8382816314697266,
-0.22469361126422882,
0.07096794247627258,
-0.20512764155864716,
-0.3787303864955902,
0.04050436243414879,
0.13233067095279694,
-0.1650325357913971,
-0.011373717337846756,
-0.07706195116043091,
0.8344926834106445,
0.28663334250450134,
-0.7323787808418274,
0.5679881572723389,
-0.0024764423724263906,
-0.41094446182250977,
-0.08878830075263977,
-0.21496543288230896,
0.1876850575208664,
0.12219378352165222,
0.30570781230926514,
0.5326768159866333,
0.14136867225170135,
-0.3243519961833954,
0.40770021080970764,
0.24972762167453766,
-0.09307874739170074,
-0.5015459656715393,
0.9174175262451172,
0.40421968698501587,
-0.026973992586135864,
0.2763043940067291,
-0.33107683062553406,
-0.4125347435474396,
0.17632602155208588,
0.5043247938156128,
0.7935921549797058,
-0.28355300426483154,
0.3314383924007416,
0.35362130403518677,
0.3497872054576874,
0.45152586698532104,
0.1460353434085846,
-0.013758099637925625,
-0.8384535312652588,
-0.1670679897069931,
-0.562731921672821,
-0.5396533608436584,
0.21888913214206696,
-0.3695966899394989,
0.1461566537618637,
-0.5269681215286255,
0.054107021540403366,
0.3643076419830322,
-0.37653684616088867,
-0.7110364437103271,
0.6287839412689209,
0.29923346638679504,
0.6589764952659607,
-0.4862516224384308,
0.5762062668800354,
0.6972271800041199,
-0.39703741669654846,
-0.2959338128566742,
-0.4765050709247589,
0.5711609125137329,
-0.7318921089172363,
0.5100387334823608,
0.5226353406906128,
-0.4015641510486603,
0.07655386626720428,
-0.5881888270378113,
-0.620895266532898,
1.0991020202636719,
0.4324577748775482,
-0.17453975975513458,
-0.034707535058259964,
0.2420884668827057,
-0.025525089353322983,
-0.6231288909912109,
-0.1155678778886795,
0.44742876291275024,
0.6470165252685547,
0.24916738271713257,
-0.6668639779090881,
0.00275492575019598,
-0.4252733290195465,
0.3733888864517212,
-0.08747127652168274,
-0.5856426358222961,
0.8810501098632812,
-0.32762610912323,
-0.2592617869377136,
-0.026829032227396965,
0.7431721687316895,
0.06967230886220932,
-0.1593765914440155,
0.5230317115783691,
0.5622096061706543,
0.41612792015075684,
-0.028386658057570457,
0.854123592376709,
-0.3451481759548187,
-0.16295073926448822,
0.8425843715667725,
-0.2149500548839569,
0.41572827100753784,
0.36400651931762695,
0.02795681543648243,
0.4314078092575073,
0.6449947357177734,
0.2517559230327606,
0.26740139722824097,
-0.1309422254562378,
-0.41240066289901733,
-0.1874171495437622,
-0.035008348524570465,
-0.10983864217996597,
0.6630330085754395,
0.2312137633562088,
-0.13376714289188385,
-0.20732302963733673,
0.3644610345363617,
0.6846320033073425,
-0.09316638857126236,
-0.055961936712265015,
0.7192283868789673,
-0.26898878812789917,
-0.3409416377544403,
0.29860445857048035,
0.4441238045692444,
0.6031429767608643,
-0.5051831007003784,
0.11000773310661316,
-0.3151647448539734,
-0.0655355304479599,
-0.27179238200187683,
-0.48835137486457825,
0.40506547689437866,
-0.08338956534862518,
-0.18478579819202423,
-0.4596959948539734,
0.5521321892738342,
-0.5929888486862183,
-0.675776481628418,
-0.14068034291267395,
0.8061344027519226,
0.010586339049041271,
-0.36680206656455994,
-0.8557547330856323,
0.2630588114261627,
0.11906824260950089,
-0.526758074760437,
0.29936715960502625,
0.39081236720085144,
-0.14367905259132385,
0.2611022889614105,
0.8871142864227295,
-0.18739505112171173,
-0.0129978246986866,
0.24129219353199005,
0.8573116660118103,
-0.5663785934448242,
-0.195603147149086,
-0.5701833963394165,
0.7826864719390869,
-0.10844433307647705,
-0.6095991730690002,
0.41733115911483765,
0.5266299247741699,
0.9187353253364563,
-0.15309098362922668,
0.897251307964325,
-0.4657365083694458,
0.4076867401599884,
-0.6898564100265503,
0.8328549861907959,
-0.7563035488128662,
-0.6677300930023193,
-0.2889133393764496,
-1.0283085107803345,
-0.6504772901535034,
0.34876418113708496,
0.3479042053222656,
0.2206980437040329,
0.4513297975063324,
1.0331443548202515,
-0.07487975060939789,
-0.2777710556983948,
0.5783593654632568,
-0.30592620372772217,
0.41577771306037903,
0.2590435743331909,
0.27578654885292053,
-0.29629313945770264,
-0.039013590663671494,
-0.5977063775062561,
-0.4158603549003601,
-0.16545206308364868,
-0.8967959880828857,
-0.7890345454216003,
-0.9313576221466064,
0.05927513167262077,
-0.04634029045701027,
-0.2630188465118408,
0.9578182697296143,
0.9212777018547058,
-0.6701054573059082,
-0.2353612184524536,
0.11715300381183624,
-0.07841978222131729,
-0.013872453942894936,
-0.21981514990329742,
0.15521740913391113,
-0.3747229278087616,
-1.0300194025039673,
0.49486997723579407,
0.45648571848869324,
0.2265537530183792,
-0.6097301840782166,
-0.010278606787323952,
-0.040643565356731415,
0.1390194296836853,
0.9903681874275208,
0.3134414851665497,
-0.7122786045074463,
-0.23770718276500702,
-0.05161476135253906,
-0.30091920495033264,
0.07744232565164566,
1.0075331926345825,
-0.3981330990791321,
0.7284103035926819,
0.08007603883743286,
0.6953582167625427,
0.08054982870817184,
0.13172900676727295,
0.629453182220459,
-0.7243720889091492,
0.31266582012176514,
-0.16700363159179688,
0.3216988444328308,
0.8285833597183228,
-0.24688629806041718,
0.26289868354797363,
0.4037399888038635,
-0.40500906109809875,
-0.46706312894821167,
0.45015794038772583,
-1.0273102521896362,
-0.21893851459026337,
0.7315183281898499,
0.22357268631458282,
-0.2734547555446625,
0.11377644538879395,
-0.6996909976005554,
0.040091682225465775,
-0.20953020453453064,
0.4652632772922516,
0.5830272436141968,
-0.38567012548446655,
-0.1948845535516739,
-0.7167003750801086,
0.9306783676147461,
0.1848772019147873,
-1.2906385660171509,
0.040656253695487976,
1.1525100469589233,
-0.009680415503680706,
0.2370850294828415,
0.615014910697937,
-0.3539620339870453,
0.4890635013580322,
-0.1852128952741623,
0.7534698247909546,
-0.3911688029766083,
-0.6627424955368042,
-0.15122365951538086,
0.16210228204727173,
-0.369453102350235,
0.11100214719772339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02364v1 | The Developmental Landscape of In-Context Learning | 2024-02-04T06:23:05 | 2024-02-04T06:23:05 | Jesse Hoogland, George Wang, Matthew Farrugia-Roberts, Liam Carroll, Susan Wei, Daniel Murfet | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We show that in-context learning emerges in transformers in discrete
developmental stages, when they are trained on either language modeling or
linear regression tasks. We introduce two methods for detecting the milestones
that separate these stages, by probing the geometry of the population loss in
both parameter space and function space. We study the stages revealed by these
new methods using a range of behavioral and structural metrics to establish
their validity. | [
-0.7020232081413269,
-0.5721693634986877,
0.4628037214279175,
0.2355872094631195,
0.3448915481567383,
0.2837456464767456,
-0.029523367062211037,
-0.05759326368570328,
-0.40995916724205017,
0.1935632973909378,
-1.133245825767517,
-0.10639020800590515,
-0.31055837869644165,
-0.18034976720809937,
-0.5714770555496216,
0.9305702447891235,
-0.043519433587789536,
0.028299059718847275,
-0.6224541664123535,
0.14121007919311523,
-0.5882635712623596,
-0.30534180998802185,
-0.9212993383407593,
-0.5708854794502258,
0.3285748064517975,
0.4428583085536957,
0.1497507095336914,
0.7373546957969666,
0.098387710750103,
0.21465016901493073,
-0.2672906517982483,
-0.24336670339107513,
-0.48782214522361755,
0.333865225315094,
-0.0071556963957846165,
-0.3543950915336609,
0.07237542420625687,
0.0714254379272461,
0.8753858804702759,
1.303743600845337,
0.06292557716369629,
0.15910926461219788,
0.5516424775123596,
0.4630637764930725,
-0.3528374433517456,
0.2622794806957245,
-0.43439972400665283,
0.16963626444339752,
-0.18969203531742096,
-0.18472591042518616,
-0.6168085336685181,
-0.2772407829761505,
0.29273295402526855,
-0.41138821840286255,
0.4383028745651245,
-0.5653440356254578,
0.7390694618225098,
0.2453051507472992,
-0.9815303683280945,
-0.3921886384487152,
-1.0748807191848755,
0.9264801144599915,
0.11899008601903915,
0.7319645881652832,
0.3694891333580017,
0.3412591218948364,
-0.3706425428390503,
-0.8106836080551147,
-0.26280584931373596,
-0.26868414878845215,
-0.10947664827108383,
0.03455831855535507,
0.04808691143989563,
-0.25492891669273376,
0.3628259599208832,
0.048261724412441254,
-0.34950149059295654,
0.11552271991968155,
-0.612558901309967,
-0.22592829167842865,
0.4092264175415039,
0.15623913705348969,
0.21274296939373016,
-0.30336445569992065,
-0.35025492310523987,
-0.33320051431655884,
-1.0397413969039917,
0.30837416648864746,
0.409904807806015,
0.38918590545654297,
-0.3448884189128876,
0.005243882071226835,
0.26729556918144226,
0.40405601263046265,
0.19672834873199463,
-0.379281222820282,
0.055345840752124786,
-0.23350615799427032,
0.22037620842456818,
-0.2594403922557831,
0.1367136389017105,
-0.08903773128986359,
0.06410768628120422,
-0.1380922943353653,
-0.2595333755016327,
0.05386843532323837,
0.4010173976421356,
-0.4361523687839508,
-0.002991755958646536,
-0.07934506982564926,
-0.3691956102848053,
-0.15906816720962524,
-0.19036558270454407,
-0.6439769268035889,
-0.4218449890613556,
-0.31155645847320557,
0.29010334610939026,
-0.7086570858955383,
-0.25537529587745667,
-0.28988757729530334,
-0.12756244838237762,
0.5837402939796448,
0.30354544520378113,
-1.1357135772705078,
0.3959047794342041,
0.6954824328422546,
0.7455008029937744,
-0.025360213592648506,
-0.11813287436962128,
-0.24351873993873596,
-0.09893438220024109,
-0.3687446415424347,
0.7446255683898926,
-0.515814483165741,
-0.6710448265075684,
0.2975756525993347,
-0.12595269083976746,
-0.09973420202732086,
-0.7943447232246399,
0.22731631994247437,
-0.3424280285835266,
0.3382258713245392,
-0.334573358297348,
-0.48660874366760254,
-0.4114024043083191,
0.4414864480495453,
-0.4233308732509613,
1.283461332321167,
0.5972338914871216,
-0.34729400277137756,
1.1983486413955688,
-0.7419391870498657,
-0.43341562151908875,
0.15891727805137634,
-0.31197741627693176,
-0.18235276639461517,
0.09567208588123322,
0.015949802473187447,
0.36330023407936096,
0.3006579279899597,
0.04849884659051895,
-0.04894350841641426,
-0.1502334028482437,
0.04929054155945778,
-0.050237733870744705,
0.9406715631484985,
0.04411480203270912,
-0.4918704926967621,
-0.09661764651536942,
-0.9016180634498596,
-0.24203485250473022,
-0.09736128151416779,
-0.6001728177070618,
-0.33123981952667236,
0.661146879196167,
0.10444028675556183,
0.46338367462158203,
-0.026046469807624817,
-0.4541507363319397,
0.15917259454727173,
-0.31237977743148804,
0.4757668972015381,
0.2864522337913513,
0.10685957223176956,
0.7359404563903809,
-0.15726567804813385,
0.5499310493469238,
0.2523253262042999,
0.49035245180130005,
-0.5582922101020813,
-0.5312461256980896,
-0.8696888089179993,
-0.08251363039016724,
-0.11151284724473953,
0.1439712941646576,
-0.7677410244941711,
0.434196799993515,
-0.12896829843521118,
-0.4373874366283417,
-0.013672280125319958,
-0.12811502814292908,
0.30530402064323425,
0.7146709561347961,
0.2625827193260193,
-0.48490673303604126,
-0.551455020904541,
-0.5305842161178589,
0.12236005067825317,
-0.32209351658821106,
-0.2920289933681488,
0.01823597215116024,
0.6618008613586426,
-0.263307124376297,
0.9846616983413696,
-0.0068781403824687,
-0.19509311020374298,
-0.2883858382701874,
0.049129508435726166,
-0.2049957513809204,
0.6462317109107971,
0.6594365239143372,
-0.8513153195381165,
-0.27962926030158997,
0.019883237779140472,
-0.793607234954834,
0.12082454562187195,
-0.18349836766719818,
0.3673509955406189,
-0.13374315202236176,
0.825508177280426,
-0.0673094317317009,
0.595811665058136,
0.3712184429168701,
-0.5426072478294373,
0.27307531237602234,
0.04441375657916069,
-0.1588810682296753,
-0.7464604377746582,
-0.1714438945055008,
0.4228830635547638,
-0.23169468343257904,
-0.9645498394966125,
-0.12992767989635468,
0.22519560158252716,
0.19059212505817413,
-0.3743877410888672,
0.3175416886806488,
-0.2488625943660736,
-0.40748292207717896,
0.09543431550264359,
0.4037867784500122,
-0.2701374888420105,
0.18224212527275085,
-0.19548411667346954,
0.7837744355201721,
0.4422629773616791,
-0.7010249495506287,
-0.3937462568283081,
0.3364495038986206,
-0.290831059217453,
0.5750651955604553,
-0.22635376453399658,
0.031032713130116463,
-0.3675427734851837,
0.40131843090057373,
-1.2293258905410767,
-0.29754430055618286,
0.14299218356609344,
-0.5480351448059082,
0.0772411897778511,
-0.22522315382957458,
-0.29253843426704407,
-0.3728346526622772,
-0.1277569681406021,
0.46585729718208313,
0.6173244714736938,
-0.4184283912181854,
0.389904648065567,
0.34641921520233154,
0.06026306003332138,
-0.13182048499584198,
-0.4817247688770294,
-0.33593040704727173,
-0.6258645057678223,
-0.4294883608818054,
0.3450685143470764,
0.20347276329994202,
-0.37893959879875183,
-0.2548513114452362,
-0.03422807157039642,
-0.15513505041599274,
0.14209602773189545,
0.26966506242752075,
0.14757992327213287,
-0.3052419126033783,
0.16553382575511932,
0.102303646504879,
-0.12214157730340958,
0.3988865911960602,
-0.3688381314277649,
0.6242117881774902,
0.07724414020776749,
-0.2676047682762146,
-0.023244302719831467,
0.017962168902158737,
0.46870186924934387,
-0.19425420463085175,
0.6026345491409302,
0.3922607898712158,
-0.639116108417511,
-0.5774551033973694,
-0.13356997072696686,
-0.175271674990654,
-0.4774743914604187,
0.4798802435398102,
-0.13883939385414124,
-0.6600591540336609,
0.8802831768989563,
-0.39258596301078796,
-0.010248462669551373,
0.5823540687561035,
0.5334992408752441,
-0.037658270448446274,
1.1027053594589233,
1.180472731590271,
0.4895997643470764,
0.7321279048919678,
-0.7090679407119751,
0.17777812480926514,
-0.9807448387145996,
-0.9253825545310974,
-0.461249977350235,
-0.3427126109600067,
-0.4521802067756653,
-0.2650218904018402,
0.8779932856559753,
0.07016301155090332,
-0.6317062377929688,
0.3231872022151947,
-0.3402870297431946,
0.571586012840271,
0.49471315741539,
0.016194308176636696,
0.15137414634227753,
-0.22598759829998016,
-0.2744745910167694,
-0.45952820777893066,
-0.5214875340461731,
-0.5304148197174072,
1.0406155586242676,
0.5333433151245117,
0.36911776661872864,
0.036069463938474655,
0.630808413028717,
0.11546416580677032,
0.729520857334137,
-0.894349217414856,
0.33141377568244934,
0.026861421763896942,
-0.8189371228218079,
-0.405957967042923,
-0.11917442083358765,
-1.0473098754882812,
0.16197669506072998,
-0.2014622539281845,
-1.1659588813781738,
0.47855788469314575,
-0.018851930275559425,
-0.3502049148082733,
0.24288687109947205,
-0.534184992313385,
0.8868275284767151,
-0.14912785589694977,
-0.08679788559675217,
-0.21996629238128662,
-0.6087045073509216,
0.5574968457221985,
-0.18330194056034088,
0.11943107843399048,
0.15244679152965546,
-0.15750719606876373,
0.7269263863563538,
-0.12926115095615387,
0.8624871373176575,
-0.43614432215690613,
-0.12874488532543182,
0.14843860268592834,
0.2887749969959259,
0.03864949196577072,
0.1856968253850937,
0.2435304820537567,
-0.39883071184158325,
-0.03374239802360535,
-0.2795657217502594,
-0.5753315687179565,
0.43795710802078247,
-0.719133734703064,
0.00131109612993896,
-0.3761769235134125,
-0.6702327132225037,
-0.5988437533378601,
0.06715814769268036,
0.32496196031570435,
0.609973132610321,
-0.34822380542755127,
0.33220374584198,
0.9986456036567688,
-0.3443913161754608,
0.6355334520339966,
0.2590028643608093,
-0.49328890442848206,
0.1309901773929596,
0.4891332685947418,
0.09969872236251831,
0.4091840088367462,
0.2019425481557846,
0.09405528753995895,
-0.39525720477104187,
-0.5072137713432312,
-0.2825140058994293,
0.09059745073318481,
-1.0809462070465088,
-0.06857351958751678,
-0.20967566967010498,
-0.3845868408679962,
0.08141515403985977,
-0.3121933043003082,
-0.23225592076778412,
0.0678401067852974,
-0.11448945850133896,
-0.052875012159347534,
-0.14720840752124786,
1.4391144514083862,
0.020581884309649467,
0.5688097476959229,
-0.5229961276054382,
-0.3558793365955353,
0.36597740650177,
0.16934141516685486,
0.22087320685386658,
-0.4785018861293793,
-0.3561497628688812,
0.0514032356441021,
-0.9626507759094238,
-0.6955286264419556,
0.322968065738678,
0.40217217803001404,
0.5579999089241028,
0.880868136882782,
-0.6098095178604126,
0.6057101488113403,
-0.3681558668613434,
1.0382795333862305,
-0.06707501411437988,
-0.9548118710517883,
0.6710091829299927,
-0.7131572961807251,
0.2102135419845581,
0.3329920470714569,
0.8200064897537231,
-0.6954299807548523,
-0.16110111773014069,
-0.6609180569648743,
-0.7823594212532043,
0.7297850251197815,
-0.10903787612915039,
0.2517926096916199,
-0.16173841059207916,
0.4432164430618286,
0.3451356887817383,
-0.0299401693046093,
-0.8338831067085266,
-0.2797088623046875,
-0.08358121663331985,
0.026391610503196716,
-0.1420460194349289,
0.1266287863254547,
-0.15554338693618774,
-0.5904936194419861,
0.1102931797504425,
-0.18433931469917297,
0.23111100494861603,
-0.05749833956360817,
-0.18952667713165283,
-0.24626944959163666,
-0.14932554960250854,
0.6173688769340515,
0.8155405521392822,
0.08904153108596802,
-0.046672169119119644,
0.20852021872997284,
-0.48894035816192627,
0.3967067003250122,
-0.2360558956861496,
-0.18545463681221008,
-0.24864889681339264,
0.8505623936653137,
0.5015687942504883,
0.8874878883361816,
-0.49167492985725403,
0.5698788166046143,
0.14560513198375702,
-0.3610365390777588,
-0.42768457531929016,
0.037694066762924194,
-0.09903881698846817,
0.3209897577762604,
0.785701334476471,
0.05412818491458893,
0.10822558403015137,
-0.8714932203292847,
0.6085396409034729,
0.07848834246397018,
-0.846688449382782,
-0.6245722770690918,
0.7165298461914062,
0.019135255366563797,
-0.3521203100681305,
0.8891086578369141,
-0.38132646679878235,
-0.38001197576522827,
0.8729606866836548,
0.7496620416641235,
1.0493541955947876,
-0.25341343879699707,
0.6198562383651733,
0.3334123492240906,
0.3699617385864258,
-0.08072338253259659,
-0.013398641720414162,
-0.0025583843234926462,
-0.6533175706863403,
-0.48502781987190247,
-0.6789270043373108,
-0.10821021348237991,
0.27520856261253357,
-0.6006785035133362,
0.1430182009935379,
-0.4666345417499542,
-0.09906069189310074,
0.2386062890291214,
-0.23120731115341187,
-0.7603955268859863,
0.23883619904518127,
0.4822661280632019,
0.9081641435623169,
-1.1123347282409668,
0.6539388298988342,
0.6541674137115479,
-0.5257799029350281,
-0.7273739576339722,
0.31816309690475464,
0.3108375072479248,
-0.7000138759613037,
1.120134711265564,
0.19024424254894257,
-0.06657005101442337,
0.1268809288740158,
-0.3188956677913666,
-1.0657490491867065,
1.045366883277893,
0.17241251468658447,
-0.15066036581993103,
-0.17154936492443085,
0.06219467893242836,
0.7247509956359863,
-0.619804859161377,
0.21331189572811127,
0.6933696269989014,
0.34843072295188904,
-0.035748180001974106,
-0.8780538439750671,
-0.4078986942768097,
0.2043798714876175,
0.13393864035606384,
0.5205581188201904,
-0.21316052973270416,
1.2322723865509033,
0.03203514963388443,
-0.49470850825309753,
-0.13007819652557373,
0.5741147398948669,
-0.1511630266904831,
0.3742184042930603,
0.7911325693130493,
0.16898153722286224,
0.4238303303718567,
-0.5675843954086304,
0.8062652945518494,
-0.17961041629314423,
0.5290421843528748,
0.26600614190101624,
0.14996545016765594,
0.9593364596366882,
0.44204413890838623,
-0.4821247458457947,
0.9745824933052063,
0.9665180444717407,
0.22476020455360413,
0.5095168352127075,
0.38949012756347656,
-0.3165789544582367,
0.038475919514894485,
0.0690094530582428,
-0.02401277795433998,
0.6095374822616577,
0.9227900505065918,
-0.0026516332291066647,
-0.45800498127937317,
0.44857683777809143,
0.03603866696357727,
0.3913412094116211,
-0.3734552264213562,
0.6134175062179565,
0.03196041285991669,
-0.8262844681739807,
0.49872249364852905,
-0.34754541516304016,
0.5346211194992065,
-0.7287156581878662,
-0.024044226855039597,
-0.5919796228408813,
0.35824719071388245,
-0.16326329112052917,
-0.6878142356872559,
0.49095743894577026,
-0.24841929972171783,
-0.02550460398197174,
-0.5063599348068237,
0.42622944712638855,
-0.37643465399742126,
-0.3793764114379883,
0.5653075575828552,
0.689674437046051,
-0.07995228469371796,
0.29049521684646606,
-0.4083733856678009,
-0.10378352552652359,
-0.30262959003448486,
-0.2596735656261444,
0.4805094599723816,
0.33294081687927246,
-0.5715834498405457,
0.9738824963569641,
0.16576333343982697,
-0.1528986543416977,
0.3280414640903473,
0.0719018504023552,
0.7947008609771729,
-0.4301518201828003,
-0.4956468641757965,
-0.7009031176567078,
0.6602851748466492,
0.026626035571098328,
-0.6171237230300903,
0.8692893981933594,
0.46537432074546814,
1.3819189071655273,
-0.13906949758529663,
0.595008134841919,
-0.37625065445899963,
0.19353313744068146,
-0.17435865104198456,
0.4122469127178192,
-0.5841547250747681,
-0.01466333121061325,
-0.22015805542469025,
-1.0107910633087158,
-0.4064658582210541,
0.47272318601608276,
-0.3434450626373291,
0.36757487058639526,
0.9505729675292969,
0.6698647141456604,
-0.18502148985862732,
-0.409628689289093,
0.16692540049552917,
-0.25718021392822266,
0.31666991114616394,
0.3982650637626648,
1.2409238815307617,
-0.29682278633117676,
0.32733336091041565,
-0.08515383303165436,
-0.526352047920227,
-0.0561460480093956,
-0.4636646807193756,
-0.903555154800415,
-1.1547465324401855,
0.017775116488337517,
-0.18927821516990662,
-0.19753508269786835,
0.6092150807380676,
0.8748989105224609,
-0.5941587686538696,
-0.5683742165565491,
-0.03194691240787506,
-0.08510513603687286,
-0.5053141117095947,
-0.24016156792640686,
0.03743072599172592,
-0.7442084550857544,
-0.6518781185150146,
0.6715681552886963,
0.3795655369758606,
-0.08586891740560532,
-0.8490208983421326,
0.02794964425265789,
-0.09010140597820282,
-0.07576018571853638,
0.7298505902290344,
0.3991375267505646,
-0.7051474452018738,
-0.7222045660018921,
-0.051476504653692245,
0.11129114776849747,
0.0312538668513298,
1.14614999294281,
-1.0975381135940552,
0.30726680159568787,
0.3892882764339447,
0.32724472880363464,
0.5282176733016968,
-0.2721725404262543,
0.5775678157806396,
-1.1977719068527222,
0.3935384452342987,
0.20017443597316742,
0.13573625683784485,
0.41241371631622314,
-0.19429245591163635,
0.46492767333984375,
0.2658816874027252,
-0.5981717705726624,
-0.9207490086555481,
0.43845856189727783,
-0.4382767975330353,
-0.020382296293973923,
0.635841429233551,
0.1219925656914711,
-0.07100139558315277,
-0.34217795729637146,
0.2175910323858261,
0.15927383303642273,
0.1841331124305725,
1.0561964511871338,
0.6415023803710938,
-0.32337725162506104,
0.06203760206699371,
-0.9199032783508301,
0.9915646910667419,
0.017362913116812706,
-0.7599576711654663,
-0.3961152136325836,
0.30671942234039307,
0.2475651502609253,
0.4203651547431946,
0.3685421049594879,
-0.10838097333908081,
0.17075681686401367,
0.38801100850105286,
-0.14743836224079132,
0.5595743656158447,
-0.6643437743186951,
-0.41412949562072754,
-0.01182898972183466,
0.08922817558050156,
-0.22084952890872955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05952v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05952v1 | Advancing Graph Representation Learning with Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey of Techniques | 2024-02-04T05:51:14 | 2024-02-04T05:51:14 | Qiheng Mao, Zemin Liu, Chenghao Liu, Zhuo Li, Jianling Sun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) with Graph Representation
Learning (GRL) marks a significant evolution in analyzing complex data
structures. This collaboration harnesses the sophisticated linguistic
capabilities of LLMs to improve the contextual understanding and adaptability
of graph models, thereby broadening the scope and potential of GRL. Despite a
growing body of research dedicated to integrating LLMs into the graph domain, a
comprehensive review that deeply analyzes the core components and operations
within these models is notably lacking. Our survey fills this gap by proposing
a novel taxonomy that breaks down these models into primary components and
operation techniques from a novel technical perspective. We further dissect
recent literature into two primary components including knowledge extractors
and organizers, and two operation techniques including integration and training
stratigies, shedding light on effective model design and training strategies.
Additionally, we identify and explore potential future research avenues in this
nascent yet underexplored field, proposing paths for continued progress. | [
-0.34528303146362305,
-0.8595855236053467,
0.7071529626846313,
-0.12877236306667328,
-0.12042727321386337,
0.718010425567627,
-0.28881368041038513,
-0.5713355541229248,
0.06646855920553207,
0.5852530598640442,
-0.30188143253326416,
-0.7839643955230713,
-0.9507923722267151,
-0.11787918955087662,
-0.36696186661720276,
0.7811378240585327,
-0.17390647530555725,
0.23530609905719757,
-0.21166230738162994,
-0.17119169235229492,
-0.33817678689956665,
-0.7658093571662903,
-0.6538781523704529,
-0.6202613711357117,
0.6272427439689636,
0.13329388201236725,
0.47262808680534363,
0.4401601254940033,
0.44593390822410583,
0.29865482449531555,
-0.305796355009079,
0.4353451132774353,
-0.643010675907135,
-0.1481892466545105,
-0.13898582756519318,
-0.22161298990249634,
-0.3751174807548523,
-0.1723402440547943,
1.0574119091033936,
1.4077329635620117,
-0.11233004182577133,
0.02023560181260109,
0.26611021161079407,
0.44482025504112244,
-0.50809645652771,
0.6610469222068787,
-0.546593189239502,
0.03164203092455864,
-0.21336930990219116,
0.011914495378732681,
-0.6041701436042786,
-0.1794091761112213,
0.13851559162139893,
-0.26757320761680603,
0.05885020270943642,
-0.11784794181585312,
0.4346139430999756,
-0.20709364116191864,
-0.756252110004425,
-0.35540470480918884,
-0.8187975287437439,
0.579012930393219,
-0.4701725244522095,
0.6078904867172241,
0.007439151406288147,
0.5278477072715759,
-0.16209203004837036,
-1.097839593887329,
-0.08884578943252563,
-0.025327106937766075,
-0.09206496924161911,
-0.21770191192626953,
-0.256428986787796,
0.3427445888519287,
0.12119052559137344,
0.28553175926208496,
-0.307750940322876,
0.44344353675842285,
-0.26496925950050354,
-0.14285071194171906,
0.6221017837524414,
0.3071812391281128,
0.4329991340637207,
0.09988876432180405,
-0.1312023401260376,
0.08206760883331299,
-0.7999899387359619,
-0.0509689524769783,
0.16047349572181702,
0.5840821862220764,
-0.04915884509682655,
0.5038638114929199,
-0.09173215925693512,
0.8218492865562439,
-0.4003826081752777,
0.04033292457461357,
0.2002592384815216,
-0.30512019991874695,
-0.2946282923221588,
-0.30246028304100037,
0.7070258259773254,
-0.02034013904631138,
0.08479291945695877,
-0.4911065399646759,
-0.3998139500617981,
-0.17335891723632812,
0.08403656631708145,
-0.5570029020309448,
-0.29418960213661194,
-0.16677424311637878,
-0.3581070005893707,
-0.22772027552127838,
0.20586785674095154,
-0.5667964220046997,
-0.46267643570899963,
-0.4073978662490845,
-0.028732869774103165,
-0.27166882157325745,
-0.3736887574195862,
0.1420498639345169,
-0.09772119671106339,
0.15938889980316162,
0.44108977913856506,
-0.7859869599342346,
0.5109666585922241,
1.1177701950073242,
0.9754073619842529,
-0.22827455401420593,
-0.21710428595542908,
-0.353577196598053,
0.29469695687294006,
-0.40622079372406006,
0.6713775992393494,
-0.7449859976768494,
-0.5816681981086731,
0.311251163482666,
0.24732306599617004,
-0.2165442407131195,
-0.43114718794822693,
0.21249133348464966,
-0.9109650254249573,
-0.039885565638542175,
-0.3387908637523651,
-0.7221810817718506,
-0.4775741994380951,
0.22567816078662872,
-0.7113349437713623,
0.7697679996490479,
0.4269797205924988,
-0.6455177068710327,
0.1264978051185608,
-0.6080455780029297,
-0.36773133277893066,
0.3429373800754547,
-0.446512371301651,
-0.1446044147014618,
0.14873287081718445,
0.09975885599851608,
0.490739643573761,
-0.2987719774246216,
0.23457404971122742,
-0.4579853117465973,
-0.24961216747760773,
0.07940427213907242,
-0.006492377258837223,
0.8054444193840027,
0.08561558276414871,
0.11245664209127426,
0.2539174556732178,
-0.41656389832496643,
-0.09529759734869003,
0.3551364541053772,
-0.272189199924469,
-0.2037074863910675,
0.06504989415407181,
-0.02359624020755291,
-0.1080278530716896,
0.42822372913360596,
-0.3249732553958893,
0.5471895933151245,
-0.14827585220336914,
0.6542931199073792,
0.6699907183647156,
-0.02753184549510479,
0.7050245404243469,
0.20683297514915466,
0.6217002868652344,
-0.3472288250923157,
0.026283985003829002,
-0.0886479988694191,
-0.27904343605041504,
-0.3766299784183502,
-0.15693984925746918,
0.28707295656204224,
0.29510629177093506,
-0.8303644061088562,
0.34393662214279175,
-0.5331591367721558,
-0.5816226005554199,
-0.02181308902800083,
0.30351802706718445,
0.2849787473678589,
0.4202297627925873,
0.15068025887012482,
-0.3244921863079071,
-0.5252199769020081,
-0.7114254236221313,
-0.0053530302830040455,
-0.2215064913034439,
0.1814241111278534,
0.3531177043914795,
0.41831135749816895,
-0.507930338382721,
0.8806792497634888,
-0.8126152157783508,
-0.04091816768050194,
-0.6446042656898499,
0.052858803421258926,
0.18126380443572998,
0.1699090451002121,
0.6543238759040833,
-0.6057344675064087,
-0.46817249059677124,
0.4116136431694031,
-0.8237659931182861,
0.12707865238189697,
0.3941147029399872,
0.007770975586026907,
-0.0019824979826807976,
0.6017317771911621,
-0.5560759902000427,
0.0324365571141243,
0.5722087025642395,
-0.05659401789307594,
0.49979162216186523,
0.008284341543912888,
-0.1592586785554886,
-0.8033090829849243,
0.01426813192665577,
-0.07769825309515,
-0.3127726912498474,
-0.8142029047012329,
0.443737655878067,
0.05212487652897835,
-0.2291661649942398,
-0.2009797841310501,
0.4716467559337616,
-0.7941117882728577,
-0.4586610198020935,
-0.3490731120109558,
0.21484999358654022,
-0.12438594549894333,
0.17713682353496552,
-0.08000107109546661,
0.6694085001945496,
0.6576103568077087,
-0.4315934479236603,
0.5227262377738953,
0.20534034073352814,
-0.3266836702823639,
0.08903958648443222,
-0.59154212474823,
0.3244653642177582,
-0.25786271691322327,
0.35057103633880615,
-1.1742768287658691,
-0.38736873865127563,
0.3875289559364319,
-0.15592069923877716,
0.6952357888221741,
-0.5596264004707336,
-0.6783517599105835,
-0.4991719126701355,
-0.004476696718484163,
0.3366757035255432,
0.45588651299476624,
-0.4800858199596405,
0.7554284930229187,
0.7612688541412354,
-0.22271336615085602,
-0.5983323454856873,
-0.5489204525947571,
0.23833294212818146,
-0.120580293238163,
-0.6947427988052368,
0.18977287411689758,
0.345343679189682,
-0.3300284147262573,
0.08014380931854248,
-0.08615913987159729,
-0.0898832380771637,
0.20413808524608612,
-0.28872284293174744,
0.23699872195720673,
-0.1731145828962326,
0.2687777578830719,
-0.1428944617509842,
-0.07348763197660446,
0.08570802211761475,
-0.5203033685684204,
0.8509654402732849,
-0.002675391500815749,
-0.5095248222351074,
-0.0469784252345562,
0.1782139241695404,
0.3630334138870239,
-0.3454655408859253,
0.5829700827598572,
0.5079736709594727,
-0.3327297568321228,
-0.19506099820137024,
-0.40575912594795227,
0.000425640435423702,
-0.4560469090938568,
0.8308850526809692,
-0.33800575137138367,
-1.108152985572815,
0.6663678884506226,
-0.4677222967147827,
0.033858031034469604,
0.2841074466705322,
0.2854672968387604,
0.004779593553394079,
1.0269289016723633,
0.9584380388259888,
-0.17889218032360077,
0.6697340607643127,
-0.5102292895317078,
0.2937331795692444,
-0.9817295670509338,
-0.3134128749370575,
-0.5289354920387268,
-0.16165554523468018,
-0.3859877288341522,
-0.5722078680992126,
0.14378829300403595,
0.10002132505178452,
-0.23561103641986847,
0.007951050996780396,
-0.3615190386772156,
0.348012775182724,
-0.034385863691568375,
0.05353967100381851,
0.20629850029945374,
0.2114686816930771,
0.1316782534122467,
0.18959365785121918,
-0.7316601872444153,
-0.6047214865684509,
1.0761686563491821,
0.5675663948059082,
0.8625888824462891,
0.03235489875078201,
0.6933521628379822,
0.15398769080638885,
0.400935560464859,
-1.0312682390213013,
0.6095637679100037,
-0.42686566710472107,
-0.08671047538518906,
-0.32498446106910706,
-0.5213929414749146,
-1.0157554149627686,
0.36629536747932434,
0.2177932858467102,
-0.8901091814041138,
0.0020828410051763058,
-0.09947668015956879,
0.11614339053630829,
0.6311420798301697,
-0.5843753814697266,
0.7026913166046143,
-0.27313628792762756,
0.034517835825681686,
-0.016424240544438362,
-0.47015953063964844,
0.4476144313812256,
-0.09605144709348679,
0.4636942148208618,
0.015639416873455048,
-0.15192395448684692,
0.6746727824211121,
-0.19949567317962646,
1.010324478149414,
-0.34119749069213867,
-0.4373898208141327,
0.3507372736930847,
0.07740076631307602,
0.7653814554214478,
-0.2517927885055542,
0.1839621663093567,
0.3100733160972595,
-0.18808011710643768,
-0.37006187438964844,
-0.7425590753555298,
0.5032423734664917,
-0.8118430972099304,
-0.4734763205051422,
-0.0610433928668499,
-0.5811943411827087,
-0.36204448342323303,
0.2335086166858673,
-0.050912562757730484,
0.5144832730293274,
-0.2057829052209854,
0.1640726625919342,
0.615502655506134,
0.04753367230296135,
0.1638646423816681,
0.1524563431739807,
-0.5722875595092773,
-0.5157918334007263,
0.8540287613868713,
0.30977585911750793,
0.27482399344444275,
0.3025072515010834,
0.07644844800233841,
-0.37258651852607727,
-0.9704922437667847,
-0.08702069520950317,
0.5196889638900757,
-1.1568251848220825,
0.09684786945581436,
-0.7449311017990112,
-0.2600686252117157,
-0.5668639540672302,
-0.006667243782430887,
-0.1645122617483139,
-0.23151810467243195,
-0.4013461470603943,
-0.29008999466896057,
0.09341821819543839,
1.1877474784851074,
0.352603942155838,
0.6269590258598328,
-0.8478851914405823,
-0.10017704218626022,
0.26883894205093384,
0.22240406274795532,
0.2086905539035797,
-0.3319866359233856,
-0.42655226588249207,
0.0045431372709572315,
-0.1520804464817047,
-0.869478702545166,
0.2162647694349289,
-0.007267271634191275,
0.9002845883369446,
0.34563106298446655,
-0.398549884557724,
0.6888312101364136,
-0.44471052289009094,
0.8103530406951904,
0.2926967442035675,
-0.8345428705215454,
0.1989046037197113,
-0.3394790589809418,
-0.06584211438894272,
0.28316572308540344,
0.46630042791366577,
-0.6640561819076538,
0.015386199578642845,
-0.4365948438644409,
-0.8393434882164001,
0.5084013342857361,
-0.318937212228775,
0.30122464895248413,
0.19951146841049194,
0.3863145709037781,
0.03116409294307232,
0.2529650032520294,
-0.5849085450172424,
-0.14763574302196503,
0.23419059813022614,
-0.17799295485019684,
-0.33664849400520325,
-0.3518773317337036,
-0.3510519862174988,
-0.2704407870769501,
0.2925117313861847,
-0.5379713177680969,
0.200788214802742,
-0.2780080735683441,
-0.30401507019996643,
0.17370747029781342,
0.006722738966345787,
0.12831829488277435,
1.0107665061950684,
0.0916755199432373,
0.22012072801589966,
0.10101310908794403,
-0.31874650716781616,
-0.06806199997663498,
0.01327470876276493,
-0.09079679846763611,
-0.11563093215227127,
0.7679077982902527,
0.8628184795379639,
0.3385862410068512,
-0.4583979547023773,
0.3072446584701538,
0.193325474858284,
-0.12480519711971283,
-0.20122197270393372,
-0.08529794216156006,
0.2722482681274414,
0.34073755145072937,
0.4707343280315399,
-0.31396248936653137,
0.04237909987568855,
-0.675157904624939,
0.09913818538188934,
0.7130177617073059,
-0.48975124955177307,
-0.4649248421192169,
0.19163978099822998,
0.06931966543197632,
-0.18932561576366425,
0.6001107692718506,
-0.20225781202316284,
-0.6377823948860168,
0.5307895541191101,
0.5035789012908936,
0.8249375224113464,
-0.017881831154227257,
0.23198427259922028,
0.15218202769756317,
0.2840348482131958,
0.07389974594116211,
0.09717946499586105,
0.07247037440538406,
-0.8590031266212463,
-0.6398276090621948,
-0.3600780665874481,
-0.396923691034317,
-0.17951872944831848,
-0.4690515995025635,
0.3220255970954895,
-0.46529173851013184,
-0.1569264829158783,
-0.19427911937236786,
0.14366182684898376,
-0.6141260266304016,
-0.24381905794143677,
0.29992035031318665,
0.9845391511917114,
-0.9682321548461914,
0.7483322620391846,
1.0240076780319214,
-0.34498170018196106,
-0.6535701155662537,
-0.19508284330368042,
-0.030596623197197914,
-0.8867289423942566,
0.8426333665847778,
-0.06413060426712036,
-0.030076203867793083,
0.1362878680229187,
-0.7083971500396729,
-0.8880712985992432,
1.1439539194107056,
0.4127931594848633,
-0.49429282546043396,
-0.2863215506076813,
0.08134029060602188,
0.40855079889297485,
-0.6641858220100403,
0.08654512465000153,
0.6507724523544312,
0.36557137966156006,
0.29629138112068176,
-0.6776561737060547,
-0.12784650921821594,
0.08851628005504608,
0.1706489771604538,
0.2326432466506958,
-0.5900910496711731,
0.8394375443458557,
0.06390903145074844,
-0.5681898593902588,
-0.1029210314154625,
0.6128766536712646,
0.11838550120592117,
0.21649028360843658,
0.4036620557308197,
0.3306993544101715,
1.0639172792434692,
-0.13075335323810577,
1.1562186479568481,
-0.2966470420360565,
0.6458714008331299,
1.0069239139556885,
-0.44181257486343384,
0.4158257842063904,
0.3054302930831909,
-0.4077288806438446,
0.5162673592567444,
0.769575297832489,
0.02702712081372738,
0.357738196849823,
0.2218269556760788,
-0.24533073604106903,
-0.3699486553668976,
-0.18669265508651733,
-0.3436098098754883,
0.35442230105400085,
0.6562494039535522,
-0.34401535987854004,
-0.5020928382873535,
-0.09922675788402557,
-0.044985052198171616,
-0.03331815451383591,
-0.32715994119644165,
0.9280270338058472,
0.19163724780082703,
-0.07991885393857956,
0.2356703132390976,
-0.11141606420278549,
0.3311011791229248,
-0.7887424826622009,
-0.05551506206393242,
-0.021316668018698692,
-0.18396811187267303,
-0.21542541682720184,
-0.9021051526069641,
0.1555216759443283,
-0.3348415195941925,
0.04021771624684334,
-0.13747411966323853,
0.9170205593109131,
-0.2479582577943802,
-0.359769344329834,
0.6191787123680115,
0.6920107007026672,
-0.011397839523851871,
0.1415204554796219,
-0.6093598008155823,
0.4457370340824127,
-0.11447025090456009,
0.021390562877058983,
0.26486366987228394,
0.589851438999176,
-0.027549318969249725,
0.7134866714477539,
0.5505932569503784,
0.24780037999153137,
0.03603469580411911,
0.26986995339393616,
1.2135536670684814,
-0.6195967197418213,
-0.30268481373786926,
-0.8327542543411255,
0.3826012909412384,
-0.18185552954673767,
0.21456556022167206,
0.7491803169250488,
0.53395015001297,
0.854404628276825,
0.11402519792318344,
1.0295902490615845,
0.07107723504304886,
0.10588911920785904,
-0.5592555999755859,
0.48611217737197876,
-0.3082852363586426,
0.2471989393234253,
-0.385567843914032,
-1.0674928426742554,
-0.384645015001297,
0.2713491916656494,
-0.5541475415229797,
0.041206929832696915,
0.6461900472640991,
0.41741856932640076,
-0.1158888041973114,
-0.09337997436523438,
0.18755516409873962,
0.16662269830703735,
0.7161551117897034,
0.38440215587615967,
0.9739218354225159,
-0.13020771741867065,
0.29959145188331604,
-0.0671539306640625,
-0.2655627131462097,
-0.2327403873205185,
-0.7665312886238098,
-0.7756307721138,
-0.4635205864906311,
-0.2881365418434143,
-0.11857205629348755,
-0.18195413053035736,
0.7166635394096375,
0.6125383377075195,
-0.5068905353546143,
-0.4735850393772125,
-0.07943954318761826,
0.36604219675064087,
-0.047146789729595184,
-0.19800274074077606,
0.4227888584136963,
-0.5935590267181396,
-0.8513455986976624,
0.48082613945007324,
0.24559713900089264,
0.03661072254180908,
-0.5463910698890686,
-0.11196382343769073,
0.0740826427936554,
-0.29919689893722534,
0.9220510125160217,
0.30539506673812866,
-0.6165649890899658,
-0.39489510655403137,
-0.028840448707342148,
-0.03355761617422104,
0.074188731610775,
1.1386569738388062,
-0.320925772190094,
0.4139755070209503,
0.7217830419540405,
1.005212426185608,
0.49546027183532715,
-0.0935371145606041,
0.49101439118385315,
-0.7239227294921875,
-0.012871027924120426,
0.18155556917190552,
0.627486526966095,
0.46348267793655396,
-0.22174276411533356,
0.7148250937461853,
0.43710869550704956,
-0.43565085530281067,
-0.9975036978721619,
0.5840888023376465,
-0.9880648851394653,
-0.33206501603126526,
1.1447629928588867,
-0.21158616244792938,
-0.26141563057899475,
-0.09580285847187042,
-0.11239618808031082,
0.2220791131258011,
-0.04214954748749733,
0.3791011869907379,
0.7957340478897095,
-0.1776038557291031,
-0.2825254499912262,
-0.45186540484428406,
-0.033337295055389404,
-0.2704797089099884,
-0.5682087540626526,
0.28116756677627563,
0.6154301166534424,
0.2688024342060089,
0.16440865397453308,
0.5815294981002808,
-0.2335665374994278,
-0.14961673319339752,
-0.21386107802391052,
0.1411612629890442,
-0.14236511290073395,
-0.3002123236656189,
-0.5933672785758972,
0.3981934189796448,
0.3856975734233856,
0.1851033717393875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05122v1 | History of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) chatbots: past, present, and future development | 2024-02-04T05:01:38 | 2024-02-04T05:01:38 | Md. Al-Amin, Mohammad Shazed Ali, Abdus Salam, Arif Khan, Ashraf Ali, Ahsan Ullah, Md Nur Alam, Shamsul Kabir Chowdhury | cs.GL | cs.GL, cs.CL, cs.HC | This research provides an in-depth comprehensive review of the progress of
chatbot technology over time, from the initial basic systems relying on rules
to today's advanced conversational bots powered by artificial intelligence.
Spanning many decades, the paper explores the major milestones, innovations,
and paradigm shifts that have driven the evolution of chatbots. Looking back at
the very basic statistical model in 1906 via the early chatbots, such as ELIZA
and ALICE in the 1960s and 1970s, the study traces key innovations leading to
today's advanced conversational agents, such as ChatGPT and Google Bard. The
study synthesizes insights from academic literature and industry sources to
highlight crucial milestones, including the introduction of Turing tests,
influential projects such as CALO, and recent transformer-based models. Tracing
the path forward, the paper highlights how natural language processing and
machine learning have been integrated into modern chatbots for more
sophisticated capabilities. This chronological survey of the chatbot landscape
provides a holistic reference to understand the technological and historical
factors propelling conversational AI. By synthesizing learnings from this
historical analysis, the research offers important context about the
developmental trajectory of chatbots and their immense future potential across
various field of application which could be the potential take ways for the
respective research community and stakeholders. | [
-0.3233849108219147,
-1.198426604270935,
0.38162535429000854,
-0.05521972477436066,
0.4777992367744446,
0.4473884701728821,
0.10819979757070541,
-0.46303442120552063,
0.12541936337947845,
0.47743409872055054,
-0.6810092329978943,
-0.258564829826355,
-0.38107892870903015,
-0.16178439557552338,
-0.6830655932426453,
0.8885071873664856,
0.546440601348877,
-0.21458062529563904,
-0.3093022108078003,
0.1171528548002243,
-0.7190456986427307,
-0.7428914308547974,
-0.7503976225852966,
-0.3474203646183014,
0.1044265478849411,
0.15496742725372314,
0.869331955909729,
0.151093527674675,
0.43991175293922424,
0.45939984917640686,
-0.1658695936203003,
0.022702397778630257,
-0.2753572165966034,
0.36344751715660095,
0.30474355816841125,
-0.6106259822845459,
-0.6073748469352722,
-0.024306096136569977,
0.4501725435256958,
0.609924852848053,
0.005455131642520428,
-0.15919695794582367,
0.020668355748057365,
0.6441745162010193,
-0.0966699942946434,
0.3614825904369354,
-0.6414282917976379,
0.24553734064102173,
-0.09455538541078568,
-0.4088243246078491,
-0.4731367528438568,
-0.49998024106025696,
0.17678338289260864,
-0.4485130310058594,
0.3694615960121155,
0.036365289241075516,
0.6375552415847778,
0.20504130423069,
-0.24306587874889374,
-0.5190702080726624,
-1.1753123998641968,
0.8142033219337463,
-0.4523286521434784,
0.23221030831336975,
0.11233698576688766,
0.5720033049583435,
-0.50986248254776,
-0.9221640229225159,
-0.5825504660606384,
-0.634752631187439,
0.23104454576969147,
-0.0100769167765975,
-0.38369888067245483,
-0.2126188725233078,
0.06263920664787292,
0.34648019075393677,
-0.5178354978561401,
0.23137615621089935,
-0.5785354375839233,
-0.24888312816619873,
0.5916244387626648,
0.389912873506546,
0.5361849665641785,
0.17135295271873474,
-0.2870173752307892,
-0.04931921139359474,
-0.5563857555389404,
0.03752165287733078,
0.2794485092163086,
0.11712668091058731,
-0.24813677370548248,
0.5503891110420227,
-0.16471996903419495,
0.4394204616546631,
0.027328671887516975,
-0.014939477667212486,
0.23874656856060028,
-0.5166003108024597,
-0.06537225097417831,
-0.12315978109836578,
1.0415191650390625,
0.038337115198373795,
0.4806639552116394,
-0.1956508606672287,
0.38584664463996887,
0.09071943908929825,
0.5516440272331238,
-0.392207533121109,
-0.05855714529752731,
0.21588416397571564,
-0.3613613545894623,
-0.4119212329387665,
-0.17413336038589478,
-0.8268353939056396,
-0.410519540309906,
-0.11383659392595291,
0.023648038506507874,
-0.5464268326759338,
-0.20374493300914764,
-0.297175794839859,
-0.3897344470024109,
0.61634761095047,
0.4294203221797943,
-0.8665919899940491,
-0.00043848995119333267,
0.8491784334182739,
0.8253600597381592,
0.10868740826845169,
-0.11010506749153137,
0.1744907647371292,
-0.2841246724128723,
-0.43795058131217957,
0.7738856077194214,
-0.6924590468406677,
-0.6459749937057495,
0.23530806601047516,
-0.22959232330322266,
0.180104598402977,
-0.37080007791519165,
0.20410597324371338,
-0.6456971168518066,
0.41599538922309875,
0.6126742362976074,
-0.40621432662010193,
-0.3414597511291504,
0.28929945826530457,
-0.4515046179294586,
0.7058010697364807,
0.013514142483472824,
-0.3320860266685486,
0.21242839097976685,
-1.015986442565918,
-0.5908510088920593,
0.44454044103622437,
-0.34752732515335083,
-0.39077985286712646,
-0.2770068049430847,
0.24115009605884552,
0.34115976095199585,
-0.3047538697719574,
0.24803930521011353,
-0.22477194666862488,
-0.2575744688510895,
0.494258850812912,
-0.6754645109176636,
1.2424663305282593,
0.013636124320328236,
-0.4166882336139679,
0.2897132933139801,
-0.4886699318885803,
-0.11592985689640045,
0.1685127317905426,
0.11613872647285461,
0.2538127303123474,
0.3968738615512848,
-0.2491629719734192,
0.0313522145152092,
0.15959098935127258,
-0.13069979846477509,
0.0027051514480262995,
-0.30841249227523804,
0.9022671580314636,
0.5713277459144592,
0.026661481708288193,
0.4537036418914795,
-0.458265095949173,
0.7159955501556396,
-0.278959721326828,
0.4502393901348114,
-0.6360830664634705,
-0.8418897390365601,
-0.7747332453727722,
0.1294739842414856,
0.05790996178984642,
0.6660342216491699,
-0.34468594193458557,
0.8356702923774719,
-0.3468553423881531,
-0.7591390609741211,
-0.4799903631210327,
-0.107450470328331,
-0.1655910164117813,
0.34365999698638916,
0.05756517872214317,
-0.2489495873451233,
-0.29245421290397644,
-0.6776158213615417,
0.19011619687080383,
-0.6635025143623352,
-0.1292378306388855,
0.3916020095348358,
0.28841572999954224,
-0.34816914796829224,
0.9371084570884705,
-0.18016590178012848,
-0.09564457088708878,
-0.4018072783946991,
0.17369846999645233,
-0.08365153521299362,
0.4492969512939453,
0.6138190031051636,
-0.9687528014183044,
-0.18848970532417297,
0.12670913338661194,
-0.6550310850143433,
0.3315807282924652,
-0.3473280072212219,
-0.20290438830852509,
0.04596438631415367,
0.5844131708145142,
-0.6558094024658203,
0.4388555884361267,
0.44479963183403015,
-0.12939010560512543,
0.3295747935771942,
0.11806689202785492,
0.20930704474449158,
-0.9573773741722107,
0.0955238938331604,
-0.19253036379814148,
0.057926855981349945,
-0.6767720580101013,
-0.35722988843917847,
-0.20266634225845337,
-0.30673426389694214,
-0.35142940282821655,
0.4214521646499634,
-0.008505117148160934,
0.22338713705539703,
-0.10329567641019821,
0.15189918875694275,
-0.5377160906791687,
0.4040127694606781,
-0.18068644404411316,
0.6132482886314392,
0.5931417346000671,
-0.7979382872581482,
0.5033710598945618,
0.35746344923973083,
0.16315864026546478,
0.6245864629745483,
-0.5868932008743286,
0.4240586757659912,
0.005922954063862562,
0.2621022164821625,
-1.108565092086792,
-0.017549069598317146,
0.36460012197494507,
-0.9486590027809143,
0.05661061033606529,
0.02224242128431797,
-0.3101159930229187,
-0.5323479175567627,
0.015816984698176384,
0.13561584055423737,
0.819065272808075,
-0.053805019706487656,
0.5973604917526245,
0.5409799814224243,
-0.4576590955257416,
-0.24768400192260742,
-0.3292835056781769,
0.3382359445095062,
-0.29117539525032043,
-0.613095760345459,
0.22471442818641663,
-0.3041262924671173,
-0.470354288816452,
-0.330818772315979,
0.29503852128982544,
-0.12597455084323883,
0.26764941215515137,
0.36803939938545227,
0.45474913716316223,
-0.22463646531105042,
0.07327388226985931,
-0.14388081431388855,
-0.14985798299312592,
0.18916179239749908,
-0.014754772186279297,
0.9879868030548096,
-0.05358835309743881,
-0.26059892773628235,
-0.7018775939941406,
0.17659378051757812,
0.6592898368835449,
-0.043631765991449356,
0.5813904404640198,
0.4120911955833435,
-0.12400650978088379,
0.0639924705028534,
-0.5229025483131409,
-0.10476025938987732,
-0.41908687353134155,
0.4002590477466583,
0.07764209806919098,
-0.9180393218994141,
0.37519243359565735,
-0.08457188308238983,
0.3724515736103058,
0.842247486114502,
0.6877544522285461,
-0.2671700119972229,
0.753555953502655,
0.5978310704231262,
-0.31675985455513,
0.9097619652748108,
-0.10244860500097275,
0.27652379870414734,
-0.37972623109817505,
-0.40210843086242676,
-0.6187427043914795,
-0.2802373468875885,
-0.9324765205383301,
0.04228119179606438,
0.3202601671218872,
-0.361783891916275,
-0.4592803716659546,
0.13022850453853607,
-0.3776850700378418,
0.027687575668096542,
0.7692767977714539,
-0.059548862278461456,
0.1543121337890625,
-0.35791081190109253,
0.5598941445350647,
0.2972026467323303,
-0.46349647641181946,
-0.47618699073791504,
1.202780842781067,
0.30484580993652344,
0.3895758092403412,
-0.02393750101327896,
0.22230930626392365,
0.8636597394943237,
0.22134114801883698,
-0.6293424367904663,
0.5727387070655823,
0.34179073572158813,
-0.6441510915756226,
-0.4130989611148834,
-0.15216919779777527,
-1.2487703561782837,
-0.17785318195819855,
0.047345902770757675,
-0.5389291644096375,
-0.22784489393234253,
0.08005240559577942,
-0.22835108637809753,
-0.07861955463886261,
-0.7000683546066284,
0.6953907012939453,
-0.3859432637691498,
0.11345474421977997,
-0.3452421724796295,
-1.0092345476150513,
0.30314987897872925,
0.20228706300258636,
0.02632601372897625,
-0.10384192317724228,
0.30991700291633606,
0.457501620054245,
-0.060898423194885254,
1.060118556022644,
0.09724776446819305,
-0.018205082044005394,
0.5826254487037659,
-0.00769738107919693,
0.10890332609415054,
-0.20933057367801666,
0.24976173043251038,
0.2904811203479767,
-0.23298321664333344,
-0.2644611895084381,
-0.43878647685050964,
0.42995673418045044,
-0.5657327771186829,
-0.5838750004768372,
-0.23207907378673553,
-0.458434522151947,
-0.131103053689003,
0.08153324574232101,
-0.10296838730573654,
0.36243438720703125,
-0.6496115326881409,
0.2554193139076233,
0.3056923747062683,
-0.2647348940372467,
0.6383602023124695,
0.11765076220035553,
-0.05374040827155113,
-0.17560455203056335,
0.45407143235206604,
-0.25741317868232727,
0.15435247123241425,
0.6284838318824768,
-0.0718638226389885,
-0.10755186527967453,
-0.38266104459762573,
-0.4089411497116089,
-0.07588101923465729,
-0.38090550899505615,
-0.11219412833452225,
-0.4793272316455841,
-0.5301239490509033,
-0.6615277528762817,
-0.1956433802843094,
-0.27724066376686096,
-0.15429069101810455,
-0.35460007190704346,
0.2335682362318039,
0.3854425549507141,
0.8173967003822327,
0.4377986788749695,
0.24405406415462494,
-0.5465181469917297,
0.26490312814712524,
0.3270471394062042,
-0.0018360419198870659,
0.19020244479179382,
-0.17450468242168427,
0.08781329542398453,
0.23731030523777008,
-0.7455370426177979,
-0.9459915161132812,
0.33238422870635986,
0.20616012811660767,
0.6611475944519043,
0.4297580420970917,
-0.22410376369953156,
0.38788729906082153,
-0.41905584931373596,
1.2010631561279297,
0.09265263378620148,
-0.504985511302948,
0.808399498462677,
-0.29150867462158203,
0.2716059982776642,
-0.02148718759417534,
0.17093691229820251,
-0.6119459867477417,
-0.26622146368026733,
-0.7709168791770935,
-0.7562506794929504,
0.454888254404068,
0.32321274280548096,
0.532924473285675,
0.1877335160970688,
0.22173669934272766,
0.3019363582134247,
0.14478948712348938,
-0.47176846861839294,
-0.3726446032524109,
-0.09653301537036896,
-0.20460885763168335,
-0.060741059482097626,
0.19871766865253448,
0.12589432299137115,
-0.09707216173410416,
0.4362293481826782,
-0.04782963544130325,
0.6258103251457214,
-0.3167923092842102,
-0.0813218280673027,
0.3535967767238617,
0.45447462797164917,
0.397632896900177,
0.6610665917396545,
0.1871800273656845,
-0.3174372911453247,
-0.09321574866771698,
-0.3207387328147888,
-0.06433749943971634,
0.18040502071380615,
-0.2259284257888794,
-0.1994481235742569,
0.29755550622940063,
0.7600735425949097,
0.037596698850393295,
-0.7947685718536377,
0.2233172506093979,
0.10101795941591263,
-0.010944133624434471,
-0.9090522527694702,
0.380244642496109,
-0.14499063789844513,
0.6536458730697632,
0.5912752151489258,
0.09100709855556488,
-0.01880158670246601,
-0.7995350956916809,
0.036851681768894196,
0.6239163279533386,
-0.4531470537185669,
-0.25290945172309875,
0.7067381143569946,
0.2663489580154419,
-0.8288813829421997,
0.9122716188430786,
-0.05797039344906807,
-0.41386085748672485,
0.6436600089073181,
0.5293073058128357,
1.1290632486343384,
-0.10216903686523438,
0.3732922077178955,
0.14674249291419983,
0.03081538900732994,
0.26236969232559204,
-0.16158686578273773,
-0.43746814131736755,
-0.6869392991065979,
-0.025864403694868088,
-0.352117657661438,
-0.5247156620025635,
0.023283611983060837,
-0.1567392796278,
0.1364108920097351,
-0.21711158752441406,
-0.46912214159965515,
0.13800445199012756,
-0.19788119196891785,
-0.9569568634033203,
-0.03466339781880379,
0.23684394359588623,
0.33276814222335815,
-0.43423327803611755,
0.23085282742977142,
0.4620225429534912,
-0.49285030364990234,
0.25267815589904785,
0.03416838496923447,
0.09867118299007416,
-1.0135226249694824,
0.5460236668586731,
-0.06333091855049133,
-0.10951002687215805,
0.16808992624282837,
-0.8023744821548462,
-0.643623948097229,
0.9787807464599609,
-0.11037532985210419,
-0.43027427792549133,
-0.38479581475257874,
0.1477338671684265,
0.8123762011528015,
-0.2080013006925583,
0.4050753712654114,
0.47137463092803955,
0.11919150501489639,
0.17946884036064148,
-0.9608495235443115,
-0.3601151704788208,
-0.4600534737110138,
0.08297118544578552,
0.2566384971141815,
-0.639202892780304,
0.48870372772216797,
-0.0853126272559166,
-0.37364426255226135,
0.49961429834365845,
0.9253913760185242,
-0.05370499938726425,
0.3593596816062927,
0.13544870913028717,
0.014190020971000195,
0.4199269711971283,
-0.3194824457168579,
0.7540675401687622,
-0.1282246708869934,
-0.16212713718414307,
0.46026572585105896,
0.0568726472556591,
0.7406203746795654,
0.2317269742488861,
-0.5589116811752319,
0.6733004450798035,
0.44501274824142456,
-0.21049699187278748,
0.17071925103664398,
0.03792136162519455,
-0.13638442754745483,
0.08232295513153076,
-0.065529465675354,
-0.2588493824005127,
0.6227018237113953,
0.6004794836044312,
-0.5019635558128357,
0.0899781733751297,
0.17512239515781403,
0.09704171121120453,
-0.1767852008342743,
-0.21555688977241516,
1.0907440185546875,
-0.3210414946079254,
-0.6669531464576721,
0.12998588383197784,
-0.5520412921905518,
0.617753267288208,
-0.6299801468849182,
-0.22459721565246582,
-0.22124026715755463,
0.15430141985416412,
0.3463813066482544,
-0.8274549245834351,
0.09562055766582489,
0.03811509907245636,
0.1562015563249588,
-0.20010018348693848,
0.5272588133811951,
0.001497364602982998,
-0.4210168719291687,
-0.045250166207551956,
0.6561329364776611,
0.1806841790676117,
0.07026515901088715,
-0.5178980827331543,
0.022918082773685455,
-0.07692743837833405,
0.23346775770187378,
0.0407601073384285,
0.3745005428791046,
-0.05925607681274414,
0.7422630190849304,
0.544563889503479,
-0.21676893532276154,
0.10678569972515106,
-0.0872819572687149,
0.5990327000617981,
-1.023452877998352,
-0.5205258727073669,
-0.9500402212142944,
0.628895103931427,
0.010355745442211628,
-0.4536833167076111,
0.5085253119468689,
0.24347048997879028,
0.7015606164932251,
0.2991905212402344,
0.9808264970779419,
-0.46873077750205994,
0.33241862058639526,
-0.2733670771121979,
0.8130037188529968,
-0.2307368367910385,
-0.06037100404500961,
-0.12551742792129517,
-0.6970384120941162,
-0.39510828256607056,
0.16732792556285858,
-0.024958066642284393,
0.39209413528442383,
0.20208677649497986,
0.4325129985809326,
0.537587583065033,
0.3172868490219116,
0.14076024293899536,
0.1435115784406662,
0.6412534117698669,
0.08999219536781311,
1.0444819927215576,
-0.2898266315460205,
0.6192250847816467,
-0.03910844773054123,
-0.20084398984909058,
-0.5000198483467102,
-0.2695830762386322,
-0.7281570434570312,
-0.9760100245475769,
-0.3650141954421997,
-0.11315184086561203,
0.3100104033946991,
0.5760031938552856,
0.47549232840538025,
-0.7320595979690552,
-0.08944901823997498,
-0.3534402549266815,
0.08105817437171936,
-0.5023074150085449,
-0.3341551721096039,
0.20457373559474945,
-0.6410341262817383,
-0.9876286387443542,
0.32648828625679016,
0.2193155735731125,
0.28526124358177185,
-0.5693658590316772,
0.027846794575452805,
0.07054249942302704,
0.0009115072898566723,
0.7990113496780396,
0.6155639290809631,
-0.8142816424369812,
-0.17763686180114746,
0.07500816881656647,
0.06910985708236694,
0.3893548548221588,
0.6685558557510376,
-0.9787055850028992,
0.5107654929161072,
0.47209498286247253,
0.515234649181366,
0.21075396239757538,
-0.07251584529876709,
0.7627564668655396,
-0.3652568757534027,
0.1424187570810318,
0.5270389914512634,
-0.006690809968858957,
0.32889461517333984,
-0.10780267417430878,
0.44043052196502686,
0.2002938985824585,
-0.7115585207939148,
-0.5385908484458923,
0.06814049184322357,
-0.873982310295105,
-0.03825962916016579,
0.7515057325363159,
0.3604508936405182,
0.07125725597143173,
-0.2388419210910797,
-0.4482879042625427,
0.47845199704170227,
-0.4317508637905121,
1.1877996921539307,
0.5870930552482605,
-0.7001663446426392,
-0.372299462556839,
-0.5236077904701233,
0.45070210099220276,
0.009128361009061337,
-1.0293316841125488,
-0.1746552586555481,
0.6886245608329773,
-0.3592156767845154,
0.34890931844711304,
0.4613269567489624,
-0.27462199330329895,
0.13294920325279236,
0.34156203269958496,
0.008628007024526596,
0.4678046703338623,
-0.3830123543739319,
0.0038893113378435373,
0.266375869512558,
-0.034056760370731354,
-0.415169894695282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02330v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02330v2 | Enhance Reasoning for Large Language Models in the Game Werewolf | 2024-02-04T03:47:10 | 2024-03-29T09:01:56 | Shuang Wu, Liwen Zhu, Tao Yang, Shiwei Xu, Qiang Fu, Yang Wei, Haobo Fu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper presents an innovative framework that integrates Large Language
Models (LLMs) with an external Thinker module to enhance the reasoning
capabilities of LLM-based agents. Unlike augmenting LLMs with prompt
engineering, Thinker directly harnesses knowledge from databases and employs
various optimization techniques. The framework forms a reasoning hierarchy
where LLMs handle intuitive System-1 tasks such as natural language processing,
while the Thinker focuses on cognitive System-2 tasks that require complex
logical analysis and domain-specific knowledge. Our framework is presented
using a 9-player Werewolf game that demands dual-system reasoning. We introduce
a communication protocol between LLMs and the Thinker, and train the Thinker
using data from 18800 human sessions and reinforcement learning. Experiments
demonstrate the framework's effectiveness in deductive reasoning, speech
generation, and online game evaluation. Additionally, we fine-tune a 6B LLM to
surpass GPT4 when integrated with the Thinker. This paper also contributes the
largest dataset for social deduction games to date. | [
-0.449751079082489,
-0.6465624570846558,
0.891227662563324,
0.237003356218338,
0.04745136573910713,
0.23596487939357758,
-0.28150516748428345,
-0.7752516269683838,
0.18188801407814026,
0.6854609251022339,
-0.5114580988883972,
-0.297880619764328,
-0.13799473643302917,
0.0013023652136325836,
0.11250189691781998,
0.5624632835388184,
0.2184121012687683,
0.0666649118065834,
-0.16326238214969635,
0.07756605744361877,
-0.39982870221138,
-0.5924893021583557,
-1.1392607688903809,
-0.861114501953125,
0.2407744973897934,
0.11428901553153992,
0.9096639156341553,
0.5177975296974182,
0.4222519099712372,
0.3821335434913635,
-0.17978119850158691,
0.38665205240249634,
-0.7465001940727234,
0.32526537775993347,
-0.7162795662879944,
-0.4923926293849945,
-0.5689768195152283,
-0.5456159710884094,
0.2519371807575226,
0.15373899042606354,
-0.03918563574552536,
-0.15113161504268646,
-0.1710827648639679,
0.342698872089386,
-0.3623941242694855,
0.3981623351573944,
-0.582084596157074,
-0.09615591168403625,
0.23567090928554535,
-0.05489642918109894,
-0.6023829579353333,
-0.4193793833255768,
0.10429462045431137,
-0.716505765914917,
-0.14995208382606506,
-0.15179158747196198,
0.381938099861145,
0.36680281162261963,
-0.2766038775444031,
-0.14437684416770935,
-0.9076546430587769,
0.5912673473358154,
-0.934462308883667,
0.37181204557418823,
0.23442797362804413,
0.4273619055747986,
-0.4346175491809845,
-0.441338449716568,
-0.717529296875,
-0.24154387414455414,
0.016849108040332794,
0.025051336735486984,
-0.24758149683475494,
0.40572497248649597,
0.46569785475730896,
0.15597586333751678,
-0.2917644679546356,
0.278849333524704,
-0.05373946949839592,
-0.20233674347400665,
0.9113643765449524,
0.2788584530353546,
0.1653592437505722,
0.24089519679546356,
-0.08234765380620956,
-0.05470621585845947,
-0.473777711391449,
0.17577719688415527,
0.310818076133728,
0.03749071806669235,
0.10001309216022491,
0.4306996464729309,
-0.04796446114778519,
0.48211488127708435,
0.4588840901851654,
-0.16851752996444702,
0.08340362459421158,
-0.11668626964092255,
-0.12560005486011505,
0.0968761071562767,
0.5965911746025085,
0.5177140235900879,
0.09441344439983368,
-0.4539487659931183,
-0.46688711643218994,
0.44000622630119324,
0.0940341204404831,
-0.6830915212631226,
-0.3026433289051056,
0.4277122914791107,
-0.205037921667099,
-0.2680884003639221,
-0.3507654070854187,
-0.6406765580177307,
-0.924249529838562,
-0.2783221900463104,
0.4664272367954254,
-0.5849020481109619,
-0.3634640574455261,
0.5895496606826782,
-0.3118855357170105,
0.5607213973999023,
0.4339132606983185,
-1.0646992921829224,
0.36709803342819214,
0.7460921406745911,
0.31148096919059753,
-0.08970404416322708,
-0.11905898153781891,
-0.41527897119522095,
0.3160381615161896,
-0.3636801540851593,
0.9624179601669312,
-0.6285173296928406,
-0.2552255094051361,
-0.18874013423919678,
-0.10638753324747086,
0.3527178168296814,
-0.5818995237350464,
0.48661431670188904,
-0.572499692440033,
0.0526246577501297,
-0.2684628963470459,
-0.7282469272613525,
-0.15759344398975372,
0.4987441599369049,
-0.5964400172233582,
1.1347646713256836,
-0.06251299381256104,
-0.38580188155174255,
0.2854290008544922,
-0.7225136160850525,
-0.47750791907310486,
0.5671775341033936,
-0.18389326333999634,
0.23594021797180176,
0.14283913373947144,
0.4335545003414154,
0.2335057556629181,
-0.5849984884262085,
0.5849976539611816,
-0.5175766348838806,
-0.5128641128540039,
0.2520682215690613,
0.17288918793201447,
0.7050024271011353,
-0.03007338009774685,
-0.4384196400642395,
0.28107762336730957,
-0.5476621985435486,
0.3700753450393677,
0.10435610264539719,
-0.34083929657936096,
-0.17971625924110413,
0.2961099147796631,
-0.1639021784067154,
0.3573448359966278,
0.2017708569765091,
-0.510543942451477,
0.25081852078437805,
-0.6392735242843628,
0.4581272304058075,
0.6459965109825134,
-0.08123694360256195,
0.5536879301071167,
-0.4627341330051422,
0.3714640438556671,
-0.31141647696495056,
0.17867465317249298,
0.12803630530834198,
-0.24250240623950958,
-0.6680383682250977,
-0.4775373637676239,
-0.0007338340510614216,
0.6992281675338745,
-1.1307458877563477,
0.6856998205184937,
-0.2389635294675827,
-0.6385502219200134,
-0.6336374282836914,
-0.10382954031229019,
0.1359437257051468,
0.032703373581171036,
0.3407498300075531,
0.1619550585746765,
-0.5796640515327454,
-0.912367045879364,
-0.05687336623668671,
-0.3903889060020447,
-0.07369951903820038,
0.2925950586795807,
0.4016522169113159,
-0.518524706363678,
0.9960280060768127,
-0.36886656284332275,
0.009032092057168484,
-0.7410497069358826,
-0.31900009512901306,
0.2252851128578186,
0.3976821303367615,
0.24880896508693695,
-0.5477408766746521,
-0.048683084547519684,
-0.13881519436836243,
-0.9393406510353088,
-0.10742998868227005,
-0.15876193344593048,
-0.20227432250976562,
-0.005120962392538786,
0.4260992407798767,
-0.6887328624725342,
-0.03357137739658356,
0.37842845916748047,
-0.4770212173461914,
0.5108972191810608,
-0.3494146764278412,
0.10033121705055237,
-0.930053174495697,
-0.27923789620399475,
0.0011075460352003574,
-0.19043652713298798,
-0.7296577095985413,
0.4030872583389282,
-0.24187813699245453,
0.09552700817584991,
-0.11974619328975677,
0.8844632506370544,
-0.3406308889389038,
0.0695999339222908,
-0.4521311819553375,
0.3514253795146942,
-0.0047020092606544495,
0.49018946290016174,
0.21008777618408203,
0.5426794290542603,
0.7657126784324646,
-0.6112022399902344,
0.8918575048446655,
0.19265705347061157,
-0.38729989528656006,
0.46702519059181213,
-0.7417886257171631,
0.39311233162879944,
-0.1623866856098175,
0.42410480976104736,
-0.6887595057487488,
-0.1403058022260666,
0.007512879092246294,
-0.2883240878582001,
-0.13467857241630554,
0.24857069551944733,
-0.745080292224884,
-0.46259552240371704,
-0.36392247676849365,
0.058773864060640335,
0.5176197290420532,
-0.6676850914955139,
0.8809362649917603,
0.7422569990158081,
0.13928258419036865,
-0.3250231146812439,
-0.6195967197418213,
0.16377222537994385,
-0.30973073840141296,
-0.9006730914115906,
0.24312108755111694,
-0.2706131637096405,
-0.6256455779075623,
-0.17771020531654358,
-0.09946726262569427,
-0.005661729257553816,
0.025287020951509476,
-0.055976927280426025,
0.260923832654953,
-0.26130548119544983,
0.3835271894931793,
0.07273543626070023,
0.02684132568538189,
0.20698322355747223,
-0.5676963925361633,
0.4533116817474365,
-0.20490330457687378,
-0.1428932398557663,
-0.01061276812106371,
0.17273899912834167,
0.3687521517276764,
-0.05601378157734871,
0.6933252215385437,
0.2868316173553467,
-0.4724370837211609,
-0.48717549443244934,
-0.7939622402191162,
-0.49711480736732483,
-0.48747751116752625,
0.474444180727005,
-0.5437652468681335,
-1.172346830368042,
0.7016292214393616,
-0.13597214221954346,
0.09891951829195023,
0.13930459320545197,
0.5327090620994568,
0.10506834834814072,
1.1935368776321411,
0.571415364742279,
0.11996712535619736,
0.07408206909894943,
-0.06864206492900848,
0.147068589925766,
-0.645231306552887,
-0.26459312438964844,
-0.09261449426412582,
-0.35708627104759216,
-0.3485604226589203,
-0.7226341366767883,
-0.03719329461455345,
0.07098246365785599,
-0.4361105263233185,
0.2400701344013214,
-0.4155105650424957,
0.8339903354644775,
0.19478188455104828,
0.3937917947769165,
0.3080139458179474,
-0.4184381067752838,
-0.2146981805562973,
0.008745062164962292,
-0.4942541718482971,
-0.5619006752967834,
0.5421315431594849,
0.3962186574935913,
0.965628981590271,
0.4608081877231598,
0.5426753759384155,
0.35546499490737915,
0.21033693850040436,
-0.9230550527572632,
0.7887725234031677,
0.19891484081745148,
-0.9134729504585266,
-0.6117993593215942,
-0.5148931741714478,
-0.3870806097984314,
0.3718470633029938,
-0.3509122431278229,
-1.0475434064865112,
0.16035524010658264,
0.15442797541618347,
-0.4533821642398834,
0.29467180371284485,
-0.5030595660209656,
0.6355782151222229,
-0.2908170819282532,
-0.5144482254981995,
-0.2887679934501648,
-0.3835742175579071,
0.4696162939071655,
-0.17641595005989075,
0.14166702330112457,
0.03874596580862999,
-0.05606376379728317,
0.41560477018356323,
-0.06373076140880585,
0.6807498931884766,
-0.17298735678195953,
-0.5741558074951172,
0.24726243317127228,
0.29883405566215515,
0.8212529420852661,
0.13460394740104675,
-0.2882886230945587,
-0.23311857879161835,
-0.14914071559906006,
-0.09953614324331284,
-0.8081725835800171,
0.6599138379096985,
-0.611687183380127,
-0.8955828547477722,
-0.15218575298786163,
-0.7479711771011353,
-0.578382134437561,
-0.0009614633745513856,
0.004481276962906122,
0.4422317445278168,
-0.27962180972099304,
0.24168872833251953,
0.7062575221061707,
-0.3089970052242279,
0.117738276720047,
0.5654870867729187,
-0.3329000473022461,
-0.3405441343784332,
0.7076646685600281,
-0.41418012976646423,
0.3058469295501709,
0.6018301844596863,
0.22779081761837006,
-0.52742600440979,
-0.4698009192943573,
-0.22379164397716522,
0.36392319202423096,
-0.8939340710639954,
-0.12123138457536697,
-0.6473910212516785,
-0.2095472812652588,
-0.2381238341331482,
-0.2866654098033905,
-0.18359962105751038,
-0.2545985281467438,
0.3457071781158447,
-0.36577853560447693,
0.33214372396469116,
0.726436972618103,
-0.1531926989555359,
0.5611742734909058,
-0.6594479084014893,
0.09400046616792679,
0.33861133456230164,
0.3551642596721649,
0.051542092114686966,
-0.5222597718238831,
-0.21094898879528046,
0.04769265651702881,
-0.07156814634799957,
-0.836792528629303,
0.18477316200733185,
-0.11023354530334473,
0.8153172731399536,
0.2522643804550171,
-0.02180514857172966,
0.5171199440956116,
-0.36211737990379333,
0.5654467940330505,
0.2200184017419815,
-1.1023310422897339,
0.38549545407295227,
-0.47965872287750244,
0.54006028175354,
0.442992240190506,
-0.06439141929149628,
-0.40825125575065613,
-0.6743832230567932,
-0.43610724806785583,
-0.4640025496482849,
1.0419893264770508,
0.1738431304693222,
-0.045710861682891846,
-0.16067026555538177,
0.274986207485199,
0.01619039662182331,
-0.17033621668815613,
-0.908241331577301,
-0.1611916422843933,
0.19269105792045593,
-0.18449023365974426,
-0.1854991316795349,
-0.13221246004104614,
0.0042396429926157,
-0.3474394977092743,
0.8298800587654114,
-0.28746646642684937,
0.04503561556339264,
-0.049209944903850555,
-0.18355856835842133,
-0.05778402462601662,
0.398724764585495,
0.2651441693305969,
0.7664439082145691,
-0.10800758004188538,
0.21303845942020416,
0.5555135011672974,
-0.2773967981338501,
0.2995529770851135,
0.21203866600990295,
-0.14023971557617188,
-0.3875385522842407,
0.30492883920669556,
0.7745605111122131,
0.3694615066051483,
-0.9234781265258789,
0.17760971188545227,
-0.14542542397975922,
-0.28177469968795776,
-0.11512832343578339,
0.20459821820259094,
0.4951336979866028,
0.9381483197212219,
0.1989845186471939,
-0.13105888664722443,
0.19820261001586914,
-0.49099624156951904,
0.10106561332941055,
0.4313511252403259,
-0.4632004499435425,
-0.3332376182079315,
0.5307201743125916,
0.34898796677589417,
-0.25493529438972473,
0.12583833932876587,
-0.37912073731422424,
-0.5767573118209839,
0.5468701124191284,
0.9206568598747253,
0.768371045589447,
-0.18688027560710907,
0.26935961842536926,
0.32806622982025146,
0.45458918809890747,
-0.37650206685066223,
0.3248935341835022,
0.10800185799598694,
-1.025072693824768,
-0.8527352809906006,
-0.40774694085121155,
-0.34589385986328125,
0.42811110615730286,
-0.09141266345977783,
0.43114060163497925,
-0.30722159147262573,
-0.4133344888687134,
0.1018320843577385,
-0.009334692731499672,
-0.4849039912223816,
-0.0921928882598877,
0.4824367165565491,
0.9025010466575623,
-0.4365844428539276,
0.8433719873428345,
0.7948518395423889,
-0.22711439430713654,
-0.7830537557601929,
-0.192735493183136,
-0.05972682684659958,
-0.6288431882858276,
0.6796802282333374,
0.054333459585905075,
-0.5136144757270813,
0.08201036602258682,
-0.5982773303985596,
-0.6474888324737549,
0.9382460713386536,
0.6516521573066711,
-0.6827306151390076,
-0.30797362327575684,
-0.11459852010011673,
0.710038423538208,
-0.5194401741027832,
0.32786938548088074,
0.6822460293769836,
0.42473533749580383,
0.44265586137771606,
-0.841338574886322,
0.2569856345653534,
-0.029888996854424477,
-0.1645829975605011,
0.39155733585357666,
-0.3637503981590271,
0.3579839766025543,
-0.5626538395881653,
-0.22526618838310242,
-0.21828565001487732,
0.5758171677589417,
0.5336421132087708,
-0.04843028262257576,
0.636700451374054,
0.5234010219573975,
0.8003160953521729,
0.10554134100675583,
0.7981177568435669,
-0.07965441793203354,
0.09704233705997467,
1.1658321619033813,
-0.7511074542999268,
0.4623335897922516,
0.15756624937057495,
0.06735048443078995,
0.3494797348976135,
0.3051738440990448,
0.07540331035852432,
0.36408093571662903,
0.4936944544315338,
-0.40635836124420166,
-0.7885765433311462,
-0.0734325423836708,
-0.1649477630853653,
0.5202450752258301,
0.5001025795936584,
-0.09447862207889557,
-0.1650114804506302,
-0.0387357622385025,
0.06138311326503754,
0.16514557600021362,
-0.28239619731903076,
1.0681843757629395,
0.0509590208530426,
-0.7514201998710632,
0.315214067697525,
-0.02790655568242073,
0.7385857105255127,
-0.6219276189804077,
-0.00423630652949214,
-0.2934929430484772,
0.7989389300346375,
-0.07466793805360794,
-0.8429766297340393,
-0.008886648342013359,
0.0002475553483236581,
-0.04508867487311363,
0.042028117924928665,
0.8717793822288513,
-0.44950664043426514,
-0.28260141611099243,
0.7937648296356201,
0.7729414701461792,
0.06599651277065277,
-0.08758006244897842,
-0.6069469451904297,
0.07657219469547272,
0.056812141090631485,
-0.03680042177438736,
0.12548716366291046,
0.7630606293678284,
-0.015014865435659885,
0.7971009612083435,
0.5203334093093872,
0.1599351316690445,
-0.43241313099861145,
0.2148316502571106,
1.0660308599472046,
-0.7417611479759216,
-0.5866233110427856,
-1.1732887029647827,
0.2194853276014328,
-0.393131285905838,
0.09133241325616837,
0.685418426990509,
0.651083767414093,
0.5067259669303894,
0.01912745274603367,
0.7912557721138,
0.002573450794443488,
0.28901851177215576,
-0.27004846930503845,
0.5508961081504822,
-0.14473968744277954,
0.30363211035728455,
-0.13175249099731445,
-0.9856844544410706,
-0.06852710247039795,
0.5529653429985046,
-0.40531373023986816,
-0.2375914603471756,
0.6162413358688354,
0.8742047548294067,
-0.011894701048731804,
0.2736857533454895,
0.5091785788536072,
0.16963939368724823,
0.5968628525733948,
0.8587344288825989,
1.1483678817749023,
-0.05804472416639328,
0.5951735973358154,
0.17680120468139648,
-0.45813366770744324,
0.16529779136180878,
-0.7621350288391113,
-1.3379707336425781,
-0.34909313917160034,
-0.1217028945684433,
-0.43715378642082214,
0.10872844606637955,
1.2899882793426514,
0.3999890983104706,
-0.5968895554542542,
-0.37739822268486023,
0.20395967364311218,
0.015088553540408611,
-0.29495614767074585,
-0.2354901283979416,
0.016669616103172302,
-0.2280108779668808,
-0.4353206753730774,
0.552539050579071,
0.3011800944805145,
-0.22058697044849396,
-0.39578351378440857,
-0.35818153619766235,
-0.18759135901927948,
0.5205722451210022,
0.8698646426200867,
0.029893409460783005,
-0.7657318115234375,
-0.39294999837875366,
0.30619245767593384,
-0.12631095945835114,
-0.12356467545032501,
0.7933641076087952,
-0.8868056535720825,
0.46802228689193726,
0.3668656647205353,
0.6673709154129028,
0.4318043291568756,
-0.11299275606870651,
0.8862647414207458,
-0.25593242049217224,
0.10828953981399536,
0.4991076588630676,
0.33748722076416016,
0.42334505915641785,
-0.4159465432167053,
0.5366798043251038,
0.02443068102002144,
-0.5508155226707458,
-0.7110490202903748,
0.2678961455821991,
-0.6566834449768066,
-0.30361342430114746,
1.3276723623275757,
0.0914716050028801,
-0.10383723676204681,
-0.3483342230319977,
-0.3574618101119995,
0.013034745119512081,
-0.6757737398147583,
0.6785445213317871,
0.9458654522895813,
-0.23071777820587158,
-0.27365556359291077,
-0.3100149929523468,
0.7137942910194397,
-0.08816016465425491,
-1.2073678970336914,
0.3039936423301697,
0.7278519868850708,
-0.1120510846376419,
0.21235467493534088,
0.870136022567749,
0.015110313892364502,
0.21813878417015076,
0.11200893670320511,
0.2623785138130188,
-0.05788920074701309,
-0.04745577648282051,
-0.17999453842639923,
-0.16376613080501556,
-0.030186239629983902,
0.3418302536010742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02318v1 | Diversity Measurement and Subset Selection for Instruction Tuning Datasets | 2024-02-04T02:09:43 | 2024-02-04T02:09:43 | Peiqi Wang, Yikang Shen, Zhen Guo, Matthew Stallone, Yoon Kim, Polina Golland, Rameswar Panda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We aim to select data subsets for the fine-tuning of large language models to
more effectively follow instructions. Prior work has emphasized the importance
of diversity in dataset curation but relied on heuristics such as the number of
tasks. In this paper, we use determinantal point processes to capture the
diversity and quality of instruction tuning datasets for subset selection. We
propose to measure dataset diversity with log determinant distance that is the
distance between the dataset of interest and a maximally diverse reference
dataset. Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed diversity measure in the
normalized weight gradient space is correlated with downstream
instruction-following performance. Consequently, it can be used to inform when
data selection is the most helpful and to analyze dataset curation strategies.
We demonstrate the utility of our approach on various instruction tuning
datasets. | [
-0.6984236240386963,
-0.38034069538116455,
0.0258333720266819,
0.027667047455906868,
-0.2811467945575714,
0.07371712476015091,
-0.3498528003692627,
-0.16994887590408325,
-0.15924328565597534,
0.2902388572692871,
-0.691948652267456,
-0.8003005385398865,
-0.7097448110580444,
0.05765703693032265,
-0.49593889713287354,
1.094131350517273,
0.1547173708677292,
0.21042396128177643,
-0.022765731438994408,
-0.30399656295776367,
-0.7782437801361084,
-0.07744231820106506,
-0.5809758305549622,
-0.05954589322209358,
0.6091738939285278,
0.6340016722679138,
0.4617800712585449,
1.1885650157928467,
0.47480860352516174,
0.23134295642375946,
-0.09006118029356003,
0.4760645627975464,
-0.6808291673660278,
0.32640084624290466,
-0.10378029197454453,
-0.8507270812988281,
0.027826718986034393,
0.011670179665088654,
0.9548625946044922,
1.0290720462799072,
0.14889150857925415,
0.36204206943511963,
0.13386018574237823,
1.0559132099151611,
-0.8097097277641296,
-0.28666210174560547,
-0.4463699758052826,
0.2573067247867584,
-0.4639822542667389,
-0.02862066775560379,
-0.17827393114566803,
-0.7267413139343262,
-0.23064671456813812,
-0.34050318598747253,
0.46092677116394043,
0.23203974962234497,
0.4145934581756592,
0.24549360573291779,
-0.2700260579586029,
-0.19249370694160461,
-1.002881646156311,
1.2742544412612915,
-0.48617714643478394,
0.4142805337905884,
0.5528602004051208,
0.2727229595184326,
-0.04194134101271629,
-0.06800128519535065,
-0.2271125316619873,
0.13216829299926758,
0.07706254720687866,
-0.04585473984479904,
-0.0686027780175209,
-0.1862480193376541,
0.5405712723731995,
0.7033160924911499,
-0.5684528946876526,
0.39108094573020935,
-0.5944283604621887,
0.004767099395394325,
0.7442910671234131,
0.504909098148346,
0.1604931354522705,
0.2578292191028595,
0.1023724302649498,
-0.32612231373786926,
-0.7289838790893555,
0.14192494750022888,
0.9519879221916199,
0.3259708285331726,
-0.09524651616811752,
0.33179277181625366,
-0.40014660358428955,
0.9923673272132874,
0.0987543910741806,
0.1265777349472046,
0.055517226457595825,
-0.7427740097045898,
-0.11767379939556122,
-0.009924580343067646,
0.31112539768218994,
0.25138455629348755,
0.051255203783512115,
0.1301957368850708,
-0.3073608875274658,
-0.35458317399024963,
0.08860395103693008,
-0.7506430149078369,
-0.5163596868515015,
-0.17679286003112793,
-0.5996686220169067,
0.17088109254837036,
0.16779488325119019,
-0.717006266117096,
-0.21083255112171173,
-0.7142048478126526,
-0.25502344965934753,
-0.5421397686004639,
-0.05849342420697212,
-0.0601983368396759,
-0.24447013437747955,
0.10228680819272995,
0.2530537247657776,
-1.2996033430099487,
0.3645484745502472,
0.8454418182373047,
0.6347380876541138,
-0.5249245166778564,
-0.08604000508785248,
-0.6037880778312683,
-0.19484134018421173,
-0.5218601822853088,
0.4653246998786926,
-0.8114030361175537,
-0.5842023491859436,
-0.25622642040252686,
-0.09965714812278748,
-0.39889952540397644,
-0.8738842010498047,
0.37316271662712097,
-0.49526646733283997,
0.07962889224290848,
-0.6833425164222717,
-0.836426854133606,
-0.3169272243976593,
-0.06123526766896248,
-0.9343897700309753,
1.1076322793960571,
0.5417654514312744,
-0.6331565380096436,
0.7024108171463013,
-0.35155680775642395,
-0.6327283978462219,
0.09973380714654922,
-0.12926949560642242,
-0.38645172119140625,
0.33453962206840515,
0.16466693580150604,
0.11950943619012833,
-0.13597610592842102,
-0.1338154822587967,
-0.2013268917798996,
-0.7192355394363403,
-0.045220453292131424,
-0.37469053268432617,
0.9781494736671448,
0.1715792417526245,
-0.2871030867099762,
-0.0552016906440258,
-0.7821663618087769,
0.04430054500699043,
-0.45301365852355957,
-0.5725985765457153,
-0.593238353729248,
0.13756538927555084,
-0.3965705335140228,
0.05262472480535507,
0.04717925935983658,
-0.25640854239463806,
0.0900077298283577,
0.08949580788612366,
-0.19797742366790771,
0.7377182245254517,
-0.03368155658245087,
0.3199073076248169,
-0.6091673374176025,
0.7404009699821472,
0.05232338607311249,
0.2712026834487915,
0.032697539776563644,
-0.47112640738487244,
-0.7306101322174072,
-0.44242537021636963,
0.3042566776275635,
0.5567020177841187,
-0.14469365775585175,
0.7961918115615845,
-0.09685298055410385,
-0.3948727250099182,
-0.6125209331512451,
0.44467076659202576,
0.2873555123806,
0.34472039341926575,
0.25501248240470886,
-0.40263831615448,
-0.6004413366317749,
-0.7395880818367004,
0.04567492753267288,
0.07493923604488373,
-0.22327521443367004,
0.3602868616580963,
0.32365211844444275,
0.062025945633649826,
0.6285938024520874,
-0.49465417861938477,
0.14318148791790009,
-0.10731825977563858,
0.029455237090587616,
0.4388430714607239,
0.6187146902084351,
0.5906978845596313,
-0.564495861530304,
-0.5604545474052429,
-0.052600592374801636,
-0.4998394846916199,
0.008328644558787346,
0.010211732238531113,
-0.5191832184791565,
0.0003235362528357655,
0.33693698048591614,
-0.1879703849554062,
0.4025062024593353,
0.5356147289276123,
-0.24522528052330017,
0.6270308494567871,
0.2016374170780182,
0.5714159607887268,
-0.7036523222923279,
0.07023099064826965,
-0.14035816490650177,
0.08394094556570053,
-0.47913697361946106,
-0.17933422327041626,
-0.20052669942378998,
0.4142496585845947,
-0.12175919860601425,
0.10384394973516464,
-0.24284717440605164,
-0.26162177324295044,
0.01805669441819191,
-0.07510753720998764,
-0.02063857391476631,
0.1673365980386734,
-0.29556137323379517,
0.6792022585868835,
0.47976329922676086,
-0.7525722980499268,
0.47788456082344055,
0.19913102686405182,
-0.6496321558952332,
0.9293557405471802,
-0.3839019238948822,
-0.08513299375772476,
-0.09448526799678802,
-0.22195596992969513,
-0.9569063186645508,
0.11528895795345306,
0.14665308594703674,
-0.13684359192848206,
0.308007150888443,
-0.05939359962940216,
-0.34636861085891724,
-0.3304049074649811,
-0.4248526096343994,
0.19246108829975128,
0.4012017250061035,
-0.4368073344230652,
-0.12690432369709015,
-0.032711852341890335,
-0.2516879141330719,
-0.6060019731521606,
-0.46506360173225403,
-0.42522290349006653,
-0.2994769811630249,
-0.5190940499305725,
0.0919547900557518,
-0.26297783851623535,
-0.2885735034942627,
-0.3190550208091736,
-0.29440778493881226,
0.08473246544599533,
0.2085985690355301,
0.17179733514785767,
0.25422725081443787,
-0.42324262857437134,
0.26116055250167847,
0.5094451308250427,
0.2661105692386627,
0.04852830991148949,
-0.375751256942749,
0.36627089977264404,
0.21938110888004303,
-0.5564946532249451,
-0.13308371603488922,
0.5652024745941162,
0.01584143564105034,
-0.1863834708929062,
0.7881653904914856,
0.8195841908454895,
-0.11556538939476013,
-0.5592149496078491,
-0.22164122760295868,
-0.45286086201667786,
-0.4687969386577606,
0.450409471988678,
-0.04733402281999588,
-0.9533905982971191,
0.6454851031303406,
0.20975887775421143,
0.46221745014190674,
0.12244764715433121,
0.34791821241378784,
-0.19070939719676971,
0.8606098890304565,
0.44330736994743347,
-0.18891942501068115,
0.8957898020744324,
-0.2766474485397339,
0.14809773862361908,
-0.808538019657135,
-0.13746730983257294,
-0.858938992023468,
-0.9578182697296143,
-0.6030569672584534,
-0.31215235590934753,
0.06598228961229324,
0.2724011540412903,
-0.4966660439968109,
0.07836447656154633,
-0.46823400259017944,
0.5998610854148865,
1.06044602394104,
0.12276893854141235,
0.3228512406349182,
0.41684281826019287,
-0.005839806515723467,
-0.23365767300128937,
-0.5773691534996033,
-0.31580308079719543,
1.0776768922805786,
-0.0011435620253905654,
0.8074522018432617,
-0.0919642373919487,
0.8019867539405823,
0.2721673548221588,
0.1199197992682457,
-0.44566160440444946,
0.450856477022171,
-0.877463698387146,
-0.41129615902900696,
-0.6190709471702576,
-0.6635651588439941,
-0.9984140992164612,
-0.10466239601373672,
0.19592778384685516,
-0.6933178305625916,
0.366536945104599,
0.05212794244289398,
-0.19269974529743195,
0.36187928915023804,
-0.2920007109642029,
0.6481619477272034,
-0.020173899829387665,
-0.048133861273527145,
-0.42361021041870117,
-0.504692792892456,
0.2854630649089813,
0.049971528351306915,
-0.1839909702539444,
-0.20277945697307587,
0.3685230016708374,
0.9321040511131287,
-0.22660194337368011,
0.6777817606925964,
-0.12793344259262085,
-0.16650593280792236,
0.29160428047180176,
0.29062336683273315,
0.11332277953624725,
-0.09259716421365738,
-0.39293694496154785,
0.19515486061573029,
-0.4256957471370697,
-0.3063160181045532,
-0.48766979575157166,
0.9759401082992554,
-0.8379849791526794,
-0.4060837924480438,
0.37194040417671204,
-0.7887223362922668,
-0.09117239713668823,
-0.029196197167038918,
0.2501211166381836,
0.38075801730155945,
0.15099231898784637,
0.4868539273738861,
0.8432350754737854,
-0.005842719227075577,
0.5212828516960144,
0.47871896624565125,
0.2466718703508377,
-0.1779663860797882,
1.0097261667251587,
0.26666033267974854,
0.5032824277877808,
0.577050507068634,
-0.0458657331764698,
-0.06276727467775345,
-0.6636075377464294,
-0.34399616718292236,
-0.22909937798976898,
-0.8298683166503906,
-0.145792156457901,
-0.1457224190235138,
-0.20511308312416077,
0.10235466063022614,
-0.09352407604455948,
-0.21405693888664246,
-0.45909684896469116,
-0.5026861429214478,
-0.3693807125091553,
0.49607396125793457,
0.4871888756752014,
-0.08818710595369339,
0.26253584027290344,
-0.731023371219635,
0.02799222804605961,
0.4502490758895874,
0.43577057123184204,
-0.11485227942466736,
-0.5845310091972351,
-0.5893556475639343,
0.13637490570545197,
-0.37697094678878784,
-0.6067319512367249,
0.1411052644252777,
0.39960214495658875,
0.8441299796104431,
0.44952642917633057,
-0.1317124217748642,
0.40238526463508606,
-0.11830791085958481,
0.6467151045799255,
-0.09558437764644623,
-0.6673459410667419,
0.7487116456031799,
-0.25927993655204773,
0.3914341628551483,
0.8461452126502991,
0.558178722858429,
-0.37925583124160767,
-0.6221523284912109,
-0.10365619510412216,
-0.5066477656364441,
0.7414253950119019,
0.0717092752456665,
-0.07781964540481567,
0.08526899665594101,
0.0990869402885437,
0.47164174914360046,
0.32671311497688293,
-0.028804605826735497,
-0.6255397796630859,
-0.0532522052526474,
-0.4763946831226349,
0.13723382353782654,
0.30154550075531006,
-0.35918617248535156,
-0.4057239890098572,
0.3839057981967926,
-0.15631408989429474,
0.09634555876255035,
-0.4660066068172455,
-0.022242723032832146,
-0.32348141074180603,
0.0795757919549942,
0.4842512011528015,
0.8294839262962341,
-0.08580774813890457,
-0.07811746001243591,
0.012377436272799969,
-0.8344451785087585,
0.09336276352405548,
0.16576175391674042,
-0.4536496102809906,
0.19743287563323975,
0.3163599371910095,
1.0288437604904175,
0.05067398399114609,
-0.3171711564064026,
-0.02292703650891781,
-0.015204053372144699,
-0.010467015206813812,
0.3292297422885895,
0.7772910594940186,
-0.11211827397346497,
0.22000929713249207,
0.3263363838195801,
-0.027619294822216034,
0.25295165181159973,
0.08150734752416611,
0.39296454191207886,
0.2945464551448822,
-0.3098122775554657,
-0.198433518409729,
0.2869041860103607,
0.22020533680915833,
-0.23640549182891846,
1.318922758102417,
-0.18533866107463837,
0.03035585582256317,
1.1621835231781006,
0.36236295104026794,
0.6986657977104187,
-0.4557042419910431,
0.36535072326660156,
0.6458786129951477,
0.3030884265899658,
-0.01951952837407589,
0.47934818267822266,
-0.1048021912574768,
-0.5472260117530823,
-0.3039686977863312,
-0.629664421081543,
-0.2618788480758667,
0.11670709401369095,
-0.8728521466255188,
0.2929600179195404,
-0.5420138835906982,
0.0017489355523139238,
-0.1520705223083496,
0.15944404900074005,
-0.8028379082679749,
0.235238716006279,
0.20167244970798492,
0.652805745601654,
-0.9397549033164978,
0.4886138141155243,
0.4473061263561249,
-0.0046280319802463055,
-0.7561793327331543,
-0.2620915174484253,
0.012077005580067635,
-0.6151002049446106,
0.8949737548828125,
0.20636025071144104,
0.2385791689157486,
-0.17746809124946594,
-0.4132506549358368,
-0.8017140030860901,
1.1679831743240356,
0.3695852756500244,
-1.0034233331680298,
0.268664687871933,
0.15945997834205627,
0.3068617880344391,
-0.511374294757843,
0.20397478342056274,
0.8995587229728699,
0.25840523838996887,
0.050543807446956635,
-0.4749408960342407,
-0.14424839615821838,
-0.11895046383142471,
0.20234578847885132,
0.5068967938423157,
-0.38834625482559204,
1.14142906665802,
-0.11991120129823685,
-0.135947585105896,
-0.20119346678256989,
0.44680720567703247,
0.4156704843044281,
0.1562744826078415,
0.5120525360107422,
0.5049328207969666,
1.0410447120666504,
-0.08696969598531723,
0.7467393279075623,
-0.3463327884674072,
0.19069033861160278,
1.039318561553955,
-0.12679177522659302,
0.43327102065086365,
0.24183745682239532,
-0.5005922317504883,
0.5570806860923767,
0.719154417514801,
-0.47665315866470337,
0.45271632075309753,
0.4619922637939453,
-0.4324016571044922,
-0.19334888458251953,
-0.1066465750336647,
-0.2722291946411133,
0.19795088469982147,
0.5673221945762634,
-0.43800088763237,
-0.2646408975124359,
-0.21066148579120636,
-0.23712629079818726,
-0.022677043452858925,
-0.39228928089141846,
0.5496845841407776,
-0.10096117109060287,
-0.6606737971305847,
0.6307098865509033,
-0.1225193440914154,
0.47715574502944946,
-0.5244293808937073,
-0.12367500364780426,
-0.753589391708374,
-0.07988238334655762,
-0.18720853328704834,
-0.8988044261932373,
0.28674226999282837,
-0.3520461916923523,
-0.5948410630226135,
0.01228038128465414,
0.3390076160430908,
-0.5888042449951172,
-0.5261335372924805,
0.053723130375146866,
0.2953414022922516,
0.024231748655438423,
0.3587077856063843,
-0.43332749605178833,
0.06665609776973724,
0.2073390930891037,
-0.22531740367412567,
0.40807846188545227,
0.3308417797088623,
-0.3006744086742401,
0.4811459183692932,
0.5214563608169556,
0.1368107795715332,
0.38235652446746826,
0.35822251439094543,
0.6539972424507141,
-0.42237770557403564,
-0.5046306848526001,
-0.9212567210197449,
0.3975178599357605,
-0.1446283906698227,
-0.5672034621238708,
0.8260528445243835,
0.6545946002006531,
1.088606595993042,
-0.12273157387971878,
0.7226871848106384,
0.02001374401152134,
0.4481991231441498,
-0.39671021699905396,
0.3076639473438263,
-0.10395249724388123,
0.363872230052948,
0.166171133518219,
-1.131475806236267,
-0.09497088193893433,
0.49945640563964844,
-0.27179962396621704,
0.2896251082420349,
0.4752746522426605,
1.0263417959213257,
-0.25446951389312744,
0.2716614305973053,
0.14419405162334442,
-0.2907533347606659,
0.04709745943546295,
0.7115702629089355,
0.6705502867698669,
-0.13442158699035645,
0.2832707464694977,
-0.23287828266620636,
-0.29013577103614807,
-0.27880311012268066,
-0.6376667618751526,
-1.011081576347351,
-0.38031691312789917,
-0.47796663641929626,
0.15079502761363983,
0.07550320774316788,
0.6520742177963257,
0.8732723593711853,
-1.1334813833236694,
-0.33787617087364197,
0.00037370421341620386,
0.5588568449020386,
-0.6933780908584595,
-0.21528202295303345,
0.22346797585487366,
-0.31166982650756836,
-0.7346904277801514,
0.20362375676631927,
0.19947993755340576,
-0.13036489486694336,
-0.31761932373046875,
-0.12181415408849716,
-0.09431156516075134,
-0.1329556256532669,
0.2913697063922882,
0.17072081565856934,
-0.16366608440876007,
-0.029923686757683754,
0.028709271922707558,
-0.12484333664178848,
0.08784114569425583,
0.8511059880256653,
-0.25627902150154114,
0.4281545579433441,
0.6846915483474731,
0.6334861516952515,
0.25656697154045105,
-0.04676221311092377,
0.6471001505851746,
-1.274641752243042,
-0.14377285540103912,
0.2637888193130493,
0.04671628773212433,
0.45410749316215515,
-0.41821417212486267,
0.436605840921402,
0.05820532143115997,
-0.5194748044013977,
-0.4559241533279419,
0.26899954676628113,
-0.3638151288032532,
0.11608768999576569,
0.9173589944839478,
-0.3019537925720215,
0.04215307906270027,
-0.07939226180315018,
0.05656006932258606,
0.15845917165279388,
-0.4194234609603882,
0.7286443710327148,
0.7670157551765442,
-0.14253346621990204,
-0.21462629735469818,
-0.6940298676490784,
0.5502021312713623,
0.29283055663108826,
-0.9374911785125732,
-0.06356652081012726,
0.6514304876327515,
0.24300476908683777,
-0.03099491447210312,
0.046197425574064255,
0.029921188950538635,
0.42659059166908264,
0.010889668948948383,
-0.22225941717624664,
0.00942227989435196,
-0.3263604938983917,
-0.29068052768707275,
-0.0800885558128357,
-0.06813071668148041,
-0.504118800163269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02315v1 | A Survey of Large Language Models in Finance (FinLLMs) | 2024-02-04T02:06:57 | 2024-02-04T02:06:57 | Jean Lee, Nicholas Stevens, Soyeon Caren Han, Minseok Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-fin.GN | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities across a wide
variety of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks and have attracted attention
from multiple domains, including financial services. Despite the extensive
research into general-domain LLMs, and their immense potential in finance,
Financial LLM (FinLLM) research remains limited. This survey provides a
comprehensive overview of FinLLMs, including their history, techniques,
performance, and opportunities and challenges. Firstly, we present a
chronological overview of general-domain Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs)
through to current FinLLMs, including the GPT-series, selected open-source
LLMs, and financial LMs. Secondly, we compare five techniques used across
financial PLMs and FinLLMs, including training methods, training data, and
fine-tuning methods. Thirdly, we summarize the performance evaluations of six
benchmark tasks and datasets. In addition, we provide eight advanced financial
NLP tasks and datasets for developing more sophisticated FinLLMs. Finally, we
discuss the opportunities and the challenges facing FinLLMs, such as
hallucination, privacy, and efficiency. To support AI research in finance, we
compile a collection of accessible datasets and evaluation benchmarks on
GitHub. | [
-0.1977134793996811,
-0.7710602879524231,
0.32574939727783203,
0.08827684819698334,
0.09133807569742203,
0.5139005780220032,
-0.5197901129722595,
-0.7158670425415039,
-0.12196463346481323,
0.858418345451355,
-0.4430187940597534,
-0.6276878118515015,
-0.6269840002059937,
-0.0508098378777504,
-0.5120472311973572,
0.9757310152053833,
0.05679699406027794,
0.37472373247146606,
-0.16542570292949677,
0.12474730610847473,
-0.16146372258663177,
-0.7642543315887451,
-1.098008155822754,
-0.2699982821941376,
0.23756475746631622,
0.06118730083107948,
0.4558822810649872,
0.2934221625328064,
0.9499019384384155,
0.35071036219596863,
-0.005595074035227299,
-0.030337302014231682,
-0.41528499126434326,
-0.12879188358783722,
-0.16977332532405853,
-0.19408494234085083,
-0.5583119988441467,
0.33741429448127747,
0.5309109687805176,
1.1097193956375122,
-0.2197348028421402,
0.21895095705986023,
-0.09250964224338531,
0.7856181859970093,
-0.48564812541007996,
0.5935116410255432,
-0.42097750306129456,
-0.1676737666130066,
-0.20489931106567383,
0.04914227873086929,
-0.47239530086517334,
-0.2556527256965637,
0.5328396558761597,
-0.3340719938278198,
0.028699271380901337,
0.40190330147743225,
0.48706313967704773,
0.04749224707484245,
-0.3318807780742645,
-0.680661141872406,
-0.7824781537055969,
0.8704728484153748,
-0.7199310064315796,
0.457127183675766,
0.429659366607666,
0.2823151648044586,
-0.17882147431373596,
-0.7462261319160461,
0.0752606987953186,
-0.37791112065315247,
-0.05911695212125778,
-0.1798759549856186,
-0.2592431902885437,
0.13988886773586273,
0.041242413222789764,
0.5530206561088562,
-0.4661638140678406,
0.5336364507675171,
-0.3251676559448242,
-0.10810714960098267,
0.7835971713066101,
0.12604615092277527,
-0.19159038364887238,
0.23132450878620148,
-0.5739166736602783,
-0.347912073135376,
-0.6759006381034851,
0.028237655758857727,
0.47425952553749084,
0.38355451822280884,
-0.08919961750507355,
0.48361366987228394,
0.1354358196258545,
0.8707482814788818,
-0.3610672354698181,
-0.4187799394130707,
0.03313861042261124,
-0.45440179109573364,
-0.5456241369247437,
-0.13199415802955627,
0.6698981523513794,
0.19464227557182312,
0.465095192193985,
-0.2939397394657135,
-0.422260046005249,
-0.5351275205612183,
-0.045990366488695145,
-0.4215905964374542,
-0.0963744968175888,
0.27911993861198425,
-0.33406883478164673,
0.07456684857606888,
0.028653418645262718,
-0.661978006362915,
-0.2998253107070923,
-0.4226687252521515,
0.11866851150989532,
-0.30516332387924194,
-0.060370203107595444,
0.6396862268447876,
-0.21077391505241394,
0.5419920682907104,
0.12459779530763626,
-0.9526548385620117,
0.7359763383865356,
1.2035201787948608,
0.6300122737884521,
-0.08556532114744186,
-0.10027240961790085,
-0.609639048576355,
0.1389620155096054,
-0.40153104066848755,
0.7000751495361328,
-0.3944092094898224,
-0.3625417947769165,
0.15936478972434998,
-0.2498578578233719,
-0.2823891341686249,
-0.7944856286048889,
0.09017858654260635,
-0.5034270286560059,
0.004413848277181387,
0.009257537312805653,
-0.821919322013855,
-0.22893761098384857,
0.16079282760620117,
-0.6557069420814514,
0.5197124481201172,
0.1742706447839737,
-0.5296679735183716,
0.2813572883605957,
-0.8509588837623596,
-0.4393240511417389,
0.07476116716861725,
-0.09026417881250381,
-0.4353208541870117,
-0.06557232141494751,
-0.05146028846502304,
0.8141622543334961,
-0.8689205050468445,
0.5996265411376953,
-0.28848886489868164,
-0.335996150970459,
0.4664885401725769,
-0.2954494059085846,
0.43254268169403076,
0.09638123214244843,
-0.2315966635942459,
0.21548347175121307,
-0.6901933550834656,
-0.4208751320838928,
0.09708685427904129,
0.08338935673236847,
-0.4662594497203827,
-0.03430167958140373,
0.3963097631931305,
-0.1599915325641632,
0.4474889636039734,
-0.23655512928962708,
0.06183023005723953,
-0.6473328471183777,
0.7809379696846008,
0.7728478312492371,
-0.2863910496234894,
0.22818021476268768,
-0.38814738392829895,
0.5458347201347351,
-0.3471324145793915,
0.05711982771754265,
-0.22695022821426392,
-0.23532120883464813,
-0.3668835759162903,
-0.39915913343429565,
0.25613489747047424,
0.46440958976745605,
-0.1315402090549469,
0.20352430641651154,
0.04588707536458969,
-0.3908677399158478,
-0.032163675874471664,
0.39878612756729126,
0.21159623563289642,
0.06011393293738365,
0.08133166283369064,
0.06001553311944008,
-0.30871275067329407,
-1.1631405353546143,
-0.21192127466201782,
-0.21792294085025787,
0.04543989151716232,
0.20855066180229187,
0.4865071475505829,
0.004702655132859945,
0.7281650900840759,
-0.6857410669326782,
-0.30768781900405884,
-0.34527647495269775,
0.23089544475078583,
0.39498764276504517,
0.4139953851699829,
0.8564931750297546,
-0.878960907459259,
-0.021089287474751472,
0.028961680829524994,
-0.29132571816444397,
0.12587976455688477,
-0.20100846886634827,
0.1951439082622528,
0.16282600164413452,
0.5943418741226196,
-0.5564807653427124,
0.050047945231199265,
0.6009017825126648,
-0.44477230310440063,
0.4313221573829651,
-0.15823101997375488,
0.009695790708065033,
-0.8408526182174683,
0.3052411377429962,
0.2882150113582611,
-0.26740458607673645,
-0.5107981562614441,
-0.030430126935243607,
-0.11926819384098053,
0.09833639860153198,
-0.20766566693782806,
0.905169665813446,
-0.4966953694820404,
-0.5277719497680664,
-0.2377355843782425,
0.16717535257339478,
-0.3434893488883972,
0.3047712445259094,
-0.03902949020266533,
0.8162842392921448,
0.5676862001419067,
-0.28104671835899353,
0.5557644367218018,
0.13017474114894867,
-0.5904263257980347,
0.33047959208488464,
-0.5487370491027832,
-0.13881416618824005,
0.08493629097938538,
0.014872482046484947,
-1.1642112731933594,
-0.1640259027481079,
0.018514957278966904,
0.06484802812337875,
0.5427935719490051,
0.23872704803943634,
-0.466966450214386,
-0.4927101731300354,
-0.2683314383029938,
0.2691664695739746,
0.2731339931488037,
-0.28439968824386597,
0.43315601348876953,
0.39171740412712097,
-0.8090011477470398,
-0.6987094283103943,
-0.4901386797428131,
0.3271675705909729,
-0.3844228982925415,
-0.496534526348114,
0.16545332968235016,
-0.12136372178792953,
-0.8043521642684937,
-0.23759664595127106,
-0.030570635572075844,
0.02465800940990448,
0.44352930784225464,
0.10270392149686813,
0.6722664833068848,
-0.31471577286720276,
0.028253454715013504,
-0.44427362084388733,
-0.11056268215179443,
0.19934789836406708,
-0.5289233922958374,
0.5696563124656677,
-0.36101609468460083,
-0.27267009019851685,
0.10901737213134766,
0.15649883449077606,
0.45237043499946594,
-0.2626096308231354,
0.6460197567939758,
0.3918522298336029,
-0.28480201959609985,
-0.14600564539432526,
-0.8788853287696838,
0.15049074590206146,
-0.4581730365753174,
0.2221962809562683,
0.012959783896803856,
-1.5601015090942383,
0.5935666561126709,
-0.19946925342082977,
0.35012298822402954,
0.6889055371284485,
0.6548754572868347,
0.19228368997573853,
0.4595939815044403,
0.8812755346298218,
-0.33742988109588623,
0.3181542456150055,
-0.33918213844299316,
0.26456040143966675,
-0.22214877605438232,
-0.3760252892971039,
-0.6750448346138,
-0.1685439497232437,
-0.19344185292720795,
-0.38895371556282043,
-0.008564803749322891,
0.25369691848754883,
-0.2524157464504242,
0.22157937288284302,
0.07279931008815765,
0.3912740647792816,
0.2943287491798401,
-0.5451515316963196,
0.38056516647338867,
-0.1264999359846115,
-0.022238563746213913,
0.25259265303611755,
-0.4749917984008789,
-0.5074446797370911,
1.1584984064102173,
0.6027365922927856,
0.9133092761039734,
-0.06558728963136673,
0.31835079193115234,
0.4379958510398865,
0.49000537395477295,
-0.6447475552558899,
0.3345411419868469,
-0.5928502082824707,
-0.4330741763114929,
-0.4978328049182892,
-0.7159399390220642,
-0.6145740747451782,
-0.35952937602996826,
0.07632272690534592,
-0.7113776803016663,
-0.06758872419595718,
-0.21695780754089355,
-0.7258206605911255,
0.3752412796020508,
-0.4472421407699585,
0.7676990628242493,
-0.5012925267219543,
-0.17250517010688782,
-0.0509527288377285,
-0.3526386320590973,
0.7227951884269714,
-0.7174355387687683,
0.5472078919410706,
-0.2593194842338562,
-0.13764925301074982,
0.7956569790840149,
-0.335762619972229,
0.7574419379234314,
0.10762575268745422,
-0.6657858490943909,
0.14815713465213776,
-0.374863862991333,
0.37504568696022034,
0.12972593307495117,
-0.06463272124528885,
0.2260308563709259,
0.057334430515766144,
-0.304053395986557,
-0.1405346840620041,
0.8253113627433777,
-0.43344852328300476,
-0.5231451988220215,
-0.2871381342411041,
-0.6596986055374146,
-0.6430186629295349,
-0.14455051720142365,
-0.2657333016395569,
0.2690664231777191,
-0.3642576336860657,
0.4372812807559967,
0.41211605072021484,
-0.2966694235801697,
0.6602799892425537,
0.5777614116668701,
-0.47123873233795166,
-0.42547276616096497,
0.606848418712616,
-0.040165744721889496,
0.20021943747997284,
0.5301158428192139,
0.09095875173807144,
-0.5909108519554138,
-0.73152095079422,
0.007650840096175671,
0.35086590051651,
-0.397051602602005,
-0.33602574467658997,
-0.3737533986568451,
-0.3034953474998474,
-0.6966208815574646,
-0.23445436358451843,
-0.47881150245666504,
-0.30245351791381836,
-0.058222100138664246,
-0.3517456352710724,
0.814767062664032,
1.0820715427398682,
-0.19203682243824005,
0.3183116018772125,
-0.7426201105117798,
0.330096960067749,
0.34629151225090027,
0.7898856997489929,
0.09970337897539139,
-0.1538895070552826,
-0.38237419724464417,
-0.16345544159412384,
0.4017695486545563,
-0.16504895687103271,
0.3873627185821533,
0.13255701959133148,
0.6811839938163757,
0.5256970524787903,
-0.20074957609176636,
0.4877226948738098,
-0.11685851216316223,
0.6061640977859497,
0.3264700472354889,
-0.7019819021224976,
0.09850290417671204,
-0.4222104251384735,
-0.035123515874147415,
0.4813876450061798,
0.5740092992782593,
-0.44060108065605164,
-0.37323495745658875,
-0.23714524507522583,
-0.9801580309867859,
0.6099868416786194,
0.03427429869771004,
0.03311656042933464,
-0.010658739134669304,
0.5541795492172241,
0.3234368860721588,
0.541204571723938,
-0.31297755241394043,
-0.2865564227104187,
0.299155592918396,
-0.09363314509391785,
-0.5836254358291626,
-0.1381673663854599,
-0.03463175520300865,
-0.13545651733875275,
0.5291969180107117,
-0.17678400874137878,
-0.3687593340873718,
-0.13197965919971466,
0.17624138295650482,
0.07896456867456436,
0.14649812877178192,
0.6914287805557251,
0.8569665551185608,
-0.4366804361343384,
-0.13063248991966248,
-0.05766627937555313,
-0.44992324709892273,
0.10034696757793427,
0.4251769781112671,
0.10857554525136948,
-0.11854238063097,
0.40140214562416077,
0.6674684286117554,
0.7618969082832336,
-1.263800024986267,
0.5105466246604919,
-0.12005702406167984,
-0.5147786736488342,
-0.555404782295227,
0.0014542134013026953,
0.4339071810245514,
0.5614520907402039,
0.8379417061805725,
-0.1886487901210785,
-0.05115969106554985,
-0.6097704768180847,
0.28226038813591003,
0.6220873594284058,
-0.23255716264247894,
-0.019614528864622116,
0.782250702381134,
-0.10292959958314896,
-0.07260356098413467,
0.4585416615009308,
0.15862686932086945,
-0.23000405728816986,
0.6606233716011047,
0.30123773217201233,
0.9608304500579834,
0.035653162747621536,
0.11779066175222397,
-0.08815951645374298,
0.17004506289958954,
-0.5191593170166016,
0.18339447677135468,
0.14685143530368805,
-0.5224750638008118,
-0.7118983864784241,
-1.1484671831130981,
-0.5834246277809143,
0.5408325791358948,
-0.6473169326782227,
0.06819447129964828,
-0.7476757168769836,
-0.37683117389678955,
0.2505759298801422,
0.10631375759840012,
-0.7652255892753601,
-0.03197639808058739,
0.2394547462463379,
1.150383710861206,
-0.3481922447681427,
0.4801647365093231,
0.5396554470062256,
-0.07128356397151947,
-0.3288676142692566,
-0.5546377301216125,
-0.05128452926874161,
-0.7574687600135803,
0.6228724122047424,
-0.11028626561164856,
-0.1381547451019287,
0.02751821093261242,
-0.5761123299598694,
-0.7391654849052429,
0.8748553991317749,
0.38363176584243774,
-0.8958514928817749,
-0.3612734079360962,
0.547142744064331,
0.2871207296848297,
-0.5618657469749451,
-0.10062261670827866,
0.8713283538818359,
0.6338905096054077,
0.13038872182369232,
-0.9540866613388062,
-0.5639340281486511,
-0.09682723134756088,
-0.10279880464076996,
0.2600133419036865,
-0.8021544218063354,
0.9034108519554138,
0.00797088909894228,
0.10416445136070251,
0.35072654485702515,
0.5337327122688293,
0.22180676460266113,
0.4634817838668823,
0.3170296251773834,
0.1946084052324295,
0.6825112104415894,
-0.2514860928058624,
0.9736537933349609,
-0.6677014827728271,
0.4320943355560303,
0.9603733420372009,
-0.5519865155220032,
0.9338823556900024,
0.3436024487018585,
-0.3197101056575775,
-0.023856207728385925,
0.7304812669754028,
-0.3298918306827545,
-0.010262678377330303,
0.56633061170578,
-0.07808790355920792,
-0.429798424243927,
-0.03806188702583313,
-0.30003857612609863,
0.5243009328842163,
0.42484647035598755,
-0.3744003474712372,
-0.15902377665042877,
0.164094015955925,
-0.1605226695537567,
0.06594827771186829,
-0.5533588528633118,
0.7455159425735474,
0.5247241258621216,
-0.22703853249549866,
0.013858514837920666,
0.2941472828388214,
0.9198384284973145,
-1.097386360168457,
0.23527739942073822,
-0.27258574962615967,
0.08605839312076569,
0.25907573103904724,
-0.5655633211135864,
0.37830162048339844,
0.17572590708732605,
0.0008703556377440691,
-0.5954931378364563,
0.7161372900009155,
-0.2967865467071533,
-0.7568658590316772,
0.5705363154411316,
0.6339349150657654,
0.0767190232872963,
-0.046946946531534195,
-0.42170295119285583,
-0.17861783504486084,
-0.34844696521759033,
-0.3538871705532074,
0.4995020031929016,
0.1504395306110382,
0.16708782315254211,
0.7114349603652954,
0.7774893641471863,
0.15345105528831482,
-0.15551981329917908,
0.14456811547279358,
0.5075997114181519,
-1.1827131509780884,
-0.1982535421848297,
-0.905052661895752,
-0.19809237122535706,
0.18514680862426758,
-0.44718149304389954,
0.7132639288902283,
0.9372454881668091,
0.9751956462860107,
-0.1255740523338318,
0.5540501475334167,
0.7451806664466858,
0.40863680839538574,
-0.8453962802886963,
0.7575801610946655,
-0.31788837909698486,
0.4660269618034363,
-0.3646388053894043,
-0.7598880529403687,
-0.3268175423145294,
0.3635101914405823,
-0.42827108502388,
-0.10545411705970764,
0.14997391402721405,
0.4036806523799896,
0.1937689185142517,
0.3148680329322815,
0.4834875464439392,
0.1222182959318161,
-0.03739919513463974,
0.3716416358947754,
0.7940202355384827,
-0.07895606011152267,
0.22556905448436737,
0.0547935850918293,
0.26592209935188293,
-0.34060555696487427,
-0.8187938928604126,
-0.7585812211036682,
-0.3886314034461975,
-0.44975775480270386,
0.25377288460731506,
0.011066046543419361,
0.977575421333313,
0.4128855764865875,
-0.7874524593353271,
-0.783059298992157,
0.3522697985172272,
0.0938265472650528,
-0.07064162939786911,
-0.18070094287395477,
0.26884549856185913,
-0.3027147352695465,
-0.7056494951248169,
0.5519428253173828,
0.7289696931838989,
0.3075816333293915,
-0.6093917489051819,
0.053960323333740234,
0.004569395910948515,
0.2006601095199585,
0.7197591662406921,
0.11056497693061829,
-0.4616768956184387,
-0.02387005090713501,
0.09491468966007233,
-0.1260775625705719,
-0.14114470779895782,
1.0899250507354736,
-0.2075778990983963,
-0.18948759138584137,
0.21645207703113556,
0.8657881021499634,
0.4858555495738983,
-0.13317054510116577,
0.7589569687843323,
-0.27626094222068787,
0.0721297562122345,
0.08649461716413498,
0.514647901058197,
0.1154751181602478,
-0.017843859270215034,
0.6679842472076416,
0.0651056095957756,
-0.29127800464630127,
-0.64473956823349,
-0.3363279402256012,
-0.9414251446723938,
-0.65965336561203,
0.9885678291320801,
-0.07953245937824249,
-0.28827181458473206,
-0.22074294090270996,
0.14600953459739685,
-0.27599555253982544,
-0.18675030767917633,
0.24197736382484436,
0.9205029606819153,
0.12078137695789337,
-0.012883034534752369,
-0.882651150226593,
0.6121097803115845,
0.0647224485874176,
-0.6494045853614807,
0.3606783151626587,
0.5153564810752869,
0.12595854699611664,
0.002710000379011035,
0.6370024681091309,
0.019787929952144623,
-0.06436210125684738,
-0.1859041154384613,
-0.14083153009414673,
-0.16738219559192657,
-0.3779086470603943,
-0.35120725631713867,
0.5298503041267395,
0.12967079877853394,
0.4671303629875183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02314v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02314v3 | Selecting Large Language Model to Fine-tune via Rectified Scaling Law | 2024-02-04T01:55:00 | 2024-05-28T16:16:42 | Haowei Lin, Baizhou Huang, Haotian Ye, Qinyu Chen, Zihao Wang, Sujian Li, Jianzhu Ma, Xiaojun Wan, James Zou, Yitao Liang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The ever-growing ecosystem of LLMs has posed a challenge in selecting the
most appropriate pre-trained model to fine-tune amidst a sea of options. Given
constrained resources, fine-tuning all models and making selections afterward
is unrealistic. In this work, we formulate this resource-constrained selection
task into predicting fine-tuning performance and illustrate its natural
connection with Scaling Law. Unlike pre-training, we find that the fine-tuning
scaling curve includes not just the well-known "power phase" but also the
previously unobserved "pre-power phase". We also explain why existing Scaling
Law fails to capture this phase transition phenomenon both theoretically and
empirically. To address this, we introduce the concept of "pre-learned data
size" into our Rectified Scaling Law, which overcomes theoretical limitations
and fits experimental results much better. By leveraging our law, we propose a
novel LLM selection algorithm that selects the near-optimal model with hundreds
of times less resource consumption, while other methods may provide negatively
correlated selection. The project page is available at
rectified-scaling-law.github.io. | [
-0.5623689293861389,
-0.6070451140403748,
0.6076555252075195,
-0.05916236713528633,
-0.46825456619262695,
-0.0042395512573421,
-0.5746838450431824,
-0.33600878715515137,
0.039652254432439804,
0.8099892735481262,
-0.8164478540420532,
0.006245724856853485,
-0.4792955815792084,
0.09907429665327072,
-0.3136832118034363,
1.1356921195983887,
0.0314718559384346,
-0.10165432840585709,
-0.06918161362409592,
0.24794483184814453,
-0.3656632602214813,
-0.0621594600379467,
-0.6857466697692871,
-0.9347094893455505,
0.41275691986083984,
0.5852824449539185,
0.5532053112983704,
0.8066050410270691,
0.4624786376953125,
0.2756212055683136,
-0.2818339169025421,
0.30346420407295227,
-0.7532059550285339,
-0.0013754430692642927,
-0.12639856338500977,
-0.5400083661079407,
-0.544166088104248,
0.22510184347629547,
0.7325299978256226,
0.6857816576957703,
-0.12165968120098114,
0.4320673942565918,
0.2918441891670227,
0.8805415630340576,
-0.6435357928276062,
0.20977596938610077,
-1.0022438764572144,
0.12819181382656097,
-0.16024403274059296,
-0.23974260687828064,
-0.4209896922111511,
-0.26732301712036133,
-0.032587144523859024,
-0.6896782517433167,
0.3841252624988556,
0.3461942672729492,
0.7075843811035156,
0.5691386461257935,
-0.3962058126926422,
0.026314012706279755,
-0.9841203689575195,
0.9988939762115479,
-0.5182698369026184,
0.45555824041366577,
0.5594195127487183,
0.22513842582702637,
-0.0974026471376419,
-0.8203026056289673,
-0.4039490520954132,
-0.3763560950756073,
0.07474736869335175,
-0.24346797168254852,
-0.19602063298225403,
0.20110365748405457,
0.4431821405887604,
0.47329995036125183,
-0.3448648452758789,
0.3334885537624359,
-0.3778230547904968,
-0.18315966427326202,
0.5258575677871704,
0.2596186697483063,
-0.1714952439069748,
0.010906585492193699,
0.19676852226257324,
0.13199582695960999,
-0.8288443088531494,
-0.19963225722312927,
0.2543540894985199,
0.685205340385437,
-0.0005335913738235831,
0.36612921953201294,
-0.20386439561843872,
0.6395798921585083,
0.4018484055995941,
-0.14227859675884247,
0.0896262377500534,
-0.31110912561416626,
-0.4238355755805969,
-0.00576568441465497,
0.5884013772010803,
0.1947733461856842,
0.6152105927467346,
0.02326047793030739,
-0.23809850215911865,
-0.6063728928565979,
0.3788478970527649,
-0.9257479310035706,
-0.3223840594291687,
0.023040974512696266,
-0.5352134108543396,
-0.09060865640640259,
-0.32822471857070923,
-0.6470678448677063,
-0.5317214727401733,
-0.43214812874794006,
0.29488301277160645,
0.03083542175590992,
-0.4796140193939209,
0.2030310034751892,
0.29639849066734314,
-0.04171430319547653,
0.12238532304763794,
-1.2226457595825195,
0.12745089828968048,
0.7052834033966064,
0.8235723376274109,
0.25228744745254517,
-0.17071740329265594,
-0.46675583720207214,
-0.15967229008674622,
-0.41033822298049927,
0.3542897701263428,
-0.4298657774925232,
-0.5236969590187073,
-0.10741152614355087,
0.014747154898941517,
0.23636466264724731,
-0.7389556765556335,
0.4711437523365021,
-0.5994199514389038,
-0.36081287264823914,
-0.2568182349205017,
-0.45397496223449707,
0.026091936975717545,
0.01750066503882408,
-0.8136313557624817,
0.5537519454956055,
0.09711983054876328,
-0.6269143223762512,
0.6510412693023682,
-0.35648423433303833,
-0.5578334331512451,
0.08345211297273636,
0.10127276927232742,
-0.7348636388778687,
0.23667117953300476,
-0.13382601737976074,
0.5962582230567932,
-0.6073780059814453,
0.13437429070472717,
-0.3716844916343689,
-0.12776097655296326,
0.00572570925578475,
-0.3467411994934082,
0.367026686668396,
0.6748248338699341,
-0.05990147590637207,
0.18005450069904327,
-0.8084454536437988,
0.17008239030838013,
0.18730242550373077,
-0.46701231598854065,
0.025016456842422485,
0.18438836932182312,
-0.16674230992794037,
-0.22822953760623932,
0.5248090028762817,
-0.5513345003128052,
0.15344257652759552,
-0.31164345145225525,
0.8624455332756042,
0.6913188099861145,
-0.25294387340545654,
0.7258185148239136,
-0.3053913414478302,
0.4959467947483063,
-0.3906257152557373,
0.21540971100330353,
0.23848053812980652,
0.15763209760189056,
-0.6569039225578308,
-0.22829556465148926,
0.33618074655532837,
0.25459837913513184,
-0.4407862424850464,
0.35353097319602966,
-0.36263903975486755,
-0.5250254273414612,
-0.5836686491966248,
0.4913632571697235,
0.2610372304916382,
0.3592817485332489,
0.40226852893829346,
-0.024971893057227135,
-0.6458107829093933,
-0.9125267863273621,
-0.22885507345199585,
-0.030823100358247757,
-0.11165230721235275,
0.384472131729126,
0.26752763986587524,
-0.13736727833747864,
0.8612121939659119,
-0.6660202145576477,
-0.3659483790397644,
-0.5442703366279602,
0.09512736648321152,
0.2556453049182892,
0.5682271718978882,
0.31880003213882446,
-0.6803581714630127,
-0.33377474546432495,
0.2916337847709656,
-0.13302108645439148,
-0.2797343134880066,
-0.10093236714601517,
0.14255085587501526,
-0.13951042294502258,
0.9513164162635803,
-0.3724799156188965,
-0.04356313496828079,
0.5111625790596008,
-0.06889750063419342,
0.6153935194015503,
-0.7504807710647583,
-0.02220587059855461,
-0.9719358682632446,
-0.029347380623221397,
0.14587163925170898,
-0.4262886643409729,
-0.4302288889884949,
0.02274535410106182,
0.38470423221588135,
0.07887404412031174,
-0.2997599244117737,
0.34774574637413025,
-0.6256427764892578,
-0.02720755524933338,
-0.5516907572746277,
-0.15030896663665771,
-0.30163776874542236,
0.3242347240447998,
-0.18230466544628143,
0.7270779013633728,
0.24391575157642365,
-0.7945453524589539,
0.22926124930381775,
-0.23976345360279083,
-0.46166181564331055,
0.2628677189350128,
-0.46900734305381775,
-0.09659617394208908,
0.077985979616642,
0.041095439344644547,
-0.49909329414367676,
-0.1090732142329216,
-0.4646435081958771,
-0.05086423084139824,
0.6052448749542236,
-0.41538187861442566,
-0.6948679089546204,
-0.27257540822029114,
0.029041383415460587,
0.6617689728736877,
0.5900694727897644,
-0.5347991585731506,
0.6327285170555115,
0.5569620728492737,
0.03871065378189087,
-0.24878914654254913,
-0.5276193618774414,
-0.3383658826351166,
-0.23166391253471375,
-0.19399327039718628,
0.25493717193603516,
-0.23005986213684082,
-0.11091464012861252,
-0.3478608727455139,
-0.11803440004587173,
-0.10838274657726288,
0.29287150502204895,
0.3560734987258911,
0.10610613971948624,
-0.17692984640598297,
0.026756471022963524,
0.08733809739351273,
-0.09228233247995377,
0.11922815442085266,
-0.23833724856376648,
0.7646826505661011,
-0.2518809139728546,
-0.15161889791488647,
-0.3822292983531952,
-0.29872390627861023,
0.8016014695167542,
-0.40237775444984436,
0.32246890664100647,
0.3320588767528534,
-0.12142477184534073,
-0.29126864671707153,
-0.5491856932640076,
-0.19464394450187683,
-0.5491613149642944,
0.6445299983024597,
-0.2061055302619934,
-0.9919377565383911,
0.4607556164264679,
-0.3687688112258911,
0.2269831895828247,
0.31366583704948425,
0.4077494144439697,
0.20383097231388092,
1.0684053897857666,
0.802265465259552,
-0.1530120074748993,
0.8818696737289429,
-0.24748410284519196,
0.05076083168387413,
-0.8890188932418823,
-0.018030203878879547,
-0.5567736625671387,
-0.38827502727508545,
-0.9741010069847107,
-0.1717696338891983,
0.26677703857421875,
-0.05837276577949524,
-0.6284148097038269,
0.29016435146331787,
-0.377923846244812,
0.8101282715797424,
0.4434393346309662,
0.13740377128124237,
0.21633261442184448,
-0.14461322128772736,
0.12314356863498688,
-0.11497507244348526,
-0.4187673330307007,
-0.20591795444488525,
1.2410670518875122,
0.2704266905784607,
0.7528167366981506,
-0.12084101885557175,
0.6806078553199768,
0.12413963675498962,
0.1376880258321762,
-0.7725694179534912,
0.6497536897659302,
-0.49843472242355347,
-0.5282438397407532,
-0.46065232157707214,
-0.820380687713623,
-1.3231467008590698,
0.19221742451190948,
-0.515867292881012,
-0.3794298470020294,
-0.2505927085876465,
0.3516974449157715,
-0.6775946617126465,
0.6220410466194153,
-0.5797753930091858,
0.6382970809936523,
-0.09413053095340729,
-0.26724570989608765,
-0.667371928691864,
-0.3741064667701721,
0.08539742976427078,
-0.4615029990673065,
0.3671189546585083,
-0.19325783848762512,
0.14843422174453735,
0.5017171502113342,
-0.39632904529571533,
0.7247326374053955,
-0.026351435109972954,
-0.08180941641330719,
0.11445458233356476,
0.2345699667930603,
0.5350037217140198,
-0.08044462651014328,
0.038489121943712234,
-0.00552900368347764,
-0.06549942493438721,
-0.3874470293521881,
-0.3317858874797821,
0.7186558246612549,
-0.7400341033935547,
-0.6742885112762451,
0.052635371685028076,
-0.5304718017578125,
-0.2902398109436035,
0.5393381118774414,
0.5223274827003479,
0.16089826822280884,
-0.11425281316041946,
0.28392264246940613,
0.8054748773574829,
-0.06432083994150162,
0.39576590061187744,
0.785785436630249,
-0.4488159120082855,
-0.177877739071846,
1.042497158050537,
0.4209939241409302,
0.4366135597229004,
0.2773459255695343,
0.28800344467163086,
-0.07016430795192719,
-0.8890183568000793,
0.05181372910737991,
0.3829849064350128,
-0.1924864798784256,
-0.159898579120636,
-0.23929482698440552,
-0.3837689161300659,
-0.3004363775253296,
-0.23782861232757568,
-0.7238690853118896,
-0.13819636404514313,
-0.6146376132965088,
-0.16659721732139587,
0.15575705468654633,
0.6195761561393738,
-0.19430245459079742,
0.2082216590642929,
-0.6152226328849792,
0.21947862207889557,
0.40129354596138,
0.458719402551651,
0.011529119685292244,
-0.8677304983139038,
-0.25213587284088135,
0.006993447430431843,
-0.34662261605262756,
-0.2532021403312683,
0.4741863012313843,
0.29326000809669495,
0.4585970342159271,
0.3499935567378998,
0.1336488425731659,
0.6579006314277649,
-0.7599456310272217,
0.32301056385040283,
0.2970767021179199,
-0.7326042056083679,
0.6627671122550964,
-0.10358905047178268,
0.4967874586582184,
0.5325119495391846,
-0.004644119180738926,
-0.21084007620811462,
-0.4114852547645569,
-0.5668213367462158,
-0.9331004619598389,
0.45915645360946655,
-0.09233688563108444,
0.3670958876609802,
0.18987447023391724,
0.7026207447052002,
0.1849183291196823,
0.2738386392593384,
-0.6964108943939209,
-0.22473430633544922,
0.08648087829351425,
-0.03756764158606529,
-0.3873973786830902,
-0.29513517022132874,
0.1864681988954544,
-0.3194771707057953,
0.5946580171585083,
-0.010938630439341068,
-0.34508758783340454,
-0.08773234486579895,
-0.10799310356378555,
-0.517406165599823,
0.2218032032251358,
0.6057969927787781,
0.5612310171127319,
-0.352758526802063,
0.04469121992588043,
0.3015371263027191,
-0.7646344304084778,
-0.037175778299570084,
0.16815395653247833,
-0.26840025186538696,
-0.41064393520355225,
0.24678221344947815,
0.9330781698226929,
0.38045960664749146,
-0.5690677165985107,
0.20204433798789978,
-0.1472892016172409,
-0.39303863048553467,
-0.33469611406326294,
0.25452062487602234,
-0.13243363797664642,
0.5498086810112,
0.2745703458786011,
-0.09464117139577866,
-0.11226283758878708,
-0.29181724786758423,
0.012328688986599445,
0.6288183927536011,
-0.32925477623939514,
-0.24587881565093994,
0.6930747032165527,
0.4331989884376526,
-0.3098300099372864,
0.7075966000556946,
-0.17040863633155823,
-0.21686401963233948,
0.6122501492500305,
0.25323599576950073,
0.7874395847320557,
-0.10956238210201263,
0.05721813440322876,
0.5338811278343201,
0.5494608879089355,
-0.5235423445701599,
0.059421390295028687,
0.052113018929958344,
-0.6932763457298279,
-0.5093128085136414,
-0.7333369851112366,
-0.16282621026039124,
0.47284457087516785,
-0.7931445837020874,
0.22174328565597534,
-0.9500711560249329,
-0.4000999629497528,
-0.12729117274284363,
0.5394560098648071,
-0.6037166118621826,
0.23616497218608856,
0.21878688037395477,
0.8773273229598999,
-0.6811923384666443,
0.9289819598197937,
0.25221917033195496,
-0.20433303713798523,
-0.8567414283752441,
0.021563787013292313,
0.00552463810890913,
-0.8408566117286682,
0.4890916049480438,
-0.06838090717792511,
-0.2024194747209549,
0.28719332814216614,
-0.6281973123550415,
-0.8967454433441162,
1.1496297121047974,
0.8572328686714172,
-0.8544915318489075,
0.10572482645511627,
-0.11667152494192123,
0.4631744921207428,
-0.33577629923820496,
0.0271446593105793,
0.7555859088897705,
0.3058360517024994,
0.10020038485527039,
-1.455722451210022,
-0.022474972531199455,
0.2837081849575043,
-0.17630541324615479,
0.7189769148826599,
-0.6291916370391846,
1.1021313667297363,
-0.6002843976020813,
-0.16810612380504608,
0.030582493171095848,
0.7473840117454529,
0.10363896936178207,
0.19564485549926758,
0.6585245132446289,
0.5318703651428223,
0.9580200910568237,
0.23664085566997528,
0.8545401096343994,
-0.32546767592430115,
0.6374449133872986,
1.2412441968917847,
-0.19635739922523499,
0.9878301024436951,
0.4447162449359894,
-0.28481101989746094,
0.2355637550354004,
0.7643046379089355,
-0.043782904744148254,
0.6204797625541687,
0.3200139105319977,
-0.15159697830677032,
-0.6503387689590454,
0.023674122989177704,
-0.26091518998146057,
0.2926441431045532,
0.10729708522558212,
-0.46314021944999695,
-0.17192159593105316,
-0.18268460035324097,
-0.033961910754442215,
0.012513822875916958,
-0.9180965423583984,
0.7883718013763428,
0.1910092681646347,
-0.5274335145950317,
0.7718026638031006,
-0.2501527667045593,
0.5816375017166138,
-0.5456122756004333,
0.3204689621925354,
-0.1479293704032898,
0.17016424238681793,
-0.18790127336978912,
-0.7660592198371887,
-0.003121820976957679,
-0.13307537138462067,
-0.3783037066459656,
-0.31882476806640625,
0.3810231387615204,
-0.4377211034297943,
-0.3813442587852478,
0.22331978380680084,
0.206266388297081,
0.06131059303879738,
-0.1526038646697998,
-0.45276033878326416,
-0.10776122659444809,
0.2659468352794647,
-0.13028421998023987,
0.6105879545211792,
0.5162161588668823,
0.23980526626110077,
0.9416956305503845,
0.5769028067588806,
0.5853957533836365,
-0.16730032861232758,
-0.04296906292438507,
0.6460247039794922,
-0.5353878140449524,
-0.46718689799308777,
-0.916894793510437,
0.06864926218986511,
0.10616900026798248,
-0.3087858557701111,
0.2026277780532837,
0.4228008985519409,
0.9336816668510437,
0.16535888612270355,
0.620186448097229,
0.27470600605010986,
0.4743640720844269,
-0.7260078191757202,
0.8459751605987549,
-0.8875133395195007,
0.3024519085884094,
0.12585407495498657,
-0.813458263874054,
-0.14426854252815247,
0.46995115280151367,
-0.3829388916492462,
0.08763870596885681,
0.5080830454826355,
0.8187276721000671,
-0.19186770915985107,
-0.04553057253360748,
0.6025573015213013,
0.4452858567237854,
0.0993521586060524,
0.481472373008728,
0.30372217297554016,
0.09110632538795471,
0.6945501565933228,
-0.02771141193807125,
-0.30962875485420227,
-0.40639016032218933,
-1.0066829919815063,
-0.7383608818054199,
-0.7215991020202637,
-0.249352365732193,
-0.3081955909729004,
-0.4476802945137024,
1.07744300365448,
0.8183081150054932,
-0.6255215406417847,
-0.33288073539733887,
-0.20001143217086792,
0.0695742592215538,
-0.0432642325758934,
-0.057930056005716324,
-0.12666530907154083,
-0.5401524901390076,
-0.5859912037849426,
0.06229475513100624,
0.02901637926697731,
0.15915794670581818,
-0.29003024101257324,
-0.17605465650558472,
0.19308218359947205,
0.13100479543209076,
0.5171598196029663,
0.5735085606575012,
-0.5436347723007202,
-0.09291606396436691,
-0.4974270164966583,
-0.13297703862190247,
-0.006427451502531767,
1.1805487871170044,
-0.37914466857910156,
0.43072256445884705,
0.20399291813373566,
0.6504175662994385,
0.6667796969413757,
-0.5020287036895752,
0.6099944114685059,
-0.7213079333305359,
0.06714212149381638,
0.18874876201152802,
0.5264248251914978,
0.1828891485929489,
-0.28588220477104187,
0.3084926903247833,
-0.09391949325799942,
-0.9615222215652466,
-0.8582898378372192,
0.5791550278663635,
-0.6999445557594299,
-0.5510020852088928,
1.2795428037643433,
0.13132956624031067,
-0.1440402716398239,
0.07046578824520111,
-0.2931588888168335,
0.31842041015625,
-0.26790493726730347,
0.8850200176239014,
0.6767006516456604,
0.025634653866291046,
-0.31806620955467224,
-0.6819148659706116,
0.7802785634994507,
0.5820757150650024,
-0.4463711380958557,
0.5998444557189941,
0.5043204426765442,
0.3827245235443115,
0.05767546966671944,
0.43282172083854675,
0.2728337347507477,
0.0036086193285882473,
-0.42264682054519653,
-0.05152680724859238,
-0.023214980959892273,
-0.09168633073568344,
-0.4185435175895691,
0.15679100155830383,
0.4935552477836609,
0.0240597166121006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02309v1 | Jailbreaking Attack against Multimodal Large Language Model | 2024-02-04T01:29:24 | 2024-02-04T01:29:24 | Zhenxing Niu, Haodong Ren, Xinbo Gao, Gang Hua, Rong Jin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV | This paper focuses on jailbreaking attacks against multi-modal large language
models (MLLMs), seeking to elicit MLLMs to generate objectionable responses to
harmful user queries. A maximum likelihood-based algorithm is proposed to find
an \emph{image Jailbreaking Prompt} (imgJP), enabling jailbreaks against MLLMs
across multiple unseen prompts and images (i.e., data-universal property). Our
approach exhibits strong model-transferability, as the generated imgJP can be
transferred to jailbreak various models, including MiniGPT-v2, LLaVA,
InstructBLIP, and mPLUG-Owl2, in a black-box manner. Moreover, we reveal a
connection between MLLM-jailbreaks and LLM-jailbreaks. As a result, we
introduce a construction-based method to harness our approach for
LLM-jailbreaks, demonstrating greater efficiency than current state-of-the-art
methods. The code is available here. \textbf{Warning: some content generated by
language models may be offensive to some readers.} | [
-0.33324164152145386,
-1.2613743543624878,
0.43084391951560974,
0.3155490756034851,
-0.23551468551158905,
-0.01075347512960434,
-0.16055865585803986,
-0.6184607148170471,
0.044542886316776276,
0.7789687514305115,
-0.467047780752182,
-0.37457597255706787,
-0.5750837922096252,
0.05799693986773491,
-0.3437296450138092,
0.753434956073761,
0.2239408642053604,
-0.08891633152961731,
0.06390386074781418,
-0.15493611991405487,
-0.602698802947998,
-0.7350512146949768,
-0.4690534472465515,
0.21230711042881012,
0.5858300924301147,
0.12316539138555527,
0.7229148149490356,
0.30712631344795227,
0.3821999430656433,
0.2789548635482788,
-0.13148340582847595,
0.08930699527263641,
-0.3645302355289459,
0.4732184410095215,
-0.04778457060456276,
-0.33236050605773926,
-0.24162298440933228,
-0.22478149831295013,
0.3341861367225647,
0.01815934292972088,
0.019668182358145714,
-0.02899593487381935,
-0.047564517706632614,
0.5817527174949646,
-0.8637889623641968,
-0.09605143964290619,
-1.0908339023590088,
0.11700660735368729,
-0.42357954382896423,
-0.1368975192308426,
-0.9496984481811523,
0.07392028719186783,
-0.39146888256073,
-0.16307204961776733,
-0.1662648469209671,
0.46647244691848755,
0.5928425192832947,
0.04026511311531067,
-0.5340699553489685,
-0.3758253753185272,
-0.3559570908546448,
0.6116689443588257,
-0.8762586712837219,
0.17839719355106354,
0.399652361869812,
0.30829834938049316,
-0.47899648547172546,
-0.3398975133895874,
-0.5081143379211426,
-0.7446184158325195,
0.06801736354827881,
-0.2701417803764343,
-0.4499768614768982,
0.2033778578042984,
0.5527055263519287,
-0.02767202816903591,
-0.6742398738861084,
0.2621768116950989,
-0.33172038197517395,
-0.21557484567165375,
0.49753355979919434,
0.18207542598247528,
0.5111312866210938,
-0.4676186740398407,
-0.5453838109970093,
0.1622118353843689,
-1.0365781784057617,
-0.05845068395137787,
0.483999103307724,
0.319438099861145,
-0.24235597252845764,
0.8273754119873047,
0.14634010195732117,
0.9529992341995239,
-0.1376645863056183,
-0.30038025975227356,
0.04270252212882042,
-0.2506507635116577,
-0.1411069631576538,
-0.15243250131607056,
0.991917073726654,
0.4341171383857727,
0.3093744218349457,
-0.14781415462493896,
-0.22142165899276733,
-0.3802641034126282,
0.07542639225721359,
-0.9711434245109558,
-0.035876765847206116,
0.33835405111312866,
-0.5836959481239319,
-0.5276086330413818,
-0.0032590809278190136,
-0.953174352645874,
-0.847902774810791,
0.25990593433380127,
0.31543537974357605,
-0.466164767742157,
-0.11209852248430252,
-0.11050470173358917,
0.027380140498280525,
0.28005537390708923,
0.21063607931137085,
-0.9973413348197937,
-0.11878529191017151,
0.5139657855033875,
0.8523109555244446,
0.18092083930969238,
-0.2504473030567169,
-0.5750966668128967,
0.3566543161869049,
0.15632441639900208,
0.6002435684204102,
-0.5739343166351318,
-0.4335710108280182,
0.04441896826028824,
0.04762483388185501,
-0.10283476114273071,
-0.5303113460540771,
0.46494707465171814,
-0.7211458086967468,
-0.0380234457552433,
0.10272174328565598,
-0.5084180235862732,
-0.1327883005142212,
0.48952943086624146,
-0.8658919334411621,
0.4707898795604706,
-0.2965667247772217,
-0.8864060640335083,
0.026271432638168335,
-0.839152455329895,
-0.35214415192604065,
-0.37170764803886414,
-0.002191411331295967,
-0.4425961375236511,
0.10262901335954666,
0.4710417091846466,
0.552230715751648,
-0.14728741347789764,
0.20503003895282745,
-0.8172631859779358,
-0.006386682391166687,
0.5187547206878662,
-0.7555562853813171,
1.1032217741012573,
0.6291800737380981,
-0.2296922653913498,
0.19354553520679474,
-0.6629029512405396,
-0.2713215947151184,
0.5938467979431152,
-0.16095533967018127,
-0.5919675230979919,
0.04018494114279747,
0.34017685055732727,
0.3160347044467926,
0.35392361879348755,
-0.7458097338676453,
0.664406955242157,
-0.17601582407951355,
0.4600527584552765,
0.8497845530509949,
0.015182636678218842,
0.043667469173669815,
0.01023899856954813,
0.5049453973770142,
-0.1160556897521019,
0.4680018126964569,
-0.5244041681289673,
-0.5352804064750671,
-0.09137731790542603,
-0.34461086988449097,
0.18518541753292084,
0.7715231776237488,
-0.6084337830543518,
0.1237538531422615,
0.32357147336006165,
-0.48425543308258057,
-0.3918416202068329,
0.3175468146800995,
0.4658789336681366,
0.24346764385700226,
0.32611075043678284,
-0.02535420097410679,
-0.487602174282074,
-0.8593969345092773,
-0.4598155617713928,
-0.11239459365606308,
0.15354114770889282,
0.29362958669662476,
0.5002161860466003,
-0.27625077962875366,
0.4768107533454895,
-0.3807527720928192,
-0.10927753150463104,
-0.25109782814979553,
-0.10432931780815125,
0.2482057809829712,
0.6232777237892151,
1.0538290739059448,
-0.734973132610321,
-0.400546133518219,
-0.3260924816131592,
-0.9542456269264221,
-0.1381455361843109,
-0.2531818747520447,
0.09516706317663193,
0.21956156194210052,
0.6627175807952881,
-0.8253912925720215,
0.37412914633750916,
0.697532057762146,
-0.8876422047615051,
0.9275273680686951,
-0.11322267353534698,
0.22476789355278015,
-1.1644264459609985,
-0.14847789704799652,
0.08779919892549515,
-0.26348090171813965,
-0.5403863191604614,
0.6547548770904541,
0.08956471085548401,
-0.2665356993675232,
-0.6180134415626526,
0.620650053024292,
-0.47653260827064514,
0.01821126602590084,
-0.2743493616580963,
-0.18685972690582275,
-0.1685962826013565,
0.3525761067867279,
-0.37627315521240234,
0.6689512133598328,
0.4898136258125305,
-0.00328432978130877,
0.6126914620399475,
0.09901944547891617,
-0.23528072237968445,
0.36677026748657227,
-0.5727241039276123,
0.2203742265701294,
-0.059936072677373886,
0.11030865460634232,
-0.8913373947143555,
-0.1630593240261078,
0.42325299978256226,
-0.41655433177948,
0.4460046887397766,
-0.6231065392494202,
-0.7794555425643921,
-0.14629028737545013,
-0.3926755487918854,
0.26023295521736145,
0.18049825727939606,
-0.6933202743530273,
0.5164257884025574,
0.2426789104938507,
-0.21832598745822906,
-0.6852051615715027,
-0.4923195242881775,
0.5627142190933228,
-0.40882059931755066,
-0.8354249596595764,
0.013660336844623089,
-0.20460838079452515,
-0.46649786829948425,
-0.1899123191833496,
0.3453041911125183,
-0.07066808640956879,
0.3497367203235626,
0.30370840430259705,
0.4577816128730774,
-0.1335880309343338,
-0.18887567520141602,
0.030706079676747322,
0.06345345079898834,
0.17133043706417084,
-0.0548807717859745,
0.7295362949371338,
-0.23451583087444305,
-0.6220722198486328,
-0.2966676950454712,
0.48645076155662537,
1.024422526359558,
-0.33897221088409424,
1.012425184249878,
0.421522319316864,
-0.16616329550743103,
0.032189130783081055,
-0.5247616171836853,
-0.26473718881607056,
-0.4796254634857178,
0.4632894694805145,
-0.5229186415672302,
-1.0519208908081055,
0.5565263628959656,
0.0430765226483345,
0.23664726316928864,
0.04016457870602608,
0.6152202486991882,
-0.09818745404481888,
1.342612862586975,
0.5315239429473877,
-0.3679172694683075,
0.6032109260559082,
0.12115959823131561,
0.07592795044183731,
-0.6581118702888489,
-0.19034630060195923,
-0.4086894989013672,
-0.07179686427116394,
-0.5567983984947205,
-0.1911427229642868,
0.13415245711803436,
0.23103205859661102,
-0.10130574554204941,
0.3603818118572235,
-0.2332606017589569,
0.5270839929580688,
0.26918935775756836,
0.13412217795848846,
0.3667469620704651,
0.03228851407766342,
-0.3074931800365448,
-0.003011621069163084,
-0.4691081941127777,
-0.3342556059360504,
1.3790429830551147,
0.41599708795547485,
1.1003443002700806,
0.4649420380592346,
0.46470195055007935,
0.5203457474708557,
0.28595834970474243,
-0.6935387253761292,
0.45978811383247375,
-0.004618712235242128,
-0.8775478601455688,
-0.11893582344055176,
-0.30550238490104675,
-0.8593927621841431,
0.7254434823989868,
-0.4035674035549164,
-1.07038414478302,
-0.15285731852054596,
0.2795674502849579,
-0.0718250423669815,
0.7912469506263733,
-0.7746179699897766,
0.9973925948143005,
-0.4242980182170868,
-0.40691325068473816,
-0.3081587553024292,
-0.7041018009185791,
0.8417032361030579,
-0.1948641687631607,
0.5700451135635376,
-0.1905013769865036,
0.27330970764160156,
0.33077487349510193,
-0.5738230347633362,
0.8455833196640015,
-0.562161386013031,
-0.12040441483259201,
0.12860003113746643,
0.38744571805000305,
0.7342237234115601,
0.21312399208545685,
0.056532420217990875,
-0.05907192826271057,
-0.0963120386004448,
-0.5186248421669006,
-0.6492664217948914,
0.6377720832824707,
-0.4741513729095459,
-0.7571386694908142,
-0.115750752389431,
-0.7111883759498596,
-0.0013773053651675582,
-0.01749011129140854,
0.17867018282413483,
0.4416690170764923,
-0.007425116840749979,
0.1084028035402298,
0.5181708335876465,
-0.3347460627555847,
0.5196201205253601,
0.4375878870487213,
-0.6353818774223328,
-0.3483792841434479,
0.7227906584739685,
-0.19713857769966125,
0.34980764985084534,
0.20901939272880554,
0.0958312526345253,
-0.19256269931793213,
-0.8293031454086304,
-0.6442601084709167,
0.029293242841959,
-0.6466566920280457,
-0.1872396320104599,
-0.5017353296279907,
-0.13979770243167877,
-0.32386863231658936,
-0.12572962045669556,
-0.3107515275478363,
-0.43781471252441406,
0.02525600604712963,
0.06336110085248947,
0.4697239100933075,
0.4156258702278137,
-0.04470488429069519,
0.29378288984298706,
-1.1269251108169556,
0.3883673846721649,
0.31529656052589417,
-0.10726702958345413,
0.0346602126955986,
-0.6804636120796204,
0.02455367147922516,
-0.12255018949508667,
-0.2770633399486542,
-1.2808023691177368,
0.3253059685230255,
-0.042307835072278976,
0.46088483929634094,
0.6612039804458618,
0.14929728209972382,
0.4004344642162323,
-0.5913951992988586,
0.5824136734008789,
0.4266449511051178,
-0.824716329574585,
0.711714506149292,
-0.511997640132904,
0.10446521639823914,
0.4402734935283661,
0.03556890785694122,
-0.4781394302845001,
-0.7500900626182556,
-0.4367898106575012,
-0.9289000630378723,
0.2770334482192993,
0.10049400478601456,
0.5026966333389282,
0.11097688227891922,
0.17938651144504547,
-0.01481700036674738,
0.20352047681808472,
-1.322755217552185,
-0.4091208577156067,
-0.04047948122024536,
0.007487397640943527,
0.44710150361061096,
-0.5640285611152649,
-0.21113890409469604,
-0.29366305470466614,
0.5507217645645142,
-0.0041417088359594345,
0.11532683670520782,
-0.10499917715787888,
-0.5295404195785522,
0.16873450577259064,
0.675401508808136,
0.6626024842262268,
0.6665995121002197,
-0.26684021949768066,
0.1627970039844513,
0.010237973183393478,
-0.4559708833694458,
0.288719117641449,
0.22085951268672943,
-0.4009624123573303,
-0.11208838224411011,
0.3868181109428406,
0.8371300101280212,
-0.012090417556464672,
-0.9960482716560364,
0.6923831701278687,
-0.11067325621843338,
0.12322854995727539,
-0.4031637907028198,
-0.09518362581729889,
-0.19817519187927246,
0.4709889590740204,
0.3187818229198456,
0.12759846448898315,
-0.04214083403348923,
-0.558016836643219,
0.218373641371727,
0.7170191407203674,
-0.4034256041049957,
-0.23825860023498535,
0.7515597939491272,
-0.0015536551363766193,
-0.08282491564750671,
0.6787446737289429,
-0.10766597837209702,
-0.4340027868747711,
0.6001584529876709,
1.042892336845398,
0.8091880679130554,
-0.34428146481513977,
-0.02430659532546997,
0.18244652450084686,
0.7608616948127747,
0.38481539487838745,
0.23384630680084229,
0.09299012273550034,
-0.8043544292449951,
-0.5605227947235107,
-0.43671417236328125,
-0.26746055483818054,
0.25968798995018005,
-0.41976648569107056,
0.29424333572387695,
-0.7494603991508484,
-0.06309117376804352,
-0.03270941600203514,
-0.6537378430366516,
-0.11268282681703568,
-0.2665424942970276,
0.47767186164855957,
0.8858332633972168,
-0.6553339958190918,
1.0403964519500732,
0.6208819150924683,
-0.25442057847976685,
-0.459172785282135,
-0.16246972978115082,
0.4308328628540039,
-0.7695989608764648,
0.5746276378631592,
0.33637696504592896,
0.06692235916852951,
-0.21986113488674164,
-0.998921275138855,
-0.6475985050201416,
0.6543675661087036,
0.5304343104362488,
-0.6142326593399048,
-0.017363302409648895,
-0.23469382524490356,
-0.07410852611064911,
-0.3388478457927704,
0.053467754274606705,
0.4294891655445099,
0.5951513648033142,
-0.09121964871883392,
-0.8555276393890381,
0.24031047523021698,
-0.3386942148208618,
-0.3032153844833374,
0.30594703555107117,
-0.4101406931877136,
0.9040164351463318,
-0.7310826182365417,
0.06414410471916199,
0.3056650757789612,
0.4710503816604614,
0.7701497077941895,
0.2424125075340271,
0.6226351857185364,
0.7129461765289307,
0.4876219630241394,
0.10445767641067505,
1.0560072660446167,
-0.30263927578926086,
0.41958802938461304,
1.1381200551986694,
-0.07888246327638626,
0.807450532913208,
0.7910237908363342,
-0.0833635926246643,
0.408936470746994,
0.3187127411365509,
-0.5216463208198547,
0.5555638074874878,
0.3392185866832733,
-0.3986138701438904,
-0.1805041879415512,
0.10943877696990967,
-0.3929438889026642,
0.6584979891777039,
0.5038163065910339,
-0.5731915831565857,
-0.2755122780799866,
0.5171117186546326,
0.6353875994682312,
-0.007621482014656067,
-0.3884734809398651,
0.5847654938697815,
0.1082940623164177,
-0.19148743152618408,
0.6504675149917603,
0.490886390209198,
0.865894615650177,
-0.6725869178771973,
0.02831299416720867,
0.14197438955307007,
-0.11076569557189941,
-0.18169263005256653,
-0.6594582200050354,
0.17229731380939484,
0.3359733521938324,
-0.08274128288030624,
-0.0007749156793579459,
0.9876471757888794,
-0.21910367906093597,
-0.3047868013381958,
0.5552841424942017,
0.5198761224746704,
0.01976339891552925,
-0.26401272416114807,
-0.9714599251747131,
0.07179496437311172,
0.20589418709278107,
-0.5434041023254395,
0.6001391410827637,
-0.006676706485450268,
0.04373355209827423,
0.7072586417198181,
0.9460520148277283,
-0.12572848796844482,
0.29854029417037964,
0.07160170376300812,
0.9005677700042725,
-0.8311512470245361,
-0.3075449764728546,
-1.3956736326217651,
0.5343083143234253,
-0.14652298390865326,
0.07469884306192398,
0.8103293180465698,
0.503196120262146,
0.6281217932701111,
-0.12202306091785431,
0.9333214163780212,
-0.42590460181236267,
0.021896932274103165,
-0.9797973036766052,
0.8805330395698547,
-0.43084046244621277,
0.5233690738677979,
-0.4680652916431427,
-0.8639742732048035,
-0.360082745552063,
0.2827238440513611,
-0.3153090476989746,
-0.22133447229862213,
0.5090128183364868,
0.9655434489250183,
-0.019021103158593178,
-0.06938383728265762,
0.5046513676643372,
0.40372776985168457,
0.5120493173599243,
0.6043526530265808,
1.223436951637268,
-0.10109242051839828,
0.6363425850868225,
-0.1267925202846527,
-0.16963401436805725,
-0.21818837523460388,
-0.8169710040092468,
-1.0418236255645752,
-0.32689160108566284,
0.06815378367900848,
-0.615960955619812,
0.14035117626190186,
1.0180230140686035,
0.5465914011001587,
-0.8243724703788757,
-0.23304657638072968,
0.2998945415019989,
0.31873491406440735,
0.11499796062707901,
-0.23533406853675842,
0.18760956823825836,
-0.253769189119339,
-0.4668009579181671,
0.5917473435401917,
0.3339669108390808,
0.13468214869499207,
-0.2746642231941223,
0.08826135098934174,
-0.24783377349376678,
-0.07085158675909042,
0.865564227104187,
0.43919020891189575,
-0.8840315341949463,
-0.21963605284690857,
-0.25303635001182556,
-0.08094358444213867,
0.0919874832034111,
0.8529805541038513,
-0.4403488039970398,
0.520093560218811,
0.2071799486875534,
0.5474143624305725,
0.37142884731292725,
-0.18004268407821655,
0.3564043641090393,
-0.8293197154998779,
0.6957197189331055,
0.047814399003982544,
0.7576711177825928,
0.18378621339797974,
-0.39894524216651917,
0.19306182861328125,
0.35952243208885193,
-0.32611241936683655,
-0.8211219906806946,
0.5528777837753296,
-0.8912373781204224,
-0.7380733489990234,
1.061238169670105,
-0.22089803218841553,
-0.22765886783599854,
-0.21883805096149445,
-0.3757367432117462,
-0.3401288688182831,
-0.49234625697135925,
0.7051393389701843,
0.5086368322372437,
-0.1361205279827118,
-0.4758434295654297,
-0.9231996536254883,
0.20300064980983734,
0.09234879165887833,
-0.929890513420105,
0.2314682900905609,
0.7325332164764404,
0.2351275533437729,
0.08813497424125671,
0.29775381088256836,
-0.5356168150901794,
0.22391262650489807,
-0.09064217656850815,
0.18663659691810608,
-0.3939814865589142,
-0.3032025396823883,
-0.43377912044525146,
0.6178986430168152,
0.2659027874469757,
0.0475786030292511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05121v1 | Large Language Model for Table Processing: A Survey | 2024-02-04T00:47:53 | 2024-02-04T00:47:53 | Weizheng Lu, Jiaming Zhang, Jing Zhang, Yueguo Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Tables, typically two-dimensional and structured to store large amounts of
data, are essential in daily activities like database queries, spreadsheet
calculations, and generating reports from web tables. Automating these
table-centric tasks with Large Language Models (LLMs) offers significant public
benefits, garnering interest from academia and industry. This survey provides
an extensive overview of table tasks, encompassing not only the traditional
areas like table question answering (Table QA) and fact verification, but also
newly emphasized aspects such as table manipulation and advanced table data
analysis. Additionally, it goes beyond the early strategies of pre-training and
fine-tuning small language models, to include recent paradigms in LLM usage.
