id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04824v1 | Learning Communication Policies for Different Follower Behaviors in a Collaborative Reference Game | 2024-02-07T13:22:17 | 2024-02-07T13:22:17 | Philipp Sadler, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Albrecht and Stone (2018) state that modeling of changing behaviors remains
an open problem "due to the essentially unconstrained nature of what other
agents may do". In this work we evaluate the adaptability of neural artificial
agents towards assumed partner behaviors in a collaborative reference game. In
this game success is achieved when a knowledgeable Guide can verbally lead a
Follower to the selection of a specific puzzle piece among several distractors.
We frame this language grounding and coordination task as a reinforcement
learning problem and measure to which extent a common reinforcement training
algorithm (PPO) is able to produce neural agents (the Guides) that perform well
with various heuristic Follower behaviors that vary along the dimensions of
confidence and autonomy. We experiment with a learning signal that in addition
to the goal condition also respects an assumed communicative effort. Our
results indicate that this novel ingredient leads to communicative strategies
that are less verbose (staying silent in some of the steps) and that with
respect to that the Guide's strategies indeed adapt to the partner's level of
confidence and autonomy. | [
-0.15194104611873627,
-0.5855249762535095,
0.5290130972862244,
0.6211955547332764,
-0.014342337846755981,
-0.055708400905132294,
-0.572665274143219,
-0.27569934725761414,
0.2309798151254654,
0.26063936948776245,
-0.7894942164421082,
-0.2545880675315857,
-0.5118317604064941,
0.27569112181663513,
0.27649030089378357,
1.047558069229126,
-0.06070079654455185,
0.1744324266910553,
-0.08559123426675797,
-0.2305741161108017,
-0.8504477739334106,
-0.5252401232719421,
-0.8288235664367676,
-0.912312924861908,
0.5106525421142578,
0.5740472674369812,
0.7143725752830505,
0.4344640076160431,
0.20619899034500122,
0.4861905574798584,
-0.27201372385025024,
0.02148493006825447,
-0.7540923357009888,
0.47962483763694763,
-0.45716536045074463,
-0.5946516990661621,
-0.2685397267341614,
0.23122601211071014,
0.465782105922699,
0.7566778659820557,
-0.3095591962337494,
-0.2979222238063812,
0.1391701102256775,
0.7032038569450378,
-0.341156542301178,
0.49689942598342896,
-0.7021012306213379,
-0.0578007698059082,
0.5373777747154236,
-0.23487715423107147,
-0.46988818049430847,
0.02897275611758232,
0.5432184934616089,
-1.2121585607528687,
0.026990611106157303,
0.011970953084528446,
0.6427857875823975,
0.3361414074897766,
-0.14806397259235382,
-0.8240814805030823,
-0.842704176902771,
0.7105562090873718,
-0.17958080768585205,
0.23922772705554962,
0.5477752089500427,
0.23466834425926208,
-0.636121928691864,
-0.4853588938713074,
-0.2889317274093628,
-0.37256184220314026,
0.1204783171415329,
0.3251473605632782,
-0.14801788330078125,
0.05445866659283638,
-0.018952330574393272,
-0.10333151370286942,
-0.10004851222038269,
-0.20323587954044342,
-0.08576194941997528,
-0.0033805877901613712,
0.46465229988098145,
-0.017699697986245155,
0.15872512757778168,
0.04763355478644371,
-0.19884993135929108,
-0.15850205719470978,
-0.1889125108718872,
0.2471632957458496,
0.354247123003006,
0.11173330247402191,
-0.4798519015312195,
-0.047502465546131134,
-0.2402282953262329,
0.32985955476760864,
0.7650134563446045,
0.23606644570827484,
0.049829449504613876,
-0.38755518198013306,
-0.04786679521203041,
0.12239709496498108,
0.5493719577789307,
0.47355663776397705,
0.6032843589782715,
-0.47860780358314514,
-0.014415938407182693,
-0.0873095691204071,
0.5108675956726074,
-0.42665812373161316,
-0.563154935836792,
-0.1801534742116928,
-0.5594478845596313,
-0.13218563795089722,
-0.10320795327425003,
-0.2636008560657501,
-0.21644331514835358,
-0.17988786101341248,
0.34017446637153625,
-0.5082944631576538,
-0.3604118227958679,
-0.05158353969454765,
-0.31804361939430237,
0.2072143852710724,
0.5363434553146362,
-1.1237492561340332,
0.6039232015609741,
0.6224633455276489,
0.7925059199333191,
-0.19719676673412323,
-0.6006373167037964,
-0.6563464403152466,
-0.002359459176659584,
-0.5573536157608032,
0.4481642544269562,
-0.3871155083179474,
-0.6235643029212952,
-0.3206983208656311,
0.13846227526664734,
-0.27761396765708923,
-0.506791353225708,
0.2795185148715973,
-0.5087549090385437,
-0.0028269211761653423,
-0.5731932520866394,
-0.31801193952560425,
-0.13739949464797974,
0.3716210424900055,
-0.61451256275177,
0.2575604319572449,
0.21281276643276215,
-0.36825570464134216,
0.15902818739414215,
-0.3317835032939911,
-0.21886399388313293,
0.011459218338131905,
-0.2661809027194977,
-0.2824011445045471,
0.00153706397395581,
-0.24611349403858185,
0.06940019875764847,
-0.013308978639543056,
-0.12557925283908844,
-0.2153180092573166,
-0.6080359816551208,
0.4039178192615509,
0.014746123924851418,
0.7615147233009338,
-0.15468813478946686,
-0.19194935262203217,
0.5106946229934692,
-0.5144778490066528,
0.06829284876585007,
0.0022681565023958683,
-0.585323691368103,
-0.4303745627403259,
0.3556506335735321,
-0.3976263105869293,
0.1579982489347458,
-0.0210976954549551,
-0.0715457946062088,
0.07220615446567535,
-0.19977782666683197,
0.21712711453437805,
0.9551977515220642,
0.47054436802864075,
0.7886185646057129,
-0.708561360836029,
0.25616323947906494,
-0.2905438244342804,
0.17939652502536774,
0.1515221744775772,
-0.41808757185935974,
-0.8918114304542542,
0.041537754237651825,
-0.08432970196008682,
0.3871583044528961,
-1.032720685005188,
0.44782084226608276,
-0.14488600194454193,
-0.283542275428772,
-0.1124543845653534,
0.1613476574420929,
0.6493896842002869,
0.28091251850128174,
0.17517080903053284,
-0.5991931557655334,
-0.5242806673049927,
-0.316163569688797,
0.12457537651062012,
-0.49661532044410706,
0.2789923846721649,
0.4925694167613983,
0.514119565486908,
0.2367023527622223,
0.3359755873680115,
-0.020832721143960953,
-0.21459999680519104,
-0.1634196937084198,
0.3626975119113922,
0.12734059989452362,
0.6362624168395996,
0.4546392560005188,
-0.8883652687072754,
-0.7877615094184875,
-0.022929027676582336,
-0.9646233320236206,
0.11515185236930847,
-0.27480369806289673,
-0.04608212783932686,
-0.04277242347598076,
0.6977506875991821,
-0.20311419665813446,
0.14311867952346802,
0.6814471483230591,
-0.6183093786239624,
0.6675166487693787,
-0.5551332235336304,
0.0820455476641655,
-0.800251841545105,
-0.40043389797210693,
-0.058443501591682434,
-0.17417627573013306,
-0.7403797507286072,
0.08014224469661713,
-0.48983627557754517,
0.5367490649223328,
-0.10537765920162201,
-0.014739666134119034,
-0.7615207433700562,
-0.13805711269378662,
-0.5233708024024963,
0.01990535669028759,
-0.36667126417160034,
0.8468589782714844,
0.3163415789604187,
0.8212611675262451,
0.45914512872695923,
-0.8956143856048584,
0.384492963552475,
0.5889173150062561,
0.02733558975160122,
0.9881502985954285,
-0.8029298186302185,
0.49586591124534607,
-0.007933100685477257,
0.2846696376800537,
-0.5415539145469666,
0.09774170070886612,
0.4892117977142334,
-0.7134749889373779,
-0.20801487565040588,
-0.2550925612449646,
-0.22019068896770477,
0.23423121869564056,
-0.017923273146152496,
-0.003200509352609515,
0.45122918486595154,
-0.2296411544084549,
0.6302081346511841,
0.07369154691696167,
0.02241492085158825,
-0.2658725678920746,
-0.2513291835784912,
-0.017410172149538994,
0.11446079611778259,
-0.40511173009872437,
0.4756172001361847,
-0.5825803875923157,
-0.37172791361808777,
0.15342220664024353,
-0.09580348432064056,
-0.31632551550865173,
0.3980858325958252,
0.6193090081214905,
0.01813901960849762,
-0.02990989200770855,
-0.047403734177351,
-0.4222281277179718,
-0.08395282179117203,
0.2846222519874573,
-0.22524958848953247,
0.6016285419464111,
-0.31247520446777344,
-0.02640700526535511,
-0.2129090130329132,
0.2688111960887909,
0.25283902883529663,
0.11887646466493607,
0.7706977128982544,
0.3942829370498657,
-0.0415557399392128,
-0.35277262330055237,
-0.004110499285161495,
-0.2485617995262146,
-0.48331284523010254,
0.33073925971984863,
-0.44262346625328064,
-0.4118070602416992,
0.6038868427276611,
-0.12918883562088013,
-0.2450476735830307,
-0.22917047142982483,
0.39597809314727783,
-0.09199103713035583,
0.6485899090766907,
0.95101398229599,
0.11273908615112305,
0.6121999621391296,
-0.09111172705888748,
-0.43432796001434326,
-0.8900520205497742,
-0.29076358675956726,
-0.4182932674884796,
-0.31182292103767395,
-0.7871500849723816,
-0.32519447803497314,
0.2806365489959717,
0.28848543763160706,
-0.1482233703136444,
0.5183216333389282,
-0.36708584427833557,
0.39071688055992126,
0.881224513053894,
0.29736605286598206,
0.33300426602363586,
-0.2536543011665344,
-0.3968476355075836,
-0.08198843151330948,
-0.7289916276931763,
-0.2357393503189087,
0.7385324835777283,
-0.034635964781045914,
0.5332586765289307,
0.3504524827003479,
0.7254683375358582,
0.10996367782354355,
0.2979198098182678,
-0.7230370044708252,
0.49279123544692993,
0.12206390500068665,
-0.32359182834625244,
-0.2817841172218323,
-0.373252272605896,
-1.0250256061553955,
0.15767446160316467,
-0.5628818273544312,
-0.8397996425628662,
0.2873971164226532,
0.02524087019264698,
-0.14578703045845032,
-0.15211930871009827,
-0.6865493655204773,
0.5878275632858276,
-0.00515453377738595,
-0.6089890003204346,
-0.30319201946258545,
-0.6914790868759155,
-0.23408348858356476,
-0.006460497621446848,
-0.09540368616580963,
0.1288769692182541,
0.0016782653983682394,
0.6065623164176941,
0.007903692312538624,
0.8261510729789734,
-0.1565869003534317,
0.28159743547439575,
0.3656790852546692,
0.15082406997680664,
0.6500334143638611,
-0.024624314159154892,
-0.30909186601638794,
-0.20653218030929565,
-0.10203788429498672,
-0.3113836944103241,
-0.7166644930839539,
0.5726673603057861,
-1.0322881937026978,
-0.5516349077224731,
-0.5129748582839966,
-0.8079921007156372,
-0.2693306505680084,
0.32625269889831543,
0.1349550038576126,
-0.2094227373600006,
-0.5529170632362366,
0.44879692792892456,
0.6103113889694214,
-0.04585518687963486,
0.659492015838623,
0.9639396667480469,
0.21500100195407867,
-0.550514817237854,
0.825667142868042,
-0.01738819107413292,
0.4736025929450989,
0.09747935086488724,
0.19972580671310425,
0.20468296110630035,
-0.7219202518463135,
-0.11870072036981583,
0.06529543548822403,
-0.5862912535667419,
0.35768765211105347,
0.021691573783755302,
-0.059216152876615524,
-0.038478828966617584,
-0.26496613025665283,
-0.08831100910902023,
0.17915180325508118,
-0.38462328910827637,
0.20896285772323608,
-0.09160962700843811,
0.916326642036438,
-0.12729322910308838,
0.5849187970161438,
-0.5141764879226685,
0.03153644874691963,
0.4076283872127533,
0.21421946585178375,
-0.12041455507278442,
-0.29308730363845825,
-0.124791219830513,
0.06763908267021179,
-0.36546772718429565,
-1.032158613204956,
0.03307994082570076,
0.001305564772337675,
0.7209402322769165,
-0.02016519010066986,
0.19249248504638672,
0.4602355360984802,
-0.30994755029678345,
0.41388872265815735,
0.25437137484550476,
-0.8728257417678833,
0.07045631855726242,
-0.6185145378112793,
0.2741113305091858,
0.5607664585113525,
0.29975074529647827,
-0.6582872271537781,
-0.014582266099750996,
-0.8440861701965332,
-0.32443416118621826,
0.7488479614257812,
0.5015162825584412,
0.106327585875988,
0.18453069031238556,
0.490854948759079,
-0.19059106707572937,
0.3361889719963074,
-0.7153688073158264,
-0.29249686002731323,
-0.0539528988301754,
0.018787067383527756,
-0.04870431125164032,
0.09812810271978378,
-0.2893922030925751,
0.09496459364891052,
0.47362762689590454,
-0.2057018280029297,
0.3947484791278839,
0.46486130356788635,
-0.04856211692094803,
-0.3719537556171417,
0.09570017457008362,
0.5370252132415771,
0.45584097504615784,
-0.27836841344833374,
-0.06180078163743019,
0.08131521940231323,
-0.4061618149280548,
0.1733427196741104,
0.03420158103108406,
-0.388278990983963,
-0.1869460940361023,
0.4550691246986389,
0.8203275203704834,
0.29702121019363403,
-0.21211324632167816,
0.5456477403640747,
-0.10669215023517609,
-0.5851401090621948,
-0.4944433569908142,
0.450788676738739,
0.15275728702545166,
0.4930983781814575,
0.21276886761188507,
0.487128347158432,
-0.2433224320411682,
-0.8044963479042053,
0.39938268065452576,
0.4150281846523285,
-0.8100371360778809,
-0.6531374454498291,
0.2959011197090149,
0.5153321623802185,
-0.8461390733718872,
0.3587293028831482,
-0.5895311832427979,
-0.4254823625087738,
0.6155782341957092,
0.6609142422676086,
0.5910894870758057,
-0.1259142905473709,
0.3981943428516388,
0.021217746660113335,
0.32822704315185547,
-0.22209817171096802,
0.10227666050195694,
-0.19136151671409607,
-1.1342918872833252,
-0.2882744371891022,
0.21545569598674774,
-0.6453976035118103,
-0.0035305500496178865,
-0.5977300405502319,
-0.007054598536342382,
-0.7722241878509521,
-0.041795145720243454,
0.04302958771586418,
0.05766720697283745,
-0.41620728373527527,
-0.07432670891284943,
-0.04889076203107834,
0.5164378881454468,
-0.5182583332061768,
0.6905503869056702,
0.9393139481544495,
-0.6929841041564941,
-0.9114668369293213,
0.22227762639522552,
0.015160520561039448,
-0.6946043372154236,
0.6291598677635193,
-0.17368395626544952,
-0.3133630156517029,
0.06817197799682617,
-0.6674942374229431,
-0.5981280207633972,
1.012852668762207,
0.2014913707971573,
-0.2495991289615631,
-0.4151713252067566,
-0.3309618830680847,
0.6469807028770447,
-0.4500160217285156,
0.20064899325370789,
0.17298774421215057,
0.29863521456718445,
0.3249009847640991,
-1.17427396774292,
0.0820123627781868,
-0.24672669172286987,
-0.28499284386634827,
-0.22355212271213531,
-1.0752557516098022,
0.8664920926094055,
-0.20388926565647125,
-0.02804369479417801,
0.2857724130153656,
0.6916228532791138,
0.2651016414165497,
0.3537638187408447,
0.822486937046051,
0.0013814300764352083,
0.6253038048744202,
-0.024191681295633316,
0.4822327792644501,
-0.21961575746536255,
0.1125200018286705,
1.4164197444915771,
-0.3574965298175812,
0.6305750012397766,
0.5913577675819397,
0.23014192283153534,
0.8735946416854858,
0.05932280793786049,
0.025207623839378357,
0.6020234227180481,
0.25755006074905396,
-0.10000372678041458,
-0.2313641905784607,
-0.29938387870788574,
0.17064914107322693,
0.5683578848838806,
0.29021984338760376,
-0.38591793179512024,
-0.1848861128091812,
-0.20370398461818695,
-0.04963204264640808,
0.695293664932251,
-0.30060112476348877,
1.0145453214645386,
0.10609396547079086,
-1.194337010383606,
0.6035125255584717,
-0.22969061136245728,
0.5789211392402649,
-0.511685311794281,
-0.4155633747577667,
0.135738343000412,
0.3840526342391968,
0.011657155118882656,
-0.4221758544445038,
0.14203804731369019,
-0.45193469524383545,
-0.1901887059211731,
-0.37476617097854614,
0.5472134351730347,
-0.3098321855068207,
0.28015658259391785,
0.6047526597976685,
0.6598007082939148,
-0.09917211532592773,
-0.08326160162687302,
-0.8436513543128967,
0.08862322568893433,
0.04064501076936722,
0.06741584092378616,
0.252882182598114,
0.31410884857177734,
0.017595021054148674,
0.8549252152442932,
0.5865946412086487,
0.267914354801178,
-0.12228291481733322,
-0.2884359061717987,
0.7586055994033813,
-0.43885114789009094,
-0.6082345843315125,
-0.3262198865413666,
0.25597429275512695,
-0.23985105752944946,
-0.3888249695301056,
0.7808430194854736,
0.01071572583168745,
0.9094796776771545,
-0.025105435401201248,
0.5453439950942993,
-0.07570943981409073,
0.004516337998211384,
-0.439573734998703,
0.3812447488307953,
0.09205123782157898,
0.11324518918991089,
-0.2077580690383911,
-0.6996089816093445,
0.2560464143753052,
0.8523421883583069,
-0.26844921708106995,
0.05318045616149902,
0.8607292771339417,
0.4952578842639923,
0.3167489171028137,
0.058106955140829086,
0.2978115975856781,
0.022174563258886337,
0.182461678981781,
0.892850935459137,
0.7593621611595154,
-0.35845857858657837,
0.8330867290496826,
-0.2942506968975067,
-0.23220153152942657,
-0.1009988933801651,
-0.7805694937705994,
-1.0135877132415771,
-0.7653381824493408,
-0.20152327418327332,
-0.6402351260185242,
0.6261500120162964,
1.1979899406433105,
0.9874348044395447,
-0.4702863395214081,
-0.4003826677799225,
-0.6929264068603516,
0.2221880555152893,
-0.7406617999076843,
-0.13322612643241882,
-0.18938815593719482,
-0.29262545704841614,
-0.8034060001373291,
0.5194541215896606,
-0.12342171370983124,
0.133809432387352,
0.04995293915271759,
-0.7691276669502258,
-0.3456125259399414,
0.02658686414361,
0.10394890606403351,
0.5400846004486084,
-0.3158244490623474,
-0.3966469466686249,
0.2219812124967575,
-0.1489289104938507,
0.02803146466612816,
0.719588041305542,
-0.4611596167087555,
0.44528263807296753,
0.2777567207813263,
0.31316474080085754,
0.4144079387187958,
0.06808239966630936,
0.8665110468864441,
-0.8362120985984802,
0.33428114652633667,
0.1751980185508728,
0.04248029738664627,
0.2472832351922989,
-0.3200770616531372,
0.49388623237609863,
0.40171170234680176,
-0.7543049454689026,
-0.24775011837482452,
0.2921602129936218,
-0.9664149880409241,
-0.15233860909938812,
1.2316547632217407,
-0.45367902517318726,
-0.39855727553367615,
-0.30904045701026917,
-0.18843437731266022,
0.4038616716861725,
-0.6346824169158936,
0.7195104956626892,
0.8927635550498962,
-0.11487124860286713,
-0.18071869015693665,
-0.34457284212112427,
0.7065813541412354,
0.622458279132843,
-0.592177152633667,
-0.19778603315353394,
0.4341803193092346,
0.48944762349128723,
0.46020710468292236,
0.8428636789321899,
0.5368470549583435,
0.5279226899147034,
0.2049051970243454,
-0.14001566171646118,
-0.18611617386341095,
-0.3028425872325897,
-0.2013518065214157,
-0.14560528099536896,
0.4324894845485687,
-0.43063515424728394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04812v1 | Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis for Open-Ended HR Survey Responses | 2024-02-07T13:01:43 | 2024-02-07T13:01:43 | Lois Rink, Job Meijdam, David Graus | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding preferences, opinions, and sentiment of the workforce is
paramount for effective employee lifecycle management. Open-ended survey
responses serve as a valuable source of information. This paper proposes a
machine learning approach for aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) of Dutch
open-ended responses in employee satisfaction surveys. Our approach aims to
overcome the inherent noise and variability in these responses, enabling a
comprehensive analysis of sentiments that can support employee lifecycle
management. Through response clustering we identify six key aspects (salary,
schedule, contact, communication, personal attention, agreements), which we
validate by domain experts. We compile a dataset of 1,458 Dutch survey
responses, revealing label imbalance in aspects and sentiments. We propose
few-shot approaches for ABSA based on Dutch BERT models, and compare them
against bag-of-words and zero-shot baselines. Our work significantly
contributes to the field of ABSA by demonstrating the first successful
application of Dutch pre-trained language models to aspect-based sentiment
analysis in the domain of human resources (HR). | [
-0.6623813509941101,
-0.6804550886154175,
0.23146161437034607,
0.3523457944393158,
-0.45515182614326477,
-0.1265462338924408,
-0.10649462789297104,
-0.6414262056350708,
0.5168980956077576,
0.653098464012146,
-0.8796635270118713,
-0.5153771638870239,
-0.2724219858646393,
0.1451287567615509,
0.09862600266933441,
1.136038064956665,
0.00572846457362175,
0.23502960801124573,
-0.588112473487854,
-0.6725981831550598,
-0.13749319314956665,
-0.7227720022201538,
-0.29410451650619507,
-0.4728893041610718,
0.5530306100845337,
0.4456577003002167,
0.2714691758155823,
-0.14650516211986542,
0.44484204053878784,
0.18837232887744904,
-0.2704507112503052,
0.10417740792036057,
-0.24657563865184784,
0.5202765464782715,
-0.07351221144199371,
-0.46484121680259705,
-0.6095090508460999,
-0.021724827587604523,
0.06132712587714195,
0.9866965413093567,
-0.06301682442426682,
0.41549360752105713,
0.3913404643535614,
0.9352635741233826,
-0.6531817317008972,
0.4423258304595947,
-0.4017181098461151,
0.2890776991844177,
0.1437063217163086,
0.13680149614810944,
-0.13027019798755646,
-0.3903803825378418,
0.19582080841064453,
-0.21871338784694672,
0.23002539575099945,
-0.17302276194095612,
0.5333155989646912,
0.11639253050088882,
0.09272215515375137,
-0.33544543385505676,
-0.7251807451248169,
1.0806161165237427,
-0.794894814491272,
0.1956043541431427,
0.332965224981308,
-0.04035520181059837,
0.15553048253059387,
0.08413499593734741,
-0.582556426525116,
0.1652616262435913,
-0.04013058543205261,
0.4466235637664795,
-0.04987769573926926,
0.03679954633116722,
-0.24222292006015778,
0.4892585873603821,
-0.49176523089408875,
0.29577210545539856,
-0.17579644918441772,
0.3046550750732422,
0.5910875201225281,
0.19303596019744873,
-0.19126668572425842,
-0.20109517872333527,
-0.08089442551136017,
-0.16411367058753967,
-0.38076335191726685,
0.3104088604450226,
0.4919244349002838,
0.4446137547492981,
-0.06268065422773361,
0.6857459545135498,
-0.4691113233566284,
0.6120025515556335,
-0.033772122114896774,
0.12468844652175903,
0.377227246761322,
0.13020844757556915,
-0.32485678791999817,
-0.15280964970588684,
0.7045176029205322,
0.18321141600608826,
-0.12509380280971527,
-0.17673394083976746,
-0.33709487318992615,
-0.04183579236268997,
0.6315110325813293,
-0.5095884799957275,
-0.1693670004606247,
0.731645941734314,
-0.6627160906791687,
-0.30415260791778564,
0.27591800689697266,
-0.8184322714805603,
-0.40223968029022217,
-0.5287721157073975,
0.07778716087341309,
-0.27536964416503906,
-0.3244019150733948,
-0.17722608149051666,
0.23806534707546234,
0.3732859492301941,
0.3314710855484009,
-0.26652878522872925,
-0.33619511127471924,
0.9087276458740234,
0.5650110244750977,
-0.2431497722864151,
0.024129047989845276,
-0.2094847857952118,
-0.38481375575065613,
-0.38459542393684387,
0.7807345390319824,
-0.5616971254348755,
-0.5452115535736084,
0.3024784028530121,
-0.28498029708862305,
0.27554258704185486,
-0.7041569352149963,
0.36979296803474426,
-0.5605922341346741,
0.687466561794281,
-0.10818914324045181,
-0.3479684293270111,
-0.5914391875267029,
0.7691280841827393,
-0.3974224627017975,
1.002630591392517,
0.47482091188430786,
-0.740954577922821,
0.5870973467826843,
-0.9064507484436035,
-0.24685952067375183,
-0.14684268832206726,
-0.23216968774795532,
-0.9643954634666443,
0.6860145926475525,
0.4258880913257599,
0.49786433577537537,
0.1948450803756714,
-0.18968944251537323,
-0.5847275257110596,
0.21898150444030762,
0.5812888741493225,
0.02850496768951416,
0.722076952457428,
0.23627173900604248,
0.11194361746311188,
0.3397778868675232,
-0.5791124105453491,
0.10452532768249512,
-0.34196245670318604,
-0.3312584459781647,
-0.620257556438446,
0.030590806156396866,
-0.020997893065214157,
0.4832444190979004,
0.3523324429988861,
-0.913264274597168,
0.1596355140209198,
-0.5533447861671448,
-0.09010803699493408,
0.7021875381469727,
0.26721423864364624,
0.20829223096370697,
-0.06063584238290787,
0.6616888642311096,
0.5461744070053101,
0.41055139899253845,
0.04520512372255325,
-0.47098392248153687,
-0.640729546546936,
-0.20400738716125488,
0.005545138381421566,
0.4354105591773987,
-0.6936274766921997,
0.9646864533424377,
-0.2986334562301636,
-0.49974802136421204,
-0.6409019231796265,
0.186110258102417,
0.24178454279899597,
0.5975441932678223,
0.3215148150920868,
-0.7658333778381348,
-0.6207350492477417,
-0.9140889644622803,
-0.2666504681110382,
-0.7053871154785156,
-0.17346687614917755,
0.24393169581890106,
0.4865178167819977,
-0.036540813744068146,
1.567175030708313,
-0.29982414841651917,
-0.36157897114753723,
-0.4228111505508423,
0.5918340682983398,
0.5000635385513306,
0.21541161835193634,
0.328363835811615,
-0.7254998683929443,
-0.18369847536087036,
0.026229415088891983,
-0.8211892247200012,
0.0077242436818778515,
0.17646567523479462,
0.06047839671373367,
0.3971434533596039,
-0.22444137930870056,
-0.11078406125307083,
0.4620393216609955,
0.4873736798763275,
-0.22851336002349854,
0.49465620517730713,
0.11766454577445984,
0.09807585179805756,
-1.0655945539474487,
0.09721466898918152,
0.30770784616470337,
-0.1921115666627884,
-0.34472155570983887,
-0.09409945458173752,
-0.31299006938934326,
-0.13941466808319092,
-0.6618371605873108,
0.28186100721359253,
-0.13400223851203918,
-0.2993505597114563,
-0.5857157707214355,
-0.3971717953681946,
-0.20912782847881317,
0.7389576435089111,
0.34646207094192505,
0.43740662932395935,
0.14718304574489594,
-0.6151565909385681,
0.2501630187034607,
0.6035380959510803,
-0.38482484221458435,
1.1464104652404785,
-0.47955894470214844,
0.2660636305809021,
-0.44110774993896484,
0.20311987400054932,
-0.7664344906806946,
-0.17357312142848969,
0.19201385974884033,
-0.7531745433807373,
-0.028914235532283783,
0.005090877879410982,
-0.0678422749042511,
-0.5993736386299133,
-0.5822347402572632,
0.0620010644197464,
0.5558772683143616,
-0.2496837079524994,
0.8550645709037781,
0.3634341061115265,
-0.44960135221481323,
-0.719771146774292,
-0.6888861656188965,
-0.18878065049648285,
-0.26312655210494995,
-0.30495119094848633,
0.07680700719356537,
0.28466299176216125,
-0.4058045446872711,
0.18241339921951294,
-0.35072943568229675,
-0.48429402709007263,
-0.14164353907108307,
0.4299938380718231,
0.3090180456638336,
-0.031085876747965813,
-0.36489254236221313,
-0.19540292024612427,
-0.029413288459181786,
0.22887234389781952,
-0.045519039034843445,
0.43178701400756836,
-0.11358242481946945,
-0.3364470601081848,
-0.3457447588443756,
0.45284304022789,
0.4419412314891815,
-0.12059725075960159,
0.9186515808105469,
0.5703985095024109,
-0.2928885817527771,
0.055023498833179474,
-0.4427327513694763,
-0.3295804262161255,
-0.34076130390167236,
0.5086248517036438,
-0.051741741597652435,
-0.712975800037384,
0.7137088775634766,
0.10755858570337296,
0.6092829704284668,
0.4997108280658722,
0.7188189625740051,
-0.5409002304077148,
0.7570101022720337,
1.051127552986145,
-0.5387687683105469,
0.599898099899292,
-0.19797192513942719,
0.22210383415222168,
-0.699773907661438,
-0.31609734892845154,
-0.6578031182289124,
-0.41784295439720154,
-0.30493661761283875,
-0.00031755611416883767,
0.8142356872558594,
0.22706006467342377,
-0.22289499640464783,
-0.016879918053746223,
-0.48486074805259705,
-0.015393247827887535,
0.6152706742286682,
0.2621743083000183,
0.04368527606129646,
-0.008749726228415966,
0.18905670940876007,
0.0947769433259964,
-0.3510933518409729,
-0.4419271945953369,
0.7244239449501038,
0.515474259853363,
0.6957518458366394,
-0.05149993672966957,
0.8419163227081299,
0.31944116950035095,
0.5448620915412903,
-0.739440381526947,
0.23874926567077637,
-0.10931345820426941,
-0.2992416322231293,
-0.43006691336631775,
-0.3503551781177521,
-0.669831395149231,
0.2188580334186554,
-0.19672468304634094,
-0.76279217004776,
0.3226848840713501,
0.12472845613956451,
-0.3041725754737854,
0.32338470220565796,
-0.2006262242794037,
0.5438724756240845,
0.0005485003930516541,
-0.20831525325775146,
-0.11357328295707703,
-0.6320858597755432,
0.22875386476516724,
-0.19217395782470703,
0.3021438717842102,
-0.14269350469112396,
0.1769707053899765,
1.0008628368377686,
-0.6704597473144531,
1.198451280593872,
-0.5176845192909241,
-0.13734158873558044,
0.35608917474746704,
-0.16207867860794067,
0.465451717376709,
-0.092551589012146,
-0.3371703028678894,
0.48094749450683594,
-0.16336573660373688,
-0.40279364585876465,
-0.45368534326553345,
0.30393365025520325,
-0.8285703659057617,
-0.06528809666633606,
-0.3933885097503662,
-0.28396981954574585,
-0.6774947643280029,
-0.08173973858356476,
0.22736428678035736,
-0.029064305126667023,
-0.24818876385688782,
0.32258886098861694,
0.542079508304596,
-0.437841534614563,
0.4238162040710449,
0.627608597278595,
-0.1865820735692978,
-0.3493613004684448,
0.6291335225105286,
0.09059330821037292,
-0.1902705430984497,
0.28863584995269775,
0.05800207331776619,
-0.489493727684021,
-0.14807622134685516,
-0.30840468406677246,
-0.031231550499796867,
-0.4362648129463196,
-0.4291485548019409,
-0.5066396594047546,
0.2102183848619461,
-0.44603556394577026,
-0.1307031810283661,
-0.38796231150627136,
-0.18302913010120392,
-0.18154537677764893,
-0.04916094243526459,
0.39794424176216125,
0.6643032431602478,
-0.06761656701564789,
0.3792363703250885,
-0.7216644287109375,
0.20199474692344666,
0.2455427199602127,
0.41245201230049133,
-0.10002194344997406,
-0.16711823642253876,
-0.3959718644618988,
-0.053569380193948746,
-0.5312026143074036,
-0.8676468133926392,
0.523158073425293,
0.02014515921473503,
0.4136565029621124,
0.45069652795791626,
0.21969109773635864,
0.22268545627593994,
0.0934591069817543,
1.3486578464508057,
0.3146507143974304,
-0.6952764391899109,
0.5799426436424255,
-0.2736190855503082,
0.05659257248044014,
0.6738014221191406,
0.31725960969924927,
-0.6318619847297668,
-0.5081347227096558,
-0.5818741321563721,
-1.1403700113296509,
0.7327021956443787,
0.06379345059394836,
0.08875218778848648,
0.11426650732755661,
0.2758888006210327,
0.49399280548095703,
0.4290502071380615,
-0.6362726092338562,
-0.2880425453186035,
-0.21599015593528748,
-0.40750300884246826,
0.26780349016189575,
-0.37025001645088196,
0.012375117279589176,
-0.0911921039223671,
0.9198395609855652,
-0.08834802359342575,
0.4039359986782074,
-0.12280166894197464,
0.036503683775663376,
-0.22253534197807312,
0.6438184976577759,
0.11009684950113297,
0.8886821866035461,
-0.38790979981422424,
-0.17112930119037628,
0.2790530323982239,
-0.18121640384197235,
0.011947046034038067,
-0.15682494640350342,
-0.051705747842788696,
0.1008596196770668,
0.1460236757993698,
0.5822335481643677,
-0.3396110236644745,
-0.3646986186504364,
0.6529544591903687,
0.32362762093544006,
-0.1300637573003769,
-0.4416605830192566,
-0.17278370261192322,
-0.3102283775806427,
-0.062955841422081,
0.5378668308258057,
-0.1380694955587387,
-0.11183245480060577,
-0.4018341600894928,
0.12412558495998383,
0.4407230615615845,
-0.9864835143089294,
-0.3381226658821106,
0.337872713804245,
0.15842102468013763,
0.06592199206352234,
0.7086200714111328,
-0.10344931483268738,
-0.4556141197681427,
0.33528679609298706,
0.04933033138513565,
1.1991325616836548,
-0.38423091173171997,
0.20729179680347443,
-0.040335413068532944,
0.06189389154314995,
0.2302250862121582,
0.711418867111206,
0.13043099641799927,
-0.5349236130714417,
-0.5941401124000549,
-0.8491597175598145,
-0.8467232584953308,
0.2310442328453064,
-1.126699686050415,
-0.13243171572685242,
-0.1319006085395813,
0.023429792374372482,
-0.2789405882358551,
-0.31732651591300964,
-0.9572831988334656,
0.4224194586277008,
-0.04349236190319061,
0.4773571491241455,
-1.089301347732544,
0.509807288646698,
1.1298904418945312,
-0.7956467270851135,
-0.2102348953485489,
0.03395737335085869,
-0.20582710206508636,
-0.7008758187294006,
0.450284868478775,
0.09785765409469604,
0.06377826631069183,
-0.610314130783081,
-0.5773993730545044,
-0.24828310310840607,
0.4476451277732849,
-0.04374260827898979,
-0.20920246839523315,
0.11186614632606506,
0.31815361976623535,
0.5770496129989624,
-0.2573074698448181,
0.3975425362586975,
0.3390510678291321,
0.2902959883213043,
-0.4047110378742218,
-0.7349278330802917,
-0.5234107971191406,
0.06603381037712097,
0.015952128916978836,
0.06285836547613144,
-0.3715972900390625,
0.6991655826568604,
0.40832215547561646,
0.29730144143104553,
-0.23161928355693817,
1.3215476274490356,
0.2323007583618164,
0.3713281750679016,
0.8088088631629944,
0.5707152485847473,
0.5052173137664795,
-0.021211136132478714,
0.7227837443351746,
-0.47222623229026794,
0.6747018694877625,
0.7660402059555054,
-0.23532967269420624,
1.0429338216781616,
0.47371774911880493,
-0.4883824288845062,
0.8948929905891418,
0.6626483798027039,
0.42906057834625244,
0.34877634048461914,
0.1940607726573944,
-0.4538728892803192,
-0.174556702375412,
-0.188157856464386,
-0.15519852936267853,
0.4838162958621979,
0.4712759256362915,
-0.19573092460632324,
-0.3975948691368103,
0.4575214087963104,
-0.3459315598011017,
-0.014437464065849781,
-0.6069616079330444,
1.0973668098449707,
0.16210293769836426,
-0.5903719067573547,
-0.055010516196489334,
0.03981294482946396,
0.9722529053688049,
-0.41359248757362366,
0.17136463522911072,
-0.4336404502391815,
0.039723388850688934,
-0.4558551609516144,
-1.1769236326217651,
0.64413982629776,
0.1985786408185959,
-0.47093698382377625,
-0.17625543475151062,
0.4206203520298004,
-0.32019808888435364,
-0.40969333052635193,
-0.2914670705795288,
0.7333815693855286,
0.2022833675146103,
-0.5461616516113281,
-0.7488148808479309,
-0.18205206096172333,
-0.030954619869589806,
-0.45592671632766724,
0.13970474898815155,
0.3690226078033447,
-0.040141891688108444,
0.23713970184326172,
0.16217859089374542,
-0.0005645522614941001,
-0.40766704082489014,
-0.16151000559329987,
0.7760122418403625,
-0.7097610831260681,
-0.9914566278457642,
-0.7001495957374573,
0.5537688136100769,
-0.07589022070169449,
-0.3010498881340027,
0.42036041617393494,
0.7151134014129639,
0.7308893203735352,
-0.2179209291934967,
1.0613105297088623,
-0.0943763256072998,
0.9819773435592651,
-0.32669034600257874,
0.4197099208831787,
-0.3219392001628876,
0.03942694887518883,
-0.3028687834739685,
-1.0558489561080933,
-0.21069733798503876,
0.49218422174453735,
-0.5948827266693115,
0.15147395431995392,
0.20786921679973602,
0.4933968186378479,
-0.16048797965049744,
0.16890276968479156,
0.04942148178815842,
-0.08783284574747086,
0.45368531346321106,
0.3416438400745392,
0.7580981254577637,
0.11847524344921112,
0.29634690284729004,
-0.4090566635131836,
-0.1697041243314743,
-0.30029040575027466,
-0.8115252256393433,
-0.48999467492103577,
-0.5436453819274902,
-0.565798819065094,
-0.5640066266059875,
-0.08827783167362213,
0.9955703020095825,
0.5192234516143799,
-1.0611085891723633,
-0.07778165489435196,
0.05006830021739006,
-0.17336855828762054,
-0.45615872740745544,
-0.35148531198501587,
0.39252933859825134,
-0.6127058267593384,
-0.5070269703865051,
0.020126337185502052,
0.3478661775588989,
-0.23886655271053314,
-0.6988351345062256,
0.12518419325351715,
0.40804538130760193,
-0.023576602339744568,
0.6966695189476013,
0.5322335362434387,
-0.7915012240409851,
-0.37346139550209045,
-0.21648426353931427,
0.13948415219783783,
0.32177111506462097,
0.8772539496421814,
-0.8205773830413818,
0.3614470362663269,
0.5930895805358887,
0.6704875230789185,
0.24686139822006226,
0.4158460199832916,
0.43027955293655396,
-1.4335800409317017,
0.047189246863126755,
0.5431893467903137,
0.2427978664636612,
0.37650996446609497,
-0.2707442343235016,
0.4583580791950226,
-0.005653579719364643,
-0.4795098304748535,
-0.45321404933929443,
0.06848234683275223,
-1.0681424140930176,
-0.47734108567237854,
1.0050996541976929,
-0.28781774640083313,
-0.4241703450679779,
-0.2938164174556732,
0.12570016086101532,
0.22160857915878296,
-0.45711976289749146,
1.0351523160934448,
0.5713878273963928,
-0.8207815885543823,
0.04678801819682121,
-0.12139510363340378,
0.1578567773103714,
0.3919980823993683,
-0.9516491889953613,
0.05151399224996567,
0.697341799736023,
-0.019376149401068687,
0.12166554480791092,
0.6620975732803345,
-0.015723038464784622,
0.0713762491941452,
-0.5423927307128906,
0.4935443103313446,
0.07587120682001114,
-0.06924933940172195,
-0.40404388308525085,
0.5919756889343262,
0.12843218445777893,
-0.6561407446861267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04792v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04792v2 | Direct Language Model Alignment from Online AI Feedback | 2024-02-07T12:31:13 | 2024-02-29T20:59:17 | Shangmin Guo, Biao Zhang, Tianlin Liu, Tianqi Liu, Misha Khalman, Felipe Llinares, Alexandre Rame, Thomas Mesnard, Yao Zhao, Bilal Piot, Johan Ferret, Mathieu Blondel | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Direct alignment from preferences (DAP) methods, such as DPO, have recently
emerged as efficient alternatives to reinforcement learning from human feedback
(RLHF), that do not require a separate reward model. However, the preference
datasets used in DAP methods are usually collected ahead of training and never
updated, thus the feedback is purely offline. Moreover, responses in these
datasets are often sampled from a language model distinct from the one being
aligned, and since the model evolves over training, the alignment phase is
inevitably off-policy. In this study, we posit that online feedback is key and
improves DAP methods. Our method, online AI feedback (OAIF), uses an LLM as
annotator: on each training iteration, we sample two responses from the current
model and prompt the LLM annotator to choose which one is preferred, thus
providing online feedback. Despite its simplicity, we demonstrate via human
evaluation in several tasks that OAIF outperforms both offline DAP and RLHF
methods. We further show that the feedback leveraged in OAIF is easily
controllable, via instruction prompts to the LLM annotator. | [
-0.31815093755722046,
-0.5885772109031677,
0.5896165370941162,
0.07221115380525589,
0.037981029599905014,
0.13857823610305786,
-0.47896885871887207,
-0.5060744881629944,
0.18435974419116974,
0.3170710504055023,
-0.6761934757232666,
-0.22919316589832306,
-0.39570194482803345,
0.19621989130973816,
0.10533342510461807,
0.9890870451927185,
-0.25894179940223694,
0.22440090775489807,
-0.3572777509689331,
-0.15113094449043274,
-0.3389793932437897,
-0.4393913447856903,
-0.7689789533615112,
-0.6171204447746277,
0.4820311963558197,
0.37339362502098083,
0.6971577405929565,
1.0284943580627441,
0.6211780309677124,
0.2672565281391144,
0.1873946636915207,
0.3483961522579193,
-0.3486210107803345,
0.06964607536792755,
0.09426917135715485,
-0.3451458513736725,
-0.52305006980896,
0.009503021836280823,
0.4975219666957855,
0.5756174921989441,
-0.3485593795776367,
-0.060456808656454086,
0.20158444344997406,
0.7745738625526428,
-0.5683267712593079,
0.24107496440410614,
-0.33966168761253357,
0.05768361687660217,
0.0787113830447197,
-0.0923013687133789,
-0.4355626404285431,
-0.5930517315864563,
0.37243446707725525,
-0.7908065319061279,
-0.24485015869140625,
-0.18126019835472107,
0.8844207525253296,
0.6843097805976868,
-0.3633425235748291,
-0.41351860761642456,
-0.9933455586433411,
0.6629804372787476,
-0.7132301926612854,
0.3113442063331604,
0.6095735430717468,
0.4577217400074005,
-0.20183885097503662,
-0.29495659470558167,
-0.6847429871559143,
-0.5230072736740112,
0.037025898694992065,
0.07623936980962753,
0.23232583701610565,
0.2418741136789322,
0.12026556581258774,
0.15302632749080658,
-0.17140738666057587,
0.48703107237815857,
0.1590612381696701,
-0.13806849718093872,
0.8485990762710571,
-0.07563000172376633,
0.10498645156621933,
0.11411507427692413,
-0.5019121170043945,
-0.2534668743610382,
-0.8374277353286743,
0.2442723512649536,
0.5716714859008789,
0.3055330216884613,
-0.2346172034740448,
0.5595867037773132,
-0.19587698578834534,
0.9684938192367554,
0.6528249979019165,
-0.38279035687446594,
0.30826544761657715,
0.0041466038674116135,
0.08040566742420197,
0.190940260887146,
0.8803821802139282,
0.40725499391555786,
0.16344687342643738,
-0.19815054535865784,
-0.2529648244380951,
0.03137325868010521,
0.18994110822677612,
-0.46535181999206543,
-0.045782413333654404,
0.232834592461586,
-0.27443405985832214,
-0.2490834891796112,
0.1992391049861908,
-0.618602991104126,
-0.6890066862106323,
-0.49157798290252686,
0.2522560954093933,
-0.03359772637486458,
-0.14946496486663818,
-0.1823696494102478,
0.1577356457710266,
0.4179514944553375,
0.6136589646339417,
-1.1220521926879883,
0.34745439887046814,
0.7120900750160217,
0.7595353722572327,
-0.5065070390701294,
-0.23564818501472473,
-0.7918416261672974,
-0.059872519224882126,
-0.18069109320640564,
0.7090266942977905,
-0.5694339871406555,
-0.15804047882556915,
0.16098327934741974,
-0.277173787355423,
-0.023354224860668182,
-0.47229915857315063,
0.3488841950893402,
-0.5502122640609741,
0.44423502683639526,
-0.23861205577850342,
-0.7248271107673645,
-0.07499390095472336,
0.28730037808418274,
-0.6821950674057007,
1.1034268140792847,
-0.12194682657718658,
-0.9227511882781982,
0.3239785432815552,
-0.8300568461418152,
-0.17924059927463531,
-0.19614700973033905,
-0.4677397310733795,
-0.40148890018463135,
-0.12480703741312027,
0.3819364309310913,
0.2654966115951538,
-0.04757555574178696,
0.2898331582546234,
-0.6099342703819275,
-0.40984097123146057,
0.3248324990272522,
-0.2777145504951477,
0.5387987494468689,
0.06714998930692673,
-0.9461463689804077,
0.43760353326797485,
-0.8868914246559143,
-0.05201229825615883,
0.15172675251960754,
-0.5466762185096741,
-0.10231247544288635,
0.16701431572437286,
-0.24044114351272583,
0.2948729395866394,
0.25222688913345337,
-0.7191058993339539,
0.6377390027046204,
-0.4597811698913574,
0.43508830666542053,
0.9815791845321655,
-0.21492603421211243,
0.5819472074508667,
-0.4253920316696167,
0.5716558694839478,
-0.32316115498542786,
-0.07690132409334183,
0.12909641861915588,
-0.5089994668960571,
-0.8340070247650146,
-0.4409446120262146,
0.37818264961242676,
0.49925363063812256,
-0.5203268527984619,
0.5756875872612,
-0.4423683285713196,
-0.20031654834747314,
-1.0014135837554932,
0.13968604803085327,
0.4126273989677429,
0.4785667359828949,
0.16066376864910126,
-0.25234439969062805,
-0.3799680769443512,
-0.6555302143096924,
-0.042608365416526794,
-0.35991546511650085,
-0.024983495473861694,
0.5387924313545227,
-0.01578632742166519,
-0.2154502421617508,
1.2827906608581543,
-0.4333784282207489,
-0.30435487627983093,
-0.2579802870750427,
0.21004106104373932,
-0.12025615572929382,
0.19010430574417114,
0.24893121421337128,
-0.5071827173233032,
-0.5449953079223633,
-0.1091986820101738,
-0.4844673275947571,
-0.3607403039932251,
-0.22788307070732117,
-0.024473490193486214,
0.44883644580841064,
0.14491446316242218,
-0.35884538292884827,
0.2588065266609192,
0.5884119868278503,
-0.2047126144170761,
-0.08266138285398483,
-0.3863605856895447,
0.26297301054000854,
-0.866722583770752,
0.13744407892227173,
-0.20071479678153992,
-0.4776628911495209,
-0.4414548873901367,
0.045632749795913696,
0.043827954679727554,
0.19294273853302002,
-0.5251267552375793,
0.7521041631698608,
-0.40091827511787415,
-0.0988229438662529,
-0.48478370904922485,
0.3004744350910187,
-0.08071029931306839,
0.7467749714851379,
0.41212600469589233,
0.4789266586303711,
0.2921071946620941,
-0.6126528382301331,
0.4504584074020386,
0.4401644766330719,
-0.17771320044994354,
0.2282695472240448,
-0.5196664929389954,
0.6561842560768127,
-0.17934472858905792,
0.4067431092262268,
-0.9693120121955872,
-0.2301749885082245,
0.5786876082420349,
-0.2377985268831253,
0.43259280920028687,
-0.002738222712650895,
-0.21987418830394745,
-0.03540586307644844,
-0.41412249207496643,
0.1078004390001297,
0.3480609357357025,
-0.835635781288147,
0.4578495919704437,
0.48980167508125305,
0.04555794596672058,
-0.5960603356361389,
-0.6028792858123779,
-0.2003721445798874,
-0.1586037427186966,
-0.35900574922561646,
0.36757078766822815,
-0.22613298892974854,
-0.3318224549293518,
-0.2240920513868332,
0.1080804094672203,
-0.02959318459033966,
0.3882848620414734,
0.5421674847602844,
0.41995951533317566,
0.0786663144826889,
-0.07204839587211609,
-0.20858465135097504,
-0.1477106809616089,
-0.1473175585269928,
-0.08164885640144348,
0.5575193762779236,
-0.008397460915148258,
-0.5838034749031067,
-0.7240756750106812,
0.12170294672250748,
0.2848699986934662,
-0.1792178750038147,
0.5743646621704102,
0.32061100006103516,
-0.18361763656139374,
-0.03140968456864357,
-0.4522206783294678,
-0.25081273913383484,
-0.40558749437332153,
0.08025091141462326,
-0.18204818665981293,
-0.8941714763641357,
0.2834586799144745,
0.13755488395690918,
0.2351323664188385,
0.2973689138889313,
0.6548612117767334,
-0.12632116675376892,
1.3917975425720215,
0.5872074365615845,
-0.18179547786712646,
0.5983719825744629,
-0.032586030662059784,
-0.10197100043296814,
-0.5732391476631165,
-0.23172754049301147,
-0.43712693452835083,
-0.5320141315460205,
-0.6403541564941406,
-0.024612491950392723,
-0.020615464076399803,
0.2082938551902771,
-0.17394952476024628,
0.14885732531547546,
-0.395442932844162,
0.38165518641471863,
0.6949640512466431,
0.32057926058769226,
0.2968801259994507,
0.01685851812362671,
-0.14178307354450226,
-0.07122378796339035,
-0.6569207310676575,
-0.4464936852455139,
1.1783244609832764,
0.5192945003509521,
0.7722567319869995,
0.027234302833676338,
0.9302490949630737,
0.15914057195186615,
0.3465029001235962,
-0.7936344146728516,
0.3385276794433594,
0.28593045473098755,
-0.3652554750442505,
-0.28018006682395935,
-0.48629409074783325,
-0.7545663714408875,
-0.10092265158891678,
-0.25409841537475586,
-0.7062572240829468,
-0.021830229088664055,
0.5202286839485168,
-0.7104374170303345,
0.18611419200897217,
-0.5706607103347778,
0.7664941549301147,
-0.5969860553741455,
-0.34310823678970337,
-0.05319114029407501,
-0.7914417386054993,
0.061598967760801315,
-0.0031128590926527977,
0.2145492136478424,
-0.14175838232040405,
-0.028773024678230286,
0.6382654905319214,
-0.5452197790145874,
0.9418688416481018,
-0.23455345630645752,
-0.3274795711040497,
0.18679270148277283,
-0.0795249193906784,
0.6848355531692505,
-0.17180927097797394,
0.029562415555119514,
0.1933758556842804,
-0.22761990129947662,
-0.13277412950992584,
-0.6447017788887024,
0.9465450048446655,
-1.2265019416809082,
-0.6683576107025146,
-0.6490324139595032,
-0.3260081708431244,
-0.3046753704547882,
-0.041860297322273254,
0.09185527265071869,
0.2402658760547638,
0.02865803986787796,
-0.12623126804828644,
0.43871864676475525,
-0.15553376078605652,
0.5621495842933655,
0.46606892347335815,
-0.5343082547187805,
-0.551630973815918,
0.7758399844169617,
-0.0617629736661911,
0.4730219542980194,
0.6611888408660889,
0.4862765371799469,
-0.6306708455085754,
-0.22116202116012573,
-0.8365047574043274,
0.08146177232265472,
-0.7146053314208984,
-0.020891884341835976,
-0.48229503631591797,
0.08946233987808228,
-0.42281803488731384,
-0.023312129080295563,
-0.444348007440567,
-0.5732364654541016,
-0.23634225130081177,
-0.01437167078256607,
0.360358864068985,
1.0196952819824219,
-0.05472889915108681,
0.2028598040342331,
-0.7582539916038513,
0.22652365267276764,
0.30071666836738586,
0.5019471049308777,
-0.08634771406650543,
-0.6205639839172363,
-0.03574344143271446,
0.39615970849990845,
-0.35627204179763794,
-0.9922046065330505,
0.0037547247484326363,
0.4015050232410431,
0.4723402261734009,
0.6317821145057678,
0.20826245844364166,
0.7222669124603271,
-0.389596164226532,
0.7046999335289001,
-0.03514488786458969,
-0.8272543549537659,
0.5307974219322205,
-0.2503695487976074,
0.3973011076450348,
0.6334562301635742,
0.5949466824531555,
-0.4745865762233734,
-0.14559020102024078,
-0.3714197874069214,
-0.6837348937988281,
1.0372021198272705,
-0.05339561030268669,
-0.1566879004240036,
0.01646423153579235,
0.4120721220970154,
0.3385249376296997,
0.2656113803386688,
-0.8118497133255005,
-0.45000478625297546,
-0.19145560264587402,
-0.3468090295791626,
0.07510415464639664,
0.0021072071976959705,
-0.19408923387527466,
0.038268279284238815,
0.7012137174606323,
-0.26121771335601807,
0.29986122250556946,
0.051616501063108444,
-0.060918305069208145,
-0.3210022747516632,
0.15520909428596497,
0.6157125234603882,
0.6208950281143188,
-0.28604933619499207,
0.020721273496747017,
-0.028437048196792603,
-0.18618720769882202,
0.3595190644264221,
0.025331739336252213,
-0.436505526304245,
-0.15921558439731598,
0.3231743574142456,
1.0560622215270996,
0.05564399063587189,
-0.6146669387817383,
0.5790405869483948,
-0.2550055980682373,
0.055006854236125946,
-0.23196084797382355,
0.025527197867631912,
-0.058206621557474136,
0.09605810791254044,
0.04389191046357155,
0.015289943665266037,
-0.13453727960586548,
-0.37646952271461487,
0.037132877856492996,
0.3622686564922333,
-0.662554144859314,
-0.26794013381004333,
0.6213134527206421,
0.419321745634079,
-0.48711249232292175,
0.6302080750465393,
-0.22368276119232178,
-0.528389573097229,
0.27333539724349976,
0.3781666159629822,
0.9334532618522644,
-0.0038345863576978445,
0.36354994773864746,
0.26994553208351135,
-0.1313716471195221,
-0.30195537209510803,
0.1729079931974411,
-0.3093439042568207,
-0.7488675117492676,
-0.5118382573127747,
-0.5831295251846313,
-0.6304445266723633,
0.06740047037601471,
-0.8138478398323059,
0.39768490195274353,
-0.6170549392700195,
-0.1352166086435318,
-0.2903410792350769,
-0.09123627841472626,
-0.6037555932998657,
0.14863263070583344,
0.44007331132888794,
0.40256625413894653,
-0.62416672706604,
1.0238499641418457,
0.7766624093055725,
-0.5190620422363281,
-0.9035966396331787,
0.22897794842720032,
0.30116918683052063,
-0.9472755789756775,
0.8120116591453552,
0.395034521818161,
-0.10455512255430222,
0.1957577019929886,
-0.21297188103199005,
-1.0874993801116943,
0.9082710146903992,
0.604539155960083,
-0.8075352311134338,
0.004279987420886755,
0.28328853845596313,
0.5161086916923523,
-0.3570929765701294,
0.6897873282432556,
0.39010098576545715,
0.3905947804450989,
0.1467723399400711,
-1.0978026390075684,
-0.09903894364833832,
-0.02895405702292919,
-0.15530960261821747,
0.2927151322364807,
-0.5007064342498779,
0.16671454906463623,
-0.29698869585990906,
-0.3351658284664154,
-0.04593610763549805,
0.686719536781311,
0.08301017433404922,
-0.1451040655374527,
0.7249908447265625,
0.7201202511787415,
0.5941441059112549,
-0.12328498065471649,
1.162017583847046,
-0.3123979866504669,
0.20789600908756256,
1.4980961084365845,
-0.5452888607978821,
1.198668360710144,
0.624712347984314,
-0.18972428143024445,
0.4275820851325989,
0.8876157999038696,
0.2528780996799469,
0.6763712167739868,
0.2383296638727188,
-0.031200150027871132,
-0.2544490694999695,
-0.235308438539505,
-0.32021960616111755,
0.5189700126647949,
-0.36705246567726135,
0.009655600413680077,
-0.061950985342264175,
-0.07653138041496277,
0.01592724584043026,
0.2338312268257141,
-0.23227590322494507,
1.283485770225525,
-0.1906740814447403,
-1.2074774503707886,
0.5768298506736755,
0.08178314566612244,
0.7634973526000977,
-0.7056556344032288,
-0.20193687081336975,
-0.23201870918273926,
0.46006569266319275,
-0.23820288479328156,
-0.47751274704933167,
0.19332709908485413,
-0.028432637453079224,
-0.006493293680250645,
-0.4145488142967224,
0.3135734498500824,
-0.6751254796981812,
-0.21836043894290924,
0.4866425395011902,
0.1628180891275406,
-0.13418760895729065,
0.11956779658794403,
-0.6805058121681213,
0.09250044822692871,
0.188528373837471,
-0.2697781026363373,
0.5135926008224487,
-0.1829330325126648,
-0.059388257563114166,
0.6459090709686279,
0.6303308010101318,
0.22341951727867126,
0.12376867234706879,
-0.015288073569536209,
0.6753259301185608,
-0.4094322919845581,
-0.5075458884239197,
-0.9753242135047913,
0.36301806569099426,
0.06036900728940964,
-0.4498351514339447,
0.6913954019546509,
0.16336201131343842,
1.2849961519241333,
-0.00927444826811552,
0.8111984133720398,
-0.04539847746491432,
0.6466331481933594,
-0.5075245499610901,
0.5005848407745361,
-0.4358071982860565,
0.3116026818752289,
-0.05636562407016754,
-1.035170555114746,
-0.19968171417713165,
0.7087926268577576,
-0.33855870366096497,
-0.003255958203226328,
0.5313449501991272,
0.6656355857849121,
0.19975054264068604,
-0.10007640719413757,
0.060247451066970825,
-0.044367313385009766,
0.30951520800590515,
0.2966320514678955,
0.8789281845092773,
-0.16200628876686096,
0.33437952399253845,
-0.500245213508606,
-0.2732621133327484,
-0.17606504261493683,
-1.2386752367019653,
-0.9073861241340637,
-0.35686662793159485,
-0.5941970944404602,
-0.3399530351161957,
-0.03694717958569527,
1.7098596096038818,
0.5707119107246399,
-1.0618001222610474,
-0.4090728759765625,
-0.1694488227367401,
-0.05499383807182312,
-0.2935393452644348,
-0.15608777105808258,
0.38119736313819885,
-0.204842671751976,
-0.7937639355659485,
0.4424647390842438,
0.24561946094036102,
0.03269210085272789,
-0.37488284707069397,
-0.6633200645446777,
-0.39547377824783325,
-0.14937080442905426,
-0.009428984485566616,
0.3753494918346405,
-0.9604179859161377,
-0.46171799302101135,
0.0403941385447979,
-0.28576934337615967,
0.37834984064102173,
0.7505511045455933,
-0.5640259981155396,
0.6819016337394714,
0.6569350957870483,
1.1975325345993042,
0.3218739628791809,
0.11292259395122528,
0.9148741364479065,
-0.6137755513191223,
0.03950262442231178,
0.05609341710805893,
0.3274849057197571,
0.6164921522140503,
-0.34054428339004517,
0.20907056331634521,
0.08027778565883636,
-0.5526366829872131,
-0.5617136359214783,
0.15020574629306793,
-0.7230954766273499,
0.06562172621488571,
1.2857304811477661,
-0.5240474939346313,
-0.18686610460281372,
0.1149664893746376,
-0.42160776257514954,
0.32841241359710693,
-0.5690118670463562,
1.084328055381775,
0.692707896232605,
-0.2918345630168915,
-0.010903362184762955,
-0.026099182665348053,
0.7629185318946838,
0.5216415524482727,
-0.939860463142395,
-0.06494829058647156,
0.4893026351928711,
-0.055716622620821,
0.11580699682235718,
0.6945607662200928,
0.24144859611988068,
0.13562403619289398,
-0.42627424001693726,
0.28852999210357666,
-0.2705928385257721,
-0.3929744362831116,
-0.8497067093849182,
-0.012658906169235706,
0.5352033376693726,
-0.3546581268310547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04788v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04788v3 | MLLM-as-a-Judge: Assessing Multimodal LLM-as-a-Judge with Vision-Language Benchmark | 2024-02-07T12:28:32 | 2024-06-11T06:21:46 | Dongping Chen, Ruoxi Chen, Shilin Zhang, Yinuo Liu, Yaochen Wang, Huichi Zhou, Qihui Zhang, Yao Wan, Pan Zhou, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have gained significant attention
recently, showing remarkable potential in artificial general intelligence.
However, assessing the utility of MLLMs presents considerable challenges,
primarily due to the absence of multimodal benchmarks that align with human
preferences. Drawing inspiration from the concept of LLM-as-a-Judge within
LLMs, this paper introduces a novel benchmark, termed MLLM-as-a-Judge, to
assess the ability of MLLMs in assisting judges across diverse modalities,
encompassing three distinct tasks: Scoring Evaluation, Pair Comparison, and
Batch Ranking. Our study reveals that, while MLLMs demonstrate remarkable
human-like discernment in Pair Comparison, there is a significant divergence
from human preferences in Scoring Evaluation and Batch Ranking. Furthermore, a
closer examination reveals persistent challenges in the judgment capacities of
LLMs, including diverse biases, hallucinatory responses, and inconsistencies in
judgment, even in advanced models such as GPT-4V. These findings emphasize the
pressing need for enhancements and further research efforts to be undertaken
before regarding MLLMs as fully reliable evaluators. In light of this, we
advocate for additional efforts dedicated to supporting the continuous
development within the domain of MLLM functioning as judges. The code and
dataset are publicly available at our project homepage:
\url{https://mllm-judge.github.io/}. | [
-0.43278077244758606,
-0.40734317898750305,
0.6695350408554077,
0.3864403963088989,
-0.23153053224086761,
0.028794478625059128,
-0.5391570329666138,
-0.4610017240047455,
-0.2011297345161438,
0.3610628545284271,
-0.2502419650554657,
-0.4210447371006012,
-0.656692624092102,
0.10611487925052643,
-0.3570758104324341,
0.7725451588630676,
-0.104056715965271,
0.5129275321960449,
-0.43410414457321167,
-0.552833616733551,
-0.5263605117797852,
-0.6723765134811401,
-0.4467865526676178,
-0.2733919024467468,
0.8193953037261963,
0.044522128999233246,
0.5522530674934387,
0.12924793362617493,
0.5819888114929199,
0.2793179154396057,
0.12943759560585022,
0.3161205053329468,
-0.04961935803294182,
0.1706792712211609,
-0.07857848703861237,
-0.3802379369735718,
-0.5327778458595276,
0.38976019620895386,
0.6270759701728821,
0.6543194651603699,
-0.12317763268947601,
0.23477131128311157,
0.09896937757730484,
0.7730777859687805,
-0.8297286033630371,
-0.03963812440633774,
-0.7416391372680664,
0.13998837769031525,
-0.26878127455711365,
0.04967130348086357,
-0.5975435972213745,
-0.26310083270072937,
-0.08927978575229645,
-0.35187622904777527,
-0.05066237226128578,
0.31356894969940186,
0.6916825771331787,
0.4178491532802582,
-0.8098054528236389,
-0.0941949263215065,
-0.46915456652641296,
0.7755610942840576,
-0.6541267037391663,
0.6365620493888855,
0.28733599185943604,
0.6130656599998474,
0.13711901009082794,
-0.7402030825614929,
-0.5596276521682739,
-0.7208819389343262,
-0.021940454840660095,
0.05215383693575859,
0.026777492836117744,
-0.005482564214617014,
0.339763343334198,
0.15590082108974457,
-0.45030704140663147,
0.20433680713176727,
0.05204833298921585,
-0.26378682255744934,
0.5672895908355713,
0.25885361433029175,
-0.1330643892288208,
-0.05138226971030235,
-0.576585054397583,
0.0704868957400322,
-0.4690054953098297,
0.17329436540603638,
0.3744479715824127,
0.21366959810256958,
-0.08982899785041809,
0.5848308205604553,
-0.30512940883636475,
0.8389762043952942,
-0.35211098194122314,
0.05236014723777771,
0.551988422870636,
-0.28590622544288635,
-0.33462485671043396,
-0.4184129536151886,
0.8776229023933411,
0.7361124157905579,
0.22641190886497498,
-0.03571199253201485,
-0.5104772448539734,
0.1427583396434784,
0.506913423538208,
-0.6152273416519165,
-0.10893934965133667,
0.008886612951755524,
-0.6964558362960815,
-0.14259196817874908,
0.1240866556763649,
-0.8741436004638672,
-0.8306804299354553,
-0.4407300651073456,
0.5214860439300537,
-0.04645351320505142,
-0.0971921905875206,
-0.09643597155809402,
-0.11819657683372498,
0.07879360765218735,
0.6594354510307312,
-0.6941540241241455,
0.2831664979457855,
0.5263541340827942,
0.5972363352775574,
-0.4291369616985321,
-0.5077114701271057,
-0.8704724907875061,
-0.15983320772647858,
-0.1443459391593933,
0.7277590036392212,
-0.6678319573402405,
-0.29080840945243835,
-0.16594722867012024,
-0.21400383114814758,
-0.17583291232585907,
-0.6219033002853394,
0.6650423407554626,
-0.3527097702026367,
0.025722594931721687,
-0.2323208898305893,
-0.32819825410842896,
-0.212407648563385,
0.5882235169410706,
-0.6246237754821777,
0.9092976450920105,
-0.029192155227065086,
-0.3882426619529724,
0.8344210982322693,
-0.5194793939590454,
-0.2418092042207718,
0.156508669257164,
-0.533437192440033,
-0.3114722967147827,
0.1372525990009308,
0.29337233304977417,
0.42170146107673645,
-0.3630499541759491,
0.3004566729068756,
-0.7195653915405273,
-0.21425661444664001,
0.3710363507270813,
-0.8936052322387695,
0.3598882257938385,
0.1679435670375824,
-0.32355019450187683,
0.42743736505508423,
-0.8474161624908447,
0.15832465887069702,
-0.1450488567352295,
-0.5710167288780212,
0.0052576446905732155,
0.2519564926624298,
0.4700317978858948,
0.2452826201915741,
0.3074890375137329,
-0.4206427335739136,
0.15620248019695282,
-0.07583798468112946,
0.15570375323295593,
1.00589919090271,
-0.3100152015686035,
0.07830719649791718,
-0.2894565165042877,
0.2998456060886383,
-0.2139396369457245,
0.5749229788780212,
0.07058710604906082,
-0.5925356149673462,
-0.8216041922569275,
-0.416635662317276,
0.49737057089805603,
0.41405215859413147,
-0.5989792943000793,
0.14692504703998566,
-0.17398260533809662,
-0.38152456283569336,
-0.7626757621765137,
0.44861021637916565,
0.4643230736255646,
0.11962901055812836,
0.3825499713420868,
-0.47737863659858704,
-0.47127315402030945,
-1.008417010307312,
-0.4171438217163086,
-0.06364907324314117,
-0.06468235701322556,
0.5391688942909241,
0.44170793890953064,
-0.3888331353664398,
0.8503014445304871,
0.05684191733598709,
-0.28769221901893616,
0.00603460893034935,
-0.14142566919326782,
0.178003191947937,
0.18444640934467316,
0.4583298861980438,
-1.045090675354004,
-0.4380335509777069,
0.20599223673343658,
-0.998892068862915,
-0.14765769243240356,
0.08428382128477097,
0.20461712777614594,
0.21828579902648926,
0.42540696263313293,
-0.5022394061088562,
0.29775115847587585,
0.6594731211662292,
-0.5702013373374939,
0.7949197292327881,
-0.3241649866104126,
0.35955607891082764,
-0.3378531038761139,
0.22728987038135529,
-0.13094161450862885,
-0.35393479466438293,
-0.5713132619857788,
0.3761269152164459,
0.28882935643196106,
0.3643404543399811,
-0.5373070240020752,
0.7170876860618591,
-0.3307517170906067,
-0.3067866861820221,
-0.23682428896427155,
0.23897626996040344,
0.009902727790176868,
0.5094898343086243,
-0.4052259624004364,
0.48286089301109314,
0.4079686999320984,
-0.4583950638771057,
0.7247503399848938,
-0.15380093455314636,
-0.48413944244384766,
0.7496238946914673,
-0.37154635787010193,
0.12809406220912933,
0.0777597725391388,
0.1690443754196167,
-0.7515536546707153,
0.16505149006843567,
0.33493557572364807,
-0.21440757811069489,
0.3296019434928894,
-0.1141095906496048,
-0.7961756587028503,
-0.39617258310317993,
-0.3899690508842468,
0.37865445017814636,
0.1373365968465805,
-0.5415999889373779,
0.945390522480011,
0.18883654475212097,
0.10551156848669052,
-0.5360274314880371,
-0.327353298664093,
0.3728272020816803,
-0.294082909822464,
-0.4081909656524658,
0.17463654279708862,
-0.4343624711036682,
-0.6435749530792236,
-0.04890856146812439,
-0.06391774117946625,
0.24813199043273926,
0.3613421618938446,
0.4111635684967041,
0.34055590629577637,
-0.15664555132389069,
0.07971511781215668,
-0.3729606568813324,
-0.13079604506492615,
-0.03437662497162819,
0.008040460757911205,
0.46258553862571716,
-0.4147106111049652,
-0.8356333374977112,
-0.2178989052772522,
0.13247041404247284,
0.7873290777206421,
-0.366566926240921,
0.23553408682346344,
0.678933322429657,
-0.022679291665554047,
-0.025490695610642433,
-0.970144510269165,
0.1419345587491989,
-0.41726604104042053,
0.2804419696331024,
-0.5612075328826904,
-0.8250117301940918,
0.17056132853031158,
0.11079833656549454,
0.13468033075332642,
0.47314852476119995,
0.8990728259086609,
-0.17298978567123413,
0.9279571175575256,
0.3180539608001709,
-0.2847338318824768,
0.3796241581439972,
0.20514824986457825,
-0.017861509695649147,
-0.987939178943634,
-0.35295140743255615,
-0.29037296772003174,
-0.4135700464248657,
-0.49780330061912537,
-0.5331160426139832,
0.44895029067993164,
-0.02183430828154087,
-0.24796724319458008,
-0.1433173567056656,
-0.1275431513786316,
0.15424208343029022,
0.5181794762611389,
0.116786889731884,
0.3623541295528412,
-0.40985190868377686,
-0.5569918155670166,
0.1763526201248169,
-0.23103323578834534,
-0.6166490912437439,
1.3405303955078125,
0.4545602798461914,
0.5960066318511963,
0.11649922281503677,
0.32661527395248413,
0.5247595310211182,
0.5176042318344116,
-0.7077189683914185,
0.6180493831634521,
-0.28120172023773193,
-0.491767942905426,
-0.19555224478244781,
-0.2814193069934845,
-0.605492889881134,
0.9046776294708252,
-0.404422789812088,
-0.7685110569000244,
-0.0906016156077385,
0.06539127230644226,
-0.27505919337272644,
0.20228327810764313,
-0.7848142385482788,
1.0871342420578003,
-0.6818267703056335,
-0.533055305480957,
-0.3568092882633209,
-0.6602591872215271,
0.22543945908546448,
-0.09442979097366333,
0.5132372975349426,
-0.5749157071113586,
-0.20400524139404297,
0.457445353269577,
-0.09416797012090683,
0.7611003518104553,
-0.5127054452896118,
-0.022731341421604156,
-0.1417912095785141,
-0.11000040918588638,
0.274313360452652,
0.02675708755850792,
-0.1573614925146103,
0.0778810903429985,
-0.11136749386787415,
-0.2999419569969177,
-0.5995053648948669,
0.5964910387992859,
-0.6160559058189392,
-0.665197491645813,
-0.30289149284362793,
-0.48082494735717773,
-0.5690322518348694,
0.02893535979092121,
-0.3285199701786041,
0.4148082137107849,
-0.03329542651772499,
0.31492751836776733,
0.12033636122941971,
-0.058584801852703094,
0.49792447686195374,
0.7132065892219543,
-0.6106862425804138,
-0.2833620309829712,
1.0247336626052856,
-0.345443993806839,
0.11949454993009567,
0.32963502407073975,
0.16231954097747803,
-0.41713660955429077,
-0.842190146446228,
-0.7058337926864624,
-0.02644110471010208,
-0.7882258296012878,
-0.02687670849263668,
-0.5317661166191101,
0.0021021212451159954,
-0.0004120577359572053,
0.1679767668247223,
-0.23776954412460327,
-0.11859249323606491,
-0.018424902111291885,
0.20068101584911346,
0.02113884501159191,
0.7077966332435608,
0.3343053162097931,
-0.215342715382576,
-0.6627240180969238,
0.47120726108551025,
0.6081336140632629,
0.4770788550376892,
-0.04655370116233826,
-0.47044986486434937,
-0.008753949776291847,
-0.1018117368221283,
-0.21773165464401245,
-0.23168550431728363,
0.12830659747123718,
0.219582661986351,
1.1277920007705688,
0.3571191430091858,
-0.3088674545288086,
0.7117279767990112,
-0.694523274898529,
0.7958850860595703,
0.20563474297523499,
-0.7275460362434387,
0.41120755672454834,
-0.025441965088248253,
0.11966685205698013,
0.7087118625640869,
-0.0234668031334877,
-0.49348539113998413,
-0.5759072303771973,
-0.06305727362632751,
-0.7253265380859375,
0.4665151834487915,
0.14056093990802765,
0.06199387088418007,
0.2610335648059845,
-0.08142215013504028,
0.2762485444545746,
0.5396771430969238,
-0.8988592028617859,
-0.25487712025642395,
-0.16176734864711761,
0.06266961246728897,
-0.393384724855423,
-0.22716374695301056,
-0.11184521019458771,
-0.2933964729309082,
0.37529999017715454,
-0.24186024069786072,
-0.035099539905786514,
-0.06368882209062576,
-0.3975200057029724,
0.2654630243778229,
0.4837954044342041,
0.7047433257102966,
0.5914128422737122,
-0.20667801797389984,
0.36917638778686523,
0.3787221610546112,
-0.17400407791137695,
-0.02929266169667244,
0.25246524810791016,
0.07458575069904327,
-0.30944332480430603,
0.4768260419368744,
0.9194894433021545,
0.39849528670310974,
-1.012114405632019,
0.6982158422470093,
-0.2786009907722473,
-0.24919214844703674,
-0.03740376979112625,
-0.00992837455123663,
-0.08510617911815643,
0.5549712777137756,
0.4351862072944641,
0.4093901216983795,
0.1203777864575386,
-0.539738655090332,
0.2778734266757965,
0.5664970278739929,
-0.6059011220932007,
-0.002035088138654828,
0.7166163325309753,
0.34145602583885193,
-0.19583693146705627,
0.4682359993457794,
-0.40799522399902344,
-0.43611544370651245,
0.3159923255443573,
0.05755523592233658,
0.7364814877510071,
0.04224809259176254,
-0.17428599298000336,
-0.1040990874171257,
0.24765802919864655,
-0.01193577516824007,
0.048521988093853,
-0.24226436018943787,
-0.8911696076393127,
-0.07720062136650085,
-0.926810085773468,
-0.48205330967903137,
-0.1563897728919983,
-0.5479753017425537,
0.26592299342155457,
-0.4111466109752655,
-0.35040080547332764,
0.034325357526540756,
-0.03189076855778694,
-0.7164073586463928,
0.1421290636062622,
0.5261935591697693,
0.7954952120780945,
-0.3492697477340698,
0.944646954536438,
0.5876871943473816,
-0.019644910469651222,
-0.25101780891418457,
-0.045298900455236435,
0.21696598827838898,
-0.9768802523612976,
0.7737939357757568,
0.425377756357193,
-0.1871129721403122,
-0.3803480267524719,
0.0024036290124058723,
-0.287492036819458,
1.045667290687561,
0.32679399847984314,
-0.6704429984092712,
0.028731847181916237,
-0.13258591294288635,
0.5958667993545532,
-0.4213068187236786,
0.4708269238471985,
0.5984752774238586,
0.7771660685539246,
-0.11945012211799622,
-1.2638986110687256,
-0.13040374219417572,
-0.6320717334747314,
-0.04181016981601715,
0.09027853608131409,
-0.6731412410736084,
0.7709745764732361,
-0.13634786009788513,
0.06674381345510483,
0.0703941285610199,
0.35494399070739746,
0.29238808155059814,
0.4314645528793335,
0.8800288438796997,
0.4187062084674835,
0.5739260911941528,
0.032812707126140594,
1.0979597568511963,
-0.2823822498321533,
0.28087252378463745,
1.085266351699829,
-0.5705650448799133,
1.0806539058685303,
0.7012845873832703,
-0.39997413754463196,
0.4181791841983795,
0.3408772349357605,
-0.4968588054180145,
0.359201043844223,
0.26517540216445923,
-0.3368748128414154,
-0.48648184537887573,
-0.18626467883586884,
-0.2059369534254074,
0.6362306475639343,
0.18010331690311432,
-0.30453675985336304,
-0.08851632475852966,
0.19681918621063232,
-0.4533770680427551,
0.20656494796276093,
-0.43508437275886536,
0.47110867500305176,
0.07829050719738007,
-0.4969589412212372,
0.27123647928237915,
0.0900547206401825,
0.9378043413162231,
-0.5709559917449951,
0.08572720736265182,
0.11159185320138931,
0.2294430285692215,
-0.0756201520562172,
-0.7497907280921936,
-0.025610556825995445,
0.10569137334823608,
-0.10994002968072891,
-0.4691896438598633,
0.3917505443096161,
-0.0941096842288971,
-0.5485087037086487,
0.7247857451438904,
0.6465383768081665,
0.026325048878788948,
-0.3185715079307556,
-0.7538681030273438,
0.31272774934768677,
-0.1039109006524086,
-0.2746846377849579,
0.40759995579719543,
0.07254507392644882,
-0.183710977435112,
0.9239724278450012,
0.5356714725494385,
0.040489885956048965,
0.18422846496105194,
0.7463560700416565,
0.8136621117591858,
-0.6218315958976746,
-0.15579071640968323,
-1.1562408208847046,
0.40716880559921265,
-0.006693008355796337,
-0.3413284718990326,
0.8038392066955566,
0.806144654750824,
0.7046532034873962,
-0.010295500047504902,
0.6597464680671692,
-0.08225951343774796,
0.28942427039146423,
-0.7198307514190674,
0.8272582292556763,
-0.8462673425674438,
0.22167479991912842,
-0.0806952640414238,
-0.6463273763656616,
-0.2680714428424835,
0.40515920519828796,
-0.21496225893497467,
0.22184601426124573,
0.7633262276649475,
0.6062010526657104,
0.1842469722032547,
-0.10237349569797516,
0.808485209941864,
0.14944159984588623,
0.30157577991485596,
0.5272505283355713,
1.1671148538589478,
-0.20621797442436218,
0.5500454306602478,
0.01560073159635067,
0.03730430454015732,
-0.3660135567188263,
-0.5725733637809753,
-1.1981123685836792,
-0.4450504183769226,
0.061322662979364395,
0.09646067023277283,
-0.11499149352312088,
1.071652889251709,
0.6978121399879456,
-0.7833399772644043,
-0.3276672959327698,
0.36854416131973267,
0.06839681416749954,
-0.2422567754983902,
-0.1434900313615799,
-0.01784675382077694,
-0.341511994600296,
-0.6675136089324951,
0.5484573841094971,
0.5815859436988831,
-0.2315446138381958,
-0.40434542298316956,
-0.27040237188339233,
-0.07055187225341797,
-0.45610928535461426,
0.909566342830658,
-0.24732735753059387,
-1.2493942975997925,
-0.4027072787284851,
-0.3732597827911377,
-0.2350151389837265,
0.11668312549591064,
0.8548528552055359,
-0.7817950248718262,
0.6577020883560181,
-0.12732259929180145,
0.5485040545463562,
0.5357333421707153,
-0.17687936127185822,
0.4666191637516022,
-0.580407977104187,
0.06665102392435074,
0.3291274905204773,
0.5932741761207581,
0.29978063702583313,
0.1711241900920868,
0.4261532723903656,
0.37942036986351013,
-0.3286021649837494,
-0.8500282764434814,
0.195156991481781,
-1.1846888065338135,
-0.06268329173326492,
1.1588082313537598,
-0.18772275745868683,
0.10793734341859818,
-0.14668291807174683,
-0.3992438316345215,
-0.14266815781593323,
-0.3762073218822479,
0.5593509674072266,
0.7441014051437378,
-0.0830269530415535,
-0.2888230085372925,
-0.8627696633338928,
0.29025936126708984,
0.31834718585014343,
-0.8263205885887146,
0.08362475782632828,
0.3823832869529724,
0.1683157980442047,
-0.0767444297671318,
0.6055105328559875,
-0.02012402005493641,
0.2986966073513031,
-0.034827329218387604,
0.08396723866462708,
-0.1298970729112625,
-0.37054237723350525,
-0.46663808822631836,
0.3721633553504944,
0.36660316586494446,
-0.06140865013003349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04787v1 | A Hypothesis-Driven Framework for the Analysis of Self-Rationalising Models | 2024-02-07T12:26:12 | 2024-02-07T12:26:12 | Marc Braun, Jenny Kunz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The self-rationalising capabilities of LLMs are appealing because the
generated explanations can give insights into the plausibility of the
predictions. However, how faithful the explanations are to the predictions is
questionable, raising the need to explore the patterns behind them further. To
this end, we propose a hypothesis-driven statistical framework. We use a
Bayesian network to implement a hypothesis about how a task (in our example,
natural language inference) is solved, and its internal states are translated
into natural language with templates. Those explanations are then compared to
LLM-generated free-text explanations using automatic and human evaluations.
This allows us to judge how similar the LLM's and the Bayesian network's
decision processes are. We demonstrate the usage of our framework with an
example hypothesis and two realisations in Bayesian networks. The resulting
models do not exhibit a strong similarity to GPT-3.5. We discuss the
implications of this as well as the framework's potential to approximate LLM
decisions better in future work. | [
-0.11979725956916809,
-0.7062981724739075,
1.0459983348846436,
0.2803575396537781,
0.010700894519686699,
-0.5237901210784912,
0.04466008022427559,
0.05243191495537758,
0.12843894958496094,
0.7825923562049866,
-0.8987753391265869,
-0.3099944293498993,
-0.1569632589817047,
0.3752134442329407,
-0.49347203969955444,
0.6077560186386108,
-0.0589764267206192,
0.1953464299440384,
0.004453353118151426,
0.18633303046226501,
-0.30165770649909973,
-0.49472594261169434,
-0.746290385723114,
-0.5853220820426941,
0.6627283692359924,
0.10312214493751526,
0.4932571053504944,
0.8542989492416382,
0.3937702775001526,
0.2353646457195282,
0.40244871377944946,
-0.14755016565322876,
-0.20146827399730682,
0.20730094611644745,
-0.4936479926109314,
-0.6069039106369019,
-0.44563981890678406,
0.32780182361602783,
0.39116013050079346,
0.7472517490386963,
-0.09753603488206863,
0.0009747744188643992,
0.14002268016338348,
0.855175793170929,
-0.36155927181243896,
0.39784371852874756,
-0.5088614225387573,
0.044104430824518204,
0.24057474732398987,
-0.3359526991844177,
-0.4143333435058594,
-0.18007442355155945,
0.06245386227965355,
-0.448156476020813,
0.6261492967605591,
0.05070146173238754,
0.17491990327835083,
0.18281863629817963,
-0.4137876033782959,
-0.40343907475471497,
-0.7255616188049316,
0.5873531103134155,
-0.8831571936607361,
0.11863506585359573,
0.2755369544029236,
0.4792856276035309,
-0.6668949723243713,
-0.4540300965309143,
-0.6830320358276367,
-0.11795281618833542,
-0.23365461826324463,
0.29704588651657104,
-0.0764753594994545,
0.24550992250442505,
0.14966531097888947,
0.3618851602077484,
-0.7985004186630249,
0.07887435704469681,
-0.17150957882404327,
-0.11703025549650192,
0.8626611828804016,
0.21269136667251587,
0.1355191171169281,
-0.3294594883918762,
-0.4914850890636444,
0.13372428715229034,
-0.739485502243042,
-0.41832494735717773,
0.310325026512146,
0.45977848768234253,
0.013428923673927784,
0.8148763179779053,
-0.5019227862358093,
0.5776928067207336,
0.19293098151683807,
-0.29031988978385925,
-0.1728043556213379,
-0.22582966089248657,
-0.5461730360984802,
0.23977264761924744,
0.8328422904014587,
0.4478200674057007,
0.44060057401657104,
-0.13365860283374786,
-0.340286523103714,
0.462356299161911,
-0.0008904169080778956,
-0.8520780801773071,
-0.26177269220352173,
0.4468452036380768,
-0.5653736591339111,
-0.40220311284065247,
-0.16796405613422394,
-0.3919444680213928,
-0.2781210243701935,
-0.5161761045455933,
0.48922061920166016,
-0.36206260323524475,
-0.5068460702896118,
0.33843713998794556,
-0.05937333405017853,
0.046087846159935,
0.3001393973827362,
-0.8844450116157532,
0.23427490890026093,
0.6853612065315247,
0.767636775970459,
-0.38192814588546753,
-0.2591150999069214,
0.0990024134516716,
0.5126894116401672,
-0.6057661771774292,
0.8460254073143005,
-0.06940002739429474,
-0.27021732926368713,
-0.18913079798221588,
-0.006681517232209444,
-0.12924255430698395,
-0.4387933909893036,
0.13618645071983337,
-0.3687392473220825,
0.4459458291530609,
-0.40579673647880554,
-0.8994044661521912,
-0.4714619219303131,
0.2750357985496521,
-0.5768164396286011,
0.566281259059906,
-0.07565055042505264,
-0.8253849148750305,
0.6843516826629639,
-0.8017313480377197,
-0.15763084590435028,
-0.23043717443943024,
-0.21700423955917358,
-0.04522588104009628,
0.04416108503937721,
0.14501738548278809,
0.8777619004249573,
-0.48777836561203003,
0.6268057823181152,
-0.7487208247184753,
-0.07509829849004745,
0.4378131628036499,
-0.7274888753890991,
0.6603766679763794,
0.4654879868030548,
-0.39202040433883667,
0.25823724269866943,
-0.8191611766815186,
-0.1590227484703064,
0.1429968774318695,
0.03005550615489483,
-0.02932494692504406,
0.29166316986083984,
-0.59237140417099,
0.09070262312889099,
0.11759517341852188,
-0.341795951128006,
0.22145280241966248,
-0.3615744113922119,
0.5301361083984375,
0.8370746374130249,
0.292570561170578,
0.7711260914802551,
-0.6340373754501343,
0.49972933530807495,
0.019640572369098663,
0.013429451733827591,
-0.09127212315797806,
-0.42292261123657227,
-0.5582689046859741,
-0.3884603679180145,
0.006907266099005938,
0.3023809492588043,
-0.32707908749580383,
0.04473269358277321,
-0.044472578912973404,
-0.2740672826766968,
-0.2773854732513428,
0.048809751868247986,
0.01407642662525177,
0.7788500785827637,
0.2981284558773041,
-0.21344836056232452,
-0.3858455419540405,
-1.1784285306930542,
-0.424738347530365,
-0.453806608915329,
-0.2631540596485138,
-0.18340909481048584,
0.5119248628616333,
-0.3907109797000885,
1.2351068258285522,
-0.16124661266803741,
-0.08140825480222702,
-0.3252108097076416,
0.28881192207336426,
0.6471791863441467,
0.48898258805274963,
0.2975691854953766,
-0.5413610935211182,
-0.15892542898654938,
-0.25078728795051575,
-0.9889492392539978,
-0.31209853291511536,
-0.49521952867507935,
-0.013243627734482288,
0.12074971944093704,
0.33506307005882263,
-0.5992202758789062,
0.648899495601654,
0.10044065862894058,
-0.24173809587955475,
0.7718905806541443,
-0.18900448083877563,
-0.056614939123392105,
-0.9414269328117371,
-0.22102564573287964,
0.3483145833015442,
-0.15425905585289001,
-0.6099193096160889,
-0.09028968214988708,
-0.09602449089288712,
0.16354110836982727,
0.0012703669490292668,
0.7048718333244324,
-0.4678533673286438,
-0.24763436615467072,
-0.38211533427238464,
-0.026712516322731972,
-0.05350535362958908,
0.28967976570129395,
0.09590724855661392,
0.7130895853042603,
0.40627193450927734,
-0.6736446619033813,
0.05937768891453743,
-0.07279910147190094,
-0.2564588785171509,
0.3887858986854553,
-0.6708191633224487,
-0.2793909013271332,
-0.35329335927963257,
0.12774859368801117,
-1.186378002166748,
-0.48870959877967834,
0.43171820044517517,
-0.3581554889678955,
0.026422420516610146,
-0.48224079608917236,
-0.5613424181938171,
-0.2538890242576599,
0.09117002040147781,
0.045729465782642365,
0.38624468445777893,
-0.6755200028419495,
0.6049546003341675,
0.015781207010149956,
-0.13862091302871704,
-0.18482542037963867,
-0.8181973099708557,
-0.18229907751083374,
-0.44573459029197693,
-0.7167652249336243,
0.4040929675102234,
-0.24114491045475006,
-0.6062490940093994,
-0.170051708817482,
-0.276414692401886,
0.02974030375480652,
0.2736133933067322,
0.3139042556285858,
0.12409999966621399,
-0.3488840162754059,
-0.0034385239705443382,
-0.0789913609623909,
-0.3163653314113617,
0.510636031627655,
-0.4971625804901123,
0.18827341496944427,
0.057695019990205765,
-0.5102344751358032,
-0.5609631538391113,
0.3095845580101013,
0.45475339889526367,
0.2915743589401245,
0.39836567640304565,
0.1869567334651947,
-0.3270382881164551,
-0.3256092965602875,
-0.5611883401870728,
-0.4494919776916504,
-0.4504709243774414,
-0.1510365754365921,
-0.6380885243415833,
-0.6879304051399231,
0.4434579014778137,
0.016341784968972206,
-0.11349429190158844,
0.5450727939605713,
0.8155410885810852,
-0.224422886967659,
1.2251118421554565,
0.496633380651474,
0.09843606501817703,
0.07935160398483276,
-0.11776106059551239,
0.22335892915725708,
-0.49223795533180237,
0.008932131342589855,
0.0011783817317336798,
0.16075710952281952,
-0.7823910713195801,
-0.42151519656181335,
0.17028990387916565,
0.2327479124069214,
-0.30659711360931396,
0.11631808429956436,
-0.3641114830970764,
0.2922010123729706,
0.39539796113967896,
-0.05428648367524147,
0.2761494219303131,
0.010165063664317131,
-0.33097055554389954,
0.20601285994052887,
-1.0408340692520142,
-0.685122013092041,
1.1141618490219116,
0.4264427721500397,
0.7451731562614441,
0.182821124792099,
0.7554647922515869,
0.353767454624176,
0.9340876936912537,
-0.537502646446228,
0.578792929649353,
0.4392428994178772,
-0.9902003407478333,
-0.3839851915836334,
-0.6651198267936707,
-0.9274272322654724,
0.5088924765586853,
-0.1450301706790924,
-0.715644359588623,
0.021509451791644096,
0.18484151363372803,
-0.22347627580165863,
0.19448381662368774,
-0.8004291653633118,
0.7886742949485779,
-0.3626495599746704,
-0.6177331209182739,
-0.3471977710723877,
-0.2357390969991684,
0.5641254782676697,
-0.06273850053548813,
0.39974215626716614,
-0.5074860453605652,
0.28921833634376526,
0.7846076488494873,
-0.49267101287841797,
1.016868233680725,
-0.1555175632238388,
-0.22321470081806183,
0.47616201639175415,
0.4882562458515167,
0.061092015355825424,
0.1388729363679886,
-0.5252017974853516,
-0.15675102174282074,
0.21997912228107452,
-0.5754693746566772,
-0.86748868227005,
0.6057671308517456,
-0.4051303267478943,
-1.053141474723816,
-0.5230772495269775,
-0.4640228748321533,
-0.1417602002620697,
0.3478858470916748,
-0.037051111459732056,
0.35902854800224304,
-0.24545668065547943,
-0.29964375495910645,
0.352323055267334,
0.1572292447090149,
0.4796951115131378,
0.6579886078834534,
-0.6525593400001526,
-0.2880740761756897,
0.6931977868080139,
0.21917292475700378,
0.2864747643470764,
0.23291383683681488,
0.497718870639801,
-0.5873144268989563,
-0.7060803174972534,
-0.3266351521015167,
0.2869897484779358,
-0.6737109422683716,
0.09518179297447205,
-0.19203589856624603,
0.18396233022212982,
-0.4350632131099701,
-0.20182321965694427,
0.055840712040662766,
-0.46983110904693604,
-0.1857004463672638,
-0.28131285309791565,
0.16537703573703766,
1.1526522636413574,
-0.4695938229560852,
0.41109800338745117,
-0.2247573584318161,
0.2349380999803543,
0.38654398918151855,
0.27280810475349426,
0.05729398503899574,
-0.31270766258239746,
0.12523970007896423,
0.19833406805992126,
-0.07511229813098907,
-1.2415741682052612,
0.74522864818573,
-0.1483895629644394,
0.5771036744117737,
0.5434488654136658,
-0.10599421709775925,
0.441255122423172,
-0.27629777789115906,
0.3939365744590759,
0.3235577940940857,
-0.65972900390625,
0.6430358290672302,
-0.7993364334106445,
-0.009875931777060032,
0.4012629985809326,
0.7150002121925354,
-0.089773029088974,
0.05821481719613075,
-0.713360607624054,
-0.397867888212204,
0.2174273133277893,
0.24515444040298462,
-0.4125019907951355,
-0.3183205723762512,
0.7812991142272949,
0.24049873650074005,
0.17304812371730804,
-0.8275216817855835,
-0.038653239607810974,
-0.0973392128944397,
-0.30597618222236633,
-0.1540193110704422,
-0.307506799697876,
0.01892351731657982,
-0.05781913176178932,
0.7048414945602417,
-0.5857216715812683,
0.35351619124412537,
0.6236936450004578,
-0.035272032022476196,
-0.018157050013542175,
0.10541841387748718,
0.08758927881717682,
0.8849284052848816,
-0.37476274371147156,
0.17528945207595825,
0.041882771998643875,
0.273603230714798,
0.27397218346595764,
-0.007382321171462536,
-0.32363444566726685,
-0.19379326701164246,
0.45489197969436646,
0.3114074170589447,
0.03267589583992958,
-0.3098680377006531,
0.3657597005367279,
-0.16718615591526031,
-0.40059220790863037,
-0.45783260464668274,
0.18594980239868164,
0.1695324182510376,
0.3350706100463867,
0.3039596378803253,
-0.08719954639673233,
0.3395408093929291,
-0.7301556468009949,
0.2603573501110077,
0.47644320130348206,
-0.2837890088558197,
-0.4294687807559967,
0.642396867275238,
-0.10554400086402893,
-0.27474915981292725,
0.13185849785804749,
-0.38212302327156067,
-0.5108875036239624,
0.5723181962966919,
0.8435407876968384,
0.789425253868103,
-0.06660689413547516,
0.29203417897224426,
0.38274866342544556,
0.24822045862674713,
-0.28571659326553345,
0.49016910791397095,
-0.10892920196056366,
-0.9413153529167175,
-0.6713351607322693,
-0.6228551268577576,
-0.3429757058620453,
0.07644969969987869,
-0.5986685156822205,
-0.06686215847730637,
-0.49667176604270935,
-0.14364022016525269,
0.15005996823310852,
-0.11436248570680618,
-0.5104053020477295,
0.5231641530990601,
0.016681324690580368,
0.8775736689567566,
-0.7028641104698181,
0.8920081257820129,
0.12040118873119354,
-0.4790817201137543,
-0.7122807502746582,
-0.00213721115142107,
0.018149960786104202,
-0.8322266340255737,
0.5742289423942566,
0.33091485500335693,
-0.08599277585744858,
-0.17404380440711975,
-0.4405730962753296,
-1.0265451669692993,
1.0848039388656616,
0.34124985337257385,
-0.591370701789856,
0.07414881885051727,
0.23390847444534302,
0.43523767590522766,
-0.646304190158844,
0.20155848562717438,
0.5752165913581848,
0.5025187134742737,
-0.22717642784118652,
-0.4341420829296112,
0.21688522398471832,
-0.05111093446612358,
-0.10515882074832916,
-0.0680706575512886,
-0.36645424365997314,
0.5973325967788696,
-0.34523484110832214,
-0.2787599265575409,
0.18655146658420563,
0.9411221146583557,
0.25585445761680603,
0.38588711619377136,
0.5433560013771057,
0.3945366442203522,
0.7607799172401428,
0.04527120664715767,
1.1545193195343018,
-0.37700414657592773,
0.2544454336166382,
1.1088188886642456,
-0.3172324597835541,
0.6005431413650513,
0.4577924609184265,
-0.18662959337234497,
0.5498476624488831,
0.7356294393539429,
0.09914222359657288,
0.41935399174690247,
0.5526048541069031,
-0.0022810478694736958,
-0.41072878241539,
0.21417608857154846,
-0.027444392442703247,
0.27663516998291016,
0.46201813220977783,
-0.41278278827667236,
-0.1986677497625351,
-0.4892357587814331,
-0.15920910239219666,
0.014220342971384525,
-0.4289802014827728,
0.6286805272102356,
0.2820068299770355,
-0.8360807299613953,
0.3642098903656006,
0.15624792873859406,
0.37265992164611816,
-0.43890780210494995,
0.09435243159532547,
-0.25780314207077026,
0.06431076675653458,
-0.1467769294977188,
-0.7858262658119202,
0.40825214982032776,
-0.2736590504646301,
-0.31927499175071716,
-0.5028735995292664,
0.912673830986023,
-0.22048471868038177,
-0.5697962641716003,
0.29755929112434387,
0.9202866554260254,
0.029243815690279007,
-0.07375933229923248,
-0.75044184923172,
-0.44434237480163574,
0.05572165921330452,
-0.2947813868522644,
0.42245152592658997,
0.6053358316421509,
0.04714878648519516,
0.9881260395050049,
0.8065434098243713,
0.008060994558036327,
-0.16499541699886322,
-0.06308700144290924,
0.3568434715270996,
-0.7439173460006714,
-0.5072169899940491,
-1.1007204055786133,
0.07691279798746109,
0.07703432440757751,
-0.033142730593681335,
0.872915506362915,
0.4205074906349182,
0.5421933531761169,
0.11623577773571014,
0.9925130605697632,
0.3840753436088562,
0.5411204099655151,
-0.7392329573631287,
0.5363936424255371,
-0.5100435018539429,
0.44186073541641235,
-0.13170666992664337,
-0.6781970858573914,
-0.19394326210021973,
0.8708823323249817,
-0.7031655311584473,
-0.1341097205877304,
0.46491774916648865,
1.0082159042358398,
-0.07292177528142929,
0.3553932309150696,
0.303239107131958,
0.32473936676979065,
0.2117663323879242,
0.19758598506450653,
0.9414256811141968,
0.07689128071069717,
-0.09354127943515778,
-0.26937007904052734,
-0.31672611832618713,
-0.06045065447688103,
-1.2195128202438354,
-1.126755952835083,
-0.5190504193305969,
-0.2363058626651764,
-0.38982588052749634,
0.03302546218037605,
0.8537943959236145,
0.7219958305358887,
-0.707155704498291,
-0.5541187524795532,
-0.563561201095581,
0.22420477867126465,
-0.011905849911272526,
-0.20032086968421936,
0.12450209259986877,
-0.34234023094177246,
0.006877950858324766,
0.7276245355606079,
0.40890344977378845,
0.27565833926200867,
-0.5523117780685425,
-0.028718126937747,
0.043482039123773575,
0.38733622431755066,
0.5792324542999268,
0.020030571147799492,
-0.7184203863143921,
-0.22356177866458893,
-0.08663038909435272,
0.1478119045495987,
0.0817430317401886,
0.8771774768829346,
-0.8502864837646484,
0.2695949971675873,
0.35790354013442993,
0.36180341243743896,
0.6513243317604065,
-0.1811162531375885,
1.08516526222229,
-0.017916986718773842,
-0.17659349739551544,
0.08275119215250015,
0.6335963010787964,
0.32569706439971924,
-0.1739889681339264,
0.862290620803833,
0.3070530891418457,
-0.43771442770957947,
-0.6059471964836121,
0.40383222699165344,
-0.6975315809249878,
-0.5227873921394348,
1.1914526224136353,
-0.14135801792144775,
-0.44775423407554626,
-0.04445166140794754,
0.07439269125461578,
0.06165340542793274,
-0.24729278683662415,
0.827183723449707,
0.44269055128097534,
-0.4243844747543335,
0.07585547119379044,
-0.5441911816596985,
0.435048371553421,
0.6116639971733093,
-0.5379590392112732,
0.21268923580646515,
0.36990588903427124,
0.5849600434303284,
-0.09268272668123245,
0.821380615234375,
0.13768887519836426,
0.053019579499959946,
-0.15767288208007812,
-0.19525136053562164,
0.2602490186691284,
-0.2775711417198181,
-0.29936423897743225,
0.3071289360523224,
0.02519257366657257,
0.36229968070983887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04779v1 | StableMask: Refining Causal Masking in Decoder-only Transformer | 2024-02-07T12:01:02 | 2024-02-07T12:01:02 | Qingyu Yin, Xuzheng He, Xiang Zhuang, Yu Zhao, Jianhua Yao, Xiaoyu Shen, Qiang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The decoder-only Transformer architecture with causal masking and relative
position encoding (RPE) has become the de facto choice in language modeling.
Despite its exceptional performance across various tasks, we have identified
two limitations: First, it requires all attention scores to be non-zero and sum
up to 1, even if the current embedding has sufficient self-contained
information. This compels the model to assign disproportional excessive
attention to specific tokens. Second, RPE-based Transformers are not universal
approximators due to their limited capacity at encoding absolute positional
information, which limits their application in position-critical tasks. In this
work, we propose StableMask: a parameter-free method to address both
limitations by refining the causal mask. It introduces pseudo-attention values
to balance attention distributions and encodes absolute positional information
via a progressively decreasing mask ratio. StableMask's effectiveness is
validated both theoretically and empirically, showing significant enhancements
in language models with parameter sizes ranging from 71M to 1.4B across diverse
datasets and encoding methods. We further show that it naturally supports (1)
efficient extrapolation without special tricks such as StreamingLLM and (2)
easy integration with existing attention optimization techniques. | [
-0.29049649834632874,
-0.5258178114891052,
0.3115089535713196,
0.3062189817428589,
-0.39114874601364136,
-0.2842855155467987,
-0.21438457071781158,
-0.5549296736717224,
0.49793383479118347,
0.39224085211753845,
-0.43643665313720703,
-0.3537376821041107,
-0.9374122023582458,
-0.14534984529018402,
-0.42804715037345886,
0.8439879417419434,
0.012951198033988476,
-0.353495329618454,
-0.14234136044979095,
-0.14392903447151184,
-0.5125821828842163,
-0.36584949493408203,
-0.49008360505104065,
-0.16861951351165771,
0.5350834131240845,
0.43215858936309814,
0.9090178608894348,
0.9486722350120544,
0.45799341797828674,
0.2783321738243103,
0.11230681091547012,
0.009055392816662788,
-0.7279167175292969,
0.3556520640850067,
-0.10829827189445496,
-0.37831175327301025,
-0.35505610704421997,
0.23135048151016235,
0.9433948993682861,
0.624680757522583,
-0.2956632971763611,
0.42144402861595154,
-0.13227210938930511,
0.5423698425292969,
-0.9885973930358887,
0.2582668364048004,
-0.6129376292228699,
0.04848800227046013,
-0.039224110543727875,
-0.0457729734480381,
-0.8081865906715393,
-0.0555405393242836,
-0.07517040520906448,
-0.5062423348426819,
0.24994665384292603,
-0.20727892220020294,
1.0634499788284302,
0.8198186755180359,
-0.215440034866333,
0.4011450409889221,
-0.7584308385848999,
1.031894564628601,
-0.4993093013763428,
0.819610595703125,
0.6048117280006409,
0.26273465156555176,
0.02965480461716652,
-0.7313328981399536,
-0.005034137982875109,
-0.06251988559961319,
-0.4174669086933136,
0.10720695555210114,
-0.3211662173271179,
0.08923739194869995,
0.32677605748176575,
0.014119858853518963,
-0.19312959909439087,
-0.21264906227588654,
-0.22124488651752472,
-0.2085402011871338,
0.3700917065143585,
0.02654285915195942,
0.16198700666427612,
-0.0017839657375589013,
-0.42301812767982483,
-0.10504399240016937,
-0.6454242467880249,
0.16448742151260376,
0.18533870577812195,
0.16643968224525452,
0.0009857594268396497,
0.5253469944000244,
-0.2632930278778076,
0.8949997425079346,
0.38199344277381897,
-0.09272661060094833,
-0.11724689602851868,
0.022926367819309235,
-0.33012300729751587,
0.05018157139420509,
0.530106782913208,
0.11981130391359329,
-0.1813661754131317,
-0.4069301187992096,
-0.04287418723106384,
0.40351343154907227,
0.6371812224388123,
-0.7753833532333374,
-0.38978058099746704,
0.20823357999324799,
-0.17819786071777344,
-0.37708303332328796,
0.16831281781196594,
-0.8230876326560974,
-0.16925841569900513,
-0.345065176486969,
0.2126052975654602,
0.09768824279308319,
-0.2565719783306122,
0.3502291440963745,
0.2039017230272293,
0.2924385666847229,
0.15191702544689178,
-0.9832117557525635,
0.2279149293899536,
0.5094209313392639,
0.556022584438324,
-0.09314051270484924,
-0.21746042370796204,
-0.6954329609870911,
0.2890948951244354,
-0.44334763288497925,
0.9059326648712158,
-0.6574406623840332,
0.12491673231124878,
-0.2155054658651352,
0.14813704788684845,
-0.1780364066362381,
-0.15204033255577087,
0.6086081266403198,
-0.6918880343437195,
0.07814832031726837,
0.029063470661640167,
-0.16401307284832,
0.014934519305825233,
0.14370125532150269,
-0.817893385887146,
1.0553524494171143,
0.016564181074500084,
-0.7078074216842651,
0.267561137676239,
-0.16662384569644928,
-0.4518108069896698,
-0.14127197861671448,
-0.11282234638929367,
-0.8040677309036255,
0.10874819755554199,
0.14701803028583527,
0.38171109557151794,
-0.2654287815093994,
0.6805914044380188,
-0.23096050322055817,
-0.4243653118610382,
0.08370648324489594,
-0.5385367274284363,
0.5909811854362488,
-0.027256114408373833,
-0.7927489280700684,
0.23850369453430176,
-0.8660006523132324,
-0.06791989505290985,
0.07196447998285294,
-0.13707557320594788,
-0.1571817547082901,
0.12613406777381897,
-0.29631564021110535,
0.5243008136749268,
-0.04012010619044304,
-0.4622606635093689,
-0.03577619791030884,
-0.2420702576637268,
0.39276930689811707,
0.736271321773529,
-0.1642119288444519,
0.5349546074867249,
-0.1096314787864685,
0.6269904971122742,
-0.24671611189842224,
0.35087698698043823,
-0.15555797517299652,
-0.6700969338417053,
-0.9928194880485535,
-0.5233278870582581,
0.3187991976737976,
0.45505020022392273,
-0.39622193574905396,
0.485281765460968,
-0.4352706968784332,
-0.46058863401412964,
-0.5744007229804993,
-0.18788257241249084,
0.4092458188533783,
0.8153989911079407,
0.4418801963329315,
-0.12114178389310837,
-0.5266575813293457,
-1.135193109512329,
-0.15464866161346436,
-0.35291191935539246,
0.0011652131797745824,
-0.22363658249378204,
-0.1424645036458969,
-0.09570065140724182,
0.8566737771034241,
-0.5305835604667664,
-0.27121424674987793,
0.033716000616550446,
-0.12479608505964279,
0.12366281449794769,
0.3196027874946594,
0.23179513216018677,
-0.6183501482009888,
-0.4482123851776123,
-0.3125636577606201,
-0.5961726307868958,
-0.23661640286445618,
-0.12445659190416336,
-0.29001516103744507,
-0.02034616656601429,
0.7075453996658325,
-0.7368046045303345,
0.42181968688964844,
0.666920006275177,
-0.4488339424133301,
0.27139317989349365,
0.07946746051311493,
0.04190247878432274,
-0.6215904951095581,
0.37655821442604065,
0.018972408026456833,
-0.6319975852966309,
-0.8975667357444763,
0.2650110125541687,
0.42023029923439026,
-0.3192442059516907,
-0.6905773878097534,
0.5010591745376587,
-0.5126651525497437,
0.3272249400615692,
-0.3391604721546173,
0.18647876381874084,
0.1183006688952446,
0.7490637302398682,
0.1540399193763733,
0.4245806634426117,
0.5694206953048706,
-0.3614650070667267,
0.1165529415011406,
0.19001662731170654,
-0.2072562724351883,
0.14388690888881683,
-0.5510779023170471,
0.16694305837154388,
-0.2096678614616394,
0.29382142424583435,
-1.1824010610580444,
-0.07079087942838669,
0.5851640701293945,
-0.12577779591083527,
0.5758991837501526,
-0.41564324498176575,
-0.1733798384666443,
-0.0578426755964756,
-0.4070393443107605,
0.622976541519165,
0.5848810076713562,
-0.3523145914077759,
0.5163174271583557,
0.7199543714523315,
-0.019995762035250664,
-0.9649729132652283,
-0.6671364307403564,
0.16560256481170654,
-0.31063249707221985,
-0.6539791822433472,
0.3449153006076813,
0.1315755546092987,
-0.001406054012477398,
-0.06531572341918945,
-0.5395650863647461,
0.20487752556800842,
-0.011066422797739506,
0.12486124038696289,
0.1243937537074089,
-0.20544655621051788,
-0.1296316236257553,
0.006632971111685038,
-0.91727215051651,
-0.021824326366186142,
-0.35417190194129944,
0.14740359783172607,
-0.14711417257785797,
-0.258550226688385,
-0.4074024260044098,
0.5100002884864807,
0.8223344087600708,
-0.2653486132621765,
0.872667670249939,
0.40606561303138733,
-0.41116929054260254,
-0.18026453256607056,
-0.6474177837371826,
-0.33481472730636597,
-0.4692777991294861,
0.266798734664917,
-0.34801316261291504,
-1.0064032077789307,
0.7546347379684448,
0.17913495004177094,
0.04527324438095093,
0.36799687147140503,
0.47897711396217346,
0.3859214782714844,
1.1022124290466309,
0.6096526384353638,
0.0363047756254673,
0.46325770020484924,
0.031406331807374954,
0.4908483922481537,
-0.7018728256225586,
-0.11889691650867462,
-0.47027549147605896,
-0.49966931343078613,
-0.17669692635536194,
-0.26185446977615356,
0.039290692657232285,
0.1915569305419922,
0.10349883139133453,
0.4792264699935913,
-0.6761420369148254,
0.7507399916648865,
0.28104230761528015,
0.20561985671520233,
0.08460310846567154,
0.00425330176949501,
0.13908450305461884,
-0.262498676776886,
-0.8165503740310669,
-0.2455318123102188,
0.6948052644729614,
0.4445311427116394,
0.727746307849884,
0.0628909021615982,
0.17308549582958221,
-0.10022891312837601,
0.29578691720962524,
-0.7123352885246277,
0.5805056095123291,
-0.1122572273015976,
-0.5059131383895874,
-0.3550800681114197,
-0.18236415088176727,
-0.8011308908462524,
0.46688205003738403,
0.05969642475247383,
-0.5402873754501343,
0.5679372549057007,
0.36884361505508423,
-0.2746242582798004,
0.17154502868652344,
-0.8538578748703003,
1.0207778215408325,
0.31357064843177795,
-0.5708387494087219,
0.10434834659099579,
-1.0684973001480103,
0.3646807372570038,
-0.0562468022108078,
0.03403892368078232,
-0.35345396399497986,
-0.15377308428287506,
0.6615114808082581,
-0.2304200679063797,
1.174545407295227,
-0.14478570222854614,
-0.14344169199466705,
0.28129395842552185,
0.2797011435031891,
0.8586492538452148,
0.30278781056404114,
-0.006062275264412165,
0.3634358048439026,
-0.17298945784568787,
-0.6160145998001099,
-0.7541633248329163,
0.6959297060966492,
-0.7600367069244385,
-0.9026855826377869,
-0.28872790932655334,
-0.3374541401863098,
-0.31630730628967285,
0.26648449897766113,
0.15536093711853027,
0.3833792805671692,
0.278392493724823,
0.3014715313911438,
0.7204612493515015,
0.1750025898218155,
0.2803519368171692,
0.5822898745536804,
0.08706433326005936,
-0.3709944784641266,
0.7241472601890564,
-0.04400421306490898,
0.36968716979026794,
0.4645932912826538,
0.3871903121471405,
-0.34989050030708313,
-0.35193830728530884,
-0.337125301361084,
0.3406737744808197,
-1.0184334516525269,
-0.4208850860595703,
-0.7370119690895081,
-0.15100370347499847,
-0.23416991531848907,
-0.12582506239414215,
-0.7646562457084656,
-0.7116767764091492,
0.020942602306604385,
-0.3870800733566284,
0.12413646280765533,
0.09498587995767593,
-0.1434241235256195,
0.1131911501288414,
-0.5638339519500732,
0.6994584798812866,
0.39903703331947327,
0.6776384115219116,
-0.15113388001918793,
-0.49934542179107666,
-0.4071235954761505,
-0.14264748990535736,
0.06541500240564346,
-0.7848708033561707,
0.07693608850240707,
0.18264883756637573,
0.6386958360671997,
0.4696902334690094,
0.368861585855484,
0.8281233310699463,
-0.6274415254592896,
0.7909995913505554,
0.033860910683870316,
-0.8545069694519043,
0.405648797750473,
-0.2828950583934784,
0.39974603056907654,
0.668777585029602,
-0.06961561739444733,
-0.5492615699768066,
-0.8944749236106873,
-0.666564404964447,
-1.038832426071167,
1.1232479810714722,
0.43735387921333313,
0.21468695998191833,
-0.20275849103927612,
0.4019070565700531,
0.0789104700088501,
-0.004834530409425497,
-0.8424098491668701,
-0.4594995677471161,
-0.4632418751716614,
-0.033881932497024536,
-0.0019404038321226835,
-0.48233187198638916,
-0.24979445338249207,
-0.3595569431781769,
0.8726649880409241,
0.09274722635746002,
0.4919135570526123,
0.22742706537246704,
-0.2819296419620514,
-0.5068349838256836,
0.10676520317792892,
1.08187997341156,
0.729555070400238,
-0.16054581105709076,
0.7437619566917419,
-0.09227120131254196,
-0.5824705362319946,
0.4287424087524414,
-0.009906632825732231,
-0.36213141679763794,
0.06544121354818344,
0.16452611982822418,
0.8929573893547058,
0.42531728744506836,
-0.29463666677474976,
0.5138449668884277,
-0.1500847488641739,
0.1126646175980568,
0.16004818677902222,
-0.15291230380535126,
-0.10229139775037766,
-0.14649523794651031,
0.07471586763858795,
0.4186497926712036,
-0.09586911648511887,
0.1740974336862564,
0.5822529196739197,
0.20788800716400146,
-0.7223052978515625,
-0.48218345642089844,
0.864280104637146,
-0.007591939531266689,
-0.1303633749485016,
0.36413073539733887,
0.18061880767345428,
-0.19760794937610626,
0.37356820702552795,
0.8126116991043091,
1.1200071573257446,
-0.7104815244674683,
0.29090502858161926,
0.39302265644073486,
0.5579443573951721,
-0.30413979291915894,
-0.2824721038341522,
-0.15271489322185516,
-0.6861340403556824,
-0.7504722476005554,
-0.4388354420661926,
-0.22769102454185486,
0.08125942200422287,
-0.48495426774024963,
0.5358986854553223,
-0.42330506443977356,
-0.09021501988172531,
-0.28907063603401184,
-0.4809095859527588,
-0.20546972751617432,
0.17313271760940552,
-0.03477031737565994,
0.40931183099746704,
-0.863234281539917,
0.8386446237564087,
0.6398584842681885,
-0.0030673088040202856,
-0.7830237746238708,
-0.1831054985523224,
-0.17391493916511536,
-0.8051328063011169,
0.15426954627037048,
0.18968331813812256,
-0.5379263162612915,
0.09026648849248886,
-0.2912864685058594,
-1.1270434856414795,
0.7697380185127258,
0.8778542876243591,
-0.3360781669616699,
0.028605002909898758,
0.11464539915323257,
0.3443313241004944,
0.05419880896806717,
0.1105327233672142,
0.33539479970932007,
0.4629434645175934,
0.07570037990808487,
-0.5023131966590881,
0.2944612205028534,
-0.4654056131839752,
-0.1306590884923935,
0.7006842494010925,
-0.7835677862167358,
0.4259859621524811,
0.27902552485466003,
-0.3733718991279602,
-0.3873290717601776,
0.5841339826583862,
0.09815023094415665,
-0.19967997074127197,
0.4862753450870514,
0.7065370082855225,
0.3288235366344452,
0.0035076227504760027,
1.051591396331787,
-0.4971199631690979,
0.6080722212791443,
0.9486624598503113,
0.1868514120578766,
0.6071115136146545,
0.6744331121444702,
0.04405881091952324,
0.23469524085521698,
0.5031852722167969,
0.2075706273317337,
0.8055893778800964,
-0.2113155722618103,
-0.10154701769351959,
-0.5182507038116455,
0.19831635057926178,
-0.3388059437274933,
0.14616376161575317,
0.0716475173830986,
-0.1304851770401001,
-0.43971434235572815,
-0.0957813635468483,
0.10419468581676483,
-0.1339740753173828,
-0.1361386626958847,
0.4645911157131195,
0.24381868541240692,
-0.7292187213897705,
0.8392456769943237,
0.26188623905181885,
0.3112194240093231,
-0.8402488827705383,
0.11108068376779556,
-0.15355001389980316,
0.13940352201461792,
-0.14541712403297424,
-0.29838475584983826,
0.7332577705383301,
-0.37674322724342346,
-0.2595479488372803,
-0.5262553691864014,
0.9722303152084351,
-0.5053515434265137,
-0.4456724524497986,
0.20919592678546906,
-0.07187340408563614,
-0.13406352698802948,
0.017927058041095734,
-0.5967233777046204,
0.16339166462421417,
-0.10421323031187057,
-0.4999163746833801,
0.1783788800239563,
0.18388807773590088,
-0.1848386526107788,
0.564530611038208,
0.5883165597915649,
-0.11865971237421036,
0.3839428424835205,
0.007989923469722271,
0.6857482194900513,
-0.5499297976493835,
-0.8603988289833069,
-0.9032678008079529,
0.9236665368080139,
0.27384334802627563,
-0.02802165225148201,
0.6844444870948792,
0.2874199151992798,
0.5228901505470276,
-0.2517063021659851,
0.2736258804798126,
0.27319592237472534,
0.049019765108823776,
-0.4681265652179718,
0.596882700920105,
-0.28142648935317993,
0.27534133195877075,
-0.3810417950153351,
-1.2348228693008423,
-1.0290651321411133,
0.7676661014556885,
-0.1953793466091156,
-0.2547190487384796,
0.7797120213508606,
0.6396856307983398,
-0.35701611638069153,
-0.019417382776737213,
0.648019015789032,
0.11502822488546371,
0.34736281633377075,
0.34852486848831177,
0.837792694568634,
-0.7132444977760315,
0.6510823369026184,
-0.26997455954551697,
-0.39080914855003357,
-0.07455391436815262,
-1.0039935111999512,
-0.7019311785697937,
-0.44807305932044983,
-0.698307991027832,
-0.2814039885997772,
-0.1480223834514618,
0.4262267053127289,
0.922899603843689,
-0.874549388885498,
0.09902585297822952,
-0.162021666765213,
0.15088814496994019,
-0.32300126552581787,
-0.17776137590408325,
0.5145827531814575,
-0.4278440773487091,
-0.5131127238273621,
0.5006179213523865,
0.664078414440155,
-0.14173178374767303,
-0.21824191510677338,
0.14819511771202087,
-0.09113392233848572,
0.17489773035049438,
0.6920686960220337,
0.41483867168426514,
-0.787324845790863,
-0.684883713722229,
0.1745586395263672,
-0.04134288430213928,
0.29123470187187195,
0.9584982991218567,
-0.8100036978721619,
0.5325321555137634,
0.49926313757896423,
0.633683443069458,
0.5127279162406921,
0.09794250875711441,
0.48426175117492676,
-1.042956829071045,
0.645821750164032,
0.16424567997455597,
0.2542869746685028,
0.16379636526107788,
-0.5020322203636169,
0.23441991209983826,
0.1635807752609253,
-0.462385892868042,
-0.8998913764953613,
0.49418905377388,
-1.0476455688476562,
-0.09207238256931305,
0.9920775294303894,
-0.017245860770344734,
-0.2135368138551712,
-0.3649473488330841,
-0.030685067176818848,
0.15177150070667267,
-0.30946114659309387,
0.9435024261474609,
0.7102789282798767,
-0.019917050376534462,
-0.5681789517402649,
-0.26274263858795166,
0.5210703611373901,
0.625947117805481,
-0.36882683634757996,
0.3800916075706482,
0.29764023423194885,
0.19206775724887848,
0.3588063418865204,
0.5600098967552185,
-0.39042219519615173,
0.25267118215560913,
-0.017416244372725487,
-0.127084419131279,
-0.2016294300556183,
-0.6567885279655457,
-0.4396788775920868,
0.5075003504753113,
-0.15324167907238007,
-0.19606085121631622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05147v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05147v3 | ApiQ: Finetuning of 2-Bit Quantized Large Language Model | 2024-02-07T09:36:54 | 2024-06-21T14:03:48 | Baohao Liao, Christian Herold, Shahram Khadivi, Christof Monz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Memory-efficient finetuning of large language models (LLMs) has recently
attracted huge attention with the increasing size of LLMs, primarily due to the
constraints posed by GPU memory limitations and the effectiveness of these
methods compared to full finetuning. Despite the advancements, current
strategies for memory-efficient finetuning, such as QLoRA, exhibit inconsistent
performance across diverse bit-width quantizations and multifaceted tasks. This
inconsistency largely stems from the detrimental impact of the quantization
process on preserved knowledge, leading to catastrophic forgetting and
undermining the utilization of pretrained models for finetuning purposes. In
this work, we introduce a novel quantization framework, ApiQ, designed to
restore the lost information from quantization by concurrently initializing the
LoRA components and quantizing the weights of LLMs. This approach ensures the
maintenance of the original LLM's activation precision while mitigating the
error propagation from shallower into deeper layers. Through comprehensive
evaluations conducted on a spectrum of language tasks with various LLMs, ApiQ
demonstrably minimizes activation error during quantization. Consequently, it
consistently achieves superior finetuning results across various bit-widths. | [
-0.12205833196640015,
-0.9083523154258728,
0.4715469777584076,
0.19926171004772186,
-0.4418157637119293,
0.015238044783473015,
-0.3578174114227295,
0.041802916675806046,
-0.42090272903442383,
0.49812984466552734,
-0.21979592740535736,
-0.4624215364456177,
-0.29624074697494507,
-0.3032684326171875,
-0.26018235087394714,
0.901983380317688,
0.07872218638658524,
0.10020948201417923,
-0.04136810451745987,
-0.25172123312950134,
-0.37846383452415466,
-0.43601635098457336,
-1.1244738101959229,
-0.3997500240802765,
0.3975721001625061,
0.2749219834804535,
0.6847983598709106,
0.6052998900413513,
0.20423199236392975,
0.191453754901886,
-0.03800581023097038,
0.20539969205856323,
-0.7338657975196838,
-0.11942658573389053,
0.07045730948448181,
-0.9228222966194153,
-0.4252339005470276,
-0.28136104345321655,
0.8419392108917236,
0.8105664849281311,
-0.20054377615451813,
0.2996145486831665,
0.21686454117298126,
0.8948928713798523,
-0.7220918536186218,
0.1089758574962616,
-0.7245312333106995,
0.033719614148139954,
-0.15516677498817444,
-0.18494237959384918,
-0.31482502818107605,
-0.4799952208995819,
0.04790989309549332,
-0.7514171004295349,
-0.12708836793899536,
-0.17802368104457855,
0.6216458678245544,
0.7131345868110657,
-0.36926034092903137,
0.027281226590275764,
-0.8514593243598938,
0.9393239617347717,
-0.8417723774909973,
0.47642964124679565,
0.5025938749313354,
0.16584889590740204,
0.15733838081359863,
-0.7096778750419617,
-0.4943704605102539,
0.19437503814697266,
0.3135848343372345,
-0.0405011922121048,
-0.19510890543460846,
0.23898454010486603,
0.13370616734027863,
0.5440175533294678,
-0.5112669467926025,
0.26210176944732666,
-0.1551862359046936,
-0.3672535717487335,
0.161048024892807,
0.018594950437545776,
0.05587827414274216,
0.24881577491760254,
-0.3717241585254669,
-0.010405583307147026,
-1.0444539785385132,
0.17287984490394592,
0.33832794427871704,
0.2909754514694214,
0.11453072726726532,
0.38024523854255676,
-0.23587104678153992,
0.3936755955219269,
0.06196806952357292,
-0.1926867812871933,
0.1320231556892395,
-0.24410420656204224,
-0.32304245233535767,
-0.05302172899246216,
0.6928235292434692,
0.23473858833312988,
0.05290836840867996,
-0.18395203351974487,
-0.3257814943790436,
0.06861801445484161,
-0.13271205127239227,
-1.0706241130828857,
-0.2703686058521271,
0.5113900899887085,
-0.2840268313884735,
0.06532920897006989,
-0.3787515461444855,
-0.1934608519077301,
-0.2912738621234894,
-0.4405090808868408,
0.7021752595901489,
-0.6682574152946472,
-0.1893662065267563,
0.10753706842660904,
0.12111354619264603,
0.3370665907859802,
0.20546245574951172,
-1.0039476156234741,
0.39257293939590454,
0.9149393439292908,
0.6405619382858276,
0.12433604151010513,
-0.03332424908876419,
-0.7231214046478271,
0.00904014054685831,
-0.5353091955184937,
0.38568946719169617,
-0.07634841650724411,
0.1555500328540802,
-0.07742952555418015,
-0.26180124282836914,
0.3062712848186493,
-0.7335538864135742,
0.4144197106361389,
-0.8436225056648254,
-0.20286297798156738,
-0.12829086184501648,
-0.6410215497016907,
-0.10133358836174011,
0.20910543203353882,
-0.6618075966835022,
0.9563125967979431,
0.3414831757545471,
-0.3625321090221405,
0.12387245893478394,
-0.08199603110551834,
-0.17726755142211914,
0.05392806977033615,
-0.09603346884250641,
-0.5685533285140991,
0.2710258662700653,
-0.009083638899028301,
0.1578701287508011,
-0.2875683903694153,
0.19546711444854736,
-0.17471787333488464,
-0.6716516017913818,
0.1786227971315384,
-0.6247860193252563,
0.873841404914856,
0.2163785845041275,
-0.22745582461357117,
0.04602880775928497,
-0.8555832505226135,
0.35971346497535706,
-0.0792771726846695,
-0.6642076969146729,
-0.7165631055831909,
-0.2596123516559601,
-0.1296546310186386,
0.07119381427764893,
0.37193337082862854,
-0.42178988456726074,
0.21772083640098572,
-0.7832246422767639,
0.7717872858047485,
0.682372510433197,
-0.0875629261136055,
0.7238409519195557,
-0.20464791357517242,
0.37344714999198914,
-0.05371692031621933,
0.1070522591471672,
-0.07544387876987457,
-0.06655478477478027,
-0.9606241583824158,
-0.21698446571826935,
0.5853694081306458,
0.6676251292228699,
-0.9775226712226868,
0.252304345369339,
-0.16719229519367218,
-0.2554149031639099,
-0.7711165547370911,
0.31119757890701294,
0.6834003925323486,
0.013655108399689198,
0.214350163936615,
-0.10163959860801697,
-0.4844299256801605,
-0.7263475656509399,
-0.126986563205719,
0.17436103522777557,
-0.32668691873550415,
0.051412783563137054,
0.009045650251209736,
-0.337255597114563,
0.7812634110450745,
-0.14278022944927216,
-0.3335297107696533,
0.08208746463060379,
0.17043817043304443,
0.12905654311180115,
0.7551639676094055,
0.4022621512413025,
-0.3345261514186859,
-0.301442414522171,
-0.10546303540468216,
-0.3965936303138733,
-0.13714498281478882,
-0.17357531189918518,
-0.47085240483283997,
0.46969524025917053,
0.6851003170013428,
-0.6663281917572021,
0.1365644633769989,
0.6338401436805725,
-0.20762977004051208,
0.5240570306777954,
-0.12485535442829132,
-0.1862458437681198,
-0.8250488042831421,
-0.08988486975431442,
-0.43496474623680115,
-0.4069726765155792,
-0.4166977107524872,
0.2069878727197647,
0.3116307854652405,
0.007985341362655163,
-0.5419109463691711,
0.654166579246521,
-0.4282817840576172,
-0.14006534218788147,
-0.38432759046554565,
0.15226954221725464,
0.13379469513893127,
0.7402028441429138,
-0.42552047967910767,
0.8245905041694641,
0.6077631711959839,
-0.7137845158576965,
0.21097685396671295,
0.13463996350765228,
-0.17722532153129578,
0.5542964339256287,
-0.5942199230194092,
0.16817711293697357,
-0.12711645662784576,
-0.08095317333936691,
-0.9793691039085388,
0.13075987994670868,
0.12423291802406311,
-0.3333825170993805,
0.21197660267353058,
-0.40707600116729736,
-0.7210957407951355,
-0.0391492024064064,
-0.39876288175582886,
0.9172301888465881,
0.7043366432189941,
-0.5995165109634399,
0.6340922117233276,
0.21403248608112335,
-0.22253935039043427,
-0.38720786571502686,
-0.765284538269043,
-0.2928953170776367,
-0.3108818531036377,
-0.277298241853714,
0.1175125315785408,
-0.18542855978012085,
-0.20716622471809387,
-0.1181669682264328,
-0.22400866448879242,
-0.1455536186695099,
0.20040737092494965,
0.17020662128925323,
0.1085987463593483,
-0.3186390995979309,
0.44368255138397217,
0.26435771584510803,
-0.1465773731470108,
0.02814478985965252,
-0.7093668580055237,
0.9737541079521179,
-0.29815492033958435,
-0.22257490456104279,
-0.6804028153419495,
0.0954064279794693,
0.3779877722263336,
-0.4519263803958893,
0.6489124298095703,
0.7913019061088562,
-0.4381178319454193,
-0.25783565640449524,
-0.480499267578125,
-0.12067804485559464,
-0.4569690227508545,
0.46865326166152954,
-0.3204481899738312,
-1.092539668083191,
0.6983740329742432,
-0.283132404088974,
0.08934284001588821,
0.378266841173172,
0.43087759613990784,
-0.026451436802744865,
0.9064245820045471,
0.5416902899742126,
0.03661402314901352,
0.5810630321502686,
-0.5458756685256958,
0.08305775374174118,
-1.0539134740829468,
0.18414022028446198,
-0.1177961528301239,
-0.2514558434486389,
-0.370356023311615,
-0.5861997604370117,
0.28539079427719116,
0.6644433736801147,
-0.63819420337677,
-0.0553385391831398,
-0.10418455302715302,
0.5440464615821838,
0.8146317601203918,
0.2418368011713028,
0.4193103015422821,
0.1576286107301712,
0.11993442475795746,
0.2570541203022003,
-0.6667406558990479,
-0.510259211063385,
1.3104426860809326,
0.3638419806957245,
0.8397218585014343,
0.30628064274787903,
0.7007492780685425,
-0.032961659133434296,
-0.0868566483259201,
-1.0065277814865112,
0.354436457157135,
-0.3497896194458008,
-0.3159925937652588,
-0.7048978805541992,
-0.5423785448074341,
-0.9044097065925598,
0.16263806819915771,
-0.10607336461544037,
-0.5064868927001953,
0.007961215451359749,
0.4658493995666504,
-1.2124347686767578,
0.18520571291446686,
-0.7169515490531921,
0.7987281084060669,
-0.12242525070905685,
-0.5854252576828003,
-0.23176193237304688,
-0.41911211609840393,
0.5677026510238647,
-0.29377231001853943,
0.13045336306095123,
-0.2199259251356125,
-0.20418813824653625,
0.6369317770004272,
-0.6837481260299683,
0.8108581900596619,
-0.15280067920684814,
-0.508655309677124,
0.4121460020542145,
0.20695760846138,
0.5196231603622437,
0.2751995921134949,
0.024974744766950607,
-0.021021617576479912,
0.279171347618103,
-0.45713236927986145,
-0.5717350840568542,
0.7442662715911865,
-0.796231746673584,
-0.32978951930999756,
0.14078837633132935,
-0.5784667134284973,
-0.3589743971824646,
0.3849599063396454,
0.08717513829469681,
0.6412638425827026,
0.11433135718107224,
0.1892377883195877,
0.8786515593528748,
-0.24061790108680725,
0.37547567486763,
0.3799220025539398,
-0.17823632061481476,
-0.5455284118652344,
1.1559364795684814,
0.1026325598359108,
0.5233206748962402,
0.2821505069732666,
0.07572666555643082,
-0.18088439106941223,
-0.7097687721252441,
-0.3744221031665802,
0.19858084619045258,
-0.5332867503166199,
-0.5639501810073853,
-0.3481992483139038,
-0.18946360051631927,
-0.21639974415302277,
0.2821493446826935,
-0.8260257244110107,
-0.6502202153205872,
-0.4666062295436859,
0.19355900585651398,
0.2956678867340088,
0.14601098001003265,
-0.011442005634307861,
0.7299423217773438,
-0.9292137622833252,
0.4344424307346344,
0.6307963728904724,
0.7355537414550781,
0.1549508273601532,
-0.5658425092697144,
-0.4024793803691864,
0.14862056076526642,
-0.18738137185573578,
-0.2298838496208191,
0.20383068919181824,
0.49160003662109375,
0.20792347192764282,
0.5324652194976807,
0.13973821699619293,
0.6619107127189636,
-0.5814955830574036,
0.41441184282302856,
-0.020872844383120537,
-1.0430989265441895,
0.3108561635017395,
-0.20713002979755402,
0.6239349246025085,
0.6059903502464294,
0.15458980202674866,
-0.38992834091186523,
-0.31906139850616455,
-0.3965873718261719,
-1.218573808670044,
0.503277063369751,
0.10982666909694672,
0.20637458562850952,
0.08404333144426346,
0.44420793652534485,
0.20523938536643982,
0.2777233421802521,
-0.5812464952468872,
-0.247239887714386,
0.016845978796482086,
-0.333464115858078,
0.18992410600185394,
-0.6440691947937012,
-0.16114315390586853,
-0.08706273138523102,
0.7130834460258484,
-0.23581506311893463,
0.16741377115249634,
-0.09387455880641937,
-0.25604525208473206,
-0.16244803369045258,
0.31420958042144775,
0.33261093497276306,
0.674827516078949,
-0.03513237461447716,
0.3505816161632538,
0.10463856160640717,
-0.34641343355178833,
0.07339148223400116,
0.254784494638443,
-0.3581046462059021,
-0.4038410484790802,
0.15371593832969666,
1.0038021802902222,
0.389839768409729,
-0.890748918056488,
0.3367123007774353,
-0.06958571821451187,
-0.03822527453303337,
-0.5896700620651245,
0.08281336724758148,
0.06623569130897522,
0.6045612692832947,
0.48957520723342896,
-0.04947291314601898,
0.15620923042297363,
-0.5911669731140137,
0.17329362034797668,
0.5463010668754578,
-0.11015339940786362,
-0.21528133749961853,
0.6907697319984436,
0.1402866244316101,
-0.06845774501562119,
0.6988579034805298,
-0.47386524081230164,
-0.3738670349121094,
0.3576345145702362,
0.4772918224334717,
0.5699266791343689,
-0.047815967351198196,
-0.21035820245742798,
0.5070708990097046,
-0.021583525463938713,
-0.2552682161331177,
0.4256627857685089,
0.061237066984176636,
-0.7182562351226807,
-0.6313852667808533,
-0.8202024698257446,
0.01316798198968172,
0.23361125588417053,
-0.5863140821456909,
-0.053501781076192856,
-0.7115126848220825,
-0.33729788661003113,
-0.3708054721355438,
-0.05075553432106972,
-0.5546311140060425,
0.03696436434984207,
0.34516608715057373,
0.6904909610748291,
-0.4357244670391083,
0.9175414443016052,
0.23308204114437103,
-0.26854580640792847,
-1.0542876720428467,
-0.19848471879959106,
-0.17717239260673523,
-0.8207356929779053,
0.4623110294342041,
-0.0674935057759285,
0.07619528472423553,
0.6539244055747986,
-0.5182706713676453,
-1.0881439447402954,
1.194608449935913,
0.511837899684906,
-0.965065598487854,
-0.04880571737885475,
0.18728137016296387,
0.3835509717464447,
0.20698559284210205,
-0.01265435479581356,
0.9779397249221802,
0.11045671999454498,
0.04600011184811592,
-0.9781056642532349,
0.03641912713646889,
0.025763098150491714,
0.13669592142105103,
0.27400287985801697,
-0.7452207207679749,
1.0468175411224365,
-0.1630571037530899,
-0.30972591042518616,
0.5529065728187561,
0.6893903613090515,
0.544082522392273,
-0.018397843465209007,
0.41947299242019653,
0.8270296454429626,
0.9255949854850769,
-0.20954959094524384,
0.7770513296127319,
-0.24292685091495514,
0.44664180278778076,
1.2842868566513062,
0.15642616152763367,
1.0231451988220215,
0.5643281936645508,
-0.3978584110736847,
0.01209089532494545,
0.4885938763618469,
0.2392853945493698,
0.5274260640144348,
0.40383800864219666,
-0.35300955176353455,
-0.3188217878341675,
0.05335438996553421,
-0.23520153760910034,
0.3674874007701874,
0.2567656338214874,
0.05158502608537674,
-0.018833188340067863,
0.297055721282959,
0.029951130971312523,
-0.10448124259710312,
-0.7404958605766296,
0.7992187142372131,
0.1342039853334427,
-0.46535205841064453,
1.118446707725525,
-0.13665427267551422,
0.7853997349739075,
-0.35433441400527954,
-0.06009984016418457,
-0.5861675143241882,
0.38637882471084595,
-0.03482939302921295,
-0.477963924407959,
0.11698359996080399,
-0.293952614068985,
-0.1610632687807083,
-0.01811576448380947,
0.31299474835395813,
-0.8576845526695251,
-0.3663722574710846,
-0.16700541973114014,
0.34660476446151733,
0.08577240258455276,
-0.41999462246894836,
-0.34414324164390564,
0.42333680391311646,
-0.08000088483095169,
-0.06546448171138763,
0.26482534408569336,
0.7414698004722595,
-0.09977124631404877,
0.7211443185806274,
0.49797317385673523,
0.0147032979875803,
0.3254200220108032,
0.3325248956680298,
0.8097398281097412,
-0.576389491558075,
-0.464181125164032,
-0.7954300045967102,
0.3752170205116272,
0.39972808957099915,
-0.12947013974189758,
0.6586537957191467,
0.7699601054191589,
0.8465030789375305,
-0.1795152723789215,
0.6422898173332214,
0.24637505412101746,
0.42530977725982666,
-0.9067748785018921,
0.8247299790382385,
-0.44273513555526733,
0.4848968982696533,
-0.0047026509419083595,
-0.9034274220466614,
-0.3290075659751892,
0.4218442440032959,
-0.04270843043923378,
-0.09588386863470078,
0.5396244525909424,
0.5861769914627075,
0.12953831255435944,
-0.5676417946815491,
0.34982889890670776,
0.41220757365226746,
0.14240656793117523,
0.9965188503265381,
0.7848759293556213,
-0.7392529249191284,
0.7709017992019653,
-0.2297038733959198,
-0.24876177310943604,
-0.21261455118656158,
-0.5036119222640991,
-0.7537602782249451,
-0.4643603265285492,
-0.4408036768436432,
-0.1449117660522461,
0.006740855053067207,
0.8488029837608337,
0.7411795258522034,
-0.8105400204658508,
-0.021008916199207306,
-0.26509228348731995,
-0.024115705862641335,
-0.14229732751846313,
-0.2470117062330246,
0.5032600164413452,
-0.4914086163043976,
-0.8500028252601624,
0.07979513704776764,
0.04663046449422836,
0.3208201825618744,
-0.2954874634742737,
-0.21947956085205078,
0.1833474338054657,
-0.0302590224891901,
0.8733120560646057,
0.4636833071708679,
-0.7677329182624817,
-0.14507988095283508,
-0.36987578868865967,
-0.27372753620147705,
-0.06222447380423546,
0.5318149328231812,
-1.0349485874176025,
0.08371172100305557,
0.20768409967422485,
0.9038559794425964,
0.2606460154056549,
0.02621152251958847,
0.4551437795162201,
-0.7581675052642822,
0.39279159903526306,
0.21546441316604614,
0.2074269950389862,
0.30520913004875183,
-0.2031344622373581,
0.3833095133304596,
-0.07181506603956223,
-0.5521649718284607,
-0.7668525576591492,
0.1161157414317131,
-1.0872660875320435,
-0.23770636320114136,
1.2212858200073242,
-0.06452710926532745,
-0.30709803104400635,
0.2333695888519287,
-0.4716712236404419,
0.41763541102409363,
-0.288698673248291,
0.5767903923988342,
0.26003292202949524,
0.11835645139217377,
-0.4061972200870514,
-0.580510675907135,
0.7611526250839233,
0.41667136549949646,
-0.5473629236221313,
0.29744815826416016,
0.5461263060569763,
0.3322764039039612,
-0.10681024938821793,
0.6341306567192078,
0.0660688504576683,
0.3168269097805023,
-0.1870095282793045,
0.2652623653411865,
-0.060687292367219925,
-0.10439784079790115,
-0.38697776198387146,
0.07928245514631271,
0.5540362596511841,
-0.18483875691890717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04678v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04678v3 | FaithLM: Towards Faithful Explanations for Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T09:09:14 | 2024-06-26T07:43:11 | Yu-Neng Chuang, Guanchu Wang, Chia-Yuan Chang, Ruixiang Tang, Shaochen Zhong, Fan Yang, Mengnan Du, Xuanting Cai, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have become proficient in addressing complex
tasks by leveraging their extensive internal knowledge and reasoning
capabilities. However, the black-box nature of these models complicates the
task of explaining their decision-making processes. While recent advancements
demonstrate the potential of leveraging LLMs to self-explain their predictions
through natural language (NL) explanations, their explanations may not
accurately reflect the LLMs' decision-making process due to a lack of fidelity
optimization on the derived explanations. Measuring the fidelity of NL
explanations is a challenging issue, as it is difficult to manipulate the input
context to mask the semantics of these explanations. To this end, we introduce
FaithLM to explain the decision of LLMs with NL explanations. Specifically,
FaithLM designs a method for evaluating the fidelity of NL explanations by
incorporating the contrary explanations to the query process. Moreover, FaithLM
conducts an iterative process to improve the fidelity of derived explanations.
Experiment results on three datasets from multiple domains demonstrate that
FaithLM can significantly improve the fidelity of derived explanations, which
also provides a better alignment with the ground-truth explanations. | [
-0.21745897829532623,
-0.9279334545135498,
1.0577837228775024,
0.3106553852558136,
-0.4615665376186371,
0.13386505842208862,
-0.3084206283092499,
-0.19970445334911346,
-0.13237929344177246,
0.34621256589889526,
-0.7445143461227417,
-0.4768517017364502,
-0.5266252756118774,
0.07803046703338623,
-0.31440848112106323,
0.7175209522247314,
-0.3464639484882355,
0.26698142290115356,
-0.5066344141960144,
-0.03278138116002083,
-0.23981113731861115,
-0.3672351539134979,
-0.6429184079170227,
-0.7340531945228577,
0.5916273593902588,
0.23103627562522888,
1.006425380706787,
0.4894618093967438,
0.4433949291706085,
0.2782149314880371,
-0.03640735521912575,
0.2543030381202698,
-0.8046045899391174,
0.2917535901069641,
-0.3888956606388092,
-0.5232354402542114,
-0.31280258297920227,
-0.023298054933547974,
0.6467042565345764,
0.7997944355010986,
-0.09428240358829498,
0.18117430806159973,
0.16832230985164642,
0.5611212849617004,
-0.218997985124588,
-0.05846724659204483,
-0.9037721753120422,
0.07500326633453369,
-0.016913266852498055,
-0.4667901396751404,
-0.3900066018104553,
-0.5086879730224609,
0.09576256573200226,
-0.5208807587623596,
0.33052346110343933,
0.4606139361858368,
0.8485146760940552,
0.3269560933113098,
-0.23039838671684265,
-0.1312626302242279,
-0.7820063233375549,
1.1513259410858154,
-0.858527421951294,
0.5850474238395691,
0.5665316581726074,
0.33234843611717224,
-0.5444265604019165,
-0.514847993850708,
-0.5009526610374451,
-0.23873597383499146,
0.14246733486652374,
0.07911047339439392,
0.21663187444210052,
0.03047986328601837,
0.21165715157985687,
0.5511394739151001,
-0.6052247881889343,
-0.1212891936302185,
-0.05326654016971588,
-0.48642948269844055,
0.7897593975067139,
0.2380335032939911,
-0.09102194756269455,
0.3035382628440857,
-0.39721545577049255,
0.13409431278705597,
-0.8445268273353577,
-0.24390840530395508,
0.19112762808799744,
0.011562059633433819,
0.1142740398645401,
0.6365100741386414,
0.103356271982193,
0.8357349038124084,
0.01614191383123398,
-0.47828593850135803,
-0.16825298964977264,
-0.21538855135440826,
-0.5556339025497437,
0.03065229021012783,
0.7529425024986267,
0.2686205208301544,
0.2534823417663574,
-0.29273003339767456,
-0.281644344329834,
0.10680451989173889,
0.35636821389198303,
-0.73164302110672,
0.07533690333366394,
0.4645492732524872,
-0.7620952725410461,
-0.3297711908817291,
-0.29107099771499634,
-0.655797004699707,
-0.2151283472776413,
-0.5208554863929749,
0.5026246905326843,
-0.4552633464336395,
-0.17726270854473114,
0.3561187982559204,
-0.03356016054749489,
0.22183586657047272,
0.7174009084701538,
-0.5794720649719238,
0.036516524851322174,
0.6817029714584351,
0.6990606188774109,
-0.2535059154033661,
-0.14033302664756775,
-0.6498338580131531,
0.29622024297714233,
-0.41922664642333984,
0.4122098684310913,
-0.5055081248283386,
-0.36863023042678833,
0.014807606115937233,
-0.15354254841804504,
0.17032688856124878,
-0.16999894380569458,
0.6717930436134338,
-0.8190460205078125,
0.27946773171424866,
-0.5909503698348999,
-0.8981913924217224,
-0.37711799144744873,
0.4314444661140442,
-0.2960894703865051,
0.8442100286483765,
-0.07171214371919632,
-0.6670762896537781,
0.42408475279808044,
-0.648108720779419,
-0.315048485994339,
0.028949623927474022,
0.016508910804986954,
-0.5457189083099365,
0.4729195833206177,
0.09243922680616379,
0.34312769770622253,
-0.35204237699508667,
0.5771936178207397,
-0.8627191781997681,
-0.3705351650714874,
0.4599646031856537,
-0.9010928869247437,
0.8047782182693481,
0.37396517395973206,
-0.2614458501338959,
0.0026661453302949667,
-0.38902080059051514,
0.11996054649353027,
0.4102078378200531,
-0.1217382401227951,
-0.39688417315483093,
0.27336201071739197,
-0.3375605344772339,
-0.002676238538697362,
0.3305547833442688,
-0.3965059816837311,
0.13635846972465515,
-0.5072495341300964,
0.11960386484861374,
0.6778578162193298,
-0.10360655933618546,
0.34077373147010803,
-0.15891773998737335,
0.5231555104255676,
-0.2399042844772339,
0.6806080937385559,
-0.09528806805610657,
-0.4925272464752197,
-0.5471515655517578,
-0.11629898101091385,
0.29799824953079224,
-0.10280439257621765,
-0.6200482249259949,
0.0289346631616354,
-0.2910546362400055,
-0.013712521642446518,
-0.7307815551757812,
0.28416934609413147,
0.43401414155960083,
0.5069178938865662,
0.3719470202922821,
0.0028736270032823086,
-0.3311269283294678,
-0.9121665358543396,
-0.6212679147720337,
-0.39490270614624023,
-0.19810061156749725,
0.10939019173383713,
0.520633339881897,
-0.23935560882091522,
1.1502699851989746,
-0.2009909749031067,
0.04872197285294533,
0.10584770888090134,
0.2985202372074127,
0.15140986442565918,
0.015432274900376797,
0.23913174867630005,
-1.0254130363464355,
-0.29825296998023987,
-0.11557476967573166,
-0.7260112762451172,
-0.12468917667865753,
-0.21173270046710968,
0.0036413208581507206,
0.1436258852481842,
0.3593805432319641,
-0.4284840524196625,
0.3366742730140686,
0.8303126096725464,
-0.4194241762161255,
0.7302939295768738,
-0.19353054463863373,
-0.053302690386772156,
-0.6466212272644043,
-0.241436168551445,
-0.2854759693145752,
-0.6370589137077332,
-0.36420127749443054,
0.340570330619812,
0.11869244277477264,
0.3560624122619629,
-0.2362951785326004,
0.635979175567627,
-0.6040122509002686,
-0.2214283049106598,
-0.2877293527126312,
0.15888890624046326,
0.5072866082191467,
0.1759861409664154,
-0.07295078039169312,
0.7851077914237976,
0.535976231098175,
-0.5267661213874817,
0.28247711062431335,
0.29212117195129395,
-0.06017317250370979,
0.16212549805641174,
-0.6907541155815125,
0.10815093666315079,
-0.16032499074935913,
0.08701847493648529,
-0.9923479557037354,
-0.23885677754878998,
0.11142141371965408,
-0.49779143929481506,
0.26963376998901367,
-0.34085506200790405,
-0.46578550338745117,
-0.5265629887580872,
-0.1870027780532837,
0.27181315422058105,
0.4140813946723938,
-0.8408782482147217,
0.9041855931282043,
-0.0968954935669899,
0.2526116669178009,
-0.39312684535980225,
-0.7476946115493774,
0.23520618677139282,
-0.32868096232414246,
-0.6832876205444336,
0.34516727924346924,
-0.379260778427124,
-0.7068225741386414,
0.04836564138531685,
-0.5023472309112549,
-0.035575658082962036,
0.35259810090065,
0.314615935087204,
0.3545985817909241,
-0.5587319731712341,
0.37158089876174927,
0.10297000408172607,
0.06463411450386047,
0.5217035412788391,
-0.39817559719085693,
0.37211912870407104,
-0.380113422870636,
-0.8470421433448792,
-0.2066250741481781,
0.18687589466571808,
0.7086978554725647,
-0.2440589815378189,
1.167383074760437,
0.584312379360199,
-0.06428101658821106,
-0.2883797883987427,
-0.6671375036239624,
-0.2874012887477875,
-0.501934289932251,
-0.27027130126953125,
-0.5900110006332397,
-0.9616013169288635,
0.5143885016441345,
-0.21678435802459717,
0.3001594543457031,
0.550369381904602,
0.708348274230957,
-0.16081316769123077,
1.2084519863128662,
0.4279925227165222,
0.22426758706569672,
-0.090445876121521,
0.22894014418125153,
0.43075236678123474,
-0.5519900918006897,
-0.3145565092563629,
-0.4450337290763855,
0.09917008876800537,
-0.10822170972824097,
-0.7602089643478394,
0.15970547497272491,
0.3645460903644562,
0.03829314187169075,
-0.14933829009532928,
-0.2142837941646576,
0.3343118727207184,
0.27280521392822266,
-0.11041714996099472,
0.539143979549408,
0.11610482633113861,
-0.4407026171684265,
-0.19203148782253265,
-0.6096618175506592,
-0.6728314161300659,
0.8509806990623474,
0.7772526741027832,
0.947510302066803,
0.1697845160961151,
0.6032105684280396,
0.1591356247663498,
0.6898996233940125,
-0.8660068511962891,
0.1715187281370163,
0.17822249233722687,
-0.616733968257904,
-0.5331680774688721,
-0.5467454195022583,
-0.6525349617004395,
0.4636659324169159,
-0.06396540999412537,
-0.3937246799468994,
-0.11337445676326752,
0.26372939348220825,
-0.2998667061328888,
0.08767804503440857,
-0.3881499469280243,
0.568448543548584,
-0.6269289255142212,
-0.6378262042999268,
-0.287660151720047,
-0.3390268385410309,
0.6311812996864319,
-0.4142288863658905,
0.33065730333328247,
-0.07014431059360504,
0.1250586062669754,
0.41472482681274414,
-0.549087643623352,
0.6169338226318359,
-0.06235921010375023,
-0.6022698283195496,
0.10863737761974335,
0.36599114537239075,
0.6427282691001892,
0.2979499399662018,
-0.6438106298446655,
0.35637712478637695,
-0.26343783736228943,
-0.3286358714103699,
-0.8059371113777161,
0.6002821922302246,
-0.3165435492992401,
-0.9220189452171326,
-0.11209829896688461,
-0.44315555691719055,
-0.44208770990371704,
0.0028973708394914865,
0.06575106084346771,
0.45942339301109314,
-0.13494046032428741,
0.3385099470615387,
0.9816575050354004,
-0.4732761085033417,
0.23179900646209717,
0.7890734076499939,
-0.6613852381706238,
-0.07994035631418228,
0.6433296799659729,
-0.3323909342288971,
0.35696160793304443,
0.14105305075645447,
0.5256290435791016,
-0.8026826977729797,
-0.847896158695221,
-0.35054025053977966,
0.3171478807926178,
-0.6132723093032837,
-0.17792853713035583,
-0.41539013385772705,
-0.009032824076712132,
-0.15500189363956451,
-0.13733527064323425,
-0.32213446497917175,
-0.043516188859939575,
-0.319959819316864,
0.011564553715288639,
0.41383644938468933,
0.487571656703949,
0.3681987524032593,
0.2999320924282074,
-0.731087863445282,
0.7363395094871521,
0.4468107223510742,
0.7259184718132019,
-0.056928880512714386,
-0.8686151504516602,
-0.019349653273820877,
0.555801510810852,
-0.0394602045416832,
-0.9149024486541748,
0.4337478578090668,
0.3339722752571106,
0.6059062480926514,
0.6724621057510376,
0.07347153127193451,
1.1847844123840332,
-0.5285294651985168,
0.7541673183441162,
0.16154423356056213,
-1.1545100212097168,
0.5400005578994751,
-0.30971747636795044,
0.28606823086738586,
0.5116022229194641,
0.35253873467445374,
-0.21224093437194824,
-0.7819299697875977,
-0.5891802906990051,
-0.45663899183273315,
0.43067389726638794,
0.4049500524997711,
0.16968153417110443,
0.09054946899414062,
0.6388707756996155,
0.37928563356399536,
0.17774082720279694,
-0.6720719337463379,
-0.3276848793029785,
-0.2733374536037445,
-0.20095767080783844,
0.17213651537895203,
-0.4024987816810608,
-0.38906264305114746,
-0.3021911680698395,
0.8947361707687378,
-0.466291218996048,
0.2158556431531906,
0.47294315695762634,
-0.2382589727640152,
-0.6017422676086426,
0.07009043544530869,
0.6592746376991272,
1.1797254085540771,
0.027461355552077293,
0.29001903533935547,
0.25455573201179504,
-0.01347863208502531,
-0.24769403040409088,
-0.18261344730854034,
0.029151322320103645,
0.3232966363430023,
0.6324143409729004,
0.746753454208374,
-0.020821979269385338,
-0.49851396679878235,
0.618808388710022,
-0.3483012914657593,
-0.5413026809692383,
-0.37368080019950867,
0.007779635023325682,
0.3361566960811615,
0.19426411390304565,
0.4803991913795471,
-0.24209384620189667,
0.0892874225974083,
-0.4772697389125824,
0.19703088700771332,
0.8142324686050415,
-0.29915839433670044,
-0.13617201149463654,
0.8656101226806641,
-0.08254221081733704,
-0.32426223158836365,
0.38838592171669006,
-0.1317615658044815,
-0.8480883240699768,
0.36694929003715515,
0.6244073510169983,
0.7982646822929382,
-0.32223713397979736,
0.49976053833961487,
0.11773532629013062,
0.28336891531944275,
-0.2717147767543793,
0.305034875869751,
0.023193707689642906,
-0.7737327218055725,
-1.0774776935577393,
-1.125038504600525,
-0.5240573883056641,
0.32997411489486694,
-0.6076463460922241,
-0.13581153750419617,
-0.2649390697479248,
0.026099596172571182,
-0.052273016422986984,
-0.0628071203827858,
-0.6882469058036804,
0.24420659244060516,
0.12715980410575867,
1.074737310409546,
-0.7144273519515991,
0.9029355049133301,
0.3042863607406616,
-0.11248425394296646,
-0.8069503903388977,
0.21262012422084808,
-0.0762733444571495,
-1.046032428741455,
0.7505738735198975,
-0.033116962760686874,
-0.3941182792186737,
-0.37208032608032227,
-0.76377934217453,
-0.8034571409225464,
0.6695109605789185,
0.5849700570106506,
-0.858775794506073,
0.39272356033325195,
0.18465018272399902,
0.8112223744392395,
-0.22684141993522644,
0.12291333824396133,
0.23468318581581116,
0.9958258271217346,
0.16752320528030396,
-0.6511805653572083,
0.13109233975410461,
0.2523995339870453,
-0.07238970696926117,
0.10794809460639954,
-0.360947847366333,
0.5278422832489014,
-0.18164986371994019,
-0.022807445377111435,
-0.17379243671894073,
0.8079367876052856,
0.34632933139801025,
0.3642558753490448,
0.6398934721946716,
0.1991468369960785,
0.8289265632629395,
-0.12653334438800812,
1.150704026222229,
-0.09764014184474945,
0.593143880367279,
1.0609251260757446,
-0.37461405992507935,
0.6093012690544128,
0.820223331451416,
-0.1787363588809967,
0.6532943248748779,
0.7061469554901123,
-0.10912241786718369,
0.10326880216598511,
0.18424946069717407,
-0.2146097868680954,
-0.7225823998451233,
-0.06230528652667999,
-0.14723528921604156,
0.47069332003593445,
0.3910450041294098,
-0.5896098613739014,
-0.2125011384487152,
-0.10225510597229004,
-0.17140303552150726,
0.015568017028272152,
-0.23319995403289795,
0.6461712718009949,
0.3764874041080475,
-0.7191869616508484,
0.8661841750144958,
-0.04935357719659805,
0.19005301594734192,
-0.6219703555107117,
-0.19106349349021912,
-0.18378235399723053,
0.05203436315059662,
-0.0987996980547905,
-0.8654922842979431,
0.5182844400405884,
-0.16346655786037445,
-0.1280156373977661,
-0.7892809510231018,
0.8148472309112549,
-0.6289893388748169,
-0.4681442975997925,
0.5054025650024414,
0.5189505219459534,
0.23843254148960114,
-0.33601802587509155,
-1.0282220840454102,
0.4125514030456543,
-0.0018833765061572194,
-0.4020301401615143,
0.03921955078840256,
0.6164708733558655,
-0.07981351017951965,
1.0132118463516235,
0.7961806654930115,
0.12058021128177643,
-0.17541156709194183,
0.3076883554458618,
0.6524768471717834,
-0.48507651686668396,
-0.213547483086586,
-1.1967368125915527,
0.27676382660865784,
-0.1335364282131195,
0.12031972408294678,
0.9288056492805481,
0.4481015205383301,
0.1992599219083786,
-0.1364552080631256,
0.608500063419342,
0.2964751422405243,
0.35374704003334045,
-0.7534182071685791,
0.5671496391296387,
-0.914012610912323,
0.4876489043235779,
0.0558144710958004,
-1.1646013259887695,
-0.22325177490711212,
0.6383132338523865,
-0.17748253047466278,
-0.16976335644721985,
0.757661759853363,
0.6163754463195801,
-0.318400114774704,
0.2014230191707611,
0.5200876593589783,
0.7440744042396545,
0.1762426346540451,
0.09291471540927887,
0.9678483009338379,
-0.19696837663650513,
0.4320003092288971,
0.1172826960682869,
0.07522435486316681,
-0.38540783524513245,
-1.3202258348464966,
-1.0510895252227783,
-0.22323811054229736,
-0.32070422172546387,
-0.2330431491136551,
0.07122878730297089,
0.6478694677352905,
0.646629273891449,
-0.9341914057731628,
0.06647257506847382,
-0.12468233704566956,
0.5126101970672607,
-0.1721835434436798,
-0.2727515399456024,
0.1738632172346115,
-0.4672567546367645,
-0.400534063577652,
0.7246914505958557,
0.3772566616535187,
-0.1324838101863861,
-0.6490376591682434,
-0.3390980064868927,
0.30722805857658386,
0.19192209839820862,
0.701461911201477,
-0.16207529604434967,
-1.2921392917633057,
-0.4574335515499115,
-0.09266460686922073,
0.16713379323482513,
0.02790823020040989,
0.7419840097427368,
-0.6376458406448364,
0.468501478433609,
0.30914220213890076,
0.718228816986084,
0.4701034128665924,
0.13921339809894562,
1.0659018754959106,
-0.5312804579734802,
-0.4594246447086334,
0.20162776112556458,
0.42268383502960205,
0.44190388917922974,
-0.3932036757469177,
0.44647231698036194,
-0.15023744106292725,
-0.48483726382255554,
-0.8225539326667786,
0.15536566078662872,
-0.8715041875839233,
-0.5175098776817322,
1.483001708984375,
-0.2828301191329956,
-0.31110692024230957,
-0.620857834815979,
-0.12657110393047333,
0.18857021629810333,
-0.18503858149051666,
0.8546431064605713,
0.944327712059021,
0.2523033022880554,
-0.12337341904640198,
-0.6166555285453796,
0.58357834815979,
0.592573344707489,
-0.6701334714889526,
0.34070611000061035,
0.41962552070617676,
0.41444677114486694,
-0.03181033954024315,
0.29073768854141235,
-0.25702589750289917,
0.06496874988079071,
-0.3714873194694519,
-0.14632081985473633,
-0.017595168203115463,
-0.2643861770629883,
-0.5057805180549622,
0.22730346024036407,
0.33289170265197754,
0.1532348245382309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04677v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04677v1 | Source Identification in Abstractive Summarization | 2024-02-07T09:09:09 | 2024-02-07T09:09:09 | Yoshi Suhara, Dimitris Alikaniotis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural abstractive summarization models make summaries in an end-to-end
manner, and little is known about how the source information is actually
converted into summaries. In this paper, we define input sentences that contain
essential information in the generated summary as $\textit{source sentences}$
and study how abstractive summaries are made by analyzing the source sentences.
To this end, we annotate source sentences for reference summaries and system
summaries generated by PEGASUS on document-summary pairs sampled from the
CNN/DailyMail and XSum datasets. We also formulate automatic source sentence
detection and compare multiple methods to establish a strong baseline for the
task. Experimental results show that the perplexity-based method performs well
in highly abstractive settings, while similarity-based methods perform robustly
in relatively extractive settings. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/suhara/sourcesum. | [
-0.20867739617824554,
-0.4537179470062256,
0.6501394510269165,
-0.14774823188781738,
-0.45969846844673157,
-0.1028129905462265,
-0.10620518028736115,
-0.659857451915741,
0.33373355865478516,
0.322783499956131,
-0.5749307870864868,
-0.2856234908103943,
-0.5719937682151794,
0.347591370344162,
-0.9392231702804565,
1.3158308267593384,
-0.2236611396074295,
-0.25584712624549866,
-0.31252115964889526,
-0.11124256253242493,
-0.07484765350818634,
-0.5670130252838135,
-0.41149288415908813,
-0.0249948687851429,
0.7353054881095886,
0.4370555579662323,
0.4960252344608307,
0.9311856627464294,
0.4511567950248718,
0.34385016560554504,
-0.20141787827014923,
0.20912471413612366,
-0.23843857645988464,
0.2866147756576538,
-0.0013587874127551913,
-0.14539125561714172,
-0.08719909936189651,
-0.030293330550193787,
0.636762261390686,
0.41391077637672424,
0.1036774143576622,
0.521023690700531,
0.052413877099752426,
0.47155553102493286,
-0.8650328516960144,
0.26514148712158203,
-0.42319735884666443,
0.1031702384352684,
-0.2399231195449829,
-0.24213674664497375,
-0.14661693572998047,
-0.3947177529335022,
0.1520524024963379,
-0.5901937484741211,
0.445302277803421,
-0.212922140955925,
1.0538147687911987,
0.1473279446363449,
-0.32870081067085266,
-0.5376892685890198,
-0.502802312374115,
0.31696397066116333,
-0.7783021926879883,
-0.22153830528259277,
0.16169364750385284,
0.32646211981773376,
0.08352316170930862,
-0.9436236619949341,
-0.6246710419654846,
-0.3449679911136627,
-0.4956861436367035,
0.1449262946844101,
-0.2801186740398407,
-0.13246431946754456,
0.0483173243701458,
0.2433794140815735,
-0.28509005904197693,
-0.2574182450771332,
-0.7085739970207214,
-0.2773725986480713,
0.5214785933494568,
0.09246376156806946,
0.3222337067127228,
-0.39293935894966125,
-0.04708011448383331,
0.17793162167072296,
-0.6846673488616943,
-0.16550354659557343,
0.3520360291004181,
0.26136675477027893,
-0.09525740146636963,
0.800765872001648,
-0.44232484698295593,
0.5887987017631531,
-0.17576053738594055,
0.16252931952476501,
0.25015026330947876,
-0.7045267820358276,
-0.22612586617469788,
0.40802618861198425,
0.7180434465408325,
0.25608697533607483,
0.39935070276260376,
-0.35106557607650757,
-0.2472490668296814,
-0.3264496624469757,
0.159013032913208,
-0.7087798714637756,
-0.12372718006372452,
0.1473080962896347,
-0.5864472389221191,
-0.679729700088501,
0.1691841185092926,
-0.17603236436843872,
-0.2732134759426117,
-0.441261351108551,
0.2386086881160736,
-0.20069876313209534,
-0.054119762033224106,
-0.5561214089393616,
-0.5475142598152161,
0.2205948382616043,
0.18381403386592865,
-0.8632362484931946,
0.3004770874977112,
0.5341371893882751,
1.0453015565872192,
-0.10363448411226273,
-0.264541357755661,
-0.5914467573165894,
0.18147513270378113,
-0.32681021094322205,
0.948584794998169,
-0.2555297911167145,
0.018070515245199203,
-0.16635318100452423,
-0.052616674453020096,
0.3103778660297394,
-0.5189166069030762,
0.5831189751625061,
-0.6869938373565674,
0.4369046986103058,
-0.42024484276771545,
-0.413896381855011,
-0.24682819843292236,
0.12192586809396744,
-0.7702594995498657,
0.2812391221523285,
-0.051595162600278854,
-1.0420416593551636,
0.06735958904027939,
-0.7882998585700989,
-0.574975311756134,
-0.2024049311876297,
-0.16465632617473602,
-0.0652988851070404,
0.4992802143096924,
0.20871976017951965,
0.5008365511894226,
-0.021705809980630875,
0.22130592167377472,
-0.03757477179169655,
-0.13552145659923553,
0.40740159153938293,
-0.2968730926513672,
0.682695746421814,
0.4242534339427948,
0.012014510110020638,
0.26928389072418213,
-0.989456832408905,
-0.41041937470436096,
0.28265443444252014,
-0.07598970830440521,
-0.46557387709617615,
0.20600713789463043,
0.29253625869750977,
0.13772936165332794,
0.26207396388053894,
-0.4924389123916626,
-0.12597115337848663,
-0.22470223903656006,
0.49689728021621704,
0.6866725087165833,
0.09348323941230774,
0.23624871671199799,
-0.16763630509376526,
0.2973020374774933,
-0.03835931792855263,
-0.33352282643318176,
-0.9167653322219849,
-0.17897096276283264,
-0.6158060431480408,
-0.02978556975722313,
0.5009068846702576,
0.5110361576080322,
-0.5138503909111023,
0.3714924156665802,
-0.13852348923683167,
-0.07479387521743774,
-0.08366815745830536,
-0.08021921664476395,
0.4213210940361023,
0.9194263815879822,
0.3236749768257141,
0.15593701601028442,
-0.7018795013427734,
-1.1035822629928589,
-0.25972750782966614,
0.02127528376877308,
-0.406961590051651,
-0.07094157487154007,
0.44717103242874146,
0.300889790058136,
0.9696183204650879,
-0.49887359142303467,
-0.07907872647047043,
-0.14912408590316772,
0.18404990434646606,
0.089356929063797,
0.4500254690647125,
0.39537668228149414,
-0.7975788712501526,
-0.20416481792926788,
-0.15732648968696594,
-1.1765934228897095,
-0.3291490077972412,
-0.37000206112861633,
-0.0066366721875965595,
-0.046159274876117706,
0.8953476548194885,
-0.5335896015167236,
0.29351717233657837,
0.2688586115837097,
-0.5291920900344849,
0.5437349081039429,
-0.14769551157951355,
-0.14169679582118988,
-1.3770767450332642,
0.3524433970451355,
0.16243600845336914,
-0.35380813479423523,
-0.2869572639465332,
0.2416462004184723,
-0.007094162050634623,
-0.041893161833286285,
-0.25608354806900024,
0.15294942259788513,
-0.6797348260879517,
-0.2965097427368164,
-0.5479932427406311,
0.25634729862213135,
-0.038530778139829636,
0.37894779443740845,
0.15055811405181885,
0.6295385956764221,
0.21099624037742615,
-0.4183511435985565,
0.45177432894706726,
0.22827991843223572,
-0.26754358410835266,
0.08850251883268356,
-1.0077152252197266,
-0.1560736447572708,
-0.47724780440330505,
0.3959095776081085,
-1.0597041845321655,
-0.3683587908744812,
0.41373059153556824,
-0.6252555251121521,
0.07088899612426758,
0.05420234799385071,
-0.5086904168128967,
0.43903648853302,
-0.13272053003311157,
0.370078444480896,
0.24865145981311798,
-0.3674905300140381,
0.5012205839157104,
0.2484324872493744,
-0.5468046069145203,
-0.6541439294815063,
-0.7234762907028198,
0.46755796670913696,
0.03779652714729309,
-0.2950926721096039,
0.5396201014518738,
0.2130497694015503,
-0.3913581371307373,
0.3776482045650482,
-0.21462656557559967,
-0.19616027176380157,
0.1903730034828186,
0.2585375905036926,
0.4126938581466675,
-0.37981492280960083,
0.13317617774009705,
0.3809817433357239,
-0.3381413221359253,
0.429941326379776,
-0.286709189414978,
-0.03213675320148468,
0.2276991903781891,
-0.09622987359762192,
-0.44435837864875793,
0.6014442443847656,
0.6802935004234314,
-0.23938851058483124,
0.44513893127441406,
0.3483586013317108,
-0.3829740285873413,
0.25854507088661194,
-0.10177755355834961,
-0.07252083718776703,
-0.38735252618789673,
0.488189160823822,
-0.3870501220226288,
-0.4672045409679413,
0.6559744477272034,
0.4100704789161682,
0.14926773309707642,
0.6808251142501831,
0.25106772780418396,
-0.02139100432395935,
0.587144672870636,
0.46757444739341736,
-0.13373757898807526,
0.4602581262588501,
-0.20938822627067566,
-0.29458940029144287,
-0.7579637169837952,
0.05123399570584297,
-0.5228533148765564,
-0.48006120324134827,
-0.3325401544570923,
0.08940081298351288,
0.09210067242383957,
0.015711303800344467,
0.012594680301845074,
0.3018862307071686,
-0.4780174791812897,
0.9447094202041626,
0.6400178670883179,
0.012183139100670815,
0.4782293438911438,
-0.0793568342924118,
0.018298855051398277,
0.27113643288612366,
-0.3606565296649933,
-0.546131432056427,
0.986693799495697,
0.20820847153663635,
0.16377484798431396,
0.2645789682865143,
0.6857579946517944,
0.3552601933479309,
0.47579944133758545,
-0.5751403570175171,
0.4785653352737427,
-0.0021305156406015158,
-0.31088176369667053,
-0.1420418620109558,
-0.486386775970459,
-0.7671298384666443,
0.3707441985607147,
-0.17573541402816772,
-0.3834770917892456,
0.19870249927043915,
-0.15209460258483887,
-0.3947272002696991,
-0.10829184204339981,
-0.6396068930625916,
0.6424212455749512,
0.016375988721847534,
0.05385113134980202,
-0.22504666447639465,
-0.7170083522796631,
0.5340844988822937,
0.008212476968765259,
-0.10783796012401581,
-0.08298544585704803,
-0.3617199659347534,
0.7232406139373779,
-0.5463021993637085,
0.4821349084377289,
-0.03610597178339958,
0.10192204266786575,
0.1390964239835739,
-0.22537223994731903,
0.22423675656318665,
0.24398690462112427,
0.17346197366714478,
0.26441633701324463,
-0.14706075191497803,
-0.5608025789260864,
-0.752924382686615,
0.6966148018836975,
-0.7991143465042114,
-0.40714573860168457,
-0.5742712020874023,
-0.4681093990802765,
0.22176074981689453,
0.4182552993297577,
0.6877941489219666,
0.6811875104904175,
-0.1265549510717392,
0.028456993401050568,
0.30914855003356934,
0.046379491686820984,
0.8410144448280334,
0.510640561580658,
0.058269646018743515,
-0.4943201243877411,
0.6035120487213135,
0.10139181464910507,
0.002880922518670559,
0.5552474856376648,
0.12375839054584503,
-0.1888856142759323,
-0.831875205039978,
-0.5999361872673035,
0.23310884833335876,
-0.6926931738853455,
-0.06334634870290756,
-0.5147609710693359,
-0.46465790271759033,
-0.3723514676094055,
-0.06162213906645775,
-0.018291793763637543,
-0.7609393000602722,
-0.41712459921836853,
-0.3743709325790405,
-0.059309348464012146,
0.7608906626701355,
0.14198605716228485,
-0.04551568254828453,
-0.9940531849861145,
0.45692795515060425,
0.18230316042900085,
-0.0731680616736412,
0.05367670953273773,
-0.4657610058784485,
-0.36040234565734863,
-0.2158721536397934,
-0.13690069317817688,
-1.1480270624160767,
0.33395615220069885,
0.12255117297172546,
0.5611134171485901,
0.4646131098270416,
0.25362783670425415,
0.19761376082897186,
-0.4215623140335083,
0.7872677445411682,
-0.001175844925455749,
-0.8469955325126648,
0.5317185521125793,
-0.25624707341194153,
0.4712715744972229,
0.5400670170783997,
0.24406547844409943,
-0.21844659745693207,
-0.6093980073928833,
-0.5515705347061157,
-0.8756177425384521,
0.6504729986190796,
0.49362868070602417,
0.3436347246170044,
0.06178748980164528,
0.6736639142036438,
-0.07132675498723984,
0.24789176881313324,
-0.6182659864425659,
-0.3829214572906494,
-0.27884891629219055,
-0.37367838621139526,
-0.05817009136080742,
-0.37783128023147583,
-0.24020472168922424,
0.1801634281873703,
0.4061913788318634,
0.023593779653310776,
0.06429733335971832,
0.47436246275901794,
-0.1813436597585678,
0.08880049735307693,
0.07436923682689667,
1.1607725620269775,
0.7480290532112122,
-0.2502794861793518,
0.23377585411071777,
-0.17088204622268677,
-0.47263315320014954,
-0.00196983409114182,
0.37872835993766785,
-0.3133632242679596,
0.5204995274543762,
0.6722578406333923,
0.39243581891059875,
0.03484101593494415,
-0.6210914254188538,
0.530777096748352,
-0.28035253286361694,
-0.03270938619971275,
-0.6479906439781189,
0.01567036285996437,
-0.09546114504337311,
0.29999658465385437,
0.7388142943382263,
0.3233475685119629,
0.6380893588066101,
-0.3561039865016937,
0.2624448239803314,
0.22741974890232086,
-0.19749334454536438,
-0.4757802188396454,
0.5870363712310791,
0.26028040051460266,
-0.1600981056690216,
0.5908381938934326,
-0.14880023896694183,
-0.17067821323871613,
0.7770288586616516,
0.4570343792438507,
1.410295009613037,
0.08549874275922775,
0.021534699946641922,
0.32284626364707947,
0.11395467817783356,
0.23966418206691742,
-0.2661954462528229,
-0.5921697616577148,
-0.773963451385498,
-0.8574414253234863,
-0.14184755086898804,
-0.46155330538749695,
0.16346530616283417,
-0.705868124961853,
0.26994627714157104,
-0.24844472110271454,
0.36592957377433777,
0.622101902961731,
-0.435055136680603,
0.1857990026473999,
0.007216516882181168,
0.529266357421875,
0.9292012453079224,
-0.9461302161216736,
0.6627223491668701,
0.6994044780731201,
-0.73833167552948,
-0.4914408028125763,
0.23197349905967712,
0.042991578578948975,
-0.4233461916446686,
0.7520929574966431,
0.0925816148519516,
-0.004634682089090347,
-0.23969042301177979,
-0.585918664932251,
-0.9212175011634827,
0.9933446049690247,
0.5933458805084229,
-0.12492269277572632,
-0.34542423486709595,
-0.43644922971725464,
0.3738694489002228,
-0.4559161961078644,
0.5129028558731079,
0.22044870257377625,
0.27861008048057556,
0.30803295969963074,
-0.590839684009552,
0.3061467707157135,
-0.7610430717468262,
-0.18125471472740173,
0.04808696359395981,
-0.28717777132987976,
0.9286238551139832,
-0.3744523525238037,
-0.228597491979599,
0.04682347550988197,
1.019688606262207,
0.4212055504322052,
0.5338267087936401,
0.28251826763153076,
0.2521999776363373,
0.4172971546649933,
0.14939747750759125,
1.0270462036132812,
-0.3331755995750427,
0.00018425991584081203,
1.4492243528366089,
0.2529507279396057,
0.8418916463851929,
0.41830483078956604,
0.26303625106811523,
0.8136878609657288,
0.5172526240348816,
-0.03598172962665558,
0.6624352931976318,
0.19129250943660736,
-0.06912548840045929,
0.3148418962955475,
0.1671973466873169,
-0.30667808651924133,
0.49336719512939453,
0.07209554314613342,
-0.9225542545318604,
-0.595316469669342,
-0.1792173832654953,
0.214799702167511,
-0.0417366586625576,
-0.323344886302948,
0.9888321757316589,
-0.10719413310289383,
-0.7717568278312683,
0.5432907342910767,
0.09067336469888687,
0.35758739709854126,
-0.6226208209991455,
-0.2039836347103119,
-0.31453609466552734,
-0.03364347666501999,
-0.495968222618103,
-0.46743056178092957,
0.6217339634895325,
0.19750629365444183,
-0.5433730483055115,
0.06353525072336197,
0.6514909863471985,
-0.3974149823188782,
-0.3885152339935303,
-0.2741876244544983,
0.19162629544734955,
0.1946491003036499,
-0.3184014558792114,
-0.26745283603668213,
-0.4204446077346802,
-0.05263742804527283,
-0.3404625654220581,
0.3876373767852783,
0.49370184540748596,
-0.033593952655792236,
0.30013778805732727,
0.6775185465812683,
0.23427551984786987,
-0.3562031090259552,
-0.18716630339622498,
0.9037681221961975,
-0.7394711375236511,
-0.8591454029083252,
-1.1141892671585083,
0.4822212755680084,
-0.44926807284355164,
-0.4798918068408966,
0.8701735734939575,
0.6557624936103821,
0.5635969638824463,
-0.07644489407539368,
1.0969359874725342,
-0.03933679684996605,
0.2995358407497406,
-0.5572856068611145,
0.6721476316452026,
-0.3017881214618683,
0.4434613287448883,
-0.09121500700712204,
-0.8677572011947632,
-0.32825079560279846,
0.48197925090789795,
0.02589421533048153,
-0.251455157995224,
0.798581600189209,
0.5000630617141724,
-0.213669091463089,
0.0822581797838211,
-0.006715776398777962,
0.04634230211377144,
0.2924129068851471,
0.2830698788166046,
0.8940420150756836,
-0.35833561420440674,
0.7185901999473572,
-0.09294983744621277,
-0.21236246824264526,
-0.1804972141981125,
-1.0519551038742065,
-0.44618791341781616,
-0.6957339644432068,
-0.4827830493450165,
-0.46877288818359375,
-0.12565204501152039,
0.7919220924377441,
0.6287115812301636,
-1.0527783632278442,
-0.15652993321418762,
-0.531766414642334,
0.27322983741760254,
-0.2639157474040985,
-0.21762792766094208,
0.5124263763427734,
-0.5863922834396362,
-0.6073459386825562,
0.21687760949134827,
0.17371679842472076,
0.08147040009498596,
-0.3328404426574707,
0.27799028158187866,
0.20531663298606873,
0.1704394817352295,
0.3887624740600586,
0.444882333278656,
-0.739061713218689,
-0.16016146540641785,
-0.01909240148961544,
-0.13967029750347137,
-0.2180803418159485,
1.0618257522583008,
-0.8204267621040344,
0.26325953006744385,
0.7522305846214294,
0.6129651069641113,
0.348021000623703,
0.23053033649921417,
0.691863477230072,
-0.788703203201294,
0.002300500636920333,
0.03164646029472351,
0.34941670298576355,
0.17462345957756042,
-0.4357408881187439,
0.44826340675354004,
0.14986921846866608,
-0.42305028438568115,
-0.8188302516937256,
-0.07522264868021011,
-0.9633990526199341,
-0.42490890622138977,
1.0580981969833374,
-0.30032166838645935,
-0.24397456645965576,
-0.16020967066287994,
-0.18450310826301575,
0.29142245650291443,
-0.3254531919956207,
0.8829768300056458,
0.6615281105041504,
-0.15826407074928284,
-0.3159850239753723,
-0.1685364693403244,
0.5222998261451721,
-0.026728034019470215,
-0.702534019947052,
-0.013093252666294575,
0.7584107518196106,
0.22830140590667725,
0.6294016242027283,
0.4725302755832672,
0.013268308714032173,
0.488543838262558,
-0.04685167223215103,
0.011612224392592907,
-0.6925538182258606,
-0.11721047759056091,
-0.5725812911987305,
0.5602844953536987,
-0.21244610846042633,
-0.6361096501350403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04636v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04636v1 | TransLLaMa: LLM-based Simultaneous Translation System | 2024-02-07T07:39:27 | 2024-02-07T07:39:27 | Roman Koshkin, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Decoder-only large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated
impressive capabilities in text generation and reasoning. Nonetheless, they
have limited applications in simultaneous machine translation (SiMT), currently
dominated by encoder-decoder transformers. This study demonstrates that, after
fine-tuning on a small dataset comprising causally aligned source and target
sentence pairs, a pre-trained open-source LLM can control input segmentation
directly by generating a special "wait" token. This obviates the need for a
separate policy and enables the LLM to perform English-German and
English-Russian SiMT tasks with BLEU scores that are comparable to those of
specific state-of-the-art baselines. We also evaluated closed-source models
such as GPT-4, which displayed encouraging results in performing the SiMT task
without prior training (zero-shot), indicating a promising avenue for enhancing
future SiMT systems. | [
-0.05623414367437363,
-0.63599693775177,
0.8789277672767639,
0.47985368967056274,
-0.6286554932594299,
0.09242174029350281,
-0.4232363998889923,
-0.19261334836483002,
0.03509119153022766,
0.4376877546310425,
-0.7609325051307678,
-0.5545774698257446,
-0.7236128449440002,
0.342977374792099,
-0.3471973240375519,
0.7113882899284363,
-0.4796847403049469,
0.3861461579799652,
0.021708568558096886,
-0.019469259306788445,
-0.7165625095367432,
-0.29743584990501404,
-0.48859652876853943,
-0.17904089391231537,
0.619290292263031,
0.40013206005096436,
0.9644531011581421,
0.8107988834381104,
0.6439096927642822,
0.2273695319890976,
0.10575636476278305,
0.21923238039016724,
-0.2170604020357132,
0.34462425112724304,
-0.23101283609867096,
-0.4303025007247925,
-0.2802455425262451,
-0.18154513835906982,
0.8195653557777405,
0.4974307417869568,
0.1779160499572754,
-0.04466717317700386,
-0.00912392232567072,
0.1089162677526474,
-0.44887712597846985,
-0.15705831348896027,
-0.6071750521659851,
0.12146855145692825,
-0.48449715971946716,
-0.21658742427825928,
-0.5687419176101685,
-0.46952176094055176,
-0.20040445029735565,
-0.5006236433982849,
-0.061405472457408905,
-0.11351445317268372,
0.9327443838119507,
0.6043574810028076,
-0.3322775363922119,
-0.046881500631570816,
-0.8288918733596802,
0.8432202339172363,
-0.6968578696250916,
0.5304412245750427,
0.010463771410286427,
0.2327808439731598,
-0.11835885047912598,
-0.6953735947608948,
-0.33682122826576233,
-0.21823136508464813,
-0.025889800861477852,
0.2585836946964264,
-0.05225503817200661,
-0.09154421836137772,
0.17651893198490143,
0.18742522597312927,
-0.8319909572601318,
0.12127567082643509,
-0.4759742021560669,
-0.10999295860528946,
0.4223647713661194,
0.21767733991146088,
0.40155401825904846,
0.2715727388858795,
-0.40944573283195496,
0.1394299566745758,
-0.717888593673706,
-0.3131140470504761,
-0.047258175909519196,
0.20030035078525543,
-0.20501257479190826,
0.8399321436882019,
0.014969896525144577,
0.8892276287078857,
-0.09946499019861221,
0.05354262888431549,
0.2541152238845825,
-0.517122745513916,
-0.4050108790397644,
0.02896231785416603,
1.127901554107666,
-0.1377537101507187,
0.2266795039176941,
-0.27639782428741455,
-0.13306641578674316,
0.2802872061729431,
0.12945517897605896,
-0.6211504340171814,
0.45129650831222534,
0.13052013516426086,
-0.12418488413095474,
-0.03621450811624527,
0.06435231864452362,
-0.3510812222957611,
0.1486649215221405,
-0.13688942790031433,
0.40628424286842346,
-0.29560473561286926,
-0.02328512631356716,
0.257102370262146,
0.2543954849243164,
0.2963992655277252,
0.31569892168045044,
-0.5113510489463806,
0.2127859741449356,
0.4170819818973541,
1.2677420377731323,
-0.5678208470344543,
-0.5063875317573547,
-0.6555860638618469,
0.448075532913208,
-0.45917534828186035,
0.5244830846786499,
-0.5268827676773071,
-0.4347865581512451,
-0.01130781602114439,
0.053458116948604584,
-0.26396873593330383,
-0.3158789873123169,
0.6208399534225464,
-0.5891748666763306,
0.04133659601211548,
-0.02112891525030136,
-0.3809750974178314,
0.0782061517238617,
0.17517177760601044,
-0.44028469920158386,
0.7758405804634094,
-0.010814530774950981,
-0.592484176158905,
0.1467571258544922,
-0.6895750164985657,
-0.7027652263641357,
0.15228162705898285,
-0.15152540802955627,
-0.24547773599624634,
0.21537989377975464,
0.34536197781562805,
0.3367803394794464,
-0.4299907684326172,
0.42118120193481445,
-0.19389599561691284,
-0.3370407819747925,
0.28342869877815247,
-0.4005208909511566,
0.48465168476104736,
0.218466654419899,
-0.27212822437286377,
0.38094738125801086,
-0.32092583179473877,
-0.15640737116336823,
0.16460146009922028,
-0.47980329394340515,
-0.1065417006611824,
-0.19238242506980896,
0.032170940190553665,
0.4549447000026703,
0.4580037295818329,
-0.7377967238426208,
0.2908451557159424,
-0.27476492524147034,
0.38710999488830566,
0.5813807845115662,
-0.22561481595039368,
0.3358173072338104,
-0.22133105993270874,
0.7341967821121216,
0.10979386419057846,
0.08455251157283783,
-0.35451585054397583,
-0.4538087844848633,
-0.9848225116729736,
-0.3512849509716034,
0.49071046710014343,
0.6852267384529114,
-0.8800601363182068,
0.22740042209625244,
-0.253727525472641,
-0.21924205124378204,
-0.7904976606369019,
0.09451261907815933,
0.23984287679195404,
0.27294009923934937,
0.3837006986141205,
-0.08348748087882996,
-0.3085629642009735,
-1.0228816270828247,
-0.16062553226947784,
0.2572779655456543,
0.009140568785369396,
-0.15842536091804504,
0.13671089708805084,
-0.14384283125400543,
0.6533029675483704,
-0.4650740921497345,
-0.37533119320869446,
-0.3403208255767822,
-0.09306130558252335,
0.271651029586792,
0.41730037331581116,
0.08596866577863693,
-0.5435721278190613,
-0.5335195064544678,
0.2131689041852951,
-0.8212824463844299,
-0.49129027128219604,
-0.17261722683906555,
-0.21073748171329498,
0.11958086490631104,
0.6422403454780579,
-0.6630241274833679,
0.3194037079811096,
0.6777384281158447,
-0.0004469115228857845,
0.03898656740784645,
-0.4313458204269409,
0.01801016740500927,
-1.2585088014602661,
-0.005963925737887621,
-0.09184753894805908,
-0.5541757941246033,
-0.5439481735229492,
0.17299380898475647,
0.2626071870326996,
-0.1417282074689865,
-0.7527235746383667,
0.4631516635417938,
-0.39741089940071106,
-0.2593761682510376,
-0.43002694845199585,
0.07264681905508041,
-0.20255126059055328,
0.3299330174922943,
0.4868573248386383,
0.8029608726501465,
0.4119229018688202,
-0.29206207394599915,
0.06459269672632217,
0.15952134132385254,
-0.15384265780448914,
0.1912008821964264,
-0.6809321045875549,
0.2872385084629059,
0.2086179405450821,
0.17970174551010132,
-0.5063936114311218,
-0.12849703431129456,
0.4491516947746277,
-0.19292229413986206,
0.18250682950019836,
0.09681258350610733,
-0.5216585397720337,
-0.2989431321620941,
0.08299324661493301,
0.5739774107933044,
0.5950160026550293,
-0.27638983726501465,
0.3999910354614258,
0.05744554474949837,
-0.302096962928772,
-0.4206749200820923,
-0.8160877823829651,
0.051742054522037506,
0.13674810528755188,
-0.5890326499938965,
0.1267431676387787,
-0.08840570598840714,
0.10970959067344666,
0.06065378338098526,
-0.02161075733602047,
-0.0533980093896389,
-0.03651505708694458,
0.35119256377220154,
0.3454683721065521,
-0.24850624799728394,
-0.05987418070435524,
0.4050481617450714,
-0.3086393475532532,
-0.38790902495384216,
-0.6226352453231812,
0.6624871492385864,
0.06888972967863083,
-0.4343521296977997,
-0.3320177495479584,
0.33338165283203125,
0.5998929142951965,
-0.5729597806930542,
0.5429811477661133,
0.42368385195732117,
-0.24467389285564423,
-0.33421915769577026,
-0.2617785334587097,
0.19363394379615784,
-0.4278365969657898,
0.25263094902038574,
-0.5471076965332031,
-1.143922209739685,
0.1571228951215744,
-0.1574537754058838,
0.2140435129404068,
0.352956086397171,
1.0861060619354248,
0.08732286095619202,
0.7992867827415466,
0.3840317726135254,
0.18587419390678406,
0.3034344017505646,
0.08188534528017044,
0.10055869072675705,
-0.5884077548980713,
-0.20180808007717133,
-0.33534714579582214,
-0.27380597591400146,
-0.3503161668777466,
-0.7221097946166992,
0.3762192130088806,
-0.03808276355266571,
0.06751583516597748,
0.26386719942092896,
-0.3475533425807953,
0.4923974871635437,
0.5616631507873535,
-0.0796840488910675,
0.4547902047634125,
-0.15406037867069244,
-0.42579713463783264,
0.022616395726799965,
-0.59403395652771,
-0.44343528151512146,
0.9368159174919128,
0.25663307309150696,
0.8246192336082458,
-0.2246141880750656,
0.8834832310676575,
0.14022283256053925,
0.18690656125545502,
-0.7845542430877686,
0.6808053851127625,
-0.359801709651947,
-0.4867991507053375,
-0.18758344650268555,
-0.4423173666000366,
-0.90062415599823,
0.4604884088039398,
0.1203380674123764,
-0.4474436044692993,
-0.06802010536193848,
0.04805842414498329,
-0.252577006816864,
0.2065080851316452,
-0.5011354088783264,
0.7751597762107849,
-0.45463746786117554,
-0.45816028118133545,
-0.04865371435880661,
-0.5644544959068298,
0.5291104912757874,
-0.5335660576820374,
0.09331335872411728,
-0.1761711686849594,
-0.2508358359336853,
0.4417484700679779,
-0.48368772864341736,
0.36311253905296326,
-0.03668493404984474,
-0.08789284527301788,
0.09211947023868561,
0.252868115901947,
0.1627199649810791,
0.0826483741402626,
0.07327412068843842,
0.4690770208835602,
-0.027653543278574944,
-0.27573978900909424,
-0.3735908567905426,
0.7742050886154175,
-0.7734206914901733,
-0.7412244081497192,
-0.6693611145019531,
-0.9767422080039978,
-0.1565668284893036,
0.5470438599586487,
0.2074180394411087,
-0.1256554275751114,
-0.24660032987594604,
0.09630130976438522,
0.3758937418460846,
-0.35647234320640564,
0.5163906216621399,
0.6935131549835205,
-0.4407479465007782,
-0.3931117653846741,
0.7718379497528076,
0.048212070018053055,
0.3255801498889923,
0.5758390426635742,
0.08242582529783249,
-0.19896432757377625,
-0.6657954454421997,
-0.6755905747413635,
0.3574625849723816,
-0.35559403896331787,
-0.330544114112854,
-0.6619620323181152,
-0.3804319500923157,
-0.268379807472229,
-0.23512589931488037,
-0.4144924581050873,
-0.39380890130996704,
-0.1670968383550644,
0.035769034177064896,
-0.16486713290214539,
0.8927382826805115,
-0.07673149555921555,
0.6337698698043823,
-0.9364677667617798,
0.4385623633861542,
0.028330525383353233,
0.14097832143306732,
-0.5346255302429199,
-0.34153321385383606,
-0.4166278541088104,
0.10672024637460709,
-0.29439622163772583,
-0.8616165518760681,
0.40675976872444153,
-0.17173919081687927,
0.25484591722488403,
0.11100997030735016,
-0.2748866081237793,
0.44479066133499146,
-0.7060067057609558,
0.6686455011367798,
0.17511196434497833,
-1.155251383781433,
0.5561148524284363,
-0.37047499418258667,
0.8236608505249023,
0.34209927916526794,
0.15459458529949188,
-0.5114588141441345,
-0.6414657831192017,
0.000029756518415524624,
-0.5123826861381531,
1.2811706066131592,
0.429627925157547,
-0.08513647317886353,
0.12389075011014938,
0.09378699958324432,
0.19431628286838531,
0.05197654664516449,
-0.7392613291740417,
0.09904831647872925,
-0.0940638929605484,
-0.5070847868919373,
-0.09797332435846329,
-0.07191174477338791,
0.16561371088027954,
0.0024432057980448008,
0.8605389595031738,
0.057750023901462555,
-0.03886492922902107,
0.09641070663928986,
-0.5135630965232849,
-0.263195276260376,
0.3767704963684082,
0.8271608352661133,
0.5044687390327454,
-0.27460864186286926,
-0.00045076321111992,
0.016063036397099495,
-0.414690226316452,
0.5926952958106995,
0.21133072674274445,
-0.7637919187545776,
0.25153765082359314,
0.2834666073322296,
0.9151281118392944,
0.19371464848518372,
-0.3898460268974304,
0.44436541199684143,
-0.21412529051303864,
-0.28483718633651733,
0.03576149418950081,
-0.16708937287330627,
0.30211010575294495,
0.298691064119339,
0.19305694103240967,
-0.019943101331591606,
-0.29394349455833435,
-0.024458181113004684,
0.1321324110031128,
0.32238054275512695,
-0.24025580286979675,
-0.3833986520767212,
0.7752765417098999,
0.18764136731624603,
-0.3819345235824585,
0.3303660452365875,
0.13039159774780273,
-0.24328738451004028,
0.33417394757270813,
0.8169155716896057,
0.9795069098472595,
-0.6084387898445129,
0.3284520208835602,
0.005711972247809172,
0.6776850819587708,
-0.28695055842399597,
0.3500441610813141,
-0.005948127247393131,
-0.6938731670379639,
-0.5462603569030762,
-0.8920031785964966,
-0.29264163970947266,
0.20325060188770294,
-0.4699152708053589,
0.4903484880924225,
-0.3430279493331909,
-0.14019596576690674,
-0.2701277434825897,
-0.3696606755256653,
-0.7687758207321167,
0.12392450869083405,
0.1918170154094696,
0.8415368795394897,
-0.8231841325759888,
1.2870898246765137,
0.8466653227806091,
-0.43924659490585327,
-0.5864132046699524,
0.12992358207702637,
-0.28889715671539307,
-0.8288766741752625,
0.6606483459472656,
0.015438951551914215,
-0.1858513206243515,
-0.0017603192245587707,
-0.18583734333515167,
-0.9167608022689819,
0.9485384821891785,
0.872252881526947,
-0.9134385585784912,
-0.3496878743171692,
0.5761362910270691,
0.2653462588787079,
-0.2182765007019043,
0.09360769391059875,
0.5904797315597534,
0.5547587871551514,
0.13126371800899506,
-1.0865530967712402,
0.0020776393357664347,
0.12819702923297882,
0.090626060962677,
0.2912752330303192,
-0.6846662163734436,
0.7566490173339844,
0.16718685626983643,
-0.2997244596481323,
0.05149051919579506,
0.6292624473571777,
0.21932488679885864,
0.08437871932983398,
0.2867250442504883,
0.5860393047332764,
0.28738102316856384,
-0.1965976357460022,
1.000589370727539,
-0.22660894691944122,
0.0785248652100563,
1.332248330116272,
-0.5183319449424744,
0.653517484664917,
0.5809063911437988,
0.12145698815584183,
0.09233372658491135,
0.6302219033241272,
0.057190991938114166,
0.6322712302207947,
0.06508070230484009,
-0.13515569269657135,
-0.4843609035015106,
-0.2275899052619934,
-0.4002346992492676,
0.5018599629402161,
0.3089374005794525,
-0.5326994061470032,
-0.3991474211215973,
0.22948434948921204,
-0.020495682954788208,
-0.08721053600311279,
-0.2397293895483017,
0.7351281642913818,
0.4591139853000641,
-0.6616060733795166,
0.3689054250717163,
0.3196312189102173,
0.4982612431049347,
-0.8960505127906799,
0.20204044878482819,
-0.4256599545478821,
0.18688969314098358,
-0.035144492983818054,
-0.5114591121673584,
0.186550572514534,
0.21628709137439728,
-0.00622937735170126,
-0.3814769387245178,
0.531313955783844,
-0.6983083486557007,
-0.8313577771186829,
0.4464275538921356,
0.8487520217895508,
0.12399209290742874,
0.26999157667160034,
-0.5320565104484558,
0.5683752298355103,
0.007929032668471336,
-0.2803775370121002,
0.07306739687919617,
0.33382347226142883,
-0.2014586329460144,
0.3993974030017853,
0.35012543201446533,
0.4306313395500183,
0.39236611127853394,
0.06606180220842361,
0.7138340473175049,
-0.5521858334541321,
-0.5175466537475586,
-1.0714205503463745,
0.23796778917312622,
0.2550848126411438,
-0.00450036209076643,
0.7012019157409668,
0.6576794981956482,
0.9613826870918274,
-0.20447246730327606,
1.0260624885559082,
0.2130957692861557,
0.22053806483745575,
-0.7162914276123047,
0.4579983055591583,
-0.542924702167511,
0.03685758262872696,
0.03749876096844673,
-1.2116308212280273,
-0.5630760788917542,
0.23684167861938477,
-0.3752640187740326,
-0.12792739272117615,
1.003052830696106,
0.7815651893615723,
-0.3468993902206421,
-0.18261417746543884,
0.7210845947265625,
0.11935946345329285,
0.15585562586784363,
0.8763871192932129,
0.9281128644943237,
-0.1208064928650856,
0.6213878989219666,
0.09889547526836395,
-0.030283382162451744,
-0.010850063525140285,
-0.5252176523208618,
-0.8872634172439575,
-0.377636581659317,
-0.16968323290348053,
-0.12943263351917267,
0.24456334114074707,
0.7596558332443237,
0.6139561533927917,
-0.7504571080207825,
-0.4093138873577118,
0.021623339504003525,
0.11660287529230118,
0.04398367926478386,
-0.09315372258424759,
0.17402246594429016,
-0.5120410919189453,
-0.9155900478363037,
0.7751128673553467,
0.721104085445404,
-0.07024864852428436,
-0.26505959033966064,
-0.29180464148521423,
-0.3516363799571991,
0.2851269841194153,
0.21352578699588776,
0.03000960312783718,
-0.8773444294929504,
-0.018704097718000412,
0.04612240567803383,
-0.1231498271226883,
0.23239123821258545,
1.1055914163589478,
-0.5229358673095703,
0.5267152786254883,
0.46339109539985657,
0.8319211602210999,
0.7987232804298401,
-0.0701461061835289,
0.9004236459732056,
-0.5968034863471985,
0.28315186500549316,
0.07681906968355179,
0.45459404587745667,
0.3566593825817108,
-0.20725774765014648,
0.3884514570236206,
0.07343561947345734,
-0.3699969947338104,
-0.6903636455535889,
0.31817975640296936,
-0.8839674592018127,
-0.23392535746097565,
1.074155569076538,
-0.409982830286026,
-0.2606494128704071,
0.10805895924568176,
-0.25759753584861755,
0.6504434943199158,
-0.42074814438819885,
0.12299653142690659,
0.6166068315505981,
0.2199239879846573,
-0.2691776752471924,
-0.34019315242767334,
0.14392174780368805,
0.5634734630584717,
-0.996059000492096,
-0.21766477823257446,
0.44980090856552124,
0.10543016344308853,
-0.02468372881412506,
0.7795030474662781,
-0.19925783574581146,
0.19008752703666687,
-0.3259839117527008,
0.015014255419373512,
-0.42879149317741394,
-0.42108944058418274,
-0.6151396036148071,
0.23940229415893555,
0.07931740581989288,
-0.47570186853408813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04631v1 | The Future of Cognitive Strategy-enhanced Persuasive Dialogue Agents: New Perspectives and Trends | 2024-02-07T07:28:34 | 2024-02-07T07:28:34 | Mengqi Chen, Bin Guo, Hao Wang, Haoyu Li, Qian Zhao, Jingqi Liu, Yasan Ding, Yan Pan, Zhiwen Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Persuasion, as one of the crucial abilities in human communication, has
garnered extensive attention from researchers within the field of intelligent
dialogue systems. We humans tend to persuade others to change their viewpoints,
attitudes or behaviors through conversations in various scenarios (e.g.,
persuasion for social good, arguing in online platforms). Developing dialogue
agents that can persuade others to accept certain standpoints is essential to
achieving truly intelligent and anthropomorphic dialogue system. Benefiting
from the substantial progress of Large Language Models (LLMs), dialogue agents
have acquired an exceptional capability in context understanding and response
generation. However, as a typical and complicated cognitive psychological
system, persuasive dialogue agents also require knowledge from the domain of
cognitive psychology to attain a level of human-like persuasion. Consequently,
the cognitive strategy-enhanced persuasive dialogue agent (defined as
CogAgent), which incorporates cognitive strategies to achieve persuasive
targets through conversation, has become a predominant research paradigm. To
depict the research trends of CogAgent, in this paper, we first present several
fundamental cognitive psychology theories and give the formalized definition of
three typical cognitive strategies, including the persuasion strategy, the
topic path planning strategy, and the argument structure prediction strategy.
Then we propose a new system architecture by incorporating the formalized
definition to lay the foundation of CogAgent. Representative works are detailed
and investigated according to the combined cognitive strategy, followed by the
summary of authoritative benchmarks and evaluation metrics. Finally, we
summarize our insights on open issues and future directions of CogAgent for
upcoming researchers. | [
-0.8077796101570129,
-1.1130013465881348,
0.8060445785522461,
0.04066379740834236,
-0.08934825658798218,
0.24222971498966217,
-0.3651946485042572,
-0.25301817059516907,
0.20948854088783264,
0.4798755943775177,
-0.8824415802955627,
-0.47010892629623413,
-0.42398369312286377,
-0.22185122966766357,
-0.28351855278015137,
0.8153290152549744,
0.35947898030281067,
0.08531291037797928,
-0.45810630917549133,
0.04554038867354393,
-0.6363537907600403,
-0.7912862300872803,
-0.7914966344833374,
-0.6503723859786987,
0.29904234409332275,
0.6854395866394043,
0.5871658325195312,
-0.039047349244356155,
0.11645229905843735,
0.39398157596588135,
-0.004717881325632334,
-0.43282994627952576,
-0.530788004398346,
0.33042705059051514,
-0.1938173621892929,
-0.40323513746261597,
-0.5952749848365784,
0.22159765660762787,
0.16237123310565948,
0.48119333386421204,
-0.3284728527069092,
-0.37366822361946106,
0.146279439330101,
0.22013038396835327,
-0.49612903594970703,
0.165933758020401,
-0.7294409275054932,
0.10904183983802795,
-0.08617065846920013,
-0.3704679012298584,
-0.4616799056529999,
-0.2619101405143738,
0.5099145770072937,
-0.8404449820518494,
0.14517280459403992,
-0.09039551764726639,
0.7122923731803894,
0.06607981026172638,
-0.3757506310939789,
-0.4664421081542969,
-0.6382339596748352,
0.8617045879364014,
-0.5418859124183655,
0.054570239037275314,
0.01522800698876381,
0.4229491353034973,
-0.44822660088539124,
-0.7028241157531738,
-0.3882092535495758,
-0.3870483338832855,
0.23652541637420654,
0.4684586822986603,
-0.43756771087646484,
0.10579285025596619,
0.0016889713006094098,
-0.017959948629140854,
-0.08141136169433594,
0.09096947312355042,
0.2656363844871521,
-0.38158437609672546,
0.8774940967559814,
0.2702541947364807,
0.2782154679298401,
0.16789327561855316,
-0.5623407959938049,
-0.1365525722503662,
-0.399072527885437,
0.15611402690410614,
0.2968323230743408,
-0.1476726084947586,
-0.09580978006124496,
-0.016780231148004532,
-0.6654617786407471,
0.2498874068260193,
0.7502633333206177,
0.14438940584659576,
-0.2549074590206146,
-0.3114193081855774,
-0.10102050751447678,
0.5694718956947327,
0.659196674823761,
0.1724998652935028,
-0.0627652257680893,
0.17219512164592743,
0.23172420263290405,
0.2441015988588333,
0.22366765141487122,
-0.6166089177131653,
-0.4691883325576782,
0.006161984987556934,
-0.4170359969139099,
-0.33640772104263306,
-0.11170792579650879,
-0.9355576634407043,
-0.5158177614212036,
-0.03161251172423363,
0.2842158377170563,
-0.4380394220352173,
-0.4093374013900757,
0.3387678563594818,
-0.13631436228752136,
0.34353768825531006,
0.7564607262611389,
-1.0148169994354248,
0.45950257778167725,
0.9743894338607788,
0.3763618469238281,
-0.26118889451026917,
0.1170811578631401,
-0.06237370893359184,
0.2579648494720459,
-0.4466498792171478,
0.9868665337562561,
-0.829712450504303,
-0.5925861597061157,
-0.0009369908948428929,
-0.19841749966144562,
-0.03922538831830025,
-0.24112330377101898,
0.8971600532531738,
-0.4136594831943512,
0.3420192301273346,
-0.5263064503669739,
-0.31666290760040283,
-0.4817137122154236,
0.698190450668335,
-0.44575172662734985,
0.07484391331672668,
-0.4294354021549225,
-0.1922909915447235,
0.20761090517044067,
-0.8946743011474609,
-0.2925249934196472,
0.4595226049423218,
-0.3602125644683838,
-0.11666618287563324,
0.007330096792429686,
0.3121669888496399,
0.3265596330165863,
-0.5045696496963501,
0.4627397358417511,
-0.07510935515165329,
-0.11225666105747223,
0.4667268693447113,
-0.7738946080207825,
0.7806172966957092,
0.24551483988761902,
-0.44575923681259155,
0.30527710914611816,
-0.3624785542488098,
0.21367795765399933,
0.06300894916057587,
-0.2629583477973938,
-0.2703896760940552,
0.22089500725269318,
-0.5162544250488281,
0.11055709421634674,
0.3288417160511017,
-0.47806254029273987,
-0.14850004017353058,
0.04261946305632591,
0.5570310354232788,
0.6719603538513184,
0.4201129078865051,
0.636295735836029,
-0.14869552850723267,
0.6886115074157715,
-0.32442188262939453,
0.3962346613407135,
-0.05035097151994705,
-0.6037754416465759,
-0.700340211391449,
-0.2660229802131653,
-0.3922704756259918,
0.3551594614982605,
-0.4445079267024994,
0.3262212872505188,
-0.07153847068548203,
-0.5768097043037415,
0.012375764548778534,
-0.4181704819202423,
0.28058308362960815,
0.5782465934753418,
0.15680812299251556,
-0.34941303730010986,
-0.46071508526802063,
-0.5446496605873108,
-0.3546451926231384,
-0.3157944679260254,
0.46724703907966614,
0.3241526186466217,
0.08345013111829758,
-0.10922261327505112,
0.7325049042701721,
-0.5456374287605286,
0.06776250153779984,
-0.39520958065986633,
0.08230143040418625,
-0.014649573713541031,
0.28523167967796326,
-0.04167555272579193,
-0.7848020195960999,
-0.3642013669013977,
-0.2252202183008194,
-0.6952592134475708,
0.06552520394325256,
-0.1044713705778122,
-0.21084626019001007,
-0.05319933965802193,
0.6344743371009827,
-0.6109110713005066,
0.28777459263801575,
0.4786302149295807,
-0.22837837040424347,
0.5398979783058167,
0.18368683755397797,
0.21660922467708588,
-0.7395485043525696,
-0.5750393271446228,
0.003918548580259085,
0.24317055940628052,
-0.916823148727417,
-0.035786714404821396,
-0.6656780242919922,
-0.3502346873283386,
-0.29125750064849854,
0.23971624672412872,
-0.3635714054107666,
0.4932641088962555,
-0.19186100363731384,
0.07411907613277435,
-0.07257167249917984,
0.41922393441200256,
0.24731913208961487,
0.38659605383872986,
0.4915132224559784,
-0.7028906941413879,
0.6098229289054871,
0.5379214882850647,
-0.1948111653327942,
0.9091135859489441,
-0.5343990921974182,
0.4039188623428345,
0.2459026277065277,
0.7375158667564392,
-1.0723086595535278,
-0.03022851049900055,
0.4445205330848694,
-0.3888273537158966,
0.05293721705675125,
0.20018169283866882,
0.27134159207344055,
-0.22128590941429138,
-0.02435287833213806,
0.027565401047468185,
0.3992636203765869,
-0.40786683559417725,
0.7008626461029053,
0.2921162247657776,
-0.4337069094181061,
-0.4162125885486603,
-0.3241993486881256,
0.5284298062324524,
-0.16221335530281067,
-0.887536883354187,
0.47450757026672363,
-0.025214074179530144,
-0.46102994680404663,
-0.18372079730033875,
0.02953999675810337,
0.2679971754550934,
0.11619748920202255,
0.19784438610076904,
0.20937234163284302,
-0.19265322387218475,
0.06795969605445862,
-0.00825804565101862,
-0.47051748633384705,
0.14465534687042236,
-0.3609517812728882,
0.8201851844787598,
-0.3404993414878845,
-0.41302648186683655,
-0.40983474254608154,
0.4464418292045593,
0.1133008748292923,
-0.2501882016658783,
0.2409875988960266,
0.48725253343582153,
0.00248344661667943,
0.34193506836891174,
-0.7255643606185913,
-0.43903830647468567,
-0.5114656090736389,
0.5940160155296326,
-0.44394874572753906,
-0.8401394486427307,
0.17508801817893982,
-0.6586511731147766,
-0.20587126910686493,
0.2689434885978699,
0.6700405478477478,
0.03426099568605423,
1.2324978113174438,
0.4967465400695801,
0.0892365500330925,
0.569208562374115,
-0.26515233516693115,
0.30596959590911865,
-0.5903618335723877,
-0.4149968922138214,
-0.4382759928703308,
-0.12772531807422638,
-0.4902583658695221,
-0.1577949821949005,
0.3112899959087372,
-0.2358439415693283,
-0.14073050022125244,
0.033312540501356125,
-0.5499423146247864,
-0.10146291553974152,
0.46734583377838135,
-0.2438044399023056,
0.267768919467926,
0.28358104825019836,
-0.23640574514865875,
0.12943586707115173,
-0.7305425405502319,
-0.6780062317848206,
0.7161034941673279,
0.25891539454460144,
0.8349499702453613,
0.1903323084115982,
0.6193284392356873,
0.2818291187286377,
-0.042214613407850266,
-0.87125164270401,
1.3452727794647217,
0.36378905177116394,
-0.6183624863624573,
-0.4206392765045166,
0.12453291565179825,
-1.0801067352294922,
0.20590488612651825,
-0.5146406888961792,
-0.6294654011726379,
0.4396739602088928,
-0.05911898612976074,
-0.21617580950260162,
-0.035589661449193954,
-0.6548294425010681,
0.6774463653564453,
-0.48259270191192627,
-0.5629996061325073,
-0.908629834651947,
-0.32996946573257446,
0.010502531193196774,
0.3711475431919098,
-0.1855480968952179,
-0.2099968045949936,
-0.1662146896123886,
0.7670316100120544,
-0.2861312925815582,
0.7304441928863525,
-0.4109838306903839,
-0.19352485239505768,
0.4505372941493988,
-0.29154476523399353,
0.5284780859947205,
0.0305457916110754,
-0.039796099066734314,
0.16248773038387299,
-0.0831497386097908,
-0.3149433732032776,
-0.5696206092834473,
0.6370792984962463,
-0.6062492728233337,
-1.337815523147583,
-0.4238662123680115,
-0.4805683493614197,
-0.3729955554008484,
-0.009596177376806736,
0.26407715678215027,
0.36600545048713684,
-0.9677957892417908,
0.06264487653970718,
0.8055763840675354,
-0.16610126197338104,
0.5508005023002625,
0.46751120686531067,
0.373446524143219,
-0.4224289655685425,
1.0515422821044922,
-0.28149428963661194,
0.3760932683944702,
0.41938868165016174,
0.4357410669326782,
-0.2302696853876114,
-0.6928504109382629,
0.02702006697654724,
-0.18506555259227753,
-0.5811808705329895,
0.264386385679245,
-0.5301218032836914,
-0.07688755542039871,
-0.5439921021461487,
-0.4094296395778656,
-0.024006690829992294,
-0.24905148148536682,
-0.1586938351392746,
0.03743482753634453,
0.19901183247566223,
0.6295838356018066,
0.12761349976062775,
0.31448644399642944,
-0.3559860289096832,
-0.1721368134021759,
0.5970854759216309,
-0.2425147294998169,
0.1574064940214157,
-0.009264298714697361,
-0.22392772138118744,
0.043850984424352646,
-0.7864469289779663,
-0.7258493900299072,
0.26104429364204407,
-0.07605401426553726,
0.8695221543312073,
0.7133416533470154,
-0.020703783258795738,
0.5110540390014648,
-0.09160881489515305,
0.8504628539085388,
0.5074219107627869,
-0.688591718673706,
0.34710386395454407,
-0.35806554555892944,
0.13280725479125977,
0.44112223386764526,
0.2430204600095749,
-0.6809617877006531,
-0.0882934033870697,
-0.7479403614997864,
-0.5418750047683716,
0.48339059948921204,
-0.21722015738487244,
0.2038300782442093,
0.10911760479211807,
0.14340773224830627,
0.20956821739673615,
0.2748568058013916,
-0.11675934493541718,
0.07348454743623734,
-0.44330936670303345,
-0.19234216213226318,
-0.18725943565368652,
-0.0840737372636795,
-0.3759150207042694,
-0.23885509371757507,
0.6831712126731873,
-0.25807997584342957,
0.6175777912139893,
0.17916390299797058,
0.13517001271247864,
0.06246413663029671,
0.7471446394920349,
0.4391098618507385,
0.28305909037590027,
-0.06750618666410446,
-0.2712828516960144,
0.0943821594119072,
-0.6279140114784241,
0.5455564260482788,
0.19683837890625,
-0.25388801097869873,
-0.5264588594436646,
0.12892957031726837,
0.725017786026001,
-0.07135605812072754,
-0.34669554233551025,
0.2514536380767822,
-0.15674272179603577,
-0.3472684323787689,
-0.5955377817153931,
0.42387062311172485,
0.09617376327514648,
0.5149581432342529,
0.5142240524291992,
0.23002289235591888,
0.1274746209383011,
-0.9729806184768677,
-0.13141141831874847,
0.9092959761619568,
-0.6926522254943848,
-0.3511008322238922,
0.34340327978134155,
0.654644787311554,
-0.3857603371143341,
0.21960487961769104,
-0.15507133305072784,
-0.6450334191322327,
0.19163724780082703,
0.49963387846946716,
0.8733497262001038,
-0.24443474411964417,
0.33962365984916687,
0.015178137458860874,
-0.06157589331269264,
0.02934681996703148,
-0.08975230157375336,
-0.2656986713409424,
-0.921403706073761,
0.036331549286842346,
0.10124371945858002,
-0.5896205902099609,
0.06255358457565308,
-0.46243560314178467,
0.06462928652763367,
-0.5819641351699829,
-0.4156724214553833,
-0.0913933590054512,
0.5760355591773987,
-0.41791650652885437,
0.3019355833530426,
0.20756077766418457,
0.7279708385467529,
-0.48899221420288086,
0.46580320596694946,
0.8882188200950623,
-0.28873834013938904,
-0.47236430644989014,
0.2742099463939667,
0.19487647712230682,
-0.6121829748153687,
0.12718607485294342,
-0.15923944115638733,
-0.3284316956996918,
0.13451601564884186,
-0.87433922290802,
-0.7460213899612427,
1.3238478899002075,
0.3321842849254608,
-0.57797771692276,
-0.13486379384994507,
-0.08235695213079453,
0.36565929651260376,
-0.811657190322876,
0.13528378307819366,
0.45967015624046326,
0.608734130859375,
0.21805399656295776,
-0.1369696408510208,
0.3948553204536438,
-0.16572359204292297,
-0.1815786510705948,
-0.15854865312576294,
-0.9847316741943359,
0.6987255215644836,
-0.14728447794914246,
-0.224371537566185,
0.3791588842868805,
0.7745063304901123,
0.22355917096138,
0.5578222274780273,
0.4507030248641968,
0.2246883660554886,
0.777723491191864,
-0.2676291763782501,
0.9014692902565002,
-0.03876056522130966,
-0.22628584504127502,
0.690273642539978,
-0.419435977935791,
0.5980277061462402,
0.283214271068573,
0.17033302783966064,
1.0995347499847412,
0.3891665041446686,
0.05891856178641319,
0.5099399089813232,
-0.04068674519658089,
-0.6492094397544861,
-0.5798638463020325,
-0.32947438955307007,
-0.12864410877227783,
0.582599937915802,
0.7529355883598328,
0.0897175744175911,
0.0391748882830143,
0.07433188706636429,
0.09223373979330063,
0.3854528069496155,
-0.16986970603466034,
0.9071424603462219,
0.0697060152888298,
-1.066296100616455,
0.3423944115638733,
-0.08305973559617996,
0.6436672806739807,
-0.7302113175392151,
-0.07441138476133347,
0.36546096205711365,
0.311612993478775,
-0.11881789565086365,
-0.6124027967453003,
-0.4331655502319336,
-0.5099124312400818,
0.17913761734962463,
-0.16662636399269104,
1.189727783203125,
-0.23194248974323273,
0.13534514605998993,
0.1804482489824295,
0.5766540169715881,
-0.0653458908200264,
0.10484395176172256,
-1.0059566497802734,
0.0986374244093895,
-0.0714384913444519,
0.03777477145195007,
0.2745162546634674,
0.09996505081653595,
-0.22227905690670013,
0.6013623476028442,
0.7358347773551941,
-0.0702124536037445,
-0.31821146607398987,
0.08560539036989212,
0.6870508193969727,
-0.6519443392753601,
-0.5005261898040771,
-0.708705484867096,
0.1503746211528778,
-0.36794325709342957,
-0.026929128915071487,
0.9048546552658081,
0.15380673110485077,
0.45477694272994995,
0.16301092505455017,
0.9630356431007385,
-0.0083544896915555,
0.004850609693676233,
-0.23654691874980927,
0.5378133654594421,
-0.12358260899782181,
-0.027136771008372307,
-0.2968592345714569,
-0.6031128764152527,
0.39490848779678345,
0.3647315204143524,
-0.7213702201843262,
0.1410534679889679,
0.6399825811386108,
0.6911436319351196,
0.4301854968070984,
0.5330210328102112,
0.2138882726430893,
0.2610580623149872,
0.7376748323440552,
0.8397859334945679,
1.1922094821929932,
0.01991102285683155,
0.7709073424339294,
0.2122637778520584,
-0.3098088204860687,
-0.44480568170547485,
-0.7070931196212769,
-0.8300856947898865,
-0.49132657051086426,
-0.38030239939689636,
-0.23676587641239166,
0.33584001660346985,
0.805877149105072,
0.7579671740531921,
-0.48454973101615906,
-0.2813117206096649,
-0.4788477122783661,
0.14260347187519073,
-0.4779479503631592,
-0.2388220876455307,
-0.026467736810445786,
-0.04744354635477066,
-0.48375892639160156,
0.369076669216156,
0.5742204785346985,
-0.03965228796005249,
-0.379010945558548,
-0.38399308919906616,
-0.5552093982696533,
0.5929644703865051,
0.5524987578392029,
0.40112465620040894,
-0.7233360409736633,
-0.07104601711034775,
-0.015200598165392876,
-0.1027715653181076,
0.1311037838459015,
0.7372226119041443,
-0.7759808301925659,
0.45181629061698914,
0.3639659583568573,
0.2785440981388092,
0.5203211307525635,
0.10903575271368027,
0.8860660195350647,
0.03969169035553932,
0.1180972084403038,
0.33113572001457214,
0.010709762573242188,
0.40614053606987,
-0.3568951189517975,
0.23701976239681244,
0.2732037603855133,
-0.3119674324989319,
-0.14342018961906433,
0.5417518019676208,
-0.8685463070869446,
-0.12047114223241806,
0.8665751814842224,
-0.00043019713484682143,
-0.28845199942588806,
-0.4016250669956207,
-0.538781464099884,
0.23929014801979065,
-0.8394978642463684,
0.5092766880989075,
0.8638449907302856,
-0.4553408920764923,
-0.13474178314208984,
-0.1682017296552658,
0.579059362411499,
0.7718327641487122,
-0.88926762342453,
-0.17131204903125763,
0.40473636984825134,
0.004420326091349125,
0.39653995633125305,
0.822849690914154,
-0.0779125913977623,
0.3210497498512268,
0.2775421142578125,
-0.09105446189641953,
0.08621113002300262,
-0.08850879967212677,
-0.13157114386558533,
0.1999519169330597,
0.07564089447259903,
-0.014112956821918488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04627v1 | SPARQL Generation: an analysis on fine-tuning OpenLLaMA for Question Answering over a Life Science Knowledge Graph | 2024-02-07T07:24:01 | 2024-02-07T07:24:01 | Julio C. Rangel, Tarcisio Mendes de Farias, Ana Claudia Sima, Norio Kobayashi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.IR | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLM) in a wide range of Natural
Language Processing applications opens the path towards novel Question
Answering Systems over Knowledge Graphs leveraging LLMs. However, one of the
main obstacles preventing their implementation is the scarcity of training data
for the task of translating questions into corresponding SPARQL queries,
particularly in the case of domain-specific KGs. To overcome this challenge, in
this study, we evaluate several strategies for fine-tuning the OpenLlama LLM
for question answering over life science knowledge graphs. In particular, we
propose an end-to-end data augmentation approach for extending a set of
existing queries over a given knowledge graph towards a larger dataset of
semantically enriched question-to-SPARQL query pairs, enabling fine-tuning even
for datasets where these pairs are scarce. In this context, we also investigate
the role of semantic "clues" in the queries, such as meaningful variable names
and inline comments. Finally, we evaluate our approach over the real-world Bgee
gene expression knowledge graph and we show that semantic clues can improve
model performance by up to 33% compared to a baseline with random variable
names and no comments included. | [
-0.5640056133270264,
-1.080225944519043,
0.4040934145450592,
-0.29421406984329224,
-0.10012219846248627,
0.1255415827035904,
-0.12154814600944519,
-0.48986726999282837,
-0.0036908972542732954,
0.8413941860198975,
-0.8864625096321106,
-0.644829511642456,
-0.4273037612438202,
0.21310001611709595,
-0.15737299621105194,
1.0697129964828491,
0.23489663004875183,
-0.02159857004880905,
-0.3350634276866913,
-0.18690693378448486,
-0.29125794768333435,
-0.08364827185869217,
-0.5601921081542969,
-0.23793886601924896,
0.6685703992843628,
0.4075869619846344,
0.9432699084281921,
0.5389310717582703,
0.20703543722629547,
0.14941874146461487,
-0.43965619802474976,
0.8756951093673706,
-0.8548214435577393,
0.48021063208580017,
-0.3106992840766907,
-0.43965327739715576,
-0.2100340873003006,
-0.31462278962135315,
0.4412303864955902,
1.1845049858093262,
0.23204240202903748,
0.4256039559841156,
-0.04400933161377907,
0.8480432033538818,
-0.5162106156349182,
0.17884790897369385,
-0.7493162155151367,
0.14385542273521423,
-0.1306876689195633,
-0.483864426612854,
-0.26927438378334045,
-0.6153751015663147,
0.06432578712701797,
-0.6490359306335449,
0.3457772135734558,
0.4000960886478424,
0.8296959400177002,
0.45839110016822815,
-0.22135955095291138,
-0.1831812858581543,
-0.546110212802887,
0.3639543056488037,
-0.6821958422660828,
0.266518771648407,
0.14083006978034973,
0.3786427080631256,
-0.6337662935256958,
-0.6583589315414429,
-0.40040260553359985,
-0.11002013087272644,
-0.06994935870170593,
0.007713622879236937,
-0.23646558821201324,
0.06970425695180893,
0.2737443745136261,
0.262713760137558,
-0.6391118764877319,
-0.15779729187488556,
-0.3741677701473236,
-0.030096372589468956,
0.44673097133636475,
0.27994510531425476,
0.15069708228111267,
-0.014444884844124317,
0.08690080791711807,
0.019808175042271614,
-0.972259521484375,
0.04794212430715561,
0.2328215092420578,
0.5414218902587891,
0.6448637843132019,
0.9561767578125,
-0.5962435603141785,
1.1997225284576416,
-0.12830595672130585,
0.44283634424209595,
0.09767124801874161,
-0.37745022773742676,
-0.07298193871974945,
-0.06073381006717682,
0.44814613461494446,
0.36915528774261475,
0.45733973383903503,
-0.518761157989502,
0.14312498271465302,
-0.24210689961910248,
0.20057816803455353,
-0.8783671259880066,
-0.08492029458284378,
0.2327294647693634,
-0.03216248378157616,
-0.1979580968618393,
-0.0720052719116211,
-0.7928494811058044,
-0.4758656919002533,
-0.0406620129942894,
0.4892871081829071,
-0.4744155704975128,
0.018266262486577034,
0.49348828196525574,
-0.20346136391162872,
0.22385843098163605,
0.32433193922042847,
-0.5337541699409485,
0.1572566032409668,
0.5723648071289062,
0.49689480662345886,
0.3051799237728119,
0.029548894613981247,
-0.6144991517066956,
0.45063045620918274,
-0.44056883454322815,
0.9147996306419373,
-0.7429882287979126,
-0.28396075963974,
-0.1676434725522995,
-0.04581119120121002,
-0.21841982007026672,
-0.6212930679321289,
0.23502494394779205,
-0.9659521579742432,
0.2842060327529907,
-0.4482637345790863,
-0.7425180673599243,
-0.19323782622814178,
0.14226134121418,
-0.37798380851745605,
1.0748788118362427,
0.37852710485458374,
-0.6302220821380615,
0.26243773102760315,
-0.9221751093864441,
-0.3898766040802002,
0.2670578956604004,
-0.11258163303136826,
-0.12531065940856934,
-0.007796149700880051,
0.4677961766719818,
0.4527217447757721,
-0.4984150826931,
0.01002493780106306,
-0.3127022087574005,
-0.021522607654333115,
0.6834966540336609,
0.04548152908682823,
0.35250547528266907,
0.34892094135284424,
0.0888509452342987,
-0.05517859756946564,
-0.7282858490943909,
0.482582688331604,
0.029661089181900024,
-0.08139004558324814,
-0.1534140557050705,
0.035216640681028366,
-0.35416775941848755,
0.03142233565449715,
0.1542273461818695,
-0.7141321301460266,
0.14008110761642456,
-0.8314469456672668,
0.4619410037994385,
0.40434855222702026,
0.32624557614326477,
0.0777362734079361,
-0.37971198558807373,
0.4622965455055237,
-0.11263487488031387,
0.14131461083889008,
-0.20753353834152222,
-0.7702454924583435,
-0.7216853499412537,
0.025667672976851463,
0.2506774365901947,
0.37827327847480774,
-0.6618008613586426,
0.4822045862674713,
-0.35310474038124084,
-0.4010058045387268,
-0.8779438734054565,
0.2332075983285904,
0.5245373845100403,
0.8248656392097473,
0.7011575698852539,
-0.1802416443824768,
-0.3032740652561188,
-0.6991257071495056,
-0.31122496724128723,
0.10481300950050354,
-0.02035469561815262,
0.6908221244812012,
0.26518550515174866,
0.00024080622824840248,
1.3755875825881958,
-1.0389782190322876,
-0.08050825446844101,
-0.1278437077999115,
-0.15871867537498474,
0.23967556655406952,
0.16046231985092163,
0.4275475740432739,
-0.5907556414604187,
-0.36406365036964417,
0.2598705291748047,
-0.525868833065033,
-0.2506704330444336,
0.47893625497817993,
-0.3576263189315796,
-0.025205429643392563,
0.48643359541893005,
-0.7962502837181091,
0.4276846945285797,
-0.05941614508628845,
-0.545462429523468,
0.2481178194284439,
-0.1827791929244995,
0.10067583620548248,
-0.9437962770462036,
0.1877940595149994,
-0.1281394511461258,
-0.08109089732170105,
-0.7641699314117432,
0.29283013939857483,
-0.1383533477783203,
-0.11298929899930954,
-0.28247570991516113,
0.6447852849960327,
-0.34409523010253906,
-0.045231424272060394,
-0.18687704205513,
0.1732911616563797,
0.14415837824344635,
0.259111225605011,
-0.25391894578933716,
0.7485201954841614,
0.32921770215034485,
-0.5681084394454956,
0.3534635305404663,
0.4962059557437897,
-0.21030351519584656,
0.12081175297498703,
-0.5992408990859985,
0.11890828609466553,
-0.42380475997924805,
0.2088501900434494,
-1.0093886852264404,
-0.3984788954257965,
0.2524004578590393,
-0.8361987471580505,
0.1580324023962021,
-0.11914218962192535,
-0.607256293296814,
-0.3604188859462738,
-0.11996110528707504,
-0.020321890711784363,
0.5667189359664917,
-0.5333400964736938,
0.28275132179260254,
0.26143956184387207,
-0.16328641772270203,
-0.40265122056007385,
-0.4393998086452484,
-0.04347938299179077,
-0.13891416788101196,
-1.0245593786239624,
0.1480962336063385,
0.013490893878042698,
-0.009522114880383015,
0.18652816116809845,
-0.14142602682113647,
0.031719181686639786,
0.0808122456073761,
-0.04100721329450607,
0.06190204247832298,
-0.4695964455604553,
0.2531176507472992,
0.33799833059310913,
-0.12619537115097046,
-0.12289684265851974,
-0.5065843462944031,
0.5168797373771667,
0.08064257353544235,
-0.24888646602630615,
0.2409433275461197,
0.1840919703245163,
0.2867434620857239,
-0.33846667408943176,
0.7761377692222595,
0.5084812641143799,
-0.37083691358566284,
-0.2893896996974945,
-0.479087233543396,
-0.18710124492645264,
-0.47621020674705505,
0.35073164105415344,
-0.1783168464899063,
-1.2650319337844849,
0.5025454163551331,
-0.3401898443698883,
-0.1627684235572815,
0.4014386534690857,
0.5937361121177673,
0.03148749843239784,
0.8619809746742249,
0.266403466463089,
0.17097586393356323,
0.0032037266064435244,
-0.2101483941078186,
0.26123541593551636,
-0.8316769599914551,
-0.45011767745018005,
-0.6852687001228333,
-0.05120627209544182,
-0.12500040233135223,
-0.781123161315918,
0.6586466431617737,
0.19262394309043884,
-0.1908535361289978,
0.12587712705135345,
-0.5489305257797241,
0.7154474258422852,
0.3097236454486847,
0.30169978737831116,
0.21594785153865814,
0.10236231237649918,
-0.06510711461305618,
0.1809672862291336,
-0.9081563949584961,
-0.35382625460624695,
1.104104995727539,
0.01914030872285366,
0.7565624713897705,
0.06751280277967453,
0.33539682626724243,
-0.056905873119831085,
0.0848177894949913,
-0.28772297501564026,
0.5249572992324829,
-0.09417460858821869,
-0.4720168113708496,
-0.5193163156509399,
-0.476850688457489,
-1.105471134185791,
0.20637355744838715,
-0.22050338983535767,
-0.8891051411628723,
0.033557455986738205,
0.13439731299877167,
-0.6500497460365295,
-0.0025195095222443342,
-0.5402570962905884,
0.8900119662284851,
0.055570654571056366,
-0.47317564487457275,
-0.0028599028009921312,
-0.9154067039489746,
0.17375588417053223,
0.011494677513837814,
0.01716158352792263,
-0.22599846124649048,
-0.07593195140361786,
0.40667596459388733,
-0.4876033663749695,
0.712876558303833,
-0.26178598403930664,
-0.08589275926351547,
0.4120163321495056,
-0.10657475888729095,
0.43532830476760864,
0.1421770453453064,
-0.22707004845142365,
-0.31664881110191345,
0.04627574235200882,
-0.31865790486335754,
-0.703120231628418,
0.628551721572876,
-0.6560478210449219,
-0.5648822784423828,
0.09124540537595749,
-0.8075283765792847,
-0.756092369556427,
-0.013783586211502552,
0.11515067517757416,
0.3112528920173645,
-0.005703824572265148,
0.35594674944877625,
1.1424620151519775,
-0.509649932384491,
-0.07348766177892685,
0.7441085577011108,
-0.38434937596321106,
-0.29651057720184326,
0.9049386978149414,
0.16896837949752808,
0.2934911251068115,
0.5050187110900879,
0.16625003516674042,
-0.43235331773757935,
-0.6086846590042114,
-0.5835062265396118,
0.09547840058803558,
-0.6822625994682312,
-0.47777387499809265,
-0.8093631267547607,
-0.3904067575931549,
-0.6704429984092712,
0.008368347771465778,
-0.05100078135728836,
-0.6306555271148682,
-0.47881409525871277,
-0.046190228313207626,
0.9317815899848938,
0.5351107716560364,
0.2829848825931549,
0.20202380418777466,
-0.9511871933937073,
0.3959116041660309,
0.13574016094207764,
0.24113354086875916,
-0.053044144064188004,
-0.460952490568161,
-0.3019731938838959,
0.14126285910606384,
-0.15532253682613373,
-0.9407851099967957,
0.3805186450481415,
0.5878102779388428,
0.5506424307823181,
0.11894531548023224,
0.12707309424877167,
0.8196370601654053,
-0.3822784423828125,
0.6346181035041809,
-0.22058327496051788,
-0.404843807220459,
0.831540584564209,
-0.4374423623085022,
0.1848246455192566,
0.5168901681900024,
0.3608725070953369,
-0.5048184990882874,
-0.6444322466850281,
-0.4857287108898163,
-1.0747426748275757,
0.5245784521102905,
0.11241324990987778,
0.18152844905853271,
-0.04671922326087952,
0.8729879260063171,
0.303012877702713,
0.2111615091562271,
-0.3023439645767212,
-0.1441417932510376,
-0.04977057874202728,
-0.2909374237060547,
0.056308403611183167,
0.06422648578882217,
-0.32162582874298096,
-0.4403137266635895,
0.6627235412597656,
-0.49662286043167114,
0.0023317441809922457,
0.18702949583530426,
-0.17167167365550995,
-0.4047255218029022,
0.3421602249145508,
0.3654439449310303,
0.4059925675392151,
-0.19149938225746155,
-0.15844415128231049,
0.25498732924461365,
-0.2348848581314087,
-0.2622864842414856,
0.35640522837638855,
-0.33246952295303345,
-0.24181854724884033,
0.052835144102573395,
0.8181264996528625,
0.1299261599779129,
-0.8865243196487427,
0.18590693175792694,
0.15519601106643677,
-0.03862343356013298,
0.21758046746253967,
0.6082128882408142,
0.23814885318279266,
0.37183597683906555,
0.5001958608627319,
-0.20307664573192596,
0.008905638009309769,
-0.2735258638858795,
0.10616369545459747,
0.7268077731132507,
-0.2865181863307953,
-0.059658534824848175,
0.7287821769714355,
-0.10491230338811874,
-0.0707540288567543,
0.3882618248462677,
-0.06401117146015167,
-0.31371185183525085,
0.580915629863739,
0.5740569233894348,
0.4515831768512726,
-0.08009037375450134,
0.21873560547828674,
0.1251157522201538,
0.34452754259109497,
0.3547275960445404,
0.5198966860771179,
-0.04058239981532097,
-0.7037992477416992,
-0.40822821855545044,
-0.8418229818344116,
-0.46360671520233154,
-0.03245941549539566,
-0.5396826267242432,
0.08968984335660934,
-0.16239269077777863,
0.02927064336836338,
0.22561109066009521,
-0.0015266890404745936,
-0.38535842299461365,
0.2528804540634155,
-0.1370113641023636,
1.0530165433883667,
-0.6136233806610107,
0.8052530288696289,
0.7931120991706848,
-0.4465118944644928,
-0.6409941911697388,
-0.254982590675354,
-0.5040963888168335,
-0.9039071798324585,
0.6546503305435181,
-0.0029133884236216545,
0.03013051487505436,
0.31569355726242065,
-0.6108273863792419,
-1.1079543828964233,
1.1931979656219482,
0.488686203956604,
-0.14283663034439087,
-0.11541768908500671,
0.5731935501098633,
0.8523645997047424,
-0.3197389543056488,
0.1523098349571228,
0.5586246848106384,
0.5186343193054199,
0.3644142746925354,
-0.5118500590324402,
0.14980901777744293,
-0.2525195777416229,
-0.049325186759233475,
0.3675062656402588,
-0.5085899233818054,
0.5743777751922607,
-0.33772167563438416,
-0.10303205251693726,
0.292961984872818,
0.7259103655815125,
0.11534564197063446,
0.3434046506881714,
0.07163652032613754,
0.7112576365470886,
0.7726778984069824,
-0.1481972336769104,
0.8901300430297852,
-0.6506378650665283,
0.34183064103126526,
0.8129896521568298,
-0.42294424772262573,
0.5681377053260803,
0.4286327064037323,
-0.30353859066963196,
-0.03832327574491501,
0.6937906742095947,
0.009841123595833778,
0.4793385863304138,
0.4601419270038605,
-0.2378263920545578,
-0.3340297341346741,
-0.227804034948349,
-0.6909300088882446,
0.0035371738485991955,
0.8764075636863708,
-0.2948513329029083,
-0.5829272270202637,
0.07378142327070236,
-0.07701148837804794,
0.06927675753831863,
-0.2749199867248535,
0.8075846433639526,
-0.11970268934965134,
-0.768009603023529,
0.4645499289035797,
-0.054060470312833786,
0.19922566413879395,
-0.5747582912445068,
-0.07352200895547867,
-0.3612044155597687,
-0.01757017895579338,
-0.3491118550300598,
-0.8257678747177124,
0.2673467993736267,
0.04932160675525665,
-0.08371111750602722,
0.10081961750984192,
0.907168447971344,
-0.4888651371002197,
-0.3251059651374817,
0.11659228056669235,
0.7118516564369202,
0.023220324888825417,
0.13271160423755646,
-0.5998736619949341,
-0.29650890827178955,
-0.17202042043209076,
-0.4208187162876129,
0.44974830746650696,
0.5543150305747986,
0.1281536966562271,
0.9435538053512573,
0.7904915809631348,
0.08845273405313492,
0.4615646302700043,
-0.0913100466132164,
1.325256586074829,
-0.5592984557151794,
-0.2290366142988205,
-0.49607107043266296,
0.19003227353096008,
-0.006147623993456364,
-0.26261356472969055,
0.7678844928741455,
0.6569157242774963,
0.6401417255401611,
-0.047891732305288315,
0.6737555861473083,
-0.044133592396974564,
0.8837174773216248,
-0.7034425735473633,
0.695655107498169,
-0.41138672828674316,
0.2986485958099365,
-0.12498749047517776,
-0.7009711861610413,
-0.464408278465271,
0.3144523501396179,
-0.24407286942005157,
0.003910234663635492,
0.4837675988674164,
1.2421631813049316,
0.26729851961135864,
0.4126411974430084,
0.17904531955718994,
0.33898791670799255,
0.2149050533771515,
0.5496830344200134,
0.8127910494804382,
-0.21882598102092743,
0.562897801399231,
-0.07505401968955994,
-0.015325294807553291,
-0.15623223781585693,
-0.600584089756012,
-0.5870764255523682,
-0.31550779938697815,
-0.34467142820358276,
-0.5890119671821594,
0.4910404682159424,
0.8051983714103699,
0.3694358766078949,
-0.6035239100456238,
0.07033243030309677,
-0.15763089060783386,
-0.07335959374904633,
0.04748321697115898,
-0.2358880341053009,
0.30544716119766235,
-0.6839628219604492,
-0.2990555465221405,
0.5653659701347351,
0.42631006240844727,
-0.24172455072402954,
-0.19064967334270477,
-0.017132559791207314,
-0.162522554397583,
0.2793121039867401,
0.5582955479621887,
0.5323231816291809,
-0.5876491665840149,
-0.46475401520729065,
0.20190249383449554,
0.12476057559251785,
0.03074331022799015,
0.6683691740036011,
-1.021052598953247,
0.3388229012489319,
0.3590708076953888,
0.8475481271743774,
0.5365229845046997,
0.08230263739824295,
0.37483468651771545,
-0.993669867515564,
-0.22922052443027496,
0.2716379463672638,
0.022738542407751083,
0.23019880056381226,
-0.46631038188934326,
0.6149542331695557,
0.13985148072242737,
-0.5220755934715271,
-0.8067052960395813,
0.23942233622074127,
-0.9593214988708496,
-0.44155222177505493,
1.226083755493164,
0.008554236963391304,
-0.37580999732017517,
-0.3288767337799072,
-0.2525920867919922,
0.21783779561519623,
-0.14044807851314545,
0.5700106024742126,
0.4269717335700989,
-0.44822031259536743,
-0.025198282673954964,
-0.6104339957237244,
0.47936832904815674,
0.4020923674106598,
-0.978350043296814,
0.23916171491146088,
0.6272406578063965,
0.30015748739242554,
-0.007441994268447161,
0.5149198770523071,
-0.19764600694179535,
0.355363130569458,
-0.3705954849720001,
-0.20055554807186127,
-0.28476056456565857,
-0.07936333119869232,
-0.09098780900239944,
0.4751186966896057,
0.15866856276988983,
0.045335277915000916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04624v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04624v2 | MEMORYLLM: Towards Self-Updatable Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T07:14:11 | 2024-05-26T23:06:32 | Yu Wang, Yifan Gao, Xiusi Chen, Haoming Jiang, Shiyang Li, Jingfeng Yang, Qingyu Yin, Zheng Li, Xian Li, Bing Yin, Jingbo Shang, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing Large Language Models (LLMs) usually remain static after deployment,
which might make it hard to inject new knowledge into the model. We aim to
build models containing a considerable portion of self-updatable parameters,
enabling the model to integrate new knowledge effectively and efficiently. To
this end, we introduce MEMORYLLM, a model that comprises a transformer and a
fixed-size memory pool within the latent space of the transformer. MEMORYLLM
can self-update with text knowledge and memorize the knowledge injected
earlier. Our evaluations demonstrate the ability of MEMORYLLM to effectively
incorporate new knowledge, as evidenced by its performance on model editing
benchmarks. Meanwhile, the model exhibits long-term information retention
capacity, which is validated through our custom-designed evaluations and
long-context benchmarks. MEMORYLLM also shows operational integrity without any
sign of performance degradation even after nearly a million memory updates. Our
code and model are open-sourced at https://github.com/wangyu-ustc/MemoryLLM. | [
-0.044485755264759064,
-0.5255622863769531,
0.7213636636734009,
0.2999303638935089,
-0.0510241836309433,
0.010793293826282024,
-0.5895517468452454,
-0.2259497344493866,
-0.03590361401438713,
0.9452764391899109,
-0.02649470791220665,
-0.3261329233646393,
-0.29632169008255005,
-0.44312259554862976,
-0.738633394241333,
0.7816349864006042,
-0.07539685815572739,
-0.2956409156322479,
-0.33244192600250244,
-0.29570138454437256,
-0.7344028353691101,
-0.6696450114250183,
-0.5011956691741943,
-0.4585013687610626,
0.31752467155456543,
0.40451228618621826,
0.7567906379699707,
0.8258652687072754,
0.22920013964176178,
0.2683079242706299,
-0.15238115191459656,
-0.055015526711940765,
-0.5370863676071167,
0.1941688507795334,
-0.3182187080383301,
-0.34629157185554504,
-0.5774909257888794,
-0.16370011866092682,
0.885810375213623,
0.4245718717575073,
-0.6175561547279358,
0.16529740393161774,
-0.1109914630651474,
0.6807765960693359,
-0.5198188424110413,
0.1057167574763298,
-0.8897624611854553,
-0.1846168041229248,
-0.04632838815450668,
0.20275916159152985,
-0.5379109978675842,
-0.10212183743715286,
0.08177081495523453,
-0.20973578095436096,
-0.050052884966135025,
0.00417553074657917,
0.4276691675186157,
0.3282257914543152,
-0.12240350246429443,
-0.24305853247642517,
-0.9021264910697937,
0.9033439755439758,
-0.7447041273117065,
0.6143903732299805,
0.2062670886516571,
0.3435894250869751,
-0.0787137895822525,
-0.7704816460609436,
-0.4597240686416626,
-0.34411224722862244,
-0.05128305032849312,
0.0346553772687912,
-0.06720343977212906,
-0.24214930832386017,
-0.03233577311038971,
0.4946458041667938,
-0.3511809706687927,
0.14528273046016693,
-0.2965243458747864,
0.0032646337058395147,
0.5086668133735657,
0.23201711475849152,
0.34428301453590393,
0.016527613624930382,
-0.49549978971481323,
0.3718203604221344,
-0.8990998864173889,
-0.6483449935913086,
0.03730703890323639,
0.13254381716251373,
-0.012659376487135887,
0.414044052362442,
0.02350441738963127,
0.5818744897842407,
0.025481468066573143,
0.07681693881750107,
-0.048081252723932266,
0.008903997018933296,
-0.23249639570713043,
0.13645151257514954,
0.6737924814224243,
0.19788236916065216,
0.31634819507598877,
-0.3140709400177002,
-0.37967467308044434,
-0.4223536252975464,
0.5020669102668762,
-0.9254871606826782,
-0.4640980064868927,
0.09783971309661865,
-0.4332973062992096,
-0.046646613627672195,
-0.3078817129135132,
-0.5412928462028503,
-0.29167595505714417,
-0.12505710124969482,
0.46675628423690796,
-0.49919629096984863,
-0.4368444085121155,
0.27775561809539795,
0.2334776520729065,
-0.024983439594507217,
0.37605205178260803,
-1.015012502670288,
0.20045273005962372,
0.5026121139526367,
0.7954632043838501,
-0.557601809501648,
-0.37527069449424744,
-0.07157745957374573,
0.6495580673217773,
-0.19094811379909515,
0.6181566119194031,
-0.35813647508621216,
-0.2975746989250183,
-0.056296173483133316,
-0.1016179621219635,
-0.17186102271080017,
-0.756557047367096,
0.1011817455291748,
-0.9017869234085083,
0.3449574112892151,
0.11976435035467148,
-0.8259006142616272,
-0.11229346692562103,
0.29561108350753784,
-0.6967982053756714,
1.2201206684112549,
0.23305831849575043,
-0.4648996889591217,
-0.01750471629202366,
-0.5988910794258118,
-0.11859586089849472,
0.10175560414791107,
-0.1702575981616974,
-0.2560828924179077,
0.1916874349117279,
-0.07839334011077881,
0.6744725704193115,
-0.36737409234046936,
0.5572014451026917,
-0.08520524948835373,
-0.19498592615127563,
0.38026273250579834,
-0.4415620267391205,
0.5058917999267578,
0.4433135986328125,
0.029119309037923813,
0.03500121086835861,
-0.815750241279602,
-0.1657174676656723,
0.2153189480304718,
-0.6260500550270081,
-0.46196696162223816,
0.07634183764457703,
-0.06143173947930336,
0.23120252788066864,
0.5657410621643066,
-0.4274752736091614,
0.38895758986473083,
-0.232933908700943,
0.41079363226890564,
0.6356059312820435,
-0.23504969477653503,
0.5823462009429932,
-0.20115900039672852,
0.26225951313972473,
0.16522648930549622,
0.10731734335422516,
-0.587563693523407,
-0.1686682552099228,
-0.9395250082015991,
-0.13538146018981934,
0.20294201374053955,
0.3104651868343353,
-0.21336333453655243,
0.3070949614048004,
-0.28803783655166626,
-0.4300040602684021,
-0.21938422322273254,
0.4333992898464203,
0.14870984852313995,
0.5547754764556885,
0.5983099937438965,
0.0667111724615097,
-0.43299171328544617,
-0.6855002641677856,
-0.10375796258449554,
-0.3469803035259247,
-0.07398057729005814,
0.19630563259124756,
0.2565876245498657,
-0.5776485204696655,
0.9072514772415161,
-0.6237053871154785,
-0.3006976842880249,
-0.32485321164131165,
-0.08355725556612015,
0.3057534694671631,
0.490482896566391,
0.37342509627342224,
-0.37416574358940125,
-0.2994409501552582,
-0.14622345566749573,
-0.8631054162979126,
-0.07851661741733551,
-0.13282479345798492,
0.14719033241271973,
0.3736570179462433,
0.7316555380821228,
-0.8395296931266785,
-0.005355176515877247,
0.7433871030807495,
-0.28044331073760986,
0.5279703140258789,
-0.684001088142395,
-0.09494467824697495,
-1.1893301010131836,
0.02856087125837803,
-0.39179304242134094,
-0.26753583550453186,
-0.531632661819458,
0.13438481092453003,
0.5022395849227905,
-0.17654018104076385,
-0.5225377082824707,
0.890555202960968,
-0.718026876449585,
0.06384848803281784,
-0.4870659410953522,
0.1315232217311859,
-0.0921020358800888,
0.08001171797513962,
0.04509701952338219,
0.8765869140625,
0.34843727946281433,
-0.6914116740226746,
0.3187795877456665,
-0.08428969234228134,
-0.43706339597702026,
0.2151087373495102,
-0.4820726215839386,
0.16809311509132385,
0.0054520126432180405,
-0.03462297096848488,
-0.8544315695762634,
-0.07912378758192062,
-0.1789560168981552,
0.13792459666728973,
0.6188146471977234,
-0.011435262858867645,
-0.49215665459632874,
-0.49733680486679077,
0.017706934362649918,
0.5799958109855652,
0.5752766132354736,
-0.7579408288002014,
0.7589025497436523,
0.6950940489768982,
-0.02679290622472763,
-0.3352099359035492,
-0.6249527335166931,
0.152769535779953,
-0.3613962233066559,
-0.5578757524490356,
0.3910006880760193,
-0.23702894151210785,
-0.16687282919883728,
0.08387406915426254,
0.09976671636104584,
-0.24231860041618347,
0.016139991581439972,
0.06722379475831985,
0.23378416895866394,
-0.3157636523246765,
0.6538370251655579,
-0.31094709038734436,
-0.24821794033050537,
0.10870734602212906,
-0.503248929977417,
0.6995455026626587,
-0.22855918109416962,
-0.2431776076555252,
-0.025620372965931892,
0.013770181685686111,
0.6078301668167114,
-0.09462615847587585,
0.8040971159934998,
0.3016648590564728,
-0.38555994629859924,
-0.32127949595451355,
-0.9810669422149658,
-0.03768050670623779,
-0.5057529807090759,
0.46429339051246643,
-0.2337515652179718,
-1.2474579811096191,
0.6349872350692749,
-0.21587805449962616,
-0.06490427255630493,
0.4964158833026886,
0.7551811337471008,
-0.2128509134054184,
0.6005464792251587,
0.7412074208259583,
-0.3689107298851013,
0.2541397213935852,
-0.021787352859973907,
0.021677235141396523,
-0.8231052756309509,
-0.02424188144505024,
-0.11718390882015228,
0.016136199235916138,
-0.1993056833744049,
-0.8237874507904053,
-0.10831509530544281,
0.1721954643726349,
-0.3075251281261444,
0.42252835631370544,
-0.372869074344635,
0.6079018712043762,
0.15560129284858704,
-0.2636268138885498,
0.44049572944641113,
-0.2871544063091278,
-0.19050832092761993,
0.010696771554648876,
-0.7994434833526611,
-0.44406402111053467,
1.1323130130767822,
0.6446577310562134,
1.2842774391174316,
0.003965010866522789,
0.5719742774963379,
0.19231553375720978,
0.5161693692207336,
-0.5680870413780212,
0.5481253862380981,
-0.2525639832019806,
-0.7180994153022766,
-0.39093950390815735,
-0.34046661853790283,
-0.855757474899292,
0.005963244941085577,
0.15421481430530548,
-0.7490618824958801,
-0.2384081780910492,
0.40729930996894836,
-0.3752051889896393,
0.644019603729248,
-0.5617848038673401,
0.7909995913505554,
-0.472073495388031,
-0.2158183753490448,
-0.4397156238555908,
-0.2673223316669464,
0.45531323552131653,
-0.5479691028594971,
0.11705583333969116,
-0.27775537967681885,
-0.1402195394039154,
0.740891695022583,
-0.2851642668247223,
0.6729813814163208,
-0.07919813692569733,
-0.36772117018699646,
0.41624879837036133,
0.2139873057603836,
0.35992562770843506,
-0.009197402745485306,
-0.29325130581855774,
0.43545597791671753,
-0.13691088557243347,
-0.13244929909706116,
-0.6882184743881226,
0.9951197504997253,
-0.6714428663253784,
-0.7820033431053162,
-0.2205321341753006,
-0.8638470768928528,
0.0733138769865036,
0.3399362564086914,
-0.2769523859024048,
0.2580881714820862,
-0.3009023666381836,
0.3899874687194824,
1.0737699270248413,
-0.539807140827179,
0.6524794101715088,
0.8980928659439087,
-0.8071423768997192,
-0.26690495014190674,
0.7515620589256287,
0.38733771443367004,
0.23321813344955444,
0.3545590341091156,
0.3684117794036865,
-0.4092419445514679,
-0.6161047220230103,
-0.37103959918022156,
0.3962565064430237,
-0.6359627842903137,
-0.18295063078403473,
-0.7638279795646667,
-0.5670052766799927,
-0.1154477521777153,
0.10120375454425812,
-0.9632300138473511,
-0.43070921301841736,
-0.19829913973808289,
0.09135788679122925,
0.45658135414123535,
0.9215882420539856,
-0.009563938714563847,
0.5856249332427979,
-0.8477040529251099,
0.20444168150424957,
0.4560657739639282,
0.6642757654190063,
0.09946797788143158,
-0.8411698937416077,
-0.6612133383750916,
-0.26963862776756287,
-0.19237931072711945,
-0.5670711398124695,
0.3283606469631195,
0.05542111396789551,
0.6275858283042908,
0.30425864458084106,
-0.25204625725746155,
0.5870067477226257,
-0.7178409695625305,
0.6149930357933044,
0.13385681807994843,
-0.7824030518531799,
0.5379975438117981,
-0.4100727140903473,
0.8200960159301758,
0.41386866569519043,
0.2548011839389801,
-0.6166579127311707,
-0.5195989608764648,
-0.42131170630455017,
-0.6556290984153748,
0.4235491156578064,
-0.25566765666007996,
0.5987489223480225,
-0.17269565165042877,
0.5928888916969299,
-0.05152164772152901,
0.08631855994462967,
-0.7009596824645996,
-0.33222314715385437,
-0.08328404277563095,
-0.2013944536447525,
-0.06837715953588486,
-0.786450982093811,
0.19725355505943298,
-0.3100387752056122,
0.5952463150024414,
0.02920212224125862,
0.3114737570285797,
-0.2540229260921478,
-0.46949708461761475,
-0.05815339833498001,
0.35543093085289,
0.5118935704231262,
0.8769375085830688,
-0.3851320147514343,
0.44767844676971436,
0.5375894904136658,
-0.5174228549003601,
0.1903526782989502,
-0.08741198480129242,
-0.3077796697616577,
-0.1973498910665512,
0.018734881654381752,
0.43562522530555725,
0.7778928279876709,
-0.604224681854248,
0.32003968954086304,
-0.17858900129795074,
0.04344821721315384,
-0.5575665235519409,
0.2523145079612732,
0.6137127876281738,
0.16048456728458405,
0.45729365944862366,
-0.2900404930114746,
-0.2764204442501068,
-0.47171032428741455,
0.5524727702140808,
0.2977789640426636,
-0.4265585243701935,
-0.24992315471172333,
0.7855953574180603,
-0.0106698302552104,
-0.19452254474163055,
0.6756439805030823,
0.014248045161366463,
-0.34430965781211853,
0.11134132742881775,
0.9570948481559753,
0.7542526721954346,
-0.7272090911865234,
-0.03017338551580906,
0.26690688729286194,
0.2741735279560089,
-0.31645843386650085,
0.15925905108451843,
0.23198887705802917,
-0.9568455219268799,
-0.4446052014827728,
-0.7034829258918762,
-0.220237597823143,
0.44141727685928345,
-0.36771655082702637,
0.1942528784275055,
-0.45082175731658936,
-0.0038997563533484936,
-0.48383674025535583,
-0.26038265228271484,
-0.45254266262054443,
0.26462167501449585,
0.06610208749771118,
1.1179322004318237,
-0.47498619556427,
1.4854825735092163,
0.38848572969436646,
-0.1695317029953003,
-0.6803027391433716,
-0.1422322690486908,
-0.3177896738052368,
-1.0135178565979004,
0.636681079864502,
0.19998709857463837,
0.033874500542879105,
0.22072549164295197,
-0.1888411045074463,
-1.2526463270187378,
1.245498776435852,
0.47309762239456177,
-0.6647651195526123,
-0.00039764452958479524,
0.10310201346874237,
0.4573094844818115,
-0.45458030700683594,
0.2700033187866211,
0.5379517078399658,
0.3072495758533478,
0.04596514627337456,
-0.6498960852622986,
0.15918411314487457,
0.0760684460401535,
0.10639858990907669,
0.3567798435688019,
-0.8744635581970215,
0.9712634086608887,
-0.22947539389133453,
-0.2837029695510864,
-0.08215759694576263,
0.9963851571083069,
0.19533352553844452,
-0.20577099919319153,
0.4352102279663086,
0.7784767150878906,
0.7818294763565063,
0.1833064705133438,
0.8832194209098816,
-0.6979449987411499,
0.35602372884750366,
1.5316028594970703,
-0.35573992133140564,
0.9995709657669067,
0.3819368779659271,
0.05157751590013504,
0.584093451499939,
0.05859597027301788,
-0.06901640444993973,
0.3290093243122101,
0.22003313899040222,
-0.273316353559494,
-0.14439983665943146,
0.15941685438156128,
-0.38458505272865295,
0.4828127920627594,
0.24672327935695648,
-0.47813138365745544,
-0.29694506525993347,
-0.17041604220867157,
0.17276324331760406,
0.07242473214864731,
-0.3684294521808624,
0.6160817742347717,
0.2632482647895813,
-0.5332178473472595,
0.5184373259544373,
0.10066085308790207,
0.601726233959198,
-0.5084137916564941,
0.24429896473884583,
-0.3015255033969879,
0.46290698647499084,
0.03400949016213417,
-0.8906278014183044,
0.6326776146888733,
-0.04569629952311516,
-0.38530871272087097,
-0.46209582686424255,
1.0351788997650146,
-0.7843113541603088,
-0.48249995708465576,
0.5911962389945984,
0.5570759773254395,
0.06580383330583572,
-0.19545318186283112,
-0.70744389295578,
0.16305109858512878,
-0.2823331952095032,
-0.36320120096206665,
0.4694468379020691,
0.3678971230983734,
0.023069798946380615,
1.0090147256851196,
0.33271023631095886,
0.1773606389760971,
0.14772747457027435,
0.20850823819637299,
0.7640354633331299,
-0.8826154470443726,
-0.24545176327228546,
-1.1324564218521118,
0.4098687767982483,
0.029546380043029785,
0.07133980840444565,
1.0429917573928833,
0.759745717048645,
0.6254788637161255,
-0.1908944845199585,
0.4969405233860016,
0.31906092166900635,
0.4351574182510376,
-0.5199598073959351,
1.1225348711013794,
-0.4112858772277832,
0.4753018319606781,
0.02606937848031521,
-0.8910202980041504,
-0.2953355014324188,
0.4732634723186493,
-0.3101438581943512,
0.06857198476791382,
0.5791358947753906,
0.8563307523727417,
-0.13025330007076263,
-0.1934231072664261,
0.6906505227088928,
0.40840384364128113,
0.19246996939182281,
0.5326199531555176,
1.121641993522644,
-0.2735251784324646,
0.4469791650772095,
-0.13230617344379425,
-0.029149195179343224,
-0.11824130266904831,
-1.1824593544006348,
-0.9937697649002075,
-0.43029338121414185,
-0.3483128845691681,
-0.03992489352822304,
-0.14369317889213562,
0.6635802984237671,
0.8510237336158752,
-0.7744089961051941,
-0.6348658204078674,
-0.04332073777914047,
0.20620667934417725,
0.2591480612754822,
-0.2155674695968628,
0.22137068212032318,
-0.49641090631484985,
-0.2821265757083893,
0.5640291571617126,
0.6052484512329102,
0.18404434621334076,
-0.6375828385353088,
-0.21982550621032715,
-0.2525615692138672,
0.19443905353546143,
0.669082760810852,
0.1599421203136444,
-0.5282422304153442,
-0.3761214315891266,
-0.09640547633171082,
-0.17429275810718536,
0.17343494296073914,
0.680380642414093,
-0.7872521877288818,
0.4503306746482849,
0.14893542230129242,
0.826251208782196,
0.7376477718353271,
-0.19640162587165833,
0.7248433828353882,
-0.6282731294631958,
0.024024439975619316,
-0.07885032147169113,
0.46920591592788696,
0.3955658972263336,
-0.3272058963775635,
0.3325572609901428,
0.017007464542984962,
-0.8221608996391296,
-0.6568990349769592,
0.004397180862724781,
-0.667483925819397,
-0.3786487281322479,
1.1087498664855957,
-0.2074699103832245,
-0.21178030967712402,
-0.08789153397083282,
0.0664956271648407,
0.17191877961158752,
-0.13062284886837006,
1.0649783611297607,
0.7481163740158081,
0.11687260121107101,
-0.4736349284648895,
-0.5058715343475342,
0.34954315423965454,
0.2892971336841583,
-0.7923293709754944,
0.46052438020706177,
0.3224047124385834,
0.4472569525241852,
0.11076734215021133,
0.8778071999549866,
-0.17234554886817932,
-0.015166586264967918,
-0.3294128179550171,
0.17567066848278046,
-0.0813775584101677,
-0.5587239265441895,
-0.4623112082481384,
0.16709676384925842,
0.29092949628829956,
0.23806467652320862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04617v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04617v2 | InfLLM: Training-Free Long-Context Extrapolation for LLMs with an Efficient Context Memory | 2024-02-07T06:50:42 | 2024-05-28T12:05:12 | Chaojun Xiao, Pengle Zhang, Xu Han, Guangxuan Xiao, Yankai Lin, Zhengyan Zhang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a cornerstone in real-world
applications with lengthy streaming inputs (e.g., LLM-driven agents). However,
existing LLMs, pre-trained on sequences with a restricted maximum length,
cannot process longer sequences due to the out-of-domain and distraction
issues. Common solutions often involve continual pre-training on longer
sequences, which will introduce expensive computational overhead and
uncontrollable change in model capabilities. In this paper, we unveil the
intrinsic capacity of LLMs for understanding extremely long sequences without
any fine-tuning. To this end, we introduce a training-free memory-based method,
InfLLM. Specifically, InfLLM stores distant contexts into additional memory
units and employs an efficient mechanism to lookup token-relevant units for
attention computation. Thereby, InfLLM allows LLMs to efficiently process long
sequences with a limited context window and well capture long-distance
dependencies. Without any training, InfLLM enables LLMs that are pre-trained on
sequences consisting of a few thousand tokens to achieve comparable performance
with competitive baselines that continually train these LLMs on long sequences.