The focus here is particularly on instruction-tuning, prompting, and
agent-based approaches within the realm of LLMs. Finally, we highlight several
challenges, ranging from private deployment and efficient inference to the
development of extensive benchmarks for table manipulation and advanced data
analysis. | [
-0.29129353165626526,
-1.1913599967956543,
0.6971231698989868,
0.05949658900499344,
0.14200818538665771,
-0.10829313844442368,
-0.28418847918510437,
-0.6507186889648438,
-0.05428127944469452,
0.7247439622879028,
-0.40042829513549805,
-0.6539883017539978,
-0.4922236502170563,
-0.08461938053369522,
-0.6833178997039795,
0.731512188911438,
-0.09627174586057663,
0.03635667636990547,
-0.33924561738967896,
0.15161855518817902,
-0.4516873061656952,
-0.6149149537086487,
-0.6892454028129578,
-0.26167386770248413,
0.6468548774719238,
0.7421548962593079,
0.6837665438652039,
0.9733932614326477,
0.5090240836143494,
0.27120959758758545,
0.09931724518537521,
0.05342935398221016,
-0.38396474719047546,
0.35726359486579895,
-0.0908721461892128,
-0.5917169451713562,
-0.7500607967376709,
0.08826076239347458,
0.6810510158538818,
0.9685686826705933,
-0.2372705340385437,
0.33892109990119934,
-0.17258095741271973,
0.9255374073982239,
-0.31137144565582275,
0.7211313843727112,
-0.5547413229942322,
0.13649317622184753,
-0.4899294078350067,
0.17139258980751038,
-0.5188502073287964,
-0.5586176514625549,
-0.039884015917778015,
-0.18363144993782043,
0.0325021892786026,
0.1456950455904007,
0.25855302810668945,
0.09767219424247742,
-0.5425876379013062,
-0.29313138127326965,
-1.0545097589492798,
0.5847374796867371,
-0.49758267402648926,
0.7054688334465027,
0.48562684655189514,
0.3799601197242737,
-0.40343764424324036,
-0.8332332968711853,
-0.5815648436546326,
-0.4126492142677307,
-0.11920662969350815,
-0.33908966183662415,
-0.15626563131809235,
0.05592910945415497,
0.5504963397979736,
0.2372523695230484,
-0.6828721165657043,
0.45886531472206116,
-0.19144651293754578,
0.09207145869731903,
0.6840150952339172,
0.5502504110336304,
0.35073328018188477,
0.29955369234085083,
0.13651016354560852,
-0.16182029247283936,
-0.8934926986694336,
-0.02717709355056286,
0.09947312623262405,
0.1538805514574051,
0.03405002877116203,
0.72760409116745,
-0.39657577872276306,
1.0209447145462036,
-0.4833468794822693,
0.1929057091474533,
-0.27848127484321594,
-0.2603773772716522,
-0.1339244842529297,
-0.2857857644557953,
0.561441957950592,
0.17693491280078888,
0.1470586508512497,
-0.20490945875644684,
-0.3520810008049011,
0.0022510190028697252,
0.06299683451652527,
-0.5425421595573425,
-0.18430379033088684,
0.21363206207752228,
-0.31565508246421814,
0.04191109910607338,
-0.23871804773807526,
-1.0736143589019775,
-0.6320708394050598,
-0.5356078147888184,
0.23506800830364227,
0.17052611708641052,
-0.019071023911237717,
-0.09260856360197067,
0.31748244166374207,
0.5157299041748047,
0.4949304163455963,
-0.9948492646217346,
0.5759075880050659,
0.8788180351257324,
0.760552704334259,
-0.5374941825866699,
-0.14282017946243286,
-0.4661716818809509,
0.25878068804740906,
-0.46133777499198914,
0.8917403221130371,
-0.5491275787353516,
-0.35096678137779236,
0.20718637108802795,
0.023934287950396538,
0.029569800943136215,
-0.5414978861808777,
0.3125971853733063,
-0.6799785494804382,
0.022381318733096123,
-0.468943327665329,
-0.5098167061805725,
-0.07872385531663895,
0.4582616686820984,
-0.9372361302375793,
0.8860471248626709,
0.13480298221111298,
-0.3237903118133545,
0.19030843675136566,
-0.8297191858291626,
-0.6162052750587463,
-0.12295470386743546,
-0.17614829540252686,
-0.3663964867591858,
0.05378520488739014,
0.06355705857276917,
0.5629692673683167,
-0.717085599899292,
0.1507417857646942,
-0.04308280348777771,
-0.14773570001125336,
0.4185056686401367,
-0.23310516774654388,
0.36740705370903015,
0.19094038009643555,
-0.11893648654222488,
0.36599835753440857,
-0.6956264972686768,
-0.0213293619453907,
0.16015319526195526,
-0.4446848928928375,
0.153622105717659,
0.2848183810710907,
0.11092101782560349,
0.25830167531967163,
0.31922128796577454,
-0.3433127999305725,
0.47549498081207275,
-0.20158472657203674,
0.5416066646575928,
0.3117223083972931,
-0.17023371160030365,
0.5031308531761169,
-0.19239667057991028,
0.5195267200469971,
-0.09079301357269287,
0.19632790982723236,
0.06825213134288788,
-0.27163729071617126,
-0.7318713665008545,
0.09756577014923096,
0.3349458575248718,
0.6656835079193115,
-0.6796218156814575,
0.05477572977542877,
-0.07186049968004227,
-0.6226998567581177,
-0.07351046055555344,
0.1035572737455368,
0.1452937126159668,
0.38533610105514526,
0.2717970609664917,
-0.05831150338053703,
-0.5788676142692566,
-0.9721871614456177,
-0.1501675248146057,
-0.031662002205848694,
0.09227656573057175,
0.14940020442008972,
0.35496923327445984,
-0.15492932498455048,
0.8562441468238831,
-0.6396583914756775,
-0.26073428988456726,
-0.6186437606811523,
0.08001307398080826,
0.17738179862499237,
0.3885769844055176,
0.22536982595920563,
-0.5350251197814941,
-0.6927926540374756,
0.03705151751637459,
-0.6858517527580261,
-0.1653328686952591,
0.23184166848659515,
0.018691936507821083,
0.527148425579071,
0.7405115365982056,
-0.8918546438217163,
0.26664260029792786,
0.3957899808883667,
-0.09739281982183456,
0.3779146373271942,
-0.22024475038051605,
-0.06536949425935745,
-0.5854464173316956,
0.11552775651216507,
-0.05948528274893761,
-0.3708091676235199,
-0.8450292348861694,
0.19689857959747314,
0.02978237345814705,
-0.2981489300727844,
-0.3029773235321045,
0.5715307593345642,
-0.8141224980354309,
-0.49464935064315796,
-0.38418063521385193,
0.03778136521577835,
-0.3454894721508026,
0.3380427062511444,
0.20658017694950104,
0.7863671183586121,
0.37661418318748474,
-0.576088547706604,
0.5180480480194092,
0.1505579650402069,
-0.4591802656650543,
0.28889933228492737,
-0.6930864453315735,
0.3433913588523865,
-0.1514066904783249,
0.15796364843845367,
-1.0082623958587646,
-0.34475329518318176,
0.18926070630550385,
-0.00968848541378975,
0.48371556401252747,
0.011533557437360287,
-0.6749365925788879,
-0.4890492558479309,
-0.18630746006965637,
0.0512186698615551,
0.5470460057258606,
-0.23091568052768707,
0.5386087894439697,
0.8469945788383484,
-0.3137880265712738,
-0.46703290939331055,
-0.628341555595398,
0.21857313811779022,
-0.055161651223897934,
-0.3755646347999573,
0.011227686889469624,
0.0783485546708107,
-0.48900312185287476,
-0.1254541575908661,
-0.042168643325567245,
-0.1348731368780136,
0.07725661993026733,
0.17666329443454742,
0.1227649375796318,
-0.12819144129753113,
0.08782292157411575,
-0.19147895276546478,
-0.04992447420954704,
0.3214153051376343,
-0.029485419392585754,
0.8647739291191101,
-0.0250509325414896,
-0.22056198120117188,
-0.470981240272522,
0.3474966287612915,
0.5287714004516602,
-0.27979138493537903,
0.7320342659950256,
0.32273876667022705,
-0.43144044280052185,
-0.22032636404037476,
-0.6884896159172058,
-0.1827145665884018,
-0.40807774662971497,
0.6096894145011902,
-0.20672167837619781,
-0.8854140043258667,
0.6737467646598816,
0.0785091295838356,
0.35352620482444763,
0.326977401971817,
0.7658504843711853,
-0.01287486869841814,
1.1063166856765747,
0.5574712157249451,
-0.1665971577167511,
0.4166037440299988,
-0.14974386990070343,
0.12720730900764465,
-0.4564562439918518,
-0.21493609249591827,
-0.9710189700126648,
-0.3376534581184387,
-0.5013744831085205,
-0.5507072806358337,
0.3789191246032715,
-0.4308623671531677,
-0.22045616805553436,
0.1817822903394699,
-0.31876757740974426,
0.5838491320610046,
0.4727668762207031,
-0.18073828518390656,
0.46363741159439087,
-0.034125640988349915,
0.5011811256408691,
0.2545771598815918,
-0.5440140962600708,
-0.5894648432731628,
0.919818639755249,
0.46641963720321655,
0.9273720383644104,
0.027341030538082123,
0.3739011883735657,
0.33692413568496704,
0.42874038219451904,
-0.8777884840965271,
0.8282772898674011,
-0.15434487164020538,
-0.6483339667320251,
-0.7710677981376648,
-0.4241448640823364,
-1.0904242992401123,
0.15336863696575165,
-0.10317244380712509,
-0.7741580605506897,
-0.11512448638677597,
0.3139687180519104,
-0.06086602807044983,
0.15949568152427673,
-0.6336295008659363,
0.9887835383415222,
-0.17841596901416779,
-0.4280341565608978,
-0.3567858338356018,
-0.500198483467102,
0.3729109466075897,
-0.057862743735313416,
0.2948758900165558,
-0.09224621951580048,
-0.06317964941263199,
0.7760366797447205,
-0.3227355480194092,
0.7573007345199585,
-0.32962191104888916,
-0.2793271839618683,
0.36204004287719727,
0.3168792724609375,
0.7386937737464905,
0.02706906571984291,
-0.20574221014976501,
-0.02689334936439991,
0.20137588679790497,
-0.13480907678604126,
-0.5239623188972473,
0.636827290058136,
-0.6383295059204102,
-0.8028284311294556,
-0.4389459788799286,
-0.7964840531349182,
-0.4751488268375397,
0.03379533439874649,
-0.20361849665641785,
0.16471174359321594,
-0.26596617698669434,
0.21794454753398895,
0.6582198143005371,
-0.15618817508220673,
0.5135197043418884,
0.8303773999214172,
-0.39088061451911926,
0.011280837468802929,
0.6951141953468323,
0.3904721140861511,
-0.037127792835235596,
0.5489621758460999,
0.007067300379276276,
-0.4939877688884735,
-0.8345997929573059,
-0.45808789134025574,
0.07682476192712784,
-0.4714605212211609,
-0.16838784515857697,
-0.7568417191505432,
-0.22529800236225128,
-0.19084936380386353,
0.1705850213766098,
-0.35616230964660645,
-0.5013994574546814,
-0.14075089991092682,
-0.14190226793289185,
0.3675486147403717,
1.0181483030319214,
0.1312142014503479,
0.43789201974868774,
-0.8134137988090515,
0.24269159138202667,
0.6145059466362,
0.5207915902137756,
0.22259508073329926,
-0.20788726210594177,
-0.3551594614982605,
-0.12328015267848969,
-0.024019373580813408,
-0.9273058772087097,
0.3350575268268585,
0.044092316180467606,
0.619339644908905,
-0.07622604817152023,
-0.2556840181350708,
0.26202547550201416,
-0.5824394822120667,
0.7700293660163879,
-0.20359884202480316,
-0.8122951984405518,
0.2954893112182617,
-0.3431161046028137,
0.22012054920196533,
0.45380890369415283,
0.36894914507865906,
-0.7734322547912598,
-0.08168544620275497,
0.007649350445717573,
-0.8040717244148254,
0.9025757312774658,
-0.22875717282295227,
0.10801274329423904,
0.08610693365335464,
0.40898656845092773,
0.1323491930961609,
0.3231750726699829,
-0.7721386551856995,
-0.06487981975078583,
0.35969653725624084,
-0.1347501128911972,
-0.08708327263593674,
-0.4531172513961792,
0.010928211733698845,
-0.19341911375522614,
0.5439793467521667,
0.04513062909245491,
0.16058701276779175,
-0.24385575950145721,
-0.36524075269699097,
-0.30169597268104553,
0.4917231500148773,
0.5780077576637268,
0.9022085666656494,
0.03213462606072426,
0.1282462775707245,
0.2844464182853699,
-0.4623721241950989,
0.16564485430717468,
0.1048470288515091,
-0.10326991975307465,
-0.31521379947662354,
0.08578869700431824,
0.5608201026916504,
-0.09612521529197693,
-0.7092766165733337,
0.1654810905456543,
-0.17284102737903595,
-0.011105593293905258,
-0.32443127036094666,
0.13917943835258484,
0.18220087885856628,
0.15148726105690002,
0.2457817643880844,
-0.7939862012863159,
0.22027993202209473,
-0.7998781800270081,
0.028474848717451096,
0.5863405466079712,
-0.30145490169525146,
-0.2663930356502533,
0.6391509771347046,
-0.046070825308561325,
-0.3437899649143219,
0.8624764680862427,
-0.07238530367612839,
-0.11752667278051376,
0.6407786011695862,
0.516589343547821,
0.5116755366325378,
-0.32316136360168457,
0.2030027061700821,
0.09048066288232803,
0.3805192708969116,
-0.3527105152606964,
0.6358091235160828,
0.14195935428142548,
-0.5029300451278687,
-0.5353358387947083,
-0.6393607258796692,
-0.7224660515785217,
0.32794925570487976,
-0.4078066647052765,
0.0876186266541481,
-0.3796122968196869,
-0.019190313294529915,
0.15508587658405304,
-0.019090186804533005,
-0.7049946188926697,
0.0535084493458271,
0.09665866196155548,
0.8565146327018738,
-0.7764601707458496,
1.0057950019836426,
0.735633134841919,
-0.26549047231674194,
-0.6770171523094177,
-0.5312315821647644,
-0.10330148041248322,
-0.6472064852714539,
0.5872716307640076,
-0.19215655326843262,
0.25468742847442627,
-0.051719360053539276,
-0.6578606367111206,
-0.8634136915206909,
0.7481008172035217,
0.34808725118637085,
-0.8167617321014404,
-0.2094036042690277,
0.7038620710372925,
0.7422005534172058,
-0.06863098591566086,
0.21852387487888336,
1.1706935167312622,
0.6853592991828918,
-0.24264837801456451,
-0.8874446749687195,
0.029995622113347054,
-0.028776872903108597,
-0.0004976455238647759,
0.39220041036605835,
-0.5242637991905212,
0.8588952422142029,
0.25462397933006287,
0.07308869808912277,
-0.09690829366445541,
0.664478063583374,
0.07665444165468216,
0.3178032338619232,
0.4779370129108429,
0.35377612709999084,
0.4019927680492401,
-0.21766363084316254,
0.7779757380485535,
-0.33411481976509094,
0.03513553366065025,
1.0889365673065186,
-0.7453226447105408,
0.7762023210525513,
0.2931133508682251,
-0.4323745667934418,
0.24198174476623535,
0.49799585342407227,
-0.035063017159700394,
-0.07373403757810593,
0.4238501191139221,
-0.024230586364865303,
-0.039448756724596024,
-0.07423031330108643,
-0.2771539092063904,
0.7540704607963562,
0.678922712802887,
-0.1263177990913391,
-0.3515799939632416,
-0.11374714970588684,
-0.0955849438905716,
0.06665216386318207,
-0.5931081771850586,
0.9427990913391113,
0.08197381347417831,
-0.6545252203941345,
0.07078676670789719,
0.10208114981651306,
0.12151718884706497,
-0.5690276622772217,
-0.2362237423658371,
-0.2772465646266937,
-0.15281446278095245,
-0.16144871711730957,
-0.9764106273651123,
0.49232953786849976,
0.07291907072067261,
-0.21114899218082428,
-0.372559517621994,
0.732396125793457,
-0.5107543468475342,
-0.14072810113430023,
-0.08873847872018814,
0.8361160159111023,
0.32027891278266907,
-0.14539845287799835,
-0.37068212032318115,
0.25533604621887207,
-0.3026522397994995,
-0.48421797156333923,
0.47290658950805664,
0.3213804364204407,
-0.398139625787735,
0.6493014693260193,
0.45350247621536255,
0.14423741400241852,
0.09032504260540009,
0.1935501992702484,
0.7704203128814697,
-0.9346136450767517,
-0.420939177274704,
-0.77842777967453,
0.20328505337238312,
0.10130295157432556,
0.21662186086177826,
0.6659653186798096,
0.7938915491104126,
0.5590635538101196,
-0.33635085821151733,
0.5372262597084045,
0.0011055173818022013,
0.6455444693565369,
-0.5935199856758118,
0.8000622391700745,
-0.22346341609954834,
0.1320401430130005,
-0.03572126850485802,
-1.2185114622116089,
-0.3071650564670563,
0.29211944341659546,
-0.5553461909294128,
-0.02521323785185814,
0.4627239406108856,
0.7756921052932739,
0.1958043873310089,
0.09109215438365936,
0.3239133954048157,
0.33420178294181824,
0.3303874433040619,
0.32862624526023865,
0.9235519766807556,
0.042181409895420074,
0.37428197264671326,
-0.09167298674583435,
0.06226052716374397,
-0.24297842383384705,
-0.6788057684898376,
-0.7117543816566467,
-0.5913920402526855,
-0.22320421040058136,
-0.08828933537006378,
-0.03494030237197876,
1.0293407440185547,
0.5492368340492249,
-0.9393730759620667,
-0.6766064167022705,
-0.1089453399181366,
0.1988471895456314,
-0.06009945273399353,
-0.19392387568950653,
0.4718104898929596,
-0.3403397798538208,
-0.8194081783294678,
0.4331882894039154,
0.2559839189052582,
0.10286843031644821,
-0.41869962215423584,
0.4256306290626526,
-0.13707475364208221,
-0.07227535545825958,
0.9294312000274658,
0.586758017539978,
-0.3222881555557251,
-0.10501346737146378,
0.05228721350431442,
-0.25673240423202515,
0.07626068592071533,
0.9194461107254028,
-0.5389615297317505,
0.08696422725915909,
0.6773593425750732,
0.6698986291885376,
0.7004873752593994,
-0.10830036550760269,
0.5568000674247742,
-0.5236473679542542,
0.07087056338787079,
0.26370179653167725,
0.2825436294078827,
0.221505269408226,
-0.40433451533317566,
0.5932158827781677,
-0.24436961114406586,
-0.8228785395622253,
-0.9397767186164856,
0.24787794053554535,
-0.9766897559165955,
-0.17227482795715332,
0.982833206653595,
0.2673202455043793,
-0.42439332604408264,
-0.24677437543869019,
-0.12851187586784363,
0.4363776743412018,
-0.20862501859664917,
0.9111180901527405,
0.6899718046188354,
-0.3547285497188568,
-0.44554051756858826,
-0.7742898464202881,
0.6554064750671387,
0.1337013840675354,
-1.343827724456787,
0.510456919670105,
0.8018509745597839,
0.09451029449701309,
-0.17468801140785217,
0.6093732118606567,
-0.25953927636146545,
0.19165824353694916,
-0.23028437793254852,
0.29493632912635803,
-0.09157825261354446,
-0.44617384672164917,
-0.42208215594291687,
0.38883060216903687,
0.5031555891036987,
0.23812322318553925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02302v1 | Predicting positive transfer for improved low-resource speech recognition using acoustic pseudo-tokens | 2024-02-03T23:54:03 | 2024-02-03T23:54:03 | Nay San, Georgios Paraskevopoulos, Aryaman Arora, Xiluo He, Prabhjot Kaur, Oliver Adams, Dan Jurafsky | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | While massively multilingual speech models like wav2vec 2.0 XLSR-128 can be
directly fine-tuned for automatic speech recognition (ASR), downstream
performance can still be relatively poor on languages that are
under-represented in the pre-training data. Continued pre-training on 70-200
hours of untranscribed speech in these languages can help -- but what about
languages without that much recorded data? For such cases, we show that
supplementing the target language with data from a similar, higher-resource
'donor' language can help. For example, continued pre-training on only 10 hours
of low-resource Punjabi supplemented with 60 hours of donor Hindi is almost as
good as continued pretraining on 70 hours of Punjabi. By contrast, sourcing
data from less similar donors like Bengali does not improve ASR performance. To
inform donor language selection, we propose a novel similarity metric based on
the sequence distribution of induced acoustic units: the Acoustic Token
Distribution Similarity (ATDS). Across a set of typologically different target
languages (Punjabi, Galician, Iban, Setswana), we show that the ATDS between
the target language and its candidate donors precisely predicts target language
ASR performance. | [
-0.3686560094356537,
0.10706807672977448,
0.06749960780143738,
-0.010286994278430939,
-0.5767330527305603,
0.1816912442445755,
-0.37689533829689026,
-0.8041794300079346,
0.2603749632835388,
0.12012262642383575,
-0.3479253053665161,
0.14165374636650085,
-0.5663713216781616,
0.24544961750507355,
-0.5053659677505493,
0.842536211013794,
0.19167861342430115,
0.2526497542858124,
0.11855131387710571,
-0.3766045868396759,
-0.38558149337768555,
-0.6367651224136353,
-0.9174644947052002,
-0.34228551387786865,
0.48247748613357544,
0.11327522248029709,
0.36529630422592163,
0.7093440294265747,
0.5065730214118958,
0.3034602999687195,
-0.1594572812318802,
-0.230542853474617,
-0.30673909187316895,
-0.41956475377082825,
-0.27633461356163025,
-0.4292067885398865,
-0.1459120512008667,
-0.07543468475341797,
0.762227475643158,
0.6839243769645691,
-0.19074341654777527,
0.3499471843242645,
0.3120397627353668,
0.2627728581428528,
-0.49286672472953796,
0.2253710925579071,
-0.7583876848220825,
0.09350266307592392,
-0.6358731985092163,
-0.23646092414855957,
-0.15289312601089478,
-0.3271592855453491,
0.29055628180503845,
-0.5439503192901611,
0.123385950922966,
-0.10127675533294678,
0.5974043011665344,
0.24289202690124512,
-0.08330037444829941,
-0.4343702793121338,
-0.8611651062965393,
0.8782457709312439,
-0.5718435645103455,
0.6491806507110596,
0.7579838633537292,
0.22368529438972473,
0.44476768374443054,
-0.4664597809314728,
-0.6132659912109375,
-0.09910309314727783,
-0.18816344439983368,
-0.04735906794667244,
-0.2215171456336975,
0.006379133556038141,
0.016440505161881447,
0.31535276770591736,
-0.3627265989780426,
0.16685083508491516,
-0.8719144463539124,
-0.7981142401695251,
0.4570099115371704,
-0.15926103293895721,
0.08889119327068329,
-0.2727939486503601,
-0.30228251218795776,
-0.30900323390960693,
-0.6544219851493835,
0.30117636919021606,
0.20027028024196625,
0.9594737887382507,
-0.35695260763168335,
0.4240921437740326,
0.29042983055114746,
0.734383225440979,
0.03714555874466896,
-0.264292448759079,
0.5188272595405579,
-0.8607524037361145,
0.23788873851299286,
0.6510711312294006,
0.6881131529808044,
-0.1844695657491684,
0.356889933347702,
0.00881529413163662,
-0.33982565999031067,
0.19173455238342285,
-0.13858161866664886,
-0.6489765644073486,
-0.1347150355577469,
-0.37803560495376587,
-0.718629002571106,
0.08497662097215652,
-0.019007086753845215,
-0.38374581933021545,
-0.17235758900642395,
-0.5916171669960022,
0.5443163514137268,
-0.39437320828437805,
-0.4101359248161316,
-0.036989543586969376,
-0.1051977351307869,
0.2544049620628357,
-0.0478055439889431,
-0.8404869437217712,
0.3096425533294678,
0.4469754695892334,
1.0780755281448364,
-0.15462146699428558,
-0.23844638466835022,
-0.9867298007011414,
0.17097057402133942,
-0.2753811180591583,
1.0072510242462158,
-0.6462387442588806,
-0.5895203948020935,
-0.03313235938549042,
-0.19713476300239563,
-0.13117319345474243,
-0.7604914307594299,
0.5053051114082336,
-0.20204377174377441,
0.06090041249990463,
-0.4313220977783203,
-0.370210736989975,
0.2008267194032669,
-0.23711654543876648,
-0.5883165001869202,
0.7345338463783264,
0.326621413230896,
-0.5700035095214844,
0.6089562773704529,
-0.5238977074623108,
-0.7068150043487549,
0.09281544387340546,
-0.1582489013671875,
-0.28480228781700134,
0.036483678966760635,
-0.039425209164619446,
0.1655537486076355,
-0.24678313732147217,
-0.12297937273979187,
-0.22221192717552185,
-0.5120034217834473,
0.16240020096302032,
-0.3840331435203552,
0.860799252986908,
0.5375004410743713,
-0.16230237483978271,
-0.05585682392120361,
-0.8949624300003052,
-0.012442518956959248,
-0.36219361424446106,
-0.46465060114860535,
-0.3470087945461273,
-0.2904525101184845,
0.25616034865379333,
0.3324625492095947,
0.012920798733830452,
-0.8066496253013611,
-0.20938560366630554,
-0.5451611876487732,
0.5297504663467407,
0.83343505859375,
-0.38094362616539,
0.44049304723739624,
-0.2778630256652832,
0.6361978650093079,
0.07278744876384735,
-0.03736695274710655,
0.14153188467025757,
-0.260588139295578,
-0.5001547932624817,
-0.4894125163555145,
0.5978643894195557,
0.44234251976013184,
-0.7070111036300659,
0.2707973122596741,
-0.2875160276889801,
-0.3234424591064453,
-1.0633562803268433,
0.1604301780462265,
0.7678346633911133,
0.7367430925369263,
0.4885988235473633,
-0.6311283707618713,
-0.8912469148635864,
-0.811009407043457,
-0.07380441576242447,
-0.7400684356689453,
-0.1106155514717102,
0.4630010426044464,
-0.21232683956623077,
-0.02390460856258869,
0.6714097857475281,
-0.06713483482599258,
-0.7854880094528198,
-0.2916231155395508,
0.08292606472969055,
0.17362293601036072,
0.4283410906791687,
0.7092210054397583,
-0.6148170232772827,
-0.5306950211524963,
0.06468988955020905,
-0.20981863141059875,
-0.10646028071641922,
-0.03706894814968109,
0.14949505031108856,
0.15118353068828583,
0.5687918663024902,
-0.3315746486186981,
0.26796552538871765,
0.5955127477645874,
-0.386274129152298,
0.4265108108520508,
-0.055905576795339584,
0.12497054785490036,
-0.9887290596961975,
0.11274781078100204,
-0.2700849771499634,
-0.08271107822656631,
-0.44313010573387146,
-0.6810007691383362,
-0.13520869612693787,
-0.25344857573509216,
-0.6521824598312378,
0.8655283451080322,
-0.2358759194612503,
-0.5049492716789246,
-0.25042611360549927,
-0.09302186965942383,
-0.5582659244537354,
0.10026765614748001,
0.21348978579044342,
1.18462336063385,
0.7415461540222168,
-0.5497327446937561,
0.2965833842754364,
0.4979161322116852,
-0.4097674489021301,
0.5840786099433899,
-0.6560562252998352,
0.15474967658519745,
0.2560812532901764,
0.18565325438976288,
-0.8792122602462769,
0.14891476929187775,
-0.09426732361316681,
-0.6745342016220093,
0.4169696867465973,
-0.2087995857000351,
-0.13567765057086945,
-0.3931690752506256,
-0.06887359917163849,
0.8295311331748962,
0.7283135652542114,
-0.5152397155761719,
0.4009256064891815,
0.44008633494377136,
-0.47308820486068726,
-0.3876660168170929,
-0.8182885646820068,
0.056107331067323685,
-0.403292715549469,
-0.1421893984079361,
0.2647262215614319,
-0.0033664440270513296,
-0.04204517602920532,
0.14795471727848053,
0.02527444250881672,
-0.14492499828338623,
-0.14567779004573822,
0.017272528260946274,
0.24975135922431946,
-0.43696311116218567,
0.06373419612646103,
-0.30893611907958984,
-0.3601996600627899,
-0.1869896799325943,
-0.5261886119842529,
0.3778221309185028,
0.077912837266922,
-0.34681564569473267,
-0.8379010558128357,
0.19005990028381348,
0.20070233941078186,
-0.3462695777416229,
0.5782392621040344,
0.811654269695282,
-0.3459143042564392,
0.2213590145111084,
-0.5164988040924072,
-0.2641754448413849,
-0.46914705634117126,
0.3264259696006775,
-0.5343462228775024,
-0.6396306753158569,
0.5537057518959045,
0.2905605137348175,
-0.2353198379278183,
0.33375823497772217,
0.47501856088638306,
-0.09917646646499634,
0.6060908436775208,
0.591020405292511,
-0.6432718634605408,
0.878425121307373,
-0.1209280714392662,
0.21516166627407074,
-0.6175394654273987,
-0.04120822623372078,
-0.8080861568450928,
-0.19825105369091034,
-0.6819775700569153,
-0.30617982149124146,
0.15097029507160187,
-0.13226264715194702,
0.10636572539806366,
0.597903847694397,
-0.30638933181762695,
0.3458439111709595,
0.5905581712722778,
-0.2279634177684784,
-0.023305634036660194,
0.21203671395778656,
0.17929372191429138,
-0.09676532447338104,
-0.6360576748847961,
-0.04818817228078842,
1.121568202972412,
-0.03934616968035698,
0.39844879508018494,
-0.019441889598965645,
0.8368096351623535,
0.501217246055603,
0.2850568890571594,
-0.5876328349113464,
0.29364925622940063,
-0.46147069334983826,
-0.4266541004180908,
-0.426060289144516,
-0.56252121925354,
-0.9820168614387512,
-0.15601499378681183,
-0.13265825808048248,
-0.567583441734314,
0.5132652521133423,
0.45130783319473267,
-0.5805969834327698,
0.20066799223423004,
-0.737239420413971,
0.28728845715522766,
-0.0825476348400116,
-0.09832806140184402,
-0.3412439227104187,
-0.5902417898178101,
-0.17608805000782013,
-0.5464776754379272,
0.34314993023872375,
0.15087078511714935,
0.18132007122039795,
1.0666208267211914,
-0.34361323714256287,
0.3798082172870636,
-0.46724608540534973,
0.10336244851350784,
0.4934684634208679,
-0.0697389543056488,
0.41945359110832214,
-0.3600407838821411,
-0.4913664758205414,
0.2992379069328308,
0.01532868854701519,
-0.38590219616889954,
-0.41173872351646423,
0.5449986457824707,
-0.9523495435714722,
-0.1585320383310318,
-0.2342638224363327,
-0.17743919789791107,
-0.31434547901153564,
0.15783625841140747,
0.4804335832595825,
0.6877416372299194,
0.10821579396724701,
0.2759474515914917,
0.22982707619667053,
-0.07462774962186813,
0.5060148239135742,
0.39385131001472473,
0.43389835953712463,
-0.3898452818393707,
1.2186833620071411,
0.3534744083881378,
0.24837921559810638,
0.2081458866596222,
0.33983054757118225,
-0.810173511505127,
-0.919702410697937,
-0.5109149813652039,
0.2684328556060791,
-0.38297557830810547,
-0.4387762248516083,
-0.43691760301589966,
-0.36336755752563477,
-0.5357621312141418,
-0.24311336874961853,
-0.601531445980072,
-0.5614503026008606,
-0.45880126953125,
-0.3136664927005768,
0.4392124116420746,
0.5658820271492004,
-0.7077518105506897,
0.1542520821094513,
-0.8467959761619568,
0.41661301255226135,
0.2795749008655548,
0.4156934320926666,
0.011471475474536419,
-1.227319359779358,
-0.3926878571510315,
0.12075229734182358,
0.23095886409282684,
-0.39813053607940674,
0.3322105407714844,
0.7708536386489868,
0.5037639141082764,
0.43869253993034363,
0.1028393879532814,
1.1342259645462036,
-0.6146806478500366,
0.685299813747406,
0.635480523109436,
-0.9959346652030945,
0.46730077266693115,
-0.1298515349626541,
-0.020991306751966476,
0.7057783603668213,
0.21516680717468262,
-0.38360172510147095,
-0.25203388929367065,
-0.4495621919631958,
-0.6974671483039856,
0.9285157322883606,
0.15906544029712677,
0.15820477902889252,
-0.010452485643327236,
0.2603529393672943,
0.21521851420402527,
0.06854613870382309,
-0.5706750154495239,
-0.19831836223602295,
-0.5149238109588623,
-0.28209537267684937,
-0.490615576505661,
-0.09114360064268112,
0.11890025436878204,
-0.45799362659454346,
0.5331352949142456,
0.029593149200081825,
0.37806397676467896,
0.10402645915746689,
-0.005690090823918581,
-0.2606724202632904,
0.19789855182170868,
0.47990667819976807,
0.4599052965641022,
-0.12360013276338577,
0.18305867910385132,
0.2925586700439453,
-0.5569606423377991,
0.4896070957183838,
0.4252977967262268,
0.2199038565158844,
-0.07962822914123535,
0.6304143667221069,
0.7393018007278442,
0.03409156575798988,
-0.5487571954727173,
0.5026494264602661,
-0.033133748918771744,
-0.05248333513736725,
-0.33331939578056335,
-0.053857654333114624,
0.024665622040629387,
0.17375057935714722,
0.44707807898521423,
0.08112677186727524,
0.2856764793395996,
-0.6800429821014404,
0.3996885418891907,
0.36387795209884644,
-0.6378030180931091,
-0.6817163825035095,
0.5263692736625671,
0.40546610951423645,
-0.7188770771026611,
0.8312337398529053,
-0.18464462459087372,
-0.3829382658004761,
0.4165213704109192,
0.6592409610748291,
0.7427200675010681,
-0.5856951475143433,
-0.08828935027122498,
0.5576975345611572,
0.017885610461235046,
-0.006787701975554228,
0.18934683501720428,
-0.37356844544410706,
-0.6133859753608704,
-0.46610966324806213,
-0.8373459577560425,
0.025365538895130157,
0.08324236422777176,
-0.9831332564353943,
0.41006195545196533,
-0.20588582754135132,
-0.1593436300754547,
0.08649912476539612,
-0.03775687888264656,
-0.8746099472045898,
0.091939277946949,
0.49304449558258057,
0.6886409521102905,
-0.961469292640686,
1.0138394832611084,
0.4851742088794708,
-0.21776603162288666,
-1.1275519132614136,
-0.26582491397857666,
0.036526359617710114,
-0.7873034477233887,
0.7407122254371643,
-0.11652113497257233,
-0.3169235289096832,
-0.033551570028066635,
0.21242080628871918,
-1.0904812812805176,
0.7884433269500732,
0.6306493878364563,
-0.8328840136528015,
0.07653636485338211,
0.2905519902706146,
0.6728511452674866,
-0.1946718394756317,
0.09630612283945084,
0.4944533407688141,
0.32552823424339294,
0.16025860607624054,
-1.5670591592788696,
-0.22027719020843506,
-0.14324963092803955,
-0.08710429817438126,
0.1864740401506424,
-0.36455971002578735,
0.6220571994781494,
-0.41262170672416687,
-0.28330478072166443,
0.1523088961839676,
0.5951569676399231,
0.22009065747261047,
0.25389364361763,
0.8072078227996826,
0.21885722875595093,
0.7281163334846497,
0.15228836238384247,
0.9424248337745667,
-0.17396973073482513,
-0.04623083397746086,
0.9207825660705566,
-0.2575750946998596,
1.023776650428772,
0.5439603924751282,
-0.42925402522087097,
0.12698067724704742,
0.5270732641220093,
0.13825932145118713,
0.914671003818512,
0.1337350308895111,
-0.21304619312286377,
-0.06577208638191223,
-0.5742073655128479,
-0.5978066921234131,
0.7989208698272705,
0.12264192849397659,
-0.21506483852863312,
0.08012229949235916,
0.3186144232749939,
-0.4469715654850006,
0.020667264237999916,
-0.4194372296333313,
1.0541117191314697,
0.19542837142944336,
-0.40410953760147095,
0.7655903697013855,
-0.5455342531204224,
0.8643636703491211,
-0.6698729395866394,
0.051015086472034454,
-0.2520541846752167,
0.18078432977199554,
-0.24115361273288727,
-0.5069600939750671,
0.5539902448654175,
0.027681926265358925,
-0.1944442093372345,
-0.3096463680267334,
0.6058009266853333,
-0.4995899200439453,
-0.5699205994606018,
0.5521288514137268,
0.46798986196517944,
0.3274484872817993,
0.3728967607021332,
-0.6355481743812561,
0.1515556424856186,
0.23947249352931976,
0.16051046550273895,
0.5806163549423218,
0.3663265109062195,
0.009362886659801006,
0.5323471426963806,
0.8590707182884216,
0.8963229060173035,
-0.018620982766151428,
0.21184255182743073,
0.7061702013015747,
-0.5031058192253113,
-0.8436164855957031,
-0.689683198928833,
0.0629677027463913,
0.26528751850128174,
-0.19532722234725952,
0.4317740499973297,
0.5988404750823975,
1.1086070537567139,
0.11659988015890121,
0.5931749939918518,
0.12921544909477234,
0.812736451625824,
-0.39321765303611755,
0.6704609394073486,
-0.5379258394241333,
0.14002719521522522,
-0.4389382600784302,
-0.9002473950386047,
-0.049568191170692444,
0.9180327653884888,
-0.07671599835157394,
-0.13349562883377075,
0.26347672939300537,
0.6831381916999817,
-0.26443397998809814,
-0.28517478704452515,
0.28016144037246704,
-0.029207520186901093,
0.30200281739234924,
0.43875205516815186,
0.8888761401176453,
-0.19430050253868103,
0.9986779093742371,
-0.05906591936945915,
-0.06967417150735855,
-0.05222431570291519,
-0.47407737374305725,
-0.4646666347980499,
-0.8210837244987488,
-0.34257614612579346,
-0.1937652826309204,
0.13246683776378632,
1.099807620048523,
1.0038235187530518,
-0.9616870284080505,
-0.4540066421031952,
0.19164004921913147,
-0.3419986963272095,
-0.1630428284406662,
-0.13702723383903503,
0.6200245022773743,
0.12654297053813934,
-0.4234215319156647,
0.44400304555892944,
0.06505295634269714,
0.2686602771282196,
0.1079837903380394,
-0.26170551776885986,
-0.00046594676678068936,
0.041667066514492035,
0.49547669291496277,
0.5226367712020874,
-0.5505200028419495,
-0.4158961772918701,
-0.19817298650741577,
0.1454295814037323,
0.21272273361682892,
0.9503384232521057,
-0.9684844017028809,
0.37261420488357544,
0.2511805593967438,
0.6945698261260986,
0.3738071322441101,
-0.059189241379499435,
0.5457744598388672,
-0.7182571291923523,
0.5918462872505188,
0.5572999119758606,
0.38426512479782104,
0.5380284190177917,
-0.18697188794612885,
0.31923121213912964,
0.20502819120883942,
-0.10853320360183716,
-1.1799613237380981,
0.05116252228617668,
-0.726770281791687,
0.1184060201048851,
1.185107946395874,
-0.16619467735290527,
0.1501934677362442,
-0.33965930342674255,
-0.14652445912361145,
0.46952423453330994,
-0.5297660231590271,
0.7424747347831726,
0.465828537940979,
-0.2227514088153839,
-0.08350779861211777,
-0.03139464929699898,
0.8856579661369324,
0.40424221754074097,
-0.45896369218826294,
0.16250218451023102,
0.28944718837738037,
0.25329530239105225,
0.40970680117607117,
1.0491814613342285,
-0.21725556254386902,
0.3651435971260071,
-0.030723467469215393,
-0.15207621455192566,
-0.04784894362092018,
-0.23573702573776245,
-0.4704451262950897,
-0.18808084726333618,
0.3736000955104828,
-0.3735901415348053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02289v1 | SemPool: Simple, robust, and interpretable KG pooling for enhancing language models | 2024-02-03T23:03:51 | 2024-02-03T23:03:51 | Costas Mavromatis, Petros Karypis, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge Graph (KG) powered question answering (QA) performs complex
reasoning over language semantics as well as knowledge facts. Graph Neural
Networks (GNNs) learn to aggregate information from the underlying KG, which is
combined with Language Models (LMs) for effective reasoning with the given
question. However, GNN-based methods for QA rely on the graph information of
the candidate answer nodes, which limits their effectiveness in more
challenging settings where critical answer information is not included in the
KG. We propose a simple graph pooling approach that learns useful semantics of
the KG that can aid the LM's reasoning and that its effectiveness is robust
under graph perturbations. Our method, termed SemPool, represents KG facts with
pre-trained LMs, learns to aggregate their semantic information, and fuses it
at different layers of the LM. Our experimental results show that SemPool
outperforms state-of-the-art GNN-based methods by 2.27% accuracy points on
average when answer information is missing from the KG. In addition, SemPool
offers interpretability on what type of graph information is fused at different
LM layers. | [
-0.3781605660915375,
-0.9349037408828735,
0.5054518580436707,
-0.09376362711191177,
-0.2599583566188812,
0.16985736787319183,
-0.01570117473602295,
-0.12389933317899704,
0.11737816035747528,
0.5018412470817566,
-0.3131171464920044,
-0.34531161189079285,
-0.6489476561546326,
-0.29202568531036377,
-0.32264724373817444,
0.8109067678451538,
0.05726242810487747,
-0.05286143347620964,
-0.42595577239990234,
-0.3550669252872467,
-0.273980051279068,
-0.27368220686912537,
-0.6173088550567627,
-0.7275685667991638,
0.6908575296401978,
0.3579787015914917,
0.9779935479164124,
0.551878809928894,
0.11742182075977325,
0.35259851813316345,
-0.005970312748104334,
0.3929794430732727,
-0.5193726420402527,
0.3234155476093292,
-0.1724548637866974,
-0.17096708714962006,
-0.311655193567276,
0.027167918160557747,
0.5130755305290222,
0.9492055177688599,
-0.11731801182031631,
0.16054214537143707,
0.10174591839313507,
0.5864351987838745,
-0.9230522513389587,
0.39998531341552734,
-0.6817091703414917,
-0.087217777967453,
0.028585750609636307,
-0.20312057435512543,
-0.3593181073665619,
-0.40246909856796265,
0.17693229019641876,
-0.4870506823062897,
-0.1576385498046875,
-0.24181073904037476,
0.8856050968170166,
0.35645413398742676,
-0.5597724914550781,
-0.2363189458847046,
-0.35117942094802856,
0.5313760638237,
-0.7357567548751831,
0.29782286286354065,
0.6209222674369812,
0.663121223449707,
-0.006146162282675505,
-1.0256261825561523,
-0.6606459617614746,
0.10976243019104004,
-0.3273232877254486,
0.16892650723457336,
-0.027352191507816315,
0.14604073762893677,
0.16744355857372284,
0.040467627346515656,
-0.5142463445663452,
0.029231254011392593,
-0.3239635229110718,
-0.3760371804237366,
0.6198189854621887,
-0.01198827289044857,
0.6766664981842041,
-0.16493535041809082,
-0.17064552009105682,
-0.08637639880180359,
-0.5297426581382751,
0.07478990405797958,
0.4462394118309021,
0.31472352147102356,
0.25738170742988586,
0.5921433568000793,
-0.2795552909374237,
0.9953851103782654,
-0.40042388439178467,
-0.07827965915203094,
0.18730217218399048,
-0.05348735302686691,
-0.3173319399356842,
-0.04025842249393463,
0.6063606142997742,
0.17514066398143768,
0.3863457441329956,
-0.45548200607299805,
0.08613654226064682,
-0.0177982896566391,
0.10615389794111252,
-0.8403815627098083,
-0.505392849445343,
0.1841336190700531,
-0.15501737594604492,
-0.2919071912765503,
-0.04354381933808327,
-0.6654611229896545,
-0.433139830827713,
-0.23344916105270386,
0.6568094491958618,
-0.5182631015777588,
-0.4310671389102936,
-0.10257335007190704,
-0.4048157036304474,
0.394836962223053,
0.24050523340702057,
-0.7083429098129272,
0.3711239993572235,
0.6583030819892883,
0.5991325378417969,
0.024320976808667183,
-0.5618510246276855,
-0.7258548140525818,
0.21627292037010193,
-0.06978672742843628,
0.8568686246871948,
-0.7055277228355408,
-0.04221797734498978,
-0.08368261903524399,
-0.06969968974590302,
-0.5239976644515991,
-0.5111193060874939,
0.3029353618621826,
-0.9742166996002197,
0.40966808795928955,
0.006466307677328587,
-0.8249920010566711,
-0.3961917757987976,
0.3559471070766449,
-0.5552283525466919,
0.9820737838745117,
0.39065563678741455,
-0.935139536857605,
0.006769905332475901,
-0.33326995372772217,
-0.47094205021858215,
0.06645245105028152,
0.07050476968288422,
-0.33525583148002625,
-0.22622784972190857,
0.39186033606529236,
0.4136001467704773,
0.18461324274539948,
0.2983396351337433,
-0.5800573825836182,
-0.2218412160873413,
0.35518717765808105,
-0.1290546953678131,
0.888559103012085,
0.5074627995491028,
0.20938925445079803,
0.20312677323818207,
-0.7245963215827942,
0.5476585030555725,
0.049841899424791336,
-0.2642478048801422,
-0.20193341374397278,
0.0029379394836723804,
-0.670211136341095,
0.27624818682670593,
0.08828534930944443,
-0.14380359649658203,
-0.07034739851951599,
-0.4643353819847107,
0.5490285754203796,
0.7229071259498596,
-0.10021121054887772,
0.5596367120742798,
-0.22056961059570312,
0.5002262592315674,
-0.21758905053138733,
-0.14500567317008972,
-0.037840280681848526,
-0.43768510222435,
-0.7349728941917419,
-0.062418509274721146,
0.4033091366291046,
0.653759777545929,
-1.0257699489593506,
0.12451013922691345,
-0.2808018922805786,
-0.6440214514732361,
-0.3263481855392456,
0.3892865478992462,
0.15404367446899414,
0.8855104446411133,
0.35959717631340027,
-0.039658695459365845,
-0.3942512273788452,
-0.6612078547477722,
-0.509475827217102,
-0.32113295793533325,
-0.08496767282485962,
0.5646691918373108,
0.1153269112110138,
-0.04393694922327995,
0.9781855344772339,
-0.5245146155357361,
0.1431046575307846,
-0.5438523888587952,
-0.02264668419957161,
0.2432786226272583,
0.12854354083538055,
0.36426523327827454,
-0.7198190689086914,
-0.5233597159385681,
-0.2707499861717224,
-0.8043783903121948,
-0.34184831380844116,
0.29679083824157715,
-0.4169280230998993,
-0.18775814771652222,
0.3527589738368988,
-0.5428791642189026,
0.06915460526943207,
0.6609094738960266,
-0.5873208045959473,
0.2686486840248108,
-0.14075800776481628,
-0.21819186210632324,
-1.030617356300354,
0.05774486064910889,
-0.3531583249568939,
-0.47895383834838867,
-0.7405816912651062,
0.16738742589950562,
-0.12074485421180725,
-0.35674920678138733,
-0.36951741576194763,
0.645768940448761,
-0.18316568434238434,
-0.168514683842659,
-0.4569712281227112,
0.5825578570365906,
0.13307546079158783,
0.48875588178634644,
-0.12970677018165588,
0.4188307821750641,
0.6056063771247864,
-0.7230926156044006,
0.6509362459182739,
0.16045358777046204,
-0.2675461173057556,
0.12237852811813354,
-0.5261361002922058,
0.4608384966850281,
-0.30342841148376465,
0.08116943389177322,
-1.093955159187317,
-0.3259919583797455,
0.23526115715503693,
-0.5964866280555725,
0.3917753994464874,
-0.2626822292804718,
-0.1949797123670578,
-0.30431458353996277,
-0.1953810304403305,
0.280937135219574,
0.5374173521995544,
-0.5978012681007385,
0.8354088664054871,
0.7214400172233582,
-0.3045457899570465,
-0.782517671585083,
-0.3491566777229309,
-0.12137318402528763,
-0.01573002152144909,
-0.91766756772995,
-0.09396035969257355,
0.2932778000831604,
-0.10597103089094162,
0.3505276143550873,
-0.17716306447982788,
-0.5038082599639893,
0.5310767292976379,
0.13107508420944214,
0.21350571513175964,
-0.12502221763134003,
0.38079699873924255,
0.036487843841314316,
-0.40340593457221985,
0.0023820283822715282,
-0.4182857275009155,
0.7457797527313232,
-0.13087981939315796,
-0.37809887528419495,
-0.06809849292039871,
0.10563354939222336,
0.4262031316757202,
-0.1788080483675003,
0.8442181348800659,
0.630505383014679,
-0.3282516300678253,
-0.301491379737854,
-0.2498830109834671,
-0.2539600729942322,
-0.45014476776123047,
0.4126412868499756,
-0.2671366035938263,
-1.1096827983856201,
0.44948142766952515,
-0.23392310738563538,
-0.2521580159664154,
0.41301047801971436,
0.39010241627693176,
-0.16842186450958252,
1.2034542560577393,
0.34352272748947144,
-0.14615565538406372,
0.3946760892868042,
-0.29403647780418396,
0.47258052229881287,
-0.5501025915145874,
-0.20571096241474152,
-0.5263525247573853,
-0.43848124146461487,
-0.29019981622695923,
-0.33927494287490845,
0.2829154133796692,
0.5578617453575134,
-0.45855721831321716,
-0.0018018712289631367,
-0.2526266276836395,
0.7119429707527161,
0.6383798718452454,
0.1342317909002304,
0.049092505127191544,
0.08167658001184464,
-0.1673140674829483,
0.32523560523986816,
-1.024011254310608,
-0.46801304817199707,
0.6752542853355408,
0.07072146981954575,
0.7109191417694092,
0.08108697831630707,
0.35003289580345154,
-0.05176478996872902,
0.309711217880249,
-0.6144453883171082,
0.6164674162864685,
0.025026122108101845,
-0.4667424261569977,
-0.6907032132148743,
-0.6758793592453003,
-0.8320918679237366,
0.4480009078979492,
-0.05948396772146225,
-0.9355406761169434,
-0.3614029884338379,
0.15403656661510468,
-0.1627463549375534,
0.3412582576274872,
-0.8588380813598633,
1.030811071395874,
-0.10139665007591248,
-0.1366601139307022,
-0.19011719524860382,
-0.7208442687988281,
0.13623584806919098,
0.16733449697494507,
0.17262236773967743,
-0.4282970130443573,
0.19221702218055725,
0.6289069652557373,
-0.8473416566848755,
0.7175121903419495,
-0.29749709367752075,
0.2912909686565399,
0.6193471550941467,
0.07846452295780182,
0.592910647392273,
-0.17235657572746277,
-0.1759839653968811,
-0.17531555891036987,
0.09374381601810455,
-0.60733962059021,
-1.097095251083374,
0.6211035251617432,
-0.9966620206832886,
-0.6394733786582947,
-0.07279666513204575,
-0.6927823424339294,
-0.54298335313797,
0.36097830533981323,
-0.031171705573797226,
0.4982650578022003,
0.3108464181423187,
0.12323459982872009,
0.2631705105304718,
-0.2881230413913727,
0.25926676392555237,
0.3956291079521179,
-0.43380314111709595,
-0.5029686689376831,
1.1087254285812378,
0.3180355131626129,
0.3999629020690918,
0.2737734615802765,
0.5810251832008362,
-0.54417484998703,
-0.4094717800617218,
-0.4333757758140564,
0.17132626473903656,
-1.0319092273712158,
-0.2115352749824524,
-0.8602432608604431,
-0.5238262414932251,
-0.5920528173446655,
-0.015583572909235954,
-0.006054695229977369,
-0.7795931696891785,
0.09977153688669205,
-0.3676741421222687,
0.19596247375011444,
0.27940210700035095,
0.03708105906844139,
0.2833636701107025,
-0.8901634812355042,
0.2112327367067337,
0.9056504964828491,
0.3348187804222107,
0.04475272074341774,
-0.4019111096858978,
-0.055638138204813004,
-0.03819132223725319,
-0.17666766047477722,
-1.0430389642715454,
0.33392053842544556,
0.3736478388309479,
0.8062041401863098,
0.3392102122306824,
0.23879553377628326,
0.5854613780975342,
-0.16853341460227966,
0.7373318076133728,
0.024191545322537422,
-0.9507238864898682,
0.7345650792121887,
-0.06850585341453552,
0.36075741052627563,
0.5023089051246643,
0.3171246349811554,
-0.6504873037338257,
-0.617927610874176,
-0.7269704937934875,
-0.9245576858520508,
0.6763454675674438,
0.06997121125459671,
0.3505086600780487,
0.009019182994961739,
0.29578348994255066,
-0.07084561139345169,
0.15066301822662354,
-0.5678339004516602,
-0.22080491483211517,
-0.3667561411857605,
-0.41421693563461304,
0.06005074083805084,
-0.4690811038017273,
-0.04709842428565025,
-0.22186748683452606,
0.9093902707099915,
-0.4649723768234253,
-0.15404623746871948,
-0.13943253457546234,
-0.29434219002723694,
0.11325930804014206,
0.37394610047340393,
0.01598825491964817,
0.888592541217804,
-0.014444176107645035,
0.8405559659004211,
0.572237491607666,
-0.3134113848209381,
-0.06300359964370728,
0.15072907507419586,
-0.31336870789527893,
-0.196258544921875,
0.48398762941360474,
0.7849249243736267,
0.01875149831175804,
-0.717242419719696,
0.5596678853034973,
0.02419755980372429,
0.017186490818858147,
0.06569425761699677,
0.4079914093017578,
0.40671926736831665,
0.2022874653339386,
-0.03419414535164833,
-0.13887359201908112,
-0.05573367327451706,
-0.3909040093421936,
0.17171227931976318,
0.3573065400123596,
-0.5717629194259644,
-0.16706934571266174,
0.421258807182312,
0.08864663541316986,
-0.11935976147651672,
1.0503766536712646,
-0.1362621784210205,
-0.8069461584091187,
0.5199015736579895,
0.6926750540733337,
0.5878316760063171,
-0.18877333402633667,
0.43719884753227234,
0.37574049830436707,
-0.050105877220630646,
0.27533531188964844,
0.30860066413879395,
-0.1837463229894638,
-1.2258353233337402,
-0.6978610157966614,
-0.6202369332313538,
-0.3385147750377655,
0.004098614677786827,
-0.42738837003707886,
0.12961971759796143,
-0.29011034965515137,
0.1508268266916275,
-0.06543717533349991,
0.07835114002227783,
-0.38625630736351013,
0.12823909521102905,
0.11928586661815643,
0.9574944972991943,
-0.875285804271698,
0.9581053853034973,
0.8699022531509399,
-0.29754582047462463,
-1.3999272584915161,
-0.48514771461486816,
-0.245210200548172,
-1.0499093532562256,
0.5166413187980652,
0.2440119832754135,
-0.08409833908081055,
0.16906782984733582,
-0.6576771140098572,
-0.8046932220458984,
1.2113443613052368,
0.68784099817276,
0.1118905246257782,
0.2366418093442917,
0.16793420910835266,
0.29392531514167786,
-0.10330117493867874,
0.31431612372398376,
0.41178229451179504,
0.3750179708003998,
0.571448028087616,
-0.6427481174468994,
-0.004077417775988579,
-0.4184059500694275,
-0.30111250281333923,
0.20239539444446564,
-0.5155631303787231,
0.6017261147499084,
-0.2747083604335785,
-0.3941781520843506,
-0.2606990933418274,
0.5846817493438721,
0.3070848882198334,
0.6715717315673828,
0.7237168550491333,
0.724037230014801,
1.3260740041732788,
-0.05338720232248306,
1.2038127183914185,
-0.4283808171749115,
0.44696372747421265,
1.1342130899429321,
-0.16415289044380188,
0.5814786553382874,
0.21091671288013458,
-0.17392832040786743,
0.5217995643615723,
0.5589268803596497,
0.36421725153923035,
0.48278191685676575,
0.18356403708457947,
-0.3331318199634552,
-0.8177695870399475,
-0.2349614053964615,
-0.32629695534706116,
0.3522173762321472,
0.1303786188364029,
-0.24033254384994507,
-0.530669629573822,
-0.2147650271654129,
0.135647252202034,
-0.03034120239317417,
-0.39943352341651917,
0.7729441523551941,
0.22527271509170532,
-0.74462890625,
0.18275593221187592,
-0.2280924916267395,
-0.12407128512859344,
-0.6238123178482056,
0.013650094158947468,
-0.12299994379281998,
0.19170106947422028,
-0.3283061981201172,
-0.8341838717460632,
0.3653469681739807,
-0.16746622323989868,
0.063206247985363,
-0.20002613961696625,
1.545802354812622,
-0.47676560282707214,
-0.42359569668769836,
0.20408234000205994,
0.9471607804298401,
0.22292084991931915,
0.027517879381775856,
-0.49487805366516113,
-0.4131892919540405,
-0.2818053960800171,
-0.13072247803211212,
0.3290913999080658,
0.4694766402244568,
0.22447562217712402,
0.9659095406532288,
0.4633059501647949,
0.059120673686265945,
0.12667042016983032,
0.36417829990386963,
1.071974515914917,
-0.3697664439678192,
-0.5359387993812561,
-1.0091995000839233,
0.31632035970687866,
-0.36778536438941956,
0.07436387240886688,
0.897621750831604,
0.4038131833076477,
0.789422333240509,
0.2508579194545746,
0.7829782962799072,
0.02779686264693737,
0.48094871640205383,
-0.6039535999298096,
0.7704594135284424,
-0.24231605231761932,
0.11982178688049316,
-0.04382225126028061,
-0.7939603924751282,
-0.4006750285625458,
0.7134799957275391,
-0.5285089612007141,
0.0385645367205143,
0.5045238733291626,
0.6916064023971558,
-0.026203257963061333,
0.2764051556587219,
0.3489777147769928,
0.254027396440506,
0.3011801242828369,
0.5577782392501831,
1.2488332986831665,
-0.04391106590628624,
0.7142502665519714,
-0.25239747762680054,
-0.050887882709503174,
0.016627540811896324,
-0.9108864665031433,
-0.8027077317237854,
-0.28894108533859253,
-0.34304079413414,
-0.6654146909713745,
-0.06160103157162666,
0.6986466646194458,
0.7751932740211487,
-0.8519108295440674,
0.09479151666164398,
-0.033690329641103745,
0.7780054211616516,
-0.20460090041160583,
-0.22806783020496368,
0.5894016623497009,
-0.7232927680015564,
-0.44916608929634094,
0.25272586941719055,
0.26541534066200256,
-0.23628729581832886,
-0.07215021550655365,
-0.2833561897277832,
-0.01912974938750267,
-0.04669256508350372,
0.551469624042511,
0.22930750250816345,
-0.22449123859405518,
-0.6262092590332031,
-0.018532998859882355,
0.024819165468215942,
-0.17338170111179352,
0.8247010707855225,
-0.940997302532196,
0.6033779978752136,
0.8801064491271973,
0.8569139838218689,
0.46824946999549866,
0.012506334111094475,
0.5711093544960022,
-0.7116286158561707,
-0.06071105971932411,
0.24918513000011444,
0.5326752662658691,
0.22582116723060608,
0.026222210377454758,
0.6929872632026672,
0.3638777732849121,
-0.5661655068397522,
-0.730854868888855,
0.3832196593284607,
-0.8061781525611877,
-0.5013299584388733,
1.2972851991653442,
-0.3390559256076813,
-0.3634142577648163,
-0.18854665756225586,
-0.04985949024558067,
0.5369929075241089,
0.16872559487819672,
0.5995590686798096,
0.6585481762886047,
-0.21418921649456024,
-0.31613633036613464,
-0.32959848642349243,
0.21043287217617035,
0.20952564477920532,
-0.7704261541366577,
-0.19385188817977905,
0.5353538393974304,
0.4368426203727722,
0.06428536772727966,
0.7865205407142639,
0.03347979858517647,
0.12205879390239716,
0.016951527446508408,
-0.5369032621383667,
-0.47494709491729736,
-0.2143862396478653,
-0.07025814056396484,
0.6059200167655945,
0.2582763135433197,
-0.012169680558145046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02285v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02285v1 | SynthDST: Synthetic Data is All You Need for Few-Shot Dialog State Tracking | 2024-02-03T22:49:00 | 2024-02-03T22:49:00 | Atharva Kulkarni, Bo-Hsiang Tseng, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Hong Yu, Shruti Bhargava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In-context learning with Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
promising avenue of research in Dialog State Tracking (DST). However, the
best-performing in-context learning methods involve retrieving and adding
similar examples to the prompt, requiring access to labeled training data.
Procuring such training data for a wide range of domains and applications is
time-consuming, expensive, and, at times, infeasible. While zero-shot learning
requires no training data, it significantly lags behind the few-shot setup.
Thus, `\textit{Can we efficiently generate synthetic data for any dialogue
schema to enable few-shot prompting?}' Addressing this question, we propose
\method, a data generation framework tailored for DST, utilizing LLMs. Our
approach only requires the dialogue schema and a few hand-crafted dialogue
templates to synthesize natural, coherent, and free-flowing dialogues with DST
annotations. Few-shot learning using data from {\method} results in $4-5%$
improvement in Joint Goal Accuracy over the zero-shot baseline on MultiWOZ 2.1
and 2.4. Remarkably, our few-shot learning approach recovers nearly $98%$ of
the performance compared to the few-shot setup using human-annotated training
data. Our synthetic data and code can be accessed at
https://github.com/apple/ml-synthdst | [
-0.38479092717170715,
-1.022586464881897,
1.0015331506729126,
-0.3274037837982178,
-0.27166295051574707,
0.0795394703745842,
-0.03072756715118885,
-0.0902060940861702,
0.2868565022945404,
0.5003750324249268,
-1.2615680694580078,
-0.6825679540634155,
-0.06618693470954895,
0.2464800626039505,
-0.07680445909500122,
1.2782037258148193,
0.19969604909420013,
0.05762617290019989,
0.0047001163475215435,
0.025139054283499718,
-0.23222674429416656,
-0.4535336494445801,
-0.3959260582923889,
-0.12393200397491455,
0.2745834290981293,
0.5011526942253113,
0.12030822783708572,
0.4836657643318176,
0.008977795019745827,
0.20053836703300476,
-0.028626855462789536,
0.4219402074813843,
-0.7266919016838074,
0.4554431438446045,
0.20245851576328278,
-0.42176052927970886,
-0.4529057741165161,
0.04392579197883606,
0.6344508528709412,
0.4583033323287964,
0.014780855737626553,
0.26110297441482544,
-0.09715064615011215,
0.4575442373752594,
-0.39552295207977295,
0.223230242729187,
-0.9458428025245667,
0.19264058768749237,
-0.23097537457942963,
-0.5113052725791931,
-0.2720223367214203,
-0.40978875756263733,
0.26797282695770264,
-0.6973643898963928,
0.3861231207847595,
-0.09238295257091522,
0.2535969913005829,
0.2747320532798767,
-0.6196159720420837,
-0.11455857753753662,
-0.5902212262153625,
0.7597348093986511,
-0.8525967001914978,
0.11970724165439606,
0.2540043294429779,
0.5176813006401062,
-0.6180433034896851,
-0.7538049817085266,
-0.6741965413093567,
-0.18890444934368134,
0.14792563021183014,
0.2769808769226074,
0.10580430179834366,
0.2592153251171112,
0.6237939596176147,
0.14931367337703705,
-0.4989265203475952,
-0.27389273047447205,
-0.43906334042549133,
-0.36737215518951416,
0.5826107263565063,
0.7117939591407776,
0.052613645792007446,
-0.3735872507095337,
-0.391975462436676,
-0.01416082214564085,
-0.8763376474380493,
-0.13774673640727997,
0.30820345878601074,
0.6336729526519775,
-0.30759233236312866,
0.7126451134681702,
-0.4525573253631592,
0.7446102499961853,
0.26336246728897095,
-0.4564064145088196,
0.04023319482803345,
-0.6336202025413513,
-0.18717649579048157,
0.3096838593482971,
0.7420299053192139,
0.3089176416397095,
-0.17365992069244385,
0.027262678369879723,
-0.2526759207248688,
0.10106303542852402,
0.10745590925216675,
-1.0484050512313843,
-0.25575414299964905,
0.1556643396615982,
0.08432835340499878,
-0.27052760124206543,
-0.2984755337238312,
-0.6234098076820374,
-0.26756468415260315,
-0.6310200095176697,
0.3037613332271576,
-0.5192322731018066,
0.049354102462530136,
-0.39275047183036804,
-0.03517669439315796,
0.07179098576307297,
0.48670440912246704,
-0.8978317975997925,
0.20071591436862946,
0.5977877378463745,
1.0276869535446167,
-0.0953499898314476,
-0.05078887939453125,
-0.7744484543800354,
0.09982695430517197,
-0.5663748383522034,
0.8203059434890747,
-0.26593542098999023,
-0.4630669355392456,
-0.11279802769422531,
-0.16819673776626587,
-0.03343002870678902,
-0.2657017111778259,
0.16336488723754883,
-0.07652100920677185,
0.22696757316589355,
-0.26917991042137146,
-0.8795362114906311,
0.02745772711932659,
0.42300117015838623,
-0.2626708447933197,
0.9364107847213745,
0.13609661161899567,
-0.5886622071266174,
0.3975846767425537,
-0.5383675694465637,
-0.3471600115299225,
0.10402244329452515,
-0.562042236328125,
-0.3589869737625122,
0.23254813253879547,
0.1817740499973297,
0.33141499757766724,
-0.10921600461006165,
0.17182447016239166,
-0.2663530111312866,
-0.47296103835105896,
0.2928119897842407,
-0.5553197860717773,
0.6221174001693726,
0.23830656707286835,
-0.10415513813495636,
-0.1037074625492096,
-0.8821048736572266,
0.1557537019252777,
-0.13280494511127472,
-0.35504424571990967,
0.147054985165596,
-0.16784870624542236,
-0.0300318393856287,
0.13148880004882812,
-0.20882946252822876,
-0.9130535125732422,
0.3784443140029907,
-0.6057094931602478,
0.26756617426872253,
0.8365789651870728,
0.5364170074462891,
0.4826681911945343,
-0.3341553211212158,
0.7822968363761902,
0.029130257666110992,
-0.17685511708259583,
-0.7022277116775513,
-0.35431811213493347,
-0.4407340884208679,
-0.5389602780342102,
-0.19282077252864838,
0.3509584367275238,
-0.7907068133354187,
0.23538751900196075,
-0.04763398319482803,
-0.3123777508735657,
-0.4198780953884125,
0.16850683093070984,
0.2652973532676697,
0.7199701070785522,
0.1606215089559555,
-0.09355595707893372,
-0.755120038986206,
-0.8070306777954102,
-0.0012431025970727205,
-0.06865280866622925,
-0.1730802357196808,
0.2701585590839386,
0.4360091984272003,
-0.10598524659872055,
1.5323132276535034,
-0.8096051216125488,
-0.4256811738014221,
-0.5386584997177124,
0.208810493350029,
0.029640987515449524,
0.32847753167152405,
0.5213053226470947,
-0.24622656404972076,
-0.6311931014060974,
-0.2791309356689453,
-0.6955026388168335,
-0.1858701854944229,
-0.1808844357728958,
-0.09122277051210403,
0.37370285391807556,
0.34423351287841797,
-0.799537718296051,
0.42873379588127136,
0.45940840244293213,
0.20029470324516296,
0.3952147960662842,
0.2075173407793045,
0.07516959309577942,
-1.444701910018921,
-0.08100871741771698,
0.050501737743616104,
-0.3894289433956146,
-0.8186370730400085,
-0.7188422083854675,
-0.21331028640270233,
-0.47382694482803345,
-0.8497456312179565,
0.6551509499549866,
-0.04720795527100563,
-0.0660983994603157,
-0.1168103814125061,
0.16914695501327515,
-0.15787860751152039,
0.781755268573761,
0.12847793102264404,
0.8442287445068359,
0.48048335313796997,
-0.5079692006111145,
0.3150802254676819,
0.4689849615097046,
-0.47993916273117065,
0.8174623847007751,
-0.3856457769870758,
0.5067918300628662,
-0.23351316154003143,
0.8243371844291687,
-0.990213930606842,
-0.5116517543792725,
0.37450581789016724,
-0.3390786349773407,
0.10979844629764557,
-0.5707147121429443,
-0.3660198450088501,
0.12674252688884735,
-0.3559908866882324,
0.1258559376001358,
0.46483567357063293,
-0.5347759127616882,
0.34571215510368347,
0.2857567071914673,
-0.1487853080034256,
-0.0691198855638504,
-0.5396774411201477,
-0.0071542635560035706,
-0.1725023090839386,
-0.36475589871406555,
0.13279254734516144,
-0.21342195570468903,
0.03575987368822098,
-0.3505434989929199,
-0.4875524342060089,
0.030484987422823906,
-0.23729954659938812,
0.2668295204639435,
0.32782652974128723,
-0.11029326915740967,
0.10788410902023315,
0.1425967514514923,
-0.30968886613845825,
-0.14763720333576202,
-0.2819664180278778,
0.2496749609708786,
0.06752043962478638,
-0.3410331606864929,
-0.8630671501159668,
0.2512914538383484,
0.5346617698669434,
0.35610300302505493,
0.313780277967453,
0.4545325040817261,
-0.2806382179260254,
-0.4663691520690918,
-0.3014850318431854,
-0.6613472104072571,
-0.45273321866989136,
0.22549885511398315,
-0.5101007223129272,
-0.7505868673324585,
0.08837959915399551,
-0.053795792162418365,
0.24494950473308563,
0.05054939165711403,
0.5549655556678772,
-0.4176284968852997,
1.270951509475708,
0.2781849205493927,
0.07326197624206543,
0.6184462308883667,
-0.30036622285842896,
0.2695713937282562,
-0.7922093272209167,
0.039270512759685516,
-0.10928923636674881,
-0.2534761428833008,
-0.6094141006469727,
-0.11062905192375183,
0.8299565315246582,
-0.21038782596588135,
-0.27865496277809143,
0.3859962224960327,
-0.19935251772403717,
0.5807961225509644,
0.48252740502357483,
0.16088049113750458,
0.30950841307640076,
0.10464475303888321,
0.025887418538331985,
-0.3532436192035675,
-0.8101856112480164,
-0.4758048355579376,
1.292812466621399,
0.0670134425163269,
0.9539552330970764,
-0.07105135917663574,
1.1218528747558594,
0.1514943540096283,
0.05505327135324478,
-0.9122266173362732,
0.7453047037124634,
0.13021409511566162,
-0.7073357701301575,
-0.097881019115448,
-0.5693976283073425,
-0.5560940504074097,
0.08492320030927658,
-0.2522794306278229,
-0.957421600818634,
-0.35117194056510925,
0.39658495783805847,
-0.5792126655578613,
0.1634402573108673,
-0.6671991348266602,
0.6629842519760132,
-0.07639414072036743,
-0.37601640820503235,
0.010286643169820309,
-0.6369203329086304,
0.5597187876701355,
-0.24519528448581696,
-0.43081727623939514,
-0.4614516794681549,
0.4369990825653076,
0.5775661468505859,
-0.5082501769065857,
1.3226546049118042,
-0.2745917737483978,
0.019302789121866226,
0.6341801881790161,
0.3698391914367676,
0.6356667876243591,
0.22675538063049316,
0.17389939725399017,
-0.06133413314819336,
0.34502026438713074,
-0.260892391204834,
-0.6653820872306824,
0.6700711846351624,
-0.32517364621162415,
-0.4866616427898407,
-0.6148645281791687,
-0.5882237553596497,
-0.43514129519462585,
-0.0828302726149559,
0.4516931474208832,
0.6762475371360779,
-0.38201746344566345,
0.10109621286392212,
0.34025803208351135,
-0.09408903121948242,
0.2840465009212494,
0.5585058927536011,
0.047621794044971466,
-0.3946954905986786,
0.7062767744064331,
0.04062895104289055,
0.48204225301742554,
0.11442380398511887,
0.11995719373226166,
-0.4085630476474762,
-0.11101623624563217,
-0.694500744342804,
0.0283307284116745,
-0.5193735957145691,
-0.5189146995544434,
-0.46640676259994507,
-0.27677902579307556,
-0.34512510895729065,
-0.29686322808265686,
-0.5499764680862427,
-0.4783823788166046,
-0.24759654700756073,
-0.24648940563201904,
0.6182160973548889,
0.7341049313545227,
-0.023514721542596817,
0.47059398889541626,
-0.8748718500137329,
0.4942752420902252,
0.2810322046279907,
0.059460125863552094,
-0.3568439781665802,
-0.3302881717681885,
-0.10492392629384995,
0.52065110206604,
-0.5944017767906189,
-0.6031749248504639,
0.349607914686203,
0.24160882830619812,
0.3389475345611572,
0.18648238480091095,
0.21641065180301666,
0.8318265676498413,
-0.47570961713790894,
1.0632574558258057,
0.3466200828552246,
-0.8940298557281494,
0.8156054615974426,
-0.46327075362205505,
0.508116602897644,
0.6905415058135986,
0.013851813040673733,
-0.5616251826286316,
-0.3966388404369354,
-0.5363640189170837,
-0.4426579475402832,
1.3285834789276123,
0.29544124007225037,
0.2979973554611206,
-0.17685770988464355,
0.20855017006397247,
0.21284884214401245,
0.19592499732971191,
-0.3153553903102875,
-0.005608032923191786,
0.0004542698443401605,
-0.4675387144088745,
0.04411120340228081,
-0.02470497414469719,
-0.2974151372909546,
-0.12888912856578827,
0.6076217889785767,
-0.6146393418312073,
0.1274636685848236,
0.13766087591648102,
-0.0573933906853199,
-0.19424450397491455,
0.31679800152778625,
0.610153317451477,
0.46581774950027466,
-0.4154249429702759,
-0.04625682160258293,
0.4078201353549957,
-0.2295413613319397,
0.3415776491165161,
-0.2735237181186676,
-0.5083185434341431,
0.04447862133383751,
0.12257768213748932,
0.9390825629234314,
0.21315285563468933,
-0.6861299872398376,
0.4352080523967743,
0.12013685703277588,
-0.21524971723556519,
-0.30857253074645996,
0.20089606940746307,
-0.24698607623577118,
0.365131676197052,
0.20060361921787262,
0.01410042867064476,
0.01566065102815628,
-0.6539654731750488,
0.32236868143081665,
0.4656812250614166,
-0.24875837564468384,
-0.589430570602417,
0.49017444252967834,
0.2572094798088074,
-0.2240225225687027,
0.6534287929534912,
-0.24963055551052094,
-0.47033777832984924,
0.3196497857570648,
0.7220615744590759,
1.0352568626403809,
0.11215326189994812,
0.4569266736507416,
0.5056570768356323,
-0.23031924664974213,
-0.061433274298906326,
0.10135690867900848,
-0.5416780710220337,
-0.5929011702537537,
-0.23061639070510864,
-0.6224604845046997,
-0.6417509317398071,
0.25138887763023376,
-0.3209306001663208,
0.40684884786605835,
-0.5674675107002258,
-0.3465438187122345,
-0.07784178853034973,
0.07169234752655029,
-0.704632043838501,
0.03349173814058304,
0.21882952749729156,
0.5426363945007324,
-0.8607118725776672,
0.7809879183769226,
0.3021109402179718,
-0.4796394407749176,
-0.3692435026168823,
0.1950739622116089,
0.8324177861213684,
-0.5810495615005493,
0.5991612672805786,
0.2021310180425644,
-0.4546874761581421,
0.19512060284614563,
-0.6812780499458313,
-0.7114669680595398,
1.0859401226043701,
0.5180434584617615,
-0.6845424175262451,
0.10399387776851654,
0.2014254778623581,
0.5943999290466309,
-0.5307714939117432,
0.09860885143280029,
0.8333274126052856,
0.11367819458246231,
0.42928174138069153,
-0.6007528901100159,
-0.1764465570449829,
0.17232541739940643,
0.006204643286764622,
0.1313614398241043,
-0.3993653953075409,
0.42874762415885925,
-0.182633638381958,
-0.5662804245948792,
0.1962391436100006,
0.24271820485591888,
0.5412999391555786,
0.5854329466819763,
0.21737127006053925,
0.5214259624481201,
0.4428652822971344,
-0.11718428134918213,
0.839954137802124,
-0.18368494510650635,
0.22257308661937714,
1.335691213607788,
-0.5601758360862732,
0.4979153573513031,
0.6210614442825317,
-0.1398313343524933,
0.04330213740468025,
0.647024393081665,
0.20570746064186096,
0.6441212296485901,
0.17848776280879974,
-0.5492837429046631,
-0.1449548751115799,
-0.1349957138299942,
0.0029009978752583265,
0.500446617603302,
0.3397277295589447,
-0.04184094816446304,
-0.3165496289730072,
-0.04657626152038574,
0.0072072288021445274,
-0.24557934701442719,
0.2751201391220093,
1.2125208377838135,
0.21567580103874207,
-0.7404012680053711,
0.6201773285865784,
-0.46715405583381653,
0.4291762709617615,
-0.8109408617019653,
-0.2579687237739563,
-0.5601034760475159,
0.04808594286441803,
-0.2071235328912735,
-0.6110295653343201,
0.17913447320461273,
0.33591726422309875,
0.10408291965723038,
-0.21517252922058105,
0.2564782500267029,
-0.6775460243225098,
-0.43359628319740295,
-0.27364474534988403,
0.5235562324523926,
0.2827478349208832,
0.18970991671085358,
-0.4080967307090759,
0.028331901878118515,
0.21982553601264954,
-0.32995283603668213,
0.35239166021347046,
0.20649346709251404,
0.09783509373664856,
0.4457504451274872,
0.8575228452682495,
0.16963601112365723,
0.04877069219946861,
0.0933137834072113,
0.7899993062019348,
-0.6515000462532043,
-0.4296611249446869,
-0.6420907974243164,
0.5025838017463684,
-0.03684600815176964,
-0.38367676734924316,
0.5993225574493408,
0.6394246816635132,
0.8130695819854736,
-0.042600784450769424,
1.0776540040969849,
-0.05847572162747383,
0.7155435681343079,
-0.8442287445068359,
0.3184128999710083,
-0.3923547863960266,
0.42862337827682495,
-0.09079215675592422,
-1.2020970582962036,
-0.047827690839767456,
0.4302278757095337,
-0.10023045539855957,
-0.17728063464164734,
0.5559094548225403,
1.2198095321655273,
-0.26540374755859375,
0.08970808982849121,
0.32569822669029236,
0.04252701997756958,
0.5245711803436279,
0.47557082772254944,
0.8755371570587158,
-0.3888273537158966,
0.40479081869125366,
-0.3065291941165924,
0.01920648291707039,
-0.16463370621204376,
-0.6529457569122314,
-0.7884103059768677,
-0.6471368074417114,
-0.3681851923465729,
-0.1783837378025055,
-0.04691532626748085,
1.4601776599884033,
0.986945629119873,
-0.7699089646339417,
-0.0819317027926445,
-0.2561369240283966,
-0.2937966585159302,
0.16017436981201172,
-0.22867001593112946,
0.14290134608745575,
-0.5981470942497253,
-0.979853630065918,
1.0114964246749878,
0.3367786109447479,
0.5844998955726624,
-0.1251668483018875,
-0.15090875327587128,
0.025125954300165176,
0.165739044547081,
0.6504687666893005,
0.3709425926208496,
-0.6870265603065491,
-0.29616624116897583,
-0.03160794451832771,
-0.1131434366106987,
0.043242525309324265,
0.9996249675750732,
-0.9574839472770691,
0.8378287553787231,
0.506147027015686,
0.5621203780174255,
1.1145797967910767,
0.23114074766635895,
0.7230398058891296,
-1.2785552740097046,
0.2756149470806122,
0.24471554160118103,
0.0453123115003109,
0.3361464738845825,
-0.1752525418996811,
0.484428346157074,
0.21097876131534576,
-0.30980780720710754,
-0.8363183736801147,
0.5226825475692749,
-1.0193589925765991,
0.06016083434224129,
1.0504181385040283,
0.08889799565076828,
-0.03275137022137642,
0.11055581271648407,
-0.5488578081130981,
0.18589633703231812,
-0.7607098817825317,
0.8181796669960022,
0.3280622661113739,
-0.5958119630813599,
-0.12455417960882187,
-0.5265771746635437,
0.9186289310455322,
0.16219733655452728,
-0.8562726378440857,
0.029610423371195793,
0.9454746246337891,
0.3059900104999542,
-0.19975419342517853,
0.8924313187599182,
0.18894198536872864,
0.03582635894417763,
0.15369364619255066,
-0.43331438302993774,
0.08275127410888672,
-0.3272077739238739,
-0.22505511343479156,
-0.3311452269554138,
-0.33594855666160583,
-0.4515403211116791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02262v1 | Data Quality Matters: Suicide Intention Detection on Social Media Posts Using a RoBERTa-CNN Model | 2024-02-03T20:58:09 | 2024-02-03T20:58:09 | Emily Lin, Jian Sun, Hsingyu Chen, Mohammad H. Mahoor | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Suicide remains a global health concern for the field of health, which
urgently needs innovative approaches for early detection and intervention. In
this paper, we focus on identifying suicidal intentions in SuicideWatch Reddit
posts and present a novel approach to suicide detection using the cutting-edge
RoBERTa-CNN model, a variant of RoBERTa (Robustly optimized BERT approach).
RoBERTa is used for various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, including
text classification and sentiment analysis. The effectiveness of the RoBERTa
lies in its ability to capture textual information and form semantic
relationships within texts. By adding the Convolution Neural Network (CNN)
layer to the original model, the RoBERTa enhances its ability to capture
important patterns from heavy datasets. To evaluate the RoBERTa-CNN, we
experimented on the Suicide and Depression Detection dataset and obtained solid
results. For example, RoBERTa-CNN achieves 98% mean accuracy with the standard
deviation (STD) of 0.0009. It also reaches over 97.5% mean AUC value with an
STD of 0.0013. In the meanwhile, RoBERTa-CNN outperforms competitive methods,
demonstrating the robustness and ability to capture nuanced linguistic patterns
for suicidal intentions. Therefore, RoBERTa-CNN can detect suicide intention on
text data very well. | [
-0.1850336790084839,
-1.2296465635299683,
0.9023221135139465,
0.4043261408805847,
-0.5130273699760437,
-0.4071597754955292,
-0.41599732637405396,
-0.169744074344635,
-0.052343811839818954,
-0.0737357810139656,
-0.8745896220207214,
-0.942006528377533,
-0.9118250608444214,
0.020451517775654793,
-0.3782576024532318,
1.3007885217666626,
0.16299580037593842,
0.4900800585746765,
-0.048969022929668427,
-0.0978907123208046,
-0.27507731318473816,
-0.17048926651477814,
-1.3988959789276123,
-0.003685188479721546,
0.8994943499565125,
0.0955449566245079,
0.7059447169303894,
-0.1952163279056549,
0.7314963936805725,
0.1091037467122078,
-0.2163047045469284,
0.2988835871219635,
-0.5884474515914917,
-0.12404625862836838,
0.2599368989467621,
0.006253563333302736,
-0.45215684175491333,
0.12993615865707397,
0.2185598611831665,
-0.04368848726153374,
0.04455557093024254,
0.5106688141822815,
0.10357183963060379,
0.78707355260849,
-0.42634934186935425,
-0.1818181872367859,
-0.29694533348083496,
0.16886013746261597,
-0.12307056784629822,
-0.0191788449883461,
-0.5310042500495911,
-0.5546329021453857,
-0.01838655211031437,
-0.11985884606838226,
0.0955524668097496,
-0.5863350033760071,
0.7776460647583008,
0.5452035665512085,
-0.3366423547267914,
-0.4403580129146576,
-0.8267350792884827,
0.9105175137519836,
-0.7849298119544983,
0.33047065138816833,
0.28975430130958557,
0.45462921261787415,
-0.2505512535572052,
-0.18882454931735992,
-0.5622852444648743,
0.04210786893963814,
0.037607062608003616,
0.28530633449554443,
-0.49535873532295227,
-0.08185475319623947,
-0.06472669541835785,
0.20006228983402252,
-1.1001365184783936,
-0.10583656281232834,
-0.16525505483150482,
0.08887914568185806,
0.8364607095718384,
0.02496497705578804,
0.5415454506874084,
-0.5281240940093994,
-0.3977383077144623,
0.1847994476556778,
-0.08820704370737076,
0.1256081461906433,
0.5128889083862305,
0.11817018687725067,
-0.20483934879302979,
0.5378016233444214,
0.000012968783266842365,
1.1045957803726196,
-0.2703385651111603,
-0.11344942450523376,
-0.1884869486093521,
-0.11554790288209915,
-0.15560707449913025,
-0.08385390043258667,
1.0294054746627808,
0.6100391149520874,
0.34328773617744446,
0.36596620082855225,
0.12410172820091248,
-0.11107877641916275,
0.4926967918872833,
-0.6559231877326965,
-0.4706338942050934,
0.5810397267341614,
-1.1430779695510864,
-0.45954835414886475,
-0.23669275641441345,
-0.49446094036102295,
-0.18498605489730835,
-0.20615142583847046,
0.3997383117675781,
-0.8203932642936707,
-0.21688757836818695,
0.08865197747945786,
-0.22502902150154114,
-0.09314710646867752,
0.49571841955184937,
-0.33979323506355286,
-0.19571664929389954,
0.8217715620994568,
1.0471055507659912,
-0.22575372457504272,
0.17357391119003296,
-0.40044546127319336,
-0.1721661537885666,
0.13544884324073792,
0.7628278136253357,
-0.2630760073661804,
-0.1126670241355896,
-0.08113467693328857,
-0.2870327830314636,
0.22263726592063904,
-0.003545482875779271,
1.25934636592865,
-0.4714920222759247,
0.27650269865989685,
0.2007657289505005,
-0.52617347240448,
-0.4072531759738922,
0.6263920664787292,
-0.6564478278160095,
0.8515301942825317,
-0.22706763446331024,
-0.7253579497337341,
0.3286571800708771,
-0.6773231029510498,
-0.5464295148849487,
-0.2707567811012268,
0.18527087569236755,
-1.0734186172485352,
0.15163388848304749,
0.2577960789203644,
0.8874105215072632,
-0.020294692367315292,
0.23473811149597168,
-0.5318124294281006,
-0.16757220029830933,
0.6113235950469971,
-0.972872257232666,
1.0988324880599976,
0.4350574314594269,
0.1393013596534729,
0.11129513382911682,
-0.717193603515625,
0.250645250082016,
0.026575319468975067,
-0.5125845074653625,
-0.48626232147216797,
0.10874994099140167,
0.44416260719299316,
0.220084547996521,
0.42525631189346313,
-0.6597524881362915,
-0.1615961194038391,
0.011541023850440979,
0.44589245319366455,
0.38803809881210327,
0.44208434224128723,
0.15490445494651794,
-0.34081825613975525,
0.4821729063987732,
-0.08529189974069595,
1.0224162340164185,
0.49613121151924133,
-0.9354970455169678,
-0.21126005053520203,
-0.5108914971351624,
0.12175174802541733,
0.5085089802742004,
-0.013042434118688107,
0.7282360792160034,
0.14641869068145752,
-0.6867044568061829,
-0.4184158742427826,
-0.062469612807035446,
0.33298560976982117,
0.4188506305217743,
0.5566693544387817,
0.05246604606509209,
-0.6397829055786133,
-0.7893358469009399,
-0.4292128086090088,
-0.019599674269557,
-0.09706676006317139,
0.20088988542556763,
-0.0011176812695339322,
-0.04224766418337822,
0.7527259588241577,
-0.5479814410209656,
-0.6867258548736572,
-0.5345527529716492,
0.3426056206226349,
0.43541276454925537,
0.4009503722190857,
0.4870501756668091,
-1.3771425485610962,
-0.7669988870620728,
-0.3365499675273895,
-1.0386240482330322,
0.394307404756546,
-0.44081825017929077,
-0.16884513199329376,
0.17795857787132263,
-0.0003988433163613081,
-0.6029790639877319,
0.8483640551567078,
0.6974738836288452,
0.1794101893901825,
0.3146057724952698,
-0.18417459726333618,
0.2104194015264511,
-1.0683215856552124,
-0.1752466857433319,
0.2784840166568756,
-0.08830136805772781,
-0.7962790727615356,
-0.4812362492084503,
0.009426528587937355,
-0.22857190668582916,
-0.5469741225242615,
0.12379995733499527,
-0.3008943200111389,
0.07346411049365997,
-0.16959139704704285,
0.10539722442626953,
-0.027456961572170258,
0.15643243491649628,
-0.008733774535357952,
0.49567243456840515,
0.18936757743358612,
-0.3463476598262787,
-0.09596037864685059,
0.5120548605918884,
-0.21825121343135834,
0.6997231245040894,
-0.5631619691848755,
-0.07031559199094772,
-0.3485722839832306,
0.4580978453159332,
-1.1303739547729492,
-0.18512485921382904,
0.22548861801624298,
-1.0769606828689575,
-0.08385223150253296,
-0.3077123463153839,
-0.3032352328300476,
-0.3210521936416626,
-0.3065537214279175,
0.4504491984844208,
0.514247715473175,
-0.02730068564414978,
0.7320492267608643,
0.260720819234848,
0.07522030919790268,
-0.21303030848503113,
-0.9546365141868591,
0.2054472267627716,
-0.3214171230792999,
-0.7209483981132507,
0.12815390527248383,
-0.025217942893505096,
0.03579067066311836,
0.07398195564746857,
0.33185967803001404,
-0.32007259130477905,
0.0934489294886589,
0.23112362623214722,
0.23861227929592133,
-0.05612471327185631,
0.263480007648468,
0.024266382679343224,
-0.2836065888404846,
0.05763975530862808,
-0.04893214628100395,
0.7200314402580261,
0.2732938528060913,
-0.18321235477924347,
-1.3298602104187012,
0.49019256234169006,
0.4942614436149597,
-0.2727985680103302,
0.9467970132827759,
0.840672492980957,
-0.4121232032775879,
-0.27736037969589233,
-0.285771906375885,
0.07636608183383942,
-0.3550097644329071,
-0.06305770576000214,
0.1003190279006958,
-0.37646570801734924,
0.42486220598220825,
0.03872038051486015,
-0.16532091796398163,
0.14874088764190674,
0.4023991823196411,
-0.5937844514846802,
1.1659281253814697,
0.42749616503715515,
-0.19400295615196228,
0.7863532900810242,
-0.3830344080924988,
0.6929137110710144,
-0.9832888841629028,
0.17804250121116638,
-0.20282363891601562,
-0.5872843265533447,
-0.3671315014362335,
-0.25100862979888916,
0.9347590804100037,
0.20064236223697662,
-0.12013421207666397,
0.349345862865448,
-0.8214273452758789,
0.2827308773994446,
0.3840029835700989,
0.8904242515563965,
0.344264417886734,
-0.16895975172519684,
0.8032820820808411,
-0.3184564411640167,
-0.40794825553894043,
-0.5622542500495911,
1.1348239183425903,
-0.0472341813147068,
0.47273486852645874,
0.30240368843078613,
0.8524185419082642,
0.568313479423523,
0.357665091753006,
-0.6377984285354614,
0.33544063568115234,
-0.6465036273002625,
-0.5061697363853455,
-0.4727119505405426,
-0.2837185859680176,
-0.6769806742668152,
-0.5202450752258301,
-0.28669190406799316,
-0.44219058752059937,
-0.047839514911174774,
0.17092585563659668,
-0.5401623249053955,
0.15454979240894318,
-0.5359824299812317,
1.0394504070281982,
-0.4888482689857483,
0.1606443226337433,
-0.5098008513450623,
-0.455963671207428,
0.48255664110183716,
0.05008349567651749,
0.0652698203921318,
-0.3612675964832306,
0.3435508608818054,
0.413754403591156,
-0.2763770818710327,
0.7212008237838745,
-0.35441920161247253,
0.17859269678592682,
0.3656313419342041,
0.11311586946249008,
0.7263159155845642,
0.3032515048980713,
-0.39096593856811523,
0.29071205854415894,
-0.6391730904579163,
-0.3310065269470215,
-0.7186786532402039,
0.6414318084716797,
-0.46893593668937683,
-0.1163310557603836,
-0.14163178205490112,
-0.35263338685035706,
0.053365711122751236,
0.2425961196422577,
0.4285728335380554,
0.3827870190143585,
-0.5470355153083801,
0.007208458613604307,
0.6575008034706116,
-0.23818440735340118,
0.3149551749229431,
0.29248085618019104,
-0.0042361547239124775,
-0.449150413274765,
0.9366258382797241,
0.1918897032737732,
0.22167733311653137,
0.1953524947166443,
0.28204619884490967,
-0.13365520536899567,
-0.8634910583496094,
-0.5149692296981812,
0.15090754628181458,
-0.4737488627433777,
-0.41579514741897583,
-0.7220383286476135,
-0.3190494179725647,
-0.1673968881368637,
-0.2939116954803467,
-0.21319818496704102,
-0.2628166079521179,
-0.6717486381530762,
-0.00036307756090536714,
0.8124038577079773,
0.7091307044029236,
-0.16502390801906586,
0.10608111321926117,
-1.0943748950958252,
0.3634032905101776,
0.004298612475395203,
-0.09374894201755524,
-0.03291086107492447,
-0.10555950552225113,
0.0009543030173517764,
0.2943171262741089,
-0.09494739025831223,
-0.8677434921264648,
0.26129940152168274,
0.3615162670612335,
0.14599601924419403,
0.6109305024147034,
0.47367262840270996,
0.7509719729423523,
-0.1683080494403839,
0.8666691184043884,
0.1742452085018158,
-0.7277144193649292,
1.0520814657211304,
-0.6634719967842102,
0.1520356982946396,
0.8061404228210449,
0.8683159947395325,
-0.795106053352356,
-0.6568461060523987,
-0.6259050369262695,
-0.5013515949249268,
0.3357151448726654,
0.48865023255348206,
0.17008106410503387,
-0.1449512541294098,
0.3504059910774231,
-0.05300486460328102,
-0.06591448932886124,
-0.6275994181632996,
-0.1837444305419922,
-0.059998318552970886,
-0.8828995823860168,
0.20050989091396332,
-0.1800951063632965,
-0.10804619640111923,
-0.13791412115097046,
0.5591503381729126,
0.08257189393043518,
0.48235753178596497,
0.39901936054229736,
0.021852713078260422,
-0.00864030234515667,
-0.1445791870355606,
0.6542524099349976,
0.31659364700317383,
-0.15195463597774506,
-0.07419749349355698,
0.050770532339811325,
-0.2762450873851776,
0.07787083089351654,
-0.08079613745212555,
-0.5613667964935303,
0.24539974331855774,
0.43330222368240356,
0.23042204976081848,
0.10107208788394928,
-0.5989053845405579,
0.8696839213371277,
-0.5781959891319275,
0.1789650321006775,
-0.8106554746627808,
0.15260078012943268,
0.08700976520776749,
0.33457785844802856,
0.22567185759544373,
0.43172526359558105,
0.4089311361312866,
-0.4191891849040985,
0.34170395135879517,
0.6138668656349182,
-0.39704087376594543,
-0.383056640625,
0.5730514526367188,
-0.037806637585163116,
-0.8121090531349182,
0.5480601191520691,
-0.3830496370792389,
-0.638181209564209,
0.5186976194381714,
0.09514376521110535,
1.0711731910705566,
-0.037336986511945724,
0.8180760741233826,
0.5219337940216064,
-0.026397094130516052,
0.04195188358426094,
0.6298823952674866,
-0.24173346161842346,
-0.5812216401100159,
-0.14501529932022095,
-0.7194423079490662,
-0.11900538951158524,
0.06505855917930603,
-0.9560648798942566,
0.33224600553512573,
-0.6908425688743591,
-0.26761382818222046,
0.18381860852241516,
-0.25381216406822205,
-0.4717881679534912,
0.3989955186843872,
0.03704136610031128,
0.7406867146492004,
-0.9185921549797058,
0.6804742813110352,
0.28550711274147034,
-0.6575355529785156,
-0.6766026020050049,
0.5326623320579529,
0.2559828460216522,
-0.5794143676757812,
0.5358716249465942,
0.24638806283473969,
-0.06734104454517365,
-0.04561801999807358,
-0.45804691314697266,
-0.818061888217926,
0.7362157106399536,
-0.059676628559827805,
-0.16956691443920135,
0.2079712450504303,
0.1445365846157074,
0.8036962747573853,
-0.23833101987838745,
0.08382303267717361,
0.20400694012641907,
0.7074032425880432,
-0.24238695204257965,
-0.32103225588798523,
-0.1312946230173111,
0.07059042900800705,
-0.024973588064312935,
0.3700072765350342,
-0.9957571029663086,
0.722853422164917,
-0.05638023093342781,
-0.4008617103099823,
0.06599696725606918,
0.6382535696029663,
-0.0429559201002121,
0.46674707531929016,
0.486277312040329,
0.833512008190155,
0.6733962893486023,
0.05993477255105972,
0.8944293260574341,
-0.09216643869876862,
0.5261926054954529,
0.9227740168571472,
0.018566874787211418,
1.1530303955078125,
0.11129492521286011,
-0.14386431872844696,
0.6052343249320984,
0.6609184741973877,
0.013694588094949722,
0.6664925217628479,
-0.2532488703727722,
-0.5727179646492004,
-0.5064202547073364,
-0.05130259692668915,
0.1888401061296463,
0.47491928935050964,
0.3180783987045288,
-0.4833325147628784,
-0.42629873752593994,
0.5624401569366455,
0.3295476734638214,
0.18753108382225037,
0.002451318083330989,
1.0483953952789307,
-0.11587540805339813,
-0.4905220568180084,
0.42000773549079895,
-0.28698045015335083,
0.4236665666103363,
-0.3517403304576874,
-0.08941279351711273,
0.08110576868057251,
0.3207648694515228,
-0.39797917008399963,
-1.0990102291107178,
0.799953818321228,
0.38413113355636597,
-0.495331346988678,
-0.41272327303886414,
0.7371225953102112,
-0.3762355148792267,
-0.864204466342926,
0.31518232822418213,
0.06083028391003609,
0.33983922004699707,
-0.3129391372203827,
-0.9359414577484131,
0.22495292127132416,
0.08523058891296387,
-0.2739414572715759,
0.07605074346065521,
0.5659000277519226,
0.11307922005653381,
0.48429062962532043,
0.9552146196365356,
0.06418842077255249,
-0.10790380090475082,
0.002307780785486102,
0.6966214179992676,
-0.41942447423934937,
-0.3690139949321747,
-0.8334345817565918,
0.745164692401886,
-0.3461703956127167,
-0.6666445732116699,
0.7735275030136108,
0.5019019842147827,
0.675390362739563,
0.10661337524652481,
0.6816534399986267,
-0.29819828271865845,
0.7702770829200745,
-0.5928563475608826,
1.0490080118179321,
-0.5160152316093445,
-0.15603910386562347,
-0.15227191150188446,
-0.6316726207733154,
-0.6641589403152466,
0.7378671765327454,
-0.5689688920974731,
-0.07089714705944061,
0.4654121398925781,
0.6249056458473206,
0.0682947039604187,
0.047468315809965134,
0.11832418292760849,
0.12045570462942123,
0.4191480875015259,
0.515616774559021,
0.6085758805274963,
-0.7384725213050842,
0.6189968585968018,
-0.1606774628162384,
-0.19414955377578735,
-0.31863969564437866,
-0.6967604160308838,
-0.9668030738830566,
-0.66033935546875,
-0.20429523289203644,
-0.07882994413375854,
0.15325495600700378,
0.6428258419036865,
0.547359824180603,
-0.624444842338562,
0.42067667841911316,
-0.39054417610168457,
0.210427924990654,
-0.3668484091758728,
-0.26287129521369934,
0.5246699452400208,
-0.3248630464076996,
-0.5555218458175659,
0.3541620373725891,
0.2838720679283142,
0.010292190127074718,
-0.276627779006958,
-0.09411926567554474,
-0.4669499397277832,
-0.12237119674682617,
0.4673474431037903,
-0.153009295463562,
-0.6386829614639282,
-0.5935348272323608,
-0.2538686692714691,
-0.19879168272018433,
0.006620470900088549,
0.7622661590576172,
-0.42176494002342224,
0.14537490904331207,
0.5453441739082336,
0.40105965733528137,
0.36819905042648315,
0.3411153554916382,
0.37463176250457764,
-0.6768240332603455,
-0.038098711520433426,
0.5397167205810547,
0.02785653993487358,
0.35073333978652954,
-1.0228947401046753,
0.17268885672092438,
-0.3010115921497345,
-0.8583009243011475,
-0.679472804069519,
0.236678346991539,
-1.1470202207565308,
-0.42258986830711365,
0.817459762096405,
-0.3217954933643341,
-0.5644522309303284,
-0.11828745156526566,
-0.3365510106086731,
0.36125314235687256,
-0.5662185549736023,
0.969124436378479,
0.5824189186096191,
-0.46472761034965515,
-0.22833123803138733,
-0.6110059022903442,
0.866191565990448,
0.2134062945842743,
-0.619767427444458,
0.16277629137039185,
0.37063267827033997,
0.09941885620355606,
0.0474013015627861,
0.529865562915802,
0.14269676804542542,
0.6552067995071411,
-0.5710136294364929,
-0.027266591787338257,
0.07150734961032867,
-0.31526055932044983,
-0.455597847700119,
0.12277835607528687,
-0.45548853278160095,
-0.3078175187110901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02255v1 | Frequency Explains the Inverse Correlation of Large Language Models' Size, Training Data Amount, and Surprisal's Fit to Reading Times | 2024-02-03T20:22:54 | 2024-02-03T20:22:54 | Byung-Doh Oh, Shisen Yue, William Schuler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent studies have shown that as Transformer-based language models become
larger and are trained on very large amounts of data, the fit of their
surprisal estimates to naturalistic human reading times degrades. The current
work presents a series of analyses showing that word frequency is a key
explanatory factor underlying these two trends. First, residual errors from
four language model families on four corpora show that the inverse correlation
between model size and fit to reading times is the strongest on the subset of
least frequent words, which is driven by excessively accurate predictions of
larger model variants. Additionally, training dynamics reveal that during later
training steps, all model variants learn to predict rare words and that larger
model variants do so more accurately, which explains the detrimental effect of
both training data amount and model size on fit to reading times. Finally, a
feature attribution analysis demonstrates that larger model variants are able
to accurately predict rare words based on both an effectively longer context
window size as well as stronger local associations compared to smaller model
variants. Taken together, these results indicate that Transformer-based
language models' surprisal estimates diverge from human-like expectations due
to the superhumanly complex associations they learn for predicting rare words. | [
-0.7249269485473633,
-0.7873331904411316,
0.2351781278848648,
-0.0049067395739257336,
-0.2903842329978943,
-0.1602063924074173,
-0.15055717527866364,
-0.6606124639511108,
0.11942583322525024,
0.5581369400024414,
-0.4442889094352722,
0.13816533982753754,
-0.5444136261940002,
0.2808857560157776,
-0.6933026909828186,
0.745399534702301,
0.1687682867050171,
0.1051846593618393,
0.00840790942311287,
-0.31019681692123413,
-0.5180113911628723,
-0.6835379600524902,
-0.14566175639629364,
-0.654105544090271,
0.48980948328971863,
0.10594506561756134,
1.1123663187026978,
0.683765709400177,
0.6629586815834045,
0.18402177095413208,
-0.0818617194890976,
-0.31657570600509644,
-0.6890777945518494,
0.025508655235171318,
0.14478474855422974,
-0.6409332156181335,
0.033213239163160324,
-0.01460633147507906,
0.6998259425163269,
1.2139803171157837,
-0.11899389326572418,
0.19270892441272736,
0.23429328203201294,
0.9082158803939819,
-0.4062700569629669,
0.20994849503040314,
-0.5340741276741028,
-0.3040897846221924,
-0.31397882103919983,
-0.14472118020057678,
-0.2696254849433899,
-0.228799968957901,
0.06782550364732742,
-0.5409464240074158,
0.5772716403007507,
0.4105847179889679,
0.9575523734092712,
0.29202672839164734,
-0.32634368538856506,
-0.22575852274894714,
-0.8444623947143555,
0.9074122309684753,
-0.41390231251716614,
0.7259365916252136,
0.6411280035972595,
0.012581633403897285,
-0.12489932775497437,
-0.4256470203399658,
-0.861095666885376,
-0.41302597522735596,
-0.3148946464061737,
-0.16298313438892365,
-0.43054237961769104,
-0.08826947957277298,
0.43234705924987793,
0.32792937755584717,
-0.62677401304245,
-0.02094903588294983,
-0.46980011463165283,
0.2437696009874344,
0.43487152457237244,
0.1666083186864853,
0.35798004269599915,
0.018155792728066444,
-0.07131726294755936,
-0.08988036960363388,
-0.8903834819793701,
-0.06057099625468254,
0.4557384252548218,
0.2524007260799408,
-0.05888640880584717,
0.5606338977813721,
-0.0157927218824625,
0.9128724932670593,
-0.15986280143260956,
-0.07456772774457932,
0.42911386489868164,
-0.304177463054657,
-0.056462612003088,
0.11195071041584015,
0.5985965728759766,
0.3019807040691376,
0.6846349835395813,
-0.2570098340511322,
0.00741654634475708,
0.10435396432876587,
0.1492321491241455,
-0.5828155875205994,
0.04611345753073692,
-0.21124495565891266,
-0.47751593589782715,
-0.20177918672561646,
0.20816954970359802,
-0.6836727261543274,
-0.2526247203350067,
-0.5176711082458496,
0.4025656282901764,
-0.5352660417556763,
-0.08804522454738617,
0.3361321687698364,
-0.23506693542003632,
0.07955271750688553,
-0.15048451721668243,
-0.9841901063919067,
0.5085634589195251,
0.7270820140838623,
0.8444613218307495,
-0.20574136078357697,
-0.2948642373085022,
-0.30507275462150574,
-0.012188426218926907,
-0.5518695712089539,
0.6285185813903809,
-0.7870755791664124,
-0.493838369846344,
-0.04785187542438507,
0.18316510319709778,
-0.3007858395576477,
-0.3607768416404724,
0.2835352420806885,
-0.8026418685913086,
0.09940142929553986,
-0.31388184428215027,
-0.39887598156929016,
-0.19397898018360138,
-0.26956993341445923,
-0.9892232418060303,
1.014467477798462,
0.13890452682971954,
-0.8738390207290649,
0.5072319507598877,
-0.26387569308280945,
-0.3073980510234833,
0.14091497659683228,
0.03893900290131569,
-0.3114970922470093,
0.5727192163467407,
-0.06037597730755806,
0.13746145367622375,
-0.5089816451072693,
0.13758987188339233,
-0.5286054015159607,
-0.815821647644043,
0.6064669489860535,
-0.8023992776870728,
0.623822033405304,
0.2758010923862457,
-0.18431003391742706,
-0.40598273277282715,
-0.7494916915893555,
-0.4817058742046356,
0.04975176230072975,
-0.060532137751579285,
-0.8316081166267395,
0.1986905336380005,
0.1550736129283905,
0.06464090943336487,
-0.03755435347557068,
-0.7539631724357605,
0.08310241997241974,
-0.6005258560180664,
0.3022506535053253,
0.2627616822719574,
0.13347360491752625,
0.18553243577480316,
-0.6426056027412415,
0.5485285520553589,
-0.19427362084388733,
0.019963877275586128,
0.036245185881853104,
-0.3603106439113617,
-0.39711901545524597,
-0.1693420708179474,
0.21532955765724182,
0.29778212308883667,
-0.39575743675231934,
0.21971318125724792,
-1.002920389175415,
-0.5867729187011719,
-0.5602340698242188,
0.2083132117986679,
0.2553797662258148,
0.4661236107349396,
0.37447991967201233,
-0.29044297337532043,
-0.2040736973285675,
-0.9555599093437195,
-0.4004213809967041,
-0.14180923998355865,
-0.10023171454668045,
0.24136514961719513,
0.4864833652973175,
-0.2270466387271881,
1.1480141878128052,
-0.6949867606163025,
-0.18695522844791412,
-0.5048896074295044,
0.12460799515247345,
0.3567865788936615,
0.14651115238666534,
0.7200117111206055,
-0.95880126953125,
-0.3414750099182129,
-0.2514632046222687,
-0.1797276884317398,
-0.21831467747688293,
-0.07274048775434494,
0.26171186566352844,
0.401104211807251,
0.6034519672393799,
-0.1663132756948471,
0.44770103693008423,
0.7515518069267273,
-0.22635623812675476,
0.37121617794036865,
-0.20975059270858765,
-0.09938696026802063,
-0.83902508020401,
0.25944554805755615,
0.09936872869729996,
0.1653793305158615,
-0.4868100583553314,
-0.18284441530704498,
0.016105778515338898,
0.015334094874560833,
-0.03500007092952728,
0.7336186170578003,
-0.44788166880607605,
-0.2077774703502655,
-0.18373611569404602,
0.10883621871471405,
0.048481643199920654,
0.3068184554576874,
0.005931669846177101,
0.8792973160743713,
0.0371139757335186,
-0.5872290134429932,
0.22380273044109344,
0.342917263507843,
-0.6589125990867615,
0.05131109058856964,
-0.9098191261291504,
-0.48870155215263367,
-0.19358104467391968,
0.08555228263139725,
-1.327635645866394,
-0.11326476186513901,
-0.32298314571380615,
-0.28263893723487854,
0.36420464515686035,
0.2524957060813904,
-0.6638022661209106,
-0.4558790326118469,
-0.19876079261302948,
0.3313332200050354,
0.5177440643310547,
-0.5182530283927917,
0.607090413570404,
0.38438770174980164,
-0.1478661149740219,
-0.62623131275177,
-1.056201696395874,
-0.27691107988357544,
-0.14903460443019867,
-0.4383738040924072,
0.25820475816726685,
-0.02957678958773613,
-0.5711230039596558,
0.05343788489699364,
-0.16649176180362701,
-0.029051687568426132,
0.21475791931152344,
0.5515128374099731,
0.32851025462150574,
-0.16550129652023315,
0.5415478944778442,
-0.2459978461265564,
-0.15129873156547546,
-0.07346831262111664,
0.19114388525485992,
0.9262858629226685,
-0.1758912205696106,
-0.2907647490501404,
-0.05955912917852402,
0.08586962521076202,
0.6158565878868103,
-0.25100499391555786,
1.235848307609558,
0.30349287390708923,
0.031975049525499344,
0.1767599880695343,
-0.6028804183006287,
-0.14750447869300842,
-0.4345340132713318,
0.5486944317817688,
-0.5435051918029785,
-0.5144287943840027,
0.535752534866333,
0.4407166838645935,
-0.12463049590587616,
0.588062584400177,
0.40929707884788513,
-0.05522393435239792,
0.955175518989563,
0.8082102537155151,
-0.23513537645339966,
0.8040257692337036,
-0.02002238854765892,
-0.0008035713108256459,
-0.7057060599327087,
-0.014437565580010414,
-0.48450636863708496,
-0.12560880184173584,
-0.750148355960846,
-0.0002921273116953671,
0.3100990653038025,
0.12956847250461578,
-0.24149049818515778,
0.39389100670814514,
-0.25140324234962463,
0.46167048811912537,
0.5120983719825745,
-0.08071938157081604,
0.47007977962493896,
0.2550380825996399,
0.11129522323608398,
-0.11159255355596542,
-0.5518458485603333,
-0.3554026484489441,
1.0244585275650024,
0.4084240198135376,
0.8455273509025574,
0.11011724919080734,
0.20418980717658997,
0.13682687282562256,
0.49569234251976013,
-0.8925877809524536,
0.2343619465827942,
-0.6182936429977417,
-0.8222786784172058,
-0.3313505947589874,
-0.2239300012588501,
-1.1228206157684326,
0.12766723334789276,
-0.1588524878025055,
-0.5084277987480164,
0.3217763900756836,
0.10432648658752441,
-0.09475560486316681,
0.1989571750164032,
-0.4632789194583893,
0.6902949810028076,
0.13631556928157806,
-0.03271038085222244,
-0.3697461187839508,
-0.6763354539871216,
0.40697354078292847,
-0.6360884308815002,
0.4482099711894989,
-0.11165614426136017,
-0.06653273105621338,
0.5519871711730957,
-0.3355112373828888,
0.8433164954185486,
0.31561410427093506,
-0.05009661242365837,
0.099403515458107,
0.20633649826049805,
0.43783700466156006,
-0.24567627906799316,
-0.2610766291618347,
0.4163999855518341,
0.17989927530288696,
-0.20348474383354187,
-0.401652991771698,
0.39083635807037354,
-0.9144893884658813,
-0.37975388765335083,
-0.3870637118816376,
-0.7443702220916748,
-0.29288214445114136,
0.0034711204934865236,
0.5308094024658203,
0.9910886287689209,
-0.1865147054195404,
0.6715788841247559,
0.604306161403656,
-0.15804746747016907,
0.5296282768249512,
0.77938312292099,
-0.26362308859825134,
-0.11500217765569687,
0.7794144153594971,
0.5328812599182129,
0.4909330904483795,
0.6650571823120117,
0.21971459686756134,
-0.26370617747306824,
-0.3096926510334015,
0.2023802548646927,
0.5722469091415405,
-0.3548998236656189,
0.12662944197654724,
-0.7479988932609558,
0.04141884669661522,
-0.3694165050983429,
-0.1412518173456192,
-0.024702657014131546,
-0.4538366198539734,
-0.20897768437862396,
0.10929220914840698,
0.5562602281570435,
0.6224199533462524,
0.15509440004825592,
0.8689193725585938,
-0.6383247375488281,
0.3723611831665039,
0.2028975486755371,
0.4974519908428192,
-0.1042906790971756,
-1.0465806722640991,
-0.09644242376089096,
-0.06763193756341934,
0.21949782967567444,
-0.8423962593078613,
0.5439713597297668,
0.39021769165992737,
0.5431303977966309,
0.3624805212020874,
-0.0674639642238617,
0.44880959391593933,
-0.5372110605239868,
0.7197007536888123,
0.059442032128572464,
-0.8725326061248779,
-0.10560975968837738,
-0.30602458119392395,
0.20376549661159515,
0.5175930261611938,
0.5429990291595459,
-1.0647937059402466,
-0.27713245153427124,
-0.6981967091560364,
-0.7986729741096497,
0.7843053340911865,
-0.15094998478889465,
0.39646515250205994,
-0.08629510551691055,
0.3684135973453522,
0.2827439308166504,
0.10999532788991928,
-0.4768814444541931,
-0.4804714620113373,
-0.26721715927124023,
-0.35137781500816345,
-0.61664879322052,
-0.5474280714988708,
0.06408499926328659,
-0.10175532102584839,
0.6745249629020691,
-0.13470491766929626,
0.06933829188346863,
-0.14424578845500946,
-0.3063168227672577,
-0.2760748565196991,
0.22942131757736206,
0.8665519952774048,
0.7035177946090698,
-0.36847159266471863,
0.0970231369137764,
0.40717852115631104,
-0.931958794593811,
-0.12005946040153503,
0.09945124387741089,
0.07323876768350601,
0.1572480946779251,
0.7247425317764282,
0.7872496247291565,
0.32451289892196655,
-0.6326072216033936,
0.5988266468048096,
-0.024132907390594482,
0.085207499563694,
-0.538346529006958,
0.15986590087413788,
0.18986211717128754,
-0.18366751074790955,
0.5060577988624573,
-0.015648530796170235,
-0.1630122810602188,
-0.5075443387031555,
0.2572390139102936,
0.3707432150840759,
-0.5984740257263184,
-0.43570753931999207,
0.5236162543296814,
-0.09818465262651443,
0.017297079786658287,
0.5543978214263916,
0.15189099311828613,
-0.35710063576698303,
0.7393962740898132,
0.5770163536071777,
0.6179690361022949,
-0.17829783260822296,
-0.021417248994112015,
0.29887494444847107,
0.41883644461631775,
-0.38581082224845886,
0.07744956761598587,
0.29976963996887207,
-0.7969030737876892,
-0.31293734908103943,
-1.007157325744629,
0.04979616403579712,
0.3075105547904968,
-0.7355078458786011,
0.28617212176322937,
0.008503898046910763,
-0.05091669782996178,
0.16774651408195496,
0.12849852442741394,
-0.6047881841659546,
0.12575633823871613,
0.011947362683713436,
0.8785863518714905,
-1.1067606210708618,
0.9121285676956177,
0.3785664439201355,
-0.6795404553413391,
-0.9054924845695496,
0.07853487879037857,
-0.01169775240123272,
-0.9544025659561157,
1.190613031387329,
0.06929676979780197,
-0.18620546162128448,
0.22397413849830627,
-0.42472952604293823,
-1.2137974500656128,
0.7513068318367004,
0.20310236513614655,
-0.9177374839782715,
-0.07426459342241287,
0.3040255010128021,
0.8711000680923462,
-0.2732945680618286,
0.2680347263813019,
0.627800703048706,
0.24057266116142273,
0.057844050228595734,
-0.9252289533615112,
-0.08312670141458511,
0.062277134507894516,
0.27632588148117065,
0.6014706492424011,
-0.5527489185333252,
0.8234357237815857,
-0.11874538660049438,
-0.2578599750995636,
0.006157896015793085,
0.4518059492111206,
-0.06651496142148972,
-0.08695142716169357,
0.5345947742462158,
0.27227020263671875,
0.26209038496017456,
-0.00911486241966486,
1.4760009050369263,
-0.7936345338821411,
0.4431876540184021,
0.8787791728973389,
-0.033129069954156876,
0.9360337257385254,
0.4605931341648102,
-0.39681583642959595,
0.3573106825351715,
0.3809199035167694,
-0.4030679166316986,
0.30993351340293884,
0.023484349250793457,
0.0006847708718851209,
-0.343639075756073,
-0.20148883759975433,
-0.4559873938560486,
0.4379139840602875,
0.48826631903648376,
-0.5986969470977783,
-0.11314714699983597,
0.15677469968795776,
-0.10238887369632721,
0.013942526653409004,
-0.17413221299648285,
0.4632624089717865,
0.17954500019550323,
-0.44522637128829956,
0.6316770911216736,
-0.2484028935432434,
0.6256532073020935,
-0.6911170482635498,
0.32803070545196533,
-0.2670356333255768,
0.3392947316169739,
0.023524049669504166,
-0.8195290565490723,
0.36412736773490906,
-0.3801664113998413,
-0.37614551186561584,
0.10025709867477417,
0.487674742937088,
-0.4828043282032013,
-0.4997607171535492,
0.1527627855539322,
0.36679428815841675,
0.08953141421079636,
-0.06862203776836395,
-0.48036330938339233,
0.06985743343830109,
-0.14014263451099396,
-0.5791111588478088,
0.19181038439273834,
0.15306121110916138,
-0.24424730241298676,
0.8048591017723083,
0.4685433804988861,
0.28290632367134094,
-0.0033471507485955954,
0.06118389591574669,
0.5250722765922546,
-0.5774967074394226,
-0.2199520766735077,
-0.8522830009460449,
-0.07406003028154373,
0.2270975559949875,
-0.37861907482147217,
0.5905309915542603,
0.5419138669967651,
0.5899485349655151,
-0.20153245329856873,
0.5017130374908447,
0.1516004502773285,
0.7013894319534302,
-0.23756249248981476,
0.728977382183075,
-0.6124939322471619,
0.3590086102485657,
-0.1869901418685913,
-1.1481199264526367,
-0.2450878769159317,
0.36494725942611694,
-0.71929532289505,
-0.019979000091552734,
0.655647337436676,
0.7122189402580261,
-0.10852478444576263,
0.16825653612613678,
0.43451470136642456,
0.27893418073654175,
0.20500190556049347,
0.14660681784152985,
0.4710470736026764,
-0.4305904507637024,
0.6568369269371033,
-0.19920854270458221,
-0.08735087513923645,
-0.504630982875824,
-0.5560287833213806,
-0.756758451461792,
-0.7772355675697327,
-0.12427131086587906,
-0.22699610888957977,
-0.10163024067878723,
0.9352037906646729,
0.12482631206512451,
-0.7019639611244202,
-0.12087027728557587,
-0.12436289340257645,
-0.23447567224502563,
-0.2868894040584564,
-0.3253742754459381,
0.4982336759567261,
-0.22069208323955536,
-0.6012627482414246,
-0.12227798998355865,
-0.03477798029780388,
0.2568306028842926,
0.060322150588035583,
0.3363129198551178,
-0.034536030143499374,
0.32857123017311096,
0.3059196472167969,
0.4893081486225128,
-0.608278214931488,
-0.22975635528564453,
0.04984138160943985,
-0.5212348699569702,
-0.08966726064682007,
0.6349530220031738,
-0.9149244427680969,
0.3021387755870819,
0.6297709941864014,
0.3387777507305145,
0.4265585243701935,
0.1122412383556366,
0.5960335731506348,
-0.6225911378860474,
0.18204249441623688,
-0.16813714802265167,
0.34503963589668274,
0.1218983605504036,
-0.19909924268722534,
0.6190279126167297,
0.4674811065196991,
-0.3237747848033905,
-0.9509439468383789,
0.23586750030517578,
-0.6588513255119324,
-0.5555998682975769,
1.249611496925354,
0.2648763656616211,
-0.38190576434135437,
-0.3551637530326843,
-0.01904974691569805,
0.2939428985118866,
-0.05153307318687439,
0.7984870076179504,
1.0551255941390991,
-0.1969776451587677,
0.0653282105922699,
-0.8324494957923889,
0.5613090991973877,
0.49622854590415955,
-0.34583592414855957,
0.4317551553249359,
0.40693971514701843,
0.5267038941383362,
0.4855853021144867,
0.07482294738292694,
-0.16008658707141876,
-0.014305262826383114,
0.2139124721288681,
-0.06358734518289566,
-0.1945367008447647,
-0.15799297392368317,
-0.5706332325935364,
0.24411527812480927,
-0.07774826139211655,
0.17935916781425476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02244v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02244v3 | Beyond the Limits: A Survey of Techniques to Extend the Context Length in Large Language Models | 2024-02-03T19:20:02 | 2024-05-29T13:38:25 | Xindi Wang, Mahsa Salmani, Parsa Omidi, Xiangyu Ren, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Armaghan Eshaghi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities
including understanding context, engaging in logical reasoning, and generating
responses. However, this is achieved at the expense of stringent computational
and memory requirements, hindering their ability to effectively support long
input sequences. This survey provides an inclusive review of the recent
techniques and methods devised to extend the sequence length in LLMs, thereby
enhancing their capacity for long-context understanding. In particular, we
review and categorize a wide range of techniques including architectural
modifications, such as modified positional encoding and altered attention
mechanisms, which are designed to enhance the processing of longer sequences
while avoiding a proportional increase in computational requirements. The
diverse methodologies investigated in this study can be leveraged across
different phases of LLMs, i.e., training, fine-tuning and inference. This
enables LLMs to efficiently process extended sequences. The limitations of the
current methodologies is discussed in the last section along with the
suggestions for future research directions, underscoring the importance of
sequence length in the continued advancement of LLMs. | [
-0.7334011793136597,
-0.7890294790267944,
0.9376411437988281,
0.0270099937915802,
-0.2063954919576645,
-0.0755462795495987,
-0.6726793646812439,
-0.6548207402229309,
-0.005328995641320944,
0.6118595600128174,
-0.47476959228515625,
-0.2587571442127228,
-0.5572509169578552,
0.15581656992435455,
-0.3054427206516266,
0.6409062147140503,
-0.11921243369579315,
-0.18655765056610107,
-0.2469119280576706,
-0.18311037123203278,
-0.5706620812416077,
-0.528022050857544,
-0.41190478205680847,
-0.09503539651632309,
0.6103549003601074,
0.4569736123085022,
0.581770658493042,
0.5773131847381592,
0.3416021764278412,
0.250671923160553,
-0.3412683308124542,
0.2803539037704468,
-0.4017009735107422,
0.2874428331851959,
-0.1333528310060501,
-0.3436170220375061,
-0.4692630171775818,
-0.3677706718444824,
1.118454098701477,
0.9459920525550842,
0.26782864332199097,
0.14507734775543213,
0.026486007496714592,
0.6839433312416077,
-0.7979714274406433,
-0.09897155314683914,
-0.2560725808143616,
0.08109015971422195,
-0.2849303185939789,
-0.2872954308986664,
-0.4530685245990753,
-0.028643351048231125,
0.34597375988960266,
-0.22632330656051636,
-0.2877163589000702,
-0.18865083158016205,
0.15806205570697784,
0.013710958883166313,
-0.5742916464805603,
-0.27944377064704895,
-0.9061625599861145,
1.0524673461914062,
-0.8531147837638855,
0.7508997321128845,
0.30653116106987,
0.19897565245628357,
-0.28781935572624207,
-0.5137931108474731,
-0.3965328633785248,
-0.39379122853279114,
0.024717256426811218,
-0.3701828122138977,
0.11018364876508713,
0.14313657581806183,
0.6059262156486511,
0.20221711695194244,
-0.47994616627693176,
0.2520606517791748,
-0.5612102150917053,
0.13146059215068817,
0.6169183850288391,
0.17740246653556824,
0.18588471412658691,
0.13549737632274628,
-0.15916621685028076,
-0.03791484981775284,
-0.9542719125747681,
0.01950262300670147,
0.016774389892816544,
-0.0039030308835208416,
0.16336311399936676,
0.5893789529800415,
-0.288178026676178,
0.9905466437339783,
-0.2960047721862793,
-0.05750390514731407,
0.030774414539337158,
-0.25774478912353516,
-0.39831334352493286,
-0.1829935759305954,
0.27886512875556946,
0.21887069940567017,
0.040946077555418015,
-0.026259250938892365,
-0.08888702839612961,
-0.3532969355583191,
-0.01829647645354271,
-0.621868908405304,
0.397614985704422,
0.26838260889053345,
-0.3335961699485779,
0.226392462849617,
-0.136244535446167,
-0.7460843324661255,
-0.3940684497356415,
-0.5722998976707458,
-0.042322851717472076,
-0.6623666286468506,
-0.10787832736968994,
0.08944450318813324,
-0.04818709194660187,
0.5467706322669983,
0.1426400989294052,
-0.8692117929458618,
0.3244996964931488,
0.9143243432044983,
0.9118937849998474,
-0.08820375800132751,
-0.28370529413223267,
-0.44390973448753357,
0.23642420768737793,
-0.31800585985183716,
0.520017147064209,
-0.779882550239563,
-0.4329409599304199,
0.08175081014633179,
-0.07632093131542206,
0.18713222444057465,
-0.3882247805595398,
0.5129508376121521,
-0.9301804900169373,
0.038867104798555374,
-0.4464587867259979,
-0.8170011043548584,
-0.314849853515625,
0.05640123412013054,
-0.5960745811462402,
0.7085244059562683,
-0.013978483155369759,
-0.343505322933197,
0.2253793179988861,
-0.8949226140975952,
-0.8268032073974609,
-0.009286542423069477,
-0.09429775178432465,
0.04426068440079689,
0.580182671546936,
0.316580593585968,
0.6384986639022827,
-0.3801439702510834,
0.38160187005996704,
-0.4342104494571686,
-0.4031253457069397,
0.38490432500839233,
-0.5252285003662109,
0.5932905077934265,
0.26894471049308777,
-0.169430673122406,
0.3638583719730377,
-0.8524932265281677,
0.03049897961318493,
-0.018529843538999557,
-0.2739245891571045,
-0.29701298475265503,
0.11008709669113159,
-0.10510501265525818,
0.25152724981307983,
0.2490338385105133,
-0.34659677743911743,
0.0829564779996872,
-0.593501091003418,
0.7587656378746033,
0.6406846046447754,
-0.2877258360385895,
0.6734009981155396,
-0.28183838725090027,
0.7046804428100586,
-0.4642437994480133,
0.09423139691352844,
-0.55879145860672,
0.009564115665853024,
-0.7223818898200989,
-0.14579124748706818,
0.013478121720254421,
0.4508381187915802,
-0.4705645442008972,
0.5652855038642883,
-0.6246238350868225,
-0.17539602518081665,
-0.06739714741706848,
0.19610045850276947,
0.1689397692680359,
0.15607838332653046,
0.47461825609207153,
-0.40104320645332336,
-0.9023249745368958,
-0.6372542381286621,
-0.11398278921842575,
0.15821339190006256,
-0.15935179591178894,
0.47308680415153503,
0.4923461675643921,
-0.2924024164676666,
1.0844708681106567,
-0.5512018799781799,
0.19025668501853943,
-0.4000644087791443,
-0.42528170347213745,
0.2967592775821686,
0.325673371553421,
0.3159095346927643,
-0.5730912089347839,
-0.10093935579061508,
-0.09142671525478363,
-0.41604772210121155,
0.006237493362277746,
-0.10682065784931183,
0.321615606546402,
0.3418509364128113,
0.7964579463005066,
-0.777566134929657,
0.32697707414627075,
0.6177821755409241,
-0.12200428545475006,
0.4671647250652313,
-0.10662856698036194,
-0.047225162386894226,
-0.8766852617263794,
0.010740681551396847,
-0.08091016113758087,
-0.36891454458236694,
-0.6624740958213806,
0.5088108777999878,
0.04809033125638962,
-0.07653601467609406,
-0.38951388001441956,
0.9013983011245728,
-0.9430987238883972,
-0.3236033022403717,
-0.5575011372566223,
0.1500149816274643,
0.00019782167510129511,
0.15478403866291046,
0.18890276551246643,
0.6223200559616089,
0.5273275375366211,
-0.634809136390686,
0.6275269985198975,
0.012716074474155903,
-0.6257349252700806,
0.22488835453987122,
-0.447550505399704,
0.15445257723331451,
-0.3417968153953552,
0.6432737708091736,
-1.0676419734954834,
-0.2723347544670105,
0.09008552134037018,
-0.26736220717430115,
0.5455650091171265,
0.00918780080974102,
-0.39818239212036133,
-0.44222190976142883,
-0.4488973319530487,
0.7272014617919922,
0.6291471719741821,
-0.5254063010215759,
0.46850743889808655,
0.19595247507095337,
-0.256779283285141,
-0.5327809453010559,
-0.7737944722175598,
0.45729464292526245,
-0.5891320109367371,
-0.7176010012626648,
0.26672422885894775,
-0.1700301170349121,
-0.42055174708366394,
-0.47545716166496277,
0.05962088704109192,
0.05341850221157074,
-0.02725587598979473,
-0.01227168645709753,
0.052514392882585526,
-0.35260453820228577,
0.2958435118198395,
0.14991633594036102,
0.28662222623825073,
0.0498395711183548,
-0.3948493003845215,
0.7434951066970825,
-0.019492391496896744,
-0.19544076919555664,
-0.1514788269996643,
0.5483225584030151,
0.6062665581703186,
-0.2533928453922272,
0.8398481011390686,
0.36297544836997986,
-0.2996569573879242,
-0.29752424359321594,
-0.7027158737182617,
-0.26640328764915466,
-0.4673651456832886,
0.5780081152915955,
-0.47634726762771606,
-1.4548451900482178,
0.4612719714641571,
-0.25261133909225464,
-0.12320441752672195,
0.08562205731868744,
0.5393979549407959,
0.19625446200370789,
0.7005200982093811,
0.7519475817680359,
-0.21088817715644836,
0.649739146232605,
0.08496780693531036,
0.29262590408325195,
-1.3472716808319092,
0.0197229515761137,
-0.0862717479467392,
-0.11968113481998444,
-0.35336944460868835,
-0.8903546929359436,
0.19565843045711517,
0.0849696546792984,
-0.07826073467731476,
0.46073153614997864,
-0.025982454419136047,
0.6174957752227783,
0.033849287778139114,
0.042586978524923325,
0.07926653325557709,
-0.14045947790145874,
0.09932847321033478,
0.1874701976776123,
-0.6887832283973694,
-0.27915263175964355,
0.9815084338188171,
0.6904690861701965,
0.529260516166687,
0.2808956205844879,
0.3689385652542114,
0.012573210522532463,
0.24846050143241882,
-0.843224823474884,
0.7371270060539246,
0.08725696057081223,
-0.5623339414596558,
-0.8988533616065979,
-0.17269016802310944,
-0.8130348920822144,
0.19946284592151642,
0.26244524121284485,
-0.8795785903930664,
0.15365004539489746,
-0.054323647171258926,
-0.5185333490371704,
0.25136715173721313,
-0.21344004571437836,
0.4456843435764313,
-0.27577850222587585,
-0.45400747656822205,
-0.37819692492485046,
-0.8370965719223022,
0.4763645827770233,
-0.12646818161010742,
0.21975472569465637,
0.046220067888498306,
-0.3613017201423645,
0.3716679513454437,
-0.3777565658092499,
0.8655420541763306,
0.21310411393642426,
-0.7238243818283081,
0.29612308740615845,
-0.1400686502456665,
0.4771415591239929,
0.0794387012720108,
-0.14816316962242126,
-0.014872252009809017,
-0.0708567202091217,
-0.3822440207004547,
-0.4119069278240204,
0.9074600338935852,
-0.219742551445961,
-0.7727732062339783,
-0.11273667961359024,
-0.7924737930297852,
-0.4851706922054291,
0.21616500616073608,
0.047219738364219666,
0.44547536969184875,
-0.18480274081230164,
0.4701908826828003,
0.8015244007110596,
-0.5772490501403809,
0.6736680269241333,
0.2858043909072876,
-0.17749540507793427,
-0.30338576436042786,
0.4127628803253174,
0.08866572380065918,
0.3600183129310608,
0.6413304209709167,
0.15451498329639435,
-0.4966636896133423,
-0.7066144943237305,
-0.19726477563381195,
0.05828404426574707,
-0.8561632633209229,
0.046105243265628815,
-0.49225497245788574,
-0.17838969826698303,
-0.9146812558174133,
-0.1347423493862152,
-0.05340581387281418,
-0.4359995126724243,
-0.2793222963809967,
-0.2224424183368683,
0.43714097142219543,
0.3911890983581543,
-0.010648023337125778,
0.3831762969493866,
-1.0113716125488281,
0.04709718003869057,
0.1741780787706375,
0.48611581325531006,
0.3251897096633911,
-0.735352635383606,
-0.18084238469600677,
-0.18132585287094116,
0.009719171561300755,
-0.7111978530883789,
0.4407854974269867,
0.1913609504699707,
0.27478811144828796,
0.2755288779735565,
-0.21231216192245483,
1.0048975944519043,
-0.8505685925483704,
0.638141930103302,
-0.004205135628581047,
-0.9646216034889221,
0.3805987238883972,
-0.4635060429573059,
0.6444995403289795,
0.2264004647731781,
0.464424729347229,
-0.6697726249694824,
0.09544333815574646,
-0.13782814145088196,
-0.9545710682868958,
0.4146728515625,
-0.07602634280920029,
0.5787642598152161,
-0.0014769498957321048,
0.6295374631881714,
-0.0022431269753724337,
-0.0666450634598732,
-0.43456822633743286,
0.14944440126419067,
0.43306154012680054,
0.023342685773968697,
-0.3673519492149353,
-0.466965913772583,
-0.016108348965644836,
-0.4314555823802948,
0.4579494297504425,
-0.21515648066997528,
-0.004657865967601538,
0.1615188866853714,
-0.24466007947921753,
0.05541035532951355,
0.6327011585235596,
1.0730916261672974,
1.311832308769226,
0.046328652650117874,
-0.08230294287204742,
0.6594128012657166,
0.07897525280714035,
-0.12096606194972992,
0.11587171256542206,
0.27050063014030457,
-0.33134394884109497,
0.5556918978691101,
0.9184317588806152,
0.11133687943220139,
-1.071738839149475,
0.3048676550388336,
0.17881052196025848,
0.1931825876235962,
-0.5964879989624023,
0.03463069349527359,
0.08495412021875381,
0.4554890990257263,
0.1349463164806366,
-0.49632906913757324,
0.33935046195983887,
-0.8011376261711121,
0.2750818133354187,
0.4926255941390991,
-0.38763055205345154,
-0.20188944041728973,
0.23337316513061523,
-0.022296512499451637,
-0.18176616728305817,
0.4776325225830078,
0.3216003179550171,
-0.21733789145946503,
0.5634117722511292,
0.624114453792572,
0.7028886675834656,
-0.28758493065834045,
-0.255237340927124,
0.14464500546455383,
0.08496381342411041,
-0.16591529548168182,
0.1415664553642273,
-0.49732527136802673,
-0.6494105458259583,
-0.9588451385498047,
-0.5663358569145203,
-0.19151069223880768,
0.4457184970378876,
-0.43960368633270264,
0.2448209822177887,
-0.5277447700500488,
-0.2064305543899536,
-0.22757121920585632,
-0.15388867259025574,
-0.3343051075935364,
0.16724957525730133,
0.5952020287513733,
1.1299222707748413,
-0.4015810787677765,
0.8182896971702576,
0.5264937877655029,
0.15526168048381805,
-0.34466615319252014,
-0.07285401970148087,
-0.10095402598381042,
-0.5929713249206543,
0.5279610753059387,
0.2831626832485199,
-0.20428887009620667,
-0.22515839338302612,
-0.5986443758010864,
-1.0490062236785889,
0.8854936957359314,
0.05307357758283615,
-0.8707020282745361,
-0.04389968886971474,
0.25353342294692993,
0.6251281499862671,
-0.20884951949119568,
0.13915155827999115,
0.9538379311561584,
0.4184461832046509,
0.08149141073226929,
-0.8336378335952759,
0.27834510803222656,
0.043927598744630814,
0.3390343189239502,
0.3518107533454895,
-0.5840076804161072,
0.5244002342224121,
-0.27579429745674133,
-0.023051511496305466,
0.6204569339752197,
0.7308236956596375,
0.3744118809700012,
-0.014482417143881321,
0.35691967606544495,
0.45422956347465515,
0.38789102435112,
0.3125540614128113,
1.0790451765060425,
-0.24176234006881714,
0.1960436999797821,
1.2627955675125122,
-0.5128196477890015,
0.8393353223800659,
0.6033791899681091,
-0.05202590674161911,
0.2752861976623535,
0.5539092421531677,
0.10096651315689087,
0.11259864270687103,
0.591833770275116,
-0.323869526386261,
-0.19978618621826172,
-0.08059597760438919,
-0.3493482172489166,
0.24997709691524506,
0.7016375064849854,
-0.5327694416046143,
0.022392962127923965,
0.3146621584892273,
-0.058814287185668945,
-0.04720529541373253,
-0.24010856449604034,
0.677028477191925,
0.3890657424926758,
-0.8488859534263611,
0.617649257183075,
0.19943414628505707,
0.7244484424591064,
-0.39780139923095703,
0.0001689241616986692,
-0.12069833278656006,
0.1511470228433609,
-0.03135654702782631,
-0.9406573176383972,
0.24376280605793,
-0.14594118297100067,
-0.15666183829307556,
-0.33785754442214966,
0.7681981325149536,
-0.3137870728969574,
-0.31255048513412476,
0.3879408836364746,
0.2593991458415985,
-0.11022375524044037,
0.028710199519991875,
-0.2967633306980133,
0.41607120633125305,
-0.32905465364456177,
-0.39953455328941345,
0.22057971358299255,
0.3122067153453827,
-0.30614331364631653,
0.6959301233291626,
0.5380244851112366,
0.0844416618347168,
0.16090917587280273,
0.08955424278974533,
0.8915517330169678,
-0.9051222205162048,
-0.32858243584632874,
-1.2210757732391357,
0.14700199663639069,
0.007190961390733719,
-0.12964582443237305,
0.7789717316627502,
0.4105525314807892,
0.9364138841629028,
-0.06745308637619019,
0.7026420831680298,
0.061720460653305054,
0.2875266373157501,
-0.6100162863731384,
0.12326737493276596,
-0.5284878015518188,
0.31923192739486694,
-0.16711591184139252,
-0.953579306602478,
-0.595108687877655,
0.39879363775253296,
-0.6701008081436157,
0.12025823444128036,
0.43378493189811707,
0.48627665638923645,
-0.041978247463703156,
-0.0446082279086113,
0.3609338104724884,
0.23810577392578125,
0.4021000862121582,
0.818025529384613,
1.0714653730392456,
-0.07501820474863052,
0.21469590067863464,
0.08514091372489929,
-0.17333385348320007,
-0.18115271627902985,
-0.8918775916099548,
-0.9832756519317627,
-0.37720033526420593,
0.10624975711107254,
0.013753890059888363,
0.0295435581356287,
0.803695023059845,
0.8873803019523621,
-0.6773914098739624,
-0.3175537884235382,
-0.031164726242423058,
-0.0359087698161602,
0.13736635446548462,
-0.18678422272205353,
0.2936822772026062,
-0.34380805492401123,
-0.6778377890586853,
0.728935956954956,
0.5099809765815735,
-0.10216371715068817,
-0.31939706206321716,
-0.03411167487502098,
-0.20270591974258423,
0.2662556767463684,
1.1859006881713867,
0.5981091856956482,
-0.7552323341369629,
-0.47341325879096985,
0.05852776765823364,
0.3467066287994385,
0.10840417444705963,
0.9763138294219971,
-0.5478010177612305,
0.1531580537557602,
0.9323867559432983,
0.8697858452796936,
0.21466192603111267,
-0.08934805542230606,
0.8460965752601624,
-0.6790753602981567,
0.16970254480838776,
0.3066025674343109,
0.46037742495536804,
0.2869957983493805,
-0.3331376612186432,
0.2787340581417084,
-0.24524076282978058,
-0.4317757189273834,
-0.8209106922149658,
0.6144523024559021,
-0.7403026223182678,
-0.7963887453079224,
1.331263542175293,
0.02362350933253765,
-0.16601839661598206,
0.14508980512619019,
-0.10900180041790009,
0.1509389579296112,
-0.0017019454389810562,
0.48189401626586914,
0.8839560747146606,
-0.36048850417137146,
-0.3939526379108429,
-0.5765350461006165,
0.38965097069740295,
0.564031183719635,
-0.8343769311904907,
0.21644891798496246,
0.6865196824073792,
0.260059654712677,
0.03889948129653931,
0.38794833421707153,
-0.2755438983440399,
0.1144975945353508,
-0.7080047130584717,
-0.5255320072174072,
0.2975149154663086,
-0.6482053399085999,
-0.791395366191864,
0.0017300997860729694,
0.0535171702504158,
0.4126235246658325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02243v1 | Language Writ Large: LLMs, ChatGPT, Grounding, Meaning and Understanding | 2024-02-03T19:19:34 | 2024-02-03T19:19:34 | Stevan Harnad | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Apart from what (little) OpenAI may be concealing from us, we all know
(roughly) how ChatGPT works (its huge text database, its statistics, its vector
representations, and their huge number of parameters, its next-word training,
and so on). But none of us can say (hand on heart) that we are not surprised by
what ChatGPT has proved to be able to do with these resources. This has even
driven some of us to conclude that ChatGPT actually understands. It is not true
that it understands. But it is also not true that we understand how it can do
what it can do. I will suggest some hunches about benign biases: convergent
constraints that emerge at LLM scale that may be helping ChatGPT do so much
better than we would have expected. These biases are inherent in the nature of
language itself, at LLM scale, and they are closely linked to what it is that
ChatGPT lacks, which is direct sensorimotor grounding to connect its words to
their referents and its propositions to their meanings. These convergent biases
are related to (1) the parasitism of indirect verbal grounding on direct
sensorimotor grounding, (2) the circularity of verbal definition, (3) the
mirroring of language production and comprehension, (4) iconicity in
propositions at LLM scale, (5) computational counterparts of human categorical
perception in category learning by neural nets, and perhaps also (6) a
conjecture by Chomsky about the laws of thought. The exposition will be in the
form of a dialogue with ChatGPT-4. | [
-0.5111085772514343,
-0.709267258644104,
0.5688367486000061,
0.2986898124217987,
-0.3430321514606476,
0.09892696887254715,
-0.4690985679626465,
-0.29283884167671204,
0.13404211401939392,
0.4299170970916748,
-0.3364529013633728,
-0.046976640820503235,
-0.9415158033370972,
-0.26840826869010925,
-0.3098657727241516,
1.0712050199508667,
-0.047449566423892975,
0.1195608526468277,
-0.12344902753829956,
-0.27147868275642395,
-0.5349990129470825,
-0.5738725662231445,
-0.7327210903167725,
-0.8081454634666443,
0.328077107667923,
0.22888503968715668,
0.7357403039932251,
0.5859805345535278,
0.3601141571998596,
0.26356738805770874,
-0.3835429251194,
-0.2311992049217224,
-0.7494239211082458,
0.0029159493278712034,
-0.14248667657375336,
-1.0094704627990723,
-0.08243804425001144,
0.2403593212366104,
0.7408397197723389,
1.0214577913284302,
0.033453695476055145,
-0.21350084245204926,
0.23335371911525726,
0.9290313720703125,
-0.37074780464172363,
0.21995921432971954,
-0.562967836856842,
0.19765514135360718,
-0.1970716118812561,
-0.21545511484146118,
-0.12755516171455383,
-0.14938011765480042,
0.06101106107234955,
-0.392112135887146,
0.2099313735961914,
0.08008082211017609,
1.032341718673706,
0.5449062585830688,
-0.5146130323410034,
-0.2993195652961731,
-0.5052999258041382,
0.7373099327087402,
-0.32156530022621155,
0.5286031365394592,
0.5104076266288757,
0.12304240465164185,
-0.13920369744300842,
-0.5827645063400269,
-0.45078566670417786,
-0.519990861415863,
0.06358107179403305,
0.36921191215515137,
-0.07692600786685944,
0.2560218870639801,
0.4470886290073395,
0.851991593837738,
-0.3547736406326294,
-0.08111690729856491,
-0.42121896147727966,
-0.14726842939853668,
0.08038069307804108,
0.008258470334112644,
0.4525871276855469,
-0.010269654914736748,
-0.26924556493759155,
0.2924893796443939,
-0.9463818073272705,
-0.2556454837322235,
0.24178536236286163,
-0.08494922518730164,
-0.15436534583568573,
0.6629695296287537,
-0.14049583673477173,
0.5481529831886292,
0.03733066841959953,
0.05839009955525398,
-0.08626262843608856,
-0.15569356083869934,
-0.14665423333644867,
-0.1115681529045105,
0.6747954487800598,
0.2337818592786789,
0.6182032227516174,
-0.33733150362968445,
0.08493147790431976,
0.5126923322677612,
0.09866290539503098,
-0.45194876194000244,
-0.13484059274196625,
0.029991917312145233,
-0.30226001143455505,
-0.18422020971775055,
-0.007675113156437874,
-0.3194178640842438,
-0.7173311710357666,
-0.614273190498352,
-0.059774186462163925,
-0.39498868584632874,
-0.24833357334136963,
0.145754873752594,
-0.02685350552201271,
0.6583481431007385,
0.24617835879325867,
-1.045515775680542,
0.5130002498626709,
0.8067033290863037,
0.7897549271583557,
-0.13168521225452423,
-0.3193919360637665,
-0.005196756683290005,
0.01021079532802105,
-0.34105420112609863,
0.7340965867042542,
-0.27391913533210754,
-0.2285529524087906,
-0.1126779317855835,
-0.06603364646434784,
-0.06294810026884079,
-0.3541637361049652,
0.7144208550453186,
-0.3193124532699585,
0.17800337076187134,
-0.5728157758712769,
-0.39861682057380676,
-0.30363553762435913,
0.4272526204586029,
-0.35858404636383057,
0.8940250873565674,
-0.26343387365341187,
-0.9279205203056335,
0.21840377151966095,
-0.41848254203796387,
-0.4397255778312683,
0.11530284583568573,
-0.5305773615837097,
0.295826256275177,
0.30159103870391846,
-0.07246411591768265,
0.32543572783470154,
-0.4882088899612427,
0.4007425606250763,
-0.020045960322022438,
-0.32679226994514465,
0.29572829604148865,
-0.6003737449645996,
0.7151689529418945,
0.2134329080581665,
-0.5241758823394775,
-0.24979595839977264,
-0.5301228165626526,
-0.15579573810100555,
0.1511664241552353,
-0.34298065304756165,
0.037692081183195114,
0.17724266648292542,
-0.22288212180137634,
0.06812446564435959,
0.31778383255004883,
-0.33701783418655396,
0.0028435299172997475,
-0.5378559827804565,
0.8825085163116455,
0.7196385860443115,
-0.18830884993076324,
0.6328717470169067,
-0.3375794589519501,
0.43887537717819214,
-0.025549782440066338,
-0.16040971875190735,
-0.22424548864364624,
-0.563292920589447,
-1.2008631229400635,
0.04885377734899521,
0.034251969307661057,
0.7143181562423706,
-0.3030438721179962,
0.3693511486053467,
-0.1370328813791275,
-0.14516223967075348,
-0.3245012164115906,
-0.03772326186299324,
0.17380404472351074,
0.3849138915538788,
0.00665254844352603,
-0.5606353282928467,
-0.45559191703796387,
-0.9889593124389648,
-0.2620004415512085,
-0.27083149552345276,
-0.22274339199066162,
0.3361145555973053,
0.214081808924675,
-0.19725067913532257,
0.7311146855354309,
-0.5473576188087463,
-0.32449865341186523,
-0.08893068879842758,
0.03252736106514931,
0.21461473405361176,
0.09229687601327896,
0.17783324420452118,
-0.6785121560096741,
-0.18967968225479126,
0.20021209120750427,
-0.9008603692054749,
-0.2661972939968109,
-0.05468335747718811,
-0.0386354960501194,
-0.2420453578233719,
0.6543728709220886,
-0.7499775290489197,
0.12160971760749817,
0.37407219409942627,
-0.15927162766456604,
0.2640725076198578,
-0.17754603922367096,
-0.23159828782081604,
-0.9309161901473999,
-0.21485182642936707,
-0.07954529672861099,
-0.11802531033754349,
-0.7249438762664795,
0.1117951050400734,
-0.21517643332481384,
0.00029583837022073567,
-0.2507757544517517,
0.24863789975643158,
-0.48927465081214905,
-0.11099042743444443,
-0.4660121500492096,
0.5854865312576294,
-0.33826857805252075,
0.5195519924163818,
0.028348557651042938,
0.7568469643592834,
0.5259018540382385,
-0.5290141701698303,
0.4261125326156616,
-0.06788390874862671,
-0.14218978583812714,
0.5363035798072815,
-0.4782778322696686,
0.26310333609580994,
-0.34033215045928955,
0.3491677939891815,
-0.9968347549438477,
-0.16951608657836914,
0.5484122633934021,
-0.5083664059638977,
0.23853278160095215,
-0.06939522922039032,
-0.19167982041835785,
-0.04075473174452782,
-0.13938578963279724,
0.35491955280303955,
0.6662657856941223,
-0.3896986246109009,
0.3108324110507965,
0.6215559840202332,
0.13038946688175201,
-0.660481870174408,
-0.7263400554656982,
0.2525176405906677,
-0.2563669681549072,
-0.5124139785766602,
-0.1686181128025055,
0.08748739957809448,
-0.6061778664588928,
-0.20170973241329193,
-0.15800023078918457,
-0.03275948017835617,
0.06555725634098053,
0.43588075041770935,
-0.1641899049282074,
-0.3702904284000397,
0.18421418964862823,
-0.30330681800842285,
-0.3101096749305725,
0.2318212240934372,
-0.6033614873886108,
0.6633189916610718,
-0.6727627515792847,
-0.4843427538871765,
0.07425263524055481,
0.006214519962668419,
0.5746785402297974,
0.11132914572954178,
0.4758216142654419,
0.5404241681098938,
-0.2710524797439575,
0.15143966674804688,
-0.603062093257904,
-0.007350985426455736,
-0.42097124457359314,
0.15157023072242737,
-0.40367043018341064,
-1.0727767944335938,
0.4814489483833313,
-0.23705604672431946,
-0.19029352068901062,
0.4468133747577667,
0.7800686359405518,
-0.05690058693289757,
0.6194576025009155,
0.5376803874969482,
-0.31337806582450867,
0.5253185033798218,
-0.14386744797229767,
0.3946274220943451,
-0.9663485884666443,
-0.00979926623404026,
-0.46378448605537415,
-0.10761803388595581,
-0.9462995529174805,
-0.47773683071136475,
0.04725861921906471,
0.12696902453899384,
-0.27294325828552246,
-0.08545268326997757,
-0.34082695841789246,
0.6111500859260559,
0.5195154547691345,
0.07352065294981003,
0.18987315893173218,
-0.1388418972492218,
-0.11757168173789978,
-0.22579003870487213,
-0.7264069318771362,
-0.7918211817741394,
0.8649054765701294,
0.5817128419876099,
0.8541088700294495,
-0.09481824934482574,
0.4228918254375458,
-0.031162410974502563,
0.2704555094242096,
-0.9322240352630615,
0.5618857741355896,
0.12773506343364716,
-0.5224637985229492,
-0.05747370049357414,
-0.0953383520245552,
-0.8795332312583923,
0.5591042041778564,
0.11704595386981964,
-0.7991529703140259,
-0.04930489882826805,
-0.12234197556972504,
0.1891915202140808,
0.39385634660720825,
-0.6384933590888977,
0.4590340852737427,
-0.268490731716156,
-0.34945520758628845,
-0.10644306242465973,
-0.8387097120285034,
0.7064638733863831,
0.08928346633911133,
0.43938860297203064,
-0.32480043172836304,
-0.2634934186935425,
0.745955765247345,
-0.09575221687555313,
1.0459321737289429,
0.11701136827468872,
-0.3619973361492157,
0.37491098046302795,
-0.14978207647800446,
0.05874691158533096,
0.14259861409664154,
0.38335350155830383,
0.2543465495109558,
-0.11440608650445938,
-0.5918353796005249,
-0.4730449318885803,
0.5297228693962097,
-0.9393351078033447,
-0.8009111881256104,
-0.5417599081993103,
-0.36723098158836365,
-0.20062461495399475,
0.31677210330963135,
0.46619194746017456,
0.12135427445173264,
-0.5474252700805664,
0.022662099450826645,
1.025639295578003,
-0.20815594494342804,
0.012923388741910458,
0.19172586500644684,
-0.15926045179367065,
-0.24360942840576172,
0.9734944701194763,
-0.03291652351617813,
0.3953530192375183,
0.5732021927833557,
0.32779017090797424,
-0.17098228633403778,
-0.32166871428489685,
-0.18654920160770416,
0.4048704504966736,
-1.0039994716644287,
0.27276450395584106,
-0.5422702431678772,
-0.3754512071609497,
-0.1254456341266632,
-0.1604241579771042,
-0.2266128957271576,
-0.38178354501724243,
-0.23869530856609344,
-0.2598022520542145,
0.14543233811855316,
1.0038940906524658,
-0.24958392977714539,
0.5737305879592896,
-0.3924732506275177,
0.37464168667793274,
0.29905208945274353,
0.36176562309265137,
-0.16085265576839447,
-0.598468542098999,
-0.03907930478453636,
0.17072799801826477,
-0.3987084627151489,
-0.7377899289131165,
-0.06113952025771141,
0.060224924236536026,
0.5102798938751221,
0.6981157064437866,
-0.31256967782974243,
0.32521238923072815,
-0.7909726500511169,
0.9067059755325317,
0.03762686625123024,
-0.9576546549797058,
0.38739094138145447,
-0.5097659230232239,
0.23613737523555756,
0.3667711019515991,
0.35907644033432007,
-1.043904185295105,
-0.7916991114616394,
-0.8210025429725647,
-0.6637436151504517,
0.4071367084980011,
0.13412077724933624,
0.4578778147697449,
-0.15650688111782074,
0.4652765989303589,
0.039072711020708084,
0.2686869204044342,
-0.8961759209632874,
-0.30545729398727417,
-0.1816941201686859,
-0.049864355474710464,
-0.2941117584705353,
-0.552933931350708,
-0.27736184000968933,
-0.024960147216916084,
0.3837103247642517,
-0.19892658293247223,
0.5133609175682068,
0.003497812431305647,
-0.09093216806650162,
-0.08397644758224487,
0.4299028217792511,
0.848526656627655,
0.797214150428772,
0.03697369992733002,
0.5401051640510559,
0.32902809977531433,
-0.7556807398796082,
0.19010035693645477,
-0.3305348753929138,
-0.14799629151821136,
-0.23592698574066162,
0.49198558926582336,
0.8980917930603027,
0.22234927117824554,
-0.3458987772464752,
0.3893003761768341,
-0.021310869604349136,
-0.2181079387664795,
-0.3326563835144043,
-0.06110963970422745,
0.15254245698451996,
0.050543688237667084,
0.11351309716701508,
0.061583735048770905,
-0.09960243105888367,
-0.6446370482444763,
0.1616070419549942,
0.45014694333076477,
-0.6271366477012634,
-0.4278618395328522,
0.7035551071166992,
0.0381091870367527,
-0.26261332631111145,
0.5748361349105835,
0.11089365184307098,
-1.0126228332519531,
0.49843651056289673,
0.46270912885665894,
1.0021331310272217,
-0.05627523362636566,
-0.16654188930988312,
0.10491527616977692,
0.704127848148346,
-0.1273430436849594,
0.14903371036052704,
-0.25333988666534424,
-1.104703426361084,
-0.46322157979011536,
-0.48578062653541565,
-0.6299315690994263,
0.12943445146083832,
-0.4929341971874237,
0.204196035861969,
-0.4880307614803314,
0.1499406397342682,
-0.2923867404460907,
0.11289491504430771,
-0.42767220735549927,
0.15392006933689117,
0.2637389600276947,
0.7441114783287048,
-1.024059772491455,
0.6293150782585144,
0.6067116856575012,
-0.48233550786972046,
-0.6067782640457153,
0.272490918636322,
0.0050728823989629745,
-1.169852375984192,
0.6754639744758606,
0.19244343042373657,
-0.06650587916374207,
0.13593967258930206,
-0.7196909785270691,
-0.7141672968864441,
0.7753770351409912,
0.23762421309947968,
-0.2103683203458786,
0.16256356239318848,
0.2625555396080017,
0.59247225522995,
-0.04029329493641853,
0.4888862669467926,
0.8351593613624573,
0.45316174626350403,
0.03786806762218475,
-0.8452395796775818,
0.023995166644454002,
0.021106962114572525,
-0.08744239062070847,
0.2984822988510132,
-0.7527708411216736,
0.736233115196228,
-0.02869785577058792,
-0.3297652006149292,
-0.20404589176177979,
0.590718150138855,
-0.021099481731653214,
0.15711121261119843,
0.05034586414694786,
0.6773573756217957,
0.7210960984230042,
-0.27588555216789246,
1.0102499723434448,
-0.1630316823720932,
0.2537235617637634,
0.7838809490203857,
-0.10393185168504715,
0.4400802552700043,
0.5824466943740845,
-0.5019446611404419,
-0.004195652902126312,
0.8734978437423706,
0.37043118476867676,
0.30026212334632874,
0.5943567156791687,
-0.41844698786735535,
0.03248491510748863,
-0.14742842316627502,
-0.3609800636768341,
0.29483675956726074,
0.6305788159370422,
-0.14562788605690002,
-0.2908417284488678,
0.0864652618765831,
0.04128633812069893,
-0.006056040525436401,
-0.20015907287597656,
0.8951610326766968,
0.6907879114151001,
-0.5616323947906494,
0.6249880194664001,
-0.1591363549232483,
0.587852418422699,
-0.41986745595932007,
0.1452946811914444,
-0.44765201210975647,
0.14912335574626923,
-0.06384750455617905,
-0.862237274646759,
0.22749795019626617,
-0.24361318349838257,
-0.003451959230005741,
-0.3673151135444641,
0.9414852857589722,
-0.2591972351074219,
0.04263513535261154,
0.11039081960916519,
0.5952799916267395,
0.6479538679122925,
-0.029881099238991737,
-0.5640397667884827,
0.2870001196861267,
-0.05515575036406517,
-0.16145892441272736,
0.3639052212238312,
0.8311783075332642,
-0.012165123596787453,
0.8806771039962769,
0.3642804026603699,
0.3464864492416382,
0.24927125871181488,
0.06060726195573807,
0.8404006361961365,
-0.753972053527832,
-0.36965543031692505,
-0.849452555179596,
0.04990611597895622,
0.22668799757957458,
-0.17273280024528503,
0.5893133282661438,
0.3684246838092804,
0.7780386805534363,
0.20640437304973602,
0.8629416823387146,
-0.1558871865272522,
0.19104798138141632,
-0.6609471440315247,
0.586486279964447,
-0.07047879695892334,
0.09047568589448929,
0.12789300084114075,
-0.9659661054611206,
-0.3241969645023346,
0.9348418116569519,
-0.5965539813041687,
-0.08390062302350998,
0.8738994002342224,
0.38964131474494934,
0.0402197502553463,
0.2641594409942627,
0.48146116733551025,
0.22960877418518066,
0.20181550085544586,
0.5831613540649414,
1.3625284433364868,
-0.3666766285896301,
0.3418368101119995,
0.02681671269237995,
-0.4184299409389496,
0.0646437555551529,
-0.7583693861961365,
-0.9040900468826294,
-0.5348669290542603,
-0.0392480231821537,
-0.33596372604370117,
-0.12447439879179001,
0.7362877726554871,
0.49698325991630554,
-0.5161406993865967,
-0.5073079466819763,
-0.5609041452407837,
0.33749595284461975,
0.08355740457773209,
-0.1944095641374588,
0.16001275181770325,
-0.6513293385505676,
-0.5980819463729858,
0.12046525627374649,
0.36736053228378296,
-0.025176573544740677,
-0.2113160490989685,
-0.15158092975616455,
-0.04769148677587509,
-0.035600244998931885,
0.701350748538971,
0.47514787316322327,
-1.0047980546951294,
-0.3520495593547821,
-0.2609974443912506,
-0.07449445873498917,
0.28214389085769653,
0.9726513624191284,
-0.5510465502738953,
0.19567769765853882,
0.384637713432312,
0.8050165176391602,
0.47552549839019775,
-0.2136768400669098,
0.7118099927902222,
-0.37697187066078186,
0.3737718462944031,
0.21196600794792175,
0.32692116498947144,
0.30142268538475037,
-0.1627124398946762,
0.7040265202522278,
0.44402673840522766,
-0.5924500823020935,
-0.6042419672012329,
0.589455246925354,
-0.8463305830955505,
-0.03578826040029526,
1.2161437273025513,
0.12916237115859985,
-0.21971486508846283,
-0.18796753883361816,
-0.4576854705810547,
0.23927421867847443,
0.07661121338605881,
0.5405792593955994,
1.1291955709457397,
-0.18300582468509674,
-0.42227333784103394,
-1.0636245012283325,
0.5236660242080688,
0.5983604192733765,
-0.6139763593673706,
0.11225679516792297,
0.3681625723838806,
0.3182353079319,
0.12392465770244598,
0.9290295839309692,
-0.12162546813488007,
-0.11609147489070892,
0.061841510236263275,
-0.1050400659441948,
0.5738482475280762,
0.07310207188129425,
-0.5007169842720032,
-0.017677713185548782,
0.42802366614341736,
-0.3002474009990692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02212v1 | A Data Generation Perspective to the Mechanism of In-Context Learning | 2024-02-03T17:13:03 | 2024-02-03T17:13:03 | Haitao Mao, Guangliang Liu, Yao Ma, Rongrong Wang, Jiliang Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-Context Learning (ICL) empowers Large Language Models (LLMs) with the
capacity to learn in context, achieving downstream generalization without
gradient updates but with a few in-context examples. Despite the encouraging
empirical success, the underlying mechanism of ICL remains unclear, and
existing research offers various viewpoints of understanding. These studies
propose intuition-driven and ad-hoc technical solutions for interpreting ICL,
illustrating an ambiguous road map. In this paper, we leverage a data
generation perspective to reinterpret recent efforts and demonstrate the
potential broader usage of popular technical solutions, approaching a
systematic angle. For a conceptual definition, we rigorously adopt the terms of
skill learning and skill recognition. The difference between them is skill
learning can learn new data generation functions from in-context data. We also
provide a comprehensive study on the merits and weaknesses of different
solutions, and highlight the uniformity among them given the perspective of
data generation, establishing a technical foundation for future research to
incorporate the strengths of different lines of research. | [
-0.2659285068511963,
-0.6223803162574768,
0.6646245121955872,
-0.25221675634384155,
-0.2069217413663864,
0.3011317551136017,
-0.35295119881629944,
-0.3340873122215271,
-0.4092711806297302,
0.24224260449409485,
-0.6882178783416748,
-0.3663156032562256,
-0.36003774404525757,
0.1474805474281311,
-0.5878403782844543,
1.0442255735397339,
-0.03774365782737732,
0.08458492159843445,
-0.515644907951355,
0.12441520392894745,
-0.5144248604774475,
-0.5749397873878479,
-0.6889475584030151,
-0.5065955519676208,
0.3270251154899597,
0.9804014563560486,
-0.03929518908262253,
0.7116632461547852,
0.3286057114601135,
0.1418343037366867,
0.18099766969680786,
0.06706275045871735,
-0.44745615124702454,
0.11528792977333069,
0.10490341484546661,
-0.5576529502868652,
0.07454697042703629,
0.03622462600469589,
0.8428033590316772,
1.1477054357528687,
-0.11185508221387863,
0.08203508704900742,
0.5821214318275452,
0.6923443675041199,
-0.42105725407600403,
0.08046077936887741,
-1.1631922721862793,
0.04959439858794212,
-0.315211683511734,
-0.25597888231277466,
-0.4947131276130676,
-0.1472286731004715,
0.2389170229434967,
-0.34399405121803284,
0.26806068420410156,
-0.07254825532436371,
0.5909067988395691,
0.1841614544391632,
-0.5139420628547668,
-0.7234501838684082,
-0.7743108868598938,
1.0030585527420044,
-0.659598171710968,
0.2090768963098526,
0.2843112647533417,
0.539279043674469,
-0.2064821720123291,
-0.7124939560890198,
-0.4915374517440796,
-0.225256085395813,
0.0937325581908226,
-0.11974941194057465,
0.3980329632759094,
-0.4482680857181549,
0.43323612213134766,
0.08054544031620026,
-0.1426282525062561,
0.20317263901233673,
-0.3594806492328644,
0.22621864080429077,
0.6677087545394897,
0.19947178661823273,
0.08786721527576447,
0.19794557988643646,
-0.48518431186676025,
0.12275070697069168,
-1.2967356443405151,
0.2951394319534302,
0.12497808039188385,
0.50937420129776,
-0.31491613388061523,
0.13574111461639404,
-0.1801232397556305,
0.7384420037269592,
0.1013965979218483,
-0.3111026883125305,
0.3024926781654358,
-0.05839340761303902,
-0.07492350041866302,
0.23829331994056702,
0.438510924577713,
-0.018841655924916267,
0.2966627776622772,
-0.2750299572944641,
-0.2744687497615814,
-0.46039891242980957,
0.2113911509513855,
-0.4374154210090637,
0.26067593693733215,
0.06950684636831284,
-0.16118381917476654,
-0.3937593996524811,
0.29513826966285706,
-0.44393685460090637,
-0.3061830401420593,
-0.6055546402931213,
0.0605856254696846,
-0.44598883390426636,
-0.27677807211875916,
-0.09543701261281967,
0.03795012831687927,
0.636224627494812,
0.18465235829353333,
-0.8146957755088806,
0.18857578933238983,
0.7884002327919006,
0.7963442802429199,
-0.14195050299167633,
-0.28159722685813904,
-0.2892458140850067,
0.3179194927215576,
-0.3279774487018585,
0.6292678117752075,
-0.4903028607368469,
-0.3359422981739044,
0.26272669434547424,
-0.2822979688644409,
-0.028454532846808434,
-0.5568148493766785,
0.16505026817321777,
-0.4461617171764374,
0.015379208140075207,
-0.4441082775592804,
-0.6147726774215698,
-0.14187684655189514,
0.11400839686393738,
-0.4658969044685364,
0.9410262107849121,
0.04608672484755516,
-0.7511689066886902,
1.0188404321670532,
-0.7033202648162842,
-0.3559679687023163,
0.3513523042201996,
-0.5603824853897095,
-0.3133772313594818,
0.3457053005695343,
-0.2585253119468689,
0.627260148525238,
-0.49782541394233704,
0.5569949150085449,
-0.3610623776912689,
-0.3268076777458191,
0.6123688817024231,
-0.302796870470047,
0.6928733587265015,
0.41846975684165955,
-0.56175297498703,
-0.3711508512496948,
-0.9002088904380798,
-0.20387086272239685,
0.0722816213965416,
-0.5582934617996216,
-0.29632771015167236,
0.3637540936470032,
-0.15141642093658447,
0.5467291474342346,
0.006423706188797951,
-0.5477573871612549,
0.04051123186945915,
-0.4179627299308777,
0.48279720544815063,
0.7529593706130981,
-0.17139863967895508,
0.44139885902404785,
-0.18744437396526337,
0.314206063747406,
0.26295706629753113,
-0.03920082747936249,
-0.17002633213996887,
-0.17208735644817352,
-0.5054036974906921,
-0.06772260367870331,
0.04648783430457115,
0.17182545363903046,
-0.811170756816864,
0.06946998834609985,
-0.23314262926578522,
-0.2980844974517822,
-0.4660157561302185,
0.32681187987327576,
0.46344950795173645,
1.0755548477172852,
0.1755247861146927,
-0.09953289479017258,
-0.4985448122024536,
-0.6985163688659668,
-0.2666362524032593,
0.037367865443229675,
0.12308944761753082,
0.4950544536113739,
0.40617915987968445,
0.12134615331888199,
1.2953740358352661,
-0.019461238756775856,
0.03039272502064705,
-0.48933228850364685,
-0.11012063175439835,
0.08382013440132141,
0.45090943574905396,
0.5230345726013184,
-0.8855708837509155,
-0.7700816988945007,
0.2756420373916626,
-1.1927379369735718,
-0.02648237906396389,
-0.0492967814207077,
0.22277730703353882,
0.209487184882164,
1.0171672105789185,
-0.12734445929527283,
0.2344171106815338,
0.09484416246414185,
-0.05423450097441673,
0.30005407333374023,
0.06839059293270111,
-0.2512003481388092,
-1.0438059568405151,
0.10403670370578766,
0.11528945714235306,
0.08639686554670334,
-0.8757904171943665,
0.20201876759529114,
0.12139160186052322,
-0.03188227117061615,
-0.6276347041130066,
0.5888350605964661,
-0.3145120143890381,
-0.09340263158082962,
-0.31303033232688904,
0.2704342007637024,
-0.35298681259155273,
0.2400415539741516,
-0.01656847447156906,
0.6843633651733398,
0.7049521803855896,
-0.8200045228004456,
0.1523435115814209,
-0.1007179245352745,
-0.4253195822238922,
0.4450107514858246,
-0.3376571834087372,
0.3202338218688965,
-0.2737056612968445,
0.03382721170783043,
-0.8184398412704468,
-0.406131774187088,
0.12255337089300156,
-0.2789674997329712,
0.4883944094181061,
-0.07278050482273102,
-0.4330560564994812,
-0.16778236627578735,
-0.11352009326219559,
0.4877525568008423,
0.31785687804222107,
-0.7533062100410461,
0.14680524170398712,
0.3816990554332733,
-0.03900090232491493,
-0.5658004879951477,
-0.7477625608444214,
0.09037858247756958,
-0.7020984292030334,
-0.44135522842407227,
0.30985474586486816,
-0.1213531494140625,
-0.7153381705284119,
-0.27313005924224854,
0.07064908742904663,
-0.06255752593278885,
0.4602280259132385,
-0.028795666992664337,
0.04810522124171257,
-0.15007978677749634,
0.3676690459251404,
0.017029954120516777,
-0.13913770020008087,
0.17076902091503143,
-0.5439621806144714,
0.3590482771396637,
0.0890120267868042,
-0.32947996258735657,
-0.15054379403591156,
0.30307555198669434,
0.427010178565979,
0.05875317007303238,
0.7346805334091187,
0.05949130281805992,
-0.18497468531131744,
-0.5123231410980225,
-0.41598138213157654,
-0.1174340695142746,
-0.4772629141807556,
0.1567024141550064,
-0.5313045382499695,
-0.5940483808517456,
0.4467605650424957,
-0.29584527015686035,
0.07838524878025055,
0.10247165709733963,
0.3648284077644348,
-0.35405775904655457,
0.9794556498527527,
0.8914293646812439,
-0.02710988000035286,
0.6040791869163513,
-0.2575848400592804,
0.20234498381614685,
-0.7908359169960022,
-0.49602997303009033,
-0.491268128156662,
-0.2858925759792328,
-0.32238471508026123,
0.31979089975357056,
0.4929511845111847,
0.138186514377594,
-0.26711857318878174,
-0.07088340073823929,
-0.2441064864397049,
0.2629753351211548,
0.5381379127502441,
0.14026468992233276,
0.284093976020813,
0.20843246579170227,
-0.20442144572734833,
0.00364505872130394,
-0.7436968088150024,
-0.5720370411872864,
1.3983869552612305,
0.1128188744187355,
0.4421099126338959,
-0.12405960261821747,
0.6863942742347717,
-0.04514249414205551,
0.3784983456134796,
-0.6743633151054382,
0.4881848096847534,
-0.009803409688174725,
-0.28011956810951233,
-0.09379692375659943,
-0.25406619906425476,
-0.7234576344490051,
-0.11549727618694305,
-0.059481147676706314,
-0.47766971588134766,
0.060519393533468246,
0.1247241199016571,
-0.04311004653573036,
0.21027375757694244,
-0.7549113035202026,
0.5189921855926514,
-0.27473488450050354,
-0.3789910674095154,
-0.14600102603435516,
-0.6432592272758484,
0.3682195842266083,
-0.36191093921661377,
0.494849294424057,
0.2091619223356247,
-0.024325866252183914,
0.378668874502182,
-0.40259119868278503,
0.9632128477096558,
-0.4057357609272003,
-0.2636668384075165,
0.33600956201553345,
-0.19713959097862244,
0.36678358912467957,
-0.015385657548904419,
-0.2194882333278656,
-0.04569225385785103,
-0.4654444456100464,
-0.3175303041934967,
-0.5558288097381592,
0.6199173331260681,
-0.50429368019104,
-0.4645291268825531,
-0.09719438850879669,
-0.7010623812675476,
-0.28406208753585815,
-0.09493570029735565,
0.40489137172698975,
0.6254705190658569,
-0.00831963773816824,
0.2997412383556366,
0.7569620013237,
-0.09068543463945389,
0.7084774971008301,
0.5727997422218323,
0.004720251075923443,
0.22375261783599854,
0.8244332075119019,
0.21976350247859955,
0.4223976731300354,
0.25310125946998596,
0.05188194662332535,
0.005460033658891916,
-0.7659043073654175,
-0.250846803188324,
0.07882902771234512,
-0.8365539312362671,
-0.03788560628890991,
-0.22237558662891388,
-0.21625877916812897,
-0.040873900055885315,
-0.4308909773826599,
0.09606048464775085,
-0.04098643735051155,
-0.294288694858551,
-0.18731297552585602,
0.22248037159442902,
1.0107818841934204,
0.07545807212591171,
0.21299992501735687,
-0.2720196545124054,
-0.23153643310070038,
0.2181573212146759,
0.17081645131111145,
0.25870734453201294,
-0.40131211280822754,
-0.7210793495178223,
0.155219167470932,
-0.38465240597724915,
-0.530086100101471,
0.1766105741262436,
0.24701182544231415,
0.5667781233787537,
0.345193475484848,
-0.3612228333950043,
0.5728418231010437,
-0.4520145356655121,
0.7712732553482056,
-0.1422252357006073,
-0.9234492778778076,
0.679712176322937,
-0.2264808714389801,
0.1470969319343567,
0.44532886147499084,
0.4286790192127228,
-0.5317287445068359,
-0.4510716199874878,
-0.6784270405769348,
-0.8037184476852417,
0.712836503982544,
-0.3772743046283722,
0.1860421597957611,
0.03749944642186165,
0.8042250871658325,
0.4671504497528076,
0.3525460660457611,
-0.7640250325202942,
-0.008972211740911007,
-0.07146631926298141,
-0.3776242434978485,
0.014032572507858276,
0.018306991085410118,
0.01868579350411892,
-0.156782865524292,
0.5587878823280334,
-0.5469172596931458,
0.01673216000199318,
-0.05024680495262146,
-0.3632236421108246,
0.020236361771821976,
0.1191444993019104,
0.3657108247280121,
0.907166063785553,
0.12083009630441666,
-0.008588838391005993,
0.07608684152364731,
-0.34532660245895386,
-0.016852587461471558,
-0.23648901283740997,
-0.4481043815612793,
-0.26105135679244995,
0.5835061073303223,
0.6184741854667664,
0.41376328468322754,
-0.7012953758239746,
0.49637115001678467,
0.18021053075790405,
-0.28236761689186096,
-0.42919087409973145,
0.17496240139007568,
-0.19737863540649414,
0.23910152912139893,
0.7724418044090271,
-0.09280019253492355,
-0.00628231605514884,
-0.743535041809082,
0.3076622188091278,
0.70392245054245,
-0.5205199122428894,
-0.40849539637565613,
0.47485074400901794,
-0.04499999061226845,
-0.09816496074199677,
0.630449116230011,
-0.13988181948661804,
-0.1334386169910431,
0.751228928565979,
0.7457971572875977,
0.8647591471672058,
-0.10273594409227371,
0.12902872264385223,
0.16096699237823486,
-0.08804213255643845,
0.14488963782787323,
0.339938223361969,
-0.28241121768951416,
-0.836669921875,
-0.38649532198905945,
-0.43164822459220886,
-0.17687390744686127,
0.11886521428823471,
-0.6588811874389648,
0.4659557044506073,
-0.37657979130744934,
0.3209145665168762,
-0.24854406714439392,
-0.17701652646064758,
-0.8002892136573792,
0.12373942881822586,
0.16754503548145294,
0.9746027588844299,
-0.794920027256012,
1.1376110315322876,
0.6444289684295654,
-0.5020761489868164,
-0.8158682584762573,
0.3816027343273163,
0.04587415233254433,
-0.8256584405899048,
1.1384000778198242,
0.11317417770624161,
-0.10352884978055954,
0.21223017573356628,
-0.9321434497833252,
-0.8512756824493408,
1.3096972703933716,
0.4829372763633728,
-0.26779815554618835,
-0.08373939990997314,
0.19694682955741882,
0.37666797637939453,
-0.9697121381759644,
-0.04488948732614517,
0.6123206615447998,
0.14895492792129517,
-0.02053767442703247,
-0.5970824360847473,
-0.0814693421125412,
-0.019724156707525253,
0.01933952607214451,
-0.06998833268880844,
-0.45104989409446716,
0.7310503721237183,
-0.11474871635437012,
-0.37341833114624023,
-0.2769905924797058,
0.3956407606601715,
0.221047505736351,
0.4187955856323242,
0.14527738094329834,
0.2353406399488449,
0.5222761034965515,
-0.015334638766944408,
1.010815978050232,
-0.3220153748989105,
0.15052267909049988,
0.7824083566665649,
-0.34799036383628845,
0.6852466464042664,
0.6525716781616211,
0.011851278133690357,
0.8190503120422363,
0.5526933670043945,
0.3337029218673706,
0.8745725750923157,
0.05817325413227081,
-0.4516674280166626,
-0.015857333317399025,
-0.17760229110717773,
-0.13956795632839203,
0.4931531548500061,
0.675222635269165,
-0.4199257791042328,
-0.28796565532684326,
0.3112170398235321,
-0.04868758097290993,
0.1973269134759903,
-0.43495988845825195,
1.0375207662582397,
0.26523491740226746,
-0.63719642162323,
0.5277785658836365,
-0.3302484154701233,
0.4591786861419678,
-0.5353214144706726,
-0.24069860577583313,
-0.06059618294239044,
0.05344143137335777,
-0.23075559735298157,
-0.7478592991828918,
0.32456183433532715,
0.05661407485604286,
-0.2548629641532898,
-0.3727319538593292,
0.5409672856330872,
-0.4036432206630707,
-0.2751897871494293,
0.3153056800365448,
0.5831382870674133,
0.036572739481925964,
0.3263850212097168,
-0.5572214126586914,
-0.03775983303785324,
0.0012452483642846346,
0.07570944726467133,
0.5347946882247925,
0.7349542379379272,
0.0031952199060469866,
0.780768096446991,
0.4087012708187103,
0.0616019181907177,
0.09518087655305862,
-0.04972545802593231,
0.8179649114608765,
-0.494397908449173,
-0.3686259090900421,
-0.9950430393218994,
0.6641693711280823,
-0.02243640087544918,
-0.4126952588558197,
0.6481647491455078,
0.34570157527923584,
1.4166324138641357,
0.11776069551706314,
1.2254072427749634,
-0.13436836004257202,
0.527199387550354,
-0.7924791574478149,
0.36826327443122864,
-0.6743473410606384,
0.5237715244293213,
-0.22059020400047302,
-0.5871142745018005,
-0.33528679609298706,
0.35324931144714355,
-0.4475115239620209,
0.12314797937870026,
0.6745656132698059,
0.600628137588501,
-0.19909290969371796,
-0.13234364986419678,
0.15865904092788696,
0.09327344596385956,
0.3344593346118927,
0.5331390500068665,
0.8670454025268555,
-0.17744357883930206,
0.251371830701828,
-0.1266309767961502,
-0.23717086017131805,
-0.2242889106273651,
-0.8352992534637451,
-0.7147405743598938,
-0.9960877895355225,
0.05801953375339508,
-0.015704285353422165,
-0.18109115958213806,
0.9281636476516724,
0.5465385317802429,
-0.5358790159225464,
-0.6523476839065552,
-0.47784224152565,
0.19290833175182343,
-0.3560101389884949,
-0.2411496788263321,
0.1694045215845108,
-0.9600908160209656,
-0.5478835701942444,
0.5980202555656433,
0.21847020089626312,
-0.13809823989868164,
-0.3533523380756378,
-0.17995385825634003,
0.05715544521808624,
-0.09699401259422302,
0.6229886412620544,
0.45102035999298096,
-0.5891669988632202,
-0.21389976143836975,
-0.24787713587284088,
0.017408091574907303,
0.11334002763032913,
1.1454781293869019,
-1.0400280952453613,
0.3333599269390106,
0.1683579385280609,
0.626906156539917,
0.30917155742645264,
-0.29128792881965637,
0.80023592710495,
-1.0427231788635254,
0.10179568827152252,
-0.07206827402114868,
0.3657830059528351,
0.45279234647750854,
-0.37862029671669006,
0.4296724200248718,
0.18445976078510284,
-0.43057581782341003,
-0.9667885899543762,
0.6009735465049744,
-0.167958065867424,
-0.31392884254455566,
0.9731004238128662,
0.03866034373641014,
-0.03573284670710564,
-0.42092496156692505,
0.10092929750680923,
0.12684877216815948,
-0.20263047516345978,
0.913337767124176,
0.6854647994041443,
-0.23927170038223267,
-0.07578795403242111,
-0.8015114665031433,
0.7695226669311523,
0.09523019194602966,
-0.740573525428772,
0.18951529264450073,
0.24026115238666534,
0.23911544680595398,
-0.1488330215215683,
0.47889822721481323,
-0.13840357959270477,
0.11537814140319824,
-0.33368730545043945,
-0.14863157272338867,
0.13011814653873444,
-0.6131949424743652,
-0.6311061978340149,
0.1907457411289215,
0.3891514837741852,
0.21115337312221527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05948v1 | DE$^3$-BERT: Distance-Enhanced Early Exiting for BERT based on Prototypical Networks | 2024-02-03T15:51:17 | 2024-02-03T15:51:17 | Jianing He, Qi Zhang, Weiping Ding, Duoqian Miao, Jun Zhao, Liang Hu, Longbing Cao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Early exiting has demonstrated its effectiveness in accelerating the
inference of pre-trained language models like BERT by dynamically adjusting the
number of layers executed. However, most existing early exiting methods only
consider local information from an individual test sample to determine their
exiting indicators, failing to leverage the global information offered by
sample population. This leads to suboptimal estimation of prediction
correctness, resulting in erroneous exiting decisions. To bridge the gap, we
explore the necessity of effectively combining both local and global
information to ensure reliable early exiting during inference. Purposefully, we
leverage prototypical networks to learn class prototypes and devise a distance
metric between samples and class prototypes. This enables us to utilize global
information for estimating the correctness of early predictions. On this basis,
we propose a novel Distance-Enhanced Early Exiting framework for BERT
(DE$^3$-BERT). DE$^3$-BERT implements a hybrid exiting strategy that
supplements classic entropy-based local information with distance-based global
information to enhance the estimation of prediction correctness for more
reliable early exiting decisions. Extensive experiments on the GLUE benchmark
demonstrate that DE$^3$-BERT consistently outperforms state-of-the-art models
under different speed-up ratios with minimal storage or computational overhead,
yielding a better trade-off between model performance and inference efficiency.
Additionally, an in-depth analysis further validates the generality and
interpretability of our method. | [
-0.3255343437194824,
-1.0451773405075073,
0.5868493318557739,
0.07961631566286087,
-0.2274707704782486,
0.007434796076267958,
-0.4975464642047882,
-0.7916218638420105,
0.019377252086997032,
0.00884274672716856,
-0.4969601631164551,
-0.13760682940483093,
-0.622244119644165,
-0.4982375204563141,
-0.2955334484577179,
0.7318199872970581,
0.12988318502902985,
-0.14102061092853546,
-0.1386520266532898,
0.4990125298500061,
-0.013175606727600098,
-0.3957906663417816,
-0.572516143321991,
-0.3917474150657654,
0.7281039357185364,
0.30690011382102966,
0.760849118232727,
0.5238916873931885,
0.2925347685813904,
0.20162156224250793,
-0.24371430277824402,
0.17370274662971497,
-0.4779930114746094,
-0.1020718440413475,
0.35992345213890076,
-0.48422133922576904,
-0.4962101876735687,
-0.17158587276935577,
0.5288940668106079,
0.9818260073661804,
-0.06051531061530113,
-0.0273889247328043,
0.2758788466453552,
0.8098360896110535,
-0.8149889707565308,
0.20245815813541412,
-0.5017552971839905,
0.15581351518630981,
-0.6074426770210266,
0.3094296455383301,
-0.6338930130004883,
-0.6386637687683105,
0.41498154401779175,
-0.5153851509094238,
0.2575037181377411,
-0.4334254562854767,
1.161981463432312,
-0.1137673556804657,
0.008534519001841545,
0.22689059376716614,
-1.064261555671692,
0.5835133194923401,
-0.657770037651062,
0.49716392159461975,
0.24463878571987152,
0.5884783267974854,
-0.3063998520374298,
-0.6551027894020081,
-0.6750149130821228,
-0.06515685468912125,
0.16012538969516754,
0.0981108695268631,
-0.3065757751464844,
0.19023078680038452,
-0.0855862945318222,
0.10799776017665863,
-0.2801169753074646,
0.4823979139328003,
-0.737078845500946,
-0.20225480198860168,
0.3384748697280884,
-0.43637678027153015,
-0.0035027957055717707,
-0.003382677910849452,
-0.48340097069740295,
-0.3532314598560333,
-0.9098970293998718,
0.10403086245059967,
0.6864300966262817,
0.47855857014656067,
-0.20317326486110687,
0.2333543449640274,
-0.0796118751168251,
0.8226156830787659,
-0.07383602112531662,
0.2593142092227936,
0.2909427583217621,
0.2832081615924835,
-0.1276254951953888,
0.04508053883910179,
0.4760296642780304,
0.481688916683197,
0.20572078227996826,
-0.3049095869064331,
-0.1328827142715454,
-0.3004709780216217,
-0.10310883074998856,
-0.6015272736549377,
-0.5832631587982178,
0.133759543299675,
-0.8277403712272644,
-0.18288107216358185,
0.04328325390815735,
-0.6970146298408508,
-0.08763878047466278,
-0.22054535150527954,
0.4967116713523865,
-0.8577833771705627,
-0.3681531846523285,
-0.17015184462070465,
-0.01944787986576557,
0.16812598705291748,
0.3622697591781616,
-0.9578787088394165,
0.2994581162929535,
0.5368155837059021,
0.9750174283981323,
-0.11837369948625565,
-0.25448253750801086,
-0.4983353614807129,
0.26003989577293396,
-0.18542252480983734,
0.6141522526741028,
-0.4916287362575531,
-0.11294746398925781,
-0.12552247941493988,
-0.28894636034965515,
0.11000102758407593,
-0.4212518334388733,
0.21621659398078918,
-0.762527585029602,
0.20971867442131042,
0.09655964374542236,
-0.4695661962032318,
-0.39664193987846375,
-0.07021274417638779,
-0.7837046384811401,
1.2001094818115234,
0.12381336092948914,
-0.6209161281585693,
0.6036211848258972,
-0.6981214284896851,
-0.3214564323425293,
-0.04094085842370987,
0.1657090038061142,
-0.2113007754087448,
0.2968735694885254,
0.35995596647262573,
0.7259206771850586,
-0.08604305237531662,
0.13623300194740295,
-0.7158233523368835,
-0.6533814668655396,
-0.3754924237728119,
-0.39075472950935364,
0.8375707864761353,
0.24330149590969086,
-0.3810442090034485,
-0.30239778757095337,
-0.9237604141235352,
0.14657247066497803,
0.02293391153216362,
-0.2459273487329483,
-0.7554855346679688,
0.11959695816040039,
-0.2846280634403229,
0.1168297603726387,
0.47332578897476196,
-0.7345004081726074,
0.1564459651708603,
-0.49097734689712524,
-0.02541211061179638,
1.1132128238677979,
-0.1397891789674759,
0.524387776851654,
-0.36259689927101135,
0.2789176404476166,
0.04767307639122009,
0.38930544257164,
0.275669664144516,
-0.7419382929801941,
-0.5972482562065125,
-0.4335508942604065,
0.5045098662376404,
0.43294286727905273,
-0.5290275812149048,
0.8151822686195374,
-0.3431219458580017,
-0.7802945375442505,
-0.31824934482574463,
-0.07309672981500626,
0.18159887194633484,
0.37957245111465454,
0.3704780340194702,
-0.22382107377052307,
-0.8271122574806213,
-0.8657156825065613,
0.019044097512960434,
-0.6171008944511414,
-0.2780158221721649,
-0.008060033433139324,
0.2342558652162552,
-0.14247645437717438,
1.094909906387329,
-0.4493226706981659,
0.04088618978857994,
-0.3276350200176239,
0.24928130209445953,
0.563125491142273,
0.5641868114471436,
0.16931776702404022,
-0.5498718023300171,
-0.27992942929267883,
-0.19657546281814575,
-0.4540671408176422,
0.12101022154092789,
-0.34715330600738525,
-0.4469095468521118,
0.017586659640073776,
0.19902683794498444,
-0.4825207591056824,
0.4063670337200165,
0.5786306858062744,
-0.04857558757066727,
0.5379911661148071,
-0.37414470314979553,
-0.24635250866413116,
-0.8015769720077515,
-0.0716150626540184,
0.029360461980104446,
0.2460923045873642,
-0.6050645112991333,
-0.3984606862068176,
0.05371405556797981,
0.34139150381088257,
-0.5667513012886047,
0.6491206884384155,
-0.3438389301300049,
-0.12069924920797348,
0.29279249906539917,
0.14217239618301392,
0.0964960902929306,
0.2667449116706848,
0.2284308224916458,
0.4942771792411804,
0.44806963205337524,
-0.7253392338752747,
0.061523161828517914,
0.15362194180488586,
-0.5176554322242737,
-0.11859522014856339,
-0.3694620728492737,
0.0863955020904541,
-0.17777910828590393,
0.38548535108566284,
-0.8143909573554993,
0.0362468883395195,
0.0027142076287418604,
-0.4857901632785797,
0.2987959384918213,
0.0101964445784688,
-0.663220226764679,
-0.43441247940063477,
-0.21977455914020538,
0.20249754190444946,
0.8576249480247498,
-0.7581777572631836,
0.40490952134132385,
-0.07384248077869415,
-0.21642501652240753,
-0.5770341157913208,
-0.6365910768508911,
-0.08818137645721436,
-0.10483235865831375,
-0.7915905714035034,
0.4623878300189972,
0.24526040256023407,
-0.23260879516601562,
-0.0775570496916771,
0.05535232275724411,
-0.3796536326408386,
0.04169430583715439,
-0.14407989382743835,
0.368608683347702,
-0.15090592205524445,
0.13065418601036072,
0.21096104383468628,
0.05193708464503288,
0.22693222761154175,
-0.2861022651195526,
0.3263465166091919,
-0.18152159452438354,
-0.24484215676784515,
-0.10319702327251434,
0.27664610743522644,
0.32624393701553345,
-0.0045711323618888855,
1.0134838819503784,
0.874110758304596,
-0.6116252541542053,
-0.0893019288778305,
-0.7386503219604492,
-0.5465523600578308,
-0.4057181775569916,
0.33247214555740356,
-0.4139648973941803,
-0.4052501916885376,
0.6882877945899963,
-0.06831242144107819,
-0.016481595113873482,
0.33243879675865173,
0.3166269361972809,
-0.431833416223526,
0.6404632329940796,
0.8072400689125061,
0.22766254842281342,
0.4637461304664612,
-0.4674948751926422,
0.47490495443344116,
-0.8702250719070435,
-0.5624629855155945,
-0.14730601012706757,
-0.37893226742744446,
-0.33849167823791504,
-0.3953089714050293,
0.4230507016181946,
0.5353550314903259,
-0.205425426363945,
0.32538285851478577,
-0.15301939845085144,
0.5822297930717468,
0.8164976835250854,
0.4709160625934601,
-0.10574543476104736,
0.09559454023838043,
-0.5010120272636414,
-0.2616425156593323,
-0.8974902629852295,
-0.4126368761062622,
1.0336689949035645,
0.5750158429145813,
0.6652888059616089,
0.3494635820388794,
1.1331506967544556,
0.2822364270687103,
0.4495857059955597,
-0.3255075216293335,
0.5699954032897949,
-0.19950325787067413,
-0.6574474573135376,
-0.3731444776058197,
-0.388542503118515,
-0.7683548331260681,
0.0297221802175045,
0.01419117208570242,
-1.138567566871643,
0.4346124231815338,
0.06929071992635727,
-0.6437536478042603,
0.7665814161300659,
-0.739363431930542,
0.6409512758255005,
-0.30392545461654663,
-0.43917757272720337,
0.059060946106910706,
-1.1335201263427734,
0.5801824927330017,
-0.24961043894290924,
0.09500600397586823,
-0.2226574718952179,
0.05330353602766991,
0.841675877571106,
-0.5054275989532471,
1.040141224861145,
-0.5590647459030151,
-0.30328866839408875,
0.29404011368751526,
0.34846729040145874,
0.4712410569190979,
-0.3562793731689453,
-0.2906548082828522,
0.5812255144119263,
-0.3072602152824402,
-0.250816285610199,
-0.5000230073928833,
0.4151003956794739,
-0.7848052978515625,
-0.038492124527692795,
-0.022726383060216904,
-0.2569288909435272,
-0.29497697949409485,
0.2658231556415558,
0.29778581857681274,
0.4819675385951996,
0.00514881731942296,
0.06625888496637344,
0.573215663433075,
-0.3121747374534607,
0.6814078092575073,
0.33394500613212585,
0.11186916381120682,
-0.274406373500824,
0.8694503903388977,
-0.05741353705525398,
0.3040938079357147,
0.7211317420005798,
0.41186103224754333,
-0.857833743095398,
-0.4382830858230591,
-0.2932901680469513,
0.07933259755373001,
-0.795880138874054,
-0.0967785120010376,
-0.36622628569602966,
-0.1666751205921173,
-0.4476492404937744,
-0.4242056906223297,
-0.3808439075946808,
-0.4564364552497864,
-0.1456155776977539,
-0.023884855210781097,
0.024630650877952576,
0.6147999167442322,
-0.8618530035018921,
0.2768518030643463,
-1.1577728986740112,
-0.09272119402885437,
0.16062712669372559,
0.47870275378227234,
0.24622511863708496,
-0.3396151065826416,
-0.3180575370788574,
-0.14328640699386597,
-0.20988933742046356,
-0.9052000641822815,
0.08612367510795593,
0.41240426898002625,
0.7452391386032104,
0.9051100611686707,
0.14530959725379944,
0.8159151077270508,
-0.47699591517448425,
0.9328137636184692,
0.43991348147392273,
-0.8139892220497131,
0.6732773780822754,
-0.37188705801963806,
0.06268621236085892,
0.4492620825767517,
0.3984145522117615,
-0.14140185713768005,
-0.4315166473388672,
-0.8051112294197083,
-1.0786312818527222,
0.5163520574569702,
0.36847081780433655,
-0.1539829969406128,
-0.3492738902568817,
0.07556100934743881,
0.33450639247894287,
-0.004485603887587786,
-0.6798468828201294,
-0.2186659276485443,
0.1751798838376999,
0.1287754625082016,
0.09114617854356766,
-0.1748467981815338,
0.16578875482082367,
-0.4179522693157196,
0.7444410920143127,
0.03990786522626877,
0.6698876023292542,
0.05239802598953247,
-0.00909133069217205,
0.04954599589109421,
0.08793246746063232,
0.41532981395721436,
0.6650498509407043,
-0.8150396347045898,
-0.001821716665290296,
0.20187537372112274,
-0.24718235433101654,
0.4048449397087097,
0.4165218472480774,
0.004997961223125458,
0.16848227381706238,
0.611068606376648,
0.38432765007019043,
0.1445179283618927,
-0.42239782214164734,
0.5756472945213318,
0.06499782204627991,
-0.06638719141483307,
-0.3525388836860657,
-0.22995567321777344,
-0.35362058877944946,
0.15226700901985168,
0.46987220644950867,
0.11681360006332397,
0.08992414176464081,
-0.16144081950187683,
0.5170037150382996,
0.13838230073451996,
-0.2794507145881653,
-0.3656781017780304,
0.7646379470825195,
0.5664437413215637,
0.18214233219623566,
0.7809086441993713,
-0.07554944604635239,
-0.3803796172142029,
0.5952371954917908,
0.43095505237579346,
1.195957899093628,
-0.09553130716085434,
0.1994716376066208,
0.30528244376182556,
0.38135918974876404,
0.05028410628437996,
0.23982708156108856,
-0.40473058819770813,
-0.811438262462616,
-0.8046556711196899,
-0.6440731287002563,
-0.28584372997283936,
0.26605895161628723,
-0.8347182869911194,
0.11508268117904663,
-0.37446892261505127,
-0.03304032236337662,
-0.6044540405273438,
-0.04507770389318466,
-0.7272425889968872,
0.26453202962875366,
0.717331051826477,
1.234816312789917,
-0.9535984396934509,
0.7875773310661316,
0.6526448726654053,
-0.10547292977571487,
-0.62173992395401,
0.15508189797401428,
-0.010201716795563698,
-0.7031561732292175,
1.180065393447876,
0.43084678053855896,
-0.28480812907218933,
-0.24101093411445618,
-0.2433357685804367,
-0.7663491368293762,
0.9000433087348938,
0.37079787254333496,
-0.6413103342056274,
-0.47666382789611816,
-0.22943736612796783,
0.18033362925052643,
-0.3022902011871338,
0.6693538427352905,
0.7742783427238464,
0.4506714642047882,
0.05773236230015755,
-0.6892625689506531,
-0.04222593456506729,
-0.1112479642033577,
0.25961217284202576,
0.39358076453208923,
-0.5375156998634338,
0.8997913002967834,
-0.6608478426933289,
-0.03594086319208145,
0.156874418258667,
0.7856132984161377,
0.04452455788850784,
-0.08473428338766098,
0.8615492582321167,
0.6013396978378296,
0.7224628329277039,
-0.26567018032073975,
0.823108971118927,
-0.44229233264923096,
0.0983874499797821,
1.273708462715149,
-0.12855039536952972,
1.0152138471603394,
0.34435561299324036,
-0.2225181609392166,
0.8172339797019958,
1.078999400138855,
0.25505322217941284,
0.9278584122657776,
0.23710571229457855,
-0.4363292157649994,
-0.31317976117134094,
0.4036826491355896,
-0.5768324136734009,
0.5771666765213013,
0.35534313321113586,
-0.3136408030986786,
-0.49705854058265686,
-0.25165536999702454,
0.019472504034638405,
-0.2708493769168854,
0.21071216464042664,
0.6346146464347839,
-0.2844372093677521,
-0.4367125928401947,
0.5305200219154358,
-0.09582297503948212,
0.4458719491958618,
-0.6745262742042542,
-0.1578337401151657,
-0.3710378110408783,
0.2193414270877838,
0.07376039773225784,
-0.46968886256217957,
0.13210441172122955,
-0.32725781202316284,
0.010364353656768799,
-0.2529038190841675,
0.5579677820205688,
-0.27909448742866516,
-0.3175818622112274,
0.4675064980983734,
0.6349422335624695,
0.31832125782966614,
0.2682726979255676,
-0.6708160042762756,
0.08714212477207184,
-0.19440773129463196,
-0.15337011218070984,
0.016306670382618904,
0.5381138920783997,
0.2706993818283081,
0.4718364179134369,
0.767877459526062,
0.5103363394737244,
0.08102525770664215,
0.15068507194519043,
0.8822128176689148,
-0.41363808512687683,
-0.6975170373916626,
-0.9671372771263123,
0.716442346572876,
-0.1956912726163864,
-0.22137947380542755,
0.5436526536941528,
0.5152283310890198,
0.8413040041923523,
-0.018560389056801796,
0.8315619230270386,
-0.31646889448165894,
0.5247907638549805,
-0.6774194240570068,
0.5803567171096802,
-0.39505255222320557,
0.3101251423358917,
-0.4542953372001648,
-1.277146577835083,
-0.256862998008728,
0.6265987157821655,
-0.31476905941963196,
0.1585368663072586,
0.6523585319519043,
0.5909553170204163,
-0.0740695372223854,
-0.16901272535324097,
0.26056504249572754,
0.17003396153450012,
0.5558526515960693,
0.7777101397514343,
0.812301516532898,
-0.19273415207862854,
0.4515345096588135,
-0.5263882875442505,
-0.5480612516403198,
-0.304230272769928,
-1.1164132356643677,
-0.7293190360069275,
-0.5385094881057739,
-0.18513642251491547,
-0.38222694396972656,
0.221914142370224,
0.7616226077079773,
1.1630580425262451,
-0.5114580392837524,
0.01645735837519169,
-0.11305177956819534,
-0.11914592981338501,
-0.5044912099838257,
-0.26932382583618164,
0.35940149426460266,
-0.4560774862766266,
-0.46190187335014343,
0.4490258991718292,
0.044834673404693604,
0.34929442405700684,
-0.4614405930042267,
-0.16338849067687988,
-0.1475740373134613,
0.03576190024614334,
0.5611687898635864,
0.21477559208869934,
-0.8304691910743713,
-0.41023027896881104,
-0.3751599192619324,
0.337553471326828,
-0.07688207179307938,
0.5124472379684448,
-0.9581093192100525,
0.7967154383659363,
0.2932479679584503,
0.6007366180419922,
0.3646058440208435,
-0.1700560450553894,
0.990528404712677,
-0.9826460480690002,
0.271147221326828,
0.34982866048812866,
0.1983073502779007,
0.22050204873085022,
-0.36696937680244446,
0.5288548469543457,
0.007426876109093428,
-0.2990644574165344,
-0.7957922220230103,
0.0604262538254261,
-0.43725743889808655,
0.060231368988752365,
0.9457493424415588,
-0.31473174691200256,
-0.36803197860717773,
0.07398150861263275,
0.2953287661075592,
0.19250552356243134,
-0.4555668830871582,
0.9132919311523438,
0.7555870413780212,
-0.430076539516449,
-0.054633788764476776,
-0.4742034375667572,
0.4540914297103882,
0.34585288166999817,
-0.6864339113235474,
0.06172632426023483,
0.3368568420410156,
-0.07736147940158844,
0.11246301978826523,
0.5926753282546997,
0.0014060735702514648,
0.2579613924026489,
-0.017773769795894623,
0.28799477219581604,
0.09486328065395355,
-0.6992804408073425,
-0.14183543622493744,
0.05947147309780121,
-0.11907307058572769,
-0.5730175971984863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02175v1 | Enhancing Complex Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs through Evidence Pattern Retrieval | 2024-02-03T14:54:13 | 2024-02-03T14:54:13 | Wentao Ding, Jinmao Li, Liangchuan Luo, Yuzhong Qu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Information retrieval (IR) methods for KGQA consist of two stages: subgraph
extraction and answer reasoning. We argue current subgraph extraction methods
underestimate the importance of structural dependencies among evidence facts.
We propose Evidence Pattern Retrieval (EPR) to explicitly model the structural
dependencies during subgraph extraction. We implement EPR by indexing the
atomic adjacency pattern of resource pairs. Given a question, we perform dense
retrieval to obtain atomic patterns formed by resource pairs. We then enumerate
their combinations to construct candidate evidence patterns. These evidence
patterns are scored using a neural model, and the best one is selected to
extract a subgraph for downstream answer reasoning. Experimental results
demonstrate that the EPR-based approach has significantly improved the F1
scores of IR-KGQA methods by over 10 points on ComplexWebQuestions and achieves
competitive performance on WebQuestionsSP. | [
-0.43813374638557434,
-1.1660226583480835,
0.6882511377334595,
-0.1425272822380066,
-0.13987261056900024,
0.1575637310743332,
0.41445258259773254,
-0.5176282525062561,
0.08061183989048004,
0.3570641577243805,
-0.13180522620677948,
-0.39274871349334717,
-0.5298411250114441,
0.02467362768948078,
0.0007056716713123024,
0.5821946859359741,
-0.14280475676059723,
0.35332852602005005,
-0.35629191994667053,
-0.022032085806131363,
-0.2255575954914093,
-0.5925690531730652,
-0.5358490347862244,
-0.7175334095954895,
0.6158122420310974,
0.5432801246643066,
0.40881797671318054,
0.7505665421485901,
0.43648967146873474,
0.30120959877967834,
-0.4356074333190918,
0.42633533477783203,
-0.39208731055259705,
0.18679308891296387,
0.03978446498513222,
-0.5948712229728699,
-0.16704727709293365,
-0.15198233723640442,
0.05291655659675598,
0.7371271252632141,
-0.2491791546344757,
0.12500759959220886,
-0.28087830543518066,
0.544479250907898,
-0.6818698048591614,
0.3333955407142639,
-0.3203335404396057,
0.0007883158978074789,
-0.12107082456350327,
-0.5628677010536194,
-0.6069082021713257,
-0.28345099091529846,
0.3080679774284363,
-0.602822482585907,
0.18925480544567108,
0.2641153335571289,
0.9056966304779053,
-0.06673519313335419,
-0.7004905343055725,
-0.48889315128326416,
-0.5661584138870239,
0.4525737166404724,
-0.3734499216079712,
0.5032094717025757,
0.5075122117996216,
0.43200892210006714,
-0.30819451808929443,
-0.9931820631027222,
-0.35518547892570496,
-0.11715072393417358,
-0.5313979387283325,
0.2249070554971695,
0.03333765268325806,
0.24411235749721527,
0.4196443557739258,
0.24320894479751587,
-0.39093783497810364,
-0.45578983426094055,
-0.3114761412143707,
-0.5467734336853027,
0.3090410828590393,
0.24363026022911072,
0.5495014190673828,
-0.35222622752189636,
-0.13854649662971497,
-0.17977003753185272,
-0.7611607313156128,
0.3751353919506073,
0.28279587626457214,
0.2630610167980194,
0.3855501115322113,
0.6663230061531067,
-0.6174672842025757,
0.8747785687446594,
0.09794622659683228,
-0.14541247487068176,
0.021325860172510147,
-0.09230447560548782,
0.12697112560272217,
0.478846937417984,
0.12015900760889053,
0.06810525804758072,
0.027283579111099243,
-0.32937902212142944,
0.06255676597356796,
-0.07939407229423523,
0.009092678315937519,
-1.008784532546997,
-0.5687843561172485,
0.2248971164226532,
-0.6359202861785889,
0.0824250802397728,
0.21248361468315125,
-0.5567299127578735,
-0.2989960014820099,
-0.28861159086227417,
0.7290855050086975,
-0.4117799699306488,
-0.36237478256225586,
0.055120427161455154,
-0.7596202492713928,
0.45163989067077637,
0.4305303394794464,
-0.2564701735973358,
0.4427635669708252,
0.6191572546958923,
0.5294257998466492,
0.3826998472213745,
0.20193392038345337,
-0.45428889989852905,
0.23304766416549683,
-0.23679092526435852,
1.004284143447876,
-0.7771749496459961,
0.09009608626365662,
-0.2561527490615845,
-0.05571260675787926,
0.2391045093536377,
-0.6715020537376404,
0.4924744665622711,
-1.1713755130767822,
0.21691279113292694,
-0.6016770005226135,
-0.6227383613586426,
-0.5867364406585693,
0.4819243550300598,
-0.710199236869812,
0.8398979902267456,
0.07156997919082642,
-0.8282209634780884,
0.13831451535224915,
-0.6651591658592224,
-0.6337170600891113,
0.03510010614991188,
-0.19681774079799652,
-0.18782994151115417,
-0.34987813234329224,
0.3476727306842804,
0.2738340497016907,
-0.29829657077789307,
-0.0877515971660614,
-0.19723224639892578,
-0.2821628749370575,
0.06064395233988762,
0.11553288251161575,
0.6282060742378235,
0.24413879215717316,
-0.12000652402639389,
-0.18845507502555847,
-0.8362396955490112,
0.45649394392967224,
-0.030208835378289223,
-0.5567117929458618,
-0.8660811185836792,
0.2256399393081665,
-0.29781028628349304,
0.10343796759843826,
-0.04734666272997856,
-0.9117966890335083,
-0.06655541062355042,
-0.19094666838645935,
0.3486897349357605,
0.6406704783439636,
0.4119771420955658,
0.12940892577171326,
-0.39338064193725586,
0.3444523811340332,
0.2702028155326843,
0.0023828689008951187,
-0.08536968380212784,
-0.635362982749939,
-0.7000301480293274,
-0.29123860597610474,
0.44045889377593994,
0.47414031624794006,
-0.7221243977546692,
-0.05618634447455406,
-0.10578812658786774,
-0.5521791577339172,
-0.43107566237449646,
-0.19670526683330536,
0.8626495003700256,
0.6162463426589966,
0.6047970652580261,
-0.48797938227653503,
-0.8225679397583008,
-0.8837960362434387,
-0.24807260930538177,
-0.24520696699619293,
-0.016642451286315918,
0.42967334389686584,
0.31076037883758545,
0.28841862082481384,
1.1004104614257812,
-0.8944013714790344,
0.12875543534755707,
-0.17540818452835083,
0.43990787863731384,
0.274029403924942,
0.2513563930988312,
0.21738256514072418,
-1.3367353677749634,
-0.5460922718048096,
0.10205146670341492,
-0.7256287932395935,
0.016439851373434067,
0.3539791703224182,
-0.4862481951713562,
-0.40407595038414,
0.48100513219833374,
-0.64033043384552,
0.18876127898693085,
-0.1575433909893036,
-0.6282162666320801,
0.07700663805007935,
0.3290359079837799,
0.3286176919937134,
-0.8710436820983887,
0.023703834041953087,
-0.14846336841583252,
-0.30052921175956726,
-0.7917535901069641,
0.18021714687347412,
-0.07791627198457718,
0.3370700776576996,
-0.050537124276161194,
0.1739560067653656,
-0.607674777507782,
-0.07706655561923981,
0.034586917608976364,
-0.21559089422225952,
0.19960075616836548,
0.48091596364974976,
-0.2284599095582962,
0.47993671894073486,
0.023121578618884087,
-0.5781118869781494,
0.2711295783519745,
0.348491370677948,
-0.6141061186790466,
0.264392226934433,
-0.8368781805038452,
0.438529372215271,
-0.616960883140564,
0.08949195593595505,
-1.2872848510742188,
-0.2790071964263916,
0.14232051372528076,
-0.4722447693347931,
0.48600974678993225,
-0.38938096165657043,
-0.15408343076705933,
-0.007801354397088289,
-0.07463496178388596,
0.20155535638332367,
0.42191991209983826,
-0.39869001507759094,
1.0890792608261108,
0.4808472692966461,
-0.25523725152015686,
-0.6476001739501953,
-0.29379475116729736,
-0.35344600677490234,
0.12589521706104279,
-0.6662119626998901,
0.28574028611183167,
0.0459737591445446,
-0.44576650857925415,
0.3349258005619049,
-0.35427653789520264,
-0.2808126211166382,
0.19502423703670502,
0.1544898897409439,
-0.07377142459154129,
-0.33437374234199524,
-0.1476927399635315,
-0.014192387461662292,
-0.049909066408872604,
0.006303867325186729,
0.08990094810724258,
0.7292565107345581,
0.19485406577587128,
-0.2906377613544464,
-0.17191137373447418,
0.5116344094276428,
0.6382685303688049,
-0.13904620707035065,
0.47571441531181335,
0.16176143288612366,
-0.33381012082099915,
0.013019572012126446,
-0.7160974144935608,
-0.24976718425750732,
-0.45456016063690186,
0.6221993565559387,
-0.6627597808837891,
-0.8163866996765137,
0.7443872094154358,
-0.40874963998794556,
-0.264473557472229,
0.14406411349773407,
0.39795997738838196,
-0.07669758051633835,
1.411808729171753,
0.34347084164619446,
0.30022531747817993,
0.41248640418052673,
-0.2544765770435333,
0.14300687611103058,
-0.8547431826591492,
-0.673961341381073,
-0.40222737193107605,
-0.17692188918590546,
-0.06310705095529556,
-0.07259033620357513,
0.7110821008682251,
0.4239751398563385,
-0.4059252440929413,
0.021858882158994675,
-0.4335264563560486,
0.5903780460357666,
0.6587304472923279,
0.6893860697746277,
0.3416566550731659,
0.14520595967769623,
-0.2677699327468872,
0.07476113736629486,
-0.8746739625930786,
-0.09175620973110199,
0.819455623626709,
-0.007692903280258179,
0.5785734057426453,
0.48346248269081116,
0.14568352699279785,
0.27176135778427124,
0.4869191348552704,
-0.7829088568687439,
0.5273650884628296,
0.13648636639118195,
-0.7752191424369812,
-0.3695739507675171,
-0.599679172039032,
-0.6971251964569092,
0.43573835492134094,
-0.05935300141572952,
-0.28244051337242126,
0.24717675149440765,
-0.12779061496257782,
-0.22569505870342255,
-0.03463677689433098,
-0.8056795597076416,
0.4340912401676178,
0.016423897817730904,
-0.12604211270809174,
-0.03954903781414032,
-0.7745937705039978,
0.12323863804340363,
0.303859144449234,
0.02610742673277855,
0.22310633957386017,
0.35176900029182434,
0.8834341764450073,
-0.5634335279464722,
0.6441553831100464,
-0.38674136996269226,
0.3376365303993225,
0.5234889388084412,
0.09813728928565979,
0.7876516580581665,
-0.321401447057724,
-0.2688889801502228,
-0.24822241067886353,
-0.04769594222307205,
-0.5056828856468201,
-0.8341645002365112,
0.11143835633993149,
-0.9431564211845398,
-0.756392240524292,
-0.21888962388038635,
-0.41856881976127625,
-0.2308831661939621,
0.20706872642040253,
0.12078718841075897,
0.7483087778091431,
0.11645649373531342,
0.30924463272094727,
0.820787787437439,
0.13840658962726593,
0.08572609722614288,
0.695861279964447,
0.23994314670562744,
-0.5521920323371887,
0.4906320571899414,
0.46221619844436646,
0.2821674048900604,
0.8305431604385376,
0.4183647930622101,
-0.2529131770133972,
-0.6532089710235596,
-0.37862828373908997,
-0.05799741670489311,
-0.9598295092582703,
-0.44585469365119934,
-0.904954731464386,
-0.21228265762329102,
-0.3894609808921814,
0.19273780286312103,
0.03135861083865166,
-0.5398780703544617,
0.3545394539833069,
-0.37277570366859436,
0.5793101191520691,
0.6191654205322266,
0.0888725146651268,
-0.0973498523235321,
-0.7897687554359436,
0.36824336647987366,
0.6324768662452698,
0.018662497401237488,
0.2925454080104828,
-0.36915603280067444,
-0.10232717543840408,
-0.05513586848974228,
-0.12617459893226624,
-0.8800279498100281,
-0.12536750733852386,
0.14837926626205444,
0.7994168996810913,
0.23781636357307434,
0.40616005659103394,
1.1767271757125854,
-0.44022858142852783,
0.46180370450019836,
-0.045474082231521606,
-0.6177275776863098,
0.5900753140449524,
-0.227973073720932,
-0.09264840185642242,
0.3615368902683258,
0.8155841827392578,
-0.3674146831035614,
-0.1955232322216034,
-0.2565259039402008,
-0.9238832592964172,
0.712327241897583,
0.08972001075744629,
-0.25061938166618347,
-0.01088174432516098,
0.7087046504020691,
-0.1953163743019104,
-0.08279004693031311,
-0.41467082500457764,
-0.30809903144836426,
-0.1593349426984787,
-0.2347075641155243,
0.7048184871673584,
-0.5162026286125183,
-0.45867496728897095,
-0.2580101788043976,
0.5805784463882446,
-0.06938066333532333,
0.29114237427711487,
0.8625826835632324,
-0.0642976388335228,
-0.2674374282360077,
0.19984766840934753,
0.034470174461603165,
0.8007732629776001,
-0.2619067430496216,
0.3886759579181671,
0.06210314482450485,
-0.6171719431877136,
0.2391221672296524,
-0.014677971601486206,
-0.37800875306129456,
-0.06279008835554123,
0.7072397470474243,
0.3054903745651245,
-0.1935608983039856,
-0.47089821100234985,
0.509645402431488,
-0.04357050359249115,
0.02655608206987381,
-0.29159972071647644,
0.04103643074631691,
-0.05685146152973175,
0.5635988116264343,
0.7343418598175049,
-0.2162790298461914,
0.38823091983795166,
-0.8187810778617859,
0.38674482703208923,
0.34176015853881836,
-0.4985235035419464,
-0.11135018616914749,
0.2718319594860077,
-0.10378945618867874,
-0.24931079149246216,
0.8176734447479248,
-0.16269852221012115,
-0.8146836161613464,
0.958203911781311,
0.7786354422569275,
0.24583815038204193,
-0.24799896776676178,
0.11459420621395111,
0.5166584849357605,
0.10273924469947815,
-0.1683528870344162,
0.8220531940460205,
-0.0741695836186409,
-0.8443651795387268,
-0.5123535990715027,
-0.5069139003753662,
-0.36585336923599243,
-0.2501085102558136,
-0.7214870452880859,
-0.0048084682784974575,
-0.39488062262535095,
0.28579726815223694,
0.12881064414978027,
-0.05873339623212814,
-0.07591115683317184,
0.20402507483959198,
-0.32068386673927307,
0.7829720973968506,
-0.7362990975379944,
0.4377170503139496,
0.872586190700531,
-0.4496525526046753,
-1.2529338598251343,
-0.24657326936721802,
-0.0944434180855751,
-0.6645821928977966,
1.008362054824829,
0.02309456840157509,
-0.12004169076681137,
0.19660145044326782,
-0.6906853914260864,
-0.9467234015464783,
1.361833930015564,
0.09136521816253662,
-0.07504883408546448,
0.10851585119962692,
-0.04394696652889252,
0.32513198256492615,
-0.14574740827083588,
0.6562005877494812,
0.08472979068756104,
0.4681091010570526,
0.5183750987052917,
-0.37166136503219604,
0.5412495732307434,
-0.5363312363624573,
-0.0932551696896553,
0.6256557703018188,
-0.6617720723152161,
0.9723460674285889,
-0.08142264932394028,
-0.4861387312412262,
0.022015618160367012,
0.5196074843406677,
0.31390807032585144,
0.42973408102989197,
0.7305523753166199,
0.7364453673362732,
0.688271701335907,
-0.06308608502149582,
0.8828443884849548,
-0.23684880137443542,
0.28529784083366394,
0.8892084360122681,
-0.1719706803560257,
0.7627967596054077,
0.37796488404273987,
-0.19595487415790558,
0.8990342617034912,
0.708310067653656,
0.22494623064994812,
0.8977338671684265,
0.3032655119895935,
-0.2191685438156128,
-0.6459286212921143,
-0.4850713312625885,
-0.39101436734199524,
0.4276493787765503,
0.314394474029541,
-0.20843783020973206,
-0.29658594727516174,
-0.2947113513946533,
0.2199786752462387,
-0.0729290023446083,
-0.37741899490356445,
0.8318633437156677,
-0.09429699182510376,
-0.8166303038597107,
0.24234195053577423,
-0.07127697765827179,
0.11730030179023743,
-0.7531336545944214,
-0.7429296970367432,
-0.1939738243818283,
0.2495187520980835,
-0.34334710240364075,
-0.48237237334251404,
0.02062515914440155,
-0.27257606387138367,
-0.4042135179042816,
0.046341847628355026,
0.8174014687538147,
-0.1803271472454071,
-0.2544543147087097,
0.3201395869255066,
0.5659728646278381,
-0.10199156403541565,
0.10298985242843628,
-0.28573930263519287,
-0.6191781163215637,
-0.15489616990089417,
-0.4975401759147644,
0.3239935338497162,
0.7094873785972595,
-0.0960812121629715,
0.4319341480731964,
0.9968717694282532,
-0.2622508108615875,
0.06757597625255585,
-0.035413708537817,
1.0904232263565063,
-0.5204067230224609,
-0.2798929214477539,
-0.7714943885803223,
0.3345898389816284,
-0.2855144441127777,
-0.12709583342075348,
0.7971699237823486,
0.6426638960838318,
0.8192209005355835,
0.3494659960269928,
0.6507917046546936,
-0.5781658887863159,
0.5286211371421814,
-0.7482882738113403,
0.4889468550682068,
-0.3544396162033081,
0.12694159150123596,
-0.22324590384960175,
-0.534057080745697,
-0.42133480310440063,
0.5106539726257324,
-0.16772279143333435,
-0.18415752053260803,
0.6210642457008362,
1.1204934120178223,
-0.1278240829706192,
0.24179618060588837,
-0.020260309800505638,
0.6100635528564453,
0.3312560021877289,
0.4483264684677124,
1.1423606872558594,
-0.5196793079376221,
0.802537739276886,
-0.27489760518074036,
-0.32168447971343994,
-0.08420495688915253,
-0.48226362466812134,
-0.6778794527053833,
-0.3750634491443634,
-0.12787790596485138,
-0.6962977051734924,
0.19218219816684723,
0.8081631660461426,
0.6945853233337402,
-0.8626615405082703,
0.0614769347012043,
-0.2044043242931366,
0.32216140627861023,
-0.35483211278915405,
-0.2595888078212738,
0.5773036479949951,
-0.0465405136346817,
-0.16966024041175842,
0.265496164560318,
0.05669086426496506,
-0.24358300864696503,
0.2773306369781494,
0.01419390644878149,
-0.6887100338935852,
-0.12788788974285126,
0.7117522358894348,
0.1753760427236557,
-0.40004491806030273,
-0.6263678073883057,
0.27562758326530457,
0.0888674408197403,
0.18380549550056458,
0.9750065207481384,
-0.6206195950508118,
0.4116656482219696,
1.1195504665374756,
0.637019157409668,
0.6790016293525696,
0.37014609575271606,
0.44456642866134644,
-0.5969975590705872,
-0.16099336743354797,
0.22600577771663666,
0.28405606746673584,
0.08287610858678818,
-0.6009473204612732,
0.7434331774711609,
0.3200085163116455,
-0.472168892621994,
-0.6807052493095398,
0.5829854011535645,
-0.8241368532180786,
-0.5810472369194031,
0.9592409133911133,
-0.38717618584632874,
-0.2669070363044739,
-0.8619123697280884,
-0.12999731302261353,
0.3903397023677826,
-0.1378956288099289,
0.8049197793006897,
0.8152064085006714,
-0.6684452295303345,
-0.09975927323102951,
-0.18655452132225037,
0.078109510242939,
0.22098824381828308,
-0.5291043519973755,
-0.3007293939590454,
0.4376341700553894,
0.42480963468551636,
0.592628538608551,
0.751939594745636,
-0.3091060221195221,
0.30161628127098083,
0.12790228426456451,
-0.1719532310962677,
-0.43516677618026733,
-0.35050302743911743,
0.2851644456386566,
0.6961709260940552,
-0.00798140000551939,
0.025743991136550903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02145v1 | Analyzing Sentiment Polarity Reduction in News Presentation through Contextual Perturbation and Large Language Models | 2024-02-03T13:27:32 | 2024-02-03T13:27:32 | Alapan Kuila, Somnath Jena, Sudeshna Sarkar, Partha Pratim Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL | In today's media landscape, where news outlets play a pivotal role in shaping
public opinion, it is imperative to address the issue of sentiment manipulation
within news text. News writers often inject their own biases and emotional
language, which can distort the objectivity of reporting. This paper introduces
a novel approach to tackle this problem by reducing the polarity of latent
sentiments in news content. Drawing inspiration from adversarial attack-based
sentence perturbation techniques and a prompt based method using ChatGPT, we
employ transformation constraints to modify sentences while preserving their
core semantics. Using three perturbation methods: replacement, insertion, and
deletion coupled with a context-aware masked language model, we aim to maximize
the desired sentiment score for targeted news aspects through a beam search
algorithm. Our experiments and human evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness
of these two models in achieving reduced sentiment polarity with minimal
modifications while maintaining textual similarity, fluency, and grammatical
correctness. Comparative analysis confirms the competitive performance of the
adversarial attack based perturbation methods and prompt-based methods,
offering a promising solution to foster more objective news reporting and
combat emotional language bias in the media. | [
-0.6503756046295166,
-0.9196856617927551,
0.3849705159664154,
0.29514193534851074,
-0.6045783758163452,
0.003827061038464308,
-0.3291434645652771,
0.2386077642440796,
0.3937080204486847,
0.5775372385978699,
-0.6386780142784119,
-0.8066158294677734,
-0.5433115363121033,
-0.044744864106178284,
-0.2499697208404541,
1.3127316236495972,
0.07862058281898499,
0.32570478320121765,
-0.07073807716369629,
-0.2956514358520508,
-0.27556365728378296,
-0.7244069576263428,
-0.42010563611984253,
-0.06638101488351822,
0.42412590980529785,
0.23423105478286743,
0.9399471282958984,
0.024036459624767303,
0.5695755481719971,
0.06779561191797256,
-0.567718505859375,
-0.33207473158836365,
-0.4919756352901459,
0.05114901810884476,
-0.21337683498859406,
-0.5489336848258972,
-0.407968670129776,
0.43543076515197754,
0.5235796570777893,
0.6204463839530945,
0.17055000364780426,
0.009217580780386925,
0.04590529203414917,
0.7578665018081665,
-0.4596404731273651,
0.13308842480182648,
-0.6020439863204956,
0.31465575098991394,
-0.1548839807510376,
-0.4115762710571289,
-0.5065476298332214,
0.0557028204202652,
-0.10388240963220596,
-0.2947099804878235,
0.30793559551239014,
-0.15284553170204163,
0.8832135796546936,
0.371832013130188,
-0.5970261096954346,
0.11130379140377045,
-0.5563517212867737,
0.9072878956794739,
-0.7880945205688477,
0.19239039719104767,
0.03823889046907425,
-0.12802602350711823,
-0.025701770558953285,
-0.06409350782632828,
-0.5609844923019409,
-0.13881729543209076,
-0.00603667926043272,
0.3839074373245239,
-0.1520920693874359,
0.15674057602882385,
0.23640605807304382,
0.22823461890220642,
-0.5141153931617737,
-0.33985644578933716,
0.07417771220207214,
-0.10901392251253128,
0.3756573498249054,
-0.10962189733982086,
0.27694565057754517,
-0.7431346774101257,
-0.39079898595809937,
-0.24787761270999908,
-0.8328590393066406,
0.1995609998703003,
0.3776478171348572,
0.1876617968082428,
0.04448731616139412,
0.6201231479644775,
-0.23043739795684814,
0.3166463375091553,
0.20549166202545166,
-0.10687992721796036,
0.20933367311954498,
-0.06067230552434921,
-0.08471637964248657,
0.10009761154651642,
0.5705258846282959,
0.8692852854728699,
-0.4033665359020233,
0.11151014268398285,
-0.15148085355758667,
0.23482783138751984,
0.11567450314760208,
-0.6747980713844299,
0.11238033324480057,
-0.05027427896857262,
-0.7692433595657349,
-0.7957432866096497,
0.13608136773109436,
-1.0214051008224487,
-0.8297296166419983,
-0.22020070254802704,
0.1367030292749405,
-0.013651175424456596,
-0.01927058957517147,
0.0045477584935724735,
0.026406658813357353,
0.2501693665981293,
0.38394954800605774,
-0.24956274032592773,
-0.06388477236032486,
0.6690293550491333,
0.6849128603935242,
0.04052463546395302,
0.1968953162431717,
-0.51213538646698,
0.028259877115488052,
-0.19271524250507355,
0.4544235169887543,
-0.5964310765266418,
-0.2677164077758789,
-0.13667935132980347,
-0.35840949416160583,
0.27378660440444946,
-0.20293617248535156,
0.5939289331436157,
-0.7897077202796936,
0.6483134031295776,
-0.2732434868812561,
-0.2462337762117386,
-0.3106599748134613,
0.40075990557670593,
-0.5648432374000549,
0.2542320787906647,
0.037118762731552124,
-1.1554322242736816,
0.0804159864783287,
-0.4273306131362915,
-0.6804932951927185,
-0.44380587339401245,
0.08384867757558823,
-0.5142648816108704,
0.37617331743240356,
0.7465487718582153,
0.32756704092025757,
-0.11529939621686935,
0.2381269484758377,
-0.18728294968605042,
-0.05187336727976799,
0.19579005241394043,
-0.40487849712371826,
0.505505383014679,
0.20509058237075806,
-0.4680338501930237,
0.276517778635025,
-0.42258867621421814,
-0.611029863357544,
-0.0587037093937397,
-0.21890008449554443,
-0.4490247368812561,
0.3423451781272888,
0.06151314824819565,
0.36082035303115845,
0.19406673312187195,
-0.46236979961395264,
0.37446320056915283,
-0.7808274030685425,
0.5262473225593567,
0.5695176124572754,
0.22299429774284363,
0.7842996120452881,
-0.03419612720608711,
0.543509840965271,
0.2279072254896164,
0.5615124106407166,
-0.052032582461833954,
-0.30890142917633057,
-0.6108096837997437,
-0.1685405969619751,
-0.14020182192325592,
0.6779334545135498,
-0.988120436668396,
0.07389765977859497,
-0.14269481599330902,
-0.062245626002550125,
-0.4427177309989929,
0.09656640887260437,
0.26045361161231995,
0.7356221675872803,
0.44194284081459045,
-0.18392421305179596,
-0.6228832602500916,
-0.8769972324371338,
-0.4947355389595032,
-0.22219882905483246,
0.0590495727956295,
0.09917204827070236,
-0.24495045840740204,
-0.12269556522369385,
1.079971194267273,
-0.4970201253890991,
-0.27762115001678467,
-0.303335040807724,
0.42827343940734863,
0.5221593976020813,
0.21635165810585022,
0.6348934173583984,
-1.2413703203201294,
-0.40412744879722595,
-0.1748240441083908,
-0.5308083891868591,
-0.180380716919899,
-0.19198821485042572,
0.16597378253936768,
0.4683298170566559,
0.5270037651062012,
-0.7020744681358337,
0.5714123249053955,
0.6519009470939636,
-0.3872396647930145,
0.3606761693954468,
0.5611826777458191,
0.4136251211166382,
-0.9283062815666199,
-0.07256288826465607,
-0.1060880646109581,
-0.4261338710784912,
-0.5357359647750854,
0.07781345397233963,
-0.30333349108695984,
-0.4388962984085083,
-0.5169838666915894,
0.4276582896709442,
-0.3180297613143921,
0.35799911618232727,
-0.33055025339126587,
0.1834784746170044,
0.2736748456954956,
0.3673810660839081,
-0.09417429566383362,
0.5433511137962341,
0.4451107680797577,
-0.0867077112197876,
0.256112277507782,
0.3185311555862427,
0.16149784624576569,
0.577704906463623,
-0.40236151218414307,
0.07303410023450851,
-0.7389147877693176,
0.570390522480011,
-0.9674193263053894,
0.03801973909139633,
0.38323184847831726,
-0.5043497681617737,
0.23920777440071106,
-0.22856414318084717,
-0.17069263756275177,
0.031243059784173965,
-0.7377306222915649,
0.24755266308784485,
0.4919736385345459,
-0.3134416341781616,
0.5062548518180847,
0.24635381996631622,
-0.4810704290866852,
-0.7033365368843079,
-0.6462411284446716,
0.46907269954681396,
-0.26664334535598755,
-0.6833107471466064,
0.48106345534324646,
-0.1808285117149353,
-0.4138708710670471,
-0.05630450323224068,
-0.1924648880958557,
0.334783673286438,
-0.050929486751556396,
0.03259241580963135,
0.43091022968292236,
-0.23275649547576904,
0.22479072213172913,
0.20514261722564697,
-0.03436839208006859,
0.04429072141647339,
-0.023312808945775032,
0.7014209628105164,
-0.23779068887233734,
-0.16590401530265808,
-0.46634921431541443,
0.4656829237937927,
0.7113280892372131,
-0.206512451171875,
0.8857415914535522,
0.6500220894813538,
-0.020678486675024033,
0.05541472136974335,
-0.7016320824623108,
-0.3232599198818207,
-0.3804992735385895,
0.5214663743972778,
-0.1420227736234665,
-0.8040946125984192,
0.4180290699005127,
0.21283838152885437,
-0.32043391466140747,
0.18217255175113678,
0.5421931743621826,
0.21255166828632355,
1.4804506301879883,
0.14903655648231506,
-0.5114477276802063,
0.7389421463012695,
0.13853152096271515,
0.6039603352546692,
-0.585725724697113,
0.21081990003585815,
-0.12584757804870605,
0.028819216415286064,
-0.30451926589012146,
-0.29042530059814453,
0.6607284545898438,
0.12546221911907196,
0.1268673539161682,
-0.08152788877487183,
-0.4500710964202881,
0.30257824063301086,
0.15124595165252686,
0.3975764811038971,
0.20403935015201569,
-0.01411583460867405,
0.3093593716621399,
-0.2486495077610016,
-0.4956827163696289,
-0.5344826579093933,
0.862669050693512,
0.4996701776981354,
0.5158895254135132,
-0.037182122468948364,
0.5459343194961548,
0.22816157341003418,
0.4911772906780243,
-0.7897605895996094,
0.62388014793396,
-0.38234513998031616,
-0.29632219672203064,
-0.1482795625925064,
-0.5780373811721802,
-0.4182349741458893,
0.27168214321136475,
-0.2657804489135742,
-0.3431502878665924,
-0.04391944780945778,
-0.05634775012731552,
0.018822893500328064,
0.30958420038223267,
-0.5347102880477905,
0.5029710531234741,
0.12615187466144562,
-0.4777372181415558,
-0.5057322382926941,
-0.46475866436958313,
0.28510719537734985,
0.44548913836479187,
0.5845715403556824,
-0.164976567029953,
-0.09958918392658234,
0.45641541481018066,
-0.23070600628852844,
0.9096528887748718,
-0.4613107144832611,
-0.03693569451570511,
0.17003986239433289,
0.1654053032398224,
0.5757715702056885,
0.4787634611129761,
-0.07908706367015839,
-0.037409137934446335,
-0.45327696204185486,
-0.43223854899406433,
-0.6852425336837769,
0.7154098749160767,
-0.7662753462791443,
-1.0091884136199951,
-0.035828497260808945,
-0.4686625301837921,
-0.3669142723083496,
0.031852178275585175,
0.23319487273693085,
0.5290622711181641,
-0.30089709162712097,
0.19506965577602386,
0.6284204721450806,
-0.317353755235672,
0.444699227809906,
0.19434936344623566,
-0.15840496122837067,
-0.6298335790634155,
0.7781515717506409,
-0.14008758962154388,
-0.027585230767726898,
0.5801924467086792,
0.31646114587783813,
-0.09346815198659897,
-0.5191628336906433,
0.06642868369817734,
0.21319536864757538,
-0.8407789468765259,
-0.2028866559267044,
-0.42082297801971436,
0.2373107373714447,
-0.8100285530090332,
-0.4888850152492523,
-0.4330381751060486,
-0.4825241267681122,
-0.4073471128940582,
0.020332545042037964,
-0.08016650378704071,
0.33810266852378845,
0.24856746196746826,
0.43718069791793823,
-0.6749927401542664,
0.26174819469451904,
0.35793861746788025,
0.06763145327568054,
-0.40855172276496887,
-0.4692857563495636,
0.15341497957706451,
-0.0571124441921711,
-0.3171895742416382,
-1.1948468685150146,
0.7768527865409851,
-0.1955987513065338,
0.2914106249809265,
0.3790452778339386,
0.3921405076980591,
0.07640984654426575,
-0.12015866488218307,
0.9754208326339722,
0.392974317073822,
-1.3280608654022217,
0.903622567653656,
-0.6260197162628174,
0.1713726967573166,
0.40470391511917114,
0.18620577454566956,
-0.42845550179481506,
-0.5907006859779358,
-0.6079172492027283,
-0.99276202917099,
0.4887584149837494,
0.21002668142318726,
0.12957894802093506,
0.01140751875936985,
0.3088414669036865,
-0.09125134348869324,
0.5256344676017761,
-0.9245641827583313,
-0.10671219974756241,
-0.6696537733078003,
-0.32093027234077454,
-0.181968554854393,
-0.5155009627342224,
-0.3695991635322571,
-0.17781749367713928,
0.8713107705116272,
-0.054696619510650635,
0.037871576845645905,
0.49292296171188354,
-0.25942566990852356,
0.09061571210622787,
0.6118801832199097,
0.5358226299285889,
0.1332610547542572,
-0.22383226454257965,
0.29172512888908386,
-0.07648961246013641,
-0.30580273270606995,
0.017305836081504822,
-0.03959212079644203,
-0.5203656554222107,
0.1772221475839615,
0.14894481003284454,
0.8078250288963318,
0.12522923946380615,
-0.29813867807388306,
0.9679490923881531,
-0.15197716653347015,
0.2390209585428238,
0.018030008301138878,
-0.4942781329154968,
-0.23888900876045227,
0.3370199203491211,
0.4172529876232147,
0.3381423354148865,
0.34875789284706116,
-0.576000452041626,
-0.06378279626369476,
0.5192012190818787,
-0.5861018896102905,
-0.48627468943595886,
0.5936471223831177,
0.3909059464931488,
-0.10020079463720322,
0.25985151529312134,
-0.24408254027366638,
-0.7777309417724609,
0.29875144362449646,
0.2166489064693451,
0.8650863766670227,
-0.27727752923965454,
0.6318854689598083,
0.1106724962592125,
0.23095524311065674,
0.03988869860768318,
-0.1252117156982422,
0.11384508013725281,
-0.7473698854446411,
-0.5380480885505676,
-0.4367189109325409,
-0.35182517766952515,
0.06713475286960602,
-0.6879112720489502,
0.43539687991142273,
-0.6328065991401672,
-0.3255511522293091,
-0.10719994455575943,
-0.06041458249092102,
-0.09984781593084335,
0.19919925928115845,
0.47842785716056824,
0.33325499296188354,
-0.8320337533950806,
0.35479074716567993,
1.1319739818572998,
-0.5837923884391785,
-0.4018573462963104,
0.39878785610198975,
0.20611560344696045,
-0.21018646657466888,
0.3772418200969696,
0.1290823221206665,
-0.07485480606555939,
-0.19171622395515442,
-0.9114765524864197,
-0.312427282333374,
0.48923128843307495,
0.6477606892585754,
-0.2613047957420349,
0.14595557749271393,
0.009581130929291248,
0.46855783462524414,
-0.3459400534629822,
0.027182748541235924,
0.15281638503074646,
0.6358000636100769,
0.013962446711957455,
-0.6049508452415466,
0.23987676203250885,
-0.23376809060573578,
0.10943277180194855,
-0.08036065101623535,
-0.8288573026657104,
1.0530407428741455,
0.2795683443546295,
-0.26074057817459106,
-0.4331503212451935,
0.516215980052948,
-0.0908355787396431,
0.36056458950042725,
0.539636492729187,
0.05980455502867699,
0.1980719119310379,
0.11788623034954071,
0.8779774308204651,
-0.4179078936576843,
0.7121403813362122,
0.4544559419155121,
-0.33102157711982727,
0.6018889546394348,
0.8838135600090027,
0.06794925034046173,
0.4978591799736023,
-0.07935987412929535,
0.3763614594936371,
0.6131241321563721,
0.028567979112267494,
-0.5099244713783264,
-0.2761280834674835,
-0.34642890095710754,
-0.04298138990998268,
0.49714913964271545,
0.1021202877163887,
-0.23421832919120789,
-0.2491053342819214,
0.6145973801612854,
0.6101816296577454,
0.47723621129989624,
-0.4908730685710907,
0.45662569999694824,
-0.059005267918109894,
-0.7198207378387451,
0.3774215281009674,
0.2138260006904602,
0.7471666932106018,
-0.1663537323474884,
0.1760798692703247,
-0.31894272565841675,
0.15746237337589264,
-0.3501253128051758,
-0.5869596004486084,
0.41033807396888733,
-0.23265860974788666,
-0.5419624447822571,
-0.5206442475318909,
0.807349681854248,
-0.2509119212627411,
-0.28026631474494934,
0.28402000665664673,
0.24130776524543762,
-0.3721081614494324,
-0.5905763506889343,
-0.3911183178424835,
0.1335434913635254,
0.20725257694721222,
-0.7219513058662415,
0.34672263264656067,
0.12116202712059021,
0.10980019718408585,
0.23021695017814636,
0.49373555183410645,
0.21954424679279327,
-0.2914751470088959,
0.3037976622581482,
1.2041106224060059,
-0.656771183013916,
-0.6193903088569641,
-0.6359373331069946,
0.3404696583747864,
-0.20426051318645477,
-0.050148312002420425,
0.6345962882041931,
0.2092466652393341,
0.384835809469223,
-0.288875013589859,
0.7921649813652039,
0.007571522146463394,
0.5168500542640686,
-0.7058662176132202,
0.7493622303009033,
-0.3485606610774994,
0.49037089943885803,
-0.5082934498786926,
-0.7168959975242615,
-0.7177295684814453,
0.584539532661438,
-0.6545049548149109,
-0.37639331817626953,
0.6360836029052734,
0.959247887134552,
0.3347981572151184,
-0.004928369540721178,
0.2672210931777954,
0.4846009612083435,
0.45110154151916504,
0.34094056487083435,
0.9454349875450134,
-0.29201963543891907,
0.6642255783081055,
-0.3447563350200653,
-0.5092839598655701,
-0.3047820031642914,
-0.8831654191017151,
-1.0047672986984253,
-0.3718685507774353,
-0.4653122127056122,
-0.4542853534221649,
0.3194383382797241,
0.6736631989479065,
0.4765891134738922,
-0.8943418264389038,
0.20923002064228058,
-0.12130033224821091,
0.3355419635772705,
-0.0026869778521358967,
-0.3644557595252991,
0.2981833815574646,
-0.4341750741004944,
-0.5126387476921082,
0.4018780291080475,
0.3548101782798767,
-0.3312707841396332,
-0.360580712556839,
0.19881436228752136,
-0.036041535437107086,
0.18286709487438202,
0.8074129223823547,
0.004297330509871244,
-0.5156518816947937,
-0.4482206702232361,
0.08659627288579941,
-0.12343905866146088,
0.31446146965026855,
0.9068546891212463,
-0.7906561493873596,
0.23690056800842285,
0.7718021273612976,
0.16041260957717896,
0.36719590425491333,
0.4138711392879486,
0.309678316116333,
-1.0227537155151367,
0.6024957299232483,
0.4953882694244385,
0.0848744586110115,
0.4832294285297394,
-0.6472851634025574,
0.03867347538471222,
0.5194979310035706,
-0.2148151397705078,
-0.6783934235572815,
0.36301925778388977,
-1.1761460304260254,
-0.4664779603481293,
1.316699743270874,
0.09347664564847946,
-0.30983299016952515,
0.08400344103574753,
-0.5172328948974609,
0.22345711290836334,
-0.5936442613601685,
0.8995147943496704,
0.6859815120697021,
-0.07866445183753967,
-0.2633242905139923,
-0.1785249412059784,
0.28320932388305664,
0.7556489706039429,
-0.4876386821269989,
-0.12211864441633224,
0.6063939332962036,
-0.016828566789627075,
0.2611018419265747,
0.3115188479423523,
-0.39487966895103455,
-0.01978624239563942,
-0.08511447161436081,
0.2025023102760315,
-0.04420577734708786,
-0.1411367803812027,
-0.4836883544921875,
0.5561226010322571,
-0.16398118436336517,
0.014579208567738533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02144v1 | Probing Critical Learning Dynamics of PLMs for Hate Speech Detection | 2024-02-03T13:23:51 | 2024-02-03T13:23:51 | Sarah Masud, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Vikram Goyal, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the widespread adoption, there is a lack of research into how various
critical aspects of pretrained language models (PLMs) affect their performance
in hate speech detection. Through five research questions, our findings and
recommendations lay the groundwork for empirically investigating different
aspects of PLMs' use in hate speech detection. We deep dive into comparing
different pretrained models, evaluating their seed robustness, finetuning
settings, and the impact of pretraining data collection time. Our analysis
reveals early peaks for downstream tasks during pretraining, the limited
benefit of employing a more recent pretraining corpus, and the significance of
specific layers during finetuning. We further call into question the use of
domain-specific models and highlight the need for dynamic datasets for
benchmarking hate speech detection. | [
-0.5045885443687439,
-0.7599291205406189,
0.19748705625534058,
-0.30337971448898315,
-0.22509054839611053,
0.22398065030574799,
-0.17479458451271057,
-0.4633193016052246,
-0.2547002136707306,
0.4876287281513214,
-0.6938595175743103,
-0.3108631670475006,
-0.9131898880004883,
-0.15061594545841217,
-0.6992905735969543,
1.192287802696228,
0.23942366242408752,
0.1607045978307724,
0.2009921669960022,
-0.22764882445335388,
-0.1679440438747406,
-0.7556586861610413,
-0.6705595254898071,
-0.3538965582847595,
0.6250390410423279,
0.33525550365448,
0.5312159061431885,
0.44836100935935974,
0.47123613953590393,
0.18366338312625885,
-0.27149519324302673,
-0.18449030816555023,
-0.9777332544326782,
0.31662923097610474,
-0.06344399601221085,
-0.5194758772850037,
-0.06879209727048874,
0.4864283502101898,
0.691951334476471,
0.6190200448036194,
0.05581876263022423,
0.2524757385253906,
0.12323945015668869,
0.3505379259586334,
-0.6411909461021423,
-0.3697432577610016,
-0.8453764319419861,
0.1682415008544922,
-0.5193631052970886,
-0.0019527091644704342,
-0.2378169149160385,
-0.35710814595222473,
0.6185859441757202,
-0.3857891261577606,
0.4183126389980316,
-0.13385415077209473,
0.5918110609054565,
0.238646999001503,
-0.27274826169013977,
-0.3464181125164032,
-0.9308637380599976,
0.8401647806167603,
-0.641236424446106,
0.4109419584274292,
0.27797186374664307,
0.047517623752355576,
0.08794823288917542,
-0.830690324306488,
-0.4475446939468384,
-0.44439393281936646,
0.27111801505088806,
-0.0792018249630928,
-0.01083763875067234,
0.2846840023994446,
0.5621593594551086,
0.4615921974182129,
-0.39104175567626953,
0.4255610704421997,
-0.3651648759841919,
-0.22946499288082123,
0.5005404949188232,
0.2507225275039673,
0.14019103348255157,
0.12279785424470901,
-0.4164719581604004,
-0.18549910187721252,
-0.572262704372406,
0.15665850043296814,
0.7405752539634705,
0.4295121431350708,
-0.14432857930660248,
0.115333192050457,
0.3000015914440155,
0.6189512610435486,
-0.15878663957118988,
-0.0822182148694992,
0.31923553347587585,
-0.09123445302248001,
-0.04709705337882042,
-0.1708519607782364,
0.7307161092758179,
0.2824241816997528,
0.5742469429969788,
-0.11627241969108582,
-0.2837817370891571,
0.30822768807411194,
0.5374863147735596,
-0.8576880097389221,
-0.3205397427082062,
0.15539850294589996,
-0.30512234568595886,
-0.49096524715423584,
-0.3711074888706207,
-0.6990284323692322,
-0.8126640319824219,
-0.41976481676101685,
0.32144638895988464,
-0.5841103196144104,
-0.5680005550384521,
-0.05196363851428032,
-0.19750338792800903,
0.17981873452663422,
0.17872124910354614,
-0.5188202261924744,
0.25779667496681213,
0.5214340090751648,
0.7293475866317749,
-0.5916551947593689,
-0.20777735114097595,
-0.42742279171943665,
-0.33780214190483093,
-0.2107999473810196,
0.523536205291748,
-0.7501745820045471,
-0.25092315673828125,
0.2263963371515274,
-0.12977808713912964,
-0.06897760182619095,
-0.9632396101951599,
0.729090690612793,
-0.6172006726264954,
-0.11723535507917404,
-0.2563185393810272,
-0.6522594094276428,
-0.267778605222702,
0.16397644579410553,
-0.35075893998146057,
0.8281022906303406,
0.019038492813706398,
-0.7669392228126526,
0.5674458742141724,
-0.4888489544391632,
-0.434625506401062,
0.03754020109772682,
-0.2120886892080307,
-0.7116698026657104,
0.19943003356456757,
-0.3973855972290039,
0.42193472385406494,
0.055863384157419205,
0.25882676243782043,
-0.5916292071342468,
-0.15812799334526062,
0.2895391881465912,
-0.29385221004486084,
1.0161391496658325,
0.5160807371139526,
-0.5845143795013428,
0.3018548786640167,
-0.9554191827774048,
-0.4022556245326996,
0.26912516355514526,
-0.1324252039194107,
-0.2886049151420593,
0.3224829137325287,
0.05911095440387726,
0.19379648566246033,
-0.16582131385803223,
-0.6106785535812378,
-0.37490060925483704,
-0.20731692016124725,
0.38468360900878906,
0.7900928854942322,
-0.20040129125118256,
0.19844184815883636,
-0.3743908107280731,
0.7419963479042053,
0.27130696177482605,
0.1571141928434372,
0.14897142350673676,
-0.2002473920583725,
-0.7412986159324646,
0.2182663381099701,
0.15192925930023193,
0.4879639744758606,
-0.3080534338951111,
-0.10209973156452179,
0.36913254857063293,
-0.3439384996891022,
-0.32106468081474304,
0.05027102306485176,
0.48838141560554504,
0.4743238389492035,
0.3416120111942291,
-0.47109612822532654,
-0.8288791179656982,
-0.6562696099281311,
-0.5201196074485779,
0.10054387897253036,
0.28486335277557373,
0.2742338180541992,
0.5659129023551941,
0.116058848798275,
0.7234050035476685,
-0.1899641454219818,
-0.2767530679702759,
-0.29711687564849854,
0.5802249908447266,
-0.2292957901954651,
0.4804556667804718,
0.7882166504859924,
-0.852033793926239,
-0.6294476985931396,
-0.6438257694244385,
-0.2759718596935272,
-0.26374149322509766,
0.22087742388248444,
0.3048677146434784,
-0.3156549334526062,
0.5400907397270203,
0.09822621196508408,
0.34633761644363403,
0.5665016174316406,
-0.046735260635614395,
0.811128556728363,
0.4293511211872101,
0.049855995923280716,
-0.5073387622833252,
-0.0783158615231514,
-0.05956793949007988,
-0.2452317178249359,
-1.1709308624267578,
0.08384618908166885,
-0.2958020269870758,
-0.2974505126476288,
-0.8502722382545471,
-0.12208706885576248,
-0.3443467617034912,
-0.017660237848758698,
-0.46261730790138245,
0.18066731095314026,
-0.6019989848136902,
0.22906656563282013,
0.02967633679509163,
0.7950441837310791,
0.591052234172821,
-0.9043920040130615,
0.05868290364742279,
-0.24036310613155365,
-0.6185253262519836,
0.24257031083106995,
-0.42325761914253235,
0.2970249652862549,
-0.21605752408504486,
-0.16556580364704132,
-0.9290333390235901,
0.034414492547512054,
0.25367027521133423,
-0.47594937682151794,
0.15044444799423218,
-0.3721936345100403,
-0.21761859953403473,
-0.3941675126552582,
-0.26438939571380615,
0.47854670882225037,
0.4863627552986145,
-0.12482050061225891,
0.3710668683052063,
0.8661051392555237,
0.03925974294543266,
-0.47628554701805115,
-0.36931800842285156,
-0.44323423504829407,
-0.5080122351646423,
-0.3062366545200348,
0.24100123345851898,
-0.19907203316688538,
-0.36663818359375,
-0.4259456694126129,
-0.15768131613731384,
-0.14722755551338196,
0.5465269684791565,
0.3690703213214874,
-0.23886708915233612,
-0.25614526867866516,
-0.19431263208389282,
-0.4193170368671417,
0.12335526198148727,
0.3465133309364319,
-0.07835959643125534,
0.6935458183288574,
0.05775201693177223,
0.09254272282123566,
-0.49305394291877747,
0.06427349150180817,
0.7111206650733948,
-0.24626807868480682,
0.7616577744483948,
0.7925806641578674,
-0.3102145493030548,
-0.42795276641845703,
-0.5102748274803162,
-0.20296382904052734,
-0.4632560908794403,
0.24191422760486603,
-0.1652722954750061,
-1.2963058948516846,
0.6659589409828186,
-0.0934557393193245,
0.000041274182876804844,
0.19037333130836487,
0.5103695392608643,
-0.11673357337713242,
1.0566200017929077,
0.6779803037643433,
0.026263685896992683,
0.9149207472801208,
-0.2145361304283142,
0.024661080911755562,
-0.46596452593803406,
-0.09648769348859787,
-0.6439330577850342,
-0.27506503462791443,
-0.34460151195526123,
-0.29557713866233826,
0.3387865722179413,
0.01710982620716095,
-0.37781861424446106,
-0.016591141000390053,
-0.3468717336654663,
0.47370216250419617,
0.3812907338142395,
-0.013421732932329178,
-0.07323799282312393,
0.06024136766791344,
-0.1265099197626114,
-0.31932884454727173,
-0.44214504957199097,
-0.255635529756546,
1.1235127449035645,
0.46566417813301086,
0.5744811296463013,
-0.06447044759988785,
0.1305306851863861,
0.21150268614292145,
0.34148970246315,
-0.5205195546150208,
0.45111820101737976,
-0.3737345039844513,
-0.9214614629745483,
-0.16064339876174927,
-0.2981673777103424,
-0.8564146161079407,
0.18069210648536682,
-0.2556835412979126,
-0.5966600179672241,
0.11429548263549805,
0.3043672740459442,
-0.7973924875259399,
0.48852336406707764,
-0.5661194324493408,
0.956001877784729,
-0.1562599241733551,
-0.2742995619773865,
-0.3688774108886719,
-0.6154263019561768,
0.43648865818977356,
-0.17214661836624146,
0.3232535719871521,
-0.40442803502082825,
0.32359227538108826,
1.3835517168045044,
-0.3305659592151642,
1.074109673500061,
-0.4980336129665375,
-0.1542821228504181,
0.5312009453773499,
0.1382238119840622,
0.28308337926864624,
-0.4502637982368469,
0.009066441096365452,
0.047884322702884674,
-0.1513039767742157,
-0.1357450932264328,
-0.11222627758979797,
0.471343070268631,
-0.7905956506729126,
-0.571565568447113,
-0.4173382520675659,
-0.5549085736274719,
-0.38258954882621765,
0.2098430097103119,
0.311154842376709,
0.3239286541938782,
-0.20026831328868866,
0.3296225666999817,
0.9724582433700562,
-0.25707322359085083,
0.23815089464187622,
0.8797035217285156,
-0.2746150493621826,
-0.1184205561876297,
0.8104450702667236,
0.48440438508987427,
0.3361976444721222,
-0.024984819814562798,
0.2846970558166504,
-0.043303295969963074,
-1.19849693775177,
-0.022025177255272865,
0.10895930975675583,
-0.1881403774023056,
0.07597793638706207,
-0.7535369396209717,
-0.2826138734817505,
-0.6227016448974609,
0.18400825560092926,
-0.5793153643608093,
0.1063041239976883,
-0.4479759931564331,
-0.11071281135082245,
0.18987330794334412,
1.0401215553283691,
-0.3117947280406952,
0.7505101561546326,
-0.4956512153148651,
0.43428266048431396,
0.25436633825302124,
0.4800044000148773,
0.0804319679737091,
-1.0634211301803589,
-0.35382547974586487,
0.025389503687620163,
-0.46544772386550903,
-1.1374592781066895,
0.3665749728679657,
0.009507748298346996,
0.4217391312122345,
0.6049702167510986,
0.2597547173500061,
0.5564525723457336,
-0.5294137597084045,
0.8316537737846375,
0.02164296992123127,
-0.791313111782074,
0.7171033024787903,
-0.3734496831893921,
-0.18074774742126465,
0.6660804152488708,
1.066831350326538,
-0.2861713469028473,
-0.37457162141799927,
-0.5817130208015442,
-0.5867794752120972,
0.9407734274864197,
-0.02954707108438015,
0.02957186847925186,
0.20840738713741302,
0.2570233643054962,
0.16680505871772766,
0.23032885789871216,
-0.7546157836914062,
-0.686710000038147,
-0.07944048941135406,
0.1485058069229126,
-0.2691694498062134,
-0.7709887027740479,
-0.10814816504716873,
-0.4711478352546692,
0.4472306966781616,
0.3749934136867523,
-0.13639628887176514,
-0.18900376558303833,
-0.2805379033088684,
-0.0425112247467041,
0.0383194237947464,
0.6689795851707458,
0.5674124360084534,
-0.4416711926460266,
0.023711686953902245,
0.05148365721106529,
-0.7083131074905396,
0.19059094786643982,
-0.09461755305528641,
-0.24240221083164215,
0.00014180080324877053,
0.07332035899162292,
1.0258225202560425,
0.21046695113182068,
-0.62859708070755,
0.7084643244743347,
0.10230371356010437,
-0.3542971909046173,
-0.4391295313835144,
0.2033771425485611,
-0.38897132873535156,
0.1725742369890213,
0.129620760679245,
0.0072114672511816025,
0.10223934799432755,
-0.4121438264846802,
0.33665433526039124,
0.39427974820137024,
-0.5913175940513611,
-0.5708605647087097,
0.7437083721160889,
0.22437366843223572,
-0.36538276076316833,
0.5496943593025208,
-0.10514747351408005,
-0.9603694677352905,
0.4060632884502411,
0.5309875011444092,
0.6713937520980835,
-0.6112775206565857,
0.17932802438735962,
0.11998679488897324,
0.4362226724624634,
0.25015735626220703,
0.1834452748298645,
-0.10176451504230499,
-0.984523594379425,
-0.3764692544937134,
-0.6928048729896545,
-0.45229652523994446,
0.8309171795845032,
-0.6846714615821838,
0.08539532870054245,
-0.7069798111915588,
-0.3066546320915222,
0.06401843577623367,
-0.013831019401550293,
-0.6344618201255798,
0.3220148980617523,
0.6853525042533875,
0.8014510869979858,
-1.0914069414138794,
0.6964707374572754,
0.5571866631507874,
-0.4419920742511749,
-0.7156248688697815,
-0.220079705119133,
0.32379111647605896,
-0.7792806029319763,
0.734083354473114,
0.16782309114933014,
-0.20629730820655823,
0.12185467034578323,
-0.7765889763832092,
-0.7688850164413452,
0.38971376419067383,
0.44010668992996216,
-0.47460833191871643,
-0.008811051025986671,
0.3225916028022766,
0.5049830079078674,
-0.3073095381259918,
0.1516900211572647,
0.7579002380371094,
0.14897248148918152,
-0.21210338175296783,
-0.7319188714027405,
-0.3945707380771637,
0.04692494496703148,
-0.32835274934768677,
0.07500633597373962,
-0.5560483336448669,
1.0311278104782104,
0.07859714329242706,
-0.48345595598220825,
-0.32562923431396484,
0.6091839075088501,
-0.09063928574323654,
0.2983114421367645,
0.7045562267303467,
0.8574371337890625,
0.6445503830909729,
0.10904994606971741,
0.8154876232147217,
-0.20266303420066833,
0.25313788652420044,
1.2048543691635132,
-0.27413085103034973,
0.6923894286155701,
0.02581906132400036,
-0.3452359437942505,
0.440736323595047,
0.6473522782325745,
0.17456363141536713,
0.4308176338672638,
0.5531170964241028,
-0.37482431530952454,
-0.3980215787887573,
-0.3613367974758148,
-0.5297003388404846,
0.30330711603164673,
0.6304430365562439,
-0.4478144645690918,
-0.17500583827495575,
0.39465367794036865,
0.13622821867465973,
-0.02323760837316513,
-0.5295054912567139,
0.6306343674659729,
0.1068805679678917,
-0.3822081685066223,
0.5519387722015381,
-0.20692363381385803,
0.9576809406280518,
-0.5864201188087463,
0.36968421936035156,
-0.10975995659828186,
0.2613086998462677,
-0.1352410614490509,
-0.6342984437942505,
0.3642374873161316,
0.3027406334877014,
-0.15421968698501587,
-0.3833580017089844,
0.71913081407547,
-0.3365214169025421,
0.31595438718795776,
0.5293445587158203,
0.30498597025871277,
0.45646393299102783,
-0.2474895566701889,
-0.8601696491241455,
0.5597488880157471,
0.07711099088191986,
-0.21984435617923737,
0.5478692650794983,
0.3509816825389862,
0.4364347457885742,
0.603302001953125,
0.7763013243675232,
0.21545149385929108,
0.6584934592247009,
0.42884561419487,
0.8429844379425049,
-0.618277907371521,
-0.34004485607147217,
-0.8178296685218811,
0.37999486923217773,
0.008066605776548386,
-0.5785000920295715,
0.8250601291656494,
0.5447002053260803,
1.3530722856521606,
0.07783674448728561,
0.6747150421142578,
0.2613537907600403,
1.0192252397537231,
-0.3114149868488312,
0.8323383331298828,
-0.35753926634788513,
0.015077298507094383,
-0.2742677628993988,
-0.6214279532432556,
-0.28839659690856934,
0.6953324675559998,
-0.5493627190589905,
0.013728583231568336,
0.6315723061561584,
0.7743601202964783,
0.014457442797720432,
0.14685136079788208,
0.4856259524822235,
0.6618671417236328,
0.3454430103302002,
0.2172117829322815,
1.0624067783355713,
-0.3225427567958832,
0.5561698079109192,
-0.4246376156806946,
-0.15105336904525757,
-0.09584493190050125,
-0.7286628484725952,
-0.8803960680961609,
-0.585114598274231,
-0.5108742117881775,
-0.4061264097690582,
0.2649507522583008,
0.6772639155387878,
0.8142099380493164,
-1.1291762590408325,
-0.35257112979888916,
-0.02694316953420639,
0.023041993379592896,
0.16689534485340118,
-0.28299590945243835,
-0.14316211640834808,
-0.5619255900382996,
-0.57846999168396,
0.5698198676109314,
-0.09720245003700256,
0.17004241049289703,
-0.06956793367862701,
0.02928999625146389,
-0.37291452288627625,
0.00297123403288424,
0.5904747843742371,
0.4099612236022949,
-0.49925851821899414,
-0.27438393235206604,
-0.4782790243625641,
-0.031045425683259964,
-0.08236226439476013,
1.272342562675476,
-0.7424883246421814,
0.20915308594703674,
0.3188554346561432,
0.8329010009765625,
0.3598322570323944,
-0.1381205916404724,
0.3195789158344269,
-0.5288814902305603,
0.1730118840932846,
0.508267343044281,
0.150940403342247,
0.13364949822425842,
0.1619708240032196,
0.2806924879550934,
0.7436426281929016,
-0.7297172546386719,
-1.197946548461914,
0.4368596374988556,
-0.7344890236854553,
-0.21984191238880157,
0.9639513492584229,
-0.10150211304426193,
-0.11861512809991837,
-0.4547525644302368,
0.09280239790678024,
0.333819717168808,
-0.20280760526657104,
0.4198022186756134,
0.7128596901893616,
-0.11786723881959915,
-0.14093193411827087,
-0.5075130462646484,
0.9634506702423096,
0.6405457258224487,
-0.13320781290531158,
0.2582697570323944,
0.45333102345466614,
0.4701673686504364,
0.07528825849294662,
0.5526443123817444,
0.027675388380885124,
0.08680906891822815,
-0.024166570976376534,
-0.09891074150800705,
0.035150013864040375,
-0.5940444469451904,
-0.5349358916282654,
0.5734925866127014,
0.040933869779109955,
-0.16404563188552856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02135v1 | Do Moral Judgment and Reasoning Capability of LLMs Change with Language? A Study using the Multilingual Defining Issues Test | 2024-02-03T12:52:36 | 2024-02-03T12:52:36 | Aditi Khandelwal, Utkarsh Agarwal, Kumar Tanmay, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the moral judgment and moral reasoning abilities
exhibited by Large Language Models (LLMs) across languages through the Defining
Issues Test. It is a well known fact that moral judgment depends on the
language in which the question is asked. We extend the work of beyond English,
to 5 new languages (Chinese, Hindi, Russian, Spanish and Swahili), and probe
three LLMs -- ChatGPT, GPT-4 and Llama2Chat-70B -- that shows substantial
multilingual text processing and generation abilities. Our study shows that the
moral reasoning ability for all models, as indicated by the post-conventional
score, is substantially inferior for Hindi and Swahili, compared to Spanish,
Russian, Chinese and English, while there is no clear trend for the performance
of the latter four languages. The moral judgments too vary considerably by the
language. | [
-0.3537379801273346,
-0.7419312000274658,
0.8233902454376221,
0.300131618976593,
-0.3864182233810425,
0.15456050634384155,
-0.34553229808807373,
-0.8070098161697388,
-0.21321839094161987,
0.4599258005619049,
-0.1709674447774887,
-0.08912763744592667,
-0.6675381064414978,
0.40204089879989624,
0.02615545317530632,
1.0190643072128296,
-0.04029836878180504,
0.4887630045413971,
-0.197389155626297,
-0.48407167196273804,
-0.5530256628990173,
-0.7160888910293579,
-0.7864145636558533,
-0.5166778564453125,
0.4339921176433563,
0.3004719316959381,
0.5450419187545776,
0.10498097538948059,
0.6623910069465637,
0.3840474486351013,
-0.28364309668540955,
-0.00030681650969199836,
-0.3057539761066437,
0.0012786018196493387,
-0.6196984648704529,
-0.7912067174911499,
-0.2665209472179413,
0.23704902827739716,
0.62404865026474,
0.2808930575847626,
0.007752623409032822,
0.28333035111427307,
-0.10119301080703735,
0.6140594482421875,
-0.3717574179172516,
0.06630109250545502,
-0.8154671788215637,
0.009023532271385193,
-0.07328895479440689,
-0.07940882444381714,
-0.4383026361465454,
-0.5753981471061707,
0.09268872439861298,
-0.01439887285232544,
-0.028778834268450737,
-0.16560420393943787,
0.9647712111473083,
0.02303449809551239,
-0.9073577523231506,
-0.47818732261657715,
-0.29762473702430725,
1.1144078969955444,
-0.5897145867347717,
0.5199759602546692,
0.5095850229263306,
0.16687846183776855,
0.26999321579933167,
-0.35848352313041687,
-0.5067697167396545,
-0.4909016788005829,
-0.1067795678973198,
0.2418539673089981,
-0.003719241824001074,
-0.21715329587459564,
0.21104508638381958,
0.3452680706977844,
-0.180396169424057,
0.15170150995254517,
-0.40822136402130127,
-0.14059188961982727,
0.8146405816078186,
0.07660268992185593,
0.14982187747955322,
-0.5885434746742249,
-0.3172259032726288,
-0.0927218422293663,
-0.9080998301506042,
0.34491875767707825,
0.5815074443817139,
0.049657270312309265,
-0.13207535445690155,
0.6464505791664124,
0.31147676706314087,
0.30793872475624084,
-0.15816961228847504,
-0.22872786223888397,
0.14530101418495178,
-0.6182411313056946,
-0.10946031659841537,
-0.09906825423240662,
0.7349068522453308,
0.6082437634468079,
0.7045844197273254,
0.6757861971855164,
-0.08663012832403183,
-0.06718650460243225,
-0.0678822249174118,
-0.40170010924339294,
0.1402101218700409,
0.03819502145051956,
-0.43716004490852356,
-0.12624594569206238,
-0.06795265525579453,
-0.3849729001522064,
-0.5728632211685181,
-0.13885702192783356,
-0.07363627105951309,
-0.579372227191925,
-0.3538627028465271,
0.3582412898540497,
-0.034263093024492264,
0.8350784182548523,
0.4116199016571045,
-0.6478988528251648,
-0.28602898120880127,
0.5107148289680481,
0.5762113928794861,
-0.08912205696105957,
-0.2603079080581665,
-0.3063214421272278,
-0.14269299805164337,
-0.5071728825569153,
0.8639702200889587,
-0.8332619667053223,
-0.6192699074745178,
-0.012943089008331299,
0.21466703712940216,
0.036195307970047,
-0.27056118845939636,
0.7059928178787231,
-0.3480261564254761,
0.13736189901828766,
-0.6505100131034851,
-0.19835548102855682,
-0.4628463387489319,
0.5481985807418823,
-0.4438820779323578,
0.6883716583251953,
-0.2713741362094879,
-0.5333644151687622,
0.37155088782310486,
-0.36923256516456604,
-0.5348621010780334,
0.031079478561878204,
-0.3129104673862457,
-0.21000640094280243,
0.09043256938457489,
-0.08488403260707855,
0.48167747259140015,
-0.6609116196632385,
0.5456680655479431,
-0.16428430378437042,
-0.32270824909210205,
0.3852047920227051,
-0.6115578413009644,
0.9074286818504333,
0.02256966196000576,
-0.2722316086292267,
-0.11521229147911072,
-0.6219844222068787,
0.2480221390724182,
0.3345067501068115,
-0.6436647176742554,
-0.2534649968147278,
0.3053467571735382,
-0.023170581087470055,
0.367552250623703,
0.3436039090156555,
-0.7013129591941833,
0.07906085252761841,
-0.2668198347091675,
0.3568187654018402,
0.8966994285583496,
-0.004854304250329733,
-0.040214572101831436,
-0.28000497817993164,
0.5736292600631714,
-0.13528995215892792,
0.22578924894332886,
0.07688334584236145,
-0.8608384132385254,
-1.0476518869400024,
0.27991506457328796,
-0.11454181373119354,
0.9302117824554443,
-0.5454184412956238,
0.08562257885932922,
0.06423480808734894,
-0.4981392025947571,
-0.3143719434738159,
-0.0270049087703228,
0.7792989015579224,
-0.01399463415145874,
0.3176632523536682,
0.05090995877981186,
-0.3065832853317261,
-1.0020830631256104,
-0.5128137469291687,
-0.5676400065422058,
0.24864117801189423,
0.4906735122203827,
0.6491912603378296,
0.12413492053747177,
0.3584004342556,
-0.3651169538497925,
0.019633758813142776,
-0.5706191062927246,
-0.2000470906496048,
0.1825350821018219,
0.1754046529531479,
0.6337869763374329,
-0.9509981870651245,
-0.43591076135635376,
0.4300183951854706,
-0.6874153017997742,
-0.2180798500776291,
-0.1412724107503891,
0.1492013931274414,
0.4523433446884155,
0.3829648196697235,
-0.44783034920692444,
0.22375987470149994,
0.7019134163856506,
-0.7432582974433899,
0.933082640171051,
-0.2275891751050949,
0.4563142657279968,
-0.9963904023170471,
-0.4476679861545563,
-0.003854722250252962,
-0.020227501168847084,
-0.3792319595813751,
0.17993278801441193,
0.24199481308460236,
0.2531723380088806,
-0.6967192888259888,
0.6494624018669128,
-0.3571088910102844,
-0.03819664940237999,
0.05081506073474884,
0.1716872900724411,
0.1800503134727478,
0.1540450155735016,
-0.044310424476861954,
0.7133386731147766,
0.6145628094673157,
-0.7375919818878174,
0.47640588879585266,
0.2301878184080124,
-0.37641629576683044,
0.6814215779304504,
-0.6984702348709106,
0.04043520241975784,
-0.19251173734664917,
-0.1579086184501648,
-0.8194814324378967,
0.08181104809045792,
-0.015626875683665276,
-0.3737764060497284,
-0.06981860101222992,
-0.18551458418369293,
-0.40472152829170227,
-0.17185336351394653,
-0.2737242877483368,
0.28597545623779297,
0.30107223987579346,
-0.34613943099975586,
0.4143480062484741,
0.14933457970619202,
-0.23975709080696106,
-0.737209141254425,
-0.8671596050262451,
-0.004576480947434902,
-0.305681973695755,
-0.5581028461456299,
-0.14779485762119293,
-0.1868220716714859,
-0.7564432621002197,
-0.3795709013938904,
0.17750009894371033,
-0.08742117881774902,
-0.023380223661661148,
-0.12501779198646545,
0.3805743455886841,
-0.1376134306192398,
0.44920405745506287,
0.163821741938591,
0.10715331137180328,
0.1740361899137497,
0.30420809984207153,
0.470908522605896,
-0.7976849675178528,
-0.6071780920028687,
-0.044321004301309586,
0.4151672124862671,
0.47716930508613586,
-0.8416435122489929,
0.5391163229942322,
0.35256510972976685,
-0.09558266401290894,
0.22262664139270782,
-0.7825223207473755,
0.1611783653497696,
-0.5050523281097412,
0.3872552216053009,
-0.6114382743835449,
-1.1320807933807373,
0.6450483798980713,
0.21814870834350586,
0.07731720805168152,
0.575702965259552,
0.6488763093948364,
0.007158808410167694,
0.9316667318344116,
0.4193201959133148,
0.38291817903518677,
0.33964237570762634,
-0.11685993522405624,
0.434701144695282,
-0.7065905332565308,
-0.10686329752206802,
-0.48232078552246094,
-0.017797961831092834,
-1.1256242990493774,
-0.5110142827033997,
0.26165086030960083,
0.20374464988708496,
-0.34849241375923157,
0.07287987321615219,
-0.19567331671714783,
0.8339207768440247,
0.05658504366874695,
-0.17655223608016968,
0.6128879189491272,
-0.20584948360919952,
-0.31098443269729614,
-0.2080237716436386,
-0.23969678580760956,
-0.933601438999176,
0.8645021915435791,
0.13157550990581512,
0.32671937346458435,
0.48626604676246643,
0.32725289463996887,
0.046460505574941635,
0.27661365270614624,
-0.7762225866317749,
0.782651424407959,
-0.28511297702789307,
-0.6673614978790283,
-0.17652291059494019,
-0.3659796416759491,
-0.8401901125907898,
0.6161118149757385,
-0.09884348511695862,
-0.6762796640396118,
0.17307572066783905,
-0.375820517539978,
-0.08152352273464203,
0.5393049716949463,
-0.8242406249046326,
0.4700394868850708,
-0.6213425397872925,
-0.26181459426879883,
-0.4877960979938507,
-0.4224447011947632,
0.5836114883422852,
-0.3507491946220398,
0.24478453397750854,
-0.48373109102249146,
-0.043572258204221725,
0.5579527020454407,
0.06646481156349182,
0.6641055941581726,
0.050889648497104645,
-0.5612573027610779,
0.44776657223701477,
0.08169540017843246,
0.22651506960391998,
0.596794068813324,
-0.4374290406703949,
0.4080617427825928,
0.20887772738933563,
-0.24798527359962463,
-0.40096813440322876,
0.5891174674034119,
-0.5235586166381836,
-1.0710546970367432,
-0.6585325598716736,
-0.45018067955970764,
-0.3064083158969879,
0.269426554441452,
0.06122194603085518,
0.1520872861146927,
-0.33721214532852173,
0.1527043581008911,
0.3076442778110504,
-0.833815336227417,
0.4660889804363251,
0.8682023882865906,
-0.3415675163269043,
-0.1304023116827011,
0.5623400807380676,
0.06610339134931564,
0.5660951137542725,
0.07850225269794464,
0.505700409412384,
-0.3787844777107239,
-0.41951432824134827,
-0.3863180875778198,
0.5386548638343811,
-0.9167754054069519,
-0.010677138343453407,
-0.30521151423454285,
0.00009098311420530081,
-0.04895726591348648,
-0.3541909158229828,
-0.4502064287662506,
-0.11103036254644394,
-0.00896319467574358,
-0.2534158229827881,
0.4300990402698517,
1.0449724197387695,
0.10039830952882767,
-0.12157673388719559,
-0.9514036178588867,
0.0632912665605545,
0.2715089023113251,
0.440029501914978,
-0.22236691415309906,
-0.4902004897594452,
0.19139891862869263,
0.07892284542322159,
-0.3635028004646301,
-0.7412691116333008,
-0.03407919779419899,
0.12895488739013672,
0.4170483648777008,
0.4466874301433563,
-0.18457446992397308,
0.5497569441795349,
-0.46839064359664917,
0.8772088289260864,
0.15107578039169312,
-1.0374563932418823,
0.44807055592536926,
-0.4449635446071625,
0.21769979596138,
0.39608049392700195,
0.4250178933143616,
-0.6699820160865784,
-0.5347905158996582,
-0.34400591254234314,
-0.29182302951812744,
0.5910050868988037,
0.18642398715019226,
0.5430541634559631,
-0.3584056496620178,
0.33495622873306274,
0.06393900513648987,
-0.03873719274997711,
-1.0414589643478394,
-0.2437877506017685,
0.034595735371112823,
0.39902573823928833,
-0.17687346041202545,
-0.24668006598949432,
0.21028782427310944,
-0.6373458504676819,
0.32464471459388733,
-0.08203884214162827,
0.03928951174020767,
0.2075745016336441,
0.10379884392023087,
0.14113694429397583,
0.666867196559906,
0.5808496475219727,
0.7826563715934753,
0.18887802958488464,
-0.09533436596393585,
0.5128130316734314,
-0.4642247259616852,
0.46953338384628296,
-0.23128773272037506,
0.04033707454800606,
-0.2629430294036865,
0.5039740800857544,
0.7113440036773682,
0.14196476340293884,
-0.8428637981414795,
0.5051329135894775,
-0.24624425172805786,
-0.3033845126628876,
-0.3599560260772705,
0.015315958298742771,
0.26927539706230164,
0.5313047170639038,
0.011857098899781704,
-0.16218151152133942,
-0.1895398646593094,
-0.7914988994598389,
0.020412256941199303,
0.44217634201049805,
-0.14885808527469635,
-0.16980116069316864,
0.39360031485557556,
0.007017189636826515,
-0.12212412059307098,
0.5204480886459351,
-0.5278862118721008,
-0.6982247233390808,
0.6598003506660461,
0.6574473977088928,
0.42042383551597595,
-0.6274048089981079,
0.5283140540122986,
0.3148970901966095,
0.6179308295249939,
0.00042663567001000047,
0.8110925555229187,
0.23059312999248505,
-1.208681583404541,
-0.7113181948661804,
-0.6445293426513672,
-0.3741716742515564,
0.02977294661104679,
-0.5192003846168518,
0.27326518297195435,
-0.4278597831726074,
-0.24656930565834045,
-0.27848827838897705,
0.1587681919336319,
-0.38435354828834534,
0.22502458095550537,
0.0857517197728157,
0.3914511501789093,
-0.4804713726043701,
0.7303475737571716,
0.8788471221923828,
-0.3017992377281189,
-0.7171102166175842,
-0.2546141743659973,
-0.1545136570930481,
-0.7871435284614563,
0.6306822299957275,
0.1629367172718048,
-0.3970087766647339,
-0.13034749031066895,
-0.281991183757782,
-0.9223362803459167,
0.6945742964744568,
0.584409236907959,
-0.3616834878921509,
0.18829771876335144,
0.3419749438762665,
0.7446202635765076,
-0.10778319835662842,
0.24489103257656097,
0.6942795515060425,
0.8604361414909363,
-0.14499889314174652,
-1.1840691566467285,
-0.23287776112556458,
-0.40599220991134644,
-0.3033057451248169,
0.26510047912597656,
-0.8358511924743652,
1.1675232648849487,
-0.6056264042854309,
-0.2887527346611023,
-0.0893842875957489,
0.1912282109260559,
0.623960018157959,
0.0872492864727974,
0.4830990433692932,
0.2741800844669342,
0.746372640132904,
-0.2632673382759094,
1.292803406715393,
-0.005167009774595499,
0.2962554097175598,
0.7935649156570435,
-0.5033323764801025,
0.7176588177680969,
0.3025211691856384,
-0.2609756588935852,
0.5753695964813232,
0.46736544370651245,
-0.1801421046257019,
-0.053924743086099625,
0.16628094017505646,
-0.09946823120117188,
-0.43585795164108276,
-0.4208327829837799,
-0.26961061358451843,
1.0863208770751953,
0.4293965697288513,
-0.2395036369562149,
-0.029387790709733963,
0.003199641825631261,
0.36077797412872314,
0.08988551795482635,
-0.3736147880554199,
0.43256309628486633,
0.3529462516307831,
-0.6460663080215454,
0.7409242987632751,
0.374881386756897,
0.6091039776802063,
-0.6177463531494141,
-0.09728587418794632,
-0.15666766464710236,
0.045626167207956314,
-0.15856869518756866,
-1.2438656091690063,
0.28131547570228577,
0.3727613091468811,
0.122823067009449,
-0.2881098985671997,
0.7372604608535767,
-0.1654660701751709,
-0.6629166007041931,
0.6800254583358765,
0.9369122982025146,
0.28855955600738525,
0.03356340155005455,
-0.7160089015960693,
-0.19225335121154785,
0.24333566427230835,
-0.43825864791870117,
0.1372518092393875,
0.35401079058647156,
-0.5144091248512268,
0.7990463376045227,
0.7532297372817993,
0.12406368553638458,
0.15855658054351807,
0.39780527353286743,
0.4037075936794281,
-0.9952161908149719,
-0.27365201711654663,
-0.941032886505127,
0.2602217197418213,
-0.06109584867954254,
-0.5678352117538452,
0.8220697641372681,
0.2949134111404419,
0.8496631979942322,
0.08111191540956497,
0.7046633362770081,
-0.11169393360614777,
0.01664259098470211,
-0.7122235298156738,
0.7521052360534668,
-0.5907907485961914,
0.05185097083449364,
-0.38434597849845886,
-0.8529077768325806,
-0.10054081678390503,
0.7794762849807739,
-0.5515075922012329,
0.4112670123577118,
1.0764740705490112,
0.345837265253067,
0.3495123088359833,
0.17219752073287964,
0.48198479413986206,
0.19330021739006042,
0.4103720188140869,
0.7569228410720825,
1.0882041454315186,
-0.2741296589374542,
0.4740763008594513,
-0.03871110826730728,
0.07114577293395996,
0.4397168457508087,
-0.7701366543769836,
-1.0657099485397339,
-0.47400838136672974,
-0.017593098804354668,
-0.00394829735159874,
-0.306746244430542,
0.46100592613220215,
0.09250492602586746,
-0.6176349520683289,
-0.21691620349884033,
0.10556142777204514,
0.43922924995422363,
-0.004938015714287758,
-0.22025175392627716,
0.31760191917419434,
-0.12878075242042542,
-0.6989645957946777,
0.39884501695632935,
0.30291232466697693,
0.07174143940210342,
-0.2553504705429077,
-0.12456560134887695,
-0.4510008990764618,
0.33902138471603394,
1.0671652555465698,
-0.2283528447151184,
-0.8890933394432068,
-0.659450113773346,
0.005931029561907053,
0.043249666690826416,
0.1228889599442482,
0.8037307858467102,
-0.296888142824173,
0.27334362268447876,
0.4469783902168274,
0.28379178047180176,
0.008810915052890778,
-0.08541740477085114,
0.5609586238861084,
-0.32454249262809753,
0.1771632432937622,
0.1727997362613678,
0.777376651763916,
0.420946329832077,
-0.3261919319629669,
0.4669506251811981,
0.15227174758911133,
-0.5376147031784058,
-0.5381075143814087,
0.710397481918335,
-0.5854875445365906,
-0.19637852907180786,
1.4247382879257202,
-0.06671717762947083,
0.18596959114074707,
-0.3634384274482727,
-0.39311492443084717,
0.13870370388031006,
-0.029816988855600357,
0.48997581005096436,
1.1176737546920776,
-0.18260148167610168,
-0.24186764657497406,
-0.8128526210784912,
0.27215030789375305,
0.6768749952316284,
-0.7679174542427063,
0.16041553020477295,
0.4334176778793335,
0.20529526472091675,
0.15980620682239532,
0.5332068204879761,
-0.5022205114364624,
0.3948563039302826,
-0.39492809772491455,
-0.029154568910598755,
0.2796018719673157,
-0.12641412019729614,
-0.27773329615592957,
-0.11907616257667542,
0.15817959606647491,
0.48492392897605896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02130v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02130v4 | GITA: Graph to Visual and Textual Integration for Vision-Language Graph Reasoning | 2024-02-03T12:19:47 | 2024-05-24T06:58:05 | Yanbin Wei, Shuai Fu, Weisen Jiang, Zejian Zhang, Zhixiong Zeng, Qi Wu, James T. Kwok, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used for various tasks with
graph structures. Though LLMs can process graph information in a textual
format, they overlook the rich vision modality, which is an intuitive way for
humans to comprehend structural information and conduct general graph
reasoning. The potential benefits and capabilities of representing graph
structures as visual images (i.e., $\textit{visual graph}$) are still
unexplored. To fill the gap, we innovatively propose an end-to-end framework,
called $\textbf{G}$raph to v$\textbf{I}$sual and $\textbf{T}$extual
Integr$\textbf{A}$tion (GITA), which firstly incorporates visual graphs into
general graph reasoning. Besides, we establish $\textbf{G}$raph-based
$\textbf{V}$ision-$\textbf{L}$anguage $\textbf{Q}$uestion $\textbf{A}$nswering
(GVLQA) dataset from existing graph data, which is the first vision-language
dataset for general graph reasoning purposes. Extensive experiments on the
GVLQA dataset and five real-world datasets show that GITA outperforms
mainstream LLMs in terms of general graph reasoning capabilities. Moreover, We
highlight the effectiveness of the layout augmentation on visual graphs and
pretraining on the GVLQA dataset. | [
-0.33190086483955383,
-1.0533555746078491,
0.8692942261695862,
-0.11388049274682999,
-0.41771426796913147,
0.43163949251174927,
-0.1523691713809967,
-0.7116758823394775,
0.37648114562034607,
0.529890775680542,
-0.015026332810521126,
-0.8209742903709412,
-0.5420595407485962,
-0.17649559676647186,
-0.6051596999168396,
0.58799809217453,
-0.4435483515262604,
0.018435601145029068,
-0.31542572379112244,
-0.21287474036216736,
-0.2688828110694885,
-0.5171782374382019,
-0.22597754001617432,
-0.18384525179862976,
0.5278704762458801,
0.31998518109321594,
0.7589655518531799,
0.64054936170578,
0.4116069972515106,
0.2906286120414734,
-0.05625123158097267,
0.502364456653595,
-0.3233529031276703,
-0.0707714632153511,
-0.17111292481422424,
-0.2787517011165619,
-0.349352091550827,
-0.2599377930164337,
0.8332284688949585,
0.8454754948616028,
0.1892928034067154,
0.09034838527441025,
-0.013466428965330124,
0.841995894908905,
-0.6393429636955261,
0.5344382524490356,
-0.2354349046945572,
-0.0478237085044384,
-0.20788267254829407,
-0.3075932264328003,
-0.5430799722671509,
-0.3375943899154663,
0.03485117480158806,
-0.7172932624816895,
-0.4612821340560913,
0.19855897128582,
1.190467357635498,
0.29752540588378906,
-0.6094861626625061,
-0.30158817768096924,
-0.6008127331733704,
0.16629956662654877,
-0.1468075066804886,
0.413211852312088,
0.06754399091005325,
0.6379349231719971,
-0.21819354593753815,
-1.0781303644180298,
-0.4379289150238037,
-0.18023094534873962,
-0.0822867751121521,
0.30363982915878296,
-0.3137798309326172,
0.2626189589500427,
0.2489960789680481,
0.3649638593196869,
-0.6638413071632385,
-0.1451142281293869,
-0.17232294380664825,
-0.07646811008453369,
0.21041759848594666,
-0.08088485896587372,
0.8740431070327759,
-0.14110133051872253,
-0.3871159851551056,
-0.1361597776412964,
-0.6835524439811707,
0.09224049746990204,
0.32761049270629883,
0.11190089583396912,
-0.1752406507730484,
0.8575904369354248,
-0.26324209570884705,
0.7698113322257996,
-0.35406211018562317,
0.3626701831817627,
0.1956319659948349,
-0.4761351943016052,
-0.49605631828308105,
-0.26112914085388184,
0.7862586975097656,
0.4246409833431244,
0.9861378073692322,
-0.1660628616809845,
0.03002537228167057,
0.4635069668292999,
-0.01969204656779766,
-0.8015891313552856,
-0.4576879143714905,
-0.0954829677939415,
-0.14040614664554596,
-0.12922924757003784,
0.09283565729856491,
-0.5202076435089111,
-0.22708511352539062,
-0.3055509030818939,
0.3279106616973877,
-0.6231810450553894,
-0.2252366840839386,
0.18969286978244781,
-0.13536828756332397,
0.4486250579357147,
0.5306975245475769,
-0.6399840116500854,
0.3553702235221863,
0.41880857944488525,
0.976171612739563,
0.10341686010360718,
-0.14407965540885925,
-0.6393982172012329,
0.3261343538761139,
-0.6078343391418457,
1.0311062335968018,
-0.6983961462974548,
-0.24324534833431244,
-0.1258002668619156,
0.07922939211130142,
-0.19095580279827118,
-0.29043594002723694,
0.22277309000492096,
-0.4839048981666565,
0.2880147397518158,
-0.2964931130409241,
-0.46594512462615967,
-0.5858702063560486,
0.3399116098880768,
-0.6038886308670044,
0.713899552822113,
0.3460211753845215,
-0.8051263093948364,
0.3792136311531067,
-0.6261647939682007,
-0.3927399218082428,
0.35925617814064026,
-0.8034088611602783,
-0.2965468466281891,
-0.2738102376461029,
0.4674766957759857,
0.13213467597961426,
-0.34346839785575867,
0.3982153832912445,
-0.3439090847969055,
-0.5535719990730286,
0.05054816976189613,
-0.20926706492900848,
0.7695540189743042,
0.00976274162530899,
-0.19026416540145874,
0.47307831048965454,
-0.4500000774860382,
0.3273341953754425,
0.32518455386161804,
-0.20559899508953094,
-0.3947441875934601,
0.019041143357753754,
0.03801308199763298,
-0.15233181416988373,
0.15391221642494202,
-0.3260016441345215,
0.4577679932117462,
-0.28832322359085083,
0.6532060503959656,
0.5937874913215637,
-0.11394409090280533,
0.4910696744918823,
0.15854232013225555,
0.6273490190505981,
0.06983496248722076,
0.05100390687584877,
-0.29239290952682495,
-0.6045310497283936,
-0.6078917384147644,
-0.491561621427536,
0.2826051414012909,
0.7564072608947754,
-1.184128761291504,
0.1414148360490799,
-0.520543098449707,
-0.22842516005039215,
0.03787827119231224,
-0.0762566328048706,
0.3996972143650055,
0.7017816305160522,
0.34022796154022217,
-0.4806416630744934,
-0.5322453379631042,
-0.8325685858726501,
0.02551265060901642,
-0.327470600605011,
0.22961628437042236,
0.3980010449886322,
0.5437377691268921,
-0.43704304099082947,
1.0911662578582764,
-0.4723109006881714,
-0.2049233764410019,
-0.30297476053237915,
-0.24843674898147583,
0.14224886894226074,
0.21745485067367554,
0.9443057775497437,
-0.7960779070854187,
-0.6258376240730286,
0.48609238862991333,
-1.0943732261657715,
-0.1028161495923996,
0.034592147916555405,
-0.4356555938720703,
0.15938833355903625,
0.42389416694641113,
-0.6332148313522339,
0.7168529629707336,
0.5276605486869812,
-0.6198580861091614,
0.6122143268585205,
-0.1150207668542862,
0.2716192901134491,
-0.9447295069694519,
0.05182221159338951,
0.12435963749885559,
-0.4574377238750458,
-0.42782461643218994,
0.0841725617647171,
0.040390923619270325,
-0.15059487521648407,
-0.02552279829978943,
0.7323763966560364,
-0.7047967314720154,
-0.5274091362953186,
-0.002472085412591696,
0.07897750288248062,
0.11523789912462234,
0.5588791370391846,
-0.25618332624435425,
1.0794533491134644,
0.8967951536178589,
-0.2912617325782776,
0.44901347160339355,
0.40798529982566833,
-0.5066596269607544,
0.4728946089744568,
-0.7834290266036987,
-0.016171999275684357,
-0.26470524072647095,
0.28245654702186584,
-1.1661878824234009,
-0.4755062162876129,
0.8694877624511719,
-0.5614742040634155,
0.25380516052246094,
-0.37775659561157227,
-0.5819628834724426,
-0.2989967167377472,
-0.19509901106357574,
0.4747750461101532,
0.31357741355895996,
-0.7480319142341614,
0.984035849571228,
0.39311525225639343,
0.04994815215468407,
-0.6302861571311951,
-0.7395430207252502,
0.6162529587745667,
-0.09380850940942764,
-0.8949146270751953,
0.1390678584575653,
-0.01386456098407507,
-0.3433312773704529,
0.3387846052646637,
0.15799543261528015,
-0.06761849671602249,
-0.1799575239419937,
0.25841984152793884,
0.5292203426361084,
-0.3728596568107605,
0.08096453547477722,
0.012629222124814987,
-0.4202662706375122,
-0.09575244784355164,
-0.569697916507721,
0.47441136837005615,
-0.6245240569114685,
-0.7796911001205444,
-0.09135644882917404,
0.4053850769996643,
0.5400514602661133,
-0.48011282086372375,
0.3394010663032532,
0.2865374982357025,
-0.35963305830955505,
0.0468100868165493,
-0.19686074554920197,
0.5605505704879761,
-0.41257765889167786,
0.5053443908691406,
-0.46702584624290466,
-0.7625183463096619,
0.6129305362701416,
-0.2139161229133606,
-0.33929377794265747,
0.2142612785100937,
0.4335322082042694,
-0.26872411370277405,
1.1070057153701782,
0.57123202085495,
0.25563257932662964,
0.7835405468940735,
-0.4863351583480835,
0.2651088535785675,
-0.8013198971748352,
-0.1724557876586914,
-0.08364260196685791,
-0.24906988441944122,
-0.3928333818912506,
-0.5031502842903137,
0.31117504835128784,
0.28288060426712036,
-0.34621936082839966,
0.025329578667879105,
-0.6571660041809082,
0.7240294218063354,
0.3727025091648102,
0.09518246352672577,
0.34801292419433594,
0.2200770378112793,
-0.3096124529838562,
0.14311443269252777,
-0.49232831597328186,
-0.5831602811813354,
0.8284732699394226,
0.18542562425136566,
0.7442511320114136,
0.1058553010225296,
0.42834094166755676,
0.11319326609373093,
0.3775760233402252,
-0.9699816107749939,
0.7481234669685364,
-0.3277665078639984,
0.13153287768363953,
-0.30080991983413696,
-0.4236186444759369,
-0.6693357825279236,
0.40701767802238464,
0.1048167496919632,
-0.8860695958137512,
0.16521655023097992,
0.20058879256248474,
0.30956700444221497,
0.4716355800628662,
-1.1250746250152588,
0.9197924733161926,
-0.4786139130592346,
-0.17276477813720703,
0.16483257710933685,
-0.5488961338996887,
0.49318063259124756,
0.2203046828508377,
0.2650397717952728,
0.06592056155204773,
0.11497698724269867,
0.3633323609828949,
-0.5279449820518494,
0.8380509614944458,
-0.3602125942707062,
0.002534381113946438,
0.4919484257698059,
-0.061216048896312714,
0.5209517478942871,
-0.1179170235991478,
0.3798825442790985,
0.1154465451836586,
-0.12075255066156387,
-0.22866255044937134,
-0.7442882657051086,
0.2974781394004822,
-0.6375642418861389,
-0.41979482769966125,
-0.30396518111228943,
-0.5119659900665283,
-0.2039903700351715,
0.31557324528694153,
0.1421920210123062,
0.6308981776237488,
0.032289981842041016,
0.18770937621593475,
0.3504655957221985,
-0.15844424068927765,
0.024855585768818855,
-0.17289616167545319,
-0.837456226348877,
-0.6321510672569275,
0.8092542886734009,
0.3288957178592682,
0.3011210858821869,
0.2777610123157501,
0.17276635766029358,
-0.3971706032752991,
-0.5660322904586792,
-0.8957866430282593,
0.2150062918663025,
-1.153354525566101,
-0.10238323360681534,
-0.5270380973815918,
-0.5069006085395813,
0.023919489234685898,
-0.2189708650112152,
0.11677510291337967,
-0.24878932535648346,
-0.10909362882375717,
-0.06278213858604431,
0.5512506365776062,
0.6780314445495605,
0.1683308482170105,
0.4047648012638092,
-0.39878979325294495,
0.485023558139801,
0.2490539848804474,
0.47405117750167847,
-0.04635285586118698,
-0.20338299870491028,
-0.19825397431850433,
0.0469333790242672,
0.14664997160434723,
-0.9876483082771301,
0.14547660946846008,
0.22623604536056519,
0.6386654376983643,
0.1961672157049179,
-0.36912670731544495,
0.7165498733520508,
-0.5395613312721252,
0.3591669797897339,
0.4227852523326874,
-0.9572951793670654,
0.5676259398460388,
-0.4475177228450775,
0.20193451642990112,
0.2825778126716614,
0.021052328869700432,
-0.4993933439254761,
-0.3345761001110077,
-0.28806617856025696,
-1.0319726467132568,
0.08316844701766968,
-0.01807786524295807,
-0.14043907821178436,
0.014542332850396633,
0.2947864234447479,
-0.22474583983421326,
0.00281392689794302,
-0.7881163358688354,
0.04776965454220772,
-0.5009874701499939,
-0.3875713348388672,
0.2719186544418335,
-0.02514943853020668,
-0.10171663761138916,
-0.4384252727031708,
0.25844115018844604,
-0.7267744541168213,
0.07906549423933029,
0.07578425854444504,
-0.40759557485580444,
0.03770403936505318,
0.15067990124225616,
0.28253674507141113,
0.7808883190155029,
0.12970472872257233,
0.32342225313186646,
-0.0016646526055410504,
-0.4402359426021576,
0.12259635329246521,
-0.10455726087093353,
-0.4274847209453583,
-0.14087539911270142,
0.5504850745201111,
0.9093117117881775,
0.23844191431999207,
-0.7103202939033508,
0.5590153336524963,
-0.031607288867235184,
-0.2660518288612366,
-0.18315573036670685,
0.057283665984869,
0.2586321234703064,
0.48079732060432434,
0.34570932388305664,
-0.13148561120033264,
0.015312254428863525,
-0.4599730670452118,
0.22764500975608826,
0.5603087544441223,
-0.354342520236969,
-0.18359796702861786,
0.7598087191581726,
-0.09977325797080994,
-0.041981518268585205,
0.4936949610710144,
-0.11346843838691711,
-0.6330956220626831,
0.6245462894439697,
0.4828440546989441,
0.7256982326507568,
0.2779276371002197,
0.3313412666320801,
0.27294954657554626,
0.2079581767320633,
0.2713247537612915,
0.581955075263977,
-0.006828451994806528,
-0.711454451084137,
-0.8310695886611938,
-0.44137948751449585,
-0.5533859729766846,
-0.40467292070388794,
-0.2701091468334198,
0.22220975160598755,
-0.5212669372558594,
-0.12784865498542786,
-0.2812492251396179,
-0.2691001892089844,
-0.506339967250824,
0.23826643824577332,
0.24117091298103333,
0.8795405030250549,
-0.6948375105857849,
0.7950507998466492,
0.9234451055526733,
-0.7401073575019836,
-0.7036046981811523,
-0.147389218211174,
-0.1829899400472641,
-1.17849862575531,
0.7572495341300964,
0.27496659755706787,
-0.5965216159820557,
0.11198699474334717,
-1.0005680322647095,
-0.7336112260818481,
1.07869553565979,
0.7412165999412537,
-0.4534846246242523,
-0.2589990794658661,
0.12272492796182632,
0.44900792837142944,
-0.5056927800178528,
0.06586220115423203,
0.29494529962539673,
0.6292104721069336,
0.5650873184204102,
-0.5287860035896301,
0.04425223916769028,
-0.5008012056350708,
0.06647029519081116,
0.30887049436569214,
-0.35341188311576843,
0.782326877117157,
-0.4784061014652252,
-0.7406889796257019,
-0.15745389461517334,
0.6827116012573242,
0.1716223508119583,
0.1118415966629982,
0.5424251556396484,
0.6023622155189514,
0.8838372826576233,
-0.26645413041114807,
1.1562362909317017,
-0.24873563647270203,
0.21067498624324799,
1.0657446384429932,
-0.21188011765480042,
0.5610010027885437,
0.440146267414093,
-0.05041969567537308,
0.7219836711883545,
0.7051089406013489,
0.03624064102768898,
0.47771114110946655,
0.15199634432792664,
0.10413950681686401,
-0.3206651210784912,
-0.2852523922920227,
-0.4427920877933502,
0.42989349365234375,
0.40581101179122925,
-0.1539885550737381,
-0.32058191299438477,
-0.2265881448984146,
-0.13829545676708221,
0.13910192251205444,
-0.21283017098903656,
0.5122568011283875,
0.1326005756855011,
-0.07938600331544876,
0.4521264433860779,
-0.417400598526001,
0.30498313903808594,
-0.6608842611312866,
-0.22401143610477448,
0.004071184899657965,
-0.08695900440216064,
-0.260125070810318,
-1.2608745098114014,
0.30268386006355286,
-0.1414908617734909,
-0.07064622640609741,
-0.14754250645637512,
0.8296731114387512,
-0.3521149158477783,
-0.4108625650405884,
0.6460810303688049,
0.7674508094787598,
-0.020430944859981537,
-0.036541376262903214,
-0.31310465931892395,
0.08745454251766205,
-0.2863261103630066,
-0.23014527559280396,
0.18174400925636292,
0.6133673787117004,
-0.34471216797828674,
0.7758817672729492,
0.7457362413406372,
0.2028389424085617,
-0.21030960977077484,
0.4177577495574951,
1.177943468093872,
-0.771671712398529,
-0.823906421661377,
-0.8334684371948242,
0.593625545501709,
-0.16027072072029114,
-0.1396295726299286,
0.33427825570106506,
0.6031228303909302,
0.6080362200737,
0.28801071643829346,
0.965685248374939,
0.06497634202241898,
-0.03558763861656189,
-0.842154860496521,
0.7218520045280457,
-0.6836697459220886,
-0.12750975787639618,
-0.3085227906703949,
-0.9884732961654663,
-0.3897850513458252,
0.6858746409416199,
-0.4399730861186981,
-0.06804918497800827,
0.7436003088951111,
0.400520920753479,
-0.1261693388223648,
-0.2593739628791809,
0.26846808195114136,
0.09593795239925385,
0.6350558400154114,
0.8262917995452881,
1.010533094406128,
-0.184666246175766,
0.6404175162315369,
0.47239071130752563,
-0.3671127259731293,
0.003317048540338874,
-0.7934960126876831,
-0.7703865766525269,
-0.5410478115081787,
-0.05264495685696602,
-0.2659262716770172,
-0.017291316762566566,
0.45643994212150574,
0.4124743342399597,
-0.43462398648262024,
-0.02282620035111904,
-0.05740191042423248,
0.21498966217041016,
0.10509773343801498,
-0.2334132045507431,
0.46637776494026184,
-0.07065097987651825,
-0.49852314591407776,
0.24261926114559174,
0.7576127052307129,
0.39281708002090454,
-0.3316293954849243,
-0.2431209534406662,
-0.07433246821165085,
-0.09680625796318054,
0.682448148727417,
0.4653611481189728,
-0.7188810110092163,
-0.8256757259368896,
-0.04761914908885956,
-0.2198019027709961,
0.5629748702049255,
0.546183705329895,
-0.8268550038337708,
0.4643993377685547,
0.49007800221443176,
0.875096321105957,
0.5392502546310425,
-0.02679796703159809,
0.5481896996498108,
-0.44083571434020996,
0.14671601355075836,
0.0018808883614838123,
0.8114640116691589,
0.4550260305404663,
-0.16392864286899567,
0.9320303797721863,
0.3116982579231262,
-0.1860375851392746,
-0.7438018321990967,
0.5206328630447388,
-1.2263797521591187,
-0.1675543487071991,
0.9764035940170288,
-0.1007523164153099,
-0.5237201452255249,
0.05761050432920456,
-0.3932989835739136,
0.33474183082580566,
0.014279630966484547,
0.23656368255615234,
0.7573590874671936,
-0.1561402827501297,
-0.3778989911079407,
-0.4721719026565552,
-0.027913900092244148,
-0.08245836943387985,
-1.385248064994812,
0.10365241020917892,
0.801531195640564,
0.0380362831056118,
0.02654174342751503,
0.9130117893218994,
-0.05024874955415726,
0.2582409977912903,
0.04419197142124176,
-0.017174825072288513,
-0.3966064453125,
-0.6171411871910095,
0.04860183224081993,
0.016395490616559982,
-0.047272998839616776,
-0.2183607816696167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02113v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02113v1 | Zero-shot Sentiment Analysis in Low-Resource Languages Using a Multilingual Sentiment Lexicon | 2024-02-03T10:41:05 | 2024-02-03T10:41:05 | Fajri Koto, Tilman Beck, Zeerak Talat, Iryna Gurevych, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Improving multilingual language models capabilities in low-resource languages
is generally difficult due to the scarcity of large-scale data in those
languages. In this paper, we relax the reliance on texts in low-resource
languages by using multilingual lexicons in pretraining to enhance multilingual
capabilities. Specifically, we focus on zero-shot sentiment analysis tasks
across 34 languages, including 6 high/medium-resource languages, 25
low-resource languages, and 3 code-switching datasets. We demonstrate that
pretraining using multilingual lexicons, without using any sentence-level
sentiment data, achieves superior zero-shot performance compared to models
fine-tuned on English sentiment datasets, and large language models like
GPT--3.5, BLOOMZ, and XGLM. These findings are observable for unseen
low-resource languages to code-mixed scenarios involving high-resource
languages. | [
-0.583739161491394,
-0.15163616836071014,
0.3016287386417389,
0.24315495789051056,
-0.3874538540840149,
0.3112695515155792,
-0.7016949653625488,
-0.3893996477127075,
0.3789384067058563,
0.13720256090164185,
-0.583279013633728,
-0.5876680016517639,
-0.523387610912323,
0.2947096824645996,
0.1613563746213913,
1.442367434501648,
-0.13685232400894165,
0.35404232144355774,
-0.11767452955245972,
-0.5501797795295715,
-0.16168925166130066,
-0.8829060792922974,
-0.33158954977989197,
-0.12267501652240753,
0.8922834396362305,
0.49274957180023193,
0.5876492857933044,
0.007887590676546097,
0.40806037187576294,
0.17736917734146118,
0.07352246344089508,
-0.11614157259464264,
-0.4808809161186218,
-0.051706451922655106,
-0.07637584209442139,
-0.31853193044662476,
-0.4314107596874237,
0.03185955435037613,
0.5402935743331909,
0.6881862282752991,
0.03664742037653923,
0.23356744647026062,
0.11271580308675766,
0.3811207413673401,
-1.1643290519714355,
0.21082128584384918,
-0.4488312005996704,
0.34057146310806274,
-0.37336841225624084,
-0.15808860957622528,
-0.35166212916374207,
-0.07649481296539307,
-0.10933585464954376,
-0.4565873146057129,
0.17073845863342285,
-0.438142329454422,
0.7555236220359802,
0.09048192203044891,
-0.2675143778324127,
-0.011144458316266537,
-0.6693484783172607,
1.2377519607543945,
-0.7094026803970337,
0.40309587121009827,
0.12948203086853027,
-0.11807385087013245,
0.6943157911300659,
-0.11139728873968124,
-0.5271794199943542,
-0.2191009670495987,
-0.06983809918165207,
0.482863187789917,
0.08157281577587128,
-0.013775787316262722,
0.17301617562770844,
0.3167791962623596,
-0.4384203255176544,
0.13584959506988525,
-0.010623703710734844,
-0.18651843070983887,
0.35558173060417175,
-0.12029828876256943,
0.08923708647489548,
-0.31007200479507446,
-0.1958451271057129,
-0.17864209413528442,
-0.5542298555374146,
0.004648635163903236,
0.3645835220813751,
0.6986174583435059,
-0.3427501618862152,
0.33280450105667114,
-0.23937317728996277,
0.6211736798286438,
-0.4557369351387024,
-0.23107708990573883,
0.613983154296875,
-0.541931688785553,
-0.20510441064834595,
-0.10449609905481339,
0.9209953546524048,
0.2998674809932709,
0.4384991228580475,
-0.0458357036113739,
-0.20699046552181244,
0.31643521785736084,
0.007757895160466433,
-0.9271867871284485,
0.004307222552597523,
-0.00249414867721498,
-0.37178438901901245,
-0.2738800346851349,
-0.19220076501369476,
-0.9412184953689575,
-0.262375146150589,
0.0514211431145668,
0.13895590603351593,
-0.27369970083236694,
-0.6285312175750732,
0.15143565833568573,
-0.05997476726770401,
0.3342675566673279,
0.08071587979793549,
-0.7131177186965942,
-0.04803388565778732,
0.19964104890823364,
1.0084435939788818,
0.015601638704538345,
-0.5618138909339905,
-0.505615770816803,
-0.20131975412368774,
-0.47005513310432434,
0.7415392994880676,
-0.5337475538253784,
-0.547565758228302,
0.21578828990459442,
-0.17605896294116974,
-0.09095491468906403,
-0.3512071371078491,
0.3949926793575287,
-0.2430506944656372,
0.3166143596172333,
-0.22086137533187866,
-0.09813939779996872,
0.11093926429748535,
0.6915642023086548,
-0.5749667286872864,
0.8338303565979004,
0.04174242541193962,
-0.7150713801383972,
0.3440900444984436,
-0.700799822807312,
-0.677476704120636,
-0.11661132425069809,
-0.2261456698179245,
-0.15335839986801147,
0.360256552696228,
0.24231818318367004,
0.377443790435791,
-0.08403122425079346,
-0.3107747733592987,
-0.4792190492153168,
-0.08841459453105927,
0.14078105986118317,
-0.5845349431037903,
0.5664218664169312,
0.30454424023628235,
-0.1948031783103943,
-0.23438780009746552,
-0.561827540397644,
0.2879360318183899,
0.07886505126953125,
-0.25934022665023804,
-0.2950594425201416,
-0.21516253054141998,
0.21001537144184113,
0.6694366335868835,
0.3039742112159729,
-0.7470895051956177,
0.05649949982762337,
-0.49745023250579834,
-0.09416154772043228,
0.23153088986873627,
-0.22649267315864563,
0.467781126499176,
0.08379832655191422,
0.931941032409668,
0.41784512996673584,
0.19767969846725464,
-0.3615932762622833,
-0.10625716298818588,
-0.7978220582008362,
-0.14899268746376038,
0.12496007978916168,
0.634949266910553,
-1.0725858211517334,
-0.0492340549826622,
-0.31400880217552185,
-0.3445693552494049,
-0.6160456538200378,
0.38106656074523926,
0.7083096504211426,
0.2974371910095215,
0.4296441972255707,
-0.38323482871055603,
-0.31570255756378174,
-0.6876498460769653,
-0.4386443793773651,
-0.12635575234889984,
0.2772707939147949,
0.20503108203411102,
0.14202818274497986,
-0.04898291826248169,
0.5082746744155884,
-0.6297573447227478,
-0.15998825430870056,
-0.6004900336265564,
0.19007009267807007,
0.2690774202346802,
0.1889505833387375,
0.7284742593765259,
-0.48396313190460205,
-0.7597205638885498,
0.0924362912774086,
-0.781877875328064,
0.04706461727619171,
-0.13442204892635345,
-0.12343347072601318,
0.5719706416130066,
0.3472959101200104,
-0.5468310117721558,
0.09447570890188217,
0.7756636142730713,
-0.1852865368127823,
0.5362247824668884,
0.0042198956944048405,
0.17802733182907104,
-1.0089077949523926,
0.15709495544433594,
0.1030285507440567,
-0.16637827455997467,
-0.7211353778839111,
0.09153905510902405,
0.0971650555729866,
-0.31965985894203186,
-0.8627490997314453,
0.6641673445701599,
-0.5798301100730896,
0.04564313963055611,
-0.21528582274913788,
0.0000775352818891406,
0.16238592565059662,
0.5070700645446777,
0.3314329981803894,
0.6087493300437927,
0.6914330124855042,
-0.2990235388278961,
0.18849888443946838,
0.008611871860921383,
-0.1686609834432602,
0.6025782227516174,
-0.2759638726711273,
-0.012909228913486004,
-0.3711545169353485,
-0.08580051362514496,
-0.5260787606239319,
-0.005249909125268459,
0.0924459844827652,
-0.524469256401062,
0.36975976824760437,
-0.14985433220863342,
-0.39945507049560547,
-0.1538594365119934,
-0.5401411056518555,
0.5149192810058594,
0.2635542154312134,
-0.28618744015693665,
0.3904038071632385,
0.18128716945648193,
-0.20048822462558746,
-0.9151699542999268,
-0.8919153213500977,
0.06107616052031517,
-0.04187741503119469,
-0.08872222900390625,
-0.1790013462305069,
-0.17165790498256683,
-0.2046540081501007,
-0.20058681070804596,
0.09589265286922455,
-0.21196474134922028,
-0.08988173305988312,
0.05364396050572395,
0.510698139667511,
-0.21321849524974823,
0.2600051760673523,
-0.2926642596721649,
-0.14678828418254852,
-0.20792540907859802,
-0.3037828505039215,
0.7164665460586548,
-0.38234496116638184,
-0.27580058574676514,
-0.061772946268320084,
0.5087645649909973,
0.5730636715888977,
-0.4812052845954895,
0.8431528806686401,
0.7874072790145874,
-0.12904810905456543,
-0.0331408828496933,
-0.3121069669723511,
0.041357386857271194,
-0.3710542619228363,
0.45517703890800476,
-0.29094722867012024,
-0.8033554553985596,
0.3363947570323944,
0.14118428528308868,
-0.03826664015650749,
0.44591081142425537,
0.7079212665557861,
-0.06014446169137955,
0.9245128035545349,
0.7336193323135376,
-0.5584796071052551,
0.543464183807373,
-0.19759152829647064,
0.37245988845825195,
-0.26779812574386597,
0.20090556144714355,
-0.44375506043434143,
-0.18935412168502808,
-0.5483018755912781,
-0.261905312538147,
0.3675694465637207,
0.10790832340717316,
-0.10325779765844345,
0.09575536102056503,
-0.09453264623880386,
0.6461913585662842,
0.4344472587108612,
-0.19687239825725555,
0.15666580200195312,
0.1943250447511673,
-0.18930402398109436,
-0.1319303661584854,
-0.7875370383262634,
-0.2632429599761963,
0.9660233855247498,
0.019003024324774742,
0.6313947439193726,
-0.13863015174865723,
0.8810001015663147,
-0.10951059311628342,
0.20879967510700226,
-1.071566104888916,
0.32632526755332947,
-0.5858982801437378,
-0.666966438293457,
-0.1388106346130371,
-0.5807473063468933,
-0.5655084252357483,
0.20067694783210754,
-0.30738478899002075,
-0.1545443832874298,
0.012388472445309162,
0.1757018268108368,
-0.6927047967910767,
0.38752874732017517,
-0.8093289136886597,
1.1270809173583984,
-0.3843018710613251,
-0.25062206387519836,
-0.39099571108818054,
-0.3841753304004669,
0.1735161989927292,
-0.17011693120002747,
0.5735078454017639,
-0.2045564204454422,
0.02255178429186344,
0.4179268479347229,
-0.31569865345954895,
0.8294692039489746,
-0.4072507917881012,
-0.21195939183235168,
0.26135385036468506,
0.004419830162078142,
0.02928701415657997,
0.12224772572517395,
-0.13186070322990417,
0.5167458653450012,
0.1781059205532074,
-0.5893594026565552,
-0.2754869759082794,
0.7149462103843689,
-0.9008060097694397,
-0.12933897972106934,
-0.5401989817619324,
-0.28629031777381897,
-0.6460435390472412,
0.38123780488967896,
0.6330410242080688,
0.4199099540710449,
-0.40574079751968384,
0.04342520982027054,
0.3220739960670471,
-0.3968186378479004,
0.8150705695152283,
0.4863550364971161,
-0.0809750184416771,
-0.2256191223859787,
1.095324158668518,
0.25064513087272644,
0.26039767265319824,
0.35338014364242554,
0.1592022329568863,
-0.24840229749679565,
-0.1734897792339325,
-0.6343677043914795,
0.10727230459451675,
-0.5740792155265808,
-0.4665021598339081,
-0.49789324402809143,
-0.011047273874282837,
-0.32466521859169006,
-0.27901020646095276,
-0.7373929619789124,
-0.3473348617553711,
-0.0356028750538826,
-0.10064315795898438,
0.1431088149547577,
0.3434307277202606,
-0.18110248446464539,
0.46980589628219604,
-1.2578699588775635,
0.28675577044487,
0.11775772273540497,
0.5213186144828796,
-0.06435077637434006,
-0.24309982359409332,
-0.7634572982788086,
0.03496658802032471,
-0.17989695072174072,
-0.7662047147750854,
0.5433398485183716,
0.4954860210418701,
0.25332388281822205,
0.3942171335220337,
-0.054009974002838135,
0.6288723349571228,
-0.39162829518318176,
0.9079974293708801,
0.5917105674743652,
-1.0339828729629517,
0.4392944276332855,
-0.37939149141311646,
0.673560380935669,
0.7567287683486938,
0.5097619295120239,
-0.8484430313110352,
-0.33985796570777893,
-0.337716668844223,
-0.7157139182090759,
0.8492042422294617,
-0.2532242238521576,
0.5379841923713684,
-0.16486410796642303,
0.21559621393680573,
0.08235533535480499,
0.41749343276023865,
-1.0781333446502686,
-0.12983167171478271,
-0.696189820766449,
-0.2840062379837036,
-0.4805665910243988,
-0.2615051567554474,
-0.08552156388759613,
-0.170561745762825,
0.5437637567520142,
-0.387429416179657,
0.05718865618109703,
-0.1366553008556366,
-0.39007389545440674,
-0.021172596141695976,
0.5977584719657898,
0.22209540009498596,
0.2833116054534912,
0.08335944265127182,
0.15096580982208252,
0.4996075928211212,
-0.49110981822013855,
0.2908231317996979,
-0.061184223741292953,
-0.16021376848220825,
0.09444741904735565,
0.5695433020591736,
0.9332244992256165,
0.3523341119289398,
-0.5993375182151794,
0.7583974003791809,
-0.08751661330461502,
-0.03456151857972145,
-0.14804822206497192,
-0.26129183173179626,
-0.06770379096269608,
-0.009648152627050877,
-0.07884270697832108,
0.0926002487540245,
-0.1650642603635788,
-0.515184223651886,
-0.11483864486217499,
0.5372485518455505,
-0.5152218341827393,
-0.5778688788414001,
0.17053639888763428,
0.17172731459140778,
0.45902368426322937,
0.5812518000602722,
-0.43036720156669617,
-0.34852084517478943,
0.22967202961444855,
0.3410435914993286,
0.8477703928947449,
-0.18562911450862885,
0.5794131755828857,
0.4704669415950775,
0.24012136459350586,
-0.07469888776540756,
0.4371734857559204,
0.006954649463295937,
-1.103285312652588,
-0.7319758534431458,
-0.817743718624115,
-0.45318669080734253,
-0.06515978276729584,
-0.7769423127174377,
0.3178941607475281,
-0.5158033967018127,
-0.20353174209594727,
-0.1665400117635727,
0.008964445441961288,
-0.8798540830612183,
0.35919517278671265,
0.5654826760292053,
0.6639185547828674,
-0.8162699937820435,
0.9436689615249634,
0.9134928584098816,
-0.5040735006332397,
-0.6674792766571045,
-0.006139562465250492,
-0.0006913094548508525,
-0.8061774373054504,
0.5808764696121216,
0.22700004279613495,
-0.4255816638469696,
0.005474362522363663,
-0.3831979036331177,
-0.6375937461853027,
0.5252376198768616,
0.5988328456878662,
-0.4512994587421417,
0.16579818725585938,
0.3236106038093567,
0.7101343870162964,
-0.17919421195983887,
0.32077541947364807,
0.38757309317588806,
0.36055809259414673,
-0.09276315569877625,
-0.7474180459976196,
-0.49453434348106384,
-0.3127889335155487,
-0.10352399200201035,
0.21469183266162872,
-0.7151507139205933,
1.0082896947860718,
-0.11101686954498291,
-0.2069258689880371,
-0.35862138867378235,
0.4925614893436432,
-0.10448774695396423,
-0.016771184280514717,
0.5459043383598328,
0.620770275592804,
0.5309562087059021,
0.05425465852022171,
0.9823662042617798,
-0.7149879336357117,
0.4637789726257324,
1.0034008026123047,
-0.6138367652893066,
1.1387782096862793,
0.37913578748703003,
-0.05995411053299904,
0.56656813621521,
0.4012632966041565,
0.27640920877456665,
0.5221179127693176,
-0.22033660113811493,
-0.7222291231155396,
-0.4789901673793793,
-0.37418699264526367,
-0.30776235461235046,
0.8468101024627686,
0.04286801815032959,
0.09201318770647049,
-0.5179808735847473,
0.3104914724826813,
0.395794540643692,
-0.1034933477640152,
-0.5878221988677979,
0.804277241230011,
0.09363057464361191,
-0.5065217018127441,
0.709975004196167,
-0.07191050052642822,
1.096155047416687,
-0.7768874168395996,
0.4001171290874481,
-0.5272048115730286,
0.31608298420906067,
-0.2949535846710205,
-0.801041305065155,
0.45805636048316956,
0.518704891204834,
-0.26532667875289917,
-0.47956371307373047,
0.639456033706665,
-0.4306957721710205,
-0.7075993418693542,
0.7392842173576355,
0.9236696362495422,
0.07094725966453552,
-0.3568470776081085,
-0.6248989105224609,
-0.06712839007377625,
-0.043979134410619736,
-0.30428311228752136,
0.5068221092224121,
0.3883458375930786,
0.20183813571929932,
0.12083947658538818,
0.5170553922653198,
0.43229445815086365,
-0.1466664969921112,
0.542152464389801,
0.8100115656852722,
-0.7906893491744995,
-0.4730544090270996,
-0.9912261962890625,
0.3306550085544586,
0.04550790414214134,
-0.42279303073883057,
0.8205745816230774,
0.4466876685619354,
1.1990435123443604,
-0.30938127636909485,
1.0679519176483154,
0.022404538467526436,
0.3938661515712738,
-0.44743210077285767,
0.8518278002738953,
-0.7043589949607849,
-0.280687540769577,
-0.27016112208366394,
-0.8783588409423828,
-0.5278059840202332,
0.5741757750511169,
-0.1995815634727478,
0.06904466450214386,
0.6174446940422058,
0.5710300207138062,
0.04366365447640419,
-0.37342819571495056,
0.492747038602829,
0.029614107683300972,
0.0537111796438694,
0.4686032235622406,
0.8168831467628479,
-0.06410533934831619,
0.7477906942367554,
-0.34805914759635925,
-0.2819209396839142,
0.12689357995986938,
-0.9738585948944092,
-0.7921578288078308,
-0.12088123708963394,
-0.17622651159763336,
-0.3110043704509735,
-0.3492336571216583,
0.9648476839065552,
0.6131699085235596,
-0.962035059928894,
-0.509822428226471,
0.30409613251686096,
-0.011198986321687698,
-0.035140931606292725,
-0.21777822077274323,
-0.12848594784736633,
-0.9176825881004333,
-0.6586510539054871,
0.29866716265678406,
0.40107643604278564,
-0.11800403892993927,
-0.27529075741767883,
-0.13481682538986206,
-0.13856226205825806,
0.00776238227263093,
0.9376631379127502,
0.46644705533981323,
-0.14512625336647034,
-0.18052911758422852,
0.2222692221403122,
-0.14640747010707855,
0.1604735404253006,
1.0452121496200562,
-0.6810542345046997,
0.5381007790565491,
0.3481948971748352,
0.41259631514549255,
0.3213503956794739,
-0.2919318974018097,
0.38817867636680603,
-1.2166208028793335,
0.6695575714111328,
0.21739394962787628,
0.5132712125778198,
0.5468093752861023,
-0.10847316682338715,
0.2606002390384674,
0.3422676920890808,
-0.11011552065610886,
-0.648418128490448,
0.2305276244878769,
-0.6041772365570068,
-0.33926281332969666,
1.0807098150253296,
-0.24867819249629974,
0.04409386217594147,
0.18265675008296967,
0.059338632971048355,
0.3204014301300049,
-0.13354699313640594,
0.5471210479736328,
0.907976508140564,
0.02075091004371643,
-0.2321101278066635,
-0.4822140634059906,
0.5761839747428894,
0.6661785244941711,
-0.8916694521903992,
0.10393121093511581,
0.6111390590667725,
-0.00551700871437788,
0.3838289678096771,
0.9404065608978271,
-0.18243326246738434,
0.06581908464431763,
-0.030443044379353523,
0.4768295884132385,
0.3030986189842224,
-0.46418851613998413,
-0.6557730436325073,
0.18984369933605194,
0.31692802906036377,
-0.15923498570919037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02101v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02101v1 | Are Large Language Models Good Prompt Optimizers? | 2024-02-03T09:48:54 | 2024-02-03T09:48:54 | Ruotian Ma, Xiaolei Wang, Xin Zhou, Jian Li, Nan Du, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLM-based Automatic Prompt Optimization, which typically utilizes LLMs as
Prompt Optimizers to self-reflect and refine prompts, has shown promising
performance in recent studies. Despite the success, the underlying mechanism of
this approach remains unexplored, and the true effectiveness of LLMs as Prompt
Optimizers requires further validation. In this work, we conducted a
comprehensive study to uncover the actual mechanism of LLM-based Prompt
Optimization. Our findings reveal that the LLM optimizers struggle to identify
the true causes of errors during reflection, tending to be biased by their own
prior knowledge rather than genuinely reflecting on the errors. Furthermore,
even when the reflection is semantically valid, the LLM optimizers often fail
to generate appropriate prompts for the target models with a single prompt
refinement step, partly due to the unpredictable behaviors of the target
models. Based on the observations, we introduce a new "Automatic Behavior
Optimization" paradigm, which directly optimizes the target model's behavior in
a more controllable manner. We hope our study can inspire new directions for
automatic prompt optimization development. | [
-0.171799436211586,
-0.9501739740371704,
1.0843534469604492,
0.5175169110298157,
-0.16601918637752533,
-0.08336156606674194,
-0.2054101824760437,
-0.12861967086791992,
-0.07843875885009766,
0.35445183515548706,
-1.1214975118637085,
-0.19292260706424713,
-0.3168216943740845,
0.689073383808136,
-0.1632499247789383,
0.7825150489807129,
-0.04261795058846474,
0.36480048298835754,
-0.11596288532018661,
0.1582874059677124,
-0.6281946301460266,
-0.25563979148864746,
-1.0445536375045776,
-0.2890414893627167,
0.7439746260643005,
0.16218020021915436,
0.3461759686470032,
0.7853510975837708,
0.28676164150238037,
0.29684072732925415,
-0.09058976918458939,
0.46767517924308777,
-0.49636897444725037,
0.48121801018714905,
0.0028404579497873783,
-0.4752809405326843,
-0.15741705894470215,
-0.018858633935451508,
0.7881202101707458,
0.5231336951255798,
-0.17340196669101715,
-0.003559183096513152,
0.18932180106639862,
0.6628400087356567,
-0.5898990631103516,
0.11887369304895401,
-0.4863045811653137,
0.1926860809326172,
0.09102191776037216,
-0.4070580005645752,
-0.606758177280426,
-0.584097683429718,
-0.027995269745588303,
-0.542777955532074,
-0.0024701151996850967,
0.39367952942848206,
0.5445512533187866,
0.7507771849632263,
-0.365504652261734,
-0.4277549088001251,
-0.6266657710075378,
0.9865792989730835,
-0.7221002578735352,
0.07362928986549377,
-0.08606824278831482,
0.2564713656902313,
-0.6605391502380371,
-0.2243722677230835,
-0.2771121859550476,
-0.6312877535820007,
0.0429900661110878,
-0.011253278702497482,
-0.2433047741651535,
0.3335549235343933,
0.6264247894287109,
-0.024671385064721107,
-0.44427695870399475,
0.4933822751045227,
0.15681208670139313,
-0.41727414727211,
0.4810837209224701,
0.599420964717865,
0.37137725949287415,
-0.1772838532924652,
-0.364033579826355,
0.1414211541414261,
-0.7418724894523621,
0.33456769585609436,
0.4656016528606415,
0.5422952771186829,
0.03738440200686455,
0.41935601830482483,
-0.0623772107064724,
0.8335772752761841,
0.2526852488517761,
-0.19344958662986755,
-0.19507278501987457,
-0.3746495246887207,
0.19357265532016754,
0.09343493729829788,
0.8034859895706177,
0.5058452486991882,
0.48325294256210327,
0.042039304971694946,
-0.7197176218032837,
-0.148756742477417,
0.1999426782131195,
-0.7595573663711548,
0.06398828327655792,
0.18937553465366364,
-0.4787374436855316,
-0.5086038708686829,
-0.2966671586036682,
-0.4752650856971741,
-0.33996227383613586,
-0.5300743579864502,
0.44243964552879333,
-0.014269720762968063,
0.009079843759536743,
0.0865127295255661,
0.0695919543504715,
0.2864905297756195,
0.5511578321456909,
-0.7803227305412292,
0.09411782026290894,
0.6502547264099121,
0.7912468910217285,
-0.49294283986091614,
-0.195431649684906,
-1.0401535034179688,
-0.16534283757209778,
-0.61407071352005,
0.6824301481246948,
-0.4712410867214203,
-0.5815439224243164,
0.1570563167333603,
-0.014572031795978546,
-0.19396214187145233,
-0.3873433768749237,
0.5553462505340576,
-0.518798828125,
0.17855969071388245,
-0.6591101884841919,
-0.48844844102859497,
-0.05315093323588371,
0.2681083381175995,
-0.6995123028755188,
0.8558955192565918,
-0.11113522946834564,
-0.4866168797016144,
0.2666533887386322,
-0.6929705142974854,
-0.21649903059005737,
-0.16058671474456787,
-0.030595406889915466,
-0.34433600306510925,
0.3817272484302521,
0.1054125428199768,
0.37379130721092224,
-0.5741150975227356,
0.5035196542739868,
-0.10239163786172867,
-0.3744818866252899,
0.41290396451950073,
-0.4865625202655792,
0.8143419027328491,
0.17955534160137177,
-0.33583587408065796,
0.34082889556884766,
-0.5964269042015076,
-0.17479340732097626,
0.24588972330093384,
-0.42457568645477295,
-0.041248369961977005,
0.14516034722328186,
-0.2992754876613617,
0.13136357069015503,
0.5231329202651978,
-0.41684040427207947,
0.5324516892433167,
-0.2632144093513489,
0.19186346232891083,
1.0301706790924072,
0.2256370633840561,
0.4148116409778595,
-0.23936232924461365,
0.9635872840881348,
-0.3690623939037323,
0.36017554998397827,
-0.5286111235618591,
-0.2238893359899521,
-0.6707904934883118,
-0.17472049593925476,
-0.12781782448291779,
0.4993721544742584,
-0.5380677580833435,
0.28144046664237976,
0.32763031125068665,
-0.19541633129119873,
-0.35709714889526367,
0.11457379162311554,
0.612105667591095,
0.9434669613838196,
0.20867280662059784,
0.11343194544315338,
-0.3117128908634186,
-0.959394633769989,
-0.4007602035999298,
-0.015410698018968105,
0.3373256027698517,
0.3203539550304413,
0.22432158887386322,
-0.19515401124954224,
1.073072075843811,
-0.4199479818344116,
0.07708466053009033,
-0.329863041639328,
-0.07588618993759155,
0.454719603061676,
0.3773193359375,
0.6515973806381226,
-0.48696091771125793,
-0.49271276593208313,
-0.555521547794342,
-0.68492192029953,
-0.7075538039207458,
-0.37817203998565674,
-0.13385504484176636,
0.3938824534416199,
0.7439717054367065,
-0.6565893888473511,
0.010447526350617409,
0.2537783980369568,
-0.1883583962917328,
1.0687384605407715,
-0.27634841203689575,
-0.11183469742536545,
-0.5782231688499451,
-0.0363403782248497,
0.20353399217128754,
-0.08700206130743027,
-0.45412832498550415,
-0.07484424859285355,
0.11829591542482376,
0.0021070472430437803,
-0.4001137316226959,
0.873111367225647,
-0.6640834212303162,
0.012005271390080452,
-0.5168642401695251,
-0.03939278796315193,
0.002147792838513851,
0.5371881723403931,
-0.03872846066951752,
1.0374181270599365,
0.7149473428726196,
-0.6892371773719788,
0.4880272448062897,
0.040459152311086655,
-0.0657094419002533,
0.45675739645957947,
-0.858366847038269,
0.10909175872802734,
-0.32762569189071655,
0.22612035274505615,
-1.159981369972229,
-0.15852685272693634,
0.3689473867416382,
-0.18857449293136597,
0.37361940741539,
-0.049486301839351654,
-0.5333619713783264,
-0.3631197214126587,
-0.3928210437297821,
0.15973252058029175,
0.5019676685333252,
-0.6377124190330505,
0.6772161722183228,
-0.1834607869386673,
-0.018799446523189545,
-0.5442566275596619,
-0.191395103931427,
-0.003773288568481803,
-0.2974589169025421,
-0.506879448890686,
-0.16954384744167328,
-0.3109608292579651,
-0.39983054995536804,
-0.48223280906677246,
-0.04641997441649437,
0.5112977027893066,
0.3344343900680542,
-0.005580597557127476,
0.4020923972129822,
-0.17771998047828674,
0.08452735841274261,
0.06610116362571716,
-0.3180955648422241,
0.527440071105957,
-0.25121358036994934,
0.6784276366233826,
0.0520704984664917,
-0.46160122752189636,
-0.6396253705024719,
0.23104625940322876,
0.2871851325035095,
-0.19190889596939087,
0.4453357756137848,
0.3726408779621124,
0.0733509436249733,
-0.5384826064109802,
-0.7478697299957275,
-0.49977782368659973,
-0.5842500329017639,
0.308284729719162,
-0.3564057946205139,
-0.7365432977676392,
0.5977836847305298,
-0.12591740489006042,
0.026429854333400726,
0.2910830080509186,
0.46056413650512695,
0.03240210562944412,
1.4411240816116333,
0.5216565132141113,
0.01541502121835947,
0.44040852785110474,
0.07301898300647736,
0.07172657549381256,
-0.9133725762367249,
-0.15927688777446747,
-0.6448551416397095,
-0.11362934857606888,
-0.5422359704971313,
-0.15123304724693298,
0.45079606771469116,
-0.17517782747745514,
-0.38951075077056885,
0.03541378676891327,
-0.5379087924957275,
0.5005065202713013,
0.6778905987739563,
-0.14766238629817963,
0.11404377222061157,
-0.27000221610069275,
-0.2884190082550049,
-0.03288937360048294,
-0.6701055765151978,
-0.6379362344741821,
0.8031616806983948,
0.38274577260017395,
1.010445475578308,
-0.26610517501831055,
0.6678644418716431,
0.13595622777938843,
-0.004957419354468584,
-0.8486604690551758,
0.7676134705543518,
0.28563588857650757,
-0.3453020453453064,
-0.3049260675907135,
-0.47571390867233276,
-0.9648262858390808,
0.056421469897031784,
0.014114275574684143,
-0.5480586886405945,
0.11039281636476517,
0.42925700545310974,
-0.4606668949127197,
-0.02248266339302063,
-0.6192398071289062,
0.9255521297454834,
-0.5188783407211304,
-0.3986196517944336,
0.1285143494606018,
-0.7484740018844604,
0.19930660724639893,
-0.34935009479522705,
0.18691188097000122,
-0.1847551017999649,
-0.23212149739265442,
0.5722250938415527,
-0.360176682472229,
0.9097986817359924,
-0.5446683764457703,
-0.5108166337013245,
0.24232327938079834,
0.356258749961853,
0.9621492028236389,
-0.1331992894411087,
-0.07273710519075394,
-0.2674216628074646,
-0.3655454218387604,
-0.163084015250206,
-0.7626562118530273,
0.5499897003173828,
-0.5956101417541504,
-0.9033073782920837,
-0.278770387172699,
-0.31720709800720215,
-0.2925032377243042,
0.20001326501369476,
0.2392486333847046,
0.6174311637878418,
-0.047302450984716415,
-0.2746443450450897,
0.7815799713134766,
-0.2866147458553314,
0.7547850012779236,
0.8540552258491516,