Even when the sequence length is scaled to $1,024$K, InfLLM still effectively
captures long-distance dependencies. Our code can be found in
\url{https://github.com/thunlp/InfLLM}. | [
-0.35151928663253784,
-0.5466445088386536,
0.6857312321662903,
0.2473047822713852,
-0.5331079959869385,
-0.056917060166597366,
-0.5095522999763489,
-0.5897109508514404,
0.034545525908470154,
0.4387572705745697,
-0.437384694814682,
-0.1572212129831314,
-0.3597147464752197,
-0.06255850195884705,
-0.4537096321582794,
0.8313038945198059,
0.11167660355567932,
-0.10466644912958145,
-0.5164269208908081,
-0.2703540027141571,
-0.038768962025642395,
-0.7024680972099304,
-0.4665048122406006,
-0.2725772261619568,
0.41956815123558044,
0.48962849378585815,
0.34555453062057495,
0.3249977231025696,
0.26210305094718933,
0.156301349401474,
-0.2669142782688141,
0.4314781129360199,
-0.7538780570030212,
0.1458030343055725,
0.11987585574388504,
-0.10708755999803543,
-0.38394227623939514,
-0.30649736523628235,
0.9122142791748047,
0.48965179920196533,
0.034757740795612335,
0.3843754529953003,
0.13053496181964874,
0.7750691175460815,
-0.5170059204101562,
0.23268529772758484,
-0.8100413084030151,
0.0361071340739727,
-0.28504690527915955,
-0.2636752724647522,
-0.6084740161895752,
0.09655661880970001,
0.19704470038414001,
-0.4615660011768341,
-0.09802769869565964,
0.1446913480758667,
0.6280638575553894,
0.34116873145103455,
-0.29025527834892273,
-0.06660444289445877,
-0.6131547689437866,
0.7470558285713196,
-0.8111671805381775,
0.47640764713287354,
0.46028199791908264,
0.350107878446579,
-0.421195924282074,
-0.6235340237617493,
-0.5604320764541626,
-0.4055197238922119,
-0.012627510353922844,
-0.12570688128471375,
0.1536291539669037,
0.12163590639829636,
0.4697941243648529,
0.12171556800603867,
-0.4398294985294342,
0.018255991861224174,
-0.066318579018116,
0.04587000235915184,
0.46987515687942505,
0.06551506370306015,
-0.16338522732257843,
0.3672994077205658,
-0.6588069796562195,
0.2651221752166748,
-0.906284749507904,
0.2074914127588272,
-0.19933082163333893,
0.29374679923057556,
-0.07718819379806519,
0.3505629897117615,
-0.09664032608270645,
0.7739218473434448,
0.06809110939502716,
-0.1446961909532547,
0.16954265534877777,
0.3514900505542755,
-0.37094801664352417,
0.024461308494210243,
0.4992836117744446,
0.0423523411154747,
0.21423183381557465,
-0.15060795843601227,
-0.37358301877975464,
-0.4840894043445587,
-0.03235109895467758,
-0.8260529041290283,
0.26657700538635254,
0.34665748476982117,
-0.10135306417942047,
0.15978267788887024,
-0.06979445368051529,
-0.7387811541557312,
-0.16843989491462708,
-0.25755876302719116,
0.2818475067615509,
-0.5011236667633057,
-0.042988747358322144,
-0.13287138938903809,
0.2043856680393219,
0.3178556561470032,
0.29859137535095215,
-0.71839439868927,
0.12366031855344772,
0.7178681492805481,
0.947580873966217,
-0.23361505568027496,
-0.42678335309028625,
-1.1557358503341675,
0.44152429699897766,
-0.06683371216058731,
0.752716064453125,
-0.572634220123291,
-0.1577494889497757,
0.08039438724517822,
-0.13325342535972595,
0.10753662884235382,
-0.5457792282104492,
0.2683559060096741,
-0.8017165660858154,
-0.12905780971050262,
0.09638550877571106,
-1.0703386068344116,
-0.11108279973268509,
0.2545236349105835,
-0.49833944439888,
1.063622236251831,
0.29738590121269226,
-0.40463361144065857,
0.2076456993818283,
-0.9012935757637024,
-0.4085148274898529,
0.25462403893470764,
-0.03423966467380524,
-0.3009350001811981,
0.29468467831611633,
0.20671455562114716,
0.5966861844062805,
-0.2419060468673706,
0.29490089416503906,
-0.5401906371116638,
-0.6177664995193481,
0.3174424171447754,
-0.476398766040802,
0.582102358341217,
0.12957383692264557,
-0.3214174807071686,
0.3861578106880188,
-0.7102735638618469,
0.02255915105342865,
-0.07028558105230331,
-0.4429098665714264,
-0.23218268156051636,
-0.11859944462776184,
0.085740827023983,
0.4135662615299225,
0.26988768577575684,
-0.48104652762413025,
-0.038085974752902985,
-0.39939162135124207,
0.45034608244895935,
0.7532903552055359,
-0.4015921652317047,
0.38036495447158813,
-0.2121896743774414,
0.47110629081726074,
-0.017081089317798615,
0.2112017422914505,
-0.4419245719909668,
-0.133978933095932,
-0.7991676330566406,
-0.5522255301475525,
-0.0388447605073452,
0.11393988877534866,
-0.6011062264442444,
0.4338008463382721,
-0.5752008557319641,
-0.24642547965049744,
-0.18842950463294983,
0.20036980509757996,
0.2927387058734894,
0.6303770542144775,
0.5328341126441956,
-0.0030850644689053297,
-0.4100607633590698,
-0.3894954323768616,
-0.1435268074274063,
0.058532606810331345,
-0.02182178758084774,
0.3151338994503021,
0.4765612483024597,
-0.1654280424118042,
1.1457445621490479,
-0.30283960700035095,
-0.5157793760299683,
-0.2946006655693054,
-0.4635030925273895,
0.25170406699180603,
0.3207944929599762,
0.35980069637298584,
-0.5483884811401367,
-0.6984360814094543,
-0.1493668407201767,
-0.5884813070297241,
0.0410570353269577,
-0.18194429576396942,
-0.16101470589637756,
0.5373260378837585,
0.7907214760780334,
-0.783473551273346,
0.28861573338508606,
0.6063836216926575,
-0.3788975179195404,
0.41510042548179626,
-0.41677433252334595,
-0.6714721322059631,
-0.6240661144256592,
0.236020028591156,
-0.3245494067668915,
-0.6917479634284973,
-0.6821244359016418,
0.2678680717945099,
0.4217526912689209,
-0.17749425768852234,
-0.8971684575080872,
1.0435150861740112,
-0.7554364204406738,
-0.22209060192108154,
-0.3274819552898407,
0.05573583394289017,
-0.051951467990875244,
0.8069206476211548,
0.12447809427976608,
0.5812475085258484,
0.5182192921638489,
-0.6294299960136414,
0.2875775396823883,
-0.10536522418260574,
-0.46398821473121643,
0.26319271326065063,
-0.19665957987308502,
0.43021658062934875,
-0.15493635833263397,
0.6029931306838989,
-0.6965708136558533,
-0.12180058658123016,
0.09141088277101517,
-0.13656194508075714,
0.4890638589859009,
-0.1166917085647583,
-0.5637558102607727,
-0.2773350775241852,
-0.26456257700920105,
0.5413221120834351,
0.5540447235107422,
-0.917806088924408,
0.6517465710639954,
0.37199780344963074,
0.2155940979719162,
-0.5802077651023865,
-0.6196793913841248,
-0.053448718041181564,
-0.48700401186943054,
-0.21303051710128784,
0.1460752934217453,
-0.24147221446037292,
-0.03578292205929756,
-0.11653492599725723,
-0.006362515967339277,
-0.05117100849747658,
-0.07152553647756577,
0.230952188372612,
0.09254854172468185,
-0.15199853479862213,
0.4845272898674011,
-0.09775105863809586,
-0.09248130768537521,
-0.06114882230758667,
-0.5595730543136597,
0.780575156211853,
-0.3018249273300171,
-0.3578137457370758,
-0.13347794115543365,
0.4241642355918884,
0.9220705628395081,
-0.14429102838039398,
0.7322248816490173,
0.47379788756370544,
-0.35973966121673584,
-0.4436422884464264,
-0.5323655009269714,
0.08134080469608307,
-0.4943805932998657,
0.5124222040176392,
-0.26043033599853516,
-1.0570933818817139,
0.4301689565181732,
0.061669860035181046,
0.09238000214099884,
0.2136252522468567,
0.38327521085739136,
-0.1001540869474411,
0.4985831379890442,
0.5694408416748047,
-0.3411872088909149,
0.6044683456420898,
-0.13548140227794647,
-0.08767124265432358,
-1.0459846258163452,
-0.12584108114242554,
0.14508390426635742,
-0.22011014819145203,
0.15799494087696075,
-0.8339623808860779,
0.371366024017334,
0.0597132183611393,
-0.4710192382335663,
0.0168421920388937,
-0.19417698681354523,
0.9187631607055664,
0.34323954582214355,
-0.021475035697221756,
0.23386387526988983,
0.14189442992210388,
-0.034024156630039215,
0.23785211145877838,
-0.6539961695671082,
-0.1649758368730545,
1.1314923763275146,
0.4515269994735718,
0.6565321087837219,
0.06322311609983444,
0.5304648876190186,
0.16106179356575012,
0.6369629502296448,
-0.9519211649894714,
0.6557426452636719,
-0.051633235067129135,
-0.3440812826156616,
-0.6727510690689087,
-0.244959756731987,
-0.7987030148506165,
0.25715330243110657,
0.1993790864944458,
-0.5495607852935791,
-0.257072389125824,
0.2521556615829468,
-0.5322818160057068,
0.5563241839408875,
-0.24371054768562317,
0.4183831512928009,
-0.515146791934967,
-0.36582323908805847,
-0.22191382944583893,
-0.8100454211235046,
0.15735508501529694,
-0.3215198218822479,
0.019110439345240593,
-0.29952099919319153,
-0.19746729731559753,
0.5354915857315063,
-0.5356169939041138,
0.8182641863822937,
-0.28496915102005005,
-0.230401411652565,
0.33241167664527893,
-0.09875031560659409,
0.7241761088371277,
0.16007216274738312,
-0.08832099288702011,
0.2421869933605194,
-0.32889747619628906,
-0.5682817101478577,
-0.46514374017715454,
0.6834946870803833,
-0.4882515072822571,
-0.5028277635574341,
-0.36085519194602966,
-0.749937891960144,
-0.39154088497161865,
0.23832447826862335,
0.22418174147605896,
0.5564806461334229,
-0.12451283633708954,
0.05734908580780029,
0.6195964813232422,
-0.12499821186065674,
0.8504531383514404,
0.48896846175193787,
-0.41795435547828674,
-0.2691441774368286,
0.8190532922744751,
0.029797200113534927,
0.3073689639568329,
0.7157273292541504,
0.1435539573431015,
-0.6326500177383423,
-0.45786142349243164,
-0.5604345798492432,
0.3022812604904175,
-0.8131579756736755,
-0.30033019185066223,
-0.5713748931884766,
-0.21457533538341522,
-0.141935333609581,
-0.13271819055080414,
-0.29760292172431946,
-0.1472141295671463,
-0.48496630787849426,
0.05720992758870125,
0.5028813481330872,
0.44814199209213257,
0.14996618032455444,
0.14395178854465485,
-0.981724202632904,
0.019446972757577896,
0.2580614387989044,
0.5153282284736633,
0.291884183883667,
-0.7975536584854126,
-0.6258527040481567,
-0.041389573365449905,
-0.033415403217077255,
-0.48794469237327576,
0.5776829719543457,
0.574884831905365,
0.3218398690223694,
0.6047609448432922,
0.15369006991386414,
1.090910792350769,
-0.6195741295814514,
0.6813138127326965,
0.01992272399365902,
-1.0309404134750366,
0.1178925484418869,
-0.19761796295642853,
0.5999767184257507,
0.3926409184932709,
0.18694129586219788,
-0.5356835722923279,
-0.36484166979789734,
-0.4628767967224121,
-0.9994972944259644,
0.6166496276855469,
-0.09668981283903122,
0.2253379076719284,
-0.09622491151094437,
0.38161924481391907,
0.08619048446416855,
0.07342926412820816,
-0.4411781430244446,
-0.0393470861017704,
0.015451224520802498,
-0.04132627323269844,
-0.3759778141975403,
-0.4459659457206726,
-0.06374719738960266,
-0.41048407554626465,
0.5246107578277588,
-0.41086363792419434,
0.3935510516166687,
0.2709416449069977,
-0.6170086860656738,
-0.07949502766132355,
0.09207505732774734,
0.9627664685249329,
0.5727630257606506,
-0.2828056812286377,
0.2639957666397095,
0.5263417959213257,
-0.3351069390773773,
0.17085976898670197,
0.0755983367562294,
0.12707971036434174,
0.04745284095406532,
0.41871407628059387,
0.8486915230751038,
0.21905776858329773,
-1.2014743089675903,
0.5245160460472107,
0.08234088867902756,
0.11416690796613693,
-0.8046570420265198,
-0.2748700976371765,
0.20681287348270416,
0.3110509514808655,
0.3907272219657898,
-0.2137778252363205,
-0.27553218603134155,
-0.30906352400779724,
0.34045931696891785,
0.4713241159915924,
-0.6116676330566406,
-0.2170563042163849,
0.4749104380607605,
0.25564083456993103,
-0.09745501726865768,
0.7763509750366211,
-0.19822059571743011,
-0.4423534572124481,
0.5222883820533752,
0.7390850186347961,
0.9447839260101318,
0.025715773925185204,
-0.19840317964553833,
0.0354267917573452,
-0.2262522429227829,
-0.07726867496967316,
0.024418650195002556,
-0.2815287411212921,
-0.5726688504219055,
-0.5572150945663452,
-0.7661397457122803,
-0.32975053787231445,
0.5445411205291748,
-0.38537731766700745,
0.1592855453491211,
-0.5448573231697083,
0.06981582194566727,
-0.6846691370010376,
-0.10928510129451752,
-0.5141703486442566,
0.0457620732486248,
0.4658382534980774,
1.1414891481399536,
-0.27003392577171326,
1.3285776376724243,
0.5608890652656555,
0.16706547141075134,
-0.6270450353622437,
0.10895715653896332,
-0.16970287263393402,
-0.6800815463066101,
0.7199795246124268,
0.6272411942481995,
-0.27982914447784424,
0.04657011851668358,
-0.43740347027778625,
-1.096394658088684,
0.9758742451667786,
0.5751839280128479,
-0.7668512463569641,
-0.10471733659505844,
0.1904357522726059,
0.5264497399330139,
-0.5735427737236023,
0.1925303339958191,
0.49792495369911194,
0.14195287227630615,
-0.007117787376046181,
-0.7522476315498352,
0.12323267012834549,
-0.23656794428825378,
-0.046780433505773544,
0.20086196064949036,
-0.8184916973114014,
0.6455696225166321,
-0.4241178631782532,
-0.16471964120864868,
0.09039582312107086,
0.8843462467193604,
0.3305501341819763,
0.1666133552789688,
0.6042612791061401,
0.463209331035614,
0.7871642708778381,
0.3200151324272156,
0.9619185924530029,
-0.4049884080886841,
0.5067231059074402,
1.4930850267410278,
-0.4267636239528656,
0.9865276217460632,
0.6697423458099365,
0.08046428859233856,
0.19822625815868378,
0.4776073396205902,
0.251200407743454,
0.48013177514076233,
0.2913168668746948,
-0.6178461909294128,
-0.28231361508369446,
0.10927701741456985,
-0.32194948196411133,
0.27625083923339844,
0.490409791469574,
-0.26714110374450684,
-0.19210682809352875,
0.16897544264793396,
0.03984012082219124,
-0.2393570840358734,
-0.41287875175476074,
0.5901669859886169,
0.3048105239868164,
-0.6249255537986755,
0.8799099922180176,
-0.4370104670524597,
0.808900773525238,
-0.7758110165596008,
0.07812799513339996,
-0.3574725091457367,
0.42017656564712524,
0.007069116923958063,
-0.5497277975082397,
0.3187054693698883,
0.06195667386054993,
0.03441774472594261,
-0.19741936028003693,
0.5396763682365417,
-0.7324478626251221,
-0.3054114580154419,
0.4686257243156433,
0.3235030174255371,
0.23800384998321533,
-0.3583064079284668,
-0.3918485939502716,
-0.15891677141189575,
-0.157577246427536,
-0.530906081199646,
0.6647471785545349,
0.42818599939346313,
-0.11397766321897507,
0.8870968818664551,
0.6787388920783997,
0.08861685544252396,
0.09737725555896759,
-0.04921441897749901,
0.8462147116661072,
-0.7638106346130371,
-0.5614587068557739,
-1.1920870542526245,
0.34569674730300903,
0.08299488574266434,
-0.26007315516471863,
0.5076679587364197,
0.5926520228385925,
0.9173779487609863,
-0.1599748730659485,
0.5643123984336853,
0.25276944041252136,
0.26253920793533325,
-0.5704300403594971,
0.7699506878852844,
-0.7054780125617981,
0.1800553947687149,
-0.009378494694828987,
-0.7729966044425964,
-0.5426961779594421,
0.4095270335674286,
-0.06480567157268524,
-0.25510576367378235,
0.5558497905731201,
0.5569824576377869,
-0.1335209608078003,
-0.23328419029712677,
0.6513538956642151,
0.1500452160835266,
0.5428300499916077,
0.9008476138114929,
1.0313669443130493,
0.1088436022400856,
0.5327296257019043,
-0.18538424372673035,
-0.12863971292972565,
-0.47796180844306946,
-1.0312495231628418,
-1.0358681678771973,
-0.43036264181137085,
0.11121612787246704,
-0.16879601776599884,
-0.1444755345582962,
1.3753466606140137,
0.8150913119316101,
-0.6371106505393982,
-0.41060829162597656,
0.019272498786449432,
-0.008718346245586872,
-0.27073824405670166,
-0.170439213514328,
0.5837799310684204,
-0.5139193534851074,
-0.6644683480262756,
0.5279887914657593,
0.4477773606777191,
0.13901525735855103,
-0.22927266359329224,
-0.3205917775630951,
-0.018810369074344635,
0.06325578689575195,
1.113403558731079,
0.4704468548297882,
-0.7241445183753967,
-0.3135625123977661,
-0.10564271360635757,
0.08447140455245972,
0.2621620297431946,
0.8296142220497131,
-0.9121282696723938,
0.32806992530822754,
0.30793842673301697,
0.6466569304466248,
0.5907527804374695,
-0.1338028758764267,
0.4150454103946686,
-0.7671529650688171,
0.44586777687072754,
0.3418937027454376,
0.4590713083744049,
0.28906169533729553,
-0.5066972374916077,
0.3871803879737854,
0.004862716421484947,
-0.558707058429718,
-0.9943229556083679,
0.29934391379356384,
-0.9996784925460815,
-0.3125763535499573,
1.321291208267212,
-0.4016626179218292,
-0.2786262631416321,
-0.17454415559768677,
-0.08618472516536713,
0.24190907180309296,
-0.6547913551330566,
0.588458776473999,
0.3859751522541046,
-0.35987553000450134,
-0.15133525431156158,
-0.3124949038028717,
0.6989932060241699,
0.45444685220718384,
-0.6942565441131592,
0.36488229036331177,
0.25472038984298706,
0.20786234736442566,
-0.11679553240537643,
0.8087893128395081,
0.001838147989474237,
0.04672174155712128,
-0.4925217032432556,
-0.25288835167884827,
-0.37249359488487244,
-0.5063713788986206,
-0.6033690571784973,
0.26612892746925354,
0.0724574401974678,
0.03624032065272331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04616v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04616v2 | TinyLLM: Learning a Small Student from Multiple Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T06:48:24 | 2024-04-01T01:28:48 | Yijun Tian, Yikun Han, Xiusi Chen, Wei Wang, Nitesh V. Chawla | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transferring the reasoning capability from stronger large language models
(LLMs) to smaller ones has been quite appealing, as smaller LLMs are more
flexible to deploy with less expense. Among the existing solutions, knowledge
distillation stands out due to its outstanding efficiency and generalization.
However, existing methods suffer from several drawbacks, including limited
knowledge diversity and the lack of rich contextual information. To solve the
problems and facilitate the learning of compact language models, we propose
TinyLLM, a new knowledge distillation paradigm to learn a small student LLM
from multiple large teacher LLMs. In particular, we encourage the student LLM
to not only generate the correct answers but also understand the rationales
behind these answers. Given that different LLMs possess diverse reasoning
skills, we guide the student model to assimilate knowledge from various teacher
LLMs. We further introduce an in-context example generator and a
teacher-forcing Chain-of-Thought strategy to ensure that the rationales are
accurate and grounded in contextually appropriate scenarios. Extensive
experiments on six datasets across two reasoning tasks demonstrate the
superiority of our method. Results show that TinyLLM can outperform large
teacher LLMs significantly, despite a considerably smaller model size. | [
-0.3178999722003937,
-0.7834667563438416,
1.0825437307357788,
-0.1971309930086136,
-0.229018896818161,
0.061228394508361816,
-0.6177205443382263,
-0.02629619650542736,
-0.2964593768119812,
0.37375926971435547,
-0.2448159158229828,
-0.24623355269432068,
-0.6924319863319397,
0.003125503659248352,
-0.22712890803813934,
0.6712247729301453,
0.17878985404968262,
0.28827619552612305,
-0.3288361728191376,
-0.15341319143772125,
-0.7092754244804382,
-0.1446317881345749,
-0.7556645274162292,
-0.6869997382164001,
0.5850390791893005,
1.0346782207489014,
0.5390719175338745,
0.516066312789917,
0.06956388056278229,
0.25062838196754456,
-0.22044652700424194,
0.38003695011138916,
-0.39608079195022583,
-0.09656175971031189,
-0.48459428548812866,
-0.7805150747299194,
-0.09883755445480347,
0.100917749106884,
0.6771937012672424,
0.997938334941864,
-0.24174363911151886,
0.24976319074630737,
0.22311389446258545,
0.5739914774894714,
-0.40521132946014404,
0.13858982920646667,
-0.9788989424705505,
-0.15282030403614044,
0.13470236957073212,
0.26979193091392517,
-0.712520956993103,
-0.5300706624984741,
0.2777746319770813,
-0.40735170245170593,
0.06999073922634125,
0.2710587978363037,
0.34468433260917664,
0.38456806540489197,
-0.7391363978385925,
-0.4883384704589844,
-0.7096738815307617,
1.0895105600357056,
-0.6268267631530762,
0.150861918926239,
0.1321614682674408,
0.6522517800331116,
-0.03857416659593582,
-0.8185457587242126,
-0.7988525629043579,
0.1224745661020279,
-0.3398137092590332,
-0.24381420016288757,
-0.019635649397969246,
-0.27286437153816223,
0.17548581957817078,
0.15175487101078033,
-0.21109150350093842,
0.1481775939464569,
-0.5051464438438416,
0.18567457795143127,
0.49330320954322815,
0.25132501125335693,
0.10038672387599945,
-0.18379297852516174,
-0.38575297594070435,
-0.06076548621058464,
-0.8532336354255676,
-0.3333761990070343,
0.09273146092891693,
0.5761116147041321,
-0.09701240807771683,
0.34537366032600403,
0.1547233611345291,
0.7475690841674805,
0.0877988263964653,
-0.8182055354118347,
-0.3164077699184418,
-0.353213906288147,
-0.2656002342700958,
0.16277071833610535,
0.6114493608474731,
-0.029862254858016968,
0.10627347975969315,
0.03295267000794411,
-0.04697513207793236,
-0.19072763621807098,
-0.12677136063575745,
-0.9247472882270813,
-0.5380830764770508,
-0.10511694103479385,
-0.3714810311794281,
-0.18077224493026733,
-0.3245307505130768,
-0.8403856754302979,
-0.4192565083503723,
-0.659410834312439,
0.45786720514297485,
-0.42456626892089844,
-0.19170551002025604,
0.10634492337703705,
-0.14313055574893951,
0.036708179861307144,
0.6728485226631165,
-1.0144855976104736,
0.27496322989463806,
0.5324462056159973,
0.7055792808532715,
-0.0965455025434494,
-0.3346574604511261,
-0.3563173711299896,
0.2814828157424927,
-0.22584187984466553,
0.5511034727096558,
-0.4167882204055786,
-0.3393450975418091,
-0.30563753843307495,
-0.25012466311454773,
-0.2577955424785614,
-0.7827685475349426,
0.20466622710227966,
-0.32306918501853943,
0.2894708216190338,
-0.25123703479766846,
-0.6723359823226929,
-0.19686578214168549,
0.3036709129810333,
-0.5298351645469666,
0.7503734827041626,
0.016901839524507523,
-0.5139096975326538,
0.3323822617530823,
-0.26333844661712646,
-0.27985432744026184,
-0.07217387855052948,
-0.45174479484558105,
-0.07703050225973129,
0.37724122405052185,
0.172029048204422,
0.5197265148162842,
-0.589413583278656,
0.18535250425338745,
-0.2932296693325043,
-0.06789406388998032,
0.08250032365322113,
-0.322261780500412,
0.838056743144989,
0.38810455799102783,
0.12135995179414749,
-0.06503871083259583,
-0.5402519106864929,
-0.08452720195055008,
0.3148166835308075,
-0.5500056147575378,
-0.6352914571762085,
-0.222834512591362,
-0.3481462299823761,
0.2388760894536972,
0.06195793300867081,
-0.27003607153892517,
0.4867608845233917,
-0.27158215641975403,
0.5788427591323853,
0.58601975440979,
0.08539833128452301,
0.977586030960083,
-0.43379613757133484,
0.2138836532831192,
0.017049023881554604,
-0.09523613005876541,
0.05367252603173256,
-0.4667929410934448,
-0.9049308896064758,
-0.34073707461357117,
0.38998058438301086,
0.11530859023332596,
-1.0076898336410522,
-0.060478754341602325,
-0.24861739575862885,
-0.39974895119667053,
-0.5121345520019531,
0.6927482485771179,
0.15174897015094757,
0.5933910608291626,
0.3998618721961975,
0.3796376585960388,
-0.49822065234184265,
-0.6259756088256836,
-0.18805210292339325,
-0.2453489452600479,
-0.0524667352437973,
0.330044150352478,
0.5937694311141968,
-0.25165098905563354,
1.0835694074630737,
-0.7144609093666077,
-0.5687428116798401,
-0.6417675614356995,
-0.009976486675441265,
0.2106674760580063,
0.4833347201347351,
0.6014463901519775,
-0.6755788922309875,
-0.708228349685669,
-0.003851252608001232,
-0.5515792965888977,
0.22583015263080597,
-0.1196875050663948,
-0.09650912135839462,
-0.0015165889635682106,
0.41666263341903687,
-0.5414982438087463,
-0.08285035938024521,
0.3791602849960327,
-0.19271691143512726,
0.4203551411628723,
-0.2153567671775818,
-0.2652968764305115,
-1.2380108833312988,
-0.38758596777915955,
-0.16549897193908691,
-0.33089902997016907,
-0.4263639450073242,
0.17014068365097046,
0.039386115968227386,
0.00860634446144104,
-0.5427252054214478,
0.8398722410202026,
-0.5656899809837341,
0.22236034274101257,
-0.38092029094696045,
0.4396369457244873,
0.2192096710205078,
0.24996060132980347,
0.003327813697978854,
0.48360633850097656,
0.363365113735199,
-0.5194235444068909,
0.49533355236053467,
0.16036105155944824,
-0.46620282530784607,
0.5547295212745667,
-0.33803117275238037,
0.11491835117340088,
0.044204097241163254,
0.16603140532970428,
-0.9335563778877258,
-0.19781813025474548,
-0.262395441532135,
-0.1371040940284729,
0.4295021593570709,
-0.5145269632339478,
-0.6270883083343506,
-0.3132360875606537,
-0.05367107316851616,
0.3054792582988739,
0.7838008403778076,
-1.0743545293807983,
0.8208743929862976,
0.31563422083854675,
-0.12343006581068039,
-0.18136277794837952,
-0.6958209872245789,
-0.19206784665584564,
-0.5465617179870605,
-0.6262257099151611,
-0.1707102209329605,
-0.12648117542266846,
-0.5941636562347412,
0.08009973913431168,
-0.2059888243675232,
-0.174764484167099,
0.15885955095291138,
-0.06427160650491714,
0.2692606449127197,
-0.2392236590385437,
0.420863538980484,
0.15769100189208984,
0.03443080931901932,
-0.028347069397568703,
-0.5674405097961426,
0.28890562057495117,
-0.24719585478305817,
-0.18254201114177704,
0.06451277434825897,
0.20005440711975098,
0.41355451941490173,
0.27908310294151306,
0.8756999373435974,
0.5263532400131226,
-0.4872334897518158,
-0.8312501907348633,
-0.5809180736541748,
-0.5912635922431946,
-0.4621213674545288,
0.03106427751481533,
-0.547519862651825,
-1.160111427307129,
0.2690129578113556,
-0.4555549621582031,
-0.09446606040000916,
0.2230079621076584,
0.750978410243988,
-0.1192249059677124,
0.8900759816169739,
0.7455058097839355,
0.014057392254471779,
0.12201978266239166,
-0.35966527462005615,
0.23674894869327545,
-0.5471343994140625,
-0.2760201096534729,
-0.5026371479034424,
-0.26648661494255066,
-0.052701644599437714,
-0.8187122344970703,
0.21661853790283203,
0.5179845094680786,
-0.10796619951725006,
0.04986746981739998,
-0.29638272523880005,
0.8500267863273621,
0.4781428575515747,
-0.004650141578167677,
0.62906813621521,
-0.09784822165966034,
-0.4431666433811188,
0.029900208115577698,
-1.1108914613723755,
-0.8206496238708496,
1.1174280643463135,
0.2099902480840683,
1.052414059638977,
0.5172625780105591,
0.8860560655593872,
-0.001889862585812807,
0.41082078218460083,
-1.0253989696502686,
0.5661775469779968,
-0.19169415533542633,
-0.6185479760169983,
-0.36535051465034485,
-0.6549257636070251,
-0.5452224612236023,
0.6821302175521851,
-0.07873914390802383,
-0.7604690194129944,
0.0058397287502884865,
0.18192067742347717,
-0.5431535243988037,
0.34298330545425415,
-1.1655455827713013,
0.8735182881355286,
0.03796317055821419,
-0.26496294140815735,
-0.19279232621192932,
-0.4549865424633026,
0.8094272017478943,
-0.3730960190296173,
0.5680515170097351,
-0.1859612762928009,
0.02775546722114086,
0.532171905040741,
-0.6635904312133789,
0.9457927346229553,
-0.06384188681840897,
-0.11597149819135666,
0.607793927192688,
0.2414730191230774,
0.45029187202453613,
0.4721340835094452,
-0.0015872482908889651,
-0.21525126695632935,
0.13209834694862366,
-0.30532532930374146,
-0.582358181476593,
1.0022292137145996,
-0.7756470441818237,
-0.9134485721588135,
-0.22027045488357544,
-0.6233488917350769,
-0.2456388920545578,
0.2265591323375702,
0.08067396283149719,
-0.032311003655195236,
0.14238466322422028,
0.24819351732730865,
0.8189976215362549,
0.22831004858016968,
0.5151762366294861,
0.618820071220398,
-0.3205239176750183,
-0.023095861077308655,
0.7984116077423096,
0.18953992426395416,
0.49318793416023254,
0.22279152274131775,
0.6817333102226257,
-0.46683788299560547,
-0.4519065022468567,
-0.45915889739990234,
0.27620676159858704,
-0.9825766682624817,
-0.25806277990341187,
-0.5290548205375671,
0.04307885095477104,
-0.3050630986690521,
-0.16483785212039948,
-0.5179504752159119,
-0.47437986731529236,
-0.49672260880470276,
-0.044095490127801895,
0.1867332011461258,
0.6170812845230103,
-0.0830058678984642,
0.40384432673454285,
-0.7361176609992981,
0.22003348171710968,
1.0323882102966309,
-0.27242982387542725,
0.24070750176906586,
-0.788824737071991,
-0.21823275089263916,
-0.035039324313402176,
-0.27610281109809875,
-0.7246034145355225,
0.21292617917060852,
0.3974565863609314,
0.5488863587379456,
0.42145073413848877,
0.23752930760383606,
0.596412718296051,
-0.5614548325538635,
0.5842509865760803,
0.47324231266975403,
-0.9599518775939941,
0.7410977482795715,
0.07938273996114731,
0.3593440651893616,
0.569383442401886,
0.3481815457344055,
-0.29878899455070496,
-0.3477928042411804,
-0.594339907169342,
-0.48740747570991516,
0.7153686285018921,
-0.14906057715415955,
0.06380224972963333,
0.16725796461105347,
0.2594320476055145,
0.22881153225898743,
0.10893258452415466,
-0.6332274079322815,
-0.15785132348537445,
0.14562638103961945,
-0.4152945578098297,
-0.0659545287489891,
-0.3163829743862152,
-0.4232991337776184,
-0.43422234058380127,
0.6864302754402161,
-0.6487328410148621,
-0.25116264820098877,
-0.20651240646839142,
-0.27631697058677673,
0.0959375873208046,
0.4662831425666809,
0.265027791261673,
0.6740192770957947,
0.045679960399866104,
0.7739921808242798,
0.6712849140167236,
-0.16097599267959595,
0.3107999563217163,
-0.15746329724788666,
-0.12792086601257324,
-0.10740140080451965,
0.31679287552833557,
0.509723961353302,
0.29137587547302246,
-0.5113572478294373,
0.5638505816459656,
-0.2861822545528412,
-0.2171144187450409,
-0.18437997996807098,
0.32172664999961853,
0.5295895338058472,
0.6134834289550781,
0.3501300811767578,
0.02939724549651146,
-0.10962645709514618,
-0.6079457998275757,
0.08878699690103531,
0.11530764400959015,
-0.1391926407814026,
-0.16973453760147095,
0.5482890605926514,
0.11617523431777954,
0.11655855923891068,
0.37024882435798645,
-0.2948736846446991,
-0.3420524597167969,
0.4681030511856079,
0.6505653858184814,
0.3675684332847595,
-0.11913563311100006,
0.10151408612728119,
0.4094817042350769,
0.3456614017486572,
-0.4797894060611725,
0.07845915108919144,
-0.14168471097946167,
-0.9821418523788452,
-0.3854660987854004,
-0.6324414014816284,
-0.46454188227653503,
0.00896537397056818,
-0.4781406819820404,
0.30718299746513367,
-0.6234590411186218,
0.04999430477619171,
0.24187186360359192,
0.21004384756088257,
-0.6483538150787354,
0.0077523039653897285,
0.23389242589473724,
0.9128836393356323,
-0.9545153379440308,
1.472851037979126,
0.9034779667854309,
-0.37375006079673767,
-1.353330135345459,
-0.15406085550785065,
0.29789724946022034,
-0.7369430661201477,
0.8629013299942017,
-0.09064512699842453,
0.09748799353837967,
0.10061981528997421,
-0.4285324513912201,
-0.577238917350769,
1.2963393926620483,
0.46824610233306885,
-0.7334837317466736,
0.016774047166109085,
-0.05412248149514198,
0.2447146326303482,
-0.7312769889831543,
0.05609013885259628,
0.9285317659378052,
0.28529804944992065,
0.5380879044532776,
-0.7531318068504333,
0.17113938927650452,
0.3810877799987793,
0.11751547455787659,
-0.04988662153482437,
-0.773045003414154,
1.062930941581726,
-0.6472241282463074,
-0.2189003974199295,
-0.04328158497810364,
0.5387784242630005,
0.5510950088500977,
0.2728586792945862,
0.5169413089752197,
0.5774300694465637,
1.0160163640975952,
-0.2641441822052002,
0.6243870258331299,
0.06415353715419769,
0.5842409133911133,
1.6223841905593872,
-0.23918570578098297,
0.7284431457519531,
0.9003536701202393,
-0.17140817642211914,
0.3577767014503479,
0.3866055905818939,
0.22259865701198578,
0.5730193853378296,
0.15457069873809814,
-0.4033445119857788,
-0.5715048909187317,
-0.027395065873861313,
-0.2796967923641205,
0.31175780296325684,
0.4503035247325897,
-0.18765917420387268,
-0.3489733636379242,
0.2845446467399597,
0.10466877371072769,
0.34226760268211365,
-0.4469102621078491,
0.7980514168739319,
0.5163090825080872,
-0.4263342618942261,
0.5176326632499695,
0.07592806220054626,
0.5945616364479065,
-0.3474010229110718,
0.08588489145040512,
-0.34011372923851013,
0.5053576231002808,
-0.140709787607193,
-0.577821671962738,
0.2604924738407135,
-0.0582711398601532,
-0.3779972195625305,
-0.34261396527290344,
1.0029997825622559,
-0.7880104184150696,
-0.4971149265766144,
0.15397481620311737,
0.8864759206771851,
0.032341860234737396,
0.22935867309570312,
-0.4286428987979889,
-0.01465504802763462,
0.1105000451207161,
0.02421298250555992,
0.46494895219802856,
0.8116071820259094,
0.18436191976070404,
0.5881889462471008,
0.40389856696128845,
0.19296741485595703,
0.22756099700927734,
0.014107073657214642,
0.9593736529350281,
-0.360174298286438,
-0.35834255814552307,
-0.9920632243156433,
0.24969878792762756,
-0.10010126233100891,
-0.0028095205780118704,
1.057813048362732,
0.4175313115119934,
1.0802916288375854,
-0.1894998550415039,
0.6878001689910889,
0.06516307592391968,
0.49555009603500366,
-0.6055619120597839,
0.6369888782501221,
-0.6435799598693848,
0.6283108592033386,
0.05122257396578789,
-0.888787031173706,
-0.05514907091856003,
0.6907752156257629,
-0.4167018532752991,
-0.17154757678508759,
0.9066043496131897,
0.42997366189956665,
-0.16426916420459747,
0.24415624141693115,
0.5128795504570007,
0.26637500524520874,
0.31954994797706604,
0.8702415823936462,
1.0710957050323486,
-0.2670980989933014,
0.6739033460617065,
-0.3768150210380554,
-0.21621006727218628,
-0.27200642228126526,
-0.8557698726654053,
-1.2218255996704102,
-0.2509440779685974,
-0.4195781648159027,
-0.13166476786136627,
-0.325552374124527,
0.9866189956665039,
0.9338213801383972,
-0.6650210618972778,
-0.14774709939956665,
0.042959701269865036,
0.7946346402168274,
0.04453621804714203,
-0.212850883603096,
0.12080579996109009,
-0.47322389483451843,
-0.8807278275489807,
0.4691309928894043,
0.010562094859778881,
0.16134147346019745,
-0.2357339709997177,
-0.343295156955719,
-0.1924196034669876,
0.1446264535188675,
0.6499537825584412,
0.009689169004559517,
-0.7289814949035645,
-0.4886896312236786,
-0.4918515086174011,
-0.2673318386077881,
-0.3346824049949646,
0.8644715547561646,
-0.7192581295967102,
0.25649988651275635,
0.37262850999832153,
0.5331194400787354,
0.5837578177452087,
-0.421707421541214,
0.1456712931394577,
-1.1512244939804077,
0.41905900835990906,
0.14982174336910248,
0.5734763741493225,
0.2250106781721115,
-0.011737722903490067,
0.49178552627563477,
0.39452046155929565,
-0.36324039101600647,
-0.9032095670700073,
0.19426999986171722,
-0.7189899682998657,
-0.726263165473938,
1.3462334871292114,
-0.32007938623428345,
-0.07024100422859192,
0.00709910411387682,
-0.1824016571044922,
0.007137874141335487,
-0.22921639680862427,
0.5589678287506104,
0.6775418519973755,
0.15541866421699524,
-0.29435595870018005,
-0.38489222526550293,
0.39378103613853455,
0.2898888885974884,
-0.7522395849227905,
-0.03282177075743675,
0.45960351824760437,
0.5773091912269592,
0.12639561295509338,
0.49283552169799805,
0.10882125794887543,
-0.012672563083469868,
0.2454206794500351,
-0.3461642563343048,
-0.1283934861421585,
-0.652899444103241,
-0.2392871379852295,
0.42924267053604126,
0.4426855742931366,
0.1299630105495453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04614v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04614v3 | Faithfulness vs. Plausibility: On the (Un)Reliability of Explanations from Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T06:32:50 | 2024-03-14T03:48:08 | Chirag Agarwal, Sree Harsha Tanneru, Himabindu Lakkaraju | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are deployed as powerful tools for several
natural language processing (NLP) applications. Recent works show that modern
LLMs can generate self-explanations (SEs), which elicit their intermediate
reasoning steps for explaining their behavior. Self-explanations have seen
widespread adoption owing to their conversational and plausible nature.
However, there is little to no understanding of their faithfulness. In this
work, we discuss the dichotomy between faithfulness and plausibility in SEs
generated by LLMs. We argue that while LLMs are adept at generating plausible
explanations -- seemingly logical and coherent to human users -- these
explanations do not necessarily align with the reasoning processes of the LLMs,
raising concerns about their faithfulness. We highlight that the current trend
towards increasing the plausibility of explanations, primarily driven by the
demand for user-friendly interfaces, may come at the cost of diminishing their
faithfulness. We assert that the faithfulness of explanations is critical in
LLMs employed for high-stakes decision-making. Moreover, we emphasize the need
for a systematic characterization of faithfulness-plausibility requirements of
different real-world applications and ensure explanations meet those needs.
While there are several approaches to improving plausibility, improving
faithfulness is an open challenge. We call upon the community to develop novel
methods to enhance the faithfulness of self explanations thereby enabling
transparent deployment of LLMs in diverse high-stakes settings. | [
-0.17660869657993317,
-0.8575057983398438,
1.2124673128128052,
0.3503161072731018,
-0.24617764353752136,
-0.2544940710067749,
-0.24337130784988403,
-0.2432113140821457,
-0.152213454246521,
0.41941091418266296,
-0.5601947903633118,
-0.1181059256196022,
-0.3070865869522095,
0.22252775728702545,
-0.3967137932777405,
0.9420457482337952,
-0.31430384516716003,
-0.07344240695238113,
-0.7489040493965149,
-0.0912666767835617,
-0.29684874415397644,
-0.41311365365982056,
-0.3638896346092224,
-0.6451948285102844,
0.6588232517242432,
0.242157444357872,
1.1681950092315674,
0.9106628894805908,
0.35264280438423157,
0.3304322361946106,
0.004349678289145231,
0.07065902650356293,
-0.502620279788971,
0.5054250955581665,
-0.4263225197792053,
-0.3625276982784271,
-0.3740387558937073,
-0.07587521523237228,
0.5426338315010071,
0.9055853486061096,
-0.11080189049243927,
0.037281304597854614,
0.38592755794525146,
0.6741460561752319,
-0.28742778301239014,
-0.1149444431066513,
-0.6982755064964294,
-0.08948823809623718,
-0.21880179643630981,
-0.19694362580776215,
-0.33520078659057617,
-0.24200867116451263,
0.1421629786491394,
-0.6271323561668396,
0.3533191382884979,
0.02365311235189438,
0.7474654912948608,
0.1657833755016327,
-0.10182829946279526,
-0.38507628440856934,
-0.9814119935035706,
0.8665913939476013,
-0.9036261439323425,
0.34777820110321045,
0.3177293837070465,
0.18785029649734497,
-0.6021372675895691,
-0.7608456015586853,
-0.440777987241745,
-0.45544880628585815,
0.14318417012691498,
0.06923752278089523,
-0.03191431239247322,
0.06353992968797684,
0.34146007895469666,
0.6612532734870911,
-0.549034595489502,
0.1194874718785286,
0.12835559248924255,
-0.42302972078323364,
0.6816645860671997,
0.11485454440116882,
0.0402236245572567,
0.039675962179899216,
-0.47349870204925537,
0.32501888275146484,
-0.8337197303771973,
-0.1982686072587967,
0.46155354380607605,
-0.041404735296964645,
0.037295863032341,
0.5160598158836365,
0.11229506134986877,
0.4544007182121277,
0.006598528474569321,
-0.19929088652133942,
-0.2234698086977005,
-0.46839669346809387,
-0.25919926166534424,
-0.20423591136932373,
0.7483402490615845,
0.14174075424671173,
0.42414402961730957,
-0.38665539026260376,
-0.30854499340057373,
0.013499530963599682,
0.25540730357170105,
-0.3739112317562103,
-0.09329177439212799,
0.6322460174560547,
-0.6808403134346008,
-0.07089890539646149,
-0.09750865399837494,
-0.6951859593391418,
-0.3610841631889343,
-0.41526302695274353,
0.3446511924266815,
-0.39222806692123413,
-0.2997095584869385,
0.12912124395370483,
0.183186337351799,
0.15490609407424927,
0.6212514638900757,
-0.7232798933982849,
0.020639987662434578,
0.9070022702217102,
0.6382957696914673,
-0.1547335535287857,
-0.619125485420227,
-0.28679323196411133,
0.2748366892337799,
-0.408363938331604,
0.6096543073654175,
-0.2646876573562622,
-0.29263222217559814,
0.05169430002570152,
-0.029468942433595657,
0.12103040516376495,
-0.4877931475639343,
0.7070623636245728,
-0.3390648365020752,
0.06503626704216003,
-0.5178077816963196,
-0.6532956957817078,
-0.07876773923635483,
0.07640999555587769,
-0.3466338515281677,
0.7434279918670654,
-0.24203777313232422,
-0.6253659725189209,
0.24330268800258636,
-0.4517691731452942,
-0.3684166669845581,
0.052617814391851425,
0.008710179477930069,
-0.3908289074897766,
0.4461665153503418,
-0.055733997374773026,
0.4685397446155548,
-0.15555551648139954,
0.49434229731559753,
-0.7842042446136475,
-0.43141183257102966,
0.8775991797447205,
-0.9595335125923157,
0.702256977558136,
0.3948829770088196,
-0.23282881081104279,
-0.3271661102771759,
-0.3403235971927643,
-0.17631766200065613,
0.3339815139770508,
-0.2933233976364136,
-0.10279934108257294,
0.3765808045864105,
-0.394258588552475,
0.016833167523145676,
0.5956057906150818,
-0.2707732915878296,
-0.07596839964389801,
-0.5519183874130249,
0.26286378502845764,
0.912946343421936,
-0.22780852019786835,
0.3966555893421173,
-0.4082549214363098,
0.31683576107025146,
-0.10992797464132309,
0.5723102688789368,
-0.32743537425994873,
-0.47412869334220886,
-0.4057703912258148,
-0.04903508350253105,
0.15764489769935608,
0.11135938763618469,
-0.49577462673187256,
0.07825182378292084,
-0.22402246296405792,
-0.20549076795578003,
-0.3735610544681549,
0.44202491641044617,
0.5364370942115784,
0.39183011651039124,
0.08944496512413025,
-0.05885479971766472,
-0.4377914071083069,
-0.9355425238609314,
-0.9056075215339661,
-0.4117199182510376,
-0.07799119502305984,
0.11752618104219437,
0.5400021076202393,
-0.13402311503887177,
1.0061943531036377,
0.06389272212982178,
0.14062844216823578,
-0.33776023983955383,
0.13169963657855988,
0.20105911791324615,
0.2103964388370514,
0.36999431252479553,
-0.7782490849494934,
-0.10899998247623444,
-0.3891717493534088,
-0.9819484949111938,
-0.05029304325580597,
-0.24904394149780273,
0.2248273342847824,
0.37485045194625854,
0.32536646723747253,
-0.5332630276679993,
0.27890220284461975,
0.7847477197647095,
-0.17972393333911896,
0.7652603983879089,
-0.5043375492095947,
-0.13606001436710358,
-0.788142740726471,
-0.14606040716171265,
0.08974743634462357,
-0.3787645101547241,
-0.5738078951835632,
0.2397177666425705,
-0.3699459731578827,
0.21642738580703735,
-0.2775036692619324,
0.415753573179245,
-0.48307645320892334,
-0.2609321177005768,
-0.35894688963890076,
0.29098016023635864,
0.23397581279277802,
0.08964826166629791,
-0.22966763377189636,
0.6270663142204285,
0.4414600729942322,
-0.611565113067627,
0.34528252482414246,
0.18618081510066986,
0.02194029837846756,
0.33873245120048523,
-0.7900529503822327,
0.03623197600245476,
-0.22134117782115936,
0.3016888499259949,
-1.0300847291946411,
-0.43732261657714844,
0.12703152000904083,
-0.5056906342506409,
-0.02854299172759056,
-0.25132864713668823,
-0.5940708518028259,
-0.3243044912815094,
-0.3064378798007965,
0.14935483038425446,
0.5291630625724792,
-0.6103826761245728,
0.6941759586334229,
-0.07835059612989426,
-0.047604937106370926,
-0.43399930000305176,
-0.839049220085144,
0.19163814187049866,
-0.24267062544822693,
-0.8077036142349243,
0.09639305621385574,
-0.27890661358833313,
-0.6510748863220215,
-0.061578381806612015,
-0.3810592293739319,
-0.18425317108631134,
0.4218182861804962,
0.4681563079357147,
0.23532480001449585,
-0.36030951142311096,
0.19239963591098785,
-0.21664650738239288,
-0.15893112123012543,
0.4297531545162201,
-0.08414223045110703,
0.25547710061073303,
-0.34533408284187317,
-0.7264490723609924,
-0.5580300688743591,
0.32632502913475037,
0.6604517698287964,
0.0032341533806174994,
0.952873170375824,
0.28216028213500977,
-0.1656235158443451,
-0.11970909684896469,
-0.7210343480110168,
-0.25236865878105164,
-0.4793998599052429,
-0.15851043164730072,
-0.5313997268676758,
-0.7317095994949341,
0.6600940227508545,
-0.27711260318756104,
0.33923545479774475,
0.6404082775115967,
0.4287150204181671,
-0.4703090786933899,
1.1194270849227905,
0.3634304106235504,
0.43644872307777405,
0.06967201828956604,
0.2618798315525055,
0.35814017057418823,
-0.5062311291694641,
-0.21175169944763184,
-0.6309137344360352,
0.15182417631149292,
-0.5961868762969971,
-0.15669065713882446,
0.12253406643867493,
0.19052577018737793,
-0.18235528469085693,
-0.12136431783437729,
-0.1756146252155304,
0.3467751443386078,
0.34108489751815796,
-0.014563310891389847,
0.580988883972168,
0.08976449072360992,
0.026308665052056313,
-0.26458272337913513,
-0.6486895680427551,
-0.9203232526779175,
0.8011372089385986,
0.8585309982299805,
0.9215184450149536,
0.1456172615289688,
0.6578139066696167,
0.09669381380081177,
0.243927463889122,
-0.5853530168533325,
0.539183497428894,
-0.11971446871757507,
-0.6929064989089966,
-0.44804224371910095,
-0.4537845551967621,
-0.9477803111076355,
0.10448035597801208,
-0.2325323224067688,
-0.5924996733665466,
0.03896848484873772,
0.5678449273109436,
-0.1906711906194687,
0.16437150537967682,
-0.5778172016143799,
0.8233602046966553,
-0.4606997072696686,
-0.6554301381111145,
-0.11962459981441498,
-0.5019429922103882,
0.5097817778587341,
-0.2300650179386139,
0.3436448574066162,
-0.0885416716337204,
0.08794410526752472,
0.46336856484413147,
-0.5666300058364868,
0.7604594230651855,
-0.0781947448849678,
-0.47687041759490967,
0.18119077384471893,
0.35110098123550415,
0.6930469274520874,
0.16237139701843262,
-0.2405649721622467,
0.2858181893825531,
0.03100547380745411,
-0.4046950340270996,
-0.7691478133201599,
0.7055733799934387,
-0.46206870675086975,
-0.8783129453659058,
-0.29469743371009827,
-0.5046735405921936,
-0.2078857123851776,
-0.06984921544790268,
0.13528715074062347,
0.45680251717567444,
-0.13428184390068054,
0.18537265062332153,
1.0610119104385376,
-0.34372755885124207,
0.28784966468811035,
0.4605123698711395,
-0.32784292101860046,
-0.19239568710327148,
0.8340926766395569,
0.048947419971227646,
0.4549904763698578,
-0.11601854115724564,
0.3786647617816925,
-0.5259310603141785,
-0.917293906211853,
-0.30876174569129944,
0.5487682223320007,
-0.7094351053237915,
0.27850982546806335,
-0.17624475061893463,
-0.10173854231834412,
-0.1286158561706543,
-0.29809078574180603,
-0.5311510562896729,
-0.10093728452920914,
-0.3785487115383148,
0.038447387516498566,
0.18820929527282715,
0.7980828881263733,
0.021156229078769684,
0.10157214850187302,
-0.7035576105117798,
0.641083300113678,
0.41034507751464844,
0.543731153011322,
0.03251306712627411,
-0.8554350733757019,
0.08458917587995529,
0.44286811351776123,
-0.11915062367916107,
-0.908510684967041,
-0.01135639101266861,
0.09999041259288788,
0.6884701251983643,
0.6073609590530396,
0.007506182417273521,
0.8614107966423035,
-0.3970862925052643,
0.8514127135276794,
0.17397886514663696,
-1.070058822631836,
0.46353304386138916,
-0.5030798316001892,
0.0579368993639946,
0.5509417057037354,
0.39479929208755493,
-0.2567580044269562,
-0.7197872996330261,
-0.7904523611068726,
-0.7728661298751831,
0.4607486128807068,
0.19898758828639984,
0.36654582619667053,
0.09636066108942032,
0.7344309687614441,
0.522713840007782,
-0.03474036604166031,
-0.8822323083877563,
-0.24341066181659698,
-0.2605398893356323,
-0.19715046882629395,
0.013160170055925846,
-0.5427370667457581,
-0.25043630599975586,
0.09351928532123566,
0.7898900508880615,
-0.21811479330062866,
0.18973387777805328,
0.4468528628349304,
-0.12952426075935364,
-0.20568729937076569,
0.29568350315093994,
0.5116609334945679,
1.2370558977127075,
0.07173115760087967,
0.407662570476532,
0.02770240604877472,
-0.13398407399654388,
-0.060332104563713074,
-0.1451602429151535,
-0.11157152056694031,
0.1904599815607071,
0.5683419108390808,
0.554542064666748,
0.09050332009792328,
-0.49907320737838745,
0.7152181267738342,
0.020601091906428337,
-0.4196860194206238,
-0.5439801216125488,
-0.13748332858085632,
0.3161097764968872,
0.18108969926834106,
0.34162622690200806,
-0.22487124800682068,
0.005010645370930433,
-0.8390404582023621,
-0.0690562054514885,
0.6300650238990784,
-0.10193800181150436,
-0.29651734232902527,
0.8346100449562073,
0.04324399307370186,
-0.33141326904296875,
0.49232834577560425,
-0.0533016212284565,
-0.2763823866844177,
0.3873833119869232,
0.5714365243911743,
0.8121035695075989,
-0.2369455248117447,
0.38481029868125916,
-0.09900914132595062,
0.32968446612358093,
-0.48391541838645935,
0.08999694883823395,
0.19846300780773163,
-0.6900755167007446,
-0.8259149193763733,
-0.6728749871253967,
-0.6388005018234253,
0.3099079430103302,
-0.3924412727355957,
-0.17280881106853485,
-0.28157535195350647,
0.09569936245679855,
0.0015594561118632555,
-0.3070206046104431,
-0.250379353761673,
0.05027968809008598,
0.11379574239253998,
0.9550615549087524,
-0.8443202972412109,
0.4317433536052704,
0.4791529178619385,
-0.3154900372028351,
-0.7650681138038635,
0.3520648181438446,
-0.18987777829170227,
-0.7005434632301331,
0.2438477724790573,
-0.05675700306892395,
-0.0946056991815567,
-0.41667377948760986,
-0.808240532875061,
-0.6562179327011108,
0.8960987329483032,
0.9446218609809875,
-0.5575997829437256,
0.0980081558227539,
0.33704251050949097,
0.6640321016311646,
0.035797227174043655,
0.09945186227560043,
0.27957069873809814,
0.7999032735824585,
0.15028992295265198,
-0.8163111209869385,
0.19992868602275848,
0.38661447167396545,
0.1697138249874115,
-0.18557387590408325,
-0.5297890305519104,
0.48511070013046265,
-0.21425890922546387,
-0.10060194879770279,
0.25901463627815247,
0.8209245800971985,
0.4097573459148407,
0.5792906284332275,
0.5303013324737549,
0.3265237510204315,
0.5903904438018799,
-0.3251964747905731,
1.2270656824111938,
-0.008524782955646515,
0.35691478848457336,
0.8578495979309082,
-0.2937346398830414,
0.6182780265808105,
0.7590211629867554,
-0.25408968329429626,
0.651419460773468,
0.6180890798568726,
-0.00714927539229393,
-0.0017233898397535086,
0.003596916561946273,
-0.23235198855400085,
-0.700873851776123,
-0.0614214651286602,
-0.07945744693279266,
0.42629826068878174,
0.08824219554662704,
-0.5517824292182922,
-0.2814989984035492,
-0.12829211354255676,
0.07497859746217728,
0.2711811065673828,
-0.3634331524372101,
0.6652992367744446,
0.3258969783782959,
-0.8584425449371338,
0.571945309638977,
-0.10501202195882797,
0.21812275052070618,
-0.5049433708190918,
-0.03092561848461628,
-0.3019242286682129,
0.10776408761739731,
-0.4701078534126282,
-0.9837796688079834,
0.4343186020851135,
-0.05652618408203125,
-0.21930386126041412,
-0.6620783805847168,
0.9045684337615967,
-0.1724589318037033,
-0.11468616873025894,
0.20393136143684387,
0.7273826003074646,
0.57156902551651,
-0.1581767499446869,
-0.8352698683738708,
0.20480194687843323,
-0.14797155559062958,
-0.43812480568885803,
0.26739758253097534,
0.5636096596717834,
0.10226504504680634,
0.9396100640296936,
0.6036808490753174,
0.034085873514413834,
-0.05705207586288452,
-0.029300084337592125,
0.5562602877616882,
-0.30532580614089966,
-0.018694764003157616,
-1.1727333068847656,
0.47536754608154297,
0.1487145572900772,
0.06010428071022034,
0.990019679069519,
0.4787389636039734,
0.3772396147251129,
-0.032461345195770264,
0.8234034180641174,
0.2990661859512329,
0.41930097341537476,
-0.6281449198722839,
0.3058219850063324,
-0.6037052869796753,
0.5620833039283752,
-0.0333792045712471,
-1.0346380472183228,
-0.05205822363495827,
0.4474869966506958,
-0.2487984001636505,
0.23915109038352966,
0.7795344591140747,
0.5979620814323425,
-0.20179904997348785,
0.21716934442520142,
0.36173269152641296,
0.5789708495140076,
-0.08332163095474243,
0.23605459928512573,
1.1017059087753296,
-0.04441208392381668,
0.6600205302238464,
0.03713614493608475,
-0.04512450471520424,
-0.22234128415584564,
-1.1772533655166626,
-0.6162306666374207,
-0.3296082317829132,
-0.44698774814605713,
-0.4807254672050476,
0.2564684748649597,
0.4192277789115906,
0.2672511339187622,
-0.6134329438209534,
-0.010214951820671558,
-0.5349941253662109,
0.4627646207809448,
-0.2048308253288269,
-0.2364102154970169,
0.10979076474905014,
-0.34391647577285767,
-0.4347984194755554,
0.4071598947048187,
0.3650173246860504,
0.13060304522514343,
-0.6721559166908264,
-0.23275256156921387,
0.2293032556772232,
0.30741119384765625,
0.34081771969795227,
0.40669670701026917,
-1.163297176361084,
-0.3939562737941742,
-0.1379532366991043,
0.10743039846420288,
0.0990644320845604,
0.641632616519928,
-0.5918805003166199,
0.2911190986633301,
0.4105817973613739,
0.5745735168457031,
0.0911497175693512,
0.12254197150468826,
0.7992547154426575,
-0.34391364455223083,
-0.5205464959144592,
0.07009776681661606,
0.5164907574653625,
0.5161415934562683,
-0.22704890370368958,
0.2661631405353546,
0.24500086903572083,
-0.7852261662483215,
-0.9262630939483643,
0.4180862009525299,
-0.8574498891830444,
-0.4782400131225586,
1.3610470294952393,
-0.49026355147361755,
-0.2737352252006531,
-0.5082789659500122,
0.045973677188158035,
0.11201629042625427,
-0.07673101127147675,
0.7572702169418335,
0.7524946331977844,
-0.1656886488199234,
-0.046979982405900955,
-0.6885777711868286,
0.3460451662540436,
0.5699881911277771,
-0.6486008763313293,
0.530066967010498,
0.39291512966156006,
0.4990357458591461,
0.12140418589115143,
0.4550055265426636,
-0.19643504917621613,
0.289338082075119,
-0.1308099329471588,
-0.20591357350349426,
-0.0772511437535286,
-0.26731422543525696,
-0.5990371108055115,
0.1437414288520813,
0.5283252000808716,
0.1500057429075241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04609v1 | Improving Cross-Domain Low-Resource Text Generation through LLM Post-Editing: A Programmer-Interpreter Approach | 2024-02-07T06:13:14 | 2024-02-07T06:13:14 | Zhuang Li, Levon Haroutunian, Raj Tumuluri, Philip Cohen, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Post-editing has proven effective in improving the quality of text generated
by large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5 or GPT-4, particularly when
direct updating of their parameters to enhance text quality is infeasible or
expensive. However, relying solely on smaller language models for post-editing
can limit the LLMs' ability to generalize across domains. Moreover, the editing
strategies in these methods are not optimally designed for text-generation
tasks. To address these limitations, we propose a neural programmer-interpreter
approach that preserves the domain generalization ability of LLMs when editing
their output. The editing actions in this framework are specifically devised
for text generation. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the
programmer-interpreter significantly enhances GPT-3.5's performance in logical
form-to-text conversion and low-resource machine translation, surpassing other
state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLM post-editing methods in cross-domain settings. | [
-0.18029312789440155,
-0.7469732165336609,
0.8169761300086975,
0.18312333524227142,
-0.2880098521709442,
0.07391447573900223,
-0.5980831980705261,
-0.3891703486442566,
0.08971719443798065,
0.4544149339199066,
-0.4516720473766327,
-0.5461403131484985,
-0.73531574010849,
0.30767160654067993,
-0.18458829820156097,
1.1998426914215088,
-0.20908017456531525,
0.015472585335373878,
-0.3355993330478668,
0.06536821275949478,
-0.4339729845523834,
-0.722165584564209,
-0.7186782956123352,
-0.21193870902061462,
0.4851547181606293,
0.07927937805652618,
0.8742400407791138,
0.4925389587879181,
0.3187602460384369,
0.292702853679657,
-0.05134081840515137,
0.39107292890548706,
-0.45064786076545715,
0.06484060734510422,
-0.46028831601142883,
-0.2575641870498657,
-0.8931871652603149,
-0.20987935364246368,
0.616969645023346,
0.677406907081604,
0.11748751252889633,
-0.0022646859288215637,
0.060369107872247696,
0.5160051584243774,
-0.535696268081665,
-0.008300223387777805,
-0.8127533793449402,
-0.10464487969875336,
-0.17641988396644592,
-0.4637162983417511,
-0.39484861493110657,
-0.4017791152000427,
-0.08388976752758026,
-0.6386820077896118,
0.33750268816947937,
-0.3113803267478943,
0.6798149347305298,
0.3126448690891266,
-0.08648760616779327,
-0.03827990964055061,
-0.7494720816612244,
0.6955219507217407,
-0.8126513361930847,
0.21641649305820465,
0.3542875647544861,
-0.22553683817386627,
-0.049785543233156204,
-0.831983208656311,
-0.6560350060462952,
0.0534016489982605,
0.029576420783996582,
0.17173020541667938,
-0.2625127136707306,
0.15982425212860107,
0.3377137780189514,
0.19878211617469788,
-0.5498935580253601,
-0.008510981686413288,
-0.23258407413959503,
-0.16012415289878845,
0.5516147017478943,
0.1611148566007614,
0.49737119674682617,
-0.07067029923200607,
0.03857923671603203,
0.3288881182670593,
-1.1699657440185547,
-0.31603196263313293,
0.4183715283870697,
0.1327487975358963,
0.30888447165489197,
0.6011566519737244,
-0.19250471889972687,
0.6588947176933289,
0.06619023531675339,
0.14418859779834747,
-0.0781269446015358,
-0.592501163482666,
-0.42158088088035583,
-0.12522989511489868,
0.8021166920661926,
0.5376709699630737,
0.13964203000068665,
-0.143228217959404,
-0.42234179377555847,
0.19717642664909363,
0.2866232991218567,
-1.0033293962478638,
-0.19533921778202057,
-0.10718139261007309,
-0.6792474389076233,
-0.3463139533996582,
-0.3885209262371063,
-0.36887603998184204,
-0.19901405274868011,
-0.33431941270828247,
0.310188353061676,
-0.521335780620575,
-0.0846034437417984,
0.018154427409172058,
0.04924217611551285,
-0.15797635912895203,
0.5470633506774902,
-1.1645432710647583,
0.34989219903945923,
0.3970869481563568,
0.7250475287437439,
-0.16057322919368744,
-0.3056185245513916,
-0.5809684991836548,
0.27330878376960754,
-0.2989620864391327,
0.7955471873283386,
-0.5531571507453918,
-0.3963680565357208,
-0.03350306302309036,
-0.4671946167945862,
-0.01602318324148655,
-0.5634759664535522,
0.1666712462902069,
-0.8746723532676697,
0.31481653451919556,
0.060900624841451645,
-0.49240583181381226,
0.22626014053821564,
0.047800879925489426,
-0.38370198011398315,
0.969851553440094,
0.41797158122062683,
-0.5044246315956116,
0.3505454659461975,
-0.6992577910423279,
-0.682801365852356,
-0.14017029106616974,
-0.21600164473056793,
-0.32873621582984924,
0.38051745295524597,
0.5240407586097717,
0.30722522735595703,
-0.46854832768440247,
0.2456270456314087,
0.13115066289901733,
-0.42353612184524536,
0.17359109222888947,
-0.48434776067733765,
0.38516712188720703,
0.09735613316297531,
-0.07483962923288345,
0.26962533593177795,
-0.6704089045524597,
0.22732104361057281,
-0.012973389588296413,
-0.6393319964408875,
-0.1770598441362381,
-0.11678574234247208,
0.05177388712763786,
0.35036903619766235,
0.3939513564109802,
-0.41369888186454773,
0.46410301327705383,
-0.502364993095398,
0.5451050400733948,
0.6910874247550964,
0.15614080429077148,
0.6066622734069824,
-0.24559004604816437,
0.6091105341911316,
-0.10014783591032028,
0.016647398471832275,
0.057040341198444366,
-0.4990653991699219,
-0.7286742329597473,
-0.03349420055747032,
0.493795245885849,
0.5046619176864624,
-1.1889848709106445,
0.17065811157226562,
-0.2412012368440628,
-0.3729158937931061,
-0.43943071365356445,
0.3712822496891022,
0.48082685470581055,
0.279776006937027,
0.582843005657196,
-0.3445751667022705,
-0.48852890729904175,
-0.7386049032211304,
-0.6148533821105957,
-0.0316147543489933,
-0.262702614068985,
0.2658223807811737,
0.1482020616531372,
-0.49880701303482056,
0.8428859710693359,
-0.5783867835998535,
0.0651635006070137,
-0.42422088980674744,
0.07224640995264053,
0.2450525462627411,
0.613681435585022,
0.5186191201210022,
-0.40021440386772156,
-0.7271763682365417,
0.11514024436473846,
-0.6407590508460999,
-0.4247710108757019,
-0.32860708236694336,
-0.37062129378318787,
0.43628576397895813,
0.40310898423194885,
-0.9594341516494751,
0.5368122458457947,
0.6469390988349915,
-0.2544359862804413,
0.5458269119262695,
-0.3916289806365967,
0.21511980891227722,
-1.0066848993301392,
-0.08902504295110703,
-0.19284012913703918,
-0.3178413510322571,
-0.7139145731925964,
-0.184564009308815,
0.08788111060857773,
-0.35457900166511536,
-0.47843608260154724,
0.42288821935653687,
-0.39362815022468567,
-0.09083525836467743,
-0.5045161843299866,
0.2990756332874298,
0.11740096658468246,
0.5016540884971619,
0.11797796934843063,
1.0661041736602783,
0.4262290596961975,
-0.4626930058002472,
0.1761876791715622,
0.41223424673080444,
-0.17478002607822418,
0.5255009531974792,
-0.5427206754684448,
0.33063700795173645,
0.05995491147041321,
0.24360087513923645,
-0.3712705671787262,
-0.015536554157733917,
0.16660484671592712,
-0.46271586418151855,
0.2856209874153137,
-0.14190098643302917,
-0.46846532821655273,
0.23080946505069733,
-0.21500732004642487,
0.44460925459861755,
0.5482797622680664,
-0.5027164220809937,
0.5290626883506775,
-0.01181088201701641,
-0.7118249535560608,
-0.28502586483955383,
-0.7649520635604858,
0.44046515226364136,
0.3128565847873688,
-0.839844286441803,
0.8185902833938599,
-0.08067130297422409,
-0.17283415794372559,
0.0856550857424736,
-0.10552828013896942,
-0.14689671993255615,
-0.12720581889152527,
-0.2860824763774872,
0.45579102635383606,
-0.32479315996170044,
-0.17451761662960052,
0.5162817239761353,
-0.25643861293792725,
-0.056724172085523605,
-0.48195987939834595,
0.4525086581707001,
0.2640802562236786,
-0.04404721409082413,
-0.47185951471328735,
0.49748703837394714,
0.2027665674686432,
-0.25761252641677856,
0.5329508185386658,
0.2714538276195526,
-0.3519057631492615,
-0.44242939352989197,
-0.1352507323026657,
-0.02707880362868309,
-0.4640924036502838,
0.40314045548439026,
-0.43393346667289734,
-0.899743914604187,
0.07454349845647812,
-0.31572532653808594,
-0.10271375626325607,
0.5333107113838196,
0.6639670133590698,
0.07971406728029251,
0.9419927597045898,
0.7064176797866821,
0.27195724844932556,
0.6334486603736877,
-0.22469106316566467,
0.2624157965183258,
-0.9424510598182678,
0.34728914499282837,
-0.2800235152244568,
-0.1945497691631317,
-0.5220481157302856,
-0.5700580477714539,
0.1554914265871048,
0.18497887253761292,
-0.05544930323958397,
0.42318081855773926,
-0.40864309668540955,
0.5721811652183533,
0.5848138928413391,
0.13782379031181335,
0.38080763816833496,
0.07504431903362274,
0.0879087969660759,
-0.17693106830120087,
-0.8389902114868164,
-0.7537841796875,
1.1562341451644897,
-0.011268948204815388,
0.604434072971344,
0.19835393130779266,
0.7064525485038757,
0.24068236351013184,
0.6476748585700989,
-0.44140735268592834,
0.601790726184845,
-0.38137128949165344,
-0.3335128426551819,
-0.20552442967891693,
-0.6656255125999451,
-0.6280065178871155,
0.25599780678749084,
-0.20873168110847473,
-0.5979108214378357,
-0.022817039862275124,
0.35757800936698914,
-0.3422335982322693,
0.32187527418136597,
-0.6602568030357361,
0.9964889287948608,
-0.14068689942359924,
-0.47286027669906616,
-0.44271889328956604,
-0.33365964889526367,
0.18424569070339203,
-0.36937859654426575,
-0.16320835053920746,
0.2088538408279419,
-0.31188371777534485,
0.4350319802761078,
-0.7042955756187439,
0.7139118909835815,
-0.22238430380821228,
-0.1504053920507431,
0.36465319991111755,
0.25221019983291626,
0.6886919140815735,
0.2274646759033203,
-0.28321507573127747,
0.23914046585559845,
-0.37794533371925354,
-0.2876231074333191,
-0.810462474822998,
0.7956218719482422,
-0.8336286544799805,
-0.6416787505149841,
-0.19473795592784882,
-0.5448940396308899,
-0.4431339204311371,
0.3043132424354553,
0.47658804059028625,
0.38518112897872925,
-0.24679133296012878,
-0.11363811045885086,
0.3950110971927643,
-0.6110388040542603,
0.3887929320335388,
0.18044103682041168,
-0.13236674666404724,
-0.690523087978363,
1.018363356590271,
0.007590417750179768,
0.559482216835022,
0.3091086447238922,
-0.03844217583537102,
-0.13040469586849213,
-0.939826488494873,
-0.7370728254318237,
0.03576245531439781,
-0.7105175256729126,
-0.2998684048652649,
-0.6082080006599426,
-0.28527355194091797,
-0.4707016050815582,
-0.4715140461921692,
-0.17665919661521912,
-0.7295696139335632,
-0.3989165127277374,
0.07388033717870712,
0.23958592116832733,
0.8145989775657654,
-0.05730334296822548,
0.6684766411781311,
-0.9365703463554382,
0.5421460270881653,
0.11170439422130585,
0.3818373382091522,
-0.2640713155269623,
-0.42901626229286194,
-0.40509673953056335,
-0.10416613519191742,
-0.4951017200946808,
-0.5687131881713867,
0.4138133227825165,
0.2826685607433319,
0.16975300014019012,
-0.16941873729228973,
-0.2502366900444031,
0.5614908933639526,
-0.7336330413818359,
0.9173895120620728,
0.24815146625041962,
-1.3620256185531616,
0.6865720748901367,
-0.4110262989997864,
0.37999802827835083,
0.36515215039253235,
-0.051347892731428146,
-0.6475334167480469,
-0.5907188057899475,
-0.5551943778991699,
-0.7450732588768005,
0.8507776260375977,
0.5097915530204773,
0.3183930218219757,
-0.015999360010027885,
0.37419676780700684,
0.13594581186771393,
0.4043678939342499,
-0.6626551747322083,
-0.017851831391453743,
-0.4725697338581085,
-0.28576162457466125,
0.12542316317558289,
-0.18633313477039337,
0.1254798322916031,
-0.09064049273729324,
0.8291082978248596,
-0.17191699147224426,
0.2664465010166168,
0.2488025426864624,
-0.2903450131416321,
-0.16903619468212128,
0.33528438210487366,
0.7556445002555847,
0.8775252103805542,
0.02637125737965107,
0.08538307249546051,
0.4045547842979431,
-0.5601345896720886,
0.12515084445476532,
0.062476735562086105,
-0.48755380511283875,
-0.024858903139829636,
0.4774799644947052,
0.7125334739685059,
-0.0623292401432991,
-0.37165573239326477,
0.5238329172134399,
-0.2206229716539383,
-0.24051353335380554,
0.17829672992229462,
0.27683430910110474,
0.010402649641036987,
0.1405945122241974,
-0.021015482023358345,
0.7062092423439026,
-0.17962346971035004,
-0.34391239285469055,
0.033699460327625275,
0.0806363970041275,
0.07435320317745209,
-0.4203619062900543,
0.9353068470954895,
0.47329577803611755,
-0.39500126242637634,
0.602241575717926,
-0.09029435366392136,
-0.36276859045028687,
0.30233320593833923,
0.7249945402145386,
1.0137808322906494,
-0.011381159536540508,
-0.036779072135686874,
0.0921698659658432,
0.20962312817573547,
0.18263772130012512,
0.4929947257041931,
0.07357124984264374,
-0.7436484694480896,
-0.8543518781661987,
-0.4898656904697418,
-0.4822327196598053,
0.06611773371696472,
-0.15681710839271545,
0.13435444235801697,
-0.773899257183075,
-0.2851119637489319,
-0.1286247968673706,
-0.23236963152885437,
-0.5928163528442383,
0.3142677843570709,
-0.008639377541840076,
0.7566078901290894,
-0.3758537471294403,
1.0546436309814453,
0.6608712077140808,
-0.5022146701812744,
-0.46140432357788086,
0.25731316208839417,
-0.2201996147632599,
-0.5504090785980225,
0.7184694409370422,
-0.09950357675552368,
-0.19208462536334991,
0.09118913114070892,
-0.2966783344745636,
-0.7213726043701172,
0.9554881453514099,
0.5689483880996704,
-0.5570233464241028,
0.0025671045295894146,
0.34505900740623474,
0.7111154794692993,
-0.2076636403799057,
0.03198380395770073,
0.47427302598953247,
0.40875744819641113,
-0.48484864830970764,
-0.7746643424034119,
0.21458372473716736,
-0.3033609688282013,
0.44382283091545105,
0.23829272389411926,
-0.4783998131752014,
0.7018428444862366,
-0.06923985481262207,
-0.13830803334712982,
0.2294202595949173,
0.8181533813476562,
0.10525908321142197,
-0.1108478531241417,
0.2856154143810272,
0.4117445945739746,
0.6588716506958008,
0.051012881100177765,
1.0084233283996582,
-0.6148132681846619,
0.1767812818288803,
1.0593507289886475,
-0.3969261944293976,
0.6965718269348145,
0.5833271145820618,
-0.062389474362134933,
0.35456427931785583,
0.38193508982658386,
0.1703355461359024,
0.4699430465698242,
0.24604220688343048,
-0.6093760132789612,
-0.21131043136119843,
0.020880738273262978,
-0.26149749755859375,
0.20791999995708466,
0.15920467674732208,
-0.5667572617530823,
0.09221746027469635,
-0.2061876356601715,
0.13236317038536072,
0.28548499941825867,
-0.26825013756752014,
0.719860851764679,
0.10878610610961914,
-0.6949347257614136,
0.5147292613983154,
0.3640575706958771,
0.6644577383995056,
-0.41184109449386597,
-0.09431267529726028,
-0.30122607946395874,
0.20305362343788147,
-0.2924201190471649,
-0.7043765187263489,
0.6033361554145813,
0.5024390816688538,
-0.48879075050354004,
-0.72690349817276,
0.9966601133346558,
-0.4500114619731903,
-0.36075925827026367,
0.2942372262477875,
0.6470497250556946,
-0.09363027662038803,
-0.18999017775058746,
-0.5422913432121277,
0.19944418966770172,
-0.04798039421439171,
-0.46671271324157715,
0.3965660631656647,
0.534456729888916,
0.1227356567978859,
0.03412771224975586,
0.7921077013015747,
0.5030179023742676,
-0.14840520918369293,
0.24036240577697754,
0.921845018863678,
-0.7589877247810364,
-0.2796376645565033,
-0.9353809356689453,
0.3892092704772949,
-0.08617852628231049,
-0.47961995005607605,
0.39911481738090515,
0.5708863139152527,
1.0799745321273804,
-0.266255646944046,
1.2179781198501587,
-0.2053406536579132,
0.0807560607790947,
-0.775957465171814,
0.7676190733909607,
-0.3977263271808624,
0.2487531155347824,
-0.3384453356266022,
-1.1512290239334106,
-0.5866295099258423,
0.5513920783996582,
-0.4352874755859375,
-0.005315476097166538,
0.8704067468643188,
0.8746167421340942,
-0.07083700597286224,
-0.20616567134857178,
0.4537489414215088,
0.1912906914949417,
0.4610207676887512,
0.7021333575248718,
0.9685360789299011,
-0.5389939546585083,
0.7205427885055542,
-0.057928819209337234,
-0.1384778916835785,
0.16101016104221344,
-0.8473058342933655,
-0.856317937374115,
-0.04320339113473892,
-0.2232339084148407,
-0.3961428105831146,
0.10483770817518234,
0.9106889963150024,
0.5052965879440308,
-0.49291250109672546,
-0.07981526851654053,
-0.1973225176334381,
-0.08256851881742477,
-0.21946176886558533,
-0.14933361113071442,
0.39540621638298035,
-0.42202314734458923,
-0.8125081658363342,
0.6274107098579407,
0.4899064004421234,
-0.15878556668758392,
0.017180737107992172,
-0.26749590039253235,
0.1204451397061348,
0.27100861072540283,
0.939293384552002,
-0.030654828995466232,
-0.4870052635669708,
-0.37973353266716003,
-0.15514007210731506,
-0.28164148330688477,
0.16785015165805817,
0.883143424987793,
-0.45745405554771423,
0.1283564269542694,
0.5774297714233398,
0.9236522912979126,
0.4105094075202942,
-0.08448175340890884,
0.9087100625038147,
-0.9132777452468872,
-0.08295968919992447,
0.24136917293071747,
0.4353746771812439,
0.38964033126831055,
-0.44707635045051575,
0.3991665840148926,
0.47199925780296326,
-0.6939943432807922,
-0.37921613454818726,
0.2513168156147003,
-0.6568967700004578,
-0.2806646525859833,
1.0790174007415771,
-0.04295215383172035,
-0.13181981444358826,
0.17331600189208984,
-0.5337311625480652,
0.4208305776119232,
-0.2586137652397156,
0.6113213300704956,
0.6015700697898865,
-0.41993674635887146,
-0.01261021476238966,
-0.4797061085700989,
0.7111104130744934,
0.5397660136222839,
-1.1883453130722046,
0.3339274823665619,
0.6702214479446411,
0.20583012700080872,
-0.10532321035861969,
0.9918288588523865,
-0.07673392444849014,
0.4709675908088684,
-0.000034831464290618896,
0.18654297292232513,
-0.0060127791948616505,
-0.24440060555934906,
-0.16131356358528137,
-0.1682203859090805,
0.17676080763339996,
0.25833508372306824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04601v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04601v2 | Alirector: Alignment-Enhanced Chinese Grammatical Error Corrector | 2024-02-07T05:56:54 | 2024-06-02T15:50:40 | Haihui Yang, Xiaojun Quan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chinese grammatical error correction (CGEC) faces serious overcorrection
challenges when employing autoregressive generative models such as
sequence-to-sequence (Seq2Seq) models and decoder-only large language models
(LLMs). While previous methods aim to address overcorrection in Seq2Seq models,
they are difficult to adapt to decoder-only LLMs. In this paper, we propose an
alignment-enhanced corrector for the overcorrection problem that applies to
both Seq2Seq models and decoder-only LLMs. Our method first trains a correction
model to generate an initial correction of the source sentence. Then, we
combine the source sentence with the initial correction and feed it through an
alignment model for another round of correction, aiming to enforce the
alignment model to focus on potential overcorrection. Moreover, to enhance the
model's ability to identify nuances, we further explore the reverse alignment
of the source sentence and the initial correction. Finally, we transfer the
alignment knowledge from two alignment models to the correction model,
instructing it on how to avoid overcorrection. Experimental results on three
CGEC datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in alleviating
overcorrection and improving overall performance. Our code has been made
publicly available. | [
0.31173497438430786,
-0.5347014665603638,
0.3726023733615875,
0.21202953159809113,
-0.20622405409812927,
0.06614071130752563,
-0.13677100837230682,
-0.3794776201248169,
-0.0012461657170206308,
0.48773714900016785,
-0.328565776348114,
-0.35564789175987244,
-0.40066608786582947,
-0.07084330916404724,
-0.5076387524604797,
0.7136834263801575,
0.028548605740070343,
0.34273070096969604,
-0.08020759373903275,
-0.09803517162799835,
-0.3342127501964569,
-0.5165413618087769,
-0.6686855554580688,
-0.029663292691111565,
0.4179232120513916,
0.5645047426223755,
0.7811614871025085,
0.7351058125495911,
0.43324014544487,
0.2855693995952606,
-0.07913167029619217,
0.5712913870811462,
-0.3273872137069702,
-0.09882492572069168,
-0.19853587448596954,
-0.34289833903312683,
-0.750477135181427,
-0.44436076283454895,
0.8808059692382812,
0.34342312812805176,
-0.5753107070922852,
-0.08720937371253967,
0.24783867597579956,
0.7605046033859253,
-1.0627377033233643,
0.1224609911441803,
-0.5915981531143188,
-0.014995342120528221,
-0.2700515389442444,
-0.11301547288894653,
-0.38734668493270874,
-0.5873194336891174,
-0.49305346608161926,
-0.6814775466918945,
0.1777900904417038,
-0.0271551925688982,
0.911761462688446,
0.2793661653995514,
-0.3825042247772217,
0.007247508503496647,
-0.6226574182510376,
0.4246116578578949,
-0.9551467895507812,
0.3729921281337738,
0.06790508329868317,
0.3521904945373535,
-0.08672429621219635,
-0.5389160513877869,
-0.7756754159927368,
-0.04427432268857956,
-0.18430551886558533,
0.5685938000679016,
-0.053846247494220734,
0.33349913358688354,
0.4573158621788025,
0.4980183243751526,
-0.7450250387191772,
0.15132951736450195,
-0.19044315814971924,
-0.1535114198923111,
0.5420796871185303,
0.19832690060138702,
0.45030951499938965,
0.03750736266374588,
-0.15282605588436127,
-0.045334093272686005,
-0.7944866418838501,
-0.010370439849793911,
0.12011601775884628,
0.27949151396751404,
0.14222735166549683,
0.6345980167388916,
-0.140194833278656,
0.7757272720336914,
0.6636098623275757,
0.19756287336349487,
0.33807849884033203,
-0.1436341106891632,
-0.41293764114379883,
0.515899658203125,
0.40571361780166626,
0.3670278489589691,
-0.21520277857780457,
0.04656153544783592,
-0.3194374144077301,
0.015956779941916466,
0.1873466521501541,
-0.7398616671562195,
-0.25920161604881287,
0.16179358959197998,
-0.11938592046499252,
-0.0069633242674171925,
0.4024694263935089,
-0.5934857726097107,
-0.522529125213623,
-0.2695021331310272,
0.41813552379608154,
-0.08530212938785553,
-0.027615927159786224,
0.122499018907547,
0.11754771322011948,
0.43566977977752686,
0.3009944260120392,
-1.001990795135498,
0.1326403170824051,
0.7777808904647827,
0.9475609064102173,
0.037525344640016556,
-0.3104337751865387,
-0.8954534530639648,
0.3985634744167328,
-0.3513842821121216,
0.622632622718811,
-0.10901903361082077,
-0.22260670363903046,
0.29780828952789307,
0.32598617672920227,
-0.38974836468696594,
-0.3168739974498749,
0.7637439370155334,
-0.4923775792121887,
0.20812563598155975,
-0.3366413712501526,
-0.7344304919242859,
-0.1152106374502182,
0.26567280292510986,
-0.7742307186126709,
1.072157382965088,
0.162364199757576,
-0.6774777770042419,
0.14274272322654724,
-0.47795945405960083,
-0.4941180348396301,
0.1704690307378769,
-0.22284983098506927,
-0.4975137710571289,
0.0000877463462529704,
0.5172892212867737,
0.1777399778366089,
-0.14745065569877625,
0.4147375822067261,
0.050357941538095474,
-0.4928167760372162,
-0.03197656199336052,
-0.28170448541641235,
1.0441792011260986,
0.17982663214206696,
-0.24969132244586945,
0.24681206047534943,
-0.9285492300987244,
0.13904458284378052,
0.026697276160120964,
-0.3756359815597534,
-0.2968651056289673,
0.039181798696517944,
-0.14936845004558563,
0.20846834778785706,
0.3014744520187378,
-0.6434420943260193,
0.2507309019565582,
-0.553830623626709,
0.1094910055398941,
0.5262828469276428,
-0.2979961335659027,
0.5208792090415955,
-0.3193424344062805,
0.48150548338890076,
-0.17428632080554962,
0.1751433163881302,
-0.09111090749502182,
0.008391107432544231,
-1.1043001413345337,
-0.1216549351811409,
0.2589893341064453,
0.9547191262245178,
-0.7956516146659851,
0.8495969176292419,
-0.19046863913536072,
-0.4796835780143738,
-0.7644287347793579,
0.09058230370283127,
0.5892670154571533,
0.5088179707527161,
0.49035027623176575,
-0.229031503200531,
-0.5950619578361511,
-0.35374706983566284,
-0.24109213054180145,
-0.3893859088420868,
0.030641542747616768,
0.08029805123806,
-0.07457137852907181,
-0.15973995625972748,
0.5987569093704224,
-0.5467624664306641,
-0.33783233165740967,
-0.17239366471767426,
0.07431494444608688,
0.015051404945552349,
0.6924328207969666,
0.5013809204101562,
-0.4015450179576874,
-0.3264360725879669,
0.23666290938854218,
-0.403237521648407,
-0.5791459083557129,
-0.4690212607383728,
-0.45889824628829956,
0.4740561246871948,
0.7214130163192749,
-0.5728365778923035,
0.1489402949810028,
0.6308581233024597,
-0.36851969361305237,
0.38587486743927,
-0.30035901069641113,
0.3565081059932709,
-1.0056607723236084,
0.21749959886074066,
-0.20074023306369781,
-0.2607947587966919,
-0.6086923480033875,
0.2555863857269287,
0.6506364941596985,
0.3000057637691498,
-0.20283229649066925,
0.152124285697937,
-0.5359055995941162,
-0.030415834859013557,
-0.3217241168022156,
0.2716776430606842,
0.28325241804122925,
0.3215232491493225,
0.16909737884998322,
0.5448189377784729,
0.1053784191608429,
-0.2667071521282196,
0.5310248732566833,
0.4435405731201172,
-0.22745469212532043,
0.36729592084884644,
-0.5583654642105103,
0.20893028378486633,
-0.2569436728954315,
0.11458882689476013,
-1.1580791473388672,
-0.19284862279891968,
0.5829679369926453,
-0.5794178247451782,
0.5572666525840759,
-0.017887046560645103,
-0.19657838344573975,
-0.2759999930858612,
-0.3415083885192871,
0.5125911831855774,
0.26065465807914734,
-0.9930080771446228,
0.8093798160552979,
-0.07542451471090317,
-0.27627766132354736,
-0.8483296632766724,
-0.8783258199691772,
0.08376006036996841,
0.14231422543525696,
-0.6849791407585144,
0.501369297504425,
-0.008455954492092133,
0.02353394217789173,
-0.31553587317466736,
0.0634838342666626,
0.07400258630514145,
0.021666493266820908,
0.03734588623046875,
0.4211956262588501,
-0.4365898370742798,
0.1850126087665558,
0.1907045990228653,
0.05232454463839531,
0.031496960669755936,
-0.16698411107063293,
0.23183582723140717,
0.19414685666561127,
-0.607915997505188,
-0.23943454027175903,
0.2296956330537796,
0.32491427659988403,
-0.35037341713905334,
0.5938355922698975,
0.3730994164943695,
-0.49972113966941833,
0.04022252559661865,
-0.7420178055763245,
0.17189687490463257,
-0.4647618234157562,
0.7544934153556824,
-0.009942181408405304,
-0.41578564047813416,
0.5056725740432739,
0.3268352448940277,
0.19852225482463837,
0.4691537320613861,
0.24421145021915436,
0.04781023785471916,
1.1812973022460938,
0.34640270471572876,
-0.42987897992134094,
0.5120937824249268,
0.21321631968021393,
0.20574092864990234,
-0.8015505075454712,
-0.1603822112083435,
-0.6355335116386414,
0.1359110176563263,
-0.2946228086948395,
-0.2105168253183365,
-0.09471534192562103,
0.29123392701148987,
-0.5710291862487793,
0.26756739616394043,
-0.3379194736480713,
0.46591123938560486,
0.44853174686431885,
0.142084538936615,
0.2421872317790985,
-0.03969823569059372,
0.1650151163339615,
-0.13242916762828827,
-0.7328420281410217,
-0.12063807249069214,
0.2992886006832123,
0.1787029653787613,
0.9108605980873108,
0.4547949731349945,
0.4215887188911438,
0.017233403399586678,
0.1090761050581932,
-0.8654074668884277,
0.25309765338897705,
-0.5024726390838623,
-0.365920752286911,
-0.11601065844297409,
-0.33098646998405457,
-0.36676913499832153,
0.24518874287605286,
-0.29755258560180664,
-0.40405210852622986,
0.3880603611469269,
0.6787711381912231,
-0.7070457935333252,
0.19832271337509155,
-0.4370948076248169,
0.966413140296936,
-0.5897308588027954,
-0.3651716411113739,
0.2600357234477997,
-0.693901538848877,
0.3856472671031952,
0.08688388019800186,
-0.12032260745763779,
0.38981935381889343,
0.13824239373207092,
0.3213256001472473,
-0.6041860580444336,
0.7952700257301331,
-0.20898525416851044,
-0.3198949694633484,
0.38705509901046753,
0.005215439945459366,
0.9279855489730835,
-0.3800477385520935,
-0.015656843781471252,
-0.19734764099121094,
-0.2658061683177948,
-0.1686316877603531,
-0.7187298536300659,
0.5052152276039124,
-0.7150719165802002,
-0.7170599102973938,
-0.5513764023780823,
-0.08187118917703629,
0.08471357822418213,
0.00859698373824358,
0.23476511240005493,
0.29296407103538513,
-0.17767935991287231,
-0.06161722168326378,
0.23338742554187775,
-0.035346224904060364,
0.19780133664608002,
0.6472035050392151,
-0.034050170332193375,
-0.5992311239242554,
0.758877158164978,
0.11851546913385391,
0.501177191734314,
0.3457721769809723,
0.10566423833370209,
-0.3043389618396759,
-0.6033556461334229,
-0.7609904408454895,
0.10232261568307877,
-0.8223534226417542,
-0.4601026773452759,
-0.5731668472290039,
-0.5917415022850037,
-0.6408495306968689,
-0.18955163657665253,
-0.2574262320995331,
-0.4803246557712555,
-0.4966728985309601,
-0.20392374694347382,
0.2590472102165222,
0.23848238587379456,
-0.14671528339385986,
0.7207390666007996,
-1.2667381763458252,
0.13282476365566254,
0.20801673829555511,
-0.029884643852710724,
0.0017873168690130115,
-0.9993942379951477,
-0.3069198727607727,
0.16599780321121216,
-0.3541758358478546,
-0.7177305817604065,
0.6609471440315247,
0.48865416646003723,
0.41946178674697876,
0.5510743856430054,
-0.04131626337766647,
1.231904149055481,
-0.41312429308891296,
0.8582398295402527,
0.14588290452957153,
-1.1920818090438843,
0.33680015802383423,
-0.06823427975177765,
0.4774203896522522,
0.472361296415329,
-0.07775292545557022,
-0.8426774144172668,
-0.3485286235809326,
-0.17126154899597168,
-0.9796240329742432,
0.7526054382324219,
0.003740516724064946,
-0.12097965180873871,
-0.1643541306257248,
0.6660774946212769,
-0.2092546820640564,
-0.09797140955924988,
-0.7446545362472534,
0.024773959070444107,
-0.39007702469825745,
-0.6245672106742859,
-0.030917590484023094,
-0.6186921000480652,
0.23602579534053802,
-0.0802922323346138,
1.2085881233215332,
-0.36009007692337036,
-0.12086522579193115,
0.4280667006969452,
-0.4873552918434143,
-0.6701898574829102,
0.2809797525405884,
0.5177093744277954,
0.3920385241508484,
-0.162949338555336,
-0.06869620829820633,
0.34942424297332764,
-0.49200698733329773,
-0.17796209454536438,
0.45954692363739014,
-0.3980412781238556,
-0.13113027811050415,
0.2829514741897583,
0.5031229853630066,
-0.16855384409427643,
-0.3756478726863861,
0.6209148168563843,
0.07905939221382141,
0.13380353152751923,
-0.5929998159408569,
-0.008000822737812996,
0.02801053784787655,
0.36868372559547424,
0.21130695939064026,
-0.0846494808793068,
0.2964380979537964,
-0.19611892104148865,
0.08145467191934586,
0.3449459671974182,
-0.3683115839958191,
-0.04523131996393204,
0.6347475051879883,
0.31721991300582886,
-0.017914364114403725,
0.7479228973388672,
-0.17486196756362915,
-0.8571208715438843,
0.7864781022071838,
0.7592259645462036,
0.8658778071403503,
-0.672965407371521,
-0.08459314703941345,
0.6525996923446655,
0.19169068336486816,
-0.4806813597679138,
0.3306753635406494,
0.20029687881469727,
-0.978010356426239,
-0.6880805492401123,
-0.053891848772764206,
-0.09580501914024353,
-0.060393720865249634,
-0.9201411604881287,
0.5309028625488281,
-0.35696250200271606,
0.13631519675254822,
-0.216922327876091,
-0.29315295815467834,
-0.024118676781654358,
0.23545555770397186,
0.4085729420185089,
0.5598552227020264,
-0.6950809359550476,
0.8255743980407715,
0.6138821244239807,
-0.2786182463169098,
-0.804287850856781,
0.004833421669900417,
0.17606313526630402,
-0.9611814022064209,
0.49287325143814087,
0.08490731567144394,
-0.3769550323486328,
-0.057308029383420944,
-0.5158423185348511,
-0.7260853052139282,
1.1898237466812134,
0.3882331848144531,
-1.3464789390563965,
-0.09810026735067368,
-0.015431745909154415,
0.45013564825057983,
-0.18043844401836395,
0.38093578815460205,
0.6202399730682373,
0.2815192639827728,
0.27987921237945557,
-0.7697041630744934,
0.23056738078594208,
-0.15259556472301483,
-0.11239232122898102,
0.329962819814682,
-0.8174958825111389,
0.6491618752479553,
-0.3252604007720947,
-0.4511324167251587,
0.5724107623100281,
0.8567789793014526,
0.1339743435382843,
0.05224136635661125,
0.47676166892051697,
0.40187868475914,
0.7313088774681091,
0.029892053455114365,
0.5631988644599915,
-0.1400642991065979,
0.48664626479148865,
1.6658979654312134,
-0.49359241127967834,
0.7529358863830566,
0.43437284231185913,
0.053303636610507965,
0.2929271161556244,
0.45530685782432556,
-0.29971423745155334,
0.36115288734436035,
0.21826690435409546,
-0.23158583045005798,
-0.3772125244140625,
-0.0714244395494461,
-0.3418833017349243,
0.2997683882713318,
0.3569224774837494,
-0.519680917263031,
-0.0342111699283123,
-0.4602716565132141,
-0.045774850994348526,
0.4397886395454407,
-0.5857097506523132,
0.8136986494064331,
-0.23731079697608948,
-0.6042638421058655,
0.563991129398346,
0.01946382038295269,
0.5983765125274658,
-0.35980311036109924,
-0.4201767146587372,
-0.31675615906715393,
0.4592755138874054,
-0.5060762166976929,
-0.509660542011261,
0.18662230670452118,
-0.17531642317771912,
0.027567151933908463,
0.35348933935165405,
0.8013746738433838,
-1.0505247116088867,
-0.6235930919647217,
0.361746609210968,
0.22657541930675507,
-0.22872276604175568,
-0.03759466111660004,
-0.6193583011627197,
-0.21086247265338898,
0.2315215766429901,
0.12535840272903442,
-0.24361562728881836,
0.2641184329986572,
-0.048690661787986755,
0.22092291712760925,
0.2598024904727936,
0.13156792521476746,
0.07340218871831894,
0.5249881148338318,
0.7236217856407166,
-0.8411099314689636,
-0.4303606450557709,
-0.928875207901001,
0.5750259757041931,
-0.2556985318660736,
-0.1111886203289032,
0.6454775929450989,
0.49981147050857544,
0.8565627336502075,
0.01451431680470705,
0.7876469492912292,
-0.05282151326537132,
0.4524914622306824,
-0.8249829411506653,
0.5620746612548828,
-0.5008870959281921,
0.31024378538131714,
-0.23711363971233368,
-0.7989906668663025,
-0.7275717258453369,
0.8027439117431641,
0.05238356068730354,
-0.0974779725074768,
0.4862326383590698,
1.0961692333221436,
0.15275312960147858,
0.05470729619264603,
0.31120648980140686,
0.30215972661972046,
0.17997922003269196,
0.7124990820884705,
1.0926361083984375,
-0.6013076305389404,
0.4462452530860901,
-0.18809638917446136,
-0.059222083538770676,
-0.3001374304294586,
-0.8039619326591492,
-0.8293680548667908,
-0.20653901994228363,
-0.5211052298545837,
-0.5726253390312195,
0.6320533156394958,
1.2306585311889648,
0.15680091083049774,
-1.1125545501708984,
0.06037412956357002,
-0.24348463118076324,
-0.235693097114563,
-0.27771326899528503,
-0.19017785787582397,
0.5862308740615845,
-0.1970643699169159,
-0.6948456168174744,
0.16725772619247437,
-0.18502508103847504,
0.297247976064682,
0.18497082591056824,
-0.10079102963209152,
-0.21407216787338257,
-0.10844550281763077,
0.404494971036911,
0.4134155511856079,
-0.6982622146606445,
-0.527265191078186,
0.0660761371254921,
-0.3359139859676361,
0.3215290606021881,
0.8544377088546753,
-0.29389944672584534,
0.4775765836238861,
0.6195198893547058,
0.8073740601539612,
0.010211022570729256,
0.5353924632072449,
0.7204660773277283,
-0.7063414454460144,
0.0009313543559983373,
0.07153761386871338,
0.677125096321106,
0.45903149247169495,
-0.8693999648094177,
0.3093239665031433,
-0.029981540516018867,
-0.6679695844650269,
-0.4198704957962036,
-0.11674895882606506,
-0.909722089767456,
-0.01851215586066246,
1.2726781368255615,
-0.39015549421310425,
-0.16171251237392426,
0.03927643597126007,
-0.6650579571723938,
0.5867618322372437,
-0.5339979529380798,
0.740899384021759,
0.5991251468658447,
0.21842557191848755,
-0.19059982895851135,
-0.11360936611890793,
0.5350236296653748,
0.8699662089347839,
-0.7121369242668152,
0.46556735038757324,
0.8897687196731567,
-0.008584926836192608,
0.07220372557640076,
0.20375828444957733,
-0.2726839482784271,
0.6998941898345947,
-0.14903564751148224,
0.5059945583343506,
-0.05072562396526337,
-0.1860858052968979,
-0.8970639109611511,
-0.43635302782058716,
0.38926154375076294,
-0.30910664796829224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04588v2 | UltraLink: An Open-Source Knowledge-Enhanced Multilingual Supervised Fine-tuning Dataset | 2024-02-07T05:05:53 | 2024-02-18T03:56:45 | Haoyu Wang, Shuo Wang, Yukun Yan, Xujia Wang, Zhiyu Yang, Yuzhuang Xu, Zhenghao Liu, Liner Yang, Ning Ding, Xu Han, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-source large language models (LLMs) have gained significant strength
across diverse fields. Nevertheless, the majority of studies primarily
concentrate on English, with only limited exploration into the realm of
multilingual abilities. In this work, we therefore construct an open-source
multilingual supervised fine-tuning dataset. Different from previous works that
simply translate English instructions, we consider both the language-specific
and language-agnostic abilities of LLMs. Firstly, we introduce a
knowledge-grounded data augmentation approach to elicit more language-specific
knowledge of LLMs, improving their ability to serve users from different
countries. Moreover, we find modern LLMs possess strong cross-lingual transfer
capabilities, thus repeatedly learning identical content in various languages
is not necessary. Consequently, we can substantially prune the
language-agnostic supervised fine-tuning (SFT) data without any performance
degradation, making multilingual SFT more efficient. The resulting UltraLink
dataset comprises approximately 1 million samples across five languages (i.e.,
En, Zh, Ru, Fr, Es), and the proposed data construction method can be easily
extended to other languages. UltraLink-LM, which is trained on UltraLink,
outperforms several representative baselines across many tasks. | [
-0.265557199716568,
-0.7279136180877686,
0.44443556666374207,
-0.007990415208041668,
-0.13269558548927307,
-0.019192636013031006,
-0.6269925832748413,
-0.4583193063735962,
-0.01852731592953205,
0.3967393934726715,
-0.49363774061203003,
-0.6476295590400696,
-0.11299453675746918,
0.30528154969215393,
-0.15419799089431763,
0.9187964200973511,
-0.03362850472331047,
0.12095323204994202,
-0.03214346989989281,
-0.3445282280445099,
-0.25067323446273804,
-0.1207127571105957,
-0.5278034806251526,
-0.31834501028060913,
0.5764970779418945,
0.8051482439041138,
0.8620223999023438,
0.7962096333503723,
0.32766735553741455,
0.24245820939540863,
0.01331219170242548,
0.7475868463516235,
-0.5949157476425171,
-0.19336111843585968,
-0.460763543844223,
-0.32235923409461975,
-0.2825520634651184,
-0.2531105875968933,
0.6802175641059875,
0.7805997729301453,
-0.1431310921907425,
0.25649493932724,
-0.02686745673418045,
0.8297330737113953,
-0.6225167512893677,
0.3044593334197998,
-0.9017876982688904,
-0.0974925234913826,
-0.2895223796367645,
-0.13818293809890747,
-0.33880889415740967,
-0.2795809805393219,
-0.3223603069782257,
-0.9221109747886658,
0.10104618966579437,
0.041513245552778244,
0.7206891179084778,
0.24514159560203552,
-0.2999100685119629,
0.1286129653453827,
-0.5246424078941345,
0.6248360872268677,
-0.48844942450523376,
0.8102249503135681,
0.40720969438552856,
0.1427045613527298,
-0.06376733630895615,
-0.3211893141269684,
-0.3727622926235199,
0.04427375644445419,
-0.16491879522800446,
0.02928910218179226,
-0.1285920888185501,
-0.007482253015041351,
0.011560522019863129,
0.365921288728714,
-0.5688274502754211,
0.43744349479675293,
-0.2925359904766083,
-0.2643277943134308,
0.49584078788757324,
0.03173231706023216,
0.18742826581001282,
0.13778623938560486,
-0.19197042286396027,
0.11891907453536987,
-1.0061951875686646,
-0.0280020572245121,
0.49249088764190674,
0.7191883325576782,
-0.19471900165081024,
0.5419724583625793,
-0.5916524529457092,
0.7118720412254333,
-0.0401463657617569,
-0.1251852810382843,
0.33354219794273376,
-0.23840539157390594,
-0.24384155869483948,
0.1768842488527298,
0.8161235451698303,
0.3438042998313904,
0.4819999635219574,
-0.322354257106781,
-0.03985574096441269,
-0.3888136148452759,
-0.13217847049236298,
-0.5566663146018982,
-0.3340420722961426,
-0.03714575245976448,
-0.29518890380859375,
-0.07116343826055527,
0.023337554186582565,
-0.301934152841568,
-0.15979218482971191,
-0.47404375672340393,
0.16407929360866547,
-0.4493895173072815,
-0.165329247713089,
0.28814199566841125,
0.4677840769290924,
-0.10350316762924194,
0.08355089277029037,
-0.8026580214500427,
-0.30136001110076904,
0.2917885482311249,
0.37655237317085266,
0.004161343444138765,
-0.6243642568588257,
-0.6048719882965088,
0.6430357694625854,
-0.34976327419281006,
0.6786882281303406,
-0.6450402736663818,
-0.05913674458861351,
0.24096257984638214,
0.49206674098968506,
0.04998047649860382,
-0.46735045313835144,
0.5301966071128845,
-0.5937401056289673,
0.11395508795976639,
-0.08277294784784317,
-0.5664615035057068,
-0.1702137142419815,
-0.04451412707567215,
-0.4747818112373352,
1.1210647821426392,
0.027640415355563164,
-0.633668065071106,
0.25275662541389465,
-0.489321231842041,
-0.7086054086685181,
0.1557018756866455,
-0.02977501042187214,
-0.13349364697933197,
0.17659512162208557,
0.5894497036933899,
0.8235608339309692,
-0.3407491445541382,
0.40471071004867554,
-0.2738311290740967,
-0.4198237955570221,
-0.14464712142944336,
-0.4582322835922241,
0.7184823155403137,
0.36639901995658875,
-0.0888853520154953,
0.05339903011918068,
-0.953354001045227,
-0.018393656238913536,
0.014422542415559292,
-0.5121577382087708,
-0.6293842792510986,
-0.23213855922222137,
0.09568417817354202,
0.1562764048576355,
0.4261217415332794,
-0.6981723308563232,
0.21501192450523376,
-0.3074507713317871,
0.11824681609869003,
0.7818073630332947,
-0.3452930152416229,
0.1419897824525833,
0.08783338218927383,
0.286228209733963,
-0.08323559165000916,
0.25286945700645447,
-0.3265555202960968,
-0.22172284126281738,
-0.6910917162895203,
-0.2271246463060379,
0.33001747727394104,
0.628145694732666,
-0.9661605954170227,
0.45865941047668457,
-0.4098333418369293,
-0.19318972527980804,
-1.0126934051513672,
0.6359078288078308,
0.6436479687690735,
0.4877129793167114,
0.6873788833618164,
0.19039802253246307,
-0.38462528586387634,
-0.9905794262886047,
-0.1775887906551361,
-0.014528260566294193,
-0.05288626253604889,
0.35304391384124756,
0.06475657224655151,
-0.36552396416664124,
0.4683624804019928,
-0.4807508885860443,
-0.5597503781318665,
-0.14144429564476013,
-0.18037596344947815,
0.2720601260662079,
0.3758944571018219,
0.25200140476226807,
-0.5802536010742188,
-0.6709312200546265,
0.4598478674888611,
-0.9217358231544495,
-0.2643168866634369,
-0.013415367342531681,
-0.13265445828437805,
0.2040468007326126,
0.8047540187835693,
-0.26273852586746216,
-0.17439745366573334,
0.5830804109573364,
-0.14433366060256958,
0.4522089958190918,
-0.645771324634552,
0.17088335752487183,
-1.1945991516113281,
-0.05102879926562309,
-0.038667935878038406,
-0.034489136189222336,
-0.30525118112564087,
0.4033394455909729,
0.5060380101203918,
0.16594143211841583,
-0.7224486470222473,
0.6019168496131897,
-0.5020667314529419,
0.2606508433818817,
-0.030750636011362076,
-0.02219913713634014,
-0.30901429057121277,
0.30717429518699646,
0.0663713589310646,
0.8862954378128052,
0.692882776260376,
-0.3837433159351349,
0.4948350489139557,
0.22143197059631348,
-0.3810296952724457,
0.6814016103744507,
-0.4805128872394562,
-0.07457949966192245,
-0.020857537165284157,
-0.2433880716562271,
-0.7396757006645203,
-0.20113562047481537,
-0.4594411551952362,
-0.2605374753475189,
0.35755854845046997,
-0.24045602977275848,
-0.6912670731544495,
-0.237929567694664,
-0.1471739262342453,
0.1690453439950943,
0.2015058398246765,
-0.8605056405067444,
0.16355885565280914,
0.2635481357574463,
-0.10843965411186218,
-0.5846397280693054,
-0.5711291432380676,
0.06954393535852432,
-0.06093839183449745,
-0.44283363223075867,
0.10904356837272644,
-0.14292971789836884,
-0.054726582020521164,
0.034211743623018265,
-0.03306413069367409,
0.03640666604042053,
-0.025792710483074188,
-0.08763231337070465,
0.06474454700946808,
-0.07947487384080887,
0.13559778034687042,
0.3768172264099121,
-0.2441495954990387,
-0.26324188709259033,
-0.5146653652191162,
0.19250807166099548,
-0.038962822407484055,
-0.4969367980957031,
-0.30867448449134827,
0.13951799273490906,
0.49814409017562866,
-0.45253321528434753,
0.7133461236953735,
0.9451146721839905,
-0.12846560776233673,
-0.2556169927120209,
-0.6501303315162659,
0.0688452199101448,
-0.48654916882514954,
0.2758680284023285,
-0.6094747185707092,
-1.3047490119934082,
0.3931209146976471,
-0.2651262879371643,
0.14050297439098358,
0.3528521656990051,
0.3742004632949829,
-0.24679668247699738,
0.9959056377410889,
0.9035095572471619,
-0.467202752828598,
0.13192662596702576,
-0.20416316390037537,
0.021300872787833214,
-0.8152552843093872,
-0.27274397015571594,
-0.5502530336380005,
-0.07104436308145523,
-0.6021833419799805,
-0.21661245822906494,
0.40434592962265015,
0.2637012004852295,
-0.17550303041934967,
0.3929537236690521,
-0.3223344683647156,
0.7840300798416138,
0.44871875643730164,
0.13320420682430267,
0.5081987977027893,
0.409950852394104,
-0.6255617141723633,
0.03821172937750816,
-0.8406392931938171,
-0.21694660186767578,
1.4246892929077148,
0.14406196773052216,
0.9704179167747498,
0.17384110391139984,
0.27384158968925476,
0.1854683756828308,
-0.014475243166089058,
-0.28896600008010864,
0.4338357746601105,
-0.5701955556869507,
-0.36913618445396423,
-0.33379966020584106,
-0.6365799307823181,
-0.9157400131225586,
0.03252262994647026,
-0.33655402064323425,
-0.3962108790874481,
-0.17978179454803467,
0.0665949359536171,
-0.15399934351444244,
0.5084648728370667,
-0.5322361588478088,
0.5760776996612549,
-0.30349528789520264,
-0.7366490364074707,
-0.1806362122297287,
-0.6249555945396423,
0.2250066101551056,
-0.32221516966819763,
0.5577751398086548,
-0.15274879336357117,
0.1557520627975464,
0.4317569136619568,
-0.16593612730503082,
0.6281650066375732,
-0.044795893132686615,
-0.4477105736732483,
-0.15073417127132416,
0.04692159965634346,
0.6031508445739746,
0.36059632897377014,
-0.11772334575653076,
0.33301398158073425,
-0.41028422117233276,
-0.44276106357574463,
-0.21816806495189667,
1.128128170967102,
-0.7848867177963257,
-0.21916402876377106,
0.26877450942993164,
-0.9507288336753845,
-0.4997554123401642,
0.3469023108482361,
0.020834030583500862,
0.35498762130737305,
-0.04944298043847084,
0.467702716588974,
0.8978857398033142,
-0.3332003355026245,
0.34060749411582947,
1.225699782371521,
-0.13558095693588257,
-0.37921369075775146,
0.9653825163841248,
-0.1678883582353592,
0.12361381947994232,
0.6226742267608643,
0.06410260498523712,
-0.4770108759403229,
-0.6680822968482971,
-0.850673258304596,
0.2743097245693207,
-0.45965853333473206,
-0.16873733699321747,
-0.47557732462882996,
0.24762699007987976,
-0.3648096024990082,
-0.2319023609161377,
-0.4410061836242676,
-0.30653655529022217,
-0.07037854939699173,
-0.30477166175842285,
0.5527002215385437,
0.5561426877975464,
-0.2150123566389084,
0.17792421579360962,
-0.9823192954063416,
0.5182901620864868,
0.3295934796333313,
0.7352247834205627,
-0.3077945113182068,
-0.4291015565395355,
-0.663883626461029,
0.26948192715644836,
0.11328405141830444,
-0.44380638003349304,
-0.016461720690131187,
0.44716325402259827,
0.8053122758865356,
0.4834723472595215,
0.03048037178814411,
0.8824976682662964,
-0.6140289902687073,
0.7063995599746704,
0.09945069998502731,
-0.5566760301589966,
0.4698852002620697,
-0.5864814519882202,
0.37926238775253296,
0.8361116647720337,
0.6284471154212952,
-0.2766701579093933,
-0.4048079252243042,
-0.4168567359447479,
-0.7886804938316345,
0.6379244327545166,
0.0027603490743786097,
0.15681131184101105,
0.11091507226228714,
0.36856716871261597,
0.16870863735675812,
0.15622198581695557,
-0.42310386896133423,
-0.49734702706336975,
0.1873525232076645,
-0.3083418905735016,
-0.4232475161552429,
-0.012845400720834732,
-0.03940761089324951,
-0.6528258323669434,
0.8941361904144287,
-0.5310606956481934,
-0.24036860466003418,
-0.09500779956579208,
-0.32225164771080017,
-0.39708736538887024,
0.3421526849269867,
0.20184561610221863,
0.5570891499519348,
-0.17247232794761658,
0.20514589548110962,
0.37672746181488037,
-0.3376805782318115,
0.21995337307453156,
0.4630982577800751,
-0.43053415417671204,
-0.08672484755516052,
0.23655368387699127,
0.7173332571983337,
0.3334580063819885,
-0.7160678505897522,
0.11965110152959824,
0.12077688425779343,
-0.17650598287582397,
0.1483924388885498,
-0.02260175533592701,
0.25323137640953064,
0.2057039588689804,
0.25191640853881836,
-0.33324968814849854,
-0.09841930866241455,
-0.43830519914627075,
0.2595384120941162,
0.46455198526382446,
-0.5313681364059448,
-0.17344753444194794,
0.847568154335022,
0.27899059653282166,
0.13182426989078522,
0.5328660607337952,
-0.10441932827234268,
-0.1319139152765274,
0.1342516988515854,
0.5632887482643127,
0.5535482168197632,
-0.4228762090206146,
0.1613505333662033,
0.2575852572917938,
0.5266386866569519,
-0.06477979570627213,
0.46750977635383606,
0.01560564711689949,
-0.6816177368164062,
-0.6393524408340454,
-0.8391547203063965,
-0.22784635424613953,
0.40304112434387207,
-0.4799749553203583,
0.19832879304885864,
0.05300844833254814,
0.43262144923210144,
-0.17622484266757965,
-0.024224771186709404,
-0.5878916382789612,
0.25471359491348267,
-0.07794713228940964,
1.0325297117233276,
-1.0061964988708496,
1.173880934715271,
1.2160805463790894,
-0.2719908058643341,
-0.9276835918426514,
-0.31000036001205444,
-0.10753835737705231,
-0.9372592568397522,
0.32160377502441406,
-0.13225404918193817,
-0.1520465463399887,
0.26927903294563293,
-0.3844367563724518,
-0.720148503780365,
0.9155289530754089,
0.7213149070739746,
-0.6653439402580261,
0.1985066533088684,
0.5468073487281799,
0.4902428686618805,
-0.19008365273475647,
0.26678961515426636,
0.4091150164604187,
0.6015490293502808,
-0.2704679071903229,
-1.1786690950393677,
-0.10554371029138565,
-0.18824245035648346,
-0.07163695245981216,
0.33484187722206116,
-0.7670121788978577,
0.5151026844978333,
-0.2180067002773285,
0.21164967119693756,
-0.30029693245887756,
0.5249292254447937,
0.033611927181482315,
-0.04730337858200073,
0.22516855597496033,
0.7828977704048157,
0.6859102845191956,
-0.018056144937872887,
0.649010956287384,
-0.7806270718574524,
0.257082462310791,
1.0378601551055908,
-0.2351960837841034,
0.6427103281021118,
0.39563509821891785,
-0.10974037647247314,
0.2002328634262085,
0.3390023410320282,
0.07988566160202026,
0.5206499099731445,
-0.1361086666584015,
-0.10341855138540268,
-0.4971696436405182,
-0.38931405544281006,
-0.45226576924324036,
0.47603270411491394,
0.21187028288841248,
-0.28421899676322937,
-0.4390023946762085,
0.08386853337287903,
0.16037404537200928,
0.283066064119339,
-0.41607290506362915,
0.7646927237510681,
-0.16196127235889435,
-0.27206486463546753,
0.8100659251213074,
0.1001213937997818,
0.9015339612960815,
-0.7165754437446594,
0.007626783102750778,
-0.4407986104488373,
0.21471711993217468,
-0.32797396183013916,
-0.9312615394592285,
0.07218675315380096,
0.1260647177696228,
-0.1186065673828125,
-0.28517717123031616,
0.6537477970123291,
-0.78052818775177,
-0.5702882409095764,
0.4336419403553009,
0.7057293653488159,
0.22102634608745575,
-0.03126101940870285,
-0.6937775611877441,
-0.03601706400513649,
0.3571301996707916,
-0.1666070818901062,
0.5136727690696716,
0.4849208891391754,
-0.15957225859165192,
0.6592835187911987,
1.0637757778167725,
0.36452168226242065,
-0.05587514489889145,
0.2326941341161728,
0.7621439099311829,
-0.4388364851474762,
-0.269228458404541,
-0.5746089220046997,
0.42883795499801636,
0.09233980625867844,
-0.2603831887245178,
0.9014149904251099,
0.8881968855857849,
1.360628366470337,
-0.1114349514245987,
0.9284948110580444,
0.2625592350959778,
0.45100101828575134,
-0.7262287139892578,
0.8196507096290588,
-0.9879243969917297,
0.24358752369880676,
-0.26022204756736755,
-0.9920892715454102,
-0.33544015884399414,
0.318337082862854,
0.21532806754112244,
-0.31477639079093933,
0.44640785455703735,
0.869484543800354,
-0.5399366021156311,
-0.021590225398540497,
0.4745069742202759,
0.20321550965309143,
0.14749018847942352,
0.7068454027175903,
0.3470623195171356,
-0.29580387473106384,
0.5946674942970276,
-0.4773634672164917,
-0.21979351341724396,
0.01724809594452381,
-0.9245400428771973,
-0.8748206496238708,
-0.4738386571407318,
-0.16162148118019104,
0.16027094423770905,
0.2542242109775543,
0.8278355002403259,
0.6583549380302429,
-0.8491088151931763,
-0.23580622673034668,
0.07009249180555344,
0.002436406211927533,
-0.2392212450504303,
-0.1401214301586151,
0.5612121820449829,
-0.4095657169818878,
-0.623631477355957,
0.9590373635292053,
0.23474638164043427,
-0.2038135826587677,
-0.14110691845417023,
-0.13330845534801483,
-0.2345849722623825,
-0.21456682682037354,
0.7104642391204834,
0.15189887583255768,
-0.4764595031738281,
-0.1349816769361496,
0.06506165117025375,
0.08205998688936234,
-0.19124628603458405,
0.4314223825931549,
-0.6132756471633911,
0.5314059853553772,
0.22653436660766602,
0.6437789797782898,
0.04851116985082626,
-0.13193684816360474,
0.4508553147315979,
-0.9171828031539917,
0.23236508667469025,
-0.4472930133342743,
0.5671445727348328,
0.3882494270801544,
-0.3447413742542267,
0.6568373441696167,
0.16919106245040894,
-0.42783603072166443,
-0.6158021688461304,
0.08997096121311188,
-0.5586011409759521,
-0.4596541225910187,
1.3505973815917969,
-0.1616804003715515,
0.26701655983924866,
-0.2807573974132538,
-0.18376339972019196,
0.2967699468135834,
-0.39841270446777344,
0.5301635265350342,
0.32538825273513794,
-0.02724660560488701,
-0.09851010143756866,
-0.6303411722183228,
0.34981364011764526,
0.3628476858139038,
-0.7528467774391174,
0.40499424934387207,
0.6550349593162537,
0.2584579885005951,
-0.03353662043809891,
0.34600645303726196,
-0.08680056035518646,
0.15109510719776154,
-0.6629226803779602,
0.25023943185806274,
-0.7078596949577332,
-0.587983250617981,
-0.41702836751937866,
0.21009746193885803,
0.024296119809150696,
0.1511715054512024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04559v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04559v2 | Can Large Language Model Agents Simulate Human Trust Behaviors? | 2024-02-07T03:37:19 | 2024-03-10T13:48:43 | Chengxing Xie, Canyu Chen, Feiran Jia, Ziyu Ye, Kai Shu, Adel Bibi, Ziniu Hu, Philip Torr, Bernard Ghanem, Guohao Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Large Language Model (LLM) agents have been increasingly adopted as
simulation tools to model humans in applications such as social science.
However, one fundamental question remains: can LLM agents really simulate human
behaviors? In this paper, we focus on one of the most critical behaviors in
human interactions, trust, and aim to investigate whether or not LLM agents can
simulate human trust behaviors. We first find that LLM agents generally exhibit
trust behaviors, referred to as agent trust, under the framework of Trust
Games, which are widely recognized in behavioral economics. Then, we discover
that LLM agents can have high behavioral alignment with humans regarding trust
behaviors, particularly for GPT-4, indicating the feasibility to simulate human
trust behaviors with LLM agents. In addition, we probe into the biases in agent
trust and the differences in agent trust towards agents and humans. We also
explore the intrinsic properties of agent trust under conditions including
advanced reasoning strategies and external manipulations. We further offer
important implications of our discoveries for various scenarios where trust is
paramount. Our study provides new insights into the behaviors of LLM agents and
the fundamental analogy between LLMs and humans. | [
-0.15264581143856049,
-0.8883954882621765,
1.080703616142273,
-0.00465418491512537,
0.11581239849328995,
0.36290791630744934,
-0.09567929059267044,
-0.7884140014648438,
0.0010684329317882657,
0.38873520493507385,
-0.41423550248146057,
-0.046485431492328644,
-0.36770859360694885,
0.10744848102331161,
-0.3216044306755066,
0.5907691121101379,
-0.0343092679977417,
0.3041895627975464,
-0.3398149013519287,
0.35126519203186035,
0.10203930735588074,
-0.9983953833580017,
-1.02578604221344,
-1.0557787418365479,
0.4546875059604645,
-0.012123399414122105,
0.979382336139679,
0.31306642293930054,
0.3203967213630676,
0.4009232819080353,
-0.0348450243473053,
0.0037551168352365494,
-0.6487491130828857,
0.006631821859627962,
-0.3495568633079529,
-0.41849637031555176,
-0.6027916073799133,
0.5163018703460693,
0.6352728605270386,
0.05387246236205101,
-0.2286914736032486,
-0.10590960085391998,
0.1910114586353302,
0.21931183338165283,
0.06855995953083038,
0.3274708688259125,
-0.6075332760810852,
-0.1993696242570877,
0.15216994285583496,
-0.11863232403993607,
-0.39451146125793457,
-0.5288042426109314,
0.27799904346466064,
-0.6104280948638916,
-0.15704095363616943,
0.4415305256843567,
1.0431914329528809,
0.0890049859881401,
-0.6665270924568176,
-0.037792980670928955,
-0.6223243474960327,
0.6514830589294434,
-0.6638157367706299,
0.14023621380329132,
0.5045680403709412,
0.12334782630205154,
-0.46881866455078125,
-0.5058912038803101,
-0.9317205548286438,
-0.6597990989685059,
-0.009593600407242775,
-0.16225509345531464,
0.01030672900378704,
0.27575838565826416,
0.48433345556259155,
-0.04760018363595009,
-0.23020830750465393,
-0.06163064017891884,
0.0011940343538299203,
-0.44738656282424927,
0.6137518882751465,
0.27262207865715027,
0.48175492882728577,
0.16969633102416992,
-0.5098704695701599,
-0.5598927736282349,
-0.6359291672706604,
0.24138182401657104,
0.6287371516227722,
-0.10022135078907013,
-0.13283966481685638,
0.42528682947158813,
0.19484834372997284,
0.07540663331747055,
0.014888082630932331,
-0.3351016640663147,
0.04534101486206055,
-0.1672278344631195,
-0.28075191378593445,
0.11175842583179474,
0.7211070656776428,
0.6504064798355103,
0.8453733921051025,
-0.24306830763816833,
-0.09851354360580444,
0.3388446271419525,
0.2971044182777405,
-0.6139803528785706,
0.21573755145072937,
0.0681154727935791,
-0.28417515754699707,
-0.5721239447593689,
0.12548735737800598,
-0.5747078061103821,
-0.6427479386329651,
-0.23012623190879822,
0.6565545797348022,
-0.40794575214385986,
-0.4223423898220062,
0.17897656559944153,
-0.06670623272657394,
0.7704319953918457,
0.42603668570518494,
-0.37945395708084106,
0.6778839826583862,
0.896412193775177,
0.5427712798118591,
-0.2746799886226654,
-1.0708138942718506,
-0.4535543620586395,
0.22401590645313263,
-0.3074232041835785,
0.19180069863796234,
-0.6647284030914307,
-0.5731157064437866,
0.0954093337059021,
-0.15970131754875183,
0.027247846126556396,
-0.2531486749649048,
0.22605791687965393,
-0.8062809705734253,
-0.3966031074523926,
-0.6401368975639343,
-0.7688206434249878,
0.04798457771539688,
0.844836413860321,
-0.5742958784103394,
0.6243661642074585,
0.029823999851942062,
-0.6850174069404602,
0.0002659923629835248,
-0.608649492263794,
-0.3411569893360138,
-0.4287533462047577,
-0.15047219395637512,
-0.21327361464500427,
-0.2903720736503601,
-0.3163530230522156,
0.5080191493034363,
-0.4901326298713684,
0.13186810910701752,
-0.6758887767791748,
-0.6659125685691833,
1.0858558416366577,
-0.39694687724113464,
0.5982353091239929,
0.056744180619716644,
-0.37209126353263855,
-0.10395415872335434,
0.1568002849817276,
0.07226678729057312,
0.32922255992889404,
-0.0941586047410965,
-0.0742531567811966,
-0.16178473830223083,
-0.04043065384030342,
0.29978838562965393,
0.4111873507499695,
-0.5835192799568176,
0.4857993721961975,
0.01722903549671173,
0.4777357876300812,
0.9519820213317871,
0.3792959749698639,
0.6265184879302979,
-0.5558317303657532,
0.7221092581748962,
-0.048725731670856476,
0.24411213397979736,
0.3571908473968506,
-0.5449584722518921,
-0.47128409147262573,
-0.08690506219863892,
-0.05054350569844246,
0.37055739760398865,
-0.4504834711551666,
0.02096228301525116,
-0.18349310755729675,
-0.17819730937480927,
-0.258058100938797,
-0.16880306601524353,
0.5812686681747437,
0.1518956422805786,
-0.014035193249583244,
-0.17184729874134064,
-0.36823371052742004,
-0.7742405533790588,
-0.5159268975257874,
-0.5268992185592651,
0.2635097801685333,
0.3809557557106018,
0.5689703822135925,
-0.33591821789741516,
0.9894297122955322,
-0.2655801773071289,
-0.040882524102926254,
-0.1242724284529686,
0.19633698463439941,
-0.26679667830467224,
0.2318311333656311,
0.47862258553504944,
-0.7054935097694397,
-0.303170770406723,
-0.12768539786338806,
-0.5181435346603394,
0.28517091274261475,
-0.1261165291070938,
-0.05438800901174545,
0.20437119901180267,
0.7251436710357666,
-0.8931486010551453,
0.26219114661216736,
0.720319926738739,
-0.6583636403083801,
0.6989389657974243,
-0.45654523372650146,
0.28099292516708374,
-1.0560377836227417,
-0.20733705163002014,
-0.027626359835267067,
-0.4381295144557953,
-0.48973116278648376,
0.11155949532985687,
-0.1816803216934204,
0.1928892731666565,
-0.37531179189682007,
0.8186522722244263,
-0.4211287200450897,
-0.28459036350250244,
-0.25307634472846985,
0.07552678883075714,
-0.07907096296548843,
0.22970521450042725,
-0.07933590561151505,
0.9468659162521362,
0.6847261190414429,
-0.504047155380249,
0.17224332690238953,
0.030894752591848373,
-0.1480773240327835,
0.5255317091941833,
-0.8085892796516418,
0.2899690568447113,
0.0603201799094677,
0.5306385159492493,
-0.6647902727127075,
-0.4100499153137207,
0.18640349805355072,
-0.41956400871276855,
0.22507984936237335,
0.03196737915277481,
-0.8985291123390198,
-0.11018133908510208,
-0.37447553873062134,
0.16407360136508942,
0.9273812770843506,
-0.1271577626466751,
0.7544969916343689,
0.36505362391471863,
0.1181768849492073,
-0.5123993754386902,
-0.5007805824279785,
0.10852787643671036,
-0.2808395028114319,
-0.525974452495575,
-0.045364148914813995,
-0.204366534948349,
-0.698992133140564,
0.008726527914404869,
0.16408808529376984,
-0.11438857764005661,
0.13639438152313232,
0.40855273604393005,
0.4332933723926544,
0.20654459297657013,
-0.292035311460495,
-0.2134118676185608,
0.21199636161327362,
0.38076090812683105,
-0.10918779671192169,
0.5299977660179138,
-0.5871372222900391,
-0.6293826103210449,
-0.4814620614051819,
0.06133974716067314,
0.9205321073532104,
0.051891960203647614,
0.7317036390304565,
0.4748890697956085,
-0.4144205152988434,
-0.006190379615873098,
-0.7680040001869202,
-0.6471893191337585,
-0.532292902469635,
0.2551339268684387,
-0.44331085681915283,
-1.2096779346466064,
0.48876622319221497,
-0.058124251663684845,
-0.21743738651275635,
-0.08166439831256866,
0.6438453793525696,
-0.24613304436206818,
0.8491136431694031,
0.4042778015136719,
-0.5296584963798523,
-0.08637954294681549,
0.026663396507501602,
0.17082823812961578,
-0.7363356351852417,
-0.08031555265188217,
-0.4046379029750824,
-0.3261411786079407,
-0.630587637424469,
-0.7556053400039673,
0.35816481709480286,
-0.2591938078403473,
-0.5656982660293579,
0.0002563163870945573,
0.18903431296348572,
0.7003406286239624,
0.3432970941066742,
0.12321902811527252,
0.3823426067829132,
-0.16305088996887207,
-0.18643894791603088,
0.04379774257540703,
-0.1249886006116867,
-0.7751449346542358,
0.7810959219932556,
0.45475801825523376,
1.060441017150879,
-0.03520817682147026,
0.7903919219970703,
0.46902352571487427,
0.35509783029556274,
-0.5458405017852783,
0.7764682173728943,
0.4455839693546295,
-0.799893856048584,
-0.6585450768470764,
-0.3600119650363922,
-0.8640202283859253,
-0.003617364214733243,
-0.17165015637874603,
-0.9092502593994141,
-0.09856557101011276,
0.3023587763309479,
-0.013049176894128323,
0.420144259929657,
-0.7491695880889893,
0.6050321459770203,
-0.13590267300605774,
-0.2382393628358841,
-0.43686628341674805,
-0.8070775866508484,
0.32431015372276306,
0.005120393354445696,
0.17934344708919525,
-0.1611022651195526,
0.12655477225780487,
0.41570502519607544,
-0.021352531388401985,
1.1373587846755981,
-0.08921073377132416,
-0.22558405995368958,
0.35418784618377686,
0.6321030855178833,
0.9248238205909729,
0.02134697698056698,
-0.17807471752166748,
0.128698468208313,
0.08330786228179932,
-0.32800960540771484,
-0.5988990068435669,
0.8178222179412842,
-1.213192343711853,
-0.6642304062843323,
-0.8003931641578674,
-0.5223318934440613,
-0.40494927763938904,
0.06968674063682556,
-0.29746225476264954,
-0.2628973424434662,
-0.6732909679412842,
-0.10668308287858963,
0.7313783168792725,
0.02928246185183525,
0.23157578706741333,
0.5002367496490479,
-0.175092414021492,
0.16650809347629547,
0.7451937198638916,
-0.38685116171836853,
0.37166717648506165,
0.2595975399017334,
0.3812572658061981,
-0.3842863142490387,
-0.1470443457365036,
0.10853636264801025,
0.5341101288795471,
-0.2751677930355072,
0.013647083193063736,
-0.33257782459259033,
-0.16976337134838104,
-0.15958340466022491,
-0.36138904094696045,
-0.3751694858074188,
0.08666336536407471,
-0.018250389024615288,
-0.2930840849876404,
0.41983771324157715,
0.816540002822876,
0.1215129941701889,
0.11242590099573135,
-0.6147254109382629,
0.1939820498228073,
0.711696982383728,
0.3224247694015503,
0.2524603009223938,
-0.3150351047515869,
0.073562853038311,
0.15176348388195038,
-0.06400424242019653,
-0.7251198887825012,
0.06801915913820267,
-0.23469315469264984,
0.43694666028022766,
0.561099648475647,
0.04664832726120949,
0.4791804254055023,
-0.46938174962997437,
0.8458440899848938,
0.040865458548069,
-1.0898847579956055,
-0.34962451457977295,
-0.7121676206588745,
-0.3390006422996521,
0.2777721881866455,
0.2868098318576813,
-0.5735200643539429,
-0.52006596326828,
-0.7491849064826965,
-0.17736904323101044,
0.578399658203125,
0.3698135316371918,
0.22814971208572388,
0.17099909484386444,
0.5433762669563293,
-0.17023740708827972,
0.24345949292182922,
-0.6294636726379395,
-0.12697814404964447,
-0.0997636541724205,
0.045177020132541656,
-0.35708799958229065,
-0.4029747247695923,
-0.41901129484176636,
0.14648526906967163,
0.4474847614765167,
-0.0500650629401207,
0.28025704622268677,
0.36182329058647156,
0.12647907435894012,
-0.30762651562690735,
0.4758061468601227,
0.6232349872589111,
0.6212341785430908,
-0.24317467212677002,
0.16263243556022644,
0.1610148549079895,
-0.4396391212940216,
0.4456721246242523,
-0.22010603547096252,
0.017420414835214615,
-0.6626812219619751,
-0.029328860342502594,
0.3479973375797272,
0.28124672174453735,
-0.7817287445068359,
0.7292418479919434,
-0.172805517911911,
-0.4332040846347809,
-0.5648775100708008,
0.09326817095279694,
0.5527904629707336,
0.7467321157455444,
0.09968376159667969,
-0.2453533262014389,
-0.09923844039440155,
-0.9169577956199646,
0.2577139437198639,
0.6471458077430725,
-0.10812893509864807,
-0.5491313934326172,
0.7366617321968079,
0.1710539311170578,
-0.4001863896846771,
0.6100625991821289,
-0.4820050895214081,
-0.8028543591499329,
0.5872491002082825,
0.5853210091590881,
0.845413327217102,
-0.09541823714971542,
0.37885531783103943,
-0.12081152200698853,
0.5278480648994446,
-0.3895885646343231,
0.25958630442619324,
0.40768924355506897,
-1.2049933671951294,
-0.4109211266040802,
-0.4807664453983307,
-0.9897041916847229,
0.03286336362361908,
-0.4542458951473236,
-0.1445283740758896,
-0.30875706672668457,
-0.24719099700450897,
-0.6128236651420593,
0.1344829946756363,
-0.714380145072937,
-0.05137393996119499,
0.2701263129711151,
0.7801761031150818,
-0.696109414100647,
1.2100043296813965,
0.9531096816062927,
-0.06911838054656982,
-1.195000410079956,
0.3730398714542389,
0.02341906726360321,
-1.0700064897537231,
0.5323669910430908,
-0.16703476011753082,
-0.693583071231842,
-0.01237399596720934,
-0.7702897191047668,
-0.5213435292243958,
1.4218688011169434,
0.5817294716835022,
-0.1433577984571457,
-0.28734391927719116,
0.2346448302268982,
0.660807192325592,
-0.4336344301700592,
0.14163407683372498,
0.6000173687934875,
0.8627318739891052,
-0.05843758210539818,
-1.1874141693115234,
0.2974001467227936,
0.01671094074845314,
0.10523336380720139,
-0.2593642473220825,
-1.1383557319641113,
0.9332139492034912,
-0.3595854640007019,
0.2756485044956207,
0.1279592365026474,
0.4848191738128662,
0.7048733830451965,
0.4257480204105377,
0.7395344376564026,
0.33080586791038513,
0.6883916854858398,
0.20376068353652954,
1.2540781497955322,
-0.3649357855319977,
0.40516436100006104,
0.9192953109741211,
-1.1310302019119263,
0.5671666860580444,
0.6281545758247375,
-0.09063126891851425,
0.5170273184776306,
0.3132588863372803,
0.19341692328453064,
-0.04839956760406494,
0.19487632811069489,
-0.07618960738182068,
-0.4672725796699524,
-0.12276222556829453,
-0.12005306035280228,
0.6100562810897827,
0.1330094039440155,
0.052450235933065414,
0.10636582225561142,
-0.4596192240715027,
0.37755781412124634,
-0.02870301343500614,
-0.23849567770957947,
0.4655294120311737,
0.2253197282552719,
-0.4853203296661377,
0.07117549329996109,
-0.008067767135798931,
0.5541778206825256,
-0.9265674948692322,
-0.035481955856084824,
0.17387230694293976,
0.11998457461595535,
0.1811116486787796,
-0.7456903457641602,
-0.32697558403015137,
-0.2511071562767029,
0.1346197873353958,
-0.4238238036632538,
0.8200862407684326,
-0.34113508462905884,
0.1554383933544159,
0.40344199538230896,
0.6302659511566162,
0.1808335930109024,
-0.3787611722946167,
-0.41686195135116577,
0.006729946471750736,
-0.19171524047851562,
-0.565990149974823,
0.9165775775909424,
0.5098140239715576,
-0.03564539924263954,
0.9950084686279297,
0.7600317597389221,
0.19362995028495789,
-0.08287281543016434,
-0.20793236792087555,
0.7073878645896912,
-0.786816418170929,
-0.4764336347579956,
-0.9324093461036682,
0.11316829919815063,
-0.26893624663352966,
0.2493051439523697,
0.8069753050804138,
0.25945666432380676,
0.6826553344726562,
-0.295889288187027,
0.7857607007026672,
0.2604401111602783,
0.21956653892993927,
-0.4892658293247223,
0.9521528482437134,
-0.2555062472820282,
-0.17376597225666046,
-0.4237637519836426,
-0.7607742547988892,
0.2483137547969818,
0.5743281841278076,
0.051540348678827286,
0.23137983679771423,
0.8965524435043335,
0.8352975845336914,
0.14081017673015594,
-0.019956225529313087,
0.5624510645866394,
0.5841519832611084,
0.40590301156044006,
0.34128400683403015,
0.9863442182540894,
0.008199954405426979,
0.5364624261856079,
0.10549047589302063,
0.04523338004946709,
-0.20369674265384674,
-0.9447444081306458,
-1.0384786128997803,
-0.4704316556453705,
0.020805777981877327,
-0.5460736751556396,
0.018145665526390076,
1.1274762153625488,
0.4475179612636566,
-0.24496930837631226,
-0.4758225083351135,
0.22888749837875366,
0.25252553820610046,
-0.16982786357402802,
-0.23308716714382172,
0.008143192157149315,
0.1887449473142624,
-0.8048781752586365,
0.2553311288356781,
0.08643769472837448,
0.3835276663303375,
-0.5011817216873169,
-0.658300518989563,
0.06529565155506134,
0.38041555881500244,
0.5243281722068787,
0.28417152166366577,
-0.8664524555206299,
-0.6227855086326599,
0.24550007283687592,
-0.3192662298679352,
-0.225922092795372,
1.2204095125198364,
-0.5670648813247681,
0.043822288513183594,
0.10315753519535065,
0.5096946954727173,
0.2652365565299988,
0.1875755786895752,
0.672040581703186,
-0.447273313999176,
0.020650850608944893,
0.25487154722213745,
0.4336301386356354,
-0.01801794394850731,
-0.4544743001461029,
0.2349577695131302,
-0.027486557140946388,
-0.8948202133178711,
-0.7127111554145813,
0.4279386103153229,
-1.2010587453842163,
0.17403796315193176,
1.4798294305801392,
-0.23888829350471497,
-0.27578577399253845,
-0.11452827602624893,
-0.3092030882835388,
0.0915752649307251,
-0.9091936945915222,
0.8918511867523193,
1.0446133613586426,
-0.23559825122356415,
-0.020365489646792412,
-0.4070377051830292,
0.5376954674720764,
0.058851297944784164,
-0.7561217546463013,
0.08545634895563126,
0.31935590505599976,
0.503803014755249,
-0.0034213808830827475,
0.9671669602394104,
-0.014793691225349903,
0.27425116300582886,
-0.10044461488723755,
-0.01653764583170414,
-0.1606777310371399,
-0.01589263416826725,
0.053771305829286575,
-0.04172421991825104,
0.5947163105010986,
0.3146481513977051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04542v1 | Share What You Already Know: Cross-Language-Script Transfer and Alignment for Sentiment Detection in Code-Mixed Data | 2024-02-07T02:59:18 | 2024-02-07T02:59:18 | Niraj Pahari, Kazutaka Shimada | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code-switching entails mixing multiple languages. It is an increasingly
occurring phenomenon in social media texts. Usually, code-mixed texts are
written in a single script, even though the languages involved have different
scripts. Pre-trained multilingual models primarily utilize the data in the
native script of the language. In existing studies, the code-switched texts are
utilized as they are. However, using the native script for each language can
generate better representations of the text owing to the pre-trained knowledge.
Therefore, a cross-language-script knowledge sharing architecture utilizing the
cross attention and alignment of the representations of text in individual
language scripts was proposed in this study. Experimental results on two
different datasets containing Nepali-English and Hindi-English code-switched
texts, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method. The interpretation
of the model using model explainability technique illustrates the sharing of
language-specific knowledge between language-specific representations. | [
-0.3258693814277649,
-0.33541610836982727,
0.3236849009990692,
0.5975737571716309,
-0.38173243403434753,
0.640324056148529,
-0.28504154086112976,
-0.45691394805908203,
0.43809959292411804,
0.3066653907299042,
-0.3267759084701538,
-0.75009685754776,
-0.6618938446044922,
0.04870613291859627,
-0.6000692248344421,
1.3748149871826172,
-0.4438057243824005,
0.22824127972126007,
-0.17276020348072052,
-0.32783418893814087,
-0.1727512776851654,
-0.585956335067749,
-0.25628381967544556,
-0.08412709832191467,
0.5476040840148926,
0.3400316536426544,
0.8014031648635864,
0.23021981120109558,
0.6281492710113525,
0.1853559911251068,
0.3705458641052246,
-0.032994676381349564,
-0.21022042632102966,
-0.2140360325574875,
-0.2484012246131897,
-0.6323930025100708,
-0.488042414188385,
-0.2443917840719223,
0.29669007658958435,
0.4618947207927704,
0.040641266852617264,
0.10099416226148605,
0.04348348081111908,
0.42759039998054504,
-0.569646954536438,
0.11514335125684738,
-0.48484501242637634,
0.17653316259384155,
0.0629316121339798,
-0.39042580127716064,
-0.32743340730667114,
-0.6567422151565552,
0.11973276734352112,
-0.49258917570114136,
-0.0534505657851696,
-0.2084590494632721,
0.7108684778213501,
0.15236037969589233,
-0.17804071307182312,
-0.32072943449020386,
-0.5065970420837402,
0.9649608135223389,
-0.635782778263092,
0.24160553514957428,
0.3427976667881012,
0.24872708320617676,
0.6379252672195435,
-0.30092716217041016,
-0.8300032615661621,
0.43749701976776123,
-0.30625587701797485,
0.27745887637138367,
-0.21247225999832153,
-0.478280246257782,
-0.23214660584926605,
0.21182601153850555,
-0.491631418466568,
-0.2657151222229004,
-0.18473170697689056,
-0.29879167675971985,
0.5828821063041687,
-0.15027549862861633,
0.7699981927871704,
-0.3117961287498474,
-0.6139681339263916,
-0.026277830824255943,
-0.4498656988143921,
0.07239069044589996,
0.4298265278339386,
0.38076311349868774,
-0.5871486663818359,
0.405204713344574,
-0.10763247311115265,
0.49840283393859863,
0.11845001578330994,
0.11006557196378708,
0.6227900981903076,
-0.6585658192634583,
-0.23083269596099854,
0.16674764454364777,
0.8801878690719604,
0.583833634853363,
0.6434905529022217,
-0.19350771605968475,
-0.09625856578350067,
0.4490993916988373,
0.183432474732399,
-0.4240969121456146,
0.0762573853135109,
-0.006379039958119392,
-0.760363757610321,
-0.4668756425380707,
-0.06237921118736267,
-1.0282405614852905,
-0.40601566433906555,
-0.27980270981788635,
0.22866474092006683,
-0.4003532826900482,
-0.7796803116798401,
0.29760032892227173,
-0.0367622934281826,
0.4763021469116211,
0.17000606656074524,
-0.8063209652900696,
0.03686515986919403,
0.46965542435646057,
0.7322770357131958,
-0.5513253211975098,
-0.46637648344039917,
-0.07165796309709549,
0.07432978600263596,
-0.10865817219018936,
0.8610057830810547,
-0.7146031856536865,
-0.26426348090171814,
0.3584999740123749,
-0.06807398796081543,
-0.22474543750286102,
-0.28697723150253296,
0.16022369265556335,
-0.6288761496543884,
0.29200732707977295,
-0.1393386870622635,
-0.1589164435863495,
-0.037656087428331375,
0.38951918482780457,
-0.5576956868171692,
0.9700264930725098,
0.13261999189853668,
-1.043821096420288,
0.37486565113067627,
-0.2844093143939972,
-0.777642548084259,
-0.26471108198165894,
-0.13045787811279297,
-0.3665095269680023,
-0.1753002554178238,
0.3995022773742676,
0.5898434519767761,
0.0035846817772835493,
0.054730117321014404,
-0.3421916365623474,
-0.36608269810676575,
0.5262742042541504,
-0.09113523364067078,
0.6245760917663574,
0.435667484998703,
-0.17742955684661865,
0.10323610156774521,
-0.587579607963562,
0.19204121828079224,
-0.12356744706630707,
-0.3042161464691162,
-0.46789902448654175,
-0.2509654760360718,
0.28319865465164185,
0.4899083077907562,
0.4752764105796814,
-0.3742314875125885,
0.12154177576303482,
-0.08032160997390747,
-0.005703881848603487,
0.35917359590530396,
-0.03293519839644432,
0.7856087684631348,
-0.30968326330184937,
0.854599118232727,
0.42162787914276123,
0.2413414865732193,
-0.059443842619657516,
-0.26679912209510803,
-0.6921899914741516,
0.06265299767255783,
0.05172136798501015,
0.6598610877990723,
-1.0202093124389648,
0.2548792064189911,
-0.12319865822792053,
-0.14643442630767822,
-1.1279035806655884,
0.29564809799194336,
0.38971737027168274,
0.015178125351667404,
0.47375306487083435,
-0.3547603487968445,
-0.7041484117507935,
-0.7703498601913452,
-0.6958919167518616,
-0.12655772268772125,
0.3807520568370819,
-0.22355180978775024,
0.10679438710212708,
-0.3547908365726471,
0.9385219216346741,
-0.37512335181236267,
-0.07358935475349426,
-0.7628946900367737,
0.13591434061527252,
0.09168968349695206,
0.36925506591796875,
0.4402613937854767,
-0.960347056388855,
-1.1550496816635132,
0.37047141790390015,
-0.7903521060943604,
-0.23598188161849976,
-0.27527010440826416,
-0.4458613097667694,
0.4641764461994171,
0.5573457479476929,
-0.2501063644886017,
0.49795112013816833,
0.8872617483139038,
-0.0454525388777256,
0.25072360038757324,
0.2816345989704132,
0.49223458766937256,
-1.4774954319000244,
-0.060319796204566956,
0.18138112127780914,
-0.3582861125469208,
-0.499644935131073,
-0.2781919538974762,
0.12949956953525543,
0.1340121626853943,
-0.469938725233078,
0.3298608958721161,
-0.4578724801540375,
-0.1689681112766266,
-0.2472739964723587,
0.08471625298261642,
0.11257725954055786,
0.7738342881202698,
0.3354753255844116,
0.5930972695350647,
0.7011653184890747,
-0.20022831857204437,
0.03119506873190403,
0.0778120830655098,
-0.3132057785987854,
0.7844944596290588,
-0.350302517414093,
0.1310119926929474,
0.002117822878062725,
-0.05515633895993233,
-1.0359508991241455,
0.12618833780288696,
0.3185502290725708,
-0.7843149304389954,
0.1609192043542862,
-0.34133291244506836,
-0.3136604428291321,
0.1750299036502838,
-0.35015615820884705,
0.4979035258293152,
0.4726791977882385,
-0.5259848237037659,
0.5301622748374939,
0.5016389489173889,
-0.23737163841724396,
-0.7231943011283875,
-0.9819886088371277,
-0.0473717637360096,
-0.23993059992790222,
-0.496012419462204,
0.0906081274151802,
0.10892204940319061,
-0.17086397111415863,
0.22423742711544037,
-0.02906746417284012,
-0.30752092599868774,
-0.46204182505607605,
0.11989680677652359,
0.37965288758277893,
-0.1549927443265915,
0.14859382808208466,
0.2477508783340454,
-0.067554771900177,
0.062047723680734634,
-0.18073254823684692,
0.7449074983596802,
-0.0663900077342987,
-0.2797936797142029,
-0.43398863077163696,
0.6870209574699402,
0.5029398202896118,
-0.47594547271728516,
0.8057641386985779,
0.7952581644058228,
-0.18800923228263855,
-0.3147667348384857,
-0.1985156089067459,
0.3425322473049164,
-0.39063364267349243,
0.26237252354621887,
-0.2567116618156433,
-0.568205714225769,
0.6392144560813904,
0.001894388347864151,
-0.1629374772310257,
0.12490376085042953,
0.7468115091323853,
-0.057254694402217865,
1.2439111471176147,
0.9130632877349854,
-0.43154215812683105,
0.7452523112297058,
0.07707292586565018,
0.6850944757461548,
-0.426517128944397,
-0.08590022474527359,
-0.43795695900917053,
-0.25229722261428833,
-0.45116278529167175,
-0.5734608769416809,
-0.0423470214009285,
0.009401051327586174,
0.061092559248209,
0.4803616404533386,
-0.45227742195129395,
0.475403368473053,
0.04665621370077133,
0.07722439616918564,
0.5307999849319458,
0.3577097952365875,
0.12987472116947174,
-0.018091000616550446,
-0.5800150036811829,
-0.3596133887767792,
0.9814502596855164,
0.13911674916744232,
1.20648992061615,
-0.08032699674367905,
0.8222690224647522,
0.4075475335121155,
0.29351097345352173,
-0.6252498626708984,
0.35830798745155334,
-0.05754372850060463,
-0.23805786669254303,
0.10696692764759064,
-0.3442075550556183,
-0.6499228477478027,
0.18390291929244995,
0.05405327305197716,
-0.4560239911079407,
0.1688399314880371,
-0.10791590809822083,
-0.07486804574728012,
0.18791238963603973,
-0.9351938366889954,
0.8542188405990601,
-0.20156274735927582,
-0.18920548260211945,
-0.3396541178226471,
-0.7092252373695374,
0.1633385270833969,
-0.08380882441997528,
0.4523865878582001,
0.1851196587085724,
0.2228965014219284,
0.6081313490867615,
-0.08358489722013474,
1.1075719594955444,
0.023926911875605583,
-0.2821738123893738,
0.38904237747192383,
0.040902938693761826,
0.29154160618782043,
0.03177591785788536,
-0.05934601649641991,
0.17488993704319,
-0.06463035196065903,
-0.37456613779067993,
-0.5381938219070435,
0.8092986941337585,
-0.9364832043647766,
-0.155973881483078,
-0.3315606713294983,
-0.5939866900444031,
-0.36233747005462646,
0.20624707639217377,
0.21062734723091125,
0.1826326996088028,
0.017394423484802246,
-0.1278289407491684,
0.5668205618858337,
-0.4138742685317993,
0.3066931962966919,
0.5129022002220154,
-0.5417209267616272,
-0.1497817039489746,
0.9815484881401062,
-0.1835109144449234,
0.547330379486084,
0.5564456582069397,
-0.08347894251346588,
-0.13995914161205292,
-0.15343979001045227,
-0.45791059732437134,
0.06683096289634705,
-0.951140284538269,
-0.2274421900510788,
-0.9007425308227539,
-0.098991259932518,
-0.48642680048942566,
-0.548627495765686,
-0.2814379334449768,
-0.23580659925937653,
-0.009820297360420227,
-0.14042219519615173,
0.4899582862854004,
0.5251955389976501,
0.039033468812704086,
0.41671642661094666,
-0.9090596437454224,
0.3941533863544464,
-0.038453612476587296,
0.46734756231307983,
0.06414027512073517,
-0.19902242720127106,
-0.603602409362793,
0.17008253931999207,
0.09913855046033859,
-1.175742268562317,
0.4934995770454407,
-0.17162346839904785,
0.45288994908332825,
0.14407560229301453,
-0.005804847460240126,
0.4710502326488495,
0.10897006839513779,
0.4253264367580414,
0.4065830409526825,
-1.2412300109863281,
0.441596657037735,
-0.31965169310569763,
0.3565443754196167,
0.7197400331497192,
0.5634680986404419,
-0.9033973217010498,
-0.6606960296630859,
-0.27436724305152893,
-0.6462414860725403,
0.725721001625061,
-0.07675707340240479,
0.1562408059835434,
0.019644739106297493,
-0.047203145921230316,
0.34362688660621643,
0.23206327855587006,
-1.0740022659301758,
-0.020411495119333267,
-0.3906027376651764,
-0.793079137802124,
0.3320101201534271,
0.2829030156135559,
-0.019493993371725082,
-0.27931249141693115,
0.2410135567188263,
-0.2887840270996094,
0.2785361409187317,
0.06309451907873154,
-0.5735438466072083,
-0.26919519901275635,
0.4199935793876648,
-0.08217271417379379,
0.4713824689388275,
0.07921873778104782,
0.31359317898750305,
0.03241046145558357,
-0.3657136857509613,
-0.20292840898036957,
-0.25421619415283203,
-0.11792958527803421,
-0.023205136880278587,
0.30838555097579956,
0.6944377422332764,
0.21754367649555206,
-0.43253058195114136,
0.5870334506034851,
-0.16882789134979248,
0.11078710108995438,
0.15569402277469635,
-0.19998764991760254,
0.3465420603752136,
0.18819618225097656,
-0.019404269754886627,
0.46046745777130127,
-0.04292367398738861,
-0.8419557809829712,
0.18628136813640594,
0.2873859703540802,
-0.5535522699356079,
-0.4315212368965149,
0.12182112038135529,
0.31702205538749695,
-0.1114175096154213,
0.15959960222244263,
-0.009856986813247204,
-0.8594011068344116,
0.6542178392410278,
0.5506341457366943,
0.7644577622413635,
-0.13326174020767212,
0.6876940131187439,
0.07078161090612411,
0.09282558411359787,
0.05254003033041954,
0.44000810384750366,
-0.28078997135162354,
-1.0303661823272705,
-0.3797151446342468,
-0.5754467844963074,
-0.2789444029331207,
-0.49423032999038696,
-1.0084726810455322,
0.4245584309101105,
-0.3730369806289673,
0.09299223870038986,
-0.06545834243297577,
-0.2474580705165863,
-0.7663676142692566,
0.21506310999393463,
0.03851687163114548,
0.5239555239677429,
-1.0425337553024292,
1.1671581268310547,
0.8258099555969238,
-0.6813048124313354,
-0.8143988251686096,
0.31230512261390686,
-0.2318452149629593,
-1.3784719705581665,
0.4539811611175537,
0.08464697003364563,
-0.3529064953327179,
-0.19874893128871918,
-0.4879973232746124,
-0.6019256114959717,
0.6872058510780334,
-0.14196395874023438,
-0.35696056485176086,
0.3082375228404999,
0.37305545806884766,
0.9172393083572388,
-0.6152050495147705,
0.101972296833992,
0.5492433905601501,
0.33397048711776733,
-0.10168507695198059,
-0.7818793058395386,
0.036100804805755615,
-0.48023784160614014,
-0.39279887080192566,
0.346659392118454,
-0.6075944900512695,
0.6528759002685547,
-0.1695602387189865,
-0.30621403455734253,
-0.33177217841148376,
0.4065451920032501,
-0.07073409855365753,
0.4762275815010071,
0.5059888362884521,
0.3782651126384735,
0.21519647538661957,
0.2461181879043579,
1.0675482749938965,
-0.5199018120765686,
0.4159701466560364,
0.8379221558570862,
-0.717219889163971,
0.9323434829711914,
0.7317298054695129,
-0.13755133748054504,
0.787634551525116,
0.2686004638671875,
0.1798323690891266,
0.6966496109962463,
-0.03618249297142029,
-0.17038968205451965,
-0.22253049910068512,
-0.21200518310070038,
-0.4646594226360321,
0.2612227201461792,
0.1229889988899231,
-0.40323323011398315,
-0.20101583003997803,
-0.02021869271993637,
0.27258241176605225,
0.1786787360906601,
-0.1966080665588379,
0.925029456615448,
0.08890960365533829,
-0.9028096795082092,
0.40430745482444763,
-0.18824593722820282,
1.051087498664856,
-0.6522701382637024,
0.04332013428211212,
-0.37417536973953247,
0.35803160071372986,
-0.627794086933136,
-1.1745597124099731,
0.6158729791641235,
0.24433296918869019,
-0.3464413583278656,
-0.6551367044448853,
0.8748133778572083,
-0.9543932676315308,
-0.49875903129577637,
0.7936662435531616,
0.6460495591163635,
-0.020619085058569908,
0.1300230622291565,
-0.6104075312614441,
0.28747236728668213,
0.37104886770248413,
0.1275610476732254,
0.578058660030365,
0.5078867673873901,
-0.15629678964614868,
0.2678525149822235,
0.5526412725448608,
0.12018688023090363,
0.20514076948165894,
0.5173255205154419,
0.8874635100364685,
-0.540174663066864,
-0.6975241303443909,
-0.7442667484283447,
0.3404943645000458,
-0.20416980981826782,
-0.2027769684791565,
0.9628169536590576,
0.3266974091529846,
0.9231351017951965,
-0.1954498589038849,
1.34112548828125,
-0.09284307062625885,
0.4892335534095764,
-0.41675662994384766,
0.9487626552581787,
-0.6075878143310547,
0.14833684265613556,
-0.584965705871582,
-0.8190330266952515,
-0.2581568658351898,
0.6096624732017517,
-0.2913137376308441,
-0.0694781094789505,
0.8156768679618835,
0.8420649170875549,
-0.11526007950305939,
0.01814338006079197,
0.06242043524980545,
-0.1360270380973816,
0.06463731825351715,
0.8865378499031067,
0.9851376414299011,
-0.3921002745628357,
0.8080158233642578,
-0.014397845603525639,
-0.2657258212566376,
0.007545085623860359,
-0.6547433137893677,
-0.955546498298645,
-0.36256468296051025,
-0.488810271024704,
-0.41764816641807556,
-0.013544213958084583,
0.6750701665878296,
0.44470417499542236,
-0.7678066492080688,
-0.3024452328681946,
0.09640689939260483,
0.41077473759651184,
-0.18011625111103058,
-0.272137850522995,
0.2641012370586395,
-0.27501368522644043,
-0.7141430377960205,
-0.07470211386680603,
0.379427433013916,
-0.22943444550037384,
-0.2549283802509308,
-0.051874447613954544,
-0.36266613006591797,
0.1634320169687271,
0.3941302001476288,
0.14718672633171082,
-0.1681639701128006,
-0.1687450259923935,
0.1904970109462738,
-0.5629025101661682,
0.19599048793315887,
1.250582218170166,
-0.5995440483093262,
0.3667353689670563,
0.9330695867538452,
0.72687828540802,
0.27567994594573975,
-0.06392773985862732,
0.6826006770133972,
-0.846206784248352,
0.14692682027816772,
0.020948927849531174,
0.3712430000305176,
0.5482447743415833,
-0.529591977596283,
0.1548888087272644,
0.07200981676578522,
-0.28833773732185364,
-0.5526866316795349,
0.19392602145671844,
-1.2546350955963135,
-0.21719959378242493,
1.3315544128417969,
-0.19027628004550934,
-0.17961385846138,
-0.3429885506629944,
-0.37640973925590515,
0.48098742961883545,
-0.5354081988334656,
0.8252852559089661,
0.7290719151496887,
0.09423545747995377,
-0.2516751289367676,
-0.1679295003414154,
0.5269818902015686,
0.5587289929389954,
-1.1871817111968994,
0.058989375829696655,
-0.007210562936961651,
0.31118834018707275,
0.1986168622970581,
0.8306912183761597,
-0.46683797240257263,
0.2153398096561432,
-0.20778898894786835,
0.4709148108959198,
0.43145158886909485,
-0.23617680370807648,
-0.3653869330883026,
0.035104237496852875,
-0.38805636763572693,
-0.27267178893089294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04523v1 | SumRec: A Framework for Recommendation using Open-Domain Dialogue | 2024-02-07T02:06:48 | 2024-02-07T02:06:48 | Ryutaro Asahara, Masaki Takahashi, Chiho Iwahashi, Michimasa Inaba | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Chat dialogues contain considerable useful information about a speaker's
interests, preferences, and experiences.Thus, knowledge from open-domain chat
dialogue can be used to personalize various systems and offer recommendations
for advanced information.This study proposed a novel framework SumRec for
recommending information from open-domain chat dialogue.The study also examined
the framework using ChatRec, a newly constructed dataset for training and
evaluation. To extract the speaker and item characteristics, the SumRec
framework employs a large language model (LLM) to generate a summary of the
speaker information from a dialogue and to recommend information about an item
according to the type of user.The speaker and item information are then input
into a score estimation model, generating a recommendation score.Experimental
results show that the SumRec framework provides better recommendations than the
baseline method of using dialogues and item descriptions in their original
form. Our dataset and code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Ryutaro-A/SumRec | [
-0.5760063529014587,
-0.37680384516716003,
0.1181013211607933,
0.08120696246623993,
-0.05780710279941559,
-0.10778627544641495,
-0.2788824439048767,
-0.2946352958679199,
0.4574621617794037,
0.6416847705841064,
-0.7376839518547058,
-0.4181031584739685,
-0.19617629051208496,
-0.21324342489242554,
-0.24191974103450775,
1.2113091945648193,
0.22933299839496613,
0.04668625816702843,
-0.44036203622817993,
-0.28361615538597107,
-0.7080967426300049,
-0.5570401549339294,
-0.46144700050354004,
-0.37182822823524475,
0.3649824559688568,
0.7921842336654663,
0.625274121761322,
-0.05738890543580055,
0.5215538740158081,
0.23560144007205963,
0.08691632747650146,
0.37083175778388977,
-1.0183905363082886,
0.4190118610858917,
-0.2040090709924698,
-0.30945688486099243,
-0.523847758769989,
-0.11458228528499603,
0.32943347096443176,
0.6988418698310852,
-0.37363702058792114,
-0.033256806433200836,
-0.029315609484910965,
0.6969439387321472,
-0.8403333425521851,
0.2905280590057373,
-0.45127353072166443,
-0.021544568240642548,
0.07248689979314804,
-0.47861000895500183,
-0.5753337144851685,
-0.3669641315937042,
0.5247321128845215,
-0.5395636558532715,
-0.08723217248916626,
0.25797238945961,
0.41757699847221375,
-0.2603282928466797,
-0.12453187257051468,
-0.3140813410282135,
-1.088974118232727,
0.7237499952316284,
-0.6262731552124023,
0.3795343041419983,
0.7386623620986938,
0.7125826478004456,
-0.17815740406513214,
-0.38693416118621826,
-0.1311647891998291,
-0.19754530489444733,
0.05220871418714523,
0.3358089029788971,
-0.10379382222890854,
-0.14249113202095032,
0.004147414583712816,
0.7150277495384216,
-0.508842408657074,
-0.22240208089351654,
-0.23988816142082214,
-0.0568743534386158,
0.357945054769516,
0.1964644491672516,
0.2533279061317444,
0.42604613304138184,
-0.3954196870326996,
0.04837707802653313,
-0.575509250164032,
-0.04168783128261566,
0.4262615442276001,
0.4977025091648102,
-0.14357244968414307,
0.6946365237236023,
-0.58057701587677,
0.7385404109954834,
-0.15738072991371155,
-0.07068177312612534,
0.0963258296251297,
-0.3389613926410675,
-0.08288846164941788,
0.03897185996174812,
0.5944716930389404,
0.9228608012199402,
0.8396521210670471,
-0.13540790975093842,
0.04506003484129906,
-0.3995821475982666,
0.08837340027093887,
-0.8710026144981384,
-0.4196505844593048,
-0.11318819969892502,
-0.572421133518219,
-0.2953875958919525,
0.3599551022052765,
-0.673899233341217,
-0.4965423047542572,
-0.05673534795641899,
0.17677131295204163,
-0.49552223086357117,
-0.1654210239648819,
0.1696084439754486,
-0.059211261570453644,
-0.03662066534161568,
0.5761973857879639,
-1.0209418535232544,
0.7624239325523376,
0.28969502449035645,
1.0067758560180664,
-0.18695519864559174,
0.05086975172162056,
-0.6708869338035583,
-0.01347380131483078,
-0.09079801291227341,
1.1544753313064575,
-0.8794246315956116,
-0.657997727394104,
0.13370420038700104,
-0.0791357234120369,
0.02108176238834858,
-0.38012245297431946,
0.12694546580314636,
-0.4547887444496155,
0.585307776927948,
0.10169229656457901,
-0.6070184111595154,
-0.309747576713562,
-0.028773833066225052,
-0.6668224334716797,
0.6528705358505249,
0.5083057284355164,
-0.8096718788146973,
0.11175209283828735,
-0.8268200755119324,
-0.4656616747379303,
0.43816113471984863,
-0.018018405884504318,
0.13489176332950592,
-0.2832554876804352,
0.293695330619812,
0.43187108635902405,
-0.5669304728507996,
0.11143632978200912,
-0.47283682227134705,
-0.3930523693561554,
0.4348941743373871,
-0.2250431478023529,
0.34784039855003357,
0.3628697395324707,
0.12198353558778763,
0.19539481401443481,
-0.6055659055709839,
-0.08107227087020874,
-0.1729203164577484,
-0.07870804518461227,
-0.4730934798717499,
0.1514161378145218,
0.04108797386288643,
-0.14781661331653595,
0.05392812192440033,
-0.378505140542984,
-0.03028109297156334,
-0.7622066736221313,
0.2066555917263031,
0.741561770439148,
0.3356170058250427,
0.5562009215354919,
-0.6031728386878967,
0.456412672996521,
-0.31845372915267944,
-0.11460054665803909,
-0.6932167410850525,
-0.6766571402549744,
-0.562554121017456,
-0.25417831540107727,
0.30114108324050903,
0.6669322848320007,
-0.4285825192928314,
0.6434096097946167,
-0.04986342415213585,
-0.231938436627388,
-0.13008944690227509,
-0.13301198184490204,
0.14901097118854523,
0.318248987197876,
0.1920645534992218,
-0.5762090682983398,
-0.7434350252151489,
-0.744333803653717,
-0.03708840161561966,
-0.47137781977653503,
-0.365138977766037,
0.8365849256515503,
0.15130746364593506,
-0.13726463913917542,
1.1199333667755127,
-0.8944481015205383,
-0.5616017580032349,
-0.34971165657043457,
-0.3008037507534027,
0.2311597466468811,
0.16161412000656128,
0.5535550117492676,
-0.4309428036212921,
-0.3061845302581787,
-0.06846735626459122,
-0.38250407576560974,
-0.051015619188547134,
0.11609075963497162,
-0.33908066153526306,
-0.2554180920124054,
0.11782144010066986,
-0.06422856450080872,
0.5331388711929321,
0.4229920208454132,
-0.3455127477645874,
0.3633231818675995,
-0.19438600540161133,
0.4931323528289795,
-1.3769959211349487,
0.007414096966385841,
0.08848297595977783,
-0.34737616777420044,
-0.4214405417442322,
-0.4394923150539398,
-0.5305420756340027,
-0.2356904298067093,
-0.2864486873149872,
0.815933346748352,
0.19580817222595215,
0.1411014199256897,
-0.2753853499889374,
0.4569721221923828,
-0.049955759197473526,
0.6858013868331909,
0.0604248121380806,
0.6526435613632202,
0.3417871296405792,
-0.7289720177650452,
0.5223127603530884,
0.6528816819190979,
-0.7058204412460327,
0.7862681150436401,
-0.6109671592712402,
0.09902834892272949,
0.3586820065975189,
0.3629300594329834,
-1.2257052659988403,
-0.13809438049793243,
0.16749389469623566,
-0.45812010765075684,
-0.13026827573776245,
-0.18641220033168793,
-0.15871880948543549,
0.18749217689037323,
-0.22258983552455902,
0.44461262226104736,
0.31178778409957886,
-0.43541568517684937,
0.507587194442749,
0.6942268013954163,
-0.4224364161491394,
-0.3221878111362457,
-0.3093055486679077,
-0.07034743577241898,
0.11239296197891235,
-0.7352136969566345,
0.3370611071586609,
-0.6141862273216248,
-0.26279395818710327,
-0.20899386703968048,
0.11999782919883728,
-0.06262031942605972,
-0.03853428363800049,
0.588710606098175,
0.3328751027584076,
-0.22821684181690216,
0.18297134339809418,
-0.3290644586086273,
-0.2139418125152588,
-0.34750857949256897,
-0.5067000985145569,
0.5984823107719421,
-0.2592233121395111,
-0.37468022108078003,
-0.12944428622722626,
0.5212413668632507,
0.30738767981529236,
-0.054997365921735764,
0.700273334980011,
0.343669593334198,
-0.2744489908218384,
-0.05796936899423599,
-0.5084987878799438,
-0.38435468077659607,
-0.41671478748321533,
0.3259086012840271,
-0.25967636704444885,
-1.136873483657837,
0.3887648582458496,
-0.2775552570819855,
0.23065201938152313,
0.3336946368217468,
0.9637741446495056,
-0.12140951305627823,
0.8958257436752319,
0.66302090883255,
-0.29342809319496155,
0.7178688645362854,
-0.241605743765831,
0.22064240276813507,
-0.729442834854126,
-0.27379676699638367,
-0.4952322244644165,
-0.13845308125019073,
-0.17632775008678436,
-0.3312712013721466,
-0.07650651782751083,
0.01699916459619999,
-0.20061160624027252,
0.3319019079208374,
-0.15369397401809692,
0.5592686533927917,
0.657029390335083,
0.1271577924489975,
0.27799758315086365,
0.014948015101253986,
-0.4010240435600281,
0.1825009286403656,
-0.5190833806991577,
-0.3500635623931885,
0.9223683476448059,
0.294139564037323,
1.0725871324539185,
0.21286320686340332,
0.12222001701593399,
0.6557374000549316,
0.013835919089615345,
-1.0375734567642212,
0.626034140586853,
-0.17711633443832397,
-0.315662145614624,
-0.2646048069000244,
-0.4488905370235443,
-0.7027222514152527,
-0.061904214322566986,
-0.2459837794303894,
-1.1690839529037476,
0.09836767613887787,
-0.17674554884433746,
-0.2703914940357208,
0.21218405663967133,
-0.4174812436103821,
0.5516341328620911,
-0.04627206549048424,
0.10993079096078873,
-0.41826435923576355,
-0.40105947852134705,
0.26030293107032776,
0.06455003470182419,
0.15897011756896973,
-0.422742635011673,
0.3849114775657654,
1.022473931312561,
-0.49731191992759705,
0.8164083361625671,
-0.1746647208929062,
0.05786504969000816,
0.3529703915119171,
0.37583595514297485,
0.3647421598434448,
0.17200365662574768,
-0.09924357384443283,
0.04653054103255272,
0.01782076247036457,
0.07190465927124023,
-0.8321437239646912,
0.7500345706939697,
-0.8060992360115051,
-0.27600836753845215,
-0.059829164296388626,
-0.3931402564048767,
-0.5351132750511169,
0.11009371280670166,
-0.03725067153573036,
0.785607099533081,
-0.697920024394989,
0.583583652973175,
0.5570479035377502,
-0.30104294419288635,
0.04013627767562866,
0.8581292629241943,
-0.3088156282901764,
-0.7968865036964417,
0.8265189528465271,
-0.4282752275466919,
0.04958830773830414,
0.7951908707618713,
0.31890127062797546,
-0.16233007609844208,
-0.21663063764572144,
-0.3454299867153168,
-0.03223004937171936,
-0.7580965161323547,
-0.31868937611579895,
-0.4762413203716278,
-0.2114575207233429,
-0.456282377243042,
0.042667828500270844,
-0.116129070520401,
-0.7362239360809326,
-0.18241530656814575,
-0.1162261962890625,
0.6316680908203125,
0.63872891664505,
0.2558205723762512,
0.48616674542427063,
-0.6556123495101929,
0.3090028166770935,
0.24451640248298645,
0.7962848544120789,
-0.06063239276409149,
-0.7196569442749023,
-0.7012943029403687,
0.13397391140460968,
-0.19036640226840973,
-0.5949582457542419,
0.202778160572052,
0.5234512090682983,
0.8238194584846497,
0.8200263381004333,
0.44908657670021057,
0.36484214663505554,
-0.4486943185329437,
0.7392354011535645,
0.27718061208724976,
-0.5560450553894043,
0.6580080389976501,
-0.32155075669288635,
0.4804289937019348,
0.5686728358268738,
0.2801041603088379,
-0.744992196559906,
-0.31337884068489075,
-0.42671793699264526,
-0.7088444232940674,
0.935791015625,
0.3927833139896393,
-0.04508811980485916,
0.15420077741146088,
0.07180581986904144,
0.2547247111797333,
0.23118716478347778,
-0.19346927106380463,
-0.16913896799087524,
-0.1870822310447693,
-0.21976840496063232,
-0.11353936046361923,
-0.40833741426467896,
-0.353492796421051,
0.264593243598938,
0.7808235287666321,
-0.2688552439212799,
0.48085516691207886,
-0.12163504213094711,
-0.023564191535115242,
-0.283377468585968,
0.11474260687828064,
0.7116725444793701,
0.5130776762962341,
-0.40907570719718933,
-0.31660571694374084,
0.1598822921514511,
-0.3274473547935486,
-0.15428467094898224,
-0.18063341081142426,
0.30667221546173096,
-0.2614920139312744,
0.29205721616744995,
0.9581474661827087,
0.5325812101364136,
-0.9466156363487244,
0.586823582649231,
-0.5093451142311096,
-0.35833168029785156,
-0.33244040608406067,
0.25067010521888733,
-0.08013731241226196,
0.1446024775505066,
0.18983101844787598,
0.42169424891471863,
0.19454285502433777,
-0.3474341630935669,
0.3764594793319702,
0.2497909963130951,
-0.7766072154045105,
-0.15934813022613525,
0.2778525650501251,
0.5770273804664612,
-0.4004842936992645,
0.6343449354171753,
0.6107439994812012,
-0.20898394286632538,
-0.053288742899894714,
0.4046509563922882,
1.130635380744934,
-0.4191606044769287,
0.30486392974853516,
0.19096210598945618,
-0.17203639447689056,
0.007362833246588707,
-0.03805427998304367,
-0.5231227874755859,
-0.9747271537780762,
-0.3866744637489319,
-0.6101993322372437,
-0.8797917366027832,
-0.18972595036029816,
-0.5281260013580322,
0.40112945437431335,
-0.4046051800251007,
-0.09841509908437729,
-0.1518799215555191,
-0.1647646278142929,
-0.48330602049827576,
0.03635580092668533,
0.02974969521164894,
0.7360633015632629,
-0.6147700548171997,
0.5282276272773743,
0.5372722744941711,
-0.28753337264060974,
-0.5834293961524963,
-0.31970253586769104,
-0.02452663518488407,
-0.7379140853881836,
0.3298901319503784,
-0.04792391508817673,
-0.5301942229270935,
-0.33748340606689453,
-0.1826067566871643,
-0.7297492027282715,
0.7856544852256775,
0.31545042991638184,
-0.33376726508140564,
0.15877772867679596,
-0.14888429641723633,
0.4801565408706665,
-1.0730352401733398,
1.0563443899154663,
0.05399295687675476,
0.15538527071475983,
0.8323361277580261,
-0.9442625641822815,
-0.18962667882442474,
-0.634124755859375,
-0.16563980281352997,
0.039106789976358414,
-0.5161364674568176,
0.46578249335289,
-0.3984684944152832,
-0.22097444534301758,
0.2231653481721878,
0.4993073642253876,
0.06437458097934723,
0.1665233075618744,
0.47154614329338074,
0.07740746438503265,
0.5893834829330444,
0.11398368328809738,
0.806373119354248,
-0.3384917378425598,
0.05008290708065033,
1.5552934408187866,
-0.5014257431030273,
0.897975504398346,
-0.19142942130565643,
-0.17389631271362305,
0.9763860702514648,
0.7473940849304199,
-0.015107041224837303,
0.6602365374565125,
0.09413287788629532,
-0.19278083741664886,
-0.03366414085030556,
-0.12359995394945145,
-0.24657993018627167,
0.2598312795162201,
0.40131598711013794,
-0.30843597650527954,
-0.23580336570739746,
0.12842747569084167,
-0.4007260799407959,
-0.12711182236671448,
0.011031809262931347,
1.4437496662139893,
0.038872264325618744,
-0.4715622365474701,
0.4762464761734009,
0.03253410384058952,
0.3087046146392822,
-0.7986552119255066,
-0.3513224124908447,
-0.2505636513233185,
0.2736053764820099,
-0.2569080591201782,
-0.6153392791748047,
-0.12973710894584656,
-0.12870855629444122,
-0.30912554264068604,
-0.17847058176994324,
0.8305262327194214,
-0.4048820436000824,
-0.16149631142616272,
0.16271519660949707,
0.39174360036849976,
0.4074413776397705,
-0.09832088649272919,
-0.3459462821483612,
-0.4163312315940857,
0.1472874879837036,
-0.033160727471113205,
0.49097564816474915,
0.32742801308631897,
0.02878355048596859,
0.9377413392066956,
0.6060518026351929,
0.10048679262399673,
-0.6710127592086792,
0.6196420192718506,
0.8916990160942078,
-0.5805559158325195,
-0.7834251523017883,
-0.5192795991897583,
0.3486124575138092,
-0.036289237439632416,
-0.18383675813674927,
0.593707263469696,
0.6806417107582092,
0.8008294701576233,
-0.08827690780162811,
0.8736121654510498,
0.19740618765354156,
0.789535403251648,
-0.2748740613460541,
0.496471107006073,
-0.11139287799596786,
0.667856752872467,
-0.37504515051841736,
-1.1761493682861328,
-0.08070193231105804,
0.7222598195075989,
-0.14939458668231964,
0.3715944290161133,
0.6324442625045776,
0.8426809310913086,
0.1267181783914566,
0.7371315956115723,
0.5350208282470703,
-0.05716222897171974,
0.28420397639274597,
0.48350536823272705,
0.841098964214325,
-0.2557348906993866,
0.7168874740600586,
0.13921315968036652,
-0.6006494760513306,
-0.5882821679115295,
-0.5439660549163818,
-1.258062720298767,
-0.7614285349845886,
-0.2899014353752136,
-0.37676069140434265,
0.12175188958644867,
1.0610085725784302,
0.9443581104278564,
-1.1210668087005615,
-0.6625627279281616,
0.19612304866313934,
0.06195735186338425,
-0.3535148799419403,
-0.27767515182495117,
0.06967097520828247,
-0.02909379079937935,
-0.4381679594516754,
0.7734568119049072,
0.5188944339752197,
0.08093957602977753,
-0.4076386094093323,
-0.19455915689468384,
-0.12732891738414764,
0.15693938732147217,
0.6322851181030273,
0.07948046922683716,
-0.43141815066337585,
-0.21166035532951355,
0.025672128424048424,
0.24426977336406708,
-0.06909961998462677,
1.4140825271606445,
-1.0382170677185059,
0.7645870447158813,
0.5331680178642273,
0.24646683037281036,
0.455105721950531,
0.07315665483474731,
1.3065065145492554,
-0.6287149786949158,
-0.09413518756628036,
0.27406659722328186,
0.30301082134246826,
0.18860609829425812,
-0.1814728081226349,
0.5491718053817749,
0.06281934678554535,
-0.5257949233055115,
-0.5633567571640015,
0.18812677264213562,
-1.0399729013442993,
-0.10441343486309052,
1.0469028949737549,
-0.36957061290740967,
0.12691427767276764,
-0.2689027190208435,
-0.5581638813018799,
-0.19071611762046814,
-0.9876394271850586,
0.43976813554763794,
0.7199225425720215,
-0.09339071065187454,
-0.11133413761854172,
-0.17834961414337158,
0.17444583773612976,
-0.11817490309476852,
-0.5471683144569397,
0.3211255371570587,
0.4132799506187439,
0.09518828243017197,
-0.0323902927339077,
0.8090960383415222,
-0.0012148700188845396,
0.01759701780974865,
-0.16814187169075012,
-0.13763900101184845,
-0.03787071630358696,
-0.4425775408744812,
0.1468018889427185,
0.25151389837265015,
0.03672749921679497,
-0.04940468445420265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04513v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04513v3 | Online Cascade Learning for Efficient Inference over Streams | 2024-02-07T01:46:50 | 2024-06-17T18:54:36 | Lunyiu Nie, Zhimin Ding, Erdong Hu, Christopher Jermaine, Swarat Chaudhuri | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have a natural role in answering complex queries
about data streams, but the high computational cost of LLM inference makes them
infeasible in many such tasks. We propose online cascade learning, the first
approach to address this challenge. The objective here is to learn a "cascade"
of models, starting with lower-capacity models (such as logistic regression)
and ending with a powerful LLM, along with a deferral policy that determines
the model to be used on a given input. We formulate the task of learning
cascades online as an imitation-learning problem, where smaller models are
updated over time imitating the collected LLM demonstrations, and give a
no-regret algorithm for the problem. Experimental results across four
benchmarks show that our method parallels LLMs in accuracy while cutting down
inference costs by as much as 90% with strong robustness against input
distribution shifts, underscoring its efficacy and adaptability in stream
processing. | [
-0.1482011377811432,
-0.8409001231193542,
0.5019031167030334,
0.31021735072135925,
-0.10579599440097809,
0.29054519534111023,
-0.1739170402288437,
-0.5135987997055054,
0.25984808802604675,
0.35404637455940247,
-0.7223899364471436,
-0.258625864982605,
-0.4502143859863281,
-0.0315396711230278,
-0.41403892636299133,
0.8133224844932556,
-0.13853870332241058,
0.27982833981513977,
-0.2740512490272522,
0.11070430278778076,
-0.22814232110977173,
-0.26782718300819397,
-1.0119038820266724,
-0.34968578815460205,
0.6222524642944336,
-0.07561051845550537,
0.1545192450284958,
0.5589690804481506,
0.26517850160598755,
0.2647164463996887,
-0.09376771748065948,
0.40600839257240295,
-0.78493332862854,
0.22983495891094208,
-0.0872102826833725,
-0.8221663236618042,
-0.1004723384976387,
-0.1770511269569397,
0.8255990743637085,
0.8541004657745361,
-0.3747420608997345,
0.23303653299808502,
0.29548999667167664,
0.8084644079208374,
-1.0566189289093018,
0.41166484355926514,
-0.7740796208381653,
0.05838024988770485,
0.03560599312186241,
-0.19290640950202942,
-0.7706910371780396,
-0.6080406308174133,
0.08627517521381378,
-0.7390848398208618,
0.08231205493211746,
-0.16566559672355652,
0.5762113928794861,
0.523505449295044,
-0.2705811560153961,
-0.3389188349246979,
-1.0644258260726929,
0.9832992553710938,
-0.5078621506690979,
0.40136733651161194,
0.5898351669311523,
0.43210023641586304,
-0.30439621210098267,
-1.082077145576477,
-0.30424344539642334,
0.01887892372906208,
0.10102275013923645,
0.27819210290908813,
-0.3006284832954407,
0.09326429665088654,
0.16914676129817963,
0.062491659075021744,
-0.2641879618167877,
0.15016049146652222,
-0.08103922754526138,
-0.08406610041856766,
0.4416368305683136,
0.18766281008720398,
-0.20694541931152344,
0.3795650899410248,
-0.21195761859416962,
0.17434433102607727,
-0.6882482171058655,
0.1282017081975937,
0.16326218843460083,
0.5528599619865417,
0.12292075902223587,
0.02038627490401268,
-0.23844406008720398,
0.6392444372177124,
0.21166841685771942,
-0.22162944078445435,
-0.029307782649993896,
0.19326864182949066,
-0.3436606526374817,
0.034969452768564224,
0.23291030526161194,
-0.2159978598356247,
0.10356739163398743,
0.006269097328186035,
-0.1886398196220398,
-0.16622096300125122,
0.22555281221866608,
-0.5700340867042542,
-0.09401217103004456,
0.2723349928855896,
-0.43059590458869934,
-0.23005150258541107,
-0.26111215353012085,
-0.6398866176605225,
-0.4525373876094818,
-0.38980981707572937,
0.6953793168067932,
-0.11055231839418411,
0.005458311177790165,
-0.3799063265323639,
0.09231943637132645,
0.338863343000412,
0.6240081787109375,
-0.7774832844734192,
0.6045167446136475,
0.8035961985588074,
1.2267682552337646,
-0.07157892733812332,
-0.2448178231716156,
-1.1843798160552979,
0.0715300664305687,
-0.360193133354187,
0.7439460158348083,
-0.44626376032829285,
-0.11690625548362732,
0.19128410518169403,
-0.2978283166885376,
-0.010502521879971027,
-0.6255371570587158,
0.29277658462524414,
-0.7063578367233276,
-0.21315059065818787,
-0.17304836213588715,
-0.9412346482276917,
-0.1686742901802063,
0.04856884479522705,
-0.8484762907028198,
0.8759199380874634,
0.03401292487978935,
-0.6994995474815369,
0.2640121281147003,
-0.3348328769207001,
-0.5161581635475159,
0.08341005444526672,
0.04556042328476906,
-0.44170522689819336,
0.24047113955020905,
0.27763813734054565,
0.3838149607181549,
-0.15652261674404144,
0.12446703016757965,
-0.4874887764453888,
-0.32323387265205383,
0.003857232164591551,
-0.46690866351127625,
0.8875599503517151,
0.1973150372505188,
-0.17480270564556122,
-0.03956849128007889,
-0.5629101395606995,
-0.1359001249074936,
-0.03265262022614479,
-0.528450608253479,
-0.35203927755355835,
0.5461561679840088,
-0.17224852740764618,
-0.08123764395713806,
-0.13090354204177856,
-0.41823652386665344,
0.3165302574634552,
-0.24751678109169006,
0.42348212003707886,
0.9844768047332764,
-0.1663878858089447,
0.42159897089004517,
-0.40182730555534363,
0.3968372642993927,
-0.20919810235500336,
0.27983996272087097,
-0.08670498430728912,
-0.4831647276878357,
-0.7968626022338867,
-0.5994129180908203,
0.5053017139434814,
0.4852401614189148,
-0.819866418838501,
0.035070136189460754,
-0.2181168645620346,
-0.3021896481513977,
-0.47679758071899414,
0.3647916615009308,
0.07556982338428497,
0.3875961899757385,
0.5197917819023132,
-0.16236470639705658,
-0.4693225622177124,
-0.4821789860725403,
-0.5314902663230896,
-0.2069249451160431,
-0.10965829342603683,
0.15619023144245148,
0.3288523256778717,
-0.005350965075194836,
1.1470187902450562,
-0.6376960277557373,
-0.5353560447692871,
-0.44265997409820557,
0.46319133043289185,
-0.0005470651667565107,
0.03693860024213791,
0.2947349548339844,
-0.5820481181144714,
-0.691045343875885,
-0.27083247900009155,
-0.5739691257476807,
-0.16003137826919556,
-0.3420972228050232,
0.09978997707366943,
0.20282363891601562,
0.47395992279052734,
-0.46972090005874634,
0.23324377834796906,
0.6122181415557861,
0.2844114899635315,
0.23275317251682281,
-0.3408678472042084,
-0.48055022954940796,
-0.9409556984901428,
-0.4019785225391388,
0.1472698599100113,
-0.5173166990280151,
-0.8899791240692139,
0.10925542563199997,
0.09123946726322174,
0.2555871307849884,
-0.5248124599456787,
0.6606833934783936,
-0.5010881423950195,
-0.11063706129789352,
-0.2944280505180359,
-0.11020835489034653,
-0.32174378633499146,
0.4972245991230011,
0.2310999482870102,
0.26088184118270874,
0.6603959202766418,
-0.68756103515625,
0.2575473487377167,
-0.06678175926208496,
-0.5515023469924927,
0.361580491065979,
-0.1928301900625229,
-0.03353818133473396,
-0.45869705080986023,
0.9703343510627747,
-0.7607605457305908,
-0.21403153240680695,
-0.02470734901726246,
-0.22315195202827454,
0.41192352771759033,
-0.24668121337890625,
-0.02853994630277157,
-0.13377125561237335,
-0.26883524656295776,
0.24711139500141144,
0.6968657970428467,
-0.9834628701210022,
1.1019654273986816,
0.3645671308040619,
0.04141584411263466,
-0.8324596881866455,
-0.8438515067100525,
-0.1892545521259308,
-0.08457154780626297,
-0.07594695687294006,
0.23119306564331055,
0.06931441277265549,
-0.22744043171405792,
-0.21673785150051117,
-0.051337119191884995,
-0.42704346776008606,
0.13986048102378845,
0.11608792096376419,
0.11038291454315186,
-0.13074319064617157,
0.1752031147480011,
-0.0019771158695220947,
0.12251555174589157,
-0.09909646213054657,
-0.5565153360366821,
0.4401704967021942,
0.26882416009902954,
-0.3559909164905548,
-0.6465958952903748,
0.16092561185359955,
0.12309490889310837,
0.041733548045158386,
0.7601427435874939,
0.46829524636268616,
-0.6537597179412842,
-0.8583475351333618,
-0.48527082800865173,
-0.21048927307128906,
-0.47374722361564636,
0.18388082087039948,
-0.2450667917728424,
-0.7245455384254456,
0.40945813059806824,
-0.28636619448661804,
0.2784711420536041,
0.1309862583875656,
0.5286106467247009,
-0.300738126039505,
0.8700491189956665,
0.4029366374015808,
-0.29841166734695435,
0.5459910035133362,
-0.253052681684494,
0.2290567010641098,
-0.4003637433052063,
-0.10870148241519928,
-0.2827431261539459,
-0.45413240790367126,
-0.4942876100540161,
-0.6817818880081177,
0.17525503039360046,
0.3449571430683136,
-0.16291934251785278,
-0.045664191246032715,
0.1129986122250557,
0.6733906269073486,
0.5114875435829163,
0.4142366647720337,
0.4864312708377838,
0.1371559500694275,
0.14293649792671204,
0.2845902144908905,
-0.7789409160614014,
0.026620563119649887,
0.9801017045974731,
0.32821986079216003,
1.19013249874115,
0.10142690688371658,
0.6093882918357849,
0.4655347168445587,
0.7088474631309509,
-0.931886613368988,
0.27517271041870117,
0.01985803432762623,
-0.4167356491088867,
-0.3399786949157715,
-0.8516143560409546,
-0.828470766544342,
0.21692579984664917,
-0.12697304785251617,
-0.6291459202766418,
0.000017523765563964844,
0.6667765974998474,
-0.30842432379722595,
0.6881501078605652,
-0.40604421496391296,
0.2976554334163666,
-0.14675657451152802,
-0.4576253294944763,
-0.37869375944137573,
-0.5313279032707214,
0.5618371367454529,
-0.3543950319290161,
0.4500988721847534,
0.018017979338765144,
-0.17150279879570007,
0.34588778018951416,
-0.484065979719162,
1.173573613166809,
-0.1585441678762436,
0.09790023416280746,
0.4412665069103241,
0.34079107642173767,
0.8717193007469177,
-0.20902101695537567,
-0.018751535564661026,
0.1817805916070938,
-0.2727547287940979,
-0.44557416439056396,
-0.5972033739089966,
0.738000750541687,
-0.6735222935676575,
-0.37657323479652405,
-0.4477502107620239,
-0.391328364610672,
-0.27790042757987976,
-0.18540631234645844,
0.0013735339744016528,
0.5217757225036621,
-0.1901516616344452,
0.024782409891486168,
0.5364573001861572,
-0.12711124122142792,
0.7307803630828857,
0.27952098846435547,
-0.19192467629909515,
-0.370754212141037,
1.1936275959014893,
0.288331538438797,
0.6543187499046326,
0.7116390466690063,
0.528224527835846,
-0.5003688335418701,
-0.39352327585220337,
-0.2410261482000351,
0.09692879766225815,
-0.9875953197479248,
-0.14609849452972412,
-0.561066210269928,
-0.247922882437706,
-0.0745779424905777,
-0.1344507336616516,
-0.37459972500801086,
-0.352183997631073,
-0.4420487582683563,
0.04859383404254913,
0.22779570519924164,
0.9526236653327942,
-0.14048932492733002,
0.22308257222175598,
-0.7597630620002747,
0.04363546893000603,
0.6463088989257812,
0.3645603060722351,
0.5349856019020081,
-0.6381677389144897,
-0.08834273368120193,
-0.05073077231645584,
-0.5497562885284424,
-0.4728541076183319,
0.514796257019043,
0.7210339903831482,
0.550378680229187,
0.6565171480178833,
0.210262268781662,
0.835013747215271,
-0.6084814667701721,
0.6948322653770447,
0.11687981337308884,
-1.0725839138031006,
0.1624975949525833,
0.030515767633914948,
0.22053197026252747,
0.34133079648017883,
0.9752430319786072,
-0.4868735074996948,
-0.4181075096130371,
-0.34773364663124084,
-0.5814343690872192,
0.6249159574508667,
0.21717721223831177,
0.20629502832889557,
0.09444590657949448,
0.37266892194747925,
0.10739041119813919,
0.03271511569619179,
-0.6938084959983826,
-0.2508578896522522,
0.037363942712545395,
-0.15241286158561707,
-0.018963690847158432,
0.13104568421840668,
0.248018279671669,
-0.34659287333488464,
0.7240737080574036,
-0.3823821246623993,
0.03008352778851986,
0.014708863571286201,
-0.3569057285785675,
-0.12167703360319138,
-0.2547225058078766,
0.5006579756736755,
0.6447532176971436,
-0.007459580898284912,
0.3124801814556122,
0.617648720741272,
-0.376939982175827,
0.04503624141216278,
-0.3655272126197815,
-0.35305315256118774,
-0.13342048227787018,
0.638286292552948,
0.7829867005348206,
0.16426946222782135,
-0.6193398237228394,
0.3361783027648926,
-0.13062594830989838,
-0.25740405917167664,
-0.2956380546092987,
-0.12771490216255188,
0.33878666162490845,
0.297025203704834,
0.6139237284660339,
-0.16499994695186615,
-0.05011787638068199,
-0.5615794658660889,
0.12211751192808151,
0.6097131967544556,
-0.48231270909309387,
-0.15047615766525269,
0.6173962950706482,
0.13827607035636902,
-0.46443846821784973,
0.5480971932411194,
-0.028348879888653755,
-0.5613053441047668,
0.42068904638290405,
0.5440346598625183,
0.8443115949630737,
-0.4467630684375763,
0.40393897891044617,
0.31560853123664856,
0.03446213901042938,
-0.5396450757980347,
0.12074559181928635,
-0.13638827204704285,
-0.5855588316917419,
-0.6563253402709961,
-0.882648766040802,
-0.656279444694519,
0.1715690791606903,
-0.5145644545555115,
0.4522196054458618,
-0.6103913187980652,
0.03846436366438866,
-0.01925923302769661,
-0.39240074157714844,
-0.36675339937210083,
-0.038207296282052994,
0.35722747445106506,
0.9513028860092163,
-0.8705230355262756,
0.8132998943328857,
0.05093074217438698,
-0.31972092390060425,
-0.5295200347900391,
0.21213780343532562,
0.05199107155203819,
-0.730751633644104,
0.7305818200111389,
0.09219103306531906,
-0.17807962000370026,
0.3594079315662384,
-0.6412931680679321,
-0.755308210849762,
0.9441371560096741,
0.4636327028274536,
-0.5625604391098022,
-0.0624389611184597,
0.07945055514574051,
0.42464351654052734,
-0.4342917799949646,
0.5850200057029724,
0.4600007236003876,
0.08598862588405609,
0.26872146129608154,
-0.7314069271087646,
-0.2301412671804428,
0.465199738740921,
-0.06555770337581635,
0.2660367786884308,
-0.7004803419113159,
0.882941484451294,
-0.20094510912895203,
-0.2163778841495514,
-0.15029755234718323,
0.7294111847877502,
0.02098735421895981,
0.15202708542346954,
0.6033728122711182,
0.45684540271759033,
0.9658709168434143,
-0.04902888834476471,
1.1681936979293823,
0.034693341702222824,
0.6669492721557617,
1.339781641960144,
-0.5101280808448792,
1.338273525238037,
0.43616101145744324,
-0.3445734679698944,
0.6716710329055786,
0.9253711700439453,
0.30573102831840515,
0.5850452780723572,
0.47421619296073914,
-0.6453737020492554,
-0.5281473398208618,
-0.053482744842767715,
0.23909863829612732,
0.10075998306274414,
0.357688307762146,
-0.21381933987140656,
-0.4661133885383606,
-0.059604618698358536,
-0.38574621081352234,
-0.07509568333625793,
-0.7218205332756042,
0.8293470740318298,
0.29588112235069275,
-0.46750709414482117,
0.6233547925949097,
-0.250573992729187,
0.4335702657699585,
-0.6960936784744263,
-0.09059807658195496,
-0.4040341377258301,
0.5026253461837769,
-0.19313789904117584,
-0.3505913317203522,
0.17276740074157715,
-0.12026161700487137,
0.06982746720314026,
-0.20720873773097992,
0.4577801823616028,
-0.38772138953208923,
-0.7179655432701111,
0.4770355224609375,
0.43341487646102905,
0.12179844081401825,
-0.10599444806575775,
-0.43102148175239563,
-0.17046195268630981,
-0.22893835604190826,
-0.2573804259300232,
0.5152292251586914,
-0.21800433099269867,
-0.2069639414548874,
1.0588898658752441,
0.6290127635002136,
0.2936255931854248,
0.38750430941581726,
0.198238343000412,
0.7074133157730103,
-0.2924702763557434,
-0.4475768506526947,
-0.9609215259552002,
0.27018028497695923,
0.030098967254161835,
0.08253534138202667,
0.37843677401542664,
0.4715614318847656,
1.195259928703308,
-0.05385215952992439,
0.9599974751472473,
0.27025097608566284,
0.3982584774494171,
-0.5537204146385193,
0.43360695242881775,
-0.629852831363678,
0.07754378020763397,
0.027115000411868095,
-1.053338885307312,
-0.41179412603378296,
0.576291024684906,
-0.1603972315788269,
-0.17177312076091766,
0.7013120055198669,
0.677025556564331,
-0.24623730778694153,
0.26968538761138916,
0.2618326246738434,
0.19426514208316803,
0.21368330717086792,
0.5817162990570068,
0.9464825987815857,
-0.175962895154953,
0.432576060295105,
-0.26158076524734497,
-0.3704271614551544,
-0.1646449714899063,
-1.0812230110168457,
-1.061933159828186,
-0.3378206491470337,
-0.12434310466051102,
-0.3296487033367157,
-0.01840209774672985,
1.4110376834869385,
0.6499356031417847,
-1.011279821395874,
-0.4584636390209198,
-0.29663845896720886,
0.16214627027511597,
-0.6297727823257446,
-0.12496556341648102,
0.1906278282403946,
-0.5190333127975464,
-0.8177074790000916,
0.4159645438194275,
0.07056982815265656,
-0.1565871238708496,
-0.49140211939811707,
-0.14401887357234955,
-0.41701561212539673,
0.36558717489242554,
0.7228990197181702,
0.4205719232559204,
-0.797430694103241,
-0.16514930129051208,
-0.2359856218099594,
0.12183356285095215,
0.14409729838371277,
1.0347633361816406,
-0.7460519075393677,
0.4295177757740021,
0.695044219493866,
1.1898285150527954,
0.9561898112297058,
0.12776078283786774,
0.36660924553871155,
-0.6633480787277222,
-0.16932561993598938,
0.11267029494047165,
0.14951491355895996,
0.1081157997250557,
-0.15782499313354492,
0.2344202995300293,
0.40025201439857483,
-0.42772823572158813,
-0.8936513066291809,
0.2666475176811218,
-0.5647521615028381,
-0.4381158947944641,
0.946752667427063,
-0.2607295513153076,
-0.22521618008613586,
-0.2658199071884155,
0.20685042440891266,
0.3676285147666931,
-0.1788804680109024,
0.8371332883834839,
0.6111441254615784,
-0.3895373046398163,
-0.11996587365865707,
-0.6760428547859192,
0.5715144872665405,
0.26839402318000793,
-0.86387038230896,
0.24956506490707397,
0.23421929776668549,
0.30559685826301575,
-0.10158894956111908,
0.4356594383716583,
0.6065469980239868,
-0.12325772643089294,
-0.12895077466964722,
-0.12318356335163116,
0.272663414478302,
-0.6023499965667725,
-0.6678552031517029,
0.12712828814983368,
0.04790772497653961,
0.05537877604365349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04505v1 | Developments in Sheaf-Theoretic Models of Natural Language Ambiguities | 2024-02-07T01:18:55 | 2024-02-07T01:18:55 | Kin Ian Lo, Mehrnoosh Sadrzadeh, Shane Mansfield | cs.CL | cs.CL, quant-ph | Sheaves are mathematical objects consisting of a base which constitutes a
topological space and the data associated with each open set thereof, e.g.
continuous functions defined on the open sets. Sheaves have originally been
used in algebraic topology and logic. Recently, they have also modelled events
such as physical experiments and natural language disambiguation processes. We
extend the latter models from lexical ambiguities to discourse ambiguities
arising from anaphora. To begin, we calculated a new measure of contextuality
for a dataset of basic anaphoric discourses, resulting in a higher proportion
of contextual models--82.9%--compared to previous work which only yielded 3.17%
contextual models. Then, we show how an extension of the natural language
processing challenge, known as the Winograd Schema, which involves anaphoric
ambiguities can be modelled on the Bell-CHSH scenario with a contextual
fraction of 0.096. | [
-0.2746710181236267,
-1.2157329320907593,
0.5027732849121094,
-0.17797788977622986,
-0.1646890938282013,
0.09601433575153351,
-0.24287357926368713,
-0.6765033006668091,
0.2325408011674881,
0.6159358024597168,
-0.1841287612915039,
-0.4771398603916168,
-0.7191001176834106,
-0.06151685118675232,
-0.54860520362854,
0.8778147101402283,
-0.1935117244720459,
-0.1737896353006363,
0.09395571798086166,
-0.5027425289154053,
-0.008067634887993336,
-0.5400022864341736,
-0.2011399120092392,
-0.2825115919113159,
0.3315422534942627,
0.2938457131385803,
1.262576937675476,
0.5974389910697937,
0.6294561624526978,
0.3339892625808716,
-0.18982826173305511,
-0.17452950775623322,
0.26433587074279785,
0.5452973246574402,
-0.11632882058620453,
-0.33685383200645447,
-0.35399341583251953,
0.020010702311992645,
0.4949605464935303,
1.4443925619125366,
-0.6133967638015747,
0.01621393673121929,
-0.0024138439912348986,
0.7154016494750977,
-0.4811497628688812,
-0.02728741429746151,
-0.5937777757644653,
0.05324887856841087,
-0.2981702387332916,
-0.2977568805217743,
-0.13697202503681183,
-0.38618203997612,
0.5491740107536316,
-0.9622711539268494,
-0.03529607132077217,
0.4441346824169159,
0.9546394944190979,
0.09083659946918488,
-0.6838728785514832,
-0.7270345091819763,
-0.7385060787200928,
0.9914995431900024,
-0.5982243418693542,
0.12979497015476227,
0.4587385654449463,
0.38063958287239075,
-0.16595055162906647,
-0.40939459204673767,
-0.2721068561077118,
-0.15129028260707855,
-0.28099238872528076,
-0.3241060674190521,
-0.4474028944969177,
0.311565637588501,
0.3116989731788635,
0.5385609269142151,
-0.41856011748313904,
-0.36498764157295227,
-0.24088187515735626,
-0.10511353611946106,
0.38305428624153137,
0.024426886811852455,
0.3945362865924835,
-0.7142884135246277,
-0.4428676962852478,
0.09207014739513397,
-0.606891393661499,
-0.17469221353530884,
0.575688362121582,
0.021209245547652245,
-0.10856294631958008,
0.556086003780365,
-0.09669387340545654,
0.952238142490387,
-0.2545548677444458,
-0.17986874282360077,
-0.00656048534438014,
-0.35600897669792175,
-0.4028642177581787,
-0.2051408588886261,
0.43155619502067566,
0.07008194923400879,
0.6983890533447266,
-0.0840170681476593,
0.030422138050198555,
0.37857750058174133,
0.09160242974758148,
-0.25792789459228516,
-0.27975699305534363,
0.10707763582468033,
-0.1978658139705658,
-0.3887298107147217,
-0.16950196027755737,
-0.5847804546356201,
-0.06873522698879242,
-0.5340468883514404,
0.08278118818998337,
-0.8102368712425232,
-0.290432333946228,
0.5016794800758362,
-0.06240655854344368,
0.23924016952514648,
0.2539741098880768,
-0.712236225605011,
0.8295623660087585,
0.47727569937705994,
0.648018479347229,
0.22694572806358337,
-0.17941024899482727,
-0.08987897634506226,
0.34500038623809814,
-0.355056494474411,
0.8294634222984314,
-0.9312421679496765,
-0.21543750166893005,
0.15855379402637482,
-0.10993364453315735,
-0.2449374943971634,
-0.4280345141887665,
0.6332817673683167,
-0.2703787088394165,
0.4077149033546448,
-0.12977927923202515,
-0.4248846173286438,
-0.3783417344093323,
0.21460901200771332,
-0.5116402506828308,
0.9588619470596313,
0.39981135725975037,
-1.0570341348648071,
0.22590655088424683,
-0.6598734855651855,
-0.6782113909721375,
0.022659702226519585,
-0.06945677101612091,
0.2840995192527771,
0.2826039791107178,
-0.1870817095041275,
-0.20215155184268951,
-0.44087108969688416,
0.7683785557746887,
-0.23297752439975739,
0.014047141186892986,
0.4067882299423218,
-0.30259090662002563,
0.8163312673568726,
0.19663557410240173,
-0.23826156556606293,
0.011619260534644127,
-0.8292980194091797,
-0.08343721926212311,
-0.35174286365509033,
-0.22227218747138977,
-0.994263231754303,
0.11860640347003937,
0.15723614394664764,
0.17378677427768707,
-0.09480103850364685,
-0.5185924172401428,
0.21935106813907623,
-0.7824207544326782,
0.450158953666687,
0.4979803264141083,
-0.05178654193878174,
0.8895083069801331,
-0.48635250329971313,
0.523101806640625,
0.20343413949012756,
-0.12702815234661102,
-0.11788224428892136,
-0.701002299785614,
-0.920081377029419,
0.04392797127366066,
0.4320984184741974,
0.5261204242706299,
-0.6419829726219177,
0.16222800314426422,
-0.03993307054042816,
-0.07828366011381149,
-0.5296007990837097,
-0.2583064138889313,
0.4551849365234375,
0.5357030630111694,
0.14487704634666443,
-0.09122875332832336,
-0.5785655379295349,
-1.2006555795669556,
-0.34871360659599304,
-0.28878411650657654,
-0.2193416804075241,
0.32620754837989807,
0.6699258685112,
0.2578507959842682,
0.976685106754303,
-0.48736828565597534,
-0.2340468168258667,
0.2896578907966614,
0.5931277275085449,
0.03614627942442894,
0.5215461254119873,
0.5558120608329773,
-0.7108599543571472,
-0.11983960121870041,
0.16885575652122498,
-0.877399206161499,
-0.13703447580337524,
0.291627436876297,
-0.20776483416557312,
0.3225090503692627,
0.19501863420009613,
-0.7510010004043579,
0.8027070164680481,
0.4398273527622223,
-0.5581800937652588,
0.7942432165145874,
-0.1670602262020111,
0.335347443819046,
-1.0003316402435303,
0.08406011760234833,
-0.2705923616886139,
-0.17887505888938904,
-0.8276103734970093,
0.2390272319316864,
-0.18138164281845093,
0.2325984388589859,
-0.39518100023269653,
0.5687318444252014,
-0.6144843697547913,
-0.13935136795043945,
-0.1801932454109192,
0.28595519065856934,
0.036379918456077576,
0.44839322566986084,
0.07650727778673172,
0.2550636827945709,
0.896190881729126,
-0.8454537987709045,
0.01829158514738083,
0.09603244811296463,
-0.29960471391677856,
0.9525845646858215,
-0.4154779314994812,
-0.28217771649360657,
-0.06545807421207428,
0.3364555537700653,
-0.7965973019599915,
-0.6582427620887756,
0.3160618245601654,
-0.21628513932228088,
-0.10461929440498352,
-0.18648582696914673,
-0.5342262983322144,
-0.2651994526386261,
-0.3476688861846924,
0.8277971744537354,
0.3561224639415741,
-0.09900401532649994,
0.5033488869667053,
0.4756395220756531,
0.08334241807460785,
-0.4182206094264984,
-0.6311478614807129,
0.22559967637062073,
-0.4961749017238617,
-1.119120478630066,
0.405131071805954,
-0.13649679720401764,
-0.8660216927528381,
0.14806972444057465,
0.038767460733652115,
-0.06401308625936508,
0.2266847938299179,
0.1918286234140396,
-0.042320914566516876,
-0.22004348039627075,
0.09761637449264526,
0.10920315235853195,
-0.03247714415192604,
0.13112065196037292,
-0.6595359444618225,
0.2966465950012207,
-0.11813271790742874,
-0.3792937695980072,
0.029327502474188805,
0.6858215928077698,
0.3440648317337036,
0.21826685965061188,
0.5383781790733337,
-0.009083530865609646,
-1.03390371799469,
-0.035626091063022614,
-0.34196099638938904,
-0.15407152473926544,
-0.44065579771995544,
-0.17661422491073608,
-0.3333204388618469,
-0.8993322253227234,
0.8181006908416748,
0.2375953644514084,
-0.015004485845565796,
0.1980244368314743,
0.2727486491203308,
-0.25464871525764465,
0.8504027128219604,
0.4681057333946228,
0.4411376714706421,
0.1294669210910797,
0.040964771062135696,
0.3256448805332184,
-1.0558174848556519,
-0.0026376252062618732,
-0.572573184967041,
-0.42186233401298523,
-0.702895998954773,
-0.5770506262779236,
0.248676598072052,
0.04260155186057091,
-0.1462826281785965,
0.4464198350906372,
-0.12874895334243774,
0.3096925914287567,
0.4505786895751953,
-0.3851257562637329,
0.5385945439338684,
0.011083165183663368,
-0.4147922694683075,
-0.17872844636440277,
-0.6348552703857422,
-0.828666090965271,
0.9143553376197815,
0.2486625462770462,
0.8263516426086426,
0.3641030192375183,
0.2536241412162781,
0.2550755441188812,
0.3482128977775574,
-0.5823162198066711,
0.4004792869091034,
0.14206430315971375,
-0.9962806105613708,
-0.18595261871814728,
-0.17652492225170135,
-1.071024775505066,
0.366717129945755,
0.09617863595485687,
-1.2352746725082397,
0.28739112615585327,
0.2555544376373291,
-0.07959339767694473,
0.46015459299087524,
-0.41375070810317993,
0.6245254874229431,
0.07992472499608994,
-0.13384924829006195,
0.06580407917499542,
-0.6769391298294067,
0.5962458848953247,
0.28475096821784973,
0.9076162576675415,
-0.17804718017578125,
-0.08831232041120529,
0.8292590379714966,
-0.4037257134914398,
0.756732702255249,
0.07869350910186768,
-0.3920362889766693,
0.673634946346283,
0.5349993109703064,
0.22099268436431885,
0.020284518599510193,
-0.054661963135004044,
-0.06949108093976974,
0.16282089054584503,
-0.5508865118026733,
-0.46148449182510376,
0.5183480381965637,
-0.19670367240905762,
-0.6715046167373657,
-0.6619910597801208,
-0.6229016780853271,
-0.23569408059120178,
0.027161048725247383,
0.34425410628318787,
0.637873113155365,
-0.3186205327510834,
0.08082819730043411,
0.6434454321861267,
0.02010996825993061,
0.4738675653934479,
0.3718714714050293,
-0.37947097420692444,
-0.23986251652240753,
0.48360002040863037,
0.19078747928142548,
0.4537915587425232,
0.09333635866641998,
0.2259998619556427,
0.061483971774578094,
-0.3196471929550171,
-0.2920035421848297,
0.209186851978302,
-0.8337641358375549,
-0.3739393353462219,
-0.5836571455001831,
-0.2057611495256424,
-0.20054171979427338,
-0.36593347787857056,
0.00998758152127266,
-0.7662100791931152,
-0.1073647066950798,
-0.1454232782125473,
0.33216792345046997,
0.9431195259094238,
-0.15011747181415558,
0.6269222497940063,
-0.3487264811992645,
0.0019834397826343775,
-0.08942903578281403,
0.40577173233032227,
0.01009751483798027,
-0.638190746307373,
-0.029609378427267075,
0.19988468289375305,
-0.33408698439598083,
-1.3107919692993164,
0.4295252561569214,
0.13206788897514343,
0.22063790261745453,
0.3858516812324524,
0.004317597486078739,
0.41754287481307983,
-0.42693766951560974,
0.5548254251480103,
-0.02380429208278656,
-1.0578813552856445,
0.4708334803581238,
-0.9147639274597168,
0.40401244163513184,
0.323588103055954,
0.18171724677085876,
-0.8408674001693726,
-0.8194452524185181,
-1.020746111869812,
-0.8498934507369995,
0.5188493132591248,
0.5346019864082336,
-0.16007408499717712,
-0.23997639119625092,
0.18704822659492493,
0.1371038407087326,
0.43876340985298157,
-0.7314758896827698,
-0.26053309440612793,
0.16260632872581482,
-0.21074847877025604,
0.24539078772068024,
-0.23567475378513336,
-0.40160441398620605,
-0.12691499292850494,
0.28171586990356445,
-0.1645847111940384,
-0.006484649144113064,
0.23091813921928406,
-0.35270383954048157,
-0.2908184230327606,
0.5792555212974548,
0.6743422746658325,
0.6173909902572632,
-0.13934919238090515,
0.5637332201004028,
0.14666269719600677,
-0.2631780505180359,
0.08312848210334778,
-0.0535401850938797,
-0.2209787517786026,
0.13609455525875092,
0.5518776178359985,
0.6510252356529236,
1.028917908668518,
-0.3811677396297455,
0.16147050261497498,
0.0829882025718689,
-0.5224032402038574,
-0.3518468141555786,
-0.1888345628976822,
0.22212165594100952,
-0.14660371840000153,
0.5070844888687134,
0.3497394621372223,
0.44149476289749146,
-0.5661975145339966,
0.3933761417865753,
0.5355236530303955,
-0.364223837852478,
-0.6157872676849365,
0.39813894033432007,
0.1216391921043396,
-0.5068199038505554,
-0.025408321991562843,
-0.23739412426948547,
-0.6963269114494324,
0.6253935098648071,
0.49796202778816223,
0.6343873143196106,
-0.20777586102485657,
0.3393983244895935,
0.27033212780952454,
0.4192850589752197,
0.21745158731937408,
0.23786520957946777,
-0.01113711018115282,
-0.5117245316505432,
-0.011321661993861198,
-0.9340643286705017,
-0.43512657284736633,
-0.09661045670509338,
-0.6079102754592896,
0.10145731270313263,
-0.27192771434783936,
-0.1474914699792862,
0.03491144999861717,
-0.25103864073753357,
-0.4808107912540436,
0.05410335212945938,
0.06128780171275139,
0.939456582069397,
-0.866388738155365,
0.6999832987785339,
0.7574675679206848,
0.0005188247305341065,
-0.5257639288902283,
-0.05375257879495621,
0.07374310493469238,
-0.3580164909362793,
0.4393545389175415,
0.02283555082976818,
-0.2063680738210678,
-0.1970970183610916,
-0.4287058413028717,
-1.2469706535339355,
0.7179463505744934,
0.3653985857963562,
-0.11268522590398788,
-0.2808934152126312,
0.22527818381786346,
0.6320430636405945,
-0.7110726833343506,
0.2593325674533844,
0.7281680703163147,
0.7296721935272217,
-0.04921591654419899,
-0.8573284149169922,
-0.06037398427724838,
-0.1445990651845932,
-0.08396481722593307,
0.5338168740272522,
-0.13961410522460938,
1.0532991886138916,
-0.01261965837329626,
-0.5538588166236877,
0.0579797700047493,
0.4840778112411499,
0.09644348919391632,
0.15157902240753174,
0.41712406277656555,
0.4167376160621643,
0.7251647710800171,
-0.36700162291526794,
1.1921544075012207,
-0.3599222004413605,
0.2958891987800598,
0.7494144439697266,
-0.14671073853969574,
0.6148306727409363,
0.7318931221961975,
-0.10768377035856247,
0.8068847060203552,
0.6094365119934082,
0.8211196064949036,
0.17269809544086456,
0.6865516901016235,
-0.3843042850494385,
-0.07805030792951584,
-0.22104446589946747,
-0.3172574043273926,
0.38103601336479187,
0.6384472846984863,
0.024983927607536316,
-0.6335395574569702,
0.12359397858381271,
0.3158506155014038,
0.24506530165672302,
0.1549866795539856,
0.6263993382453918,
0.28245896100997925,
-0.9737181663513184,
0.4684267044067383,
0.24758435785770416,
0.6547446846961975,
-0.6650049090385437,
-0.03290875628590584,
-0.1347319781780243,
-0.18555741012096405,
-0.05909331887960434,
-0.7952287793159485,
0.6270901560783386,
-0.11282233893871307,
0.034634802490472794,
-0.2441219836473465,
0.7387142777442932,
-0.5401617884635925,
-0.6429859399795532,
0.5549964904785156,
0.4994344115257263,
0.11132930219173431,
0.30221182107925415,
-0.4946449100971222,
-0.16541723906993866,
-0.16741672158241272,
-0.45704391598701477,
0.15480661392211914,
0.6126347184181213,
-0.2339577078819275,
0.6057495474815369,
0.4674142599105835,
-0.009591604582965374,
0.20571336150169373,
-0.09155334532260895,
0.7345909476280212,
-0.8483632206916809,
-0.47893258929252625,
-0.7181528210639954,
0.40928012132644653,
-0.044147852808237076,
-0.5875558257102966,
0.4756722152233124,
0.20944209396839142,
0.5344209671020508,
0.2364894151687622,
0.7677975296974182,
-0.2922252118587494,
0.329783171415329,
-0.6098380088806152,
0.5500253438949585,
-0.3558225929737091,
0.356507807970047,
-0.4815104901790619,
-0.767659604549408,
-0.24187402427196503,
0.8097260594367981,
-0.31328028440475464,
0.007151858415454626,
1.107477068901062,
0.3243017792701721,
-0.22674702107906342,
0.3719831705093384,
0.20247893035411835,
0.05680736526846886,
0.07321863621473312,
0.6825740933418274,
0.9590572118759155,
-0.584696888923645,
0.1964951455593109,
-0.3505931496620178,
-0.3394080102443695,
-0.06576428562402725,
-1.06184720993042,
-0.5874179601669312,
-0.8649005889892578,
-0.34809932112693787,
-0.22387391328811646,
0.24652473628520966,
0.46486949920654297,
0.574332594871521,
-0.6589595675468445,
-0.6579429507255554,
-0.21603429317474365,
0.5013670921325684,
0.08458887785673141,
-0.25811833143234253,
0.19838771224021912,
-0.20407210290431976,
-0.5315350294113159,
0.047010742127895355,
0.3032144606113434,
0.1788499653339386,
-0.26924875378608704,
0.06582285463809967,
-0.6921262145042419,
0.5723719000816345,
0.43893590569496155,
0.10176422446966171,
-0.8786717653274536,
-0.7567878365516663,
0.14259637892246246,
-0.06655852496623993,
0.30899566411972046,
0.7933616042137146,
-0.802176296710968,
-0.028443409129977226,
0.14599284529685974,
0.04233367368578911,
0.06113936007022858,
0.08199145644903183,
0.7680882811546326,
-0.824304461479187,
0.26117584109306335,
0.1966729760169983,
0.4615325629711151,
0.47162875533103943,
-0.03771686181426048,
0.42312097549438477,
0.2878255844116211,
-0.27436962723731995,
-0.9883421659469604,
0.6887884140014648,
-0.7170884013175964,
-0.34195730090141296,
1.1003528833389282,
0.1647404432296753,
-0.40755727887153625,
-0.20781837403774261,
-0.04682007431983948,
-0.017401350662112236,
-0.18096065521240234,
0.4368726313114166,
1.3562458753585815,
-0.03335598111152649,
0.31151071190834045,
-0.8363825678825378,
0.7320941090583801,
0.605038583278656,
-0.9146223068237305,
0.3824310600757599,
0.5779017806053162,
0.16435644030570984,
0.4039599597454071,
0.6057853102684021,
0.03462766110897064,
0.14354529976844788,
0.00988274160772562,
-0.3203585147857666,
0.4720219373703003,
-0.5498126745223999,
-0.20023053884506226,
0.3616156280040741,
-0.014964142814278603,
0.11864013969898224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04497v1 | The Fine-Grained Complexity of Gradient Computation for Training Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T00:45:31 | 2024-02-07T00:45:31 | Josh Alman, Zhao Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CC, cs.CL, cs.DS | Large language models (LLMs) have made fundamental contributions over the
last a few years. To train an LLM, one needs to alternatingly run `forward'
computations and `backward' computations. The forward computation can be viewed
as attention function evaluation, and the backward computation can be viewed as
a gradient computation. In previous work by [Alman and Song, NeurIPS 2023], it
was proved that the forward step can be performed in almost-linear time in
certain parameter regimes, but that there is no truly sub-quadratic time
algorithm in the remaining parameter regimes unless the popular hypothesis SETH
is false. In this work, we show nearly identical results for the harder-seeming
problem of computing the gradient of loss function of one layer attention
network, and thus for the entire process of LLM training. This completely
characterizes the fine-grained complexity of every step of LLM training. | [
-0.2578754723072052,
-0.7592247128486633,
0.726456880569458,
0.4855269491672516,
0.07877993583679199,
-0.11693631112575531,
-0.46061691641807556,
-0.40583646297454834,
-0.09230080246925354,
0.3840394914150238,
-0.7334733009338379,
-0.24715717136859894,
-0.7924702167510986,
-0.06408214569091797,
-0.4914039373397827,
0.790412187576294,
-0.1684202253818512,
0.44472992420196533,
0.15630875527858734,
-0.3423299193382263,
0.11324508488178253,
-0.22762222588062286,
-1.035667896270752,
-0.6403688788414001,
0.6540224552154541,
-0.013662675395607948,
0.31336307525634766,
0.6269379258155823,
0.4719410240650177,
0.2676711082458496,
-0.14580892026424408,
-0.14843186736106873,
-0.7411379814147949,
-0.13552938401699066,
-0.17407011985778809,
-0.56026291847229,
-0.15260086953639984,
0.06163588538765907,
0.879857063293457,
1.0153497457504272,
-0.07769390940666199,
0.26656636595726013,
0.19454297423362732,
1.0595734119415283,
-0.641716480255127,
-0.03131609782576561,
-0.5535715818405151,
0.22625678777694702,
-0.24270477890968323,
-0.18350467085838318,
-0.3352433145046234,
-0.22952744364738464,
0.06670990586280823,
-0.3101549744606018,
0.18665502965450287,
-0.1323210746049881,
0.6217682957649231,
0.2113932967185974,
-0.017682265490293503,
-0.2467833310365677,
-1.0646684169769287,
0.9197719693183899,
-0.4785137176513672,
0.3114387094974518,
0.05590951815247536,
0.06160673499107361,
-0.013916981406509876,
-0.5121663212776184,
-0.4408348500728607,
-0.28494951128959656,
0.24191774427890778,
-0.25734275579452515,
-0.14728261530399323,
0.41259950399398804,
0.31346645951271057,
0.5388222932815552,
-0.2836366593837738,
0.43494275212287903,
-0.18471165001392365,
-0.05002420395612717,
0.41381362080574036,
0.5792167782783508,
-0.13651494681835175,
0.2509565055370331,
-0.21246342360973358,
0.1236833781003952,
-0.727695882320404,
0.2739356458187103,
0.10592318326234818,
0.32634904980659485,
-0.16064777970314026,
0.3824339509010315,
-0.43065768480300903,
0.5814947485923767,
0.21101754903793335,
-0.2556568384170532,
0.022976702079176903,
-0.0739709660410881,
-0.49440041184425354,
-0.1316039115190506,
0.7038614749908447,
0.188720703125,
0.481310099363327,
-0.2211993932723999,
-0.19946721196174622,
-0.29800862073898315,
-0.08977584540843964,
-0.891393780708313,
-0.1990431398153305,
0.17078983783721924,
-0.21584998071193695,
-0.024940405040979385,
-0.330649197101593,
-0.3105233907699585,
-0.46699783205986023,
-0.24649637937545776,
0.432913213968277,
-0.10371767729520798,
0.36521077156066895,
0.15147665143013,
0.5308265686035156,
0.3418671190738678,
0.476959228515625,
-0.7146502733230591,
0.4477148950099945,
0.9492769837379456,
0.921593427658081,
-0.009897813200950623,
-0.5777351260185242,
-0.8542932271957397,
-0.26269885897636414,
-0.33608540892601013,
0.40702584385871887,
-0.7673306465148926,
-0.0018402374116703868,
0.027904387563467026,
-0.02272827923297882,
-0.20213936269283295,
-0.34530818462371826,
0.2634216248989105,
-0.6150836944580078,
-0.21906910836696625,
-0.09235160797834396,
-0.5950198173522949,
-0.09041298180818558,
0.25233718752861023,
-0.33076798915863037,
0.873090922832489,
0.09593652188777924,
-0.7949942946434021,
-0.17838069796562195,
-0.2038728892803192,
-0.5307167768478394,
-0.2564111649990082,
-0.01616174727678299,
-0.5099681615829468,
0.3071407973766327,
-0.12294061481952667,
0.5973572731018066,
-0.6276952028274536,
-0.1436595320701599,
-0.6172781586647034,
-0.47163644433021545,
0.27904167771339417,
-0.42645323276519775,
0.790779709815979,
-0.13318873941898346,
-0.44435393810272217,
-0.12136708945035934,
-0.9249317049980164,
0.02105036750435829,
0.19170686602592468,
-0.7010740041732788,
-0.1493503302335739,
-0.09438557177782059,
-0.21444463729858398,
0.1920405477285385,
0.24530433118343353,
-0.6198626160621643,
0.27723053097724915,
-0.6384285092353821,
0.5446154475212097,
0.8486761450767517,
-0.3475983142852783,
0.6682794690132141,
-0.12320500612258911,
0.47483715415000916,
-0.0774499699473381,
0.054697055369615555,
-0.3011428713798523,
-0.19031837582588196,
-1.0717989206314087,
-0.029665151610970497,
0.4045063257217407,
0.45496466755867004,
-0.1513897031545639,
-0.042848702520132065,
-0.29477065801620483,
-0.4616256654262543,
-0.5104283094406128,
0.1438881754875183,
0.649946928024292,
0.5370533466339111,
0.28197890520095825,
-0.26020047068595886,
-0.2880084812641144,
-0.9343147873878479,
-0.2686683237552643,
-0.054117169231176376,
0.04443572461605072,
0.36511218547821045,
0.312661349773407,
-0.25007864832878113,
0.41376203298568726,
-0.4014682173728943,
-0.286296546459198,
-0.10617395490407944,
0.1256074607372284,
0.24161767959594727,
0.5054699182510376,
0.25261276960372925,
-0.11340128630399704,
-0.5470945239067078,
0.10398849844932556,
-0.3930715024471283,
-0.22072282433509827,
-0.10974665731191635,
0.14441752433776855,
0.3402111828327179,
0.6413632035255432,
-0.6255077123641968,
0.41018298268318176,
0.38925957679748535,
0.2950478494167328,
0.3545568585395813,
-0.17664512991905212,
-0.04831737279891968,
-0.31032872200012207,
0.04736196622252464,
0.17953038215637207,
-0.14908047020435333,
-0.7198143005371094,
0.1716294139623642,
-0.02598422020673752,
0.2435029298067093,
-0.32019704580307007,
0.7538970708847046,
-0.4366248846054077,
-0.3603290915489197,
-0.1870332807302475,
0.07422485947608948,
-0.11137765645980835,
0.871220052242279,
-0.4822673201560974,
0.4607362449169159,
0.7782264351844788,
-0.776490330696106,
0.3822858929634094,
-0.24851712584495544,
-0.28941088914871216,
0.37232184410095215,
-0.7320923209190369,
0.15168261528015137,
-0.3380129635334015,
0.21168705821037292,
-0.9762917757034302,
-0.0142216170206666,
0.25774502754211426,
-0.10983795672655106,
0.5046294331550598,
-0.16180744767189026,
-0.1656552404165268,
-0.3928317129611969,
-0.5177013874053955,
0.565636396408081,
0.4110162854194641,
-0.36625632643699646,
0.47701212763786316,
0.1779106706380844,
-0.18849478662014008,
-0.7376450300216675,
-0.9650949239730835,
-0.07070230692625046,
-0.08211615681648254,
-0.4309059977531433,
0.17304950952529907,
0.02600357122719288,
-0.17556004226207733,
-0.14633144438266754,
-0.09500651806592941,
0.021087534725666046,
0.22573119401931763,
0.10651449859142303,
-0.26227957010269165,
-0.35157862305641174,
0.04907011613249779,
-0.3913598954677582,
0.0264305230230093,
0.19227953255176544,
-0.4275297522544861,
0.7488545179367065,
-0.1902683675289154,
-0.5565212368965149,
-0.6269572377204895,
0.3464595377445221,
0.4591316878795624,
-0.23202133178710938,
0.5646010041236877,
0.6105617880821228,
-0.24602673947811127,
-0.5173642039299011,
-0.48781558871269226,
0.17918778955936432,
-0.40077903866767883,
0.7058326601982117,
-0.22058738768100739,
-0.9184411764144897,
1.01740562915802,
0.1414674073457718,
0.02109629102051258,
0.39928048849105835,
0.627075731754303,
-0.07041056454181671,
0.781718373298645,
0.5708392858505249,
-0.15721996128559113,
0.5261441469192505,
-0.403365820646286,
0.16771766543388367,
-1.0430634021759033,
-0.4749816358089447,
-0.6291764378547668,
-0.6379258632659912,
-0.5266473889350891,
-0.33277627825737,
0.2678646743297577,
0.14730283617973328,
-0.6991996169090271,
-0.17119993269443512,
-0.14004434645175934,
0.5961830019950867,
0.41749924421310425,
0.17992331087589264,
0.16136376559734344,
0.09448229521512985,
-0.008102585561573505,
0.07933378219604492,
-0.7062295079231262,
-0.21474063396453857,
0.9698984622955322,
0.5103577375411987,
1.217896580696106,
-0.17666198313236237,
0.7911666035652161,
0.0378342866897583,
0.29264163970947266,
-1.1180782318115234,
0.7018816471099854,
-0.4107494056224823,
-0.2288878858089447,
-0.6270739436149597,
-0.45594674348831177,
-1.0023833513259888,
0.10859260708093643,
0.2968723475933075,
-0.836906909942627,
-0.002255217172205448,
0.25428351759910583,
-0.5378987789154053,
0.38494259119033813,
-0.49092158675193787,
0.5555065870285034,
0.09948382526636124,
-0.5307541489601135,
-0.19510561227798462,
-0.8083122372627258,
0.2811110019683838,
-0.033077895641326904,
0.1269713044166565,
-0.0194696094840765,
0.13108938932418823,
0.7224293947219849,
-0.5095539689064026,
0.6823388338088989,
-0.20533648133277893,
-0.2339809685945511,
0.20107892155647278,
0.2812683880329132,
0.6505711674690247,
0.11645456403493881,
0.14884963631629944,
0.014863773249089718,
-0.5579304695129395,
-0.42604440450668335,
-0.5236126184463501,
0.9213653802871704,
-0.586784839630127,
-0.7803680896759033,
-0.3003450036048889,
-0.3967519700527191,
-0.25323325395584106,
0.08714480698108673,
0.1813628226518631,
0.7277783155441284,
-0.15147697925567627,
0.10517897456884384,
0.9297396540641785,
-0.16906608641147614,
0.6144623160362244,
0.31610044836997986,
-0.18217003345489502,
-0.022100605070590973,
0.6160025596618652,
0.3631943166255951,
0.34964892268180847,
0.6324442028999329,
0.18802031874656677,
0.08212395757436752,
-0.8207905292510986,
-0.2139236479997635,
0.2804795205593109,
-0.8685904145240784,
-0.04499593749642372,
-0.6729273200035095,
-0.5134685635566711,
0.09094377607107162,
-0.08948928862810135,
-0.6455336809158325,
-0.38631129264831543,
-0.37529194355010986,
0.3007635474205017,
0.006548601668328047,
0.6779175400733948,
0.029829127714037895,
0.340390682220459,
-0.7574794888496399,
0.12401176244020462,
0.540528416633606,
0.5020326972007751,
0.5095165967941284,
-0.670131266117096,
-0.6205545663833618,
0.16295883059501648,
-0.24034462869167328,
-0.4183104336261749,
-0.0950128361582756,
0.4472445249557495,
0.32387322187423706,
0.3700231909751892,
-0.36565250158309937,
0.6455560922622681,
-0.9123790860176086,
0.6119857430458069,
0.16561593115329742,
-0.8548070192337036,
0.012055465020239353,
-0.2114385962486267,
0.39449864625930786,
0.5571584105491638,
0.2218170166015625,
-0.3504016101360321,
-0.2160131186246872,
-0.43374305963516235,
-0.6616655588150024,
1.0741292238235474,
0.11388196796178818,
0.2661893963813782,
0.24919086694717407,
0.39420562982559204,
0.033714696764945984,
0.05008362978696823,
-0.6079529523849487,
-0.47465279698371887,
0.20137327909469604,
0.060748931020498276,
-0.3441590666770935,
-0.22024746239185333,
-0.10490518063306808,
-0.34916409850120544,
0.567193329334259,
0.08687896281480789,
0.4084404408931732,
0.2013518363237381,
-0.021490642800927162,
-0.2805195450782776,
0.27054932713508606,
0.6858934760093689,
0.5306316614151001,
-0.020150868222117424,
0.3030615746974945,
0.1762826293706894,
-0.23374642431735992,
0.15317857265472412,
0.1143154427409172,
-0.0744151845574379,
-0.22570276260375977,
0.7025772929191589,
1.0625436305999756,
0.3219456374645233,
-0.3299632966518402,
0.6613397598266602,
0.08299729228019714,
-0.18157736957073212,
-0.1709669828414917,
0.12072653323411942,
0.22453442215919495,
0.4780435562133789,
0.32289013266563416,
0.1297977715730667,
0.12108087539672852,
-0.5455660820007324,
-0.1366184949874878,
0.44415396451950073,
-0.4220616817474365,
-0.3971204161643982,
0.5600961446762085,
0.09647276997566223,
-0.4517781138420105,
0.5089347958564758,
-0.2008611559867859,
-0.7182556390762329,
0.7211247682571411,
0.3934169411659241,
1.114912748336792,
-0.18782341480255127,
0.11265616863965988,
0.17327861487865448,
0.20414431393146515,
-0.3230213224887848,
0.1100773811340332,
0.013762733899056911,
-0.3694409430027008,
-0.5401799082756042,
-0.9287991523742676,
-0.3074653446674347,
0.4803411662578583,
-0.4369969666004181,
0.01316575612872839,
-0.7101837992668152,
0.08051490038633347,
0.4178673028945923,
-0.11279661953449249,
-0.57655268907547,
0.3356494903564453,
0.14879219233989716,
0.6284925937652588,
-0.44532930850982666,
0.5102671384811401,
0.6970131993293762,
0.1873970627784729,
-0.7029341459274292,
0.1879022866487503,
-0.35616692900657654,
-1.0324705839157104,
0.9400480389595032,
0.2470991462469101,
-0.46647629141807556,
0.01023503951728344,
-0.6629658341407776,
-0.6282418370246887,
0.7284650802612305,
0.5831587910652161,
-0.7594147324562073,
-0.12141270190477371,
0.17880114912986755,
0.6947263479232788,
-0.4008980989456177,
-0.012311526574194431,
0.5921932458877563,
0.22626955807209015,
0.08444265276193619,
-0.9654093980789185,
-0.20403461158275604,
0.0728726014494896,
0.1532236486673355,
0.41312384605407715,
-0.9521965384483337,
1.3119275569915771,
-0.3299877941608429,
-0.24241769313812256,
0.05639972537755966,
0.4954710304737091,
-0.08498850464820862,
0.37807366251945496,
0.27218541502952576,
0.6489809155464172,
0.5320300459861755,
-0.08366783708333969,
1.0916731357574463,
-0.32816481590270996,
0.7313992381095886,
1.0522918701171875,
-0.12668849527835846,
0.5798985958099365,
0.32211053371429443,
-0.7243067622184753,
0.06454319506883621,
0.49547845125198364,
0.2049654871225357,
0.3290209174156189,
0.5203700661659241,
-0.13158640265464783,
-0.3688076138496399,
0.0027603681664913893,
-0.11408150941133499,
0.2798215448856354,
0.12734466791152954,
-0.36709752678871155,
-0.30163994431495667,
-0.07575714588165283,
0.0982370600104332,
0.06878860294818878,
-0.8435733318328857,
0.39274415373802185,
0.40253639221191406,
-0.5648772120475769,
0.99543696641922,
0.17542560398578644,
0.5696476697921753,
-0.3729616105556488,
0.3027378022670746,
-0.3001519441604614,
0.2899552583694458,
-0.22909536957740784,
-0.8592885136604309,
0.11494993418455124,
-0.1397581249475479,
-0.2496495544910431,
0.21439404785633087,
0.31774479150772095,
-0.38629916310310364,
-0.41540056467056274,
0.34010833501815796,
0.08360876142978668,
-0.003258097218349576,
0.04262251406908035,
-0.5405979156494141,
0.016222266480326653,
-0.07432785630226135,
-0.5544835925102234,
0.27798181772232056,
0.45609813928604126,
0.06546781212091446,
1.012851595878601,
0.115071140229702,
0.1610850989818573,
0.557987630367279,
0.22068560123443604,
0.8594913482666016,
-0.4373575747013092,
-0.4450896978378296,
-1.1498326063156128,
0.06985540688037872,
0.3172681927680969,
-0.32307708263397217,
0.5268767476081848,
0.3503638803958893,
0.8365805745124817,
-0.14644400775432587,
0.5089993476867676,
0.286882609128952,
0.24149766564369202,
-0.7862972617149353,
0.25987502932548523,
-0.7021273374557495,
0.4095534384250641,
-0.20638513565063477,
-1.082228660583496,
-0.364723801612854,
0.44490450620651245,
-0.25375550985336304,
0.3368764817714691,
0.8452190160751343,
0.7642154693603516,
-0.12786418199539185,
-0.18373143672943115,
0.18269532918930054,
0.48178771138191223,
0.026979347690939903,
1.053898572921753,
0.6973647475242615,
-0.4424806237220764,
0.2621007263660431,
-0.32012343406677246,
-0.012332282029092312,
-0.40467560291290283,
-0.6257457733154297,
-1.0708106756210327,
-0.4491535723209381,
-0.31035178899765015,
-0.31882432103157043,
0.020686212927103043,
0.8092660307884216,
0.45131915807724,
-0.8483846187591553,
-0.012351548299193382,
-0.3344789445400238,
-0.0527186319231987,
0.11609122902154922,
-0.08899734169244766,
0.47374290227890015,
-0.17619745433330536,
-0.8804094195365906,
0.047598402947187424,
0.5548093318939209,
0.01748182438313961,
-0.6122255921363831,
-0.22875750064849854,
-0.2593809962272644,
0.2265348732471466,
0.5285428166389465,
0.4627438485622406,
-0.7334874868392944,
-0.20214135944843292,
-0.1926000863313675,
-0.4493154287338257,
0.3089703917503357,
0.7620481252670288,
-0.40650948882102966,
0.2528705596923828,
0.5767360329627991,
1.0160105228424072,
0.7313029766082764,
-0.25090181827545166,
0.17852221429347992,
-0.6268182396888733,
0.14580334722995758,
0.14755278825759888,
0.31354519724845886,
0.40062087774276733,
-0.19821977615356445,
0.2428150326013565,
0.17115092277526855,
-0.6606490015983582,
-0.8030794858932495,
0.44091376662254333,
-1.0831851959228516,
0.048713088035583496,
1.2555702924728394,
-0.2710452973842621,
-0.3894954323768616,
0.12130659818649292,
-0.08724331110715866,
0.2271963208913803,
-0.285185843706131,
0.6063471436500549,
0.743590235710144,
-0.18399678170681,
0.014105786569416523,
-0.31385162472724915,
0.4027160406112671,
0.5263170599937439,
-0.3157534897327423,
0.32388654351234436,
0.0947866216301918,
0.32557356357574463,
0.1450553834438324,
0.6819734573364258,
0.035501621663570404,
-0.04639928787946701,
-0.22074635326862335,
-0.24482809007167816,
-0.15751615166664124,
-0.49482521414756775,
-0.8706321716308594,
0.31436464190483093,
0.10047780722379684,
0.07545780390501022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04492v1 | ColorSwap: A Color and Word Order Dataset for Multimodal Evaluation | 2024-02-07T00:31:49 | 2024-02-07T00:31:49 | Jirayu Burapacheep, Ishan Gaur, Agam Bhatia, Tristan Thrush | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This paper introduces the ColorSwap dataset, designed to assess and improve
the proficiency of multimodal models in matching objects with their colors. The
dataset is comprised of 2,000 unique image-caption pairs, grouped into 1,000
examples. Each example includes a caption-image pair, along with a
``color-swapped'' pair. We follow the Winoground schema: the two captions in an
example have the same words, but the color words have been rearranged to modify
different objects. The dataset was created through a novel blend of automated
caption and image generation with humans in the loop. We evaluate image-text
matching (ITM) and visual language models (VLMs) and find that even the latest
ones are still not robust at this task. GPT-4V and LLaVA score 72% and 42% on
our main VLM metric, although they may improve with more advanced prompting
techniques. On the main ITM metric, contrastive models such as CLIP and SigLIP
perform close to chance (at 12% and 30%, respectively), although the
non-contrastive BLIP ITM model is stronger (87%). We also find that finetuning
on fewer than 2,000 examples yields significant performance gains on this
out-of-distribution word-order understanding task. The dataset is here:
https://github.com/Top34051/colorswap. | [
-0.3834710121154785,
-0.12397581338882446,
0.3135530948638916,
0.5376384854316711,
-0.45688948035240173,
0.03091898374259472,
-0.23521974682807922,
-0.6360083222389221,
-0.19427452981472015,
0.31500130891799927,
-0.4161842167377472,
-0.6624345779418945,
-0.8007723689079285,
0.08104526251554489,
-0.27639514207839966,
0.673821210861206,
0.03943190351128578,
0.13552561402320862,
-0.20721890032291412,
-0.8042714595794678,
-0.8763598203659058,
0.018710512667894363,
-0.30797168612480164,
0.013402286916971207,
0.4376576244831085,
0.5259712934494019,
0.8100830316543579,
0.49607038497924805,
0.5655807256698608,
0.4496822953224182,
0.2489452213048935,
0.2421426922082901,
-0.27112770080566406,
0.12403243035078049,
-0.15769822895526886,
-0.42070552706718445,
0.030333153903484344,
0.15616433322429657,
-0.0006437938427552581,
0.4116915464401245,
-0.25976279377937317,
0.3180079460144043,
-0.12154324352741241,
0.6275912523269653,
-0.904226541519165,
0.762761116027832,
-0.7603991627693176,
0.20799963176250458,
-0.1770460158586502,
-0.43821871280670166,
-0.40804773569107056,
-0.05681406334042549,
0.0670459121465683,
-0.606020987033844,
0.22293151915073395,
0.45957112312316895,
0.8725244998931885,
0.09880088269710541,
-0.4236641228199005,
-0.20217452943325043,
-0.4536600112915039,
0.904879629611969,
-0.6129096150398254,
0.40476611256599426,
0.38217779994010925,
0.5478886365890503,
0.010438409633934498,
-0.7325819730758667,
-0.9921435117721558,
-0.011948896571993828,
0.065802201628685,
0.6925079226493835,
-0.19913475215435028,
0.07220245897769928,
0.2997008264064789,
0.40621963143348694,
-0.6181759834289551,
-0.14995098114013672,
-0.6257734298706055,
-0.11578390747308731,
0.5468687415122986,
0.370628297328949,
0.47389349341392517,
-0.26798486709594727,
-0.5632554292678833,
-0.6697885394096375,
-0.05489443987607956,
-0.16196411848068237,
0.2332896888256073,
0.4646196663379669,
-0.318752646446228,
1.0050108432769775,
-0.3577757775783539,
1.0772379636764526,
-0.517146110534668,
-0.2774524688720703,
0.3635435998439789,
-0.6731839179992676,
-0.3291414976119995,
-0.34035998582839966,
0.7328316569328308,
1.0854742527008057,
0.4260762929916382,
-0.008493470959365368,
-0.1368837207555771,
0.5284650325775146,
0.16655802726745605,
-0.5530352592468262,
-0.5117311477661133,
0.23894022405147552,
-0.5336952805519104,
-0.15275852382183075,
0.05384320020675659,
-1.0596280097961426,
-0.5855371952056885,
-0.6331095099449158,
0.8130708336830139,
-0.47285693883895874,
-0.09607145935297012,
0.2288953959941864,
-0.5467427372932434,
0.2566332221031189,
0.39654240012168884,
-0.928268551826477,
0.218353271484375,
0.2651597559452057,
0.8894591927528381,
-0.4345625936985016,
-0.5121600031852722,
-0.07488187402486801,
0.02451469749212265,
-0.2221253365278244,
0.9050700664520264,
-0.5470499396324158,
-0.10629386454820633,
0.06749901920557022,
-0.1560693085193634,
-0.22036908566951752,
-0.43742090463638306,
0.2783997654914856,
-0.6083868741989136,
0.43319839239120483,
-0.3148185908794403,
-0.43176841735839844,
-0.17602570354938507,
0.2505553364753723,
-0.5800480842590332,
0.8694867491722107,
0.09727853536605835,
-0.9110929369926453,
0.5783031582832336,
-0.8422395586967468,
-0.1863938271999359,
0.1399587243795395,
-0.18093915283679962,
-0.14550401270389557,
0.001630396582186222,
0.42378413677215576,
0.39813584089279175,
-0.02235407941043377,
-0.27028030157089233,
-0.5067269206047058,
-0.45926395058631897,
0.06388963758945465,
-0.1977599561214447,
0.6426327228546143,
0.36756259202957153,
-0.19857251644134521,
0.4717487394809723,
-0.6592118144035339,
0.2728302776813507,
0.4466932713985443,
-0.1844830960035324,
-0.20651088654994965,
-0.16281884908676147,
0.5340011119842529,
0.4643296003341675,
0.08693540096282959,
-0.6048552989959717,
0.08509765565395355,
0.14582706987857819,
0.3709375560283661,
0.8482190370559692,
-0.2785170376300812,
0.3728707730770111,
-0.22596082091331482,
0.6077755093574524,
-0.029633676633238792,
0.47811663150787354,
-0.44503623247146606,
-0.7250965237617493,
-0.7521905899047852,
-0.42166227102279663,
0.29478633403778076,
0.6480455994606018,
-0.7888878583908081,
0.042297109961509705,
-0.1390063315629959,
-0.5016093254089355,
-0.45159292221069336,
-0.1406860500574112,
0.27661845088005066,
0.4491429626941681,
0.6431171894073486,
-0.29424235224723816,
-0.14570525288581848,
-0.8815233707427979,
0.06914810836315155,
-0.10534065216779709,
0.033977095037698746,
0.3388432264328003,
0.3202764689922333,
-0.25467783212661743,
0.827397346496582,
-0.7900832295417786,
-0.43687373399734497,
-0.02853241376578808,
0.3628527820110321,
0.06706200540065765,
0.3263900578022003,
0.5459241271018982,
-0.8706371188163757,
-0.30305519700050354,
-0.1428271234035492,
-0.5692679286003113,
0.011382467113435268,
0.18523608148097992,
-0.14800824224948883,
0.14583051204681396,
0.5106847286224365,
-0.314806193113327,
0.27179574966430664,
1.0961450338363647,
-0.47752854228019714,
0.529744029045105,
-0.33979833126068115,
0.5094922184944153,
-1.1633270978927612,
0.09613634645938873,
-0.02373962476849556,
0.036677077412605286,
-0.3286643326282501,
0.14513428509235382,
0.21650539338588715,
-0.43138983845710754,
-0.260904461145401,
0.6754871606826782,
-0.49770036339759827,
-0.4251134991645813,
-0.14491581916809082,
0.1724390834569931,
0.045646023005247116,
0.7485163807868958,
0.0702459067106247,
0.6897616386413574,
0.32980209589004517,
-0.1963222771883011,
0.45481428503990173,
0.4525236487388611,
-0.7206509709358215,
0.774642288684845,
-0.44600820541381836,
0.002310456708073616,
-0.14058081805706024,
-0.23890264332294464,
-1.6112478971481323,
-0.22818860411643982,
0.09439930319786072,
-0.10499183088541031,
0.16291870176792145,
-0.19140292704105377,
-0.7538706660270691,
-0.44121959805488586,
-0.43641647696495056,
0.42957010865211487,
0.24913667142391205,
-0.6123341917991638,
0.29776284098625183,
0.17440100014209747,
-0.6081188321113586,
-0.6902751326560974,
-0.5310590267181396,
0.2372288852930069,
-0.1609669029712677,
-0.6333605051040649,
0.37059494853019714,
-0.4114435315132141,
-0.05722988769412041,
-0.25768858194351196,
-0.0336686372756958,
-0.12094277143478394,
-0.1422286182641983,
0.31451526284217834,
0.3124293088912964,
0.021832585334777832,
0.2115533947944641,
-0.16644173860549927,
0.03836166113615036,
-0.4938417971134186,
0.18181505799293518,
0.6567617058753967,
-0.19245152175426483,
-0.47514262795448303,
-0.24200434982776642,
0.24835188686847687,
0.6868148446083069,
-0.3843911588191986,
0.39401131868362427,
0.5803490281105042,
-0.14327703416347504,
-0.04287209361791611,
-0.5323876738548279,
0.007209150120615959,
-0.5094171166419983,
0.38090699911117554,
-0.20326422154903412,
-0.39637720584869385,
0.35102060437202454,
0.383158415555954,
0.30530083179473877,
0.09168443828821182,
0.29366183280944824,
-0.4557322561740875,
1.148950457572937,
0.7822690010070801,
0.14519047737121582,
0.9008133411407471,
-0.10401986539363861,
-0.2056155949831009,
-0.5892960429191589,
-0.25788894295692444,
-0.24294818937778473,
-0.36974892020225525,
-0.6512380242347717,
-0.5173930525779724,
0.13746704161167145,
0.042499519884586334,
0.1458706110715866,
0.3463587462902069,
-0.3814140856266022,
0.4666311740875244,
0.5093375444412231,
0.26080822944641113,
0.3113696575164795,
0.3537663221359253,
-0.000011734340660041198,
-0.24863412976264954,
-0.7092940807342529,
-0.2483864575624466,
1.0263160467147827,
0.13938623666763306,
0.5720030665397644,
0.06823445856571198,
0.3179643154144287,
0.5092334747314453,
0.39450082182884216,
-0.7570103406906128,
0.5511080622673035,
-0.22565041482448578,
-0.2834300398826599,
-0.21358487010002136,
-0.1454753577709198,
-1.2241278886795044,
0.6149870753288269,
-0.5902611613273621,
-0.4260755777359009,
0.03675142303109169,
0.25716447830200195,
0.1457507461309433,
-0.15709464251995087,
-0.9091495275497437,
1.0858863592147827,
-0.28282681107521057,
-0.15059150755405426,
-0.15192855894565582,
-0.498582124710083,
0.3945111334323883,
0.36826130747795105,
0.1870373636484146,
-0.29272744059562683,
-0.06824091076850891,
0.9002310037612915,
-0.3259311616420746,
0.4282977283000946,
-0.09393080323934555,
0.13401055335998535,
-0.05490030720829964,
-0.0227128267288208,
0.20497001707553864,
-0.4855883717536926,
0.015188786201179028,
0.09527657181024551,
0.08414233475923538,
-0.6374698281288147,
-0.6225994229316711,
0.37082675099372864,
-0.4226917326450348,
-0.09753421694040298,
-0.4161462187767029,
-0.8673244714736938,
-0.49888303875923157,
0.1771993637084961,
0.2829407751560211,
0.5477797985076904,
0.36190932989120483,
-0.2096708118915558,
0.060007818043231964,
-0.2804955542087555,
0.5514124631881714,
0.39516016840934753,
-0.12487094849348068,
-0.6480211615562439,
1.107288122177124,
0.050802551209926605,
0.21106185019016266,
-0.07757514715194702,
0.24184228479862213,
-0.5960338711738586,
-0.9062255620956421,
-0.49551546573638916,
0.306146502494812,
-1.1820101737976074,
-0.23865032196044922,
-0.554563581943512,
0.3639540672302246,
-0.029270030558109283,
-0.07234624773263931,
-0.07172136753797531,
-0.42836543917655945,
0.05161776393651962,
-0.002560504013672471,
0.4893348515033722,
0.9191155433654785,
0.1970740407705307,
0.14253239333629608,
-0.6061986088752747,
0.4808986485004425,
0.6050955057144165,
0.48806384205818176,
-0.15436843037605286,
-0.4025012254714966,
0.13049574196338654,
-0.31935054063796997,
-0.16478483378887177,
-1.0255388021469116,
0.3591456413269043,
-0.07151234894990921,
0.556065559387207,
0.28235137462615967,
0.007518717087805271,
1.1021946668624878,
-0.4097152650356293,
0.7757872939109802,
0.47076216340065,
-0.7047792077064514,
0.43975546956062317,
-0.4645770490169525,
0.5034174919128418,
0.7102221250534058,
0.14672118425369263,
-0.6603798270225525,
-0.558302104473114,
-0.631525993347168,
-1.0193185806274414,
0.7667552828788757,
0.2966384291648865,
0.057074807584285736,
-0.02233266271650791,
-0.1364593207836151,
0.026655307039618492,
0.5133436918258667,
-0.8586452603340149,
-0.18630395829677582,
-0.43988236784935,
-0.7326827049255371,
-0.13039100170135498,
-0.21146260201931,
-0.256154328584671,
-0.028424307703971863,
0.17567507922649384,
-0.5220292806625366,
0.49632707238197327,
-0.15500260889530182,
-0.32252299785614014,
0.1983274668455124,
0.21332426369190216,
0.940902829170227,
0.8178275227546692,
-0.14953142404556274,
0.1436552256345749,
0.1046055257320404,
-0.32890039682388306,
-0.24044249951839447,
0.17828312516212463,
0.1686415672302246,
-0.15729515254497528,
0.7485079765319824,
0.6576920747756958,
0.12582065165042877,
-0.8134788274765015,
0.7355098724365234,
-0.26348212361335754,
0.1635512262582779,
0.09607888758182526,
0.02876964770257473,
0.03245681896805763,
0.3575535714626312,
0.1872754544019699,
0.198809415102005,
0.19968177378177643,
-0.5316908359527588,
-0.002876721555367112,
0.5488733649253845,
-0.27966707944869995,
-0.13796919584274292,
0.4409870207309723,
0.2615588307380676,
-0.05406336486339569,
0.7099621891975403,
-0.07016739249229431,
-0.40796932578086853,
0.7767322063446045,
0.43574661016464233,
0.2736111879348755,
0.09806905686855316,
0.23212291300296783,
0.48637038469314575,
0.20857882499694824,
-0.2133752554655075,
0.7207593321800232,
-0.47976088523864746,
-0.7833535075187683,
-0.08988887816667557,
-0.5810781717300415,
-0.5412783622741699,
0.060490407049655914,
-0.7064485549926758,
0.3560413718223572,
-0.39828982949256897,
-0.13029375672340393,
-0.06919093430042267,
-0.22402909398078918,
-0.7680909037590027,
0.31729885935783386,
0.3054501414299011,
0.9086887240409851,
-1.0913805961608887,
0.43442070484161377,
0.5594802498817444,
-0.5408259034156799,
-0.3696522116661072,
-0.00860170740634203,
-0.14305666089057922,
-0.8030285835266113,
0.7441739439964294,
0.4007761776447296,
0.02945016697049141,
-0.19286052882671356,
-0.39777424931526184,
-0.7340074181556702,
1.2281763553619385,
0.28118693828582764,
-0.4563387632369995,
0.4296654164791107,
-0.004562093410640955,
0.47963112592697144,
-0.10550671815872192,
0.47020313143730164,
0.16822725534439087,
0.6353707313537598,
-0.10552869737148285,
-0.8160993456840515,
-0.15024887025356293,
-0.2435576617717743,
0.12875406444072723,
-0.0981224924325943,
-0.5980813503265381,
0.6194756031036377,
-0.5228177905082703,
-0.4864368736743927,
0.2138790339231491,
0.6307541131973267,
0.5069986581802368,
0.2916875183582306,
0.8468143343925476,
0.32008039951324463,
0.5788517594337463,
-0.19185376167297363,
1.2009633779525757,
0.028401875868439674,
0.28961440920829773,
1.0498950481414795,
-0.13951969146728516,
1.1086058616638184,
0.631123423576355,
-0.2991676926612854,
0.21285219490528107,
0.6280466914176941,
-0.26440906524658203,
0.7649049758911133,
0.2016870230436325,
0.0848054438829422,
-0.16017739474773407,
-0.02223905920982361,
-0.1414923518896103,
0.5296545624732971,
0.09142947196960449,
-0.18392916023731232,
-0.22205044329166412,
0.13604842126369476,
-0.21224331855773926,
0.17248116433620453,
-0.11512893438339233,
0.6832274198532104,
-0.3175937235355377,
-0.5015160441398621,
0.3396959900856018,
-0.05995127186179161,
0.8594253063201904,
-0.6021934747695923,
-0.28488922119140625,
-0.32908374071121216,
-0.00028045132057741284,
-0.18659712374210358,
-1.1015644073486328,
0.016061486676335335,
-0.23612622916698456,
-0.14613908529281616,
-0.13506931066513062,
0.2738555371761322,
-0.578896701335907,
-0.4383510947227478,
0.5210500955581665,
0.105799600481987,
-0.15766869485378265,
0.23203670978546143,
-1.0789692401885986,
0.30966830253601074,
-0.18500804901123047,
-0.22938035428524017,
0.20186667144298553,
0.044942546635866165,
-0.18782442808151245,
0.559709370136261,
0.6636055707931519,
-0.061213742941617966,
0.26664242148399353,
0.3419122099876404,
0.3952697217464447,
-0.6538439989089966,
-0.3894159495830536,
-0.5112208724021912,
0.5311226844787598,
-0.32515498995780945,
-0.3784889876842499,
0.6492579579353333,
0.2556019723415375,
0.8459429144859314,
-0.3411827087402344,
0.5563482642173767,
0.04113341122865677,
-0.047088198363780975,
-0.6853570938110352,
0.5317081212997437,
-0.7083789706230164,
-0.20846031606197357,
-0.6412132978439331,
-1.0038703680038452,
-0.42643338441848755,
0.5136423707008362,
-0.019920242950320244,
0.2737467885017395,
0.552964985370636,
0.8117388486862183,
-0.29154664278030396,
0.005604668520390987,
0.4334070086479187,
-0.039723385125398636,
0.15032343566417694,
0.1872144341468811,
0.9740481972694397,
-0.6431347131729126,
0.7883279323577881,
-0.5145604014396667,
-0.17750577628612518,
-0.16736158728599548,
-1.0450079441070557,
-0.7693272829055786,
-0.8033977746963501,
-0.48006874322891235,
-0.12129982560873032,
-0.1035594791173935,
0.6894460916519165,
0.9262508749961853,
-0.8128716349601746,
-0.23299545049667358,
0.0954260379076004,
-0.14525362849235535,
-0.44944295287132263,
-0.22623302042484283,
0.3361082971096039,
-0.29297539591789246,
-0.8421380519866943,
0.41948071122169495,
0.3700945973396301,
0.20878875255584717,
0.15409408509731293,
0.048640090972185135,
-0.04980628192424774,
0.09530498832464218,
0.9832267165184021,
0.14203990995883942,
-0.6706386804580688,
-0.27125585079193115,
-0.18159104883670807,
-0.11955440044403076,
0.09582968801259995,
0.5540210604667664,
-0.4209667146205902,
0.8688349723815918,
0.7020268440246582,
0.318473756313324,
0.5010601878166199,
0.05975630134344101,
0.3432680666446686,
-0.8403869271278381,
0.2684948742389679,
-0.11014711111783981,
0.7943043112754822,
0.6046446561813354,
0.19439347088336945,
0.5989348888397217,
0.23396360874176025,
-0.13045071065425873,
-0.7992944121360779,
0.33196744322776794,
-1.3476943969726562,
-0.36331263184547424,
1.0406302213668823,
0.03986567258834839,
0.0698842853307724,
-0.153641477227211,
-0.5703290700912476,
-0.05679183453321457,
-0.2629839777946472,
0.8362354636192322,
0.6352468132972717,
-0.3003388047218323,
-0.4003235697746277,
-0.43341314792633057,
0.33722591400146484,
0.5160026550292969,
-1.05948007106781,
0.19668570160865784,
0.5251824855804443,
0.4424383044242859,
0.407216340303421,
0.5555822849273682,
-0.24893252551555634,
0.4261191785335541,
-0.039635296911001205,
0.24891963601112366,
-0.3475326895713806,
-0.2603430151939392,
-0.4431447982788086,
0.3424895107746124,
0.1218058168888092,
-0.6231859922409058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09676v1 | Unmasking the Shadows of AI: Investigating Deceptive Capabilities in Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T00:21:46 | 2024-02-07T00:21:46 | Linge Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This research critically navigates the intricate landscape of AI deception,
concentrating on deceptive behaviours of Large Language Models (LLMs). My
objective is to elucidate this issue, examine the discourse surrounding it, and
subsequently delve into its categorization and ramifications. The essay
initiates with an evaluation of the AI Safety Summit 2023 (ASS) and
introduction of LLMs, emphasising multidimensional biases that underlie their
deceptive behaviours.The literature review covers four types of deception
categorised: Strategic deception, Imitation, Sycophancy, and Unfaithful
Reasoning, along with the social implications and risks they entail. Lastly, I
take an evaluative stance on various aspects related to navigating the
persistent challenges of the deceptive AI. This encompasses considerations of
international collaborative governance, the reconfigured engagement of
individuals with AI, proposal of practical adjustments, and specific elements
of digital education. | [
-0.22681663930416107,
-0.5359695553779602,
0.6276736259460449,
0.01821744069457054,
-0.023942437022924423,
0.8572333455085754,
0.11134666949510574,
-0.6926044225692749,
0.07055918127298355,
0.8632276058197021,
-0.47466400265693665,
-0.33731192350387573,
-0.7392998337745667,
0.11820917576551437,
-0.7378926277160645,
0.9723572731018066,
0.014375084079802036,
0.2268896996974945,
-0.4363356828689575,
-0.02194315381348133,
-0.09955081343650818,
-0.705269992351532,
-0.78486567735672,
-0.40883374214172363,
0.07553195208311081,
0.01326791848987341,
0.5796571373939514,
0.5522404909133911,
0.5626876950263977,
0.37481173872947693,
0.06817249208688736,
0.21726228296756744,
-0.5004231333732605,
0.022078048437833786,
0.002689661690965295,
-0.7106966376304626,
-0.13160011172294617,
0.42278677225112915,
0.6110684275627136,
0.7115063071250916,
-0.21960805356502533,
0.25422048568725586,
0.23992864787578583,
0.45632508397102356,
-0.6940685510635376,
0.3416028320789337,
-0.5739867687225342,
-0.1823338270187378,
-0.07540391385555267,
0.14092637598514557,
-0.4538494646549225,
-0.0330827571451664,
-0.048716068267822266,
-0.4125381112098694,
0.0734511986374855,
0.3201354444026947,
0.5105100274085999,
0.5362242460250854,
-0.5269268751144409,
-0.38358423113822937,
-1.1235322952270508,
0.871825098991394,
-0.3950406610965729,
0.006176460534334183,
0.48172762989997864,
0.25924789905548096,
-0.05284593254327774,
-0.9131148457527161,
-0.5657177567481995,
-0.24933363497257233,
-0.013673685491085052,
0.06695375591516495,
-0.34781092405319214,
0.3732009530067444,
0.19881781935691833,
0.4134215712547302,
-0.2662847340106964,
0.2560727298259735,
-0.4641398787498474,
-0.4257223606109619,
0.8994911909103394,
0.34865182638168335,
0.36178889870643616,
0.23675018548965454,
-0.16738206148147583,
0.0887625515460968,
-0.701248824596405,
-0.09243092685937881,
0.7599929571151733,
0.06288489699363708,
-0.33107033371925354,
0.27582353353500366,
0.017019059509038925,
0.39567798376083374,
-0.06512836366891861,
-0.20428705215454102,
0.12370672821998596,
-0.36882832646369934,
-0.18641401827335358,
0.16020269691944122,
0.6747943162918091,
0.2697063088417053,
0.2654813826084137,
-0.12646810710430145,
-0.3150593340396881,
0.35954877734184265,
0.49891746044158936,
-0.5532887578010559,
-0.06573576480150223,
0.2897174060344696,
-0.728996753692627,
-0.6450595855712891,
0.13896048069000244,
-0.8357205986976624,
-0.8058585524559021,
-0.2392585426568985,
0.3036145567893982,
-0.09119658172130585,
-0.2464563250541687,
0.07913871854543686,
-0.05097033083438873,
0.361141175031662,
0.24844296276569366,
-0.7399348020553589,
0.4931739866733551,
0.8471148610115051,
0.4715925455093384,
-0.06846269965171814,
-0.27783486247062683,
-0.06626775860786438,
0.13978368043899536,
-0.4849189519882202,
0.2843196392059326,
-0.6431590914726257,
-0.3992573022842407,
0.2058955878019333,
0.0039237732999026775,
-0.08852583169937134,
-0.4392549991607666,
0.48423999547958374,
-0.3300430178642273,
0.37992778420448303,
0.025418462231755257,
-0.08676078915596008,
-0.4236500561237335,
0.35491567850112915,
-0.7807104587554932,
0.7317793369293213,
-0.05373271927237511,
-0.471614807844162,
0.02845868654549122,
-0.8619512915611267,
-0.3023819625377655,
0.0302406158298254,
-0.6592384576797485,
-0.3536655902862549,
0.04927971959114075,
0.19188906252384186,
0.20960400998592377,
-0.45720648765563965,
0.2794177234172821,
0.02738066203892231,
-0.5782150626182556,
0.21291139721870422,
-0.8722569346427917,
1.2205588817596436,
0.012432385236024857,
-0.7079702019691467,
0.03890867903828621,
-0.7890579700469971,
-0.2885613739490509,
0.31697878241539,
0.03666321933269501,
-0.383352130651474,
-0.11090536415576935,
-0.3588968515396118,
-0.180974543094635,
0.38084742426872253,
-0.40068352222442627,
-0.0019317003898322582,
-0.44264423847198486,
0.5799686908721924,
0.9276803135871887,
0.06571334600448608,
0.5269346237182617,
-0.39112773537635803,
0.7278384566307068,
-0.07145387679338455,
0.4902370274066925,
-0.2676713764667511,
-0.32355526089668274,
-0.7365947961807251,
-0.11316520720720291,
0.2302079051733017,
0.4586847126483917,
-0.9124315977096558,
0.20216573774814606,
-0.12119776755571365,
-0.2982024550437927,
-1.0255001783370972,
-0.10482360422611237,
0.6460137963294983,
-0.02288401871919632,
-0.059246666729450226,
-0.16309911012649536,
-0.3539871573448181,
-0.9926159977912903,
-0.1692531257867813,
-0.5534533858299255,
0.19420991837978363,
0.2123737633228302,
0.8701573610305786,
-0.2251313179731369,
0.35837435722351074,
-0.012610848061740398,
-0.3700261414051056,
-0.12667490541934967,
0.23923635482788086,
-0.34583204984664917,
0.41052117943763733,
0.5416169762611389,
-1.0222657918930054,
-0.2809672951698303,
-0.25420254468917847,
-0.8152558207511902,
0.2628079354763031,
-0.30811285972595215,
0.4590928554534912,
0.24665024876594543,
0.793921947479248,
-0.5634015202522278,
0.500972330570221,
0.7161393165588379,
-0.31054553389549255,
0.6479858160018921,
0.03605629503726959,
0.39787575602531433,
-0.8308285474777222,
0.05768883600831032,
-0.36038386821746826,
0.24967025220394135,
-0.5933613777160645,
0.3764728903770447,
-0.5258991718292236,
0.11918648332357407,
-0.37416785955429077,
0.38768208026885986,
-0.7851212620735168,
0.016483522951602936,
-0.21147878468036652,
0.05731472745537758,
-0.10314913839101791,
0.19220125675201416,
-0.5831307172775269,
0.8731550574302673,
0.7526680827140808,
-0.2695666253566742,
0.3991295397281647,
0.015133056789636612,
-0.5725216269493103,
0.41649574041366577,
-0.30718427896499634,
0.3252185583114624,
-0.26958510279655457,
0.24709272384643555,
-1.0440218448638916,
-0.18683169782161713,
0.4505830407142639,
-0.5686719417572021,
0.15134014189243317,
0.04688280075788498,
-0.7481463551521301,
-0.3885430693626404,
-0.32767653465270996,
0.6203267574310303,
0.5416655540466309,
-0.42611992359161377,
0.9752900004386902,
0.41374459862709045,
0.20508909225463867,
-0.8636175990104675,
-0.6699873805046082,
0.4468437731266022,
-0.4672482907772064,
-0.29660722613334656,
0.5354088544845581,
-0.10592960566282272,
-1.0787347555160522,
-0.21199138462543488,
0.04859821870923042,
0.23264147341251373,
0.41216984391212463,
0.546608567237854,
0.06423245370388031,
0.044679805636405945,
-0.36708471179008484,
-0.32168737053871155,
-0.1417136937379837,
0.5954132676124573,
-0.009497097693383694,
0.43054911494255066,
-0.0293253343552351,
-0.5969333648681641,
-0.5189144611358643,
0.31388041377067566,
0.8809879422187805,
-0.10310767590999603,
0.7839229702949524,
0.49387016892433167,
-0.42902711033821106,
-0.25770103931427,
-0.46908238530158997,
-0.4141056537628174,
-0.4980003237724304,
0.21989278495311737,
-0.07905173301696777,
-0.8218746185302734,
0.8022040128707886,
-0.21289300918579102,
0.11424709111452103,
0.2862911522388458,
0.32737961411476135,
0.04312416538596153,
1.3313051462173462,
1.204772710800171,
-0.2892100512981415,
0.2104199081659317,
-0.35177674889564514,
0.3695876896381378,
-0.5270069241523743,
-0.6349323987960815,
-0.57558673620224,
-0.08614099770784378,
-0.7255963087081909,
-0.21287454664707184,
0.3705129027366638,
-0.2987443506717682,
-0.3391624093055725,
-0.2602379024028778,
-0.4680635929107666,
0.5843759179115295,
0.6423231959342957,
-0.07273411005735397,
0.4095200002193451,
-0.05608197674155235,
0.11240673810243607,
0.10251082479953766,
-0.40189290046691895,
-0.707294762134552,
1.1088075637817383,
0.4841592013835907,
0.635116696357727,
0.14306166768074036,
0.455543577671051,
0.3974575698375702,
0.31526005268096924,
-0.4885474443435669,
0.8362549543380737,
0.007816330529749393,
-0.7532809972763062,
-0.10950445383787155,
-0.09118418395519257,
-0.9111106395721436,
0.14922279119491577,
-0.2615809738636017,
-0.8895753026008606,
-0.18027693033218384,
-0.2484273761510849,
-0.3181280493736267,
0.47691333293914795,
-0.3269372284412384,
0.39038220047950745,
-0.49518483877182007,
-0.0540497824549675,
-0.43424302339553833,
-0.7627263069152832,
0.6981942653656006,
-0.10003472864627838,
0.3469034731388092,
0.03751832991838455,
-0.1575814038515091,
0.9929161071777344,
0.11631021648645401,
1.3204495906829834,
0.03914922848343849,
-0.2934725284576416,
0.2800908386707306,
0.1099688932299614,
0.3894708454608917,
-0.3256053626537323,
0.004064296837896109,
0.5653669238090515,
-0.023257868364453316,
-0.32702603936195374,
-0.5267078876495361,
0.4525395929813385,
-0.8774764537811279,
-1.05115807056427,
-0.5587610602378845,
-0.4930590093135834,
-0.26998257637023926,
0.3256504535675049,
0.026796407997608185,
0.23780429363250732,
-0.49236589670181274,
0.10586074739694595,
0.7363449335098267,
-0.13486774265766144,
0.44754573702812195,
0.42050647735595703,
-0.20243056118488312,
-0.33844947814941406,
0.6601799130439758,
-0.06853406876325607,
0.24669265747070312,
0.1884741634130478,
-0.15952175855636597,
-0.06768078356981277,
-1.0018810033798218,
-0.26149308681488037,
0.28996995091438293,
-0.6737278699874878,
0.11453816294670105,
-0.31880003213882446,
-0.6052643060684204,
-0.4075720012187958,
-0.1423037350177765,
-0.259590208530426,
-0.08679356426000595,
-0.4214094281196594,
-0.24702121317386627,
0.01392439380288124,
1.1843152046203613,
0.03768141195178032,
0.6025257110595703,
-0.24765713512897491,
0.15684406459331512,
0.00008605254697613418,
0.1147858127951622,
0.062414076179265976,
-0.37802112102508545,
-0.13882218301296234,
0.14896313846111298,
-0.2805379331111908,
-0.6058850288391113,
0.09146634489297867,
-0.36668041348457336,
0.9118940830230713,
0.6725245118141174,
0.2701820433139801,
0.3856792449951172,
-0.2895686626434326,
1.2083570957183838,
0.19337862730026245,
-0.6067739129066467,
0.1314905434846878,
-0.28642770648002625,
-0.18281744420528412,
0.4355541169643402,
0.4433923363685608,
-0.16635586321353912,
-0.5612705945968628,
-0.8879210948944092,
-0.8390156030654907,
0.4011055529117584,
0.18798887729644775,
0.4684610366821289,
0.441737562417984,
0.4050632417201996,
0.23285843431949615,
0.5002499222755432,
-0.9592611789703369,
-0.8263367414474487,
0.33618152141571045,
-0.1933446079492569,
-0.21344976127147675,
-0.36245039105415344,
-0.6278018355369568,
0.09714031964540482,
0.5290775895118713,
-0.09934306144714355,
0.2890303134918213,
-0.3303559124469757,
0.22270944714546204,
-0.1424093097448349,
-0.10562491416931152,
0.44130226969718933,
0.8070515394210815,
0.38357865810394287,
0.31758618354797363,
-0.09817856550216675,
-0.6028674244880676,
0.22437922656536102,
0.05975913628935814,
-0.1974770873785019,
-0.3660378158092499,
0.8450124263763428,
0.5614227652549744,
-0.17504043877124786,
-0.6699408292770386,
0.5032495856285095,
0.03820136561989784,
-0.457109659910202,
-0.685810923576355,
0.15695974230766296,
-0.30675646662712097,
0.3633146584033966,
0.6640558838844299,
0.12901605665683746,
0.16646713018417358,
-0.942847490310669,
-0.025829005986452103,
0.7718798518180847,
-0.2590544521808624,
-0.35525786876678467,
0.6009480953216553,
0.22472678124904633,
-0.4426916241645813,
0.712647020816803,
-0.0015275715850293636,
-0.6306189298629761,
0.6941025257110596,
0.2739531993865967,
0.9767991304397583,
-0.3487636148929596,
0.3895576000213623,
-0.1730784773826599,
0.9073481559753418,
0.048073697835206985,
0.01063972245901823,
0.0596928671002388,
-0.8009224534034729,
-0.26823851466178894,
-0.21032005548477173,
-0.346545547246933,
0.6061794757843018,
-0.4864158034324646,
-0.08036752790212631,
-0.4970238506793976,
0.06849268823862076,
0.1511535346508026,
0.24908113479614258,
-0.3878321051597595,
-0.007516889832913876,
0.27207425236701965,
0.7895293235778809,
-0.8211358189582825,
0.42684051394462585,
0.355437695980072,
-0.4327974319458008,
-0.2572668790817261,
0.4700387716293335,
0.40624576807022095,
-1.1139330863952637,
0.36719849705696106,
0.2133539915084839,
-0.44037988781929016,
0.10138043761253357,
-1.023823618888855,
-0.6507655382156372,
1.0673892498016357,
0.43109962344169617,
-0.17449286580085754,
-0.2588520348072052,
0.5086020827293396,
0.6640356779098511,
-0.5581856369972229,
0.06659611314535141,
0.7431464791297913,
0.5132483839988708,
-0.23202793300151825,
-1.0479750633239746,
0.09310133010149002,
0.03323192894458771,
-0.2673625349998474,
-0.12389382719993591,
-0.9544212222099304,
0.5620641112327576,
-0.3423801362514496,
-0.4286492168903351,
0.34498536586761475,
0.3085246980190277,
-0.12584583461284637,
0.5476971864700317,
0.33873555064201355,
0.2823522090911865,
0.6523694396018982,
-0.10218540579080582,
0.7942742705345154,
-0.38457056879997253,
-0.25113460421562195,
0.5999235510826111,
-0.24514532089233398,
0.24442194402217865,
0.5033673644065857,
-0.09206866472959518,
0.7460136413574219,
0.5951996445655823,
-0.18286991119384766,
0.5111634731292725,
0.22354410588741302,
-0.2891547679901123,
-0.13615787029266357,
-0.32357603311538696,
-0.04917283356189728,
0.8402295112609863,
0.5691002011299133,
-0.47588980197906494,
-0.06023792922496796,
0.13575412333011627,
0.03887229040265083,
0.4292018413543701,
-0.5426253080368042,
0.9170069694519043,
0.10656033456325531,
-0.7090993523597717,
0.20337359607219696,
0.15544360876083374,
0.4497523903846741,
-0.2790169417858124,
-0.32483717799186707,
0.011056060902774334,
0.1642262190580368,
0.06971651315689087,
-0.8177285194396973,
0.16562440991401672,
-0.4253970980644226,
0.01636817306280136,
-0.4708936810493469,
0.5424912571907043,
-0.1388985961675644,
-0.3447122275829315,
0.4238571524620056,
0.5916708111763,
0.20890463888645172,
0.007457909639924765,
-1.1364121437072754,
0.4003373682498932,
0.135184183716774,
0.110092893242836,
0.2984931170940399,
0.25440743565559387,
-0.19251959025859833,
1.0302679538726807,
0.581503689289093,
-0.021753283217549324,
-0.30136197805404663,
-0.08260098844766617,
0.5516119599342346,
-0.6374209523200989,
-0.6039494276046753,
-0.8681498765945435,
0.41897717118263245,
-0.06866234540939331,
-0.09251322597265244,
0.923964262008667,
0.43678608536720276,
0.8179425001144409,
0.32161444425582886,
0.9547688961029053,
0.21560770273208618,
0.16697295010089874,
-0.4574488401412964,
0.8919062614440918,
-0.33268967270851135,
0.5070803761482239,
-0.0806393027305603,
-0.5562143325805664,
-0.17944873869419098,
0.345926433801651,
-0.29305291175842285,
0.3486673831939697,
0.4490813612937927,
0.6250140070915222,
0.2597861588001251,
0.10198790580034256,
0.4257895052433014,
0.4353530704975128,
0.15889155864715576,
0.19430659711360931,
1.127303123474121,
-0.37150976061820984,
0.48156192898750305,
-0.09354918450117111,
-0.12901590764522552,
-0.16081611812114716,
-0.5136111378669739,
-1.1782052516937256,
-0.8598312735557556,
-0.4391181766986847,
-0.6685547828674316,
0.18834984302520752,
0.2952999174594879,
0.5151364207267761,
-0.5072617530822754,
-0.2076703906059265,
0.04782635346055031,
0.4248315095901489,
-0.238653764128685,
-0.24032042920589447,
0.2912192642688751,
0.319223016500473,
-0.8809162974357605,
0.21987682580947876,
0.12134245038032532,
0.34093940258026123,
-1.0850472450256348,
0.02532465197145939,
0.21666990220546722,
0.3556893765926361,
0.4139818847179413,
-0.021003540605306625,
-0.9768998622894287,
-0.31030699610710144,
-0.2911868393421173,
-0.03637634217739105,
-0.29216399788856506,
0.7310191988945007,
-0.7140223979949951,
0.16166037321090698,
-0.0959678515791893,
0.5230858325958252,
0.05833325907588005,
0.008202522993087769,
0.614717960357666,
-0.5289490818977356,
-0.012286110781133175,
0.4142668545246124,
0.17513257265090942,
0.3438463509082794,
-0.5725524425506592,
0.4547150433063507,
0.33928167819976807,
-0.4125930964946747,
-1.3044756650924683,
0.3481251299381256,
-0.651587188243866,
-0.6881129741668701,
1.177028775215149,
0.1430383324623108,
-0.08462532609701157,
-0.4632883369922638,
-0.009603865444660187,
-0.13645222783088684,
-0.06823279708623886,
1.2295888662338257,
0.7264582514762878,
-0.13744276762008667,
-0.1736069917678833,
-0.5542351603507996,
0.8316319584846497,
-0.013342623598873615,
-0.6511518955230713,
0.27269136905670166,
0.5022230744361877,
0.13841138780117035,
0.5770254731178284,
0.4897395968437195,
-0.21822449564933777,
0.05988728627562523,
0.4125184714794159,
-0.1558854877948761,
-0.07105652242898941,
-0.5707982778549194,
-0.4459751844406128,
0.2553558945655823,
-0.0551096647977829,
-0.13438235223293304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04477v1 | Detecting Mode Collapse in Language Models via Narration | 2024-02-06T23:52:58 | 2024-02-06T23:52:58 | Sil Hamilton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | No two authors write alike. Personal flourishes invoked in written
narratives, from lexicon to rhetorical devices, imply a particular author--what
literary theorists label the implied or virtual author; distinct from the real
author or narrator of a text. Early large language models trained on unfiltered
training sets drawn from a variety of discordant sources yielded incoherent
personalities, problematic for conversational tasks but proving useful for
sampling literature from multiple perspectives. Successes in alignment research
in recent years have allowed researchers to impose subjectively consistent
personae on language models via instruction tuning and reinforcement learning
from human feedback (RLHF), but whether aligned models retain the ability to
model an arbitrary virtual author has received little scrutiny. By studying
4,374 stories sampled from three OpenAI language models, we show successive
versions of GPT-3 suffer from increasing degrees of "mode collapse" whereby
overfitting the model during alignment constrains it from generalizing over
authorship: models suffering from mode collapse become unable to assume a
multiplicity of perspectives. Our method and results are significant for
researchers seeking to employ language models in sociological simulations. | [
-0.2884247899055481,
-0.7299544215202332,
0.9835962653160095,
-0.03939511999487877,
0.05321770906448364,
0.021683352068066597,
-0.3122711479663849,
-0.47923168540000916,
0.09677750617265701,
0.5390498042106628,
-0.48902031779289246,
-0.23730029165744781,
-0.5334284901618958,
0.14150266349315643,
-0.49384644627571106,
1.241381287574768,
-0.24357888102531433,
0.0287521593272686,
-0.3306334912776947,
-0.26450100541114807,
-0.3778891861438751,
-0.45168474316596985,
-0.5174840092658997,
-0.36971601843833923,
0.3948040008544922,
-0.08923100680112839,
0.7566220164299011,
0.49889546632766724,
0.1071217730641365,
0.33825168013572693,
0.14703544974327087,
0.02819014899432659,
-0.45694616436958313,
0.30270153284072876,
0.18317167460918427,
-0.563506543636322,
-0.3034038841724396,
0.37128108739852905,
0.8438076376914978,
0.49839797616004944,
0.032272107899188995,
-0.11963746696710587,
0.38202011585235596,
0.3205883800983429,
-0.5131234526634216,
0.2819269597530365,
-0.32801494002342224,
-0.07465432584285736,
-0.1692028045654297,
-0.09962471574544907,
-0.6724098920822144,
-0.43539825081825256,
0.1093524694442749,
-0.30234289169311523,
0.2727881968021393,
-0.1280631721019745,
0.9558686017990112,
-0.05215379223227501,
-0.57759690284729,
-0.08602123707532883,
-1.0921216011047363,
0.6613870859146118,
-0.7043160796165466,
0.15959306061267853,
0.39660724997520447,
0.18897081911563873,
0.06857647746801376,
-0.27056095004081726,
-0.723042368888855,
-0.5659510493278503,
-0.40410444140434265,
0.1344892829656601,
0.14552359282970428,
0.1905689686536789,
0.10572629421949387,
0.19433169066905975,
-0.5240738391876221,
0.11895277351140976,
-0.35457780957221985,
-0.15950456261634827,
0.27779510617256165,
0.19115781784057617,
0.5331229567527771,
-0.3940662741661072,
-0.35773056745529175,
-0.09402478486299515,
-0.6142994165420532,
0.037691790610551834,
0.7816431522369385,
0.07155247032642365,
-0.24146702885627747,
0.4310492277145386,
0.18143489956855774,
0.6203616857528687,
0.02743556536734104,
-0.36415693163871765,
0.08935210853815079,
-0.23508220911026,
-0.1383402943611145,
-0.011281812563538551,
0.9743618369102478,
0.2667805254459381,
0.25314295291900635,
-0.22504013776779175,
-0.23862458765506744,
-0.07755912840366364,
0.2518310844898224,
-0.36913758516311646,
-0.10512538999319077,
0.16824130713939667,
-0.4213763475418091,
-0.20637059211730957,
0.194293811917305,
-0.46168413758277893,
-0.6399939656257629,
-0.19825993478298187,
0.5071367621421814,
-0.4806016683578491,
-0.5321950316429138,
-0.0969773530960083,
-0.04013538360595703,
0.273685485124588,
0.16381117701530457,
-0.8209452033042908,
0.388517826795578,
0.8088013529777527,
0.9594110250473022,
-0.10522045195102692,
-0.6877785921096802,
-0.4939670264720917,
0.08540160208940506,
-0.18979956209659576,
0.6935308575630188,
-0.48440659046173096,
-0.31849583983421326,
0.18914951384067535,
-0.0644662082195282,
-0.37428751587867737,
-0.1705419421195984,
0.42759403586387634,
-0.19043071568012238,
0.5894781351089478,
-0.23249508440494537,
-0.53631991147995,
-0.18571163713932037,
0.27485567331314087,
-0.7590563297271729,
0.5701123476028442,
0.10717394202947617,
-0.6958255171775818,
0.400858610868454,
-0.2544378340244293,
-0.2366665154695511,
-0.08786432445049286,
-0.6370477676391602,
-0.5227555632591248,
0.25822514295578003,
0.02138315886259079,
0.40244874358177185,
-0.25060874223709106,
0.47994735836982727,
-0.26286011934280396,
-0.15730850398540497,
0.3447975516319275,
-0.2735069990158081,
0.7565072178840637,
-0.07653433829545975,
-0.2643343508243561,
0.23135727643966675,
-0.43694064021110535,
-0.2601352334022522,
0.21377800405025482,
-0.21456699073314667,
-0.3003135025501251,
0.175566628575325,
0.22226230800151825,
-0.05074068158864975,
-0.05324168875813484,
-0.5604032874107361,
0.3021952509880066,
-0.27738115191459656,
0.4011417329311371,
0.6223307251930237,
0.030796974897384644,
0.353023499250412,
-0.8327643871307373,
0.767893373966217,
-0.05565580353140831,
-0.03501169756054878,
-0.18652835488319397,
-0.4892212152481079,
-0.6706314086914062,
-0.18856267631053925,
0.2597227096557617,
0.40008220076560974,
-0.6349693536758423,
0.2628321647644043,
-0.37093445658683777,
-0.30969399213790894,
-0.47752031683921814,
-0.07345359772443771,
0.6075959801673889,
0.5447741746902466,
0.0483490489423275,
-0.17612625658512115,
-0.46550580859184265,
-1.0959454774856567,
-0.6103670597076416,
-0.5788020491600037,
-0.17921774089336395,
-0.009282005950808525,
0.43567588925361633,
0.08107038587331772,
1.001412034034729,
-0.3013416826725006,
-0.31764909625053406,
-0.6009415984153748,
0.37391749024391174,
-0.11341479420661926,
0.4415799081325531,
0.7065426707267761,
-0.713078498840332,
-0.47110095620155334,
0.019912367686629295,
-0.7939247488975525,
0.06366293132305145,
-0.4775058627128601,
0.29143327474594116,
0.39314472675323486,
0.4716165363788605,
-0.44356077909469604,
0.2197290062904358,
0.5952942967414856,
-0.3457355499267578,
0.8381572365760803,
-0.08980805426836014,
0.35219141840934753,
-1.016721487045288,
0.042624663561582565,
0.1948344111442566,
-0.26951155066490173,
-0.6152762770652771,
0.016180284321308136,
0.06121885031461716,
0.14622054994106293,
-0.015076705254614353,
0.45856237411499023,
-0.6000548601150513,
0.13771754503250122,
-0.15689799189567566,
0.29358577728271484,
-0.11789312213659286,
0.5917275547981262,
0.07306279987096786,
0.42412617802619934,
0.12036990374326706,
-0.20579741895198822,
-0.12944607436656952,
0.15495441854000092,
-0.48914602398872375,
0.4620429277420044,
-0.5683304071426392,
0.24696126580238342,
-0.45653772354125977,
0.3712204396724701,
-1.1100447177886963,
-0.6762402653694153,
0.24445080757141113,
-0.29871028661727905,
0.4365414083003998,
-0.23797006905078888,
-0.41150417923927307,
0.08110461384057999,
-0.4969042241573334,
0.42701634764671326,
0.4348309636116028,
-0.22065618634223938,
0.6795419454574585,
0.3941507041454315,
-0.12626366317272186,
-0.18487821519374847,
-0.5653972029685974,
-0.08876840770244598,
-0.3712455630302429,
-0.642184853553772,
0.04756731539964676,
-0.08693945407867432,
-0.4422644376754761,
-0.018629176542162895,
-0.06151214614510536,
-0.2505287230014801,
-0.01534891314804554,
0.31573641300201416,
0.333965003490448,
-0.2486160546541214,
-0.06947745382785797,
0.26539433002471924,
0.15393699705600739,
0.16321808099746704,
0.19445890188217163,
0.5115910172462463,
-0.09922999888658524,
-0.23522111773490906,
-0.5356247425079346,
0.4119630455970764,
0.7287606596946716,
-0.23616915941238403,
1.090175986289978,
0.40682077407836914,
-0.24664640426635742,
0.0599437952041626,
-0.6484254002571106,
-0.07933620363473892,
-0.3928961455821991,
0.24092167615890503,
-0.32767581939697266,
-1.0120574235916138,
0.7075998187065125,
0.3033730685710907,
0.11244657635688782,
0.4555908143520355,
0.45405489206314087,
0.2883254587650299,
0.9530860781669617,
0.7894855737686157,
-0.025266854092478752,
0.42819154262542725,
0.12120027840137482,
0.23306414484977722,
-0.8221374750137329,
-0.25225570797920227,
-0.4974513649940491,
-0.22612552344799042,
-0.4638100266456604,
0.03487367928028107,
0.7020434737205505,
0.05183318629860878,
-0.1678006500005722,
0.32072940468788147,
-0.30418655276298523,
0.6666138172149658,
0.31359291076660156,
0.21616509556770325,
0.4619824290275574,
-0.17230036854743958,
-0.018705960363149643,
-0.12811684608459473,
-0.3920561969280243,
-0.5644766092300415,
0.902167558670044,
0.432308167219162,
0.5343897342681885,
0.3231545686721802,
0.8145497441291809,
0.08368970453739166,
0.441876083612442,
-0.5889443755149841,
0.3082447052001953,
0.2893880009651184,
-0.7178429365158081,
-0.30515092611312866,
-0.2631813883781433,
-0.6025558114051819,
0.20090922713279724,
-0.015175805427134037,
-1.0201478004455566,
0.3731432855129242,
0.16653017699718475,
-0.5885269641876221,
0.18797262012958527,
-0.6437782645225525,
0.8342872262001038,
0.04771522060036659,
-0.21823230385780334,
0.06841570883989334,
-0.7538767457008362,
0.8095247745513916,
-0.07397767901420593,
0.25068899989128113,
-0.016243765130639076,
0.07118979841470718,
0.6077111959457397,
-0.24584871530532837,
1.0575206279754639,
-0.03821751847863197,
-0.2797243297100067,
0.10297609120607376,
0.504104733467102,
0.3598169684410095,
0.1353398859500885,
0.03114699386060238,
-0.07986242324113846,
0.1732056587934494,
-0.2911515533924103,
-0.5023930072784424,
0.7979437112808228,
-0.9027330875396729,
-0.6109923720359802,
-0.39100512862205505,
-0.40166139602661133,
-0.3621767461299896,
0.08298568427562714,
0.707705557346344,
0.5908395051956177,
-0.4224802255630493,
0.10969197750091553,
0.4974895119667053,
0.053485337644815445,
0.3345990777015686,
0.34002140164375305,
-0.32035350799560547,
-0.4217686057090759,
0.5052464008331299,
0.10993320494890213,
0.5205000042915344,
0.1350863128900528,
0.14753451943397522,
-0.0795830711722374,
-0.4477194547653198,
-0.2846728265285492,
0.3506793975830078,
-0.5366654992103577,
-0.09775745868682861,
-0.7321516275405884,
-0.3343716859817505,
-0.40364328026771545,
-0.18924875557422638,
-0.27720871567726135,
-0.24487240612506866,
0.008394996635615826,
-0.17326541244983673,
-0.05833160877227783,
0.9430335164070129,
0.0013834376586601138,
0.2934809923171997,
-0.7274293303489685,
0.18098022043704987,
0.11863729357719421,
0.1990991085767746,
0.0483739897608757,
-0.4891313314437866,
-0.2061775177717209,
-0.11773309856653214,
-0.27922341227531433,
-1.1709136962890625,
0.24421462416648865,
0.2588489353656769,
0.44604724645614624,
0.585376501083374,
0.028499096632003784,
0.28430935740470886,
-0.48936164379119873,
0.7998295426368713,
0.2257249802350998,
-1.008812427520752,
0.346295565366745,
-0.8616225123405457,
0.2661449611186981,
0.5283810496330261,
0.4728439748287201,
-0.6335980892181396,
-0.7180284261703491,
-0.37082216143608093,
-0.5774239301681519,
0.6935963034629822,
0.23896394670009613,
0.0846509039402008,
-0.19174009561538696,
0.40557435154914856,
0.44453132152557373,
0.20791573822498322,
-1.1993430852890015,
-0.10306725651025772,
-0.0284095611423254,
-0.11922962963581085,
-0.18367856740951538,
-0.5371798872947693,
-0.3670516610145569,
-0.21203738451004028,
0.5207037329673767,
-0.1912127435207367,
0.1004052385687828,
0.3589833080768585,
-0.09745422750711441,
-0.201964870095253,
0.17880943417549133,
0.7539777159690857,
0.7234508395195007,
-0.07563365250825882,
0.11549030989408493,
-0.39239636063575745,
-0.3108173906803131,
0.1282796412706375,
-0.08550901710987091,
-0.4559764862060547,
-0.19861820340156555,
0.7251896262168884,
0.8214271068572998,
0.4086700677871704,
-0.4135260581970215,
0.5747523903846741,
-0.18390928208827972,
-0.318441778421402,
-0.3645089268684387,
0.12232901901006699,
-0.1295730620622635,
0.25470831990242004,
0.16331715881824493,
0.0947682112455368,
0.06490552425384521,
-0.7904218435287476,
-0.04781893640756607,
0.3411361575126648,
-0.41004979610443115,
-0.6607155203819275,
1.000482439994812,
0.12647315859794617,
-0.2729920744895935,
0.5482460260391235,
-0.12090890109539032,
-0.46774929761886597,
0.4729796350002289,
0.649749755859375,
1.3050150871276855,
-0.3052208721637726,
0.5222110748291016,
0.3085358440876007,
0.5145271420478821,
-0.4661787748336792,
-0.04483366012573242,
0.06536219269037247,
-0.8836886286735535,
-0.5115927457809448,
-0.6145073771476746,
-0.2635512053966522,
0.3947553038597107,
-0.8455314040184021,
0.1121739074587822,
-0.4285859763622284,
0.09064563363790512,
-0.07351966202259064,
-0.32783132791519165,
-0.30188241600990295,
-0.26700669527053833,
0.13926158845424652,
0.3543122112751007,
-1.154045581817627,
0.7668015956878662,
0.6277399063110352,
-0.5834687352180481,
-0.5401917099952698,
0.4979361593723297,
0.4085223376750946,
-0.3068389594554901,
0.2868455648422241,
0.3171308934688568,
-0.21246641874313354,
-0.05692481994628906,
-0.7189465165138245,
-0.4764043986797333,
0.794350266456604,
0.6465453505516052,
-0.22743989527225494,
-0.32543474435806274,
-0.13077856600284576,
0.6623119711875916,
-0.4413534104824066,
0.04963432252407074,
0.5378225445747375,
0.4298570454120636,
-0.3069918751716614,
-1.2702628374099731,
0.06042036786675453,
-0.061180491000413895,
-0.04882855340838432,
0.34697896242141724,
-0.7512054443359375,
0.9375807046890259,
0.043100062757730484,
-0.36070188879966736,
0.466417521238327,
0.6392413377761841,
0.0799892470240593,
0.11753909289836884,
0.5352550745010376,
0.2709234058856964,
0.43138501048088074,
0.1076451763510704,
1.144250750541687,
-0.19416776299476624,
0.502582848072052,
1.1766095161437988,
-0.1904875785112381,
0.6169520616531372,
0.1866384595632553,
-0.06962374597787857,
0.6890432834625244,
0.23810333013534546,
0.19203506410121918,
0.37386468052864075,
-0.2566949427127838,
-0.41537782549858093,
-0.5009953379631042,
0.11243388056755066,
-0.1320435106754303,
0.5669901371002197,
0.10540317744016647,
-0.2981760799884796,
-0.17915470898151398,
0.14575785398483276,
0.4230882227420807,
0.4899815022945404,
0.03927278518676758,
0.5692200064659119,
0.0577884316444397,
-0.985843300819397,
0.2944195568561554,
-0.03761816397309303,
0.33819225430488586,
-0.5579833388328552,
0.11046511679887772,
-0.3004836440086365,
0.0568414181470871,
-0.08668386936187744,
-0.4807296693325043,
0.2508029341697693,
-0.29360657930374146,
-0.23591476678848267,
-0.367320716381073,
0.4193621873855591,
-0.5919376611709595,
-0.2837488055229187,
0.13559094071388245,
0.6363582611083984,
0.06815225630998611,
-0.018306225538253784,
-0.20853325724601746,
0.29939791560173035,
0.12001266330480576,
-0.20364652574062347,
0.5477695465087891,
0.2647997736930847,
0.13384777307510376,
0.42819538712501526,
0.10882338881492615,
-0.21580387651920319,
-0.13469934463500977,
-0.11980366706848145,
0.7411256432533264,
-0.5502592921257019,
-0.45217621326446533,
-0.9787657260894775,
0.5337416529655457,
-0.03679567202925682,
-0.41082054376602173,
0.9475831389427185,
0.5728310346603394,
0.8106221556663513,
-0.11678830534219742,
0.7943900227546692,
-0.06932173669338226,
0.41625943779945374,
-0.6519187092781067,
0.9700896143913269,
-0.48806697130203247,
0.20650042593479156,
-0.3226969838142395,
-0.768652617931366,
-0.23820318281650543,
0.45943790674209595,
-0.3020287752151489,
0.23095041513442993,
0.9256685972213745,
0.4265359044075012,
-0.08676214516162872,
-0.07916876673698425,
0.35237929224967957,
0.3509436845779419,
0.37810343503952026,
0.3264445960521698,
0.6289704442024231,
-0.15674163401126862,
0.3257872760295868,
-0.12290747463703156,
-0.3438340425491333,
-0.10830675065517426,
-0.6761645674705505,
-1.1326484680175781,
-1.0770949125289917,
-0.40613171458244324,
-0.5489252805709839,
0.04322841390967369,
0.5918029546737671,
0.3858548104763031,
-0.5176392793655396,
-0.21605202555656433,
-0.02194792777299881,
0.05347374454140663,
-0.2317388653755188,
-0.25275471806526184,
0.2186434268951416,
-0.3885094225406647,
-0.7980763912200928,
0.39059728384017944,
0.36261218786239624,
-0.11165202409029007,
-0.6633260250091553,
0.07991746068000793,
-0.0060381656512618065,
0.05629375949501991,
0.29891759157180786,
0.3909563720226288,
-0.7935230135917664,
-0.490725040435791,
-0.21086058020591736,
-0.034337617456912994,
0.0827917829155922,
1.069722056388855,
-0.8009511232376099,
0.5197173953056335,
0.41079869866371155,
0.24660895764827728,
0.12208881229162216,
0.01511058397591114,
0.8380921483039856,
-0.8090387582778931,
0.044423460960388184,
0.23275630176067352,
0.38309434056282043,
0.14614033699035645,
-0.32888564467430115,
0.289905846118927,
0.2096637338399887,
-0.7682540416717529,
-0.9276601672172546,
0.5269061923027039,
-0.8908730745315552,
-0.2716193199157715,
1.1406866312026978,
-0.10524718463420868,
-0.2587074935436249,
-0.12999461591243744,
-0.18725211918354034,
0.05428782477974892,
-0.23266758024692535,
0.9612884521484375,
0.9932212829589844,
-0.3273009657859802,
-0.2440062016248703,
-0.8453165888786316,
0.8073952794075012,
0.2688857913017273,
-0.5284338593482971,
0.1032785102725029,
0.7733199596405029,
0.22058534622192383,
0.1765938550233841,
0.7872893214225769,
-0.08356442302465439,
0.15735527873039246,
0.01606745459139347,
-0.2094152867794037,
0.06709741801023483,
-0.40417447686195374,
-0.4383220374584198,
0.4364469647407532,
0.14838957786560059,
0.17097815871238708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04476v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04476v2 | Dual-View Visual Contextualization for Web Navigation | 2024-02-06T23:52:10 | 2024-03-30T05:18:05 | Jihyung Kil, Chan Hee Song, Boyuan Zheng, Xiang Deng, Yu Su, Wei-Lun Chao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Automatic web navigation aims to build a web agent that can follow language
instructions to execute complex and diverse tasks on real-world websites.
Existing work primarily takes HTML documents as input, which define the
contents and action spaces (i.e., actionable elements and operations) of
webpages. Nevertheless, HTML documents may not provide a clear task-related
context for each element, making it hard to select the right (sequence of)
actions. In this paper, we propose to contextualize HTML elements through their
"dual views" in webpage screenshots: each HTML element has its corresponding
bounding box and visual content in the screenshot. We build upon the insight --
web developers tend to arrange task-related elements nearby on webpages to
enhance user experiences -- and propose to contextualize each element with its
neighbor elements, using both textual and visual features. The resulting
representations of HTML elements are more informative for the agent to take
action. We validate our method on the recently released Mind2Web dataset, which
features diverse navigation domains and tasks on real-world websites. Our
method consistently outperforms the baseline in all the scenarios, including
cross-task, cross-website, and cross-domain ones. | [
-0.5918944478034973,
-0.5873980522155762,
0.5612078905105591,
0.1557118445634842,
-0.33524736762046814,
0.05113670602440834,
-0.12230905145406723,
-0.3916139602661133,
0.09644800424575806,
0.11543159186840057,
-0.5614126324653625,
-0.5241745710372925,
-0.1509159952402115,
-0.1504519283771515,
-0.28421807289123535,
0.6243829727172852,
-0.09970765560865402,
-0.1197403222322464,
-0.6098961234092712,
0.04603336378931999,
-0.4781469404697418,
-0.10157928615808487,
-0.4659315347671509,
0.06406981498003006,
0.613005518913269,
0.4605507552623749,
0.7411131858825684,
0.600792407989502,
0.3890547454357147,
0.292610764503479,
0.4717766046524048,
0.09730206429958344,
-0.27002641558647156,
0.1973297894001007,
-0.5345445275306702,
-0.3283212184906006,
-0.37692704796791077,
0.05270441249012947,
0.5060926079750061,
0.6406015753746033,
0.18747574090957642,
0.14115969836711884,
0.293262779712677,
0.4881468713283539,
-0.6455811858177185,
0.25973668694496155,
0.03110666014254093,
-0.03357284888625145,
-0.01885654404759407,
-0.18015147745609283,
-0.21235918998718262,
-0.22582106292247772,
0.3440355062484741,
-0.9837921857833862,
0.025081604719161987,
0.18638759851455688,
0.5931362509727478,
0.5216074585914612,
-1.009015440940857,
0.11108686774969101,
-0.5125483274459839,
0.6707441210746765,
-0.19326135516166687,
0.5664535760879517,
0.23909179866313934,
0.6390277743339539,
0.13500243425369263,
-0.6726154088973999,
-0.6016767621040344,
0.07600087672472,
-0.1429600864648819,
0.26964983344078064,
-0.29559454321861267,
-0.20459382236003876,
0.07594188302755356,
0.009902624413371086,
-0.8624577522277832,
0.11513787508010864,
0.010740431025624275,
-0.26691171526908875,
0.49568232893943787,
0.04273790121078491,
0.800627589225769,
0.08174487948417664,
-0.49213290214538574,
-0.493892103433609,
-0.5324369072914124,
0.23246009647846222,
0.020223740488290787,
0.09828068315982819,
-0.3089686632156372,
0.1821756213903427,
-0.33190110325813293,
0.8848907351493835,
0.022768964990973473,
-0.007506543770432472,
0.0552547350525856,
-0.24410668015480042,
-0.1716259866952896,
-0.3363383710384369,
0.2774140536785126,
1.2085908651351929,
0.11884228140115738,
-0.38403114676475525,
0.03480939194560051,
0.10745962709188461,
0.7636927366256714,
-0.6977007985115051,
-0.3788949251174927,
0.4390977621078491,
-0.4720016121864319,
-0.01932317577302456,
0.1455073356628418,
-0.9911025762557983,
-0.57138991355896,
-0.43042412400245667,
0.2944561541080475,
-0.19524294137954712,
-0.36880096793174744,
-0.47689205408096313,
-0.6370997428894043,
0.22932887077331543,
0.8532053232192993,
-0.4550512135028839,
0.27282458543777466,
0.4064524173736572,
0.5687671303749084,
-0.4865938127040863,
-0.4016075134277344,
-0.37864524126052856,
0.36222389340400696,
-0.18372860550880432,
1.0014910697937012,
-0.7021170854568481,
-0.28051891922950745,
0.3984425663948059,
-0.1937544047832489,
0.16379354894161224,
-0.24513883888721466,
-0.1904224157333374,
-0.6641848087310791,
0.12147851288318634,
-0.639768660068512,
-0.12729449570178986,
-0.6522240042686462,
0.3041594922542572,
-0.6385858654975891,
0.5889906287193298,
-0.0917479619383812,
-0.4898151755332947,
0.5713817477226257,
-0.5298590660095215,
-0.8185879588127136,
0.002331544877961278,
-0.389835387468338,
0.05726271867752075,
-0.05651942268013954,
0.19393210113048553,
0.3714439570903778,
0.08791112899780273,
-0.37592682242393494,
-0.11817803978919983,
-0.19633257389068604,
0.18222199380397797,
-0.16432015597820282,
0.4036853015422821,
-0.11302939802408218,
-0.6044125556945801,
0.15175779163837433,
-0.5856258273124695,
0.18959102034568787,
0.2621583044528961,
-0.34560298919677734,
-0.6272928714752197,
0.24377648532390594,
0.45542290806770325,
0.4425433874130249,
0.3013446629047394,
-0.0910506471991539,
0.43381616473197937,
-0.15487447381019592,
0.001409522956237197,
0.5750775933265686,
0.026454616338014603,
0.8370991349220276,
-0.19315120577812195,
0.6807520389556885,
-0.02404448762536049,
-0.006745290942490101,
-0.050003062933683395,
-0.48061609268188477,
-0.8964309692382812,
0.15657652914524078,
-0.03154784440994263,
0.6573314666748047,
-0.9380292892456055,
0.1970355063676834,
-0.29612043499946594,
-0.2867966592311859,
0.20616203546524048,
0.09668989479541779,
0.713431715965271,
0.4275265336036682,
0.6011409163475037,
-0.48906922340393066,
-0.3734206557273865,
-1.0400371551513672,
-0.1635444462299347,
0.03789849206805229,
-0.02931916154921055,
0.2877888083457947,
0.5737103819847107,
-0.14448300004005432,
1.077109456062317,
-0.5819761753082275,
-0.3577624261379242,
-0.1787840723991394,
0.2594625651836395,
-0.3964400291442871,
0.5456601977348328,
0.4830377995967865,
-1.3214771747589111,
-0.680424153804779,
0.045105282217264175,
-0.9228713512420654,
-0.0955163985490799,
-0.12142530828714371,
-0.35575857758522034,
-0.08820334821939468,
0.18367786705493927,
-0.1662694811820984,
0.6968713402748108,
0.21796107292175293,
-0.3333562910556793,
0.22363132238388062,
-0.16770298779010773,
0.23460714519023895,
-0.934579610824585,
0.14213153719902039,
0.48379644751548767,
-0.47513750195503235,
-0.7610668540000916,
0.370261013507843,
0.5546519756317139,
0.008544962853193283,
-0.1989707052707672,
0.6694815158843994,
-0.8874564170837402,
-0.3289646804332733,
-0.33526062965393066,
0.28423017263412476,
0.2370743304491043,
0.7258042693138123,
0.22657015919685364,
0.863093912601471,
0.2321571260690689,
-0.6870041489601135,
0.46969324350357056,
0.17944997549057007,
0.11359821259975433,
1.0008678436279297,
-0.08091922849416733,
0.1442508101463318,
-0.013845035806298256,
0.64445960521698,
-0.9385259747505188,
-0.24936160445213318,
0.14112427830696106,
-0.35124671459198,
0.3489634096622467,
-0.10663822293281555,
-0.40265676379203796,
-0.38368576765060425,
-0.544607400894165,
0.3243589699268341,
0.3754056394100189,
-0.4450649619102478,
0.5328832268714905,
0.6147318482398987,
-0.1372281312942505,
-0.5204800367355347,
-0.6462484002113342,
0.2548265755176544,
-0.13417945802211761,
-0.7191569209098816,
0.5902047753334045,
-0.16154098510742188,
-0.3962997794151306,
-0.03284899890422821,
-0.3198770582675934,
-0.1687946319580078,
0.07967077940702438,
0.7202973365783691,
0.17932933568954468,
0.018475640565156937,
-0.09982609748840332,
0.24171145260334015,
-0.1492478847503662,
-0.048955272883176804,
-0.5012799501419067,
0.3433801829814911,
0.009885840117931366,
-0.47134461998939514,
-0.8943397998809814,
0.6888567805290222,
0.32278233766555786,
-0.42048805952072144,
0.16525842249393463,
0.393782377243042,
-0.5201079845428467,
-0.23993097245693207,
-0.5996869802474976,
0.052846312522888184,
-0.4458630084991455,
0.12076003104448318,
-0.49499621987342834,
-0.37335509061813354,
0.5468162298202515,
-0.2192140817642212,
0.16262640058994293,
0.16840790212154388,
0.34836047887802124,
-0.588291585445404,
1.1154944896697998,
0.7805620431900024,
0.06214360520243645,
0.5074557662010193,
-0.44093406200408936,
-0.03171315789222717,
-0.8433533906936646,
-0.45866918563842773,
-0.19907939434051514,
-0.7034900188446045,
-0.15162411332130432,
-0.6614275574684143,
0.6010858416557312,
-0.08682175725698471,
0.1592617928981781,
0.2392149120569229,
-0.5013614892959595,
0.3034444749355316,
1.002835988998413,
0.20303283631801605,
0.2130274772644043,
0.09034883975982666,
-0.41136547923088074,
0.013918958604335785,
-0.45444023609161377,
-0.5138687491416931,
0.8751940727233887,
-0.07070715725421906,
0.66925448179245,
0.36055243015289307,
0.5066102147102356,
0.49476927518844604,
-0.007051090244203806,
-0.6297661066055298,
0.69724440574646,
0.10223732143640518,
-0.4599176049232483,
-0.3072834014892578,
0.05496501922607422,
-0.9917277693748474,
0.5364575982093811,
-0.0400695838034153,
-0.8328819274902344,
0.29637086391448975,
0.4945254325866699,
-0.43934857845306396,
-0.0045853471383452415,
-0.8814771175384521,
0.9983507990837097,
-0.2365390509366989,
-0.7337796092033386,
-0.6073542237281799,
-0.8505430817604065,
-0.1571992039680481,
0.4656579792499542,
0.28792062401771545,
0.34307006001472473,
-0.2984786927700043,
0.4142322540283203,
-0.39148569107055664,
0.9183573126792908,
-0.3696984052658081,
-0.06960935890674591,
-0.00462757796049118,
0.32238879799842834,
0.32277852296829224,
-0.026014812290668488,
0.5360334515571594,
-0.1800537258386612,
-0.21783103048801422,
-0.2581092417240143,
-0.6943345665931702,
0.6792068481445312,
-0.4767332673072815,
-0.7208051085472107,
-0.7774642109870911,
-0.30095070600509644,
-0.3825361132621765,
0.3186264932155609,
0.002485388657078147,
0.8737161159515381,
-0.27228888869285583,
0.04835434630513191,
0.34377843141555786,
-0.17788226902484894,
0.6314910054206848,
0.6606543660163879,
-0.22546841204166412,
-0.07945562154054642,
0.8386002779006958,
0.019295193254947662,
-0.10031995922327042,
0.7610224485397339,
-0.25405192375183105,
-0.46108585596084595,
-0.6997782588005066,
-0.8779269456863403,
-0.04296785593032837,
-0.7440176010131836,
-0.09104280173778534,
-0.28432413935661316,
0.16968117654323578,
-0.40973860025405884,
-0.4620179235935211,
-0.0642128437757492,
-0.39667588472366333,
-0.2424306571483612,
0.04598116874694824,
-0.19319882988929749,
0.7079451084136963,
-0.12618455290794373,
0.009401789866387844,
-0.5295583605766296,
0.5958679914474487,
0.7765688300132751,
0.05488510802388191,
0.15082432329654694,
0.1650482416152954,
-0.3387286365032196,
0.05546276271343231,
-0.23785892128944397,
-1.2204769849777222,
0.20712895691394806,
-0.20229259133338928,
0.7726037502288818,
0.5520181655883789,
-0.017981108278036118,
0.8394473791122437,
-0.636421799659729,
0.8732203245162964,
0.2955459952354431,
-0.6714834570884705,
0.8451061844825745,
-0.23739652335643768,
0.7529200911521912,
0.4763021469116211,
0.3051973879337311,
-0.6575368046760559,
-0.19548340141773224,
-0.13156069815158844,
-0.7410406470298767,
0.6452908515930176,
0.1691705882549286,
-0.14540725946426392,
0.35047534108161926,
0.04082920774817467,
0.00183664180804044,
0.10482074320316315,
-0.5208755135536194,
-0.3147158920764923,
-0.4307817816734314,
-0.195680171251297,
0.007564482744783163,
-0.0816449522972107,
-0.28212857246398926,
-0.06481017917394638,
0.4643576145172119,
-0.416603147983551,
0.16568182408809662,
0.19621655344963074,
-0.8311958909034729,
-0.006215799134224653,
0.07704435288906097,
0.3952878415584564,
1.1465359926223755,
-0.13965171575546265,
0.48093464970588684,
-0.14754101634025574,
-0.48230186104774475,
0.09130140393972397,
0.39870283007621765,
-0.21724079549312592,
-0.3397550582885742,
0.19061143696308136,
0.4696095287799835,
0.31820815801620483,
-0.6272121071815491,
0.6752777695655823,
-0.11400526762008667,
0.408774733543396,
-0.515436053276062,
0.062362223863601685,
-0.08332900702953339,
0.6534144282341003,
0.5565329194068909,
-0.00834161788225174,
0.6909968852996826,
-0.6489861011505127,
0.000846870883833617,
0.5982276797294617,
-0.27431219816207886,
-0.4553157389163971,
0.8755978345870972,
0.8084189295768738,
-0.28762197494506836,
0.30902260541915894,
-0.31003338098526,
-0.6177719831466675,
0.6551215052604675,
0.5470362305641174,
0.6948318481445312,
-0.056037481874227524,
0.08088816702365875,
0.06094389036297798,
0.042261410504579544,
0.08433206379413605,
0.04896436259150505,
-0.569034993648529,
-0.41039642691612244,
0.18820472061634064,
-0.34324368834495544,
-0.4039144217967987,
-0.37577274441719055,
-0.8245368003845215,
-0.209791898727417,
-0.16680383682250977,
-0.2572941780090332,
-0.09499283134937286,
0.07959119975566864,
-0.8680269718170166,
0.7371386289596558,
0.4215262830257416,
0.8006898164749146,
-0.47272229194641113,
0.921739935874939,
1.1955835819244385,
-0.5918930768966675,
-0.18438409268856049,
0.395059198141098,
0.6879597306251526,
-0.6986173987388611,
0.3676498234272003,
0.412700891494751,
-0.43694135546684265,
-0.08542968332767487,
-0.05413931608200073,
-0.6456283926963806,
1.3328977823257446,
-0.303329199552536,
-0.3923409879207611,
-0.45299312472343445,
-0.11553583294153214,
0.3332212567329407,
-0.10930237919092178,
0.11747970432043076,
0.04131188988685608,
0.5936049818992615,
-0.23113125562667847,
-0.9954113364219666,
0.308175265789032,
-0.6494878530502319,
0.23612374067306519,
0.06510872393846512,
-0.7198248505592346,
0.28665995597839355,
-0.009001722559332848,
-0.36876747012138367,
-0.2718453109264374,
0.6263124942779541,
-0.19628217816352844,
0.4868418574333191,
0.8928505778312683,
0.462206095457077,
0.42486974596977234,
0.0707092434167862,
0.9806120991706848,
-0.09859208762645721,
-0.0246435534209013,
1.112714409828186,
-0.24675476551055908,
0.9526750445365906,
0.563924252986908,
-0.07363100349903107,
0.6550003290176392,
0.37892550230026245,
0.13039271533489227,
0.789069652557373,
-0.15569202601909637,
-0.028879068791866302,
-0.23478706181049347,
0.062477175146341324,
-0.37369000911712646,
0.42707282304763794,
0.4205996096134186,
-0.10138237476348877,
-0.29890280961990356,
0.1237325593829155,
0.10076506435871124,
0.33313295245170593,
-0.22752811014652252,
0.765072762966156,
-0.006674759555608034,
-0.8641132116317749,
0.06973829865455627,
0.06618157029151917,
0.5603168606758118,
-0.5917245149612427,
-0.15902316570281982,
-0.26188355684280396,
-0.212951198220253,
-0.21552051603794098,
-0.8958225250244141,
-0.020042575895786285,
0.16894865036010742,
-0.07490956038236618,
-0.7634471654891968,
0.7986695170402527,
-0.1150701567530632,
-0.042333438992500305,
0.3049295246601105,
0.5393192768096924,
-0.018353071063756943,
-0.3378508388996124,
-0.44782495498657227,
-0.01927662268280983,
0.12111344188451767,
-0.13599243760108948,
0.5268388986587524,
-0.09719496220350266,
-0.14398325979709625,
0.6995222568511963,
0.4740878939628601,
-0.37849918007850647,
0.09315921366214752,
0.02417941950261593,
0.7701958417892456,
-0.731614351272583,
-0.948430061340332,
-0.626133918762207,
0.830704391002655,
-0.5969803333282471,
-0.0865214541554451,
0.8719531893730164,
0.9849932789802551,
0.6812517642974854,
0.07817063480615616,
1.0453238487243652,
-0.05833740532398224,
0.12753824889659882,
-0.4541401267051697,
0.7335233688354492,
-0.9940128922462463,
-0.23387320339679718,
-0.02097826823592186,
-0.937578558921814,
-0.33403903245925903,
0.6376252174377441,
-0.16700924932956696,
-0.05750449001789093,
0.8695142269134521,
0.5433732867240906,
-0.31852924823760986,
-0.29546111822128296,
0.0976538434624672,
-0.07715689390897751,
0.07400622218847275,
0.629961371421814,
0.6831791400909424,
-0.016321862116456032,
0.5887937545776367,
-0.5221810936927795,
-0.46074309945106506,
-0.6089231967926025,
-0.6265563368797302,
-0.816764235496521,
-0.9663878083229065,
-0.43394941091537476,
-0.23966439068317413,
0.1170656606554985,
0.6510932445526123,
1.1392614841461182,
-0.5086110830307007,
-0.2894240915775299,
0.16694819927215576,
0.06119566038250923,
-0.5313711762428284,
-0.22418518364429474,
0.21433669328689575,
0.08639736473560333,
-0.8081287741661072,
0.5838717222213745,
0.6345089077949524,
0.16712841391563416,
-0.3722248077392578,
0.22076481580734253,
-0.0855162963271141,
-0.07634282112121582,
0.41074317693710327,
0.31563857197761536,
-0.8022381663322449,
-0.46244314312934875,
-0.2787713408470154,
-0.26974785327911377,
0.2573014199733734,
0.6346526145935059,
-0.8849750757217407,
0.6425988674163818,
0.6065654158592224,
0.2995942533016205,
0.6105433702468872,
0.2759614586830139,
0.6556617021560669,
-0.77717524766922,
0.1834820657968521,
0.028839334845542908,
0.25466296076774597,
0.25598686933517456,
-0.22410732507705688,
0.4148313105106354,
0.01946544274687767,
-0.12578321993350983,
-0.39012622833251953,
0.27613502740859985,
-1.4146459102630615,
-0.5805628895759583,
1.0949233770370483,
-0.11655499786138535,
-0.0035649570636451244,
-0.041304219514131546,
-0.19280590116977692,
0.32228708267211914,
-0.5388159155845642,
0.6202821731567383,
0.4280548095703125,
-0.22074159979820251,
-0.07539069652557373,
-0.6584193706512451,
0.4653405249118805,
0.10346571356058121,
-1.0384869575500488,
-0.43572232127189636,
0.990840494632721,
0.2036934196949005,
0.316051185131073,
0.6053234338760376,
0.5323678851127625,
0.5418441891670227,
0.056526076048612595,
0.06153923645615578,
-0.08468007296323776,
-0.4182799160480499,
-0.17771123349666595,
0.2692110240459442,
-0.20036914944648743,
-0.41979241371154785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04442v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04442v1 | Evaluating Embeddings for One-Shot Classification of Doctor-AI Consultations | 2024-02-06T22:24:56 | 2024-02-06T22:24:56 | Olumide Ebenezer Ojo, Olaronke Oluwayemisi Adebanji, Alexander Gelbukh, Hiram Calvo, Anna Feldman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Effective communication between healthcare providers and patients is crucial
to providing high-quality patient care. In this work, we investigate how
Doctor-written and AI-generated texts in healthcare consultations can be
classified using state-of-the-art embeddings and one-shot classification
systems. By analyzing embeddings such as bag-of-words, character n-grams,
Word2Vec, GloVe, fastText, and GPT2 embeddings, we examine how well our
one-shot classification systems capture semantic information within medical
consultations. Results show that the embeddings are capable of capturing
semantic features from text in a reliable and adaptable manner. Overall,
Word2Vec, GloVe and Character n-grams embeddings performed well, indicating
their suitability for modeling targeted to this task. GPT2 embedding also shows
notable performance, indicating its suitability for models tailored to this
task as well. Our machine learning architectures significantly improved the
quality of health conversations when training data are scarce, improving
communication between patients and healthcare providers. | [
-0.07313048839569092,
-0.5990968346595764,
0.7559537887573242,
-0.08803552389144897,
-0.3651500940322876,
-0.12953563034534454,
0.10378403961658478,
-0.5847760438919067,
0.24200905859470367,
0.5702994465827942,
-0.18236646056175232,
-0.7122762203216553,
-1.0201826095581055,
0.11629335582256317,
-0.3356560170650482,
0.937842845916748,
-0.11736354976892471,
0.4636602997779846,
-0.5099886655807495,
-0.33554762601852417,
-0.36107853055000305,
-0.5318956971168518,
-0.7108924388885498,
-0.2882165014743805,
0.4286988079547882,
0.34646281599998474,
0.9217236042022705,
0.6363808512687683,
0.5662873983383179,
0.26166048645973206,
0.04894062876701355,
0.21529023349285126,
-0.0466584675014019,
0.12270279973745346,
0.08968353271484375,
-0.2966693937778473,
-0.1928921341896057,
0.16852599382400513,
0.5814269185066223,
0.5728985667228699,
-0.3342503607273102,
-0.06827237457036972,
0.12599360942840576,
0.08834154158830643,
-0.5800832509994507,
0.5133057832717896,
-0.20119453966617584,
0.5743186473846436,
-0.046760305762290955,
-0.2930433750152588,
-0.447793185710907,
-0.3213455379009247,
0.6033057570457458,
-0.6493749022483826,
-0.023316066712141037,
-0.004286987241357565,
0.8647764325141907,
0.6579174399375916,
-0.2306317239999771,
-0.6584855318069458,
-0.479703813791275,
0.3448205590248108,
-0.6683288812637329,
0.304484099149704,
0.6906344890594482,
0.39946356415748596,
0.09671187400817871,
-0.7584933638572693,
-0.4971182346343994,
0.027314022183418274,
-0.5103607177734375,
0.27320390939712524,
-0.19540393352508545,
0.3166291117668152,
0.12610884010791779,
0.012922205030918121,
-0.19777493178844452,
0.39831656217575073,
0.0069059706293046474,
-0.17649948596954346,
0.548770546913147,
0.33033066987991333,
0.3072008788585663,
-0.14529860019683838,
-0.3487703800201416,
0.045821189880371094,
-0.3727715313434601,
-0.3479524254798889,
-0.07192875444889069,
-0.026384051889181137,
-0.10227835923433304,
0.37563085556030273,
0.18836764991283417,
0.6721904277801514,
0.03876013308763504,
-0.6050398945808411,
-0.08646415919065475,
-0.21540986001491547,
-0.30174970626831055,
0.29079505801200867,
0.9207707047462463,
0.34598296880722046,
0.09284985065460205,
-0.40354427695274353,
0.19989453256130219,
0.07358480244874954,
0.52872633934021,
-0.7399232387542725,
-0.17090536653995514,
0.22782352566719055,
-0.525794506072998,
-0.34993264079093933,
0.15779350697994232,
-0.3351225256919861,
-0.5706514716148376,
-0.029154067859053612,
0.25802168250083923,
-0.41952937841415405,
-0.16221283376216888,
0.35945937037467957,
-0.17423628270626068,
0.12621870636940002,
0.51738041639328,
-0.681204617023468,
0.5118700265884399,
0.7144121527671814,
0.5993353128433228,
0.17900045216083527,
0.04046100378036499,
-0.2755640745162964,
0.17815233767032623,
-0.43089792132377625,
0.877392590045929,
-0.5545230507850647,
-0.47582513093948364,
0.3964448571205139,
-0.07850165665149689,
-0.047973986715078354,
-0.6438001990318298,
0.5046311020851135,
-0.1433284878730774,
0.609077513217926,
-0.04997797682881355,
-0.7655952572822571,
-0.06281495094299316,
0.6632413268089294,
-0.2734823524951935,
0.5058553814888,
0.4415610432624817,
-1.0750762224197388,
0.7191431522369385,
-0.5667569637298584,
-0.43079647421836853,
0.45791542530059814,
-0.65790194272995,
-0.6978477835655212,
-0.15332761406898499,
0.12702405452728271,
0.6902983784675598,
-0.36992907524108887,
-0.17481228709220886,
-0.07937612384557724,
-0.24543949961662292,
0.21895325183868408,
-0.20001819729804993,
0.43999776244163513,
0.1410253494977951,
-0.03905303776264191,
-0.1749311238527298,
-0.44525519013404846,
0.08560004085302353,
-0.010723826475441456,
-0.341169148683548,
-0.32495033740997314,
0.13900479674339294,
0.07205166667699814,
0.23233401775360107,
-0.1354660987854004,
-0.6651841402053833,
0.4999432861804962,
-0.5587643384933472,
0.46493521332740784,
0.23389247059822083,
0.22946053743362427,
0.2401329129934311,
-0.27210474014282227,
0.6195409297943115,
0.2991721034049988,
0.28238627314567566,
-0.28734034299850464,
-0.7634983062744141,
-0.457669734954834,
-0.39116039872169495,
0.4552544355392456,
0.7270797491073608,
-0.769031822681427,
0.5285310745239258,
-0.3949768543243408,
-0.40922290086746216,
-1.0100129842758179,
-0.22680120170116425,
0.6427212357521057,
0.6426483392715454,
0.3702148199081421,
-0.4482901692390442,
0.010474087670445442,
-0.8104081153869629,
-0.10016357153654099,
-0.3756798505783081,
-0.014027378521859646,
0.7948822975158691,
0.04488790035247803,
-0.5263240337371826,
0.9034799337387085,
-0.4864028990268707,
-0.4185175895690918,
-0.05650654062628746,
0.1945861428976059,
-0.3404623866081238,
0.42302238941192627,
0.6084592342376709,
-0.5349652767181396,
-0.5222187638282776,
0.026969794183969498,
-0.8102741837501526,
0.22479943931102753,
-0.29361197352409363,
0.03429238870739937,
0.019029885530471802,
0.06583122909069061,
-0.4680774509906769,
0.9751280546188354,
0.279936283826828,
-0.4461412727832794,
0.1784747838973999,
-0.41176939010620117,
0.22210201621055603,
-1.3730334043502808,
-0.05551338195800781,
-0.12154455482959747,
-0.4493551552295685,
-0.5653043985366821,
-0.17826145887374878,
-0.1619233787059784,
-0.08597098290920258,
-0.47159066796302795,
0.6772388219833374,
-0.23499572277069092,
0.18307693302631378,
-0.18543899059295654,
-0.012266617268323898,
-0.038840629160404205,
-0.0849340483546257,
0.06332635134458542,
0.4576854109764099,
0.6690753102302551,
-0.5547784566879272,
0.20791111886501312,
1.0326125621795654,
-0.41398465633392334,
0.7856116890907288,
-0.5670921802520752,
0.4569331109523773,
-0.13774152100086212,
0.3871802091598511,
-0.8060871362686157,
-0.25400999188423157,
0.5722545981407166,
-0.4435352087020874,
0.5315665602684021,
-0.508144199848175,
-0.7589407563209534,
-0.29741594195365906,
-0.02512839436531067,
0.3895365297794342,
0.26223498582839966,
-0.2376181185245514,
0.40577811002731323,
0.6052469611167908,
-0.2783111035823822,
-0.3408415615558624,
-0.9888518452644348,
0.1754855513572693,
0.10944660007953644,
-0.3881323039531708,
0.40034782886505127,
0.5471398234367371,
0.23166795074939728,
0.19200550019741058,
0.07080603390932083,
-0.2847481071949005,
-0.00016635806241538376,
0.508567750453949,
0.11984707415103912,
0.0431022122502327,
0.45309194922447205,
0.2465926557779312,
-0.39320313930511475,
0.015058906748890877,
-0.27085426449775696,
0.5131210684776306,
0.39370736479759216,
-0.6451507210731506,
-0.9292965531349182,
0.7535130381584167,
0.6025723218917847,
-0.10792943090200424,
0.8568726778030396,
0.7210153341293335,
-0.5651902556419373,
0.11942249536514282,
-0.5466774702072144,
-0.2411477267742157,
-0.36155369877815247,
0.3449634611606598,
-0.05329549312591553,
-0.8204236626625061,
0.2929929196834564,
-0.14592783153057098,
0.08078935742378235,
0.42051440477371216,
0.34228867292404175,
-0.23033156991004944,
1.2046765089035034,
0.5324087142944336,
-0.3005424737930298,
0.1865711212158203,
-0.2005651742219925,
0.18203601241111755,
-0.5606088638305664,
-0.4021138846874237,
-0.5819525122642517,
-0.14451025426387787,
-0.9363433718681335,
-0.442247599363327,
0.6966823935508728,
-0.07637084275484085,
-0.08089852333068848,
0.33430421352386475,
-0.876853346824646,
0.08322186022996902,
0.3487556278705597,
0.43383291363716125,
-0.17895741760730743,
-0.039448123425245285,
-0.16134509444236755,
-0.026817724108695984,
-0.9166086912155151,
-0.5842524766921997,
0.7694123983383179,
0.6143490076065063,
0.9181729555130005,
-0.031721122562885284,
0.9118074774742126,
-0.014286509715020657,
0.4322764575481415,
-1.0600367784500122,
0.25239697098731995,
-0.5118838548660278,
-0.2101784348487854,
0.02091376855969429,
-0.26569241285324097,
-1.0555299520492554,
-0.1862766295671463,
-0.5814065337181091,
-0.49514734745025635,
0.014763378538191319,
0.009157267399132252,
-0.625455379486084,
0.2576098144054413,
-0.5820493102073669,
0.8501297831535339,
-0.03677772358059883,
0.13808587193489075,
-0.3266458511352539,
-0.7068186402320862,
-0.3821283280849457,
0.3570214807987213,
-0.17060673236846924,
0.10531248152256012,
-0.1305234432220459,
0.8557531237602234,
-0.4570019245147705,
0.6937558650970459,
-0.18151339888572693,
-0.06411349773406982,
0.22517728805541992,
-0.14811602234840393,
0.12319725751876831,
0.21847976744174957,
0.08568593114614487,
0.3089753985404968,
0.49933919310569763,
-0.4134252071380615,
-0.7067350745201111,
0.15649421513080597,
-0.6793493032455444,
-0.34848734736442566,
-0.46572062373161316,
-0.19340072572231293,
-0.5020607709884644,
0.006623521447181702,
0.47413212060928345,
0.7299196124076843,
-0.1592632532119751,
-0.08184012770652771,
0.4013185203075409,
-0.3524574339389801,
-0.012199558317661285,
0.4274913966655731,
0.00389564735814929,
-0.2162216752767563,
0.6214473843574524,
0.23958279192447662,
-0.04223203659057617,
0.26320502161979675,
0.3678296208381653,
-0.20097145438194275,
-0.5062962174415588,
-0.4820934236049652,
0.2058696448802948,
-0.8636595606803894,
-0.2939293086528778,
-0.8419283628463745,
-0.5410053133964539,
-0.6036706566810608,
-0.028342420235276222,
-0.06981251388788223,
-0.203282430768013,
-0.41190841794013977,
0.0402633473277092,
0.139038547873497,
1.176454782485962,
0.4138619005680084,
0.21106025576591492,
-1.2512060403823853,
-0.05232332646846771,
0.17967365682125092,
0.36998501420021057,
-0.4052366018295288,
-0.3306044340133667,
-0.26823481917381287,
-0.292120099067688,
-0.20780935883522034,
-1.0930657386779785,
0.10508901625871658,
0.11364804953336716,
0.6794160008430481,
0.8430550694465637,
-0.07814919203519821,
0.6076898574829102,
-0.7785834670066833,
0.9430280327796936,
0.3072108328342438,
-0.62534099817276,
0.6438562870025635,
0.14404870569705963,
0.15529999136924744,
0.6656733751296997,
0.7101934552192688,
-0.7831388711929321,
-0.18116723001003265,
-0.591741144657135,
-0.4436425268650055,
0.575509250164032,
-0.21512912213802338,
0.24256888031959534,
-0.44436052441596985,
0.5643237233161926,
0.052290819585323334,
0.1285717934370041,
0.06186686456203461,
-0.2647578716278076,
0.03338133543729782,
-0.5155708193778992,
0.2337508648633957,
-0.318632036447525,
-0.43032556772232056,
-0.16309529542922974,
0.021788666024804115,
-0.15310776233673096,
0.7889370322227478,
0.31019988656044006,
0.16535639762878418,
0.22746221721172333,
0.24327275156974792,
0.4301912188529968,
0.29386106133461,
0.2966788709163666,
-0.09821393340826035,
0.22431200742721558,
-0.569118857383728,
-0.1183696985244751,
0.16478575766086578,
0.011193904094398022,
0.40162453055381775,
0.6266696453094482,
0.7884697914123535,
0.26068735122680664,
-0.33809712529182434,
0.7102684378623962,
-0.12772254645824432,
-0.14136305451393127,
0.07635141164064407,
0.08361107110977173,
-0.3869222402572632,
0.03342048451304436,
-0.2884986102581024,
0.060326751321554184,
0.4614444673061371,
-0.6315131783485413,
0.2690560519695282,
0.5301879048347473,
-0.6856878399848938,
-0.04580560326576233,
0.15753231942653656,
0.1285494565963745,
-0.4405052959918976,
0.7222103476524353,
-0.18373429775238037,
-0.7768145203590393,
0.09365431219339371,
0.32874563336372375,
0.8186931610107422,
-0.33168572187423706,
0.3535251021385193,
0.2635292112827301,
-0.09005602449178696,
0.023950103670358658,
0.19644993543624878,
-0.2993457317352295,
-0.5542203783988953,
-0.19272871315479279,
-0.2671748697757721,
-0.9246333837509155,
-0.5192664861679077,
-0.8222503066062927,
0.2141697257757187,
-0.612162172794342,
-0.4626879096031189,
0.10519854724407196,
-0.1365189552307129,
-1.0364880561828613,
0.24137063324451447,
0.20535561442375183,
0.8994766473770142,
-0.6508575677871704,
0.6563257575035095,
0.8551270365715027,
-0.4265922009944916,
-1.0627257823944092,
0.09526193141937256,
0.04315735027194023,
-0.8940606713294983,
0.37264207005500793,
0.2693141996860504,
0.15181364119052887,
-0.3362700939178467,
-0.4447688162326813,
-0.3829368054866791,
0.9556506276130676,
0.19917726516723633,
-0.2744726240634918,
-0.4513455331325531,
0.4674986004829407,
0.6209591031074524,
-0.3495049476623535,
0.46007001399993896,
0.32109686732292175,
0.278597891330719,
-0.08800628036260605,
-1.358548879623413,
-0.08050929754972458,
-0.08636441826820374,
-0.13771338760852814,
0.08153799921274185,
-0.3381463587284088,
0.3900817632675171,
-0.10102018713951111,
-0.6088892817497253,
0.07272247225046158,
0.04386897012591362,
-0.37599533796310425,
0.25274112820625305,
0.34488511085510254,
0.9552469253540039,
0.8460401892662048,
-0.4382573664188385,
1.462355375289917,
-0.47612157464027405,
0.3608749210834503,
0.8981867432594299,
-0.16714543104171753,
0.9107999205589294,
0.09305427223443985,
-0.3473907709121704,
0.6468117237091064,
0.3679942786693573,
0.08232570439577103,
0.508328378200531,
0.19761738181114197,
-0.47245296835899353,
-0.1516917198896408,
-0.3487216532230377,
-0.5617309212684631,
0.665643572807312,
0.6293632388114929,
-0.4739004969596863,
-0.20747825503349304,
0.1992386132478714,
0.013885368593037128,
-0.18960872292518616,
-0.018869100138545036,
1.4798485040664673,
0.0501851923763752,
-0.6238282322883606,
0.306875079870224,
-0.06451871246099472,
0.6450200080871582,
-0.48419326543807983,
-0.2222607582807541,
0.16231374442577362,
0.11916505545377731,
-0.4241848289966583,
-0.937966525554657,
0.27634137868881226,
-0.12986862659454346,
0.09409812837839127,
-0.22916480898857117,
0.6334938406944275,
-0.5025710463523865,
-0.4462096393108368,
-0.054591741412878036,
0.2995508909225464,
0.3285144865512848,
0.13916291296482086,
-0.8308818936347961,
-0.16578476130962372,
-0.5262717008590698,
0.2135603427886963,
0.31814882159233093,
0.3742554783821106,
0.3687044680118561,
0.5237860083580017,
0.3445417284965515,
0.3122035562992096,
-0.2653122544288635,
0.09745423495769501,
0.8827842473983765,
-0.355877161026001,
-0.5822252631187439,
-0.4845384955406189,
0.34972527623176575,
-0.07747228443622589,
-0.5168102979660034,
0.3072842061519623,
0.31054767966270447,
0.4754379689693451,
0.07960137724876404,
0.6992354393005371,
0.22285529971122742,
0.6618612408638,
-0.4056369960308075,
0.9821352362632751,
-0.362944632768631,
-0.12117864191532135,
-0.18752816319465637,
-0.19917701184749603,
-0.4096418619155884,
0.912494421005249,
-0.17904679477214813,
-0.11031171679496765,
0.5905698537826538,
0.37900233268737793,
0.1757916957139969,
0.051216915249824524,
0.3834906816482544,
-0.10562772303819656,
0.43139779567718506,
0.4850617051124573,
0.5306107401847839,
-0.5217642784118652,
0.14647559821605682,
-0.15534164011478424,
-0.15172171592712402,
-0.19972969591617584,
-0.5806595683097839,
-0.8133466839790344,
-0.45625829696655273,
-0.6612691879272461,
-0.595405101776123,
0.018445579335093498,
0.9643785953521729,
1.131011724472046,
-0.6843313574790955,
0.6154727935791016,
0.31146204471588135,
-0.3165847957134247,
0.15752941370010376,
-0.15867206454277039,
0.4473941922187805,
-0.3360350430011749,
-0.4896213412284851,
0.11651177704334259,
0.614934504032135,
0.28884920477867126,
-0.2969335615634918,
-0.08332180976867676,
0.2213730663061142,
-0.0908229723572731,
0.5147987604141235,
0.09999695420265198,
-0.790274977684021,
-0.3335251808166504,
-0.081482894718647,
-0.47202420234680176,
0.14200550317764282,
0.7568689584732056,
-0.8192225098609924,
0.678156852722168,
0.09594570845365524,
1.2238104343414307,
0.1373230218887329,
0.07316098362207413,
0.17299392819404602,
-0.6267779469490051,
0.2368200272321701,
0.7193867564201355,
0.3597467541694641,
0.29109346866607666,
-0.5033314228057861,
0.33475321531295776,
-0.023925986140966415,
-0.5377335548400879,
-0.4907901883125305,
0.11007195711135864,
-0.9520578384399414,
-0.06524878740310669,
1.0102094411849976,
-0.7489010691642761,
0.1891728639602661,
-0.33636024594306946,
-0.47083818912506104,
0.45752254128456116,
0.012815411202609539,
0.6687892079353333,
0.7041422128677368,
-0.23340454697608948,
-0.1407533437013626,
-0.19712099432945251,
0.5453213453292847,
0.41376206278800964,
-1.072194218635559,
-0.4332118332386017,
0.09713997691869736,
0.36108994483947754,
0.5438220500946045,
0.8880823850631714,
-0.2789004147052765,
0.41355299949645996,
-0.06041332334280014,
-0.37074926495552063,
-0.04411644488573074,
-0.17660722136497498,
-0.16973085701465607,
0.028918400406837463,
0.031815629452466965,
-0.5187599062919617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04437v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04437v4 | Learning to Extract Structured Entities Using Language Models | 2024-02-06T22:15:09 | 2024-06-18T22:11:27 | Haolun Wu, Ye Yuan, Liana Mikaelyan, Alexander Meulemans, Xue Liu, James Hensman, Bhaskar Mitra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in machine learning have significantly impacted the field of
information extraction, with Language Models (LMs) playing a pivotal role in
extracting structured information from unstructured text. Prior works typically
represent information extraction as triplet-centric and use classical metrics
such as precision and recall for evaluation. We reformulate the task to be
entity-centric, enabling the use of diverse metrics that can provide more
insights from various perspectives. We contribute to the field by introducing
Structured Entity Extraction and proposing the Approximate Entity Set OverlaP
(AESOP) metric, designed to appropriately assess model performance. Later, we
introduce a new model that harnesses the power of LMs for enhanced
effectiveness and efficiency by decomposing the extraction task into multiple
stages. Quantitative and human side-by-side evaluations confirm that our model
outperforms baselines, offering promising directions for future advancements in
structured entity extraction. | [
-0.17841707170009613,
-0.9367907643318176,
0.6540415287017822,
0.13773611187934875,
-0.18984560668468475,
0.1335734874010086,
-0.19157569110393524,
-0.8467378616333008,
-0.01607082039117813,
0.6057153344154358,
-0.16167226433753967,
-0.42356449365615845,
-0.7323565483093262,
0.13467402756214142,
-0.5743757486343384,
1.0692846775054932,
-0.24047081172466278,
-0.1432819813489914,
0.007093868684023619,
0.22378429770469666,
-0.3495481014251709,
-0.31634828448295593,
-0.5181384086608887,
-0.35449591279029846,
0.33753567934036255,
0.3827214539051056,
0.4955652952194214,
1.061605453491211,
0.5820720195770264,
0.26381051540374756,
0.18388615548610687,
0.2927270531654358,
-0.05707177892327309,
0.2565619647502899,
-0.0957198292016983,
-0.2951502203941345,
-0.5870317220687866,
0.18642309308052063,
0.8546726703643799,
1.0928959846496582,
-0.41185957193374634,
0.20410121977329254,
0.1785571575164795,
0.33683863282203674,
-0.6735812425613403,
0.6894104480743408,
-0.8772991895675659,
0.03223840892314911,
-0.16622935235500336,
-0.3668678104877472,
-0.4408225119113922,
-0.24025361239910126,
0.2796298563480377,
-0.6747003793716431,
0.09489449858665466,
0.15249103307724,
0.9969114065170288,
0.09067625552415848,
-0.2849283814430237,
-0.45749667286872864,
-0.8961191773414612,
0.8166365027427673,
-0.4412263035774231,
0.6077449321746826,
0.14949700236320496,
-0.07948136329650879,
-0.03532171994447708,
-0.9908966422080994,
-0.36077743768692017,
-0.03002277947962284,
0.014737696386873722,
-0.22326919436454773,
-0.1084127277135849,
0.1098639965057373,
0.2204897403717041,
0.43394720554351807,
-0.23683646321296692,
0.33035093545913696,
-0.60027015209198,
0.10948118567466736,
0.5596230030059814,
0.01009643729776144,
0.6123331785202026,
-0.34119102358818054,
-0.486343115568161,
0.2724607288837433,
-0.6717984080314636,
0.10178191214799881,
0.30854853987693787,
0.43792298436164856,
0.44062089920043945,
0.6866214871406555,
0.015527546405792236,
0.5407184958457947,
-0.1634252369403839,
-0.2653678059577942,
0.10688234865665436,
-0.10089316219091415,
-0.3331269919872284,
0.12731751799583435,
0.7866671085357666,
0.01032519992440939,
0.34331804513931274,
-0.4632154107093811,
-0.5641586780548096,
-0.13521243631839752,
0.40078115463256836,
-0.8432379961013794,
-0.47155070304870605,
0.20669399201869965,
-0.6221758127212524,
-0.34868884086608887,
0.16529835760593414,
-0.8715323805809021,
-0.09420736879110336,
-0.43152785301208496,
0.22068476676940918,
-0.4637906551361084,
-0.357697993516922,
0.0429927259683609,
-0.16561166942119598,
0.13116240501403809,
0.2552523612976074,
-1.0041301250457764,
0.6640982627868652,
0.9714827537536621,
0.7915632128715515,
-0.5036612153053284,
-0.12760648131370544,
-0.4834713637828827,
0.22660130262374878,
-0.27971869707107544,
0.8077476620674133,
-0.7694008946418762,
-0.28605061769485474,
-0.1701028198003769,
-0.02284008078277111,
-0.03757360205054283,
-0.5292360186576843,
0.5707721710205078,
-0.6894080638885498,
0.38049012422561646,
0.08578310161828995,
-0.9586983323097229,
-0.16979318857192993,
0.04579025134444237,
-0.9566879868507385,
1.2014909982681274,
0.1062217652797699,
-0.6626662611961365,
0.4062288999557495,
-0.6629600524902344,
-0.32785895466804504,
0.3796887993812561,
-0.3570140302181244,
-0.40415817499160767,
0.19914154708385468,
0.2016497254371643,
0.47991880774497986,
-0.36157986521720886,
0.252725213766098,
-0.44779306650161743,
-0.2415803074836731,
-0.03763185068964958,
-0.14700357615947723,
0.6599234938621521,
0.09868963062763214,
0.06154722347855568,
-0.1434069275856018,
-0.9330522418022156,
0.18918274343013763,
0.33367231488227844,
-0.5226951837539673,
-0.6399125456809998,
0.10171292722225189,
0.009586390107870102,
0.08340746909379959,
0.21808652579784393,
-0.491552472114563,
0.2741744816303253,
-0.4982394278049469,
0.4521394968032837,
0.6596947908401489,
0.19763974845409393,
0.7713571786880493,
0.05255219712853432,
0.4690302014350891,
-0.14722193777561188,
-0.2861708700656891,
-0.20979462563991547,
-0.30996307730674744,
-0.38519275188446045,
-0.6215204000473022,
0.5399714708328247,
0.6176357865333557,
-0.45845896005630493,
0.42031848430633545,
-0.49060240387916565,
-0.4028552770614624,
-0.6567449569702148,
0.1948748379945755,
0.2419598251581192,
0.7320863604545593,
0.33445921540260315,
-0.5341068506240845,
-0.721943199634552,
-0.8061555027961731,
-0.6227495074272156,
-0.18478715419769287,
-0.09196577221155167,
0.061120063066482544,
0.5050252676010132,
0.26121407747268677,
1.0657892227172852,
-0.5481982231140137,
-0.04252700135111809,
-0.34931111335754395,
0.15796461701393127,
0.20319801568984985,
0.38538721203804016,
-0.00805311743170023,
-1.035426139831543,
-0.22721317410469055,
0.030163396149873734,
-0.8984165191650391,
-0.14898383617401123,
0.15433749556541443,
0.17531901597976685,
-0.0475630983710289,
0.3868802785873413,
-0.7729923725128174,
0.26547789573669434,
0.06503839790821075,
0.022497842088341713,
0.49955031275749207,
0.082440085709095,
-0.030202709138393402,
-0.9478193521499634,
0.2083861231803894,
0.04452549293637276,
-0.3864310383796692,
-0.8136250972747803,
0.10450335592031479,
0.2170419692993164,
-0.05692201480269432,
-0.22991704940795898,
0.48874905705451965,
-0.9809601306915283,
-0.5387197136878967,
-0.2053973376750946,
0.44725096225738525,
0.46018752455711365,
0.35972240567207336,
0.278742253780365,
0.5150085091590881,
0.22615501284599304,
-0.5797469019889832,
0.174117311835289,
0.09949941188097,
-0.6391080021858215,
0.28774493932724,
-0.6521196365356445,
0.24956142902374268,
-0.2638951241970062,
0.013560404069721699,
-0.3518877625465393,
-0.013029532507061958,
0.17504848539829254,
-0.2030024528503418,
0.788936972618103,
-0.2501959800720215,
-0.4720754027366638,
-0.09251504391431808,
-0.14083422720432281,
0.23016229271888733,
0.287759929895401,
-0.30669498443603516,
0.5501002669334412,
0.8888586759567261,
-0.47919297218322754,
-0.8261483907699585,
-0.31046509742736816,
-0.10430462658405304,
-0.4515826106071472,
-0.3693164587020874,
0.5681103467941284,
0.34328773617744446,
-0.5535783767700195,
0.30008241534233093,
-0.3049628436565399,
-0.33410996198654175,
0.4491843283176422,
0.18147796392440796,
0.5358126163482666,
-0.3438519239425659,
0.3232201337814331,
-0.17740178108215332,
0.0057273670099675655,
0.11289472132921219,
-0.5616874098777771,
0.4367612600326538,
-0.17128856480121613,
-0.18434923887252808,
-0.3434162437915802,
0.44648632407188416,
0.024574780836701393,
-0.4896828830242157,
0.7532522678375244,
0.33173489570617676,
-0.9539264440536499,
0.15019600093364716,
-0.36823129653930664,
-0.0773010328412056,
-0.328647643327713,
0.7401857376098633,
-0.5566091537475586,
-0.6827365756034851,
0.26218363642692566,
-0.14197756350040436,
0.3829425573348999,
0.5969627499580383,
0.22358886897563934,
-0.1023596003651619,
1.0312974452972412,
0.9289272427558899,
0.081144317984581,
0.5039409399032593,
-0.11723950505256653,
0.3030596971511841,
-0.8435658812522888,
-0.4170779585838318,
-0.6523470282554626,
0.08257922530174255,
-0.34562063217163086,
-0.02259211428463459,
0.029108930379152298,
0.6955952048301697,
0.09248118102550507,
0.3837994337081909,
-0.15093038976192474,
0.48909246921539307,
0.05292157083749771,
-0.07288243621587753,
0.46538636088371277,
0.09868089109659195,
0.30469459295272827,
-0.10908889770507812,
-0.3815295696258545,
-0.8826965093612671,
1.043630599975586,
0.6306089758872986,
0.3041868507862091,
0.05554133653640747,
0.7442899942398071,
0.24845081567764282,
0.45466819405555725,
-0.9184451103210449,
0.22325065732002258,
0.057141244411468506,
-0.5263914465904236,
-0.40233486890792847,
-0.5327507853507996,
-0.9512215256690979,
0.425568550825119,
-0.08751858025789261,
-1.044575572013855,
-0.006082610227167606,
-0.13119269907474518,
-0.26974520087242126,
0.35422876477241516,
-0.6607303023338318,
0.6939870119094849,
-0.046873968094587326,
-0.11879676580429077,
0.16273146867752075,
-0.43496209383010864,
0.39483585953712463,
-0.3118903934955597,
0.5112382769584656,
-0.3928813636302948,
-0.38329100608825684,
0.8489088416099548,
-0.29536277055740356,
0.39838242530822754,
-0.07880488783121109,
-0.14589466154575348,
0.16857977211475372,
0.16583576798439026,
0.5415220260620117,
-0.07073448598384857,
-0.1677403450012207,
0.2892634868621826,
0.07216613739728928,
-0.268509179353714,
-0.7738174796104431,
0.3729419708251953,
-0.456447035074234,
-0.3657076358795166,
-0.1588180959224701,
-0.44260427355766296,
0.00011597859702305868,
0.4127075970172882,
0.08783356100320816,
0.3424510955810547,
-0.2932952642440796,
0.010947341099381447,
0.6263068914413452,
0.16936159133911133,
0.5317389965057373,
0.3556363582611084,
-0.25765377283096313,
-0.19196024537086487,
0.5645290613174438,
0.009063225239515305,
0.11433818936347961,
0.6453034281730652,
-0.10091304033994675,
-0.38143566250801086,
-0.5056842565536499,
-0.41435083746910095,
-0.021924611181020737,
-0.7858561873435974,
-0.20722836256027222,
-1.0638521909713745,
-0.23807145655155182,
-0.46675458550453186,
0.42293596267700195,
-0.49204063415527344,
-0.6864010691642761,
-0.3963784873485565,
-0.1707414835691452,
-0.2379673421382904,
0.853388786315918,
0.22887404263019562,
0.12811937928199768,
-0.9934489130973816,
0.12830501794815063,
-0.04281917214393616,
0.07775560021400452,
-0.23527973890304565,
-0.4148927330970764,
-0.021398399025201797,
-0.3047402799129486,
-0.15409907698631287,
-1.345018982887268,
0.5143927335739136,
0.45151227712631226,
0.6871805191040039,
0.3300018608570099,
-0.37053126096725464,
0.4943384826183319,
-0.6349828243255615,
0.5362433195114136,
0.04238958656787872,
-0.8363439440727234,
0.4875819981098175,
0.04874039813876152,
-0.3074035942554474,
0.3039792478084564,
0.6098631024360657,
-0.41107791662216187,
-0.039907943457365036,
-0.7169444561004639,
-0.9038322567939758,
0.634274959564209,
0.2725406289100647,
-0.3180367350578308,
-0.007070980966091156,
0.6012322306632996,
0.2784639894962311,
0.3254167139530182,
-1.0025291442871094,
-0.09180130064487457,
0.2953718602657318,
-0.32381004095077515,
0.10740631073713303,
-0.311630517244339,
0.20702193677425385,
0.1371275633573532,
0.700925350189209,
0.07580249756574631,
-0.0056614321656525135,
0.07135381549596786,
-0.5343311429023743,
-0.04273097217082977,
0.4260975420475006,
-0.061484016478061676,
0.81778484582901,
-0.08418767154216766,
0.26259705424308777,
0.09457758814096451,
-0.3737265169620514,
-0.17401279509067535,
0.47235292196273804,
-0.1323457658290863,
-0.018943870440125465,
0.6999775171279907,
0.5652254223823547,
0.38931357860565186,
-0.5537404417991638,
0.45706382393836975,
-0.09056755155324936,
0.1932750940322876,
-0.38859671354293823,
-0.05669992417097092,
-0.18689626455307007,
0.19543808698654175,
0.2860966622829437,
-0.08865835517644882,
0.4987086057662964,
-0.5647144317626953,
0.42501476407051086,
0.34045419096946716,
-0.4425831139087677,
-0.29850876331329346,
0.3282375633716583,
-0.07830320298671722,
-0.505405068397522,
0.6796230673789978,
-0.03757457435131073,
-0.5000304579734802,
0.5299476981163025,
0.46111124753952026,
0.7235628962516785,
-0.2802550196647644,
-0.08576390147209167,
0.2434837818145752,
0.3995426595211029,
-0.27815091609954834,
0.12843863666057587,
-0.20881034433841705,
-0.7700634002685547,
-0.4082777202129364,
-0.8368678092956543,
0.0032110288739204407,
0.16457417607307434,
-0.8923752307891846,
0.45948830246925354,
-0.22963550686836243,
0.13236702978610992,
0.3725999891757965,
0.3003675937652588,
-0.8165912628173828,
-0.004480781964957714,
0.1106858029961586,
0.8738090991973877,
-0.7486540675163269,
0.8746725916862488,
0.6285107135772705,
-0.6083744168281555,
-0.8331825137138367,
-0.2729104161262512,
-0.11940217018127441,
-0.7030187249183655,
0.4169861674308777,
0.49057888984680176,
0.1082049086689949,
-0.05235055834054947,
-0.28302645683288574,
-0.8079012036323547,
1.040244698524475,
0.23888792097568512,
-0.5152934789657593,
-0.6233596801757812,
-0.13012415170669556,
0.3477063477039337,
-0.8363168239593506,
0.4107879102230072,
0.8130283355712891,
0.2136591523885727,
-0.3692215383052826,
-0.8320657014846802,
-0.04776912182569504,
-0.3557537794113159,
0.012687388807535172,
0.47931602597236633,
0.10531662404537201,
0.8602926731109619,
-0.13698525726795197,
-0.566328763961792,
-0.06617525964975357,
0.8639199733734131,
0.24357227981090546,
0.14059250056743622,
0.7400713562965393,
0.2902214825153351,
1.1159000396728516,
0.15099242329597473,
0.914939820766449,
-0.14030669629573822,
0.4057604670524597,
1.3612737655639648,
-0.3556460738182068,
0.9559919238090515,
0.39753589034080505,
-0.07521822303533554,
0.6952001452445984,
0.7724640965461731,
0.14723600447177887,
0.30782097578048706,
0.000558497675228864,
-0.05116870999336243,
-0.1807807981967926,
-0.16989827156066895,
-0.19484718143939972,
0.7992601990699768,
0.6279415488243103,
-0.6779425144195557,
-0.17231379449367523,
-0.37281742691993713,
0.08968833833932877,
-0.04271111637353897,
-0.1729363203048706,
0.8445286750793457,
0.2143642008304596,
-0.6845782399177551,
-0.06326711922883987,
0.3327721655368805,
0.104231096804142,
-0.3331303596496582,
-0.36575642228126526,
0.08426744490861893,
0.025312017649412155,
-0.1129700243473053,
-0.8229897618293762,
0.3335096538066864,
0.05119278281927109,
-0.3670189380645752,
-0.32798346877098083,
1.0468751192092896,
-0.6333873271942139,
-0.27101534605026245,
0.2953489422798157,
0.5506865978240967,
0.5420434474945068,
-0.3202081322669983,
-0.6910036206245422,
-0.1362714171409607,
-0.10629016160964966,
-0.38939449191093445,
0.035821493715047836,
0.5777236223220825,
-0.08673067390918732,
0.425528883934021,
0.4917691946029663,
0.33376771211624146,
-0.04694755747914314,
-0.13002699613571167,
0.594491183757782,
-0.6430997848510742,
-0.42916715145111084,
-1.112425684928894,
0.2897346317768097,
-0.4399586319923401,
-0.0492108054459095,
0.4611920714378357,
0.8001709580421448,
0.7426244020462036,
0.3995659351348877,
0.6660217046737671,
0.022370636463165283,
0.5531891584396362,
-0.7260947227478027,
0.37339869141578674,
-0.5041952133178711,
0.608831524848938,
-0.3571653664112091,
-1.2154042720794678,
0.09516644477844238,
0.22591090202331543,
-0.12111341953277588,
0.08110474795103073,
0.6591247320175171,
0.34996840357780457,
-0.23668137192726135,
0.37793201208114624,
0.0390360951423645,
0.03744497522711754,
0.5145308971405029,
0.4941416382789612,
0.8178091049194336,
-0.42766839265823364,
0.528762698173523,
-0.28140372037887573,
-0.43573635816574097,
0.10174155235290527,
-0.9468801021575928,
-0.46354812383651733,
-0.6328626871109009,
-0.20056602358818054,
-0.20592662692070007,
-0.08595272153615952,
0.9425697922706604,
0.7004837989807129,
-0.5993419289588928,
0.046355750411748886,
0.05146384984254837,
0.31467205286026,
0.06022072955965996,
-0.2832912504673004,
0.41958630084991455,
-0.2909243702888489,
-0.9044281244277954,
0.49468815326690674,
0.5166714787483215,
-0.05007006227970123,
-0.2133355736732483,
0.19369623064994812,
-0.1484818458557129,
-0.13037322461605072,
0.4424891769886017,
0.31488290429115295,
-0.6319243311882019,
-0.30294620990753174,
-0.049551595002412796,
-0.2364378422498703,
0.1577753722667694,
0.886978805065155,
-0.5708098411560059,
0.2329624593257904,
0.3167002499103546,
0.6451039910316467,
0.3698323667049408,
0.04262905567884445,
0.7013162970542908,
-0.8170541524887085,
0.012538421899080276,
0.21575424075126648,
0.48149117827415466,
0.45509395003318787,
-0.3945714831352234,
0.5446600317955017,
0.2955903112888336,
-0.40231963992118835,
-0.9450867772102356,
0.288170725107193,
-0.6090967655181885,
-0.3557259440422058,
1.0632022619247437,
-0.38539230823516846,
-0.3178982436656952,
-0.13403920829296112,
0.2542918026447296,
0.47441405057907104,
-0.21291612088680267,
0.6381542086601257,
0.6675920486450195,
-0.10070767253637314,
-0.22008633613586426,
-0.5570389628410339,
0.4522431492805481,
0.1673022210597992,
-1.0271040201187134,
-0.1266508251428604,
0.4225573241710663,
0.42250144481658936,
0.22122012078762054,
0.7127950191497803,
-0.4429776966571808,
-0.07498593628406525,
-0.13639093935489655,
0.3888998329639435,
0.11683439463376999,
-0.6402631998062134,
-0.4047665297985077,
0.520041286945343,
0.036315735429525375,
-0.05205370485782623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04411v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04411v2 | DFA-RAG: Conversational Semantic Router for Large Language Model with Definite Finite Automaton | 2024-02-06T21:14:45 | 2024-06-03T01:40:46 | Yiyou Sun, Junjie Hu, Wei Cheng, Haifeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces the retrieval-augmented large language model with
Definite Finite Automaton (DFA-RAG), a novel framework designed to enhance the
capabilities of conversational agents using large language models (LLMs).
Traditional LLMs face challenges in generating regulated and compliant
responses in special scenarios with predetermined response guidelines, like
emotional support and customer service. Our framework addresses these
challenges by embedding a Definite Finite Automaton (DFA), learned from
training dialogues, within the LLM. This structured approach acts as a semantic
router which enables the LLM to adhere to a deterministic response pathway. The
routing is achieved by the retrieval-augmentation generation (RAG) strategy,
which carefully selects dialogue examples aligned with the current
conversational context. The advantages of DFA-RAG include an interpretable
structure through human-readable DFA, context-aware retrieval for responses in
conversations, and plug-and-play compatibility with existing LLMs. Extensive
benchmarks validate DFA-RAG's effectiveness, indicating its potential as a
valuable contribution to the conversational agent. | [
-0.4387325644493103,
-0.9217132329940796,
0.5903376936912537,
0.054292529821395874,
-0.1588239073753357,
0.3847697675228119,
0.06394137442111969,
-0.4926833212375641,
0.3377164900302887,
0.7064559459686279,
-0.6405301094055176,
-0.19791261851787567,
-0.30610135197639465,
0.1572011560201645,
-0.4800596833229065,
0.7222477793693542,
0.16160492599010468,
0.035801857709884644,
-0.19805096089839935,
0.062135569751262665,
-0.38053223490715027,
-0.6511471271514893,
-0.8349402546882629,
-0.40692412853240967,
0.6180561780929565,
0.1678512543439865,
0.9447926878929138,
0.7076058983802795,
0.5664321780204773,
0.5477654933929443,
-0.1523333042860031,
0.02107338421046734,
-0.39084574580192566,
0.5393856167793274,
-0.25166070461273193,
-0.36044782400131226,
-0.8753098845481873,
-0.26739224791526794,
0.8364326357841492,
0.6868395805358887,
-0.3084734380245209,
-0.2271825075149536,
-0.37734082341194153,
0.7914437651634216,
-0.3900628089904785,
0.2355295568704605,
-0.6039568185806274,
-0.04677582532167435,
-0.04497303441166878,
-0.015995193272829056,
-0.4489635229110718,
-0.14832405745983124,
0.18499867618083954,
-0.5696367621421814,
-0.0550931915640831,
0.037909187376499176,
0.5873544812202454,
0.5979866981506348,
-0.6187878847122192,
-0.3980885148048401,
-0.9176759719848633,
0.604894757270813,
-0.6483862996101379,
0.35257136821746826,
0.443063348531723,
0.6398515105247498,
-0.6701536774635315,
-0.7887733578681946,
-0.8103519082069397,
-0.46745169162750244,
-0.0889805480837822,
0.08730370551347733,
0.04520181193947792,
0.3325353264808655,
0.12289860099554062,
0.58297199010849,
-0.2889205515384674,
0.13587763905525208,
0.20151035487651825,
0.0548376590013504,
0.8435627222061157,
0.511759877204895,
0.09248597174882889,
0.07950825244188309,
-0.43984219431877136,
-0.04101790115237236,
-0.34338247776031494,
-0.31661301851272583,
0.3954390585422516,
0.05484996363520622,
-0.05057680234313011,
0.35140618681907654,
-0.4307411313056946,
0.898431122303009,
0.20641839504241943,
-0.32786938548088074,
0.35583460330963135,
0.1222471371293068,
-0.10605733096599579,
-0.053522758185863495,
0.6747414469718933,
-0.16297604143619537,
-0.029100675135850906,
-0.25909367203712463,
-0.35065916180610657,
-0.13642749190330505,
0.3435843288898468,
-0.8850976824760437,
0.08755199611186981,
0.14578337967395782,
-0.2236306220293045,
-0.4355660080909729,
-0.05569270998239517,
-0.7832825779914856,
-0.40632104873657227,
-0.45226213335990906,
0.16352783143520355,
-0.1798664629459381,
-0.5072701573371887,
0.2526625096797943,
0.17291311919689178,
0.5193976759910583,
0.5405100584030151,
-0.6633037328720093,
0.5660350322723389,
0.9597770571708679,
0.4514324367046356,
-0.20604565739631653,
-0.0789455845952034,
-0.6200685501098633,
0.12087107449769974,
-0.45170965790748596,
0.6692622303962708,
-0.7237635254859924,
-0.4573250412940979,
-0.025816025212407112,
0.007557456847280264,
-0.03148632496595383,
-0.5416330099105835,
0.7514403462409973,
-0.9642711877822876,
0.16851425170898438,
0.0385880246758461,
-0.6317585706710815,
-0.27240270376205444,
0.21575437486171722,
-0.8479193449020386,
0.6473650932312012,
0.22882483899593353,
-0.46200457215309143,
-0.08376108855009079,
-0.5457414984703064,
-0.412148118019104,
0.17252551019191742,
-0.2507427930831909,
-0.16310569643974304,
-0.06939774751663208,
-0.3302377164363861,
0.2657623589038849,
-0.5712209343910217,
0.39487192034721375,
-0.2839585840702057,
-0.17070521414279938,
0.5400877594947815,
-0.6841036677360535,
0.5986335277557373,
0.41632553935050964,
-0.28728312253952026,
-0.03655737638473511,
-0.9084444642066956,
-0.19020439684391022,
0.3211604952812195,
-0.40825724601745605,
-0.2963787019252777,
0.07601174712181091,
-0.09956677258014679,
0.4496086835861206,
0.29607143998146057,
-0.5832051038742065,
0.06178069859743118,
-0.7140734195709229,
-0.12433598190546036,
0.7607967257499695,
-0.0821596309542656,
0.6002383828163147,
-0.5106996297836304,
0.5122637748718262,
-0.018856102600693703,
-0.011120681650936604,
-0.33999577164649963,
-0.2968926727771759,
-0.9242347478866577,
-0.4951900243759155,
0.06862559169530869,
0.4975745975971222,
-0.8079218864440918,
0.5634502172470093,
-0.22368185222148895,
-0.45398327708244324,
-0.27861765027046204,
-0.10123144835233688,
0.45641088485717773,
0.6778408288955688,
0.058086853474378586,
-0.24475309252738953,
-0.4148596227169037,
-0.691227912902832,
0.201131209731102,
-0.30350449681282043,
0.039890602231025696,
0.48375505208969116,
0.2736952602863312,
-0.5049100518226624,
0.9922448992729187,
-0.6057870388031006,
-0.3612613379955292,
-0.11183340847492218,
-0.11376141756772995,
0.22687536478042603,
0.3277941942214966,
0.3371085226535797,
-1.1613508462905884,
-0.6602266430854797,
-0.017975231632590294,
-0.5652270317077637,
-0.10986310988664627,
0.08709461987018585,
-0.23033933341503143,
0.5020034909248352,
0.27092304825782776,
-0.7485262155532837,
0.3297973573207855,
0.47356346249580383,
-0.5118831396102905,
0.3404247760772705,
-0.12866154313087463,
0.17432203888893127,
-1.22186279296875,
0.11782457679510117,
-0.3517296314239502,
-0.48555275797843933,
-0.8305612802505493,
-0.0731939896941185,
-0.37696489691734314,
-0.14189012348651886,
-0.2481255829334259,
0.8937475085258484,
-0.13179993629455566,
-0.19484812021255493,
-0.5485961437225342,
0.09952885657548904,
0.11702164262533188,
0.5356882214546204,
0.08550959080457687,
0.8016874194145203,
0.3108943998813629,
-0.6670017242431641,
0.6186501383781433,
0.507560670375824,
0.09384977072477341,
0.7611590623855591,
-0.5884499549865723,
0.3450026512145996,
-0.299397736787796,
0.6465510725975037,
-1.0108202695846558,
-0.28693827986717224,
0.2583635449409485,
-0.3784567415714264,
0.4034583568572998,
-0.08628086745738983,
-0.35610222816467285,
-0.24244089424610138,
0.17764019966125488,
0.31054356694221497,
0.5213119983673096,
-0.4383670389652252,
1.0387940406799316,
0.5774015188217163,
-0.2574498653411865,
-0.4640755355358124,
-0.25252944231033325,
0.22581428289413452,
-0.15014363825321198,
-0.6707010269165039,
0.45536959171295166,
-0.3535631597042084,
-0.47630301117897034,
-0.27748727798461914,
-0.06079750880599022,
-0.2852747440338135,
0.2009180337190628,
0.21885961294174194,
0.2376803457736969,
-0.054176315665245056,
0.17845532298088074,
-0.23896826803684235,
-0.3553657829761505,
0.10877226293087006,
-0.014904958195984364,
0.7651156783103943,
-0.1736087203025818,
-0.4289347529411316,
-0.2616160809993744,
0.548576831817627,
0.6918049454689026,
-0.3341223895549774,
0.5845651030540466,
0.5077748894691467,
-0.14807210862636566,
-0.09479229152202606,
-0.7705135941505432,
-0.15124398469924927,
-0.5713394284248352,
0.35523831844329834,
-0.5666598081588745,
-0.9171192049980164,
0.5926247239112854,
-0.23742663860321045,
0.041814472526311874,
0.3021555244922638,
0.6741364002227783,
0.09550298750400543,
1.115755558013916,
0.6162382960319519,
-0.1328233778476715,
0.5539852380752563,
-0.022064458578824997,
-0.027821559458971024,
-0.671487033367157,
-0.13425712287425995,
-0.5720893144607544,
0.002005570800974965,
-0.5339046716690063,
-0.5869048237800598,
0.20894670486450195,
-0.2430664747953415,
-0.4146624803543091,
0.0033526543993502855,
-0.0952456146478653,
0.22292885184288025,
0.10239052772521973,
-0.13322436809539795,
0.5178994536399841,
-0.19677616655826569,
-0.07995763421058655,
0.2585447132587433,
-0.5057435631752014,
-0.48130059242248535,
0.5458482503890991,
0.648379385471344,
0.9881809949874878,
0.5184191465377808,
0.616749107837677,
0.264202356338501,
0.1639539748430252,
-1.0503122806549072,
0.8220396041870117,
-0.1683836430311203,
-0.6351084113121033,
-0.27310407161712646,
-0.5720059275627136,
-1.013810396194458,
0.26683855056762695,
-0.09883631020784378,
-0.5878257751464844,
0.1429624855518341,
-0.07180608063936234,
-0.07874143868684769,
0.07760822772979736,
-0.26480337977409363,
0.5380198359489441,
-0.28247538208961487,
-0.32675793766975403,
-0.2904195487499237,
-0.5594797730445862,
0.12822845578193665,
-0.31392574310302734,
0.09538722038269043,
-0.1969136744737625,
-0.27430108189582825,
0.48474618792533875,
-0.4741448163986206,
0.7336521148681641,
-0.2293303906917572,
-0.42124342918395996,
0.2067132145166397,
0.23809009790420532,
0.8171342611312866,
-0.1263967901468277,
-0.1871042549610138,
-0.16389012336730957,
-0.2005072832107544,
-0.09403606504201889,
-0.8019155263900757,
0.6505047678947449,
-0.6246857643127441,
-0.8029294610023499,
-0.4237542152404785,
-0.677507221698761,
-0.48438403010368347,
0.2626880705356598,
-0.45675286650657654,
0.4914368987083435,
-0.3717063367366791,
0.14186684787273407,
0.871995210647583,
-0.26998499035835266,
0.3928138017654419,
1.1597398519515991,
-0.31603094935417175,
-0.37057819962501526,
0.6503670811653137,
-0.2241685390472412,
0.3479892909526825,
0.5312919616699219,
0.195501908659935,
-0.387356162071228,
-0.23043575882911682,
-0.4235009253025055,
0.2636389136314392,
-0.5885902643203735,
-0.2690128982067108,
-0.8584233522415161,
-0.36387717723846436,
-0.20884311199188232,
-0.030431732535362244,
-0.5614122152328491,
-0.32874372601509094,
-0.14986808598041534,
0.08737620711326599,
0.6203743815422058,
0.7686380743980408,
0.06933237612247467,
0.32035377621650696,
-0.7367781400680542,
0.4598185122013092,
0.2775387465953827,
0.636256217956543,
0.11854185163974762,
-0.5884377956390381,
-0.31309178471565247,
0.12762892246246338,
-0.029627008363604546,
-0.7401549220085144,
0.3563416600227356,
0.1671036332845688,
0.7264173626899719,
0.14195169508457184,
0.2816648781299591,
0.527729868888855,
-0.8396086692810059,
0.41066309809684753,
0.10472980886697769,
-0.6117227077484131,
0.19156181812286377,
-0.657400906085968,
0.2429172247648239,
0.39289987087249756,
0.3890693485736847,
-0.4330236315727234,
-0.26043757796287537,
-0.526877760887146,
-0.9205374121665955,
0.6611591577529907,
0.07166583091020584,
0.3778671324253082,
-0.2756146192550659,
0.30259495973587036,
-0.2607458531856537,
0.14571578800678253,
-0.19075477123260498,
-0.2509920597076416,
0.05299175903201103,
-0.32570400834083557,
0.11906378716230392,
-0.37198638916015625,
-0.22981831431388855,
0.0947369635105133,
0.6968105435371399,
-0.23269598186016083,
0.3715607821941376,
0.26027679443359375,
0.017678730189800262,
-0.2066442221403122,
0.18525943160057068,
0.35285335779190063,
0.5435017347335815,
-0.14514020085334778,
-0.3315228223800659,
0.11113337427377701,
-0.5420262217521667,
0.4300146996974945,
0.40550121665000916,
0.08195029944181442,
0.08609075099229813,
-0.12396366894245148,
0.7041760683059692,
0.1595645397901535,
-0.724928081035614,
0.4745633900165558,
-0.25918251276016235,
0.00797995738685131,
-0.9211405515670776,
0.1491713672876358,
-0.10210876166820526,
0.39730849862098694,
0.5766379833221436,
-0.39640143513679504,
0.2522110342979431,
-0.33346879482269287,
0.5826501846313477,
0.44824597239494324,
-0.37487131357192993,
0.060727186501026154,
0.49372807145118713,
0.37825027108192444,
-0.5581347346305847,
0.1881147027015686,
-0.167070209980011,
-0.3862488269805908,
0.5428224205970764,
0.6342786550521851,
1.030194640159607,
-0.3675698935985565,
0.1771504431962967,
0.24867461621761322,
-0.2576017677783966,
0.04006554186344147,
-0.08197842538356781,
0.040765274316072464,
-0.6903685927391052,
-0.5751776695251465,
-0.8993273377418518,
-0.5485379695892334,
-0.08889365941286087,
-0.542422354221344,
0.10872160643339157,
-0.38995039463043213,
-0.18479573726654053,
-0.09330043196678162,
0.07214720547199249,
-0.4684336185455322,
0.26103028655052185,
0.15626297891139984,
0.904188334941864,
-0.2791420519351959,
0.8937563896179199,
0.6135863065719604,
-0.3698608875274658,
-0.8262795805931091,
0.0276878010481596,
0.05526209622621536,
-0.46554917097091675,
0.830075204372406,
-0.14493891596794128,
-0.4890112280845642,
0.11014889180660248,
0.05658190697431564,
-1.0799697637557983,
1.1678754091262817,
0.19257934391498566,
-0.5507803559303284,
-0.06122386455535889,
0.32525813579559326,
0.5734090209007263,
-0.5006808638572693,
0.23192505538463593,
0.49728694558143616,
0.195111945271492,
0.6400401592254639,
-0.977994441986084,
0.12351061403751373,
-0.15814702212810516,
0.24571047723293304,
0.23736439645290375,
-0.9010332822799683,
0.6668599247932434,
0.2491595298051834,
-0.05552564933896065,
0.5028696060180664,
0.6249679327011108,
0.12328968942165375,
0.09518194943666458,
0.6354374289512634,
0.5775201320648193,
0.5172070264816284,
0.10046907514333725,
0.9520776867866516,
-0.32743898034095764,
0.0034934075083583593,
1.2248880863189697,
-0.6121958494186401,
0.8457990288734436,
0.24042516946792603,
-0.08666850626468658,
0.7244262099266052,
0.1178700253367424,
0.37305325269699097,
0.3791924715042114,
0.25754204392433167,
-0.7816179394721985,
-0.06386114656925201,
-0.28117507696151733,
-0.1687932163476944,
0.8532366156578064,
0.4709429442882538,
-0.2409861534833908,
-0.281527042388916,
-0.02653488889336586,
0.18304187059402466,
0.24580104649066925,
-0.23661479353904724,
1.2971361875534058,
0.11728671938180923,
-0.6559057235717773,
0.7027966380119324,
-0.04983097314834595,
0.513670027256012,
-0.8459777235984802,
-0.27182722091674805,
-0.36584627628326416,
0.3268618881702423,
-0.07266520708799362,
-0.5890900492668152,
0.5178526639938354,
0.0487837977707386,
-0.1488025039434433,
-0.04519178718328476,
0.9583774209022522,
-0.3709239363670349,
-0.2462891787290573,
0.4048667252063751,
0.4235629439353943,
0.1007973700761795,
0.19827881455421448,
-0.913831353187561,
0.2113306075334549,
-0.36157092452049255,
-0.4299958348274231,
0.5259283781051636,
0.6123807430267334,
0.09535472095012665,
0.8123537302017212,
0.6860051155090332,
-0.22614935040473938,
-0.28047609329223633,
0.16979368031024933,
1.0979878902435303,
-0.5993633270263672,
-0.4216042459011078,
-0.5817834138870239,
0.6596948504447937,
-0.14587152004241943,
0.21760369837284088,
0.61285400390625,
0.33403655886650085,
0.5052117705345154,
0.09803421795368195,
0.4256552755832672,
-0.14497825503349304,
0.7892889976501465,
-0.3888455927371979,
0.7611032724380493,
-0.441444456577301,
0.4044620990753174,
-0.334902822971344,
-0.8618263006210327,
-0.032935984432697296,
0.769574761390686,
-0.22531557083129883,
0.18767569959163666,
0.33079519867897034,
1.028266191482544,
0.12738394737243652,
-0.1571100503206253,
0.5407914519309998,
0.2782120108604431,
0.5467332005500793,
0.31962862610816956,
0.8569969534873962,
-0.2680293917655945,
0.435933917760849,
-0.07985492050647736,
-0.3275168836116791,
-0.13595494627952576,
-0.8690284490585327,
-0.694128692150116,
-0.7625070810317993,
-0.11590229719877243,
-0.4758080244064331,
0.08999302238225937,
0.9997947812080383,
0.5281311273574829,
-0.41972315311431885,
-0.4099518954753876,
-0.1422300487756729,
0.13927066326141357,
0.2355419248342514,
-0.25892335176467896,
0.008423195220530033,
-0.6433250308036804,
-0.8867529034614563,
0.4076642096042633,
0.22859396040439606,
0.1333848536014557,
-0.5354604721069336,
-0.3665149509906769,
-0.39016032218933105,
0.32899776101112366,
0.7082815766334534,
0.2727196216583252,
-0.49871134757995605,
-0.08676131814718246,
0.010227436199784279,
-0.3081149756908417,
-0.06244388595223427,
0.6145196557044983,
-0.8567574620246887,
0.42147138714790344,
0.3823385238647461,
1.0735971927642822,
0.3778263032436371,
-0.05763612687587738,
0.8699166774749756,
-0.4617117643356323,
0.42397233843803406,
0.5642764568328857,
0.22640495002269745,
0.32035449147224426,
-0.3899534046649933,
0.5799866914749146,
0.020934468135237694,
-0.7790743708610535,
-0.5662462711334229,
0.6233277916908264,
-0.9550389647483826,
-0.15806686878204346,
1.3343470096588135,
-0.24146050214767456,
-0.31438347697257996,
-0.3478805720806122,
-0.37079697847366333,
0.09805677831172943,
-0.35605165362358093,
0.5157663226127625,
0.26436492800712585,
0.00763134378939867,
-0.05402367189526558,
-0.5514039993286133,
0.6938053965568542,
0.22871042788028717,
-0.7782868146896362,
0.10169951617717743,
0.7980672717094421,
0.1299518495798111,
0.1401970386505127,
0.9804019331932068,
-0.20881767570972443,
0.14050480723381042,
-0.06724074482917786,
-0.24437731504440308,
-0.10020358115434647,
-0.3090496361255646,
-0.22309105098247528,
-0.2976800203323364,
0.298705130815506,
0.021313339471817017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04401v1 | Democratizing Large Language Models via Personalized Parameter-Efficient Fine-tuning | 2024-02-06T21:03:52 | 2024-02-06T21:03:52 | Zhaoxuan Tan, Qingkai Zeng, Yijun Tian, Zheyuan Liu, Bing Yin, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Personalization in large language models (LLMs) is increasingly important,
aiming to align LLM's interactions, content, and recommendations with
individual user preferences. Recent advances in LLM personalization have
spotlighted effective prompt design, by enriching user queries with
non-parametric knowledge through behavior history retrieval and textual
profiles. However, these approaches were limited due to a lack of model
ownership, resulting in constrained customization and privacy issues. Moreover,
they often failed to accurately capture user behavior patterns, especially in
cases where user data were complex and dynamic. To address these shortcomings,
we introduce One PEFT Per User (OPPU), which employs personalized
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) modules, to store user-specific behavior
patterns and preferences. By plugging in users' personal PEFT parameters, they
can own and use their LLMs personally. OPPU integrates parametric user
knowledge in the personal PEFT parameters with the non-parametric knowledge
acquired through retrieval and profile. This integration adapts individual LLMs
to user behavior shifts. Experimental results demonstrate that OPPU
significantly outperforms existing prompt-based methods across seven diverse
tasks in the LaMP benchmark. Further in-depth studies reveal OPPU's enhanced
capabilities in handling user behavior shifts, modeling users at different
active levels, maintaining robustness across various user history formats, and
displaying versatility with different PEFT methods. | [
-0.39864373207092285,
-0.9311233162879944,
0.764499843120575,
0.2280043065547943,
-0.02632421813905239,
0.03028677962720394,
-0.6303057074546814,
0.07206761091947556,
0.10223975777626038,
0.7055268287658691,
-0.40544694662094116,
-0.6982166171073914,
-0.038250140845775604,
0.05511150881648064,
-0.16067399084568024,
0.8396692276000977,
0.17269842326641083,
-0.295362651348114,
0.027470074594020844,
-0.010143171064555645,
-0.41967102885246277,
-0.5804209113121033,
-0.5742682814598083,
-0.2635456323623657,
0.9252810478210449,
0.6602385640144348,
0.6897938847541809,
0.5066276788711548,
0.21859760582447052,
0.27193111181259155,
-0.011470255441963673,
0.3386417031288147,
-0.6031696200370789,
0.33303380012512207,
-0.45594802498817444,
-0.2427869588136673,
-0.5039303302764893,
-0.2803274691104889,
0.5734915733337402,
0.847822368144989,
-0.3217083215713501,
0.12484811246395111,
0.16100536286830902,
0.5533882975578308,
-0.5163108706474304,
0.08885463327169418,
-0.571259081363678,
-0.2391190230846405,
-0.38232606649398804,
-0.3319889008998871,
-0.5773878693580627,
-0.3525885343551636,
0.05712219327688217,
-0.5917252898216248,
-0.019129952415823936,
0.25517508387565613,
0.5639393329620361,
-0.02366773597896099,
-0.44465094804763794,
0.12495827674865723,
-0.8661057353019714,
0.8083070516586304,
-0.7925980091094971,
0.3933929204940796,
0.4670528471469879,
0.38992825150489807,
-0.2725333273410797,
-0.5692545175552368,
-0.2928884029388428,
-0.2610780894756317,
-0.1612810641527176,
-0.35578471422195435,
-0.11349115520715714,
0.09405654668807983,
0.16606728732585907,
0.10571402311325073,
-0.4957391917705536,
0.4147707223892212,
-0.12810291349887848,
-0.2300683856010437,
0.6635008454322815,
0.4457164704799652,
0.1827612668275833,
0.05671237036585808,
-0.30321916937828064,
-0.046631213277578354,
-0.7307571768760681,
0.3699234426021576,
0.7412024140357971,
0.5145485401153564,
-0.016898509114980698,
0.46354418992996216,
-0.647350013256073,
0.870577335357666,
0.3800348937511444,
-0.22975733876228333,
0.2845476567745209,
-0.2067762017250061,
-0.07461287081241608,
-0.1679203063249588,
0.9927140474319458,
0.21326757967472076,
0.3311205804347992,
-0.31537115573883057,
-0.28642550110816956,
-0.8108568787574768,
-0.003913803957402706,
-0.8098700046539307,
-0.3635122776031494,
0.1213434487581253,
-0.4659932851791382,
-0.10182634741067886,
0.28906628489494324,
-0.7366824150085449,
-0.6889163851737976,
-0.5584582686424255,
0.2750580310821533,
-0.48802462220191956,
-0.16239170730113983,
0.2925431430339813,
0.24793343245983124,
0.004945399705320597,
0.5174810290336609,
-1.0692148208618164,
0.24068039655685425,
0.7977994680404663,
0.8012378811836243,
-0.4380165934562683,
-0.40731409192085266,
-0.7577099204063416,
0.2497851401567459,
-0.1560303270816803,
0.6393824219703674,
-0.9796754121780396,
-0.30713045597076416,
0.04094184190034866,
0.0036844955757260323,
0.050426747649908066,
-0.4997279644012451,
0.3235183656215668,
-0.5928763747215271,
0.2449840009212494,
-0.5039785504341125,
-0.4821305572986603,
0.02202424965798855,
0.010827125981450081,
-0.21021752059459686,
0.8013837337493896,
0.1352810561656952,
-0.5070868730545044,
0.20935793220996857,
-0.5661267042160034,
-0.3486812114715576,
0.15686972439289093,
-0.12960363924503326,
-0.2299603968858719,
0.3330952227115631,
0.24559049308300018,
0.689277708530426,
-0.13524894416332245,
0.5059795379638672,
-0.5806201100349426,
-0.4236851632595062,
0.14206139743328094,
-0.25062134861946106,
0.6397420167922974,
0.24809646606445312,
-0.0018837169045582414,
0.4572659134864807,
-0.7320466041564941,
-0.15542994439601898,
0.022416381165385246,
-0.5044131875038147,
-0.4925270974636078,
0.021054508164525032,
0.14543116092681885,
-0.005843366030603647,
0.7878033518791199,
-0.5780084133148193,
0.4876483976840973,
-0.5214326977729797,
0.38151854276657104,
1.0147790908813477,
0.0005047958693467081,
0.534856379032135,
-0.24237339198589325,
0.43296757340431213,
-0.18006546795368195,
0.17447954416275024,
-0.4338448643684387,
-0.2972666025161743,
-0.40536394715309143,
-0.2627871036529541,
-0.0726177915930748,
0.3471848666667938,
-0.14545641839504242,
0.6417294144630432,
-0.0022155202459543943,
-0.5207552313804626,
-0.049217093735933304,
0.48063498735427856,
0.14576725661754608,
0.6271371245384216,
0.20624135434627533,
-0.018672442063689232,
-0.2574322819709778,
-0.9595659375190735,
-0.5350645780563354,
-0.1797761172056198,
-0.3550487458705902,
0.7476207613945007,
-0.06612826883792877,
-0.2319774627685547,
1.0670403242111206,
-0.6850910186767578,
-0.2707667052745819,
-0.1692434549331665,
0.036583274602890015,
0.445319265127182,
0.35724392533302307,
0.4889284074306488,
-0.6138190031051636,
-0.6602862477302551,
0.23598560690879822,
-0.2470674067735672,
-0.5298997759819031,
-0.21879367530345917,
-0.2650461792945862,
-0.005541989579796791,
0.48915159702301025,
-0.28584980964660645,
-0.013225642964243889,
0.4503355920314789,
-0.7419112324714661,
0.3002658784389496,
-0.48456844687461853,
0.09829890727996826,
-0.9911491870880127,
0.12847094237804413,
-0.06684988737106323,
-0.3844590485095978,
-0.5040079355239868,
-0.11137881875038147,
0.1177554503083229,
-0.030722206458449364,
-0.29585158824920654,
0.7706809043884277,
-0.2663962244987488,
0.1623670756816864,
-0.2082902044057846,
-0.18158788979053497,
-0.2025567889213562,
0.5686366558074951,
-0.15220411121845245,
0.7450757622718811,
0.5391098260879517,
-0.555391788482666,
0.2271571159362793,
0.16770902276039124,
-0.12228984385728836,
0.4787841737270355,
-0.8163881301879883,
0.38174527883529663,
-0.041356202214956284,
-0.11974908411502838,
-1.150587558746338,
-0.4841635227203369,
0.1360723376274109,
0.06828270107507706,
0.12034700065851212,
-0.13908268511295319,
-0.7034159302711487,
0.2770976722240448,
-0.4630596339702606,
0.07948308438062668,
0.7045596241950989,
-0.6250903606414795,
0.718468964099884,
0.19642633199691772,
-0.25279927253723145,
-0.19632379710674286,
-0.18724830448627472,
0.14735469222068787,
-0.4218670129776001,
-0.6083229184150696,
0.5102798938751221,
-0.23085205256938934,
-0.22299222648143768,
-0.42831698060035706,
0.04861576482653618,
0.0016526987310498953,
0.1473854035139084,
0.2690815329551697,
-0.0990772470831871,
-0.11916430294513702,
0.27475035190582275,
0.288064569234848,
0.007533205207437277,
-0.21594828367233276,
-0.0515960268676281,
0.9049951434135437,
-0.11465736478567123,
-0.34619101881980896,
-0.5536507368087769,
0.326962411403656,
0.49427786469459534,
-0.42204952239990234,
0.7244051098823547,
0.6769819855690002,
-0.08523884415626526,
-0.3042830526828766,
-0.765234112739563,
-0.2454318255186081,
-0.5906065702438354,
0.19671981036663055,
-0.3829903304576874,
-1.1043777465820312,
0.5657946467399597,
-0.16950814425945282,
0.31678134202957153,
-0.02644510008394718,
0.7757874131202698,
-0.19039763510227203,
1.121909499168396,
0.7292941808700562,
-0.07076453417539597,
0.8296424746513367,
0.32905271649360657,
0.09434375911951065,
-0.6700245141983032,
-0.293373167514801,
-0.4110892415046692,
-0.5526018142700195,
-0.39123043417930603,
-0.010283189825713634,
0.38305798172950745,
0.07648684084415436,
-0.5935143232345581,
0.14668196439743042,
-0.3200319707393646,
0.45880448818206787,
0.5895470380783081,
0.3441469371318817,
0.5294542908668518,
0.13777458667755127,
0.20456306636333466,
-0.08424884080886841,
-0.31010696291923523,
-0.665780246257782,
0.9639854431152344,
0.23649919033050537,
1.2260738611221313,
0.18588514626026154,
0.834400475025177,
0.1821403056383133,
-0.09350566565990448,
-0.5937216877937317,
0.6761351823806763,
-0.329897403717041,
-0.23971880972385406,
-0.41860195994377136,
-0.3771476745605469,
-0.9016076922416687,
0.06360119581222534,
0.11381735652685165,
-1.0972343683242798,
0.322674959897995,
0.5053724646568298,
-0.573947548866272,
0.23169557750225067,
-0.7662634253501892,
0.7494047284126282,
-0.25808143615722656,
-0.456655353307724,
-0.1899319887161255,
-0.41936779022216797,
0.025056255981326103,
-0.28584006428718567,
-0.024729734286665916,
-0.24994629621505737,
-0.5334939360618591,
0.519555389881134,
-0.2884801924228668,
1.1407426595687866,
-0.34934288263320923,
-0.08784348517656326,
-0.15680380165576935,
0.24459944665431976,
0.6931891441345215,
0.26613786816596985,
-0.24231135845184326,
0.04654426872730255,
-0.0041059041395783424,
-0.21740631759166718,
-0.5124799013137817,
1.1575994491577148,
-0.7140840888023376,
-0.9266960024833679,
-0.0029620621353387833,
-0.5029857754707336,
-0.45590540766716003,
0.3149305582046509,
0.03851931169629097,
0.19623053073883057,
-0.12718935310840607,
0.5106443762779236,
0.7359180450439453,
-0.4955322742462158,
0.33455562591552734,
0.8423779010772705,
-0.38024166226387024,
-0.137137770652771,
0.7870861887931824,
-0.013066226616501808,
-0.026462677866220474,
0.5781426429748535,
0.7705011963844299,
-0.21940553188323975,
-0.6136908531188965,
-0.17687086760997772,
0.2549343407154083,
-0.39259588718414307,
-0.07366268336772919,
-0.7135422229766846,
0.506666362285614,
-0.29716581106185913,
-0.26717326045036316,
-0.23565031588077545,
-0.06737986207008362,
-0.5144500136375427,
0.13322730362415314,
0.5563645362854004,
0.4259914457798004,
0.3559914529323578,
0.5601770877838135,
-0.5039981007575989,
0.3239232003688812,
0.3301413953304291,
0.5297673940658569,
-0.2076389044523239,
-0.7075822353363037,
0.025359638035297394,
-0.27968207001686096,
-0.13520802557468414,
-0.9057715535163879,
0.28187957406044006,
0.42124661803245544,
0.5168404579162598,
0.608269989490509,
0.2199222594499588,
0.6705928444862366,
-0.5913054943084717,
0.749703049659729,
-0.03880368545651436,
-0.8984005451202393,
0.5369616150856018,
-0.5517022609710693,
0.3513772487640381,
0.6320922374725342,
0.23411494493484497,
-0.543006956577301,
-0.15756046772003174,
-0.1767549216747284,
-0.7822059392929077,
0.8228617310523987,
-0.2861497700214386,
0.598792314529419,
0.24380137026309967,
0.5503669381141663,
0.5012195706367493,
0.13838467001914978,
-0.27801060676574707,
-0.0989437997341156,
0.05810609459877014,
-0.24704250693321228,
-0.10644830018281937,
-0.25174325704574585,
0.07609862089157104,
-0.4013634920120239,
0.5100331902503967,
-0.32478833198547363,
-0.30102473497390747,
-0.045044902712106705,
0.17069745063781738,
-0.10353080183267593,
0.3559553623199463,
0.30010947585105896,
0.8404421806335449,
-0.18651169538497925,
0.0715457871556282,
0.14167048037052155,
-0.0934968888759613,
-0.018901122733950615,
0.031129805371165276,
-0.3284541368484497,
-0.11494883894920349,
0.008426107466220856,
0.6257421374320984,
0.293445885181427,
-0.8617935180664062,
0.422896146774292,
-0.043038804084062576,
0.127671018242836,
-0.24904239177703857,
0.45619723200798035,
0.2654581367969513,
0.24869580566883087,
0.14642393589019775,
-0.052226316183805466,
0.18949265778064728,
-0.4259573221206665,
-0.04594608396291733,
0.35270240902900696,
-0.06386805325746536,
-0.6220597624778748,
0.6710973978042603,
0.18295416235923767,
-0.5553374290466309,
0.36353006958961487,
0.09217885881662369,
0.10567523539066315,
0.052038129419088364,
0.3975074887275696,
0.7898672819137573,
-0.4195103943347931,
0.2507055401802063,
0.20949773490428925,
-0.10584356635808945,
-0.0968271940946579,
0.3162834346294403,
-0.2298239916563034,
-0.46720805764198303,
-0.2932942509651184,
-0.682610034942627,
-0.3314375877380371,
0.26074516773223877,
-0.4942665100097656,
0.5597274303436279,
-0.7992027401924133,
-0.09965316206216812,
-0.0051201581954956055,
-0.20083343982696533,
-0.6416979432106018,
-0.24919767677783966,
0.03902672976255417,
0.8327332735061646,
-0.6170079112052917,
0.8866147398948669,
0.9836941957473755,
-0.14272437989711761,
-0.6769611239433289,
-0.029362622648477554,
-0.14400245249271393,
-0.7464900612831116,
0.4635280668735504,
-0.16633617877960205,
-0.05757734552025795,
-0.09504402428865433,
-0.5033044815063477,
-0.6693328619003296,
0.9093527793884277,
0.885058581829071,
-1.0466779470443726,
-0.01787945069372654,
0.012206408195197582,
0.5617755055427551,
-0.24002662301063538,
-0.06648240983486176,
0.5885278582572937,
0.5234808325767517,
-0.19526371359825134,
-0.8872371315956116,
0.11668551713228226,
0.2046431303024292,
0.04455283284187317,
0.2259538620710373,
-0.8381786942481995,
0.8851847648620605,
-0.16725651919841766,
0.011017217300832272,
-0.0007925347308628261,
0.4489310383796692,
0.1801639348268509,
0.2519128620624542,
0.6120304465293884,
0.030761655420064926,
0.7891706228256226,
0.08534538000822067,
0.9618521332740784,
-0.4810080826282501,
0.2444888949394226,
1.1302040815353394,
-0.3113757073879242,
0.8032218217849731,
0.625527560710907,
-0.09176069498062134,
0.38078224658966064,
0.45075416564941406,
0.05706015229225159,
0.4675709009170532,
0.012882010079920292,
-0.20962835848331451,
-0.6387873291969299,
-0.048488862812519073,
-0.07509433478116989,
0.3288601040840149,
0.07744508236646652,
-0.5557891726493835,
-0.2218722254037857,
0.040221959352493286,
0.15398356318473816,
0.4311693012714386,
-0.16323363780975342,
0.8934049010276794,
-0.06571584939956665,
-0.6220651865005493,
0.3267248570919037,
0.2816722095012665,
0.876967191696167,
-0.83367919921875,
0.13408012688159943,
-0.3731292188167572,
0.20768004655838013,
-0.4163881242275238,
-0.7747650146484375,
0.09536226093769073,
0.05059681087732315,
-0.1168447807431221,
-0.6540479063987732,
0.7256590127944946,
-0.34975266456604004,
-0.32118716835975647,
0.04993171989917755,
0.5630202889442444,
0.016263535246253014,
-0.37145692110061646,
-0.4099012613296509,
0.10715442895889282,
0.13882069289684296,
-0.6466044187545776,
0.48492011427879333,
0.23697133362293243,
-0.11893802881240845,
0.6345403790473938,
0.6399445533752441,
0.17188796401023865,
-0.07920527458190918,
0.31718283891677856,
0.8487388491630554,
-0.6665401458740234,
-0.503530740737915,
-1.191274642944336,
0.2240835428237915,
0.09857740253210068,
-0.6429506540298462,
0.8895161151885986,
0.5286829471588135,
0.7809338569641113,
-0.2026549130678177,
0.6264044642448425,
0.06600859761238098,
0.4932124614715576,
-0.3725989758968353,
0.5930384993553162,
-0.6114014387130737,
0.5516952872276306,
-0.13562080264091492,
-0.8653120994567871,
-0.21807928383350372,
0.3283577561378479,
-0.4612521529197693,
0.07672879844903946,
0.0033863564021885395,
0.8538119792938232,
-0.33714941143989563,
-0.3000417947769165,
0.5103554725646973,
0.19852936267852783,
0.6894151568412781,
0.4047926366329193,
0.6406333446502686,
0.2801881730556488,
0.4237532317638397,
-0.4068039357662201,
-0.3051329255104065,
-0.3803767263889313,
-0.7349758148193359,
-1.0942375659942627,
-0.625816822052002,
-0.32102736830711365,
0.16346213221549988,
0.06386297941207886,
1.170635461807251,
0.8879761695861816,
-0.8832910656929016,
-0.277832567691803,
-0.048126306384801865,
-0.035707347095012665,
-0.038255199790000916,
-0.23941107094287872,
0.33309006690979004,
-0.3718074560165405,
-0.8884812593460083,
0.5037180185317993,
0.4197799861431122,
-0.23722262680530548,
-0.5252363085746765,
-0.12205400317907333,
0.32698094844818115,
0.04096546769142151,
0.5752454996109009,
0.2505775988101959,
-0.876042902469635,
-0.27496248483657837,
0.220023050904274,
0.03408090025186539,
0.08350266516208649,
0.9037368893623352,
-0.8080692291259766,
0.5438756346702576,
0.8494501709938049,
0.5645077228546143,
0.24294383823871613,
0.2731124460697174,
0.6916044354438782,
-0.9102568626403809,
-0.11782275885343552,
0.25251469016075134,
0.5143662691116333,
0.3366696834564209,
-0.6875045299530029,
0.052339840680360794,
-0.19407419860363007,
-0.5823133587837219,
-0.847357988357544,
0.30987873673439026,
-1.172033667564392,
-0.30475640296936035,
1.324734091758728,
-0.19080528616905212,
0.06613852083683014,
-0.07457941025495529,
-0.631136417388916,
-0.22621822357177734,
-0.9500300884246826,
0.7470151782035828,
0.5185146331787109,
-0.45170602202415466,
-0.19273968040943146,
-0.24279212951660156,
0.3371233642101288,
0.3068046271800995,
-0.699487030506134,
0.33396029472351074,
0.46266627311706543,
0.5376192927360535,
-0.16402089595794678,
0.49344825744628906,
0.03828476741909981,
-0.08372511714696884,
-0.6812114715576172,
-0.3343225121498108,
-0.5961466431617737,
-0.17249207198619843,
-0.47351476550102234,
0.5044803619384766,
0.2649913728237152,
0.1439410150051117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04396v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04396v2 | QuIP#: Even Better LLM Quantization with Hadamard Incoherence and Lattice Codebooks | 2024-02-06T20:52:12 | 2024-06-04T04:51:52 | Albert Tseng, Jerry Chee, Qingyao Sun, Volodymyr Kuleshov, Christopher De Sa | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Post-training quantization (PTQ) reduces the memory footprint of LLMs by
quantizing their weights to low-precision. In this work, we introduce QuIP#, a
weight-only PTQ method that achieves state-of-the-art results in extreme
compression regimes ($\le$ 4 bits per weight) using three novel techniques.
First, QuIP# improves QuIP's (Chee et al., 2023) incoherence processing by
using the randomized Hadamard transform, which is faster and has better
theoretical properties. Second, QuIP# uses vector quantization to take
advantage of the ball-shaped sub-Gaussian distribution that incoherent weights
possess: specifically, we introduce a set of hardware-efficient codebooks based
on the highly symmetric $E_8$ lattice, which achieves the optimal 8-dimension
unit ball packing. Third, QuIP# uses fine-tuning to improve fidelity to the
original model. Our experiments show that QuIP# outperforms existing PTQ
methods, enables new behaviors in PTQ scaling, and supports fast inference. Our
code can be found at https://github.com/Cornell-RelaxML/quip-sharp. | [
-0.14506562054157257,
-0.23681047558784485,
0.43761369585990906,
0.18880411982536316,
-0.413578063249588,
0.3320515751838684,
0.0720488429069519,
-0.06718353182077408,
0.10284403711557388,
0.0800609141588211,
-0.17671771347522736,
-0.50567626953125,
-0.35810109972953796,
-0.3046100437641144,
-0.3126619756221771,
0.5882407426834106,
0.2530754506587982,
0.48251792788505554,
-0.020355481654405594,
-0.16174152493476868,
0.09366265684366226,
-0.8658571839332581,
-0.4950324594974518,
-0.41166165471076965,
0.3031601905822754,
0.472368448972702,
1.1628837585449219,
0.6159999370574951,
0.6710035800933838,
0.14325067400932312,
-0.22847475111484528,
0.03945433348417282,
-0.5865312814712524,
-0.11486060172319412,
0.3261295557022095,
-0.6442893743515015,
-0.935652494430542,
-0.1529121994972229,
0.6304723620414734,
0.41800737380981445,
-0.30302295088768005,
0.19615738093852997,
-0.08637122064828873,
0.8356287479400635,
-0.7104911804199219,
-0.1447533667087555,
-0.5607380270957947,
0.5287925601005554,
-0.3439737856388092,
-0.42264601588249207,
-0.1856881082057953,
-0.45488348603248596,
-0.30553439259529114,
-0.7615796327590942,
0.29433292150497437,
0.32098716497421265,
0.7232092022895813,
0.22033976018428802,
-0.30408599972724915,
0.3084515929222107,
-0.5952449440956116,
0.8105902075767517,
-0.8359944820404053,
0.509278416633606,
0.29485705494880676,
0.2903066873550415,
-0.12782353162765503,
-0.7836609482765198,
-0.6822813749313354,
0.1977512687444687,
0.49147456884384155,
0.3196091651916504,
0.03179660066962242,
0.251878023147583,
0.6907504200935364,
0.8699547648429871,
-0.5507817268371582,
-0.04386837035417557,
-0.17389264702796936,
-0.0059316325932741165,
0.41730567812919617,
-0.176414355635643,
0.14363457262516022,
-0.003454703837633133,
-0.505031406879425,
-0.3830600082874298,
-1.057884693145752,
0.12698334455490112,
0.3861125707626343,
-0.45747825503349304,
-0.029049115255475044,
0.583557665348053,
-0.38846173882484436,
0.010856551118195057,
0.17803417146205902,
-0.1591881662607193,
0.3293984830379486,
0.09080717712640762,
-0.4748890697956085,
0.06583723425865173,
0.5436703562736511,
0.33433839678764343,
0.03282361105084419,
-0.15936246514320374,
-0.188172847032547,
0.030712371692061424,
-0.001286280108615756,
-0.770928144454956,
-0.818600058555603,
0.34956154227256775,
-0.5682076811790466,
-0.30497267842292786,
-0.19135546684265137,
-0.38910144567489624,
-0.6313601136207581,
-0.16581322252750397,
0.7595699429512024,
-0.5502097010612488,
-0.06826701760292053,
0.3209880590438843,
-0.27929267287254333,
0.513604462146759,
0.36944693326950073,
-0.808666467666626,
0.2927190661430359,
0.7607038021087646,
0.7077668309211731,
0.18104442954063416,
0.0896778330206871,
-0.9450346827507019,
0.0996483862400055,
-0.6112176775932312,
0.964475154876709,
-0.35173431038856506,
-0.2279767245054245,
-0.08959268778562546,
-0.6430588364601135,
0.377787321805954,
-0.8019611239433289,
0.6396308541297913,
-0.4694555699825287,
-0.3201271891593933,
-0.5297532081604004,
-0.374417781829834,
-0.05342434346675873,
0.2026551216840744,
-0.44820842146873474,
1.2347421646118164,
0.20081332325935364,
-0.537499725818634,
0.3545316457748413,
-0.02317769080400467,
-0.08956097066402435,
0.15683861076831818,
-0.1990860551595688,
-0.5528921484947205,
0.49256232380867004,
0.5537196397781372,
0.3783513903617859,
-0.47693413496017456,
-0.118063785135746,
-0.7000025510787964,
-0.6257849335670471,
0.5136252641677856,
-0.16458944976329803,
0.67246413230896,
0.29553765058517456,
-0.0394224151968956,
0.15745337307453156,
-0.6915581822395325,
0.466505765914917,
-0.062457531690597534,
-0.23749642074108124,
-0.06215253844857216,
-0.06300023943185806,
-0.4108072519302368,
0.06607101857662201,
0.1680298149585724,
-0.438467413187027,
0.47166430950164795,
-0.3792996108531952,
0.4331554174423218,
0.6019484996795654,
-0.19740597903728485,
0.5535885691642761,
-0.7954933047294617,
0.4903559684753418,
-0.2153264284133911,
0.558172881603241,
0.17037223279476166,
-0.3610295057296753,
-1.0548582077026367,
-0.4180619716644287,
0.2454330176115036,
0.5386682152748108,
-0.9169830679893494,
-0.010991751216351986,
-0.2315572053194046,
-0.3107433319091797,
-0.4433625042438507,
0.04958557337522507,
0.2818324565887451,
0.3329988420009613,
0.4935513734817505,
-0.20929965376853943,
-0.5050621628761292,
-0.7562311291694641,
-0.1052144393324852,
-0.33711907267570496,
-0.40798643231391907,
0.0047408766113221645,
-0.27046728134155273,
0.08342123031616211,
0.20585379004478455,
-0.24612654745578766,
0.08823755383491516,
0.037632156163454056,
0.16724881529808044,
0.16059187054634094,
0.593490481376648,
0.19650539755821228,
-0.5228254795074463,
-0.47297030687332153,
-0.15181545913219452,
-0.43430250883102417,
-0.24855008721351624,
-0.11469520628452301,
-0.5678878426551819,
0.09172025322914124,
0.42293664813041687,
-0.6391854286193848,
0.5664235353469849,
0.2745853364467621,
0.09587416797876358,
0.5863068699836731,
-0.10247474163770676,
0.35265207290649414,
-0.7233889698982239,
-0.4014674425125122,
-0.4562393128871918,
-0.3824317157268524,
-0.38798269629478455,
0.2700440287590027,
0.5628861784934998,
-0.0736079290509224,
-0.5518907904624939,
0.09661320596933365,
-0.4917117655277252,
-0.209919273853302,
-0.046273123472929,
-0.2882435917854309,
0.10774662345647812,
0.6031332612037659,
-0.06815525889396667,
0.691967248916626,
0.47951799631118774,
-0.5156764984130859,
0.36466798186302185,
0.11414464563131332,
-0.010712675750255585,
0.7117261290550232,
-0.7082222104072571,
0.28289172053337097,
-0.0488191656768322,
-0.0467892624437809,
-1.018653392791748,
0.23368267714977264,
0.27757346630096436,
-0.4868476688861847,
0.46247798204421997,
-0.3337976038455963,
-0.9274930357933044,
-0.24053695797920227,
-1.0006848573684692,
0.4097102880477905,
0.9193591475486755,
-0.6492606997489929,
0.27785128355026245,
0.2945939004421234,
0.20970478653907776,
-0.49729177355766296,
-0.7003034949302673,
-0.1021055281162262,
-0.19871939718723297,
-0.49080029129981995,
0.48342737555503845,
-0.48024624586105347,
-0.10168274492025375,
-0.3889339566230774,
-0.6262131333351135,
-0.16301444172859192,
-0.09177474677562714,
0.2202514261007309,
0.11653606593608856,
-0.15816833078861237,
0.3691505491733551,
0.28048041462898254,
-0.12438714504241943,
-0.16319212317466736,
-0.47710201144218445,
0.6085608601570129,
-0.3472261130809784,
-0.1696905791759491,
-0.32879671454429626,
0.24233925342559814,
0.06272470206022263,
0.0704340860247612,
0.32142066955566406,
0.7000760436058044,
-0.3148018419742584,
-0.40912434458732605,
-0.632080614566803,
-0.113153375685215,
-0.555077075958252,
0.08144677430391312,
-0.5833389759063721,
-0.9114065766334534,
0.2593693733215332,
-0.06872004270553589,
0.03484371677041054,
0.14447295665740967,
0.34010475873947144,
-0.36717236042022705,
0.9957494139671326,
0.6840200424194336,
0.1512746959924698,
0.27881619334220886,
-0.23506419360637665,
0.22722579538822174,
-0.9686264991760254,
0.03352709859609604,
-0.3784370720386505,
-0.5888317823410034,
-0.3159818947315216,
-0.7603169083595276,
0.46492016315460205,
0.5997076630592346,
-0.36361128091812134,
0.14696970582008362,
-0.48838746547698975,
0.5376588702201843,
0.6050403118133545,
0.3324030637741089,
0.36427587270736694,
0.2552974820137024,
-0.08464882522821426,
-0.21560359001159668,
-0.8878200054168701,
-0.2583737075328827,
1.2904775142669678,
0.22288069128990173,
0.8758825063705444,
0.21193373203277588,
0.7618458271026611,
0.17088422179222107,
0.3552212417125702,
-0.9472290277481079,
0.5296028852462769,
-0.05641693249344826,
-0.01096352282911539,
-0.04930414631962776,
-0.5394614338874817,
-0.5670724511146545,
0.38523441553115845,
-0.466142863035202,
-0.48725637793540955,
0.247877299785614,
0.43230605125427246,
-0.7714393138885498,
0.5030699372291565,
-0.5348455905914307,
0.3799595534801483,
-0.03869907930493355,
-0.05796957388520241,
-0.2287289798259735,
-0.25262758135795593,
0.45496752858161926,
0.13409753143787384,
-0.13387785851955414,
-0.24129585921764374,
-0.46889761090278625,
0.5165609121322632,
-0.6787772178649902,
0.34497207403182983,
0.1914413869380951,
-0.048412781208753586,
0.2922631502151489,
0.41264209151268005,
0.6280784606933594,
0.3585432469844818,
-0.15380746126174927,
0.2620090842247009,
0.4039812684059143,
-0.5645138621330261,
-0.6286884546279907,
0.5262722373008728,
-0.6960305571556091,
-0.444974422454834,
-0.35415875911712646,
-0.8150631785392761,
-0.2640438675880432,
-0.11060959845781326,
0.34174269437789917,
0.5635713338851929,
0.4171554446220398,
0.15674379467964172,
1.0488743782043457,
-0.3318784832954407,
0.4440612494945526,
0.45638778805732727,
-0.14249788224697113,
-0.5943943858146667,
0.849716067314148,
0.2978214919567108,
0.2450927346944809,
0.794955313205719,
0.3498786985874176,
-0.026414278894662857,
-0.8813936114311218,
-0.04634218290448189,
0.30362293124198914,
-0.5623103380203247,
-0.6574865579605103,
-0.5702276229858398,
-0.20003105700016022,
-0.8351444602012634,
-0.12000178545713425,
-0.3620074391365051,
-1.008400321006775,
-0.07889897376298904,
0.023674873635172844,
0.33173662424087524,
0.33293166756629944,
-0.25744864344596863,
0.6151267886161804,
-0.8519533276557922,
0.3833189010620117,
0.44441187381744385,
0.09994129091501236,
-0.16414561867713928,
-0.7925658226013184,
-0.23030036687850952,
-0.2815186381340027,
-0.3720831274986267,
-0.6775909662246704,
0.5769649744033813,
0.27150025963783264,
0.19347289204597473,
0.4230765700340271,
0.4936951994895935,
0.8280646800994873,
-0.4286268353462219,
0.38448214530944824,
0.11174477636814117,
-0.942992091178894,
0.04500628635287285,
-0.11375531554222107,
0.4225156009197235,
0.3636656403541565,
0.44675785303115845,
-0.6387625336647034,
-0.1098027229309082,
-0.7803493738174438,
-0.9033044576644897,
0.2946096658706665,
0.12405560910701752,
-0.08001627773046494,
0.13864265382289886,
0.6281510591506958,
-0.09136724472045898,
0.5060132145881653,
-0.6367219090461731,
-0.3031374216079712,
0.017512036487460136,
-0.21512869000434875,
0.36605173349380493,
-0.7754990458488464,
0.08346512168645859,
-0.10361117869615555,
0.7071844935417175,
-0.10502846539020538,
0.4175972044467926,
0.3584423065185547,
-0.1699715107679367,
-0.15460161864757538,
0.11345614492893219,
0.09343855082988739,
0.43602707982063293,
-0.34160634875297546,
0.5035239458084106,
0.14931422472000122,
-0.46757814288139343,
0.03556946665048599,
0.10416103899478912,
-0.24458730220794678,
-0.35995012521743774,
-0.07337251305580139,
0.23533783853054047,
0.23515133559703827,
-0.47787681221961975,
0.5204254984855652,
-0.19405372440814972,
-0.22915330529212952,
-0.40864524245262146,
0.2650856077671051,
-0.14422962069511414,
0.638929009437561,
0.3552567660808563,
0.02804662473499775,
0.48909667134284973,
-0.30480626225471497,
0.23952843248844147,
0.6069836020469666,
-0.11084556579589844,
-0.3762095868587494,
0.7479472160339355,
-0.023942185565829277,
-0.1593928039073944,
0.32820945978164673,
-0.5695410370826721,
-0.4289708733558655,
0.4433433413505554,
0.33591052889823914,
0.6557062268257141,
-0.0493621751666069,
0.24008384346961975,
0.32028430700302124,
0.34247106313705444,
-0.16688597202301025,
0.7757018804550171,
-0.6075541973114014,
-0.5723357796669006,
-0.4638444483280182,
-0.5239079594612122,
-0.6197338700294495,
-0.03730587288737297,
-0.5281116962432861,
0.21876181662082672,
-1.235152244567871,
0.032278236001729965,
-0.3396148979663849,
0.17537105083465576,
-0.5770635008811951,
-0.1309555321931839,
0.4339635968208313,
0.7954785227775574,
-0.23555457592010498,
1.1510761976242065,
0.528827428817749,
0.012823824770748615,
-0.9138341546058655,
-0.12022598832845688,
0.07968505471944809,
-0.9544015526771545,
0.25496354699134827,
0.0526762492954731,
0.15760838985443115,
0.29113465547561646,
-0.9195533990859985,
-1.0998647212982178,
1.093961238861084,
0.43603983521461487,
-0.7092403769493103,
0.3151800036430359,
0.06194604933261871,
0.1584165245294571,
0.19121460616588593,
0.3487118184566498,
0.5373482704162598,
0.04534345492720604,
0.3616322875022888,
-0.5616611242294312,
0.022255808115005493,
-0.28073301911354065,
0.0903189480304718,
0.38586652278900146,
-0.8324320912361145,
0.9952401518821716,
-0.04855057969689369,
-0.37554436922073364,
0.36995840072631836,
0.919067919254303,
0.37927085161209106,
0.0942382961511612,
0.24114952981472015,
0.8776769638061523,
1.100834608078003,
0.0233241505920887,
0.966644287109375,
-0.10415400564670563,
0.29399096965789795,
1.172630786895752,
-0.26265332102775574,
0.821811854839325,
0.4189058542251587,
-0.5559108257293701,
0.08580227941274643,
0.5651336312294006,
0.2712930142879486,
0.08018011599779129,
0.47859370708465576,
-0.45816558599472046,
-0.38486048579216003,
0.0638771653175354,
-0.45140454173088074,
-0.2840054929256439,
0.17077180743217468,
0.37786656618118286,
0.04518062248826027,
-0.19538281857967377,
0.23205602169036865,
-0.17307864129543304,
-0.5114178657531738,
0.23507285118103027,
0.2628561854362488,
-0.05813386291265488,
0.7620300054550171,
-0.09420791268348694,
0.9815906286239624,
-0.5892069339752197,
-0.016536761075258255,
-0.46242421865463257,
0.13118143379688263,
-0.2634411156177521,
-0.45348942279815674,
0.0583159476518631,
-0.3534141778945923,
-0.03317246586084366,
-0.22966444492340088,
0.5856801271438599,
-0.45640403032302856,
-0.3797999620437622,
-0.33875253796577454,
0.17450378835201263,
0.4176512360572815,
-0.5567492842674255,
-0.6646270751953125,
0.05155590549111366,
-0.15775135159492493,
-0.22955892980098724,
0.36013516783714294,
0.7881884574890137,
0.2142592966556549,
0.6659286022186279,
0.7147105932235718,
0.1714046597480774,
0.3358779549598694,
0.11040706187486649,
0.7610941529273987,
-0.6657142639160156,
-0.22229334712028503,
-0.4931808412075043,
0.22040003538131714,
0.09092490375041962,
-0.3134083151817322,
0.8715305328369141,
0.5021840333938599,
0.7252897024154663,
0.1989436149597168,
0.3693659007549286,
0.15655261278152466,
0.37035760283470154,
-0.7466223835945129,
0.3840729892253876,
-0.5173817873001099,
0.47323077917099,
-0.2137606143951416,
-0.7982712388038635,
-0.7543357610702515,
0.641400158405304,
-0.08674180507659912,
-0.30763259530067444,
0.8036770820617676,
0.7664361000061035,
0.2562706172466278,
-0.23185919225215912,
0.6708198189735413,
0.20835116505622864,
0.35037150979042053,
0.9359373450279236,
0.784217119216919,
-0.7854930758476257,
0.8560801148414612,
-0.6559856534004211,
-0.23208856582641602,
-0.14495839178562164,
-0.8833792209625244,
-0.7836645245552063,
-0.03466763719916344,
-0.5906692147254944,
-0.3960875868797302,
-0.060507774353027344,
0.9232145547866821,
0.8285471200942993,
-0.5631353855133057,
-0.16685166954994202,
0.019634757190942764,
0.20395933091640472,
-0.33449673652648926,
-0.18585866689682007,
0.4245350658893585,
-0.5089676380157471,
-0.6104657053947449,
0.29289668798446655,
0.5174332857131958,
0.37432554364204407,
0.13894593715667725,
-0.09886041283607483,
0.20089474320411682,
0.09144587814807892,
0.7139355540275574,
0.29958733916282654,
-0.1470426470041275,
-0.13862758874893188,
0.1656452715396881,
-0.0661228746175766,
0.37620922923088074,
0.9196435213088989,
-0.9402400851249695,
0.3492448925971985,
0.6679688096046448,
0.4590481221675873,
0.5671347975730896,
-0.0978451743721962,
0.45693835616111755,
-0.4059178829193115,
0.40816161036491394,
0.4344554543495178,
0.367818683385849,
0.20466527342796326,
-0.5349733829498291,
0.6913716197013855,
0.3709461987018585,
-0.6821725368499756,
-0.7829320430755615,
0.19003728032112122,
-1.1886405944824219,
-0.13171210885047913,
0.9345758557319641,
0.003958259243518114,
-0.5142349600791931,
0.21714848279953003,
-0.28159046173095703,
0.2669086456298828,
-0.576647162437439,
0.8033673167228699,
0.3056989312171936,
-0.26397502422332764,
-0.5664743781089783,
-0.5095579624176025,
0.6461652517318726,
0.7257903218269348,
-0.5942341089248657,
-0.2674762010574341,
0.42867934703826904,
-0.1170942559838295,
-0.37719640135765076,
0.7642929553985596,
-0.35936713218688965,
0.4738222062587738,
0.03373038396239281,
0.41760319471359253,
-0.08522599935531616,
-0.13511650264263153,
-0.39470288157463074,
0.02938603051006794,
0.2785331904888153,
-0.1087087094783783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05548v1 | Monitoring the evolution of antisemitic discourse on extremist social media using BERT | 2024-02-06T20:34:49 | 2024-02-06T20:34:49 | Raza Ul Mustafa, Nathalie Japkowicz | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SI | Racism and intolerance on social media contribute to a toxic online
environment which may spill offline to foster hatred, and eventually lead to
physical violence. That is the case with online antisemitism, the specific
category of hatred considered in this study. Tracking antisemitic themes and
their associated terminology over time in online discussions could help monitor
the sentiments of their participants and their evolution, and possibly offer
avenues for intervention that may prevent the escalation of hatred. Due to the
large volume and constant evolution of online traffic, monitoring conversations
manually is impractical. Instead, we propose an automated method that extracts
antisemitic themes and terminology from extremist social media over time and
captures their evolution. Since supervised learning would be too limited for
such a task, we created an unsupervised online machine learning approach that
uses large language models to assess the contextual similarity of posts. The
method clusters similar posts together, dividing, and creating additional
clusters over time when sub-themes emerge from existing ones or new themes
appear. The antisemitic terminology used within each theme is extracted from
the posts in each cluster. Our experiments show that our methodology
outperforms existing baselines and demonstrates the kind of themes and
sub-themes it discovers within antisemitic discourse along with their
associated terminology. We believe that our approach will be useful for
monitoring the evolution of all kinds of hatred beyond antisemitism on social
platforms. | [
-0.9813476800918579,
-1.0646964311599731,
0.19247084856033325,
-0.13832759857177734,
-0.5944985151290894,
0.23434413969516754,
-0.13358506560325623,
-0.44656509160995483,
0.8734406232833862,
0.2217685878276825,
-0.6950021386146545,
-0.41609546542167664,
-0.7408971190452576,
-0.2740930914878845,
-0.7768357992172241,
1.215875506401062,
0.04532454535365105,
-0.07806836813688278,
0.4264090657234192,
-0.21099139750003815,
0.09716907888650894,
-0.30204442143440247,
-0.5245335698127747,
-0.23920822143554688,
0.5382674336433411,
-0.2821525037288666,
0.4349035322666168,
0.452579140663147,
0.5723570585250854,
0.26916271448135376,
-0.18410968780517578,
-0.060807861387729645,
-0.35700055956840515,
0.35380446910858154,
-0.3751926124095917,
-0.007643155287951231,
-0.06408456712961197,
-0.19564175605773926,
0.392258882522583,
0.13600827753543854,
0.10793782770633698,
0.21617391705513,
0.018235979601740837,
0.395801305770874,
-0.36521100997924805,
-0.16082993149757385,
-0.9769025444984436,
0.013453344814479351,
-0.2401900291442871,
-0.2615518271923065,
0.051867786794900894,
-0.8279142379760742,
0.25749486684799194,
-0.17476363480091095,
0.32994344830513,
-0.21065008640289307,
0.8213343024253845,
0.19549383223056793,
-0.36037567257881165,
-0.8923149108886719,
-0.5046460628509521,
0.6180474758148193,
-0.44065454602241516,
0.4087395966053009,
0.24429966509342194,
0.310719758272171,
-0.05089282989501953,
-0.43656203150749207,
-0.6036319732666016,
-0.006469474174082279,
0.140282541513443,
0.12827832996845245,
-0.38704249262809753,
-0.3813416063785553,
0.031882498413324356,
-0.024580271914601326,
-0.4798339903354645,
0.008320201188325882,
-0.3222270905971527,
-0.02998240664601326,
0.4637432098388672,
-0.12189200520515442,
0.37950006127357483,
-0.252848356962204,
-0.4056171774864197,
0.0927097350358963,
-0.6197067499160767,
0.11309929937124252,
0.6662774085998535,
0.32053661346435547,
-0.12292782962322235,
0.05481370538473129,
0.3721868097782135,
0.43152353167533875,
0.000644241226837039,
0.20061291754245758,
0.32160475850105286,
0.004964437801390886,
0.036327797919511795,
0.07500213384628296,
0.5662694573402405,
0.46983811259269714,
0.13622832298278809,
0.06810666620731354,
-0.014896903187036514,
0.3115639388561249,
0.7513138055801392,
-0.6359643936157227,
-0.46599090099334717,
0.02001436986029148,
-0.542151927947998,
-0.24436020851135254,
0.08171280473470688,
-1.0682146549224854,
-0.7853107452392578,
-0.06541269272565842,
0.22418387234210968,
-0.4913577735424042,
-0.13241241872310638,
-0.7032319903373718,
-0.3245677947998047,
0.2783680856227875,
0.370392382144928,
-0.5462670922279358,
-0.04037405923008919,
0.6027988791465759,
0.8989209532737732,
-0.10289905965328217,
0.3484910726547241,
-0.2603769600391388,
-0.1716320961713791,
-0.3780864179134369,
0.7958052158355713,
-0.5900236368179321,
-0.29685407876968384,
0.44851478934288025,
0.07391189783811569,
0.4448930323123932,
-0.24715730547904968,
0.6105906367301941,
-1.0344688892364502,
-0.07747875154018402,
-0.21135012805461884,
-0.8262453079223633,
-0.3527669608592987,
0.24531275033950806,
-0.34989142417907715,
0.9493941068649292,
0.0731537938117981,
-0.9192516803741455,
0.29829734563827515,
-0.8516467809677124,
-0.26995912194252014,
0.23029844462871552,
-0.301062673330307,
-0.6738093495368958,
0.3234882950782776,
0.0925217941403389,
0.3475589454174042,
-0.017679976299405098,
0.18254882097244263,
-0.6726233959197998,
-0.20321129262447357,
0.3269672393798828,
0.2708623707294464,
1.0649536848068237,
0.252476304769516,
-0.6998895406723022,
0.23844142258167267,
-0.6130756139755249,
-0.20465680956840515,
0.27297279238700867,
0.08104065805673599,
-0.5706560015678406,
0.5478906035423279,
0.0437164381146431,
0.21871551871299744,
-0.046142298728227615,
-0.9008133411407471,
-0.18590568006038666,
-0.4563928544521332,
0.4888550937175751,
1.1793227195739746,
0.2663522958755493,
0.007229974027723074,
-0.5416741967201233,
0.2335035800933838,
-0.03904931619763374,
0.3481326699256897,
0.1156029999256134,
-0.4684028923511505,
-0.9004930257797241,
-0.08515015989542007,
-0.07917329668998718,
0.3256824314594269,
-0.7038593888282776,
0.8722054958343506,
-0.08886346966028214,
-0.7173842787742615,
-0.4066372215747833,
0.1038820818066597,
0.05750393867492676,
0.15665169060230255,
0.64325350522995,
-0.30612754821777344,
-0.7443805932998657,
-0.8595321178436279,
-0.26612576842308044,
-0.21211136877536774,
-0.009706072509288788,
0.1896379292011261,
0.5913724303245544,
-0.6383076906204224,
0.8950311541557312,
-0.2969897985458374,
-0.20472238957881927,
-0.10365582257509232,
0.6208618879318237,
-0.12296325713396072,
0.2022615671157837,
0.8833272457122803,
-0.8463217616081238,
-0.9734614491462708,
-0.026613973081111908,
-0.5921524167060852,
-0.29074904322624207,
-0.048132214695215225,
-0.28666990995407104,
0.08159427344799042,
0.46060627698898315,
0.2402956783771515,
0.2703695595264435,
0.3385361433029175,
-0.0647275373339653,
0.04573676362633705,
0.2789168059825897,
0.22461040318012238,
-1.1982574462890625,
-0.029051484540104866,
0.18600237369537354,
-0.09578347951173782,
-0.6728686690330505,
0.12257132679224014,
0.012066182680428028,
0.15167871117591858,
-0.5220257639884949,
0.27946937084198,
0.01905863732099533,
-0.01805245503783226,
-0.42058637738227844,
0.11181410402059555,
-0.6145885586738586,
0.26788169145584106,
-0.015444143675267696,
0.17777813971042633,
0.4064297080039978,
-0.25532594323158264,
0.690327525138855,
0.22857245802879333,
-0.523449718952179,
0.3728020489215851,
-0.06544408202171326,
0.28556492924690247,
-0.42589864134788513,
0.31480473279953003,
-1.0347522497177124,
-0.056151892989873886,
0.4124407470226288,
-0.6583598256111145,
0.029432551935315132,
-0.17998258769512177,
-0.42236366868019104,
-0.511437714099884,
-0.6073903441429138,
0.006533659063279629,
0.6720135807991028,
-0.45343583822250366,
0.5053755044937134,
0.572316586971283,
-0.38749998807907104,
-0.19492389261722565,
-0.3550882637500763,
-0.1269533932209015,
-0.5545832514762878,
-0.31908831000328064,
0.18397782742977142,
-0.10825946182012558,
-0.5367636680603027,
0.03627791255712509,
-0.07972502708435059,
-0.19902494549751282,
0.07360809296369553,
0.3791980743408203,
0.1417188048362732,
0.13404884934425354,
0.23896676301956177,
0.4534076750278473,
0.2519959509372711,
0.30713191628456116,
-0.20361649990081787,
0.6573165655136108,
0.1830074042081833,
-0.03961446136236191,
-0.4935855567455292,
0.5308199524879456,
0.3647027909755707,
0.191670760512352,
0.679925262928009,
0.5278673768043518,
-0.3987780213356018,
-0.3872636556625366,
-0.4473976790904999,
-0.3701527714729309,
-0.44342344999313354,
0.13001947104930878,
0.10802489519119263,
-0.9029706120491028,
0.5891020894050598,
0.000059058587794424966,
0.41163408756256104,
0.4518657922744751,
0.7621337175369263,
-0.5475158095359802,
0.719435453414917,
0.6855385303497314,
-0.010504495352506638,
0.8370136618614197,
0.19954295456409454,
0.15614788234233856,
-0.46610668301582336,
-0.0020234384573996067,
-0.5352473855018616,
-0.4654533267021179,
-0.6109142303466797,
-0.30572283267974854,
0.41780903935432434,
-0.2861267030239105,
-0.42021337151527405,
0.41424521803855896,
-0.43766120076179504,
0.23775054514408112,
0.29472190141677856,
0.11571064591407776,
-0.22766275703907013,
0.44740280508995056,
0.21645468473434448,
-0.34611308574676514,
-0.07019834965467453,
-0.24873892962932587,
1.0644938945770264,
0.4117759168148041,
0.5437481999397278,
0.17766296863555908,
0.6433276534080505,
1.039689064025879,
1.052028775215149,
-0.4149784743785858,
0.3182325065135956,
-0.09561657160520554,
-0.7488450407981873,
-0.012111982330679893,
-0.36848223209381104,
-0.7635087370872498,
0.04512573406100273,
-0.11667631566524506,
-0.9058093428611755,
-0.09426708519458771,
0.24290844798088074,
-0.3778516352176666,
0.5570893883705139,
0.0718877837061882,
0.4157473146915436,
-0.23717087507247925,
-0.030396362766623497,
-0.34741443395614624,
-1.1027977466583252,
0.08958585560321808,
-0.8043174743652344,
0.6038420796394348,
0.0036161316093057394,
0.1375724971294403,
1.0157063007354736,
-0.18264725804328918,
0.9690761566162109,
-0.08322416990995407,
-0.3390577435493469,
0.3844822645187378,
0.019736407324671745,
0.451555997133255,
-0.5582112073898315,
0.13038812577724457,
0.2862016558647156,
-0.28447505831718445,
-0.32894834876060486,
-0.26278480887413025,
0.8305597305297852,
-0.9823658466339111,
-0.24902117252349854,
-0.18694226443767548,
-0.21925033628940582,
-0.18788206577301025,
0.02151898480951786,
0.4198448956012726,
0.160181924700737,
-0.3377995193004608,
0.20730337500572205,
0.7089213728904724,
-0.38803330063819885,
0.3649708330631256,
0.4705829322338104,
-0.42176198959350586,
-0.48253774642944336,
1.0462794303894043,
0.2783835828304291,
0.06692049652338028,
0.30847999453544617,
0.2950585186481476,
-0.5867435336112976,
-0.32996654510498047,
-0.5537745356559753,
-0.054879773408174515,
-0.8545058965682983,
-0.10705538094043732,
-0.8550400137901306,
0.07094951719045639,
-0.4268687963485718,
-0.695615291595459,
-0.13768216967582703,
0.06158047169446945,
-0.060196638107299805,
0.24939773976802826,
0.43847861886024475,
0.7507940530776978,
-0.14944596588611603,
0.6231412887573242,
-0.7608636617660522,
0.14009450376033783,
0.19448605179786682,
0.08020942658185959,
-0.16276542842388153,
-0.8705311417579651,
-0.03277936577796936,
0.2416573315858841,
-0.4731743037700653,
-1.3645514249801636,
0.4263860285282135,
0.008952593430876732,
0.3558078408241272,
0.859624445438385,
0.2626110315322876,
0.43919268250465393,
-0.2733919620513916,
0.6438724398612976,
0.40796104073524475,
-1.060316562652588,
0.9289538264274597,
-0.6129056215286255,
-0.21955040097236633,
0.1382325440645218,
0.9409608840942383,
-0.4493696689605713,
-0.7742116451263428,
-0.6190842390060425,
-0.7066170573234558,
0.5281876921653748,
0.09940002113580704,
0.13003671169281006,
-0.2594538927078247,
-0.022511005401611328,
0.18676333129405975,
0.1394595205783844,
-0.7575299143791199,
-0.39356353878974915,
-0.4630078673362732,
-0.12546691298484802,
0.13107843697071075,
-0.0882204920053482,
-0.3059324324131012,
-0.13484717905521393,
0.8819548487663269,
-0.04585908353328705,
0.17818671464920044,
-0.29166001081466675,
-0.1958056390285492,
-0.38662153482437134,
0.20637430250644684,
0.2814299464225769,
0.5558969974517822,
-0.14995211362838745,
0.22564271092414856,
0.16142050921916962,
-0.2536490261554718,
0.08843407034873962,
0.07195378094911575,
-0.38596972823143005,
0.21455061435699463,
0.14611613750457764,
0.5549908876419067,
-0.14341771602630615,
-0.8233356475830078,
0.519663393497467,
0.2808026075363159,
-0.2525157928466797,
-0.5834793448448181,
-0.21575996279716492,
0.04473090544342995,
0.5611200928688049,
0.3588244616985321,
-0.18735894560813904,
-0.08848249167203903,
-0.7796787023544312,
0.5275489687919617,
0.4764527380466461,
-0.5611063241958618,
-0.3414976894855499,
0.4330112934112549,
0.07553964108228683,
-0.33695876598358154,
0.31044501066207886,
-0.43455708026885986,
-0.796669065952301,
0.5879382491111755,
0.5081511735916138,
0.7623242735862732,
-0.409734845161438,
0.30626991391181946,
0.2739597260951996,
0.2567475140094757,
0.6849408745765686,
0.13385610282421112,
-0.04108363017439842,
-0.7454437017440796,
-0.025652455165982246,
-1.0293666124343872,
-0.10825306177139282,
0.30250313878059387,
-0.6919996738433838,
0.009857228957116604,
-0.5446047186851501,
-0.2768218517303467,
0.34843501448631287,
-0.060711219906806946,
-0.2475460171699524,
0.11599521338939667,
0.4855526387691498,
0.5563867092132568,
-1.1547619104385376,
0.8405873775482178,
1.0395547151565552,
-0.08395618945360184,
0.10132627189159393,
0.1957537680864334,
0.3293151259422302,
-0.8682752251625061,
0.7059056758880615,
0.29471448063850403,
-0.18509484827518463,
0.014420530758798122,
-0.37857839465141296,
-0.6270809173583984,
0.2597988545894623,
-0.26661762595176697,
-0.5054947733879089,
0.30503252148628235,
0.08076058328151703,
0.699134886264801,
-0.15848729014396667,
-0.23723973333835602,
0.26896169781684875,
0.29454952478408813,
0.0013088173000141978,
-0.3934952914714813,
-0.04173848405480385,
-0.3121139705181122,
-0.1197502613067627,
0.8760688304901123,
-0.35848623514175415,
0.8216711282730103,
0.27480125427246094,
-0.4116729497909546,
-0.08313717693090439,
0.39112988114356995,
-0.4641400873661041,
0.0923437774181366,
0.662964940071106,
0.5138475894927979,
0.2654888927936554,
-0.07190084457397461,
0.15824931859970093,
-0.5187203288078308,
0.5216625928878784,
0.9002918004989624,
-0.16946159303188324,
0.5994978547096252,
0.2911154329776764,
-0.22322198748588562,
0.6573294401168823,
0.6263357400894165,
-0.28672656416893005,
0.5558047294616699,
0.5454201102256775,
-0.48855581879615784,
-0.17557232081890106,
-0.260427325963974,
-0.3738090693950653,
0.2754500210285187,
0.6059186458587646,
-0.7508071660995483,
-0.7523994445800781,
0.3237192928791046,
-0.02826816774904728,
0.1707511842250824,
-0.5404688119888306,
0.9570743441581726,
-0.23195327818393707,
-0.4418312907218933,
0.3088257312774658,
0.13243301212787628,
0.6813567280769348,
-0.6688508987426758,
0.19777005910873413,
0.10215255618095398,
0.45336270332336426,
0.05772200599312782,
-0.5562483668327332,
0.7004401087760925,
0.3132611811161041,
0.17334295809268951,
-0.2525402903556824,
0.6366443037986755,
-0.19816751778125763,
-0.2935141921043396,
0.6492412686347961,
0.6501424312591553,
0.294185608625412,
-0.007332054432481527,
-0.8896505832672119,
0.40391039848327637,
0.25293412804603577,
0.049551837146282196,
0.5174544453620911,
0.04437125846743584,
-0.21480247378349304,
0.42688775062561035,
0.6497547030448914,
-0.13089989125728607,
0.21317894756793976,
-0.16718338429927826,
1.178746223449707,
-0.5380134582519531,
-0.6438733339309692,
-1.1718976497650146,
-0.013985021971166134,
-0.23332588374614716,
-0.24390901625156403,
0.7199321389198303,
0.49817919731140137,
0.9105975031852722,
0.33645227551460266,
1.0093897581100464,
-0.40562930703163147,
0.9047259092330933,
0.15197709202766418,
0.9143016934394836,
-0.8379554152488708,
-0.3093683421611786,
-0.4196328818798065,
-0.8278422951698303,
-0.16829511523246765,
0.8375084400177002,
-0.3255237936973572,
-0.5382384657859802,
0.3036673665046692,
0.6719533801078796,
0.012566925957798958,
0.6126385927200317,
-0.025824125856161118,
0.2272917777299881,
0.37606874108314514,
0.18392106890678406,
0.8925639390945435,
0.1324165165424347,
0.3145517110824585,
-0.18378624320030212,
-0.5596997141838074,
-0.385694682598114,
-0.5306570529937744,
-1.0424151420593262,
-0.5874062776565552,
-0.2713572382926941,
-0.4431730806827545,
0.3680005371570587,
1.3490890264511108,
0.24333712458610535,
-0.9144726991653442,
-0.09574206918478012,
0.01571729965507984,
-0.16783517599105835,
-0.07571836560964584,
-0.18967482447624207,
0.4141942262649536,
-0.34842774271965027,
-0.6062111854553223,
-0.01637706533074379,
0.20263808965682983,
0.07568145543336868,
-0.31597864627838135,
0.46439287066459656,
-0.2571691572666168,
0.360001802444458,
0.7961488366127014,
0.27536335587501526,
-0.7399802803993225,
-0.3375445008277893,
-0.32740113139152527,
0.07339482754468918,
0.04284324496984482,
0.7829257249832153,
-0.39575129747390747,
0.6030547618865967,
0.34815260767936707,
0.8957746028900146,
0.3614846169948578,
0.02477947063744068,
-0.025388507172465324,
-0.6734402775764465,
-0.18736913800239563,
0.41395843029022217,
0.4134068191051483,
0.0517723448574543,
0.2997775971889496,
0.11782108247280121,
0.5233247876167297,
-0.3164569139480591,
-0.8330544829368591,
0.5383816361427307,
-0.5119472146034241,
-0.6616775989532471,
0.9048302173614502,
-0.35445642471313477,
0.1685974895954132,
-0.5143387913703918,
-0.027393968775868416,
0.5326237678527832,
-0.4868306815624237,
1.2452778816223145,
0.5445716977119446,
-0.1420329511165619,
0.08631216734647751,
-0.40335971117019653,
0.4696737825870514,
0.1856960654258728,
-0.9167027473449707,
-0.12641911208629608,
0.4245467782020569,
0.07755136489868164,
0.3698187470436096,
0.33738353848457336,
0.18996311724185944,
-0.04978785291314125,
-0.16812533140182495,
-0.0790245458483696,
0.46512284874916077,
-0.258453369140625,
0.04361160472035408,
0.49096837639808655,
-0.7145375609397888,
-0.12071415036916733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04373v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04373v1 | The World of Generative AI: Deepfakes and Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T20:18:32 | 2024-02-06T20:18:32 | Alakananda Mitra, Saraju P. Mohanty, Elias Kougianos | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | We live in the era of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI). Deepfakes
and Large Language Models (LLMs) are two examples of GenAI. Deepfakes, in
particular, pose an alarming threat to society as they are capable of spreading
misinformation and changing the truth. LLMs are powerful language models that
generate general-purpose language. However due to its generative aspect, it can
also be a risk for people if used with ill intentions. The ethical use of these
technologies is a big concern. This short article tries to find out the
interrelationship between them. | [
-0.26181939244270325,
-0.8259631395339966,
0.6378098726272583,
0.07406874746084213,
0.06008165329694748,
0.2700766324996948,
0.11440813541412354,
-0.5435882806777954,
-0.13267795741558075,
0.7303972840309143,
-0.4613066017627716,
-0.06652358919382095,
-0.6253547668457031,
-0.09697037935256958,
-0.7243096828460693,
0.8330264091491699,
0.13597847521305084,
0.06479322165250778,
-0.24821728467941284,
0.008755738846957684,
-0.10797016322612762,
-0.5986790657043457,
-0.9637982249259949,
-0.5564921498298645,
0.3652055561542511,
0.13991637527942657,
1.092881679534912,
0.20956352353096008,
0.4571708142757416,
0.4608784317970276,
0.016108155250549316,
-0.21028123795986176,
-0.47195789217948914,
0.43439581990242004,
-0.2328878939151764,
-0.5563486218452454,
-0.3195573091506958,
0.10614155232906342,
0.4874553680419922,
0.7068895101547241,
-0.0750039592385292,
-0.004199860151857138,
-0.18254882097244263,
0.6801547408103943,
-0.4398866891860962,
-0.26912176609039307,
-0.44718417525291443,
0.26456865668296814,
-0.21592772006988525,
-0.1524994820356369,
-0.24907717108726501,
-0.5306968688964844,
-0.11907528340816498,
-0.4579325020313263,
0.18005627393722534,
-0.1501673012971878,
0.7069734334945679,
0.4331630766391754,
-0.2816042900085449,
-0.5892783403396606,
-0.8902182579040527,
0.7806246876716614,
-0.8633739948272705,
0.18839576840400696,
0.36876219511032104,
0.1446947306394577,
-0.5112411975860596,
-0.7183457016944885,
-0.881689190864563,
-0.373215913772583,
0.031883880496025085,
-0.08715758472681046,
-0.2909044325351715,
0.2830314040184021,
0.3056691288948059,
0.7504521608352661,
-0.37653008103370667,
0.6050551533699036,
-0.26937729120254517,
0.016775336116552353,
0.8578404188156128,
0.3105526566505432,
0.7769848704338074,
-0.007735965307801962,
-0.2715483605861664,
0.048712294548749924,
-1.0263229608535767,
-0.4133954644203186,
0.5741182565689087,
-0.04639141261577606,
-0.3694840669631958,
0.6769025921821594,
-0.08378059417009354,
0.41254541277885437,
0.08145461976528168,
-0.14081671833992004,
0.29196879267692566,
-0.2326924204826355,
-0.5916528701782227,
-0.11980165541172028,
0.9823033809661865,
0.21405117213726044,
0.8437539935112,
-0.12535597383975983,
-0.002189148683100939,
0.022344956174492836,
0.08083444088697433,
-0.6654061079025269,
0.18227910995483398,
0.33195552229881287,
-0.5255204439163208,
-0.5102647542953491,
0.12689876556396484,
-0.7971634268760681,
-0.6412668824195862,
-0.2882015109062195,
0.25383681058883667,
-0.1976291537284851,
-0.43760108947753906,
0.07508469372987747,
0.13514003157615662,
0.6292318105697632,
0.26389080286026,
-0.9185875058174133,
0.03695887327194214,
1.030186414718628,
0.7077798247337341,
0.4143306314945221,
-0.2737514078617096,
-0.28040674328804016,
0.3328384459018707,
-0.5875877737998962,
0.29653632640838623,
-0.6450166702270508,
-0.7482934594154358,
0.12351080775260925,
-0.09603419154882431,
0.34128710627555847,
-0.47543540596961975,
0.16016785800457,
-0.6622790098190308,
0.15696457028388977,
-0.2206171154975891,
-0.6212326884269714,
-0.0592077374458313,
-0.1019287183880806,
-0.6712393164634705,
0.5995558500289917,
-0.014610067009925842,
-0.4840817451477051,
0.3064611256122589,
-0.8369649648666382,
-0.9117882251739502,
0.47264623641967773,
-0.3570246994495392,
-0.3586840033531189,
0.04163498058915138,
-0.17645269632339478,
0.8443644642829895,
-0.4772982895374298,
0.5584713816642761,
-0.3463280200958252,
-0.22472785413265228,
0.5588683485984802,
-0.8170938491821289,
1.0659282207489014,
0.5956488251686096,
-0.6125473976135254,
0.0034482963383197784,
-0.3687136471271515,
-0.3418923616409302,
0.13268110156059265,
-0.3341664671897888,
-0.39050641655921936,
-0.06832927465438843,
-0.1292782574892044,
0.24838052690029144,
0.016834186390042305,
-0.3961524963378906,
0.05125035345554352,
-0.37714582681655884,
0.7692416310310364,
0.8846074342727661,
0.07252077758312225,
0.4471588730812073,
-0.26276054978370667,
0.5219018459320068,
-0.000411719927797094,
0.3697866201400757,
-0.005600789561867714,
-0.5166207551956177,
-0.7644718885421753,
-0.15807077288627625,
0.17902648448944092,
0.4809054732322693,
-0.8623937964439392,
0.5179647207260132,
-0.04376045614480972,
-0.365615576505661,
-0.7617514729499817,
0.20175085961818695,
0.31171613931655884,
0.027863411232829094,
-0.09285587072372437,
0.09599872678518295,
-0.21627739071846008,
-0.9418371915817261,
-0.21746131777763367,
-0.11726725101470947,
-0.07767441868782043,
0.08544286340475082,
0.5387080907821655,
-0.5323546528816223,
0.47894129157066345,
-0.10547475516796112,
-0.10772544145584106,
-0.15418030321598053,
0.34411129355430603,
-0.047258391976356506,
0.7093098163604736,
0.7662488222122192,
-1.0918879508972168,
-0.2187998741865158,
-0.042310018092393875,
-1.1133418083190918,
0.2067459225654602,
-0.39592280983924866,
0.04986068233847618,
0.34915241599082947,
0.7791992425918579,
-1.0093764066696167,
0.4127548635005951,
0.5338947772979736,
-0.3441332280635834,
0.20903711020946503,
-0.05100245401263237,
0.3443008065223694,
-1.3763216733932495,
-0.03276199474930763,
-0.18105944991111755,
-0.002408041385933757,
-0.7277035117149353,
0.38340601325035095,
-0.5728194117546082,
-0.12072184681892395,
-0.6362846493721008,
0.47499388456344604,
-0.4251723289489746,
-0.26098179817199707,
-0.19576843082904816,
-0.24126777052879333,
-0.058714769780635834,
-0.2571884095668793,
-0.5051866769790649,
1.092263102531433,
0.7286655306816101,
-0.7138214111328125,
0.6520719528198242,
0.2034129649400711,
-0.522223174571991,
0.32692816853523254,
-0.582279622554779,
0.23807735741138458,
-0.10228999704122543,
0.11055826395750046,
-0.7172352075576782,
-0.49881625175476074,
0.3549083173274994,
-0.6665144562721252,
0.3294641077518463,
0.2620377540588379,
-0.821085512638092,
-0.2548438608646393,
-0.25835874676704407,
0.5205878019332886,
0.6600558161735535,
-0.4767477810382843,
0.5959917306900024,
0.6317161321640015,
-0.4002688229084015,
-0.5960186719894409,
-1.2048892974853516,
0.5040653944015503,
-0.20913515985012054,
-0.52711421251297,
0.06584414094686508,
-0.12827177345752716,
-0.8025618195533752,
0.1477496474981308,
0.4239239990711212,
0.06061466783285141,
0.48743295669555664,
0.589101254940033,
0.09733260422945023,
-0.27505987882614136,
0.13508856296539307,
0.19411025941371918,
-0.14784547686576843,
0.19701404869556427,
0.06915581226348877,
0.7267084717750549,
-0.23881971836090088,
-0.38866689801216125,
-0.5628383159637451,
0.7600187659263611,
0.8929994106292725,
-0.05712975934147835,
0.9178861379623413,
0.43130794167518616,
-0.4766155779361725,
0.09899532049894333,
-0.7043612003326416,
-0.01644427515566349,
-0.558935821056366,
0.24343928694725037,
-0.36385512351989746,
-1.2480747699737549,
0.2648243308067322,
-0.1254231184720993,
-0.0002072821807814762,
0.6100929379463196,
0.8877511620521545,
-0.2204711139202118,
0.9012702107429504,
0.7669441103935242,
-0.40171828866004944,
0.2792411148548126,
-0.27496352791786194,
0.3534814417362213,
-0.5780949592590332,
-0.3463183045387268,
-0.3846260607242584,
-0.1123536005616188,
-0.9306750893592834,
-0.2683649957180023,
0.030955845490098,
-0.0758896917104721,
-0.6090608239173889,
-0.15754051506519318,
-0.20442719757556915,
0.5611504316329956,
0.669217586517334,
-0.32807213068008423,
0.2636299431324005,
0.16401919722557068,
0.3065047264099121,
0.3668515980243683,
-0.5161105394363403,
-0.675430417060852,
0.9244116544723511,
0.47682684659957886,
1.0336576700210571,
0.2711392045021057,
0.5346711277961731,
0.6901845335960388,
0.3330126106739044,
-0.5995252728462219,
0.624713659286499,
-0.5006402134895325,
-0.8466277122497559,
-0.4158983528614044,
-0.38642746210098267,
-1.06107759475708,
-0.16840286552906036,
-0.21780429780483246,
-0.3986329436302185,
0.18641597032546997,
0.012423379346728325,
-0.421938419342041,
0.592313826084137,
-0.4867044687271118,
0.4108321964740753,
-0.4478389620780945,
-0.1269625872373581,
-0.48910534381866455,
-0.7216842770576477,
0.37953269481658936,
0.18572962284088135,
0.2663092315196991,
-0.22881469130516052,
0.12921281158924103,
0.5165172815322876,
-0.10397390276193619,
1.112524151802063,
0.17736870050430298,
-0.3481365144252777,
0.4368402659893036,
0.2859438359737396,
0.05817152559757233,
0.024432161822915077,
-0.12495843321084976,
0.3760634660720825,
-0.3963540196418762,
-0.3353351652622223,
-0.1794474571943283,
1.0014210939407349,
-1.1103907823562622,
-0.892626941204071,
-0.4993981420993805,
-0.5001342296600342,
-0.019897382706403732,
0.19443482160568237,
0.41846194863319397,
0.16350901126861572,
-0.46856361627578735,
0.12091998010873795,
0.929042398929596,
-0.5331290364265442,
0.5071874260902405,
0.2560279071331024,
-0.07959838211536407,
-0.1533609926700592,
0.7604230642318726,
-0.17209318280220032,
0.3803112804889679,
0.33834654092788696,
-0.01955769956111908,
0.05796695500612259,
-0.34297654032707214,
-0.3550820052623749,
0.30668944120407104,
-0.7329624891281128,
-0.07321909815073013,
-0.6054421067237854,
-0.5253978371620178,
-0.632638692855835,
-0.5011811256408691,
-0.13450048863887787,
0.054047390818595886,
-0.5792508721351624,
-0.3676097095012665,
0.4606575071811676,
1.0629327297210693,
-0.25724169611930847,
0.2320755273103714,
-0.575451135635376,
0.5206222534179688,
0.6360138654708862,
0.42043063044548035,
-0.004437766969203949,
-0.13451555371284485,
0.28738337755203247,
0.07393456250429153,
0.14175863564014435,
-0.6251980066299438,
-0.01222845446318388,
0.03261275216937065,
0.5199242234230042,
0.5231568813323975,
-0.2645844519138336,
0.12923577427864075,
-0.32241204380989075,
0.8891563415527344,
0.3660367429256439,
-0.9269887804985046,
0.3494506776332855,
-0.420784592628479,
0.16017210483551025,
0.42039233446121216,
0.6359209418296814,
-0.7304301857948303,
-0.32708126306533813,
-0.6116765737533569,
-0.8314641714096069,
0.23466379940509796,
0.04667549580335617,
0.7439500093460083,
0.04340618848800659,
0.46387869119644165,
0.4435086250305176,
0.3890083134174347,
-0.6922548413276672,
-0.14944390952587128,
-0.11797911673784256,
-0.2782081961631775,
-0.17369648814201355,
-0.5237953662872314,
-0.3257386088371277,
-0.21553833782672882,
0.5331048965454102,
0.09148845076560974,
0.31103944778442383,
-0.054721008986234665,
0.054160505533218384,
-0.38768044114112854,
0.3193873465061188,
0.6113077998161316,
0.4408554136753082,
0.504294753074646,
0.24308787286281586,
-0.07955165207386017,
-0.4717576205730438,
0.3436279296875,
-0.2020646035671234,
-0.3042978048324585,
-0.3655591309070587,
0.572167158126831,
0.8007124066352844,
-0.14757660031318665,
-0.5615608096122742,
0.4977969527244568,
0.2096412628889084,
-0.23511692881584167,
-0.6758995652198792,
0.08854499459266663,
0.2153039127588272,
0.3818519711494446,
0.18467341363430023,
-0.01984715275466442,
0.19169306755065918,
-0.9919424653053284,
0.07909879088401794,
0.5918503403663635,
-0.06553122401237488,
-0.2798263132572174,
0.5817007422447205,
0.5383845567703247,
-0.41316598653793335,
0.7489269375801086,
0.005565181374549866,
-0.37886202335357666,
0.6664736270904541,
0.2631451487541199,
1.1778995990753174,
-0.4438287913799286,
0.49567118287086487,
-0.1886153668165207,
0.3836219310760498,
0.12559282779693604,
0.21854466199874878,
0.11839902400970459,
-0.8828161358833313,
-0.47931841015815735,
-0.6343128085136414,
-0.25777068734169006,
0.7191020250320435,
-0.30846038460731506,
-0.21520955860614777,
-0.6941947340965271,
-0.15857072174549103,
0.14689306914806366,
-0.24967439472675323,
-0.6344609260559082,
0.2464568316936493,
0.35478416085243225,
0.5887088179588318,
-0.8110111951828003,
0.6273171305656433,
0.5340916514396667,
-0.5027596354484558,
-0.38507580757141113,
0.4435112476348877,
-0.07834524661302567,
-0.8817041516304016,
0.7476502656936646,
0.053894493728876114,
-0.2592942416667938,
-0.011776943691074848,
-0.8098862767219543,
-0.8221808075904846,
0.9301505088806152,
0.4034308195114136,
-0.5828647017478943,
-0.011062159202992916,
0.5199258327484131,
0.4960363209247589,
-0.349126935005188,
-0.36717066168785095,
0.6702181100845337,
0.5194705128669739,
-0.16812147200107574,
-0.4976317286491394,
0.2757580578327179,
-0.1287412792444229,
0.1913098692893982,
0.3221786916255951,
-0.7739251255989075,
0.9986763000488281,
-0.4292662739753723,
-0.3930668830871582,
0.3677420914173126,
0.5074157118797302,
0.037563055753707886,
0.2929381728172302,
0.2380141168832779,
0.5331434607505798,
0.3455510139465332,
0.07413987070322037,
1.2604306936264038,
-0.07836507260799408,
0.045361753553152084,
0.6979312300682068,
-0.3643113672733307,
0.4264845550060272,
0.3679739236831665,
-0.25807300209999084,
0.44235724210739136,
0.5143247246742249,
-0.2360750138759613,
0.23740284144878387,
0.24986688792705536,
-0.39943403005599976,
-0.2952914237976074,
0.003729859832674265,
-0.5294959545135498,
0.3392437994480133,
0.6074033379554749,
-0.4694824814796448,
0.10275339335203171,
0.15910789370536804,
0.4048152267932892,
0.052502211183309555,
-0.33546891808509827,
0.8151036500930786,
0.4340966045856476,
-0.45661064982414246,
0.10128844529390335,
-0.009583783335983753,
0.7390660047531128,
-0.310009241104126,
-0.06002824753522873,
-0.022584669291973114,
0.09571920335292816,
-0.14821621775627136,
-1.040466547012329,
0.236595019698143,
0.014096459373831749,
-0.18828421831130981,
-0.028880009427666664,
0.8585418462753296,
-0.20587056875228882,
-0.5344117283821106,
0.4428466856479645,
0.5189442038536072,
0.08863355219364166,
0.19435685873031616,
-0.890262246131897,
0.10938168317079544,
-0.2493210881948471,
-0.27110934257507324,
0.2765192687511444,
0.24195881187915802,
0.08240260183811188,
0.8565568327903748,
0.690471351146698,
0.0015326669672504067,
0.11688610911369324,
0.36133140325546265,
0.769819438457489,
-0.8029902577400208,
-0.22239629924297333,
-1.0107743740081787,
0.17819185554981232,
-0.013768475502729416,
-0.48591962456703186,
0.5700502395629883,
0.19628995656967163,
0.6576458811759949,
-0.10264886915683746,
1.0711615085601807,
-0.1347411870956421,
0.06780733168125153,
-0.7236774563789368,
1.0431104898452759,
-0.525367259979248,
0.04701002687215805,
-0.2334168255329132,
-0.6594814658164978,
-0.26370254158973694,
0.3304353654384613,
-0.29935863614082336,
0.40663889050483704,
0.21734140813350677,
0.5175204873085022,
0.3549624979496002,
0.07771584391593933,
0.5347853302955627,
0.559054434299469,
0.2445404827594757,
0.4327913522720337,
1.177740216255188,
-0.148154616355896,
0.04324032738804817,
-0.03695855662226677,
-0.18525700271129608,
-0.40814509987831116,
-0.668967604637146,
-0.8502467274665833,
-0.6324402093887329,
-0.20347487926483154,
-0.13965332508087158,
0.23863086104393005,
0.5386452674865723,
0.4990595579147339,
-0.8085501194000244,
-0.2563854455947876,
-0.31620314717292786,
0.06919043511152267,
0.17273783683776855,
-0.3180426359176636,
0.11105457693338394,
-0.06399466842412949,
-0.7465758323669434,
0.2676284611225128,
0.40579789876937866,
0.5570078492164612,
-0.8518474102020264,
-0.021401040256023407,
-0.378219872713089,
0.2946144640445709,
0.8406803011894226,
0.35118868947029114,
-0.950359046459198,
-0.3719264268875122,
-0.3346332609653473,
-0.2720811665058136,
-0.27615824341773987,
0.831509530544281,
-0.6193996071815491,
0.07399129122495651,
0.433960497379303,
0.7896242141723633,
0.04365125298500061,
-0.22472763061523438,
0.7449007630348206,
-0.34582316875457764,
0.2340293675661087,
0.37587788701057434,
0.18429046869277954,
0.6125448346138,
-0.7762465476989746,
0.5540367960929871,
0.1755860149860382,
-0.5622714161872864,
-0.8917163014411926,
0.7432430982589722,
-0.5801336169242859,
-0.5853694081306458,
1.2211154699325562,
0.1365985870361328,
-0.02671436034142971,
-0.1026015505194664,
0.08386971801519394,
0.3649160861968994,
-0.10923531651496887,
0.803351879119873,
0.4923636317253113,
-0.01674061082303524,
-0.0586576871573925,
-0.7307640910148621,
0.592789351940155,
0.27241623401641846,
-0.913068950176239,
-0.12435049563646317,
0.2610812187194824,
0.35573723912239075,
0.2485123723745346,
0.5460442900657654,
-0.11609968543052673,
0.2441757172346115,
0.20925505459308624,
0.13487508893013,
0.03837097808718681,
-0.3099190592765808,
-0.29144999384880066,
0.17806212604045868,
0.061831630766391754,
-0.010404977016150951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05140v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05140v2 | Tag-LLM: Repurposing General-Purpose LLMs for Specialized Domains | 2024-02-06T20:11:54 | 2024-05-30T17:37:06 | Junhong Shen, Neil Tenenholtz, James Brian Hall, David Alvarez-Melis, Nicolo Fusi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
understanding and generating natural language. However, their capabilities wane
in highly specialized domains underrepresented in the pretraining corpus, such
as physical and biomedical sciences. This work explores how to repurpose
general LLMs into effective task solvers for specialized domains. We introduce
a novel, model-agnostic framework for learning custom input tags, which are
parameterized as continuous vectors appended to the LLM's embedding layer, to
condition the LLM. We design two types of input tags: domain tags are used to
delimit specialized representations (e.g., chemical formulas) and provide
domain-relevant context; function tags are used to represent specific functions
(e.g., predicting molecular properties) and compress function-solving
instructions. We develop a three-stage protocol to learn these tags using
auxiliary data and domain knowledge. By explicitly disentangling task domains
from task functions, our method enables zero-shot generalization to unseen
problems through diverse combinations of the input tags. It also boosts LLM's
performance in various specialized domains, such as predicting protein or
chemical properties and modeling drug-target interactions, outperforming expert
models tailored to these tasks. | [
-0.1793815642595291,
-0.8007869124412537,
0.826367974281311,
-0.1141117736697197,
-0.331974595785141,
0.5597907900810242,
-0.25213465094566345,
-0.22094525396823883,
0.3412397503852844,
0.6015450358390808,
-0.4142674505710602,
-0.70920729637146,
-0.6832964420318604,
-0.0871315449476242,
0.038032274693250656,
0.9297215342521667,
-0.33706942200660706,
0.08055447787046432,
-0.5740815997123718,
0.05769478157162666,
-0.43860697746276855,
-0.6620578765869141,
-0.362655371427536,
-0.7396050691604614,
0.704526960849762,
0.08406197279691696,
0.06775575131177902,
0.7243373990058899,
0.6528415679931641,
0.2274264395236969,
0.27416160702705383,
0.470970094203949,
-0.39079442620277405,
0.13773564994335175,
-0.5534961223602295,
-0.3847912549972534,
-0.6567343473434448,
0.06670111417770386,
0.5769433379173279,
0.9083188772201538,
-0.24279426038265228,
0.12451273947954178,
-0.004242489114403725,
0.08942822366952896,
-0.4827868640422821,
0.3329295814037323,
-1.0151560306549072,
-0.18353018164634705,
-0.22798097133636475,
-0.3713374435901642,
-0.43092188239097595,
0.22714976966381073,
0.018576892092823982,
-0.6991743445396423,
0.39308828115463257,
-0.07273876667022705,
0.9289333820343018,
0.527655303478241,
-0.23814916610717773,
-0.20437288284301758,
-0.9171275496482849,
0.9406912922859192,
-0.518583357334137,
0.24405702948570251,
0.2596224844455719,
0.27536001801490784,
-0.5055887699127197,
-0.7705380916595459,
-0.35707730054855347,
-0.2158622443675995,
-0.013021009974181652,
-0.055828869342803955,
-0.30840134620666504,
0.2561066448688507,
-0.028377573937177658,
0.029910605400800705,
-0.6166806221008301,
0.2304166853427887,
-0.16851429641246796,
-0.05482294782996178,
0.4252566993236542,
0.19392873346805573,
0.33961713314056396,
0.24880464375019073,
-0.3715800344944,
0.39210382103919983,
-0.7422622442245483,
-0.24637778103351593,
0.011798355728387833,
0.4177068769931793,
0.23826837539672852,
0.4901256263256073,
0.030814260244369507,
0.9359810948371887,
-0.011930340901017189,
-0.27232807874679565,
0.2869729995727539,
-0.18677642941474915,
-0.33174368739128113,
-0.5011448860168457,
0.3549751937389374,
-0.08200187981128693,
0.21325275301933289,
-0.41496050357818604,
-0.2829742729663849,
0.22812998294830322,
0.6043664216995239,
-0.5087524056434631,
-0.3083023428916931,
0.2925635576248169,
0.00040001454181037843,
0.06917959451675415,
-0.4735446274280548,
-0.26812079548835754,
-0.15633156895637512,
-0.4342751204967499,
0.6474627256393433,
-0.36873099207878113,
0.09023642539978027,
0.2560684382915497,
-0.058689989149570465,
0.11390690505504608,
0.37517374753952026,
-0.7948652505874634,
0.36476707458496094,
0.7780516743659973,
0.5964290499687195,
-0.543549656867981,
-0.07346338778734207,
-0.5106027126312256,
0.5906468629837036,
0.07935269922018051,
0.7933474779129028,
-1.0512969493865967,
-0.5459455847740173,
-0.10087140649557114,
-0.0047465055249631405,
-0.23667025566101074,
-0.6237967014312744,
0.5341611504554749,
-0.6224324703216553,
-0.3496084213256836,
-0.04124869033694267,
-0.7306365966796875,
-0.0808722972869873,
0.2759028375148773,
-0.3856308162212372,
0.7252965569496155,
0.17064349353313446,
-0.38831260800361633,
0.17182855308055878,
-0.5722857117652893,
-0.4622509479522705,
0.4821053147315979,
-0.38614898920059204,
-0.2820661962032318,
0.15838980674743652,
0.02057703770697117,
0.7695493698120117,
-0.13005331158638,
0.4883984625339508,
-0.33068299293518066,
-0.15893039107322693,
0.2013476938009262,
0.11430378258228302,
0.039385002106428146,
0.06824798882007599,
0.18582819402217865,
0.028002727776765823,
-0.7698017358779907,
0.018208231776952744,
0.23034882545471191,
-0.5789206624031067,
-0.3883059620857239,
0.17317403852939606,
-0.20647428929805756,
-0.04443216323852539,
0.3334161043167114,
-0.7057206630706787,
0.47206270694732666,
-0.4127981662750244,
0.7186884880065918,
0.4198835790157318,
0.11694938689470291,
0.6178464889526367,
-0.36208584904670715,
0.5889967679977417,
0.003808440873399377,
-0.3521817922592163,
-0.14641904830932617,
-0.4395236372947693,
-0.6443906426429749,
-0.6201490163803101,
0.23433135449886322,
0.3896511197090149,
-0.9041423797607422,
0.333036869764328,
-0.22796602547168732,
-0.43509069085121155,
-0.3816068172454834,
0.19718198478221893,
0.42699357867240906,
0.7404694557189941,
0.7549927830696106,
-0.2789318561553955,
-0.4252680540084839,
-0.9430127143859863,
-0.2628358006477356,
0.11356864124536514,
-0.08099725097417831,
0.37831154465675354,
0.7205856442451477,
-0.6160457730293274,
1.0610004663467407,
-0.75116366147995,
-0.5052814483642578,
-0.4039216935634613,
0.1795320361852646,
0.1525389701128006,
0.6859261393547058,
0.30069831013679504,
-0.513654887676239,
-0.23571056127548218,
-0.061538342386484146,
-0.34653913974761963,
-0.15340563654899597,
-0.017207715660333633,
-0.011245988309383392,
0.023470958694815636,
0.22491857409477234,
-0.7729235291481018,
0.1925240457057953,
0.4016932547092438,
0.16321052610874176,
0.5457776784896851,
-0.4264581799507141,
-0.25703492760658264,
-0.9778257608413696,
0.05018282309174538,
0.241892471909523,
-0.28813567757606506,
-0.8307560086250305,
0.23530888557434082,
-0.026783809065818787,
-0.10779290646314621,
-0.42862430214881897,
0.7894657850265503,
-0.3618755340576172,
0.09851112961769104,
-0.5259599685668945,
-0.1185428649187088,
0.20603449642658234,
0.6402441263198853,
0.2619246542453766,
0.33226799964904785,
0.45488622784614563,
-0.5392734408378601,
0.13970057666301727,
0.03583136945962906,
0.04841327667236328,
0.29861316084861755,
-0.9220275282859802,
0.26047268509864807,
-0.18188436329364777,
0.30611419677734375,
-0.9611384272575378,
-0.41922980546951294,
0.4547836184501648,
-0.5203378796577454,
0.6089147925376892,
-0.3905200958251953,
-0.4600953161716461,
-0.20200864970684052,
0.06225951388478279,
0.4376695156097412,
0.6668346524238586,
-0.35346853733062744,
0.8923770785331726,
0.5272965431213379,
-0.09182116389274597,
-0.5176458954811096,
-0.6722901463508606,
-0.1416073590517044,
0.015692204236984253,
-0.25612032413482666,
0.956645667552948,
-0.17960724234580994,
0.16306383907794952,
0.24603721499443054,
-0.15376049280166626,
-0.3321032226085663,
0.19146618247032166,
0.21190577745437622,
0.16809791326522827,
0.10603487491607666,
0.3258552551269531,
0.21631544828414917,
-0.08848945796489716,
0.02711254358291626,
-0.5207967162132263,
0.6134253144264221,
0.1855558604001999,
-0.3873607814311981,
0.12324576079845428,
0.5107923150062561,
0.03571321815252304,
-0.63111811876297,
0.42613527178764343,
0.47228384017944336,
-0.6912084817886353,
-0.7825075387954712,
-0.1817556470632553,
0.10822178423404694,
-0.5153493285179138,
0.5863803029060364,
-0.44205838441848755,
-1.1404141187667847,
0.3214399218559265,
-0.3193202018737793,
0.0132841682061553,
0.22768190503120422,
0.7718445658683777,
-0.2979571521282196,
0.7111814618110657,
0.866696298122406,
0.1926528960466385,
0.10981397330760956,
-0.26194995641708374,
0.15331807732582092,
-0.8140649199485779,
-0.2934764325618744,
-0.24942521750926971,
-0.4275285601615906,
-0.049345649778842926,
-1.0878961086273193,
0.12924371659755707,
0.06260731816291809,
-0.09507724642753601,
0.32208681106567383,
-0.5645536184310913,
0.5326880216598511,
0.32045838236808777,
0.08042316138744354,
0.094196617603302,
0.08735688775777817,
-0.13742899894714355,
0.026825638487935066,
-0.5528748631477356,
-0.4322528541088104,
1.0301908254623413,
0.4739454984664917,
0.9470119476318359,
-0.21743233501911163,
1.1112357378005981,
0.1085357815027237,
0.5874444842338562,
-1.049217939376831,
0.5384957194328308,
-0.45888078212738037,
-0.3555446267127991,
0.11220131814479828,
-0.3197440803050995,
-1.0185275077819824,
0.24298273026943207,
-0.014498157426714897,
-0.8222874999046326,
0.08038251101970673,
0.3279508352279663,
-0.3726639151573181,
0.2605742812156677,
-0.45776402950286865,
0.4281090497970581,
-0.13744628429412842,
-0.20104242861270905,
-0.13881991803646088,
-0.30465084314346313,
0.20092569291591644,
-0.2920932471752167,
0.19581358134746552,
-0.44676774740219116,
-0.4053209722042084,
0.6053665280342102,
-0.14115113019943237,
0.993026614189148,
-0.18805046379566193,
-0.2308521866798401,
0.14228209853172302,
0.12904907763004303,
0.28882649540901184,
0.09323468059301376,
0.2836856245994568,
0.08030335605144501,
-0.21330676972866058,
-0.28127366304397583,
-0.6258203387260437,
0.8720942139625549,
-0.7132494449615479,
-0.9179332852363586,
-0.281533807516098,
-0.6771097779273987,
-0.5010141134262085,
0.14781567454338074,
0.04378747195005417,
0.45306873321533203,
-0.1682465523481369,
-0.1965453177690506,
0.8070574998855591,
-0.1037062406539917,
0.16403838992118835,
0.7600961327552795,
-0.00414285296574235,
-0.34824055433273315,
1.2137353420257568,
0.20992760360240936,
0.08481161296367645,
0.6004012227058411,
-0.1818210482597351,
-0.012333574704825878,
-0.8136793375015259,
-0.15562257170677185,
0.5514385104179382,
-0.916619062423706,
-0.37918123602867126,
-0.7713565230369568,
-0.08463370054960251,
-0.2151985913515091,
-0.34453707933425903,
-0.3439740240573883,
-0.18411199748516083,
-0.634131908416748,
-0.013232637196779251,
0.11478184908628464,
0.5739603638648987,
0.1549740731716156,
0.26303768157958984,
-0.9295519590377808,
0.4726540446281433,
0.11739237606525421,
0.4498840570449829,
-0.2978972792625427,
-0.6231169700622559,
-0.36793258786201477,
-0.03184005245566368,
-0.16171085834503174,
-0.6920062899589539,
0.7018964290618896,
0.5126579403877258,
0.9417759776115417,
-0.22128547728061676,
-0.20497442781925201,
0.2872413098812103,
-0.9781644344329834,
0.6274164319038391,
-0.051061324775218964,
-0.7825542688369751,
0.4664058983325958,
-0.3776189088821411,
0.2644922137260437,
0.18599502742290497,
0.8322542905807495,
-0.2004825919866562,
-0.28427934646606445,
-0.3834555745124817,
-0.8310967683792114,
0.33207085728645325,
-0.05975143983960152,
0.3141562044620514,
-0.05019139498472214,
0.7344955205917358,
0.19294589757919312,
0.17803479731082916,
-0.5600998997688293,
-0.33779555559158325,
0.10398834943771362,
-0.31688106060028076,
-0.165932297706604,
-0.1349773406982422,
-0.31103605031967163,
-0.4122826159000397,
0.43427494168281555,
-0.24622687697410583,
0.5118523240089417,
0.18313579261302948,
-0.43558308482170105,
0.0902266800403595,
0.25942546129226685,
0.5307253003120422,
0.6584373116493225,
-0.14905230700969696,
0.33222582936286926,
-0.08594059199094772,
-0.33998268842697144,
0.2984285354614258,
0.24184146523475647,
0.15805979073047638,
0.020790744572877884,
0.318369060754776,
0.4879729747772217,
0.16485260426998138,
-0.6201762557029724,
0.08243004977703094,
0.1642044633626938,
-0.333644300699234,
-0.09063556045293808,
0.24337074160575867,
0.3411146104335785,
0.1979614645242691,
0.37897443771362305,
0.08845009654760361,
0.08133893460035324,
-0.20460431277751923,
0.41616857051849365,
0.5288158059120178,
-0.10573789477348328,
-0.6853633522987366,
0.7382641434669495,
0.36812102794647217,
-0.32188549637794495,
-0.009193936362862587,
-0.33219388127326965,
-0.44500046968460083,
0.5281298756599426,
0.7882900834083557,
0.8518010377883911,
-0.240200012922287,
0.31431087851524353,
0.18904994428157806,
0.05921114981174469,
0.20821793377399445,
0.2490089237689972,
0.025164740160107613,
-0.948538601398468,
-0.5589583516120911,
-0.8569612503051758,
-0.3826948404312134,
0.18924649059772491,
-0.367260217666626,
0.03621978312730789,
-0.7033739686012268,
-0.3248487710952759,
0.29229840636253357,
-0.06757234036922455,
-0.9079256653785706,
0.25558939576148987,
0.3628970682621002,
0.6211111545562744,
-0.6633039116859436,
1.2868634462356567,
0.9633958339691162,
-0.3599010407924652,
-0.45156994462013245,
-0.1721135675907135,
-0.2978128492832184,
-0.9525814056396484,
1.0122718811035156,
-0.00830498244613409,
-0.17943288385868073,
0.23805686831474304,
-0.7496863603591919,
-1.0900288820266724,
0.8302462100982666,
0.4334351420402527,
-0.48155561089515686,
-0.18086904287338257,
0.38873156905174255,
0.6300438642501831,
-0.6655319929122925,
-0.20263352990150452,
0.5747389793395996,
0.14051146805286407,
0.01789090968668461,
-0.8477841019630432,
0.03615551441907883,
-0.28227290511131287,
0.11150605231523514,
0.12699948251247406,
-0.398896723985672,
0.9483965635299683,
-0.15529358386993408,
-0.20222775638103485,
-0.026599464938044548,
0.41243356466293335,
0.33745160698890686,
0.04425982013344765,
0.12214343994855881,
0.6998531222343445,
0.6957657337188721,
-0.04192454367876053,
0.8769256472587585,
-0.08989889919757843,
0.31966081261634827,
1.160710334777832,
-0.46420714259147644,
0.8323305249214172,
0.5241917371749878,
-0.023208077996969223,
0.48563629388809204,
0.41638073325157166,
-0.2873542904853821,
0.5536782741546631,
0.5914170742034912,
-0.2804392874240875,
-0.5109389424324036,
-0.2345113605260849,
-0.1576009839773178,
0.3837873041629791,
0.8591621518135071,
-0.3534288704395294,
-0.42093196511268616,
0.15690691769123077,
-0.1290530115365982,
0.055667951703071594,
-0.3643559515476227,
0.5328481197357178,
0.30064907670021057,
-0.3055221736431122,
0.608571469783783,
0.39564165472984314,
0.7772577404975891,
-0.722032904624939,
-0.26491257548332214,
0.008680426515638828,
0.17249605059623718,
-0.08608158677816391,
-0.6879266500473022,
0.3249306082725525,
-0.1499611884355545,
-0.351331889629364,
-0.3295530080795288,
1.132230281829834,
-0.6562439203262329,
-0.4025263786315918,
0.3229080140590668,
0.5523556470870972,
-0.10666964948177338,
0.09761331230401993,
-0.6603783965110779,
0.22348549962043762,
-0.31431370973587036,
-0.1299668550491333,
0.39774513244628906,
0.029744306579232216,
0.1369468867778778,
0.879404604434967,
0.37504979968070984,
-0.00961002241820097,
-0.17707976698875427,
-0.10660330206155777,
1.164386510848999,
-0.5745359063148499,
-0.14631785452365875,
-0.6798182129859924,
0.4905864894390106,
0.2882773280143738,
-0.018431061878800392,
0.541225016117096,
0.18193510174751282,
0.9153071045875549,
-0.40291762351989746,
0.9917958378791809,
0.26403218507766724,
0.4580017030239105,
-0.44162043929100037,
0.5796794891357422,
-0.5599842667579651,
0.24718546867370605,
0.08322613686323166,
-0.7740297317504883,
-0.5195441246032715,
0.25967466831207275,
-0.35843425989151,
0.09901478886604309,
0.32372942566871643,
0.5950790047645569,
0.04751879349350929,
-0.6076701879501343,
0.40355148911476135,
-0.10056953877210617,
0.6242271065711975,
0.8731212019920349,
0.7185325026512146,
0.12711329758167267,
0.2038360834121704,
0.0303072240203619,
-0.11285753548145294,
-0.16781997680664062,
-0.7852135300636292,
-0.994113564491272,
-0.4924367368221283,
-0.5580250024795532,
0.11827001720666885,
0.047788046300411224,
0.9756098389625549,
0.7525326013565063,
-0.623825192451477,
0.002681565936654806,
0.13692335784435272,
-0.022305140271782875,
0.1671791523694992,
-0.17227289080619812,
0.07368925213813782,
-0.5407991409301758,
-0.7912978529930115,
0.6661781668663025,
0.3995978832244873,
-0.001244855928234756,
-0.24966023862361908,
0.21971753239631653,
-0.1385691612958908,
0.3118430972099304,
0.5874559283256531,
0.3129996955394745,
-0.8546789884567261,
-0.42227616906166077,
0.06535184383392334,
-0.13431605696678162,
0.16478244960308075,
0.9105097055435181,
-0.8827576637268066,
0.3637962341308594,
0.3887506127357483,
1.0369495153427124,
0.3671926259994507,
-0.12147383391857147,
0.6806334257125854,
-1.2411487102508545,
-0.17089028656482697,
0.48785024881362915,
0.5229515433311462,
0.2398015409708023,
-0.28020673990249634,
0.2235109508037567,
0.4356176257133484,
-0.5050851702690125,
-0.818215548992157,
0.47183287143707275,
-1.2314093112945557,
-0.49835947155952454,
1.145512342453003,
-0.4703000485897064,
-0.2290657013654709,
-0.1391938030719757,
-0.011269263923168182,
0.15993474423885345,
-0.3456375002861023,
0.27504047751426697,
0.46310901641845703,
-0.3313086926937103,
-0.02785874530673027,
-0.3048725724220276,
0.4794897139072418,
0.2570393681526184,
-0.7450169920921326,
-0.10798019915819168,
0.23498742282390594,
0.5402346253395081,
0.12279380857944489,
0.621890664100647,
0.11773607134819031,
-0.11041243374347687,
-0.32646483182907104,
0.204582080245018,
-0.427374929189682,
-0.3682982325553894,
-0.35584592819213867,
0.20052990317344666,
0.013731032609939575,
-0.141531303524971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04347v1 | The Hedgehog & the Porcupine: Expressive Linear Attentions with Softmax Mimicry | 2024-02-06T19:31:26 | 2024-02-06T19:31:26 | Michael Zhang, Kush Bhatia, Hermann Kumbong, Christopher Ré | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Linear attentions have shown potential for improving Transformer efficiency,
reducing attention's quadratic complexity to linear in sequence length. This
holds exciting promise for (1) training linear Transformers from scratch, (2)
"finetuned-conversion" of task-specific Transformers into linear versions that
recover task performance, and (3) "pretrained-conversion" of Transformers such
as large language models into linear versions finetunable on downstream tasks.