-0.13960027694702148,
-0.08338111639022827,
0.7468783855438232,
-0.22231237590312958,
0.2806830406188965,
0.26315709948539734,
0.5211890935897827,
-0.23315195739269257,
-0.7687826156616211,
-0.21846720576286316,
0.45588943362236023,
-0.6748498678207397,
-0.17897969484329224,
-0.5352044105529785,
0.13142666220664978,
-0.16480490565299988,
-0.23522676527500153,
-0.18572953343391418,
-0.09907188266515732,
-0.5693258047103882,
-0.061914268881082535,
0.11374396085739136,
0.5264564752578735,
0.047262951731681824,
0.4773091971874237,
-0.7351019978523254,
0.010707048699259758,
0.15060262382030487,
-0.004559186287224293,
0.10856238752603531,
-0.4682398736476898,
-0.1393037587404251,
-0.12932394444942474,
-0.10119467228651047,
-0.7620339393615723,
0.4740679860115051,
0.01980503275990486,
0.7115359306335449,
0.5257241725921631,
0.016550809144973755,
0.23897409439086914,
-0.7577756643295288,
0.7563349604606628,
0.09052454680204391,
-0.8231461644172668,
0.7587877511978149,
-0.5540586709976196,
0.43480220437049866,
0.3966771364212036,
0.32552051544189453,
-0.45308125019073486,
-0.36804357171058655,
-0.15672749280929565,
-0.6117965579032898,
0.8525776863098145,
-0.10724889487028122,
0.30161139369010925,
-0.28426578640937805,
0.6772623658180237,
0.20974408090114594,
0.34253886342048645,
-0.6719624996185303,
-0.3094763159751892,
0.1868094801902771,
-0.20696359872817993,
0.01766449585556984,
-0.6134349703788757,
-0.09478583186864853,
0.20006756484508514,
0.692758321762085,
-0.41335761547088623,
0.17230869829654694,
0.14657188951969147,
0.04104669392108917,
-0.4885198175907135,
-0.052488576620817184,
0.7680675387382507,
0.48956212401390076,
-0.023333106189966202,
-0.2936190366744995,
0.03589148819446564,
-0.3363826274871826,
0.2806902527809143,
-0.12464629858732224,
-0.4535919427871704,
-0.15986303985118866,
0.49165159463882446,
0.8909435272216797,
0.04372667893767357,
-0.7800635099411011,
0.5733574628829956,
-0.05521079897880554,
0.13523244857788086,
-0.44942256808280945,
0.477145791053772,
-0.2416408210992813,
0.4897843897342682,
0.5484347939491272,
-0.1034708246588707,
0.3270844519138336,
-0.19568422436714172,
-0.1287480592727661,
0.8853248357772827,
-0.13716430962085724,
-0.35096031427383423,
0.8837736248970032,
0.3590107262134552,
-0.5627960562705994,
0.5002865195274353,
-0.22786350548267365,
-0.7085651159286499,
0.7280362844467163,
0.4630371630191803,
1.233046293258667,
-0.4475829303264618,
0.054503705352544785,
0.5035091638565063,
0.24203935265541077,
-0.275717556476593,
0.19142696261405945,
-0.03414011746644974,
-0.741213858127594,
-0.6907530426979065,
-0.6599542498588562,
-0.5436743497848511,
-0.3607211709022522,
-0.5128125548362732,
0.508375883102417,
-0.47247380018234253,
-0.16953931748867035,
-0.41773921251296997,
0.02403574250638485,
-0.5386574268341064,
0.2379724532365799,
0.06299611181020737,
0.8424400687217712,
-0.6557303071022034,
0.37870797514915466,
0.5358604192733765,
-0.2536567151546478,
-0.9784932732582092,
-0.07318277657032013,
0.14511650800704956,
-1.1895431280136108,
1.033300518989563,
0.2175290435552597,
-0.3272852301597595,
0.09179709106683731,
-0.7525244355201721,
-0.9867624044418335,
0.7552213668823242,
0.5203399658203125,
-0.8652824759483337,
-0.5454292893409729,
-0.10018056631088257,
0.406942754983902,
-0.5154612064361572,
0.3329561650753021,
0.29114675521850586,
0.6694067120552063,
0.074626624584198,
-1.018080472946167,
0.34388110041618347,
-0.02337030880153179,
0.17984554171562195,
0.28473326563835144,
-0.8490706086158752,
0.662557065486908,
-0.36879247426986694,
-0.029211822897195816,
0.09411672502756119,
0.44778624176979065,
0.31532084941864014,
0.15593352913856506,
0.5313601493835449,
0.15844067931175232,
0.553411066532135,
0.017590010538697243,
1.1026779413223267,
-0.4463924765586853,
0.1909230500459671,
0.878894031047821,
-0.41716131567955017,
0.2514379620552063,
0.6141095757484436,
-0.07212932407855988,
0.3918795585632324,
0.8170656561851501,
-0.3131502866744995,
0.5532197952270508,
0.3022501468658447,
-0.17290115356445312,
-0.49422189593315125,
-0.07984646409749985,
0.15112079679965973,
0.23448996245861053,
0.11903150379657745,
-0.3890989422798157,
-0.2285703718662262,
0.12098068743944168,
0.07626409828662872,
-0.07929705083370209,
-0.35332560539245605,
0.8638740181922913,
0.04937051609158516,
-0.9310921430587769,
0.5683218240737915,
-0.06059524789452553,
0.5915818214416504,
-0.6082000732421875,
0.15101009607315063,
-0.2966051995754242,
-0.19063521921634674,
-0.056866519153118134,
-0.3062978684902191,
-0.11307873576879501,
-0.06816861033439636,
0.01166590116918087,
-0.35250216722488403,
0.7593634724617004,
-0.17688441276550293,
-0.14225657284259796,
0.1957378387451172,
0.49475470185279846,
0.015129686333239079,
-0.10513032972812653,
-0.6289632320404053,
0.2337542027235031,
0.11264010518789291,
-0.6612820029258728,
0.04774695634841919,
0.5238522291183472,
-0.034421373158693314,
0.9953538179397583,
0.6668593883514404,
0.1505802571773529,
-0.15320362150669098,
0.027557488530874252,
0.7370997667312622,
-0.7935938239097595,
-0.463679701089859,
-1.2490382194519043,
0.4280623197555542,
0.07182225584983826,
-0.20165422558784485,
0.8912423849105835,
0.4363488554954529,
0.26864901185035706,
-0.11797548085451126,
0.6117581725120544,
0.5834845304489136,
0.6203135251998901,
-0.9344930052757263,
0.36592474579811096,
-0.5619983077049255,
0.3981529474258423,
-0.2690645754337311,
-1.4643751382827759,
-0.08476648479700089,
0.5189577341079712,
-0.4101186692714691,
0.26964545249938965,
0.6041704416275024,
0.9195752739906311,
0.373613566160202,
-0.10740956664085388,
0.18183103203773499,
0.1507319062948227,
0.44355669617652893,
0.3783867359161377,
1.0245001316070557,
0.22660525143146515,
0.3124215006828308,
0.032490186393260956,
-0.2245926707983017,
-0.39640381932258606,
-1.1626979112625122,
-1.0151206254959106,
-0.4660716950893402,
-0.4776804745197296,
-0.13478392362594604,
0.07120080292224884,
1.3384857177734375,
0.35731041431427,
-0.44530510902404785,
-0.11205888539552689,
-0.2788093090057373,
-0.0038842572830617428,
0.21188253164291382,
-0.25481462478637695,
0.3071901202201843,
-0.9314149022102356,
-0.7848864793777466,
0.6114035844802856,
0.2571038007736206,
0.2851032614707947,
-0.5637308955192566,
-0.10833480209112167,
0.3206389844417572,
0.33429524302482605,
0.39842861890792847,
0.2092898190021515,
-0.6895191669464111,
-0.16421537101268768,
0.3403257131576538,
-0.32476767897605896,
-0.010922503657639027,
0.8507638573646545,
-0.6476306915283203,
0.39465707540512085,
0.26743921637535095,
0.5248314738273621,
0.08540578186511993,
0.10181746631860733,
0.7716494202613831,
-0.49621301889419556,
-0.18058514595031738,
0.43133026361465454,
0.463224858045578,
0.36377012729644775,
-0.5814155340194702,
0.3256124258041382,
0.06660114228725433,
-0.7687705159187317,
-0.9714612364768982,
0.3488452434539795,
-0.7495630979537964,
-0.21453602612018585,
1.3979499340057373,
0.11558159440755844,
-0.5480703711509705,
0.2293621301651001,
-0.6380654573440552,
-0.010818852111697197,
-0.6569235920906067,
0.8872056007385254,
0.7991613149642944,
-0.4379001259803772,
-0.24747441709041595,
-0.41809454560279846,
0.8364954590797424,
0.5790854096412659,
-0.6115225553512573,
0.10492941737174988,
0.7973878383636475,
0.12787769734859467,
0.04549168050289154,
0.5233432650566101,
0.27994251251220703,
0.29960668087005615,
-0.3928338885307312,
-0.14036695659160614,
-0.15040604770183563,
-0.20509381592273712,
-0.6186651587486267,
-0.14005731046199799,
0.3916260302066803,
0.11076279729604721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02099v1 | Analyzing the Evaluation of Cross-Lingual Knowledge Transfer in Multilingual Language Models | 2024-02-03T09:41:52 | 2024-02-03T09:41:52 | Sara Rajaee, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in training multilingual language models on large datasets
seem to have shown promising results in knowledge transfer across languages and
achieve high performance on downstream tasks. However, we question to what
extent the current evaluation benchmarks and setups accurately measure
zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer. In this work, we challenge the
assumption that high zero-shot performance on target tasks reflects high
cross-lingual ability by introducing more challenging setups involving
instances with multiple languages. Through extensive experiments and analysis,
we show that the observed high performance of multilingual models can be
largely attributed to factors not requiring the transfer of actual linguistic
knowledge, such as task- and surface-level knowledge. More specifically, we
observe what has been transferred across languages is mostly data artifacts and
biases, especially for low-resource languages. Our findings highlight the
overlooked drawbacks of existing cross-lingual test data and evaluation setups,
calling for a more nuanced understanding of the cross-lingual capabilities of
multilingual models. | [
-0.3847842812538147,
-0.4352189004421234,
0.49056410789489746,
0.1911809742450714,
0.20179182291030884,
0.07172568142414093,
-0.3689529299736023,
-0.7117202877998352,
-0.11630620807409286,
0.2011975646018982,
-0.29628410935401917,
-0.19199854135513306,
-0.6970973610877991,
0.06516756117343903,
-0.36372771859169006,
0.9636102914810181,
-0.29490721225738525,
0.05242273584008217,
-0.15124595165252686,
-0.35321250557899475,
-0.4682271182537079,
-0.48987966775894165,
-0.17139483988285065,
-0.479256272315979,
0.6321495175361633,
0.4533490538597107,
0.5080137848854065,
0.32668885588645935,
0.16072455048561096,
0.08549769967794418,
0.31611305475234985,
-0.2791265845298767,
-0.6705823540687561,
-0.3036666214466095,
-0.498774915933609,
-0.4802844226360321,
-0.18948455154895782,
-0.03586013615131378,
0.8870285153388977,
1.125320553779602,
0.3257853090763092,
0.3505748212337494,
-0.06091129779815674,
0.3896050751209259,
-0.9284231662750244,
0.20338425040245056,
-0.5605945587158203,
0.3244132101535797,
-0.29217782616615295,
-0.08124394714832306,
-0.5278744101524353,
0.13812774419784546,
0.2419305443763733,
-0.7681166529655457,
0.06664203852415085,
-0.09703007340431213,
0.7726845741271973,
-0.16912245750427246,
-0.6877589225769043,
-0.09688962996006012,
-0.7806462049484253,
0.917957603931427,
-0.530352771282196,
0.5921100974082947,
0.12124549597501755,
0.42994144558906555,
0.4944763779640198,
-0.06384695321321487,
-0.4608888626098633,
-0.23345966637134552,
-0.11768071353435516,
0.052176907658576965,
-0.2601276934146881,
-0.37095242738723755,
0.29299768805503845,
0.10619481652975082,
-0.591443657875061,
0.2082878053188324,
-0.45667514204978943,
-0.17260242998600006,
0.5753393769264221,
-0.058593977242708206,
0.4614931344985962,
0.0456058643758297,
-0.5836021304130554,
-0.20750130712985992,
-0.5790854096412659,
0.2237478643655777,
0.2767391502857208,
0.5456738471984863,
-0.4418583810329437,
0.5011348724365234,
-0.37553009390830994,
0.6993470191955566,
-0.22905386984348297,
-0.08635293692350388,
0.29791930317878723,
-0.8012450933456421,
-0.011342920362949371,
-0.010872330516576767,
0.6245076060295105,
0.3370436131954193,
0.6573294997215271,
-0.6263748407363892,
0.03824960067868233,
-0.09981144219636917,
0.053944721817970276,
-0.6531869173049927,
0.07885721325874329,
-0.25082463026046753,
-0.13171087205410004,
-0.0030755598563700914,
-0.2948545813560486,
-0.7757962346076965,
-0.10522978752851486,
-0.15301907062530518,
0.5917374491691589,
-0.348929226398468,
-0.5262831449508667,
0.19963061809539795,
-0.2725847661495209,
0.3175751268863678,
0.19908669590950012,
-0.7390583753585815,
0.21224159002304077,
0.49162325263023376,
0.6135069727897644,
-0.41560226678848267,
-0.9519907236099243,
-0.42085257172584534,
0.15873277187347412,
-0.6323705911636353,
0.7769240140914917,
-0.4973384737968445,
-0.07711885124444962,
0.13449887931346893,
0.09935354441404343,
-0.7153341770172119,
-0.20261900126934052,
0.009930270723998547,
-0.25785985589027405,
0.1872304379940033,
-0.658610999584198,
-0.3220377564430237,
-0.2393045276403427,
0.3162757158279419,
-0.4986695945262909,
0.8296244740486145,
0.22314304113388062,
-0.6381917595863342,
0.6637891530990601,
-0.4935275614261627,
-0.7672276496887207,
-0.04701561853289604,
0.032495055347681046,
0.17902760207653046,
0.11945796757936478,
0.13868767023086548,
0.2992987334728241,
-0.3732469081878662,
0.00531671941280365,
-0.6150338649749756,
-0.4952390789985657,
0.18405185639858246,
-0.41193947196006775,
0.9167782068252563,
0.03258398175239563,
-0.5988675355911255,
-0.28631311655044556,
-0.6637612581253052,
0.13950768113136292,
-0.034938517957925797,
-0.2228778600692749,
-0.5230546593666077,
-0.7897042632102966,
0.11147062480449677,
0.583319365978241,
0.02864437736570835,
-0.5808484554290771,
0.09048199653625488,
0.026376618072390556,
-0.08648134768009186,
0.3443280756473541,
-0.32659250497817993,
0.743035078048706,
-0.3685365915298462,
0.7438851594924927,
0.01604188047349453,
-0.0835767313838005,
-0.08542005717754364,
-0.3418542444705963,
-0.6237478256225586,
0.07230975478887558,
0.39464569091796875,
0.6310386061668396,
-1.053248643875122,
-0.3348241448402405,
-0.5562780499458313,
-0.5528870820999146,
-0.5245087742805481,
0.2727051079273224,
0.7813728451728821,
0.5442325472831726,
0.23533467948436737,
-0.4775521159172058,
-0.06895246356725693,
-1.066860318183899,
-0.5007667541503906,
-0.07765918225049973,
0.3065657913684845,
0.33923429250717163,
0.44512802362442017,
0.31983208656311035,
0.36887726187705994,
0.14429378509521484,
-0.04292205721139908,
-0.3885018527507782,
0.3757895827293396,
-0.13462784886360168,
0.3507520258426666,
0.9583567380905151,
-0.32316985726356506,
-0.7464455962181091,
0.5867217183113098,
-0.907492458820343,
-0.24436327815055847,
-0.22107252478599548,
-0.24414823949337006,
0.38601234555244446,
0.15262553095817566,
-0.5203556418418884,
0.1489814966917038,
0.7912232875823975,
-0.34125861525535583,
0.7525302171707153,
-0.001739660743623972,
0.5126566886901855,
-0.6147730350494385,
0.4859350621700287,
-0.0140194958075881,
-0.03686258941888809,
-0.8556057214736938,
0.035448234528303146,
0.2194335162639618,
-0.01455289963632822,
-0.8796504139900208,
1.003353238105774,
-0.5443928837776184,
-0.5817195177078247,
0.07634225487709045,
0.15090693533420563,
0.1618894636631012,
0.6260749697685242,
0.17122112214565277,
0.7518311738967896,
0.7974364757537842,
-0.4157019257545471,
0.1496593952178955,
0.058791548013687134,
-0.42726802825927734,
1.1260288953781128,
-0.34736207127571106,
0.05878357216715813,
0.15224790573120117,
-0.1775018274784088,
-0.8056698441505432,
0.10868193209171295,
0.17593064904212952,
-0.22539100050926208,
0.4354258179664612,
-0.38601359724998474,
-0.19064739346504211,
0.019291618838906288,
-0.133962020277977,
0.7643113136291504,
0.28180715441703796,
-0.31236666440963745,
0.1403646171092987,
0.1196674033999443,
-0.12082143127918243,
-0.8625925183296204,
-0.9021620750427246,
0.16943766176700592,
-0.24858176708221436,
-0.5966507196426392,
0.14465194940567017,
0.14502598345279694,
-0.26866886019706726,
0.12271355837583542,
-0.022122716531157494,
-0.18031258881092072,
0.07517825067043304,
-0.17835211753845215,
0.07415987551212311,
-0.48501208424568176,
0.05837184563279152,
-0.12739185988903046,
0.06295908242464066,
0.055308613926172256,
-0.2671944200992584,
0.16281920671463013,
0.0046571106649935246,
-0.6968357563018799,
-0.08066786825656891,
0.2321661412715912,
0.7332607507705688,
-0.15149053931236267,
0.6382938027381897,
0.724317193031311,
-0.20795492827892303,
-0.213166281580925,
-0.45685234665870667,
0.20422928035259247,
-0.23813210427761078,
0.49178335070610046,
-0.8282268643379211,
-0.6272159814834595,
0.6748157143592834,
0.27181771397590637,
0.0631437748670578,
0.5082051753997803,
0.4753603935241699,
0.3046388328075409,
0.6943144798278809,
0.638961672782898,
-0.05288459360599518,
0.2615674138069153,
-0.12077917158603668,
0.18337592482566833,
-0.7054542303085327,
-0.07084251195192337,
-0.6058220267295837,
-0.15773944556713104,
-0.3783295452594757,
-0.40984171628952026,
0.0890139490365982,
0.032819561660289764,
-0.15086643397808075,
0.5484168529510498,
0.2117910087108612,
0.1834092140197754,
0.46364179253578186,
-0.3555050790309906,
0.4812295734882355,
0.10727932304143906,
-0.21570985019207,
0.016829289495944977,
-1.1887352466583252,
-0.1642422378063202,
1.2056461572647095,
0.1927311271429062,
0.6757517457008362,
-0.04227318987250328,
0.23832522332668304,
0.14834308624267578,
0.2655967175960541,
-0.5881720185279846,
0.162260040640831,
-0.19716347754001617,
-0.741399884223938,
-0.44335830211639404,
-0.5606747269630432,
-0.8451324701309204,
0.5592001676559448,
-0.07068368047475815,
-0.6559334397315979,
0.45044466853141785,
-0.27050021290779114,
-0.21607594192028046,
0.47833120822906494,
-0.7615095973014832,
1.2453818321228027,
-0.5267499685287476,
-0.5796016454696655,
-0.06036265566945076,
-0.2849915325641632,
0.4644419252872467,
-0.3480403423309326,
0.5868550539016724,
-0.20719662308692932,
0.15485763549804688,
0.6600199341773987,
0.15229493379592896,
0.6185523271560669,
-0.19165442883968353,
-0.41961848735809326,
-0.07723415642976761,
0.3359375596046448,
0.01512664183974266,
-0.22167588770389557,
-0.1630972921848297,
0.5204063057899475,
0.3553260862827301,
-0.7132327556610107,
-0.5867148637771606,
0.6159963011741638,
-0.6991627812385559,
-0.2554032504558563,
-0.23503056168556213,
-0.8729419112205505,
-0.48702576756477356,
0.30008813738822937,
0.19412513077259064,
0.31638020277023315,
-0.17441079020500183,
-0.033246465027332306,
0.19026823341846466,
-0.32601284980773926,
0.34195396304130554,
0.7692162990570068,
-0.32652342319488525,
-0.014542494900524616,
1.0121616125106812,
0.5152773261070251,
0.691955029964447,
0.2859317362308502,
-0.15912970900535583,
-0.25645893812179565,
-0.43868571519851685,
-1.139671802520752,
0.16348984837532043,
-0.7300889492034912,
0.16148990392684937,
-0.3433329164981842,
-0.021907180547714233,
-0.5703749656677246,
-0.130502387881279,
-0.671342134475708,
-0.590092122554779,
0.19261275231838226,
-0.04043395444750786,
-0.01587810553610325,
0.6697587370872498,
-0.31270670890808105,
-0.1181163638830185,
-0.8434257507324219,
0.19326046109199524,
0.19913604855537415,
0.43119093775749207,
0.17082157731056213,
-0.6940521001815796,
-0.6640698313713074,
0.23459620773792267,
0.19977828860282898,
-0.6947429180145264,
0.25760623812675476,
0.2717120051383972,
0.8659476637840271,
0.0013140677474439144,
0.0059770080260932446,
0.8077411651611328,
-0.3335427939891815,
0.7040761113166809,
0.07116714119911194,
-0.9442978501319885,
0.04968906566500664,
-0.1975736767053604,
0.39301708340644836,
0.5243851542472839,
0.4706443250179291,
-0.7201988101005554,
-0.1756768673658371,
-0.4059608280658722,
-0.44754084944725037,
0.8931108713150024,
-0.042949188500642776,
0.09647533297538757,
0.43934085965156555,
-0.016654938459396362,
0.4432046115398407,
0.1594189554452896,
-0.7845911979675293,
-0.03984058275818825,
-0.001442079315893352,
0.42597803473472595,
-0.3053513467311859,
0.02310708723962307,
-0.13826505839824677,
-0.06657934188842773,
0.5702010989189148,
-0.34359779953956604,
0.07209105789661407,
-0.033476974815130234,
-0.5777254700660706,
-0.3732421100139618,
0.47998449206352234,
0.5094874501228333,
0.8959987163543701,
-0.00432477705180645,
0.19635899364948273,
0.47191092371940613,
-0.05135500058531761,
0.2564135491847992,
0.21641236543655396,
-0.1917344033718109,
-0.04561605304479599,
0.8539103269577026,
0.9855342507362366,
0.6749427914619446,
-0.4216999411582947,
0.5400255918502808,
0.10016447305679321,
-0.23836928606033325,
0.18593518435955048,
-0.22670534253120422,
-0.16495001316070557,
0.05019187554717064,
0.2590523958206177,
-0.09755049645900726,
0.04147469997406006,
-0.7658464908599854,
0.18812482059001923,
0.502572774887085,
-0.5651951432228088,
-0.6719884872436523,
0.2994973957538605,
-0.05069824680685997,
0.18368013203144073,
0.44939249753952026,
-0.06000363081693649,
-0.5047347545623779,
0.5104817748069763,
0.3960244357585907,
0.5844888687133789,
-0.20393455028533936,
0.36394768953323364,
0.3031242787837982,
0.47498780488967896,
0.07550862431526184,
0.08483999967575073,
-0.21391551196575165,
-0.723823606967926,
-0.7264347076416016,
-0.5927301049232483,
-0.42691853642463684,
-0.015596890822052956,
-0.7708828449249268,
0.20483216643333435,
0.15399965643882751,
0.20898112654685974,
0.09644439816474915,
-0.1276812106370926,
-0.9692569971084595,
-0.044956862926483154,
0.3100802004337311,
0.9131451845169067,
-1.2283132076263428,
0.8580999374389648,
0.5564055442810059,
-0.39510107040405273,
-0.5814897418022156,
-0.28176674246788025,
-0.14612796902656555,
-1.0236238241195679,
0.7669769525527954,
0.06271692365407944,
-0.0431419312953949,
-0.3482609987258911,
0.255708783864975,
-0.8001384139060974,
0.7446539998054504,
0.6866326928138733,
-0.33599579334259033,
-0.10150374472141266,
0.647377073764801,
0.6484471559524536,
-0.3923238217830658,
0.4526434540748596,
0.5019196271896362,
0.7370696067810059,
0.04211430996656418,
-1.6540851593017578,
0.10671146214008331,
-0.3926364481449127,
-0.061781324446201324,
-0.15116731822490692,
-0.472198486328125,
0.9224115610122681,
-0.17957210540771484,
-0.17077378928661346,
-0.31251969933509827,
0.04797967150807381,
-0.12608763575553894,
0.43269601464271545,
0.2943750023841858,
0.6603103280067444,
0.2721705436706543,
0.0015435854438692331,
1.284206509590149,
-0.42007890343666077,
0.3175109922885895,
0.929908037185669,
-0.6745394468307495,
0.737125039100647,
0.5398837327957153,
-0.1438826322555542,
0.30033183097839355,
0.31795963644981384,
0.021676965057849884,
0.43916064500808716,
0.0038669067434966564,
0.09486261755228043,
-0.35221067070961,
-0.3433722257614136,
-0.48587411642074585,
0.6457816362380981,
-0.08544538915157318,
-0.08345460146665573,
-0.607811689376831,
0.23632773756980896,
-0.03996821865439415,
-0.1871604472398758,
-0.12995266914367676,
0.6069441437721252,
-0.04900438338518143,
-0.9330183863639832,
0.9625272154808044,
-0.2803085446357727,
0.6110854148864746,
-0.3471297323703766,
-0.09370917081832886,
-0.26977774500846863,
0.09566117078065872,
-0.10489106923341751,
-0.8273043036460876,
0.5086260437965393,
-0.030599994584918022,
0.049708738923072815,
-0.47909241914749146,
0.7206038236618042,
-0.6243063807487488,
-0.4664103388786316,
0.7393177151679993,
1.1634601354599,
0.342009037733078,
-0.04557738080620766,
-0.5422794222831726,
-0.1421891301870346,
-0.0718037337064743,
-0.15855735540390015,
0.7096051573753357,
0.6128049492835999,
-0.16617469489574432,
0.3229537606239319,
0.6772596836090088,
0.34374916553497314,
0.31076982617378235,
0.17346297204494476,
0.3539152145385742,
-0.41748467087745667,
-0.10286802798509598,
-0.5925929546356201,
0.4044520854949951,
0.21316049993038177,
-0.39100417494773865,
1.0751547813415527,
0.5787137746810913,
1.3735705614089966,
-0.1143326461315155,
1.046893835067749,
-0.039194751530885696,
0.26538267731666565,
-0.40421262383461,
0.8289827704429626,
-0.7717068195343018,
0.026089735329151154,
-0.19849124550819397,
-0.7620477676391602,
-0.041135597974061966,
0.3408316373825073,
-0.5313156843185425,
0.14516058564186096,
0.5872569680213928,
0.45744967460632324,
-0.27398911118507385,
-0.3207651674747467,
0.8152605295181274,
0.06351159512996674,
0.03285457566380501,
0.9295789003372192,
0.8622767329216003,
-0.49685239791870117,
0.6565437912940979,
-0.6420581340789795,
-0.16198451817035675,
-0.0681794136762619,
-0.8493860363960266,
-0.8824228048324585,
-0.509976863861084,
-0.28929269313812256,
-0.028631936758756638,
0.30597588419914246,
0.17464832961559296,
0.8789324760437012,
-0.8364034295082092,
-0.7076764702796936,
0.30977487564086914,
0.2065380960702896,
-0.428959459066391,
-0.2172018438577652,
0.15191711485385895,
-0.5018025636672974,
-0.6345988512039185,
0.4587065875530243,
0.15242213010787964,
-0.13499078154563904,
-0.42912018299102783,
-0.11751966178417206,
-0.34079018235206604,
-0.16550683975219727,
0.5676119327545166,
0.47727736830711365,
-0.5429754853248596,
-0.3124557435512543,
0.29134076833724976,
-0.09576237946748734,
-0.10771417617797852,
0.688491940498352,
-0.6683481335639954,
0.3680582642555237,
0.5171230435371399,
0.6603551506996155,
0.6436334252357483,
-0.45904475450515747,
0.7624208331108093,
-0.5881317257881165,
0.006555300205945969,
-0.19859224557876587,
0.42810264229774475,
0.4930560290813446,
-0.05887234956026077,
0.5928491353988647,
0.2534044682979584,
-0.08877632766962051,
-0.9782374501228333,
-0.06458357721567154,
-0.5626373887062073,
-0.25440582633018494,
1.196897268295288,
-0.5490597486495972,
-0.0961701050400734,
-0.13168752193450928,
0.2779257297515869,
0.21799004077911377,
0.0921848863363266,
0.5954285860061646,
1.0015169382095337,
-0.1758948117494583,
-0.28402596712112427,
-0.8202218413352966,
0.169956773519516,
0.6017167568206787,
-0.8319145441055298,
0.26438236236572266,
0.3254997730255127,
0.47507134079933167,
0.4518318772315979,
0.36709076166152954,
-0.16062666475772858,
0.5111680626869202,
0.21992170810699463,
0.0734381303191185,
-0.035259686410427094,
-0.4784581959247589,
-0.5055986642837524,
0.2008114904165268,
0.011883608065545559,
0.0818122997879982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02084v1 | Revisiting the Markov Property for Machine Translation | 2024-02-03T08:50:50 | 2024-02-03T08:50:50 | Cunxiao Du, Hao Zhou, Zhaopeng Tu, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we re-examine the Markov property in the context of neural
machine translation. We design a Markov Autoregressive Transformer~(MAT) and
undertake a comprehensive assessment of its performance across four WMT
benchmarks. Our findings indicate that MAT with an order larger than 4 can
generate translations with quality on par with that of conventional
autoregressive transformers. In addition, counter-intuitively, we also find
that the advantages of utilizing a higher-order MAT do not specifically
contribute to the translation of longer sentences. | [
-0.5028083920478821,
-0.31956809759140015,
0.4047628343105316,
0.33003637194633484,
-0.4064427316188812,
-0.002861121203750372,
-0.13061216473579407,
-0.2713613510131836,
-0.032683923840522766,
0.2739218473434448,
-0.4453122615814209,
-0.20276105403900146,
-1.0931540727615356,
-0.12682068347930908,
-0.69244384765625,
1.0127075910568237,
-0.23035173118114471,
-0.1447816640138626,
0.14097079634666443,
-0.3568231761455536,
-0.547103762626648,
-0.40778276324272156,
-0.26523029804229736,
-0.5427882671356201,
0.7406408786773682,
-0.09669134020805359,
1.246128797531128,
1.019667387008667,
0.9523925185203552,
0.33658668398857117,
0.24621997773647308,
-0.023086540400981903,
0.005845009349286556,
0.5226062536239624,
-0.023887889459729195,
-0.6041036248207092,
-0.6485140919685364,
0.33886533975601196,
0.7010946273803711,
0.5561840534210205,
-0.2928367257118225,
0.43868139386177063,
-0.19335882365703583,
0.9513417482376099,
-0.4809166193008423,
0.1766045242547989,
-0.7068791389465332,
0.45184484124183655,
-0.010671391151845455,
-0.3382677137851715,
-0.6623144149780273,
-0.29005658626556396,
-0.1756390631198883,
-0.13481123745441437,
0.1406962126493454,
0.1516476571559906,
0.8162972331047058,
0.8616895079612732,
-0.8454127907752991,
0.27935609221458435,
-0.9857147932052612,
0.8930127024650574,
-0.49237850308418274,
0.6252989172935486,
0.17726445198059082,
0.8637455105781555,
-0.19138410687446594,
-0.8294810056686401,
-0.5102046132087708,
-0.1205608919262886,
-0.07377675175666809,
0.3471182584762573,
-0.3757123649120331,
-0.2423098236322403,
0.412552148103714,
0.5895763635635376,
-0.4775836765766144,
0.1794041097164154,
-0.18289892375469208,
0.06589401513338089,
0.6105453372001648,
0.7080814838409424,
0.16703039407730103,
-0.025815315544605255,
-0.39192456007003784,
-0.5058382749557495,
-0.2577805519104004,
-0.08642593026161194,
0.37420588731765747,
-0.1591874659061432,
0.3858252167701721,
0.9113438129425049,
-0.051802750676870346,
0.7229759097099304,
-0.17098860442638397,
-0.13436278700828552,
0.32748153805732727,
-0.31972813606262207,
-0.12163667380809784,
-0.0137849822640419,
1.0193626880645752,
0.3885420560836792,
0.09334112703800201,
-0.17818473279476166,
-0.49519237875938416,
0.11120683699846268,
0.5428667068481445,
-0.9290373921394348,
-0.5185742378234863,
-0.19088272750377655,
-0.6560533046722412,
0.054423484951257706,
-0.08845402300357819,
-0.46002477407455444,
0.054850973188877106,
-0.3540860712528229,
0.6126871705055237,
-0.3581171929836273,
-0.1626746952533722,
0.07216670364141464,
-0.17891503870487213,
0.2955438792705536,
0.2603522539138794,
-0.6086382269859314,
0.4017527401447296,
0.44239357113838196,
0.7425696849822998,
-0.44031456112861633,
-0.346718966960907,
-0.34482550621032715,
-0.1471993774175644,
-0.6891792416572571,
0.48820915818214417,
-0.34034502506256104,
-0.19332221150398254,
-0.34771060943603516,
-0.10324390977621078,
-0.23982489109039307,
-0.44995367527008057,
0.1192675456404686,
-0.6591939926147461,
0.36255431175231934,
0.013655174523591995,
-0.03472398966550827,
-0.057190004736185074,
-0.11042306572198868,
-0.4061424732208252,
0.9626253843307495,
0.30926716327667236,
-0.3791225552558899,
0.599561333656311,
-0.5932968854904175,
-0.7756137847900391,
-0.41556403040885925,
0.11117663979530334,
-0.6493097543716431,
0.2166023552417755,
-0.028236988931894302,
0.5834274888038635,
-0.21411661803722382,
0.41450488567352295,
0.0939914658665657,
-0.1144055426120758,
0.9330313801765442,
-0.9462865591049194,
0.39487889409065247,
0.7928789258003235,
-0.4799686670303345,
-0.03832729905843735,
-0.9381605982780457,
-0.04516008868813515,
0.1483958214521408,
-0.6471399664878845,
0.26735585927963257,
0.16129860281944275,
-0.10548745840787888,
0.9295908212661743,
0.07858194410800934,
-0.4477979242801666,
0.23547229170799255,
-0.14360488951206207,
0.5490102171897888,
0.47375816106796265,
0.028145575895905495,
0.7306185364723206,
-0.40146157145500183,
0.6382271647453308,
0.3684430420398712,
0.10873367637395859,
-0.38752010464668274,
-0.8500117063522339,
-0.9614977836608887,
-0.40873414278030396,
0.21132822334766388,
0.30004647374153137,
-0.5571777820587158,
0.468860387802124,
-0.23932211101055145,
-0.49784594774246216,
-0.918918788433075,
-0.10877085477113724,
0.3867287039756775,
0.4167810380458832,
0.7784818410873413,
-0.4431454539299011,
-0.44949981570243835,
-1.2970128059387207,
-0.36971718072891235,
-0.03418557345867157,
-0.1970696896314621,
0.07921437174081802,
0.1639200896024704,
-0.3158743381500244,
0.5435801148414612,
-0.5521853566169739,
-0.14947162568569183,
0.011547676287591457,
0.39492297172546387,
0.5214595794677734,
0.6744009256362915,
0.2631871700286865,
-0.4935707449913025,
-0.3800167739391327,
-0.014023040421307087,
-0.3161998689174652,
-0.015533758327364922,
-0.2823152542114258,
-0.18883661925792694,
0.45922794938087463,
0.2559291422367096,
-0.9740990996360779,
0.5779679417610168,
0.3883226215839386,
-0.04995986446738243,
0.025232136249542236,
-0.4542721211910248,
0.2329391986131668,
-1.3682456016540527,
0.1555631309747696,
-0.13062551617622375,
-0.5223186612129211,
-0.2953319847583771,
-0.19347158074378967,
0.22604240477085114,
0.010273818857967854,
-0.6087923645973206,
-0.20062898099422455,
-0.5475233793258667,
-0.5476775765419006,
-0.3322616219520569,
-0.2059299647808075,
-0.10141929984092712,
0.36743399500846863,
-0.27735817432403564,
0.8732960224151611,
-0.055865317583084106,
-0.8022317290306091,
0.1756737381219864,
0.3167831599712372,
-0.4149044156074524,
0.6507743000984192,
-0.429371178150177,
0.004677558783441782,
-0.03818877041339874,
0.1850464940071106,
-1.0574250221252441,
0.2813909947872162,
0.01991204172372818,
-0.7897847294807434,
0.4974920153617859,
-0.23042069375514984,
-0.7935096621513367,
-0.5205538868904114,
0.3045940697193146,
0.21446926891803741,
1.197755217552185,
-0.3859357535839081,
0.14983421564102173,
0.2614949345588684,
0.4132465124130249,
-0.5550187230110168,
-0.9733356833457947,
0.31722524762153625,
-0.22170110046863556,
-0.3868965208530426,
0.10068827867507935,
-0.07835692912340164,
-0.05866283178329468,
-0.23570168018341064,
-0.021897947415709496,
0.033755671232938766,
0.3421134352684021,
0.2498968541622162,
-0.008402650244534016,
-0.6503876447677612,
-0.08141887187957764,
-0.07200813293457031,
-0.6624865531921387,
0.4188392460346222,
-0.704937219619751,
0.563084602355957,
0.024882884696125984,
-0.32315269112586975,
-0.496665358543396,
0.16959108412265778,
0.9779787659645081,
-0.33455953001976013,
0.7681068778038025,
0.8715523481369019,
-0.22001489996910095,
-0.06733667850494385,
-0.3310711979866028,
0.07776849716901779,
-0.5069612860679626,
0.37578144669532776,
-0.5952280759811401,
-0.2954312860965729,
0.3559128940105438,
0.19543133676052094,
0.0286715105175972,
0.9713104963302612,
0.8462353348731995,
-0.3087743818759918,
1.5116019248962402,
0.29030489921569824,
-0.10268782824277878,
0.4609357416629791,
-0.31305065751075745,
0.3581083416938782,
-1.0096851587295532,
-0.3118796646595001,
-0.5126848816871643,
-1.0170929431915283,
-0.7837126851081848,
-0.23293960094451904,
-0.027835195884108543,
-0.2526693344116211,
-0.40292516350746155,
1.0021517276763916,
-0.565159022808075,
0.1548186093568802,
0.508156955242157,
-0.2960129678249359,
0.21166366338729858,
-0.3630288243293762,
-0.10243663191795349,
-0.39920252561569214,
-0.6679543852806091,
-0.39819464087486267,
0.6883977055549622,
0.3957805931568146,
0.7539271712303162,
0.3431903123855591,
0.4124405086040497,
0.12093448638916016,
0.11156307905912399,
-0.8327187299728394,
0.5155901312828064,
0.12264149636030197,
-0.5143615007400513,
-0.2228221893310547,
-0.5070252418518066,
-1.3826727867126465,
0.6058085560798645,
-0.2018919587135315,
-0.4738383889198303,
0.048462361097335815,
-0.003162406850606203,
0.18524594604969025,
0.4406881630420685,
-0.46640413999557495,
0.7963500618934631,
-0.2501966655254364,
0.00821959599852562,
-0.17779874801635742,
-0.8125219345092773,
0.21260914206504822,
-0.08159364014863968,
-0.23148709535598755,
-0.33152496814727783,
-0.3087345361709595,
0.5326572060585022,
-0.4569629430770874,
0.25012657046318054,
-0.060457900166511536,
-0.025228159502148628,
0.014127086848020554,
0.6475071907043457,
0.22419308125972748,
-0.15515407919883728,
0.13903367519378662,
-0.17517787218093872,
-0.28906217217445374,
-0.2867680788040161,
-0.7012342810630798,
0.6089780330657959,
-0.850974977016449,
-0.628975510597229,
-0.298721045255661,
-0.8908039927482605,
-0.049958325922489166,
0.36162179708480835,
0.2832314372062683,
0.33710864186286926,
0.06041649729013443,
0.15743771195411682,
0.4723799526691437,
0.14439496397972107,
0.9992393851280212,
0.5226609110832214,
-0.26209914684295654,
-0.4120703339576721,
0.9157935976982117,
0.5423876047134399,
0.3821515440940857,
0.4075869917869568,
0.021730460226535797,
-0.25945213437080383,
-0.6913296580314636,
-0.7223796248435974,
-0.05683702230453491,
-0.7125935554504395,
-0.4622969925403595,
-1.1233443021774292,
-0.2971741557121277,
-0.1296202540397644,
0.08169961720705032,
-0.7532469034194946,
-1.1093995571136475,
-0.2085321843624115,
0.03641384094953537,
0.3142749071121216,
1.0069212913513184,
0.17665991187095642,
0.23951956629753113,
-0.9097029566764832,
0.3572275936603546,
0.1562364548444748,
0.17731471359729767,
-0.3499923050403595,
-0.9274020195007324,
-0.19652482867240906,
-0.13285861909389496,
-0.6088674068450928,
-0.6900482177734375,
0.7997593879699707,
0.010916518978774548,
0.6612896919250488,
0.16078150272369385,
-0.06495963037014008,
0.6324326992034912,
-1.0054086446762085,
0.7229458093643188,
0.3084128201007843,
-0.7355592250823975,
0.3962594270706177,
-0.37091514468193054,
0.4806068241596222,
0.21990980207920074,
0.3859083354473114,
-0.4853731691837311,
-0.38803789019584656,
-0.9041435122489929,
-0.7860162854194641,
0.3192490041255951,
0.49730169773101807,
0.24930652976036072,
-0.06693609803915024,
0.31916099786758423,
0.10651051998138428,
0.6143892407417297,
-0.260567307472229,
-0.4916953444480896,
-0.42787104845046997,
-0.136990487575531,
-0.6383264660835266,
0.04027516767382622,
0.39756110310554504,
-0.30233368277549744,
0.529414176940918,
0.08839965611696243,
0.5767521858215332,
0.09349861741065979,
-0.3787365257740021,
-0.15624283254146576,
0.3308708667755127,
0.81672203540802,
0.6614075303077698,
-0.19019727408885956,
0.6191428303718567,
0.31263020634651184,
-0.2310325652360916,
0.5092880725860596,
-0.2063020020723343,
0.16132141649723053,
0.13496656715869904,
-0.08805891126394272,
0.5896480679512024,
-0.010788720101118088,
0.22219106554985046,
0.4426649808883667,
-0.115074522793293,
-0.2418946772813797,
-0.12137563526630402,
0.2444401979446411,
0.050203483551740646,
0.22383008897304535,
0.13845983147621155,
0.6581095457077026,
0.16519783437252045,
-0.3685886859893799,
0.5302650332450867,
0.24391712248325348,
-0.5735682249069214,
-0.5730897188186646,
0.9639659523963928,
-0.27499818801879883,
-0.8680729866027832,
0.8306215405464172,
0.0805031880736351,
-0.6089614629745483,
0.5428884029388428,
0.8897433280944824,
0.7521342635154724,
-0.4588581323623657,
-0.19204749166965485,
0.207220196723938,
0.642151951789856,
-0.05790824070572853,
-0.0523516982793808,
-0.22982987761497498,
-0.1962081491947174,
-0.2858162522315979,
-0.3771129250526428,
-0.22645629942417145,
-0.3364379405975342,
-0.9697011113166809,
-0.05216153338551521,
-0.276968389749527,
-0.6095575094223022,
-0.0636729970574379,
-0.2895008623600006,
-0.9136869311332703,
0.34966611862182617,
-0.2668704092502594,
0.694522500038147,
-0.6230188012123108,
1.236221432685852,
0.4728779196739197,
-0.39362993836402893,
-0.2101217806339264,
-0.2201787680387497,
-0.25671347975730896,
-0.896971583366394,
0.8328710198402405,
0.06816825270652771,
-0.06604625284671783,
0.2002960741519928,
-0.17935490608215332,
-1.0468571186065674,
1.1780455112457275,
0.2585635781288147,
-0.21290016174316406,
0.40147459506988525,
0.446285605430603,
0.8546605110168457,
-0.39354586601257324,
0.16510999202728271,
0.6466143131256104,
0.35563206672668457,
-0.1725384145975113,
-0.7782047390937805,
-0.006189819425344467,
-0.2822328805923462,
0.46253544092178345,
0.655955970287323,
-0.6032889485359192,
0.7171216607093811,
-0.05686337873339653,
-0.15910041332244873,
-0.11521873623132706,
0.9214609861373901,
-0.5217995047569275,
-0.12551116943359375,
0.14366039633750916,
0.622814416885376,
0.5144187211990356,
-0.1996249109506607,
1.2217011451721191,
-0.2834455072879791,
0.1525307148694992,
1.0324938297271729,
-0.0628054216504097,
1.0795788764953613,
0.6666246652603149,
-0.30677488446235657,
0.4177546203136444,
0.39622896909713745,
-0.0795205682516098,
0.5760598182678223,
0.6217683553695679,
0.13436369597911835,
-0.2309824675321579,
0.22083666920661926,
-0.3668067455291748,
0.22058838605880737,
0.19228358566761017,
-0.6314914226531982,
0.1672656536102295,
-0.08514759689569473,
-0.07242050766944885,
0.06531907618045807,
-0.0020962199196219444,
0.7895009517669678,
0.4432404637336731,
-0.8230372071266174,
0.587748646736145,
0.12143303453922272,
0.2550372779369354,
-0.037790052592754364,
-0.02148941531777382,
-0.04597853124141693,
0.44711047410964966,
0.013967406004667282,
-0.9726060628890991,
0.6594838500022888,
-0.32629913091659546,
-0.3206162750720978,
-0.6312628388404846,
0.4810536503791809,
-0.35404691100120544,
-0.21952024102210999,
0.09082139283418655,
0.43624603748321533,
0.3633647561073303,
0.3438579738140106,
-0.619475245475769,
-0.28373074531555176,
-0.499148964881897,
-0.4796733260154724,
0.4475620985031128,
0.5623226761817932,
0.2690691649913788,
0.8650544285774231,
0.6482959389686584,
-0.25265616178512573,
0.457942932844162,
-0.2767072916030884,
0.5570619106292725,
-0.8479122519493103,
-0.1419411301612854,
-0.851243257522583,
0.6204096078872681,
0.26985234022140503,
-0.3023015558719635,
0.8590614795684814,
0.6442991495132446,
0.5935887694358826,
-0.0052861557342112064,
0.41146600246429443,
0.4424765706062317,
-0.080086849629879,
-0.494040846824646,
0.9940894842147827,
-0.2460043579339981,
0.1092449203133583,
0.030406735837459564,
-1.3851070404052734,
-0.41548076272010803,
0.6644365191459656,
-0.01579415239393711,
-0.03142708167433739,
1.045986294746399,
0.3906440734863281,
-0.11023341119289398,
-0.3220735490322113,
0.8638612031936646,
0.18585531413555145,
0.3960669934749603,
0.6560347080230713,
1.1916447877883911,
-0.9964709281921387,
0.5694803595542908,
-0.09336342662572861,
0.24529463052749634,
0.15003785490989685,
-0.8871095180511475,
-1.0859564542770386,
-0.7553152441978455,
-0.4420250654220581,
-0.7085191011428833,
-0.1775130033493042,
0.8673019409179688,
0.5663173794746399,
-0.5247517228126526,
-0.04880036786198616,
0.0016054153675213456,
-0.03920821473002434,
-0.18149447441101074,
-0.10870278626680374,
0.19226567447185516,
-0.5447861552238464,
-0.579439640045166,
0.46653446555137634,
0.2998756468296051,
0.33862626552581787,
-0.2630660831928253,
-0.2111617475748062,
-0.03963092342019081,
0.20182882249355316,
0.5146142244338989,
-0.22238217294216156,
-0.44027411937713623,
-0.19871081411838531,
0.15257582068443298,
-0.5303836464881897,
0.7968364953994751,
0.923700213432312,
-0.7544847726821899,
0.21686968207359314,
0.6136818528175354,
0.8947380185127258,
0.83028244972229,
-0.4139731228351593,
0.726828932762146,
-0.38067635893821716,
-0.09337922930717468,
0.15935373306274414,
0.6053043007850647,
0.10404293984174728,
-0.18560510873794556,
0.3062492609024048,
0.1389952450990677,
-0.6818916201591492,
-0.5275091528892517,
0.2307307869195938,
-0.8840143084526062,
0.1533384770154953,
1.0766549110412598,
-0.019309084862470627,
-0.35512059926986694,
-0.1045479103922844,
-0.07541635632514954,
0.46845147013664246,
-0.29188477993011475,
0.5300706624984741,
0.3899695575237274,
-0.017469752579927444,
-0.19819924235343933,
-0.7616252303123474,
0.25637656450271606,
0.6151333451271057,
-0.48275068402290344,
-0.2254962921142578,
0.08292447775602341,
0.1191086694598198,
0.15944042801856995,
0.2911369204521179,
-0.5066715478897095,
0.30877792835235596,
-0.21935461461544037,
0.01827504299581051,
-0.2738476097583771,
-0.3823801279067993,
-0.5155868530273438,
-0.030818050727248192,
0.26202917098999023,
-0.5441433787345886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02082v1 | GliDe with a CaPE: A Low-Hassle Method to Accelerate Speculative Decoding | 2024-02-03T08:44:11 | 2024-02-03T08:44:11 | Cunxiao Du, Jing Jiang, Xu Yuanchen, Jiawei Wu, Sicheng Yu, Yongqi Li, Shenggui Li, Kai Xu, Liqiang Nie, Zhaopeng Tu, Yang You | cs.CL | cs.CL | Speculative decoding is a relatively new decoding framework that leverages
small and efficient draft models to reduce the latency of LLMs. In this study,
we introduce GliDe and CaPE, two low-hassle modifications to vanilla
speculative decoding to further improve the decoding speed of a frozen LLM.
Specifically, GliDe is a modified draft model architecture that reuses the
cached keys and values from the target LLM, while CaPE is a proposal expansion
method that uses the draft model's confidence scores to help select additional
candidate tokens for verification. Extensive experiments on different
benchmarks demonstrate that our proposed GliDe draft model significantly
reduces the expected decoding latency. Additional evaluation using walltime
reveals that GliDe can accelerate Vicuna models up to 2.17x and further extend
the improvement to 2.61x with CaPE. We will release our code, data, and the
trained draft models. | [
-0.09835401922464371,
-0.7055150270462036,
0.2959931492805481,
0.17567528784275055,
-0.30347657203674316,
0.4520198106765747,
0.21345776319503784,
-0.8229902386665344,
0.5455820560455322,
0.8096303939819336,
-0.5072376728057861,
-0.3503072261810303,
-0.7614864706993103,
-0.19732072949409485,
-0.3404105305671692,
0.441023051738739,
0.015498178079724312,
-0.23791557550430298,
0.141676664352417,
0.2592819929122925,
0.0115653770044446,
-0.7049031257629395,
-0.5477956533432007,
0.04128970205783844,
0.36851394176483154,
0.537407636642456,
0.902370035648346,
0.8916832804679871,
0.5600808262825012,
0.18372178077697754,
-0.3446658253669739,
0.2911383807659149,
-0.8442596197128296,
-0.0870693251490593,
0.45914116501808167,
-0.6751487255096436,
-0.968230664730072,
-0.3135284185409546,
0.3717919886112213,
0.6287134289741516,
-0.069972462952137,
0.004059358034282923,
-0.22357672452926636,
0.8861111998558044,
-1.2525451183319092,
-0.168867826461792,
-0.5821780562400818,
-0.18501722812652588,
-0.5002986192703247,
-0.4238930642604828,
-0.44886282086372375,
-0.2138185203075409,
-0.06311944872140884,
-0.798882246017456,
0.3163287043571472,
0.2598075568675995,
0.6978650093078613,
-0.1235225722193718,
-0.44632482528686523,
-0.12568166851997375,
-0.5654832720756531,
0.6654517650604248,
-0.6149511337280273,
0.6784302592277527,
0.4508965313434601,
0.27860939502716064,
-0.13410179316997528,
-1.0137596130371094,
-0.24925772845745087,
-0.22147917747497559,
0.4310864508152008,
0.06739059835672379,
-0.15375901758670807,
0.1434817612171173,
0.21915023028850555,
0.4561655521392822,
-0.12369783967733383,
0.27743494510650635,
-0.5324554443359375,
-0.6202319860458374,
0.5532305836677551,
0.4035874307155609,
-0.1358252316713333,
-0.15102703869342804,
-0.5844913721084595,
0.008950736373662949,
-0.7037182450294495,
0.3807559907436371,
0.4092344045639038,
0.5123273730278015,
-0.6486479043960571,
0.5211896300315857,
-0.33492806553840637,
0.626961886882782,
0.14746315777301788,
-0.12547534704208374,
0.18432371318340302,
-0.13843439519405365,
-0.18962311744689941,
-0.023084286600351334,
0.08938310295343399,
0.522735059261322,
-0.3980181813240051,
-0.18492713570594788,
-0.23452581465244293,
0.11030758917331696,
-0.02010772004723549,
-0.8704671859741211,
-0.24033904075622559,
0.21784047782421112,
-0.8172793388366699,
-0.24302636086940765,
-0.1531534045934677,
-0.7195830941200256,
-0.35066333413124084,
-0.016113879159092903,
-0.021554328501224518,
-0.5916115641593933,
-0.42309868335723877,
0.7101004719734192,
-0.3046920597553253,
0.23376332223415375,
0.5691927671432495,
-1.0259207487106323,
0.5650628805160522,
0.9293544888496399,
0.8546655774116516,
-0.32833731174468994,
-0.1610032618045807,
-0.9146362543106079,
0.07921317964792252,
-0.7000171542167664,
1.0076764822006226,
-0.6483834981918335,
-0.7530088424682617,
0.19263991713523865,
-0.4481414556503296,
0.10899447649717331,
-0.030952321365475655,
0.6710138916969299,
-0.9660384654998779,
-0.3064926266670227,
-0.834571123123169,
-0.6114141941070557,
-0.2572295367717743,
0.2375168800354004,
-0.7837686538696289,
0.8055782914161682,
0.2987005114555359,
-0.662566065788269,
0.5984175205230713,
-0.4315762519836426,
-0.4021138548851013,
0.19611641764640808,
0.1364477574825287,
0.16640624403953552,
0.3437209129333496,
0.3140859305858612,
0.09719729423522949,
-0.49223363399505615,
-0.6664433479309082,
-0.2560482323169708,
-0.8672863245010376,
-0.14448507130146027,
-0.39895376563072205,
0.5351781249046326,
0.5346415638923645,
0.16558484733104706,
-0.3086015284061432,
-0.7369426488876343,
0.23340556025505066,
-0.47969934344291687,
-0.6641080379486084,
-0.05893869698047638,
-0.09111802279949188,
0.17517352104187012,
-0.2809872329235077,
0.2945346534252167,
-0.25287434458732605,
0.5374250411987305,
-0.573082685470581,
-0.03861973434686661,
0.44323480129241943,
0.2652023136615753,
0.6467843651771545,
-0.4485173523426056,
0.7016523480415344,
0.08025023341178894,
0.2914547324180603,
-0.08214086294174194,
-0.4577898383140564,
-0.8853380680084229,
-0.5475374460220337,
0.3129144012928009,
0.3492880165576935,
-0.8582608699798584,
0.0667581781744957,
-0.23318974673748016,
-0.46350187063217163,
-0.5400727987289429,
0.19672705233097076,
0.3536580502986908,
0.38272738456726074,
0.38415828347206116,
-0.0797697901725769,
-0.5476266741752625,
-0.7018111348152161,
-0.31415218114852905,
-0.25171202421188354,
0.19191329181194305,
0.23286262154579163,
0.018057117238640785,
-0.3561325967311859,
0.6080909371376038,
-0.34153079986572266,
0.09660834819078445,
-0.11407450586557388,
0.21808946132659912,
0.267389714717865,
0.43143340945243835,
0.8248481154441833,
-0.7504667639732361,
-0.3696616590023041,
0.0032151341438293457,
-0.48242753744125366,
0.43446099758148193,
0.23232319951057434,
-0.18941166996955872,
0.30962762236595154,
0.5252655744552612,
-0.5871561169624329,
0.5506943464279175,
0.27550339698791504,
-0.4687441289424896,
0.48646268248558044,
-0.3598167300224304,
0.825133204460144,
-0.6171125769615173,
-0.037034887820482254,
-0.5709133744239807,
0.007213740609586239,
-0.6400542259216309,
0.21988479793071747,
0.1591312289237976,
-0.013218885287642479,
-0.7971736788749695,
0.4973900020122528,
-0.7846364378929138,
0.2077086865901947,
-0.4154556393623352,
-0.1499817669391632,
-0.06215973570942879,
0.024479540064930916,
0.1318853348493576,
0.7913468480110168,
0.9191684126853943,
-0.8770688772201538,
-0.11102946102619171,
0.06866881996393204,
-0.11977330595254898,
0.099999338388443,
-0.16070732474327087,
0.4545407295227051,
-0.10212977975606918,
-0.021507499739527702,
-0.7970429062843323,
-0.2097940593957901,
0.12457956373691559,
-0.18234308063983917,
0.11051977425813675,
-0.6560815572738647,
-0.2544889450073242,
-0.4053797721862793,
-0.5703464150428772,
0.3046736717224121,
0.7607842683792114,
-0.44529786705970764,
0.8847166895866394,
0.1571044623851776,
0.4038712978363037,
-0.9726794958114624,
-0.8587807416915894,
0.24961556494235992,
0.12714140117168427,
-0.7010173797607422,
0.26124903559684753,
-0.13986892998218536,
-0.3812970221042633,
-0.17144492268562317,
-0.06826049834489822,
-0.028446832671761513,
0.00244470639154315,
0.3279084861278534,
0.31949785351753235,
-0.3984622061252594,
-0.26468801498413086,
0.34390783309936523,
-0.20308303833007812,
-0.25951334834098816,
-0.40932926535606384,
0.40084388852119446,
-0.31867972016334534,
-0.04417162388563156,
-0.10699295997619629,
0.4419565200805664,
0.6427167654037476,
0.17705610394477844,
0.5869591236114502,
0.27056261897087097,
-0.387980192899704,
-0.20192447304725647,
-0.8204629421234131,
-0.1752384454011917,
-0.5463482737541199,
-0.04202405363321304,
-0.7638753056526184,
-0.7925031185150146,
1.0173897743225098,
-0.20482255518436432,
-0.06150128319859505,
0.31266531348228455,
0.3682090640068054,
0.052965953946113586,
0.2789026200771332,
1.3336628675460815,
-0.0018267950508743525,
0.15952907502651215,
-0.5775132775306702,
-0.28777408599853516,
-0.5813297033309937,
-0.36239418387413025,
-0.48162680864334106,
-0.30067968368530273,
-0.09484729170799255,
-0.8440412878990173,
0.02958100661635399,
0.6460602283477783,
-0.003948911093175411,
0.23250585794448853,
-0.21347510814666748,
0.4525098204612732,
0.13491211831569672,
0.4097035825252533,
0.34704625606536865,
0.13687928020954132,
-0.13592538237571716,
-0.056163523346185684,
-1.0598251819610596,
-0.38942235708236694,
1.2454237937927246,
0.20121455192565918,
0.8025603890419006,
0.025874927639961243,
0.589621901512146,
0.6583175659179688,
0.2047690600156784,
-0.6441254019737244,
0.4934910833835602,
-0.4075375497341156,
-0.49410468339920044,
0.0784529373049736,
-0.14294469356536865,
-0.6383958458900452,
-0.1665584146976471,
-0.6108913421630859,
-0.756253182888031,
0.7637973427772522,
0.5373001098632812,
-0.46441808342933655,
0.5807133316993713,
-0.5204024910926819,
0.3490370810031891,
-0.1225297749042511,
-0.6599292159080505,
-0.404112845659256,
-0.3599322438240051,
0.7099235653877258,
-0.08130801469087601,
0.10087637603282928,
-0.06646144390106201,
-0.47026485204696655,
0.8521817922592163,
-0.6609763503074646,
0.6544538736343384,
-0.3451066017150879,
-0.1184503510594368,
0.4618973731994629,
0.6480901837348938,
0.6454775929450989,
0.06456446647644043,
-0.7605580687522888,
0.29456496238708496,
-0.03671426698565483,
-0.5803878307342529,
-0.37519314885139465,
0.7102356553077698,
-0.6847156286239624,
-0.40998607873916626,
-0.23375959694385529,
-0.43945080041885376,
-0.2664651572704315,
0.11266722530126572,
0.6692550182342529,
0.27550187706947327,
-0.0902562364935875,
-0.16656197607517242,
0.337017297744751,
0.38751283288002014,
0.3998621106147766,
0.7734312415122986,
-0.15281780064105988,
-0.29252657294273376,
0.5196074843406677,
0.12931746244430542,
0.23029688000679016,
0.4537559151649475,
-0.11871511489152908,
-0.3738231360912323,
-1.0943447351455688,
-0.17545293271541595,
0.05555744841694832,
-0.8910186290740967,
-0.33481162786483765,
-0.5261185765266418,
-0.0348510816693306,
-0.36406949162483215,
-0.5383778810501099,
-0.6288935542106628,
-0.6968821287155151,
-0.39422881603240967,
-0.02118743397295475,
0.8736463785171509,
0.66336590051651,
-0.39081189036369324,
0.6351689696311951,
-0.8554816842079163,
0.48228928446769714,
-0.1363188922405243,
0.3282243311405182,
0.07170478999614716,
-0.7938543558120728,
-0.35233476758003235,
0.14040350914001465,
0.20527848601341248,
-0.5418684482574463,
0.34589987993240356,
0.004972059279680252,
0.4034244120121002,
0.5273878574371338,
0.34848684072494507,
1.0447440147399902,
-0.2876608371734619,
0.9493938684463501,
0.31442537903785706,
-1.0522695779800415,
0.4001214802265167,
-0.3207798898220062,
0.004874682053923607,
0.7385869026184082,
0.3637329339981079,
-0.061632316559553146,
0.03796154633164406,
-0.42059525847435,
-0.5937732458114624,
0.3185966908931732,
-0.10132908076047897,
-0.07218236476182938,
-0.027721872553229332,
0.9263800978660583,
0.3677080571651459,
0.015544549562036991,
0.22971993684768677,
-0.19693084061145782,
-0.1047615110874176,
0.5559129118919373,
-0.09050985425710678,
-0.7547788619995117,
-0.028398441150784492,
0.005034641362726688,
0.2111450731754303,
-0.0520305410027504,
0.2872646749019623,
0.1593289077281952,
0.05875436216592789,
-0.5378844738006592,
-0.1236841157078743,
0.40395671129226685,
0.5627118349075317,
-0.3957218527793884,
0.04988749697804451,
0.29663410782814026,
-0.7166737914085388,
0.20496991276741028,
-0.2844860255718231,
-0.18619614839553833,
-0.17762558162212372,
0.6496090292930603,
0.807988166809082,
0.408244252204895,
-0.18531084060668945,
0.3082485496997833,
-0.052024956792593,
-0.5129650235176086,
0.19671787321567535,
0.24621646106243134,
-0.10249453037977219,
0.25151053071022034,
0.5362362861633301,
0.8429930806159973,
0.34313449263572693,
-0.4164348244667053,
0.3319319486618042,
0.2609925866127014,
-0.096614308655262,
-0.32267680764198303,
0.8873336315155029,
0.3172159194946289,
-0.47376132011413574,
0.7115325927734375,
0.045098450034856796,
-0.1697118878364563,
0.4397392272949219,
0.4298724830150604,
0.7460330128669739,
0.16963456571102142,
-0.02330269291996956,
0.1350078582763672,
0.24918405711650848,
-0.2747689187526703,
0.7620404362678528,
-0.07668610662221909,
-0.6628163456916809,
-0.45100513100624084,
-0.5338475704193115,
-0.5286862850189209,
-0.25887933373451233,
-0.8677201867103577,
0.49624696373939514,
-0.45886707305908203,
-0.3693428337574005,
-0.5427727103233337,
0.18248000741004944,
-0.848047137260437,
-0.02345009706914425,
0.11355879157781601,
1.6926026344299316,
-0.5608003735542297,
0.9242920279502869,
0.12849707901477814,
-0.00041037859045900404,
-0.714080810546875,
0.20279772579669952,
-0.022167745977640152,
-0.6824501156806946,
0.7274803519248962,
-0.2453775703907013,
-0.6892523765563965,
-0.03211526200175285,
-0.4325055181980133,
-0.9428545236587524,
0.9662345051765442,
0.7589616775512695,
-0.7993555068969727,
-0.02618325687944889,
-0.27444401383399963,
0.368531733751297,
-0.41867148876190186,
0.1931033432483673,
0.5088695287704468,
0.3958010673522949,
0.44271180033683777,
-0.7254887819290161,
-0.10807587206363678,
-0.227622851729393,
-0.08510234951972961,
-0.3351624310016632,
-0.6602493524551392,
0.8973533511161804,
-0.6581729650497437,
-0.2303088754415512,
0.5098234415054321,
0.9909663200378418,
0.34941166639328003,
0.19439028203487396,
0.32995864748954773,
0.21316514909267426,
1.2080622911453247,
0.17820101976394653,
1.3670649528503418,
-0.7183970212936401,
0.025245631113648415,
0.4778110980987549,
-0.46392807364463806,
1.3053579330444336,
0.4331928491592407,
0.008267098106443882,
0.43857115507125854,
0.6437523365020752,
0.424225777387619,
0.612977921962738,
0.08588216453790665,
-0.40021124482154846,
-0.68153977394104,
0.31309986114501953,
-0.6042230129241943,
0.31192171573638916,
0.42949679493904114,
0.2626860439777374,
-0.14626836776733398,
0.32395896315574646,
-0.1414085030555725,
0.16943491995334625,
-0.6929671764373779,
0.32021504640579224,
0.008267260156571865,
-0.3049097955226898,
1.158629059791565,
0.008739044889807701,
0.9543982744216919,
-0.9342275857925415,
0.02595936693251133,
-0.341571182012558,
0.2248351126909256,
-0.1730966418981552,
-0.4838827848434448,
0.06379031389951706,
-0.14326420426368713,
-0.2820308208465576,
0.08933872729539871,
0.8903765678405762,
-0.018648188561201096,
-0.7672008872032166,
0.5320570468902588,
0.5508143305778503,
0.41770899295806885,
0.26303642988204956,
-0.6314541697502136,
0.8132216930389404,
-0.1562439203262329,
-0.289631187915802,
0.04384298622608185,
0.3585737943649292,
0.037680476903915405,
0.9187243580818176,
0.8018409013748169,
0.4024784564971924,
0.20439976453781128,
-0.016799475997686386,
1.2989128828048706,
-0.5676015615463257,
-0.6762092113494873,
-0.5133854746818542,
0.5065151453018188,
0.24998816847801208,
-0.2985765337944031,
0.8537697792053223,
0.9450430274009705,
0.042219486087560654,
-0.37811946868896484,
0.6842014789581299,
0.02692904695868492,
0.49847516417503357,
-1.0018011331558228,
0.7720271944999695,
-0.39068588614463806,
0.7123998999595642,
-0.03396376594901085,
-0.574009895324707,
-0.3693433403968811,
0.22864428162574768,
-0.13022533059120178,
0.007897600531578064,
0.3796151578426361,
1.0403777360916138,
-0.10321252793073654,
-0.10611218959093094,
0.40969428420066833,
0.1834876388311386,
0.12266158312559128,
0.6105693578720093,
0.7164241075515747,
-0.7876092791557312,
0.36318325996398926,
-0.18794137239456177,
-0.323354572057724,
-0.3868337571620941,
-1.1749579906463623,
-0.9143615961074829,
-0.19898198544979095,
-0.3566514551639557,
-0.5927367806434631,
0.6125013828277588,
0.4856262505054474,
1.1445084810256958,
-0.5480737686157227,
-0.45374131202697754,
0.034415025264024734,
-0.007357525173574686,
-0.4617452621459961,
-0.12841080129146576,
0.44091716408729553,
-0.2871426045894623,
-0.38612326979637146,
0.9717038869857788,
0.282167911529541,
0.17224903404712677,
0.10868765413761139,
-0.5666811466217041,
-0.02476469613611698,
0.28771376609802246,
0.40556856989860535,
0.5541554689407349,
-0.5039825439453125,
-0.1383572369813919,
0.255465567111969,
0.028928425163030624,
0.017024168744683266,
1.147723913192749,
-1.0677030086517334,
0.39315441250801086,
0.5487813949584961,
0.23447225987911224,
1.1336349248886108,
0.15820394456386566,
0.5718402862548828,
-0.32015976309776306,
0.688140332698822,
0.21836476027965546,
0.17311464250087738,
-0.2550131380558014,
-0.7808438539505005,
0.1576664000749588,
0.292087584733963,
-0.08186311274766922,
-0.8384777307510376,
-0.004031021147966385,
-1.475679636001587,
-0.16610190272331238,
0.8203085660934448,
0.03348270803689957,
-0.45914047956466675,
-0.23978987336158752,
-0.18762820959091187,
-0.4067152440547943,
-0.4441542625427246,
0.4678724706172943,
0.24022404849529266,
-0.2242889553308487,
-0.32626911997795105,
-0.1453240066766739,
0.8773374557495117,
-0.015810208395123482,
-0.4371313750743866,
0.4830254316329956,
0.24748656153678894,
0.15945056080818176,
0.12278645485639572,
0.9394609928131104,
-0.11499465256929398,
0.7232516407966614,
0.7438375353813171,
-0.21323570609092712,
-0.48887887597084045,
-0.36191561818122864,
-0.19817471504211426,
0.4360390901565552,
0.1640581488609314,
-0.09399064630270004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02080v1 | Translation Errors Significantly Impact Low-Resource Languages in Cross-Lingual Learning | 2024-02-03T08:22:51 | 2024-02-03T08:22:51 | Ashish Sunil Agrawal, Barah Fazili, Preethi Jyothi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Popular benchmarks (e.g., XNLI) used to evaluate cross-lingual language
understanding consist of parallel versions of English evaluation sets in
multiple target languages created with the help of professional translators.
When creating such parallel data, it is critical to ensure high-quality
translations for all target languages for an accurate characterization of
cross-lingual transfer. In this work, we find that translation inconsistencies
do exist and interestingly they disproportionally impact low-resource languages
in XNLI. To identify such inconsistencies, we propose measuring the gap in
performance between zero-shot evaluations on the human-translated and
machine-translated target text across multiple target languages; relatively
large gaps are indicative of translation errors. We also corroborate that
translation errors exist for two target languages, namely Hindi and Urdu, by
doing a manual reannotation of human-translated test instances in these two
languages and finding poor agreement with the original English labels these
instances were supposed to inherit. | [
-0.016341879963874817,
-0.21455611288547516,
0.19288749992847443,
0.3815003037452698,
0.1095241904258728,
0.5692771673202515,
-0.13975965976715088,
-0.718255877494812,
0.0592067651450634,
0.00493710208684206,
-0.4461704194545746,
-0.06297464668750763,
-0.8544613718986511,
0.40379196405410767,
-0.2761090099811554,
0.8120049834251404,
-0.610977828502655,
0.15690813958644867,
0.14530988037586212,
-0.5885956883430481,
-0.6289353370666504,
-0.2642914354801178,
-0.5533322691917419,
-0.23730790615081787,
0.7243369221687317,
0.7132867574691772,
0.8248814940452576,
0.5633888840675354,
0.3770252466201782,
0.21512962877750397,
0.07026565819978714,
0.1690659075975418,
-0.5667520761489868,
-0.3470001518726349,
-0.3582763969898224,
-0.6549469232559204,
-0.3256229758262634,
-0.1451251059770584,
1.07783842086792,
0.9743117094039917,
0.27625027298927307,
0.26595160365104675,
0.08800125122070312,
0.5005534291267395,
-0.8307259678840637,
0.036604009568691254,
-0.325210303068161,
0.5192019939422607,
-0.542036235332489,
0.05070142075419426,
-0.30419597029685974,
0.0156228207051754,
-0.09014422446489334,
-0.6425058245658875,
0.21818505227565765,
0.09579049795866013,
0.8485997915267944,
0.25047820806503296,
-0.09422717243432999,
-0.1776760369539261,
-0.5397042036056519,
1.1670501232147217,
-0.6047062873840332,
0.7456508874893188,
0.22644606232643127,
0.2672611176967621,
0.17363303899765015,
-0.09887763112783432,
-0.5340332388877869,
0.07845117896795273,
-0.445032000541687,
0.09028013050556183,
-0.08176721632480621,
-0.32620349526405334,
0.24700647592544556,
0.30500420928001404,
-0.6520301103591919,
0.29182595014572144,
-0.31106945872306824,
-0.14315791428089142,
0.5794044137001038,
0.14156033098697662,
0.5842016935348511,
-0.2673511803150177,
-0.24643905460834503,
-0.4937228560447693,
-0.7847498059272766,
0.24996094405651093,
0.3331899642944336,
0.4699717164039612,
-0.441902756690979,
0.4268726408481598,
-0.07414130866527557,
0.6777706146240234,
-0.16026364266872406,
-0.24354511499404907,
0.4586956202983856,
-0.871286153793335,
-0.06709872931241989,
0.42674461007118225,
0.6488140821456909,
0.2253398448228836,
0.16278021037578583,
-0.24043011665344238,
-0.18346096575260162,
-0.0767640769481659,
-0.2536385953426361,
-0.38659510016441345,
0.21295948326587677,
-0.15757393836975098,
-0.13876621425151825,
-0.12779825925827026,
-0.17218296229839325,
-0.8259989023208618,
-0.2544914484024048,
0.05969792604446411,
0.275323748588562,
-0.17364296317100525,
-0.23869702219963074,
-0.07686358690261841,
0.07964541018009186,
0.2296568751335144,
0.14251798391342163,
-0.7288115620613098,
0.043009161949157715,
0.35882019996643066,
0.7915220856666565,
-0.15879571437835693,
-0.7837815880775452,
-0.47716185450553894,
0.19336789846420288,
-0.6041668057441711,
0.6046333909034729,
-0.31902897357940674,
-0.40532490611076355,
-0.011272352188825607,
-0.02765488438308239,
-0.3734738528728485,
-0.5835584402084351,
0.5270385146141052,
-0.14267274737358093,
0.07712787389755249,
-0.497422456741333,
-0.21756421029567719,
-0.12113692611455917,
0.23761236667633057,
-0.5436106324195862,
0.7281162738800049,
0.40330183506011963,
-0.6939943432807922,
0.46924689412117004,
-0.3877224326133728,
-0.5610128045082092,
-0.1532583236694336,
-0.2717936635017395,
-0.29071784019470215,
0.3591358959674835,
0.06793493777513504,
0.05705518648028374,
-0.37812188267707825,
-0.19085626304149628,
0.11469703167676926,
-0.5114338994026184,
0.22099317610263824,
-0.47665590047836304,
0.8471328020095825,
-0.06105863302946091,
-0.6191138625144958,
-0.15766943991184235,
-0.7089110016822815,
0.35327431559562683,
0.16529566049575806,
-0.34781038761138916,
-0.3224257826805115,
-0.25438109040260315,
0.2455017864704132,
0.3815595805644989,
0.14908908307552338,
-0.5672544240951538,
-0.16158336400985718,
-0.36068758368492126,
-0.09438417106866837,
0.5118805170059204,
-0.39104053378105164,
0.283566415309906,
-0.29743802547454834,
0.5005326271057129,
0.3439047038555145,
0.06154222786426544,
-0.02226686291396618,
-0.46115177869796753,
-0.7397083044052124,
0.3309968113899231,
0.38755708932876587,
0.7411418557167053,
-0.8782315850257874,
-0.16923558712005615,
-0.5039441585540771,
-0.40553024411201477,
-0.6065266132354736,
0.6711335182189941,
0.9821915030479431,
0.40614771842956543,
0.40208375453948975,
-0.3176465928554535,
-0.4530094861984253,
-0.8129774928092957,
-0.5641566514968872,
-0.2586785852909088,
0.29302552342414856,
0.17728763818740845,
0.10884757339954376,
-0.3105528652667999,
0.5838660001754761,
-0.138998880982399,
-0.38467708230018616,
-0.3926897943019867,
0.402688205242157,
-0.1249300017952919,
0.5505499243736267,
0.6675745248794556,
-0.606895387172699,
-0.9900980591773987,
0.5043882131576538,
-0.6077727675437927,
-0.2771143913269043,
-0.3778887987136841,
-0.0728321522474289,
0.3969689905643463,
0.24952466785907745,
-0.26837971806526184,
0.38916319608688354,
0.7949302792549133,
-0.15770180523395538,
0.5146192312240601,
-0.031112784519791603,
0.4541708827018738,
-0.6593351364135742,
-0.04518816992640495,
0.10435814410448074,
-0.08228907734155655,
-0.4031376838684082,
-0.15118174254894257,
0.1302989423274994,
0.23682568967342377,
-0.6747997999191284,
0.6645626425743103,
-0.3623082935810089,
-0.2065097838640213,
0.052833035588264465,
0.4146958291530609,
0.12055756151676178,
0.2715110778808594,
-0.10131882131099701,
0.9340909719467163,
0.2070826143026352,
0.0915081724524498,
-0.0053762514144182205,
0.2861453592777252,
-0.3026786148548126,
0.6575506925582886,
-0.42626675963401794,
-0.1796577423810959,
0.13845035433769226,
-0.13725444674491882,
-0.9529619216918945,
-0.29846954345703125,
0.5388156175613403,
-0.4599636197090149,
0.6537591218948364,
0.04661672189831734,
-0.5025784373283386,
0.21385237574577332,
-0.0716063380241394,
0.8694837689399719,
0.282510370016098,
-0.3913068473339081,
0.10125253349542618,
0.09157606214284897,
0.11515339463949203,
-0.9605896472930908,
-0.9336812496185303,
0.15480484068393707,
0.2194456160068512,
-0.4692815840244293,
0.03129613399505615,
0.3326150178909302,
-0.3182468116283417,
0.21475760638713837,
-0.20598864555358887,
-0.2262682020664215,
-0.11254434287548065,
-0.004960356280207634,
0.0735524594783783,
-0.3443468511104584,
-0.10577107965946198,
0.07775432616472244,
-0.07152070105075836,
0.010216906666755676,
0.10590195655822754,
-0.02105982042849064,
-0.08019332587718964,
-0.6470946669578552,
-0.3374805748462677,
0.5265271663665771,
0.6538079977035522,
-0.034802600741386414,
0.5487128496170044,
0.6372631192207336,
-0.3209676146507263,
-0.13345825672149658,
-0.472990483045578,
0.2414749562740326,
-0.343086838722229,
0.5933846831321716,
-0.48922401666641235,
-0.4310360848903656,
0.5255653262138367,
0.23177580535411835,
-0.11636628210544586,
0.481807678937912,
0.14627796411514282,
-0.02157730981707573,
1.071987509727478,
0.5704448819160461,
-0.14840373396873474,
0.27201175689697266,
-0.18157939612865448,
0.383467435836792,
-0.6277071833610535,
0.12986306846141815,
-0.5336618423461914,
-0.3834231197834015,
-0.6492628455162048,
-0.4932311773300171,
0.21712137758731842,
0.2828368544578552,
0.11113497614860535,
0.5326359868049622,
-0.02315468154847622,
0.5052387714385986,
0.29673027992248535,
-0.3120259940624237,
0.3782365322113037,
0.15646706521511078,
-0.16931217908859253,
-0.4057357907295227,
-0.9451220035552979,
-0.19417594373226166,
0.7050705552101135,
0.16371412575244904,
0.6821038722991943,
0.24896152317523956,
0.63459312915802,
0.17761187255382538,
0.3815980553627014,
-0.5393384695053101,
0.14842528104782104,
-0.4455573260784149,
-0.49069181084632874,
-0.309439480304718,
-0.6691287159919739,
-0.8700436353683472,
0.20658385753631592,
-0.046380024403333664,
-0.5487436652183533,
0.4778314232826233,
-0.040571607649326324,
-0.34908878803253174,
0.5200455188751221,
-0.8389382362365723,
1.2941523790359497,
-0.6518794894218445,
-0.5659871101379395,
-0.3194526135921478,
-0.5081340670585632,
0.3929307460784912,
-0.4411660134792328,
0.2331293523311615,
-0.19060900807380676,
-0.013376956805586815,
0.6146289706230164,
-0.21854563057422638,
0.7440897822380066,
-0.028467051684856415,
-0.09114663302898407,
0.1960856318473816,
0.13112372159957886,
0.3137422800064087,
-0.20248331129550934,
-0.03196854144334793,
0.5948113799095154,
0.1830897033214569,
-0.7736766338348389,
-0.651093065738678,
0.5674895644187927,
-1.010798454284668,
-0.43168556690216064,
-0.604516863822937,
-0.6568706035614014,
-0.2529405355453491,
0.07640225440263748,
0.3429831564426422,
0.048750195652246475,
-0.08217475563287735,
-0.2114783674478531,
0.35400059819221497,
-0.3461456894874573,
0.24982570111751556,
0.5801824331283569,
-0.0824466422200203,
-0.19403554499149323,
1.214543104171753,
0.5099340677261353,
0.4813910722732544,
0.29854097962379456,
-0.03331921249628067,
-0.2718251347541809,
-0.47548189759254456,
-0.8969181776046753,
0.42341044545173645,
-0.7983503341674805,
-0.11431054770946503,
-0.12563557922840118,
-0.11020435392856598,
-0.23526479303836823,
-0.33177903294563293,
-0.6135595440864563,
-0.1677001267671585,
-0.0585981160402298,
0.16637268662452698,
-0.09154102206230164,
0.7149893641471863,
-0.35445675253868103,
0.29943549633026123,
-1.2315605878829956,
-0.024856388568878174,
0.047218505293130875,
0.20090900361537933,
0.004095988813787699,
-0.6244785189628601,
-0.8106064796447754,
0.18405497074127197,
-0.0012356432853266597,
-0.7987244129180908,
0.22433868050575256,
0.28534892201423645,
0.5782336592674255,
0.0690063089132309,
-0.10788389295339584,
0.9707786440849304,
-0.49350982904434204,
0.44178128242492676,
0.4232180416584015,
-1.0966378450393677,
0.34443172812461853,
-0.019073382019996643,
0.4531532824039459,
0.6350947022438049,
0.42537209391593933,
-1.0001169443130493,
-0.20128677785396576,
-0.28655922412872314,
-0.6208685040473938,
0.7533764839172363,
0.12205731868743896,
-0.18040116131305695,
0.025285882875323296,
0.17523200809955597,
0.10115770250558853,
-0.15075069665908813,
-0.5671025514602661,
-0.24840565025806427,
0.060122523456811905,
-0.06086188554763794,
-0.24220706522464752,
-0.23987217247486115,
0.0005333017325028777,
-0.1479252725839615,
0.5596869587898254,
-0.12401828914880753,
-0.32008039951324463,
0.19847185909748077,
-0.5327203273773193,
-0.6705488562583923,
0.3203545808792114,
0.6348170042037964,
0.8759316802024841,
-0.034938689321279526,
-0.010343087837100029,
0.5275755524635315,
-0.3993150591850281,
0.5164688229560852,
-0.11117514222860336,
-0.12469059228897095,
0.3428790271282196,
0.4833708703517914,
0.59433913230896,
0.6909465789794922,
-0.902529776096344,
0.476828008890152,
0.020147550851106644,
0.4147056043148041,
-0.16948620975017548,
-0.188003808259964,
-0.21847835183143616,
0.007517223712056875,
0.14747945964336395,
0.3345198631286621,
-0.210221067070961,
-0.4700227379798889,
0.1757548451423645,
0.04728127643465996,
-0.5122503042221069,
-0.5211933851242065,
0.357740193605423,
0.2672807574272156,
-0.15064646303653717,
0.4776061177253723,
-0.46658673882484436,
-0.5713314414024353,
0.3341166377067566,
0.22599363327026367,
0.887652575969696,
-0.406340628862381,
0.2842617630958557,
0.40776804089546204,
0.5434109568595886,
-0.06161446124315262,
-0.0820259228348732,
-0.05051954835653305,
-0.768535315990448,
-0.8818910717964172,
-0.37383607029914856,
-0.5576699376106262,
-0.38254514336586,
-0.6126234531402588,
0.3025008738040924,
-0.2339460253715515,
0.13933652639389038,
-0.054820433259010315,
-0.13218344748020172,
-0.641859769821167,
0.05277881771326065,
0.3256625235080719,
0.7375603914260864,
-1.238766074180603,
0.8958786129951477,
0.6183741092681885,
-0.5530499815940857,
-0.8035011887550354,
0.019715240225195885,
0.08121663331985474,
-0.7732974290847778,
1.2874820232391357,
-0.11520182341337204,
-0.3099032938480377,
-0.23468680679798126,
0.29476651549339294,
-0.9432588815689087,
0.5788953900337219,
0.32725900411605835,
-0.7402045130729675,
0.056639231741428375,
0.8607983589172363,
0.5953439474105835,
-0.10029620677232742,
0.27478528022766113,
0.6057009100914001,
0.5917666554450989,
-0.1877714991569519,
-1.3301175832748413,
0.08215465396642685,
-0.048067379742860794,
-0.06800148636102676,
0.27033790946006775,
-0.6681726574897766,
0.8920460939407349,
-0.07693548500537872,
-0.4669593274593353,
-0.06911835074424744,
0.31606239080429077,
0.0022146611008793116,
0.42748090624809265,
0.4487140476703644,
0.7149747014045715,
0.41229215264320374,
-0.18147632479667664,
1.035714030265808,
-0.21150009334087372,
0.27560028433799744,
1.2246806621551514,
-0.46293914318084717,
0.9422638416290283,
0.6198627352714539,
-0.3481734097003937,
0.24089278280735016,
0.5791721940040588,
0.06900839507579803,
0.23470862209796906,
0.1281053125858307,
-0.2613770067691803,
-0.11778099089860916,
-0.30686259269714355,
-0.33146902918815613,
0.4119526147842407,
0.39837712049484253,
-0.1362917572259903,
-0.6136133074760437,
0.025314820930361748,
0.042275603860616684,
0.0443233884871006,
-0.13608486950397491,
0.3329485356807709,
-0.02949644811451435,
-0.7412861585617065,
0.898457944393158,
-0.048892561346292496,
0.6620131731033325,
-0.37237435579299927,
-0.1431068480014801,
-0.4295544922351837,
0.43054479360580444,
-0.4175596833229065,
-0.7499736547470093,
0.6919397711753845,
0.0702073723077774,
-0.23373189568519592,
-0.19153465330600739,
0.3734302222728729,
-0.48239248991012573,
-0.6358276009559631,
0.6790122389793396,
0.8381396532058716,
0.2689826190471649,
0.23483623564243317,
-0.8783473968505859,
0.42760607600212097,
0.21311961114406586,
0.16452927887439728,
0.502246081829071,
0.3288682997226715,
-0.26483094692230225,
0.19570067524909973,
0.29246559739112854,
0.19581790268421173,
0.39366862177848816,
-0.14586716890335083,
0.32408928871154785,
-0.484274685382843,
-0.06677493453025818,
-0.5792446136474609,
0.39843225479125977,
-0.02946312725543976,
-0.5514629483222961,
0.9834917783737183,
0.49879777431488037,
1.5390852689743042,
-0.015218627639114857,
0.748573362827301,
-0.010435855016112328,
0.5198444724082947,
-0.10184480249881744,
0.7038708329200745,
-0.799213171005249,
0.22426435351371765,
-0.14305031299591064,
-0.885054349899292,
-0.2982974350452423,
0.463550865650177,
-0.35645240545272827,
-0.22397911548614502,
0.8093269467353821,
0.7053468823432922,
-0.04649025574326515,
-0.358183890581131,
0.6633687615394592,
0.17338252067565918,
0.04716974496841431,
0.7693495154380798,
0.6547234654426575,
-0.9868192672729492,
0.8665225505828857,
-0.5112969279289246,
-0.1258593648672104,
-0.17598436772823334,
-0.4422609508037567,
-0.5232996344566345,
-0.33985862135887146,
-0.7301405668258667,
-0.3391525149345398,
0.27117428183555603,
0.7292892336845398,
0.48206979036331177,
-1.1488171815872192,
-0.6547108292579651,
0.027115795761346817,
0.5609834790229797,
-0.43817949295043945,
-0.21005800366401672,
0.3269708752632141,
-0.6243155598640442,
-1.0876719951629639,
0.5125263929367065,
0.33537226915359497,
0.078300841152668,
-0.4340481162071228,
-0.2907772958278656,
-0.25482529401779175,
-0.2082909792661667,
0.3985646069049835,
0.8117313385009766,
-0.810908317565918,
-0.333249568939209,
-0.0589791014790535,
-0.39622315764427185,
0.21000339090824127,
0.6689102649688721,
-0.5066473484039307,
0.588810920715332,
0.615790605545044,
0.9379914402961731,
0.20505401492118835,
-0.46654948592185974,
0.5036468505859375,
-0.9408815503120422,
0.24648511409759521,
-0.10469643026590347,
0.35205763578414917,
0.5338801145553589,
-0.32308992743492126,
0.6899821758270264,
0.5079298615455627,
-0.19882899522781372,
-1.0252894163131714,
0.06944989413022995,
-0.6583070158958435,
-0.03015262633562088,
0.7938508987426758,
-0.5084108710289001,
-0.4557696580886841,
-0.14491857588291168,
0.0810375064611435,
0.2429204136133194,
0.1911909431219101,
0.6559438109397888,
0.8830109238624573,
-0.13982003927230835,
-0.2684958875179291,
-0.6568913459777832,
0.45526519417762756,
0.9061918258666992,
-0.4846303164958954,
-0.14800839126110077,
0.17058420181274414,
0.16690686345100403,
0.6773394346237183,
0.07900510728359222,
-0.14481240510940552,
0.5984070301055908,
0.4377579689025879,
-0.020532654598355293,
0.3598317801952362,
0.013871759176254272,
-0.19641715288162231,
-0.1615903079509735,
0.05998028814792633,
-0.3245738744735718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02078v1 | Exploring the Robustness of Task-oriented Dialogue Systems for Colloquial German Varieties | 2024-02-03T08:16:43 | 2024-02-03T08:16:43 | Ekaterina Artemova, Verena Blaschke, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mainstream cross-lingual task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems leverage the
transfer learning paradigm by training a joint model for intent recognition and
slot-filling in English and applying it, zero-shot, to other languages. We
address a gap in prior research, which often overlooked the transfer to
lower-resource colloquial varieties due to limited test data. Inspired by prior
work on English varieties, we craft and manually evaluate perturbation rules
that transform German sentences into colloquial forms and use them to
synthesize test sets in four ToD datasets. Our perturbation rules cover 18
distinct language phenomena, enabling us to explore the impact of each
perturbation on slot and intent performance. Using these new datasets, we
conduct an experimental evaluation across six different transformers. Here, we
demonstrate that when applied to colloquial varieties, ToD systems maintain
their intent recognition performance, losing 6% (4.62 percentage points) in
accuracy on average. However, they exhibit a significant drop in slot
detection, with a decrease of 31% (21 percentage points) in slot F1 score. Our
findings are further supported by a transfer experiment from Standard American
English to synthetic Urban African American Vernacular English. | [
-0.2837779223918915,
-0.8992353677749634,
0.6840224862098694,
0.13431806862354279,
-0.11549154669046402,
-0.06347183138132095,
-0.19910866022109985,
-0.22514848411083221,
-0.07536490261554718,
0.448709100484848,
-0.34350135922431946,
-0.519205629825592,
-0.7078001499176025,
0.144696906208992,
-0.4956153631210327,
1.0034250020980835,
-0.20157454907894135,
-0.1933261603116989,
-0.19579792022705078,
-0.10496416687965393,
-0.4836389422416687,
-0.41888487339019775,
-0.6926854252815247,
-0.233927384018898,
0.42345213890075684,
0.48337483406066895,
0.5695852041244507,
0.15871615707874298,
0.3049851357936859,
0.2592039108276367,
0.12137353420257568,
-0.15269941091537476,
-0.6313707828521729,
0.43734872341156006,
-0.0950813740491867,
-0.45380663871765137,
-0.22770579159259796,
-0.05077723041176796,
0.5224207639694214,
0.8180654644966125,
0.0472312793135643,
-0.2703808844089508,
0.11534274369478226,
0.12054993212223053,
-0.6577789783477783,
0.3779504895210266,
-0.752657949924469,
0.056835632771253586,
-0.3112960755825043,
-0.25521257519721985,
-0.7539312243461609,
0.034402795135974884,
0.2798523008823395,
-0.5800490379333496,
0.02452091872692108,
-0.1317114681005478,
0.8475645184516907,
0.15093377232551575,
-0.43576082587242126,
-0.04156167432665825,
-0.9492282271385193,
0.8761104345321655,
-0.47449618577957153,
0.5087658762931824,
0.21361619234085083,
0.18517041206359863,
-0.3123690187931061,
-0.4165235161781311,
-0.5473651885986328,
-0.24721765518188477,
-0.2251463532447815,
0.07270942628383636,
-0.31840434670448303,
0.10138294100761414,
0.31290093064308167,
0.0905291810631752,
-0.6520845293998718,
0.12411715090274811,
-0.0474943108856678,
-0.21962907910346985,
0.5131601691246033,
0.14669445157051086,
0.21386028826236725,
0.015801865607500076,
-0.38150888681411743,
-0.3238241374492645,
-0.5862951874732971,
0.4585990309715271,
0.24733221530914307,
0.3201289176940918,
-0.11472142487764359,
0.47298815846443176,
-0.1038384661078453,
0.9070842862129211,
0.33774736523628235,
-0.34359869360923767,
0.0747263953089714,
-0.4076155424118042,
-0.27737677097320557,
-0.15132397413253784,
0.8545315265655518,
0.08729491382837296,
0.024840328842401505,
-0.4227792024612427,
-0.20461463928222656,
-0.1802428960800171,
0.34442803263664246,
-0.3374992311000824,
0.04675137624144554,
0.0025327056646347046,
-0.027356449514627457,
-0.03106100670993328,
-0.017356904223561287,
-0.12513084709644318,
0.07586055994033813,
-0.08334942907094955,
0.4337030053138733,
-0.6851879358291626,
0.12500029802322388,
0.24131900072097778,
-0.2069244533777237,
0.17407537996768951,
0.6136909127235413,
-0.7243901491165161,
0.06359176337718964,
0.5507218241691589,
0.5359032154083252,
-0.5613929629325867,
-0.42585116624832153,
-0.4982830584049225,
0.4042116701602936,
-0.190840482711792,
0.9510305523872375,
-0.48899731040000916,
-0.6413249373435974,
0.08971092104911804,
0.07378219813108444,
-0.47189003229141235,
-0.3165397644042969,
0.6425607800483704,
-0.3344643712043762,
0.5073816776275635,
0.1763099581003189,
-0.18653912842273712,
-0.1489177644252777,
0.3063512444496155,
-0.3409901261329651,
0.8359789252281189,
0.3183399736881256,
-0.4725019931793213,
0.34224918484687805,
-0.7203344702720642,
-0.8676722049713135,
0.02355840429663658,
-0.15713223814964294,
-0.05800393968820572,
0.2043481171131134,
-0.07798697799444199,
0.34296417236328125,
0.06580337136983871,
0.21732033789157867,
-0.22477371990680695,
-0.45054975152015686,
0.2536497116088867,
-0.7286399602890015,
0.7442983388900757,
-0.02318456396460533,
-0.4446006119251251,
-0.037668321281671524,
-0.6142825484275818,
-0.06443167477846146,
-0.15158411860466003,
-0.2485029101371765,
-0.5800418853759766,
-0.27257150411605835,
-0.06271059811115265,
0.24728575348854065,
0.0035990229807794094,
-0.5634459853172302,
0.1578138768672943,
-0.209209606051445,
0.13135285675525665,
0.5778363943099976,
-0.21424444019794464,
0.5545684099197388,
-0.43405595421791077,
0.6582141518592834,
0.17359216511249542,
0.18616983294487,
-0.14080137014389038,
-0.5564565658569336,
-0.8156043291091919,
-0.20893633365631104,
0.260176420211792,
0.6915381550788879,
-0.9030361771583557,
0.6801831126213074,
-0.28933483362197876,
-0.4118369221687317,
-0.11952819675207138,
-0.23574306070804596,
0.29636821150779724,
0.65781569480896,
-0.008390354923903942,
-0.6806488633155823,
-0.21685099601745605,
-0.8992050290107727,
-0.18848411738872528,
-0.31759941577911377,
-0.010590625926852226,
0.4549592435359955,
0.05811288207769394,
0.05109173804521561,
0.914423942565918,
-0.23545008897781372,
-0.22171711921691895,
-0.2990737855434418,
0.20153121650218964,
0.11132296919822693,
0.3631703853607178,
0.514866292476654,
-0.4545852541923523,
-0.8646508455276489,
0.1696375161409378,
-0.5410820841789246,
-0.13049864768981934,
-0.1625148057937622,
-0.04647509753704071,
0.4900224804878235,
0.34396257996559143,
-0.6804438233375549,
0.6262383460998535,
0.6676246523857117,
-0.5263490080833435,
0.547543466091156,
0.16379515826702118,
0.21814043819904327,
-0.9000798463821411,
0.11699772626161575,
-0.08607177436351776,
-0.426875501871109,
-0.7398253083229065,
-0.3386855721473694,
-0.44810062646865845,
-0.07734044641256332,
-0.6887115240097046,
0.6093396544456482,
-0.10504168272018433,
-0.1388709992170334,
-0.10196712613105774,
0.050376854836940765,
0.033337485045194626,
0.5132044553756714,
0.07975271344184875,
0.9527418613433838,
0.560675859451294,
-0.6656165719032288,
-0.20199871063232422,
0.5431957840919495,
-0.30709731578826904,
0.7081863284111023,
-0.40384259819984436,
0.23915359377861023,
-0.12100550532341003,
0.3571428656578064,
-1.122789978981018,
-0.09775476157665253,
0.22914958000183105,
-0.27586546540260315,
0.36181262135505676,
-0.2742803990840912,
-0.1207183226943016,
-0.0061712441965937614,
0.08667049556970596,
0.29990342259407043,
0.4695179760456085,
-0.04812976345419884,
0.6362202167510986,
0.361709862947464,
-0.416669636964798,
-0.5834352374076843,
-0.4633553624153137,
-0.05644974485039711,
-0.07013717293739319,
-0.5950050354003906,
0.3790650963783264,
0.1794939786195755,
-0.16701945662498474,
-0.061683669686317444,
-0.21532361209392548,
-0.12457412481307983,
0.2142312228679657,
0.22209665179252625,
0.32566484808921814,
0.07571970671415329,
-0.02309943176805973,
0.21426062285900116,
0.03637214004993439,
-0.1623050421476364,
-0.27123650908470154,
0.8231223821640015,
0.1948995739221573,
-0.4834411144256592,
-0.6071413159370422,
0.3867010474205017,
0.8616464734077454,
0.13099876046180725,
0.3719309866428375,
0.6719056367874146,
0.1646430939435959,
-0.17342303693294525,
-0.3618198335170746,
-0.13795685768127441,
-0.4535185992717743,
0.2540867328643799,
-0.7307105660438538,
-1.1408774852752686,
0.33587685227394104,
0.1457495391368866,
0.15447725355625153,
0.290986031293869,
0.4022917151451111,
-0.25085118412971497,
0.8013638854026794,
0.7302461862564087,
0.1423456221818924,
0.8102560639381409,
-0.09285735338926315,
0.48835673928260803,
-0.6132196187973022,
0.01275454368442297,
-0.629494845867157,
-0.31656360626220703,
-0.4913162589073181,
-0.44004350900650024,
0.7138335704803467,
-0.11048618704080582,
-0.05970689281821251,
0.6640647053718567,
-0.09487469494342804,
0.10900797694921494,
0.5491331815719604,
-0.2486090362071991,
0.44878560304641724,
0.3392542004585266,
-0.2411426305770874,
-0.009215513244271278,
-0.8873756527900696,
-0.5250360369682312,
1.0533568859100342,
0.2792893648147583,
0.7158339023590088,
0.026607351377606392,
0.785093367099762,
0.44385239481925964,
0.12355702370405197,
-0.9622523784637451,
0.6502646803855896,
-0.4894546866416931,
-0.3561168313026428,
-0.628000020980835,
-0.25178760290145874,
-1.151132583618164,
-0.05655587464570999,
0.001645491225644946,
-0.9028210043907166,
0.33272117376327515,
-0.061808835715055466,
-0.2770293354988098,
0.15194372832775116,
-0.8020193576812744,
0.8048192858695984,
-0.11970517784357071,
-0.22830526530742645,
-0.19612668454647064,
-0.2900288701057434,
0.10295163840055466,
0.032781172543764114,
-0.04218490794301033,
-0.17789524793624878,
0.22228457033634186,
0.39780333638191223,
-0.047854337841272354,
0.8571519255638123,
-0.15580035746097565,
-0.47891882061958313,
0.19228331744670868,
0.2885298728942871,
0.6979613900184631,
-0.05728693678975105,
0.005177745129913092,
0.3291032016277313,
-0.14472781121730804,
-0.45930302143096924,
-0.8614091277122498,
0.6307206153869629,
-0.5260915756225586,
-0.9369286894798279,
-0.18965785205364227,
-1.0144543647766113,
-0.6034539937973022,
0.1890275776386261,
0.14084745943546295,
0.28940215706825256,
-0.34349557757377625,
0.04331740364432335,
0.5444712042808533,
0.10693004727363586,
0.5310215353965759,
0.6835734248161316,
-0.09533320367336273,
-0.05459514632821083,
0.6447362899780273,
-0.0023116578813642263,
0.49860459566116333,
0.34620437026023865,
-0.18000726401805878,
-0.34200143814086914,
-0.6887689232826233,
-0.5744662284851074,
-0.005802552681416273,
-0.3835289180278778,
0.11069414019584656,
-0.6599205732345581,
-0.13360771536827087,
-0.603826105594635,
-0.23538844287395477,
-0.13761784136295319,
-0.6646000742912292,
-0.03338522091507912,
0.22139579057693481,
-0.0035470568109303713,
0.6329947113990784,
0.16246531903743744,
0.24956166744232178,
-0.9306075572967529,
-0.16837729513645172,
0.36582329869270325,
0.38372379541397095,
-0.40706077218055725,
-0.7288960218429565,
0.04261930659413338,
-0.10044794529676437,
-0.42803820967674255,
-0.5980526804924011,
0.18775153160095215,
0.06743137538433075,
0.6670727133750916,
0.46160614490509033,
0.188740536570549,
0.5342585444450378,
-0.42207181453704834,
0.7525036334991455,
0.2986862361431122,
-0.8936468958854675,
0.3555696904659271,
-0.4789715111255646,
0.4444158673286438,
0.6852564811706543,
0.5781506299972534,
-0.5311267375946045,
-0.768501877784729,
-0.7156379222869873,
-0.5529655814170837,
0.9359354972839355,
0.1781958043575287,
0.29111650586128235,
0.11660566180944443,
-0.05128699913620949,
0.47293463349342346,
0.15924739837646484,
-0.5834868550300598,
-0.2731483280658722,
0.042160943150520325,
-0.2450055629014969,
-0.16703738272190094,
0.08932089805603027,
-0.30042460560798645,
-0.12355352193117142,
0.5724944472312927,
-0.18241296708583832,
0.2969197630882263,
0.3551372289657593,
-0.1350860744714737,
-0.025612475350499153,
0.7146547436714172,
0.6468212604522705,
0.34942150115966797,
-0.0805024653673172,
-0.10019497573375702,
-0.10879482328891754,
-0.4928681552410126,
0.41714680194854736,
0.3094725012779236,
-0.7729623317718506,
0.3497762084007263,
0.02444489300251007,
1.165946125984192,
0.1953759491443634,
-0.7172504663467407,
0.3715476095676422,
0.04430153965950012,
-0.2183622568845749,
-0.11949009448289871,
0.20826230943202972,
-0.5673808455467224,
0.09836158156394958,
0.2888404428958893,
0.2751564383506775,
0.2353150099515915,
-0.8533860445022583,
0.12262079119682312,
0.6449356079101562,
-0.7131281495094299,
-0.46699273586273193,
0.09031641483306885,
0.36927956342697144,
-0.4980621337890625,
0.15955901145935059,
-0.477550745010376,
-0.498444527387619,
0.14541950821876526,
0.6583418846130371,
0.8482648730278015,
-0.029191771522164345,
0.5644867420196533,
0.09866635501384735,
0.1116095632314682,
0.20336903631687164,
0.14928165078163147,
-0.34319886565208435,
-0.8394812941551208,
-0.7154102921485901,
-0.5064780116081238,
-0.43167343735694885,
0.24309583008289337,
-0.35055193305015564,
0.22736258804798126,
-0.19135825335979462,
-0.34514573216438293,
-0.14927399158477783,
-0.40029269456863403,
-0.6060473918914795,
-0.10651670396327972,
0.06462044268846512,
0.7440263032913208,
-0.8610790967941284,
0.7933620810508728,
1.1081101894378662,
-0.00021564240159932524,
-0.797509491443634,
0.234354630112648,
-0.2875955402851105,
-0.7568601369857788,
0.6284158229827881,
-0.10800071805715561,
-0.052988965064287186,
0.07534622400999069,
-0.15148183703422546,
-0.9590741991996765,
0.7902909517288208,
0.38386234641075134,
-0.5393285751342773,
-0.2658025920391083,
0.3153916299343109,
0.4305241107940674,
-0.32807406783103943,
0.3740440905094147,
0.635528028011322,
0.5110781788825989,
0.18959660828113556,
-1.4502606391906738,
-0.09246557205915451,
0.10672587156295776,
-0.1281542330980301,
0.3613751232624054,
-0.5245112776756287,
0.6726099848747253,
0.07041547447443008,
-0.49976369738578796,
-0.047610122710466385,
0.18690094351768494,
0.045881859958171844,
0.32188135385513306,
0.796470046043396,
0.8032674789428711,
0.3159377872943878,
-0.33961427211761475,
0.9722223281860352,
-0.2557279169559479,
0.052261561155319214,
0.9593322277069092,
-0.6270115971565247,
0.7096700668334961,
0.7580886483192444,
-0.26815614104270935,
0.885323166847229,
-0.05473723262548447,
0.2725403308868408,
0.450562447309494,
-0.16881859302520752,
-0.3938761055469513,
-0.25893858075141907,
-0.43552684783935547,
0.12930791079998016,
0.9363205432891846,
0.37114983797073364,
-0.12855686247348785,
-0.33996355533599854,
0.22912071645259857,
-0.07311641424894333,
-0.03806627541780472,
-0.13163690268993378,
0.9142669439315796,
-0.1688641756772995,
-1.198731780052185,
0.7479864954948425,
-0.35703983902931213,
0.6925499439239502,
-0.6346438527107239,
0.022695012390613556,
-0.1748591512441635,
-0.10150238126516342,
-0.06680390238761902,
-0.8124685883522034,
0.3277800381183624,
-0.2025749385356903,
-0.1117946207523346,
-0.4460260570049286,
0.8034327626228333,
-0.5026872158050537,
-0.142400324344635,
0.13593420386314392,
0.7844969630241394,
0.21617251634597778,
0.2341904193162918,
-0.3986273407936096,
-0.03684709593653679,
0.2657657861709595,
0.1645883470773697,
0.565891444683075,
0.3867827355861664,
-0.21081531047821045,
0.5134678483009338,
0.5759579539299011,
0.048491403460502625,
0.11290749907493591,
0.05708136036992073,
0.6202044486999512,
-0.38068392872810364,
-0.3405419588088989,
-0.21944895386695862,
0.6414661407470703,
-0.02952207811176777,
-0.337543249130249,
0.8860927820205688,
0.36170682311058044,
1.291366696357727,
-0.22814035415649414,
1.0544567108154297,
-0.32682502269744873,
0.31438398361206055,
-0.3907131850719452,
0.4194781184196472,
-0.3094804883003235,
0.11028829962015152,
0.005785196553915739,
-0.8250849843025208,
-0.052613016217947006,
0.36719244718551636,
-0.5042362213134766,
-0.1694989949464798,
0.7625288963317871,
0.5700564384460449,
-0.10391897708177567,
-0.17262029647827148,
0.8098592162132263,
0.15888240933418274,
0.2044965922832489,
0.5875537395477295,
0.825674831867218,
-0.4812694191932678,
0.8367779850959778,
-0.37343305349349976,
-0.15962554514408112,
-0.2362823784351349,
-0.5244230031967163,
-0.6950434446334839,
-0.6150839328765869,
-0.3752554655075073,
-0.3607465326786041,
0.21004386246204376,
0.39219895005226135,
0.7864115834236145,
-0.904749870300293,
-0.40546467900276184,
-0.24489063024520874,
0.20557178556919098,
-0.26842308044433594,
-0.3604912757873535,
0.048395220190286636,
-0.8471405506134033,
-1.0564216375350952,
0.6032688617706299,
0.5687177181243896,
0.21737810969352722,
-0.22861984372138977,
-0.004762990865856409,
-0.055654048919677734,
-0.08161687105894089,
0.7842273116111755,
0.4231739938259125,
-0.7001083493232727,
-0.42985808849334717,
0.20022879540920258,
-0.16349799931049347,
0.09089186042547226,
1.0523759126663208,
-0.7952930331230164,
0.3262631297111511,
0.4397790729999542,
0.5041429996490479,
0.2619527280330658,
-0.1554087996482849,
0.8404173851013184,
-0.7640181183815002,
0.31426841020584106,
0.40654292702674866,
0.40261098742485046,
0.06887021660804749,
-0.23916982114315033,
0.3681861162185669,
0.3252964913845062,
-0.43988630175590515,
-0.6960014700889587,
0.42926153540611267,
-1.2063887119293213,
-0.02707398124039173,
1.1665418148040771,
-0.4384317696094513,
-0.25189024209976196,
-0.638821005821228,
-0.18937529623508453,
0.06517361849546432,
-0.623031497001648,
0.8632507920265198,
0.8125995397567749,
-0.4107222557067871,
-0.045828212052583694,
-0.04380487650632858,
0.5310905575752258,
0.8054296374320984,
-0.6960197687149048,
-0.07817327976226807,
0.511421263217926,
0.20098672807216644,
0.5023195147514343,
0.6227815747261047,
-0.1365719884634018,
0.5076563358306885,
-0.201712504029274,
-0.07997467368841171,
0.045269206166267395,
-0.3330950438976288,
-0.3694794476032257,
0.28931355476379395,
0.13434670865535736,
-0.11554653197526932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02077v1 | Investigating Content Planning for Navigating Trade-offs in Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue | 2024-02-03T08:16:39 | 2024-02-03T08:16:39 | Kushal Chawla, Hannah Rashkin, Gaurav Singh Tomar, David Reitter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-grounded dialogue generation is a challenging task because it
requires satisfying two fundamental yet often competing constraints: being
responsive in a manner that is specific to what the conversation partner has
said while also being attributable to an underlying source document. In this
work, we bring this trade-off between these two objectives (specificity and
attribution) to light and ask the question: Can explicit content planning
before the response generation help the model to address this challenge? To
answer this question, we design a framework called PLEDGE, which allows us to
experiment with various plan variables explored in prior work, supporting both
metric-agnostic and metric-aware approaches. While content planning shows
promise, our results on whether it can actually help to navigate this trade-off
are mixed -- planning mechanisms that are metric-aware (use automatic metrics
during training) are better at automatic evaluations but underperform in human
judgment compared to metric-agnostic mechanisms. We discuss how this may be
caused by over-fitting to automatic metrics and the need for future work to
better calibrate these metrics towards human judgment. We hope the observations
from our analysis will inform future work that aims to apply content planning
in this context. | [
-0.6317166090011597,
-0.10003351420164108,
0.8118659257888794,
-0.10973168909549713,
-0.26634201407432556,
0.2704600691795349,
-0.04465126618742943,
-0.13033224642276764,
0.1656542420387268,
0.4793280363082886,
-0.874373733997345,
-0.3080065846443176,
-0.475840300321579,
-0.19597689807415009,
-0.18982933461666107,
1.0619698762893677,
-0.06029687821865082,
-0.13512785732746124,
-0.3693767786026001,
-0.1870506852865219,
-0.8755990862846375,
-0.16127875447273254,
-0.7181015610694885,
-0.28987377882003784,
0.4886377155780792,
0.8666155338287354,
0.740511417388916,
0.573331892490387,
0.24074727296829224,
0.17326247692108154,
-0.20786389708518982,
-0.047216471284627914,
-0.6681993007659912,
-0.026035524904727936,
-0.3647671639919281,
-0.5641650557518005,
-0.4558870792388916,
0.20340947806835175,
0.42722487449645996,
0.6232436299324036,
0.08240004628896713,
0.3671681582927704,
0.027507800608873367,
0.5960721373558044,
-0.9114212989807129,
0.18510106205940247,
-0.7339275479316711,
0.28394538164138794,
0.4500771462917328,
-0.27573448419570923,
-0.11648222804069519,
-0.00006524368654936552,
0.32876768708229065,
-0.8680750131607056,
0.38787519931793213,
-0.002498748479411006,
0.49227389693260193,
0.35270434617996216,
-0.4258652627468109,
-0.51451176404953,
-0.7018823027610779,
0.827296793460846,
-0.6553864479064941,
0.38264521956443787,
0.4706180691719055,
0.14667125046253204,
-0.2001456767320633,
-0.6849583983421326,
-0.6148577332496643,
0.20810525119304657,
-0.07022612541913986,
0.4770166575908661,
0.22163356840610504,
0.13537976145744324,
0.33282387256622314,
0.41782450675964355,
-0.24006401002407074,
-0.18208320438861847,
-0.20534692704677582,
-0.3573820888996124,
0.5662588477134705,
0.26436498761177063,
-0.16398005187511444,
-0.3479175567626953,
-0.19033515453338623,
-0.0434601791203022,
-0.7350509166717529,
0.489595890045166,
0.40881574153900146,
0.2419334352016449,
-0.020203886553645134,
0.8203736543655396,
-0.4733336269855499,
0.6044955849647522,
0.2038460671901703,
-0.06316343694925308,
-0.5013412237167358,
-0.7937340140342712,
0.1332068145275116,
0.23175929486751556,
0.4779330790042877,
0.609634280204773,
0.3005595803260803,
0.23995468020439148,
-0.1478458046913147,
0.22093841433525085,
0.6871420741081238,
-0.813017725944519,
-0.22216646373271942,
0.34026020765304565,
-0.32066553831100464,
-0.26707497239112854,
-0.2279496043920517,
-0.4859374165534973,
-0.22116170823574066,
-0.5288895964622498,
-0.015775427222251892,
-0.31824639439582825,
-0.4017505347728729,
0.3256973326206207,
-0.262447714805603,
0.18334898352622986,
0.26475560665130615,
-0.762357771396637,
0.3819606304168701,
0.7141338586807251,
0.6705520153045654,
-0.07427623867988586,
0.17154179513454437,
-0.6314303874969482,
0.46321192383766174,
-0.29076656699180603,
0.6023620367050171,
-0.3888621926307678,
-0.7992366552352905,
0.16035208106040955,
-0.5450857281684875,
0.22494465112686157,
-0.08216549456119537,
0.9579831957817078,
-0.23013527691364288,
0.4487704634666443,
-0.6950735449790955,
-0.5838810205459595,
0.004635068587958813,
0.5659828782081604,
-0.781754732131958,
0.5053561925888062,
0.3299522399902344,
-0.908478856086731,
0.903172492980957,
-0.4410233795642853,
-0.4281856417655945,
-0.257021427154541,
-0.3790469467639923,
-0.22559025883674622,
0.14971664547920227,
0.08030945807695389,
0.11799468845129013,
-0.30258557200431824,
0.4299357235431671,
0.1208442971110344,
-0.3002541661262512,
0.26944875717163086,
-0.16562683880329132,
0.12603598833084106,
0.23251520097255707,
-0.4844875931739807,
0.14716684818267822,
-0.6860477328300476,
0.3125793933868408,
-0.12007608264684677,
-0.35901936888694763,
-0.06740814447402954,
0.3621329069137573,
-0.4010389745235443,
0.5161367654800415,
0.011003797873854637,
-0.5571575164794922,
0.0676921010017395,
-0.37949487566947937,
0.32688194513320923,
0.618424117565155,
0.0524107962846756,
0.8227112293243408,
-0.5739757418632507,
0.7141059637069702,
-0.1409035176038742,
0.16263696551322937,
-0.2106749564409256,
-0.5497708916664124,
-0.818131685256958,
-0.048602137714624405,
-0.1063358336687088,
0.1816038340330124,
-0.6304575800895691,
0.2833114266395569,
-0.3357868492603302,
-0.38568222522735596,
-0.38426950573921204,
-0.19455081224441528,
0.7313789129257202,
0.5789039134979248,
0.2553819715976715,
-0.7451996803283691,
-0.33470815420150757,
-0.6591352224349976,
-0.6014813184738159,
-0.7648218274116516,
-0.018157511949539185,
0.3027326762676239,
0.15473943948745728,
0.5812628865242004,
1.5256192684173584,
-0.8570266962051392,
-0.40204566717147827,
-0.5223225355148315,
0.2430436760187149,
0.03595990315079689,
0.4352234899997711,
0.31275954842567444,
-1.0112015008926392,
-0.5468863248825073,
-0.27860185503959656,
-0.11491633206605911,
-0.11841364949941635,
-0.48107415437698364,
-0.09479720890522003,
-0.23691929876804352,
0.21305201947689056,
-0.7355730533599854,
0.6682464480400085,
0.49814295768737793,
-0.5650068521499634,
0.7529586553573608,
0.3687393367290497,
0.24799947440624237,
-1.10910165309906,
0.024894556030631065,
-0.44949832558631897,
-0.19468240439891815,
-0.5615703463554382,
-0.24060265719890594,
-0.18388986587524414,
-0.1701040267944336,
-0.4136667549610138,
0.6454578638076782,
-0.21413397789001465,
-0.20077913999557495,
-0.1809430718421936,
0.003784378059208393,
0.4456292688846588,
0.5452896356582642,
0.48292797803878784,
0.8026019334793091,
0.0010454097064211965,
-0.7653149366378784,
-0.24185273051261902,
0.9337300658226013,
-0.41737210750579834,
0.8639259934425354,
-0.5872300863265991,
0.05045456439256668,
0.1525026112794876,
0.5316952466964722,
-1.0310267210006714,
0.06437494605779648,
0.4127630293369293,
-0.7731168270111084,
0.23174172639846802,
-0.40837299823760986,
-0.17386552691459656,
-0.2745639979839325,
-0.22144903242588043,
0.6513311266899109,
0.23358751833438873,
-0.012189018540084362,
0.6195282936096191,
0.24101002514362335,
-0.37927037477493286,
-0.3414299786090851,
-0.49749425053596497,
-0.22140926122665405,
-0.2735618054866791,
-0.6756501197814941,
0.5552117228507996,
-0.19092391431331635,
-0.20282505452632904,
-0.11283672600984573,
-0.46574363112449646,
-0.016183972358703613,
-0.09739352017641068,
0.36296865344047546,
-0.14342252910137177,
-0.12780694663524628,
-0.16774791479110718,
0.060141224414110184,
-0.34300506114959717,
0.25245997309684753,
-0.4892725944519043,
0.6260249614715576,
0.041862841695547104,
-0.6964593529701233,
-0.39530476927757263,
0.4333379864692688,
0.39459967613220215,
-0.35694533586502075,
0.404915988445282,
0.3678893446922302,
0.19399049878120422,
0.2696976065635681,
-0.5783255696296692,
-0.1992122232913971,
-0.49986743927001953,
0.015493040904402733,
-0.3458731472492218,
-0.7398950457572937,
0.6560875773429871,
-0.17603793740272522,
0.48472723364830017,
0.11974573135375977,
0.17389367520809174,
0.1017756313085556,
1.0431535243988037,
0.4867519438266754,
0.2981289327144623,
0.4736100435256958,
-0.3056330978870392,
0.30010074377059937,
-0.8792554140090942,
-0.09108024835586548,
-0.4503459632396698,
-0.4262784719467163,
-0.1355821192264557,
-0.5259931087493896,
0.25556331872940063,
-0.23483902215957642,
-0.008234466426074505,
0.39585793018341064,
-0.21335285902023315,
0.11586161702871323,
0.46672412753105164,
-0.3406679630279541,
0.6060537099838257,
-0.3455694019794464,
-0.22994865477085114,
-0.5406525135040283,
-0.8973582983016968,
-0.40440598130226135,
1.0024243593215942,
0.14681217074394226,
0.32580864429473877,
-0.19912764430046082,
0.5297085642814636,
0.12096284329891205,
0.1556350141763687,
-1.0785064697265625,
0.6279448866844177,
0.3560512661933899,
-0.7579160332679749,
-0.31865084171295166,
-0.41948527097702026,
-0.667848527431488,
0.14462149143218994,
-0.30622199177742004,
-0.411891371011734,
-0.0002583043242339045,
0.15818336606025696,
-0.37513238191604614,
0.29312944412231445,
-0.5948747396469116,
0.5465685129165649,
-0.04211999103426933,
-0.3066900670528412,
-0.2797467112541199,
-0.6991013884544373,
0.20476555824279785,
-0.12921729683876038,
0.24546895921230316,
-0.14482207596302032,
0.30346423387527466,
0.7923293709754944,
-0.09776264429092407,
0.6573039889335632,
-0.2011721432209015,
-0.2515765428543091,
0.6275173425674438,
0.3100318908691406,
0.43013396859169006,
0.28709784150123596,
0.11314479261636734,
-0.4947858452796936,
-0.1181129515171051,
-0.40527376532554626,
-0.7045543193817139,
0.10085976868867874,
-0.4413459300994873,
-0.6910736560821533,
-0.15371569991111755,
-0.6964918971061707,
-0.5929444432258606,
0.2772527039051056,
0.33945322036743164,
0.37195122241973877,
-0.648986279964447,
-0.06324131786823273,
0.7858069539070129,
-0.1653490960597992,
0.2435312271118164,
0.7873741984367371,
-0.03206002339720726,
-0.38010919094085693,
0.7613074779510498,
-0.07900629937648773,
0.8939274549484253,
0.2794209122657776,
0.289497971534729,
-0.2926507592201233,
-0.6210411190986633,
-0.1845637857913971,
-0.08928443491458893,
-0.6624457240104675,
-0.2260708510875702,
-0.41537758708000183,
-0.10353367775678635,
-0.45402002334594727,
-0.5768630504608154,
-0.7173464894294739,
-0.7260624170303345,
-0.15011033415794373,
-0.2609294354915619,
-0.14112114906311035,
0.5100260972976685,
0.058758046478033066,
0.5998349785804749,
-0.7569521069526672,
0.25991785526275635,
0.14667217433452606,
0.171036958694458,
-0.24293829500675201,
-0.4803903102874756,
-0.22447597980499268,
0.4175160229206085,
-0.4720514714717865,
-0.5988004207611084,
0.11126715689897537,
0.12381371855735779,
0.5052509903907776,
0.7337133884429932,
0.4657151401042938,
0.7151020765304565,
-0.47454315423965454,
0.9184362292289734,
0.41799256205558777,
-0.8270204663276672,
0.6589057445526123,
-0.44356417655944824,
0.5808265209197998,
1.0175977945327759,
0.3718368709087372,
-0.6354668140411377,
-0.7887052297592163,
-0.9698577523231506,
-0.7652527689933777,
0.5243576169013977,
0.5031304359436035,
0.2516361474990845,
0.13804353773593903,
0.11873476952314377,
0.2758478820323944,
0.5950044989585876,
-0.3917422294616699,
0.18171614408493042,
-0.32843443751335144,
0.16718874871730804,
0.08594409376382828,
-0.10170022398233414,
-0.5460540056228638,
-0.09416656196117401,
0.39571622014045715,
-0.5353296995162964,
0.3242093026638031,
0.1341983824968338,
0.025190113112330437,
-0.17599086463451385,
0.3666384220123291,
0.4772045314311981,
0.7907307147979736,
0.005050770007073879,
-0.21689173579216003,
-0.056994374841451645,
-0.5164848566055298,
0.024244286119937897,
-0.21407324075698853,
-0.26384443044662476,
-0.10648823529481888,
0.30079352855682373,
0.6950333714485168,
0.5900035500526428,
-0.5943177342414856,
0.5599825382232666,
-0.28090721368789673,
-0.4042423963546753,
-0.23022833466529846,
0.25755003094673157,
-0.022739442065358162,
0.1453353315591812,
0.0511784702539444,
-0.0680772066116333,
0.05423879623413086,
-0.43086758255958557,
0.3354789912700653,
0.4045526683330536,
-0.6697509288787842,
-0.20357148349285126,
0.463388592004776,
0.3230813443660736,
-0.15728023648262024,
0.6047850251197815,
-0.024765541777014732,
-0.7686519622802734,
0.4041382968425751,
0.2962121367454529,
0.6693071722984314,
-0.0768420398235321,
0.7950711250305176,
0.18441027402877808,
-0.07022099196910858,
0.2897944450378418,
0.3566008508205414,
-0.33684346079826355,
-0.9216395616531372,
-0.541282057762146,
-0.4715123176574707,
-0.3422459661960602,
-0.3351716995239258,
-0.8842307329177856,
0.33229362964630127,
-0.5293524265289307,
-0.30128130316734314,
-0.3232070803642273,
0.29208919405937195,
-0.6057665944099426,
0.29410645365715027,
-0.06668474525213242,
1.0756081342697144,
-0.7756584286689758,
0.020870855078101158,
0.4705514907836914,
-0.33364903926849365,
-1.0490084886550903,
0.2963831126689911,
0.17535632848739624,
-0.7829602360725403,
0.26152321696281433,
0.08331518620252609,
-0.26322460174560547,
0.11797048896551132,
-0.35220447182655334,
-0.7236567139625549,
1.3058305978775024,
0.07959752529859543,
-0.1170814260840416,
-0.4209851026535034,
0.4995848834514618,
0.22999325394630432,
-0.2766824960708618,
0.10569775104522705,
0.5905800461769104,
0.4913657307624817,
0.7524315714836121,
-0.8502642512321472,
0.08750735968351364,
0.16678787767887115,
-0.4544498920440674,
0.16058780252933502,
-0.5906132459640503,
0.3916080594062805,
-0.2447434365749359,
-0.35206112265586853,
0.11716801673173904,
0.7686902284622192,
0.22938595712184906,
0.3482794761657715,
0.6818003058433533,
0.6257469654083252,
0.40666159987449646,
0.09534448385238647,
0.7432107925415039,
-0.24564941227436066,
-0.08037547767162323,
1.1177781820297241,
-0.30332303047180176,
0.5779803991317749,
0.6638620495796204,
-0.09368246048688889,
0.38431882858276367,
0.5753013491630554,
0.42447441816329956,
0.7566978931427002,
0.2365821748971939,
-0.4809509813785553,
-0.12914225459098816,
-0.5617234110832214,
-0.38725048303604126,
0.509367823600769,
0.619199275970459,
-0.12145153433084488,
-0.2014683037996292,
-0.42296624183654785,
0.10333061963319778,
0.08881065994501114,
-0.30546197295188904,
1.0433354377746582,
0.15087805688381195,
-1.2814736366271973,
0.19911092519760132,
-0.24934068322181702,
0.16788996756076813,
-0.8319564461708069,
0.1560811698436737,
-0.09392095357179642,
-0.16627812385559082,
-0.0678449347615242,
-1.1626724004745483,
0.388985276222229,
-0.2836582660675049,
-0.06673654913902283,
-0.7404119968414307,
0.8076493144035339,
-0.3907076120376587,
0.12396926432847977,
0.04804356023669243,
0.6076481342315674,
-0.3074408769607544,
-0.36508065462112427,
-0.4608874022960663,
-0.2849363088607788,
0.06975813955068588,
-0.3119153380393982,
0.424103707075119,
0.535753607749939,
-0.024391643702983856,
0.6039113998413086,
0.8554105758666992,
0.07327347993850708,
-0.23356406390666962,
-0.14803174138069153,
1.239208698272705,
-0.3739565312862396,
-1.014329195022583,
-0.11485867947340012,
0.9591496586799622,
-0.16940614581108093,
-0.44508597254753113,
0.24433007836341858,
0.5592280626296997,
0.9631918668746948,
0.13392005860805511,
0.7446135878562927,
-0.20973153412342072,
0.1924109309911728,
-0.6971293687820435,
0.6204244494438171,
-0.41122671961784363,
0.07584497332572937,
-0.39604300260543823,
-1.0231739282608032,
0.1526579111814499,
0.4417407214641571,
-0.33946654200553894,
-0.38956210017204285,
0.7789739370346069,
0.43818026781082153,
-0.01780523918569088,
0.26222559809684753,
0.24941961467266083,
-0.4909448027610779,
0.7399274110794067,
0.6180548071861267,
1.0615458488464355,
0.24808618426322937,
0.7070316672325134,
0.08944873511791229,
-0.12911245226860046,
0.1337665617465973,
-0.9336241483688354,
-0.7176798582077026,
-0.6596717238426208,
-0.11633868515491486,
-0.31795138120651245,
-0.03285195678472519,
0.5271628499031067,
0.6153073906898499,
-0.4330611824989319,
-0.060348641127347946,
-0.35293468832969666,
0.1051359623670578,
0.06428100168704987,
-0.16728748381137848,
-0.1614467352628708,
-0.212845116853714,
-0.3331618010997772,
0.14889433979988098,
-0.027005691081285477,
0.0747518539428711,
-0.3075217306613922,
-0.3373260796070099,
-0.0757150873541832,
0.14892126619815826,
0.37470099329948425,
0.5007115006446838,
-0.38087818026542664,
-0.3873940110206604,
0.1234830692410469,
0.10301714390516281,
0.08622542023658752,
1.7074798345565796,
-0.8856757283210754,
0.3525974750518799,
0.434415727853775,
0.6550390720367432,
0.5892916917800903,
0.29014280438423157,
1.2644248008728027,
-1.04410982131958,
0.14142747223377228,
0.691972017288208,
-0.08872909098863602,
0.23713234066963196,
-0.2867805063724518,
0.42606303095817566,
-0.06545501202344894,
-0.39119574427604675,
-0.28915753960609436,
1.0045870542526245,
-0.8862260580062866,
-0.029535280540585518,
1.179390788078308,
-0.4291827082633972,
0.33819180727005005,
-0.26343584060668945,
-0.4701843857765198,
0.37037500739097595,
-0.3518943786621094,
0.6611537337303162,
1.075213074684143,
-0.10005632042884827,
0.12640146911144257,
-0.5676458477973938,
0.924490749835968,
0.7679126858711243,
-0.5006735920906067,
0.04154208302497864,
0.5401961207389832,
-0.07854235172271729,
0.3817013204097748,
1.0704429149627686,
0.13809941709041595,
0.16087743639945984,
-0.07423647493124008,
-0.5103626847267151,
0.15280495584011078,
-0.5668835639953613,
0.45843908190727234,
-0.22121088206768036,
0.12902715802192688,
0.06214269623160362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02057v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02057v1 | Break the Sequential Dependency of LLM Inference Using Lookahead Decoding | 2024-02-03T06:37:50 | 2024-02-03T06:37:50 | Yichao Fu, Peter Bailis, Ion Stoica, Hao Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Autoregressive decoding of large language models (LLMs) is memory bandwidth
bounded, resulting in high latency and significant wastes of the parallel
processing power of modern accelerators. Existing methods for accelerating LLM
decoding often require a draft model (e.g., speculative decoding), which is
nontrivial to obtain and unable to generalize. In this paper, we introduce
Lookahead decoding, an exact, parallel decoding algorithm that accelerates LLM
decoding without needing auxiliary models or data stores. It allows trading
per-step log(FLOPs) to reduce the number of total decoding steps, is more
parallelizable on single or multiple modern accelerators, and is compatible
with concurrent memory-efficient attention (e.g., FlashAttention). Our
implementation of Lookahead decoding can speed up autoregressive decoding by up
to 1.8x on MT-bench and 4x with strong scaling on multiple GPUs in code
completion tasks. Our code is avialable at
https://github.com/hao-ai-lab/LookaheadDecoding | [
0.031899385154247284,
-0.6024746298789978,
0.5366923213005066,
0.5677486062049866,
-0.29639750719070435,
0.29074975848197937,
0.029923047870397568,
-0.6783865094184875,
0.35345882177352905,
0.6607581973075867,
-0.4066210389137268,
-0.5335265398025513,
-0.7434759736061096,
0.14096622169017792,
-0.5242400765419006,
0.240524023771286,
-0.36955946683883667,
-0.1995318979024887,
0.11920322477817535,
-0.26935556530952454,
-0.16524633765220642,
-0.17606663703918457,
-0.6595238447189331,
-0.3255237340927124,
0.3902244567871094,
0.4407103657722473,
0.6580507159233093,
1.135754942893982,
0.4176924228668213,
0.32805511355400085,
-0.1471051275730133,
0.18338346481323242,
-0.5200677514076233,
0.23922847211360931,
0.2381666749715805,
-0.5876697897911072,
-0.6411737203598022,
-0.15708096325397491,
0.4974095821380615,
0.39042869210243225,
-0.44360288977622986,
0.35910314321517944,
-0.05735400691628456,
0.7856435775756836,
-0.9021891951560974,
0.3334724009037018,
-0.4116029143333435,
0.01184871792793274,
-0.3663363456726074,
-0.41665560007095337,
-0.648700475692749,
-0.43008530139923096,
-0.19791512191295624,
-0.47927477955818176,
0.11820032447576523,
0.22830671072006226,
0.47945088148117065,
0.7067511677742004,
-0.1390763819217682,
0.054496295750141144,
-0.5195532441139221,
0.7207805514335632,
-1.086428165435791,
0.5473495125770569,
0.4549590051174164,
0.096147820353508,
-0.26856616139411926,
-0.7375714778900146,
-0.5844449400901794,
0.07044759392738342,
0.05791638046503067,
-0.006942195817828178,
-0.015528501942753792,
0.1398869901895523,
0.39580655097961426,
0.44719648361206055,
-0.7006084322929382,
0.1530645191669464,
0.0866977721452713,
-0.030119514092803,
0.3586554229259491,
0.28214600682258606,
0.183161199092865,
0.03073696978390217,
-0.11178509891033173,
-0.20360729098320007,
-0.7299771904945374,
-0.1011744812130928,
0.13294261693954468,
-0.17014889419078827,
-0.2574998736381531,
0.38394057750701904,
-0.4308624565601349,
0.504255473613739,
0.07381822913885117,
-0.015104672871530056,
0.41761237382888794,
-0.2392837554216385,
-0.35538405179977417,
0.08840624243021011,
0.8136011958122253,
-0.05283782631158829,
0.242334246635437,
-0.012500512413680553,
-0.019272536039352417,
-0.0950566753745079,
0.19850020110607147,
-0.8127354383468628,
-0.21399715542793274,
0.5484734177589417,
-0.7077925205230713,
-0.1949130892753601,
-0.3363650143146515,
-0.9560912251472473,
0.12077106535434723,
-0.06722186505794525,
-0.03157069534063339,
-0.39899012446403503,
-0.04327034950256348,
0.4261970520019531,
0.0061258357018232346,
0.4710579812526703,
0.20467598736286163,
-1.082582950592041,
0.4606969952583313,
0.5087697505950928,
0.8709098100662231,
-0.03222798928618431,
-0.6045070886611938,
-0.7646482586860657,
0.2777840793132782,
-0.3888612389564514,
0.8132587671279907,
-0.3951207101345062,
-0.25630491971969604,
-0.015263277105987072,
-0.25143253803253174,
0.001174367032945156,
-0.7373931407928467,
0.5398156642913818,
-0.8652040958404541,
-0.37038204073905945,
0.018954355269670486,
-0.5311923027038574,
-0.2234792411327362,
-0.010500967502593994,
-0.7703768014907837,
0.7659733891487122,
-0.26516029238700867,
-0.6367612481117249,
0.04597137123346329,
-0.3278082609176636,
-0.6384323835372925,
-0.03358127549290657,
-0.16847503185272217,
-0.21268293261528015,
0.26090380549430847,
0.6237790584564209,
0.014073057100176811,
-0.3262869417667389,
0.12435032427310944,
-0.5027223825454712,
-0.5892520546913147,
-0.107049360871315,
-0.4346010684967041,
0.6773797273635864,
0.16252018511295319,
-0.6401790380477905,
0.2766679525375366,
-0.7368306517601013,
0.02570689097046852,
0.4404260218143463,
-0.458846777677536,
-0.14020785689353943,
0.2645425796508789,
-0.11336755007505417,
-0.20995719730854034,
0.49545013904571533,
-0.40882763266563416,
0.2607680857181549,
-0.32990604639053345,
0.15967854857444763,
0.6704663634300232,
-0.2954266369342804,
0.11740071326494217,
-0.11941995471715927,
0.5029162764549255,
0.006690895650535822,
-0.0746321976184845,
-0.5304679870605469,
-0.29402536153793335,
-0.9189229011535645,
-0.42901912331581116,
0.16783306002616882,
0.6841766238212585,
-0.7783615589141846,
0.28616049885749817,
-0.13134537637233734,
-0.12292835861444473,
-0.9009009003639221,
0.21411798894405365,
0.564896285533905,
0.4430617690086365,
0.6006408929824829,
-0.186649352312088,
-0.5859895944595337,
-0.9563226699829102,
-0.4932664632797241,
-0.07723215222358704,
-0.030862202867865562,
0.02231641672551632,
0.061603620648384094,
-0.16789516806602478,
0.36171388626098633,
-0.579571008682251,
-0.011664079502224922,
-0.05949603021144867,
0.2506236433982849,
0.41381534934043884,
0.46979981660842896,
0.1463201940059662,
-0.2605970799922943,
-0.4164130985736847,
-0.24543875455856323,
-1.0566277503967285,
-0.17364327609539032,
-0.060659512877464294,
-0.22820687294006348,
0.11684390902519226,
0.8185683488845825,
-0.731874942779541,
0.5441770553588867,
0.4774976074695587,
-0.37991151213645935,
0.5242384076118469,
-0.45812392234802246,
0.1643512099981308,
-0.6420742869377136,
-0.01913319155573845,
-0.4059026539325714,
-0.5071601867675781,
-0.3759227693080902,
0.40503165125846863,
0.1691925823688507,
0.28447210788726807,
-0.2672785818576813,
0.6255641579627991,
-0.5694055557250977,
-0.10604827851057053,
-0.44416382908821106,
-0.17965613305568695,
-0.021424973383545876,
0.3623654842376709,
0.1839073896408081,
0.88737952709198,
0.6298145055770874,
-0.3529263436794281,
0.0533587671816349,
0.4519418478012085,
-0.32206296920776367,
-0.23622295260429382,
-0.6439231634140015,
0.4080734848976135,
0.09112603217363358,
0.4582355320453644,
-0.6567075848579407,
-0.09450282156467438,
0.22912895679473877,
-0.2315719872713089,
0.19243499636650085,
-0.08678139746189117,
-0.6609904766082764,
-0.34691712260246277,
-0.24177582561969757,
0.972083330154419,
0.7772911787033081,
-1.1210029125213623,
0.6555881500244141,
0.15874794125556946,
-0.03626713156700134,
-0.8221641778945923,
-0.7628121972084045,
0.15319818258285522,
0.07392394542694092,
-0.5141465663909912,
0.3562273681163788,
-0.130915105342865,
-0.1706676036119461,
-0.07117767632007599,
-0.2315043807029724,
0.07211053371429443,
-0.10469204932451248,
-0.04568474739789963,
0.27534249424934387,
-0.28088369965553284,
-0.5373090505599976,
0.08544363081455231,
-0.24578110873699188,
0.15773659944534302,
-0.5182675123214722,
0.6239332556724548,
0.08633601665496826,
-0.23187600076198578,
-0.663112223148346,
0.3946911096572876,
0.6869633197784424,
-0.21401101350784302,
0.733214795589447,
0.44012564420700073,
-0.14640334248542786,
-0.43665918707847595,
-0.5807616114616394,
0.04722021520137787,
-0.5511012673377991,
0.10323648899793625,
-0.45356860756874084,
-0.8427280783653259,
0.6669453978538513,
-0.01588943973183632,
0.1466979831457138,
0.18730460107326508,
0.7395099997520447,
0.15965677797794342,
0.8210838437080383,
0.4566093385219574,
-0.21152976155281067,
0.37644481658935547,
-0.03907983377575874,
0.12901300191879272,
-0.6160323619842529,
-0.05558255314826965,
-0.2995600998401642,
-0.31422656774520874,
-0.27619612216949463,
-0.6326119899749756,
-0.15179842710494995,
0.06998558342456818,
-0.13704492151737213,
0.15172500908374786,
-0.10970792919397354,
0.656978964805603,
0.6691793203353882,
0.2927594780921936,
0.6006090641021729,
0.03241116926074028,
-0.038801178336143494,
0.21381255984306335,
-0.5760018825531006,
-0.02893543615937233,
1.1829943656921387,
0.3588934540748596,
0.8996228575706482,
0.11860668659210205,
0.9070932865142822,
0.4047541618347168,
0.24635125696659088,
-0.7349243760108948,
0.6211403012275696,
-0.3222804069519043,
0.064358189702034,
-0.01758943870663643,
-0.6167277097702026,
-0.6762019991874695,
0.31349658966064453,
0.294101357460022,
-0.538029670715332,
0.26017510890960693,
0.29166749119758606,
-0.2502022683620453,
0.23690097033977509,
-0.2613906264305115,
0.6502507328987122,
0.04024852067232132,
-0.35649916529655457,
-0.6396284699440002,
-0.22437240183353424,
0.7099609375,
-0.06666842103004456,
0.042930968105793,
-0.03529512137174606,
-0.024898430332541466,
0.889071524143219,
-0.7153264880180359,
0.6049049496650696,
-0.06150589883327484,
-0.178251713514328,
0.24133038520812988,
0.24047191441059113,
0.7435122132301331,
-0.10800918936729431,
-0.0223863385617733,
0.4700556993484497,
-0.15143832564353943,
-0.8001837730407715,
-0.48893049359321594,
0.5818928480148315,
-0.5464816689491272,
-0.6145562529563904,
-0.25504404306411743,
-0.5575778484344482,
-0.2408704310655594,
0.27894559502601624,
0.21246227622032166,
0.2364286184310913,
-0.06796102225780487,
-0.48087549209594727,
0.659114420413971,
-0.0009623332880437374,
0.5580320954322815,
0.536687433719635,
-0.4808148145675659,
-0.3434434235095978,
0.7808700203895569,
-0.34265103936195374,
0.15209466218948364,
0.24936498701572418,
-0.10381666570901871,
-0.3089185953140259,
-0.9804139733314514,
-0.2656788229942322,
0.3631778359413147,
-0.6004330515861511,
-0.05032804608345032,
-0.6731811761856079,
-0.17064949870109558,
-0.4039522111415863,
-0.041467055678367615,
-0.515651524066925,
-0.13764338195323944,
-0.17772997915744781,
0.09585656225681305,
0.25140413641929626,
0.6108796000480652,
-0.15128976106643677,
0.563473105430603,
-1.0463545322418213,
0.8865419030189514,
0.17876964807510376,
0.3330095112323761,
0.3919183611869812,
-0.7431693077087402,
-0.4189186990261078,
-0.46629565954208374,
-0.0061597321182489395,
-0.6191737651824951,
0.6517683267593384,
-0.1908312737941742,
0.32754895091056824,
0.5764703750610352,
0.09181398898363113,
0.9056504964828491,
-0.932641327381134,
0.1351783275604248,
-0.04765594005584717,
-1.0640311241149902,
0.2291344255208969,
-0.29233813285827637,
0.7370518445968628,
0.5800191760063171,
0.19707918167114258,
-0.2238604724407196,
-0.3703222870826721,
-0.423521488904953,
-0.9197553396224976,
0.7081983089447021,
0.13716243207454681,
-0.22639141976833344,
-0.20196084678173065,
0.27941107749938965,
0.18120479583740234,
0.03585916757583618,
-0.3467160761356354,
-0.2954658269882202,
0.07732082903385162,
-0.4350912570953369,
-0.018107930198311806,
-0.592167854309082,
0.009463016875088215,
-0.054787155240774155,
0.41662144660949707,
-0.06916629523038864,
0.2919079661369324,
0.1938399374485016,
-0.23986566066741943,
-0.18787309527397156,
0.043905749917030334,
0.21611036360263824,
0.4408545196056366,
-0.5296897888183594,
0.1273086667060852,
-0.2522013485431671,
-0.6787186861038208,
0.06981256604194641,
0.3022845387458801,
-0.13186226785182953,
-0.03823796659708023,
0.6180335283279419,
0.7648943662643433,
0.2932131886482239,
-0.8623844385147095,
0.05349588766694069,
-0.3030771017074585,
-0.1349620819091797,
-0.22137422859668732,
0.012505641207098961,
0.038100652396678925,
0.6069977283477783,
0.40660133957862854,
-0.052208177745342255,
0.262832909822464,
-0.33779585361480713,
0.4164820611476898,
0.1414099633693695,
0.36179089546203613,
-0.13877904415130615,
0.9086700081825256,
0.15637719631195068,
-0.28375697135925293,
1.0083198547363281,
-0.023188551887869835,
-0.26988503336906433,
0.6836485266685486,
0.55218505859375,
1.2428011894226074,
-0.32675525546073914,
-0.13506461679935455,
0.31288784742355347,
0.19425886869430542,
-0.48364436626434326,
0.45582425594329834,
-0.14712391793727875,
-0.6763907074928284,
-0.7544740438461304,
-1.0219011306762695,
-0.5405821800231934,
0.055486228317022324,
-0.7341881394386292,
-0.1799841821193695,
-0.6684597730636597,
0.1704932451248169,
-0.18911370635032654,
-0.6009552478790283,
-0.5124723315238953,
-0.19772818684577942,
0.40384992957115173,
1.1554979085922241,
-0.16665668785572052,
1.166560411453247,
0.07914859056472778,
0.08070224523544312,
-0.44929996132850647,
0.54097580909729,
0.16367337107658386,
-1.1033748388290405,
0.7392053008079529,
0.3955843448638916,
-0.23058103024959564,
0.18830707669258118,
-0.5290130972862244,
-1.168857216835022,
0.8943594098091125,
0.3116615414619446,
-0.9239448308944702,
-0.26057395339012146,
-0.11174672096967697,
0.2375802993774414,
-0.440197616815567,
0.36351150274276733,
0.8922119140625,
0.29651063680648804,
0.07594643533229828,
-0.7809984683990479,
0.28829294443130493,
-0.06892746686935425,
-0.2521195113658905,
0.17098073661327362,
-0.5917667746543884,
0.5776441693305969,
-0.4411103427410126,
-0.17196981608867645,
0.2533329129219055,
0.9685580730438232,
0.3877226412296295,
0.21009668707847595,
0.26935702562332153,
0.8947792649269104,
0.6055416464805603,
0.3840937614440918,
1.0771855115890503,
-0.49469074606895447,
0.2820255756378174,
1.6316787004470825,
-0.35070499777793884,
1.198033332824707,
0.3736104965209961,
-0.34687477350234985,
0.3723878562450409,
0.6471595764160156,
0.19583380222320557,
0.5339636206626892,
-0.034268759191036224,
-0.3369743525981903,
-0.34831535816192627,
0.2594142556190491,
-0.14811377227306366,
0.41979098320007324,
0.3825950622558594,
-0.29532408714294434,
-0.27053624391555786,
-0.26749223470687866,
-0.04788186401128769,
-0.25045254826545715,
-0.26577362418174744,
0.4855048656463623,
0.3160684406757355,
-0.556947648525238,
1.0709737539291382,
-0.05470344424247742,
0.6171557903289795,
-0.5018625855445862,
-0.1669328510761261,
-0.4360380172729492,
0.32741326093673706,
-0.028281204402446747,
-0.49848371744155884,
0.39972808957099915,
-0.07658085227012634,
-0.3211607038974762,
-0.10100193321704865,
0.39861270785331726,
-0.3950096368789673,
-0.3260100781917572,
0.9305208921432495,
0.612949788570404,
0.16722337901592255,
0.01710006222128868,
-0.643554151058197,
0.37844181060791016,
0.20907028019428253,
-0.586381196975708,
0.4726964235305786,
-0.04926462098956108,
0.3260587751865387,
0.6686228513717651,
0.8680052161216736,
0.00979689322412014,
0.2954542934894562,
0.006578145548701286,
0.8118147850036621,
-1.0849473476409912,
-0.44597601890563965,
-0.9623442888259888,
0.16767095029354095,
0.3101857006549835,
0.06622759997844696,
0.5627666711807251,
0.34517595171928406,
0.6429621577262878,
0.06433641165494919,
0.5891866087913513,
0.1585759073495865,
0.17393195629119873,
-0.8771677613258362,
0.5885089635848999,
-0.49190381169319153,
0.4311659634113312,
0.3328537344932556,
-0.8272677659988403,
-0.0787048414349556,
0.17892329394817352,
-0.1346912533044815,
-0.24412751197814941,
0.7861542105674744,
0.48612159490585327,
-0.05810987204313278,
-0.0574885718524456,
0.3107185661792755,
0.759391725063324,
0.16101595759391785,
0.4825602173805237,
0.2912169396877289,
-0.24686776101589203,
0.3884660303592682,
-0.14686188101768494,
-0.3917361795902252,
-0.14114172756671906,
-0.5740975141525269,
-0.830621063709259,
0.13377262651920319,
-0.14997656643390656,
-0.6218547821044922,
0.12274344265460968,
0.4605160057544708,
0.4554261863231659,
-0.6725450158119202,
-0.49065715074539185,
-0.24738122522830963,
0.09279484301805496,
-0.21447224915027618,
-0.23173165321350098,
0.48497655987739563,
-0.5777397751808167,
-0.8316481709480286,
0.9473913908004761,
0.5500332713127136,
-0.22460432350635529,
-0.09832406789064407,
-0.11068602651357651,
-0.29889583587646484,
0.2557752728462219,
0.5070500373840332,
0.72966468334198,
-0.7348841428756714,
0.18173745274543762,
-0.3113808333873749,
0.06574343144893646,
0.390076220035553,
0.8184059262275696,
-1.0453444719314575,
0.27212318778038025,
0.5007522106170654,
0.8784693479537964,
0.811198353767395,
-0.000392086454667151,
0.529922366142273,
-0.08078590035438538,
0.4741049110889435,
0.04634873941540718,
0.5109285116195679,
-0.09146738052368164,
-0.44294121861457825,
0.41629186272621155,
0.34141531586647034,
-0.6187151074409485,
-0.5119364857673645,
0.2920987010002136,
-1.0050936937332153,
-0.3127478361129761,
0.7030683755874634,
-0.2844850420951843,
-0.6889078617095947,
-0.019383898004889488,
0.3741290271282196,
0.107069231569767,
-0.6656029224395752,
0.6380442380905151,
0.40212589502334595,
-0.3421967327594757,
-0.5368629097938538,
-0.5399654507637024,
0.3412497937679291,
0.762752890586853,
-0.7491218447685242,
0.51981520652771,
0.4077613353729248,
0.13426139950752258,
-0.1458907425403595,
0.834881067276001,
-0.11471235752105713,
0.2224157601594925,
0.36066851019859314,
0.15801548957824707,
-0.0805206373333931,
-0.25923168659210205,
-0.5309287905693054,
0.1022198274731636,
-0.0078068883158266544,
-0.1995062232017517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02056v1 | AnthroScore: A Computational Linguistic Measure of Anthropomorphism | 2024-02-03T06:36:11 | 2024-02-03T06:36:11 | Myra Cheng, Kristina Gligoric, Tiziano Piccardi, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Anthropomorphism, or the attribution of human-like characteristics to
non-human entities, has shaped conversations about the impacts and
possibilities of technology. We present AnthroScore, an automatic metric of
implicit anthropomorphism in language. We use a masked language model to
quantify how non-human entities are implicitly framed as human by the
surrounding context. We show that AnthroScore corresponds with human judgments
of anthropomorphism and dimensions of anthropomorphism described in social
science literature. Motivated by concerns of misleading anthropomorphism in
computer science discourse, we use AnthroScore to analyze 15 years of research
papers and downstream news articles. In research papers, we find that
anthropomorphism has steadily increased over time, and that papers related to
language models have the most anthropomorphism. Within ACL papers, temporal
increases in anthropomorphism are correlated with key neural advancements.