However, linear attentions often underperform standard softmax attention in
quality. To close this performance gap, we find prior linear attentions lack
key properties of softmax attention tied to good performance: low-entropy (or
"spiky") weights and dot-product monotonicity. We further observe surprisingly
simple feature maps that retain these properties and match softmax performance,
but are inefficient to compute in linear attention. We thus propose Hedgehog, a
learnable linear attention that retains the spiky and monotonic properties of
softmax attention while maintaining linear complexity. Hedgehog uses simple
trainable MLPs to produce attention weights mimicking softmax attention.
Experiments show Hedgehog recovers over 99% of standard Transformer quality in
train-from-scratch and finetuned-conversion settings, outperforming prior
linear attentions up to 6 perplexity points on WikiText-103 with causal GPTs,
and up to 8.7 GLUE score points on finetuned bidirectional BERTs. Hedgehog also
enables pretrained-conversion. Converting a pretrained GPT-2 into a linear
attention variant achieves state-of-the-art 16.7 perplexity on WikiText-103 for
125M subquadratic decoder models. We finally turn a pretrained Llama-2 7B into
a viable linear attention Llama. With low-rank adaptation, Hedgehog-Llama2 7B
achieves 28.1 higher ROUGE-1 points over the base standard attention model,
where prior linear attentions lead to 16.5 point drops. | [
-0.4632281959056854,
-0.3730331361293793,
0.4560084939002991,
0.02705967240035534,
0.08301250636577606,
-0.08046955615282059,
-0.2960851788520813,
-0.5936706066131592,
0.375355988740921,
0.27052947878837585,
-0.7725650668144226,
-0.1928306519985199,
-0.6603079438209534,
-0.15824392437934875,
-0.21165354549884796,
1.2918832302093506,
-0.05369612202048302,
-0.3893170654773712,
0.3158857822418213,
-0.36815109848976135,
-0.21281327307224274,
-0.10106821358203888,
-0.5794183015823364,
-0.3524809777736664,
1.0347808599472046,
0.2489842027425766,
0.8200616240501404,
0.7546771168708801,
0.3976353406906128,
0.3945978283882141,
0.10177482664585114,
-0.016274340450763702,
-1.1381412744522095,
-0.10497310757637024,
-0.12578167021274567,
-0.29146531224250793,
-0.5616694092750549,
0.29540422558784485,
0.4596744477748871,
0.7484164834022522,
-0.01172732375562191,
0.38033851981163025,
0.20793020725250244,
0.5632349252700806,
-0.5436702966690063,
0.1673780381679535,
-0.8081339597702026,
0.2687825560569763,
-0.013171534053981304,
0.07472053170204163,
-0.2952635586261749,
-0.11538037657737732,
0.1216626837849617,
-1.134515404701233,
0.2459411919116974,
-0.1220414862036705,
0.9458112716674805,
0.6065055131912231,
-0.10066810250282288,
-0.10315943509340286,
-0.839417576789856,
0.9026345610618591,
-0.4693741798400879,
0.15202131867408752,
0.028579216450452805,
0.2297409176826477,
0.13969683647155762,
-1.0503575801849365,
-0.2092602699995041,
-0.27638891339302063,
-0.005149593111127615,
0.5296518206596375,
-0.490020751953125,
0.11541414260864258,
0.7871841192245483,
0.36751559376716614,
-0.3409460186958313,
-0.14681865274906158,
-0.3508184552192688,
-0.2776937484741211,
0.4706583023071289,
0.16161911189556122,
-0.06333527714014053,
0.26300039887428284,
-0.35323742032051086,
-0.12831658124923706,
-0.41659191250801086,
0.4342106282711029,
0.3206216096878052,
0.027764324098825455,
0.45782071352005005,
0.280610054731369,
0.002553316066041589,
0.23955459892749786,
0.6718347668647766,
-0.24142859876155853,
0.06720572710037231,
-0.17996861040592194,
-0.19351135194301605,
0.19209980964660645,
0.4612589478492737,
0.06811238825321198,
0.5301554799079895,
-0.4156247079372406,
-0.36238792538642883,
0.20037370920181274,
0.4269644618034363,
-0.6405894160270691,
-0.16355688869953156,
0.06208591163158417,
-0.624751627445221,
-0.15456902980804443,
0.07421191036701202,
-0.49305468797683716,
-0.11430738121271133,
-0.23445415496826172,
0.6185095906257629,
-0.37723585963249207,
-0.24761441349983215,
0.5033186078071594,
0.028026141226291656,
0.46821966767311096,
0.4020077884197235,
-1.1178559064865112,
0.5000778436660767,
0.7712141871452332,
0.6078292727470398,
-0.03223181888461113,
-0.38338199257850647,
-0.47026708722114563,
0.30072879791259766,
-0.2826851010322571,
0.7055575847625732,
-0.4212583303451538,
0.0005551581853069365,
-0.14027661085128784,
0.2899715006351471,
-0.21352800726890564,
-0.44490742683410645,
0.600735604763031,
-0.18180611729621887,
0.14469410479068756,
-0.39626345038414,
-0.06998399645090103,
-0.11794882267713547,
-0.06087823957204819,
-0.8427111506462097,
1.0009522438049316,
0.4728619456291199,
-0.9781413674354553,
0.2884317636489868,
-0.595842719078064,
-0.4280397593975067,
0.020042521879076958,
0.31797531247138977,
-0.3828328251838684,
0.1739359349012375,
0.016668448224663734,
0.05778218433260918,
0.12353222072124481,
-0.3175710141658783,
-0.5298712849617004,
-0.7290945053100586,
0.060693833976984024,
-0.2510620653629303,
0.4090381860733032,
-0.1898532509803772,
-0.5824253559112549,
0.1572262942790985,
-0.6432554721832275,
-0.032270148396492004,
0.36156153678894043,
-0.17429372668266296,
-0.09337475150823593,
-0.1646457016468048,
0.012052373960614204,
0.43898695707321167,
0.2864646315574646,
-0.4155920147895813,
0.1497306376695633,
-0.6228174567222595,
0.6780288815498352,
0.8379638195037842,
-0.39772292971611023,
0.6361270546913147,
-0.5732221603393555,
0.5405023097991943,
-0.10984760522842407,
0.3779102563858032,
-0.09313806891441345,
-0.2926367223262787,
-1.2629550695419312,
-0.034973978996276855,
0.0805848091840744,
0.4928693473339081,
-0.138115793466568,
0.180807426571846,
-0.21456030011177063,
-0.36769258975982666,
-0.7952901124954224,
0.23465794324874878,
0.3545975685119629,
0.5817587375640869,
0.27358007431030273,
-0.4095454812049866,
-0.3262471556663513,
-0.9382173418998718,
-0.14315156638622284,
0.17710329592227936,
-0.09317317605018616,
0.521124541759491,
0.14507673680782318,
-0.2263849675655365,
0.44672858715057373,
-0.18823279440402985,
-0.33107656240463257,
-0.15121446549892426,
-0.04139317572116852,
0.560899019241333,
0.3736417293548584,
0.44349512457847595,
-0.22864104807376862,
-0.3772760331630707,
0.041634563356637955,
-0.2675134241580963,
-0.0691387876868248,
-0.2051706314086914,
-0.15964019298553467,
-0.2185898721218109,
0.4739763140678406,
-1.0279208421707153,
0.4036354720592499,
0.09733198583126068,
-0.05727698281407356,
0.4722117483615875,
0.020314864814281464,
-0.3802015483379364,
-0.5383324027061462,
0.32714274525642395,
-0.21696950495243073,
-0.4240511953830719,
-0.5966289639472961,
-0.28552520275115967,
-0.10369773209095001,
-0.0970284640789032,
-0.3928356468677521,
0.21238288283348083,
-0.3869629204273224,
-0.33698251843452454,
-0.04676906764507294,
0.021221518516540527,
0.042346540838479996,
0.7766306400299072,
-0.1291079819202423,
0.6690272092819214,
0.27435949444770813,
-0.14684638381004333,
0.3283039927482605,
0.13481272757053375,
0.0016749429050832987,
0.3140721917152405,
-0.9216572642326355,
0.45861783623695374,
-0.26659825444221497,
-0.006547851022332907,
-1.1700292825698853,
-0.046073973178863525,
0.2612079679965973,
-0.2795472741127014,
0.5724912285804749,
0.22630402445793152,
-0.028320573270320892,
-0.5674058794975281,
-0.7466787099838257,
0.08002257347106934,
0.6439144611358643,
-0.24196170270442963,
0.5613577365875244,
0.058088649064302444,
-0.100716732442379,
-0.8902778029441833,
-0.513882577419281,
-0.0976029485464096,
-0.27432599663734436,
-0.5972986817359924,
0.2633201479911804,
0.005572083871811628,
-0.030968546867370605,
0.1122061237692833,
-0.4985271394252777,
0.43928518891334534,
0.10677695274353027,
0.20432360470294952,
0.04811488091945648,
-0.7619836926460266,
0.002272101351991296,
-0.27393388748168945,
-0.5844953656196594,
0.2072923630475998,
-0.5926413536071777,
0.3103773891925812,
-0.27360066771507263,
-0.10500472038984299,
-0.3254046142101288,
0.3828395903110504,
0.8196782469749451,
-0.14151623845100403,
0.021751297637820244,
1.08245849609375,
-0.2298211306333542,
-0.2839145362377167,
-0.5257113575935364,
-0.36980870366096497,
-0.5230820775032043,
0.4257534146308899,
-0.38870635628700256,
-0.7288109660148621,
0.5135977268218994,
-0.11310150474309921,
0.06906582415103912,
0.4583478271961212,
0.3960147202014923,
-0.1622183471918106,
1.3248181343078613,
0.8796966671943665,
-0.17744691669940948,
0.7361550331115723,
-0.33032187819480896,
0.20147381722927094,
-0.9383600950241089,
-0.0568377822637558,
-0.1823037564754486,
-0.8237253427505493,
-0.5394956469535828,
-0.014209862798452377,
0.18800315260887146,
-0.07757098227739334,
-0.432333379983902,
0.36105749011039734,
-0.7956158518791199,
0.38632550835609436,
0.5860430598258972,
0.17117375135421753,
0.076468326151371,
-0.047365497797727585,
0.02652130275964737,
-0.35035431385040283,
-0.748579740524292,
-0.4553270637989044,
1.025148868560791,
0.657048225402832,
0.9980041980743408,
-0.10541555285453796,
0.361731618642807,
0.005296476185321808,
0.4851115047931671,
-1.0543304681777954,
0.48811447620391846,
-0.1645284742116928,
-0.18446306884288788,
-0.3275861442089081,
0.008648793213069439,
-1.1279751062393188,
0.1267131119966507,
-0.08405930548906326,
-0.7188537120819092,
0.2118767648935318,
0.06807627528905869,
-0.5482013821601868,
-0.05236819013953209,
-0.6810160279273987,
1.063974380493164,
-0.13522329926490784,
-0.9147573709487915,
-0.17924116551876068,
-0.7558777332305908,
0.5479876399040222,
-0.023674357682466507,
-0.23632080852985382,
-0.3600460886955261,
-0.37345975637435913,
0.5785154104232788,
-0.2851620018482208,
0.5779318809509277,
-0.05500001087784767,
0.014948318712413311,
-0.20507198572158813,
0.06592392921447754,
0.6640182137489319,
0.31495729088783264,
0.3096649646759033,
-0.14738641679286957,
-0.24515357613563538,
-0.47139325737953186,
-0.6523871421813965,
0.5689184665679932,
-1.0274715423583984,
-0.9345362782478333,
-0.3958490490913391,
-0.8703367114067078,
-0.1714649498462677,
0.2879370450973511,
0.13744831085205078,
0.30626392364501953,
-0.004741822835057974,
0.0266556479036808,
1.0473449230194092,
0.18430818617343903,
0.5749235153198242,
0.3696294128894806,
0.16505856812000275,
-0.1695675551891327,
0.7053082585334778,
-0.02805650606751442,
0.1776672601699829,
0.13551288843154907,
0.0774533748626709,
-0.24075189232826233,
-0.47374242544174194,
-0.128431037068367,
0.5299568772315979,
-0.7149262428283691,
-0.16439750790596008,
-0.6994717121124268,
-0.5207539796829224,
-0.21325482428073883,
-0.2426871806383133,
-0.3617066442966461,
-0.36714303493499756,
-0.42768651247024536,
0.19323165714740753,
0.107010617852211,
0.9286566376686096,
-0.211528941988945,
0.1182749792933464,
-0.31324198842048645,
0.2096920609474182,
0.9450648427009583,
0.11154701560735703,
-0.029868124052882195,
-0.7410444021224976,
-0.07359762489795685,
-0.2278440147638321,
-0.3683076500892639,
-0.6820143461227417,
0.395841121673584,
0.3497588038444519,
0.6588260531425476,
0.6780668497085571,
-0.2871580719947815,
0.7396303415298462,
-0.6662956476211548,
0.2044866383075714,
0.1971922218799591,
-0.9061654210090637,
0.3422681987285614,
-0.46602800488471985,
0.3051952123641968,
0.423611581325531,
0.2821826934814453,
-0.4380611777305603,
-0.4503319561481476,
-0.7316193580627441,
-0.642938494682312,
0.9903329014778137,
0.05340159311890602,
0.2570134699344635,
0.49752500653266907,
0.33582091331481934,
0.17280039191246033,
0.11519836634397507,
-0.8129178285598755,
-0.018442939966917038,
-0.6921563148498535,
-0.21027235686779022,
-0.2634763717651367,
-0.17875222861766815,
-0.2178000509738922,
-0.4254516065120697,
0.30752769112586975,
-0.12348990887403488,
0.3841205835342407,
0.363974392414093,
-0.214346244931221,
-0.41389748454093933,
-0.03636246919631958,
0.6172854900360107,
0.6775036454200745,
-0.573083221912384,
0.2365560680627823,
0.3263561427593231,
-0.7989299297332764,
0.12197265028953552,
0.2090381532907486,
-0.08436816185712814,
0.17476578056812286,
0.35593467950820923,
0.8271715044975281,
0.585939884185791,
-0.33691078424453735,
0.5532611012458801,
-0.05550001934170723,
-0.14439111948013306,
-0.15725469589233398,
0.2317603975534439,
0.2017616331577301,
0.2390362173318863,
0.2514239251613617,
0.21511311829090118,
0.31770437955856323,
-0.3777824342250824,
0.25487998127937317,
0.45280471444129944,
-0.6255369782447815,
-0.5466827750205994,
0.8383159041404724,
0.03409427031874657,
-0.2704309821128845,
0.15672452747821808,
-0.07282985746860504,
-0.5039957761764526,
0.6442885994911194,
0.765541136264801,
0.7251747250556946,
-0.4857425391674042,
0.00003497589932521805,
0.37005260586738586,
0.5303747653961182,
0.14666415750980377,
-0.01499598752707243,
-0.3205377459526062,
-0.5021740198135376,
-0.3298293948173523,
-0.3806723654270172,
-0.28035178780555725,
0.383406400680542,
-0.7419694066047668,
0.2526162266731262,
-0.720179557800293,
-0.2791651487350464,
0.3079349398612976,
0.21874603629112244,
-0.6579770445823669,
-0.19107398390769958,
0.3398447036743164,
0.8680225610733032,
-0.6982945203781128,
0.8055747151374817,
0.5857629179954529,
-0.3488686978816986,
-0.8182789087295532,
-0.160873144865036,
-0.37433260679244995,
-1.0959160327911377,
0.4804842174053192,
0.4982692003250122,
-0.14422233402729034,
0.3767376244068146,
-0.41443151235580444,
-1.1161762475967407,
1.1308614015579224,
0.5595910549163818,
-0.7407841086387634,
-0.1487351953983307,
0.10702481865882874,
0.35494282841682434,
-0.28298792243003845,
0.5284963250160217,
0.806074321269989,
0.45986735820770264,
0.1126583069562912,
-0.9153020977973938,
0.16199801862239838,
-0.284009724855423,
0.009050527587532997,
0.19580255448818207,
-0.9965048432350159,
1.0312846899032593,
-0.324626624584198,
-0.4107323884963989,
-0.08849775046110153,
0.3809276521205902,
-0.01588338240981102,
0.1621241718530655,
0.5224609375,
0.665235698223114,
0.672969400882721,
-0.1705116331577301,
0.746110737323761,
-0.36047297716140747,
0.4230630695819855,
0.6697204113006592,
-0.3435482084751129,
0.5913448333740234,
0.559413492679596,
-0.29590079188346863,
0.43273040652275085,
0.5393065214157104,
0.10719386488199234,
0.6936336159706116,
0.21287000179290771,
-0.03297899290919304,
-0.36161646246910095,
-0.17380273342132568,
-0.4228948652744293,
0.3370227813720703,
0.4958805739879608,
-0.20495185256004333,
-0.25466668605804443,
-0.052337534725666046,
-0.009266831912100315,
-0.18884575366973877,
-0.555078387260437,
0.8227195739746094,
0.15539920330047607,
-0.6118814945220947,
0.7587165236473083,
-0.40393581986427307,
0.7047938704490662,
-0.7238094806671143,
0.09180821478366852,
-0.36343032121658325,
0.46982866525650024,
-0.07683253288269043,
-0.49878284335136414,
0.23291915655136108,
-0.49701666831970215,
-0.24386806786060333,
-0.2963160276412964,
1.1548455953598022,
-0.38837188482284546,
-0.2920182943344116,
0.3531089127063751,
0.14954018592834473,
0.0258801206946373,
0.06646331399679184,
-0.994912326335907,
-0.0026181696448475122,
-0.19737090170383453,
-0.4315555691719055,
0.08136365562677383,
0.4354986548423767,
0.2881583273410797,
0.495343953371048,
0.602165162563324,
0.12081720679998398,
0.2001042664051056,
0.03189728781580925,
1.1003247499465942,
-0.6063671112060547,
-0.35114312171936035,
-0.4900757670402527,
0.3011438548564911,
-0.1466185599565506,
-0.4015845060348511,
0.6026859283447266,
0.2770397663116455,
0.6044588088989258,
-0.19829967617988586,
0.5695685744285583,
0.40097254514694214,
0.3206401467323303,
-0.2893203794956207,
0.6167709231376648,
-0.38863644003868103,
-0.20631401240825653,
-0.022470906376838684,
-1.129162073135376,
0.07644575834274292,
0.8107439279556274,
-0.311024010181427,
0.0663800984621048,
0.9285516142845154,
0.6823530793190002,
-0.4790023863315582,
-0.38194671273231506,
0.48752468824386597,
0.3353210687637329,
-0.10457529127597809,
1.694826364517212,
1.1735892295837402,
-0.619929850101471,
0.8604591488838196,
-0.15978993475437164,
-0.1351034939289093,
-0.3404991328716278,
-0.5942102074623108,
-0.9034835696220398,
-0.18465034663677216,
-0.16357958316802979,
-0.4719083309173584,
0.032596003264188766,
0.47780969738960266,
0.8661426305770874,
-0.8173984289169312,
0.07708646357059479,
-0.001424077432602644,
0.002941967686638236,
-0.17348454892635345,
-0.18005479872226715,
0.3419816195964813,
-0.6013069748878479,
-0.7309649586677551,
-0.0735841616988182,
0.7615855932235718,
0.09698938578367233,
-0.5124221444129944,
-0.03183209151029587,
0.31099262833595276,
0.2323315143585205,
0.44338229298591614,
0.42164552211761475,
-0.8949379920959473,
-0.3760591447353363,
0.33424410223960876,
-0.49388471245765686,
0.39800819754600525,
0.8673561215400696,
-0.7262623906135559,
0.13896216452121735,
0.2224712073802948,
0.49129992723464966,
0.8704935312271118,
-0.07032499462366104,
0.22003735601902008,
-0.35934823751449585,
0.605303168296814,
0.583677351474762,
0.38366684317588806,
0.19285498559474945,
-0.3468265235424042,
0.31696662306785583,
0.4552769064903259,
-0.6171764135360718,
-0.64485764503479,
0.16992509365081787,
-1.2959634065628052,
0.1669979691505432,
1.1130465269088745,
-0.2705603241920471,
-0.6144171357154846,
-0.3517829179763794,
-0.462319940328598,
0.15096019208431244,
-0.40445464849472046,
0.7104569673538208,
0.5784207582473755,
0.179839625954628,
-0.25238877534866333,
-0.7394680976867676,
0.7686994671821594,
0.6723645925521851,
-0.5770825147628784,
-0.07338748872280121,
0.08778560161590576,
0.44196784496307373,
0.24649697542190552,
0.38200584053993225,
0.09646815061569214,
0.6533830761909485,
0.14966867864131927,
-0.11570267379283905,
-0.10020352154970169,
-0.09828244149684906,
-0.3190598487854004,
0.1849980354309082,
0.09432384371757507,
-0.19191399216651917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04335v1 | LegalLens: Leveraging LLMs for Legal Violation Identification in Unstructured Text | 2024-02-06T19:18:56 | 2024-02-06T19:18:56 | Dor Bernsohn, Gil Semo, Yaron Vazana, Gila Hayat, Ben Hagag, Joel Niklaus, Rohit Saha, Kyryl Truskovskyi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this study, we focus on two main tasks, the first for detecting legal
violations within unstructured textual data, and the second for associating
these violations with potentially affected individuals. We constructed two
datasets using Large Language Models (LLMs) which were subsequently validated
by domain expert annotators. Both tasks were designed specifically for the
context of class-action cases. The experimental design incorporated fine-tuning
models from the BERT family and open-source LLMs, and conducting few-shot
experiments using closed-source LLMs. Our results, with an F1-score of 62.69\%
(violation identification) and 81.02\% (associating victims), show that our
datasets and setups can be used for both tasks. Finally, we publicly release
the datasets and the code used for the experiments in order to advance further
research in the area of legal natural language processing (NLP). | [
0.2182687222957611,
-0.7907336950302124,
0.6694246530532837,
0.11899767816066742,
-0.45629289746284485,
-0.0625559464097023,
-0.2851063013076782,
-0.6060757040977478,
0.008297312073409557,
0.9026215672492981,
-0.20791280269622803,
-0.7067739963531494,
-0.5398362278938293,
0.1333126425743103,
-0.9101405739784241,
1.202365517616272,
-0.05901576951146126,
0.11275828629732132,
-0.3268309533596039,
-0.16538938879966736,
-0.5498741269111633,
-0.6222614645957947,
-0.36155053973197937,
-0.15553578734397888,
0.599987804889679,
0.3664679527282715,
0.10727749764919281,
0.6489407420158386,
0.666451096534729,
0.345180869102478,
-0.20666830241680145,
0.12032634019851685,
-0.5394355654716492,
0.05838588625192642,
-0.34551313519477844,
-0.41926854848861694,
-0.257589727640152,
-0.07703893631696701,
0.4401995837688446,
0.23154105246067047,
-0.09900113195180893,
0.2371007651090622,
0.03650553151965141,
0.47092530131340027,
-0.6887240409851074,
-0.06718674302101135,
-0.8002987504005432,
0.2567997872829437,
-0.5729466676712036,
-0.4095504581928253,
-0.4911227226257324,
-0.4415034055709839,
-0.19145534932613373,
-0.4683411121368408,
0.34587362408638,
0.11849244683980942,
0.7121986746788025,
0.4527747929096222,
-0.445945680141449,
-0.7488743662834167,
-0.53292316198349,
0.7386504411697388,
-0.8582688570022583,
0.09410462528467178,
0.37469398975372314,
0.06929928809404373,
-0.3882775902748108,
-0.698759138584137,
-0.6105332374572754,
-0.20336559414863586,
-0.3702991306781769,
0.004484030418097973,
-0.30205121636390686,
0.13499553501605988,
0.4133550226688385,
0.23989643156528473,
-0.602855920791626,
0.5781455636024475,
-0.4726455509662628,
-0.3930709660053253,
0.9619699120521545,
0.11557300388813019,
0.24347172677516937,
-0.21423493325710297,
-0.4397803544998169,
0.3648333251476288,
-0.6823824048042297,
0.08746558427810669,
0.6663027405738831,
0.6062005162239075,
-0.06284300982952118,
0.9727669358253479,
0.1086978018283844,
0.5719239115715027,
-0.12916894257068634,
-0.010089402087032795,
0.29692283272743225,
-0.1854707896709442,
-0.5049489736557007,
0.3134624660015106,
0.8324688673019409,
0.37409549951553345,
0.4438190758228302,
-0.21570482850074768,
-0.5742233991622925,
-0.26905739307403564,
0.14000459015369415,
-0.48613786697387695,
0.13019916415214539,
0.31862887740135193,
-0.6893138289451599,
-0.5573768019676208,
0.27387717366218567,
-0.8602662682533264,
-0.9846819043159485,
-0.7007032632827759,
0.24214668571949005,
-0.15025757253170013,
0.08503489196300507,
0.16051073372364044,
-0.23289917409420013,
0.2661207616329193,
0.09913397580385208,
-0.6395301818847656,
0.26668331027030945,
0.7979114651679993,
0.5322084426879883,
-0.16708189249038696,
-0.0803062692284584,
-0.7187797427177429,
0.2809509336948395,
-0.12881456315517426,
0.7303529381752014,
-0.5497198104858398,
-0.20740026235580444,
0.4245156943798065,
0.00739662442356348,
0.09773291647434235,
-0.6518204212188721,
1.0481038093566895,
-0.7628825306892395,
0.05724146589636803,
-0.288912832736969,
-0.8347475528717041,
-0.11817146837711334,
0.28329870104789734,
-0.5568943023681641,
0.9853391647338867,
-0.028690937906503677,
-0.8054336905479431,
0.6317353844642639,
-0.7170165181159973,
-0.655400276184082,
0.41244763135910034,
-0.4283014237880707,
-0.7451837658882141,
0.17494437098503113,
-0.18286272883415222,
0.49393409490585327,
0.05208577215671539,
0.29595640301704407,
-0.059873729944229126,
-0.3545757234096527,
0.4003662168979645,
-0.31362655758857727,
1.0123205184936523,
0.2688463628292084,
-0.2164851874113083,
0.36983728408813477,
-0.6997608542442322,
-0.32931676506996155,
0.37908515334129333,
-0.6885671615600586,
-0.620847761631012,
0.20674002170562744,
0.23261970281600952,
0.04144753888249397,
0.3804997503757477,
-0.8242642283439636,
-0.04933842644095421,
0.0046202754601836205,
0.05937806889414787,
0.8479396104812622,
0.06411727517843246,
0.1865009218454361,
-0.2788929343223572,
0.3482781648635864,
-0.16795186698436737,
0.15870894491672516,
0.21472911536693573,
-0.3825848400592804,
-0.5016345381736755,
-0.3227107524871826,
0.550914466381073,
0.6747888326644897,
-0.29741355776786804,
0.5699549913406372,
-0.27565130591392517,
-0.10978201776742935,
-0.27332767844200134,
0.3387533128261566,
0.4029974937438965,
0.39262130856513977,
0.3752148747444153,
0.15547935664653778,
-0.827068567276001,
-0.6756470799446106,
-0.6169368624687195,
-0.03200693428516388,
-0.2959349751472473,
0.44839996099472046,
0.6872656941413879,
-0.21714366972446442,
1.1510522365570068,
-0.1594206988811493,
-0.6857976913452148,
-0.14799454808235168,
0.23089510202407837,
0.12218265980482101,
0.23766303062438965,
0.7509809732437134,
-0.6951127648353577,
-0.41187894344329834,
-0.10740531235933304,
-0.8687341809272766,
-0.5662413239479065,
-0.18353398144245148,
0.13456305861473083,
0.20904141664505005,
0.8305048942565918,
-0.21167610585689545,
0.4593060612678528,
0.18951356410980225,
-0.841890275478363,
0.5294579267501831,
-0.24486415088176727,
0.043083272874355316,
-0.7611618638038635,
-0.12043710798025131,
0.07048723846673965,
-0.21835051476955414,
-0.8502782583236694,
0.06353076547384262,
0.05071744695305824,
0.31752899289131165,
-0.7927544116973877,
0.292412132024765,
-0.1442471146583557,
-0.1546291708946228,
-0.3443100154399872,
0.0815695971250534,
-0.40489575266838074,
0.28075671195983887,
-0.22514250874519348,
0.6429420113563538,
0.15192115306854248,
-0.641726016998291,
0.5422004461288452,
0.2002299278974533,
-0.41278076171875,
0.6396039128303528,
-0.6117924451828003,
0.01570761576294899,
-0.36073359847068787,
-0.17741020023822784,
-0.48219478130340576,
-0.4080347418785095,
0.37852931022644043,
-0.18390262126922607,
0.10651268064975739,
-0.27393022179603577,
-0.8501020669937134,
-0.3243861198425293,
-0.39683765172958374,
0.22215116024017334,
0.20227667689323425,
-0.5061765909194946,
0.8238895535469055,
0.5189216732978821,
0.054919786751270294,
-0.5229466557502747,
-0.8319613337516785,
0.2004113644361496,
-0.5322186350822449,
-0.16072063148021698,
0.36349430680274963,
0.14249080419540405,
-0.5993455648422241,
0.021625202149152756,
0.23023337125778198,
-0.18505539000034332,
0.21790653467178345,
0.4698573648929596,
0.07680954784154892,
0.05966400355100632,
0.28029003739356995,
0.2198951691389084,
0.19590620696544647,
0.2692413926124573,
0.21246805787086487,
0.46758079528808594,
0.0701213851571083,
-0.39829105138778687,
-0.4008209705352783,
0.4284111559391022,
0.4847376048564911,
-0.2128017395734787,
0.3492671251296997,
0.21598219871520996,
-0.5574614405632019,
-0.24293948709964752,
-0.4916277825832367,
0.1867413967847824,
-0.49734947085380554,
0.19652746617794037,
-0.15369388461112976,
-0.9626433253288269,
0.5349391102790833,
0.0026550411712378263,
0.2689933776855469,
0.4488492012023926,
0.6451916098594666,
-0.22338540852069855,
0.4960285425186157,
0.6843525171279907,
-0.41756340861320496,
0.5520368814468384,
0.12404520809650421,
0.12144027650356293,
-0.37345820665359497,
-0.4169209897518158,
-0.7738667726516724,
-0.23105193674564362,
-0.7930238842964172,
-0.21372438967227936,
0.13621072471141815,
-0.05835207551717758,
-0.20024439692497253,
0.401520699262619,
-0.24997763335704803,
0.8568463325500488,
0.6782240271568298,
0.09863492101430893,
0.41460901498794556,
0.1661026030778885,
-0.16053907573223114,
0.10739916563034058,
-0.33086857199668884,
-0.8243556022644043,
1.2179807424545288,
0.4180588126182556,
0.5419474840164185,
0.35145705938339233,
0.5705562233924866,
0.7613457441329956,
0.2806369364261627,
-0.9300321340560913,
0.7655628323554993,
-0.43136921525001526,
-0.6551623940467834,
-0.36369946599006653,
-0.36235129833221436,
-1.1058708429336548,
-0.04786575585603714,
-0.3283512592315674,
-0.6767946481704712,
0.19812029600143433,
-0.18604393303394318,
-0.3995266556739807,
0.2644656300544739,
-0.49082180857658386,
0.5959171056747437,
-0.45612674951553345,
-0.45616787672042847,
-0.1287575364112854,
-0.48216524720191956,
0.29856666922569275,
-0.44775789976119995,
0.43913203477859497,
-0.27481675148010254,
0.0854160264134407,
0.8325069546699524,
-0.622216522693634,
1.0720129013061523,
-0.2877689003944397,
-0.409785658121109,
0.4554957151412964,
-0.11683958023786545,
0.50565105676651,
-0.005998085718601942,
-0.015859391540288925,
0.05576612427830696,
-0.0028020390309393406,
-0.16064982116222382,
-0.2853659689426422,
0.5423058271408081,
-0.49487432837486267,
-0.3225858807563782,
-0.4049798846244812,
-0.6230721473693848,
-0.0029439544305205345,
0.5689806938171387,
0.04648926109075546,
0.11286789178848267,
-0.04786038398742676,
0.1437082141637802,
0.6288957595825195,
-0.13127490878105164,
0.6209402084350586,
1.1586490869522095,
-0.025719722732901573,
-0.024297190830111504,
0.7772753238677979,
-0.15476714074611664,
-0.42432695627212524,
0.263711154460907,
0.2573935389518738,
-0.36735817790031433,
-0.8099486827850342,
-0.12295934557914734,
0.29983842372894287,
-0.6158794164657593,
-0.42775940895080566,
-0.21437889337539673,
-0.07247526943683624,
-0.3571007549762726,
0.0584917776286602,
-0.04221324250102043,
-0.006384984590113163,
-0.4859931170940399,
-0.053382184356451035,
0.25819987058639526,
0.8743332624435425,
0.05151993781328201,
0.048607438802719116,
-0.8503681421279907,
0.27819332480430603,
0.3788818120956421,
0.6695571541786194,
-0.5135319828987122,
-0.7641253471374512,
0.009826702997088432,
-0.18872293829917908,
0.10231693089008331,
-0.8207764625549316,
0.13800953328609467,
0.013279248028993607,
0.584898054599762,
0.539871096611023,
0.16192147135734558,
0.3214654326438904,
-0.6533343195915222,
0.5434983372688293,
-0.14939327538013458,
-0.8616304993629456,
0.6043344140052795,
-0.3655286133289337,
-0.40660592913627625,
0.6487155556678772,
0.15674781799316406,
-0.40154024958610535,
-0.42251309752464294,
-0.24068482220172882,
-0.6118252873420715,
0.580757200717926,
0.2543349266052246,
0.3639416992664337,
0.22715476155281067,
0.6559128165245056,
-0.13565364480018616,
0.21077321469783783,
-0.8342544436454773,
-0.05948181450366974,
0.33929651975631714,
-0.4823894798755646,
0.2819441258907318,
-0.6161620616912842,
-0.4824005961418152,
-0.10094451904296875,
0.47140464186668396,
0.05430245399475098,
-0.0306007768958807,
-0.09765376150608063,
-0.2566489279270172,
-0.14815056324005127,
0.354586124420166,
0.8920518159866333,
0.43467551469802856,
-0.030594488605856895,
0.10343015193939209,
0.13916145265102386,
-0.5288419723510742,
0.08463726937770844,
0.15355181694030762,
-0.21628344058990479,
0.22123005986213684,
0.544437050819397,
0.4852149784564972,
-0.01861521601676941,
-0.9994986057281494,
0.8131483793258667,
-0.06206780672073364,
-0.508482038974762,
-0.5942782163619995,
-0.01923363097012043,
-0.556301474571228,
0.6166163086891174,
0.2502307891845703,
-0.3479123115539551,
0.3045596480369568,
-0.25221505761146545,
0.31069645285606384,
0.4420469105243683,
-0.27730923891067505,
0.01333714835345745,
0.6072878837585449,
0.11357830464839935,
-0.41715556383132935,
0.3908371031284332,
-0.29407334327697754,
-0.5312471985816956,
0.6241030693054199,
0.2982914447784424,
0.6579838395118713,
-0.05892790108919144,
-0.08222021907567978,
-0.09406125545501709,
0.3433419466018677,
-0.12339939177036285,
0.38864773511886597,
-0.012144438922405243,
-0.8621965646743774,
-0.38524842262268066,
-0.5725865960121155,
-0.29769009351730347,
0.3088991343975067,
-0.622702419757843,
0.4137694537639618,
-0.2502165138721466,
-0.021415220573544502,
-0.17673321068286896,
-0.07556669414043427,
-0.32945939898490906,
0.040836069732904434,
0.25381991267204285,
0.7869526743888855,
-1.009581446647644,
0.6230495572090149,
0.792391300201416,
-0.35100993514060974,
-0.4679996073246002,
-0.009512191638350487,
0.27967581152915955,
-0.5767487287521362,
0.6096124649047852,
-0.06872126460075378,
0.10880935192108154,
-0.19526682794094086,
-0.6832534670829773,
-0.3296578526496887,
1.0650619268417358,
0.23621904850006104,
-0.8341295719146729,
0.1480138748884201,
0.7166696190834045,
0.6807538866996765,
0.09201113134622574,
-0.3117559254169464,
0.9237116575241089,
0.4152657091617584,
0.021275736391544342,
-0.6799151301383972,
0.05718032643198967,
-0.1329525113105774,
-0.2492416352033615,
0.2414732575416565,
-0.3223015069961548,
0.5994778871536255,
0.01846686750650406,
-0.23219896852970123,
0.01173169631510973,
0.6300309896469116,
0.3643544614315033,
0.44881471991539,
0.5646905899047852,
0.7507643699645996,
1.0735594034194946,
-0.16377371549606323,
0.871618926525116,
-0.24949848651885986,
0.4757917821407318,
1.106895923614502,
-0.3177264928817749,
0.6397873759269714,
0.5191760659217834,
-0.11804263293743134,
0.36135566234588623,
0.4187488555908203,
-0.5051082968711853,
0.41956430673599243,
0.5357756614685059,
-0.4247646629810333,
-0.08700254559516907,
-0.4081193804740906,
0.07381260395050049,
0.5934938788414001,
0.3359321355819702,
-0.6750263571739197,
-0.17586925625801086,
0.09024590253829956,
0.1329861730337143,
0.3635031580924988,
-0.5347579717636108,
0.838079571723938,
-0.1788228452205658,
-0.22869545221328735,
-0.149428129196167,
0.463693767786026,
0.8076075315475464,
-0.28061774373054504,
0.002270558848977089,
-0.1836548000574112,
0.24391883611679077,
-0.39284324645996094,
-0.961681604385376,
0.24505136907100677,
0.6442947387695312,
-0.053542621433734894,
-0.3572942614555359,
0.909091591835022,
-0.4104669392108917,
-0.4734632968902588,
0.22959378361701965,
0.18085767328739166,
0.36321133375167847,
-0.04273853823542595,
-0.6098752021789551,
0.1935812383890152,
-0.19548141956329346,
-0.0647430419921875,
0.12673772871494293,
0.4424217939376831,
-0.24404467642307281,
0.30720704793930054,
0.6006375551223755,
0.11319661885499954,
0.22733719646930695,
0.4474869966506958,
0.8763357400894165,
-0.5573692321777344,
-0.25163254141807556,
-0.872380256652832,
0.4097534716129303,
-0.3154851794242859,
-0.2520056962966919,
0.7076326608657837,
0.8941864371299744,
0.7686870694160461,
0.08972453325986862,
0.7065516114234924,
-0.02041647583246231,
0.8664733171463013,
-0.8614904880523682,
0.5770177245140076,
-0.2945897877216339,
0.5924506187438965,
-0.10805156826972961,
-0.4751855432987213,
-0.6693167090415955,
0.3964451253414154,
-0.221664160490036,
-0.07674386352300644,
0.3836425840854645,
0.6468890309333801,
0.09796442091464996,
-0.1715404987335205,
0.26614290475845337,
0.04401644691824913,
0.5422056317329407,
0.29870930314064026,
0.721019446849823,
-0.2923435568809509,
0.504565954208374,
-0.06857242435216904,
-0.022789618000388145,
-0.5118927359580994,
-0.8985034823417664,
-1.1511460542678833,
-0.022203661501407623,
-0.28722038865089417,
-0.2543193995952606,
-0.01674581505358219,
0.8195784687995911,
0.11687427014112473,
-1.1320420503616333,
-0.1721280813217163,
-0.25363025069236755,
0.11046192049980164,
0.1636396199464798,
-0.25039222836494446,
0.2833757996559143,
-0.5287884473800659,
-0.7697331309318542,
0.4281725585460663,
0.08421190083026886,
0.2731238603591919,
0.03448059782385826,
0.055062636733055115,
-0.11780092865228653,
0.16676931083202362,
0.6746646165847778,
0.30238309502601624,
-0.5842180252075195,
-0.3399852514266968,
-0.2856656312942505,
-0.2952415645122528,
-0.2416398823261261,
1.2729475498199463,
-0.4529761075973511,
0.16013209521770477,
0.4812324345111847,
0.6805140376091003,
0.026085689663887024,
0.2983575761318207,
0.21736901998519897,
-0.9969482421875,
0.015002799220383167,
0.33611831068992615,
0.565636396408081,
-0.015005609951913357,
-0.28216540813446045,
0.4375787079334259,
0.255886971950531,
-0.5770905613899231,
-0.8619659543037415,
-0.05241168662905693,
-0.7376521229743958,
-0.4438249170780182,
1.3056890964508057,
-0.009304791688919067,
-0.023046746850013733,
-0.40094253420829773,
-0.07812909036874771,
0.25374940037727356,
-0.22657759487628937,
0.8753629922866821,
0.5726948380470276,
0.0791553482413292,
0.11017955094575882,
-0.6731246113777161,
0.574273407459259,
0.1882256418466568,
-1.0258033275604248,
0.13176487386226654,
0.704600989818573,
0.3505047559738159,
-0.049970194697380066,
0.340092271566391,
-0.261375367641449,
0.1613043248653412,
-0.4772071838378906,
0.06631249934434891,
-0.10040639340877533,
-0.1494825780391693,
-0.7056101560592651,
0.17602211236953735,
-0.18327359855175018,
-0.23577187955379486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04333v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04333v3 | LESS: Selecting Influential Data for Targeted Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-06T19:18:04 | 2024-06-13T03:42:02 | Mengzhou Xia, Sadhika Malladi, Suchin Gururangan, Sanjeev Arora, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction tuning has unlocked powerful capabilities in large language
models (LLMs), effectively using combined datasets to develop generalpurpose
chatbots. However, real-world applications often require a specialized suite of
skills (e.g., reasoning). The challenge lies in identifying the most relevant
data from these extensive datasets to effectively develop specific
capabilities, a setting we frame as targeted instruction tuning. We propose
LESS, an optimizer-aware and practically efficient algorithm to effectively
estimate data influences and perform Low-rank gradiEnt Similarity Search for
instruction data selection. Crucially, LESS adapts existing influence
formulations to work with the Adam optimizer and variable-length instruction
data. LESS first constructs a highly reusable and transferable gradient
datastore with low-dimensional gradient features and then selects examples
based on their similarity to few-shot examples embodying a specific capability.
Experiments show that training on a LESS-selected 5% of the data can often
outperform training on the full dataset across diverse downstream tasks.
Furthermore, the selected data is highly transferable: smaller models can be
leveraged to select useful data for larger models and models from different
families. Our qualitative analysis shows that our method goes beyond surface
form cues to identify data that exemplifies the necessary reasoning skills for
the intended downstream application. | [
-0.36073967814445496,
-0.6602043509483337,
0.42779743671417236,
-0.22469468414783478,
0.0862174853682518,
-0.10389076918363571,
-0.37663641571998596,
-0.26695516705513,
0.28572791814804077,
0.45848390460014343,
-0.9131231307983398,
-0.660427451133728,
-0.6731238961219788,
-0.332766056060791,
-0.30788877606391907,
0.7378504276275635,
0.18402864038944244,
0.03275998681783676,
-0.39017269015312195,
-0.07261341065168381,
-0.37907928228378296,
-0.11882277578115463,
-0.742656409740448,
-0.42102399468421936,
0.4869004189968109,
0.7048813104629517,
0.269526869058609,
0.8228991627693176,
0.42566823959350586,
0.2246728092432022,
-0.12932434678077698,
0.22750312089920044,
-1.0694493055343628,
-0.05886705964803696,
-0.03328127786517143,
-0.6884124875068665,
-0.37258458137512207,
-0.00004880209235125221,
0.3030933141708374,
0.7099340558052063,
0.009544389322400093,
0.48978427052497864,
0.12220580875873566,
0.9279951453208923,
-0.8639686703681946,
0.12556524574756622,
-1.0075448751449585,
0.17409925162792206,
-0.09186265617609024,
-0.23960191011428833,
-0.5254296064376831,
-0.30024123191833496,
-0.07930078357458115,
-0.6741782426834106,
0.29167643189430237,
-0.008660180494189262,
0.5450732707977295,
0.6779925227165222,
-0.14063794910907745,
-0.027921760454773903,
-0.6395999193191528,
1.1753844022750854,
-0.5721025466918945,
0.6136296987533569,
0.5376770496368408,
0.11262106895446777,
-0.062099967151880264,
-0.4149559438228607,
-0.1961379051208496,
-0.34431716799736023,
0.014189626090228558,
0.05294402316212654,
-0.10617092251777649,
0.14777523279190063,
0.4543818235397339,
-0.014087331481277943,
-0.2985110580921173,
0.2116287797689438,
-0.6060823798179626,
-0.1908460110425949,
0.4679770767688751,
0.2485792338848114,
-0.084157295525074,
0.11422810703516006,
-0.14307136833667755,
-0.26865991950035095,
-0.9788303971290588,
0.26155662536621094,
0.40934380888938904,
0.4906143248081207,
-0.2499186098575592,
0.4847666621208191,
-0.38694649934768677,
0.6753457188606262,
0.19062332808971405,
-0.1397254317998886,
0.02692289650440216,
-0.17202216386795044,
-0.1513778418302536,
0.17249594628810883,
0.38792911171913147,
0.30799341201782227,
0.17143544554710388,
0.07416711002588272,
-0.09108060598373413,
-0.12931573390960693,
0.3637436032295227,
-0.9954079389572144,
-0.34709644317626953,
-0.20068278908729553,
-0.5054681301116943,
-0.059525858610868454,
-0.04940207302570343,
-0.8432225584983826,
-0.53892982006073,
-0.7483243942260742,
-0.02295982837677002,
-0.3743126392364502,
0.41536393761634827,
-0.24252822995185852,
-0.12738296389579773,
0.5450636744499207,
0.3275945484638214,
-0.995229959487915,
0.27153366804122925,
0.9430580735206604,
0.7774627804756165,
-0.20752455294132233,
0.07128021866083145,
-0.7159836888313293,
0.013970457948744297,
-0.4677961766719818,
0.5553202033042908,
-1.3935375213623047,
-0.2583015561103821,
-0.23079121112823486,
-0.09783622622489929,
-0.28333747386932373,
-0.5046485662460327,
0.5073394775390625,
-0.574059247970581,
-0.023714302107691765,
-0.14127999544143677,
-0.769173264503479,
-0.09820866584777832,
0.0009296618518419564,
-0.7549089789390564,
1.0774531364440918,
0.35203438997268677,
-0.4391143023967743,
0.5186392664909363,
-0.5582272410392761,
-0.6736192107200623,
-0.16730648279190063,
-0.3686129152774811,
-0.4659648537635803,
0.1948396861553192,
0.3567046821117401,
0.46391594409942627,
-0.291139155626297,
-0.3174586296081543,
-0.32669132947921753,
-0.6039725542068481,
-0.4025748372077942,
-0.5178879499435425,
0.47741618752479553,
-0.18368083238601685,
-0.3869396448135376,
-0.025519514456391335,
-0.7935605049133301,
0.11971887201070786,
-0.18541216850280762,
-0.4484320282936096,
-0.37931588292121887,
0.1112334206700325,
-0.3723669946193695,
-0.15331411361694336,
0.336566686630249,
-0.4938358664512634,
0.2529469132423401,
-0.25119736790657043,
0.3947322964668274,
0.7149055600166321,
-0.011731220409274101,
0.7016347050666809,
-0.30498385429382324,
0.7193275690078735,
-0.4447382986545563,
0.2592543065547943,
0.2615053653717041,
-0.4736672043800354,
-0.7892130613327026,
-0.2775431275367737,
0.2951267957687378,
0.6570253372192383,
-0.7313143610954285,
0.30541616678237915,
-0.46146243810653687,
-0.5920416712760925,
-0.7693740725517273,
0.6966968774795532,
0.6006579995155334,
0.7305471897125244,
0.5995060205459595,
-0.021503934636712074,
-0.510392963886261,
-0.9301124811172485,
-0.10988771170377731,
0.2693149745464325,
-0.1184328943490982,
0.7445303201675415,
0.1472373902797699,
-0.26267510652542114,
0.5139493942260742,
-0.8218963742256165,
-0.33467280864715576,
-0.27531448006629944,
-0.19323962926864624,
0.30323880910873413,
0.4039086401462555,
0.4285038411617279,
-0.3552798330783844,
-0.61162269115448,
0.1730591207742691,
-0.32068896293640137,
-0.019288601353764534,
-0.23423337936401367,
-0.49991610646247864,
0.026126500219106674,
0.8375257253646851,
-0.4730471670627594,
0.39251580834388733,
0.4388226270675659,
0.26719439029693604,
-0.07209707796573639,
-0.024776658043265343,
0.11946390569210052,
-0.5782533288002014,
0.01908416859805584,
0.1200563982129097,
-0.09869465976953506,
-0.33903786540031433,
-0.24108806252479553,
-0.04942714795470238,
0.015801476314663887,
-0.3061666190624237,
0.5726727843284607,
-0.3587029278278351,
0.07980138063430786,
-0.0036641245242208242,
0.10712027549743652,
0.15596123039722443,
0.6658101081848145,
-0.017104152590036392,
0.8796496987342834,
0.6712716817855835,
-0.737107515335083,
0.31514647603034973,
0.34024834632873535,
-0.5425387620925903,
0.5089905261993408,
-0.5510815978050232,
0.3665783405303955,
-0.04903268814086914,
-0.07722777873277664,
-0.6480992436408997,
-0.14414311945438385,
0.20936435461044312,
-0.1381087452173233,
0.42172765731811523,
-0.7808299660682678,
-0.07245374470949173,
-0.07236037403345108,
-0.5349887013435364,
-0.05471573397517204,
0.7516286373138428,
-0.5509327054023743,
0.5701311230659485,
0.3076486587524414,
-0.19249801337718964,
-0.5683461427688599,
-0.6126837134361267,
-0.4269633889198303,
-0.25509172677993774,
-0.3529716432094574,
0.49466103315353394,
0.17909890413284302,
0.14966820180416107,
-0.1818004846572876,
-0.3618282079696655,
-0.20108647644519806,
0.12785442173480988,
0.2160390168428421,
0.2919521927833557,
-0.46650588512420654,
0.16072291135787964,
0.6693299412727356,
-0.054873254150152206,
-0.14632883667945862,
0.03352610394358635,
0.39855334162712097,
0.375914067029953,
-0.48572495579719543,
-0.4825644791126251,
-0.021350501105189323,
0.29632923007011414,
0.04741944745182991,
0.8166622519493103,
0.6709069609642029,
0.10135583579540253,
-0.6958845257759094,
-0.20374064147472382,
-0.5767971873283386,
-0.5471429824829102,
0.3904837965965271,
-0.13985058665275574,
-0.6712921261787415,
0.19175617396831512,
-0.08799689263105392,
0.2811269164085388,
-0.10750340670347214,
0.18475662171840668,
-0.024223843589425087,
1.0174694061279297,
0.5357555747032166,
-0.3455703854560852,
1.0224971771240234,
-0.4528424143791199,
0.12888671457767487,
-1.1104658842086792,
-0.19840040802955627,
-0.24905134737491608,
-0.8407829999923706,
-0.5883958339691162,
-0.6077122688293457,
0.35319507122039795,
-0.12093774974346161,
-0.14870420098304749,
0.4320586919784546,
-0.7428919672966003,
0.7542551755905151,
0.8677374124526978,
0.38999080657958984,
0.03443291410803795,
0.14611561596393585,
0.30404165387153625,
0.04363255947828293,
-0.676977813243866,
-0.44726577401161194,
1.275926947593689,
-0.07604992389678955,
0.9151511192321777,
-0.13374817371368408,
0.5244778990745544,
0.3158304989337921,
0.16307075321674347,
-0.7952616810798645,
0.5632918477058411,
-0.5119835734367371,
-0.3884909749031067,
-0.34338995814323425,
-0.6403014659881592,
-1.088303565979004,
-0.0864497646689415,
-0.2585788071155548,
-0.582821786403656,
0.0637182667851448,
0.3477557897567749,
-0.5226336717605591,
0.0448584221303463,
-1.0532855987548828,
0.5887396931648254,
-0.08574046939611435,
-0.4482983946800232,
-0.3865486979484558,
-0.5585321187973022,
0.09383074939250946,
0.12564623355865479,
-0.19579550623893738,
-0.07012021541595459,
-0.17277969419956207,
0.6324294805526733,
-0.26444417238235474,
0.9275956749916077,
-0.3153320550918579,
-0.07074283808469772,
0.3146421015262604,
0.12568838894367218,
0.5557529926300049,
-0.10164614766836166,
-0.3840262293815613,
0.02134018763899803,
-0.07937740534543991,
-0.4211559295654297,
-0.8866342902183533,
0.9068069458007812,
-0.7275757789611816,
-0.5951933860778809,
0.530430257320404,
-0.19017046689987183,
-0.3580400049686432,
0.06887675821781158,
0.129011332988739,
0.4759175777435303,
0.00028008371009491384,
0.5142782926559448,
0.75542151927948,
0.03821752592921257,
0.13180901110172272,
0.40033742785453796,
0.3274606466293335,
-0.029641639441251755,
1.34188973903656,
0.2094271332025528,
0.13262350857257843,
0.8254743814468384,
0.22199030220508575,
-0.06895466893911362,
-0.4943975508213043,
-0.3826296925544739,
-0.11873374879360199,
-0.6782168745994568,
-0.28253763914108276,
-0.2960323989391327,
-0.1676231473684311,
-0.10494382679462433,
-0.41230180859565735,
-0.49066317081451416,
-0.3500770032405853,
-0.5592349171638489,
-0.1808585375547409,
0.6993261575698853,
0.4373135566711426,
0.15535196661949158,
0.5735531449317932,
-0.7108972072601318,
0.31624773144721985,
0.4272075593471527,
0.36084839701652527,
0.05067050829529762,
-0.6729941368103027,
-0.1737765371799469,
0.20177382230758667,
-0.28222957253456116,
-0.37689438462257385,
0.18657663464546204,
0.597916841506958,
0.7025856971740723,
0.5586896538734436,
0.10093707591295242,
0.6902437806129456,
-0.4765700399875641,
0.31539011001586914,
-0.2955775260925293,
-0.8938963413238525,
0.6118784546852112,
0.02281365543603897,
-0.04324530437588692,
0.9314603209495544,
0.42349934577941895,
0.05476745218038559,
-0.02912209928035736,
-0.4658859968185425,
-0.8721006512641907,
0.9350622892379761,
0.2266707718372345,
0.46808379888534546,
0.32757461071014404,
0.41918864846229553,
0.22222104668617249,
0.3895629644393921,
-0.2627488076686859,
-0.40069010853767395,
0.14151373505592346,
-0.4082489013671875,
0.24888427555561066,
0.19698937237262726,
-0.030584126710891724,
-0.4409129023551941,
0.719944417476654,
-0.1945895105600357,
0.14544618129730225,
-0.20143142342567444,
-0.0751570463180542,
0.10978930443525314,
0.06243721768260002,
0.4580022692680359,
0.31500837206840515,
-0.09548825770616531,
-0.07037864625453949,
0.28441786766052246,
-0.5433560609817505,
-0.15725332498550415,
-0.016883961856365204,
-0.26155316829681396,
-0.22305800020694733,
0.6438071131706238,
0.9971819519996643,
0.3457290232181549,
-0.7795988321304321,
0.39225947856903076,
0.08470900356769562,
0.024907106533646584,
0.014547822996973991,
0.865378201007843,
-0.10839923471212387,
0.24299928545951843,
-0.0044670854695141315,
0.1060125008225441,
0.21565279364585876,
-0.2604448199272156,
0.23990394175052643,
0.6983329057693481,
-0.7068163752555847,
-0.2269534021615982,
0.2355530560016632,
0.4589775800704956,
-0.1674768328666687,
0.6631060838699341,
-0.22805355489253998,
-0.1734790951013565,
0.8716927766799927,
0.01702260598540306,
0.4343040883541107,
-0.05234859138727188,
0.29473018646240234,
0.2899027168750763,
0.3387822210788727,
0.13516409695148468,
0.025501975789666176,
-0.3255153298377991,
-0.6720826625823975,
-0.39687809348106384,
-0.13596399128437042,
-0.481658399105072,
0.3323993980884552,
-0.834823727607727,
0.48208123445510864,
-0.8850192427635193,
-0.133660688996315,
0.06954294443130493,
0.026456760242581367,
-0.7487484812736511,
-0.07975375652313232,
0.15001049637794495,
0.5593456029891968,
-0.6951116323471069,
0.5890675783157349,
0.485594242811203,
-0.07241299748420715,
-0.7695834636688232,
-0.16874852776527405,
0.06349395960569382,
-1.2792905569076538,
0.6551902890205383,
0.07655919343233109,
-0.3305126428604126,
0.1385568082332611,
-0.8888996839523315,
-0.903982400894165,
1.108229637145996,
0.7842242121696472,
-0.8790460824966431,
0.10982376337051392,
-0.19005738198757172,
0.4288558065891266,
-0.3702184855937958,
0.3860074281692505,
0.7867863774299622,
0.3605579733848572,
0.46902620792388916,
-0.35881680250167847,
-0.07548758387565613,
-0.051376260817050934,
-0.2950475811958313,
0.3817933201789856,
-0.747109591960907,
0.526202380657196,
-0.28363439440727234,
-0.22540833055973053,
-0.24952948093414307,
0.2767464220523834,
0.09309200942516327,
0.3070216774940491,
0.08652886003255844,
0.5558480620384216,
0.8538714647293091,
0.2730252742767334,
1.0058867931365967,
-0.555612325668335,
0.11057907342910767,
1.337076187133789,
-0.340364545583725,
0.7801648378372192,
0.3333210349082947,
-0.18547065556049347,
0.5708132982254028,
0.3979567587375641,
-0.2310299575328827,
0.6422020196914673,
0.18857747316360474,
0.039591722190380096,
-0.4199371635913849,
-0.08920514583587646,
-0.08029371500015259,
0.5071535110473633,
0.3551384508609772,
-0.39054495096206665,
-0.044038496911525726,
-0.34754347801208496,
0.14525435864925385,
0.02146301418542862,
-0.4118984639644623,
0.8299652338027954,
0.04974985122680664,
-0.47150877118110657,
0.6449459791183472,
-0.15213005244731903,
0.5122377276420593,
-0.46094611287117004,
-0.4549560546875,
-0.3474828898906708,
0.01257370039820671,
-0.3068208694458008,
-0.5044182538986206,
0.11896579712629318,
-0.007228539790958166,
-0.2885713577270508,
-0.14713241159915924,
0.5417934060096741,
-0.27281346917152405,
-0.5904461741447449,
0.2595621347427368,
0.504327118396759,
-0.09441667795181274,
0.058612972497940063,
-0.7596793174743652,
0.043908920139074326,
0.26081395149230957,
-0.27284812927246094,
0.32501277327537537,
0.31677740812301636,
0.0203463863581419,
0.9221073985099792,
0.7098696827888489,
0.31907808780670166,
0.12903140485286713,
0.13529522716999054,
1.0108416080474854,
-0.4796765446662903,
-0.046063099056482315,
-0.7043389081954956,
0.18008404970169067,
-0.26385825872421265,
-0.3893696069717407,
0.6051228046417236,
0.5633564591407776,
0.8603066205978394,
0.033780016005039215,
0.7178565859794617,
0.13298027217388153,
0.5522968769073486,
-0.8219788074493408,
0.41576695442199707,
-0.3755415380001068,
0.5987505316734314,
-0.06971405446529388,
-1.0159952640533447,
0.1379023939371109,
0.9324074387550354,
-0.7421634793281555,
0.18417921662330627,
0.3354339003562927,
1.0789382457733154,
-0.25339922308921814,
-0.08299671113491058,
0.3049314022064209,
-0.05135539546608925,
0.0944114625453949,
0.7012777328491211,
0.6213259696960449,
-0.1712038815021515,
0.4498085677623749,
-0.24992816150188446,
-0.03350840136408806,
-0.22691617906093597,
-0.7100547552108765,
-1.2712615728378296,
-0.1900470107793808,
-0.35461658239364624,
0.22177667915821075,
-0.055715162307024,
1.0749564170837402,
1.015734076499939,
-0.8065423965454102,
0.23086261749267578,
-0.24379277229309082,
0.594852864742279,
-0.1485491693019867,
-0.2416948527097702,
0.3436940014362335,
-0.1778898686170578,
-0.7624639272689819,
0.6202505230903625,
0.04208581894636154,
-0.2204781472682953,
-0.006668674759566784,
0.1449308544397354,
0.20136623084545135,
0.23552833497524261,
0.5789334177970886,
0.26422545313835144,
-0.31010958552360535,
-0.28507187962532043,
-0.0028771022334694862,
-0.032073311507701874,
0.16918125748634338,
0.8784933090209961,
-0.8385945558547974,
0.17394542694091797,
0.43529102206230164,
0.952479898929596,
0.44334840774536133,
0.24512813985347748,
0.30301475524902344,
-1.0650277137756348,
0.1339626908302307,
0.3137838840484619,
0.04094209894537926,
0.3147813379764557,
-0.570389449596405,
0.4404333233833313,
-0.04419837146997452,
-0.2523607909679413,
-0.5291239023208618,
0.22320708632469177,
-0.7146808505058289,
-0.08960092812776566,
1.288838267326355,
-0.09268037229776382,
-0.184828519821167,
-0.015047774650156498,
-0.16855400800704956,
-0.03861589357256889,
-0.9224227070808411,
0.7727107405662537,
0.2627663016319275,
-0.5120721459388733,
-0.3763943314552307,
-0.5504743456840515,
0.6709795594215393,
0.34176236391067505,
-0.7682114243507385,
0.00475942762568593,
0.43861809372901917,
0.021607249975204468,
-0.017864089459180832,
0.15287327766418457,
0.33279871940612793,
-0.1345909833908081,
0.15163834393024445,
-0.3115810751914978,
-0.15908236801624298,
-0.40989723801612854,
0.027003925293684006,
-0.08975933492183685,
-0.09049046039581299,
-0.21709632873535156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05138v1 | SceMQA: A Scientific College Entrance Level Multimodal Question Answering Benchmark | 2024-02-06T19:16:55 | 2024-02-06T19:16:55 | Zhenwen Liang, Kehan Guo, Gang Liu, Taicheng Guo, Yujun Zhou, Tianyu Yang, Jiajun Jiao, Renjie Pi, Jipeng Zhang, Xiangliang Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The paper introduces SceMQA, a novel benchmark for scientific multimodal
question answering at the college entrance level. It addresses a critical
educational phase often overlooked in existing benchmarks, spanning high school
to pre-college levels. SceMQA focuses on core science subjects including
Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry, and Biology. It features a blend of
multiple-choice and free-response formats, ensuring a comprehensive evaluation
of AI models' abilities. Additionally, our benchmark provides specific
knowledge points for each problem and detailed explanations for each answer.
SceMQA also uniquely presents problems with identical contexts but varied
questions to facilitate a more thorough and accurate assessment of reasoning
capabilities. In the experiment, we evaluate both open-source and close-source
state-of-the-art Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs), across various
experimental settings. The results show that further research and development
are needed in developing more capable MLLM, as highlighted by only 50% to 60%
accuracy achieved by the strongest models. Our benchmark and analysis will be
available at https://scemqa.github.io/ | [
-0.21292956173419952,
-0.8874350190162659,
0.7856122255325317,
0.3525536060333252,
0.14699730277061462,
0.3641504943370819,
-0.13081352412700653,
-0.3064095973968506,
-0.286274790763855,
0.1938081681728363,
-0.6315931081771851,
-0.3594697415828705,
-0.5631723403930664,
0.3523770272731781,
-0.2034767121076584,
0.4632847309112549,
-0.2346239686012268,
0.36677151918411255,
-0.9997652173042297,
-0.31495729088783264,
-0.1017155572772026,
-0.3421330749988556,
-0.37061262130737305,
0.21638576686382294,
0.5756750702857971,
0.3875489830970764,
0.32212671637535095,
0.3977246880531311,
0.7171677350997925,
0.282252699136734,
-0.003976240288466215,
0.07933042198419571,
-0.08823782205581665,
0.5320431590080261,
-0.20146483182907104,
-0.11060821264982224,
-0.24042575061321259,
-0.04868997633457184,
0.878309428691864,
0.8449807167053223,
-0.17051014304161072,
0.6562556028366089,
-0.11510173231363297,
0.4489578604698181,
-1.07057523727417,
0.11015670001506805,
-0.5110460519790649,
-0.3401138186454773,
-0.08846449851989746,
0.18184992671012878,
-0.6121801733970642,
-0.34620171785354614,
0.05524146184325218,
-0.5887235403060913,
-0.15590600669384003,
-0.054474443197250366,
0.7744051814079285,
0.3537501096725464,
-0.8998563289642334,
-0.11261530220508575,
-0.40202590823173523,
0.8395558595657349,
-0.48767122626304626,
0.7857860922813416,
0.16244693100452423,
0.5969185829162598,
0.18703985214233398,
-0.9195560216903687,
-0.6880849599838257,
-0.3388972282409668,
0.3817511200904846,
0.37278056144714355,
-0.39075690507888794,
0.003996903542429209,
0.1387159377336502,
-0.038039639592170715,
-0.8923611044883728,
-0.31991690397262573,
-0.8041577935218811,
-0.2854660749435425,
0.4516945779323578,
0.34418100118637085,
0.1328454315662384,
0.01731116697192192,
-0.4003560543060303,
-0.1699402928352356,
-0.3914273977279663,
0.5095158219337463,
0.030589470639824867,
0.2324177622795105,
0.18416735529899597,
0.8753313422203064,
-0.5481681227684021,
0.6058965921401978,
-0.4733588695526123,
-0.011801352724432945,
0.2624361217021942,
-0.7351341843605042,
-0.1724490225315094,
-0.22248893976211548,
0.6068370342254639,
0.3421595096588135,
-0.09399881213903427,
0.18454743921756744,
0.08289062231779099,
0.19097471237182617,
0.21387477219104767,
-0.7946609854698181,
0.03593819588422775,
0.3873654007911682,
-0.35598698258399963,
0.24541246891021729,
-0.21403931081295013,
-0.7134818434715271,
-0.04705067723989487,
-0.22942151129245758,
0.5683462619781494,
-0.2639034390449524,
-0.00476812245324254,
0.13337726891040802,
-0.013150346465408802,
0.07437591254711151,
0.4875803291797638,
-0.31648963689804077,
0.14969828724861145,
0.4346681535243988,
0.6919747591018677,
-0.3027676045894623,
-0.3269940912723541,
-0.2942604124546051,
0.05199543386697769,
-0.03260750696063042,
0.8085351586341858,
-0.835184633731842,
-0.31103789806365967,
-0.1849699467420578,
-0.013643501326441765,
-0.2494760900735855,
-0.2907317578792572,
0.4581337571144104,
-0.5440130233764648,
0.15415078401565552,
-0.22400200366973877,
-0.2948322296142578,
-0.2166297435760498,
0.2966288924217224,
-0.47879764437675476,
1.2090777158737183,
0.13363805413246155,
-0.5049169063568115,
0.03381867706775665,
-0.753149151802063,
-0.04519587755203247,
0.04377547651529312,
-0.12917666137218475,
0.06311827152967453,
-0.14811812341213226,
0.19472841918468475,
0.2839425802230835,
-0.3461676836013794,
0.17141112685203552,
-0.4712573289871216,
-0.11583138257265091,
0.5071316361427307,
-0.4610247313976288,
0.7702717185020447,
0.6471503376960754,
0.03429058566689491,
0.10156365483999252,
-0.8304185271263123,
0.371149480342865,
0.04721375182271004,
-0.13574504852294922,
-0.27091285586357117,
-0.1640111356973648,
-0.07461359351873398,
0.49408262968063354,
0.48079293966293335,
-0.919674813747406,
0.2394164353609085,
0.14966289699077606,
0.5642126798629761,
0.6190060973167419,
-0.17711225152015686,
0.29848742485046387,
-0.170962393283844,
0.5907064080238342,
-0.08787249773740768,
0.28654778003692627,
-0.3289414048194885,
-0.5942544341087341,
-0.4635273218154907,
-0.49626266956329346,
0.2634730935096741,
0.6139125227928162,
-0.7933022379875183,
-0.1830597072839737,
0.01325780339539051,
-0.9481424689292908,
-0.7966669201850891,
-0.051117513328790665,
0.40468913316726685,
0.5271143317222595,
0.7120180130004883,
-0.1743219792842865,
-0.41902539134025574,
-1.0678662061691284,
-0.3942646086215973,
-0.1182372197508812,
-0.03528652712702751,
0.3953983187675476,
0.7619073987007141,
-0.0974549800157547,
0.7540232539176941,
-0.4568959176540375,
0.27321669459342957,
-0.013817522674798965,
0.16093607246875763,
-0.051982611417770386,
0.25578346848487854,
0.31189587712287903,
-0.6821295022964478,
-0.22824060916900635,
-0.3354407250881195,
-0.8929667472839355,
-0.1887931376695633,
0.1494314968585968,
-0.030848849564790726,
-0.280771404504776,
0.495418906211853,
-0.7310647964477539,
0.4593890309333801,
0.7341924905776978,
-0.4907706379890442,
0.849068284034729,
0.016969244927167892,
0.36185935139656067,
-0.9406992793083191,
0.16631361842155457,
-0.007464784197509289,
0.15838420391082764,
-0.5454930067062378,
0.4163781702518463,
0.31543031334877014,
-0.31230592727661133,
-0.8962169885635376,
0.7814536690711975,
-0.30842939019203186,
-0.09163851290941238,
0.02008775621652603,
0.19277064502239227,
0.16862225532531738,
0.21884360909461975,
-0.19133055210113525,
1.17322838306427,
0.5125475525856018,
-0.4664441645145416,
0.2596685290336609,
0.23191045224666595,
-0.4239819049835205,
0.6047410368919373,
-0.9940669536590576,
-0.14456498622894287,
-0.1258377730846405,
0.481743186712265,
-1.0997629165649414,
-0.17708148062229156,
-0.01956736296415329,
-0.4646061658859253,
-0.2631472647190094,
0.28080013394355774,
-0.23393556475639343,
-0.5111036896705627,
0.019324112683534622,
0.8508335947990417,
0.00963800959289074,
0.016229107975959778,
0.9059020280838013,
0.029065512120723724,
-0.6041384935379028,
-0.8627265691757202,
-0.3682364523410797,
0.024470966309309006,
0.2563411593437195,
-0.6157326102256775,
0.0030885387677699327,
-0.48611924052238464,
-0.3549800217151642,
-0.09681697189807892,
-0.12662863731384277,
-0.3470938801765442,
0.07358492910861969,
0.2976067066192627,
0.47417399287223816,
-0.4075622260570526,
0.142530620098114,
0.18741284310817719,
0.11524845659732819,
0.24631771445274353,
0.10301297903060913,
0.3904050290584564,
-0.4396003186702728,
-0.5138052701950073,
-0.6576735973358154,
0.6686851382255554,
0.9604306817054749,
-0.47802579402923584,
0.5364450812339783,
0.4205561876296997,
-0.311088502407074,
0.31606635451316833,
-0.4615843892097473,
-0.3083072900772095,
-0.46097347140312195,
0.6348159313201904,
-0.47408556938171387,
-0.9318651556968689,
0.31752291321754456,
0.138313427567482,
0.1693980097770691,
0.34852221608161926,
0.48396673798561096,
-0.35908642411231995,
1.2374284267425537,
0.29612162709236145,
0.6303569674491882,
0.04969519004225731,
0.09174277633428574,
-0.011479259468615055,
-0.8605806827545166,
-0.3957130014896393,
-0.9423494338989258,
-0.07228130847215652,
-0.28002122044563293,
-0.6096914410591125,
0.47846540808677673,
-0.032466303557157516,
-0.6291956305503845,
0.3680046796798706,
-0.3324325382709503,
0.30555805563926697,
0.694412350654602,
0.14334282279014587,
0.32538852095603943,
-0.2529847025871277,
-0.3917735517024994,
-0.14470748603343964,
-0.5082632303237915,
-0.6064653396606445,
1.1861417293548584,
0.3026244044303894,
0.5204048752784729,
0.15824857354164124,
0.24557535350322723,
0.08794606477022171,
0.38894402980804443,
-0.4379581809043884,
0.6814969182014465,
0.14802876114845276,
-1.0745036602020264,
-0.4492798447608948,
-0.3382749557495117,
-0.712591290473938,
0.4394713044166565,
-0.4508076012134552,
-0.6819924116134644,
0.12303569912910461,
-0.10931982845067978,
-0.37692636251449585,
0.14912526309490204,
-0.5615463852882385,
0.9033645987510681,
-0.13929998874664307,
-0.5211685299873352,
-0.1140594482421875,
-0.8840160369873047,
0.29744571447372437,
0.026095738634467125,
0.390941321849823,
-0.2708321809768677,
-0.12714742124080658,
0.7620596885681152,
0.05418558418750763,
0.5798672437667847,
-0.09135856479406357,
0.1970558613538742,
0.3755658268928528,
0.18428431451320648,
0.18072724342346191,
0.09162591397762299,
-0.15742601454257965,
0.2631804347038269,
0.555513858795166,
-0.9342172145843506,
-0.6377502083778381,
0.47732388973236084,
-0.8616410493850708,
-0.639276385307312,
-0.6583961844444275,
-0.8091185092926025,
-0.5390352606773376,
0.22753821313381195,
-0.17237140238285065,
0.29298731684684753,
-0.08884528279304504,
0.7115200757980347,
0.667722761631012,
-0.1438041776418686,
0.3692508637905121,
0.5241754651069641,
-0.059411462396383286,
-0.5184560418128967,
0.6268889307975769,
-0.0010917984182015061,
0.4387392997741699,
0.1465158462524414,
-0.013623693957924843,
-0.48522692918777466,
-0.37517255544662476,
-0.6582188010215759,
0.29736700654029846,
-0.8364518284797668,
-0.189269557595253,
-1.084875226020813,
-0.41401079297065735,
-0.5681309103965759,
-0.10554004460573196,
-0.45860108733177185,
-0.5453727841377258,
0.11657632142305374,
0.045213695615530014,
-0.16878598928451538,
0.5036134123802185,
0.2289731800556183,
0.1305048018693924,
-0.9191008806228638,
0.14147764444351196,
0.6433349847793579,
-0.0021286827977746725,
-0.2478732317686081,
-0.4268587827682495,
-0.005304364953190088,
0.3455231189727783,
-0.5727860331535339,
-0.7918703556060791,
-0.22293269634246826,
0.20747682452201843,
0.8399249315261841,
0.22998730838298798,
0.05558352172374725,
0.3955129384994507,
-0.30511710047721863,
1.1991685628890991,
0.28666558861732483,
-0.9461274147033691,
0.3633836507797241,
-0.2059263437986374,
0.549763560295105,
0.8149927258491516,
0.7828561663627625,
-0.4049984812736511,
-0.4092615246772766,
-0.38428059220314026,
-0.6929528117179871,
0.32747191190719604,
0.2953931987285614,
0.08372294902801514,
-0.038583122193813324,
-0.025460362434387207,
0.17001907527446747,
0.5121710896492004,
-0.6704682111740112,
-0.22101660072803497,
-0.4789808690547943,
-0.3282218873500824,
-0.10034094005823135,
-0.12243334949016571,
-0.28083428740501404,
-0.24428245425224304,
0.5399657487869263,
-0.06482920050621033,
0.2803650200366974,
0.11031703650951385,
-0.2045932412147522,
0.11626169830560684,
0.5928943753242493,
0.9010798931121826,
0.9491422176361084,
-0.15471677482128143,
0.2707321047782898,
0.3689483404159546,
-0.7494680881500244,
0.17790380120277405,
0.018461808562278748,
-0.10914649814367294,
-0.17567771673202515,
0.3046756684780121,
0.3434278666973114,
-0.003739882493391633,
-1.036867380142212,
0.6776337623596191,
-0.13814695179462433,
-0.502810537815094,
0.18113529682159424,
-0.03751303255558014,
0.08665655553340912,
0.3913586139678955,
0.8050622940063477,
0.102684386074543,
0.1930902600288391,
-0.4812602996826172,
0.27023833990097046,
0.3692166209220886,
-0.5151540637016296,
-0.20033912360668182,
0.8944315314292908,
0.135825976729393,
-0.017223920673131943,
0.3571339547634125,
0.238108292222023,
-0.24470186233520508,
0.7103396058082581,
0.5661099553108215,
0.44132086634635925,
-0.3692578673362732,
0.47344160079956055,
0.6844186782836914,
0.3821619153022766,
0.23668991029262543,
0.5378801822662354,
-0.16689787805080414,
-0.4745926856994629,
-0.33577510714530945,
-0.669866681098938,
-0.7655745148658752,
-0.19168390333652496,
-0.701092541217804,
-0.007563514169305563,
-0.3116750717163086,
-0.15757115185260773,
0.1405535787343979,
-0.23568545281887054,
-0.6682313680648804,
0.505336344242096,
-0.07180145382881165,
1.2627780437469482,
-0.840302050113678,
0.5452566146850586,
0.8498232960700989,
-0.4188430905342102,
-0.6084457039833069,
-0.39428871870040894,
0.04421934485435486,
-0.7049175500869751,
0.6940621733665466,
0.05428476259112358,
-0.24993674457073212,
0.005493036471307278,
-0.7863535284996033,
-1.0838967561721802,
1.2051109075546265,
0.09667273610830307,
-0.3449840545654297,
-0.038127824664115906,
0.132806196808815,
0.4270530939102173,
-0.5195862650871277,
0.7129202485084534,
0.19519051909446716,
0.5899633169174194,
0.21010620892047882,
-0.8194805979728699,
0.05064602941274643,
-0.4918530285358429,
-0.21662481129169464,
-0.21504950523376465,
-0.6761227250099182,
1.006515622138977,
-0.1661515086889267,
-0.02913537248969078,
0.19235341250896454,
0.8434385061264038,
0.6628354787826538,
0.8595598936080933,
0.41854363679885864,
0.33671626448631287,
0.5602861046791077,
-0.3923143148422241,
0.4850040674209595,
-0.30525779724121094,
0.1714186668395996,
0.9742256999015808,
-0.3869129419326782,
1.0990440845489502,
0.7065353989601135,
-0.28194427490234375,
0.6722709536552429,
0.6678234338760376,
0.1832929253578186,
0.45290815830230713,
0.08358875662088394,
-0.37870869040489197,
-0.5587028861045837,
-0.22038933634757996,
-0.8365448117256165,
0.7539131045341492,
0.44238850474357605,
-0.05021088197827339,
-0.28116390109062195,
0.38006505370140076,
-0.15509185194969177,
0.19901856780052185,
-0.26865464448928833,
0.32070502638816833,
-0.14480705559253693,
-0.539671003818512,
0.2687995731830597,
-0.24242831766605377,
0.15847992897033691,
-0.6670096516609192,
0.017079994082450867,
-0.19463202357292175,
-0.1835891604423523,
0.11148174107074738,
-0.9772519469261169,
-0.030747707933187485,
-0.1670098751783371,
-0.13253289461135864,
-0.11312384903430939,
0.2619820237159729,
-0.4375995099544525,
-0.4920335114002228,
0.007906646467745304,
0.7836970090866089,
0.09675285220146179,
0.09407252818346024,
-0.7614858746528625,
0.0375414602458477,
-0.36980557441711426,
-0.2962501645088196,
0.13282239437103271,
0.28977274894714355,
-0.20892859995365143,
1.0048454999923706,
0.8337720036506653,
-0.16344010829925537,
0.21504002809524536,
-0.2794763445854187,
0.8928482532501221,
-0.5706232786178589,
-0.3431093096733093,
-0.3439447581768036,
0.7068986296653748,
-0.155492901802063,
-0.5439183115959167,
0.8766725063323975,
0.6730356812477112,
0.8213494420051575,
-0.11700031161308289,
0.805273175239563,
0.09083211421966553,
0.4405570328235626,
-0.2620525062084198,
0.5093243718147278,
-0.7958248257637024,
-0.12756574153900146,
-0.3995507061481476,
-0.992501974105835,
-0.36065760254859924,
0.27095791697502136,
-0.21669143438339233,
0.09243562072515488,
1.0676158666610718,
0.8057800531387329,
0.01288597472012043,
0.1314675211906433,
0.3657805025577545,
0.07991794496774673,
0.025323359295725822,
0.5409597158432007,
1.1671451330184937,
-0.5560508966445923,
0.7605313062667847,
-0.12892338633537292,
-0.26499196887016296,
-0.2824823558330536,
-0.6000288724899292,
-0.767738938331604,
-0.7444512844085693,
-0.2135782390832901,
-0.5206515789031982,
0.22773709893226624,
0.937931478023529,
0.5748487114906311,
-0.793448805809021,
-0.1324513852596283,
0.564235270023346,
-0.1975162774324417,
-0.4613651931285858,
-0.18463405966758728,
0.25281214714050293,
0.0008089950424619019,
-0.6228183507919312,
0.487363338470459,
0.37140145897865295,
-0.05698242038488388,
-0.2215346395969391,
0.028298649936914444,
-0.5393105745315552,
0.5487114787101746,
0.6990772485733032,
0.3512326180934906,
-0.843032717704773,
-0.33827733993530273,
0.7570673227310181,
-0.5063062906265259,
-0.09823340177536011,
0.6943488717079163,
-0.3967769145965576,
0.6009422540664673,
0.3946225643157959,
0.7216694355010986,
0.34769466519355774,
0.01755356974899769,
0.1599968671798706,
-0.38533931970596313,
-0.025267479941248894,
0.2977101802825928,
0.2872946858406067,
0.07068364322185516,
-0.034280382096767426,
0.3643673062324524,
0.2203061729669571,
-0.7080579400062561,
-0.9634131193161011,
0.1645030528306961,
-1.3757727146148682,
-0.46145468950271606,
1.0669502019882202,
-0.11836106330156326,
-0.2890322506427765,
-0.3326873481273651,
-0.25384771823883057,
0.10295134037733078,
-0.3398689031600952,
0.6509221196174622,
0.8908653259277344,
-0.04478568583726883,
-0.3143976628780365,
-0.7087112069129944,
0.06960836797952652,
0.4975731372833252,
-0.8301405906677246,
0.04748900979757309,
0.42148470878601074,
0.1489410400390625,
0.20284296572208405,
0.4414869248867035,
-0.1180642694234848,
0.6705999970436096,
0.14966382086277008,
0.3088676929473877,
-0.2971247434616089,
-0.6559770703315735,
0.10685496777296066,
0.5166358947753906,
-0.2700332701206207,
-0.14147964119911194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04315v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04315v2 | Training Language Models to Generate Text with Citations via Fine-grained Rewards | 2024-02-06T19:00:40 | 2024-05-27T09:32:15 | Chengyu Huang, Zeqiu Wu, Yushi Hu, Wenya Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have proven useful in answering
user queries, they are prone to hallucination, and their responses often lack
credibility due to missing references to reliable sources. An intuitive
solution to these issues would be to include in-text citations referring to
external documents as evidence. While previous works have directly prompted
LLMs to generate in-text citations, their performances are far from
satisfactory, especially when it comes to smaller LLMs. In this work, we
propose an effective training framework using fine-grained rewards to teach
LLMs to generate highly supportive and relevant citations, while ensuring the
correctness of their responses. We also conduct a systematic analysis of
applying these fine-grained rewards to common LLM training strategies,
demonstrating its advantage over conventional practices. We conduct extensive
experiments on Question Answering (QA) datasets taken from the ALCE benchmark
and validate the model's generalizability using EXPERTQA. On LLaMA-2-7B, the
incorporation of fine-grained rewards achieves the best performance among the
baselines, even surpassing that of GPT-3.5-turbo. | [
-0.2142765372991562,
-0.4407428205013275,
0.9450041055679321,
-0.10016924887895584,
-0.07858818769454956,
-0.007725963834673166,
-0.3290029466152191,
-0.3981265127658844,
0.11232593655586243,
0.24815495312213898,
-0.30929532647132874,
-0.3161877691745758,
-0.508089542388916,
0.22829963266849518,
-0.3937787711620331,
1.084608793258667,
-0.04074617847800255,
0.13384608924388885,
-0.5229986906051636,
0.041931796818971634,
-0.29581141471862793,
-0.7576336860656738,
-0.6034966707229614,
-0.478537380695343,
0.9564314484596252,
0.5951727032661438,
0.3049211800098419,
0.5373923778533936,
0.4798310697078705,
0.15995186567306519,
-0.10724809020757675,
0.5701545476913452,
-0.4424586296081543,
0.4058525860309601,
-0.5342281460762024,
-0.37899544835090637,
-0.10295180231332779,
0.020651856437325478,
0.45581310987472534,
0.5581480264663696,
-0.04842060059309006,
0.16435052454471588,
0.3495706021785736,
0.5046018958091736,
-0.5408200621604919,
0.19530275464057922,
-1.0494794845581055,
-0.34766173362731934,
-0.3642171025276184,
-0.5509791970252991,
-0.5634902715682983,
-0.6427526473999023,
-0.16035711765289307,
-0.479353129863739,
0.032615289092063904,
-0.12377510219812393,
1.007307767868042,
0.11688224971294403,
-0.11140386015176773,
-0.5944827198982239,
-0.48345139622688293,
0.6379441022872925,
-0.6462940573692322,
-0.021612703800201416,
0.6111174821853638,
0.2672148048877716,
-0.18814702332019806,
-0.6683667302131653,
-0.21284885704517365,
-0.16063816845417023,
-0.10341425985097885,
-0.13068850338459015,
0.13068243861198425,
-0.2053883671760559,
-0.025768620893359184,
0.19554969668388367,
-0.33106932044029236,
0.15213218331336975,
-0.02479553036391735,
0.005994852166622877,
0.4276413023471832,
0.12151357531547546,
-0.13465017080307007,
-0.11920299381017685,
-0.17758294939994812,
-0.1301983892917633,
-0.7974251508712769,
0.2981020212173462,
0.24078525602817535,
0.8074287176132202,
0.17745760083198547,
0.5841115713119507,
-0.22013896703720093,
0.33061638474464417,
0.10883201658725739,
-0.09769544005393982,
0.0165773406624794,
-0.17324766516685486,
-0.014543082565069199,
-0.03706301376223564,
0.5505815744400024,
0.029468510299921036,
0.5709336400032043,
-0.6616884469985962,
-0.3951752483844757,
-0.22848202288150787,
0.14913025498390198,
-1.1033354997634888,
-0.03863059729337692,
0.18133701384067535,
-0.3129099905490875,
-0.3911133408546448,
0.03200004994869232,
-0.40497109293937683,
-0.442413330078125,
-0.5043982267379761,
0.444117933511734,
-0.46576282382011414,
-0.05488820746541023,
-0.10187854617834091,
-0.12092078477144241,
0.08858051896095276,
0.3295903205871582,
-1.2185156345367432,
0.23229780793190002,
0.6958878040313721,
0.6819321513175964,
-0.005422436632215977,
-0.3284064829349518,
-1.1204243898391724,
0.29053470492362976,
-0.222990021109581,
1.237227439880371,
-0.8808114528656006,
-0.12908011674880981,
0.4314201772212982,
-0.08585001528263092,
-0.2878703773021698,
-0.7544893026351929,
0.5534682273864746,
-0.5897791981697083,
-0.0160231851041317,
-0.5824658870697021,
-0.712792694568634,
0.1976102590560913,
0.46076181530952454,
-0.31032609939575195,
1.2564245462417603,
0.08939453959465027,
-0.6178109049797058,
0.054626062512397766,
-0.4080030918121338,
-0.18793533742427826,
0.03918939456343651,
-0.30107200145721436,
-0.13002578914165497,
0.2306603491306305,
0.227355495095253,
0.5503249764442444,
-0.3854961097240448,
0.5204521417617798,
-0.3856458365917206,
-0.3601088523864746,
0.427374005317688,
-0.26377102732658386,
0.21906690299510956,
0.24375954270362854,
-0.16658037900924683,
0.19172684848308563,
-0.8786188960075378,
0.16905242204666138,
0.20053230226039886,
-0.6421746015548706,
-0.6343306303024292,
-0.010670512914657593,
0.08587165176868439,
0.08974258601665497,
0.15255501866340637,
-0.49675095081329346,
0.25015386939048767,
-0.4208179712295532,
0.2405940294265747,
0.8314706683158875,
-0.0073350160382688046,
0.36423608660697937,
-0.2859320342540741,
0.32604730129241943,
-0.15738658607006073,
-0.3367603123188019,
-0.335917204618454,
-0.17603370547294617,
-0.6920163035392761,
-0.014962087385356426,
0.4197174310684204,
0.3170394003391266,
-0.8339921236038208,
0.16158798336982727,
-0.42973804473876953,
-0.4233909845352173,
-0.2896508574485779,
0.3392951488494873,
0.26558175683021545,
0.40682560205459595,
0.4106515645980835,
0.03343319892883301,
-0.4100608229637146,
-0.7194851636886597,
-0.3462580144405365,
-0.29411327838897705,
-0.22238478064537048,
0.30579590797424316,
0.6127794981002808,
0.008516705594956875,
1.0572075843811035,
-0.22277817130088806,
-0.25177642703056335,
-0.12271774560213089,
0.3463894724845886,
-0.09190955758094788,
0.5150668621063232,
0.4663563072681427,
-0.4408278167247772,
-0.2797587215900421,
-0.009493479505181313,
-0.8097846508026123,
-0.18748612701892853,
-0.15774588286876678,
-0.17259907722473145,
0.09709959477186203,
0.6158331632614136,
-0.4155990481376648,
-0.0590796023607254,
0.26647189259529114,
-0.30259132385253906,
0.38406315445899963,
0.0584493912756443,
0.04832707345485687,
-0.9577264785766602,
0.27867591381073,
-0.04675016924738884,
-0.47126442193984985,
-0.3770903944969177,
0.21148793399333954,
0.13174451887607574,
0.0287404116243124,
-0.24724090099334717,
0.676893949508667,
-0.0948462262749672,
0.13022229075431824,
-0.520632803440094,
0.10874418914318085,
0.02224273793399334,
0.5196400880813599,
0.042376432567834854,
0.8198497891426086,
0.08734137564897537,
-0.5177819728851318,
0.044357627630233765,
0.0797506794333458,
-0.26232704520225525,
0.6612628102302551,
-0.5801792144775391,
0.14196723699569702,
-0.13542531430721283,
0.1951255053281784,
-0.8115172386169434,
-0.3615632653236389,
-0.10745705664157867,
-0.36401617527008057,
0.23305527865886688,
-0.14571613073349,
-0.6962182521820068,
-0.08990443497896194,
-0.38134539127349854,
0.3358125686645508,
0.08640125393867493,
-0.7979913353919983,
0.4342787265777588,
0.2303437888622284,
-0.34300485253334045,
-0.2712632715702057,
-0.6191566586494446,
0.011991741135716438,
-0.2795238196849823,
-0.4287964403629303,
0.2984026372432709,
-0.25626805424690247,
-0.18826203048229218,
-0.07993673533201218,
0.01076410710811615,
0.02880358323454857,
0.3744547665119171,
0.1010066568851471,
-0.0498383603990078,
-0.18724118173122406,
0.5125100612640381,
0.021336693316698074,
-0.08776332437992096,
0.09332197904586792,
-0.2268640249967575,
0.6709715127944946,
-0.314351350069046,
-0.41826120018959045,
-0.15283745527267456,
0.4521060287952423,
0.2647164762020111,
-0.20553091168403625,
0.6681254506111145,
0.5825425386428833,
-0.3644105792045593,
0.003447916591539979,
-0.6073732376098633,
-0.39660531282424927,
-0.4162095785140991,
0.15758530795574188,
-0.34150221943855286,
-1.0234174728393555,
0.49970659613609314,
-0.054559316486120224,
0.16226473450660706,
0.36793041229248047,
0.5816441178321838,
-0.03691874444484711,
0.8791636228561401,
0.37026065587997437,
-0.052259527146816254,
0.5217025279998779,
0.05828914791345596,
-0.19251157343387604,
-0.660856306552887,
-0.4347001016139984,
-0.9149439334869385,
-0.09321504831314087,
-0.35328608751296997,
-0.37914952635765076,
0.08175423741340637,
0.32903894782066345,
-0.4705246686935425,
-0.045552175492048264,
-0.3203553855419159,
0.6038890480995178,
0.7695260047912598,
-0.06920699030160904,
0.325651615858078,
0.289189875125885,
-0.23780661821365356,
0.15149249136447906,
-0.548036515712738,
-0.8956388831138611,
0.9653676748275757,
0.4569600224494934,
0.9094677567481995,
-0.03759405389428139,
0.9340303540229797,
0.08400163799524307,
0.37934109568595886,
-0.6785626411437988,
0.38666507601737976,
0.11541624367237091,
-0.4272668659687042,
-0.14295025169849396,
-0.33298686146736145,
-0.9508270621299744,
0.1678423434495926,
-0.026672491803765297,
-0.7994433641433716,
0.2372119128704071,
-0.01594110205769539,
-0.42421624064445496,
0.14635689556598663,
-0.5421222448348999,
0.6255710124969482,
-0.09016961604356766,
-0.6072543859481812,
0.043492477387189865,
-0.4205082654953003,
0.04520702362060547,
0.004900546278804541,
0.1447424590587616,
-0.09587427973747253,
0.2076137661933899,
0.7526703476905823,
-0.408335417509079,
0.8248606324195862,
-0.2847871780395508,
-0.17734737694263458,
0.36965540051460266,
-0.016916925087571144,
0.8813091516494751,
0.31828999519348145,
-0.2537469267845154,
-0.26422518491744995,
-0.0742851123213768,
-0.49815991520881653,
-0.3875901997089386,
0.9053452610969543,
-0.4919694662094116,
-0.4982735812664032,
-0.4457796514034271,
-0.7971791625022888,
-0.5211789608001709,
-0.04017769172787666,
0.049879785627126694,
0.5126965641975403,
0.023410920053720474,
0.2953757345676422,
0.9018399715423584,
-0.017812829464673996,
0.5885080099105835,
0.5041666030883789,
-0.14837001264095306,
-0.4527280628681183,
0.9000036120414734,
-0.004710634239017963,
0.15001729130744934,
0.40157029032707214,
0.1869567632675171,
-0.26546311378479004,
-0.5842124819755554,
-0.6268286108970642,
0.14420488476753235,
-0.817939281463623,
-0.5522566437721252,
-0.49769505858421326,
-0.3771861791610718,
-0.3411093056201935,
-0.10536319017410278,
-0.2538428008556366,
-0.3528004288673401,
-0.33263158798217773,
-0.07668506354093552,
0.3632574677467346,
0.6768553853034973,
0.05477321892976761,
0.20200082659721375,
-0.7629250288009644,
-0.05881190672516823,
0.5933409929275513,
0.3835199177265167,
0.23685316741466522,
-0.5756284594535828,
-0.5826543569564819,
0.02940848097205162,
-0.461424320936203,
-0.5465255975723267,
0.156453937292099,
0.19473972916603088,
0.5318302512168884,
0.12916147708892822,
-0.10307818651199341,
0.7594536542892456,
-0.6222445368766785,
0.805204451084137,
-0.04175689443945885,
-0.63053297996521,
0.5457121133804321,
-0.5360921025276184,
0.29440099000930786,
0.913631796836853,
0.3549421727657318,
-0.2585184872150421,
-0.633368194103241,
-0.4446398615837097,
-0.9857214093208313,
0.6248971819877625,
0.17553849518299103,
0.18988244235515594,
-0.3955141305923462,
0.4720042049884796,
0.18156440556049347,
0.158985897898674,
-1.075474500656128,
0.04927549883723259,
0.048229776322841644,
-0.5254126787185669,
0.15973924100399017,
-0.43612974882125854,
-0.15786606073379517,
-0.0197367612272501,
0.9403858184814453,
-0.48054081201553345,
0.13416603207588196,
0.2663107216358185,
-0.1765696108341217,
-0.15936985611915588,
0.4521878659725189,
0.5318289399147034,
0.5842539668083191,
-0.3010861873626709,
0.4131554961204529,
-0.15421193838119507,
-0.0990862250328064,
0.03614427149295807,
0.2919657826423645,
-0.1396385282278061,
-0.06754908710718155,
0.1750793159008026,
0.4560554027557373,
0.23964913189411163,
-0.8341366648674011,
0.3781563937664032,
-0.03946276009082794,
-0.18347306549549103,
-0.1562986969947815,
-0.04974021017551422,
0.34509187936782837,
0.47969934344291687,
0.7053698301315308,
-0.09686920046806335,
0.00701535539701581,
-0.5044508576393127,
-0.07066891342401505,
0.5364971160888672,
-0.31730934977531433,
-0.1616557389497757,
0.6076905131340027,
0.1545369029045105,
-0.043233707547187805,
0.1454869508743286,
-0.32197073101997375,
-0.36165180802345276,
0.285683274269104,
0.6549623608589172,
0.6854608654975891,
-0.01194345485419035,
0.12663161754608154,
0.4074927866458893,
0.11082262545824051,
-0.29369139671325684,
0.09154508262872696,
-0.016396798193454742,
-0.3299158811569214,
-0.3236042559146881,
-0.9297852516174316,
-0.4722898602485657,
0.31688523292541504,
-0.5214855670928955,
0.07733123004436493,
-0.06998098641633987,
0.10765396058559418,
0.06796985119581223,
0.0035338392481207848,
-0.5741197466850281,
0.1671692430973053,
0.3670743405818939,
0.8663394451141357,
-0.8286135196685791,
1.0657271146774292,
0.7435882091522217,
-0.7813120484352112,
-0.9768725633621216,
-0.044991545379161835,
-0.289734810590744,
-0.6001973152160645,
0.7213111519813538,
0.2895474433898926,
-0.1221495047211647,
0.013076880015432835,
-0.6585836410522461,
-0.9923191070556641,
0.9708472490310669,
0.4580640494823456,
-0.41941890120506287,
-0.06803639978170395,
0.29071617126464844,
0.47769853472709656,
-0.5565786361694336,
0.46957749128341675,
0.3653256297111511,
0.34479260444641113,
0.16226813197135925,
-0.7066574692726135,
0.034951966255903244,
-0.36641231179237366,
0.17470750212669373,
-0.13431870937347412,
-0.501040518283844,
0.682246744632721,
0.10955625027418137,
0.01893841288983822,
0.5053179264068604,
0.7697753310203552,
0.5312545299530029,
0.46075716614723206,
0.35568565130233765,
0.30399131774902344,
1.1636358499526978,
-0.15862159430980682,
1.0907859802246094,
-0.17725946009159088,
0.34091639518737793,
1.3128329515457153,
-0.1660480946302414,
1.1370024681091309,
0.7141541838645935,
0.10269936919212341,
0.8585416674613953,
0.8036584258079529,
0.19343651831150055,
0.6566203236579895,
0.15667939186096191,
-0.03001393936574459,
-0.5438160300254822,
-0.42621049284935,
-0.47822681069374084,
0.10742458701133728,
0.09068719297647476,
-0.5369114875793457,
-0.43294939398765564,
0.12037356942892075,
0.12322783470153809,
0.49268171191215515,
-0.44291937351226807,
0.7274314165115356,
0.09483399242162704,
-0.8457105159759521,
0.7467862367630005,
0.04670102894306183,
0.673321545124054,
-0.7365097999572754,
0.08571547269821167,
-0.5455096960067749,
0.2024514228105545,
-0.22244399785995483,
-0.5986484885215759,
0.08124668896198273,
0.43237343430519104,
-0.4710392951965332,
-0.23382531106472015,
0.6731866002082825,
-0.6008173823356628,
-0.4019539952278137,
0.11963717639446259,
0.40630608797073364,
0.17347478866577148,
-0.21680603921413422,
-0.2745727002620697,
-0.17525601387023926,
-0.19889575242996216,
-0.3295869827270508,
0.7539033889770508,
0.5842794179916382,
-0.08988896757364273,
0.5307418704032898,
0.6241228580474854,
-0.06770697981119156,
-0.10979045927524567,
0.40165573358535767,
1.019473910331726,
-0.5459335446357727,
-0.32399412989616394,
-0.8943495750427246,
0.3361186981201172,
-0.21757008135318756,
-0.1016821339726448,
0.7855304479598999,
0.8188485503196716,
0.8101962208747864,
0.07669120281934738,
0.6640638709068298,
0.15259931981563568,
0.5759696364402771,
-0.6175438165664673,
0.42503419518470764,
-0.7269616723060608,
0.5008123517036438,
-0.2233114242553711,
-0.7284542918205261,
-0.10604376345872879,
0.5076643824577332,
-0.19699203968048096,
0.030265124514698982,
0.7047289609909058,
0.6515678763389587,
-0.008173863403499126,
0.017903104424476624,
-0.023343950510025024,
-0.0071600209921598434,
0.4737975597381592,
0.7135590314865112,
0.8885567784309387,
-0.3661622703075409,
0.7209124565124512,
-0.07571686059236526,
0.0889698788523674,
-0.373161256313324,
-0.8338768482208252,
-0.979172945022583,
-0.44271549582481384,
-0.10840632766485214,
-0.4464227259159088,
0.047684237360954285,
1.1633490324020386,
0.5109800100326538,
-0.9024243950843811,
-0.2387964427471161,
-0.15466076135635376,
0.06667198240756989,
-0.12845680117607117,
-0.20354396104812622,
0.3922629654407501,
-1.0417975187301636,
-0.8415716290473938,
0.49287891387939453,
0.11006385833024979,
0.008182182908058167,
-0.1406700164079666,
-0.176357239484787,
-0.37003132700920105,
0.28606700897216797,
0.636997401714325,
0.18443410098552704,
-0.6559175252914429,
-0.5287914872169495,
0.0005526911118067801,
-0.4245624840259552,
0.06121314689517021,
0.8496608734130859,
-1.0300357341766357,
0.08095773309469223,
0.35436442494392395,
1.0190902948379517,
0.38013437390327454,
0.18428421020507812,
0.3098275363445282,
-0.8592256307601929,
-0.06859436631202698,
0.1788022518157959,
0.3039018511772156,
0.5476158857345581,
-0.16342639923095703,
0.6606743335723877,
0.01994692161679268,
-0.807007372379303,
-1.043325424194336,
-0.08357484638690948,
-0.8866998553276062,
-0.4030061960220337,
1.537542700767517,
-0.1919979602098465,
-0.13415829837322235,
-0.038788918405771255,
-0.10589544475078583,
0.05622103065252304,
-0.4219530522823334,
0.9355457425117493,
0.7793063521385193,
0.11357318609952927,
0.23710934817790985,
-0.35612866282463074,
0.5556746125221252,
0.5267329812049866,
-1.042755365371704,
0.33894413709640503,
0.3846859931945801,
0.35413166880607605,
0.2110266089439392,
0.5403804779052734,
-0.08649619668722153,
0.26818764209747314,
-0.18296539783477783,
-0.10349775850772858,
-0.30037611722946167,
-0.2926706373691559,
-0.2518882751464844,
0.4235149621963501,
0.6280584335327148,
0.09100989997386932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04253v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04253v1 | AnyTool: Self-Reflective, Hierarchical Agents for Large-Scale API Calls | 2024-02-06T18:59:57 | 2024-02-06T18:59:57 | Yu Du, Fangyun Wei, Hongyang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce AnyTool, a large language model agent designed to revolutionize
the utilization of a vast array of tools in addressing user queries. We utilize
over 16,000 APIs from Rapid API, operating under the assumption that a subset
of these APIs could potentially resolve the queries. AnyTool primarily
incorporates three elements: an API retriever with a hierarchical structure, a
solver aimed at resolving user queries using a selected set of API candidates,
and a self-reflection mechanism, which re-activates AnyTool if the initial
solution proves impracticable. AnyTool is powered by the function calling
feature of GPT-4, eliminating the need for training external modules. We also
revisit the evaluation protocol introduced by previous works and identify a
limitation in this protocol that leads to an artificially high pass rate. By
revising the evaluation protocol to better reflect practical application
scenarios, we introduce an additional benchmark, termed AnyToolBench.
Experiments across various datasets demonstrate the superiority of our AnyTool
over strong baselines such as ToolLLM and a GPT-4 variant tailored for tool
utilization. For instance, AnyTool outperforms ToolLLM by +35.4% in terms of
average pass rate on ToolBench. Code will be available at
https://github.com/dyabel/AnyTool. | [
-0.2504829466342926,
-0.6585413217544556,
0.528480589389801,
0.3410598635673523,
0.038062624633312225,
0.23390431702136993,
0.027324452996253967,
-0.7250189781188965,
0.17537812888622284,
0.8282154202461243,
-0.27998724579811096,
-0.6254076361656189,
0.0556633360683918,
0.18978112936019897,
-0.5710402727127075,
0.754447340965271,
0.4329892694950104,
-0.21244177222251892,
0.02954804338514805,
-0.1919715702533722,
-0.4056633412837982,
-0.3356361389160156,
-0.9228923320770264,
-0.47281160950660706,
0.5716798901557922,
0.1754109412431717,
0.8351301550865173,
0.8422654867172241,
0.2605229318141937,
0.49413755536079407,
0.45739665627479553,
-0.29971936345100403,
-0.15320992469787598,
0.44282200932502747,
-0.3247464895248413,
-0.6449540853500366,
-0.7318924069404602,
0.02792266197502613,
0.360025554895401,
0.5790719389915466,
-0.37822747230529785,
0.29649993777275085,
-0.26601460576057434,
0.4991912841796875,
-0.6594371199607849,
0.20989494025707245,
-0.6791955232620239,
0.2180943787097931,
-0.17858359217643738,
-0.4387069642543793,
-0.54539555311203,
-0.4325439929962158,
0.42140740156173706,
-0.5872035026550293,
-0.055052500218153,
0.12557069957256317,
0.2959651052951813,
0.30796918272972107,
-0.3271007537841797,
-0.20979361236095428,
-0.5223215222358704,
0.7558324933052063,
-0.6453655362129211,
0.45378047227859497,
0.23969678580760956,
0.602664589881897,
-0.11217194050550461,
-0.9879524111747742,
-0.23778307437896729,
-0.48093435168266296,
0.15582218766212463,
0.07632176578044891,
-0.08888527005910873,
0.13452748954296112,
0.1075696349143982,
0.15866605937480927,
-0.6982077956199646,
-0.11744014918804169,
0.008821493946015835,
-0.22154057025909424,
0.5270506143569946,
0.43101853132247925,
0.32510051131248474,
-0.2589694559574127,
-0.3379608988761902,
-0.026842808350920677,
-0.39380455017089844,
-0.03499680384993553,
0.025689786300063133,
0.6055387854576111,
0.18487727642059326,
0.27626535296440125,
-0.03679809346795082,
0.6946079134941101,
-0.07929986715316772,
-0.21414485573768616,
0.24571382999420166,
-0.14492064714431763,
-0.3191351294517517,
-0.03154190629720688,
0.7885441184043884,
0.01601307839155197,
0.09300051629543304,
-0.395389586687088,
-0.5979806780815125,
-0.4512604773044586,
0.7748629450798035,
-0.8815099596977234,
-0.1457083821296692,
0.33466264605522156,
-0.4950772225856781,
-0.27233901619911194,
-0.19302484393119812,
-0.9025864601135254,
-0.674181342124939,
-0.18919982016086578,
0.43917566537857056,
-0.23048104345798492,
-0.33730199933052063,
-0.1321650892496109,
0.14988115429878235,
0.5096176266670227,
0.24251292645931244,
-0.6120315194129944,
0.6872506141662598,
0.5223173499107361,
0.7462980151176453,
-0.08254917711019516,
-0.6677278876304626,
-0.4943600594997406,
-0.1026916578412056,
-0.6061972975730896,
0.9874618649482727,
-0.6172384023666382,
-0.7001335024833679,
0.09940081834793091,
-0.1391756534576416,
0.03149726986885071,
-0.6573032140731812,
0.432496577501297,
-0.6797512173652649,
-0.2804919481277466,
-0.20608042180538177,
-0.29069238901138306,
0.11483468860387802,
0.29712972044944763,
-0.7158832550048828,
1.1080049276351929,
0.3201269805431366,
-0.344442754983902,
0.2629323899745941,
-1.0382044315338135,
-0.3016115725040436,
0.2739720642566681,
-0.32891884446144104,
-0.29241499304771423,
-0.14003027975559235,
-0.09177890419960022,
0.05470497906208038,
-0.5039295554161072,
-0.2605360448360443,
-0.3854237496852875,
-0.23937411606311798,
-0.047207269817590714,
-0.16571922600269318,
0.8249013423919678,
0.33277997374534607,
-0.4161948561668396,
0.27910488843917847,
-0.6590214967727661,
0.2403029203414917,
0.15618936717510223,
-0.19293095171451569,
-0.17020227015018463,
-0.20103967189788818,
0.2192375808954239,
0.142703115940094,
0.33201202750205994,
-0.7310306429862976,
0.46726739406585693,
-0.22200463712215424,
0.43234723806381226,
0.9167106747627258,
-0.262094110250473,
0.5715028643608093,
-0.05877260863780975,
0.8043414950370789,
-0.6980106830596924,
0.5572887063026428,
-0.21508866548538208,
-0.3820644021034241,
-0.4009135365486145,
-0.20030280947685242,
0.3402251601219177,
0.359328031539917,
-0.6777988076210022,
0.3943859934806824,
-0.25911805033683777,
-0.5940520167350769,
-0.4853088855743408,
0.10124721378087997,
0.3048146963119507,
0.5673651695251465,
0.11677783727645874,
-0.19822077453136444,
-0.5307027697563171,
-0.7249881625175476,
-0.20152823626995087,
-0.4653570353984833,
-0.21603024005889893,
0.33417120575904846,
0.5252836346626282,
-0.13636258244514465,
1.1853742599487305,
-0.21147798001766205,
-0.5868293642997742,
-0.1533462554216385,
0.3015162944793701,
0.1338687688112259,
0.31164249777793884,
0.6839661002159119,
-0.6411153674125671,
-0.6324150562286377,
0.12396986782550812,
-0.7237440347671509,
-0.3945544362068176,
0.0922515019774437,
-0.29205748438835144,
0.3603403568267822,
0.39565372467041016,
-0.5033816695213318,
0.1214684545993805,
0.5389759540557861,
-0.327457457780838,
0.7985907196998596,
-0.15938395261764526,
-0.0003277586947660893,
-0.7937923669815063,
0.2261185199022293,
-0.41707849502563477,
-0.41608232259750366,
-0.49461695551872253,
0.09971301257610321,
0.08858099579811096,
-0.4708997905254364,
-0.45688584446907043,
0.901120126247406,
-0.2963904142379761,
-0.39318549633026123,
-0.3210143446922302,
0.17711645364761353,
-0.12494069337844849,
0.13521043956279755,
-0.2528907358646393,
0.9997782707214355,
0.8223202228546143,
-0.27550044655799866,
0.6493284702301025,
0.19289137423038483,
0.027208494022488594,
0.5132234692573547,
-0.6006064414978027,
0.4323352873325348,
0.44529080390930176,
0.45205044746398926,
-1.130792498588562,
-0.16059066355228424,
-0.00682406360283494,
-0.4409177303314209,
0.07992994040250778,
-0.413898229598999,
-0.8360176682472229,
-0.5185409188270569,
-0.6169320344924927,
0.26640576124191284,
0.4507315754890442,
-0.8562324047088623,
1.3845998048782349,
0.35334113240242004,
-0.06850240379571915,
-0.5236372947692871,
-0.494666188955307,
0.1841488927602768,
0.15842004120349884,
-0.4781571328639984,
0.023067308589816093,
0.02182527631521225,
0.13182087242603302,
0.23688843846321106,
-0.6791409850120544,
-0.295861154794693,
-0.1912972629070282,
0.2092965543270111,
0.21162815392017365,
-0.06044707074761391,
0.2117968648672104,
-0.42300400137901306,
-0.29599764943122864,
0.23433475196361542,
-0.6373029947280884,
0.6297610998153687,
-0.37395477294921875,
-0.42185351252555847,
-0.3545667231082916,
0.2853406071662903,
0.713493287563324,
-0.37149783968925476,
0.13987313210964203,
0.24328859150409698,
0.0895221158862114,
-0.3449774384498596,
-0.7720613479614258,
-0.0995895117521286,
-0.5658281445503235,
0.2885042726993561,
-0.8242733478546143,
-0.47642096877098083,
0.9160268902778625,
0.0023518078960478306,
0.3535875082015991,
0.15942731499671936,
0.4871693551540375,
0.3266768753528595,
1.4719467163085938,
0.7191724181175232,
-0.37312036752700806,
0.5289791822433472,
-0.2559763789176941,
0.05727453529834747,
-0.4438590109348297,
-0.11382313817739487,
-0.6102743148803711,
0.01910695806145668,
-0.7791992425918579,
-0.11745450645685196,
0.29733774065971375,
-0.4331047534942627,
-0.2967863976955414,
0.32995864748954773,
-0.6300221085548401,
0.6914457082748413,
0.5702821016311646,
-0.2712331712245941,
0.40877678990364075,
-0.3028394877910614,
0.006859472021460533,
0.4639546275138855,
-0.6266148090362549,
-0.46758440136909485,
1.1596174240112305,
0.1999506950378418,
1.0793942213058472,
-0.16604655981063843,
0.6604873538017273,
0.3694944679737091,
0.582223117351532,
-0.8590912818908691,
0.7053643465042114,
0.1791941225528717,
-0.9812639355659485,
-0.5506537556648254,
-0.5924139618873596,
-1.1599129438400269,
0.5657526850700378,
0.3198498785495758,
-0.8480692505836487,
-0.00041175202932208776,
0.07129555940628052,
-0.39107346534729004,
0.3866407573223114,
-0.7474576830863953,
1.0199354887008667,
-0.2581801116466522,
-0.30340784788131714,
0.19543862342834473,
-0.5575496554374695,
-0.015614612959325314,
-0.14037282764911652,
-0.0463704876601696,
0.07069277763366699,
-0.25233983993530273,
0.5641478300094604,
-0.45130348205566406,
0.7313241362571716,
-0.3597557246685028,
-0.3258874714374542,
0.35203659534454346,
0.41852784156799316,
0.5816245675086975,
0.017941530793905258,
-0.37386202812194824,
-0.1323445439338684,
0.44359487295150757,
-0.6994218826293945,
-0.83700031042099,
0.8006702661514282,
-0.6826338768005371,
-0.4991476237773895,
-0.3235929608345032,
-0.4595108926296234,
-0.0979427769780159,
0.49320054054260254,
-0.07700891047716141,
0.46362942457199097,
0.005614098627120256,
0.04601013660430908,
0.08081876486539841,
-0.001209233538247645,
0.30151158571243286,
0.9532278180122375,
-0.5387455224990845,
-0.0302738007158041,
1.0147695541381836,
0.17413842678070068,
0.025448346510529518,
0.008134122006595135,
0.2285923957824707,
-0.6841039657592773,
-0.30980372428894043,
-0.3659813106060028,
0.09984242916107178,
-0.7147635221481323,
-0.4113456606864929,
-0.5720345377922058,
0.02967514470219612,
-0.3271788954734802,
-0.1198904737830162,
-0.9924125671386719,
-0.17162378132343292,
0.5407960414886475,
0.12221217155456543,
0.1816823035478592,
0.6834772229194641,
-0.009578382596373558,
0.04310854524374008,
-0.6883086562156677,
0.19463106989860535,
0.5419018864631653,
0.7176578044891357,
0.07629384845495224,
-0.2080368548631668,
0.0035522549878805876,
-0.5753172039985657,
-0.33996230363845825,
-0.6454210877418518,
0.23695501685142517,
-0.016098733991384506,
0.5345839262008667,
0.5701777338981628,
0.3521101474761963,
0.5162542462348938,
-0.6533799767494202,
0.7386467456817627,
-0.20157849788665771,
-0.9095687866210938,
0.4668370187282562,
-0.35510173439979553,
0.2775975167751312,
0.6451902985572815,
0.12999150156974792,
-0.2991769015789032,
-0.7296346426010132,
-0.4698401093482971,
-0.9086079001426697,
0.6734771728515625,
0.24416960775852203,
0.22159932553768158,
0.08870508521795273,
0.3144187331199646,
0.15639083087444305,
0.11244066059589386,
-0.528129518032074,
-0.3075660467147827,
-0.3098001778125763,
0.29152193665504456,
0.2510238587856293,
0.18444779515266418,
-0.21448561549186707,
-0.00494821323081851,
0.21821747720241547,
-0.22236105799674988,
0.30871570110321045,
0.23924006521701813,
0.05015323683619499,
-0.1941772699356079,
0.5044010877609253,
-0.022635364904999733,
1.1528847217559814,
-0.5214025378227234,
0.16512417793273926,
0.18072736263275146,
-0.4589073359966278,
0.006637879181653261,
0.3162152171134949,
0.020253464579582214,
-0.05593131110072136,
0.31154873967170715,
0.05036633089184761,
0.042676717042922974,
-0.8726062774658203,
0.30156269669532776,
-0.13386021554470062,
-0.18421050906181335,
-0.34510567784309387,
-0.1873311996459961,
-0.3313758671283722,
0.3752245604991913,
0.7016209959983826,
-0.2083776593208313,
0.5754446387290955,
-0.7570559978485107,
0.20104889571666718,
0.22855937480926514,
-0.43665388226509094,
-0.4732077717781067,
0.606141209602356,
0.5747498869895935,
-0.39060717821121216,
0.5176498293876648,
-0.3622061312198639,
-0.5987431406974792,
0.43265393376350403,
0.5118210315704346,
1.0167747735977173,
-0.49007120728492737,
0.2941865026950836,
-0.07448119670152664,
0.142086461186409,
0.0701804906129837,
0.22163674235343933,
-0.21670496463775635,
-0.5339138507843018,
-0.6356798410415649,
-0.48726463317871094,
-0.7926030158996582,
0.09322982281446457,
-0.5088948011398315,
-0.2901155948638916,
-0.37487250566482544,
-0.17765551805496216,
0.11816413700580597,
0.2583938539028168,
-0.3744891285896301,
-0.052488572895526886,
-0.1561514437198639,
1.1367990970611572,
-0.5856831669807434,
0.799166202545166,
0.9525389671325684,
-0.5533159375190735,
-0.7307975888252258,
-0.018170392140746117,
0.2956533432006836,
-0.621440589427948,
0.6369351148605347,
-0.01956227235496044,
-0.4647708833217621,
0.0069555435329675674,
-0.477555513381958,
-0.5008746981620789,
0.9388865232467651,
0.38838937878608704,
0.024046342819929123,
0.002793213352560997,
0.1662217229604721,
0.6780033111572266,
-0.5538549423217773,
0.4691343903541565,
1.025334358215332,
0.6351883411407471,
0.010584655217826366,
-1.1218515634536743,
0.23689956963062286,
-0.39808934926986694,
0.08751153200864792,
0.25143948197364807,
-0.5830278396606445,
0.7241395711898804,
-0.045816075056791306,
-0.0008963456493802369,
0.417814165353775,
0.19453401863574982,
0.14043603837490082,
0.14795273542404175,
0.72715163230896,
0.2637260854244232,
0.5669204592704773,
0.09746593236923218,
1.5569761991500854,
-0.2906506061553955,
0.35905951261520386,
1.0915454626083374,
-0.5110241770744324,
0.7321794629096985,
0.29828697443008423,
-0.16584081947803497,
0.1568032205104828,
0.5989278554916382,
-0.07862725108861923,
0.27956509590148926,
0.06778405606746674,
-0.24836041033267975,
-0.2160123586654663,
-0.25033488869667053,
-0.33860668540000916,
0.5745879411697388,
-0.11506617814302444,
0.0773196816444397,
-0.5853666067123413,
-0.044267721474170685,
-0.31636297702789307,
-0.14046220481395721,
-0.22110000252723694,
0.5480159521102905,
-0.18274644017219543,
-0.362858384847641,
0.6290601491928101,
-0.3388240337371826,
0.27942854166030884,
-0.671675443649292,
-0.10027255862951279,
-0.4100334048271179,
0.2012833207845688,
-0.24068938195705414,
-0.716984212398529,
0.028773216530680656,
-0.165230393409729,
0.20563921332359314,
-0.2669837474822998,
0.6043738126754761,
0.08722143620252609,
0.02611512877047062,
0.8112094402313232,
0.520912766456604,
0.2214318811893463,
-0.4365675151348114,
-0.968878984451294,
0.031816281378269196,
-0.34628164768218994,
-0.5451964139938354,
0.2967800199985504,
0.7064240574836731,
0.0879695788025856,
1.1100594997406006,
0.5432705879211426,
0.11105317622423172,
0.27670836448669434,
0.5221004486083984,
1.0924432277679443,
-0.5468264222145081,
-0.3523218631744385,
-0.439226895570755,
0.2073681652545929,
-0.03576983883976936,
-0.18398788571357727,
0.8984236717224121,
0.814332127571106,
0.671443521976471,
-0.016241377219557762,
0.7477867007255554,
-0.18239809572696686,
0.4763597249984741,
-0.07236327975988388,
0.6616370677947998,
-0.727724552154541,
0.32323527336120605,
-0.2246008962392807,
-1.1650006771087646,
-0.3363271653652191,
0.5059221982955933,
-0.39463353157043457,
0.36459770798683167,
0.6448509693145752,
0.7699344158172607,
0.028775880113244057,
0.005892504006624222,
0.6619347333908081,
0.45414668321609497,
0.5229384303092957,
-0.011307374574244022,
1.0066055059432983,
-0.11592178791761398,
1.2262157201766968,
-0.1546783745288849,
-0.435071736574173,
-0.2068033218383789,
-0.3771154582500458,
-0.8251839280128479,
-0.22246165573596954,
0.1553121954202652,
-0.18575601279735565,
0.2761680483818054,
0.9257178902626038,
1.0210204124450684,
-0.6517608165740967,
-0.6069302558898926,
-0.17421464622020721,
-0.01921110972762108,
-0.19827310740947723,
-0.2728094160556793,
0.30806270241737366,
-1.0653735399246216,
-0.7682401537895203,
0.3445691168308258,
0.386813223361969,
-0.46848994493484497,
-0.3097725808620453,
0.1235014870762825,
0.16237960755825043,
0.1270773857831955,
0.8463925719261169,
0.6366288065910339,
-0.5402986407279968,
-0.3189224600791931,
-0.035683322697877884,
-0.11684912443161011,
0.2090524435043335,
0.9447934031486511,
-0.6715056300163269,
0.8197478652000427,
0.38047781586647034,
0.828033983707428,
0.57021564245224,
0.12046226859092712,
0.46674689650535583,
-0.7676897048950195,
-0.027546675875782967,
0.42601755261421204,
0.06549368053674698,
-0.1449836939573288,
-0.05699581280350685,
0.8100026249885559,
-0.3778141736984253,
-0.872260332107544,
-0.7865540981292725,
0.10332479327917099,
-0.8963155150413513,
-0.23640793561935425,
0.7461304068565369,
-0.14280341565608978,
-0.37688782811164856,
-0.3813546299934387,
-0.4285460412502289,
-0.13786077499389648,
-0.9781820178031921,
0.9595985412597656,
0.23291753232479095,
-0.7142100930213928,
-0.16203895211219788,
-0.8941914439201355,
0.3820716142654419,
0.38485661149024963,
-0.950240969657898,
0.30570611357688904,
0.24400608241558075,
0.38367024064064026,
0.5857848525047302,
0.9197360873222351,
-0.3899365961551666,
0.3772445619106293,
0.20101982355117798,
0.3330698609352112,
0.05405126139521599,
-0.28985968232154846,
-0.17738600075244904,
0.18007002770900726,
0.20633096992969513,
-0.18144510686397552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04251v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04251v2 | Linear-time Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding with Reference Aggregation | 2024-02-06T18:59:30 | 2024-06-03T09:33:14 | Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding is a text generation technique that has
been shown to improve the quality of machine translations, but is expensive,
even if a sampling-based approximation is used. Besides requiring a large
number of sampled sequences, it requires the pairwise calculation of a utility
metric, which has quadratic complexity. In this paper, we propose to
approximate pairwise metric scores with scores calculated against aggregated
reference representations. This changes the complexity of utility estimation
from $O(n^2)$ to $O(n)$, while empirically preserving most of the quality gains
of MBR decoding. We release our source code at https://github.com/ZurichNLP/mbr | [
-0.056936636567115784,
-0.4246462285518646,
0.6939152479171753,
0.07433760166168213,
-0.2831638753414154,
0.05192003771662712,
0.4609620273113251,
-0.29193222522735596,
0.005325119476765394,
0.4559081792831421,
-0.13388372957706451,
-0.34995388984680176,
-0.5424755215644836,
-0.21218062937259674,
0.06409039348363876,
1.134523630142212,
0.23031188547611237,
0.1517457365989685,
-0.008717365562915802,
-0.17553353309631348,
-0.08726853877305984,
-0.7453975081443787,
-0.7508723735809326,
-0.09527341276407242,
0.4957127869129181,
0.28991881012916565,
0.8614062070846558,
0.3473082184791565,
0.8325110673904419,
0.2580207884311676,
-0.07742001116275787,
0.061579737812280655,
-0.6087700724601746,
-0.42443355917930603,
0.01724286936223507,
-0.35869792103767395,
-0.5902215838432312,
0.008258024230599403,
0.928064227104187,
0.9119710326194763,
-0.16378788650035858,
0.301566481590271,
0.10410922765731812,
1.1599396467208862,
-0.8752965927124023,
0.23690804839134216,
-0.40334776043891907,
-0.11275926232337952,
0.21431292593479156,
-0.38472244143486023,
-0.7333184480667114,
-0.7245541214942932,
-0.06321690231561661,
-0.20537103712558746,
0.2330986112356186,
0.24432098865509033,
0.5326778292655945,
0.0378350093960762,
-0.6351608037948608,
0.11651142686605453,
-0.8222379088401794,
0.8891705870628357,
-0.42612963914871216,
0.13665242493152618,
0.5408245921134949,
0.44401559233665466,
-0.4526594281196594,
-0.3030957579612732,
-0.3655160069465637,
-0.028253383934497833,
-0.23987434804439545,
0.030574968084692955,
-0.505767285823822,
0.23773175477981567,
0.23353278636932373,
0.37934789061546326,
-0.3769192695617676,
-0.18760888278484344,
-0.8619593381881714,
-0.3049865663051605,
1.0219635963439941,
0.4374772906303406,
-0.18334609270095825,
-0.35641154646873474,
-0.38138464093208313,
-0.055201366543769836,
-0.5335645079612732,
0.4480859637260437,
0.40057894587516785,
-0.22221867740154266,
-0.15583951771259308,
0.4420340955257416,
0.006672972813248634,
0.6065465211868286,
0.10035927593708038,
-0.26103097200393677,
0.3364940881729126,
-0.3767595589160919,
-0.14041770994663239,
0.06200309470295906,
0.9015184044837952,
0.927460253238678,
-0.28877103328704834,
-0.32944053411483765,
-0.15170665085315704,
0.0024155681021511555,
0.32438158988952637,
-0.6065804362297058,
-0.47997623682022095,
0.13623911142349243,
-0.7607699632644653,
-0.26059675216674805,
0.12354934215545654,
-0.8761601448059082,
-0.019436033442616463,
-0.008400140330195427,
0.7770957350730896,
-0.736126184463501,
0.19823846220970154,
0.3713048994541168,
-0.28389692306518555,
0.4801179766654968,
-0.08145099133253098,
-0.47577619552612305,
0.5377807021141052,
0.3954976201057434,
1.065598487854004,
0.295184850692749,
0.3115898668766022,
-1.021085262298584,
0.04461689293384552,
-0.2918134927749634,
0.7125696539878845,
-0.19291578233242035,
-0.8601071238517761,
-0.2901224195957184,
-0.40398430824279785,
0.08243444561958313,
-0.24348437786102295,
0.6527273058891296,
-0.442184716463089,
-0.11342135816812515,
-0.15149007737636566,
-0.491659015417099,
-0.07188676297664642,
-0.20906585454940796,
-0.7703281044960022,
1.067541241645813,
0.36602136492729187,
-0.867278516292572,
0.21252678334712982,
-0.5270869731903076,
-0.39656132459640503,
-0.13972337543964386,
0.11696679145097733,
-0.5956311225891113,
0.44848641753196716,
0.34812504053115845,
0.6759941577911377,
-0.08201876282691956,
-0.005170048680156469,
-0.5898213982582092,
-0.42212384939193726,
0.6297995448112488,
-0.3662419021129608,
0.5857471823692322,
0.2854982912540436,
0.19442158937454224,
-0.23048293590545654,
-1.048514723777771,
0.12008769065141678,
-0.017131907865405083,
-0.3261614739894867,
-0.7214256525039673,
0.3852560818195343,
0.005740519613027573,
0.005647262558341026,
0.12861892580986023,
-0.573701024055481,
0.04186660423874855,
-0.40136682987213135,
0.4163345694541931,
0.8685312271118164,
0.2754606008529663,
0.5372685194015503,
-0.8486958742141724,
0.18923009932041168,
0.13003313541412354,
0.15216141939163208,
-0.058478839695453644,
-0.55088210105896,
-0.5002905130386353,
-0.1951221376657486,
0.18726477026939392,
0.5238234400749207,
-0.9644254446029663,
0.6713563203811646,
-0.6681773662567139,
-0.6454969048500061,
-0.7177104353904724,
-0.06923641264438629,
0.5931987762451172,
0.34813857078552246,
0.42224642634391785,
-0.23679640889167786,
-0.2966388761997223,
-1.025652289390564,
-0.07620628923177719,
-0.38045164942741394,
-0.07437562942504883,
-0.018789909780025482,
0.15133780241012573,
-0.04932486638426781,
0.9805868864059448,
-0.766001284122467,
-0.04242788627743721,
-0.1859578639268875,
0.25635871291160583,
0.5959811210632324,
0.7700310945510864,
0.7972612977027893,
-0.5549037456512451,
-0.4077564477920532,
-0.229924738407135,
-0.2986399233341217,
-0.08373156189918518,
-0.10294480621814728,
-0.42145663499832153,
0.22896085679531097,
0.348483681678772,
-0.2104424685239792,
0.3375457227230072,
0.9195333123207092,
-0.34915849566459656,
0.47017720341682434,
-0.6496449112892151,
0.22754068672657013,
-1.210452675819397,
0.22633112967014313,
0.3152994215488434,
-0.4208286702632904,
-0.7673393487930298,
0.005239505786448717,
0.05035186558961868,
0.09890186786651611,
-0.13038113713264465,
0.2507634460926056,
-0.4438042938709259,
0.049285318702459335,
-0.1236046850681305,
-0.08208797872066498,
-0.14155204594135284,
0.26980289816856384,
-0.24276284873485565,
0.8657846450805664,
0.13401412963867188,
-0.9280888438224792,
-0.0822838544845581,
0.16857798397541046,
-0.5274043679237366,
0.6720950603485107,
-0.5059728026390076,
0.3514038026332855,
-0.54607754945755,
0.11953499168157578,
-1.1300110816955566,
0.2157631367444992,
0.37085220217704773,
-0.496945321559906,
0.26667752861976624,
-0.292630136013031,
-0.3531738817691803,
-0.24485425651073456,
-0.5660623908042908,
0.5244266986846924,
0.7905062437057495,
-0.4660642743110657,
0.5119955539703369,
0.6651662588119507,
-0.356939435005188,
-0.5205314755439758,
-0.6711011528968811,
-0.18993961811065674,
0.10719247907400131,
-0.4922540783882141,
0.3521541357040405,
-0.48708435893058777,
-0.14815564453601837,
0.13360565900802612,
-0.2855001389980316,
-0.22219206392765045,
-0.24136656522750854,
0.22552897036075592,
0.40276405215263367,
-0.016864903271198273,
-0.2012469321489334,
0.4333578944206238,
-0.5898820161819458,
0.2816227674484253,
-0.25263044238090515,
0.13489487767219543,
-0.04584008455276489,
-0.11876808851957321,
-0.1468701958656311,
0.6348473429679871,
0.37214216589927673,
0.14944322407245636,
0.7386366724967957,
0.4709569811820984,
-0.30745795369148254,
0.18832902610301971,
-0.6803466081619263,
0.3110847473144531,
-0.5247513651847839,
-0.005361516494303942,
-0.589937150478363,
-0.9379222989082336,
0.4564130902290344,
0.2553092837333679,
-0.0006712751346640289,
0.538497805595398,
0.17556186020374298,
-0.4236939251422882,
1.0449072122573853,
0.5924147367477417,
-0.6558347344398499,
0.20349925756454468,
-0.2694665789604187,
0.26411759853363037,
-0.7525452375411987,
-0.38723528385162354,
-0.5826053023338318,
-0.40473636984825134,
-0.6167120337486267,
-0.5684773325920105,
0.923430860042572,
-0.010898469015955925,
0.0017239487497135997,
0.09212439507246017,
-0.1536187380552292,
0.5644068121910095,
0.7626310586929321,
0.6434125900268555,
0.30933353304862976,
0.2689879238605499,
-0.21228890120983124,
-0.19560843706130981,
-0.8928816914558411,
-0.33340054750442505,
1.2231404781341553,
0.18494153022766113,
0.7087792158126831,
0.4333331882953644,
0.7562387585639954,
0.5532819628715515,
0.3226511478424072,
-0.8220085501670837,
0.4383997619152069,
-0.26379305124282837,
-0.47217872738838196,
-0.0418204665184021,
-1.0581501722335815,
-0.9623842239379883,
0.2818608283996582,
-0.42013540863990784,
-0.7791852355003357,
0.35367485880851746,
0.4939539432525635,
-0.6330872774124146,
0.3869430124759674,
-0.5057079792022705,
0.5588486194610596,
-0.014669639058411121,
-0.23456597328186035,
-0.35855168104171753,
-0.7113243937492371,
0.49271756410598755,
-0.009857874363660812,
0.5963585376739502,
0.05787493661046028,
-0.08611452579498291,
0.6750860214233398,
-0.4335397481918335,
0.6247196793556213,
-0.23947450518608093,
0.20486022531986237,
0.17463533580303192,
0.3083370625972748,
0.5652987360954285,
0.0032966050785034895,
-0.2661036550998688,
0.18734437227249146,
0.43391022086143494,
-0.9432515501976013,
-0.4221644997596741,
0.3802037835121155,
-0.6598910093307495,
-0.3408145308494568,
-0.6954407095909119,
-0.40062814950942993,
-0.1465478241443634,
-0.09188748896121979,
0.2749636471271515,
0.336374968290329,
-0.4511812627315521,
0.22726771235466003,
0.581993818283081,
-0.09873396903276443,
0.3880522847175598,
0.34942638874053955,
0.031079286709427834,
-0.870186984539032,
0.7488116025924683,
-0.13824042677879333,
0.3447059094905853,
0.804825484752655,
0.1727626621723175,
-0.30987271666526794,
-0.6616307497024536,
-0.2376534789800644,
0.2123415172100067,
-0.5458375215530396,
-0.3717183470726013,
-0.5457317233085632,
-0.20004820823669434,
-0.06491401046514511,
-0.2887226343154907,
-0.08192679286003113,
-0.3185770809650421,
0.06539290398359299,
-0.18327514827251434,
0.3619884252548218,
0.39448806643486023,
-0.47545182704925537,
0.6406061053276062,
-1.5439926385879517,
0.2743970453739166,
0.06472618132829666,
0.4158375561237335,
-0.3413938879966736,
-0.46738046407699585,
-0.528197169303894,
-0.0015026904875412583,
-0.03758735582232475,
-0.8909233808517456,
0.31229230761528015,
0.16087843477725983,
0.6415109038352966,
0.5713898539543152,
0.3712023198604584,
0.7790582180023193,
-0.6073533296585083,
0.46471354365348816,
0.5202710628509521,
-1.0032882690429688,
0.1960606426000595,
-0.08216547220945358,
0.14996592700481415,
0.777061402797699,
0.5431219935417175,
-0.3722224533557892,
0.01729610748589039,
-0.5870403051376343,
-0.5518817901611328,
0.6595808267593384,
0.40941378474235535,
0.20549479126930237,
0.15981842577457428,
0.5575032830238342,
-0.0939490869641304,
-0.1880415380001068,
-0.4883199632167816,
-0.4208105206489563,
0.11965245753526688,
-0.2996005415916443,
-0.6590176224708557,
-0.7768827080726624,
0.14557375013828278,
-0.2774879038333893,
0.5872387886047363,
0.047117799520492554,
0.636231541633606,
0.2955648899078369,
-0.023821821436285973,
-0.25249817967414856,
0.28589341044425964,
0.12424557656049728,
0.09128715842962265,
-0.656737208366394,
0.21875029802322388,
0.19749251008033752,
-0.46222999691963196,
0.5522410869598389,
0.23722778260707855,
-0.20391908288002014,
0.16005562245845795,
0.04688210040330887,
0.5552462339401245,
0.6010184288024902,
-0.473708838224411,
0.5546616911888123,
0.024729765951633453,
-0.3856922686100006,
-0.30616986751556396,
0.12719477713108063,
-0.38339540362358093,
0.12602266669273376,
0.39275816082954407,
0.3085162341594696,
0.5131574273109436,
-0.32896313071250916,
0.33494383096694946,
0.27951550483703613,
-0.43049776554107666,
-0.3061090111732483,
0.5661998987197876,
0.1427346169948578,
0.11492694169282913,
0.3778633773326874,
-0.5323594212532043,
-0.2040870040655136,
0.22298473119735718,
0.4082409143447876,
0.7355282306671143,
-0.510675847530365,
0.04661392793059349,
0.7000634670257568,
0.6758448481559753,
-0.041711434721946716,
0.6023083329200745,
0.15974122285842896,
-0.7630648016929626,
-0.5048946738243103,
-0.6831827163696289,
-0.41798025369644165,
0.016875220462679863,
-0.7702504992485046,
-0.12165633589029312,
-0.6252105832099915,
-0.42091384530067444,
0.09779374301433563,
-0.2546563148498535,
-0.39440760016441345,
-0.004584127105772495,
-0.19968374073505402,
0.7802670001983643,
-0.6156259179115295,
0.7040619254112244,
0.5673059821128845,
-0.21271821856498718,
-0.4557074010372162,
-0.19209852814674377,
0.02200513891875744,
-0.4604111313819885,
0.32007721066474915,
-0.03686489537358284,
-0.3616432249546051,
0.07264943420886993,
-0.2538434565067291,
-0.9018030166625977,
1.0285624265670776,
0.26936236023902893,
-0.5370275378227234,
0.046374645084142685,
0.04227820411324501,
0.16024523973464966,
-0.03487938642501831,
-0.12304076552391052,
0.677895188331604,
0.2098420113325119,
-0.016746530309319496,
-0.612752377986908,
0.0011407213751226664,
-0.42840591073036194,
0.22890165448188782,
0.6044520139694214,
-0.3956533670425415,
0.5177773833274841,
-0.3517727255821228,
-0.21731887757778168,
0.19750811159610748,
0.6235518455505371,
0.09861568361520767,
0.5356352925300598,
0.4879700839519501,
0.41087865829467773,
0.5763491988182068,
0.12522312998771667,
1.181438684463501,
-0.4418613612651825,
0.2781832218170166,
0.7496830224990845,
0.06493386626243591,
1.060701608657837,
0.3434494435787201,
-0.6683777570724487,
0.3741455376148224,
0.39781951904296875,
0.1896689385175705,
0.5190227031707764,
0.024500254541635513,
-0.36782604455947876,
-0.24532878398895264,
0.5026087164878845,
-0.26010966300964355,
0.12197735160589218,
0.543300449848175,
-0.4870017468929291,
-0.002294762758538127,
-0.37849947810173035,
0.019218632951378822,
0.09251312166452408,
-0.6257184743881226,
0.697307288646698,
0.43096059560775757,
-0.29883822798728943,
0.35014110803604126,
0.3097672462463379,
0.5021767616271973,
-0.5629658699035645,
0.056851696223020554,
-0.06658856570720673,
0.3791784346103668,
-0.017820091918110847,
-0.6435012817382812,
0.42208415269851685,
-0.13879916071891785,
-0.3481298089027405,
0.1648535281419754,
0.6887712478637695,
-0.24246233701705933,
-1.017323613166809,
0.23947980999946594,
0.2910170257091522,
0.2746396064758301,
-0.02246219851076603,
-0.2743101716041565,
-0.45298609137535095,
-0.23375527560710907,
0.1804598569869995,
0.3407171964645386,
0.2015666514635086,
0.30677080154418945,
0.6509191989898682,
0.9221999645233154,
-0.08379195630550385,
0.19108930230140686,
-0.44861072301864624,
0.6899287104606628,
-0.8533159494400024,
-0.6244240999221802,
-0.8331456780433655,
0.5660285949707031,
-0.02067999169230461,
0.007823364809155464,
0.3810324966907501,
0.858330488204956,
0.7650734782218933,
-0.3730378746986389,
0.8860605955123901,
0.06299743056297302,
0.22637243568897247,
-0.9939273595809937,
0.5727757811546326,
-0.34066998958587646,
-0.04955516755580902,
-0.4454176723957062,
-0.8320783376693726,
-0.4954603314399719,
0.7976627945899963,
-0.24318934977054596,
-0.27973949909210205,
0.6110045313835144,
0.723051905632019,
-0.1770537942647934,
-0.1578776240348816,
0.5484245419502258,
-0.015624787658452988,
0.016965284943580627,
0.8647634983062744,
0.46334317326545715,
-0.6319666504859924,
0.7125949263572693,
-0.3418010473251343,
-0.47299644351005554,
-0.4948621690273285,
-0.96425861120224,
-0.7458124756813049,
-0.47322574257850647,
-0.2931743264198303,
-0.6069625616073608,
0.08420419692993164,
1.0748939514160156,
0.37981289625167847,
-0.7331932187080383,
-0.2844245433807373,
0.28522220253944397,
0.045828454196453094,
-0.5327274203300476,
-0.13531696796417236,
0.33820292353630066,
-0.2506483197212219,
-0.5082192420959473,
0.14252869784832,
0.3424205482006073,
0.06805714219808578,
0.08096466958522797,
-0.32587477564811707,
0.08052108436822891,
0.20674742758274078,
0.8845669627189636,
-0.035163406282663345,
-0.18653850257396698,
-0.41872987151145935,
-0.343197762966156,
-0.14783011376857758,
0.13468120992183685,
0.9567877650260925,
-0.4113937020301819,
0.45550718903541565,
0.6402988433837891,
0.6499624848365784,
0.5931028723716736,
-0.05210075154900551,
0.523208737373352,
-0.6495975852012634,
0.09250359982252121,
-0.04779675975441933,
0.6385814547538757,
-0.05240822955965996,
-0.3387863337993622,
0.43963849544525146,
0.47611236572265625,
-0.44640079140663147,
-0.40059298276901245,
0.1570412963628769,
-1.471921443939209,
-0.013005593791604042,
0.8601044416427612,
-0.17730730772018433,
-0.35161691904067993,
-0.250822514295578,
-0.3813113272190094,
-0.047564584761857986,
-0.6130475401878357,
0.8349376916885376,
0.41433170437812805,
-0.03070656768977642,
-0.21081207692623138,
-0.3952321410179138,
0.14121674001216888,
-0.011148381978273392,
-0.3455958366394043,
-0.30831632018089294,
0.8292936682701111,
0.4043942987918854,
0.09781928360462189,
1.0855786800384521,
-0.24484606087207794,
0.433589369058609,
0.2771623432636261,
0.03990645706653595,
0.05577835813164711,
0.015417158603668213,
-0.4405546486377716,
0.12440738081932068,
0.07272016257047653,
-0.3148341476917267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04249v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04249v2 | HarmBench: A Standardized Evaluation Framework for Automated Red Teaming and Robust Refusal | 2024-02-06T18:59:08 | 2024-02-27T04:43:08 | Mantas Mazeika, Long Phan, Xuwang Yin, Andy Zou, Zifan Wang, Norman Mu, Elham Sakhaee, Nathaniel Li, Steven Basart, Bo Li, David Forsyth, Dan Hendrycks | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Automated red teaming holds substantial promise for uncovering and mitigating
the risks associated with the malicious use of large language models (LLMs),
yet the field lacks a standardized evaluation framework to rigorously assess
new methods. To address this issue, we introduce HarmBench, a standardized
evaluation framework for automated red teaming. We identify several desirable
properties previously unaccounted for in red teaming evaluations and
systematically design HarmBench to meet these criteria. Using HarmBench, we
conduct a large-scale comparison of 18 red teaming methods and 33 target LLMs
and defenses, yielding novel insights. We also introduce a highly efficient
adversarial training method that greatly enhances LLM robustness across a wide
range of attacks, demonstrating how HarmBench enables codevelopment of attacks
and defenses. We open source HarmBench at
https://github.com/centerforaisafety/HarmBench. | [
-0.3790924847126007,
-0.6710469722747803,
0.26616090536117554,
0.4281848073005676,
0.14820744097232819,
0.3287738263607025,
-0.24409502744674683,
-0.5902407765388489,
-0.05369715392589569,
0.3878566324710846,
-0.8236484527587891,
-0.6312233805656433,
-0.5131328701972961,
0.24722974002361298,
-0.5157083868980408,
1.1320207118988037,
-0.0011739449109882116,
0.1182112842798233,
-0.14638856053352356,
-0.37185367941856384,
-0.5997317433357239,
-0.40985527634620667,
-0.622873842716217,
-0.3306885063648224,
0.3817305862903595,
0.2789963185787201,
0.749585747718811,
0.3149048089981079,
1.210692286491394,
0.4436858892440796,
-0.03311381861567497,
-0.43734192848205566,
-0.6024256348609924,
0.36251550912857056,
-0.1782347857952118,
-0.4445735216140747,
-0.43991973996162415,
0.2019302248954773,
0.3360777795314789,
0.6578922867774963,
-0.16153575479984283,
0.09221523255109787,
-0.23156411945819855,
0.5744507908821106,
-0.9853270053863525,
-0.2677268385887146,
-0.8214290738105774,
0.1659988909959793,
-0.13800641894340515,
0.14882709085941315,
-0.6137745380401611,
-0.25188881158828735,
0.053700488060712814,
-0.40176957845687866,
0.03147377818822861,
0.12429014593362808,
0.5840322375297546,
0.7188197374343872,
-0.03767961636185646,
0.07749800384044647,
-0.3729631304740906,
0.8992967009544373,
-0.4244192838668823,
0.2689589262008667,
0.37561342120170593,
0.7423623204231262,
-0.09548637270927429,
-0.5750939846038818,
-0.16724124550819397,
-0.6964459419250488,
0.01401738915592432,
0.2870878279209137,
-0.6755916476249695,
0.42935752868652344,
0.2442907840013504,
0.31242749094963074,
-1.040647029876709,
0.46274834871292114,
-0.21919333934783936,
-0.12560203671455383,
0.8552672863006592,
0.22184820473194122,
0.5833620429039001,
0.11482152342796326,
-0.8095152378082275,
-0.1813102811574936,
-0.5083861947059631,
-0.49030300974845886,
0.42320185899734497,
0.2514205276966095,
-0.14071056246757507,
0.40781936049461365,
-0.11595236510038376,
0.6500383615493774,
-0.08235488831996918,
0.2363530546426773,
0.2556065618991852,
-0.19571101665496826,
-0.44961798191070557,
-0.12337494641542435,
0.9762800931930542,
0.5880516767501831,
-0.010987142100930214,
-0.5514280200004578,
-0.37506741285324097,
0.31518155336380005,
0.8409437537193298,
-0.7193071246147156,
-0.5644207000732422,
0.5151373147964478,
-0.3577404320240021,
-0.7862909436225891,
0.0485411062836647,
-0.8972868323326111,
-0.7475429177284241,
0.032791588455438614,
0.2669244110584259,
-0.3639775812625885,
-0.05495298653841019,
-0.10227791219949722,
-0.6095703840255737,
0.2351388782262802,
0.17750221490859985,
-0.5728850960731506,
0.6137567162513733,
0.7277233600616455,
0.6296243667602539,
-0.8605188131332397,
-0.6664378046989441,
-0.7942214608192444,
-0.23165106773376465,
-0.3510664403438568,
0.6937740445137024,
-0.2724044919013977,
-0.4321475923061371,
-0.22813665866851807,
-0.18963469564914703,
0.12909244000911713,
-0.9424468874931335,
0.5851792693138123,
-0.7723692655563354,
0.016248948872089386,
0.0842008888721466,
-0.12429725378751755,
-0.14316417276859283,
0.5703769326210022,
-0.7897606492042542,
0.7001321315765381,
0.2615746855735779,
-0.8489013314247131,
0.6239382028579712,
-1.048406720161438,
-0.49898234009742737,
0.12022528797388077,
0.22903776168823242,
-0.6615198850631714,
-0.2248382568359375,
-0.15291640162467957,
0.342549204826355,
-0.389133483171463,
0.09680946171283722,
-0.7862502932548523,
-0.37531229853630066,
0.09273617714643478,
-0.378779798746109,
1.2503072023391724,
0.39135366678237915,
-0.6362469792366028,
0.8486667275428772,
-0.7055272459983826,
0.2820214331150055,
0.23719672858715057,
-0.3452051281929016,
-0.29480627179145813,
-0.1595143973827362,
0.12856203317642212,
-0.04030130058526993,
-0.0747823491692543,
-0.41949912905693054,
-0.13735447824001312,
-0.4722398817539215,
0.20595456659793854,
0.8640437722206116,
-0.1596706360578537,
0.45883291959762573,
-0.24134868383407593,
0.8624229431152344,
-0.5270125269889832,
0.41330593824386597,
0.468046098947525,
0.1838967651128769,
-0.6510058641433716,
-0.359190970659256,
0.16168095171451569,
0.6029800772666931,
-0.4902385175228119,
0.5047028064727783,
-0.0643705353140831,
-0.6895347237586975,
-0.2284298539161682,
0.18340682983398438,
0.6766996383666992,
0.08676081150770187,
0.44590574502944946,
-0.4639348089694977,
-0.8268750905990601,
-1.047499656677246,
-0.25347980856895447,
-0.3708189129829407,
-0.18012826144695282,
-0.09728065133094788,
0.6411907076835632,
-0.4517250657081604,
0.6995002031326294,
-0.2284490019083023,
-0.22663114964962006,
-0.5613272190093994,
0.010065224021673203,
-0.2564099133014679,
0.34882962703704834,
0.7260013818740845,
-0.7659149765968323,
-0.3541640043258667,
-0.3801608681678772,
-0.6593276858329773,
-0.31801632046699524,
-0.09247798472642899,
-0.17520707845687866,
0.26855483651161194,
0.5033722519874573,
-0.022967014461755753,
0.26159828901290894,
0.8491517305374146,
-0.38075733184814453,
0.7819498181343079,
0.33329346776008606,
0.19389398396015167,
-0.6268132328987122,
0.3216649293899536,
-0.19461742043495178,
-0.3996894955635071,
-0.36444219946861267,
0.5990391373634338,
-0.028818756341934204,
-0.1587199866771698,
-0.7579911947250366,
0.45200055837631226,
-0.15339575707912445,
-0.03965888172388077,
-0.1744764894247055,
0.26655203104019165,
-0.12393627315759659,
0.2326684147119522,
-0.261157363653183,
0.9296046495437622,
0.3508814871311188,
-0.6243236660957336,
0.8382453918457031,
0.1685759276151657,
-0.20590302348136902,
0.7719035148620605,
-0.9160109162330627,
0.04925098642706871,
0.3607591986656189,
0.21726155281066895,
-0.5875311493873596,
-0.31432831287384033,
0.32034945487976074,
-0.2791651487350464,
0.32532998919487,
-0.09565568715333939,
-0.32219696044921875,
-0.4082607328891754,
-0.6135488748550415,
0.30507200956344604,
0.37093549966812134,
-0.5717862844467163,
0.27662816643714905,
0.6851779222488403,
-0.07007668167352676,
-0.6906331181526184,
-0.7740404009819031,
0.3767327070236206,
-0.5220242738723755,
-0.48105159401893616,
0.41827717423439026,
-0.3858957588672638,
-0.7616892457008362,
-0.2679138779640198,
0.015549935400485992,
-0.4245058000087738,
0.6801897883415222,
0.5260463953018188,
0.20684482157230377,
0.17727679014205933,
-0.22342154383659363,
-0.6418437957763672,
-0.3822667598724365,
0.23635117709636688,
0.015398898161947727,
0.43782639503479004,
-0.4098929166793823,
-0.7234475016593933,
-0.17371748387813568,
0.26889753341674805,
0.6593478918075562,
-0.13703495264053345,
0.45903003215789795,
0.4460769593715668,
0.10049840807914734,
-0.4723820686340332,
-0.40296095609664917,
-0.17609329521656036,
-0.4887584149837494,
0.7338865995407104,
-0.035295020788908005,
-0.810649037361145,
0.3502363860607147,
-0.14936469495296478,
0.3105817437171936,
0.4596562683582306,
0.5392211675643921,
0.07237555831670761,
0.6789045929908752,
0.7245293855667114,
-0.281568706035614,
0.31881415843963623,
-0.03363560140132904,
-0.191608265042305,
-0.4325670003890991,
-0.03364464268088341,
-0.5687636137008667,
-0.3130951523780823,
-0.14885881543159485,
-0.1554405242204666,
0.4173453152179718,
-0.11656733602285385,
-0.5393268465995789,
0.45448288321495056,
-0.5954379439353943,
0.7889663577079773,
0.46688371896743774,
-0.11712202429771423,
0.13410994410514832,
-0.26663604378700256,
-0.08130074292421341,
0.034946225583553314,
-0.6772201657295227,
-0.4010806679725647,
0.8952091932296753,
0.5096936225891113,
0.7888166904449463,
0.3477144241333008,
0.6634846329689026,
0.3792891800403595,
0.5112484097480774,
-0.99811851978302,
0.8371379971504211,
0.0872640535235405,
-0.7701331377029419,
-0.293814480304718,
-0.4956503212451935,
-1.0039911270141602,
0.1833372563123703,
0.023870237171649933,
-0.4003622531890869,
-0.42950955033302307,
0.016316503286361694,
-0.393459290266037,
0.296354740858078,
-0.769092857837677,
1.0598193407058716,
-0.5000530481338501,
-0.38714319467544556,
-0.2638862431049347,
-0.7172051072120667,
0.4706794321537018,
-0.12065954506397247,
0.022278541699051857,
0.21891704201698303,
0.023468390107154846,
0.9720573425292969,
-0.4359886348247528,
1.0216500759124756,
-0.11759772896766663,
-0.11543991416692734,
0.1371574103832245,
0.6219446063041687,
0.35116666555404663,
-0.19484829902648926,
-0.37729260325431824,
0.15771298110485077,
-0.10383764654397964,
-0.18485109508037567,
-0.3193952143192291,
0.6032627820968628,
-0.4312925934791565,
-0.5469323992729187,
-0.46812838315963745,
-0.534271776676178,
-0.24981842935085297,
0.47951844334602356,
0.0005786774563603103,
-0.14898718893527985,
-0.8957703709602356,
0.23502467572689056,
0.30029115080833435,
-0.31641173362731934,
0.4947744607925415,
0.6794183850288391,
-0.08278758078813553,
-0.45531851053237915,
0.7279338240623474,
-0.4439396262168884,
0.5381837487220764,
0.1009894460439682,
-0.07594121992588043,
-0.1414744257926941,
-0.882061779499054,
-0.24666427075862885,
-0.20287556946277618,
-0.7183055281639099,
-0.5246530175209045,
-0.20079641044139862,
-0.05376404896378517,
-0.021261800080537796,
-0.38949885964393616,
-0.5550934076309204,
-0.2529836893081665,
0.28090181946754456,
-0.19387707114219666,
0.2543569505214691,
0.7422839403152466,
-0.10050976276397705,
-0.04005739837884903,
-0.6713972687721252,
0.1482534110546112,
0.23957814276218414,
0.6812793016433716,
-0.417366087436676,
-0.2392587512731552,
0.0035284985788166523,
-0.2347170114517212,
-0.561412513256073,
-0.8232201933860779,
0.3110012114048004,
-0.22407764196395874,
0.7005746960639954,
0.1930008977651596,
0.6111555099487305,
0.3898465931415558,
-0.305966854095459,
0.7147744297981262,
0.26039546728134155,
-0.8974347710609436,
0.7122165560722351,
-0.2852232754230499,
0.05142569914460182,
0.9815128445625305,
0.23242928087711334,
-0.17623552680015564,
-0.5811342000961304,
-0.7876491546630859,
-0.783905029296875,
0.65594482421875,
0.2548186182975769,
-0.19053150713443756,
0.16681428253650665,
-0.2063368856906891,
-0.048280779272317886,
0.050244200974702835,
-0.9143030047416687,
-0.20799654722213745,
0.14144736528396606,
-0.0874553918838501,
-0.015488679520785809,
-0.08175297826528549,
-0.6748862862586975,
0.29970109462738037,
0.5525085926055908,
0.056674353778362274,
0.09614172577857971,
-0.07209155708551407,
-0.2350272834300995,
-0.08560916036367416,
0.45144641399383545,
0.28977951407432556,
0.36616161465644836,
-0.15990214049816132,
0.28979700803756714,
0.8562372922897339,
-0.3293929100036621,
0.24183660745620728,
0.13969574868679047,
-0.056915633380413055,
-0.17284275591373444,
0.718588650226593,
0.46116700768470764,
0.27938738465309143,
-0.9987649917602539,
0.6189329028129578,
-0.019182562828063965,
-0.4671393632888794,
-0.17513202130794525,
0.4468604624271393,
-0.3922581076622009,
0.16455934941768646,
-0.13015098869800568,
0.36712804436683655,
0.19633840024471283,
-0.3034612536430359,
0.3481817841529846,
0.6681958436965942,
-0.7297571301460266,
-0.02355322428047657,
0.5612138509750366,
0.33539748191833496,
-0.18569301068782806,
0.3042820394039154,
-0.229051411151886,
-0.8806121349334717,
0.6977550983428955,
0.34196174144744873,
1.1072264909744263,
-0.23881711065769196,
0.1417066901922226,
0.08819812536239624,
0.4123094379901886,
0.15864992141723633,
-0.10259858518838882,
0.06440142542123795,
-0.27046987414360046,
-0.21733473241329193,
-0.5843910574913025,
-0.8405513763427734,
0.05111455172300339,
-0.42476341128349304,
0.21068760752677917,
-0.7329179048538208,
0.03943057358264923,
-0.28815096616744995,
0.0035520452074706554,
-0.31894510984420776,
0.0078096650540828705,
-0.0909423902630806,
0.9036428928375244,
-0.490524023771286,
0.1989934742450714,
0.7169292569160461,
-0.35712552070617676,
-0.5800281763076782,
0.10167311877012253,
0.6103530526161194,
-0.7251447439193726,
0.784019947052002,
-0.04220767691731453,
-0.32180657982826233,
-0.29944464564323425,
-0.5424206256866455,
-0.33607885241508484,
0.869204580783844,
0.4562521278858185,
-0.3953060805797577,
0.40413421392440796,
-0.09583406895399094,
0.30959630012512207,
0.09620831161737442,
0.30799493193626404,
0.4826805889606476,
0.6728651523590088,
0.11217034608125687,
-1.1071230173110962,
0.24359296262264252,
-0.17290674149990082,
-0.35223388671875,
0.07482936978340149,
-0.764820396900177,
0.32066842913627625,
-0.4872138798236847,
-0.34152933955192566,
-0.11200331151485443,
0.19442501664161682,
0.3445454239845276,
0.07288746535778046,
0.6486133337020874,
0.5933091640472412,
0.585904598236084,
-0.086629219353199,
1.182173252105713,
0.018456369638442993,
0.23936806619167328,
1.1579710245132446,
-0.311385840177536,
0.912196934223175,
0.23069573938846588,
-0.5856186151504517,
0.18012118339538574,
0.36105024814605713,
-0.38421767950057983,
0.3217967450618744,
0.6038181185722351,
-0.1168225109577179,
-0.22893697023391724,
0.08854479342699051,
-0.21362543106079102,
0.47425222396850586,
-0.1452254354953766,
-0.15950807929039001,
-0.4663419723510742,
-0.14912529289722443,
0.1851447969675064,
0.07090392708778381,
-0.01704503409564495,
0.920954167842865,
-0.07286419719457626,
-0.7674059867858887,
0.9897411465644836,
0.0965777263045311,
0.8869379758834839,
-0.6948609948158264,
0.1988046020269394,
0.13490304350852966,
0.32951104640960693,
-0.27271896600723267,
-0.8009418845176697,
0.6976003646850586,
0.23955093324184418,
0.0263996422290802,
-0.27112826704978943,
0.7352410554885864,
0.10192751884460449,
-0.008088517934083939,
0.6359531283378601,
0.201165109872818,
-0.03739337995648384,
-0.22601060569286346,
-1.083136796951294,
0.4617122709751129,
-0.021695654839277267,
-0.20927336812019348,
0.4286925494670868,
-0.05417989194393158,
0.19316068291664124,
0.9487900137901306,
0.6096252202987671,
0.03431385010480881,
-0.26170289516448975,
0.25389963388442993,
0.9475340247154236,
-0.5025341510772705,
-0.19309592247009277,
-1.1063355207443237,
0.4055461287498474,
-0.07765917479991913,
-0.015212967991828918,
0.8129811882972717,
0.4322582483291626,
0.8385217189788818,
0.0723540186882019,
0.8977176547050476,
-0.09381894022226334,
0.4097159802913666,
-0.3521243929862976,
1.1200261116027832,
-0.5182088613510132,
0.39924272894859314,
-0.634334921836853,
-0.7249688506126404,
-0.9227313995361328,
0.6634513139724731,
-0.232463076710701,
0.151081383228302,
0.812594473361969,
0.7603840827941895,
0.06598557531833649,
-0.006048716604709625,
0.36416172981262207,
0.359824001789093,
0.6675918698310852,
0.564393162727356,
0.8896139860153198,
-0.2642921507358551,
0.9645980596542358,
-0.12174303829669952,
-0.4158128798007965,
-0.20211954414844513,
-0.895145058631897,
-1.10446035861969,
-0.23329448699951172,
-0.3698543906211853,
-0.38037174940109253,
0.2838069200515747,
0.8778444528579712,
0.78423011302948,
-0.8338479399681091,
-0.06489606946706772,
-0.3896205723285675,
0.15660330653190613,
-0.1735556572675705,
-0.24404633045196533,
0.03557343780994415,
-0.5658738613128662,
-0.5414664149284363,
0.704460620880127,
0.2410643994808197,
0.18782848119735718,
-0.33644258975982666,
-0.18761226534843445,
0.2681437134742737,
-0.381154865026474,
0.47284436225891113,
0.3704957067966461,
-0.6319386959075928,
-0.1576867699623108,
-0.1920669674873352,
-0.2624111771583557,
-0.3017156422138214,
0.4677256941795349,
-0.6780627965927124,
0.21482916176319122,
0.3179306983947754,
0.825253427028656,
-0.3194214701652527,
-0.14063160121440887,
0.7998765110969543,
-0.4993986189365387,
0.15145088732242584,
0.6456711888313293,
0.18171419203281403,
0.0723189041018486,
-0.004964845255017281,
0.8271103501319885,
-0.03916380926966667,
-0.5536328554153442,
-1.0002533197402954,
0.227850541472435,
-0.9449267387390137,
-0.4395733177661896,
1.207642674446106,
-0.13263718783855438,
-0.013519900850951672,
-0.2995256781578064,
-0.36246585845947266,
-0.08711376041173935,
-0.2140946090221405,
0.7720564603805542,
0.45312684774398804,
0.1834937334060669,
0.027673283591866493,
-0.35931891202926636,
0.5607808232307434,
0.7344409823417664,
-1.0142732858657837,
0.4561561942100525,
0.5637525320053101,
0.2176601141691208,
0.12929996848106384,
0.3480050563812256,
-0.15683239698410034,
0.439239501953125,
0.09410130232572556,
0.20582842826843262,
-0.35778576135635376,
-0.4163864850997925,
-0.3201894462108612,
0.4577558636665344,
0.15988990664482117,
-0.06555246561765671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04247v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04247v4 | Prioritizing Safeguarding Over Autonomy: Risks of LLM Agents for Science | 2024-02-06T18:54:07 | 2024-06-05T06:13:09 | Xiangru Tang, Qiao Jin, Kunlun Zhu, Tongxin Yuan, Yichi Zhang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Meng Qu, Yilun Zhao, Jian Tang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Arman Cohan, Zhiyong Lu, Mark Gerstein | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Intelligent agents powered by large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated
substantial promise in autonomously conducting experiments and facilitating
scientific discoveries across various disciplines. While their capabilities are
promising, these agents, called scientific LLM agents, also introduce novel
vulnerabilities that demand careful consideration for safety. However, there
exists a notable gap in the literature, as there has been no comprehensive
exploration of these vulnerabilities. This perspective paper fills this gap by
conducting a thorough examination of vulnerabilities in LLM-based agents within
scientific domains, shedding light on potential risks associated with their
misuse and emphasizing the need for safety measures. We begin by providing a
comprehensive overview of the potential risks inherent to scientific LLM
agents, taking into account user intent, the specific scientific domain, and
their potential impact on the external environment. Then, we delve into the
origins of these vulnerabilities and provide a scoping review of the limited
existing works. Based on our analysis, we propose a triadic framework involving
human regulation, agent alignment, and an understanding of environmental
feedback (agent regulation) to mitigate these identified risks. Furthermore, we
highlight the limitations and challenges associated with safeguarding
scientific agents and advocate for the development of improved models, robust
benchmarks, and comprehensive regulations to address these issues effectively. | [
-0.16602016985416412,
-0.24873867630958557,
0.7626898288726807,
-0.03440230339765549,
0.322019100189209,
0.32284799218177795,
0.21710754930973053,
-0.872494101524353,
-0.2337387651205063,
0.7765463590621948,
-0.41040170192718506,
-0.3113619387149811,
-0.6468639373779297,
0.24992787837982178,
-0.0797041803598404,
1.0187257528305054,
-0.045188840478658676,
-0.09271971881389618,
-0.7761732935905457,
0.15413892269134521,
-0.2153068333864212,
-0.391825407743454,
-0.42542263865470886,
-0.3699890375137329,
0.8164805173873901,
0.21461446583271027,
0.8592568039894104,
0.7758035659790039,
0.8104950785636902,
0.4609012007713318,
-0.07285050302743912,
0.10047987848520279,
-0.3626473844051361,
0.42247527837753296,
-0.4031105041503906,
-0.5601488947868347,
-0.55206298828125,
0.19936621189117432,
0.5415259003639221,
0.4103248715400696,
0.14908979833126068,
-0.008829922415316105,
-0.11684198677539825,
0.30008605122566223,
-0.6319276690483093,
0.10681802034378052,
-0.5667341351509094,
0.13057038187980652,
-0.023946696892380714,
-0.560011088848114,
-0.3486805558204651,
-0.2599949538707733,
0.16603948175907135,
-0.5298197865486145,
-0.14802232384681702,
0.22824761271476746,
0.6579262614250183,
0.5891988277435303,
-0.5601472854614258,
0.0423545241355896,
-0.709405243396759,
0.9017812609672546,
-0.3826158344745636,
-0.13592159748077393,
0.3727925419807434,
0.2733100652694702,
-0.5498468279838562,
-0.6921989321708679,
-0.2700531780719757,
-0.4743100702762604,
0.12620361149311066,
0.016143832355737686,
-0.16336731612682343,
0.2689882516860962,
-0.02594258449971676,
-0.17574483156204224,
-0.4124297797679901,
0.34574124217033386,
-0.38856667280197144,
-0.4296495020389557,
0.8836662769317627,
0.408217191696167,
0.39912503957748413,
0.20288579165935516,
-0.5736086368560791,
-0.31582894921302795,
-1.0218029022216797,
0.21609215438365936,
0.6833415627479553,
0.3598194420337677,
0.28383669257164,
0.6150256395339966,
-0.07400289177894592,
0.1667293757200241,
-0.26970174908638,
-0.07804634422063828,
-0.03835563734173775,
-0.5908944010734558,
0.017959516495466232,
0.060466986149549484,
0.7098379731178284,
0.5029429197311401,
0.05815533176064491,
-0.20698758959770203,
-0.28365346789360046,
-0.11202416568994522,
0.6232439279556274,
-0.6466220021247864,
0.04196658730506897,
0.4973539710044861,
0.057121455669403076,
-0.6280124187469482,
0.19862426817417145,
-0.6065977811813354,
-0.6322828531265259,
-0.11342605948448181,
0.2885555624961853,
-0.11163225769996643,
-0.16761523485183716,
-0.1258699744939804,
0.0828779935836792,
0.045370373874902725,
0.26329851150512695,
-0.5141675472259521,
0.2634587585926056,
0.8808196187019348,
0.7447652816772461,
-0.2771763205528259,
-0.41385141015052795,
-0.12482644617557526,
0.47309166193008423,
-0.26910045742988586,
0.7837852239608765,
-0.16292914748191833,
-0.7613358497619629,
-0.21236617863178253,
0.07430215179920197,
0.12360454350709915,
-0.1850246638059616,
0.24963989853858948,
-0.5488694906234741,
-0.217655211687088,
-0.3826206624507904,
-0.326215922832489,
-0.08249153941869736,
0.04557041823863983,
-0.4887283444404602,
0.5748671293258667,
-0.08698812127113342,
-0.9120143055915833,
0.2566920816898346,
-0.6409721374511719,
-0.20140668749809265,
0.27672556042671204,
-0.1720518320798874,
-0.3884340524673462,
-0.3781287968158722,
-0.2687735855579376,
0.33584293723106384,
-0.082146055996418,
0.23543791472911835,
-0.46443629264831543,
-0.07322907447814941,
0.37558111548423767,
-0.30330005288124084,
0.7021997570991516,
0.294802725315094,
-0.23054306209087372,
0.7438002228736877,
-0.355559766292572,
0.22668373584747314,
-0.15892913937568665,
-0.00004228012767271139,
-0.3407991826534271,
0.18974287807941437,
-0.015455188229680061,
0.2957075834274292,
0.33996641635894775,
-0.4943952262401581,
-0.017131488770246506,
-0.2975464463233948,
0.5592009425163269,
1.2143771648406982,
0.25582098960876465,
0.6654744148254395,
-0.8508164882659912,
0.5370437502861023,
-0.23567624390125275,
0.6607612371444702,
0.1736888736486435,
-0.19613789021968842,
-0.16441459953784943,
-0.5144261121749878,
-0.07900397479534149,
0.7522870302200317,
-0.4800843298435211,
0.6045567393302917,
-0.0017514603678137064,
-0.6446533799171448,
-0.4251747727394104,
-0.021040841937065125,
0.3652278482913971,
0.27604666352272034,
0.0914328470826149,
-0.11076398938894272,
-0.1894320398569107,
-0.7949838638305664,
-0.06567550450563431,
-0.38039469718933105,
0.11338531970977783,
0.18233494460582733,
0.7042237520217896,
-0.5762555599212646,
1.2024668455123901,
-0.14117790758609772,
-0.09444741159677505,
0.1165027767419815,
-0.3361768126487732,
-0.18443845212459564,
0.6836525797843933,
0.42505794763565063,
-0.8548272252082825,
-0.08195380121469498,
0.2180042713880539,
-0.9559498429298401,
-0.07028397172689438,
0.12142280489206314,
-0.24719467759132385,
0.17819419503211975,
0.715473473072052,
-1.0474685430526733,
0.3198662996292114,
0.06835655868053436,
-0.27537670731544495,
0.6787786483764648,
-0.1954348385334015,
-0.08462638407945633,
-0.7035651206970215,
0.14502952992916107,
-0.20531710982322693,
-0.21581906080245972,
-0.7813485264778137,
0.30699801445007324,
-0.1089121624827385,
0.3241211473941803,
-0.7742911577224731,
0.6511462330818176,
-0.3306398093700409,
0.06966622173786163,
-0.5926832556724548,
-0.004243478644639254,
-0.060588885098695755,
-0.19178418815135956,
-0.06245630979537964,
0.6350183486938477,
0.6737123727798462,
-0.708865761756897,
0.2885299324989319,
0.0014499153476208448,
0.09694541245698929,
0.23887236416339874,
-0.8238649368286133,
0.1416807770729065,
-0.08273055404424667,
0.2886328101158142,
-0.30772536993026733,
-0.28280001878738403,
0.47903430461883545,
-0.22698257863521576,
0.5100588202476501,
0.22804924845695496,
-0.5655452013015747,
-0.2050965130329132,
-0.590130090713501,
0.1652919054031372,
0.2004709243774414,
-0.11808744072914124,
0.5852826833724976,
0.6768894791603088,
-0.5158066153526306,
-1.04719877243042,
-0.26534318923950195,
0.028441578149795532,
-0.5129388570785522,
-0.6973962783813477,
0.23859740793704987,
-0.13392378389835358,
-0.7532622218132019,
0.22541919350624084,
-0.4113632142543793,
0.3888699412345886,
0.5859386920928955,
0.749235212802887,
0.2839614152908325,
0.1302727460861206,
-0.039301805198192596,
-0.05577792599797249,
-0.4069083333015442,
0.3131108283996582,
-0.18940432369709015,
0.0677746832370758,
-0.4172714352607727,
-0.33633437752723694,
-0.2161083221435547,
0.4613463878631592,
0.6899311542510986,
-0.13258440792560577,
0.5489403009414673,
0.2123112678527832,
-0.2602337896823883,
-0.22556772828102112,
-0.1486573964357376,
-0.4898413121700287,
-0.591422438621521,
0.48223042488098145,
0.020602574571967125,
-0.8894309997558594,
0.5672228336334229,
0.023502282798290253,
0.2417055070400238,
0.2640550136566162,
0.5737446546554565,
-0.22861556708812714,
0.5611675381660461,
0.9398101568222046,
-0.11831367015838623,
0.2567073404788971,
-0.041818954050540924,
0.3063186705112457,
-0.5036449432373047,
-0.33329594135284424,
-0.46988645195961,
0.1103179082274437,
-0.8692967295646667,
-0.5231224894523621,
0.5234758853912354,
-0.44324836134910583,
-0.3167775273323059,
0.12128861248493195,
-0.5890825986862183,
0.7654504776000977,
0.6082145571708679,
-0.2118445485830307,
0.20864920318126678,
-0.361042320728302,
0.010137593373656273,
0.44474145770072937,
-0.5872974991798401,
-1.1005257368087769,
0.906781792640686,
0.5729566216468811,
1.1429808139801025,
-0.030847923830151558,
0.8718316555023193,
0.228469118475914,
0.2700899839401245,
-0.5283002853393555,
0.6691926121711731,
0.5240621566772461,
-0.7575545907020569,
-0.7117056846618652,
-0.3273142874240875,
-1.1162147521972656,
0.3875667154788971,
0.052139315754175186,
-0.770343542098999,
0.13378994166851044,
-0.10055512189865112,
-0.4559779465198517,
0.12417934834957123,
-0.3920873701572418,
0.4648878872394562,
-0.4886164963245392,
-0.6681951284408569,
-0.05511654168367386,
-1.1871590614318848,
0.30194520950317383,
-0.1240203008055687,
0.20657660067081451,
-0.37294888496398926,
-0.2100757658481598,
0.29322195053100586,
-0.25148463249206543,
1.1459685564041138,
0.017046039924025536,
-0.17179158329963684,
0.4069008529186249,
0.017604095861315727,
0.32518279552459717,
0.26035261154174805,
0.1283825933933258,
0.08179128170013428,
0.43702855706214905,
-0.39822468161582947,
-0.05585033446550369,
0.890848696231842,
-1.1642916202545166,
-1.1627707481384277,
-1.0343196392059326,
-0.8288061022758484,
-0.1630186289548874,
0.25093889236450195,
0.16393214464187622,
-0.326593816280365,
-0.1196032240986824,
0.026758262887597084,
0.8485302329063416,
-0.09952710568904877,
0.5027689933776855,
0.7509191036224365,
0.016941215842962265,
-0.19103780388832092,
0.8291482329368591,
0.115274578332901,
0.48069584369659424,
0.09223068505525589,
0.07577165961265564,
-0.3069694936275482,
-0.7886744737625122,
0.19540679454803467,
0.06634099781513214,
-0.797361433506012,
-0.4971291124820709,
-0.7143430709838867,
-0.32372140884399414,
-0.6160496473312378,
-0.1775972992181778,
-0.245148167014122,
-0.09654857218265533,
-0.4421038329601288,
-0.502960741519928,
0.4685503840446472,
0.7940067648887634,
-0.1416902095079422,
0.06260326504707336,
-0.5197075009346008,
-0.12936672568321228,
0.15643465518951416,
-0.15645456314086914,
-0.29474979639053345,
0.050861600786447525,
0.044139254838228226,
-0.1181347444653511,
-0.5155707597732544,
-0.48393064737319946,
0.5354363322257996,
-0.03401528671383858,
1.0737553834915161,
0.39390259981155396,
0.37461504340171814,
0.07101579755544662,
-0.5935945510864258,
0.54917973279953,
-0.07450229674577713,
-0.6696609258651733,
0.4333252012729645,
-0.43236640095710754,
-0.25907397270202637,
0.5400035977363586,
0.5429443717002869,
-0.23035122454166412,
-0.7299039363861084,
-0.45063212513923645,
-1.340274453163147,
0.5144802331924438,
0.28475964069366455,
-0.14543701708316803,
0.20835928618907928,
0.15241624414920807,
0.18699154257774353,
0.24221637845039368,
-0.7278901934623718,
0.14933784306049347,
-0.20931456983089447,
0.12300732731819153,
-0.14824041724205017,
0.13579653203487396,
-0.7623927593231201,
0.1779765486717224,
0.7074301838874817,
-0.22871720790863037,
0.029675500467419624,
0.44410043954849243,
-0.07041708379983902,
-0.20945124328136444,
0.2865290939807892,
0.7105754017829895,
0.24542315304279327,
-0.11681079864501953,
0.4153844118118286,
-0.13001850247383118,
-0.5048046112060547,
0.3935033977031708,
0.13729830086231232,
-0.3735544979572296,
-0.7483704686164856,
0.4381049871444702,
0.24848543107509613,
-0.11683999747037888,
-0.7474419474601746,
0.19379764795303345,
0.12237264215946198,
0.0011094305664300919,
-0.24270619451999664,
0.2843462824821472,
-0.09408212453126907,
0.41231605410575867,
0.34377431869506836,
0.3475480377674103,
0.0679847002029419,
-0.47219738364219666,
0.29753416776657104,
0.6757445931434631,
-0.05092262104153633,
-0.2995681166648865,
0.5220910310745239,
0.18197810649871826,
-0.12367260456085205,
0.02463134191930294,
0.04110780358314514,
-0.37078967690467834,
1.1253390312194824,
0.29854148626327515,
0.8532525300979614,
-0.445677250623703,
0.19908565282821655,
-0.3344115614891052,
0.8949207663536072,
-0.09126720577478409,
0.0870983898639679,
0.2375994324684143,
-0.7541815042495728,
0.008313536643981934,
-0.41295331716537476,
-0.7733584642410278,
-0.22317449748516083,
-0.30733346939086914,
-0.04462894797325134,
-0.6031563878059387,
-0.4697113037109375,
-0.015878543257713318,
0.2918885350227356,
-0.14431855082511902,
-0.22370149195194244,
0.013626855798065662,
0.7178638577461243,
-0.7793455719947815,
0.580759584903717,
0.582683265209198,
-0.17384715378284454,
-0.5308402180671692,
-0.12347616255283356,
0.3312797248363495,
-0.45462286472320557,
0.4776066243648529,
0.1835756003856659,
-0.509412944316864,
-0.260282039642334,
-0.7588376998901367,
-1.0130181312561035,
1.4838285446166992,
0.41116684675216675,
-0.35246387124061584,
0.22286848723888397,
0.18452802300453186,
0.721194326877594,
-0.39650848507881165,
0.040595389902591705,
0.34901347756385803,
0.7620058059692383,
-0.07694245874881744,
-0.7234671711921692,
0.13015198707580566,
-0.3028032183647156,
-0.08330980688333511,
-0.11817055940628052,
-0.7399213314056396,
0.731383740901947,
-0.4619383215904236,
-0.2764725089073181,
0.15183903276920319,
0.5561792850494385,
0.4089440107345581,
0.8278045654296875,
0.1348629891872406,
-0.016863584518432617,
0.8813460469245911,
0.025021713227033615,
1.211851716041565,
-0.2546115219593048,
-0.07884100824594498,
0.8088570237159729,
-0.8945487141609192,
0.4790835380554199,
0.7052903771400452,
-0.116073839366436,
-0.0797167643904686,
0.8465029001235962,
-0.06268830597400665,
0.6276566386222839,
0.3781415522098541,
-0.5335062146186829,
-0.08807142078876495,
-0.44151681661605835,
-0.14040222764015198,
0.11278441548347473,
0.43288543820381165,
-0.03701112046837807,
0.0028481120243668556,
-0.016832539811730385,
-0.07241459935903549,
0.06806311756372452,
-0.31132930517196655,
0.5314151048660278,
0.2333770990371704,
-0.5280612707138062,
-0.24620966613292694,
-0.21524150669574738,
0.4931589365005493,
-0.6581636667251587,
0.2915292978286743,
0.037266314029693604,
0.06770489364862442,
-0.28680485486984253,
-0.8732222318649292,
0.313211590051651,
-0.11237525194883347,
-0.09618678689002991,
-0.4398902654647827,
0.806293785572052,
-0.1294882595539093,
-0.17784687876701355,
0.3936031758785248,
0.4069027602672577,
-0.005972626153379679,
0.3485930860042572,
-0.41079309582710266,
-0.12121154367923737,
-0.49154195189476013,
-0.22351615130901337,
0.6024258732795715,
0.2979615330696106,
-0.5774450302124023,
1.1975771188735962,
0.6274507641792297,
0.12129274010658264,
0.14780502021312714,
-0.2053721845149994,
0.9074378609657288,
-0.39445462822914124,
-0.37646761536598206,
-0.8632038235664368,
0.22452275454998016,
0.09512922167778015,
0.04793540760874748,
0.897487998008728,
0.0907772034406662,
0.4715282917022705,
-0.14070160686969757,
0.8467833995819092,
0.1347360908985138,
-0.053323496133089066,
-0.2687229514122009,
1.12112295627594,
-0.13969996571540833,
0.41020381450653076,
-0.21451283991336823,
-0.4788496196269989,
-0.42368683218955994,
0.35305696725845337,
-0.2385479211807251,
0.04512728378176689,
0.48417678475379944,
0.961409866809845,
0.6198588013648987,
-0.17731019854545593,
0.2894749045372009,
0.3192426860332489,
0.6625909209251404,
0.39073646068573,
1.2322102785110474,
0.24363826215267181,
0.19975772500038147,
-0.19375227391719818,
-0.1238158643245697,
-0.16410204768180847,
-1.155103325843811,
-0.9057377576828003,
-0.35448336601257324,
-0.4276987910270691,
-0.1582948863506317,
0.07597745954990387,
0.9552788734436035,
0.7372509241104126,
-0.7648240923881531,
-0.02052764594554901,
-0.13826848566532135,
0.5683310031890869,
-0.177734836935997,
-0.2326134890317917,
0.12454801052808762,
-0.19938455522060394,
-0.5243266224861145,
0.5229279398918152,
0.5555750131607056,
0.3746457099914551,
-0.3475256562232971,
-0.07626068592071533,
0.027828631922602654,
0.35664504766464233,
0.3210442066192627,
0.7387782335281372,
-0.7249167561531067,
-0.5541846752166748,
0.1342242807149887,
-0.46849921345710754,
-0.4516570270061493,
0.4992419183254242,
-0.3759687542915344,
0.1885213851928711,
0.32664841413497925,
0.604478120803833,
-0.15368549525737762,
-0.23711057007312775,
0.6706787943840027,
-0.5999135375022888,
0.0550278015434742,
0.876652717590332,
0.18874606490135193,
0.2582433819770813,
-0.9399994015693665,
0.6138668060302734,
-0.05468049645423889,
-1.0005146265029907,
-1.291140079498291,
0.2991812825202942,
-1.3102692365646362,
-0.15048491954803467,
1.0642759799957275,
-0.33108749985694885,
-0.3564416170120239,
-0.20163582265377045,
-0.19183121621608734,
0.0753120705485344,
-0.30503517389297485,
0.9158856272697449,
0.5473777055740356,
-0.3320167660713196,
0.08933112770318985,
-0.5981199145317078,
0.5784271359443665,
0.01188802532851696,
-0.9596514105796814,
0.0841175839304924,
0.20058149099349976,
0.3620568811893463,
0.33628731966018677,
0.31850966811180115,
-0.23244249820709229,
0.242820143699646,
-0.08740437030792236,
0.15827199816703796,
-0.29004669189453125,
-0.7086020112037659,
-0.3049769401550293,
0.11437378078699112,
0.07532472908496857,
-0.033803120255470276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04236v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04236v2 | CogCoM: Train Large Vision-Language Models Diving into Details through Chain of Manipulations | 2024-02-06T18:43:48 | 2024-05-22T17:10:29 | Ji Qi, Ming Ding, Weihan Wang, Yushi Bai, Qingsong Lv, Wenyi Hong, Bin Xu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have demonstrated their broad effectiveness
thanks to extensive training in aligning visual instructions to responses.
However, such training of conclusive alignment leads models to ignore essential
visual reasoning, further resulting in failures in meticulous visual problems
and unfaithful responses. Drawing inspiration from human cognition in solving
visual problems (e.g., marking, zoom in), this paper introduces Chain of
Manipulations, a mechanism that enables VLMs to solve problems step-by-step
with evidence. After training, models can solve various visual problems by
eliciting intrinsic manipulations (e.g., grounding, zoom in) with results
(e.g., boxes, image) actively without involving external tools, while also
allowing users to trace error causes. We study the roadmap to implement this
mechanism, including (1) a flexible design of manipulations upon extensive
analysis, (2) an efficient automated data generation pipeline, (3) a compatible
VLM architecture capable of multi-turn multi-image, and (4) a model training
process for versatile capabilities. With the design, we also manually annotate
6K high-quality samples for the challenging graphical mathematical problems.
Our trained model, \textbf{CogCoM}, equipped with this mechanism with 17B
parameters achieves state-of-the-art performance across 9 benchmarks from 4
categories, demonstrating the effectiveness while preserving the
interpretability. Our code, model weights, and collected data are publicly
available at https://github.com/THUDM/CogCoM. | [
-0.3979029655456543,
-0.7711264491081238,
0.5017275214195251,
-0.02863219380378723,
-0.2854859530925751,
-0.05624108761548996,
-0.08781492710113525,
-0.7135041356086731,
-0.1006770208477974,
0.7836851477622986,
-0.6150630116462708,
-0.3705718219280243,
-0.6012595891952515,
-0.29403844475746155,
-0.6076463460922241,
0.7553317546844482,
-0.30756744742393494,
0.19634750485420227,
-0.2869376540184021,
-0.17454656958580017,
-0.12094152718782425,
-0.6213271021842957,
-0.2050469070672989,
-0.15472976863384247,
0.5431692004203796,
0.2778624892234802,
0.805561363697052,
0.7662194967269897,
0.9548989534378052,
0.29247531294822693,
0.05570429190993309,
0.4749695062637329,
-0.7464527487754822,
-0.3309755027294159,
-0.2217749059200287,
-0.4885682761669159,
-0.4948982894420624,
0.046710703521966934,
0.15578371286392212,
0.9089455604553223,
-0.2324497103691101,
0.1872861087322235,
0.031186241656541824,
0.6274076104164124,
-0.7270998358726501,
0.28435033559799194,
-0.5889087915420532,
0.10763466358184814,
0.06335911899805069,
-0.12985286116600037,
-0.44076618552207947,
-0.1685710847377777,
0.1802198439836502,
-0.8587082028388977,
0.09338418394327164,
0.18212831020355225,
1.0281107425689697,
0.3239351511001587,
-0.26784566044807434,
-0.41012823581695557,
-0.637748658657074,
0.7047205567359924,
-0.3351738452911377,
0.22329315543174744,
0.19518424570560455,
0.6297770142555237,
-0.16219562292099,
-0.7709171175956726,
-0.34036609530448914,
-0.15219901502132416,
-0.1757100373506546,
0.1417538821697235,
0.06738685071468353,
0.2783011496067047,
0.6502439975738525,
0.31041276454925537,
-0.48117539286613464,
-0.10168308764696121,
-0.6373612284660339,
-0.030283993110060692,
0.7077431082725525,
0.41085684299468994,
0.4996158182621002,
0.3083272874355316,
-0.6826479434967041,
-0.09832601994276047,
-0.6156401038169861,
0.06220026686787605,
0.18570305407047272,
0.03583848476409912,
-0.16234607994556427,
0.7813757658004761,
-0.23826132714748383,
1.1477420330047607,
0.16215525567531586,
0.1273144632577896,
-0.16119545698165894,
-0.22725427150726318,
-0.45909571647644043,
-0.20572756230831146,
0.6209214329719543,
0.3265573978424072,
0.3370104432106018,
-0.1509542465209961,
-0.15509778261184692,
0.3374544382095337,
0.4409743845462799,
-0.6272328495979309,
-0.40981435775756836,
0.021879855543375015,
-0.22762417793273926,
-0.3979877829551697,
0.10738208144903183,
-0.6820607781410217,
-0.1726938784122467,
-0.8306506872177124,
0.5971774458885193,
-0.20224623382091522,
0.07069139927625656,
0.2981175482273102,
-0.008799085393548012,
0.2021683156490326,
0.6589587330818176,
-0.8923155069351196,
0.4014644920825958,
0.6950167417526245,
0.6179072856903076,
-0.18813222646713257,
-0.37896600365638733,
-0.928091287612915,
0.3172203004360199,
-0.38401052355766296,
0.4168398678302765,
-0.6538554430007935,
0.04358939453959465,
0.05329379439353943,
-0.08130782842636108,
-0.0747557282447815,
-0.5700791478157043,
0.21752244234085083,
-0.42577219009399414,
0.008723171427845955,
-0.22419428825378418,
-0.37129607796669006,
-0.28130200505256653,
0.4340786039829254,
-0.7176499962806702,
0.4839034378528595,
-0.0872945785522461,
-0.5660409331321716,
0.18572364747524261,
-0.45984888076782227,
-0.15942783653736115,
-0.0682167187333107,
-0.27513712644577026,
-0.4898744821548462,
0.30459141731262207,
0.29679441452026367,
0.2711603045463562,
-0.16625240445137024,
0.4476340711116791,
-0.6136684417724609,
-0.4859580993652344,
-0.12289951741695404,
-0.22760508954524994,
0.8237006664276123,
0.038851048797369,
-0.1820828914642334,
0.42785680294036865,
-0.8449078798294067,
0.025393111631274223,
0.03455927595496178,
-0.0013390443054959178,
-0.3087870180606842,
-0.11295239627361298,
-0.11941077560186386,
0.574115514755249,
0.2406124621629715,
0.05358293652534485,
0.5367603302001953,
-0.14662395417690277,
0.24387286603450775,
0.6795685291290283,
-0.38025039434432983,
0.43673667311668396,
0.17020218074321747,
0.39122241735458374,
0.09599699079990387,
0.5702356100082397,
-0.11749375611543655,
-0.1301671415567398,
-1.0187650918960571,
-0.1840035766363144,
-0.14005444943904877,
0.3801175355911255,
-1.1302860975265503,
0.2156665325164795,
-0.13468806445598602,
-0.4716927111148834,
-0.25360727310180664,
0.18841417133808136,
0.4259462058544159,
0.6422585248947144,
0.5016664862632751,
-0.47060278058052063,
-0.4742456376552582,
-0.7333259582519531,
-0.3086871802806854,
0.05440724641084671,
0.1882786750793457,
-0.030154848471283913,
0.5493535399436951,
-0.1369059830904007,
0.6999975442886353,
-0.5160648822784424,
-0.1270754635334015,
0.13607396185398102,
0.4772747755050659,
0.09790050238370895,
0.28310146927833557,
0.21511347591876984,
-1.0648564100265503,
-0.25835809111595154,
0.16408821940422058,
-1.1353245973587036,
-0.0849827453494072,
-0.14739276468753815,
-0.3091753423213959,
0.061181869357824326,
0.5854241251945496,
-0.4369756281375885,
0.7657790780067444,
0.6553260087966919,
-0.23617219924926758,
0.8585201501846313,
-0.2574615478515625,
-0.09900016337633133,
-0.5528496503829956,
0.07852444052696228,
-0.021556749939918518,
-0.35350945591926575,
-0.6336436867713928,
0.5434675812721252,
-0.060078635811805725,
-0.20225480198860168,
-0.49927014112472534,
0.2057337760925293,
-0.7864612936973572,
-0.039171360433101654,
-0.3683534860610962,
-0.012011297047138214,
-0.2145242840051651,
0.7970860600471497,
0.23491235077381134,
0.4145220220088959,
0.6108894348144531,
-0.6574510335922241,
0.6568426489830017,
0.15820086002349854,
-0.3030123710632324,
0.584930419921875,
-0.5346753597259521,
0.2062932848930359,
0.0679141953587532,
-0.1161903589963913,
-0.7361010313034058,
-0.2816714644432068,
0.5339328050613403,
-0.11947109550237656,
0.21626710891723633,
-0.2194155752658844,
-0.34895873069763184,
-0.488586962223053,
-0.07482796162366867,
0.3009551167488098,
0.31635573506355286,
-0.8962550759315491,
0.7238436937332153,
0.17181243002414703,
0.2950666546821594,
-0.5769141912460327,
-0.6177552342414856,
0.22825174033641815,
-0.00554694514721632,
-0.5984094142913818,
0.060310155153274536,
-0.08056493103504181,
-0.26130595803260803,
0.01528558786958456,
-0.20265771448612213,
-0.03070017881691456,
0.04916742816567421,
0.15206626057624817,
0.4004237949848175,
0.2800123393535614,
-0.02080059051513672,
-0.03365306556224823,
-0.22602903842926025,
0.07356998324394226,
-0.4010642468929291,
0.6018645763397217,
-0.15442006289958954,
-0.7434896230697632,
-0.22397716343402863,
0.09175887703895569,
0.5884239077568054,
-0.46015992760658264,
0.38087454438209534,
0.6017849445343018,
-0.29450175166130066,
0.13166014850139618,
-0.19134120643138885,
-0.05339904874563217,
-0.47521233558654785,
0.492470383644104,
-0.42004451155662537,
-0.8302608728408813,
0.34027767181396484,
-0.31832486391067505,
-0.1499941647052765,
0.015385718084871769,
0.6575722098350525,
-0.08066482841968536,
1.2728112936019897,
0.7418094873428345,
0.15087738633155823,
0.5412038564682007,
-0.3829715847969055,
0.24153603613376617,
-0.6464725732803345,
-0.16556023061275482,
-0.08350993692874908,
-0.36781397461891174,
-0.45961952209472656,
-0.6479769945144653,
0.5405418276786804,
0.33778250217437744,
-0.10763582587242126,
0.33639171719551086,
-0.43095359206199646,
0.2746940553188324,
0.5002477169036865,
0.19903221726417542,
0.305376261472702,
0.3469242751598358,
-0.030691972002387047,
0.07562101632356644,
-0.7722870707511902,
-0.35870155692100525,
0.7596487402915955,
0.11494573205709457,
1.2232840061187744,
-0.26197007298469543,
0.5029626488685608,
-0.2343239188194275,
0.2149050086736679,
-0.6988822817802429,
0.7472203373908997,
-0.14999885857105255,
-0.23472169041633606,
-0.31603050231933594,
-0.46351635456085205,
-0.6754216551780701,
0.35954442620277405,
-0.16707538068294525,
-0.7853164076805115,
0.2842743694782257,
0.47857582569122314,
0.09917884320020676,
0.40409570932388306,
-0.6919859051704407,
0.8198943138122559,
-0.6320136785507202,
-0.8906360864639282,
-0.3446796238422394,
-0.8037551045417786,
0.4709928631782532,
0.21066978573799133,
0.1271052360534668,
0.2917781472206116,
0.06508033722639084,
0.16927656531333923,
-0.874008297920227,
0.9316191077232361,
-0.07117480784654617,
-0.2803283929824829,
0.33455654978752136,
0.1781882643699646,
0.7682723999023438,
-0.2544335126876831,
0.4523865580558777,
0.2768406569957733,
-0.20235073566436768,
-0.5408836007118225,
-0.7610571980476379,
0.31118884682655334,
-0.41951167583465576,
-0.5672311782836914,
-0.38354453444480896,
-0.8028760552406311,
-0.08274238556623459,
0.1676117181777954,
0.13902875781059265,
0.528423547744751,
0.10974901914596558,
-0.09590405225753784,
0.4416172206401825,
-0.0915571004152298,
0.3528714179992676,
0.1256052851676941,
-0.6388845443725586,
-0.26730597019195557,
1.0636276006698608,
0.13324138522148132,
0.6529906988143921,
0.4021766483783722,
0.07740819454193115,
0.008476323448121548,
-0.42917463183403015,
-0.5741751194000244,
-0.1015300378203392,
-0.5845856666564941,
0.08718497306108475,
-0.3210684359073639,
-0.18968315422534943,
-0.06044631823897362,
-0.19490651786327362,
-0.19442729651927948,
-0.2772032916545868,
-0.1411808282136917,
0.04981095343828201,
0.10244808346033096,
0.541671097278595,
-0.050807613879442215,
0.19602267444133759,
-0.6600450873374939,
0.5256708860397339,
0.6842543482780457,
0.40857550501823425,
0.021308738738298416,
-0.21646632254123688,
-0.5448330640792847,
0.19945882260799408,
-0.32238221168518066,
-0.5044440627098083,
0.45732393860816956,
-0.1464255452156067,
0.16093237698078156,
0.35354819893836975,
-0.3184760510921478,
1.227368950843811,
-0.42359259724617004,
0.5325317978858948,
0.5378170609474182,
-1.0465302467346191,
0.5552929043769836,
-0.38497138023376465,
0.26137638092041016,
0.21252770721912384,
0.30393415689468384,
-0.46440088748931885,
-0.444399356842041,
-0.327159583568573,
-0.6968878507614136,
0.5176535844802856,
0.08588146418333054,
-0.21365171670913696,
0.470956414937973,
0.3591170608997345,
0.05690348148345947,
0.3905355930328369,
-0.4746795892715454,
0.0429382398724556,
-0.04666633531451225,
-0.3452991545200348,
0.18317966163158417,
-0.09013007581233978,
-0.29290300607681274,
-0.5257470607757568,
0.39676836133003235,
-0.3899823725223541,
0.05719851702451706,
0.22265374660491943,
-0.46427038311958313,
-0.3362530767917633,
-0.22134174406528473,
0.6960709095001221,
1.073941946029663,
0.10439779609441757,
0.30111366510391235,
-0.10899043083190918,
-0.5525342226028442,
0.008861144073307514,
0.023704512044787407,
-0.29526403546333313,
-0.3851570785045624,
0.5328893065452576,
0.9978373050689697,
0.11366759985685349,
-0.7089919447898865,
0.24600327014923096,
0.0519491583108902,
-0.2023872286081314,
-0.10515251755714417,
0.2127062827348709,
-0.20118485391139984,
0.230285182595253,
0.15187251567840576,
0.24594417214393616,
0.29474058747291565,
-0.5829310417175293,
0.13379070162773132,
0.4352518916130066,
-0.6679306626319885,
-0.4987712800502777,
0.7115241289138794,
-0.08086549490690231,
-0.16418839991092682,
0.6483917832374573,
-0.1794268637895584,
-0.6412146091461182,
0.5407951474189758,
0.2840486764907837,
0.4959678053855896,
0.01990027166903019,
0.18640409409999847,
0.34551215171813965,
0.3232819736003876,
-0.23463387787342072,
0.33746445178985596,
0.07863631099462509,
-0.5712282657623291,
-0.6390522122383118,
-0.2145516574382782,
-0.5023666620254517,
-0.13149218261241913,
-0.8723756670951843,
0.6386176943778992,
-0.36201125383377075,
0.3452897369861603,
-0.3535194993019104,
-0.26325228810310364,
-0.699701726436615,
0.37681540846824646,
0.3010193705558777,
0.8677680492401123,
-0.6953802704811096,
0.7901119589805603,
0.7783758044242859,
-0.6192564964294434,
-0.7307096123695374,
-0.24624501168727875,
-0.09125601500272751,
-1.0184348821640015,
0.5652428269386292,
0.17590630054473877,
-0.260309100151062,
-0.20811863243579865,
-1.352500081062317,
-0.6354231834411621,
0.9409688115119934,
0.5516222715377808,
-1.2182786464691162,
-0.03893323615193367,
0.16102640330791473,
0.6592150926589966,
-0.20470274984836578,
0.06810062378644943,
0.35350504517555237,
0.4118329882621765,
0.3331519067287445,
-0.8114843964576721,
-0.058464907109737396,
-0.23971690237522125,
-0.0877985954284668,
0.35325804352760315,
-0.8433107137680054,
0.7457671761512756,
-0.39556604623794556,
-0.012817038223147392,
0.14011888206005096,
0.5231835246086121,
0.303436815738678,
0.4559152126312256,
0.49347060918807983,
0.8886032104492188,
0.7096869945526123,
-0.23184217512607574,
1.0799431800842285,
-0.1195218563079834,
0.6930307149887085,
1.2592507600784302,
-0.2083876132965088,
0.594426155090332,
0.9115537405014038,
-0.03525153547525406,
0.33977118134498596,
0.29490023851394653,
-0.23378804326057434,
0.6008241772651672,
0.35373902320861816,
0.057398661971092224,
-0.5421547293663025,
0.009045913815498352,
-0.07356561720371246,
0.5422462821006775,
0.30810073018074036,
-0.2536839246749878,
-0.15488074719905853,
0.07784377038478851,
-0.3064383566379547,
0.042605865746736526,
-0.6274901032447815,
0.5974805355072021,
0.2189408242702484,
-0.5242081880569458,
0.5690720677375793,
-0.4522188901901245,
0.3156591057777405,
-0.48550257086753845,
-0.3892460763454437,
0.18509632349014282,
0.2648252844810486,
-0.11552024632692337,
-0.6063953638076782,
0.3384232223033905,
-0.21685032546520233,
0.015988778322935104,
-0.1216968223452568,
0.8986661434173584,
-0.636781632900238,
-0.6559363007545471,
0.2970690429210663,
0.39348968863487244,
0.01165820099413395,
-0.1231352910399437,
-0.5879828929901123,
0.3545261323451996,
-0.2277274876832962,
0.08226284384727478,
0.20674178004264832,
0.3683919906616211,
-0.31880319118499756,
0.6797592043876648,
0.5331047773361206,
0.08427932113409042,
0.19666890799999237,
0.18064625561237335,
0.8474553823471069,
-0.7103754281997681,
-0.2391456812620163,
-0.9319800138473511,
0.5743609070777893,
-0.27450913190841675,
0.017265187576413155,
0.5668805241584778,
0.5174124836921692,
1.0997587442398071,
-0.2776758372783661,
0.6048402190208435,
0.07285799086093903,
-0.16261234879493713,
-0.7117300629615784,
0.3645520508289337,
-0.6079848408699036,
0.042688045650720596,
-0.34544020891189575,
-0.72557133436203,
-0.5361128449440002,
0.5082029700279236,
-0.5872513055801392,
-0.14306962490081787,
0.5160161256790161,
0.6082889437675476,
-0.22799445688724518,
-0.028176456689834595,
0.4731162488460541,
0.23816467821598053,
0.5058934092521667,
0.8584306240081787,
0.9530319571495056,
-0.49406376481056213,
0.6589357256889343,
-0.3117530643939972,
-0.12495431303977966,
-0.40930673480033875,
-0.7818024754524231,
-0.9929568767547607,
-0.3034694194793701,
-0.3424346148967743,
-0.18038786947727203,
0.10194233059883118,
0.7072245478630066,
0.8976396322250366,
-0.610149621963501,
-0.3894472122192383,
-0.4969925284385681,
0.1763785481452942,
-0.6963175535202026,
-0.09712903946638107,
0.28631946444511414,
-0.3675730228424072,
-0.7130602598190308,
-0.11250520497560501,
0.6918027400970459,
0.03687768429517746,
-0.3984357416629791,
-0.13849909603595734,
-0.08832376450300217,
-0.30434226989746094,
0.8057555556297302,
0.15818734467029572,
-0.7893589735031128,
-0.3577992618083954,
0.04977671056985855,
-0.18511226773262024,
0.08533161878585815,
0.9269896149635315,
-0.5297111868858337,
1.0039433240890503,
0.46462708711624146,
0.43336236476898193,
0.7172952890396118,
-0.08062711358070374,
0.669367790222168,
-0.41023144125938416,
0.22114141285419464,
-0.07956936210393906,
0.356230765581131,
0.1840912252664566,
-0.2621791660785675,
0.7108765840530396,
0.34106966853141785,
-0.1766543686389923,
-0.7305900454521179,
0.4080222249031067,
-1.136682391166687,
-0.10124021768569946,
0.7668207883834839,
-0.07233206927776337,
-0.6039493083953857,
0.13760554790496826,
-0.487284779548645,
0.2688761353492737,
0.2208007425069809,
0.8598560094833374,
0.8024419546127319,
-0.17588387429714203,
-0.33357471227645874,
-0.30713748931884766,
0.21334174275398254,
0.2539590895175934,
-1.0400605201721191,
-0.045360904186964035,
0.4951954185962677,
0.003712792880833149,
0.23149824142456055,
0.11054474860429764,
-0.26222100853919983,
0.47831568121910095,
-0.095767080783844,
0.3440294861793518,
-0.2662760317325592,
-0.5324915051460266,
-0.49924424290657043,
0.18491633236408234,
-0.16145406663417816,
-0.2392091304063797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04232v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04232v2 | Can Generative Agents Predict Emotion? | 2024-02-06T18:39:43 | 2024-02-07T17:27:09 | Ciaran Regan, Nanami Iwahashi, Shogo Tanaka, Mizuki Oka | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated a number of human-like
abilities, however the empathic understanding and emotional state of LLMs is
yet to be aligned to that of humans. In this work, we investigate how the
emotional state of generative LLM agents evolves as they perceive new events,
introducing a novel architecture in which new experiences are compared to past
memories. Through this comparison, the agent gains the ability to understand
new experiences in context, which according to the appraisal theory of emotion
is vital in emotion creation. First, the agent perceives new experiences as
time series text data. After perceiving each new input, the agent generates a
summary of past relevant memories, referred to as the norm, and compares the
new experience to this norm. Through this comparison we can analyse how the
agent reacts to the new experience in context. The PANAS, a test of affect, is
administered to the agent, capturing the emotional state of the agent after the
perception of the new event. Finally, the new experience is then added to the
agents memory to be used in the creation of future norms. By creating multiple
experiences in natural language from emotionally charged situations, we test
the proposed architecture on a wide range of scenarios. The mixed results
suggests that introducing context can occasionally improve the emotional
alignment of the agent, but further study and comparison with human evaluators
is necessary. We hope that this paper is another step towards the alignment of
generative agents. | [
-0.64304119348526,
-0.6907141208648682,
0.672809898853302,
-0.007436392828822136,
-0.11909788846969604,
0.004475874826312065,
-0.13232676684856415,
-0.5722729563713074,
0.31486648321151733,
0.16756722331047058,
-0.52664715051651,
-0.40394327044487,
-0.4059585630893707,
0.2651286721229553,
-0.2226579189300537,
0.8903400301933289,
-0.1804349273443222,
-0.2867695391178131,
-0.20432907342910767,
-0.04748627543449402,
-0.40533000230789185,
-0.5661848783493042,
-0.6151214241981506,
-0.7422921061515808,
0.3621329367160797,
0.1361640989780426,
0.8230038285255432,
0.15774793922901154,
0.22369509935379028,
0.3610461950302124,
-0.13016609847545624,
-0.031111683696508408,
-0.3880032002925873,
0.3386261463165283,
0.05147992819547653,
-0.5646910071372986,
-0.6394710540771484,
0.10630439221858978,
0.3220803737640381,
0.035171639174222946,
-0.2795701026916504,
-0.450032114982605,
-0.15230019390583038,
0.4746263325214386,
-0.679094135761261,
0.17615333199501038,
-0.5542780160903931,
0.5763445496559143,
0.10050611943006516,
-0.7035223245620728,
-0.4758327305316925,
-0.14890477061271667,
0.2907666265964508,
-0.44706106185913086,
0.16067542135715485,
0.01458120159804821,
0.8465555310249329,
0.1897887885570526,
-0.7963804602622986,
-0.45094889402389526,
-0.5215153694152832,
0.39513805508613586,
-0.503240704536438,
0.16112084686756134,
-0.06796111166477203,
0.2989398241043091,
-0.10596486181020737,
-0.3592643737792969,
-1.0069372653961182,
-0.36794960498809814,
0.12575465440750122,
0.3420930802822113,
-0.39558708667755127,
-0.012160790152847767,
0.13834382593631744,
0.36440610885620117,
-0.3781909942626953,
0.051859233528375626,
0.04483164846897125,
0.1426413208246231,
0.5501928329467773,
0.648623526096344,
0.5461084842681885,
-0.3612384796142578,
-0.5803602933883667,
-0.22514593601226807,
-0.5063116550445557,
0.0026805689558386803,
0.23044253885746002,
0.1343209445476532,
-0.41106081008911133,
0.4980994462966919,
0.18209151923656464,
0.44859933853149414,
0.2301439344882965,
0.05308506265282631,
0.3839087188243866,
0.16587987542152405,
-0.3881739377975464,
0.3556941747665405,
0.6934489011764526,
0.5657548308372498,
0.538784921169281,
0.0827290490269661,
-0.11087458580732346,
0.4290553331375122,
0.6169161796569824,
-0.6449421644210815,
0.15692949295043945,
0.17372149229049683,
-0.39966073632240295,
-0.444467157125473,
-0.12156093120574951,
-1.0604044198989868,
-0.884803056716919,
-0.3881547451019287,
0.2458638697862625,
-0.5874613523483276,
-0.29791340231895447,
0.01330774836242199,
-0.02228698506951332,
0.6126400232315063,
0.471623957157135,
-0.9072800874710083,
0.2757122218608856,
0.7299326658248901,
0.6815850138664246,
0.09114062041044235,
-0.5765724778175354,
-0.21633122861385345,
-0.05091892182826996,
-0.40010395646095276,
0.8255918622016907,
-0.7641725540161133,
-0.28194892406463623,
0.2839949429035187,
-0.12231215089559555,
0.04096456244587898,
-0.3350394070148468,
0.23377114534378052,
-0.6640181541442871,
-0.02942494861781597,
-0.21060548722743988,
-0.46269360184669495,
0.056225135922431946,
0.29561853408813477,
-0.5800620913505554,
0.6590551733970642,
0.25532376766204834,
-0.5444850325584412,
0.4718237817287445,
-0.6882779002189636,
-0.3907313048839569,
-0.069758839905262,
-0.18617253005504608,
-0.1019194945693016,
0.4408339262008667,
-0.035583727061748505,
0.6004639863967896,
-0.3264128565788269,
0.1451728343963623,
-0.32033032178878784,
-0.11313371360301971,
0.6026333570480347,
-0.18843324482440948,
0.322223961353302,
0.30205675959587097,
-0.41375818848609924,
0.10371634364128113,
-0.36777573823928833,
-0.28529244661331177,
-0.0003844776947516948,
-0.16374419629573822,
-0.24049144983291626,
0.014309282414615154,
-0.03326817974448204,
0.37837257981300354,
0.0095295375213027,
-0.49041709303855896,
0.21521645784378052,
-0.34893473982810974,
0.14256569743156433,
1.0965237617492676,
0.08111139386892319,
0.5502283573150635,
-0.19018959999084473,
0.8518338799476624,
0.3169352412223816,
0.1259882152080536,
-0.23277050256729126,
-0.2820277214050293,
-0.7643135786056519,
0.1903308928012848,
-0.5013400912284851,
0.3030465841293335,
-0.4073661267757416,
0.34247785806655884,
-0.1772742122411728,
-0.40123650431632996,
-0.3625611364841461,
0.025525467470288277,
0.1910950392484665,
0.3471502363681793,
0.1111067458987236,
-0.2289627343416214,
-0.5984444618225098,
-0.5075662136077881,
0.015720171853899956,
-0.05075334757566452,
0.15929879248142242,
0.5368037819862366,
0.3752177357673645,
-0.43677428364753723,
0.940295398235321,
-0.4622608721256256,
-0.09303877502679825,
-0.19471943378448486,
0.37376195192337036,
-0.23334237933158875,
0.17048247158527374,
0.6078460216522217,
-0.7068397402763367,
-0.3737912178039551,
0.27826163172721863,
-0.9879374504089355,
0.06305710971355438,
-0.21431264281272888,
-0.07532922178506851,
0.3977852165699005,
0.28719598054885864,
-0.726771354675293,
0.4238848090171814,
0.6256584525108337,
-0.8038287162780762,
0.3855295777320862,
-0.16939043998718262,
0.2010088860988617,
-1.2441926002502441,
-0.31120094656944275,
0.06210671737790108,
0.20608274638652802,
-0.5195487141609192,
-0.34814706444740295,
0.01815345324575901,
-0.16494536399841309,
-0.48626795411109924,
0.8637192249298096,
-0.6616236567497253,
-0.31380173563957214,
-0.38389158248901367,
0.26251083612442017,
0.0518467016518116,
0.2928067445755005,
0.06618155539035797,
0.5147029757499695,
0.6098104119300842,
-0.44869065284729004,
0.6176823973655701,
0.3835049867630005,
-0.5491659641265869,
0.8924723863601685,
-0.14870895445346832,
0.21323642134666443,
-0.5337720513343811,
0.3728826940059662,
-0.7249717116355896,
-0.2145816534757614,
-0.07545414566993713,
-0.5243397355079651,
0.39148253202438354,
0.39192599058151245,
-0.22334901988506317,
-0.11659793555736542,
-0.09978475421667099,
0.32241448760032654,
0.6989015936851501,
-0.520045280456543,
1.0711065530776978,
0.11467486619949341,
-0.1545087695121765,
-0.47755226492881775,
-0.5483392477035522,
0.38301751017570496,
-0.385232537984848,
-0.5113552808761597,
0.1358998566865921,
-0.030166639015078545,
-0.6337564587593079,
0.19024334847927094,
0.2999568581581116,
0.09906826168298721,
0.1586391031742096,
0.6380742192268372,
0.16987237334251404,
-0.29682406783103943,
0.31643712520599365,
-0.02661254070699215,
-0.04842856526374817,
0.1821288764476776,
0.3341524302959442,
0.5981798768043518,
-0.4488189220428467,
-0.13292233645915985,
-0.5442385077476501,
0.3609347343444824,
0.7689527273178101,
-0.20244349539279938,
0.8355726003646851,
0.5550906658172607,
-0.3656757175922394,
-0.20527081191539764,
-0.5379928946495056,
-0.004202148411422968,
-0.4208240807056427,
0.35210955142974854,
-0.6487185955047607,
-0.8564847111701965,
0.6987431645393372,
0.04499928280711174,
-0.3516852855682373,
0.44810399413108826,
0.825446367263794,
-0.19357988238334656,
0.8985402584075928,
0.4972674250602722,
-0.2392040491104126,
0.5991929173469543,
-0.16783736646175385,
0.23129597306251526,
-1.3279578685760498,
-0.25188446044921875,
-0.1415805071592331,
-0.4468858540058136,
-0.5018903613090515,
-0.3760213851928711,
0.2529411315917969,
-0.11508391052484512,
-0.34612229466438293,
-0.09015011042356491,
-0.14800280332565308,
0.4281195104122162,
-0.054784029722213745,
0.013520256616175175,
-0.11794168502092361,
-0.19367188215255737,
0.14456449449062347,
0.14152181148529053,
-0.2898636758327484,
-0.7499504089355469,
1.0766152143478394,
0.35056594014167786,
0.7487489581108093,
0.24754056334495544,
0.6327529549598694,
0.46901899576187134,
0.9722099900245667,
-0.7125273942947388,
0.3736617863178253,
0.25546795129776,
-0.3556728959083557,
-0.20954051613807678,
-0.07238823920488358,
-1.122131586074829,
0.1286025196313858,
-0.1840972900390625,
-1.0609769821166992,
0.43652793765068054,
0.032001759856939316,
-0.2848018705844879,
0.26774919033050537,
-0.5747662782669067,
0.768767237663269,
-0.25005343556404114,
-0.33419328927993774,
-0.22551704943180084,
-0.5678333044052124,
0.31194034218788147,
0.04090941697359085,
-0.03626110032200813,
-0.1689465343952179,
0.006241754628717899,
0.40470242500305176,
-0.20419229567050934,
0.9878746271133423,
-0.13982060551643372,
-0.3497171998023987,
0.2696293890476227,
0.2432420551776886,
0.5483331084251404,
-0.16374342143535614,
-0.3762741684913635,
-0.3184553384780884,
-0.41998666524887085,
-0.21218812465667725,
-0.9592158198356628,
0.670276403427124,
-0.9769472479820251,
-0.524830162525177,
-0.45993515849113464,
-0.6039314270019531,
-0.12809735536575317,
-0.38396942615509033,
0.03861549124121666,
0.2562956213951111,
-0.5381969809532166,
-0.05836449936032295,
0.560172438621521,
-0.3824358880519867,
0.33988311886787415,
0.6485189199447632,
0.08305136114358902,
-0.17123109102249146,
0.4033348560333252,
-0.41073426604270935,
0.24774155020713806,
0.48572513461112976,
0.27441784739494324,
-0.17228297889232635,
-0.08889276534318924,
-0.04422331601381302,
-0.01972804218530655,
-0.8088318705558777,
-0.2370118647813797,
-0.5886399149894714,
0.008471895009279251,
-0.5609804391860962,
-0.59140545129776,
-0.20438683032989502,
0.3583327531814575,
-0.38580477237701416,
-0.4235224425792694,
0.5245251059532166,
0.8226460218429565,
-0.04008166864514351,
0.2540924549102783,
-0.5830104351043701,
0.04312022402882576,
0.4029857814311981,
0.21081282198429108,
0.39169755578041077,
-0.4348308742046356,
-0.07264666259288788,
-0.08903772383928299,
-0.28802624344825745,
-1.0522449016571045,
0.7443757653236389,
0.20572097599506378,
0.30834850668907166,
0.9348313808441162,
0.06500664353370667,
0.5006195306777954,
-0.4421284794807434,
0.7273989915847778,
0.07831300050020218,
-1.0925565958023071,
0.486101359128952,
-0.3536701202392578,
0.1532817929983139,
0.1961224377155304,
0.21847648918628693,
-0.6884366273880005,
-0.15920861065387726,
-0.6775175333023071,
-0.5902220606803894,
0.569759726524353,
-0.08672425150871277,
0.5418638586997986,
-0.3129117488861084,
0.6229243278503418,
0.03447708114981651,
0.08597780764102936,
-0.5752634406089783,
-0.1510440707206726,
-0.1369830071926117,
-0.29012608528137207,
-0.6655732989311218,
-0.6492014527320862,
-0.11308060586452484,
0.08778232336044312,
0.1591646522283554,
-0.1216094121336937,
0.5830400586128235,
0.10403613746166229,
0.03459121659398079,
-0.3975135385990143,
0.5052694082260132,
0.7333577275276184,
0.36861926317214966,
-0.3599123954772949,
0.3610982298851013,
0.16378901898860931,
-0.05477190390229225,
0.38751745223999023,
-0.16713634133338928,
0.36133256554603577,
-0.3607001304626465,
0.4808065593242645,
1.2222779989242554,
0.2334335595369339,
-0.7549155354499817,
0.6539555191993713,
-0.007933291606605053,
-0.12972398102283478,
-0.5193514227867126,
-0.028264179825782776,
0.07372807711362839,
0.6585631370544434,
0.17697952687740326,
-0.2411777377128601,
-0.038169559091329575,
-1.0405025482177734,
0.19182325899600983,
0.35802412033081055,
-0.5508253574371338,
-0.580594003200531,
0.4268377125263214,
0.22491995990276337,
-0.555798351764679,
0.6614816784858704,
-0.336530864238739,
-0.8041940331459045,
0.8144948482513428,
0.7105283737182617,
1.2516846656799316,
-0.5813239812850952,
0.24030634760856628,
-0.015476842410862446,
0.12956412136554718,
0.19756397604942322,
0.3278751075267792,
-0.13869187235832214,
-1.2644108533859253,
-0.08225526660680771,
-0.8509451150894165,
-0.36356988549232483,
-0.11062697321176529,
-0.7078385353088379,
-0.1787697821855545,
-0.17543697357177734,
-0.11497645080089569,
-0.2611295282840729,
-0.09131269156932831,
-0.852895975112915,
0.4192073345184326,
0.4473154544830322,
0.7127549648284912,
-1.2471212148666382,
0.6902137398719788,
0.6488138437271118,
-0.1599394530057907,
-0.7018148303031921,
0.06557557731866837,
0.21030886471271515,
-0.7605082392692566,
0.8425344824790955,
0.26618948578834534,
-0.050150394439697266,
-0.07550416886806488,
-0.06877367943525314,
-0.6923085451126099,
1.2029489278793335,
0.11101250350475311,
-0.22156831622123718,
0.12087806314229965,
-0.015970833599567413,
1.0338205099105835,
-0.7466344833374023,
0.34926003217697144,
0.4969789981842041,
0.37183067202568054,
-0.06338051706552505,
-0.45858433842658997,
0.24224507808685303,
-0.5999432802200317,
0.018853280693292618,
0.34660887718200684,
-0.6150220632553101,
1.073777675628662,
-0.4044511616230011,
-0.250995397567749,
0.023921269923448563,
0.727238655090332,
0.08028444647789001,
0.6126723885536194,
0.49396756291389465,
0.6651631593704224,
0.6437748074531555,
0.014157730154693127,
1.4381448030471802,
-0.25976985692977905,
0.13881656527519226,
1.141593337059021,
-0.8074659705162048,
0.860058069229126,
0.5255527496337891,
-0.12980712950229645,
0.8798057436943054,
0.6944578289985657,
0.10763979703187943,
0.25980430841445923,
0.4549078345298767,
-0.5822148323059082,
-0.1871291995048523,
-0.35874757170677185,
-0.2676773965358734,
0.6629821062088013,
0.2657212018966675,
-0.49204787611961365,
0.048344921320676804,
0.326300710439682,
-0.1608148217201233,
-0.09094509482383728,
-0.14260149002075195,
0.8556117415428162,
0.08858146518468857,
-0.5596040487289429,
0.09758251905441284,
-0.3208564519882202,
0.42320215702056885,
-0.3737790584564209,
0.1209498941898346,
-0.3617275059223175,
0.17628949880599976,
-0.11970590054988861,
-0.8207879066467285,
0.16643886268138885,
0.05098581686615944,
-0.10286775231361389,
-0.1878017783164978,
0.3826126754283905,
-0.22687862813472748,
-0.12239275872707367,
0.455810010433197,
0.4328271448612213,
0.20574818551540375,
-0.1319281905889511,
-0.2995414733886719,
0.1473110318183899,
-0.3043566644191742,
-0.6325482726097107,
0.47609779238700867,
0.748869776725769,
0.08244070410728455,
0.6735754013061523,
0.20947088301181793,
0.04302899166941643,
-0.019919555634260178,
0.13197875022888184,
0.5802899599075317,
-0.8915094137191772,
-0.4203914999961853,
-1.014833927154541,
0.48958879709243774,
0.13047464191913605,
-0.3946100175380707,
0.20255596935749054,
0.2958119511604309,
0.3781728148460388,
0.042306575924158096,
0.7130470275878906,
-0.13905088603496552,
-0.22482044994831085,
-0.5173932313919067,
0.4246913194656372,
-0.6649951934814453,
0.018400132656097412,
-0.5886098742485046,
-0.7758849859237671,
0.10606305301189423,
0.4717819392681122,
-0.33877798914909363,
-0.03440780192613602,
0.6863372325897217,
0.714154839515686,
0.38232505321502686,
0.06213854253292084,
0.36723655462265015,
0.37786781787872314,
0.32387685775756836,
0.9429705739021301,
1.2653652429580688,
-0.13897071778774261,
0.06745897233486176,
-0.02638443186879158,
-0.16050809621810913,
-0.2014712542295456,
-0.8640028834342957,
-0.6627993583679199,
-0.7462770938873291,
-0.0861433669924736,
-0.22228096425533295,
0.023647567257285118,
0.9125588536262512,
0.13262861967086792,
-0.45482173562049866,
-0.20132501423358917,
-0.17725913226604462,
-0.08016439527273178,
0.08834856748580933,
-0.3356076180934906,
0.4053336977958679,
-0.37008148431777954,
-0.8197529911994934,
0.3091217577457428,
0.5020606517791748,
0.4077583849430084,
-0.20909449458122253,
-0.33055153489112854,
0.02581034228205681,
0.16426795721054077,
0.7184531092643738,
0.10134213417768478,
-0.8349639177322388,
-0.46493420004844666,
-0.26067671179771423,
-0.279148131608963,
0.22257235646247864,
0.7886946201324463,
-0.6951912641525269,
0.6705466508865356,
0.2902206480503082,
0.5211905837059021,
0.3312475085258484,
0.017033535987138748,
0.9507014155387878,
-0.2860400974750519,
0.09279913455247879,
0.18138733506202698,
0.5021722912788391,
0.11519114673137665,
-0.5523560047149658,
0.27484825253486633,
-0.24900564551353455,
-0.3875443637371063,
-0.6583518981933594,
0.3391380310058594,
-1.102052092552185,
-0.03012363240122795,
1.0571815967559814,
-0.04027721285820007,
-0.13332010805606842,
0.3805272579193115,
-0.18976613879203796,
0.44842469692230225,
-0.42648741602897644,
1.1597483158111572,
0.6895970106124878,
-0.5937906503677368,
-0.3846224546432495,
-0.2404370903968811,
0.5711597800254822,
0.519034743309021,
-1.0395798683166504,
0.11460652947425842,
0.5664867162704468,
-0.11746743321418762,
0.11488443613052368,
0.5231209397315979,
0.13309918344020844,
0.24289582669734955,
0.0918283462524414,
0.38111957907676697,
0.1608976572751999,
-0.1262340545654297,
-0.48738059401512146,
0.3118045926094055,
-0.010565043427050114,
0.14317519962787628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04222v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04222v3 | What is "Typological Diversity" in NLP? | 2024-02-06T18:29:39 | 2024-06-16T07:51:41 | Esther Ploeger, Wessel Poelman, Miryam de Lhoneux, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CL | cs.CL | The NLP research community has devoted increased attention to languages
beyond English, resulting in considerable improvements for multilingual NLP.
However, these improvements only apply to a small subset of the world's
languages. Aiming to extend this, an increasing number of papers aspires to
enhance generalizable multilingual performance across languages. To this end,
linguistic typology is commonly used to motivate language selection, on the
basis that a broad typological sample ought to imply generalization across a
broad range of languages. These selections are often described as being
'typologically diverse'. In this work, we systematically investigate NLP
research that includes claims regarding 'typological diversity'. We find there
are no set definitions or criteria for such claims. We introduce metrics to
approximate the diversity of language selection along several axes and find
that the results vary considerably across papers. Crucially, we show that
skewed language selection can lead to overestimated multilingual performance.