Building upon concerns of scientific misinformation in mass media, we identify
higher levels of anthropomorphism in news headlines compared to the research
papers they cite. Since AnthroScore is lexicon-free, it can be directly applied
to a wide range of text sources. | [
-0.4180956780910492,
-0.7452535629272461,
0.4363248944282532,
-0.08595973998308182,
-0.2856302857398987,
0.3046436011791229,
-0.24067477881908417,
-0.9043952822685242,
0.4965384602546692,
-0.0728708952665329,
-0.33633747696876526,
-0.33657658100128174,
-0.6381161212921143,
0.18975350260734558,
-0.5574651956558228,
0.7265010476112366,
0.02170799858868122,
-0.09586481004953384,
-0.47330063581466675,
-0.3344648778438568,
0.11260440945625305,
-0.5664799213409424,
-0.20564979314804077,
-0.4084136486053467,
0.2759605944156647,
0.09639355540275574,
1.2527689933776855,
0.9955637454986572,
0.031475938856601715,
0.4401896893978119,
-0.3564682900905609,
-0.020574647933244705,
0.15043142437934875,
0.019441602751612663,
-0.35269811749458313,
-0.20194804668426514,
-0.4139329791069031,
0.5059952735900879,
0.7282148599624634,
0.8599405884742737,
-0.1540829986333847,
0.6527430415153503,
0.13262394070625305,
0.47846972942352295,
-0.5663076043128967,
0.05122789740562439,
-0.3874260187149048,
0.08256149291992188,
-0.09992635995149612,
-0.041761189699172974,
0.15396800637245178,
-0.24380359053611755,
-0.16745640337467194,
-0.6760126948356628,
0.4833256006240845,
0.5571320652961731,
0.49800702929496765,
0.39939236640930176,
-0.2590980529785156,
-0.4234689474105835,
-0.5848260521888733,
0.7847827076911926,
-0.2875458598136902,
0.5677436590194702,
0.5597161054611206,
0.15375873446464539,
0.1023145467042923,
-0.027651390060782433,
-0.8572441339492798,
-0.41507065296173096,
-0.004952569957822561,
-0.14485977590084076,
-0.03676857054233551,
-0.3197975754737854,
0.1477404236793518,
0.3446182906627655,
-0.6878228187561035,
-0.2736000716686249,
-0.5304762125015259,
-0.5022391080856323,
0.7608202695846558,
-0.024209732189774513,
0.6501456499099731,
-0.49384504556655884,
-0.07295964658260345,
-0.003055752022191882,
-0.5023688077926636,
-0.015548581257462502,
0.4711051881313324,
0.1492461860179901,
-0.2884731888771057,
0.4724012315273285,
-0.022384921088814735,
0.551140546798706,
-0.21641027927398682,
-0.182521253824234,
0.21960242092609406,
0.034714475274086,
0.18564264476299286,
0.6282625794410706,
0.376675009727478,
0.2746458649635315,
0.12765558063983917,
-0.508092999458313,
0.17150425910949707,
0.5864170789718628,
0.40174761414527893,
-0.39217841625213623,
-0.08194541186094284,
-0.09133560955524445,
-0.3333091735839844,
-0.3781798779964447,
-0.051722798496484756,
-0.47745102643966675,
-0.6984573006629944,
-0.39142367243766785,
-0.04463925212621689,
-0.20282284915447235,
-0.47233128547668457,
-0.12089836597442627,
-0.05090058967471123,
0.02286168560385704,
0.31747516989707947,
-0.46966707706451416,
0.44744426012039185,
0.8887676000595093,
1.1017447710037231,
-0.12425335496664047,
-0.5305647850036621,
-0.13260610401630402,
0.18615397810935974,
-0.7502411603927612,
0.9646086692810059,
-0.4629359245300293,
-0.27397727966308594,
-0.35679754614830017,
0.05490969493985176,
0.21612225472927094,
-0.3176990747451782,
0.5142210721969604,
-0.22094608843326569,
0.3132789134979248,
0.026303907856345177,
-0.2965295612812042,
-0.38491904735565186,
0.46936503052711487,
-0.46656766533851624,
0.896494448184967,
0.03772431239485741,
-0.7675215601921082,
0.07832171767950058,
-0.5713951587677002,
-0.5127186179161072,
0.1386188566684723,
-0.3634853959083557,
-0.158332958817482,
0.3823608160018921,
-0.13148660957813263,
-0.20861080288887024,
-0.504054844379425,
0.17286646366119385,
-0.3832799196243286,
-0.250906765460968,
0.42816606163978577,
0.17183594405651093,
0.6656377911567688,
0.21788638830184937,
-0.24321423470973969,
-0.01938006840646267,
-0.4060739576816559,
-0.11538246273994446,
0.0039846221916377544,
-0.00705118291079998,
-0.6989039182662964,
0.3792494833469391,
-0.07044856995344162,
0.3053901791572571,
0.10091418027877808,
-0.8398808836936951,
-0.08658087253570557,
-0.3677007555961609,
0.859885573387146,
0.7933977842330933,
-0.37101826071739197,
0.6545873880386353,
-0.5100868940353394,
0.38561737537384033,
-0.13598090410232544,
0.1885337382555008,
0.1589515209197998,
-0.5389748811721802,
-0.2815835773944855,
-0.1652321219444275,
-0.08063843846321106,
0.3346993327140808,
-0.41415950655937195,
0.32610392570495605,
-0.3861309885978699,
-0.51181560754776,
-0.49348437786102295,
-0.15407885611057281,
0.35835331678390503,
0.792216956615448,
0.3479897975921631,
-0.4297184348106384,
-0.30131232738494873,
-1.0170978307724,
-0.6896087527275085,
-0.668278694152832,
-0.13634663820266724,
0.46701911091804504,
0.32976284623146057,
-0.24764445424079895,
0.8538087010383606,
-0.4004229009151459,
-0.02855696529150009,
0.5105453729629517,
0.6333886384963989,
-0.13875338435173035,
0.6308063268661499,
0.4509815275669098,
-0.49924105405807495,
0.09879755973815918,
-0.027802899479866028,
-0.6680272817611694,
-0.0351315438747406,
0.30143001675605774,
-0.06358474493026733,
0.41416770219802856,
0.4158831536769867,
-0.7078595161437988,
0.041905444115400314,
0.5952938795089722,
-0.7470739483833313,
0.5656826496124268,
0.01761217787861824,
0.4456997513771057,
-0.8459680676460266,
0.431327223777771,
-0.22077299654483795,
-0.29823389649391174,
-0.1848064512014389,
-0.0674525797367096,
-0.13179604709148407,
-0.4290473461151123,
-0.4594513177871704,
0.8067595958709717,
-0.7287301421165466,
-0.6946688294410706,
-0.174311563372612,
0.08201564103364944,
-0.07134681195020676,
-0.055383987724781036,
0.0655672699213028,
0.6542820930480957,
0.6478378772735596,
-0.5363743901252747,
0.3561996817588806,
0.38919368386268616,
-0.5454245805740356,
0.4979206621646881,
-0.4825008511543274,
0.4363093674182892,
-0.4651292860507965,
0.2999855875968933,
-0.8128774166107178,
-0.2892281115055084,
0.20162968337535858,
-0.8508805632591248,
-0.1378934681415558,
0.05065397918224335,
-0.5159240961074829,
-0.43022334575653076,
-0.5352017879486084,
0.6697025299072266,
0.5167363286018372,
-0.03362085297703743,
0.5791730284690857,
0.6905267834663391,
-0.25980955362319946,
-0.06010253727436066,
-0.723151445388794,
0.3365459740161896,
-0.000487663724925369,
-0.633518636226654,
0.3447810113430023,
-0.2226698398590088,
-0.3849427402019501,
0.42041707038879395,
-0.32964465022087097,
-0.08586074411869049,
0.1344570368528366,
0.509212076663971,
0.20244675874710083,
-0.29694515466690063,
0.1346985548734665,
-0.06773918122053146,
-0.03701924905180931,
0.3024842441082001,
-0.1861848384141922,
0.411278635263443,
-0.13130132853984833,
-0.10595783591270447,
-0.3505910634994507,
0.4623706340789795,
0.8099995851516724,
0.3630725145339966,
0.4115954339504242,
0.2224477082490921,
-0.4655688405036926,
0.1112864539027214,
-0.48602601885795593,
-0.21878238022327423,
-0.41062137484550476,
0.22489282488822937,
-0.009316138923168182,
-0.6727537512779236,
0.5049774646759033,
0.07052776962518692,
-0.22488757967948914,
0.5438032746315002,
0.2777104675769806,
-0.0023240100126713514,
1.3920272588729858,
0.4002625048160553,
-0.04131395369768143,
0.38923969864845276,
0.3070053160190582,
-0.11769985407590866,
-0.8995552062988281,
-0.25182098150253296,
-0.754209578037262,
-0.43903231620788574,
-0.6968753933906555,
-0.40228185057640076,
0.16269604861736298,
-0.24484878778457642,
-0.5975706577301025,
0.2928066551685333,
-0.7779867649078369,
0.4327501058578491,
0.2581310272216797,
0.10499371588230133,
0.32936474680900574,
-0.023662250488996506,
0.16400256752967834,
0.04083770141005516,
-0.48985135555267334,
-0.5851966738700867,
0.4091097414493561,
0.161391943693161,
0.44269895553588867,
0.0024566410575062037,
0.18980367481708527,
0.7987252473831177,
0.8126882910728455,
-0.7093656659126282,
0.5775201916694641,
0.13807706534862518,
-0.9069330096244812,
-0.14753803610801697,
-0.5218688249588013,
-0.6223838925361633,
0.018887387588620186,
-0.3084205090999603,
-0.7198295593261719,
0.2634721100330353,
0.3478586673736572,
-0.1562160849571228,
0.14192572236061096,
-0.36126819252967834,
0.4878126382827759,
-0.35699591040611267,
-0.18115189671516418,
-0.46441003680229187,
-0.6728637218475342,
0.17741668224334717,
0.18194237351417542,
0.7903993129730225,
-0.5528392791748047,
-0.33882030844688416,
0.6828420758247375,
-0.04125998169183731,
0.8115317821502686,
0.10488064587116241,
0.09359773248434067,
0.23410947620868683,
0.5636781454086304,
0.2284439653158188,
-0.08217783272266388,
-0.2503335773944855,
0.4866101145744324,
0.02778652124106884,
-0.4903377890586853,
-0.3495250344276428,
0.825244665145874,
-1.02189302444458,
-0.5372362732887268,
-0.8551400303840637,
-0.6170148253440857,
-0.19001004099845886,
0.10111355781555176,
0.0976511761546135,
0.22225748002529144,
-0.3756718933582306,
-0.09098071604967117,
0.029756542295217514,
-0.22313380241394043,
0.3556496798992157,
0.6744369864463806,
-0.05226419121026993,
-0.3339593708515167,
0.891845703125,
-0.05188760906457901,
-0.05916685238480568,
-0.11140070110559464,
0.39677146077156067,
-0.27443748712539673,
-0.18419131636619568,
-0.5913494229316711,
0.22213560342788696,
-0.511725902557373,
-0.15851207077503204,
-0.559289276599884,
-0.011946635320782661,
-0.6231076121330261,
-0.356071799993515,
-0.43247076869010925,
-0.750198483467102,
-0.17395077645778656,
0.00953664816915989,
0.13295653462409973,
0.6816458106040955,
-0.15852861106395721,
-0.19714483618736267,
-0.690146267414093,
0.37641918659210205,
0.15916089713573456,
0.39459171891212463,
-0.1372435837984085,
-0.540835976600647,
-0.18361899256706238,
0.16573461890220642,
-0.04454910382628441,
-0.9103274941444397,
0.29720085859298706,
0.4635601341724396,
0.4838961958885193,
0.24766284227371216,
0.1634279042482376,
0.5118528008460999,
-0.5210846066474915,
0.9181656837463379,
0.30136188864707947,
-1.1313074827194214,
0.43725910782814026,
-0.34924423694610596,
0.43477001786231995,
0.3827134668827057,
0.30790525674819946,
-0.7392417192459106,
-0.4798929989337921,
-0.6513559818267822,
-0.7243884205818176,
0.7053558826446533,
0.023001184687018394,
0.3213464319705963,
-0.10179309546947479,
0.4041177034378052,
-0.007440346293151379,
0.3702413737773895,
-0.5479897260665894,
-0.06026611849665642,
-0.5490785241127014,
0.13641944527626038,
-0.2804097533226013,
-0.10915131866931915,
-0.28805607557296753,
-0.4571082592010498,
0.35661494731903076,
-0.1866876184940338,
0.34931784868240356,
0.24054144322872162,
-0.5088083744049072,
-0.3966803550720215,
0.1186944842338562,
0.8388059735298157,
0.6764617562294006,
-0.0693998709321022,
0.8489306569099426,
-0.006375699304044247,
-0.49128201603889465,
0.04158329218626022,
0.0017959136748686433,
-0.09131402522325516,
-0.020903119817376137,
0.6292340159416199,
0.437899112701416,
0.15743540227413177,
-0.585209846496582,
0.11483251303434372,
0.1765735000371933,
-0.11123965680599213,
-0.3033963143825531,
-0.06164785474538803,
-0.0015533467521890998,
0.11072943359613419,
0.5632920265197754,
0.26685699820518494,
0.4577995836734772,
-1.0546272993087769,
0.13954608142375946,
0.3170005977153778,
-0.5929637551307678,
-0.7729613780975342,
0.6462968587875366,
0.17596669495105743,
-0.4295528531074524,
0.49686387181282043,
-0.12918031215667725,
-0.5419415831565857,
0.617896318435669,
0.4714411497116089,
1.0836836099624634,
-0.677886426448822,
0.3054226338863373,
0.45704397559165955,
0.4784872531890869,
-0.2123231738805771,
-0.04281901195645332,
-0.36729076504707336,
-0.7071340084075928,
-0.1378471702337265,
-0.8743039965629578,
-0.3299786448478699,
-0.3434102237224579,
-0.31641265749931335,
-0.029334550723433495,
-0.41199296712875366,
-0.2376016080379486,
0.28323447704315186,
-0.34679242968559265,
-0.15294447541236877,
0.060596100986003876,
0.4321059584617615,
0.7194135189056396,
-1.129606008529663,
0.45424261689186096,
1.3744969367980957,
-0.05273450165987015,
-0.14875032007694244,
0.23369579017162323,
0.4797196686267853,
-0.668570876121521,
0.4969116449356079,
0.2738337516784668,
-0.5541083216667175,
-0.03420322760939598,
-0.6331336498260498,
-0.8459380269050598,
0.8699451088905334,
0.7455443143844604,
0.03226441890001297,
-0.09476086497306824,
0.258553683757782,
0.6050041317939758,
-0.4917675852775574,
-0.05955548584461212,
0.30828046798706055,
0.4649229645729065,
0.04784771427512169,
-0.8769928216934204,
0.3907443881034851,
-0.5399320721626282,
0.15494461357593536,
0.20581494271755219,
-0.4361589252948761,
0.8980900049209595,
-0.09326253086328506,
-0.6084426641464233,
-0.38673555850982666,
0.4157208800315857,
0.026400543749332428,
0.37831106781959534,
0.8001221418380737,
0.2852562665939331,
0.5220492482185364,
0.2512974739074707,
1.1088978052139282,
-0.5677560567855835,
0.346004843711853,
0.792206346988678,
-0.013699764385819435,
0.4201626777648926,
0.2906799912452698,
-0.005289045162498951,
0.5430532097816467,
0.5836368799209595,
0.35261115431785583,
0.288495272397995,
0.3271543085575104,
-0.3325384855270386,
-0.38633522391319275,
-0.46422046422958374,
-0.4035349488258362,
0.4549446105957031,
0.4349767565727234,
-0.30469200015068054,
-0.36269357800483704,
0.09761317074298859,
0.10796874016523361,
0.24425676465034485,
-0.2689443528652191,
0.7421415448188782,
0.07463222742080688,
-0.6332094073295593,
0.5680657029151917,
-0.08951260149478912,
0.44008439779281616,
-0.1333416998386383,
0.09401988983154297,
-0.1399528533220291,
0.0022289897315204144,
-0.270972341299057,
-0.6566880941390991,
1.0385140180587769,
-0.07935601472854614,
-0.3635340631008148,
-0.2650887072086334,
0.5650591850280762,
-0.24390791356563568,
-0.530979573726654,
0.2976948618888855,
0.4517533481121063,
0.3751041293144226,
-0.31040817499160767,
-0.7233855724334717,
0.26108884811401367,
-0.5511852502822876,
-0.3177487552165985,
0.25589510798454285,
0.1545659452676773,
-0.24398137629032135,
0.6292102336883545,
0.6495876908302307,
0.08495152741670609,
-0.12751290202140808,
-0.6954036355018616,
0.9743205904960632,
-0.7458112835884094,
-0.774360716342926,
-0.858680784702301,
-0.030510390177369118,
-0.16263216733932495,
-0.3235676884651184,
0.5624529719352722,
0.6991801261901855,
0.2964307963848114,
0.2239808738231659,
0.5015769600868225,
-0.3631903827190399,
0.5729010105133057,
-0.07189546525478363,
0.888263463973999,
-0.669235348701477,
-0.11444711685180664,
-0.15670433640480042,
-0.859319269657135,
-0.2681206464767456,
0.6966419816017151,
-0.3898888826370239,
-0.15498052537441254,
0.7218644022941589,
0.6498187780380249,
-0.1682225465774536,
0.11182775348424911,
0.019115500152111053,
0.24401216208934784,
-0.18710404634475708,
-0.12898293137550354,
0.8550798892974854,
-0.013161884620785713,
0.2999283969402313,
-0.06320470571517944,
-0.5067337155342102,
-0.21606169641017914,
-0.982635498046875,
-0.4814138114452362,
-0.7924945950508118,
-0.6074298024177551,
-0.40088412165641785,
0.35798022150993347,
0.8549209833145142,
0.9043926000595093,
-0.6242566704750061,
-0.22912904620170593,
-0.10811153799295425,
0.34301820397377014,
-0.2546358108520508,
-0.21947048604488373,
0.27498871088027954,
-0.163194477558136,
-0.5483676791191101,
0.17114941775798798,
0.32086214423179626,
-0.1198321208357811,
-0.36377307772636414,
0.08126815408468246,
-0.02377261593937874,
0.3569847345352173,
0.7251603603363037,
0.5818068981170654,
-0.6219632029533386,
-0.5610547661781311,
0.056839313358068466,
-0.29484251141548157,
0.08520118147134781,
1.0908453464508057,
-0.6934530138969421,
0.32643452286720276,
0.6369132995605469,
0.1275346279144287,
0.3394451141357422,
0.2529112994670868,
0.4638121426105499,
-0.7869037985801697,
0.6085938215255737,
0.4867730140686035,
0.004384906031191349,
0.6438909769058228,
-0.37675777077674866,
0.3955736458301544,
0.5158871412277222,
-0.3613128662109375,
-0.9095642566680908,
0.3821345865726471,
-0.730383574962616,
-0.6890239119529724,
1.0082244873046875,
0.30733662843704224,
-0.5917026996612549,
-0.23998451232910156,
0.17348898947238922,
0.3837105929851532,
-0.4451328217983246,
1.5026355981826782,
0.5957797169685364,
-0.4000726044178009,
-0.44793763756752014,
-0.6060816049575806,
0.5882362127304077,
0.14705835282802582,
-0.8574745655059814,
0.007517509628087282,
0.7909984588623047,
0.15214495360851288,
0.7262718677520752,
0.5875599384307861,
-0.29467475414276123,
0.15222673118114471,
0.1174551472067833,
0.2665502429008484,
-0.26687920093536377,
0.0036902478896081448,
0.17458157241344452,
0.024831334128975868,
0.016502447426319122,
-0.2054637372493744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05120v1 | More Agents Is All You Need | 2024-02-03T05:55:24 | 2024-02-03T05:55:24 | Junyou Li, Qin Zhang, Yangbin Yu, Qiang Fu, Deheng Ye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We find that, simply via a sampling-and-voting method, the performance of
large language models (LLMs) scales with the number of agents instantiated.
Also, this method is orthogonal to existing complicated methods to further
enhance LLMs, while the degree of enhancement is correlated to the task
difficulty. We conduct comprehensive experiments on a wide range of LLM
benchmarks to verify the presence of our finding, and to study the properties
that can facilitate its occurrence. Our code is publicly available at:
\url{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/more_agent_is_all_you_need}. | [
-0.5202317237854004,
-0.7082180380821228,
0.9374125003814697,
0.1980898380279541,
0.04586680233478546,
0.2066928744316101,
-0.35397061705589294,
-0.6854531168937683,
0.2030370682477951,
0.7063077092170715,
-0.30261966586112976,
-0.364429771900177,
-0.7742190957069397,
0.10160264372825623,
-0.5021736025810242,
0.648981511592865,
0.19294972717761993,
0.20296542346477509,
-0.32737645506858826,
-0.11426997929811478,
-0.08754351735115051,
-0.43516379594802856,
-0.6074877977371216,
-0.48940595984458923,
0.68453049659729,
0.5248331427574158,
0.7083520889282227,
0.8968995213508606,
0.6742179989814758,
0.4385513365268707,
-0.25349143147468567,
0.28001442551612854,
-0.4231150150299072,
0.29884129762649536,
0.10349363088607788,
-0.8470404744148254,
-0.801001787185669,
0.24868467450141907,
0.9470636248588562,
0.6513936519622803,
-0.07345352321863174,
0.3199697434902191,
-0.08586248010396957,
0.40343597531318665,
-0.5041801333427429,
0.19008052349090576,
-0.54878169298172,
-0.4416828453540802,
-0.31507518887519836,
-0.2600003182888031,
-0.5726687908172607,
-0.3727723956108093,
0.02060079574584961,
-0.44147005677223206,
0.15279081463813782,
0.041526149958372116,
0.521211564540863,
0.08641497790813446,
-0.7655547261238098,
-0.10854341089725494,
-0.7733291387557983,
0.8209648728370667,
-0.6790918707847595,
0.2836225628852844,
0.10262381285429001,
0.28766748309135437,
-0.3799893260002136,
-0.8997306823730469,
-0.7093170881271362,
-0.9746192693710327,
0.25332748889923096,
-0.08592987060546875,
0.17476531863212585,
0.1510593444108963,
0.4950915575027466,
0.2794903516769409,
-0.34452465176582336,
0.12170612066984177,
-0.22242732346057892,
0.014232265762984753,
0.7410879135131836,
0.3870106339454651,
0.3790469765663147,
0.22986376285552979,
-0.07175814360380173,
-0.5731801390647888,
-0.6602306962013245,
-0.1025555208325386,
0.5204839110374451,
0.341526597738266,
-0.06903860718011856,
0.6336926817893982,
-0.17459271848201752,
0.7412694096565247,
-0.21527692675590515,
-0.06977217644453049,
0.44769132137298584,
-0.5885168313980103,
0.11989777535200119,
-0.42821598052978516,
0.6180104613304138,
0.13000178337097168,
0.28837472200393677,
0.15064217150211334,
-0.22718609869480133,
-0.10226356983184814,
0.17453289031982422,
-0.9547428488731384,
-0.058511409908533096,
0.19490954279899597,
-0.37701061367988586,
-0.1896411031484604,
-0.15684786438941956,
-0.4075324535369873,
-0.725942075252533,
-0.5007416605949402,
0.34863710403442383,
-0.3287956416606903,
-0.5355870127677917,
-0.0894545465707779,
-0.4695189893245697,
0.4389536678791046,
0.43193408846855164,
-0.47861388325691223,
0.41541096568107605,
0.9102782011032104,
0.9440100193023682,
-0.2693604528903961,
-0.7140136361122131,
-0.570806622505188,
-0.33081668615341187,
-0.7582384943962097,
1.1327975988388062,
-0.8582496643066406,
-0.18620233237743378,
0.04741258919239044,
-0.040861863642930984,
0.04380505904555321,
-0.75077885389328,
0.32654380798339844,
-0.7324326634407043,
-0.14112357795238495,
-0.5844812393188477,
-0.7583298683166504,
-0.0008896405925042927,
0.08535861223936081,
-1.0461950302124023,
1.2097549438476562,
0.002400328405201435,
-0.1425822377204895,
0.3470660150051117,
-0.8112841844558716,
-0.4778347909450531,
0.1189723014831543,
-0.08988906443119049,
-0.17475858330726624,
0.44076624512672424,
-0.09121052175760269,
0.48038697242736816,
-0.4666149914264679,
0.09618449956178665,
-0.43903401494026184,
-0.27527186274528503,
0.624358594417572,
-0.32648220658302307,
0.754732072353363,
0.26956501603126526,
-0.19621023535728455,
0.3975207209587097,
-0.7437790036201477,
0.07932174205780029,
-0.0018969079246744514,
-0.6576848030090332,
-0.11212368309497833,
0.15595552325248718,
0.12145671248435974,
0.07746713608503342,
0.3586142659187317,
-0.4466472566127777,
0.2672213613986969,
-0.4844529330730438,
0.09447656571865082,
0.7230729460716248,
-0.029926858842372894,
0.5991708636283875,
-0.678668737411499,
0.6852697730064392,
-0.19060707092285156,
0.07504571229219437,
0.04114546254277229,
-0.6286687254905701,
-0.8178678154945374,
-0.4460815191268921,
0.12394000589847565,
0.18884222209453583,
-0.521724283695221,
0.18855588138103485,
-0.2313970923423767,
-0.7710763216018677,
-0.44665592908859253,
0.46645739674568176,
0.32101404666900635,
-0.21577247977256775,
0.08750820904970169,
-0.36801356077194214,
-0.4551335275173187,
-0.677499532699585,
-0.07282597571611404,
-0.06384922564029694,
-0.19084367156028748,
0.3757639229297638,
0.6699960231781006,
-0.2388104498386383,
1.029923439025879,
-0.48148900270462036,
-0.032065533101558685,
-0.47706928849220276,
0.10518147796392441,
0.20296664535999298,
0.019592488184571266,
0.584819495677948,
-0.4386940896511078,
-0.5078757405281067,
0.0569654181599617,
-0.5997174382209778,
-0.24151742458343506,
0.1239890530705452,
-0.08839602023363113,
-0.02896602638065815,
0.6732763051986694,
-0.7260356545448303,
-0.2373342663049698,
0.4894789457321167,
-0.08607075363397598,
0.435036301612854,
-0.4093092679977417,
-0.009176517836749554,
-1.2704814672470093,
-0.2582302391529083,
0.09534783661365509,
-0.32107770442962646,
-0.6572643518447876,
0.6690986156463623,
0.06856242567300797,
0.09824161231517792,
-0.49920654296875,
0.669957160949707,
-0.9166381359100342,
-0.3241204023361206,
-0.6935513615608215,
0.41549721360206604,
-0.15627692639827728,
0.24671046435832977,
-0.10548918694257736,
0.848182737827301,
0.7123026251792908,
-0.7099571228027344,
0.8310266733169556,
-0.2671482264995575,
-0.557065486907959,
0.2501329779624939,
-0.6485773921012878,
0.05812949687242508,
-0.2787282466888428,
0.4768851399421692,
-1.297129511833191,
-0.43113744258880615,
-0.35378074645996094,
-0.38016146421432495,
0.13808561861515045,
0.21649427711963654,
-0.6979185938835144,
-0.20583827793598175,
-0.5610294938087463,
0.33360621333122253,
0.4113989472389221,
-0.588625431060791,
0.6365190744400024,
0.5898191928863525,
-0.24609704315662384,
-0.36623021960258484,
-0.3200288414955139,
0.24424287676811218,
-0.06850633025169373,
-0.2956739366054535,
0.0011647975770756602,
-0.20214205980300903,
-0.5244166851043701,
-0.146964430809021,
0.38853901624679565,
-0.053147245198488235,
0.31353673338890076,
0.19438186287879944,
-0.009195062331855297,
-0.29810860753059387,
0.39543968439102173,
-0.24784459173679352,
-0.03227881342172623,
0.17854727804660797,
0.007190032862126827,
0.8420706391334534,
-0.12761905789375305,
-0.5388972163200378,
-0.1683480590581894,
0.3139031231403351,
0.8289779424667358,
-0.4177001714706421,
0.5890114903450012,
0.5369912385940552,
-0.24292780458927155,
-0.3024366497993469,
-0.6673912405967712,
-0.33814626932144165,
-0.5282731056213379,
0.7495426535606384,
-0.37828102707862854,
-0.8757937550544739,
0.6333765387535095,
-0.2647593915462494,
0.1575334370136261,
0.33323612809181213,
0.9708229899406433,
0.3685637414455414,
1.2428480386734009,
0.531164288520813,
-0.2632964551448822,
0.6286007165908813,
-0.19642283022403717,
-0.0970788300037384,
-0.7894020676612854,
-0.07082423567771912,
-0.6623415350914001,
-0.26408645510673523,
-0.7450919151306152,
-0.8004039525985718,
0.24894307553768158,
-0.2440079301595688,
-0.13376198709011078,
0.3058719336986542,
-0.417789101600647,
0.7068700194358826,
0.7494862079620361,
0.029942968860268593,
0.45479312539100647,
-0.03462015464901924,
0.05661052465438843,
0.33319559693336487,
-0.3452666699886322,
-0.4308246076107025,
1.237589955329895,
0.385015070438385,
0.7475714087486267,
0.5895026922225952,
0.8199910521507263,
0.2560785114765167,
0.6819283962249756,
-0.8787447810173035,
0.7997764945030212,
0.14350050687789917,
-0.9637653231620789,
-0.6627429723739624,
-0.4956916868686676,
-1.1110318899154663,
0.3126102387905121,
-0.24077129364013672,
-0.5744369029998779,
0.17852316796779633,
-0.05194396153092384,
-0.3889140486717224,
-0.07978177815675735,
-0.5981538891792297,
0.3021008372306824,
-0.1625773310661316,
-0.2736254632472992,
-0.48063328862190247,
-0.28300660848617554,
0.22390173375606537,
-0.15269944071769714,
0.17548790574073792,
-0.23106859624385834,
-0.40470653772354126,
0.6400598883628845,
-0.46036672592163086,
0.9483857750892639,
0.00905174482613802,
-0.35240715742111206,
0.561050295829773,
-0.13812007009983063,
0.7846646904945374,
-0.13250097632408142,
-0.20582233369350433,
-0.3032345473766327,
-0.2315502017736435,
-0.5460382103919983,
-0.5223727822303772,
0.9234532713890076,
-1.0083510875701904,
-0.48841968178749084,
-0.38556909561157227,
-0.6479808688163757,
-0.09577425569295883,
0.09586503356695175,
0.10019299387931824,
0.44174617528915405,
-0.03260814771056175,
0.3922847509384155,
0.4319990575313568,
-0.0007481240318156779,
0.6151750683784485,
0.8824068903923035,
-0.282328337430954,
-0.1460820436477661,
0.9330165386199951,
0.3474215269088745,
0.39410388469696045,
0.38738247752189636,
0.20195169746875763,
-0.38664209842681885,
-0.7568966150283813,
-0.141536146402359,
0.21971938014030457,
-0.5112811326980591,
-0.03535345196723938,
-0.722419023513794,
-0.15986627340316772,
-0.5697842240333557,
0.26469096541404724,
-0.5613545179367065,
-0.16147206723690033,
-0.16550129652023315,
-0.2932295799255371,
0.7819117307662964,
1.0392768383026123,
-0.1914871782064438,
0.7630186080932617,
-0.6542752981185913,
0.27479255199432373,
0.6267581582069397,
0.43094924092292786,
0.24477311968803406,
-0.721903920173645,
-0.37089717388153076,
-0.20513352751731873,
-0.2949543297290802,
-0.9656078815460205,
0.4147917330265045,
0.27521130442619324,
0.6878282427787781,
0.36843013763427734,
-0.06656566262245178,
0.5937495827674866,
-0.537922203540802,
0.6923292875289917,
-0.17262060940265656,
-0.7977036833763123,
-0.028135299682617188,
-0.39945468306541443,
0.15727204084396362,
0.3271448016166687,
0.1998666226863861,
-0.2026899755001068,
-0.48406511545181274,
-0.47721555829048157,
-0.8718038201332092,
0.6434363126754761,
0.03442513570189476,
0.6127971410751343,
-0.08084060251712799,
0.37795835733413696,
-0.29444631934165955,
0.11912482976913452,
-0.8093863129615784,
-0.35385069251060486,
0.5267587304115295,
0.037123147398233414,
-0.3814108669757843,
-0.6467176079750061,
0.04435722529888153,
-0.14032073318958282,
0.6377084255218506,
-0.0955648198723793,
0.06887608766555786,
-0.16930024325847626,
-0.0997702106833458,
-0.05979079008102417,
0.39147934317588806,
0.6260856986045837,
0.734071671962738,
-0.20122192800045013,
0.1825902909040451,
0.4500696063041687,
-0.3585728406906128,
0.2681402266025543,
0.1492130160331726,
0.33694326877593994,
-0.07378070801496506,
0.806960940361023,
0.862472653388977,
-0.09276165068149567,
-0.8467509150505066,
0.5139170289039612,
0.024747908115386963,
-0.25607162714004517,
-0.4057316184043884,
0.34223538637161255,
0.39153772592544556,
0.5974117517471313,
0.51445072889328,
-0.41585391759872437,
0.2560093104839325,
-0.840478777885437,
0.3565918505191803,
0.5303847789764404,
-0.24622322618961334,
-0.06601719558238983,
0.2964535355567932,
0.3394263982772827,
-0.5948637127876282,
0.29707545042037964,
-0.5635309815406799,
-0.2686169445514679,
0.9052338004112244,
0.520330011844635,
0.590135931968689,
-0.38836702704429626,
0.24752455949783325,
0.10679858922958374,
0.450001060962677,
-0.5524337887763977,
0.2888084053993225,
0.1205897331237793,
-0.8164977431297302,
-0.9193931818008423,
-0.4811673164367676,
-0.7037298679351807,
0.3073942959308624,
-0.3972838521003723,
0.11501304060220718,
-0.2023731917142868,
-0.3605998754501343,
0.09526148438453674,
0.37192434072494507,
-0.4539487063884735,
-0.016532445326447487,
0.01934703253209591,
0.677158534526825,
-0.9649171829223633,
0.8301213979721069,
0.8687452077865601,
-0.09361530095338821,
-0.8220773339271545,
-0.16831465065479279,
-0.03219914063811302,
-0.9185298681259155,
0.45567601919174194,
0.03387543559074402,
-0.1021195724606514,
-0.005125720985233784,
-0.6615746021270752,
-1.214209794998169,
0.8988897204399109,
0.405622661113739,
-0.7386698126792908,
0.15883810818195343,
0.17682628333568573,
0.8763900995254517,
-0.45709314942359924,
0.8235961198806763,
0.7335057854652405,
0.4449596405029297,
0.04076412320137024,
-0.8403682112693787,
0.11992433667182922,
-0.3376034200191498,
0.05306883156299591,
0.11153844743967056,
-0.5165995955467224,
1.2388635873794556,
-0.3332756757736206,
0.015322267077863216,
0.14826586842536926,
0.6448763608932495,
0.3702402710914612,
0.351855605840683,
0.5986273288726807,
0.21969899535179138,
0.8912495970726013,
0.3283926248550415,
1.2675468921661377,
-0.4037739038467407,
0.317123144865036,
1.3510667085647583,
-0.6067216396331787,
0.7825514078140259,
0.12351474910974503,
-0.36326539516448975,
0.19530287384986877,
0.5767325758934021,
-0.03786540403962135,
-0.037067607045173645,
0.5635251998901367,
-0.48151594400405884,
-0.6763448715209961,
-0.4195471704006195,
-0.4055999219417572,
0.5072599053382874,
0.15216389298439026,
-0.3714791238307953,
-0.14812874794006348,
0.07246845215559006,
-0.002522986615076661,
0.12411104142665863,
0.03926588594913483,
0.8228026032447815,
0.10402640700340271,
-0.5617204308509827,
0.3844239413738251,
-0.01766587793827057,
0.6161475777626038,
-0.37136349081993103,
-0.1512145847082138,
-0.17770007252693176,
0.15246620774269104,
0.02408553846180439,
-0.7312012910842896,
-0.2701014578342438,
-0.13726668059825897,
-0.19493184983730316,
0.09360386431217194,
0.46931973099708557,
-0.45049187541007996,
-0.7649899125099182,
0.5892961621284485,
0.9323696494102478,
0.3833150565624237,
-0.2503341734409332,
-0.2331942766904831,
0.06848154962062836,
-0.20104378461837769,
-0.6092650890350342,
0.40722131729125977,
0.44985318183898926,
-0.13348963856697083,
0.8075401186943054,
0.7348244190216064,
0.4135258197784424,
0.23514968156814575,
0.3861563205718994,
0.8477708697319031,
-0.5272088050842285,
0.015438083559274673,
-1.065050721168518,
0.03706325590610504,
-0.40267178416252136,
-0.17550994455814362,
0.7991871237754822,
0.5959969758987427,
0.6374152898788452,
-0.04252786189317703,
0.8386938571929932,
0.19114190340042114,
0.5842048525810242,
-0.17201164364814758,
0.5579695105552673,
-0.6683623194694519,
0.36281082034111023,
-0.197098508477211,
-0.9659754037857056,
-0.17547470331192017,
0.4247395098209381,
-0.23171906173229218,
0.23974809050559998,
0.5211361646652222,
1.224479079246521,
0.2654547393321991,
-0.43402621150016785,
0.47228559851646423,
0.3423179090023041,
0.40740886330604553,
0.38389667868614197,
1.150873064994812,
-0.037706080824136734,
0.6676316261291504,
0.07198421657085419,
-0.4170558750629425,
-0.3432885408401489,
-0.8596853017807007,
-0.994117259979248,
-0.5582103133201599,
-0.21954146027565002,
-0.2943730652332306,
-0.09410187602043152,
1.0701366662979126,
0.8330853581428528,
-0.5567025542259216,
-0.5643854141235352,
-0.012705723755061626,
0.32008785009384155,
-0.17221441864967346,
-0.16816724836826324,
0.02603759616613388,
-0.47102487087249756,
-1.1084614992141724,
0.41564586758613586,
-0.19567877054214478,
-0.08086006343364716,
-0.22109922766685486,
-0.13212884962558746,
-0.08880116790533066,
0.44806718826293945,
0.8352307677268982,
0.05289766192436218,
-0.4092736840248108,
-0.13100124895572662,
0.003510219044983387,
-0.21594446897506714,
-0.13136732578277588,
0.9051156044006348,
-0.3756917715072632,
0.2803974747657776,
0.890893280506134,
0.49955666065216064,
0.4875161051750183,
-0.1660204529762268,
0.5782480835914612,
-0.734515368938446,
-0.06311234086751938,
-0.08906497806310654,
0.31384697556495667,
0.01776912249624729,
-0.10969340056180954,
0.3219701051712036,
-0.0024737510830163956,
-0.5857991576194763,
-0.9745873212814331,
0.3166947364807129,
-0.9040541052818298,
-0.3124198317527771,
1.4848295450210571,
0.17132623493671417,
-0.14235182106494904,
0.009681080467998981,
-0.30230212211608887,
0.200228750705719,
-0.6955286264419556,
0.6215720772743225,
0.7014045119285583,
-0.35403215885162354,
-0.2753719687461853,
-0.593010425567627,
0.4372592568397522,
0.29934459924697876,
-0.9591253399848938,
0.03941941261291504,
0.5670310854911804,
0.28176310658454895,
0.4288480281829834,
0.8541363477706909,
0.1305602341890335,
0.11459344625473022,
0.023274658247828484,
0.12820203602313995,
-0.018275344744324684,
-0.5451593995094299,
-0.2583330571651459,
0.37145206332206726,
0.7707192301750183,
-0.03722210228443146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02037v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02037v3 | EffiBench: Benchmarking the Efficiency of Automatically Generated Code | 2024-02-03T05:24:39 | 2024-06-07T09:21:21 | Dong Huang, Yuhao Qing, Weiyi Shang, Heming Cui, Jie M. Zhang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Code generation models have increasingly become integral to aiding software
development. Although current research has thoroughly examined the correctness
of the code produced by code generation models, a vital aspect that plays a
pivotal role in green computing and sustainability efforts has often been
neglected. This paper presents EffiBench, a benchmark with 1,000
efficiency-critical coding problems to assess the efficiency of code generated
by code generation models. EffiBench contains a diverse set of LeetCode coding
problems. Each problem is paired with an executable human-written canonical
solution, which obtains the SOTA efficiency on the LeetCode solution
leaderboard. With EffiBench, we empirically examine the ability of 42 large
language models (35 open-source and 7 closed-source) to generate efficient
code. Our evaluation results demonstrate that the efficiency of the code
generated by LLMs is generally worse than the efficiency of human-written
canonical solutions. For example, GPT-4 generated code has an average
\textbf{3.12} times execution time that of the human-written canonical
solutions. In the most extreme cases, the execution time and total memory usage
of GPT-4 generated code are \textbf{13.89} and \textbf{43.92} times that of the
canonical solutions. The source code of EffiBench is released on
https://github.com/huangd1999/EffiBench. We also provide the LeaderBoard at
https://huggingface.co/spaces/EffiBench/effibench-leaderboard. | [
-0.1573580801486969,
-0.6041391491889954,
0.3945417106151581,
0.15561065077781677,
-0.1367645412683487,
0.006954423151910305,
-0.38279587030410767,
-0.18793722987174988,
-0.0884552001953125,
0.08866812288761139,
-0.4266299903392792,
-0.5226469039916992,
-0.11880923062562943,
0.2062525451183319,
-0.4454755187034607,
0.7570053935050964,
-0.042248472571372986,
0.01206961926072836,
-0.21288934350013733,
-0.0952458456158638,
-0.20865069329738617,
-0.2698863446712494,
-0.3936452567577362,
-0.09320345520973206,
0.09321528673171997,
0.5338202714920044,
0.49986791610717773,
0.5319406986236572,
0.6363659501075745,
0.336511492729187,
0.3054957389831543,
-0.06168670579791069,
-0.9016347527503967,
0.25447091460227966,
-0.18552593886852264,
-0.10297643393278122,
-0.3761554956436157,
-0.05498678609728813,
0.4258752465248108,
0.21020250022411346,
-0.5480307936668396,
0.6912252902984619,
0.23269781470298767,
0.7313045859336853,
-0.6196581721305847,
-0.03819246217608452,
-0.6514335870742798,
-0.010761101730167866,
-0.11418265104293823,
-0.31002771854400635,
-0.24546046555042267,
-0.8727967143058777,
-0.6142172813415527,
-0.43615731596946716,
0.14104750752449036,
0.1586247831583023,
0.9113343954086304,
0.5321637392044067,
0.08967819809913635,
-0.5062612891197205,
-0.513096034526825,
0.6815250515937805,
-0.6475985050201416,
0.3509615659713745,
0.05191268026828766,
0.29381951689720154,
-0.1300666481256485,
-0.7262622714042664,
-0.6219925284385681,
-0.5275702476501465,
0.21910028159618378,
0.21706175804138184,
-0.4965953528881073,
-0.11782623827457428,
0.6695302724838257,
0.5138654708862305,
-0.875724196434021,
0.00347173772752285,
-0.3026498258113861,
-0.11684869974851608,
0.7127371430397034,
0.06309351325035095,
0.3012731969356537,
-0.4437524974346161,
-0.2697165310382843,
-0.2555095851421356,
-0.6568437814712524,
-0.29734548926353455,
0.5940587520599365,
-0.25514450669288635,
0.053859736770391464,
0.5706642270088196,
-0.024231530725955963,
0.6125308275222778,
-0.08201504498720169,
-0.03942742571234703,
0.3034135699272156,
-0.4593619108200073,
-0.23597726225852966,
-0.29635363817214966,
0.5687187314033508,
0.7162144780158997,
0.3095104396343231,
-0.15438039600849152,
-0.35603559017181396,
0.24110393226146698,
0.3831317722797394,
-1.1004987955093384,
-0.5635462999343872,
0.1787024289369583,
-0.4072432518005371,
-0.3367807865142822,
0.05385235697031021,
-0.6172994375228882,
-0.020110810175538063,
-0.05370507016777992,
0.062495142221450806,
-0.19106242060661316,
-0.5025438070297241,
-0.21825987100601196,
-0.1547585427761078,
0.38203927874565125,
0.044873349368572235,
-0.276180237531662,
0.17992140352725983,
0.743073582649231,
0.9775110483169556,
-0.12906761467456818,
-0.031928762793540955,
-0.7867095470428467,
-0.06969559192657471,
-0.30542850494384766,
0.682972252368927,
-0.16733604669570923,
-0.46787723898887634,
-0.15641166269779205,
-0.12984931468963623,
0.23392823338508606,
-0.7483747005462646,
0.6527565121650696,
-0.4317924976348877,
-0.5805714130401611,
-0.326172411441803,
-0.870397686958313,
0.09899093955755234,
-0.040584634989500046,
-0.8207019567489624,
1.308434247970581,
0.23046275973320007,
-0.6525875329971313,
0.3102162778377533,
-0.5365423560142517,
-0.09488600492477417,
0.30998557806015015,
-0.3619258403778076,
-0.5324739217758179,
0.2859519124031067,
-0.5996134281158447,
0.4292268455028534,
-0.5659409165382385,
0.5492216944694519,
-0.2587810456752777,
-0.2954860329627991,
-0.04929035156965256,
-0.13266441226005554,
0.820880651473999,
0.7504334449768066,
-0.6534874439239502,
-0.023596126586198807,
-0.9194341897964478,
0.5733945369720459,
0.28519460558891296,
-0.4840282201766968,
-0.09577126801013947,
-0.18036864697933197,
0.2886790335178375,
0.08155284821987152,
0.035950519144535065,
-0.5133631229400635,
-0.22376927733421326,
0.2390843778848648,
0.3033480942249298,
0.8963310718536377,
-0.13576747477054596,
0.019314579665660858,
-0.30881696939468384,
0.6708419919013977,
-0.5609295964241028,
-0.1605246216058731,
-0.007832189090549946,
-0.2749122083187103,
-0.642589807510376,
-0.128773495554924,
0.43502917885780334,
0.4540902078151703,
-0.598913848400116,
0.4384346008300781,
-0.2771388590335846,
-0.6736530065536499,
-0.16567978262901306,
0.3841610252857208,
0.6339200139045715,
0.25133511424064636,
-0.006385441403836012,
-0.30845534801483154,
-0.3830798864364624,
-1.0050137042999268,
-0.5114575028419495,
-0.16857124865055084,
0.08066361397504807,
0.4348743259906769,
0.6338003873825073,
-0.14499938488006592,
0.6136059165000916,
-0.6709585785865784,
0.4817318916320801,
-0.09900149703025818,
0.018375257030129433,
0.16053958237171173,
0.658555805683136,
0.609484851360321,
-0.597537100315094,
-0.7247797846794128,
-0.08290883153676987,
-0.7352616786956787,
-0.46860459446907043,
-0.17698447406291962,
-0.3938542306423187,
0.26795390248298645,
0.7261598110198975,
-0.19390243291854858,
0.14643414318561554,
0.80104660987854,
-0.2101590782403946,
0.68556809425354,
-0.4998360574245453,
0.18184038996696472,
-0.6583050489425659,
0.6829453706741333,
-0.10668718069791794,
-0.4314189851284027,
-0.37637221813201904,
0.739539384841919,
0.32134073972702026,
-0.28054875135421753,
-0.08090952038764954,
0.05516338348388672,
-0.6225688457489014,
-0.2780846357345581,
0.0402093380689621,
0.20066456496715546,
-0.08959157764911652,
0.349931001663208,
-0.39001256227493286,
1.0120986700057983,
-0.000666841515339911,
-0.5353103280067444,
0.4692576229572296,
-0.363982230424881,
-0.5446809530258179,
0.4761503040790558,
-0.8319634795188904,
0.4911407232284546,
0.30261850357055664,
0.08229289203882217,
-0.7962831854820251,
-0.30595752596855164,
-0.15204960107803345,
-0.1522008776664734,
0.23337578773498535,
0.3396633267402649,
-0.8706634640693665,
-0.5158970355987549,
-0.43218350410461426,
0.24015766382217407,
0.788428008556366,
-0.5687299370765686,
0.2698633670806885,
0.3096819221973419,
-0.18124224245548248,
-0.13191911578178406,
-0.5829613208770752,
0.028507810086011887,
-0.1391870677471161,
-0.7074605822563171,
0.2828444242477417,
-0.3790883719921112,
-0.274365097284317,
0.11725746095180511,
-0.2504264712333679,
0.07008684426546097,
0.4274387061595917,
0.0681484267115593,
-0.01118113286793232,
-0.009470772929489613,
0.1949138194322586,
-0.19017374515533447,
-0.3096473217010498,
0.0025184680707752705,
-0.12568438053131104,
0.5433997511863708,
-0.36856985092163086,
-0.5302322506904602,
-0.1584615260362625,
0.4269047975540161,
0.20775853097438812,
-0.027695031836628914,
0.4031963348388672,
0.2221832424402237,
-0.2535158097743988,
-0.3231525123119354,
-0.6826440691947937,
0.29065775871276855,
-0.4614909887313843,
0.5047236680984497,
-0.44020673632621765,
-0.4813579320907593,
0.45910656452178955,
-0.3680219054222107,
0.3426525592803955,
0.6279022097587585,
0.5501295328140259,
0.2771414518356323,
0.6823268532752991,
0.6856400966644287,
0.29419559240341187,
0.46424412727355957,
-0.36375322937965393,
0.17842979729175568,
-0.4696495532989502,
0.009259581565856934,
-0.6378464698791504,
-0.13538327813148499,
-0.7240567207336426,
-0.5502400398254395,
0.2872968018054962,
0.40395382046699524,
-0.4525648057460785,
0.5644318461418152,
-0.7507671117782593,
0.7154129147529602,
0.47448787093162537,
-0.07676476985216141,
0.43559548258781433,
-0.16671840846538544,
-0.2731360197067261,
0.084080770611763,
-0.7957560420036316,
-0.6077060103416443,
1.046512484550476,
0.07915613055229187,
0.6847018599510193,
0.21875405311584473,
1.0440804958343506,
0.3864879310131073,
0.4284933805465698,
-0.2764362096786499,
0.5490763187408447,
-0.014235801063477993,
-0.4919157326221466,
0.03718647360801697,
-0.7144101858139038,
-0.5029332637786865,
0.022195857018232346,
0.23829331994056702,
-0.2714829444885254,
0.0242896918207407,
0.352687269449234,
-0.4695708751678467,
0.19530931115150452,
-0.9309539198875427,
1.0663261413574219,
-0.4644967019557953,
-0.9230420589447021,
-0.4584578573703766,
-0.21965068578720093,
0.2820621430873871,
-0.281891793012619,
0.3103656768798828,
0.029831288382411003,
0.04240674152970314,
0.6050674915313721,
-0.7932893633842468,
0.3431568443775177,
-0.4937879741191864,
-0.21347428858280182,
0.4372206926345825,
0.0858897864818573,
0.7367761135101318,
-0.19443534314632416,
-0.40271642804145813,
0.02650812827050686,
-0.227938711643219,
-0.4128534495830536,
-0.23036473989486694,
0.9334393739700317,
-0.43541428446769714,
-0.3892492353916168,
-0.2938691973686218,
0.1435864418745041,
0.32117804884910583,
0.19898177683353424,
0.5607076287269592,
0.37860050797462463,
-0.5319945812225342,
0.10529886186122894,
0.412410706281662,
-0.4817539155483246,
0.44200599193573,
0.37645256519317627,
-0.30308306217193604,
-0.181533083319664,
1.0509388446807861,
0.2813975214958191,
0.4805752635002136,
-0.293598473072052,
0.016097363084554672,
0.015514004975557327,
-0.40883371233940125,
-0.6647140979766846,
-0.12625376880168915,
-0.8856146931648254,
-0.5578066110610962,
-0.6202982068061829,
-0.11195699870586395,
0.10128358006477356,
-0.42569538950920105,
-0.3101602792739868,
-0.3022741973400116,
0.08639933168888092,
-0.2270612269639969,
0.32606059312820435,
0.9117630124092102,
-0.4891890585422516,
-0.07852034270763397,
-0.5911776423454285,
0.34650400280952454,
0.23745572566986084,
0.4876325726509094,
0.1469263732433319,
-0.0133543461561203,
-0.40053823590278625,
-0.23346847295761108,
-0.626300036907196,
-0.88876873254776,
0.18378984928131104,
0.3834626376628876,
0.7391581535339355,
0.15515325963497162,
0.1822034865617752,
0.6636558175086975,
-0.4719015657901764,
0.6974660754203796,
0.3714354932308197,
-1.0736232995986938,
0.4222193956375122,
-0.1281597912311554,
0.3258619010448456,
0.7305498123168945,
-0.03606352582573891,
-0.2223970741033554,
-0.47838032245635986,
-0.8303536772727966,
-0.9355450868606567,
0.43908238410949707,
0.39535588026046753,
-0.13615116477012634,
-0.1862078756093979,
0.18370452523231506,
0.17912940680980682,
0.1724095493555069,
-0.5690140724182129,
-0.093773752450943,
-0.291026771068573,
-0.08971545845270157,
-0.04646387696266174,
-0.20219571888446808,
0.15411756932735443,
-0.10878710448741913,
0.5608859062194824,
-0.13708528876304626,
0.2281905561685562,
0.1192881241440773,
-0.5157046914100647,
-0.22922596335411072,
0.26384520530700684,
0.48386257886886597,
0.6076295971870422,
-0.09932269901037216,
-0.014679002575576305,
0.14055770635604858,
-0.3101113736629486,
0.08915884792804718,
-0.0063559068366885185,
-0.022174982354044914,
-0.03019486553966999,
0.1980815976858139,
0.3239874839782715,
0.25560006499290466,
-0.7280405759811401,
0.46706297993659973,
-0.1454123556613922,
-0.23949573934078217,
-0.4317711591720581,
0.26957622170448303,
0.35980722308158875,
0.17770864069461823,
0.299983412027359,
0.11003691703081131,
0.5101667642593384,
-0.3998453915119171,
0.21558216214179993,
0.4046393036842346,
0.2678966224193573,
-0.12705443799495697,
0.6616029143333435,
0.6649017930030823,
-0.3056969940662384,
0.6433032751083374,
-0.7023715376853943,
-0.5952029824256897,
0.9411104917526245,
0.4973095655441284,
1.2120425701141357,
0.003817619290202856,
-0.02733277529478073,
0.8016195893287659,
0.0988108366727829,
0.0005197306745685637,
0.45590826869010925,
-0.39052775502204895,
-0.22007343173027039,
-0.2882275879383087,
-0.7879570126533508,
-0.3102254867553711,
-0.4655417203903198,
-0.691166341304779,
0.12785615026950836,
-0.5018861293792725,
-0.2822072207927704,
-0.07161565124988556,
0.08817750215530396,
-0.9261324405670166,
-0.2979546785354614,
0.054798781871795654,
0.9242998957633972,
-0.6858780384063721,
0.46143198013305664,
0.5905323624610901,
-0.15530385076999664,
-0.9469824433326721,
0.07144003361463547,
0.033385373651981354,
-0.600838303565979,
0.6980797052383423,
0.31943371891975403,
-0.5643243193626404,
0.31234148144721985,
-0.6286195516586304,
-0.6446961760520935,
1.1250290870666504,
0.5600159168243408,
-0.9294825792312622,
0.2873397767543793,
-0.4015670120716095,
0.330145001411438,
-0.21297350525856018,
0.4345594048500061,
0.6216817498207092,
0.5216200947761536,
-0.20881138741970062,
-1.002149224281311,
0.24501247704029083,
-0.716823160648346,
0.3483765721321106,
0.09010762721300125,
-0.8450315594673157,
0.7117201685905457,
-0.4149666130542755,
-0.75076824426651,
0.25689566135406494,
0.2531350553035736,
0.3149811327457428,
-0.03997211158275604,
0.46816033124923706,
0.7207984924316406,
1.0683985948562622,
-0.03193141520023346,
1.282233476638794,
-0.8430230021476746,
0.7016482949256897,
0.7387434244155884,
-0.41076239943504333,
0.8498213291168213,
0.12773273885250092,
-0.4001171290874481,
0.594427764415741,
0.4897458255290985,
-0.19280706346035004,
0.4475024342536926,
0.6769671440124512,
0.07436368614435196,
-0.3542492091655731,
0.15577521920204163,
-0.6823741793632507,
0.051930781453847885,
-0.12489058077335358,
-0.2029886692762375,
-0.38182076811790466,
-0.35752612352371216,
0.060378119349479675,
0.04977908357977867,
-0.04009544104337692,
0.7104282379150391,
0.08467210084199905,
-0.688421368598938,
0.8691452145576477,
0.040092624723911285,
0.6366232633590698,
-0.341706246137619,
-0.14531081914901733,
-0.07586248964071274,
0.5362915992736816,
-0.400846391916275,
-0.3664707839488983,
0.32085007429122925,
0.4848896265029907,
-0.005602921359241009,
-0.2432207316160202,
0.5203138589859009,
-0.05012631416320801,
-0.5431831479072571,
0.40022188425064087,
0.6005248427391052,
0.303248792886734,
0.19998808205127716,
-0.7145462036132812,
0.23643265664577484,
0.2765630781650543,
-0.3473356366157532,
0.07868684828281403,
0.3188386857509613,
0.331298828125,
0.3855648338794708,
0.6249312162399292,
-0.09007558226585388,
0.15458551049232483,
-0.03830258175730705,
1.012416124343872,
-0.7824690937995911,
-0.6098141074180603,
-0.9054989218711853,
0.3602566719055176,
-0.461841881275177,
-0.34122374653816223,
0.9318015575408936,
0.8344776034355164,
0.844914972782135,
-0.01698259636759758,
0.8219508528709412,
-0.39871636033058167,
0.36675456166267395,
-0.4649878144264221,
0.6847348809242249,
-0.7197812795639038,
0.3524915277957916,
-0.501656174659729,
-1.1886521577835083,
0.10967495292425156,
0.7593422532081604,
-0.0012182419886812568,
0.3055191934108734,
0.7817668318748474,
0.8680984973907471,
0.08225483447313309,
0.12163334339857101,
0.22281843423843384,
0.09205556660890579,
0.2336643636226654,
0.6352798342704773,
0.8310523629188538,
-0.10665453225374222,
0.39183878898620605,
-0.19215011596679688,
-0.5706380009651184,
-0.41565629839897156,
-1.1954187154769897,
-0.3918024003505707,
-0.16713105142116547,
-0.3501620292663574,
-0.20376896858215332,
0.17675231397151947,
0.9208646416664124,
0.5262796878814697,
-0.7206319570541382,
-0.36698612570762634,
-0.6168560981750488,
-0.1300504207611084,
-0.20809254050254822,
-0.20253080129623413,
0.33036792278289795,
-0.48043331503868103,
-0.43628600239753723,
-0.012333649210631847,
0.09963907301425934,
-0.3042754828929901,
-0.3889838755130768,
-0.2595524489879608,
0.1644280105829239,
-0.1418451964855194,
0.3366937041282654,
0.1585197001695633,
-0.31173276901245117,
-0.04151627793908119,
0.09942933171987534,
-0.4011429250240326,
-0.1267159879207611,
0.9112775325775146,
-0.472516804933548,
0.3637283742427826,
0.5611476302146912,
0.5281662344932556,
0.47862252593040466,
0.18485933542251587,
0.6819453835487366,
-0.4108596742153168,
-0.3503563106060028,
0.09080026298761368,
0.3723762035369873,
0.40608012676239014,
-0.32298213243484497,
0.7543140053749084,
0.1494680643081665,
-0.8838368654251099,
-0.9289079904556274,
0.14065784215927124,
-0.4692179560661316,
-0.2376781702041626,
1.2308341264724731,
-0.38456955552101135,
-0.2261938899755478,
-0.0019211492035537958,
0.054867133498191833,
0.1318235993385315,
-0.4793855845928192,
0.3643575608730316,
0.5820921063423157,
-0.13984815776348114,
0.2327962964773178,
-0.8673366904258728,
0.42391547560691833,
0.5054706931114197,
-0.8564352989196777,
0.37892159819602966,
0.7359079718589783,
0.4178752899169922,
0.2486363798379898,
0.8793349266052246,
0.0862080380320549,
0.5108941793441772,
0.5286532044410706,
0.4145447015762329,
-0.11713597178459167,
-0.05386481061577797,
-0.2976817786693573,
0.16640964150428772,
0.3468608558177948,
0.09244919568300247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02030v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02030v2 | Panacea: Pareto Alignment via Preference Adaptation for LLMs | 2024-02-03T05:01:04 | 2024-05-23T13:49:25 | Yifan Zhong, Chengdong Ma, Xiaoyuan Zhang, Ziran Yang, Haojun Chen, Qingfu Zhang, Siyuan Qi, Yaodong Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current methods for large language model alignment typically use scalar human
preference labels. However, this convention tends to oversimplify the
multi-dimensional and heterogeneous nature of human preferences, leading to
reduced expressivity and even misalignment. This paper presents Panacea, an
innovative approach that reframes alignment as a multi-dimensional preference
optimization problem. Panacea trains a single model capable of adapting online
and Pareto-optimally to diverse sets of preferences without the need for
further tuning. A major challenge here is using a low-dimensional preference
vector to guide the model's behavior, despite it being governed by an
overwhelmingly large number of parameters. To address this, Panacea is designed
to use singular value decomposition (SVD)-based low-rank adaptation, which
allows the preference vector to be simply injected online as singular values.
Theoretically, we prove that Panacea recovers the entire Pareto front with
common loss aggregation methods under mild conditions. Moreover, our
experiments demonstrate, for the first time, the feasibility of aligning a
single LLM to represent an exponentially vast spectrum of human preferences
through various optimization methods. Our work marks a step forward in
effectively and efficiently aligning models to diverse and intricate human
preferences in a controllable and Pareto-optimal manner. | [
-0.4569424092769623,
-0.4474809467792511,
0.6067240834236145,
0.35156723856925964,
-0.26524847745895386,
0.057958658784627914,
-0.2853531241416931,
-0.011594529263675213,
0.5369459390640259,
0.49068403244018555,
-0.34196335077285767,
-0.4233730733394623,
-0.4417043924331665,
-0.1829502284526825,
0.26089394092559814,
0.9859492778778076,
0.1581091582775116,
0.21302391588687897,
-0.3192494511604309,
-0.4330243170261383,
-0.4772520959377289,
-0.5213285088539124,
-0.25098490715026855,
-0.23469682037830353,
0.7604739665985107,
0.6020812392234802,
0.8255190253257751,
0.8320195078849792,
0.4742036461830139,
0.20468181371688843,
0.05297220125794411,
0.12099888920783997,
-0.5952681303024292,
-0.0699772909283638,
-0.33686599135398865,
-0.5307015776634216,
-0.7866995930671692,
0.01629130356013775,
0.4073115885257721,
0.817967414855957,
-0.2429153472185135,
0.13306663930416107,
0.10963036864995956,
0.8259857296943665,
-0.9329331517219543,
-0.288663387298584,
-0.7258602380752563,
0.05374092981219292,
-0.32855749130249023,
-0.09119212627410889,
-0.2222956120967865,
-0.5841788053512573,
0.13680189847946167,
-0.6539289355278015,
-0.10548380017280579,
-0.13175620138645172,
0.7680248022079468,
0.3678458631038666,
-0.41764113306999207,
-0.153991237282753,
-0.7969234585762024,
0.8589127659797668,
-0.6991512179374695,
0.36110296845436096,
0.03730782866477966,
0.3581927716732025,
-0.15438978374004364,
-0.16918767988681793,
-0.4067184627056122,
0.29994532465934753,
0.41112467646598816,
0.1949964016675949,
-0.16191613674163818,
-0.190948024392128,
-0.28975674510002136,
0.11755617707967758,
-0.3294706642627716,
0.5408912897109985,
-0.17897102236747742,
-0.018832499161362648,
0.34163379669189453,
0.20136304199695587,
0.25452426075935364,
0.0918412134051323,
-0.8238280415534973,
-0.158451110124588,
-0.6247833967208862,
0.39517736434936523,
0.3306196928024292,
0.6509497165679932,
-0.13487963378429413,
0.5431395173072815,
0.24071268737316132,
0.7513238191604614,
0.34233716130256653,
-0.40826401114463806,
0.15393850207328796,
0.0582328662276268,
-0.2694239616394043,
0.31155699491500854,
0.5120865106582642,
0.7484090328216553,
-0.1900370866060257,
-0.004001511726528406,
0.031912483274936676,
0.35237547755241394,
0.45442941784858704,
-0.39094778895378113,
-0.0493498295545578,
0.1439916342496872,
-0.32657885551452637,
-0.2896748185157776,
-0.207749605178833,
-1.2337347269058228,
-0.7554208040237427,
-0.6375085711479187,
0.4886120855808258,
-0.043331779539585114,
0.11539836972951889,
0.4250645637512207,
0.11975623667240143,
0.5776330232620239,
0.44843021035194397,
-1.0515040159225464,
0.23000092804431915,
0.8544314503669739,
0.8398239016532898,
-0.35832229256629944,
-0.47673869132995605,
-0.6277564167976379,
0.3110247552394867,
-0.2819879949092865,
0.9810893535614014,
-0.7498667240142822,
-0.14301809668540955,
-0.2623263895511627,
-0.2793625295162201,
-0.06882623583078384,
-0.4759039878845215,
0.5812632441520691,
-0.34617555141448975,
0.29613184928894043,
-0.6234347820281982,
-0.40531936287879944,
0.13678158819675446,
0.22966472804546356,
-0.5447646379470825,
0.6111052632331848,
-0.11758758127689362,
-0.8128045797348022,
0.41487252712249756,
-0.8199566602706909,
-0.010590001940727234,
-0.3089964985847473,
-0.020442960783839226,
-0.6283816695213318,
0.27999669313430786,
0.4191626310348511,
0.4230273365974426,
-0.285404235124588,
0.08700910955667496,
-0.9769279360771179,
-0.14271840453147888,
0.23095831274986267,
-0.1125437542796135,
0.7571437358856201,
0.056210339069366455,
-0.08477119356393814,
0.2903197705745697,
-0.46896520256996155,
-0.3501546084880829,
0.032388754189014435,
-0.3896518647670746,
-0.6231281757354736,
0.16198401153087616,
-0.1717035472393036,
0.1578625738620758,
0.6013596653938293,
-0.3654339015483856,
0.6206040978431702,
-0.38816866278648376,
0.2896491587162018,
1.2329970598220825,
-0.17109206318855286,
0.8153605461120605,
-0.24357391893863678,
0.5118511319160461,
0.018564021214842796,
0.42988890409469604,
0.5654403567314148,
-0.23848776519298553,
-0.802546501159668,
-0.5577979683876038,
0.13038204610347748,
0.531317949295044,
-0.34223681688308716,
0.5038067698478699,
-0.4963096082210541,
-0.44364646077156067,
-0.6465553045272827,
0.16787369549274445,
0.06316514313220978,
0.5678434371948242,
0.3414091467857361,
-0.19433894753456116,
-0.4795127809047699,
-1.3085795640945435,
-0.32096752524375916,
0.1054152399301529,
-0.01084410771727562,
0.2476654052734375,
-0.11858167499303818,
-0.44319868087768555,
1.1418133974075317,
-0.7142431735992432,
-0.3889189064502716,
-0.10373977571725845,
-0.13137608766555786,
0.2532077431678772,
0.2399514615535736,
0.6748180985450745,
-0.5318088531494141,
-0.527235746383667,
0.24813826382160187,
-0.263301283121109,
-0.23315522074699402,
-0.06325503438711166,
-0.5258178114891052,
-0.013561042957007885,
0.03211517259478569,
-0.2394847571849823,
0.05291890352964401,
0.6041774153709412,
-0.1922900378704071,
0.13311971724033356,
-0.3406808376312256,
-0.1578546017408371,
-1.4291290044784546,
-0.024014068767428398,
0.07087801396846771,
-0.22037839889526367,
-0.6401750445365906,
-0.2180827409029007,
0.19279026985168457,
-0.09152606129646301,
-0.5422754287719727,
0.35523322224617004,
-0.23185190558433533,
-0.45370975136756897,
-0.34195247292518616,
0.2530686855316162,
0.08365810662508011,
0.6348992586135864,
-0.16627636551856995,
0.7629604935646057,
0.5109524726867676,
-0.49775511026382446,
0.238566592335701,
0.4045802056789398,
0.12900260090827942,
0.9545756578445435,
-0.23822422325611115,
0.2239488959312439,
-0.4568774402141571,
0.21323005855083466,
-0.8161552548408508,
-0.08483700454235077,
0.2999894917011261,
0.010256398469209671,
0.00456652557477355,
-0.11028636246919632,
0.07783828675746918,
0.16724391281604767,
-0.6649322509765625,
0.2040211260318756,
0.2604467570781708,
-0.7685163021087646,
0.7405775785446167,
0.7523205876350403,
-0.4119966924190521,
-0.6883648633956909,
-0.2060614973306656,
0.09132087975740433,
-0.6670049428939819,
-0.2456224411725998,
0.38328319787979126,
-0.32435089349746704,
-0.25528857111930847,
-0.3392612040042877,
-0.09121142327785492,
0.1409008651971817,
0.013873832300305367,
0.09412741661071777,
0.5099681615829468,
-0.1470586359500885,
-0.055240534245967865,
0.30776992440223694,
-0.24578821659088135,
-0.3834076225757599,
-0.20688050985336304,
0.5895633697509766,
-0.3500025272369385,
-0.18408185243606567,
-0.15882423520088196,
0.438813179731369,
1.0426950454711914,
-0.19995932281017303,
0.49000653624534607,
0.4743596613407135,
-0.2638803720474243,
-0.0509650781750679,
-0.5717821717262268,
0.10189060866832733,
-0.42900997400283813,
0.18224534392356873,
-0.35701775550842285,
-0.6923791170120239,
0.6731899380683899,
-0.25106966495513916,
0.125397726893425,
0.32586610317230225,
0.7279639840126038,
-0.09320849180221558,
1.0309562683105469,
0.6460656523704529,
-0.41535961627960205,
0.3247838616371155,
0.21753251552581787,
0.26278382539749146,
-0.9477319717407227,
-0.06816627085208893,
-0.6719701886177063,
-0.6933647990226746,
-0.40257248282432556,
-0.37455064058303833,
0.7198508381843567,
0.2206115871667862,
-0.4340723156929016,
0.2370058298110962,
-0.5409255027770996,
0.6383516192436218,
0.4206687808036804,
0.30658861994743347,
0.011574005708098412,
-0.09933978319168091,
0.03926561400294304,
-0.3041638731956482,
-0.6112645268440247,
-0.5794408917427063,
1.032669186592102,
0.36863186955451965,
0.6901969909667969,
0.3021245002746582,
0.6547712087631226,
0.16189885139465332,
0.3833129405975342,
-0.71831876039505,
0.29024553298950195,
-0.541530966758728,
-0.15797454118728638,
-0.37954282760620117,
-0.22665393352508545,
-0.8984971642494202,
0.5046138763427734,
-0.3076011538505554,
-0.7583948373794556,
0.6683055758476257,
0.20753350853919983,
-0.6100010275840759,
0.31130751967430115,
-0.7308257818222046,
0.9750746488571167,
-0.5568609237670898,
-0.4311455190181732,
0.09332458674907684,
-0.6869029998779297,
0.39156559109687805,
-0.214935764670372,
0.2773166298866272,
-0.30046749114990234,
-0.4092172086238861,
0.5626496076583862,
-0.2979888916015625,
0.9982003569602966,
-0.30839240550994873,
-0.22211845219135284,
-0.5971561670303345,
-0.08677314966917038,
0.7135958671569824,
-0.02786301076412201,
-0.042991578578948975,
0.0389193519949913,
0.06812187284231186,
-0.7261000871658325,
-0.5816118717193604,
1.0512681007385254,
-1.0898226499557495,
-0.4811670482158661,
-0.411833256483078,
-0.5246052145957947,
-0.529393196105957,
0.15664595365524292,
0.03452311083674431,
0.0006417206604965031,
-0.1445273756980896,
0.01278101745992899,
0.6213849782943726,
-0.37996605038642883,
0.36418581008911133,
0.21098433434963226,
-0.22477968037128448,
-0.7872545719146729,
1.039581298828125,
-0.1308484673500061,
0.21838201582431793,
0.4419707655906677,
0.528052031993866,
-0.38149091601371765,
-0.38610726594924927,
-0.4334059953689575,
0.15825419127941132,
-0.6331577897071838,
-0.23530982434749603,
-0.46329835057258606,
0.42031511664390564,
-0.4097204804420471,
-0.7514423727989197,
-0.7050616145133972,
-0.19176791608333588,
-0.5282192230224609,
0.08842334896326065,
0.07715011388063431,
0.4123964011669159,
0.0654992163181305,
0.18353964388370514,
-0.6372894048690796,
0.5017266273498535,
0.6838365197181702,
0.485603004693985,
-0.3355334997177124,
-0.2219533920288086,
-0.04375213012099266,
0.04264036566019058,
-0.17555207014083862,
-0.943726658821106,
0.538131594657898,
0.09078928828239441,
0.5469619035720825,
0.5960272550582886,
0.24606990814208984,
0.9771048426628113,
-0.4370601177215576,
0.5285102128982544,
0.31528615951538086,
-1.147290825843811,
0.2962517738342285,
-0.24836310744285583,
0.23225517570972443,
0.7032943964004517,
0.18187126517295837,
-0.46295204758644104,
0.1473691463470459,
-0.061381202191114426,
-0.8297333121299744,
0.6721049547195435,
-0.1810966283082962,
0.07694099098443985,
0.30812910199165344,
0.3314758241176605,
0.560374915599823,
0.008275832049548626,
-0.7260969877243042,
-0.12467976659536362,
-0.47161975502967834,
-0.18655885756015778,
-0.1661434769630432,
-0.21578356623649597,
-0.4229736924171448,
-0.16322369873523712,
0.6736852526664734,
-0.41511037945747375,
0.2399776428937912,
-0.13495834171772003,
0.02640802040696144,
-0.07461779564619064,
0.4436403214931488,
1.085166335105896,
0.771868109703064,
-0.3644696772098541,
0.3277038633823395,
0.12356286495923996,
-0.09847671538591385,
0.27643775939941406,
-0.10212988406419754,
0.06966840475797653,
-0.4702027440071106,
-0.15220913290977478,
0.9557315111160278,
0.26658445596694946,
-0.39646556973457336,
0.5972574353218079,
-0.0935545265674591,
-0.022005101665854454,
-0.04785985127091408,
-0.23269642889499664,
0.24585852026939392,
0.35938772559165955,
0.17759083211421967,
0.2767888009548187,
-0.10371924191713333,
-0.34124431014060974,
-0.15997380018234253,
0.6043935418128967,
-0.37000223994255066,
-0.25228655338287354,
0.6091241836547852,
0.17737452685832977,
-0.2828943729400635,
0.054610613733530045,
0.14092963933944702,
-0.47141239047050476,
0.15087315440177917,
0.5017884969711304,
1.038529872894287,
-0.3132229149341583,
0.26485177874565125,
-0.17034341394901276,
0.23916146159172058,
-0.02274238131940365,
0.08519306033849716,
0.2504020035266876,
-0.9621521830558777,
-0.17665541172027588,
-0.7708351016044617,
-0.5700880885124207,
-0.05841275677084923,
-0.7674224972724915,
0.25897255539894104,
-0.5796575546264648,
-0.06933566927909851,
0.23869457840919495,
-0.23933345079421997,
-0.39064207673072815,
-0.2389240860939026,
0.05167233571410179,
0.3362795412540436,
-1.2275569438934326,
0.8244854807853699,
0.7790781855583191,
-0.1421028971672058,
-0.3991031050682068,
-0.024036051705479622,
0.016284765675663948,
-0.7581081390380859,
0.1387508064508438,
-0.18878309428691864,
-0.10411681979894638,
-0.11015630513429642,
-0.4913506507873535,
-0.8484897017478943,
1.0517841577529907,
0.9799878597259521,
-0.4998632073402405,
0.12163714319467545,
0.35084930062294006,
0.38555797934532166,
-0.5892896056175232,
-0.2958424985408783,
0.5270964503288269,
0.6645070314407349,
-0.03088960610330105,
-0.8537657856941223,
-0.21245218813419342,
-0.02185809426009655,
0.2742861211299896,
0.3285037875175476,
-0.7127078771591187,
0.8577823042869568,
0.09930846840143204,
0.11439330130815506,
-0.28723329305648804,
0.3501060903072357,
0.2605040669441223,
0.2844853699207306,
0.6492453217506409,
0.7274426817893982,
0.7106531858444214,
0.15921157598495483,
0.6879590749740601,
-0.1797654777765274,
0.4451080560684204,
1.0988065004348755,
-0.6632614731788635,
0.8942988514900208,
0.9216432571411133,
-0.30696219205856323,
0.31655651330947876,
0.6719236969947815,
0.34853410720825195,
0.583731472492218,
-0.11878474056720734,
-0.1116725504398346,
-0.6022741794586182,
-0.007713038474321365,
-0.2594052851200104,
0.5283479690551758,
0.22085563838481903,
-0.028148971498012543,
-0.41362428665161133,
0.2768403887748718,
-0.09876298159360886,
0.168024942278862,
-0.3300769627094269,
0.8999667167663574,
-0.2334153801202774,
-0.4983353316783905,
0.6039736270904541,
0.09733051061630249,
0.614517331123352,
-0.3116385340690613,
0.2148527354001999,
-0.41689667105674744,
0.35611289739608765,
-0.04824856296181679,
-0.18060874938964844,
0.07877810299396515,
-0.33502814173698425,
-0.42724689841270447,
-0.1647169291973114,
0.45589157938957214,
-0.4446195662021637,
-0.5776168704032898,
0.06054595485329628,
0.2818223237991333,
-0.18664027750492096,
0.04973621293902397,
-0.72612065076828,
0.32602575421333313,
0.08398477733135223,
0.040992751717567444,
0.759547233581543,
0.01764608733355999,
-0.12960903346538544,
0.5630884766578674,
0.6404546499252319,
0.07763500511646271,
0.14075703918933868,
-0.26997023820877075,
0.9312329888343811,
-0.5425785779953003,
-0.6593008637428284,
-0.7295888066291809,
0.34254729747772217,
0.010791366919875145,
-0.2457106113433838,
0.5529618263244629,
0.6366022825241089,
0.5169967412948608,
-0.23137260973453522,
0.7191005945205688,
0.4692748486995697,
0.5328415036201477,
-0.471891850233078,
0.425275593996048,
-0.4611528813838959,
0.5898250937461853,
-0.35550859570503235,
-1.2652912139892578,
-0.5552656054496765,
0.5058426260948181,
-0.3451445698738098,
-0.4893546998500824,
0.4394938349723816,
0.7199999690055847,
-0.36310404539108276,
-0.3093240261077881,
0.2873711585998535,
0.04679245501756668,
0.3494454026222229,
0.6975200772285461,
0.4566064178943634,
0.04855344444513321,
0.18122291564941406,
-0.24335765838623047,
-0.4211050868034363,
-0.3499414622783661,
-0.9634609818458557,
-0.47214606404304504,
-0.47367891669273376,
-0.18760354816913605,
-0.03422373905777931,
-0.0356147475540638,
1.2737693786621094,
0.5030905604362488,
-0.7821817994117737,
-0.334703654050827,
0.15198664367198944,
0.17954592406749725,
-0.2782278060913086,
-0.19689488410949707,
0.5532363057136536,
-0.2234906256198883,
-0.9182872176170349,
0.555415689945221,
0.7384475469589233,
0.05356569588184357,
-0.4107658863067627,
-0.3125897943973541,
-0.2464490383863449,
0.2583424150943756,
0.5621964335441589,
0.3512730598449707,
-0.8890696167945862,
-0.3772237002849579,
-0.03580210357904434,
-0.17081312835216522,
0.40067702531814575,
0.8361082077026367,
-0.5210536122322083,
0.6939963102340698,
0.49298274517059326,
0.8600600361824036,
0.29455143213272095,
0.22274096310138702,
0.6945765614509583,
-0.5501126646995544,
-0.02485925517976284,
0.15147215127944946,
0.3371366262435913,
0.2344018667936325,
-0.2914840877056122,
-0.061594147235155106,
0.007130729965865612,
-0.5142446756362915,
-0.8494693636894226,
0.21242737770080566,
-1.5276199579238892,
-0.3742023706436157,
0.8850794434547424,
-0.04706888645887375,
-0.15115933120250702,
-0.11808271706104279,
-0.4074343144893646,
0.054634060710668564,
-0.45174428820610046,
1.1456173658370972,
0.4386415183544159,
-0.23733171820640564,
-0.12669391930103302,
-0.02896946482360363,
0.24473877251148224,
0.5539824962615967,
-0.9455361366271973,
0.2527759075164795,
0.6280707716941833,
0.2292659729719162,
0.14574822783470154,
0.42923659086227417,
0.016004426404833794,
-0.03625883534550667,
-0.5742499232292175,
0.2770053446292877,
0.17656029760837555,
-0.19602355360984802,
-0.6943178176879883,
0.5101695656776428,
0.21358555555343628,
-0.33378297090530396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05119v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05119v4 | A Closer Look at the Limitations of Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-03T04:45:25 | 2024-05-28T01:55:38 | Sreyan Ghosh, Chandra Kiran Reddy Evuru, Sonal Kumar, Ramaneswaran S, Deepali Aneja, Zeyu Jin, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction Tuning (IT), the process of training large language models (LLMs)
using instruction-response pairs, has emerged as the predominant method for
transforming base pre-trained LLMs into open-domain conversational agents.
While IT has achieved notable success and widespread adoption, its limitations
and shortcomings remain underexplored. In this paper, through rigorous
experiments and an in-depth analysis of the changes LLMs undergo through IT, we
reveal various limitations of IT. In particular, we show that (1) IT fails to
enhance knowledge or skills in LLMs. LoRA fine-tuning is limited to learning
response initiation and style tokens, and full-parameter fine-tuning leads to
knowledge degradation. (2) Copying response patterns from IT datasets derived
from knowledgeable sources leads to a decline in response quality. (3)
Full-parameter fine-tuning increases hallucination by inaccurately borrowing
tokens from conceptually similar instances in the IT dataset for generating
responses. (4) Popular methods to improve IT do not lead to performance
improvements over a simple LoRA fine-tuned model. Our findings reveal that
responses generated solely from pre-trained knowledge consistently outperform
responses by models that learn any form of new knowledge from IT on open-source
datasets. We hope the insights and challenges revealed in this paper inspire
future work in related directions. | [
-0.4416138827800751,
-0.939441442489624,
0.4030928909778595,
-0.19105742871761322,
-0.09162205457687378,
-0.014892206527292728,
-0.5498420000076294,
-0.518856406211853,
-0.11284855753183365,
0.7907978892326355,
-0.5880180597305298,
-0.4122433662414551,
-0.5877571105957031,
-0.02720864675939083,
-0.3706665337085724,
1.1831973791122437,
0.11776237189769745,
0.020800258964300156,
-0.2033119797706604,
-0.04925672709941864,
-0.5210468769073486,
-0.3336741328239441,
-0.6515644192695618,
-0.307483971118927,
0.3854852318763733,
0.8998726606369019,
0.5581167340278625,
0.7636504173278809,
0.5023859143257141,
0.3323838710784912,
0.06826505810022354,
0.5076501369476318,
-0.8221018314361572,
-0.07460526376962662,
0.10652702301740646,
-0.7256479859352112,
-0.4058321416378021,
0.12195626646280289,
0.7295368313789368,
0.8178704977035522,
-0.14265292882919312,
0.18065159022808075,
0.23273663222789764,
0.8626149892807007,
-0.7789478302001953,
0.07005029916763306,
-1.000022530555725,
-0.15670128166675568,
-0.0990728884935379,
-0.40199774503707886,
-0.5789593458175659,
-0.37827128171920776,
0.10651551932096481,
-0.6003366112709045,
0.2259414941072464,
-0.02869308739900589,
0.851646900177002,
0.6861475706100464,
-0.1690443456172943,
-0.5807619094848633,
-0.9716055989265442,
0.7195338606834412,
-0.9482801556587219,
0.0776764377951622,
0.4980579912662506,
0.27862924337387085,
-0.2112123668193817,
-0.33397382497787476,
-0.37045779824256897,
-0.2743853032588959,
0.09943115711212158,
-0.1923140287399292,
0.050761014223098755,
0.11819780617952347,
0.4681801199913025,
0.45092105865478516,
-0.15695175528526306,
0.4317431151866913,
-0.7506917119026184,
0.09313446283340454,
0.4427773952484131,
0.37513473629951477,
0.05976025015115738,
0.14796768128871918,
-0.23430176079273224,
-0.18472957611083984,
-0.9269612431526184,
0.39681655168533325,
0.579400360584259,
0.5345775485038757,
0.1430150866508484,
0.6483663320541382,
-0.019632089883089066,
0.9305443167686462,
0.08777116239070892,
0.0038030361756682396,
-0.10927198082208633,
0.09518984705209732,
-0.30951687693595886,
0.04848775267601013,
0.6445099711418152,
0.2689247131347656,
0.3647454082965851,
-0.19201499223709106,
-0.19886478781700134,
0.11014313995838165,
0.40770062804222107,
-0.6874295473098755,
0.10311269015073776,
0.05709296092391014,
0.0737214908003807,
-0.04499748349189758,
0.07094498723745346,
-0.5101211667060852,
-0.3723451793193817,
-0.4984618127346039,
0.40158578753471375,
-0.5222803950309753,
0.04006808623671532,
0.2408953458070755,
0.029655739665031433,
0.4864691495895386,
0.10489976406097412,
-1.073618769645691,
0.30116569995880127,
0.7811276912689209,
0.46721091866493225,
-0.23369374871253967,
-0.30334603786468506,
-0.6509302854537964,
-0.04796281456947327,
-0.5631315112113953,
0.923732340335846,
-0.8279833793640137,
-0.4897647798061371,
0.0290792528539896,
0.027997037395834923,
-0.36133426427841187,
-0.9902796149253845,
0.21259728074073792,
-0.7397879362106323,
-0.09421388059854507,
-0.33074715733528137,
-0.7101015448570251,
0.22916553914546967,
-0.0553678460419178,
-0.5965682864189148,
0.5833340883255005,
0.13239651918411255,
-0.4138878881931305,
0.20059533417224884,
-0.4042581617832184,
-0.5823259353637695,
-0.28102532029151917,
-0.14955537021160126,
-0.35023248195648193,
0.424873948097229,
-0.12743277847766876,
0.214073047041893,
-0.42305341362953186,
-0.1364668756723404,
-0.11416763812303543,
-0.8469148874282837,
0.30141258239746094,
-0.16182267665863037,
0.5007997751235962,
0.2088518887758255,
-0.2843235433101654,
0.07998035848140717,
-0.9724057912826538,
0.30983299016952515,
-0.06948956102132797,
-0.6137479543685913,
-0.21266594529151917,
0.20050647854804993,
-0.6040214896202087,
-0.10156349092721939,
0.13943356275558472,
-0.2891928255558014,
0.31616565585136414,
-0.5603617429733276,
0.6547329425811768,
1.1122688055038452,
-0.3387666344642639,
0.5129144191741943,
-0.3792804479598999,
0.5221450328826904,
0.06755903363227844,
0.015190930105745792,
-0.34304094314575195,
-0.14937272667884827,
-1.051853060722351,
0.22281917929649353,
0.11102627962827682,
0.5094122886657715,
-0.6951066255569458,
0.3148033022880554,
-0.30072033405303955,
-0.20826853811740875,
-0.9202460050582886,
0.2806823253631592,
0.4428400993347168,
0.5552586317062378,
0.3495314121246338,
-0.0957927405834198,
-0.3017651438713074,
-0.8476081490516663,
-0.3538716435432434,
0.1172713041305542,
0.10366453975439072,
0.33940112590789795,
0.21522346138954163,
0.055551882833242416,
0.5338186621665955,
-0.3181965947151184,
-0.32501667737960815,
0.0747402086853981,
0.04136001691222191,
0.1021542027592659,
0.3840201497077942,
0.15349741280078888,
-0.34221816062927246,
-0.4952835142612457,
0.1493670791387558,
-0.507835865020752,
0.07036937773227692,
0.1521047055721283,
0.147091805934906,
0.46521028876304626,
0.5539101362228394,
-0.3298415541648865,
0.534438967704773,
0.6456014513969421,
-0.1390497237443924,
0.3363926112651825,
-0.2059200555086136,
0.2669614553451538,
-0.9233596324920654,
-0.18487568199634552,
-0.2154117077589035,
0.21822120249271393,
-0.4896875321865082,
0.08284929394721985,
0.028032783418893814,
0.0014505846193060279,
-0.296993613243103,
0.39118078351020813,
-0.35096439719200134,
-0.1828995645046234,
-0.5253676772117615,
0.2359231859445572,
-0.2689722180366516,
0.6294554471969604,
-0.2233617603778839,
1.1194936037063599,
0.30188068747520447,
-1.1105115413665771,
0.31303632259368896,
0.28417524695396423,
-0.552986204624176,
0.5431488156318665,
-0.7874088883399963,
0.487325519323349,
-0.06875509768724442,
-0.23233039677143097,
-0.7372435927391052,
-0.41759076714515686,
0.08952697366476059,
-0.28836265206336975,
0.5375333428382874,
0.029425978660583496,
-0.2911130487918854,
-0.2249733954668045,
-0.2881442606449127,
0.12379780411720276,
0.6426584124565125,
-0.5583636164665222,
0.4633985459804535,
-0.08453479409217834,
0.11623504757881165,
-0.6799580454826355,
-0.5881592035293579,
-0.26476308703422546,
-0.0420534722507,
-0.6113404631614685,
0.13773073256015778,
-0.30256399512290955,
-0.2936221957206726,
0.02612144686281681,
-0.3507401943206787,
0.024205120280385017,
0.09409071505069733,
0.08681870251893997,
0.14442291855812073,
-0.5084330439567566,
0.2082698941230774,
0.07552710920572281,
0.07034539431333542,
0.09678006917238235,
-0.1548260897397995,
0.48198533058166504,
-0.21009428799152374,
-0.5439779162406921,
-0.4347153604030609,
0.21701766550540924,
0.527348518371582,
-0.24478211998939514,
0.919972836971283,
0.34145668148994446,
0.14826926589012146,
-0.43852147459983826,
-0.4498779773712158,
-0.3782046437263489,
-0.5172677040100098,
0.45997557044029236,
-0.3051811754703522,
-0.9620442390441895,
0.3311699330806732,
-0.11571430414915085,
0.20291130244731903,
0.15769052505493164,
0.23289795219898224,
-0.10152426362037659,
1.0040054321289062,
0.7147261500358582,
0.13651123642921448,
0.6909749507904053,
-0.2526714503765106,
0.17531950771808624,
-0.9635577201843262,
-0.13015881180763245,
-0.7660362124443054,
-0.34057825803756714,
-0.8058159351348877,
-0.1034262403845787,
0.4286057949066162,
-0.0522225946187973,
-0.4460790753364563,
0.004337014630436897,
-0.4476040005683899,
0.7609357833862305,
0.6163800954818726,
0.33397331833839417,
0.43361806869506836,
0.2726529836654663,
0.378692626953125,
0.02263997681438923,
-0.6252053380012512,
-0.5812592506408691,
1.1302781105041504,
0.0635124072432518,
1.152177095413208,
-0.03957696631550789,
0.4859777092933655,
0.10801490396261215,
0.02501317299902439,
-0.9324450492858887,
0.6177200078964233,
-0.39313095808029175,
-0.366892009973526,
-0.4735420346260071,
-0.5678455233573914,
-0.949817955493927,
-0.20399057865142822,
-0.034450713545084,
-0.6982464790344238,
-0.14354433119297028,
0.36448848247528076,
-0.39564332365989685,
0.4204997420310974,
-0.9719541072845459,
0.48875728249549866,
-0.23077461123466492,
-0.5434384942054749,
-0.15250834822654724,
-0.4897957146167755,
0.22952277958393097,
-0.004743324592709541,
-0.01559271290898323,
-0.032756462693214417,
0.16668200492858887,
0.6011805534362793,
-0.4390823245048523,
0.9157620072364807,
-0.08570225536823273,
-0.5584961175918579,
0.23620258271694183,
-0.14419347047805786,
0.5957151055335999,
-0.3415341377258301,
-0.13516578078269958,
-0.22495827078819275,
-0.10183976590633392,
-0.6459035277366638,
-0.7141241431236267,
0.8902975916862488,
-1.0599299669265747,
-1.1532742977142334,
0.028741968795657158,
-0.617160975933075,
-0.7199418544769287,
0.09430314600467682,
0.37809938192367554,
0.4068840444087982,
0.05638734996318817,
0.29776790738105774,
1.0879697799682617,
-0.3290213942527771,
0.10544750839471817,
0.5712538361549377,
-0.01199591439217329,
-0.15989647805690765,
1.050613522529602,
0.16496475040912628,
0.6966630816459656,
0.1708282083272934,
0.01576225273311138,
0.18339323997497559,
-0.4938441216945648,
-0.3711671233177185,
0.14710664749145508,
-0.7788762450218201,
-0.05945334583520889,
-0.158290833234787,
-0.24777455627918243,
-0.3931666612625122,
0.060767244547605515,
-0.41069692373275757,
-0.17315387725830078,
-0.6037918329238892,
0.03978786617517471,
0.24765688180923462,
1.0552698373794556,
0.21209509670734406,
0.4342106580734253,
-0.5688878297805786,
0.17843063175678253,
0.4638311564922333,
0.5852034091949463,
-0.07370352745056152,
-0.7829452157020569,
-0.5408134460449219,
0.3086593747138977,
-0.2609984874725342,
-0.6049910187721252,
-0.05093492195010185,
0.37624236941337585,
0.3913133144378662,
0.49628371000289917,
0.08867281675338745,
0.7793697118759155,
-0.5907639265060425,
0.7351275086402893,
-0.3267273008823395,
-0.735594630241394,
0.6315351128578186,
-0.19922219216823578,
0.29997655749320984,
0.3436741232872009,
0.2647194564342499,
0.11724162846803665,
-0.4112021028995514,
-0.2708657383918762,
-0.7805958986282349,
1.0309691429138184,
-0.2587375342845917,
0.5566513538360596,
0.04796332120895386,
0.5391202569007874,
0.24421162903308868,
0.22579120099544525,
-0.23546111583709717,
-0.3729911744594574,
-0.1289362907409668,
0.034903593361377716,
-0.15773305296897888,
-0.28426921367645264,
-0.2337198406457901,
-0.33837226033210754,
0.8736045956611633,
-0.2685680091381073,
0.3655051290988922,
-0.227882519364357,
0.01337265595793724,
-0.5598310828208923,
0.4988453686237335,
0.8475862741470337,
0.6640280485153198,
-0.06932146847248077,
-0.10403449088335037,
0.08349788188934326,
-0.09754352271556854,
-0.031253594905138016,
0.05079558864235878,
-0.09911878407001495,
-0.45363643765449524,
0.3482828140258789,
1.168071985244751,
0.3142220675945282,
-0.5805249214172363,
0.06916320323944092,
-0.041376158595085144,
-0.14313074946403503,
-0.13773411512374878,
0.7440187931060791,
-0.0563741996884346,
0.2898808419704437,
0.19605271518230438,
0.08209756761789322,
-0.23891940712928772,
-0.7039573192596436,
-0.2717031240463257,
0.7457801699638367,
-0.3229292929172516,
-0.3089768886566162,
0.5414930582046509,
0.016614586114883423,
-0.5445700287818909,
0.6705299615859985,
0.12111436575651169,
-0.06432411074638367,
0.7023119926452637,
0.6820890307426453,
0.5171358585357666,
-0.2532876431941986,
0.23846867680549622,
0.23523235321044922,
0.33906319737434387,
0.08042854070663452,
0.07646408677101135,
-0.19961673021316528,
-0.6581019163131714,
-0.33731499314308167,
-0.3800404369831085,
-0.412272185087204,
0.45647913217544556,
-1.05218505859375,
0.10031434893608093,
-0.68177729845047,
-0.18518176674842834,
-0.08210936933755875,
-0.11584924161434174,
-0.7627336978912354,
-0.11329872906208038,
-0.1423424482345581,
0.7807886600494385,
-0.5174175500869751,
0.658738374710083,
0.9084600210189819,
-0.3707740604877472,
-0.9004620909690857,
0.1342354416847229,
-0.3560742735862732,
-1.142821192741394,
0.5260142087936401,
0.09524863213300705,
-0.2921542525291443,
0.23339730501174927,
-0.9795781373977661,
-0.6025384664535522,
0.874123752117157,
0.6693217158317566,
-0.6351277828216553,
-0.39649614691734314,
0.3970494270324707,
0.5819013714790344,
-0.1158829778432846,
-0.009992952458560467,
0.8434557318687439,
0.28445905447006226,
0.24598662555217743,
-1.0049127340316772,
-0.22468137741088867,
-0.12125331908464432,
0.02249310538172722,
0.204695925116539,
-0.851334810256958,
1.0299835205078125,
-0.37830212712287903,
-0.2545914351940155,
0.24491724371910095,
0.38816365599632263,
-0.09529758989810944,
0.1474127471446991,
0.19214890897274017,
0.5763276815414429,
0.7302777767181396,
-0.18513180315494537,
0.9269535541534424,
-0.3016742467880249,
0.07991605997085571,
1.1712570190429688,
-0.21750898659229279,
0.8111329078674316,
0.4753928482532501,
-0.07535632699728012,
0.5362753868103027,
0.4498729407787323,
0.15199357271194458,
0.41168761253356934,
0.16609445214271545,
-0.26614144444465637,
-0.2606850862503052,
-0.081185482442379,
-0.4728285074234009,
0.44748514890670776,
0.5813469290733337,
-0.31056922674179077,
-0.01085249800235033,
0.07737976312637329,
-0.08403091132640839,
0.2933841645717621,
-0.3996250629425049,
1.044663906097412,
0.023560520261526108,
-0.9776883125305176,
1.0334360599517822,
-0.2820357084274292,
0.5077449679374695,
-0.6188190579414368,
-0.17490066587924957,
-0.30459100008010864,
0.31499582529067993,
-0.2163258194923401,
-0.38114652037620544,
0.040338899940252304,
-0.00999479740858078,
-0.2399751842021942,
0.08029434084892273,
0.4868481457233429,
-0.2786126434803009,
-0.11935261636972427,
0.12173493206501007,
0.43613284826278687,
-0.16210678219795227,
0.15441793203353882,
-0.3225233852863312,
0.31026244163513184,
0.0712536945939064,
-0.35081857442855835,
0.4619356393814087,
0.6307716369628906,
0.2226327359676361,
0.73989337682724,
0.35973283648490906,
0.1732078492641449,
0.21060612797737122,
-0.17930011451244354,
1.102381944656372,
-0.5396345257759094,
-0.059328123927116394,
-0.7400822639465332,
0.2881796956062317,
0.19155800342559814,
-0.21315684914588928,
0.6258026361465454,
0.15350593626499176,
1.073258876800537,
-0.21255649626255035,
0.7918782234191895,
0.231012225151062,
0.34132397174835205,
-0.949004054069519,
0.2897562086582184,
-0.610948383808136,
0.7940131425857544,
0.04792848601937294,
-0.7245157957077026,
0.2805040180683136,
0.4280516505241394,
-0.44922542572021484,
0.269584983587265,
0.7281550765037537,
0.8253138065338135,
0.08276093751192093,
0.039514221251010895,
0.6476074457168579,
0.4225417971611023,
0.15127317607402802,
0.6452616453170776,
0.9944362044334412,
-0.283022940158844,
0.5890799760818481,
-0.17368310689926147,
-0.12152199447154999,
-0.21059340238571167,
-0.4875902235507965,
-1.2053461074829102,
-0.6274030208587646,
-0.07840894162654877,
-0.368465393781662,
0.3100455403327942,
0.8636658191680908,
0.6145497560501099,
-0.8670879602432251,
-0.21482771635055542,
-0.06923142820596695,
0.18541038036346436,
-0.048226818442344666,
-0.24289490282535553,
0.15764304995536804,
-0.8520073890686035,
-0.7431681752204895,
0.3914768099784851,
0.03787548467516899,
-0.002244197065010667,
-0.30998751521110535,
-0.028777793049812317,
0.25373944640159607,
0.1789109855890274,
0.48895499110221863,
0.6063225865364075,
-0.6653415560722351,
-0.19006145000457764,
0.299165278673172,
-0.05591041222214699,
0.14203989505767822,
0.8900172710418701,
-0.6787007451057434,
0.4839998483657837,
-0.08361733704805374,
0.8505218029022217,
0.19544270634651184,
-0.1990557760000229,
0.4693184196949005,
-0.8399157524108887,
-0.03541943430900574,
0.07393024861812592,
-0.03459707275032997,
0.2395276576280594,
-0.3772377073764801,
0.2929724156856537,
-0.1551046520471573,
-0.734726071357727,
-0.7380346655845642,
0.43667471408843994,
-0.6114987134933472,
-0.2050914168357849,
1.2364425659179688,
-0.0564458966255188,
-0.3702376186847687,
0.2209664136171341,
-0.2101466804742813,
0.16555872559547424,
-0.384450227022171,
1.0642403364181519,
0.6111413836479187,
-0.29954811930656433,
-0.06545013189315796,
-0.728371798992157,
0.6623961329460144,
0.3937552273273468,
-0.8439348340034485,
0.2213817685842514,
0.5702088475227356,
0.31177881360054016,
0.06700609624385834,
0.4276619553565979,
0.21608014404773712,
0.3085862398147583,
-0.20006099343299866,
-0.22481082379817963,
-0.3870166838169098,
-0.32908910512924194,
-0.2515101134777069,
-0.0681767538189888,
0.46233272552490234,
-0.11822152137756348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02008v1 | How well do LLMs cite relevant medical references? An evaluation framework and analyses | 2024-02-03T03:44:57 | 2024-02-03T03:44:57 | Kevin Wu, Eric Wu, Ally Cassasola, Angela Zhang, Kevin Wei, Teresa Nguyen, Sith Riantawan, Patricia Shi Riantawan, Daniel E. Ho, James Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are currently being used to answer medical
questions across a variety of clinical domains. Recent top-performing
commercial LLMs, in particular, are also capable of citing sources to support
their responses. In this paper, we ask: do the sources that LLMs generate
actually support the claims that they make? To answer this, we propose three
contributions. First, as expert medical annotations are an expensive and
time-consuming bottleneck for scalable evaluation, we demonstrate that GPT-4 is
highly accurate in validating source relevance, agreeing 88% of the time with a
panel of medical doctors. Second, we develop an end-to-end, automated pipeline
called \textit{SourceCheckup} and use it to evaluate five top-performing LLMs
on a dataset of 1200 generated questions, totaling over 40K pairs of statements
and sources. Interestingly, we find that between ~50% to 90% of LLM responses
are not fully supported by the sources they provide. We also evaluate GPT-4
with retrieval augmented generation (RAG) and find that, even still, around
30\% of individual statements are unsupported, while nearly half of its
responses are not fully supported. Third, we open-source our curated dataset of
medical questions and expert annotations for future evaluations. Given the
rapid pace of LLM development and the potential harms of incorrect or outdated
medical information, it is crucial to also understand and quantify their
capability to produce relevant, trustworthy medical references. | [
-0.11239352822303772,
-0.25354471802711487,
1.274289846420288,
-0.11361651867628098,
-0.22591222822666168,
-0.023902131244540215,
-0.12012901902198792,
-0.7111694812774658,
0.17777235805988312,
0.47440847754478455,
-0.16180682182312012,
-0.29305705428123474,
-0.7352763414382935,
0.5056727528572083,
-0.20948100090026855,
1.023046612739563,
0.05192117765545845,
0.4909076988697052,
-0.4905056357383728,
-0.24705611169338226,
-0.17155836522579193,
-0.7010116577148438,
-0.45638129115104675,
-0.45528939366340637,
0.7198821902275085,
0.12992574274539948,
0.7488727569580078,
0.7337667942047119,
0.802725613117218,
0.19241495430469513,
-0.12488199770450592,
0.11918025463819504,
-0.27761736512184143,
0.37229815125465393,
-0.3781017065048218,
-0.3237747848033905,
-0.2802208960056305,
0.11495128273963928,
0.4355006515979767,
0.577610194683075,
-0.03840693458914757,
0.25451895594596863,
0.0026400256901979446,
0.4918142557144165,
-0.3294219374656677,
-0.018336661159992218,
-0.8668330311775208,
-0.04192853346467018,
-0.4521715044975281,
-0.29859238862991333,
-0.34511879086494446,
-0.5366185307502747,
0.28961607813835144,
-0.3961966037750244,
0.19778047502040863,
-0.11646673828363419,
0.8555629849433899,
0.5400422811508179,
-0.5238076448440552,
-0.5468028783798218,
-0.4393582046031952,
0.46273115277290344,
-0.8226569294929504,
0.16086432337760925,
0.5952180027961731,
0.4427805542945862,
-0.16937555372714996,
-0.9271067380905151,
-0.3042149245738983,
-0.6054381132125854,
-0.23580466210842133,
0.1648799628019333,
0.04239514842629433,
-0.011899861507117748,
0.5127127766609192,
0.5471923351287842,
-0.3495330214500427,
0.1643925905227661,
-0.3112563192844391,
-0.30918410420417786,
0.4185502529144287,
0.0541239008307457,
0.24950188398361206,
-0.1273852288722992,
-0.33441361784935,
0.39823922514915466,
-1.1024357080459595,
-0.5248391032218933,
0.021505409851670265,
-0.030922358855605125,
0.1782159060239792,
0.8935623168945312,
0.2829057276248932,
0.6759699583053589,
0.0610327422618866,
-0.19943071901798248,
0.2048381268978119,
-0.5899171829223633,
-0.1713651865720749,
-0.09732402861118317,
0.785102367401123,
0.44452446699142456,
0.4280574321746826,
-0.31247109174728394,
0.08821854740381241,
-0.2667776048183441,
0.5103316903114319,
-0.6672948002815247,
-0.14630405604839325,
0.3471427857875824,
-0.21750466525554657,
-0.25426238775253296,
-0.08347377181053162,
-0.3100697696208954,
-0.6924407482147217,
-0.06798572838306427,
0.17023050785064697,
-0.21978135406970978,
0.00025214345077984035,
-0.24021382629871368,
0.011069456115365028,
0.05407455191016197,
0.37898391485214233,
-0.5722598433494568,
0.06490344554185867,
0.4750223159790039,
0.8525089025497437,
-0.16119161248207092,
0.12447158247232437,
-0.7072383761405945,
0.21030528843402863,
-0.508143961429596,
1.065226674079895,
-0.4277607202529907,
-0.32423874735832214,
0.1524275541305542,
-0.024868635460734367,
0.06053812429308891,
-0.9596309661865234,
0.7374452352523804,
-0.4235992431640625,
0.2153041809797287,
-0.664577066898346,
-0.6435540318489075,
0.2809261977672577,
0.26955458521842957,
-0.7600919604301453,
0.6460369825363159,
0.02994208224117756,
-0.7653787732124329,
0.43476665019989014,
-0.38753482699394226,
-0.22450073063373566,
0.276434063911438,
-0.5849800705909729,
-0.3634772300720215,
0.12782059609889984,
0.28659799695014954,
0.44024503231048584,
-0.692172110080719,
0.47672227025032043,
-0.3441430926322937,
-0.12190961092710495,
0.6042242646217346,
-0.2764359414577484,
0.6244049072265625,
0.4033190608024597,
-0.275936484336853,
-0.23424522578716278,
-0.806929886341095,
-0.20528768002986908,
0.06297298520803452,
-0.4160671532154083,
-0.2728389799594879,
-0.05198055878281593,
-0.2007795125246048,
0.3403525650501251,
-0.008441311307251453,
-0.6297546625137329,
0.12089776247739792,
-0.15916752815246582,
0.386231929063797,
0.5766974687576294,
0.37123802304267883,
-0.16121579706668854,
-0.28003615140914917,
0.5437016487121582,
-0.1344028115272522,
-0.17101487517356873,
-0.20932172238826752,
-0.5649377107620239,
-0.36515143513679504,
-0.20978808403015137,
0.43507298827171326,
0.17298752069473267,
-0.7899878621101379,
0.05492182821035385,
-0.15511886775493622,
-0.35067322850227356,
-0.6991122364997864,
0.13989782333374023,
0.3645990788936615,
0.9573182463645935,
0.4508408308029175,
-0.008225854486227036,
-0.4079519212245941,
-1.1335244178771973,
-0.46571114659309387,
-0.3584970235824585,
-0.3222040832042694,
0.5608854293823242,
0.3581828773021698,
-0.13629542291164398,
0.7418926358222961,
-0.26854267716407776,
-0.09492376446723938,
0.13545362651348114,
0.01045823935419321,
0.19972380995750427,
0.15138959884643555,
0.7726852297782898,
-0.4683696925640106,
-0.4505771994590759,
-0.03953409940004349,
-1.0059255361557007,
-0.7686340808868408,
-0.019108276814222336,
-0.0497528575360775,
0.003115799045190215,
0.22348114848136902,
-0.6276885867118835,
-0.03481859341263771,
0.7114158272743225,
-0.3742431104183197,
0.456753134727478,
-0.21132345497608185,
0.12235168367624283,
-1.0719305276870728,
0.4245467483997345,
0.1477966606616974,
-0.5097190737724304,
-0.31279274821281433,
0.020135514438152313,
0.04466354101896286,
0.19592233002185822,
-0.20999692380428314,
0.5610958337783813,
-0.486240953207016,
-0.09872627258300781,
-0.26666733622550964,
0.23052875697612762,
-0.11178582161664963,
-0.27696654200553894,
-0.16698160767555237,
0.8449108600616455,
0.279422402381897,
-0.2730013132095337,
0.3091309070587158,
0.09780305624008179,
-0.368767648935318,
0.8295651078224182,
-0.7728861570358276,
0.19572466611862183,
0.23996467888355255,
0.288275808095932,
-0.954035758972168,
-0.3138641119003296,
0.24399995803833008,
-0.4302101135253906,
0.17837080359458923,
-0.34460964798927307,
-0.6871676445007324,
-0.40003451704978943,
-0.053421325981616974,
0.12026574462652206,
0.35878467559814453,
-0.39106985926628113,
0.3622399866580963,
0.5069324374198914,
-0.2379712015390396,
-0.61757892370224,
-0.6372356414794922,
0.27194681763648987,
0.04740350693464279,
-0.2808670997619629,
0.12642823159694672,
-0.10447414964437485,
-0.44589918851852417,
0.19315604865550995,
-0.37645864486694336,
-0.050553515553474426,
0.010140716098248959,
0.1608547568321228,
0.3662024736404419,
-0.19945944845676422,
0.22189001739025116,
-0.2675860822200775,
-0.04929892346262932,
0.35764047503471375,
-0.12147422134876251,
0.11258427798748016,
0.20491519570350647,
-0.765375554561615,
-0.029611820355057716,
0.15316428244113922,
0.7197533845901489,
0.00829042587429285,
0.3363099694252014,
0.4186255633831024,
-0.38119927048683167,
0.30397337675094604,
-1.0004903078079224,
-0.03366341441869736,
-0.34085819125175476,
0.30724629759788513,
-0.12764078378677368,
-0.932281494140625,
0.43184348940849304,
0.1633126139640808,
0.2151830494403839,
0.8429999351501465,
0.9591181874275208,
-0.15717262029647827,
0.7539286613464355,
-0.013924500904977322,
0.1764702945947647,
-0.04411230981349945,
0.08135490119457245,
-0.08433925360441208,
-0.7957711219787598,
-0.29313430190086365,
-0.5839096903800964,
-0.08607321977615356,
-0.6987910270690918,
-0.6448919177055359,
0.5596556067466736,
-0.0734534040093422,
-0.07525920867919922,
-0.06263919919729233,
-0.36598774790763855,
0.26040416955947876,
0.3182893693447113,
0.10497526079416275,
0.536331057548523,
-0.09232009947299957,
-0.4727349281311035,
-0.006535422522574663,
-0.5111069083213806,
-0.6694934368133545,
1.3708117008209229,
0.67818683385849,
0.7556198239326477,
0.0860612615942955,
0.41428136825561523,
0.2131902575492859,
0.9046050906181335,
-0.574880838394165,
0.4005509316921234,
0.05862636864185333,
-0.846592366695404,
0.1327964812517166,
-0.31549227237701416,
-0.7990376949310303,
0.22020992636680603,
-0.29090771079063416,
-0.30826830863952637,
0.026453500613570213,
0.034080322831869125,
-0.41423025727272034,
0.1591913104057312,
-0.5018122792243958,
0.4225706160068512,
-0.44757047295570374,
-0.4731457233428955,
0.03262145072221756,
-0.6493721604347229,
0.2397603690624237,
-0.4483559727668762,
-0.012236320413649082,
-0.14571969211101532,
-0.2556920647621155,
0.8156875967979431,
-0.5834648609161377,
0.5999655723571777,
-0.15535494685173035,
-0.2451190948486328,
0.3238128125667572,
-0.15584345161914825,
0.3606606423854828,
0.3649140000343323,
-0.19637617468833923,
0.3982793092727661,
0.0489107146859169,
-0.3246113061904907,
-0.6588615775108337,
0.8653228282928467,
-0.5855202674865723,
-0.8196021318435669,
-0.7661724090576172,
-0.43654540181159973,
-0.5121321082115173,
0.1854657083749771,
0.06592034548521042,
0.2513669729232788,
0.034762922674417496,
0.2396887093782425,
0.3593416213989258,
-0.13619720935821533,
0.10953421890735626,
0.6110570430755615,
-0.03864666447043419,
-0.778229296207428,
0.2784041464328766,
0.29809272289276123,
0.26873302459716797,
0.08289223909378052,
0.22379514575004578,
-0.4511473774909973,
-0.7532185912132263,
-0.7143986821174622,
0.6732397079467773,
-0.75162672996521,
-0.2441449910402298,
-0.6154729127883911,
-0.2397201657295227,
-0.1838662475347519,
0.1825597882270813,
-0.23511750996112823,
-0.16372083127498627,
-0.040183089673519135,
-0.3794076442718506,
0.30216050148010254,
1.0924632549285889,
0.07026837021112442,
-0.22273950278759003,
-0.8438733816146851,
0.06407289206981659,
0.2686261534690857,
0.49243682622909546,
-0.33368223905563354,
-0.3956739902496338,
-0.43895915150642395,
-0.2343764305114746,
-0.20768089592456818,
-1.0835384130477905,
-0.09006548672914505,
-0.1729191690683365,
1.0210225582122803,
0.2572818398475647,
-0.14697012305259705,
0.6751358509063721,
-0.8270376920700073,
1.0554851293563843,
0.011545348912477493,
-0.4343605041503906,
0.3925001621246338,
-0.3366369307041168,
0.07131791859865189,
0.6305537223815918,
0.6677644848823547,
-0.13546189665794373,
-0.5466001033782959,
-0.6222000122070312,
-0.7150419354438782,
0.1661165952682495,
0.21829411387443542,
-0.1068282201886177,
-0.3219567537307739,
0.7444725632667542,
0.0737493559718132,
0.13733214139938354,
-0.7078601121902466,
-0.3266741633415222,
0.19443155825138092,
-0.22362878918647766,
-0.04559102654457092,
-0.5525820851325989,
-0.41666316986083984,
0.057852573692798615,
0.3793259263038635,
-0.23886673152446747,
0.32570675015449524,
0.528647780418396,
0.05176355317234993,
-0.23487909138202667,
0.13344158232212067,
0.723512589931488,
1.1245296001434326,
-0.24743029475212097,
0.259701132774353,
0.061671726405620575,
-0.652452290058136,
0.086439348757267,
0.24154746532440186,
-0.026515452191233635,
0.3002726137638092,
0.5946051478385925,
0.38135823607444763,
0.07223469763994217,
-0.721802294254303,
0.4750913083553314,
0.04928408935666084,
-0.059732500463724136,
-0.31742915511131287,
-0.2526962459087372,
0.20319108664989471,
0.4118747413158417,
0.6312893033027649,
-0.071793332695961,
-0.007396018598228693,
-0.36800098419189453,
0.4285273849964142,
0.5951129794120789,
-0.19901606440544128,
-0.22520294785499573,
0.8819084763526917,
0.24727945029735565,
-0.011109679937362671,
0.32237735390663147,
0.3636590838432312,
-0.24376334249973297,
0.380647212266922,
0.5743088722229004,
0.7508527636528015,
-0.07840827852487564,
-0.12143796682357788,
0.4055626094341278,
0.22322776913642883,
-0.027706904336810112,
0.036528874188661575,
0.1882333606481552,
-0.3972979187965393,
-0.9284729361534119,
-0.3844982385635376,
-0.8185453414916992,
0.4043554663658142,
-0.5059090256690979,
0.14415088295936584,
-0.22059287130832672,
-0.47710081934928894,
0.0410580039024353,
-0.05588801950216293,
-0.6797255277633667,
0.2245120257139206,
0.30005690455436707,
0.9526597261428833,
-0.6643045544624329,
0.8053607940673828,
0.9555460214614868,
-0.6287095546722412,
-0.7603492736816406,
0.23255160450935364,
-0.013871069066226482,
-1.1241798400878906,
0.7629470825195312,
-0.18684029579162598,
0.11138114333152771,
-0.28020915389060974,
-0.5047447681427002,
-0.9783123135566711,
1.0812679529190063,
0.6929827928543091,
-0.5168790817260742,
-0.13839438557624817,
0.008184951730072498,
0.7993767857551575,
-0.4363010823726654,
0.6242229342460632,
0.22925707697868347,
0.35510754585266113,
0.367956280708313,
-1.1791611909866333,
0.2830823063850403,
-0.20882026851177216,
-0.09796767681837082,
-0.2514883875846863,
-0.3117328882217407,
0.5445510745048523,
-0.47365620732307434,
0.0381421260535717,
0.00640862388536334,
0.2521953880786896,
0.6071496605873108,
0.28787314891815186,
0.2531569004058838,
0.5716004371643066,
0.7838277220726013,
-0.08700675517320633,
1.3331223726272583,
-0.5542474389076233,
0.39767780900001526,
0.953408420085907,
-0.4705090820789337,
0.8571715950965881,
0.6808406114578247,
-0.3130476176738739,
0.4952411353588104,
0.6982376575469971,
-0.13428093492984772,
0.39280131459236145,
0.18469277024269104,
-0.13165660202503204,
-0.19705383479595184,
-0.1365012377500534,
-0.5720764994621277,
-0.02649439126253128,
0.17539672553539276,
-1.028192162513733,
-0.20768961310386658,
-0.284267395734787,
0.26877620816230774,
-0.21064884960651398,
-0.12098954617977142,
0.8504757285118103,
0.3111836612224579,
-0.7860003709793091,
0.5713087320327759,
-0.4127804934978485,
0.05703394114971161,
-0.6126248240470886,
-0.2317405790090561,
-0.17683404684066772,
-0.07206759601831436,
-0.4101596176624298,
-0.9267654418945312,
0.1887827217578888,
0.2981830835342407,
0.04087909311056137,
-0.027008067816495895,
0.7748895883560181,
-0.29898399114608765,
-0.3427715003490448,
0.017382508143782616,
0.8212147951126099,
0.3006742000579834,
0.118659108877182,
-0.4881663918495178,
0.006326813250780106,
-0.07666251063346863,
-0.38254109025001526,
0.563197672367096,
0.31869763135910034,
0.16954299807548523,
0.5727555751800537,
0.7055362462997437,
0.7083728313446045,
-0.11339037120342255,
0.1251233071088791,
0.8778181076049805,
-0.6363446116447449,
0.05807783454656601,
-1.041691541671753,
0.4217120110988617,
-0.27069538831710815,
-0.10573597252368927,
0.8082683682441711,
0.48147067427635193,
0.6402002573013306,
0.1547694206237793,
0.9410107135772705,
0.22305619716644287,
0.6215026378631592,
-0.6092561483383179,
0.6453299522399902,
-0.45365601778030396,
0.4946906864643097,
-0.1739896535873413,
-0.8818939328193665,
-0.5080853700637817,
0.6297469735145569,
-0.4392438232898712,
0.3269001543521881,
0.8527704477310181,
0.330628901720047,
0.1829826980829239,
-0.1923835426568985,
0.3044121265411377,
0.5071353912353516,
0.5697250366210938,
0.4063360393047333,
0.7635319828987122,
-0.09870777279138565,
0.42551136016845703,
0.02114183083176613,
-0.08383782207965851,
-0.15877699851989746,
-1.1758934259414673,
-0.661099374294281,
-0.21219100058078766,
-0.3849732279777527,
-0.7034557461738586,
0.0702824667096138,
1.0011494159698486,
0.4802693724632263,
-0.6864191293716431,
0.14808689057826996,
0.2488061636686325,
-0.13874390721321106,
-0.030680857598781586,
-0.1335536539554596,
0.4814210534095764,
-0.3594375550746918,
-0.5732249021530151,
0.2655812203884125,
0.36517849564552307,
-0.1739237755537033,
-0.44809556007385254,
0.043279003351926804,
-0.03472309932112694,
-0.08527226001024246,
0.5010870695114136,
0.12540574371814728,
-0.8669194579124451,
-0.4580972492694855,
-0.05249570310115814,
-0.4953782558441162,
0.16429221630096436,
0.8669591546058655,
-0.8478290438652039,
0.5079115629196167,
0.19247300922870636,
1.0132603645324707,
0.2742294371128082,
0.19679583609104156,
0.5001123547554016,
-0.4252527058124542,
-0.5621100068092346,
0.41024473309516907,
0.6422372460365295,
0.41554856300354004,
-0.30946084856987,
0.9030465483665466,
0.4800465703010559,
-0.9163106083869934,
-0.8604210615158081,
-0.060857053846120834,
-0.9548258781433105,
0.12097962945699692,
1.4782776832580566,
-0.3092752993106842,
0.07122746855020523,
-0.26542040705680847,
-0.19493094086647034,
0.07847538590431213,
-0.010520159266889095,
0.5876827836036682,
0.8468309640884399,
-0.5074968338012695,
-0.05413781479001045,
-1.04596745967865,
0.37237218022346497,
0.30893972516059875,
-0.6051795482635498,
-0.03822549805045128,
0.6239187121391296,
0.7754606604576111,
0.34676453471183777,
0.9814671874046326,
-0.4585224390029907,
0.23621588945388794,
-0.37213334441185,
-0.2799455225467682,
-0.18391525745391846,
0.1496385782957077,
-0.35820573568344116,
0.10243506729602814,
0.5018037557601929,
-0.02760949544608593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01981v1 | Self-Debiasing Large Language Models: Zero-Shot Recognition and Reduction of Stereotypes | 2024-02-03T01:40:11 | 2024-02-03T01:40:11 | Isabel O. Gallegos, Ryan A. Rossi, Joe Barrow, Md Mehrab Tanjim, Tong Yu, Hanieh Deilamsalehy, Ruiyi Zhang, Sungchul Kim, Franck Dernoncourt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable advances in language
generation and understanding but are also prone to exhibiting harmful social
biases. While recognition of these behaviors has generated an abundance of bias
mitigation techniques, most require modifications to the training data, model
parameters, or decoding strategy, which may be infeasible without access to a
trainable model. In this work, we leverage the zero-shot capabilities of LLMs
to reduce stereotyping in a technique we introduce as zero-shot self-debiasing.