We recommend future work to include an operationalization of 'typological
diversity' that empirically justifies the diversity of language samples. | [
-0.5483900308609009,
-0.2421921193599701,
0.1885320544242859,
0.6845022439956665,
-0.30230867862701416,
0.750137448310852,
-0.4121420383453369,
-0.7986745238304138,
0.49161896109580994,
0.2253354787826538,
-0.18856249749660492,
-0.5556047558784485,
-0.6663139462471008,
0.4832589030265808,
-0.2585403323173523,
1.2415398359298706,
0.3682844638824463,
-0.11954715102910995,
0.02442617155611515,
-0.44370755553245544,
-0.11616764217615128,
-0.8134681582450867,
-0.3228970468044281,
-0.26047784090042114,
0.5079389810562134,
0.14906920492649078,
0.7428382039070129,
0.3144264221191406,
0.2476927638053894,
0.26303061842918396,
-0.648482084274292,
0.21264366805553436,
-0.3300841450691223,
0.3318479061126709,
-0.4658832848072052,
-0.8432453274726868,
-0.10194642096757889,
-0.048433102667331696,
0.7631521821022034,
0.8796748518943787,
-0.23149965703487396,
0.26228418946266174,
0.05140922591090202,
0.9308485388755798,
-0.6924969553947449,
-0.14036692678928375,
-0.7055468559265137,
0.2784041464328766,
-0.6121696829795837,
-0.15967345237731934,
-0.14450523257255554,
-0.11285490542650223,
0.4142512381076813,
-0.4844663143157959,
0.4598787724971771,
0.2925785183906555,
0.37096112966537476,
-0.2627972960472107,
-0.2914796471595764,
-0.31344074010849,
-0.9137207865715027,
0.9154874682426453,
-0.3620558977127075,
0.2496621012687683,
0.370424747467041,
0.23928430676460266,
0.32936012744903564,
-0.3170495331287384,
-0.05295408144593239,
-0.2546069324016571,
0.12457694113254547,
0.19372279942035675,
-0.021856358274817467,
0.002235173713415861,
0.21141716837882996,
0.5505415201187134,
-0.6344635486602783,
0.09622206538915634,
-0.4678162634372711,
0.12361212819814682,
0.5583739876747131,
-0.05364736542105675,
0.5755320191383362,
-0.15869808197021484,
0.3761838376522064,
-0.012372392229735851,
-0.1651076078414917,
0.07357301563024521,
0.6839040517807007,
0.48343557119369507,
-0.12450044602155685,
0.6284986734390259,
-0.2229127436876297,
0.5606502294540405,
-0.4463810622692108,
-0.22994902729988098,
0.36449533700942993,
-0.46058985590934753,
-0.004365352913737297,
-0.28917670249938965,
0.5550271272659302,
0.19651201367378235,
0.45466721057891846,
-0.5591591000556946,
0.1080755740404129,
-0.2893260717391968,
0.2499997764825821,
-0.16720141470432281,
-0.0644901692867279,
0.1966618001461029,
-0.4286079704761505,
-0.46445146203041077,
-0.18187648057937622,
-1.3174023628234863,
-0.2590344548225403,
0.28300121426582336,
-0.46318480372428894,
-0.3507416844367981,
-0.4244506061077118,
0.23698319494724274,
-0.7292440533638,
-0.17523054778575897,
0.012037353590130806,
-1.0927222967147827,
0.1845075488090515,
0.8207359910011292,
0.9238687753677368,
-0.5002272129058838,
-0.6352360248565674,
0.07757780700922012,
-0.08018678426742554,
-0.4326403737068176,
0.9490816593170166,
-0.7924790978431702,
-0.5320623517036438,
0.1878805011510849,
-0.5274490714073181,
-0.24602200090885162,
-0.7195528149604797,
0.29324957728385925,
-0.2971903681755066,
0.564460813999176,
-0.2755236327648163,
-0.12589065730571747,
-0.16633549332618713,
0.2828817665576935,
-0.716930091381073,
0.8520092964172363,
0.21171315014362335,
-0.7968767285346985,
0.8800379633903503,
-0.3707026243209839,
-0.43561995029449463,
0.4372696876525879,
-0.14994697272777557,
-0.1889982372522354,
0.4549940824508667,
-0.11653406172990799,
-0.38632529973983765,
-0.2612345218658447,
0.2628176212310791,
-0.3973747193813324,
0.05096357315778732,
0.1272275149822235,
-0.16204215586185455,
0.9987828135490417,
0.20669114589691162,
-0.2637562155723572,
-0.2424582540988922,
-0.8691600561141968,
0.22547127306461334,
-0.13462868332862854,
-0.5490473508834839,
-0.5346528887748718,
0.13737346231937408,
0.15262308716773987,
0.3323720693588257,
0.012806876562535763,
-0.4081662893295288,
0.19262142479419708,
-0.5993894934654236,
0.320639967918396,
0.24671165645122528,
-0.2895297408103943,
0.5700615048408508,
-0.7377239465713501,
0.8991538286209106,
-0.5284413695335388,
-0.01979142613708973,
0.4053511619567871,
-0.9023839831352234,
-0.44081252813339233,
-0.24512173235416412,
0.32516565918922424,
0.5994479656219482,
-0.6417582035064697,
0.2152949720621109,
-0.21796837449073792,
-0.3964054584503174,
-0.42938271164894104,
0.317745178937912,
0.4041301906108856,
-0.2784668207168579,
0.3491766154766083,
-0.1826118677854538,
-0.644677460193634,
-0.8877230286598206,
-0.680895984172821,
-0.4963958263397217,
0.006048916839063168,
0.2764740288257599,
0.18334943056106567,
0.09312216192483902,
0.848143994808197,
-0.06965065747499466,
-0.2264413833618164,
-0.7245579957962036,
0.26690709590911865,
0.09979163855314255,
0.23734471201896667,
1.1490581035614014,
-0.6848409175872803,
-0.4914104640483856,
0.0882374569773674,
-0.3006983995437622,
-0.2946476340293884,
0.07127445191144943,
-0.06876792758703232,
0.43166276812553406,
0.199746772646904,
-0.44200798869132996,
0.12296730279922485,
0.8152205944061279,
-0.2392246127128601,
0.7633492946624756,
-0.12106797844171524,
-0.180303156375885,
-0.7909726500511169,
-0.12235787510871887,
-0.11934719234704971,
-0.014602047391235828,
-0.5790910124778748,
0.3863023519515991,
-0.36574769020080566,
0.041850849986076355,
-0.006834168918430805,
0.354765385389328,
-0.1324557214975357,
-0.048999786376953125,
-0.26560336351394653,
-0.08995489031076431,
0.08837621659040451,
0.22353661060333252,
0.09914340823888779,
0.45896273851394653,
0.433976411819458,
-0.3578338623046875,
0.09029466658830643,
0.10263287276029587,
-0.27887338399887085,
0.351945161819458,
-0.40764328837394714,
-0.3485676944255829,
-0.060909681022167206,
0.008048659190535545,
-0.883612871170044,
-0.053726695477962494,
-0.017881231382489204,
-0.255447119474411,
0.16966871917247772,
-0.47465890645980835,
-0.48651960492134094,
-0.40375909209251404,
-0.2286492884159088,
0.6457216739654541,
0.2508322298526764,
-0.2524242699146271,
0.4977453947067261,
0.4874129891395569,
-0.38342902064323425,
-0.5762258768081665,
-0.8511876463890076,
0.07889547199010849,
-0.2024829238653183,
-0.49805358052253723,
0.2313336282968521,
-0.08872213959693909,
-0.6126396656036377,
-0.20044761896133423,
-0.40753474831581116,
-0.27192091941833496,
0.0773482471704483,
-0.22803695499897003,
-0.10837530344724655,
-0.38286978006362915,
0.20636048913002014,
0.05242756009101868,
0.3285037577152252,
0.07079411298036575,
-0.6429229974746704,
0.8248354196548462,
-0.27860531210899353,
-0.2584588825702667,
0.3160516917705536,
0.5413668751716614,
0.39480164647102356,
-0.20751790702342987,
0.663220226764679,
0.3828030526638031,
0.026883313432335854,
-0.39953869581222534,
-0.5527963638305664,
0.49101534485816956,
-0.4107152819633484,
0.48336368799209595,
-0.1503143161535263,
-0.9291526079177856,
0.7193015217781067,
0.44157975912094116,
0.24762211740016937,
0.5815218687057495,
0.37605053186416626,
-0.12130800634622574,
0.7336523532867432,
0.6196919679641724,
0.03628956899046898,
0.5418480634689331,
-0.008926614187657833,
-0.002796206856146455,
-0.32518666982650757,
-0.3018839955329895,
-0.8896374702453613,
-0.21304190158843994,
-1.29091477394104,
-0.2806612253189087,
-0.1527647227048874,
-0.12681220471858978,
0.06253388524055481,
0.1838459074497223,
-0.4249940514564514,
0.4385908842086792,
0.5351545214653015,
-0.23770155012607574,
0.3948567807674408,
0.2039753645658493,
-0.31518328189849854,
-0.29089418053627014,
-0.8557474613189697,
-0.21288341283798218,
1.1502273082733154,
0.06282983720302582,
0.42032748460769653,
0.20057395100593567,
0.7763001918792725,
0.14438870549201965,
0.06285838037729263,
-0.4861775040626526,
0.2866266965866089,
-0.6473336219787598,
-0.9293506741523743,
-0.3559650182723999,
-0.48295822739601135,
-0.925532877445221,
0.732025682926178,
-0.5413164496421814,
-0.8979747891426086,
0.3027077913284302,
0.048974450677633286,
-0.1670360267162323,
0.4881240129470825,
-0.5173896551132202,
0.5469934344291687,
-0.33179420232772827,
0.11723314225673676,
-0.143530011177063,
-0.2645101845264435,
0.3392595946788788,
-0.16239425539970398,
0.41359999775886536,
-0.17802032828330994,
0.10078097134828568,
0.6228209733963013,
0.2037857472896576,
0.46936294436454773,
0.2314029484987259,
0.012738770805299282,
0.006966485641896725,
0.09084893763065338,
-0.11924821883440018,
0.27704593539237976,
-0.04253576695919037,
0.35631704330444336,
0.08677583932876587,
-0.5291486978530884,
-0.486142635345459,
0.2544173002243042,
-0.7233467102050781,
-0.6005958318710327,
-0.48110872507095337,
-0.7462967038154602,
-0.3957403004169464,
0.1959279477596283,
0.673575222492218,
0.29595044255256653,
-0.1848417967557907,
0.40308982133865356,
0.2594068944454193,
-0.49620792269706726,
0.3396013081073761,
0.14916835725307465,
-0.7135257124900818,
-0.39706698060035706,
1.0257899761199951,
0.3511612117290497,
0.45617496967315674,
0.5589269399642944,
0.2553303837776184,
0.04744705930352211,
-0.8506790995597839,
0.15798723697662354,
0.17657703161239624,
-0.4823330044746399,
0.33796027302742004,
-0.887842059135437,
-0.21922439336776733,
-0.3777305781841278,
-0.2666606307029724,
-0.36938798427581787,
-0.8596256971359253,
0.09779612720012665,
-0.05359932407736778,
0.04536445811390877,
0.5447948575019836,
-0.1002790555357933,
0.2643631100654602,
-0.5827982425689697,
0.5681301355361938,
0.381022572517395,
0.5647916197776794,
-0.26283589005470276,
-0.445892870426178,
-0.007585617713630199,
-0.14092756807804108,
-0.11085063219070435,
-0.6170915961265564,
0.5420374870300293,
0.25332459807395935,
0.9824638962745667,
0.11148075759410858,
-0.21991418302059174,
0.3121333718299866,
-0.27138009667396545,
0.7289636731147766,
0.08971790224313736,
-0.8119948506355286,
0.32240548729896545,
-0.4498501121997833,
0.439085453748703,
0.8119126558303833,
0.11723368614912033,
-0.7454324960708618,
-1.246556282043457,
-0.842566192150116,
-1.19334077835083,
0.5720187425613403,
0.47068488597869873,
-0.01800462417304516,
0.03161300718784332,
-0.07373563945293427,
0.2392646074295044,
0.49611905217170715,
-1.0087082386016846,
-0.35658103227615356,
-0.4312589764595032,
0.24827727675437927,
-0.2073908895254135,
-0.3828413188457489,
-0.3707282245159149,
-0.01376250945031643,
0.10722140222787857,
-0.05331236496567726,
0.035518232733011246,
-0.06408815085887909,
-0.2067427784204483,
0.030580906197428703,
0.5698556900024414,
0.8015492558479309,
1.1634252071380615,
-0.4533112645149231,
0.05550476163625717,
0.024129042401909828,
-0.5915772318840027,
-0.11853402853012085,
0.28436172008514404,
-0.33480751514434814,
0.45939886569976807,
0.5775410532951355,
0.5340853929519653,
0.02685677632689476,
-0.3832627236843109,
-0.02661990188062191,
-0.05641856789588928,
-0.2714597284793854,
-0.15221045911312103,
0.09630059450864792,
-0.1973426192998886,
0.21866050362586975,
0.6398040056228638,
0.4319474995136261,
0.19123223423957825,
-0.5355432033538818,
0.10646910965442657,
0.6127938032150269,
0.07088381052017212,
-0.14435598254203796,
0.34254711866378784,
0.32188326120376587,
-0.5800595283508301,
0.2186048924922943,
-0.5170793533325195,
-0.538245439529419,
0.9874023199081421,
0.43858399987220764,
1.0909165143966675,
0.1628378927707672,
0.5630248188972473,
0.20898188650608063,
0.8234345316886902,
-0.1072918027639389,
0.20678192377090454,
0.07830251753330231,
-0.781434178352356,
-0.39567747712135315,
-0.6136519908905029,
-0.5260444283485413,
0.31554150581359863,
-0.6812722682952881,
0.03413025289773941,
-0.579383373260498,
-0.27971217036247253,
-0.08424396067857742,
-0.14547541737556458,
-0.42153024673461914,
0.0722447857260704,
0.39354977011680603,
1.008103847503662,
-0.6521666646003723,
0.44856712222099304,
0.5894591808319092,
-0.028688866645097733,
-0.27928006649017334,
0.3798817992210388,
0.0060174427926540375,
-0.7788112759590149,
0.5962565541267395,
0.047902897000312805,
0.14107877016067505,
-0.4125971794128418,
-0.2979230284690857,
-0.7993665933609009,
0.5374278426170349,
0.10472769290208817,
-0.19015298783779144,
-0.32408595085144043,
0.5398505330085754,
0.9639846682548523,
-0.5638957023620605,
0.24211162328720093,
0.44409188628196716,
0.29018348455429077,
-0.21398133039474487,
-1.0053507089614868,
-0.4545075297355652,
-0.4170113801956177,
0.3044067621231079,
0.05360399931669235,
-0.4289865791797638,
0.7280297875404358,
-0.05399060994386673,
-0.10623006522655487,
-0.07668336480855942,
0.3693844974040985,
0.6991176009178162,
0.25550830364227295,
0.37794241309165955,
0.23650626838207245,
0.6387696266174316,
-0.12723186612129211,
1.1382511854171753,
-0.48812294006347656,
0.441745400428772,
1.0062252283096313,
0.058449503034353256,
0.3762195408344269,
0.3830731213092804,
-0.39386603236198425,
0.32885390520095825,
0.4866201877593994,
-0.21485933661460876,
0.4078453779220581,
0.08942805230617523,
-0.006976171862334013,
-0.21489201486110687,
0.0009654943714849651,
-0.42632120847702026,
0.7525953054428101,
0.4675295650959015,
-0.34055158495903015,
-0.6016944050788879,
-0.21123717725276947,
-0.32404959201812744,
-0.05561671033501625,
-0.2352474331855774,
0.43453338742256165,
-0.047471076250076294,
-0.8043239712715149,
0.38023698329925537,
-0.10641807317733765,
0.8726963996887207,
-0.636752188205719,
0.28986671566963196,
-0.29411277174949646,
-0.38599511981010437,
-0.17567095160484314,
-1.0348397493362427,
0.47827643156051636,
-0.12436508387327194,
-0.40429922938346863,
-0.44575929641723633,
0.5472574830055237,
-0.4961809813976288,
-0.444854736328125,
0.6329120397567749,
0.6663302183151245,
-0.15457580983638763,
-0.0454360768198967,
-0.5438886284828186,
-0.36810368299484253,
0.11528267711400986,
-0.08131851255893707,
0.4180157482624054,
0.5385905504226685,
0.03785630688071251,
0.8302374482154846,
0.4293953776359558,
0.5284396409988403,
0.3647463917732239,
0.23139417171478271,
0.5639440417289734,
-0.5360991954803467,
-0.6935889720916748,
-0.835824728012085,
0.21786966919898987,
-0.13551290333271027,
-0.9165388345718384,
0.5065653920173645,
0.5740238428115845,
0.8868156671524048,
-0.014766797423362732,
1.0689234733581543,
-0.024564551189541817,
0.4805639386177063,
-0.3914591670036316,
0.5124730467796326,
-0.5738749504089355,
0.12376625090837479,
-0.34646886587142944,
-1.0278451442718506,
-0.39137008786201477,
0.3803367614746094,
-0.24230580031871796,
0.23823383450508118,
0.7816694974899292,
0.13699492812156677,
0.0922464057803154,
0.1675713062286377,
0.35582026839256287,
-0.08689064532518387,
0.0640130266547203,
0.23767511546611786,
0.8436841368675232,
0.27285510301589966,
0.8989974856376648,
-0.40644317865371704,
-0.22869184613227844,
-0.1852809339761734,
-0.7276333570480347,
-0.922470211982727,
-0.36828938126564026,
-0.0081963324919343,
-0.44072023034095764,
0.13832460343837738,
0.7882055044174194,
0.46275222301483154,
-0.9244803190231323,
-0.4839852452278137,
-0.16173724830150604,
0.440432071685791,
-0.20955602824687958,
-0.2137860655784607,
-0.3701370060443878,
-0.7024542093276978,
-0.7719175219535828,
0.11465505510568619,
0.44264501333236694,
0.0018137055449187756,
0.05327197164297104,
0.4446982741355896,
-0.19716481864452362,
-0.15433306992053986,
0.5222077965736389,
0.6666104793548584,
-0.577536940574646,
0.04193951562047005,
0.16543537378311157,
-0.185878187417984,
0.22784581780433655,
1.018006443977356,
-0.02397874929010868,
0.45598408579826355,
0.7376568913459778,
0.5042597055435181,
0.21221879124641418,
-0.3038080334663391,
0.9218789935112,
-0.9225232601165771,
0.36409151554107666,
0.4300505816936493,
0.4552154541015625,
0.17979711294174194,
-0.055452220141887665,
0.4850190281867981,
0.6468290090560913,
-0.4139817953109741,
-0.6575656533241272,
0.6088619828224182,
-0.9037740230560303,
-0.4904891550540924,
1.5799541473388672,
0.18161198496818542,
0.14627662301063538,
-0.5302396416664124,
0.06348627805709839,
-0.07914076745510101,
-0.3067253828048706,
1.2065802812576294,
1.2339798212051392,
0.0018283932004123926,
-0.12581893801689148,
-0.596027135848999,
0.7583965063095093,
0.6464155316352844,
-0.7804020643234253,
-0.1617274135351181,
0.11682742089033127,
0.18945299088954926,
0.8663556575775146,
0.4268082082271576,
-0.024722646921873093,
0.2616416811943054,
-0.08259475231170654,
-0.04749978333711624,
0.4078220725059509,
-0.32227835059165955,
-0.23158758878707886,
0.5411190390586853,
0.1819281131029129,
0.151229128241539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04177v1 | Scaling Laws for Downstream Task Performance of Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T17:31:20 | 2024-02-06T17:31:20 | Berivan Isik, Natalia Ponomareva, Hussein Hazimeh, Dimitris Paparas, Sergei Vassilvitskii, Sanmi Koyejo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Scaling laws provide important insights that can guide the design of large
language models (LLMs). Existing work has primarily focused on studying scaling
laws for pretraining (upstream) loss. However, in transfer learning settings,
in which LLMs are pretrained on an unsupervised dataset and then finetuned on a
downstream task, we often also care about the downstream performance. In this
work, we study the scaling behavior in a transfer learning setting, where LLMs
are finetuned for machine translation tasks. Specifically, we investigate how
the choice of the pretraining data and its size affect downstream performance
(translation quality) as judged by two metrics: downstream cross-entropy and
BLEU score. Our experiments indicate that the size of the finetuning dataset
and the distribution alignment between the pretraining and downstream data
significantly influence the scaling behavior. With sufficient alignment, both
downstream cross-entropy and BLEU score improve monotonically with more
pretraining data. In such cases, we show that it is possible to predict the
downstream BLEU score with good accuracy using a log-law. However, there are
also cases where moderate misalignment causes the BLEU score to fluctuate or
get worse with more pretraining, whereas downstream cross-entropy monotonically
improves. By analyzing these observations, we provide new practical insights
for choosing appropriate pretraining data. | [
-0.2220710664987564,
-0.3598847985267639,
0.4788401424884796,
0.32102227210998535,
-0.3673146069049835,
-0.4387093484401703,
-0.6724044680595398,
-0.45222580432891846,
-0.08932418376207352,
0.5899918079376221,
-0.5137139558792114,
-0.10315446555614471,
-1.055954933166504,
-0.13228079676628113,
-0.3309403955936432,
1.3111225366592407,
-0.0028474575374275446,
0.14764101803302765,
-0.08646875619888306,
-0.2340903878211975,
-0.6478123068809509,
-0.44441723823547363,
-0.7126876711845398,
-0.4667811095714569,
0.711794912815094,
0.33918485045433044,
0.6779018044471741,
0.9154472947120667,
0.6522185206413269,
0.19132253527641296,
0.05288946256041527,
-0.37136104702949524,
-0.8343938589096069,
0.16713900864124298,
-0.39444974064826965,
-0.7400577664375305,
-0.2911010682582855,
-0.04345298931002617,
0.8341280221939087,
0.7441661953926086,
-0.0711304098367691,
0.36133110523223877,
0.5018741488456726,
0.9264997243881226,
-0.580621600151062,
0.10544684529304504,
-0.500852108001709,
-0.1505412608385086,
-0.2597920894622803,
-0.2410791665315628,
-0.5369065403938293,
-0.2866309881210327,
0.14947223663330078,
-0.5196253061294556,
0.14444521069526672,
0.061136990785598755,
0.8555477857589722,
0.5182384848594666,
-0.4901692569255829,
-0.25168415904045105,
-0.7658300995826721,
0.9014174938201904,
-0.5866624712944031,
0.627798318862915,
0.25825080275535583,
0.016121091321110725,
0.11776407808065414,
-0.4931466281414032,
-0.16625526547431946,
-0.03683982789516449,
-0.27032560110092163,
-0.12282151728868484,
-0.41660481691360474,
-0.07031181454658508,
0.21633285284042358,
0.415412962436676,
-0.6049020290374756,
0.6422467827796936,
-0.5106333494186401,
-0.12426040321588516,
0.8516076803207397,
0.19718945026397705,
-0.026273496448993683,
0.25589579343795776,
-0.239343523979187,
-0.4854297637939453,
-0.68182772397995,
0.1998976171016693,
0.20050720870494843,
0.6394506692886353,
-0.1638334095478058,
0.29805538058280945,
-0.1252620369195938,
0.6086337566375732,
0.369931697845459,
0.012291994877159595,
0.3971155285835266,
-0.5281854867935181,
-0.2849775552749634,
0.2105209082365036,
0.8604174256324768,
0.40652933716773987,
0.5209024548530579,
-0.0963657945394516,
-0.3684900999069214,
-0.6627514362335205,
0.37665626406669617,
-1.0022447109222412,
-0.07658280432224274,
-0.08523976057767868,
-0.5390122532844543,
-0.04158010706305504,
-0.0933576449751854,
-0.34399786591529846,
-0.2809402346611023,
-0.802885890007019,
0.6880658268928528,
-0.21601751446723938,
-0.26665812730789185,
-0.17453384399414062,
0.0794336199760437,
0.3017970323562622,
0.2880924940109253,
-1.0853283405303955,
0.14718350768089294,
0.5468652844429016,
0.9959967136383057,
-0.24270716309547424,
-0.4996832013130188,
-0.914687991142273,
-0.0901249498128891,
-0.3261515200138092,
0.2618750035762787,
-0.18909917771816254,
-0.16709713637828827,
-0.15891988575458527,
0.15279442071914673,
-0.3258195221424103,
-0.6342431306838989,
0.4036690294742584,
-0.5630247592926025,
-0.3768748342990875,
-0.14630019664764404,
-0.5866310596466064,
-0.06718660145998001,
-0.05748237296938896,
-0.6660373210906982,
0.5493987202644348,
0.06955776363611221,
-0.5773024559020996,
0.7282038927078247,
-0.2674950361251831,
-0.8137863874435425,
-0.10927613079547882,
0.12098057568073273,
-0.4385506808757782,
0.42769455909729004,
-0.23354698717594147,
0.6989767551422119,
-0.2950443625450134,
0.09542268514633179,
-0.310817152261734,
-0.15232843160629272,
0.09830059856176376,
-0.40471351146698,
0.6785316467285156,
0.32831358909606934,
-0.17501823604106903,
0.11093806475400925,
-0.4547484517097473,
0.10958068817853928,
-0.32891932129859924,
-0.5111203193664551,
-0.5408217310905457,
-0.0825839638710022,
-0.05479484796524048,
0.05586889386177063,
0.12127289175987244,
-0.44926488399505615,
0.1234087124466896,
0.05805076286196709,
0.23749880492687225,
0.8844031691551208,
-0.031173206865787506,
0.787723183631897,
-0.2318015694618225,
0.3681531548500061,
0.01496900338679552,
0.05561060458421707,
0.2466014325618744,
-0.16868285834789276,
-0.4367769658565521,
-0.16853532195091248,
0.4129299819469452,
0.5418341159820557,
-0.11269974708557129,
0.3810703754425049,
-0.6247835159301758,
-0.6155897974967957,
-0.4561094641685486,
0.3930915594100952,
0.1516927033662796,
0.4137609899044037,
0.5024523735046387,
-0.2010830044746399,
-0.39760681986808777,
-0.7309240102767944,
-0.3903622031211853,
0.06833858042955399,
-0.2782421112060547,
-0.04135563597083092,
0.39320510625839233,
-0.16924937069416046,
0.5874190926551819,
-0.44880211353302,
-0.4138259291648865,
-0.20165427029132843,
0.32957932353019714,
0.340609073638916,
0.8507840037345886,
0.408458948135376,
-0.5844177603721619,
-0.48396655917167664,
0.42089271545410156,
-0.3349362313747406,
-0.267334908246994,
-0.2366676777601242,
-0.1331547647714615,
0.2685015797615051,
0.6607382297515869,
-0.5274374485015869,
0.2547292113304138,
0.765271008014679,
-0.318091481924057,
0.7124150991439819,
-0.40954867005348206,
0.02452903427183628,
-0.9850568771362305,
0.03440011665225029,
0.2620834410190582,
-0.3234175741672516,
-0.5581933856010437,
-0.07776019722223282,
0.1573856920003891,
0.32496824860572815,
-0.3160831034183502,
0.307625412940979,
-0.2737686336040497,
-0.13982051610946655,
-0.15137594938278198,
-0.25296565890312195,
-0.21591578423976898,
0.31638047099113464,
0.08807609230279922,
0.6986963748931885,
0.6124335527420044,
-0.8716484308242798,
0.07125256955623627,
-0.18288969993591309,
-0.38247230648994446,
0.4782355725765228,
-0.5446135401725769,
-0.1267692744731903,
0.07287789136171341,
0.15095815062522888,
-0.8472383618354797,
0.139123797416687,
-0.43665269017219543,
-0.41206303238868713,
0.6911744475364685,
-0.33006712794303894,
-0.39385807514190674,
0.09576625376939774,
0.054106250405311584,
0.5999810695648193,
0.6195894479751587,
-0.393062561750412,
0.3172011375427246,
0.09172318875789642,
-0.11022277176380157,
-0.37814024090766907,
-0.9712473154067993,
-0.3005782663822174,
-0.4789435863494873,
-0.4826951324939728,
0.19176627695560455,
0.042927008122205734,
-0.028538549318909645,
-0.17878352105617523,
-0.2347383350133896,
-0.14582353830337524,
0.018131697550415993,
0.1609402894973755,
0.13444286584854126,
-0.4805096387863159,
0.0917930081486702,
0.05941605567932129,
0.05577266588807106,
0.3813822269439697,
-0.5601569414138794,
0.47806185483932495,
0.0016723437001928687,
0.1526634395122528,
-0.3787532448768616,
-0.11807017028331757,
0.7627121806144714,
-0.24620135128498077,
0.9618851542472839,
0.6581661701202393,
-0.03717389330267906,
-0.14682164788246155,
-0.33905771374702454,
-0.07128365337848663,
-0.4315538704395294,
0.3888098895549774,
-0.36282995343208313,
-0.8159608244895935,
0.6479533910751343,
-0.060080863535404205,
0.06857772916555405,
0.5334354043006897,
0.7940335869789124,
-0.35138261318206787,
0.6969103217124939,
0.6320846676826477,
-0.3087310492992401,
0.7133833169937134,
-0.3655453622341156,
0.10144554823637009,
-0.8672536611557007,
0.023980431258678436,
-0.6390230059623718,
-0.6807071566581726,
-1.0942124128341675,
-0.39453786611557007,
0.10715139657258987,
0.36556997895240784,
-0.4296245872974396,
0.39288753271102905,
-0.02109157107770443,
0.5107471346855164,
0.48105910420417786,
0.04573030769824982,
0.2291024774312973,
0.01710517145693302,
0.09073038399219513,
0.14387118816375732,
-0.589057445526123,
-0.23208490014076233,
1.2284513711929321,
0.33351173996925354,
0.9333642721176147,
0.1711501181125641,
0.8114972114562988,
0.27332374453544617,
0.5254266262054443,
-0.9080602526664734,
0.13526257872581482,
-0.4204826056957245,
-0.4671366214752197,
-0.7724393606185913,
-0.8662523627281189,
-1.274526596069336,
0.2146061211824417,
-0.044274620711803436,
-0.7798040509223938,
0.26687267422676086,
0.22708134353160858,
-0.2122211903333664,
0.28774040937423706,
-0.8384852409362793,
1.030752182006836,
-0.21970701217651367,
-0.44585028290748596,
-0.4467763900756836,
-0.7018761038780212,
0.05368257313966751,
-0.4629882276058197,
0.20566777884960175,
0.05194142460823059,
0.10145555436611176,
0.7472162246704102,
-0.5587602853775024,
0.6468673348426819,
-0.13187497854232788,
-0.25791075825691223,
0.14232982695102692,
0.22334595024585724,
0.499356210231781,
-0.19977949559688568,
-0.08671417832374573,
0.34792259335517883,
0.16987796127796173,
-0.5042087435722351,
-0.5561836957931519,
0.7595840096473694,
-0.8874516487121582,
-0.40963688492774963,
-0.0904664695262909,
-0.6767491698265076,
-0.10408496111631393,
0.3985511362552643,
0.661677360534668,
0.21936729550361633,
0.17361585795879364,
0.5126768946647644,
0.6783773303031921,
0.13536830246448517,
0.4709600508213043,
0.48026159405708313,
0.03318706154823303,
0.002961946651339531,
0.9759774208068848,
0.535515308380127,
0.6513891816139221,
0.4190530478954315,
0.4408843219280243,
-0.4635574221611023,
-0.7001748085021973,
-0.49237433075904846,
0.21445497870445251,
-0.4221751391887665,
-0.27627599239349365,
0.008315958082675934,
-0.18867464363574982,
-0.3777047395706177,
-0.09013132005929947,
-0.48275598883628845,
-0.21340978145599365,
-0.21268923580646515,
-0.09117551892995834,
0.20452332496643066,
0.5515378713607788,
-0.2772406041622162,
0.260771781206131,
-0.9803802371025085,
-0.21343740820884705,
0.08812768012285233,
0.4706754982471466,
0.14604593813419342,
-1.0811409950256348,
-0.6487613320350647,
0.09602998197078705,
-0.24877163767814636,
-0.38184255361557007,
0.17095091938972473,
0.20731516182422638,
0.38779374957084656,
0.3786453604698181,
0.05993085727095604,
0.740206778049469,
-0.5613362193107605,
0.2887727916240692,
0.4572409689426422,
-0.8163878321647644,
0.430693119764328,
-0.26499950885772705,
0.46568602323532104,
0.6481855511665344,
0.4821285307407379,
-0.4873954951763153,
-0.4384724795818329,
-0.24105337262153625,
-0.6208267211914062,
0.6576544046401978,
0.18205079436302185,
0.3145437240600586,
0.5206233263015747,
0.3778078258037567,
0.32910972833633423,
-0.06767462193965912,
-0.7063697576522827,
0.022488104179501534,
0.07923948019742966,
-0.06477589905261993,
-0.5059341788291931,
0.3241669833660126,
0.2646871507167816,
-0.4935394823551178,
0.37945133447647095,
0.12596331536769867,
-0.08342664688825607,
0.02402142621576786,
-0.2813393771648407,
-0.34770575165748596,
0.1409745216369629,
0.6294811964035034,
0.6367819905281067,
-0.20408636331558228,
-0.016562936827540398,
0.17792263627052307,
-0.6901258230209351,
0.3129519522190094,
-0.007248204201459885,
-0.11662052571773529,
-0.29294562339782715,
0.6997761130332947,
1.0541741847991943,
-0.2308274507522583,
-0.4655515253543854,
0.3965199589729309,
0.09070191532373428,
-0.37824785709381104,
0.04186031222343445,
0.117430679500103,
-0.08492109924554825,
0.30768147110939026,
0.4116862118244171,
0.1311131715774536,
0.019009049981832504,
-0.5276289582252502,
0.1400572955608368,
0.19270922243595123,
-0.3429833650588989,
-0.40973034501075745,
0.43085727095603943,
0.08124380558729172,
-0.16575093567371368,
0.9247568845748901,
-0.045397356152534485,
-0.26823124289512634,
0.48764461278915405,
0.4044710695743561,
0.6486495137214661,
-0.5365321636199951,
-0.09676329791545868,
0.5017524361610413,
0.5290670990943909,
-0.2678910195827484,
-0.32125309109687805,
-0.1418294459581375,
-0.7127469182014465,
-0.8085189461708069,
-0.8236415982246399,
0.01891816034913063,
0.17743271589279175,
-0.9670044183731079,
0.22561241686344147,
-0.15888558328151703,
-0.25813770294189453,
-0.11434169858694077,
-0.061493899673223495,
-0.9355394244194031,
0.4857690930366516,
0.31193405389785767,
0.6285341382026672,
-1.0280404090881348,
0.8789572715759277,
0.5678321123123169,
-0.3604622483253479,
-1.0262930393218994,
0.18603405356407166,
-0.1795654147863388,
-0.6182054877281189,
0.8356150388717651,
0.07831354439258575,
-0.043395254760980606,
0.12336080521345139,
-0.15377742052078247,
-1.1383826732635498,
0.9680870771408081,
0.6171488761901855,
-0.8436052203178406,
-0.07382967323064804,
0.21329225599765778,
0.6267148852348328,
-0.2745564579963684,
-0.04827987402677536,
0.7591866850852966,
0.30175772309303284,
0.13713093101978302,
-1.3060238361358643,
0.21203264594078064,
0.2334589958190918,
-0.1689324975013733,
0.6998407244682312,
-0.7341070175170898,
0.7561152577400208,
-0.3417900800704956,
-0.06638985127210617,
-0.4319237768650055,
0.5121385455131531,
-0.01463507954031229,
0.27235323190689087,
0.6005247235298157,
0.7873103618621826,
0.7838700413703918,
0.0020945032592862844,
1.1923612356185913,
-0.08388756960630417,
0.5556854605674744,
1.1202267408370972,
-0.015101969242095947,
1.098976492881775,
0.6184438467025757,
-0.24236206710338593,
0.3740183413028717,
0.7676824331283569,
0.13951168954372406,
0.4937962293624878,
0.5032862424850464,
0.24452181160449982,
-0.1595328003168106,
0.11123800277709961,
-0.21525588631629944,
0.3835577368736267,
0.07135751843452454,
-0.4715123474597931,
-0.04584290832281113,
0.15571077167987823,
-0.05346338823437691,
-0.3648798167705536,
-0.7882239818572998,
0.7152436971664429,
0.13640201091766357,
-0.7964524030685425,
0.8508169651031494,
-0.29788121581077576,
0.39072805643081665,
-0.45870593190193176,
0.4145832657814026,
-0.46687963604927063,
0.2741374969482422,
-0.351997971534729,
-1.0351957082748413,
0.477516770362854,
-0.11875377595424652,
-0.3687068223953247,
-0.5856125354766846,
0.32307907938957214,
-0.4016304314136505,
-0.4586738348007202,
0.3605474829673767,
0.31697505712509155,
0.3033439815044403,
-0.153472900390625,
-0.36968833208084106,
0.04073542356491089,
-0.007342951837927103,
-0.47229593992233276,
0.7255538702011108,
0.6956320405006409,
-0.128461092710495,
0.6293336153030396,
0.4885622262954712,
0.43662792444229126,
0.32058051228523254,
0.12282703816890717,
0.6303627490997314,
-0.3737947344779968,
-0.5387183427810669,
-0.9883978366851807,
0.37172770500183105,
0.13494065403938293,
-0.3478996455669403,
0.7152233719825745,
0.6204195618629456,
1.1118099689483643,
-0.0009639610652811825,
0.4071090519428253,
0.0874214693903923,
0.08952213823795319,
-0.7204960584640503,
0.7190929055213928,
-0.6759517192840576,
-0.05239035189151764,
-0.036160361021757126,
-1.208025336265564,
-0.13235828280448914,
0.37328192591667175,
-0.530434787273407,
0.025622835382819176,
0.7007966637611389,
0.514733076095581,
-0.24804899096488953,
-0.24192410707473755,
0.39530521631240845,
0.2871093451976776,
0.04221189394593239,
0.6545647382736206,
0.4210200905799866,
-0.25442591309547424,
0.6103998422622681,
0.1480715572834015,
-0.22010689973831177,
-0.22567425668239594,
-0.6947874426841736,
-0.4997759759426117,
-0.6413732767105103,
-0.4614994525909424,
-0.31548795104026794,
-0.3647392690181732,
0.5911476016044617,
0.9315075278282166,
-0.7123242020606995,
-0.6320986747741699,
-0.19042399525642395,
-0.05643811821937561,
-0.4229869246482849,
-0.19391635060310364,
0.2738151252269745,
-0.6787505745887756,
-0.43149057030677795,
-0.014754481613636017,
-0.008996840566396713,
0.08624585717916489,
-0.0031992774456739426,
-0.39605388045310974,
-0.1642065942287445,
-0.006530093494802713,
0.5955966114997864,
0.157408207654953,
-0.3858993947505951,
-0.16548492014408112,
-0.33916378021240234,
-0.26210373640060425,
0.14333894848823547,
1.0241509675979614,
-0.3618567883968353,
0.21885620057582855,
0.6524184942245483,
0.8682381510734558,
0.8424366116523743,
-0.0255267471075058,
0.7073273062705994,
-0.8362110257148743,
-0.07600927352905273,
-0.012753434479236603,
0.18892619013786316,
0.10812181979417801,
-0.4309057891368866,
0.43771594762802124,
-0.0034630473237484694,
-0.7938151955604553,
-0.7438105344772339,
0.000978535390459001,
-0.7094652056694031,
-0.18078459799289703,
1.0759246349334717,
-0.2153591364622116,
-0.2046564519405365,
0.3843528926372528,
0.18205130100250244,
0.3628576695919037,
-0.2211775928735733,
0.37287938594818115,
1.007920265197754,
-0.22998730838298798,
-0.243089959025383,
-0.616514265537262,
0.457364559173584,
0.670042097568512,
-0.5152104496955872,
0.47120201587677,
0.3209879994392395,
0.47828245162963867,
0.058809906244277954,
0.270084410905838,
0.2335602194070816,
0.18105250597000122,
-0.2745220959186554,
-0.22648689150810242,
0.4404601454734802,
-0.1270100325345993,
-0.4930346608161926,
-0.18918588757514954,
0.18746767938137054,
-0.2454991638660431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04161v1 | Attention with Markov: A Framework for Principled Analysis of Transformers via Markov Chains | 2024-02-06T17:18:59 | 2024-02-06T17:18:59 | Ashok Vardhan Makkuva, Marco Bondaschi, Adway Girish, Alliot Nagle, Martin Jaggi, Hyeji Kim, Michael Gastpar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT, stat.ML | In recent years, attention-based transformers have achieved tremendous
success across a variety of disciplines including natural languages. A key
ingredient behind their success is the generative pretraining procedure, during
which these models are trained on a large text corpus in an auto-regressive
manner. To shed light on this phenomenon, we propose a new framework that
allows both theory and systematic experiments to study the sequential modeling
capabilities of transformers through the lens of Markov chains. Inspired by the
Markovianity of natural languages, we model the data as a Markovian source and
utilize this framework to systematically study the interplay between the
data-distributional properties, the transformer architecture, the learnt
distribution, and the final model performance. In particular, we theoretically
characterize the loss landscape of single-layer transformers and show the
existence of global minima and bad local minima contingent upon the specific
data characteristics and the transformer architecture. Backed by experiments,
we demonstrate that our theoretical findings are in congruence with the
empirical results. We further investigate these findings in the broader context
of higher order Markov chains and deeper architectures, and outline open
problems in this arena. Code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Bond1995/Markov}. | [
-0.5584102869033813,
-0.8099908828735352,
0.48399320244789124,
0.1401667445898056,
-0.001197807607240975,
-0.17819324135780334,
-0.16374334692955017,
0.05266164615750313,
0.019906871020793915,
0.617014467716217,
-0.776973307132721,
-0.28653037548065186,
-0.5082454681396484,
-0.13097572326660156,
-0.7107877135276794,
1.2876579761505127,
0.027078617364168167,
-0.41705796122550964,
-0.03470239415764809,
-0.029641982167959213,
-0.23901775479316711,
-0.4186358153820038,
-0.43868881464004517,
-0.128668874502182,
0.6502225399017334,
0.23786865174770355,
0.8128237724304199,
0.6327593326568604,
0.8216402530670166,
0.25403138995170593,
0.22907942533493042,
-0.29548022150993347,
-0.38986068964004517,
0.185954287648201,
-0.24378542602062225,
-0.521837055683136,
-0.14174358546733856,
0.062169261276721954,
1.0032596588134766,
0.7215162515640259,
-0.3964312970638275,
0.5081171989440918,
0.12463617324829102,
0.8566424250602722,
-0.6325473189353943,
0.11052868515253067,
-0.6392950415611267,
0.3361234664916992,
-0.29652372002601624,
-0.3516511917114258,
-0.6452716588973999,
-0.07942261546850204,
0.356762170791626,
-0.3063373565673828,
0.5310150980949402,
-0.010714261792600155,
0.5439350605010986,
0.7777587175369263,
-0.5001510977745056,
0.21629181504249573,
-1.3241957426071167,
0.6265857815742493,
-0.2529047429561615,
0.3235985040664673,
-0.0018290859879925847,
0.567224383354187,
-0.014347500167787075,
-0.7151618599891663,
-0.5678295493125916,
-0.2070261389017105,
0.026078451424837112,
0.36122751235961914,
-0.3150118291378021,
-0.02315458282828331,
0.43522199988365173,
0.682346761226654,
-0.5111680030822754,
-0.039038173854351044,
-0.13476158678531647,
0.14506211876869202,
0.21198876202106476,
0.332728773355484,
0.2241978794336319,
0.016360512003302574,
-0.5138049125671387,
-0.2608218491077423,
-0.44082850217819214,
-0.10505394637584686,
0.7724119424819946,
0.12684732675552368,
-0.20769774913787842,
0.6005996465682983,
-0.04105517268180847,
0.8008285164833069,
0.07213481515645981,
0.3193735182285309,
-0.01876220852136612,
-0.19988711178302765,
-0.30625855922698975,
-0.045290883630514145,
0.9180572628974915,
-0.11888118088245392,
0.40793728828430176,
-0.2686479091644287,
-0.07357264310121536,
0.4093399941921234,
0.8388530611991882,
-0.498443067073822,
-0.7030984163284302,
0.0659693032503128,
-0.5180162191390991,
-0.33697375655174255,
-0.03506201505661011,
-0.6919087767601013,
-0.2292107790708542,
-0.35713431239128113,
0.6054553389549255,
-0.13162976503372192,
-0.4725024402141571,
0.1504206657409668,
0.11579981446266174,
0.17664435505867004,
-0.1980961114168167,
-0.8991363048553467,
0.560479462146759,
0.4793408215045929,
0.8176021575927734,
-0.34869998693466187,
-0.12303704768419266,
-0.24574674665927887,
0.19110357761383057,
-0.28233546018600464,
0.7675265073776245,
-0.3533191382884979,
-0.01926894672214985,
0.052459027618169785,
-0.19367274641990662,
-0.3541592061519623,
-0.5377177000045776,
0.3852674663066864,
-0.7118085026741028,
0.2290383279323578,
0.3104479908943176,
-0.20656906068325043,
0.02146821841597557,
0.1399383395910263,
-0.9872317910194397,
0.9384019374847412,
0.03625788539648056,
-1.2033233642578125,
0.3018430173397064,
-0.8197809457778931,
-0.4839102029800415,
-0.3742404282093048,
0.04128332436084747,
-0.5493519902229309,
0.14903253316879272,
-0.022501962259411812,
0.4646149277687073,
-0.3401060104370117,
0.381050169467926,
-0.2666914463043213,
0.02960861288011074,
0.4947257339954376,
-0.7395394444465637,
0.66411292552948,
0.27503809332847595,
-0.33078399300575256,
0.3320057690143585,
-1.0636011362075806,
-0.24946118891239166,
0.14270980656147003,
-0.30732864141464233,
0.006938369944691658,
0.43340662121772766,
0.12181825190782547,
0.4968913793563843,
-0.14830689132213593,
-0.2277861088514328,
0.3170958459377289,
-0.44043126702308655,
0.32637885212898254,
0.7205416560173035,
0.25155308842658997,
0.70011967420578,
-0.2058587670326233,
0.6014827489852905,
0.468650758266449,
0.36049002408981323,
-0.38276755809783936,
-0.3231772184371948,
-1.0347412824630737,
-0.19370056688785553,
0.143107607960701,
0.400167316198349,
-0.6578060984611511,
0.4184381663799286,
-0.3381352722644806,
-0.2685582935810089,
-0.6134057641029358,
-0.03310572728514671,
0.014627211727201939,
0.511949360370636,
0.4269072115421295,
-0.649569571018219,
-0.7530747652053833,
-1.2565418481826782,
-0.2495933622121811,
-0.016563333570957184,
-0.16662561893463135,
-0.012995202094316483,
0.22567498683929443,
-0.4751652181148529,
1.1718157529830933,
-0.35286960005760193,
-0.2520972490310669,
-0.3092251718044281,
-0.06095174700021744,
0.6274892091751099,
0.5734046697616577,
0.10290300846099854,
-0.643706738948822,
-0.10727141052484512,
-0.14062009751796722,
-0.5092912316322327,
0.2992821931838989,
-0.3958463966846466,
-0.2718202769756317,
0.18019133806228638,
0.10736915469169617,
-0.717835545539856,
0.3811957538127899,
0.35611802339553833,
-0.09539570659399033,
0.3963998258113861,
-0.29066359996795654,
-0.3366696238517761,
-1.1068997383117676,
0.2393050491809845,
0.3177264332771301,
-0.13117557764053345,
-0.8202314376831055,
-0.1715274155139923,
-0.1393192708492279,
0.013206053525209427,
-0.2999323904514313,
0.031978558748960495,
-0.20963911712169647,
-0.3523652255535126,
-0.06611654907464981,
-0.11750739812850952,
-0.45846718549728394,
0.7259728908538818,
0.12132206559181213,
0.3254667818546295,
0.6448361873626709,
-0.9038733243942261,
0.18613320589065552,
0.07864362001419067,
-0.6401260495185852,
0.4532504081726074,
-0.7080913782119751,
-0.01929469034075737,
-0.38280123472213745,
0.26370763778686523,
-1.093217134475708,
0.10264045745134354,
0.4778863489627838,
-0.18078534305095673,
0.3104454278945923,
-0.31985265016555786,
-0.8261385560035706,
-0.4357891380786896,
0.20905902981758118,
0.4653151333332062,
0.6817368268966675,
-0.5676164031028748,
0.4141925573348999,
0.5226256847381592,
0.19500359892845154,
-0.41548097133636475,
-0.38158148527145386,
-0.13431072235107422,
-0.4159620404243469,
-0.4737990200519562,
0.04355841875076294,
-0.1509147584438324,
-0.20429348945617676,
-0.20188497006893158,
-0.27053356170654297,
-0.16463422775268555,
0.3217620849609375,
0.21662890911102295,
0.18570969998836517,
-0.2949545979499817,
0.17249029874801636,
-0.37180840969085693,
-0.6013683080673218,
0.47056353092193604,
-0.9081026315689087,
0.6638126373291016,
-0.08550885319709778,
-0.14803773164749146,
-0.513936460018158,
0.12473613023757935,
0.46821489930152893,
-0.40996965765953064,
0.8110559582710266,
0.6672133207321167,
-0.2263565957546234,
-0.37361496686935425,
-0.31897956132888794,
-0.0855807363986969,
-0.49009227752685547,
0.19203050434589386,
-0.32089492678642273,
-0.3493533134460449,
0.4689028561115265,
0.17425252497196198,
-0.11845003813505173,
0.8297533988952637,
0.9505121111869812,
-0.15645089745521545,
0.9965687394142151,
0.7992076277732849,
-0.2836006283760071,
0.7413673400878906,
-0.7566342353820801,
0.21329884231090546,
-0.7640118598937988,
-0.08735252171754837,
-0.24753554165363312,
-0.5028852224349976,
-0.819014310836792,
-0.25953415036201477,
0.19670283794403076,
-0.19036179780960083,
-0.4562608599662781,
0.4565105438232422,
-0.4671098589897156,
0.39629316329956055,
0.4425148367881775,
-0.07748811691999435,
0.1958169937133789,
-0.054462287575006485,
-0.2200806438922882,
-0.009416232816874981,
-0.9211955070495605,
-0.5338542461395264,
0.8933523893356323,
0.5489411950111389,
0.960464358329773,
0.09971687942743301,
0.5287423729896545,
0.28232109546661377,
0.2899436056613922,
-0.7924458980560303,
0.340506374835968,
0.3331100046634674,
-0.6667884588241577,
-0.2661900222301483,
-0.48094654083251953,
-1.0995694398880005,
0.3281264007091522,
-0.08380314707756042,
-0.7418254017829895,
0.14852432906627655,
0.3467717468738556,
-0.18872445821762085,
0.3015895187854767,
-0.5547457337379456,
1.3447185754776,
-0.006652127020061016,
-0.36706429719924927,
-0.23114463686943054,
-0.9193674921989441,
0.46546122431755066,
0.05573229864239693,
-0.05752693489193916,
0.06107523664832115,
0.08363064378499985,
0.6225565075874329,
-0.14756879210472107,
0.7453530430793762,
-0.03821004182100296,
-0.45170241594314575,
0.4421323537826538,
0.16587908565998077,
0.38647526502609253,
0.09195666760206223,
0.3336174786090851,
-0.028264161199331284,
-0.16391657292842865,
-0.2729590833187103,
-0.6620199084281921,
0.4801350235939026,
-0.7022785544395447,
-0.3017611503601074,
-0.23348477482795715,
-0.5640172362327576,
-0.16373154520988464,
0.2002122551202774,
0.2001195102930069,
0.5299564003944397,
-0.15808860957622528,
-0.01616002433001995,
0.8841419219970703,
0.040646035224199295,
0.5272663235664368,
0.25334858894348145,
-0.15640592575073242,
-0.060967110097408295,
0.9949198961257935,
0.11991499364376068,
0.2224767506122589,
0.5718517899513245,
-0.038799453526735306,
-0.21988201141357422,
-0.403870552778244,
-0.18758782744407654,
0.04990660026669502,
-0.6026700735092163,
0.10016843676567078,
-0.8919017314910889,
-0.13073879480361938,
-0.03526470065116882,
0.4735777676105499,
-0.545287549495697,
-0.41669997572898865,
-0.23402740061283112,
-0.004037021659314632,
-0.03318364545702934,
0.7386481165885925,
0.13846643269062042,
0.3988776206970215,
-0.678059995174408,
0.6617329716682434,
0.18859156966209412,
0.5245785117149353,
0.148444265127182,
-0.4959125220775604,
-0.5036370158195496,
-0.1104150116443634,
-0.5267249941825867,
-0.763123095035553,
0.4104782044887543,
0.08024176210165024,
0.5706826448440552,
0.5875067114830017,
0.0678047388792038,
0.48539283871650696,
-0.9441134333610535,
0.35074934363365173,
0.1090988963842392,
-0.8112236857414246,
0.6215261816978455,
-0.590866208076477,
0.3189755976200104,
0.27047574520111084,
0.5387107133865356,
-0.6441605091094971,
-0.5081096291542053,
-0.9906101226806641,
-0.8798669576644897,
0.740026593208313,
0.3927646279335022,
-0.071603924036026,
-0.12804536521434784,
0.10815855115652084,
-0.03827778249979019,
0.3604831099510193,
-0.6193817853927612,
-0.5709257125854492,
-0.14656546711921692,
-0.40065085887908936,
-0.4248215854167938,
-0.117713063955307,
0.11219065636396408,
-0.06235145404934883,
0.37163275480270386,
0.04105979949235916,
0.5562076568603516,
0.09268718212842941,
-0.4453932046890259,
-0.06000874191522598,
0.22096557915210724,
0.4503948986530304,
0.44923877716064453,
-0.13405436277389526,
0.4350073039531708,
-0.15452079474925995,
-0.2741868495941162,
0.24508298933506012,
-0.10521095991134644,
0.07067008316516876,
-0.17958995699882507,
0.09828130900859833,
0.6609821915626526,
0.3284832537174225,
-0.2562948167324066,
0.18573665618896484,
-0.11672355979681015,
0.2731688916683197,
-0.5167586803436279,
0.07857022434473038,
-0.09668848663568497,
0.3231396973133087,
0.39252984523773193,
0.49290674924850464,
0.3258311152458191,
-0.5560545921325684,
0.4596835672855377,
0.34897226095199585,
-0.5350417494773865,
-0.6349170804023743,
0.6172154545783997,
-0.04569665715098381,
-0.411700576543808,
0.5952880382537842,
0.1762090027332306,
-0.4469001591205597,
0.6490532159805298,
0.5763899087905884,
0.9453882575035095,
-0.19056250154972076,
0.15072929859161377,
0.18412484228610992,
0.4848499298095703,
-0.19860324263572693,
-0.11431153863668442,
-0.42052963376045227,
-0.6571172475814819,
-0.4394562840461731,
-0.46976038813591003,
-0.17623209953308105,
-0.16885784268379211,
-0.8729152083396912,
-0.025468239560723305,
-0.5350618362426758,
-0.2894413471221924,
0.017997749149799347,
-0.1754722148180008,
-0.9887232184410095,
0.11526143550872803,
0.12487117946147919,
0.6654924750328064,
-0.692399799823761,
0.9323995113372803,
0.5047796368598938,
-0.2909112274646759,
-0.2543179988861084,
0.22536715865135193,
-0.28865689039230347,
-0.48165416717529297,
0.798121452331543,
0.3216968774795532,
-0.09099365770816803,
0.46384260058403015,
-0.31203994154930115,
-1.0740267038345337,
0.6294854283332825,
0.2625100016593933,
-0.45997387170791626,
-0.05590672045946121,
0.07052095234394073,
0.69868403673172,
-0.34352976083755493,
0.3434017598628998,
0.8445960283279419,
0.2116200476884842,
-0.19856686890125275,
-0.4522998631000519,
-0.34755751490592957,
-0.2310505360364914,
0.19652608036994934,
0.5692508220672607,
-0.3653910160064697,
0.6632041931152344,
-0.3201388716697693,
-0.7104674577713013,
-0.051167674362659454,
0.7574282288551331,
-0.30966922640800476,
-0.06284655630588531,
0.43157312273979187,
0.7586782574653625,
0.34106993675231934,
-0.051209066063165665,
1.366672158241272,
-0.34551024436950684,
0.6802449226379395,
1.078403115272522,
-0.09248021245002747,
0.8121298551559448,
0.4983251690864563,
-0.45071765780448914,
0.6302580237388611,
0.4401825964450836,
0.043990738689899445,
0.7392433285713196,
0.6284205913543701,
-0.008889054879546165,
-0.2742227017879486,
0.05799109488725662,
-0.10190656781196594,
0.1382754147052765,
0.13897056877613068,
-0.31892091035842896,
0.041949499398469925,
-0.03045458346605301,
-0.6095249652862549,
-0.1638798862695694,
-0.172871932387352,
0.745473325252533,
-0.05483447015285492,
-0.39526036381721497,
0.3657863140106201,
-0.2424638569355011,
0.46733319759368896,
-0.29513320326805115,
0.1528889238834381,
0.00787585973739624,
0.5527117252349854,
-0.08604403585195541,
-0.5201621651649475,
0.3957652449607849,
-0.159218892455101,
-0.5519010424613953,
-0.29850664734840393,
0.4497953951358795,
-0.49582549929618835,
-0.4640273451805115,
-0.0014789807610213757,
0.16269651055335999,
-0.07012532651424408,
0.07284363359212875,
-0.35026004910469055,
-0.062163811177015305,
-0.46454504132270813,
-0.3931785225868225,
0.14895445108413696,
0.3183106482028961,
0.3328312933444977,
0.8544053435325623,
0.525879442691803,
-0.14399054646492004,
0.33381879329681396,
0.008278929628431797,
0.5669514536857605,
-0.730952262878418,
-0.5527576208114624,
-0.98313969373703,
0.795862078666687,
0.16437633335590363,
-0.10813743621110916,
0.8709277510643005,
0.45900973677635193,
0.9619470238685608,
-0.36051520705223083,
0.4814630448818207,
0.3713762164115906,
0.2612026333808899,
-0.4919586777687073,
0.661279559135437,
-0.09365014731884003,
0.22764737904071808,
-0.35428258776664734,
-1.3393073081970215,
-0.26641586422920227,
0.7966776490211487,
-0.270271360874176,
0.01774728298187256,
0.7741173505783081,
0.4920600950717926,
-0.15727104246616364,
-0.24483522772789001,
0.19140110909938812,
0.3151865005493164,
0.245784729719162,
0.7119652628898621,
1.2464804649353027,
-0.5535402297973633,
0.32942432165145874,
-0.15029911696910858,
0.10257170349359512,
-0.08978627622127533,
-0.6513192653656006,
-0.9229291677474976,
-0.7742364406585693,
-0.4612409174442291,
-0.1664668768644333,
-0.23874779045581818,
0.7424835562705994,
0.49553099274635315,
-0.5559669137001038,
-0.3233615458011627,
-0.3877284526824951,
0.24839705228805542,
-0.16008391976356506,
-0.28052961826324463,
0.1682705581188202,
-0.49199122190475464,
-0.4874690771102905,
0.16199643909931183,
0.3594338595867157,
0.12120934575796127,
-0.584703266620636,
0.06772398203611374,
-0.14018015563488007,
0.022248713299632072,
0.5623706579208374,
0.09990068525075912,
-0.45046570897102356,
-0.04866335541009903,
-0.13573801517486572,
-0.036017876118421555,
0.17716294527053833,
1.2263938188552856,
-1.2104158401489258,
0.38571304082870483,
0.29962536692619324,
0.7703456282615662,
0.5568947792053223,
-0.23863458633422852,
0.6335521936416626,
-0.7210766673088074,
0.1358182728290558,
0.1683901846408844,
0.34682250022888184,
0.1299390345811844,
-0.01998138427734375,
0.32189592719078064,
0.1761796772480011,
-0.45292896032333374,
-0.742089033126831,
0.5018945336341858,
-0.9492900967597961,
0.24805235862731934,
0.9121680855751038,
0.15239876508712769,
-0.21781094372272491,
-0.00623844750225544,
0.02274279296398163,
0.5097192525863647,
-0.11890057474374771,
0.8642595410346985,
0.4616592824459076,
0.21932697296142578,
-0.24442629516124725,
-0.5971328616142273,
0.4101817011833191,
0.48179566860198975,
-0.7318262457847595,
0.17311742901802063,
0.3905450999736786,
0.09559927880764008,
0.3362334370613098,
0.3718991279602051,
0.10235746204853058,
0.14982718229293823,
-0.23869386315345764,
-0.10020217299461365,
0.2569415867328644,
-0.8640801906585693,
-0.7431294918060303,
0.1507950723171234,
-0.11491362005472183,
-0.30484816431999207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04160v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04160v1 | Harnessing the Plug-and-Play Controller by Prompting | 2024-02-06T17:18:25 | 2024-02-06T17:18:25 | Hao Wang, Lei Sha | cs.CL | cs.CL | Controllable text generation is a growing field within natural language
generation (NLG) that focuses on producing text that meets specific constraints
in real-world applications. Previous approaches, such as plug-and-play
controllers (PPCs), aimed to steer the properties of generated text in a
flexible manner. However, these methods often compromised the integrity of the
language model's decoding process, resulting in less smooth text generation.
Alternatively, other techniques utilized multiple attribute prompts to align
the generated text with desired attributes, but this approach required prompt
design for each attribute and was dependent on the size of the language model.
This paper introduces a novel method for flexible attribute control in text
generation using pre-trained language models (PLMs). The proposed approach aims
to enhance the fluency of generated text by guiding the generation process with
PPCs. The key idea is to dynamically adjust the distribution of generated text
by modifying prompts, effectively constraining the output space of the language
model and influencing the desired attribute. To enable smooth cooperation
between the PLM and the PPC, our work innovatively proposes a new model
fine-tuning method: Reinforcement Learning with Dynamic Adjust Feedback
(RLDAF).This fine-tuning process adapts a small subset of the language model's
parameters based on the generating actions taken during the PPC control
process. The resulting harmonious collaboration between the PLM and PPC leads
to improved smoothness in text generation during inference. Extensive
experiments were conducted on the SST2 dataset, and the proposed method
outperformed previous approaches in various evaluation metrics, including text
fluency and attribute consistency. | [
-0.39910224080085754,
-0.9646798968315125,
0.4140786826610565,
0.3822656571865082,
-0.22612431645393372,
0.2144358605146408,
-0.28696343302726746,
-0.025112295523285866,
-0.2087114006280899,
0.4942837059497833,
-0.9868961572647095,
-0.28480902314186096,
-0.25907328724861145,
0.20748302340507507,
0.12470816820859909,
1.1860544681549072,
-0.2461133748292923,
-0.49989065527915955,
-0.06643391400575638,
0.05537070706486702,
-0.5434240698814392,
-0.14070852100849152,
-0.8644907474517822,
-0.3876141309738159,
0.8556815981864929,
0.45168811082839966,
0.8609424829483032,
0.401612251996994,
0.13694539666175842,
0.32699301838874817,
-0.24096830189228058,
0.8032081723213196,
-0.30041927099227905,
0.34763410687446594,
-0.23387332260608673,
-0.2717094123363495,
-0.5509666800498962,
0.04910082742571831,
0.5953656435012817,
0.1777489185333252,
-0.29367345571517944,
-0.21888495981693268,
0.27635180950164795,
0.4991914629936218,
-0.4759087562561035,
-0.02144397608935833,
-0.5505642890930176,
0.05603983253240585,
0.05293715372681618,
-0.5744981169700623,
-0.74916672706604,
-0.5956217050552368,
0.0014322317438200116,
-0.6913425326347351,
0.17870204150676727,
0.037217967212200165,
1.0672439336776733,
0.22415520250797272,
-0.4775392413139343,
-0.3532715141773224,
-0.7807344794273376,
0.7895346283912659,
-0.8121843338012695,
0.07070039212703705,
0.24408897757530212,
0.08411154896020889,
-0.6005815267562866,
-0.646181046962738,
-0.7608404755592346,
-0.4074794054031372,
-0.20803852379322052,
0.14692923426628113,
0.2624618709087372,
0.1069108247756958,
0.14813095331192017,
0.07625589519739151,
-0.41162216663360596,
0.35960379242897034,
0.02842099778354168,
-0.10057851672172546,
0.6468313932418823,
0.10404369235038757,
0.2526335120201111,
-0.34614941477775574,
-0.29491591453552246,
-0.16411671042442322,
-0.7769221067428589,
0.3740347921848297,
0.5991816520690918,
0.4202137887477875,
-0.15429413318634033,
0.39454740285873413,
0.061739299446344376,
0.6944141983985901,
0.4665502607822418,
-0.3435221314430237,
0.05566653609275818,
-0.28763580322265625,
-0.1713869869709015,
-0.05368872731924057,
1.041805386543274,
0.004721832927316427,
0.12883731722831726,
-0.03445342928171158,
-0.28782370686531067,
-0.22739936411380768,
0.423877090215683,
-0.5182973146438599,
-0.22489552199840546,
0.07476156949996948,
-0.23064233362674713,
-0.6667013764381409,
0.0652264803647995,
-0.664348840713501,
-0.24278055131435394,
-0.4007987678050995,
0.36563220620155334,
-0.6013361811637878,
-0.29610171914100647,
-0.1574249267578125,
0.24902454018592834,
0.22899432480335236,
0.30717456340789795,
-1.0408837795257568,
0.10552086681127548,
0.38668906688690186,
0.8399274349212646,
-0.4922705888748169,
-0.25027063488960266,
-0.6777223348617554,
0.3562247157096863,
-0.39499691128730774,
0.6594178676605225,
-0.34261325001716614,
-0.3891601860523224,
0.025989903137087822,
-0.16120092570781708,
-0.01649218425154686,
-0.38826796412467957,
0.23756103217601776,
-0.5517977476119995,
0.5493611097335815,
0.11264865100383759,
-0.3440023362636566,
0.16178388893604279,
0.00646912632510066,
-0.6103406548500061,
1.0980677604675293,
0.11811135709285736,
-0.6661442518234253,
0.5977979898452759,
-0.4639359712600708,
-0.5987201929092407,
0.17607462406158447,
-0.2731039524078369,
-0.8187789916992188,
0.059972841292619705,
0.2733268439769745,
0.42058542370796204,
0.014802433550357819,
0.6249790787696838,
0.1051565632224083,
0.0909506306052208,
0.5008048415184021,
-0.5087303519248962,
0.407450795173645,
0.17390266060829163,
-0.3892905116081238,
0.5669344067573547,
-0.9437468647956848,
0.2329864352941513,
-0.1163407489657402,
-0.6307426691055298,
0.10737977176904678,
0.16967160999774933,
-0.02774536795914173,
0.3223850429058075,
0.05345931649208069,
-0.0572626106441021,
0.18989622592926025,
-0.4145960211753845,
0.30422118306159973,
0.8249263167381287,
0.2128440886735916,
0.663569450378418,
-0.33082419633865356,
0.7600362300872803,
-0.15166635811328888,
-0.13665653765201569,
-0.3064863383769989,
-0.19724977016448975,
-0.7369182705879211,
-0.2549426853656769,
0.4711967408657074,
0.479900062084198,
-1.109156847000122,
0.8598827719688416,
0.27236655354499817,
-0.302508682012558,
-0.3965897560119629,
0.19508007168769836,
0.36676323413848877,
0.5863532423973083,
0.14898838102817535,
-0.1812453418970108,
-0.11760915815830231,
-0.5458532571792603,
-0.13259798288345337,
-0.02261440083384514,
-0.43765395879745483,
0.4364319145679474,
0.15955939888954163,
0.22580738365650177,
0.913949191570282,
-0.3986031413078308,
-0.19074666500091553,
-0.5797367095947266,
0.73173588514328,
-0.047981396317481995,
0.8905677199363708,
0.39249899983406067,
-0.7543615102767944,
-0.5024739503860474,
-0.07616940140724182,
-0.13576152920722961,
-0.4266524314880371,
-0.6310153603553772,
-0.330636203289032,
0.4345470368862152,
0.4204026460647583,
-0.4401717185974121,
0.4154815673828125,
0.5349259376525879,
-0.504379391670227,
0.7123525738716125,
-0.6799613237380981,
0.10376263409852982,
-0.836341142654419,
0.11828811466693878,
-0.16277848184108734,
-0.4518532454967499,
-0.4760279655456543,
-0.027423223480582237,
0.21805071830749512,
0.12646368145942688,
-0.40802693367004395,
0.22404198348522186,
-0.3647332191467285,
0.3583126962184906,
-0.37556174397468567,
0.1404709368944168,
0.28205302357673645,
0.6395413875579834,
0.09857232123613358,
0.869205892086029,
0.3318834900856018,
-1.0094470977783203,
0.28182530403137207,
0.1959855556488037,
-0.27806589007377625,
0.6457599401473999,
-0.6478143930435181,
-0.029835382476449013,
-0.1880916953086853,
0.28540709614753723,
-0.8171576857566833,
-0.3783732056617737,
0.0906522274017334,
-0.31674352288246155,
0.5556890964508057,
0.4086102247238159,
-0.618048906326294,
-0.11781913042068481,
-0.01474469993263483,
-0.03318179398775101,
0.6038683652877808,
-0.5101940631866455,
0.6893141269683838,
0.08774006366729736,
-0.40500977635383606,
0.1293317973613739,
-0.6417528390884399,
-0.2951565980911255,
-0.16825218498706818,
-0.4228608310222626,
0.538749098777771,
-0.1805494725704193,
0.21958333253860474,
-0.3920091688632965,
0.060823954641819,
0.014376468025147915,
0.15423643589019775,
0.060450222343206406,
0.2902131974697113,
-0.04893101006746292,
0.2869994044303894,
0.5190742611885071,
-0.1626741737127304,
-0.16427013278007507,
0.03789375349879265,
0.5401877760887146,
0.3396410644054413,
0.03010070137679577,
-0.6546529531478882,
0.24737630784511566,
0.08436085283756256,
-0.5341012477874756,
0.8064637184143066,
0.42063629627227783,
0.13977372646331787,
-0.6568941473960876,
-0.09465227276086807,
-0.2826782464981079,
-0.6095010042190552,
0.034368015825748444,
-0.32977619767189026,
-1.0388531684875488,
0.303364098072052,
-0.2919293940067291,
0.18222899734973907,
0.13862034678459167,
0.5501712560653687,
-0.014966612681746483,
1.3305188417434692,
0.860831081867218,
0.4928840398788452,
0.5814816951751709,
0.1083451434969902,
0.2484789937734604,
-0.47765013575553894,
-0.37303516268730164,
-0.46555954217910767,
-0.46445155143737793,
-0.7969537973403931,
-0.29753369092941284,
0.19400210678577423,
0.33301791548728943,
-0.3477466404438019,
0.09212160855531693,
-0.5526549816131592,
0.3772831857204437,
0.5280342102050781,
0.19488593935966492,
0.15945330262184143,
-0.21076075732707977,
-0.4867461919784546,
-0.1899425983428955,
-0.8630260825157166,
-0.5173550248146057,
0.3883243799209595,
0.3316737413406372,
0.7447203993797302,
0.16747143864631653,
0.4395618736743927,
0.08442895114421844,
0.12422357499599457,
-0.4975205361843109,
0.48574012517929077,
-0.059269122779369354,
-0.17568936944007874,
-0.30711856484413147,
-0.5452854037284851,
-0.6744094491004944,
-0.1165580078959465,
-0.3746407926082611,
-0.7137202024459839,
0.12291058897972107,
0.5080579519271851,
-0.6761428713798523,
0.042363960295915604,
-0.7231848239898682,
0.5923863649368286,
-0.3285047709941864,
-0.6520134806632996,
0.06078455597162247,
-0.48934558033943176,
0.27960965037345886,
0.014508280903100967,
-0.016018273308873177,
-0.0920281857252121,
-0.10831405967473984,
0.4447197914123535,
-0.44009628891944885,
0.6497526168823242,
-0.09127873182296753,
-0.4281843900680542,
0.27187421917915344,
0.36130085587501526,
0.745638370513916,
0.21102803945541382,
-0.0068586040288209915,
-0.6685346364974976,
-0.5578898787498474,
-0.28471308946609497,
-0.6722674369812012,
0.7742006182670593,
-0.49234142899513245,
-0.33103010058403015,
-0.30584949254989624,
-0.7011821866035461,
-0.3160243630409241,
0.30915287137031555,
0.2432350069284439,
0.294528990983963,
-0.06137602776288986,
0.02550629712641239,
0.9828285574913025,
-0.7056230902671814,
0.5807234048843384,
0.5357164144515991,
-0.2838881313800812,
-0.47056132555007935,
0.8968658447265625,
-0.14091530442237854,
0.5537550449371338,
0.4029048979282379,
0.239540234208107,
-0.17700353264808655,
-0.3395949602127075,
-0.36402371525764465,
-0.026409976184368134,
0.04576147347688675,
-0.3610707223415375,
-0.3955506682395935,
-0.20826052129268646,
-0.460450142621994,
-0.4718347489833832,
-0.1648084670305252,
-0.18365362286567688,
-0.6056528091430664,
-0.2891956865787506,
0.6299676299095154,
0.7495409250259399,
0.0514153428375721,
0.9417169094085693,
-0.5116344094276428,
0.3952634632587433,
0.3507803678512573,
0.6500478386878967,
-0.017986200749874115,
-0.35198429226875305,
0.08302311599254608,
-0.22199662029743195,
-0.6268990635871887,
-0.8816326260566711,
0.609686553478241,
0.3052203059196472,
0.18223227560520172,
0.37364503741264343,
0.14958609640598297,
0.4688691794872284,
-0.7098544836044312,
0.9442670345306396,
0.34140095114707947,
-0.94147127866745,
0.727698028087616,
-0.4293372929096222,
0.5875827670097351,
0.3384542167186737,
0.11708089709281921,
-0.13605540990829468,
-0.7388462424278259,
-0.6739637851715088,
-1.0356477499008179,
1.0339394807815552,
0.30257439613342285,
0.11622399836778641,
0.16345252096652985,
0.3181173503398895,
0.2615121006965637,
0.3368385136127472,
-0.620414674282074,
-0.08285976201295853,
-0.25845515727996826,
-0.38562530279159546,
0.15360918641090393,
-0.19645163416862488,
0.050122667104005814,
-0.03571033477783203,
0.7367332577705383,
-0.2636323571205139,
-0.05753149464726448,
0.035699956119060516,
0.10532290488481522,
-0.1672154814004898,
0.3936364948749542,
0.7693912386894226,
0.4883303940296173,
0.07756667584180832,
0.2180166244506836,
0.06518366932868958,
-0.23953314125537872,
0.0743672102689743,
0.0669030174612999,
-0.5888798832893372,
-0.020471720024943352,
-0.04401760920882225,
1.2499018907546997,
0.20010443031787872,
-0.5869799852371216,
0.18257741630077362,
-0.134122833609581,
-0.38463976979255676,
0.07922384142875671,
0.4237825572490692,
-0.05642113462090492,
0.0845571979880333,
0.11204363405704498,
-0.014531835913658142,
-0.37517476081848145,
-0.06060006842017174,
0.3670112192630768,
0.2778671979904175,
-0.31608447432518005,
-0.21855603158473969,
0.8482368588447571,
0.31884971261024475,
-0.4364757537841797,
0.21759650111198425,
-0.289142370223999,
-0.366564005613327,
0.40101632475852966,
0.7230750322341919,
0.5866163372993469,
-0.2612402141094208,
0.7509342432022095,
0.33382654190063477,
0.17194490134716034,
0.06771537661552429,
0.3120364844799042,
-0.1359962373971939,
-0.5215146541595459,
-0.5547571182250977,
-0.6527256369590759,
-0.2700953483581543,
0.3592643439769745,
-0.3651353716850281,
0.31460845470428467,
-0.7478416562080383,
-0.12263976782560349,
-0.1656866818666458,
0.02932155877351761,
-0.37520262598991394,
0.29513904452323914,
-0.1019807979464531,
0.8660361766815186,
-0.6157063245773315,
0.8249055743217468,
0.3631480634212494,
-0.5256585478782654,
-1.2984005212783813,
0.08662285655736923,
-0.23178666830062866,
-0.18049627542495728,
0.3001454770565033,
-0.023129092529416084,
0.05401280149817467,
0.25669798254966736,
-0.7516530752182007,
-0.5006622076034546,
1.0338131189346313,
0.19542989134788513,
-0.3771306276321411,
-0.12454232573509216,
0.13637468218803406,
0.5155846476554871,
-0.3730180561542511,
0.14705942571163177,
0.6315022706985474,
0.5682685375213623,
0.166678324341774,
-0.7159228920936584,
0.12522605061531067,
-0.024531466886401176,
0.3468826413154602,
0.20179788768291473,
-0.5636861324310303,
0.6798490285873413,
-0.0015366326551884413,
-0.23200534284114838,
0.2177758365869522,
1.0373265743255615,
0.6552480459213257,
-0.17653606832027435,
0.4557701051235199,
0.11993987113237381,
0.7857250571250916,
-0.06638885289430618,
0.8215844035148621,
-0.11187749356031418,
0.06435784697532654,
1.209563136100769,
-0.26930567622184753,
0.5826064944267273,
0.6324177384376526,
0.03149794042110443,
0.7639021873474121,
0.3347982168197632,
0.09703519940376282,
0.6623777747154236,
0.311612606048584,
-0.45755577087402344,
-0.12537738680839539,
-0.26283881068229675,
0.09671542048454285,
0.040739987045526505,
0.31765711307525635,
-0.28241392970085144,
-0.19810327887535095,
0.12580926716327667,
0.1286984086036682,
0.5190461874008179,
-0.23983849585056305,
0.9782475233078003,
-0.13565100729465485,
-0.9647438526153564,
0.3512348234653473,
0.10512737929821014,
0.9414807558059692,
-0.9591370224952698,
-0.04058913514018059,
-0.13597698509693146,
0.14727723598480225,
-0.15707488358020782,
-0.7360749840736389,
0.06361901760101318,
0.16304144263267517,
-0.2007245421409607,
-0.7548784017562866,
0.7071887254714966,
-0.8434590101242065,
-0.32871025800704956,
-0.15484923124313354,
0.09622608125209808,
-0.29183050990104675,
0.491381973028183,
-0.5581449270248413,
-0.10259795933961868,
0.1221228763461113,
-0.42706379294395447,
0.28086569905281067,
0.8449832797050476,
0.004664450418204069,
0.4051729738712311,
0.5872885584831238,
0.43832042813301086,
0.2206638753414154,
0.006995266769081354,
0.7218999862670898,
-0.361652672290802,
-0.6845859885215759,
-0.5141662955284119,
0.81903076171875,
-0.05814991518855095,
-0.47715452313423157,
0.5284613966941833,
0.1316644549369812,
0.690443754196167,
-0.041151776909828186,
0.7770532369613647,
-0.34617727994918823,
0.6435466408729553,
-0.607277512550354,
0.9289145469665527,
-0.39228618144989014,
0.049295298755168915,
-0.19429007172584534,
-0.4739483594894409,
-0.3598165810108185,
0.7277358770370483,
-0.05449826642870903,
-0.009125282987952232,
0.5733293294906616,
0.893828809261322,
0.014311117120087147,
-0.25285980105400085,
0.1333681344985962,
0.023821985349059105,
0.6262261867523193,
0.3733366131782532,
0.5114036202430725,
-0.04570598527789116,
0.35389167070388794,
-0.19124767184257507,
-0.3753519356250763,
0.16374807059764862,
-1.338288426399231,
-0.7481421828269958,
-0.41000956296920776,
-0.3363057076931,
-0.4047847092151642,
-0.08937547355890274,
0.8811367750167847,
0.39047232270240784,
-1.0016512870788574,
0.0027078366838395596,
-0.7269761562347412,
0.33370542526245117,
-0.34520387649536133,
-0.34087884426116943,
0.2751280665397644,
-0.6654123067855835,
-0.710568904876709,
0.29888829588890076,
0.19484665989875793,
0.2699345350265503,
-0.4410589039325714,
-0.40947189927101135,
-0.31622397899627686,
0.2481800764799118,
0.3481622636318207,
0.27466315031051636,
-0.4551393389701843,
-0.20330502092838287,
-0.1492549031972885,
-0.23413904011249542,
-0.07398997992277145,
1.0669132471084595,
-0.9792196750640869,
0.26764976978302,
0.7357322573661804,
0.4433816373348236,
-0.03420932963490486,
0.021920718252658844,
1.1395022869110107,
-1.1762412786483765,
0.20530599355697632,
0.22719746828079224,
-0.2553851306438446,
0.274505078792572,
-0.3651907742023468,
-0.15252575278282166,
-0.12012917548418045,
-0.7162712216377258,
-0.7347040772438049,
0.4428769052028656,
-0.7290721535682678,
-0.2999345660209656,
0.9937400221824646,
-0.22644725441932678,
-0.2453690469264984,
0.16992099583148956,
-0.5768571496009827,
0.5169599056243896,
-0.5642797946929932,
0.7845010161399841,
0.35873401165008545,
-0.1567939966917038,
-0.47223272919654846,
-0.2500029504299164,
1.0472768545150757,
0.46077290177345276,
-0.9033542275428772,
0.09385865181684494,
0.5415381193161011,
-0.1474311351776123,
-0.06874434649944305,
0.49158185720443726,
0.05663380026817322,
0.17603139579296112,
-0.5660924911499023,
0.007495494559407234,
-0.04456722363829613,
-0.5205683708190918,
-0.28994059562683105,
0.18800322711467743,
0.046077337116003036,
0.24771353602409363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06665v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06665v2 | The Essential Role of Causality in Foundation World Models for Embodied AI | 2024-02-06T17:15:33 | 2024-04-29T23:21:33 | Tarun Gupta, Wenbo Gong, Chao Ma, Nick Pawlowski, Agrin Hilmkil, Meyer Scetbon, Marc Rigter, Ade Famoti, Ashley Juan Llorens, Jianfeng Gao, Stefan Bauer, Danica Kragic, Bernhard Schölkopf, Cheng Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | Recent advances in foundation models, especially in large multi-modal models
and conversational agents, have ignited interest in the potential of generally
capable embodied agents. Such agents will require the ability to perform new
tasks in many different real-world environments. However, current foundation
models fail to accurately model physical interactions and are therefore
insufficient for Embodied AI. The study of causality lends itself to the
construction of veridical world models, which are crucial for accurately
predicting the outcomes of possible interactions. This paper focuses on the
prospects of building foundation world models for the upcoming generation of
embodied agents and presents a novel viewpoint on the significance of causality
within these. We posit that integrating causal considerations is vital to
facilitating meaningful physical interactions with the world. Finally, we
demystify misconceptions about causality in this context and present our
outlook for future research. | [
-0.31404420733451843,
-0.9055730700492859,
0.7310289144515991,
0.2942107319831848,
0.11857175827026367,
-0.4786020517349243,
0.543294370174408,
-1.0188840627670288,
0.26768773794174194,
0.2885546386241913,
-0.3473380506038666,
0.0978763997554779,
-0.5202732682228088,
-0.08471457660198212,
-0.6933460831642151,
0.6570408344268799,
0.20045486092567444,
-0.19946378469467163,
-0.5286977291107178,
0.02897452376782894,
-0.6436726450920105,
-0.2902000844478607,
-0.5046653151512146,
-0.7340131998062134,
0.514268696308136,
-0.09316670894622803,
0.9047214984893799,
0.5256388187408447,
0.2000240832567215,
0.3241458237171173,
0.2211061418056488,
-0.029438434168696404,
-0.36791518330574036,
0.49365830421447754,
-0.3597242832183838,
-0.5692480206489563,
-0.347663551568985,
0.1728833019733429,
0.6557596921920776,
0.9972828030586243,
0.2887040376663208,
-0.2839968800544739,
-0.2910166084766388,
0.30546844005584717,
-0.57818204164505,
0.3085891902446747,
-0.0907076746225357,
0.32222628593444824,
0.23623178899288177,
-0.13219428062438965,
-0.30321329832077026,
-0.10431212931871414,
0.2557562589645386,
-0.6982851028442383,
0.21946975588798523,
0.05745873600244522,
0.48892661929130554,
0.5449924468994141,
-0.9828733205795288,
0.012251446023583412,
-1.2807320356369019,
0.24735870957374573,
-0.372340589761734,
0.43274372816085815,
0.30611565709114075,
0.3721581697463989,
-0.5811272263526917,
-0.9203194379806519,
-0.7029611468315125,
-0.48705366253852844,
-0.20792227983474731,
0.0224904827773571,
-0.2104840725660324,
0.19712106883525848,
0.290093332529068,
0.015604643151164055,
0.06632635742425919,
0.09517285227775574,
-0.1764698028564453,
0.020078832283616066,
0.3395390808582306,
0.35475632548332214,
0.7215394377708435,
0.005334649235010147,
-0.5017317533493042,
0.17862668633460999,
-1.0466821193695068,
0.12015640735626221,
0.21562761068344116,
0.10116331279277802,
-0.3792814016342163,
0.4493945837020874,
-0.10892155766487122,
0.8555712699890137,
0.0031196861527860165,
0.022554192692041397,
-0.6696649789810181,
-0.09639882296323776,
-0.08577332645654678,
0.1447955071926117,
0.11371424794197083,
0.13238805532455444,
-0.054839543998241425,
-0.39995527267456055,
0.03936783969402313,
0.29592999815940857,
0.5857483148574829,
-0.8870677351951599,
0.2042786031961441,
0.3333711326122284,
-0.238184854388237,
-0.5173722505569458,
0.5259750485420227,
-0.06032322719693184,
-0.5892696976661682,
-0.4816722869873047,
0.2672075033187866,
0.14079302549362183,
-0.40265780687332153,
0.180388405919075,
-0.23495781421661377,
0.14673203229904175,
0.5737832188606262,
-0.7065808176994324,
0.36727267503738403,
0.8017410039901733,
0.4808991551399231,
0.3427295386791229,
-0.7267260551452637,
-0.3607138395309448,
0.6401656866073608,
-0.5141063332557678,
0.7083834409713745,
-0.46844619512557983,
-0.4532132148742676,
-0.022294841706752777,
0.10451444983482361,
-0.011199268512427807,
0.1659374088048935,
0.3518708348274231,
-0.38394713401794434,
-0.28362977504730225,
-0.4478241503238678,
-0.30190637707710266,
-0.37902340292930603,
0.3765503168106079,
-0.7728210687637329,
0.4027103781700134,
-0.25322964787483215,
-0.6987251043319702,
0.529817521572113,
-0.2332121878862381,
-0.7482046484947205,
-0.08450121432542801,
-0.215615376830101,
-0.005212529096752405,
0.5235201716423035,
-0.41567686200141907,
0.6432744860649109,
-0.7125405073165894,
0.9996181130409241,
-0.5505239367485046,
-0.5708370208740234,
0.4341660737991333,
-0.5204592943191528,
0.7330293655395508,
-0.21424500644207,
-1.0176764726638794,
-0.18440362811088562,
-0.5702804923057556,
-0.41644027829170227,
-0.20203959941864014,
0.22002311050891876,
-0.22336234152317047,
0.5236716866493225,
0.13398082554340363,
0.6134830713272095,
-0.21149422228336334,
-0.22964146733283997,
0.013212650083005428,
-0.48160937428474426,
0.2853870689868927,
0.8542374968528748,
-0.04997249320149422,
0.536212682723999,
-0.5039509534835815,
0.2401839792728424,
-0.28303948044776917,
0.24000851809978485,
0.1625627726316452,
-0.6735005974769592,
-0.6371967196464539,
-0.06987334787845612,
-0.412226140499115,
0.1366819590330124,
-0.35688793659210205,
0.2609550356864929,
-0.15174253284931183,
-0.7042245268821716,
0.4108211398124695,
-0.5009740591049194,
0.49552661180496216,
0.4999544620513916,
-0.16230957210063934,
-0.1500205248594284,
-0.2540144920349121,
-0.8185333609580994,
-0.13788990676403046,
-0.5512800812721252,
0.42766422033309937,
0.48431798815727234,
0.7933688759803772,
-0.3306865990161896,
1.180108904838562,
-0.19751906394958496,
0.1163523718714714,
0.13958606123924255,
-0.01624029316008091,
0.11801526695489883,
0.8013752698898315,
0.708631157875061,
-1.417096734046936,
0.09843365848064423,
0.17977923154830933,
-1.1864442825317383,
0.06592300534248352,
-0.18602605164051056,
-0.20522701740264893,
-0.3669484257698059,
0.40340736508369446,
-1.1152867078781128,
0.6930768489837646,
0.18633051216602325,
-0.7309326529502869,
0.6186809539794922,
-0.2524888813495636,
0.41531673073768616,
-0.7753382921218872,
0.46296221017837524,
-0.12816566228866577,
0.05851438269019127,
-0.7741972208023071,
0.019783230498433113,
-0.3186226487159729,
-0.32841286063194275,
-0.3643898367881775,
1.0261485576629639,
-0.3940102159976959,
-0.27981266379356384,
-0.37109509110450745,
0.16023240983486176,
-0.0028222722467035055,
0.21281014382839203,
0.009998899884521961,
0.3587878942489624,
0.5265064239501953,
-0.9766924381256104,
0.18598781526088715,
0.3043423295021057,
0.14491231739521027,
0.8131259083747864,
-1.1066259145736694,
-0.4454413056373596,
-0.22901467978954315,
0.8245785236358643,
-0.6613959670066833,
-0.4769412875175476,
0.2163502275943756,
-0.3250662088394165,
0.34339627623558044,
0.0526912622153759,
-0.40767937898635864,
-0.19993551075458527,
0.020010581240057945,
0.509662926197052,
0.18574489653110504,
-0.45280683040618896,
0.9119821190834045,
0.39075180888175964,
0.3770744204521179,
-0.6040021777153015,
-0.7196818590164185,
0.08232457935810089,
-0.12699103355407715,
-0.8866453170776367,
0.3339799642562866,
-0.01519272942095995,
-0.5433629751205444,
0.05217873305082321,
-0.23641334474086761,
0.08357369154691696,
0.7177029252052307,
0.8994998335838318,
0.05358969420194626,
0.005217443220317364,
0.08676786720752716,
0.17324014008045197,
-0.48681333661079407,
0.4138478934764862,
-0.4529436528682709,
0.018413173034787178,
0.037988755851984024,
-0.6010221242904663,
-0.41453465819358826,
0.30418163537979126,
0.9836378693580627,
0.1618206650018692,
0.9763805866241455,
0.2777016758918762,
-0.9003164172172546,
0.09635210782289505,
-0.6060479879379272,
-0.18521621823310852,
-0.3266446590423584,
0.0587938092648983,
-0.21602867543697357,
-0.5526934266090393,
0.5816346406936646,
-0.12297914177179337,
-0.15801337361335754,
0.2580679655075073,
0.27666017413139343,
0.09740396589040756,
0.872639536857605,
0.717221200466156,
-0.1346624493598938,
0.4390999674797058,
-0.24229246377944946,
0.3554263710975647,
-0.7387722134590149,
-0.39641326665878296,
-0.74760901927948,
-0.13629721105098724,
-0.6022936701774597,
-0.18892928957939148,
0.3112866282463074,
0.026333056390285492,
-0.6321604251861572,
0.19799143075942993,
-0.11703777313232422,
0.19540882110595703,
0.2986677587032318,
0.08494599908590317,
0.1576167792081833,
-0.24790745973587036,
0.15406285226345062,
0.2970767021179199,
-0.5651559829711914,
-0.5487029552459717,
0.6804202795028687,
-0.07884915173053741,
0.6991134881973267,
0.36493757367134094,
0.2747478783130646,
0.43138548731803894,
0.3544025719165802,
-0.17275524139404297,
0.2467084676027298,
0.41052305698394775,
-0.9652451872825623,
-0.27651849389076233,
0.15808014571666718,
-0.8602052927017212,
0.6108676791191101,
-0.45127540826797485,
-0.7751940488815308,
0.6230793595314026,
0.2188449203968048,
-0.05105859786272049,
0.1465880274772644,
-0.40061673521995544,
0.918262243270874,
0.15534467995166779,
-0.9177154302597046,
-0.446530818939209,
-0.9339664578437805,
0.6143398880958557,
0.2611674666404724,
0.1966322660446167,
-0.03835370019078255,
-0.05007628723978996,
0.20285063982009888,
-0.45060011744499207,
1.4485867023468018,
-0.18223926424980164,
-0.19095689058303833,
0.21952758729457855,
-0.013594577088952065,
0.6790779829025269,
0.2841375172138214,
0.16003574430942535,
-0.06390935182571411,
-0.23088578879833221,
-0.49494707584381104,
-0.5928186178207397,
0.8918209671974182,
-0.8552384972572327,
-0.8490884900093079,
-0.5028188228607178,
-0.1397440880537033,
-0.39616191387176514,
0.19944170117378235,
-0.02410859242081642,
0.7794979214668274,
-0.8201172947883606,
0.02085784450173378,
0.7832874655723572,
0.048354148864746094,
0.3051438331604004,
0.39253750443458557,
0.1670232117176056,
-0.24859920144081116,
0.7106420397758484,
-0.14423680305480957,
0.2498590648174286,
0.5325876474380493,
0.2918922007083893,
0.0547366738319397,
-0.08089664578437805,
-0.24844875931739807,
0.24651817977428436,
-0.7232863903045654,
-0.09698903560638428,
-0.8919990062713623,
0.11680373549461365,
-0.13330896198749542,
-0.8038426041603088,
0.012998907826840878,
-0.3538613021373749,
-0.21126589179039001,
-0.29511645436286926,
-0.06147663667798042,
1.0699840784072876,
-0.237207293510437,
0.2436954230070114,
-0.6247772574424744,
0.2444496601819992,
0.5379430055618286,
-0.1519492268562317,
0.5239611864089966,
-0.04323023930191994,
-0.36305472254753113,
0.05593999847769737,
-0.14488165080547333,
-0.7462337613105774,
-0.22557741403579712,
0.08890388160943985,
0.8345457911491394,
0.527458131313324,
-0.0671759694814682,
0.674601674079895,
-0.5306346416473389,
0.7226532697677612,
0.18059472739696503,
-0.9668557047843933,
0.6072237491607666,
-0.5287487506866455,
-0.18113058805465698,
-0.012491713277995586,
0.25441059470176697,
-0.5992143750190735,
-0.4526772201061249,
-0.9337718486785889,
-0.5774907469749451,
0.7216125130653381,
0.2839483618736267,
0.20606006681919098,
-0.03672270476818085,
0.29629603028297424,
0.23102620244026184,
0.20906668901443481,
-0.7031528949737549,
-0.2714531123638153,
-0.016122223809361458,
0.3319912254810333,
-0.021020911633968353,
-0.2893374562263489,
-0.26983845233917236,
-0.07860098779201508,
0.7593297958374023,
-0.15025387704372406,
0.12825459241867065,
0.23429545760154724,
-0.1997600495815277,
-0.07102342694997787,
-0.23903349041938782,
0.62535560131073,
0.765809953212738,
0.24615931510925293,
0.12942007184028625,
-0.2655051052570343,
-0.2439420372247696,
0.46395984292030334,
0.2630144953727722,
-0.3855191171169281,
-0.4847526252269745,
0.8760315179824829,
0.7141014933586121,
0.9800313711166382,
-0.29152512550354004,
0.6033846139907837,
0.15656067430973053,
0.4184688329696655,
-0.38227930665016174,
0.02559577114880085,
0.04100887477397919,
0.6024150848388672,
0.19775427877902985,
0.4540182054042816,
0.4214903712272644,
-0.6904194355010986,
0.0742957815527916,
0.3435554504394531,
-0.40315186977386475,
-0.7177578806877136,
1.0461915731430054,
0.42409536242485046,
0.03801126778125763,
0.4467463791370392,
0.3935055434703827,
-0.38081103563308716,
1.2077049016952515,
0.6883153915405273,
1.0797977447509766,
-0.22033050656318665,
0.30934083461761475,
0.36011356115341187,
0.3997438848018646,
-0.17277935147285461,
-0.291812926530838,
-0.3233307898044586,
-0.857042670249939,
0.02918466366827488,
-0.328930526971817,
-0.2558302879333496,
-0.8858652114868164,
-0.2872157394886017,
0.1755133867263794,
-0.2363482117652893,
-0.022770335897803307,
-0.28114068508148193,
-0.3655214011669159,
-0.5266531109809875,
0.3993791937828064,
-0.016732195392251015,
0.5800222158432007,
-1.2475638389587402,
0.2587806284427643,
0.45016592741012573,
-0.7831127643585205,
-0.5406814217567444,
-0.022912705317139626,
-0.1556542068719864,
-0.4479242265224457,
0.958097517490387,
0.3259006142616272,
-0.39236944913864136,
-0.22604213654994965,
-0.5663797855377197,
-0.8883296251296997,
1.388216257095337,
0.6334584951400757,
0.2072926163673401,
-0.17202210426330566,
-0.08852192759513855,
0.5857222676277161,
-0.2776891589164734,
0.23710103332996368,
0.1443157196044922,
0.5956781506538391,
-0.04996537044644356,
-0.388567715883255,
0.3670535683631897,
-0.2809635400772095,
0.20333442091941833,
0.1662265509366989,
-0.7303650975227356,
0.86565101146698,
-0.3216864764690399,
-0.16291505098342896,
0.044917602092027664,
0.7253269553184509,
0.33869296312332153,
0.4493536949157715,
0.21180446445941925,
0.2661028206348419,
0.3263735771179199,
-0.0710090771317482,
1.4209896326065063,
-0.23014675080776215,
0.1725149303674698,
0.6356860399246216,
-0.3282216787338257,
0.08838679641485214,
0.5334142446517944,
-0.14363740384578705,
0.24950149655342102,
0.25931230187416077,
0.6028153300285339,
0.33703717589378357,
0.16709887981414795,
-0.5029350519180298,
-0.5139095187187195,
-0.2591015696525574,
-0.5343883037567139,
0.4491238594055176,
0.2785765528678894,
0.19088637828826904,
-0.14062415063381195,
0.06960664689540863,
-0.08180955052375793,
0.041949983686208725,
0.14171746373176575,
0.37859198451042175,
0.2008146196603775,
-0.4557727575302124,
-0.1814720630645752,
-0.23770539462566376,
0.11142119020223618,
-0.6752180457115173,
-0.49055010080337524,
-0.30257612466812134,
-0.03390537202358246,
-0.2016444057226181,
0.046873509883880615,
0.23220083117485046,
-0.4677402377128601,
-0.40220966935157776,
-0.19723282754421234,
0.8931247591972351,
0.11562908440828323,
-0.21503998339176178,
0.3966520130634308,
0.5503355264663696,
-0.06923792511224747,
0.06298203766345978,
-0.39122265577316284,
0.03887035697698593,
-0.5441135764122009,
-0.21839676797389984,
0.2260015904903412,
0.6592263579368591,
-0.3612969219684601,
0.8790374398231506,
0.599665641784668,
-0.2463691532611847,
-0.11515628546476364,
-0.32206711173057556,
0.782620370388031,
-0.8353459239006042,
-0.7947450876235962,
-0.6797109842300415,
0.8090161085128784,
0.04260898008942604,
-0.29134121537208557,
0.48791995644569397,
0.13565193116664886,
0.30125361680984497,
-0.10416140407323837,
0.5532185435295105,
-0.5220425724983215,
-0.5226601362228394,
-0.4833088219165802,
0.7815994024276733,
-0.6533987522125244,
0.019482193514704704,
-0.6878007054328918,
-0.7565292716026306,
-0.32459545135498047,
0.5345941781997681,
-0.07284997403621674,
0.2107829451560974,
0.6751149892807007,
0.32884320616722107,
0.07782706618309021,
0.27843230962753296,
0.5688815116882324,
0.057288702577352524,
0.6798521280288696,
0.27647924423217773,
0.9937705397605896,
-0.6515278816223145,
-0.17961463332176208,
-0.0104562072083354,
-0.2379157692193985,
-0.46631547808647156,
-0.8955944776535034,
-0.6524631977081299,
-0.8555107116699219,
-0.21792373061180115,
-0.16220037639141083,
0.0949811115860939,
0.5082305073738098,
0.7042754888534546,
-0.4943258762359619,
-0.20781734585762024,
-0.4557506740093231,
0.6043758392333984,
-0.3678582012653351,
-0.14638736844062805,
0.2327577769756317,
-0.04085421562194824,
-0.6273913383483887,
0.4444195628166199,
0.44629064202308655,
0.3614482879638672,
-0.34137392044067383,
-0.020998746156692505,
-0.29269203543663025,
0.025964098051190376,
0.7018327713012695,
0.5620355606079102,
-0.7686293721199036,
-0.47204962372779846,
-0.42389604449272156,
-0.17498177289962769,
-0.5338646173477173,
1.205644130706787,
-0.9082514047622681,
0.38756564259529114,
0.22187580168247223,
0.6744900941848755,
0.40278011560440063,
-0.3620290160179138,
0.9936460852622986,
-0.14249278604984283,
0.644486665725708,
0.10887202620506287,
0.5894700884819031,
0.22489170730113983,
-0.7422806620597839,
0.759960412979126,
0.6989153027534485,
-0.40145930647850037,
-0.903178870677948,
0.4025460481643677,
-0.6476260423660278,
-0.19425047934055328,
0.5720270276069641,
0.011909750290215015,
-0.30773764848709106,
-0.08344987779855728,
-0.0699644610285759,
0.13534072041511536,
0.16500639915466309,
0.5429529547691345,
0.7035443782806396,
-0.2882686257362366,
0.3988019526004791,
-0.5425059795379639,
0.1110277995467186,
0.15538980066776276,
-0.9618115425109863,
0.011485123075544834,
0.9782232046127319,
-0.1556367129087448,
0.015831654891371727,
0.6907216310501099,
0.2768491506576538,
0.537582278251648,
0.4445933401584625,
-0.0820748582482338,
-0.15404671430587769,
-0.5691096186637878,
-0.09706740826368332,
-0.008346667513251305,
0.040345434099435806,
0.1788785755634308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04110v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04110v1 | Behind the Screen: Investigating ChatGPT's Dark Personality Traits and Conspiracy Beliefs | 2024-02-06T16:03:57 | 2024-02-06T16:03:57 | Erik Weber, Jérôme Rutinowski, Markus Pauly | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT is notorious for its intransparent behavior. This paper tries to shed
light on this, providing an in-depth analysis of the dark personality traits
and conspiracy beliefs of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. Different psychological tests and
questionnaires were employed, including the Dark Factor Test, the Mach-IV
Scale, the Generic Conspiracy Belief Scale, and the Conspiracy Mentality Scale.
The responses were analyzed computing average scores, standard deviations, and
significance tests to investigate differences between GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. For
traits that have shown to be interdependent in human studies, correlations were
considered. Additionally, system roles corresponding to groups that have shown
distinct answering behavior in the corresponding questionnaires were applied to
examine the models' ability to reflect characteristics associated with these
roles in their responses. Dark personality traits and conspiracy beliefs were
not particularly pronounced in either model with little differences between
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. However, GPT-4 showed a pronounced tendency to believe in
information withholding. This is particularly intriguing given that GPT-4 is
trained on a significantly larger dataset than GPT-3.5. Apparently, in this
case an increased data exposure correlates with a greater belief in the control
of information. An assignment of extreme political affiliations increased the
belief in conspiracy theories. Test sequencing affected the models' responses
and the observed correlations, indicating a form of contextual memory. | [
-0.7582842111587524,
-0.6399623155593872,
0.7934407591819763,
-0.229640930891037,
-0.10858465731143951,
0.3473990559577942,
0.12075205892324448,
-0.3369450271129608,
0.19661037623882294,
0.5093154907226562,
-0.5883680582046509,
0.00937797874212265,
-0.7735676765441895,
-0.049965374171733856,
-0.23900145292282104,
1.3922836780548096,
-0.008013531565666199,
-0.06555675715208054,
0.5276193022727966,
0.3824385106563568,
-0.4593701660633087,
-1.0008186101913452,
-0.4863770306110382,
-0.3776051104068756,
0.7764634490013123,
0.4520086348056793,
1.0314648151397705,
0.0908304750919342,
0.6271008849143982,
0.12756040692329407,
0.3950027525424957,
-0.2863529324531555,
-0.8635501265525818,
-0.2597085237503052,
-0.343718022108078,
-0.5526812672615051,
-0.16892394423484802,
0.575661838054657,
0.30802205204963684,
0.19021974503993988,
0.04277356341481209,
0.0063259354792535305,
-0.0797971710562706,
0.3903586268424988,
-0.37096577882766724,
0.032001134008169174,
-0.7072046399116516,
-0.0028998551424592733,
-0.24483777582645416,
-0.26778650283813477,
-0.17037461698055267,
-0.3827398121356964,
0.09318341314792633,
-0.5284032821655273,
0.6754173636436462,
0.12312106788158417,
0.8581165671348572,
-0.0649094358086586,
-0.9627807140350342,
-0.4094008803367615,
-0.8829724788665771,
0.13016317784786224,
-0.48948460817337036,
-0.06211533397436142,
0.6825718879699707,
0.27354326844215393,
-0.03363029658794403,
-0.401686429977417,
-1.043241262435913,
-0.37704193592071533,
-0.17284949123859406,
0.28867921233177185,
-0.0014085907023400068,
0.3261653184890747,
0.5057148337364197,
0.5708882212638855,
-0.5338320136070251,
-0.07015909254550934,
-0.4616328775882721,
-0.2418258786201477,
0.3166511654853821,
0.28883519768714905,
0.06163227930665016,
-0.1403108835220337,
-0.16758328676223755,
-0.19378577172756195,
-0.8286223411560059,
-0.07564056664705276,
0.8613523840904236,
-0.18548595905303955,
-0.16977612674236298,
0.7140365839004517,
-0.1476292461156845,
0.027940191328525543,
0.19647730886936188,
0.2469877004623413,
-0.25373518466949463,
-0.3601195216178894,
-0.3737269639968872,
0.08952412754297256,
0.5748390555381775,
0.55721515417099,
0.2811381220817566,
0.1658320426940918,
0.07310450077056885,
0.5616482496261597,
0.5773142576217651,
-1.0048671960830688,
-0.7122353911399841,
-0.08015038073062897,
-0.5552628040313721,
-0.3694785535335541,
0.11565443128347397,
-0.7504302263259888,
-0.948552131652832,
0.037384893745183945,
0.6410199403762817,
-0.5041793584823608,
-0.45746558904647827,
-0.24840496480464935,
-0.34731167554855347,
0.5035779476165771,
0.39757269620895386,
-0.9880980253219604,
0.2576265037059784,
0.6559253931045532,
0.7267707586288452,
-0.20831671357154846,
-0.14846171438694,
-0.040977369993925095,
0.15870985388755798,
-0.570786714553833,
0.6036124229431152,
-0.7468701601028442,
-0.464823842048645,
-0.2354445457458496,
-0.00047259166603907943,
-0.2825812101364136,
0.0845547765493393,
0.5512834787368774,
-0.7131745219230652,
0.5865708589553833,
-0.7313387989997864,
-0.6600378751754761,
-0.2936781048774719,
0.4529478847980499,
-0.28831911087036133,
0.6475435495376587,
-0.04773824289441109,
-1.1226199865341187,
0.5886681079864502,
-0.7800476551055908,
0.15833021700382233,
-0.14175015687942505,
-0.5136435627937317,
-0.19458551704883575,
0.07210079580545425,
-0.18000738322734833,
0.38488098978996277,
0.09259656071662903,
-0.06533509492874146,
-0.5173438191413879,
-0.6700318455696106,
0.5667687654495239,
-0.43227389454841614,
0.4320419132709503,
0.011253967881202698,
-0.6408986449241638,
0.00482527120038867,
-0.3834989070892334,
-0.2107696533203125,
0.00030092732049524784,
-0.13875462114810944,
-0.04457715153694153,
0.09317312389612198,
-0.5212447047233582,
0.37898898124694824,
-0.10937590152025223,
-0.6313732266426086,
0.3154858350753784,
0.1499352902173996,
0.1349864900112152,
0.8126898407936096,
0.6125993728637695,
0.06353913992643356,
-0.3999117612838745,
0.4906984269618988,
-0.024698715656995773,
0.34384676814079285,
0.11377967894077301,
-0.9327864050865173,
-0.8223613500595093,
0.3257819414138794,
-0.4788815975189209,
0.4928968548774719,
-0.522132933139801,
-0.05109645426273346,
-0.05630897730588913,
-0.7014396786689758,
0.06424850970506668,
-0.4947754144668579,
0.40001457929611206,
0.4805586040019989,
0.1394471675157547,
-0.18296685814857483,
-0.21615704894065857,
-1.113882064819336,
-0.3151262700557709,
-0.29097723960876465,
-0.1712699681520462,
0.25830551981925964,
0.9032617211341858,
-0.1593494564294815,
0.5627213716506958,
-0.6390473246574402,
-0.014506744220852852,
0.13930656015872955,
0.09586650878190994,
0.5659483671188354,
0.465818852186203,
0.31419485807418823,
-0.9949126243591309,
-0.3416629731655121,
-0.03284372761845589,
-0.39540860056877136,
0.3500547409057617,
0.1259964555501938,
-0.01300661452114582,
-0.08955828100442886,
0.52370685338974,
-0.6203670501708984,
0.7242353558540344,
0.5013447999954224,
-0.9203180074691772,
0.8716164231300354,
-0.04685705155134201,
0.7634031772613525,
-0.8740473985671997,
-0.07186861336231232,
-0.27089446783065796,
0.2848753333091736,
-0.9664538502693176,
-0.15314888954162598,
-0.0423063263297081,
-0.05004465579986572,
-0.012564095668494701,
-0.022004786878824234,
-0.4147515296936035,
-0.24634942412376404,
-0.25457969307899475,
0.1099081039428711,
-0.17022787034511566,
0.5933904647827148,
-0.048159413039684296,
0.9205715656280518,
0.34996190667152405,
-0.16223052144050598,
0.28095129132270813,
0.18093135952949524,
-0.4479658305644989,
0.4004311263561249,
-0.3152845501899719,
0.45734184980392456,
-0.018985474482178688,
0.2253754734992981,
-1.3526464700698853,
-0.6911638379096985,
0.4263927936553955,
-0.47076714038848877,
0.19367407262325287,
-0.3447839021682739,
-0.38373348116874695,
-0.11241501569747925,
-0.1276940256357193,
0.1404610425233841,
0.5137903690338135,
-0.055247314274311066,
0.45287153124809265,
0.36572304368019104,
-0.16864420473575592,
-0.3208405673503876,
-0.7870460748672485,
0.24351713061332703,
-0.6371353268623352,
-0.3893335461616516,
0.4528338611125946,
0.0008557674591429532,
-0.4470146894454956,
-0.37174150347709656,
-0.24118556082248688,
-0.10975243151187897,
-0.28815987706184387,
0.37800803780555725,
0.2893577516078949,
-0.29271721839904785,
-0.057083841413259506,
-0.4509412944316864,
0.14309285581111908,
0.2412816882133484,
0.13932077586650848,
0.3655862808227539,
-0.21490393579006195,
-0.4166910648345947,
-0.19566529989242554,
0.40241751074790955,
0.5779364705085754,
0.3264865577220917,
0.771568775177002,
0.5019418001174927,
-0.09650548547506332,
0.3690747320652008,
-0.7603789567947388,
-0.47347918152809143,
-0.4312647581100464,
0.2713107764720917,
-0.44492343068122864,
-0.8983133435249329,
0.9700654149055481,
0.34163424372673035,
-0.24219194054603577,
0.2839593291282654,
0.6546802520751953,
0.05154257267713547,
0.9222252368927002,
0.766769528388977,
0.2448781579732895,
0.6488639116287231,
0.0466969795525074,
0.2763068974018097,
-0.7757391333580017,
-0.18980994820594788,
-0.3408334255218506,
-0.09637794643640518,
-1.0150773525238037,
-0.2847384512424469,
0.4416247606277466,
-0.21941247582435608,
-0.8232842087745667,
0.0029647594783455133,
-0.5700874328613281,
0.5765252709388733,
0.44655531644821167,
0.17278943955898285,
0.16767971217632294,
-0.3636602461338043,
0.09237045794725418,
-0.06864683330059052,
-0.43398410081863403,
-0.5062264204025269,
1.1588401794433594,
0.32791391015052795,
0.6720374822616577,
0.5061894655227661,
0.17095673084259033,
0.45109823346138,
0.36281272768974304,
-0.2613980174064636,
0.4012455344200134,
0.17619800567626953,
-0.9735217690467834,
-0.14300566911697388,
-0.263986200094223,
-0.4895947277545929,
0.4010728597640991,
-0.18963487446308136,
-1.1163010597229004,
0.47350025177001953,
0.23844178020954132,
-0.3396929204463959,
0.32983776926994324,
-1.1643145084381104,
0.8369120955467224,
-0.003335885237902403,
-0.35785582661628723,
-0.5109457969665527,
-0.8087701797485352,
0.8242198824882507,
-0.1254829317331314,
-0.12361513078212738,
-0.32508450746536255,
0.021615996956825256,
0.5768241882324219,
-0.16171663999557495,
1.1998049020767212,
-0.1894908845424652,
-0.049399808049201965,
-0.136633038520813,
0.41455942392349243,
0.6447691917419434,
0.3015129864215851,
-0.018279554322361946,
0.07057678699493408,
0.039537761360406876,
-0.2218037098646164,
-0.4910636246204376,
0.7419037818908691,
-0.9836801290512085,
-0.8908166885375977,
-0.6959971785545349,
-0.4165804386138916,
-0.3295747637748718,
0.23949415981769562,
0.43461495637893677,
0.37735283374786377,
-0.3560585677623749,
0.0907062515616417,
0.8042547106742859,
-0.18277961015701294,
0.2629328966140747,
0.35150986909866333,
-0.18754710257053375,
-0.13555704057216644,
0.3825615644454956,
0.010301302187144756,
0.7595791220664978,
0.18201208114624023,
0.18176424503326416,
-0.00021072637173347175,
-0.5947551727294922,
-0.06797567754983902,
0.029045460745692253,
-0.7341126203536987,
0.18315951526165009,
-0.5461946725845337,
-0.3115624487400055,
-0.2627076804637909,
-0.01519575621932745,
-0.1364160180091858,
-0.20503263175487518,
0.08743049949407578,
-0.01567794196307659,
0.3466005325317383,
0.8801766037940979,
0.4260307550430298,
0.726532518863678,
-0.035395052284002304,
0.45029300451278687,
0.4468589127063751,
0.418503999710083,
-0.4205036461353302,
-0.7015758156776428,
-0.04412984475493431,
0.002881465945392847,
-0.557335615158081,
-1.2964394092559814,
-0.08631458133459091,
-0.08987050503492355,
0.29843780398368835,
0.636062502861023,
-0.09345361590385437,
0.3747585117816925,
-0.056382205337285995,
1.0719884634017944,
-0.06696859002113342,
-0.7283657789230347,
0.1988723874092102,
-0.9358873963356018,
-0.02796425111591816,
0.2942085862159729,
0.3722938001155853,
-0.5496032238006592,
-0.6204323768615723,
-0.9308810830116272,
0.016674267128109932,
0.9023684859275818,
0.7096298336982727,
0.10420738905668259,
0.33034417033195496,
0.23523838818073273,
0.23622259497642517,
0.277424693107605,
-0.8700369596481323,
-0.09042000770568848,
-0.7421160340309143,
0.4974490702152252,
-0.13152174651622772,
-0.18342992663383484,
-0.422782838344574,
-0.06724764406681061,
0.42497363686561584,
-0.35994666814804077,
0.44079360365867615,
0.2621487081050873,
0.4647989571094513,
0.10264134407043457,
0.2827836275100708,
0.8518759608268738,
0.8267678618431091,
-0.3882932662963867,
0.35633164644241333,
0.08635600656270981,
-0.820645809173584,
-0.01986834593117237,
0.02182913012802601,
0.15141792595386505,
-0.41386494040489197,
0.3674406111240387,
0.675035834312439,
-0.03242531046271324,
0.06198182329535484,
0.7415398955345154,
-0.20698268711566925,
-0.09807846695184708,
-0.52176833152771,
0.31851068139076233,
0.034150272607803345,
0.2765890955924988,
0.6003482937812805,
0.4103590250015259,
0.1401350349187851,
-0.992023766040802,
-0.058088500052690506,
0.39036282896995544,
-0.14681376516819,
-0.46420374512672424,
0.6581228971481323,
-0.03265638276934624,
0.0016991742886602879,
0.5974307656288147,
-0.1213143840432167,
-0.6247305870056152,
0.6149215698242188,
0.3291262686252594,
0.6604593992233276,
-0.3175465166568756,
0.3505949079990387,
0.23170849680900574,
0.680363655090332,
0.24907028675079346,
0.08419342339038849,
-0.04637424275279045,
-1.1379880905151367,
-0.2518359124660492,
0.03211857005953789,
-0.6368343830108643,
0.5186184048652649,
-0.2095719575881958,
0.11468718945980072,
-0.5059080123901367,
-0.2643597424030304,
-0.049816280603408813,
0.2675468325614929,
-0.49180880188941956,
0.3171779215335846,
0.057205986231565475,
0.6411911249160767,
-0.6389569044113159,
0.8545618057250977,
0.13344934582710266,
-0.3378487527370453,
-0.7798178791999817,
0.48930177092552185,
0.41949623823165894,
-0.7704859375953674,
0.3425225019454956,
0.2771596610546112,
0.033824678510427475,
-0.1933232843875885,
-0.4154088795185089,
-1.0388706922531128,
0.7975165247917175,
0.4202643632888794,
-0.2508927881717682,
-0.26243388652801514,
0.10265785455703735,
0.3662891089916229,
-0.4243007302284241,
0.5659663677215576,
0.6844553351402283,
0.5616510510444641,
0.005711161997169256,
-0.8248982429504395,
0.2660426199436188,
-0.2588624656200409,
-0.28381937742233276,
0.358601450920105,
-0.802704930305481,
0.9563338160514832,
-0.1689550280570984,
-0.23108892142772675,
-0.3836335837841034,
0.1578749567270279,
0.18383020162582397,
0.20888851583003998,
0.3273972272872925,
-0.07182459533214569,
0.5516501665115356,
-0.14709042012691498,
0.9554696083068848,
-0.1832273006439209,
-0.016978474333882332,
0.8831855654716492,
-0.17224366962909698,
0.1717328280210495,
0.6436533331871033,
-0.14194652438163757,
0.7800968885421753,
0.7945629954338074,
-0.28360775113105774,
0.5820487141609192,
-0.028145311400294304,
-0.17628081142902374,
0.10530557483434677,
0.31540876626968384,
-0.37453019618988037,
0.437032550573349,
0.668118417263031,
-0.3735314905643463,
-0.0959455594420433,
-0.16505712270736694,
0.3850398659706116,
-0.37666982412338257,
-0.1949058324098587,
0.5287193059921265,
-0.11543944478034973,
-0.928905725479126,
0.20059427618980408,
-0.358111172914505,
0.36033982038497925,
-0.816124677658081,
-0.0593118742108345,
-0.24381843209266663,
0.25030165910720825,
-0.26625725626945496,
-1.0959700345993042,
0.17763052880764008,
-0.16913577914237976,
-0.11542734503746033,
-0.057340774685144424,
0.69071364402771,
0.011010267771780491,
0.13763174414634705,
0.01353450771421194,
0.12073355168104172,
0.21010087430477142,
-0.5344142913818359,
-0.4180999994277954,
-0.05157293751835823,
0.28713977336883545,
-0.4844692647457123,
0.22531360387802124,
0.4691522419452667,
-0.2744038701057434,
0.5081501007080078,
0.7348842024803162,
0.19959770143032074,
0.10187379270792007,
-0.15801118314266205,
1.005875587463379,
-0.7452116012573242,
-0.7516413927078247,
-0.9798216223716736,
0.23504503071308136,
-0.4729367196559906,
-0.6030541062355042,
1.0013796091079712,
0.43896612524986267,
0.5639311671257019,
0.023570921272039413,
0.7364933490753174,
-0.2948167622089386,
0.3789919316768646,
-0.5225970149040222,
0.6290284991264343,
0.1509731262922287,
0.09172038733959198,
-0.5779270529747009,
-0.9001960158348083,
0.213647723197937,
0.1813175529241562,
-0.579585075378418,
0.22277241945266724,
0.8156490921974182,
1.0089380741119385,
-0.2627454698085785,
0.390593022108078,
0.298624724149704,
0.43474143743515015,
0.6598547697067261,
0.5980072021484375,
1.1594123840332031,
-0.0828709676861763,
0.6727315187454224,
-0.12910600006580353,
-0.5003291368484497,
-0.2586073577404022,
-0.7686735391616821,
-1.115675926208496,
-0.7338307499885559,
-0.023721834644675255,
-0.2708584666252136,
-0.21064606308937073,
0.11315851658582687,
0.686280369758606,
-0.41418689489364624,
0.00607279734686017,
-0.16306252777576447,
-0.07697480171918869,
0.05468108877539635,
-0.31219008564949036,
0.41389328241348267,
0.3316423296928406,
-0.1370672732591629,
0.20248264074325562,
0.1318325251340866,
0.16767258942127228,
-0.22369684278964996,
0.19055552780628204,
0.011290505528450012,
0.3074687719345093,
0.19289706647396088,
0.11632999777793884,
-0.775193452835083,
-0.8208237886428833,
-0.23542089760303497,
-0.06881885230541229,
0.02825002931058407,
1.0329093933105469,
-0.5077829360961914,
0.2620827257633209,
0.3444800078868866,
-0.1252182424068451,
0.8241803646087646,
0.11298753321170807,
0.8049942255020142,
-0.3297084867954254,
0.11309814453125,
0.2975151836872101,
0.23502886295318604,
0.25318339467048645,
-0.8800435066223145,
0.4657011330127716,
0.3516809642314911,
-1.0685046911239624,
-0.6911031603813171,
0.5022819638252258,
-0.7705642580986023,
-0.17700257897377014,
0.9018781185150146,
0.12658482789993286,
0.28385618329048157,
-0.45454493165016174,
-0.5270929336547852,
0.1284368932247162,
-0.47308021783828735,
1.1428279876708984,
0.8747935891151428,
-0.8079752922058105,
-0.18790309131145477,
-1.0600193738937378,
1.0138731002807617,
-0.029972828924655914,
-0.7165439128875732,
0.21082757413387299,
0.522480309009552,
0.3504054844379425,
0.3005192279815674,
0.8166995644569397,
-0.07239563018083572,
0.2283405363559723,
0.380062073469162,
-0.20202763378620148,
0.07725632935762405,
0.2003130316734314,
0.07963220775127411,
0.394661009311676,
-0.4417422413825989,
-0.059604477137327194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04105v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04105v2 | Measuring Implicit Bias in Explicitly Unbiased Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T15:59:23 | 2024-05-23T15:50:45 | Xuechunzi Bai, Angelina Wang, Ilia Sucholutsky, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can pass explicit social bias tests but still
harbor implicit biases, similar to humans who endorse egalitarian beliefs yet
exhibit subtle biases. Measuring such implicit biases can be a challenge: as
LLMs become increasingly proprietary, it may not be possible to access their
embeddings and apply existing bias measures; furthermore, implicit biases are
primarily a concern if they affect the actual decisions that these systems
make. We address both challenges by introducing two new measures of bias: LLM
Implicit Bias, a prompt-based method for revealing implicit bias; and LLM
Decision Bias, a strategy to detect subtle discrimination in decision-making
tasks. Both measures are based on psychological research: LLM Implicit Bias
adapts the Implicit Association Test, widely used to study the automatic
associations between concepts held in human minds; and LLM Decision Bias
operationalizes psychological results indicating that relative evaluations
between two candidates, not absolute evaluations assessing each independently,
are more diagnostic of implicit biases. Using these measures, we found
pervasive stereotype biases mirroring those in society in 8 value-aligned
models across 4 social categories (race, gender, religion, health) in 21
stereotypes (such as race and criminality, race and weapons, gender and
science, age and negativity). Our prompt-based LLM Implicit Bias measure
correlates with existing language model embedding-based bias methods, but
better predicts downstream behaviors measured by LLM Decision Bias. These new
prompt-based measures draw from psychology's long history of research into
measuring stereotype biases based on purely observable behavior; they expose
nuanced biases in proprietary value-aligned LLMs that appear unbiased according
to standard benchmarks. | [
-0.4400864839553833,
-0.8094848394393921,
0.9635221362113953,
0.4610789716243744,
0.04302745312452316,
0.08586341887712479,
-0.4242393672466278,
-0.4209328889846802,
0.12678326666355133,
0.259601354598999,
-0.49689820408821106,
-0.5133112668991089,
-0.7401496171951294,
0.07428011298179626,
-0.25026935338974,
0.7183392643928528,
-0.04486079514026642,
0.5134535431861877,
-0.347287654876709,
-0.2505095303058624,
-0.42163464426994324,
-0.39966344833374023,
-0.6533458828926086,
-0.47937434911727905,
0.4829239845275879,
0.19719021022319794,
0.6249184608459473,
0.35701504349708557,
0.12794198095798492,
0.21262501180171967,
-0.2772012948989868,
-0.18784739077091217,
-0.36981987953186035,
0.12130506336688995,
-0.1527104526758194,
-0.2807890772819519,
-0.4927372336387634,
0.2805526554584503,
0.7279981374740601,
0.9694034457206726,
0.2521190941333771,
0.36947089433670044,
0.18139022588729858,
0.5490115880966187,
-0.7233465313911438,
0.2181958258152008,
-0.41341549158096313,
0.0710577741265297,
-0.13279438018798828,
0.1912280023097992,
-0.2619699537754059,
-0.5431510210037231,
0.13516202569007874,
-0.19109664857387543,
0.0890093445777893,
0.2486644685268402,
0.27555903792381287,
0.3925200402736664,
-0.7761089205741882,
-0.3597641885280609,
-0.711873471736908,
0.9083219766616821,
-0.6968568563461304,
0.5119588971138,
0.2212637960910797,
0.005020275712013245,
-0.1500513255596161,
-0.2781583368778229,
-0.46213629841804504,
-0.6292382478713989,
-0.03236256539821625,
-0.00009302938997279853,
-0.17411233484745026,
0.12098593264818192,
0.49198248982429504,
0.109280064702034,
-0.22015973925590515,
0.19293217360973358,
-0.07021009176969528,
-0.1779661327600479,
0.7054855823516846,
0.09443315863609314,
0.14931246638298035,
0.03385648876428604,
-0.32600346207618713,
0.060686495155096054,
-0.7243308424949646,
0.014301776885986328,
0.611108660697937,
0.010895558632910252,
-0.11562634259462357,
0.6081333160400391,
-0.1361442655324936,
0.17058897018432617,
0.270616352558136,
0.05338560789823532,
0.23843978345394135,
-0.164311483502388,
0.11132080107927322,
0.4130403697490692,
0.7249642014503479,
0.3921447992324829,
0.5751150250434875,
0.095972940325737,
-0.23025184869766235,
0.24402007460594177,
-0.2458551824092865,
-0.5179657340049744,
0.13449381291866302,
0.07381998002529144,
-0.285221129655838,
-0.21835343539714813,
-0.12336447834968567,
-0.7984188199043274,
-0.8157058954238892,
-0.15963798761367798,
0.024361487478017807,
0.04532884806394577,
-0.30318841338157654,
0.06742295622825623,
-0.12295475602149963,
0.33190348744392395,
0.26649102568626404,
-0.7299468517303467,
0.3768923878669739,
0.6661760210990906,
0.8510466814041138,
-0.3290662169456482,
-0.19712117314338684,
-0.4326241612434387,
0.031135400757193565,
-0.4598325490951538,
0.6768500208854675,
-0.769311249256134,
-0.3227100670337677,
0.19849824905395508,
-0.012969852425158024,
0.29514920711517334,
-0.3237534463405609,
0.6801136136054993,
-0.24658149480819702,
-0.00819369312375784,
-0.6269462704658508,
-0.5545465350151062,
0.00019476105808280408,
0.21373625099658966,
-0.4851866662502289,
1.1741758584976196,
-0.2345624715089798,
-0.7666904926300049,
0.7105910778045654,
-0.4502943754196167,
-0.1706877052783966,
-0.3144289255142212,
-0.3084334433078766,
-0.3096070885658264,
0.3048465847969055,
0.11235770583152771,
0.35001757740974426,
-0.4046533703804016,
0.49514248967170715,
-1.0227270126342773,
-0.3876217305660248,
0.3710542619228363,
-0.5648903250694275,
0.7082663178443909,
-0.16209225356578827,
-0.5727797746658325,
0.1788768619298935,
-0.4271310865879059,
-0.2531547248363495,
0.08081108331680298,
-0.1623067706823349,
-0.6926141381263733,
0.10184408724308014,
-0.2006564736366272,
0.14660927653312683,
0.43197813630104065,
-0.643652081489563,
0.11602838337421417,
-0.140853613615036,
0.0762786790728569,
1.2393808364868164,
-0.18486398458480835,
0.6629433631896973,
-0.0961058959364891,
0.2695619463920593,
-0.09368577599525452,
0.39293792843818665,
0.2178836464881897,
-0.468097984790802,
-0.849395751953125,
-0.3085837960243225,
0.12513074278831482,
0.26418885588645935,
0.0483107715845108,
0.4871619939804077,
-0.07365932315587997,
-0.15607009828090668,
-0.43805965781211853,
0.07484612613916397,
0.3648451864719391,
0.1311083734035492,
0.0778990313410759,
-0.3405844271183014,
-0.33361977338790894,
-0.9937869906425476,
-0.7761462926864624,
-0.28975194692611694,
-0.10430922359228134,
0.3625580668449402,
0.6557746529579163,
-0.377329021692276,
0.8346736431121826,
-0.4356071650981903,
-0.13591501116752625,
0.044543471187353134,
0.36026424169540405,
0.14462529122829437,
0.21181410551071167,
0.2392415702342987,
-0.2982110381126404,
-0.21254301071166992,
-0.3267970383167267,
-0.6415087580680847,
-0.6370452642440796,
0.21546512842178345,
0.10336431115865707,
0.21786010265350342,
0.5236865878105164,
-0.37362009286880493,
0.16226398944854736,
0.4427430331707001,
-0.6975962519645691,
0.5623500943183899,
-0.013240214437246323,
-0.05854225158691406,
-0.4903216063976288,
-0.16713817417621613,
0.24787628650665283,
0.0019506978569552302,
-0.2934507429599762,
-0.32479235529899597,
0.06375143676996231,
0.5083915591239929,
-0.4516136050224304,
0.9848924279212952,
-0.8032292127609253,
-0.5365285277366638,
-0.0313258059322834,
0.09830743819475174,
-0.08401951193809509,
0.21622471511363983,
-0.0177000779658556,
0.48301154375076294,
0.5344247221946716,
-0.5665748119354248,
0.23256847262382507,
-0.051944054663181305,
-0.27177920937538147,
0.6207390427589417,
-0.7357215285301208,
0.34060758352279663,
-0.36039939522743225,
0.41476234793663025,
-1.0451980829238892,
-0.025503138080239296,
0.23139986395835876,
-0.40139541029930115,
0.06879203766584396,
-0.13182024657726288,
-0.36993420124053955,
-0.17495088279247284,
-0.6256886720657349,
0.45302921533584595,
0.6430071592330933,
-0.46246424317359924,
0.6890447735786438,
0.3787870407104492,
-0.2834252119064331,
-0.7045294642448425,
-0.4204059839248657,
-0.21382389962673187,
-0.19701337814331055,
-0.5551591515541077,
0.08257423341274261,
-0.17967671155929565,
-0.6602301597595215,
-0.157215878367424,
-0.32871171832084656,
0.11153172701597214,
-0.00028220348758623004,
0.3043670356273651,
0.3492424190044403,
-0.12377278506755829,
0.02380302920937538,
0.21547284722328186,
0.06530241668224335,
0.5777608156204224,
-0.16672030091285706,
0.6289785504341125,
-0.1371644139289856,
-0.6716914176940918,
0.24933873116970062,
0.1973351538181305,
0.6572367548942566,
0.019565686583518982,
0.505343496799469,
0.6576991081237793,
-0.2531636953353882,
-0.21382054686546326,
-1.0248667001724243,
-0.36289697885513306,
-0.4273448586463928,
0.3625504672527313,
0.018443584442138672,
-1.0005117654800415,
0.5704020857810974,
-0.1930275410413742,
0.026638584211468697,
0.1496373414993286,
0.5863629579544067,
0.17143981158733368,
1.4921399354934692,
0.5734528303146362,
-0.12627510726451874,
0.36215993762016296,
0.21489016711711884,
0.23913463950157166,
-0.9577431678771973,
-0.28668326139450073,
-0.4694299101829529,
-0.20853249728679657,
-0.6693161725997925,
-0.3341084420681,
0.36708536744117737,
-0.023328732699155807,
-0.6093007922172546,
-0.660727322101593,
-0.12255039066076279,
0.4821067750453949,
0.5178349614143372,
-0.025690268725156784,
0.4120217561721802,
-0.18831899762153625,
-0.2320791333913803,
-0.09457884728908539,
-0.2592637538909912,
-0.7299982905387878,
1.271169900894165,
0.5710716247558594,
0.7709117531776428,
-0.1018623560667038,
0.3894563913345337,
0.4829534590244293,
0.6192692518234253,
-0.7695063352584839,
0.6505305767059326,
0.07629061490297318,
-0.6799870729446411,
-0.2692353129386902,
-0.3869277834892273,
-0.5125948786735535,
0.19189386069774628,
-0.17851895093917847,
-0.6076474189758301,
0.30883800983428955,
0.2683449387550354,
-0.030545393005013466,
0.14923378825187683,
-0.46483662724494934,
0.5851466059684753,
-0.49114611744880676,
-0.7316021919250488,
0.10519446432590485,
-0.2781192362308502,
0.6781205534934998,
-0.16698786616325378,
0.2274181991815567,
-0.5273762941360474,
-0.23464302718639374,
0.8748513460159302,
0.04647521674633026,
0.9821147918701172,
-0.2802978754043579,
-0.2797483503818512,
-0.2037467509508133,
0.03584914654493332,
0.6287820339202881,
0.17520001530647278,
-0.016045667231082916,
0.4499906003475189,
-0.24443766474723816,
-0.38806378841400146,
-0.5739618539810181,
0.8594434857368469,
-0.806053876876831,
-0.6837056875228882,
-0.8026247024536133,
-0.48754817247390747,
-0.3760516345500946,
0.19236277043819427,
0.011503832414746284,
-0.066494420170784,
-0.6180927157402039,
-0.12966102361679077,
0.9270352721214294,
-0.4011969566345215,
0.19267746806144714,
1.0090235471725464,
-0.28879547119140625,
0.013183347880840302,
0.3092457056045532,
0.019606223329901695,
0.260814905166626,
0.010267560370266438,
0.4980591833591461,
-0.6282832622528076,
-0.38269928097724915,
-0.022296151146292686,
0.3415837585926056,
-0.5841675400733948,
0.3046829402446747,
-0.6035288572311401,
0.12519903481006622,
-0.6102516651153564,
-0.06973566114902496,
-0.3642999827861786,
0.017115134745836258,
0.06313405185937881,
-0.2715480327606201,
0.3286440968513489,
0.9874354004859924,
-0.13641320168972015,
-0.010686199180781841,
-0.21310807764530182,
0.2781357169151306,
0.44699281454086304,
0.4356211721897125,
-0.01450348924845457,
-0.5050802230834961,
0.29875344038009644,
0.008062493056058884,
-0.024899866431951523,
-1.0253784656524658,
0.26935383677482605,
-0.2124365270137787,
0.5414956212043762,
0.5909048318862915,
0.07188840955495834,
0.27232229709625244,
-0.49216428399086,
0.7167234420776367,
0.18749524652957916,
-1.0700876712799072,
0.2903594374656677,
-0.33157458901405334,
0.10889072716236115,
0.37657588720321655,
0.43705037236213684,
-0.5433051586151123,
-0.5312549471855164,
-0.3330709636211395,
-0.7384148836135864,
0.5580206513404846,
-0.1373244822025299,
0.15675105154514313,
-0.26421719789505005,
0.20749670267105103,
0.00837160274386406,
0.2259935736656189,
-0.9006916880607605,
-0.6581034660339355,
0.15899242460727692,
-0.17453734576702118,
-0.25824880599975586,
-0.6081877946853638,
-0.031137071549892426,
-0.41067132353782654,
0.4964084327220917,
-0.11921264976263046,
0.09460105746984482,
0.12728498876094818,
-0.051403023302555084,
-0.05571923032402992,
0.4936687648296356,
0.3491007387638092,
0.40580397844314575,
-0.40885868668556213,
0.381842702627182,
0.47903183102607727,
-0.5160792469978333,
0.40725380182266235,
0.018527161329984665,
-0.3927759826183319,
0.08511124551296234,
0.1860889345407486,
0.661474347114563,
0.30939239263534546,
-0.6209740042686462,
0.6648736596107483,
0.039042506366968155,
0.010946289636194706,
-0.6488737463951111,
-0.08837827295064926,
0.11620838195085526,
0.3107959032058716,
0.1950463354587555,
-0.1316511183977127,
0.19823837280273438,
-0.6936752796173096,
-0.092505544424057,
0.7387397289276123,
-0.7103589177131653,
-0.36877498030662537,
0.48129090666770935,
0.3428316116333008,
-0.028265034779906273,
0.41036319732666016,
-0.16616103053092957,
-0.41059181094169617,
0.5700315833091736,
0.48269420862197876,
1.0565190315246582,
-0.40365085005760193,
0.23095791041851044,
0.21604418754577637,
0.6709089875221252,
-0.41200339794158936,
0.1687082052230835,
0.07704641669988632,
-0.946639358997345,
-0.24853597581386566,
-0.5571020841598511,
-0.31309670209884644,
0.2034214586019516,
-0.6568423509597778,
0.17838206887245178,
-0.4642980098724365,
-0.27924543619155884,
-0.19693821668624878,
0.036204639822244644,
-0.724768877029419,
-0.13699999451637268,
0.348084032535553,
0.8575337529182434,
-1.1807358264923096,
0.4059699773788452,
0.7151227593421936,
-0.17695990204811096,
-0.3308298587799072,
0.12429095804691315,
0.3180961012840271,
-1.0414154529571533,
0.7791543006896973,
0.13470318913459778,
-0.29448065161705017,
-0.26484158635139465,
-0.6138325333595276,
-0.8750941753387451,
0.9155443906784058,
0.6253803372383118,
-0.724945068359375,
-0.013229329138994217,
0.1561119109392166,
0.34047773480415344,
-0.43539959192276,
0.7177690863609314,
0.9343228936195374,
0.9019373655319214,
-0.19405904412269592,
-0.7632771134376526,
0.3040039837360382,
-0.06902795284986496,
0.052215639501810074,
0.1699569821357727,
-0.5545751452445984,
0.8039666414260864,
-0.23958136141300201,
-0.1944270133972168,
-0.4123111069202423,
0.48649513721466064,
0.4975031316280365,
0.5293031930923462,
0.5827494859695435,
0.3581050634384155,
0.9112086892127991,
-0.09800370782613754,
0.9877097010612488,
-0.13031889498233795,
0.06740308552980423,
1.0633903741836548,
-0.7552773356437683,
0.39761921763420105,
0.5866165161132812,
-0.06379670649766922,
0.2955429255962372,
0.5346111059188843,
0.1917412281036377,
0.19554810225963593,
0.4299529790878296,
-0.48252156376838684,
-0.24063391983509064,
-0.5105607509613037,
-0.24582134187221527,
0.17507536709308624,
0.3454134166240692,
-0.522075355052948,
0.0648019090294838,
-0.3091708719730377,
0.40824392437934875,
-0.07785268872976303,
-0.5428749918937683,
0.7233020663261414,
0.26775896549224854,
-0.5966945290565491,
0.23300263285636902,
-0.07440891116857529,
1.0864982604980469,
-0.6975734233856201,
0.084959976375103,
-0.43949446082115173,
0.07142968475818634,
-0.17314089834690094,
-0.8341223001480103,
-0.050451215356588364,
0.21559275686740875,
-0.27471309900283813,
-0.16451682150363922,
0.726116955280304,
-0.4938828647136688,
-0.6066042184829712,
0.7505806684494019,
0.7201293706893921,
0.08453590422868729,
-0.2444962114095688,
-0.5048388242721558,
0.3474482595920563,
-0.06573996692895889,
-0.4038650393486023,
0.3744262754917145,
0.3540821373462677,
-0.19075120985507965,
0.653838038444519,
0.5499548316001892,
0.3316231071949005,
0.422276109457016,
0.3631545901298523,
0.5175565481185913,
-0.7641099691390991,
-0.24216215312480927,
-1.0813246965408325,
0.10327840596437454,
-0.21581071615219116,
-0.25850436091423035,
0.9353803992271423,
0.3659937083721161,
0.6973713040351868,
0.1904401034116745,
0.9501574039459229,
0.41790083050727844,
0.22893081605434418,
-0.5239256024360657,
0.473897784948349,
-0.31249114871025085,
0.3264695703983307,
-0.42073220014572144,
-1.1816380023956299,
0.0754571333527565,
0.42417603731155396,
-0.674749493598938,
0.3000968098640442,
0.6518270373344421,
0.7359606027603149,
0.028126342222094536,
-0.11699998378753662,
0.1799997240304947,
0.4717414677143097,
0.046432722359895706,
0.37002259492874146,
1.1144429445266724,
0.04251975938677788,
0.13191905617713928,
0.1635693609714508,
-0.5612431168556213,
-0.08488026261329651,
-1.0176137685775757,
-1.0382925271987915,
-0.18496264517307281,
-0.326550155878067,
-0.11227171123027802,
0.17860282957553864,
0.8883586525917053,
0.47508928179740906,
-0.647554874420166,
-0.24831609427928925,
0.10688468813896179,
0.44754648208618164,
-0.07953325659036636,
-0.2940990626811981,
0.11272161453962326,
-0.1511835902929306,
-0.7397762537002563,
0.10660478472709656,
0.2546331584453583,
-0.08364173769950867,
-0.6660698056221008,
-0.2536000609397888,
0.07604880630970001,
0.4082546830177307,
0.6409474611282349,
-0.004723479505628347,
-0.8133228421211243,
-0.41671961545944214,
0.009728513658046722,
0.06882379949092865,
-0.2522357106208801,
0.7848899364471436,
-0.46950894594192505,
0.23434726893901825,
0.4940928518772125,
0.2287137806415558,
0.29087233543395996,
-0.3206408619880676,
0.7785625457763672,
-0.7317788600921631,
-0.04141678288578987,
0.24222347140312195,
0.6294280290603638,
0.3579111099243164,
-0.2486373782157898,
0.23416106402873993,
-0.00027122037135995924,
-0.41584351658821106,
-0.9083822965621948,
0.46097683906555176,
-0.7580347657203674,
-0.16918426752090454,
1.4359937906265259,
0.18750935792922974,
-0.16452538967132568,
-0.35513219237327576,
-0.044915489852428436,
0.17845918238162994,
-0.7383000254631042,
0.747547447681427,
0.6816679239273071,
0.055232658982276917,
-0.05611136555671692,
-0.6443638801574707,
0.5364632606506348,
0.41521093249320984,
-0.5175251960754395,
0.12030746787786484,
0.6576647758483887,
0.4395102560520172,
0.0378265306353569,
0.7096472382545471,
-0.19545577466487885,
0.04157862067222595,
-0.23564741015434265,
0.23555757105350494,
-0.037587519735097885,
-0.14921405911445618,
-0.48288047313690186,
-0.15683448314666748,
0.12357769161462784,
0.1587405502796173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04088v1 | The Use of a Large Language Model for Cyberbullying Detection | 2024-02-06T15:46:31 | 2024-02-06T15:46:31 | Bayode Ogunleye, Babitha Dharmaraj | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.AP, H.3.3 | The dominance of social media has added to the channels of bullying for
perpetrators. Unfortunately, cyberbullying (CB) is the most prevalent
phenomenon in todays cyber world, and is a severe threat to the mental and
physical health of citizens. This opens the need to develop a robust system to
prevent bullying content from online forums, blogs, and social media platforms
to manage the impact in our society. Several machine learning (ML) algorithms
have been proposed for this purpose. However, their performances are not
consistent due to high class imbalance and generalisation issues. In recent
years, large language models (LLMs) like BERT and RoBERTa have achieved
state-of-the-art (SOTA) results in several natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. Unfortunately, the LLMs have not been applied extensively for CB
detection. In our paper, we explored the use of these models for cyberbullying
(CB) detection. We have prepared a new dataset (D2) from existing studies
(Formspring and Twitter). Our experimental results for dataset D1 and D2 showed
that RoBERTa outperformed other models. | [
-0.2814616560935974,
-1.4338080883026123,
0.33292460441589355,
0.504612922668457,
-0.18723569810390472,
0.07548987865447998,
-0.32601073384284973,
-0.6800877451896667,
0.14993110299110413,
0.31029513478279114,
-0.36246341466903687,
-0.3943266272544861,
-1.0917141437530518,
-0.0142503771930933,
-0.6212714910507202,
0.9475701451301575,
0.12754826247692108,
0.2936928868293762,
0.1053953692317009,
0.2609066963195801,
-0.6013652086257935,
-0.7609307765960693,
-0.7647451758384705,
-0.2010812908411026,
0.27477723360061646,
-0.03602372854948044,
0.3559664785861969,
-0.08795162290334702,
0.4045063853263855,
0.27384433150291443,
-0.4776492416858673,
0.15682129561901093,
-0.707793653011322,
0.17761215567588806,
-0.3093242347240448,
-0.37098827958106995,
-0.23716919124126434,
-0.291349321603775,
0.5691843628883362,
0.173362135887146,
0.1270601898431778,
-0.03245455026626587,
0.2320156991481781,
0.37255731225013733,
-0.307031512260437,
0.06170445680618286,
-0.8030489087104797,
-0.05117175355553627,
-0.2824406027793884,
-0.03656935691833496,
-0.6103807687759399,
-0.1861974447965622,
-0.08027967810630798,
0.0900418609380722,
-0.07891452312469482,
0.008513377048075199,
0.8037087321281433,
-0.0834016427397728,
-0.2862466275691986,
-0.4869621694087982,
-0.6403025388717651,
0.7591309547424316,
-0.6889017820358276,
0.16940777003765106,
0.5005399584770203,
0.2352745085954666,
-0.44104066491127014,
-0.34905534982681274,
-0.522621214389801,
-0.05127284675836563,
0.2804197371006012,
-0.3467486798763275,
-0.6828207969665527,
-0.11969345808029175,
0.040043771266937256,
-0.13912153244018555,
-0.7644312381744385,
0.7262457013130188,
-0.4031917452812195,
-0.105243019759655,
0.5355350375175476,
0.11754609644412994,
0.3232276439666748,
-0.33458876609802246,
-0.4228256046772003,
0.08901386708021164,
-0.4600387215614319,
-0.039390068501234055,
0.228159099817276,
0.7093685269355774,
-0.353194922208786,
0.15736709535121918,
0.2468111366033554,
0.8269279599189758,
0.13180653750896454,
-0.4349723756313324,
0.0348605215549469,
-0.052439384162425995,
-0.09893936663866043,
0.007698464673012495,
0.9107456207275391,
0.2732931077480316,
0.5637906193733215,
0.009860963560640812,
-0.11607182770967484,
0.31826838850975037,
0.1879776120185852,
-0.8809147477149963,
-0.07327664643526077,
0.25234511494636536,
-0.6202667951583862,
-0.6243869066238403,
-0.17536845803260803,
-0.6721146106719971,
-0.5112738013267517,
-0.21981938183307648,
0.35557401180267334,
-0.487466037273407,
-0.46200233697891235,
0.004308605100959539,
0.05560915172100067,
-0.0010178624652326107,
0.2117508053779602,
-0.7148022055625916,
0.3971934914588928,
0.8355342745780945,
0.8245294690132141,
-0.10918670892715454,
0.24259592592716217,
-0.517127513885498,
-0.20364999771118164,
-0.19886986911296844,
0.8416873812675476,
-0.6606819033622742,
-0.05738658830523491,
0.1351972222328186,
0.01672402396798134,
0.13912592828273773,
-0.683131992816925,
0.5266559720039368,
-0.5480901002883911,
0.019123723730444908,
0.2201649695634842,
-0.6027469038963318,
-0.18474073708057404,
0.4333643913269043,
-0.30435648560523987,
0.9186919331550598,
0.1079736202955246,
-0.6100951433181763,
0.24383588135242462,
-0.17433558404445648,
-0.705938994884491,
0.18061842024326324,
0.22121566534042358,
-0.9060360789299011,
0.15026098489761353,
0.3435494899749756,
0.9358436465263367,
-0.34734973311424255,
0.6481001973152161,
-0.6893875598907471,
-0.3299099802970886,
0.3243301212787628,
-0.385973185300827,
1.0859512090682983,
0.1387096792459488,
-0.32220742106437683,
0.05017693340778351,
-0.47862884402275085,
0.09602715820074081,
0.21412961184978485,
-0.2149708867073059,
-0.43101975321769714,
-0.05634954944252968,
0.39493489265441895,
0.3517645001411438,
0.024088870733976364,
-0.7222176194190979,
-0.13001060485839844,
-0.01602266915142536,
0.5527476072311401,
0.8159241676330566,
-0.12860676646232605,
-0.1952194720506668,
-0.3526874780654907,
0.5239533185958862,
0.015714773908257484,
-0.009366064332425594,
0.1951272338628769,
-0.6655874848365784,
-0.0899413526058197,
-0.739924967288971,
0.7423484921455383,
0.5453997850418091,
-0.4994315207004547,
0.6745837926864624,
-0.22150757908821106,
-0.5211732387542725,
-0.3742273151874542,
0.09470855444669724,
0.39654913544654846,
-0.016142884269356728,
0.352139949798584,
-0.12480109930038452,
-0.828056812286377,
-0.5640180110931396,
-0.0726529210805893,
-0.013643845915794373,
-0.04315715283155441,
0.10920605808496475,
0.4400966167449951,
-0.19358471035957336,
0.7077434062957764,
-0.1434408724308014,
-0.42010176181793213,
-0.6592284440994263,
0.18310682475566864,
0.14271311461925507,
0.256848007440567,
0.8326522707939148,
-0.9753150343894958,
-0.7602328658103943,
-0.4231816232204437,
-1.0423263311386108,
-0.30080166459083557,
-0.025668974965810776,
0.10532111674547195,
0.3739568591117859,
0.4309239983558655,
-0.46033528447151184,
0.5347312688827515,
0.8598765730857849,
-0.16404315829277039,
0.5742177963256836,
0.18017585575580597,
-0.04475308582186699,
-1.0254708528518677,
-0.21408097445964813,
0.4922439455986023,
-0.6518521904945374,
-0.8518357872962952,
0.16025769710540771,
-0.0323917493224144,
-0.16234171390533447,
-0.3941881060600281,
0.42398908734321594,
-0.18858122825622559,
0.01182249654084444,
-0.5229334831237793,
0.4145919680595398,
-0.30283039808273315,
0.19527587294578552,
-0.004977602977305651,
0.30426913499832153,
0.5064359903335571,
-0.6726128458976746,
0.3200090229511261,
0.10174696892499924,
-0.3447078466415405,
0.9724812507629395,
-0.7838385105133057,
-0.14195197820663452,
-0.24467329680919647,
0.6217198967933655,
-1.1321183443069458,
-0.06879876554012299,
0.13960036635398865,
-0.7782901525497437,
0.4180299937725067,
-0.14116862416267395,
-0.8027826547622681,
-0.6736484169960022,
-0.3368425965309143,
0.06813067942857742,
0.3856164515018463,
-0.6935402154922485,
0.5031018257141113,
0.8008858561515808,
-0.249766543507576,
-0.3300262689590454,
-0.47424614429473877,
0.3666132688522339,
-0.3865354061126709,
-0.8859212398529053,
0.4173620641231537,
-0.06207098066806793,
-0.22997362911701202,
-0.12736953794956207,
0.1257140338420868,
-0.21624071896076202,
0.29105234146118164,
0.16167666018009186,
0.29651936888694763,
0.010401400737464428,
0.17448770999908447,
-0.28662601113319397,
0.12093894183635712,
0.08474908024072647,
0.14183975756168365,
1.0491327047348022,
0.1660672277212143,
0.14288686215877533,
-0.612267255783081,
0.14187957346439362,
0.24984608590602875,
0.047608111053705215,
1.0390998125076294,
0.7748482823371887,
-0.521418571472168,
-0.3411198854446411,
-0.5843236446380615,
-0.2301398068666458,
-0.44008153676986694,
0.4541410207748413,
-0.19203218817710876,
-1.0626757144927979,
0.23617017269134521,
-0.02662571892142296,
-0.18658868968486786,
-0.05628114566206932,
0.7183730006217957,
-0.10828956216573715,
1.0516659021377563,
0.545266330242157,
-0.6394793391227722,
0.6470309495925903,
-0.05216848477721214,
0.5778098702430725,
-0.6212587952613831,
0.07918229699134827,
-0.5396560430526733,
-0.34508904814720154,
-0.7984779477119446,
-0.06698375940322876,
0.27767956256866455,
0.026094358414411545,
0.03174849599599838,
0.6483643054962158,
-0.3616027235984802,
0.13268710672855377,
0.2509503960609436,
0.4766087234020233,
-0.012691210955381393,
0.3091312646865845,
0.3038702607154846,
-0.1082548126578331,
-0.6547088027000427,
-0.39489999413490295,
1.2747070789337158,
0.4986101984977722,
0.5642324090003967,
0.32883936166763306,
0.6509717106819153,
0.43054425716400146,
0.4351099133491516,
-0.6034032106399536,
0.6317861676216125,
-0.4761412739753723,
-0.9122089743614197,
-0.34757912158966064,
-0.5108728408813477,
-1.3310112953186035,
0.390568345785141,
-0.5672056078910828,
-1.0518436431884766,
-0.3344753384590149,
-0.06270674616098404,
-0.13558460772037506,
0.5219702124595642,
-0.2637311518192291,
0.5553674101829529,
-0.04387500509619713,
-0.6128555536270142,
-0.5325783491134644,
-0.45254454016685486,
0.46339544653892517,
-0.41520753502845764,
0.5488857626914978,
0.05684972181916237,
0.6802363991737366,
0.6894286274909973,
-0.2417217642068863,
1.0900039672851562,
-0.2140357494354248,
-0.1608990877866745,
0.5823490619659424,
0.0005275838193483651,
0.64532870054245,
-0.3812600374221802,
0.09482613205909729,
0.06002258136868477,
-0.24275986850261688,
-0.3660246431827545,
-0.3250254690647125,
0.7141851186752319,
-0.4651682376861572,
-0.4276060461997986,
-0.36955946683883667,
-0.4177664816379547,
0.023848745971918106,
0.05492319166660309,
-0.20350578427314758,
0.45867428183555603,
-0.20035713911056519,
0.6094182133674622,
0.7750933766365051,
-0.319084495306015,
0.33569037914276123,
0.6492083072662354,
-0.42227476835250854,
-0.18087421357631683,
0.9595445394515991,
0.08886229991912842,
0.005814789794385433,
0.34107211232185364,
0.3223244845867157,
-0.1522352248430252,
-0.4691159129142761,
-0.09972406178712845,
0.3717891573905945,
-0.25487446784973145,
-0.35017815232276917,
-0.6420189738273621,
-0.2211327850818634,
-0.6945008635520935,
-0.053496137261390686,
0.10670299828052521,
-0.1506311446428299,
0.02302057482302189,
0.016759376972913742,
0.28044605255126953,
0.7782014608383179,
-0.23231208324432373,
0.4562206268310547,
-0.6595810651779175,
0.5986976027488708,
0.23549744486808777,
0.020650360733270645,
0.07390323281288147,
-0.8853938579559326,
-0.02195039950311184,
0.05272027105093002,
-0.5020485520362854,
-0.7288334369659424,
0.5555406212806702,
-0.1703530102968216,
0.3522707223892212,
0.2339620441198349,
-0.08354183286428452,
0.5727750062942505,
-0.1308528482913971,
0.519295334815979,
0.14823147654533386,
-0.5747259259223938,
0.43388548493385315,
-0.5274335741996765,
-0.12734903395175934,
-0.037512026727199554,
0.6764813661575317,
-0.5150410532951355,
-0.27364709973335266,
-0.7840200066566467,
-0.6994897723197937,
0.5061107873916626,
0.12935134768486023,
0.24401426315307617,
-0.03696494922041893,
-0.08015121519565582,
-0.22633180022239685,
0.21493516862392426,
-1.2067251205444336,
0.08927302807569504,
0.2856786549091339,
-0.3968890309333801,
0.052473992109298706,
-0.5106279253959656,
0.2991665005683899,
-0.0659688338637352,
0.9248314499855042,
0.35046741366386414,
0.2412644326686859,
-0.5172566771507263,
-0.1807817667722702,
-0.0412081703543663,
0.1516694575548172,
0.4058069884777069,
0.40294912457466125,
-0.1418711245059967,
-0.2114751785993576,
0.1494094878435135,
-0.2639704942703247,
0.002802459755912423,
0.0026223789900541306,
-0.33954674005508423,
0.14894728362560272,
0.3703409731388092,
0.5776768326759338,
0.35947054624557495,
-0.9280884265899658,
0.8301400542259216,
0.187238410115242,
-0.15384529531002045,
-0.48333749175071716,
-0.12873409688472748,
0.014383579604327679,
0.3431987762451172,
0.05875295773148537,
-0.3499194085597992,
-0.07385178655385971,
-0.782606840133667,
0.23012112081050873,
0.7387687563896179,
-0.2853552997112274,
-0.2116604596376419,
0.4161496162414551,
0.02250410057604313,
-0.5128785371780396,
0.42292481660842896,
-0.27525025606155396,
-0.8951478004455566,
0.5929218530654907,
0.9123736619949341,
0.46905577182769775,
-0.4356040060520172,
0.30617815256118774,
0.3560660183429718,
0.26236268877983093,
-0.19572429358959198,
0.24267621338367462,
0.2519393861293793,
-0.8393417596817017,
-0.1698935329914093,
-0.547845184803009,
-0.06826095283031464,
0.6725999116897583,
-0.3963510990142822,
0.5237698554992676,
-0.8563370108604431,
-0.4391312897205353,
0.2304036021232605,
-0.12966296076774597,
-0.5620608925819397,
0.2995043992996216,
0.49381667375564575,
0.450993150472641,
-1.0054821968078613,
0.5833800435066223,
0.4621688723564148,
-0.0976792722940445,
-0.4889707863330841,
-0.0618818961083889,
0.30032238364219666,
-0.7307896614074707,
0.8900892734527588,
0.4257615804672241,
0.1179371178150177,
-0.25371330976486206,
-0.5770111680030823,
-0.6163259148597717,
0.36045902967453003,
-0.06888474524021149,
-0.5131640434265137,
0.09677545726299286,
0.14872963726520538,
0.8000218868255615,
-0.3106554448604584,
0.102280393242836,
0.3101612627506256,
0.41713255643844604,
-0.2655331492424011,
-0.9182230830192566,
-0.05927550792694092,
-0.0402148962020874,
0.10182616114616394,
0.33755967020988464,
-0.7452152371406555,
0.8275666236877441,
0.1433182954788208,
0.09968038648366928,
-0.002444932935759425,
0.4431869089603424,
0.5900959968566895,
0.15020832419395447,
0.4058547019958496,
0.6652323603630066,
0.5049670934677124,
-0.055481210350990295,
0.7648131251335144,
-0.20258398354053497,
0.22932952642440796,
0.9755293726921082,
-0.11559487134218216,
0.9643735885620117,
-0.15302641689777374,
-0.46613889932632446,
0.5837085843086243,
0.44194114208221436,
-0.2835961580276489,
0.27052685618400574,
0.6498886346817017,
-0.1717521995306015,
-0.42448174953460693,
-0.180267333984375,
-0.058947958052158356,
0.6712068319320679,
0.575300931930542,
-0.44447314739227295,
-0.19644221663475037,
0.16882920265197754,
0.6706175804138184,
0.45172613859176636,
-0.49498146772384644,
0.5365258455276489,
0.0030991530511528254,
-0.40267056226730347,
0.6862512826919556,
0.28137198090553284,
1.087673544883728,
-0.4103882312774658,
0.16207720339298248,
0.06798175722360611,
0.3466016352176666,
-0.11043347418308258,
-0.6037133932113647,
0.03321429714560509,
0.3611464202404022,
0.013687324710190296,
-0.17965906858444214,
0.8829570412635803,
-0.23946024477481842,
-0.6592401266098022,
0.5941330194473267,
0.2230372279882431,
0.4178151488304138,
-0.06013491749763489,
-0.7005871534347534,
0.19348150491714478,
-0.08219980448484421,
0.004120741505175829,
0.7003723382949829,
0.4401608109474182,
-0.17509008944034576,
0.8120519518852234,
0.5463855266571045,
0.06912921369075775,
-0.014831778593361378,
0.06555493175983429,
0.8609750270843506,
-0.2645241320133209,
-0.6020625233650208,
-0.9618444442749023,
0.12576714158058167,
-0.35321056842803955,
-0.028412150219082832,
0.7356429696083069,
0.4105825126171112,
0.759234607219696,
0.2448093295097351,
0.829031229019165,
-0.29467499256134033,
0.9762989282608032,
-0.4579457938671112,
0.26058563590049744,
-0.23829790949821472,
0.06055862456560135,
-0.6741265654563904,
-0.913761556148529,
-0.3333023488521576,
0.8604474663734436,
-0.37948670983314514,
0.19282805919647217,
0.44543176889419556,
0.7820336222648621,
0.08068014681339264,
0.09600307047367096,
0.40926072001457214,
0.4108976721763611,
0.48816990852355957,
0.43905171751976013,
0.41257038712501526,
-0.4855113625526428,
0.5299557447433472,
0.27504876255989075,
-0.3295932710170746,
-0.531018078327179,
-0.5850757360458374,
-1.5906091928482056,
-0.2718825936317444,
-0.17360636591911316,
-0.5703224539756775,
0.4416099786758423,
1.0025259256362915,
0.6756078600883484,
-0.9402938485145569,
-0.1588890105485916,
0.2035144418478012,
-0.10014550387859344,
-0.09063809365034103,
-0.2425534576177597,
-0.028060106560587883,
-0.2517269551753998,
-0.5805459022521973,
0.3226214647293091,
-0.06626597046852112,
0.026437917724251747,
-0.3089199662208557,
0.21794207394123077,
-0.4874521493911743,
0.10484309494495392,
0.9672122597694397,
0.06093413755297661,
-0.575397789478302,
-0.2973194718360901,
-0.3639778196811676,
-0.010608200915157795,
-0.072636179625988,
0.408575177192688,
-0.731282651424408,
0.15634454786777496,
0.38940268754959106,
0.6853387951850891,
0.6206654906272888,
0.12769174575805664,
0.3218808174133301,
-0.722503125667572,
0.19633594155311584,
0.0004214948567096144,
0.2658359110355377,
0.4137967526912689,
-0.17460498213768005,
0.5183656811714172,
0.3242373764514923,
-0.48914143443107605,
-0.9379128813743591,
0.06159939244389534,
-0.47310885787010193,
-0.8102772235870361,
1.0947153568267822,
-0.16085614264011383,
-0.3791804611682892,
-0.2016773670911789,
-0.1236397922039032,
0.18665020167827606,
-0.4957257807254791,
1.183203101158142,
0.7560369372367859,
0.24321158230304718,
0.09428068995475769,
-0.4726451337337494,
0.025243479758501053,
0.2520858645439148,
-0.6812576055526733,
-0.0009476899867877364,
0.35081058740615845,
0.3852211833000183,
0.07005900144577026,
0.3896337151527405,
0.07384074479341507,
0.064274862408638,
-0.28713035583496094,
-0.04288710281252861,
0.08644505590200424,
-0.5266751646995544,
-0.27250799536705017,
0.3565077483654022,
-0.3414241671562195,
0.22654777765274048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07932v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07932v1 | A Human-Machine Collaboration Framework for the Development of Schemas | 2024-02-06T15:41:49 | 2024-02-06T15:41:49 | Nicos Isaak | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0; I.2.3; I.2.4; I.2.7; I.5.1; I.5.4 | The Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC), a seemingly well-thought-out test for
machine intelligence, has been proposed to shed light on developing systems
that exhibit human behavior. Since its introduction, it aimed to pivot the
focus of the AI community from the technology to the science of AI. While
common and trivial for humans, studies show that it is still challenging for
machines, especially when they have to deal with novel schemas, that is,
well-designed sentences that require the resolving of definite pronouns. As
researchers have become increasingly interested in the challenge itself, this
presumably necessitates the availability of an extensive collection of Winograd
schemas, which goes beyond what human experts can reasonably develop
themselves, especially after proposed ways of utilizing them as novel forms of
CAPTCHAs.
To address this necessity, we propose a novel framework that explicitly
focuses on how humans and machines can collaborate as teammates to design novel
schemas from scratch. This is being accomplished by combining two recent
studies from the literature: i) Winventor, a machine-driven approach for the
development of large amounts of Winograd schemas, albeit not of high quality,
and ii) WinoFlexi, an online crowdsourcing system that allows crowd workers to
develop a limited number of schemas often of similar quality to that of
experts. Our proposal crafts a new road map toward developing a novel
collaborative platform that amplifies human and machine intelligence by
combining their complementary strengths. | [
-0.5163058042526245,
-0.22138331830501556,
0.5937040448188782,
0.0014847054844722152,
0.30368930101394653,
0.5827483534812927,
-0.28255343437194824,
-0.7371468544006348,
0.3569338917732239,
0.5202337503433228,
-0.6838045716285706,
-0.2923179268836975,
-0.3999086022377014,
0.15136028826236725,
0.03598104417324066,
0.8561502695083618,
-0.08642713725566864,
-0.16140061616897583,
-0.5829315781593323,
-0.17893341183662415,
-0.6183140277862549,
-0.38409414887428284,
0.10759824514389038,
-0.248755544424057,
0.577032744884491,
0.7503266334533691,
0.9811056852340698,
0.4469599723815918,
0.8859209418296814,
0.374995619058609,
0.02082192152738571,
0.3671516478061676,
-0.05139283463358879,
0.5830203890800476,
-0.4368957579135895,
-0.3308820128440857,
-0.3410547077655792,
0.22714197635650635,
0.04636968672275543,
1.3503618240356445,
-0.5542195439338684,
0.32063740491867065,
0.06437287479639053,
0.5079441666603088,
-0.5192614793777466,
0.23242856562137604,
-0.4302627146244049,
0.10064227133989334,
-0.2786020338535309,
0.2797667384147644,
-0.4227103888988495,
-0.25124630331993103,
0.06147417798638344,
-1.0887647867202759,
0.3008567690849304,
0.49098047614097595,
0.6523277759552002,
0.31604456901550293,
-0.16124102473258972,
-0.27456504106521606,
-0.8375851511955261,
0.5484817028045654,
-0.37812790274620056,
-0.03556947037577629,
0.17788736522197723,
0.434833288192749,
-0.6568633317947388,
-0.5775703191757202,
-0.6578529477119446,
-0.05663067474961281,
-0.15743690729141235,
0.03985077515244484,
-0.12404268980026245,
0.002240653382614255,
0.22429344058036804,
0.17415690422058105,
-0.7994871139526367,
0.04668150097131729,
-0.6556800603866577,
-0.39950960874557495,
0.7754321098327637,
0.46759989857673645,
0.14883211255073547,
-0.03305232897400856,
-0.2672736644744873,
0.13697363436222076,
-0.32894086837768555,
-0.16406194865703583,
0.2375885397195816,
0.48457953333854675,
0.3358606696128845,
0.6961809992790222,
-0.5175696611404419,
0.492532342672348,
0.05966838821768761,
0.0016449708491563797,
0.4320157468318939,
-0.28591468930244446,
-0.03314003348350525,
-0.12567798793315887,
0.878324031829834,
0.19178326427936554,
-0.023242074996232986,
-0.4134346842765808,
0.17156848311424255,
0.5818313360214233,
0.29445621371269226,
-0.38523921370506287,
-0.19314180314540863,
0.28427737951278687,
-0.5441963076591492,
-0.6332375407218933,
0.24908919632434845,
-0.5307201147079468,
-0.5001981258392334,
-0.46764227747917175,
0.3455827832221985,
-0.2721605896949768,
-0.3420725464820862,
0.1441064178943634,
-0.3915262222290039,
0.15940947830677032,
0.2871011793613434,
-0.7700673937797546,
0.3660469055175781,
0.8953641057014465,
0.3621409237384796,
-0.07740763574838638,
-0.8012558817863464,
-0.46252143383026123,
0.3684788942337036,
-0.5523272156715393,
0.9270961284637451,
-0.48998305201530457,
-0.35792022943496704,
-0.3999408781528473,
-0.09867125004529953,
-0.016621844843029976,
-0.4275969862937927,
0.1390998810529709,
-0.18562914431095123,
0.8783162236213684,
-0.2875767648220062,
-0.3995080590248108,
0.002155476249754429,
0.10707210004329681,
-0.513078510761261,
0.9835271239280701,
0.3630559742450714,
-1.0491245985031128,
0.5139502882957458,
-1.064754605293274,
-0.5201154351234436,
0.5797966718673706,
-0.45019906759262085,
-0.121167853474617,
0.055471137166023254,
-0.3040768802165985,
0.1606176495552063,
-0.5672090649604797,
0.6482287645339966,
-0.4813850522041321,
-0.494736909866333,
0.11248885095119476,
0.2560136616230011,
1.0911800861358643,
0.20146626234054565,
-0.41547688841819763,
0.5271850824356079,
-0.5354021191596985,
0.07302791625261307,
0.3033830523490906,
-0.02839302271604538,
-0.22720664739608765,
0.15429481863975525,
-0.2826421558856964,
0.3745397925376892,
0.29219889640808105,
-0.49512338638305664,
0.3504864573478699,
-0.060747090727090836,
0.4897712767124176,
0.7143533229827881,
-0.21574899554252625,
0.6396016478538513,
-0.6176474094390869,
0.39044442772865295,
-0.4209752678871155,
0.411167711019516,
-0.275795042514801,
-0.5925319194793701,
-0.7459017634391785,
-0.361554354429245,
0.018674122169613838,
0.7232587337493896,
-0.6845776438713074,
0.5053321719169617,
0.08577799052000046,
-0.7259394526481628,
-0.8869869709014893,
0.06213625147938728,
0.17547807097434998,
0.40736663341522217,
0.24995237588882446,
-0.4703509211540222,
-0.5379191040992737,
-1.129329800605774,
0.032253071665763855,
-0.43161511421203613,
-0.4841630160808563,
0.316851943731308,
0.5230399966239929,
-0.11576097458600998,
1.1775667667388916,
-0.448869913816452,
-0.3894446790218353,
-0.18215227127075195,
0.26493415236473083,
0.06830119341611862,
0.6285886764526367,
0.33247536420822144,
-0.6176950335502625,
-0.21789437532424927,
-0.11463998258113861,
-1.1896471977233887,
0.26552918553352356,
0.18413546681404114,
-0.5487464666366577,
-0.09030947089195251,
0.44255581498146057,
-0.9573955535888672,
0.34165024757385254,
0.21929563581943512,
-0.7564920783042908,
0.7735991477966309,
-0.24182601273059845,
0.16795341670513153,
-1.15260910987854,
0.3576671779155731,
-0.7145137786865234,
0.04756630212068558,
-0.5668805241584778,
0.3615437150001526,
-0.35451358556747437,
-0.32002726197242737,
-0.40402621030807495,
0.01911320723593235,
-0.34825798869132996,
-0.16715006530284882,
0.07122956961393356,
0.1161341592669487,
0.07423144578933716,
0.45520395040512085,
-0.13014930486679077,
0.4908641278743744,
0.5712471008300781,
-0.2828192114830017,
0.3893260955810547,
0.5232530236244202,
-0.003615161869674921,
1.2112784385681152,
-0.7699295878410339,
0.3566751182079315,
-0.14954876899719238,
0.1473671942949295,
-0.679122269153595,
-0.7021501064300537,
0.4905077815055847,
-0.5376880764961243,
0.07835646718740463,
0.2732242941856384,
-0.86662757396698,
-0.7605080604553223,
-0.22300297021865845,
0.19679105281829834,
0.2509310245513916,
-0.1514022946357727,
0.659735918045044,
0.6507886648178101,
-0.11541564017534256,
-0.28816574811935425,
-0.33870789408683777,
0.48055121302604675,
-0.2633189558982849,
-0.9815154075622559,
0.6610889434814453,
-0.34520167112350464,
-0.5253914594650269,
0.03698166832327843,
0.3327198326587677,
0.04633477330207825,
0.38101300597190857,
0.5127546787261963,
0.43181052803993225,
-0.11771600693464279,
0.05728272721171379,
-0.02818393148481846,
-0.48317134380340576,
0.01767246052622795,
-0.4459315538406372,
0.19638338685035706,
-0.3246505558490753,
-0.39671456813812256,
-0.5218477249145508,
0.9073293805122375,
0.732255756855011,
-0.39945176243782043,
0.5476925373077393,
0.3711465001106262,
-0.5636087656021118,
0.08251239359378815,
-0.4556753933429718,
-0.19082699716091156,
-0.5047018527984619,
-0.01791062392294407,
-0.35930752754211426,
-1.1166239976882935,
0.4075515568256378,
-0.12506726384162903,
0.23322011530399323,
0.2784562408924103,
0.41440337896347046,
-0.6253988742828369,
0.8269554972648621,
0.8472992777824402,
-0.06743739545345306,
-0.07493039220571518,
0.11083877086639404,
-0.18857470154762268,
-0.5556319355964661,
-0.47567468881607056,
-0.6769209504127502,
-0.37439990043640137,
-0.4696924686431885,
-0.5666807889938354,
-0.08667928725481033,
-0.24041062593460083,
-0.6208505630493164,
0.6788308620452881,
-0.8654295206069946,
0.4604388177394867,
0.8782864809036255,
-0.09177514910697937,
0.2722543478012085,
-0.1896514892578125,
-0.30091044306755066,
-0.28895682096481323,
-0.7461809515953064,
-0.44940897822380066,
0.7184569835662842,
-0.01345788687467575,
0.2528838515281677,
0.016793549060821533,
0.7685868144035339,
0.5098134279251099,
0.3620070219039917,
-0.3065713942050934,
0.6555922627449036,
0.3454737663269043,
-0.9007554650306702,
-0.3181707262992859,
-0.20576104521751404,
-1.0205892324447632,
0.371356725692749,
-0.26800552010536194,
-0.7526839375495911,
0.1321418583393097,
-0.03532055765390396,
-0.16200141608715057,
0.24879956245422363,
-0.3815990090370178,
1.042889952659607,
-0.12119711935520172,
-0.4638044238090515,
-0.09862104803323746,
-1.138662576675415,
-0.014933212660253048,
0.32733455300331116,
0.508250892162323,
-0.19849473237991333,
0.06739014387130737,
0.8601528406143188,
-0.46616971492767334,
0.832243025302887,
-0.24378702044487,
-0.12265640497207642,
0.61851966381073,
0.536109447479248,
0.30984124541282654,
-0.33585935831069946,
-0.030654925853013992,
0.15526655316352844,
-0.3913457691669464,
-0.6308735013008118,
-0.24646542966365814,
0.28752878308296204,
-0.3185330629348755,
-0.5486516356468201,
-0.38095414638519287,
-0.6054744720458984,
-0.24390418827533722,
0.5421156883239746,
0.13823626935482025,
-0.20274056494235992,
-0.40105709433555603,
0.027412669733166695,
0.3103042244911194,
0.18933504819869995,
0.25592535734176636,
0.3529151678085327,
-0.17442423105239868,
-0.4467858076095581,
1.0305076837539673,
-0.2534834146499634,
0.0355110839009285,
0.010178213007748127,
0.022978436201810837,
0.40412721037864685,
-0.27674615383148193,
-0.41974422335624695,
0.255985826253891,
-0.33843693137168884,
-0.2686242461204529,
-0.06572746485471725,
0.1044868528842926,
-0.12741076946258545,
-0.3826018273830414,
-0.49462053179740906,
-0.41401898860931396,
-0.2984639108181,
0.00521699246019125,
0.02703874185681343,
0.8058374524116516,
-0.11590433120727539,
-0.0207402054220438,
-0.43784916400909424,
-0.09544380754232407,
0.22665585577487946,
0.25049474835395813,
-0.29992353916168213,
-0.03891358524560928,
0.12946590781211853,
-0.038189299404621124,
-0.35276302695274353,
-0.8280801177024841,
0.01029465813189745,
-0.2841397225856781,
0.6983289122581482,
0.399392306804657,
0.15471124649047852,
0.5389087796211243,
-0.39715561270713806,
0.6634547114372253,
0.17814123630523682,
-0.9958652853965759,
0.6282632946968079,
-0.7372987866401672,
-0.1946219801902771,
0.8199902176856995,
0.15141429007053375,
-0.7330003380775452,
-0.5785613059997559,
-0.7796964645385742,
-0.6837144494056702,
0.6029280424118042,
0.6332716345787048,
-0.2103477567434311,
0.06309808045625687,
0.009332678280770779,
0.4096055030822754,
0.44445306062698364,
-0.11090795695781708,
0.04658793658018112,
-0.03278995677828789,
-0.3068380057811737,
0.2765520513057709,
0.20551735162734985,
-0.3586744964122772,
0.1343412846326828,
0.01492522843182087,
-0.22708231210708618,
0.3243161141872406,
-0.0015462719602510333,
0.03724047169089317,
-0.11955509334802628,
0.1331135779619217,
0.38615167140960693,
0.6425634026527405,
0.032004933804273605,
0.1458822786808014,
0.07329418510198593,
-0.0323030948638916,
-0.012679441832005978,
0.13430264592170715,
-0.4193565845489502,
-0.2102913111448288,
0.5241683125495911,
0.4215485453605652,
0.22500237822532654,
-0.7642857432365417,
0.46566155552864075,
0.12416514754295349,
-0.8481189012527466,
-0.16762275993824005,
0.18979354202747345,
0.43186521530151367,
0.45809677243232727,
0.49920061230659485,
0.500015139579773,
0.04127209633588791,
-0.27659112215042114,
0.3699166476726532,
0.33785977959632874,
-0.5303023457527161,
-0.3407856225967407,
0.8981589078903198,
0.2938604950904846,
-0.7574395537376404,
0.46926236152648926,
-0.7654809355735779,
-0.6625987887382507,
0.728003740310669,
0.27981171011924744,
0.41170215606689453,
-0.16860857605934143,
0.6101314425468445,
0.04926314577460289,
0.387425035238266,
-0.08175897598266602,
0.31500348448753357,
-0.329772412776947,
-0.44413313269615173,
-0.13420400023460388,
0.02635928802192211,
-0.6039755344390869,
-0.4984111487865448,
-0.7235572338104248,
0.1822071671485901,
-0.07107382267713547,
-0.10895149409770966,
-0.12350296229124069,
-0.01651359349489212,
-0.795211672782898,
-0.2000475525856018,
0.20225098729133606,
0.5985416769981384,
-0.5933745503425598,
0.1694350242614746,
0.6642460823059082,
-0.40564098954200745,
-0.4271506071090698,
-0.3191291391849518,
0.05703660845756531,
-0.28651168942451477,
0.2996668219566345,
0.197341650724411,
-0.10596150904893875,
-0.23530012369155884,
-0.7673881649971008,
-0.8008859753608704,
1.4591120481491089,
0.2281838357448578,
-0.43521907925605774,
-0.29179489612579346,
0.0557006374001503,
0.6151724457740784,
-0.5512596964836121,
-0.08823325484991074,
0.25347843766212463,
0.515510082244873,
-0.03289881348609924,
-1.116736650466919,
0.260189414024353,
-0.3380652964115143,
-0.23583342134952545,
0.12178032100200653,
-0.7744974493980408,
0.8634516596794128,
-0.8018643856048584,
-0.15215308964252472,
0.17679505050182343,
0.8418112397193909,
0.38184988498687744,
0.7100528478622437,
0.5496478080749512,
0.24996259808540344,
1.2573480606079102,
0.14370092749595642,
0.4170442223548889,
0.02072053961455822,
0.35774287581443787,
1.2171926498413086,
-0.7039551734924316,
0.7401984333992004,
0.6046256422996521,
-0.48889753222465515,
0.6638821959495544,
0.4497058689594269,
-0.18144850432872772,
0.23964038491249084,
0.3814812898635864,
-0.05514839291572571,
-0.4707549214363098,
-0.20560795068740845,
-0.33516812324523926,
0.667023777961731,
0.3556881546974182,
-0.016451412811875343,
-0.05804886296391487,
0.24654756486415863,
0.2075328826904297,
0.2466285228729248,
0.20283563435077667,
0.7842187881469727,
-0.4321253001689911,
-0.7439085841178894,
-0.04442277550697327,
-0.14514189958572388,
0.5971343517303467,
-0.22211764752864838,
-0.01110220979899168,
-0.2387826293706894,
-0.07369014620780945,
-0.047590579837560654,
-0.5064378380775452,
0.24766410887241364,
-0.11836356669664383,
-0.23245090246200562,
0.09828436374664307,
0.6088923811912537,
-0.26741689443588257,
-0.500276505947113,
0.2939296066761017,
0.7606374621391296,
0.06310570985078812,
0.0445668026804924,
-0.4846225082874298,
-0.06182447448372841,
-0.13768884539604187,
0.05554458126425743,
0.2820230722427368,
0.36467987298965454,
-0.13544395565986633,
0.6692022681236267,
0.7924887537956238,
-0.06778378039598465,
-0.4971697926521301,
-0.3157254457473755,
1.071545958518982,
-0.7281615734100342,
-0.42133820056915283,
-0.547118067741394,
0.48858407139778137,
-0.36569660902023315,
-0.1747848391532898,
0.41722381114959717,
0.5959891080856323,
0.8261111378669739,
0.04513521492481232,
0.9841818809509277,
-0.5252669453620911,
0.6239603757858276,
0.23237614333629608,
0.863719642162323,
-0.2949462831020355,
0.010303575545549393,
-0.6548210382461548,
-0.6902614235877991,
-0.5692935585975647,
0.6573209762573242,
0.3940165042877197,
-0.26759329438209534,
0.5605116486549377,
0.5524818301200867,
0.20858682692050934,
0.09819868206977844,
-0.03829282149672508,
-0.18105338513851166,
0.43602076172828674,
0.8210756182670593,
0.9946863651275635,
-0.18443048000335693,
0.8858259320259094,
-0.5405656099319458,
-0.4702504575252533,
-0.3349098265171051,
-0.7829723954200745,
-0.872399628162384,
-0.71242356300354,
-0.22496181726455688,
-0.3190152049064636,
0.15097378194332123,
1.000055193901062,
0.6965618133544922,
-0.5440056920051575,
-0.2394455373287201,
-0.14233793318271637,
0.19233712553977966,
-0.42344173789024353,
-0.18353302776813507,
0.3012838363647461,
-0.159287691116333,
-0.33768022060394287,
0.3829805254936218,
0.3586697280406952,
-0.13119928538799286,
-0.3963305354118347,
-0.3244920074939728,
0.25617942214012146,
0.023917455226182938,
0.49199870228767395,
0.2933502197265625,
-0.47112804651260376,
-0.4262197017669678,
0.6415529251098633,
-0.22100384533405304,
-0.13427363336086273,
1.0669039487838745,
-0.7739719748497009,
0.4322241246700287,
0.3589680790901184,
0.34846746921539307,
0.019898395985364914,
0.0023987647145986557,
0.40660327672958374,
-0.22115780413150787,
0.2168482393026352,
0.31937727332115173,
0.19825023412704468,
0.31202203035354614,
-0.17153124511241913,
0.5936136841773987,
0.6082050800323486,
-0.53731769323349,
-1.0345516204833984,
0.3270072340965271,
-0.7221181988716125,
-0.4378701448440552,
0.6281234622001648,
-0.010398512706160545,
0.013839288614690304,
-0.40666377544403076,
-0.5758721828460693,
0.0029497838113456964,
-0.4027279019355774,
1.018536925315857,
0.6809333562850952,
-0.3739355504512787,
0.5126878023147583,
-0.2408285290002823,
0.310321569442749,
0.3313409984111786,
-0.9133645296096802,
0.29116764664649963,
0.532360851764679,
0.021916497498750687,
0.5937919020652771,
0.6903365254402161,
0.23254390060901642,
0.46792709827423096,
0.3873249590396881,
0.2822859287261963,
-0.4931115508079529,
-0.6690275073051453,
0.5033426880836487,
0.44071051478385925,
-0.07141140103340149,
-0.4147353172302246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04075v1 | Iterative Prompt Refinement for Radiation Oncology Symptom Extraction Using Teacher-Student Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T15:25:09 | 2024-02-06T15:25:09 | Reza Khanmohammadi, Ahmed I Ghanem, Kyle Verdecchia, Ryan Hall, Mohamed Elshaikh, Benjamin Movsas, Hassan Bagher-Ebadian, Indrin Chetty, Mohammad M. Ghassemi, Kundan Thind | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study introduces a novel teacher-student architecture utilizing Large
Language Models (LLMs) to improve prostate cancer radiotherapy symptom
extraction from clinical notes. Mixtral, the student model, initially extracts
symptoms, followed by GPT-4, the teacher model, which refines prompts based on
Mixtral's performance. This iterative process involved 294 single symptom
clinical notes across 12 symptoms, with up to 16 rounds of refinement per
epoch. Results showed significant improvements in extracting symptoms from both
single and multi-symptom notes. For 59 single symptom notes, accuracy increased
from 0.51 to 0.71, precision from 0.52 to 0.82, recall from 0.52 to 0.72, and
F1 score from 0.49 to 0.73. In 375 multi-symptom notes, accuracy rose from 0.24
to 0.43, precision from 0.6 to 0.76, recall from 0.24 to 0.43, and F1 score
from 0.20 to 0.44. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of advanced
prompt engineering in LLMs for radiation oncology use. | [
0.12259268760681152,
-0.7405405044555664,
1.2472350597381592,
0.22737838327884674,
-0.383828341960907,
-0.12388209998607635,
-0.2510739862918854,
-0.13303399085998535,
0.06750180572271347,
0.37034252285957336,
-0.857038140296936,
-0.7974268794059753,
-0.6951754093170166,
0.4419616460800171,
-0.21085752546787262,
0.8120598196983337,
0.08183273673057556,
0.5275605320930481,
0.23643240332603455,
0.25115150213241577,
-0.7889416813850403,
0.2601892948150635,
-0.9827144742012024,
-0.4737534523010254,
0.4746508300304413,
0.8836508989334106,
0.5793363451957703,
0.37967410683631897,
0.6003220081329346,
0.21988093852996826,
-0.035272590816020966,
-0.34560516476631165,
-0.4513564705848694,
0.34673354029655457,
-0.13736006617546082,
0.007823852822184563,
-0.4713890552520752,
-0.01107016485184431,
0.455423504114151,
0.6296616792678833,
-0.15456995368003845,
-0.13847994804382324,
0.1335703283548355,
0.5382214188575745,
-0.4205671548843384,
0.35296618938446045,
-0.13234709203243256,
0.21700727939605713,
-0.07543597370386124,
-0.5889392495155334,
-0.619784951210022,
-0.5394008755683899,
0.3433372378349304,
-0.6841506361961365,
0.19023014605045319,
-0.35098007321357727,
0.8862124085426331,
-0.11373607069253922,
-0.3638419806957245,
-0.5774524211883545,
-0.665665328502655,
0.8967472910881042,
-0.8881834745407104,
0.11274455487728119,
0.3213987350463867,
0.7945539355278015,
-0.03534362092614174,
-1.2202436923980713,
0.024797163903713226,
-0.08228997141122818,
-0.30219385027885437,
0.2572445571422577,
-0.19975581765174866,
0.5131537914276123,
0.4152064621448517,
0.5944632291793823,
-0.6240718364715576,
-0.011516437865793705,
-0.5394605994224548,
-0.23439344763755798,
0.4066924750804901,
0.39498665928840637,
0.48691773414611816,
-0.5165202617645264,
-0.4091200828552246,
0.2549270987510681,
-0.9125424027442932,
0.0889759212732315,
-0.2874962389469147,
0.5593769550323486,
0.2964688241481781,
0.48035937547683716,
-0.4911397099494934,
0.8261100053787231,
-0.1773708611726761,
-0.467465341091156,
0.03824498504400253,
-0.3075524568557739,
-0.27978241443634033,
0.2780078053474426,
0.9330244660377502,
0.032635875046253204,
-0.20966309309005737,
0.05785766616463661,
-0.021285343915224075,
-0.06630516797304153,
0.1755955070257187,
-0.966620922088623,
-0.6177628040313721,
0.4234784245491028,
-0.7735382914543152,
-0.26301637291908264,
-0.29646459221839905,
-0.9702575206756592,
-0.4769026041030884,
-0.19859689474105835,
0.6529292464256287,
-0.6790359616279602,
-0.005100433249026537,
0.6142436265945435,
0.06671624630689621,
0.06849861145019531,
0.562534511089325,
-0.5210912823677063,
0.08605533838272095,
0.5527786016464233,
0.9405300617218018,
0.3061675429344177,
0.0023628189228475094,
-0.7991454601287842,
-0.03357918933033943,
0.35315337777137756,
1.0026072263717651,
-1.017791748046875,
-0.5501508712768555,
-0.03195222467184067,
-0.062260884791612625,
-0.2642464339733124,
-0.24176812171936035,
0.8627294301986694,
-0.15284329652786255,
0.8902149200439453,
-0.5296584963798523,
-0.5846891403198242,
0.02705744467675686,
0.12604017555713654,
-0.5591995120048523,
0.9892063736915588,
0.4083999991416931,
-0.7110744714736938,
0.12098617851734161,
-0.6088329553604126,
-0.0783390924334526,
0.2750450074672699,
-0.49426159262657166,
-0.40170079469680786,
-0.16403867304325104,
0.4751163721084595,
0.48505544662475586,
-0.6594609618186951,
0.2759265601634979,
0.023298047482967377,
-0.4306265711784363,
0.023122455924749374,
0.11230349540710449,
1.0438836812973022,
0.5787099003791809,
-0.20882609486579895,
0.2859477698802948,
-0.7288402915000916,
0.01818087510764599,
-0.057877231389284134,
-0.32511645555496216,
-0.006734198424965143,
-0.28051111102104187,
-0.386432945728302,
0.4422730803489685,
-0.021079879254102707,
-0.8667192459106445,
0.5427524447441101,
-0.20510998368263245,
0.41761964559555054,
0.595520555973053,
0.5626188516616821,
-0.04247280955314636,
-0.5046274662017822,
0.8614159226417542,
-0.2921782433986664,
0.2524108290672302,
-0.7450553178787231,
-0.8378869891166687,
-0.3694537580013275,
-0.7098856568336487,
-0.1958017498254776,
0.3547864854335785,
-0.8141922950744629,
0.06424496322870255,
-0.06633079797029495,
-0.5398113131523132,
-0.48143646121025085,
0.03398336097598076,
0.5879607796669006,
0.8965075016021729,
0.2949177622795105,
-0.19021806120872498,
-0.6918491125106812,
-0.4724401533603668,
-0.1526547223329544,
-0.10410761088132858,
-0.15279383957386017,
0.16721346974372864,
-0.07497822493314743,
0.006664176471531391,
0.8456573486328125,
-0.7686630487442017,
-0.5150843858718872,
-0.35028329491615295,
0.1449076533317566,
0.4530278444290161,
0.280561238527298,
0.18316292762756348,
-0.05117334425449371,
-0.544389545917511,
-0.03186148777604103,
-0.7744700908660889,
-0.5128020644187927,
-0.43187499046325684,
-0.09256885945796967,
-0.4161951541900635,
0.593123733997345,
-0.5694396495819092,
0.28824424743652344,
0.04685670882463455,
-0.6544916033744812,
0.3721449375152588,
-0.3644481599330902,
0.449300080537796,
-1.0674923658370972,
0.20031017065048218,
0.1432802677154541,
-0.15989169478416443,
-0.5555649995803833,
0.11094579100608826,
0.04666202515363693,
-0.4308479130268097,
-0.5011829137802124,
0.3082736134529114,
-0.6188039779663086,
-0.16124717891216278,
-0.41279932856559753,
0.38030532002449036,
0.3005828857421875,
0.0877104103565216,
-0.09429224580526352,
0.4102534055709839,
0.7518082857131958,
-0.4806625545024872,
0.6212846040725708,
0.2250409722328186,
-0.3441430628299713,
0.43447810411453247,
-0.6663467288017273,
0.08235613256692886,
-0.06917883455753326,
0.2568652927875519,
-1.3070861101150513,
-0.012426842004060745,
0.32328668236732483,
-0.49177759885787964,
0.20567187666893005,
0.13895471394062042,
-0.21523328125476837,
-0.33408603072166443,
-0.4031801223754883,
0.2477659434080124,
0.48569005727767944,
-0.28176799416542053,
0.7818621397018433,
-0.3113798201084137,
-0.722076952457428,
-0.34973472356796265,
-0.33460867404937744,
0.039650849997997284,
-0.14088957011699677,
-0.5903018712997437,
0.28538697957992554,
-0.013260229490697384,
-0.17436635494232178,
-0.17296288907527924,
0.17906445264816284,
0.13180099427700043,
0.053712766617536545,
0.1895149052143097,
0.28342223167419434,
-0.30311957001686096,
0.30722615122795105,
0.2738012373447418,
-0.32119351625442505,
0.07073573768138885,
0.011241655796766281,
0.7725359201431274,
0.13589808344841003,
-0.39962461590766907,
-0.7154252529144287,
0.43521812558174133,
0.30018487572669983,
0.01638662815093994,
0.3023553192615509,
0.418001651763916,
-0.44693511724472046,
0.023178867995738983,
-0.32290810346603394,
-0.6532041430473328,
-0.5074101090431213,
0.2789117097854614,
-0.5163427591323853,
-0.6111297011375427,
0.69058758020401,
-0.3407583236694336,
0.17689721286296844,
0.4049891531467438,
0.6818823218345642,
0.21465587615966797,
1.0605536699295044,
0.5827823877334595,
0.12264211475849152,
0.6840028166770935,
-0.10104120522737503,
-0.00290226424112916,
-0.635810375213623,
-0.5070669651031494,
-0.8317106366157532,
-0.16306956112384796,
-0.07443761080503464,
-0.20190219581127167,
0.4287239909172058,
-0.247304767370224,
-0.4118558466434479,
-0.06276176869869232,
-0.5606313943862915,
0.32514482736587524,
0.3319922685623169,
0.48886236548423767,
0.451504111289978,
0.09876853227615356,
-0.1774221807718277,
-0.6325108408927917,
-0.6707760691642761,
-0.42351603507995605,
1.1948286294937134,
0.3862179219722748,
0.542485773563385,
0.19771762192249298,
0.7584413290023804,
0.17217451333999634,
0.3873412311077118,
-0.884149432182312,
0.609960675239563,
-0.20328879356384277,
-0.3236295282840729,
-0.14706839621067047,
-0.48576223850250244,
-1.1628352403640747,
0.18153458833694458,
-0.1535111665725708,
-0.809265673160553,
-0.022234676405787468,
-0.17157921195030212,
-0.7698783278465271,
-0.039764709770679474,
-0.4546743631362915,
0.8277856111526489,
0.027012424543499947,
-0.19055543839931488,
-0.11004532128572464,
-0.5139880180358887,
0.3260175883769989,
0.1382562518119812,
0.3554361164569855,
-0.08967430889606476,
0.16221021115779877,
0.588763952255249,
-0.6380894780158997,
0.7324461936950684,
-0.3353880047798157,
-0.17570596933364868,
0.04503241181373596,
0.18219967186450958,
0.6050164699554443,
0.15679122507572174,
-0.2583099603652954,
-0.4986918270587921,
-0.1632748544216156,
-0.6010332703590393,
-0.6428053975105286,
0.9034038782119751,
-0.8833919763565063,
-0.5728211402893066,
-0.3657085597515106,
-0.5194994211196899,
-0.30148547887802124,
0.31938636302948,
0.45236632227897644,
0.6975350975990295,
0.0761132538318634,
-0.2704879641532898,
0.8424609303474426,
-0.6588017344474792,
0.35476240515708923,
0.945249617099762,
-0.46022069454193115,
-0.5326462984085083,
0.6112908720970154,
-0.18764783442020416,
0.29551568627357483,
0.09822181612253189,
0.7566872835159302,
-0.0293593630194664,
-0.32927337288856506,
-0.5012858510017395,
0.39702898263931274,
-1.0269834995269775,
-0.3360716998577118,
-0.8549265265464783,
-0.0858737900853157,
-0.7423210740089417,
-0.2776619493961334,
-0.2611786723136902,
-0.414750337600708,
-0.4490513503551483,
-0.1993519514799118,
0.6449731588363647,
0.700677752494812,
0.22358810901641846,
0.6139127016067505,
-1.1150254011154175,
0.018932877108454704,
0.17680728435516357,
0.09608501940965652,
-0.20071691274642944,
-1.1186572313308716,
-0.05822226405143738,
-0.30383482575416565,
-0.22044223546981812,
-1.1974397897720337,
0.7827445268630981,
0.41892749071121216,
0.39839091897010803,
0.718492329120636,
0.14173629879951477,
0.7983196377754211,
-0.1486196219921112,
0.8611974120140076,
0.3473218083381653,
-0.9720834493637085,
0.9283696413040161,
-0.5368608236312866,
0.7313384413719177,
0.41639378666877747,
0.491683691740036,
-0.7576215863227844,
-0.6100889444351196,
-0.638954758644104,
-0.9496912956237793,
1.1380821466445923,
-0.07372740656137466,
-0.16709263622760773,
0.08426172286272049,
0.6670398116111755,
0.327112078666687,
-0.30720770359039307,
-0.6655871868133545,
-0.2535535991191864,
-0.12544529139995575,
-0.6146268844604492,
0.02251577004790306,
-0.7150377631187439,
-0.32915836572647095,
-0.22072534263134003,
0.6426404118537903,
0.06024959683418274,
0.43894803524017334,
0.20214256644248962,
0.07188872247934341,
-0.6011065244674683,
0.4347182810306549,
0.5766366124153137,
0.8889786601066589,
-0.48239392042160034,
0.20230218768119812,
-0.031505148857831955,
-0.5308871865272522,
0.019502131268382072,
0.22060063481330872,
-0.1682148277759552,
0.3571552634239197,
0.5616447925567627,
0.7367202043533325,
0.42319637537002563,
-0.6207970976829529,
0.6009886264801025,
-0.27076005935668945,
-0.0970132052898407,
-0.2208305448293686,
-0.1690862625837326,
-0.21203050017356873,
0.3458271026611328,
0.45791733264923096,
-0.26006197929382324,
0.5953598618507385,
-0.5530835390090942,
0.24607115983963013,
0.08238618075847626,
-0.4536822438240051,
-0.2838478684425354,
0.444572389125824,
-0.016370080411434174,
0.00266204122453928,
0.6855344176292419,
0.22991299629211426,
-0.2571406066417694,
0.3470793068408966,
0.7529526948928833,
0.6930046081542969,
-0.47803664207458496,
0.4851096570491791,
0.8241907954216003,
0.08030865341424942,
-0.36301228404045105,
0.7309143543243408,
0.23790474236011505,
-0.2860470712184906,
-0.42875099182128906,
-0.18581047654151917,
-0.5357154011726379,
-0.2246199995279312,
-0.9105185270309448,
0.5169923305511475,
-0.8298050165176392,
-0.15294687449932098,
0.07510780543088913,
0.30058884620666504,
-0.3476017117500305,
0.26512816548347473,
0.08494475483894348,
0.7402641177177429,
-1.2018916606903076,
0.9764854907989502,
1.067407250404358,
-0.5257424116134644,
-1.285390019416809,
-0.5038276314735413,
0.3170013725757599,
-0.7339787483215332,
0.6942359805107117,
0.23858165740966797,
0.2618224024772644,
0.09539331495761871,
-0.12260590493679047,
-1.0375378131866455,
1.5074936151504517,
0.5567154884338379,
-0.5300354957580566,
-0.061296701431274414,
0.031047340482473373,
0.4764798879623413,
-0.31473061442375183,
0.8317903876304626,
0.55583256483078,
0.24380876123905182,
0.669126570224762,
-0.9168532490730286,
0.44307100772857666,
-0.2632887065410614,
-0.10078518092632294,
0.02864706516265869,
-0.47033658623695374,
1.2828822135925293,
-0.21144059300422668,
-0.6090438365936279,
-0.10535932332277298,
0.4596218466758728,
0.40137404203414917,
0.46135759353637695,
0.03660968691110611,
0.5551496744155884,
1.0702426433563232,
-0.07792804390192032,
1.1844266653060913,
-0.34025609493255615,
0.3809542655944824,
0.8555423617362976,
-0.2038854956626892,
0.471671462059021,
0.3534010350704193,
-0.14067329466342926,
0.661396324634552,
0.626289427280426,
0.45645859837532043,
0.6057087779045105,
-0.24310389161109924,
-0.49715957045555115,
-0.4274182617664337,
-0.03323471173644066,
-0.5668028593063354,
-0.024715609848499298,
0.36336013674736023,
-0.7081134915351868,
-0.5516427159309387,
0.47447824478149414,
0.5067659616470337,
-0.06625290215015411,
-0.3926381766796112,
0.8328732252120972,
0.1849721223115921,
-0.5824215412139893,
0.6688652038574219,
0.15291541814804077,
0.35146379470825195,
-0.7293296456336975,
-0.014226925559341908,
-0.5130250453948975,
0.38878339529037476,
-0.42835429310798645,
-0.5562803745269775,
0.09187478572130203,
0.0477900467813015,
-0.0021945007611066103,
-0.40931668877601624,
0.7927971482276917,
-0.3770618140697479,
-0.4911516308784485,
0.059221602976322174,
0.3623460829257965,
0.29610809683799744,
0.03684704378247261,
-0.7108208537101746,
0.419607013463974,
0.2882671654224396,
-0.3562127649784088,
0.2837814390659332,
0.6777194738388062,
0.17698191106319427,
0.7913522720336914,
0.20957361161708832,
0.2917631268501282,
-0.0879182517528534,
0.1355700045824051,
1.200535535812378,
-0.7890346050262451,
-0.20424161851406097,
-1.0128506422042847,
0.378091037273407,
0.06642653793096542,
-0.45950812101364136,
0.8918011784553528,
0.342452734708786,
0.32221099734306335,
-0.00035832769935950637,
0.5754551291465759,
0.10010028630495071,
0.7519756555557251,
-0.7749018669128418,
0.23018774390220642,
-0.1788906455039978,
0.7624396681785583,
-0.6297829151153564,
-0.6314792633056641,
-0.5023342967033386,
0.7079153060913086,
-0.5585654973983765,
-0.06144203990697861,
0.9293717741966248,
0.6636578440666199,
0.29446372389793396,
0.3105913996696472,
0.1502886712551117,
0.23596841096878052,
0.7490654587745667,
1.0207937955856323,
0.614931046962738,
-0.42455488443374634,
0.5150753259658813,
-0.4151398539543152,
-0.3942749500274658,
-0.32869553565979004,
-0.5949533581733704,
-0.5256264209747314,
-0.24086512625217438,
-0.633202075958252,
-0.5731237530708313,
0.027084315195679665,
1.2204853296279907,
0.1896813064813614,
-0.7934084534645081,
-0.20150397717952728,
0.17905107140541077,
-0.21790967881679535,
-0.17697758972644806,
-0.21811412274837494,
0.5273181200027466,
-0.348198801279068,
-0.4863479435443878,
0.48650628328323364,
0.1884954273700714,
-0.2898806035518646,
-0.024193020537495613,
-0.10768431425094604,
-0.11955829709768295,
-0.14618657529354095,
0.5001536011695862,
0.31730595231056213,
-0.4806463420391083,
-0.22983676195144653,
0.05008646845817566,
-0.4823870360851288,
0.087173230946064,
1.1064515113830566,
-0.9316070079803467,
0.8004521727561951,
0.546469509601593,
0.32277369499206543,
0.37678903341293335,
-0.09377653896808624,
0.6038941144943237,
-0.6470427513122559,
0.1500101089477539,
0.36903268098831177,
0.5822370648384094,
0.33067116141319275,
-0.4681874215602875,
0.025599855929613113,
0.3264995217323303,
-0.5633119940757751,
-0.7575830817222595,
0.2750181555747986,
-1.2056788206100464,
-0.4414505958557129,
1.3009673357009888,
-0.6138474345207214,
-0.1547776460647583,
-0.2789788246154785,
-0.7190446257591248,
0.23661194741725922,
-0.5640392899513245,
1.13883376121521,
0.3353044092655182,
-0.26981228590011597,
-0.8194919228553772,
-0.40761393308639526,
0.5294806361198425,
0.596018373966217,
-0.647882342338562,
-0.015789514407515526,
0.8807598948478699,
0.34083470702171326,
-0.3664743900299072,
1.1477960348129272,
-0.40011799335479736,
0.664860188961029,
-0.15733632445335388,
0.26030683517456055,
-0.3235325515270233,
0.06240633875131607,
-0.5508999824523926,
0.28024670481681824,
0.38912010192871094,
0.09054789692163467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04068v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04068v3 | Retrieve to Explain: Evidence-driven Predictions with Language Models | 2024-02-06T15:13:17 | 2024-06-18T10:42:54 | Ravi Patel, Angus Brayne, Rogier Hintzen, Daniel Jaroslawicz, Georgiana Neculae, Dane Corneil | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Language models hold incredible promise for enabling scientific discovery by
synthesizing massive research corpora. Many complex scientific research
questions have multiple plausible answers, each supported by evidence of
varying strength. However, existing language models lack the capability to
quantitatively and faithfully compare answer plausibility in terms of
supporting evidence. To address this issue, we introduce Retrieve to Explain
(R2E), a retrieval-based language model. R2E scores and ranks all possible
answers to a research question based on evidence retrieved from a document
corpus. The architecture represents each answer only in terms of its supporting
evidence, with the answer itself masked. This allows us to extend feature
attribution methods, such as Shapley values, to transparently attribute each
answer's score back to its supporting evidence at inference time. The
architecture also allows R2E to incorporate new evidence without retraining,
including non-textual data modalities templated into natural language. We
assess on the challenging task of drug target identification from scientific
literature, a human-in-the-loop process where failures are extremely costly and
explainability is paramount. When predicting whether drug targets will
subsequently be confirmed as efficacious in clinical trials, R2E not only
matches non-explainable literature-based models but also surpasses a
genetics-based target identification approach used throughout the
pharmaceutical industry. | [
0.03475140035152435,
-0.6896578669548035,
0.9521214962005615,
0.029114607721567154,
0.006126029416918755,
-0.13813412189483643,
-0.17340087890625,
-0.5649160742759705,
0.12697167694568634,
0.6083600521087646,
-0.43796151876449585,
-0.32696226239204407,
-0.8157868981361389,
0.026172548532485962,
-0.6540474891662598,
0.9733242392539978,
-0.10483357310295105,
0.18399672210216522,
-0.44538769125938416,
-0.0857195109128952,
-0.24360188841819763,
-0.11455103009939194,
-0.45242229104042053,
-0.6179686784744263,
0.7872487902641296,
0.5594934225082397,
0.6778523921966553,
0.9734764099121094,
0.5042237639427185,
0.16479116678237915,
0.09626449644565582,
-0.19234083592891693,
-0.618981122970581,
0.1900450438261032,
-0.4435912072658539,
-0.7742706537246704,
-0.08138872683048248,
0.07928638905286789,
0.21156775951385498,
0.9694573879241943,
-0.16690760850906372,
0.15192848443984985,
-0.1113603338599205,
0.5455541610717773,
-0.5313008427619934,
-0.07535158097743988,
-0.5923986434936523,
-0.04207988083362579,
-0.10331889986991882,
-0.16605722904205322,
-0.5558988451957703,
-0.2842317521572113,
0.2759959101676941,
-0.6975871920585632,
0.5914583206176758,
0.2580930292606354,
0.9921521544456482,
-0.018184764310717583,
-0.2779703140258789,
-0.6630771160125732,
-0.5521721243858337,
0.8345561027526855,
-0.4817120432853699,
0.35313737392425537,
0.5177465081214905,
0.27144673466682434,
-0.3550453782081604,
-0.7951160073280334,
-0.25853943824768066,
-0.42675402760505676,
-0.40374094247817993,
-0.06671760231256485,
-0.07427973300218582,
-0.1401272714138031,
0.2736509144306183,
0.3306955397129059,
-0.7727901935577393,
0.005923992954194546,
-0.3632088005542755,
-0.44889476895332336,
0.4544844627380371,
-0.2174847573041916,
0.4086953103542328,
-0.12057076394557953,
-0.3935934007167816,
-0.03652603179216385,
-0.6944937109947205,
-0.03983328491449356,
0.06316344439983368,
0.23977328836917877,
0.1701059192419052,
0.8889031410217285,
-0.07369456440210342,
0.22105300426483154,
0.08277502655982971,
0.23282362520694733,
-0.11479585617780685,
-0.35343191027641296,
-0.010341745801270008,
0.2360614687204361,
0.6574020981788635,
0.19415859878063202,
-0.1788291335105896,
-0.3720150291919708,
-0.12156464904546738,
0.09250766038894653,
0.16706067323684692,
-1.0446072816848755,
-0.2857014834880829,
0.548894464969635,
-0.7212094068527222,
-0.38904711604118347,
-0.17262350022792816,
-1.0639317035675049,
-0.6860510110855103,
0.12957489490509033,
0.5340485572814941,
-0.484222412109375,
-0.43671077489852905,
0.1551198810338974,
-0.48873046040534973,
0.08216964453458786,
0.0930442363023758,
-1.0304936170578003,
0.4433523416519165,
0.847916841506958,
0.8063341975212097,
-0.15403170883655548,
-0.21441474556922913,
-0.5092687606811523,
0.09585350751876831,
-0.45157933235168457,
1.0994659662246704,
-0.5645995736122131,
-0.369831383228302,
-0.14262564480304718,
0.05049464851617813,
0.16706717014312744,
-0.6374114751815796,
0.7351874113082886,
-0.5134435296058655,
0.6069697737693787,
-0.48058027029037476,
-0.6720629334449768,
-0.48864665627479553,
-0.020771099254488945,
-0.6653119325637817,
0.7484309077262878,
-0.013418933376669884,
-0.7657642364501953,
0.4141673445701599,
-0.7796535491943359,
-0.3573824465274811,
0.0925978347659111,
-0.07910188287496567,
-0.49442657828330994,
0.40356823801994324,
0.0439252145588398,
0.02032560482621193,
-0.4969556927680969,
0.6027234792709351,
-0.5147250294685364,
-0.23218464851379395,
0.30217522382736206,
-0.38175901770591736,
0.6482194662094116,
0.3433862328529358,
-0.4045047461986542,
0.16836468875408173,
-0.6690409779548645,
-0.04763007536530495,
0.3495006859302521,
-0.19390521943569183,
-0.416072815656662,
0.12110982835292816,
-0.02524402365088463,
-0.02014068514108658,
0.2212001383304596,
-0.6863546371459961,
-0.06505361944437027,
-0.473205029964447,
0.4103298485279083,
0.29705241322517395,
0.030450616031885147,
0.5498372912406921,
-0.23033274710178375,
0.5833863615989685,
-0.2843029797077179,
-0.14628860354423523,
-0.21349242329597473,
-0.5581178665161133,
-0.24408748745918274,
-0.21743051707744598,
0.38991793990135193,
0.47205889225006104,
-0.28565269708633423,
-0.1062728762626648,
-0.2608846127986908,
-0.2728670835494995,
-0.6846213340759277,
-0.04618548974394798,
0.565433144569397,
0.7778885364532471,
0.5146139860153198,
-0.21660974621772766,
-0.6584736108779907,
-1.1815409660339355,
-0.629960298538208,
-0.3511011004447937,
-0.4845806956291199,
0.36689525842666626,
0.6533214449882507,
-0.010747595690190792,
0.8683064579963684,
-0.4881007969379425,
-0.0027500600554049015,
-0.254300057888031,
0.3118129074573517,
0.12040799111127853,
0.161496102809906,
0.15663684904575348,
-0.772428035736084,
-0.05447441339492798,
0.07954282313585281,
-1.0834543704986572,
-0.2364586442708969,
0.02980910614132881,
-0.13782286643981934,
-0.16586600244045258,
0.4411541223526001,
-0.5041589736938477,
0.3549787402153015,
0.22974799573421478,
-0.3465443551540375,
0.4424434006214142,
-0.22225144505500793,
0.18382325768470764,
-0.7612550258636475,
0.35687199234962463,
0.05555805563926697,
-0.09354939311742783,
-0.6833401322364807,
-0.05382555350661278,
0.2140403687953949,
-0.28789255023002625,
-0.16179503500461578,
0.7454466819763184,
-0.42956119775772095,
-0.22279806435108185,
-0.38560590147972107,
0.11787831783294678,
0.3334888219833374,
0.0124687310308218,
0.2514891028404236,
0.7368375658988953,
0.37737560272216797,
-0.34717023372650146,
0.07342778891324997,
0.3050819933414459,
-0.25481998920440674,
0.2966836094856262,
-0.8118630647659302,
-0.06789398193359375,
-0.343911737203598,
0.17171519994735718,
-0.8636798858642578,
-0.48802897334098816,
0.17055124044418335,
-0.7211763858795166,
0.27649426460266113,
-0.3588232100009918,
-0.11944664269685745,
-0.2624201476573944,
-0.18951237201690674,
0.2558974623680115,
0.3379305899143219,
-0.5257120728492737,
0.6893579959869385,
0.36966508626937866,
-0.272243469953537,
-0.559174120426178,
-0.5313884615898132,
0.27691593766212463,
-0.46670982241630554,
-0.5159675478935242,
0.4187760353088379,
0.11374363303184509,
-0.4825928509235382,
0.20207825303077698,
-0.0815461203455925,
-0.23235782980918884,
0.17587876319885254,
0.2920154333114624,
0.2505377531051636,
-0.27356863021850586,
0.35843008756637573,
-0.08343058079481125,
-0.21313880383968353,
0.5776705741882324,
-0.14424486458301544,
0.11747502535581589,
0.1650857925415039,
-0.2958550751209259,
-0.12274222820997238,
0.7848786115646362,
0.48119980096817017,
-0.14247168600559235,
0.5320392847061157,
0.33443477749824524,
-0.5437478423118591,
-0.14742411673069,
-0.2884369194507599,
-0.6705610752105713,
-0.4081385135650635,
0.82441246509552,
-0.3452639579772949,
-0.48957905173301697,
0.5357303619384766,
-0.2605043053627014,
0.00381814525462687,
0.4476604461669922,
0.4916197657585144,
-0.058864738792181015,
1.1278514862060547,
0.4705890417098999,
0.38858455419540405,
0.28211790323257446,
0.06113431975245476,
0.41052934527397156,
-0.5686299800872803,
-0.59220290184021,
-0.7240761518478394,
-0.03689251467585564,
-0.2508399784564972,
-0.4380797743797302,
0.27774232625961304,
0.28434762358665466,
0.046651046723127365,
0.2158840149641037,
-0.5215939879417419,
0.38552549481391907,
0.5092688798904419,
0.10409775376319885,
0.2056683450937271,
-0.0006678756326436996,
0.058595895767211914,
0.07119586318731308,
-0.6626131534576416,
-0.632529079914093,
1.2726579904556274,
0.5100733637809753,
0.6028193235397339,
0.0667228102684021,
0.5486531853675842,
0.2712711989879608,
0.4559907913208008,
-0.8066748976707458,
0.38107284903526306,
0.06601079553365707,
-1.0184638500213623,
-0.20484787225723267,
-0.24655681848526,
-1.0482604503631592,
0.18459384143352509,
-0.4135740101337433,
-0.5639120936393738,
0.2090923935174942,
0.030147859826683998,
-0.18025344610214233,
-0.11356550455093384,
-0.8671674728393555,
0.9083698391914368,
-0.3985985219478607,
-0.6055377721786499,
-0.3534526526927948,
-0.6638243794441223,
0.4845150113105774,
-0.019167426973581314,
0.4230048954486847,
-0.04475975036621094,
0.07384917140007019,
0.9830018281936646,
-0.3122028112411499,
0.5395510196685791,
-0.25234097242355347,
0.002959942677989602,
0.17301402986049652,
0.2508072257041931,
0.42530369758605957,
0.19877032935619354,
-0.31559115648269653,
0.0660083219408989,
0.143528550863266,
-0.6370036602020264,
-0.9252944588661194,
0.8036975860595703,
-0.35290321707725525,
-0.5605210661888123,
-0.2638198435306549,
-0.45986273884773254,
-0.014786964282393456,
0.28156420588493347,
0.27440816164016724,
0.49304574728012085,
-0.11977886408567429,
0.019845906645059586,
0.9279336333274841,
-0.3123242259025574,
0.08656538277864456,
0.8074908256530762,
-0.31772589683532715,
-0.2343158721923828,
0.7601968050003052,
-0.25405174493789673,
0.2285613715648651,
0.5752772688865662,
0.37663811445236206,
-0.7962451577186584,
-0.901097297668457,
-0.24277184903621674,
0.24081729352474213,
-0.6949433088302612,
0.10213693231344223,
-0.6171643137931824,
0.17012089490890503,
-0.4041604995727539,
0.0954168513417244,
-0.3132491707801819,
-0.3089480400085449,
-0.24766266345977783,
-0.31055670976638794,
0.3747888505458832,
0.8344394564628601,
-0.1754816770553589,
-0.22489021718502045,
-0.4331563413143158,
0.5633321404457092,
0.07633745670318604,
0.4161846935749054,
-0.21207475662231445,
-0.5471885204315186,
-0.23820003867149353,
0.12082143127918243,
-0.04317901283502579,
-1.1677172183990479,
0.3068237602710724,
0.2573864758014679,
0.5871714949607849,
0.23108839988708496,
-0.05999456346035004,
0.5634393095970154,
-0.4373466372489929,
0.5657838582992554,
0.029019299894571304,
-0.572573721408844,
0.9144291281700134,
-0.12846717238426208,
-0.24603234231472015,
0.4434555768966675,
0.3658030927181244,
-0.392216295003891,
-0.1807868778705597,
-0.6146577596664429,
-0.8847115635871887,
0.371427983045578,
-0.02537885122001171,
-0.26079148054122925,
-0.09216473251581192,
0.6863622665405273,
0.4382254481315613,
-0.002553401980549097,
-0.607771098613739,
-0.15347908437252045,
-0.19505217671394348,
-0.4051903784275055,
0.15657471120357513,
-0.4001082479953766,
-0.36264267563819885,
0.1276736706495285,
0.6737471222877502,
-0.1968173235654831,
0.4164174199104309,
0.4314282536506653,
-0.13168422877788544,
-0.2878122329711914,
0.39865610003471375,
0.6488183736801147,
0.7508111000061035,
-0.39684411883354187,
0.37945055961608887,
-0.24177326261997223,
-0.4539530277252197,
-0.1702854186296463,
0.32397910952568054,
-0.21097151935100555,
0.016109293326735497,
0.7276296615600586,
0.6662721037864685,
0.1300676017999649,
-0.9820330739021301,
0.43621477484703064,
-0.0462656170129776,
-0.38367965817451477,
-0.1279062181711197,
-0.181151881814003,
0.0012558124726638198,
0.20298998057842255,
0.5416151881217957,
0.09015103429555893,
0.5078909993171692,
-0.7182372212409973,
0.4810498058795929,
0.6206315159797668,
-0.588659942150116,
-0.3214786946773529,
0.9641256928443909,
-0.1139354407787323,
-0.45268332958221436,
0.42578205466270447,
0.13097743690013885,
-0.3652102053165436,
0.637859046459198,
0.5717077851295471,
0.6566035151481628,
0.18049809336662292,
0.39411476254463196,
0.4800640046596527,
0.05579930543899536,
-0.3334565758705139,
0.1393209844827652,
0.349849134683609,
-0.5773575305938721,
-0.441683828830719,
-0.5096697807312012,
-0.4199511408805847,
0.14749498665332794,
-0.7032099962234497,
0.12744462490081787,
-0.13533443212509155,
0.13269448280334473,
0.5339599251747131,
0.04577067494392395,
-0.17317873239517212,
0.11802066117525101,
-0.020595846697688103,
0.745073139667511,
-1.1908116340637207,
0.8176825642585754,
0.4204340875148773,
-0.5243793725967407,
-0.7743309736251831,
-0.22031210362911224,
0.09386469423770905,
-0.8878398537635803,
0.5127554535865784,
0.08770882338285446,
0.026261083781719208,
-0.27524441480636597,
-0.7191601991653442,
-0.9039017558097839,
1.0471528768539429,
0.4458671510219574,
-0.36142972111701965,
0.06993632018566132,
-0.1167886033654213,
0.6127163171768188,
-0.5047751069068909,
0.46208688616752625,
0.5768905282020569,
0.5393082499504089,
0.29437255859375,
-0.5547251105308533,
0.3028297424316406,
-0.22249257564544678,
-0.30890953540802,
0.12672415375709534,
0.13329114019870758,
0.5247389674186707,
-0.8168402910232544,
-0.1963977813720703,
0.10253491997718811,
0.5467744469642639,
0.4197957515716553,
0.7037796378135681,
0.2945006191730499,
0.4189281463623047,
1.003472924232483,
-0.04382176697254181,
1.1841776371002197,
-0.038618721067905426,
0.3918592631816864,
1.0496770143508911,
-0.33361250162124634,
0.9248160123825073,
0.6678219437599182,
-0.27345308661460876,
0.7051482796669006,
0.7184897661209106,
-0.08987799286842346,
0.7300695180892944,
0.2004290074110031,
-0.054609768092632294,
-0.15808773040771484,
-0.3324155807495117,
-0.10623785108327866,
0.14899300038814545,
0.472898006439209,
-0.6137260794639587,
-0.22170017659664154,
0.09147317707538605,
-0.04941863939166069,
0.37615638971328735,
-0.04923488572239876,
0.8123022317886353,
-0.0441892072558403,
-0.9219473600387573,
0.6341920495033264,
-0.09668637812137604,
0.13669349253177643,
-0.6845747232437134,
-0.2758997678756714,
-0.2120598703622818,
0.15419486165046692,
-0.3156684935092926,
-0.9025515913963318,
0.3574019968509674,
-0.14409580826759338,
-0.6051658391952515,
-0.16024909913539886,
0.7113564014434814,
-0.6209823489189148,
-0.4618782699108124,
0.3571248948574066,
0.2313709706068039,
0.3152546286582947,
-0.0435507595539093,
-0.6917815208435059,
-0.07267879694700241,
0.1266050785779953,
-0.12006077170372009,
0.4874633550643921,
0.5159986019134521,
-0.19021250307559967,
0.9803628325462341,
0.6589211821556091,
0.17207682132720947,
-0.1444467455148697,
-0.23766712844371796,
0.5581316947937012,
-0.5791692733764648,
-0.08799631893634796,
-0.6842895746231079,
0.25927284359931946,
-0.12160497158765793,
0.1102224588394165,
0.6045321226119995,
0.7948371171951294,
0.101345956325531,
0.020436376333236694,
0.7434915900230408,
-0.06122588366270065,
0.9333354830741882,
-0.33887678384780884,
0.5882036685943604,
-0.47668805718421936,
0.44286853075027466,
0.30677711963653564,
-0.5239380598068237,
-0.2650834918022156,
0.38121071457862854,
-0.32093846797943115,
-0.13979393243789673,
0.9937971234321594,
0.8796207308769226,
0.07868356257677078,
0.15176326036453247,
0.0009042053716257215,
0.5126628875732422,
0.5189835429191589,
0.5524842143058777,
0.4194205403327942,
-0.43803852796554565,
0.6899825930595398,
-0.10785911232233047,
-0.421059787273407,
-0.16180391609668732,
-0.9108729362487793,
-0.5803821682929993,
-0.3459818363189697,
-0.35837796330451965,
-0.6787537336349487,
0.15102355182170868,
0.643033504486084,
0.5982423424720764,
-1.0437586307525635,
-0.04406573250889778,
-0.2892633080482483,
0.4224099814891815,
-0.3708565831184387,
-0.25213032960891724,
0.5301844477653503,
-0.17792333662509918,
-0.41158342361450195,
0.8104925751686096,
0.3534873127937317,
-0.22517751157283783,
-0.17175710201263428,
-0.055109359323978424,
-0.24397017061710358,
0.039797112345695496,
0.21757523715496063,
0.6650002598762512,
-0.9894335269927979,
-0.25768864154815674,
0.10021718591451645,
-0.0685219094157219,
-0.033019427210092545,
0.8539916276931763,
-0.9327941536903381,
0.5014546513557434,
0.4294058084487915,
0.5144234895706177,
0.5046826004981995,
0.050037167966365814,
0.9498817920684814,
-0.23626708984375,
-0.12038154900074005,
0.3480464518070221,
0.2725313603878021,
0.3430628776550293,
-0.394069105386734,
0.48645448684692383,
0.11494267731904984,
-0.586481511592865,
-0.9364146590232849,
0.3204028904438019,
-0.8788555264472961,
-0.5550975799560547,
1.0451552867889404,
-0.21533671021461487,
-0.4688570201396942,
-0.49062207341194153,
-0.15771041810512543,
0.02053224854171276,
-0.3509282171726227,
0.9874328970909119,
0.4836031496524811,
0.011318743228912354,
-0.3483826220035553,
-0.7209060192108154,
0.6246848106384277,
0.5122267603874207,
-0.6386332511901855,
0.45855623483657837,
0.41622552275657654,
0.5708085894584656,
0.19505834579467773,
0.4972853660583496,
-0.2819145917892456,
0.1816307157278061,
0.043654218316078186,
-0.04312876984477043,
0.006098550278693438,
-0.13298289477825165,
-0.2629062235355377,
0.4592256546020508,
0.19869709014892578,
0.021709788590669632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04049v1 | Systematic Biases in LLM Simulations of Debates | 2024-02-06T14:51:55 | 2024-02-06T14:51:55 | Amir Taubenfeld, Yaniv Dover, Roi Reichart, Ariel Goldstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in natural language processing, especially the emergence
of Large Language Models (LLMs), have opened exciting possibilities for
constructing computational simulations designed to replicate human behavior
accurately. However, LLMs are complex statistical learners without
straightforward deductive rules, making them prone to unexpected behaviors. In
this study, we highlight the limitations of LLMs in simulating human
interactions, particularly focusing on LLMs' ability to simulate political
debates. Our findings indicate a tendency for LLM agents to conform to the
model's inherent social biases despite being directed to debate from certain
political perspectives. This tendency results in behavioral patterns that seem
to deviate from well-established social dynamics among humans. We reinforce
these observations using an automatic self-fine-tuning method, which enables us
to manipulate the biases within the LLM and demonstrate that agents
subsequently align with the altered biases. These results underscore the need
for further research to develop methods that help agents overcome these biases,
a critical step toward creating more realistic simulations. | [
-0.5613508820533752,
-1.2105519771575928,
0.8239374756813049,
0.08162679523229599,
-0.12466931343078613,
0.25196748971939087,
-0.4111843407154083,
-0.20183490216732025,
0.31974127888679504,
0.7900781631469727,
-0.7382667660713196,
-0.25475966930389404,
-0.5044219493865967,
0.22405380010604858,
-0.20100116729736328,
0.9056726694107056,
0.11557289212942123,
0.2427104264497757,
-0.09671245515346527,
0.04687368869781494,
-0.13518378138542175,
-0.7714471817016602,
-0.5295932292938232,
-0.7600176930427551,
0.5404911041259766,
0.3973323702812195,
0.7664976716041565,
0.524474561214447,
0.428413450717926,
0.37435853481292725,
-0.10314377397298813,
0.2452136129140854,
-0.6512424349784851,
0.34979748725891113,
-0.41806960105895996,
-0.5595004558563232,
-0.15178769826889038,
0.31370699405670166,
0.7451633214950562,
0.6620968580245972,
-0.10155506432056427,
-0.07758177816867828,
0.20317356288433075,
0.8478806614875793,
-0.35358473658561707,
0.092327781021595,
-0.8852499127388,
-0.05379769951105118,
-0.2539672553539276,
-0.2525554299354553,
-0.30030277371406555,
-0.3795366883277893,
0.2748638391494751,
-0.36235225200653076,
0.4101415276527405,
0.009045083075761795,
0.7202849388122559,
0.32995495200157166,
-0.4605215787887573,
-0.30315569043159485,
-0.8938517570495605,
0.5920612215995789,
-0.6747333407402039,
-0.11910800635814667,
0.2659189701080322,
0.12786918878555298,
-0.6897193789482117,
-0.29973646998405457,
-0.5780590772628784,
-0.1935943216085434,
0.10345996916294098,
-0.1591128259897232,
-0.016305875033140182,
0.42064034938812256,
0.5052676796913147,
-0.1661483645439148,
-0.14531104266643524,
0.10972068458795547,
-0.29434528946876526,
-0.02773425541818142,
0.7481949925422668,
0.5117918252944946,
-0.010887004435062408,
-0.4678957462310791,
-0.1816970407962799,
-0.21938292682170868,
-0.6233692169189453,
-0.0014362850924953818,
0.8021025061607361,
0.3724519908428192,
-0.03305092081427574,
0.5938849449157715,
-0.23631533980369568,
0.35425350069999695,
0.36053887009620667,
0.21604852378368378,
-0.07727223634719849,
-0.16182664036750793,
-0.3189200758934021,
-0.09828638285398483,
0.8385202884674072,
0.4829358458518982,
0.6969407200813293,
0.228653684258461,
-0.042583730071783066,
0.3155069351196289,
0.2908738851547241,
-0.5524221658706665,
-0.10406075417995453,
0.23132488131523132,
-0.34744489192962646,
-0.5275678634643555,
-0.1697334498167038,
-0.9541386961936951,
-0.766248345375061,
-0.44569382071495056,
0.12475652247667313,
-0.04942544549703598,
-0.1260232776403427,
0.17029890418052673,
-0.19558443129062653,
0.2724345326423645,
0.5793638825416565,
-0.5547232031822205,
0.5251221656799316,
0.5972684025764465,
0.4807325005531311,
-0.3818662166595459,
-0.33895179629325867,
-0.22445495426654816,
0.048820000141859055,
-0.5089703798294067,
0.8590404391288757,
-0.7217774391174316,
-0.48058465123176575,
0.049709491431713104,
-0.04771360754966736,
-0.022409221157431602,
-0.8476093411445618,
0.4554257094860077,
-0.43478938937187195,
0.02612856961786747,
-0.7351075410842896,
-0.5653324127197266,
0.2325117588043213,
0.49788230657577515,
-0.5563710927963257,
0.6788375973701477,
-0.38477176427841187,
-0.9162624478340149,
0.18037106096744537,
-0.5976964831352234,
-0.2577996253967285,
-0.35744816064834595,
-0.5995221734046936,
-0.26851823925971985,
0.0038753238040953875,
-0.07605823874473572,
0.33710888028144836,
-0.3600096106529236,
0.5196975469589233,
-0.5315394997596741,
-0.32794860005378723,
0.5303996801376343,
-0.4712410271167755,
0.6777409315109253,
0.1375953108072281,
-0.5677041411399841,
0.3970052897930145,
-0.48478561639785767,
-0.40953272581100464,
0.25874415040016174,
-0.05780606344342232,
-0.2720780074596405,
0.4089667499065399,
-0.24813172221183777,
0.20123431086540222,
-0.11841484159231186,
-0.41473692655563354,
0.3859576880931854,
-0.36872416734695435,
0.36439669132232666,
1.240417242050171,
0.09697526693344116,
0.789401113986969,
-0.6322880387306213,
0.47911888360977173,
0.14653676748275757,
-0.035928875207901,
0.1990942507982254,
-0.39994290471076965,
-0.8015850782394409,
0.1068241149187088,
0.07176139950752258,
0.56392502784729,
-0.6442404985427856,
-0.0052787926979362965,
-0.08815714716911316,
-0.22274354100227356,
-0.3199537396430969,
0.13140647113323212,
0.08690302819013596,
0.13815270364284515,
-0.03490235656499863,
-0.07103689759969711,
-0.6308620572090149,
-0.9974108934402466,
-0.6608974933624268,
-0.19374577701091766,
0.053210701793432236,
0.46402111649513245,
0.5780314803123474,
-0.30149826407432556,
1.0448970794677734,
-0.20177942514419556,
-0.0989592894911766,
-0.1847224086523056,
0.2944607436656952,
-0.14148589968681335,
0.41567617654800415,
0.2546407878398895,
-0.4084412455558777,
-0.2706058621406555,
-0.3610210716724396,
-0.5575292706489563,
-0.2058088630437851,
-0.38385698199272156,
-0.2281675636768341,
0.296882688999176,
0.7430791258811951,
-0.5968254208564758,
0.4743344187736511,
0.33468589186668396,
-0.3757557272911072,
0.6101220846176147,
-0.042681075632572174,
0.016490070149302483,
-0.7577638626098633,
-0.45284777879714966,
0.186915785074234,
-0.22910138964653015,
-0.629406750202179,
-0.2629207372665405,
-0.2577936053276062,
0.4191020429134369,
-0.38002967834472656,
0.6568306684494019,
-0.4977850019931793,
0.1931326538324356,
-0.3351006805896759,
0.15994013845920563,
-0.1808868944644928,
0.17820625007152557,
0.16452139616012573,
0.6289742588996887,
0.2727585434913635,
-0.632911205291748,
0.1142057552933693,
-0.22850589454174042,
-0.21863041818141937,
0.40038055181503296,
-0.7577996253967285,
0.3083362877368927,
-0.4202907085418701,
0.41296738386154175,
-0.9633074402809143,
-0.4985630214214325,
0.331352174282074,
0.010999562218785286,
0.139637753367424,
-0.13549193739891052,
-0.5361059308052063,
-0.11533867567777634,
-0.5331832766532898,
0.3303740322589874,
0.5730109214782715,
-0.2739551067352295,
0.6241418123245239,
0.56296706199646,
-0.08723510056734085,
-0.43599987030029297,
-0.45180338621139526,
0.09331630170345306,
-0.37519407272338867,
-0.4153943657875061,
0.07751407474279404,
-0.09831485152244568,
-0.8910610675811768,
-0.22233593463897705,
0.30376139283180237,
0.32573026418685913,
-0.12594656646251678,
0.2951090335845947,
0.18840856850147247,
0.12009546905755997,
-0.04525552690029144,
0.08563321828842163,
0.41859176754951477,
0.502028226852417,
0.048856694251298904,
0.5618084669113159,
0.014037974178791046,
-0.5360816717147827,
-0.3391447961330414,
0.10404976457357407,
0.5888068079948425,
0.3732544183731079,
0.4146560728549957,
0.03431811183691025,
-0.2721269130706787,
-0.3664473295211792,
-0.8924721479415894,
-0.5149584412574768,
-0.5551539063453674,
0.4526140093803406,
-0.09977120906114578,
-0.932677149772644,
0.7743974328041077,
-0.22127655148506165,
0.055801063776016235,
0.09178394824266434,
0.7602666616439819,
-0.18841834366321564,
1.023520588874817,
0.257575124502182,
-0.006478819530457258,
0.4293616712093353,
0.0790436789393425,
-0.15964579582214355,
-0.7825496196746826,
-0.12455493956804276,
-0.6491680145263672,
-0.42915117740631104,
-0.8838996887207031,
-0.740604043006897,
0.17043687403202057,
-0.4846978485584259,
-0.35766398906707764,
-0.30775243043899536,
-0.4038028419017792,
0.7049638628959656,
0.2926897406578064,
-0.012525969184935093,
-0.01110711321234703,
0.24366368353366852,
-0.15336357057094574,
-0.21131795644760132,
-0.6936041116714478,
-0.7315157055854797,
1.0150083303451538,
0.3421799838542938,
1.293336272239685,
-0.21429334580898285,
0.6384046673774719,
0.3072619140148163,
0.4980897009372711,
-0.41103696823120117,
0.6937094330787659,
0.24738793075084686,
-0.8515495657920837,
-0.4698157012462616,
-0.5703855156898499,
-1.0683003664016724,
0.35315072536468506,
-0.2590806186199188,
-0.6347697973251343,
0.2434360384941101,
0.14976677298545837,
-0.05758135765790939,
0.425736665725708,
-0.46307528018951416,
0.5354036688804626,
-0.06286533921957016,
-0.6830478310585022,
-0.18721355497837067,
-0.609544038772583,
0.3239801824092865,
0.22037124633789062,
0.4948931932449341,
-0.4628853499889374,
0.19929154217243195,
0.6221338510513306,
-0.09985880553722382,
1.3302624225616455,
-0.10617224872112274,
-0.24194718897342682,
0.41824766993522644,
0.2227165549993515,
0.6266971230506897,
0.158604696393013,
-0.07450668513774872,
0.006376969628036022,
-0.15267929434776306,
-0.49726516008377075,
-0.3607843220233917,
0.6297014355659485,
-0.9978232383728027,
-1.1130168437957764,
-0.6427829265594482,
-0.6586310267448425,
-0.1575617641210556,
-0.03509257361292839,
0.06657961010932922,
-0.1514737755060196,
-0.6893075108528137,
-0.18275199830532074,
0.6672065854072571,
-0.1315184086561203,
0.16252975165843964,
0.47312095761299133,
-0.29171326756477356,
-0.2120792120695114,
0.4261336624622345,
0.3525979816913605,
0.4255479574203491,
-0.30063045024871826,
0.33864015340805054,
-0.13605377078056335,
-0.3460969924926758,
-0.27459990978240967,
0.30350053310394287,
-0.49995771050453186,
0.06088625267148018,
-0.5191028118133545,
-0.1567414402961731,
-0.262101948261261,
-0.1397528499364853,
-0.41868123412132263,
-0.31109195947647095,
-0.37176835536956787,
-0.06081874296069145,
0.15938818454742432,
1.2058579921722412,
0.09370848536491394,
0.2305467575788498,
-0.14272509515285492,
0.2639724314212799,
0.3597709536552429,
0.28357675671577454,
-0.03519963100552559,
-0.5975934863090515,
0.2592640221118927,
0.2436026781797409,
-0.46380898356437683,
-1.0877951383590698,
0.18654535710811615,
-0.14120285212993622,
0.44155314564704895,
0.41927334666252136,
0.22790367901325226,
0.5937222242355347,
-0.775892436504364,
0.7927366495132446,
-0.2581149637699127,
-0.6513870358467102,
0.5167769193649292,
-0.6646569967269897,
0.1755732148885727,
0.4560752809047699,
0.1958313286304474,
-0.20300866663455963,
-0.7773125171661377,
-0.5947664976119995,
-0.5209754705429077,
0.6816693544387817,
0.2535816729068756,
0.3615812361240387,
-0.298326700925827,
0.652391254901886,
-0.06709685176610947,
0.13708828389644623,
-0.5558297634124756,
-0.31637343764305115,
0.031350277364254,
0.14186862111091614,
-0.05349818244576454,
-0.3443716764450073,
-0.4527133107185364,
-0.3909150958061218,
0.46120205521583557,
-0.1383790671825409,
-0.13439306616783142,
0.4280018210411072,
0.24503950774669647,
-0.3680766224861145,
0.32354846596717834,
0.8051365613937378,
0.539453387260437,
-0.20747728645801544,
0.2612358629703522,
0.35927486419677734,
-0.20824159681797028,
0.3334499001502991,
-0.13263289630413055,
-0.3279884457588196,
0.1006465032696724,
-0.10086046904325485,
0.5940958261489868,
0.07395830750465393,
-0.5845082402229309,
0.2440096139907837,
-0.29889336228370667,
-0.46630173921585083,
-0.39048081636428833,
0.10780598223209381,
0.3392219841480255,
0.399217814207077,
0.2037380337715149,
0.19921569526195526,
0.09204056859016418,
-0.892106831073761,
-0.04544607549905777,
0.9317505359649658,
-0.13464441895484924,
-0.31193530559539795,
0.6665445566177368,
0.3427043855190277,
-0.575951099395752,
0.26628291606903076,
-0.27013060450553894,
-0.5576115846633911,
0.8430061340332031,
0.44574135541915894,
0.735705554485321,
-0.16397346556186676,
0.15640535950660706,
0.10182411968708038,
0.6188591122627258,
-0.26895901560783386,
0.3037269413471222,
0.280698299407959,
-0.9214295744895935,
-0.340253621339798,
-0.3465117812156677,
-0.8142613768577576,
0.16243165731430054,
-0.38322389125823975,
0.3552094101905823,
-0.6135262846946716,
-0.5094879269599915,
-0.08566781133413315,
0.05447734147310257,
-0.5893222689628601,
-0.28387972712516785,
0.28059154748916626,
0.8012306094169617,
-0.8154548406600952,
0.8493217825889587,
0.7452125549316406,
0.11673476547002792,
-0.439431756734848,
0.1481955200433731,
0.24312321841716766,
-0.4586206078529358,
0.4682038426399231,
-0.1301192194223404,
-0.3920764625072479,
-0.4296245574951172,
-0.916507363319397,
-0.5812340378761292,
0.616032063961029,
0.7185991406440735,
-0.579425573348999,
-0.17384889721870422,
0.41562965512275696,
0.6124911904335022,
-0.3882649540901184,
0.23263627290725708,
0.617315948009491,
0.5208568572998047,
-0.18124088644981384,
-0.8362100124359131,
0.14785215258598328,
-0.048434287309646606,
0.027221141383051872,
-0.170024111866951,
-0.9582539200782776,
0.8878829479217529,
-0.19216600060462952,
-0.04670001566410065,
-0.16516931354999542,
0.5113099813461304,
0.5033735632896423,
0.35637539625167847,
0.49245935678482056,
0.020589591935276985,
0.6891856789588928,
0.010311119258403778,
0.9166057705879211,
-0.32016274333000183,
0.2765964865684509,
1.0892043113708496,
-0.8025211691856384,
0.48368197679519653,
0.654238760471344,
-0.0879640281200409,
0.5594058036804199,
0.472453236579895,
0.24071840941905975,
0.05289584398269653,
0.5671056509017944,
-0.21918366849422455,
-0.4084576368331909,
0.005555578041821718,
-0.18865707516670227,
0.34917300939559937,
0.5367401838302612,
-0.15418867766857147,
-0.07180219888687134,
-0.3816917836666107,
0.02668151631951332,
0.38628047704696655,
-0.12876228988170624,
0.7323487997055054,
0.09762223809957504,
-0.7208185791969299,
0.3270561397075653,
-0.05791425332427025,
0.8455403447151184,
-0.5129373073577881,
-0.12367691099643707,
-0.05695692077279091,
0.014960531145334244,
-0.15348370373249054,
-0.7549542784690857,
0.1834488958120346,
-0.06708143651485443,
-0.1422768384218216,
-0.2429187297821045,
0.8257389068603516,
-0.3322911858558655,
-0.36879727244377136,
0.41791030764579773,
0.6899932026863098,
0.036530278623104095,
0.0624503567814827,
-0.6083843111991882,
0.35759812593460083,
0.044036902487277985,
-0.6620601415634155,
0.6350654363632202,
0.7009322047233582,
-0.16318941116333008,
0.7227350473403931,
0.6408443450927734,
0.2020125687122345,
0.03661295399069786,
0.12356046587228775,
1.0493215322494507,
-0.7089882493019104,
-0.25580906867980957,
-1.2305655479431152,
0.0968443900346756,
-0.24575366079807281,
-0.0074012186378240585,
0.7506459951400757,
0.3731435239315033,
0.7567288279533386,
-0.014483573846518993,
0.8849199414253235,
0.4626125991344452,
0.38721948862075806,
-0.3828040063381195,
0.7635919451713562,
-0.19751392304897308,
0.42865100502967834,
-0.3897317945957184,
-0.5541265606880188,
0.03248583525419235,
0.8013768196105957,
-0.4136280119419098,
0.08387181162834167,
0.4219873547554016,
0.7755800485610962,
0.0574820451438427,
0.005627533886581659,
0.2219885289669037,
0.4571310579776764,
0.28529566526412964,
0.19441872835159302,
1.0830926895141602,
0.13940244913101196,
0.32433512806892395,
-0.28306323289871216,
-0.0637398436665535,
-0.19400544464588165,
-0.8528613448143005,
-1.361033320426941,
-0.18828189373016357,
-0.15761657059192657,
-0.4824068546295166,
0.31020984053611755,
1.3568540811538696,
0.6235233545303345,
-0.6585466861724854,
-0.6518083214759827,
-0.1094476580619812,
0.48652154207229614,
0.3373892605304718,
-0.27929455041885376,
-0.13152018189430237,
-0.3693235516548157,
-0.8708967566490173,
-0.02719709649682045,
0.04659572243690491,
0.035962849855422974,
-0.4544178545475006,
-0.1047481894493103,
-0.18328607082366943,
0.6833358407020569,
0.49350082874298096,
0.24382340908050537,
-0.979752242565155,
-0.4266166388988495,
-0.010408682748675346,
-0.291283518075943,
0.206213116645813,
0.8685227632522583,
-0.9065449833869934,
0.2949174642562866,
0.36182931065559387,
0.32661569118499756,
0.22223368287086487,
0.22415998578071594,
0.633518636226654,
-0.47684764862060547,
0.21323516964912415,
0.2803535759449005,
0.2010168582201004,
0.24102354049682617,
-0.2487260103225708,
0.2532387673854828,
0.16848473250865936,
-0.8217963576316833,
-1.0258535146713257,
0.37440234422683716,
-0.6866407990455627,
-0.28881123661994934,
1.4081690311431885,
0.3532886505126953,
-0.24897204339504242,
-0.17080575227737427,
-0.5007573962211609,
0.11636607348918915,
-0.5548117160797119,
1.0801583528518677,
0.9469793438911438,
-0.41825124621391296,
0.05498854070901871,
-0.8087946772575378,
0.7654880285263062,
0.5327025055885315,
-0.6221983432769775,
0.36587396264076233,
0.4858011305332184,
0.5050034523010254,
-0.09061605483293533,
0.8662303686141968,
0.10234113037586212,
0.08772209286689758,
-0.19258882105350494,
-0.07582911849021912,
0.4193439781665802,
-0.14899136126041412,
-0.3932195007801056,
0.08903830498456955,
0.2483363151550293,
0.46051934361457825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04028v1 | AlbNews: A Corpus of Headlines for Topic Modeling in Albanian | 2024-02-06T14:24:28 | 2024-02-06T14:24:28 | Erion Çano, Dario Lamaj | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The scarcity of available text corpora for low-resource languages like
Albanian is a serious hurdle for research in natural language processing tasks.