With two approaches, self-debiasing via explanation and self-debiasing via
reprompting, we show that self-debiasing can significantly reduce the degree of
stereotyping across nine different social groups while relying only on the LLM
itself and a simple prompt, with explanations correctly identifying invalid
assumptions and reprompting delivering the greatest reductions in bias. We hope
this work opens inquiry into other zero-shot techniques for bias mitigation. | [
-0.46615326404571533,
-0.6394656300544739,
0.5691916346549988,
0.08936405181884766,
-0.17087703943252563,
-0.04347620904445648,
-0.20378808677196503,
-0.28324416279792786,
0.3742060363292694,
0.7130933403968811,
-0.4111647605895996,
-0.5537653565406799,
-0.5147294998168945,
0.2022150158882141,
-0.3330933153629303,
0.8360583186149597,
0.03146621957421303,
0.2500322163105011,
-0.017995886504650116,
-0.17724640667438507,
-0.28737375140190125,
-0.7451356053352356,
-0.5635321140289307,
-0.46750110387802124,
0.609992265701294,
0.4909801781177521,
0.3335016965866089,
0.6281154751777649,
0.1559261828660965,
0.14298862218856812,
-0.008028482086956501,
-0.39771175384521484,
-0.7999755144119263,
0.4895414113998413,
-0.2248426079750061,
-0.4162501096725464,
-0.10440974682569504,
0.16505788266658783,
0.7543129324913025,
0.6563279032707214,
0.3253512382507324,
0.41056710481643677,
0.004248604644089937,
0.7166615128517151,
-0.9236956238746643,
0.20399928092956543,
-0.6207681894302368,
0.15979261696338654,
-0.1080237403512001,
-0.0536813847720623,
-0.36296916007995605,
-0.09914665669202805,
-0.3199672996997833,
-0.10965245962142944,
0.4243440330028534,
-0.31177401542663574,
0.46126845479011536,
0.25802740454673767,
-0.31693848967552185,
0.24594302475452423,
-1.0496376752853394,
0.9825513958930969,
-0.7530539035797119,
0.16145893931388855,
0.4744300842285156,
0.1056918129324913,
0.19853879511356354,
0.07727304100990295,
-0.4022412598133087,
-0.044560033828020096,
0.10109331458806992,
-0.11441700905561447,
-0.2045057713985443,
0.19477981328964233,
0.382617324590683,
0.1084115207195282,
-0.4314994513988495,
0.2561545968055725,
-0.5702506303787231,
-0.45272672176361084,
0.6805466413497925,
-0.07101158052682877,
0.0696747675538063,
-0.3337973952293396,
-0.10003635287284851,
-0.03644989803433418,
-0.941330075263977,
-0.4229912757873535,
0.42090222239494324,
0.1836799532175064,
0.014781445264816284,
0.5741375684738159,
-0.40806424617767334,
0.3855040371417999,
0.2231340855360031,
-0.14776180684566498,
0.2197527289390564,
0.07667618989944458,
-0.368730366230011,
0.2724296450614929,
0.6305725574493408,
0.6873287558555603,
0.534414529800415,
-0.07798126339912415,
-0.05240986496210098,
0.18721939623355865,
-0.17881375551223755,
-0.8714774250984192,
0.024840958416461945,
0.12984301149845123,
-0.5063458681106567,
-0.5990419983863831,
-0.4675651788711548,
-0.7825119495391846,
-0.5148464441299438,
-0.06788472831249237,
0.14083318412303925,
-0.2278456836938858,
-0.06813490390777588,
0.06057881936430931,
-0.2586612403392792,
0.531312108039856,
0.2670215964317322,
-0.8700456619262695,
0.06173829734325409,
0.3888753354549408,
0.894623339176178,
0.30611199140548706,
-0.039565909653902054,
-0.3413631319999695,
0.5203213095664978,
-0.5383269786834717,
0.5675581097602844,
-0.4511464834213257,
-0.3876864016056061,
-0.1459544599056244,
-0.3445434868335724,
0.2903777062892914,
-0.36480721831321716,
0.15410304069519043,
-0.2940588891506195,
0.12026841938495636,
-0.3014070987701416,
-0.5750385522842407,
-0.28220438957214355,
0.4459463953971863,
-0.4537447392940521,
0.6558173894882202,
-0.0575808621942997,
-0.6497359275817871,
0.33959901332855225,
-0.23010455071926117,
-0.39477455615997314,
-0.2700068950653076,
-0.2385246902704239,
-0.3467404842376709,
0.39714479446411133,
0.53226238489151,
0.421603798866272,
-0.11114649474620819,
0.009203137829899788,
-0.9758160710334778,
-0.2551385760307312,
-0.2361084520816803,
-0.5154992341995239,
0.8274381756782532,
0.4623934030532837,
-0.4109780192375183,
-0.13274677097797394,
-0.6867420673370361,
-0.26864179968833923,
0.3867030739784241,
0.1810142993927002,
-0.6548530459403992,
-0.3846529424190521,
-0.3770870268344879,
0.2820952236652374,
0.17344124615192413,
-0.7403039932250977,
0.25106173753738403,
-0.4265616834163666,
0.2892540395259857,
0.8210665583610535,
0.014076240360736847,
0.7418842911720276,
-0.11595775932073593,
0.5951135754585266,
-0.06866089254617691,
0.20939292013645172,
-0.15798214077949524,
-0.05104923993349075,
-0.8102593421936035,
-0.5485732555389404,
0.09354738891124725,
0.4295857846736908,
-0.6281015276908875,
0.30930840969085693,
0.08902668207883835,
-0.32114478945732117,
-0.6087840795516968,
0.30981937050819397,
0.5490462779998779,
0.4879188537597656,
0.2602926790714264,
-0.3537449240684509,
-0.6855730414390564,
-1.1126084327697754,
-0.45800504088401794,
-0.19233205914497375,
-0.22716334462165833,
-0.041365571320056915,
0.29741036891937256,
-0.057004664093256,
0.9093911051750183,
-0.4802422523498535,
-0.37346595525741577,
-0.39386263489723206,
0.18319062888622284,
0.019896438345313072,
0.29315170645713806,
0.8742899894714355,
-0.07676217705011368,
-0.37962302565574646,
-0.5944441556930542,
-0.8375474214553833,
-0.4903518259525299,
-0.09422437101602554,
0.17089839279651642,
0.4226424992084503,
0.7888815999031067,
-0.4912484586238861,
0.6307389736175537,
0.4125766158103943,
-0.12345125526189804,
0.5396924018859863,
-0.044215258210897446,
-0.009218056686222553,
-0.7824790477752686,
-0.3218049705028534,
0.17151102423667908,
-0.3957218527793884,
-0.661923885345459,
0.05806350335478783,
-0.12723514437675476,
-0.014855473302304745,
-0.22796794772148132,
0.7802672982215881,
-0.8259373307228088,
-0.028460493311285973,
-0.37518084049224854,
0.11699815094470978,
0.15070627629756927,
0.16089516878128052,
0.08415059000253677,
0.32038459181785583,
0.7869214415550232,
-0.38342320919036865,
0.1510247439146042,
0.135166198015213,
-0.18965458869934082,
0.41665083169937134,
-0.6467530727386475,
0.17523179948329926,
-0.6806076169013977,
0.4565637409687042,
-1.173231840133667,
0.05745915323495865,
0.5859726667404175,
-0.3011487126350403,
0.26908597350120544,
-0.4873778820037842,
-0.26536309719085693,
-0.288745254278183,
-0.7820272445678711,
0.6064571142196655,
0.5581817030906677,
-0.5904394388198853,
0.208257257938385,
0.27224066853523254,
-0.04885370656847954,
-0.6843034029006958,
-0.8295161128044128,
0.17870110273361206,
-0.2832045257091522,
-0.26913490891456604,
0.1156340017914772,
0.008879592642188072,
-0.428155779838562,
-0.28051459789276123,
-0.1627105325460434,
0.10308971256017685,
-0.06539864093065262,
0.08226491510868073,
0.3151167929172516,
0.1165463924407959,
0.3761430084705353,
-0.01621473766863346,
-0.2949674427509308,
0.07904865592718124,
-0.15958841145038605,
0.6787478923797607,
0.2273816615343094,
-0.3042144179344177,
-0.26349586248397827,
0.2313678115606308,
0.5135133862495422,
-0.08567407727241516,
0.9356839060783386,
0.5208007097244263,
-0.13951309025287628,
-0.2503977417945862,
-0.9301021099090576,
-0.46564239263534546,
-0.39808204770088196,
0.18258516490459442,
-0.2583143413066864,
-1.02688729763031,
0.4750892221927643,
0.3034176826477051,
-0.10484664142131805,
0.26717522740364075,
0.6990634799003601,
0.08019773662090302,
0.8484766483306885,
0.5111697912216187,
-0.6759921312332153,
0.4606035351753235,
-0.09286921471357346,
0.5314329266548157,
-0.6661091446876526,
0.24724987149238586,
-0.5690564513206482,
-0.22589750587940216,
-0.5000126361846924,
-0.5541320443153381,
0.1910356879234314,
-0.04360063374042511,
-0.37403279542922974,
0.02559782564640045,
-0.5220556259155273,
0.6470595598220825,
0.5175504088401794,
0.11940306425094604,
0.31554052233695984,
0.18311356008052826,
0.08493475615978241,
-0.030377794057130814,
-0.5719679594039917,
-0.41546499729156494,
1.2649452686309814,
0.5356079339981079,
1.1235647201538086,
-0.21304558217525482,
1.1505645513534546,
0.24160319566726685,
0.3154447078704834,
-0.7625080347061157,
0.6492800116539001,
-0.02541057951748371,
-1.0218499898910522,
-0.5733327865600586,
-0.6324489712715149,
-0.47173774242401123,
0.2906617522239685,
-0.14850077033042908,
-0.6146247982978821,
0.17790420353412628,
0.373992383480072,
-0.25354886054992676,
0.43277278542518616,
-0.5035138726234436,
0.5916363000869751,
-0.07440544664859772,
-0.2816048562526703,
-0.3511580526828766,
-0.4513382315635681,
0.6410712003707886,
-0.002978971693664789,
0.49835360050201416,
-0.4741884171962738,
0.3270381689071655,
0.44405901432037354,
-0.24681401252746582,
1.2852085828781128,
-0.35947129130363464,
-0.24784977734088898,
0.24178388714790344,
0.4893839955329895,
0.2618257701396942,
-0.07976016402244568,
-0.169169619679451,
0.4446563720703125,
0.05606328323483467,
-0.47129642963409424,
-0.632232666015625,
0.6951465606689453,
-0.6709023714065552,
-0.7687504887580872,
-0.3004389703273773,
-0.6153261065483093,
-0.02654488943517208,
0.048593565821647644,
0.07470524311065674,
0.326847106218338,
-0.3947455883026123,
0.07148953527212143,
0.4297384023666382,
-0.4266941547393799,
0.3707856237888336,
0.4937293529510498,
-0.513404130935669,
-0.394065797328949,
0.5200764536857605,
0.2494473159313202,
0.47105759382247925,
0.14325623214244843,
0.2607195973396301,
-0.38811248540878296,
-0.47336581349372864,
-0.05405009165406227,
0.5745888352394104,
-0.7738463878631592,
-0.1640687882900238,
-0.4142017066478729,
-0.05359133332967758,
-1.1068412065505981,
-0.17115534842014313,
-0.3941511809825897,
-0.7148239612579346,
-0.06189177930355072,
-0.27589118480682373,
0.24101299047470093,
0.5410033464431763,
-0.5490877032279968,
0.30468839406967163,
-0.6014614701271057,
0.5358039140701294,
0.3159867227077484,
0.26494100689888,
-0.07622341811656952,
-0.7543193101882935,
0.061720989644527435,
-0.03058318793773651,
-0.019071215763688087,
-1.0448431968688965,
0.6747055649757385,
-0.004207641817629337,
0.4292168617248535,
0.5501950979232788,
0.3026524484157562,
0.5908575654029846,
-0.5507397651672363,
0.5743641257286072,
0.45364171266555786,
-1.1388978958129883,
0.5308678150177002,
-0.22885748744010925,
0.23974822461605072,
0.49235376715660095,
0.3543630838394165,
-0.6342076063156128,
-0.5607744455337524,
-0.47473108768463135,
-0.6353923082351685,
0.5047844648361206,
0.13038134574890137,
0.3151583671569824,
-0.27770185470581055,
0.5969533920288086,
-0.07017392665147781,
0.14493747055530548,
-0.9446250796318054,
-0.34437352418899536,
-0.3037489056587219,
-0.09168176352977753,
-0.29869726300239563,
-0.6828317046165466,
-0.37035733461380005,
-0.42114487290382385,
0.7755382657051086,
-0.07167810946702957,
-0.03805609792470932,
0.38388919830322266,
-0.2943218946456909,
-0.05417610704898834,
0.5228855013847351,
0.3917948603630066,
0.2516559660434723,
-0.375741571187973,
0.3402251601219177,
0.1992407739162445,
-0.07840625941753387,
0.3707979619503021,
-0.25175678730010986,
-0.673565685749054,
0.08192168921232224,
0.16013482213020325,
0.6445414423942566,
-0.07601726055145264,
-0.15485064685344696,
0.41020792722702026,
0.1832326203584671,
-0.23651491105556488,
-0.17621946334838867,
-0.13713906705379486,
-0.12198155373334885,
0.19962617754936218,
-0.05110180377960205,
-0.32050764560699463,
0.14078356325626373,
-0.6614864468574524,
-0.024839986115694046,
0.768848717212677,
-0.48999500274658203,
-0.17272913455963135,
0.45273664593696594,
0.2548064589500427,
0.008031891658902168,
0.31036463379859924,
-0.13509657979011536,
-0.2718982994556427,
0.4909195899963379,
0.6822474002838135,
1.1010839939117432,
-0.5754184126853943,
0.6214938759803772,
0.5556203126907349,
0.5528157949447632,
-0.14244362711906433,
-0.34198129177093506,
-0.11124042421579361,
-1.1941360235214233,
-0.3895927369594574,
-0.5669012069702148,
-0.3572025001049042,
0.3194482922554016,
-0.6672676801681519,
0.1415225863456726,
-0.6333240270614624,
0.006384536158293486,
-0.09676493704319,
-0.36465489864349365,
-0.5264247059822083,
0.00935027189552784,
0.5176827907562256,
0.6348779201507568,
-0.9632789492607117,
0.8277310132980347,
0.28116512298583984,
-0.5975463390350342,
-0.51888507604599,
0.07639951258897781,
0.26339635252952576,
-1.0692435503005981,
0.814043402671814,
0.2155432552099228,
-0.40210142731666565,
-0.13428965210914612,
-0.8481405377388,
-0.6491081714630127,
0.6688964366912842,
0.7550565600395203,
-0.8044367432594299,
0.09589245170354843,
0.22470811009407043,
0.4761064648628235,
-0.3579438626766205,
0.3430386781692505,
0.7211056351661682,
0.5333628058433533,
0.17232701182365417,
-0.7847939729690552,
0.19316108524799347,
0.3684772849082947,
0.1275498867034912,
-0.03154902905225754,
-0.48696863651275635,
0.6640719175338745,
-0.21596434712409973,
-0.10888691991567612,
-0.20757026970386505,
0.24885910749435425,
0.19614221155643463,
0.2072170525789261,
0.6168897747993469,
0.5332459211349487,
0.27464500069618225,
0.3251570761203766,
0.8149132132530212,
-0.3457161486148834,
0.620720386505127,
1.1667476892471313,
-0.7043958902359009,
0.4387480616569519,
0.6363036036491394,
0.10278307646512985,
0.28131020069122314,
0.20060759782791138,
0.09915592521429062,
0.36642104387283325,
0.32731929421424866,
-0.3921085298061371,
-0.6155957579612732,
0.03796207904815674,
-0.17149819433689117,
0.7244203686714172,
0.1421649307012558,
-0.5230485200881958,
-0.7135763764381409,
0.0870228186249733,
0.34327059984207153,
0.0686916634440422,
-0.44495078921318054,
0.6909824013710022,
0.1294681280851364,
-0.32874953746795654,
0.7340900301933289,
-0.1509322077035904,
0.6262566447257996,
-0.4129894971847534,
0.03545667603611946,
-0.4050082564353943,
0.195522278547287,
-0.09164654463529587,
-0.656733512878418,
0.3592819571495056,
-0.011629478074610233,
-0.30549710988998413,
-0.4597606360912323,
1.0682302713394165,
-0.49384748935699463,
-0.5258417129516602,
0.7058184742927551,
0.5795356631278992,
0.3384070098400116,
-0.3580835461616516,
-0.6299776434898376,
0.05102379992604256,
0.16167105734348297,
-0.22246980667114258,
0.3312646746635437,
0.24095366895198822,
0.09385523945093155,
0.6946185231208801,
0.46436798572540283,
0.2778187692165375,
-0.14125244319438934,
0.4815135896205902,
0.798992395401001,
-0.8825600147247314,
-0.11231112480163574,
-1.1601437330245972,
-0.09181712567806244,
-0.17513857781887054,
0.19964802265167236,
1.0066349506378174,
0.347390741109848,
0.9319705367088318,
-0.2723899483680725,
1.0363770723342896,
0.18126113712787628,
0.6271242499351501,
-0.3073025643825531,
0.7855767607688904,
-0.39075967669487,
0.3040091097354889,
-0.4296758770942688,
-0.9586398601531982,
-0.6818197965621948,
0.870742917060852,
-0.6712303757667542,
0.04955996200442314,
0.3213270604610443,
1.0198848247528076,
0.2408345490694046,
-0.4781113266944885,
0.8088065981864929,
0.5887351632118225,
0.38116225600242615,
0.06501983106136322,
0.6547586917877197,
-0.18525391817092896,
0.6344034075737,
-0.34933364391326904,
-0.41260531544685364,
-0.13361456990242004,
-0.9930955767631531,
-1.2318238019943237,
-0.0829719603061676,
-0.19300851225852966,
-0.28962838649749756,
0.26975908875465393,
0.8182175159454346,
0.710856556892395,
-0.7878831028938293,
-0.274545282125473,
0.14583361148834229,
0.3757155239582062,
0.1056857481598854,
-0.20069563388824463,
-0.1522601693868637,
-0.5329727530479431,
-0.5620949864387512,
0.2922823131084442,
0.4966610074043274,
-0.07703118771314621,
-0.6809777617454529,
0.18450142443180084,
0.0459800623357296,
0.34349822998046875,
0.8755617141723633,
0.45509570837020874,
-0.604454755783081,
-0.7105028033256531,
-0.21142655611038208,
0.06755194813013077,
0.16368915140628815,
0.7621391415596008,
-0.8169345855712891,
0.5286072492599487,
0.5332082509994507,
0.1281166970729828,
0.5855282545089722,
-0.006723584141582251,
0.7085875868797302,
-0.7006605267524719,
0.3898845911026001,
0.09519138932228088,
0.3991186022758484,
0.37683525681495667,
-0.25300219655036926,
0.43741071224212646,
0.3276732861995697,
-0.5366347432136536,
-0.7132688164710999,
0.617803692817688,
-0.7649517059326172,
-0.46239423751831055,
1.3471503257751465,
0.08118046075105667,
-0.3516731262207031,
-0.2429399937391281,
-0.30853700637817383,
0.3589724004268646,
-0.3177884817123413,
1.2528510093688965,
0.6187191605567932,
0.04983304440975189,
-0.43292590975761414,
-0.2069254368543625,
0.3204026222229004,
0.5516963601112366,
-0.6870555281639099,
0.3927946090698242,
0.8630955219268799,
0.6969432234764099,
-0.00852128490805626,
0.794780433177948,
-0.21022886037826538,
-0.15583431720733643,
-0.15819433331489563,
0.669727623462677,
0.053455062210559845,
-0.3106893002986908,
-0.6922305822372437,
-0.04326588287949562,
0.06330982595682144,
-0.28050804138183594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01980v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01980v2 | SOCIALITE-LLAMA: An Instruction-Tuned Model for Social Scientific Tasks | 2024-02-03T01:33:16 | 2024-03-14T15:30:41 | Gourab Dey, Adithya V Ganesan, Yash Kumar Lal, Manal Shah, Shreyashee Sinha, Matthew Matero, Salvatore Giorgi, Vivek Kulkarni, H. Andrew Schwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social science NLP tasks, such as emotion or humor detection, are required to
capture the semantics along with the implicit pragmatics from text, often with
limited amounts of training data. Instruction tuning has been shown to improve
the many capabilities of large language models (LLMs) such as commonsense
reasoning, reading comprehension, and computer programming. However, little is
known about the effectiveness of instruction tuning on the social domain where
implicit pragmatic cues are often needed to be captured. We explore the use of
instruction tuning for social science NLP tasks and introduce Socialite-Llama
-- an open-source, instruction-tuned Llama. On a suite of 20 social science
tasks, Socialite-Llama improves upon the performance of Llama as well as
matches or improves upon the performance of a state-of-the-art, multi-task
finetuned model on a majority of them. Further, Socialite-Llama also leads to
improvement on 5 out of 6 related social tasks as compared to Llama, suggesting
instruction tuning can lead to generalized social understanding. All resources
including our code, model and dataset can be found through
bit.ly/socialitellama. | [
0.30172982811927795,
-0.9272048473358154,
0.4693863093852997,
0.5081589221954346,
-0.36311575770378113,
0.35625553131103516,
-0.4984380900859833,
-0.3488216996192932,
0.48776474595069885,
0.17801013588905334,
-0.5452258586883545,
-0.8356425762176514,
-0.8874750137329102,
0.18161527812480927,
-0.411506712436676,
1.1806608438491821,
0.2903462052345276,
-0.1493854969739914,
-0.30969327688217163,
0.27864307165145874,
-0.1115533784031868,
-0.14082632958889008,
-0.8193041682243347,
-0.41793397068977356,
0.7595798373222351,
0.7533302307128906,
0.7081683278083801,
0.7524833083152771,
0.4381273686885834,
0.3589392304420471,
-0.3192111849784851,
0.5567911267280579,
-0.835629403591156,
-0.02605319209396839,
-0.30093148350715637,
-0.5446955561637878,
-0.48528599739074707,
-0.03330717235803604,
0.4818834662437439,
0.4992554187774658,
-0.23949658870697021,
0.735028862953186,
0.09622830897569656,
0.7821895480155945,
-0.6307293772697449,
0.43178606033325195,
-0.8096814751625061,
-0.18878602981567383,
-0.08194797486066818,
-0.4616621732711792,
-0.27652427554130554,
-0.5618976950645447,
-0.07644204795360565,
-0.8430038094520569,
0.3493206202983856,
0.21263784170150757,
0.6443291306495667,
0.5117709636688232,
-0.3644755780696869,
-0.265438973903656,
-0.4047311246395111,
0.8120473027229309,
-0.4053032100200653,
-0.07402639836072922,
0.4976411759853363,
0.01708216406404972,
-0.29250475764274597,
-0.5694260597229004,
-0.5428382754325867,
-0.1236727237701416,
0.23549386858940125,
-0.0018331687897443771,
0.06512796878814697,
0.14002494513988495,
0.19229039549827576,
0.13111524283885956,
-0.2190493792295456,
-0.027734624221920967,
-0.5307609438896179,
0.05368637293577194,
0.938342809677124,
0.11490189284086227,
0.24436213076114655,
-0.19710135459899902,
0.09773558378219604,
0.017610197886824608,
-0.7733402252197266,
-0.0007713906816206872,
0.512835681438446,
0.2060423493385315,
-0.31153351068496704,
0.6274930834770203,
-0.4238550662994385,
0.42784371972084045,
0.1266629844903946,
-0.06376098096370697,
0.0604945532977581,
-0.13928288221359253,
0.0721278116106987,
0.24391813576221466,
0.35617345571517944,
0.5905002951622009,
0.5976709127426147,
-0.29086217284202576,
0.12073568254709244,
0.5805982947349548,
0.2699451446533203,
-0.55094313621521,
-0.23791484534740448,
-0.12383339554071426,
-0.3119053542613983,
-0.6556833982467651,
-0.5767737030982971,
-0.5866075754165649,
-0.3964809477329254,
-0.5247362852096558,
0.2737261950969696,
-0.07873207330703735,
-0.20187993347644806,
0.3716747462749481,
-0.10167639702558517,
0.10357606410980225,
0.3776538372039795,
-1.0664407014846802,
0.20885854959487915,
1.0425703525543213,
1.1054972410202026,
0.026842905208468437,
-0.25869014859199524,
-0.5366184115409851,
0.1906164586544037,
-0.12202002108097076,
0.9196800589561462,
-1.000059962272644,
-0.35852470993995667,
-0.0425434447824955,
0.2152760773897171,
-0.31940755248069763,
-0.1627863645553589,
0.21204784512519836,
-0.3454139530658722,
-0.20999014377593994,
-0.3508129417896271,
-0.4369688630104065,
-0.04656582325696945,
0.020904848352074623,
-0.35030344128608704,
1.1522139310836792,
-0.21576900780200958,
-0.6243176460266113,
0.0043345545418560505,
-0.7526957988739014,
-0.6137819886207581,
0.202690988779068,
0.056060198694467545,
-0.04421783983707428,
0.274797260761261,
0.017320852726697922,
0.6096823215484619,
-0.3886527121067047,
0.36488667130470276,
-0.4737233817577362,
-0.8459413051605225,
-0.004948445595800877,
-0.010035622864961624,
0.6762430667877197,
-0.2046697437763214,
-0.4926055371761322,
0.23667390644550323,
-0.6824402213096619,
-0.1890251338481903,
0.2979562282562256,
-0.2635205090045929,
-0.3952954113483429,
0.43630409240722656,
-0.2601650357246399,
-0.3013492226600647,
0.5158818960189819,
-0.6150381565093994,
0.08366481959819794,
-0.3320082426071167,
0.695565402507782,
1.1540932655334473,
-0.23437054455280304,
0.32413920760154724,
-0.37744998931884766,
0.35377436876296997,
-0.6214179396629333,
0.30976349115371704,
0.2359924018383026,
-0.8661872744560242,
-0.742429792881012,
-0.05593874678015709,
0.10862615704536438,
0.7427443265914917,
-0.6774994134902954,
0.16903257369995117,
-0.09751341491937637,
-0.6571378111839294,
-0.7933197021484375,
0.346952885389328,
0.48639681935310364,
0.2851652204990387,
0.30757567286491394,
0.07831130921840668,
-0.29499468207359314,
-0.6092727780342102,
-0.41377171874046326,
0.02882419526576996,
0.015186430886387825,
0.48610618710517883,
0.5644432902336121,
-0.1316175013780594,
0.3584427535533905,
-0.5300516486167908,
-0.033146437257528305,
0.07683254033327103,
0.21431909501552582,
0.1887596994638443,
0.1450970619916916,
0.16473554074764252,
-0.5418033599853516,
-0.4188291132450104,
0.1397550255060196,
-0.7360020875930786,
-0.26254934072494507,
0.4204234778881073,
-0.22479583323001862,
0.01307738944888115,
0.44258683919906616,
-0.5565957427024841,
0.30832117795944214,
0.6671702861785889,
-0.412651926279068,
0.6393292546272278,
-0.18534329533576965,
0.18779338896274567,
-0.8604406714439392,
-0.14059744775295258,
0.343574196100235,
-0.0698697566986084,
-0.42706769704818726,
0.11876749992370605,
0.10459445416927338,
-0.14257462322711945,
-0.4779025614261627,
0.3986372649669647,
-0.4181833267211914,
0.08733338862657547,
-0.3146432340145111,
0.2782917320728302,
-0.18431860208511353,
0.47517895698547363,
0.0692882165312767,
0.7810294032096863,
0.5955497622489929,
-0.6201707720756531,
0.3330024480819702,
-0.05710843950510025,
-0.3983856439590454,
0.4749775230884552,
-1.0729219913482666,
0.6376047730445862,
-0.3097796142101288,
-0.028705542907118797,
-0.728915810585022,
-0.4201032221317291,
0.11194902658462524,
-0.2663406729698181,
0.1678476631641388,
0.014746543020009995,
-0.5127788186073303,
-0.16444939374923706,
-0.4189146161079407,
0.03149819374084473,
0.42485448718070984,
-0.574374794960022,
0.5572131276130676,
0.4909326434135437,
-0.31041067838668823,
-0.7711233496665955,
0.018745431676506996,
-0.12418893724679947,
-0.19160830974578857,
-0.7362573146820068,
0.5759581327438354,
0.016361594200134277,
-0.17482778429985046,
0.17075537145137787,
-0.16768713295459747,
0.3267700970172882,
0.300839900970459,
0.449673593044281,
0.3025636672973633,
-0.21630695462226868,
0.186449334025383,
0.5837720036506653,
0.12091703712940216,
0.1619572788476944,
0.3511916995048523,
0.41701585054397583,
-0.20797109603881836,
-0.14554114639759064,
-0.3614260256290436,
0.19084575772285461,
0.17553383111953735,
-0.049485936760902405,
0.8151105642318726,
0.42805370688438416,
-0.25471630692481995,
-0.24776116013526917,
-0.5339298248291016,
-0.35701972246170044,
-0.5839711427688599,
0.3178054392337799,
0.09765800088644028,
-1.194649338722229,
0.1909307986497879,
-0.422057569026947,
0.09839648008346558,
0.034758761525154114,
0.28873902559280396,
-0.30790117383003235,
1.099004864692688,
0.7321515083312988,
-0.06017971783876419,
0.67128986120224,
0.04449886828660965,
0.12169703096151352,
-0.8253713250160217,
-0.2342076152563095,
-0.7171577215194702,
-0.45089831948280334,
-0.3510185182094574,
-0.4914965033531189,
0.2843210995197296,
-0.08573778718709946,
-0.37236282229423523,
0.12124686688184738,
-0.914812445640564,
0.9314301013946533,
0.5170301795005798,
0.5759804844856262,
0.16688919067382812,
0.1505594551563263,
0.46348288655281067,
0.20378080010414124,
-0.5950767993927002,
-0.8603404760360718,
1.1797568798065186,
0.08785705268383026,
0.8315383791923523,
-0.10279586166143417,
0.7181496024131775,
0.33892303705215454,
0.36147522926330566,
-0.5245494246482849,
0.8431129455566406,
-0.5683023929595947,
-0.3072988986968994,
-0.2754422426223755,
-0.2641039192676544,
-0.8992764949798584,
0.0028910436667501926,
-0.34287452697753906,
-0.9257526993751526,
-0.021433647722005844,
0.42956024408340454,
-0.17344984412193298,
-0.14492683112621307,
-0.876937210559845,
0.8485363721847534,
-0.2982996106147766,
-0.5648637413978577,
-0.7704338431358337,
-0.5408090949058533,
0.30184462666511536,
0.2409415990114212,
0.20306552946567535,
-0.5531863570213318,
0.05488166585564613,
0.7160018086433411,
0.1888687014579773,
1.4634262323379517,
-0.23191775381565094,
0.016470089554786682,
-0.012560507282614708,
-0.18900242447853088,
0.6295377612113953,
0.1702159196138382,
-0.06465581059455872,
0.3050747215747833,
0.15335169434547424,
-0.3358432948589325,
-0.5675472617149353,
0.8637756705284119,
-0.8717318177223206,
-0.9794665575027466,
-0.1759142428636551,
-0.6328811645507812,
0.12704691290855408,
-0.2915463149547577,
-0.18006815016269684,
-0.052819788455963135,
-0.05348693206906319,
0.3760078549385071,
0.7578867673873901,
-0.2108498066663742,
-0.0391659177839756,
0.5916175842285156,
0.20517031848430634,
0.056430328637361526,
1.1198375225067139,
-0.01043929997831583,
0.18123002350330353,
0.1812230497598648,
0.29170671105384827,
-0.11570903658866882,
-0.1802002340555191,
-0.27136000990867615,
0.5213871598243713,
-0.6796092391014099,
-0.18714813888072968,
-0.610598623752594,
0.0207216814160347,
-0.38532960414886475,
-0.42430928349494934,
-0.08445653319358826,
-0.4213220775127411,
-0.5753594040870667,
-0.00731378048658371,
0.762129008769989,
0.8277749419212341,
-0.007342769764363766,
0.4674443006515503,
-0.4077320694923401,
0.3816608786582947,
0.3925209939479828,
0.1839653104543686,
0.031370729207992554,
-0.5856959819793701,
-0.164441779255867,
0.1624988317489624,
-0.1729726940393448,
-1.0659173727035522,
0.1445072442293167,
0.6448875665664673,
0.4293089210987091,
0.12646836042404175,
-0.04651273787021637,
0.6974056959152222,
-0.6387256383895874,
0.4569607675075531,
-0.12670956552028656,
-1.0226536989212036,
0.8349085450172424,
-0.21853411197662354,
0.15780480206012726,
0.3566350042819977,
0.5602300763130188,
-0.5103950500488281,
-0.4642600119113922,
-0.2637774646282196,
-0.9126866459846497,
0.7420030236244202,
-0.16497063636779785,
0.4241250455379486,
-0.3292187452316284,
0.6731883883476257,
-0.1263968050479889,
0.2557401657104492,
-0.6300827860832214,
-0.034628503024578094,
-0.3180968761444092,
-0.49580806493759155,
-0.15255072712898254,
-0.3410257399082184,
-0.2658841609954834,
-0.3533567488193512,
0.7665913701057434,
-0.3260781168937683,
0.08670501410961151,
-0.12279566377401352,
-0.22681856155395508,
-0.3008287250995636,
0.16319310665130615,
0.4638078808784485,
0.37965503334999084,
-0.15465109050273895,
0.09655451774597168,
0.18966107070446014,
-0.6144193410873413,
0.03464546799659729,
0.0774533823132515,
-0.1233939528465271,
-0.37646371126174927,
0.19508926570415497,
0.7319782376289368,
0.7853825688362122,
-0.5878034830093384,
0.2930668890476227,
-0.0425407811999321,
-0.07369132339954376,
-0.0191308856010437,
0.6261849999427795,
0.525537371635437,
0.5362570881843567,
0.27875182032585144,
-0.33219072222709656,
0.1650846302509308,
-0.4939439594745636,
-0.34688395261764526,
0.513213574886322,
0.025405464693903923,
-0.36444780230522156,
0.6386589407920837,
0.33822718262672424,
-0.6998166441917419,
0.3736523985862732,
-0.30139267444610596,
-0.3428165912628174,
1.0063364505767822,
0.8586074113845825,
0.4896792769432068,
-0.27790507674217224,
0.647400438785553,
0.23878128826618195,
0.4822922646999359,
-0.14859190583229065,
0.5618993639945984,
-0.3294055759906769,
-0.6660657525062561,
-0.8718106746673584,
-0.8388575315475464,
-0.6641391515731812,
-0.204091414809227,
-0.6356974244117737,
0.1515972763299942,
-0.393085241317749,
-0.06152733787894249,
0.16852369904518127,
-0.10623383522033691,
-0.5928434729576111,
-0.13439209759235382,
-0.11211443692445755,
0.769371747970581,
-1.0367435216903687,
0.73923659324646,
0.8997466564178467,
0.21061964333057404,
-0.8288004994392395,
-0.4396452307701111,
0.05892861261963844,
-1.0411783456802368,
0.8639227151870728,
0.2863788306713104,
-0.6655988097190857,
0.22757388651371002,
-0.9498580098152161,
-0.937451958656311,
1.099123239517212,
0.5718822479248047,
-0.8369234800338745,
-0.18220646679401398,
-0.1358257234096527,
0.6469022035598755,
-0.25408896803855896,
-0.06252358853816986,
0.5810158252716064,
0.2719816565513611,
-0.03243955969810486,
-0.7147701978683472,
0.13836205005645752,
-0.5808447599411011,
-0.0744490996003151,
0.007577102165669203,
-0.8282809853553772,
0.5153647065162659,
-0.30065518617630005,
-0.3144579231739044,
-0.1485995501279831,
0.6460868716239929,
0.6127374172210693,
0.6603439450263977,
0.4587337076663971,
0.1464957892894745,
0.8934048414230347,
-0.04362911358475685,
0.9321657419204712,
-0.5083317160606384,
0.10247696936130524,
0.878768265247345,
-0.5785890817642212,
0.7726421356201172,
0.2820168435573578,
-0.11459506303071976,
0.532070517539978,
0.7530630230903625,
0.2347574383020401,
0.451071172952652,
0.15804412961006165,
-0.44671154022216797,
-0.29058998823165894,
-0.3954605162143707,
-0.3034960627555847,
0.33909881114959717,
0.7913219332695007,
-0.127766951918602,
0.2405613213777542,
-0.24170464277267456,
0.0068113780580461025,
0.23713049292564392,
-0.6416441202163696,
0.605303168296814,
0.18725767731666565,
-0.45885181427001953,
0.3909057676792145,
-0.23551911115646362,
0.9841788411140442,
-0.4815484583377838,
-0.30577635765075684,
-0.13998156785964966,
-0.13957783579826355,
-0.364271879196167,
-0.5161730051040649,
0.16621707379817963,
0.22091440856456757,
-0.1293715238571167,
0.0846766009926796,
1.058718204498291,
-0.3124741315841675,
-0.549862802028656,
0.4407590627670288,
-0.05954689905047417,
0.3485049307346344,
0.00041451590368524194,
-0.7219818830490112,
0.047943148761987686,
-0.20724396407604218,
-0.21049396693706512,
0.2994183301925659,
0.5201217532157898,
-0.02967892959713936,
0.6945603489875793,
0.8409609198570251,
0.26164510846138,
0.16947175562381744,
0.20851072669029236,
0.8971500396728516,
-0.45620009303092957,
-0.19957885146141052,
-0.7547852993011475,
0.18137788772583008,
-0.30377307534217834,
-0.3212152123451233,
0.6759786009788513,
0.051027812063694,
0.6949092149734497,
-0.040681589394807816,
0.36535024642944336,
0.10158003121614456,
0.3588252067565918,
-0.4521903693675995,
0.5188457369804382,
-0.5978031158447266,
-0.022382518276572227,
-0.32285913825035095,
-0.9343423247337341,
-0.1758832186460495,
0.923324704170227,
-0.5734915733337402,
-0.22487913072109222,
0.5331109762191772,
1.0776268243789673,
0.04852193221449852,
0.34649917483329773,
0.07679188251495361,
-0.0888047069311142,
-0.22729791700839996,
0.3433980941772461,
0.9170308709144592,
0.1585763692855835,
0.3263283669948578,
-0.33262261748313904,
-0.4133951663970947,
-0.2670793831348419,
-0.9828755855560303,
-1.1480207443237305,
-0.1268371343612671,
-0.40358448028564453,
-0.15494120121002197,
0.690982460975647,
0.9910415410995483,
0.5521879196166992,
-0.46474552154541016,
-0.23081044852733612,
0.17575480043888092,
0.4222533106803894,
-0.3565922677516937,
-0.23446932435035706,
0.3326209485530853,
-0.4875314235687256,
-0.688273549079895,
0.5781933069229126,
0.5082064270973206,
-0.4395618140697479,
0.05099131539463997,
0.02848898246884346,
-0.29456084966659546,
0.257367342710495,
0.795721709728241,
0.19373448193073273,
-0.5436691641807556,
-0.512866199016571,
0.35247236490249634,
0.13804885745048523,
-0.345037043094635,
0.47460731863975525,
-0.22009523212909698,
0.10667684674263,
0.10689622908830643,
0.503872811794281,
0.6742429733276367,
-0.1442573070526123,
0.3219796121120453,
-0.7575355172157288,
0.11238570511341095,
-0.02960519678890705,
0.2965097427368164,
0.310385137796402,
-0.8112059831619263,
0.7025917768478394,
0.17213737964630127,
-0.9934225082397461,
-0.9338110089302063,
0.04926132783293724,
-0.805642306804657,
-0.18209025263786316,
1.1794381141662598,
-0.003510317299515009,
-0.7557791471481323,
-0.07173888385295868,
-0.2138873189687729,
0.5532611608505249,
-0.5610457062721252,
1.4032446146011353,
0.5421409010887146,
0.13084687292575836,
-0.1766737550497055,
-0.5497594475746155,
0.3096921145915985,
0.6627280116081238,
-0.8764292597770691,
-0.08600018173456192,
0.41648605465888977,
0.2169278860092163,
0.11063159257173538,
0.6161559224128723,
0.27531158924102783,
0.5866551399230957,
-0.1923619955778122,
0.1523371785879135,
-0.02284274995326996,
-0.45884230732917786,
0.022978534922003746,
0.0404292456805706,
-0.005523379892110825,
-0.05651964247226715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01976v1 | MasonPerplexity at ClimateActivism 2024: Integrating Advanced Ensemble Techniques and Data Augmentation for Climate Activism Stance and Hate Event Identification | 2024-02-03T01:06:33 | 2024-02-03T01:06:33 | Al Nahian Bin Emran, Amrita Ganguly, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Dhiman Goswami, Md Nishat Raihan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of identifying public opinions on social media, particularly
regarding climate activism and the detection of hate events, has emerged as a
critical area of research in our rapidly changing world. With a growing number
of people voicing either to support or oppose to climate-related issues -
understanding these diverse viewpoints has become increasingly vital. Our team,
MasonPerplexity, participates in a significant research initiative focused on
this subject. We extensively test various models and methods, discovering that
our most effective results are achieved through ensemble modeling, enhanced by
data augmentation techniques like back-translation. In the specific components
of this research task, our team achieved notable positions, ranking 5th, 1st,
and 6th in the respective sub-tasks, thereby illustrating the effectiveness of
our approach in this important field of study. | [
-0.77092045545578,
-0.6144811511039734,
0.49398913979530334,
-0.012478760443627834,
-0.24245913326740265,
0.6080868244171143,
-0.09049751609563828,
-0.6230171918869019,
0.37765660881996155,
0.08262237906455994,
-0.45697352290153503,
-0.4763404130935669,
-0.9216101765632629,
-0.08385873585939407,
-0.6852236390113831,
1.0725476741790771,
0.020774120464920998,
0.17762264609336853,
-0.17913523316383362,
-0.22248420119285583,
-0.13646669685840607,
-0.3713245689868927,
-0.571117639541626,
-0.2628684937953949,
0.6241456866264343,
0.2721366584300995,
0.8368274569511414,
0.36391395330429077,
0.2550443112850189,
0.3522745370864868,
-0.13257178664207458,
-0.1894274353981018,
-0.6529322862625122,
-0.19465507566928864,
-0.36304986476898193,
0.025212345644831657,
-0.12661254405975342,
0.5168789029121399,
0.6306334137916565,
0.3769594728946686,
0.1245708167552948,
0.4305483400821686,
-0.022176135331392288,
0.14706926047801971,
-0.8444651961326599,
0.02723308838903904,
-0.6716822981834412,
0.02736072987318039,
0.06333986669778824,
-0.18219783902168274,
-0.05919977277517319,
-0.4370574653148651,
-0.07847849279642105,
-0.7419232726097107,
0.7116963267326355,
0.3149142265319824,
0.41663119196891785,
0.22066128253936768,
-0.4725026786327362,
-0.2271864116191864,
-0.7385637164115906,
0.9097485542297363,
-0.32009878754615784,
0.35283902287483215,
0.03554821386933327,
0.13090744614601135,
-0.20702579617500305,
-0.5587952733039856,
-1.0078558921813965,
0.5106025338172913,
-0.013585296459496021,
0.40799152851104736,
-0.33049026131629944,
-0.17060206830501556,
-0.0739554837346077,
0.37125417590141296,
-0.5135019421577454,
0.2052992433309555,
-0.418962299823761,
-0.15717898309230804,
1.09567391872406,
0.16582868993282318,
0.1328577995300293,
-0.16549919545650482,
-0.5364788174629211,
-0.1712673157453537,
-0.3264605700969696,
0.07239678502082825,
0.8871626257896423,
0.16459307074546814,
-0.22502106428146362,
0.4689778685569763,
-0.2228022813796997,
0.31019920110702515,
0.2637839913368225,
0.32608282566070557,
0.09950356930494308,
-0.2270996868610382,
-0.3529948890209198,
0.2949550151824951,
0.7162567377090454,
0.306363046169281,
-0.3241538107395172,
-0.11709212511777878,
-0.1548708975315094,
0.16564445197582245,
0.21387970447540283,
-0.6908929944038391,
-0.47041887044906616,
0.4461100697517395,
-0.49758926033973694,
-0.7227895259857178,
0.37000134587287903,
-1.192474126815796,
-0.9965972900390625,
-0.5559344291687012,
0.2686547636985779,
0.04779758304357529,
-0.714873731136322,
-0.21392664313316345,
-0.6997951865196228,
0.22054500877857208,
0.6824781894683838,
-0.6008124947547913,
0.2878371477127075,
1.0557608604431152,
0.8142675161361694,
-0.584874153137207,
-0.19142583012580872,
-0.16422520577907562,
-0.07878574728965759,
-0.2950951159000397,
1.013136863708496,
-1.0713468790054321,
-0.5967501997947693,
-0.3100180923938751,
-0.012048827484250069,
-0.20366914570331573,
-0.2898891866207123,
0.37869980931282043,
-0.6220374703407288,
0.2815764248371124,
0.07789845764636993,
-0.5866585373878479,
-0.3877090513706207,
0.2821028232574463,
-0.6082561612129211,
1.0031607151031494,
-0.2199854552745819,
-0.8001304268836975,
0.44306930899620056,
-0.7360340356826782,
-0.006183633115142584,
0.22618357837200165,
-0.11384668946266174,
-0.4813808500766754,
0.22682799398899078,
-0.1066952645778656,
0.6028385162353516,
-0.18996405601501465,
0.2703889012336731,
-0.6158148646354675,
-0.027186697348952293,
0.15370811522006989,
-0.40750399231910706,
0.7535703182220459,
0.25572720170021057,
-0.5042440891265869,
0.5692698359489441,
-0.8273881673812866,
-0.3642403483390808,
0.06413593143224716,
-0.10217975080013275,
-0.2677902281284332,
0.02178846299648285,
0.38263338804244995,
0.1851150244474411,
0.06735426187515259,
-0.744272768497467,
0.17774668335914612,
0.16008113324642181,
0.3217606246471405,
1.086450219154358,
0.27326786518096924,
0.5939761996269226,
-0.3856482207775116,
0.6533073782920837,
0.007452982012182474,
0.3539251983165741,
0.4275960624217987,
-0.7977668642997742,
-0.34001854062080383,
-0.16558274626731873,
-0.23536431789398193,
0.5214172601699829,
-0.5380897521972656,
0.08371339738368988,
-0.23936951160430908,
-0.9388179779052734,
-0.10731218010187149,
-0.05015895888209343,
0.14622105658054352,
0.4205687940120697,
0.5234885811805725,
-0.29543355107307434,
-0.635573148727417,
-0.6286655068397522,
-0.39022091031074524,
-0.421397864818573,
0.2834150195121765,
-0.09857650101184845,
0.7289320230484009,
-0.16061615943908691,
0.8051407337188721,
-0.434977263212204,
0.2430722713470459,
0.08692581206560135,
0.4045553505420685,
0.18892627954483032,
0.6343442797660828,
0.41479504108428955,
-1.530044674873352,
-0.1143195629119873,
0.01952253468334675,
-0.24110594391822815,
0.29404520988464355,
0.03582808002829552,
-0.12427238374948502,
0.21126504242420197,
0.29633060097694397,
-0.3509100377559662,
0.5829264521598816,
0.8077711462974548,
-0.6687006950378418,
0.5348076224327087,
0.5063762068748474,
0.7247162461280823,
-1.099446177482605,
-0.02173248678445816,
0.21596038341522217,
0.07697520405054092,
-0.943955659866333,
0.07678744196891785,
-0.39016929268836975,
-0.1584467887878418,
-0.6394218802452087,
0.495085209608078,
-0.29668524861335754,
0.09283130615949631,
-0.20679394900798798,
-0.204583540558815,
-0.33025068044662476,
0.24558447301387787,
0.39868947863578796,
0.3686298727989197,
0.5227615237236023,
-0.44484779238700867,
0.6191912889480591,
0.26732081174850464,
-0.23196940124034882,
0.4587748646736145,
-0.17674539983272552,
0.26843616366386414,
-0.23745682835578918,
0.4201950132846832,
-1.3272292613983154,
-0.433044970035553,
0.49925723671913147,
-0.6706938743591309,
-0.0014326522359624505,
-0.44698354601860046,
-0.42518922686576843,
-0.35153165459632874,
-0.26904839277267456,
0.5945736765861511,
0.47383296489715576,
-0.6126339435577393,
1.1270729303359985,
0.831147313117981,
0.06370443850755692,
-0.3566911220550537,
-0.41441571712493896,
0.04722675308585167,
-0.6807118654251099,
-0.5645751357078552,
0.3430582284927368,
-0.17162173986434937,
-0.6856459379196167,
-0.2896886467933655,
0.008395383134484291,
-0.09690070897340775,
0.2418835312128067,
0.6314445734024048,
0.09060296416282654,
0.10504130274057388,
0.16638298332691193,
-0.24620415270328522,
0.01798402890563011,
0.17783907055854797,
-0.3312104344367981,
0.46312621235847473,
-0.0756172314286232,
-0.11969421058893204,
-0.3977409601211548,
0.46113520860671997,
0.6736503839492798,
0.1053747683763504,
0.8444250226020813,
0.8425164818763733,
-0.5015301704406738,
0.1589667946100235,
-0.6613698601722717,
-0.1625453382730484,
-0.473022997379303,
-0.12518763542175293,
0.15746667981147766,
-0.9620400667190552,
0.6063072681427002,
-0.11028015613555908,
0.19620279967784882,
0.4678681492805481,
0.6368609070777893,
0.13864871859550476,
1.1241275072097778,
0.25839313864707947,
-0.2187657207250595,
0.4025620222091675,
-0.23559562861919403,
0.16001562774181366,
-0.6457542777061462,
-0.3658088445663452,
-0.6345412135124207,
-0.21992960572242737,
-0.7674458622932434,
-0.44485732913017273,
0.28262805938720703,
-0.16514085233211517,
-0.18542703986167908,
0.3049386739730835,
-0.8062325119972229,
0.15672968327999115,
0.22202801704406738,
-0.04991034418344498,
0.31054922938346863,
-0.33077219128608704,
0.6053565144538879,
0.2247685194015503,
-0.44451168179512024,
-0.4475383460521698,
0.7591225504875183,
0.07498105615377426,
0.1924753338098526,
0.45977944135665894,
0.6803398132324219,
0.5403550863265991,
0.5617181658744812,
-0.8875386714935303,
0.6773693561553955,
0.46149730682373047,
-0.7456899881362915,
-0.42041945457458496,
-0.17364193499088287,
-0.9095797538757324,
0.3904550075531006,
-0.6496560573577881,
-0.5909121632575989,
0.542751669883728,
0.42497512698173523,
-0.08460788428783417,
0.4707227051258087,
-0.5128809809684753,
0.6945547461509705,
0.16503307223320007,
-0.4515518546104431,
-0.5039429068565369,
-0.3659094274044037,
0.3990529775619507,
-0.16260598599910736,
0.7703529000282288,
-0.18765731155872345,
-0.12948951125144958,
0.7743757367134094,
-0.11261351406574249,
0.9822848439216614,
-0.2697831988334656,
-0.07683749496936798,
0.131794735789299,
-0.10130312293767929,
0.720719575881958,
0.15401826798915863,
-0.2576791048049927,
0.15270140767097473,
-0.16065466403961182,
-0.5989057421684265,
-0.4320392906665802,
0.8643537163734436,
-0.7136006951332092,
-0.9063565731048584,
-0.4716159999370575,
-0.27408120036125183,
-0.10648474842309952,
0.04561374709010124,
0.11601772904396057,
0.35237929224967957,
-0.5612925291061401,
-0.07047073543071747,
0.5359922647476196,
0.18927910923957825,
0.7312207818031311,
0.35350295901298523,
-0.03672584518790245,
-0.5958825945854187,
0.9524874687194824,
0.11625233292579651,
0.07621921598911285,
0.12502449750900269,
0.5183013677597046,
-0.10030974447727203,
-1.057486653327942,
-0.27764177322387695,
-0.25084540247917175,
-0.68597412109375,
-0.04271905496716499,
-0.8805602788925171,
0.3715808689594269,
-0.9205222129821777,
-0.3551469147205353,
-0.2886347770690918,
-0.7006440162658691,
-0.3795209228992462,
-0.30470791459083557,
0.5346896648406982,
0.8905498385429382,
-0.0859185978770256,
0.09591621160507202,
-0.5287426114082336,
0.06052128225564957,
0.26112109422683716,
-0.07447439432144165,
-0.20765286684036255,
-0.3204215168952942,
-0.13664671778678894,
-0.24232494831085205,
-0.4944431781768799,
-0.7767567038536072,
0.41164320707321167,
-0.10524331033229828,
0.5783156752586365,
0.4259909987449646,
0.3055364191532135,
0.7469778060913086,
-0.18973693251609802,
1.1223535537719727,
0.3054036796092987,
-1.0989354848861694,
0.5072054266929626,
-0.5613600015640259,
-0.0060532535426318645,
0.4189349114894867,
0.7187948822975159,
-0.23202243447303772,
-0.6311091780662537,
-1.2523828744888306,
-0.8532530665397644,
0.31926003098487854,
0.3593451976776123,
0.15950986742973328,
0.017281487584114075,
-0.020898576825857162,
0.09156312793493271,
0.30559879541397095,
-0.32562142610549927,
-0.052960705012083054,
-0.5684916377067566,
0.009314760565757751,
-0.2746545970439911,
0.18769438564777374,
-0.566089391708374,
-0.3148585259914398,
0.9468072056770325,
-0.387227863073349,
-0.03826496750116348,
0.20960497856140137,
0.3130846917629242,
-0.15438738465309143,
0.17056432366371155,
0.8292142748832703,
0.7876762747764587,
0.10535106807947159,
0.22495262324810028,
0.41220802068710327,
-0.590969979763031,
0.02031041495501995,
0.28464481234550476,
0.09356555342674255,
-0.19210802018642426,
0.5051847696304321,
0.5779877305030823,
0.050566598773002625,
-0.1867855191230774,
0.48186206817626953,
0.04518058896064758,
-0.25711679458618164,
-0.8619662523269653,
0.05084087699651718,
-0.1136985644698143,
0.31764453649520874,
0.7293329834938049,
0.4644083082675934,
0.5760110020637512,
-0.726306140422821,
0.009628193452954292,
0.49456551671028137,
-0.7595016956329346,
-0.5585062503814697,
0.5460853576660156,
0.28748974204063416,
-0.13328365981578827,
0.06464210152626038,
0.18007880449295044,
-0.5812024474143982,
0.791319727897644,
0.10846225917339325,
0.669838547706604,
-0.3978024125099182,
0.19499525427818298,
0.5184643268585205,
0.01388715859502554,
0.02091175504028797,
-0.12485697865486145,
-0.23097074031829834,
-1.0266704559326172,
-0.03510713204741478,
-0.5406255722045898,
-0.492384135723114,
-0.12970711290836334,
-0.8421714305877686,
0.3955954611301422,
-0.631161093711853,
-0.0916166678071022,
0.20252688229084015,
-0.03131284937262535,
-0.439020037651062,
0.3119707405567169,
0.09669451415538788,
0.843086838722229,
-1.1538716554641724,
0.5607722997665405,
0.7293434143066406,
-0.06976184248924255,
-0.6231870055198669,
-0.0471990667283535,
0.7905339002609253,
-0.6481958031654358,
0.37131616473197937,
0.10666283220052719,
-0.3369215726852417,
0.26528406143188477,
-0.9571487307548523,
-0.7156315445899963,
1.3815629482269287,
-0.22908417880535126,
-0.42615124583244324,
0.4564780592918396,
-0.3429034650325775,
0.4614284336566925,
-0.5675089359283447,
0.17798593640327454,
0.6870169043540955,
0.975836992263794,
0.45751795172691345,
-0.5380145907402039,
0.1605413556098938,
-0.3896420896053314,
-0.17900222539901733,
0.483409583568573,
-0.876073956489563,
0.49800556898117065,
0.14838773012161255,
-0.4586418569087982,
-0.2175786793231964,
0.7426158785820007,
0.20413777232170105,
0.7021908164024353,
0.8282473683357239,
0.45030927658081055,
0.7101660966873169,
-0.015324168838560581,
1.244892954826355,
-0.13221579790115356,
0.394863098859787,
0.8267379999160767,
-0.028779983520507812,
0.5823063254356384,
0.795611560344696,
0.04544674977660179,
0.3357146978378296,
0.7310003638267517,
-0.04363809898495674,
0.33471962809562683,
0.2754490077495575,
-0.6647406220436096,
-0.4842718541622162,
-0.38536036014556885,
-0.045983340591192245,
0.40102607011795044,
0.44400545954704285,
-0.2315334975719452,
0.21497943997383118,
0.11094700545072556,
0.18174698948860168,
0.2921667695045471,
-0.5721112489700317,
0.9520830512046814,
-0.19364023208618164,
-0.7067528963088989,
0.18505778908729553,
-0.33805224299430847,
0.6405897736549377,
-0.10725703835487366,
-0.28644803166389465,
0.27814236283302307,
-0.07711591571569443,
-0.6193702816963196,
-0.9454573392868042,
0.510252833366394,
-0.275453120470047,
-0.18554188311100006,
-0.3440321683883667,
0.36307743191719055,
-0.22550225257873535,
-0.48371902108192444,
0.363206684589386,
-0.05962821841239929,
0.24119488894939423,
0.04947156086564064,
-0.6334070563316345,
0.35713547468185425,
-0.1663559079170227,
-0.38198480010032654,
0.1972685307264328,
0.011451825499534607,
-0.20221105217933655,
0.28524237871170044,
0.9204482436180115,
-0.10077199339866638,
0.024527765810489655,
-0.03490813449025154,
0.9951124787330627,
-0.35471972823143005,
-0.1972259283065796,
-0.6957558989524841,
0.5497915148735046,
-0.5160170197486877,
-0.5757197737693787,
0.8777775168418884,
0.8053985238075256,
0.8764517903327942,
0.06406866759061813,
0.8447010517120361,
-0.18470099568367004,
0.3997160792350769,
-0.4713982045650482,
0.43052318692207336,
-0.27550360560417175,
0.044416557997465134,
-0.3776174485683441,
-0.7439477443695068,
-0.4343745708465576,
0.05438907444477081,
-0.5255505442619324,
-0.31195157766342163,
0.3926059305667877,
0.9688113331794739,
-0.04848017543554306,
0.6554425954818726,
0.21614354848861694,
-0.024710724130272865,
0.5795207619667053,
0.12452779710292816,
0.9594143629074097,
-0.2327159345149994,
0.5142971873283386,
-0.15134002268314362,
-0.33736711740493774,
0.01672581024467945,
-0.9674210548400879,
-0.7498401403427124,
-0.8215966820716858,
-0.6089767217636108,
-0.49674442410469055,
-0.056604739278554916,
1.1420605182647705,
0.6309396028518677,
-1.1033635139465332,
0.007399120833724737,
-0.36692869663238525,
0.16853134334087372,
-0.15968751907348633,
-0.2984786927700043,
0.2841934859752655,
0.2330850213766098,
-1.0749086141586304,
0.4298698902130127,
0.1237361878156662,
0.07138428092002869,
-0.31299617886543274,
-0.014447042718529701,
-0.32723525166511536,
0.20232990384101868,
0.38911256194114685,
0.4687809944152832,
-0.6323137879371643,
-0.8243545293807983,
-0.5047776699066162,
0.3761294186115265,
-0.08913390338420868,
1.0198016166687012,
-0.6847281455993652,
0.33175745606422424,
0.7795653343200684,
0.5211758017539978,
0.43866968154907227,
0.2390359342098236,
0.4949936270713806,
-0.27263587713241577,
0.1668124794960022,
0.42250528931617737,
0.2081575095653534,
0.4406367242336273,
-0.6443247199058533,
0.6860781908035278,
0.5823542475700378,
-0.6854441165924072,
-0.7350068092346191,
0.2409997582435608,
-0.9361317753791809,
-0.23657739162445068,
1.177436351776123,
0.07896436005830765,
-0.160519540309906,
-0.5492038130760193,
-0.0232868455350399,
0.06894256919622421,
-0.6805823445320129,
0.8741933107376099,
0.8777136206626892,
-0.43088826537132263,
-0.4383794069290161,
-0.09898635745048523,
0.4059441387653351,
0.019228415563702583,
-0.653128981590271,
-0.21831506490707397,
0.658230185508728,
0.10426250845193863,
0.6701797246932983,
0.336740106344223,
0.06496988981962204,
0.25775212049484253,
-0.26053646206855774,
0.053038351237773895,
0.03462361544370651,
-0.21708975732326508,
-0.3646533191204071,
0.3737594783306122,
-0.3510724902153015,
0.05395803600549698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01967v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01967v2 | MasonPerplexity at Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection 2024: Hate Speech and Target Detection Using Transformer Ensembles | 2024-02-03T00:23:36 | 2024-02-18T06:39:55 | Amrita Ganguly, Al Nahian Bin Emran, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Md Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL | The automatic identification of offensive language such as hate speech is
important to keep discussions civil in online communities. Identifying hate
speech in multimodal content is a particularly challenging task because
offensiveness can be manifested in either words or images or a juxtaposition of
the two. This paper presents the MasonPerplexity submission for the Shared Task
on Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection at CASE 2024 at EACL 2024. The task
is divided into two sub-tasks: sub-task A focuses on the identification of hate
speech and sub-task B focuses on the identification of targets in text-embedded
images during political events. We use an XLM-roBERTa-large model for sub-task
A and an ensemble approach combining XLM-roBERTa-base, BERTweet-large, and
BERT-base for sub-task B. Our approach obtained 0.8347 F1-score in sub-task A
and 0.6741 F1-score in sub-task B ranking 3rd on both sub-tasks. | [
-0.7159796357154846,
-0.8079100847244263,
0.3130732476711273,
0.18181131780147552,
-0.1716127246618271,
0.22722193598747253,
-0.24948126077651978,
-0.7787003517150879,
0.29369640350341797,
0.18195480108261108,
-0.6765285134315491,
-0.3514758050441742,
-1.0630826950073242,
0.09683608263731003,
-0.6814935803413391,
1.171857476234436,
0.12459783256053925,
0.025701049715280533,
-0.14320656657218933,
-0.33834466338157654,
-0.2596614360809326,
-0.6176307201385498,
-0.6558400392532349,
0.011338675394654274,
0.7192989587783813,
0.1860225647687912,
0.44701746106147766,
0.3574775755405426,
0.44667527079582214,
0.36659014225006104,
0.12306453287601471,
-0.048651888966560364,
-0.46103212237358093,
0.3273124694824219,
-0.32135099172592163,
-0.04171501100063324,
-0.26580601930618286,
0.15624791383743286,
0.4940493106842041,
-0.05998418480157852,
0.27624356746673584,
0.1279447227716446,
-0.1066943034529686,
-0.022971736267209053,
-0.7423275113105774,
-0.040218535810709,
-0.779167115688324,
0.1566084921360016,
-0.4558945894241333,
-0.11264253407716751,
-0.39059245586395264,
0.029996078461408615,
-0.05476502329111099,
-0.42316776514053345,
0.3936713933944702,
0.24564394354820251,
0.3340184986591339,
0.07157158106565475,
-0.5293104648590088,
-0.6338635683059692,
-0.643852174282074,
0.912843644618988,
-0.2501087784767151,
0.3985013961791992,
-0.033324237912893295,
0.11802256852388382,
0.11694656312465668,
-0.5751582980155945,
-0.9588011503219604,
-0.10432934761047363,
-0.11494613438844681,
0.13912609219551086,
-0.8252158761024475,
-0.05013090744614601,
0.08852842450141907,
0.15210741758346558,
-0.7263508439064026,
0.26447999477386475,
-0.3601161241531372,
-0.4112069606781006,
0.8251177072525024,
0.2799157500267029,
0.16016723215579987,
-0.21246445178985596,
-0.5916363000869751,
-0.14298850297927856,
-0.09678104519844055,
-0.15457560122013092,
0.6641063690185547,
0.23771794140338898,
-0.047666050493717194,
0.35820621252059937,
-0.02863685041666031,
0.22515875101089478,
0.3252817392349243,
-0.13110622763633728,
0.3434337377548218,
-0.24517619609832764,
0.08178186416625977,
0.10449101030826569,
0.8477871417999268,
0.20562735199928284,
0.15953265130519867,
-0.012537799775600433,
-0.15346091985702515,
0.3386504352092743,
0.4534262716770172,
-0.5168033838272095,
-0.30148380994796753,
0.24559544026851654,
-0.44200482964515686,
-0.33663615584373474,
-0.22221659123897552,
-1.0041488409042358,
-0.7103989124298096,
-0.20811063051223755,
0.4739992022514343,
-0.23079246282577515,
-0.45680150389671326,
-0.4329041540622711,
-0.38845694065093994,
0.028014972805976868,
0.3402651846408844,
-0.7274715900421143,
0.13206589221954346,
0.6268141269683838,
0.4326360821723938,
-0.8226170539855957,
-0.2148861587047577,
-0.4958604574203491,
0.0660237967967987,
0.24386319518089294,
0.8537368178367615,
-0.9737129807472229,
-0.26334601640701294,
-0.10786019265651703,
0.08432476967573166,
-0.20763114094734192,
-0.4780347943305969,
1.0374654531478882,
-0.5367041230201721,
0.2553131878376007,
0.48581504821777344,
-0.40932056307792664,
-0.21539634466171265,
0.4746430814266205,
-0.6434823274612427,
0.8282761573791504,
-0.2501523494720459,
-0.7606335282325745,
0.29353731870651245,
-0.6373966932296753,
-0.25636500120162964,
0.2693949341773987,
-0.28286001086235046,
-0.7042743563652039,
-0.012703221291303635,
0.05150492489337921,
0.49728327989578247,
0.16432656347751617,
0.14071914553642273,
-0.3721054196357727,
-0.014395234175026417,
0.17659252882003784,
-0.5448057651519775,
0.599825382232666,
0.2472163289785385,
-0.8047357797622681,
0.5666526556015015,
-0.7746853232383728,
-0.20327922701835632,
0.26363667845726013,
-0.11607414484024048,
-0.21800658106803894,
-0.030334345996379852,
0.5745257139205933,
0.463846892118454,
0.17198653519153595,
-0.7931234240531921,
-0.0696411058306694,
0.2195407599210739,
-0.09346375614404678,
0.85576331615448,
-0.25291138887405396,
0.2601516842842102,
-0.3325274586677551,
0.7405298352241516,
0.2655887305736542,
0.3851880133152008,
0.27265504002571106,
-0.88332599401474,
-0.5394425988197327,
-0.5499345064163208,
-0.17725783586502075,
0.7137386202812195,
-0.6895866990089417,
0.09888249635696411,
0.09355083107948303,
-0.612971842288971,
0.011878777295351028,
-0.3040516972541809,
0.6295082569122314,
0.038435205817222595,
0.6004567742347717,
-0.2003019005060196,
-1.005121111869812,
-1.093533992767334,
-0.4498555660247803,
-0.1135701835155487,
0.13894855976104736,
0.2689303457736969,
0.6821674704551697,
-0.1390824168920517,
0.5920155048370361,
-0.28968048095703125,
-0.5186736583709717,
-0.12769167125225067,
0.5433595180511475,
-0.2770965099334717,
0.4458460211753845,
0.5227493643760681,
-1.351851224899292,
-0.4268755614757538,
-0.3331781327724457,
-0.29571348428726196,
-0.12705032527446747,
0.10507815331220627,
0.19727925956249237,
0.3985290825366974,
0.3272397220134735,
-0.14681169390678406,
0.40544384717941284,
0.9097338914871216,
-0.514312207698822,
0.6011859178543091,
0.36275216937065125,
0.673896849155426,
-0.9706432819366455,
-0.40599262714385986,
0.11881433427333832,
-0.21845759451389313,
-0.9238755702972412,
0.1063908264040947,
-0.20910237729549408,
-0.015610091388225555,
-0.6511609554290771,
0.12818697094917297,
-0.17962205410003662,
0.13504056632518768,
-0.20825210213661194,
0.08401025831699371,
-0.5102247595787048,
0.5826675891876221,
0.15779298543930054,
0.36475804448127747,
0.3510518968105316,
-0.18161830306053162,
0.6253657937049866,
0.14032889902591705,
-0.16450192034244537,
0.8749445676803589,
-0.11569661647081375,
0.2487320601940155,
-0.11746636033058167,
0.3024062514305115,
-1.1903760433197021,
-0.06286515295505524,
0.5355375409126282,
-0.5341607928276062,
0.04514061659574509,
-0.1567230224609375,
-0.2638314366340637,
-0.22891050577163696,
-0.2943513095378876,
0.931677520275116,
0.168631449341774,
-0.437214732170105,
0.9575773477554321,
0.7985023260116577,
-0.011552784591913223,
-0.48181432485580444,
-0.42911192774772644,
0.14832235872745514,
-0.5252711772918701,
-0.7592039704322815,
0.5679635405540466,
-0.1873777061700821,
-0.2974507510662079,
-0.13284634053707123,
0.2100284993648529,
-0.17783714830875397,
-0.15720993280410767,
0.6681907773017883,
0.08426418900489807,
-0.0363185852766037,
-0.1483227014541626,
-0.29110050201416016,
0.07201606035232544,
0.16432590782642365,
-0.06375129520893097,
0.5107100605964661,
-0.08725180476903915,
-0.231600821018219,
-0.4730216860771179,
0.8543584942817688,
0.6507344841957092,
-0.09451036900281906,
0.5589061379432678,
1.0524165630340576,
-0.40407729148864746,
-0.013695838861167431,
-0.6898556351661682,
-0.05735483765602112,
-0.3872172236442566,
0.3168911337852478,
-0.17543545365333557,
-1.2738308906555176,
0.44614991545677185,
0.2732129991054535,
-0.05151725932955742,
0.6317789554595947,
0.9461743831634521,
0.1608048975467682,
1.2330001592636108,
0.3752535879611969,
-0.0020821199286729097,
0.5100104212760925,
0.1744464486837387,
0.3080625832080841,
-0.5474185347557068,
-0.518110990524292,
-0.7459150552749634,
-0.2875714898109436,
-0.5800731778144836,
-0.5244530439376831,
0.47254690527915955,
-0.45798036456108093,
0.25665929913520813,
0.6449815630912781,
-0.45996758341789246,
0.3575851619243622,
0.32281047105789185,
-0.1570523977279663,
0.4236421287059784,
-0.04397464916110039,
0.16920951008796692,
-0.229440838098526,
-0.34587615728378296,
-0.11515197157859802,
0.834013819694519,
0.1370932012796402,
0.2991652190685272,
0.46989545226097107,
0.5709503889083862,
0.6540582776069641,
0.3387846052646637,
-0.7008860111236572,
0.4779125452041626,
-0.1091538816690445,
-1.0016696453094482,
-0.19403383135795593,
-0.21903768181800842,
-0.8376847505569458,
0.4501231610774994,
-0.6478461623191833,
-0.7495728731155396,
0.13305412232875824,
0.19600142538547516,
-0.0041162013076245785,
0.3790404498577118,
-0.4223482310771942,
0.9075355529785156,
0.19204474985599518,
-0.1577541083097458,
-0.40411025285720825,
-0.40182074904441833,
0.5080064535140991,
-0.28261426091194153,
0.7876588106155396,
-0.09211704134941101,
-0.008057693019509315,
1.0156317949295044,
0.2817482054233551,
0.7908917665481567,
-0.13790735602378845,
-0.1337616741657257,
0.019561806693673134,
-0.03710221126675606,
0.5499944686889648,
-0.10860776901245117,
0.027192488312721252,
0.2154807597398758,
-0.04799081012606621,
-0.08812254667282104,
-0.3378681242465973,
0.6807985901832581,
-0.35916516184806824,
-0.620497465133667,
-0.471092164516449,
-0.7577576637268066,
-0.07780720293521881,
-0.0346934050321579,
0.24673457443714142,
0.6627323627471924,
-0.29558536410331726,
0.24747595191001892,
0.5900196433067322,
0.08455519378185272,
0.563660740852356,
0.43936994671821594,
-0.08445729315280914,
-0.35045596957206726,
0.9275450706481934,
-0.06912440061569214,
0.0015303785912692547,
0.19894596934318542,
0.11526814848184586,
-0.2867961823940277,
-0.9090146422386169,
-0.407745361328125,
-0.16681857407093048,
-0.6709461808204651,
0.004735056776553392,
-1.043145775794983,
0.04915277287364006,
-0.5968445539474487,
-0.10209370404481888,
-0.2627609968185425,
-0.4479891061782837,
-0.11295238137245178,
0.34929221868515015,
0.0036303307861089706,
0.8348872065544128,
-0.3247608542442322,
-0.02806750312447548,
-0.536567211151123,
0.4877104163169861,
0.33635300397872925,
-0.14112110435962677,
-0.31282633543014526,
-0.841990053653717,
0.054650261998176575,
-0.21474263072013855,
-0.47238534688949585,
-0.7919317483901978,
0.2749822437763214,
0.06754527240991592,
0.5691927075386047,
0.2817985415458679,
0.2403300255537033,
0.48828452825546265,
-0.5520488619804382,
0.8806648850440979,
0.2871485948562622,
-0.8757747411727905,
0.5480971932411194,
-0.3188469707965851,
0.09159545600414276,
0.23594924807548523,
0.9839039444923401,
-0.3366181552410126,
-1.0336103439331055,
-0.7940519452095032,
-0.6386878490447998,
0.6736794710159302,
0.5611284971237183,
0.19631406664848328,
-0.1872701495885849,
-0.36784628033638,
-0.050431035459041595,
0.040829308331012726,
-0.9937596917152405,
-0.5793280601501465,
-0.08807007223367691,
-0.1616845577955246,
0.10951016843318939,
-0.38472747802734375,
-0.501116931438446,
-0.230763778090477,
0.7793932557106018,
-0.07388933002948761,
0.283848375082016,
-0.06170804798603058,
-0.06435677409172058,
0.024732934311032295,
0.4260368347167969,
1.1016175746917725,
0.6546885371208191,
0.019149240106344223,
0.3034007251262665,
0.18985524773597717,
-0.6126291751861572,
0.04039846360683441,
0.14351174235343933,
0.4242626428604126,
0.07960110902786255,
0.6792486906051636,
0.5074735283851624,
0.150950625538826,
-0.6177182197570801,
0.8909221291542053,
-0.2933052182197571,
-0.5311887264251709,
-0.7669756412506104,
-0.023810941725969315,
-0.23796838521957397,
0.7212082147598267,
0.6533325910568237,
0.17763952910900116,
0.3770377039909363,
-0.5923926830291748,
0.4408775866031647,
0.5857145190238953,
-0.5402011275291443,
-0.161597341299057,
0.7020866274833679,
0.16005709767341614,
-0.3535632789134979,
0.08586019277572632,
-0.4425879716873169,
-0.9733375310897827,
0.6709854602813721,
0.6506937146186829,
0.6538201570510864,
-0.34136077761650085,
0.05927794426679611,
0.3507035970687866,
0.2239067256450653,
0.614055871963501,
-0.025105498731136322,
-0.08947491645812988,
-0.9116829037666321,
-0.1053139716386795,
-0.5885084271430969,
-0.3062516450881958,
0.24469545483589172,
-0.6818560361862183,
0.14678223431110382,
-0.40376463532447815,
0.047835417091846466,
0.4364451467990875,
-0.28130924701690674,
-0.21423998475074768,
0.11785762757062912,
0.6396819353103638,
0.5089026093482971,
-0.9874053597450256,
0.6702417135238647,
0.40207332372665405,
0.07145830988883972,
-0.5540324449539185,
-0.1929251253604889,
0.7869850397109985,
-0.7424668073654175,
0.6954618096351624,
0.0995301678776741,
-0.29460829496383667,
0.009483718313276768,
-0.333879679441452,
-0.6197289824485779,
0.8469887375831604,
0.027100611478090286,
-0.4946346879005432,
0.18243737518787384,
0.03791603073477745,
0.40193450450897217,
-0.5449026823043823,
0.24430209398269653,
0.45406273007392883,
0.6132017374038696,
0.34992092847824097,
-0.9686813354492188,
0.11551260948181152,
-0.09067222476005554,
-0.2724567651748657,
0.49997323751449585,
-0.3522758483886719,
0.8921431303024292,
0.24405579268932343,
-0.44809025526046753,
-0.08508116006851196,
0.536933958530426,
0.10658299177885056,
0.40201276540756226,
0.9252709150314331,
0.7274882197380066,
0.3166792094707489,
-0.10948066413402557,
0.7986217141151428,
0.14943841099739075,
0.40466398000717163,
0.9627378582954407,
0.08966629207134247,
0.5933194756507874,
0.39403825998306274,
-0.11363325268030167,
0.4856480360031128,
0.168365478515625,
-0.09220424294471741,
0.37256309390068054,
0.31350308656692505,
-0.7738664746284485,
-0.4533957242965698,
-0.3633589446544647,
-0.2154189646244049,
0.8537924289703369,
0.4231392741203308,
-0.32473742961883545,
-0.26883846521377563,
0.5883578658103943,
0.15163011848926544,
0.17417940497398376,
-0.4219796359539032,
0.7454299330711365,
-0.3893487751483917,
-0.5701268315315247,
0.36849313974380493,
0.163212388753891,
1.055287480354309,
-0.3165002465248108,
-0.07768018543720245,
0.28963831067085266,
0.20013566315174103,
-0.40291064977645874,
-0.8223795890808105,
0.6052631735801697,
0.046906229108572006,
-0.33072081208229065,
-0.27273109555244446,
0.48436257243156433,
-0.6073334813117981,
-0.3280104398727417,
0.5640444159507751,
-0.07908716052770615,
0.23317167162895203,
-0.2860335111618042,
-0.8709176778793335,
0.5693511962890625,
-0.04503542557358742,
-0.13464972376823425,
0.3307631313800812,
0.09286031126976013,
-0.20495539903640747,
0.25686436891555786,
0.5656940937042236,
-0.39326217770576477,
0.357197642326355,
0.12253466993570328,
0.8357933759689331,
-0.2067154049873352,
-0.22931183874607086,
-0.8182128667831421,
0.36635735630989075,
-0.23625682294368744,
-0.5437926054000854,
0.8150662779808044,
0.7394393682479858,
1.1012566089630127,
-0.05363396927714348,
0.42080679535865784,
-0.5015682578086853,
0.47057977318763733,
-0.39714476466178894,
0.36308300495147705,
-0.5543762445449829,
-0.2895056903362274,
-0.5144060850143433,
-0.7060855627059937,
-0.5537331700325012,
0.2362762689590454,
-0.22205330431461334,
-0.2544006109237671,
0.9175907373428345,
1.0669363737106323,
-0.13102339208126068,
0.366966187953949,
0.49234578013420105,
-0.02798161469399929,
0.35814639925956726,
0.6911060810089111,
0.9722939729690552,
-0.3544558882713318,
0.9837983846664429,
-0.28963521122932434,
-0.30000025033950806,
-0.1682940125465393,
-0.9255104064941406,
-0.7463669776916504,
-1.153407096862793,
-0.5227078199386597,
-0.2324264943599701,
-0.038184989243745804,
0.8122806549072266,
0.8120617866516113,
-1.0647631883621216,
0.01132824458181858,
0.3778758645057678,
0.0538269579410553,
-0.009691707789897919,
-0.31886547803878784,
-0.027789555490016937,
0.12349999696016312,
-1.1416113376617432,
0.6008636355400085,
0.3306347727775574,
-0.26909154653549194,
-0.03547278791666031,
0.11590442806482315,
-0.7496181130409241,
-0.01676308922469616,
0.6996573209762573,
0.12720465660095215,
-0.7787817120552063,
-0.7903136610984802,
-0.5571115612983704,
0.08944837003946304,
-0.13466203212738037,
1.0448660850524902,
-0.67275470495224,
0.20983704924583435,
0.30639249086380005,
0.6580840349197388,
0.52533358335495,
-0.06359391659498215,
0.12250015884637833,
-0.7769379615783691,
0.3465353548526764,
0.48263317346572876,
0.3433935344219208,
0.0076744225807487965,
-0.44528958201408386,
0.2876024544239044,
0.6392926573753357,
-0.6112583875656128,
-0.5794085264205933,
0.5184034109115601,
-1.2975493669509888,
-0.22061967849731445,
0.9288698434829712,
-0.000015121595424716361,
-0.02571895532310009,
-0.6766075491905212,
-0.16597174108028412,
0.07370296865701675,
-0.3447229266166687,
0.5577085614204407,
0.7503356337547302,
-0.5084040760993958,
-0.47533026337623596,
-0.1701377034187317,
0.459954172372818,
0.3886689245700836,
-0.6623460054397583,
-0.25102072954177856,
0.6717317700386047,
-0.02164648286998272,
0.6330011487007141,
0.3843187391757965,
-0.1202065646648407,
0.48807042837142944,
-0.05185230076313019,
0.0785214975476265,
-0.13764706254005432,
-0.5167909860610962,
-0.38223782181739807,
0.7686221599578857,
-0.5916416049003601,
-0.2065046727657318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01963v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01963v1 | Improving Large-Scale k-Nearest Neighbor Text Categorization with Label Autoencoders | 2024-02-03T00:11:29 | 2024-02-03T00:11:29 | Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Shuyuan Cao, Víctor M. Darriba Bilbao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR, 68T50, 68T07, I.2.6; I.2.7; H.3.1 | In this paper, we introduce a multi-label lazy learning approach to deal with
automatic semantic indexing in large document collections in the presence of
complex and structured label vocabularies with high inter-label correlation.
The proposed method is an evolution of the traditional k-Nearest Neighbors
algorithm which uses a large autoencoder trained to map the large label space
to a reduced size latent space and to regenerate the predicted labels from this
latent space. We have evaluated our proposal in a large portion of the MEDLINE
biomedical document collection which uses the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
thesaurus as a controlled vocabulary. In our experiments we propose and
evaluate several document representation approaches and different label
autoencoder configurations. | [
-0.2667347192764282,
-0.389138400554657,
0.3203286826610565,
-0.06359630078077316,
-0.14086821675300598,
0.12908433377742767,
-0.0427904911339283,
-0.4915851056575775,
0.5719891786575317,
0.4094317853450775,
-0.06477797776460648,
-0.41484934091567993,
-0.8301216959953308,
0.38537514209747314,
-0.09481658786535263,
1.0593290328979492,
-0.13225603103637695,
-0.09153421223163605,
-0.24918223917484283,
-0.13836781680583954,
0.06219726800918579,
-0.7493919134140015,
-0.4555205702781677,
-0.2147189825773239,
0.9767370223999023,
0.4167797863483429,
0.7893992066383362,
1.09778892993927,
0.6221930384635925,
0.40927863121032715,
0.0034436837304383516,
0.15360257029533386,
-0.48556289076805115,
0.13869522511959076,
0.07642854750156403,
-0.26016315817832947,
-0.23204247653484344,
-0.15037982165813446,
0.9317588806152344,
0.6488669514656067,
0.054921407252550125,
-0.15952488780021667,
-0.17155705392360687,
0.560876190662384,
-0.6989274024963379,
0.33826330304145813,
-0.410400927066803,
0.25722065567970276,
-0.3335408866405487,
-0.10945193469524384,
-0.10266251116991043,
-0.2147568166255951,
0.12564517557621002,
-0.4177526533603668,
0.35395002365112305,
0.23335117101669312,
0.9598633646965027,
0.5939252376556396,
-0.5151898264884949,
-0.4512885510921478,
-0.5867470502853394,
0.6042121648788452,
-0.3664547801017761,
0.7723929286003113,
0.5828973054885864,
0.228204146027565,
-0.21614478528499603,
-0.7799241542816162,
-0.44815483689308167,
-0.0616907998919487,
-0.11700675636529922,
0.15286703407764435,
0.16119246184825897,
0.1637285351753235,
-0.02100110612809658,
0.6981176733970642,
-0.6753838062286377,
0.48860886693000793,
-0.40161147713661194,
-0.43567827343940735,
0.4401494562625885,
0.24602848291397095,
-0.20620398223400116,
-0.19118434190750122,
-0.29304245114326477,
-0.3966003358364105,
-0.07625036686658859,
-0.23079586029052734,
0.09249516576528549,
0.01603437215089798,
0.3742704689502716,
0.5680161118507385,
-0.35973379015922546,
0.781579852104187,
0.1881638616323471,
-0.3342708945274353,
0.6280304193496704,
-0.4930828809738159,
-0.08603343367576599,
0.33572298288345337,
0.9653123021125793,
0.2624570429325104,
-0.20084312558174133,
-0.3611662983894348,
-0.1459026336669922,
0.014051524922251701,
0.3653014600276947,
-0.7741534113883972,
-0.5234771370887756,
0.12379710376262665,
-0.6699918508529663,
-0.051388129591941833,
-0.0888310968875885,
-0.892521858215332,
-0.3512743413448334,
-0.30649247765541077,
0.470150887966156,
-0.1760762333869934,
0.08887343108654022,
0.12494798749685287,
-0.02758236788213253,
0.10574612766504288,
0.045254502445459366,
-0.7149433493614197,
0.1319461315870285,
0.2806748151779175,
0.7404242753982544,
-0.1554165631532669,
-0.2773902714252472,
-0.37817123532295227,
0.3680950701236725,
-0.14056916534900665,
0.7668907642364502,
-0.5071524977684021,
-0.4849146902561188,
-0.13059380650520325,
0.27854639291763306,
-0.04352695867419243,
-0.7175817489624023,
0.4137873351573944,
-0.6521750092506409,
0.055153362452983856,
0.09802357107400894,
-0.5438619256019592,
0.13509704172611237,
0.4031851887702942,
-0.7113275527954102,
1.0164934396743774,
0.21587032079696655,
-0.7415200471878052,
0.1785297691822052,
-0.3489108979701996,
-0.33065447211265564,
-0.12542830407619476,
0.09034308046102524,
-0.8873268961906433,
-0.2245643138885498,
0.18057429790496826,
0.6857500672340393,
-0.10157844424247742,
0.1094062477350235,
-0.4730193614959717,
-0.08387219905853271,
0.11128568649291992,
-0.10867515951395035,
0.2857625484466553,
0.2050478607416153,
-0.06156514957547188,
-0.035879138857126236,
-0.8399968147277832,
0.004344523418694735,
-0.024830063804984093,
-0.46714672446250916,
-0.7772789597511292,
-0.2157464623451233,
0.05680832266807556,
0.5064000487327576,
0.43442460894584656,
-0.6475955843925476,
0.5219402313232422,
-0.649925708770752,
0.0967230275273323,
0.3176555037498474,
0.2248588651418686,
0.5158559083938599,
-0.13953445851802826,
0.057964518666267395,
0.17152781784534454,
0.2875685393810272,
-0.057670433074235916,
-0.3542017340660095,
-0.8730818629264832,
-0.19706931710243225,
0.6893815398216248,
0.320107638835907,
-1.0678547620773315,
0.6221916079521179,
-0.32427749037742615,
-0.6653334498405457,
-0.5411413311958313,
0.33694952726364136,
0.4909406304359436,
0.31336724758148193,
0.5193158388137817,
-0.535971999168396,
-0.16775327920913696,
-1.0075098276138306,
0.21276380121707916,
-0.022326350212097168,
-0.05344315990805626,
0.5109615325927734,
0.5667658448219299,
-0.694794774055481,
0.7941761016845703,
-0.7809838652610779,
-0.630588710308075,
0.5741652250289917,
0.5146669149398804,
-0.05568758025765419,
0.565201461315155,
0.23445211350917816,
-1.106004238128662,
-0.540895402431488,
-0.07541657984256744,
-0.48923173546791077,
-0.06561078876256943,
0.21451923251152039,
-0.046105001121759415,
0.054717399179935455,
0.9800772070884705,
-0.2145078480243683,
0.2244269996881485,
0.30626288056373596,
-0.17394350469112396,
0.32786673307418823,
-0.6016871929168701,
0.023395730182528496,
-1.0986944437026978,
-0.13580870628356934,
-0.003087000222876668,
0.0777154490351677,
-0.3668328523635864,
-0.25425687432289124,
0.1814241260290146,
-0.10408112406730652,
0.021904028952121735,
0.4674299359321594,
-0.6953331828117371,
-0.03808685019612312,
-0.416498601436615,
0.045810505747795105,
-0.05049948766827583,
0.3181796967983246,
0.23863928020000458,
0.4306025803089142,
0.2569906413555145,
-0.750472366809845,
0.5278569459915161,
0.18164406716823578,
-0.16025027632713318,
0.481680303812027,
-0.35074928402900696,
0.03572699800133705,
-0.5561802387237549,
0.4178619384765625,
-0.9926415085792542,
-0.4697346091270447,
0.147587850689888,
-0.3456522822380066,
0.7133789658546448,
0.14611487090587616,
-1.0171715021133423,
-1.0496758222579956,
-0.23468303680419922,
0.48626837134361267,
0.16468077898025513,
-0.48689183592796326,
0.43212077021598816,
0.679394006729126,
-0.11811903119087219,
-0.4831523895263672,
-0.3281359076499939,
0.054506123065948486,
0.05032104626297951,
-0.19447121024131775,
0.332307904958725,
-0.14927098155021667,
0.1510399878025055,
0.16245849430561066,
0.09935413300991058,
-0.528386116027832,
-0.18276309967041016,
0.13233359158039093,
-0.02461804822087288,
-0.11897861212491989,
0.8490574359893799,
0.06325225532054901,
-0.2773107886314392,
-0.20990559458732605,
-0.5658535361289978,
0.13138531148433685,
0.00017898382793646306,
0.12583598494529724,
-0.057933464646339417,
0.30162346363067627,
0.5450482368469238,
-0.30757397413253784,
0.6627987623214722,
0.7656129598617554,
-0.2489774525165558,
0.027409134432673454,
-0.6189519166946411,
0.08853611350059509,
-0.47537103295326233,
0.5659517645835876,
-0.32240524888038635,
-0.8094816207885742,
0.14307741820812225,
-0.47089505195617676,
-0.24974200129508972,
0.5116328001022339,
0.6491062641143799,
-0.18341971933841705,
0.5939815640449524,
0.849410891532898,
-0.1694466769695282,
0.2030295878648758,
-0.29906851053237915,
0.11130733788013458,
-0.8345474004745483,
-0.447681725025177,
-0.7826114892959595,
-0.32285866141319275,
-0.619300127029419,
-0.8753975629806519,
0.48431694507598877,
-0.028797697275877,
-0.048557646572589874,
0.21358619630336761,
-0.846112072467804,
0.3521021902561188,
0.3914108872413635,
0.23445481061935425,
0.10267278552055359,
-0.00299641746096313,
-0.18620994687080383,
-0.037882015109062195,
-0.9399540424346924,
-0.061833854764699936,
0.8417038321495056,
0.2635214328765869,
0.7245017290115356,
-0.036244042217731476,
0.7792163491249084,
0.04020688682794571,
0.6424582600593567,
-0.9878659844398499,
0.16998708248138428,
-0.48845747113227844,
-0.49788954854011536,
-0.3431514501571655,
-0.48893773555755615,
-1.42897367477417,
0.30630677938461304,
-0.3525651693344116,
-0.6005345582962036,
0.4435599446296692,
0.07166601717472076,
-0.13066227734088898,
0.24576765298843384,
-0.6605775356292725,
0.8871557712554932,
-0.20012784004211426,
-0.1709100306034088,
0.15702377259731293,
-0.88068687915802,
0.100374236702919,
-0.5720018148422241,
0.037195779383182526,
0.32055166363716125,
-0.5068562030792236,
0.9962432384490967,
-0.591185450553894,
0.7869435548782349,
0.05339436233043671,
-0.22607789933681488,
0.2918049395084381,
-0.2843312919139862,
0.35024237632751465,
-0.2127613127231598,
-0.1597980409860611,
0.11352693289518356,
-0.06099449843168259,
-0.6024003624916077,
-0.3046340048313141,
0.7601795792579651,
-0.8702162504196167,
-0.15573406219482422,
-0.4372177720069885,
-0.5332850217819214,
-0.4782094955444336,
0.32122603058815,
0.40362823009490967,
0.49159806966781616,
0.07304219901561737,
0.3344385027885437,
0.8879536390304565,
-0.16220906376838684,
0.3579178750514984,
0.4466113746166229,
0.10716185718774796,
-0.6550462245941162,
1.218279480934143,
0.46071144938468933,
-0.08789829164743423,
0.5835884213447571,
0.2562785744667053,
-0.4848741888999939,
-0.30408546328544617,
-0.15789128839969635,
0.43766167759895325,
-0.661463737487793,
-0.3634733557701111,
-1.016671895980835,
-0.13597680628299713,
-0.39485299587249756,
-0.16918717324733734,
-0.31735432147979736,
-0.060839373618364334,
-0.4004746973514557,
0.35870596766471863,
0.32024085521698,
0.8599138259887695,
-0.017805296927690506,
0.4374077022075653,
-1.039461374282837,
0.39529529213905334,
0.1980656087398529,
0.6769317984580994,
0.17328797280788422,
-0.29215461015701294,
-0.55278080701828,
-0.4000083804130554,
-0.2121465504169464,
-0.6649125814437866,
0.35494428873062134,
0.13276126980781555,
0.429784893989563,
0.48948490619659424,
0.3148595988750458,
0.4661617577075958,
-0.625693678855896,
0.5191369652748108,
0.2490420937538147,
-0.2763780653476715,
0.3369203209877014,
-0.3088840842247009,
0.6273045539855957,
0.5103747844696045,
0.9966446161270142,
-0.2744530141353607,
-0.3921288549900055,
-0.7119561433792114,
-0.957025408744812,
0.3204408884048462,
-0.04145742580294609,
-0.1534150242805481,
-0.03414830192923546,
0.5120831727981567,
0.21871906518936157,
0.1290677934885025,
-0.5856640934944153,
-0.46241846680641174,
-0.15958216786384583,
-0.5214325785636902,
-0.4739629924297333,
-0.3529707193374634,
0.2851888835430145,
-0.2652261555194855,
0.6438679695129395,
-0.17743709683418274,
0.3765491247177124,
0.4470781683921814,
0.040575459599494934,
0.08721435815095901,
0.10772975534200668,
0.1728004366159439,
0.09590595215559006,
-0.10681229829788208,
0.19424203038215637,
-0.1809210479259491,
-0.7367655038833618,
0.18989238142967224,
0.5208442211151123,
-0.07805419713258743,
0.26340022683143616,
0.047713812440633774,
0.45347827672958374,
0.4091378450393677,
-0.30188655853271484,
0.4063994884490967,
-0.013753489591181278,
-0.39418309926986694,
-0.07267530262470245,
-0.18072204291820526,
-0.1273478865623474,
0.09377802908420563,
0.22004105150699615,
-0.26518377661705017,
0.2675112187862396,
-0.3031289875507355,
0.44332459568977356,
0.21152512729167938,
-0.5676522254943848,
0.06986329704523087,
0.46966254711151123,
0.07409834116697311,
-0.25134170055389404,
0.545830249786377,
-0.21731902658939362,
-0.5938916206359863,
0.6911964416503906,
0.4798644781112671,
0.5888586044311523,
-0.3439943790435791,
0.049915969371795654,
0.6100299954414368,
0.20672427117824554,
-0.06942985206842422,
-0.28192415833473206,
-0.22317345440387726,
-0.36251601576805115,
-0.2892420291900635,
-0.7779321670532227,
-0.20485271513462067,
0.23996131122112274,
-0.30020785331726074,
-0.011951176449656487,
-0.15989521145820618,
-0.21850551664829254,
0.3462328314781189,
0.026259776204824448,
-0.39847812056541443,
0.2593245506286621,
0.12363307178020477,
0.49027296900749207,
-0.5552161931991577,
0.9706704020500183,
0.857600212097168,
-0.1893616020679474,
-0.49836036562919617,
0.19860613346099854,
-0.21945713460445404,
-0.12727485597133636,
0.9987602829933167,
0.13525745272636414,
0.05134030431509018,
0.06293770670890808,
-0.526604175567627,
-1.204929232597351,
0.7417858839035034,
-0.5590376853942871,
-0.6201105117797852,
-0.024988248944282532,
-0.11190151423215866,
0.6557115912437439,
0.07501466572284698,
0.0014287226367741823,
0.007391022518277168,
0.3095957040786743,
-0.09333554655313492,
-1.1377291679382324,
-0.35922062397003174,
-0.1940213292837143,
0.12396402657032013,
0.7034343481063843,
-0.8855633735656738,
0.5437718629837036,
0.05244043841958046,
0.11334087699651718,
0.32245540618896484,
0.6463944911956787,
-0.3298875093460083,
0.47796082496643066,
0.46909675002098083,
0.5871512293815613,
0.8617296814918518,
-0.04267657920718193,
1.0350208282470703,
-0.18862570822238922,
0.44125860929489136,
1.0387760400772095,
-0.21663782000541687,
0.7424716353416443,
0.27876392006874084,
-0.03653982654213905,
0.36701706051826477,
0.7237051129341125,
-0.3526400625705719,
0.5005817413330078,
0.5319236516952515,
-0.26709848642349243,
-0.17208003997802734,
-0.15926773846149445,
-0.3648917078971863,
0.558273196220398,
0.8080487251281738,
-0.45339494943618774,
-0.40876495838165283,
0.5475006699562073,
-0.2588026225566864,
-0.021948328241705894,
-0.6150815486907959,
0.9029998779296875,
0.042078349739313126,
-0.35345062613487244,
0.738113522529602,
0.04942996799945831,
0.7220409512519836,
-0.4397978186607361,
-0.014611893333494663,
0.3561764657497406,
0.44735580682754517,
0.02675488218665123,
-0.6313382983207703,
0.0514274537563324,
-0.5331900119781494,
-0.5078237652778625,
-0.04269716888666153,
1.040167212486267,
-0.5730398297309875,
-0.3757539391517639,
0.24814823269844055,
0.31848111748695374,
0.4384598731994629,
0.40819093585014343,
-0.7650543451309204,
-0.234454944729805,
-0.35396406054496765,
-0.13969652354717255,
0.4863118529319763,
0.6913767457008362,
-0.22935986518859863,
0.5538130402565002,
0.47816962003707886,
-0.1285460740327835,
0.1996246874332428,
-0.31354761123657227,
0.8997134566307068,
-0.6183148622512817,
-0.5648544430732727,
-0.30161404609680176,
-0.2127855271100998,
-0.1136574074625969,
-0.20349617302417755,
0.7351990938186646,
0.8050967454910278,
0.8006727695465088,
-0.3132811188697815,
0.24269720911979675,
0.03232404962182045,
0.5277152061462402,
-0.335359662771225,
0.5874007344245911,
-0.6524341702461243,
-0.3385412395000458,
-0.34732478857040405,
-0.8594440817832947,
-0.5513384342193604,
0.5660860538482666,
-0.3846064507961273,
-0.12883895635604858,
0.7107002139091492,
0.7461250424385071,
-0.07825863361358643,
-0.4836646318435669,
0.2871645987033844,
0.5541831851005554,
-0.2373306304216385,
0.611026406288147,
0.49096447229385376,
-0.6123396158218384,
0.767744779586792,
-0.46367883682250977,
-0.2506919801235199,
-0.29692041873931885,
-0.58718341588974,
-0.7505881786346436,
-0.7933834791183472,
-0.5900391340255737,
-0.6761309504508972,
0.06843399256467819,
0.5659268498420715,
0.4611373245716095,
-0.5018777251243591,
0.1358763873577118,
0.3404001295566559,
-0.048317182809114456,
0.1023581475019455,
-0.2527583837509155,
0.8289164304733276,
-0.4273104965686798,
-0.71370530128479,
0.045885078608989716,
0.3500065207481384,
0.18308475613594055,
-0.18674668669700623,
-0.0027603432536125183,
-0.43991151452064514,
-0.3001117706298828,
0.7582129836082458,
0.5978071689605713,
-0.3232801556587219,
0.0803208127617836,
-0.37358349561691284,
-0.5638495087623596,
0.17939919233322144,
0.5589239001274109,
-0.95958012342453,
0.8424270749092102,
0.3990905284881592,
0.854375958442688,
0.5304151773452759,
-0.06290938705205917,
-0.01025239285081625,
-0.614130437374115,
0.10345623642206192,
0.24798789620399475,
0.08105222135782242,
0.2308875471353531,
-0.40886038541793823,
0.5405682921409607,
0.30862364172935486,
-0.8199459314346313,
-0.46039047837257385,
-0.10060659050941467,
-0.9021831154823303,
-0.4439008831977844,
1.0784907341003418,
0.05078773573040962,
-0.5071153044700623,
-0.6583212018013,
-0.2373703569173813,
0.2913990616798401,
-0.1929256021976471,
0.8142228722572327,
0.4893108606338501,
0.03471944481134415,
0.022443972527980804,
-0.5987188220024109,
0.4175276756286621,
0.26786723732948303,
-0.567119300365448,
-0.21485742926597595,
0.5109222531318665,
0.009998757392168045,
0.7183589935302734,
0.789844810962677,
-0.2792122960090637,
0.1020936667919159,
-0.04181182384490967,
0.1681721955537796,
0.17630329728126526,
-0.12179689109325409,
-0.28708845376968384,
0.25215035676956177,
-0.07963830977678299,
-0.14286193251609802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01945v1 | A Case Study on Filtering for End-to-End Speech Translation | 2024-02-02T22:42:33 | 2024-02-02T22:42:33 | Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is relatively easy to mine a large parallel corpus for any machine
learning task, such as speech-to-text or speech-to-speech translation. Although
these mined corpora are large in volume, their quality is questionable. This
work shows that the simplest filtering technique can trim down these big, noisy
datasets to a more manageable, clean dataset. We also show that using this
clean dataset can improve the model's performance, as in the case of the
multilingual-to-English Speech Translation (ST) model, where, on average, we
obtain a 4.65 BLEU score improvement. | [
-0.421195924282074,
-0.5657113790512085,
0.4455565810203552,
-0.22589421272277832,
-0.5914451479911804,
0.0601620152592659,
-0.6596412062644958,
-0.5996972918510437,
-0.11166298389434814,
0.7545228600502014,
-0.43180787563323975,
-0.6455875635147095,
-0.8010843992233276,
0.18603330850601196,
-0.8853962421417236,
1.2605881690979004,
0.2449580281972885,
0.13504894077777863,
-0.10629090666770935,
-0.04860844835639,
-0.43279123306274414,
-0.5027909278869629,
-0.9493946433067322,
-0.33413904905319214,
0.49266842007637024,
0.3268078565597534,
0.8914978504180908,
0.7515637874603271,
0.5163480639457703,
0.26868295669555664,
-0.3417573571205139,
0.20201261341571808,
-0.8375533223152161,
0.3402019143104553,
-0.3674604594707489,
-0.6520748138427734,
0.0033950076904147863,
-0.07351566851139069,
0.5770145058631897,
1.0035470724105835,
-0.15289747714996338,
0.11923997849225998,
-0.026820490136742592,
0.7594611644744873,
-0.3494170904159546,
0.08894822001457214,
-0.655163049697876,
-0.06678014248609543,
-0.45871618390083313,
-0.08671087771654129,
-0.5970388054847717,
-0.03329360857605934,
-0.07496560364961624,
-0.48950085043907166,
0.2656167149543762,
0.29910504817962646,
1.1069036722183228,
0.5861527919769287,
-0.36789703369140625,
-0.21963472664356232,
-0.9308637976646423,
1.0598770380020142,
-0.5458466410636902,
0.659180223941803,
0.7313944697380066,
0.31551313400268555,
-0.2324327826499939,
-0.7627555727958679,
-0.24907644093036652,
-0.030071483924984932,
-0.1975782960653305,
0.2768038511276245,
-0.36606380343437195,
0.10928147286176682,
0.3123401701450348,
0.4902617633342743,
-0.7351787686347961,
0.21992188692092896,
-0.928008496761322,
-0.23378366231918335,
0.6562684774398804,
-0.12714485824108124,
0.27970069646835327,
-0.0041392710991203785,
0.03100772015750408,
-0.12525135278701782,
-0.6643138527870178,
0.14904212951660156,
0.42132970690727234,
0.5263484120368958,
0.2757223844528198,
0.4391997456550598,
-0.29716405272483826,
0.8858797550201416,
-0.33006659150123596,
0.07288900762796402,
0.15927402675151825,
-0.41511523723602295,
-0.5114316344261169,
0.1328323632478714,
0.4005318284034729,
0.08889119327068329,
0.4563599228858948,
-0.22344759106636047,
-0.3080439567565918,
0.1006745845079422,
0.14704474806785583,
-0.9894644618034363,
-0.2576838433742523,
0.3937554955482483,
-0.671138346195221,
0.006510710343718529,
-0.026206016540527344,
-0.49765312671661377,
-0.06311782449483871,
-0.74806809425354,
0.17737023532390594,
-0.22643083333969116,
0.006678110919892788,
0.13864025473594666,
0.0009766982402652502,
0.05778666213154793,
0.18492957949638367,
-0.5432774424552917,
0.5829146504402161,
0.7073760628700256,
0.8434687852859497,
-0.05631008371710777,
0.015187319368124008,
-1.2348357439041138,
-0.07830317318439484,
-0.6493430733680725,
0.762493908405304,
-0.5485934019088745,
-0.314353346824646,
-0.02451673150062561,
-0.09062016755342484,
-0.03072250820696354,
-0.750860333442688,
0.9019750952720642,
-0.48449310660362244,
0.3379703164100647,
0.0016806191997602582,
-0.6370551586151123,
-0.3831695318222046,
-0.2907158136367798,
-0.5820263028144836,
0.8605215549468994,
0.029414810240268707,
-0.1281372308731079,
0.30078160762786865,
-0.1712748408317566,
-0.7168940305709839,
0.04942793399095535,
0.128040611743927,
-0.3509088158607483,
0.36970585584640503,
0.3417050838470459,
0.29410839080810547,
-0.4713072180747986,
0.2993108928203583,
-0.22493068873882294,
-0.5933687090873718,
0.011222993023693562,
-0.3257712125778198,
0.8169200420379639,
0.752807080745697,
0.23887623846530914,
0.19366095960140228,
-0.7382199168205261,
-0.07329408079385757,
-0.372440367937088,
-0.20775502920150757,
-0.49257543683052063,
0.19063936173915863,
0.2635383605957031,
0.39808693528175354,
0.06921250373125076,
-0.6864140629768372,
-0.3128175735473633,
-0.39224717020988464,
0.664812445640564,
0.43627870082855225,
-0.16850058734416962,
0.33393168449401855,
-0.48440858721733093,
0.19488674402236938,
-0.005945939105004072,
0.028173347935080528,
-0.2888690233230591,
-0.7504061460494995,
-0.6419010162353516,
-0.794340968132019,
0.7523857951164246,
0.5206443071365356,
-0.4418869912624359,
0.4122418463230133,
-0.3719034790992737,
-0.3921053111553192,
-1.066426396369934,
0.4996626675128937,
0.29215991497039795,
0.34640026092529297,
0.5234121680259705,
-0.3042179048061371,
-0.5405740737915039,
-0.9673382639884949,
-0.3563600778579712,
0.08011697977781296,
-0.23992811143398285,
-0.009901144541800022,
0.26880311965942383,
-0.02146676927804947,
0.7692350745201111,
-0.36113274097442627,
-0.5449562668800354,
0.026077590882778168,
-0.0036798492074012756,
0.5777140855789185,
0.38824135065078735,
0.07728510349988937,
-1.0100953578948975,
-0.5223972797393799,
0.19789530336856842,
-0.5597736835479736,
-0.3367801904678345,
-0.04666813090443611,
-0.27220937609672546,
-0.05966551601886749,
0.8312183618545532,
-0.5199748873710632,
0.5155989527702332,
0.48657286167144775,
-0.2098548412322998,
0.18484720587730408,
-0.38559412956237793,
0.18473710119724274,
-1.0403079986572266,
0.2208460122346878,
0.05134150758385658,
-0.8211139440536499,
-0.9942066669464111,
0.006922254804521799,
-0.055532053112983704,
-0.16465717554092407,
-0.5021172165870667,
0.286026269197464,
-0.2681128680706024,
-0.17680469155311584,
-0.4907325506210327,
0.3266018331050873,
0.02040308713912964,
0.29434874653816223,
0.036267995834350586,
0.5658015012741089,
0.47265470027923584,
-0.843862771987915,
0.23745791614055634,
0.32941216230392456,
-0.4828098714351654,
0.7245709300041199,
-0.41351065039634705,
-0.03310612961649895,
-0.32934582233428955,
0.21307174861431122,
-1.079163670539856,
-0.06510224938392639,
-0.2950851321220398,
-0.5151736736297607,
0.475237637758255,
-0.4334453046321869,
-0.5641458630561829,
-0.07607819885015488,
0.010395776480436325,
-0.029045231640338898,
0.7090992331504822,
-0.7918442487716675,
0.14040327072143555,
0.3236199617385864,
-0.403950035572052,
-0.2693169414997101,
-0.6064527034759521,
0.3380581736564636,
-0.2951459586620331,
-0.5385345816612244,
0.6708565950393677,
-0.15095099806785583,
-0.13624335825443268,
0.10401815921068192,
0.031520869582891464,
-0.2799690365791321,
-0.04062632471323013,
0.07711062580347061,
0.20612221956253052,
0.14244294166564941,
0.23230761289596558,
0.14400546252727509,
-0.016472991555929184,
-0.09251250326633453,
-0.17274107038974762,
0.47796714305877686,
0.21905340254306793,
-0.20148172974586487,
-0.24521245062351227,
0.6147391200065613,
0.6694570183753967,
-0.27186116576194763,
0.6155537366867065,
0.676068127155304,
-0.6780651807785034,
-0.21176710724830627,
-0.35332149267196655,
-0.1617887318134308,
-0.3986271023750305,
0.4345172941684723,
-0.5579115152359009,
-0.717416524887085,
0.4550388753414154,
-0.03234748914837837,
0.24690291285514832,
0.37894406914711,
0.43333789706230164,
-0.37911391258239746,
1.1154100894927979,
0.2973420023918152,
-0.2540132403373718,
0.5450465083122253,
-0.10494156926870346,
0.5016619563102722,
-0.7868168354034424,
-0.0321706123650074,
-0.7450094223022461,
-0.37178078293800354,
-0.7210802435874939,
-0.18961137533187866,
0.16058866679668427,
0.2576049864292145,
-0.12001669406890869,
0.38564127683639526,
-0.41669559478759766,
0.22922009229660034,
0.8669601678848267,
0.18858732283115387,
0.39959871768951416,
0.28668466210365295,
0.2946855425834656,
-0.005821669939905405,
-0.4140014052391052,
-0.25683701038360596,
1.0464351177215576,
0.19825665652751923,
0.33195960521698,
0.1122661679983139,
0.6320697665214539,
0.2000536024570465,
0.1170915737748146,
-0.7299826145172119,
0.3753555119037628,
-0.8681574463844299,
-0.5487512946128845,
-0.48918670415878296,
-0.6431442499160767,
-1.0761597156524658,
0.4918690323829651,
-0.2175840586423874,
-0.45097678899765015,
0.25062429904937744,
-0.11379790306091309,
-0.0011355951428413391,
0.3878133296966553,
-0.7483240962028503,
0.6237107515335083,
-0.09603365510702133,
-0.45658281445503235,
-0.5786148309707642,
-0.40385088324546814,
0.1414879709482193,
-0.38036686182022095,
0.5425459146499634,
-0.20188948512077332,
0.20398515462875366,
0.6619996428489685,
-0.5931881070137024,
0.6156766414642334,
-0.14542679488658905,
0.20943380892276764,
0.30076903104782104,
-0.01411642599850893,
0.48074573278427124,
-0.3318837583065033,
-0.16861844062805176,
0.4792560040950775,
0.08613009750843048,
-0.5064931511878967,
-0.5154418349266052,
0.6545308828353882,
-0.7084751725196838,
-0.5466462969779968,
-0.11084810644388199,
-0.6333394050598145,
0.08350203931331635,
0.16174133121967316,
0.30197873711586,
0.09505414217710495,
-0.02174324542284012,
0.4975981116294861,
0.6941707134246826,
-0.11876419931650162,
0.48270145058631897,
0.5202406048774719,
-0.1010843813419342,
-0.35823923349380493,
0.9948937892913818,
0.4506620168685913,
0.08440596610307693,
0.43706580996513367,
0.2360236942768097,
-0.48054468631744385,
-0.7566020488739014,
-0.7483648657798767,
0.1120198667049408,
-0.5240458846092224,
-0.2711435854434967,
-0.35297855734825134,
-0.28521350026130676,
-0.4543454945087433,
0.11079384386539459,
-0.25517794489860535,
-0.44609272480010986,
-0.18028032779693604,
-0.11273360252380371,
0.4588559865951538,
0.43537232279777527,
-0.16488885879516602,
0.41287627816200256,
-0.6360157132148743,
0.41376128792762756,
0.08271069824695587,
0.38987964391708374,
-0.5894253849983215,
-1.146259069442749,
-0.45016950368881226,
-0.01599794439971447,
0.02949259616434574,
-0.6893390417098999,
0.7278934121131897,
0.5635828971862793,
0.48621881008148193,
0.1161339282989502,
0.0971275269985199,
0.8949143290519714,
-0.6468228697776794,
0.5478771328926086,
0.12741732597351074,
-1.0443387031555176,
0.5501352548599243,
-0.0755537897348404,
0.20426103472709656,
0.5270648002624512,
0.24737781286239624,
-0.7930303812026978,
-0.305735319852829,
-0.2382846176624298,
-1.0966206789016724,
0.6179355382919312,
0.32858842611312866,
-0.0690440833568573,
0.16931690275669098,
0.300160676240921,
0.01563739962875843,
0.3584796190261841,
-0.32917794585227966,
-0.184051051735878,
-0.10609965026378632,
-0.3765203356742859,
-0.45776912569999695,
-0.14811712503433228,
0.06401913613080978,
-0.11491208523511887,
0.9359471201896667,
0.2907390892505646,
-0.07492708414793015,
0.16840265691280365,
-0.4228246510028839,
-0.19570815563201904,
0.4070272743701935,
0.32697129249572754,
0.2729905843734741,
-0.1640823632478714,
-0.012206519953906536,
0.17763248085975647,
-0.3147123456001282,
-0.1384797841310501,
0.18091636896133423,
-0.3915802240371704,
0.07650817185640335,
0.11363906413316727,
0.7499457001686096,
0.10879701375961304,
-0.7378091812133789,
0.34116920828819275,
0.2468203753232956,
-0.32319071888923645,
-0.04655471444129944,
-0.14820922911167145,
-0.03664345666766167,
-0.14422160387039185,
0.17889273166656494,
0.046977851539850235,
0.4887322783470154,
-0.6186363697052002,
0.46278518438339233,
0.0802699625492096,
-0.5429351329803467,
-0.058223843574523926,
0.7209091782569885,
-0.03660072758793831,
-0.3744155466556549,
0.8731074929237366,
0.01798955537378788,
-0.3216179609298706,
0.2630734145641327,
0.4602140188217163,
0.6040377020835876,
-0.43175727128982544,
-0.06734141707420349,
0.37602004408836365,
0.5002577304840088,
-0.20410500466823578,
0.12136104702949524,
-0.07112807780504227,
-0.30050143599510193,
-1.0213072299957275,
-0.7409296631813049,
-0.46888673305511475,
0.18721166253089905,
-0.8100959062576294,
0.39894282817840576,
0.2009897530078888,
-0.024071799591183662,
0.12728983163833618,
0.08100847154855728,
-0.8592075705528259,
0.5611798167228699,
0.27502456307411194,
0.67533278465271,
-0.998352587223053,
1.0300748348236084,
0.6140568852424622,
-0.3136873245239258,
-0.3706969618797302,
-0.6054735779762268,
-0.2988327741622925,
-0.5084862112998962,
0.5352603197097778,
0.11492061614990234,
0.014080550521612167,
-0.18737098574638367,
-0.3376370668411255,
-0.9933128356933594,
0.4907509386539459,
0.44949373602867126,
-0.9056603312492371,
0.16718608140945435,
0.30435991287231445,
0.8791091442108154,
-0.12636953592300415,
0.13951809704303741,
0.670195996761322,
0.4660737216472626,
-0.06045174598693848,
-1.0247057676315308,
-0.27399176359176636,
-0.4458617568016052,
0.014534988440573215,
0.18941034376621246,
-0.556199312210083,
0.7216100692749023,
0.18421122431755066,
-0.16903507709503174,
-0.2685391306877136,
0.7944238781929016,
-0.09404829889535904,
0.48525470495224,
0.6190286874771118,
0.5191634893417358,
1.0742995738983154,
-0.16456100344657898,
0.9484007954597473,
-0.40895217657089233,
0.0030931648798286915,
1.253812551498413,
-0.2503596544265747,
1.1188998222351074,
0.4757176637649536,
0.037717804312705994,
0.16567175090312958,
0.8934161067008972,
-0.06776239722967148,
0.6250345706939697,
0.5512168407440186,
-0.21666009724140167,
-0.3784573972225189,
-0.19327111542224884,
0.1117887869477272,
0.4823986291885376,
0.5711790919303894,
-0.3091330826282501,
-0.07178487628698349,
0.267403244972229,
-0.17759105563163757,
0.47582918405532837,
-0.4968574345111847,
0.6801126599311829,
0.29100334644317627,
-0.7916216850280762,
0.44981542229652405,
0.07457829266786575,
0.43362298607826233,
-0.24472586810588837,
-0.025871839374303818,
-0.17750632762908936,
0.1040981113910675,
-0.48299047350883484,
-0.7148911952972412,
0.5445498824119568,
0.15534748136997223,
-0.32078349590301514,
-0.3372586667537689,
0.519196629524231,
-0.7984465956687927,
-0.4131561815738678,
0.5781626105308533,
0.6081685423851013,
0.8722008466720581,
-0.22394214570522308,
-0.4730401039123535,
-0.03590702265501022,
0.20906996726989746,
-0.24787023663520813,
0.3452225923538208,
0.12808442115783691,
-0.3363737463951111,
0.7065967321395874,
1.1061420440673828,
0.4649067521095276,
0.24080878496170044,
0.3239676356315613,
0.5057148337364197,
-0.4926186800003052,
-0.4961547255516052,
-0.6060847640037537,
0.19887524843215942,
-0.19935892522335052,
-0.03685282915830612,
0.39334845542907715,
0.9134275913238525,
1.1693834066390991,
0.29653820395469666,
0.8469401001930237,
0.25394830107688904,
0.7601638436317444,
-0.44881072640419006,
0.562778890132904,
-0.3344109356403351,
0.33247700333595276,
0.22894825041294098,
-0.8746946454048157,
-0.4352187514305115,
0.6767707467079163,
-0.1804700493812561,
-0.200599804520607,
0.6295187473297119,
0.8440409898757935,
-0.08940774947404861,
0.10870680212974548,
0.9766082763671875,
0.27287447452545166,
0.4560987055301666,
0.4483281672000885,
0.47059309482574463,
-0.6764445900917053,
1.0625742673873901,
-0.24831721186637878,
-0.127179816365242,
0.0034502679482102394,
-0.5261803865432739,
-0.7383484840393066,
-0.5861250162124634,
-0.4267440438270569,
-0.388232558965683,
0.3154645562171936,
0.6861311197280884,
1.062207818031311,
-0.9962700605392456,
-0.45872437953948975,
0.058019474148750305,
0.06661787629127502,
-0.5752081871032715,
-0.023905610665678978,
0.4465872347354889,
-0.5852160453796387,
-1.2507638931274414,
0.8332673907279968,
0.012662394903600216,
-0.4241465926170349,
0.13241083920001984,
0.028878364711999893,
0.02520517259836197,
-0.008354557678103447,
0.7638429999351501,
0.031567737460136414,
-0.4126936197280884,
-0.17319554090499878,
-0.09622450172901154,
0.036775536835193634,
0.20566101372241974,
0.5784682035446167,
-0.5987117290496826,
0.6559369564056396,
0.34562036395072937,
0.5730926990509033,
1.0208042860031128,
-0.18161411583423615,
0.48307493329048157,
-0.7316466569900513,
-0.04953695088624954,
-0.030473073944449425,
0.6277892589569092,
0.4535878002643585,
-0.310797780752182,
0.6625643372535706,
0.04375632107257843,
-0.64973384141922,
-0.9592317938804626,
0.11037272959947586,
-0.9708941578865051,
-0.35783687233924866,
1.038892388343811,
-0.10998166352510452,
-0.22816698253154755,
-0.43722060322761536,
-0.1962803155183792,
0.5969979763031006,
-0.5189507007598877,
0.559447169303894,
0.8715906143188477,
0.10996510088443756,
-0.09619700163602829,
-1.0439271926879883,
0.34835609793663025,
0.6031032204627991,
-0.4634326696395874,
0.13984325528144836,
0.4632169008255005,
0.25479379296302795,
0.03383878245949745,
0.3387882709503174,
-0.19131417572498322,
0.14883047342300415,
-0.24844220280647278,
-0.09908080101013184,
-0.1403495818376541,
-0.32854345440864563,
-0.4692099392414093,
0.23073357343673706,
-0.1211303323507309,
-0.36122581362724304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01939v1 | A Morphologically-Aware Dictionary-based Data Augmentation Technique for Machine Translation of Under-Represented Languages | 2024-02-02T22:25:44 | 2024-02-02T22:25:44 | Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Sina Ahmadi, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | The availability of parallel texts is crucial to the performance of machine
translation models. However, most of the world's languages face the predominant
challenge of data scarcity. In this paper, we propose strategies to synthesize
parallel data relying on morpho-syntactic information and using bilingual
lexicons along with a small amount of seed parallel data. Our methodology
adheres to a realistic scenario backed by the small parallel seed data. It is
linguistically informed, as it aims to create augmented data that is more
likely to be grammatically correct. We analyze how our synthetic data can be
combined with raw parallel data and demonstrate a consistent improvement in
performance in our experiments on 14 languages (28 English <-> X pairs) ranging
from well- to very low-resource ones. Our method leads to improvements even
when using only five seed sentences and a bilingual lexicon. | [
-0.44768083095550537,
-0.5118281841278076,
0.4764499068260193,
0.4229694902896881,
-0.27367424964904785,
0.1473926156759262,
-0.24401287734508514,
-0.334423303604126,
0.651853621006012,
0.42247238755226135,
-0.5154750943183899,
-0.39402681589126587,
-0.42622336745262146,
0.5082996487617493,
-0.5274336338043213,
0.6086519360542297,
-0.10677067190408707,
0.07840342074632645,
-0.34156033396720886,
-0.13721437752246857,
-0.27493375539779663,
-0.6659438610076904,
0.0476224310696125,
-0.054498810321092606,
0.2257901281118393,
0.3978998064994812,
1.019165277481079,
1.340711236000061,
0.32589632272720337,
0.3591917157173157,
-0.15881137549877167,
0.7386292815208435,
-0.19851337373256683,
0.09600883722305298,
-0.21477676928043365,
-0.5611637830734253,
-0.5192148089408875,
-0.44482579827308655,
0.8315533399581909,
1.0424816608428955,
0.23097528517246246,
-0.13600248098373413,
0.06099934130907059,
0.6737017035484314,
-0.4247579276561737,
0.3178798258304596,
-0.9253455400466919,
0.029333239421248436,
-0.7903622388839722,
0.09135966747999191,
0.026645032688975334,
0.06523439288139343,
-0.2501760721206665,
-0.9184429049491882,
0.430193156003952,
-0.04872027412056923,
0.3835937976837158,
0.22570547461509705,
0.009284536354243755,
-0.13395683467388153,
-0.3959804177284241,
0.7195910811424255,
-0.5170129537582397,
0.4236733913421631,
0.29628920555114746,
0.2035474181175232,
-0.2651008665561676,
-0.4743231236934662,
-0.6551769971847534,
0.1407392919063568,
-0.26247045397758484,
0.12441247701644897,
0.1592104285955429,
-0.08195383101701736,
0.2065007984638214,
0.6425520777702332,
-0.43951818346977234,
0.11317708343267441,
-0.33800196647644043,
-0.12328736484050751,
0.4193635880947113,
0.3166291415691376,
0.5501447916030884,
-0.3950707018375397,
-0.06316594034433365,
-0.24529369175434113,
-0.8301087021827698,
-0.35857728123664856,
0.4196833372116089,
0.757872998714447,
-0.14606644213199615,
0.9521397948265076,
-0.30071449279785156,
0.5951803922653198,
-0.0711662620306015,
0.1079106479883194,
0.7103078961372375,
-0.8090127110481262,
-0.03237853944301605,
0.07532418519258499,
0.8238992094993591,
0.2920822203159332,
0.2570832073688507,
-0.19246400892734528,
-0.45808547735214233,
0.24679848551750183,
-0.004208935424685478,
-0.5824621915817261,
-0.1072804257273674,
0.24698559939861298,
-0.10647182166576385,
-0.184791699051857,
-0.12324471026659012,
-0.8994812369346619,
-0.3660610318183899,
-0.2278161197900772,
0.16368471086025238,
-0.5672100186347961,
-0.06099449470639229,
-0.03138969466090202,
-0.12915240228176117,
-0.7436483502388,
-0.004224228672683239,
-1.054200291633606,
0.354510098695755,
0.60321044921875,
1.0975453853607178,
-0.08556004613637924,
-0.3233969211578369,
-0.32889291644096375,
0.2503346800804138,
-0.6018902063369751,
0.506230890750885,
-0.41405075788497925,
-0.549721896648407,
-0.11359657347202301,
-0.0868958905339241,
-0.03806331381201744,
-0.871347188949585,
0.48696017265319824,
0.10403861105442047,
-0.07861621677875519,
-0.299471914768219,
-0.46119609475135803,
0.19033585488796234,
0.06676504015922546,
-0.781879723072052,
0.9151344299316406,
0.08534236252307892,
-0.8365018963813782,
0.24117614328861237,
-0.3771795928478241,
-0.5673004388809204,
0.07502015680074692,
-0.3348689675331116,
-0.10155948251485825,
0.2718104124069214,
0.839325487613678,
0.2953075170516968,
-0.2874434292316437,
0.19078490138053894,
-0.1262422353029251,
-0.11555562168359756,
-0.026487523689866066,
-0.29006239771842957,
0.4434957206249237,
0.19086161255836487,
0.15867047011852264,
-0.2556718587875366,
-0.8542466759681702,
-0.15455953776836395,
0.016008811071515083,
-0.17907768487930298,
-0.7124220728874207,
0.17113211750984192,
-0.01591559126973152,
0.08875861018896103,
0.2973446846008301,
-0.8100280165672302,
0.32664623856544495,
-1.036658763885498,
0.27876996994018555,
0.504093587398529,
-0.3150506019592285,
0.6042450070381165,
-0.4354824423789978,
0.07917312532663345,
0.2491179257631302,
-0.1089833676815033,
-0.2779214680194855,
-0.650536060333252,
-0.8460516333580017,
-0.5380818843841553,
0.36538463830947876,
0.6683149337768555,
-1.2017734050750732,
0.2547668218612671,
-0.6287155151367188,
-0.2548263370990753,
-0.9275104999542236,
0.3709560036659241,
0.22494080662727356,
0.5071260333061218,
0.5637782216072083,
-0.3013770282268524,
-0.946413516998291,
-0.9004338979721069,
-0.1618364453315735,
-0.047839902341365814,
-0.0343904085457325,
0.18978247046470642,
0.17436031997203827,
-0.48879915475845337,
0.8074246644973755,
-0.24315661191940308,
-0.3636671006679535,
-0.15448442101478577,
0.09147290140390396,
0.5111656188964844,
0.7187012434005737,
0.5226643085479736,
-0.6626757979393005,
-0.5189564824104309,
0.4219200909137726,
-0.6599089503288269,
-0.32038047909736633,
-0.09194919466972351,
0.0510883629322052,
0.2092045694589615,
0.20362059772014618,
-0.7126287221908569,
0.06963429600000381,
0.5141761302947998,
0.17641447484493256,
0.050260137766599655,
-0.5977150797843933,
0.2395937293767929,
-1.1326818466186523,
-0.19883814454078674,
-0.15969683229923248,
-0.22946015000343323,
-0.7304247617721558,
0.05963101238012314,
0.3148442506790161,
-0.07531177252531052,
-0.44758346676826477,
0.5453587770462036,
-0.3896062672138214,
0.09487185627222061,
-0.22101186215877533,
-0.21948188543319702,
-0.3911641240119934,
0.07143354415893555,
0.13095055520534515,
0.9747613668441772,
0.6299200654029846,
-0.31795570254325867,
0.32274186611175537,
0.3004636764526367,
-0.39693379402160645,
0.07728826999664307,
-0.429849773645401,
-0.09610714018344879,
-0.3049948215484619,
-0.015167967416346073,
-0.4913350045681,
-0.5576469898223877,
0.24314363300800323,
-0.38401657342910767,
0.09501457214355469,
-0.20941990613937378,
-0.8519832491874695,
-0.2798599600791931,
0.011375649832189083,
0.634740948677063,
0.7059677243232727,
-0.5778050422668457,
0.2630803883075714,
0.5082256197929382,
-0.3358845114707947,
-0.19088837504386902,
-0.907494843006134,
0.1370513141155243,
-0.009605598635971546,
-0.7283220291137695,
0.5846677422523499,
0.19259555637836456,
-0.3248470425605774,
-0.025950396433472633,
-0.012247170321643353,
-0.1997862607240677,
-0.23316524922847748,
0.1881752461194992,
0.07608399540185928,
0.13384516537189484,
0.2100469470024109,
0.4345738887786865,
-0.08759742975234985,
-0.1908985823392868,
-0.4301922619342804,
0.46623456478118896,
0.24064747989177704,
-0.22562816739082336,
-0.10747936367988586,
0.5138483643531799,
0.587485134601593,
0.027447309345006943,
0.604123592376709,
0.1512686014175415,
-0.6494836211204529,
-0.179534450173378,
-0.2318088710308075,
-0.010482288897037506,
-0.41441625356674194,
0.10683872550725937,
-0.667074978351593,
-0.3472822904586792,
0.4770541489124298,
0.15429313480854034,
-0.040588147938251495,
0.48066458106040955,
0.7346792817115784,
-0.14961369335651398,
1.2745559215545654,
0.35704305768013,
-0.11637718975543976,
0.12083607912063599,
-0.07129554450511932,
-0.04184141755104065,
-0.34736257791519165,
-0.20636749267578125,
-0.36439189314842224,
-0.08362821489572525,
-0.7691901922225952,
-0.9101805686950684,
0.5599361062049866,
0.10843902081251144,
0.40651658177375793,
0.5181620121002197,
-0.29167646169662476,
0.2541431188583374,
0.5953091382980347,
0.207656130194664,
0.26937440037727356,
0.24484053254127502,
-0.38588833808898926,
-0.27198365330696106,
-0.8192169070243835,
-0.1591208428144455,
1.2051464319229126,
0.051969531923532486,
0.5211254954338074,
-0.1068466380238533,
0.9329268932342529,
0.06995368003845215,
-0.10566506534814835,
-0.3981921970844269,
0.34659725427627563,
-0.6133180260658264,
-0.29433420300483704,
-0.04532778263092041,
-0.5173115134239197,
-0.7993164658546448,
0.3692138195037842,
-0.3631012439727783,
-0.14719684422016144,
0.24149811267852783,
0.33450624346733093,
-0.052795782685279846,
0.1300855129957199,
-0.7050132751464844,
0.5111263394355774,
-0.2077891230583191,
-0.03350001573562622,
-0.33096250891685486,
-0.3978902995586395,
0.13418297469615936,
-0.6162795424461365,
0.5814219117164612,
-0.03484097123146057,
-0.2861321270465851,
0.4281182885169983,
-1.069366455078125,
0.5393972992897034,
0.03793773800134659,
0.19468778371810913,
0.09721203148365021,
-0.05314527079463005,
0.719394326210022,
0.008363931439816952,
-0.01668265275657177,
0.32770460844039917,
-0.15684513747692108,
-0.5161650776863098,
-0.6617674827575684,
0.8763110041618347,
-0.5574010610580444,
-0.6326848268508911,
-0.14199115335941315,
-1.1489619016647339,
-0.43952053785324097,
0.05948713794350624,
0.10256978124380112,
0.08738651126623154,
0.22681358456611633,
0.028134139254689217,
0.2896546721458435,
-0.11833606660366058,
0.22366827726364136,
-0.0011808788403868675,
-0.22188620269298553,
-0.6612332463264465,
1.0678491592407227,
0.44244882464408875,
0.1548967957496643,
0.4410689175128937,
0.2273527979850769,
-0.18411371111869812,
-0.5897918343544006,
-0.9267854690551758,
0.2061375379562378,
-0.23184162378311157,
-0.021622752770781517,
-0.6754453778266907,
-0.030654441565275192,
-0.5410970449447632,
-0.031307000666856766,
-0.46666812896728516,
-0.8940041661262512,
-0.011693903245031834,
0.057260677218437195,
0.42052334547042847,
0.40587136149406433,
-0.49160248041152954,
0.19884540140628815,
-1.0215457677841187,
0.5667370557785034,
-0.020764248445630074,
-0.06148994341492653,
-0.40990981459617615,
-0.11550486087799072,
-0.1959499716758728,
0.4710320234298706,
0.2547534108161926,
-0.7885670065879822,
0.7530126571655273,
0.14528606832027435,
0.5219786167144775,
0.0033220115583389997,
-0.17773030698299408,
1.0038878917694092,
-0.8429195284843445,
0.5219518542289734,
0.17815010249614716,
-0.8223766684532166,
0.6100648045539856,
-0.4337681531906128,
0.1714167445898056,
0.26044195890426636,
0.2895037829875946,
-0.3036166727542877,
-0.6504164934158325,
-0.49443480372428894,
-0.9621813893318176,
0.5706791877746582,
0.6919371485710144,
0.18921571969985962,
-0.21836577355861664,
-0.04576548933982849,
0.3468370735645294,
0.26836833357810974,
-0.1541653722524643,
-0.3269319534301758,
-0.21800658106803894,
-0.5493139624595642,
-0.15606561303138733,
-0.12746445834636688,
0.10454858094453812,
-0.40618696808815,
0.5461150407791138,
0.02954396791756153,
-0.1917705088853836,
0.10384207963943481,
-0.21661198139190674,
0.028700735419988632,
0.009111798368394375,
0.21391423046588898,
0.37061792612075806,
-0.1581454575061798,
0.15284192562103271,
0.08612436056137085,
-0.48216313123703003,
0.06646831333637238,
0.40227144956588745,
-0.4376051723957062,
0.5207810997962952,
0.06711920350790024,
0.5705392956733704,
-0.09727605432271957,
-0.815389096736908,
0.190489262342453,
0.49960416555404663,
0.1480870395898819,
0.21995984017848969,
-0.304399698972702,
-0.05962570384144783,
0.19396176934242249,
0.21573694050312042,
0.29469016194343567,
0.12851335108280182,
-0.3812861740589142,
0.33666473627090454,
0.32059088349342346,
0.2017555981874466,
-0.2979505956172943,
0.5391948223114014,
0.2979416847229004,
-0.002743588062003255,
0.5017962455749512,
0.026206007227301598,
-0.3694300353527069,
0.47603535652160645,
0.5918140411376953,
0.5146265625953674,
-0.11090608686208725,
0.08045946806669235,
0.35087090730667114,
0.2731247842311859,
-0.2380935400724411,
0.3657767176628113,
-0.2242247611284256,
-0.5974597334861755,
-0.4269946813583374,
-0.6107174754142761,
-0.13719038665294647,
-0.10800273716449738,
-0.3003329932689667,
0.2311886101961136,
-0.19211620092391968,
-0.03454090654850006,
0.009368943981826305,
-0.31517550349235535,
-0.45890843868255615,
0.16020801663398743,
0.15247376263141632,
0.8793937563896179,
-0.9051231741905212,
0.9837731719017029,
0.7448295950889587,
-0.32066234946250916,
-0.32983750104904175,
-0.25700196623802185,
-0.0638074278831482,
-1.0803420543670654,
0.6552464365959167,
-0.06456410884857178,
0.2804584503173828,
-0.049293339252471924,
0.03596172481775284,
-0.8712460994720459,
0.47469663619995117,
0.5347278714179993,
-0.7241649031639099,
-0.03539469838142395,
0.8287951350212097,
0.6508063077926636,
-0.10282038897275925,
-0.06862781941890717,
0.36935460567474365,
0.4159725308418274,
0.018400277942419052,
-1.095108985900879,
-0.1732952892780304,
-0.3528043329715729,
0.2813654839992523,
0.3751722574234009,
-0.08284447342157364,
1.0404177904129028,
0.05034809187054634,
-0.5436835885047913,
0.36980196833610535,
0.6561367511749268,
0.23498262465000153,
-0.039464954286813736,
0.4252995550632477,
0.8237704038619995,
0.5438957214355469,
-0.16074985265731812,
1.0877050161361694,
-0.5226132273674011,
0.1739380657672882,
0.7871799468994141,
0.13670584559440613,
0.5674150586128235,
0.9236947894096375,
-0.0583668053150177,
0.019576197490096092,
0.5392199754714966,
0.19207417964935303,
0.6185278296470642,
0.03452323377132416,
-0.21432052552700043,
-0.31853196024894714,
-0.409822553396225,
-0.41695716977119446,
0.14553716778755188,
0.6264883279800415,
-0.49695533514022827,
-0.43265166878700256,
0.09560917317867279,
-0.13534829020500183,
0.44589027762413025,
-0.5374562740325928,
0.45034366846084595,
-0.04367132484912872,
-0.4780937731266022,
0.7636317610740662,
0.12079361826181412,
0.6465405225753784,
-0.2393561750650406,
-0.05808917060494423,
-0.5229203104972839,
0.19130460917949677,
-0.18745280802249908,
-0.9013426303863525,
0.4282520115375519,
0.25285783410072327,
-0.36734941601753235,
-0.4650106728076935,
0.45705410838127136,
-0.722018837928772,
-0.8285088539123535,
-0.019298819825053215,
0.7063843011856079,
0.3503322899341583,
-0.08161324262619019,
-0.40674689412117004,
0.005629486870020628,
-0.19808915257453918,
0.4943051338195801,
0.26764023303985596,
0.48348867893218994,
-0.4524366557598114,
0.5791868567466736,
0.7179477214813232,
0.664853572845459,
0.470302015542984,
0.04472650960087776,
0.815360963344574,
-0.25294655561447144,
-0.4380016624927521,
-0.7750589847564697,
0.441668838262558,
-0.11490762233734131,
0.04302207753062248,
0.9054528474807739,
0.7272790670394897,
1.2035908699035645,
-0.19711479544639587,
0.9149123430252075,
-0.11620872467756271,
0.7054582834243774,
-0.5518910884857178,
0.49868640303611755,
-0.5364186763763428,
0.1398114114999771,
-0.08375804126262665,
-0.8205365538597107,
-0.3366979956626892,
0.12929369509220123,
-0.025369908660650253,
-0.5201133489608765,
0.3451544940471649,
0.9704763889312744,
-0.35163477063179016,
-0.26062336564064026,
0.40792593359947205,
0.11822512745857239,
-0.127073734998703,
0.5639252066612244,
0.532040536403656,
-0.5609032511711121,
0.4088214933872223,
-0.7536519765853882,
-0.04524606838822365,
0.1474533975124359,
-0.4314655661582947,
-0.6127480268478394,
-0.7117303609848022,
0.09710077941417694,
-0.11355168372392654,
0.29999810457229614,
0.879455029964447,
0.4291432797908783,
-0.9197095036506653,
-0.20646004378795624,
-0.5132238268852234,
0.09141215682029724,
-0.12071706354618073,
-0.11601341515779495,
0.19369307160377502,
-0.6599560976028442,
-1.2888355255126953,
0.78546541929245,
0.3290688991546631,
0.28518545627593994,
0.015525858849287033,
-0.008131077513098717,
0.028110478073358536,
-0.03516917675733566,
0.39022013545036316,
0.21543268859386444,
-0.6722087264060974,
-0.007747493218630552,
-0.1360570639371872,
-0.17880991101264954,
0.08780789375305176,
0.8170385956764221,
-1.0508347749710083,
0.9310856461524963,
0.8533319234848022,
1.0122348070144653,
0.18746672570705414,
0.27039849758148193,
0.8211866021156311,
-1.0463474988937378,
0.6205466389656067,
0.05726469308137894,
0.5056983828544617,
0.41801372170448303,
-0.25650152564048767,
0.32894885540008545,
0.7389856576919556,
0.09640104323625565,
-0.8737460374832153,
-0.0019110545981675386,
-0.6329315900802612,
-0.2128109633922577,
0.9902345538139343,
0.07428071647882462,
-0.24916626513004303,
0.1275317519903183,
-0.006036512088030577,
0.14801809191703796,
-0.16506287455558777,
0.6579415798187256,
0.4149913787841797,
0.10797502845525742,
0.0641714334487915,
-0.2224811166524887,
0.43123170733451843,
0.5077084302902222,
-0.7238829135894775,
-0.0665593147277832,
0.615421712398529,
-0.11851816624403,
0.32369181513786316,
0.33393752574920654,
-0.14737899601459503,
0.051745738834142685,
0.2529159486293793,
-0.2335115522146225,
-0.19650550186634064,
-0.44260022044181824,
-0.12938982248306274,
0.03465373441576958,
-0.323587030172348,
-0.440250039100647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01935v1 | Code Representation Learning At Scale | 2024-02-02T22:19:15 | 2024-02-02T22:19:15 | Dejiao Zhang, Wasi Ahmad, Ming Tan, Hantian Ding, Ramesh Nallapati, Dan Roth, Xiaofei Ma, Bing Xiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have shown that code language models at scale demonstrate
significant performance gains on downstream tasks, i.e., code generation.
However, most of the existing works on code representation learning train
models at a hundred million parameter scale using very limited pretraining
corpora. In this work, we fuel code representation learning with a vast amount
of code data via a two-stage pretraining scheme. We first train the encoders
via a mix that leverages both randomness in masking language modeling and the
structure aspect of programming language. We then enhance the representations
via contrastive learning with hard negative and hard positive constructed in an
unsupervised manner. We establish an off-the-shelf encoder model that
persistently outperforms the existing models on a wide variety of downstream
tasks by large margins. To comprehend the factors contributing to successful
code representation learning, we conduct detailed ablations and share our
findings on (i) a customized and effective token-level denoising scheme for
source code; (ii) the importance of hard negatives and hard positives; (iii)
how the proposed bimodal contrastive learning boost the cross-lingual semantic
search performance; and (iv) how the pretraining schemes decide the downstream
task performance scales with the model size. | [
-0.5408903956413269,
-0.10911467671394348,
0.1229228749871254,
0.19579879939556122,
-0.3991798162460327,
0.27423956990242004,
-0.4140787124633789,
-0.36199575662612915,
0.16605287790298462,
0.4381633400917053,
-0.13430561125278473,
-0.4840150475502014,
-0.7470300197601318,
0.05439595505595207,
-0.09958691149950027,
0.9161216616630554,
0.09337212890386581,
0.37704363465309143,
-0.01751980371773243,
-0.06356620788574219,
-0.47559940814971924,
-0.5763694643974304,
-0.557461678981781,
-0.4614267349243164,
0.5138087868690491,
0.412670761346817,
0.47184643149375916,
0.7288492918014526,
0.41321510076522827,
0.2159014791250229,
0.11930758506059647,
-0.1279633790254593,
-0.7400599718093872,
-0.04660487920045853,
0.004401525482535362,
-0.5904015302658081,
0.16915181279182434,
0.0012410382041707635,
0.41939517855644226,
0.7712151408195496,
-0.20038242638111115,
0.012602114118635654,
-0.003434198210015893,
0.5756615400314331,
-0.4427010118961334,
0.3260399103164673,
-0.6279082298278809,
0.11178398132324219,
-0.03393825143575668,
-0.1693653166294098,
-0.5377588272094727,
-0.17480464279651642,
-0.3420116603374481,
-0.43753159046173096,
0.09323684871196747,
-0.030451450496912003,
0.6319804787635803,
0.28653961420059204,
-0.4703054130077362,
-0.4725084602832794,
-0.7185324430465698,
0.7185466289520264,
-0.5192668437957764,
0.4456672966480255,
0.18710727989673615,
0.20495611429214478,
0.28671321272850037,
-0.7811934947967529,
-0.21784989535808563,
-0.21629950404167175,
-0.12230721861124039,
-0.10154338926076889,
-0.05625823885202408,
0.15790212154388428,
0.46525242924690247,
0.5545307993888855,
-0.5895363092422485,
0.21188847720623016,
-0.7031965255737305,
-0.2222493439912796,
0.3313003480434418,
-0.17833860218524933,
0.20059366524219513,
0.01852763071656227,
-0.2816391587257385,
-0.4136883616447449,
-0.7602183818817139,
-0.09118060767650604,
0.24009400606155396,
0.26549646258354187,
-0.1517328917980194,
0.3310335874557495,
0.004467170685529709,
0.564165472984314,
0.11242485046386719,
0.26326367259025574,
0.32889220118522644,
-0.19998233020305634,
-0.07278487831354141,
-0.09157583862543106,
0.4331623315811157,
0.007326482329517603,
0.1908242106437683,
-0.26528751850128174,
-0.3795429468154907,
0.2700246572494507,
0.7348239421844482,
-1.2173806428909302,
-0.40155643224716187,
0.11217246949672699,
-0.5710405707359314,
-0.1103779524564743,
0.08101870864629745,
-0.5224047899246216,
-0.5026683807373047,
-0.6363659501075745,
0.47766822576522827,
-0.3271431028842926,
-0.48515743017196655,
0.11774829030036926,
-0.10054813325405121,
0.36717110872268677,
0.0350809283554554,
-0.8296096324920654,
0.18901805579662323,
0.32424014806747437,
0.4953314960002899,
0.197389617562294,
-0.02575109712779522,
-0.5561047196388245,
-0.1826048493385315,
-0.6999238729476929,
0.4164165258407593,
-0.8271309733390808,
-0.3176010847091675,
-0.011011343449354172,
-0.2521154582500458,
0.16935373842716217,
-0.7905911207199097,
-0.09660889208316803,
-0.8978127837181091,
-0.2174849957227707,
-0.04180851951241493,
-0.4579505920410156,
-0.16683898866176605,
0.09334162622690201,
-0.6811420321464539,
0.6961087584495544,
0.4922294616699219,
-0.5943099856376648,
0.45520758628845215,
-0.4256019592285156,
-0.42672863602638245,
0.1096484363079071,
-0.51910400390625,
-0.37063318490982056,
0.452946275472641,
0.08780942857265472,
0.5118313431739807,
-0.07392528653144836,
-0.009201085194945335,
-0.0025213086046278477,
-0.6617701053619385,
-0.03456030413508415,
0.014607300981879234,
0.5866497159004211,
0.4654709994792938,
-0.40949562191963196,
0.11169122159481049,
-0.8269882798194885,
-0.06258954107761383,
0.027235526591539383,
-0.4275813400745392,
-0.3209991455078125,
-0.34404876828193665,
0.015522048808634281,
0.3600413501262665,
0.29903534054756165,
-0.48034995794296265,
0.1588134765625,
-0.22877082228660583,
0.4180646240711212,
0.2815222144126892,
0.00012368820898700505,
0.6291460990905762,
0.13332553207874298,
0.6715640425682068,
0.30759134888648987,
-0.1488163024187088,
-0.34835970401763916,
-0.09167531132698059,
-0.5767818093299866,
-0.1095823124051094,
0.3532314598560333,
0.15330396592617035,
-0.8759649991989136,
0.261756032705307,
-0.08461780846118927,
-0.4900948405265808,
-0.4257277250289917,
0.40818503499031067,
0.6481455564498901,
0.05774242803454399,
0.5060283541679382,
-0.5026628375053406,
-0.6748644113540649,
-0.7267149090766907,
0.03037611022591591,
-0.10937032848596573,
-0.3802368938922882,
-0.011990510858595371,
0.492073655128479,
-0.4972269535064697,
0.6673656105995178,
-0.6040919423103333,
-0.12365631014108658,
-0.3954618573188782,
0.5600512623786926,
0.19657579064369202,
0.8073945641517639,
0.2727952003479004,
-1.0349944829940796,
-0.3090684413909912,
-0.0053814793936908245,
-0.38573935627937317,
0.06666389107704163,
-0.2049649953842163,
0.06377483159303665,
0.07197277247905731,
1.0924489498138428,
-0.06705603003501892,
0.1129305437207222,
0.738532543182373,
-0.19250603020191193,
0.33815544843673706,
-0.5440922975540161,
0.020711610093712807,
-0.9264892339706421,
0.09541202336549759,
-0.017620429396629333,
-0.14460620284080505,
-0.5472434759140015,
0.41963234543800354,
0.47596386075019836,
-0.5005550980567932,
-0.2546103000640869,
0.045151736587285995,
-0.6833506226539612,
-0.14423073828220367,
-0.1961769312620163,
-0.2523767948150635,
-0.07238231599330902,
0.8144149780273438,
0.2482326775789261,
0.7417603135108948,
0.5457637310028076,
-0.5015339851379395,
-0.02064310386776924,
-0.19664356112480164,
-0.2517007887363434,
0.11131555587053299,
-0.7223363518714905,
0.22728578746318817,
-0.24480299651622772,
0.17603783309459686,
-1.1573338508605957,
-0.14295953512191772,
-0.2821252942085266,
-0.4235319495201111,
0.7321853637695312,
-0.39123594760894775,
-0.535625696182251,
-0.27445900440216064,
-0.0948132649064064,
0.5848135948181152,
0.7664374113082886,
-0.5582460761070251,
0.33321505784988403,
0.37497466802597046,
0.0946323573589325,
-0.1404031366109848,
-0.6900334358215332,
-0.05924815312027931,
-0.027257926762104034,
-0.17357388138771057,
0.3272401690483093,
0.06727764755487442,
0.014695125631988049,
-0.21440674364566803,
-0.26124414801597595,
-0.2041110247373581,
-0.04044923558831215,
0.30624932050704956,
0.07929795235395432,
-0.2229575216770172,
0.24627499282360077,
-0.1182582899928093,
-0.25409364700317383,
0.0861678496003151,
-0.3821956515312195,
0.776965320110321,
-0.15574413537979126,
-0.281685471534729,
0.2760980725288391,
0.30272525548934937,
0.49275854229927063,
-0.5552180409431458,
0.745701253414154,
0.7536700963973999,
-0.3810964822769165,
-0.33659717440605164,
-0.29646775126457214,
-0.17204976081848145,
-0.4616223871707916,
0.6063969731330872,
-0.1824149340391159,
-0.9221127033233643,
0.6106709837913513,
-0.2393103390932083,
0.03626434877514839,
0.17414169013500214,
0.4047980308532715,
0.15034428238868713,
1.0145784616470337,
0.9707578420639038,
-0.054601963609457016,
0.6526418924331665,
-0.5277988314628601,
0.3032896816730499,
-0.5724788308143616,
-0.28907352685928345,
-0.6664131283760071,
-0.20832093060016632,
-0.6320752501487732,
-0.9319626688957214,
0.2608805298805237,
0.6146895289421082,
-0.5845789313316345,
0.5791884064674377,
-0.5563772916793823,
0.6838715076446533,
0.3964177668094635,
0.26972004771232605,
0.07244891673326492,
0.1878552883863449,
0.007856619544327259,
0.02284403331577778,
-0.5538226962089539,
-0.27394649386405945,
1.0517388582229614,
0.49332189559936523,
0.9067364931106567,
-0.11824806779623032,
1.0036979913711548,
0.18013978004455566,
0.39470162987709045,
-0.4361061155796051,
0.1437285840511322,
-0.3677796423435211,
-0.4703421890735626,
-0.274752676486969,
-0.6477767825126648,
-0.6499702334403992,
0.26524338126182556,
-0.05207495763897896,
-0.23019754886627197,
0.3755350410938263,
0.048179540783166885,
-0.2795448899269104,
0.14528587460517883,
-0.9440542459487915,
0.99722820520401,
0.060022249817848206,
-0.15320542454719543,
-0.4670087695121765,
-0.7318223118782043,
0.04111383855342865,
-0.14582973718643188,
0.29388320446014404,
0.5003319382667542,
-0.2370220571756363,
0.5964756608009338,
-0.27381470799446106,
0.9122586250305176,
-0.37752220034599304,
-0.2356594055891037,
0.1824941337108612,
0.2241068184375763,
0.48703503608703613,
0.11067982763051987,
-0.07160916179418564,
0.2966017425060272,
-0.3593238890171051,
-0.6633582711219788,
-0.4844033122062683,
0.36949801445007324,
-0.817147970199585,
-0.23525041341781616,
0.04720773175358772,
-0.3620087504386902,
-0.18163563311100006,
0.2765435576438904,
0.38317906856536865,
0.7894729375839233,
0.11400298029184341,
0.46561354398727417,
0.8099809288978577,
-0.40551310777664185,
0.2509334087371826,
0.1544170379638672,
-0.24797244369983673,
-0.26466500759124756,
1.1275367736816406,
-0.05997147411108017,
0.3159911036491394,
0.6288317441940308,
-0.1559857875108719,
-0.20190012454986572,
-0.8025457262992859,
-0.4857215881347656,
0.12001882493495941,
-0.861171305179596,
-0.2167922407388687,
-0.48002445697784424,
-0.254448264837265,
-0.2510356903076172,
-0.37029558420181274,
-0.38943591713905334,
-0.05963629484176636,
-0.2946069538593292,
-0.09845452010631561,
0.05178983509540558,
0.9169893264770508,
-0.04341530427336693,
0.16856595873832703,
-0.6503982543945312,
0.3656251132488251,
0.1974998414516449,
0.5697567462921143,
0.07998474687337875,
-0.4325703978538513,
-0.7403632998466492,
-0.03914441913366318,
-0.08789560943841934,
-0.46789124608039856,
0.33251118659973145,
-0.08400166034698486,
0.39197975397109985,
0.4107729196548462,
0.01883244328200817,
0.6638107299804688,
-0.36657461524009705,
0.6687656044960022,
0.48907649517059326,
-0.7683877348899841,
0.33492833375930786,
-0.09191799908876419,
0.5065786242485046,
0.6776779294013977,
0.575836718082428,
-0.34156185388565063,
-0.45416325330734253,
-0.24777500331401825,
-0.7158426642417908,
0.6060837507247925,
0.06079155579209328,
0.3307826817035675,
-0.11922606825828552,
0.29506367444992065,
0.1822437345981598,
0.2505132853984833,
-0.9411498308181763,
-0.004527039360255003,
-0.5482182502746582,
-0.14647507667541504,
-0.37012749910354614,
-0.17615139484405518,
0.14294974505901337,
-0.2211032211780548,
0.23292489349842072,
-0.22540488839149475,
0.33562925457954407,
-0.01974005065858364,
-0.377422571182251,
-0.03798004612326622,
0.16823622584342957,
0.35861092805862427,
0.6042045950889587,
-0.09993354231119156,
0.4006158411502838,
-0.18741945922374725,
-0.5257453322410583,
-0.04959866404533386,
-0.048543673008680344,
0.29384952783584595,
-0.21368375420570374,
0.539656937122345,
0.6458266973495483,
0.34827131032943726,
-0.7602230906486511,
0.5178728699684143,
0.028786711394786835,
-0.09712546318769455,
0.037243619561195374,
-0.01919839344918728,
0.2810403108596802,
0.13394303619861603,
0.5041166543960571,
0.24200676381587982,
0.006630068179219961,
-0.6453810930252075,
0.2944927513599396,
0.1129751205444336,
-0.3890424966812134,
-0.23030146956443787,
0.5506640672683716,
0.22192588448524475,
0.059557776898145676,
0.6537234783172607,
-0.4906977713108063,
-0.6590368151664734,
0.8555343747138977,
0.5274832248687744,
0.5516479015350342,
-0.062297843396663666,
0.2611861228942871,
0.5392879843711853,
0.29303526878356934,
-0.05637972429394722,
0.09599801898002625,
-0.38840341567993164,
-0.5145370364189148,
-0.4440321624279022,
-0.822284996509552,
-0.13045097887516022,
-0.07540392875671387,
-0.5983981490135193,
0.2197546809911728,
-0.5702624917030334,
0.3420206904411316,
-0.33971309661865234,
0.3080814778804779,
-0.7408240437507629,
0.23511981964111328,
0.4683258831501007,
0.8983930945396423,
-0.8129230737686157,
0.9103174805641174,
0.7211118936538696,
-0.8096287250518799,
-1.0462234020233154,
-0.019546279683709145,
-0.41985708475112915,
-0.7510819435119629,
0.9007559418678284,
0.3654346168041229,
0.011346711777150631,
0.13282939791679382,
-0.5248537063598633,
-0.7325251698493958,
0.7931489944458008,
0.2907932996749878,
-0.763326108455658,
-0.0790952667593956,
0.05417622998356819,
0.7309789061546326,
-0.6613374352455139,
0.2807009518146515,
0.2423812747001648,
0.04632765054702759,
0.1564844846725464,
-0.45567557215690613,
0.09902233630418777,
-0.2798663377761841,
0.409054696559906,
0.2520871162414551,
-0.23487736284732819,
1.012907862663269,
-0.23805831372737885,
-0.29998886585235596,
-0.27384015917778015,
0.47703811526298523,
0.1772543489933014,
-0.003752546152099967,
0.5520095229148865,
0.3459152281284332,
0.530521810054779,
0.1742849498987198,
1.078553318977356,
-0.5298401117324829,
0.25611817836761475,
0.7858620285987854,
-0.14665965735912323,
0.7928917407989502,
0.4553811550140381,
-0.13469921052455902,
0.7883910536766052,
0.6683929562568665,
0.06202952563762665,
0.609657883644104,
0.6238766312599182,
0.08185000717639923,
-0.39000359177589417,
0.11827647686004639,
-0.45358338952064514,
0.1849232316017151,
0.32864683866500854,
-0.42204979062080383,
-0.30832424759864807,
0.30724555253982544,
-0.2580358684062958,
0.19111359119415283,
-0.5092093348503113,
0.6739630103111267,
0.09405485540628433,
-0.5186847448348999,
0.7228879332542419,
-0.036969639360904694,
0.7791783213615417,
-0.7012354731559753,
-0.2762606739997864,
-0.40223580598831177,
0.15826736390590668,
-0.29952406883239746,
-0.3560013473033905,
0.2669728398323059,
0.0035645971074700356,
-0.22121448814868927,
-0.42255470156669617,
0.5651845932006836,
-0.6284888386726379,
-0.2683625817298889,
0.5785834193229675,
0.09471393376588821,
0.13792352378368378,
-0.17257672548294067,
-0.28215503692626953,
0.28122612833976746,
-0.0044682687148451805,
-0.1204761192202568,
0.5177715420722961,
0.614180862903595,
0.029359860345721245,
0.32087987661361694,
0.434817373752594,
0.14284288883209229,
0.1691572368144989,
0.2619659900665283,
1.0771794319152832,
-0.655756413936615,
-0.665800929069519,
-0.3983769714832306,
0.403987318277359,
-0.022056207060813904,
-0.12574172019958496,
0.4639289081096649,
0.6520675420761108,
1.2146469354629517,
-0.1924731284379959,
0.3880220651626587,
-0.11283697187900543,
0.09007813781499863,
-0.484176903963089,
0.6029937863349915,
-0.5244084000587463,
0.46370944380760193,
-0.10196689516305923,
-1.0147151947021484,
-0.44103628396987915,
0.49953868985176086,
-0.2043420672416687,
0.14024430513381958,
0.5901317596435547,
0.9643977880477905,
-0.05566788464784622,
-0.07123792916536331,
0.5150884985923767,
0.1410660445690155,
0.23178724944591522,
0.6756607890129089,
0.596402108669281,
-0.3384030759334564,
0.7630085349082947,
-0.22155483067035675,
-0.2291257232427597,
-0.26796430349349976,
-0.620896577835083,
-0.8367425203323364,
-0.6743172407150269,
-0.3603128492832184,
-0.2063816338777542,
-0.27126383781433105,
0.9267334938049316,
0.9698810577392578,
-0.6836521625518799,
-0.29203611612319946,
-0.4403080344200134,
0.004138146061450243,
-0.18919917941093445,
-0.12731416523456573,
0.15632034838199615,
-0.7681233882904053,
-0.40664052963256836,
0.15740922093391418,
0.18854162096977234,
-0.24369622766971588,
-0.45702221989631653,
-0.3537040650844574,
0.1964292824268341,
-0.05533868446946144,
0.6400955319404602,
0.22882568836212158,
-0.1795557290315628,
-0.16601651906967163,
-0.16377289593219757,
-0.4503803253173828,
0.1828186959028244,
1.250306487083435,
-0.8985248804092407,
0.3924872875213623,
0.4333963394165039,
0.7841200232505798,
0.6901353597640991,
-0.1953200399875641,
0.4784640371799469,
-0.9981908798217773,
0.10599073022603989,
0.256020188331604,
0.2577393054962158,
0.27361878752708435,
-0.2768704295158386,
0.45353367924690247,
-0.09592875093221664,
-0.34365785121917725,
-0.7067877650260925,
0.25421544909477234,
-0.6816551089286804,
-0.7223613858222961,
1.0309234857559204,
-0.10043571144342422,
0.0195030365139246,
-0.20148229598999023,
-0.16947267949581146,
0.30521151423454285,
-0.23081745207309723,
0.5004767775535583,
0.387673556804657,
0.004423230420798063,
-0.18132136762142181,
-0.2178293764591217,
0.34429508447647095,
0.14899492263793945,
-0.402079701423645,
0.17496487498283386,
0.4618314504623413,
0.24776652455329895,
0.48154783248901367,
0.480640709400177,
-0.48603391647338867,
0.20640724897384644,
0.5023393630981445,
0.37328824400901794,
-0.18860195577144623,
-0.47303760051727295,
-0.7206587791442871,
0.40628623962402344,
0.20272845029830933,
-0.11546525359153748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01931v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01931v1 | Digits micro-model for accurate and secure transactions | 2024-02-02T22:01:27 | 2024-02-02T22:01:27 | Chirag Chhablani, Nikhita Sharma, Jordan Hosier, Vijay K. Gurbani | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems are used in the financial domain
to enhance the caller experience by enabling natural language understanding and
facilitating efficient and intuitive interactions. Increasing use of ASR
systems requires that such systems exhibit very low error rates. The
predominant ASR models to collect numeric data are large, general-purpose
commercial models -- Google Speech-to-text (STT), or Amazon Transcribe -- or
open source (OpenAI's Whisper). Such ASR models are trained on hundreds of
thousands of hours of audio data and require considerable resources to run.