This paper introduces AlbNews, a collection of 600 topically labeled news
headlines and 2600 unlabeled ones in Albanian. The data can be freely used for
conducting topic modeling research. We report the initial classification scores
of some traditional machine learning classifiers trained with the AlbNews
samples. These results show that basic models outrun the ensemble learning ones
and can serve as a baseline for future experiments. | [
-0.8149872422218323,
-0.8608644008636475,
0.23760005831718445,
0.1938544511795044,
-0.33389073610305786,
-0.16035661101341248,
-0.19903972744941711,
-0.22223594784736633,
0.49912768602371216,
0.6583648920059204,
-0.3512662947177887,
-0.672361433506012,
-0.7194921970367432,
0.16349917650222778,
-0.7621980309486389,
1.3466042280197144,
0.08509679138660431,
-0.16539621353149414,
-0.03247510641813278,
-0.12275399267673492,
-0.1865500509738922,
0.03253307193517685,
-0.5076078176498413,
0.17408034205436707,
0.697906494140625,
0.8235559463500977,
0.7318071722984314,
0.7187979221343994,
0.6166854500770569,
0.2720692753791809,
-0.13462907075881958,
0.08128328621387482,
0.02475091442465782,
0.19950133562088013,
-0.4460063576698303,
-0.1628880351781845,
-0.19847600162029266,
0.20967675745487213,
0.49333682656288147,
0.9276344776153564,
-0.23961010575294495,
0.37951743602752686,
-0.25286224484443665,
0.6760966181755066,
-0.5314823389053345,
-0.03896328806877136,
-0.6118926405906677,
-0.12140465527772903,
-0.44945454597473145,
-0.1426275670528412,
-0.18494825065135956,
-0.37185153365135193,
0.16263917088508606,
-0.16698908805847168,
0.5348764061927795,
0.37390488386154175,
0.7701496481895447,
0.16252297163009644,
-0.6678146123886108,
-0.9754921197891235,
-0.3560676872730255,
0.7928507328033447,
-0.42455917596817017,
0.4047892987728119,
0.6907857656478882,
-0.046616800129413605,
-0.08429451286792755,
-0.49365508556365967,
-0.14541545510292053,
-0.2153266966342926,
0.011799929663538933,
-0.16276821494102478,
-0.5263659954071045,
-0.04793236404657364,
-0.25370967388153076,
0.32373398542404175,
-0.7416837215423584,
0.20452581346035004,
-0.9936619400978088,
0.1133023127913475,
0.6142310500144958,
0.05906029790639877,
0.12919101119041443,
-0.562188982963562,
-0.07220996916294098,
0.21810349822044373,
-0.5054926872253418,
-0.01752004213631153,
0.7358258962631226,
0.4493506848812103,
-0.09402892738580704,
0.8300683498382568,
-0.46479716897010803,
1.0346614122390747,
0.34148871898651123,
-0.05181875079870224,
0.12890590727329254,
-0.0806594267487526,
-0.13297271728515625,
0.44570979475975037,
0.5431758761405945,
0.19921544194221497,
-0.39994046092033386,
-0.2779329717159271,
0.22341428697109222,
0.04858821630477905,
0.3113476037979126,
-0.6987380385398865,
-0.32818329334259033,
0.5362473726272583,
-0.5239742398262024,
-0.2960229516029358,
0.00969722494482994,
-0.8334614634513855,
-0.012563071213662624,
-0.27721554040908813,
-0.17902863025665283,
-0.3583334684371948,
-0.03368499130010605,
-0.019130179658532143,
0.051031358540058136,
-0.38589343428611755,
0.20921683311462402,
-0.790123701095581,
0.10579295456409454,
0.5661196112632751,
0.8594030141830444,
-0.39016029238700867,
-0.01762785017490387,
-0.3462328314781189,
-0.27497145533561707,
-0.699607253074646,
1.0649482011795044,
-0.4203997552394867,
-0.21773916482925415,
-0.27327680587768555,
-0.0007585771381855011,
0.03755463659763336,
-0.5227616429328918,
0.808944046497345,
-0.7318562865257263,
0.10528871417045593,
0.26949968934059143,
-0.5481207370758057,
-0.18151415884494781,
0.00041328510269522667,
-0.7206013202667236,
0.803225040435791,
0.016116905957460403,
-0.9770375490188599,
0.10179552435874939,
-0.7973580360412598,
-0.4614640772342682,
-0.09538479149341583,
0.14259570837020874,
-0.1830863207578659,
0.2583053708076477,
0.024989193305373192,
0.6468554139137268,
-0.07311449199914932,
0.578711986541748,
0.0023152828216552734,
0.012193998321890831,
0.22541514039039612,
-0.3346593677997589,
0.903390645980835,
0.9226017594337463,
-0.04593236744403839,
0.12376396358013153,
-0.9234734773635864,
-0.21633830666542053,
-0.5298571586608887,
-0.4228493273258209,
-0.5315364003181458,
-0.07735516130924225,
0.1730004847049713,
0.07320350408554077,
0.07930421829223633,
-0.3636254072189331,
0.11558638513088226,
-0.15776905417442322,
0.2951360046863556,
0.36166998744010925,
0.11276664584875107,
0.557014524936676,
-0.288831889629364,
0.47626757621765137,
0.23015138506889343,
-0.49700862169265747,
-0.23098957538604736,
-0.6627669930458069,
-0.7680890560150146,
-0.46688252687454224,
0.6057384014129639,
0.5716791749000549,
-0.8372909426689148,
0.5810996890068054,
0.08261995762586594,
-0.7439706921577454,
-0.5135011076927185,
0.2675657272338867,
-0.008517695590853691,
0.41334134340286255,
0.21201838552951813,
-0.01022251695394516,
-0.7959042191505432,
-0.9988011717796326,
-0.1977199912071228,
-0.12278665602207184,
0.010665103793144226,
-0.0030638352036476135,
0.40907856822013855,
-0.3367684781551361,
1.2416013479232788,
-0.27338749170303345,
-0.1435341238975525,
-0.396390438079834,
0.8005762100219727,
0.40619033575057983,
0.5164914131164551,
0.552894115447998,
-1.1379382610321045,
-0.025051290169358253,
-0.22904203832149506,
-0.6711165904998779,
-0.10541339963674545,
0.20383280515670776,
-0.0018878914415836334,
0.40153270959854126,
0.5379128456115723,
-0.5080301761627197,
0.36570948362350464,
0.7566208839416504,
-0.5235171318054199,
0.5531808733940125,
0.03617864474654198,
0.052538808435201645,
-1.0766373872756958,
-0.03217931464314461,
0.1614988148212433,
-0.11137361824512482,
-0.6112640500068665,
-0.009723966009914875,
-0.176725834608078,
-0.42375195026397705,
-0.7058357000350952,
0.8548848628997803,
-0.3756932020187378,
-0.01119224727153778,
-0.4882982075214386,
-0.25534626841545105,
-0.18792134523391724,
0.13634921610355377,
0.2689915597438812,
0.7341453433036804,
0.36919498443603516,
-0.8295750617980957,
0.6416289806365967,
0.33309870958328247,
-0.7322554588317871,
0.34715691208839417,
-0.2508198022842407,
-0.15561945736408234,
-0.5242659449577332,
0.06509168446063995,
-0.8973011374473572,
-0.5488371849060059,
0.25334998965263367,
-0.4144596755504608,
0.043088398873806,
-0.1545897275209427,
-0.054259028285741806,
-0.5206667184829712,
0.07733535766601562,
0.2304372787475586,
0.1047147884964943,
-0.26040953397750854,
0.2714236378669739,
0.4553530812263489,
-0.8040861487388611,
-0.34595394134521484,
-0.6109352707862854,
0.2569933831691742,
-0.49250495433807373,
-0.2844143807888031,
0.0034508444368839264,
0.02161230519413948,
-0.713941752910614,
0.6567182540893555,
0.19128163158893585,
-0.4547041058540344,
0.20311449468135834,
0.27829837799072266,
0.024695076048374176,
-0.4130581021308899,
0.3643673062324524,
0.20893552899360657,
0.054837848991155624,
-0.22046305239200592,
-0.18528835475444794,
0.5438910126686096,
-0.47387540340423584,
-0.07864146679639816,
-0.2446022778749466,
0.7003554105758667,
0.20353758335113525,
-0.1655648946762085,
0.8731049299240112,
0.3841676712036133,
-0.36125633120536804,
0.07835933566093445,
-0.49173909425735474,
0.12895028293132782,
-0.4253522455692291,
0.7012079358100891,
-0.036738984286785126,
-0.6990939378738403,
0.18053394556045532,
-0.025094635784626007,
-0.10541296005249023,
0.6915019750595093,
0.5469875335693359,
-0.20467354357242584,
0.4206348955631256,
0.6233725547790527,
-0.10677216947078705,
0.206987202167511,
-0.22928041219711304,
0.19589568674564362,
-0.5055046081542969,
0.03964555263519287,
-0.6561187505722046,
-0.2658071517944336,
-0.6659543514251709,
-0.2251552939414978,
0.09337985515594482,
0.3708091974258423,
-0.12927229702472687,
0.4967097043991089,
-0.3179026246070862,
0.49893638491630554,
0.9290404915809631,
0.0015799328684806824,
0.36338376998901367,
0.15136472880840302,
0.5208963751792908,
0.12346849590539932,
-0.6746510863304138,
-0.8010426759719849,
1.0959203243255615,
0.18863973021507263,
0.6377382874488831,
-0.1087794080376625,
0.8599525094032288,
0.7212831974029541,
0.4307146966457367,
-0.6625266075134277,
0.2424214631319046,
-0.27137407660484314,
-1.1020220518112183,
-0.5151863098144531,
-0.5570772290229797,
-0.8564977645874023,
-0.046598561108112335,
-0.0545896477997303,
-0.7789233326911926,
0.6714450120925903,
-0.014755889773368835,
-0.5865979194641113,
0.5426731109619141,
-0.30950409173965454,
0.6788457036018372,
-0.2002853900194168,
-0.08903232216835022,
-0.07339397072792053,
-0.3784300982952118,
0.5399726033210754,
-0.19309002161026,
0.678641140460968,
-0.3220970034599304,
0.1109001487493515,
1.1175155639648438,
0.09025195240974426,
0.5054380297660828,
0.1337432712316513,
0.00543656200170517,
0.5652034282684326,
0.007641712203621864,
0.14134736359119415,
0.18272413313388824,
-0.34415140748023987,
0.24112434685230255,
-0.23048686981201172,
-0.53319251537323,
-0.08494345098733902,
0.6321227550506592,
-0.5731582641601562,
-0.5478478074073792,
-0.6038856506347656,
-0.7518374919891357,
-0.13638043403625488,
0.10692337155342102,
0.5769795179367065,
0.5062788724899292,
-0.26233023405075073,
0.3706907033920288,
0.6378236413002014,
-0.3402976095676422,
0.4554491341114044,
0.24770274758338928,
-0.22141267359256744,
-0.39489662647247314,
0.9312594532966614,
0.23125606775283813,
-0.24931491911411285,
0.055678535252809525,
-0.2680884599685669,
0.13165412843227386,
-0.6982761025428772,
-0.5550868511199951,
-0.164325550198555,
-0.4944068193435669,
-0.4219995141029358,
-0.8726168870925903,
-0.24399550259113312,
-0.4597664475440979,
-0.300894558429718,
-0.5546560287475586,
-0.5820707082748413,
-0.605426549911499,
-0.2948654294013977,
0.4566398859024048,
0.7287062406539917,
-0.47796937823295593,
0.5468055009841919,
-0.6926934719085693,
0.6325643062591553,
0.0019628070294857025,
0.16963380575180054,
-0.22186049818992615,
-0.4142622649669647,
-0.5053697824478149,
0.19304236769676208,
-0.4471937417984009,
-0.866524875164032,
0.782528281211853,
0.29439565539360046,
0.3588656485080719,
0.9545425176620483,
0.3947153091430664,
0.20362545549869537,
-0.506621778011322,
0.5791289806365967,
0.10016253590583801,
-0.7140612006187439,
0.6220033168792725,
-0.6185879707336426,
-0.20785340666770935,
0.5840206742286682,
0.9038718342781067,
-0.5679432153701782,
-0.3849162459373474,
-0.7107876539230347,
-1.0183217525482178,
0.7429875135421753,
0.10802055895328522,
0.1347225159406662,
-0.46493756771087646,
0.36547982692718506,
0.33611953258514404,
0.5383929014205933,
-0.3092643916606903,
-0.3457801640033722,
-0.13375261425971985,
-0.4863816499710083,
-0.31289970874786377,
-0.5554600954055786,
0.10192877799272537,
-0.30153200030326843,
0.9191169738769531,
0.1366419792175293,
0.35061535239219666,
0.02318955957889557,
-0.09251311421394348,
-0.1898728609085083,
0.52348792552948,
0.7187165021896362,
0.7820875644683838,
-0.5521349906921387,
0.27533912658691406,
-0.021340448409318924,
-0.38348162174224854,
0.3816169798374176,
0.08886634558439255,
-0.23677299916744232,
0.4312494397163391,
0.257318913936615,
0.9880096912384033,
0.19921325147151947,
-0.7609137892723083,
0.02415562979876995,
0.239457368850708,
-0.17644155025482178,
-0.22744888067245483,
-0.10835294425487518,
0.1635463535785675,
0.3183009624481201,
0.8893736004829407,
0.2101801037788391,
0.47007617354393005,
-0.9741615653038025,
0.5629468560218811,
0.07885967195034027,
-0.369579017162323,
-0.19898231327533722,
0.5729253888130188,
0.05108782649040222,
-0.32028117775917053,
0.6403119564056396,
-0.3758839964866638,
-0.5025420784950256,
0.8243236541748047,
0.36317378282546997,
0.46036648750305176,
-0.32682526111602783,
0.5737919211387634,
0.1547698825597763,
0.17241539061069489,
-0.30806082487106323,
-0.19049015641212463,
0.1583445966243744,
-0.5936722159385681,
-0.05910877510905266,
-0.8378146290779114,
-0.6746472716331482,
-0.03422112017869949,
-0.9181742668151855,
0.2764268219470978,
-0.25235411524772644,
-0.2459498643875122,
0.01014474406838417,
0.23397861421108246,
-0.4313185513019562,
0.33421939611434937,
0.15685391426086426,
1.0159958600997925,
-0.9127583503723145,
0.7026200890541077,
0.79191654920578,
-0.06318965554237366,
-0.09952358901500702,
-0.23347841203212738,
-0.15405376255512238,
-0.34990376234054565,
1.139356255531311,
0.05133002996444702,
0.4388047456741333,
0.1049945205450058,
-0.46068280935287476,
-1.171247959136963,
0.601087212562561,
0.05927019193768501,
-0.32693880796432495,
-0.37745922803878784,
0.0875597894191742,
0.21099792420864105,
-0.39004847407341003,
0.0684695765376091,
0.3742573857307434,
0.4926292598247528,
-0.08311361819505692,
-0.6332178711891174,
-0.6205062866210938,
-0.376837819814682,
-0.2922096848487854,
0.046928081661462784,
-0.5571974515914917,
1.3007469177246094,
0.013515942730009556,
0.1332731395959854,
0.33185577392578125,
1.1017851829528809,
0.23410004377365112,
0.6774231791496277,
0.1299838125705719,
0.5545750856399536,
0.7676361203193665,
-0.09806790202856064,
0.8480119705200195,
-0.2177761048078537,
0.32700565457344055,
1.013198733329773,
-0.08503329008817673,
0.7770928740501404,
0.30406567454338074,
-0.052973486483097076,
0.43897679448127747,
0.899817705154419,
0.041549764573574066,
0.9236433506011963,
0.19322505593299866,
-0.06593192368745804,
-0.11556701362133026,
-0.1340230107307434,
-0.3641103208065033,
0.5483589172363281,
0.4978371560573578,
-0.08248718082904816,
-0.5325114727020264,
0.7083916664123535,
-0.013631394132971764,
-0.09477517008781433,
-0.6936964988708496,
0.5080991983413696,
0.09539142996072769,
-0.38275793194770813,
0.26838886737823486,
0.5143452882766724,
0.8445782661437988,
-0.3313004672527313,
0.16066434979438782,
-0.4131644070148468,
0.058775387704372406,
-0.15405458211898804,
-0.41803091764450073,
0.7118822336196899,
0.27112138271331787,
-0.5658248662948608,
0.01709738001227379,
0.5378767848014832,
-0.5080541968345642,
-1.1542134284973145,
-0.10106627643108368,
0.328285276889801,
0.40219101309776306,
0.01708155684173107,
-0.29486995935440063,
-0.06328018009662628,
-0.21176785230636597,
-0.5227969884872437,
0.20632494986057281,
0.5663663744926453,
-0.3223928213119507,
0.7372381687164307,
0.43257540464401245,
0.27028772234916687,
0.3416290283203125,
-0.8914624452590942,
0.6031158566474915,
-0.7932480573654175,
-0.6478132605552673,
-0.46038150787353516,
0.03269824758172035,
0.30869609117507935,
-0.37982824444770813,
0.8358836770057678,
0.8311030864715576,
0.6793919801712036,
0.012045243754982948,
0.7881167531013489,
-0.17400412261486053,
0.9542505145072937,
-0.6244959831237793,
0.8841402530670166,
-0.42227545380592346,
0.10698994994163513,
-0.1345517337322235,
-0.7788561582565308,
-0.21133388578891754,
0.6256822347640991,
-0.3288196325302124,
-0.20191748440265656,
0.33558452129364014,
0.34195151925086975,
-0.3268781304359436,
0.2854467034339905,
0.1437387466430664,
0.06110282987356186,
-0.2531851828098297,
0.07269038259983063,
0.716059684753418,
-0.24711526930332184,
0.16301944851875305,
-0.5504418611526489,
-0.06905469298362732,
-0.5465373396873474,
-0.738036036491394,
-0.970584511756897,
-0.6667827367782593,
-0.30793023109436035,
-0.028209179639816284,
0.6117589473724365,
1.3126198053359985,
0.5908567309379578,
-1.2645045518875122,
-0.3170873522758484,
0.008680036291480064,
0.2196744829416275,
0.14076867699623108,
-0.2402784675359726,
0.7408804893493652,
-0.35592490434646606,
-0.6545810699462891,
0.3485284149646759,
-0.2052641659975052,
-0.11108715832233429,
-0.04504162073135376,
0.08282260596752167,
-0.5138602256774902,
0.003527176333591342,
0.25348564982414246,
0.41586631536483765,
-0.45898327231407166,
0.1010977253317833,
-0.19861534237861633,
0.03218298405408859,
0.0006939638406038284,
0.6324717402458191,
-0.8304749131202698,
-0.34259504079818726,
0.1860523521900177,
0.5619348883628845,
0.15913118422031403,
0.2461598962545395,
0.09100251644849777,
-0.7745057344436646,
0.7456082105636597,
0.1379862278699875,
0.32318106293678284,
0.2730485498905182,
-0.3702198565006256,
0.428487628698349,
0.05701993405818939,
-0.20744967460632324,
-1.0466214418411255,
-0.060832954943180084,
-0.6644425988197327,
-0.6197240948677063,
0.9879780411720276,
0.033246926963329315,
-0.36735183000564575,
-0.3383128345012665,
-0.06065595522522926,
0.23627379536628723,
-0.5257790684700012,
0.8463097810745239,
0.8202715516090393,
0.04650912806391716,
-0.2793935537338257,
-0.8288285136222839,
0.3098647892475128,
0.0722576454281807,
-0.635286808013916,
-0.15170998871326447,
0.36750319600105286,
0.16362018883228302,
0.44248324632644653,
0.41520175337791443,
0.31947213411331177,
0.21701599657535553,
-0.12003184854984283,
0.21256403625011444,
-0.18619735538959503,
-0.7908069491386414,
-0.14305534958839417,
0.24670468270778656,
-0.3343653976917267,
-0.0301177017390728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04023v1 | Google Translate Error Analysis for Mental Healthcare Information: Evaluating Accuracy, Comprehensibility, and Implications for Multilingual Healthcare Communication | 2024-02-06T14:16:32 | 2024-02-06T14:16:32 | Jaleh Delfani, Constantin Orasan, Hadeel Saadany, Ozlem Temizoz, Eleanor Taylor-Stilgoe, Diptesh Kanojia, Sabine Braun, Barbara Schouten | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study explores the use of Google Translate (GT) for translating mental
healthcare (MHealth) information and evaluates its accuracy, comprehensibility,
and implications for multilingual healthcare communication through analysing GT
output in the MHealth domain from English to Persian, Arabic, Turkish,
Romanian, and Spanish. Two datasets comprising MHealth information from the UK
National Health Service website and information leaflets from The Royal College
of Psychiatrists were used. Native speakers of the target languages manually
assessed the GT translations, focusing on medical terminology accuracy,
comprehensibility, and critical syntactic/semantic errors. GT output analysis
revealed challenges in accurately translating medical terminology, particularly
in Arabic, Romanian, and Persian. Fluency issues were prevalent across various
languages, affecting comprehension, mainly in Arabic and Spanish. Critical
errors arose in specific contexts, such as bullet-point formatting,
specifically in Persian, Turkish, and Romanian. Although improvements are seen
in longer-text translations, there remains a need to enhance accuracy in
medical and mental health terminology and fluency, whilst also addressing
formatting issues for a more seamless user experience. The findings highlight
the need to use customised translation engines for Mhealth translation and the
challenges when relying solely on machine-translated medical content,
emphasising the crucial role of human reviewers in multilingual healthcare
communication. | [
-0.10295005887746811,
-0.6204531192779541,
0.6456193327903748,
0.37729617953300476,
-0.25497981905937195,
0.16704988479614258,
-0.3191661834716797,
-0.6232937574386597,
0.31595781445503235,
0.000907525303773582,
-0.6834105253219604,
-0.6210775375366211,
-0.9424053430557251,
0.5030180811882019,
-0.11918594688177109,
1.1320180892944336,
-0.28618189692497253,
0.5082623958587646,
0.07413490861654282,
-0.18497760593891144,
-0.2545875310897827,
-0.7311717867851257,
-0.7890071868896484,
-0.18532654643058777,
0.5562801957130432,
0.3352985680103302,
1.0623643398284912,
0.2473105639219284,
0.7710723876953125,
0.2405293881893158,
0.2059895545244217,
0.32081660628318787,
-0.41517582535743713,
-0.02585740201175213,
-0.06059564650058746,
-0.0008502385462634265,
-0.7247669100761414,
-0.10988195985555649,
0.38825827836990356,
0.5313836932182312,
-0.4819846749305725,
0.21381549537181854,
0.10885118693113327,
0.7643941640853882,
-0.5620623826980591,
0.34608352184295654,
-0.06330495327711105,
0.1998034417629242,
-0.21817368268966675,
-0.4070887565612793,
-0.1951720416545868,
-0.5389940142631531,
0.044003188610076904,
-0.594915509223938,
0.03515121340751648,
-0.024497337639331818,
0.7210818529129028,
0.43255290389060974,
-0.43222591280937195,
-0.622941255569458,
-0.6595792174339294,
0.5369039177894592,
-0.8558093905448914,
0.5951400399208069,
0.23976236581802368,
0.477435827255249,
-0.19739702343940735,
-0.6777682900428772,
-0.5769358277320862,
0.04497109726071358,
-0.3048907220363617,
0.44986632466316223,
-0.6058158278465271,
-0.06626681238412857,
0.1425391137599945,
0.43876323103904724,
-0.7819280624389648,
-0.1267368644475937,
-0.3949205279350281,
-0.37553778290748596,
0.4846799373626709,
0.2809954583644867,
0.726288914680481,
-0.39945825934410095,
0.19643692672252655,
-0.14762459695339203,
-0.41557660698890686,
-0.17146405577659607,
0.08691106736660004,
0.12623275816440582,
-0.3355127274990082,
0.5553059577941895,
-0.2211458384990692,
0.4726594388484955,
-0.18948252499103546,
-0.6372249126434326,
0.3217913806438446,
-0.5444987416267395,
-0.37086519598960876,
0.13806354999542236,
0.7830685973167419,
0.6347942352294922,
0.031970199197530746,
-0.5244410634040833,
0.028695132583379745,
0.02906998246908188,
0.4755381941795349,
-0.6361618638038635,
-0.26931777596473694,
0.39687058329582214,
-0.4088994860649109,
0.2026750147342682,
-0.017084412276744843,
-0.7609380483627319,
-0.3926544487476349,
-0.1168227568268776,
-0.026455359533429146,
-0.3762524425983429,
0.010690802708268166,
0.5368210077285767,
0.12446123361587524,
-0.05030875280499458,
0.39214998483657837,
-0.6325255036354065,
0.12278158962726593,
0.3758728802204132,
0.6978527307510376,
-0.1386210322380066,
-0.2470797300338745,
-0.19388319551944733,
0.266287237405777,
-0.24079763889312744,
0.49580302834510803,
-0.15262673795223236,
-0.4298238158226013,
0.23590058088302612,
0.1692267507314682,
-0.27044323086738586,
-0.35325244069099426,
0.9112165570259094,
-0.16344299912452698,
0.495679646730423,
-0.08164249360561371,
-0.1217707097530365,
-0.2058822363615036,
0.2444295883178711,
-0.5971797704696655,
0.4413309693336487,
0.3018372654914856,
-0.7590557932853699,
0.26361194252967834,
-0.5384925603866577,
-0.5840700268745422,
0.04458975791931152,
-0.10963726788759232,
-0.28115755319595337,
0.24910692870616913,
0.3677729070186615,
0.2923588752746582,
-0.2774959206581116,
0.1863841414451599,
-0.09170849621295929,
-0.2625245749950409,
0.2717092037200928,
-0.37976282835006714,
0.6262463331222534,
0.1731918454170227,
-0.3755715489387512,
0.23481442034244537,
-0.605837881565094,
0.27119916677474976,
-0.06825331598520279,
-0.465606689453125,
-0.2240068018436432,
0.19573388993740082,
0.47974735498428345,
0.6183557510375977,
0.24117042124271393,
-0.3928656280040741,
-0.06294925510883331,
-0.19107404351234436,
0.29489850997924805,
0.2021772563457489,
0.004124951083213091,
0.04930596053600311,
-0.1371312290430069,
0.6954339146614075,
-0.1884726881980896,
0.5138822197914124,
0.2743400037288666,
-0.9466732740402222,
-0.17994831502437592,
-0.13722266256809235,
0.19669897854328156,
0.8730904459953308,
-0.8016349077224731,
0.49272993206977844,
-0.6638931035995483,
-0.4353685677051544,
-0.9487120509147644,
-0.028955655172467232,
0.575364351272583,
0.6756072044372559,
0.39846131205558777,
-0.3225967586040497,
-0.45168426632881165,
-0.8351361751556396,
-0.24291951954364777,
-0.2567734718322754,
0.08327524363994598,
0.2881459891796112,
0.4410138726234436,
-1.0153789520263672,
0.17632554471492767,
-0.42093169689178467,
-0.39724746346473694,
-0.14534780383110046,
0.1629219502210617,
-0.015144278295338154,
0.35966071486473083,
0.279135137796402,
-0.6950977444648743,
-0.5408852696418762,
0.36793890595436096,
-0.7517390251159668,
-0.14369535446166992,
-0.15684238076210022,
-0.16409467160701752,
0.204421728849411,
-0.07726297527551651,
-0.330810010433197,
0.45653948187828064,
1.0862094163894653,
-0.2713894248008728,
0.7643465995788574,
-0.49770087003707886,
0.5872990489006042,
-1.2797762155532837,
0.20091447234153748,
0.16705305874347687,
-0.0960625633597374,
-0.5728752613067627,
0.17903384566307068,
0.20439407229423523,
0.058768052607774734,
-0.40252211689949036,
0.4322054982185364,
-0.25800952315330505,
0.3601481318473816,
-0.2624399662017822,
0.0415688082575798,
0.020325683057308197,
-0.016358956694602966,
-0.33146435022354126,
1.199344277381897,
0.1165659949183464,
-0.3038027584552765,
0.46765515208244324,
0.4647310674190521,
-0.3315665125846863,
0.871748685836792,
-0.29860919713974,
0.10175923258066177,
0.10624419152736664,
0.08072826266288757,
-0.8509553670883179,
-0.6186490654945374,
0.5857428908348083,
-0.6661266088485718,
0.22241654992103577,
0.2481241524219513,
-0.6951259970664978,
-0.44092386960983276,
-0.04283216968178749,
0.10827208310365677,
0.10621624439954758,
-0.0662640854716301,
0.03008049912750721,
0.6592646241188049,
-0.2937227785587311,
-0.5619107484817505,
-0.7582205533981323,
0.5287176370620728,
-0.13702820241451263,
-0.6086065769195557,
0.29169777035713196,
0.07843588292598724,
-0.2541072368621826,
-0.008335726335644722,
-0.20730876922607422,
-0.498820424079895,
0.237725168466568,
0.02799127995967865,
0.1825622171163559,
-0.13537967205047607,
0.16759993135929108,
0.1386948823928833,
-0.011407021433115005,
0.3809451162815094,
-0.21195457875728607,
0.26893332600593567,
-0.1734340935945511,
-0.25386762619018555,
-0.5857860445976257,
0.7129859924316406,
0.6216300129890442,
0.06547676771879196,
0.9008071422576904,
0.7696674466133118,
-0.5410969853401184,
0.5573402643203735,
-0.49614062905311584,
0.02084856480360031,
-0.3732219636440277,
0.376587837934494,
-0.12693338096141815,
-0.6679763793945312,
0.6243796944618225,
0.2571621537208557,
-0.13229188323020935,
0.6600787043571472,
0.49927395582199097,
-0.34836849570274353,
1.1423596143722534,
0.6248717308044434,
-0.1748477816581726,
0.04512900859117508,
0.1518488973379135,
0.4102875292301178,
-0.6390467286109924,
-0.18037614226341248,
-0.7001991271972656,
-0.22127322852611542,
-1.003503441810608,
-0.35358425974845886,
0.6279754042625427,
-0.30392298102378845,
0.1580614447593689,
0.05433928966522217,
-0.3442864716053009,
-0.14615659415721893,
0.2963610589504242,
0.25418874621391296,
0.4036421477794647,
0.28523409366607666,
-0.053975921124219894,
-0.6992985010147095,
-0.5146046876907349,
-0.6249609589576721,
0.8725380897521973,
0.10707274079322815,
0.796595573425293,
0.49666863679885864,
0.4333667755126953,
0.3589077293872833,
0.4947737157344818,
-0.9761752486228943,
-0.05247512459754944,
-0.3157162070274353,
-0.4512629210948944,
-0.18806087970733643,
-0.6060755252838135,
-1.0072190761566162,
0.035592835396528244,
-0.24481038749217987,
-0.6437198519706726,
-0.04603724926710129,
-0.012747030705213547,
-0.32545197010040283,
0.2432512640953064,
-0.7136750817298889,
0.8677754402160645,
-0.35534510016441345,
-0.03928592428565025,
-0.32368555665016174,
-0.6225934624671936,
0.32070520520210266,
-0.4147934913635254,
0.25490495562553406,
0.1429208517074585,
-0.022962691262364388,
0.7377237677574158,
0.057962965220212936,
0.4365363121032715,
0.20289812982082367,
-0.31299516558647156,
-0.3497360944747925,
-0.22700980305671692,
0.1958947330713272,
0.11650530248880386,
-0.1407172828912735,
0.3766213655471802,
0.2313259392976761,
-0.48979541659355164,
-0.6731416583061218,
0.5220814347267151,
-0.7350894212722778,
-0.67433762550354,
-0.5820508599281311,
-0.5916709303855896,
-0.5123686790466309,
0.3397861421108246,
0.34069618582725525,
0.30430230498313904,
-0.2678835690021515,
-0.11314835399389267,
0.3281424939632416,
-0.31119346618652344,
-0.11646672338247299,
0.5485318899154663,
-0.003357137320563197,
-0.6304728984832764,
0.7920927405357361,
0.0871986672282219,
0.03475213050842285,
0.15527863800525665,
0.15039655566215515,
-0.4311619997024536,
-0.5748370885848999,
-0.814667284488678,
0.4327073395252228,
-0.7072078585624695,
0.20205006003379822,
-0.4623715281486511,
-0.2324148565530777,
-0.4939804673194885,
0.026795482262969017,
0.04416415095329285,
-0.15183469653129578,
-0.12086249142885208,
0.08135490864515305,
-0.027146534994244576,
0.8749150037765503,
0.036969754844903946,
0.6019567251205444,
-1.055524230003357,
0.1339244395494461,
-0.12386240065097809,
0.3621824085712433,
-0.41934704780578613,
-0.28317898511886597,
-0.6817314624786377,
0.14984525740146637,
-0.33875688910484314,
-1.289421796798706,
0.5422935485839844,
-0.04131321236491203,
0.5664918422698975,
0.49400901794433594,
-0.33342668414115906,
1.1168667078018188,
-0.6373218297958374,
0.6576869487762451,
0.44400554895401,
-0.7646154165267944,
0.483248770236969,
-0.2547667622566223,
0.4934338629245758,
0.7946338653564453,
0.6166327595710754,
-1.3023144006729126,
-0.39350268244743347,
-0.5827691555023193,
-0.6981677412986755,
0.25265032052993774,
0.16820555925369263,
0.03368109092116356,
-0.035822104662656784,
0.31699874997138977,
0.03997955843806267,
0.28505516052246094,
-0.378601998090744,
-0.5446152091026306,
0.13258856534957886,
-0.13428498804569244,
-0.5750784873962402,
-0.29908910393714905,
-0.46329402923583984,
-0.1924232691526413,
0.590747058391571,
-0.17627066373825073,
0.4602087140083313,
0.3554791212081909,
-0.24542587995529175,
-0.20826074481010437,
0.640884280204773,
0.9191650748252869,
0.9998248815536499,
-0.3091183006763458,
-0.05395995453000069,
-0.20130294561386108,
-0.9031206369400024,
0.17117395997047424,
0.26179903745651245,
-0.026380129158496857,
0.43553850054740906,
0.08665933459997177,
0.40004852414131165,
0.25914114713668823,
-0.5237471461296082,
0.14877016842365265,
-0.38895076513290405,
0.06997083872556686,
0.059929173439741135,
-0.3672889173030853,
-0.0325738862156868,
-0.1682356297969818,
0.21857663989067078,
0.11886835098266602,
0.48767080903053284,
-0.2739953100681305,
0.17119787633419037,
0.24563123285770416,
-0.48897334933280945,
-0.3841930031776428,
0.50705885887146,
0.16565610468387604,
-0.13310988247394562,
0.6537943482398987,
-0.19890746474266052,
-0.36057931184768677,
0.1778843253850937,
0.5550047755241394,
0.8824318647384644,
-0.2435460090637207,
0.35789498686790466,
0.3428972065448761,
0.5882397294044495,
-0.06213836744427681,
0.47509801387786865,
0.2914207875728607,
-0.3101162314414978,
-0.7288753986358643,
-0.04068051651120186,
-0.7574127316474915,
0.09216975420713425,
-0.9952905178070068,
-0.14372354745864868,
-0.11928705126047134,
-0.5863616466522217,
-0.07363871484994888,
0.003263940801844001,
-0.6760245561599731,
0.4536237418651581,
0.47084763646125793,
0.8530404567718506,
-0.6624053120613098,
0.8418142199516296,
1.0460463762283325,
-0.12612470984458923,
-0.6552398204803467,
0.28898030519485474,
0.2645322382450104,
-0.6069868803024292,
0.20132160186767578,
0.08801371604204178,
-0.47686105966567993,
-0.1823558360338211,
-0.1611148566007614,
-0.7931638360023499,
0.6973052024841309,
0.4881487190723419,
-0.3029457628726959,
-0.1330244094133377,
0.28722119331359863,
0.6961590051651001,
-0.10996824502944946,
0.1421731412410736,
0.5613133907318115,
0.5759202837944031,
-0.5125020742416382,
-1.3181953430175781,
-0.03722645714879036,
-0.39890429377555847,
-0.2725347578525543,
0.06372372061014175,
-0.2542431056499481,
0.45898380875587463,
-0.09652622789144516,
-0.5011810064315796,
-0.187699556350708,
0.37023916840553284,
-0.017758265137672424,
0.248689204454422,
0.022700024768710136,
0.544360339641571,
1.1650334596633911,
-0.27037933468818665,
1.4109545946121216,
-0.35164257884025574,
0.3506670892238617,
1.1285299062728882,
-0.004362077917903662,
0.7327402830123901,
0.6704233288764954,
-0.3128032684326172,
0.5230872631072998,
0.6652441620826721,
0.3855368196964264,
0.4621807932853699,
0.05356428772211075,
-0.2991815209388733,
0.2540895938873291,
-0.05884320288896561,
-0.6104190349578857,
0.25797587633132935,
0.7388098239898682,
-0.283933162689209,
-0.3190290629863739,
0.000753576576244086,
0.30343082547187805,
-0.10233018547296524,
-0.14237137138843536,
0.6225806474685669,
0.04488899186253548,
-0.596943736076355,
0.6723528504371643,
0.28334930539131165,
0.5023858547210693,
-0.5079141855239868,
0.20501752197742462,
-0.2464558482170105,
0.13423673808574677,
-0.4407866597175598,
-0.6277281641960144,
0.8570019006729126,
0.028407473117113113,
-0.17324182391166687,
-0.16783347725868225,
0.31825387477874756,
-0.12001869082450867,
-0.6741174459457397,
0.3771519064903259,
0.9809558391571045,
0.3391736149787903,
-0.0927003026008606,
-1.090846300125122,
-0.1458122432231903,
-0.031076494604349136,
0.24447014927864075,
0.23465293645858765,
0.34156057238578796,
-0.013991596177220345,
0.545132040977478,
0.6851028800010681,
0.5481519103050232,
0.26026707887649536,
0.045090481638908386,
0.44996178150177,
-0.6656699776649475,
-0.42359429597854614,
-0.8733492493629456,
0.3182849884033203,
0.03713929280638695,
-0.5022350549697876,
1.000118613243103,
0.44865700602531433,
0.8223869800567627,
-0.2746405601501465,
0.8147063851356506,
0.005667048506438732,
0.17370301485061646,
-0.2775639295578003,
0.921930193901062,
-0.6089117527008057,
-0.34855443239212036,
-0.11338281631469727,
-0.4827095568180084,
-0.6206578612327576,
0.573851466178894,
-0.4575316607952118,
-0.39559701085090637,
1.0777063369750977,
0.4814969599246979,
0.10768002271652222,
-0.10320914536714554,
0.46387502551078796,
0.007484938018023968,
0.18160799145698547,
0.49504363536834717,
0.5219180583953857,
-0.5305999517440796,
0.34686800837516785,
-0.25702840089797974,
-0.06243419647216797,
-0.28777605295181274,
-0.51675945520401,
-0.283111572265625,
-0.284030020236969,
-0.40442827343940735,
-0.7798476219177246,
0.22443440556526184,
0.7465410232543945,
0.5603629946708679,
-1.0599180459976196,
-0.30102765560150146,
0.4871377646923065,
0.07404948025941849,
-0.5214061141014099,
-0.17132876813411713,
0.23326608538627625,
-0.3121519684791565,
-0.8302227854728699,
0.2767932116985321,
0.5288825631141663,
-0.00241734366863966,
-0.3416045308113098,
-0.12771621346473694,
-0.00856560654938221,
-0.2214176058769226,
0.5439534187316895,
0.24426737427711487,
-1.0064542293548584,
-0.045018259435892105,
0.12136904895305634,
-0.9564646482467651,
0.44950199127197266,
0.6219364404678345,
-0.19082550704479218,
0.825252115726471,
0.2753508985042572,
0.7417030334472656,
-0.1077628880739212,
-0.10253017395734787,
0.6380127668380737,
-0.18209068477153778,
-0.06972287595272064,
0.06976565718650818,
0.47096019983291626,
0.548468828201294,
-0.5985743403434753,
0.4766862988471985,
0.2038567215204239,
-0.3930438756942749,
-0.400307297706604,
-0.1554325371980667,
-0.9948558807373047,
0.09700097888708115,
1.1011182069778442,
-0.47182273864746094,
-0.37118950486183167,
-0.36876577138900757,
-0.382477730512619,
0.41444987058639526,
-0.3024728298187256,
1.1544086933135986,
0.9788233041763306,
-0.07556993514299393,
0.05950016900897026,
-1.1375311613082886,
0.6332929730415344,
0.33399027585983276,
-1.0851032733917236,
-0.44976696372032166,
0.4838849902153015,
0.08482744544744492,
0.35725098848342896,
0.6733834147453308,
-0.2073478400707245,
0.7776708602905273,
-0.5159904956817627,
0.13306200504302979,
0.45307472348213196,
-0.00944285187870264,
-0.5332112312316895,
-0.10238904505968094,
-0.23944106698036194,
-0.07257746905088425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03988v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03988v2 | REBORN: Reinforcement-Learned Boundary Segmentation with Iterative Training for Unsupervised ASR | 2024-02-06T13:26:19 | 2024-05-28T17:19:59 | Liang-Hsuan Tseng, En-Pei Hu, Cheng-Han Chiang, Yuan Tseng, Hung-yi Lee, Lin-shan Lee, Shao-Hua Sun | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Unsupervised automatic speech recognition (ASR) aims to learn the mapping
between the speech signal and its corresponding textual transcription without
the supervision of paired speech-text data. A word/phoneme in the speech signal
is represented by a segment of speech signal with variable length and unknown
boundary, and this segmental structure makes learning the mapping between
speech and text challenging, especially without paired data. In this paper, we
propose REBORN,Reinforcement-Learned Boundary Segmentation with Iterative
Training for Unsupervised ASR. REBORN alternates between (1) training a
segmentation model that predicts the boundaries of the segmental structures in
speech signals and (2) training the phoneme prediction model, whose input is
the speech feature segmented by the segmentation model, to predict a phoneme
transcription. Since supervised data for training the segmentation model is not
available, we use reinforcement learning to train the segmentation model to
favor segmentations that yield phoneme sequence predictions with a lower
perplexity. We conduct extensive experiments and find that under the same
setting, REBORN outperforms all prior unsupervised ASR models on LibriSpeech,
TIMIT, and five non-English languages in Multilingual LibriSpeech. We
comprehensively analyze why the boundaries learned by REBORN improve the
unsupervised ASR performance. | [
-0.46109044551849365,
-0.5185676217079163,
0.34592026472091675,
0.31915467977523804,
-0.5028823614120483,
0.41040775179862976,
-0.22482284903526306,
-0.1928558647632599,
0.09966226667165756,
0.6145116686820984,
-0.6375725865364075,
-0.3722626864910126,
-0.39704567193984985,
-0.05749760940670967,
-0.378336101770401,
0.7354161739349365,
0.037456780672073364,
0.2899882197380066,
-0.2109760195016861,
-0.14966674149036407,
-0.39681345224380493,
-0.3079516291618347,
-0.7114236950874329,
-0.6673018932342529,
0.2615607976913452,
0.2799074351787567,
0.10417893528938293,
0.5593935251235962,
-0.009929697960615158,
0.43335816264152527,
-0.06512544304132462,
0.020900413393974304,
-0.0077035618014633656,
0.23526354134082794,
0.02881629951298237,
-0.017566198483109474,
0.028325224295258522,
-0.07490038871765137,
1.039893627166748,
0.8827036619186401,
-0.27399712800979614,
-0.05609121918678284,
-0.06482329219579697,
0.6368728876113892,
-0.3291381597518921,
-0.08538215607404709,
-0.6938859820365906,
0.050285402685403824,
-0.09152151644229889,
-0.4126480221748352,
-0.41141265630722046,
-0.3908948004245758,
0.3249804675579071,
-0.2987421452999115,
0.05753767490386963,
-0.08261583000421524,
0.6359418630599976,
0.604964017868042,
-0.500514566898346,
-0.03113512322306633,
-0.8276711106300354,
0.5993886590003967,
-0.38242989778518677,
1.0971012115478516,
-0.12603746354579926,
0.47721970081329346,
-0.24654895067214966,
-0.752336859703064,
-0.4903683364391327,
-0.10377384722232819,
0.32695484161376953,
0.292776882648468,
-0.13868340849876404,
-0.023089131340384483,
0.1191028356552124,
0.4250096380710602,
-0.4185398817062378,
0.1985587775707245,
-0.6425187587738037,
-0.3346950113773346,
0.6149411797523499,
-0.1387356072664261,
0.2588014006614685,
0.13469067215919495,
-0.6645802855491638,
-0.35711580514907837,
-0.5117669701576233,
0.617331862449646,
0.26264330744743347,
0.5078803300857544,
0.15137231349945068,
0.040880680084228516,
0.07761075347661972,
0.7842137217521667,
0.10958581417798996,
-0.28692740201950073,
0.507768452167511,
0.5879552960395813,
0.060986798256635666,
0.46068689227104187,
0.765889585018158,
0.06230498105287552,
0.18142688274383545,
-0.4434884190559387,
-0.2695590555667877,
0.20359176397323608,
0.4039851129055023,
-0.71135014295578,
-0.21395669877529144,
0.18690569698810577,
-0.07782813906669617,
0.2834264636039734,
0.17117935419082642,
-0.3106882870197296,
-0.16563700139522552,
-0.37092217803001404,
0.33656004071235657,
-0.5589544773101807,
-0.3369980752468109,
0.11013666540384293,
-0.28566569089889526,
0.4921075403690338,
0.43756046891212463,
-0.5090888738632202,
0.5115184783935547,
0.3925168812274933,
0.7008474469184875,
-0.557060718536377,
-0.4089634418487549,
-0.877894401550293,
-0.18245717883110046,
-0.20275667309761047,
1.1558666229248047,
-0.4910541772842407,
-0.7169428467750549,
-0.2122301161289215,
0.41519075632095337,
-0.41361701488494873,
-0.763785719871521,
0.34731346368789673,
-0.6752626299858093,
0.11679334938526154,
0.165409654378891,
-0.7046864032745361,
-0.42671966552734375,
-0.09272177517414093,
-0.6444038152694702,
0.7352899312973022,
-0.08736509829759598,
-0.3696333169937134,
0.2941243350505829,
-0.6299017071723938,
-0.6393114328384399,
0.007470752578228712,
-0.18713583052158356,
-0.7103397250175476,
0.031252212822437286,
0.17219987511634827,
0.16449134051799774,
0.04781468212604523,
0.02315061166882515,
-0.037379514425992966,
-0.22752024233341217,
0.46032512187957764,
-0.38969793915748596,
0.6940412521362305,
0.009712869301438332,
-0.31842154264450073,
0.28754621744155884,
-0.855985701084137,
0.4364871680736542,
-0.10597512125968933,
-0.5003854632377625,
0.013631162233650684,
-0.018824545666575432,
0.20652127265930176,
0.06180690601468086,
-0.14285634458065033,
-0.9458196759223938,
0.016124553978443146,
-0.7958968877792358,
0.19316533207893372,
0.539297342300415,
0.3935379087924957,
0.5812318921089172,
-0.22267082333564758,
0.4056228697299957,
0.14100956916809082,
-0.1309709995985031,
0.006665528751909733,
-0.297025203704834,
-0.6111900210380554,
-0.34721463918685913,
0.49408599734306335,
0.46792083978652954,
-0.6615716814994812,
0.28018060326576233,
0.03418644517660141,
-0.32789021730422974,
-0.7884436249732971,
-0.13770675659179688,
0.4832817614078522,
0.2921561002731323,
0.5358156561851501,
-0.44900748133659363,
-0.9316985011100769,
-0.6120588779449463,
-0.20789723098278046,
0.13516023755073547,
0.010259540751576424,
0.01944061554968357,
0.29989510774612427,
-0.6903299689292908,
1.0222735404968262,
-0.3372531235218048,
-0.35629400610923767,
-0.11314580589532852,
0.1613699197769165,
-0.07492606341838837,
0.46076375246047974,
-0.21201741695404053,
-0.7986687421798706,
-0.49934011697769165,
-0.06646610051393509,
-0.1697966456413269,
-0.04876520484685898,
-0.04158754274249077,
0.38451650738716125,
0.10626335442066193,
0.5548920035362244,
0.051456958055496216,
0.33041906356811523,
0.3584994077682495,
-0.06325459480285645,
0.17872487008571625,
-0.37855595350265503,
-0.10096103698015213,
-1.046700358390808,
-0.08599056303501129,
-0.10897114127874374,
-0.40312013030052185,
-0.6922906637191772,
-0.3297846019268036,
0.06136858090758324,
-0.18237805366516113,
-0.25164321064949036,
0.6236723065376282,
-0.7068288326263428,
-0.5995175242424011,
-0.6253734230995178,
0.09644779562950134,
-0.25119778513908386,
0.3969414532184601,
0.5712018609046936,
0.710730791091919,
0.5614271759986877,
-0.6173667311668396,
0.23477749526500702,
0.43533629179000854,
-0.04983020946383476,
0.2972949147224426,
-0.4421970546245575,
0.38967612385749817,
-0.010652742348611355,
0.24474036693572998,
-0.8353050947189331,
0.11874211579561234,
-0.3162648379802704,
-0.7150956392288208,
0.3142775893211365,
-0.16502422094345093,
-0.09071771055459976,
-0.30751198530197144,
-0.037616051733493805,
0.12206260859966278,
0.7162706255912781,
-0.7392197847366333,
0.5787456035614014,
0.5377131700515747,
0.1540454924106598,
-0.27594810724258423,
-0.18141217529773712,
-0.23612986505031586,
-0.12304055690765381,
-0.42090606689453125,
0.3748558759689331,
-0.07785359025001526,
-0.16827359795570374,
-0.14994506537914276,
-0.244461789727211,
-0.29361578822135925,
0.1151726245880127,
0.8025826811790466,
-0.09429282695055008,
-0.08329702913761139,
-0.061214808374643326,
0.007552021183073521,
-0.5206550359725952,
-0.1561576873064041,
-0.5124518275260925,
0.5198580622673035,
-0.2590784728527069,
-0.3219943344593048,
-0.30649733543395996,
0.17262358963489532,
0.37799152731895447,
-0.5495564937591553,
0.12759897112846375,
0.6150075793266296,
-0.33098071813583374,
-0.4545031785964966,
-0.5155273675918579,
-0.15331310033798218,
-0.46439701318740845,
-0.13864797353744507,
-0.32092034816741943,
-1.0219773054122925,
0.4486882984638214,
-0.4554049074649811,
0.0017306486843153834,
0.2651844620704651,
0.41786494851112366,
-0.1331847459077835,
0.8216344714164734,
0.7596111297607422,
0.06119668483734131,
0.41996443271636963,
-0.394851416349411,
-0.18161621689796448,
-1.0245308876037598,
-0.505707323551178,
-0.13144630193710327,
-0.02802860550582409,
-0.5948331952095032,
-0.4556725025177002,
0.7014495134353638,
-0.22076433897018433,
-0.11903811246156693,
0.22433777153491974,
-0.5622634291648865,
0.28882384300231934,
0.5811280012130737,
0.11968094110488892,
0.34951651096343994,
0.19510194659233093,
-0.21154813468456268,
-0.13851670920848846,
-0.3455747365951538,
-0.19961214065551758,
0.7030123472213745,
0.2710669934749603,
0.6849992275238037,
-0.20686164498329163,
0.8985982537269592,
0.23820582032203674,
0.05853744596242905,
-0.8986647725105286,
0.3469694256782532,
-0.1350036859512329,
-0.1654031127691269,
-0.40343841910362244,
-0.2694845497608185,
-1.15227472782135,
0.27913838624954224,
0.07714381814002991,
-0.8663540482521057,
0.2842552363872528,
0.12032666802406311,
-0.7890574336051941,
0.16780070960521698,
-0.3016115725040436,
0.48045074939727783,
-0.260571151971817,
-0.10141079872846603,
-0.08929302543401718,
-0.6671392321586609,
-0.2131190299987793,
0.02009771578013897,
-0.08031484484672546,
0.10197601467370987,
0.07245754450559616,
0.9280163645744324,
-0.3538772761821747,
0.626265287399292,
-0.4477406442165375,
-0.029704241082072258,
0.32091668248176575,
-0.08755093067884445,
0.1521805226802826,
0.0073687611147761345,
0.18353423476219177,
-0.08651150017976761,
-0.03160035237669945,
-0.043422065675258636,
-0.575928270816803,
0.4643343985080719,
-0.8271497488021851,
-0.5251539349555969,
-0.5187020301818848,
-0.21284571290016174,
-0.6197657585144043,
0.06784386932849884,
0.3089039921760559,
0.5385951995849609,
-0.42269235849380493,
0.21888333559036255,
0.9269344210624695,
-0.09514009207487106,
0.5979739427566528,
0.9658970236778259,
-0.14787597954273224,
-0.706795871257782,
0.973722517490387,
0.1714896857738495,
-0.02160102128982544,
0.11093488335609436,
0.009651421569287777,
-0.5968027114868164,
-0.44116514921188354,
-0.6491292715072632,
0.0885118618607521,
-0.38469773530960083,
-0.062051936984062195,
-0.8910106420516968,
-0.6334777474403381,
-0.10350602120161057,
-0.111730195581913,
-0.6905772686004639,
-0.03083880990743637,
-0.24609588086605072,
0.0860697329044342,
0.44342049956321716,
0.6123722791671753,
-0.3478439450263977,
0.578517496585846,
-0.5381073355674744,
0.21714246273040771,
0.4611014723777771,
0.30870065093040466,
-0.1308034211397171,
-1.061506986618042,
-0.010609910823404789,
0.04431222006678581,
-0.22848330438137054,
-0.7736268639564514,
0.5689194798469543,
0.23813924193382263,
0.46954554319381714,
0.41678664088249207,
-0.127610981464386,
0.6933447122573853,
-1.0087872743606567,
0.26265668869018555,
0.15286821126937866,
-0.7458300590515137,
0.44086354970932007,
-0.11629342287778854,
0.40015003085136414,
0.5199950933456421,
0.27120208740234375,
-0.656797468662262,
-0.09601981192827225,
-0.906119704246521,
-0.8354719877243042,
0.4633324146270752,
-0.16052848100662231,
-0.16056354343891144,
0.30295267701148987,
0.1333649754524231,
0.2683032155036926,
0.2470989227294922,
-0.46750158071517944,
-0.10663847625255585,
-0.3443736732006073,
0.19707940518856049,
-0.03038734383881092,
-0.10265810787677765,
0.04172897711396217,
-0.4964374899864197,
0.6976386904716492,
-0.11592913419008255,
0.43972304463386536,
0.16353759169578552,
-0.2563363015651703,
-0.18537481129169464,
0.2832168638706207,
0.4272269308567047,
0.14367829263210297,
-0.21967992186546326,
-0.04293577000498772,
0.24533671140670776,
-0.21323272585868835,
0.5535768866539001,
0.4542052149772644,
-0.038797199726104736,
0.1074538305401802,
0.2501806318759918,
1.1851247549057007,
0.261618971824646,
-0.5170629024505615,
0.4717476963996887,
0.030648307874798775,
-0.1631196290254593,
-0.8818880319595337,
0.019642174243927002,
0.21897682547569275,
0.6887054443359375,
0.5218403339385986,
-0.011048366315662861,
0.2417622059583664,
-0.40845105051994324,
0.7322538495063782,
0.3702833354473114,
-0.700053870677948,
-0.4134872257709503,
0.45674270391464233,
0.0753849446773529,
-0.49512767791748047,
0.5021523833274841,
-0.25116387009620667,
-0.8287094831466675,
0.40647584199905396,
0.8372325301170349,
0.8898501396179199,
-0.5531668066978455,
0.41664591431617737,
0.28902652859687805,
-0.0238153338432312,
-0.11405521631240845,
0.3214557468891144,
-0.24559441208839417,
-0.9528025388717651,
-0.17082686722278595,
-0.7664259076118469,
-0.4893386960029602,
0.15056490898132324,
-0.734737753868103,
-0.1708124727010727,
-0.6918002367019653,
-0.002356764394789934,
0.04447133466601372,
0.08231804519891739,
-0.4430254101753235,
0.5437024831771851,
0.17409871518611908,
0.6820400953292847,
-0.8044551014900208,
0.7269033193588257,
0.8157029151916504,
-0.20691069960594177,
-0.8525519967079163,
0.2292552888393402,
-0.07289787381887436,
-0.8366457223892212,
0.517556369304657,
0.30122774839401245,
-0.34036532044410706,
0.5110246539115906,
-0.2980997860431671,
-0.8936961889266968,
0.8525592684745789,
0.04803727939724922,
-0.39598530530929565,
0.22977828979492188,
-0.17322562634944916,
0.500506579875946,
-0.4067535996437073,
0.03141959011554718,
0.551164448261261,
0.1931239515542984,
0.3953995406627655,
-0.9281268119812012,
-0.22437229752540588,
-0.17300042510032654,
0.10937849432229996,
0.16513247787952423,
-0.6838158369064331,
0.7133845090866089,
-0.255082905292511,
-0.47572168707847595,
0.027663802728056908,
0.7462178468704224,
0.11546721309423447,
0.21153058111667633,
0.8150043487548828,
0.5270165801048279,
0.7289735078811646,
-0.1862281858921051,
0.4637530446052551,
0.038007158786058426,
0.029260622337460518,
1.1047773361206055,
-0.41389089822769165,
0.9809958934783936,
0.2511763870716095,
0.04079020768404007,
0.8513731956481934,
0.7958352565765381,
0.06928583979606628,
0.6637939810752869,
0.24728040397167206,
-0.4287478029727936,
-0.3563528060913086,
-0.08796419948339462,
-0.21850815415382385,
0.7415416240692139,
0.27237269282341003,
0.06561952829360962,
-0.48150548338890076,
0.6347416043281555,
-0.14016352593898773,
0.24824485182762146,
-0.16282951831817627,
1.3389588594436646,
0.13923406600952148,
-0.436139315366745,
0.8486623167991638,
-0.13599729537963867,
0.4794335961341858,
-0.5158907175064087,
-0.02789798192679882,
-0.1768232136964798,
0.30784061551094055,
-0.20975419878959656,
-0.45613646507263184,
0.22861246764659882,
-0.1270551234483719,
-0.10329396277666092,
-0.2910432517528534,
0.6163380146026611,
-0.6249290704727173,
-0.10853859037160873,
0.4125661253929138,
0.46597209572792053,
0.2174331098794937,
-0.3357720673084259,
-0.7123054265975952,
0.03304758667945862,
0.17231261730194092,
-0.13279762864112854,
0.14578047394752502,
0.3643086552619934,
-0.09907514601945877,
0.825685441493988,
0.5548205971717834,
0.07834814488887787,
0.02745898813009262,
0.05504890903830528,
1.0749716758728027,
-0.7206048369407654,
-0.6612188816070557,
-0.5859046578407288,
0.8164182305335999,
-0.15845707058906555,
-0.07794567942619324,
0.5985391736030579,
0.6992021799087524,
0.7774821519851685,
0.08128151297569275,
0.7796891927719116,
0.348356693983078,
0.9044075608253479,
-0.43477538228034973,
0.5290064811706543,
-0.5965588092803955,
-0.13619746267795563,
-0.03901168331503868,
-0.7611413598060608,
-0.037695955485105515,
0.7340522408485413,
-0.43320485949516296,
-0.11724259704351425,
0.5784369707107544,
0.6472992897033691,
0.014152183197438717,
-0.14218895137310028,
0.43137624859809875,
-0.09230168163776398,
-0.007109626196324825,
0.3367534875869751,
0.9130238890647888,
-0.3796648681163788,
0.10449383407831192,
0.04294632002711296,
-0.21464696526527405,
-0.08513667434453964,
-0.3089130222797394,
-0.8446344137191772,
-1.001098871231079,
-0.15472663938999176,
-0.35030409693717957,
0.16186784207820892,
1.0800493955612183,
0.5526286959648132,
-0.8817806243896484,
-0.3897981345653534,
0.06013360992074013,
-0.07737039029598236,
-0.0946701318025589,
-0.15762455761432648,
0.32615354657173157,
-0.3174023926258087,
-0.521108865737915,
0.969951868057251,
0.30867964029312134,
0.1889125406742096,
-0.206857830286026,
-0.19903147220611572,
-0.15270566940307617,
-0.09725192934274673,
0.1987360268831253,
0.8857634663581848,
-0.5523741841316223,
-0.18701240420341492,
-0.07182520627975464,
0.1798652708530426,
0.3386797606945038,
0.8369725346565247,
-1.0384615659713745,
0.5902683734893799,
-0.025082767009735107,
1.0711517333984375,
0.7637109160423279,
0.10569798201322556,
0.6501716375350952,
-0.9573079347610474,
0.3039742410182953,
0.24568942189216614,
0.25984713435173035,
0.6413342356681824,
-0.1301901489496231,
0.2634159028530121,
0.27163803577423096,
-0.37748032808303833,
-0.8095634579658508,
0.2520330846309662,
-0.657741904258728,
-0.29108473658561707,
1.193221092224121,
0.086952805519104,
-0.3004934787750244,
-0.13363763689994812,
-0.23405443131923676,
0.4982224404811859,
-0.4235415756702423,
0.563025176525116,
-0.0665285587310791,
-0.10947896540164948,
-0.3532510995864868,
-0.2715928554534912,
0.899185061454773,
0.2569630444049835,
-0.6907033920288086,
-0.1485639214515686,
0.35480087995529175,
0.5240904092788696,
0.21623176336288452,
0.7863497138023376,
0.09363799542188644,
0.40705451369285583,
-0.0878233090043068,
0.45802193880081177,
-0.1344926506280899,
-0.5733543634414673,
-0.4903540015220642,
-0.05316774919629097,
0.1428963541984558,
-0.5431835651397705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16874v1 | Enhancing Retrieval Processes for Language Generation with Augmented Queries | 2024-02-06T13:19:53 | 2024-02-06T13:19:53 | Julien Pierre Edmond Ghali, Kosuke Shima, Koichi Moriyama, Atsuko Mutoh, Nobuhiro Inuzuka | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | In the rapidly changing world of smart technology, searching for documents
has become more challenging due to the rise of advanced language models. These
models sometimes face difficulties, like providing inaccurate information,
commonly known as "hallucination." This research focuses on addressing this
issue through Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), a technique that guides
models to give accurate responses based on real facts. To overcome scalability
issues, the study explores connecting user queries with sophisticated language
models such as BERT and Orca2, using an innovative query optimization process.
The study unfolds in three scenarios: first, without RAG, second, without
additional assistance, and finally, with extra help. Choosing the compact yet
efficient Orca2 7B model demonstrates a smart use of computing resources. The
empirical results indicate a significant improvement in the initial language
model's performance under RAG, particularly when assisted with prompts
augmenters. Consistency in document retrieval across different encodings
highlights the effectiveness of using language model-generated queries. The
introduction of UMAP for BERT further simplifies document retrieval while
maintaining strong results. | [
-0.47558870911598206,
-1.0503661632537842,
0.5117349624633789,
-0.021425381302833557,
-0.04716317728161812,
0.10508790612220764,
-0.07642380148172379,
-0.749174952507019,
0.3565330505371094,
0.7841811180114746,
-0.3123098313808441,
-0.03825414925813675,
-0.16871659457683563,
-0.0494118295609951,
-0.47509831190109253,
0.7863214015960693,
0.2569713890552521,
0.07910741865634918,
-0.11560044437646866,
-0.19620661437511444,
-0.6228492259979248,
-0.627800703048706,
-0.7787312865257263,
-0.33577191829681396,
0.46866554021835327,
0.35327717661857605,
0.8448029160499573,
0.5833737850189209,
0.5120956897735596,
0.27821680903434753,
-0.14081282913684845,
0.7506495714187622,
-0.4440642297267914,
0.7125779390335083,
-0.2950371503829956,
-0.40522849559783936,
-0.3566373884677887,
-0.3961390554904938,
0.4668697416782379,
0.732242226600647,
-0.07339591532945633,
0.0269488338381052,
-0.006987184286117554,
0.7983689308166504,
-0.720422625541687,
-0.19136549532413483,
-0.9208179712295532,
-0.1062212884426117,
-0.368486225605011,
-0.4681253135204315,
-0.5109862089157104,
-0.38488873839378357,
0.03543929010629654,
-0.53861004114151,
0.5010828375816345,
0.33505091071128845,
0.8267159461975098,
0.12953747808933258,
-0.07275859266519547,
-0.7033748626708984,
-0.6673088669776917,
0.6127846837043762,
-0.4881393313407898,
0.5257558226585388,
0.5440564155578613,
0.3400733768939972,
-0.5828489065170288,
-0.8513683080673218,
-0.6866245865821838,
-0.21398387849330902,
-0.037524618208408356,
-0.061944443732500076,
0.21164175868034363,
-0.18189318478107452,
0.2881944179534912,
0.12647990882396698,
-0.5577760934829712,
-0.0022919310722500086,
-0.25963664054870605,
-0.16996131837368011,
0.5616395473480225,
0.06941009312868118,
0.31986483931541443,
-0.4994257986545563,
-0.0862484723329544,
-0.20874570310115814,
-0.4233214259147644,
-0.15605704486370087,
0.4576784372329712,
0.5399068593978882,
0.6794320940971375,
0.8192415833473206,
-0.010360089130699635,
0.7970582842826843,
0.09662911295890808,
-0.11373910307884216,
0.06902457028627396,
-0.2937459945678711,
0.12721094489097595,
-0.061888206750154495,
0.22934579849243164,
0.03244620934128761,
-0.05479990318417549,
-0.2416182905435562,
-0.642301082611084,
-0.19146503508090973,
0.5234367847442627,
-0.6098423600196838,
-0.09316955506801605,
0.24715614318847656,
-0.37298858165740967,
-0.17868205904960632,
0.013074537739157677,
-0.6037744283676147,
-0.647318422794342,
-0.33176228404045105,
0.5650957226753235,
-0.564041018486023,
-0.12803316116333008,
-0.13680331408977509,
-0.2517808973789215,
0.14744983613491058,
0.22883953154087067,
-1.105026125907898,
0.34893661737442017,
0.6225582361221313,
0.4865863621234894,
-0.050852466374635696,
0.10048524290323257,
-0.647725522518158,
0.14639829099178314,
-0.47094178199768066,
1.0800316333770752,
-0.6111462116241455,
-0.6291680932044983,
-0.04640397056937218,
-0.360099732875824,
0.06915316730737686,
-0.7397702932357788,
0.7789459824562073,
-1.031989336013794,
0.35226312279701233,
-0.4663347899913788,
-0.4047165513038635,
-0.11438531428575516,
0.14485237002372742,
-0.7907925844192505,
1.5863218307495117,
0.09912533313035965,
-0.6758118867874146,
0.2750186324119568,
-0.7096456289291382,
-0.4494037628173828,
0.2961771488189697,
-0.30205321311950684,
-0.3301515579223633,
0.32914236187934875,
0.27909114956855774,
0.07642143964767456,
-0.3628009259700775,
0.10434626787900925,
0.021391017362475395,
-0.3719724714756012,
-0.016834907233715057,
-0.030857441946864128,
0.5421133041381836,
0.440827876329422,
-0.1725575178861618,
-0.2211669385433197,
-0.807782769203186,
0.12201172858476639,
0.28828734159469604,
-0.46771299839019775,
-0.7110259532928467,
0.20842355489730835,
0.19197526574134827,
-0.13797682523727417,
0.4251804053783417,
-0.48256590962409973,
0.3868248760700226,
-0.5716062188148499,
-0.04012930765748024,
0.4336071312427521,
-0.014236199669539928,
0.403517484664917,
-0.2112131416797638,
0.29121044278144836,
-0.5217621922492981,
0.005419124849140644,
-0.1343664824962616,
-0.47928065061569214,
-0.7171306014060974,
-0.07032458484172821,
0.42533791065216064,
0.4017352759838104,
-1.0445334911346436,
0.24046148359775543,
0.0045877923257648945,
-0.4124818742275238,
-0.6614022254943848,
-0.09661534428596497,
0.3134988844394684,
0.7733889818191528,
0.309490829706192,
-0.31548428535461426,
-0.7452056407928467,
-0.5962544679641724,
-0.35230034589767456,
-0.2821154296398163,
0.01753860153257847,
0.7166304588317871,
0.14556732773780823,
-0.40628477931022644,
1.0098612308502197,
-0.5214323997497559,
-0.14501570165157318,
-0.2854839563369751,
0.45279228687286377,
0.16662433743476868,
0.3711162209510803,
0.4928465783596039,
-1.2482162714004517,
-0.4658313989639282,
0.12909798324108124,
-0.5628501772880554,
-0.3176197111606598,
0.0026946396101266146,
-0.2315450757741928,
0.8453704118728638,
0.3405115604400635,
-0.43409886956214905,
0.4372574985027313,
0.22263428568840027,
-0.1260906457901001,
0.6083942651748657,
-0.49814093112945557,
0.2011893093585968,
-0.9660269618034363,
0.38269785046577454,
-0.5076838731765747,
-0.20417420566082,
-0.5479981899261475,
0.35215646028518677,
0.08461934328079224,
-0.3861204981803894,
-0.06308270990848541,
0.7379030585289001,
-0.6492868661880493,
-0.4060109555721283,
-0.5731359124183655,
0.31831517815589905,
0.1644192785024643,
0.1192624643445015,
0.02671722322702408,
0.9826505780220032,
0.3139439821243286,
-0.6509501338005066,
0.1091982051730156,
0.29703599214553833,
-0.1332482099533081,
0.32583391666412354,
-0.5230647921562195,
0.3714497685432434,
-0.33084946870803833,
0.035138100385665894,
-0.9617599844932556,
-0.5221275687217712,
-0.2520323693752289,
-0.6827692985534668,
0.4940441846847534,
0.18307505548000336,
-0.9435369968414307,
-0.3576350808143616,
-0.313789963722229,
0.23658284544944763,
0.37693727016448975,
-0.8398755192756653,
0.8765610456466675,
0.5823663473129272,
-0.2661449611186981,
-0.5050321817398071,
-0.3791850805282593,
0.09998352825641632,
0.05074154958128929,
-0.7593636512756348,
0.3906956911087036,
-0.014284545555710793,
-0.11748123914003372,
0.0004415292351040989,
-0.19013577699661255,
-0.09269574284553528,
0.0007653308566659689,
-0.1112050786614418,
0.3339059054851532,
0.14971670508384705,
0.3863891363143921,
0.14686664938926697,
0.038510512560606,
-0.2344387322664261,
-0.11111452430486679,
0.8097410798072815,
0.12941063940525055,
-0.25618433952331543,
0.09925313293933868,
0.5667563080787659,
0.3674258291721344,
-0.42500653862953186,
0.6800360679626465,
0.6189515590667725,
-0.4043586850166321,
-0.2253303825855255,
-1.002862811088562,
-0.39295080304145813,
-0.5060558915138245,
0.20683832466602325,
-0.6130586862564087,
-0.7622005939483643,
0.7447057962417603,
0.013113194145262241,
0.10793697088956833,
0.3877604007720947,
0.5827793478965759,
-0.17745843529701233,
1.4018181562423706,
0.714606523513794,
0.3207356631755829,
0.6050804853439331,
-0.025254014879465103,
0.25506800413131714,
-0.8660684823989868,
-0.6042081117630005,
-0.8323598504066467,
-0.07695884257555008,
-0.7577763795852661,
-0.43241751194000244,
0.6840055584907532,
0.26662808656692505,
0.10574812442064285,
0.45761463046073914,
-0.6944746375083923,
0.2864619195461273,
0.7257786393165588,
0.03601391240954399,
0.22308947145938873,
0.20976296067237854,
-0.266338586807251,
-0.013290069065988064,
-0.8324019908905029,
-0.510159432888031,
1.0163568258285522,
-0.09689205884933472,
0.7865146994590759,
0.2361922711133957,
0.7271243333816528,
0.34159600734710693,
0.012083503417670727,
-0.5715287923812866,
0.5881186723709106,
-0.07077263295650482,
-0.8194054961204529,
-0.2629736661911011,
-0.3788551092147827,
-1.2983500957489014,
0.2764027714729309,
-0.3102235198020935,
-0.8308466672897339,
0.30899882316589355,
0.05742078274488449,
-0.31796762347221375,
-0.09273548424243927,
-0.65597003698349,
0.34510064125061035,
-0.26444536447525024,
-0.391299843788147,
-0.13868999481201172,
-0.7072921991348267,
0.14421388506889343,
-0.37276899814605713,
0.02175198495388031,
0.2887742221355438,
-0.09087500721216202,
0.4655919671058655,
-0.5819952487945557,
0.22003374993801117,
-0.0389658659696579,
0.052125703543424606,
0.45375365018844604,
0.08640645444393158,
0.8236955404281616,
-0.1311769187450409,
-0.513500988483429,
-0.4380519390106201,
-0.11487998068332672,
-0.32202550768852234,
-0.8174725770950317,
0.8083503842353821,
-0.5255236029624939,
-0.6199212074279785,
-0.2654932141304016,
-0.8426271080970764,
-0.21104460954666138,
0.4348585605621338,
0.23006248474121094,
0.509183406829834,
0.12024092674255371,
0.09874484688043594,
0.9450160264968872,
-0.2979396879673004,
0.4023374617099762,
0.6455937027931213,
-0.5167726874351501,
-0.12092375010251999,
1.026424527168274,
0.3925914466381073,
0.05857977643609047,
0.3841962516307831,
0.12937317788600922,
-0.5522736310958862,
-0.39604538679122925,
-0.2687947154045105,
0.32343482971191406,
-0.46236127614974976,
-0.11469337344169617,
-0.9663026928901672,
-0.0421038493514061,
-0.8350637555122375,
-0.08739059418439865,
-0.32079994678497314,
-0.6436486840248108,
-0.259615033864975,
0.1739051789045334,
0.22604061663150787,
0.5421638488769531,
-0.17299401760101318,
-0.1170755922794342,
-0.7649713158607483,
0.6038063764572144,
0.2525775730609894,
0.17755648493766785,
0.03863745555281639,
-0.4763883650302887,
-0.23177005350589752,
-0.2954237759113312,
-0.3770067095756531,
-0.9189161062240601,
0.5008849501609802,
0.06821777671575546,
0.6048717498779297,
0.07180897146463394,
0.17602258920669556,
0.6867708563804626,
-0.5564541816711426,
0.7045074701309204,
-0.30197426676750183,
-0.6307746767997742,
0.726871907711029,
-0.3841727375984192,
0.1287555992603302,
0.5378078818321228,
0.2761223018169403,
-0.12662525475025177,
-0.25027522444725037,
-0.7167659997940063,
-1.1446707248687744,
0.7393917441368103,
0.2505287230014801,
0.12828031182289124,
-0.13984107971191406,
0.43265435099601746,
0.07477980852127075,
0.16133959591388702,
-0.15272431075572968,
-0.07504194229841232,
0.05491752550005913,
0.2563624978065491,
0.5044092535972595,
-0.435898095369339,
0.21335144340991974,
-0.04134044423699379,
0.9003269076347351,
-0.047355469316244125,
0.247425839304924,
0.2735063433647156,
0.01986781321465969,
-0.17760440707206726,
-0.05313385650515556,
0.42563188076019287,
0.5798459649085999,
-0.3754425048828125,
-0.1411242038011551,
-0.020104747265577316,
-0.4602186381816864,
-0.30009108781814575,
0.3245146572589874,
-0.25370877981185913,
0.3305395841598511,
-0.012929323129355907,
0.5214471817016602,
-0.13758353888988495,
-0.9810882806777954,
0.021992970257997513,
-0.017257466912269592,
0.23737037181854248,
-0.1782071739435196,
0.07423096895217896,
-0.19727323949337006,
0.31766456365585327,
0.7435881495475769,
-0.0887332409620285,
0.6000669002532959,
-0.6585635542869568,
0.15800778567790985,
0.5710068345069885,
0.0518847331404686,
0.12024788558483124,
0.8326168656349182,
0.0551239475607872,
-0.5797712206840515,
0.6913556456565857,
-0.18063978850841522,
-0.41465696692466736,
0.32867488265037537,
0.5766028165817261,
0.6141268014907837,
-0.19625085592269897,
-0.00021546025527641177,
0.21807120740413666,
0.21264328062534332,
-0.1883780062198639,
0.6737613081932068,
-0.17372269928455353,
-0.5605215430259705,
-0.39878779649734497,
-0.7751647233963013,
-0.49901697039604187,
-0.0553973950445652,
-0.770186722278595,
0.2532581388950348,
-0.09414909780025482,
-0.5110235214233398,
0.01808396354317665,
0.33566129207611084,
-0.33129552006721497,
0.2539394199848175,
0.004724203608930111,
0.8784953355789185,
-0.31420156359672546,
0.8289424180984497,
0.8315778970718384,
-0.4862615466117859,
-0.9464622139930725,
-0.06755422800779343,
-0.25760185718536377,
-0.6784256100654602,
0.6669204235076904,
-0.021103879436850548,
-0.1607740819454193,
0.07500918954610825,
-0.39284709095954895,
-0.769519031047821,
0.871128261089325,
0.2879582345485687,
-0.21567951142787933,
-0.0792166143655777,
-0.03972284495830536,
0.6982970237731934,
-0.10571195930242538,
0.2656534016132355,
0.6236644387245178,
0.42281830310821533,
0.23979441821575165,
-0.7333524227142334,
-0.17398163676261902,
-0.22783860564231873,
0.48541224002838135,
0.415031373500824,
-0.37146565318107605,
0.7957533597946167,
-0.16424669325351715,
-0.20632484555244446,
0.46568772196769714,
0.8311501145362854,
0.573422372341156,
0.3288133442401886,
0.3307487666606903,
0.4989243447780609,
0.972909152507782,
0.01737619750201702,
1.3716518878936768,
-0.24478960037231445,
0.25421079993247986,
1.0399212837219238,
-0.2892715632915497,
0.9274901747703552,
0.5595753788948059,
0.18249404430389404,
0.3137226104736328,
0.4572015404701233,
0.3075794577598572,
0.5062164664268494,
-0.04843272268772125,
-0.3392139971256256,
-0.05390137806534767,
-0.5751349925994873,
-0.29900458455085754,
0.29965558648109436,
0.46147865056991577,
-0.36277422308921814,
-0.21625922620296478,
0.010687373578548431,
-0.043941035866737366,
0.4292956292629242,
-0.1464320421218872,
0.8476284742355347,
-0.33058762550354004,
-0.9564618468284607,
0.5699551105499268,
0.13875192403793335,
0.33949342370033264,
-0.480888694524765,
-0.22227537631988525,
-0.565578043460846,
-0.09305538982152939,
-0.23992130160331726,
-0.5300788283348083,
0.32945600152015686,
0.17078660428524017,
-0.43610459566116333,
-0.16588349640369415,
1.0809086561203003,
-0.34475043416023254,
-0.4769996404647827,
0.08226871490478516,
0.4662344753742218,
0.5455345511436462,
0.02609950117766857,
-0.6362122297286987,
0.2582054138183594,
-0.052507057785987854,
-0.31387367844581604,
0.37618890404701233,
0.5685234665870667,
-0.31614282727241516,
0.523815929889679,
0.7262097597122192,
0.18127402663230896,
0.18482986092567444,
0.20375245809555054,
1.0957815647125244,
-0.3377609848976135,
-0.20723450183868408,
-0.35862141847610474,
0.3085611164569855,
-0.13434626162052155,
0.16279126703739166,
0.8214285373687744,
0.6677225828170776,
0.69717937707901,
0.0908489003777504,
0.6303189396858215,
-0.34742313623428345,
0.9435232281684875,
-0.3950556814670563,
0.7983216643333435,
-0.7104805111885071,
0.45858120918273926,
-0.21879924833774567,
-1.2737705707550049,
-0.2083054929971695,
0.44781485199928284,
-0.10188314318656921,
0.14573754370212555,
0.3458918333053589,
1.1828783750534058,
0.10558446496725082,
-0.18980920314788818,
0.31612882018089294,
0.00740654906257987,
0.349808931350708,
-0.0771431028842926,
0.439434289932251,
-0.494240403175354,
0.4399074614048004,
-0.04363356903195381,
-0.17054583132266998,
-0.5765560865402222,
-0.6572538614273071,
-0.6548144817352295,
-0.5618212223052979,
0.14162969589233398,
-0.40681955218315125,
0.3096091151237488,
0.7603421211242676,
0.49650102853775024,
-0.6815646886825562,
-0.08550820499658585,
-0.05117965489625931,
0.04107340797781944,
0.01725747622549534,
-0.2888355255126953,
0.49831002950668335,
-0.9489802718162537,
-0.9726905226707458,
0.593660831451416,
0.18440550565719604,
-0.09737592935562134,
-0.3405170142650604,
0.12972763180732727,
-0.40543773770332336,
0.4472234547138214,
0.6434853076934814,
0.5725277662277222,
-0.5253608822822571,
-0.16944819688796997,
0.2137679159641266,
-0.24992190301418304,
-0.21487106382846832,
0.684654951095581,
-1.0471614599227905,
0.9865014553070068,
0.801361620426178,
0.9433766603469849,
0.5153319239616394,
0.3598370850086212,
0.52571040391922,
-0.833060622215271,
0.042623236775398254,
0.4373384118080139,
0.05047020688652992,
0.4649292826652527,
-0.5311258435249329,
0.7325930595397949,
0.040046658366918564,
-0.6812759041786194,
-1.0922212600708008,
0.053090669214725494,
-0.7820767164230347,
-0.2700026333332062,
0.984039843082428,
0.3097892999649048,
-0.12134816497564316,
-0.11886642128229141,
-0.5214690566062927,
0.2904704809188843,
-0.41941264271736145,
1.0216141939163208,
0.3858611285686493,
-0.437877357006073,
0.16077934205532074,
-0.5886222124099731,
0.3773018419742584,
0.7103775143623352,
-0.6138886213302612,
-0.26376932859420776,
0.5546307563781738,
-0.3571477234363556,
0.5012474060058594,
0.4746767282485962,
-0.17507296800613403,
0.3142838180065155,
-0.04109775647521019,
0.10203386843204498,
-0.05142514035105705,
-0.4526088237762451,
0.09435679018497467,
0.29257073998451233,
0.14771392941474915,
0.038141533732414246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05136v1 | LV-Eval: A Balanced Long-Context Benchmark with 5 Length Levels Up to 256K | 2024-02-06T13:11:19 | 2024-02-06T13:11:19 | Tao Yuan, Xuefei Ning, Dong Zhou, Zhijie Yang, Shiyao Li, Minghui Zhuang, Zheyue Tan, Zhuyu Yao, Dahua Lin, Boxun Li, Guohao Dai, Shengen Yan, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) are now claiming remarkable
supported context lengths of 256k or even more. In contrast, the average
context lengths of mainstream benchmarks are insufficient (5k-21k), and they
suffer from potential knowledge leakage and inaccurate metrics, resulting in
biased evaluation. This paper introduces LV-Eval, a challenging long-context
benchmark with five length levels (16k, 32k, 64k, 128k, and 256k) reaching up
to 256k words. LV-Eval features two main tasks, single-hop QA and multi-hop QA,
comprising 11 bilingual datasets. The design of LV-Eval has incorporated three
key techniques, namely confusing facts insertion, keyword and phrase
replacement, and keyword-recall-based metric design. The advantages of LV-Eval
include controllable evaluation across different context lengths, challenging
test instances with confusing facts, mitigated knowledge leakage, and more
objective evaluations. We evaluate 10 LLMs on LV-Eval and conduct ablation
studies on the techniques used in LV-Eval construction. The results reveal
that: (i) Commercial LLMs generally outperform open-source LLMs when evaluated
within length levels shorter than their claimed context length. However, their
overall performance is surpassed by open-source LLMs with longer context
lengths. (ii) Extremely long-context LLMs, such as Yi-6B-200k, exhibit a
relatively gentle degradation of performance, but their absolute performances
may not necessarily be higher than those of LLMs with shorter context lengths.
(iii) LLMs' performances can significantly degrade in the presence of confusing
information, especially in the pressure test of "needle in a haystack". (iv)
Issues related to knowledge leakage and inaccurate metrics introduce bias in
evaluation, and these concerns are alleviated in LV-Eval. All datasets and
evaluation codes are released at: https://github.com/infinigence/LVEval. | [
-0.3878425359725952,
-0.8653793334960938,
0.636425256729126,
0.17849791049957275,
-0.16906973719596863,
0.318275511264801,
-0.3228640556335449,
-0.7157111167907715,
-0.22887755930423737,
0.5195867419242859,
-0.29747095704078674,
-0.38859793543815613,
-0.2990923523902893,
0.19353121519088745,
-0.6889017224311829,
0.8360427021980286,
-0.34500476717948914,
-0.09142870455980301,
-0.4366113841533661,
-0.44213050603866577,
-0.48848778009414673,
-0.46831780672073364,
-0.34872522950172424,
-0.21745474636554718,
0.5810652375221252,
0.16860172152519226,
0.3686937689781189,
0.5570028424263,
0.3673226833343506,
0.19119620323181152,
-0.3057287931442261,
0.30364876985549927,
-0.6057887673377991,
0.15498819947242737,
-0.1026054099202156,
-0.37773817777633667,
-0.37131452560424805,
-0.34439975023269653,
0.9422199726104736,
0.516085147857666,
-0.14543025195598602,
0.3011449873447418,
0.08066730946302414,
1.10105562210083,
-0.9337838888168335,
-0.16497854888439178,
-0.37926626205444336,
-0.14656437933444977,
-0.367841511964798,
0.05617748945951462,
-0.3541170060634613,
-0.13678932189941406,
-0.03145366534590721,
-0.25529158115386963,
-0.33380913734436035,
0.09680180996656418,
0.6329169273376465,
0.336696982383728,
-0.47846654057502747,
-0.2189437448978424,
-0.6318871974945068,
0.9807075262069702,
-0.5532656311988831,
0.8351333141326904,
0.14980021119117737,
0.3694726824760437,
0.018742363899946213,
-0.6547670364379883,
-0.4615352153778076,
-0.1776197999715805,
0.16256083548069,
0.12373936176300049,
-0.20440298318862915,
0.05156288668513298,
0.40695810317993164,
0.23836229741573334,
-0.4670000672340393,
0.3540482223033905,
-0.5632609128952026,
-0.05555808171629906,
0.6977931261062622,
0.3244521915912628,
-0.035342298448085785,
-0.21060873568058014,
-0.7608082890510559,
0.03152227774262428,
-1.0542598962783813,
0.4597581624984741,
0.22694319486618042,
0.02119099535048008,
0.06195357069373131,
0.5040425658226013,
-0.4376642405986786,
0.7523224353790283,
-0.2849370241165161,
-0.18969234824180603,
0.4916219115257263,
-0.48851877450942993,
-0.37117981910705566,
-0.02519700489938259,
0.7014340758323669,
0.29844143986701965,
0.04802247881889343,
0.006545581389218569,
-0.5123031139373779,
-0.14074921607971191,
0.17917375266551971,
-0.8496475219726562,
0.5218706130981445,
0.46137914061546326,
-0.23866519331932068,
0.04297585412859917,
-0.20989537239074707,
-0.7852393984794617,
-0.18648242950439453,
-0.25542691349983215,
0.445188969373703,
-0.5700920224189758,
0.17021343111991882,
0.22450771927833557,
0.028314290568232536,
0.39082691073417664,
0.3225414752960205,
-0.3461662232875824,
0.4963928461074829,
0.9188090562820435,
0.7329102754592896,
-0.39791521430015564,
-0.25588834285736084,
-0.6576140522956848,
-0.3907495439052582,
-0.3348095417022705,
0.44727131724357605,
-0.43821951746940613,
-0.32094237208366394,
0.15684860944747925,
-0.07966160029172897,
0.22592571377754211,
-0.4591476023197174,
0.5893993973731995,
-0.5525110363960266,
0.20271897315979004,
-0.25608837604522705,
-0.8450304865837097,
0.011763745918869972,
0.22026470303535461,
-0.47483789920806885,
1.2771791219711304,
0.2959690988063812,
-0.5297149419784546,
0.36046868562698364,
-0.4900290369987488,
-0.13496854901313782,
0.2524092197418213,
-0.12020740658044815,
-0.29270556569099426,
-0.042422614991664886,
0.07745645940303802,
0.3156183958053589,
-0.4244011342525482,
0.18893559277057648,
-0.022521277889609337,
-0.6137508153915405,
0.20398209989070892,
-0.6491065621376038,
0.604731023311615,
0.321730375289917,
-0.172336146235466,
0.0541137158870697,
-0.8527666330337524,
0.1202097088098526,
-0.10198775678873062,
-0.4503323435783386,
-0.46875691413879395,
0.023019669577479362,
-0.13640443980693817,
0.06740009039640427,
0.38137415051460266,
-0.5480480790138245,
0.04436655342578888,
-0.47664496302604675,
0.18697087466716766,
0.6894745230674744,
-0.13583716750144958,
0.22273211181163788,
-0.17032195627689362,
0.7236641049385071,
-0.16216512024402618,
0.15079562366008759,
-0.374062180519104,
-0.05795702338218689,
-0.7292084097862244,
-0.37233424186706543,
0.362756609916687,
0.5835256576538086,
-0.7140379548072815,
0.5225209593772888,
-0.4083869755268097,
-0.41994282603263855,
-0.6788519620895386,
0.4355951249599457,
0.6571961641311646,
0.5329406261444092,
0.47216376662254333,
-0.2198769897222519,
-0.30294859409332275,
-1.1090799570083618,
-0.44444355368614197,
0.004081198945641518,
-0.0989101305603981,
0.27578407526016235,
0.6713809370994568,
-0.2331583946943283,
0.9334067702293396,
-0.2056461125612259,
-0.09260199964046478,
-0.06981997191905975,
-0.15509876608848572,
0.2796168327331543,
-0.008768662810325623,
0.39084216952323914,
-0.4038076102733612,
-0.4309297800064087,
-0.02640494890511036,
-0.38218802213668823,
-0.2331790328025818,
0.14069290459156036,
0.2028535008430481,
0.39050206542015076,
0.41945886611938477,
-0.34723469614982605,
0.10013069957494736,
0.6277825236320496,
-0.3460823893547058,
0.5865960121154785,
-0.19734276831150055,
0.03938347473740578,
-0.9947717189788818,
0.05772414058446884,
0.1576991230249405,
-0.5010154247283936,
-0.5619602799415588,
0.24717284739017487,
0.5998400449752808,
0.3398192822933197,
-0.9750310778617859,
0.7990003824234009,
-0.3880734443664551,
0.019282294437289238,
-0.13206635415554047,
0.26065000891685486,
0.023689545691013336,
0.35131943225860596,
-0.21152128279209137,
0.9594014286994934,
0.32557326555252075,
-0.363694965839386,
0.5931681394577026,
-0.12357428669929504,
-0.7757076621055603,
0.6505517959594727,
-0.5370423197746277,
0.022231603041291237,
-0.13366854190826416,
0.42721331119537354,
-0.5906367897987366,
0.1682247519493103,
-0.25735002756118774,
-0.15746672451496124,
0.19231539964675903,
0.2033666968345642,
-0.43348127603530884,
-0.4290104806423187,
-0.5855152010917664,
0.7512251734733582,
0.82341068983078,
-0.6472643613815308,
0.1044418066740036,
0.09888051450252533,
0.04034481570124626,
-0.9786631464958191,
-0.4837689995765686,
0.11186204105615616,
-0.5445335507392883,
-0.5990275144577026,
0.34636548161506653,
-0.23761814832687378,
-0.3493712544441223,
-0.2065609097480774,
-0.11867745220661163,
0.15930232405662537,
0.024807976558804512,
-0.03623338043689728,
0.029518892988562584,
-0.2054591327905655,
0.31700706481933594,
-0.16935697197914124,
0.07392095029354095,
0.11485563218593597,
0.05793953686952591,
0.38159844279289246,
-0.5483303070068359,
-0.4356182813644409,
-0.15111590921878815,
0.23854918777942657,
0.638258695602417,
-0.13742363452911377,
0.5444362759590149,
0.3209291398525238,
-0.3813415765762329,
-0.5645376443862915,
-0.7488602995872498,
0.22598694264888763,
-0.4479335844516754,
0.6362919807434082,
-0.37710797786712646,
-0.907365083694458,
0.5424525141716003,
-0.14607739448547363,
-0.028333188965916634,
0.3477323055267334,
0.562593936920166,
0.09307733923196793,
0.7536028027534485,
0.416791170835495,
-0.3500853478908539,
0.3222859799861908,
-0.06150045245885849,
0.11323050409555435,
-1.0656375885009766,
-0.15529488027095795,
-0.3150266706943512,
-0.1938752681016922,
-0.44338876008987427,
-0.6425188183784485,
0.5406765341758728,
0.1719609797000885,
-0.26760590076446533,
0.12581637501716614,
-0.2789705991744995,
0.6157782077789307,
0.26186829805374146,
-0.1433367282152176,
0.20090925693511963,
-0.36561697721481323,
-0.038109585642814636,
0.04945160448551178,
-0.3963320553302765,
-0.38208040595054626,
1.1460285186767578,
0.747422993183136,
0.7813372611999512,
0.015354851260781288,
0.6742745041847229,
0.2217181921005249,
0.04042782634496689,
-0.8569678664207458,
0.4484015107154846,
0.10115285217761993,
-0.25420233607292175,
-0.5027454495429993,
-0.25668010115623474,
-0.977410078048706,
0.2826283574104309,
0.04221043735742569,
-0.7249996662139893,
-0.020880430936813354,
-0.13717888295650482,
-0.3728748857975006,
0.14632254838943481,
-0.3768309950828552,
0.6267001032829285,
-0.6969952583312988,
-0.7069863677024841,
-0.12507496774196625,
-0.529328465461731,
0.4620856046676636,
-0.4183865487575531,
0.4722634553909302,
-0.026467038318514824,
-0.24435563385486603,
0.7530349493026733,
-0.4733164608478546,
0.5016400814056396,
0.10426011681556702,
-0.31144335865974426,
0.1447622925043106,
-0.08995327353477478,
0.6622384190559387,
0.13246779143810272,
-0.005766537506133318,
0.11498112231492996,
0.21200746297836304,
-0.309496134519577,
-0.5128920078277588,
0.802288293838501,
-0.7415720224380493,
-0.5180895328521729,
-0.3260384500026703,
-0.33093130588531494,
-0.28665727376937866,
0.20829421281814575,
0.13925303518772125,
0.27524709701538086,
-0.362186074256897,
0.7251081466674805,
0.7053408026695251,
-0.3868233859539032,
0.4081858992576599,
0.6631132364273071,
-0.34808123111724854,
-0.27533426880836487,
0.8141729831695557,
0.021793365478515625,
0.4338670074939728,
0.39571523666381836,
0.1763274222612381,
-0.39363572001457214,
-0.4401300549507141,
-0.401674747467041,
-0.03188829496502876,
-0.6463067531585693,
-0.2791491448879242,
-0.4717916250228882,
-0.5099655389785767,
0.007220055907964706,
-0.16690003871917725,
-0.8370303511619568,
-0.04646480455994606,
0.08875879645347595,
-0.14610688388347626,
0.24413181841373444,
0.565079391002655,
0.15674535930156708,
-0.22145935893058777,
-0.5706791877746582,
0.2745213806629181,
0.2017599642276764,
0.5000061392784119,
-0.09760070592164993,
-0.3760472238063812,
-0.40069106221199036,
0.015423059463500977,
-0.21691550314426422,
-0.6933217644691467,
0.36381492018699646,
-0.11712584644556046,
0.5010006427764893,
0.37572774291038513,
0.035234734416007996,
0.594125509262085,
-0.658420741558075,
1.0889763832092285,
0.2533567547798157,
-1.004429817199707,
0.37683767080307007,
-0.22549891471862793,
0.24637295305728912,
0.5642659664154053,
0.11341802030801773,
-0.772646963596344,
-0.32705971598625183,
-0.4896807372570038,
-1.1982108354568481,
0.37195125222206116,
0.03872007131576538,
0.04493528977036476,
-0.0336567759513855,
0.11619114130735397,
0.30840766429901123,
0.15386246144771576,
-0.641112208366394,
-0.21461345255374908,
0.027809549123048782,
-0.08778594434261322,
-0.1585293710231781,
-0.44096943736076355,
-0.18283580243587494,
-0.3494647443294525,
0.423943430185318,
-0.09875523298978806,
-0.13054141402244568,
0.1703023612499237,
-0.19362393021583557,
0.07339336723089218,
0.618222177028656,
0.86053067445755,
0.9304584860801697,
-0.2749151289463043,
0.14860741794109344,
0.7138750553131104,
-0.023643821477890015,
0.11548741906881332,
-0.12586823105812073,
0.08081469684839249,
-0.2806614339351654,
0.5140098333358765,
0.8758975863456726,
0.13509467244148254,
-1.038124918937683,
0.7632972598075867,
0.10657571256160736,
-0.2886650264263153,
-0.4789728820323944,
-0.018121769651770592,
0.1711985170841217,
0.19418416917324066,
0.2738725543022156,
-0.5001394748687744,
-0.026402581483125687,
-0.5115591287612915,
0.08843976259231567,
0.5668741464614868,
-0.3327226936817169,
-0.1666085422039032,
0.4293450117111206,
0.37204480171203613,
-0.38155752420425415,
0.48742374777793884,
0.10165176540613174,
-0.37523406744003296,
0.5519293546676636,
0.3771243095397949,
0.6697170734405518,
-0.22668953239917755,
-0.1082523763179779,
0.19779670238494873,
0.3232751190662384,
-0.28678834438323975,
0.1960245817899704,
-0.1249418556690216,
-0.5555070042610168,
-0.4139023423194885,
-0.8101226687431335,
-0.46807363629341125,
0.4979349374771118,
-0.6581622958183289,
0.38714468479156494,
-0.0912635549902916,
0.22844356298446655,
-0.39290571212768555,
0.21730412542819977,
-0.95000821352005,
0.09550217539072037,
0.12114708870649338,
1.1252355575561523,
-0.6518281698226929,
0.7757754921913147,
0.21695467829704285,
-0.12024997919797897,
-0.49888986349105835,
-0.2748536765575409,
0.047494854778051376,
-0.9439010620117188,
0.6455090045928955,
0.13830555975437164,
0.013023117557168007,
-0.46675431728363037,
-0.28393229842185974,
-0.8573839664459229,
1.2605619430541992,
0.08299098163843155,
-0.9150238037109375,
0.07982899993658066,
0.2803402841091156,
0.7929840087890625,
-0.24155880510807037,
0.23117470741271973,
0.8378188014030457,
0.5573714375495911,
-0.2354171723127365,
-1.1408298015594482,
0.0827089473605156,
-0.12499065697193146,
-0.04344698786735535,
0.2585729956626892,
-0.9386922121047974,
0.7684891223907471,
0.12816289067268372,
-0.15340808033943176,
0.1091160848736763,
0.4736425578594208,
0.31035226583480835,
0.2813851833343506,
0.46593010425567627,
0.49943020939826965,
0.7921146750450134,
0.09976879507303238,
1.1041947603225708,
-0.5745722651481628,
0.3116939663887024,
0.8049399256706238,
-0.4417760670185089,
1.12848961353302,
0.6453497409820557,
-0.2237829566001892,
0.3345504105091095,
0.4522285461425781,
0.08004720509052277,
0.35556960105895996,
0.5420473217964172,
-0.34517207741737366,
-0.014480517245829105,
0.02883235178887844,
-0.46669939160346985,
0.385415643453598,
0.4270665943622589,
-0.22127455472946167,
-0.17819403111934662,
-0.1112932562828064,
-0.19170790910720825,
0.045013830065727234,
-0.15117043256759644,
0.5381870865821838,
0.3211204409599304,
-0.748927116394043,
0.781586229801178,
0.04100698605179787,
0.7824741005897522,
-0.5992414951324463,
0.1929721236228943,
-0.288195937871933,
0.24819451570510864,
-0.055092062801122665,
-0.8810076117515564,
0.0491262748837471,
0.09256846457719803,
0.10519294440746307,
-0.4799830913543701,
0.6798679232597351,
-0.42540329694747925,
-0.33408674597740173,
0.5348397493362427,
0.6371954679489136,
-0.0461030937731266,
0.06677291542291641,
-0.4512108862400055,
0.1969636231660843,
-0.22172881662845612,
-0.6111562848091125,
0.45442941784858704,
0.309450626373291,
-0.2382536232471466,
0.7620261907577515,
0.38637086749076843,
0.2855713963508606,
-0.12268819659948349,
-0.044652678072452545,
0.7312920689582825,
-0.8758807182312012,
-0.31552883982658386,
-0.9753751158714294,
0.54465252161026,
0.03835812211036682,
-0.31866008043289185,
0.6115444302558899,
0.8050157427787781,
0.887148380279541,
0.2737051844596863,
0.7544767260551453,
0.41349121928215027,
0.5432665348052979,
-0.6731260418891907,
0.4720788300037384,
-0.8799073100090027,
0.519694983959198,
-0.1173485517501831,
-0.9366686344146729,
-0.004221112933009863,
0.19356654584407806,
0.038174837827682495,
0.0849367156624794,
0.8869235515594482,
0.416936993598938,
0.046572454273700714,
-0.3729728162288666,
0.5608309507369995,
0.22407399117946625,
0.5803146958351135,
0.9700751304626465,
1.0873788595199585,
-0.30393534898757935,
0.3562207818031311,
-0.14757001399993896,
-0.1868625432252884,
-0.3627427816390991,
-0.9206222891807556,
-0.7944201827049255,
-0.5153417587280273,
-0.061563607305288315,
-0.18783776462078094,
0.18018501996994019,
0.7116665840148926,
0.438005268573761,
-0.3901577591896057,
-0.30587393045425415,
0.06254944205284119,
0.20545019209384918,
-0.2019994854927063,
-0.23355156183242798,
0.3296061158180237,
-0.25544121861457825,
-0.7316156625747681,
0.8381239175796509,
0.36044102907180786,
-0.35213035345077515,
-0.5400257706642151,
-0.22674855589866638,
0.1798774152994156,
0.24533000588417053,
0.8336284160614014,
0.3473289906978607,
-0.9774121046066284,
-0.6800491809844971,
-0.06649050861597061,
-0.16821664571762085,
-0.03642068803310394,
0.4435769319534302,
-0.998155951499939,
0.49006137251853943,
0.6556298136711121,
0.7127139568328857,
0.4117489755153656,
0.09393346309661865,
0.5091830492019653,
-0.922756552696228,
-0.15796324610710144,
0.26977303624153137,
0.4685353636741638,
0.05417971685528755,
-0.20356327295303345,
0.489464670419693,
-0.1720544844865799,
-0.675442099571228,
-1.1216222047805786,
0.11270395666360855,
-1.0384478569030762,
-0.320137083530426,
1.4084073305130005,
0.16127385199069977,
-0.35852792859077454,
0.1255113035440445,
-0.04081832244992256,
-0.12258730083703995,
-0.2599527835845947,
0.6723290085792542,
0.9289000630378723,
-0.1382422149181366,
-0.11764036118984222,
-0.7526856660842896,
0.5535682439804077,
0.39414435625076294,
-0.6719773411750793,
0.17579860985279083,
0.485545814037323,
0.5197831392288208,
0.08484742045402527,
0.6924676895141602,
0.02375207468867302,
0.22782553732395172,
-0.31106656789779663,
0.041775524616241455,
-0.1808287501335144,
-0.29556092619895935,
-0.46229270100593567,
0.13814350962638855,
0.042522940784692764,
-0.03017471544444561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03962v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03962v3 | Position: Stop Making Unscientific AGI Performance Claims | 2024-02-06T12:42:21 | 2024-05-31T15:16:21 | Patrick Altmeyer, Andrew M. Demetriou, Antony Bartlett, Cynthia C. S. Liem | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Developments in the field of Artificial Intelligence (AI), and particularly
large language models (LLMs), have created a 'perfect storm' for observing
'sparks' of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) that are spurious. Like
simpler models, LLMs distill meaningful representations in their latent
embeddings that have been shown to correlate with external variables.
Nonetheless, the correlation of such representations has often been linked to
human-like intelligence in the latter but not the former. We probe models of
varying complexity including random projections, matrix decompositions, deep
autoencoders and transformers: all of them successfully distill information
that can be used to predict latent or external variables and yet none of them
have previously been linked to AGI. We argue and empirically demonstrate that
the finding of meaningful patterns in latent spaces of models cannot be seen as
evidence in favor of AGI. Additionally, we review literature from the social
sciences that shows that humans are prone to seek such patterns and
anthropomorphize. We conclude that both the methodological setup and common
public image of AI are ideal for the misinterpretation that correlations
between model representations and some variables of interest are 'caused' by
the model's understanding of underlying 'ground truth' relationships. We,
therefore, call for the academic community to exercise extra caution, and to be
keenly aware of principles of academic integrity, in interpreting and
communicating about AI research outcomes. | [
-0.11285509914159775,
-0.7935846447944641,
0.8090104460716248,
-0.11780782788991928,
0.15704934298992157,
0.3253605365753174,
-0.1895318180322647,
-0.5940185189247131,
0.14739666879177094,
0.09878569096326828,
-0.16474080085754395,
-0.05685458332300186,
-0.658586859703064,
-0.11419342458248138,
-0.7085000872612,
0.6449762582778931,
0.24513432383537292,
-0.06012452393770218,
-0.6641712784767151,
-0.2103896141052246,
-0.16360661387443542,
-0.7403912544250488,
-0.5069539546966553,
-0.6838923096656799,
0.49460238218307495,
0.10744892805814743,
0.9971042275428772,
0.8989410400390625,
0.3577466607093811,
0.33033788204193115,
-0.20501065254211426,
0.1143028736114502,
-0.4241097867488861,
-0.08650358021259308,
-0.15775887668132782,
-0.6703482866287231,
-0.347648948431015,
0.5469500422477722,
0.5796990394592285,
1.0198992490768433,
-0.1044110357761383,
0.12278693169355392,
-0.0030378669034689665,
0.5611425638198853,
-0.5676041841506958,
0.10553929954767227,
-0.5397957563400269,
-0.06555178761482239,
-0.256299763917923,
-0.008000990375876427,
-0.3694741725921631,
-0.025252167135477066,
-0.06662137806415558,
-0.4627458155155182,
0.38497260212898254,
0.17819257080554962,
0.7782449126243591,
0.5542553663253784,
-0.2516438066959381,
-0.22944815456867218,
-1.251194715499878,
0.9376293420791626,
-0.546455442905426,
0.09308227896690369,
0.513577401638031,
0.17593707144260406,
-0.1685234159231186,
-0.47724196314811707,
-0.8032172322273254,
-0.5213388800621033,
-0.1417248547077179,
0.033242397010326385,
-0.26697108149528503,
-0.11110866814851761,
0.28676849603652954,
0.3381536304950714,
-0.4035584330558777,
0.3134731948375702,
-0.46039772033691406,
-0.13563784956932068,
0.9166656136512756,
0.12668751180171967,
0.2884349524974823,
0.35410964488983154,
0.0671214908361435,
-0.10732609778642654,
-0.8261398077011108,
0.30152422189712524,
0.4170931577682495,
0.10460292547941208,
0.03679265081882477,
0.5604693293571472,
0.04103460535407066,
0.25997576117515564,
0.06037559732794762,
0.33655014634132385,
0.08924804627895355,
-0.2692534923553467,
0.08612684905529022,
-0.11485964804887772,
0.8118957877159119,
0.044830258935689926,
0.48149847984313965,
-0.6172290444374084,
0.04997352883219719,
0.6730430126190186,
0.3963146209716797,
-0.40374287962913513,
-0.2522459924221039,
0.0930858701467514,
-0.30389055609703064,
-0.2068570852279663,
0.3400653302669525,
-0.5242573022842407,
-0.34499549865722656,
-0.3867935836315155,
-0.0010058105690404773,
-0.2830502986907959,
-0.20998790860176086,
-0.37760433554649353,
-0.0417444221675396,
0.37429800629615784,
0.04540121927857399,
-0.6641008853912354,
0.3460167348384857,
0.8311759829521179,
0.7489878535270691,
-0.17536717653274536,
-0.5787068009376526,
-0.15308703482151031,
0.28039664030075073,
-0.7054353952407837,
0.7790187001228333,
-0.8626226782798767,
-0.5595241189002991,
-0.0686124935746193,
-0.15046735107898712,
-0.16890612244606018,
-0.4527323544025421,
0.41338610649108887,
-0.23982134461402893,
0.20346835255622864,
-0.2585635781288147,
-0.4395604133605957,
-0.30095717310905457,
-0.03578374162316322,
-0.5311482548713684,
0.769956648349762,
-0.028865521773695946,
-0.3603232800960541,
0.3148933947086334,
-0.8822271227836609,
-0.556817889213562,
0.03523460403084755,
-0.5868759155273438,
-0.17233023047447205,
0.4136349558830261,
-0.013772724196314812,
0.1760641634464264,
-0.2426004409790039,
0.8678056001663208,
-0.4052828550338745,
-0.413117378950119,
0.38417723774909973,
-0.6914823651313782,
0.4043639302253723,
0.19529807567596436,
-0.42309144139289856,
0.15913817286491394,
-0.6462210416793823,
-0.24175617098808289,
0.1630871593952179,
0.03423541784286499,
-0.401348739862442,
0.3477022349834442,
-0.4619777202606201,
0.041798293590545654,
0.18460658192634583,
-0.34694454073905945,
0.19401168823242188,
-0.3682313859462738,
0.6902400851249695,
0.8665823936462402,
-0.4252433478832245,
0.5279263257980347,
-0.5562266707420349,
0.22965393960475922,
0.035105131566524506,
0.08407315611839294,
0.10573700815439224,
-0.6086251735687256,
-0.610338032245636,
-0.0701352059841156,
0.15178853273391724,
0.3881596326828003,
-0.4172457158565521,
0.3360265791416168,
-0.32138484716415405,
-0.4606718420982361,
-0.617211103439331,
0.06311117857694626,
0.2669466733932495,
0.500615656375885,
0.3174046277999878,
-0.2118331789970398,
-0.17726977169513702,
-0.9694406390190125,
-0.5926486253738403,
-0.43753358721733093,
-0.1935330480337143,
0.6270738840103149,
0.6562088131904602,
-0.476799339056015,
1.055229902267456,
-0.17852936685085297,
-0.053675051778554916,
0.09499530494213104,
0.6191758513450623,
0.11144707351922989,
0.45199301838874817,
0.8320050239562988,
-0.8992038369178772,
0.006008913740515709,
-0.196564719080925,
-1.0789114236831665,
0.16225647926330566,
0.11489412933588028,
0.1863573044538498,
0.10127776861190796,
0.3360852897167206,
-0.6839072704315186,
0.4689038097858429,
0.16261136531829834,
-0.6708661913871765,
0.31633874773979187,
-0.28572702407836914,
0.21463963389396667,
-0.5009514093399048,
0.5250396132469177,
0.07589568942785263,
0.04380376636981964,
-0.6926087737083435,
-0.026358483359217644,
-0.48861947655677795,
0.1279243677854538,
-0.07476230710744858,
0.5120913982391357,
-0.27663275599479675,
0.035443730652332306,
-0.3739250600337982,
-0.27340638637542725,
-0.13548091053962708,
0.24730925261974335,
-0.2805490791797638,
0.9760819673538208,
0.4477475881576538,
-0.6067315936088562,
0.18202196061611176,
0.20480647683143616,
-0.14639705419540405,
0.14327548444271088,
-0.8398072123527527,
0.2834443151950836,
-0.3294018507003784,
0.02499728836119175,
-0.8688283562660217,
-0.4862850308418274,
0.07356134802103043,
-0.525159478187561,
0.23628981411457062,
0.45383986830711365,
-0.2679808735847473,
-0.5122352838516235,
-0.15936493873596191,
0.5204437375068665,
0.6248618960380554,
-0.3937716782093048,
0.7577831745147705,
0.5174453854560852,
-0.14778637886047363,
-0.4348709285259247,
-0.7617257833480835,
0.09336580336093903,
-0.3385626971721649,
-0.4916999936103821,
0.26788756251335144,
-0.14709623157978058,
-0.712579607963562,
0.23072713613510132,
-0.08204382658004761,
-0.1748272180557251,
0.3866264820098877,
0.4518742561340332,
0.24685876071453094,
-0.17176848649978638,
-0.00713663175702095,
-0.4246029555797577,
0.002113277092576027,
0.41147857904434204,
-0.05577521026134491,
0.24510321021080017,
-0.1208159476518631,
-0.39698326587677,
-0.1749308556318283,
0.5206900238990784,
0.7606173753738403,
-0.03140074759721756,
0.7268998622894287,
0.52336585521698,
-0.2077437937259674,
0.15800946950912476,
-0.44241926074028015,
-0.07007541507482529,
-0.388572633266449,
0.3121597468852997,
-0.03803161904215813,
-0.8697857856750488,
0.5855339765548706,
-0.21286992728710175,
-0.13338734209537506,
0.7278733253479004,
0.25588124990463257,
-0.10687656700611115,
1.2903436422348022,
0.873167872428894,
-0.5546336770057678,
0.3277195394039154,
-0.5178332924842834,
0.31248560547828674,
-0.6935802698135376,
-0.3267993927001953,
-0.6528329849243164,
-0.2104557752609253,
-0.5632458329200745,
-0.22944405674934387,
0.0660218745470047,
-0.036572348326444626,
-0.432035893201828,
-0.3045748472213745,
-0.5756595134735107,
0.53068608045578,
0.6723149418830872,
-0.14915134012699127,
0.048386313021183014,
-0.062191009521484375,
0.2656498849391937,
0.1765904277563095,
-0.7370513081550598,
-0.6222251653671265,
1.057923436164856,
0.22469252347946167,
0.7354415655136108,
-0.0726621150970459,
0.14155073463916779,
0.704289436340332,
0.3392174243927002,
-0.5594441890716553,
0.40903347730636597,
-0.23286396265029907,
-0.464059054851532,
-0.22972731292247772,
-0.43828073143959045,
-0.9705314040184021,
-0.11514211446046829,
-0.14841143786907196,
-0.9394279718399048,
0.41475710272789,
0.14893552660942078,
-0.384700208902359,
0.27873632311820984,
-0.6035914421081543,
0.5081198811531067,
-0.26359766721725464,
-0.48147597908973694,
-0.43362513184547424,
-0.591536819934845,
0.3819515109062195,
0.04190102219581604,
0.4903568923473358,
-0.071983702480793,
0.28551384806632996,
0.7908579111099243,
-0.14294439554214478,
0.9363256692886353,
-0.08918920904397964,
-0.03609516844153404,
0.4129553735256195,
-0.13261261582374573,
0.43060967326164246,
-0.06040222570300102,
-0.0004553126636892557,
0.48730799555778503,
-0.2839362621307373,
-0.3958660960197449,
-0.5365237593650818,
0.7175165414810181,
-1.1916836500167847,
-0.8040065169334412,
-0.5409618616104126,
-0.545840859413147,
0.106759212911129,
-0.09363307803869247,
0.3027409315109253,
0.27032899856567383,
-0.42770934104919434,
0.09985243529081345,
0.4393608868122101,
0.11729439347982407,
0.41583943367004395,
0.061207644641399384,
0.16792146861553192,
-0.015869999304413795,
1.101155161857605,
0.2601251006126404,
-0.10366256535053253,
-0.0837942436337471,
0.14673282206058502,
-0.27772289514541626,
-0.560846209526062,
-0.0496513694524765,
0.2545761168003082,
-0.4258427321910858,
0.09018395841121674,
-0.41805213689804077,
-0.33496060967445374,
-0.5487502813339233,
-0.12604071199893951,
-0.33511751890182495,
-0.2435520738363266,
-0.47013670206069946,
0.1741078644990921,
0.16878674924373627,
1.0683724880218506,
-0.20490215718746185,
0.23460033535957336,
-0.4669150710105896,
0.3851763904094696,
0.33449169993400574,
0.2057371437549591,
0.0910540372133255,
-0.4568316340446472,
-0.276581346988678,
0.4107629954814911,
-0.388481467962265,
-0.4171229600906372,
0.31109222769737244,
0.47976112365722656,
0.8290581107139587,
0.6821258664131165,
-0.048257097601890564,
0.6209959983825684,
-0.5635942816734314,
0.8855467438697815,
-0.05800829082727432,
-0.8472589254379272,
0.5558151602745056,
-0.20818088948726654,
0.056559447199106216,
0.37640896439552307,
0.7025407552719116,
-0.037040263414382935,
-0.6030359268188477,
-0.9149000644683838,
-0.9183335900306702,
0.4677964150905609,
0.10756368935108185,
0.07210160791873932,
-0.012856650166213512,
0.5077611804008484,
0.10890070348978043,
0.32667404413223267,
-0.6336334347724915,
-0.24801917374134064,
-0.253913551568985,
-0.09217758476734161,
-0.3208904266357422,
-0.3639131784439087,
-0.3004016876220703,
-0.3122754693031311,
0.48828747868537903,
-0.25768882036209106,
0.3604820966720581,
0.2886523902416229,
0.07950566709041595,
-0.33764195442199707,
0.20274455845355988,
0.4746151566505432,
0.8430584669113159,
0.010107564739882946,
0.07307462394237518,
-0.2026483565568924,
-0.45349428057670593,
0.17871084809303284,
0.07533667236566544,
-0.39467936754226685,
-0.18790224194526672,
0.6448373198509216,
0.6194588541984558,
-0.18931953608989716,
-0.5297583341598511,
0.33084535598754883,
-0.0056590489111840725,
-0.10198516398668289,
-0.6529982686042786,
0.4149048924446106,
-0.3849104642868042,
0.4508359730243683,
0.5585293769836426,
0.35320013761520386,
0.19412004947662354,
-1.0518404245376587,
0.06200625002384186,
0.6521025896072388,
-0.24830123782157898,
-0.7748584151268005,
0.8726668357849121,
0.11027412861585617,
-0.5075773596763611,
0.7459694147109985,
-0.09250757843255997,
-0.3442251682281494,
0.5861387848854065,
0.2392393946647644,
0.7483260035514832,
-0.18883287906646729,
0.12970703840255737,
0.06321167200803757,
0.24159303307533264,
-0.15739691257476807,
-0.05554432421922684,
0.06853340566158295,
-0.7332696318626404,
-0.7278351783752441,
-0.44354748725891113,
-0.35622069239616394,
0.3718717098236084,
-0.5059608817100525,
-0.22092583775520325,
-0.25117748975753784,
-0.15088094770908356,
0.13791561126708984,
-0.18642441928386688,
-0.6430997252464294,
0.017615322023630142,
0.2513892352581024,
0.5093420743942261,
-1.0558432340621948,
0.6684703230857849,
0.7210306525230408,
-0.3437238931655884,
-0.6166383624076843,
0.2386922836303711,
-0.05803871154785156,
-0.6568117737770081,
0.5621018409729004,
0.22822120785713196,
-0.14204232394695282,
-0.19307658076286316,
-1.0723614692687988,
-0.8766987919807434,
0.9498386383056641,
0.3312399387359619,
-0.24542494118213654,
-0.35911881923675537,
0.17072957754135132,
0.6363470554351807,
-0.5462226867675781,
0.4121220111846924,
0.6749427914619446,
0.572461724281311,
0.1834992617368698,
-0.5858603715896606,
-0.06120056286454201,
-0.36737650632858276,
-0.013860714621841908,
-0.1491619199514389,
-0.7630470991134644,
0.8876646161079407,
-0.40091899037361145,
-0.4136078953742981,
0.18251530826091766,
0.724402666091919,
-0.03819656744599342,
0.565913736820221,
0.24430310726165771,
0.36166560649871826,
0.8923330903053284,
-0.12085840851068497,
1.1702245473861694,
-0.3497008681297302,
0.0928732305765152,
0.8791226148605347,
-0.3521328568458557,
0.4734763503074646,
0.4503495991230011,
-0.19715620577335358,
0.5444257855415344,
0.43064597249031067,
-0.34421902894973755,
0.5201791524887085,
0.0880134254693985,
0.05033751577138901,
-0.30451446771621704,
-0.40010878443717957,
-0.24983759224414825,
0.8586299419403076,
0.46641671657562256,
-0.26403507590293884,
-0.02338126115500927,
-0.3002001941204071,
-0.3012109100818634,
0.4497716724872589,
-0.1774398684501648,
0.6707606911659241,
-0.02281750924885273,
-0.7374441027641296,
0.38250577449798584,
-0.3340955972671509,
0.6114522218704224,
-0.32958877086639404,
-0.2474673092365265,
-0.1043659895658493,
0.06859450042247772,
0.0013352244859561324,
-0.5812917351722717,
0.5900500416755676,
-0.08219040185213089,
-0.40483614802360535,
0.10118089616298676,
0.7661473751068115,
-0.05308660864830017,
-0.3895840346813202,
0.35695570707321167,
0.870074987411499,
0.24714918434619904,
0.06468556821346283,
-0.4684285521507263,
-0.2006710022687912,
-0.1357872039079666,
-0.15563981235027313,
0.2478155642747879,
0.5524020195007324,
-0.010577816516160965,
0.7948235273361206,
0.7744839191436768,
0.2613162398338318,
-0.33184364438056946,
-0.1406080573797226,
0.8999218940734863,
-0.866256833076477,
-0.25274109840393066,
-1.133878231048584,
0.2760942280292511,
-0.12268853932619095,
-0.2212386131286621,
0.5055369138717651,
0.28553539514541626,
0.5996322631835938,
0.19030573964118958,
0.81172114610672,
0.11335939913988113,
0.21518868207931519,
-0.2625582218170166,
0.7239136695861816,
-0.45715707540512085,
0.15050296485424042,
-0.03805921971797943,
-0.6332665085792542,
-0.11042554676532745,
0.5807976126670837,
-0.41997382044792175,
0.20458726584911346,
0.3237243592739105,
0.30102667212486267,
0.1649785339832306,
0.030355580151081085,
0.4067354202270508,
0.532239556312561,
0.2982194125652313,
0.31612780690193176,
1.13661527633667,
0.05719568952918053,
0.220096617937088,
0.2220238596200943,
-0.3936218321323395,
-0.09382572025060654,
-0.5459091067314148,
-0.8236572742462158,
-0.42475828528404236,
-0.31756702065467834,
-0.012785670347511768,
0.11113457381725311,
0.48344728350639343,
0.49747487902641296,
-0.6864796280860901,
-0.11917933076620102,
-0.26127901673316956,
0.11031415313482285,
-0.16090460121631622,
-0.24438105523586273,
0.2593439221382141,
-0.22343216836452484,
-0.6208063364028931,
0.44361791014671326,
0.22526943683624268,
0.1601259559392929,
-0.46769437193870544,
-0.028687428683042526,
-0.20784586668014526,
0.24109333753585815,
0.39001989364624023,
0.48974794149398804,
-0.8973715305328369,
-0.46941104531288147,
-0.09285082668066025,
0.09457619488239288,
0.18474392592906952,
0.6189731359481812,
-0.9724327921867371,
-0.02206030860543251,
0.09016751497983932,
0.5241976976394653,
-0.15878501534461975,
0.007308975327759981,
0.6429799199104309,
-0.6194695830345154,
0.2542364299297333,
0.3961513638496399,
0.38616377115249634,
0.3162333369255066,
-0.5688066482543945,
0.7706795930862427,
0.3967122733592987,
-0.837795078754425,
-0.8470896482467651,
0.23517316579818726,
-0.4206487536430359,
-0.4071909785270691,
0.8688865900039673,
-0.1802436113357544,
-0.704573392868042,
0.023540886119008064,
0.23251381516456604,
0.32031479477882385,
-0.4551340937614441,
1.3244407176971436,
0.6674203276634216,
-0.42514145374298096,
0.20196372270584106,
-0.5805270671844482,
0.38080883026123047,
0.40977853536605835,
-0.48854637145996094,
0.06544268131256104,
0.389585018157959,
-0.12895892560482025,
0.7762712836265564,
0.3819947838783264,
0.1325865238904953,
0.0021801055409014225,
0.17540453374385834,
-0.14771254360675812,
-0.08843645453453064,
-0.5718461275100708,
-0.28481873869895935,
0.0278784092515707,
0.19833791255950928,
0.017655275762081146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03957v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03957v1 | Sparse Graph Representations for Procedural Instructional Documents | 2024-02-06T12:34:15 | 2024-02-06T12:34:15 | Shruti Singh, Rishabh Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Computation of document similarity is a critical task in various NLP domains
that has applications in deduplication, matching, and recommendation.
Traditional approaches for document similarity computation include learning
representations of documents and employing a similarity or a distance function
over the embeddings. However, pairwise similarities and differences are not
efficiently captured by individual representations. Graph representations such
as Joint Concept Interaction Graph (JCIG) represent a pair of documents as a
joint undirected weighted graph. JCIGs facilitate an interpretable
representation of document pairs as a graph. However, JCIGs are undirected, and
don't consider the sequential flow of sentences in documents. We propose two
approaches to model document similarity by representing document pairs as a
directed and sparse JCIG that incorporates sequential information. We propose
two algorithms inspired by Supergenome Sorting and Hamiltonian Path that
replace the undirected edges with directed edges. Our approach also sparsifies
the graph to $O(n)$ edges from JCIG's worst case of $O(n^2)$. We show that our
sparse directed graph model architecture consisting of a Siamese encoder and
GCN achieves comparable results to the baseline on datasets not containing
sequential information and beats the baseline by ten points on an instructional
documents dataset containing sequential information. | [
-0.08905872702598572,
-0.698258638381958,
0.8213297128677368,
-0.17518119513988495,
-0.13086122274398804,
0.3521959185600281,
-0.0791347548365593,
-0.22773444652557373,
0.461584210395813,
0.4585532546043396,
-0.7269285321235657,
-0.7820649147033691,
-0.6066199541091919,
0.1390896588563919,
-0.5363937616348267,
0.818210244178772,
-0.050124168395996094,
0.24296236038208008,
-0.5928020477294922,
-0.2536155879497528,
-0.1211022362112999,
-0.19994139671325684,
-0.6665993332862854,
-0.5902371406555176,
0.47241637110710144,
-0.026297299191355705,
0.6729542016983032,
0.7603799700737,
0.2803266942501068,
0.5356845855712891,
-0.0890599712729454,
0.33074137568473816,
-0.637520432472229,
0.17372198402881622,
0.06617827713489532,
-0.34735387563705444,
-0.14607134461402893,
-0.026084866374731064,
0.8776663541793823,
1.2724570035934448,
0.08629430830478668,
-0.2381192147731781,
0.3833504319190979,
0.6590254902839661,
-0.08041076362133026,
0.3909941613674164,
-0.3474026620388031,
0.029338529333472252,
-0.08881056308746338,
-0.3088148236274719,
-0.36378392577171326,
-0.42569291591644287,
0.05249587818980217,
-1.0735150575637817,
0.5247319340705872,
0.08135209232568741,
0.7320488095283508,
-0.05261971801519394,
-0.1914094239473343,
-0.6918365955352783,
-0.40841034054756165,
0.38084062933921814,
-0.23671501874923706,
0.3644869029521942,
0.21459096670150757,
-0.21694537997245789,
-0.5049228668212891,
-0.6826496124267578,
-0.6940634250640869,
-0.29492148756980896,
-0.27341774106025696,
0.26111695170402527,
-0.049535274505615234,
0.26930809020996094,
0.3688899278640747,
0.16658304631710052,
-1.0474711656570435,
0.1742813140153885,
-0.26339536905288696,
0.10226542502641678,
0.39414170384407043,
0.299617737531662,
0.21008729934692383,
-0.4098515808582306,
-0.4032081663608551,
-0.4400896728038788,
-0.43177470564842224,
-0.3027004599571228,
0.7380415201187134,
0.24416348338127136,
0.11283929646015167,
0.3910506069660187,
-0.05081961303949356,
0.707271158695221,
0.14502844214439392,
-0.1961774080991745,
0.391398161649704,
-0.20118211209774017,
-0.1882946938276291,
0.08775915950536728,
0.7770863771438599,
0.3421809673309326,
0.19747494161128998,
-0.3337818682193756,
0.047104496508836746,
-0.0845661386847496,
0.2106183022260666,
-0.5174058675765991,
-0.24366502463817596,
-0.21373102068901062,
-0.5534917116165161,
-0.025003114715218544,
0.1382436454296112,
-0.6931468844413757,
-0.5182917714118958,
-0.6269140839576721,
0.25429418683052063,
-0.7056757211685181,
0.1688501089811325,
-0.24635085463523865,
-0.18024896085262299,
-0.0870596170425415,
0.47589874267578125,
-0.9901264309883118,
0.6930315494537354,
0.9767283797264099,
1.2091811895370483,
-0.06459188461303711,
-0.2215343415737152,
-0.12013530731201172,
0.2340899258852005,
-0.3420116901397705,
0.5596253275871277,
-0.804759681224823,
-0.7261664867401123,
-0.04266098141670227,
0.12668487429618835,
-0.44098082184791565,
-0.4336828887462616,
0.20501448214054108,
-0.4753462076187134,
0.08347443491220474,
-0.2109176516532898,
-0.9431003332138062,
-0.2282976508140564,
0.0790775790810585,
-0.6405014395713806,
0.8694143891334534,
0.390830397605896,
-0.9653934240341187,
0.14211860299110413,
-0.1595752239227295,
-0.3070179522037506,
0.323574960231781,
-0.421165406703949,
-0.2954316735267639,
-0.2314395010471344,
-0.22746077179908752,
0.3808076083660126,
-0.03234062343835831,
0.10578037798404694,
-0.3161753714084625,
-0.7326050996780396,
-0.11915859580039978,
-0.21338695287704468,
0.8060794472694397,
0.1098531186580658,
0.20949316024780273,
0.19123198091983795,
-0.8093684911727905,
-0.09830918908119202,
0.1622481495141983,
-0.03137669712305069,
-1.0514527559280396,
-0.12051501125097275,
-0.20852583646774292,
-0.1442047506570816,
0.2778109312057495,
-0.45469024777412415,
0.6144546866416931,
-0.42151644825935364,
0.3361192047595978,
0.8679684400558472,
0.12349023669958115,
0.6039285659790039,
-0.3976607620716095,
0.2549607753753662,
-0.16370391845703125,
-0.22674088180065155,
-0.15495339035987854,
-0.5101774334907532,
-0.668756902217865,
0.01812690496444702,
0.4503897428512573,
0.34853702783584595,
-0.9332513213157654,
0.2979365885257721,
-0.6350716948509216,
-0.2923005521297455,
-0.3819770812988281,
0.2578088343143463,
0.48677146434783936,
0.6192267537117004,
0.23668272793293,
-0.7730647921562195,
-0.3289729654788971,
-0.48030465841293335,
0.29891785979270935,
-0.19868020713329315,
-0.10597821325063705,
0.25977420806884766,
0.27602288126945496,
-0.08918184041976929,
0.353147953748703,
-0.5926144123077393,
-0.16594666242599487,
-0.022628340870141983,
0.6365810632705688,
0.26297813653945923,
0.6379032135009766,
0.4842972159385681,
-0.6360694766044617,
-0.6753002405166626,
-0.054982949048280716,
-0.776146650314331,
0.0653197392821312,
-0.4537927508354187,
-0.16574408113956451,
0.07006415724754333,
0.7171390652656555,
-0.651463508605957,
0.32248201966285706,
0.22388526797294617,
0.10552526265382767,
0.02276972495019436,
-0.5198818445205688,
0.2922047972679138,
-0.9041225910186768,
-0.05273309722542763,
0.008894835598766804,
-0.11755267530679703,
-0.608038604259491,
0.21498934924602509,
-0.11027313023805618,
-0.2561211884021759,
0.16061873733997345,
0.24564436078071594,
-0.3354686498641968,
-0.2811394929885864,
-0.02471388503909111,
0.3454238176345825,
0.051384903490543365,
0.832233726978302,
0.16386061906814575,
0.5753620266914368,
0.45408356189727783,
-0.1703033596277237,
0.17950136959552765,
0.34158268570899963,
-0.1237051859498024,
0.714537501335144,
-0.5601112842559814,
0.38347575068473816,
-0.3491567373275757,
0.3478418290615082,
-0.9675612449645996,
0.032004524022340775,
0.48947420716285706,
-0.34912073612213135,
0.7500566840171814,
-0.36667415499687195,
-0.5662477016448975,
-0.3699340522289276,
-0.5865169763565063,
0.15842919051647186,
0.34870126843452454,
-0.38471564650535583,
0.3691183030605316,
0.06592922657728195,
-0.3353002965450287,
-0.36603114008903503,
-0.34596434235572815,
-0.25398188829421997,
0.066538505256176,
-0.47201454639434814,
0.5922951102256775,
0.04423900693655014,
0.12081917375326157,
0.3775365948677063,
-0.2333495318889618,
-0.230657696723938,
-0.24098998308181763,
0.8097070455551147,
0.34982210397720337,
-0.08905103802680969,
0.20972643792629242,
0.11806240677833557,
-0.1777486950159073,
-0.08536937087774277,
-0.5229253768920898,
0.5242447853088379,
0.3256331980228424,
-0.46414968371391296,
-0.15879663825035095,
0.6796604990959167,
0.25406530499458313,
0.2905937731266022,
0.7850565314292908,
0.7003741264343262,
-0.4553510546684265,
0.000028069036488886923,
-0.1309128850698471,
0.2544965147972107,
-0.47522249817848206,
0.23324154317378998,
-0.41471099853515625,
-0.8477374911308289,
0.42879122495651245,
-0.2589288651943207,
-0.1215445026755333,
0.3596753776073456,
0.23391936719417572,
-0.17056326568126678,
0.7476868033409119,
0.5034517645835876,
0.08821935951709747,
0.5941298007965088,
-0.7582587599754333,
0.15982098877429962,
-0.8111169338226318,
-0.5667468905448914,
-0.5987769365310669,
-0.16719672083854675,
-0.745602011680603,
-0.4968545436859131,
0.3816587030887604,
0.29772916436195374,
-0.11163582652807236,
0.6103896498680115,
-0.5900599360466003,
0.41064175963401794,
0.8231881856918335,
0.2053234577178955,
0.25692787766456604,
0.17320312559604645,
-0.6323127150535583,
-0.07866578549146652,
-0.9219485521316528,
-0.38582858443260193,
0.9100419282913208,
-0.15554314851760864,
0.6841325759887695,
-0.20175614953041077,
1.1110777854919434,
0.2655089795589447,
0.0035231770016252995,
-0.5593624711036682,
0.7551938891410828,
-0.5521847009658813,
0.3123255968093872,
-0.43793490529060364,
-0.6891345381736755,
-1.2193001508712769,
0.08245232701301575,
-0.35281428694725037,
-0.8280918598175049,
0.18511635065078735,
-0.15086662769317627,
-0.14661160111427307,
0.19046996533870697,
-0.7127517461776733,
0.7695396542549133,
0.3673558235168457,
-0.43237194418907166,
-0.45358893275260925,
-0.5187944173812866,
0.05843568965792656,
0.06939239799976349,
-0.01608632132411003,
0.29549333453178406,
0.3183753490447998,
0.8562353849411011,
-0.824654757976532,
0.5654274225234985,
-0.0938219204545021,
0.23346205055713654,
0.5621928572654724,
0.22674180567264557,
0.43408268690109253,
-0.18711042404174805,
-0.12045897543430328,
0.16749484837055206,
-0.06313564628362656,
-0.16557779908180237,
-0.9628625512123108,
1.257798194885254,
-0.7749769687652588,
-0.5576788783073425,
-0.5016283392906189,
-0.47941601276397705,
0.05006217956542969,
0.29791149497032166,
-0.0007250619819387794,
0.7850071787834167,
0.018249832093715668,
-0.18601424992084503,
0.48431330919265747,
-0.016404110938310623,
0.20442970097064972,
0.298448771238327,
0.3678832948207855,
-0.07400718331336975,
1.1251708269119263,
0.548011064529419,
0.07912897318601608,
0.5594022274017334,
-0.1769954413175583,
-0.48558780550956726,
-0.5681235790252686,
-0.37572404742240906,
0.2413041740655899,
-0.9136841893196106,
-0.1704907864332199,
-0.7161754965782166,
-0.49713489413261414,
-0.5087932348251343,
-0.4367361068725586,
0.13800963759422302,
-0.566131055355072,
-0.41200003027915955,
0.039025597274303436,
0.3307448923587799,
1.1123974323272705,
-0.12803392112255096,
0.08406741917133331,
-0.5648238062858582,
0.32609060406684875,
0.40301182866096497,
0.48304471373558044,
0.4681832790374756,
-0.2444806843996048,
-0.14076443016529083,
-0.17070654034614563,
-0.4281989634037018,
-0.7274092435836792,
0.1548437923192978,
0.03930159658193588,
0.43021827936172485,
0.32475554943084717,
-0.021183546632528305,
0.9587970972061157,
-0.7107176780700684,
0.49208366870880127,
0.2479013055562973,
-0.6774384379386902,
0.2894265949726105,
-0.21228663623332977,
0.027040060609579086,
0.5646572113037109,
1.0005037784576416,
-0.4124533534049988,
-0.41530850529670715,
-0.7614611387252808,
-0.7378731369972229,
0.6901925206184387,
0.19574297964572906,
0.0721188485622406,
-0.25809282064437866,
0.38251030445098877,
0.07386127859354019,
-0.05685138702392578,
-0.26843294501304626,
-0.1915663778781891,
-0.2601529657840729,
-0.5689845681190491,
0.16768649220466614,
-0.018877999857068062,
0.00036617033765651286,
0.09667237848043442,
0.398431658744812,
-0.026830723509192467,
0.47486412525177,
0.27326762676239014,
0.01160113513469696,
-0.16024094820022583,
0.036721665412187576,
0.14679713547229767,
0.2483062744140625,
-0.335420697927475,
0.2255474478006363,
0.02755984477698803,
-0.6026820540428162,
0.1828823834657669,
0.43626669049263,
-0.45411667227745056,
0.12338589876890182,
0.7563126683235168,
0.45093607902526855,
0.3562154173851013,
-0.4396916627883911,
0.5688336491584778,
0.12149269133806229,
-0.18104727566242218,
0.06893806904554367,
0.13421884179115295,
0.0939793735742569,
0.09207150340080261,
-0.06577692925930023,
0.09512099623680115,
0.4499828517436981,
-0.5613601803779602,
0.09144113957881927,
0.39705371856689453,
-0.300887793302536,
-0.02669587731361389,
0.4306822419166565,
0.1753421276807785,
-0.43928948044776917,
0.8470937609672546,
-0.577041506767273,
-0.35560178756713867,
0.632277250289917,
0.5201557278633118,
0.5096085667610168,
0.18168847262859344,
0.4383062720298767,
0.6298914551734924,
-0.20113685727119446,
-0.04294755309820175,
-0.13115450739860535,
-0.4216100573539734,
-0.33264216780662537,
-0.08520236611366272,
-0.5025843381881714,
-0.5149673223495483,
-0.11372365057468414,
-0.6355999112129211,
0.0006485451594926417,
-0.7729764580726624,
0.1781156063079834,
0.3106859028339386,
0.33156394958496094,
-0.6947035789489746,
-0.132737934589386,
0.07005073875188828,
0.4846181869506836,
-0.7068188190460205,
0.8673194050788879,
0.4065190255641937,
-0.4511590301990509,
-0.8104246854782104,
-0.15078037977218628,
0.004482246935367584,
-0.8247562646865845,
0.5154699087142944,
0.24487340450286865,
-0.1174180656671524,
-0.09657789766788483,
-0.17175227403640747,
-0.5015385150909424,
1.257802128791809,
0.07356765121221542,
-0.8809890151023865,
-0.20977915823459625,
0.0853591337800026,
0.6646921038627625,
-0.27706730365753174,
0.33574435114860535,
0.1070035845041275,
0.0658155232667923,
0.3460899293422699,
-0.4376736581325531,
0.2663049101829529,
-0.2513153851032257,
0.23670943081378937,
0.2706003487110138,
-0.607447624206543,
0.7594074010848999,
-0.07938549667596817,
-0.529964029788971,
0.32440686225891113,
0.37164515256881714,
0.04625975713133812,
0.4486057162284851,
0.4693271815776825,
0.7692613005638123,
0.9072116017341614,
-0.053014229983091354,
0.9710478782653809,
-0.2513057589530945,
0.32656100392341614,
1.3006432056427002,
-0.37356433272361755,
0.4393329322338104,
0.03540031984448433,
-0.3256213366985321,
0.8504675030708313,
0.45016470551490784,
-0.21133680641651154,
0.37263888120651245,
0.29817521572113037,
-0.036524828523397446,
0.016218338161706924,
-0.3340827226638794,
-0.33593347668647766,
0.0780867263674736,
0.3117522597312927,
-0.40744125843048096,
-0.2991396188735962,
-0.3727673888206482,
-0.13395380973815918,
0.5439051389694214,
-0.37835046648979187,
0.8073133826255798,
-0.030543699860572815,
-0.5010203123092651,
0.49675846099853516,
0.07990612834692001,
0.3234686255455017,
-0.7098107933998108,
-0.47879868745803833,
-0.1562073528766632,
-0.2997263967990875,
-0.1301877647638321,
-0.93707275390625,
0.2882732152938843,
-0.15050700306892395,
-0.16689488291740417,
-0.3824356496334076,
0.7772263884544373,
-0.6504061222076416,
-0.4722135365009308,
0.3692651391029358,
0.17007529735565186,
0.15601857006549835,
0.5986725687980652,
-0.8039422035217285,
0.04408258572220802,
-0.2864701747894287,
0.15913765132427216,
0.45133376121520996,
0.6336275339126587,
-0.16224993765354156,
0.5124492645263672,
0.4905291497707367,
0.008038967847824097,
-0.09171538054943085,
0.5691602826118469,
1.0386967658996582,
-0.4022131562232971,
-0.47198694944381714,
-0.5263557434082031,
-0.12808780372142792,
-0.1944633424282074,
-0.080045685172081,
0.7161628603935242,
0.44371190667152405,
0.9486010074615479,
0.06788007915019989,
0.3133707344532013,
0.11789488047361374,
0.36810940504074097,
-0.8215227723121643,
0.4366719722747803,
-0.29071587324142456,
0.027733206748962402,
-0.6576693058013916,
-0.9216198921203613,
-0.2372058928012848,
0.6887661218643188,
-0.13034436106681824,
-0.011039236560463905,
0.7268136143684387,
0.9770205020904541,
-0.07914041727781296,
0.044078413397073746,
0.16295896470546722,
0.11543145030736923,
-0.20965179800987244,
0.8067451119422913,
0.4755033850669861,
-0.30548930168151855,
0.41719886660575867,
-0.17526565492153168,
-0.12810420989990234,
0.007155687548220158,
-0.5020176768302917,
-1.114363193511963,
-0.8792895674705505,
-0.41129088401794434,
-0.33138900995254517,
0.28285130858421326,
0.9993455410003662,
0.7765308618545532,
-0.5600084066390991,
0.10671200603246689,
-0.374059796333313,
0.5960425734519958,
-0.16819076240062714,
-0.23768964409828186,
0.7075945138931274,
-0.022963184863328934,
-0.598690927028656,
0.1987604796886444,
0.44523006677627563,
0.3128160536289215,
-0.21013040840625763,
-0.19441694021224976,
-0.2043207585811615,
0.00001991313365579117,
0.20840394496917725,
0.18940146267414093,
-0.46195411682128906,
-0.3712821900844574,
-0.2853561341762543,
-0.13691069185733795,
0.008685496635735035,
1.0058473348617554,
-0.8162471055984497,
0.6704307198524475,
0.5898615717887878,
0.5979942679405212,
0.5929059982299805,
0.06727318465709686,
0.09155066311359406,
-0.7768582105636597,
0.21665818989276886,
-0.04445222392678261,
0.31285297870635986,
0.4907340407371521,
-0.4506557285785675,
0.594936728477478,
0.5319454669952393,
-0.33345362544059753,
-0.4618164300918579,
0.08586268126964569,
-1.2632650136947632,
-0.24828286468982697,
0.6958107352256775,
-0.7055413722991943,
-0.19725733995437622,
-0.12998665869235992,
-0.0068352920934557915,
0.3622313439846039,
-0.3900187909603119,
0.5511561036109924,
0.5067722201347351,
-0.03805418685078621,
0.021310511976480484,
-0.055349674075841904,
0.13174602389335632,
-0.1215246170759201,
-0.3021923005580902,
-0.1964268535375595,
0.3270300626754761,
0.07731006294488907,
0.4228091239929199,
0.8485487699508667,
0.038131050765514374,
-0.017658092081546783,
0.5315024256706238,
-0.3348422050476074,
-0.21462522447109222,
-0.43937546014785767,
-0.27411088347435,
0.2254880964756012,
-0.20043715834617615,
-0.05613481253385544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03927v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03927v2 | Leak, Cheat, Repeat: Data Contamination and Evaluation Malpractices in Closed-Source LLMs | 2024-02-06T11:54:23 | 2024-02-22T12:32:24 | Simone Balloccu, Patrícia Schmidtová, Mateusz Lango, Ondřej Dušek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural Language Processing (NLP) research is increasingly focusing on the
use of Large Language Models (LLMs), with some of the most popular ones being
either fully or partially closed-source. The lack of access to model details,
especially regarding training data, has repeatedly raised concerns about data
contamination among researchers. Several attempts have been made to address
this issue, but they are limited to anecdotal evidence and trial and error.
Additionally, they overlook the problem of \emph{indirect} data leaking, where
models are iteratively improved by using data coming from users. In this work,
we conduct the first systematic analysis of work using OpenAI's GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, the most prominently used LLMs today, in the context of data
contamination. By analysing 255 papers and considering OpenAI's data usage
policy, we extensively document the amount of data leaked to these models
during the first year after the model's release. We report that these models
have been globally exposed to $\sim$4.7M samples from 263 benchmarks. At the
same time, we document a number of evaluation malpractices emerging in the
reviewed papers, such as unfair or missing baseline comparisons and
reproducibility issues. We release our results as a collaborative project on
https://leak-llm.github.io/, where other researchers can contribute to our
efforts. | [
-0.15414544939994812,
-0.6303725242614746,
0.7127538919448853,
0.07915610074996948,
-0.24504441022872925,
-0.22969353199005127,
-0.0003522827464621514,
-0.721440851688385,
-0.25884294509887695,
1.1342957019805908,
-0.32182711362838745,
-0.4651373624801636,
-0.7377068996429443,
-0.03517940640449524,
-0.5614007115364075,
1.1671918630599976,
-0.5052769184112549,
0.12144806981086731,
-0.3159373998641968,
-0.11922838538885117,
-0.3924075663089752,
-0.7212257981300354,
-0.37201476097106934,
-0.3683661222457886,
0.5056576132774353,
0.32643482089042664,
0.606231689453125,
0.6705740690231323,
0.630301296710968,
0.15795756876468658,
-0.11023113876581192,
-0.04613861069083214,
-0.4549849331378937,
0.14411327242851257,
-0.3360915780067444,
-0.526856005191803,
-0.26054203510284424,
0.21642017364501953,
0.47323259711265564,
0.5202720165252686,
-0.2581512928009033,
0.1436309814453125,
0.1952873319387436,
0.8474510312080383,
-0.8078517317771912,
0.075216144323349,
-0.6550672054290771,
0.03447847440838814,
-0.5348029136657715,
-0.17358028888702393,
-0.5153555274009705,
-0.4578340947628021,
0.06496153026819229,
-0.5889037847518921,
0.1660970002412796,
-0.28917616605758667,
0.885335385799408,
0.3466545343399048,
-0.024387124925851822,
-0.46658316254615784,
-0.9774848222732544,
0.790217936038971,
-0.7703576683998108,
0.1392512023448944,
0.4805210530757904,
0.27612176537513733,
-0.13168396055698395,
-0.9646515250205994,
-0.3541024923324585,
-0.29888084530830383,
0.10672512650489807,
-0.005329471081495285,
-0.33862829208374023,
-0.1357630491256714,
0.32310083508491516,
0.44092270731925964,
-0.39574071764945984,
0.1613793820142746,
-0.42564088106155396,
-0.1375652700662613,
0.7171254754066467,
0.13682246208190918,
0.49384456872940063,
-0.03733863681554794,
-0.6350749731063843,
-0.09385866671800613,
-1.1769378185272217,
-0.4029545485973358,
0.6860213279724121,
0.08558326959609985,
0.051659829914569855,
0.6745985746383667,
-0.08438146859407425,
0.5692164897918701,
-0.6076472997665405,
0.10591618716716766,
0.2620307207107544,
-0.8061210513114929,
-0.4263129234313965,
-0.20007255673408508,
0.9455326199531555,
0.025797471404075623,
0.41468292474746704,
-0.399192750453949,
-0.12113215029239655,
-0.21079599857330322,
0.4542654752731323,
-0.5343773365020752,
-0.17526176571846008,
0.3212975859642029,
-0.08106502890586853,
-0.48631277680397034,
0.19354446232318878,
-0.8264779448509216,
-0.4846394956111908,
-0.33160802721977234,
0.46166738867759705,
-0.18119002878665924,
-0.18759627640247345,
0.2800118923187256,
-0.062072038650512695,
-0.09091372042894363,
0.18712298572063446,
-0.46165433526039124,
0.35555753111839294,
0.9056265950202942,
0.8284247517585754,
-0.3176713287830353,
-0.4021923243999481,
-0.3331914246082306,
0.1274702399969101,
-0.1624130755662918,
0.6066014170646667,
-0.37854161858558655,
-0.3721526265144348,
0.15175770223140717,
-0.25418925285339355,
0.08059308677911758,
-0.7363868951797485,
0.9146113395690918,
-0.36006996035575867,
0.4234870970249176,
-0.339225709438324,
-0.4624866247177124,
-0.006288672331720591,
0.15005037188529968,
-0.8479533791542053,
0.8517674207687378,
-0.11242154985666275,
-1.0860828161239624,
0.34918874502182007,
-0.6124317049980164,
0.021261446177959442,
-0.021299835294485092,
-0.3143223822116852,
-0.5656808018684387,
-0.07881156355142593,
0.34433311223983765,
0.308341920375824,
-0.18273591995239258,
0.5312411785125732,
-0.28320279717445374,
-0.532018780708313,
0.3213846981525421,
-0.7112470269203186,
1.0089446306228638,
0.13587205111980438,
-0.2758481800556183,
0.03711681813001633,
-0.4072185754776001,
-0.22353173792362213,
0.19097211956977844,
-0.2039836347103119,
-0.4202904999256134,
-0.21310339868068695,
-0.15855802595615387,
0.21923448145389557,
-0.06646701693534851,
-0.6514658331871033,
0.22147081792354584,
-0.20249120891094208,
0.20628806948661804,
0.8379198908805847,
0.33831003308296204,
0.16417400538921356,
-0.6942353844642639,
0.48071497678756714,
0.17893749475479126,
0.3412743806838989,
-0.27325791120529175,
-0.5905436277389526,
-0.4438583552837372,
-0.1050931066274643,
0.4210713803768158,
0.37284034490585327,
-0.6658867597579956,
0.0867779478430748,
-0.4835958182811737,
-0.6667700409889221,
-0.5977106690406799,
0.17314977943897247,
0.3276406526565552,
0.5366085767745972,
0.2788463234901428,
-0.15975698828697205,
-0.20038606226444244,
-1.0256363153457642,
-0.5942384004592896,
0.08013009279966354,
-0.20560109615325928,
0.5509003400802612,
0.5846140384674072,
-0.3094155788421631,
0.9140682220458984,
-0.3729688823223114,
-0.5748181343078613,
0.04156102240085602,
0.25029557943344116,
0.1337517946958542,
0.4594153165817261,
0.2446635365486145,
-0.39595890045166016,
-0.2761615514755249,
-0.3825241029262543,
-0.8995054960250854,
-0.18242034316062927,
-0.14048972725868225,
-0.280245840549469,
0.22273150086402893,
0.47307491302490234,
-0.406100332736969,
0.4122561514377594,
0.7392063736915588,
-0.16979892551898956,
0.7649410963058472,
-0.13455331325531006,
-0.07962106168270111,
-0.8657146096229553,
0.356088787317276,
-0.04411448910832405,
-0.14758801460266113,
-0.6177897453308105,
0.2657741606235504,
0.02865823172032833,
0.06170674413442612,
-0.5846357345581055,
0.46504536271095276,
-0.5274094939231873,
0.027025071904063225,
-0.16398273408412933,
0.3011881411075592,
-0.04202782362699509,
0.18696141242980957,
-0.22934141755104065,
0.8636879324913025,
0.34925228357315063,
-0.404742032289505,
0.1304474174976349,
0.2585298717021942,
-0.47839611768722534,
-0.037751100957393646,
-0.6784543395042419,
0.5630101561546326,
0.17010852694511414,
0.3113464117050171,
-0.5195502638816833,
-0.185145765542984,
0.4692375063896179,
-0.2756918966770172,
0.3049198389053345,
-0.4404905140399933,
-0.8941799402236938,
0.1298237442970276,
-0.5523964762687683,
0.28269636631011963,
0.2828029692173004,
-0.7041898369789124,
0.13098011910915375,
0.5128812193870544,
-0.2201612889766693,
-0.9690111875534058,
-0.9438924193382263,
0.19221678376197815,
-0.12355601042509079,
-0.8268279433250427,
0.1742076277732849,
0.11930589377880096,
-0.4471881091594696,
0.20273730158805847,
-0.1689380556344986,
-0.15769588947296143,
0.21455402672290802,
0.2476547211408615,
0.21009713411331177,
-0.05095396935939789,
-0.015518936328589916,
-0.1281774640083313,
0.02668757364153862,
0.30688828229904175,
0.16092832386493683,
0.6068825125694275,
-0.00031080699409358203,
-0.7334223389625549,
-0.33804234862327576,
0.132261261343956,
0.30827778577804565,
-0.16250386834144592,
0.6741759181022644,
0.16061727702617645,
-0.4714692234992981,
-0.2705135941505432,
-0.516796350479126,
0.05898386612534523,
-0.450594425201416,
0.21698971092700958,
-0.0006687694112770259,
-0.6139765977859497,
0.477020263671875,
0.11800651252269745,
0.22898608446121216,
0.3092794120311737,
0.3148295283317566,
-0.01744399033486843,
0.4077852666378021,
0.6530889868736267,
-0.25348955392837524,
0.34911417961120605,
-0.11271621286869049,
0.10133303701877594,
-0.7965932488441467,
-0.22553710639476776,
-0.5346484184265137,
-0.11909134685993195,
-0.6204063296318054,
-0.6479673385620117,
0.2607699930667877,
0.11313722282648087,
-0.02979274094104767,
-0.006536349654197693,
-0.1938208043575287,
0.6415641903877258,
0.4110037088394165,
0.1475839763879776,
0.7273778915405273,
-0.05302635207772255,
-0.12735384702682495,
-0.10060272365808487,
-0.39329925179481506,
-0.6818251609802246,
1.485290288925171,
0.6974189877510071,
0.8555589318275452,
-0.010355065576732159,
0.9800646305084229,
0.14558245241641998,
0.5032075643539429,
-0.5045737624168396,
0.25072968006134033,
-0.06338293105363846,
-0.5746474266052246,
-0.1887817233800888,
-0.6173967123031616,
-0.979048490524292,
0.09594941884279251,
0.2991317808628082,
-0.7969709038734436,
0.21274028718471527,
-0.04427310451865196,
0.11291078478097916,
0.47970014810562134,
-0.4140753746032715,
0.5724332928657532,
-0.16023515164852142,
-0.5016441941261292,
0.18072539567947388,
-0.3816904127597809,
1.0131585597991943,
-0.3879767656326294,
0.12094222754240036,
-0.06023092567920685,
-0.12805497646331787,
0.8775418996810913,
-0.3128880560398102,
0.652816653251648,
-0.16882206499576569,
-0.3158949017524719,
0.0764918103814125,
0.15977151691913605,
0.592218279838562,
0.18541258573532104,
-0.0017847201088443398,
0.6635499000549316,
-0.09464286267757416,
-0.18499690294265747,
-0.3831055760383606,
0.6508309245109558,
-0.5871723294258118,
-0.3676316440105438,
-0.7953700423240662,
-0.3833669126033783,
-0.41488251090049744,
0.2756026089191437,
0.4574072062969208,
0.18387000262737274,
-0.021454714238643646,
0.19276289641857147,
0.7198363542556763,
-0.37283244729042053,
0.3131023347377777,
0.4448905289173126,
-0.39434143900871277,
-0.20706482231616974,
0.7215049862861633,
0.07482597976922989,
0.3980645537376404,
-0.1408599317073822,
0.3226495385169983,
-0.0710548385977745,
-0.9407264590263367,
-0.33247339725494385,
0.5565481781959534,
-0.5863030552864075,
-0.3038359582424164,
-0.4705148935317993,
-0.42371270060539246,
-0.12449148297309875,
0.32396677136421204,
-0.5667141675949097,
-0.11884073168039322,
-0.2569630444049835,
-0.10504774004220963,
0.07427884638309479,
1.0243635177612305,
0.06100476160645485,
0.09958645701408386,
-0.8222944736480713,
0.2566358745098114,
-0.22725790739059448,
0.6549924612045288,
-0.3008953630924225,
-0.5005814433097839,
-0.011998789384961128,
0.1542559713125229,
-0.30308014154434204,
-0.9736961722373962,
0.3711085319519043,
-0.1573684811592102,
0.7416864633560181,
0.20082354545593262,
-0.028092117980122566,
0.3465055525302887,
-0.2117544263601303,
0.8500993847846985,
-0.08390079438686371,
-0.8011687397956848,
0.41735708713531494,
-0.5437090396881104,
0.1258278489112854,
0.7594186663627625,
0.4223199784755707,
-0.7149191498756409,
-0.6086825728416443,
-0.6922934651374817,
-1.0489375591278076,
0.8844848871231079,
0.3730205297470093,
0.07970718294382095,
0.44144678115844727,
0.38513749837875366,
0.236526221036911,
0.28819137811660767,
-0.7783026099205017,
-0.348989874124527,
0.25411859154701233,
0.0016978188650682569,
0.1967998892068863,
-0.4246983230113983,
-0.4498923122882843,
0.11347857117652893,
0.6407585144042969,
0.024025840684771538,
0.2089688777923584,
0.20330573618412018,
-0.3863479793071747,
-0.001874218345619738,
0.26294368505477905,
0.6594278216362,
0.9725322127342224,
-0.11743844300508499,
0.019474228844046593,
-0.189756840467453,
-0.8591105341911316,
-0.12705206871032715,
0.14456602931022644,
-0.38814979791641235,
0.07003659754991531,
0.4189869165420532,
0.3775367736816406,
0.22958868741989136,
-0.6943156123161316,
0.7080126404762268,
-0.18570375442504883,
-0.161407932639122,
-0.5015574097633362,
-0.04678576439619064,
0.1250232607126236,
-0.1600654274225235,
0.16667185723781586,
0.12789614498615265,
0.1449413150548935,
-0.6249726414680481,
0.6305416822433472,
0.14266759157180786,
-0.3488548994064331,
-0.0560515932738781,
0.4093978703022003,
-0.10673319548368454,
0.10508491843938828,
0.762831449508667,
0.10771903395652771,
-0.3663271963596344,
0.2747690677642822,
0.19594109058380127,
0.988810122013092,
-0.09927690774202347,
0.15632976591587067,
0.15284211933612823,
0.496906042098999,
-0.28598856925964355,
0.30881208181381226,
0.3215990364551544,
-0.6607744693756104,
-0.5033763647079468,
-0.4344846308231354,
-0.6728922724723816,
0.6334044337272644,
-0.8647595643997192,
0.25614336133003235,
-0.4189629852771759,
0.2896566689014435,
-0.2293177992105484,
-0.06291407346725464,
-0.5969876050949097,
-0.20238040387630463,
0.25734132528305054,
1.0413976907730103,
-0.8152649998664856,
0.7658108472824097,
0.09278830885887146,
-0.5550781488418579,
-0.607391357421875,
0.3663758635520935,
0.08873315155506134,
-0.768061101436615,
0.4174584150314331,
0.041054561734199524,
0.12294062227010727,
-0.5757806301116943,
-0.6819490194320679,
-0.8590478301048279,
0.9917823672294617,
0.5931019186973572,
-0.5262661576271057,
-0.0924256443977356,
0.47451162338256836,
0.5196223855018616,
0.06959602981805801,
0.11528065800666809,
0.8547710180282593,
0.41374316811561584,
-0.24638032913208008,
-0.9061228632926941,
0.02238515205681324,
-0.1005711704492569,
-0.2681332230567932,
0.1913651078939438,
-0.37538257241249084,
0.7424579858779907,
-0.022131843492388725,
-0.3137974441051483,
-0.059196799993515015,
0.2047441005706787,
0.4352957010269165,
0.38450655341148376,
0.1973978579044342,
0.6369217038154602,
0.8320401906967163,
-0.24134598672389984,
1.2720650434494019,
0.06824544072151184,
0.33147966861724854,
1.6342817544937134,
-0.28503793478012085,
0.9714418649673462,
0.48786112666130066,
-0.03278568387031555,
0.2553279399871826,
0.32869505882263184,
-0.26649078726768494,
0.34719106554985046,
0.36219388246536255,
-0.1234680786728859,
0.5443217754364014,
0.0015214420855045319,
-0.27469661831855774,
0.4186674654483795,
0.2597241699695587,
-0.6499817967414856,
-0.3738578259944916,
-0.16668902337551117,
0.476906418800354,
-0.15068979561328888,
0.03723754733800888,
0.875095546245575,
0.147223100066185,
-0.6518574953079224,
0.27297642827033997,
-0.016131090000271797,
0.6080941557884216,
-0.5626512169837952,
-0.07235224545001984,
-0.5015860199928284,
0.14775317907333374,
-0.3286365568637848,
-1.0454357862472534,
0.5528620481491089,
0.3307684659957886,
0.3195202946662903,
-0.36957740783691406,
0.679297149181366,
-0.2623954117298126,
-0.22432595491409302,
0.46142974495887756,
0.5400283336639404,
0.2764994204044342,
-0.4761572480201721,
-0.6148491501808167,
0.3033461272716522,
0.01214618980884552,
-0.2778952121734619,
0.4545010030269623,
-0.0330810621380806,
0.07174114137887955,
0.6865194439888,
0.6972380876541138,
0.47142294049263,
0.40340638160705566,
0.1450474113225937,
0.9371266961097717,
-0.5670705437660217,
-0.019224325194954872,
-0.9372958540916443,
0.46590009331703186,
-0.030806593596935272,
-0.4006197154521942,
0.7360544204711914,
0.699096143245697,
0.9143701791763306,
0.2550612688064575,
0.9217617511749268,
0.4916221499443054,
0.4376745820045471,
-0.7898353934288025,
0.819140613079071,
-0.17911824584007263,
0.574578046798706,
-0.2855408489704132,
-0.9354965090751648,
-0.16633039712905884,
-0.05387064069509506,
-0.22478759288787842,
0.08020731806755066,
0.7338687181472778,
0.3936530351638794,
-0.17943616211414337,
0.22244615852832794,
0.18032753467559814,
0.2510971426963806,
0.7598522305488586,
0.3187420666217804,
0.7704863548278809,
-0.47690507769584656,
0.6244922876358032,
-0.6894323825836182,
-0.08584970235824585,
-0.08212050050497055,
-0.8513273000717163,
-0.36618515849113464,
-0.23524630069732666,
-0.29159608483314514,
-0.2541957497596741,
0.03541399911046028,
0.23120489716529846,
0.26502272486686707,
-0.6865897178649902,
-0.058978743851184845,
-0.18991176784038544,
0.1013188362121582,
-0.054579198360443115,
-0.23013697564601898,
0.26777538657188416,
-0.2758462429046631,
-0.7039710879325867,
0.4783313572406769,
-0.07084010541439056,
-0.16257573664188385,
-0.5709763765335083,
0.2907259464263916,
-0.006655322387814522,
-0.018159247934818268,
0.1504879593849182,
0.24295783042907715,
-0.565414547920227,
-0.16780687868595123,
-0.23898117244243622,
-0.20977872610092163,
0.12164343148469925,
0.8732091784477234,
-0.48133108019828796,
0.6508743166923523,
0.5426393747329712,
0.8017264008522034,
0.5364038348197937,
0.15381716191768646,
0.7890639305114746,
-0.9040170907974243,
-0.24134889245033264,
0.5688009858131409,
0.4694361686706543,
0.3716628849506378,
-0.5367744565010071,
0.7517954111099243,
0.09957350790500641,
-0.7358163595199585,
-1.2661226987838745,
0.03306625410914421,
-0.8026794195175171,
-0.17728498578071594,
1.36379075050354,
-0.30349206924438477,
-0.08994557708501816,
-0.18239668011665344,
0.15053322911262512,
0.11106229573488235,
-0.22416876256465912,
0.6234204769134521,
0.9188736081123352,
-0.24540409445762634,
0.07169441878795624,
-1.2207385301589966,
0.5409356951713562,
0.11313466727733612,
-1.167626976966858,
0.3959043622016907,
0.3915715515613556,
0.6408578157424927,
0.18395613133907318,
0.47834157943725586,
-0.7609443068504333,
0.0897987112402916,
0.045960914343595505,
-0.09436460584402084,
-0.3206183612346649,
-0.4209076464176178,
-0.8149711489677429,
0.04956506937742233,
-0.0354544036090374,
-0.22530214488506317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03916v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03916v2 | Can Large Language Models Detect Rumors on Social Media? | 2024-02-06T11:33:57 | 2024-02-08T16:09:36 | Qiang Liu, Xiang Tao, Junfei Wu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In this work, we investigate to use Large Language Models (LLMs) for rumor
detection on social media. However, it is challenging for LLMs to reason over
the entire propagation information on social media, which contains news
contents and numerous comments, due to LLMs may not concentrate on key clues in
the complex propagation information, and have trouble in reasoning when facing
massive and redundant information. Accordingly, we propose an LLM-empowered
Rumor Detection (LeRuD) approach, in which we design prompts to teach LLMs to
reason over important clues in news and comments, and divide the entire
propagation information into a Chain-of-Propagation for reducing LLMs' burden.
We conduct extensive experiments on the Twitter and Weibo datasets, and LeRuD
outperforms several state-of-the-art rumor detection models by 3.2% to 7.7%.
Meanwhile, by applying LLMs, LeRuD requires no data for training, and thus
shows more promising rumor detection ability in few-shot or zero-shot
scenarios. | [
-0.28414663672447205,
-1.0727770328521729,
0.9784430861473083,
0.4687044322490692,
-0.6634333729743958,
0.08666575700044632,
-0.48328182101249695,
-0.6661978363990784,
0.5376822352409363,
0.3248649537563324,
-0.4257565140724182,
-0.4009832739830017,
-0.7651623487472534,
-0.047654345631599426,
-0.6467666625976562,
0.7009902000427246,
-0.0008486617007292807,
-0.06617728620767593,
0.05568953603506088,
0.2344428449869156,
0.20030204951763153,
-0.42513301968574524,
-0.7193123698234558,
-0.03963818773627281,
0.8654038906097412,
0.4631837010383606,
0.37323132157325745,
0.22837822139263153,
0.20707617700099945,
0.27405449748039246,
-0.4272737503051758,
0.5645453929901123,
-0.47886866331100464,
0.2517172396183014,
-0.13693146407604218,
-0.4000951945781708,
-0.3379284143447876,
-0.22610555589199066,
0.79501873254776,
0.33370986580848694,
-0.010517721064388752,
0.18504075706005096,
-0.12287554144859314,
0.5168724060058594,
-0.4477830231189728,
-0.07230575382709503,
-0.919538676738739,
-0.24798977375030518,
-0.3554967939853668,
-0.2502575218677521,
-0.37111902236938477,
-0.32641056180000305,
-0.18391430377960205,
-0.39006173610687256,
-0.11973829567432404,
0.22269122302532196,
0.7219781279563904,
0.018943266943097115,
-0.41697415709495544,
-0.11366249620914459,
-0.7686513066291809,
0.6428834199905396,
-0.7457411289215088,
0.47694432735443115,
0.2294059544801712,
0.5363658666610718,
-0.21928687393665314,
-0.3611183762550354,
-0.7554081678390503,
-0.18160615861415863,
0.20065680146217346,
-0.15036188066005707,
-0.4546779990196228,
-0.21401022374629974,
0.2511521279811859,
-0.04782835766673088,
-0.26199260354042053,
0.3210473954677582,
-0.48309043049812317,
-0.41377735137939453,
0.5753214955329895,
-0.37483394145965576,
0.08181503415107727,
-0.24986888468265533,
-0.23160512745380402,
0.4471653401851654,
-0.7040671706199646,
-0.4061637818813324,
0.5740229487419128,
0.1626010537147522,
-0.13663816452026367,
0.4099501073360443,
-0.32649046182632446,
0.4652339816093445,
-0.017634738236665726,
-0.5343548655509949,
0.23841266334056854,
0.35496723651885986,
-0.13312064111232758,
0.18398702144622803,
0.8943799138069153,
0.4137246310710907,
0.448904812335968,
-0.2102476805448532,
-0.24365580081939697,
-0.09712053090333939,
-0.10516338795423508,
-0.703356921672821,
0.17644570767879486,
0.1334114372730255,
-0.38977429270744324,
-0.5295802354812622,
-0.13852858543395996,
-0.5735975503921509,
-0.7801046371459961,
-0.05703868344426155,
0.27890199422836304,
-0.24231083691120148,
-0.4869968891143799,
0.09399182349443436,
-0.3324356973171234,
0.30575916171073914,
0.8105837106704712,
-0.4826945662498474,
-0.1764376163482666,
0.7222306132316589,
0.836317241191864,
0.1183469220995903,
-0.09505951404571533,
-0.6367835402488708,
0.2790345847606659,
-0.5053040385246277,
1.2301422357559204,
-0.4313724637031555,
0.013920814730226994,
0.13365429639816284,
-0.04984666779637337,
0.2875567078590393,
-0.212733194231987,
0.9053949117660522,
-0.7114462852478027,
-0.17996124923229218,
-0.5484430193901062,
-0.6752104759216309,
-0.044717807322740555,
0.39171645045280457,
-0.5216159820556641,
0.592353343963623,
-0.19240731000900269,
-1.0011552572250366,
0.2546052038669586,
-0.23941993713378906,
-0.5590848922729492,
0.04387331008911133,
-0.14319142699241638,
-0.07233132421970367,
0.26434144377708435,
0.6964150071144104,
0.6787621974945068,
-0.29446783661842346,
0.28644677996635437,
-0.5928499102592468,
-0.5038576126098633,
0.358365923166275,
-0.7630152106285095,
0.6062024831771851,
0.33663225173950195,
-0.08919033408164978,
-0.11961249262094498,
-0.28874650597572327,
-0.37194257974624634,
0.11866957694292068,
-0.27908313274383545,
-0.4396848976612091,
-0.06893950700759888,
-0.2803356647491455,
0.15028509497642517,
0.054967451840639114,
-0.7645735740661621,
0.36588117480278015,
-0.04919225722551346,
0.3032971918582916,
0.7450557947158813,
0.1540844887495041,
0.36069828271865845,
-0.343126118183136,
0.32176029682159424,
0.026704855263233185,
0.2568517029285431,
-0.02051951363682747,
-0.38569706678390503,
-0.8341414332389832,
-0.2322387397289276,
0.2479582279920578,
0.15987646579742432,
-0.991098165512085,
0.18912474811077118,
-0.240935280919075,
-0.5264765024185181,
-0.5015210509300232,
0.3087775409221649,
-0.1690087914466858,
0.3617969751358032,
0.128877654671669,
0.6932413578033447,
-0.6700855493545532,
-0.7045965790748596,
-0.5842071175575256,
-0.30327650904655457,
0.0392436645925045,
0.14593732357025146,
0.22275836765766144,
0.04946894571185112,
0.6788505911827087,
-0.2353963553905487,
-0.13738928735256195,
-0.6468222737312317,
0.04732266068458557,
0.3572702705860138,
-0.18813589215278625,
0.6728408932685852,
-0.9123095273971558,
-0.5056139230728149,
-0.2810310125350952,
-0.864948034286499,
-0.5304295420646667,
0.01660418137907982,
0.03693999722599983,
0.49109089374542236,
0.9654975533485413,
-0.747681736946106,
0.1773219108581543,
0.6361994743347168,
-0.1474086195230484,
0.3677893579006195,
0.21818408370018005,
0.1757877767086029,
-0.9668224453926086,
-0.3821222186088562,
0.2504301071166992,
-0.4737198054790497,
-0.47639957070350647,
-0.030829979106783867,
-0.13765092194080353,
0.4224977195262909,
-0.5081470012664795,
0.5709499716758728,
-0.6249691247940063,
0.058246366679668427,
-0.6592053771018982,
0.3639008402824402,
-0.077887162566185,
0.06628672033548355,
0.03379203751683235,
0.18161317706108093,
0.66762375831604,
-0.5337960124015808,
0.3695860207080841,
-0.42895132303237915,
-0.5694530010223389,
0.4643089473247528,
-0.6029447317123413,
0.0401342548429966,
-0.4196048378944397,
0.7084017395973206,
-0.8793166279792786,
-0.43770259618759155,
0.3612600862979889,
-0.5622656941413879,
-0.024717086926102638,
-0.32913193106651306,
-0.966705322265625,
-0.6334792375564575,
-0.3361911177635193,
-0.04779057949781418,
0.8295844793319702,
-0.813087522983551,
0.6886672973632812,
0.4473869502544403,
0.014826596714556217,
-0.535481333732605,
-0.5895511507987976,
-0.005261790473014116,
-0.25625717639923096,
-0.73485267162323,
0.04785122349858284,
0.13747502863407135,
-0.4870907962322235,
0.0584152489900589,
-0.23029740154743195,
0.08361180126667023,
-0.14542411267757416,
0.2516818642616272,
0.11652849614620209,
-0.0706610158085823,
0.4939369559288025,
0.2713659405708313,
0.28419801592826843,
-0.03440731763839722,
-0.20336608588695526,
0.6533742547035217,
0.04714155197143555,
-0.3475663959980011,
-0.21355606615543365,
-0.06619110703468323,
0.6786019802093506,
0.1677131950855255,
0.9125737547874451,
0.8954722285270691,
-0.5060959458351135,
-0.6690757274627686,
-1.236519694328308,
-0.2805698812007904,
-0.49268725514411926,
0.11772838979959488,
0.12325888872146606,
-1.1257147789001465,
0.3066886365413666,
-0.2940388321876526,
-0.10596983879804611,
0.4627438485622406,
0.4651312828063965,
-0.10006272792816162,
0.8551960587501526,
0.5879648327827454,
-0.4090200960636139,
0.2542594373226166,
-0.06374797224998474,
0.24332638084888458,
-0.5654634833335876,
0.0421733595430851,
-0.2893458306789398,
-0.21414603292942047,
-0.2562750279903412,
-0.634553849697113,
0.3883639872074127,
0.4702363610267639,
0.010084880515933037,
0.05244700610637665,
-0.20921626687049866,
0.6965510249137878,
0.30262529850006104,
0.13274654746055603,
0.645507276058197,
0.2716050148010254,
0.07822584360837936,
0.19543196260929108,
-0.6196335554122925,
-0.27920135855674744,
0.6606969833374023,
0.7710278630256653,
0.934650182723999,
0.10179933160543442,
0.7154762744903564,
0.3912421762943268,
0.72983318567276,
-0.7701478004455566,
0.6966029405593872,
-0.10041593760251999,
-0.47629615664482117,
-0.42276155948638916,
-0.5374941229820251,
-0.30781257152557373,
0.26092401146888733,
-0.2893039882183075,
-0.8540838956832886,
-0.01678326353430748,
-0.03583196923136711,
-0.2247072160243988,
0.7188791632652283,
-0.36314836144447327,
0.12750142812728882,
-0.2613872289657593,
-0.07061082124710083,
-0.3435039222240448,
-0.2476685345172882,
0.6583448052406311,
-0.3214784860610962,
0.7805573344230652,
-0.3716721534729004,
0.06855448335409164,
0.7184363603591919,
-0.4956929385662079,
1.0073413848876953,
-0.21428628265857697,
-0.28372159600257874,
0.6682572364807129,
-0.2209920585155487,
0.6770368218421936,
0.11797427386045456,
-0.32449010014533997,
0.27327123284339905,
-0.4516213536262512,
-0.08571840077638626,
-0.378953218460083,
0.9185115098953247,
-0.6600947380065918,
-0.6188331246376038,
-0.3334660828113556,
-0.6827250719070435,
-0.1726928949356079,
0.09132085740566254,
0.36039143800735474,
-0.055520012974739075,
-0.03439612314105034,
0.23626334965229034,
0.40245577692985535,
-0.13275213539600372,
0.5077431201934814,
0.869236946105957,
-0.6164231300354004,
-0.18845079839229584,
0.7580220103263855,
0.3753899335861206,
-0.031796570867300034,
0.11560848355293274,
0.43195274472236633,
-0.17043878138065338,
-0.4491262435913086,
-0.364147424697876,
0.5247069597244263,
-0.8251481652259827,
-0.1702081710100174,
-0.7640413641929626,
-0.5209290981292725,
-0.3565862476825714,
-0.22913767397403717,
-0.15906164050102234,
-0.20477963984012604,
0.029198015108704567,
-0.1965215802192688,
0.784752368927002,
0.7387344837188721,
-0.20137426257133484,
0.6299671530723572,
-0.8852132558822632,
0.4595944881439209,
0.1925143003463745,
0.1605970859527588,
0.1146732047200203,
-0.8494699001312256,
-0.08074725419282913,
0.12763947248458862,
0.11541057378053665,
-0.8789960741996765,
0.2719520926475525,
-0.2515222728252411,
0.47389230132102966,
0.5970442295074463,
0.13742326200008392,
0.44745662808418274,
-0.3596463203430176,
0.5202310681343079,
0.02719155140221119,
-0.7818597555160522,
0.36325782537460327,
-0.7668538093566895,
0.03177420422434807,
0.19096888601779938,
0.5114717483520508,
-0.48076876997947693,
-0.7116819620132446,
-0.574485182762146,
-0.5359215140342712,
0.3452218472957611,
-0.010432413779199123,
0.3112142086029053,
-0.18508680164813995,
0.4055110514163971,
-0.22849240899085999,
0.3076496720314026,
-0.9514498114585876,
-0.06442415714263916,
0.34792187809944153,
0.2014445811510086,
0.22081854939460754,
-0.6286185383796692,
0.06098107248544693,
-0.5201961994171143,
0.6786708831787109,
0.009966492652893066,
-0.10704449564218521,
0.1273186206817627,
-0.09418965876102448,
-0.37042900919914246,
0.435275137424469,
0.3511529862880707,
0.4744381308555603,
-0.1980137825012207,
0.12449464201927185,
0.1249743103981018,
-0.19083033502101898,
-0.08335665613412857,
0.09369868040084839,
-0.35121065378189087,
0.36115774512290955,
0.5236045718193054,
0.6738696694374084,
-0.03952891007065773,
-0.4663011431694031,
0.7571344971656799,
0.13135413825511932,
-0.5463076829910278,
-0.4371684193611145,
-0.051067426800727844,
0.5633488297462463,
0.6050856709480286,
0.6020948886871338,
-0.17836540937423706,
-0.11867015063762665,
-0.6212921142578125,
-0.029079966247081757,
0.4006602168083191,
-0.30103808641433716,
-0.15813377499580383,
0.3566080927848816,
0.2412581592798233,
0.13224413990974426,
0.3109174072742462,
-0.43947887420654297,
-0.6923044323921204,
0.4876801371574402,
0.5866356492042542,
0.6842086315155029,
-0.29124903678894043,
0.5708031058311462,
0.01552332192659378,
0.6130313873291016,
-0.6047841906547546,
0.33266210556030273,
0.23559162020683289,
-1.0188568830490112,
-0.6960535645484924,
-0.7750465273857117,
-0.3055151104927063,
0.5828956961631775,
0.01435602642595768,
0.5330027937889099,
-0.5614957213401794,
0.028897633776068687,
0.285434365272522,
-0.3947187662124634,
-0.1656106859445572,
-0.2255961298942566,
0.6203728914260864,
1.2112632989883423,
-0.8809532523155212,
0.9092973470687866,
0.4302533268928528,
-0.22712168097496033,
-1.0400961637496948,
0.4583159387111664,
0.11830474436283112,
-0.7010810375213623,
0.7314786314964294,
0.31372782588005066,
-0.05426160991191864,
-0.21200864017009735,
-1.000784993171692,
-0.7212404012680054,
0.9601109027862549,
0.7013491988182068,
-0.9582647085189819,
0.026403076946735382,
-0.1655014455318451,
0.5015832781791687,
-0.29726725816726685,
0.18811437487602234,
0.1905500441789627,
0.7236202359199524,
0.6093178987503052,
-0.926457405090332,
-0.018268093466758728,
0.08676803857088089,
-0.539110004901886,
0.14046350121498108,
-0.8793004751205444,
1.0269956588745117,
-0.4287653863430023,
0.05619988217949867,
-0.17073248326778412,
0.7385982275009155,
0.4317020773887634,
0.4215913414955139,
0.8827504515647888,
0.30168530344963074,
0.733755350112915,
0.04880094900727272,
0.9174134135246277,
-0.3009405732154846,
0.13324421644210815,
0.8041923642158508,
-0.4862598478794098,
0.8196852207183838,
0.388826847076416,
0.18276125192642212,
0.6969918012619019,
0.4510137438774109,
0.01979541964828968,
0.12601561844348907,
0.2662828266620636,
-0.47172218561172485,
-0.7129310369491577,
-0.5417172908782959,
-0.27143800258636475,
0.31736987829208374,
0.48855161666870117,
-0.5132275223731995,
-0.5399670004844666,
0.04191623628139496,
0.43599435687065125,
-0.04372972622513771,
-0.7471910715103149,
0.2930006682872772,
0.48700767755508423,
-0.5304258465766907,
0.4105890393257141,
0.17063313722610474,
0.8811788558959961,
-0.5342084765434265,
-0.012229443527758121,
0.0390600711107254,
0.17251047492027283,
-0.2726103365421295,
-0.6076069474220276,
0.12815435230731964,
0.15985983610153198,
0.14656570553779602,
0.02803177945315838,
1.4561339616775513,
-0.5047990083694458,
-0.7014181613922119,
0.4641488790512085,
0.821592390537262,
0.2316075712442398,
-0.5147055387496948,
-0.27502813935279846,
0.32901275157928467,
-0.19680172204971313,
-0.45301181077957153,
0.13431155681610107,
0.6027042269706726,
-0.283369243144989,
0.6526830792427063,
0.7990419268608093,
0.29467302560806274,
-0.21781335771083832,
0.48619481921195984,
1.1907328367233276,
-0.277365118265152,
-0.3446650803089142,
-1.1640114784240723,
-0.0002860652457457036,
-0.5521319508552551,
0.20413582026958466,
1.0318301916122437,
0.13837389647960663,
0.37529489398002625,
0.14241525530815125,
1.0748975276947021,
0.11616132408380508,
0.7124651670455933,
-0.5675246715545654,
0.7122352123260498,
-0.4886954426765442,
0.49963513016700745,
-0.46739742159843445,
-0.8012467622756958,
-0.2581290304660797,
0.5426387190818787,
-0.5762450098991394,
0.08056307584047318,
0.6646483540534973,
0.5964294075965881,
-0.08875136077404022,
0.1120915338397026,
0.24580217897891998,
0.6576896905899048,
0.2462713122367859,
0.23485000431537628,
1.1887460947036743,
0.009948008693754673,
0.5919129848480225,
0.029360169544816017,
-0.20866818726062775,
-0.46136143803596497,
-1.1240639686584473,
-1.3840409517288208,
-0.10095905512571335,
-0.1109900027513504,
-0.5730820894241333,
0.2819851338863373,
0.8645064830780029,
0.5654072165489197,
-0.308059960603714,
0.04390069097280502,
-0.03294965252280235,
0.5247105360031128,
0.1145814061164856,
-0.19111990928649902,
0.24238944053649902,
-0.10601551830768585,
-0.41532135009765625,
0.5440528392791748,
0.18928994238376617,
0.0062700603157281876,
-0.4267394542694092,
0.08744167536497116,
-0.15872260928153992,
0.45829033851623535,
0.6842535138130188,
0.1544867902994156,
-0.70677649974823,
-0.4983796775341034,
0.23045285046100616,
-0.030325422063469887,
-0.5720517039299011,
0.5606474876403809,
-0.6060384511947632,
-0.17207764089107513,
0.604337215423584,
0.37517163157463074,
0.4107283055782318,
0.04982634261250496,
0.3699028789997101,
-0.886014461517334,
0.32675111293792725,
-0.062078818678855896,
0.6467545032501221,
0.3559926748275757,
-0.4517644941806793,
0.39332571625709534,
0.30627861618995667,
-0.5310771465301514,
-0.8865241408348083,
0.03601548820734024,
-0.9784095287322998,
-0.5017459392547607,
1.9582583904266357,
0.25466975569725037,
-0.41268715262413025,
-0.027174482122063637,
-0.17443129420280457,
0.016670377925038338,
-0.6344266533851624,
0.5997520089149475,
0.7844412922859192,
0.22655853629112244,
-0.23091822862625122,
-0.6227864027023315,
0.3753770589828491,
0.005945914424955845,
-0.5313031077384949,
-0.034712836146354675,
0.37750598788261414,
0.40030044317245483,
0.12996108829975128,
1.1537225246429443,
0.16588415205478668,
0.16649839282035828,
-0.2604299783706665,
-0.19370967149734497,
-0.16801011562347412,
-0.5294660329818726,
-0.016887281090021133,
0.12801629304885864,
0.16698768734931946,
0.22570641338825226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05135v1 | CADReN: Contextual Anchor-Driven Relational Network for Controllable Cross-Graphs Node Importance Estimation | 2024-02-06T11:29:44 | 2024-02-06T11:29:44 | Zijie Zhong, Yunhui Zhang, Ziyi Chang, Zengchang Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, 68T07 | Node Importance Estimation (NIE) is crucial for integrating external
information into Large Language Models through Retriever-Augmented Generation.
Traditional methods, focusing on static, single-graph characteristics, lack
adaptability to new graphs and user-specific requirements. CADReN, our proposed
method, addresses these limitations by introducing a Contextual Anchor (CA)
mechanism. This approach enables the network to assess node importance relative
to the CA, considering both structural and semantic features within Knowledge
Graphs (KGs). Extensive experiments show that CADReN achieves better
performance in cross-graph NIE task, with zero-shot prediction ability. CADReN
is also proven to match the performance of previous models on single-graph NIE
task. Additionally, we introduce and opensource two new datasets, RIC200 and
WK1K, specifically designed for cross-graph NIE research, providing a valuable
resource for future developments in this domain. | [
-0.5212334990501404,
-0.4669233560562134,
0.3227905035018921,
0.08339762687683105,
-0.03916675224900246,
-0.06549367308616638,
-0.19297657907009125,
-0.3410250246524811,
0.36840206384658813,
0.34052082896232605,
-0.35659584403038025,
-0.8567244410514832,
-0.6650390028953552,
-0.18591883778572083,
-0.24933674931526184,
0.8242703676223755,
0.034655097872018814,
-0.10314679890871048,
-0.34112757444381714,
-0.23119711875915527,
-0.18592225015163422,
-0.14997464418411255,
-1.0729289054870605,
-0.046672429889440536,
1.0885450839996338,
0.35721346735954285,
0.5742466449737549,
0.5795953273773193,
0.422473281621933,
0.23245565593242645,
0.0028519881889224052,
0.01918240636587143,
-0.8278640508651733,
0.14131197333335876,
-0.7389901876449585,
0.14368018507957458,
-0.9801105856895447,
-0.14957885444164276,
0.3900687098503113,
1.003126859664917,
0.1673460304737091,
0.1451854556798935,
0.13482646644115448,
0.4968133568763733,
-0.9494175314903259,
0.16933049261569977,
-0.4880145490169525,
-0.31157219409942627,
-0.29149869084358215,
-0.3923983871936798,
-0.22477753460407257,
-0.41601669788360596,
0.16935643553733826,
-0.5916391611099243,
0.07800818234682083,
0.12514525651931763,
0.6327848434448242,
0.19131194055080414,
-0.7134947180747986,
0.1192869320511818,
-0.5171183943748474,
0.5659603476524353,
-0.4607834219932556,
0.2912673354148865,
0.20993860065937042,
0.5517899990081787,
-0.330218106508255,
-0.9776427745819092,
-0.21851423382759094,
0.09078975021839142,
-0.05085817724466324,
0.12643469870090485,
0.023587830364704132,
0.2789399325847626,
0.03684798255562782,
0.11576759070158005,
-0.44338110089302063,
-0.11090739071369171,
-0.06739500910043716,
-0.17563496530056,
0.5814451575279236,
0.06862714886665344,
0.654211163520813,
-0.07157459855079651,
-0.5280858278274536,
-0.21027670800685883,
-0.8079577088356018,
0.06911611557006836,
0.24166050553321838,
0.41155704855918884,
-0.1409408450126648,
0.42272502183914185,
-0.4957089424133301,
0.7844631671905518,
0.17569780349731445,
0.06380931288003922,
-0.14838232100009918,
-0.48257243633270264,
-0.2517322897911072,
0.4916673004627228,
0.8754291534423828,
0.30715546011924744,
0.07259077578783035,
-0.4095717668533325,
0.260368287563324,
-0.2100094109773636,
0.018738405779004097,
-0.7658243775367737,
-0.13402214646339417,
0.2159372717142105,
-0.1650412380695343,
-0.49007129669189453,
0.026209954172372818,
-0.47064366936683655,
-0.2288251519203186,
-0.12722016870975494,
-0.005708172917366028,
-0.15639686584472656,
-0.5432377457618713,
-0.2444545328617096,
-0.1949981302022934,
0.045173533260822296,
0.48435309529304504,
-0.6389679312705994,
0.3586803078651428,
0.47724050283432007,
0.7690778374671936,
-0.32568424940109253,
-0.22565387189388275,
-0.649241030216217,
0.5981464982032776,
-0.2729037404060364,
0.6363494396209717,
-0.48983466625213623,
-0.19296857714653015,
-0.35108086466789246,
0.350832998752594,
-0.3728984296321869,
-0.050781842321157455,
0.5673879384994507,
-0.8205907344818115,
-0.1841583251953125,
-0.48209401965141296,
-0.24729636311531067,
-0.36429736018180847,
0.5324329733848572,
-0.9571598768234253,
0.9210448861122131,
0.3049636483192444,
-1.3753458261489868,
0.316832959651947,
-0.5974442362785339,
-0.4065662920475006,
-0.029645584523677826,
-0.2727743983268738,
-0.06762043386697769,
0.02745121717453003,
0.09977345913648605,
0.21661731600761414,
-0.6599725484848022,
0.34824424982070923,
-0.6400498747825623,
-0.08870230615139008,
-0.23419855535030365,
-0.3508637547492981,
1.1137700080871582,
-0.29592105746269226,
-0.43720757961273193,
0.4260672926902771,
-0.7003599405288696,
0.28670650720596313,
-0.11130926012992859,
-0.13209334015846252,
-0.6711639165878296,
-0.06580474227666855,
0.1688917577266693,
0.6046220064163208,
0.18357810378074646,
-0.6115208864212036,
-0.10651683062314987,
-0.48887693881988525,
0.22654512524604797,
0.4059963524341583,
0.2696530818939209,
0.3375172019004822,
0.2259252369403839,
0.7204412221908569,
-0.2543688416481018,
0.1523757129907608,
0.5447571873664856,
-0.3541182279586792,
-0.09209888428449631,
0.13308018445968628,
0.5968146324157715,
0.5155830979347229,
-0.7142906785011292,
-0.03706205263733864,
-0.5981475114822388,
-0.27581584453582764,
0.23364116251468658,
0.07183769345283508,
0.42573899030685425,
0.6205135583877563,
0.16342653334140778,
-0.4115459620952606,
-0.3610723912715912,
-0.7637875080108643,
0.1173541396856308,
-0.11289910972118378,
0.28755247592926025,
0.6477687358856201,
0.23085865378379822,
0.09423227608203888,
1.1160225868225098,
-0.1777038872241974,
-0.027872415259480476,
-0.3569469153881073,
-0.13924983143806458,
0.0994674488902092,
0.4117935299873352,
0.6803178787231445,
-0.7642132043838501,
-0.8356997966766357,
0.5748299360275269,
-0.9644947052001953,
-0.0205039344727993,
0.3155728876590729,
-0.5573418140411377,
-0.24453534185886383,
0.5739511251449585,
-0.4242265522480011,
0.6057771444320679,
0.8504088521003723,
-0.043778833001852036,
0.3080374598503113,
-0.07750364392995834,
-0.019702283665537834,
-1.0989367961883545,
0.391056090593338,
-0.26969820261001587,
-0.3280305862426758,
-0.4681062400341034,
-0.46670204401016235,
-0.009535354562103748,
-0.21934135258197784,
-0.5746830105781555,
0.9363228678703308,
-0.5375445485115051,
-0.29620128870010376,
-0.2793579697608948,
0.7640288472175598,
0.13004229962825775,
0.5480118989944458,
0.03510550409555435,
0.48561471700668335,
0.6299237608909607,
-0.6073974967002869,
0.2608560621738434,
0.02538100630044937,
-0.13490085303783417,
0.7066099643707275,
-0.8597317337989807,
-0.08509181439876556,
0.03666356950998306,
0.037018582224845886,
-0.8758932948112488,
-0.22274662554264069,
0.2922194302082062,
-0.3917250335216522,
0.6325666904449463,
-0.3308030366897583,
0.025256548076868057,
-0.35866501927375793,
-0.205551415681839,
0.8149020671844482,
-0.5742509365081787,
-0.3610324263572693,
0.5197254419326782,
0.47387680411338806,
-0.06729581952095032,
-0.9927444458007812,
-0.11630095541477203,
0.2523441016674042,
0.11002527177333832,
-0.8508573770523071,
0.4442845582962036,
0.26996171474456787,
-0.04863720387220383,
0.49618229269981384,
-0.18106986582279205,
-0.03441537544131279,
0.22492749989032745,
0.4746912717819214,
-0.1875266283750534,
-0.19615115225315094,
0.16930773854255676,
0.4167793095111847,
-0.5341156721115112,
0.15223555266857147,
-0.6759577393531799,
0.24957969784736633,
0.24981631338596344,
-0.3315223157405853,
-0.17387011647224426,
0.31194591522216797,
0.6997524499893188,
-0.26845958828926086,
0.735181450843811,
0.5079218149185181,
-0.34500640630722046,
-0.23267830908298492,
0.08450594544410706,
-0.12056796252727509,
-0.3615168333053589,
0.5011223554611206,
-0.18866457045078278,
-0.6401010751724243,
0.38326361775398254,
-0.40053698420524597,
-0.32330894470214844,
0.5603116154670715,
0.1857350766658783,
0.10911552608013153,
1.0257930755615234,
0.675032377243042,
-0.3413381576538086,
0.273908406496048,
-0.4389956295490265,
0.4003889858722687,
-1.0736842155456543,
0.13758248090744019,
-0.252281129360199,
-0.5045804381370544,
-0.6541579365730286,
-0.2703675627708435,
0.6621118187904358,
0.5130863785743713,
-0.2629951238632202,
0.4136509299278259,
-0.3675592243671417,
0.24325305223464966,
0.49179574847221375,
-0.10313665866851807,
0.24211570620536804,
0.024750452488660812,
-0.4438070058822632,
0.301716685295105,
-1.1492823362350464,
-0.21970844268798828,
1.0984245538711548,
-0.15880058705806732,
0.715122640132904,
0.17047303915023804,
0.2636635899543762,
0.16783370077610016,
0.4704497158527374,
-0.38974428176879883,
0.4081144332885742,
-0.0031243080738931894,
-0.8531634211540222,
-0.6694077253341675,
-0.3361050486564636,
-0.9433430433273315,
0.0432903915643692,
0.009801175445318222,
-0.8444865942001343,
0.6724684834480286,
0.2620686888694763,
-0.12496866285800934,
0.4537363052368164,
-0.12992733716964722,
1.187255620956421,
-0.34676557779312134,
-0.755492091178894,
-0.06888292729854584,
-0.7133494019508362,
0.4068329632282257,
0.38973867893218994,
-0.11536257714033127,
-0.19532568752765656,
0.09785810112953186,
0.5500274300575256,
-0.7120870351791382,
0.9149466156959534,
-0.1384594589471817,
0.11818555742502213,
0.46741434931755066,
0.034205082803964615,
0.7912203669548035,
0.37814009189605713,
-0.15316888689994812,
0.1778317242860794,
-0.096059650182724,
-0.3768830895423889,
-0.7748667597770691,
1.2016310691833496,
-0.5503246784210205,
-0.6012677550315857,
-0.4008030593395233,
-0.5779556035995483,
-0.05024637281894684,
0.41580355167388916,
0.3082614541053772,
0.8616467714309692,
-0.4680892825126648,
0.2504158020019531,
0.3691593408584595,
-0.07210124284029007,
0.5906172394752502,
0.04129122942686081,
0.03861025720834732,
-0.67685866355896,
0.7903633117675781,
0.10692857205867767,
0.5159813761711121,
0.599828839302063,
0.017160458490252495,
-0.20089420676231384,
-0.38327375054359436,
-0.6260971426963806,
0.12239045649766922,
-0.7434301972389221,
-0.28643783926963806,
-0.8153708577156067,
-0.4160725474357605,
-0.2989664375782013,
-0.3867337107658386,
-0.4128957986831665,
-0.667988657951355,
0.05584537982940674,
-0.2780604958534241,
0.478586882352829,
0.5468629598617554,
-0.1598878800868988,
0.275750070810318,
-0.2801090478897095,
-0.1665956974029541,
0.4875345826148987,
0.41320958733558655,
0.2724595367908478,
0.20418480038642883,
-0.4372004270553589,
-0.12026193737983704,
-0.03695297986268997,
-0.9976288676261902,
0.23048247396945953,
0.07305547595024109,
0.6646309494972229,
0.5170291662216187,
0.28849121928215027,
0.2081640511751175,
-0.141846165060997,
0.22329522669315338,
0.002145862439647317,
-0.6689563393592834,
0.5911787748336792,
-0.604135274887085,
0.18628253042697906,
0.7760358452796936,
0.4842626452445984,
-0.431718647480011,
-0.0022101006470620632,
-0.604591429233551,
-0.9814420342445374,
0.7187312841415405,
0.2786077857017517,
-0.312309592962265,
-0.2239319384098053,
0.41477471590042114,
-0.5294756889343262,
0.38337215781211853,
-0.4153726398944855,
-0.3632539212703705,
-0.16692215204238892,
-0.1342465728521347,
0.17693980038166046,
-0.1945139318704605,
-0.13214506208896637,
-0.04479340836405754,
0.740122377872467,
-0.40996667742729187,
0.006222052499651909,
0.2530229985713959,
-0.11984134465456009,
-0.1250310093164444,
-0.020286481827497482,
0.42441895604133606,
1.0141727924346924,
-0.4652777910232544,
0.22985564172267914,
0.18473711609840393,
-0.4760197103023529,
0.0018259831704199314,
0.005718973930925131,
-0.50345379114151,
0.03491107374429703,
0.32595884799957275,
0.8547777533531189,
0.5643944144248962,
-0.14802299439907074,
0.6806734800338745,
0.041946299374103546,
0.2032632827758789,
-0.10645551234483719,
-0.06362852454185486,
0.19521291553974152,
-0.09988841414451599,
-0.24938900768756866,
-0.0576278492808342,
0.1954951286315918,
-0.19976504147052765,
0.1447945386171341,
0.5394815802574158,
-1.1829577684402466,
-0.46215227246284485,
0.8687705397605896,
0.3425687551498413,
0.11086124926805496,
0.15363484621047974,
-0.31436026096343994,
-0.38395410776138306,
0.8525453209877014,
0.4258880317211151,
0.9718574285507202,
-0.4045421779155731,
0.3077182471752167,
0.7803651094436646,
0.2675737738609314,
0.3799141049385071,
0.2393944412469864,
-0.12421179562807083,
-0.627311110496521,
-0.46467795968055725,
-0.29219892621040344,
-0.27704840898513794,
-0.3721266984939575,
-0.5732232332229614,
0.2804279029369354,
-0.5168159604072571,
-0.39259418845176697,
-0.20658403635025024,
0.0295511893928051,
-0.6186907291412354,
0.3177279829978943,
-0.4691057503223419,
0.8518874645233154,
-0.6980135440826416,
1.0840480327606201,
0.6118059754371643,
-0.3234359323978424,
-0.5325032472610474,
-0.46789848804473877,
0.04113388434052467,
-0.3108624219894409,
1.0679974555969238,
-0.2867244482040405,
-0.4815719425678253,
0.30674391984939575,
-0.20591622591018677,
-1.414808988571167,
1.4597288370132446,
0.23633478581905365,
-0.41428372263908386,
-0.07893968373537064,
-0.053793713450431824,
0.13355745375156403,
-0.6367585062980652,
0.5371817350387573,
0.05558532848954201,
0.5143635272979736,
0.16143468022346497,
-0.6529394388198853,
0.21817979216575623,
-0.164757639169693,
0.270042359828949,
0.4796522557735443,
-0.5356717109680176,
0.6458784937858582,
-0.11187898367643356,
-0.3568130135536194,
-0.5597313642501831,
0.41016680002212524,
-0.033808205276727676,
0.40802595019340515,
0.43578699231147766,
0.4597603380680084,
0.7728433012962341,
0.17364351451396942,
1.2572168111801147,
-0.6561431288719177,
0.19974210858345032,
1.6361525058746338,
-0.33044150471687317,
0.6362412571907043,
0.22180894017219543,
0.1641620695590973,
0.6731148958206177,
0.4757024645805359,
0.7146532535552979,
0.5460185408592224,
-0.06660118699073792,
-0.2697561979293823,
-0.35374826192855835,
-0.4656461179256439,
-0.4322742223739624,
0.24855439364910126,
0.4411174952983856,
-0.5490708351135254,
-0.689384400844574,
-0.25404098629951477,
0.008957842364907265,
-0.22593729197978973,
-0.2407883107662201,
0.5707157850265503,
0.09467070549726486,
-0.3200835883617401,
0.34092476963996887,
-0.04985979571938515,
-0.2928110957145691,
-0.4594413936138153,
-0.024277955293655396,
-0.15696778893470764,
0.020438941195607185,
-0.15979726612567902,
-0.3178711533546448,
0.2174096405506134,
-0.4316113591194153,
-0.49442389607429504,
0.14845149219036102,
0.9574553966522217,
-0.3529623746871948,
-0.5937137603759766,
0.7674686908721924,
0.5665878653526306,
-0.08089285343885422,
-0.10886936634778976,
-0.40636110305786133,
-0.17993496358394623,
-0.17056624591350555,
-0.12646442651748657,
0.2861335873603821,
0.6663660407066345,
-0.7888742685317993,
0.43757784366607666,
0.5292320251464844,
0.09584646672010422,
0.04222148656845093,
0.1229439228773117,
1.0077893733978271,
-0.7342570424079895,
-0.2881079316139221,
-0.38319557905197144,
0.3799229860305786,
-0.5700606107711792,
-0.3013139069080353,
0.9147024154663086,
0.4858841598033905,
0.6329966187477112,
0.3562956154346466,
0.8195206522941589,
-0.3093189001083374,
0.2264423668384552,
-0.18603235483169556,
0.6395853757858276,
-0.3516886532306671,
0.08938788622617722,
-0.2570028007030487,
-1.010044813156128,
-0.37435823678970337,
0.06262490898370743,
-0.6609517335891724,
0.09443461894989014,
0.8608849048614502,
0.8404552936553955,
-0.4550686478614807,
-0.16331090033054352,
0.3408159613609314,
0.14294877648353577,
0.11544577032327652,
0.7633599042892456,
0.19023051857948303,
-0.7096096277236938,
0.5340321063995361,
-0.32848241925239563,
-0.1919812262058258,
-0.2637706398963928,
-1.1733155250549316,
-1.061387300491333,
-0.3036069869995117,
-0.6684713959693909,
-0.34960412979125977,
0.11281179636716843,
0.6336547136306763,
0.957098126411438,
-1.04343581199646,
-0.12796615064144135,
-0.1589578241109848,
0.6607142090797424,
-0.46635422110557556,
-0.1356152445077896,
0.9290549159049988,
-0.18919840455055237,
-0.4619579315185547,
0.344398558139801,
0.7632364630699158,
-0.22577975690364838,
-0.10234326869249344,
-0.121877022087574,
-0.506244421005249,
-0.1304609477519989,
0.4851782023906708,
0.5970998406410217,
-0.529673159122467,
-0.2497066706418991,
-0.020986687391996384,
-0.24381473660469055,
-0.1848284900188446,
0.805020272731781,
-0.6742593050003052,
0.6841618418693542,
0.9255387187004089,
0.7303523421287537,
0.5807698965072632,
0.23736229538917542,
0.7844028472900391,
-0.8656238317489624,
0.11792466044425964,
-0.1577346920967102,
0.27512428164482117,
0.2557809054851532,
-0.40420466661453247,
0.637033224105835,
0.29932329058647156,
-0.28200072050094604,
-0.4312444031238556,
0.15757736563682556,
-1.079697847366333,
0.06189412251114845,
0.7538651823997498,
-0.19572564959526062,
-0.7768688201904297,
-0.37641894817352295,
0.031397875398397446,
0.2335616648197174,
-0.10189841687679291,
0.20825283229351044,
0.38531339168548584,
0.1279705911874771,
-0.156916543841362,
-0.586308479309082,
0.6071508526802063,
0.11963331699371338,
-0.8008482456207275,
-0.10216926783323288,
0.2902339994907379,
0.144626647233963,
0.15289603173732758,
0.5895804762840271,
-0.07804830372333527,
0.2907201945781708,
-0.06362725049257278,
0.272766649723053,
-0.21247577667236328,
-0.587003231048584,
0.1642734855413437,
0.5464071035385132,
0.004217745736241341,
-0.0407111681997776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03900v1 | Pro-HAN: A Heterogeneous Graph Attention Network for Profile-Based Spoken Language Understanding | 2024-02-06T11:12:09 | 2024-02-06T11:12:09 | Dechuan Teng, Chunlin Lu, Xiao Xu, Wanxiang Che, Libo Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Profile-based Spoken Language Understanding (SLU) has gained
increasing attention, which aims to incorporate various types of supplementary
profile information (i.e., Knowledge Graph, User Profile, Context Awareness) to
eliminate the prevalent ambiguities in user utterances. However, existing
approaches can only separately model different profile information, without
considering their interrelationships or excluding irrelevant and conflicting
information within them. To address the above issues, we introduce a
Heterogeneous Graph Attention Network to perform reasoning across multiple
Profile information, called Pro-HAN. Specifically, we design three types of
edges, denoted as intra-Pro, inter-Pro, and utterance-Pro, to capture
interrelationships among multiple Pros. We establish a new state-of-the-art on
the ProSLU dataset, with an improvement of approximately 8% across all three
metrics. Further analysis experiments also confirm the effectiveness of our
method in modeling multi-source profile information. | [
-0.5001149773597717,
-1.1337741613388062,
0.6384497880935669,
0.2772083282470703,
-0.07981476932764053,
0.1808735877275467,
-0.2593914270401001,
-0.29328468441963196,
0.3631148040294647,
0.6047490835189819,
-0.6786550879478455,
-0.6781203746795654,
-0.283473402261734,
-0.23808328807353973,
0.23984825611114502,
0.8949765563011169,
0.15767769515514374,
-0.08201131969690323,
-0.13234350085258484,
-0.436445027589798,
-0.4809766113758087,
-0.19188688695430756,
-0.8068552017211914,
-0.32534679770469666,
0.8132798075675964,
0.7928881049156189,
0.8706240057945251,
0.43630895018577576,
0.5305294990539551,
0.2891656458377838,
0.06379799544811249,
0.3508389890193939,
-0.5178583264350891,
0.16523325443267822,
-0.008954592980444431,
-0.16472475230693817,
-0.8450364470481873,
0.1734464466571808,
1.0232864618301392,
0.797324001789093,
0.33048394322395325,
0.3680739402770996,
0.0719466358423233,
0.48133450746536255,
-0.5951338410377502,
0.4047640264034271,
-0.33805781602859497,
-0.04720645770430565,
-0.2264978289604187,
0.08656305819749832,
-0.5004112720489502,
-0.2831539809703827,
0.1996331512928009,
-0.9966598749160767,
-0.13742707669734955,
-0.12021997570991516,
1.022753119468689,
0.2669265866279602,
-0.09383682906627655,
0.2705168128013611,
-0.745816171169281,
0.42503276467323303,
-0.6454793810844421,
0.4266062378883362,
0.6066847443580627,
0.6092645525932312,
0.36800312995910645,
-0.686004102230072,
-0.5279657244682312,
-0.07252731174230576,
-0.3482256233692169,
0.5088870525360107,
-0.2744433879852295,
0.17513813078403473,
-0.024676186963915825,
0.11738978326320648,
-0.5941938161849976,
0.1311277598142624,
0.049195755273103714,
-0.2737654745578766,
0.5142965316772461,
-0.1302475780248642,
0.254841148853302,
0.032379742711782455,
-0.23893141746520996,
0.1753961741924286,
-0.6620842814445496,
0.03883284330368042,
0.6242777109146118,
0.5468618273735046,
-0.07410864531993866,
0.4035606384277344,
-0.01876451075077057,
0.7721177935600281,
0.03932039812207222,
-0.2013883888721466,
0.5661777257919312,
-0.4037538766860962,
-0.159140944480896,
0.09968817979097366,
0.7872987389564514,
0.1573144793510437,
0.5662572979927063,
-0.19816599786281586,
0.17581960558891296,
-0.16297344863414764,
-0.01605636440217495,
-0.47962844371795654,
-0.13173158466815948,
0.3236144781112671,
-0.5131349563598633,
0.057476647198200226,
0.10994943976402283,
-0.48267558217048645,
-0.23554334044456482,
-0.32794758677482605,
0.26630085706710815,
-0.5428665280342102,
-0.6560792922973633,
-0.1300717294216156,
0.13850946724414825,
-0.08387782424688339,
0.1286543905735016,
-0.228227436542511,
0.2539505958557129,
0.6433295607566833,
0.7702761292457581,
0.11864995211362839,
-0.4244163930416107,
-1.0517266988754272,
0.3067096471786499,
0.05910738557577133,
0.6635875105857849,
-0.7454019784927368,
-0.037727247923612595,
-0.19881385564804077,
-0.03020313009619713,
-0.47687289118766785,
-0.4464934170246124,
0.638156533241272,
-0.3767116665840149,
0.30829763412475586,
-0.267902135848999,
-0.5405774712562561,
-0.36066654324531555,
0.2641001045703888,
-0.7403358221054077,
0.7193549871444702,
0.1544095128774643,
-0.9939178228378296,
-0.28740426898002625,
-0.7080069780349731,
-0.4745349884033203,
0.4533538222312927,
-0.3347315490245819,
-0.5207156538963318,
-0.30568739771842957,
0.15137091279029846,
0.28926557302474976,
-0.048002347350120544,
0.5222554802894592,
-0.3813396394252777,
-0.34492117166519165,
-0.14874528348445892,
-0.06798991560935974,
0.8624250888824463,
0.2930717468261719,
-0.1555287390947342,
0.44416800141334534,
-0.686460018157959,
-0.09242275357246399,
0.09372241050004959,
-0.15734557807445526,
-0.5142192244529724,
-0.0861029177904129,
-0.11335120350122452,
0.17292924225330353,
0.176131010055542,
-0.5877050161361694,
-0.3516911268234253,
-0.2116493433713913,
0.36365431547164917,
0.5148904919624329,
-0.13092635571956635,
0.3120979964733124,
-0.07135791331529617,
0.5440476536750793,
0.009999634698033333,
0.19156409800052643,
-0.10845938324928284,
-0.5945192575454712,
-0.5469748973846436,
-0.2827235460281372,
0.00716579332947731,
0.8285656571388245,
-0.5908386707305908,
0.49251770973205566,
-0.09237221628427505,
-0.2639194428920746,
-0.7874578237533569,
-0.19030115008354187,
0.8720479607582092,
1.0783764123916626,
0.4822671711444855,
-0.019234953448176384,
-0.5258650183677673,
-1.0637530088424683,
-0.47701963782310486,
-0.40133506059646606,
0.15926139056682587,
0.8138045072555542,
-0.09765094518661499,
-0.37588971853256226,
1.076186180114746,
-0.40774115920066833,
-0.4217303395271301,
-0.453342080116272,
0.03296295180916786,
0.1446278840303421,
0.3543875813484192,
0.49388909339904785,
-0.7180256843566895,
-0.8099828958511353,
0.3825935423374176,
-0.6889859437942505,
-0.338548868894577,
-0.11972367018461227,
-0.22536107897758484,
-0.36582908034324646,
0.6143721342086792,
-0.34412717819213867,
0.11374067515134811,
0.6405894756317139,
-0.35704880952835083,
0.7028807997703552,
-0.11576520651578903,
-0.08544538915157318,
-0.8767974972724915,
0.27793145179748535,
0.3058392405509949,
-0.4626493752002716,
-0.9937215447425842,
-0.08487309515476227,
-0.13415350019931793,
-0.12209998816251755,
-0.35591134428977966,
0.6481319665908813,
-0.3415561318397522,
-0.4005134701728821,
0.01423376239836216,
0.6172605156898499,
0.259541779756546,
0.5389853119850159,
-0.02497474104166031,
0.8172315359115601,
0.6351034045219421,
-0.4376021921634674,
0.21720299124717712,
0.25809234380722046,
-0.18951267004013062,
0.7161067128181458,
-0.6497625708580017,
0.26792120933532715,
-0.27438265085220337,
0.25687509775161743,
-1.057591199874878,
-0.1532442271709442,
0.3850528299808502,
-0.43030914664268494,
0.08264754712581635,
0.07657361775636673,
-0.12661311030387878,
-0.32038864493370056,
-0.02109810896217823,
0.1705513298511505,
-0.030710171908140182,
-0.08785602450370789,
0.9067229628562927,
0.5623396635055542,
-0.10691540688276291,
-0.8281967639923096,
-0.47808900475502014,
-0.029465653002262115,
-0.27555379271507263,
-0.8242865204811096,
0.5061261057853699,
0.018019819632172585,
-0.6936377286911011,
0.2475060373544693,
-0.03138211742043495,
-0.012775270268321037,
0.20964838564395905,
0.08156872540712357,
0.04746035486459732,
-0.5504536032676697,
0.24625040590763092,
-0.15984942018985748,
-0.3982352316379547,
-0.17633195221424103,
-0.29396602511405945,
0.5585484504699707,
-0.4343188405036926,
-0.37743011116981506,
-0.9847328662872314,
0.5096942782402039,
0.4116436839103699,
-0.4831884801387787,
0.6762601137161255,
1.0335896015167236,
-0.4117347300052643,
0.13518814742565155,
-0.3984585702419281,
-0.025473719462752342,
-0.393290251493454,
0.495604008436203,
-0.8107190728187561,
-1.0410411357879639,
0.8653209209442139,
-0.0867261290550232,
0.06511061638593674,
0.494795560836792,
0.38622331619262695,
-0.4947627782821655,
1.0947833061218262,
0.4451363980770111,
-0.14709453284740448,
0.6196116805076599,
-0.17584507167339325,
0.3773311376571655,
-0.9315938353538513,
-0.19205495715141296,
-0.3415818214416504,
-0.3665563464164734,
-0.30120834708213806,
-0.2508153021335602,
0.29582133889198303,
0.03726675733923912,
-0.4873346984386444,
0.35369908809661865,
-0.07443496584892273,
0.39336273074150085,
0.576320230960846,
0.21725425124168396,
0.22983995079994202,
-0.3746810853481293,
-0.046555206179618835,
0.142762690782547,
-0.6004228591918945,
-0.43500903248786926,
0.35318732261657715,
0.5305534601211548,
0.3866841495037079,
0.13321705162525177,
0.29842182993888855,
0.1816733032464981,
0.1969694346189499,
-0.6341240406036377,
0.5756438374519348,
-0.5554580092430115,
-0.4307727515697479,
-0.5670638084411621,
-0.5433545708656311,
-0.7736532688140869,
0.4322955310344696,
0.17645113170146942,
-0.9201766848564148,
0.21306221187114716,
0.31345170736312866,
-0.5703959465026855,
0.13373860716819763,
-0.9793531894683838,
1.078455924987793,
-0.05007779225707054,
-0.15796254575252533,
-0.08708329498767853,
-1.0952274799346924,
0.4131229817867279,
0.14705206453800201,
0.46120503544807434,
-0.48244404792785645,
0.46387189626693726,
0.6523397564888,
-0.3214217722415924,
0.842961311340332,
-0.459308922290802,
0.026765258982777596,
0.4883376359939575,
-0.0007212766213342547,
0.453005850315094,
0.34954530000686646,
-0.16512411832809448,
-0.04172935336828232,
-0.468043714761734,
-0.141256645321846,
-0.36397549510002136,
0.5416841506958008,
-0.9754846692085266,
-0.6776133179664612,
0.308246910572052,
-0.8193982839584351,
-0.42161720991134644,
0.26027119159698486,
0.1169782429933548,
0.3807313144207001,
-0.15954184532165527,
0.08019964396953583,
0.5674285292625427,
-0.12717951834201813,
0.051316190510988235,
0.2680152654647827,
-0.1263355016708374,
-0.19401268661022186,
1.0541232824325562,
0.08124727755784988,
0.4586452841758728,
0.3415948450565338,
0.474928081035614,
-0.16383878886699677,
-0.20501556992530823,
-0.25985297560691833,
0.5699987411499023,
-0.7938607931137085,
-0.03579610586166382,
-0.9222171306610107,
-0.3277812600135803,
-0.60248202085495,
0.1067042425274849,
-0.3845365345478058,
-0.05068856105208397,
-0.35806187987327576,
-0.050791069865226746,
0.18136870861053467,
0.36957117915153503,
0.01570010557770729,
0.8953932523727417,
-0.6489779353141785,
0.4913690388202667,
0.42219245433807373,
0.2852476239204407,
-0.2898540198802948,
-0.38222792744636536,
-0.35085785388946533,
0.011065618135035038,
0.0982634425163269,
-1.0705351829528809,
0.10169436782598495,
0.567064106464386,
1.1330493688583374,
0.6793873906135559,
-0.16148249804973602,
0.5826441049575806,
-0.4095071256160736,
0.5489975214004517,
-0.002916480414569378,
-1.147914171218872,
0.59739089012146,
-0.4572031795978546,
0.40511614084243774,
0.7835534811019897,
0.24930435419082642,
-0.8874169588088989,
-0.5912443399429321,
-0.7635668516159058,
-0.49793457984924316,
0.896517813205719,
0.14308761060237885,
-0.2643003463745117,
0.19116933643817902,
0.35915902256965637,
0.001191868563182652,
-0.08640454709529877,
-0.5073255300521851,
-0.36136436462402344,
-0.2869550585746765,
-0.25924021005630493,
-0.1764170378446579,
-0.07929414510726929,
-0.14752627909183502,
-0.16546334326267242,
0.6470120549201965,
-0.4174709916114807,
0.08931303024291992,
0.05976361408829689,
-0.3205132782459259,
0.12683998048305511,
0.01639747992157936,
0.2909547984600067,
0.6543310284614563,
-0.3286457359790802,
0.5640857219696045,
-0.08523532003164291,
-0.7011217474937439,
-0.2787940204143524,
0.17206613719463348,
-0.026631254702806473,
0.07405274361371994,
0.5019102692604065,
1.2900992631912231,
-0.2873508036136627,
-0.3870812952518463,
0.4002716839313507,
-0.03303694352507591,
-0.2659684717655182,
0.2680061459541321,
-0.1082136332988739,
0.3827838897705078,
0.35221001505851746,
0.006557362619787455,
-0.10055800527334213,
0.05935477465391159,
-0.5304079651832581,
0.3708670437335968,
0.17793096601963043,
-0.7603567242622375,
-0.475163996219635,
0.5840902924537659,
0.3119297921657562,
-0.43563559651374817,
0.5757295489311218,
-0.07652457058429718,
-0.5303812026977539,
0.7708766460418701,
0.5403482913970947,
0.6997179985046387,
-0.5423700213432312,
0.6067690849304199,
0.43449336290359497,
0.10120511800050735,
0.31921666860580444,
0.40522301197052,
0.014452412724494934,
-1.0719993114471436,
-0.5435934066772461,
-0.10407353937625885,
-0.4210006296634674,
0.26723524928092957,
-0.4559208154678345,
0.08747991174459457,
-0.35239043831825256,
-0.4134799540042877,
0.22853218019008636,
-0.10205554217100143,
-0.5650562644004822,
0.236748605966568,
0.22540271282196045,
0.48766812682151794,
-1.1001560688018799,
0.9426823258399963,
0.6346825361251831,
-0.4349398612976074,
-0.7251778244972229,
0.12517525255680084,
-0.016965558752417564,
-0.8299807906150818,
0.5531649589538574,
0.35986289381980896,
-0.5122441649436951,
0.27293744683265686,
-0.16394753754138947,
-0.7853559851646423,
0.7844169735908508,
0.641911506652832,
-0.6515753269195557,
0.17955411970615387,
-0.1401616930961609,
0.3166052997112274,
-0.6633855104446411,
0.29191118478775024,
0.9070277810096741,
0.7307857275009155,
-0.22013190388679504,
-0.883656919002533,
-0.21304085850715637,
-0.27305251359939575,
-0.2649194896221161,
-0.21567754447460175,
-0.8347105979919434,
1.2373368740081787,
-0.24606040120124817,
-0.43249666690826416,
-0.6075040698051453,
0.6441423296928406,
0.44774967432022095,
0.4069785475730896,
0.9026836156845093,
0.37436550855636597,
0.9500729441642761,
-0.008268334902822971,
0.579791247844696,
-0.24254556000232697,
0.3402385413646698,
1.6038572788238525,
-0.517789363861084,
0.3879084289073944,
0.2798486649990082,
-0.0974758043885231,
0.645894467830658,
0.7367209196090698,
0.47980183362960815,
0.4240436851978302,
0.1312849074602127,
-0.039396196603775024,
-0.5236772298812866,
-0.4284180998802185,
-0.24402402341365814,
0.4870711863040924,
0.48039600253105164,
-0.20574846863746643,
-0.17427793145179749,
0.1317598819732666,
0.2843410074710846,
0.27470457553863525,
0.01997854933142662,
0.7577281594276428,
-0.09485532343387604,
-0.610073983669281,
0.2331622689962387,
-0.18073877692222595,
0.2773047685623169,
-0.435655415058136,
0.18892906606197357,
-0.23822849988937378,
0.14114977419376373,
-0.2837710380554199,
-1.164844274520874,
0.4736228883266449,
-0.11269591748714447,
-0.06437543779611588,
-0.28344088792800903,
0.9725503325462341,
-0.47648856043815613,
-0.1471836268901825,
0.5654637217521667,
0.8574327230453491,
0.34662631154060364,
-0.22785967588424683,
-0.7996297478675842,
-0.04305543005466461,
-0.017729684710502625,
-0.36466559767723083,
-0.16487668454647064,
0.441723495721817,
-0.27069151401519775,
0.43766260147094727,
0.3187931478023529,
-0.11816015839576721,
-0.1781264841556549,
0.9766442775726318,
0.7833398580551147,
-0.10761791467666626,
-0.757618248462677,
-0.7866756916046143,
0.4121174216270447,
-0.4297582805156708,
-0.3538661301136017,
0.7699796557426453,
0.42200207710266113,
0.7116588950157166,
0.33870142698287964,
0.8587656021118164,
0.2616995573043823,
0.5983060002326965,
-0.13121452927589417,
0.6343770027160645,
-0.44401511549949646,
0.014231952838599682,
-0.22329799830913544,
-0.8946686387062073,
-0.46905526518821716,
0.7676413655281067,
-0.2780170440673828,
-0.10001525282859802,
0.557378351688385,
0.40991315245628357,
-0.04615357518196106,
0.08072354644536972,
0.15677422285079956,
0.07216434180736542,
0.4224075376987457,
0.5466495156288147,
0.6258635520935059,
-0.03112204372882843,
0.3194064497947693,
0.04394552856683731,
-0.24026909470558167,
-0.22685211896896362,
-0.5646485090255737,
-0.619286060333252,
-0.6027175784111023,
-0.4398249089717865,
-0.29032716155052185,
0.1322966068983078,
0.45281580090522766,
0.7490839958190918,
-0.6630060076713562,
-0.13465914130210876,
-0.014834820292890072,
0.26458680629730225,
-0.47352316975593567,
-0.18374642729759216,
0.6682441234588623,
-0.3802577555179596,
-0.6546499133110046,
0.48804885149002075,
0.3610096275806427,
-0.3700161278247833,
-0.48614421486854553,
-0.3663628399372101,
-0.519766628742218,
0.0060223545879125595,
0.4709557592868805,
0.24930182099342346,
-0.7872011065483093,
-0.4547187387943268,
0.09054021537303925,
-0.11539536714553833,
0.2272728979587555,
0.7442722916603088,
-0.6386541724205017,
0.4817636013031006,
0.7534701228141785,
0.6928665041923523,
0.3927236795425415,
0.16507776081562042,
0.4046038091182709,
-1.1281875371932983,
0.15567174553871155,
0.2258155643939972,
0.46884670853614807,
0.35719308257102966,
-0.5787897706031799,
0.4448549747467041,
0.43801969289779663,
-0.33946356177330017,
-0.6502425670623779,
0.4481165111064911,
-1.0409443378448486,
-0.4037286639213562,
1.3178677558898926,
-0.4939526319503784,
-0.07282674312591553,
-0.3496321141719818,
-0.16683268547058105,
0.7388471364974976,
-0.24007748067378998,
-0.058941878378391266,
0.5636515617370605,
-0.278460830450058,
-0.34792065620422363,
-0.6938395500183105,
0.2262118011713028,
0.34399470686912537,
-1.1602543592453003,
0.31665730476379395,
0.2778594195842743,
-0.07163549214601517,
0.26690131425857544,
0.9902307391166687,
0.11970464885234833,
0.018727917224168777,
-0.12420289218425751,
-0.1034100353717804,
-0.19465406239032745,
-0.7806130051612854,
0.11308267712593079,
0.07490511983633041,
-0.2832834720611572,
-0.5150640606880188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03898v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03898v2 | DistiLLM: Towards Streamlined Distillation for Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T11:10:35 | 2024-07-03T04:57:41 | Jongwoo Ko, Sungnyun Kim, Tianyi Chen, Se-Young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Knowledge distillation (KD) is widely used for compressing a teacher model to
a smaller student model, reducing its inference cost and memory footprint while
preserving model capabilities. However, current KD methods for auto-regressive
sequence models (e.g., large language models) suffer from missing a
standardized objective function. Moreover, the recent use of student-generated
outputs to address training-inference mismatches has significantly escalated
computational costs. To tackle these issues, we introduce DistiLLM, a more
effective and efficient KD framework for auto-regressive language models.
DistiLLM comprises two components: (1) a novel skew Kullback-Leibler divergence
loss, where we unveil and leverage its theoretical properties, and (2) an
adaptive off-policy approach designed to enhance the efficiency in utilizing
student-generated outputs. Extensive experiments, including
instruction-following tasks, demonstrate the effectiveness of DistiLLM in
building high-performing student models while achieving up to 4.3$\times$
speedup compared to recent KD methods. | [
-0.24065962433815002,
-0.6878266334533691,
0.5650571584701538,
0.07298730313777924,
-0.11777041107416153,
0.4173232913017273,
-0.4457714855670929,
0.29521411657333374,
-0.24489378929138184,
0.4128299653530121,
-0.23691047728061676,
-0.3544895350933075,
-0.7924202084541321,
-0.1992524415254593,
-0.5025566220283508,
0.8581171035766602,
0.05525980889797211,
0.04428359493613243,
-0.33984071016311646,
-0.031185006722807884,
-0.43431341648101807,
-0.4426782727241516,
-0.5116540789604187,
-0.6024656295776367,
0.38034501671791077,
0.46793195605278015,
0.532229483127594,
0.6323158740997314,
0.2325979322195053,
0.32124507427215576,
-0.21307669579982758,
-0.09571196883916855,
-0.6472037434577942,
0.4276541769504547,
-0.1410527527332306,
-0.6295598745346069,
-0.13732200860977173,
0.04438214749097824,
0.4817851483821869,
0.9803690910339355,
-0.5930442214012146,
0.021719787269830704,
0.4231840968132019,
1.170198678970337,
-0.8371204733848572,
0.34546974301338196,
-0.47836172580718994,
-0.1572640836238861,
0.1506698727607727,
0.23373886942863464,
-0.5906607508659363,
-0.6222888231277466,
0.42601633071899414,
-0.35057228803634644,
0.08847251534461975,
-0.3084452450275421,
0.5877605676651001,
0.5549612045288086,
-0.4169296324253082,
-0.39841875433921814,
-1.0136961936950684,
0.6531043648719788,
-0.993216872215271,
0.45894855260849,
0.30075162649154663,
0.5044471025466919,
-0.3201664388179779,
-0.8544229865074158,
-0.5826486349105835,
0.041682060807943344,
-0.005631773266941309,
0.058524828404188156,
-0.14018245041370392,
0.08340227603912354,
0.03619203716516495,
0.5670139193534851,
-0.35186293721199036,
0.0883026272058487,
-0.3217394948005676,
0.2046632021665573,
0.5907627940177917,
0.11101842671632767,
-0.13429205119609833,
0.27490079402923584,
-0.14786699414253235,
-0.5386220812797546,
-0.4763537645339966,
-0.15665005147457123,
0.5268394351005554,
0.21467947959899902,
0.06422881782054901,
0.19368451833724976,
-0.28458771109580994,
0.612646758556366,
0.23678161203861237,
-0.4707408547401428,
-0.040044937282800674,
-0.06256156414747238,
-0.26395800709724426,
0.20498204231262207,
0.6170477271080017,
0.19132420420646667,
0.2153804898262024,
0.055334560573101044,
0.014704213477671146,
-0.11008718609809875,
-0.01750124990940094,
-1.0872910022735596,
-1.0234638452529907,
-0.004533775616437197,
-0.29021987318992615,
-0.5012152194976807,
-0.19941829144954681,
-0.7523945569992065,
-0.2583836317062378,
-0.4638538062572479,
0.38644224405288696,
-0.39935627579689026,
-0.46824127435684204,
0.2560664713382721,
-0.25992175936698914,
-0.13479898869991302,
0.241349995136261,
-0.7026126980781555,
0.34832116961479187,
0.4136813282966614,
0.8927321434020996,
-0.2303033322095871,
-0.12317553162574768,
-0.3322717547416687,
-0.007353144232183695,
-0.44624826312065125,
0.21302530169487,
-0.41155746579170227,
-0.4904687702655792,
-0.14091157913208008,
-0.22181867063045502,
0.16877026855945587,
-0.5892626047134399,
0.1646854132413864,
-0.5373709201812744,
0.34820985794067383,
-0.16485907137393951,
-0.8562073707580566,
-0.32024648785591125,
-0.03408074378967285,
-0.6281405687332153,
1.2347984313964844,
0.27697107195854187,
-0.5436860918998718,
0.5317671298980713,
-0.44829437136650085,
-0.46644702553749084,
-0.01239932794123888,
0.12521445751190186,
-0.48853799700737,
0.34022876620292664,
0.05858873203396797,
0.5485387444496155,
-0.4555113613605499,
0.662490725517273,
-0.4198744595050812,
0.023133566603064537,
-0.13183218240737915,
-0.5189735293388367,
0.9234147071838379,
0.3512125313282013,
-0.2325693964958191,
-0.45306581258773804,
-0.9291709065437317,
-0.10776455700397491,
0.07748062908649445,
-0.5455347299575806,
-0.9516446590423584,
0.1261480301618576,
-0.15953460335731506,
0.07516305148601532,
0.031527016311883926,
-0.18794311583042145,
0.5484590530395508,
-0.21411678194999695,
0.5314729809761047,
0.7211362719535828,
-0.23169800639152527,
0.7491857409477234,
0.024213548749685287,
0.4372648596763611,
0.17149430513381958,
0.012470884248614311,
-0.36175546050071716,
-0.19276218116283417,
-0.757209837436676,
-0.6134944558143616,
0.45287951827049255,
0.2038053423166275,
-0.8396376371383667,
0.3854880630970001,
-0.10467538982629776,
-0.829164445400238,
-0.4907696545124054,
0.3062039017677307,
0.24684184789657593,
0.7763527631759644,
0.31510475277900696,
-0.14527574181556702,
-0.32738837599754333,
-0.5665474534034729,
-0.1781080812215805,
-0.5232195854187012,
0.15311004221439362,
-0.026131028309464455,
0.25333452224731445,
-0.10080533474683762,
1.241637945175171,
-1.0107403993606567,
-0.16000640392303467,
-0.23045307397842407,
0.46968600153923035,
0.2429165542125702,
0.4044528901576996,
0.545279324054718,
-0.5285854935646057,
-1.0040156841278076,
-0.13653698563575745,
-0.40007203817367554,
-0.5107857584953308,
-0.0725141391158104,
-0.0553692989051342,
0.43099015951156616,
0.5073856115341187,
-0.55569988489151,
0.29356858134269714,
0.39611780643463135,
-0.30144599080085754,
0.5972108840942383,
-0.36732736229896545,
0.0026784383226186037,
-1.199051022529602,
-0.041185952723026276,
-0.09748035669326782,
-0.3802542984485626,
-0.5833000540733337,
-0.15227867662906647,
0.17123045027256012,
0.14346463978290558,
-0.17526808381080627,
0.3418648838996887,
-0.5752578973770142,
0.21853305399417877,
-0.4712950587272644,
-0.07235362380743027,
0.3520660698413849,
0.31936660408973694,
0.003034883877262473,
0.4088972806930542,
0.663443922996521,
-0.6668429970741272,
0.46546539664268494,
-0.16913923621177673,
-0.29550549387931824,
0.5281183123588562,
-0.5815356373786926,
-0.05105999484658241,
-0.29224321246147156,
0.22338570654392242,
-1.0785152912139893,
-0.03280629590153694,
-0.15206705033779144,
-0.09381269663572311,
0.6782076358795166,
-0.3896501660346985,
-0.3642515540122986,
-0.4473634958267212,
-0.1266816407442093,
0.3038957118988037,
1.008575201034546,
-0.7502267360687256,
0.7767658233642578,
0.1999368816614151,
-0.29782548546791077,
-0.4595906436443329,
-0.6434775590896606,
-0.02131243422627449,
-0.5558291077613831,
-0.25687551498413086,
0.169945627450943,
-0.10739511996507645,
-0.3228781223297119,
0.07619952410459518,
-0.18007014691829681,
-0.2796005606651306,
0.31769680976867676,
-0.03137623518705368,
0.36407560110092163,
-0.19942399859428406,
0.25740426778793335,
0.2959091067314148,
0.08476881682872772,
0.02053397335112095,
-0.49687716364860535,
0.5407098531723022,
0.25768470764160156,
-0.18811289966106415,
-0.3461982011795044,
0.12192852795124054,
0.7712849378585815,
0.13027802109718323,
0.6335341334342957,
0.3657435476779938,
-0.15697555243968964,
-0.6313672065734863,
-0.6234668493270874,
-0.38114723563194275,
-0.509753942489624,
0.5620865821838379,
-0.19971026480197906,
-0.740173876285553,
0.3736205995082855,
-0.385685533285141,
0.09294788539409637,
0.2555329203605652,
0.7377964854240417,
0.03776821121573448,
0.8938652873039246,
0.7081575989723206,
-0.40661174058914185,
0.26855701208114624,
-0.3245832920074463,
0.4373600482940674,
-0.2020644098520279,
-0.14689581096172333,
-0.5735368728637695,
-0.3070686459541321,
-0.3071751296520233,
-0.4412532448768616,
0.11456061154603958,
0.6780780553817749,
-0.04005605727434158,
0.3836651146411896,
-0.48682841658592224,
0.6392549872398376,
0.6635213494300842,
-0.45348361134529114,
0.5489680171012878,
-0.10274107754230499,
-0.15424790978431702,
0.08445187658071518,
-1.0663161277770996,
-0.39812570810317993,
1.1780356168746948,
0.4168713092803955,
1.287929892539978,
0.028510771691799164,
0.8984152674674988,
0.2851484417915344,
0.35258427262306213,
-0.7705460786819458,
0.3135946989059448,
-0.2376381903886795,
-0.33444496989250183,
-0.37016814947128296,
-0.5464234352111816,
-0.4778943657875061,
0.2909461557865143,
0.14487813413143158,
-0.37221428751945496,
0.27217647433280945,
0.5495897531509399,
-0.36122751235961914,
0.32047945261001587,
-0.9375965595245361,
0.6725903749465942,
0.027968958020210266,
-0.1776442527770996,
-0.1370943933725357,
-0.3945104479789734,
0.5100053548812866,
-0.37585997581481934,
0.1250791698694229,
-0.09521488845348358,
0.2309183031320572,
0.5045992732048035,
-0.8111390471458435,
0.6903457045555115,
-0.5402697920799255,
-0.33366525173187256,
0.41946282982826233,
0.24332168698310852,
0.4836488664150238,
0.04086730256676674,
0.20895612239837646,
0.09141512960195541,
0.19102227687835693,
-0.10555124282836914,
-0.7781594395637512,
0.8491370677947998,
-0.5843793749809265,
-0.5790956616401672,
-0.3275711238384247,
-0.7282319664955139,
-0.02199876680970192,
-0.001975482562556863,
0.07637886703014374,
0.24598582088947296,
-0.05062379688024521,
0.20074231922626495,
0.7338111400604248,
-0.1638670265674591,
0.7258298397064209,
0.7302232980728149,
-0.3325108289718628,
-0.1975335031747818,
0.858548104763031,
0.2995098829269409,
0.6237921714782715,
-0.06063319370150566,
0.43678849935531616,
-0.5151435732841492,
-0.2777644395828247,
-0.40619760751724243,
-0.13226215541362762,
-0.6480845212936401,
-0.3240374028682709,
-0.5896938443183899,
-0.0879233255982399,
-0.6787573099136353,
-0.0054001109674572945,
-0.7699795365333557,
-0.558777928352356,
-0.3398591876029968,
0.015652386471629143,
0.5316387414932251,
0.5475472807884216,
-0.1832202970981598,
0.3831340968608856,
-0.5012996792793274,
0.16277793049812317,
0.43636706471443176,
0.22718849778175354,
0.21210159361362457,
-0.6552857756614685,
-0.24988558888435364,
0.09366120398044586,
-0.44117021560668945,
-0.6334435343742371,
0.553081214427948,
0.7588131427764893,
0.31353339552879333,
0.5499237775802612,
0.546507716178894,
0.7633706331253052,
-0.6812544465065002,
0.6411800980567932,
0.3803926408290863,
-0.7425867915153503,
0.36661097407341003,
0.27231496572494507,
0.6102904081344604,
0.5521574020385742,
0.6330040693283081,
-0.499288409948349,
-0.6713581085205078,
-0.3279849588871002,
-1.0003916025161743,
0.5935638546943665,
-0.11820729821920395,
0.14783109724521637,
-0.10865797102451324,
0.26124894618988037,
0.3258141577243805,
0.0805482417345047,
-0.38551977276802063,
-0.4514232575893402,
-0.15515118837356567,
-0.5617848634719849,
-0.06322162598371506,
-0.245000958442688,
0.17436423897743225,
-0.3613138198852539,
0.9764349460601807,
-0.1444142758846283,
-0.4852592647075653,
0.16816124320030212,
-0.22523559629917145,
0.32458263635635376,
0.17729713022708893,
0.10303613543510437,
0.34549200534820557,
-0.01204146072268486,
0.3718162178993225,
-0.007653358392417431,
-0.6835287809371948,
0.5565909743309021,
0.24939534068107605,
-0.1712893843650818,
0.19724678993225098,
0.02759627252817154,
0.5704384446144104,
-0.012665589340031147,
-0.6501677632331848,
0.4030241370201111,
-0.09912251681089401,
-0.4518488943576813,
-0.10196468979120255,
0.25713181495666504,
0.3162696659564972,
0.5228601694107056,
0.5861045718193054,
-0.289851576089859,
0.3413797914981842,
-0.3740083873271942,
0.20801036059856415,
0.11361388117074966,
-0.37234681844711304,
-0.15665003657341003,
0.714958131313324,
0.03877115622162819,
-0.042457107454538345,
0.579656183719635,
-0.16470767557621002,
-0.43766000866889954,
0.4279409348964691,
0.3284265995025635,
0.9328877329826355,
-0.528633177280426,
0.2688734531402588,
0.29852294921875,
-0.0541018508374691,
-0.5510978102684021,
0.04654544219374657,
-0.1273265779018402,
-0.4450308084487915,
-0.5866050124168396,
-0.8439103960990906,
-0.03561457246541977,
0.13573862612247467,
-0.8161869049072266,
0.20627976953983307,
-0.18006578087806702,
-0.19325242936611176,
0.11069834977388382,
-0.27427294850349426,
-0.35217881202697754,
-0.12602879106998444,
-0.05008549243211746,
0.7665461301803589,
-0.9836283922195435,
1.076062798500061,
0.38821303844451904,
-0.07109526544809341,
-0.8039966225624084,
-0.21002933382987976,
-0.019351990893483162,
-0.22322233021259308,
0.8786134719848633,
-0.1295997053384781,
0.03278997167944908,
0.1719723343849182,
-0.32309532165527344,
-0.6514813303947449,
1.056165099143982,
0.5681240558624268,
-1.0865769386291504,
-0.09504502266645432,
0.3124798834323883,
0.37958309054374695,
-0.2060360312461853,
0.05541643127799034,
0.9612210392951965,
0.08979421108961105,
0.26246628165245056,
-0.7316553592681885,
-0.2150358408689499,
0.1236119195818901,
0.3176485300064087,
0.4271509647369385,
-0.37992313504219055,
0.8076401352882385,
-0.13685844838619232,
-0.18615001440048218,
-0.254347562789917,
0.6158339977264404,
0.009381807409226894,
0.17515990138053894,
0.5388131141662598,
0.9117822647094727,
0.7216091752052307,
-0.19323909282684326,
0.46975770592689514,
-0.5441573262214661,
0.596427321434021,
1.5831801891326904,
-0.4219943583011627,
0.5597048997879028,
0.7464185953140259,
-0.3247049152851105,
0.341921329498291,
0.33448439836502075,
0.1617547571659088,
0.9252046942710876,
0.4184163212776184,
-0.33445462584495544,
-0.11898376047611237,
0.2620021402835846,
-0.17619012296199799,
0.3897811770439148,
0.002685570390895009,
-0.3744201958179474,
-0.461933434009552,
0.2625696361064911,
0.11705878376960754,
0.31715935468673706,
-0.14185312390327454,
0.9277341365814209,
0.15646496415138245,
-0.6898043751716614,
0.7727317214012146,
-0.06237213313579559,
0.5813669562339783,
-0.34095117449760437,
-0.14007388055324554,
-0.44431930780410767,
0.39905160665512085,
0.11634976416826248,
-0.38828861713409424,
0.36310333013534546,
-0.043574411422014236,
-0.3676697909832001,
-0.33228135108947754,
0.6864435076713562,
-1.1078901290893555,
-0.5747845768928528,
0.19374462962150574,
0.3259631097316742,
0.03404208645224571,
0.005786101799458265,
-0.5028429627418518,
-0.1209944561123848,
-0.13050229847431183,
-0.33625683188438416,
0.12714101374149323,
0.5715513229370117,
0.14695507287979126,
0.7154943346977234,
0.41329365968704224,
0.08587648719549179,
0.2340729832649231,
0.15975907444953918,
0.9538574814796448,
-0.12552380561828613,
-0.39426955580711365,
-1.241411805152893,
0.4807611107826233,
-0.09553823620080948,
-0.07858096063137054,
0.6780691742897034,
0.6337254643440247,
0.9694779515266418,
-0.09745951741933823,
0.8225868344306946,
-0.1510099321603775,
0.4972537159919739,
-0.30505576729774475,
1.0531343221664429,
-0.4619152843952179,
0.2460969239473343,
-0.33067822456359863,
-0.9947875142097473,
0.057898394763469696,
0.5753516554832458,
-0.028073463588953018,
-0.11962027102708817,
0.4270159900188446,
0.6687735319137573,
-0.08336839824914932,
-0.21377623081207275,
0.35080018639564514,
0.34359708428382874,
0.392869234085083,
0.3579581081867218,
0.631898820400238,
-0.404175728559494,
0.3860776126384735,
-0.5203596353530884,
-0.23605050146579742,
-0.19012662768363953,
-1.0561766624450684,
-0.9148427248001099,
-0.699562132358551,
-0.8044598698616028,
-0.2115945965051651,
0.0372886061668396,
0.7517485022544861,
0.7760100364685059,
-0.5714068412780762,
-0.26771730184555054,
-0.3286503553390503,
-0.0572115033864975,
-0.09251227974891663,
-0.27842462062835693,
0.37646862864494324,
-0.6473106741905212,
-0.8818937540054321,
0.1189047247171402,
0.19641491770744324,
0.13565944135189056,
-0.5773893594741821,
-0.31595396995544434,
-0.17737288773059845,
0.13190867006778717,
0.5970447659492493,
0.027731655165553093,
-0.485211580991745,
0.06446469575166702,
-0.1844015270471573,
-0.02681592106819153,
-0.17697662115097046,
0.6439778208732605,
-0.8226186633110046,
0.636825442314148,
0.48450616002082825,
0.7039289474487305,
0.6188507676124573,
-0.15731389820575714,
0.7943319082260132,
-0.6468713283538818,
0.08872544765472412,
0.1961909979581833,
0.18145620822906494,
0.1819935142993927,
-0.16619080305099487,
0.39807766675949097,
0.25254273414611816,
-0.5321070551872253,
-1.1209172010421753,
-0.00041822210187092423,
-0.4340134859085083,
-0.5418557524681091,
0.9775000810623169,
-0.5366069078445435,
-0.15919949114322662,
-0.09474389255046844,
-0.12118737399578094,
0.31013768911361694,
-0.4097944498062134,
1.059593677520752,
0.9723665714263916,
0.3174804747104645,
-0.10618297010660172,
-0.3195006847381592,
0.7155184745788574,
0.33257266879081726,
-0.5264755487442017,
0.42218658328056335,
0.6162770986557007,
0.37827685475349426,
-0.07960279285907745,
0.39193594455718994,
-0.043738044798374176,
-0.03054460510611534,
-0.0997147187590599,
0.22343215346336365,
-0.14688600599765778,
-0.45879384875297546,
-0.29567548632621765,
-0.04013461992144585,
0.18355345726013184,
-0.014220708049833775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03887v1 | Shifting social norms as a driving force for linguistic change: Struggles about language and gender in the German Bundestag | 2024-02-06T10:49:28 | 2024-02-06T10:49:28 | Carolin Müller-Spitzer, Samira Ochs | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper focuses on language change based on shifting social norms, in
particular with regard to the debate on language and gender. It is a recurring
argument in this debate that language develops "naturally" and that "severe
interventions" - such as gender-inclusive language is often claimed to be - in
the allegedly "organic" language system are inappropriate and even "dangerous".
Such interventions are, however, not unprecedented. Socially motivated
processes of language change are neither unusual nor new. We focus in our
contribution on one important political-social space in Germany, the German
Bundestag. Taking other struggles about language and gender in the plenaries of
the Bundestag as a starting point, our article illustrates that language and
gender has been a recurring issue in the German Bundestag since the 1980s. We
demonstrate how this is reflected in linguistic practices of the Bundestag, by
the use of a) designations for gays and lesbians; b) pair forms such as
B\"urgerinnen und B\"urger (female and male citizens); and c) female forms of
addresses and personal nouns ('Pr\"asidentin' in addition to 'Pr\"asident').
Lastly, we will discuss implications of these earlier language battles for the
currently very heated debate about gender-inclusive language, especially
regarding new forms with gender symbols like the asterisk or the colon
(Lehrer*innen, Lehrer:innen; male*female teachers) which are intended to
encompass all gender identities. | [
-0.306613028049469,
-1.0472015142440796,
0.26489415764808655,
0.24704395234584808,
-0.036856092512607574,
0.1516583412885666,
-0.5028402209281921,
-0.2517530620098114,
-0.01198311522603035,
0.4568621814250946,
-0.4228525161743164,
-0.10091760754585266,
-1.0626460313796997,
0.4505499303340912,
-0.549445629119873,
0.850985050201416,
-0.19482164084911346,
0.054984819144010544,
0.09068096429109573,
-0.2814066410064697,
-0.5144044756889343,
-0.5786537528038025,
-0.6823093891143799,
-0.2567073702812195,
0.6124029755592346,
0.01825372315943241,
0.5931692123413086,
0.541894257068634,
0.41627585887908936,
0.4508945643901825,
-0.616662859916687,
-0.17820905148983002,
-0.412723571062088,
0.41296085715293884,
-0.25292083621025085,
-0.20887255668640137,
-0.1759488880634308,
-0.035698678344488144,
0.8469421863555908,
0.8379167318344116,
-0.01582985930144787,
0.2130945920944214,
0.059815216809511185,
1.0240217447280884,
-0.17002831399440765,
0.2596447467803955,
-0.5004660487174988,
-0.13547223806381226,
-0.7372869253158569,
0.15735557675361633,
0.07385550439357758,
-0.4734991788864136,
-0.04721270874142647,
-0.021420340985059738,
0.19588810205459595,
-0.19521108269691467,
0.9127033948898315,
-0.07087493687868118,
-0.9306882619857788,
-0.3937265872955322,
-0.5828496813774109,
0.4732147455215454,
-0.3066102862358093,
0.8824193477630615,
0.0756920650601387,
0.13260233402252197,
-0.3128538727760315,
-0.3617163598537445,
-0.28774595260620117,
-0.07097284495830536,
0.1698310673236847,
-0.21118901669979095,
-0.6018065214157104,
-0.3698806166648865,
0.30274322628974915,
0.10524126142263412,
-0.27425310015678406,
0.05804123729467392,
-0.7811697721481323,
0.23409469425678253,
0.5709209442138672,
0.016763649880886078,
0.25548118352890015,
-0.2729873061180115,
-0.16895702481269836,
0.12568342685699463,
-0.6383655071258545,
0.3336527347564697,
0.829811692237854,
0.6429293155670166,
-0.0817323550581932,
0.36102601885795593,
-0.06572890281677246,
0.13804832100868225,
0.31265583634376526,
0.2586139440536499,
0.3510679006576538,
-0.25025004148483276,
0.050888631492853165,
-0.07390040904283524,
0.4462244510650635,
0.3277299106121063,
0.5120899677276611,
0.01368429884314537,
-0.2670534551143646,
0.3894384205341339,
0.3703441023826599,
-0.43122223019599915,
-0.18055810034275055,
-0.08464713394641876,
-0.30457252264022827,
-0.2590967118740082,
0.2986837923526764,
-0.6293479204177856,
-0.32496753334999084,
-0.1397305727005005,
-0.2211793065071106,
-0.28125786781311035,
-0.37196168303489685,
0.3463295102119446,
-0.44810178875923157,
0.39371171593666077,
0.399442195892334,
-1.0911163091659546,
0.39653724431991577,
0.7852654457092285,
0.30994468927383423,
0.2626086175441742,
-0.07576891779899597,
-0.2112119346857071,
-0.0551554411649704,
-0.5164715647697449,
0.6847056150436401,
-0.7340276837348938,
-0.6215574145317078,
0.3556663691997528,
0.48900431394577026,
0.041463956236839294,
-0.469351589679718,
0.41368377208709717,
-0.28311386704444885,
0.13691355288028717,
-0.29627135396003723,
-0.3715323507785797,
-0.05405116081237793,
-0.20892715454101562,
-0.5335469245910645,
1.1707088947296143,
-0.22594894468784332,
-0.32784631848335266,
0.6079517006874084,
-0.7052684426307678,
-0.654090404510498,
0.2848226726055145,
-0.2599714696407318,
-0.3563865125179291,
0.3423037528991699,
-0.3534836769104004,
0.10285434871912003,
-0.26148489117622375,
0.2416948825120926,
-0.09554936736822128,
0.019509561359882355,
0.46022331714630127,
-0.20769564807415009,
1.0554487705230713,
-0.3576245903968811,
-0.5166994333267212,
0.20630675554275513,
-0.2943975031375885,
-0.5318515300750732,
0.46293073892593384,
-0.2544797658920288,
-0.3683258891105652,
-0.0027053598314523697,
0.1308194249868393,
0.1602129489183426,
0.030605899170041084,
-0.5349831581115723,
-0.1259177327156067,
-0.01312860008329153,
0.3544829487800598,
1.1080912351608276,
-0.0979907438158989,
0.7374541163444519,
-0.2710529863834381,
0.4523293972015381,
-0.16575536131858826,
0.38025760650634766,
0.32222259044647217,
-0.564981997013092,
-0.5587927103042603,
0.20465241372585297,
0.42283234000205994,
0.368667870759964,
-0.09210681915283203,
0.609458327293396,
-0.006609576754271984,
-0.40198612213134766,
-0.5582582354545593,
0.365000456571579,
0.16724763810634613,
0.04693328216671944,
-0.00953577272593975,
-0.31966084241867065,
-0.6658920645713806,
-0.941218912601471,
-0.425941526889801,
-0.433668315410614,
0.3264572322368622,
0.23960675299167633,
0.5940176248550415,
-0.452860563993454,
0.5210325717926025,
-0.5227648615837097,
-0.4109083116054535,
-0.21096086502075195,
0.23447121679782867,
0.010118077509105206,
0.3362564742565155,
0.6281659007072449,
-0.9835458397865295,
-0.408934086561203,
-0.09662578999996185,
-0.3631967306137085,
-0.46334412693977356,
0.3375103771686554,
-0.17062179744243622,
0.5177842378616333,
0.7542697787284851,
-0.2546517550945282,
0.27237623929977417,
0.6490059494972229,
-0.7495096921920776,
0.5366011261940002,
-0.04873716086149216,
0.001620464026927948,
-0.6519399881362915,
-0.18291045725345612,
0.043268878012895584,
-0.25902923941612244,
-0.8097034096717834,
-0.09077322483062744,
-0.04197433218359947,
0.27378562092781067,
-0.5850213170051575,
0.7736149430274963,
-0.437463641166687,
0.4291333556175232,
-0.20616017282009125,
-0.01361116860061884,
-0.268974244594574,
-0.052289459854364395,
-0.07472293078899384,
0.35514387488365173,
0.5887497663497925,
-0.5338386297225952,
0.3173285126686096,
0.37458568811416626,
-0.00373715627938509,
0.5855692625045776,
-0.29746681451797485,
0.28718656301498413,
-0.5415487885475159,
0.3172916769981384,
-0.8188095688819885,
-0.19332867860794067,
0.5078175067901611,
-0.1285039484500885,
-0.03359513729810715,
0.019291000440716743,
-0.6224190592765808,
-0.3356873095035553,
-0.15431466698646545,
0.16371461749076843,
0.5593488812446594,
-0.05456123873591423,
0.271167129278183,
0.808411180973053,
-0.30932748317718506,
-0.14310237765312195,
-0.41624733805656433,
0.21126599609851837,
-0.3520137071609497,
-0.5473997592926025,
0.015772070735692978,
0.0032896259799599648,
-0.6582282781600952,
0.03429827466607094,
-0.14373627305030823,
-0.08806481957435608,
0.3258509039878845,
0.2833973467350006,
-0.07693475484848022,
-0.14691364765167236,
0.3076254427433014,
0.438644140958786,
-0.19544704258441925,
0.005607168190181255,
-0.04002019762992859,
0.6636336445808411,
-0.6388916969299316,
0.11797697097063065,
-0.09903232753276825,
0.8322148323059082,
0.03078961744904518,
-0.15593960881233215,
0.6554360389709473,
0.5398730039596558,
-0.4621511697769165,
0.05830759182572365,
-0.41077372431755066,
-0.4478819668292999,
-0.4546946883201599,
0.2339811772108078,
-0.321442186832428,
-1.1926451921463013,
0.411472886800766,
-0.12409655749797821,
0.008947095833718777,
0.5063464641571045,
0.5389860272407532,
-0.4483036696910858,
0.7142529487609863,
0.8454226851463318,
0.48787155747413635,
0.6598344445228577,
0.401876300573349,
0.21298003196716309,
-0.5283273458480835,
0.13414070010185242,
-0.804831862449646,
-0.10508065670728683,
-0.8226755857467651,
-0.2736893594264984,
0.1410703957080841,
-0.09715691208839417,
-0.18697986006736755,
0.4719177186489105,
-0.1835363507270813,
-0.025189856067299843,
0.08840959519147873,
-0.23682308197021484,
0.13278214633464813,
-0.28857454657554626,
0.4215095639228821,
-0.310777485370636,
-0.5169788002967834,
-0.8190619945526123,
0.6393371224403381,
0.47529587149620056,
0.4493231773376465,
0.44842445850372314,
0.6314042806625366,
0.38371628522872925,
0.2964326739311218,
-0.2573750615119934,
0.6631392240524292,
-0.406663179397583,
-1.0194122791290283,
-0.2852390706539154,
-0.2507503926753998,
-1.196804165840149,
0.09397032111883163,
-0.002218660432845354,
-0.752373218536377,
0.4010946452617645,
0.008570733480155468,
0.16203820705413818,
0.22525988519191742,
-0.3846203088760376,
0.8267138600349426,
-0.13707074522972107,
-0.05137024447321892,
0.020854054018855095,
-0.591237485408783,
0.07586534321308136,
-0.08547858148813248,
0.41516610980033875,
-0.47883185744285583,
-0.01632436364889145,
0.8916559219360352,
-0.08777520060539246,
1.0666429996490479,
0.09978004544973373,
-0.6031538248062134,
-0.11529534310102463,
0.07102784514427185,
0.3144710958003998,
0.009939586743712425,
0.19530744850635529,
0.4129127860069275,
-0.247854083776474,
-0.24223186075687408,
-0.323486328125,
0.3123973309993744,
-0.5033494830131531,
-0.9285475015640259,
-0.41944387555122375,
-0.42098817229270935,
0.23374134302139282,
0.2544343173503876,
-0.08026129752397537,
0.4903939664363861,
-0.358257532119751,
0.2589915096759796,
0.585617184638977,
0.027981644496321678,
0.12059570103883743,
0.31846848130226135,
-0.44475820660591125,
-0.09851192682981491,
0.5399922132492065,
0.43311163783073425,
0.40309253334999084,
-0.15606945753097534,
0.22648321092128754,
-0.4401034116744995,
0.1661602109670639,
-0.3307410180568695,
0.3013715147972107,
-0.5811744332313538,
0.1219693049788475,
-0.7284020781517029,
-0.09972744435071945,
-0.7000540494918823,
-0.5550115704536438,
-0.43104088306427,
-0.11386425793170929,
-0.057301778346300125,
0.09754028171300888,
0.3465697765350342,
0.6494888663291931,
-0.22472819685935974,
0.248165100812912,
-0.4071328938007355,
0.10810224711894989,
0.17110072076320648,
0.28218162059783936,
-0.6032506227493286,
-0.47351929545402527,
0.2619151473045349,
-0.23296485841274261,
-0.06067841500043869,
-1.310824990272522,
-0.02155216597020626,
-0.06510388106107712,
0.31385287642478943,
0.27625739574432373,
0.15501166880130768,
0.30575278401374817,
-0.5988585352897644,
0.5101503729820251,
0.06850402802228928,
-1.0074818134307861,
0.330050528049469,
-0.4660324156284332,
0.2544662654399872,
0.21140097081661224,
-0.028154389932751656,
-1.2512718439102173,
-0.9317643642425537,
-1.057580590248108,
-1.0880048274993896,
0.5699660181999207,
0.15378215909004211,
0.8039170503616333,
-0.16323937475681305,
0.2114212065935135,
0.38413411378860474,
0.5238335728645325,
-0.7937856912612915,
-0.4657517969608307,
0.0878792479634285,
0.2570958435535431,
0.08751936256885529,
-0.20716287195682526,
-0.415046751499176,
-0.5113674998283386,
0.5302826762199402,
0.03603692725300789,
0.3450000286102295,
-0.0789043977856636,
-0.04532453417778015,
-0.20686066150665283,
0.6282985210418701,
0.3819292187690735,
0.6208958625793457,
0.12950830161571503,
0.4147765040397644,
0.15053807199001312,
-0.2835296094417572,
0.3574499785900116,
0.00451779505237937,
-0.3190348744392395,
0.18414455652236938,
-0.07488030195236206,
1.056315302848816,
0.49021390080451965,
-0.2074805200099945,
0.2965661883354187,
0.07801681011915207,
-0.3613923490047455,
-0.338642418384552,
0.018740428611636162,
0.15129345655441284,
0.3011951446533203,
0.1455630213022232,
0.11619863659143448,
-0.1994045078754425,
-0.644423246383667,
0.09719426184892654,
0.42757588624954224,
-0.6321896910667419,
-0.3748827576637268,
0.5253275036811829,
0.2297084629535675,
-0.7292736172676086,
0.12682457268238068,
-0.45285916328430176,
-0.7863645553588867,
0.24157501757144928,
0.7771868705749512,
0.8718716502189636,
-0.4536270797252655,
0.6705950498580933,
0.034561626613140106,
0.5725117921829224,
0.2907576858997345,
0.37715229392051697,
0.020095599815249443,
-0.873731791973114,
0.1937459409236908,
-0.27640265226364136,
-0.13203999400138855,
-0.181959867477417,
-0.390280157327652,
0.3184027373790741,
-0.49813559651374817,
-0.32308247685432434,
-0.047204937785863876,
-0.15956895053386688,
-0.37321946024894714,
-0.23929251730442047,
0.3946358263492584,
0.8585702180862427,
-1.058686375617981,
0.46781837940216064,
0.9223155975341797,
-0.11589866131544113,
-0.05667473375797272,
0.1659233719110489,
0.31230396032333374,
-0.14273735880851746,
0.5360009670257568,
-0.05281490087509155,
-0.17094433307647705,
0.08746320009231567,
-0.410942405462265,
-0.5203021168708801,
0.29809117317199707,
0.37345048785209656,
-0.18558180332183838,
0.22420445084571838,
0.27482980489730835,
0.49628952145576477,
-0.10445013642311096,
-0.2258366048336029,
0.6036076545715332,
0.9872643947601318,
-0.6174755096435547,
-0.7761279940605164,
0.2553909718990326,
-0.29140692949295044,
0.06582054495811462,
0.8419013023376465,
-0.7934504747390747,
0.8957948684692383,
0.25688880681991577,
-0.44936540722846985,
-0.28482675552368164,
0.6783210635185242,
-0.08031047880649567,
-0.19984711706638336,
0.7636290192604065,
-0.2077375203371048,
0.7607128620147705,
-0.41514852643013,
0.8576918840408325,
0.135624960064888,
0.07016347348690033,
0.23339998722076416,
-0.4550102949142456,
0.5176758766174316,
0.5702553987503052,
-0.20540961623191833,
0.3987051248550415,
0.25420552492141724,
-0.007189661264419556,
0.07760963588953018,
0.19814622402191162,
-0.29206666350364685,
-0.2200687825679779,
-0.1507890224456787,
-0.23927481472492218,
0.6689605712890625,
0.22230365872383118,
0.061555683612823486,
-0.638070821762085,
-0.03176882117986679,
0.43216225504875183,
0.25271305441856384,
0.061365436762571335,
0.6550775170326233,
0.15711355209350586,
-0.21995261311531067,
0.18228042125701904,
0.12883208692073822,
0.37566956877708435,
-0.6251850128173828,
0.2979145050048828,
-0.0027522698510438204,
0.02478971891105175,
-0.022173207253217697,
-0.853930652141571,
0.45170754194259644,
-0.022443700581789017,
-0.20405448973178864,
-0.6315670013427734,
0.7956362962722778,
-0.5156421065330505,
-0.4747728407382965,
0.5776493549346924,
0.7155659198760986,
0.15234695374965668,
0.2185613363981247,
-0.7405853271484375,
0.31909361481666565,
-0.25015774369239807,
0.09138169139623642,
0.30077072978019714,
0.41124337911605835,
-0.43279772996902466,
0.2673429250717163,
0.6523416638374329,
0.06781335920095444,
0.27050644159317017,
0.006230651400983334,
0.6348577737808228,
-0.5068528652191162,
-0.3923599421977997,
-0.6697214841842651,
0.548664927482605,
0.021090786904096603,
-0.5758748054504395,
0.7866818308830261,
0.32616499066352844,
0.6949113011360168,
0.03061749041080475,
0.6030387282371521,
-0.44819244742393494,
0.16192957758903503,
-0.19125832617282867,
0.890554666519165,
-0.389026403427124,
-0.4981381595134735,
-0.537341833114624,
-0.6638302206993103,
-0.34614768624305725,
0.5578963160514832,
-0.48802122473716736,
-0.02596851997077465,
0.5688543319702148,
0.5973604917526245,
0.03960435092449188,
0.323679655790329,
0.15249103307724,
0.3630622625350952,
0.33846813440322876,
-0.004358982667326927,
0.8592337369918823,
-0.3143840432167053,
0.25550389289855957,
-0.09925717860460281,
-0.3465609550476074,
-0.20485645532608032,
-0.651848316192627,
-0.46537160873413086,
-1.186489462852478,
-0.7674272656440735,
-0.5115566253662109,
0.4421905279159546,
1.1035220623016357,
0.30245301127433777,
-0.3228919208049774,
-0.6602573990821838,
-0.08567934483289719,
0.2471209615468979,
-0.3182961046695709,
-0.14263415336608887,
0.05406089499592781,
-0.3549019396305084,
-1.0024853944778442,
0.04309457913041115,
0.1783696860074997,
-0.1401209980249405,
-0.11555210500955582,
-0.0749332383275032,
-0.37255364656448364,
0.27770891785621643,
0.550126850605011,
0.4609734117984772,
-0.635667085647583,
-0.7121701240539551,
-0.13366065919399261,
-0.2888930141925812,
0.05103634297847748,
0.7111089825630188,
-0.34840744733810425,
0.16894878447055817,
0.35277101397514343,
0.29261812567710876,
0.024608418345451355,
-0.2651645541191101,
0.7917248606681824,
-0.6439229249954224,
0.26533129811286926,
0.03423884138464928,
0.22330006957054138,
0.3760969936847687,
-0.02951989136636257,
0.24796244502067566,
0.5169130563735962,
-0.4168117642402649,
-1.15099036693573,
0.40113598108291626,
-0.5344480872154236,
-0.09747421741485596,
1.4088220596313477,
0.5319929718971252,
-0.427175372838974,
-0.40573590993881226,
-0.3712798058986664,
0.37302160263061523,
-0.6120408773422241,
0.713640034198761,
0.8161410689353943,
-0.009004855528473854,
-0.28570231795310974,
-0.7199893593788147,
0.7497378587722778,
0.3731619417667389,
-0.42540431022644043,
0.3441338837146759,
0.14701050519943237,
0.20045384764671326,
0.15460169315338135,
0.6498589515686035,
-0.33869633078575134,
0.36543986201286316,
-0.14878565073013306,
0.04393164813518524,
0.43157804012298584,
-0.3615734577178955,
-0.3874099552631378,
0.0670003741979599,
-0.2822871804237366,
0.07972950488328934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03877v2 | Beyond Lines and Circles: Unveiling the Geometric Reasoning Gap in Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T10:37:21 | 2024-02-14T19:33:19 | Spyridon Mouselinos, Henryk Michalewski, Mateusz Malinowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate ever-increasing abilities in
mathematical and algorithmic tasks, yet their geometric reasoning skills are
underexplored. We investigate LLMs' abilities in constructive geometric
problem-solving one of the most fundamental steps in the development of human
mathematical reasoning. Our work reveals notable challenges that the
state-of-the-art LLMs face in this domain despite many successes in similar
areas. LLMs exhibit biases in target variable selection and struggle with 2D
spatial relationships, often misrepresenting and hallucinating objects and
their placements. To this end, we introduce a framework that formulates an
LLMs-based multi-agents system that enhances their existing reasoning potential
by conducting an internal dialogue. This work underscores LLMs' current
limitations in geometric reasoning and improves geometric reasoning
capabilities through self-correction, collaboration, and diverse role
specializations. | [
-0.6407557725906372,
-0.7605034708976746,
1.1968417167663574,
-0.010026670061051846,
0.2704513669013977,
0.31887418031692505,
-0.2676525115966797,
-0.638244092464447,
-0.09086108207702637,
0.5905378460884094,
-0.7950828075408936,
-0.6289973258972168,
-0.5403186678886414,
0.2382270097732544,
-0.034777116030454636,
0.25350698828697205,
-0.09706485271453857,
0.20010802149772644,
-0.4471977651119232,
-0.050502367317676544,
-0.36102500557899475,
-0.5601100921630859,
-0.49041351675987244,
-0.4547024965286255,
0.5027118921279907,
0.40737593173980713,
0.8932508230209351,
0.3449881374835968,
0.5535063147544861,
0.46821171045303345,
0.0512852780520916,
0.6388250589370728,
-0.3974815309047699,
0.39941173791885376,
-0.17324791848659515,
-0.5056452751159668,
-0.2162809669971466,
-0.06443464010953903,
0.6710195541381836,
1.0773594379425049,
-0.018208827823400497,
-0.31269562244415283,
-0.03285767883062363,
0.6960302591323853,
-0.23569360375404358,
0.4962638020515442,
-0.4539387822151184,
0.06170037016272545,
-0.22308054566383362,
0.08552554994821548,
-0.2567366063594818,
-0.5100091695785522,
0.1837242841720581,
-1.048720121383667,
-0.045581936836242676,
0.02015678770840168,
0.559796929359436,
0.37752872705459595,
-0.2057729810476303,
-0.5652799010276794,
-0.7680950164794922,
0.671556830406189,
-0.5985706448554993,
0.3980015814304352,
0.32878825068473816,
0.46946457028388977,
-0.7064400911331177,
-0.4207228422164917,
-0.3295423984527588,
-0.24057142436504364,
0.08877505362033844,
-0.261400431394577,
-0.19939596951007843,
0.028361361473798752,
0.38706156611442566,
0.07415100187063217,
-0.41378384828567505,
0.048528239130973816,
-0.4732980728149414,
-0.06484173983335495,
0.7926352024078369,
0.3164185881614685,
0.30079764127731323,
0.17036455869674683,
0.11256702244281769,
0.056089404970407486,
-0.9013071060180664,
0.0004502692318055779,
0.28655871748924255,
0.43366116285324097,
0.03553015738725662,
0.8539090752601624,
-0.18715427815914154,
0.5616884827613831,
-0.12921755015850067,
0.07369007915258408,
-0.16443823277950287,
0.045645102858543396,
-0.01144394651055336,
-0.17105983197689056,
0.624274730682373,
0.018838439136743546,
0.33247849345207214,
-0.013523641973733902,
-0.1391787976026535,
0.24921002984046936,
-0.023049602285027504,
-0.48140376806259155,
-0.2906478941440582,
-0.03535992652177811,
-0.09920462965965271,
0.17676520347595215,
0.12050573527812958,
-0.4627237319946289,
-0.7167335748672485,
-0.594878613948822,
0.06037481129169464,
-0.3714037239551544,
-0.2036498337984085,
0.47926437854766846,
0.15649063885211945,
-0.12104887515306473,
0.6672521233558655,
-0.5101022124290466,
0.2533281147480011,
0.8535104393959045,
0.6330053806304932,
0.32882508635520935,
-0.33861351013183594,
-0.3012285530567169,
0.23607751727104187,
-0.6402085423469543,
1.088853359222412,
-0.9344143271446228,
-0.33420953154563904,
-0.0027089561335742474,
-0.051656514406204224,
0.18349742889404297,
-0.632734477519989,
0.4495399594306946,
-0.15998892486095428,
0.27435702085494995,
-0.7065548300743103,
-0.4869748055934906,
-0.33400630950927734,
0.25423142313957214,
-0.5501977205276489,
0.9395330548286438,
0.03461010381579399,
-0.21937595307826996,
0.04232366010546684,
-0.6785662770271301,
-0.06072832643985748,
0.32507121562957764,
-0.7127785682678223,
-0.2795506715774536,
0.20632144808769226,
0.3641309440135956,
0.3693642020225525,
-0.4658830165863037,
0.10225066542625427,
-0.8469206690788269,
-0.2584691643714905,
0.26067444682121277,
0.01520026195794344,
0.5479068756103516,
0.17937172949314117,
-0.1202651858329773,
0.3338495194911957,
-0.43746325373649597,
0.12223748117685318,
0.35298359394073486,
0.041214436292648315,
-0.1508314609527588,
0.2626466751098633,
-0.4478391110897064,
0.4341096580028534,
0.07990994304418564,
-0.33133143186569214,
0.5797436833381653,
-0.28798550367355347,
0.6633143424987793,
0.8144177794456482,
-0.4930879473686218,
0.5305539965629578,
-0.3545406758785248,
0.5370418429374695,
-0.21928152441978455,
-0.02975190430879593,
0.013082451187074184,
-0.5563368201255798,
-0.8164680004119873,
-0.23911403119564056,
-0.5780912041664124,
0.31623730063438416,
-1.0099433660507202,
0.4098871350288391,
-0.11526095867156982,
-0.5105312466621399,
-0.19182385504245758,
0.30483299493789673,
0.23745845258235931,
0.16878481209278107,
0.1608625203371048,
0.1083139106631279,
-0.31199997663497925,
-0.611722469329834,
-0.08334128558635712,
-0.03758418932557106,
-0.1325918734073639,
0.46887901425361633,
0.311548113822937,
-0.2566724419593811,
0.8869540691375732,
-0.6052660346031189,
-0.46680641174316406,
-0.38326239585876465,
-0.29106882214546204,
0.11428329348564148,
0.11045726388692856,
0.21286344528198242,
-0.17829257249832153,
-0.24913020431995392,
0.06262468546628952,
-1.1292449235916138,
-0.3630455434322357,
-0.09057607501745224,
-0.375939279794693,
0.04948217794299126,
0.8147425055503845,
-0.8495855331420898,
0.5278526544570923,
0.5613468289375305,
-0.7090361714363098,
0.5678890943527222,
-0.24162113666534424,
-0.24933691322803497,
-0.582929253578186,
-0.4500463604927063,
0.2722156345844269,
0.09915857017040253,
-0.38715022802352905,
-0.11188048124313354,
-0.4635859429836273,
-0.21927842497825623,
-0.07114042341709137,
0.6628543734550476,
-0.9163097739219666,
-0.43020230531692505,
-0.3627189099788666,
0.4122137129306793,
0.10008390992879868,
0.44393080472946167,
0.1626918464899063,
0.6653791069984436,
0.8231179714202881,
-0.5445599555969238,
0.5755530595779419,
0.32682764530181885,
-0.3374330401420593,
0.7322356700897217,
-0.6532530188560486,
0.15408125519752502,
-0.22249938547611237,
0.45227739214897156,
-0.8216583132743835,
-0.10175593942403793,
0.4825611710548401,
-0.18900319933891296,
-0.11408887058496475,
-0.010131345130503178,
-0.526698887348175,
-0.5424792766571045,
0.05573544278740883,
0.6628443598747253,
0.03570609539747238,
-0.43802759051322937,
0.8004825711250305,
0.44419461488723755,
-0.25264477729797363,
-0.08002404123544693,
-0.304862916469574,
0.3178279995918274,
-0.10747017711400986,
-1.0782675743103027,
-0.11623550206422806,
0.00010887408279813826,
-0.6262108087539673,
0.024373790249228477,
-0.044137004762887955,
-0.0029357904568314552,
-0.16146719455718994,
0.13546453416347504,
0.1264510154724121,
-0.2753913700580597,
0.24424849450588226,
-0.07741313427686691,
-0.2030279040336609,
0.24918708205223083,
-0.5264038443565369,
0.5714681148529053,
-0.4206845760345459,
-0.8864911198616028,
-0.541654109954834,
0.4207558333873749,
0.6174447536468506,
-0.28673282265663147,
0.47733747959136963,
0.15086449682712555,
-0.5431405305862427,
-0.2970427870750427,
-0.5955740213394165,
-0.25579288601875305,
-0.49556979537010193,
0.43228358030319214,
-0.696544885635376,
-1.04807710647583,
0.609208881855011,
-0.09504767507314682,
-0.0827007070183754,
0.2504432797431946,
0.5166090130805969,
0.0017248658696189523,
1.11211097240448,
0.553973376750946,
0.39842790365219116,
0.23709721863269806,
-0.24643437564373016,
0.4067682921886444,
-0.9381894469261169,
-0.7077308893203735,
-0.564262866973877,
-0.09414390474557877,
-0.246218740940094,
-0.757862389087677,
0.5558373928070068,
0.265074759721756,
-0.43028077483177185,
0.15046942234039307,
-0.6613744497299194,
0.6601417064666748,
0.31445953249931335,
0.032907139509916306,
0.3031236529350281,
0.011853027157485485,
-0.2209859937429428,
-0.08697105944156647,
-0.7810437083244324,
-0.6046913862228394,
0.7085772752761841,
0.5052943229675293,
0.9814408421516418,
0.27167221903800964,
0.12784096598625183,
-0.10317376255989075,
0.1889590471982956,
-0.6115424633026123,
0.7476484179496765,
0.027418510988354683,
-0.36964091658592224,
-0.7536851763725281,
-0.5944012999534607,
-0.9626490473747253,
0.6051050424575806,
-0.19967956840991974,
-0.7258492708206177,
-0.054066773504018784,
-0.16534991562366486,
-0.3435594439506531,
0.5981528162956238,
-0.39180341362953186,
0.6961131691932678,
-0.449701726436615,
-0.41624706983566284,
-0.25439053773880005,
-0.2970373034477234,
0.3830350637435913,
0.2531226575374603,
0.29843729734420776,
-0.5991513133049011,
0.16143962740898132,
0.20226378738880157,
-0.5736232995986938,
0.8100784420967102,
-0.023557953536510468,
-0.5743212103843689,
0.43619734048843384,
0.4328371286392212,
0.4215388000011444,
0.1962970793247223,
0.19970284402370453,
0.42471662163734436,
-0.2597264051437378,
-0.34505632519721985,
-0.6663064956665039,
0.6534319519996643,
-0.7819460034370422,
-0.7486546039581299,
-0.47207584977149963,
-0.8919491767883301,
-0.31042084097862244,
0.07574636489152908,
-0.1787027269601822,
0.34741219878196716,
-0.06299524009227753,
-0.0998777523636818,
0.5857028365135193,
-0.36160868406295776,
0.3069694936275482,
0.20517221093177795,
-0.45840945839881897,
-0.3153650164604187,
0.6158158779144287,
-0.061145003885030746,
0.23079602420330048,
0.02159160003066063,
0.24574023485183716,
-0.5957086682319641,
-0.3602597713470459,
-0.4602607190608978,
0.7551230788230896,
-0.8296723365783691,
-0.03374554216861725,
-0.3507344126701355,
-0.3032121956348419,
-0.3262745440006256,
-0.3858545422554016,
-0.3836095929145813,
-0.3117966949939728,
-0.16663961112499237,
0.15729479491710663,
0.06210034713149071,
1.4074981212615967,
0.0154624804854393,
0.11488392949104309,
-0.7335382699966431,
0.1169399544596672,
0.30324238538742065,
0.49858522415161133,
0.04685452580451965,
-0.2738448679447174,
-0.05919778347015381,
0.17723993957042694,
-0.293706476688385,
-0.6007019877433777,
0.22640369832515717,
-0.3550340533256531,
0.7031699419021606,
0.4605591297149658,
-0.27517834305763245,
0.8339104652404785,
-0.6108908653259277,
0.42480090260505676,
0.34066271781921387,
-1.0055087804794312,
0.23581193387508392,
-0.5603691935539246,
0.4421238899230957,
-0.11872532963752747,
-0.00032271037343889475,
-0.5793149471282959,
-0.5488306283950806,
-0.2565859854221344,
-0.40368810296058655,
0.6396857500076294,
0.4078587591648102,
-0.18974480032920837,
0.07235957682132721,
0.42699939012527466,
-0.16714328527450562,
-0.0868465006351471,
-0.6966077089309692,
0.07025239616632462,
-0.09568328410387039,
-0.028810162097215652,
-0.041744768619537354,
-0.015115405432879925,
-0.3549814224243164,
-0.4279251992702484,
0.38165488839149475,
-0.21887420117855072,
0.19804951548576355,
0.22863397002220154,
0.1201179102063179,
-0.35611262917518616,
0.10149135440587997,
1.008731484413147,
1.0960577726364136,
0.4345974922180176,
0.07342015206813812,
0.08752299100160599,
-0.007430278230458498,
0.12368625402450562,
0.18278497457504272,
0.26318681240081787,
-0.19222001731395721,
0.38684365153312683,
0.6438775062561035,
-0.023707810789346695,
-0.6399413347244263,
0.0845000371336937,
-0.022177139297127724,
-0.28016185760498047,
-0.5398834943771362,
-0.12623272836208344,
0.19347892701625824,
0.7344057559967041,
0.41315799951553345,
0.019152509048581123,
-0.23337262868881226,
-0.5414945483207703,
0.03624161705374718,
0.8330215215682983,
-0.303680956363678,
-0.2283943146467209,
0.5388140082359314,
0.2560967803001404,
-0.4088781774044037,
0.6917914152145386,
-0.1795971691608429,
-0.603686511516571,
0.586250364780426,
0.23402716219425201,
0.7104057669639587,
-0.20653793215751648,
0.23739027976989746,
0.16036690771579742,
0.42632192373275757,
-0.16191571950912476,
0.02773440070450306,
0.1214391440153122,
-0.9823835492134094,
-0.5987141728401184,
-0.17120005190372467,
-0.3458428680896759,
-0.07911697775125504,
-0.2015814185142517,
0.2801324725151062,
-0.5647177696228027,
-0.08840136229991913,
-0.28532499074935913,
0.017345599830150604,
-0.32213976979255676,
-0.29860734939575195,
0.49151289463043213,
0.5808461308479309,
-0.5734278559684753,
0.5794011354446411,
0.6471747756004333,
-0.2530769407749176,
-0.7418909072875977,
-0.42287763953208923,
0.17401981353759766,
-0.8276382088661194,
0.7098566889762878,
0.3010390102863312,
-0.5154954195022583,
-0.36661088466644287,
-0.5657087564468384,
-1.001386046409607,
0.9191690683364868,
0.5702699422836304,
-0.7166492342948914,
-0.2691967487335205,
0.43768003582954407,
0.6001490950584412,
-0.5187802314758301,
0.23982374370098114,
0.3264017701148987,
0.40344497561454773,
0.5498687624931335,
-0.9587281346321106,
0.08235478401184082,
-0.03415483608841896,
0.0505031943321228,
0.40269145369529724,
-0.6246411204338074,
0.9933217763900757,
-0.4279220998287201,
-0.22563131153583527,
0.270964652299881,
0.6079161167144775,
0.6783310174942017,
0.23943127691745758,
0.43522149324417114,
0.7596331238746643,
0.810123860836029,
-0.29727259278297424,
0.7949492931365967,
-0.10564307123422623,
0.20116904377937317,
0.9144370555877686,
-0.5622459650039673,
0.34562015533447266,
0.20045775175094604,
-0.08561106026172638,
0.7029470205307007,
0.47086167335510254,
0.0733066126704216,
-0.04241568222641945,
0.5818055868148804,
-0.38289281725883484,
-0.7503360509872437,
-0.08903693407773972,
-0.4452337622642517,
0.35952088236808777,
0.7563232779502869,
0.20179995894432068,
-0.45077329874038696,
-0.20862826704978943,
0.026535751298069954,
0.418445348739624,
-0.3646910488605499,
0.5550915002822876,
0.36033543944358826,
-0.5335980653762817,
0.3094245493412018,
-0.12298337370157242,
0.21475903689861298,
-0.43846458196640015,
-0.4173964262008667,
-0.14576569199562073,
0.3978089392185211,
-0.2127908617258072,
-1.0405913591384888,
0.283806711435318,
-0.3448121249675751,
0.0926431193947792,
-0.22256064414978027,
0.3455275297164917,
-0.6558524370193481,
-0.7207492589950562,
0.36813196539878845,
0.6434133648872375,
0.16050787270069122,
-0.26427391171455383,
-0.8230525255203247,
0.44284966588020325,
-0.22939740121364594,
0.11482735723257065,
-0.044746480882167816,
1.0564600229263306,
-0.36236053705215454,
1.2431299686431885,
0.8392972350120544,
0.1805809587240219,
0.0276033915579319,
0.2924661338329315,
1.050391435623169,
-0.7318076491355896,
-0.5089813470840454,
-0.815137505531311,
0.3591777980327606,
-0.09264609217643738,
-0.09171101450920105,
0.7475867867469788,
0.473408579826355,
0.870370090007782,
0.16073311865329742,
0.6612257361412048,
0.3862152099609375,
0.4156945049762726,
-0.6445263028144836,
0.3869706690311432,
-0.34008675813674927,
0.5989457964897156,
-0.32402145862579346,
-1.0322775840759277,
-0.5080534815788269,
1.0725517272949219,
-0.5557811856269836,
0.17059288918972015,
0.8373205661773682,
0.6328584551811218,
0.15622298419475555,
-0.11781429499387741,
0.4778425991535187,
0.22196099162101746,
0.7519184947013855,
1.0081000328063965,
1.461708664894104,
0.06941605359315872,
0.6081039905548096,
0.011548136360943317,
-0.11981435120105743,
0.1393924206495285,
-0.5009969472885132,
-1.30967116355896,
-0.38610708713531494,
-0.11107028275728226,
-0.32746779918670654,
-0.18708357214927673,
0.8658084869384766,
0.7081267833709717,
-0.42036500573158264,
-0.643648624420166,
-0.3584977686405182,
0.2594289183616638,
0.14592309296131134,
-0.1933213621377945,
0.11242470890283585,
-0.36226943135261536,
-0.6944297552108765,
0.3711290657520294,
0.6153311729431152,
0.09317793697118759,
-0.7083733081817627,
-0.440997451543808,
0.15398761630058289,
0.08948755264282227,
0.6969431638717651,
0.38240307569503784,
-1.1324472427368164,
-0.2810194194316864,
0.05933864787220955,
-0.15758924186229706,
0.12457514554262161,
1.112146258354187,
-0.5140588283538818,
0.22908975183963776,
0.238772913813591,
0.6300718188285828,
0.22743038833141327,
-0.06467108428478241,
0.6908097863197327,
-0.1348278969526291,
0.27973926067352295,
0.37170207500457764,
0.5315425992012024,
0.4418656527996063,
-0.2678726017475128,
0.36045631766319275,
0.3879026174545288,
-0.6188541650772095,
-0.5966871380805969,
0.6474782228469849,
-0.6777086853981018,
-0.5816344618797302,
1.0573103427886963,
0.03319588303565979,
0.06309833377599716,
-0.2267916351556778,
-0.3385407030582428,
-0.11765845865011215,
-0.35257846117019653,
0.8437710404396057,
0.9062138199806213,
-0.5419227480888367,
-0.35786351561546326,
-0.22348394989967346,
0.4826244115829468,
0.4291287660598755,
-1.0553609132766724,
0.06551437079906464,
1.0272043943405151,
0.037315305322408676,
0.17639747262001038,
0.5070952773094177,
-0.09854251891374588,
0.038169391453266144,
-0.22806982696056366,
0.12426157295703888,
-0.26686814427375793,
-0.7450172901153564,
-0.30909785628318787,
0.006098591722548008,
0.08462715148925781,
0.1840573400259018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03870v1 | Less than one percent of words would be affected by gender-inclusive language in German press texts | 2024-02-06T10:32:34 | 2024-02-06T10:32:34 | Carolin Müller-Spitzer, Samira Ochs, Alexander Koplenig, Jan-Oliver Rüdiger, Sascha Wolfer | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | Research on gender and language is tightly knitted to social debates on
gender equality and non-discriminatory language use. Psycholinguistic scholars
have made significant contributions in this field. However, corpus-based
studies that investigate these matters within the context of language use are
still rare. In our study, we address the question of how much textual material
would actually have to be changed if non-gender-inclusive texts were rewritten
to be gender-inclusive. This quantitative measure is an important empirical
insight, as a recurring argument against the use of gender-inclusive German is
that it supposedly makes written texts too long and complicated. It is also
argued that gender-inclusive language has negative effects on language
learners. However, such effects are only likely if gender-inclusive texts are
very different from those that are not gender-inclusive. In our
corpus-linguistic study, we manually annotated German press texts to identify
the parts that would have to be changed. Our results show that, on average,
less than 1% of all tokens would be affected by gender-inclusive language. This
small proportion calls into question whether gender-inclusive German presents a
substantial barrier to understanding and learning the language, particularly
when we take into account the potential complexities of interpreting masculine
generics. | [
-0.3688557744026184,
-0.7252038717269897,
0.3492009937763214,
0.3277439773082733,
-0.2662925720214844,
-0.02446024678647518,
-0.3508283793926239,
-0.6129143238067627,
0.2288559228181839,
0.11660359054803848,
-0.5701358318328857,
-0.4358732998371124,
-0.900930643081665,
0.5138870477676392,
-0.6210194230079651,
0.8800944685935974,
0.07523602247238159,
0.2357018142938614,
-0.0030405663419514894,
-0.47168728709220886,
-0.4995168149471283,
-0.7006127834320068,
-0.39169859886169434,
-0.18885080516338348,
0.571813702583313,
0.2378053367137909,
0.6846354007720947,
0.16936266422271729,
0.39949363470077515,
0.24786904454231262,
-0.593233585357666,
-0.4427410662174225,
-0.5907679796218872,
0.05057862773537636,
-0.11250187456607819,
-0.6689033508300781,
-0.4600667655467987,
0.0683843195438385,
0.9091729521751404,
1.0685197114944458,
0.19667023420333862,
0.16718368232250214,
0.16574178636074066,
0.9806273579597473,
-0.458244264125824,
-0.03446624428033829,
-0.2665763199329376,
0.17605344951152802,
-0.3321620225906372,
0.07361434400081635,
-0.21120701730251312,
-0.14532315731048584,
0.10115355998277664,
-0.3628678023815155,
0.3073725402355194,
-0.0908084437251091,
0.5196217894554138,
-0.18223616480827332,
-0.5060883164405823,
-0.3206699788570404,
-0.626929759979248,
0.6780035495758057,
-0.5325900316238403,
0.7097278833389282,
0.5535579919815063,
-0.3283769488334656,
-0.4936465620994568,
-0.3008548617362976,
-0.45711156725883484,
-0.3005155920982361,
-0.256160169839859,
0.03779922425746918,
-0.5935913920402527,
-0.01818803697824478,
0.33016008138656616,
0.028305847197771072,
-0.5336743593215942,
0.21195754408836365,
-0.6010353565216064,
0.16774491965770721,
0.383415549993515,
-0.05721830949187279,
0.3927921950817108,
-0.3177659809589386,
-0.03516573831439018,
-0.02941080927848816,
-0.5787538886070251,
0.07539030909538269,
0.67995685338974,
0.49267950654029846,
0.012090728618204594,
0.7317179441452026,
0.18618865311145782,
0.46168163418769836,
-0.06477513909339905,
-0.12371570616960526,
0.3527766168117523,
-0.17464932799339294,
-0.011581774801015854,
0.2162056416273117,
0.4932221472263336,
0.08177882432937622,
0.475088506937027,
-0.2814568281173706,
-0.13811925053596497,
-0.020639536902308464,
0.3453715443611145,
-0.7639270424842834,
0.2768707871437073,
0.11374356597661972,
-0.45324355363845825,
0.07272296398878098,
0.1912614405155182,
-0.505776584148407,
-0.4542301595211029,
0.04273006692528725,
0.026103179901838303,
-0.4692203104496002,
-0.12515889108181,
0.2311117798089981,
-0.581471860408783,
0.06039980798959732,
0.167710080742836,
-0.9330931305885315,
0.11890580505132675,
0.6887261271476746,
0.5202173590660095,
0.008561140857636929,
-0.35703131556510925,
-0.01974492147564888,
-0.1605553925037384,
-0.46875786781311035,
0.6167041659355164,
-0.4561838209629059,
-0.8288933634757996,
0.19013746082782745,
0.27785447239875793,
-0.05714412406086922,
-0.3024197220802307,
0.6456185579299927,
-0.10181926190853119,
0.5609914660453796,
-0.26815077662467957,
-0.6276907920837402,
-0.0065478673204779625,
-0.07196617126464844,
-0.6528974771499634,
0.6468142867088318,
0.28528469800949097,
-1.0789636373519897,
0.6342426538467407,
-0.36406630277633667,
-0.7961111664772034,
-0.0534583181142807,
-0.3556077480316162,
-0.5151615738868713,
0.44376254081726074,
-0.27502280473709106,
-0.1994311809539795,
0.043065957725048065,
0.2329467535018921,
-0.23276230692863464,
-0.5333907008171082,
0.8149125576019287,
-0.4600178003311157,
0.6954511404037476,
-0.2834073007106781,
-0.5297890901565552,
-0.07583446800708771,
-0.6237753629684448,
-0.2189481258392334,
-0.005563800688832998,
-0.3082698881626129,
-0.5305918455123901,
-0.019200775772333145,
0.35374489426612854,
0.2505864202976227,
0.08711792528629303,
-0.7948323488235474,
-0.019839009270071983,
-0.28621670603752136,
0.06299788504838943,
0.7363470792770386,
-0.3544165790081024,
0.8354682922363281,
-0.23721010982990265,
0.6715841293334961,
-0.19186803698539734,
0.05057253688573837,
0.05355331674218178,
-0.5681831240653992,
-0.5114079117774963,
-0.3130837678909302,
0.7787871360778809,
0.42506399750709534,
-0.3838789761066437,
0.33902114629745483,
-0.09972188621759415,
-0.3579889237880707,
-0.5877675414085388,
0.12534046173095703,
0.4927196204662323,
0.3011414706707001,
-0.026853514835238457,
-0.24514298141002655,
-0.5081645846366882,
-1.2268476486206055,
-0.6142960786819458,
-0.4762759208679199,
-0.07935589551925659,
0.11269908398389816,
0.7247001528739929,
-0.04085005074739456,
1.1210757493972778,
-0.5373378396034241,
-0.6570714712142944,
-0.24557264149188995,
0.26669660210609436,
-0.14735162258148193,
0.464017391204834,
0.6380777359008789,
-0.6874116659164429,
0.014922729693353176,
-0.43846821784973145,
-0.7482884526252747,
-0.49364572763442993,
0.07499901205301285,
0.0028817804995924234,
0.5941799879074097,
0.42950084805488586,
-0.5568076372146606,
0.48400217294692993,
0.605266809463501,
-0.7184635996818542,
0.24639882147312164,
-0.3735830783843994,
0.07958739995956421,
-0.3366439938545227,
0.04940658435225487,
0.101454958319664,
-0.06380948424339294,
-0.7772616147994995,
-0.06160588189959526,
0.18362174928188324,
-0.15801742672920227,
-0.6757230758666992,
0.8761704564094543,
-0.32920536398887634,
0.11957243829965591,
-0.5897294878959656,
0.12289037555456161,
-0.15396730601787567,
0.33716636896133423,
-0.033066295087337494,
0.7636947631835938,
0.15652044117450714,
-0.4363572895526886,
-0.7184360027313232,
0.3051278293132782,
-0.11454872041940689,
0.5280908346176147,
-0.3345418870449066,
0.07436629384756088,
-0.5280477404594421,
0.4702284336090088,
-0.9285159111022949,
-0.0008321727509610355,
0.31909942626953125,
-0.4441079795360565,
0.22351399064064026,
0.17068608105182648,
-0.4895040690898895,
-0.1510230153799057,
-0.4012657701969147,
0.14690205454826355,
0.36475202441215515,
-0.01563354954123497,
0.33761101961135864,
0.549062192440033,
-0.189950630068779,
-0.30367225408554077,
-0.889561653137207,
0.130086749792099,
-0.17791084945201874,
-0.6401904225349426,
0.24054305255413055,
0.13237948715686798,
-0.3239673376083374,
0.0945579931139946,
-0.3130783140659332,
-0.13408958911895752,
0.38867154717445374,
0.2907792329788208,
0.08745436370372772,
0.13401217758655548,
0.5490867495536804,
0.39840206503868103,
-0.2339956909418106,
-0.22224175930023193,
-0.1579490751028061,
0.49305757880210876,
-0.41730567812919617,
-0.34258410334587097,
-0.22631391882896423,
1.0308603048324585,
0.2878111004829407,
0.15135458111763,
0.9274905920028687,
0.552266001701355,
-0.5063062310218811,
0.11496607959270477,
-0.24797199666500092,
-0.369247168302536,
-0.434918612241745,
0.5084084868431091,
-0.31578606367111206,
-1.2107571363449097,
0.4270283281803131,
0.3281349837779999,
0.026746954768896103,
0.5754761695861816,
0.25494325160980225,
-0.5821455717086792,
0.9743342995643616,
0.9281708598136902,
0.2948337495326996,
0.6969069242477417,
0.30810248851776123,
0.03208421543240547,
-0.362969309091568,
0.11866413801908493,
-0.8174297213554382,
-0.48183226585388184,
-1.1085392236709595,
0.09962181001901627,
0.19306927919387817,
-0.07273027300834656,
-0.023228216916322708,
0.2305530458688736,
-0.30865049362182617,
-0.13095004856586456,
0.4199651777744293,
-0.17469874024391174,
0.4334515929222107,
-0.1234240010380745,
0.48536670207977295,
-0.44184932112693787,
-0.7962778806686401,
-0.7239660024642944,
0.7781550288200378,
0.3682864010334015,
0.5593761205673218,
0.24641063809394836,
0.6602440476417542,
0.5948617458343506,
0.39441075921058655,
-0.6072654128074646,
0.5335500240325928,
-0.47808676958084106,
-1.1744482517242432,
-0.3017217218875885,
-0.3583891987800598,
-1.3018916845321655,
0.26498934626579285,
-0.290119469165802,
-0.7797441482543945,
0.5853750109672546,
-0.17341777682304382,
0.23019814491271973,
0.17006754875183105,
-0.8015148043632507,
0.5741665959358215,
-0.11336857825517654,
0.008893962018191814,
0.03759424015879631,
-0.49270758032798767,
0.1633077710866928,
-0.639173150062561,
0.6141312718391418,
-0.08816706389188766,
-0.12203604727983475,
1.1150367259979248,
0.02005728892982006,
1.0734823942184448,
0.026451222598552704,
-0.4245203733444214,
0.20042695105075836,
-0.041277848184108734,
0.17062251269817352,
-0.12188424170017242,
-0.07025527209043503,
0.4838191866874695,
0.029256245121359825,
-0.6365142464637756,
-0.342845618724823,
0.19361671805381775,
-0.5860238075256348,
-0.7971898913383484,
-0.6874536275863647,
-0.44949546456336975,
-0.02886025793850422,
0.20848630368709564,
0.35453155636787415,
0.26656481623649597,
-0.5550991892814636,
0.005636570509523153,
0.2860488295555115,
-0.45929446816444397,
0.4683331251144409,
0.7015790343284607,
-0.4227446913719177,
-0.2454984039068222,
0.7944816946983337,
0.6740578413009644,
0.19558149576187134,
0.049716997891664505,
0.14258317649364471,
-0.18989045917987823,
-0.16173945367336273,
-0.5690852403640747,
0.34808093309402466,
-0.6697953939437866,
0.2688603401184082,
-0.6758056879043579,
0.003034034511074424,
-0.29961225390434265,
-0.3732876777648926,
-0.35494428873062134,
-0.4957084059715271,
-0.32307326793670654,
0.018668998032808304,
0.2147017866373062,
0.4636135697364807,
0.0018920863512903452,
0.5244147777557373,
-0.7089612483978271,
0.3604714572429657,
0.11150698363780975,
0.3879703879356384,
-0.31950339674949646,
-0.5341054201126099,
-0.07528127729892731,
-0.11765794456005096,
-0.08925068378448486,
-0.9607905745506287,
0.13485722243785858,
0.14216680824756622,
0.2538195848464966,
0.22576911747455597,
0.0931176245212555,
0.36894237995147705,
-0.496119886636734,
0.6578823328018188,
0.3071708083152771,
-1.1143276691436768,
0.2541424036026001,
-0.41038402915000916,
0.4779672622680664,
0.6270867586135864,
-0.009949233382940292,
-0.8651658892631531,
-0.9892051815986633,
-0.965989887714386,
-0.9491515159606934,
0.6365474462509155,
0.5740092396736145,
0.641100287437439,
-0.25803956389427185,
0.19929495453834534,
0.5412402749061584,
0.47599005699157715,
-0.6890435218811035,
-0.5617737770080566,
0.12510466575622559,
0.1892566680908203,
0.041313644498586655,
-0.395968496799469,
-0.01071370393037796,
-0.29595911502838135,
0.5301012992858887,
0.2634596526622772,
0.4042566120624542,
0.22903189063072205,
-0.18326787650585175,
-0.022220192477107048,
0.9236889481544495,
0.7772848010063171,
0.8431434631347656,
-0.3689284920692444,
0.1860184371471405,
0.3296870291233063,
-0.696334183216095,
0.3269757926464081,
0.1038932278752327,
-0.608586311340332,
0.471548467874527,
0.407533198595047,
0.7863517999649048,
0.3165872395038605,
-0.7076830863952637,
0.37408122420310974,
-0.09824345260858536,
-0.3603103458881378,
-0.42243364453315735,
-0.1359696388244629,
0.12971945106983185,
0.08494475483894348,
0.5035303831100464,
-0.057965364307165146,
-0.08128286153078079,
-0.7114757895469666,
0.19471023976802826,
0.2877671420574188,
-0.6839697360992432,
-0.23425531387329102,
0.44600924849510193,
0.14055019617080688,
-0.7131147384643555,
0.3360724449157715,
-0.5695616006851196,
-0.5923535823822021,
0.4815247654914856,
0.7850618958473206,
0.8598998188972473,
-0.03290911763906479,
0.41282784938812256,
0.020405298098921776,
0.6343223452568054,
0.07209566980600357,
0.3655507564544678,
0.6168886423110962,
-0.4770544469356537,
-0.13227613270282745,
-0.37996214628219604,
-0.36359545588493347,
-0.19606806337833405,
-0.26647090911865234,
0.27166125178337097,
-0.22669245302677155,
-0.5675256252288818,
-0.08695679157972336,
-0.2083580493927002,
-0.4195220470428467,
0.11404909938573837,
0.3332025110721588,
0.8433774709701538,
-1.0336500406265259,
0.6076546311378479,
0.7940579056739807,
-0.3925197124481201,
-0.16536280512809753,
0.1501631885766983,
-0.16288888454437256,
-0.30286601185798645,
0.5068953633308411,
0.10866297036409378,
-0.11761080473661423,
-0.0706801638007164,
-0.19546130299568176,
-0.39770057797431946,
0.45651137828826904,
0.615863025188446,
-0.4229588508605957,
0.23651309311389923,
0.47095787525177,
0.8287394642829895,
-0.15910081565380096,
0.17789426445960999,
0.4413486421108246,
0.7427933812141418,
-0.44952353835105896,
-0.784748911857605,
-0.0823659896850586,
-0.13201765716075897,
-0.0825451910495758,
0.5240345001220703,
-0.49548423290252686,
0.9139143824577332,
0.0698886513710022,
-0.4737875759601593,
-0.34002694487571716,
0.7174818515777588,
-0.008554122410714626,
0.49323979020118713,
0.7316124439239502,
0.2493610978126526,
0.8173834681510925,
0.08846528083086014,
1.0398504734039307,
0.0009377271635457873,
0.16540446877479553,
0.7967329621315002,
-0.05347450077533722,
0.6214271187782288,
0.49890851974487305,
-0.25847336649894714,
0.3791440725326538,
0.33633026480674744,
0.15495429933071136,
0.11556927114725113,
0.44349250197410583,
-0.5141980648040771,
-0.03137160465121269,
-0.2726549804210663,
-0.3712126910686493,
0.7035411596298218,
0.14351515471935272,
-0.41290482878685,
-0.30969947576522827,
0.23139740526676178,
0.4294940233230591,
-0.051688939332962036,
0.05678986385464668,
0.48051896691322327,
0.47697004675865173,
-0.4317571818828583,
0.2449159324169159,
0.3692297041416168,
0.6323947906494141,
-0.6095781326293945,
0.2887110412120819,
-0.40110155940055847,
0.02495003119111061,
-0.2118494063615799,
-0.9332893490791321,
0.32349660992622375,
0.4122278094291687,
-0.37561652064323425,
-0.26760947704315186,
0.9739664793014526,
-0.3095459043979645,
-0.7391479015350342,
0.38206639885902405,
1.081531286239624,
0.16546283662319183,
-0.052259668707847595,
-0.21428930759429932,
-0.27321720123291016,
0.03752072528004646,
-0.17807637155056,
0.817066490650177,
0.24295668303966522,
-0.2855049967765808,
0.4903982877731323,
0.6112967133522034,
-0.006691816728562117,
-0.07582543045282364,
0.18584850430488586,
0.6305091977119446,
-0.8954669833183289,
-0.4586891829967499,
-0.8347011208534241,
0.5903440713882446,
-0.004538495559245348,
-0.6404225826263428,
0.7784420251846313,
0.39697688817977905,
0.6062594056129456,
0.08880797028541565,
0.7618058919906616,
-0.12394518405199051,
0.06852834671735764,
-0.08019056171178818,
0.9061516523361206,
-0.5240784883499146,
0.09416859596967697,
-0.5515767335891724,
-0.8508674502372742,
-0.27384084463119507,
0.4526798129081726,
-0.21004286408424377,
-0.0948515385389328,
0.8061985373497009,
0.3504319489002228,
0.07044681906700134,
0.4750751256942749,
0.26541826128959656,
0.034387242048978806,
0.08642827719449997,
-0.14808306097984314,
0.6518065333366394,
-0.3856544494628906,
0.5912949442863464,
-0.12277799099683762,
-0.28516149520874023,
0.02278389409184456,
-0.9588993787765503,
-0.6464289426803589,
-0.5313686728477478,
-0.5272196531295776,
-0.4375247657299042,
0.20465625822544098,
0.7639197111129761,
-0.018561121076345444,
-0.3552163541316986,
-0.2685839831829071,
-0.02956773154437542,
0.46254193782806396,
-0.07206757366657257,
-0.1337551772594452,
0.4971853494644165,
-0.13086187839508057,
-0.8511626124382019,
-0.04503529146313667,
0.09957791864871979,
-0.07982662320137024,
-0.11909286677837372,
0.11029424518346786,
-0.06528307497501373,
0.06609503924846649,
0.6900464296340942,
0.18123476207256317,
-0.3857668936252594,
-0.4397563934326172,
0.2597213387489319,
-0.3127670884132385,
0.16922308504581451,
0.6220493316650391,
-0.608068585395813,
0.33076897263526917,
0.5069262981414795,
0.33668774366378784,
0.31474965810775757,
-0.21994470059871674,
0.6008298993110657,
-0.882553219795227,
0.3592292070388794,
0.1085624098777771,
0.34502112865448,
0.23001909255981445,
-0.20833151042461395,
0.38611575961112976,
0.2963443696498871,
-0.24098774790763855,
-0.8099066615104675,
0.22306236624717712,
-0.952870786190033,
-0.6459488272666931,
1.3453477621078491,
-0.04440698027610779,
-0.10480757057666779,
-0.2724241316318512,
-0.29021763801574707,
0.3994169533252716,
-0.7023062705993652,
0.7215330600738525,
1.0455396175384521,
-0.02729193866252899,
-0.03103536367416382,
-0.7912036776542664,
0.16747629642486572,
0.6959448456764221,
-0.5387638807296753,
0.060947224497795105,
0.3573189377784729,
0.11085936427116394,
0.026223987340927124,
0.7083596587181091,
-0.07442579418420792,
0.12265323847532272,
0.1988271325826645,
0.0751010850071907,
0.20317113399505615,
0.08488161116838455,
-0.5338635444641113,
0.2649388313293457,
0.03035721927881241,
-0.042944952845573425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03848v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03848v6 | ANLS* -- A Universal Document Processing Metric for Generative Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T09:50:08 | 2024-06-28T06:49:39 | David Peer, Philemon Schöpf, Volckmar Nebendahl, Alexander Rietzler, Sebastian Stabinger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditionally, discriminative models have been the predominant choice for
tasks like document classification and information extraction. These models
make predictions that fall into a limited number of predefined classes,
facilitating a binary true or false evaluation and enabling the direct
calculation of metrics such as the F1 score. However, recent advancements in
generative large language models (GLLMs) have prompted a shift in the field due
to their enhanced zero-shot capabilities, which eliminate the need for a
downstream dataset and computationally expensive fine-tuning. However,
evaluating GLLMs presents a challenge as the binary true or false evaluation
used for discriminative models is not applicable to the predictions made by
GLLMs.
This paper introduces a new metric for generative models called ANLS* for
evaluating a wide variety of tasks, including information extraction and
classification tasks. The ANLS* metric extends existing ANLS metrics as a
drop-in-replacement and is still compatible with previously reported ANLS
scores. An evaluation of 7 different datasets, and more than 10 different GLLMs
together with 3 different prompting methods using the ANLS* metric is also
provided, demonstrating the importance of the proposed metric.
We also benchmark a novel approach to generate prompts for documents, called
SFT, against other prompting techniques such as LATIN. In 6 out of 7 cases, SFT
outperforms other techniques and improves the state-of-the-art, sometimes by as
much as $10$ percentage points.
Sources are available at https://github.com/deepopinion/anls_star_metric | [
-0.2494330108165741,
-0.7843099236488342,
0.5899155139923096,
0.14207474887371063,
-0.028934985399246216,
0.40316686034202576,
-0.18335220217704773,
-0.37873727083206177,
-0.25275054574012756,
0.34371671080589294,
-0.598135769367218,
-0.7637265920639038,
-0.6751344799995422,
0.32701531052589417,
-0.906147837638855,
0.8172294497489929,
0.07730939239263535,
0.011693242006003857,
-0.3035552501678467,
0.03200273588299751,
-0.24816013872623444,
-0.4177510142326355,
-0.9156264662742615,
0.03661657124757767,
0.3957039415836334,
0.16785794496536255,
0.9061883687973022,
0.7578547596931458,
0.6642184257507324,
0.24843084812164307,
-0.2549731433391571,
0.17641861736774445,
-0.02543141320347786,
0.19653703272342682,
-0.003472184296697378,
-0.5088722109794617,
-0.5267099142074585,
0.23755784332752228,
0.9234044551849365,
0.6404020190238953,
-0.020261194556951523,
0.22291459143161774,
-0.123453788459301,
0.752949595451355,
-0.5581804513931274,
-0.04677353799343109,
-0.39416438341140747,
0.5019767880439758,
-0.19573694467544556,
-0.4311574399471283,
-0.4882705509662628,
-0.6950414180755615,
0.15463753044605255,
-0.633370578289032,
0.6448644399642944,
0.06903111189603806,
0.9186790585517883,
0.0860508531332016,
-0.1437189131975174,
-0.748211145401001,
-0.8151224255561829,
0.8361965417861938,
-0.6874938011169434,
0.5435380339622498,
0.045733798295259476,
0.43933340907096863,
0.189748615026474,
-0.5089473724365234,
-0.48723509907722473,
-0.49336278438568115,
-0.2056833952665329,
-0.01140594482421875,
-0.4903709888458252,
0.03443962708115578,
0.4795615077018738,
0.5846915245056152,
-0.7417671084403992,
0.32486674189567566,
-0.41303709149360657,
0.002621253253892064,
0.597054660320282,
0.4093433618545532,
0.23128443956375122,
-0.09508176892995834,
-0.5844485759735107,
0.047310035675764084,
-0.7714519500732422,
-0.012869084253907204,
0.450639933347702,
0.2163633406162262,
-0.3244503438472748,
0.26270216703414917,
0.06856553256511688,
1.0020904541015625,
0.12892073392868042,
0.0014021560782566667,
0.2311127483844757,
-0.4973177909851074,
-0.08385779708623886,
-0.34724488854408264,
0.8881376385688782,
0.0717092901468277,
0.3344075381755829,
-0.4288714528083801,
-0.38536813855171204,
0.16318750381469727,
0.4020698368549347,
-0.7965691089630127,
-0.11821349710226059,
-0.04609603062272072,
-0.5444262027740479,
-0.3221535086631775,
0.11059556901454926,
-0.8082846403121948,
-0.6731972694396973,
-0.465552419424057,
0.017516961321234703,
-0.39980342984199524,
-0.18159830570220947,
0.024126920849084854,
-0.2330174446105957,
-0.008389257825911045,
0.819275438785553,
-0.7181020975112915,
0.23066431283950806,
0.2626399099826813,
0.9843677878379822,
-0.47843366861343384,
-0.25093919038772583,
-0.4851721525192261,
-0.24657240509986877,
-0.6240441203117371,
0.8519149422645569,
-0.7855833172798157,
-0.6661726832389832,
0.1540471315383911,
-0.2973446547985077,
-0.26370352506637573,
-0.5760529041290283,
0.7253631353378296,
-0.3922431468963623,
0.5325908660888672,
-0.26233354210853577,
-0.658349871635437,
-0.3136925995349884,
0.3293372094631195,
-0.5241239666938782,
1.0336533784866333,
0.15176090598106384,
-0.5646233558654785,
0.35413631796836853,
-0.8351129293441772,
-0.4117923080921173,
0.4075128436088562,
-0.3767298460006714,
-0.14914554357528687,
0.13762760162353516,
-0.0143512524664402,
0.47161272168159485,
-0.9173210263252258,
0.3266449570655823,
-0.22850456833839417,
-0.4190707504749298,
0.2893790900707245,
-0.7518424391746521,
0.700940728187561,
0.3442520201206207,
-0.09783530980348587,
0.3483543395996094,
-0.7871494293212891,
-0.11178991943597794,
-0.049948833882808685,
-0.48310598731040955,
0.04088759794831276,
-0.04452572390437126,
-0.04401162266731262,
0.21260923147201538,
0.31333786249160767,
-0.7279860973358154,
0.24246561527252197,
-0.22741606831550598,
0.2690640985965729,
0.5456739664077759,
-0.15067662298679352,
0.4702909588813782,
-0.26163238286972046,
0.7298005819320679,
-0.26443442702293396,
0.29403549432754517,
-0.2383813112974167,
-0.2818625569343567,
-0.8118838667869568,
-0.4445984363555908,
0.23280534148216248,
0.49648723006248474,
-0.4571685492992401,
0.8340916037559509,
-0.14273160696029663,
-0.6505592465400696,
-0.8506268262863159,
0.22129413485527039,
0.5404902100563049,
0.44948074221611023,
0.3280862867832184,
-0.4556716978549957,
-0.44695401191711426,
-0.5444635152816772,
-0.04660513252019882,
-0.22630080580711365,
-0.2687356472015381,
0.21329377591609955,
0.1853266805410385,
0.024339895695447922,
1.0288704633712769,
-0.40369799733161926,
-0.7398880124092102,
-0.1178128719329834,
0.4334615170955658,
0.24991635978221893,
0.06881596893072128,
0.7008480429649353,
-0.816068172454834,
-0.6200143098831177,
-0.05881945416331291,
-1.2032910585403442,
-0.023272980004549026,
-0.15115314722061157,
0.37643003463745117,
0.3261778950691223,
0.4293350279331207,
-0.7676267027854919,
0.3492082953453064,
0.3961104452610016,
-0.6467294096946716,
0.884382426738739,
-0.39181986451148987,
0.29944440722465515,
-0.42402201890945435,
0.3327232897281647,
0.07701949030160904,
0.11979205906391144,
-0.672855794429779,
0.049780603498220444,
0.3056574761867523,
-0.320115327835083,
-0.4391426146030426,
0.8725664019584656,
-0.6618314981460571,
-0.33623072504997253,
-0.056771181523799896,
0.06150240823626518,
0.273611843585968,
0.11230149865150452,
-0.011244046501815319,
0.9075694680213928,
0.9314484000205994,
-0.6842888593673706,
0.6169474124908447,
0.21053454279899597,
-0.2939312160015106,
0.6295766830444336,
-0.34899240732192993,
0.19174858927726746,
-0.26930665969848633,
0.11249905824661255,
-0.9830344915390015,
0.270682156085968,
-0.14425110816955566,
-0.5646663308143616,
0.484832227230072,
0.239615336060524,
-0.7250533103942871,
-0.6558224558830261,
-0.41001224517822266,
-0.017225468531250954,
0.31721657514572144,
-0.8084971904754639,
0.49551087617874146,
0.009536710567772388,
-0.2973244786262512,
-0.3047792613506317,
-0.3771507740020752,
0.3102455139160156,
-0.20480920374393463,
-0.6110872626304626,
0.2785393297672272,
-0.31979796290397644,
0.09017498046159744,
0.43473780155181885,
0.08481258898973465,
0.1329914629459381,
0.1925157606601715,
0.015136901289224625,
0.4461459815502167,
-0.370509535074234,
0.2134503275156021,
-0.269675612449646,
-0.2663542628288269,
-0.08057466894388199,
-0.14968836307525635,
0.46299365162849426,
-0.24031400680541992,
-0.19720269739627838,
-0.4788613021373749,
0.33121711015701294,
0.7346971035003662,
-0.43653634190559387,
0.46633800864219666,
0.6500155329704285,
-0.24947135150432587,
0.034099776297807693,
-0.8085585236549377,
0.05921453610062599,
-0.4415646195411682,
0.30458685755729675,
-0.2962088882923126,
-0.7837640047073364,
0.28928813338279724,
0.23082788288593292,
0.284180611371994,
0.627465546131134,
0.4829092025756836,
0.005255199037492275,
1.2872079610824585,
0.3954067826271057,
-0.15971572697162628,
0.42507705092430115,
-0.18136927485466003,
0.2224065661430359,
-0.5671116709709167,
-0.09076078236103058,
-0.7301425337791443,
0.061024490743875504,
-0.07823300361633301,
-0.36761900782585144,
0.28575512766838074,
0.2665950655937195,
-0.0034138800110667944,
0.21372179687023163,
-0.5859772562980652,
0.3370344042778015,
0.3174714148044586,
-0.5785992741584778,
0.4075603187084198,
0.04054959863424301,
0.04961371049284935,
0.10832225531339645,
-0.4109203815460205,
-0.5716966390609741,
0.9224607944488525,
0.39069339632987976,
0.6583645939826965,
0.13215720653533936,
0.5813111662864685,
0.8442793488502502,
0.5293197631835938,
-0.7955443263053894,
0.6113572716712952,
-0.922446608543396,
-0.5016229748725891,
-0.3724382221698761,
-0.42607980966567993,
-0.9728637933731079,
0.3020065128803253,
-0.3563138544559479,
-0.830020010471344,
0.015881871804594994,
0.09558072686195374,
-0.40680256485939026,
0.23341603577136993,
-0.6570183038711548,
0.9089503884315491,
-0.24799245595932007,
0.0227187629789114,
-0.12700870633125305,
-0.17287661135196686,
0.108146533370018,
0.03150112181901932,
0.28788870573043823,
-0.34927627444267273,
0.04940535128116608,
0.7524901032447815,
0.05812833085656166,
0.7174527645111084,
-0.2864364981651306,
-0.08476413786411285,
0.22925326228141785,
0.08668260276317596,
0.41223591566085815,
-0.34237244725227356,
-0.4989870488643646,
0.10439951717853546,
-0.02884743921458721,
-0.06678365170955658,
-0.7553305625915527,
0.5815359354019165,
-0.5057796239852905,
-0.46748247742652893,
-0.29343974590301514,
-0.514839768409729,
-0.11195378005504608,
0.09499835968017578,
0.5274446606636047,
0.5544585585594177,
-0.278729110956192,
0.20599094033241272,
0.4413483738899231,
-0.24132993817329407,
0.5093544721603394,
1.0117216110229492,
-0.012200437486171722,
-0.15208888053894043,
1.0416162014007568,
0.08736781775951385,
0.040455061942338943,
0.42264100909233093,
0.3527239263057709,
-0.7621145844459534,
-0.6426364779472351,
-0.8526623845100403,
0.04523065686225891,
-0.7569420337677002,
-0.41093146800994873,
-0.5759894847869873,
-0.5575093030929565,
-0.4379917085170746,
-0.3139341175556183,
-0.14709478616714478,
-0.2530826926231384,
-0.4668033719062805,
-0.22729502618312836,
-0.007583245635032654,
0.8500742316246033,
0.1600082963705063,
-0.02076469548046589,
-0.9968019723892212,
0.29137682914733887,
0.046936050057411194,
0.26663196086883545,
0.24323362112045288,
-0.49162793159484863,
0.09033873677253723,
-0.45673424005508423,
-0.31102046370506287,
-0.9809773564338684,
0.45258116722106934,
0.3190511167049408,
0.7492737174034119,
0.38193872570991516,
-0.0068917712196707726,
0.2156723290681839,
-0.2664550542831421,
0.7961729168891907,
0.5984999537467957,
-0.8025992512702942,
0.5329472422599792,
-0.2031608521938324,
0.4450047016143799,
0.3945874571800232,
0.4314431846141815,
-0.6621692776679993,
-0.7194997072219849,
-0.6793856620788574,
-0.5801287889480591,
0.8038703799247742,
-0.027480127289891243,
0.14027762413024902,
-0.15718196332454681,
0.16201315820217133,
0.33669808506965637,
0.3301343321800232,
-0.44866710901260376,
-0.26968133449554443,
0.21410098671913147,
-0.29570525884628296,
-0.17425589263439178,
-0.37767353653907776,
0.19164887070655823,
-0.04864846542477608,
0.6105539798736572,
0.0617237463593483,
0.08948677033185959,
0.007448437623679638,
-0.15202750265598297,
-0.36440595984458923,
0.5340079069137573,
0.1980673223733902,
0.45582878589630127,
-0.14504019916057587,
0.23358727991580963,
-0.03502244874835014,
-0.29263177514076233,
0.14645317196846008,
0.25138038396835327,
-0.7623916268348694,
0.1196623146533966,
0.3308570683002472,
1.057802438735962,
-0.0066623687744140625,
-0.5218687653541565,
0.49108460545539856,
-0.2825043201446533,
-0.2859957218170166,
-0.2170448750257492,
0.219096377491951,
-0.3991306722164154,
-0.0015641135396435857,
0.5230461955070496,
0.1377505660057068,
0.3498933017253876,
-0.3620447516441345,
0.10667353868484497,
0.42613908648490906,
-0.6562364101409912,
-0.42972052097320557,
0.4375850260257721,
0.4165250360965729,
-0.5788196921348572,
0.5278096795082092,
-0.7270721197128296,
-0.3483782708644867,
0.4886823296546936,
0.48733648657798767,
1.0430535078048706,
-0.41330841183662415,
0.5674155354499817,
0.5261266827583313,
0.15816660225391388,
0.05142255872488022,
0.052198123186826706,
-0.12684758007526398,
-0.6801902651786804,
-0.030830103904008865,
-1.1880866289138794,
-0.3145480155944824,
0.25547805428504944,
-0.5514943599700928,
0.18400178849697113,
-0.5270447731018066,
-0.10637238621711731,
0.4027836322784424,
0.15340538322925568,
-0.8702576756477356,
0.4266508221626282,
0.21835055947303772,
0.9293510913848877,
-0.8547426462173462,
0.7856966257095337,
0.8108348846435547,
-0.36382147669792175,
-0.36925116181373596,
-0.09214255213737488,
0.29380711913108826,
-0.5389162302017212,
0.5729374289512634,
0.3248344361782074,
0.02364148013293743,
0.017598971724510193,
0.12213832885026932,
-0.8607468605041504,
0.7759471535682678,
0.4749404191970825,
-0.4274906814098358,
-0.41789475083351135,
0.03762242570519447,
0.6703899502754211,
-0.4979643225669861,
0.43117019534111023,
0.8423283100128174,
0.5343387126922607,
0.21567997336387634,
-0.8418952822685242,
0.2679341733455658,
-0.464440256357193,
0.010035091079771519,
0.18711335957050323,
-0.15420512855052948,
0.9332656264305115,
-0.356554239988327,
-0.7014811038970947,
0.4326578676700592,
0.2505985200405121,
0.034895990043878555,
0.06023717671632767,
0.7426713705062866,
0.2595823109149933,
1.0129077434539795,
-0.11086180061101913,
1.1951013803482056,
-0.09531663358211517,
0.3656405806541443,
0.6878180503845215,
-0.2175319492816925,
0.7069170475006104,
-0.012056668289005756,
-0.35079821944236755,
0.3729086220264435,
0.3214193284511566,
-0.4304051995277405,
0.3378968834877014,
0.2275157868862152,
-0.4442354440689087,
-0.23636864125728607,
-0.33989378809928894,
-0.3837875723838806,
0.3396494686603546,
0.5721669793128967,
-0.3580826222896576,
-0.5407631397247314,
-0.18530668318271637,
-0.18134978413581848,
0.2147211730480194,
-0.09927519410848618,
0.8345265984535217,
-0.05610813573002815,
-0.7631357312202454,
0.5874121189117432,
0.11313405632972717,
0.7556911706924438,
-0.8040317893028259,
0.06324449926614761,
-0.22915220260620117,
0.13640020787715912,
-0.35305753350257874,
-0.9807627201080322,
0.31589245796203613,
0.48942092061042786,
-0.3616165816783905,
-0.4132862389087677,
0.7183759808540344,
-0.4076940715312958,
-0.4835481345653534,
0.6269508004188538,
0.3118036091327667,
0.07913191616535187,
0.07151314616203308,
-0.8669217824935913,
-0.005466661415994167,
-0.141215980052948,
-0.13278286159038544,
0.42402592301368713,
0.26238033175468445,
0.07234655320644379,
0.4242826998233795,
0.6222735643386841,
0.19264471530914307,
0.033523742109537125,
0.38026997447013855,
0.5240974426269531,
-0.5958571434020996,
-0.652977705001831,
-0.6915078163146973,
0.3087804615497589,
-0.1856594681739807,
-0.4397936463356018,
0.7358571290969849,
0.7066200971603394,
0.5750011801719666,
-0.11073798686265945,
0.9535010457038879,
-0.06293260306119919,
0.7297828793525696,
-0.6259329915046692,
0.6311887502670288,
-0.6099897623062134,
0.26781541109085083,
-0.09942103922367096,
-1.0302802324295044,
-0.2833484411239624,
0.4339434802532196,
-0.3346368372440338,
-0.24066591262817383,
0.6365521550178528,
0.6378287672996521,
0.2449977844953537,
0.27348071336746216,
0.5260137319564819,
0.09602727741003036,
0.48285284638404846,
0.27760177850723267,
0.9580690860748291,
-0.10741645842790604,
0.465494304895401,
0.007556258235126734,
-0.2923068106174469,
0.03625771030783653,
-0.8165857791900635,
-0.7834446430206299,
-0.454513281583786,
-0.4473534822463989,
-0.06830773502588272,
0.2976861596107483,
0.3424908518791199,
0.5409556031227112,
-0.9152848720550537,
-0.308228075504303,
-0.14755181968212128,
0.06382341682910919,
-0.09100883454084396,
-0.25619959831237793,
0.46161606907844543,
-0.8139236569404602,
-0.620603621006012,
0.6106640696525574,
0.5099669694900513,
0.06716987490653992,
-0.31851133704185486,
-0.26373291015625,
-0.03397852182388306,
-0.15010489523410797,
0.4488459527492523,
0.35987311601638794,
-0.7911291122436523,
-0.2659998834133148,
0.04206881672143936,
-0.23386453092098236,
0.053935352712869644,
0.6799653768539429,
-0.5555104613304138,
0.5969841480255127,
0.43158644437789917,
0.48348429799079895,
0.4993533492088318,
-0.07375761866569519,
0.545735239982605,
-1.1135461330413818,
-0.08973090350627899,
0.33640557527542114,
0.18921013176441193,
0.6818299293518066,
-0.3277416229248047,
0.5306347608566284,
0.30532851815223694,
-0.021866757422685623,
-0.8718253970146179,
0.16568298637866974,
-0.5481299757957458,
-0.19259114563465118,
1.2518925666809082,
-0.34005898237228394,
0.25136837363243103,
0.05004943534731865,
-0.17781315743923187,
0.03453996777534485,
-0.38036009669303894,
0.7821768522262573,
0.4820229411125183,
-0.008538519963622093,
-0.05408960208296776,
-0.352560430765152,
0.6063933968544006,
0.433819442987442,
-0.9287623167037964,
0.3277333676815033,
0.46670031547546387,
0.016733013093471527,
0.5512748956680298,
0.9789323210716248,
-0.27254217863082886,
0.4659430980682373,
-0.03230033069849014,
0.06696767359972,
-0.1373402625322342,
-0.6163516044616699,
-0.3711026906967163,
0.4012048542499542,
0.28339359164237976,
-0.05282798409461975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04291v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04291v2 | BiLLM: Pushing the Limit of Post-Training Quantization for LLMs | 2024-02-06T09:26:34 | 2024-05-15T13:55:12 | Wei Huang, Yangdong Liu, Haotong Qin, Ying Li, Shiming Zhang, Xianglong Liu, Michele Magno, Xiaojuan Qi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Pretrained large language models (LLMs) exhibit exceptional general language
processing capabilities but come with significant demands on memory and
computational resources. As a powerful compression technology, binarization can
extremely reduce model weights to a mere 1 bit, lowering the expensive
computation and memory requirements. However, existing quantization techniques
fall short of maintaining LLM performance under ultra-low bit-widths. In
response to this challenge, we present BiLLM, a groundbreaking 1-bit
post-training quantization scheme tailored for pretrained LLMs. Based on the
weight distribution of LLMs, BiLLM first identifies and structurally selects
salient weights, and minimizes the compression loss through an effective binary
residual approximation strategy. Moreover, considering the bell-shaped
distribution of the non-salient weights, we propose an optimal splitting search
to group and binarize them accurately. BiLLM achieving for the first time
high-accuracy inference (e.g. 8.41 perplexity on LLaMA2-70B) with only 1.08-bit
weights across various LLMs families and evaluation metrics, outperforms SOTA
quantization methods of LLM by significant margins. Moreover, BiLLM enables the
binarization process of the LLM with 7 billion weights within 0.5 hours on a
single GPU, demonstrating satisfactory time efficiency. Our code is available
at https://github.com/Aaronhuang-778/BiLLM. | [
-0.5978110432624817,
-0.497041255235672,
0.3885244131088257,
0.23218855261802673,
-0.9258406162261963,
0.0982004702091217,
-0.1768651306629181,
-0.14543847739696503,
0.1552005559206009,
0.7627343535423279,
-0.37525293231010437,
-0.6143599152565002,
-0.7155541777610779,
-0.07545876502990723,
0.0021221796050667763,
0.9320746064186096,
0.14569033682346344,
0.21161699295043945,
-0.13046568632125854,
-0.06574593484401703,
-0.35894080996513367,
-0.7940424084663391,
-0.6180530190467834,
-0.24851854145526886,
0.5518609881401062,
0.09524867683649063,
0.42180874943733215,
0.6756905317306519,
0.4005223512649536,
0.16321957111358643,
-0.07769252359867096,
0.06481458246707916,
-0.37853574752807617,
-0.1318223625421524,
0.19804903864860535,
-0.78029465675354,
-0.5327146053314209,
-0.06501837819814682,
0.8083407282829285,
0.7570774555206299,
-0.22890520095825195,
0.13930869102478027,
-0.25375041365623474,
0.6805801391601562,
-0.7080755829811096,
0.0842982679605484,
-0.6848214864730835,
0.03001890890300274,
-0.4503737688064575,
-0.3794674873352051,
-0.28463301062583923,
-0.5323681235313416,
-0.2622460722923279,
-0.48625728487968445,
0.18465375900268555,
0.27269670367240906,
0.9170199036598206,
0.4285740852355957,
-0.27334266901016235,
0.11421853303909302,
-0.475310742855072,
0.8023701906204224,
-0.8082113862037659,
0.40658196806907654,
0.4847772419452667,
0.09002543240785599,
0.10924827307462692,
-0.5765405297279358,
-0.34168198704719543,
0.01799967885017395,
0.22500556707382202,
-0.10296669602394104,
-0.17086315155029297,
0.30133023858070374,
0.2562052011489868,
0.41512492299079895,
-0.6027933955192566,
0.09766501933336258,
-0.3593652844429016,
-0.07114553451538086,
0.5212737917900085,
-0.117343470454216,
0.03426416218280792,
0.0695057362318039,
-0.5274468064308167,
-0.028761398047208786,
-0.8975673913955688,
-0.06473249197006226,
0.46648460626602173,
0.005361881572753191,
0.146042600274086,
0.32796502113342285,
0.023186517879366875,
0.7098931074142456,
-0.0919329822063446,
0.21873317658901215,
-0.018227992579340935,
-0.13124844431877136,
-0.46980035305023193,
0.3516172170639038,
0.8827678561210632,
0.13422901928424835,
-0.1312597543001175,
0.0018131280085071921,
-0.3699406087398529,
-0.07551649957895279,
0.24643278121948242,
-1.2238670587539673,
-0.3296346962451935,
0.07807344198226929,
-0.2865273058414459,
-0.14420945942401886,
-0.13587084412574768,
-0.3207310140132904,
-0.2402539849281311,
-0.15228891372680664,
0.6861885190010071,
-0.4250512421131134,
-0.16358689963817596,
0.37593531608581543,
0.03094959817826748,
0.22950157523155212,
0.2597394585609436,
-1.1724265813827515,
0.3641337752342224,
0.8394966721534729,
0.7044242024421692,
0.2504737079143524,
0.20634907484054565,
-0.6380131244659424,
-0.07420872151851654,
-0.6922532320022583,
0.6568580269813538,
-0.23895391821861267,
-0.2787048816680908,
-0.3335910141468048,
-0.3537808656692505,
0.243671253323555,
-0.7144156098365784,
0.3469509184360504,
-0.9344985485076904,
-0.011506333015859127,
0.026093600317835808,
-0.5349324345588684,
-0.0852455198764801,
0.21399933099746704,
-0.6278916001319885,
0.7211431264877319,
0.34216177463531494,
-0.6771760582923889,
0.4232490062713623,
-0.4490143954753876,
-0.3429156243801117,
0.3238452970981598,
-0.16560032963752747,
-0.5701947212219238,
0.39730724692344666,
0.13130271434783936,
0.27805617451667786,
-0.5003625154495239,
0.14592324197292328,
-0.209415465593338,
-0.6661947965621948,
0.12720879912376404,
-0.3736709952354431,
0.6412306427955627,
0.11566068232059479,
-0.16005322337150574,
0.19828979671001434,
-0.6332831978797913,
0.17896759510040283,
0.13141144812107086,
-0.45426806807518005,
-0.4052394926548004,
-0.25174540281295776,
-0.23168054223060608,
-0.03291536122560501,
0.36719387769699097,
-0.3886871933937073,
0.37642061710357666,
-0.5604357123374939,
0.435612291097641,
0.8911388516426086,
-0.3709653615951538,
0.35771340131759644,
-0.17491623759269714,
0.7084705233573914,
-0.2692463994026184,
0.2579018175601959,
-0.1509612798690796,
-0.013612562790513039,
-0.6869297623634338,
-0.5447837710380554,
0.714273989200592,
0.36670956015586853,
-0.5610095858573914,
0.6895667910575867,
-0.49653196334838867,
-0.25229424238204956,
-0.6100868582725525,
0.12187585979700089,
0.4414280354976654,
-0.07293464243412018,
0.2974300682544708,
-0.7761112451553345,
-0.5849589705467224,
-0.9034178256988525,
-0.11802410334348679,
-0.02825341559946537,
-0.32402437925338745,
0.10571900010108948,
0.1112142875790596,
-0.20148837566375732,
0.8160986304283142,
-0.46602582931518555,
-0.07616500556468964,
-0.10833555459976196,
0.2787262201309204,
0.23910857737064362,
0.5058460831642151,
0.018513411283493042,
-0.6205498576164246,
-0.17573875188827515,
-0.06280526518821716,
-0.3001449406147003,
-0.3079777657985687,
0.015843769535422325,
-0.22052036225795746,
0.36986300349235535,
0.5026097893714905,
-0.5288412570953369,
0.18215987086296082,
0.746512770652771,
-0.20613670349121094,
0.6666579246520996,
-0.29826441407203674,
-0.06708572059869766,
-0.995968222618103,
-0.012021991424262524,
-0.2412794530391693,
-0.58088618516922,
-0.31105318665504456,
-0.22194761037826538,
0.017377499490976334,
-0.1088278591632843,
-0.38106995820999146,
0.5553607940673828,
-0.7982502579689026,
-0.09478811919689178,
-0.41422948241233826,
0.07148955017328262,
0.00985268596559763,
0.5350975394248962,
-0.1564207673072815,
0.6439173221588135,
0.5670010447502136,
-0.47178447246551514,
0.2893470823764801,
0.17586109042167664,
-0.5721709132194519,
0.3204422891139984,
-0.48814526200294495,
0.295627236366272,
-0.19047777354717255,
0.26836878061294556,
-0.8458918333053589,
0.1804143786430359,
0.21410253643989563,
-0.3074236214160919,
0.6223964691162109,
-0.3224099576473236,
-0.5443739295005798,
-0.07065944373607635,
-0.4693530201911926,
0.67143714427948,
0.7092882394790649,
-0.4075597822666168,
0.42573440074920654,
0.3924057185649872,
-0.24853605031967163,
-0.6109092831611633,
-0.6540431976318359,
0.22866958379745483,
-0.14923885464668274,
-0.3314483165740967,
0.37349122762680054,
-0.11150188744068146,
-0.09637168794870377,
-0.16837956011295319,
-0.5472226142883301,
-0.05963568016886711,
0.0548015795648098,
0.21086381375789642,
0.402300626039505,
-0.10616295039653778,
0.17010338604450226,
0.03321055695414543,
-0.36893725395202637,
0.09650665521621704,
-0.6159472465515137,
0.8887174725532532,
-0.1045946255326271,
-0.061425257474184036,
-0.04442097991704941,
0.11808247119188309,
0.2400648593902588,
-0.41290631890296936,
0.5715667605400085,
0.6337867975234985,
-0.27449068427085876,
-0.26846855878829956,
-0.6187765598297119,
-0.029578745365142822,
-0.4612204134464264,
0.47675901651382446,
-0.3850647211074829,
-1.2730414867401123,
0.01444308366626501,
-0.31204918026924133,
-0.03584267571568489,
0.11923249065876007,
0.3917081654071808,
0.12516644597053528,
0.7427829504013062,
0.6981604695320129,
-0.08366759121417999,
0.5941473841667175,
-0.20394417643547058,
0.2590719759464264,
-0.9376825094223022,
0.04006054624915123,
-0.21643298864364624,
-0.19445385038852692,
-0.46386584639549255,
-0.8269296884536743,
0.30733007192611694,
0.7054197788238525,
-0.03636929392814636,
0.20130541920661926,
-0.48734959959983826,
0.6183531880378723,
0.750669538974762,
0.1821974813938141,
0.0948181077837944,
0.09586907923221588,
0.14947830140590668,
0.17924852669239044,
-0.764809787273407,
-0.5145649313926697,
1.232428789138794,
0.07383277267217636,
0.8245701789855957,
-0.1355612426996231,
0.8319118022918701,
0.1861751824617386,
0.5950782895088196,
-0.8304786086082458,
0.7814605832099915,
-0.2708856165409088,
-0.4676121473312378,
-0.5717388391494751,
-0.7997573018074036,
-1.2469086647033691,
0.3382352888584137,
-0.09805326163768768,
-0.3848053216934204,
-0.3662373423576355,
0.12021679431200027,
-0.45065733790397644,
0.43798142671585083,
-0.39023640751838684,
0.9582343697547913,
-0.24508874118328094,
-0.19447173178195953,
-0.343547523021698,
-0.8790116906166077,
0.5797936916351318,
-0.3972755968570709,
0.23785801231861115,
-0.2769915461540222,
-0.3147223889827728,
0.8683099150657654,
-0.674972414970398,
0.5185695886611938,
-0.06840777397155762,
-0.2203799933195114,
0.20219722390174866,
0.018757222220301628,
0.46336764097213745,
-0.22713521122932434,
0.1977759301662445,
0.5166476964950562,
0.11410684138536453,
-0.5836220979690552,
-0.4935334622859955,
0.45005711913108826,
-0.5118321776390076,
-0.7144536972045898,
-0.22136329114437103,
-0.5229745507240295,
-0.15414093434810638,
0.23557093739509583,
0.19191178679466248,
0.5139845609664917,
0.03177052363753319,
0.18105001747608185,
0.8591210246086121,
-0.27918192744255066,
0.3822821080684662,
0.3795023262500763,
-0.3382531702518463,
-0.7717486023902893,
0.9725534915924072,
0.1414656639099121,
0.3086581826210022,
0.7911770939826965,
0.3119117021560669,
-0.39329269528388977,
-0.9526049494743347,
-0.31460994482040405,
0.3053196370601654,
-0.5232447981834412,
-0.1652761846780777,
-0.4895293414592743,
-0.04077667370438576,
-0.45082053542137146,
-0.04904472082853317,
-0.3748737573623657,
-0.3956611156463623,
-0.210794597864151,
0.11925555765628815,
0.03518233820796013,
0.26192668080329895,
-0.11505201458930969,
0.5473480224609375,
-1.0523160696029663,
0.26007264852523804,
0.5112450122833252,
0.46222251653671265,
-0.47093769907951355,
-0.5537274479866028,
-0.5211498141288757,
-0.41506093740463257,
-0.1269419938325882,
-0.555989146232605,
0.4161425232887268,
-0.046203479170799255,
0.160115584731102,
0.5303317904472351,
0.00897605437785387,
0.6172405481338501,
-0.5762401819229126,
0.6030706763267517,
0.5326802134513855,
-1.0122147798538208,
0.3021904230117798,
-0.03421827033162117,
0.26189398765563965,
0.4580458700656891,
0.41027605533599854,
-0.474115788936615,
-0.14394700527191162,
-0.5264894962310791,
-0.881921112537384,
0.7082938551902771,
-0.02670278400182724,
0.14126530289649963,
0.14996863901615143,
0.2600407302379608,
0.18192929029464722,
0.5059192776679993,
-0.5314558744430542,
-0.37414517998695374,
0.018672266975045204,
-0.17900101840496063,
-0.14905548095703125,
-0.5021381378173828,
-0.1635463684797287,
-0.15226133167743683,
0.7054652571678162,
-0.11311311274766922,
0.16203883290290833,
-0.039097633212804794,
-0.14248231053352356,
0.007813473232090473,
0.3616430461406708,
0.5959397554397583,
0.6662644743919373,
-0.23206555843353271,
0.5055909752845764,
0.18838061392307281,
-0.49452701210975647,
0.33123597502708435,
0.5267043113708496,
-0.01577853225171566,
0.08660499006509781,
0.1320277601480484,
1.0584467649459839,
0.24065573513507843,
-0.8160721063613892,
0.5769903659820557,
-0.11451853811740875,
-0.36309266090393066,
-0.04529149457812309,
0.029791681095957756,
0.00891683716326952,
0.34251636266708374,
0.4225206971168518,
-0.08396457880735397,
-0.08287090808153152,
-0.25651469826698303,
0.17739008367061615,
0.7342202067375183,
-0.26319268345832825,
-0.38849812746047974,
0.7553750872612,
0.004104256629943848,
-0.3595345616340637,
0.20254850387573242,
-0.3435894250869751,
-0.6162520051002502,
0.27285951375961304,
0.31400686502456665,
0.9333249926567078,
-0.28381434082984924,
-0.0010319577995687723,
0.18981000781059265,
0.464851438999176,
-0.13024602830410004,
0.11592420935630798,
-0.34299546480178833,
-0.5923498868942261,
-0.6546566486358643,
-0.9418965578079224,
-0.41818198561668396,
0.12942777574062347,
-0.39815884828567505,
0.2549588084220886,
-0.7788470387458801,
-0.27586090564727783,
-0.38457098603248596,
0.21623347699642181,
-0.38381436467170715,
0.3917725384235382,
0.4973348379135132,
0.538597822189331,
-0.22955477237701416,
0.853129506111145,
0.4682160019874573,
-0.030510183423757553,
-0.7060577869415283,
-0.33527418971061707,
-0.4320041239261627,
-0.929692804813385,
0.6333609819412231,
0.2276677042245865,
-0.006546464283019304,
0.3835960924625397,
-0.6073296070098877,
-0.6550682783126831,
0.8885145783424377,
0.6754955053329468,
-0.9973111748695374,
0.10421564429998398,
0.17133931815624237,
0.01978113129734993,
0.1841873675584793,
0.2960679531097412,
0.4709678888320923,
0.3394228518009186,
0.11267946660518646,
-0.7815507054328918,
0.1845162957906723,
-0.04407263919711113,
0.0983109325170517,
0.7058170437812805,
-0.7272147536277771,
0.845693051815033,
-0.10257059335708618,
-0.348478764295578,
-0.1629520207643509,
0.5282430648803711,
0.5825520753860474,
0.08410060405731201,
0.7079161405563354,
0.7807995676994324,
0.8099549412727356,
-0.02383396402001381,
0.876205325126648,
-0.46330204606056213,
0.2962113320827484,
0.9576674699783325,
-0.04501122981309891,
0.5981996059417725,
0.5353955030441284,
-0.46551716327667236,
0.19385100901126862,
0.8207617402076721,
0.16527535021305084,
0.41976070404052734,
0.9044023156166077,
-0.8037636876106262,
-0.4613092243671417,
-0.05262088030576706,
-0.23792660236358643,
0.06704048812389374,
-0.07854893058538437,
-0.13719603419303894,
-0.09656156599521637,
-0.07624714076519012,
0.07786338776350021,
-0.5043249130249023,
-0.527766764163971,
0.5407832264900208,
0.28261059522628784,
-0.2853649854660034,
0.9667844176292419,
0.07973268628120422,
0.9873301982879639,
-0.9203433394432068,
0.07987915724515915,
-0.3793668746948242,
-0.06681407988071442,
0.035128235816955566,
-0.24872569739818573,
0.03659677132964134,
-0.15396030247211456,
0.01627785712480545,
-0.47628527879714966,
0.6474746465682983,
-0.6190764307975769,
-0.408040314912796,
-0.08339374512434006,
0.24507677555084229,
0.5134918093681335,
-0.5851688385009766,
-0.2898866534233093,
0.12765024602413177,
-0.07196531444787979,
-0.46594470739364624,
0.48128336668014526,
0.5896055698394775,
0.07673462480306625,
0.5947948694229126,
0.757822573184967,
0.3350253999233246,
0.29487136006355286,
0.040599431842565536,
0.7729470729827881,
-0.7579113245010376,
-0.36472848057746887,
-1.0482914447784424,
0.26147162914276123,
0.33443060517311096,
-0.1843082159757614,
0.5740281939506531,
0.8053575158119202,
0.8525208234786987,
0.013657920062541962,
0.6772618293762207,
0.2517782151699066,
-0.08679487556219101,
-0.6660327911376953,
0.6576294302940369,
-0.636440634727478,
0.18953780829906464,
0.21235360205173492,
-0.8542004227638245,
-0.5642182230949402,
0.42088186740875244,
-0.17206783592700958,
-0.06218043342232704,
0.6330390572547913,
0.7316979765892029,
0.2844317853450775,
-0.3557610809803009,
0.6912788152694702,
-0.04714801162481308,
0.2719806134700775,
0.8455419540405273,
0.7186785936355591,
-0.43411940336227417,
0.8687052726745605,
0.09392717480659485,
-0.2836260497570038,
-0.2009161412715912,
-0.7139898538589478,
-0.8518733978271484,
-0.09752999991178513,
-0.4479111433029175,
-0.05185697227716446,
-0.11267494410276413,
0.9686614274978638,
0.9631057977676392,
-0.36795774102211,
-0.09487242251634598,
-0.23885314166545868,
0.13256758451461792,
-0.11061874777078629,
-0.1590431034564972,
0.31061094999313354,
-0.32254138588905334,
-0.7288210988044739,
0.26406654715538025,
0.5321555137634277,
0.07874123007059097,
-0.33032646775245667,
-0.13785269856452942,
0.12188923358917236,
0.23747077584266663,
0.7128463983535767,
0.06841908395290375,
-0.4804498255252838,
-0.021840926259756088,
-0.3468327522277832,
-0.23937560617923737,
0.29968446493148804,
0.8897219300270081,
-0.6423888802528381,
0.4894482493400574,
0.24974189698696136,
0.8707267642021179,
0.9117196202278137,
0.10387010127305984,
0.2717067301273346,
-0.6906099915504456,
0.0804644227027893,
0.4536794424057007,
0.06746875494718552,
0.17357704043388367,
0.0023082992993295193,
0.41068071126937866,
0.4308672547340393,
-0.5563947558403015,
-0.9105825424194336,
-0.01658039167523384,
-0.9780458807945251,
-0.3943498730659485,
0.9016742706298828,
-0.1282966136932373,
-0.4360767900943756,
0.20977386832237244,
-0.3246915340423584,
0.5281172394752502,
-0.10455503314733505,
0.7203590273857117,
0.726326048374176,
0.0954919084906578,
-0.4511047601699829,
-0.39574921131134033,
0.37508678436279297,
0.6589038372039795,
-0.943288266658783,
0.09596241265535355,
0.34661364555358887,
0.24659417569637299,
-0.17212635278701782,
0.9250884056091309,
0.05681150034070015,
-0.06394007056951523,
0.15304070711135864,
0.6358832716941833,
-0.2988643944263458,
-0.05161101743578911,
-0.5556063055992126,
0.1552857905626297,
0.10997011512517929,
-0.5150432586669922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03832v1 | Rethinking Skill Extraction in the Job Market Domain using Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T09:23:26 | 2024-02-06T09:23:26 | Khanh Cao Nguyen, Mike Zhang, Syrielle Montariol, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | Skill Extraction involves identifying skills and qualifications mentioned in
documents such as job postings and resumes. The task is commonly tackled by
training supervised models using a sequence labeling approach with BIO tags.
However, the reliance on manually annotated data limits the generalizability of
such approaches. Moreover, the common BIO setting limits the ability of the
models to capture complex skill patterns and handle ambiguous mentions. In this
paper, we explore the use of in-context learning to overcome these challenges,
on a benchmark of 6 uniformized skill extraction datasets. Our approach
leverages the few-shot learning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to
identify and extract skills from sentences. We show that LLMs, despite not
being on par with traditional supervised models in terms of performance, can
better handle syntactically complex skill mentions in skill extraction tasks. | [
-0.03217463940382004,
-0.7395898103713989,
0.591916024684906,
-0.20556874573230743,
-0.08460044115781784,
0.04155164957046509,
-0.4025784134864807,
-0.9227849841117859,
-0.1993534117937088,
0.5339094996452332,
-0.43528464436531067,
-0.4934088885784149,
-0.811903715133667,
0.25081968307495117,
-0.15401339530944824,
0.855326235294342,
0.2950592339038849,
-0.1874420940876007,
-0.3380938768386841,
-0.005080457776784897,
-0.46796053647994995,
-0.4410672187805176,
-0.576637327671051,
-0.310625821352005,
0.5536120533943176,
0.6454041600227356,
0.2636760473251343,
0.7948865294456482,
0.521406352519989,
0.28332626819610596,
0.09864188730716705,
0.39020204544067383,
-0.3875293731689453,
0.24593991041183472,
-0.14606167376041412,
-0.4682930111885071,
-0.38928520679473877,
0.25613006949424744,
0.6848386526107788,
0.9836632609367371,
0.10504242032766342,
0.3541840612888336,
0.05552142485976219,
0.18001146614551544,
-0.4948686361312866,
0.5051619410514832,
-0.9984625577926636,
-0.20327319204807281,
-0.5379711985588074,
-0.05387397110462189,
-0.44072169065475464,
-0.06150055304169655,
0.2408241331577301,
-0.47081759572029114,
0.24509309232234955,
-0.3259679973125458,
0.9297142028808594,
-0.0077161951921880245,
-0.3498305380344391,
-0.16618934273719788,
-0.5431131720542908,
0.9432789087295532,
-0.661689817905426,
0.2462751418352127,
0.5358442664146423,
0.6719503402709961,
-0.09096690267324448,
-0.7012099623680115,
-0.22871366143226624,
0.24557465314865112,
-0.09502507001161575,
-0.1548323929309845,
0.31893467903137207,
-0.13637959957122803,
0.5724594593048096,
-0.03241324424743652,
-0.1721780151128769,
0.5594359636306763,
-0.47256505489349365,
0.23580330610275269,
0.793609082698822,
0.03614063188433647,
0.07030288130044937,
-0.08500488847494125,
-0.20066262781620026,
-0.1271996945142746,
-0.7590451240539551,
0.34419742226600647,
0.21058252453804016,
0.5917513966560364,
0.15788213908672333,
0.4460541307926178,
-0.4066804349422455,
0.8847464919090271,
-0.2116427719593048,
-0.6912841796875,
0.21341592073440552,
0.03558870032429695,
-0.24270887672901154,
-0.23734532296657562,
0.6045912504196167,
-0.14807935059070587,
0.3690100908279419,
-0.3936039209365845,
-0.29371246695518494,
-0.50754714012146,
0.4592902660369873,
-0.5735282301902771,
0.07570359855890274,
-0.004498298745602369,
-0.3308744728565216,
-0.30604299902915955,
0.2721007168292999,
-0.7378975749015808,
-0.3871247172355652,
-0.04694874957203865,
0.3283148407936096,
-0.3103010356426239,
0.06758637726306915,
-0.2089047133922577,
-0.2356591820716858,
0.4583793878555298,
0.23935465514659882,
-1.0389533042907715,
0.12730568647384644,
0.9345953464508057,
0.6375513672828674,
-0.18505899608135223,
-0.15497547388076782,
-0.6550727486610413,
0.22393415868282318,
-0.06682143360376358,
0.7125058174133301,
-0.9866230487823486,
-0.11458088457584381,
0.2693718373775482,
0.2291974276304245,
-0.18244227766990662,
-0.6772750616073608,
0.11666133254766464,
-0.7485327124595642,
-0.12918458878993988,
-0.25774911046028137,
-0.5256311893463135,
-0.2716275453567505,
0.2012409269809723,
-0.5942137241363525,
1.0794416666030884,
0.413246750831604,
-0.4235970377922058,
0.7016305923461914,
-0.4239526093006134,
-0.49152475595474243,
0.45485934615135193,
-0.5595873594284058,
-0.42495670914649963,
-0.01056643296033144,
-0.02558259665966034,
1.0018579959869385,
-0.23439528048038483,
0.185354083776474,
-0.34121593832969666,
-0.5782466530799866,
0.3880242705345154,
-0.26558858156204224,
0.6213986277580261,
0.024558493867516518,
-0.14181889593601227,
-0.2957136631011963,
-0.7378788590431213,
-0.03140686824917793,
-0.027721049264073372,
-0.6633307337760925,
-0.2260105013847351,
-0.21695654094219208,
-0.19213883578777313,
0.5771878957748413,
-0.02627607434988022,
-0.49287641048431396,
0.3511071503162384,
-0.7230404019355774,
0.23040662705898285,
0.5668873190879822,
-0.08358314633369446,
0.596490204334259,
-0.1446291208267212,
0.7044171690940857,
-0.1468895971775055,
-0.40195727348327637,
-0.16186927258968353,
-0.2929650545120239,
-0.08600965887308121,
-0.6992570161819458,
0.30742010474205017,
0.5437253713607788,
-0.7550807595252991,
0.46275249123573303,
-0.35705387592315674,
-0.5902944207191467,
-0.5925869941711426,
0.577194094657898,
0.4766109883785248,
0.6160959601402283,
0.3550192713737488,
-0.41481465101242065,
-0.4749382436275482,
-0.7595559358596802,
-0.5529532432556152,
0.2918638586997986,
-0.033284518867731094,
0.27881044149398804,
0.47498252987861633,
-0.15418663620948792,
1.252626657485962,
-0.5050190687179565,
-0.32599470019340515,
-0.48721927404403687,
0.14320731163024902,
0.3860919773578644,
0.39560264348983765,
0.17951600253582,
-0.8045526742935181,
-0.42362645268440247,
0.2340928167104721,
-1.0538091659545898,
0.08009612560272217,
-0.21157382428646088,
0.06565120071172714,
0.14479444921016693,
0.6193059086799622,
-0.7769517302513123,
0.35005754232406616,
0.10360193997621536,
0.22273984551429749,
0.4337829053401947,
0.04533899948000908,
-0.31746402382850647,
-0.9396335482597351,
0.40954136848449707,
0.4770001471042633,
-0.3929591178894043,
-0.5531060099601746,
0.051747530698776245,
0.039405327290296555,
-0.09402059018611908,
-0.6584807634353638,
0.773320198059082,
-0.5625438094139099,
-0.38956233859062195,
-0.23386381566524506,
0.06283286958932877,
-0.12888814508914948,
0.32203879952430725,
0.26944246888160706,
0.6249070167541504,
0.4350363612174988,
-0.49721479415893555,
0.1967582255601883,
0.43806198239326477,
-0.5430422425270081,
0.32300883531570435,
-0.251920610666275,
0.21309798955917358,
-0.23188786208629608,
0.3294578492641449,
-0.8678324222564697,
-0.5185526013374329,
-0.053044531494379044,
-0.0352918803691864,
0.5199517607688904,
-0.36400192975997925,
-0.49630269408226013,
-0.31556567549705505,
-0.10778253525495529,
0.19829434156417847,
0.469461590051651,
-0.3618347644805908,
0.30976253747940063,
0.4696570932865143,
-0.2592969536781311,
-0.8554937839508057,
-0.6067005395889282,
-0.18000797927379608,
-0.36673519015312195,
-0.30320608615875244,
0.5029219388961792,
0.429085910320282,
-0.18959975242614746,
-0.5026099681854248,
-0.17119206488132477,
-0.5208463072776794,
0.5125241279602051,
0.18386247754096985,
0.3071399927139282,
-0.032355718314647675,
0.30805864930152893,
-0.09328345954418182,
-0.14721453189849854,
-0.11533504724502563,
0.019930997863411903,
0.09957230091094971,
0.2972477972507477,
-0.14253224432468414,
-0.3138183653354645,
0.20088912546634674,
0.39645522832870483,
-0.19534257054328918,
0.9227791428565979,
0.8279344439506531,
-0.45091986656188965,
-0.35413944721221924,
-0.709432065486908,
-0.37396708130836487,
-0.4562128484249115,
0.537306547164917,
-0.41219258308410645,
-0.8740348815917969,
0.29100561141967773,
-0.537680447101593,
0.10396628081798553,
0.5033751130104065,
0.19854328036308289,
-0.42078179121017456,
0.6187095046043396,
0.9168731570243835,
-0.03975769504904747,
0.5573694705963135,
-0.3801833391189575,
0.1215389296412468,
-0.7838230133056641,
-0.38834017515182495,
-0.38489314913749695,
-0.23689036071300507,
-0.33163660764694214,
-0.17263583838939667,
0.3914341628551483,
0.16026993095874786,
0.07732397317886353,
0.41278159618377686,
-0.2501008212566376,
0.5193352699279785,
0.44193312525749207,
0.3641287088394165,
0.040715012699365616,
-0.021153882145881653,
0.22089484333992004,
0.06009916216135025,
-0.6716804504394531,
-0.6111814975738525,
1.1413923501968384,
0.45893213152885437,
0.3766235411167145,
-0.098406583070755,
0.691647469997406,
-0.05259447917342186,
0.3301622271537781,
-0.8804534673690796,
0.3953242897987366,
-0.5124994516372681,
-0.5098884105682373,
-0.6120643615722656,
-0.2612002491950989,
-0.9391432404518127,
0.2966903746128082,
-0.4653884768486023,
-0.7891976237297058,
0.17473198473453522,
-0.18530204892158508,
-0.696725606918335,
0.13481241464614868,
-0.5482940077781677,
0.9960070252418518,
-0.019760174676775932,
-0.4066798985004425,
0.17419031262397766,
-0.820932924747467,
0.23712791502475739,
-0.44866102933883667,
0.4988081157207489,
-0.11861294507980347,
0.07929578423500061,
0.6841202974319458,
-0.20398522913455963,
1.3127294778823853,
-0.06522247940301895,
-0.030531903728842735,
0.0678858682513237,
-0.03809776529669762,
0.6033623218536377,
-0.16777601838111877,
-0.48853304982185364,
0.19646528363227844,
0.0888751819729805,
-0.35629183053970337,
-0.23522761464118958,
0.2935809791088104,
-0.4632492959499359,
-0.3958315849304199,
-0.1549919843673706,
-0.5981752872467041,
-0.4903676211833954,
0.14639224112033844,
0.3522534966468811,
0.3256581723690033,
-0.18293701112270355,
0.3829692006111145,
0.6629064083099365,
-0.2141258418560028,
0.5674015283584595,
0.18861740827560425,
0.4257536828517914,
0.046406473964452744,
0.6398205757141113,
0.4083888828754425,
0.1390610784292221,
0.26115748286247253,
-0.1107722818851471,
-0.07706154882907867,
-0.18389953672885895,
0.03211507201194763,
0.2697886824607849,
-0.8974067568778992,
-0.41947105526924133,
-0.6659138202667236,
-0.2931118607521057,
-0.6935867071151733,
-0.26988422870635986,
-0.1153838038444519,
0.01732870191335678,
-0.3939829170703888,
-0.09209135174751282,
0.2106233835220337,
0.6959424018859863,
0.2993859648704529,
0.4118298590183258,
-0.9785724878311157,
0.17259427905082703,
0.42554596066474915,
0.29645612835884094,
-0.08829210698604584,
-0.47806528210639954,
-0.6198751330375671,
-0.18371541798114777,
-0.1874402016401291,
-0.8402775526046753,
0.5455151200294495,
0.4039369225502014,
0.8240962028503418,
0.3560405969619751,
-0.430266410112381,
0.6392070651054382,
-0.40871569514274597,
0.6955097317695618,
-0.12834225594997406,
-0.5808793902397156,
0.39389583468437195,
-0.31525304913520813,
0.34137284755706787,
0.7107826471328735,
0.765819251537323,
-0.5245784521102905,
-0.11252238601446152,
-0.7283509373664856,
-0.892467200756073,
0.8302024006843567,
-0.17774125933647156,
0.12982147932052612,
-0.34697049856185913,
0.7058166861534119,
0.6535936594009399,
0.3054365813732147,
-0.654474139213562,
0.34692439436912537,
0.5108157992362976,
-0.3751334547996521,
-0.15905947983264923,
-0.46859443187713623,
0.008247899822890759,
-0.2940202057361603,
0.3118438422679901,
-0.25433865189552307,
0.009223765693604946,
-0.09011802822351456,
-0.5870575904846191,
0.03772091120481491,
0.23644638061523438,
0.2820096015930176,
0.8701243996620178,
-0.0738249346613884,
0.07513482868671417,
0.40292996168136597,
-0.09150106459856033,
-0.20820803940296173,
-0.11292001605033875,
0.3238309323787689,
-0.0684111937880516,
0.7029100656509399,
0.2675996720790863,
0.5456494688987732,
-0.8022900819778442,
0.7947325706481934,
0.5964236259460449,
-0.15920449793338776,
-0.3156527578830719,
0.21586982905864716,
-0.09750727564096451,
0.45720311999320984,
0.41127505898475647,
-0.1805410236120224,
0.01480654813349247,
-0.7138532996177673,
0.3785537779331207,
0.6379247903823853,
-0.3898026943206787,
-0.2091759592294693,
0.3548642098903656,
0.1976967304944992,
-0.24449802935123444,
0.7997650504112244,
0.025243647396564484,
-0.22014617919921875,
0.6833250522613525,
0.634406328201294,
0.6256360411643982,
-0.062024377286434174,
0.10500861704349518,
0.30806228518486023,
-0.03488188609480858,
-0.5494269132614136,
-0.02295312099158764,
-0.011274696327745914,
-0.6755669116973877,
-0.49106425046920776,
-0.5001760721206665,
-0.3534105122089386,
0.04418638348579407,
-0.5318722128868103,
0.36406639218330383,
-0.4812108874320984,
-0.14604924619197845,
0.19794872403144836,
-0.13696493208408356,
-1.1509326696395874,
0.39093995094299316,
0.27131354808807373,
0.5719021558761597,
-1.1637629270553589,
1.2019069194793701,
0.5322479605674744,
-0.6017081141471863,
-0.5668511986732483,
-0.27665576338768005,
-0.06611742824316025,
-0.6718106865882874,
1.071877360343933,
0.4575076997280121,
0.1615816056728363,
0.0024034699890762568,
-0.7880060076713562,
-0.6398369669914246,
1.2094517946243286,
0.46314480900764465,
-0.35285714268684387,
-0.2518852651119232,
0.07148242741823196,
0.35498204827308655,
-0.8126556277275085,
0.3190355896949768,
0.7327814698219299,
0.2211642563343048,
-0.09954678267240524,
-1.007591962814331,
-0.08456984162330627,
0.029864273965358734,
0.04960491880774498,
-0.23670253157615662,
-0.3139038383960724,
0.8416115045547485,
0.017726829275488853,
-0.21011249721050262,
-0.27370452880859375,
0.33127930760383606,
0.21549640595912933,
0.14235720038414001,
0.3226006329059601,
0.037677422165870667,
0.9793244004249573,
0.12396393716335297,
1.0493086576461792,
0.25242623686790466,
0.19290560483932495,
1.1171315908432007,
-0.36940279603004456,
1.0851229429244995,
0.38508880138397217,
0.019178248941898346,
0.7579527497291565,
0.5487481951713562,
-0.15119528770446777,
0.28270435333251953,
0.06841852515935898,
-0.043836094439029694,
-0.5333186984062195,
0.04264921694993973,
-0.04293622449040413,
0.7700057029724121,
0.36987167596817017,
-0.47641050815582275,
-0.2908444404602051,
0.1800132393836975,
-0.06714965403079987,
0.07187431305646896,
-0.17169582843780518,
1.0336084365844727,
0.3630056083202362,
-0.45479026436805725,
0.23655939102172852,
0.039841894060373306,
0.7758287191390991,
-0.528397262096405,
-0.538943886756897,
0.043956924229860306,
-0.0904529020190239,
-0.32522717118263245,
-0.7360764145851135,
0.29507768154144287,
-0.03692318871617317,
-0.13866651058197021,
-0.49122434854507446,
1.0007524490356445,
-0.5214759111404419,
-0.3425792455673218,
0.062628835439682,
0.5027130842208862,
0.35235562920570374,
-0.14359764754772186,
-0.421353280544281,
-0.25641703605651855,
-0.3573782742023468,
-0.05957154929637909,
0.5794198513031006,
0.4934769868850708,
-0.027991311624646187,
0.5821152329444885,
0.532931923866272,
0.15887057781219482,
-0.09904739260673523,
-0.29336050152778625,
0.5594651699066162,
-0.7522540092468262,
-0.43124642968177795,
-0.8598249554634094,
0.5857182741165161,
-0.39216184616088867,
-0.31742873787879944,
0.41552338004112244,
0.35078164935112,
1.0315378904342651,
-0.250165194272995,
0.7986595630645752,
0.17877495288848877,
0.45004430413246155,
-0.46842101216316223,
0.5824059247970581,
-0.46091872453689575,
0.35380658507347107,
-0.3540251851081848,
-0.8873494267463684,
-0.3888982832431793,
0.534903883934021,
-0.6259483695030212,
0.26989907026290894,
0.6668204069137573,
0.6355831027030945,
-0.08923650532960892,
-0.4554527997970581,
0.5899907946586609,
-0.0991857647895813,
0.15911881625652313,
0.41045114398002625,
0.3893176317214966,
-0.3787335455417633,
0.3126008212566376,
-0.13079245388507843,
-0.09335817396640778,
-0.42831867933273315,
-0.8911317586898804,
-0.8566190600395203,
-0.4241184890270233,
-0.375033974647522,
-0.1203620582818985,
-0.07305384427309036,
0.9636465311050415,
0.875902533531189,
-0.48322489857673645,
-0.4541843831539154,
0.4837448000907898,
0.08770287036895752,
-0.6590996980667114,
-0.21115721762180328,
0.20928464829921722,
-0.5874136686325073,
-0.5109797716140747,
0.8252370357513428,
0.12848161160945892,
-0.22777694463729858,
0.16069470345973969,
0.3756991922855377,
-0.41281768679618835,
-0.18839587271213531,
0.652452826499939,
0.43086859583854675,
-0.5508894920349121,
-0.5312762260437012,
-0.31668397784233093,
-0.3574973940849304,
-0.035027727484703064,
0.5899370908737183,
-0.8605961203575134,
0.3989909887313843,
0.3423345685005188,
0.8997427225112915,
0.3706360161304474,
0.08634888380765915,
0.5365183353424072,
-1.257521152496338,
0.21152475476264954,
0.015011086128652096,
0.13358959555625916,
0.21861043572425842,
-0.6150382161140442,
0.6417374014854431,
0.3153197169303894,
-0.23134414851665497,
-0.7492870092391968,
0.019784701988101006,
-0.8433580994606018,
-0.5562413334846497,
1.2781805992126465,
-0.24990913271903992,
-0.24830837547779083,
-0.2967240810394287,
0.1401897817850113,
0.40696123242378235,
-0.001636343658901751,
0.9113553762435913,
0.6217533349990845,
0.04244471713900566,
-0.16413342952728271,
-0.8757848739624023,
0.5398685336112976,
0.027776962146162987,
-0.7564433813095093,
0.028629286214709282,
0.3037988245487213,
0.47576582431793213,
-0.17664536833763123,
0.7000163793563843,
-0.14640308916568756,
0.3820990025997162,
-0.29067790508270264,
0.24425500631332397,
-0.020130261778831482,
-0.5700306296348572,
-0.4800056517124176,
0.5705723166465759,
0.33744513988494873,
-0.04155496507883072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03822v2 | RevOrder: A Novel Method for Enhanced Arithmetic in Language Models | 2024-02-06T09:10:35 | 2024-02-24T01:11:14 | Si Shen, Peijun Shen, Danhao Zhu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents RevOrder, a novel technique aimed at improving arithmetic
operations in large language models (LLMs) by reversing the output digits in
addition, subtraction, and n-digit by 1-digit (nD by 1D) multiplication tasks.
Our method significantly reduces the Count of Sequential Intermediate Digits
(CSID) to $\mathcal{O}(1)$, a new metric we introduce to assess equation
complexity. Through comprehensive testing, RevOrder not only achieves perfect
accuracy in basic arithmetic operations but also substantially boosts LLM
performance in division tasks, particularly with large numbers where
traditional models struggle. Implementation of RevOrder is cost-effective for
both training and inference phases. Moreover, applying RevOrder to fine-tune
the LLaMA2-7B model on the GSM8K math task results in a considerable
improvement, reducing equation calculation errors by 46% and increasing overall
scores from 41.6 to 44.4. | [
-0.26269009709358215,
-0.7346792221069336,
0.15311840176582336,
0.4146926999092102,
-0.35802772641181946,
0.1776268184185028,
0.10408705472946167,
-0.4151441156864166,
0.15623866021633148,
0.5354539155960083,
-0.6276215314865112,
-0.3531108498573303,
-0.6202189326286316,
-0.03390834480524063,
-0.21717117726802826,
0.556367039680481,
0.04895360395312309,
0.49937599897384644,
-0.18408535420894623,
-0.2385806292295456,
-0.131715789437294,
-0.6477781534194946,
-0.6651025414466858,
-0.44900190830230713,
0.42012590169906616,
0.42892223596572876,
0.6686474084854126,
0.4332258701324463,
0.8870130181312561,
0.4710654020309448,
-0.02490677498281002,
0.2206905633211136,
-0.6134353876113892,
0.15154790878295898,
-0.05762791261076927,
-0.7655981183052063,
-0.8978493213653564,
-0.1772995889186859,
0.7077170610427856,
0.9738544225692749,
-0.37851110100746155,
0.18932873010635376,
-0.45466941595077515,
1.0787019729614258,
-0.6032816767692566,
0.11183477193117142,
-0.4439469873905182,
-0.22194452583789825,
-0.15732792019844055,
0.007879500277340412,
-0.5381879806518555,
-0.6008673906326294,
-0.199983149766922,
-0.5462741255760193,
0.2604311406612396,
-0.13547486066818237,
0.404410719871521,
0.1700553596019745,
-0.24026386439800262,
-0.05457562580704689,
-0.8005741238594055,
0.8165218830108643,
-1.0191880464553833,
0.8093162178993225,
-0.08604400604963303,
0.214690163731575,
-0.25228944420814514,
-0.839137613773346,
-0.6828925609588623,
0.09050256013870239,
0.1992432028055191,
0.05050445720553398,
-0.22649294137954712,
0.16757456958293915,
0.41768041253089905,
0.5697087049484253,
-0.32088956236839294,
0.2476770281791687,
-0.34286049008369446,
-0.030059266835451126,
0.8127630949020386,
0.4333363175392151,
0.3131055533885956,
0.4395882189273834,
0.008908633142709732,
-0.2117549329996109,
-1.017670750617981,
0.03758401796221733,
0.2789054811000824,
0.09538768231868744,
0.07961823046207428,
0.699421226978302,
-0.5878745913505554,
0.5135500431060791,
0.18863093852996826,
-0.3587779700756073,
0.4682154655456543,
-0.11588013172149658,
-0.5203091502189636,
-0.09104174375534058,
0.4026738703250885,
0.36908796429634094,
0.05337418243288994,
0.02150856889784336,
-0.5370720028877258,
0.23298606276512146,
0.0907849371433258,
-1.2396578788757324,
-0.33246055245399475,
-0.05236976966261864,
-0.030325232073664665,
-0.3559449017047882,
-0.10398506373167038,
-0.4376152753829956,
-0.21527646481990814,
-0.34719353914260864,
0.45502981543540955,
-0.19952568411827087,
0.050290629267692566,
0.2548612356185913,
0.2724428176879883,
0.14918282628059387,
0.6544092297554016,
-0.7533270120620728,
0.4891129732131958,
1.0534300804138184,
0.5739724636077881,
0.10976305603981018,
-0.24396058917045593,
-0.47817325592041016,
-0.5273241400718689,
-0.7098537683486938,
0.5705665349960327,
-0.5699695944786072,
-0.3696155846118927,
-0.23513533174991608,
-0.033490151166915894,
0.02388012781739235,
-0.6093980073928833,
0.6166225075721741,
-1.0239996910095215,
0.19868390262126923,
0.12702099978923798,
-0.45940014719963074,
-0.45684880018234253,
0.15138126909732819,
-0.7172448635101318,
0.907463014125824,
0.08368363976478577,
-0.33150714635849,
-0.014811351895332336,
-0.4085346460342407,
-0.6010953783988953,
-0.009401997551321983,
0.31169432401657104,
-0.5552076697349548,
0.6154992580413818,
0.3528742790222168,
0.04947806894779205,
-0.5650435090065002,
0.08171175420284271,
-0.3462739884853363,
-0.3405609428882599,
0.22073817253112793,
-0.8339698314666748,
0.6871902346611023,
-0.07626119256019592,
-0.06579694896936417,
0.08801224827766418,
-0.9573633670806885,
0.13412614166736603,
0.22398993372917175,
-0.39855772256851196,
-0.371050626039505,
-0.1905171424150467,
-0.4300248920917511,
0.07093995809555054,
0.47493839263916016,
-0.5596844553947449,
0.4231240153312683,
-0.8976828455924988,
0.03541647642850876,
0.6846910119056702,
0.003864165162667632,
0.6733410358428955,
-0.17931786179542542,
0.47693899273872375,
-0.19116847217082977,
0.25244036316871643,
-0.3827096223831177,
-0.5177503824234009,
-1.0702729225158691,
-0.1626787632703781,
0.34152814745903015,
0.6873564124107361,
-0.7479864954948425,
0.2812785506248474,
-0.46789082884788513,
-0.64687180519104,
-0.6736005544662476,
0.052329160273075104,
0.6446961760520935,
0.44330355525016785,
0.41183963418006897,
-0.33507490158081055,
-0.41295766830444336,
-0.652985692024231,
-0.16303759813308716,
-0.29322847723960876,
0.013528110459446907,
-0.09938687831163406,
0.10696429759263992,
-0.35208895802497864,
0.2810932397842407,
-0.5957953333854675,
0.08205605298280716,
-0.10460557043552399,
0.464626669883728,
0.4199539124965668,
0.3532126545906067,
0.0008762534707784653,
-0.7672333121299744,
-0.20181553065776825,
-0.024867337197065353,
-0.3714296817779541,
-0.5051647424697876,
-0.014208088628947735,
0.05980544164776802,
0.5649088025093079,
0.34034213423728943,
-0.4534088671207428,
0.5691897869110107,
0.6587110757827759,
-0.13736045360565186,
0.40229448676109314,
-0.24049541354179382,
0.29110273718833923,
-0.7056980133056641,
-0.3151276111602783,
-0.2057441771030426,
-0.19938142597675323,
-0.9575200080871582,
0.4582613706588745,
0.2693628966808319,
0.2397957742214203,
-0.3805375099182129,
0.0743601843714714,
-0.43677157163619995,
0.0007445712108165026,
-0.3754196763038635,
-0.06436851620674133,
0.027932830154895782,
0.3392379879951477,
-0.16954529285430908,
0.930355966091156,
0.13186830282211304,
-0.40763434767723083,
0.36052170395851135,
-0.11468910425901413,
-0.39146313071250916,
0.3399667739868164,
-0.7181690335273743,
0.3432100713253021,
-0.12366880476474762,
-0.0248678270727396,
-1.4238883256912231,
0.23047180473804474,
-0.18002422153949738,
-0.5495085120201111,
0.39510276913642883,
-0.1820780634880066,
-0.35176628828048706,
-0.24374061822891235,
-0.33281877636909485,
0.7482004761695862,
0.5171114206314087,
-0.5870906710624695,
0.8334264755249023,
0.36763089895248413,
-0.5001686215400696,
-0.4918085038661957,
-0.4722326993942261,
-0.02066892571747303,
0.16973811388015747,
-0.8388631343841553,
0.4371417760848999,
-0.09470593929290771,
-0.4829612374305725,
-0.4024854600429535,
-0.24260617792606354,
-0.03655482828617096,
0.06849194318056107,
0.12455183267593384,
0.7041962742805481,
-0.3966858983039856,
0.09253650158643723,
0.29312992095947266,
-0.31490910053253174,
0.21513967216014862,
-0.05004822090268135,
0.7621404528617859,
-0.018151268362998962,
-0.5707566142082214,
-0.24034953117370605,
0.032923102378845215,
0.7840464115142822,
-0.29505616426467896,
0.5091590285301208,
0.2237813025712967,
-0.4924947917461395,
0.03648482635617256,
-0.8515923023223877,
-0.10299190878868103,
-0.520628035068512,
0.5751763582229614,
-0.4400215744972229,
-0.7645429968833923,
0.47330644726753235,
-0.28241249918937683,
0.3787851333618164,
0.45928284525871277,
0.5047253966331482,
0.37002652883529663,
1.194167971611023,
0.4956649839878082,
-0.1602908819913864,
0.3550301194190979,
-0.20590563118457794,
0.4504384994506836,
-0.8509067893028259,
-0.27500730752944946,
-0.40460944175720215,
-0.19816924631595612,
-0.5678245425224304,
-0.7907398343086243,
0.25191086530685425,
0.44590362906455994,
-0.30228689312934875,
0.15956149995326996,
-0.3281139135360718,
0.6690917015075684,
0.22593806684017181,
-0.03766852617263794,
0.5440601706504822,
-0.05621814355254173,
0.12402588874101639,
-0.12414690852165222,
-0.43505987524986267,
-0.14459003508090973,
0.9959492683410645,
0.30467256903648376,
0.9354193210601807,
0.3604905307292938,
0.7799720168113708,
-0.011869361624121666,
0.8860874772071838,
-1.0916531085968018,
0.7183201313018799,
-0.2929184138774872,
-0.20007766783237457,
-0.5310157537460327,
-0.587876558303833,
-0.6500278115272522,
0.5421388745307922,
-0.009010178036987782,
-0.488982230424881,
0.21931137144565582,
-0.08122479170560837,
-0.2294221669435501,
0.13261321187019348,
-0.7471967935562134,
0.34283557534217834,
-0.30352696776390076,
-0.41206851601600647,
-0.4252299666404724,
-0.2786712050437927,
0.47430184483528137,
-0.14490003883838654,
0.3075805604457855,
0.049161769449710846,
-0.3110256791114807,
0.7909183502197266,
-0.8093984127044678,
0.6738572120666504,
-0.08748967945575714,
-0.4309881329536438,
-0.057451408356428146,
0.5334147810935974,
0.9513512253761292,
-0.08562083542346954,
-0.15843670070171356,
0.17923207581043243,
-0.5454221367835999,
-0.1526510864496231,
-0.8917633295059204,
0.9101648926734924,
-0.5934309959411621,
-0.8458583354949951,
-0.21446961164474487,
-0.6306969523429871,
-0.203242227435112,
0.356018602848053,
-0.0038019639905542135,
0.7277933359146118,
-0.05944235995411873,
0.03347713500261307,
0.6118037104606628,
0.0013670537155121565,
0.3993394672870636,
0.8639177083969116,
-0.45621341466903687,
-1.018035888671875,
0.7668439745903015,
0.3214953541755676,
0.4639682173728943,
0.7195687890052795,
0.10047757625579834,
-0.5353485345840454,
-0.5985161066055298,
-0.3722938001155853,
0.29310688376426697,
-0.6909263730049133,
-0.37069886922836304,
-0.3847890794277191,
-0.08178362250328064,
-0.5561591386795044,
-0.07466715574264526,
-0.5569448471069336,
-0.9607002139091492,
0.11170133203268051,
-0.20160984992980957,
0.1748090386390686,
0.7337326407432556,
0.11984698474407196,
0.2995503842830658,
-0.6677172183990479,
0.47433868050575256,
0.4100591838359833,
0.35046204924583435,
0.07556131482124329,
-0.9133184552192688,
-0.015550270676612854,
0.11624564975500107,
-0.23255009949207306,
-0.5854600667953491,
0.598760187625885,
0.018270473927259445,
0.2363157421350479,
0.29729992151260376,
-0.023068508133292198,
1.0026415586471558,
-0.6568893790245056,
0.40465599298477173,
0.3846183121204376,
-1.07725191116333,
0.011048916727304459,
0.08752456307411194,
0.4165459871292114,
0.3177565932273865,
0.13114386796951294,
-0.4192928075790405,
0.011253869161009789,
-0.5340123176574707,
-1.0868107080459595,
0.5604837536811829,
0.12549175322055817,
0.1587609052658081,
0.15824735164642334,
0.16620706021785736,
-0.24453461170196533,
0.08294650167226791,
-0.30983874201774597,
-0.5320808291435242,
0.16304445266723633,
-0.05946333333849907,
-0.2526121437549591,
-0.42857834696769714,
0.17708852887153625,
-0.48592647910118103,
0.7991451621055603,
0.15804126858711243,
0.09825797379016876,
0.21800662577152252,
-0.08458449691534042,
-0.25816577672958374,
0.37830936908721924,
0.8129451274871826,
0.7515231966972351,
0.0031823855824768543,
0.12325369566679001,
0.6554077863693237,
-0.7557472586631775,
0.17188410460948944,
0.21795162558555603,
-0.046591322869062424,
-0.1055176630616188,
0.44630348682403564,
0.5020802617073059,
0.4130822420120239,
-0.33751165866851807,
0.3656558394432068,
0.025625357404351234,
-0.12638810276985168,
-0.2780498266220093,
-0.08142302930355072,
0.176160991191864,
0.17346760630607605,
0.4440035820007324,
0.09552690386772156,
0.3847130835056305,
-0.2738094925880432,
0.12890492379665375,
0.3115059733390808,
-0.2606995105743408,
-0.32127463817596436,
0.18240886926651,
0.2148212045431137,
-0.738401472568512,
0.7197611331939697,
-0.2811616063117981,
-0.6755692958831787,
0.6464425921440125,
0.9301267862319946,
0.8524027466773987,
-0.7182391881942749,
-0.05641273781657219,
0.24178843200206757,
0.41093048453330994,
-0.1791633665561676,
0.4175119698047638,
0.205733984708786,
-0.8174248933792114,
-0.6875777244567871,
-0.5062808394432068,
-0.48905184864997864,
-0.10024948418140411,
-0.6292774677276611,
0.08007287234067917,
-0.46638038754463196,
0.07314448803663254,
0.26127055287361145,
0.020622218027710915,
-0.360073059797287,
0.14770850539207458,
-0.010695138946175575,
0.8748034834861755,
-0.4130629897117615,
0.7581250071525574,
0.6937378644943237,
0.12467335909605026,
-0.6564962863922119,
-0.25953587889671326,
0.0014228486688807607,
-1.0072565078735352,
0.7776005864143372,
0.06467203795909882,
-0.6650238633155823,
0.1651700884103775,
-0.3615950345993042,
-0.5820063352584839,
0.9304697513580322,
0.21475668251514435,
-1.003308653831482,
0.3101204037666321,
0.3776399493217468,
0.6897197961807251,
-0.33094751834869385,
0.5447849631309509,
0.5448817014694214,
0.2479974925518036,
0.30482664704322815,
-0.7430658936500549,
-0.005162020679563284,
-0.5164576172828674,
-0.021182257682085037,
0.9189841747283936,
-0.5301576256752014,
1.052040934562683,
-0.5694326758384705,
-0.2771903872489929,
0.11810345202684402,
0.5975246429443359,
0.210513636469841,
0.47442176938056946,
0.5173726081848145,
0.8640838861465454,
0.7637738585472107,
-0.10922791808843613,
0.8137063980102539,
-0.21615901589393616,
0.3086432218551636,
1.0587862730026245,
-0.4018731117248535,
0.96877121925354,
0.43885087966918945,
-0.5896974205970764,
0.554871141910553,
-0.038260627537965775,
0.365318238735199,
0.20283174514770508,
0.3216303586959839,
-0.50953608751297,
-0.4582657814025879,
0.148342564702034,
-0.28214290738105774,
0.06463468819856644,
0.2906016707420349,
-0.03170808404684067,
-0.08190658688545227,
-0.38122957944869995,
0.10090361535549164,
0.10637598484754562,
-0.3980063199996948,
0.8494372367858887,
0.09215834736824036,
-0.5423482060432434,
0.7832457423210144,
0.2666628062725067,
0.5185916423797607,
-0.32324501872062683,
-0.38739416003227234,
-0.5647274851799011,
0.5964677929878235,
-0.11691693961620331,
-0.5978803634643555,
0.12634865939617157,
-0.20286422967910767,
-0.17095740139484406,
0.16886171698570251,
0.5590514540672302,
-0.41429030895233154,
-1.1832228899002075,
0.07351740449666977,
0.32212144136428833,
-0.2120547592639923,
-0.1564924418926239,
-0.5423949360847473,
0.0863536074757576,
-0.02461845986545086,
-0.2602252662181854,
0.10227731615304947,
0.6567193865776062,
-0.22725476324558258,
0.8807634711265564,
0.8904085755348206,
0.009535272605717182,
-0.0016968094278126955,
0.3990345895290375,
1.0598465204238892,
-0.5863489508628845,
-0.23683854937553406,
-0.9475682377815247,
0.3394061326980591,
-0.04044073820114136,
-0.09135819971561432,
0.7343477606773376,
0.8900951743125916,
0.8751968145370483,
-0.08934371173381805,
0.36336496472358704,
0.36253225803375244,
0.44573575258255005,
-0.3397630751132965,
0.2459835410118103,
-0.24906806647777557,
0.7382336854934692,
-0.130894273519516,
-0.7967848777770996,
-0.6898563504219055,
0.4069781005382538,
-0.5916885733604431,
-0.19957661628723145,
0.4652605950832367,
1.0733842849731445,
0.06070386618375778,
0.13543108105659485,
0.43901458382606506,
0.12580901384353638,
0.2750212848186493,
0.5229361653327942,
0.8204059600830078,
-0.8745761513710022,
0.30550986528396606,
-0.6312225461006165,
-0.37545138597488403,
-0.06056496500968933,
-0.4455018937587738,
-0.774852991104126,
-0.16803622245788574,
-0.1885843724012375,
-0.16117770969867706,
0.0668817013502121,
1.0813285112380981,
0.3634260892868042,
-0.867024838924408,
-0.38727661967277527,
-0.22699685394763947,
0.2912803590297699,
-0.22805306315422058,
-0.23075659573078156,
0.11624862253665924,
-0.2826869785785675,
-0.7967690229415894,
0.22727040946483612,
0.3312436044216156,
0.04465043172240257,
-0.07370243966579437,
-0.16211792826652527,
0.01479432824999094,
0.3331008553504944,
0.9179143309593201,
0.04071420431137085,
-0.5579740405082703,
0.06657212972640991,
0.3716360926628113,
0.06746267527341843,
-0.015500943176448345,
0.9906671047210693,
-0.6687803268432617,
0.3694095015525818,
0.9113662838935852,
0.4869854748249054,
0.3402538597583771,
0.37802326679229736,
0.5056713223457336,
-0.21233104169368744,
0.040177393704652786,
0.07658982276916504,
0.32210323214530945,
0.2931738793849945,
-0.23972663283348083,
0.5071964263916016,
0.2758979797363281,
-0.43278953433036804,
-0.8070791363716125,
0.16005679965019226,
-0.8351926207542419,
0.0508815236389637,
0.8491590023040771,
-0.1813618242740631,
-0.24165236949920654,
-0.0276053324341774,
-0.2732832431793213,
0.0700097382068634,
-0.46635425090789795,
0.8369873762130737,
0.26073721051216125,
0.004328471142798662,
-0.3721468448638916,
0.03462924808263779,
0.03488030657172203,
0.43517524003982544,
-0.7036645412445068,
0.3351198732852936,
0.4938083291053772,
0.10468686372041702,
0.3381195366382599,
0.29550185799598694,
-0.46979352831840515,
0.3222304582595825,
-0.0804373249411583,
0.22033125162124634,
-0.2737880051136017,
-0.3068593144416809,
-0.4577351212501526,
0.0178401917219162,
0.20094643533229828,
-0.03435259684920311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03782v1 | Soft Prompt Tuning for Cross-Lingual Transfer: When Less is More | 2024-02-06T07:52:30 | 2024-02-06T07:52:30 | Fred Philippy, Siwen Guo, Shohreh Haddadan, Cedric Lothritz, Jacques Klein, Tegawendé F. Bissyandé | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Soft Prompt Tuning (SPT) is a parameter-efficient method for adapting
pre-trained language models (PLMs) to specific tasks by inserting learnable
embeddings, or soft prompts, at the input layer of the PLM, without modifying
its parameters. This paper investigates the potential of SPT for cross-lingual
transfer. Unlike previous studies on SPT for cross-lingual transfer that often
fine-tune both the soft prompt and the model parameters, we adhere to the
original intent of SPT by keeping the model parameters frozen and only training
the soft prompt. This does not only reduce the computational cost and storage
overhead of full-model fine-tuning, but we also demonstrate that this very
parameter efficiency intrinsic to SPT can enhance cross-lingual transfer
performance to linguistically distant languages. Moreover, we explore how
different factors related to the prompt, such as the length or its
reparameterization, affect cross-lingual transfer performance. | [
-0.4516599476337433,
-0.7880070209503174,
0.4263705015182495,
0.34653398394584656,
-0.5236824154853821,
-0.2142278105020523,
-0.657978892326355,
-0.21254923939704895,
0.021063771098852158,
0.2282317578792572,
-0.8519344925880432,
-0.1070927307009697,
-0.3143257200717926,
0.27645641565322876,
0.040604569017887115,
1.2366236448287964,
-0.07316610962152481,
-0.07259310781955719,
0.1857004463672638,
-0.010672714561223984,
-0.7486792206764221,
-0.14925456047058105,
-0.751929759979248,
0.040382299572229385,
0.748878002166748,
0.6465624570846558,
0.6228669881820679,
0.4936283528804779,
0.014925502240657806,
0.263472318649292,
0.03258764371275902,
0.10880059003829956,
-0.47154906392097473,
0.1386675089597702,
-0.5362270474433899,
-0.4962363839149475,
-0.21326304972171783,
-0.15899412333965302,
0.7244396209716797,
0.7372031211853027,
0.10679585486650467,
-0.010046636685729027,
0.2800317108631134,
0.612629771232605,
-0.29056331515312195,
0.19044828414916992,
-0.5168321132659912,
0.08902353048324585,
-0.2645498216152191,
-0.4624224007129669,
-0.4007716774940491,
-0.5208650827407837,
0.40386566519737244,
-0.7452906966209412,
0.32255318760871887,
0.023487919941544533,
0.8980568647384644,
0.13123683631420135,
-0.49835672974586487,
-0.0878271833062172,
-0.5436975359916687,
0.5994937419891357,
-0.24938607215881348,
0.5623233318328857,
0.0960850939154625,
0.22981226444244385,
0.09249196201562881,
-0.40147292613983154,
-0.20916549861431122,
-0.37789371609687805,
-0.028762947767972946,
-0.006682013161480427,
0.09912174940109253,
0.13819511234760284,
0.20682579278945923,
0.09796026349067688,
-0.6950724720954895,
0.10955684632062912,
-0.38427942991256714,
-0.38513851165771484,
0.445190966129303,
-0.06319724023342133,
0.5445873141288757,
0.05125277861952782,
-0.5997468829154968,
0.02531892992556095,
-0.763503909111023,
0.199273481965065,
0.2877156436443329,
0.9226030707359314,
-0.11534140259027481,
0.22392985224723816,
-0.05826761573553085,
0.7223842144012451,
0.4135076403617859,
0.0827733501791954,
-0.06212295964360237,
-0.5834582448005676,
0.17868159711360931,
0.3046855628490448,
0.3998723328113556,
0.36185863614082336,
0.6384397745132446,
-0.284388929605484,
-0.21116238832473755,
-0.30443912744522095,
-0.05817308649420738,
-0.894790530204773,
-0.04879685118794441,
-0.4597871005535126,
-0.29975003004074097,
0.19711579382419586,
-0.1395404189825058,
-0.6069800853729248,
-0.1404479593038559,
-0.4243820607662201,
0.5124440789222717,
-0.6405136585235596,
-0.4911600351333618,
0.07933583855628967,
-0.011691196821630001,
0.12665298581123352,
0.3416786789894104,
-1.0301892757415771,
0.17166681587696075,
0.7081659436225891,
0.9303967952728271,
-0.490826815366745,
-0.7842925190925598,
-0.941706120967865,
-0.040578000247478485,
-0.3287348747253418,
0.9580141305923462,
-0.416314035654068,
-0.28711941838264465,
0.1264040619134903,
0.3923868238925934,
-0.5370444059371948,
-0.2282973825931549,
0.33906289935112,
-0.2974902093410492,
0.1948455423116684,
-0.5588831901550293,
-0.34339994192123413,
-0.1841861456632614,
-0.16002017259597778,
-0.6659240126609802,
0.8439502120018005,
0.26225370168685913,
-0.27892574667930603,
0.5893738269805908,
-0.44036316871643066,
-1.0235203504562378,
0.2221876084804535,
0.13078434765338898,
-0.07989252358675003,
0.29880446195602417,
0.21658442914485931,
0.44352850317955017,
-0.27707552909851074,
0.1925172209739685,
-0.10556820034980774,
-0.5033901929855347,
0.28577756881713867,
-0.4699440598487854,
0.634205162525177,
0.23087871074676514,
-0.40909335017204285,
0.05518196523189545,
-0.533604621887207,
0.014485154300928116,
-0.1354667991399765,
-0.27097299695014954,
-0.45873594284057617,
-0.5822653770446777,
0.1524008959531784,
0.1878327876329422,
0.3129037916660309,
-0.35457131266593933,
0.25418248772621155,
-0.4303244948387146,
0.2932433485984802,
0.7231515645980835,
-0.2019118070602417,
0.7474546432495117,
-0.36871787905693054,
0.7573482394218445,
0.020354654639959335,
0.1321759968996048,
-0.27636682987213135,
-0.4250018000602722,
-0.6018516421318054,
-0.26810240745544434,
0.6261880397796631,
0.6105776429176331,
-1.035954475402832,
0.09874755889177322,
-0.19965064525604248,
-0.3740643858909607,
-0.6798866987228394,
0.18279437720775604,
0.28953126072883606,
0.549171507358551,
0.13396614789962769,
-0.15031090378761292,
-0.10176461935043335,
-0.8499535918235779,
-0.5767274498939514,
0.09497576206922531,
0.1490326225757599,
0.4667222201824188,
0.030750904232263565,
0.39845046401023865,
0.8307569622993469,
-0.08315065503120422,
-0.22325828671455383,
-0.5497276186943054,
0.18692687153816223,
0.34324294328689575,
0.6109520792961121,
0.7352564334869385,
-0.7335407137870789,
-0.9889205694198608,
0.18490396440029144,
-0.1207900196313858,
-0.6499202251434326,
-0.3292422890663147,
-0.013042572885751724,
0.4465305507183075,
0.4563048779964447,
-0.725784420967102,
0.04714467376470566,
0.5869549512863159,
-0.6646177172660828,
0.42643988132476807,
-0.42662474513053894,
0.45423710346221924,
-0.8230304718017578,
0.050797268748283386,
-0.1525774449110031,
-0.26546403765678406,
-0.6132273077964783,
-0.23272587358951569,
0.33392655849456787,
-0.33297058939933777,
-0.8357361555099487,
0.6890972256660461,
-0.7148314118385315,
0.007257452234625816,
-0.22866687178611755,
0.14653393626213074,
0.06289535760879517,
0.6793045997619629,
0.2912449240684509,
1.0386979579925537,
0.845226526260376,
-0.571479082107544,
0.14253342151641846,
-0.07119684666395187,
-0.09988150000572205,
0.8982115387916565,
-0.5665221214294434,
0.2637653946876526,
0.030945787206292152,
0.1138768196105957,
-0.9000819325447083,
0.44957196712493896,
0.23947849869728088,
-0.13614840805530548,
0.4782721698284149,
-0.5723297595977783,
-0.3402402698993683,
0.3584112226963043,
-0.14166978001594543,
0.5933240652084351,
0.37326961755752563,
-0.40874192118644714,
0.718137264251709,
-0.21225303411483765,
-0.7200750708580017,
-0.10870937258005142,
-0.598457396030426,
-0.10020753741264343,
-0.3099505603313446,
-0.6723636984825134,
0.39714619517326355,
-0.1920548528432846,
0.34236612915992737,
-0.023829801008105278,
0.02196645550429821,
0.2065126597881317,
-0.06200993061065674,
0.003968348726630211,
0.1595114767551422,
-0.6368146538734436,
-0.007989851757884026,
0.45559605956077576,
-0.44248712062835693,
-0.34204167127609253,
-0.49657726287841797,
0.38957229256629944,
-0.15225547552108765,
-0.2152443528175354,
-0.3992037773132324,
0.6091510057449341,
0.5154180526733398,
-0.15828995406627655,
0.6553593873977661,
0.8289625644683838,
-0.0022204238921403885,
-0.39377450942993164,
-0.3584355115890503,
-0.27712130546569824,
-0.5127602219581604,
0.25121358036994934,
-0.7951288223266602,
-0.8228638172149658,
0.4914044439792633,
-0.3111732304096222,
-0.0872720330953598,
0.18852204084396362,
0.3572220504283905,
0.43449997901916504,
1.158427357673645,
0.861006498336792,
0.1080825999379158,
0.8585538864135742,
0.3464767634868622,
-0.03546571359038353,
-0.5243356227874756,
0.03938351199030876,
-0.5843126177787781,
-0.2583230137825012,
-0.6833243370056152,
-0.3350265622138977,
0.14554882049560547,
-0.10906223952770233,
-0.19458617269992828,
0.380829781293869,
-0.3335171639919281,
0.5235350728034973,
0.5537483096122742,
-0.07357002794742584,
0.0767836943268776,
-0.08795217424631119,
-0.34277117252349854,
-0.15944041311740875,
-1.0710393190383911,
0.02299453690648079,
0.39473453164100647,
0.3539194166660309,
0.7061700224876404,
0.010396908037364483,
0.3538714349269867,
0.05538482218980789,
-0.07554555684328079,
-0.675916314125061,
0.6472949385643005,
-0.5720199942588806,
-0.5402683615684509,
-0.2469942569732666,
-0.4827435314655304,
-0.9841458797454834,
0.11948993057012558,
0.12680497765541077,
-0.5916579961776733,
0.40753358602523804,
-0.04272538051009178,
-0.6371480226516724,
0.09247758984565735,
-1.0540733337402344,
0.8591477870941162,
-0.44088679552078247,
-0.506126344203949,
-0.017934219911694527,
-0.5214897394180298,
-0.17654164135456085,
-0.0688302293419838,
-0.07125086337327957,
-0.23768118023872375,
-0.2712245583534241,
0.8125805854797363,
-0.1820353865623474,
0.8377551436424255,
-0.3776341378688812,
-0.32932838797569275,
-0.021772997453808784,
0.40839454531669617,
0.6824430823326111,
0.11115643382072449,
-0.05020589008927345,
0.08386460691690445,
0.19985102117061615,
-0.34932276606559753,
-0.7413862943649292,
0.7735714912414551,
-0.6125388741493225,
-0.6461330652236938,
-0.2682821750640869,
-0.6823379397392273,
-0.31103023886680603,
0.31570836901664734,
0.2518750727176666,
0.47475481033325195,
0.198272705078125,
0.05022037774324417,
0.8725763559341431,
-0.4589358866214752,
0.2511698007583618,
0.9418920278549194,
-0.042318519204854965,
-0.12086984515190125,
1.0847567319869995,
0.3532586991786957,
0.40844279527664185,
0.33608195185661316,
0.4727988839149475,
-0.42958196997642517,
-0.3772120177745819,
-0.8716578483581543,
0.3075270652770996,
-0.604863703250885,
-0.28100916743278503,
-0.19368146359920502,
-0.07552672922611237,
-0.5650283694267273,
-0.5079699158668518,
-0.608468770980835,
-0.3918682932853699,
-0.5396997928619385,
0.014474320225417614,
0.8287119269371033,
0.250577837228775,
-0.26345229148864746,
0.3488691449165344,
-0.9378949999809265,
0.2994832992553711,
0.25964730978012085,
0.5808054804801941,
-0.45322147011756897,
-0.7792698740959167,
-0.129947230219841,
-0.09111103415489197,
0.5116788148880005,
-0.8125205636024475,
0.2939574420452118,
0.6346607208251953,
0.5131869316101074,
0.28820672631263733,
0.24360433220863342,
0.8475441932678223,
-0.48642054200172424,
0.7887256145477295,
0.02358313649892807,
-1.0731468200683594,
0.4456310272216797,
-0.3725842535495758,
0.6297038793563843,
0.809328019618988,
0.36491072177886963,
-0.645557165145874,
-0.04036559909582138,
-0.23812024295330048,
-0.8579856753349304,
1.1455233097076416,
-0.32156944274902344,
0.26150327920913696,
0.35672372579574585,
0.2949197590351105,
0.7214589715003967,
-0.0340922474861145,
-0.37076905369758606,
-0.09918253868818283,
-0.16872386634349823,
-0.057817570865154266,
-0.07326973974704742,
-0.06844153255224228,
0.12940555810928345,
-0.23835699260234833,
0.5839288830757141,
-0.3718043565750122,
-0.015366263687610626,
0.063702791929245,
-0.3897096812725067,
-0.43839073181152344,
0.2595217823982239,
0.6085099577903748,
0.36665236949920654,
0.05447973683476448,
0.21014049649238586,
0.5306146740913391,
-0.3542978763580322,
0.07655469328165054,
0.3848332464694977,
-0.2090264856815338,
0.08601752668619156,
0.11306227743625641,
1.0856835842132568,
0.6509055495262146,
-0.44159889221191406,
0.4951309859752655,
-0.18940849602222443,
-0.1264168620109558,
0.2109399288892746,
0.12398814409971237,
-0.20865292847156525,
0.3321678936481476,
0.2463545799255371,
-0.03034084476530552,
0.014736447483301163,
-0.5615631341934204,
0.23376479744911194,
0.17207002639770508,
-0.4583865702152252,
-0.5387018322944641,
0.4211269021034241,
0.3840973973274231,
-0.5214250087738037,
0.5608109831809998,
0.10162796825170517,
-0.6918463706970215,
0.2726197838783264,
0.7907808423042297,
0.8416083455085754,
-0.40537238121032715,
0.3548956513404846,
0.004963418003171682,
0.29343175888061523,
0.1707906723022461,
0.24915577471256256,
-0.3886262774467468,
-0.42886847257614136,
-0.5161569118499756,
-0.5665251612663269,
-0.14873220026493073,
-0.18987485766410828,
-0.6035270094871521,
0.4406885504722595,
-0.16432911157608032,
0.04562506824731827,
-0.35272684693336487,
0.18029779195785522,
-0.7608848214149475,
-0.013091360218822956,
0.2153492569923401,
1.1606459617614746,
-1.10934579372406,
0.8004809021949768,
0.7139827609062195,
-0.18870298564434052,
-1.0300532579421997,
-0.22345641255378723,
-0.33921390771865845,
-0.846175491809845,
0.3662324547767639,
-0.027554841712117195,
-0.2680570185184479,
0.20341630280017853,
-0.11513794213533401,
-0.8447928428649902,
0.6581758260726929,
0.7229127287864685,
-0.6234571933746338,
0.026751702651381493,
0.39448410272598267,
0.38098156452178955,
-0.17405080795288086,
0.24342192709445953,
0.7003331184387207,
0.690578818321228,
0.05495980754494667,
-1.3379443883895874,
0.5622188448905945,
-0.28441277146339417,
0.025257961824536324,
0.1458836793899536,
-0.8090511560440063,
0.8199019432067871,
-0.0895439013838768,
-0.398395299911499,
0.03996092453598976,
0.5499604940414429,
0.20503678917884827,
0.23000989854335785,
0.7883546352386475,
-0.11618393659591675,
0.40325242280960083,
-0.024630675092339516,
0.7573961615562439,
-0.388201504945755,
0.004589597694575787,
0.5865881443023682,
-0.441588431596756,
0.4450211822986603,
0.7291635274887085,
0.24848243594169617,
0.2210775762796402,
0.719106912612915,
0.1284976452589035,
0.7677189707756042,
-0.05417230725288391,
-0.06151140108704567,
-0.24000078439712524,
-0.30787795782089233,
-0.6118362545967102,
0.16709992289543152,
0.3062048852443695,
-0.15595073997974396,
-0.2256694883108139,
0.5268667340278625,
0.031403910368680954,
-0.18193337321281433,
-0.40578773617744446,
0.8280575275421143,
0.15645748376846313,
-1.1693787574768066,
0.6412060260772705,
-0.2605774700641632,
0.7788687944412231,
-0.8304957747459412,
0.03532670438289642,
-0.36780014634132385,
0.04923652857542038,
0.007804402150213718,
-0.6958651542663574,
0.07015188783407211,
-0.1633126139640808,
0.14639520645141602,
-0.8632016181945801,
0.9561522006988525,
-0.7057296633720398,
-0.2955372631549835,
0.27396902441978455,
0.6999578475952148,
0.19663013517856598,
-0.09357322752475739,
-0.8781994581222534,
-0.02462475746870041,
0.016661958768963814,
-0.5127720832824707,
0.5208421349525452,
1.0122315883636475,
0.04998777434229851,
0.4329839050769806,
0.7542939782142639,
0.5140154957771301,
-0.003931674174964428,
0.3059796690940857,
0.7220398783683777,
-0.7132891416549683,
-0.9196577668190002,
-0.5590657591819763,
0.44153133034706116,
0.4338407814502716,
-0.640044093132019,
0.7806311249732971,
0.23013027012348175,
0.6321747899055481,
-0.13524901866912842,
0.5884496569633484,
-0.06489545851945877,
0.46934112906455994,
-0.7217643857002258,
0.7800084948539734,
-0.6447618007659912,
0.11974304169416428,
-0.0936865359544754,
-0.794934868812561,
-0.03186066448688507,
0.42799344658851624,
-0.3941437900066376,
0.25439611077308655,
0.7174545526504517,
0.9831064939498901,
-0.2590228319168091,
0.10294236242771149,
0.5141371488571167,
-0.028813404962420464,
-0.08163855224847794,
0.6237802505493164,
0.9788843989372253,
-0.05649798735976219,
0.6915522217750549,
-0.3470771908760071,
-0.13056720793247223,
-0.4415439963340759,
-0.954938530921936,
-0.7527145743370056,
-0.7785586714744568,
-0.43446528911590576,
-0.1664864867925644,
0.45486465096473694,
0.9166237115859985,
0.8041226267814636,
-0.7356560826301575,
-0.1430991291999817,
0.06561279296875,
0.09943781048059464,
-0.550499677658081,
-0.2411767840385437,
0.5631816983222961,
-0.4203631579875946,
-0.6731221079826355,
0.5522897839546204,
0.173996239900589,
-0.09002542495727539,
-0.25533929467201233,
-0.04564180597662926,
-0.11893504858016968,
0.06805223226547241,
0.4432825744152069,
0.2888351380825043,
-0.17997650802135468,
-0.30836719274520874,
0.2814808189868927,
0.03651623800396919,
-0.07116386294364929,
1.1024998426437378,
-0.7337660193443298,
0.08406710624694824,
0.6131412982940674,
0.5683743357658386,
0.43989264965057373,
-0.13910652697086334,
0.9864187240600586,
-0.8892573118209839,
0.23055894672870636,
0.1648397147655487,
0.240417942404747,
0.3135676085948944,
-0.5644626617431641,
0.05040022358298302,
0.2161080688238144,
-0.4265080392360687,
-0.8758334517478943,
0.010166953317821026,
-1.0535250902175903,
-0.416957288980484,
1.3914697170257568,
-0.17203179001808167,
-0.4223012924194336,
-0.3517269790172577,
-0.4878309369087219,
0.4740019738674164,
-0.5719078779220581,
0.46424293518066406,
0.4560193717479706,
-0.05965656042098999,
-0.4669104516506195,
-0.3640933036804199,
0.5959333181381226,
0.8270922899246216,
-0.5021647214889526,
0.1456644982099533,
0.1441745162010193,
0.5711867213249207,
-0.13714756071567535,
0.3629547357559204,
0.16002725064754486,
0.6940396428108215,
0.014362700283527374,
-0.5501086711883545,
-0.22450923919677734,
-0.4450044631958008,
-0.6125649213790894,
0.22221335768699646,
-0.0025671583134680986,
-0.08537061512470245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03780v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03780v3 | Exposing propaganda: an analysis of stylistic cues comparing human annotations and machine classification | 2024-02-06T07:51:54 | 2024-02-26T14:07:20 | Géraud Faye, Benjamin Icard, Morgane Casanova, Julien Chanson, François Maine, François Bancilhon, Guillaume Gadek, Guillaume Gravier, Paul Égré | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper investigates the language of propaganda and its stylistic
features. It presents the PPN dataset, standing for Propagandist Pseudo-News, a
multisource, multilingual, multimodal dataset composed of news articles
extracted from websites identified as propaganda sources by expert agencies. A
limited sample from this set was randomly mixed with papers from the regular
French press, and their URL masked, to conduct an annotation-experiment by
humans, using 11 distinct labels. The results show that human annotators were
able to reliably discriminate between the two types of press across each of the
labels. We propose different NLP techniques to identify the cues used by the
annotators, and to compare them with machine classification. They include the
analyzer VAGO to measure discourse vagueness and subjectivity, a TF-IDF to
serve as a baseline, and four different classifiers: two RoBERTa-based models,
CATS using syntax, and one XGBoost combining syntactic and semantic features. | [
-0.5753652453422546,
-0.8093876838684082,
0.17036104202270508,
0.4812975823879242,
-0.12773919105529785,
-0.0044241659343242645,
-0.5619091987609863,
-0.3058415651321411,
0.0991683304309845,
0.7432222962379456,
-0.42039015889167786,
-0.4561319947242737,
-0.7346463799476624,
0.3528899848461151,
-0.41907674074172974,
1.1831525564193726,
-0.01071853470057249,
0.06667841970920563,
0.030274096876382828,
-0.04277420789003372,
0.012511232867836952,
-0.7604579925537109,
-0.4009453356266022,
-0.049157675355672836,
0.6169884204864502,
0.18556055426597595,
0.8516992330551147,
0.6335932016372681,
0.42527323961257935,
0.4258129596710205,
0.41984325647354126,
0.173778235912323,
-0.2508623003959656,
-0.23667457699775696,
-0.3646217882633209,
-0.47193658351898193,
0.10273557156324387,
0.515988826751709,
0.5565425157546997,
0.32940128445625305,
0.5696529150009155,
0.3318357467651367,
0.211379274725914,
0.42090094089508057,
-0.553109884262085,
0.17422311007976532,
-0.4478451907634735,
-0.10563702881336212,
-0.41136476397514343,
-0.2017916887998581,
-0.7712273597717285,
-0.2952609658241272,
0.22466149926185608,
-0.6701945066452026,
0.4286794066429138,
0.267409086227417,
1.3317772150039673,
0.07402831315994263,
-0.4824124872684479,
-0.36103424429893494,
-0.6520836353302002,
0.9140542149543762,
-0.2058752030134201,
0.2525555491447449,
0.4315318167209625,
0.11362165957689285,
0.027844246476888657,
-0.7407662868499756,
-0.5882964730262756,
-0.36458802223205566,
-0.46873611211776733,
0.17363300919532776,
-0.2597731053829193,
-0.16434505581855774,
0.12198202311992645,
0.1380837857723236,
-0.7933599352836609,
-0.03983337804675102,
-0.5144281387329102,
-0.7105032205581665,
0.7442265748977661,
-0.6473057270050049,
0.384519100189209,
-0.7472882866859436,
-0.5783742070198059,
-0.2498803436756134,
-0.48676279187202454,
-0.41122785210609436,
0.8297196626663208,
0.1534871906042099,
-0.12534698843955994,
0.5240445137023926,
-0.18498921394348145,
0.8697919845581055,
-0.14907732605934143,
-0.25743913650512695,
0.23810094594955444,
-0.057551074773073196,
-0.24935707449913025,
0.015582549385726452,
1.065077304840088,
0.5688855051994324,
0.5867827534675598,
0.10376763343811035,
-0.20139619708061218,
0.2974197566509247,
0.48218512535095215,
-0.22085119783878326,
-0.5723621845245361,
-0.3538631796836853,
-0.4870900511741638,
-0.4991147518157959,
0.37993207573890686,
-0.9046541452407837,
-0.46176597476005554,
-0.22795149683952332,
0.6527380347251892,
-0.3301088511943817,
-0.08046134561300278,
-0.2044907957315445,
-0.4636913239955902,
0.2953687310218811,
0.1413547247648239,
-0.5037949681282043,
0.08389460295438766,
0.7153371572494507,
0.8180893659591675,
0.054989710450172424,
0.08730213344097137,
-0.16207605600357056,
-0.26188334822654724,
-0.4178592264652252,
1.0161207914352417,
-0.3960801959037781,
-0.18684595823287964,
0.3138948380947113,
0.23613017797470093,
0.021037349477410316,
-0.39656805992126465,
1.094215750694275,
-0.3099437654018402,
0.6782028675079346,
-0.10827883332967758,
-0.28520098328590393,
-0.4194331169128418,
0.14648602902889252,
-0.9506081938743591,
0.765296995639801,
0.35635122656822205,
-0.9629023671150208,
0.41475173830986023,
-0.5811128616333008,
-0.3733675181865692,
-0.12753544747829437,
-0.21995435655117035,
-0.4930785596370697,
0.050748638808727264,
0.09211909770965576,
0.3921882212162018,
-0.05725280940532684,
0.08627462387084961,
-0.12121393531560898,
-0.24947629868984222,
0.7656684517860413,
-0.5906986594200134,
0.7807870507240295,
0.36138907074928284,
-0.27324411273002625,
0.17697331309318542,
-0.8635993599891663,
-0.29423391819000244,
0.2657620310783386,
-0.14276549220085144,
-0.5849143862724304,
-0.10159384459257126,
0.3647908568382263,
0.5868802666664124,
0.05293732136487961,
-0.362230122089386,
0.19518351554870605,
-0.11023402214050293,
0.3914699852466583,
0.7601709961891174,
0.1068740263581276,
0.4321401119232178,
-0.6162179708480835,
0.2243695855140686,
-0.2066039741039276,
0.16652235388755798,
-0.23719999194145203,
-0.36935660243034363,
-1.1331112384796143,
-0.3724210560321808,
0.5241836905479431,
0.7875085473060608,
-0.9421641230583191,
0.37855079770088196,
-0.08692474663257599,
-0.31811845302581787,
-0.6525318026542664,
0.05233607068657875,
0.6219940781593323,
0.5047158002853394,
0.17439286410808563,
-0.08434566855430603,
-0.7746919989585876,
-1.4611037969589233,
-0.543170154094696,
-0.27441832423210144,
-0.46190062165260315,
-0.02693600207567215,
0.47802695631980896,
0.3204193115234375,
0.521268904209137,
-0.5090753436088562,
-0.40113428235054016,
-0.20298069715499878,
0.8189850449562073,
-0.2230335921049118,
0.2896837592124939,
0.5234264731407166,
-1.0684374570846558,
-0.42676082253456116,
-0.23469680547714233,
-0.6343161463737488,
-0.34919479489326477,
-0.2627367377281189,
-0.1150079071521759,
0.3132251799106598,
0.38220876455307007,
-0.1086338683962822,
0.28099656105041504,
0.3932149410247803,
-0.19632084667682648,
0.6153064966201782,
0.09066788107156754,
0.4207775592803955,
-0.9117357730865479,
-0.2221371829509735,
0.5775096416473389,
-0.20131921768188477,
-0.7574796676635742,
-0.36304429173469543,
0.020386219024658203,
-0.04614415392279625,
-0.6549915075302124,
0.4507614076137543,
-0.3935694694519043,
0.15963101387023926,
-0.2580459713935852,
0.32523855566978455,
0.46833592653274536,
0.4293332099914551,
0.3303477466106415,
0.5742558240890503,
0.3095792829990387,
-0.2315845787525177,
0.23094108700752258,
-0.025250719860196114,
-0.3111410439014435,
0.6882419586181641,
-0.28326717019081116,
0.17531093955039978,
-0.24380314350128174,
0.2873753309249878,
-1.116698145866394,
-0.4702933728694916,
0.6880782246589661,
-0.38981425762176514,
0.41171011328697205,
-0.11760500073432922,
-0.7479829788208008,
-0.25135093927383423,
-0.4777413308620453,
-0.0822175070643425,
0.4874783456325531,
-0.1352853775024414,
0.2787289023399353,
0.21184605360031128,
-0.07885313034057617,
-0.4779304265975952,
-0.5290399193763733,
0.0427829883992672,
-0.6484282612800598,
-0.5133599042892456,
0.13592201471328735,
0.3067743480205536,
-0.6672903895378113,
-0.07718933373689651,
0.15308620035648346,
-0.16046978533267975,
-0.045333776623010635,
0.2555273175239563,
0.4935871660709381,
-0.2937985360622406,
0.19804520905017853,
-0.20996622741222382,
-0.019155465066432953,
0.05759872868657112,
-0.5058037638664246,
0.266436368227005,
-0.15117432177066803,
-0.048329390585422516,
-0.6786555647850037,
0.3750286102294922,
0.13394053280353546,
-0.17352065443992615,
0.7443767786026001,
0.7831785082817078,
-0.06549237668514252,
-0.09786929935216904,
-0.6693993210792542,
-0.13890187442302704,
-0.3906113803386688,
0.24138277769088745,
-0.2505338490009308,
-0.35219481587409973,
0.053577911108732224,
-0.06941051781177521,
-0.10877253860235214,
0.7757743000984192,
0.47044122219085693,
-0.1286427229642868,
0.795218825340271,
0.6300981640815735,
-0.047302983701229095,
0.49688461422920227,
-0.22014263272285461,
-0.1526949256658554,
-0.5472987294197083,
-0.11698617041110992,
-0.7593464255332947,
-0.37342166900634766,
-0.8741274476051331,
-0.4255081117153168,
0.19609424471855164,
-0.1856248676776886,
-0.0025095203891396523,
0.4089074730873108,
-0.6956695914268494,
0.2823963165283203,
0.6420808434486389,
-0.12962496280670166,
0.18475866317749023,
-0.05439258739352226,
0.19648738205432892,
-0.2666841149330139,
-0.4128677248954773,
-1.003313422203064,
1.071578025817871,
0.36892804503440857,
0.5320163369178772,
-0.11823127418756485,
0.41417354345321655,
0.5235682725906372,
0.7983235120773315,
-0.6173085570335388,
0.44944775104522705,
-0.39843645691871643,
-0.8217737674713135,
0.09504502266645432,
-0.16915233433246613,
-0.5209357142448425,
0.43418943881988525,
-0.3972855508327484,
-0.8411350250244141,
0.2053242027759552,
0.058196771889925,
-0.05424218997359276,
0.13518843054771423,
-0.9517145752906799,
0.9288349151611328,
-0.3184351623058319,
-0.19271670281887054,
0.16358759999275208,
-0.7614750266075134,
0.5200577974319458,
-0.10625696182250977,
0.43686169385910034,
-0.16603486239910126,
-0.21794885396957397,
1.0143171548843384,
0.28967931866645813,
0.9344319701194763,
0.2720731794834137,
0.006436753086745739,
0.17154480516910553,
-0.1304806023836136,
0.015816600993275642,
-0.24888138473033905,
0.01047798153012991,
0.41676321625709534,
-0.3508642315864563,
-0.3377605676651001,
-0.5224032402038574,
0.5804399251937866,
-0.9453712701797485,
-0.6320138573646545,
-0.5886412858963013,
-0.4081690013408661,
0.05090491101145744,
0.10597577691078186,
0.6769552826881409,
0.5425803065299988,
-0.35409030318260193,
0.2401130646467209,
0.5005184412002563,
-0.22943629324436188,
0.20185114443302155,
0.40742871165275574,
-0.21983297169208527,
-0.3299134373664856,
1.0620169639587402,
0.3687027096748352,
0.4219246506690979,
0.7171312570571899,
0.24902382493019104,
-0.39193591475486755,
-0.16374658048152924,
-0.6050975322723389,
0.30283185839653015,
-0.806885302066803,
0.021131839603185654,
-0.4359176754951477,
-0.3280889391899109,
-0.30591124296188354,
-0.1802755445241928,
-0.14058047533035278,
-0.4796035587787628,
-0.37201064825057983,
0.03330063819885254,
-0.029550062492489815,
0.662765383720398,
0.07656725496053696,
0.6131759881973267,
-0.4008004665374756,
0.39476966857910156,
-0.11202424764633179,
-0.09511252492666245,
-0.7044949531555176,
-0.609574019908905,
-0.02713540755212307,
-0.19101063907146454,
-0.5810497403144836,
-1.3283838033676147,
0.36357730627059937,
-0.058528341352939606,
0.380431205034256,
0.8775614500045776,
0.2686034142971039,
0.16124136745929718,
-0.2883601486682892,
0.7791853547096252,
-0.07837442308664322,
-0.6553530097007751,
0.41127148270606995,
-0.2962978780269623,
-0.09753455966711044,
0.35684290528297424,
0.9119703769683838,
-0.3913422226905823,
-0.6289171576499939,
-0.9752712845802307,
-0.5665943622589111,
0.6418908834457397,
0.2684667110443115,
0.003826116444543004,
-0.19560600817203522,
0.00482526607811451,
0.20365871489048004,
0.30229106545448303,
-0.753692626953125,
-0.38551393151283264,
-0.6559042930603027,
-0.12998491525650024,
-0.21533749997615814,
-0.27406802773475647,
-0.37852925062179565,
0.13911469280719757,
0.7119045257568359,
-0.05151413008570671,
0.08975695073604584,
0.2695244252681732,
-0.364774227142334,
0.26375091075897217,
0.4542044401168823,
0.9171349406242371,
0.8252962827682495,
0.0544225238263607,
0.3688470125198364,
-0.3038194477558136,
-0.15710002183914185,
0.05457156524062157,
0.2007901519536972,
-0.38388919830322266,
0.38947606086730957,
0.7114711999893188,
0.848332405090332,
0.27571988105773926,
-0.3062993586063385,
0.445046067237854,
0.031417153775691986,
-0.2283521443605423,
-0.5641665458679199,
-0.1258091777563095,
-0.2560616135597229,
0.03779369220137596,
0.4016038775444031,
-0.03793676942586899,
0.11871185153722763,
-0.7451092004776001,
0.3151891529560089,
0.35612955689430237,
-0.43612563610076904,
-0.42896997928619385,
0.4296571612358093,
0.17640063166618347,
-0.5870838165283203,
0.3339132070541382,
-0.32335352897644043,
-0.6542476415634155,
0.2578139305114746,
0.4261077046394348,
0.7456236481666565,
-0.28964853286743164,
0.6679050326347351,
0.25428062677383423,
0.5830485820770264,
0.10489919036626816,
-0.18257254362106323,
0.22779512405395508,
-0.5605239272117615,
-0.39215925335884094,
-0.5882875323295593,
-0.024486325681209564,
0.5429044961929321,
-0.5519775152206421,
0.2813660800457001,
-0.2796013653278351,
-0.0819401666522026,
0.4693482220172882,
0.05682055279612541,
-0.47846612334251404,
0.169528529047966,
0.27856844663619995,
0.7508936524391174,
-1.357956051826477,
0.6844228506088257,
0.6630865931510925,
-0.598430335521698,
-0.5227723717689514,
0.3963913023471832,
0.6251717209815979,
-0.5550497174263,
0.7485811114311218,
0.2536398768424988,
0.2964448928833008,
-0.2909511923789978,
-0.4101007878780365,
-0.4363134205341339,
0.4234492778778076,
0.34216219186782837,
-0.2782042920589447,
0.11594007164239883,
0.18666279315948486,
0.40417271852493286,
-0.38708993792533875,
0.11945534497499466,
0.6391234397888184,
0.8781785368919373,
-0.2746922969818115,
-0.8615867495536804,
-0.14074845612049103,
-0.02583441138267517,
-0.1677141934633255,
0.2299950271844864,
-0.7008048892021179,
0.7834110260009766,
0.3994176685810089,
-0.4052078127861023,
-0.06212490797042847,
0.815418004989624,
-0.38564327359199524,
0.1771761029958725,
0.6329637169837952,
0.033544860780239105,
0.452216774225235,
-0.36089688539505005,
1.0824235677719116,
-0.0022279550321400166,
0.11222921311855316,
0.7944633960723877,
0.10896917432546616,
0.5516618490219116,
0.2476467490196228,
0.03008742816746235,
0.7316548824310303,
0.4810733497142792,
-0.1308000236749649,
0.39556771516799927,
0.3857615888118744,
-0.2821343243122101,
0.10154560208320618,
-0.3862168788909912,
0.18390914797782898,
0.6182535886764526,
0.3536140024662018,
-0.6540347337722778,
-0.33087414503097534,
0.26132166385650635,
0.5450376272201538,
0.47801288962364197,
-0.29832205176353455,
0.9709171056747437,
0.12807850539684296,
-0.8200907707214355,
0.43145135045051575,
0.1854225993156433,
0.43548330664634705,
-0.6740206480026245,
-0.057098452001810074,
0.21038711071014404,
0.22644436359405518,
-0.09796158969402313,
-0.7267947196960449,
0.33848774433135986,
-0.19519789516925812,
-0.09946061670780182,
-0.28547826409339905,
0.9041096568107605,
-0.446184903383255,
-0.7059819102287292,
0.015139496885240078,
0.2864691913127899,
0.1651153415441513,
-0.1960519403219223,
-0.7839890122413635,
0.355887234210968,
-0.11972328275442123,
-0.20667092502117157,
0.3958710730075836,
0.4570213854312897,
-0.46296414732933044,
0.40804749727249146,
0.6135165691375732,
0.025420747697353363,
-0.030850980430841446,
0.09543532878160477,
0.7144295573234558,
-0.4376063644886017,
-0.29910215735435486,
-0.9526656866073608,
0.35226163268089294,
-0.5022917985916138,
-0.3560771048069,
1.0762604475021362,
0.5019239187240601,
0.8951609134674072,
-0.2697712182998657,
0.8611089587211609,
-0.07190831750631332,
0.39830514788627625,
-0.43756693601608276,
0.8016929030418396,
-0.1981450915336609,
-0.320147305727005,
-0.31083622574806213,
-0.724456250667572,
-0.33024656772613525,
0.70313560962677,
-0.5625231862068176,
-0.19986538589000702,
0.7217838168144226,
0.8198495507240295,
0.01940889097750187,
-0.006734655704349279,
0.26410770416259766,
0.25226983428001404,
0.05689972639083862,
0.0483613982796669,
0.9784529209136963,
0.048423510044813156,
0.587346613407135,
-0.6925965547561646,
-0.40351322293281555,
-0.32162022590637207,
-0.9532482624053955,
-1.020864486694336,
-1.0090810060501099,
-0.4166378676891327,
-0.5017161965370178,
0.1535874307155609,
0.7850810885429382,
0.7094617486000061,
-0.5357056856155396,
0.004845629446208477,
0.6201696991920471,
0.20038671791553497,
-0.31314942240715027,
-0.33250701427459717,
0.611181378364563,
-0.14559145271778107,
-0.9587616324424744,
0.10403183847665787,
0.35397443175315857,
-0.14177361130714417,
-0.7483858466148376,
0.413773775100708,
-0.34579411149024963,
0.3176101744174957,
0.39613139629364014,
0.2363036572933197,
-0.8848313689231873,
-0.7000945806503296,
-0.20200178027153015,
0.0336320735514164,
0.08168859034776688,
0.9332475066184998,
-0.5413583517074585,
0.43642234802246094,
0.4558747708797455,
0.11203835159540176,
0.07204356789588928,
0.2990025281906128,
0.4072064161300659,
-1.1143535375595093,
0.6192605495452881,
0.16768242418766022,
0.3207087814807892,
0.6387792825698853,
-0.21025089919567108,
0.2507811486721039,
0.3455326557159424,
-0.40305572748184204,
-0.5461382269859314,
0.3456626534461975,
-0.8376240134239197,
-0.3054063022136688,
1.1263298988342285,
-0.3418428897857666,
-0.5589460134506226,
-0.4268827438354492,
-0.41069701313972473,
0.3192184865474701,
-0.26537707448005676,
0.7344948053359985,
0.9996153712272644,
0.05428290367126465,
-0.08925614506006241,
-0.9038717150688171,
0.6712426543235779,
-0.23838374018669128,
-0.6300304532051086,
-0.2497159093618393,
0.5500554442405701,
0.31580308079719543,
0.7344701886177063,
0.40561726689338684,
-0.08919632434844971,
0.00009645437239669263,
0.053741324692964554,
-0.11416509002447128,
0.0986977368593216,
-0.5273206830024719,
-0.01237696036696434,
0.328560471534729,
-0.27443796396255493,
-0.370292603969574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03776v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03776v4 | Large Language Models As MOOCs Graders | 2024-02-06T07:43:07 | 2024-03-01T04:48:41 | Shahriar Golchin, Nikhil Garuda, Christopher Impey, Matthew Wenger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Massive open online courses (MOOCs) unlock the doors to free education for
anyone around the globe with access to a computer and the internet. Despite
this democratization of learning, the massive enrollment in these courses means
it is almost impossible for one instructor to assess every student's writing
assignment. As a result, peer grading, often guided by a straightforward
rubric, is the method of choice. While convenient, peer grading often falls
short in terms of reliability and validity. In this study, using 18 distinct
settings, we explore the feasibility of leveraging large language models (LLMs)
to replace peer grading in MOOCs. Specifically, we focus on two
state-of-the-art LLMs: GPT-4 and GPT-3.5, across three distinct courses:
Introductory Astronomy, Astrobiology, and the History and Philosophy of
Astronomy. To instruct LLMs, we use three different prompts based on a variant
of the zero-shot chain-of-thought (Zero-shot-CoT) prompting technique:
Zero-shot-CoT combined with instructor-provided correct answers; Zero-shot-CoT
in conjunction with both instructor-formulated answers and rubrics; and
Zero-shot-CoT with instructor-offered correct answers and LLM-generated
rubrics. Our results show that Zero-shot-CoT, when integrated with
instructor-provided answers and rubrics, produces grades that are more aligned
with those assigned by instructors compared to peer grading. However, the
History and Philosophy of Astronomy course proves to be more challenging in
terms of grading as opposed to other courses. Finally, our study reveals a
promising direction for automating grading systems for MOOCs, especially in
subjects with well-defined rubrics. | [
-0.09074210375547409,
-0.8279512524604797,
0.8827626705169678,
-0.17323103547096252,
-0.012466862797737122,
0.2343502938747406,
-0.43081578612327576,
-0.4747253358364105,
0.06054368242621422,
0.42007240653038025,
-0.19501060247421265,
-0.5608439445495605,
-0.5820795297622681,
-0.17156735062599182,
-0.3848286271095276,
1.4392931461334229,
-0.1590316742658615,
0.41401103138923645,
-0.28374847769737244,
0.04203357174992561,
-0.3276437520980835,
-0.6044209003448486,
-0.5439218282699585,
-0.49041470885276794,
0.6739813685417175,
0.5225249528884888,
0.6718710660934448,
0.6318324208259583,
0.7999147176742554,
0.2572515308856964,
-0.24151363968849182,
-0.08649496734142303,
-0.4153714179992676,
-0.14400559663772583,
-0.2789013981819153,
-0.40395858883857727,
-0.7693294286727905,
0.2974269986152649,
0.7238914966583252,
0.9262537360191345,
-0.25226616859436035,
0.38171419501304626,
-0.01866992563009262,
0.5060592293739319,
-0.5426822304725647,
0.18099826574325562,
-0.5069227814674377,
0.07101794332265854,
-0.12906628847122192,
-0.06770006567239761,
-0.624521791934967,
-0.4676748514175415,
0.10186391323804855,
-0.6656168699264526,
0.0908753052353859,
-0.1576133370399475,
0.8242588639259338,
-0.01047918014228344,
-0.374427855014801,
-0.6759296655654907,
-0.7150631546974182,
0.9277470707893372,
-0.4475732147693634,
0.05155501514673233,
0.4447306990623474,
0.38308992981910706,
0.09034358710050583,
-0.5099998712539673,
-0.472048282623291,
-0.48452624678611755,
0.24126942455768585,
0.17490154504776,
0.4347085654735565,
0.17312093079090118,
0.2365248203277588,
0.9405717253684998,
-0.3903759717941284,
0.3922124207019806,
-0.5103021264076233,
-0.20107856392860413,
0.411049485206604,
0.3390386998653412,
0.14666198194026947,
-0.04545744135975838,
-0.26907169818878174,
-0.23512034118175507,
-0.9771494269371033,
0.08113659173250198,
0.6402851343154907,
0.4468781054019928,
0.07204227894544601,
0.7419337630271912,
-0.04486165568232536,
0.5070173144340515,
0.07895951718091965,
-0.46851521730422974,
0.049227744340896606,
-0.24873259663581848,
-0.1278356909751892,
-0.21274469792842865,
0.7854493856430054,
0.3652535676956177,
0.3569461703300476,
0.0908653661608696,
-0.14108462631702423,
0.025060752406716347,
0.1059582307934761,
-0.7793276309967041,
-0.2765301764011383,
0.07049478590488434,
-0.10138684511184692,
-0.469308465719223,
-0.20420235395431519,
-0.8046744465827942,
-0.35404303669929504,
-0.35357749462127686,
0.7981940507888794,
-0.12424255907535553,
0.33071446418762207,
-0.001767895300872624,
0.1662130504846573,
0.15940771996974945,
0.8400407433509827,
-0.8718210458755493,
0.2179788202047348,
0.6175731420516968,
1.0844669342041016,
0.007011979352682829,
-0.34658005833625793,
-0.4243670403957367,
0.06885606050491333,
-0.33080294728279114,
0.581353485584259,
-0.7252812385559082,
-0.30049100518226624,
0.07574667781591415,
-0.22323812544345856,
0.25473570823669434,
-0.2910025417804718,
0.40108466148376465,
-0.45935848355293274,
0.8111323118209839,
-0.11759419739246368,
-0.8149630427360535,
-0.1238333061337471,
0.49293214082717896,
-0.3011249303817749,
1.0092962980270386,
0.023317350074648857,
-0.10394920408725739,
0.128033846616745,
-0.5660066604614258,
0.013567600399255753,
0.17189782857894897,
0.028433870524168015,
-0.08886592090129852,
-0.0937398225069046,
0.09905113279819489,
0.6235042810440063,
-0.3384408950805664,
0.3968307673931122,
-0.14956361055374146,
-0.35074010491371155,
0.06877411901950836,
-0.15238118171691895,
0.5624615550041199,
0.13417555391788483,
-0.3424660563468933,
-0.014977303333580494,
-0.5862535238265991,
0.11217081546783447,
0.015911003574728966,
-0.467058002948761,
-0.22504805028438568,
0.034554675221443176,
-0.24142128229141235,
0.11091940850019455,
0.27025797963142395,
-0.676480233669281,
0.5775851607322693,
-0.16185544431209564,
0.42918094992637634,
1.1292779445648193,
-0.22823408246040344,
0.6431658864021301,
-0.2998369336128235,
0.48191821575164795,
-0.31779423356056213,
0.14293202757835388,
-0.4135028123855591,
-0.6429675221443176,
-1.0176726579666138,
-0.2907398045063019,
0.09693831205368042,
0.38100603222846985,
-0.5371501445770264,
0.04739082604646683,
-0.2788207530975342,
-0.8477338552474976,
-0.326383501291275,
0.45051565766334534,
0.6161291003227234,
0.30203238129615784,
0.3839316964149475,
-0.3056654930114746,
0.0050717550329864025,
-0.24765662848949432,
-0.19873841106891632,
-0.3443596065044403,
-0.1477547436952591,
0.2549528479576111,
0.5219220519065857,
0.0478690005838871,
0.5233868956565857,
-0.7148303985595703,
-0.4410439133644104,
-0.08692873269319534,
0.07149211317300797,
0.16467039287090302,
0.3863275349140167,
0.2207767814397812,
-0.1785702258348465,
-0.44484594464302063,
0.08903000503778458,
-0.6227390170097351,
-0.16953283548355103,
0.11093907803297043,
-0.029656752943992615,
-0.033895060420036316,
0.4281993806362152,
-0.19376789033412933,
0.09075183421373367,
0.6179432272911072,
-0.3607370853424072,
0.569301426410675,
-0.20791077613830566,
0.09358832985162735,
-0.8075389266014099,
-0.15439526736736298,
0.07720034569501877,
-0.3196916878223419,
-0.5132730007171631,
0.5210041403770447,
0.02695087343454361,
-0.3935740292072296,
-0.4212040305137634,
0.6255397200584412,
-0.403591126203537,
-0.03797876089811325,
-0.3006514310836792,
0.2576397955417633,
0.10964194685220718,
0.42549362778663635,
-0.0192068163305521,
0.6336463689804077,
0.4897301197052002,
-0.4590519368648529,
0.2464994490146637,
0.015595524571835995,
-0.47500041127204895,
0.5881139039993286,
-0.5164775252342224,
0.16408030688762665,
-0.15742431581020355,
0.5666294693946838,
-0.8421400189399719,
-0.26715946197509766,
-0.01648143120110035,
-0.3532397150993347,
0.14785610139369965,
-0.29120513796806335,
-0.30671438574790955,
-0.16723158955574036,
-0.27363553643226624,
0.36075305938720703,
0.5654985308647156,
-0.4922243654727936,
0.44676673412323,
0.06488867849111557,
-0.25965696573257446,
-0.5270988345146179,
-0.4236021637916565,
-0.010277681052684784,
0.015085019171237946,
-0.2662222683429718,
0.06536928564310074,
-0.25902435183525085,
-0.29724034667015076,
-0.18370060622692108,
0.271273136138916,
-0.03125468268990517,
-0.030098557472229004,
0.44899776577949524,
0.6159470677375793,
-0.2538793087005615,
0.22215037047863007,
-0.26292404532432556,
-0.05332116782665253,
-0.1068459004163742,
-0.523232638835907,
0.5249373316764832,
-0.32421135902404785,
-0.47616660594940186,
-0.36990228295326233,
0.11333879083395004,
1.0231404304504395,
-0.16999101638793945,
0.8262000679969788,
0.2788211703300476,
-0.2491309642791748,
-0.07692091166973114,
-0.8159086108207703,
-0.1764613389968872,
-0.4738524556159973,
0.042042326182127,
0.04752936214208603,
-1.0796374082565308,
0.4662766456604004,
0.26407507061958313,
0.4100504517555237,
0.09762280434370041,
0.8090728521347046,
-0.0825745239853859,
0.6557444930076599,
0.5412408709526062,
0.170272558927536,
0.6540784239768982,
-0.28623878955841064,
0.35896289348602295,
-0.7767840027809143,
-0.30801787972450256,
-0.6067302823066711,
-0.2146950513124466,
-0.4792124330997467,
-0.7465440034866333,
0.28273507952690125,
-0.03423114866018295,
-0.3084132969379425,
0.13264766335487366,
-0.23172427713871002,
0.9273738265037537,
0.5257888436317444,
0.001393649959936738,
0.5345199704170227,
0.19749815762043,
0.026379665359854698,
0.08414008468389511,
-0.21448662877082825,
-0.8587561845779419,
1.41036856174469,
0.3464772403240204,
0.8362109661102295,
0.08496177196502686,
0.4674995243549347,
0.1179547905921936,
0.7531947493553162,
-1.005985140800476,
0.7195056676864624,
-0.15947896242141724,
-0.9471344351768494,
-0.3384247124195099,
-0.6433486938476562,
-0.32073867321014404,
0.36934834718704224,
-0.17069609463214874,
-0.5946875810623169,
-0.20897582173347473,
0.13396650552749634,
-0.28744661808013916,
0.6747814416885376,
-0.7755733728408813,
0.6701024174690247,
-0.0542021244764328,
-0.610643208026886,
-0.18597698211669922,
-0.35936567187309265,
0.29358750581741333,
-0.20886483788490295,
0.40982314944267273,
-0.24477675557136536,
-0.010919314809143543,
0.6863187551498413,
-0.40356290340423584,
0.6734508872032166,
-0.024150919169187546,
-0.3314678966999054,
0.5258195400238037,
0.3032812178134918,
0.34219348430633545,
-0.1289909929037094,
-0.21211674809455872,
0.17445728182792664,
-0.10963688790798187,
-0.5372569561004639,
-0.5144572854042053,
1.042695164680481,
-1.0475741624832153,
-0.6219434142112732,
-0.6830241680145264,
-0.5554671883583069,
0.019163675606250763,
-0.01806621626019478,
0.050733957439661026,
0.5841124057769775,
0.06378231197595596,
0.1197739765048027,
0.3194264769554138,
-0.33742809295654297,
0.35113298892974854,
0.7284552454948425,
-0.5272437930107117,
-0.5661448836326599,
1.0566750764846802,
0.29882708191871643,
0.8058645725250244,
0.32450205087661743,
0.43020522594451904,
-0.12638254463672638,
-0.3234816789627075,
-0.5170501470565796,
0.34637874364852905,
-1.0023242235183716,
-0.16134515404701233,
-0.6225338578224182,
-0.008962919004261494,
-0.4014260768890381,
-0.5995739698410034,
-0.19545391201972961,
-0.5121750831604004,
-0.15044713020324707,
-0.2735840380191803,
0.08894600719213486,
0.944118320941925,
0.10719624161720276,
0.5838472843170166,
-0.6268635392189026,
-0.09424983710050583,
0.5060263276100159,
0.3688133656978607,
0.1411508470773697,
-0.8640896677970886,
-0.012863101437687874,
0.002619071863591671,
-0.7343820929527283,
-0.5072349905967712,
0.08717205375432968,
0.28913000226020813,
0.036042794585227966,
0.43454205989837646,
-0.3494960069656372,
0.758988618850708,
-0.7749492526054382,
1.1205673217773438,
0.33306923508644104,
-1.1748600006103516,
0.33509331941604614,
-0.46877169609069824,
0.044707655906677246,
0.41996845602989197,
0.3887329399585724,
-0.5692200660705566,
-0.7918114066123962,
-0.2754940390586853,
-0.6680013537406921,
0.8276776671409607,
0.09093713760375977,
0.46006661653518677,
0.02087555080652237,
0.42036354541778564,
0.2531678378582001,
0.13951309025287628,
-1.2863121032714844,
-0.08114168792963028,
-0.1062876433134079,
-0.14071741700172424,
-0.45855793356895447,
-0.2800394296646118,
0.05140922591090202,
-0.21458564698696136,
0.7546122670173645,
-0.05972496047616005,
-0.20793874561786652,
0.12552589178085327,
-0.0258881077170372,
-0.38878586888313293,
0.5759580135345459,
0.7113844156265259,
0.7696110010147095,
-0.3144190013408661,
-0.03179103508591652,
0.14169307053089142,
-0.6704279780387878,
0.40901777148246765,
-0.5121725797653198,
-0.2370964139699936,
-0.2412303388118744,
0.3678438365459442,
0.3715551495552063,
-0.05966487526893616,
-0.7853065729141235,
0.5716447234153748,
0.19396701455116272,
-0.11292435973882675,
-0.2819914221763611,
0.015944039449095726,
-0.2535346746444702,
-0.018513169139623642,
0.3912551999092102,
-0.2412918657064438,
-0.11254018545150757,
-0.8563467264175415,
-0.43577754497528076,
0.2718486189842224,
-0.3825085759162903,
-0.33788639307022095,
0.38762325048446655,
0.5512648224830627,
-0.2544402778148651,
0.43592822551727295,
-0.013507994823157787,
-0.4018559157848358,
0.4876598119735718,
0.46389397978782654,
0.6913104057312012,
-0.2181292027235031,
0.49765443801879883,
0.45983946323394775,
0.36201778054237366,
-0.27030396461486816,
-0.15230034291744232,
-0.004038666840642691,
-0.36172550916671753,
-0.7091135382652283,
-0.9933182597160339,
-1.0096014738082886,
0.007178131490945816,
-0.514218270778656,
0.40527990460395813,
-0.8831301927566528,
-0.09744010865688324,
-0.07398534566164017,
0.045022834092378616,
-0.39392778277397156,
0.18668267130851746,
0.3419336676597595,
0.41578418016433716,
-0.8877677321434021,
0.5027921795845032,
1.0552988052368164,
-0.270384281873703,
-0.8173971176147461,
-0.2520284652709961,
0.26117295026779175,
-0.607731282711029,
0.4985800087451935,
0.33216744661331177,
-0.004676980897784233,
-0.05925978720188141,
-0.40054094791412354,
-0.7339276671409607,
1.0923765897750854,
0.16600191593170166,
-0.5710909962654114,
-0.32293081283569336,
0.09247789531946182,
0.7324428558349609,
-0.10570584982633591,
0.7515212893486023,
-0.031595006585121155,
0.24376952648162842,
0.16920866072177887,
-1.1383877992630005,
-0.288213849067688,
0.09743651002645493,
-0.1922697275876999,
0.48789405822753906,
-0.7146979570388794,
1.0609045028686523,
-0.30467861890792847,
0.015108756721019745,
0.26024729013442993,
0.4819159507751465,
0.10208747535943985,
0.4600958824157715,
0.16121482849121094,
0.8168821334838867,
0.6866785287857056,
-0.27933210134506226,
0.9868385791778564,
-0.18622997403144836,
0.6551600098609924,
0.7780138254165649,
-0.4024752676486969,
0.8774374127388,
0.45719361305236816,
-0.34960436820983887,
0.8937610983848572,
0.2823188304901123,
0.110428586602211,
0.018328703939914703,
0.1857554018497467,
-0.34287551045417786,
-0.4084276258945465,
-0.22150462865829468,
-0.42353901267051697,
0.47726935148239136,
0.40132907032966614,
-0.30208903551101685,
-0.32144030928611755,
0.27781862020492554,
0.21452368795871735,
0.25519657135009766,
-0.840363621711731,
0.5908981561660767,
0.09482398629188538,
-0.82338547706604,
0.2099035382270813,
0.12628644704818726,
0.5497575998306274,
-0.6998957991600037,
0.12054191529750824,
-0.356934517621994,
0.4106060564517975,
-0.1839858740568161,
-0.8707984685897827,
-0.25160011649131775,
0.6115025281906128,
-0.16728951036930084,
-0.5836415886878967,
0.09665322303771973,
-0.32882174849510193,
-0.7471876740455627,
0.006699679419398308,
0.30241909623146057,
0.266322523355484,
0.15804170072078705,
-0.15571729838848114,
-0.12614047527313232,
-0.1858784556388855,
-0.05312570556998253,
0.42501166462898254,
0.3277031183242798,
0.04102030396461487,
0.8938071727752686,
0.8355661034584045,
0.0888172835111618,
0.14290548861026764,
-0.07748643308877945,
0.7220835089683533,
-0.5859294533729553,
-0.3561537563800812,
-0.8585920929908752,
0.274374783039093,
0.1648135632276535,
-0.3592199981212616,
0.9403969049453735,
0.3045714199542999,
1.09501051902771,
-0.04582176357507706,
0.3630587160587311,
-0.12191515415906906,
0.3853512704372406,
-0.621392548084259,
0.43335407972335815,
-0.5425379276275635,
0.2744854986667633,
-0.47395798563957214,
-1.2016047239303589,
-0.290201336145401,
0.4359906315803528,
-0.6660403609275818,
0.08354859799146652,
0.9104790687561035,
0.59698086977005,
0.32283756136894226,
-0.1679014265537262,
0.39619725942611694,
-0.13815879821777344,
0.6276344060897827,
0.675031840801239,
1.0776703357696533,
-0.33860334753990173,
0.8128213286399841,
-0.26146596670150757,
-0.16788452863693237,
-0.26108109951019287,
-0.6720661520957947,
-1.2324004173278809,
-0.26574498414993286,
-0.40290898084640503,
-0.42978355288505554,
0.07804032415151596,
0.9526790976524353,
0.3445599377155304,
-0.6745467782020569,
-0.3452666103839874,
0.12038440257310867,
0.021150821819901466,
0.19472606480121613,
-0.2624543011188507,
0.1035308912396431,
-0.24924726784229279,
-0.9775402545928955,
0.08185587078332901,
0.3701534867286682,
0.26861482858657837,
-0.41959357261657715,
0.04379328712821007,
0.06844575703144073,
0.02587004192173481,
0.6642304062843323,
0.12701046466827393,
-0.9833163619041443,
-0.38128185272216797,
0.08527124673128128,
-0.393076092004776,
-0.053887564688920975,
0.8427613973617554,
-0.6609436273574829,
0.4384639859199524,
0.4307214915752411,
0.3058987557888031,
0.16529975831508636,
0.07953312247991562,
0.3562297224998474,
-0.44831082224845886,
0.07324528694152832,
0.3185625970363617,
0.30183497071266174,
0.5333254337310791,
-0.08332909643650055,
0.3676441013813019,
0.22820234298706055,
-0.8578802943229675,
-0.9933640360832214,
0.13417983055114746,
-0.8858498930931091,
-0.04071713238954544,
1.2168775796890259,
-0.3245023787021637,
0.0423956997692585,
0.22490184009075165,
-0.19489502906799316,
-0.23706962168216705,
-0.19900518655776978,
0.7850395441055298,
1.3477520942687988,
0.3575626015663147,
0.07933039218187332,
-0.47625553607940674,
-0.02530030533671379,
0.553642213344574,
-0.7785596251487732,
-0.09515967965126038,
0.586122453212738,
0.3272306025028229,
0.43386417627334595,
0.40623828768730164,
-0.22537942230701447,
0.1133454218506813,
-0.31942543387413025,
0.15152610838413239,
-0.14742237329483032,
-0.5528107285499573,
-0.3342413306236267,
0.2361907809972763,
0.16753047704696655,
0.13968436419963837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03774v1 | Learning a Decision Tree Algorithm with Transformers | 2024-02-06T07:40:53 | 2024-02-06T07:40:53 | Yufan Zhuang, Liyuan Liu, Chandan Singh, Jingbo Shang, Jianfeng Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Decision trees are renowned for their interpretability capability to achieve
high predictive performance, especially on tabular data. Traditionally, they
are constructed through recursive algorithms, where they partition the data at
every node in a tree. However, identifying the best partition is challenging,
as decision trees optimized for local segments may not bring global
generalization. To address this, we introduce MetaTree, which trains a
transformer-based model on filtered outputs from classical algorithms to
produce strong decision trees for classification. Specifically, we fit both
greedy decision trees and optimized decision trees on a large number of
datasets. We then train MetaTree to produce the trees that achieve strong
generalization performance. This training enables MetaTree to not only emulate
these algorithms, but also to intelligently adapt its strategy according to the
context, thereby achieving superior generalization performance. | [
-0.33918496966362,
-0.41136711835861206,
0.6179517507553101,
-0.1729128509759903,
-0.20831911265850067,
0.37458568811416626,
0.03573441877961159,
-0.18423347175121307,
0.10860297083854675,
0.47918710112571716,
-0.7011996507644653,
-0.4548095166683197,
-0.6506590843200684,
-0.009986075572669506,
-0.4608086049556732,
1.311020851135254,
0.024425985291600227,
-0.11984675377607346,
-0.11342957615852356,
-0.33765706419944763,
-0.6646169424057007,
-0.21277758479118347,
-0.5601897835731506,
-0.33832257986068726,
0.2930907607078552,
0.46210357546806335,
0.860191285610199,
0.6297094821929932,
0.5288717150688171,
0.40581879019737244,
0.05248938873410225,
-0.04068080335855484,
-0.31294843554496765,
0.12477032840251923,
-0.2947055995464325,
-0.5929652452468872,
-0.04936736449599266,
-0.14812031388282776,
0.5382259488105774,
0.5109926462173462,
-0.4747055172920227,
0.30938586592674255,
0.06772635132074356,
0.8048813343048096,
-0.546077311038971,
0.4727866053581238,
-0.8703617453575134,
0.6008586883544922,
-0.12160687893629074,
-0.33629199862480164,
-0.6820463538169861,
-0.666951060295105,
0.2183111160993576,
-0.44564369320869446,
0.6838602423667908,
-0.14630773663520813,
0.5575723052024841,
0.5141814947128296,
-0.7421720623970032,
-0.1316525936126709,
-1.099661111831665,
0.6516226530075073,
-0.03522747382521629,
0.523175835609436,
0.046116579324007034,
1.1826122999191284,
0.23532605171203613,
-0.8582671880722046,
0.11965116858482361,
0.1919107884168625,
-0.3542693555355072,
0.08745652437210083,
-0.14766384661197662,
0.2620956301689148,
0.4275698959827423,
0.3400704264640808,
-0.5448235869407654,
-0.14562132954597473,
-0.3249432146549225,
-0.10259386152029037,
0.4954732656478882,
0.4246758222579956,
-0.17285770177841187,
-0.14347043633460999,
0.10067387670278549,
-0.4441379904747009,
-0.2087550312280655,
0.25607582926750183,
0.027247892692685127,
0.3724018335342407,
0.4872080385684967,
0.12532629072666168,
0.03374283015727997,
0.8088284730911255,
0.2400914430618286,
-0.25376608967781067,
0.1502389758825302,
-0.012496507726609707,
-0.33210936188697815,
0.08580169081687927,
0.5421735048294067,
0.08525320887565613,
0.2799093425273895,
-0.37458813190460205,
-0.28844475746154785,
0.15097467601299286,
0.3744405210018158,
-0.9609617590904236,
-0.30585408210754395,
-0.03626362606883049,
-0.5879263281822205,
-0.6386539340019226,
0.2100265622138977,
-0.9318806529045105,
-0.2366202026605606,
-0.27474531531333923,
0.1653042882680893,
-0.13478974997997284,
-0.04136307165026665,
-0.25096479058265686,
-0.03465329855680466,
0.2547781765460968,
0.23431159555912018,
-1.200093150138855,
0.40902408957481384,
0.5876779556274414,
0.6448022723197937,
0.056582577526569366,
-0.0455746091902256,
-0.6882571578025818,
0.1311108022928238,
-0.4493604600429535,
0.7390839457511902,
-0.9705361723899841,
-0.28695204854011536,
-0.16547857224941254,
0.06170729175209999,
-0.3202863931655884,
-0.7822378277778625,
0.8788518309593201,
-0.5857610106468201,
0.15318188071250916,
-0.008742006495594978,
-0.16023044288158417,
-0.6304227113723755,
0.09733869135379791,
-0.8354191780090332,
0.6851387619972229,
0.5828046798706055,
-0.8562005162239075,
0.9423877596855164,
-0.7737606167793274,
-0.5864220857620239,
0.11731968075037003,
-0.1906207799911499,
-0.9056686758995056,
0.2833043336868286,
0.31831374764442444,
0.4910274147987366,
-0.32788410782814026,
0.7595126628875732,
-0.07422616332769394,
0.005831896793097258,
-0.38074925541877747,
-0.4423532485961914,
0.453167200088501,
0.2215109020471573,
-0.2634347677230835,
0.23164419829845428,
-0.5044673681259155,
0.12715835869312286,
0.25836771726608276,
-0.3306255340576172,
0.010064970701932907,
0.5108206272125244,
-0.1257120966911316,
-0.12376855313777924,
-0.340269535779953,
-0.4813469648361206,
0.4954632520675659,
-0.3052440285682678,
0.6907156109809875,
0.6726486682891846,
-0.16605091094970703,
0.43016377091407776,
-0.1131022647023201,
0.586101233959198,
0.01371193677186966,
0.24881722033023834,
-0.17912106215953827,
-0.5271674394607544,
-0.5714430809020996,
0.21700355410575867,
0.7349032163619995,
0.6167336702346802,
-0.5952188968658447,
0.42629575729370117,
-0.5904355049133301,
-0.5205575227737427,
-0.38863736391067505,
-0.09407868981361389,
-0.20165839791297913,
0.44098833203315735,
0.41140279173851013,
-0.10734865814447403,
-0.8830510377883911,
-1.0290553569793701,
-0.08889336884021759,
0.00008879968663677573,
-0.06249000504612923,
0.3469211757183075,
0.4391389489173889,
-0.5692003965377808,
1.3698201179504395,
-0.7174894213676453,
-0.3306378722190857,
-0.22788812220096588,
0.10003717243671417,
0.6632554531097412,
0.22445134818553925,
0.2407407909631729,
-0.8841294050216675,
-0.6539362072944641,
0.3246125280857086,
-0.6601824760437012,
0.20978696644306183,
-0.24110236763954163,
0.1956033557653427,
-0.050386808812618256,
0.3043266236782074,
-0.42168089747428894,
0.29218339920043945,
0.34852340817451477,
-0.31360676884651184,
0.2420114427804947,
0.015469029545783997,
-0.1693134605884552,
-0.9195008277893066,
-0.050718553364276886,
-0.11037487536668777,
-0.5203080773353577,
-0.5027604103088379,
-0.12487713992595673,
-0.028153790161013603,
-0.3104058504104614,
-0.14749424159526825,
-0.04871674254536629,
-0.01549600251019001,
-0.3415304124355316,
0.0013562473468482494,
-0.5551867485046387,
-0.19250264763832092,
0.4787968695163727,
0.1475759893655777,
0.5808571577072144,
0.6545131802558899,
-0.5564968585968018,
0.3527141511440277,
0.21719181537628174,
-0.22559604048728943,
0.5390159487724304,
-0.2916245758533478,
-0.07778055965900421,
-0.43069204688072205,
0.6117886304855347,
-0.7190409898757935,
-0.17519153654575348,
0.01652856171131134,
-0.22296132147312164,
0.3275209963321686,
-0.2604171335697174,
-0.0033969494979828596,
-0.8709073662757874,
-0.09356317669153214,
0.3356896936893463,
0.4932754635810852,
-0.9014587998390198,
1.32767653465271,
0.0878489688038826,
0.5040031671524048,
-0.4877111613750458,
-0.4680436849594116,
-0.2657361924648285,
-0.3359944820404053,
-0.616790771484375,
0.4628946781158447,
0.3079628646373749,
0.17997214198112488,
0.11763957142829895,
-0.1383925974369049,
-0.0571417510509491,
0.2616089880466461,
0.4063166677951813,
-0.22084687650203705,
-0.06037391722202301,
0.18047265708446503,
0.007779039908200502,
-0.5105233192443848,
0.07877978682518005,
-0.4872712790966034,
0.4091898500919342,
-0.22586530447006226,
-0.3078816831111908,
-0.38963618874549866,
-0.09577236324548721,
0.6899980902671814,
-0.32427355647087097,
0.37271592020988464,
0.6409477591514587,
-0.19211959838867188,
-0.480082243680954,
-0.2529677152633667,
-0.37313687801361084,
-0.493266761302948,
0.5152547359466553,
-0.5405479669570923,
-0.44197890162467957,
0.11296682804822922,
-0.38759854435920715,
0.4371492862701416,
0.6111751794815063,
0.09066874533891678,
0.037045639008283615,
1.4989632368087769,
0.45400136709213257,
-0.35860931873321533,
0.4060076177120209,
-0.8171249032020569,
0.2260402888059616,
-0.5829768180847168,
-0.12406624108552933,
-0.5117709636688232,
-0.686161458492279,
-0.8624765276908875,
-0.2161363661289215,
0.3410949110984802,
-0.2301720380783081,
-0.3358563780784607,
0.31536534428596497,
-0.9534671902656555,
0.6626753807067871,
0.7293701767921448,
0.08894617110490799,
0.24794690310955048,
0.14470785856246948,
0.03915033116936684,
0.12025799602270126,
-0.7666604518890381,
-0.32405680418014526,
1.0987063646316528,
0.518210768699646,
0.4799584150314331,
-0.318845272064209,
0.6911537051200867,
0.3912232518196106,
0.6258352994918823,
-0.9950283169746399,
0.3441126346588135,
-0.28008130192756653,
-0.37424638867378235,
-0.24007725715637207,
-0.7372420430183411,
-1.345926284790039,
0.3443555235862732,
-0.2884778082370758,
-0.36543595790863037,
0.02632478065788746,
0.19769233465194702,
-0.28484925627708435,
0.7280463576316833,
-0.8071051239967346,
0.9385243654251099,
-0.35851070284843445,
0.05485985055565834,
-0.3364810347557068,
-0.4797806739807129,
0.2963593006134033,
-0.2055748850107193,
0.04911739006638527,
0.3653401732444763,
0.3367988169193268,
1.0452659130096436,
-0.30360710620880127,
0.6206308603286743,
-0.5565265417098999,
0.4898427426815033,
0.46002915501594543,
0.29988154768943787,
0.6743550300598145,
-0.19916488230228424,
0.11323079466819763,
-0.060695622116327286,
-0.06770332157611847,
-0.19990164041519165,
-0.6952781677246094,
0.13983164727687836,
-0.885145902633667,
-0.6151204109191895,
-0.4146564304828644,
-0.23134875297546387,
-0.2121393382549286,
0.027079440653324127,
0.12893247604370117,
0.25638556480407715,
-0.3230760991573334,
0.4308249056339264,
0.34256964921951294,
0.049728259444236755,
0.5593229532241821,
0.3067309856414795,
-0.34670212864875793,
-0.5550145506858826,
1.1568607091903687,
0.3424224555492401,
-0.223496213555336,
0.5396355986595154,
0.626564085483551,
-0.26777148246765137,
-0.6108168959617615,
-0.5318285226821899,
-0.15863461792469025,
-0.40329471230506897,
-0.5880264639854431,
-0.495173841714859,
-0.4121006727218628,
0.0627056434750557,
-0.10591235756874084,
0.0013833316043019295,
-0.23438085615634918,
0.1161864623427391,
-0.5260819792747498,
0.08173560351133347,
1.038619041442871,
0.031486280262470245,
0.5986959934234619,
-0.7822805643081665,
0.21198683977127075,
1.0030606985092163,
0.42049700021743774,
0.11406600475311279,
-0.0851539894938469,
-0.09057410061359406,
-0.1639651209115982,
-0.9952819347381592,
-0.8093055486679077,
0.17660658061504364,
0.26895081996917725,
0.4883391261100769,
0.6588709354400635,
-0.2586422264575958,
0.2548335790634155,
-0.46292439103126526,
0.12466874718666077,
0.10484149307012558,
-0.7618256211280823,
0.5673471093177795,
-0.1561182141304016,
0.21185371279716492,
0.7600657343864441,
0.3387623429298401,
-0.5145035982131958,
0.08466032892465591,
-0.8271303176879883,
-0.3950250446796417,
1.0444176197052002,
-0.043636713176965714,
-0.16626065969467163,
0.3940799832344055,
0.1572173684835434,
0.1616828441619873,
0.2385147660970688,
-0.793287456035614,
0.11690618842840195,
-0.3641146421432495,
-0.33536919951438904,
-0.19922327995300293,
0.048929017037153244,
0.14731207489967346,
-0.5538808107376099,
0.3367864489555359,
-0.19125832617282867,
0.027121758088469505,
-0.04896409437060356,
-0.03583149239420891,
-0.3383639454841614,
0.112474225461483,
0.019221866503357887,
0.566169798374176,
-0.3483085632324219,
0.20011495053768158,
0.4549170434474945,
-0.4240444600582123,
0.28143835067749023,
-0.18424735963344574,
-0.44978460669517517,
-0.07321716099977493,
0.4377926290035248,
1.0684818029403687,
-0.21722091734409332,
-0.25409218668937683,
0.41589540243148804,
-0.06745847314596176,
-0.4291940927505493,
-0.014389739371836185,
0.11058260500431061,
0.013586606830358505,
0.2115524858236313,
0.46246129274368286,
0.4543827772140503,
0.3710317611694336,
-0.5915685296058655,
0.33431240916252136,
0.6563448309898376,
-0.38076052069664,
-0.3607073426246643,
0.44482746720314026,
0.4861811101436615,
-0.5353960394859314,
0.8881118893623352,
-0.1246340200304985,
-1.0185260772705078,
0.6492995023727417,
0.3384845554828644,
1.0967447757720947,
-0.5971808433532715,
0.5033432841300964,
0.6410245895385742,
0.3826894760131836,
0.09002934396266937,
-0.24308130145072937,
-0.43645626306533813,
-0.6003815531730652,
-0.41069477796554565,
-0.7265878319740295,
-0.4061190187931061,
-0.10308482497930527,
-0.3741344213485718,
0.27834364771842957,
-0.5681418180465698,
-0.2394077330827713,
-0.09677319973707199,
-0.03675736486911774,
-0.948357343673706,
0.26471367478370667,
-0.036719221621751785,
0.8555304408073425,
-1.1838750839233398,
0.6079049706459045,
0.23594863712787628,
0.14662311971187592,
-0.634004533290863,
-0.1828276813030243,
-0.5604355335235596,
-0.6406460404396057,
0.5899928212165833,
0.6556079983711243,
0.2783248722553253,
-0.03459690883755684,
-0.22195981442928314,
-0.7625872492790222,
1.1445680856704712,
0.29251718521118164,
-0.8120017051696777,
-0.22409005463123322,
0.35598281025886536,
0.3946599066257477,
-0.26383841037750244,
0.771634042263031,
0.971580982208252,
0.8163483738899231,
0.30132928490638733,
-0.5872136950492859,
-0.2437550127506256,
0.25997698307037354,
-0.17181938886642456,
0.7995590567588806,
-0.3461731970310211,
0.6344296932220459,
-0.1374160349369049,
-0.4861786365509033,
-0.7198436260223389,
0.5118820071220398,
-0.17431311309337616,
0.46386489272117615,
0.9733037948608398,
1.0333267450332642,
0.8561477065086365,
-0.37301141023635864,
0.9056721925735474,
-0.12665899097919464,
0.52912437915802,
0.9622430801391602,
-0.048105109483003616,
0.6824991703033447,
-0.016051018610596657,
-0.46755367517471313,
0.693206250667572,
0.8153778910636902,
-0.3875550627708435,
0.567609965801239,
0.10010888427495956,
-0.0035437201149761677,
-0.38643667101860046,
0.1780782788991928,
-0.12114085257053375,
0.4173852801322937,
0.1601853221654892,
-0.5963663458824158,
-0.6548465490341187,
0.13022349774837494,
-0.3998086750507355,
-0.15887556970119476,
-0.48486945033073425,
1.043060541152954,
-0.420012891292572,
-0.8390592932701111,
0.437366783618927,
-0.0016442689811810851,
0.4289392828941345,
-0.43291783332824707,
-0.10063263028860092,
0.04852035269141197,
0.239316925406456,
-0.7115549445152283,
-0.8231853246688843,
0.5670767426490784,
-0.4003027081489563,
-0.23381611704826355,
-0.3000161647796631,
0.48336687684059143,
-0.092788927257061,
-0.7462465167045593,
0.22379621863365173,
0.3119341731071472,
-0.16973289847373962,
-0.2604859173297882,
-0.6016256809234619,
-0.33016008138656616,
0.33086520433425903,
-0.06675280630588531,
-0.002757617738097906,
0.19503197073936462,
-0.27646782994270325,
0.7057245969772339,
0.465385764837265,
-0.3889061212539673,
-0.17853285372257233,
-0.051052045077085495,
0.8532467484474182,
-0.5891635417938232,
-0.44448214769363403,
-0.9574180841445923,
0.31307217478752136,
0.019536007195711136,
0.13805252313613892,
0.29030072689056396,
0.910656213760376,
0.6481456756591797,
0.02960197813808918,
0.6097984313964844,
-0.028901033103466034,
0.4279239773750305,
-0.22144104540348053,
0.1447988897562027,
-0.22306370735168457,
-0.2906009554862976,
0.053602974861860275,
-1.4243777990341187,
-0.26804015040397644,
0.5766923427581787,
-0.6091987490653992,
0.11227688193321228,
0.6375005841255188,
0.6608628034591675,
-0.467656672000885,
0.2769501209259033,
0.09242963790893555,
0.11054549366235733,
0.47411495447158813,
0.8262910842895508,
0.7379185557365417,
-0.32292601466178894,
0.857093334197998,
-0.10668927431106567,
-0.38394784927368164,
-0.1891084462404251,
-0.5545991063117981,
-0.6983689665794373,
-0.6856057047843933,
0.018911205232143402,
-0.15191680192947388,
-0.24150045216083527,
0.700538158416748,
1.0791637897491455,
-0.9231970310211182,
-0.23310795426368713,
-0.6086810231208801,
0.5016167759895325,
-0.20031403005123138,
-0.2879595458507538,
0.5712798237800598,
-0.35769107937812805,
-0.4796365201473236,
0.2615811824798584,
-0.05601731687784195,
0.024844959378242493,
-0.22654837369918823,
-0.04280427098274231,
0.3052399158477783,
-0.16030673682689667,
0.5308268070220947,
0.03192715719342232,
-0.17216268181800842,
-0.1316332370042801,
-0.38740766048431396,
0.4027901589870453,
0.47222036123275757,
1.0570969581604004,
-1.2533485889434814,
0.43505093455314636,
0.5778130888938904,
0.7261012196540833,
0.9084951877593994,
0.37735676765441895,
0.3978427052497864,
-0.32440224289894104,
-0.3129732012748718,
0.5155758857727051,
0.3918285667896271,
0.29902729392051697,
-0.09042509645223618,
0.7826533913612366,
0.1892886757850647,
-0.6025101542472839,
-0.6755635142326355,
0.1974785029888153,
-0.5314656496047974,
-0.3304682970046997,
0.6764904856681824,
0.5636609792709351,
-0.40935686230659485,
0.06609413027763367,
-0.5551081299781799,
0.013535228557884693,
-0.3353528380393982,
0.5691003203392029,
0.4422873854637146,
-0.01595303602516651,
0.025219108909368515,
-0.21082055568695068,
0.6625593304634094,
0.2236853390932083,
-0.6933218240737915,
0.16508737206459045,
0.16698381304740906,
0.22575244307518005,
0.41001567244529724,
0.14952296018600464,
0.2632324695587158,
0.09488790482282639,
-0.23384588956832886,
-0.1706472933292389,
0.1341114193201065,
-0.6917194128036499,
-0.26690948009490967,
0.6253998279571533,
0.13944172859191895,
-0.25116419792175293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03757v1 | The Instinctive Bias: Spurious Images lead to Hallucination in MLLMs | 2024-02-06T06:48:46 | 2024-02-06T06:48:46 | Tianyang Han, Qing Lian, Rui Pan, Renjie Pi, Jipeng Zhang, Shizhe Diao, Yong Lin, Tong Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have recently experienced remarkable progress,
where the advent of multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) has endowed LLMs
with visual capabilities, leading to impressive performances in various
multi-modal tasks. However, those powerful MLLMs such as GPT-4V still fail
spectacularly when presented with certain image and text inputs. In this paper,
we identify a typical class of inputs that baffles MLLMs, which consist of
images that are highly relevant but inconsistent with answers, causing MLLMs to
suffer from hallucination. To quantify the effect, we propose CorrelationQA,
the first benchmark that assesses the hallucination level given spurious
images. This benchmark contains 7,308 text-image pairs across 13 categories.