Despite recent progress large speech recognition models, we highlight the
potential of smaller, specialized "micro" models. Such light models can be
trained perform well on number recognition specific tasks, competing with
general models like Whisper or Google STT while using less than 80 minutes of
training time and occupying at least an order of less memory resources. Also,
unlike larger speech recognition models, micro-models are trained on carefully
selected and curated datasets, which makes them highly accurate, agile, and
easy to retrain, while using low compute resources. We present our work on
creating micro models for multi-digit number recognition that handle diverse
speaking styles reflecting real-world pronunciation patterns. Our work
contributes to domain-specific ASR models, improving digit recognition
accuracy, and privacy of data. An added advantage, their low resource
consumption allows them to be hosted on-premise, keeping private data local
instead uploading to an external cloud. Our results indicate that our
micro-model makes less errors than the best-of-breed commercial or open-source
ASRs in recognizing digits (1.8% error rate of our best micro-model versus 5.8%
error rate of Whisper), and has a low memory footprint (0.66 GB VRAM for our
model versus 11 GB VRAM for Whisper). | [
-0.06689033657312393,
-0.5466969013214111,
0.3338097631931305,
-0.05850043147802353,
-0.37407249212265015,
0.11878405511379242,
-0.11727717518806458,
-0.6859321594238281,
0.1196262463927269,
0.41733047366142273,
-0.11647167056798935,
-0.12812380492687225,
-0.3497316837310791,
0.021796412765979767,
-0.40270766615867615,
0.5828074216842651,
0.4909181296825409,
0.27898773550987244,
0.005551015492528677,
-0.16339413821697235,
-0.06781403720378876,
-0.8002033233642578,
-0.9367105960845947,
-0.37399300932884216,
0.14629393815994263,
0.4567927420139313,
0.8547720909118652,
0.8527133464813232,
0.7318146824836731,
0.36777207255363464,
-0.07714226841926575,
-0.1912776678800583,
0.1391380876302719,
-0.4510722756385803,
0.2290877103805542,
-0.23504361510276794,
-0.7325893044471741,
-0.12303774058818817,
0.4742238223552704,
0.5993847846984863,
-0.35676461458206177,
0.36312201619148254,
-0.07477008551359177,
0.5970233082771301,
-0.13316559791564941,
0.3151191771030426,
-0.5655455589294434,
-0.20612706243991852,
-0.3308635354042053,
0.10892212390899658,
-0.3422504961490631,
-0.4491564929485321,
0.2523866891860962,
-0.3238218128681183,
0.3825763463973999,
-0.013041367754340172,
0.4847958981990814,
0.21674710512161255,
-0.18670278787612915,
-0.5009392499923706,
-1.014560341835022,
0.6035711169242859,
-0.6396064758300781,
0.6679857969284058,
0.3895374536514282,
0.39871203899383545,
0.5145258903503418,
-0.4869711995124817,
-0.41561317443847656,
-0.2761439085006714,
0.20746585726737976,
-0.26125630736351013,
-0.5179261565208435,
-0.06650073826313019,
0.41683924198150635,
0.27339693903923035,
-0.2417791485786438,
0.10605403035879135,
-0.5762195587158203,
-0.1599610149860382,
0.6023850440979004,
0.37079811096191406,
0.0649404302239418,
0.024210568517446518,
-0.16897958517074585,
-0.19867482781410217,
-0.6676430106163025,
0.5766773223876953,
0.2118140608072281,
0.7640660405158997,
-0.2811843752861023,
0.33779898285865784,
-0.03432488441467285,
0.5706425309181213,
0.1864142268896103,
-0.4662345349788666,
0.05209514871239662,
-0.19005510210990906,
-0.46278929710388184,
0.26026442646980286,
0.7764161825180054,
-0.08971551060676575,
0.29791682958602905,
0.01809195801615715,
-0.33609360456466675,
0.33347469568252563,
0.24963906407356262,
-0.9151814579963684,
-0.3567938506603241,
0.16036173701286316,
-0.6305729150772095,
-0.4561834931373596,
0.04685106873512268,
-0.6000019311904907,
-0.31955665349960327,
-0.588779866695404,
0.3611699938774109,
-0.5753825902938843,
0.004965450614690781,
0.18283262848854065,
0.0010764390463009477,
-0.17529045045375824,
0.4663204848766327,
-1.0561238527297974,
0.6957862973213196,
0.7520133256912231,
0.7990262508392334,
0.44252291321754456,
0.06959214806556702,
-0.42514559626579285,
-0.05697392299771309,
-0.3673993647098541,
0.4454024136066437,
-0.6020349860191345,
-0.5786380767822266,
-0.39055293798446655,
-0.3492833077907562,
-0.08102807402610779,
-0.7859381437301636,
0.1443038284778595,
-0.664743185043335,
-0.5050913691520691,
-0.05375469848513603,
-0.4647526741027832,
-0.005498157348483801,
-0.14012421667575836,
-0.5630993843078613,
0.30531173944473267,
-0.24174201488494873,
-0.3865113854408264,
0.2626613974571228,
-0.62618488073349,
-0.2525039315223694,
0.23968079686164856,
-0.35961899161338806,
-0.4226953387260437,
0.3884105086326599,
-0.03326668217778206,
0.1700328141450882,
-0.5341194272041321,
0.0873810425400734,
-0.1734747439622879,
-0.37916815280914307,
0.5480508804321289,
-0.6269611716270447,
0.8598232269287109,
0.30271974205970764,
-0.2704146206378937,
-0.17018096148967743,
-0.9920834302902222,
-0.09692742675542831,
-0.0220323596149683,
-0.47973522543907166,
-0.39550092816352844,
-0.00185111491009593,
0.04610001668334007,
-0.10118059813976288,
0.22576268017292023,
-0.8029314279556274,
-0.015243272297084332,
-0.3363107442855835,
0.6212489008903503,
0.5872775316238403,
-0.4260859489440918,
0.6256567239761353,
-0.23865945637226105,
0.3764520585536957,
0.06674403697252274,
0.36616000533103943,
-0.276886522769928,
-0.6081521511077881,
-0.6686914563179016,
-0.32022571563720703,
0.8314316868782043,
0.6114587187767029,
-0.7215813994407654,
0.3082977831363678,
-0.5577973127365112,
-0.6184482574462891,
-0.7031273245811462,
-0.049564097076654434,
0.3987622857093811,
0.334105908870697,
0.12989990413188934,
-0.23163048923015594,
-0.27169570326805115,
-0.8474854230880737,
-0.17332738637924194,
-0.23365110158920288,
-0.27658766508102417,
0.5361120104789734,
0.2963266968727112,
-0.3301013708114624,
0.9223337173461914,
-0.32616010308265686,
-0.4058172106742859,
0.15258027613162994,
0.11940976977348328,
0.09447614848613739,
0.5698240399360657,
0.33101603388786316,
-0.9617804288864136,
-0.5682418346405029,
0.1917780190706253,
-0.36839064955711365,
0.265596479177475,
0.033964209258556366,
0.7205051779747009,
0.21505381166934967,
0.2221011072397232,
-0.4707942008972168,
0.6745026707649231,
0.5245971083641052,
-0.3509466052055359,
0.08076789230108261,
-0.3807277977466583,
-0.006888910662382841,
-0.6138168573379517,
-0.053225595504045486,
0.09746807813644409,
-0.2824532091617584,
-0.9266255497932434,
-0.30514615774154663,
0.4440692961215973,
-0.5951688289642334,
-0.17399199306964874,
0.4644329249858856,
-0.40858855843544006,
-0.20746099948883057,
-0.1073671206831932,
-0.48204466700553894,
-0.2796848714351654,
0.18564210832118988,
0.13617295026779175,
1.00967538356781,
0.35027584433555603,
-0.6535165905952454,
0.11782326549291611,
0.23445862531661987,
-0.4710574150085449,
0.23463021218776703,
-0.7691180109977722,
0.33663931488990784,
0.44645267724990845,
-0.1627364158630371,
-0.6336658596992493,
-0.08100137859582901,
-0.034427255392074585,
-0.5835055112838745,
0.26246821880340576,
-0.2608562409877777,
-0.45787274837493896,
-0.36141952872276306,
-0.03583681955933571,
0.3682830035686493,
0.7832414507865906,
-0.47484898567199707,
0.8859032392501831,
0.6018468141555786,
-0.5930486917495728,
-0.18659524619579315,
-0.6376360058784485,
0.150587260723114,
-0.19737400114536285,
-0.6612858772277832,
0.18222357332706451,
0.1700822114944458,
-0.5181459188461304,
-0.40842488408088684,
-0.062376510351896286,
-0.1769607961177826,
-0.005500191822648048,
0.35337305068969727,
0.338695228099823,
-0.27580422163009644,
0.07853168249130249,
-0.35955333709716797,
-0.5669357180595398,
-0.18197467923164368,
-0.21196776628494263,
0.3824659287929535,
-0.33026620745658875,
-0.36588534712791443,
-0.6267784237861633,
0.47294357419013977,
0.7009467482566833,
-0.21399669349193573,
0.4547560513019562,
0.2945150136947632,
-0.5658754110336304,
-0.050141118466854095,
-0.7152356505393982,
-0.21765843033790588,
-0.5635894536972046,
-0.3178676962852478,
-0.7158514857292175,
-0.9946084022521973,
0.7048758268356323,
0.21785223484039307,
-0.14037412405014038,
0.32131528854370117,
0.45481443405151367,
-0.09529786556959152,
1.050787091255188,
0.8203850984573364,
-0.06908484548330307,
0.6842948794364929,
0.026736807078123093,
0.4430988132953644,
-0.4145492911338806,
-0.08462551981210709,
-0.7136348485946655,
0.036726485937833786,
-0.5103246569633484,
-0.6863502860069275,
0.4228723645210266,
-0.1982383280992508,
-0.39937812089920044,
0.27219364047050476,
-0.5046852827072144,
0.4010261595249176,
0.7473164796829224,
0.1393461972475052,
0.3183227479457855,
0.2251923531293869,
0.14172600209712982,
-0.23326259851455688,
-0.5361213684082031,
-0.7573124170303345,
0.8347690105438232,
0.7101075649261475,
1.1842327117919922,
0.049923524260520935,
0.5556910634040833,
0.39511749148368835,
0.14985968172550201,
-0.8079327940940857,
0.4137236773967743,
-0.6952544450759888,
-0.3775556981563568,
-0.4746517539024353,
-0.611278235912323,
-0.6990712285041809,
-0.05580999329686165,
0.05657530203461647,
-0.5939536094665527,
0.748741090297699,
0.3858835995197296,
-1.1843409538269043,
0.4814724624156952,
-0.7027658820152283,
0.5326858758926392,
-0.18409773707389832,
0.10325271636247635,
-0.026783578097820282,
-0.4817879796028137,
-0.015298280864953995,
-0.35741734504699707,
0.24962617456912994,
-0.002592765260487795,
-0.13536234200000763,
0.8195129632949829,
-0.6937013268470764,
1.0190799236297607,
-0.42596888542175293,
-0.041223324835300446,
0.4505824148654938,
0.18662618100643158,
0.5193743109703064,
-0.17489036917686462,
-0.15967795252799988,
0.6797783970832825,
-0.0297833438962698,
0.06710182875394821,
-0.22910147905349731,
0.2769913971424103,
-0.7284960746765137,
-0.2163749635219574,
-0.33546918630599976,
-0.3649345338344574,
-0.14350435137748718,
-0.06078771874308586,
0.1866154819726944,
0.7384452819824219,
-0.22274477779865265,
0.4600440263748169,
0.6814714670181274,
-0.024342909455299377,
0.38662081956863403,
0.7644596099853516,
0.16870717704296112,
-0.6195664405822754,
1.0942857265472412,
0.6140766143798828,
0.17183220386505127,
0.15737007558345795,
0.2666096091270447,
-0.2772982716560364,
-0.6240359544754028,
-0.6039073467254639,
0.11432274430990219,
-0.3532204329967499,
-0.5143024921417236,
-0.8709692358970642,
-0.2954554557800293,
-0.6338769197463989,
-0.19212967157363892,
-0.4836167097091675,
-0.5948005318641663,
-0.3974948525428772,
0.10403288155794144,
0.5902718305587769,
0.6309483647346497,
-0.3212685286998749,
0.7014763355255127,
-1.2055588960647583,
0.46224913001060486,
0.639930784702301,
0.3802785873413086,
0.15126469731330872,
-0.6496217250823975,
-0.3654882311820984,
0.15789903700351715,
0.09611213952302933,
-0.5101190805435181,
0.5877432823181152,
0.14140430092811584,
-0.0061231618747115135,
0.5345238447189331,
-0.13670654594898224,
0.8538748025894165,
-0.843849778175354,
0.514270007610321,
0.36274436116218567,
-1.3412103652954102,
0.42680296301841736,
-0.41396647691726685,
-0.05785955861210823,
0.7297258377075195,
0.05103148892521858,
-0.4306574761867523,
0.02789405919611454,
-1.0723377466201782,
-0.6340039372444153,
0.8249222040176392,
0.030841270461678505,
0.06590008735656738,
0.23526063561439514,
0.2912997007369995,
0.0685012936592102,
0.43897977471351624,
-0.3177209794521332,
-0.0021890101488679647,
-0.019388685002923012,
-0.2739478349685669,
-0.24428178369998932,
-0.41478431224823,
-0.05572950839996338,
-0.27616339921951294,
0.36623018980026245,
-0.13525351881980896,
0.46598020195961,
-0.057874102145433426,
0.17642129957675934,
-0.08734140545129776,
0.2059798240661621,
0.4112119674682617,
0.3999345302581787,
-0.36058783531188965,
0.0006030461518093944,
0.290078341960907,
-0.736553966999054,
0.35162776708602905,
0.242063507437706,
-0.33999624848365784,
0.05584372580051422,
-0.026852594688534737,
0.5903252363204956,
0.2418758124113083,
-0.4221428632736206,
0.6088888049125671,
-0.1915871798992157,
0.0073234583251178265,
-0.6765163540840149,
0.07815852761268616,
0.10074183344841003,
0.49397918581962585,
0.27900800108909607,
0.5560809969902039,
0.3695125877857208,
-0.46167275309562683,
0.16922248899936676,
0.39136776328086853,
-0.6259960532188416,
-0.33897852897644043,
0.7416671514511108,
0.3649032711982727,
-0.8622971773147583,
0.8120837211608887,
-0.07881428301334381,
-0.3205472528934479,
0.8651276230812073,
0.4156554341316223,
0.9356651306152344,
-0.5448760986328125,
-0.03735676780343056,
0.03707355260848999,
0.40661588311195374,
-0.33919990062713623,
0.47852203249931335,
-0.17888160049915314,
-0.8590357303619385,
0.10215578228235245,
-0.6045567393302917,
-0.9879641532897949,
-0.27992504835128784,
-0.8688344359397888,
0.16494101285934448,
-0.9001855254173279,
-0.5190820097923279,
0.5003684163093567,
-0.08739017695188522,
-0.6961066126823425,
0.36535748839378357,
0.5757587552070618,
1.2292932271957397,
-0.7957110404968262,
1.1216046810150146,
0.500340461730957,
-0.22420814633369446,
-0.7407313585281372,
-0.5392621159553528,
0.24548159539699554,
-0.804879367351532,
0.5694099068641663,
0.10078545659780502,
-0.2806874215602875,
-0.02496502734720707,
-0.40422293543815613,
-0.6882321834564209,
1.064149260520935,
0.3241507112979889,
-0.9731519818305969,
0.0011698062298819423,
0.28612589836120605,
0.5643066167831421,
-0.5544622540473938,
-0.15924584865570068,
0.6584660410881042,
0.1222439631819725,
0.05052180960774422,
-1.0551574230194092,
-0.2660449743270874,
-0.2429818958044052,
0.1767880618572235,
0.2390565127134323,
-0.8112931251525879,
1.2743752002716064,
-0.2948395609855652,
-0.19407029449939728,
0.12523752450942993,
0.2966006100177765,
0.3827255964279175,
0.5233614444732666,
0.6755155324935913,
0.2963065207004547,
0.9466302394866943,
-0.19964800775051117,
0.9997624158859253,
-0.20829416811466217,
0.11417919397354126,
1.013884425163269,
-0.33140134811401367,
1.196007490158081,
0.21875469386577606,
-0.32088372111320496,
0.05017438158392906,
0.3958275318145752,
-0.09318560361862183,
0.31256961822509766,
0.00567035423591733,
-0.30478015542030334,
-0.24218255281448364,
0.003663718467578292,
-0.14727471768856049,
0.49126461148262024,
0.5050256252288818,
-0.326169490814209,
0.46194010972976685,
0.0836411863565445,
-0.22122067213058472,
-0.29534247517585754,
-0.4533703029155731,
0.9983530640602112,
0.4236660301685333,
0.1637863963842392,
0.053194500505924225,
0.07265394181013107,
0.8299840092658997,
-0.6690359115600586,
0.22096213698387146,
0.013889887370169163,
0.5741291046142578,
-0.11095162481069565,
-0.25155773758888245,
0.34349188208580017,
0.4219980835914612,
-0.4146985113620758,
-0.5110812783241272,
0.92043536901474,
-0.19902586936950684,
-0.8086196780204773,
0.17306187748908997,
0.40754228830337524,
0.178618386387825,
-0.38944685459136963,
-0.5699743628501892,
0.08564258366823196,
0.07800570875406265,
0.1039183959364891,
0.25040102005004883,
0.5278729200363159,
0.037016525864601135,
0.6308128833770752,
0.8219319581985474,
0.3257947564125061,
-0.05364760011434555,
0.19728538393974304,
0.626110851764679,
-1.0805199146270752,
-0.9262364506721497,
-0.8789176940917969,
0.39361387491226196,
-0.07446924597024918,
-0.021310679614543915,
0.653537392616272,
0.6043327450752258,
0.5320243835449219,
-0.07403245568275452,
0.5181393623352051,
0.35187917947769165,
0.8551132678985596,
-0.18078471720218658,
0.7689419984817505,
-0.24938100576400757,
0.3096356689929962,
-0.08215087652206421,
-0.520129919052124,
-0.27144360542297363,
0.7926050424575806,
-0.33742421865463257,
-0.14753887057304382,
0.06685834378004074,
0.6598296165466309,
-0.14455246925354004,
0.49835658073425293,
0.3974956274032593,
-0.005263778381049633,
0.25241604447364807,
0.15779556334018707,
0.8328042030334473,
-0.704992413520813,
0.5695597529411316,
-0.45582127571105957,
-0.21145273745059967,
-0.418992817401886,
-0.43020206689834595,
-0.5278270840644836,
-0.22929246723651886,
-0.38323310017585754,
-0.12777554988861084,
-0.3945503532886505,
0.956229031085968,
0.7594323754310608,
-0.9637051820755005,
-0.5951744914054871,
0.423400342464447,
-0.3085371255874634,
-0.15061026811599731,
-0.11993659287691116,
0.2422213852405548,
0.055666640400886536,
-0.4535156190395355,
0.35348281264305115,
0.5724819898605347,
0.6245602369308472,
0.17249564826488495,
0.0631587877869606,
0.43277478218078613,
0.3981231153011322,
0.6222787499427795,
0.32236596941947937,
-0.5897329449653625,
-0.21744422614574432,
0.10903752595186234,
-0.2455378621816635,
0.24471451342105865,
0.9342297911643982,
-0.5065649747848511,
0.28297150135040283,
0.2005549520254135,
0.7580678462982178,
0.2581971287727356,
0.25824183225631714,
0.36494380235671997,
-0.3291226625442505,
0.19232475757598877,
0.37646105885505676,
0.40067264437675476,
0.37366247177124023,
-0.3900777995586395,
0.6115649342536926,
0.055153436958789825,
-0.506211519241333,
-0.7932543754577637,
-0.11951509863138199,
-0.8483919501304626,
0.09525761753320694,
0.804416298866272,
-0.02180054783821106,
-0.258348286151886,
-0.27628186345100403,
-0.013118368573486805,
-0.14513033628463745,
-0.5738911628723145,
0.6887534856796265,
0.34385189414024353,
-0.14634966850280762,
0.009702877141535282,
-0.42876625061035156,
0.6813406348228455,
0.029370533302426338,
-0.5077031254768372,
0.35017046332359314,
0.4366639256477356,
0.22093376517295837,
0.6656179428100586,
1.0636969804763794,
-0.19710801541805267,
0.30803388357162476,
0.6314637660980225,
0.07251333445310593,
-0.11201959103345871,
-0.6142416000366211,
-0.9858646988868713,
0.21575789153575897,
0.11233692616224289,
-0.30325353145599365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01920v1 | Preference Poisoning Attacks on Reward Model Learning | 2024-02-02T21:45:24 | 2024-02-02T21:45:24 | Junlin Wu, Jiongxiao Wang, Chaowei Xiao, Chenguang Wang, Ning Zhang, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Learning utility, or reward, models from pairwise comparisons is a
fundamental component in a number of application domains. These approaches
inherently entail collecting preference information from people, with feedback
often provided anonymously. Since preferences are subjective, there is no gold
standard to compare against; yet, reliance of high-impact systems on preference
learning creates a strong motivation for malicious actors to skew data
collected in this fashion to their ends. We investigate the nature and extent
of this vulnerability systematically by considering a threat model in which an
attacker can flip a small subset of preference comparisons with the goal of
either promoting or demoting a target outcome. First, we propose two classes of
algorithmic approaches for these attacks: a principled gradient-based
framework, and several variants of rank-by-distance methods. Next, we
demonstrate the efficacy of best attacks in both these classes in successfully
achieving malicious goals on datasets from three diverse domains: autonomous
control, recommendation system, and textual prompt-response preference
learning. We find that the best attacks are often highly successful, achieving
in the most extreme case 100% success rate with only 0.3% of the data poisoned.
However, which attack is best can vary significantly across domains,
demonstrating the value of our comprehensive vulnerability analysis that
involves several classes of attack algorithms. In addition, we observe that the
simpler and more scalable rank-by-distance approaches are often competitive
with the best, and on occasion significantly outperform gradient-based methods.
Finally, we show that several state-of-the-art defenses against other classes
of poisoning attacks exhibit, at best, limited efficacy in our setting. | [
-0.14084036648273468,
-0.5019976496696472,
0.38049817085266113,
-0.30865511298179626,
0.14243832230567932,
-0.1029823049902916,
0.058373212814331055,
-0.26583990454673767,
0.10947777330875397,
0.649915337562561,
-0.36551642417907715,
-0.28696709871292114,
-0.7620159983634949,
-0.41240260004997253,
-0.2580404281616211,
1.3065636157989502,
0.3763907849788666,
-0.0651082769036293,
-0.21691158413887024,
-0.22423580288887024,
-0.5021564364433289,
-1.2299474477767944,
-0.7296775579452515,
-0.34298497438430786,
0.7588972449302673,
0.40213239192962646,
0.48663458228111267,
0.3287063241004944,
0.7052744626998901,
0.1745312362909317,
0.3653804659843445,
-0.20921845734119415,
-0.8471764922142029,
0.11183309555053711,
-0.2227703034877777,
-0.6833920478820801,
-0.2429283708333969,
0.17338454723358154,
-0.16830380260944366,
0.5327443480491638,
0.01896323263645172,
-0.04689684510231018,
0.029562298208475113,
1.0497647523880005,
-1.127079725265503,
-0.2959064245223999,
-0.9212729334831238,
-0.01627744734287262,
-0.33718153834342957,
-0.45222532749176025,
-0.9430134296417236,
-0.15377122163772583,
0.28419381380081177,
-0.407273530960083,
-0.02789061889052391,
0.07688307762145996,
0.5400900840759277,
0.08780112862586975,
-0.6172171831130981,
-0.24542461335659027,
-0.43936973810195923,
0.9366284608840942,
-0.26289457082748413,
-0.1416301429271698,
0.5711857080459595,
0.5738204121589661,
-0.25693652033805847,
-0.43867093324661255,
0.05222560837864876,
-0.35642343759536743,
0.07107874006032944,
-0.06261007487773895,
-0.34676337242126465,
0.04464005306363106,
0.19663992524147034,
0.20219162106513977,
-0.5838321447372437,
0.12896545231342316,
-0.20044149458408356,
-0.09530399739742279,
0.7682042717933655,
0.33435606956481934,
0.16304148733615875,
-0.5422418117523193,
-0.8134320378303528,
-0.5245734453201294,
-0.8390313982963562,
0.5483043193817139,
0.8749865293502808,
0.29123932123184204,
0.010504918172955513,
0.2725689709186554,
-0.08341530710458755,
0.5450879335403442,
0.12929551303386688,
0.13512934744358063,
-0.05503931641578674,
0.10949064791202545,
-0.21526625752449036,
0.14011912047863007,
0.6620445251464844,
0.8949147462844849,
0.11560267210006714,
-0.3194657862186432,
-0.22835862636566162,
0.08544062823057175,
0.69525545835495,
-0.6334646344184875,
-0.6693236827850342,
0.4813591539859772,
-0.49082332849502563,
-1.0087751150131226,
-0.009340329095721245,
-0.9016761779785156,
-0.7393325567245483,
0.19397394359111786,
0.6985812187194824,
-0.35276421904563904,
-0.1982647180557251,
0.21237121522426605,
-0.39850249886512756,
0.189733624458313,
0.008772797882556915,
-1.3144428730010986,
0.44838273525238037,
0.6684136986732483,
0.7294886708259583,
-0.6434712409973145,
-0.09664570540189743,
-0.793731689453125,
0.000486801058286801,
-0.16167490184307098,
0.7799590826034546,
-0.4698738753795624,
-0.6401336193084717,
-0.148329958319664,
-0.4179297983646393,
0.03547235205769539,
-0.6149201989173889,
0.5355237126350403,
-0.8435252904891968,
-0.022983567789196968,
-0.5130016803741455,
-0.3755713105201721,
-0.17329826951026917,
0.5020254254341125,
-0.5978896021842957,
0.6644299626350403,
-0.013272713869810104,
-1.0512521266937256,
0.3214928209781647,
-0.5662132501602173,
-0.3307020664215088,
-0.23430442810058594,
0.3012334406375885,
-0.22917139530181885,
-0.026736043393611908,
-0.11281819641590118,
0.6403376460075378,
-0.0695466548204422,
-0.05356914550065994,
-0.5772792100906372,
-0.03610004857182503,
0.37129196524620056,
-0.33709996938705444,
0.8562218546867371,
0.16614730656147003,
-0.2430162876844406,
0.314832866191864,
-0.5882046222686768,
0.057764727622270584,
0.5458029508590698,
0.19677913188934326,
-0.9213940501213074,
0.14705435931682587,
0.05218574404716492,
0.010414207354187965,
0.15375031530857086,
-0.3410426676273346,
0.2972560524940491,
-0.36331605911254883,
0.4265512228012085,
1.1671394109725952,
0.4623055160045624,
0.5418522953987122,
-0.6568799614906311,
0.2915666103363037,
0.10325676202774048,
0.6738646626472473,
0.09287051111459732,
-0.10715929418802261,
-0.43311962485313416,
0.04477163031697273,
0.22733740508556366,
0.5559266209602356,
-0.7732831835746765,
0.030879389494657516,
-0.09140103310346603,
-0.7450084686279297,
-0.008396727964282036,
-0.30808258056640625,
0.37447333335876465,
0.6736133098602295,
0.5909494757652283,
-0.3800918161869049,
-0.06986527144908905,
-0.748370885848999,
-0.6461539268493652,
-0.19586989283561707,
0.09020502120256424,
0.3727216124534607,
0.5111514329910278,
0.1237051710486412,
0.7092435956001282,
-0.7360079884529114,
-0.17895323038101196,
-0.08630020171403885,
-0.16189482808113098,
0.0831756740808487,
0.650834858417511,
0.9492983222007751,
-0.8884562253952026,
-0.44911375641822815,
-0.14979764819145203,
-0.6547948718070984,
0.2779231667518616,
-0.0722673088312149,
-0.23634763062000275,
-0.11868251115083694,
-0.016761621460318565,
0.03250131011009216,
0.4143526554107666,
0.17134225368499756,
-0.14999531209468842,
0.5934107899665833,
0.223108172416687,
0.31624090671539307,
-0.8451051115989685,
0.11238128691911697,
0.27646604180336,
-0.004647616762667894,
-1.3135004043579102,
0.24902409315109253,
0.028419770300388336,
0.24571463465690613,
-0.6841099262237549,
0.4450179636478424,
0.24688157439231873,
0.26554638147354126,
-0.11754646897315979,
-0.4314018785953522,
-0.10979320853948593,
0.6045912504196167,
-0.11422616243362427,
0.4469688832759857,
0.644196629524231,
-0.6326613426208496,
0.4034734070301056,
-0.20196533203125,
0.033257871866226196,
0.7740594148635864,
-0.5879809260368347,
0.2906690835952759,
0.12248938530683517,
0.021149372681975365,
-0.7599639892578125,
-0.4215445816516876,
0.6043398976325989,
-0.5691235065460205,
0.41183409094810486,
-0.44063106179237366,
0.013867194764316082,
0.13410165905952454,
-0.9228363037109375,
0.48387137055397034,
0.3529790937900543,
-0.9263577461242676,
0.1908934861421585,
0.4466029107570648,
0.08903048932552338,
-1.1070963144302368,
-0.30061793327331543,
0.05473048985004425,
-0.6721541881561279,
-0.4875847101211548,
0.17343170940876007,
-0.10356734693050385,
-0.4247344434261322,
-0.3650451600551605,
-0.15004143118858337,
0.2464340329170227,
0.6118985414505005,
0.3280271887779236,
0.4249916076660156,
0.3968871533870697,
-0.33544421195983887,
-0.14687702059745789,
-0.3663623631000519,
0.504520058631897,
-0.2441003918647766,
0.4875469207763672,
0.055623553693294525,
-0.4744080603122711,
-0.3460167646408081,
0.565381646156311,
0.7035656571388245,
0.020961951464414597,
0.6038037538528442,
-0.16709017753601074,
-0.21773095428943634,
-0.3528456389904022,
-0.3007628321647644,
-0.4429576098918915,
-0.4967193603515625,
0.18111585080623627,
-0.40456312894821167,
-0.4390396773815155,
0.3728572726249695,
-0.03061165101826191,
0.16649840772151947,
0.335207998752594,
0.1565961092710495,
-0.05268591269850731,
1.045843482017517,
0.3977982997894287,
-0.5769604444503784,
0.42466509342193604,
-0.4174208343029022,
0.14491918683052063,
-0.5994930267333984,
-0.3654254972934723,
-0.4786629378795624,
-0.2054123431444168,
-0.5206936597824097,
0.12540626525878906,
0.738400399684906,
-0.3135879933834076,
-0.36589187383651733,
0.11627477407455444,
-0.5706709027290344,
0.6194840669631958,
0.6748362183570862,
0.22246447205543518,
-0.07600198686122894,
0.27002450823783875,
-0.17555765807628632,
-0.023599525913596153,
-0.5808553099632263,
-0.23737666010856628,
1.6946783065795898,
0.2412661612033844,
0.7504315376281738,
0.11516852676868439,
0.8109704852104187,
0.7382214665412903,
-0.006013369187712669,
-0.8299742937088013,
0.3161197304725647,
-0.08712447434663773,
-0.30991917848587036,
-0.12272544205188751,
-0.3807043135166168,
-0.9290751218795776,
0.3063529431819916,
-0.07737291604280472,
-0.654961884021759,
0.26724737882614136,
0.12289191782474518,
-0.32906967401504517,
0.615994393825531,
-0.792026698589325,
0.7290685772895813,
-0.4698733389377594,
-0.7120841145515442,
-0.07395245134830475,
-0.8981077075004578,
0.3967394232749939,
0.046333007514476776,
-0.03288177400827408,
0.14819934964179993,
0.46986475586891174,
0.83233243227005,
-0.5254658460617065,
0.6917126774787903,
-0.39935848116874695,
0.24602648615837097,
-0.27709266543388367,
0.3964730203151703,
0.4198937714099884,
-0.031934142112731934,
-0.23332010209560394,
0.3266049325466156,
0.09813953936100006,
-0.803965151309967,
-0.6992267966270447,
0.65912926197052,
-0.785000205039978,
-0.6571674346923828,
-0.7982365489006042,
-0.10566215217113495,
-0.33689984679222107,
0.0761725902557373,
0.49390557408332825,
0.42747342586517334,
-0.17427687346935272,
-0.037850260734558105,
0.8856417536735535,
-0.07236580550670624,
0.3463315963745117,
0.1886468380689621,
0.1651562750339508,
-0.4980424642562866,
1.3031197786331177,
-0.13667352497577667,
0.6443074345588684,
0.3244786560535431,
0.17392651736736298,
-0.14014054834842682,
-0.6637547612190247,
-0.3472873270511627,
-0.12229479849338531,
-0.7235194444656372,
-0.38548779487609863,
-0.41569483280181885,
-0.1349194198846817,
-0.40236523747444153,
-0.48693135380744934,
-0.1796756237745285,
-0.2297961413860321,
-0.08531468361616135,
-0.11564934998750687,
0.3911074697971344,
0.7440888285636902,
-0.13164885342121124,
0.25294166803359985,
-0.3654182553291321,
0.0032207274343818426,
0.5634790062904358,
0.025709446519613266,
0.23365511000156403,
-0.2608042359352112,
0.08437293767929077,
-0.09114748984575272,
-0.48688802123069763,
-1.1651818752288818,
0.5227506160736084,
-0.47236788272857666,
0.5488139390945435,
0.7530257105827332,
0.5050428509712219,
0.1514786034822464,
-0.163957417011261,
1.0230921506881714,
0.32621070742607117,
-0.6748445630073547,
0.5219839215278625,
-0.27663734555244446,
-0.28986698389053345,
0.7790535688400269,
0.6791189908981323,
-0.6994224786758423,
0.04898257926106453,
-0.5682389736175537,
-0.8886023163795471,
0.78395015001297,
0.08408437669277191,
0.06847462058067322,
0.1175851821899414,
0.48138269782066345,
0.33106136322021484,
0.12172764539718628,
-0.7721515893936157,
-0.7622472047805786,
-0.4006805419921875,
0.1341778039932251,
-0.02103470079600811,
-0.26264864206314087,
-0.26659920811653137,
0.0529295951128006,
0.8270288109779358,
0.06531959772109985,
0.06753714382648468,
-0.1402425467967987,
0.0365857370197773,
0.11367250978946686,
0.2510429918766022,
0.38684287667274475,
0.1261167824268341,
-0.27750569581985474,
0.4339240491390228,
0.0017640022560954094,
-0.5594218373298645,
0.43120741844177246,
-0.23896802961826324,
-0.13001348078250885,
-0.6583367586135864,
0.1846798211336136,
0.7141213417053223,
0.0009588031680323184,
-0.441348671913147,
0.7587985396385193,
-0.22075803577899933,
0.06375204771757126,
-0.026352286338806152,
0.2523609399795532,
-0.5313356518745422,
-0.1913866251707077,
0.490713894367218,
0.4230520725250244,
0.42717528343200684,
-0.41495755314826965,
0.07984865456819534,
0.7089563012123108,
-0.4450269341468811,
-0.20447131991386414,
0.4584437310695648,
0.09561870247125626,
-0.1507583111524582,
0.29038068652153015,
0.1168617308139801,
-0.7490420341491699,
0.6327995657920837,
0.361296147108078,
0.7777614593505859,
-0.5926299095153809,
0.20634162425994873,
0.12770535051822662,
0.2668091356754303,
0.03131870925426483,
-0.1818392276763916,
-0.254424512386322,
-0.5383893251419067,
0.5049435496330261,
-0.25150829553604126,
-0.616346001625061,
0.22144010663032532,
-0.9857064485549927,
-0.023419136181473732,
-0.6468316316604614,
-0.21301734447479248,
0.10939569771289825,
-0.07938600331544876,
-0.18832047283649445,
-0.007435969077050686,
-0.15630383789539337,
0.5502303838729858,
-0.9659711122512817,
0.3588138222694397,
0.555650532245636,
-0.32905521988868713,
-0.4808598458766937,
0.14314335584640503,
0.2688569128513336,
-0.645826518535614,
0.6166108846664429,
0.140848308801651,
-0.23346693813800812,
-0.34179913997650146,
-0.6151772737503052,
-0.560330331325531,
0.6581256985664368,
0.2195061296224594,
0.04071524739265442,
0.04736516997218132,
0.13162705302238464,
0.19256918132305145,
-0.10411212593317032,
0.17218872904777527,
0.6969576478004456,
0.2950039505958557,
-0.0068733892403542995,
-0.5157931447029114,
-0.13398174941539764,
-0.37303775548934937,
-0.29602473974227905,
0.2857067883014679,
-0.6593806743621826,
0.6179600954055786,
-0.1342155635356903,
0.15924622118473053,
-0.40280717611312866,
0.21676908433437347,
0.09268717467784882,
0.6231306195259094,
0.6546406745910645,
0.48094549775123596,
0.6861931681632996,
0.10461176186800003,
1.1620817184448242,
-0.036894168704748154,
0.24286006391048431,
0.8940076231956482,
-0.4490899443626404,
0.8734515905380249,
0.43038421869277954,
-0.16866537928581238,
0.36889004707336426,
0.8735190629959106,
0.15217438340187073,
1.0333181619644165,
0.227320596575737,
-0.2622505724430084,
-0.24087011814117432,
0.12565121054649353,
-0.3320784270763397,
0.12478858977556229,
0.25782066583633423,
-0.21552574634552002,
-0.04378557205200195,
0.26559531688690186,
0.12535706162452698,
-0.047053977847099304,
-0.3829445540904999,
0.8760203123092651,
-0.14687003195285797,
-0.6849496960639954,
0.6709223389625549,
0.18535257875919342,
0.6761758327484131,
-0.6385891437530518,
0.26124417781829834,
-0.1465320587158203,
0.04660018905997276,
-0.39242327213287354,
-0.4046507477760315,
-0.11643754690885544,
-0.05194864794611931,
-0.29602235555648804,
-0.08987800031900406,
0.7117106914520264,
0.11060251295566559,
0.1607920080423355,
0.3036739230155945,
-0.054898228496313095,
-0.11144338548183441,
-0.10310584306716919,
-0.6248963475227356,
-0.12689611315727234,
0.12477415055036545,
-0.24779173731803894,
0.8122478723526001,
-0.3482900857925415,
-0.048647381365299225,
0.765655517578125,
0.7679351568222046,
0.11947311460971832,
0.15880230069160461,
-0.35399603843688965,
0.9357606768608093,
-0.2650366723537445,
-0.7389393448829651,
-1.009722352027893,
0.22213858366012573,
-0.44143185019493103,
0.18509836494922638,
0.7422948479652405,
0.5229568481445312,
0.9166172742843628,
-0.04265442490577698,
0.903093695640564,
0.31470370292663574,
0.22222168743610382,
-0.4542478919029236,
0.9715685248374939,
-0.42560821771621704,
0.3924720287322998,
-0.2986392378807068,
-0.5016228556632996,
-0.30781954526901245,
0.22439229488372803,
-0.6964035630226135,
0.08606483787298203,
0.6917740106582642,
0.6917057037353516,
0.00322653423063457,
0.02041277103126049,
0.17858050763607025,
-0.12367105484008789,
0.5704875588417053,
0.8514279723167419,
0.8457750678062439,
-0.32649368047714233,
0.19136807322502136,
-0.5113803744316101,
-0.48984265327453613,
-0.4404503405094147,
-0.7300949096679688,
-1.1091043949127197,
-0.6472366452217102,
-0.0868232473731041,
-0.6630305051803589,
0.323660671710968,
0.9135520458221436,
0.9034425020217896,
-0.9556499719619751,
-0.16795194149017334,
0.30887192487716675,
0.2946959435939789,
-0.2681204378604889,
-0.22553937137126923,
0.5529475808143616,
-0.20690028369426727,
-0.36127573251724243,
0.36063671112060547,
0.28102508187294006,
-0.15252311527729034,
-0.2540673613548279,
0.023179873824119568,
0.1445150375366211,
0.2815532684326172,
0.39439114928245544,
0.41502517461776733,
-0.4203387200832367,
-0.2594181001186371,
-0.1523376852273941,
-0.18110135197639465,
0.06937055289745331,
0.9652596712112427,
-0.7023904323577881,
0.581737220287323,
0.417741596698761,
0.7460755705833435,
0.10274859517812729,
0.015617086552083492,
0.15541741251945496,
-0.5401661992073059,
-0.1328008472919464,
0.17777800559997559,
0.2562932074069977,
0.2710861563682556,
-0.9000468254089355,
0.26143303513526917,
0.3999570310115814,
-0.4462376534938812,
-1.1627914905548096,
0.34295204281806946,
-1.0512163639068604,
-0.40535858273506165,
1.0678740739822388,
-0.09729812294244766,
-0.33765071630477905,
-0.12036639451980591,
-0.12706954777240753,
-0.2993009090423584,
-0.5881754755973816,
1.0104783773422241,
0.44178885221481323,
-0.20907624065876007,
0.5975270867347717,
-0.4574636220932007,
0.819911777973175,
0.45223668217658997,
-0.8376743793487549,
0.27772626280784607,
0.3391086161136627,
0.60395348072052,
-0.01423745509237051,
0.27979540824890137,
-0.1723361313343048,
0.4864930510520935,
-0.29966968297958374,
-0.18879397213459015,
-0.06791838258504868,
-0.518744945526123,
-0.7203837633132935,
0.8685424327850342,
-0.008670409210026264,
-0.23096413910388947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01917v1 | Whispering in Norwegian: Navigating Orthographic and Dialectic Challenges | 2024-02-02T21:38:12 | 2024-02-02T21:38:12 | Per E Kummervold, Javier de la Rosa, Freddy Wetjen, Rolv-Arild Braaten, Per Erik Solberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | This article introduces NB-Whisper, an adaptation of OpenAI's Whisper,
specifically fine-tuned for Norwegian language Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR). We highlight its key contributions and summarise the results achieved in
converting spoken Norwegian into written forms and translating other languages
into Norwegian. We show that we are able to improve the Norwegian Bokm{\aa}l
transcription by OpenAI Whisper Large-v3 from a WER of 10.4 to 6.6 on the
Fleurs Dataset and from 6.8 to 2.2 on the NST dataset. | [
-0.2471594363451004,
-0.5033991932868958,
0.2377481311559677,
0.37171196937561035,
-0.2531053423881531,
-0.004550918471068144,
-0.4239499568939209,
-0.9147967100143433,
0.34749147295951843,
0.5955190658569336,
-0.37618210911750793,
-0.5225362777709961,
-0.38537535071372986,
0.21538285911083221,
-0.4019174873828888,
0.7859535217285156,
-0.12797443568706512,
0.22797386348247528,
0.47614848613739014,
-0.18118074536323547,
-0.38929283618927,
-0.45119959115982056,
-0.908966600894928,
-0.27011051774024963,
0.575989305973053,
0.2748945951461792,
0.5386098623275757,
0.18372847139835358,
0.22176773846149445,
0.25557741522789,
-0.5957921743392944,
-0.09782717376947403,
-0.4453950524330139,
0.4032972455024719,
0.20459668338298798,
-0.5556209087371826,
-0.47048449516296387,
-0.21049518883228302,
1.044176459312439,
0.44366592168807983,
-0.4701542556285858,
0.09429097175598145,
0.04016486182808876,
0.8190186023712158,
-0.2376880794763565,
0.2630768120288849,
-0.44496074318885803,
-0.10128600895404816,
-0.6018630862236023,
0.1924663633108139,
-0.20187515020370483,
-0.5804235339164734,
0.9559060335159302,
-0.8158840537071228,
0.22991085052490234,
0.11795271188020706,
0.7779537439346313,
0.20170219242572784,
-0.5404022336006165,
-0.8016523122787476,
-0.7778653502464294,
0.7207240462303162,
-0.7765416502952576,
0.756736695766449,
0.3074413239955902,
0.618103563785553,
-0.21096836030483246,
-0.6759244799613953,
-0.5500615835189819,
-0.014061558060348034,
0.10486745834350586,
0.27333682775497437,
-0.2083175629377365,
0.22293825447559357,
-0.02248445712029934,
0.5893358588218689,
-0.3167811632156372,
-0.04210085794329643,
-0.9605565071105957,
-0.2607745826244354,
0.7915154695510864,
-0.06633652001619339,
0.1101432591676712,
-0.25642094016075134,
0.09268778562545776,
-0.31751158833503723,
-0.5916656255722046,
0.06093301251530647,
0.7418482303619385,
0.6965602040290833,
-0.48335960507392883,
0.2008996605873108,
-0.15483757853507996,
0.9410795569419861,
-0.0014694187557324767,
-0.11266491562128067,
0.41867026686668396,
-0.0831262469291687,
-0.020573126152157784,
0.6776487231254578,
0.6170867085456848,
0.2967323064804077,
0.11928778886795044,
0.039071645587682724,
-0.3614499270915985,
-0.15370187163352966,
0.11410346627235413,
-0.4107833206653595,
-0.5181143879890442,
-0.01811213605105877,
-0.5641630291938782,
-0.14685110747814178,
0.0710904598236084,
-0.6352661848068237,
-0.48397743701934814,
-0.04929005727171898,
0.646989643573761,
-0.30549997091293335,
-0.5914202928543091,
0.4633669853210449,
-0.43531864881515503,
0.581147313117981,
0.47774896025657654,
-0.7978099584579468,
0.39759573340415955,
0.6056241989135742,
1.01515531539917,
-0.02743264101445675,
0.024653607979416847,
-0.30498555302619934,
0.02568972483277321,
-0.6153327226638794,
0.802618682384491,
-0.2116062343120575,
-0.7119094729423523,
0.15020544826984406,
-0.3593887388706207,
-0.10771878808736801,
-0.6706264019012451,
0.48100388050079346,
-0.29271265864372253,
0.45638802647590637,
-0.16533628106117249,
-0.06848825514316559,
-0.6113044619560242,
-0.09523586183786392,
-0.6377419829368591,
0.8155025243759155,
0.0391167588531971,
-0.36514145135879517,
0.20899523794651031,
-1.034397006034851,
-0.427413672208786,
-0.09143861383199692,
0.2337961047887802,
-0.023861180990934372,
0.5665820240974426,
0.3412046432495117,
0.11453846096992493,
-0.3127047121524811,
-0.09325490146875381,
0.27701595425605774,
-0.020147444680333138,
0.20345254242420197,
-0.19900867342948914,
0.9295107126235962,
0.14237043261528015,
0.11814378947019577,
0.09564411640167236,
-0.6759223341941833,
0.1457153707742691,
-0.3777933120727539,
-0.3508336544036865,
-0.1127973422408104,
-0.21526582539081573,
0.2245015650987625,
-0.16810651123523712,
0.052323345094919205,
-0.9436308145523071,
0.0017497685039415956,
-1.0869067907333374,
0.7599475383758545,
0.6397987604141235,
0.1908281147480011,
0.4872968792915344,
-0.5297439694404602,
0.544914722442627,
-0.24287095665931702,
0.30374330282211304,
-0.03764345869421959,
-0.8517259359359741,
-0.9278520345687866,
-0.21424496173858643,
0.7864106297492981,
0.48452430963516235,
-1.0477532148361206,
-0.2466375231742859,
-0.1215660348534584,
-0.4922274649143219,
-1.2358183860778809,
-0.10275505483150482,
0.6663301587104797,
0.39107879996299744,
0.09863065183162689,
-0.49388065934181213,
-0.8606084585189819,
-0.6652507185935974,
-0.29970359802246094,
-0.541813850402832,
0.009410831145942211,
0.2966002821922302,
0.08725618571043015,
-0.09616273641586304,
0.5979933142662048,
-0.3262988030910492,
-0.9145962595939636,
-0.16420131921768188,
0.2837250828742981,
0.8300018906593323,
0.4006556570529938,
0.3693409860134125,
-0.9298924207687378,
-0.9548038244247437,
0.4010046422481537,
-0.41849610209465027,
-0.32532355189323425,
0.12303537130355835,
0.13577932119369507,
0.6058230400085449,
0.7643096446990967,
-0.13981181383132935,
0.5777990221977234,
0.8613112568855286,
-0.368589848279953,
0.6290015578269958,
0.05146179348230362,
-0.10067135840654373,
-0.9378081560134888,
-0.10520923882722855,
-0.5528593063354492,
-0.22739537060260773,
-1.072733759880066,
0.007034850772470236,
-0.43179449439048767,
-0.0412786602973938,
-0.49853748083114624,
0.861082136631012,
-0.6153777837753296,
0.07804246991872787,
-0.10920534282922745,
0.012507183477282524,
-0.3103606402873993,
0.1340407133102417,
0.14749272167682648,
0.5471768975257874,
0.8567425012588501,
-0.5805361270904541,
0.3598909080028534,
0.9080754518508911,
-0.36978286504745483,
0.6509843468666077,
-0.6735725998878479,
0.4765559434890747,
-0.03610740229487419,
0.07851138710975647,
-0.7590670585632324,
-0.308257520198822,
0.1576562374830246,
-0.8776009678840637,
0.4480540454387665,
-0.3500637710094452,
-0.4069342613220215,
-0.037193283438682556,
-0.24340291321277618,
0.06496351212263107,
0.6928473711013794,
-0.5805338025093079,
1.0861071348190308,
0.41221123933792114,
-0.5198562741279602,
-0.013717865571379662,
-0.6016055941581726,
0.16536374390125275,
0.038992274552583694,
-0.5883876085281372,
0.12471772730350494,
0.1453934609889984,
-0.2609424591064453,
-0.06950188428163528,
-0.33499783277511597,
-0.20124246180057526,
-0.4144209027290344,
0.5094027519226074,
0.06304766237735748,
-0.6752000451087952,
-0.27227646112442017,
0.0636017695069313,
-0.3039351999759674,
-0.07457981258630753,
-0.2964242696762085,
0.2982979714870453,
-0.3029460310935974,
-0.04341014847159386,
-0.6369568705558777,
0.42506110668182373,
0.3516976237297058,
0.05583551153540611,
0.31383922696113586,
0.3421533703804016,
-0.22217506170272827,
0.02268492616713047,
-0.6439833045005798,
-0.11780799925327301,
-0.5454643964767456,
-0.15448220074176788,
-0.6613662838935852,
-1.0362696647644043,
0.6458375453948975,
0.06524385511875153,
0.3459712862968445,
0.33272239565849304,
0.21261832118034363,
-0.4578496813774109,
0.8032585382461548,
0.7899218201637268,
-0.0865938737988472,
0.5158329606056213,
-0.18883909285068512,
0.05493348091840744,
-1.0310068130493164,
-0.2974341809749603,
-0.6698350310325623,
-0.5185008645057678,
-0.731393039226532,
-0.29112833738327026,
1.0576610565185547,
0.0341264046728611,
0.000014617266060668044,
0.14277257025241852,
-0.42314761877059937,
0.2918071746826172,
0.7822966575622559,
-0.06069251894950867,
0.24619349837303162,
-0.05772188678383827,
0.0122828995808959,
-0.1482776403427124,
-0.8844441175460815,
-0.09811069071292877,
0.9272195100784302,
0.43651676177978516,
0.6485729813575745,
0.5187796354293823,
0.7168040871620178,
-0.20981571078300476,
0.1903466433286667,
-0.5527026057243347,
0.3140943646430969,
-0.3911331295967102,
-0.8057507276535034,
-0.6425246000289917,
-0.19669675827026367,
-0.8667915463447571,
0.11739138513803482,
-0.20435254275798798,
-0.6308018565177917,
0.582068681716919,
0.32091405987739563,
-0.3514047861099243,
0.03837789222598076,
-0.5471326112747192,
0.4459962844848633,
0.12550754845142365,
0.5977259278297424,
-0.01682390831410885,
-0.741467297077179,
0.013363361358642578,
0.0917201042175293,
-0.04446900635957718,
0.19963237643241882,
-0.006874575279653072,
0.9696844220161438,
-0.1605473905801773,
0.9048316478729248,
-0.3527502417564392,
-0.346149206161499,
0.3506895899772644,
0.17586497962474823,
0.21824143826961517,
-0.3138662576675415,
-0.3006362020969391,
0.6428414583206177,
0.11504821479320526,
-0.03271074220538139,
-0.7225818037986755,
0.349991112947464,
-0.6218030452728271,
-0.3217984139919281,
-0.5935133695602417,
-0.19430766999721527,
-0.30521804094314575,
0.18301020562648773,
0.4743994176387787,
0.7273054122924805,
-0.35448816418647766,
0.22826209664344788,
0.7229679822921753,
-0.18538233637809753,
0.2799248993396759,
0.8351585268974304,
-0.6015450954437256,
-1.0039514303207397,
1.0262898206710815,
0.2609696686267853,
0.2885899245738983,
0.23853324353694916,
0.481093168258667,
-0.7624719142913818,
-0.8879428505897522,
-0.7478652596473694,
0.31132298707962036,
-0.6376435160636902,
-0.26728832721710205,
-0.45539391040802,
-0.5189504027366638,
-0.46379774808883667,
-0.39287710189819336,
-0.15325504541397095,
-0.6018258929252625,
-0.31189581751823425,
-0.01798609457910061,
0.8378733992576599,
1.1882013082504272,
-0.37713199853897095,
0.6578992009162903,
-0.6021960377693176,
0.5871212482452393,
0.3259012997150421,
0.41049924492836,
-0.1258554309606552,
-0.9391553997993469,
0.02496085688471794,
-0.12906749546527863,
-0.05032993480563164,
-0.7443106174468994,
0.44757646322250366,
0.7903074622154236,
0.3601924180984497,
0.2200489342212677,
0.08671300113201141,
0.9334244132041931,
-0.6068442463874817,
0.8885244727134705,
0.21754297614097595,
-1.1655385494232178,
0.4521876573562622,
-0.5735501646995544,
0.5448052287101746,
0.4913717806339264,
0.05690927430987358,
-0.9391241073608398,
-0.4419216811656952,
-0.5499750375747681,
-0.9407823085784912,
0.7131771445274353,
0.19522526860237122,
-0.021206563338637352,
0.4206567406654358,
0.43205779790878296,
0.18461281061172485,
0.4249894618988037,
-0.2316514402627945,
-0.11156921088695526,
-0.38964104652404785,
-0.1375109702348709,
-0.40455180406570435,
-0.35657763481140137,
0.06779823452234268,
-0.2890600562095642,
0.8381166458129883,
-0.17026443779468536,
0.41135725378990173,
0.5594220757484436,
0.03290705755352974,
-0.028641093522310257,
0.05611543357372284,
0.4633161127567291,
0.2904888689517975,
-0.035739965736866,
-0.0643569603562355,
0.39329007267951965,
-0.9542118906974792,
-0.14589768648147583,
-0.021218350157141685,
-0.3936001658439636,
0.3936096429824829,
0.6052566170692444,
1.011392593383789,
0.38494253158569336,
-0.43334248661994934,
0.287312388420105,
0.022264188155531883,
-0.551237165927887,
-0.42352283000946045,
-0.026753783226013184,
0.008790993131697178,
0.37135520577430725,
0.2994028925895691,
-0.13927152752876282,
0.3440140187740326,
-0.628524124622345,
-0.1554916799068451,
0.14425243437290192,
-0.896443247795105,
-0.6098847985267639,
0.48194795846939087,
0.3832033574581146,
-0.5771071910858154,
0.6646561026573181,
0.11166506260633469,
-0.8625580668449402,
-0.02995607629418373,
0.6214693784713745,
1.2171555757522583,
-0.5864835381507874,
0.08199882507324219,
0.2162218987941742,
0.42346107959747314,
-0.07097608596086502,
1.2313591241836548,
-0.12307000160217285,
-0.4108024835586548,
-0.40630656480789185,
-0.8888329267501831,
-0.705263078212738,
-0.2579405605792999,
-1.1471612453460693,
0.07106588035821915,
-0.42877790331840515,
0.029822014272212982,
0.1541932225227356,
-0.1479695588350296,
-0.31254842877388,
-0.10412291437387466,
0.04887963831424713,
1.2156955003738403,
-0.5212105512619019,
0.6267268061637878,
0.7680014371871948,
0.3143653869628906,
-0.5934519171714783,
-0.01871398091316223,
0.15213391184806824,
-0.572378933429718,
0.5489136576652527,
-0.1055157259106636,
-0.38807550072669983,
0.13576549291610718,
-0.5238244533538818,
-0.9384392499923706,
0.6954228281974792,
0.317595899105072,
-0.504988968372345,
0.09889054298400879,
-0.057062432169914246,
0.7597920298576355,
-0.07838109880685806,
-0.2351076453924179,
0.5424708127975464,
0.7274878621101379,
0.030669480562210083,
-1.9531151056289673,
-0.38556888699531555,
-0.13634449243545532,
0.15949465334415436,
0.429166316986084,
-0.6829841732978821,
0.7270749807357788,
-0.03957686945796013,
-0.45321762561798096,
0.4109024703502655,
0.9586001634597778,
-0.2091130018234253,
0.45081183314323425,
0.4401780962944031,
0.3011381924152374,
0.7251656651496887,
-0.03226257488131523,
0.8090280294418335,
0.3950445055961609,
-0.5580803155899048,
0.9814507365226746,
-0.3602427542209625,
1.2397396564483643,
0.40703916549682617,
0.0779508650302887,
0.7152190208435059,
0.06652084738016129,
0.5111472606658936,
0.6545389890670776,
0.1518850326538086,
-0.4651017487049103,
0.22029393911361694,
-0.02008908800780773,
-0.17303524911403656,
0.8332238793373108,
0.6663720607757568,
0.1808001697063446,
-0.10057935863733292,
0.3267844617366791,
-0.2829512357711792,
0.22165131568908691,
-0.5710694193840027,
1.3903998136520386,
0.38126084208488464,
-0.28059855103492737,
0.846077024936676,
-0.14340268075466156,
0.7132365107536316,
-0.8251723051071167,
-0.21540525555610657,
0.31964412331581116,
0.016968972980976105,
-0.0468565933406353,
-0.6933891773223877,
0.687835693359375,
-0.16088752448558807,
-0.2417059987783432,
-0.6340025067329407,
0.7171932458877563,
-0.4317918121814728,
-0.18246248364448547,
0.15445588529109955,
0.23823179304599762,
0.5704570412635803,
-0.27355194091796875,
-0.524613082408905,
0.3820611238479614,
0.3225688934326172,
0.07063504308462143,
-0.04116913303732872,
0.4785379469394684,
-0.1418442726135254,
0.7120397686958313,
0.8484479784965515,
0.4482053518295288,
0.33994928002357483,
-0.17874839901924133,
0.7508891820907593,
-0.8016858100891113,
-0.8994187116622925,
-0.3476668894290924,
0.3138837218284607,
0.15104719996452332,
-0.7878386378288269,
0.9025239944458008,
0.5276008248329163,
0.7512158155441284,
-0.14477896690368652,
0.6641420125961304,
-0.11266468465328217,
1.0824311971664429,
-0.9090737104415894,
0.9369646906852722,
-0.11129050701856613,
-0.4300185441970825,
-0.1166340708732605,
-0.6968419551849365,
-0.3508604168891907,
0.8998696804046631,
-0.1878795176744461,
-0.4638475179672241,
0.44465547800064087,
0.9221498370170593,
0.20205074548721313,
0.3516460359096527,
0.4441109597682953,
0.7262804508209229,
-0.1082518920302391,
0.3901330232620239,
0.9035559892654419,
-0.6753286719322205,
0.38504505157470703,
0.062364522367715836,
-0.11259240657091141,
-0.09524405002593994,
-0.9532859325408936,
-0.9139792919158936,
-1.0445255041122437,
-0.35034486651420593,
-0.37166813015937805,
0.46057525277137756,
0.5187636017799377,
0.8810277581214905,
-1.0193127393722534,
-0.541898787021637,
0.31318965554237366,
-0.03893931210041046,
-0.33319586515426636,
-0.11170974373817444,
0.278937965631485,
0.2302670180797577,
-0.5580959916114807,
0.778961718082428,
0.21643294394016266,
0.4114822745323181,
-0.25322651863098145,
-0.26868000626564026,
0.1976757049560547,
0.04639340564608574,
0.4048881232738495,
0.6233785152435303,
-0.7315801978111267,
-0.22823724150657654,
0.01727103628218174,
0.5158856511116028,
-0.04950103908777237,
0.7331626415252686,
-0.7598204612731934,
0.8446403741836548,
0.4202924966812134,
0.17202751338481903,
0.5693766474723816,
-0.34869563579559326,
1.0417720079421997,
-0.8345929384231567,
0.19959242641925812,
0.49018967151641846,
-0.15169747173786163,
0.42454853653907776,
-0.10254623740911484,
0.2496109902858734,
-0.2619228959083557,
-0.31517818570137024,
-1.306431531906128,
0.173227459192276,
-0.9273859858512878,
0.23683148622512817,
1.100911259651184,
0.14801622927188873,
-0.40818220376968384,
-0.7280927896499634,
-0.5460760593414307,
-0.25654149055480957,
-0.6345004439353943,
0.4944322407245636,
0.7461101412773132,
-0.15785323083400726,
-0.24606648087501526,
-0.8148999214172363,
0.9305738210678101,
-0.03253179416060448,
-0.1469145566225052,
0.014654645696282387,
0.15163946151733398,
0.0241059772670269,
0.4469655752182007,
0.8597371578216553,
-0.23835262656211853,
0.4721963107585907,
0.1228744238615036,
0.1456141620874405,
-0.05852755159139633,
-0.5214738249778748,
-0.8948853611946106,
-0.21528124809265137,
0.24047139286994934,
-0.4041369557380676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01916v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01916v1 | CoLe and LYS at BioASQ MESINESP8 Task: similarity based descriptor assignment in Spanish | 2024-02-02T21:36:03 | 2024-02-02T21:36:03 | Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Shuyuan Cao, Elmurod Kuriyozov | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68P20, 68T50, H.3.3; I.2.7 | In this paper, we describe our participation in the MESINESP Task of the
BioASQ biomedical semantic indexing challenge. The participating system follows
an approach based solely on conventional information retrieval tools. We have
evaluated various alternatives for extracting index terms from IBECS/LILACS
documents in order to be stored in an Apache Lucene index. Those indexed
representations are queried using the contents of the article to be annotated
and a ranked list of candidate labels is created from the retrieved documents.
We also have evaluated a sort of limited Label Powerset approach which creates
meta-labels joining pairs of DeCS labels with high co-occurrence scores, and an
alternative method based on label profile matching. Results obtained in
official runs seem to confirm the suitability of this approach for languages
like Spanish. | [
-0.13017770648002625,
-0.07254858314990997,
0.6110146045684814,
0.24610981345176697,
-0.22740156948566437,
0.29702088236808777,
0.30459505319595337,
-0.8244044184684753,
0.8148621320724487,
0.3534424901008606,
-0.7965105772018433,
-0.5970561504364014,
-0.47770956158638,
0.7776468992233276,
-0.17364917695522308,
0.9123031497001648,
0.06471814215183258,
0.25557437539100647,
-0.24162590503692627,
-0.425309419631958,
-0.07513333112001419,
-0.41560178995132446,
-0.6586835980415344,
-0.13898268342018127,
0.9183918237686157,
0.2914772033691406,
0.5783275961875916,
0.6814287900924683,
0.9197217226028442,
0.3727090060710907,
-0.19365665316581726,
-0.1837041676044464,
-0.3254607915878296,
0.2696816325187683,
-0.8053211569786072,
-0.4009787440299988,
-0.23666882514953613,
-0.05363599583506584,
0.4500303864479065,
0.8457090854644775,
0.26041319966316223,
0.37186649441719055,
-0.225251242518425,
0.6580391526222229,
-0.593951404094696,
0.07121147960424423,
-0.7222157716751099,
0.10180268436670303,
-0.41709136962890625,
-0.3806564211845398,
-0.15229228138923645,
-0.262570321559906,
0.15035289525985718,
-0.32548630237579346,
0.17482812702655792,
0.2393992692232132,
0.7231875061988831,
0.42408719658851624,
-0.4552341103553772,
-0.5640976428985596,
-0.41624364256858826,
0.9641584753990173,
-0.5357171893119812,
0.6097263097763062,
0.13973218202590942,
0.28124120831489563,
-0.17481237649917603,
-0.6186797022819519,
-0.16324713826179504,
-0.08867848664522171,
-0.0616026446223259,
0.21584820747375488,
0.02071664109826088,
0.09682153165340424,
0.3393931984901428,
0.36336731910705566,
-0.5370442867279053,
0.23457984626293182,
-0.7913293242454529,
-0.5913580060005188,
0.44467893242836,
0.27709391713142395,
0.006127233151346445,
-0.04673770070075989,
-0.30386069416999817,
-0.23550604283809662,
-0.7374304533004761,
0.1425970494747162,
0.13077755272388458,
0.2269010692834854,
0.40942108631134033,
0.743492603302002,
-0.5966174602508545,
0.33501341938972473,
0.07687364518642426,
-0.17546746134757996,
0.7234189510345459,
-0.20573052763938904,
0.00019268579490017146,
0.2187587320804596,
0.7365627288818359,
0.40501436591148376,
-0.21942564845085144,
-0.28909265995025635,
-0.09578772634267807,
-0.02244655229151249,
-0.029112113639712334,
-0.805074155330658,
0.15111234784126282,
0.27213895320892334,
-0.44892439246177673,
-0.3220987617969513,
0.23387788236141205,
-0.7902036309242249,
-0.09321890771389008,
-0.09536921232938766,
0.4458996653556824,
-0.23499150574207306,
0.36479952931404114,
-0.11593944579362869,
-0.3953276574611664,
0.3020009994506836,
-0.03528427705168724,
-1.1194716691970825,
0.23005446791648865,
0.4845641255378723,
0.6264323592185974,
-0.32041051983833313,
-0.12966768443584442,
-0.21137593686580658,
0.3803396224975586,
-0.014212774112820625,
0.5929437279701233,
-0.5507643222808838,
-0.2563925087451935,
-0.38552325963974,
0.7045327425003052,
-0.35602882504463196,
-0.5791551470756531,
0.5179333686828613,
-0.3353540897369385,
-0.042399484664201736,
-0.4301120936870575,
-0.303727388381958,
0.07234117388725281,
0.10004501044750214,
-0.6385600566864014,
0.9820652008056641,
0.35356393456459045,
-0.8121398687362671,
-0.18436171114444733,
-0.6804530024528503,
-0.17097368836402893,
0.17727860808372498,
-0.2621838450431824,
0.005802909377962351,
-0.13540464639663696,
-0.2543182969093323,
0.2917618751525879,
-0.2766394317150116,
0.07296482473611832,
-0.10177143663167953,
-0.137294203042984,
0.35570409893989563,
-0.033504415303468704,
0.9208772778511047,
0.35304802656173706,
-0.27533185482025146,
0.18562449514865875,
-0.7545884847640991,
0.02332247979938984,
-0.1252555251121521,
-0.15143224596977234,
-0.5358337163925171,
-0.14972318708896637,
-0.18846839666366577,
0.2560129165649414,
0.5767208933830261,
-1.0267057418823242,
0.051046039909124374,
-0.60010826587677,
0.21778710186481476,
0.45288097858428955,
0.038940493017435074,
0.3174739480018616,
-0.14898192882537842,
0.5021257400512695,
-0.2216179519891739,
0.32699814438819885,
0.10776583105325699,
-0.4993313252925873,
-0.5033872127532959,
-0.24969568848609924,
0.45452120900154114,
0.9192622900009155,
-0.8200613260269165,
0.3711419403553009,
-0.18560905754566193,
-0.6008172631263733,
-0.7153505682945251,
-0.19161802530288696,
0.461718887090683,
0.5839188098907471,
0.6182782053947449,
-0.2326442301273346,
-0.38764235377311707,
-1.2734363079071045,
0.1284177452325821,
0.10088229179382324,
-0.4846009314060211,
0.31933730840682983,
0.6286244988441467,
-0.5641946792602539,
0.4919004440307617,
-0.4329818785190582,
-0.4300670325756073,
0.3332233130931854,
0.0758500024676323,
0.44447219371795654,
0.5303701758384705,
0.7418071627616882,
-0.6087154150009155,
-0.12030679732561111,
0.055372290313243866,
-0.6174070835113525,
-0.44672882556915283,
0.36773040890693665,
-0.14760705828666687,
-0.003958013840019703,
0.8095014095306396,
-0.011187983676791191,
0.2761666178703308,
0.6108154058456421,
-0.3310641348361969,
0.45784953236579895,
-0.22618752717971802,
0.5086975693702698,
-1.0179704427719116,
0.15378719568252563,
-0.3045780062675476,
-0.2567770779132843,
-0.11586804687976837,
0.10160429775714874,
-0.0008030819008126855,
-0.03883146867156029,
-0.6619831323623657,
0.4709400534629822,
-0.32016271352767944,
-0.03414184972643852,
-0.007504826411604881,
-0.25932610034942627,
0.12895381450653076,
0.31455615162849426,
0.0652543157339096,
0.6145687103271484,
0.34303349256515503,
-0.4006215035915375,
0.48694437742233276,
0.33001744747161865,
-0.054704900830984116,
0.6168184876441956,
-0.8307392597198486,
-0.20201006531715393,
-0.2598799765110016,
0.05225066840648651,
-0.7743167877197266,
0.039050549268722534,
0.38678357005119324,
-0.08625231683254242,
0.1164836436510086,
0.2620280981063843,
-0.08471228927373886,
-0.7305598258972168,
-0.8174179196357727,
0.5724506974220276,
0.05400305986404419,
-0.4294998347759247,
0.1753140538930893,
0.4489237368106842,
-0.19598530232906342,
-0.7005598545074463,
-0.6767131090164185,
-0.03522918000817299,
-0.46944090723991394,
-0.3328152596950531,
0.8500177264213562,
-0.0680907666683197,
-0.1634456217288971,
0.08098786324262619,
-0.05314362421631813,
-0.0387851856648922,
0.1828135848045349,
0.346116840839386,
-0.13327357172966003,
-0.22275030612945557,
0.11262109875679016,
0.302036315202713,
-0.2813767194747925,
-0.04163012653589249,
0.04700080305337906,
0.1683773696422577,
-0.24725300073623657,
-0.15912309288978577,
-0.31812262535095215,
0.6751250624656677,
0.40595346689224243,
-0.3165062963962555,
0.6165512800216675,
0.2444164901971817,
-0.3051425516605377,
0.3942849636077881,
-0.29333338141441345,
-0.10525667667388916,
-0.462219774723053,
0.34686538577079773,
-0.5819942951202393,
-0.7967355251312256,
0.794823944568634,
-0.34772926568984985,
-0.12136437743902206,
0.7900984287261963,
0.553909420967102,
-0.46131229400634766,
0.8170595169067383,
0.722065806388855,
0.15120360255241394,
0.3547385036945343,
-0.2977125942707062,
0.20542116463184357,
-1.0111291408538818,
-0.4876594841480255,
-0.9774124026298523,
-0.4879743158817291,
-0.7254631519317627,
-0.5125453472137451,
0.6022465229034424,
-0.14502789080142975,
0.07432425022125244,
0.5306171774864197,
-0.6240516304969788,
0.3810381591320038,
0.7043973803520203,
0.2744522988796234,
0.22228825092315674,
-0.37723082304000854,
-0.1769995093345642,
-0.1361142098903656,
-0.48362722992897034,
-0.49201035499572754,
0.734887421131134,
0.20310857892036438,
0.6951002478599548,
0.164747416973114,
0.8643748164176941,
0.1750633865594864,
0.2278754711151123,
-0.7530514001846313,
0.3737878203392029,
-0.2085590362548828,
-0.4204953610897064,
-0.4074353575706482,
-0.09627920389175415,
-1.3360356092453003,
-0.027650946751236916,
-0.40263473987579346,
-1.0517514944076538,
0.5805783867835999,
-0.2900754511356354,
-0.17279423773288727,
-0.37261852622032166,
-0.2783428728580475,
1.1033705472946167,
-0.4147737920284271,
-0.19714562594890594,
-0.16924355924129486,
-0.9527040123939514,
-0.16741326451301575,
0.030117783695459366,
0.09205301105976105,
-0.3836676776409149,
-0.06686615943908691,
1.249309778213501,
-0.48540008068084717,
0.30650147795677185,
0.18535473942756653,
0.07719629257917404,
0.28141167759895325,
-0.14876173436641693,
-0.060721613466739655,
-0.16327714920043945,
-0.47757798433303833,
0.1185663565993309,
1.05377995967865,
-0.36954978108406067,
-0.3829278349876404,
0.7324967980384827,
-0.4656080901622772,
-0.3233744502067566,
-0.6469006538391113,
-0.520951509475708,
-0.033095117658376694,
0.2907920479774475,
0.26326993107795715,
0.4899342358112335,
-0.2160436362028122,
0.32881635427474976,
0.3304542899131775,
-0.22405017912387848,
0.16879142820835114,
0.5645791888237,
-0.07986296713352203,
-0.17760591208934784,
0.9511262774467468,
0.1458885669708252,
0.01351325586438179,
0.67789626121521,
0.3060831129550934,
-0.6039896607398987,
-0.5240695476531982,
-0.20999766886234283,
0.41656067967414856,
-0.5931107401847839,
-0.486269474029541,
-0.5043774843215942,
-0.10857059061527252,
-0.5007765293121338,
-0.16846446692943573,
-0.31438472867012024,
-0.6232278347015381,
-0.043495405465364456,
-0.05176296457648277,
0.32524776458740234,
0.5681622624397278,
-0.17633289098739624,
0.2542271912097931,
-0.7240458130836487,
0.2738170921802521,
0.03131198510527611,
0.2457236647605896,
-0.3923332393169403,
-0.12666387856006622,
-0.3077077865600586,
0.16082686185836792,
-0.4939524829387665,
-1.3677977323532104,
0.1391630619764328,
0.1956731677055359,
0.7014014720916748,
0.4422679543495178,
0.19098591804504395,
0.4379691779613495,
-0.39526641368865967,
0.39284154772758484,
-0.0964316576719284,
-0.6035746335983276,
0.7177777886390686,
-0.3571227192878723,
0.0802234634757042,
1.1260701417922974,
0.9106100797653198,
-0.391630083322525,
-0.7190788984298706,
-0.6712227463722229,
-0.9713941812515259,
0.30700165033340454,
0.029795754700899124,
-0.21381732821464539,
-0.544303834438324,
0.381361186504364,
0.04549027606844902,
0.04971187934279442,
-0.559637725353241,
-0.27678629755973816,
0.13577347993850708,
-0.7245596647262573,
0.29956215620040894,
-0.4719947874546051,
0.07591097056865692,
-0.3482266366481781,
0.8256624341011047,
-0.23362182080745697,
0.11740870028734207,
0.5341167449951172,
-0.15849344432353973,
0.19476832449436188,
0.22102093696594238,
0.26644080877304077,
0.5143402218818665,
-0.5239098072052002,
0.22272931039333344,
-0.05583207681775093,
-0.2961888611316681,
0.17157204449176788,
0.012374146841466427,
-0.3696719706058502,
0.06550881266593933,
0.13656315207481384,
0.27274811267852783,
0.4194706678390503,
-0.9879920482635498,
0.36280950903892517,
0.022795604541897774,
-0.15126295387744904,
-0.03481609746813774,
-0.18478955328464508,
0.10635044425725937,
0.4106716513633728,
0.46729421615600586,
-0.4045364558696747,
0.7622246742248535,
-0.7303717136383057,
0.33210060000419617,
0.6370745897293091,
-0.5809884071350098,
-0.3250654935836792,
0.6899253129959106,
0.28491684794425964,
-0.23968097567558289,
0.30532702803611755,
-0.30300500988960266,
-0.6576879620552063,
0.817085862159729,
0.6180959939956665,
0.4175706207752228,
-0.5000956654548645,
0.28755250573158264,
0.5918797850608826,
0.051268331706523895,
-0.004375452641397715,
0.28394177556037903,
0.08644111454486847,
-0.4893045723438263,
-0.19328732788562775,
-0.7680867314338684,
-0.542823076248169,
0.03570513799786568,
-0.5785707235336304,
0.5566133260726929,
-0.3248004913330078,
0.000059988869907101616,
0.2931250035762787,
-0.06178489327430725,
-0.5134721398353577,
0.19002853333950043,
0.08759863674640656,
0.6787819266319275,
-1.1277188062667847,
0.49025610089302063,
0.6635327935218811,
-0.31844934821128845,
-0.49167600274086,
-0.6084656715393066,
-0.0654047280550003,
-0.500038206577301,
0.33314594626426697,
0.23751863837242126,
-0.049776431173086166,
0.05410870537161827,
-0.19915266335010529,
-1.1077998876571655,
1.3508570194244385,
0.12335924804210663,
-0.3872627317905426,
-0.07830507308244705,
0.16129298508167267,
0.836169421672821,
-0.24265605211257935,
0.5885292887687683,
0.5936689972877502,
0.4077921211719513,
0.26195207238197327,
-1.1009891033172607,
0.06891527771949768,
-0.2045259326696396,
-0.3372268080711365,
0.06546519696712494,
-0.5291576981544495,
0.6966187953948975,
0.0087950574234128,
-0.13790805637836456,
0.4491969645023346,
0.5906404256820679,
-0.03726893663406372,
0.589779257774353,
0.19424602389335632,
0.34688809514045715,
0.9830690026283264,
0.11257912963628769,
0.8311436176300049,
-0.2335711270570755,
0.36271774768829346,
0.9043503403663635,
-0.11038549244403839,
0.6146070957183838,
0.8397126793861389,
-0.45276010036468506,
0.4166007936000824,
0.869103193283081,
-0.07527721673250198,
0.655622661113739,
0.26535871624946594,
-0.16655893623828888,
0.3839533030986786,
-0.6919518113136292,
-0.44202640652656555,
0.5792648792266846,
0.5620511770248413,
-0.49375858902931213,
-0.45904192328453064,
0.06619945168495178,
-0.30181917548179626,
0.16774828732013702,
-0.37403708696365356,
0.7881936430931091,
-0.04072035104036331,
-0.32004743814468384,
0.3235888183116913,
0.16231083869934082,
0.7163006067276001,
-0.39678069949150085,
0.007195459678769112,
-0.03451230004429817,
0.08513545989990234,
-0.36867445707321167,
-0.6375318765640259,
0.8344985842704773,
-0.3311287760734558,
-0.24921815097332,
-0.11536113172769547,
0.46769052743911743,
-0.557987630367279,
-0.8187114596366882,
0.22790244221687317,
0.4692273437976837,
0.6546273827552795,
0.1922767013311386,
-0.7354228496551514,
-0.19699440896511078,
-0.0036908958572894335,
0.1296187788248062,
0.2944261431694031,
0.444315105676651,
-0.6598154902458191,
0.5443918108940125,
0.20300160348415375,
-0.05512703210115433,
0.17761600017547607,
0.0073395404033362865,
0.5049839019775391,
-0.7443305253982544,
-0.19300514459609985,
-0.5949493050575256,
-0.10133541375398636,
0.1436747908592224,
-0.027100134640932083,
0.5088109374046326,
0.8834500312805176,
0.5498703718185425,
-0.29727333784103394,
0.31808555126190186,
-0.24026358127593994,
0.8014088869094849,
-0.3927510678768158,
0.18684469163417816,
-0.34733518958091736,
-0.08599480986595154,
-0.3724633455276489,
-1.0674878358840942,
-0.35888344049453735,
0.6638947129249573,
-0.05386873334646225,
-0.5539672374725342,
1.0720773935317993,
0.9455797672271729,
0.015593241900205612,
-0.3548538088798523,
0.0914229303598404,
0.08770307153463364,
0.2433384358882904,
0.8343691825866699,
0.5108029842376709,
-0.4903111159801483,
0.13783961534500122,
-0.57822185754776,
-0.4055286943912506,
-0.11708763241767883,
-0.8525339961051941,
-0.6164944767951965,
-0.7989715337753296,
-0.39804309606552124,
-0.3914167284965515,
0.11056726425886154,
0.9211881160736084,
-0.04326840862631798,
-1.0801805257797241,
-0.048846710473299026,
0.4599013328552246,
0.35249412059783936,
-0.16941848397254944,
-0.18444709479808807,
0.4516889452934265,
0.04450088366866112,
-0.9986934661865234,
0.4123736023902893,
0.31130945682525635,
0.13329742848873138,
0.08598992228507996,
0.2974899113178253,
-0.4432731568813324,
-0.2203214317560196,
0.45293962955474854,
0.5723951458930969,
-0.3178861141204834,
-0.5716825127601624,
0.23869121074676514,
-0.2352420836687088,
-0.0076226843520998955,
0.5442335605621338,
-0.9464530348777771,
0.06654234230518341,
0.6760194897651672,
0.593218982219696,
0.44855421781539917,
0.17610348761081696,
0.23724456131458282,
-0.45395901799201965,
0.6352100372314453,
0.3454885184764862,
0.2160012274980545,
0.3295260965824127,
-0.2953127920627594,
0.8531793355941772,
0.16139601171016693,
-0.34091460704803467,
-0.5262806415557861,
0.015275416895747185,
-1.3735270500183105,
-0.0030315371695905924,
0.8758860230445862,
0.2872794568538666,
-0.6182193756103516,
-0.21576809883117676,
-0.40592196583747864,
0.025767339393496513,
-0.12303332984447479,
0.6664304137229919,
0.2371010184288025,
-0.20674891769886017,
0.2588518261909485,
-0.31342312693595886,
0.531882107257843,
0.3332277536392212,
-0.45545631647109985,
-0.524532675743103,
0.1905980259180069,
0.18725405633449554,
0.5330852270126343,
0.9436739683151245,
-0.2979276180267334,
0.14016374945640564,
-0.46632999181747437,
0.19155395030975342,
0.24542905390262604,
-0.25680506229400635,
0.021466808393597603,
-0.24810144305229187,
0.04331161826848984,
-0.2981765568256378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01912v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01912v1 | Natural language guidance of high-fidelity text-to-speech with synthetic annotations | 2024-02-02T21:29:34 | 2024-02-02T21:29:34 | Dan Lyth, Simon King | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Text-to-speech models trained on large-scale datasets have demonstrated
impressive in-context learning capabilities and naturalness. However, control
of speaker identity and style in these models typically requires conditioning
on reference speech recordings, limiting creative applications. Alternatively,
natural language prompting of speaker identity and style has demonstrated
promising results and provides an intuitive method of control. However,
reliance on human-labeled descriptions prevents scaling to large datasets. Our
work bridges the gap between these two approaches. We propose a scalable method
for labeling various aspects of speaker identity, style, and recording
conditions. We then apply this method to a 45k hour dataset, which we use to
train a speech language model. Furthermore, we propose simple methods for
increasing audio fidelity, significantly outperforming recent work despite
relying entirely on found data. Our results demonstrate high-fidelity speech
generation in a diverse range of accents, prosodic styles, channel conditions,
and acoustic conditions, all accomplished with a single model and intuitive
natural language conditioning. Audio samples can be heard at
https://text-description-to-speech.com/. | [
-0.5228826403617859,
-0.9173805117607117,
0.18257281184196472,
0.3157498836517334,
-0.23384550213813782,
0.015496174804866314,
-0.5733895897865295,
-0.5597838163375854,
0.25205931067466736,
0.727794885635376,
-0.5127629041671753,
-0.39210864901542664,
-0.38290804624557495,
0.19163574278354645,
-0.2688978910446167,
1.0496912002563477,
0.3676255941390991,
0.11094262450933456,
-0.07568563520908356,
-0.06024584174156189,
-0.584430456161499,
-0.6106501221656799,
-0.7766686677932739,
-0.34713903069496155,
0.42149725556373596,
0.4233604073524475,
0.8865494728088379,
0.9388249516487122,
0.2808842957019806,
0.22406311333179474,
-0.23719729483127594,
0.4178370535373688,
-0.2633536159992218,
0.06005644425749779,
-0.15806280076503754,
0.07901903986930847,
-0.4624168574810028,
0.11178616434335709,
0.8404450416564941,
0.8988871574401855,
-0.14687611162662506,
0.03704280033707619,
-0.006793275475502014,
0.4390547275543213,
-0.31691718101501465,
0.1673893928527832,
-0.601311206817627,
0.012668821960687637,
-0.22214262187480927,
-0.3342433273792267,
-0.7929486036300659,
-0.35194411873817444,
0.46527954936027527,
-0.901238203048706,
0.1478217989206314,
0.2509060800075531,
0.6436022520065308,
0.36819595098495483,
-0.34471163153648376,
-0.2029835283756256,
-1.1529927253723145,
0.6372169256210327,
-0.5371423363685608,
0.4246482253074646,
0.5761646032333374,
0.6046879291534424,
-0.0057458216324448586,
-0.6869245171546936,
-0.4262380003929138,
-0.34356018900871277,
-0.045339640229940414,
-0.07750700414180756,
0.2343718707561493,
0.21245749294757843,
0.26040971279144287,
0.29824844002723694,
-0.32960185408592224,
0.10195652395486832,
-0.28992193937301636,
-0.44074922800064087,
0.7827232480049133,
-0.3214777112007141,
0.21056286990642548,
-0.060814037919044495,
-0.294118732213974,
-0.2639894485473633,
-0.4883129596710205,
-0.1281498521566391,
0.47565051913261414,
0.7616009712219238,
-0.1364351212978363,
0.532636284828186,
-0.24917331337928772,
0.7440565824508667,
0.18577782809734344,
-0.2956865727901459,
0.30182909965515137,
-0.474776953458786,
-0.1014292985200882,
0.5538397431373596,
0.6680734157562256,
0.2222285121679306,
0.48376965522766113,
-0.5064471960067749,
-0.06660273671150208,
-0.21102400124073029,
0.31586816906929016,
-0.6918003559112549,
-0.2505238950252533,
-0.021023325622081757,
-0.07103607803583145,
-0.1659979373216629,
-0.025335799902677536,
-0.7068251967430115,
-0.38403379917144775,
-0.8126469254493713,
0.64650559425354,
-0.40956881642341614,
-0.08038073778152466,
-0.019070103764533997,
-0.19146378338336945,
-0.010232312604784966,
0.14307701587677002,
-1.1461735963821411,
0.2993529438972473,
0.3564341366291046,
0.6997203826904297,
-0.10179367661476135,
0.04331330955028534,
-0.8663365840911865,
0.3820604383945465,
-0.49178650975227356,
0.5610088109970093,
-0.652267336845398,
-0.36191314458847046,
-0.015705864876508713,
-0.25581812858581543,
0.3592035174369812,
-0.4783315360546112,
0.6508598327636719,
-0.11499766260385513,
0.3213932514190674,
-0.21627916395664215,
-0.46982407569885254,
0.017008131369948387,
-0.11579912155866623,
-0.6675596237182617,
0.9168812036514282,
-0.07798410952091217,
-0.5669846534729004,
0.4662960171699524,
-0.47967928647994995,
-0.573382556438446,
0.23371466994285583,
-0.07393278181552887,
-0.3685501217842102,
-0.040723465383052826,
0.24191799759864807,
0.4103628695011139,
-0.1324927806854248,
0.4383939206600189,
0.03971198573708534,
-0.17400838434696198,
0.1877959966659546,
-0.41955459117889404,
0.3379157781600952,
0.17606289684772491,
-0.28040558099746704,
0.1715889573097229,
-1.0581258535385132,
-0.05021221935749054,
-0.05705787241458893,
-0.3680316209793091,
-0.26135095953941345,
0.09346947073936462,
0.35158950090408325,
-0.11065967381000519,
0.02673640102148056,
-0.5374051332473755,
0.014406241476535797,
-0.6132180094718933,
0.49508872628211975,
0.4558717608451843,
0.23299501836299896,
0.6069071888923645,
-0.28933995962142944,
0.24445542693138123,
-0.422774076461792,
-0.0879552885890007,
-0.4114094376564026,
-0.5394282341003418,
-0.4961390793323517,
-0.31505075097084045,
0.25236862897872925,
0.5131498575210571,
-0.6235229969024658,
0.5274667143821716,
-0.28953760862350464,
-0.5042126774787903,
-0.5821764469146729,
0.0055924984626472,
0.4974924325942993,
0.6570127010345459,
0.736769437789917,
-0.05306794121861458,
-0.721517026424408,
-0.9937810301780701,
-0.31276795268058777,
-0.029636718332767487,
-0.4064224362373352,
0.40050187706947327,
0.020887350663542747,
-0.11995399743318558,
1.1201846599578857,
-0.1917925477027893,
-0.20276843011379242,
0.026765502989292145,
0.5390781164169312,
-0.10902189463376999,
0.5365076661109924,
0.2730556130409241,
-0.8372285962104797,
-0.3325977325439453,
0.0021486778277903795,
-0.16442780196666718,
-0.17975005507469177,
-0.40284815430641174,
-0.25367653369903564,
0.09643763303756714,
0.6124987006187439,
-0.2630660831928253,
-0.021765997633337975,
0.4585726857185364,
-0.1261623352766037,
0.4656871557235718,
-0.36819612979888916,
-0.04920809343457222,
-1.2349005937576294,
0.066298708319664,
0.2889312505722046,
-0.3180517554283142,
-0.8793861269950867,
-0.4555424153804779,
-0.2037762701511383,
-0.1907273530960083,
-0.32890090346336365,
0.6473743915557861,
-0.1370312124490738,
0.15123409032821655,
-0.18174852430820465,
0.33690303564071655,
-0.07990841567516327,
0.3528456687927246,
0.370985746383667,
0.7978715300559998,
0.43025901913642883,
-0.7458916306495667,
0.491050660610199,
0.4243331253528595,
-0.172586128115654,
0.6949383020401001,
-0.6891119480133057,
0.3644388020038605,
-0.22758476436138153,
0.48958882689476013,
-0.9912700653076172,
-0.6753053665161133,
0.0611339695751667,
-0.5289477705955505,
0.4582553505897522,
-0.16625598073005676,
-0.5302361249923706,
0.05925654619932175,
0.11707069724798203,
0.2971302568912506,
0.5188708901405334,
-0.7811029553413391,
0.5024632215499878,
0.3493480682373047,
-0.4118233919143677,
-0.13545037806034088,
-0.6678643822669983,
0.3558332622051239,
-0.3582462668418884,
-0.34117409586906433,
0.7838900685310364,
-0.15849052369594574,
-0.2345661222934723,
-0.48323556780815125,
-0.001898009330034256,
-0.27854591608047485,
-0.12277073413133621,
0.285388708114624,
0.21440833806991577,
0.015783730894327164,
0.5387618541717529,
0.051794666796922684,
-0.09616127610206604,
0.0949503555893898,
-0.4015359580516815,
0.21339920163154602,
0.13476109504699707,
0.02141924761235714,
-0.7130215764045715,
0.4055626392364502,
0.2835882902145386,
-0.3230941593647003,
0.507099986076355,
0.7437039017677307,
-0.35226789116859436,
-0.2695479691028595,
-0.4714961051940918,
-0.3685227632522583,
-0.4611258804798126,
0.2968553304672241,
-0.12203898280858994,
-0.6898902654647827,
0.05680854618549347,
0.06908458471298218,
0.2218770980834961,
0.28167426586151123,
0.4533713161945343,
-0.03874661400914192,
1.106231927871704,
0.5048404932022095,
0.026237891986966133,
0.5031550526618958,
0.08560147881507874,
0.1804814487695694,
-0.5417712926864624,
-0.3292439579963684,
-0.6501093506813049,
-0.07921212911605835,
-0.7450400590896606,
-0.3572595715522766,
0.1747714877128601,
-0.13386525213718414,
-0.2305094599723816,
0.35690170526504517,
-0.8156393766403198,
0.3967724144458771,
0.6708027720451355,
0.046461351215839386,
0.15356075763702393,
0.060512859374284744,
0.12625037133693695,
-0.22174350917339325,
-0.4184719920158386,
-0.5612879991531372,
0.911666750907898,
0.4840886890888214,
0.6203212738037109,
-0.06833452731370926,
0.5761606097221375,
0.32245030999183655,
0.03283543884754181,
-0.7960447072982788,
0.2966599464416504,
-0.06319267302751541,
-0.586070716381073,
-0.508305013179779,
-0.44531604647636414,
-0.5395171642303467,
-0.17505432665348053,
-0.3259044289588928,
-0.7171250581741333,
-0.020706871524453163,
0.5925623178482056,
-0.5290109515190125,
-0.13459321856498718,
-0.8131237626075745,
0.5496906638145447,
-0.008042051456868649,
-0.33796006441116333,
0.000782655319198966,
-0.6918520927429199,
0.05336614325642586,
-0.18660135567188263,
0.3015153408050537,
-0.06369515508413315,
0.07627549022436142,
0.8516272306442261,
-0.09259452670812607,
0.8101302981376648,
-0.21507681906223297,
-0.18934781849384308,
0.2213120311498642,
-0.03932631388306618,
0.5407776236534119,
0.2120518982410431,
-0.09546661376953125,
-0.1129569560289383,
-0.048064492642879486,
-0.26632651686668396,
-0.5269832015037537,
0.44018566608428955,
-0.531708836555481,
-0.22580859065055847,
0.09737884998321533,
-0.661860466003418,
-0.6462297439575195,
0.06597927957773209,
0.38500624895095825,
0.786078155040741,
-0.1319076120853424,
0.5115282535552979,
0.9521406888961792,
-0.28865280747413635,
0.4626501798629761,
0.04858415573835373,
0.0004924939712509513,
-0.5919464826583862,
0.9996287822723389,
0.09349528700113297,
0.5526052117347717,
0.42394310235977173,
0.4225705862045288,
-0.488814115524292,
-0.3993737995624542,
-0.44268760085105896,
0.16855807602405548,
-0.3888680934906006,
0.17894858121871948,
-0.29572761058807373,
-0.16339541971683502,
-0.5437748432159424,
-0.1481703668832779,
-0.5643954277038574,
-0.6137232184410095,
-0.2884637415409088,
-0.07110818475484848,
0.4094930589199066,
0.5787956118583679,
0.10271606594324112,
0.5931082367897034,
-0.541540801525116,
0.42208632826805115,
0.5453762412071228,
0.26732146739959717,
-0.4131215512752533,
-0.7619104981422424,
-0.25264665484428406,
0.3807327449321747,
-0.08963210135698318,
-0.7853008508682251,
0.40737226605415344,
0.6338093280792236,
0.4173647165298462,
0.39982739090919495,
0.30729401111602783,
0.5090734958648682,
-0.5540370345115662,
0.8382553458213806,
0.06143819913268089,
-0.9287996292114258,
0.7703427076339722,
-0.47684401273727417,
0.41205382347106934,
0.4466014504432678,
0.3211953938007355,
-0.5912652015686035,
-0.36088094115257263,
-0.5165757536888123,
-0.8586956858634949,
0.5422309041023254,
0.23222152888774872,
0.3874591290950775,
0.10930043458938599,
0.34371548891067505,
-0.023049740120768547,
0.16821007430553436,
-0.6567658185958862,
-0.24264535307884216,
-0.4496237337589264,
-0.08735205978155136,
-0.32793161273002625,
-0.1253901571035385,
-0.38899269700050354,
-0.22582963109016418,
0.7410449385643005,
-0.35861340165138245,
0.20506954193115234,
0.27520304918289185,
0.12087151408195496,
-0.050638191401958466,
0.37188881635665894,
0.7167714834213257,
0.42051467299461365,
-0.21313706040382385,
0.19134166836738586,
0.1370561122894287,
-0.2358154058456421,
-0.10296578705310822,
0.14129118621349335,
0.020566515624523163,
0.15597301721572876,
0.35518792271614075,
1.085455060005188,
0.25059935450553894,
-0.4871170222759247,
0.1483621895313263,
0.13127541542053223,
-0.3467697501182556,
-0.2976152300834656,
0.015551540069282055,
0.12700144946575165,
-0.1679573804140091,
0.31394511461257935,
-0.09561847895383835,
0.01764768920838833,
-0.45376384258270264,
0.15888376533985138,
0.21184468269348145,
-0.5343688130378723,
-0.1665271669626236,
0.70852130651474,
0.4662342369556427,
-0.6608916521072388,
0.5317011475563049,
-0.17282754182815552,
-0.10189642757177353,
0.3101936876773834,
0.530561089515686,
0.788465142250061,
-0.31585654616355896,
0.19105535745620728,
0.42925572395324707,
0.07726023346185684,
-0.0937039852142334,
-0.004414415452629328,
-0.432155966758728,
-0.39335960149765015,
-0.6252810955047607,
-0.6257680654525757,
-0.6614729166030884,
0.04896162450313568,
-0.6902495622634888,
0.18874123692512512,
-0.44957247376441956,
-0.34115737676620483,
0.3525697886943817,
-0.19028089940547943,
-0.2421635389328003,
0.38616040349006653,
0.4493344724178314,
0.8372136950492859,
-0.8827852606773376,
0.9020950794219971,
0.4503330886363983,
-0.20624293386936188,
-0.8408403396606445,
0.03637146204710007,
0.00003639824717538431,
-0.2042393833398819,
0.4484233856201172,
0.21046625077724457,
-0.1570201963186264,
0.1520819514989853,
-0.5472317337989807,
-0.720417857170105,
0.761168897151947,
0.5030063986778259,
-0.57480388879776,
-0.21793317794799805,
0.21127630770206451,
0.6205744743347168,
-0.3186863362789154,
-0.016708925366401672,
0.6691008806228638,
0.6519147157669067,
0.5160996317863464,
-1.1844987869262695,
-0.31949612498283386,
-0.04837137833237648,
0.08328947424888611,
0.0733717679977417,
-0.2258104681968689,
0.41195014119148254,
-0.067411869764328,
-0.06966604292392731,
-0.15040159225463867,
0.8125063180923462,
0.10607905685901642,
0.13157717883586884,
0.5000070929527283,
0.25540798902511597,
0.7914374470710754,
-0.1847802847623825,
0.8331217169761658,
-0.14860226213932037,
0.01778380386531353,
1.411711573600769,
0.103515625,
0.7992814183235168,
0.4832155108451843,
0.07190375030040741,
0.15387597680091858,
0.5658328533172607,
0.14379248023033142,
0.41846516728401184,
0.1822923868894577,
-0.32958510518074036,
-0.34580734372138977,
-0.5663353204727173,
-0.30565932393074036,
0.3905249536037445,
0.23709985613822937,
-0.31246551871299744,
0.1285780817270279,
0.12793943285942078,
0.008255671709775925,
0.4643402397632599,
-0.10020443797111511,
0.806152880191803,
-0.16854692995548248,
-0.6788785457611084,
0.6209214925765991,
-0.3357350826263428,
0.6256282925605774,
-0.5085054039955139,
-0.12182092666625977,
0.06891242414712906,
-0.20743495225906372,
-0.17692407965660095,
-0.46991801261901855,
0.2572614252567291,
-0.09258849173784256,
-0.1680988073348999,
-0.6208661198616028,
0.1856653243303299,
-0.7191401720046997,
-0.39813175797462463,
-0.03359294310212135,
-0.1503225415945053,
-0.06619765609502792,
-0.07172051072120667,
-0.06692387908697128,
-0.16947807371616364,
-0.10438136011362076,
-0.13975514471530914,
0.04828588292002678,
0.32744163274765015,
0.03767171874642372,
0.6360412240028381,
0.5450900793075562,
0.3815264105796814,
0.19692175090312958,
0.1291629523038864,
0.3825041353702545,
-0.29532375931739807,
-0.5686817765235901,
-0.6495329737663269,
0.43777602910995483,
-0.2788463532924652,
-0.38083237409591675,
0.5465722680091858,
0.5213965773582458,
0.8597549796104431,
0.03136765584349632,
0.6858373284339905,
0.2294798344373703,
0.7553407549858093,
-0.5630937218666077,
0.5431045293807983,
-0.13942207396030426,
0.02781371772289276,
-0.34170517325401306,
-0.8946430683135986,
-0.2377418428659439,
0.47267842292785645,
-0.05558418110013008,
0.02001628652215004,
0.3931143581867218,
0.857494592666626,
0.07871702313423157,
0.0322115495800972,
0.2689830958843231,
-0.03494073823094368,
0.4383492171764374,
0.10044645518064499,
0.48571836948394775,
-0.058348655700683594,
0.5888368487358093,
-0.4410811960697174,
-0.09825067967176437,
-0.1542963683605194,
-1.0015500783920288,
-0.7022801637649536,
-0.7852248549461365,
-0.5956721305847168,
-0.21936316788196564,
0.05913034826517105,
1.1804311275482178,
1.282812237739563,
-0.6633326411247253,
-0.18572327494621277,
-0.12197975814342499,
-0.35446441173553467,
-0.21711504459381104,
-0.15304827690124512,
0.12848372757434845,
-0.41087961196899414,
-0.9744490385055542,
0.7647570967674255,
0.11474286764860153,
0.39852991700172424,
-0.33549609780311584,
-0.3201693594455719,
0.01985531859099865,
0.3923071324825287,
0.5079512596130371,
0.39085128903388977,
-0.7847802639007568,
-0.3217437267303467,
-0.41110044717788696,
-0.07205472141504288,
0.0021055927500128746,
0.6831757426261902,
-0.754764974117279,
0.8533363342285156,
0.34167903661727905,
0.6396326422691345,
0.4382442533969879,
0.21891121566295624,
0.8148190975189209,
-1.2417479753494263,
0.20435956120491028,
0.37782803177833557,
-0.12729717791080475,
0.46356263756752014,
-0.3290615379810333,
0.17753253877162933,
-0.0050279200077056885,
-0.5457720756530762,
-0.8229261040687561,
0.17358842492103577,
-1.1038355827331543,
0.14619693160057068,
1.2648013830184937,
0.13024385273456573,
0.07492388784885406,
0.054973188787698746,
-0.5832014083862305,
0.49454715847969055,
-0.5034288167953491,
0.7559452652931213,
0.5967458486557007,
-0.05309201031923294,
-0.07606977969408035,
-0.6733179688453674,
0.8878467082977295,
0.24478164315223694,
-0.7659303545951843,
0.33532246947288513,
0.5070714354515076,
-0.13480287790298462,
0.24695360660552979,
0.20250651240348816,
0.24608571827411652,
0.1110461950302124,
-0.12989000976085663,
0.1564299464225769,
-0.17659421265125275,
-0.5292612910270691,
-0.2703840732574463,
-0.01351726334542036,
0.21981294453144073,
-0.316234290599823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01878v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01878v2 | LiPO: Listwise Preference Optimization through Learning-to-Rank | 2024-02-02T20:08:10 | 2024-05-22T18:51:02 | Tianqi Liu, Zhen Qin, Junru Wu, Jiaming Shen, Misha Khalman, Rishabh Joshi, Yao Zhao, Mohammad Saleh, Simon Baumgartner, Jialu Liu, Peter J. Liu, Xuanhui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Aligning language models (LMs) with curated human feedback is critical to
control their behaviors in real-world applications. Several recent policy
optimization methods, such as DPO and SLiC, serve as promising alternatives to
the traditional Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) approach. In
practice, human feedback often comes in a format of a ranked list over multiple
responses to amortize the cost of reading prompt. Multiple responses can also
be ranked by reward models or AI feedback. There lacks such a thorough study on
directly fitting upon a list of responses. In this work, we formulate the LM
alignment as a \textit{listwise} ranking problem and describe the LiPO
framework, where the policy can potentially learn more effectively from a
ranked list of plausible responses given the prompt. This view draws an
explicit connection to Learning-to-Rank (LTR), where most existing preference
optimization work can be mapped to existing ranking objectives. Following this
connection, we provide an examination of ranking objectives that are not well
studied for LM alignment with DPO and SLiC as special cases when list size is
two. In particular, we highlight a specific method, LiPO-$\lambda$, which
leverages a state-of-the-art \textit{listwise} ranking objective and weights
each preference pair in a more advanced manner. We show that LiPO-$\lambda$ can
outperform DPO variants and SLiC by a clear margin on several preference
alignment tasks with both curated and real rankwise preference data. | [
-0.3274737596511841,
-0.06603391468524933,
0.4213143587112427,
-0.2751578986644745,
-0.11977122724056244,
0.22739137709140778,
-0.197456493973732,
-0.40191659331321716,
0.1587197333574295,
0.6705554127693176,
-0.5750952363014221,
-0.24981321394443512,
-0.5600208640098572,
-0.1174023449420929,
0.09745491296052933,
1.4111334085464478,
0.25681042671203613,
-0.02491731010377407,
-0.2250557690858841,
-0.1325751394033432,
-0.26775750517845154,
-0.33218932151794434,
-0.5035821199417114,
-0.36238667368888855,
0.8017439246177673,
0.7385863065719604,
0.8345323801040649,
0.8425166010856628,
0.3940136432647705,
0.21911098062992096,
0.046827707439661026,
0.39299067854881287,
-0.7997317910194397,
0.01140188705176115,
-0.056795306503772736,
-0.23545855283737183,
-0.4356234073638916,
0.1340230256319046,
0.7697080969810486,
0.569315493106842,
-0.3966883718967438,
0.12181902676820755,
0.08661670982837677,
1.1050227880477905,
-0.5940213203430176,
-0.21717922389507294,
-0.5312859416007996,
-0.06922609359025955,
0.21632426977157593,
0.014700088649988174,
-0.40409255027770996,
-0.5523250699043274,
0.354772686958313,
-0.7003719210624695,
-0.3304460048675537,
0.5077385902404785,
0.7603757381439209,
0.5883130431175232,
-0.3192868232727051,
-0.35381487011909485,
-0.6328420639038086,
1.0209975242614746,
-0.3169841766357422,
0.3921979069709778,
0.40362852811813354,
0.4157087802886963,
-0.04250776767730713,
-0.08067408204078674,
-0.24197547137737274,
-0.3359988033771515,
0.15449373424053192,
0.44109830260276794,
0.5133938193321228,
0.0147150419652462,
-0.10033942759037018,
0.25454458594322205,
-0.6000726819038391,
0.5473318099975586,
-0.14919988811016083,
-0.08583999425172806,
0.5538251399993896,
-0.339744508266449,
0.11803124099969864,
-0.1289851814508438,
-0.5938058495521545,
-0.3664545714855194,
-0.5685967803001404,
0.38082778453826904,
0.6419320106506348,
0.4281649887561798,
0.09822583943605423,
0.5651376247406006,
0.1263113170862198,
0.8322790861129761,
0.0415995754301548,
-0.3556288480758667,
-0.23829416930675507,
-0.09617426246404648,
0.08418122678995132,
0.3777187764644623,
0.5319604277610779,
0.557843029499054,
0.29588988423347473,
-0.29937607049942017,
-0.32723549008369446,
-0.2931722104549408,
0.4859412908554077,
-0.7059942483901978,
0.16987654566764832,
0.30674684047698975,
-0.3226364552974701,
-0.5455182790756226,
0.11756402254104614,
-0.7453550100326538,
-0.4576047360897064,
-0.2041662037372589,
0.27842068672180176,
0.06075063720345497,
-0.009839741513133049,
0.026972748339176178,
-0.07227357476949692,
0.1818896234035492,
0.1691163331270218,
-1.2025666236877441,
0.49194207787513733,
0.9161803126335144,
0.5525031089782715,
-0.42195287346839905,
-0.26300689578056335,
-0.790925920009613,
0.2668141722679138,
-0.415023535490036,
0.6913550496101379,
-0.489120751619339,
-0.3882937729358673,
0.11229666322469711,
-0.43680793046951294,
0.10800381004810333,
-0.463683158159256,
0.6342134475708008,
-0.4503640830516815,
0.3397948145866394,
-0.32541218400001526,
-0.6630459427833557,
0.24775317311286926,
0.12156695872545242,
-0.520867645740509,
1.0894123315811157,
0.04986385628581047,
-0.4593978524208069,
0.5466238260269165,
-0.3951675295829773,
-0.1440756618976593,
-0.1471080482006073,
-0.24338401854038239,
-0.5387159585952759,
-0.22645840048789978,
0.08581528067588806,
0.22133128345012665,
-0.5013076066970825,
0.15014849603176117,
-0.4542785584926605,
-0.3389877378940582,
0.3438020646572113,
0.2691948711872101,
0.313412070274353,
0.14558403193950653,
-0.18630871176719666,
0.41275250911712646,
-0.42100539803504944,
0.12512928247451782,
-0.06560295820236206,
-0.23891650140285492,
-0.36596643924713135,
0.3499622046947479,
-0.2056516706943512,
0.140116885304451,
0.28457045555114746,
-0.3843679130077362,
0.6442585587501526,
-0.6556522250175476,
0.5566538572311401,
0.9358728528022766,
-0.31067290902137756,
0.7992653846740723,
-0.6473032832145691,
0.38398459553718567,
-0.4999561607837677,
0.42551061511039734,
0.6527028679847717,
-0.3693918287754059,
-0.34025734663009644,
-0.2979370951652527,
0.16931454837322235,
0.6136922836303711,
-0.3328588008880615,
0.5578392744064331,
-0.35606148838996887,
-0.29795584082603455,
-0.6162107586860657,
0.13390249013900757,
0.4528501033782959,
0.6874182224273682,
0.31141898036003113,
0.054053474217653275,
-0.20564857125282288,
-1.0644973516464233,
-0.2881849408149719,
-0.22839492559432983,
0.16644439101219177,
0.7397754192352295,
0.10560671240091324,
0.13000328838825226,
0.7191581130027771,
-0.5355318784713745,
-0.34525591135025024,
-0.26628416776657104,
-0.21733565628528595,
0.2710000276565552,
0.35546374320983887,
0.5745933055877686,
-0.49183008074760437,
-0.3943155109882355,
0.019966822117567062,
-0.14975355565547943,
0.0805225521326065,
0.20044121146202087,
-0.220781609416008,
0.24183285236358643,
0.07485881447792053,
-0.02709708921611309,
-0.042134881019592285,
0.5013390183448792,
0.18744677305221558,
0.21290706098079681,
-0.2539215087890625,
0.03026995249092579,
-1.017991542816162,
-0.04603269323706627,
-0.12778380513191223,
-0.19791822135448456,
-0.4271624982357025,
-0.09973791986703873,
-0.08488626778125763,
-0.38498327136039734,
-0.2990827262401581,
0.7779039740562439,
-0.2293270230293274,
-0.442538321018219,
-0.1781216859817505,
0.22658395767211914,
-0.2707982063293457,
0.6011322140693665,
0.17641718685626984,
0.8446981906890869,
0.32883062958717346,
-0.5726972222328186,
-0.12349019944667816,
0.15906929969787598,
-0.0649053081870079,
0.24616920948028564,
-0.5376272797584534,
0.286698579788208,
-0.15029063820838928,
0.09350228309631348,
-1.207938313484192,
0.13064628839492798,
0.2604410648345947,
-0.2312498837709427,
0.2779842019081116,
-0.38974401354789734,
-0.3112475275993347,
-0.19976148009300232,
-0.757088303565979,
0.5430586934089661,
0.5187944173812866,
-0.6480482220649719,
0.1258338838815689,
0.6411246061325073,
0.1452556699514389,
-1.1987555027008057,
-0.06497984379529953,
-0.40578728914260864,
-0.34403181076049805,
-0.06167961284518242,
0.5510306358337402,
-0.1769992709159851,
-0.011285553686320782,
-0.38805532455444336,
-0.41017797589302063,
0.17871473729610443,
0.12759484350681305,
0.08657960593700409,
0.5215039849281311,
0.32229506969451904,
0.09586170315742493,
0.0016365253832191229,
-0.2244170606136322,
-0.2567240297794342,
-0.6885858774185181,
0.37901073694229126,
-0.19681498408317566,
-0.00803162157535553,
-0.4329078793525696,
0.18204772472381592,
0.5372058749198914,
-0.11025191843509674,
0.47423216700553894,
0.18651919066905975,
-0.23100733757019043,
-0.23089717328548431,
-0.46372658014297485,
-0.2937827706336975,
-0.43047934770584106,
0.03533352538943291,
-0.36619600653648376,
-0.7941185235977173,
0.2794899344444275,
-0.11925572156906128,
0.19280461966991425,
0.16564065217971802,
0.18904726207256317,
-0.2707350254058838,
1.3121163845062256,
0.5215657353401184,
-0.36610981822013855,
0.529144287109375,
-0.16123835742473602,
0.14151719212532043,
-0.8091976046562195,
-0.10895035415887833,
-0.6878176927566528,
-0.5971783399581909,
-0.8473728895187378,
-0.04852410405874252,
0.3372492492198944,
0.3840559422969818,
-0.3872428834438324,
0.26649340987205505,
-0.9806296825408936,
0.3050577938556671,
0.42890483140945435,
0.09577606618404388,
0.055840544402599335,
0.06409559398889542,
-0.35837322473526,
-0.08093315362930298,
-0.8019630908966064,
-0.45655757188796997,
1.0955597162246704,
0.19978249073028564,
0.6603774428367615,
0.3910914659500122,
0.9981061816215515,
0.298036128282547,
0.29775649309158325,
-1.0775229930877686,
0.4669865071773529,
-0.4823557436466217,
-0.029521647840738297,
-0.7129149436950684,
-0.18251487612724304,
-1.0356405973434448,
0.06536247581243515,
-0.22928786277770996,
-0.9156744480133057,
0.11455487459897995,
0.2782934010028839,
-0.24691201746463776,
0.0014488219749182463,
-0.35353153944015503,
0.7542310953140259,
-0.6001179814338684,
-0.42098915576934814,
-0.2720968425273895,
-0.742451548576355,
0.13028644025325775,
0.35634645819664,
0.22963064908981323,
-0.18983978033065796,
-0.391547292470932,
0.7488692998886108,
-0.5761920213699341,
0.5160561800003052,
-0.025431349873542786,
-0.14850102365016937,
-0.15206575393676758,
-0.17012161016464233,
0.4950856864452362,
0.35383957624435425,
-0.23319081962108612,
-0.24356594681739807,
0.15767408907413483,
-0.41890907287597656,
-0.5624121427536011,
0.8610964417457581,
-1.2720237970352173,
-0.5814451575279236,
-0.5295409560203552,
-0.40338829159736633,
-0.28714466094970703,
0.16537204384803772,
0.10536323487758636,
0.23673689365386963,
-0.0025786051992326975,
-0.12937913835048676,
0.7495461702346802,
-0.010062707588076591,
0.21789361536502838,
0.3956987261772156,
-0.4704746603965759,
-0.7124307155609131,
1.1192466020584106,
0.007197533268481493,
0.3295031785964966,
0.9462343454360962,
0.6314972639083862,
-0.7359030246734619,
-0.47701215744018555,
-0.6686954498291016,
0.46084409952163696,
-0.3998565673828125,
0.07216949015855789,
-0.15935713052749634,
-0.014843599870800972,
-0.4162747859954834,
-0.09571735560894012,
-0.40366607904434204,
-0.5850620865821838,
-0.20936161279678345,
0.1467631757259369,
0.15270516276359558,
0.48673591017723083,
0.14400972425937653,
-0.07042677700519562,
-0.4134141504764557,
0.26272308826446533,
0.41510891914367676,
0.3383478820323944,
-0.07508782297372818,
-0.3333014249801636,
0.0693013072013855,
-0.14728708565235138,
-0.0487823486328125,
-0.9559581279754639,
0.04125167056918144,
0.15865086019039154,
0.6719160676002502,
0.45202240347862244,
0.19832874834537506,
0.6849799156188965,
-0.3097625970840454,
0.37719205021858215,
0.09161265939474106,
-0.6805990934371948,
0.8235986232757568,
-0.1992124319076538,
0.04474257677793503,
0.716839075088501,
0.6219035387039185,
-0.4502652585506439,
-0.10354327410459518,
-0.3912401497364044,
-0.6339097619056702,
0.6253747940063477,
-0.18072323501110077,
-0.3497776389122009,
0.16630059480667114,
0.7482223510742188,
0.255985826253891,
0.2678506076335907,
-0.5733239650726318,
-0.3314666152000427,
-0.4220009446144104,
-0.06424359232187271,
-0.18935780227184296,
-0.12308400124311447,
-0.42388269305229187,
-0.08370137214660645,
0.7415828704833984,
-0.3838326334953308,
-0.000914058880880475,
0.12617041170597076,
-0.12000778317451477,
0.05673635005950928,
0.36187681555747986,
0.9933342337608337,
0.6117532253265381,
-0.44980940222740173,
-0.07100573927164078,
-0.23890526592731476,
-0.13502918183803558,
0.05969982221722603,
0.09585899859666824,
-0.17277054488658905,
-0.6179328560829163,
-0.12106317281723022,
0.7018444538116455,
0.3074073791503906,
-0.8245397210121155,
0.36245793104171753,
0.014416988007724285,
-0.0861785039305687,
-0.20576779544353485,
0.17142581939697266,
-0.1569174975156784,
-0.1323176771402359,
0.2216435819864273,
-0.17607082426548004,
0.208027184009552,
-0.6350061297416687,
0.11390072107315063,
0.7180982232093811,
-0.7003290057182312,
0.1107751801609993,
0.5654124021530151,
0.24412786960601807,
-0.4833179712295532,
0.5647801160812378,
-0.07012105733156204,
-0.49523112177848816,
0.587080180644989,
0.41463083028793335,
0.4184747040271759,
-0.1491313874721527,
0.3554471433162689,
0.5099236965179443,
0.14887142181396484,
-0.18201395869255066,
0.19823886454105377,
-0.3783933222293854,
-0.951353132724762,
-0.10933244973421097,
-0.4230208992958069,
-0.55672287940979,
0.12147228419780731,
-0.8650808334350586,
0.19570569694042206,
-0.6552764177322388,
-0.05946452543139458,
-0.06558828800916672,
0.27431970834732056,
-0.2900461256504059,
-0.1367570459842682,
-0.06890104711055756,
0.31358349323272705,
-0.4880525469779968,
0.8548025488853455,
0.8723384737968445,
-0.4672448933124542,
-0.7653815150260925,
-0.08340205252170563,
0.0686575248837471,
-1.2378644943237305,
0.6566290259361267,
0.12429612874984741,
-0.38024938106536865,
0.2717650532722473,
-0.022416304796934128,
-0.9907169342041016,
0.9499247074127197,
0.1892218142747879,
-0.6142450571060181,
0.03622814640402794,
0.048510730266571045,
0.32922717928886414,
-0.456715852022171,
0.418239027261734,
0.4268878698348999,
0.5210755467414856,
-0.04425835981965065,
-0.9501557350158691,
-0.006766590755432844,
0.1321628987789154,
0.0571642629802227,
0.5421850085258484,
-0.8839636445045471,
0.2007518857717514,
-0.3829954266548157,
0.1290941685438156,
0.22007641196250916,
0.3795533776283264,
0.5649611353874207,
-0.07307814806699753,
0.7832663655281067,
0.5765430927276611,
0.8485791087150574,
0.10934173315763474,
1.0997742414474487,
-0.4256114661693573,
0.27992624044418335,
0.9748290777206421,
-0.598519504070282,
0.8903861045837402,
0.608940064907074,
-0.11392893642187119,
0.3587144613265991,
0.904869019985199,
0.10858871787786484,
0.733491837978363,
0.45367196202278137,
0.05085166543722153,
-0.288562536239624,
-0.3787842392921448,
-0.26982852816581726,
0.3171999752521515,
0.13309767842292786,
0.06409663707017899,
0.09339062124490738,
-0.10683877766132355,
-0.29914695024490356,
0.31633129715919495,
-0.2967934012413025,
1.0561350584030151,
-0.1752014458179474,
-1.2063082456588745,
0.8041446805000305,
-0.28570911288261414,
0.5598061084747314,
-0.49425214529037476,
-0.06413224339485168,
0.019104769453406334,
0.12101881206035614,
-0.09976457804441452,
-0.6750784516334534,
-0.13439440727233887,
-0.4472843408584595,
-0.45000961422920227,
-0.5879243612289429,
0.5388082265853882,
-0.4607493579387665,
-0.1815134435892105,
0.2842727303504944,
0.32415539026260376,
0.2630496323108673,
0.31687694787979126,
-0.9529529213905334,
-0.09213968366384506,
-0.057503458112478256,
0.1530202031135559,
0.6798377633094788,
-0.4288325011730194,
-0.2063267081975937,
0.872269868850708,
0.5851356387138367,
0.12482276558876038,
-0.369039922952652,
0.32634878158569336,
0.31872090697288513,
-0.36816030740737915,
-0.695717990398407,
-0.4620053470134735,
0.12198477238416672,
-0.14652536809444427,
-0.3582182228565216,
0.16609476506710052,
0.7711576223373413,
0.6897924542427063,
0.09871332347393036,
0.5291628241539001,
0.4269438683986664,
0.6740230321884155,
-0.5891335606575012,
0.49734756350517273,
-0.799768328666687,
0.42322587966918945,
0.04233419895172119,
-0.9844231009483337,
0.061573803424835205,
0.6333857774734497,
-0.211608424782753,
0.03444305807352066,
0.7092978954315186,
0.6942747235298157,
0.3310973346233368,
-0.2829958498477936,
0.13703787326812744,
-0.1466972827911377,
0.13501663506031036,
0.5256674289703369,
0.7898290753364563,
-0.13823218643665314,
0.6548652052879333,
-0.29196369647979736,
-0.3426608145236969,
-0.28905346989631653,
-0.9687352776527405,
-0.6868701577186584,
-0.5493437647819519,
-0.22977623343467712,
-0.2762026786804199,
0.37791386246681213,
0.9697299003601074,
0.8249030113220215,
-0.6558940410614014,
-0.6642510890960693,
-0.013946054503321648,
0.6828211545944214,
-0.696860671043396,
-0.19859687983989716,
0.407173752784729,
-0.23020942509174347,
-0.9057931900024414,
0.3971783220767975,
0.37979769706726074,
0.003823858220130205,
-0.2088080644607544,
-0.4246225953102112,
-0.17969536781311035,
-0.1906629204750061,
0.38716959953308105,
0.5319874882698059,
-1.1865700483322144,
-0.5157923102378845,
0.2060001790523529,
-0.159625843167305,
0.12728966772556305,
0.9881641864776611,
-0.7168424129486084,
0.2656060457229614,
0.4898700714111328,
0.8603054881095886,
0.6059950590133667,
0.14606186747550964,
0.5647561550140381,
-0.5429645776748657,
-0.17689135670661926,
0.30383551120758057,
0.11712177097797394,
0.06029149144887924,
-0.4736264646053314,
0.4213286340236664,
-0.017854154109954834,
-0.8232946991920471,
-0.8218645453453064,
0.4637403190135956,
-1.5190839767456055,
-0.3593771159648895,
0.8957536220550537,
0.4327588677406311,
0.10668729990720749,
0.20638954639434814,
-0.17990830540657043,
0.1015421450138092,
-0.8559750914573669,
0.8676945567131042,
0.6213206648826599,
-0.5138680338859558,
-0.2771558165550232,
-0.40418341755867004,
0.8025730848312378,
0.7805395722389221,
-0.7674572467803955,
-0.2235276699066162,
0.29673120379447937,
0.1798296868801117,
-0.05570947006344795,
0.5414106249809265,
0.21310287714004517,
0.20964716374874115,
-0.8635572195053101,
-0.10893552005290985,
0.04833744838833809,
-0.38877367973327637,
-0.11298888176679611,
0.04430554062128067,
0.4552602469921112,
-0.12321742624044418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01874v1 | The RL/LLM Taxonomy Tree: Reviewing Synergies Between Reinforcement Learning and Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T20:01:15 | 2024-02-02T20:01:15 | Moschoula Pternea, Prerna Singh, Abir Chakraborty, Yagna Oruganti, Mirco Milletari, Sayli Bapat, Kebei Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO | In this work, we review research studies that combine Reinforcement Learning
(RL) and Large Language Models (LLMs), two areas that owe their momentum to the
development of deep neural networks. We propose a novel taxonomy of three main
classes based on the way that the two model types interact with each other. The
first class, RL4LLM, includes studies where RL is leveraged to improve the
performance of LLMs on tasks related to Natural Language Processing. L4LLM is
divided into two sub-categories depending on whether RL is used to directly
fine-tune an existing LLM or to improve the prompt of the LLM. In the second
class, LLM4RL, an LLM assists the training of an RL model that performs a task
that is not inherently related to natural language. We further break down
LLM4RL based on the component of the RL training framework that the LLM assists
or replaces, namely reward shaping, goal generation, and policy function.
Finally, in the third class, RL+LLM, an LLM and an RL agent are embedded in a
common planning framework without either of them contributing to training or
fine-tuning of the other. We further branch this class to distinguish between
studies with and without natural language feedback. We use this taxonomy to
explore the motivations behind the synergy of LLMs and RL and explain the
reasons for its success, while pinpointing potential shortcomings and areas
where further research is needed, as well as alternative methodologies that
serve the same goal. | [
-0.3641209006309509,
-0.6909409761428833,
0.48994550108909607,
0.10215195268392563,
0.078846774995327,
0.605398416519165,
-0.4025651514530182,
-0.6692324876785278,
0.20126062631607056,
0.48907655477523804,
-0.5942479372024536,
-0.20560148358345032,
-0.5900747179985046,
0.1578942984342575,
-0.1925148069858551,
1.1532795429229736,
-0.005183702800422907,
0.22248907387256622,
-0.2935977280139923,
-0.2665984630584717,
-0.4953078329563141,
-0.6218113303184509,
-0.9583214521408081,
-0.977544903755188,
1.2598152160644531,
0.07394301891326904,
0.8353869915008545,
0.4545432925224304,
0.4539824426174164,
0.27777549624443054,
-0.2665157914161682,
0.09574229270219803,
-0.3385876715183258,
0.19854110479354858,
-0.41631612181663513,
-0.3719341456890106,
-0.3323873281478882,
0.016543732956051826,
0.6120074987411499,
0.6284748911857605,
-0.16361258924007416,
-0.04850953072309494,
0.1221180111169815,
0.6864932775497437,
-0.5638657808303833,
0.21671029925346375,
-0.25372499227523804,
0.26886770129203796,
-0.0071956380270421505,
-0.18890416622161865,
-0.2598571181297302,
-0.2454133927822113,
0.08426621556282043,
-0.37145471572875977,
-0.3344805836677551,
-0.007436133921146393,
0.5358386635780334,
0.2599256932735443,
-0.6306782960891724,
-0.40544021129608154,
-0.7977212071418762,
0.8057809472084045,
-0.8253604769706726,
0.29136186838150024,
-0.007711790502071381,
0.16814443469047546,
-0.16214041411876678,
-0.7269108295440674,
-0.56633061170578,
-0.32160136103630066,
-0.2171495258808136,
0.20021963119506836,
-0.07257331162691116,
0.4157940447330475,
0.09500718861818314,
0.4473533034324646,
-0.37719205021858215,
0.6680983304977417,
-0.20870573818683624,
-0.19309654831886292,
0.6635763049125671,
0.37138617038726807,
0.147191122174263,
0.05243007466197014,
-0.4863622188568115,
-0.1405303031206131,
-0.8422072529792786,
0.19752156734466553,
0.4276479482650757,
0.43426352739334106,
0.09379531443119049,
0.456606388092041,
0.028843902051448822,
0.6164834499359131,
-0.34274032711982727,
-0.43900609016418457,
0.10645531117916107,
-0.4777476489543915,
-0.09946394711732864,
0.014940907247364521,
1.0030218362808228,
0.17921341955661774,
0.33443784713745117,
-0.2293485701084137,
-0.6236934661865234,
0.10159314423799515,
0.172218456864357,
-0.4394280016422272,
-0.023197636008262634,
-0.09754002839326859,
-0.5190348625183105,
-0.39123204350471497,
-0.17194035649299622,
-0.4340868890285492,
-0.31345000863075256,
-0.5299193859100342,
0.37101930379867554,
-0.17815665900707245,
-0.5999656915664673,
0.0767505094408989,
0.03814081475138664,
0.4021061658859253,
0.1578500121831894,
-1.0374016761779785,
0.5792691707611084,
1.1240530014038086,
0.5131560564041138,
-0.3589591383934021,
-0.626702606678009,
-0.3873691260814667,
-0.058416418731212616,
-0.34443098306655884,
0.6530815362930298,
-0.5577875375747681,
-0.26447591185569763,
0.44771525263786316,
-0.0856572613120079,
-0.14326034486293793,
-0.5332175493240356,
0.3294808268547058,
-0.7464939951896667,
0.4228196144104004,
-0.013248387724161148,
-0.6223397850990295,
-0.4523947238922119,
0.5424484014511108,
-0.7426018714904785,
0.868980884552002,
-0.10793854296207428,
-0.6494156718254089,
0.4274621307849884,
-0.531845211982727,
-0.603866457939148,
0.21136972308158875,
-0.3610052764415741,
-0.2809838354587555,
-0.2797163128852844,
-0.23867222666740417,
0.5068106055259705,
-0.2821076810359955,
0.5710192918777466,
-0.2761991024017334,
-0.11234577745199203,
0.30210474133491516,
-0.18586106598377228,
0.3955763876438141,
0.06464619189500809,
-0.1276882439851761,
0.5879768133163452,
-0.38545092940330505,
0.06130678579211235,
0.04923919215798378,
-0.6647074818611145,
-0.17363640666007996,
0.17083792388439178,
-0.056695397943258286,
0.37387654185295105,
0.37023910880088806,
-0.1874714344739914,
0.2914271056652069,
-0.5036488175392151,
0.6033298373222351,
0.63076251745224,
-0.03621669486165047,
0.5140422582626343,
-0.3815314471721649,
0.6640557646751404,
-0.1560068130493164,
0.13953673839569092,
-0.01990307867527008,
-0.17723408341407776,
-0.7548932433128357,
0.12834666669368744,
0.4024091362953186,
0.47399964928627014,
-0.8742574453353882,
0.12078291177749634,
-0.06883689016103745,
-0.2680978775024414,
-0.3874824643135071,
0.16818253695964813,
0.5979312062263489,
0.023755768314003944,
0.30626237392425537,
-0.3656253218650818,
-0.5726606249809265,
-0.8511620163917542,
-0.40068894624710083,
-0.21978463232517242,
0.5142049193382263,
0.28212523460388184,
0.612414538860321,
-0.05525149032473564,
0.7580496668815613,
0.07210008800029755,
-0.33710116147994995,
-0.7582395672798157,
0.0013198992237448692,
0.2373945415019989,
0.2703952193260193,
0.2813664674758911,
-0.6346914172172546,
-0.25888410210609436,
-0.026231393218040466,
-0.5357410907745361,
0.371499240398407,
-0.03478611260652542,
0.42772629857063293,
0.2808378040790558,
0.5529237389564514,
-0.5453560948371887,
0.10470740497112274,
0.4966835081577301,
-0.28972986340522766,
0.5700108408927917,
-0.24636782705783844,
-0.33471032977104187,
-0.8466188311576843,
-0.15506350994110107,
-0.09822851419448853,
-0.10410893708467484,
-0.7953801155090332,
0.1852114498615265,
-0.17933692038059235,
0.29825282096862793,
-0.5015150308609009,
0.7178213000297546,
-0.3717316687107086,
-0.36088719964027405,
-0.35197362303733826,
0.11998134106397629,
-0.21991202235221863,
0.6056308746337891,
0.1705397665500641,
0.5533887147903442,
0.40546029806137085,
-0.6916183829307556,
0.6274665594100952,
-0.04974209889769554,
-0.026251506060361862,
0.0776386484503746,
-0.5087081789970398,
-0.15746571123600006,
0.12879227101802826,
0.36869341135025024,
-0.4688483774662018,
-0.03871045261621475,
0.39466336369514465,
-0.346993088722229,
0.33010268211364746,
0.16469798982143402,
-0.7527549266815186,
-0.43740931153297424,
-0.33365198969841003,
0.3592342734336853,
0.4130343794822693,
-0.5155852437019348,
0.5917503237724304,
0.31379565596580505,
-0.009162605740129948,
-0.6455331444740295,
-0.5934156775474548,
0.06518109142780304,
-0.38452497124671936,
-0.25744763016700745,
0.4320991635322571,
0.13783325254917145,
-0.398388147354126,
0.21972213685512543,
0.03749280422925949,
0.18047165870666504,
0.20034968852996826,
0.05888288840651512,
0.19241230189800262,
-0.2688898742198944,
0.3571223020553589,
-0.5865604877471924,
-0.10735278576612473,
0.2665673792362213,
-0.2745860517024994,
0.5112692713737488,
-0.18493697047233582,
-0.1074506863951683,
-0.10262729227542877,
-0.08881232142448425,
0.25556135177612305,
-0.3590260446071625,
0.7374691367149353,
0.6275436282157898,
0.0770142450928688,
-0.3244704604148865,
-0.377307265996933,
-0.4009630084037781,
-0.4009197950363159,
0.22123052179813385,
-0.29792681336402893,
-1.3809629678726196,
0.23060289025306702,
-0.14480963349342346,
0.21289274096488953,
0.3898983299732208,
0.6852869987487793,
0.12109102308750153,
0.8234646320343018,
0.8728111982345581,
-0.20525988936424255,
0.5482615232467651,
-0.2492041438817978,
0.33590537309646606,
-0.8962672352790833,
-0.44223037362098694,
-0.25920569896698,
-0.36919090151786804,
-0.7128557562828064,
-0.25221458077430725,
-0.0960933268070221,
-0.02167108841240406,
-0.24927419424057007,
0.20418110489845276,
-0.214408740401268,
0.36735400557518005,
0.577757716178894,
-0.35808491706848145,
0.39530494809150696,
-0.38211145997047424,
-0.1436106562614441,
0.17690853774547577,
-1.0487431287765503,
-0.4598228335380554,
0.9223109483718872,
0.6243627667427063,
0.8308707475662231,
0.2407090961933136,
0.8628135919570923,
0.21259137988090515,
0.2510390281677246,
-1.1140583753585815,
0.6819551587104797,
0.06004505231976509,
-0.35406431555747986,
-0.2864336371421814,
-0.32418209314346313,
-1.2096046209335327,
0.4834592938423157,
-0.3294794261455536,
-0.4364207684993744,
-0.25767189264297485,
0.025134945288300514,
-0.4010849893093109,
0.53864586353302,
-0.3381101191043854,
0.9183555841445923,
-0.585412323474884,
-0.5772863626480103,
-0.5268840789794922,
-0.6603594422340393,
0.6836583018302917,
0.24644123017787933,
0.3443518877029419,
-0.046512849628925323,
-0.20133031904697418,
0.8627424240112305,
-0.1311514675617218,
0.868236243724823,
0.13625264167785645,
-0.3625197112560272,
0.13103103637695312,
0.11759145557880402,
0.49764758348464966,
-0.1156536117196083,
0.31413036584854126,
-0.23604880273342133,
-0.007606739178299904,
-0.1413097232580185,
-0.5618639588356018,
0.7486427426338196,
-0.7415779829025269,
-0.5870318412780762,
-0.7545949816703796,
-0.5758934617042542,
-0.41442322731018066,
0.18279418349266052,
-0.30304986238479614,
0.3020588457584381,
-0.15772685408592224,
0.07154261320829391,
0.6966635584831238,
-0.2584853768348694,
0.5467203855514526,
0.6432795524597168,
-0.5928131341934204,
-0.3506760895252228,
1.0099152326583862,
-0.16166996955871582,
0.45770496129989624,
0.47106611728668213,
0.18471446633338928,
-0.46191948652267456,
-0.6831278800964355,
0.23608461022377014,
0.3650469481945038,
-0.7595437169075012,
-0.040800124406814575,
-0.5269817113876343,
-0.5942409634590149,
-0.3015395402908325,
0.06576361507177353,
-0.16912157833576202,
-0.22361348569393158,
-0.2729174494743347,
-0.13129447400569916,
0.36438754200935364,
1.2066017389297485,
-0.14792223274707794,
0.18513022363185883,
-0.4871726632118225,
-0.030908439308404922,
0.36860477924346924,
0.3012808859348297,
0.33500105142593384,
-0.30940672755241394,
-0.2407403439283371,
-0.2564966380596161,
-0.21257370710372925,
-0.5528486371040344,
0.3994597792625427,
-0.006950967479497194,
0.7277384996414185,
0.16952253878116608,
-0.2620187997817993,
0.2526625096797943,
-0.4096004366874695,
0.8057610988616943,
0.5721771121025085,
-0.48558440804481506,
0.20418131351470947,
-0.2644850015640259,
0.09054151177406311,
0.28099513053894043,
0.32909342646598816,
-0.756232738494873,
-0.3590809106826782,
-0.749589741230011,
-0.925915539264679,
0.7773913145065308,
-0.23897145688533783,
-0.02426365204155445,
0.14887866377830505,
-0.037295591086149216,
-0.019553419202566147,
0.27657458186149597,
-1.2448641061782837,
-0.14805999398231506,
0.10296229273080826,
-0.013716955669224262,
-0.36137279868125916,
-0.3204125165939331,
-0.2690730392932892,
-0.12676434218883514,
0.7373102307319641,
-0.16183188557624817,
-0.18753620982170105,
-0.060109492391347885,
-0.0913432240486145,
0.02554767206311226,
0.5606377124786377,
0.5468699932098389,
0.4134507179260254,
0.011566190049052238,
0.3377901315689087,
0.1415577381849289,
-0.0034752481151372194,
0.14554090797901154,
-0.24185144901275635,
0.08164876699447632,
-0.27091190218925476,
0.7722275853157043,
1.0286049842834473,
0.6912450194358826,
-0.7530741095542908,
0.31959614157676697,
0.04633185267448425,
-0.5221429467201233,
-0.4078270494937897,
0.18357989192008972,
0.2861770689487457,
0.5791783928871155,
-0.00609668018296361,
-0.16637477278709412,
-0.09932519495487213,
-0.8528333902359009,
0.11575312912464142,
0.5801637768745422,
-0.36218559741973877,
-0.18497306108474731,
0.2099384367465973,
0.3261015713214874,
-0.48433470726013184,
0.2588115334510803,
-0.32782232761383057,
-0.7811029553413391,
0.5481585264205933,
0.465424120426178,
0.7856599688529968,
0.1544349491596222,
0.32107123732566833,
0.2839905023574829,
0.3106992244720459,
-0.11000736802816391,
0.11220792680978775,
-0.050178539007902145,
-0.8201470971107483,
-0.7679355144500732,
-0.659392774105072,
-0.4101894199848175,
0.42735323309898376,
-0.48497700691223145,
-0.009052540175616741,
-0.4615142047405243,
0.06278578191995621,
-0.013992282561957836,
0.21590730547904968,
-0.5344284176826477,
-0.17332665622234344,
0.27754199504852295,
0.9416792988777161,
-0.5699704885482788,
0.9022397994995117,
0.832335889339447,
-0.5482208728790283,
-1.0874933004379272,
0.025496985763311386,
0.026094265282154083,
-0.7837193012237549,
1.163600206375122,
-0.09849025309085846,
-0.07176966220140457,
0.1224413514137268,
-0.07991643995046616,
-0.8763628602027893,
1.2238233089447021,
-0.396184504032135,
-0.6806300282478333,
-0.3163573145866394,
0.015460160560905933,
0.6925277709960938,
-0.5423034429550171,
0.2308865338563919,
0.7701185941696167,
0.5577793717384338,
0.19199416041374207,
-1.0458935499191284,
-0.05137467011809349,
0.210887610912323,
0.18334968388080597,
0.4341076612472534,
-0.7001247406005859,
0.748870849609375,
-0.2715776264667511,
-0.2713942229747772,
0.2317163348197937,
0.6111592650413513,
0.30102768540382385,
0.19073787331581116,
0.3923425078392029,
0.6820071935653687,
0.38768038153648376,
-0.10379502922296524,
0.9759876728057861,
-0.24732854962348938,
0.37483328580856323,
1.1062415838241577,
-0.5233006477355957,
0.7844455242156982,
0.7263191938400269,
-0.3691609501838684,
0.4291744530200958,
0.8697128295898438,
-0.07762426882982254,
0.5212066769599915,
0.5977679491043091,
-0.281728595495224,
-0.21702775359153748,
-0.20064899325370789,
-0.35275229811668396,
0.1525144875049591,
0.44949090480804443,
-0.2222951352596283,
-0.4867876470088959,
0.17455609142780304,
-0.0012656127801164985,
0.20127417147159576,
-0.518519937992096,
1.0493662357330322,
0.2718341648578644,
-1.0230433940887451,
0.2938196361064911,
-0.047336235642433167,
0.9300866723060608,
-0.6494241952896118,
0.1263003796339035,
-0.1914375275373459,
0.2988182008266449,
-0.3085778057575226,
-1.1047887802124023,
0.1743871569633484,
-0.2543993890285492,
0.021000053733587265,
-0.4960349500179291,
0.8279388546943665,
-0.6662426590919495,
-0.030205104500055313,
0.7808877229690552,
0.7057056427001953,
0.02317674830555916,
0.6126748919487,
-1.0574166774749756,
0.1536334604024887,
-0.22027015686035156,
-0.25106921792030334,
0.5535992980003357,
0.35104700922966003,
0.14005613327026367,
0.8659182190895081,
0.6659772992134094,
0.3744593858718872,
-0.012625228613615036,
0.31581833958625793,
0.8480886220932007,
-0.8476897478103638,
-0.23889072239398956,
-0.8851495385169983,
0.1499273031949997,
0.24964292347431183,
-0.17987769842147827,
0.7678245902061462,
0.40478938817977905,
0.8910033106803894,
0.11399120092391968,
0.5812515616416931,
-0.12119758874177933,
0.40446722507476807,
-0.8112711906433105,
0.20865386724472046,
-0.6177718043327332,
0.29844170808792114,
0.14189690351486206,
-0.7576505541801453,
-0.22673150897026062,
0.25661033391952515,
-0.4389879107475281,
0.1271340698003769,
0.8652448058128357,
0.6657277941703796,
0.13960322737693787,
-0.1738373190164566,
0.2984362542629242,
0.09294891357421875,
0.3400721549987793,
0.6861900687217712,
1.3433276414871216,
0.07574977725744247,
0.46489056944847107,
-0.05479742959141731,
0.21800297498703003,
-0.2984004616737366,
-0.714245080947876,
-0.9496942758560181,
-0.3865926265716553,
-0.2565899193286896,
-0.398345410823822,
0.19373074173927307,
0.8463658690452576,
0.5126163363456726,
-0.5501424074172974,
-0.5402255058288574,
-0.3690364956855774,
0.5240138173103333,
-0.1421215981245041,
-0.3051605820655823,
-0.05259459465742111,
-0.7737120389938354,
-0.34581395983695984,
0.46546298265457153,
0.3112456798553467,
-0.06455658376216888,
-0.8149990439414978,
-0.6648766994476318,
-0.4012428820133209,
-0.24228964745998383,
0.6751355528831482,
0.6562861204147339,
-1.2206120491027832,
0.026648372411727905,
-0.27371591329574585,
-0.1496814489364624,
-0.24776670336723328,
1.0761030912399292,
-0.9282189011573792,
0.10397224128246307,
0.3482545018196106,
0.6916622519493103,
0.2978960871696472,
-0.4841815233230591,
0.4690738320350647,
-0.5815699100494385,
0.04595554620027542,
0.5775485634803772,
0.21167302131652832,
0.13812503218650818,
0.03151293471455574,
0.5681611895561218,
0.13729321956634521,
-0.6814776062965393,
-0.8086448311805725,
0.6647637486457825,
-0.7256060838699341,
-0.46307212114334106,
1.2269973754882812,
0.14474143087863922,
-0.15993042290210724,
0.08237011730670929,
-0.045518167316913605,
0.06094636768102646,
-0.3288715183734894,
0.367597371339798,
0.7713689208030701,
-0.2933032810688019,
-0.46433186531066895,
-0.6920632123947144,
0.8277243971824646,
0.41014957427978516,
-0.6976341009140015,
-0.10995705425739288,
0.236106738448143,
0.14958669245243073,
0.1866343766450882,
0.4549732506275177,
0.09954486042261124,
0.1450437605381012,
-0.39780303835868835,
0.27234455943107605,
-0.001063243136741221,
-0.3682713508605957,
-0.548574686050415,
-0.0067238835617899895,
0.5438987612724304,
0.2734259068965912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01869v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01869v2 | InferCept: Efficient Intercept Support for Augmented Large Language Model Inference | 2024-02-02T19:47:57 | 2024-05-30T04:18:03 | Reyna Abhyankar, Zijian He, Vikranth Srivatsa, Hao Zhang, Yiying Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Large language models are increasingly integrated with external environments,
tools, and agents like ChatGPT plugins to extend their capability beyond
language-centric tasks. However, today's LLM inference systems are designed for
standalone LLMs. They treat each external interaction as the end of LLM
generation and form a new request when the interaction finishes, causing
unnecessary recomputation of already computed contexts, which accounts for
37-40% of total model forwarding time. This paper presents InferCept, the first
LLM inference framework targeting augmented LLMs and supporting the efficient
interception of LLM generation. InferCept minimizes the GPU resource waste
caused by LLM interceptions and dedicates saved memory for serving more
requests. InferCept improves the overall serving throughput by 1.6x-2x and
completes 2x more requests per second compared to the state-of-the-art LLM
inference systems. | [
-0.5854820609092712,
-0.891697108745575,
0.5910229086875916,
0.23758962750434875,
-0.053229160606861115,
0.23347818851470947,
-0.15187275409698486,
-0.6488082408905029,
0.09415707737207413,
0.6494048237800598,
-0.5313242077827454,
-0.1074487641453743,
-0.46623462438583374,
-0.1628350168466568,
-0.5216835737228394,
0.502900242805481,
0.3478979468345642,
0.26806947588920593,
-0.5505416989326477,
0.2487030327320099,
0.04430948942899704,
-0.6442603468894958,
-1.0233513116836548,
-0.5734564661979675,
0.17933808267116547,
0.6445841193199158,
0.609708845615387,
0.27582108974456787,
0.3653096556663513,
0.28620991110801697,
-0.1457667201757431,
0.5929957032203674,
-0.4381483793258667,
0.25375691056251526,
-0.06671789288520813,
-0.09908924251794815,
-0.6379348039627075,
-0.33413609862327576,
0.7998262643814087,
0.756949782371521,
-0.12673451006412506,
0.09656739234924316,
0.4582141041755676,
0.3951915204524994,
-0.820012092590332,
-0.08834606409072876,
-0.5932608842849731,
-0.10426431149244308,
-0.33968597650527954,
-0.06319595873355865,
-0.710615336894989,
0.033990081399679184,
-0.10583831369876862,
-0.4985252916812897,
0.12040531635284424,
-0.03936139866709709,
0.5477172136306763,
0.20788812637329102,
-0.3297039866447449,
0.07397394627332687,
-0.4078400135040283,
0.5530991554260254,
-0.9138640761375427,
0.7236623167991638,
0.3896999955177307,
0.13594292104244232,
-0.9640432000160217,
-0.9341603517532349,
-0.5975590944290161,
-0.31088757514953613,
0.0020490752067416906,
0.03162378817796707,
-0.4058137834072113,
0.3474510610103607,
0.3085988461971283,
0.24978360533714294,
-0.33656391501426697,
0.2796705365180969,
0.1521780788898468,
-0.28671374917030334,
0.3991343080997467,
0.05705457180738449,
0.22686342895030975,
-0.00037401739973574877,
-0.5051380395889282,
0.46527695655822754,
-1.1338316202163696,
-0.18118898570537567,
0.40539461374282837,
0.25954747200012207,
0.1772034615278244,
0.5134521722793579,
-0.3332441449165344,
0.79354327917099,
0.16831648349761963,
-0.07687533646821976,
-0.16314132511615753,
-0.03008895181119442,
-0.5696083903312683,
0.10197878628969193,
0.5781694054603577,
0.009804068133234978,
-0.06388942152261734,
-0.10454598814249039,
-0.10081656277179718,
-0.18700221180915833,
-0.08862344175577164,
-1.1072399616241455,
-0.10611334443092346,
0.19156838953495026,
-0.2395411878824234,
0.07078930735588074,
-0.2346724420785904,
-0.8433551788330078,
-0.43847256898880005,
-0.1309192180633545,
0.09244000911712646,
-0.6091099977493286,
-0.4269255995750427,
0.13936041295528412,
0.04497856646776199,
0.4307844340801239,
0.327701598405838,
-0.9852157235145569,
0.999924898147583,
1.1424041986465454,
0.9478463530540466,
-0.39215442538261414,
-0.17205947637557983,
-1.1249996423721313,
0.07757379859685898,
-0.08787041157484055,
1.025767207145691,
-0.39334914088249207,
-0.3188168406486511,
-0.03821210563182831,
-0.022775163874030113,
-0.06596489995718002,
-0.4319568872451782,
0.5426322221755981,
-0.809412956237793,
-0.05733250826597214,
-0.09329480677843094,
-1.2870112657546997,
-0.4686329662799835,
0.3976324200630188,
-0.5433940887451172,
0.8885726928710938,
-0.05063527449965477,
-0.601786732673645,
0.44921910762786865,
-0.6708109378814697,
-0.48221278190612793,
0.5825832486152649,
0.03901165723800659,
-0.09957976639270782,
0.16347578167915344,
0.47598007321357727,
0.3749353587627411,
-0.263271301984787,
-0.14306490123271942,
-0.6376932263374329,
-0.44736889004707336,
0.05913678556680679,
-0.5927475690841675,
0.6877425909042358,
0.2542751133441925,
0.0038757757283747196,
-0.006257717963308096,
-0.6806998252868652,
0.1688440442085266,
0.00528737623244524,
-0.3645939528942108,
-0.3785383403301239,
0.3623487651348114,
0.1424044519662857,
-0.20536412298679352,
0.18970853090286255,
-0.8164474368095398,
0.10608279705047607,
-0.4704115688800812,
0.41459888219833374,
0.6097182631492615,
0.03218541294336319,
0.5458974838256836,
0.19066393375396729,
0.5052921772003174,
-0.37355297803878784,
-0.05349786952137947,
0.0649387389421463,
-0.5152029991149902,
-0.5589995384216309,
-0.9034832715988159,
-0.05275789275765419,
0.39722940325737,
-0.8192592263221741,
-0.19089050590991974,
-0.30630409717559814,
-0.3441378176212311,
-0.1431051790714264,
0.2184070646762848,
0.425078421831131,
0.4463040232658386,
0.06175973266363144,
0.14766660332679749,
-0.5893367528915405,
-0.7124713659286499,
-0.4019396901130676,
-0.07243314385414124,
-0.032547783106565475,
-0.00942917913198471,
0.4058166742324829,
-0.02378612756729126,
0.7634395956993103,
-0.2660306394100189,
0.1694744974374771,
-0.6107801795005798,
-0.4932815134525299,
0.513793408870697,
0.4587431252002716,
0.5211210250854492,
-0.5965940356254578,
-0.5300436019897461,
0.013427907600998878,
-0.660322368144989,
-0.11241809278726578,
0.22013536095619202,
-0.48716357350349426,
0.21838445961475372,
0.759484052658081,
-0.7963061332702637,
0.08452204614877701,
0.7649173140525818,
-0.5435575246810913,
0.29568126797676086,
-0.15301603078842163,
0.08775310963392258,
-0.6932737231254578,
-0.24106904864311218,
-0.24570204317569733,
-0.564169704914093,
-0.8603664040565491,
0.19876419007778168,
0.21273058652877808,
0.07228828966617584,
-0.5842459797859192,
0.8544403910636902,
-0.534364640712738,
-0.013189041055738926,
-0.3118983209133148,
0.10344748198986053,
0.022435327991843224,
0.17618727684020996,
0.04902500659227371,
0.9860960841178894,
0.33835941553115845,
-0.7283416986465454,
0.34734538197517395,
0.30909299850463867,
-0.24779154360294342,
0.6498357057571411,
-0.4424450695514679,
0.3735648989677429,
0.06592200696468353,
0.07772232592105865,
-0.9956568479537964,
-0.4037524461746216,
0.37200868129730225,
-0.4982863962650299,
0.3443206548690796,
-0.6772757768630981,
-0.5853375196456909,
-0.14332060515880585,
-0.24946196377277374,
0.3237811028957367,
0.33300018310546875,
-1.1085258722305298,
0.8602326512336731,
0.3607875406742096,
0.0252169631421566,
-0.6074661612510681,
-0.7422991394996643,
0.2902909815311432,
-0.2049509733915329,
-0.6951382160186768,
0.1340106874704361,
-0.10742364078760147,
-0.4705263674259186,
-0.04094432294368744,
0.19321534037590027,
-0.1902194768190384,
-0.08283057808876038,
0.2937391400337219,
0.2834523618221283,
-0.22392317652702332,
0.07145614176988602,
0.1311396211385727,
-0.12221365422010422,
0.0613296814262867,
-0.44377562403678894,
0.7309445738792419,
0.24052850902080536,
-0.7307818531990051,
-0.27310195565223694,
0.43757694959640503,
0.6490646004676819,
0.0442219004034996,
0.7288610935211182,
0.048763372004032135,
-0.41012510657310486,
-0.19510571658611298,
-0.739432156085968,
-0.1143036037683487,
-0.4735119342803955,
0.6386321187019348,
-0.5881665349006653,
-0.6162015795707703,
0.39576902985572815,
0.024167677387595177,
0.2805596888065338,
0.3155525326728821,
0.4768027067184448,
0.15249726176261902,
1.0896579027175903,
0.4511987864971161,
-0.3235596716403961,
0.7686787843704224,
-0.12142433226108551,
-0.1296188235282898,
-0.9895628690719604,
0.05698833987116814,
-0.0806996300816536,
0.1541881412267685,
-0.2948543131351471,
-0.21745282411575317,
0.2244899719953537,
-0.04172274097800255,
-0.4071844220161438,
0.09996362030506134,
-0.28088390827178955,
0.4800540506839752,
0.5916702747344971,
0.3575168251991272,
0.5068832635879517,
0.27647727727890015,
0.06310729682445526,
-0.052608028054237366,
-0.8134518265724182,
-0.18065881729125977,
1.0013898611068726,
0.2963109314441681,
0.7188077569007874,
0.15918000042438507,
0.3650617003440857,
0.33885127305984497,
0.4958868622779846,
-0.7754855155944824,
0.7854366898536682,
-0.07226759940385818,
-0.6963558197021484,
-0.11554089933633804,
-0.23050720989704132,
-0.560520589351654,
0.5540239214897156,
-0.12412189692258835,
-0.8070291876792908,
-0.008968749083578587,
0.4324677884578705,
-0.19060198962688446,
0.6685053706169128,
-0.650512158870697,
0.5250909924507141,
-0.0676102563738823,
-0.8383628129959106,
-0.4103236794471741,
-0.13584373891353607,
0.5769771337509155,
0.2593487799167633,
-0.09334974735975266,
-0.1708599328994751,
-0.0910290852189064,
0.34086865186691284,
-0.6173508763313293,
0.7059197425842285,
-0.37667709589004517,
0.16004137694835663,
0.3977710008621216,
0.315600723028183,
0.8884482383728027,
0.14060285687446594,
-0.3278109133243561,
0.16356252133846283,
-0.0915159359574318,
-0.35706037282943726,
-0.36673206090927124,
0.7895906567573547,
-0.26689204573631287,
-0.4368353486061096,
-0.34306272864341736,
-0.545376181602478,
-0.09681437164545059,
0.07803954184055328,
0.38984182476997375,
0.49029630422592163,
-0.1992480456829071,
-0.13783955574035645,
0.7762389183044434,
-0.22991147637367249,
0.5496372580528259,
0.5864577293395996,
-0.39968639612197876,
-0.532102644443512,
0.6936217546463013,
-0.05982029438018799,
0.6896424293518066,
0.3782350718975067,
-0.10818447917699814,
-0.35326436161994934,
-0.744713544845581,
-0.6525850892066956,
0.18683217465877533,
-0.8364443778991699,
-0.38560596108436584,
-0.6137073636054993,
-0.4382183849811554,
-0.17418505251407623,
-0.012513738125562668,
-0.4769360423088074,
-0.166134312748909,
0.019672328606247902,
-0.10951682180166245,
0.7129802703857422,
0.5144275426864624,
-0.13375620543956757,
0.6000880002975464,
-0.6225551962852478,
-0.033043522387742996,
0.08285707980394363,
0.31737256050109863,
-0.009332703426480293,
-0.6822848916053772,
-0.11389541625976562,
-0.18223993480205536,
-0.030244771391153336,
-0.5657297372817993,
0.4250451922416687,
0.3576156497001648,
0.6617237329483032,
0.6132738590240479,
-0.16317687928676605,
0.8419463634490967,
-0.3263402283191681,
0.6437699198722839,
-0.16798590123653412,
-0.9073367714881897,
0.0913613885641098,
-0.124388687312603,
0.3859412968158722,
0.2726478576660156,
-0.017268478870391846,
-0.3897160589694977,
-0.36638662219047546,
-0.2287403792142868,
-0.8025231957435608,
0.4120739996433258,
0.09945420175790787,
0.06315800547599792,
-0.13008958101272583,
0.4496251940727234,
0.22416681051254272,
0.09455158561468124,
-0.39071834087371826,
-0.03670026361942291,
0.24295687675476074,
-0.004950260277837515,
-0.04469669982790947,
-0.6412395238876343,
0.20354722440242767,
-0.41188472509384155,
0.7703390121459961,
-0.17801696062088013,
0.3125806748867035,
0.1648220717906952,
-0.39268234372138977,
0.15591375529766083,
0.015927614644169807,
0.4743051528930664,
0.5543183088302612,
-0.10569201409816742,
0.33263131976127625,
0.7335993051528931,
-0.6512646079063416,
0.003058384405449033,
0.3262733817100525,
-0.31344640254974365,
-0.018636023625731468,
0.5797268152236938,
0.45192691683769226,
0.33347824215888977,
-0.6602972149848938,
0.30896952748298645,
-0.0813763290643692,
-0.08397548645734787,
-0.695409893989563,
-0.029950017109513283,
-0.008641812019050121,
0.5001139044761658,
0.16946443915367126,
-0.17393673956394196,
0.4168556034564972,
-0.07398130744695663,
0.16057853400707245,
0.8562758564949036,
-0.35861480236053467,
-0.06640941649675369,
0.7026360034942627,
-0.01560247503221035,
-0.07340925931930542,
0.7421395182609558,
-0.20672857761383057,
-0.5011093616485596,
0.2500353455543518,
0.6998212337493896,
0.9175527095794678,
-0.13785456120967865,
-0.14419014751911163,
0.3564820885658264,
-0.03011130355298519,
-0.10342919826507568,
0.3096769154071808,
-0.18367484211921692,
-0.8715961575508118,
-0.8734762668609619,
-0.5966823697090149,
-0.4745078682899475,
0.03348834812641144,
-0.2552957236766815,
0.158375084400177,
-0.30349069833755493,
0.013902395963668823,
-0.25715795159339905,
-0.19374436140060425,
-0.4054989218711853,
-0.18240438401699066,
0.40153324604034424,
1.2348896265029907,
-0.3693631589412689,
0.9818573594093323,
0.7227608561515808,
-0.1697738766670227,
-0.39673876762390137,
-0.42296433448791504,
0.11646483838558197,
-0.9626212120056152,
0.6030147671699524,
-0.1290527582168579,
-0.5703897476196289,
0.21303491294384003,
-0.8099526762962341,
-0.9258441925048828,
0.6616967916488647,
0.7846538424491882,
-0.364528089761734,
0.27854156494140625,
0.05131695419549942,
0.002933025360107422,
-0.31676745414733887,
0.4492523670196533,
0.8023204803466797,
0.45604997873306274,
0.24113738536834717,
-0.5035371780395508,
0.11543290317058563,
-0.25147414207458496,
-0.16502057015895844,
0.32858195900917053,
-0.26864954829216003,
0.6627761721611023,
-0.10765427350997925,
-0.19177940487861633,
0.3269742429256439,
0.7906121611595154,
0.32014673948287964,
0.19010640680789948,
0.5836519002914429,
0.44556722044944763,
0.5315850377082825,
-0.04002434015274048,
1.1825108528137207,
-0.21923327445983887,
0.048616547137498856,
1.2400182485580444,
-0.0009718653163872659,
0.9550641179084778,
0.8045523762702942,
-0.11881394684314728,
0.09399344772100449,
0.6857014894485474,
0.15581877529621124,
0.45910534262657166,
0.05241348221898079,
-0.8241753578186035,
-0.38114261627197266,
-0.12033200263977051,
-0.08873052150011063,
0.30780431628227234,
0.5785946249961853,
-0.03774970397353172,
-0.27570271492004395,
0.1311628520488739,
0.4343511760234833,
-0.029756315052509308,
-0.463662713766098,
0.6725811958312988,
0.07655619829893112,
-0.6668730974197388,
0.3138923943042755,
-0.45403504371643066,
0.6288892030715942,
-0.8067635297775269,
-0.26337260007858276,
-0.3859544098377228,
0.692134439945221,
-0.38489338755607605,
-0.6828249096870422,
-0.05973241105675697,
-0.27132532000541687,
-0.06254986673593521,
-0.004635175224393606,
0.8308940529823303,
-0.4314019978046417,
-0.42664897441864014,
0.6265307068824768,
0.4315330386161804,
0.19678130745887756,
-0.5822750329971313,
-0.16587218642234802,
0.08791422843933105,
-0.1934879571199417,
-0.6165339946746826,
0.29562097787857056,
0.22253349423408508,
0.10185601562261581,
0.8887283802032471,
0.695416271686554,
0.2732306122779846,
0.21880555152893066,
0.009772625751793385,
0.8596434593200684,
-0.3756311237812042,
-0.20930621027946472,
-1.230975866317749,
0.4905287027359009,
-0.22409720718860626,
0.04782206192612648,
0.9511409401893616,
0.6859726309776306,
0.5112877488136292,
0.1303788274526596,
0.6618707776069641,
-0.09870914369821548,
0.5001237392425537,
-0.6497730612754822,
0.5739330649375916,
-0.5116486549377441,
0.25265491008758545,
-0.2010556012392044,
-0.7174800634384155,
-0.3668632209300995,
0.05318004637956619,
-0.24056895077228546,
-0.22838599979877472,
0.30648675560951233,
0.8346384763717651,
-0.3282628357410431,
-0.12325303256511688,
0.445062518119812,
0.031778521835803986,
0.677073061466217,
0.5254333019256592,
0.9167252779006958,
-0.1767949014902115,
0.35370320081710815,
-0.2264946699142456,
-0.293541818857193,
-0.2526819109916687,
-0.7937911152839661,
-0.7841419577598572,
-0.07952700555324554,
0.03734908252954483,
-0.3557951748371124,
0.041804276406764984,
1.0927584171295166,
0.7203038334846497,
-0.7418507933616638,
-0.41597118973731995,
-0.34490934014320374,
0.15903280675411224,
-0.4394598603248596,
-0.18822921812534332,
0.2923780381679535,
-0.40064433217048645,
-0.8332970142364502,
0.6810473799705505,
0.22079434990882874,
-0.09507792443037033,
-0.19983245432376862,
-0.22425736486911774,
-0.25376084446907043,
-0.007631584070622921,
0.8778598308563232,
0.47766947746276855,
-0.5983355641365051,
-0.36068081855773926,
-0.05014006420969963,
0.1805306375026703,
0.04804994538426399,
0.6425814032554626,
-0.7826739549636841,
0.44624385237693787,
0.5171613097190857,
0.6910569071769714,
0.8601040244102478,
-0.15211114287376404,
0.8074429631233215,
-0.3903106153011322,
0.6262114644050598,
-0.022645508870482445,
0.6661055684089661,
0.2719310224056244,
-0.5308642983436584,
0.4360489845275879,
0.11955192685127258,
-0.5984595417976379,
-0.8464753031730652,
0.28518998622894287,
-0.5546920895576477,
-0.008936449885368347,
1.0075221061706543,
-0.18249189853668213,
-0.14005997776985168,
-0.06966638565063477,
-0.16265317797660828,
0.07866433262825012,
-0.5696274042129517,
0.03790069371461868,
0.449286550283432,
-0.49596789479255676,
-0.46169647574424744,
-0.9255374073982239,
0.45648837089538574,
0.21959343552589417,
-0.7534100413322449,
0.07164444774389267,
0.3985757827758789,
0.37659573554992676,
-0.3304313123226166,
0.685483992099762,
0.11069607734680176,
0.04458688199520111,
0.3149586021900177,
0.20239698886871338,
-0.14185020327568054,
-0.018402118235826492,
-0.10787755250930786,
0.06692223250865936,
0.21625031530857086,
-0.5664486289024353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01867v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Structure Learning in Prompted Weak Supervision | 2024-02-02T19:45:39 | 2024-02-02T19:45:39 | Jinyan Su, Peilin Yu, Jieyu Zhang, Stephen H. Bach | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Prompted weak supervision (PromptedWS) applies pre-trained large language
models (LLMs) as the basis for labeling functions (LFs) in a weak supervision
framework to obtain large labeled datasets. We further extend the use of LLMs
in the loop to address one of the key challenges in weak supervision: learning
the statistical dependency structure among supervision sources. In this work,
we ask the LLM how similar are these prompted LFs. We propose a Structure
Refining Module, a simple yet effective first approach based on the
similarities of the prompts by taking advantage of the intrinsic structure in
the embedding space. At the core of Structure Refining Module are Labeling
Function Removal (LaRe) and Correlation Structure Generation (CosGen). Compared
to previous methods that learn the dependencies from weak labels, our method
finds the dependencies which are intrinsic to the LFs and less dependent on the
data. We show that our Structure Refining Module improves the PromptedWS
pipeline by up to 12.7 points on the benchmark tasks. We also explore the
trade-offs between efficiency and performance with comprehensive ablation
experiments and analysis. Code for this project can be found in
https://github.com/BatsResearch/su-bigdata23-code. | [
-0.046653226017951965,
-0.8957951664924622,
0.5657428503036499,
0.03147146850824356,
-0.1335488259792328,
-0.1770278364419937,
-0.38914403319358826,
-0.4034814238548279,
0.20772580802440643,
0.6854979395866394,
-0.4106515645980835,
-0.6492823362350464,
-0.44018951058387756,
0.11800378561019897,
-0.22335468232631683,
0.9677550792694092,
0.025473423302173615,
0.07154915481805801,
0.02377963438630104,
0.005711248144507408,
-0.3145682215690613,
-0.373472660779953,
-0.5092114210128784,
-0.49982672929763794,
1.0032912492752075,
0.5414722561836243,
0.5081382989883423,
0.7926899790763855,
0.35080718994140625,
0.35506102442741394,
-0.4806990921497345,
0.05343456566333771,
-0.6790313720703125,
0.3067353665828705,
-0.21123066544532776,
-0.45051899552345276,
-0.5501823425292969,
-0.45951226353645325,
0.6035374402999878,
1.1027833223342896,
-0.08326547592878342,
0.1214289665222168,
0.37266626954078674,
0.6064154505729675,
-0.6318597197532654,
0.43309858441352844,
-0.6658666133880615,
-0.2595795691013336,
-0.31365343928337097,
-0.08613430708646774,
-0.6602146029472351,
0.0295316893607378,
0.2585003972053528,
-0.13573408126831055,
0.4044119417667389,
0.06711290031671524,
0.7917216420173645,
0.31523802876472473,
-0.6031460165977478,
-0.3077843189239502,
-0.39382204413414,
0.8102542161941528,
-0.4882580041885376,
0.3834013044834137,
0.675634503364563,
-0.02939467690885067,
-0.278304785490036,
-0.7261707186698914,
0.13962195813655853,
-0.34118470549583435,
-0.18950915336608887,
-0.15905427932739258,
0.09656137228012085,
0.26465535163879395,
0.5582199692726135,
0.3589625954627991,
-0.36157843470573425,
0.41948947310447693,
-0.6888288855552673,
-0.33964696526527405,
0.36182910203933716,
0.04274881258606911,
-0.01368100568652153,
-0.13874855637550354,
-0.3517453074455261,
-0.14063604176044464,
-0.9869391322135925,
-0.049327749758958817,
0.33547186851501465,
0.9012075066566467,
-0.16599054634571075,
0.7422453165054321,
-0.2608282268047333,
0.5995369553565979,
-0.001314659253694117,
-0.10574300587177277,
0.3836669921875,
0.08096551150083542,
-0.2597198486328125,
0.2751157283782959,
0.5229681134223938,
-0.21371647715568542,
0.20088714361190796,
-0.02928054705262184,
-0.31325802206993103,
-0.11969005316495895,
0.4101918339729309,
-0.8186944127082825,
-0.5336828827857971,
0.17405053973197937,
-0.3654356598854065,
-0.01727493293583393,
0.021718895062804222,
-0.3656530976295471,
-0.20649008452892303,
-0.5205915570259094,
0.34847497940063477,
-0.29827094078063965,
0.05387527868151665,
-0.13426701724529266,
-0.06581580638885498,
0.1970946192741394,
0.26194921135902405,
-1.0551265478134155,
0.03550052270293236,
0.5524024963378906,
0.8287050127983093,
0.012935161590576172,
-0.13280516862869263,
-1.0801143646240234,
0.3539965748786926,
-0.3361402153968811,
0.6001537442207336,
-0.3154972195625305,
-0.23582081496715546,
0.12507444620132446,
0.08102225512266159,
0.353236585855484,
-0.7546717524528503,
0.5333741307258606,
-0.5804353952407837,
-0.2617810070514679,
-0.31820639967918396,
-0.5249527096748352,
-0.02787395939230919,
0.12396644055843353,
-0.7723982334136963,
1.0245882272720337,
0.2968776822090149,
-0.6092599630355835,
0.4707038998603821,
-0.019105535000562668,
-0.692305862903595,
0.2498583346605301,
-0.07652949541807175,
-0.7865564227104187,
0.13545799255371094,
0.19369445741176605,
0.7068332433700562,
-0.014709778130054474,
0.6125561594963074,
-0.8035892248153687,
-0.36053740978240967,
-0.1267838180065155,
-0.07422921806573868,
0.7122005820274353,
0.09485835582017899,
-0.1479944884777069,
0.5607457756996155,
-1.061275839805603,
-0.10450970381498337,
-0.18632405996322632,
-0.562850832939148,
-0.490742951631546,
0.08315442502498627,
-0.26651203632354736,
-0.3222430348396301,
0.006263247225433588,
-0.07922855764627457,
0.2813621163368225,
-0.5860610008239746,
0.22184017300605774,
0.8007689714431763,
0.07324927300214767,
0.528242826461792,
0.10958503186702728,
0.15930332243442535,
-0.10479408502578735,
-0.09099658578634262,
-0.34535902738571167,
-0.09756375849246979,
-0.6326419711112976,
-0.6151599287986755,
0.012600330635905266,
0.20174215734004974,
-0.7510416507720947,
0.5836701989173889,
0.19711938500404358,
-0.33080482482910156,
-0.10833071172237396,
0.6987437009811401,
0.5283701419830322,
0.6925772428512573,
0.6613973379135132,
-0.06661567836999893,
-0.736758828163147,
-0.9988681674003601,
-0.09103219211101532,
-0.38421431183815,
-0.13488569855690002,
-0.11044353246688843,
0.4515456557273865,
-0.16063009202480316,
0.7066076993942261,
-0.6566547751426697,
-0.38792863488197327,
-0.36287060379981995,
0.007051660213619471,
0.5210105180740356,
0.2807552218437195,
0.44412994384765625,
-0.5337499380111694,
-0.33894532918930054,
-0.2229955941438675,
-0.5691842436790466,
-0.3199995160102844,
0.2822360694408417,
0.02081131562590599,
-0.0404914952814579,
0.8420314788818359,
-0.4924870431423187,
0.1326618641614914,
0.4182393550872803,
-0.16168621182441711,
0.7726408839225769,
0.05856605991721153,
-0.24638928472995758,
-0.9720654487609863,
0.1337384730577469,
0.16575251519680023,
-0.059087857604026794,
-0.6581348776817322,
0.02438250184059143,
0.1894107311964035,
-0.09692278504371643,
-0.6049003005027771,
0.4974745213985443,
-0.6835167407989502,
0.04312177374958992,
-0.2929515540599823,
-0.2605409026145935,
-0.05865755304694176,
0.6018291115760803,
-0.11508532613515854,
0.40170249342918396,
0.8383861184120178,
-0.7291020154953003,
0.23509317636489868,
0.31853654980659485,
-0.5054899454116821,
0.09823720902204514,
-0.7755822539329529,
-0.06730662286281586,
0.039039526134729385,
0.17407377064228058,
-1.0323779582977295,
-0.4523797929286957,
0.34089335799217224,
0.03816603124141693,
0.4957124590873718,
-0.6263914108276367,
-0.3955991268157959,
-0.28492873907089233,
-0.1351427584886551,
0.15963523089885712,
0.40071195363998413,
-0.8800688982009888,
0.3077847361564636,
0.1476963311433792,
-0.275664746761322,
-0.6680108904838562,
-0.7082314491271973,
-0.1258409321308136,
-0.34258973598480225,
-0.43006497621536255,
0.13383246958255768,
0.2715647518634796,
-0.39398983120918274,
-0.13487508893013,
-0.3002658188343048,
0.006751605309545994,
0.19519205391407013,
0.35102516412734985,
0.33527836203575134,
-0.2980040907859802,
0.37595298886299133,
-0.0007273735827766359,
-0.021092457696795464,
0.14828714728355408,
-0.1759074330329895,
0.39747756719589233,
-0.052814360707998276,
-0.29445090889930725,
-0.14460422098636627,
0.0368475578725338,
0.1313379555940628,
-0.0948379784822464,
0.8231205344200134,
0.5214344263076782,
-0.057896584272384644,
-0.7289619445800781,
-0.4521547555923462,
-0.47678717970848083,
-0.5590322017669678,
0.4460682272911072,
-0.5258854627609253,
-1.2907660007476807,
0.5004600286483765,
-0.0654178112745285,
-0.10835928469896317,
0.32008203864097595,
0.6996908783912659,
0.032332826405763626,
0.9000043272972107,
0.6455873250961304,
-0.19589802622795105,
0.7069389224052429,
-0.12686961889266968,
0.06812087446451187,
-0.4894358813762665,
-0.12439703941345215,
-0.6702713966369629,
-0.085677869617939,
-0.08565185964107513,
-0.2502358555793762,
0.2140384465456009,
0.5221035480499268,
-0.19215303659439087,
0.33634400367736816,
-0.2991669774055481,
0.4075515568256378,
0.4199550151824951,
0.21944564580917358,
0.09721961617469788,
0.16082613170146942,
-0.060283612459897995,
0.3258456587791443,
-0.5791965126991272,
-0.3623977601528168,
0.8904405236244202,
0.3384760320186615,
1.1314738988876343,
-0.163304403424263,
0.7251640558242798,
0.03879949077963829,
0.475972056388855,
-1.092027187347412,
0.558007538318634,
-0.08844570070505142,
-0.3441363275051117,
-0.29839199781417847,
-0.8534291982650757,
-0.9462634921073914,
0.20057173073291779,
-0.01593734696507454,
-0.7045804262161255,
0.07415793091058731,
0.3718182444572449,
-0.050877299159765244,
0.16932262480258942,
-1.0196380615234375,
0.6830374598503113,
-0.12146233767271042,
-0.5670556426048279,
-0.12763363122940063,
-0.5831097364425659,
0.4104442596435547,
0.10001107305288315,
-0.10030896216630936,
0.01843787357211113,
0.3118019700050354,
0.5925745964050293,
-0.5750755071640015,
1.255230188369751,
-0.21235881745815277,
-0.562305212020874,
0.5045151114463806,
-0.14425291121006012,
0.6397402286529541,
0.05835786089301109,
-0.234928697347641,
0.12424786388874054,
-0.3999303877353668,
-0.3336094617843628,
-0.3108018636703491,
0.5299984216690063,
-0.44550129771232605,
-0.6373648047447205,
-0.02470499463379383,
-0.3455307185649872,
-0.2230987548828125,
0.3684951961040497,
0.03126070275902748,
0.764878511428833,
-0.053614117205142975,
0.40458187460899353,
0.5739084482192993,
-0.038322340697050095,
0.1758105456829071,
0.32303640246391296,
-0.16672125458717346,
-0.2742632031440735,
0.632623553276062,
0.04456326365470886,
0.16684618592262268,
0.3566201627254486,
0.1905217468738556,
-0.24090228974819183,
-0.6902397871017456,
-0.06879264861345291,
0.37590447068214417,
-0.7800818085670471,
-0.38487523794174194,
-0.5457324385643005,
-0.014099480584263802,
-0.5196072459220886,
-0.1948237121105194,
-0.2764240503311157,
-0.08857022225856781,
-0.384438693523407,
-0.26422354578971863,
0.326476514339447,
0.6418609619140625,
0.20438894629478455,
0.49028411507606506,
-0.8327255249023438,
0.3756839632987976,
0.21272708475589752,
0.5009666681289673,
0.12414539605379105,
-0.32287055253982544,
-0.6829540133476257,
-0.24946555495262146,
-0.15651719272136688,
-0.8315508961677551,
0.2480679154396057,
0.11034081131219864,
0.5567032694816589,
0.6977341175079346,
0.06036205217242241,
0.6806074380874634,
-0.444693386554718,
0.45756280422210693,
0.2206680029630661,
-0.8568792939186096,
0.7176114916801453,
-0.3778732717037201,
0.30807703733444214,
0.5793843865394592,
0.38221102952957153,
0.027438554912805557,
-0.5931215286254883,
-0.34890812635421753,
-1.1270419359207153,
0.8378271460533142,
-0.17593473196029663,
-0.23606640100479126,
-0.27178704738616943,
0.5304180979728699,
0.020780004560947418,
-0.006879834458231926,
-0.5886911153793335,
-0.0651874840259552,
0.39413681626319885,
-0.17880943417549133,
-0.1583918333053589,
-0.4119125306606293,
-0.2513422966003418,
0.021112151443958282,
0.6965776681900024,
-0.43683645129203796,
-0.35767441987991333,
0.20283059775829315,
-0.404131680727005,
-0.25089094042778015,
0.3769153952598572,
0.05296660214662552,
0.492167592048645,
-0.23457355797290802,
0.4028022587299347,
0.18097929656505585,
-0.24537812173366547,
0.07035381346940994,
-0.16594325006008148,
-0.04822453111410141,
-0.2687785029411316,
0.779411792755127,
0.9317275881767273,
0.48484909534454346,
-0.589252233505249,
0.13740284740924835,
0.4290616512298584,
-0.33878275752067566,
0.07153183221817017,
0.27949976921081543,
0.08264920860528946,
0.4164477586746216,
0.4293118119239807,
-0.22093519568443298,
0.08623645454645157,
-0.607620358467102,
0.46194881200790405,
0.30303725600242615,
-0.476580947637558,
-0.5288062691688538,
0.3272326588630676,
0.03443313390016556,
0.005595286842435598,
0.6981180310249329,
-0.05440988764166832,
-0.5167423486709595,
0.5539577603340149,
0.6557173132896423,
0.6686522364616394,
-0.20687609910964966,
0.11191430687904358,
0.5671783685684204,
0.12085658311843872,
-0.5471644997596741,
0.1759122908115387,
-0.23926356434822083,
-0.5318201780319214,
-0.9213847517967224,
-0.8151646852493286,
-0.4692954123020172,
0.07454723119735718,
-0.8131842613220215,
0.6837583184242249,
-0.49337348341941833,
0.004703144542872906,
-0.22860243916511536,
-0.08764395117759705,
-0.3058217763900757,
0.044054046273231506,
0.18404927849769592,
0.5639280676841736,
-0.9523080587387085,
0.7941859364509583,
0.797853946685791,
-0.18233108520507812,
-1.163725733757019,
-0.0890187993645668,
0.248799666762352,
-0.6144306063652039,
0.9524007439613342,
0.37620779871940613,
-0.12118193507194519,
-0.1327255517244339,
-0.6800342798233032,
-0.8246996402740479,
0.6611260175704956,
0.42472219467163086,
-0.7123593688011169,
0.009585930034518242,
-0.26523610949516296,
0.5973843336105347,
-0.05214589089155197,
0.0771760419011116,
0.2631089389324188,
0.3846154808998108,
0.2744135856628418,
-0.4898753762245178,
0.2416091412305832,
-0.03597730025649071,
-0.2856484353542328,
0.4761671721935272,
-0.589598536491394,
0.6841273903846741,
-0.3907338082790375,
-0.3299630880355835,
0.041847679764032364,
0.9643262028694153,
0.42821985483169556,
0.23771055042743683,
0.554125964641571,
0.5879555344581604,
0.6443078517913818,
0.02846277691423893,
0.6675608158111572,
0.0528496652841568,
0.422055184841156,
1.2784394025802612,
-0.4760169982910156,
0.7600052356719971,
0.5465811491012573,
-0.1210356056690216,
0.43110471963882446,
0.3599066734313965,
-0.2889561355113983,
0.39462992548942566,
0.22907346487045288,
0.045666616410017014,
-0.1562148630619049,
-0.08117397129535675,
-0.20054610073566437,
0.287896066904068,
0.4610171616077423,
-0.3726278245449066,
-0.42647236585617065,
-0.09863121062517166,
-0.24485766887664795,
-0.20510224997997284,
-0.40008142590522766,
0.7361364960670471,
0.4619167447090149,
-0.5803802013397217,
0.6332219243049622,
-0.22314323484897614,
0.3960515856742859,
-0.9868277907371521,
0.03193982318043709,
0.02037704549729824,
0.4073188900947571,
-0.37471020221710205,
-0.6229318976402283,
0.43820515275001526,
-0.08013034611940384,
-0.20084942877292633,
-0.5722250938415527,
0.9005594849586487,
-0.7346294522285461,
-0.06605647504329681,
0.6872974634170532,
0.36536699533462524,
-0.017998933792114258,
-0.003986439201980829,
-0.2960185706615448,
0.12051993608474731,
-0.006072713527828455,
-0.6006850600242615,
0.3520725965499878,
0.4107104539871216,
-0.10298606008291245,
0.48905134201049805,
0.6950697302818298,
0.25045260787010193,
-0.15327495336532593,
0.6289299726486206,
0.9723053574562073,
-0.6198528409004211,
-0.43719837069511414,
-0.9651549458503723,
0.331816166639328,
0.18385007977485657,
-0.23447225987911224,
0.8745605945587158,
0.505282998085022,
0.8126522898674011,
-0.09845323860645294,
0.34836500883102417,
0.01875418983399868,
0.30994492769241333,
-0.8219426870346069,
0.4234164357185364,
-0.5980164408683777,
0.450891375541687,
-0.33092454075813293,
-1.3412933349609375,
-0.5292202830314636,
0.2890337109565735,
-0.38843950629234314,
-0.17986391484737396,
0.6292334198951721,
0.9882734417915344,
-0.11195222288370132,
-0.13382680714130402,
0.22425347566604614,
0.6187811493873596,
0.45485353469848633,
0.26826316118240356,
0.9533905982971191,
0.03644231706857681,
0.6818112730979919,
-0.12747235596179962,
-0.13932941854000092,
-0.22073546051979065,
-0.5858672261238098,
-1.225213646888733,
-0.41308489441871643,
-0.35864290595054626,
-0.4713849127292633,
-0.09445725381374359,
0.822169303894043,
0.6344984173774719,
-0.8371961712837219,
-0.17862346768379211,
-0.09532506763935089,
0.21442721784114838,
-0.1227138340473175,
-0.25739091634750366,
0.5673884749412537,
-0.7396196126937866,
-0.4921676516532898,
0.8726046681404114,
0.4378179609775543,
-0.1442144215106964,
0.03746102750301361,
0.052406396716833115,
-0.1257666051387787,
-0.4530980587005615,
0.5950373411178589,
0.26559698581695557,
-0.4566352367401123,
-0.39317357540130615,
-0.21022675931453705,
-0.21120499074459076,
-0.023064441978931427,
0.9506635665893555,
-0.5570573806762695,
0.10714074969291687,
0.7456212043762207,
0.5901556611061096,
0.6306747794151306,
0.060788366943597794,
0.4205155372619629,
-1.1474220752716064,
0.1806625872850418,
0.06668668240308762,
0.4978178143501282,
0.26187819242477417,
-0.3327603340148926,
0.4866166412830353,
0.04878051578998566,
-0.49789825081825256,
-0.9379293918609619,
0.46983852982521057,
-1.0472904443740845,
-0.3305872678756714,
1.1308380365371704,
-0.13349264860153198,
-0.45912450551986694,
-0.30104827880859375,
-0.22083966434001923,
0.43978142738342285,
-0.3413350284099579,
0.6622592806816101,
0.5207054615020752,
0.12259510904550552,
-0.06851975619792938,
0.010200933553278446,
0.25421494245529175,
0.7158622145652771,
-0.5117580890655518,
0.2543781101703644,
0.558773934841156,
0.203193798661232,
0.03872077539563179,
0.5029195547103882,
-0.020694689825177193,
-0.12780256569385529,
-0.0546087846159935,
0.007348131388425827,
-0.12641531229019165,
-0.602410614490509,
-0.44540876150131226,
0.43182486295700073,
-0.0053649842739105225,
0.46937504410743713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01865v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01865v2 | What Will My Model Forget? Forecasting Forgotten Examples in Language Model Refinement | 2024-02-02T19:43:15 | 2024-06-20T06:25:39 | Xisen Jin, Xiang Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Language models deployed in the wild make errors. However, simply updating
the model with the corrected error instances causes catastrophic forgetting --
the updated model makes errors on instances learned during the instruction
tuning or upstream training phase. Randomly replaying upstream data yields
unsatisfactory performance and often comes with high variance and poor
controllability. To this end, we try to forecast upstream examples that will be
forgotten due to a model update for improved controllability of the replay
process and interpretability. We train forecasting models given a collection of
online learned examples and corresponding forgotten upstream pre-training
examples. We propose a partially interpretable forecasting model based on the
observation that changes in pre-softmax logit scores of pretraining examples
resemble that of online learned examples, which performs decently on BART but
fails on T5 models. We further show a black-box classifier based on inner
products of example representations achieves better forecasting performance
over a series of setups. Finally, we show that we reduce forgetting of upstream
pretraining examples by replaying examples that are forecasted to be forgotten,
demonstrating the practical utility of forecasting example forgetting. | [
0.004269332159310579,
-0.43233522772789,
0.4174615144729614,
0.3638817369937897,
-0.2837621867656708,
0.0031669167801737785,
0.06151410564780235,
-0.3146428167819977,
0.02298407442867756,
0.45531362295150757,
-0.6609418392181396,
-0.16213808953762054,
-0.482649564743042,
-0.30042529106140137,
-0.49061286449432373,
1.2159299850463867,
-0.1596335619688034,
0.08318689465522766,
-0.036365073174238205,
0.042902786284685135,
-0.7921346426010132,
-0.5846534371376038,
-0.9698531031608582,
-0.47434064745903015,
0.3180219531059265,
0.3954431414604187,
0.3189604580402374,
0.596890389919281,
0.07285099476575851,
0.2217409312725067,
0.04773770645260811,
-0.07404102385044098,
-0.8744347095489502,
0.007165194489061832,
-0.1633978635072708,
-0.7086762189865112,
-0.5232849717140198,
0.026063615456223488,
0.7309749722480774,
0.7861718535423279,
-0.47908949851989746,
0.06187916174530983,
-0.0413811057806015,
0.46911370754241943,
-0.5072333216667175,
0.4816156327724457,
-0.8611671924591064,
0.019510777667164803,
0.11992445588111877,
-0.12294837832450867,
-0.36068278551101685,
-0.2780446410179138,
0.24701842665672302,
-0.48800206184387207,
0.49007344245910645,
0.1308174431324005,
0.8115095496177673,
0.1915615350008011,
-0.05873449146747589,
-0.2508789300918579,
-1.0443106889724731,
1.0771523714065552,
-0.9869096875190735,
0.25831741094589233,
0.5189903974533081,
0.5836970210075378,
-0.15519940853118896,
-0.8810439705848694,
-0.32897868752479553,
0.15883632004261017,
0.06172678619623184,
0.5934866666793823,
-0.4377329647541046,
-0.2617197632789612,
-0.0033955280669033527,
0.2225770801305771,
-0.2786792516708374,
0.0015771688194945455,
-0.45697101950645447,
-0.2059304267168045,
0.40360403060913086,
0.037053827196359634,
-0.37877562642097473,
0.4308620095252991,
-0.193948432803154,
-0.043632958084344864,
-0.9618368148803711,
-0.17639893293380737,
0.3051829934120178,
0.27805671095848083,
0.04111412167549133,
0.05013471096754074,
0.0054803527891635895,
0.35055655241012573,
0.1262681931257248,
0.03867068886756897,
0.16010308265686035,
0.03011534921824932,
-0.3299407362937927,
-0.035058699548244476,
0.2822725474834442,
0.32491162419319153,
0.546144425868988,
-0.15828737616539001,
-0.4530985653400421,
-0.2819311022758484,
0.36588263511657715,
-0.22504311800003052,
-0.4520343840122223,
0.1803719699382782,
-0.37650802731513977,
-0.11163734644651413,
-0.2564374804496765,
-0.534281849861145,
-0.13165436685085297,
-0.25823575258255005,
0.5397615432739258,
-0.2640047073364258,
-0.31020182371139526,
0.06005712226033211,
-0.483791321516037,
-0.08735612034797668,
0.4785600006580353,
-0.913756251335144,
0.4226558804512024,
0.4616358280181885,
0.48294103145599365,
0.3794575035572052,
-0.6108715534210205,
-0.4589620530605316,
0.15794579684734344,
-0.4843975305557251,
0.7784087061882019,
-0.27147695422172546,
-0.34399905800819397,
-0.03676242381334305,
0.14612822234630585,
-0.18899311125278473,
-0.6180601716041565,
0.14053988456726074,
-0.5714933276176453,
0.3432813584804535,
-0.22157029807567596,
-0.695878803730011,
-0.5944302678108215,
0.029197411611676216,
-0.5638180375099182,
0.8471357226371765,
0.23503099381923676,
-0.2770414650440216,
0.4949570298194885,
-0.2676761746406555,
-0.11777716875076294,
-0.06315141916275024,
0.2343813180923462,
-0.7462651133537292,
0.2295031100511551,
0.012674236670136452,
0.4950186014175415,
-0.007366945035755634,
0.25618359446525574,
-0.38932105898857117,
-0.4911811053752899,
-0.12531104683876038,
-0.42483457922935486,
0.34476375579833984,
0.07075130939483643,
-0.43995413184165955,
0.19405537843704224,
-0.6295405030250549,
-0.10456275939941406,
0.2993673086166382,
-0.01573469489812851,
-0.3217337727546692,
0.46240049600601196,
0.12025132775306702,
0.057824984192848206,
0.07193700224161148,
-0.17212866246700287,
0.04076877236366272,
-0.37398722767829895,
0.5057597756385803,
1.2449935674667358,
0.1508318930864334,
0.3630269169807434,
-0.6851953864097595,
0.6512964367866516,
0.5573037266731262,
0.10938521474599838,
-0.5665810108184814,
-0.4602159559726715,
-1.0313555002212524,
0.3126085102558136,
0.21639813482761383,
0.5293619632720947,
-0.5274023413658142,
-0.0381418839097023,
-0.23380357027053833,
-0.6686459183692932,
-0.299185186624527,
0.23869846761226654,
0.4012052118778229,
0.3665698766708374,
0.4121895730495453,
-0.2168586403131485,
-0.7128928303718567,
-0.7214943766593933,
-0.40225425362586975,
-0.13811743259429932,
0.01758337765932083,
0.06042783707380295,
0.5295498967170715,
-0.18377406895160675,
0.8274527192115784,
-0.43047112226486206,
-0.23020105063915253,
-0.5013234615325928,
0.2757897973060608,
0.17677678167819977,
0.5383817553520203,
0.566372811794281,
-0.6600281596183777,
-0.026730326935648918,
-0.3002920150756836,
-0.4841039478778839,
0.3038167655467987,
-0.3896915912628174,
0.1571468859910965,
0.20391902327537537,
0.528355598449707,
-0.18953026831150055,
0.23943465948104858,
0.49059489369392395,
-0.22006161510944366,
0.5212259292602539,
-0.5551379323005676,
-0.5306516885757446,
-0.8793001174926758,
-0.3070821762084961,
-0.08463288098573685,
-0.5368843674659729,
-0.4273703396320343,
-0.14862586557865143,
0.0366380549967289,
-0.020174114033579826,
-0.4550897181034088,
0.6334359049797058,
-0.3001965284347534,
-0.02687346376478672,
-0.16789521276950836,
-0.2448752373456955,
-0.1183147057890892,
0.4991815984249115,
0.04680626839399338,
0.6479016542434692,
0.4924500584602356,
-0.7907395958900452,
-0.026261286810040474,
-0.15027672052383423,
-0.31247860193252563,
-0.016344718635082245,
-0.5288890600204468,
0.23874077200889587,
-0.4513697028160095,
0.16752617061138153,
-0.779694676399231,
0.009366785176098347,
0.0926983505487442,
-0.1267288625240326,
0.6274142265319824,
-0.19756706058979034,
-0.18399065732955933,
-0.3286968171596527,
-0.05751049891114235,
0.021622346714138985,
0.8614174127578735,
-0.5428975820541382,
0.5759568214416504,
0.3230038583278656,
-0.22658707201480865,
-0.5959116816520691,
-0.6295697689056396,
-0.1847219169139862,
-0.2449454963207245,
0.21441318094730377,
0.05688295140862465,
-0.10705385357141495,
0.04446939378976822,
0.0837664008140564,
-0.2291812002658844,
-0.2009395807981491,
0.3744155764579773,
0.26620087027549744,
0.21193180978298187,
-0.29212719202041626,
0.12694652378559113,
0.03443152830004692,
-0.08209651708602905,
-0.002822462236508727,
-0.6419196128845215,
0.3731314539909363,
-0.36777329444885254,
-0.11714082956314087,
-0.08781460672616959,
0.12800800800323486,
0.5081266760826111,
0.2586730420589447,
0.755172610282898,
0.1435936689376831,
-0.5872796773910522,
-0.37820321321487427,
-0.6105361580848694,
-0.20618031919002533,
-0.4477449059486389,
0.4572204351425171,
-0.14905676245689392,
-0.5383809804916382,
0.6876969337463379,
-0.16028250753879547,
0.27457162737846375,
0.4399605691432953,
0.17958806455135345,
-0.45416009426116943,
0.9123005270957947,
0.9124234914779663,
-0.32824572920799255,
0.5147009491920471,
-0.31253761053085327,
0.13286733627319336,
-0.4014446437358856,
0.012137094512581825,
-0.3150026500225067,
-0.1604950875043869,
-0.6056168079376221,
-0.23218870162963867,
-0.03947393223643303,
0.4410158693790436,
-0.437583327293396,
0.3130226731300354,
-0.03009490668773651,
0.5493891835212708,
0.7348938584327698,
-0.08804764598608017,
0.19462724030017853,
0.12721215188503265,
-0.034416988492012024,
-0.1572706699371338,
-1.103224515914917,
-0.5198900103569031,
1.1718147993087769,
0.35311949253082275,
0.7803224921226501,
-0.3939356505870819,
0.5450999140739441,
0.362518846988678,
0.7234793901443481,
-0.5073655843734741,
0.1847878396511078,
-0.21936941146850586,
-0.5804830193519592,
0.03732602298259735,
-0.39444872736930847,
-0.7698962688446045,
-0.05062060430645943,
0.06181678548455238,
-0.5673592686653137,
0.2616111934185028,
0.7836698889732361,
-0.16524192690849304,
0.5111890435218811,
-1.0636357069015503,
0.9865124821662903,
0.009686071425676346,
0.04024902358651161,
-0.3481996953487396,
-0.26415690779685974,
0.2134629786014557,
-0.34327778220176697,
0.3637371063232422,
0.07825816422700882,
0.2610810697078705,
0.6173088550567627,
-0.1166892722249031,
1.1010791063308716,
-0.2956719398498535,
0.16135908663272858,
0.15662464499473572,
-0.06453821808099747,
0.4213467836380005,
-0.39292290806770325,
-0.10978381335735321,
0.4084961712360382,
-0.01604274846613407,
-0.7012835144996643,
-0.46904119849205017,
0.6129063963890076,
-0.6774474382400513,
-0.5341208577156067,
-0.4280685484409332,
-0.09343917667865753,
-0.2173420935869217,
0.10165829956531525,
0.27567073702812195,
0.3816014230251312,
-0.1968676596879959,
-0.20006129145622253,
0.38715025782585144,
-0.12605178356170654,
0.6573241353034973,
0.43716952204704285,
-0.3001430630683899,
-0.11951768398284912,
1.1165729761123657,
0.29205483198165894,
0.4038711488246918,
0.3222678303718567,
0.15515190362930298,
-0.09032213687896729,
-0.6439918279647827,
-0.47712069749832153,
0.2609795033931732,
-0.8243647217750549,
-0.10749652236700058,
-0.24930410087108612,
-0.17637211084365845,
-0.1989736109972,
-0.12652307748794556,
-0.5141923427581787,
-0.5042729377746582,
-0.34268784523010254,
-0.224628746509552,
0.13981114327907562,
1.1208399534225464,
0.05133018642663956,
0.6281911730766296,
-0.7462893128395081,
-0.028166696429252625,
0.2702215909957886,
0.6054534912109375,
0.5265853404998779,
-0.43079978227615356,
-0.47396403551101685,
0.2138165980577469,
-0.6278921961784363,
-0.46803897619247437,
0.638012170791626,
0.4230649173259735,
0.5940203070640564,
0.5402910709381104,
-0.18831734359264374,
0.8322924375534058,
-0.6707140803337097,
0.6267651319503784,
0.052637144923210144,
-0.9671884775161743,
0.6116313934326172,
-0.09045929461717606,
0.6435034871101379,
0.21183623373508453,
0.44520390033721924,
-0.7067810297012329,
-0.7963537573814392,
-0.7659425139427185,
-0.7964709401130676,
0.7189369201660156,
-0.18480278551578522,
0.2905513644218445,
-0.05134756118059158,
0.3905617296695709,
0.43825259804725647,
0.3831847012042999,
-0.866811215877533,
-0.4966594874858856,
-0.5521664619445801,
-0.06831492483615875,
-0.5770912170410156,
-0.4489634037017822,
0.31818994879722595,
-0.21265465021133423,
0.8204447627067566,
0.0690731480717659,
0.36094197630882263,
-0.060908883810043335,
-0.09827253967523575,
-0.3708069920539856,
0.17104540765285492,
0.6782503724098206,
0.8984898328781128,
-0.38873928785324097,
-0.039615485817193985,
0.4494255483150482,
-0.44448554515838623,
-0.06097552552819252,
-0.09784696996212006,
-0.3892765939235687,
0.18633440136909485,
0.5636392831802368,
0.9329188466072083,
0.6360788941383362,
-0.6875713467597961,
0.12296216934919357,
-0.005218180827796459,
0.02756871096789837,
-0.9525231719017029,
0.04912218824028969,
0.28741487860679626,
0.0448167622089386,
0.5234856605529785,
0.6494662761688232,
-0.1613352745771408,
-0.7757441401481628,
-0.14001023769378662,
0.04455569013953209,
-0.7102352380752563,
-0.4975719153881073,
0.7581580877304077,
-0.29271429777145386,
-0.09551908820867538,
0.673711359500885,
-0.15146350860595703,
-0.7976909279823303,
0.6958675980567932,
0.630004346370697,
0.8072773218154907,
-0.5063870549201965,
-0.0608711913228035,
0.22889316082000732,
0.43295958638191223,
-0.4717271625995636,
0.3167474865913391,
0.2482624351978302,
-0.8060630559921265,
-0.3934299051761627,
-0.545505940914154,
-0.31511348485946655,
0.33697354793548584,
-0.7095186114311218,
0.18717266619205475,
-0.7339608073234558,
-0.05135840177536011,
-0.17434105277061462,
-0.35431793332099915,
-0.8502328395843506,
0.43595466017723083,
0.017194151878356934,
0.8933224081993103,
-1.0023189783096313,
0.8077535033226013,
0.5802491307258606,
-0.34494030475616455,
-0.8341778516769409,
-0.11270812153816223,
-0.16569551825523376,
-0.7341793775558472,
0.599541962146759,
0.05326385051012039,
0.0030470588244497776,
0.07728185504674911,
-0.4561857581138611,
-0.7215613722801208,
0.879404604434967,
0.21183402836322784,
-0.7347135543823242,
-0.1643596887588501,
-0.2196522206068039,
0.49710771441459656,
-0.3517167866230011,
0.4337417185306549,
0.44474729895591736,
0.251361608505249,
-0.0423724539577961,
-0.9126924872398376,
-0.32170993089675903,
-0.12610898911952972,
-0.1677429974079132,
0.2104678452014923,
-0.49259066581726074,
1.0331603288650513,
-0.3666124641895294,
-0.16882354021072388,
-0.058330487459897995,
0.4622175097465515,
-0.15370535850524902,
0.6952898502349854,
0.39335474371910095,
0.49308454990386963,
0.7391461133956909,
-0.15021352469921112,
1.335898995399475,
0.22265896201133728,
0.2900390923023224,
1.52336847782135,
-0.13472573459148407,
1.0852333307266235,
0.2248980700969696,
-0.15068425238132477,
0.5006028413772583,
0.6512905359268188,
0.05235646292567253,
0.7095154523849487,
-0.07219444960355759,
-0.06405873596668243,
-0.26688265800476074,
0.35531964898109436,
-0.5545549392700195,
0.2847500741481781,
0.3528233468532562,
-0.339437335729599,
-0.3156665861606598,
0.1604681760072708,
0.03231875225901604,
-0.0666324645280838,
-0.7052538990974426,
0.8874449729919434,
0.2455984354019165,
-0.5868273377418518,
0.705941915512085,
-0.014349380508065224,
0.36568230390548706,
-0.694278359413147,
-0.09170663356781006,
-0.3973334729671478,
0.571300208568573,
0.1979113072156906,
-0.21955269575119019,
0.36623236536979675,
-0.2496820092201233,
-0.4290563762187958,
-0.762001097202301,
0.20007115602493286,
-0.4387694299221039,
-0.6638526916503906,
0.3761458694934845,
0.41345712542533875,
0.1611369103193283,
-0.029090337455272675,
-0.5727970600128174,
-0.36377066373825073,
0.05226524919271469,
-0.059369515627622604,
0.3168908655643463,
0.1858283430337906,
-0.260886013507843,
1.121606707572937,
0.43580037355422974,
0.3776699900627136,
0.1181270182132721,
0.16280195116996765,
0.7313234210014343,
-0.8222488760948181,
-0.5404048562049866,
-0.6699801087379456,
0.19721929728984833,
0.16882091760635376,
-0.29242151975631714,
0.7091015577316284,
0.5781034231185913,
1.174226999282837,
-0.5644722580909729,
0.7552082538604736,
0.6682777404785156,
0.7112925052642822,
-0.5259444713592529,
0.904991626739502,
-0.5234891772270203,
0.34880170226097107,
-0.13491739332675934,
-0.7741045951843262,
0.0016841066535562277,
0.41779816150665283,
-0.5106167793273926,
0.12534809112548828,
0.7369971871376038,
0.41431379318237305,
-0.23358599841594696,
0.21716046333312988,
0.3979140818119049,
0.5923341512680054,
0.12535345554351807,
0.5753516554832458,
0.8526061773300171,
-0.5755382776260376,
0.323771595954895,
-0.4802498519420624,
0.0038791594561189413,
-0.21507762372493744,
-1.095147728919983,
-0.6847220063209534,
-0.6616268157958984,
-0.32486692070961,
-0.15529802441596985,
0.30657023191452026,
0.8564861416816711,
0.958960771560669,
-1.273290753364563,
-0.4754602313041687,
-0.26949214935302734,
0.36388370394706726,
-0.5438514947891235,
-0.22564135491847992,
0.08962704986333847,
-0.5573646426200867,
-0.5507939457893372,
0.34548255801200867,
-0.014868715777993202,
0.5130000710487366,
-0.012202395126223564,
0.13563261926174164,
-0.026732349768280983,
-0.02217129059135914,
0.37141937017440796,
0.4954773485660553,
-0.5546596646308899,
-0.17413799464702606,
-0.27347639203071594,
0.4618079960346222,
-0.004654317628592253,
0.8387688994407654,
-0.9868258237838745,
0.5148188471794128,
-0.12584249675273895,
0.34790703654289246,
0.7847453951835632,
-0.22537080943584442,
1.0257853269577026,
-0.696215033531189,
0.33584946393966675,
0.32781746983528137,
0.5481576323509216,
0.28517553210258484,
-0.1661619246006012,
0.030421612784266472,
0.268363893032074,
-0.2911249101161957,
-0.5812900066375732,
0.08859679102897644,
-0.5538374781608582,
-0.4517999589443207,
0.3888842761516571,
-0.448547899723053,
-0.20047281682491302,
-0.23567090928554535,
0.08794620633125305,
0.13493095338344574,
-0.2733663022518158,
1.0148078203201294,
0.8611406683921814,
0.4573610723018646,
-0.39158132672309875,
-0.8671329617500305,
0.5782604217529297,
0.4922162890434265,
-0.3291809856891632,
0.21676644682884216,
0.33777087926864624,
0.5015514492988586,
-0.1970216929912567,
0.5704957246780396,
0.25808167457580566,
0.3792244493961334,
0.03420170396566391,
-0.11879218369722366,
-0.0314580462872982,
-0.38253167271614075,
-0.4943621754646301,
-0.07098230719566345,
0.22067178785800934,
0.06193608045578003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01858v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01858v3 | Explaining latent representations of generative models with large multimodal models | 2024-02-02T19:28:33 | 2024-04-18T03:54:39 | Mengdan Zhu, Zhenke Liu, Bo Pan, Abhinav Angirekula, Liang Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Learning interpretable representations of data generative latent factors is
an important topic for the development of artificial intelligence. With the
rise of the large multimodal model, it can align images with text to generate
answers. In this work, we propose a framework to comprehensively explain each
latent variable in the generative models using a large multimodal model. We
further measure the uncertainty of our generated explanations, quantitatively
evaluate the performance of explanation generation among multiple large
multimodal models, and qualitatively visualize the variations of each latent
variable to learn the disentanglement effects of different generative models on
explanations. Finally, we discuss the explanatory capabilities and limitations
of state-of-the-art large multimodal models. | [
-0.3794226348400116,
-0.9516305327415466,
0.8321321606636047,
0.15397939085960388,
-0.3060257136821747,
0.03800104558467865,
-0.20432820916175842,
-0.11629702150821686,
-0.14734141528606415,
-0.05204501748085022,
-0.7214413285255432,
-0.1985604166984558,
-0.7795558571815491,
-0.19444531202316284,
-0.20127493143081665,
0.8562896251678467,
-0.22893205285072327,
0.15604978799819946,
-0.49841320514678955,
0.20957142114639282,
-0.37445303797721863,
-0.32943636178970337,
-0.15881270170211792,
-0.47659146785736084,
0.78578782081604,
0.11030076444149017,
0.9452455639839172,
0.3592313230037689,
0.5154101252555847,
0.3785783648490906,
0.011012054048478603,
-0.003213954856619239,
-0.3239288628101349,
0.16731789708137512,
-0.18158406019210815,
-0.571629524230957,
-0.42297127842903137,
-0.08777716010808945,
0.6665590405464172,
0.9139357209205627,
0.047756344079971313,
-0.044798966497182846,
-0.09142206609249115,
0.24702219665050507,
-0.46246248483657837,
0.3635539412498474,
-0.2477339208126068,
0.2447342723608017,
-0.06038311496376991,
-0.22687987983226776,
-0.47399580478668213,
-0.039444103837013245,
-0.01783406361937523,
-0.8152443766593933,
0.24277371168136597,
-0.25560837984085083,
0.5498775243759155,
0.2745964527130127,
-0.8010198473930359,
-0.10700788348913193,
-1.2179782390594482,
0.8021204471588135,
-0.3022131621837616,
0.3620392978191376,
0.2916748821735382,
0.6503577828407288,
-0.06598065793514252,
-0.7425200343132019,
-0.8664186000823975,
-0.032280366867780685,
0.012108227238059044,
0.4620911777019501,
-0.12687401473522186,
-0.019964970648288727,
0.23939897119998932,
0.5608702301979065,
-0.8033342957496643,
0.16817022860050201,
-0.03661163151264191,
-0.14563526213169098,
0.6194458603858948,
0.24732396006584167,
0.1279458999633789,
-0.15576954185962677,
-0.47133663296699524,
-0.1496114581823349,
-0.43864011764526367,
-0.11941543966531754,
0.3403419256210327,
-0.04469196870923042,
-0.42169710993766785,
0.7330663800239563,
0.2212470918893814,
0.5879863500595093,
0.047325391322374344,
-0.16972966492176056,
0.25380954146385193,
-0.5234553217887878,
-0.011756899766623974,
-0.3598051369190216,
0.7206364870071411,
0.37007877230644226,
-0.3027641773223877,
-0.11252087354660034,
-0.12349048256874084,
0.0897238627076149,
0.267760694026947,
-0.7757548093795776,
-0.0919162705540657,
0.279985249042511,
-0.8623887300491333,
-0.2618158161640167,
-0.0767446830868721,
-1.110547423362732,
-0.4762878715991974,
-0.3893255591392517,
0.598665714263916,
-0.27722153067588806,
-0.6665111184120178,
-0.17132645845413208,
-0.1774737685918808,
0.10245215147733688,
0.5633979439735413,
-1.1219874620437622,
-0.1923351138830185,
0.35402435064315796,
0.7126407623291016,
0.1270381063222885,
-0.18822245299816132,
-0.17818959057331085,
0.2757137417793274,
-0.507746696472168,
0.46220818161964417,
-0.5878906846046448,
-0.24022719264030457,
-0.11234871298074722,
-0.009602667763829231,
-0.014078222215175629,
-0.11886543035507202,
-0.1420070081949234,
-0.8016388416290283,
0.3034276068210602,
-0.055013738572597504,
-0.4997226297855377,
-0.41643479466438293,
0.11200790107250214,
-0.9459270238876343,
0.26001596450805664,
0.2018292099237442,
-0.6315944790840149,
0.17874330282211304,
-0.698951005935669,
-0.1301165074110031,
0.0462963804602623,
-0.2360086292028427,
-0.3862939178943634,
0.42383620142936707,
0.31627482175827026,
0.6208257675170898,
-0.32841727137565613,
0.6070477962493896,
-0.44936996698379517,
-0.033472027629613876,
0.7785581946372986,
-1.008067011833191,
0.6088681817054749,
0.33185064792633057,
-0.1773255616426468,
0.16931284964084625,
-0.5026485323905945,
-0.2621135115623474,
0.15433833003044128,
-0.0898396298289299,
0.07881904393434525,
0.11007661372423172,
-0.029918750748038292,
0.18506471812725067,
0.31132155656814575,
-0.0354982390999794,
-0.0962497740983963,
0.09980595111846924,
0.49608659744262695,
0.7892071604728699,
0.11657457053661346,
0.5631123781204224,
-0.1885880082845688,
0.7158425450325012,
0.5370952486991882,
0.17658229172229767,
-0.5743693113327026,
-0.34059685468673706,
-0.18418654799461365,
-0.21779057383537292,
0.30084121227264404,
-0.05182808265089989,
-1.1774240732192993,
0.05844942107796669,
-0.21258123219013214,
-0.3915473520755768,
-0.15258480608463287,
0.02723255753517151,
0.21945126354694366,
0.16777248680591583,
0.22920097410678864,
-0.1444777399301529,
-0.13318593800067902,
-0.9234293699264526,
0.35000789165496826,
-0.1289052963256836,
-0.10618849098682404,
0.13444802165031433,
0.7602949738502502,
-0.2857605218887329,
0.7183741331100464,
-0.4974674880504608,
0.32152020931243896,
-0.00884889904409647,
0.6547980308532715,
-0.04661404713988304,
0.5036985874176025,
0.6129876375198364,
-1.4580758810043335,
-0.05576713755726814,
-0.029322227463126183,
-0.9146862626075745,
0.5817770957946777,
-0.5281941294670105,
-0.03904416784644127,
-0.24124738574028015,
0.5230188965797424,
-0.6344189047813416,
0.3290681540966034,
0.6518429517745972,
-0.2685074806213379,
0.7634513974189758,
-0.32609233260154724,
0.09373031556606293,
-1.2373661994934082,
-0.023153726011514664,
0.02554665319621563,
-0.08215463906526566,
-0.4154732823371887,
0.18831652402877808,
-0.04265540838241577,
-0.38849076628685,
-0.08339603245258331,
0.18922357261180878,
-0.4686710834503174,
-0.05119522288441658,
-0.01751858741044998,
0.08707281202077866,
0.2736372649669647,
0.40684589743614197,
-0.11767672002315521,
0.5879446268081665,
0.6600688695907593,
-0.5452550053596497,
0.7962856888771057,
0.19251133501529694,
-0.23085041344165802,
0.45075416564941406,
-0.7853798866271973,
-0.35067319869995117,
-0.5608872771263123,
0.3398398160934448,
-1.280755877494812,
-0.6091368198394775,
-0.049683358520269394,
-0.5968623757362366,
0.39416950941085815,
-0.23306001722812653,
-0.48694315552711487,
-0.38932299613952637,
-0.05610399693250656,
0.6469905972480774,
0.2458094358444214,
-0.7959511876106262,
0.8951696157455444,
0.019320659339427948,
-0.14560498297214508,
-0.40837761759757996,
-0.559206485748291,
-0.15427185595035553,
-0.4446823000907898,
-0.6992630362510681,
0.6350644826889038,
-0.4289354383945465,
-0.26463717222213745,
0.08992965519428253,
0.09103405475616455,
-0.22976133227348328,
0.30730053782463074,
0.4181836247444153,
0.28274983167648315,
-0.46301576495170593,
0.6759908199310303,
0.12636689841747284,
-0.2677845060825348,
0.2614409625530243,
-0.053131118416786194,
0.45176076889038086,
-0.0029897382482886314,
-0.6211104989051819,
-0.30858179926872253,
0.5603047013282776,
0.8472594618797302,
-0.4160115718841553,
0.9426462054252625,
0.9327166080474854,
-0.30224207043647766,
0.10343412309885025,
0.008655829355120659,
-0.0930597111582756,
-0.40147334337234497,
0.6175558567047119,
-0.49749618768692017,
-0.495920330286026,
0.6753239631652832,
-0.2680879235267639,
-0.20784445106983185,
0.522589921951294,
0.768589198589325,
-0.14736096560955048,
1.5513277053833008,
0.765900194644928,
0.48748061060905457,
0.5688990354537964,
-0.3012809455394745,
0.22317643463611603,
-0.6779251098632812,
-0.5588459968566895,
-0.1058013066649437,
-0.095393106341362,
-0.6010850071907043,
-0.8304378390312195,
0.3944058418273926,
0.2874930799007416,
-0.1021934226155281,
-0.33150023221969604,
-0.16275569796562195,
0.35770830512046814,
0.3385087847709656,
0.24031071364879608,
0.08287741243839264,
0.1252359002828598,
-0.0237665344029665,
0.025131674483418465,
-0.5242424607276917,
-0.5513558387756348,
1.0728063583374023,
0.5563526749610901,
1.0528178215026855,
0.5986760854721069,
0.25147178769111633,
0.030659092590212822,
-0.05963369086384773,
-0.5979201793670654,
0.015291830524802208,
-0.19022338092327118,
-0.6839848756790161,
-0.1549653708934784,
-0.5308696031570435,
-0.9834467172622681,
0.3334817588329315,
-0.6603921055793762,
-0.6527205109596252,
0.20214179158210754,
0.2900713384151459,
-0.571380078792572,
0.15236082673072815,
-0.9542352557182312,
1.013290524482727,
-0.47668302059173584,
-0.4014463722705841,
-0.29190874099731445,
-0.5943472385406494,
0.5092381834983826,
-0.15711569786071777,
0.27200624346733093,
0.3412691354751587,
0.13986609876155853,
0.5858870148658752,
-0.14795637130737305,
0.8926752209663391,
-0.3074162006378174,
-0.25204232335090637,
0.18475067615509033,
-0.16437028348445892,
0.039616234600543976,
0.30241069197654724,
0.02150028571486473,
0.008599805645644665,
-0.13497425615787506,
-0.34626615047454834,
-0.9322380423545837,
0.4930645823478699,
-0.8548173308372498,
-0.4079001843929291,
0.004673430696129799,
-0.6991206407546997,
0.01833331026136875,
-0.0023000603541731834,
0.3531300723552704,
0.7255687713623047,
-0.1986350566148758,
0.29975223541259766,
0.8515779972076416,
-0.4852750897407532,
0.41905900835990906,
-0.020973142236471176,
-0.4040895402431488,
-0.04470401629805565,
0.9785807728767395,
0.02978450432419777,
0.201438307762146,
0.39291858673095703,
0.20574259757995605,
-0.5352233052253723,
-0.44688376784324646,
-0.5365349054336548,
0.09855595231056213,
-0.6547823548316956,
0.053725410252809525,
-0.36208444833755493,
-0.10509011149406433,
-0.1816089153289795,
-0.02241860143840313,
-0.153651162981987,
-0.29231080412864685,
-0.5803266763687134,
-0.040258679538965225,
0.2514176368713379,
0.9830878973007202,
-0.14318515360355377,
0.6622569561004639,
-0.4802002012729645,
0.5750911831855774,
0.6696755886077881,
0.48852449655532837,
0.36087894439697266,
-0.35802942514419556,
-0.310041606426239,
0.4487355947494507,
-0.47610557079315186,
-1.156759262084961,
-0.05448518320918083,
0.028057293966412544,
0.6917916536331177,
0.7747381329536438,
-0.12214458733797073,
0.6218218207359314,
-0.2732238173484802,
0.9621190428733826,
0.624372124671936,
-0.9712958931922913,
0.4337218999862671,
-0.33255118131637573,
0.2550816535949707,
-0.23912569880485535,
0.676906406879425,
-0.11185029149055481,
0.05872758850455284,
-0.6153402328491211,
-0.9330243468284607,
0.4304463267326355,
0.24704930186271667,
0.27891796827316284,
0.18327628076076508,
0.26506951451301575,
0.37519270181655884,
0.14449281990528107,
-0.9331842660903931,
-0.09239375591278076,
-0.49811241030693054,
-0.3041805028915405,
-0.5056294798851013,
-0.4260568916797638,
-0.39811381697654724,
0.11410935968160629,
0.3339288830757141,
-0.1994158923625946,
0.7101956605911255,
-0.23578855395317078,
-0.34430113434791565,
-0.06501440703868866,
0.103744275867939,
0.7306215167045593,
0.9433341026306152,
0.11347170919179916,
0.6004051566123962,
-0.4006463587284088,
-0.12532120943069458,
0.07446891069412231,
0.3191984295845032,
0.2796896994113922,
0.014952410012483597,
0.8130987286567688,
1.0005911588668823,
-0.3293742537498474,
-0.3399474322795868,
0.6073453426361084,
-0.25856858491897583,
-0.18467159569263458,
-0.44304952025413513,
-0.12778052687644958,
0.36370816826820374,
0.5986078381538391,
0.3850822150707245,
-0.0034960878547281027,
-0.14837928116321564,
-0.5334931015968323,
0.029034335166215897,
0.3622383773326874,
-0.17256692051887512,
-0.5175625681877136,
0.7782014608383179,
-0.03146114945411682,
0.1406014859676361,
0.464893639087677,
-0.15565037727355957,
-0.4452519416809082,
0.8251466751098633,
0.5083371996879578,
0.22490845620632172,
-0.29993200302124023,
0.6345634460449219,
0.2781711220741272,
0.12416472285985947,
0.1251680701971054,
-0.010338821448385715,
-0.20162631571292877,
-0.6725984811782837,
-0.7252002954483032,
-0.37166640162467957,
-0.07180532068014145,
0.32191044092178345,
-0.8677375316619873,
-0.247225821018219,
-0.22599312663078308,
-0.2393704652786255,
0.7493306398391724,
-0.4646807312965393,
-0.6652660965919495,
0.2811032235622406,
0.2653105854988098,
0.14714589715003967,
-1.1872793436050415,
0.2010038048028946,
0.7170118093490601,
-0.8834757804870605,
-0.6362404823303223,
0.1434737592935562,
-0.014659118838608265,
-0.7644705772399902,
0.792793869972229,
0.025872135534882545,
0.08116807043552399,
-0.3082639276981354,
-0.7824737429618835,
-0.8472796678543091,
0.9952634572982788,
0.41699084639549255,
-0.521251380443573,
0.11793676763772964,
-0.014860500581562519,
0.5794829726219177,
-0.3434540927410126,
0.48482224345207214,
-0.07871517539024353,
0.4551544189453125,
0.18126040697097778,
-0.29414305090904236,
-0.048863962292671204,
-0.21597923338413239,
0.40579915046691895,
-0.027040833607316017,
-0.28860560059547424,
1.2107406854629517,
-0.3800583779811859,
-0.14196300506591797,
-0.10184825956821442,
0.6504717469215393,
-0.18314306437969208,
0.2763318419456482,
0.47136256098747253,
0.16119125485420227,
0.6337255835533142,
-0.19274085760116577,
0.9773383140563965,
0.022754404693841934,
0.428974986076355,
1.0238063335418701,
0.13861222565174103,
0.4599839448928833,
0.5707052946090698,
-0.1158946305513382,
0.6444985270500183,
0.78753662109375,
-0.11573802679777145,
0.37006810307502747,
0.1865725815296173,
-0.3190476894378662,
-0.4712885320186615,
-0.0243199672549963,
-0.4656464457511902,
0.7902334332466125,
0.5681007504463196,
-0.5866462588310242,
-0.33718037605285645,
0.5651012063026428,
-0.4644412100315094,
-0.001328146900050342,
-0.22880254685878754,
0.7432447075843811,
-0.17556604743003845,
-0.5410110354423523,
0.3887960910797119,
-0.018388500437140465,
0.1420464962720871,
-0.361497163772583,
-0.33980876207351685,
-0.027681952342391014,
0.18727020919322968,
-0.21914659440517426,
-0.9131433963775635,
0.21945711970329285,
-0.18109427392482758,
-0.6374310851097107,
-0.19423571228981018,
0.22141112387180328,
-0.6308773756027222,
-0.5193359851837158,
0.24022674560546875,
0.5330516695976257,
0.2124219685792923,
0.01453445851802826,
-0.6642741560935974,
0.08937946707010269,
-0.1552707999944687,
-0.19118674099445343,
0.11208578944206238,
0.7769441604614258,
-0.23377585411071777,
0.6022714376449585,
0.48061880469322205,
-0.3257107734680176,
0.012149571441113949,
0.13118861615657806,
0.8310137987136841,
-0.3673817217350006,
-0.2964257299900055,
-0.8201634883880615,
0.7607382535934448,
0.10677465051412582,
0.07617078721523285,
0.41214555501937866,
0.2159312665462494,
0.4473135769367218,
-0.24583490192890167,
0.6684986352920532,
-0.23398590087890625,
-0.02572072483599186,
-0.7317605018615723,
0.5001049637794495,
-0.9488670229911804,
0.06796019524335861,
-0.08992676436901093,
-0.8598502278327942,
-0.1148376539349556,
0.8515849709510803,
-0.2009286880493164,
0.4228461980819702,
0.701857328414917,
0.6305059790611267,
-0.22116850316524506,
0.08044334501028061,
0.4570087492465973,
0.5537806153297424,
0.3458269238471985,
0.5012950301170349,
1.0309776067733765,
-0.1935926228761673,
0.47094079852104187,
-0.1748553216457367,
-0.4254065752029419,
-0.18837231397628784,
-0.9268409013748169,
-0.6648246645927429,
-1.0564978122711182,
-0.44019246101379395,
-0.15188898146152496,
-0.33201301097869873,
0.23518972098827362,
0.8508694171905518,
-0.3960302174091339,
0.19324122369289398,
0.13998845219612122,
0.42066019773483276,
-0.26810362935066223,
-0.23791687190532684,
0.37423139810562134,
-0.017291156575083733,
-0.6435384154319763,
0.06506586074829102,
0.05519072711467743,
0.43612194061279297,
-0.5154435634613037,
-0.008699077181518078,
-0.07632718235254288,
-0.19884711503982544,
0.8512656092643738,
-0.23600293695926666,
-0.6379942297935486,
-0.09481799602508545,
-0.2863180935382843,
0.11747200787067413,
-0.1583079993724823,
0.6877990365028381,
-0.27605298161506653,
0.8239378333091736,
0.26802268624305725,
0.39054059982299805,
0.6965528130531311,
-0.03265707567334175,
0.758638858795166,
-0.7592809200286865,
0.017895037308335304,
0.027119508013129234,
0.4147443175315857,
0.33793362975120544,
-0.3579983711242676,
0.09805905818939209,
-0.026363519951701164,
-0.26696568727493286,
-0.5730285048484802,
0.5858326554298401,
-0.8921754360198975,
-0.5394777655601501,
0.786477267742157,
-0.4344298243522644,
-0.18155109882354736,
-0.0231939647346735,
0.17768444120883942,
0.5338113307952881,
-0.03069140389561653,
0.7182410359382629,
0.7787935733795166,
-0.033285222947597504,
-0.377370148897171,
-0.4904034733772278,
0.02184806764125824,
0.3006508946418762,
-0.8930711150169373,
0.1713680773973465,
0.7269601821899414,
0.05208253115415573,
0.5485808849334717,
0.18142303824424744,
-0.3054376542568207,
0.3029826879501343,
0.4505835771560669,
-0.08128038793802261,
0.02392970770597458,
-0.48696020245552063,
-0.4768332839012146,
0.243362694978714,
0.09490928053855896,
-0.2884037494659424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01841v1 | COMET: Generating Commit Messages using Delta Graph Context Representation | 2024-02-02T19:01:52 | 2024-02-02T19:01:52 | Abhinav Reddy Mandli, Saurabhsingh Rajput, Tushar Sharma | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Commit messages explain code changes in a commit and facilitate collaboration
among developers. Several commit message generation approaches have been
proposed; however, they exhibit limited success in capturing the context of
code changes. We propose Comet (Context-Aware Commit Message Generation), a
novel approach that captures context of code changes using a graph-based
representation and leverages a transformer-based model to generate high-quality
commit messages. Our proposed method utilizes delta graph that we developed to
effectively represent code differences. We also introduce a customizable
quality assurance module to identify optimal messages, mitigating subjectivity
in commit messages. Experiments show that Comet outperforms state-of-the-art
techniques in terms of bleu-norm and meteor metrics while being comparable in
terms of rogue-l. Additionally, we compare the proposed approach with the
popular gpt-3.5-turbo model, along with gpt-4-turbo; the most capable GPT
model, over zero-shot, one-shot, and multi-shot settings. We found Comet
outperforming the GPT models, on five and four metrics respectively and provide
competitive results with the two other metrics. The study has implications for
researchers, tool developers, and software developers. Software developers may
utilize Comet to generate context-aware commit messages. Researchers and tool
developers can apply the proposed delta graph technique in similar contexts,
like code review summarization. | [
-0.29251551628112793,
-0.45604705810546875,
0.39374977350234985,
0.12278785556554794,
-0.3587896525859833,
0.07202908396720886,
-0.0546141192317009,
-0.22573399543762207,
0.6677098870277405,
0.41641515493392944,
-0.8111729621887207,
-0.5393538475036621,
-0.39696547389030457,
-0.04471063241362572,
-0.5965896248817444,
1.2747235298156738,
0.04199874773621559,
-0.08861633390188217,
0.03877582773566246,
0.08507834374904633,
-1.0556901693344116,
-0.42104995250701904,
-0.25843149423599243,
0.0006126372027210891,
0.4504925608634949,
0.3993428945541382,
0.607251763343811,
0.5914382338523865,
0.7478461265563965,
0.1508835107088089,
0.07783948630094528,
-0.1821770966053009,
-0.5464946031570435,
0.3153427243232727,
-0.270953506231308,
-0.2577461302280426,
-0.4230597913265228,
-0.2702655494213104,
0.737017035484314,
0.5232845544815063,
0.12182476371526718,
0.1934894174337387,
-0.0054968879558146,
0.7982481718063354,
-0.8922713398933411,
0.15130306780338287,
-0.6031370759010315,
-0.19053693115711212,
-0.24924299120903015,
-0.12190766632556915,
-0.5591414570808411,
-0.2847414016723633,
-0.47117432951927185,
-0.42721477150917053,
0.0715256854891777,
-0.29364651441574097,
0.7805326581001282,
0.1806681603193283,
-0.5988172888755798,
-0.4359517991542816,
-0.8880795240402222,
0.41552165150642395,
-0.6051087975502014,
0.3642622232437134,
-0.12846249341964722,
0.6521092057228088,
-0.33996307849884033,
-0.8657616376876831,
-0.28057199716567993,
-0.030743081122636795,
-0.07043793052434921,
0.45328283309936523,
-0.040705349296331406,
-0.4709354639053345,
-0.2462020069360733,
0.337639182806015,
-0.4198971688747406,
0.01108572818338871,
0.003047059290111065,
-0.6647771000862122,
0.4734379053115845,
0.43934956192970276,
-0.04653280973434448,
-0.4006922245025635,
-0.11152614653110504,
-0.18525542318820953,
-0.8141428828239441,
0.13779211044311523,
0.14266148209571838,
0.4469435513019562,
0.001686455449089408,
0.39036521315574646,
-0.12822923064231873,
0.46490198373794556,
0.26212960481643677,
0.278664767742157,
-0.23791812360286713,
-0.645999550819397,
0.03805426135659218,
-0.14378200471401215,
0.6941629648208618,
0.4591054916381836,
-0.41163167357444763,
-0.14333127439022064,
-0.2055625319480896,
0.12076830863952637,
0.34373170137405396,
-1.0322158336639404,
-0.1197841614484787,
0.4596392810344696,
-0.35942190885543823,
-0.23360151052474976,
0.3991793096065521,
-0.636722981929779,
-0.40711307525634766,
0.010959157720208168,
-0.10240121185779572,
-0.6233129501342773,
-0.4019501507282257,
-0.30050113797187805,
-0.23841699957847595,
-0.024907149374485016,
0.5855626463890076,
-0.7221799492835999,
-0.0767897441983223,
0.8100392818450928,
0.7400722503662109,
0.16411368548870087,
-0.25826019048690796,
-0.7891989350318909,
0.2949538230895996,
-0.5579842925071716,
0.5683530569076538,
-0.24288307130336761,
-0.41643190383911133,
0.2202031910419464,
-0.23387207090854645,
0.3839931786060333,
-0.12234308570623398,
-0.10356689244508743,
-0.674669086933136,
0.016283709555864334,
-0.3128931522369385,
-0.862632155418396,
-0.10283169895410538,
0.12481136620044708,
-0.6162426471710205,
0.6683617234230042,
0.771137535572052,
-0.569015622138977,
0.6350603103637695,
-0.49263548851013184,
-0.2527161240577698,
0.5725501775741577,
-0.19818145036697388,
-0.4470623731613159,
-0.003766748821362853,
-0.07857584953308105,
0.4878336489200592,
-0.1599787175655365,
0.20477309823036194,
0.13002431392669678,
-0.26833462715148926,
0.37675607204437256,
0.2856837511062622,
0.500175952911377,
0.230502650141716,
-0.6205064654350281,
0.33919379115104675,
-0.18979637324810028,
0.11843565851449966,
-0.07319389283657074,
-0.27301329374313354,
0.04674532637000084,
0.09178447723388672,
0.11932103335857391,
-0.0038417065516114235,
0.26565366983413696,
-0.4152497947216034,
0.25935083627700806,
0.09572552889585495,
0.300140380859375,
0.4583616256713867,
0.370023250579834,
0.5782598257064819,
-0.1638616919517517,
0.26061126589775085,
0.08448376506567001,
0.2795173227787018,
-0.5998409986495972,
-0.3777468502521515,
-0.4045184552669525,
-0.013843797147274017,
0.46230947971343994,
0.27524828910827637,
-0.5260275602340698,
0.48761463165283203,
-0.5375031232833862,
-0.6568049788475037,
-0.033730316907167435,
0.005768505856394768,
0.4930819571018219,
0.3834714889526367,
0.3055119216442108,
-0.7038364410400391,
-0.16206148266792297,
-0.6973196268081665,
-0.35534873604774475,
-0.3313833773136139,
0.0414745919406414,
0.35043564438819885,
0.651156485080719,
-0.42570677399635315,
1.3406782150268555,
-0.56158047914505,
-0.23724167048931122,
-0.15595252811908722,
0.14091670513153076,
-0.0009119208552874625,
0.6027575731277466,
0.8064356446266174,
-0.8671585321426392,
-0.42495039105415344,
0.06709152460098267,
-0.503765344619751,
0.27797597646713257,
-0.4652276635169983,
-0.21048353612422943,
0.3583851754665375,
0.23699961602687836,
-0.28061142563819885,
0.37865906953811646,
0.5052207112312317,
-0.5846801996231079,
0.6972302198410034,
0.0845814049243927,
0.48755431175231934,
-1.169608473777771,
0.026871109381318092,
-0.020587705075740814,
-0.6038719415664673,
-0.5932998657226562,
0.3936498761177063,
0.6849325299263,
-0.2503409683704376,
-0.7188732028007507,
0.17668072879314423,
-0.44340839982032776,
-0.183343768119812,
-0.21747350692749023,
0.25586560368537903,
-0.23243561387062073,
0.1720103770494461,
-0.04410763829946518,
0.6492822170257568,
0.45810699462890625,
-0.7600304484367371,
0.18807245790958405,
0.31365966796875,
-0.16279233992099762,
0.7013089656829834,
-0.37157800793647766,
0.22619585692882538,
0.05882028490304947,
0.7364401817321777,
-0.6206888556480408,
-0.5990928411483765,
0.11832674592733383,
-0.7365802526473999,
0.26326367259025574,
-0.45782896876335144,
-0.4744514524936676,
-0.43877115845680237,
-0.1486082524061203,
0.026005912572145462,
0.7026618123054504,
-0.2401035577058792,
0.3326497972011566,
0.2965638041496277,
0.1425171047449112,
-0.29037073254585266,
-0.7324395179748535,
0.3441978394985199,
-0.03416106849908829,
-0.8993850946426392,
0.37693360447883606,
-0.006248630117624998,
0.0379575677216053,
-0.07954586297273636,
-0.21478652954101562,
-0.09381790459156036,
-0.0016252612695097923,
0.32300251722335815,
0.11027886718511581,
-0.11751655489206314,
-0.0915108248591423,
0.14418934285640717,
-0.19717784225940704,
-0.010425298474729061,
-0.6060447096824646,
0.42311280965805054,
-0.282600075006485,
-0.3283903896808624,
-0.41446489095687866,
0.5189858078956604,
0.6164435744285583,
-0.06160479784011841,
0.7393596172332764,
0.5536441802978516,
-0.2456110566854477,
-0.16413480043411255,
-0.3635682165622711,
-0.702948272228241,
-0.4404580295085907,
0.2939908504486084,
-0.1485302746295929,
-0.9341845512390137,
0.8521896600723267,
-0.5400891900062561,
0.18855468928813934,
0.26874759793281555,
0.7025428414344788,
-0.06207907944917679,
0.6016746163368225,
0.6361414790153503,
-0.024285385385155678,
0.720923125743866,
-0.40313175320625305,
-0.0991990715265274,
-0.8750370144844055,
0.016705268993973732,
-0.4486141502857208,
-0.04310977831482887,
-0.2891073524951935,
-0.1831761747598648,
0.3281683921813965,
0.4989139437675476,
-0.3395173251628876,
0.9537320137023926,
-0.8425801992416382,
0.2815362513065338,
0.47749781608581543,
-0.11576490104198456,
-0.0390421561896801,
-0.515043318271637,
0.19285784661769867,
0.0028731850907206535,
-0.6338688135147095,
-0.522963285446167,
0.9638966917991638,
0.051783639937639236,
0.3486964702606201,
0.3171764612197876,
1.0421360731124878,
0.36273428797721863,
0.5385544300079346,
-0.44748514890670776,
0.43237677216529846,
0.34051018953323364,
-0.6798272728919983,
-0.3359021544456482,
-0.7422255277633667,
-0.9631389379501343,
-0.00029820125200785697,
0.03521553799510002,
-0.7450490593910217,
-0.13825610280036926,
0.2893325090408325,
0.030039144679903984,
0.16939158737659454,
-0.6287066340446472,
0.9070270657539368,
0.38621798157691956,
-0.09850729256868362,
-0.09831360727548599,
-0.7090100646018982,
0.26572999358177185,
-0.25969237089157104,
0.4464399814605713,
0.0521625392138958,
0.07397211343050003,
0.42497748136520386,
-0.7806279063224792,
0.7754154205322266,
-0.40233197808265686,
-0.11589334905147552,
0.6895325183868408,
0.8536486625671387,
0.9347847700119019,
0.47194355726242065,
-0.018086707219481468,
0.03452983871102333,
-0.1826271116733551,
-0.2500843405723572,
-0.413743257522583,
0.7341821193695068,
-0.4972896873950958,
-0.4780997633934021,
-0.0748734176158905,
-0.6470584869384766,
0.2780584692955017,
0.5215998291969299,
0.5388612151145935,
0.6144464015960693,
-0.22894854843616486,
0.1340925395488739,
-0.06066036969423294,
0.0924183577299118,
0.8038678765296936,
0.5853485465049744,
-0.17960143089294434,
-0.528085470199585,
0.781096339225769,
0.09231211245059967,
0.42000070214271545,
0.17480015754699707,
0.020342808216810226,
0.09851828962564468,
-0.6889200806617737,
-0.6698441505432129,
-0.033904626965522766,
-0.9107540845870972,
-0.6350319385528564,
-0.2215694934129715,
0.12552057206630707,
-0.6262274384498596,
-0.6805845499038696,
-0.6630632281303406,
-0.510920524597168,
-0.057476285845041275,
0.43066585063934326,
0.4047485291957855,
0.8506149053573608,
-0.0538032092154026,
0.3890707492828369,
-1.15694260597229,
-0.12134908139705658,
-0.0004955657059326768,
0.2540213167667389,
-0.3080176115036011,
-0.13610190153121948,
-0.6129655838012695,
0.32383233308792114,
-0.5464006066322327,
-1.2320069074630737,
0.43366026878356934,
-0.15127457678318024,
0.20993460714817047,
-0.15320737659931183,
0.22191156446933746,
0.31604820489883423,
-0.3875717520713806,
1.2466967105865479,
0.3681112229824066,
-1.4421095848083496,
1.0681114196777344,
-0.7535703778266907,
0.41253575682640076,
0.5848771333694458,
0.012944797053933144,
-0.8742290139198303,
-1.059710144996643,
-0.6046741604804993,
-0.7222462892532349,
0.5677487254142761,
0.737496018409729,
0.1308327317237854,
-0.23099568486213684,
0.7399370670318604,
0.07688143849372864,
0.051381129771471024,
-0.6787030696868896,
-0.36264508962631226,
-0.679289698600769,
0.18570305407047272,
0.17588333785533905,
0.2037145346403122,
-0.10026928037405014,
0.21865056455135345,
0.46710845828056335,
-0.4539467394351959,
0.4199722111225128,
0.2626625597476959,
-0.21425262093544006,
-0.2696370482444763,
0.1520383507013321,
0.6626441478729248,
0.6869550347328186,
-0.20985513925552368,
-0.19721555709838867,
-0.018912315368652344,
-0.7400152087211609,
-0.016131596639752388,
-0.30280882120132446,
-0.2723659574985504,
0.12456077337265015,
0.425357848405838,
0.30505847930908203,
-0.1080569475889206,
-0.07281983643770218,
0.7139405608177185,
-0.11682380735874176,
-0.17643949389457703,
-0.24055923521518707,
0.13096283376216888,
0.30977365374565125,
-0.045186709612607956,
0.4339713156223297,
0.24526365101337433,
0.14416590332984924,
-0.5593201518058777,
0.32173392176628113,
0.25150346755981445,
-0.6764671206474304,
-0.37110769748687744,
0.7664799690246582,
0.452163428068161,
-0.36617255210876465,
0.7250286936759949,
-0.4620742201805115,
-0.4078189730644226,
0.9710174798965454,
0.593330442905426,
0.7731106281280518,
-0.20267584919929504,
0.3496628701686859,
0.4047594368457794,
0.1638985425233841,
0.21334078907966614,
0.02608584426343441,
0.056727051734924316,
-0.5589247345924377,
-0.5363247990608215,
-0.06879952549934387,
-0.7736149430274963,
-0.3465494215488434,
-0.7093547582626343,
0.46190378069877625,
-0.3321831226348877,
-0.3021097183227539,
-0.03442443907260895,
-0.13188090920448303,
-0.4342973232269287,
0.05467504635453224,
-0.108291395008564,
0.7549622654914856,
-0.5523465275764465,
0.7217166423797607,
0.7120867967605591,
-0.6766018271446228,
-0.8277572393417358,
0.061451658606529236,
0.3170187771320343,
-0.15670426189899445,
0.5541674494743347,
0.3089843690395355,
-0.0259641595184803,
0.0361197292804718,
-0.3621005117893219,
-0.7689583897590637,
1.4073927402496338,
0.32056549191474915,
-0.6450629830360413,
0.5057621002197266,
-0.013486855663359165,
0.2614493668079376,
-0.6151497960090637,
0.2902262806892395,
0.2006087601184845,
0.45288681983947754,
0.10036575049161911,
-0.7391597628593445,
0.36432817578315735,
-0.14590756595134735,
0.022772952914237976,
0.7201096415519714,
-0.6660078167915344,
0.7238519787788391,
-0.11984242498874664,
-0.5798625349998474,
-0.14919298887252808,
0.7622332572937012,
0.354518324136734,
0.1669224351644516,
0.21305245161056519,
-0.05590256303548813,
0.6887326836585999,
-0.22478428483009338,
1.5086143016815186,
-0.72795170545578,
0.6276555061340332,
0.9064884185791016,
-0.3254840672016144,
0.4624161720275879,
0.3588458299636841,
0.2735368311405182,
0.9591225385665894,
0.683554470539093,
0.19775044918060303,
0.44302138686180115,
0.20771370828151703,
-0.05005386471748352,
-0.09645587205886841,
0.07915850728750229,
-0.4546530246734619,
0.04854125902056694,
0.31280532479286194,
0.016352759674191475,
-0.1228322759270668,
-0.09360504150390625,
0.22837790846824646,
0.11794527620077133,
-0.29000532627105713,
0.8761513233184814,
-0.07553107291460037,
-0.755202054977417,
0.5424142479896545,
0.017185427248477936,
0.3979257345199585,
-0.48425063490867615,
0.0963083803653717,
-0.3532331585884094,
0.25879862904548645,
-0.2359544336795807,
-0.8798871040344238,
0.6092126369476318,
-0.05360348895192146,
-0.1903005987405777,
-0.23185183107852936,
0.5515892505645752,
-0.09491868317127228,
-0.13242685794830322,
0.23579277098178864,
0.20664070546627045,
0.16818051040172577,
-0.17985771596431732,
-0.44957152009010315,
0.17990508675575256,
-0.022363586351275444,
-0.2994419038295746,
0.18247567117214203,
0.4196344316005707,
-0.09859241545200348,
0.4615960717201233,
0.48361536860466003,
-0.07037340104579926,
-0.17015255987644196,
0.19200417399406433,
1.0879490375518799,
-0.7721958756446838,
-0.758971631526947,
-0.674028754234314,
0.9312814474105835,
-0.21946652233600616,
-0.34899038076400757,
0.8465422987937927,
0.6975980401039124,
0.44920796155929565,
-0.12684835493564606,
0.6775472164154053,
-0.24640417098999023,
0.1073274239897728,
-0.34026679396629333,
0.654890239238739,
-0.09071742743253708,
0.19902510941028595,
-0.4701773524284363,
-1.339839220046997,
-0.5166759490966797,
0.12009406834840775,
0.09245706349611282,
0.0006148457759991288,
1.127517580986023,
0.6825422644615173,
0.11986727267503738,
0.11975301057100296,
0.016591772437095642,
-0.22064702212810516,
0.8306881785392761,
0.666266679763794,
0.6839770078659058,
-0.6166024208068848,
0.6738417148590088,
-0.10121559351682663,
-0.40782541036605835,
-0.3200911283493042,
-1.1322641372680664,
-0.7725538611412048,
-0.8432288765907288,
-0.6238784790039062,
-0.6759111881256104,
-0.21030491590499878,
0.28464409708976746,
0.9945755004882812,
-0.5638946890830994,
-0.06509876251220703,
-0.7002382874488831,
0.0645257979631424,
-0.3961430490016937,
-0.26594987511634827,
0.20335206389427185,
-0.6221877932548523,
-0.31628653407096863,
0.3896467983722687,
0.24857653677463531,
0.10967101901769638,
-0.25647273659706116,
-0.3135923743247986,
0.4342190623283386,
0.034182846546173096,
0.2330133318901062,
0.07891010493040085,
-0.37992918491363525,
-0.6604196429252625,
0.0009476642007939517,
-0.4033076763153076,
-0.006563290022313595,
1.1720302104949951,
-0.6305344700813293,
0.07329386472702026,
0.4202457070350647,
0.29209503531455994,
0.8220380544662476,
-0.2446487993001938,
0.7615945339202881,
-0.9072813987731934,
-0.06145889312028885,
0.3493116796016693,
0.3793407380580902,
0.3621792495250702,
-0.8703210353851318,
0.5573549866676331,
-0.01593106985092163,
-0.7730793952941895,
-0.5987162590026855,
0.6342103481292725,
-0.8100809454917908,
-0.5616313815116882,
1.0608532428741455,
-0.16434022784233093,
-0.2888396382331848,
-0.13854923844337463,
-0.10525428503751755,
0.25860416889190674,
-0.6267852783203125,
0.49203383922576904,
0.4805929660797119,
-0.03444922715425491,
0.1485622078180313,
-0.11421439796686172,
0.4345284104347229,
0.2806894779205322,
-0.9725664258003235,
0.3720114529132843,
0.7925200462341309,
0.16827072203159332,
0.6525964140892029,
0.6549903154373169,
-0.31770405173301697,
0.7038387656211853,
0.36018380522727966,
0.3386977016925812,
-0.201629176735878,
-0.29123082756996155,
-0.09177496284246445,
0.28089192509651184,
-0.16732563078403473,
0.12519660592079163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01830v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01830v2 | PiCO: Peer Review in LLMs based on the Consistency Optimization | 2024-02-02T18:49:26 | 2024-04-20T09:09:38 | Kun-Peng Ning, Shuo Yang, Yu-Yang Liu, Jia-Yu Yao, Zhen-Hui Liu, Yu Wang, Ming Pang, Li Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Existing large language models (LLMs) evaluation methods typically focus on
testing the performance on some closed-environment and domain-specific
benchmarks with human annotations. In this paper, we explore a novel
unsupervised evaluation direction, utilizing peer-review mechanisms to measure
LLMs automatically. In this setting, both open-source and closed-source LLMs
lie in the same environment, capable of answering unlabeled questions and
evaluating each other, where each LLM's response score is jointly determined by
other anonymous ones. To obtain the ability hierarchy among these models, we
assign each LLM a learnable capability parameter to adjust the final ranking.
We formalize it as a constrained optimization problem, intending to maximize
the consistency of each LLM's capabilities and scores. The key assumption
behind is that high-level LLM can evaluate others' answers more accurately than
low-level ones, while higher-level LLM can also achieve higher response scores.
Moreover, we propose three metrics called PEN, CIN, and LIS to evaluate the gap
in aligning human rankings. We perform experiments on multiple datasets with
these metrics, validating the effectiveness of the proposed approach. | [
-0.35687923431396484,
-0.44154638051986694,
0.7244245409965515,
0.3655165135860443,
-0.24447308480739594,
0.30568838119506836,
-0.8112015128135681,
-0.2361612468957901,
0.06823337823152542,
0.26242396235466003,
-0.21545535326004028,
-0.6311348676681519,
-0.6768064498901367,
0.23424550890922546,
-0.06669221818447113,
0.8417423963546753,
-0.12731397151947021,
0.2420339435338974,
-0.5925763845443726,
-0.12490564584732056,
-0.10802201926708221,
-0.07905638217926025,
-0.240372434258461,
-0.3967435956001282,
0.20513467490673065,
0.5515601634979248,
0.7458786368370056,
0.6184659004211426,
0.635638952255249,
0.3377898633480072,
-0.07495781779289246,
0.1617787927389145,
-0.5254049897193909,
0.094147227704525,
-0.32126694917678833,
-0.2616386115550995,
-0.5019297003746033,
0.16703006625175476,
1.016996145248413,
0.8815726041793823,
-0.17664994299411774,
0.2541969120502472,
0.5385528206825256,
0.6857439279556274,
-0.7862178683280945,
0.10504916310310364,
-0.7302911877632141,
0.0010607162257656455,
0.12655425071716309,
0.05101586505770683,
-0.2671526372432709,
-0.5214070677757263,
0.10082130879163742,
-0.5016948580741882,
0.09952862560749054,
0.06876526027917862,
0.7683098912239075,
0.10126859694719315,
0.0530005618929863,
0.061465874314308167,
-0.628538966178894,
0.7943593263626099,
-0.534464418888092,
0.5186135172843933,
0.17545761168003082,
0.11269243061542511,
-0.18883074820041656,
-0.3412739932537079,
-0.47081199288368225,
-0.39808201789855957,
0.24274350702762604,
0.30204978585243225,
-0.01797349750995636,
0.052342139184474945,
-0.20932447910308838,
0.5070000886917114,
-0.3771103322505951,
0.41149869561195374,
-0.12354914098978043,
-0.3791356384754181,
0.7002560496330261,
0.055696871131658554,
0.014993465505540371,
-0.09785236418247223,
-0.4227786660194397,
0.09270971268415451,
-0.6826377511024475,
0.2913772463798523,
0.3974077105522156,
0.20159903168678284,
0.13530030846595764,
0.948567271232605,
-0.37910184264183044,
0.5428837537765503,
-0.04737745597958565,
-0.1516903042793274,
0.145681694149971,
-0.43279755115509033,
0.012575918808579445,
-0.25732651352882385,
1.1863384246826172,
0.44995400309562683,
0.12085393071174622,
-0.456475168466568,
-0.5553971529006958,
-0.05632614344358444,
0.15084028244018555,
-0.616784930229187,
-0.04272420331835747,
0.21976663172245026,
-0.41423773765563965,
-0.3354392647743225,
0.26440244913101196,
-0.7274925708770752,
-0.40380236506462097,
-0.22850556671619415,
0.5737930536270142,
-0.01360146515071392,
-0.06900535523891449,
0.1457281857728958,
0.20336145162582397,
0.00955177191644907,
0.3408218026161194,
-0.6569470763206482,
0.5605514645576477,
0.9063423871994019,
0.8654593825340271,
-0.5667698979377747,
-0.47873637080192566,
-0.615649402141571,
0.028381170704960823,
-0.39076074957847595,
0.6785904169082642,
-0.4674832224845886,
-0.24994038045406342,
-0.21953454613685608,
-0.04028671607375145,
0.0017988109029829502,
-0.4690704643726349,
0.5915261507034302,
-0.44045114517211914,
0.2845725417137146,
-0.13172325491905212,
-0.7589163184165955,
0.26065242290496826,
0.3781580328941345,
-0.3580816090106964,
0.979069173336029,
0.10986895114183426,
-0.8537380695343018,
0.3761349618434906,
-0.5537929534912109,
0.04991971701383591,
0.2407793551683426,
-0.10077691823244095,
-0.5784263014793396,
0.1205853596329689,
0.2577805519104004,
0.4184994399547577,
-0.5691841244697571,
0.3659304678440094,
-0.38321152329444885,
-0.6465122699737549,
0.1628555804491043,
-0.10885002464056015,
0.6345155239105225,
0.10920263826847076,
-0.42795413732528687,
0.48809778690338135,
-0.41027921438217163,
0.3258509635925293,
0.018293200060725212,
-0.668337881565094,
-0.21459020674228668,
0.1505245566368103,
-0.3596131205558777,
-0.2634333372116089,
0.5352135300636292,
-1.0272003412246704,
0.18637721240520477,
-0.4020899534225464,
0.46211951971054077,
0.9143436551094055,
-0.026752173900604248,
0.48575109243392944,
-0.31439289450645447,
0.463073194026947,
-0.364327073097229,
0.5795859694480896,
0.3048480749130249,
-0.4659719467163086,
-0.7759096026420593,
-0.26139670610427856,
0.423763245344162,
0.4316929876804352,
-0.32268863916397095,
0.940803587436676,
-0.34214186668395996,
-0.6313648223876953,
-0.7866802215576172,
0.5717890858650208,
0.5555865168571472,
0.3629392087459564,
0.06900909543037415,
-0.4980739951133728,
-0.1331281065940857,
-0.8632755279541016,
-0.1752476692199707,
-0.46398529410362244,
-0.20303040742874146,
0.4823496341705322,
0.19932684302330017,
-0.2446995973587036,
0.8012696504592896,
-0.32513582706451416,
-0.33534371852874756,
-0.17997370660305023,
-0.14014576375484467,
0.2882506549358368,
0.33893463015556335,
0.02387484349310398,
-0.35535043478012085,
-0.3486140966415405,
-0.05472119152545929,
-0.48260727524757385,
-0.4376612901687622,
0.2838083505630493,
-0.036671821027994156,
0.07344935834407806,
0.4471141993999481,
-0.2014085352420807,
-0.022378072142601013,
0.6739054918289185,
-0.013119224458932877,
0.6106140613555908,
-0.3608746826648712,
0.20179568231105804,
-0.73992919921875,
-0.04470706731081009,
-0.0452825166285038,
-0.12980151176452637,
0.03620181605219841,
0.2888709604740143,
0.1725025624036789,
-0.12257538735866547,
-0.1688762903213501,
0.44402027130126953,
-0.6275878548622131,
-0.4571760892868042,
-0.10049090534448624,
0.626192033290863,
0.07293684035539627,
0.3808755576610565,
-0.022968480363488197,
0.7373729944229126,
0.7931668162345886,
-0.2634289860725403,
0.5391376614570618,
-0.006887082010507584,
-0.6423560976982117,
0.364154189825058,
-0.9424592852592468,
0.3330492079257965,
-0.06570623815059662,
-0.06369680166244507,
-1.2424243688583374,
0.027411052957177162,
0.04056188464164734,
-0.32652467489242554,
-0.06379714608192444,
-0.17150841653347015,
-0.7389562129974365,
-0.2586570084095001,
-0.6131458878517151,
0.32984116673469543,
0.43577128648757935,
-0.4517596960067749,
0.22908635437488556,
0.5425906181335449,
-0.1445268988609314,
-0.5418121218681335,
-0.02092394046485424,
0.036199674010276794,
0.09115836024284363,
-0.5923989415168762,
0.33128756284713745,
-0.3061091899871826,
-0.1906304657459259,
-0.038172394037246704,
-0.0736062228679657,
0.24364571273326874,
-0.015564731322228909,
0.27617815136909485,
0.35751840472221375,
-0.09301406145095825,
-0.023989921435713768,
0.01979125291109085,
0.12414634227752686,
0.011580124497413635,
-0.28915175795555115,
0.3344542980194092,
-0.5511460304260254,
-0.5416868925094604,
-0.4306972622871399,
0.027367793023586273,
0.5208874344825745,
-0.3712834417819977,
0.41228312253952026,
0.28134316205978394,
-0.10796200484037399,
-0.21259944140911102,
-0.7160322666168213,
-0.1545325368642807,
-0.48035570979118347,
0.17220845818519592,
-0.3313784599304199,
-1.1073719263076782,
0.470152348279953,
-0.1701119989156723,
0.1265593022108078,
0.18301978707313538,
0.614800751209259,
-0.04573814570903778,
0.913353443145752,
0.669608473777771,
-0.06391885876655579,
0.15546903014183044,
-0.0777667686343193,
-0.04885966330766678,
-1.0932217836380005,
-0.5729730129241943,
-0.5492112040519714,
-0.34428906440734863,
-0.6030961871147156,
-0.42058807611465454,
0.6020679473876953,
0.451447069644928,
-0.15062744915485382,
0.2382163554430008,
-0.6185221076011658,
0.7797314524650574,
0.46231383085250854,
0.17830967903137207,
0.56130051612854,
-0.1324421912431717,
-0.7365050911903381,
-0.08285597711801529,
-0.5934043526649475,
-0.5873612761497498,
1.3088864088058472,
0.5578691363334656,
0.8211797475814819,
0.05937273055315018,
0.7750137448310852,
0.005631610751152039,
0.4728451073169708,
-0.887064516544342,
0.7514002323150635,
-0.07162261754274368,
-0.2147325575351715,
-0.6436144113540649,
-0.460584431886673,
-0.8642879724502563,
0.4095161557197571,
-0.34128910303115845,
-0.724836528301239,
-0.04245099425315857,
-0.2839439809322357,
0.040362223982810974,
0.27792859077453613,
-0.45270422101020813,
0.6665640473365784,
-0.3736205995082855,
-0.5525158643722534,
-0.08161342889070511,
-0.48684370517730713,
0.21481844782829285,
-0.15583162009716034,
0.046102266758680344,
-0.2193383127450943,
-0.42193466424942017,
0.694526195526123,
-0.3431071639060974,
0.596521258354187,
-0.020078836008906364,
0.009906218387186527,
0.1830659806728363,
0.16073015332221985,
0.32674044370651245,
0.31572583317756653,
-0.19139158725738525,
0.3426581025123596,
-0.08345938473939896,
-0.31894204020500183,
-0.5566658973693848,
0.9903741478919983,
-1.0889818668365479,
-0.7666112184524536,
-0.32359206676483154,
-0.4631284773349762,
-0.4616664946079254,
0.3660006821155548,
0.23406819999217987,
-0.07731684297323227,
-0.2728331983089447,
0.2429337501525879,
0.5881980061531067,
-0.18089643120765686,
0.3286381661891937,
0.8827829957008362,
-0.29991772770881653,
-0.4428902864456177,
0.45743057131767273,
-0.19014930725097656,
0.19088123738765717,
0.36901363730430603,
0.5524890422821045,
-0.481838583946228,
-0.9583931565284729,
-0.3000725209712982,
0.39796996116638184,
-0.5104405283927917,
-0.1274235099554062,
-0.38057491183280945,
-0.12110229581594467,
-0.4565315246582031,
0.0636795163154602,
-0.602294921875,
-0.22619692981243134,
0.018474029377102852,
0.1203133687376976,
-0.17565174400806427,
0.7445241808891296,
-0.08071709424257278,
-0.01410869974642992,
-0.5652498602867126,
0.16356448829174042,
0.3391043543815613,
0.8705607056617737,
-0.14432203769683838,
-0.5783226490020752,
0.0005427058204077184,
-0.1204022690653801,
-0.34033679962158203,
-0.6246376633644104,
-0.13228818774223328,
0.21309152245521545,
0.7740784287452698,
0.3512924313545227,
0.19537533819675446,
0.40346935391426086,
-0.5456739068031311,
0.5146140456199646,
0.15609867870807648,
-1.0960979461669922,
0.6696730852127075,
-0.2384803742170334,
0.20830243825912476,
0.7712681293487549,
0.3732460141181946,
-0.3156883120536804,
-0.7407182455062866,
-0.39602532982826233,
-0.5988004803657532,
0.34611228108406067,
0.1971672773361206,
0.030759934335947037,
0.12985730171203613,
0.5763188004493713,
0.09337496012449265,
0.11761454492807388,
-0.803417980670929,
0.05582856386899948,
0.0465736947953701,
0.17847123742103577,
-0.07328392565250397,
-0.17417104542255402,
-0.32255491614341736,
-0.3382161557674408,
0.5271411538124084,
-0.11923262476921082,
0.0876450315117836,
0.2386200875043869,
0.044509291648864746,
-0.3420174717903137,
0.3774964213371277,
0.31222039461135864,
1.0006141662597656,
-0.3109126091003418,
0.13246800005435944,
-0.12447243928909302,
-0.3436242341995239,
0.1854105293750763,
-0.13424788415431976,
-0.10901019722223282,
-0.1373118907213211,
0.3306397795677185,
0.33887267112731934,
0.1667535901069641,
-0.7643553614616394,
0.8877087831497192,
-0.05513346940279007,
-0.1114942878484726,
-0.22583985328674316,
0.16246189177036285,
0.026110170409083366,
0.23891492187976837,
0.1979461908340454,
-0.12682375311851501,
-0.013235333375632763,
-0.46638646721839905,
0.2593285143375397,
0.6622893214225769,
-0.3464012145996094,
-0.1754469871520996,
0.6810773611068726,
0.28064975142478943,
-0.29480603337287903,
0.6491422057151794,
-0.1973251849412918,
-0.44011470675468445,
0.37817779183387756,
0.35204705595970154,
0.7695340514183044,
-0.27005258202552795,
0.3295542895793915,
0.26053687930107117,
0.5390254855155945,
-0.1702943593263626,
0.2967594563961029,
-0.08483780175447464,
-0.8929041624069214,
-0.48065197467803955,
-0.740928053855896,
-0.7273797988891602,
0.15234437584877014,
-0.7029812335968018,
0.29935482144355774,
-0.7823429107666016,
-0.1298428773880005,
-0.08738508820533752,
0.2689400017261505,
-0.2954602837562561,
-0.05955519527196884,
-0.22160165011882782,
0.7467105984687805,
-0.6727610230445862,
0.7851647138595581,
0.719543993473053,
-0.13028421998023987,
-0.5788857936859131,
-0.01672050543129444,
-0.22748799622058868,
-0.9698639512062073,
0.4679454267024994,
0.001363104092888534,
-0.2913981080055237,
-0.2015768587589264,
-0.4721124470233917,
-0.7105385661125183,
1.0345460176467896,
0.6196926832199097,
-0.881120502948761,
0.30650535225868225,
-0.05016765743494034,
0.6826052665710449,
-0.5315883755683899,
0.10366742312908173,
0.27405309677124023,
0.33204036951065063,
-0.06581076979637146,
-1.2323048114776611,
-0.04787568002939224,
-0.19658243656158447,
0.16473305225372314,
0.13935837149620056,
-0.7618426084518433,
0.5432401895523071,
-0.5426759719848633,
-0.10131047666072845,
0.24498924612998962,
0.5236566066741943,
0.5986883044242859,
0.11489734053611755,
0.5977316498756409,
0.5410457253456116,
0.7031522989273071,
-0.10601836442947388,
0.9527940154075623,
-0.3399837613105774,
0.5706897377967834,
1.0278807878494263,
-0.3449971377849579,
0.9809291362762451,
0.45777198672294617,
-0.24418304860591888,
0.4066222012042999,
0.6025922894477844,
-0.24076353013515472,
0.44051408767700195,
0.5766299366950989,
-0.18955466151237488,
-0.3123064339160919,
-0.17219795286655426,
0.0002001503307837993,
0.520206868648529,
-0.1179627999663353,
-0.2800748348236084,
-0.0363534651696682,
-0.1453779637813568,
-0.024204373359680176,
0.4311080574989319,
-0.33557572960853577,
0.7410199642181396,
-0.17574752867221832,
-0.7571610808372498,
0.5908961296081543,
0.4134882986545563,
0.6650548577308655,
-0.40117189288139343,
0.24170035123825073,
-0.39431312680244446,
0.13391640782356262,
-0.1528812050819397,
-1.015601396560669,
-0.0758233368396759,
0.03860931098461151,
-0.06384135782718658,
-0.10785844177007675,
0.4160153567790985,
-0.41351813077926636,
-0.5493217706680298,
0.4173318147659302,
0.5129273533821106,
0.3372434377670288,
0.04107175022363663,
-0.8125923275947571,
0.3346697986125946,
-0.2841423451900482,
-0.1467842161655426,
0.3865172564983368,
0.2211555689573288,
-0.06156380847096443,
0.8920154571533203,
0.4142482578754425,
0.5007818341255188,
-0.1686651110649109,
0.3019641935825348,
0.8604689240455627,
-0.13075384497642517,
-0.460226833820343,
-0.6885721683502197,
0.04921175166964531,
0.024207890033721924,
-0.2606947422027588,
0.759151041507721,
0.7922062277793884,
0.9228824377059937,
0.2342512011528015,
0.5134192705154419,
0.29804348945617676,
0.4646967649459839,
-0.3806179463863373,
0.6659048795700073,
-0.4511856436729431,
0.6159033179283142,
-0.47690194845199585,
-1.5907825231552124,
-0.18476004898548126,
0.5401754379272461,
-0.2324848175048828,
0.07188304513692856,
0.6179808378219604,
0.7157449722290039,
0.012117418460547924,
-0.250597208738327,
0.3398606777191162,
0.1287439912557602,
0.0932956114411354,
0.7653847932815552,
0.7831090688705444,
-0.23945096135139465,
0.4544987380504608,
-0.38853001594543457,
-0.6127669811248779,
0.18002299964427948,
-1.0532811880111694,
-0.8665358424186707,
-0.5596720576286316,
-0.5169063806533813,
-0.27645930647850037,
0.04222941771149635,
0.641021192073822,
0.6484944820404053,
-0.7058305740356445,
-0.5994128584861755,
0.04260202869772911,
0.29149293899536133,
-0.12711256742477417,
-0.23847410082817078,
0.47609007358551025,
-0.404102087020874,
-0.9705771803855896,
0.4384539723396301,
0.4745120406150818,
-0.22174972295761108,
-0.7081952095031738,
-0.20402951538562775,
0.09115972369909286,
-0.07840394973754883,
0.3245827257633209,
-0.029766449704766273,
-0.8655652403831482,
-0.3362847566604614,
0.08031640946865082,
-0.09105193614959717,
-0.04405324533581734,
0.8219168186187744,
-0.6507830023765564,
0.7359915971755981,
0.5410522818565369,
0.6771947145462036,
0.1541297882795334,
0.07429173588752747,
0.4309036135673523,
-0.745329737663269,
-0.12473619729280472,
0.3681016266345978,
0.4033772945404053,
0.4483613669872284,
-0.3388921320438385,
0.5052400827407837,
0.18642854690551758,
-0.8155009746551514,
-0.7837462425231934,
0.14351920783519745,
-1.0225780010223389,
-0.2260080724954605,
1.1553032398223877,
-0.446848064661026,
0.07179085165262222,
-0.012282752431929111,
0.13883236050605774,
-0.09605740755796432,
-0.30562880635261536,
1.01453697681427,
0.759032666683197,
-0.3424175977706909,
-0.2984706163406372,
-0.19007360935211182,
0.22878649830818176,
0.469245582818985,
-0.6765284538269043,
0.0031639125663787127,
0.38434281945228577,
0.6433731317520142,
0.13097429275512695,
0.6302787065505981,
-0.5909099578857422,
0.11615309864282608,
-0.5814578533172607,
0.04937911406159401,
-0.20135822892189026,
-0.41959744691848755,
-0.3944028615951538,
0.2078610211610794,
0.4496525824069977,
-0.10102769732475281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01629v1 | Position Paper: Generalized grammar rules and structure-based generalization beyond classical equivariance for lexical tasks and transduction | 2024-02-02T18:44:37 | 2024-02-02T18:44:37 | Mircea Petrache, Shubhendu Trivedi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Compositional generalization is one of the main properties which
differentiates lexical learning in humans from state-of-art neural networks. We
propose a general framework for building models that can generalize
compositionally using the concept of Generalized Grammar Rules (GGRs), a class
of symmetry-based compositional constraints for transduction tasks, which we
view as a transduction analogue of equivariance constraints in physics-inspired
tasks. Besides formalizing generalized notions of symmetry for language
transduction, our framework is general enough to contain many existing works as
special cases. We present ideas on how GGRs might be implemented, and in the
process draw connections to reinforcement learning and other areas of research. | [
0.2971799373626709,
-0.6233913898468018,
0.8946766257286072,
0.25700393319129944,
-0.18497906625270844,
-0.022150931879878044,
-0.06046222895383835,
-0.09641381353139877,
0.28196749091148376,
0.21605172753334045,
-0.5580161213874817,
-0.7265204191207886,
-0.4916704595088959,
0.013551067560911179,
-0.3509213626384735,
0.8176965713500977,
-0.19011759757995605,
0.29463696479797363,
-0.5441223978996277,
0.237150177359581,
-0.3181205093860626,
-0.7598380446434021,
-0.2557714879512787,
-0.464991956949234,
0.3137606382369995,
-0.07741393893957138,
0.6590763330459595,
0.8477353453636169,
0.30194467306137085,
0.3780789375305176,
-0.19455206394195557,
0.2567805349826813,
-0.09169649332761765,
0.2051171064376831,
-0.586280345916748,
-0.5627065896987915,
-0.3038089871406555,
-0.19281987845897675,
0.7549929022789001,
0.9706026315689087,
-0.5206186175346375,
-0.06076158210635185,
0.03419342264533043,
0.44132575392723083,
-0.6266934275627136,
0.5549760460853577,
-0.24750018119812012,
0.3622335195541382,
0.2885028123855591,
0.1855555921792984,
-0.21979176998138428,
-0.21205130219459534,
0.07760674506425858,
-0.9031421542167664,
0.3153766095638275,
-0.0787741169333458,
0.7806885242462158,
-0.05306828394532204,
-0.3505133092403412,
-0.4229671359062195,
-0.9140944480895996,
0.8349186182022095,
-0.2118656039237976,
0.5680496692657471,
0.4814831018447876,
0.17579029500484467,
-0.27911651134490967,
-0.8517548441886902,
-0.045560963451862335,
-0.07480219751596451,
-0.5397225618362427,
-0.015230026096105576,
-0.18133775889873505,
0.5877211689949036,
0.2971572279930115,
0.44366300106048584,
-0.6538833379745483,
-0.6446724534034729,
-0.2699347138404846,
-0.32836928963661194,
0.3081691265106201,
0.3136039674282074,
0.6794725656509399,
0.17370623350143433,
0.24541518092155457,
0.027243459597229958,
-0.4399455189704895,
0.13828665018081665,
0.39936593174934387,
0.2505093812942505,
-0.36972305178642273,
0.2646971642971039,
-0.3081302344799042,
0.9316558837890625,
0.19229581952095032,
0.07036615163087845,
0.1397179216146469,
-0.6950647234916687,
-0.3809114694595337,
-0.24505046010017395,
0.4952101409435272,
-0.17075209319591522,
0.28786155581474304,
-0.7592430114746094,
-0.007229395676404238,
0.4111134111881256,
0.3074916899204254,
-0.6111164689064026,
0.02398652583360672,
-0.32682520151138306,
-0.49297523498535156,
-0.13687260448932648,
0.34808751940727234,
-0.5305659770965576,
0.127766951918602,
-0.755035400390625,
0.509138286113739,
-0.16926874220371246,
-0.1349780261516571,
0.5526890754699707,
-0.30828994512557983,
0.2906210124492645,
-0.07378904521465302,
-1.5664191246032715,
0.756678581237793,
0.908515989780426,
0.9065555334091187,
0.16365496814250946,
-0.20314493775367737,
-0.4393027126789093,
0.6942236423492432,
-0.15245677530765533,
0.47294101119041443,
-1.0403205156326294,
-0.6499211192131042,
0.05943380296230316,
-0.07058697193861008,
-0.3338128924369812,
-0.2861001789569855,
0.6345625519752502,
-0.0915888249874115,
0.625220537185669,
-0.5178515315055847,
-0.45661574602127075,
-0.08874901384115219,
0.19519372284412384,
-0.29710501432418823,
0.20798355340957642,
0.28225889801979065,
-0.2751549184322357,
0.1725742518901825,
-0.28956785798072815,
-0.8636734485626221,
-0.3630271553993225,
-0.5090186595916748,
-0.2617138922214508,
0.5069528222084045,
0.10850336402654648,
0.15852461755275726,
-0.26243436336517334,
0.5156777501106262,
-0.3190925717353821,
-0.3245972990989685,
-0.3322736322879791,
0.3235926330089569,
0.5577220320701599,
0.2488943487405777,
-0.19179202616214752,
0.1050085797905922,
-0.5963003635406494,
0.3501611649990082,
-0.13836528360843658,
-0.42545589804649353,
-0.36940041184425354,
0.4627169072628021,
-0.5623800754547119,
0.06369160860776901,
-0.15294519066810608,
-0.4669080078601837,
0.28101539611816406,
-0.48776528239250183,
0.6834756731987,
0.38378241658210754,
-0.1847507357597351,
0.9471375346183777,
-0.42491623759269714,
0.34654587507247925,
-0.09437102824449539,
0.2543257176876068,
0.07513284683227539,
-0.35260897874832153,
-0.3878736197948456,
-0.3056550621986389,
0.01386218424886465,
0.49271416664123535,
-0.4253586232662201,
0.538553774356842,
-0.14108194410800934,
-0.15709549188613892,
0.007597880903631449,
0.1941577047109604,
0.5774399638175964,
0.4153614342212677,
0.4733579754829407,
-0.23700740933418274,
-0.9588853120803833,
-0.9634674787521362,
-0.40338048338890076,
-0.29501333832740784,
-0.17040349543094635,
-0.17475026845932007,
0.11157432943582535,
-0.1400904655456543,
0.8470267653465271,
-0.43515217304229736,
-0.20479807257652283,
-0.297782838344574,
-0.03960128128528595,
0.18371452391147614,
0.4343944191932678,
0.5839857459068298,
-0.6563868522644043,
-0.2855238914489746,
-0.010880407877266407,
-0.961913526058197,
-0.11186876147985458,
0.12145701795816422,
-0.3319537341594696,
-0.24439989030361176,
0.8550004363059998,
-0.567417323589325,
0.12431401014328003,
0.5542617440223694,
-0.6858696341514587,
0.3247922360897064,
-0.07498796284198761,
-0.21075403690338135,
-0.8777106404304504,
-0.13745185732841492,
0.08776338398456573,
-0.34907495975494385,
-1.031805157661438,
0.22488735616207123,
-0.15291665494441986,
-0.1285550445318222,
-0.18593649566173553,
0.3500848710536957,
-0.3598136305809021,
-0.08929860591888428,
-0.11437240242958069,
-0.6308685541152954,
0.2332647144794464,
0.48829254508018494,
0.1881495863199234,
0.2589819133281708,
0.8320708870887756,
-0.8425720930099487,
0.30361562967300415,
0.027053844183683395,
0.1810925006866455,
0.5824728012084961,
-1.0272043943405151,
-0.15234987437725067,
-0.4943980872631073,
0.1724574714899063,
-0.770656406879425,
-0.07217054814100266,
0.7348991632461548,
-0.17403043806552887,
0.3962867259979248,
-0.09810225665569305,
-0.20025227963924408,
-0.061235878616571426,
0.042448874562978745,
0.3834209144115448,
0.5629370212554932,
-0.04684264585375786,
1.3184800148010254,
-0.005321059841662645,
0.19088491797447205,
-0.34899723529815674,
-0.7664383053779602,
-0.24053893983364105,
-0.04626534506678581,
-0.5417870283126831,
0.650529682636261,
-0.0022964361123740673,
-0.41785335540771484,
0.19271442294120789,
-0.13154931366443634,
-0.0040312823839485645,
0.1305578500032425,
0.24644269049167633,
-0.0494067408144474,
-0.09787129610776901,
0.18205928802490234,
0.11205879598855972,
0.2723645269870758,
0.2510139048099518,
-0.6405420899391174,
0.6106979846954346,
-0.26562538743019104,
-0.42219725251197815,
-0.18962904810905457,
0.4194052815437317,
0.2859947383403778,
0.000020410181605257094,
0.3572468161582947,
0.41589784622192383,
-0.23456744849681854,
-0.3381001949310303,
-0.07814623415470123,
-0.04561460018157959,
-0.5062018036842346,
0.48924291133880615,
-0.3439420759677887,
-0.8608946204185486,
0.5200015902519226,
0.2387915849685669,
-0.16176150739192963,
0.27145493030548096,
0.45968252420425415,
0.011754858307540417,
1.1948285102844238,
0.823111891746521,
-0.12719903886318207,
0.7006285190582275,
-0.031236620619893074,
-0.1595080941915512,
-0.4595074951648712,
-0.26980558037757874,
-0.42660319805145264,
-0.5217703580856323,
-0.3595534563064575,
-0.2725496292114258,
0.1699276566505432,
-0.0020458614453673363,
-0.34776076674461365,
0.010308202356100082,
-0.4390914738178253,
0.7901716232299805,
0.48222726583480835,
0.1403060108423233,
-0.009195433929562569,
0.18228577077388763,
-0.5635598301887512,
0.3047451674938202,
-0.5160114169120789,
-0.06971001625061035,
1.0402864217758179,
0.11103901267051697,
0.8297717571258545,
0.3128058612346649,
0.7878167033195496,
0.2993811368942261,
-0.01971602812409401,
-0.7756035327911377,
0.5248439908027649,
-0.37520676851272583,
-0.6532524824142456,
-0.15077780187129974,
-0.5241004228591919,
-0.7901637554168701,
0.51046222448349,
-0.01248552929610014,
-0.6890931725502014,
0.2655317187309265,
0.2356233298778534,
-0.09110771119594574,
0.34453022480010986,
-0.8018230199813843,
0.5868672728538513,
-0.1423790454864502,
-0.37606537342071533,
-0.10769012570381165,
-0.4802066385746002,
0.3113161325454712,
0.44597145915031433,
0.1735493242740631,
0.2296416163444519,
-0.04119209572672844,
0.1540459543466568,
-0.2972451150417328,
1.1165648698806763,
-0.3806432783603668,
0.06848738342523575,
0.41126111149787903,
0.07544037699699402,
0.41089707612991333,
-0.013556313700973988,
0.25080442428588867,
-0.1588597446680069,
0.09795118123292923,
-0.35353055596351624,
-0.6081666350364685,
0.22778956592082977,
-0.9745686650276184,
-0.6375882029533386,
-0.3401840627193451,
-0.4801171123981476,
-0.52921062707901,
0.03047807700932026,
0.2915656864643097,
0.24160516262054443,
-0.6021931171417236,
-0.016227493062615395,
0.64055997133255,
0.18490120768547058,
0.3130040168762207,
0.1948632299900055,
-0.3612702786922455,
-0.6573370099067688,
0.8953347206115723,
-0.22996976971626282,
0.20266009867191315,
0.640160858631134,
0.4686566889286041,
-0.2282518446445465,
-0.34680888056755066,
-0.1622474193572998,
0.3785686492919922,
-0.5625132322311401,
0.12726585566997528,
-0.44320154190063477,
-0.22381305694580078,
-0.527561366558075,
-0.17597748339176178,
0.12546241283416748,
-0.3837527632713318,
-0.5201566219329834,
0.04996451362967491,
-0.45548316836357117,
0.9205073118209839,
-0.21839645504951477,
0.3225453197956085,
-0.5525270700454712,
0.450212299823761,
0.8700864911079407,
0.48578670620918274,
-0.19869117438793182,
-0.4089261591434479,
-0.2623985707759857,
0.17628876864910126,
-0.4957278072834015,
-0.6514579057693481,
-0.008582016453146935,
0.7359480857849121,
0.9831441044807434,
0.28582778573036194,
-0.6916955709457397,
0.34716710448265076,
-0.4561443030834198,
0.5215790867805481,
0.4294520318508148,
-1.3892878293991089,
0.21121859550476074,
-0.6107892990112305,
0.2600785791873932,
0.16364331543445587,
0.18570832908153534,
-0.9844779372215271,
-0.2660725712776184,
-0.39416274428367615,
-0.38547104597091675,
0.3133038878440857,
-0.037879131734371185,
0.39144065976142883,
-0.13863271474838257,
0.7024722695350647,
-0.07796875387430191,
0.47471216320991516,
-0.7870334386825562,
0.04757086560130119,
-0.6135777831077576,
-0.3993322551250458,
-0.1587597131729126,
-0.20825690031051636,
-0.22501236200332642,
-0.46437081694602966,
0.3502570390701294,
-0.2927250266075134,
0.30154648423194885,
0.34798482060432434,
-0.3700600564479828,
-0.17975157499313354,
0.5300314426422119,
1.0380557775497437,
0.553536593914032,
0.08207740634679794,
0.13187862932682037,
-0.20707115530967712,
-0.3841358721256256,
0.688051164150238,
-0.22768336534500122,
-0.5575338006019592,
-0.1527828872203827,
0.3716132342815399,
0.6442831158638,
0.2948644459247589,
-0.05703449994325638,
0.32090437412261963,
-0.20234495401382446,
-0.9639672040939331,
0.17231999337673187,
0.4143669605255127,
0.07776474952697754,
0.28661760687828064,
0.026338154450058937,
-0.30325639247894287,
0.15224282443523407,
-0.7653154134750366,
0.01315858494490385,
0.6223961710929871,
-0.24795962870121002,
-0.9408913254737854,
0.6140000224113464,
-0.03926876559853554,
0.21530382335186005,
0.12867024540901184,
-0.37819379568099976,
-0.3886256515979767,
0.4904249310493469,
0.8472246527671814,
1.1463803052902222,
-0.25888973474502563,
0.506980836391449,
0.29468825459480286,
0.1522696614265442,
-0.5610191226005554,
0.7010884284973145,
-0.003288383362814784,
-0.7680832147598267,
-0.5295634865760803,
-0.7272899746894836,
-0.4589990973472595,
-0.22822053730487823,
-0.40827810764312744,
0.21002814173698425,
-1.0861647129058838,
-0.03981451690196991,
-0.27594974637031555,
-0.5386617183685303,
-0.5309990644454956,
0.11507726460695267,
0.5635462999343872,
0.21066609025001526,
-0.9663084149360657,
0.468758225440979,
1.2570489645004272,
-0.2296847552061081,
-0.6117405295372009,
-0.32540032267570496,
-0.0021105369087308645,
-0.6439716815948486,
0.8030072450637817,
-0.26017042994499207,
-0.1462136209011078,
-0.28342390060424805,
-0.8033850789070129,
-1.2725235223770142,
0.8848229646682739,
0.6919000148773193,
-0.35509973764419556,
-0.7040185332298279,
0.41617411375045776,
0.7554774284362793,
-0.4347911477088928,
0.02208220772445202,
0.4605724513530731,
0.5277753472328186,
0.2007777839899063,
-0.7139861583709717,
-0.16274043917655945,
-0.28772470355033875,
0.20428822934627533,
0.2593608498573303,
-0.8448019623756409,
1.2549915313720703,
0.20348139107227325,
-0.33302226662635803,
0.031397659331560135,
0.7199224829673767,
-0.08734334260225296,
0.06811365485191345,
0.17091426253318787,
1.0461654663085938,
0.5522268414497375,
-0.22161467373371124,
0.7793734669685364,
-0.007422837894409895,
0.22355832159519196,
0.7873966097831726,
-0.0824684277176857,
-0.1632264107465744,
0.4169165790081024,
-0.2095753401517868,
0.9023963809013367,
0.09046059101819992,
-0.10591240972280502,
0.8820550441741943,
0.7063813805580139,
-0.3045470416545868,
-0.428070604801178,
-0.14912910759449005,
-0.4073900878429413,
0.5131334662437439,
0.5361887216567993,
-0.6549769043922424,
-0.5212777256965637,
-0.20542314648628235,
0.014516934752464294,
0.2889023423194885,
-0.8024736046791077,
0.8245784640312195,
0.013010852038860321,
-0.6019461154937744,
0.36010733246803284,
0.09106986969709396,
0.6096391677856445,
-0.9829389452934265,
0.07497663050889969,
0.1213512048125267,
0.2020997554063797,
-0.28044363856315613,
-0.2559311091899872,
0.5130751729011536,
-0.5480421781539917,
-0.4652218222618103,
-0.30556902289390564,
0.8626194596290588,
-0.5423159599304199,
-0.5744566321372986,
0.13520951569080353,
0.672531247138977,
-0.5219271183013916,
0.08890378475189209,
-0.2861024737358093,
-0.19984720647335052,
-0.06877416372299194,
-0.05849362537264824,
0.4512893855571747,
0.3360375165939331,
0.004899946041405201,
0.3353802263736725,
0.3184508681297302,
0.3979836106300354,
0.2069394290447235,
-0.025775138288736343,
0.9189350008964539,
-0.7528263926506042,
-0.9555883407592773,
-1.0184341669082642,
0.18684205412864685,
0.2878234088420868,
-0.010198954492807388,
0.3148021996021271,
0.2810012996196747,
0.9157196879386902,
-0.25107866525650024,
1.0811206102371216,
0.028702709823846817,
0.20049497485160828,
-0.6850187182426453,
0.15916875004768372,
-0.3629024028778076,
-0.279294490814209,
-0.29601359367370605,
-0.9669598340988159,
-0.7036757469177246,
0.5550242066383362,
-0.4678398370742798,
0.11346711963415146,
0.7450955510139465,
0.455414354801178,
-0.2904776930809021,
0.13060058653354645,
0.5216474533081055,
-0.4286383390426636,
0.592056155204773,
0.784673273563385,
0.8909645080566406,
-0.0516400970518589,
0.463503360748291,
-0.11093077808618546,
0.3125077784061432,
0.1277274489402771,
-0.7498945593833923,
-0.9342392086982727,
-0.45411446690559387,
-0.11078788340091705,
-0.073784239590168,
0.24541814625263214,
0.8877673745155334,
0.7603697180747986,
-0.7362133860588074,
-0.47459155321121216,
-0.6116495728492737,
0.24336479604244232,
-0.25100526213645935,
-0.11572247743606567,
0.027126995846629143,
-0.7339286208152771,
-0.5032661557197571,
0.30877816677093506,
0.2089281678199768,
0.3528328537940979,
0.11688626557588577,
-0.26027897000312805,
-0.018688904121518135,
0.018929067999124527,
0.6520858407020569,
0.6816322803497314,
-0.44088244438171387,
-0.4911406338214874,
0.08985079079866409,
-0.1352066993713379,
-0.03701402619481087,
1.2098819017410278,
-0.5168918371200562,
0.25626713037490845,
0.6479567289352417,
0.4853518307209015,
0.09847941249608994,
0.16222986578941345,
0.7473406791687012,
-1.1504074335098267,
0.2438756674528122,
0.11628056317567825,
0.5564306378364563,
0.03958643972873688,
-0.1713072508573532,
0.3423079550266266,
0.71915203332901,
-0.356813907623291,
-0.342160701751709,
0.7100405097007751,
-0.5219424962997437,
-0.21344071626663208,
1.2320990562438965,
0.13321417570114136,
-0.5065761208534241,
0.07087966799736023,
0.24527376890182495,
0.20207300782203674,
-0.24429680407047272,
0.44142696261405945,
0.9192454218864441,
-0.15173190832138062,
0.1514948159456253,
0.13188648223876953,
0.5513759851455688,
0.468399316072464,
-0.8644062280654907,
-0.09634145349264145,
0.8098068833351135,
0.3567545413970947,
0.04447000101208687,
0.32679685950279236,
-0.11604639887809753,
0.3641201853752136,
-0.23480096459388733,
0.1775825321674347,
-0.33412328362464905,
-0.4375995993614197,
-0.43139779567718506,
0.39291760325431824,
-0.09807097166776657,
-0.15545539557933807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01829v1 | Predicting ATP binding sites in protein sequences using Deep Learning and Natural Language Processing | 2024-02-02T18:42:39 | 2024-02-02T18:42:39 | Shreyas V, Swati Agarwal | q-bio.BM | q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.LG | Predicting ATP-Protein Binding sites in genes is of great significance in the
field of Biology and Medicine. The majority of research in this field has been
conducted through time- and resource-intensive 'wet experiments' in
laboratories. Over the years, researchers have been investigating computational
methods computational methods to accomplish the same goals, utilising the
strength of advanced Deep Learning and NLP algorithms. In this paper, we
propose to develop methods to classify ATP-Protein binding sites. We conducted
various experiments mainly using PSSMs and several word embeddings as features.
We used 2D CNNs and LightGBM classifiers as our chief Deep Learning Algorithms.
The MP3Vec and BERT models have also been subjected to testing in our study.
The outcomes of our experiments demonstrated improvement over the
state-of-the-art benchmarks. | [
-0.5802998542785645,
-0.7453702092170715,
0.7702028155326843,
0.004882132168859243,
-0.0948854386806488,
-0.009662960655987263,
-0.21255916357040405,
-0.4861419200897217,
-0.1142730638384819,
0.3504132628440857,
-0.2881706953048706,
-0.45240089297294617,
-1.034726619720459,
0.27163445949554443,
-0.4646177291870117,
0.38335147500038147,
-0.30000343918800354,
0.7720040678977966,
-0.31754955649375916,
0.022104548290371895,
-0.04554164409637451,
-0.4559113085269928,
0.018952028825879097,
-0.6219047904014587,
0.22468535602092743,
0.14134207367897034,
0.49732711911201477,
0.600287914276123,
0.8688139319419861,
0.2941281795501709,
-0.11014199256896973,
0.0336729995906353,
-0.07093589752912521,
0.11270956695079803,
-0.018546873703598976,
-0.2360401153564453,
-0.1397428959608078,
0.20639385282993317,
0.3572039008140564,
1.0686413049697876,
0.12575089931488037,
-0.057126235216856,
0.05944616720080376,
0.47718483209609985,
-0.7391108274459839,
0.0868934765458107,
-0.2628398835659027,
0.5481337904930115,
-0.12911532819271088,
-0.7409271597862244,
-0.4675059914588928,
-0.5262588262557983,
0.5444263219833374,
0.035689882934093475,
0.5330080986022949,
-0.09654100984334946,
0.7936378121376038,
0.18096213042736053,
-0.736689031124115,
-0.27334538102149963,
-0.557867705821991,
0.8231500387191772,
-0.6805951595306396,
0.581619381904602,
0.7360520958900452,
0.29067784547805786,
-0.5493344068527222,
-0.5826752781867981,
-0.08682721108198166,
-0.17634685337543488,
-0.039724547415971756,
-0.3937477171421051,
0.1830454170703888,
0.3878491520881653,
0.10692485421895981,
0.4882909059524536,
-0.6521387696266174,
-0.2232508659362793,
-0.49862200021743774,
-0.09129895269870758,
0.42008963227272034,
-0.26345178484916687,
0.3183116018772125,
-0.11549130827188492,
-0.46041759848594666,
0.19113485515117645,
-0.48301586508750916,
0.1352377086877823,
0.005104717332869768,
0.3818879723548889,
0.3580935001373291,
0.7923809289932251,
-0.10564360022544861,
0.7714905142784119,
-0.04821086302399635,
0.03537439554929733,
0.16100457310676575,
-0.04016592353582382,
-0.47367551922798157,
0.6023978590965271,
0.6469768285751343,
0.13355980813503265,
0.28033098578453064,
-0.0035749084781855345,
0.09691844135522842,
-0.049758341163396835,
0.1805638074874878,
-0.8805454969406128,
-0.40706148743629456,
0.3166024684906006,
-0.5848172903060913,
-0.1925472617149353,
-0.024311987683176994,
-0.7034289836883545,
-0.3011976480484009,
-0.5990126729011536,
0.39402422308921814,
-0.9058033227920532,
0.2156868875026703,
0.4925931990146637,
-0.21951675415039062,
0.026366837322711945,
0.1328728049993515,
-0.800895094871521,
0.5886834263801575,
0.4260871410369873,
0.8174887299537659,
0.08667054772377014,
-0.36194974184036255,
-0.47917941212654114,
0.22616392374038696,
0.12589427828788757,
0.8555089235305786,
-0.8588435649871826,
-0.10987941920757294,
0.10237147659063339,
-0.2642379701137543,
-0.06089993938803673,
-0.19057036936283112,
0.5075175762176514,
-0.8218393921852112,
0.1734350472688675,
-0.3090085983276367,
-1.1836603879928589,
-0.45476803183555603,
-0.022094476968050003,
-0.43106287717819214,
0.6029655337333679,
-0.21251007914543152,
-0.7245031595230103,
0.24543021619319916,
-0.48035264015197754,
-0.7196102142333984,
-0.08697671443223953,
0.07365863025188446,
-0.12151272594928741,
0.27408695220947266,
0.2620171308517456,
0.5521159172058105,
-0.19458849728107452,
0.5159701108932495,
-0.41758111119270325,
-0.1406276673078537,
0.46307680010795593,
-0.0757731944322586,
0.4831792414188385,
0.36547157168388367,
-0.419455885887146,
-0.10054417699575424,
-0.7210128903388977,
0.41224411129951477,
-0.16932880878448486,
-0.3147794008255005,
-0.13457849621772766,
0.18373028934001923,
-0.040115371346473694,
0.3023461401462555,
-0.00757058197632432,
-0.4842655062675476,
0.6400722861289978,
-0.23890945315361023,
0.5230519771575928,
0.5601245164871216,
0.08413831889629364,
0.5146763324737549,
0.34875744581222534,
0.20336109399795532,
-0.14872266352176666,
0.05191363766789436,
0.22054341435432434,
-0.8673266768455505,
-0.11159497499465942,
0.06705925613641739,
0.5149341821670532,
0.270001620054245,
-0.2592344284057617,
0.4690697193145752,
-0.3279438614845276,
-0.45549798011779785,
-0.3228893280029297,
0.1521940976381302,
0.4226709008216858,
0.4855019748210907,
0.7482129335403442,
-0.24881063401699066,
-0.4979001581668854,
-0.7811941504478455,
-0.1348562389612198,
0.16680394113063812,
-0.24615216255187988,
0.49207833409309387,
0.5874770283699036,
-0.31870943307876587,
0.8503493666648865,
-0.7961217761039734,
-0.37257686257362366,
-0.09552197903394699,
0.29999884963035583,
0.20509013533592224,
0.5017834305763245,
0.3709927201271057,
-0.9358953833580017,
-0.21108601987361908,
-0.21708400547504425,
-0.6353692412376404,
0.012282825075089931,
0.2604832351207733,
0.17737464606761932,
-0.3809660077095032,
0.15718795359134674,
-0.5439437627792358,
0.33845168352127075,
0.5164605379104614,
-0.30309978127479553,
0.08969229459762573,
-0.2778785824775696,
0.4011341631412506,
-0.356638103723526,
-0.0028546249959617853,
0.19573402404785156,
-0.15278874337673187,
-0.8652738928794861,
-0.19933465123176575,
0.15503698587417603,
-0.25419023633003235,
-0.5554530620574951,
0.14413806796073914,
-0.4805387556552887,
-0.3730580806732178,
-0.27767661213874817,
-0.21839210391044617,
0.22707341611385345,
0.554078996181488,
0.23782826960086823,
0.4140240252017975,
0.5285871028900146,
-0.7531201839447021,
0.2918710708618164,
0.4817959666252136,
-0.47277313470840454,
-0.3211641013622284,
-0.5032737851142883,
0.0038133554626256227,
0.1930871307849884,
0.4467308223247528,
-0.9077087044715881,
-0.3640637993812561,
0.19428877532482147,
-0.5714622139930725,
0.49612778425216675,
-0.3031754195690155,
-0.5476794242858887,
-0.2548118531703949,
-0.3846049904823303,
0.6755251884460449,
0.36474090814590454,
-0.5576695203781128,
0.3139064311981201,
0.6380693912506104,
0.15060044825077057,
-0.034726280719041824,
-0.9241511821746826,
-0.17668095231056213,
0.14197267591953278,
-0.4755242168903351,
0.44362133741378784,
0.32075729966163635,
0.17060384154319763,
-0.008573818020522594,
-0.06650640070438385,
-0.36718887090682983,
-0.016873830929398537,
0.41504377126693726,
-0.127847820520401,
-0.15323945879936218,
0.10365545749664307,
-0.03889215365052223,
-0.2720639407634735,
0.03178824856877327,
-0.5035078525543213,
0.952013373374939,
-0.349933385848999,
-0.3257633447647095,
-0.5131268501281738,
0.32977622747421265,
0.5438641309738159,
-0.4962937533855438,
0.7528858184814453,
0.4882394075393677,
-0.6984256505966187,
0.13357526063919067,
-0.21844792366027832,
-0.05131453275680542,
-0.4674597382545471,
0.13394585251808167,
-0.05648791044950485,
-0.5758593678474426,
0.2538660168647766,
-0.6045821905136108,
-0.46054795384407043,
0.330373078584671,
0.39511892199516296,
-0.12935379147529602,
1.2944276332855225,
0.621466338634491,
0.2399531602859497,
0.1344817876815796,
-0.6046485304832458,
0.35602807998657227,
-0.9061569571495056,
-0.371265709400177,
-0.6195437908172607,
-0.7665363550186157,
-0.3501308262348175,
-0.5837375521659851,
0.0721297338604927,
0.3336699306964874,
-0.043723609298467636,
0.6154764294624329,
-0.4370456337928772,
0.37855663895606995,
0.5910739898681641,
0.07392491400241852,
-0.3313150703907013,
0.11651686578989029,
-0.428037166595459,
-0.041564010083675385,
-0.5825321674346924,
-0.38393720984458923,
1.0885313749313354,
0.3999088406562805,
0.3914409279823303,
0.02194148488342762,
0.5482341647148132,
0.36490994691848755,
0.041878994554281235,
-0.7400042414665222,
0.35739806294441223,
-0.2748792767524719,
-0.41326242685317993,
-0.1144462451338768,
-0.2167646586894989,
-0.9695791006088257,
-0.18437737226486206,
-0.25471338629722595,
-0.6304718852043152,
0.5705004930496216,
-0.017179477959871292,
-0.2216092199087143,
0.514067530632019,
-0.5594402551651001,
0.7315999865531921,
-0.5178936719894409,
-0.26030996441841125,
-0.2920365035533905,
-0.7286018133163452,
0.09185721725225449,
0.38450583815574646,
0.12929636240005493,
-0.27005940675735474,
0.10584141314029694,
0.5042264461517334,
-0.4289484918117523,
0.4771820604801178,
-0.14951510727405548,
-0.09453650563955307,
0.07449332624673843,
0.09974507242441177,
0.3881278932094574,
-0.11569701135158539,
-0.33605608344078064,
0.4405629634857178,
-0.1027245819568634,
-0.7393996119499207,
-0.27561765909194946,
0.8754295110702515,
-0.7058208584785461,
0.02257084660232067,
-0.6192194223403931,
-0.04342976585030556,
-0.3846498131752014,
0.3262036144733429,
0.5760688185691833,
0.5766831636428833,
0.11627450585365295,
0.04619503393769264,
0.8828615546226501,
-0.34877273440361023,
0.20500217378139496,
0.09899602830410004,
-0.27431949973106384,
-0.3322979807853699,
0.7339221239089966,
0.13865137100219727,
-0.043221648782491684,
0.7144566774368286,
0.2516873776912689,
-0.42990878224372864,
-1.1352440118789673,
-0.1906777024269104,
-0.2532753050327301,
-0.5941238403320312,
-0.4642634093761444,
-0.43909239768981934,
-0.20266036689281464,
-0.5899795293807983,
-0.446897029876709,
-0.24777619540691376,
-0.3451729416847229,
-0.23421646654605865,
-0.3316795825958252,
0.2595297396183014,
0.32883915305137634,
0.11912944167852402,
0.03823107108473778,
-1.107711911201477,
0.6086593866348267,
0.15475520491600037,
0.8472590446472168,
-0.2741173505783081,
-0.05660547688603401,
-0.13119013607501984,
0.05811456963419914,
-0.20602695643901825,
-1.230488896369934,
0.6527107357978821,
0.6438717842102051,
0.5476047992706299,
0.47547560930252075,
-0.0051976703107357025,
0.47850704193115234,
-0.6391962766647339,
0.8024822473526001,
0.0651460513472557,
-0.8528696298599243,
1.1891554594039917,
-0.2758314609527588,
0.07403942942619324,
0.6670739054679871,
0.5058573484420776,
-0.2645385265350342,
-0.0721268504858017,
-0.6545673608779907,
-1.0704472064971924,
0.5726305842399597,
0.4596443176269531,
-0.19636143743991852,
-0.28875619173049927,
0.43606388568878174,
0.3642255365848541,
0.3070176839828491,
-0.14165626466274261,
-0.46594497561454773,
0.031190577894449234,
-0.0870344340801239,
0.035104233771562576,
-0.5052462816238403,
-0.026058487594127655,
-0.2610684335231781,
0.676600992679596,
-0.10442858189344406,
0.34979766607284546,
0.4675903022289276,
-0.4184105694293976,
-0.4947056472301483,
0.036875661462545395,
0.4615970551967621,
0.5008116364479065,
-0.6707348823547363,
0.5488592982292175,
0.037716519087553024,
-0.4703104496002197,
0.1367560774087906,
0.19234630465507507,
-0.16794125735759735,
0.053323742002248764,
0.5799273252487183,
0.4976849853992462,
0.41616395115852356,
-0.7500655651092529,
0.366690456867218,
-0.29439353942871094,
-0.0015502237947657704,
-0.2837643623352051,
0.22986547648906708,
-0.1323849856853485,
0.10348441451787949,
0.32545432448387146,
0.5786576867103577,
0.6762202382087708,
-0.3671002984046936,
0.36557525396347046,
0.0941927433013916,
-0.4085356891155243,
-0.23334427177906036,
0.4465721845626831,
0.3515830338001251,
-0.3373521566390991,
0.7511836290359497,
-0.04893907532095909,
-0.6494911313056946,
0.622032642364502,
0.17809048295021057,
0.91353440284729,
-0.25345054268836975,
-0.07513094693422318,
0.39450928568840027,
-0.3583628833293915,
-0.11089467257261276,
0.17579025030136108,
-0.23614323139190674,
-0.4343242347240448,
-0.3536907732486725,
-1.0910078287124634,
-0.31170934438705444,
0.0073505183681845665,
-0.7546918988227844,
0.34073606133461,
-0.5989580154418945,
-0.20353905856609344,
0.4311824440956116,
0.5590174198150635,
-0.7251094579696655,
0.15881797671318054,
0.5887810587882996,
1.110334873199463,
-0.8715042471885681,
1.2076889276504517,
0.7776094079017639,
-0.08636417239904404,
-0.05600939691066742,
-0.16216926276683807,
0.13827858865261078,
-0.415437251329422,
0.6380892992019653,
0.48900848627090454,
0.035617437213659286,
-0.13279472291469574,
-0.43537044525146484,
-1.0994861125946045,
0.9327296018600464,
0.25784793496131897,
-0.6328125596046448,
0.36983466148376465,
0.23661699891090393,
0.7041611671447754,
-0.06555132567882538,
-0.1896381825208664,
0.3887416422367096,
0.5803287029266357,
-0.12123843282461166,
-0.596496045589447,
-0.12250634282827377,
-0.4827665388584137,
-0.21429212391376495,
0.565131664276123,
-0.2636461853981018,
0.5201360583305359,
-0.1573982685804367,
0.034222960472106934,
0.1145862340927124,
0.6365225315093994,
0.1695433408021927,
0.4927005171775818,
0.10785061866044998,
0.523820161819458,
0.7559273838996887,
-0.22650371491909027,
1.2938053607940674,
-0.3892432451248169,
0.6683018207550049,
0.6868078708648682,
-0.2464890480041504,
0.7785475254058838,
0.5603978037834167,
-0.6042729616165161,
0.237379789352417,
0.8221250176429749,
-0.49150654673576355,
0.797364354133606,
0.5592672824859619,
-0.06984902173280716,
-0.2761111855506897,
-0.2529403865337372,
-0.5848115682601929,
0.09458311647176743,
0.6176909804344177,
-0.4699408710002899,
-0.09762140363454819,
0.1387813538312912,
-0.4920096695423126,
0.04885883629322052,
-0.23519015312194824,
0.43216320872306824,
0.20320135354995728,
-0.38786107301712036,
0.22146044671535492,
0.1509331464767456,
0.3808140158653259,
-0.6705410480499268,
-0.28719884157180786,
0.11105192452669144,
0.38136571645736694,
-0.3438582122325897,
-0.9375620484352112,
0.17789088189601898,
-0.12873007357120514,
-0.21697470545768738,
-0.48102065920829773,
0.8732321858406067,
-0.40347054600715637,
-0.5750327110290527,
0.6365665197372437,
0.07582464814186096,
0.046208951622247696,
-0.0023868156131356955,
-0.5670713186264038,
-0.23873044550418854,
-0.1001049056649208,
-0.3940163850784302,
0.660321831703186,
0.41023051738739014,
0.33394700288772583,
0.7363530993461609,
0.7435169219970703,
0.13790954649448395,
-0.024445094168186188,
-0.051439765840768814,
0.6945950388908386,
-0.8897995948791504,
-0.09900227189064026,
-0.7256088852882385,
-0.009366038255393505,
0.16343830525875092,
-0.3187394440174103,
0.593380331993103,
0.6539634466171265,
0.586405336856842,
-0.1951637864112854,
0.3604210615158081,
0.04500250890851021,
0.04628484696149826,
-0.6948832869529724,
0.4187721908092499,
-0.32835376262664795,
0.4078295826911926,
-0.18344992399215698,
-0.6854203343391418,
-0.6726230382919312,
0.6093124747276306,
-0.29869288206100464,
-0.08063054084777832,
0.638528048992157,
0.060196105390787125,
-0.13614746928215027,
0.40000927448272705,
-0.19898827373981476,
0.19711381196975708,
0.5783715844154358,
0.802275538444519,
0.6020796298980713,
-0.5974132418632507,
0.27803581953048706,
-1.0791761875152588,
0.1547274887561798,
-0.6897681951522827,
-0.8506447672843933,
-0.47741496562957764,
-0.5350539684295654,
-0.4439055919647217,
-0.21426604688167572,
0.020584162324666977,
1.0184557437896729,
0.7023518681526184,
-1.3313542604446411,
0.12510961294174194,
-0.3939421474933624,
0.07823629677295685,
-0.40167081356048584,
-0.12584057450294495,
0.9239115715026855,
-0.31133225560188293,
-0.5122314095497131,
0.47856342792510986,
0.48364126682281494,
0.10045551508665085,
0.11909978836774826,
-0.1605340838432312,
-0.7830579280853271,
-0.35833504796028137,
0.409797340631485,
0.34022998809814453,
-0.579991340637207,
-0.25294652581214905,
0.03480873256921768,
-0.22096331417560577,
0.05676313117146492,
1.0108968019485474,
-1.0248082876205444,
0.1309330314397812,
0.8879821300506592,
0.5446026921272278,
0.2605935335159302,
-0.09559398889541626,
0.7817285656929016,
-0.668835461139679,
-0.1534431427717209,
0.5424739122390747,
0.7204289436340332,
0.24515476822853088,
-0.4381290078163147,
0.521639883518219,
0.10546044260263443,
-0.6109664440155029,
-0.6787627935409546,
0.03724084421992302,
-0.9256839156150818,
-0.5345107316970825,
1.090739369392395,
-0.006570116616785526,
-0.11466781795024872,
-0.15480774641036987,
-0.07360029965639114,
0.48455291986465454,
-0.02124641463160515,
1.058578610420227,
0.5804437398910522,
-0.7115898728370667,
0.16189955174922943,
-0.5515998005867004,
0.5549206137657166,
0.38913285732269287,
-0.424234002828598,
-0.01755972020328045,
0.3618873357772827,
0.0298794973641634,
0.36994388699531555,
0.02546965330839157,
-0.021679244935512543,
0.28595808148384094,
-0.3169489800930023,
-0.19022276997566223,
-0.17065586149692535,
-0.3794946074485779,
-0.47796252369880676,
0.4980032742023468,
-0.09868299216032028,
-0.08084844052791595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01622v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01622v3 | TravelPlanner: A Benchmark for Real-World Planning with Language Agents | 2024-02-02T18:39:51 | 2024-06-23T08:50:17 | Jian Xie, Kai Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Tinghui Zhu, Renze Lou, Yuandong Tian, Yanghua Xiao, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Planning has been part of the core pursuit for artificial intelligence since
its conception, but earlier AI agents mostly focused on constrained settings
because many of the cognitive substrates necessary for human-level planning
have been lacking. Recently, language agents powered by large language models
(LLMs) have shown interesting capabilities such as tool use and reasoning. Are
these language agents capable of planning in more complex settings that are out
of the reach of prior AI agents? To advance this investigation, we propose
TravelPlanner, a new planning benchmark that focuses on travel planning, a
common real-world planning scenario. It provides a rich sandbox environment,
various tools for accessing nearly four million data records, and 1,225
meticulously curated planning intents and reference plans. Comprehensive
evaluations show that the current language agents are not yet capable of
handling such complex planning tasks-even GPT-4 only achieves a success rate of
0.6%. Language agents struggle to stay on task, use the right tools to collect
information, or keep track of multiple constraints. However, we note that the
mere possibility for language agents to tackle such a complex problem is in
itself non-trivial progress. TravelPlanner provides a challenging yet
meaningful testbed for future language agents. | [
-0.5338453650474548,
-0.545364499092102,
0.7185365557670593,
0.23429475724697113,
0.24824456870555878,
0.0891764909029007,
-0.1983041912317276,
-0.4029477834701538,
0.028878653421998024,
0.4134543538093567,
-0.8909680247306824,
-0.19694437086582184,
-0.2242463082075119,
-0.030719352886080742,
-0.2228233367204666,
0.5958414077758789,
-0.3499142825603485,
-0.39546141028404236,
-0.3506636917591095,
-0.1082843616604805,
-0.5504847168922424,
-0.670105516910553,
-0.34423691034317017,
-0.4118925929069519,
0.4556322991847992,
0.4330015182495117,
1.0159250497817993,
0.39856353402137756,
0.554757833480835,
0.264181911945343,
0.05252937227487564,
0.299739271402359,
-0.266624391078949,
0.13160081207752228,
-0.24308963119983673,
-0.3291725218296051,
-0.43459129333496094,
-0.09104134142398834,
0.6305521130561829,
0.772582471370697,
-0.11478273570537567,
-0.0847688689827919,
-0.6305190324783325,
0.32384273409843445,
-0.5682671070098877,
0.29583993554115295,
-0.40416795015335083,
0.19838783144950867,
-0.08247994631528854,
0.11484814435243607,
-0.12727883458137512,
-0.3485531806945801,
0.22119556367397308,
-0.7156213521957397,
0.1937030553817749,
0.17396646738052368,
0.6179843544960022,
0.4419046640396118,
-0.3236125409603119,
-0.14879664778709412,
-1.3922476768493652,
0.616773784160614,
-0.33117416501045227,
0.42069512605667114,
0.39472219347953796,
0.7510743737220764,
-0.38902848958969116,
-0.6185402274131775,
-0.8558822870254517,
-0.33584317564964294,
0.09567253291606903,
-0.011083567515015602,
-0.063103586435318,
-0.13404764235019684,
0.3851371109485626,
-0.2061890810728073,
-0.8417580723762512,
-0.09863224625587463,
-0.19504672288894653,
-0.16426578164100647,
0.6186572313308716,
0.2960861027240753,
0.3365618586540222,
0.4255402088165283,
-0.10716361552476883,
-0.3477236330509186,
-0.7858425974845886,
0.056141894310712814,
-0.002206923672929406,
0.16099481284618378,
-0.13401131331920624,
0.5019859075546265,
-0.39769041538238525,
0.4727357029914856,
-0.6791051030158997,
-0.11479026079177856,
0.007869894616305828,
-0.3085392713546753,
-0.04895440861582756,
-0.16262087225914001,
0.3329295814037323,
0.3086695373058319,
0.6541578769683838,
-0.42666542530059814,
-0.2714974284172058,
-0.020106203854084015,
0.31996190547943115,
-0.7897751331329346,
-0.33423829078674316,
0.26873084902763367,
-0.022395893931388855,
0.2312982678413391,
-0.060923416167497635,
-0.5203336477279663,
-0.18981264531612396,
-0.08963149785995483,
0.018342891708016396,
-0.3771059811115265,
-0.22865889966487885,
0.007052849978208542,
-0.026037050411105156,
0.544187068939209,
0.4427146315574646,
-0.43073832988739014,
0.42827337980270386,
0.8944541811943054,
0.8018719553947449,
-0.02532263472676277,
-0.8334759473800659,
-0.4985811710357666,
0.1939043551683426,
-0.3550960123538971,
1.1834882497787476,
-0.5923447608947754,
-0.7109360694885254,
0.2514922022819519,
-0.23173274099826813,
0.027605438604950905,
-0.5155612826347351,
0.5908194780349731,
-0.3992439806461334,
-0.19751954078674316,
-0.3530559241771698,
-0.3705136477947235,
-0.042716484516859055,
0.5894388556480408,
-0.6616067886352539,
0.6759762167930603,
0.196069598197937,
0.10543525218963623,
0.4740777909755707,
-0.48742347955703735,
-0.5834879875183105,
0.10168792307376862,
-0.3952222466468811,
-0.26433834433555603,
-0.23975349962711334,
0.042738765478134155,
0.06753060221672058,
-0.36817222833633423,
0.5081048607826233,
-0.21756508946418762,
-0.5224694013595581,
0.3915628492832184,
-0.2422652542591095,
0.358829140663147,
0.10097341984510422,
-0.20258469879627228,
0.06345433741807938,
-0.515221357345581,
0.10812104493379593,
0.023658258840441704,
-0.4305201470851898,
0.052341703325510025,
0.33104702830314636,
0.1828763484954834,
0.4525829255580902,
0.31041663885116577,
-0.41771170496940613,
0.5965555310249329,
-0.22365546226501465,
0.25325414538383484,
0.6464904546737671,
-0.2786475121974945,
0.5520594120025635,
-0.6890367269515991,
0.8154886960983276,
-0.366716593503952,
0.21836502850055695,
-0.035867199301719666,
-0.3919450342655182,
-0.7146907448768616,
0.24264413118362427,
-0.023857027292251587,
0.5473004579544067,
-0.3786938786506653,
0.395219624042511,
-0.7501987218856812,
-0.6087841391563416,
0.02487388625741005,
-0.2183842808008194,
0.27877575159072876,
0.10964277386665344,
0.3315499722957611,
0.08744215220212936,
-0.15685199201107025,
-0.6291596293449402,
-0.3243522047996521,
-0.1070941612124443,
0.1437550187110901,
0.4123487174510956,
0.5766773223876953,
-0.2256724238395691,
0.9001184701919556,
-0.5818760991096497,
-0.3478577435016632,
-0.5483241677284241,
-0.05003788694739342,
-0.11219920963048935,
0.40440046787261963,
0.39993882179260254,
-0.916041910648346,
-0.2592790126800537,
-0.13006871938705444,
-0.5815268754959106,
0.01796061545610428,
-0.42163994908332825,
-0.1143227219581604,
-0.24758796393871307,
0.5757158398628235,
-0.8311070799827576,
0.2944932281970978,
0.3434056043624878,
-0.5193437933921814,
0.5668012499809265,
-0.3933875262737274,
-0.4430622160434723,
-0.5143045783042908,
0.14614102244377136,
-0.40882766246795654,
-0.31239286065101624,
-0.6813485622406006,
0.07565005868673325,
-0.003497073194012046,
-0.3649556636810303,
-0.39797279238700867,
0.8389585018157959,
-0.37924832105636597,
-0.15797792375087738,
-0.32405415177345276,
0.18387016654014587,
-0.1446201056241989,
0.5691707134246826,
0.06699942797422409,
0.887787938117981,
0.2786625027656555,
-0.5042163729667664,
0.30079248547554016,
0.483657568693161,
-0.12622813880443573,
0.4671516418457031,
-0.37161746621131897,
0.21734197437763214,
-0.060047369450330734,
0.7616389393806458,
-0.37658971548080444,
-0.2813717722892761,
-0.05777132138609886,
-0.019494757056236267,
-0.08630820363759995,
-0.013032115064561367,
-0.35358357429504395,
-0.26913270354270935,
-0.15936164557933807,
0.5095467567443848,
0.5259838104248047,
-0.3032229542732239,
1.0188236236572266,
0.431656152009964,
-0.2347697764635086,
-0.15303564071655273,
-0.6939722299575806,
0.33697324991226196,
0.03552018478512764,
-0.37010154128074646,
0.36971887946128845,
-0.2603583037853241,
-0.48792168498039246,
0.1316097378730774,
-0.33698636293411255,
-0.12943559885025024,
-0.08277131617069244,
0.46753695607185364,
0.057960350066423416,
0.10291601717472076,
-0.06750515848398209,
-0.25028637051582336,
-0.33597245812416077,
0.07494932413101196,
-0.20064246654510498,
0.6523106694221497,
-0.010615197941660881,
-0.4807421565055847,
-0.24035976827144623,
0.4515739381313324,
0.4160017967224121,
-0.3784746527671814,
0.35562223196029663,
0.12479069828987122,
-0.4056360125541687,
-0.3476811945438385,
-0.4972074627876282,
0.29731547832489014,
-0.43182241916656494,
0.17938494682312012,
-0.8000397086143494,
-0.5145166516304016,
0.372470498085022,
-0.45271146297454834,
0.3106200397014618,
0.12348314374685287,
0.20942547917366028,
0.12852028012275696,
0.8171941637992859,
0.6900470852851868,
-0.07503046840429306,
0.343733549118042,
-0.3511832356452942,
0.27409327030181885,
-0.6558082103729248,
-0.15986348688602448,
-0.548510730266571,
-0.47554296255111694,
-0.6037598252296448,
-0.695888102054596,
0.3380469083786011,
-0.33119988441467285,
-0.274652361869812,
0.2791224718093872,
-0.1185196191072464,
0.6951558589935303,
0.7499989867210388,
-0.4755162298679352,
0.3241089880466461,
-0.4739018380641937,
0.13181856274604797,
0.31929072737693787,
-0.4603000283241272,
-0.5451993942260742,
1.0074626207351685,
-0.1547519713640213,
0.6245282292366028,
0.13299310207366943,
0.41954073309898376,
0.24905328452587128,
0.21515993773937225,
-0.5867465138435364,
0.800989031791687,
0.12991343438625336,
-0.4714113175868988,
-0.36978936195373535,
-0.2722723186016083,
-0.945715069770813,
0.21092726290225983,
-0.00822745356708765,
-0.6007996797561646,
0.37684109807014465,
-0.01224183477461338,
-0.3682612180709839,
0.15804775059223175,
-0.5542826652526855,
0.761469841003418,
-0.47301435470581055,
-0.12864011526107788,
-0.22653521597385406,
-0.6275542378425598,
-0.21530407667160034,
-0.10121748596429825,
0.32574859261512756,
-0.5869058966636658,
-0.16373658180236816,
0.42599767446517944,
-0.4717540144920349,
0.43635857105255127,
-0.2360902726650238,
0.24046427011489868,
0.03889095038175583,
0.4706401526927948,
0.8793463706970215,
-0.24687327444553375,
-0.11635584384202957,
-0.03678520768880844,
-0.13141493499279022,
-0.4866618514060974,
-0.42396673560142517,
0.8395074009895325,
-0.7366865873336792,
-0.32930469512939453,
-0.5468255877494812,
-0.8845051527023315,
-0.4681444764137268,
0.38832512497901917,
-0.05381852388381958,
0.3567705452442169,
-0.5838997960090637,
-0.35881873965263367,
0.13528135418891907,
-0.22404134273529053,
0.538236677646637,
0.5435189008712769,
-0.10210485756397247,
-0.03755348548293114,
1.0606896877288818,
0.2374626249074936,
0.15050838887691498,
0.5602729916572571,
0.15356940031051636,
-0.2349344789981842,
-0.783054530620575,
-0.33190155029296875,
0.07712516188621521,
-0.4437609314918518,
0.07813172787427902,
-0.5583868622779846,
-0.18782761693000793,
-0.2815091609954834,
-0.5274849534034729,
-0.4523230195045471,
-0.49469709396362305,
0.4559519588947296,
0.05448395386338234,
-0.20398545265197754,
0.7418063282966614,
0.10189717262983322,
0.2209278792142868,
-0.4070126712322235,
0.19193154573440552,
0.2579305171966553,
0.23283424973487854,
-0.36654889583587646,
0.1443253457546234,
-0.227244570851326,
-0.09651845693588257,
-0.32720962166786194,
-0.364516019821167,
0.40105774998664856,
0.13655737042427063,
0.6746846437454224,
0.274082750082016,
0.3413238823413849,
0.847895085811615,
-0.41411662101745605,
0.7157710790634155,
-0.5826989412307739,
-0.3889986574649811,
0.6759597659111023,
-0.27393367886543274,
0.6908390522003174,
0.6849830150604248,
0.1656457483768463,
-0.49287787079811096,
-0.42157965898513794,
-0.8150553703308105,
-0.8362700939178467,
0.5965347290039062,
0.4412316381931305,
-0.1456308215856552,
0.3551652133464813,
0.15067222714424133,
-0.05818093568086624,
0.27771756052970886,
-0.6304345726966858,
0.05025259405374527,
-0.017286932095885277,
0.22517338395118713,
-0.35007718205451965,
0.006529500707983971,
-0.22923284769058228,
-0.018369432538747787,
0.4314441680908203,
-0.031375542283058167,
0.2481173425912857,
0.31460437178611755,
-0.16752517223358154,
-0.10860548913478851,
0.2439735382795334,
0.8060340881347656,
0.96259605884552,
-0.31503039598464966,
0.2503455579280853,
0.20713020861148834,
-0.4720279276371002,
0.090529665350914,
0.5794644951820374,
-0.4240666329860687,
-0.24983888864517212,
0.6137863993644714,
0.37412139773368835,
-0.12681707739830017,
-1.2757467031478882,
0.3920438587665558,
-0.36854201555252075,
-0.0458654910326004,
-0.7956780791282654,
0.266644686460495,
-0.05397063493728638,
0.27090826630592346,
0.05184965953230858,
0.051533039659261703,
-0.01281597651541233,
-0.5581856369972229,
-0.03158816322684288,
0.3183142840862274,
-0.44534698128700256,
-0.2899740934371948,
0.6870226263999939,
0.419677734375,
-0.8633519411087036,
0.7004145383834839,
-0.6138419508934021,
-0.4216771423816681,
0.633309543132782,
0.4391639530658722,
0.8264232873916626,
-0.03586602956056595,
-0.058149080723524094,
0.05567915365099907,
0.4599117338657379,
-0.11478764563798904,
0.49845418334007263,
-0.16866889595985413,
-0.9504519701004028,
-0.3353451192378998,
-0.4371756315231323,
-0.7261999845504761,
-0.05571018159389496,
-0.07637272775173187,
0.04078025370836258,
-0.412832111120224,
0.17009557783603668,
-0.420034259557724,
0.014491520822048187,
-0.8800437450408936,
0.07263536751270294,
-0.005662231706082821,
1.0728485584259033,
-0.5909067392349243,
0.7328851222991943,
1.0010260343551636,
-0.24427811801433563,
-0.737267017364502,
0.4418394863605499,
0.1906479150056839,
-0.7042508721351624,
0.14799560606479645,
0.37349051237106323,
-0.2670040726661682,
-0.19234894216060638,
-0.10754673182964325,
-0.6811827421188354,
1.1120840311050415,
0.16077229380607605,
-0.6025435924530029,
-0.4434964656829834,
0.4517071545124054,
0.38195928931236267,
-0.17493082582950592,
0.13547281920909882,
0.7957128286361694,
0.5548912286758423,
-0.0045115286484360695,
-0.8652225732803345,
0.15869317948818207,
-0.24761034548282623,
-0.07806135714054108,
0.43543702363967896,
-0.6955519318580627,
0.7375563979148865,
-0.20550663769245148,
-0.15454302728176117,
0.049451448023319244,
0.311635285615921,
0.22902651131153107,
0.3812726140022278,
0.7578991055488586,
0.4424512982368469,
0.6947619318962097,
-0.1588948667049408,
1.174004077911377,
-0.17289716005325317,
0.021494437009096146,
1.1977430582046509,
-0.753459632396698,
0.8284816741943359,
0.16247409582138062,
-0.26872292160987854,
0.3812759816646576,
0.23929134011268616,
0.1998419612646103,
0.607938826084137,
0.16330094635486603,
-0.5147657990455627,
-0.4171835780143738,
-0.2985915243625641,
-0.10897325724363327,
0.5511220097541809,
0.24220779538154602,
0.4483933448791504,
-0.40091472864151,
0.05503237247467041,
0.1510602980852127,
0.022408533841371536,
0.015049740672111511,
0.6781502962112427,
-0.1141287237405777,
-1.0097931623458862,
0.14247238636016846,
-0.3984059989452362,
0.15688937902450562,
-0.6514219045639038,
-0.08973265439271927,
-0.2864580452442169,
0.3765380084514618,
0.2715989351272583,
-0.8605456948280334,
0.3760280907154083,
-0.11316853016614914,
0.32082974910736084,
-0.5016360282897949,
0.7039794325828552,
0.04541107267141342,
-0.45902183651924133,
0.23451106250286102,
0.7702871561050415,
0.14500240981578827,
-0.3827890455722809,
-0.4337118864059448,
0.007159820757806301,
-0.2708635926246643,
-0.3331585228443146,
0.25135380029678345,
0.5225116014480591,
-0.17913754284381866,
1.0866284370422363,
0.8115043044090271,
0.45481571555137634,
-0.11838805675506592,
0.1126493439078331,
0.7969076633453369,
-1.1630083322525024,
-0.7217934131622314,
-0.6643766164779663,
0.18742455542087555,
-0.1539584994316101,
-0.41405290365219116,
0.2863781452178955,
0.8676781058311462,
0.9064173102378845,
0.23892879486083984,
0.9086094498634338,
-0.11995511502027512,
0.3269939720630646,
-0.2909914255142212,
0.22749218344688416,
-0.33027592301368713,
0.34554523229599,
0.17447790503501892,
-0.7993283271789551,
-0.32560959458351135,
0.7162867784500122,
-0.3195214867591858,
-0.1610550582408905,
0.5620930194854736,
0.7827035784721375,
-0.05943930521607399,
-0.15032760798931122,
0.34484657645225525,
0.0048737721517682076,
1.0075173377990723,
0.7518247365951538,
1.122124433517456,
0.16115105152130127,
0.9277414083480835,
-0.4586244225502014,
-0.3142704665660858,
-0.28123998641967773,
-0.6728163957595825,
-0.7818334102630615,
-0.4560968279838562,
0.07083911448717117,
0.17928104102611542,
0.34676727652549744,
1.0257271528244019,
0.753117561340332,
-0.37491241097450256,
-0.3589381277561188,
-0.531333863735199,
0.17019903659820557,
-0.4784466028213501,
-0.12922795116901398,
0.1280992031097412,
-0.021609041839838028,
-0.6277214288711548,
0.6907760500907898,
0.32577070593833923,
0.09525593370199203,
-0.4320744276046753,
-0.1784965693950653,
-0.13511325418949127,
-0.04271753504872322,
0.31559309363365173,
0.5755975842475891,
-0.49435126781463623,
-0.19459299743175507,
-0.09176795929670334,
0.08795533329248428,
-0.1289706528186798,
1.0955218076705933,
-0.8433845639228821,
0.3298717737197876,
0.2995249927043915,
0.39590734243392944,
0.7323628664016724,
0.016250817105174065,
0.7328054308891296,
-0.48857876658439636,
0.35063809156417847,
0.501683235168457,
0.3227694034576416,
0.015964549034833908,
-0.17025220394134521,
0.7309595346450806,
-0.17166931927204132,
-1.000031590461731,
-0.6781750321388245,
0.3320641815662384,
-1.2441643476486206,
-0.2458799034357071,
1.036191701889038,
0.0760328397154808,
-0.0052412948571145535,
-0.3157280385494232,
-0.3269798457622528,
-0.04059409350156784,
-0.47660067677497864,
0.6802006363868713,
0.5176482200622559,
-0.800548791885376,
0.1172332912683487,
-0.8101105093955994,
0.35033857822418213,
0.12105897068977356,
-1.0011467933654785,
0.271623820066452,
0.6293767690658569,
0.011966515332460403,
0.28982415795326233,
1.1893736124038696,
0.4285549521446228,
0.20945210754871368,
0.2033960074186325,
0.011626503430306911,
-0.042360201478004456,
-0.5767003297805786,
0.22578780353069305,
0.09614945948123932,
0.3850839138031006,
-0.043982017785310745
] |
Subsets and Splits