Based on the proposed CorrelationQA, we conduct a thorough analysis on 9
mainstream MLLMs, illustrating that they universally suffer from this
instinctive bias to varying degrees. We hope that our curated benchmark and
evaluation results aid in better assessments of the MLLMs' robustness in the
presence of misleading images. The resource is available in
https://github.com/MasaiahHan/CorrelationQA. | [
-0.47754979133605957,
-0.8887516260147095,
0.7602960467338562,
0.28518736362457275,
-0.3908889889717102,
-0.1470344364643097,
-0.025463169440627098,
-0.543384313583374,
0.05875843018293381,
0.4181865453720093,
-0.5372719168663025,
-0.42006149888038635,
-0.8204355835914612,
0.16583941876888275,
-0.5567429661750793,
0.8627718687057495,
-0.017894485965371132,
0.2706042528152466,
-0.320891410112381,
-0.29009780287742615,
-0.7119858264923096,
-0.7271074056625366,
-0.38186925649642944,
-0.11834973841905594,
0.6068515777587891,
-0.12773095071315765,
0.911405622959137,
0.1950875073671341,
0.4813108444213867,
0.16413530707359314,
0.16514568030834198,
0.26694801449775696,
-0.6091029047966003,
0.2660481333732605,
0.13531313836574554,
-0.16921928524971008,
-0.210528165102005,
-0.057924140244722366,
0.4737922251224518,
0.40157046914100647,
0.33006513118743896,
0.07781723886728287,
0.16057811677455902,
0.8416656255722046,
-0.7072120308876038,
-0.02510027401149273,
-0.8549379110336304,
0.17156286537647247,
-0.08282383531332016,
-0.4714130163192749,
-0.5058881044387817,
-0.2659716010093689,
0.17259541153907776,
-0.4798778295516968,
0.25746339559555054,
0.0445404052734375,
0.9698188900947571,
0.761410117149353,
-0.34963729977607727,
-0.4902910590171814,
-0.6292043924331665,
0.6560649871826172,
-0.2588598132133484,
0.5560805201530457,
0.7295827269554138,
-0.0050877900794148445,
-0.16891752183437347,
-0.48972073197364807,
-0.4189535081386566,
-0.3153669834136963,
-0.06544613838195801,
-0.06021866202354431,
-0.06201130524277687,
-0.20263950526714325,
0.45851460099220276,
0.020454732701182365,
-0.7223206758499146,
-0.046673741191625595,
-0.06525711715221405,
-0.42889347672462463,
0.3437272310256958,
0.15693457424640656,
0.24670915305614471,
-0.07306405901908875,
-0.3344515562057495,
-0.2450832724571228,
-0.6542797684669495,
-0.12237828969955444,
0.4144282937049866,
-0.0173337422311306,
0.08051615208387375,
0.5721980333328247,
0.2067594975233078,
0.7204333543777466,
0.06145494431257248,
0.02511967532336712,
0.3193126320838928,
-0.3139403164386749,
-0.2580379247665405,
-0.01655670441687107,
1.0499099493026733,
0.5926185846328735,
0.22762176394462585,
-0.09106700867414474,
-0.25115475058555603,
0.28916680812835693,
0.38598868250846863,
-0.7788535952568054,
-0.2944798767566681,
0.3353939652442932,
-0.4159839451313019,
-0.5736541152000427,
-0.0849786251783371,
-0.8988329768180847,
-0.840199887752533,
0.1012793704867363,
0.651128888130188,
-0.5399607419967651,
0.038919102400541306,
-0.09363562613725662,
-0.12813663482666016,
0.3342475891113281,
0.3059067130088806,
-0.6865952014923096,
0.09995931386947632,
0.37077105045318604,
0.9503328800201416,
-0.3794887065887451,
-0.40753263235092163,
-0.6342740654945374,
-0.35390833020210266,
-0.645635724067688,
0.9776029586791992,
-0.4468234181404114,
-0.40615251660346985,
0.062003690749406815,
0.005842805840075016,
0.09326278418302536,
-0.5232452750205994,
1.021596074104309,
-0.6262570023536682,
0.14540374279022217,
-0.525493323802948,
-0.25412696599960327,
-0.20085683465003967,
0.2822034955024719,
-0.8566440939903259,
1.0764293670654297,
-0.1857522577047348,
-0.945122241973877,
0.810873806476593,
-0.18516795337200165,
-0.22618278861045837,
-0.10129902511835098,
-0.6948792338371277,
-0.6966612935066223,
-0.06318081170320511,
0.28626811504364014,
0.4481929540634155,
-0.18237687647342682,
0.5892121195793152,
-0.4103696346282959,
-0.718413770198822,
0.5571334362030029,
-0.7135629653930664,
0.7954898476600647,
0.0018814431969076395,
-0.6248210072517395,
0.20353469252586365,
-0.7080753445625305,
-0.35523533821105957,
0.29385101795196533,
0.15701960027217865,
-0.5190346240997314,
0.04575686901807785,
0.05478360131382942,
0.4200253188610077,
0.03922956436872482,
-0.026621805503964424,
-0.028621304780244827,
0.12700307369232178,
-0.0588427409529686,
1.0553041696548462,
-0.12270045280456543,
0.21102431416511536,
-0.478788286447525,
0.2512371242046356,
0.30648788809776306,
0.1146952360868454,
-0.08841799199581146,
-0.6375265121459961,
-0.7653928995132446,
-0.19684521853923798,
-0.08360913395881653,
0.22290578484535217,
-0.9051395654678345,
0.3245720863342285,
-0.09399908781051636,
-0.35850632190704346,
-0.469190776348114,
0.13467614352703094,
0.2557184100151062,
0.45070090889930725,
0.4693968892097473,
-0.43292009830474854,
-0.4572789967060089,
-1.2115161418914795,
-0.46409621834754944,
-0.040394023060798645,
0.012583465315401554,
0.42054471373558044,
0.4494732916355133,
-0.3368559181690216,
0.5017679333686829,
-0.020216772332787514,
-0.606156587600708,
0.3753911554813385,
0.19074103236198425,
0.07115647196769714,
0.2110767960548401,
0.5750739574432373,
-0.7959308624267578,
-0.2275436669588089,
-0.22851434350013733,
-0.89417564868927,
0.10867080092430115,
-0.3891255855560303,
-0.12343797087669373,
0.5315671563148499,
0.3168928921222687,
-0.7381415963172913,
0.5937004089355469,
0.5470839142799377,
-0.512433648109436,
0.908997118473053,
0.05229184404015541,
0.13970376551151276,
-0.661162257194519,
0.04079875349998474,
0.09452676773071289,
-0.032541029155254364,
-0.3771328330039978,
-0.238764226436615,
0.13105210661888123,
0.47282248735427856,
-0.20762436091899872,
0.40329092741012573,
-0.627343475818634,
-0.25877925753593445,
-0.03744993358850479,
-0.05465089902281761,
-0.033061932772397995,
0.39493879675865173,
0.18969158828258514,
0.8494074940681458,
0.9146633148193359,
-0.5477397441864014,
0.2583761215209961,
0.19665735960006714,
-0.38543710112571716,
0.3957105875015259,
-0.4594579339027405,
0.35332903265953064,
-0.16660520434379578,
0.3023283779621124,
-0.7380737662315369,
-0.4236818850040436,
0.47581082582473755,
-0.38182345032691956,
0.23938146233558655,
0.2016630470752716,
-0.4389788508415222,
-0.20562702417373657,
-0.5869590640068054,
0.5117864012718201,
0.570519208908081,
-0.6741078495979309,
0.5155985951423645,
0.24346904456615448,
0.36460527777671814,
-1.041344404220581,
-0.8012278079986572,
0.24105508625507355,
-0.2563506066799164,
-0.2947654724121094,
-0.009449157863855362,
-0.0804065391421318,
-0.24883930385112762,
-0.05821805074810982,
-0.07115017622709274,
-0.02864123322069645,
-0.08267544209957123,
0.5356106162071228,
0.4990280568599701,
-0.1376774162054062,
0.09823717921972275,
-0.43218889832496643,
0.36997339129447937,
0.523941695690155,
-0.14569367468357086,
0.6049063801765442,
-0.2106425166130066,
-0.5215060710906982,
-0.29968374967575073,
0.057161636650562286,
0.7656458020210266,
0.26260480284690857,
0.5443012118339539,
0.7916589975357056,
-0.21168483793735504,
-0.12093287706375122,
-0.6670821905136108,
-0.41572749614715576,
-0.42036938667297363,
0.48470452427864075,
-0.49361684918403625,
-0.7367138862609863,
0.4912511706352234,
0.3881574273109436,
-0.20144832134246826,
0.14949703216552734,
0.7767736911773682,
0.04421228915452957,
0.9812242388725281,
0.26265043020248413,
-0.08948000520467758,
0.20636962354183197,
0.01041422225534916,
0.14183948934078217,
-0.704294741153717,
-0.24419328570365906,
-0.2590092718601227,
-0.1170373484492302,
-0.6219708919525146,
-0.6392995715141296,
0.27013543248176575,
-0.39926260709762573,
-0.07350021600723267,
-0.1649642437696457,
-0.6201844215393066,
0.451354444026947,
0.5205256342887878,
0.3021165132522583,
0.3237086832523346,
0.174981951713562,
-0.3768877387046814,
-0.23923182487487793,
-0.6696118712425232,
-0.6555978655815125,
1.2837871313095093,
0.32670724391937256,
0.8294369578361511,
-0.04813417047262192,
0.30128082633018494,
0.33269691467285156,
0.22039858996868134,
-0.9208505749702454,
0.4961811900138855,
0.2162366360425949,
-0.6036058664321899,
-0.2378077208995819,
-0.07962244749069214,
-0.8979140520095825,
0.3449714183807373,
-0.35563546419143677,
-0.6945211291313171,
0.2675255537033081,
0.2640519440174103,
-0.14114433526992798,
0.2020009309053421,
-0.3566814363002777,
0.725999653339386,
-0.4020213186740875,
-0.9808120727539062,
0.05577579885721207,
-0.6719756722450256,
0.9525192975997925,
-0.45540836453437805,
0.31196483969688416,
0.16588430106639862,
-0.02728964015841484,
0.5341625809669495,
-0.07589548081159592,
0.838996171951294,
0.08980387449264526,
-0.26263687014579773,
0.07312796264886856,
0.38350537419319153,
0.5804603695869446,
-0.15685486793518066,
0.051671333611011505,
0.27014726400375366,
-0.3092578053474426,
-0.4556887745857239,
-0.5041900873184204,
0.6551340222358704,
-0.7795493006706238,
-0.5103752613067627,
-0.6508331298828125,
-0.5247632265090942,
-0.4093412458896637,
-0.037119243294000626,
0.685741126537323,
0.47562775015830994,
-0.28204286098480225,
0.04943610727787018,
0.6708018183708191,
-0.29019010066986084,
0.3401981294155121,
-0.05895596742630005,
-0.44405892491340637,
-0.0581897497177124,
0.9010182619094849,
-0.0475391149520874,
0.1653180867433548,
-0.13704578578472137,
-0.10048846155405045,
-0.41268810629844666,
-0.5885090231895447,
-0.4749488830566406,
0.12040867656469345,
-0.9510406851768494,
0.02687392570078373,
-0.9091088175773621,
-0.24199514091014862,
-0.29960402846336365,
-0.015450804494321346,
-0.24334445595741272,
-0.006023317575454712,
-0.37484750151634216,
0.12299516797065735,
0.15301722288131714,
0.8472630381584167,
0.11124563962221146,
-0.2818184792995453,
-0.4948537349700928,
0.3668444752693176,
0.4023776650428772,
0.376870721578598,
0.13279898464679718,
-0.7632457613945007,
-0.040169790387153625,
-0.2395549863576889,
-0.24524128437042236,
-0.8758549690246582,
0.2681446075439453,
-0.07215102016925812,
0.5502145886421204,
0.6925792694091797,
0.014177031815052032,
0.5904768109321594,
-0.5007402300834656,
0.8679738640785217,
0.10439564287662506,
-0.6309385299682617,
0.2534177601337433,
-0.3090365529060364,
0.12020938098430634,
0.4076472818851471,
0.6336357593536377,
-0.18631160259246826,
-0.6426185965538025,
-0.5627618432044983,
-0.5261163115501404,
0.38276636600494385,
0.2774532735347748,
0.029363350942730904,
0.01429507415741682,
-0.12062779814004898,
0.37267836928367615,
-0.13568387925624847,
-1.0886220932006836,
-0.2770991921424866,
-0.3683926463127136,
0.12304455786943436,
-0.007209438364952803,
-0.5308623313903809,
-0.2582137882709503,
-0.23456521332263947,
0.6114752292633057,
-0.14323295652866364,
0.19689711928367615,
0.4996233284473419,
-0.3745010793209076,
-0.13339155912399292,
0.058156490325927734,
0.9689064621925354,
0.5397903323173523,
-0.35732004046440125,
0.5824748873710632,
0.012412519194185734,
-0.728702187538147,
0.2565571963787079,
-0.27384084463119507,
-0.2721474766731262,
0.29286056756973267,
0.3809976279735565,
1.0246938467025757,
-0.06966833025217056,
-0.6941778063774109,
0.685461699962616,
-0.2929365932941437,
-0.330908864736557,
-0.3608244061470032,
-0.13802190124988556,
-0.12150803953409195,
-0.11232857406139374,
0.5062519311904907,
0.5053753852844238,
0.34331831336021423,
-0.4100314676761627,
0.29177233576774597,
0.8063076138496399,
-0.49606895446777344,
-0.37214696407318115,
0.5885070562362671,
-0.08868535608053207,
-0.1585872918367386,
0.2617940306663513,
-0.25723549723625183,
-0.6535915732383728,
0.41354072093963623,
0.3824615478515625,
0.9400108456611633,
0.08194338530302048,
0.24777916073799133,
0.5192362666130066,
0.7435573935508728,
-0.20786863565444946,
0.0007711859070695937,
0.0896778553724289,
-0.878504753112793,
-0.2091292440891266,
-0.4235743582248688,
-0.24790969491004944,
0.5355409383773804,
-0.4448915719985962,
0.5013753771781921,
-0.31838399171829224,
-0.22619397938251495,
-0.23433591425418854,
-0.5203741788864136,
-0.8968667387962341,
-0.04789239913225174,
0.3204764127731323,
0.5034300088882446,
-0.8931947350502014,
0.798481285572052,
0.6713569760322571,
-0.3105570375919342,
-0.6702677607536316,
0.3419071137905121,
0.2801235318183899,
-0.9223138093948364,
0.8059895634651184,
0.31180062890052795,
-0.27784985303878784,
-0.24809153378009796,
-0.7319919466972351,
-0.6288481950759888,
0.6952585577964783,
0.06942570954561234,
-0.4564349949359894,
0.160514235496521,
0.11435335874557495,
0.3393368124961853,
-0.32127517461776733,
0.3461889922618866,
0.7050067782402039,
0.6186366677284241,
0.14821477234363556,
-0.7069714069366455,
0.5096777081489563,
-0.15869620442390442,
-0.07140029221773148,
-0.19733557105064392,
-0.48679736256599426,
0.7797510027885437,
-0.41575077176094055,
-0.1721261739730835,
-0.07038123905658722,
0.19361503422260284,
0.46813419461250305,
0.3952515423297882,
0.5052189826965332,
0.4372319281101227,
0.724483847618103,
0.03782869130373001,
1.0040323734283447,
-0.08614106476306915,
0.11274010688066483,
1.2085281610488892,
-0.3275143802165985,
0.7069298028945923,
0.8473422527313232,
-0.09308953583240509,
0.44333595037460327,
0.7748240828514099,
-0.27704745531082153,
0.4667435884475708,
0.05189971253275871,
-0.22061437368392944,
-0.11136212199926376,
-0.08042050898075104,
-0.37005579471588135,
0.37388262152671814,
0.4712502658367157,
-0.5435184836387634,
0.057452648878097534,
-0.1280842274427414,
-0.2784261405467987,
-0.23493030667304993,
0.03288538381457329,
0.6623275876045227,
0.00646072207018733,
-0.6794171333312988,
0.9811625480651855,
-0.7805057764053345,
0.9458224177360535,
-0.17403346300125122,
-0.027952896431088448,
-0.23150844871997833,
-0.17475466430187225,
-0.3379794657230377,
-0.6904978156089783,
0.15436430275440216,
-0.05338433012366295,
0.023262420669198036,
0.06295126676559448,
0.9556534290313721,
-0.21215176582336426,
-0.4100254774093628,
0.4540878236293793,
0.6225263476371765,
0.4793684184551239,
-0.20866559445858002,
-0.7167488932609558,
0.5475349426269531,
-0.006436546333134174,
-0.2539583444595337,
0.34581494331359863,
0.5044472217559814,
-0.15210668742656708,
0.6208683252334595,
0.5831413269042969,
0.11600716412067413,
0.20037686824798584,
0.1431247740983963,
0.8857900500297546,
-0.596686601638794,
-0.09685757756233215,
-1.2058889865875244,
0.3558865487575531,
-0.19563885033130646,
-0.2789480686187744,
0.7711336016654968,
0.5556934475898743,
0.573696494102478,
-0.26194798946380615,
0.7631729245185852,
0.29868024587631226,
-0.08940775692462921,
-0.5486183166503906,
0.8547346591949463,
-0.5512453317642212,
0.2808935046195984,
-0.5902587175369263,
-1.011950969696045,
-0.373343825340271,
0.5795284509658813,
-0.2812648415565491,
-0.026325030252337456,
1.0779660940170288,
0.9592137932777405,
0.08062735199928284,
-0.003937956877052784,
0.7110097408294678,
0.3650481402873993,
0.026038408279418945,
0.40331998467445374,
1.2393447160720825,
-0.42168349027633667,
0.6036818027496338,
-0.22096028923988342,
-0.1927076131105423,
-0.3821040987968445,
-0.9643577337265015,
-1.1926735639572144,
-0.748355507850647,
-0.22736209630966187,
-0.6136050224304199,
-0.02117261104285717,
0.7911326289176941,
0.6159984469413757,
-0.6854391694068909,
-0.05194181948900223,
-0.16034427285194397,
0.19914531707763672,
0.12746486067771912,
-0.2893088757991791,
0.44267070293426514,
-0.48985251784324646,
-0.5191158056259155,
-0.054303128272295,
0.3935997188091278,
0.32614824175834656,
-0.5485054850578308,
-0.136031836271286,
-0.06325600296258926,
-0.12335679680109024,
0.5625615119934082,
-0.028190258890390396,
-1.1221688985824585,
-0.20983313024044037,
0.18445545434951782,
-0.41495373845100403,
0.21006064116954803,
0.6867020726203918,
-0.9284595847129822,
0.39739343523979187,
0.046739861369132996,
0.7176433205604553,
0.2831258773803711,
-0.27583685517311096,
0.4944971203804016,
-0.4015241861343384,
0.38733726739883423,
0.33996477723121643,
0.31907591223716736,
0.5138228535652161,
-0.5070093870162964,
0.43589508533477783,
0.3047395646572113,
-0.6305758357048035,
-0.9442348480224609,
0.057280853390693665,
-1.042988896369934,
-0.35832479596138,
1.2451306581497192,
0.31578633189201355,
-0.32247939705848694,
-0.23412783443927765,
-0.37221208214759827,
-0.040493350476026535,
-0.3162078857421875,
1.1427724361419678,
1.175225019454956,
-0.11496269702911377,
-0.2729390263557434,
-0.8092374205589294,
0.9078579545021057,
0.8078296780586243,
-0.5379183292388916,
-0.013182193972170353,
0.8413056135177612,
0.05959702655673027,
0.22725678980350494,
0.6077869534492493,
-0.1226339340209961,
0.3452158272266388,
0.297450989484787,
0.13396403193473816,
0.3533588647842407,
-0.13736985623836517,
-0.4532024562358856,
-0.017432019114494324,
0.18351739645004272,
-0.11081240326166153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03744v1 | INSIDE: LLMs' Internal States Retain the Power of Hallucination Detection | 2024-02-06T06:23:12 | 2024-02-06T06:23:12 | Chao Chen, Kai Liu, Ze Chen, Yi Gu, Yue Wu, Mingyuan Tao, Zhihang Fu, Jieping Ye | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge hallucination have raised widespread concerns for the security and
reliability of deployed LLMs. Previous efforts in detecting hallucinations have
been employed at logit-level uncertainty estimation or language-level
self-consistency evaluation, where the semantic information is inevitably lost
during the token-decoding procedure. Thus, we propose to explore the dense
semantic information retained within LLMs' \textbf{IN}ternal \textbf{S}tates
for halluc\textbf{I}nation \textbf{DE}tection (\textbf{INSIDE}). In particular,
a simple yet effective \textbf{EigenScore} metric is proposed to better
evaluate responses' self-consistency, which exploits the eigenvalues of
responses' covariance matrix to measure the semantic consistency/diversity in
the dense embedding space. Furthermore, from the perspective of self-consistent
hallucination detection, a test time feature clipping approach is explored to
truncate extreme activations in the internal states, which reduces
overconfident generations and potentially benefits the detection of
overconfident hallucinations. Extensive experiments and ablation studies are
performed on several popular LLMs and question-answering (QA) benchmarks,
showing the effectiveness of our proposal. | [
-0.5571634769439697,
-0.7301329374313354,
0.6783071160316467,
-0.025966642424464226,
-0.30708926916122437,
0.1553497612476349,
-0.3389483392238617,
-0.43402987718582153,
0.43306130170822144,
0.24814796447753906,
-0.39322423934936523,
-0.6041073203086853,
-0.5496821403503418,
0.2179931104183197,
-0.4888123571872711,
0.5558174848556519,
-0.14010581374168396,
0.022707294672727585,
-0.2540661692619324,
0.08455955982208252,
-0.2980739176273346,
-0.6331234574317932,
-0.284272700548172,
-0.21046699583530426,
0.22042174637317657,
0.37247854471206665,
0.4898086190223694,
0.28811123967170715,
0.3917909860610962,
0.26342955231666565,
-0.24424435198307037,
0.49126502871513367,
-0.5428211092948914,
0.42187973856925964,
-0.030274271965026855,
-0.401687890291214,
-0.13521023094654083,
-0.27628347277641296,
0.6997747421264648,
0.3378553092479706,
-0.20148900151252747,
-0.12514953315258026,
0.19325289130210876,
0.38031134009361267,
-0.6993103623390198,
0.09256570786237717,
-0.9431509971618652,
0.3034611642360687,
0.013269920833408833,
-0.41532284021377563,
-0.251924604177475,
-0.3773666024208069,
-0.013349393382668495,
-0.2020638883113861,
0.07429429143667221,
-0.02316005527973175,
0.8301358819007874,
0.46182551980018616,
-0.19929766654968262,
-0.4372686445713043,
-0.6595056056976318,
0.5307412147521973,
-0.5489895343780518,
0.7392998933792114,
0.6168175339698792,
0.13726748526096344,
-0.4902406632900238,
-0.33421215415000916,
-0.522445023059845,
-0.49055054783821106,
-0.027347544208168983,
0.12144385278224945,
-0.04407668113708496,
0.1957893818616867,
0.06369057297706604,
0.44586411118507385,
-0.3920835256576538,
0.22817504405975342,
-0.16919119656085968,
-0.7016764879226685,
0.3576594889163971,
0.2566368579864502,
0.15946701169013977,
-0.22720755636692047,
-0.43564721941947937,
-0.12903645634651184,
-0.6093389391899109,
-0.09876354783773422,
0.22144931554794312,
0.09977531433105469,
0.24588997662067413,
0.6916381120681763,
-0.07769056409597397,
0.10718587040901184,
0.11787152290344238,
-0.17933066189289093,
0.11240469664335251,
-0.2840672433376312,
-0.2729077935218811,
0.21727529168128967,
0.5575330853462219,
0.20381279289722443,
-0.061441607773303986,
-0.6860257983207703,
-0.24949724972248077,
0.2317681461572647,
0.4023134112358093,
-0.7937844395637512,
-0.11865594983100891,
0.39742234349250793,
-0.45576611161231995,
0.08487295359373093,
0.13687171041965485,
-0.7382017374038696,
-0.6574270129203796,
-0.2639971077442169,
0.6329846382141113,
-0.7171751260757446,
-0.35434266924858093,
0.2535492479801178,
-0.11803421378135681,
0.3976939618587494,
0.05340941995382309,
-0.7328376173973083,
0.32689008116722107,
0.7393081188201904,
0.9333818554878235,
-0.5358774065971375,
-0.17987599968910217,
-0.22434240579605103,
0.12459783256053925,
-0.1932973861694336,
0.7419931292533875,
-0.2741217315196991,
-0.39851894974708557,
-0.01603887602686882,
0.13483427464962006,
0.030374273657798767,
-0.9455914497375488,
0.31767311692237854,
-0.40125322341918945,
-0.2175479382276535,
-0.5293927788734436,
-1.0066715478897095,
-0.08448619395494461,
0.4759300947189331,
-0.402830570936203,
1.0447144508361816,
-0.019669925794005394,
-0.43368813395500183,
0.6565727591514587,
-0.15991109609603882,
0.07730116695165634,
-0.09177692979574203,
-0.4988381862640381,
-0.44635337591171265,
0.4006038308143616,
0.17622949182987213,
0.4586048722267151,
0.0717409998178482,
-0.07310862839221954,
-0.4622310996055603,
-0.6560487151145935,
0.4767175018787384,
-0.19456088542938232,
0.39465612173080444,
0.13560695946216583,
-0.6280046105384827,
0.1184355616569519,
-0.5748646259307861,
-0.011908015236258507,
0.06191788986325264,
-0.06377022713422775,
-0.2809807062149048,
0.018561530858278275,
-0.48449286818504333,
-0.02962127886712551,
0.2633926272392273,
-0.9230982065200806,
0.11115755885839462,
-0.25114956498146057,
0.02968161180615425,
0.8755382299423218,
0.30386829376220703,
0.20850533246994019,
-0.22093282639980316,
0.3221209943294525,
0.3194863796234131,
0.24046358466148376,
0.266259104013443,
-0.29869312047958374,
-0.8324966430664062,
-0.3081626296043396,
-0.19984033703804016,
0.4061560034751892,
-0.2748093008995056,
0.8860064744949341,
-0.09740302711725235,
-0.34017521142959595,
-0.5354684591293335,
0.0038362781051546335,
0.2259279191493988,
0.3826139569282532,
0.4816214144229889,
-0.11628913134336472,
-0.5248997211456299,
-0.8398898839950562,
-0.059545133262872696,
-0.09201333671808243,
-0.06507620960474014,
0.016047382727265358,
0.6003939509391785,
-0.384319007396698,
0.8160772323608398,
-0.2858172655105591,
-0.6119765043258667,
-0.0618727020919323,
-0.3455137312412262,
-0.051261384040117264,
0.2690984010696411,
0.11219008266925812,
-0.3158564865589142,
-0.07152678817510605,
-0.2387576848268509,
-1.1794849634170532,
0.15651138126850128,
-0.08013587445020676,
-0.16962096095085144,
0.314151793718338,
0.6226834058761597,
-0.4557453691959381,
0.5123379230499268,
0.20914602279663086,
-0.4936339557170868,
0.36932581663131714,
-0.2497188001871109,
0.192017063498497,
-0.6962032914161682,
-0.4275289475917816,
-0.3325401246547699,
0.03290315344929695,
-0.3322540521621704,
0.006252245977520943,
0.2999550700187683,
0.40106773376464844,
-0.202708438038826,
0.23757842183113098,
-0.5925635099411011,
-0.2813015878200531,
-0.2968323826789856,
0.31346118450164795,
-0.21726103127002716,
0.32352373003959656,
-0.06057187542319298,
0.8358192443847656,
0.37767332792282104,
-0.5113734602928162,
0.16581352055072784,
0.1565362811088562,
-0.46434295177459717,
0.6329577565193176,
-0.2577058672904968,
0.5131251811981201,
-0.32217052578926086,
0.11948226392269135,
-0.9880245327949524,
-0.030534924939274788,
0.21359091997146606,
-0.2902590036392212,
0.23512935638427734,
0.08194494992494583,
-0.7285849452018738,
-0.010123150423169136,
-0.4822000563144684,
0.1443452537059784,
0.5690821409225464,
-0.5902029871940613,
0.5972176194190979,
0.5616461038589478,
0.5728854537010193,
-0.4100233018398285,
-0.667877197265625,
0.17354215681552887,
-0.36181706190109253,
-0.6659935116767883,
0.33579719066619873,
-0.19679543375968933,
-0.39474084973335266,
0.026659175753593445,
-0.3548853099346161,
0.12112189084291458,
0.11076316982507706,
0.30283746123313904,
-0.008703621104359627,
-0.09288154542446136,
0.42142364382743835,
0.1322014331817627,
0.07536432892084122,
0.34805992245674133,
-0.40507715940475464,
0.7258754372596741,
-0.46809834241867065,
-0.5678917765617371,
-0.523208498954773,
0.2628481686115265,
0.34225431084632874,
0.21945025026798248,
0.9135531187057495,
0.47122618556022644,
-0.6957519054412842,
-0.30661824345588684,
-0.771405041217804,
-0.6783860325813293,
-0.47842898964881897,
0.36778849363327026,
-0.678234875202179,
-0.7759992480278015,
0.8334689736366272,
0.14068180322647095,
-0.2430850863456726,
0.39934787154197693,
0.5813782215118408,
-0.2762642502784729,
0.6393399834632874,
0.39140912890434265,
0.11517860740423203,
0.17425255477428436,
-0.4761185646057129,
0.170530304312706,
-1.0561710596084595,
-0.7554011940956116,
-0.19973431527614594,
-0.3455238342285156,
-0.30137452483177185,
-0.24492153525352478,
0.5341706871986389,
0.062405385076999664,
-0.10140349715948105,
0.1599850207567215,
-0.7118284106254578,
0.4388727843761444,
0.16610120236873627,
0.5663090348243713,
0.3210470378398895,
0.06758849322795868,
-0.15395861864089966,
-0.4955397844314575,
-0.38107985258102417,
-0.350048691034317,
0.9536152482032776,
0.49331134557724,
0.9637048840522766,
0.04310891777276993,
1.0055452585220337,
0.24524836242198944,
-0.04614139348268509,
-0.7689405083656311,
0.6810656785964966,
0.11107905209064484,
-0.3477573096752167,
-0.5802778601646423,
-0.3510584533214569,
-0.8390090465545654,
0.3321719467639923,
-0.11847830563783646,
-0.7770830392837524,
0.32609811425209045,
-0.13481447100639343,
-0.30305713415145874,
0.6907805800437927,
-0.2590477466583252,
0.39211246371269226,
-0.20019133388996124,
-0.10127173364162445,
-0.2868514358997345,
-0.30278250575065613,
0.28534117341041565,
0.00807217974215746,
-0.23997057974338531,
-0.3217122554779053,
-0.2001904398202896,
0.6259034276008606,
-0.22793421149253845,
0.8976110816001892,
-0.22058913111686707,
-0.3845761716365814,
0.22675049304962158,
0.23121073842048645,
0.46276572346687317,
0.2247176617383957,
-0.018567977473139763,
0.2864997386932373,
-0.15076471865177155,
-0.08126932382583618,
-0.6710878610610962,
0.7419276237487793,
-0.7288941740989685,
-0.5140842199325562,
-0.26329344511032104,
-0.5384558439254761,
-0.1937958002090454,
-0.26892906427383423,
0.5303773283958435,
0.23639769852161407,
-0.056518036872148514,
0.31562569737434387,
1.26041579246521,
-0.030526164919137955,
0.23197641968727112,
0.1242533028125763,
-0.2122250348329544,
-0.40866854786872864,
0.7553535103797913,
0.4035297930240631,
0.16717030107975006,
0.15794607996940613,
0.20698443055152893,
-0.5582825541496277,
-0.7172466516494751,
-0.19140225648880005,
0.32555273175239563,
-1.009097933769226,
-0.2756125032901764,
-0.8273598551750183,
-0.4246823787689209,
-0.3066171705722809,
-0.07352161407470703,
-0.36624544858932495,
-0.12661921977996826,
-0.24055923521518707,
-0.2963304817676544,
0.3192763030529022,
0.8170466423034668,
-0.1297360360622406,
-0.08310622721910477,
-0.4740228056907654,
0.3829832673072815,
0.21394923329353333,
0.3586229085922241,
-0.029270581901073456,
-0.6956756114959717,
-0.12936954200267792,
-0.12736138701438904,
0.02095400169491768,
-1.0951956510543823,
0.0819370225071907,
0.04208355024456978,
0.8252317905426025,
0.5431575775146484,
0.2125893533229828,
0.6754943132400513,
0.12029758840799332,
0.7535926103591919,
-0.0907645896077156,
-0.8862724304199219,
0.41236039996147156,
0.14111751317977905,
0.29367151856422424,
0.7126778364181519,
0.20225897431373596,
-0.4760668873786926,
-0.9332283139228821,
-0.37602347135543823,
-0.7398878335952759,
0.2243831902742386,
0.09277956932783127,
0.019241321831941605,
-0.33731842041015625,
0.5135685205459595,
0.30263790488243103,
0.047040414065122604,
-0.647711992263794,
-0.2536156177520752,
-0.17094968259334564,
-0.14145413041114807,
0.45314085483551025,
-0.5381475687026978,
-0.28110814094543457,
-0.3055262565612793,
0.43799516558647156,
0.029773585498332977,
0.5319737792015076,
0.5583771467208862,
-0.33937281370162964,
-0.04362642765045166,
0.037724871188402176,
0.5517385601997375,
0.5333621501922607,
-0.3940829038619995,
0.48072564601898193,
0.5346589684486389,
-0.5812419652938843,
0.36674630641937256,
-0.3514052927494049,
-0.16784825921058655,
-0.046694301068782806,
0.17174957692623138,
0.46767741441726685,
0.1525307297706604,
-0.4095136821269989,
0.4974430799484253,
-0.046294961124658585,
-0.17075616121292114,
-0.838271975517273,
0.06772013753652573,
-0.21212708950042725,
0.3967989981174469,
0.38143569231033325,
-0.34665030241012573,
0.17489881813526154,
-0.5749403238296509,
0.48914241790771484,
0.7180907130241394,
-0.5255869626998901,
-0.22171974182128906,
0.5437974333763123,
-0.1948137879371643,
-0.13067561388015747,
0.8178573846817017,
-0.49522995948791504,
-0.6277598142623901,
0.5965568423271179,
0.6584264636039734,
1.2193430662155151,
0.011033965274691582,
-0.04182262718677521,
0.3784868121147156,
0.6512162089347839,
0.08530231565237045,
0.4954414963722229,
-0.05084672197699547,
-0.847531259059906,
-0.06895376741886139,
-0.5193995833396912,
-0.13218000531196594,
0.23572756350040436,
-0.4973905682563782,
0.0026884216349571943,
-0.5635920763015747,
-0.2555617690086365,
-0.7487451434135437,
-0.11244655400514603,
-0.5322376489639282,
0.0012954426929354668,
0.4415898025035858,
0.8018403053283691,
-0.5232585072517395,
0.7486293315887451,
0.06456860154867172,
-0.33098703622817993,
-0.4372231960296631,
0.24925409257411957,
0.07234466820955276,
-0.8081547617912292,
0.53778475522995,
0.32039758563041687,
-0.539394199848175,
-0.27374008297920227,
-0.3670516014099121,
-1.0432230234146118,
1.1321033239364624,
0.4046609401702881,
-0.3884977102279663,
0.06126701086759567,
0.0657157450914383,
0.34120526909828186,
-0.26478075981140137,
0.15297895669937134,
0.8530210256576538,
0.5467498898506165,
-0.0328945517539978,
-0.6869509220123291,
0.409017413854599,
0.04146873950958252,
-0.24598261713981628,
0.3567511737346649,
-0.5390896201133728,
0.554600179195404,
-0.25790494680404663,
-0.5350887775421143,
-0.08913059532642365,
1.0400941371917725,
0.24904586374759674,
0.11788155883550644,
0.7138465642929077,
0.7031026482582092,
0.9582052230834961,
-0.12985055148601532,
0.6875283718109131,
-0.3787352442741394,
0.1581585705280304,
0.9401483535766602,
-0.0185051579028368,
0.6569238305091858,
0.5748710632324219,
-0.010865413583815098,
0.5010856986045837,
0.6013839840888977,
-0.17156216502189636,
0.5439121127128601,
0.4393744170665741,
-0.2274615317583084,
-0.21380169689655304,
-0.10147570073604584,
-0.48048362135887146,
0.39559027552604675,
0.5269063711166382,
-0.06876709312200546,
-0.040790509432554245,
0.12358859181404114,
0.1788765788078308,
-0.10444819182157516,
-0.08376407623291016,
0.8308835625648499,
0.10416818410158157,
-0.4136326313018799,
0.6498186588287354,
-0.4522416889667511,
0.8284628391265869,
-0.5346303582191467,
-0.032491616904735565,
-0.49493977427482605,
0.19801117479801178,
-0.2687840759754181,
-0.7960036396980286,
0.4171791970729828,
-0.44914183020591736,
0.21361392736434937,
0.05785496160387993,
0.6038707494735718,
-0.5157049298286438,
-0.13850507140159607,
0.8072100877761841,
0.29241594672203064,
0.4405003786087036,
-0.26422643661499023,
-0.22906461358070374,
0.24676737189292908,
-0.24442501366138458,
-0.1118561252951622,
0.2827405631542206,
0.40807250142097473,
0.2322273999452591,
0.6026403307914734,
0.2443249374628067,
0.2162635773420334,
0.46704211831092834,
0.14848056435585022,
0.7719346880912781,
-0.7024914026260376,
-0.2368352711200714,
-0.9030334949493408,
0.2076183408498764,
-0.2496386617422104,
-0.5115824937820435,
0.9832699298858643,
0.5867018699645996,
0.8744245767593384,
0.14724206924438477,
0.44626206159591675,
0.16245318949222565,
0.06687164306640625,
-0.7188475728034973,
0.6800348162651062,
-0.48589006066322327,
0.20985186100006104,
-0.13215777277946472,
-1.0629119873046875,
-0.06938350200653076,
0.4637914299964905,
0.14809641242027283,
-0.19631239771842957,
0.9213736057281494,
0.8707114458084106,
0.14141316711902618,
-0.040550701320171356,
0.634024441242218,
0.3574444353580475,
0.2502712607383728,
0.5001593232154846,
1.1425085067749023,
-0.17493805289268494,
0.5417273640632629,
-0.48382607102394104,
-0.19846700131893158,
-0.17722143232822418,
-0.5335627794265747,
-1.003434419631958,
-0.7129528522491455,
-0.0850791409611702,
-0.5639190077781677,
-0.09593234956264496,
0.9679020643234253,
0.46833905577659607,
-0.75765061378479,
-0.30480849742889404,
0.14052912592887878,
-0.039242953062057495,
-0.19712145626544952,
-0.22067509591579437,
0.4666827917098999,
-0.5840147733688354,
-0.3528723418712616,
0.7582433819770813,
0.5439839959144592,
0.27163657546043396,
-0.7764320373535156,
-0.03706676885485649,
0.2895580232143402,
0.13968315720558167,
0.45345979928970337,
-0.11392229795455933,
-1.0425244569778442,
-0.47739171981811523,
0.3609408438205719,
-0.22585564851760864,
0.07767549157142639,
0.7231917977333069,
-0.7587780952453613,
0.5196107625961304,
0.3367116451263428,
0.7189089059829712,
0.4972258508205414,
-0.3397313952445984,
0.24720148742198944,
-0.394347608089447,
0.12652793526649475,
0.3831522762775421,
0.461147665977478,
0.21878458559513092,
-0.7760276794433594,
0.5291715860366821,
0.1139855682849884,
-0.6153720617294312,
-0.7754086852073669,
0.20601986348628998,
-0.8153733015060425,
-0.35947197675704956,
1.076897382736206,
0.1292085200548172,
-0.1329146772623062,
-0.4494931101799011,
0.005149614531546831,
0.25882261991500854,
-0.39412975311279297,
1.364531397819519,
0.6626704335212708,
-0.3561936318874359,
-0.06286776065826416,
-0.2865798771381378,
0.7036674618721008,
0.4143809676170349,
-0.8515251278877258,
-0.04899244010448456,
0.33981168270111084,
0.10546282678842545,
0.23293428122997284,
0.5419577360153198,
-0.18185926973819733,
0.013103206641972065,
0.03587089851498604,
-0.07664655894041061,
0.004787989426404238,
-0.5286965370178223,
-0.44411519169807434,
0.35707706212997437,
-0.07262517511844635,
-0.341895192861557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03732v1 | Deep Outdated Fact Detection in Knowledge Graphs | 2024-02-06T05:58:15 | 2024-02-06T05:58:15 | Huiling Tu, Shuo Yu, Vidya Saikrishna, Feng Xia, Karin Verspoor | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG, 68T09, 68T30, 68P20, I.2.6; I.2.4; H.3.7; H.3.3 | Knowledge graphs (KGs) have garnered significant attention for their vast
potential across diverse domains. However, the issue of outdated facts poses a
challenge to KGs, affecting their overall quality as real-world information
evolves. Existing solutions for outdated fact detection often rely on manual
recognition. In response, this paper presents DEAN (Deep outdatEd fAct
detectioN), a novel deep learning-based framework designed to identify outdated
facts within KGs. DEAN distinguishes itself by capturing implicit structural
information among facts through comprehensive modeling of both entities and
relations. To effectively uncover latent out-of-date information, DEAN employs
a contrastive approach based on a pre-defined Relations-to-Nodes (R2N) graph,
weighted by the number of entities. Experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness and superiority of DEAN over state-of-the-art baseline methods. | [
-0.4760034680366516,
-0.653318464756012,
0.9157714247703552,
-0.2839644253253937,
-0.3861101567745209,
0.10949584096670151,
0.098233662545681,
-0.4535907804965973,
-0.040018290281295776,
0.2889493703842163,
-0.4072721302509308,
-0.835141122341156,
-0.40856921672821045,
-0.16152313351631165,
0.07195722311735153,
1.0042953491210938,
-0.16463123261928558,
-0.1586066633462906,
-0.7238460183143616,
-0.5377830862998962,
-0.47062948346138,
0.12026722729206085,
-0.7630192041397095,
-0.6049079298973083,
0.542990505695343,
0.4980846047401428,
0.8209713697433472,
0.6429336071014404,
0.23848317563533783,
0.23872864246368408,
-0.25196656584739685,
0.6655739545822144,
-0.6045982837677002,
0.31631553173065186,
-0.45507264137268066,
0.04690665751695633,
-0.7324708104133606,
-0.0824955478310585,
0.5647010803222656,
0.960660457611084,
0.4474053680896759,
0.16849064826965332,
0.10900113731622696,
0.9669521450996399,
-0.9405525922775269,
0.6751625537872314,
-0.6420162916183472,
0.03073490783572197,
-0.1932232528924942,
-0.1391870677471161,
-0.23503148555755615,
-0.557934582233429,
0.0755559504032135,
-0.49399489164352417,
0.2091546654701233,
-0.19824427366256714,
0.7120957970619202,
0.4481314718723297,
-0.9517716765403748,
-0.4568279981613159,
-0.4725325405597687,
0.31215786933898926,
-0.7102822065353394,
0.8435489535331726,
0.34180575609207153,
0.3953857421875,
-0.555584192276001,
-1.1174861192703247,
-0.6533435583114624,
-0.21382884681224823,
-0.4243707060813904,
-0.12829580903053284,
-0.2730448544025421,
-0.1918758898973465,
0.09172320365905762,
0.35856351256370544,
-0.4947721064090729,
0.06275245547294617,
-0.4933951795101166,
-0.1620899736881256,
0.499089777469635,
0.09443923830986023,
0.04985445365309715,
-0.20352080464363098,
-0.43286895751953125,
0.0730459913611412,
-0.8082766532897949,
-0.11647742241621017,
0.30954262614250183,
0.06610099971294403,
-0.1652284562587738,
0.3583087921142578,
-0.4349876046180725,
0.4954739809036255,
0.2727159857749939,
-0.16494710743427277,
0.6407149434089661,
-0.1607542484998703,
-0.2055162936449051,
0.2560487985610962,
0.5983660221099854,
0.5089958310127258,
0.03126111626625061,
-0.46118107438087463,
-0.010863911360502243,
-0.32740283012390137,
0.05969807133078575,
-0.8479094505310059,
-0.8324326872825623,
0.08962288498878479,
-0.40505364537239075,
-0.12882299721240997,
-0.29130467772483826,
-0.9060754776000977,
-1.1398032903671265,
-0.3391079604625702,
0.12255353480577469,
-0.21973556280136108,
-0.511950671672821,
-0.33779457211494446,
-0.3309532701969147,
-0.03653278574347496,
0.542346179485321,
-0.16881057620048523,
-0.11174235492944717,
0.5105623602867126,
0.7105388045310974,
0.019771195948123932,
0.04671119153499603,
-0.37491512298583984,
0.09455309063196182,
-0.4645112156867981,
0.7940523028373718,
-0.4882185459136963,
-0.0006770197069272399,
-0.3725985288619995,
0.04538479819893837,
0.3249126076698303,
-0.8061978816986084,
0.7034604549407959,
-0.9686735272407532,
-0.15016692876815796,
-0.36619800329208374,
-0.7253516316413879,
-0.2809417247772217,
0.3504040539264679,
-0.9378873109817505,
0.9336555004119873,
0.3723174035549164,
-1.0774147510528564,
0.6882062554359436,
-0.15426130592823029,
-0.30518844723701477,
0.11383959650993347,
-0.17810139060020447,
-0.8276660442352295,
-0.09558402001857758,
0.17580409348011017,
0.5496050715446472,
-0.11328005790710449,
0.6313544511795044,
-1.0155928134918213,
-0.20735937356948853,
0.10154160857200623,
-0.6591042876243591,
0.7126873731613159,
0.5051276683807373,
-0.05865273252129555,
-0.21252501010894775,
-1.0457044839859009,
-0.08536560833454132,
0.0212947316467762,
-0.36856400966644287,
-0.30374225974082947,
0.058811869472265244,
-0.9635766744613647,
0.20013315975666046,
0.3579809367656708,
-0.6694729924201965,
0.18731972575187683,
0.08668726682662964,
0.055235542356967926,
0.4345880448818207,
0.39449965953826904,
0.442640483379364,
-0.23065708577632904,
-0.060548894107341766,
0.3223079741001129,
-0.020045477896928787,
0.019743995741009712,
-0.390557199716568,
-0.6640617251396179,
-0.12097974121570587,
0.14256812632083893,
0.20550855994224548,
-0.8331705927848816,
0.3647404909133911,
-0.6892350912094116,
-0.567153811454773,
-0.030479351058602333,
0.19769732654094696,
-0.05245876684784889,
0.9323212504386902,
0.6539318561553955,
-0.1706816703081131,
-0.6365288496017456,
-0.718429446220398,
-0.35763558745384216,
-0.32733067870140076,
0.26462095975875854,
0.5215131640434265,
0.6134908199310303,
-0.4144781231880188,
1.24881112575531,
-0.7642427086830139,
-0.22243191301822662,
0.0947127416729927,
0.33400383591651917,
0.2101307362318039,
0.4588707983493805,
0.4655676782131195,
-0.9638273119926453,
-0.3051702678203583,
0.27797412872314453,
-1.2662831544876099,
0.06151585653424263,
0.10039080679416656,
0.3706490695476532,
-0.0002984508464578539,
0.8828273415565491,
-0.6481228470802307,
0.5949490666389465,
0.1282789260149002,
-0.17716342210769653,
0.4000948667526245,
0.03948814794421196,
0.04186394810676575,
-0.5979205965995789,
0.16722388565540314,
-0.11243660748004913,
-0.35607990622520447,
-0.2917301654815674,
-0.1485666036605835,
0.12818428874015808,
-0.2567363977432251,
-0.3979983329772949,
0.9292604923248291,
-0.37905433773994446,
-0.01673952303826809,
-0.22368410229682922,
0.11242605000734329,
0.16571791470050812,
0.43314114212989807,
-0.16403627395629883,
0.5042315125465393,
-0.020536134019494057,
-0.7865908145904541,
0.6822180151939392,
-0.01051494013518095,
-0.41727909445762634,
0.6528847813606262,
-0.204048290848732,
0.20605453848838806,
-0.5458258986473083,
0.49106350541114807,
-1.0394688844680786,
-0.18880654871463776,
0.7489548325538635,
-0.6362480521202087,
0.5930730104446411,
-0.7472739815711975,
0.00552408630028367,
-0.5600392818450928,
-0.23526616394519806,
0.4795498847961426,
0.17282678186893463,
-0.5865258574485779,
0.8387030959129333,
0.17414766550064087,
-0.1550566852092743,
-0.8016365766525269,
-0.1661594957113266,
-0.0037265908904373646,
0.08279507607221603,
-0.5316751599311829,
0.12762513756752014,
0.3099158704280853,
-0.44568243622779846,
0.7553673982620239,
-0.7475638389587402,
-0.511821985244751,
0.1692030131816864,
0.23326224088668823,
-0.2121770679950714,
-0.3433716595172882,
0.38176900148391724,
0.08170109987258911,
-0.07387321442365646,
0.14058518409729004,
-0.6693805456161499,
0.28323549032211304,
0.0538327619433403,
-0.16016414761543274,
-0.4777213931083679,
-0.2175723761320114,
0.8252173662185669,
0.042294181883335114,
0.6752756834030151,
0.8556481599807739,
-0.4918857216835022,
-0.1868106573820114,
-0.5322532057762146,
-0.01030876487493515,
-0.5208795070648193,
0.5779187083244324,
-0.22167062759399414,
-0.41340547800064087,
0.29773440957069397,
-0.6964632272720337,
-0.26347050070762634,
0.629116415977478,
0.052585724741220474,
-0.19278854131698608,
0.5762378573417664,
0.15144215524196625,
-0.016915887594223022,
0.050709858536720276,
-0.4556640088558197,
0.314105749130249,
-0.7464665770530701,
-0.654687225818634,
-0.3552306890487671,
-0.27671167254447937,
-0.36339491605758667,
-0.2675936818122864,
0.30683770775794983,
0.603061318397522,
-0.5966813564300537,
0.1301838904619217,
-0.0775393396615982,
0.353231817483902,
0.17296144366264343,
0.38566863536834717,
0.3324713706970215,
-0.21750089526176453,
-0.44585204124450684,
0.10890848189592361,
-0.6218641400337219,
-0.3633882403373718,
1.136997103691101,
0.42848214507102966,
0.6837168335914612,
0.17508405447006226,
0.5252020955085754,
0.8277386426925659,
0.5804046988487244,
-0.6394059658050537,
0.4324708580970764,
-0.09017112851142883,
-0.5063828825950623,
-0.22003276646137238,
-0.9160770773887634,
-0.6800116300582886,
-0.17513751983642578,
-0.08388086408376694,
-0.4487125873565674,
0.5112406015396118,
0.2897917628288269,
-0.178444042801857,
0.698427677154541,
-0.6213163137435913,
0.9251444935798645,
-0.042283546179533005,
-0.522289514541626,
0.01954987645149231,
-0.35075297951698303,
0.3523320257663727,
0.02213183417916298,
0.07410389930009842,
-0.2704532742500305,
0.36057713627815247,
0.5456717014312744,
-0.3246288001537323,
0.8935648798942566,
-0.4686340093612671,
-0.2026589810848236,
0.38137298822402954,
0.2107294648885727,
1.0194029808044434,
0.38978374004364014,
0.030333757400512695,
-0.12556394934654236,
-0.34602031111717224,
-0.36124080419540405,
-1.044062852859497,
0.797329843044281,
-0.7953208088874817,
-0.48445138335227966,
-0.338479608297348,
-0.3832530379295349,
-0.26825442910194397,
0.284041166305542,
-0.05088801681995392,
0.6378800272941589,
-0.12431279569864273,
0.30925264954566956,
0.5131742358207703,
-0.15541234612464905,
0.0973416268825531,
0.5943728685379028,
0.06610359251499176,
-0.6360064744949341,
1.116140604019165,
0.2839338779449463,
-0.24056996405124664,
0.24891886115074158,
0.02033936232328415,
-0.6034072637557983,
-0.6974571943283081,
-0.5507213473320007,
0.1465817093849182,
-1.0721626281738281,
-0.47415271401405334,
-1.0126659870147705,
-0.19910471141338348,
-0.5144802331924438,
0.08860216289758682,
-0.3893018662929535,
-0.3911832273006439,
-0.4569171667098999,
-0.16307924687862396,
0.08250003308057785,
1.0037175416946411,
-0.08968668431043625,
-0.13762904703617096,
-0.613959789276123,
0.2711562216281891,
0.6291082501411438,
0.368907630443573,
0.29599690437316895,
-0.20740000903606415,
-0.04842574521899223,
0.24590006470680237,
-0.5732976794242859,
-0.669262170791626,
-0.07875950634479523,
0.050000473856925964,
0.6329823136329651,
0.7164726853370667,
0.5886827707290649,
0.4856128990650177,
-0.11472716182470322,
0.5093674659729004,
0.0891726166009903,
-0.48415112495422363,
0.125900998711586,
-0.12691988050937653,
-0.06480169296264648,
0.5533178448677063,
0.7939245700836182,
-0.47005200386047363,
0.011771534569561481,
-0.47257891297340393,
-0.8653453588485718,
0.2624121308326721,
-0.08878720551729202,
0.01408410631120205,
-0.01996731571853161,
0.7113028764724731,
0.049780651926994324,
0.3349868655204773,
-0.6122564077377319,
-0.3768772482872009,
-0.28831586241722107,
-0.4060736298561096,
0.3496338129043579,
-0.38502493500709534,
0.03017663210630417,
-0.3628641963005066,
0.7772570848464966,
-0.193489670753479,
0.15274308621883392,
0.11244011670351028,
-0.2394644021987915,
0.10245949774980545,
0.3113594353199005,
0.4133143126964569,
1.024596095085144,
-0.5640503764152527,
0.6213943958282471,
0.5799254179000854,
-0.4955054223537445,
0.3059704601764679,
0.31141746044158936,
-0.22097353637218475,
-0.02676340751349926,
0.6568095684051514,
0.6586821675300598,
0.11978575587272644,
-0.04348956421017647,
0.708572506904602,
0.28873732686042786,
0.16503185033798218,
-0.3990260064601898,
0.019911402836441994,
-0.002936361124739051,
0.5378702282905579,
0.5258399248123169,
0.47151651978492737,
0.14265181124210358,
-0.5444881319999695,
0.6593753695487976,
0.2665267288684845,
-1.0484764575958252,
-0.2209928035736084,
0.49999698996543884,
0.3514823019504547,
0.2645513117313385,
0.642736554145813,
-0.9688934087753296,
-0.5928510427474976,
0.6054543256759644,
0.31756511330604553,
0.4696040153503418,
0.20114535093307495,
0.3145895004272461,
0.3271229863166809,
-0.11364579200744629,
0.25047236680984497,
0.0020719978492707014,
-0.1316717267036438,
-0.7518365979194641,
-0.297940194606781,
-0.3162774443626404,
-0.05821378156542778,
0.6503664255142212,
-0.439517617225647,
0.3109656870365143,
-0.40602871775627136,
-0.28571128845214844,
0.0520891435444355,
0.36662763357162476,
-0.7126075029373169,
0.512490451335907,
-0.026113269850611687,
0.8028507232666016,
-0.6554621458053589,
0.6237801313400269,
0.4907056391239166,
-0.20095616579055786,
-0.3921067714691162,
-0.008517230860888958,
0.3070082366466522,
-0.4832245111465454,
1.1952518224716187,
-0.039561446756124496,
-0.26766979694366455,
0.02289576828479767,
-0.42205095291137695,
-0.6800887584686279,
1.404239535331726,
0.5150874853134155,
-0.3691263496875763,
0.012767479754984379,
-0.29525166749954224,
0.18696793913841248,
-0.04763920232653618,
0.16751070320606232,
0.32669126987457275,
0.6615116000175476,
0.36883416771888733,
-0.22689035534858704,
0.09759827703237534,
-0.25595545768737793,
-0.6901245713233948,
0.4074563980102539,
-0.47429224848747253,
1.0477720499038696,
-0.3446960151195526,
-0.4835653007030487,
-0.0660262405872345,
1.0422258377075195,
-0.038625530898571014,
1.1024819612503052,
0.47439098358154297,
0.962974488735199,
1.2566277980804443,
0.13199998438358307,
0.6694381237030029,
-0.12708620727062225,
0.48061829805374146,
1.5457547903060913,
-0.44877123832702637,
0.26425042748451233,
-0.1650298535823822,
-0.08626669645309448,
0.7448186874389648,
0.3584670424461365,
-0.22227507829666138,
0.6059659719467163,
0.07459073513746262,
-0.40132132172584534,
-0.33982402086257935,
-0.386073499917984,
-0.6952897310256958,
0.18196626007556915,
0.128033846616745,
-0.5578336715698242,
-0.5992980599403381,
-0.4002538025379181,
0.8069187998771667,
-0.12214653193950653,
-0.4881432354450226,
0.5915839076042175,
0.07777578383684158,
-0.5170479416847229,
0.6052401065826416,
-0.16684560477733612,
0.05444635823369026,
-0.1864185333251953,
-0.3796025812625885,
-0.35061022639274597,
0.5007043480873108,
-0.2649972140789032,
-0.8848388195037842,
0.05433664470911026,
-0.3711111843585968,
-0.25395986437797546,
0.2792418599128723,
1.147761344909668,
-0.2871854901313782,
-0.2254820168018341,
0.38759082555770874,
0.6112340688705444,
-0.10878267884254456,
-0.1126628965139389,
-0.2921963334083557,
-0.21954774856567383,
-0.23246408998966217,
0.2879927456378937,
0.016399791464209557,
0.7564626336097717,
-0.04941757023334503,
0.917521595954895,
0.4992934763431549,
-0.18030931055545807,
-0.3322487771511078,
-0.2605304718017578,
1.2111830711364746,
-0.27386537194252014,
-0.2869212031364441,
-0.7722994089126587,
0.19125834107398987,
-0.5619548559188843,
-0.47531187534332275,
0.809958815574646,
0.6659862399101257,
0.9137976765632629,
0.2801465094089508,
0.7174866199493408,
0.21278876066207886,
0.21899424493312836,
-0.6387308239936829,
0.8090996146202087,
-0.5964080691337585,
0.38150960206985474,
-0.21112379431724548,
-0.7078126072883606,
-0.1049787625670433,
0.17052587866783142,
-0.45334264636039734,
0.20332355797290802,
0.6524477005004883,
0.6738271713256836,
-0.3567170202732086,
0.25956034660339355,
-0.028820637613534927,
0.4634243845939636,
0.2728038728237152,
0.366103857755661,
0.9594147205352783,
-0.2584677040576935,
0.6263527274131775,
-0.2177136093378067,
0.19396010041236877,
-0.19343093037605286,
-0.9828728437423706,
-1.0270664691925049,
-0.5445114374160767,
-0.6427904963493347,
-0.6694258451461792,
0.26299524307250977,
0.8267247676849365,
0.7825321555137634,
-0.9572373032569885,
0.5367303490638733,
-0.0008828849531710148,
0.7246508002281189,
-0.16573262214660645,
-0.20269282162189484,
0.7853567004203796,
-0.2506003975868225,
0.012499302625656128,
0.5162074565887451,
0.05468517541885376,
0.24808229506015778,
0.05852556601166725,
-0.16805662214756012,
-0.08921011537313461,
-0.20786970853805542,
0.33107516169548035,
0.37336429953575134,
-0.179857537150383,
-0.5635742545127869,
-0.22013477981090546,
0.0747312605381012,
0.02529171109199524,
1.0085004568099976,
-1.1531637907028198,
0.3532218635082245,
0.6208246946334839,
0.6579682230949402,
0.4722527861595154,
0.06956250965595245,
0.27946993708610535,
-0.9135146141052246,
-0.1828470081090927,
0.23166941106319427,
0.2307932823896408,
0.5563924908638,
-0.37022876739501953,
0.5208526253700256,
0.8482008576393127,
-0.42099934816360474,
-0.6953100562095642,
0.3634148836135864,
-0.5153014063835144,
-0.5990678668022156,
0.8666951656341553,
-0.445217102766037,
-0.21861723065376282,
-0.9556544423103333,
0.15729108452796936,
0.4045790731906891,
-0.4052019417285919,
0.636613130569458,
0.38604646921157837,
0.11993774771690369,
-0.04530630260705948,
-0.2790531814098358,
0.7586634159088135,
-0.35309016704559326,
-0.4857926666736603,
0.06068975105881691,
0.4219599664211273,
0.38869625329971313,
0.14062170684337616,
0.572837769985199,
0.055358272045850754,
0.22847473621368408,
0.0918293446302414,
-0.4403371512889862,
-0.6773557662963867,
-0.7293156981468201,
0.2534002959728241,
0.4824201464653015,
-0.001081084948964417,
0.05241025611758232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03728v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03728v1 | Consistent Joint Decision-Making with Heterogeneous Learning Models | 2024-02-06T05:50:04 | 2024-02-06T05:50:04 | Hossein Rajaby Faghihi, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO | This paper introduces a novel decision-making framework that promotes
consistency among decisions made by diverse models while utilizing external
knowledge. Leveraging the Integer Linear Programming (ILP) framework, we map
predictions from various models into globally normalized and comparable values
by incorporating information about decisions' prior probability, confidence
(uncertainty), and the models' expected accuracy. Our empirical study
demonstrates the superiority of our approach over conventional baselines on
multiple datasets. | [
-0.30791500210762024,
-0.15854193270206451,
0.673895537853241,
0.29106879234313965,
0.5602899193763733,
-0.11284428089857101,
-0.29580655694007874,
-0.7569851875305176,
-0.1623697727918625,
0.3357097804546356,
-0.36626264452934265,
-0.5805259943008423,
-0.41178572177886963,
-0.1307557225227356,
0.24209187924861908,
0.7042629718780518,
0.0297550018876791,
0.22176991403102875,
-0.48762527108192444,
-0.36265039443969727,
-0.34373950958251953,
-0.17652644217014313,
-0.4473859965801239,
-0.6900665163993835,
0.3296288847923279,
0.4373290538787842,
1.0145998001098633,
0.43983301520347595,
0.6046075820922852,
0.13900139927864075,
0.192742720246315,
0.21289052069187164,
-0.3828561007976532,
0.018050190061330795,
-0.6484896540641785,
-0.6953561902046204,
-0.17100027203559875,
0.10797026753425598,
0.8400002717971802,
1.1819099187850952,
-0.18012063205242157,
0.16599906980991364,
0.3144751489162445,
0.545434296131134,
-1.0769950151443481,
0.07334836572408676,
-0.7305994033813477,
0.5739235877990723,
0.4278884828090668,
0.11899666488170624,
-0.5588093996047974,
-0.6964046359062195,
0.221077099442482,
-0.6737409234046936,
-0.03249766305088997,
0.11022734642028809,
0.69886714220047,
0.32483458518981934,
-0.3940628170967102,
-0.14098942279815674,
-1.0196506977081299,
0.8127930760383606,
-0.6747949123382568,
0.4220585525035858,
0.6588155031204224,
0.32383930683135986,
-0.035527780652046204,
-0.8082266449928284,
-0.3050200939178467,
-0.07447519153356552,
0.1159772053360939,
0.2051374912261963,
0.1860934942960739,
0.13244406878948212,
0.3917154371738434,
0.2502594590187073,
-0.048395704478025436,
0.34406259655952454,
-0.327613890171051,
-0.049712181091308594,
0.70972740650177,
0.07776717841625214,
0.07956176996231079,
0.20148307085037231,
-0.6714431047439575,
0.1728523075580597,
-0.7210482358932495,
0.42183542251586914,
0.4587363004684448,
0.6721981763839722,
-0.3080310523509979,
0.683253288269043,
-0.5621646642684937,
0.9186405539512634,
0.14334389567375183,
-0.602547287940979,
0.252312570810318,
-0.15632209181785583,
-0.4219561815261841,
-0.08829662203788757,
0.2670062482357025,
0.7628936171531677,
0.10608712583780289,
-0.23032812774181366,
-0.35408860445022583,
0.1179138794541359,
-0.1781691461801529,
-0.23413045704364777,
-0.1418592780828476,
0.18006716668605804,
-0.7615087628364563,
-0.21006883680820465,
0.27614036202430725,
-0.5862433910369873,
-0.08492573350667953,
-1.026674509048462,
0.5593183040618896,
-0.4203048348426819,
-0.2409687340259552,
0.06387684494256973,
0.03589402511715889,
-0.16876551508903503,
0.5981388092041016,
-0.9759094715118408,
0.4045060873031616,
0.55824214220047,
0.751400351524353,
-0.23503127694129944,
-0.19133462011814117,
-0.4903263449668884,
0.3937437832355499,
-0.5916832089424133,
0.604913592338562,
-0.7550989985466003,
-0.46405088901519775,
0.20347779989242554,
-0.45338618755340576,
-0.07782024145126343,
-0.6076481938362122,
0.2594296336174011,
0.036359287798404694,
0.2594154477119446,
-0.6050828099250793,
-0.7998812794685364,
-0.19591116905212402,
0.5716224312782288,
-0.4729117155075073,
0.8338460326194763,
0.07845905423164368,
-0.7294762134552002,
0.9838858246803284,
-0.40748775005340576,
0.26344358921051025,
-0.12852878868579865,
-0.5817264914512634,
-0.3568887710571289,
0.11642147600650787,
-0.17950691282749176,
0.4485241770744324,
-0.22512902319431305,
0.293273389339447,
-0.9586672186851501,
-0.13831575214862823,
-0.12318146973848343,
-0.256277471780777,
0.870539128780365,
0.31162434816360474,
0.005024854559451342,
0.12974895536899567,
-0.6800653338432312,
0.3297886252403259,
-0.4903044104576111,
-0.5564650297164917,
-0.3020175099372864,
0.09888797253370285,
-0.1572885364294052,
0.702648401260376,
0.1173584833741188,
-0.31781479716300964,
0.675780713558197,
0.16665437817573547,
-0.2986375093460083,
1.0023449659347534,
-0.10733158141374588,
0.5410053133964539,
-0.9373254179954529,
0.29641762375831604,
-0.1110827773809433,
0.12165553122758865,
0.18226245045661926,
-0.6264612078666687,
-0.6064466834068298,
0.040413983166217804,
0.3540383577346802,
0.4928767681121826,
-0.4864153563976288,
0.23167374730110168,
-0.04958633705973625,
-0.17489935457706451,
-0.11415335536003113,
-0.05736139044165611,
0.07531819492578506,
0.6447568535804749,
0.36486342549324036,
0.0449681356549263,
-0.6564996838569641,
-0.6738004088401794,
-0.11022549867630005,
-0.2790432870388031,
0.08110648393630981,
0.24885664880275726,
0.2827075719833374,
-0.36800840497016907,
0.806125283241272,
-0.25258132815361023,
-0.28494903445243835,
0.05384405702352524,
0.40287917852401733,
0.2272607982158661,
0.8653174042701721,
0.6949310898780823,
-0.8504129648208618,
-0.9255117177963257,
0.19582101702690125,
-0.9193465113639832,
0.26774242520332336,
-0.26146364212036133,
-0.1866121143102646,
-0.018346039578318596,
0.5663928389549255,
-0.15008625388145447,
0.7232325077056885,
0.4178488552570343,
-0.27247872948646545,
0.5500490069389343,
-0.39706951379776,
0.16759289801120758,
-1.1022319793701172,
-0.16236631572246552,
0.1741526871919632,
-0.048752255737781525,
-0.36452722549438477,
-0.17163658142089844,
-0.17881746590137482,
0.12755587697029114,
-0.04871103912591934,
0.31856775283813477,
-0.27436330914497375,
-0.3875737488269806,
0.25478824973106384,
-0.6121461391448975,
-0.1509745568037033,
0.36642777919769287,
0.24291689693927765,
0.4705677926540375,
0.63960200548172,
-0.4485088586807251,
0.16989143192768097,
0.16301369667053223,
-0.4213871657848358,
0.9088069796562195,
-0.43874865770339966,
-0.23917745053768158,
-0.17294777929782867,
0.07966966181993484,
-0.5556804537773132,
-0.3005926012992859,
0.07763081789016724,
-0.20081481337547302,
0.02084679715335369,
-0.23346365988254547,
-0.17805923521518707,
0.07440315186977386,
-0.1365632712841034,
-0.01886558346450329,
0.36454376578330994,
-0.6391972899436951,
1.016910433769226,
0.22461740672588348,
-0.08408385515213013,
-0.7882689833641052,
-0.4732753038406372,
-0.37436598539352417,
-0.06997013837099075,
-0.5454419851303101,
0.5778275728225708,
-0.2747687101364136,
-0.6827713251113892,
0.019293898716568947,
-0.22750914096832275,
-0.3252183198928833,
-0.11116146296262741,
0.3467980623245239,
0.5063943862915039,
-0.4108242392539978,
0.23664312064647675,
-0.21346870064735413,
0.03698432072997093,
-0.023691756650805473,
-0.49146732687950134,
0.2744220197200775,
-0.23291178047657013,
-0.6672667860984802,
-0.2976381480693817,
0.4786292612552643,
0.3809395134449005,
-0.01015172153711319,
0.6854528784751892,
0.5240849852561951,
-0.7868781089782715,
-0.3445543050765991,
-0.38451167941093445,
0.030232010409235954,
-0.3199431002140045,
-0.17153993248939514,
-0.7135040163993835,
-0.39909282326698303,
0.7024033665657043,
-0.20723168551921844,
0.26865771412849426,
0.4385513365268707,
0.4503013491630554,
-0.12408541142940521,
1.2847267389297485,
1.1480631828308105,
0.036585476249456406,
0.25012704730033875,
-0.15789926052093506,
-0.005046828184276819,
-0.3822392523288727,
-0.6174970269203186,
-0.5516849160194397,
-0.34196382761001587,
-0.6641567349433899,
-0.25811561942100525,
0.4386684000492096,
0.3511752486228943,
-0.39799410104751587,
-0.4112630784511566,
-0.3440913259983063,
0.5057049989700317,
0.7641971111297607,
0.015627825632691383,
0.41090577840805054,
-0.055844713002443314,
-0.6384062767028809,
-0.10628658533096313,
-0.8257390260696411,
-0.3764384090900421,
1.437922477722168,
0.19192931056022644,
1.0017204284667969,
0.12209144979715347,
0.8570596575737,
0.30036452412605286,
0.41828104853630066,
-0.2595400810241699,
-0.012305581010878086,
-0.04345235601067543,
-0.6589063405990601,
-0.09866557270288467,
-0.480045348405838,
-0.6232086420059204,
0.26222938299179077,
-1.0677909851074219,
-1.2303669452667236,
0.6281918883323669,
0.2895132899284363,
-0.720118522644043,
0.7951491475105286,
-0.5664240717887878,
0.5066601037979126,
-0.075620636343956,
-0.5887932181358337,
-0.09339415282011032,
-0.6791722774505615,
0.5854226350784302,
0.21998079121112823,
0.11043758690357208,
-0.47857466340065,
0.040254369378089905,
0.4203683137893677,
0.03902316838502884,
0.5133677124977112,
-0.2196003943681717,
0.21158146858215332,
0.17330282926559448,
-0.08923552930355072,
0.2414647787809372,
0.38293319940567017,
-0.5147503018379211,
0.1309756636619568,
0.06355811655521393,
-0.2859303057193756,
-0.43873468041419983,
0.6310607194900513,
-0.9932495355606079,
-0.17912007868289948,
-0.5996041297912598,
-0.9195648431777954,
-0.5274057984352112,
0.11144479364156723,
0.42770206928253174,
0.3691670298576355,
-0.032620690762996674,
0.46843287348747253,
0.8206873536109924,
-0.004046163521707058,
0.21820901334285736,
0.2773086428642273,
-0.5633676648139954,
-0.11449918150901794,
0.7813323140144348,
0.3412425220012665,
0.5699564814567566,
0.2679099440574646,
0.09918597340583801,
-0.24369226396083832,
-0.5563143491744995,
0.18919770419597626,
-0.2913854718208313,
-0.9117446541786194,
-0.40730732679367065,
-0.28326764702796936,
-0.2423935830593109,
-0.6831545233726501,
-0.459652841091156,
-0.43253570795059204,
-0.2738736867904663,
0.09142624586820602,
-0.05594160780310631,
-0.4569816589355469,
0.8734869360923767,
-0.868718147277832,
-0.21263575553894043,
-0.5358431339263916,
0.6052361130714417,
0.53214031457901,
0.5654923319816589,
-0.3736557960510254,
0.048059362918138504,
-0.23343674838542938,
0.33527669310569763,
-0.1433117389678955,
-0.48478662967681885,
0.07112032920122147,
0.25604337453842163,
0.8982880115509033,
0.5254164934158325,
0.299299955368042,
0.4297718405723572,
0.03058096207678318,
0.37694135308265686,
0.5352724194526672,
-0.6375415325164795,
0.559124767780304,
-0.2587369382381439,
0.3335418999195099,
0.7851489782333374,
0.8243909478187561,
-0.403167724609375,
-0.02174391597509384,
-0.8811182379722595,
-0.6498944163322449,
0.5272485017776489,
-0.010266084223985672,
-0.5064573884010315,
0.45357370376586914,
0.027933575212955475,
0.3655036687850952,
0.04803053289651871,
-0.9381170868873596,
-0.22488921880722046,
0.04851008951663971,
-0.35082608461380005,
0.20047850906848907,
0.06573443859815598,
-0.4413798153400421,
-0.2620733976364136,
0.7417312264442444,
-0.2626783549785614,
0.1480516791343689,
-0.053636543452739716,
0.17278067767620087,
-0.060378242284059525,
-0.0294332318007946,
0.29843488335609436,
1.1048862934112549,
-0.563668429851532,
0.09380418062210083,
0.2802697420120239,
-0.060138627886772156,
0.12374217063188553,
0.25671669840812683,
-0.2884313464164734,
-0.12758517265319824,
0.42245790362358093,
0.36267805099487305,
-0.04885012283921242,
-0.4443434178829193,
0.1922556608915329,
-0.08379742503166199,
-0.2640555799007416,
-0.2882338762283325,
0.22441934049129486,
-0.1017034575343132,
0.279325932264328,
0.27606073021888733,
0.8063532114028931,
0.1480940729379654,
-0.6350619196891785,
0.42677783966064453,
0.1254439800977707,
-0.44665205478668213,
0.03402603790163994,
0.5194453597068787,
0.0933171883225441,
0.0893700048327446,
0.5816320180892944,
-0.1513461470603943,
-0.1368280053138733,
0.7358871698379517,
0.4807685613632202,
0.3019048273563385,
-0.288173645734787,
0.29999005794525146,
0.5971089005470276,
0.1298961192369461,
-0.5548268556594849,
0.4213094115257263,
-0.16696994006633759,
-1.2892510890960693,
-0.3274959325790405,
-0.42004773020744324,
-0.7299100160598755,
-0.07325611263513565,
-1.0753779411315918,
0.3895569145679474,
-0.9905589818954468,
-0.07959050685167313,
0.3535679280757904,
-0.0096658980473876,
-0.9873252511024475,
0.6550896763801575,
0.374149352312088,
0.6843262314796448,
-1.0020452737808228,
0.9992754459381104,
0.6482153534889221,
-0.6325432658195496,
-1.0472006797790527,
-0.009781022556126118,
0.19501061737537384,
-0.7272168397903442,
0.6473193168640137,
0.18917466700077057,
0.05997345596551895,
-0.313541442155838,
-0.662445068359375,
-1.0312254428863525,
0.8664159774780273,
0.43620118498802185,
-0.5360800623893738,
-0.14718079566955566,
-0.09654757380485535,
-0.13257424533367157,
-0.71722012758255,
0.08282051980495453,
0.33354029059410095,
0.5101749300956726,
0.12867043912410736,
-0.8782568573951721,
-0.4640957713127136,
-0.24604536592960358,
-0.04047127440571785,
-0.00032788023236207664,
-0.24098104238510132,
1.3101264238357544,
-0.4928964078426361,
0.17540374398231506,
-0.19455748796463013,
0.846603512763977,
0.5561469197273254,
0.5378678441047668,
0.6204764246940613,
0.8508403897285461,
1.1327528953552246,
-0.19765068590641022,
0.7826281785964966,
-0.2612341344356537,
0.36341944336891174,
1.6177854537963867,
-0.4187704026699066,
0.8452721238136292,
0.3914974629878998,
-0.43989869952201843,
0.6641294360160828,
0.7145084738731384,
-0.007988139986991882,
0.6052471399307251,
-0.26965975761413574,
-0.4104297161102295,
-0.5584271550178528,
-0.2746470868587494,
-0.7032831907272339,
0.5268799662590027,
0.4301731288433075,
-0.1751583218574524,
-0.1252366453409195,
-0.13340625166893005,
-0.3886594772338867,
0.48414918780326843,
-0.4968394339084625,
0.6186319589614868,
-0.1745859831571579,
-0.8466740846633911,
0.1556866466999054,
0.010622230358421803,
0.7069877982139587,
-0.6825578808784485,
-0.22286854684352875,
0.20711296796798706,
0.2488073855638504,
-0.41093340516090393,
-0.9251660108566284,
0.44450700283050537,
-0.642146110534668,
-0.6306585669517517,
-0.24736419320106506,
0.7384334802627563,
-0.5373293161392212,
-0.6855365037918091,
0.13492140173912048,
0.48638737201690674,
-0.4408811032772064,
0.2651754319667816,
-0.6300464272499084,
0.03648976609110832,
0.2788439393043518,
0.30146151781082153,
0.33498871326446533,
0.38339507579803467,
0.12086337804794312,
0.7529644966125488,
0.8250695466995239,
-0.020588606595993042,
-0.11522237211465836,
-0.16462603211402893,
0.4455926716327667,
-0.2538444697856903,
-0.709132969379425,
-0.32037046551704407,
0.6625373363494873,
-0.3831409811973572,
-0.5581799745559692,
0.5331082344055176,
0.5316931009292603,
1.2169263362884521,
0.25141531229019165,
1.1701561212539673,
-0.07858863472938538,
0.39479777216911316,
-0.7494174838066101,
-0.01596004329621792,
-0.3065081238746643,
0.3580367863178253,
0.04495493322610855,
-1.1032161712646484,
-0.3674842417240143,
1.1535152196884155,
-0.4395636022090912,
-0.028902368620038033,
0.16140487790107727,
0.3101459741592407,
-0.31254178285598755,
0.09250447154045105,
0.3520621061325073,
-0.23449315130710602,
0.06246963515877724,
0.7330120801925659,
0.6256536841392517,
-0.08870486915111542,
-0.14009909331798553,
-0.57703697681427,
-0.20367513597011566,
-0.13961456716060638,
-0.909686803817749,
-0.7416732311248779,
-0.5554385781288147,
-0.2848208546638489,
-0.3451913595199585,
0.044876810163259506,
1.5449159145355225,
1.0189887285232544,
-0.9009412527084351,
-0.381573349237442,
-0.07308420538902283,
0.45032042264938354,
-0.3876561224460602,
-0.2055021971464157,
-0.034854914993047714,
-0.5773373246192932,
-0.5701904892921448,
-0.06313464790582657,
0.3565788269042969,
0.3114917278289795,
-0.11857574433088303,
-0.41561755537986755,
-0.6574825644493103,
-0.08480298519134521,
0.26170483231544495,
0.40817394852638245,
-0.4289914071559906,
-0.2985664904117584,
-0.5382459163665771,
-0.06594657152891159,
0.18791650235652924,
0.540381133556366,
-0.6518359184265137,
0.5520115494728088,
0.5929132699966431,
0.5372317433357239,
0.4882012605667114,
-0.11088229715824127,
1.097586989402771,
-0.434347540140152,
0.44651713967323303,
0.5113075971603394,
0.5152686238288879,
0.4161522388458252,
-0.2968696057796478,
0.7920535802841187,
0.12973171472549438,
-0.5287659168243408,
-0.6263788938522339,
0.320420503616333,
-0.6979534029960632,
-0.4571903944015503,
0.8534110188484192,
-0.675062894821167,
0.37267419695854187,
-0.1918318122625351,
0.1806444674730301,
-0.15577742457389832,
-0.11597542464733124,
0.6919627785682678,
0.6246345043182373,
-0.37035226821899414,
0.16465994715690613,
-0.48279985785484314,
0.5180765390396118,
0.15762440860271454,
-0.8958629369735718,
-0.5715426802635193,
0.5883980989456177,
0.21664077043533325,
0.20404045283794403,
0.4642527997493744,
0.41070613265037537,
0.1741889864206314,
0.4470767378807068,
-0.017896659672260284,
0.3903830349445343,
-0.6961934566497803,
0.12828755378723145,
0.49497857689857483,
0.13933977484703064,
0.08561450242996216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03720v1 | Similarity-based Neighbor Selection for Graph LLMs | 2024-02-06T05:29:05 | 2024-02-06T05:29:05 | Rui Li, Jiwei Li, Jiawei Han, Guoyin Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI | Text-attributed graphs (TAGs) present unique challenges for direct processing
by Language Learning Models (LLMs), yet their extensive commonsense knowledge
and robust reasoning capabilities offer great promise for node classification
in TAGs. Prior research in this field has grappled with issues such as
over-squashing, heterophily, and ineffective graph information integration,
further compounded by inconsistencies in dataset partitioning and
underutilization of advanced LLMs. To address these challenges, we introduce
Similarity-based Neighbor Selection (SNS). Using SimCSE and advanced neighbor
selection techniques, SNS effectively improves the quality of selected
neighbors, thereby improving graph representation and alleviating issues like
over-squashing and heterophily. Besides, as an inductive and training-free
approach, SNS demonstrates superior generalization and scalability over
traditional GNN methods. Our comprehensive experiments, adhering to standard
dataset partitioning practices, demonstrate that SNS, through simple prompt
interactions with LLMs, consistently outperforms vanilla GNNs and achieves
state-of-the-art results on datasets like PubMed in node classification,
showcasing LLMs' potential in graph structure understanding. Our research
further underscores the significance of graph structure integration in LLM
applications and identifies key factors for their success in node
classification. Code is available at https://github.com/ruili33/SNS. | [
-0.24313078820705414,
-0.3478507399559021,
0.7330889105796814,
-0.04626163840293884,
-0.3035648465156555,
0.47312963008880615,
-0.12759388983249664,
-0.4699211120605469,
0.5646223425865173,
0.3411608636379242,
-0.3979397714138031,
-0.75628662109375,
-0.6306702494621277,
0.20547626912593842,
-0.09197799861431122,
0.9910852313041687,
0.034907370805740356,
0.11929669976234436,
-0.7018338441848755,
-0.19656014442443848,
0.14152124524116516,
-0.18109560012817383,
-0.6986265778541565,
-0.5488332509994507,
0.7721612453460693,
0.28118687868118286,
0.5399823188781738,
1.1340229511260986,
0.5592842698097229,
0.3570421040058136,
-0.4197641611099243,
0.4239089787006378,
-0.3702927827835083,
0.12036571651697159,
-0.1716488152742386,
-0.2389715164899826,
-0.41782912611961365,
-0.035780951380729675,
0.8821747303009033,
0.869663655757904,
0.2390705943107605,
0.26469686627388,
0.23851948976516724,
0.7329726219177246,
-0.22526462376117706,
0.16274504363536835,
-0.8248026371002197,
0.1250831037759781,
-0.17990277707576752,
0.04458347335457802,
-0.24819281697273254,
-0.6580193638801575,
-0.04769901931285858,
-0.2898070216178894,
0.25793758034706116,
0.25999993085861206,
1.013320803642273,
0.255708783864975,
-0.23019826412200928,
-0.12388385087251663,
-0.10517682880163193,
0.48644357919692993,
-0.43179813027381897,
0.5888367295265198,
0.43023908138275146,
0.19840365648269653,
-0.2393118441104889,
-0.8812669515609741,
-0.16051219403743744,
-0.19524601101875305,
0.04431857541203499,
-0.06706977635622025,
-0.15093563497066498,
0.1470734179019928,
0.46382397413253784,
0.4038192927837372,
-0.6890382170677185,
0.4249767065048218,
-0.17206239700317383,
-0.3659416139125824,
0.22649945318698883,
0.1457047015428543,
0.03648693487048149,
-0.32280829548835754,
-0.49188634753227234,
0.053389061242341995,
-0.7779362201690674,
-0.1148170530796051,
0.5828858017921448,
0.666054904460907,
0.2250041961669922,
0.20728878676891327,
-0.35428011417388916,
0.7520116567611694,
-0.2904067039489746,
-0.04776040092110634,
0.6858890652656555,
-0.14234548807144165,
-0.1027875542640686,
-0.19862990081310272,
1.009127140045166,
0.3659229576587677,
0.33560824394226074,
-0.37057384848594666,
-0.054586004465818405,
-0.10673128813505173,
-0.16373519599437714,
-0.8318191766738892,
-0.3390222191810608,
-0.12993839383125305,
-0.5609492659568787,
-0.4866994023323059,
0.05331011116504669,
-0.6407700777053833,
-0.36921456456184387,
-0.11598625779151917,
-0.1971507966518402,
-0.30686214566230774,
-0.07887596637010574,
-0.2697809338569641,
-0.21162638068199158,
-0.03466126322746277,
0.030460501089692116,
-0.4960130453109741,
0.6193432211875916,
0.7891941070556641,
1.2173396348953247,
-0.5589691996574402,
-0.49809736013412476,
-0.591439425945282,
-0.011122334748506546,
-0.032405685633420944,
0.8331125974655151,
-0.712854266166687,
-0.2673693597316742,
-0.22665247321128845,
-0.10606622695922852,
-0.028972124680876732,
-0.8005109429359436,
0.23352748155593872,
-0.473713219165802,
-0.3951047956943512,
-0.351919949054718,
-0.4279254078865051,
0.038128387182950974,
0.45615628361701965,
-0.7061792612075806,
1.3210006952285767,
0.16794884204864502,
-1.2185627222061157,
-0.003243051003664732,
-0.052471064031124115,
-0.3367531895637512,
-0.03653784841299057,
-0.36845824122428894,
-0.6989712715148926,
-0.07910361140966415,
0.1358616203069687,
0.6070342659950256,
-0.09701082855463028,
-0.18249501287937164,
-0.5919265151023865,
-0.4067133963108063,
0.18523451685905457,
-0.11865437775850296,
0.6350542902946472,
0.3543306887149811,
0.25595757365226746,
0.114558145403862,
-0.5534794330596924,
0.1683667153120041,
0.36313751339912415,
-0.05481026694178581,
-0.40821370482444763,
0.028870293870568275,
-0.3842813968658447,
0.05643896758556366,
0.27918151021003723,
-0.7689401507377625,
0.1528998464345932,
-0.4678037166595459,
0.43829384446144104,
0.701156497001648,
0.013566679321229458,
0.5311796069145203,
-0.44015297293663025,
0.3129115402698517,
-0.1605577915906906,
-0.17656037211418152,
0.027106083929538727,
-0.33927392959594727,
-0.32896003127098083,
-0.3075685203075409,
0.5399019718170166,
0.487113893032074,
-0.9749883413314819,
0.25570785999298096,
-0.7729225158691406,
-0.4645683765411377,
-0.21964432299137115,
0.11913520097732544,
0.3746485412120819,
0.5955916047096252,
0.19019538164138794,
-0.44727692008018494,
-0.24947324395179749,
-0.621870756149292,
-0.11168335378170013,
-0.03091328963637352,
0.019412929192185402,
0.6387418508529663,
0.12230196595191956,
-0.17308349907398224,
1.009853720664978,
-0.9171883463859558,
-0.2724069058895111,
-0.39092501997947693,
-0.2715570330619812,
0.12652307748794556,
0.1380472034215927,
0.6045844554901123,
-0.5231996178627014,
-0.6875208020210266,
0.1507347971200943,
-0.42398715019226074,
-0.43461379408836365,
0.29238972067832947,
0.09533411264419556,
-0.23474854230880737,
0.756149172782898,
-0.2528551518917084,
0.43817007541656494,
0.550593376159668,
0.18558967113494873,
0.5172258019447327,
0.008650940842926502,
-0.17466706037521362,
-1.193748116493225,
-0.24380789697170258,
0.0009791443590074778,
-0.7574343681335449,
-0.26600226759910583,
0.0678071603178978,
-0.13861148059368134,
-0.07006114721298218,
-0.20725476741790771,
0.4354223906993866,
-0.44933149218559265,
-0.6008737087249756,
-0.3329249918460846,
0.23754997551441193,
-0.12384506314992905,
0.3942391872406006,
-0.11184844374656677,
0.7068554162979126,
0.6767313480377197,
-0.40880635380744934,
0.5550256371498108,
0.03765451908111572,
-0.17507699131965637,
0.33008429408073425,
-0.41923412680625916,
0.3244324326515198,
-0.09845685958862305,
0.3344060182571411,
-0.7985907793045044,
0.05286421254277229,
0.4125349521636963,
-0.6165887713432312,
0.3182588517665863,
-0.3161550760269165,
-0.7166940569877625,
-0.4022066295146942,
-0.5474569797515869,
0.32660046219825745,
0.21950897574424744,
-0.6804522275924683,
0.5225642323493958,
0.20274990797042847,
-0.24687744677066803,
-0.5470903515815735,
-0.5481675863265991,
0.009031231515109539,
-0.03590746223926544,
-0.2383192479610443,
0.3173677921295166,
-0.00893778819590807,
0.14890813827514648,
0.33187127113342285,
-0.24733293056488037,
-0.05951143428683281,
-0.011519917286932468,
0.3974098861217499,
-0.033281296491622925,
0.031882673501968384,
0.3289969563484192,
0.10200069099664688,
-0.42555978894233704,
-0.030699793249368668,
-0.24272195994853973,
0.6388902068138123,
-0.16996292769908905,
-0.4470723867416382,
-0.2194630205631256,
0.01409742422401905,
0.042102739214897156,
-0.38957756757736206,
0.2870824337005615,
0.5690111517906189,
-0.07211258262395859,
-0.5140281915664673,
-0.3455130457878113,
-0.08760090917348862,
-0.4748161733150482,
0.7111921906471252,
-0.4910007417201996,
-1.226189374923706,
0.6315158605575562,
-0.6439135670661926,
-0.4207291305065155,
-0.009521129541099072,
-0.009977607056498528,
-0.3003978133201599,
0.4740518629550934,
0.2623005211353302,
-0.3989923894405365,
0.6524608731269836,
-0.2342718243598938,
0.037458889186382294,
-1.014818549156189,
-0.10126804560422897,
-0.6681551337242126,
-0.3902321457862854,
-0.7580745816230774,
-0.7452797889709473,
0.13565051555633545,
-0.2595589756965637,
-0.18753549456596375,
0.21491946280002594,
-0.6404352188110352,
0.9950048327445984,
0.2774370312690735,
0.3791061341762543,
0.28323858976364136,
0.4729923903942108,
-0.37661993503570557,
-0.22237002849578857,
-0.5971775650978088,
-0.17319561541080475,
0.8593958616256714,
0.4921557903289795,
0.752939760684967,
-0.13840503990650177,
1.1761467456817627,
0.23645897209644318,
0.32364723086357117,
-0.8807328939437866,
0.8685873746871948,
-0.4475906789302826,
0.11926638334989548,
-0.20259042084217072,
-0.9638444185256958,
-0.9298091530799866,
0.189851775765419,
-0.03939589112997055,
-0.9323862791061401,
-0.24116776883602142,
-0.1069178357720375,
0.143167182803154,
0.8030456900596619,
-0.17543627321720123,
0.5102980732917786,
0.1394006460905075,
-0.027240652590990067,
0.06131662800908089,
-0.6570220589637756,
-0.09593099355697632,
0.1208510622382164,
0.11523912101984024,
-0.3219049572944641,
-0.005235724616795778,
0.4189280569553375,
-0.3897038400173187,
0.8206361532211304,
0.0031384401954710484,
0.2648678719997406,
0.3961957097053528,
0.2317429631948471,
0.5366060137748718,
-0.23571288585662842,
-0.17768360674381256,
0.41425660252571106,
-0.3069491982460022,
-0.15716619789600372,
-0.7263903617858887,
1.0225403308868408,
-0.6424790024757385,
-0.352263867855072,
-0.419710636138916,
-0.48073461651802063,
-0.07749495655298233,
0.1982044130563736,
0.16530153155326843,
0.3879747986793518,
-0.10605106502771378,
-0.0034057716839015484,
0.7232651710510254,
0.13535822927951813,
0.37191465497016907,
0.07248824089765549,
-0.5471299886703491,
-0.8243435025215149,
1.4026583433151245,
0.15560202300548553,
0.40159717202186584,
0.32201775908470154,
0.2895382344722748,
-0.3720622658729553,
-0.8375357985496521,
-0.23837822675704956,
0.4542604386806488,
-0.8439390063285828,
-0.6211320757865906,
-0.5595842599868774,
-0.5657998323440552,
-0.23163314163684845,
0.03915644437074661,
-0.2503078877925873,
-0.24148401618003845,
-0.2894754707813263,
-0.397935688495636,
0.31575527787208557,
0.9247028231620789,
-0.060151733458042145,
0.30732280015945435,
-0.6043596863746643,
0.08309219032526016,
0.33345550298690796,
0.7493409514427185,
0.14163902401924133,
-0.42932963371276855,
-0.04807191714644432,
-0.33251532912254333,
-0.1995106190443039,
-1.0536249876022339,
-0.07962267845869064,
0.1688922643661499,
0.5744690299034119,
0.14556202292442322,
-0.05765337869524956,
0.4477478861808777,
-0.6492727398872375,
0.2812111973762512,
0.12987886369228363,
-0.7541493773460388,
0.3827504515647888,
-0.29366299510002136,
0.010211690329015255,
0.6767218708992004,
0.45373865962028503,
-0.28207075595855713,
-0.1426757574081421,
-0.5080612301826477,
-0.6670389771461487,
0.6548612713813782,
0.1366819143295288,
0.035070911049842834,
-0.010617597959935665,
0.5911238193511963,
-0.14453822374343872,
0.03409609571099281,
-1.0366625785827637,
-0.47822946310043335,
0.02157028391957283,
-0.3107277750968933,
0.3193022608757019,
-0.06658341735601425,
0.2922407388687134,
-0.2517935633659363,
0.3467664122581482,
-0.3591984212398529,
0.02818247489631176,
0.1911030262708664,
0.07644810527563095,
-0.022478006780147552,
-0.0630553662776947,
-0.021708078682422638,
0.2751137316226959,
-0.15344759821891785,
0.3993782103061676,
0.6670393943786621,
-0.3660701513290405,
-0.0038888489361852407,
0.13758568465709686,
-0.30249443650245667,
0.08779459446668625,
0.3031817078590393,
0.5046219229698181,
-0.05953294411301613,
-0.12848563492298126,
0.7893847823143005,
0.1340978592634201,
-0.14324863255023956,
0.20772019028663635,
0.055008262395858765,
0.2530967891216278,
0.18020401895046234,
-0.04142702743411064,
0.02332671917974949,
0.2202998697757721,
-0.2274438738822937,
0.26084303855895996,
0.5739855766296387,
-0.6673861145973206,
-0.1411011666059494,
0.15339267253875732,
0.09980232268571854,
-0.4993586242198944,
0.4526735544204712,
-0.849399745464325,
-0.7415308952331543,
0.7236562967300415,
0.7227012515068054,
0.8540650606155396,
-0.29953864216804504,
0.4284249246120453,
0.4663332402706146,
0.17908021807670593,
0.09676454961299896,
0.15773718059062958,
-0.21932381391525269,
-0.82868492603302,
-0.4443886876106262,
-0.6848713755607605,
-0.3454713225364685,
-0.15402452647686005,
-0.519794225692749,
0.035303954035043716,
-0.7991188168525696,
-0.1751495599746704,
-0.28906798362731934,
0.10651795566082001,
-0.381254643201828,
0.11264461278915405,
0.20948362350463867,
0.9150064587593079,
-0.985528826713562,
0.7828275561332703,
0.9235095977783203,
-0.15629909932613373,
-0.7633910179138184,
0.20833036303520203,
-0.15406663715839386,
-0.680203378200531,
0.6227462887763977,
0.21817074716091156,
-0.40298399329185486,
0.15167804062366486,
-0.774497389793396,
-0.8681511282920837,
1.102254033088684,
0.2546559274196625,
-0.281222403049469,
0.1944585144519806,
0.32264629006385803,
0.46665263175964355,
-0.5810604691505432,
0.25827422738075256,
0.24085436761379242,
-0.03313928470015526,
0.5803403258323669,
-0.8564125895500183,
0.21255464851856232,
0.04752754420042038,
0.3763781785964966,
0.3770948350429535,
-0.8333735466003418,
0.5225067734718323,
-0.28635239601135254,
-0.09237699955701828,
-0.0011503830319270492,
0.855503499507904,
0.42102158069610596,
0.607664167881012,
0.5706788301467896,
0.8377895355224609,
0.8592361807823181,
-0.0916307345032692,
0.6045422554016113,
0.21141177415847778,
0.44359639286994934,
1.3780075311660767,
-0.2968006134033203,
0.8373611569404602,
0.2155023068189621,
-0.5533416271209717,
0.6819579601287842,
0.6176146864891052,
-0.0667772889137268,
0.3342737853527069,
0.5303387641906738,
-0.024335181340575218,
-0.3676065504550934,
-0.49524426460266113,
-0.411510169506073,
0.41782355308532715,
0.29108262062072754,
-0.3470247685909271,
-0.46911686658859253,
-0.4485885798931122,
0.009322755970060825,
0.3659462034702301,
-0.32110100984573364,
0.8293521404266357,
0.28306910395622253,
0.1525997817516327,
-0.07303759455680847,
-0.26584193110466003,
0.5001499056816101,
-0.6448853611946106,
-0.029135936871170998,
-0.2157246619462967,
-0.27276474237442017,
-0.40609943866729736,
-0.9573480486869812,
0.3093191981315613,
-0.13824333250522614,
-0.26214438676834106,
-0.19300997257232666,
1.0520317554473877,
-0.32435867190361023,
-0.32981306314468384,
0.3950953483581543,
0.4412609934806824,
0.43264850974082947,
-0.0682896077632904,
-0.6844305992126465,
0.2996542453765869,
0.2482709139585495,
0.24431926012039185,
0.47764864563941956,
0.5721673965454102,
0.13149425387382507,
0.8048544526100159,
0.6163179278373718,
0.5847217440605164,
-0.22823835909366608,
0.1932096630334854,
1.2699905633926392,
-0.6458938717842102,
-0.6220185160636902,
-0.7944889664649963,
-0.11824482679367065,
-0.4630381464958191,
0.027661317959427834,
0.7342116832733154,
0.7556487321853638,
0.9414058327674866,
0.37781596183776855,
0.4330441951751709,
0.2762332260608673,
0.6533715128898621,
-0.37671607732772827,
0.5583564639091492,
-0.4206334054470062,
0.24299116432666779,
-0.39300790429115295,
-1.3083558082580566,
-0.3949204683303833,
0.5667200684547424,
-0.4417295455932617,
0.2334708869457245,
0.6387233138084412,
0.7475941181182861,
-0.12750375270843506,
-0.2545746862888336,
0.2291000485420227,
-0.04946218430995941,
0.17250151932239532,
0.45057129859924316,
1.0419176816940308,
-0.27133461833000183,
0.7014064788818359,
-0.07028017193078995,
-0.10896609723567963,
0.03077291138470173,
-1.0365867614746094,
-1.1213890314102173,
-0.4236341714859009,
-0.4276524484157562,
-0.3626396954059601,
-0.02060794271528721,
1.1242263317108154,
0.4958280622959137,
-0.5642009973526001,
0.019081100821495056,
0.04698650911450386,
0.6569483876228333,
0.22225791215896606,
-0.18872205913066864,
0.46988216042518616,
-0.3323187530040741,
-0.5794361233711243,
0.21753722429275513,
0.4262363910675049,
0.13491053879261017,
0.17434091866016388,
-0.1596432328224182,
0.030533140525221825,
-0.3671647608280182,
0.21201615035533905,
0.20342950522899628,
-0.6000800132751465,
-0.2762584984302521,
-0.19824126362800598,
-0.2898247539997101,
0.24182499945163727,
0.5623403191566467,
-0.786044180393219,
0.355132520198822,
0.6903901100158691,
0.8132220506668091,
0.4625302255153656,
0.1717611849308014,
-0.15121537446975708,
-1.2358906269073486,
0.03375651687383652,
0.21916469931602478,
0.33505913615226746,
0.5812547206878662,
-0.1682330220937729,
0.51788729429245,
0.37668952345848083,
-0.5664951801300049,
-0.8468613028526306,
0.6717848777770996,
-0.8549085855484009,
-0.16885006427764893,
1.2874512672424316,
-0.25293809175491333,
-0.3227996230125427,
-0.06648041307926178,
-0.13788150250911713,
0.23365984857082367,
-0.23218724131584167,
0.0921715721487999,
0.30732229351997375,
-0.11690028011798859,
-0.08572371304035187,
-0.06625866144895554,
0.5691590905189514,
0.15690340101718903,
-0.5608848929405212,
0.038613904267549515,
0.22395357489585876,
0.43909475207328796,
0.007169262506067753,
0.711956799030304,
0.1854153871536255,
-0.2593132257461548,
-0.07494410872459412,
-0.09765949845314026,
-0.48937857151031494,
-0.361232191324234,
-0.3123877942562103,
0.1399303525686264,
0.23095087707042694,
-0.29472365975379944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03719v1 | Empowering Language Models with Active Inquiry for Deeper Understanding | 2024-02-06T05:24:16 | 2024-02-06T05:24:16 | Jing-Cheng Pang, Heng-Bo Fan, Pengyuan Wang, Jia-Hao Xiao, Nan Tang, Si-Hang Yang, Chengxing Jia, Sheng-Jun Huang, Yang Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rise of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the way that we
interact with artificial intelligence systems through natural language.
However, LLMs often misinterpret user queries because of their uncertain
intention, leading to less helpful responses. In natural human interactions,
clarification is sought through targeted questioning to uncover obscure
information. Thus, in this paper, we introduce LaMAI (Language Model with
Active Inquiry), designed to endow LLMs with this same level of interactive
engagement. LaMAI leverages active learning techniques to raise the most
informative questions, fostering a dynamic bidirectional dialogue. This
approach not only narrows the contextual gap but also refines the output of the
LLMs, aligning it more closely with user expectations. Our empirical studies,
across a variety of complex datasets where LLMs have limited conversational
context, demonstrate the effectiveness of LaMAI. The method improves answer
accuracy from 31.9% to 50.9%, outperforming other leading question-answering
frameworks. Moreover, in scenarios involving human participants, LaMAI
consistently generates responses that are superior or comparable to baseline
methods in more than 82% of the cases. The applicability of LaMAI is further
evidenced by its successful integration with various LLMs, highlighting its
potential for the future of interactive language models. | [
-0.21335627138614655,
-1.2974010705947876,
0.6630595326423645,
0.18688876926898956,
0.012138038873672485,
0.1878264993429184,
-0.5492690801620483,
-0.4803265929222107,
-0.1026582345366478,
0.25334233045578003,
-0.5720767378807068,
-0.4465339481830597,
-0.27447840571403503,
-0.08248616755008698,
-0.24150383472442627,
0.5803788900375366,
-0.1869281679391861,
0.011416574008762836,
-0.0946364626288414,
-0.24868951737880707,
-0.23492947220802307,
-0.13392895460128784,
-0.725620687007904,
-0.28760677576065063,
0.9094472527503967,
0.4478055536746979,
0.9282257556915283,
0.6272308826446533,
0.39749273657798767,
0.2940848469734192,
-0.4468879699707031,
0.41947054862976074,
-0.49345430731773376,
0.42225944995880127,
0.13760574162006378,
-0.914263129234314,
-0.2879415452480316,
0.003501885337755084,
0.6561985015869141,
1.1730717420578003,
-0.44175079464912415,
-0.023504693061113358,
-0.19083423912525177,
0.43076345324516296,
-0.7184156775474548,
0.10049239546060562,
-0.5170708894729614,
-0.014585737138986588,
0.1429131031036377,
0.07687544822692871,
-0.2885870039463043,
-0.3985459506511688,
0.31254181265830994,
-0.47549647092819214,
-0.017217999324202538,
-0.22508014738559723,
0.6733472347259521,
0.3924996256828308,
-0.7488910555839539,
-0.5198826193809509,
-0.8122544884681702,
0.7033620476722717,
-0.8165923357009888,
0.3700729012489319,
0.3735046982765198,
0.3705434203147888,
-0.14729848504066467,
-0.7663337588310242,
-0.7366006970405579,
-0.11821214854717255,
-0.20425599813461304,
0.0005087684839963913,
-0.1438477635383606,
0.024892674759030342,
0.08510667830705643,
0.3711757957935333,
-0.2780808210372925,
0.17926433682441711,
-0.14347964525222778,
0.14572036266326904,
0.4658452868461609,
0.10956273972988129,
0.3312188982963562,
-0.06611546128988266,
-0.12618376314640045,
0.06683021038770676,
-0.8757255673408508,
0.3970290720462799,
0.369371235370636,
0.1598770171403885,
0.08355441689491272,
0.38828590512275696,
-0.04781655967235565,
0.9038568139076233,
0.00046847068006172776,
0.21557283401489258,
-0.05428164452314377,
-0.4273686707019806,
-0.07578424364328384,
-0.10613515973091125,
0.5931806564331055,
0.07039033621549606,
0.10368292778730392,
-0.17915551364421844,
-0.19834603369235992,
-0.35036441683769226,
0.1873992532491684,
-0.8816483020782471,
-0.07424705475568771,
0.431769996881485,
-0.08792844414710999,
-0.30029430985450745,
0.1769677996635437,
-0.6033262014389038,
-0.5267844200134277,
-0.30296558141708374,
0.1269826591014862,
-0.07985028624534607,
-0.43779364228248596,
0.18008407950401306,
0.3825393617153168,
0.45258834958076477,
0.6845210790634155,
-0.7675743103027344,
0.1348731815814972,
0.7598332166671753,
0.5943254828453064,
-0.11153025925159454,
-0.1234816461801529,
-0.7549498677253723,
0.3850848078727722,
-0.43483754992485046,
0.5744048357009888,
-0.8935497403144836,
-0.39284393191337585,
0.23690828680992126,
0.13924717903137207,
-0.1731167435646057,
-0.4994086027145386,
0.5139634609222412,
-0.811763346195221,
0.4562090039253235,
-0.27596715092658997,
-0.28083518147468567,
-0.4061129093170166,
0.627287745475769,
-0.530247688293457,
1.0173280239105225,
-0.36764827370643616,
-0.592366099357605,
-0.03811633586883545,
-0.7698636054992676,
-0.3734501004219055,
0.0866178423166275,
-0.18371273577213287,
-0.2917182743549347,
0.009367108345031738,
0.33141154050827026,
0.36007869243621826,
-0.2573294937610626,
0.8010278344154358,
-0.26094740629196167,
-0.2830781042575836,
0.5421815514564514,
-0.56747967004776,
0.5684329867362976,
0.13111093640327454,
-0.3639950156211853,
0.4230935573577881,
-0.6067279577255249,
0.021884072571992874,
0.09801376610994339,
-0.6439429521560669,
-0.17946375906467438,
0.032020919024944305,
-0.3036452531814575,
-0.0995480865240097,
0.2648082673549652,
-0.5534945726394653,
0.18566979467868805,
-0.6294090151786804,
0.4861208498477936,
0.6551812291145325,
0.005364527925848961,
0.6034614443778992,
-0.10176511853933334,
0.44508060812950134,
-0.07430083304643631,
0.25419116020202637,
-0.4333599805831909,
-0.4695473909378052,
-0.9759465456008911,
-0.04020166024565697,
0.3454788029193878,
0.6186346411705017,
-0.6621110439300537,
0.1311870962381363,
-0.1962486058473587,
-0.39214152097702026,
-0.8721160888671875,
0.34869804978370667,
0.15980061888694763,
0.5672922134399414,
0.12161422520875931,
0.21062611043453217,
-0.27587684988975525,
-0.7826808094978333,
-0.10367785394191742,
-0.528796911239624,
-0.23329001665115356,
0.8207297325134277,
0.2189091444015503,
-0.415872186422348,
0.8208985924720764,
-0.4957249164581299,
0.27852532267570496,
-0.442422091960907,
0.4564029574394226,
0.29211124777793884,
0.21685020625591278,
0.19700121879577637,
-1.1440612077713013,
-0.4528321921825409,
0.043432775884866714,
-0.7135111093521118,
-0.14470870792865753,
-0.015570889227092266,
-0.31248167157173157,
-0.22747980058193207,
0.32714059948921204,
-0.6792897582054138,
0.22374725341796875,
0.26582202315330505,
-0.20049211382865906,
-0.21880826354026794,
-0.1334933489561081,
0.1747400015592575,
-1.0176461935043335,
0.29426345229148865,
-0.1957395225763321,
-0.07921621948480606,
-0.9467446804046631,
0.23021627962589264,
0.13763856887817383,
-0.23530790209770203,
-0.5241549611091614,
0.6296871304512024,
-0.7144551873207092,
0.15743578970432281,
-0.215713232755661,
0.43681690096855164,
0.06304312497377396,
0.4316474497318268,
0.06723039597272873,
0.8532143831253052,
0.7581506967544556,
-0.6560702919960022,
0.5233994126319885,
0.3326832950115204,
-0.27721256017684937,
-0.14039583504199982,
-0.984998345375061,
0.28658682107925415,
-0.20832596719264984,
0.20960576832294464,
-1.0992377996444702,
-0.3966262936592102,
0.1341322660446167,
-0.30047377943992615,
0.394088476896286,
-0.07452452927827835,
-0.3936101496219635,
-0.17384998500347137,
-0.3619966506958008,
0.6707410216331482,
0.3309841454029083,
-0.7537318468093872,
0.7535642385482788,
0.48714280128479004,
-0.3200209140777588,
-0.6422402262687683,
-0.5019259452819824,
0.2622479200363159,
0.0023283991031348705,
-0.7408435344696045,
-0.09930968284606934,
-0.2844271957874298,
-0.49569782614707947,
-0.25260698795318604,
-0.004234555643051863,
-0.143108531832695,
0.3485880196094513,
0.026863226667046547,
0.20443566143512726,
-0.47108057141304016,
0.2359732836484909,
-0.052164606750011444,
0.19381891191005707,
0.10481161624193192,
0.29351532459259033,
0.4925525188446045,
-0.22442807257175446,
-0.7110393047332764,
-0.5190501809120178,
0.44389623403549194,
0.7673625946044922,
-0.5458023548126221,
0.6570045948028564,
0.4433412551879883,
-0.3461167812347412,
-0.04187842085957527,
-0.69514000415802,
-0.30255571007728577,
-0.4708320200443268,
0.11959688365459442,
-0.29794472455978394,
-1.0221441984176636,
0.6720653772354126,
-0.3742061257362366,
0.199101522564888,
-0.04320378229022026,
0.49686264991760254,
0.011083124205470085,
1.4252793788909912,
0.5781201720237732,
0.23596827685832977,
0.5318488478660583,
-0.2134949266910553,
0.5058024525642395,
-0.8398069143295288,
-0.6097978949546814,
-0.39616939425468445,
-0.3909149765968323,
-0.3465542793273926,
-0.6330171227455139,
0.28399235010147095,
0.15138646960258484,
0.08957722038030624,
-0.1982368677854538,
-0.177838534116745,
0.4245075583457947,
0.4075228273868561,
0.19832834601402283,
0.16614887118339539,
-0.4347984194755554,
0.2086348682641983,
0.17862817645072937,
-0.6890339255332947,
-0.7084378600120544,
0.7159823775291443,
0.5028984546661377,
0.9169979691505432,
0.6398221254348755,
0.2864907681941986,
0.01739134080708027,
0.47477486729621887,
-0.9526728391647339,
0.6592227220535278,
0.6252651214599609,
-0.6078831553459167,
-0.46926945447921753,
-0.4363282024860382,
-1.1450560092926025,
0.3277464509010315,
-0.017096593976020813,
-0.333107054233551,
0.35879775881767273,
-0.16833622753620148,
-0.4604247808456421,
0.19288772344589233,
-0.7160620093345642,
0.7230890393257141,
-0.3771751821041107,
-0.6601892113685608,
-0.10140052437782288,
-0.7872806787490845,
0.29209017753601074,
0.06668335199356079,
0.21261438727378845,
-0.2340046763420105,
-0.46832147240638733,
0.4998488128185272,
-0.2433367669582367,
1.152931809425354,
-0.09616439044475555,
-0.4290567934513092,
0.5561310648918152,
0.03231874853372574,
0.584324836730957,
0.37852707505226135,
-0.38308462500572205,
-0.30272677540779114,
-0.38881757855415344,
-0.49592214822769165,
-1.0028773546218872,
0.8458467125892639,
-0.6282790899276733,
-1.0919753313064575,
-0.18079204857349396,
-0.47493690252304077,
-0.34521031379699707,
0.0685085579752922,
-0.5660510659217834,
0.4163106381893158,
-0.3187362849712372,
0.2112264186143875,
0.9917989373207092,
-0.13802765309810638,
0.49346956610679626,
1.012853741645813,
-0.06873355060815811,
-0.040645185858011246,
0.37661781907081604,
-0.3019745349884033,
0.11696941405534744,
0.3242075741291046,
0.2671809494495392,
-0.3569236397743225,
-0.44515666365623474,
-0.7194881439208984,
0.5526639819145203,
-0.7311443090438843,
-0.199247345328331,
-0.8086997866630554,
-0.015560630708932877,
-0.3542262315750122,
0.03172985091805458,
-0.04062170162796974,
-0.2627612054347992,
-0.4187173843383789,
-0.3509178161621094,
0.23932507634162903,
0.9353048801422119,
0.1040310338139534,
0.08886037021875381,
-0.7237968444824219,
0.16034843027591705,
0.7784423828125,
0.15262576937675476,
0.10067595541477203,
-0.5927714109420776,
0.07776378095149994,
0.36345741152763367,
-0.18361268937587738,
-1.0074876546859741,
0.2097569853067398,
0.42895692586898804,
0.8772724270820618,
0.5958986878395081,
0.20835857093334198,
0.704265296459198,
-0.4778805673122406,
0.7890934348106384,
-0.047839466482400894,
-0.8017522096633911,
1.011366844177246,
-0.39180606603622437,
0.35657256841659546,
0.6672396659851074,
0.5874976515769958,
-0.4938746690750122,
-0.47399455308914185,
-0.28851279616355896,
-0.9265331029891968,
0.6679672598838806,
0.11381963640451431,
0.40234407782554626,
-0.08531191945075989,
0.5633957982063293,
0.03349637985229492,
0.23760011792182922,
-0.6530362963676453,
-0.03425497189164162,
0.12515506148338318,
-0.188670352101326,
0.1518244743347168,
-0.3694124221801758,
-0.3024646043777466,
-0.4215945601463318,
0.684135377407074,
-0.1326461285352707,
-0.03472091630101204,
0.10992133617401123,
-0.09650225192308426,
-0.2904605269432068,
0.41293108463287354,
0.40659835934638977,
0.8290241956710815,
-0.010742687620222569,
0.4196457266807556,
0.30644118785858154,
-0.20342254638671875,
-0.15127305686473846,
0.01809617131948471,
-0.08229177445173264,
-0.13267096877098083,
0.40737083554267883,
0.9372672438621521,
0.40935853123664856,
-1.0290805101394653,
0.6740213632583618,
-0.33945244550704956,
0.31665992736816406,
0.014920063316822052,
0.20479363203048706,
0.16041244566440582,
0.2856798768043518,
0.37478432059288025,
-0.2170100212097168,
0.1371532827615738,
-0.9819219708442688,
0.05682104453444481,
0.4084872603416443,
-0.6384184956550598,
-0.4265294373035431,
0.6330896615982056,
0.546152651309967,
-0.4912225008010864,
0.5874202251434326,
0.06871238350868225,
-0.6482782959938049,
0.3824326694011688,
0.3653908967971802,
0.5881677269935608,
-0.4782586395740509,
0.29364705085754395,
0.24942170083522797,
0.003645567921921611,
-0.00009506101196166128,
0.34919312596321106,
-0.5775246620178223,
-0.6213995814323425,
-0.5052247643470764,
-0.5521471500396729,
-0.7131944298744202,
0.01839272491633892,
-0.7230743169784546,
0.21873998641967773,
-0.11732352524995804,
0.1327497810125351,
-0.18264591693878174,
-0.013574091717600822,
-0.10195580124855042,
-0.07816793769598007,
0.10279720276594162,
0.7922621965408325,
-0.7234125733375549,
0.7301978468894958,
1.0667355060577393,
-0.33891668915748596,
-0.5905660390853882,
0.18902604281902313,
-0.4011553227901459,
-0.8675061464309692,
0.4983103573322296,
0.2665858864784241,
-0.27632683515548706,
0.04283180460333824,
-0.8697971701622009,
-0.6750838756561279,
0.9814473390579224,
0.20060229301452637,
-0.19973427057266235,
0.05513429269194603,
0.06288892030715942,
0.6760650277137756,
-0.2764626145362854,
0.4112247824668884,
0.4492746889591217,
0.5450796484947205,
0.48941347002983093,
-0.6565004587173462,
-0.02387670986354351,
-0.5499444603919983,
-0.28070610761642456,
0.4007391333580017,
-0.5976019501686096,
0.5230919718742371,
-0.5058549642562866,
-0.46021637320518494,
0.15330690145492554,
0.8444415926933289,
0.0273522287607193,
0.44658640027046204,
0.5198922753334045,
0.18898658454418182,
1.0595675706863403,
-0.08489570021629333,
0.872643768787384,
-0.32364320755004883,
-0.04522954300045967,
0.7642635107040405,
-0.3498585522174835,
1.0430859327316284,
0.43625521659851074,
0.08780442178249359,
0.5442211627960205,
0.7752698659896851,
0.27088773250579834,
0.35617291927337646,
0.27338728308677673,
-0.7412106990814209,
-0.5615194439888,
-0.37190282344818115,
-0.0754125788807869,
0.3187779188156128,
0.4239717721939087,
0.06520775705575943,
-0.13653205335140228,
0.13653843104839325,
0.044698867946863174,
0.43381911516189575,
-0.09153758734464645,
1.0030503273010254,
-0.24357105791568756,
-0.9293488264083862,
0.6090787649154663,
-0.05859387665987015,
0.4465682804584503,
-0.5405454039573669,
-0.17117738723754883,
-0.3930666148662567,
-0.007523688022047281,
-0.0415533110499382,
-0.897382915019989,
0.04723268002271652,
0.19040468335151672,
-0.06143397465348244,
-0.34067776799201965,
0.4958808720111847,
-0.7096328735351562,
-0.47275310754776,
0.12922661006450653,
0.8165304660797119,
0.18355423212051392,
0.1685161292552948,
-0.7064032554626465,
0.1301557868719101,
0.12984417378902435,
-0.34973257780075073,
0.05077981576323509,
0.7411734461784363,
0.023318756371736526,
1.0288589000701904,
0.6592497229576111,
-0.13407811522483826,
0.08440198749303818,
0.3045817017555237,
1.0906094312667847,
-0.47515368461608887,
-0.23507142066955566,
-0.5919877290725708,
0.4514029026031494,
-0.2515418529510498,
-0.06028089299798012,
0.6736978888511658,
0.6293233036994934,
0.3270712196826935,
0.36700695753097534,
0.4707319140434265,
0.32055187225341797,
0.596878170967102,
-0.3579554259777069,
0.5983386635780334,
-0.5509776473045349,
0.696584165096283,
0.27083688974380493,
-0.63653165102005,
-0.34759852290153503,
0.6242662072181702,
-0.4710176885128021,
-0.039044976234436035,
0.3568429946899414,
0.810444176197052,
-0.19838757812976837,
0.24984215199947357,
0.22975480556488037,
0.3712799847126007,
0.38922813534736633,
0.3985993266105652,
1.3568998575210571,
-0.27741581201553345,
0.6700587868690491,
-0.08377684652805328,
-0.32807794213294983,
0.012972704134881496,
-0.5554699897766113,
-1.0878393650054932,
-0.36083370447158813,
-0.3715125322341919,
0.15742063522338867,
0.1282425820827484,
0.50464928150177,
0.5516374111175537,
-0.7813352942466736,
-0.3129410147666931,
-0.15715506672859192,
0.3339957594871521,
0.2996179163455963,
-0.2189650535583496,
0.35556262731552124,
-0.4030604362487793,
-1.1587049961090088,
0.8025016784667969,
0.20839329063892365,
0.08518153429031372,
-0.3531438410282135,
-0.007501376327127218,
-0.5225034356117249,
0.340651273727417,
0.4414926767349243,
0.21468278765678406,
-0.9233475923538208,
-0.0775528997182846,
0.3382411599159241,
-0.09339648485183716,
0.09019133448600769,
0.9223538041114807,
-0.7099930644035339,
0.4588190019130707,
0.4573065936565399,
0.8757280111312866,
0.4432756006717682,
0.25149208307266235,
0.6936781406402588,
-0.562035083770752,
0.11676333099603653,
0.45742690563201904,
0.15560530126094818,
0.5845893621444702,
-0.46791717410087585,
0.4469488859176636,
-0.1383269727230072,
-0.45328769087791443,
-1.1139127016067505,
0.39385852217674255,
-0.8255743384361267,
-0.43330174684524536,
1.4058564901351929,
-0.19163087010383606,
-0.4131883382797241,
-0.19195258617401123,
-0.37533408403396606,
0.2131257951259613,
-0.29600009322166443,
0.7137056589126587,
0.5062585473060608,
-0.18193675577640533,
-0.32189029455184937,
-0.44085219502449036,
0.2741073966026306,
0.5805841088294983,
-0.7673362493515015,
0.36150962114334106,
0.47294026613235474,
-0.10657701641321182,
0.06873022764921188,
0.23050515353679657,
0.02876894176006317,
0.09786130487918854,
-0.5249248743057251,
-0.20238837599754333,
-0.0325954407453537,
-0.22536151111125946,
-0.39479416608810425,
0.310100793838501,
0.22217610478401184,
-0.06265753507614136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03715v1 | Clarify: Improving Model Robustness With Natural Language Corrections | 2024-02-06T05:11:38 | 2024-02-06T05:11:38 | Yoonho Lee, Michelle S. Lam, Helena Vasconcelos, Michael S. Bernstein, Chelsea Finn | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In supervised learning, models are trained to extract correlations from a
static dataset. This often leads to models that rely on high-level
misconceptions. To prevent such misconceptions, we must necessarily provide
additional information beyond the training data. Existing methods incorporate
forms of additional instance-level supervision, such as labels for spurious
features or additional labeled data from a balanced distribution. Such
strategies can become prohibitively costly for large-scale datasets since they
require additional annotation at a scale close to the original training data.
We hypothesize that targeted natural language feedback about a model's
misconceptions is a more efficient form of additional supervision. We introduce
Clarify, a novel interface and method for interactively correcting model
misconceptions. Through Clarify, users need only provide a short text
description to describe a model's consistent failure patterns. Then, in an
entirely automated way, we use such descriptions to improve the training
process by reweighting the training data or gathering additional targeted data.
Our user studies show that non-expert users can successfully describe model
misconceptions via Clarify, improving worst-group accuracy by an average of
17.1% in two datasets. Additionally, we use Clarify to find and rectify 31
novel hard subpopulations in the ImageNet dataset, improving minority-split
accuracy from 21.1% to 28.7%. | [
-0.29948753118515015,
-0.8646055459976196,
0.252677321434021,
-0.03722357004880905,
0.08679395914077759,
-0.16298215091228485,
-0.456580251455307,
-0.49103471636772156,
-0.17205673456192017,
0.47934526205062866,
-0.3892984390258789,
-0.5452499389648438,
-0.5289444327354431,
0.17400290071964264,
-0.38001352548599243,
1.003800868988037,
-0.088465616106987,
-0.0373554490506649,
-0.4539613127708435,
-0.16422420740127563,
-0.4097644090652466,
-0.3677005171775818,
-0.6391957402229309,
-0.34880727529525757,
0.4458867311477661,
0.49075397849082947,
0.9797300696372986,
0.8429778218269348,
0.62977534532547,
0.3515509068965912,
-0.1820097714662552,
0.5981524586677551,
-0.3518105745315552,
-0.11685729771852493,
-0.2679945230484009,
-0.7967327237129211,
-0.4004167914390564,
-0.27154383063316345,
0.349841833114624,
1.0742582082748413,
-0.2043481469154358,
-0.03619041293859482,
0.2863965630531311,
0.5394245982170105,
-0.8233413100242615,
0.10564722865819931,
-0.6318885684013367,
0.029742032289505005,
-0.10423403978347778,
-0.11578245460987091,
-0.6943880915641785,
-0.19149057567119598,
0.29675933718681335,
-0.9797754287719727,
0.8438883423805237,
0.08256866782903671,
1.1958857774734497,
0.5828319787979126,
-0.37515172362327576,
0.033784959465265274,
-0.8340379595756531,
0.6530856490135193,
-1.0076051950454712,
0.20495936274528503,
0.5857225060462952,
0.46143102645874023,
-0.23477263748645782,
-0.516362190246582,
-0.3491080105304718,
-0.23161983489990234,
-0.54091477394104,
-0.0662720650434494,
-0.21219119429588318,
0.2098972052335739,
0.6151943802833557,
0.27055299282073975,
0.024838225916028023,
0.17133580148220062,
-0.3357607126235962,
-0.5918347835540771,
0.6579641103744507,
-0.061724692583084106,
0.20459860563278198,
0.03875548392534256,
-0.09934896230697632,
-0.2586751878261566,
-0.6248179078102112,
0.04598572850227356,
0.49884310364723206,
0.6685333847999573,
-0.18543238937854767,
0.5126791596412659,
-0.28038930892944336,
0.6859245300292969,
0.28376778960227966,
-0.027323810383677483,
0.3605114221572876,
-0.24891425669193268,
-0.1473165601491928,
-0.09922883659601212,
0.3307039439678192,
0.6822588443756104,
0.06095443665981293,
-0.08791232109069824,
-0.18561914563179016,
0.011670046485960484,
0.2766738533973694,
-0.5605692863464355,
-0.5206140279769897,
0.06284715235233307,
-0.2850126028060913,
-0.14141643047332764,
0.06916342675685883,
-0.6384966969490051,
-0.6150708794593811,
-0.599526584148407,
0.3938857913017273,
-0.4494602084159851,
-0.23000149428844452,
0.13199889659881592,
-0.20257870852947235,
-0.0852271318435669,
0.7992084622383118,
-0.8440657258033752,
0.24057544767856598,
0.5070752501487732,
0.6121847629547119,
0.23137827217578888,
-0.11518839746713638,
-0.5752193331718445,
0.3322647213935852,
-0.39528918266296387,
0.7115760445594788,
-0.3251498341560364,
-0.06257504969835281,
-0.005766186397522688,
-0.00008404965774388984,
-0.05483679845929146,
-0.6980336308479309,
0.6493785977363586,
-0.09244547039270401,
0.40782052278518677,
-0.26963797211647034,
-0.6713053584098816,
-0.36281657218933105,
0.44717103242874146,
-0.7340928912162781,
0.9522046446800232,
-0.0794871374964714,
-1.1971681118011475,
0.5837888121604919,
-0.5098524689674377,
-0.3515048027038574,
-0.20821695029735565,
0.09088414162397385,
-0.5535252094268799,
0.03794143348932266,
0.585947573184967,
0.19081784784793854,
0.15393999218940735,
0.4489324688911438,
-0.5367613434791565,
-0.04229888692498207,
0.02467593178153038,
-0.3886931836605072,
0.49373066425323486,
0.03305293619632721,
-0.22687683999538422,
0.23433427512645721,
-0.9760724902153015,
-0.07161851227283478,
-0.264622300863266,
-0.3186497986316681,
-0.49294862151145935,
0.011019870638847351,
-0.20091859996318817,
-0.21177975833415985,
-0.0036932791117578745,
-0.2292478233575821,
0.141942098736763,
-0.49805888533592224,
0.31600499153137207,
0.5469111800193787,
0.042194392532110214,
0.45708632469177246,
-0.4197985529899597,
0.2258879542350769,
0.3051089346408844,
0.33386871218681335,
-0.37913134694099426,
-0.3531484007835388,
-1.1306849718093872,
-0.14446894824504852,
0.3001229465007782,
0.560688853263855,
-0.9490677714347839,
0.2841309607028961,
-0.11530692875385284,
-0.3485511839389801,
-0.6346359252929688,
0.5184436440467834,
0.4809022545814514,
1.0988168716430664,
0.5967156887054443,
-0.18358388543128967,
-0.8651083707809448,
-1.1112533807754517,
-0.38535764813423157,
-0.2937203347682953,
-0.17675048112869263,
0.05194085091352463,
0.39148056507110596,
-0.43196025490760803,
1.052398920059204,
-0.21732567250728607,
-0.1495843380689621,
-0.039066512137651443,
0.40768498182296753,
-0.04096127673983574,
0.6330716013908386,
0.3411851227283478,
-0.7657383680343628,
-0.2522716522216797,
0.00935517717152834,
-0.7032356262207031,
-0.041333772242069244,
-0.23247770965099335,
-0.18178173899650574,
0.13336914777755737,
0.5741204619407654,
-0.45528891682624817,
0.5027823448181152,
0.037989772856235504,
-0.02445315010845661,
0.3382931053638458,
-0.32385677099227905,
-0.02389083243906498,
-0.9602258205413818,
-0.013674229383468628,
0.2927398681640625,
-0.10827086120843887,
-0.6599821448326111,
-0.05654777213931084,
0.19175095856189728,
0.43658533692359924,
-0.224661186337471,
0.18754792213439941,
-0.2899805009365082,
0.44707074761390686,
-0.038138795644044876,
0.11769367754459381,
0.13840773701667786,
0.2592301666736603,
0.031037040054798126,
0.40225544571876526,
0.6397468447685242,
-0.6287654042243958,
0.25929194688796997,
0.35583046078681946,
-0.0016105032991617918,
0.6930176615715027,
-0.5139774084091187,
0.014267070218920708,
-0.3703662157058716,
0.3220756947994232,
-0.8340703845024109,
-0.8139299750328064,
0.17270980775356293,
-0.3844676911830902,
0.2983831763267517,
-0.3471119999885559,
-0.37193453311920166,
-0.3932552635669708,
-0.13548363745212555,
0.15335868299007416,
0.07084067165851593,
-0.7437983751296997,
0.6230295896530151,
0.137140154838562,
0.279278963804245,
-0.673359751701355,
-0.9346365928649902,
0.2361365258693695,
-0.2446427047252655,
-0.7008482813835144,
0.023597775027155876,
0.07832914590835571,
-0.32650676369667053,
-0.04078337177634239,
-0.1588977724313736,
-0.45952853560447693,
0.20082080364227295,
0.2619710862636566,
0.30559828877449036,
-0.11706230789422989,
0.5532486438751221,
0.008335994556546211,
0.06694376468658447,
-0.09769035130739212,
-0.07892109453678131,
-0.12001798301935196,
-0.2970787584781647,
-0.39864441752433777,
-0.5208003520965576,
0.11061857640743256,
0.12056227028369904,
-0.10648741573095322,
0.5978550314903259,
0.6105189323425293,
-0.7408332824707031,
-0.2609204351902008,
-0.5512321591377258,
-0.461229145526886,
-0.47558027505874634,
0.3023677170276642,
-0.0614534467458725,
-0.7058787941932678,
0.44246238470077515,
0.12998397648334503,
0.21746401488780975,
0.43364301323890686,
0.04223908856511116,
-0.17077912390232086,
1.1787347793579102,
0.9419981241226196,
0.23551581799983978,
0.1416950523853302,
-0.031724631786346436,
0.30668261647224426,
-0.5076179504394531,
-0.3703860342502594,
-0.5686818957328796,
-0.2390865832567215,
-0.28137797117233276,
-0.2898709774017334,
-0.015931852161884308,
0.34521085023880005,
-0.022178376093506813,
0.4277576208114624,
-0.43974941968917847,
0.3253447115421295,
0.7070035338401794,
0.3354761600494385,
0.356083482503891,
0.08085132390260696,
-0.06409843266010284,
-0.29980048537254333,
-0.7041478157043457,
-0.6899336576461792,
1.0358614921569824,
0.5051116347312927,
0.9330359697341919,
0.0693168044090271,
0.5485244393348694,
0.09392786771059036,
0.6836085319519043,
-0.5563634634017944,
0.16206610202789307,
0.05335985869169235,
-0.6798269748687744,
-0.1384851634502411,
-0.683853030204773,
-0.5860846042633057,
-0.1329541802406311,
-0.48087406158447266,
-0.5005955696105957,
0.21892820298671722,
0.9388622045516968,
-0.5287278294563293,
0.4048612713813782,
-1.1335200071334839,
0.7971895337104797,
-0.129983052611351,
-0.4091936945915222,
0.10020312666893005,
-0.8012551069259644,
0.4457898736000061,
-0.0013390234671533108,
0.44883641600608826,
0.08152654767036438,
0.032427508383989334,
0.35676151514053345,
-0.8041464686393738,
1.2496800422668457,
-0.2801111936569214,
-0.24198274314403534,
0.1909535676240921,
-0.12750355899333954,
0.4081735908985138,
-0.009674583561718464,
-0.07022999227046967,
-0.14306668937206268,
-0.15702535212039948,
-0.23334354162216187,
-0.8253937363624573,
0.19381605088710785,
-0.5221426486968994,
-0.5666248798370361,
0.13779617846012115,
-0.6986569762229919,
-0.4274866580963135,
0.045289743691682816,
0.34763503074645996,
0.5296887159347534,
0.17192186415195465,
0.24014946818351746,
0.7888218760490417,
-0.05038079991936684,
0.09084650874137878,
0.3999369442462921,
-0.09581219404935837,
-0.30604231357574463,
0.5400381684303284,
-0.15482790768146515,
0.4084238111972809,
0.4234941601753235,
0.10260201245546341,
-0.3114701807498932,
-0.5323113799095154,
-0.30536186695098877,
0.0037837873678654432,
-0.8616743087768555,
-0.2798905074596405,
-0.5851829648017883,
0.10501843690872192,
-0.4958314597606659,
0.060810890048742294,
-0.34217554330825806,
-0.4862171709537506,
-0.26967164874076843,
-0.28475284576416016,
0.5214717388153076,
0.46595126390457153,
-0.299418568611145,
0.6959754824638367,
-0.6790459752082825,
0.14958162605762482,
0.2728877365589142,
0.4073278307914734,
-0.1380232274532318,
-0.7303351759910583,
-0.2687276005744934,
0.2925662100315094,
-0.16350339353084564,
-0.6757778525352478,
0.16501210629940033,
0.5272217988967896,
0.5025326013565063,
0.6401160955429077,
0.16659916937351227,
0.9098690748214722,
-0.2149105966091156,
0.5058065056800842,
0.2810044586658478,
-0.8927266597747803,
0.7966057062149048,
-0.3081359565258026,
0.14325645565986633,
0.8361377716064453,
0.208390474319458,
-0.47241950035095215,
-0.6223548650741577,
-0.7530061602592468,
-0.9442740082740784,
0.5070695877075195,
0.11192755401134491,
0.01798144355416298,
-0.0377979651093483,
0.5395560264587402,
0.03302725777029991,
0.1388314664363861,
-0.7823969125747681,
-0.30891335010528564,
-0.312120258808136,
-0.43310269713401794,
0.0559481680393219,
-0.08186756819486618,
-0.49148428440093994,
-0.27789872884750366,
0.9401946663856506,
-0.42827343940734863,
-0.3262327313423157,
0.27308762073516846,
-0.20203232765197754,
-0.1384590119123459,
0.27427178621292114,
0.4475570619106293,
0.6673853993415833,
-0.19502604007720947,
0.5151311159133911,
0.337237685918808,
-0.32287389039993286,
-0.0810157060623169,
0.10944142937660217,
-0.4427793025970459,
0.3241858184337616,
0.5847919583320618,
0.8094756603240967,
0.20995177328586578,
-0.5730196237564087,
0.4738207757472992,
-0.23574626445770264,
-0.17397154867649078,
0.011456158012151718,
0.270307719707489,
-0.009895849041640759,
0.006130990572273731,
0.15861938893795013,
0.6514491438865662,
0.21949045360088348,
-0.21087151765823364,
0.3745512366294861,
0.15282487869262695,
-0.5881539583206177,
-0.12429235875606537,
0.664520800113678,
0.3739966154098511,
-0.08329891413450241,
0.5109399557113647,
-0.09376473724842072,
-0.31226661801338196,
0.6152679324150085,
0.3762862980365753,
0.5709449052810669,
-0.09181936085224152,
0.19888022541999817,
0.7604570984840393,
0.5917620062828064,
-0.4384775757789612,
-0.19394004344940186,
0.09965304285287857,
-0.7367410063743591,
-0.5019969344139099,
-0.21406729519367218,
-0.5899892449378967,
0.07065173238515854,
-0.9685998558998108,
0.3428114950656891,
-0.6399747133255005,
-0.36694663763046265,
-0.021123377606272697,
-0.44795212149620056,
-0.43985602259635925,
0.29724520444869995,
0.11217803508043289,
1.0674328804016113,
-1.0694243907928467,
0.47379758954048157,
0.9008678197860718,
-0.5341227650642395,
-1.0957025289535522,
-0.0674135759472847,
0.2093595415353775,
-0.2912535071372986,
0.28924933075904846,
0.4796755909919739,
0.12756891548633575,
-0.36394640803337097,
-0.8351956009864807,
-0.7974081635475159,
0.6462580561637878,
0.6571985483169556,
-0.6629621982574463,
0.006416958756744862,
0.009795439429581165,
0.5936218500137329,
-0.22088004648685455,
0.2904232144355774,
0.5311894416809082,
0.5483902096748352,
0.06942806392908096,
-0.8877605199813843,
-0.06621573120355606,
-0.4218587279319763,
0.0044985623098909855,
0.02917245589196682,
-0.05475103482604027,
0.47320929169654846,
-0.5644636750221252,
-0.3272923231124878,
0.0628584772348404,
0.7226905226707458,
-0.004275167360901833,
0.3897392451763153,
0.6787160634994507,
0.7908074855804443,
1.2498157024383545,
-0.24248956143856049,
0.8129228949546814,
0.13232029974460602,
0.4926290810108185,
1.7113405466079712,
-0.02091399021446705,
0.7140123248100281,
0.5507163405418396,
-0.05877763777971268,
0.47127655148506165,
0.7828954458236694,
-0.14933893084526062,
0.1864103227853775,
0.1347893327474594,
-0.14627499878406525,
-0.5983324646949768,
-0.14506685733795166,
-0.3354569971561432,
0.09639173746109009,
0.3534103035926819,
-0.2108999788761139,
-0.4950621724128723,
-0.0164505448192358,
0.09989029914140701,
0.4947373867034912,
-0.22590038180351257,
0.6683427691459656,
-0.21940289437770844,
-0.6976855993270874,
0.5449343323707581,
-0.022157104685902596,
0.6717973947525024,
-0.23459629714488983,
-0.19674305617809296,
-0.34735769033432007,
0.4515394866466522,
-0.6813879609107971,
-0.42996007204055786,
0.465434193611145,
0.029229486361145973,
-0.39663979411125183,
0.16945473849773407,
0.5636996030807495,
-0.5461529493331909,
-0.623698353767395,
0.018674442544579506,
0.13054093718528748,
-0.034350428730249405,
0.009964533150196075,
-0.5907667279243469,
-0.07547593861818314,
0.22246935963630676,
0.3812253177165985,
-0.4216502904891968,
0.42630860209465027,
-0.22883519530296326,
0.8886352181434631,
0.5474746227264404,
-0.17364946007728577,
0.25993746519088745,
0.29575949907302856,
0.6873461008071899,
-0.27214905619621277,
-0.1777123212814331,
-0.6265210509300232,
0.6208486557006836,
-0.47546640038490295,
-0.2892976999282837,
0.8676772117614746,
0.4123198688030243,
1.1691852807998657,
-0.025342851877212524,
0.9276748299598694,
-0.0005553289665840566,
0.9020103812217712,
-0.3275958001613617,
0.46580830216407776,
-0.35985347628593445,
0.5007190108299255,
-0.08483021706342697,
-0.5477998852729797,
-0.671290397644043,
0.570946991443634,
-0.4239712655544281,
0.06684219837188721,
0.4008881747722626,
0.9397239685058594,
-0.2061903178691864,
0.04370929300785065,
-0.11372077465057373,
0.4042840600013733,
0.4471242427825928,
0.3514121174812317,
0.7614981532096863,
-0.4501698613166809,
0.635551929473877,
-0.5944607853889465,
-0.1837785691022873,
-0.20702427625656128,
-1.0744848251342773,
-0.9419912099838257,
-0.1277044415473938,
-0.8884689807891846,
-0.3463824391365051,
-0.006605342496186495,
0.8316234946250916,
0.8534719944000244,
-1.1005624532699585,
0.2336416393518448,
-0.2985953390598297,
0.1146884337067604,
-0.18986916542053223,
-0.24303258955478668,
0.15333092212677002,
-0.6866147518157959,
-0.5803824067115784,
0.18284189701080322,
0.038569629192352295,
0.23504911363124847,
0.049663227051496506,
-0.1136474460363388,
0.008761144243180752,
-0.12378083914518356,
0.10675927996635437,
0.3784419894218445,
-0.8029006719589233,
-0.4577051103115082,
-0.3241881728172302,
-0.21075370907783508,
0.180718332529068,
0.44753190875053406,
-0.4855186939239502,
0.7884044051170349,
0.15309590101242065,
0.7541624903678894,
0.11033958941698074,
0.14781345427036285,
0.7254985570907593,
-0.9447746872901917,
0.21132034063339233,
0.01017831452190876,
0.41825053095817566,
0.9782488346099854,
-0.43004310131073,
0.499329537153244,
0.267032653093338,
-0.047845080494880676,
-0.8365673422813416,
0.16520409286022186,
-0.8155753016471863,
-0.06880360841751099,
0.8975847363471985,
-0.2942483723163605,
-0.31547728180885315,
-0.3381393253803253,
-0.43967175483703613,
0.3157379925251007,
-0.19299378991127014,
0.9707125425338745,
0.6626711487770081,
0.1767476499080658,
-0.12376940995454788,
-0.5652500987052917,
0.6354151368141174,
0.5938838124275208,
-0.9559343457221985,
0.19920945167541504,
0.8167181611061096,
0.28693753480911255,
0.3076072931289673,
0.023609306663274765,
0.024262798950076103,
0.3301052153110504,
-0.06124555319547653,
0.2600962817668915,
-0.1289409101009369,
-0.2874417006969452,
-0.13282056152820587,
-0.06555499136447906,
0.1423279196023941,
-0.03271205350756645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03710v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03710v1 | Listen, Chat, and Edit: Text-Guided Soundscape Modification for Enhanced Auditory Experience | 2024-02-06T05:05:38 | 2024-02-06T05:05:38 | Xilin Jiang, Cong Han, Yinghao Aaron Li, Nima Mesgarani | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | In daily life, we encounter a variety of sounds, both desirable and
undesirable, with limited control over their presence and volume. Our work
introduces "Listen, Chat, and Edit" (LCE), a novel multimodal sound mixture
editor that modifies each sound source in a mixture based on user-provided text
instructions. LCE distinguishes itself with a user-friendly chat interface and
its unique ability to edit multiple sound sources simultaneously within a
mixture, without needing to separate them. Users input open-vocabulary text
prompts, which are interpreted by a large language model to create a semantic
filter for editing the sound mixture. The system then decomposes the mixture
into its components, applies the semantic filter, and reassembles it into the
desired output. We developed a 160-hour dataset with over 100k mixtures,
including speech and various audio sources, along with text prompts for diverse
editing tasks like extraction, removal, and volume control. Our experiments
demonstrate significant improvements in signal quality across all editing tasks
and robust performance in zero-shot scenarios with varying numbers and types of
sound sources. | [
-0.5201110243797302,
-0.8534135818481445,
0.5686184763908386,
0.5282076001167297,
0.06325271725654602,
0.09920009225606918,
-0.4001232087612152,
-0.8485850095748901,
0.43899592757225037,
0.5028476119041443,
-1.082310438156128,
-0.6765808463096619,
-0.34794881939888,
-0.006095352116972208,
-0.4510698914527893,
0.7330725193023682,
0.3156726658344269,
-0.07542388141155243,
0.23205852508544922,
-0.3101217746734619,
-1.133581519126892,
-0.04753381758928299,
-0.8135369420051575,
0.08471640944480896,
0.5423967838287354,
0.2771972417831421,
0.7847302556037903,
0.37109145522117615,
0.15464714169502258,
0.3469907343387604,
-0.6812818646430969,
0.3207000195980072,
-0.41377297043800354,
0.45496514439582825,
-0.13428735733032227,
-0.32929107546806335,
-0.6160614490509033,
-0.0542546883225441,
0.26125961542129517,
0.5396685600280762,
-0.1522766351699829,
-0.13988947868347168,
0.18402940034866333,
0.4041469693183899,
-0.5155770778656006,
-0.19886377453804016,
-0.6111317873001099,
0.09408652782440186,
0.014013048261404037,
-0.47909265756607056,
-0.4172349274158478,
0.018583502620458603,
0.07538866251707077,
-1.1992006301879883,
-0.05876140296459198,
-0.1643742024898529,
0.1168014407157898,
0.4211941957473755,
-0.3011191487312317,
-0.44622576236724854,
-0.9036338925361633,
0.7208359241485596,
-0.45333370566368103,
0.7204151749610901,
0.3468800187110901,
0.22127382457256317,
-0.39245879650115967,
-0.56396484375,
-0.6969731450080872,
0.05802274867892265,
0.21309445798397064,
0.3318880498409271,
-0.06329883635044098,
0.45352551341056824,
0.0447254478931427,
0.2987297773361206,
-0.4139283299446106,
-0.09985857456922531,
-0.13340789079666138,
-0.5833966732025146,
0.350132554769516,
0.13763859868049622,
0.8787646293640137,
0.033661387860774994,
-0.036223914474248886,
-0.21312732994556427,
-0.2895459532737732,
0.07912761718034744,
0.4766557514667511,
0.19888043403625488,
-0.0924714133143425,
0.5359960198402405,
-0.11416196078062057,
0.8993567824363708,
0.029726797714829445,
-0.4901540279388428,
0.167765274643898,
-0.5918102264404297,
-0.2457338273525238,
0.37810656428337097,
0.5333157777786255,
0.564028263092041,
-0.40230026841163635,
0.2040443867444992,
-0.1661810427904129,
0.1037517860531807,
-0.04192304238677025,
-0.45300692319869995,
-0.34919941425323486,
0.5344891548156738,
-0.40079057216644287,
-0.4152112901210785,
-0.2678845524787903,
-0.7634955644607544,
-0.7228047847747803,
-0.5653473138809204,
0.6229992508888245,
-0.6279176473617554,
-0.10325191915035248,
0.43843507766723633,
-0.6296530961990356,
-0.436006098985672,
0.6044830679893494,
-0.8038237690925598,
0.2634233236312866,
0.4971868097782135,
0.8722540736198425,
-0.08404674381017685,
-0.13554111123085022,
-0.6795259714126587,
0.28107261657714844,
-0.1514991670846939,
0.9042757749557495,
-0.8174722194671631,
-1.0596213340759277,
-0.3239867687225342,
-0.4007137417793274,
0.21759457886219025,
-0.555814802646637,
0.8102038502693176,
-0.35022783279418945,
0.5819177031517029,
0.041609279811382294,
-0.5178099870681763,
0.17650271952152252,
-0.26107126474380493,
-0.5682584643363953,
1.003362774848938,
-0.05026235058903694,
-0.6051464080810547,
0.44851723313331604,
-1.2213249206542969,
-0.2406913936138153,
-0.152626633644104,
0.10776656866073608,
0.18950815498828888,
0.00680540082976222,
0.45769810676574707,
-0.3236468732357025,
0.5954506993293762,
-0.0028494999278336763,
-0.18223662674427032,
-0.5393515825271606,
0.4759975075721741,
-0.6038267612457275,
0.7422129511833191,
0.36424967646598816,
0.12248937785625458,
0.6331197023391724,
-0.9841606020927429,
-0.26332858204841614,
-0.4827973246574402,
-0.4862765371799469,
-0.4087044596672058,
0.20038862526416779,
0.7738867402076721,
0.13594956696033478,
0.12449587881565094,
-0.8907208442687988,
-0.05546288937330246,
-0.3335249722003937,
0.6229032278060913,
0.747869074344635,
0.27738964557647705,
0.47415822744369507,
-0.4810315668582916,
0.34507882595062256,
0.13863292336463928,
0.2546229362487793,
-0.6299960017204285,
-0.44693440198898315,
-0.41243499517440796,
-0.7685914039611816,
0.3561604917049408,
0.7154337167739868,
-0.6199651956558228,
0.33798888325691223,
0.07322082668542862,
-0.39841657876968384,
-0.8681296706199646,
0.23442442715168,
-0.2974167466163635,
0.48885276913642883,
0.5162896513938904,
-0.2007349580526352,
-0.7906134724617004,
-0.5121352076530457,
-0.49148833751678467,
-0.08383074402809143,
-0.49751994013786316,
0.5776440501213074,
-0.2206954061985016,
-0.407755047082901,
1.1872241497039795,
-0.5989560484886169,
-0.36103323101997375,
0.0990755707025528,
-0.038986340165138245,
0.2359752506017685,
0.5557666420936584,
0.4297029376029968,
-0.5665848255157471,
-0.33683496713638306,
-0.11013448983430862,
-0.34043118357658386,
-0.5687050223350525,
-0.39748501777648926,
-0.3467796742916107,
-0.32008498907089233,
0.6066977977752686,
-0.4206797778606415,
0.16442009806632996,
0.6952260136604309,
-0.46641287207603455,
0.44394975900650024,
-0.03535421937704086,
0.41399291157722473,
-0.9736098051071167,
-0.35412678122520447,
-0.12877674400806427,
-0.30326536297798157,
-0.690857470035553,
-0.11788956820964813,
-0.3281470537185669,
-0.41164636611938477,
-0.5615315437316895,
0.3580496609210968,
-0.08066178858280182,
0.1585468351840973,
-0.4404617249965668,
0.5191158056259155,
0.15103411674499512,
0.2568754255771637,
-0.03239469602704048,
0.7881139516830444,
0.8036343455314636,
-0.45194172859191895,
0.2329566925764084,
0.5110365748405457,
-0.40559259057044983,
0.894593358039856,
-0.6227262616157532,
0.33796724677085876,
-0.16542977094650269,
0.6354215145111084,
-1.0468010902404785,
-0.22736211121082306,
0.1050332561135292,
-0.3303041458129883,
-0.17952655255794525,
0.08841241896152496,
-0.3701340854167938,
0.3306271731853485,
-0.40727680921554565,
0.4453229606151581,
0.18466123938560486,
-0.6026954650878906,
0.7530267238616943,
0.5751855969429016,
-0.5071336030960083,
-0.1487084925174713,
-0.6960689425468445,
0.4041115641593933,
-0.1925337314605713,
-0.742327868938446,
0.5367039442062378,
-0.658278226852417,
-0.2642543315887451,
0.014113967306911945,
-0.22626082599163055,
-0.43422165513038635,
-0.06831426173448563,
0.36898916959762573,
0.40814632177352905,
-0.02241642400622368,
0.20661260187625885,
0.4601224958896637,
-0.06711266934871674,
-0.268500417470932,
-0.1863763928413391,
0.237043559551239,
0.5151194334030151,
-0.35240212082862854,
-0.7785911560058594,
0.6889259219169617,
0.5833021402359009,
-0.2960893213748932,
0.11896898597478867,
0.6985763311386108,
-0.18792283535003662,
-0.037418000400066376,
-0.34922537207603455,
-0.31188586354255676,
-0.5626036524772644,
0.32526835799217224,
-0.21373096108436584,
-1.3288452625274658,
0.4152858555316925,
-0.15012124180793762,
0.4431459903717041,
0.05117305740714073,
0.19777412712574005,
-0.4709944427013397,
0.7853381633758545,
0.41724807024002075,
0.14188095927238464,
0.9459437727928162,
0.39361587166786194,
-0.015936244279146194,
-0.7076149582862854,
0.044979698956012726,
-0.4979289174079895,
-0.5154464840888977,
-0.5708690881729126,
-0.3382630944252014,
0.757509708404541,
-0.268027126789093,
0.15378603339195251,
0.1997440606355667,
-0.6137474775314331,
0.8173128366470337,
0.5663658380508423,
0.6163493990898132,
0.5444223284721375,
-0.25612056255340576,
0.17506062984466553,
-0.33039772510528564,
-0.4582987427711487,
-0.0717863216996193,
0.8293171525001526,
0.30815282464027405,
0.6711645126342773,
0.20396870374679565,
0.6448521018028259,
0.46092596650123596,
-0.1924062967300415,
-0.766853392124176,
0.4198409914970398,
0.010315515100955963,
-0.6950253844261169,
-0.45621368288993835,
-0.1488550901412964,
-0.6596987843513489,
0.4802725613117218,
-0.6869239807128906,
-0.6751065254211426,
0.3417362570762634,
0.16690659523010254,
-0.40198996663093567,
0.0009680991061031818,
-0.7445691227912903,
0.4961194694042206,
0.23755083978176117,
-0.003881958080455661,
-0.7197792530059814,
-0.32028988003730774,
0.1561872512102127,
-0.199702188372612,
0.761385440826416,
-0.16552436351776123,
-0.11596029996871948,
0.4502229690551758,
-0.18604964017868042,
0.7531669735908508,
-0.17045867443084717,
-0.2478274554014206,
0.37378087639808655,
0.3642130196094513,
0.10749197006225586,
0.3555855453014374,
-0.10231756418943405,
0.0969340056180954,
0.32899007201194763,
-0.062126047909259796,
-0.6131226420402527,
0.7866771221160889,
-0.70176762342453,
-0.13645607233047485,
0.11214292049407959,
-0.9596377611160278,
-0.5275538563728333,
0.1982475221157074,
-0.014465853571891785,
0.8326139450073242,
-0.35791099071502686,
0.38011667132377625,
0.6831740736961365,
-0.6834750771522522,
0.4999922811985016,
0.4041278660297394,
-0.36268964409828186,
-0.5496267676353455,
0.6576588749885559,
-0.2408776879310608,
0.16693386435508728,
0.30024319887161255,
0.25066426396369934,
-0.20330968499183655,
-0.36641374230384827,
-0.24693168699741364,
-0.28370097279548645,
-0.7347443103790283,
0.28880441188812256,
-0.7962876558303833,
0.10277414321899414,
-0.17200346291065216,
-0.3023476004600525,
-0.3693513572216034,
-0.5156537294387817,
-0.20367953181266785,
0.10920730233192444,
0.42791616916656494,
0.473193496465683,
-0.37812888622283936,
0.5175419449806213,
-0.8391613960266113,
0.7756872177124023,
0.5840177536010742,
0.4832793176174164,
-0.6171109080314636,
-0.5032992362976074,
-0.1298002302646637,
0.22789366543293,
-0.16711044311523438,
-1.0765565633773804,
0.1716291904449463,
0.3941768407821655,
0.34664052724838257,
-0.2031257301568985,
-0.07686441391706467,
0.8414053320884705,
-0.4024887681007385,
1.0002050399780273,
0.2046654224395752,
-1.3288211822509766,
0.6602876782417297,
-0.45994582772254944,
0.5761853456497192,
0.5042250156402588,
-0.5058861374855042,
-1.0509119033813477,
-0.6675230860710144,
-0.2794533669948578,
-0.8212651610374451,
0.7584878206253052,
0.24749286472797394,
0.2546992897987366,
0.21960513293743134,
-0.010313536040484905,
0.10545831173658371,
0.1986999660730362,
-0.37469324469566345,
-0.2319910079240799,
-0.5031511187553406,
-0.37460920214653015,
0.15623196959495544,
-0.314491331577301,
-0.21821622550487518,
-0.39319780468940735,
0.6289615631103516,
0.10502128303050995,
0.15225659310817719,
0.4230306148529053,
-0.03658246248960495,
-0.10960058122873306,
0.5433791279792786,
0.8301424384117126,
0.4214600622653961,
-0.04903584346175194,
-0.03874039277434349,
0.3652370870113373,
-0.6345593929290771,
-0.10771948099136353,
-0.3095945417881012,
-0.08984039723873138,
0.35696011781692505,
0.18610335886478424,
0.9921783208847046,
0.7539272904396057,
-0.8454697132110596,
0.09397272020578384,
-0.3016144335269928,
-0.3027459979057312,
-0.10664580017328262,
0.4829503297805786,
0.28681111335754395,
0.005052028689533472,
0.10355241596698761,
0.5339850187301636,
0.580359697341919,
-0.3795108497142792,
0.1790185570716858,
-0.07881913334131241,
-0.49753475189208984,
-0.07484796643257141,
0.8573599457740784,
0.36809220910072327,
-0.4114994406700134,
0.2460860013961792,
0.44419097900390625,
0.21657338738441467,
0.14368343353271484,
0.23868399858474731,
0.8640850782394409,
-0.15393738448619843,
0.11882351338863373,
0.11110048741102219,
0.18387797474861145,
0.49442100524902344,
0.3170783817768097,
-0.21047300100326538,
-0.6924576163291931,
-0.6684449911117554,
-0.35969191789627075,
-0.7726258039474487,
0.25967642664909363,
-0.4061962962150574,
0.2813745439052582,
-0.27057498693466187,
-0.18022167682647705,
0.3415096700191498,
-0.5745255947113037,
-0.3464369475841522,
0.18751120567321777,
-0.03518379479646683,
0.9361133575439453,
-0.6177937984466553,
0.5001007914543152,
0.5600241422653198,
0.12983576953411102,
-0.5397199392318726,
0.02222527004778385,
0.350028932094574,
-0.2776453495025635,
0.04768149554729462,
-0.16310200095176697,
-0.20955446362495422,
-0.066069595515728,
-0.6434618234634399,
-0.586558997631073,
0.7349375486373901,
0.4231255054473877,
-0.5952330827713013,
0.42779868841171265,
-0.08472216874361038,
0.48822709918022156,
0.11324989795684814,
0.3864581882953644,
0.5744917392730713,
0.7816718816757202,
0.2426619678735733,
-1.109296441078186,
-0.5915179252624512,
-0.13117782771587372,
-0.04071527719497681,
0.042588479816913605,
-0.27173447608947754,
0.45269152522087097,
0.30566105246543884,
-0.09153762459754944,
-0.260524183511734,
0.6473286151885986,
0.2024310976266861,
0.24200215935707092,
0.9719627499580383,
0.17646966874599457,
0.709417998790741,
-0.07478829473257065,
0.5336065292358398,
-0.6269246339797974,
-0.10318344086408615,
1.4140301942825317,
-0.08234909921884537,
0.7272668480873108,
0.5956006050109863,
-0.06556182354688644,
0.48922231793403625,
0.5913923978805542,
0.5148769617080688,
0.6460030674934387,
-0.21818427741527557,
-0.926364004611969,
-0.2518253028392792,
-0.28351831436157227,
-0.26822325587272644,
0.7218562364578247,
0.3073100745677948,
0.09169337898492813,
-0.18485990166664124,
0.29326966404914856,
-0.22447717189788818,
0.2671729326248169,
-0.14067314565181732,
0.9224743247032166,
-0.08524006605148315,
-0.2585185468196869,
-0.06901358813047409,
-0.00021084790932945907,
0.8440022468566895,
-0.5415452122688293,
-0.14607790112495422,
0.05269893631339073,
-0.21949678659439087,
-0.4115835130214691,
-0.9572069644927979,
0.4780994951725006,
-0.013752445578575134,
-0.1685320883989334,
-0.4494694173336029,
0.8722816109657288,
-0.6173763871192932,
-0.24699823558330536,
0.17749181389808655,
0.2273683398962021,
-0.23769403994083405,
-0.2795696556568146,
-0.569468080997467,
0.4722786247730255,
0.14291177690029144,
-0.20980709791183472,
0.11425042152404785,
0.5606970191001892,
0.2901364862918854,
0.47407302260398865,
1.1604946851730347,
0.19395503401756287,
0.01525386143475771,
0.13893891870975494,
0.6612048149108887,
-0.5187240242958069,
-0.9333652853965759,
-0.5546584725379944,
0.6923251152038574,
-0.07818630337715149,
-0.4079180955886841,
0.4398679733276367,
0.4018360376358032,
0.6079795360565186,
-0.15618062019348145,
0.94575434923172,
0.1299259215593338,
0.6557545065879822,
-0.426765501499176,
0.5412148237228394,
-0.20426690578460693,
0.2256508618593216,
-0.5335965156555176,
-0.8372951149940491,
-0.2439744621515274,
0.4140068292617798,
0.3629455268383026,
-0.3748554587364197,
0.39061272144317627,
1.0471930503845215,
-0.056052789092063904,
0.5921293497085571,
0.41402846574783325,
0.2784515619277954,
0.5525314211845398,
0.22244103252887726,
0.6586188077926636,
-0.2130679339170456,
0.4845380187034607,
-0.3651045262813568,
-0.25989046692848206,
0.09461547434329987,
-0.7575082182884216,
-0.42416223883628845,
-0.4842640459537506,
-0.37065133452415466,
0.011515864171087742,
-0.03975996747612953,
1.014257788658142,
0.7655038833618164,
-0.7160579562187195,
-0.21956267952919006,
0.06150761991739273,
0.06608514487743378,
-0.29829102754592896,
-0.24946390092372894,
-0.0643547922372818,
-0.1513148546218872,
-0.8923133015632629,
1.3470486402511597,
0.6022812724113464,
-0.04970487579703331,
0.00031862829928286374,
-0.0794968381524086,
0.19931244850158691,
0.3515269160270691,
0.8624497056007385,
0.031258516013622284,
-0.4682701528072357,
-0.4741656184196472,
-0.10503976047039032,
-0.0563487745821476,
0.1389009952545166,
0.5310435891151428,
-0.6477313041687012,
1.151691198348999,
0.558843195438385,
0.4004010856151581,
0.3482380509376526,
-0.19002270698547363,
0.48065900802612305,
-0.863073468208313,
0.39657214283943176,
-0.09986694157123566,
0.1608341485261917,
0.15762203931808472,
-0.24954631924629211,
0.1917193979024887,
0.19580689072608948,
-0.44266167283058167,
-0.6948100328445435,
0.024927983060479164,
-1.5436561107635498,
-0.3594767451286316,
1.019309163093567,
0.3467361330986023,
0.17452310025691986,
-0.377302885055542,
-1.2401572465896606,
0.3536713719367981,
-0.6215555667877197,
0.6332520842552185,
0.9519730806350708,
-0.2523548901081085,
-0.10943160951137543,
-0.7678235173225403,
0.4127548038959503,
0.2348126620054245,
-0.7052916288375854,
-0.15777844190597534,
0.9903053045272827,
0.22992295026779175,
-0.06256797164678574,
0.7636215686798096,
-0.11917688697576523,
0.4226192533969879,
-0.0289914570748806,
0.11005707830190659,
-0.193863183259964,
-0.13914358615875244,
-0.2521389126777649,
0.22022280097007751,
-0.08686649799346924,
-0.4852526783943176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05133v1 | Personalized Language Modeling from Personalized Human Feedback | 2024-02-06T04:18:58 | 2024-02-06T04:18:58 | Xinyu Li, Zachary C. Lipton, Liu Leqi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is the current dominating
framework to fine-tune large language models to better align with human
preferences. However, the underlying premise of algorithms developed under this
framework can be problematic when user preferences encoded in human feedback
are diverse. In this work, we aim to address this problem by developing methods
for building personalized language models. We first formally introduce the task
of learning from personalized human feedback and explain why vanilla RLHF can
be problematic in this context. We then propose a general Personalized-RLHF
(P-RLHF) framework, which requires one to jointly learn a user model and a
language (or reward) model. The user model takes in user information and
outputs user representations. Its structure encodes our assumptions about user
preferences underlying the feedback data. We develop new learning objectives
for personalized reward modeling and personalized Direct Preference
Optimization. To demonstrate the efficacy of our method, we test it on
real-world text summarization data with annotated preferences and annotator
information. We fine-tune GPT-J 6B to obtain personalized language (and reward)
models, which outperform non-personalized models in terms of aligning with
individual preferences. | [
-0.36140790581703186,
-0.8786278367042542,
0.44073769450187683,
0.10940392315387726,
-0.00006259246583795175,
0.15822665393352509,
-0.6862094402313232,
-0.3370136022567749,
0.2920972406864166,
0.6776469945907593,
-0.6161198616027832,
-0.5669368505477905,
-0.31916344165802,
0.1432211697101593,
0.04660817235708237,
1.3288054466247559,
0.005297545343637466,
-0.057592909783124924,
-0.1188817173242569,
-0.11803209036588669,
-0.5692058801651001,
-0.8318316340446472,
-0.37603485584259033,
-0.5936517715454102,
0.8610129952430725,
0.6444954872131348,
0.5356173515319824,
0.5638840794563293,
0.27130866050720215,
0.25779345631599426,
-0.008061950094997883,
0.10122548043727875,
-0.5433209538459778,
0.2149636596441269,
-0.28323474526405334,
-0.2508031725883484,
-0.16128197312355042,
-0.212176114320755,
0.4479854106903076,
0.778576135635376,
-0.40824273228645325,
0.1159309670329094,
0.006291152909398079,
0.7218263745307922,
-0.5668715834617615,
0.30010026693344116,
-0.21371124684810638,
0.10028732568025589,
-0.01330837793648243,
-0.23631682991981506,
-0.4499855935573578,
-0.4828920364379883,
0.4213319420814514,
-0.5470578670501709,
0.22333724796772003,
0.08908960968255997,
0.6164549589157104,
0.06592550128698349,
-0.42954304814338684,
-0.3150332570075989,
-0.9028117060661316,
0.8543040752410889,
-0.7294086813926697,
0.25359266996383667,
0.4868879020214081,
0.4304671883583069,
-0.13904576003551483,
-0.5001639127731323,
-0.2585633099079132,
-0.5339098572731018,
-0.25173044204711914,
0.10516366362571716,
0.302312433719635,
0.11182282119989395,
-0.04274744912981987,
0.27958688139915466,
-0.5275338292121887,
0.15499448776245117,
-0.1828172355890274,
-0.1353025734424591,
0.7100829482078552,
0.28916412591934204,
0.25746455788612366,
-0.041806504130363464,
-0.2744413912296295,
-0.23792526125907898,
-0.47437626123428345,
0.3928360044956207,
0.6720894575119019,
0.48678481578826904,
-0.24299496412277222,
0.33974215388298035,
-0.508462131023407,
0.765457272529602,
0.10559064149856567,
-0.23714232444763184,
0.20864394307136536,
-0.030743859708309174,
-0.02572610415518284,
-0.052820127457380295,
0.7311658263206482,
0.2747648358345032,
0.45895490050315857,
-0.339164674282074,
-0.4294103980064392,
-0.09298907965421677,
0.15078051388263702,
-0.6912612915039062,
-0.4139794707298279,
0.14402684569358826,
-0.45827433466911316,
-0.575100302696228,
0.05540897697210312,
-0.5709264874458313,
-0.43763449788093567,
-0.4761798679828644,
0.32940608263015747,
-0.11100044846534729,
-0.26522254943847656,
0.19294984638690948,
0.0980776846408844,
-0.21170444786548615,
0.27244868874549866,
-1.5130572319030762,
0.348660945892334,
0.5549476146697998,
0.4083959460258484,
-0.34769439697265625,
-0.4080677628517151,
-0.6161753535270691,
0.033751316368579865,
-0.00520856911316514,
0.8623714447021484,
-0.6642720699310303,
-0.5675244927406311,
0.2542835772037506,
-0.20600466430187225,
0.10266565531492233,
-0.6812289357185364,
0.4794030487537384,
-0.42395535111427307,
0.6445955634117126,
-0.5156415700912476,
-0.6535274982452393,
-0.19875143468379974,
0.2730066180229187,
-0.47031453251838684,
0.5746966600418091,
0.24879300594329834,
-0.8352508544921875,
0.20580925047397614,
-0.7574530243873596,
-0.4744636118412018,
0.09558404237031937,
-0.1275893598794937,
-0.39262720942497253,
0.12013071775436401,
0.1904030740261078,
0.4781518876552582,
-0.15918034315109253,
0.6033433675765991,
-0.40376168489456177,
-0.41154688596725464,
0.281486839056015,
-0.16426458954811096,
0.23596398532390594,
0.18013478815555573,
-0.28129205107688904,
0.7557657361030579,
-0.5539788603782654,
-0.1370757669210434,
0.23145191371440887,
-0.778290867805481,
-0.3513203561306,
0.10360094159841537,
0.36447444558143616,
-0.12537497282028198,
0.3873556852340698,
-0.4106983244419098,
0.20818199217319489,
-0.6129806637763977,
0.296138733625412,
0.8963975310325623,
0.020661912858486176,
0.4853920340538025,
-0.3793973922729492,
0.560664176940918,
-0.08302750438451767,
-0.056091468781232834,
-0.3503565788269043,
-0.272861510515213,
-0.46053534746170044,
0.020565848797559738,
0.3565807342529297,
0.473249614238739,
-0.2056705355644226,
0.4295285642147064,
-0.13870882987976074,
0.053796909749507904,
-0.2841508686542511,
0.23295509815216064,
0.5090647339820862,
0.588072657585144,
0.29736074805259705,
-0.38771241903305054,
-0.5496483445167542,
-1.0220533609390259,
-0.44970694184303284,
-0.2337060421705246,
-0.010938894003629684,
0.5231451988220215,
0.19274453818798065,
-0.30732372403144836,
1.1158888339996338,
-0.738849401473999,
-0.32010316848754883,
-0.5210463404655457,
0.19329118728637695,
0.0687122792005539,
0.29080069065093994,
0.3269372284412384,
-0.736894965171814,
-0.4742554724216461,
0.12334253638982773,
-0.5238404273986816,
-0.1362198144197464,
-0.009871191345155239,
0.22623533010482788,
0.023773079738020897,
0.08626483380794525,
-0.025984017178416252,
0.06553737819194794,
0.553382396697998,
-0.4700189530849457,
0.6145903468132019,
-0.4312686622142792,
0.020066939294338226,
-0.9759300947189331,
0.027372291311621666,
0.09460383653640747,
-0.543816864490509,
-0.6060716509819031,
-0.07145708054304123,
-0.08603515475988388,
0.02783077582716942,
-0.29099059104919434,
0.9055494666099548,
-0.06326992064714432,
-0.022295141592621803,
-0.5328226685523987,
-0.042127057909965515,
-0.27920401096343994,
0.9331324100494385,
0.26759228110313416,
0.5165297985076904,
-0.0005635509733110666,
-0.6046149134635925,
0.2960505187511444,
0.28040391206741333,
-0.08938790112733841,
0.31357499957084656,
-0.7580171823501587,
0.11783972382545471,
-0.24585506319999695,
0.14655321836471558,
-0.7165651321411133,
-0.6244089007377625,
0.3084571361541748,
-0.41402652859687805,
0.059822823852300644,
0.01049702800810337,
-0.19115151464939117,
0.05975531414151192,
-0.24554383754730225,
0.1967025250196457,
0.48442569375038147,
-0.7409054040908813,
0.4638689458370209,
0.506184995174408,
-0.2916586399078369,
-0.38489842414855957,
-0.21925748884677887,
-0.12639085948467255,
-0.2163570374250412,
-0.4306981861591339,
0.46961870789527893,
-0.31913337111473083,
-0.09566795080900192,
0.002962767845019698,
0.20287953317165375,
0.14750415086746216,
0.26648804545402527,
0.2613855004310608,
0.01937291957437992,
0.06148538365960121,
0.1698223203420639,
0.0003677101922221482,
-0.2600434422492981,
-0.026695577427744865,
-0.22700758278369904,
0.6015360355377197,
-0.3571596145629883,
-0.1808970868587494,
-0.35899484157562256,
0.33414793014526367,
0.03763769567012787,
-0.38778018951416016,
0.5037988424301147,
0.730931282043457,
-0.1700792908668518,
-0.23946711421012878,
-0.5667580962181091,
-0.490648478269577,
-0.4348556697368622,
0.5905897617340088,
-0.2848570644855499,
-1.354711651802063,
0.44868898391723633,
-0.08558813482522964,
0.2361450493335724,
0.07063215225934982,
0.9030320644378662,
-0.12167715281248093,
1.2377469539642334,
0.8039126992225647,
-0.27841895818710327,
0.709121584892273,
0.045326244086027145,
-0.1139163225889206,
-0.5896916389465332,
-0.30396899580955505,
-0.29205092787742615,
-0.4189775586128235,
-0.37764012813568115,
0.2339416742324829,
0.17637556791305542,
0.09829393774271011,
-0.434488981962204,
0.05922933295369148,
-0.34240660071372986,
0.5679075717926025,
0.7059816718101501,
0.1624506115913391,
0.37161222100257874,
0.1317179948091507,
-0.3458636999130249,
-0.1404433250427246,
-0.47646281123161316,
-0.43602851033210754,
0.9459654688835144,
0.4916997253894806,
0.8652945756912231,
0.17970630526542664,
0.9191758632659912,
0.39616698026657104,
0.47656306624412537,
-0.6626092195510864,
0.22025205194950104,
-0.2805517911911011,
-0.36093443632125854,
-0.2727394700050354,
-0.564645528793335,
-0.875938892364502,
0.2727474570274353,
-0.19663287699222565,
-0.8955515027046204,
-0.0567350871860981,
0.6340951919555664,
-0.42204752564430237,
0.031172195449471474,
-0.9318376183509827,
1.0001447200775146,
-0.35547858476638794,
-0.3274776041507721,
-0.25211769342422485,
-0.6850200891494751,
0.5763494968414307,
0.2375619262456894,
0.3121039569377899,
-0.10666888952255249,
0.20332230627536774,
0.679790735244751,
-0.1922120302915573,
1.1264344453811646,
-0.2850300371646881,
0.022912276908755302,
-0.1180858239531517,
0.03269368037581444,
0.5745849013328552,
0.23190782964229584,
0.15711405873298645,
-0.3388177156448364,
-0.13138779997825623,
-0.25818899273872375,
-0.6151813268661499,
0.7227514982223511,
-0.9113019108772278,
-0.583452582359314,
-0.256131112575531,
-0.4144083261489868,
-0.3887879550457001,
0.1459982693195343,
0.1961761862039566,
0.3177148699760437,
-0.39435073733329773,
0.04364682734012604,
0.6099693775177002,
-0.3869149088859558,
0.3688298761844635,
0.5753378868103027,
-0.5446895956993103,
-0.6704386472702026,
1.0506221055984497,
-0.5086537003517151,
0.07349956035614014,
0.6518046259880066,
0.6402272582054138,
-0.49817773699760437,
-0.3739420175552368,
-0.3355291783809662,
0.28130581974983215,
-0.7109866142272949,
0.09688421338796616,
-0.5276774764060974,
0.16123370826244354,
-0.25687888264656067,
-0.051771193742752075,
-0.2732199728488922,
-0.11970841139554977,
-0.27295416593551636,
0.027573779225349426,
0.16471920907497406,
0.8967490196228027,
0.18921741843223572,
0.34517860412597656,
-0.8214433193206787,
0.3387313485145569,
0.4541551470756531,
0.48319920897483826,
-0.024259502068161964,
-0.47838160395622253,
-0.4150012731552124,
0.04016881808638573,
-0.1185588613152504,
-0.8156184554100037,
0.407199889421463,
0.005323475226759911,
0.5880739092826843,
0.27362924814224243,
0.0874929204583168,
0.2827436029911041,
-0.2964351773262024,
0.5518752336502075,
0.26132717728614807,
-0.8175594806671143,
0.4399963617324829,
-0.42969170212745667,
0.35526201128959656,
0.5787516236305237,
0.11638227850198746,
-0.9377987384796143,
-0.02931615151464939,
-0.4070192575454712,
-0.7492901682853699,
0.6291339993476868,
-0.2071482390165329,
0.1339741200208664,
0.19055864214897156,
0.5546551942825317,
0.21332047879695892,
0.22641406953334808,
-0.8168509602546692,
-0.11210828274488449,
-0.11838012933731079,
-0.4244192838668823,
-0.18821777403354645,
-0.2694920599460602,
-0.05397553741931915,
-0.020776931196451187,
0.5495485067367554,
-0.33851584792137146,
-0.08028895407915115,
0.04829157143831253,
-0.2765522003173828,
-0.17589937150478363,
0.4229646325111389,
0.8143676519393921,
0.5650434494018555,
-0.4065493643283844,
-0.0461270846426487,
-0.04793519154191017,
-0.20099851489067078,
0.17460997402668,
-0.04985911771655083,
-0.30121198296546936,
-0.2598814368247986,
0.24154052138328552,
1.0317909717559814,
0.3989201486110687,
-0.884505033493042,
0.4878314733505249,
-0.4007313549518585,
-0.16882216930389404,
-0.3427039384841919,
0.2698235809803009,
0.3307821750640869,
0.05961078032851219,
0.015068677254021168,
-0.01354625541716814,
0.050878673791885376,
-0.36963796615600586,
0.15041449666023254,
0.2974960505962372,
-0.5077216625213623,
-0.5731685161590576,
0.6756592392921448,
0.40544724464416504,
-0.4554023742675781,
0.2925708591938019,
-0.21699179708957672,
-0.5287081599235535,
0.18399307131767273,
0.5169087052345276,
1.000792145729065,
-0.22455719113349915,
0.4054771959781647,
0.29909548163414,
-0.18769125640392303,
-0.22684955596923828,
0.05748733878135681,
-0.291045606136322,
-0.7261393666267395,
-0.3695177435874939,
-0.6440203189849854,
-0.6589722633361816,
0.08451946824789047,
-0.5630384087562561,
0.2702130675315857,
-0.6194038987159729,
-0.047339677810668945,
-0.035019055008888245,
-0.027309874072670937,
-0.4491852819919586,
0.18087217211723328,
0.09450322389602661,
0.23020362854003906,
-0.6721338629722595,
0.8757945895195007,
0.8837746977806091,
-0.48690900206565857,
-0.747028648853302,
-0.06553971022367477,
-0.012248644605278969,
-0.5901620984077454,
0.7446684837341309,
-0.01222037523984909,
-0.06238201633095741,
0.05226738005876541,
-0.29465124011039734,
-0.45200830698013306,
0.766057550907135,
0.33021700382232666,
-0.6429450511932373,
-0.03881053626537323,
0.03743750974535942,
0.4845070242881775,
-0.5617096424102783,
0.21975286304950714,
0.6238287091255188,
0.31947198510169983,
-0.10552601516246796,
-0.7807478904724121,
-0.10724152624607086,
-0.09991335868835449,
0.19847239553928375,
0.14900533854961395,
-0.4920986294746399,
0.6244077086448669,
-0.46762019395828247,
0.027290279045701027,
-0.07070578634738922,
0.6915573477745056,
0.37704378366470337,
0.012683337554335594,
0.6327840685844421,
0.47634056210517883,
0.5347480773925781,
0.13530157506465912,
1.177949070930481,
-0.1825159788131714,
0.4963277280330658,
1.383837342262268,
-0.20728309452533722,
0.8305196166038513,
0.2381833791732788,
-0.12097529321908951,
0.41022008657455444,
0.690741240978241,
0.18294265866279602,
0.6375322937965393,
0.31267040967941284,
-0.30553996562957764,
-0.2329142987728119,
-0.06829296797513962,
-0.22897300124168396,
0.22285445034503937,
0.053584985435009,
-0.31927913427352905,
-0.20274989306926727,
0.07970763742923737,
-0.0489470474421978,
0.4989781081676483,
0.04725002497434616,
1.0675259828567505,
-0.08279828727245331,
-0.8564777374267578,
0.4344194233417511,
0.5331045389175415,
0.9516319036483765,
-0.6456355452537537,
0.06641128659248352,
-0.39279505610466003,
0.36748430132865906,
-0.20884424448013306,
-0.4727458357810974,
0.15647916495800018,
-0.09645088762044907,
-0.4231058955192566,
-0.34157806634902954,
0.6796591877937317,
-0.8091368079185486,
-0.19487084448337555,
0.2362973541021347,
0.20184385776519775,
-0.2122749388217926,
-0.043107420206069946,
-0.5233712196350098,
-0.09994266927242279,
0.2684915065765381,
-0.37552353739738464,
0.6697075366973877,
-0.19312047958374023,
-0.022264959290623665,
0.6537759900093079,
0.7512257695198059,
0.10000289976596832,
-0.2196139395236969,
0.4481126070022583,
0.6115739941596985,
-0.9318456053733826,
-0.8844877481460571,
-0.8667537569999695,
0.4299209713935852,
0.18281663954257965,
-0.4415484368801117,
0.3845841586589813,
0.3885902762413025,
0.8767614960670471,
-0.3525816798210144,
1.0089950561523438,
0.3574276566505432,
0.8457413911819458,
-0.4921385943889618,
0.5374744534492493,
-0.4981403648853302,
0.42989081144332886,
-0.13469816744327545,
-0.8485545516014099,
-0.3440384268760681,
0.49883610010147095,
-0.21953511238098145,
0.28340408205986023,
0.4404316246509552,
0.6182219982147217,
0.049904417246580124,
0.10158021003007889,
0.29583996534347534,
-0.08111752569675446,
0.706235408782959,
0.5743186473846436,
0.8010404706001282,
0.090242400765419,
0.34366095066070557,
-0.5262659192085266,
-0.14431379735469818,
-0.4169587790966034,
-0.8054643273353577,
-0.9459837675094604,
-0.6077600121498108,
-0.2936316132545471,
-0.11370449513196945,
0.14546085894107819,
1.3646794557571411,
0.7072742581367493,
-0.9626271724700928,
-0.545246958732605,
-0.13598573207855225,
0.2172994762659073,
-0.049573615193367004,
-0.24581123888492584,
0.3272401988506317,
-0.49647465348243713,
-0.7625504732131958,
0.2186492383480072,
0.30781158804893494,
0.07285770773887634,
-0.45575129985809326,
-0.569328248500824,
0.16260989010334015,
-0.2947772443294525,
0.4974776804447174,
0.5856809616088867,
-0.8939452767372131,
-0.3344630300998688,
0.005618713330477476,
0.033233657479286194,
-0.048926349729299545,
1.0895766019821167,
-0.8276987075805664,
0.43967482447624207,
0.6376244425773621,
0.8524458408355713,
0.4631572961807251,
0.2293933779001236,
0.8394297361373901,
-0.8670498132705688,
0.03558991104364395,
0.23086518049240112,
0.28595590591430664,
0.5355610251426697,
-0.39133110642433167,
0.170318141579628,
0.22602304816246033,
-0.5262967348098755,
-0.6411558389663696,
0.41973239183425903,
-0.8064783215522766,
-0.2980356514453888,
1.0042086839675903,
-0.22521601617336273,
-0.06602665036916733,
-0.051046501845121384,
-0.32622185349464417,
0.024668145924806595,
-0.633762538433075,
0.8966179490089417,
0.5814720392227173,
-0.23443512618541718,
-0.2231915444135666,
-0.24348334968090057,
0.6712626814842224,
0.5092915296554565,
-0.8871753811836243,
0.1425856649875641,
0.4094681143760681,
0.48392122983932495,
-0.0808442234992981,
0.7366317510604858,
0.11597299575805664,
0.2575170397758484,
-0.61549973487854,
0.16655266284942627,
-0.34538573026657104,
-0.18079884350299835,
-0.5399105548858643,
0.32313087582588196,
0.3812673091888428,
0.0923934355378151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03686v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03686v3 | Are Machines Better at Complex Reasoning? Unveiling Human-Machine Inference Gaps in Entailment Verification | 2024-02-06T04:14:09 | 2024-05-27T18:44:14 | Soumya Sanyal, Tianyi Xiao, Jiacheng Liu, Wenya Wang, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Making inferences in text comprehension to understand the meaning is
essential in language processing. This work studies the entailment verification
(EV) problem of multi-sentence premises that requires a system to make multiple
inferences implicitly. Studying EV for such complex premises is important
because modern NLP problems, such as detecting inconsistent model-generated
rationales, require complex multi-hop reasoning. However, current textual
inference datasets mostly contain short premises that only partially focus on
these challenges. To address this, we compile an EV benchmark that includes
datasets from three NLP domains (NLI, contextual QA, and rationales) containing
multi-sentence premises. On benchmarking humans and LLMs, we find that LLMs are
better than humans in multi-hop reasoning across extended contexts, while
humans perform better in simple deductive reasoning tasks. We also finetune a
Flan-T5 model for EV using two training objectives to obtain a strong
open-source model that outperforms GPT-3.5 and rivals GPT-4. Finally, we use
this model to filter out inconsistent model-generated rationales in
self-consistency decoding, resulting in a 6% accuracy improvement on average
across three MCQ datasets. | [
-0.4074234664440155,
-0.8753828406333923,
0.8328565359115601,
-0.007152746897190809,
0.2529779076576233,
0.049228981137275696,
-0.2263355851173401,
-0.6546342968940735,
-0.4417879283428192,
0.30761343240737915,
-0.5799447298049927,
-0.38762515783309937,
-0.6380883455276489,
0.6392214298248291,
-0.2227092981338501,
0.23687809705734253,
-0.26184380054473877,
-0.11099975556135178,
-0.4974030554294586,
-0.15677592158317566,
-0.2758454382419586,
-0.494791716337204,
-0.37502506375312805,
-0.6088865995407104,
0.22340920567512512,
0.2070785015821457,
0.46966999769210815,
0.40003979206085205,
0.3375329077243805,
0.264180451631546,
0.12953892350196838,
0.8274278044700623,
0.08125732094049454,
0.40091416239738464,
-0.08075276762247086,
-0.585707426071167,
-0.3797370195388794,
0.011074170470237732,
0.20701831579208374,
0.6023465394973755,
0.08371549099683762,
-0.11579857021570206,
-0.04813976213335991,
0.6173363327980042,
-0.8194029927253723,
-0.04146407172083855,
-0.7247911095619202,
-0.10088178515434265,
-0.042257994413375854,
-0.11051779985427856,
-0.7268139123916626,
-0.21369856595993042,
0.07349614053964615,
-0.8237968683242798,
0.31986385583877563,
0.4066351354122162,
1.2394062280654907,
0.5474575757980347,
-0.6820277571678162,
-0.32724830508232117,
-0.5936687588691711,
0.6849417090415955,
-0.6706176400184631,
0.6324670910835266,
0.48190975189208984,
0.15890386700630188,
-0.3530780076980591,
-0.5436502695083618,
-0.6355705261230469,
-0.2677892744541168,
-0.07627948373556137,
0.10770722478628159,
-0.2433117777109146,
0.2668232321739197,
0.6413703560829163,
0.05673249065876007,
-0.5674368739128113,
-0.03447575867176056,
-0.01796514168381691,
-0.26029908657073975,
0.4650574326515198,
-0.02594253234565258,
0.3256599009037018,
-0.054838743060827255,
-0.20299032330513,
-0.1259082555770874,
-0.8072587847709656,
0.09971801936626434,
0.40533486008644104,
-0.10140052437782288,
0.3576226532459259,
0.7897759675979614,
-0.3800315856933594,
0.5995984077453613,
0.04665738344192505,
0.05783236399292946,
0.40362030267715454,
-0.3173291087150574,
-0.34544041752815247,
0.013123876415193081,
0.5131706595420837,
0.31792888045310974,
0.5031596422195435,
-0.1763254851102829,
-0.21270404756069183,
0.19510087370872498,
0.0891769751906395,
-0.5948175191879272,
-0.04021706059575081,
0.5003453493118286,
-0.28435322642326355,
0.20207823812961578,
0.10379622131586075,
-0.29581400752067566,
-0.13784091174602509,
-0.576343297958374,
0.4039752185344696,
-0.7473036646842957,
-0.12115395069122314,
0.6534522771835327,
-0.29641640186309814,
0.28360632061958313,
0.47043031454086304,
-0.6552635431289673,
0.2804528772830963,
0.758481502532959,
0.527077317237854,
0.1350105106830597,
-0.7335780262947083,
-0.7023195624351501,
0.31221210956573486,
-0.20378121733665466,
0.973724901676178,
-0.4493430554866791,
0.27943432331085205,
-0.0006007037009112537,
0.11602773517370224,
-0.46093302965164185,
-0.6030691266059875,
1.0588699579238892,
-0.3660528361797333,
0.14118194580078125,
-0.28098294138908386,
-1.0482693910598755,
-0.2782173156738281,
0.6371446251869202,
-0.540378749370575,
0.9314385056495667,
-0.29637810587882996,
-0.8706517219543457,
0.4969901442527771,
-0.6707258224487305,
-0.5170072913169861,
-0.16583223640918732,
-0.17904290556907654,
-0.4224770665168762,
-0.026402346789836884,
0.5109012126922607,
0.5709214210510254,
-0.31655535101890564,
0.3378981947898865,
-0.5306443572044373,
-0.1674741506576538,
0.14391086995601654,
-0.5116106867790222,
0.6762818098068237,
0.1403127908706665,
-0.4524365961551666,
0.040675677359104156,
-0.8221712708473206,
0.1307060718536377,
0.00582595681771636,
-0.28782594203948975,
-0.40234848856925964,
0.246200293302536,
-0.45092156529426575,
0.16286545991897583,
-0.07824728637933731,
-0.6040013432502747,
0.1946406066417694,
-0.30498048663139343,
0.6109820604324341,
0.44118309020996094,
-0.08109056204557419,
0.20363545417785645,
-0.3337101638317108,
0.2609109580516815,
0.10491582751274109,
-0.2076292186975479,
-0.41376736760139465,
-0.5354447364807129,
-0.7408009767532349,
-0.3964836299419403,
0.24338191747665405,
0.6881173253059387,
-0.6054919362068176,
0.6465579271316528,
-0.053149450570344925,
-0.09051157534122467,
-0.6178392171859741,
-0.2858605980873108,
0.1658361852169037,
0.3343542516231537,
0.5165702700614929,
0.49525877833366394,
-0.5147423148155212,
-0.978261411190033,
-0.8342103362083435,
-0.01978985033929348,
-0.429551362991333,
0.04809548333287239,
0.7654870748519897,
-0.3187776505947113,
0.8071470260620117,
-0.29807963967323303,
0.025071600452065468,
-0.14192503690719604,
0.3883161246776581,
-0.03680296614766121,
0.3700122833251953,
0.20568068325519562,
-0.5397657155990601,
-0.3612818121910095,
-0.08451798558235168,
-0.9422294497489929,
-0.11063781380653381,
-0.3138948976993561,
-0.20969265699386597,
0.07493698596954346,
0.3666054606437683,
-0.962973952293396,
0.4094933867454529,
0.22026857733726501,
-0.4536520540714264,
0.46539416909217834,
-0.4659932553768158,
0.45663636922836304,
-0.6231759786605835,
-0.09677261114120483,
0.10632263123989105,
-0.569355309009552,
-0.481938898563385,
0.047772280871868134,
0.1771799772977829,
0.35694918036460876,
-0.047761909663677216,
0.15474121272563934,
-0.6130759716033936,
0.01993080973625183,
0.06722716987133026,
0.18562057614326477,
0.5137109756469727,
0.37549692392349243,
-0.11252670735120773,
0.6033643484115601,
0.5317050814628601,
-0.6888734698295593,
0.23857761919498444,
0.03565330058336258,
-0.38161227107048035,
0.5033102035522461,
-0.7487726211547852,
0.23217472434043884,
-0.3227543532848358,
0.5017390847206116,
-0.8392168283462524,
-0.5042396783828735,
0.09939932823181152,
-0.29383161664009094,
-0.003715386614203453,
0.1956062614917755,
-0.7339815497398376,
-0.20539601147174835,
-0.16667120158672333,
0.24993480741977692,
0.43907299637794495,
-0.5548989772796631,
0.8898849487304688,
-0.010502567514777184,
0.4452986419200897,
-0.6835405230522156,
-0.4874044358730316,
-0.023904312402009964,
-0.10960952937602997,
-1.0549768209457397,
0.41473671793937683,
0.17838892340660095,
-0.5454225540161133,
-0.06502453982830048,
-0.09196358919143677,
-0.09057798981666565,
0.18813328444957733,
0.024802139028906822,
-0.12073349952697754,
-0.19461484253406525,
0.21638795733451843,
0.16890820860862732,
-0.03914705663919449,
0.17941872775554657,
-0.2314680963754654,
0.22040534019470215,
-0.35280492901802063,
-0.7776224613189697,
-0.5842598676681519,
0.46770161390304565,
0.70563805103302,
-0.2058231681585312,
0.5990694165229797,
0.5920692682266235,
-0.7384375929832458,
-0.21970902383327484,
-0.6569714546203613,
-0.2937195897102356,
-0.3328222334384918,
0.10599768906831741,
-0.9465972185134888,
-0.8117154836654663,
0.44327622652053833,
-0.302591472864151,
0.2875825762748718,
0.8126727342605591,
0.2536594271659851,
-0.1495007425546646,
1.2018533945083618,
0.13300468027591705,
0.47912511229515076,
-0.22438357770442963,
-0.04380309581756592,
0.14131617546081543,
-0.7459055185317993,
-0.42046332359313965,
-0.6599932312965393,
0.05557158216834068,
-0.3908584713935852,
-0.25442034006118774,
0.06647661328315735,
0.35979199409484863,
-0.452922523021698,
0.185860276222229,
-0.3591320216655731,
0.489299476146698,
0.545880138874054,
0.21113936603069305,
0.5252410173416138,
-0.15995919704437256,
-0.24030271172523499,
-0.10754397511482239,
-0.5136035084724426,
-0.7690887451171875,
0.8547012209892273,
0.4462895095348358,
0.47500649094581604,
0.07849444448947906,
0.49543678760528564,
0.3234320878982544,
0.013840846717357635,
-0.5203604102134705,
0.2679075598716736,
-0.04985335096716881,
-0.5994926691055298,
-0.25244319438934326,
-0.35318613052368164,
-0.8738685250282288,
0.5948632955551147,
-0.2253934144973755,
-0.4117434620857239,
-0.10290596634149551,
0.18201643228530884,
-0.22666700184345245,
0.3009609282016754,
-0.7891231775283813,
0.8345628976821899,
-0.17406617105007172,
-0.4146542549133301,
-0.21951237320899963,
-0.7388143539428711,
0.45905137062072754,
0.19638682901859283,
0.273802787065506,
-0.5081726908683777,
0.10557515174150467,
0.25772497057914734,
-0.4904060363769531,
0.49451011419296265,
-0.144474595785141,
-0.10697542876005173,
0.28460296988487244,
-0.07429755479097366,
0.6957146525382996,
-0.03493481129407883,
-0.18652911484241486,
0.04203799366950989,
-0.2042817324399948,
-0.37868231534957886,
-0.5912840962409973,
0.20943480730056763,
-0.7980114817619324,
-0.5075551271438599,
-0.2261771857738495,
-0.10913980007171631,
-0.2485107034444809,
0.12609459459781647,
0.45981016755104065,
0.35395193099975586,
-0.023992015048861504,
0.23274247348308563,
1.023688554763794,
-0.14083817601203918,
0.09587082266807556,
0.11546804010868073,
0.20609532296657562,
-0.17903244495391846,
0.38301464915275574,
-0.1895068734884262,
0.2778913676738739,
0.722780704498291,
0.1757076531648636,
-0.54316645860672,
-0.2923850119113922,
-0.778512179851532,
0.042438335716724396,
-0.8642739057540894,
-0.07018743455410004,
-0.9812692999839783,
-0.05647779628634453,
-0.2863362729549408,
-0.014439531601965427,
-0.3472394347190857,
-0.28118595480918884,
-0.08694354444742203,
-0.0357186459004879,
0.10666833072900772,
0.6831218004226685,
0.16137553751468658,
-0.08387349545955658,
-0.7213523983955383,
0.5478242635726929,
0.3350581228733063,
0.023493075743317604,
-0.14719848334789276,
-0.46057894825935364,
0.18561704456806183,
0.1399504840373993,
-0.24503564834594727,
-0.7576578855514526,
0.01272120513021946,
0.2879592478275299,
0.6879942417144775,
0.15661293268203735,
0.18285474181175232,
0.620997428894043,
-0.664675235748291,
0.7339550256729126,
0.10953668504953384,
-1.1382217407226562,
0.4831966161727905,
-0.185136079788208,
0.24835103750228882,
0.46427616477012634,
0.2132650464773178,
-0.3110215365886688,
-0.5403455495834351,
-0.5762622356414795,
-0.7902034521102905,
0.35951921343803406,
0.5658489465713501,
-0.4051358997821808,
-0.04384150728583336,
0.44722747802734375,
0.14096568524837494,
0.0551566444337368,
-0.6295791268348694,
-0.14271672070026398,
-0.18921872973442078,
-0.31623801589012146,
0.32846158742904663,
-0.05392364785075188,
0.03002815879881382,
-0.11938190460205078,
0.6259366869926453,
-0.21430346369743347,
0.2006162852048874,
0.5225923657417297,
-0.27368223667144775,
0.02996033802628517,
0.44624316692352295,
0.7224500179290771,
0.5944305062294006,
-0.20808038115501404,
0.5439488291740417,
0.34171709418296814,
-0.024541201069951057,
0.3079339563846588,
-0.08517810702323914,
0.009708811528980732,
0.16469044983386993,
0.6778667569160461,
0.6883307695388794,
-0.15969663858413696,
-0.6538019180297852,
0.620322585105896,
-0.25202476978302,
-0.48240819573402405,
-0.20019090175628662,
0.057105354964733124,
0.14680740237236023,
0.18939663469791412,
0.35595089197158813,
0.48974767327308655,
0.3028368055820465,
-0.28215596079826355,
0.2588886618614197,
0.25144264101982117,
0.07613833248615265,
-0.25818371772766113,
0.9141045808792114,
0.20808230340480804,
-0.25434109568595886,
0.7320204377174377,
-0.23091131448745728,
-0.6558957099914551,
0.7605063319206238,
0.3561314344406128,
1.0441738367080688,
0.12468614429235458,
-0.16461189091205597,
0.6273787021636963,
0.5315036177635193,
-0.5455468893051147,
0.23602354526519775,
0.03889140114188194,
-0.86729896068573,
-0.7445511221885681,
-0.21710054576396942,
-0.5638841390609741,
0.0066381171345710754,
-0.4550464451313019,
0.2744597792625427,
0.06794048845767975,
0.019734090194106102,
0.16646404564380646,
-0.24567386507987976,
-0.7150098085403442,
0.18737713992595673,
0.06479550153017044,
0.8123055100440979,
-0.7707623839378357,
0.7417221069335938,
0.6021828055381775,
-0.16749757528305054,
-0.7517061233520508,
0.1920924186706543,
-0.16878770291805267,
-0.5597083568572998,
0.6171573400497437,
0.697543740272522,
-0.5754511952400208,
-0.1553862988948822,
-0.7330877184867859,
-0.45684170722961426,
0.9228640198707581,
0.5236822962760925,
-0.7882161736488342,
0.12491115182638168,
0.0037656817585229874,
0.28983259201049805,
-0.43978267908096313,
0.4268067479133606,
0.49455687403678894,
0.6650024652481079,
-0.06956513971090317,
-0.7297182083129883,
0.09566335380077362,
0.004465376492589712,
-0.3498682677745819,
0.12834006547927856,
-0.3443436622619629,
0.7947378754615784,
-0.2710846960544586,
-0.16594889760017395,
-0.21153157949447632,
0.642204761505127,
0.6328174471855164,
0.4775756001472473,
0.763019859790802,
0.6156260371208191,
1.1430144309997559,
-0.18833903968334198,
0.9466903805732727,
-0.1806742548942566,
0.3453480303287506,
1.0986902713775635,
-0.48033010959625244,
0.8187068104743958,
0.3141104280948639,
-0.24972572922706604,
0.5512879490852356,
0.8635818362236023,
0.219072625041008,
0.15199322998523712,
0.2379450649023056,
-0.18809939920902252,
-0.7651636600494385,
0.16953395307064056,
-0.24485664069652557,
0.21607251465320587,
0.3945261538028717,
-0.049014702439308167,
-0.08370175957679749,
-0.10892928391695023,
-0.08021813631057739,
0.10037459433078766,
0.03830667957663536,
0.6160573363304138,
-0.03711026534438133,
-1.0077685117721558,
0.5399221777915955,
0.16352981328964233,
0.6317906975746155,
-0.36144402623176575,
-0.1040816456079483,
0.0003646932600531727,
0.3791345953941345,
-0.33376967906951904,
-0.6702461242675781,
0.2609212398529053,
0.0014623526949435472,
-0.2520759403705597,
-0.20395074784755707,
0.7705403566360474,
-0.4405044615268707,
-0.13018350303173065,
0.23517349362373352,
0.6779505610466003,
0.2900446355342865,
-0.2947547435760498,
-0.6210476756095886,
-0.22328537702560425,
0.05809110030531883,
-0.30285802483558655,
-0.0713881328701973,
0.847841739654541,
-0.02979789301753044,
0.7085686922073364,
0.5144163370132446,
-0.35962024331092834,
0.19378645718097687,
0.43866652250289917,
0.5067946910858154,
-0.5718353390693665,
-0.07347355782985687,
-1.201014757156372,
0.5193781852722168,
-0.28649240732192993,
-0.20692723989486694,
0.7577759027481079,
0.6904318332672119,
0.7835498452186584,
-0.03676845133304596,
0.9089458584785461,
0.04484609514474869,
0.472915917634964,
-0.7682368755340576,
0.14846794307231903,
-0.6114978194236755,
0.3237610161304474,
0.08789126574993134,
-0.6845097541809082,
-0.48121997714042664,
0.777418315410614,
0.03764335811138153,
-0.11908715218305588,
1.005548357963562,
0.4519971013069153,
-0.1637972742319107,
0.15336927771568298,
0.3187998831272125,
-0.09582552313804626,
0.49112462997436523,
0.6647014617919922,
1.2676070928573608,
-0.5661796927452087,
0.3173668384552002,
0.01407574862241745,
-0.006833934225142002,
-0.11273816227912903,
-0.9696608185768127,
-0.9812126755714417,
-0.2686970829963684,
-0.408801406621933,
-0.41278979182243347,
0.005350087303668261,
1.1597023010253906,
0.6466154456138611,
-0.7048888206481934,
0.05901411920785904,
-0.5404292345046997,
0.3428593575954437,
-0.4641713798046112,
-0.18021951615810394,
0.32788512110710144,
-0.6105560660362244,
-0.7505876421928406,
0.4025540351867676,
0.3963335156440735,
-0.06216229498386383,
-0.14389196038246155,
-0.18158124387264252,
-0.33962708711624146,
0.20252357423305511,
0.6819214820861816,
-0.16503272950649261,
-1.120638370513916,
-0.4949086010456085,
0.2916327118873596,
-0.21329478919506073,
0.24955615401268005,
0.8941925168037415,
-0.4179893732070923,
0.3384552001953125,
0.5752844214439392,
0.8237738609313965,
0.3327120542526245,
0.13881359994411469,
0.6206944584846497,
-0.5739381909370422,
-0.2255147099494934,
0.14254456758499146,
0.671973466873169,
0.3121720850467682,
-0.33572062849998474,
0.6025312542915344,
0.2445637434720993,
-0.7412079572677612,
-0.7257546186447144,
0.29455259442329407,
-0.7017937302589417,
-0.3348071277141571,
1.2175323963165283,
-0.41552382707595825,
-0.1558452546596527,
-0.5293400883674622,
-0.006491248495876789,
0.20344676077365875,
-0.3550431430339813,
0.4197017550468445,
0.9289296865463257,
-0.44674965739250183,
-0.0048526315949857235,
-0.6309815049171448,
0.4647519290447235,
0.4346869885921478,
-1.2130119800567627,
0.2133808583021164,
0.503046452999115,
0.2553679943084717,
0.027668284252285957,
0.42066019773483276,
0.3319396376609802,
0.08433087170124054,
0.18935085833072662,
0.019342411309480667,
0.03906625881791115,
-0.45241299271583557,
-0.004529202822595835,
0.34828683733940125,
0.013042504899203777,
-0.33681806921958923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03667v1 | Large Language Models as an Indirect Reasoner: Contrapositive and Contradiction for Automated Reasoning | 2024-02-06T03:41:12 | 2024-02-06T03:41:12 | Yanfang Zhang, Yiliu Sun, Yibing Zhan, Dapeng Tao, Dacheng Tao, Chen Gong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, increasing attention has been focused drawn on to improve the
ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform complex reasoning. However,
previous methods, such as Chain-of-Thought and Self-Consistency, mainly follow
Direct Reasoning (DR) frameworks, so they will meet difficulty in solving
numerous real-world tasks which can hardly be solved via DR. Therefore, to
strengthen the reasoning power of LLMs, this paper proposes a novel Indirect
Reasoning (IR) method that employs the logic of contrapositives and
contradictions to tackle IR tasks such as factual reasoning and mathematic
proof. Specifically, our methodology comprises two steps. Firstly, we leverage
the logical equivalence of contrapositive to augment the data and rules to
enhance the comprehensibility of LLMs. Secondly, we design a set of prompt
templates to trigger LLMs to conduct IR based on proof by contradiction that is
logically equivalent to the original DR process. Our IR method is simple yet
effective and can be straightforwardly integrated with existing DR methods to
further boost the reasoning abilities of LLMs. The experimental results on
popular LLMs, such as GPT-3.5-turbo and Gemini-pro, show that our IR method
enhances the overall accuracy of factual reasoning by 27.33% and mathematical
proof by 31.43%, when compared with traditional DR methods. Moreover, the
methods combining IR and DR significantly outperform the methods solely using
IR or DR, further demonstrating the effectiveness of our strategy. | [
-0.31467074155807495,
-0.7921818494796753,
0.8148086071014404,
0.11560551822185516,
-0.25694045424461365,
-0.01964026875793934,
-0.2898521423339844,
-0.20463505387306213,
-0.0977659597992897,
0.31366539001464844,
-0.7373388409614563,
-0.3488825559616089,
-0.3166795074939728,
0.3101256489753723,
-0.2682659327983856,
0.4646647870540619,
-0.30225229263305664,
0.20229355990886688,
-0.23037296533584595,
-0.10043006390333176,
-0.4456450045108795,
-0.2969054579734802,
-0.2573583424091339,
-0.4909404218196869,
0.642052412033081,
0.6802484393119812,
0.5746920704841614,
0.6224717497825623,
0.5574864745140076,
0.4315197169780731,
0.3292365074157715,
0.43359246850013733,
-0.14178797602653503,
0.22671572864055634,
-0.6858110427856445,
-0.5179365277290344,
-0.3106229603290558,
-0.15390455722808838,
0.31422245502471924,
0.43211740255355835,
0.01215377077460289,
0.006117568351328373,
-0.22813044488430023,
0.6026003956794739,
-0.5747737288475037,
0.1524868607521057,
-0.8054249882698059,
-0.09112972766160965,
-0.05876651033759117,
-0.38084307312965393,
-0.5935998558998108,
-0.4218360185623169,
-0.06618315726518631,
-0.48336732387542725,
0.01024267915636301,
0.10012266039848328,
0.7508037090301514,
0.4967983365058899,
-0.37839019298553467,
-0.3338550627231598,
-0.8680598139762878,
0.7428416013717651,
-0.8947126865386963,
0.3347805440425873,
0.058797143399715424,
0.3743247985839844,
-0.07751503586769104,
-0.582631528377533,
-1.0140140056610107,
-0.4752424359321594,
-0.22492997348308563,
0.028195906430482864,
-0.37051165103912354,
-0.021265743300318718,
0.4994279742240906,
0.1106603741645813,
-0.6243654489517212,
0.2036198377609253,
0.16602693498134613,
0.16437187790870667,
0.40094876289367676,
0.02134045772254467,
0.30741822719573975,
0.026804408058524132,
-0.1197628304362297,
-0.06326008588075638,
-1.1115232706069946,
-0.41460224986076355,
0.23290689289569855,
0.2090863734483719,
0.007378584239631891,
0.6972864866256714,
0.011472528800368309,
0.5507754683494568,
0.23796607553958893,
-0.28994178771972656,
0.20064610242843628,
-0.1509624719619751,
-0.28088346123695374,
-0.09886375814676285,
0.606114387512207,
-0.11720667779445648,
0.3062244653701782,
0.0906587615609169,
-0.27411702275276184,
0.08000379055738449,
-0.26960036158561707,
-0.6246612071990967,
0.09868954867124557,
0.18263982236385345,
-0.08546343445777893,
0.01567736640572548,
-0.06095266342163086,
-0.36448630690574646,
-0.10412518680095673,
-0.7582595348358154,
0.7160661220550537,
-0.40465500950813293,
-0.03410836309194565,
0.25462377071380615,
0.05891307443380356,
0.09419570118188858,
0.6327340006828308,
-0.3747589588165283,
0.06191468611359596,
0.7753283977508545,
0.3993540108203888,
0.319740891456604,
-0.1523606777191162,
-0.6474268436431885,
0.33361396193504333,
-0.37726348638534546,
0.8449746370315552,
-0.44525888562202454,
0.00042124747415073216,
-0.09830410778522491,
-0.3272193372249603,
0.03852846100926399,
-0.6882749795913696,
0.7448439598083496,
-0.48668909072875977,
0.48807471990585327,
-0.27666592597961426,
-0.43401381373405457,
-0.28075823187828064,
0.3490487337112427,
-0.2779533863067627,
0.620365560054779,
-0.33353349566459656,
-0.5556463599205017,
0.05265894532203674,
-0.6262933015823364,
-0.4926074147224426,
0.0782201737165451,
-0.39827823638916016,
-0.28120970726013184,
-0.09504396468400955,
0.4185667037963867,
0.34783610701560974,
-0.7381073832511902,
0.6684717535972595,
-0.32237017154693604,
-0.26908761262893677,
0.18008138239383698,
-0.4944041669368744,
0.7230674624443054,
0.08116412907838821,
-0.7284567356109619,
0.07906569540500641,
-0.6394662261009216,
0.11596891283988953,
0.15515215694904327,
-0.07594040781259537,
-0.45100486278533936,
0.09278073906898499,
-0.5528357625007629,
0.43642503023147583,
0.055449265986680984,
-0.29077163338661194,
0.3851379156112671,
-0.3681928217411041,
0.1430719643831253,
0.936316192150116,
-0.40697771310806274,
0.14087681472301483,
-0.273203581571579,
0.3180706202983856,
0.19317059218883514,
-0.11634494364261627,
-0.24881993234157562,
-0.150249645113945,
-1.050365686416626,
-0.5783899426460266,
0.24626699090003967,
0.7027263045310974,
-1.0516924858093262,
0.8352068662643433,
-0.2812601923942566,
-0.4559492766857147,
-0.2953599691390991,
0.012506122700870037,
0.5900189280509949,
0.8789169788360596,
0.4578590393066406,
0.4402185380458832,
-0.7208263278007507,
-0.8412516713142395,
-0.4550696313381195,
-0.27532777190208435,
0.017275571823120117,
0.3343658447265625,
0.6660701036453247,
-0.5013570189476013,
0.8219142556190491,
-0.47669148445129395,
-0.14969289302825928,
-0.3045842945575714,
0.3550845682621002,
0.516326367855072,
0.5004804730415344,
0.23937392234802246,
-0.7803030014038086,
-0.6090582609176636,
-0.24732448160648346,
-0.8908366560935974,
-0.5987539291381836,
-0.2249140590429306,
-0.005073515698313713,
0.3141228258609772,
0.4878998398780823,
-0.605089008808136,
0.3381839096546173,
0.23613221943378448,
-0.4943043291568756,
0.683698296546936,
-0.22939206659793854,
0.10531202703714371,
-0.6197748780250549,
0.12068696320056915,
0.22514291107654572,
-0.3715486526489258,
-0.38794493675231934,
0.17976592481136322,
-0.09888066351413727,
0.10019030421972275,
-0.20218196511268616,
0.5918564796447754,
-0.49713242053985596,
0.3798007071018219,
-0.2869020402431488,
0.07696150243282318,
-0.10910320281982422,
0.31160423159599304,
0.07180824130773544,
0.5142092108726501,
0.5725353360176086,
-0.45285239815711975,
0.7479598522186279,
0.0508611835539341,
-0.2642790675163269,
0.6314961314201355,
-0.7479240298271179,
0.16432596743106842,
-0.43695658445358276,
0.5861102938652039,
-1.0234943628311157,
0.054655350744724274,
0.3524896204471588,
-0.22733518481254578,
0.1690041869878769,
0.009353849105536938,
-0.6881544589996338,
-0.46305227279663086,
-0.0548628568649292,
0.3488503694534302,
0.5845993161201477,
-0.8880512118339539,
1.053780436515808,
-0.37294718623161316,
-0.14144586026668549,
-0.7605076432228088,
-0.6169304251670837,
0.18155862390995026,
-0.21206031739711761,
-0.8303323984146118,
0.36367759108543396,
-0.32355937361717224,
-0.7330166101455688,
0.030527548864483833,
-0.06419995427131653,
0.1646064966917038,
-0.2313031405210495,
0.052247896790504456,
0.41206246614456177,
-0.4905346632003784,
0.10194937884807587,
0.07761368155479431,
-0.3386244773864746,
-0.0438372902572155,
-0.2514933943748474,
0.5152249932289124,
-0.09687170386314392,
-0.7071175575256348,
-0.6399208903312683,
0.39027419686317444,
0.5267266631126404,
-0.008698392659425735,
0.7577252388000488,
0.10593222081661224,
-0.29064488410949707,
-0.3693830966949463,
-0.8880192637443542,
-0.2760380506515503,
-0.5132456421852112,
-0.016076751053333282,
-0.6171526908874512,
-0.4213835597038269,
0.26486068964004517,
-0.3508497178554535,
-0.11452104151248932,
0.43032610416412354,
0.5586243867874146,
0.15123338997364044,
1.1235690116882324,
0.25228366255760193,
0.15089209377765656,
0.07545046508312225,
-0.07870393246412277,
0.47349947690963745,
-0.29464733600616455,
-0.2939396798610687,
-0.824478030204773,
-0.05351034179329872,
-0.2554422616958618,
-0.5127349495887756,
0.34758520126342773,
0.04848409816622734,
-0.5123611092567444,
0.1606588214635849,
-0.15602150559425354,
0.5276760458946228,
0.5272457599639893,
-0.032533831894397736,
0.507889449596405,
-0.06443843245506287,
-0.408367395401001,
-0.12057311832904816,
-0.5720779895782471,
-0.5878230929374695,
0.4919826090335846,
0.21379606425762177,
0.8861125111579895,
0.27757465839385986,
0.35888412594795227,
0.13223494589328766,
0.4601595401763916,
-0.6658317446708679,
0.8263681530952454,
-0.18856698274612427,
-0.5814237594604492,
-0.1559845507144928,
-0.6934941411018372,
-0.35398250818252563,
0.3560510277748108,
-0.13121971487998962,
-0.480078786611557,
0.13672897219657898,
0.27205294370651245,
0.029678253456950188,
0.27517497539520264,
-0.8949645161628723,
0.5277602076530457,
-0.4322921633720398,
-0.4637415409088135,
-0.2972796559333801,
-0.4811927080154419,
0.3613797128200531,
-0.15257614850997925,
0.276339054107666,
0.036748986691236496,
0.04599833860993385,
0.21443134546279907,
-0.7505133748054504,
0.7010180950164795,
-0.17957668006420135,
-0.37408018112182617,
0.10711316764354706,
0.1999981701374054,
0.9054704308509827,
0.0302022323012352,
-0.14371426403522491,
-0.00968728307634592,
-0.46470680832862854,
-0.08007510751485825,
-0.8544792532920837,
0.7895537614822388,
-0.5567734837532043,
-1.1130821704864502,
-0.510412335395813,
-0.5725254416465759,
-0.24307626485824585,
0.2804023027420044,
0.015635794028639793,
0.44815346598625183,
0.12809130549430847,
0.037906285375356674,
0.6655808091163635,
-0.3965552747249603,
0.19356012344360352,
0.9410558938980103,
-0.046520255506038666,
-0.34410619735717773,
0.5920754075050354,
-0.03199978172779083,
0.18752869963645935,
0.8886746764183044,
0.5183925628662109,
-0.3705500066280365,
-0.15637436509132385,
-0.28958433866500854,
0.5344725251197815,
-0.8454778790473938,
-0.34474867582321167,
-0.5612198710441589,
-0.12370973080396652,
-0.5105811953544617,
-0.2413410097360611,
-0.235915407538414,
-0.3055739998817444,
0.09016662836074829,
0.2625538408756256,
0.07731212675571442,
0.35692504048347473,
-0.47302937507629395,
-0.0023230889346450567,
-0.5169225931167603,
0.7587118744850159,
0.5091564059257507,
0.08521637320518494,
0.08229174464941025,
-0.48647502064704895,
0.3140634298324585,
0.09421234577894211,
-0.19364985823631287,
-0.6137409210205078,
0.3586290180683136,
-0.08203129470348358,
0.4670299291610718,
0.5871776342391968,
0.06709330528974533,
1.0151560306549072,
-0.7449933886528015,
0.23472431302070618,
0.36867380142211914,
-1.343010425567627,
0.5293799042701721,
-0.28962597250938416,
0.18603771924972534,
0.15237905085086823,
0.45680660009384155,
-0.2975243330001831,
-0.22620399296283722,
-0.558025062084198,
-0.7574793696403503,
0.5926627516746521,
0.1968614012002945,
-0.1339384913444519,
0.165996715426445,
0.21755221486091614,
0.21243919432163239,
-0.004146099090576172,
-0.943772554397583,
-0.40121763944625854,
0.09137497842311859,
-0.369060754776001,
0.10223888605833054,
-0.1892004758119583,
-0.19324803352355957,
-0.5097413063049316,
1.0604268312454224,
-0.232059046626091,
0.22860302031040192,
0.19862797856330872,
0.004830031655728817,
-0.2568208575248718,
0.3833121657371521,
0.6461753249168396,
0.8673286437988281,
-0.08653699606657028,
0.5697715282440186,
0.11863059550523758,
0.018519269302487373,
0.35496461391448975,
0.35350972414016724,
-0.19386327266693115,
0.09923802316188812,
0.596984326839447,
0.4378579556941986,
-0.2653229832649231,
-0.8207890391349792,
0.5603483319282532,
-0.051073022186756134,
-0.12950661778450012,
-0.3549584448337555,
0.057635534554719925,
0.09150885045528412,
0.3684934973716736,
0.5055378675460815,
0.09631845355033875,
-0.1773967742919922,
-0.6627565622329712,
-0.10279977321624756,
0.46288639307022095,
0.019345436245203018,
-0.1830013394355774,
0.4407579302787781,
0.1297164261341095,
-0.2519288957118988,
0.5650365948677063,
0.005138300359249115,
-0.6086586713790894,
0.594567596912384,
0.8660026788711548,
0.6614753603935242,
-0.17593547701835632,
0.12582454085350037,
0.22766362130641937,
0.2037174105644226,
-0.2789279520511627,
0.24268998205661774,
0.07987085729837418,
-0.8122674822807312,
-0.8227514624595642,
-0.020720962435007095,
-0.35214248299598694,
0.2741882801055908,
-0.06564678251743317,
0.584285318851471,
-0.3324486315250397,
0.4044923782348633,
0.17114132642745972,
-0.1820002794265747,
-0.43623384833335876,
0.33391886949539185,
0.15856897830963135,
1.0300432443618774,
-0.6227157115936279,
0.6702620983123779,
0.5421574711799622,
-0.2806517481803894,
-0.8951629996299744,
0.19535420835018158,
-0.011023784056305885,
-0.8590998649597168,
1.1324397325515747,
0.16829584538936615,
-0.4753556549549103,
-0.28656330704689026,
-0.7608340978622437,
-0.6149078011512756,
0.828686535358429,
0.7490754723548889,
-1.042269229888916,
0.0599723681807518,
0.1516643613576889,
0.45095309615135193,
-0.19767813384532928,
0.4668172597885132,
0.12328597158193588,
0.7637826204299927,
0.5173767805099487,
-0.8375411033630371,
0.35944047570228577,
-0.11027801781892776,
-0.3980318605899811,
0.13066506385803223,
-0.45532578229904175,
0.6795147061347961,
-0.5138818621635437,
-0.06401117146015167,
0.18110671639442444,
0.5472964644432068,
0.6365672945976257,
0.28975075483322144,
0.6084477305412292,
0.7378931641578674,
0.703226625919342,
-0.12569928169250488,
0.7913019061088562,
0.04370066523551941,
0.13342183828353882,
1.0544121265411377,
-0.6809043288230896,
0.4916161298751831,
0.5605379343032837,
0.13445307314395905,
0.9322212934494019,
-0.19218012690544128,
0.03934295102953911,
0.36450105905532837,
0.44766300916671753,
-0.3947181701660156,
-0.690471351146698,
-0.08777287602424622,
-0.3581760823726654,
0.38156795501708984,
0.1501704752445221,
-0.2866348624229431,
-0.28886696696281433,
-0.037577662616968155,
0.2964617908000946,
0.29935094714164734,
-0.13544373214244843,
0.44818294048309326,
0.19065523147583008,
-0.9837225675582886,
0.6565685272216797,
0.31053391098976135,
0.5758615732192993,
-0.6373740434646606,
-0.2630210816860199,
-0.2020040899515152,
0.7675328254699707,
-0.1377512812614441,
-0.6315057277679443,
0.1423538476228714,
0.26961901783943176,
-0.04628012329339981,
-0.44133704900741577,
0.7314275503158569,
-0.1791854053735733,
-0.5105727910995483,
0.19827845692634583,
0.6242535710334778,
-0.14138127863407135,
0.06155534088611603,
-0.6967747807502747,
-0.12433316558599472,
0.04124988988041878,
0.026109132915735245,
-0.2168140560388565,
0.87291419506073,
-0.02241937443614006,
0.9466955661773682,
0.6110467910766602,
0.1539798527956009,
-0.5167611837387085,
0.30566075444221497,
1.0260648727416992,
-0.8466470837593079,
-0.3885365426540375,
-1.300751805305481,
0.35484060645103455,
-0.008883802220225334,
0.061657097190618515,
0.8317133188247681,
0.4455423355102539,
0.5425235033035278,
-0.12225860357284546,
0.7553120255470276,
-0.11624061316251755,
0.7157357931137085,
-0.5658872723579407,
0.09000051766633987,
-0.5340905785560608,
0.5206663012504578,
-0.3488239347934723,
-0.6499415040016174,
-0.6658578515052795,
0.7522287368774414,
-0.658399760723114,
0.024859143421053886,
0.8736991882324219,
0.7799075245857239,
-0.2536797523498535,
-0.17077481746673584,
0.13350464403629303,
0.5227617621421814,
0.5192920565605164,
0.6918292045593262,
1.147963047027588,
-0.21351388096809387,
0.4979349374771118,
0.00938358623534441,
-0.24144601821899414,
0.033142946660518646,
-1.2689003944396973,
-1.0351228713989258,
-0.19292767345905304,
-0.5658490657806396,
-0.3854583203792572,
0.14973120391368866,
1.123352289199829,
0.5781097412109375,
-0.6305946707725525,
0.025383004918694496,
-0.4304090738296509,
0.4204365313053131,
-0.08274602890014648,
-0.2099652737379074,
0.25910213589668274,
-0.05019662156701088,
-0.6458582878112793,
0.3535829186439514,
0.28943362832069397,
-0.03535865247249603,
-0.2608037292957306,
-0.17978009581565857,
-0.3391498625278473,
0.3919244706630707,
0.36920469999313354,
0.26621726155281067,
-0.786199688911438,
-0.23453639447689056,
-0.19915910065174103,
-0.07833722978830338,
-0.02599073015153408,
0.8934462070465088,
-0.9783661365509033,
-0.0015927153872326016,
0.7048070430755615,
0.2709595561027527,
0.183368980884552,
0.009676431305706501,
0.6338170170783997,
-0.4232197105884552,
0.22755059599876404,
0.37036892771720886,
0.5316126346588135,
0.36068978905677795,
-0.2902171015739441,
0.31130728125572205,
0.3683944344520569,
-0.43376508355140686,
-0.9093546271324158,
0.37951377034187317,
-0.7852700352668762,
-0.5680806636810303,
1.3559014797210693,
-0.14459922909736633,
0.05114828795194626,
0.11938941478729248,
-0.3345632255077362,
0.17099295556545258,
-0.25324368476867676,
0.7756752967834473,
0.3127290606498718,
-0.06869037449359894,
-0.026916859671473503,
0.07939768582582474,
0.18488112092018127,
0.538436770439148,
-0.9910139441490173,
-0.07309361547231674,
0.6019086241722107,
0.25442975759506226,
0.2006312906742096,
0.3425540626049042,
-0.1981801688671112,
0.09117631614208221,
-0.2464689314365387,
-0.2378363311290741,
-0.19762948155403137,
-0.4172688126564026,
-0.149282306432724,
0.0004239243862684816,
-0.02838742546737194,
0.34187376499176025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06049v1 | Limits of Large Language Models in Debating Humans | 2024-02-06T03:24:27 | 2024-02-06T03:24:27 | James Flamino, Mohammed Shahid Modi, Boleslaw K. Szymanski, Brendan Cross, Colton Mikolajczyk | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, stat.AP | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable promise in their ability
to interact proficiently with humans. Subsequently, their potential use as
artificial confederates and surrogates in sociological experiments involving
conversation is an exciting prospect. But how viable is this idea? This paper
endeavors to test the limits of current-day LLMs with a pre-registered study
integrating real people with LLM agents acting as people. The study focuses on
debate-based opinion consensus formation in three environments: humans only,
agents and humans, and agents only. Our goal is to understand how LLM agents
influence humans, and how capable they are in debating like humans. We find
that LLMs can blend in and facilitate human productivity but are less
convincing in debate, with their behavior ultimately deviating from human's. We
elucidate these primary failings and anticipate that LLMs must evolve further
before being viable debaters. | [
-0.8537235260009766,
-0.9878060221672058,
0.8120071887969971,
0.11561671644449234,
-0.022690637037158012,
0.18075306713581085,
-0.5041555762290955,
-0.7623909115791321,
0.23238879442214966,
0.6990170478820801,
-0.2443622350692749,
-0.09307622164487839,
-0.4388163387775421,
0.22599375247955322,
-0.09939662367105484,
0.8231080770492554,
0.19571799039840698,
0.09445604681968689,
-0.34949541091918945,
-0.2858753204345703,
-0.20472267270088196,
-0.8137751221656799,
-0.5247802138328552,
-0.5605902671813965,
0.6786432862281799,
0.5619717240333557,
1.0117052793502808,
0.28757354617118835,
0.11816960573196411,
0.39812955260276794,
-0.1901644617319107,
-0.04278971999883652,
-0.6984117031097412,
0.2891407907009125,
-0.3222413659095764,
-0.5317411422729492,
-0.4256870150566101,
0.3985101282596588,
0.6897587776184082,
0.8388206958770752,
-0.09245344996452332,
-0.2046278864145279,
0.1319466382265091,
0.4154852032661438,
-0.2488834261894226,
-0.12459588795900345,
-0.7332866191864014,
-0.08579008281230927,
-0.17656627297401428,
0.272097647190094,
-0.4926476776599884,
-0.3583090901374817,
0.25947296619415283,
-0.11875621974468231,
-0.08554461598396301,
0.09182808548212051,
0.8210342526435852,
-0.05750459432601929,
-0.5812032222747803,
-0.12231937795877457,
-0.7191174030303955,
0.5541698336601257,
-0.8801793456077576,
0.15715160965919495,
0.3353545367717743,
0.006035155151039362,
-0.5606253743171692,
-0.5589527487754822,
-0.8611226677894592,
-0.5901929140090942,
0.01882057636976242,
-0.03827929496765137,
-0.3926314413547516,
0.2609965205192566,
0.21125884354114532,
-0.033923253417015076,
-0.1659543663263321,
0.3127482235431671,
-0.3955104649066925,
0.20105381309986115,
0.6187804341316223,
0.22850894927978516,
0.19718037545681,
-0.19474981725215912,
-0.23974187672138214,
0.00246638897806406,
-0.5351948738098145,
-0.1854393184185028,
0.4308510422706604,
0.23174600303173065,
0.1916421502828598,
0.5154582262039185,
-0.08485402911901474,
0.390651673078537,
0.0359741635620594,
0.18284334242343903,
-0.13793694972991943,
-0.02525234967470169,
-0.22083938121795654,
-0.4067421555519104,
0.9137920141220093,
0.404990017414093,
0.36987289786338806,
0.16717000305652618,
-0.08840307593345642,
0.16362358629703522,
0.34423384070396423,
-0.7728505730628967,
-0.05059228092432022,
0.004420953337103128,
-0.16245649755001068,
-0.2629292607307434,
-0.09261322021484375,
-0.696927547454834,
-0.8140483498573303,
-0.07550149410963058,
0.31518828868865967,
0.08421807736158371,
-0.5315257906913757,
0.27810338139533997,
0.0016191129107028246,
0.3646438717842102,
0.39221110939979553,
-0.6365814805030823,
0.6833776235580444,
0.7452746033668518,
0.64384925365448,
-0.07413860410451889,
-0.4706903100013733,
-0.04341010004281998,
-0.09864599257707596,
-0.7555572986602783,
0.8515235781669617,
-0.4180256426334381,
-0.7732870578765869,
-0.07471312582492828,
-0.14108912646770477,
-0.022718636319041252,
-0.7574286460876465,
0.6230852603912354,
-0.5016919374465942,
0.09644868969917297,
-0.47624650597572327,
-0.6501598954200745,
0.03262091428041458,
0.42121103405952454,
-0.6159453988075256,
0.5919537544250488,
-0.08224639296531677,
-0.5281228423118591,
0.07660049945116043,
-0.6803112030029297,
-0.5162410140037537,
0.2563731372356415,
-0.47573474049568176,
-0.14365878701210022,
0.15115371346473694,
-0.3374272584915161,
0.49113595485687256,
-0.46827560663223267,
0.4391842484474182,
-0.5584310293197632,
-0.10326877981424332,
0.8201112747192383,
-0.36623844504356384,
0.676888644695282,
0.1576625406742096,
-0.2619355320930481,
0.32894471287727356,
-0.07946324348449707,
-0.20612329244613647,
0.26276978850364685,
-0.29389113187789917,
-0.0646844431757927,
0.32196253538131714,
-0.1660887748003006,
0.23272567987442017,
-0.025205640122294426,
-0.6696873903274536,
0.25932687520980835,
-0.3104451596736908,
0.748872697353363,
0.8686327934265137,
-0.13605135679244995,
0.4159848392009735,
-0.6985849142074585,
0.643528938293457,
-0.3591461181640625,
0.01178715005517006,
0.35010743141174316,
-0.5783887505531311,
-0.9462751746177673,
0.048574142158031464,
0.1604345440864563,
0.28292039036750793,
-0.6009595990180969,
0.16788755357265472,
-0.35557371377944946,
-0.5491623282432556,
-0.2509978413581848,
0.10016707330942154,
0.09174758940935135,
0.2522701919078827,
-0.03386417031288147,
-0.2453024834394455,
-0.5992605686187744,
-0.9921824932098389,
-0.23296187818050385,
-0.5471220016479492,
-0.07816573977470398,
0.497570663690567,
0.5741065144538879,
-0.2898710370063782,
1.0770788192749023,
-0.2596018612384796,
0.11026424169540405,
-0.8016371726989746,
0.14074987173080444,
0.06013375148177147,
0.27214962244033813,
0.25184446573257446,
-0.6139184236526489,
-0.33235564827919006,
-0.06398963183164597,
-0.5519763231277466,
-0.06754297763109207,
-0.08499063551425934,
-0.05219806358218193,
0.42344895005226135,
0.5570955872535706,
-0.925365149974823,
0.28236472606658936,
0.6775612235069275,
-0.36075037717819214,
0.6631883382797241,
-0.15369299054145813,
-0.07448986917734146,
-0.8522791862487793,
-0.313469260931015,
0.22962278127670288,
-0.37013471126556396,
-0.7930355072021484,
-0.06946956366300583,
-0.22387628257274628,
-0.06542851775884628,
-0.2703458070755005,
0.7789987921714783,
-0.43640875816345215,
0.06409327685832977,
-0.47376489639282227,
0.37304964661598206,
-0.11432972550392151,
0.19855903089046478,
0.24086345732212067,
0.43641215562820435,
0.12136495858430862,
-0.5712583065032959,
0.11742127686738968,
0.0916183665394783,
-0.47240617871284485,
0.6774420142173767,
-0.827353298664093,
0.361341655254364,
-0.09527557343244553,
0.7228044271469116,
-1.0753202438354492,
-0.6248719692230225,
0.24183961749076843,
-0.3667844831943512,
0.024745091795921326,
-0.009701095521450043,
-0.5014408230781555,
-0.4753229022026062,
-0.4268656075000763,
0.23874785006046295,
0.48852741718292236,
-0.20895402133464813,
0.6662600636482239,
0.6762107610702515,
-0.45737409591674805,
-0.17193566262722015,
-0.6010112762451172,
0.6733061075210571,
-0.2542940378189087,
-0.8053649067878723,
-0.0344262532889843,
-0.17501245439052582,
-0.925167441368103,
-0.19787020981311798,
0.36925312876701355,
0.03715713322162628,
-0.02566796913743019,
0.25477612018585205,
0.3359980881214142,
-0.0885947123169899,
0.23898667097091675,
-0.17354537546634674,
0.26171180605888367,
0.08155696094036102,
0.17856091260910034,
0.42976877093315125,
-0.3238329589366913,
-0.4022867977619171,
-0.30363035202026367,
0.3649977445602417,
0.8040618896484375,
0.054983485490083694,
0.6784676909446716,
-0.09250160306692123,
-0.26718828082084656,
-0.23604178428649902,
-1.0099622011184692,
-0.23648114502429962,
-0.5233802199363708,
0.7426081299781799,
-0.294048935174942,
-1.1058247089385986,
0.45113980770111084,
-0.12244609743356705,
0.2958003282546997,
0.28046485781669617,
0.6566729545593262,
-0.1077393963932991,
0.8504307270050049,
0.28292524814605713,
0.03182999789714813,
0.1594448685646057,
0.1517770141363144,
0.005346574354916811,
-0.8809562921524048,
0.012000440619885921,
-0.5274079442024231,
-0.4096558392047882,
-0.5066606402397156,
-0.6165273189544678,
0.2659890353679657,
-0.16644704341888428,
-0.20984819531440735,
0.02820822410285473,
-0.15354220569133759,
0.6638782024383545,
0.037880878895521164,
0.06030875816941261,
0.08368833363056183,
-0.36483296751976013,
0.20016267895698547,
-0.1051253080368042,
-0.6418901085853577,
-0.7008441090583801,
0.808357834815979,
0.5504470467567444,
0.7810343503952026,
0.16048435866832733,
0.26118218898773193,
0.47579318284988403,
0.7319382429122925,
-0.8784997463226318,
0.9141329526901245,
0.18938198685646057,
-0.9028251767158508,
-0.561309278011322,
-0.353998601436615,
-1.1176313161849976,
0.6543218493461609,
-0.2654508948326111,
-0.6349353790283203,
0.17772379517555237,
-0.09240899235010147,
-0.15371578931808472,
0.5655738115310669,
-0.47698670625686646,
0.7529007792472839,
-0.1719755083322525,
-0.5900154113769531,
-0.2843095362186432,
-0.6913527846336365,
0.3800765573978424,
0.05739525705575943,
0.5216089487075806,
-0.24599982798099518,
-0.1356423795223236,
0.7734763026237488,
-0.23194801807403564,
1.1632078886032104,
-0.022442804649472237,
-0.38607093691825867,
0.4906291365623474,
0.14491137862205505,
0.48811474442481995,
-0.15005812048912048,
-0.1962965726852417,
0.06148301810026169,
-0.37368154525756836,
-0.47200730443000793,
-0.21770046651363373,
0.6003413796424866,
-0.8704049587249756,
-1.2329126596450806,
-0.37452855706214905,
-0.5206515789031982,
-0.3129267990589142,
0.028453242033720016,
-0.06958004087209702,
0.09347618371248245,
-0.6340786814689636,
0.42368191480636597,
0.5240347385406494,
-0.025708597153425217,
0.30857810378074646,
0.5666034817695618,
-0.48128363490104675,
-0.47711947560310364,
0.6334199905395508,
0.22368314862251282,
0.5471267104148865,
-0.19818921387195587,
0.5234697461128235,
-0.3371172547340393,
-0.49756330251693726,
-0.2605244815349579,
0.3089107871055603,
-0.7876085042953491,
0.18730908632278442,
-0.5983205437660217,
-0.008552317507565022,
-0.34264448285102844,
-0.22247979044914246,
-0.3714424967765808,
-0.07505665719509125,
-0.3430371880531311,
-0.128186896443367,
-0.04346594214439392,
1.2060853242874146,
-0.040698010474443436,
0.06544951349496841,
-0.5435425639152527,
-0.002839930122718215,
0.7843847870826721,
0.04197743907570839,
0.11843211948871613,
-0.6188305616378784,
-0.002202429575845599,
0.11424136906862259,
-0.3459332287311554,
-1.0039138793945312,
0.12096378207206726,
-0.09774944186210632,
0.4679771661758423,
0.4873766601085663,
0.34860169887542725,
0.42990386486053467,
-0.45426687598228455,
0.879195511341095,
0.03266194090247154,
-0.9147313833236694,
-0.12964805960655212,
-0.5906572341918945,
0.09532930701971054,
0.36317288875579834,
0.2980908155441284,
-0.7039191126823425,
-0.5704219341278076,
-0.5714824199676514,
-0.5810368061065674,
0.4703432023525238,
0.13404354453086853,
0.5601183772087097,
-0.15046356618404388,
0.2837072014808655,
-0.02476269192993641,
-0.09897391498088837,
-0.8528656363487244,
0.12536349892616272,
0.21258297562599182,
0.3622257709503174,
-0.13125061988830566,
-0.4753846526145935,
-0.30977222323417664,
-0.3330574631690979,
0.34679001569747925,
-0.031135519966483116,
-0.18610301613807678,
0.3037194311618805,
0.10194187611341476,
-0.33249732851982117,
0.6585463285446167,
0.8477339744567871,
0.9179273843765259,
0.1229683980345726,
0.31371650099754333,
0.6053023934364319,
0.006108048837631941,
0.36162441968917847,
-0.1794092208147049,
0.07055467367172241,
-0.20748451352119446,
0.22343763709068298,
0.8054567575454712,
0.22144715487957,
-0.8423340916633606,
0.4084794819355011,
-0.2466660588979721,
-0.5932889580726624,
-0.35271504521369934,
0.02068549208343029,
0.7119210362434387,
0.5983790755271912,
0.33038637042045593,
-0.016562804579734802,
-0.31652677059173584,
-0.8630066514015198,
0.01840934343636036,
0.7140625715255737,
-0.18528473377227783,
-0.3466336727142334,
0.5309603214263916,
0.4865143895149231,
-0.7132103443145752,
0.23978888988494873,
-0.28726816177368164,
-0.6480115652084351,
0.5557010769844055,
0.4575088322162628,
0.8075768947601318,
-0.07821725308895111,
0.19775985181331635,
-0.08361317962408066,
0.39769595861434937,
-0.2506777346134186,
-0.08372010290622711,
0.0982690155506134,
-1.0497058629989624,
-0.39257586002349854,
-0.2689732015132904,
-1.0444262027740479,
0.1281638890504837,
-0.4437762498855591,
0.2071099877357483,
-0.46416088938713074,
-0.5674331188201904,
0.06525257229804993,
0.14480997622013092,
-0.1244095042347908,
-0.22845502197742462,
0.33363109827041626,
0.6567777395248413,
-0.6204476356506348,
0.818841814994812,
0.714776337146759,
0.0428510345518589,
-0.31103262305259705,
0.1249208077788353,
-0.052179187536239624,
-0.4254860281944275,
0.4195612668991089,
0.04660922288894653,
-0.3664657771587372,
-0.1174587607383728,
-1.034541130065918,
-0.3099488317966461,
0.6430513262748718,
0.5061545372009277,
-0.5419881939888,
-0.012129757553339005,
0.07099517434835434,
0.6867232322692871,
-0.28475645184516907,
0.14446917176246643,
0.4936022460460663,
0.5614697337150574,
0.20426370203495026,
-1.0923765897750854,
0.04741878807544708,
-0.20789361000061035,
-0.06279657036066055,
-0.055648088455200195,
-0.9468898773193359,
1.174484133720398,
-0.34793150424957275,
-0.12675635516643524,
0.27732551097869873,
0.7795660495758057,
0.374592125415802,
0.11032818257808685,
0.7694563865661621,
0.21630701422691345,
0.6374696493148804,
0.24540789425373077,
1.1101341247558594,
0.012382080778479576,
0.15746012330055237,
1.0842206478118896,
-0.7774258255958557,
0.9954122304916382,
0.27497804164886475,
-0.36861735582351685,
0.5047979950904846,
0.4047246277332306,
0.24467530846595764,
-0.4095253050327301,
0.7044050693511963,
-0.5288307070732117,
-0.5444314479827881,
-0.3509145975112915,
-0.15127673745155334,
0.37362292408943176,
0.38353946805000305,
0.08708517998456955,
0.17243467271327972,
-0.09548060595989227,
0.49068716168403625,
0.2544163465499878,
-0.05098547413945198,
0.7773229479789734,
0.15316712856292725,
-0.8222050666809082,
0.49016985297203064,
-0.033846016973257065,
0.7084287405014038,
-0.4825628399848938,
0.15295623242855072,
-0.08465681970119476,
-0.04252789542078972,
-0.022016171365976334,
-0.793509304523468,
-0.176104336977005,
0.032744359225034714,
0.13974669575691223,
-0.11600025743246078,
0.7510595917701721,
-0.29575616121292114,
-0.31720906496047974,
0.3260740637779236,
0.6953568458557129,
0.2837843596935272,
0.041515905410051346,
-0.27079448103904724,
0.21313221752643585,
-0.09542182832956314,
-0.6149284243583679,
0.5520341992378235,
0.3981419801712036,
-0.07748563587665558,
0.7882454991340637,
0.518475353717804,
0.18836069107055664,
-0.20586226880550385,
-0.10382868349552155,
1.0750606060028076,
-0.6403873562812805,
-0.30769744515419006,
-1.100321888923645,
0.13590271770954132,
-0.2350262850522995,
-0.160959392786026,
0.6823105216026306,
0.3066701292991638,
0.5485363006591797,
0.2702101171016693,
0.8974698185920715,
0.021109523251652718,
0.2477215975522995,
-0.0838465541601181,
0.889759361743927,
-0.31450462341308594,
0.04758256673812866,
-0.2748439908027649,
-0.6156291961669922,
-0.006708513479679823,
0.4994736611843109,
-0.383873850107193,
0.07825804501771927,
0.535422146320343,
0.6200863718986511,
0.3585452139377594,
0.23791278898715973,
0.6215794086456299,
0.5319244861602783,
0.47942858934402466,
0.42622071504592896,
1.3475807905197144,
0.39855220913887024,
0.5105821490287781,
0.01670914702117443,
-0.17017395794391632,
-0.10362505912780762,
-0.6420793533325195,
-1.1959103345870972,
-0.2846841514110565,
-0.1109980046749115,
-0.37118157744407654,
-0.15239426493644714,
1.1641372442245483,
0.5739819407463074,
-0.32660147547721863,
-0.7165096998214722,
0.02937282994389534,
0.14634929597377777,
0.4551151394844055,
-0.2108466923236847,
-0.10648999363183975,
-0.028550036251544952,
-0.9557984471321106,
0.4162888526916504,
0.027948161587119102,
0.08393224328756332,
-0.7203835844993591,
-0.4007323980331421,
-0.24475900828838348,
0.673667848110199,
0.6697722673416138,
0.5445660948753357,
-0.8408493399620056,
-0.35688021779060364,
-0.10289065539836884,
-0.19256511330604553,
0.04078125208616257,
0.885043203830719,
-0.6292092800140381,
0.4203612506389618,
0.3153474032878876,
0.47279220819473267,
0.17639575898647308,
0.13333234190940857,
0.7107270359992981,
-0.38399943709373474,
0.1411977857351303,
0.5488830208778381,
0.25940626859664917,
0.28135478496551514,
0.17376050353050232,
0.32064956426620483,
0.24879662692546844,
-0.9009133577346802,
-0.9150176644325256,
0.3253813683986664,
-0.5995372533798218,
-0.4597136080265045,
1.2770639657974243,
-0.031410228461027145,
-0.03903678432106972,
-0.29906123876571655,
-0.4301246702671051,
0.006990843918174505,
-0.571921169757843,
0.6968051195144653,
0.8757649064064026,
-0.3645622432231903,
-0.04436860606074333,
-0.7964000701904297,
0.25423598289489746,
0.40933600068092346,
-0.9096621870994568,
0.2977258861064911,
0.5617120862007141,
0.10670430958271027,
0.07959664613008499,
1.027051329612732,
0.22316867113113403,
-0.026783639565110207,
-0.004023930989205837,
-0.03348482772707939,
0.2589152157306671,
-0.0947614312171936,
-0.21337364614009857,
0.24533528089523315,
0.509488046169281,
0.2563836872577667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03659v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03659v3 | Learning to Generate Explainable Stock Predictions using Self-Reflective Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T03:18:58 | 2024-02-29T12:10:37 | Kelvin J. L. Koa, Yunshan Ma, Ritchie Ng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, q-fin.ST | Explaining stock predictions is generally a difficult task for traditional
non-generative deep learning models, where explanations are limited to
visualizing the attention weights on important texts. Today, Large Language
Models (LLMs) present a solution to this problem, given their known
capabilities to generate human-readable explanations for their decision-making
process. However, the task of stock prediction remains challenging for LLMs, as
it requires the ability to weigh the varying impacts of chaotic social texts on
stock prices. The problem gets progressively harder with the introduction of
the explanation component, which requires LLMs to explain verbally why certain
factors are more important than the others. On the other hand, to fine-tune
LLMs for such a task, one would need expert-annotated samples of explanation
for every stock movement in the training set, which is expensive and
impractical to scale. To tackle these issues, we propose our
Summarize-Explain-Predict (SEP) framework, which utilizes a self-reflective
agent and Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) to let a LLM teach itself how to
generate explainable stock predictions in a fully autonomous manner. The
reflective agent learns how to explain past stock movements through
self-reasoning, while the PPO trainer trains the model to generate the most
likely explanations from input texts. The training samples for the PPO trainer
are also the responses generated during the reflective process, which
eliminates the need for human annotators. Using our SEP framework, we fine-tune
a LLM that can outperform both traditional deep-learning and LLM methods in
prediction accuracy and Matthews correlation coefficient for the stock
classification task. To justify the generalization capability of our framework,
we further test it on the portfolio construction task, and demonstrate its
effectiveness through various portfolio metrics. | [
-0.21937239170074463,
-0.42659807205200195,
0.3997848331928253,
0.20322652161121368,
-0.4310991168022156,
0.12045934051275253,
-0.4464340806007385,
-0.41302940249443054,
0.26299792528152466,
0.5173352360725403,
-0.7187849283218384,
-0.47199326753616333,
-0.5706399083137512,
-0.003545521991327405,
-0.4022640287876129,
1.170377254486084,
-0.13591983914375305,
0.06501629203557968,
0.28299859166145325,
0.1765984147787094,
-0.36662915349006653,
-0.3008328676223755,
-0.5871247053146362,
-0.401439905166626,
0.24098068475723267,
0.32879191637039185,
0.7984564304351807,
0.6980382800102234,
0.3393029272556305,
0.3601093888282776,
0.20283977687358856,
0.23013177514076233,
-0.5490114092826843,
0.18773168325424194,
-0.08163299411535263,
-0.27652692794799805,
-0.4317223131656647,
-0.04858719930052757,
0.6663371324539185,
0.5725448131561279,
-0.2668042480945587,
0.20734860002994537,
0.35877612233161926,
0.5153904557228088,
-0.6708894968032837,
0.3979271948337555,
-0.7144731879234314,
0.15333569049835205,
0.06783688813447952,
-0.3368595838546753,
-0.4694928526878357,
-0.03354380652308464,
0.1788325011730194,
-0.7716365456581116,
0.33649617433547974,
0.27793192863464355,
0.7182362079620361,
0.06509645283222198,
-0.19043494760990143,
-0.19586926698684692,
-0.8530588150024414,
0.9196391105651855,
-0.636974036693573,
0.15785816311836243,
0.3367634415626526,
0.29925039410591125,
-0.17429356276988983,
-0.5013895034790039,
-0.4376104772090912,
-0.002928137546405196,
-0.06841260194778442,
0.23898476362228394,
0.05461208149790764,
0.0403379388153553,
-0.23628883063793182,
0.43131765723228455,
-0.4473951756954193,
0.42478182911872864,
-0.3519729673862457,
-0.1943577527999878,
0.9293011426925659,
0.28405386209487915,
-0.15226785838603973,
0.030674610286951065,
-0.6189368367195129,
-0.08849159628152847,
-0.5916423797607422,
-0.12456859648227692,
0.3031291365623474,
0.3337478041648865,
-0.06756072491407394,
0.3179856836795807,
-0.018157878890633583,
0.4210171401500702,
0.2806270122528076,
0.039503686130046844,
0.20166748762130737,
-0.09511740505695343,
-0.3827531635761261,
0.24361230432987213,
0.8779526948928833,
0.4762207269668579,
0.2871483862400055,
-0.13186942040920258,
-0.31340259313583374,
-0.3059552013874054,
0.17498372495174408,
-0.8413423299789429,
-0.32180681824684143,
0.29987987875938416,
-0.6001148223876953,
-0.38908129930496216,
-0.15602168440818787,
-0.9009172916412354,
-0.506807804107666,
-0.43683862686157227,
0.5966741442680359,
-0.2419676035642624,
-0.3279191851615906,
0.3229750096797943,
-0.03437234088778496,
0.2216113805770874,
0.48876574635505676,
-1.1191728115081787,
0.10540241003036499,
0.7692905068397522,
0.688571035861969,
-0.0814548209309578,
-0.6363518834114075,
-0.5988487005233765,
0.3950847387313843,
-0.6353399753570557,
0.6682742834091187,
-0.34870877861976624,
-0.3225342333316803,
0.013209028169512749,
-0.21737046539783478,
-0.02061925083398819,
-0.5076677799224854,
-0.014473517425358295,
-0.3959692716598511,
0.4675096571445465,
-0.3208804726600647,
-0.6271862387657166,
-0.2629730999469757,
0.20398299396038055,
-0.31186798214912415,
0.5634561777114868,
-0.2609877288341522,
-0.7346488237380981,
0.5863635540008545,
-0.8524467945098877,
-0.2547317147254944,
0.14937017858028412,
-0.2484641820192337,
-0.39479535818099976,
-0.055557556450366974,
0.5105047821998596,
0.9298655986785889,
-0.21329686045646667,
0.36808159947395325,
-0.4675609767436981,
-0.36654189229011536,
0.5097463130950928,
-0.2785697877407074,
0.23771488666534424,
0.2790778577327728,
-0.447909951210022,
0.21708683669567108,
-0.49837201833724976,
-0.27556824684143066,
0.26569390296936035,
0.05252638831734657,
-0.1825512796640396,
0.2669597864151001,
-0.4079342782497406,
-0.10781288892030716,
0.3729950487613678,
-0.1717776656150818,
-0.017504682764410973,
-0.5472978353500366,
0.2507610023021698,
1.3018399477005005,
-0.08102254569530487,
0.5653030872344971,
-0.09002114087343216,
0.7316298484802246,
0.1577398180961609,
0.28630557656288147,
-0.4017691910266876,
-0.018499577417969704,
-0.436657577753067,
-0.369338721036911,
0.10915418714284897,
0.3338845372200012,
-0.42725345492362976,
0.20247741043567657,
-0.18244501948356628,
-0.31997150182724,
-0.35297009348869324,
0.3866344392299652,
0.2768101692199707,
0.5540583729743958,
0.38096076250076294,
-0.1944349855184555,
-0.49654293060302734,
-1.0548452138900757,
-0.4165634214878082,
-0.14738816022872925,
-0.13437709212303162,
-0.031508076936006546,
0.4271199703216553,
0.029765715822577477,
0.6767991781234741,
-0.7063983678817749,
-0.26548826694488525,
-0.3944142162799835,
0.3666459619998932,
0.23554199934005737,
0.06411680579185486,
0.26891887187957764,
-0.5207290649414062,
-0.24426749348640442,
-0.003257014090195298,
-0.7420631051063538,
0.13718311488628387,
-0.5592905879020691,
-0.014657454565167427,
-0.0037577033508569,
0.48111164569854736,
-0.2759198844432831,
0.1115558072924614,
0.4864327609539032,
-0.2909426689147949,
0.713458776473999,
-0.28064537048339844,
-0.41302236914634705,
-1.2115975618362427,
-0.20267891883850098,
0.37222644686698914,
-0.1760517656803131,
-0.3708597421646118,
-0.1262471079826355,
-0.2892261743545532,
0.01279702503234148,
-0.09235189855098724,
0.5910386443138123,
-0.6200825572013855,
-0.23906444013118744,
-0.363220751285553,
0.17801149189472198,
-0.025187276303768158,
0.4429852068424225,
-0.007988093420863152,
0.8377795219421387,
0.6320670247077942,
-0.5696060657501221,
-0.026229767128825188,
0.16217011213302612,
-0.4151335060596466,
0.003930557519197464,
-0.5959612131118774,
-0.3643214702606201,
-0.29707658290863037,
0.2608051002025604,
-1.0591857433319092,
-0.18187586963176727,
0.19050602614879608,
-0.2994157373905182,
0.43857961893081665,
0.04930747672915459,
-0.35425397753715515,
-0.2933446168899536,
-0.4304054379463196,
-0.03228716552257538,
0.38610219955444336,
-0.7913641929626465,
0.7815537452697754,
0.23206093907356262,
-0.1428568959236145,
-0.8914889693260193,
-0.7759569883346558,
0.15180373191833496,
-0.42821839451789856,
-0.3762463629245758,
0.30451518297195435,
-0.059828296303749084,
-0.3125082850456238,
-0.2372315376996994,
-0.03762412443757057,
0.14249682426452637,
0.34426385164260864,
0.3057175278663635,
0.5203807353973389,
-0.20202197134494781,
0.5003848671913147,
-0.03453502431511879,
-0.2931784987449646,
0.37445834279060364,
-0.14877191185951233,
0.3814166486263275,
-0.4131907820701599,
-0.1841380000114441,
-0.44117113947868347,
0.09996585547924042,
0.3895617425441742,
-0.2648020386695862,
0.9221576452255249,
0.63005131483078,
0.06807252764701843,
-0.6078484654426575,
-0.4644406735897064,
-0.38137736916542053,
-0.5566137433052063,
0.4565233588218689,
-0.3193337321281433,
-0.7977088689804077,
0.7987712621688843,
-0.15945792198181152,
0.1828681379556656,
0.7019726037979126,
0.6995419859886169,
-0.0055432128719985485,
1.1220617294311523,
0.5340803265571594,
-0.04253702983260155,
0.44729888439178467,
-0.3860909342765808,
0.4514554738998413,
-0.5971857905387878,
-0.21368096768856049,
0.044258881360292435,
-0.563884973526001,
-0.5015619397163391,
-0.16922417283058167,
0.20982147753238678,
0.04569392278790474,
-0.3770691454410553,
0.058678336441516876,
-0.6592912673950195,
0.5590848326683044,
0.5250256061553955,
-0.18463341891765594,
0.31146708130836487,
0.06923435628414154,
-0.003983751870691776,
0.037886105477809906,
-0.4948190152645111,
-0.4752618372440338,
1.1495466232299805,
0.7234637141227722,
1.100847601890564,
-0.26909446716308594,
0.881044328212738,
0.23614192008972168,
0.4304177463054657,
-0.8104565143585205,
0.5579370260238647,
-0.3896139860153198,
-0.4613863229751587,
-0.26675355434417725,
-0.4101456105709076,
-0.6815992593765259,
0.42504069209098816,
-0.28695952892303467,
-0.537580668926239,
0.2648857831954956,
0.29339203238487244,
-0.4722585082054138,
0.24748308956623077,
-0.9122934341430664,
0.877217173576355,
-0.5385777354240417,
-0.24171648919582367,
-0.3434201180934906,
-0.5032679438591003,
0.38814815878868103,
-0.15063701570034027,
0.24305742979049683,
-0.12126265466213226,
-0.17046350240707397,
0.7747469544410706,
-0.3957150876522064,
1.2053717374801636,
-0.11271407455205917,
-0.15896208584308624,
0.172383651137352,
0.21421006321907043,
0.48176491260528564,
-0.16697806119918823,
-0.15529948472976685,
0.14531640708446503,
-0.17518223822116852,
-0.2244376838207245,
-0.6492642760276794,
0.472319096326828,
-0.8953953981399536,
-0.49147897958755493,
-0.20089860260486603,
-0.43531927466392517,
-0.05665677785873413,
-0.16722027957439423,
0.30371615290641785,
0.2195344716310501,
0.09849660843610764,
0.053312819451093674,
0.3600117564201355,
-0.07857991755008698,
0.4607420265674591,
0.6164418458938599,
-0.47462141513824463,
-0.47119781374931335,
1.015885829925537,
0.2569587826728821,
-0.033213697373867035,
0.3044070899486542,
0.5844435095787048,
-0.5325207114219666,
-0.7013792395591736,
-0.16978751122951508,
0.21395644545555115,
-0.6667649149894714,
-0.15730662643909454,
-0.44712722301483154,
-0.09576908499002457,
-0.18355369567871094,
-0.3393339216709137,
-0.413287490606308,
-0.25293847918510437,
-0.6600477695465088,
-0.4667810797691345,
0.18812958896160126,
0.8340328335762024,
-0.24602848291397095,
0.3740285634994507,
-0.5833636522293091,
0.1920049637556076,
0.4670051038265228,
0.34256577491760254,
0.3193100392818451,
-0.6183562874794006,
-0.47212663292884827,
0.18596461415290833,
-0.4953329861164093,
-0.7279261946678162,
0.5701685547828674,
0.2745932936668396,
0.34185290336608887,
0.7585272192955017,
0.16110867261886597,
0.7844692468643188,
-0.06208965182304382,
0.6304453611373901,
0.3836945593357086,
-0.9435502886772156,
0.6171713471412659,
-0.3868088126182556,
0.040176451206207275,
0.3985550105571747,
0.41628313064575195,
-0.14047078788280487,
-0.4986542761325836,
-0.48182806372642517,
-0.9750748872756958,
0.5304914116859436,
-0.110276959836483,
0.2212647646665573,
-0.1297689825296402,
0.5084138512611389,
0.4462997317314148,
0.22914274036884308,
-0.8430818319320679,
-0.0033568732906132936,
-0.2916428744792938,
-0.2878127694129944,
-0.31902310252189636,
-0.4170553684234619,
-0.0628252625465393,
-0.1342536062002182,
0.7201322913169861,
-0.3497790992259979,
0.03386718034744263,
0.17479710280895233,
0.013470076955854893,
-0.19130069017410278,
0.2026875913143158,
0.5183683037757874,
0.8655721545219421,
-0.16177614033222198,
0.17158696055412292,
0.2782473862171173,
-0.03418773412704468,
-0.26177096366882324,
0.23197932541370392,
0.1270042508840561,
-0.17532187700271606,
0.5390189290046692,
0.7711998224258423,
0.15766368806362152,
-0.784846305847168,
0.6126344799995422,
0.01948794536292553,
-0.4678244888782501,
-0.6476885676383972,
-0.016970964148640633,
0.09667090326547623,
0.542819619178772,
0.5828740000724792,
-0.27206090092658997,
0.19106325507164001,
-0.5134955644607544,
-0.01329880952835083,
0.4413825273513794,
-0.1443154662847519,
-0.45083364844322205,
0.6934903264045715,
0.09674958139657974,
0.23638476431369781,
0.4253445863723755,
-0.2739070653915405,
-0.75273597240448,
0.5560545921325684,
0.5193572640419006,
1.1417255401611328,
-0.15114161372184753,
0.5180832147598267,
0.22818629443645477,
0.21265357732772827,
-0.32275474071502686,
0.20092786848545074,
-0.027298588305711746,
-0.9167429804801941,
-0.8559929728507996,
-0.664618730545044,
-0.6196714043617249,
0.2540964186191559,
-0.5656047463417053,
0.1461934745311737,
-0.5935412645339966,
-0.04157465696334839,
0.22418631613254547,
-0.06239582598209381,
-0.4077525734901428,
0.2623683512210846,
0.255962610244751,
0.4577747881412506,
-0.9149836897850037,
0.26449689269065857,
0.4581858515739441,
-0.3059876263141632,
-0.8194150328636169,
-0.001725466107018292,
-0.27103155851364136,
-1.2058197259902954,
0.7821049690246582,
0.2504310607910156,
-0.11319281905889511,
-0.461483359336853,
-0.6818478107452393,
-0.5613735318183899,
0.9274488687515259,
0.5038172602653503,
-0.735497772693634,
0.11359121650457382,
-0.054623354226350784,
0.6627887487411499,
-0.5583195090293884,
0.10273232311010361,
0.13426490128040314,
0.3542117178440094,
0.2858251631259918,
-0.5797872543334961,
0.05967568978667259,
-0.04108772799372673,
-0.1303223967552185,
0.31999558210372925,
-0.6771474480628967,
0.8578938245773315,
-0.4320034682750702,
-0.0245542973279953,
-0.2897293269634247,
0.8324223160743713,
0.10522238165140152,
0.5175613760948181,
0.4586320221424103,
0.5394865870475769,
0.5946469306945801,
0.2625395655632019,
1.0617421865463257,
-0.525802493095398,
0.3603774607181549,
1.546308159828186,
-0.2560195028781891,
1.1052857637405396,
0.21500390768051147,
-0.01713760383427143,
0.6219379305839539,
0.7735143303871155,
-0.3188250958919525,
0.330169677734375,
0.2508210837841034,
-0.21361176669597626,
-0.7526152729988098,
-0.024451415985822678,
-0.32705551385879517,
0.7361714243888855,
0.2693297863006592,
-0.8629649877548218,
-0.14426875114440918,
-0.13403382897377014,
-0.171746164560318,
-0.013906296342611313,
-0.4065602421760559,
0.8486456871032715,
0.18752387166023254,
-0.49862807989120483,
0.31110769510269165,
-0.06372030824422836,
0.4765731394290924,
-0.6127426624298096,
0.20762065052986145,
-0.012197119183838367,
0.4871200621128082,
-0.024955175817012787,
-0.9472454786300659,
0.37216728925704956,
-0.22587741911411285,
-0.06923812627792358,
-0.6554979085922241,
0.7008731365203857,
-0.43758195638656616,
-0.5579636693000793,
0.33876311779022217,
0.3915695548057556,
0.10455657541751862,
-0.24876761436462402,
-0.6816415786743164,
-0.36827462911605835,
0.01674700155854225,
-0.45433902740478516,
0.39957019686698914,
0.41157129406929016,
0.20676745474338531,
1.0179810523986816,
0.7061986327171326,
-0.008126153610646725,
-0.2599126994609833,
-0.07684249430894852,
0.7943720817565918,
-0.6046463847160339,
-0.6367442011833191,
-0.9702922105789185,
0.29817995429039,
0.05212032049894333,
-0.18987855315208435,
0.5305157899856567,
0.605846643447876,
0.3653954565525055,
-0.09917080402374268,
0.6676844358444214,
0.6378208994865417,
0.5739261507987976,
-0.5044850707054138,
0.6760311126708984,
-0.6778704524040222,
0.4043635129928589,
0.17068171501159668,
-0.7727680206298828,
-0.1307530403137207,
0.5982751846313477,
-0.6262716054916382,
0.08518345654010773,
0.5565470457077026,
0.6014810800552368,
0.010463335551321507,
0.34684649109840393,
0.22565558552742004,
0.6650360226631165,
0.11760398745536804,
0.17924845218658447,
0.7657912969589233,
-0.15123598277568817,
0.6655797362327576,
-0.3487975299358368,
0.04117383062839508,
-0.2562176287174225,
-1.0816084146499634,
-0.9053204655647278,
-0.4174410402774811,
-0.6145377159118652,
-0.21623770892620087,
-0.12437361478805542,
0.8859353065490723,
0.6551619172096252,
-0.6383862495422363,
-0.34006503224372864,
-0.014516407623887062,
0.060175247490406036,
-0.1738203912973404,
-0.2704888582229614,
0.39507609605789185,
-0.45751479268074036,
-0.2965937554836273,
0.36487898230552673,
0.3642699718475342,
0.20136353373527527,
-0.557607114315033,
-0.10621681064367294,
0.33512774109840393,
-0.005608279258012772,
0.7113372087478638,
0.1893189698457718,
-0.5549883842468262,
-0.09917119890451431,
-0.11701500415802002,
0.3527384400367737,
-0.10738877952098846,
0.48889434337615967,
-0.5790326595306396,
0.5264898538589478,
0.3238945007324219,
0.5670323967933655,
0.5727258324623108,
0.0336536169052124,
0.821316123008728,
-0.5227539539337158,
-0.17518649995326996,
0.23844090104103088,
0.4012106657028198,
0.22040192782878876,
-0.4081890881061554,
0.421817421913147,
-0.1346368044614792,
-0.6261212229728699,
-0.5602870583534241,
-0.03580066189169884,
-0.8723484873771667,
-0.452022910118103,
1.0116472244262695,
-0.053438834846019745,
-0.3664487302303314,
0.2300989329814911,
0.01870582066476345,
0.007735423278063536,
-0.5077566504478455,
1.079224705696106,
0.5895253419876099,
-0.021168990060687065,
-0.37227991223335266,
-0.3497457802295685,
0.24214842915534973,
0.5267480611801147,
-0.4872399568557739,
0.43089109659194946,
0.3627595603466034,
0.29238268733024597,
-0.11497955769300461,
0.5544891953468323,
0.16176536679267883,
0.062022559344768524,
-0.18746550381183624,
0.04556756466627121,
-0.18474888801574707,
-0.24938437342643738,
-0.337749719619751,
0.2589738070964813,
0.15469032526016235,
-0.5258702039718628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03658v1 | Sentiment-enhanced Graph-based Sarcasm Explanation in Dialogue | 2024-02-06T03:14:46 | 2024-02-06T03:14:46 | Kun Ouyang, Liqiang Jing, Xuemeng Song, Meng Liu, Yupeng Hu, Liqiang Nie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | Sarcasm Explanation in Dialogue (SED) is a new yet challenging task, which
aims to generate a natural language explanation for the given sarcastic
dialogue that involves multiple modalities (i.e., utterance, video, and audio).
Although existing studies have achieved great success based on the generative
pretrained language model BART, they overlook exploiting the sentiments
residing in the utterance, video and audio, which are vital clues for sarcasm
explanation. In fact, it is non-trivial to incorporate sentiments for boosting
SED performance, due to three main challenges: 1) diverse effects of utterance
tokens on sentiments; 2) gap between video-audio sentiment signals and the
embedding space of BART; and 3) various relations among utterances, utterance
sentiments, and video-audio sentiments. To tackle these challenges, we propose
a novel sEntiment-enhanceD Graph-based multimodal sarcasm Explanation
framework, named EDGE. In particular, we first propose a lexicon-guided
utterance sentiment inference module, where a heuristic utterance sentiment
refinement strategy is devised. We then develop a module named Joint Cross
Attention-based Sentiment Inference (JCA-SI) by extending the multimodal
sentiment analysis model JCA to derive the joint sentiment label for each
video-audio clip. Thereafter, we devise a context-sentiment graph to
comprehensively model the semantic relations among the utterances, utterance
sentiments, and video-audio sentiments, to facilitate sarcasm explanation
generation. Extensive experiments on the publicly released dataset WITS verify
the superiority of our model over cutting-edge methods. | [
-0.4943898022174835,
-1.0703619718551636,
0.403076708316803,
0.17120768129825592,
-0.3744152784347534,
0.1452684849500656,
-0.060659732669591904,
-0.07669102400541306,
0.3864622414112091,
0.2626311182975769,
-1.1703219413757324,
-0.6626907587051392,
-0.48110681772232056,
0.029502885416150093,
0.13311727344989777,
1.254982829093933,
0.2176862359046936,
0.33243659138679504,
-0.1600036919116974,
-0.34600937366485596,
-0.4357703626155853,
-0.2621414363384247,
-0.6484165787696838,
-0.02280607633292675,
0.448045015335083,
0.20182101428508759,
0.7167608141899109,
0.10527383536100388,
0.4751823842525482,
0.2900388836860657,
-0.24581429362297058,
0.03222265467047691,
-0.4396214783191681,
0.11019591987133026,
0.08200205862522125,
-0.048761237412691116,
-0.599753737449646,
-0.36557838320732117,
0.4991791844367981,
0.6655550599098206,
0.34462007880210876,
-0.06310146301984787,
-0.12258108705282211,
0.4566926658153534,
-0.5509971380233765,
0.18373802304267883,
-0.48158150911331177,
0.07731886953115463,
0.028208661824464798,
-0.3895515501499176,
-0.3295571506023407,
-0.4125538170337677,
0.037996407598257065,
-0.5210435390472412,
0.18175339698791504,
-0.4556119441986084,
0.7780316472053528,
0.5175783038139343,
-0.5445150136947632,
-0.04829873517155647,
-0.44610071182250977,
0.3993704915046692,
-0.7232273817062378,
0.2621183395385742,
-0.22177089750766754,
0.37090420722961426,
0.08575772494077682,
-0.5038022994995117,
-0.5396000146865845,
0.17984001338481903,
0.27138811349868774,
0.4611993432044983,
0.03666146099567413,
0.5887037515640259,
0.538467526435852,
0.3166930675506592,
-0.47748368978500366,
-0.30702146887779236,
0.13142547011375427,
-0.3292597830295563,
0.38268136978149414,
0.17483730614185333,
0.50948166847229,
-0.642654538154602,
-0.65594083070755,
-0.14135141670703888,
-0.347782164812088,
0.3392064869403839,
0.4103507995605469,
0.38632357120513916,
-0.19060491025447845,
0.37583285570144653,
-0.10166231542825699,
0.2249520868062973,
-0.18823057413101196,
-0.176345095038414,
0.5695592761039734,
-0.3204992115497589,
-0.2608702778816223,
0.09223441779613495,
0.7526123523712158,
0.69184809923172,
0.32793205976486206,
0.2624054551124573,
-0.10817069560289383,
0.4432776868343353,
0.02369936928153038,
-0.7567013502120972,
-0.25048568844795227,
0.18333907425403595,
-0.36520540714263916,
-0.18621572852134705,
-0.16948433220386505,
-1.0566692352294922,
-0.28871893882751465,
-0.11996569484472275,
0.4296495020389557,
-0.5462346076965332,
-0.4232887327671051,
-0.23020076751708984,
-0.6440897583961487,
0.19185395538806915,
0.4565237760543823,
-0.4258039891719818,
0.24323111772537231,
0.5104777812957764,
0.7979826927185059,
0.26837578415870667,
0.05895153433084488,
-0.5664714574813843,
0.10035768896341324,
-0.03463125228881836,
0.6647214293479919,
-0.7690737843513489,
-0.3609701693058014,
-0.08728712052106857,
-0.09470483660697937,
-0.12466726452112198,
-0.1366032361984253,
0.6849113702774048,
-0.17246685922145844,
0.22234007716178894,
-0.3154330253601074,
-0.3550255596637726,
-0.40619149804115295,
0.2879819869995117,
-0.6725618243217468,
1.1965558528900146,
0.2103467583656311,
-1.1665226221084595,
0.13258513808250427,
-0.834255576133728,
-0.601977527141571,
-0.049424003809690475,
-0.21928365528583527,
-0.14620208740234375,
0.08797615766525269,
0.6954337358474731,
0.17796596884727478,
-0.1068650633096695,
0.45223110914230347,
-0.7436555027961731,
-0.294380247592926,
0.334480345249176,
-0.8397595286369324,
1.0111228227615356,
0.17285384237766266,
-0.46128758788108826,
-0.0404062494635582,
-0.1933700442314148,
0.05410311371088028,
-0.18756148219108582,
0.26672881841659546,
-0.2133229672908783,
-0.21419119834899902,
-0.0850088894367218,
0.41230061650276184,
0.14954668283462524,
-0.508303165435791,
-0.27496418356895447,
-0.3929492235183716,
0.25703123211860657,
0.9811176061630249,
0.18960681557655334,
0.06778852641582489,
0.1573626697063446,
0.8800711035728455,
0.26077529788017273,
0.39255449175834656,
-0.5786489844322205,
-0.5074021220207214,
-0.2961514890193939,
-0.5900495052337646,
0.01764768734574318,
0.5636230111122131,
-0.8494133949279785,
-0.006641565356403589,
-0.47960081696510315,
0.07462020218372345,
-0.6332197189331055,
-0.0707448348402977,
0.4761645495891571,
0.6713764071464539,
0.35604986548423767,
-0.48312580585479736,
-0.3707064390182495,
-0.8750357031822205,
-0.4928811490535736,
-0.2093723714351654,
0.37489065527915955,
0.7694109678268433,
0.12392312288284302,
-0.05868938937783241,
1.101175308227539,
-0.5825373530387878,
0.03592900186777115,
-0.3806201219558716,
0.24908044934272766,
0.025037774816155434,
0.11712683737277985,
0.43487101793289185,
-0.7857505679130554,
-0.4055468738079071,
0.005303210113197565,
-0.5971631407737732,
-0.26828187704086304,
-0.2193475216627121,
-0.13360866904258728,
-0.050293873995542526,
0.5131838917732239,
-0.666225016117096,
0.505707323551178,
0.27283284068107605,
-0.12665462493896484,
0.4568222463130951,
0.4012219309806824,
0.33895793557167053,
-1.0869343280792236,
-0.15270957350730896,
0.13050773739814758,
-0.473764032125473,
-0.4478301405906677,
-0.045657992362976074,
-0.36953750252723694,
-0.4535462260246277,
-0.556106448173523,
0.5098034739494324,
-0.1541559398174286,
-0.4045315384864807,
0.08054609596729279,
0.581714928150177,
0.009759618900716305,
0.776743471622467,
-0.2402074784040451,
0.46725350618362427,
0.7618650794029236,
-0.3232373297214508,
0.3765137493610382,
0.11579369753599167,
0.25622183084487915,
0.7191580533981323,
-0.5819087028503418,
-0.08154620975255966,
-0.371186763048172,
0.6287247538566589,
-1.4768410921096802,
-0.36935362219810486,
0.4049062430858612,
-0.7702187299728394,
0.16128471493721008,
-0.5037087202072144,
-0.055219706147909164,
-0.4353361129760742,
-0.4966707229614258,
0.6021484732627869,
0.3155815005302429,
-0.5399244427680969,
0.9591202139854431,
0.16287977993488312,
-0.5935981273651123,
-0.9308523535728455,
-0.4874405562877655,
0.0393190011382103,
-0.3330511748790741,
-1.0443041324615479,
0.25517958402633667,
-0.26131170988082886,
-0.2376488298177719,
0.06164225935935974,
-0.2682773768901825,
0.058791253715753555,
0.0775829628109932,
0.38819074630737305,
0.3394292891025543,
-0.30559006333351135,
0.228090301156044,
0.34301233291625977,
-0.06286308914422989,
0.26791298389434814,
0.033184345811605453,
0.42294082045555115,
-0.1421375423669815,
-0.46960604190826416,
-0.7814539074897766,
0.43168458342552185,
0.6276340484619141,
0.04013410955667496,
0.14900468289852142,
1.0284842252731323,
-0.18473827838897705,
-0.23680497705936432,
-0.33562594652175903,
-0.25155767798423767,
-0.46543318033218384,
0.4424503743648529,
-0.41626253724098206,
-0.7133293747901917,
0.7191306352615356,
-0.5253104567527771,
-0.22215798497200012,
0.44407349824905396,
0.2954072952270508,
-0.12500783801078796,
1.5535156726837158,
0.2555028200149536,
-0.04961223900318146,
0.7477281093597412,
-0.14576967060565948,
0.4609968960285187,
-0.7703351378440857,
-0.1417585164308548,
-0.3363947868347168,
-0.3685716688632965,
-0.41124120354652405,
-0.41937825083732605,
0.5121950507164001,
-0.05395612120628357,
-0.07738225907087326,
-0.1874840408563614,
-0.09342461824417114,
0.47191500663757324,
0.1756872683763504,
0.0771554559469223,
0.04584338515996933,
0.13339461386203766,
-0.25615957379341125,
-0.12979350984096527,
-0.6800535917282104,
-0.23661735653877258,
0.5753536224365234,
0.4662909209728241,
0.6014717817306519,
0.08086033910512924,
0.6581617593765259,
0.46820077300071716,
0.03495631366968155,
-0.8392740488052368,
0.6812607645988464,
-0.3217774033546448,
-0.5359947085380554,
-0.09728836268186569,
-0.6759166717529297,
-0.30191630125045776,
0.08121943473815918,
0.1094728484749794,
-0.6837232708930969,
-0.21001817286014557,
0.2529113292694092,
-0.2428789883852005,
0.06660723686218262,
-0.8793425559997559,
1.0297871828079224,
-0.29043659567832947,
-0.2104465663433075,
-0.3785259425640106,
-0.9628552794456482,
0.45492833852767944,
0.6738876104354858,
0.5033237934112549,
-0.1333325058221817,
0.37238404154777527,
0.5292370319366455,
-0.5363897085189819,
1.0518218278884888,
-0.7127596735954285,
0.13603344559669495,
0.5398488640785217,
0.15101946890354156,
0.5064504146575928,
0.41413426399230957,
0.12850134074687958,
-0.16120661795139313,
-0.3317238688468933,
-0.3560502827167511,
-0.8139508366584778,
0.6247007846832275,
-0.7676761150360107,
-0.4888351857662201,
0.07058577984571457,
-0.4472128748893738,
-0.27587586641311646,
-0.001720207161270082,
0.08778893202543259,
1.0910652875900269,
-0.34713655710220337,
-0.14603860676288605,
0.6101734638214111,
-0.26797938346862793,
0.5220520496368408,
-0.29799482226371765,
-0.04074482619762421,
-0.74463951587677,
1.088633418083191,
-0.40442416071891785,
0.4153677821159363,
0.17214824259281158,
0.07487867027521133,
-0.3635251224040985,
-0.1288813203573227,
-0.7071666121482849,
0.24891217052936554,
-1.1703840494155884,
-0.06593195348978043,
-0.8426229357719421,
0.02083675004541874,
-0.642555296421051,
-0.2838078737258911,
-0.29302099347114563,
-0.6934939026832581,
-0.26707661151885986,
-0.2760652005672455,
0.5073291063308716,
0.48210763931274414,
0.10274616628885269,
0.48113706707954407,
-0.5793794989585876,
0.45691683888435364,
0.12138520926237106,
0.23489288985729218,
-0.12950077652931213,
-0.4060022234916687,
0.042516112327575684,
0.3035254180431366,
-0.3269319236278534,
-1.143261194229126,
0.40730902552604675,
0.18451088666915894,
0.44470444321632385,
0.6011996865272522,
-0.004193887580186129,
0.9363570213317871,
0.0298970527946949,
1.1175014972686768,
0.44643649458885193,
-1.147179126739502,
0.6187812089920044,
-0.4700402617454529,
0.19224928319454193,
0.5020490288734436,
0.24953944981098175,
-0.5133489370346069,
-0.3354473412036896,
-0.7756954431533813,
-1.0866464376449585,
0.7267558574676514,
-0.11871272325515747,
0.29795601963996887,
-0.17338362336158752,
0.018389223143458366,
0.17232167720794678,
0.09845475852489471,
-0.9396881461143494,
-0.0807173028588295,
-0.5898909568786621,
-0.5118204355239868,
0.14688287675380707,
0.0478067472577095,
-0.3593198359012604,
-0.07691498845815659,
0.6859659552574158,
-0.6650844216346741,
0.4323900640010834,
0.2792646288871765,
-0.34178850054740906,
0.05507596954703331,
0.2713526785373688,
0.275711327791214,
0.0796162411570549,
-0.1313573718070984,
0.20436345040798187,
0.18658235669136047,
-0.1334398239850998,
-0.2808287739753723,
-0.03877636417746544,
0.03693699464201927,
0.25507989525794983,
0.2748046815395355,
1.184577465057373,
0.03196333721280098,
-0.6673381328582764,
0.9111626148223877,
0.04974751174449921,
-0.1712205410003662,
-0.06088922545313835,
-0.12926138937473297,
0.01213281974196434,
0.2227851301431656,
0.107209712266922,
0.3387856185436249,
0.45506608486175537,
-0.5656444430351257,
0.07667811214923859,
0.7397728562355042,
-0.8451668620109558,
-0.46971890330314636,
0.3485330641269684,
0.4283252954483032,
-0.11053076386451721,
0.5138296484947205,
-0.30703452229499817,
-1.0112271308898926,
0.7402364015579224,
0.4267788231372833,
1.1055002212524414,
0.09066467732191086,
0.6496230363845825,
0.31338566541671753,
-0.012005810625851154,
0.44927725195884705,
0.47888287901878357,
-0.28307443857192993,
-0.44530385732650757,
-0.5419104695320129,
-0.2534094750881195,
-0.33834025263786316,
-0.3109913766384125,
-0.6928975582122803,
0.350525438785553,
-0.47974538803100586,
-0.4707840383052826,
-0.06770947575569153,
-0.3979794979095459,
-0.5410258769989014,
0.44247010350227356,
0.27083268761634827,
0.6018304824829102,
-1.0653045177459717,
0.15630531311035156,
0.5581114292144775,
-0.3459264039993286,
-0.8045505881309509,
0.13155041635036469,
0.0985800102353096,
-0.5412499308586121,
0.42668014764785767,
0.3492193818092346,
-0.680015504360199,
0.05734352022409439,
-0.4896176755428314,
-0.4187559485435486,
0.9001595377922058,
0.4930060803890228,
-0.12305182963609695,
0.03366364538669586,
-0.030981114134192467,
0.5542728900909424,
-0.5435513854026794,
0.8804433345794678,
0.30563461780548096,
0.42633500695228577,
0.40762871503829956,
-0.418912798166275,
-0.015705332159996033,
-0.5319631695747375,
-0.22083967924118042,
0.14310987293720245,
-0.7081236839294434,
0.7421991229057312,
-0.33492153882980347,
-0.25348716974258423,
-0.3170436918735504,
0.44886454939842224,
-0.18097825348377228,
0.6519328951835632,
0.7537780404090881,
0.6435307860374451,
0.6264812350273132,
-0.16816158592700958,
1.068109393119812,
-0.4394127428531647,
0.18284402787685394,
0.9645751714706421,
-0.17521999776363373,
0.43390536308288574,
0.4440959692001343,
0.002534474479034543,
0.9821454882621765,
0.662429690361023,
0.38249677419662476,
0.2904018759727478,
-0.17245730757713318,
-0.4240831732749939,
-0.5107153058052063,
-0.4853367209434509,
-0.3938213884830475,
0.382060170173645,
0.5418410301208496,
-0.4478752613067627,
-0.10238205641508102,
-0.09238304197788239,
-0.06253279000520706,
-0.21012258529663086,
-0.4092969000339508,
0.8757418394088745,
-0.011025823652744293,
-0.6321091055870056,
0.2068432718515396,
-0.27287980914115906,
0.35800451040267944,
-0.2711635231971741,
0.1785694807767868,
-0.24097605049610138,
-0.014044004492461681,
-0.3115384876728058,
-0.6497418880462646,
0.06540091335773468,
0.1615283191204071,
0.0817282423377037,
-0.068057119846344,
0.6774305701255798,
-0.2910495400428772,
-0.2786318361759186,
0.4317544400691986,
0.4385989010334015,
0.16432228684425354,
0.08522213995456696,
-0.8233861923217773,
0.015036585740745068,
0.16189685463905334,
-0.18149057030677795,
-0.04877368360757828,
0.7598433494567871,
-0.0887032002210617,
0.586193323135376,
0.44324779510498047,
-0.2566903531551361,
0.04986745864152908,
0.8101263046264648,
1.1599653959274292,
-0.7113093137741089,
-0.7762051820755005,
-0.8414120078086853,
0.7915482521057129,
-0.2897700071334839,
-0.40484941005706787,
0.5359647870063782,
0.26244932413101196,
0.4450852572917938,
0.0028771045617759228,
1.085928201675415,
-0.03662511333823204,
0.1825210601091385,
-0.4912767708301544,
-0.15448886156082153,
-0.6793175935745239,
0.12349820882081985,
-0.9709290862083435,
-0.8740708231925964,
-0.17061147093772888,
0.4282597005367279,
-0.18513557314872742,
0.34491291642189026,
0.9304326772689819,
0.9615234136581421,
-0.06490606814622879,
0.5245450139045715,
-0.11362747848033905,
0.31033897399902344,
0.2032412737607956,
0.4209553897380829,
0.8700968027114868,
-0.1468706727027893,
0.7487747073173523,
-0.052082374691963196,
-0.11899015307426453,
-0.27642422914505005,
-0.8191587924957275,
-0.8497645854949951,
-0.2244221717119217,
-0.5137958526611328,
-0.3692343831062317,
0.013017099350690842,
0.9212304353713989,
0.4680747091770172,
-0.4203578233718872,
0.19757328927516937,
-0.15242899954319,
0.31297004222869873,
-0.19803988933563232,
-0.3514210879802704,
0.14426495134830475,
-0.29097315669059753,
-0.6261864900588989,
0.33897820115089417,
0.46679049730300903,
-0.11302841454744339,
-0.08838866651058197,
-0.18562544882297516,
0.05971449613571167,
0.25141555070877075,
0.4979897439479828,
-0.028353393077850342,
-0.7780687212944031,
-0.4534178674221039,
0.10820907354354858,
0.10575535893440247,
0.20490805804729462,
1.0765644311904907,
-0.7660279870033264,
0.6159721612930298,
0.6837382912635803,
0.5574724078178406,
0.47626566886901855,
0.4100916385650635,
0.5451074242591858,
-0.929921567440033,
-0.05737292394042015,
0.2779289484024048,
0.2934051752090454,
0.6884647011756897,
-0.4063257873058319,
0.2237837016582489,
0.5920603275299072,
-0.13864783942699432,
-0.8519218564033508,
0.5190204381942749,
-1.4200468063354492,
-0.25186973810195923,
1.1304728984832764,
-0.18907342851161957,
-0.1786225289106369,
-0.14331629872322083,
-0.4446243643760681,
0.6525390148162842,
-0.679749608039856,
0.41704487800598145,
0.5560842156410217,
-0.2202679067850113,
-0.1918860226869583,
-0.26714521646499634,
0.5300748348236084,
0.780953049659729,
-0.7226617336273193,
0.3331218361854553,
0.7941992282867432,
0.08246787637472153,
-0.02583874762058258,
0.7936881184577942,
-0.1915619671344757,
0.48664963245391846,
0.20890210568904877,
0.03721044212579727,
0.042854245752096176,
-0.5975613594055176,
-0.46693384647369385,
0.2606818675994873,
-0.26013490557670593,
0.09578126668930054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03642v1 | Stanceosaurus 2.0: Classifying Stance Towards Russian and Spanish Misinformation | 2024-02-06T02:39:59 | 2024-02-06T02:39:59 | Anton Lavrouk, Ian Ligon, Tarek Naous, Jonathan Zheng, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SI | The Stanceosaurus corpus (Zheng et al., 2022) was designed to provide
high-quality, annotated, 5-way stance data extracted from Twitter, suitable for
analyzing cross-cultural and cross-lingual misinformation. In the Stanceosaurus
2.0 iteration, we extend this framework to encompass Russian and Spanish. The
former is of current significance due to prevalent misinformation amid
escalating tensions with the West and the violent incursion into Ukraine. The
latter, meanwhile, represents an enormous community that has been largely
overlooked on major social media platforms. By incorporating an additional
3,874 Spanish and Russian tweets over 41 misinformation claims, our objective
is to support research focused on these issues. To demonstrate the value of
this data, we employed zero-shot cross-lingual transfer on multilingual BERT,
yielding results on par with the initial Stanceosaurus study with a macro F1
score of 43 for both languages. This underlines the viability of stance
classification as an effective tool for identifying multicultural
misinformation. | [
-0.2828404903411865,
-0.21766874194145203,
-0.006548522040247917,
0.8203980922698975,
-0.26122015714645386,
0.25815317034721375,
-0.038701336830854416,
-0.8455448746681213,
0.782585084438324,
-0.11108195781707764,
-0.3108901381492615,
-0.5389626026153564,
-0.907938539981842,
0.14811645448207855,
-0.08971460908651352,
0.8500776290893555,
0.11355599015951157,
0.4468514919281006,
0.24914175271987915,
-0.4741734564304352,
0.06376232951879501,
-0.2942650616168976,
-0.13859248161315918,
-0.2238980084657669,
0.6546303033828735,
0.5433210730552673,
1.0130800008773804,
0.5660943984985352,
0.04520763084292412,
0.10582439601421356,
0.11744024604558945,
-0.44964420795440674,
-0.1807509958744049,
0.13122498989105225,
-0.38085612654685974,
-0.25419771671295166,
-0.05950791388750076,
-0.007816960103809834,
0.4910429120063782,
0.6445127129554749,
-0.18203036487102509,
0.25559768080711365,
-0.34297579526901245,
0.060701899230480194,
-0.5002354979515076,
0.06163390725851059,
-0.3786100447177887,
0.2793176472187042,
-0.352297306060791,
0.09359849989414215,
-0.20566043257713318,
-0.4881468713283539,
0.14247868955135345,
-0.5315333008766174,
-0.19943256676197052,
-0.2873878479003906,
0.9466012120246887,
-0.18046891689300537,
-0.49520760774612427,
-0.31260445713996887,
-0.16833269596099854,
0.858674943447113,
-0.2594851553440094,
0.5452980399131775,
0.2706199586391449,
0.20632851123809814,
0.04542907699942589,
-0.36988091468811035,
-0.6291331052780151,
0.3517095744609833,
0.20714204013347626,
0.2354481816291809,
-0.6971539855003357,
-0.45634880661964417,
-0.13554206490516663,
0.0009449039353057742,
-0.603569746017456,
0.44907715916633606,
-0.46753552556037903,
-0.8815189599990845,
0.41124311089515686,
-0.5525901317596436,
0.6281397938728333,
-0.667044460773468,
-0.2804441452026367,
-0.28851690888404846,
-0.6252448558807373,
0.18512049317359924,
0.8332611918449402,
0.5891045331954956,
-0.1408039927482605,
0.8763582110404968,
-0.08884437382221222,
0.19055411219596863,
0.2825550138950348,
-0.26127758622169495,
0.35612863302230835,
-0.0942145586013794,
-0.10492144525051117,
0.3357492685317993,
1.018328309059143,
0.7647282481193542,
0.1299748569726944,
-0.17906183004379272,
0.10141107439994812,
-0.06789878010749817,
0.09468577802181244,
-0.7123944163322449,
0.09327051043510437,
0.2291160523891449,
-0.42939984798431396,
-0.36418798565864563,
0.019785968586802483,
-1.277833342552185,
-0.6694535613059998,
-0.07844451069831848,
0.15799742937088013,
-0.48645809292793274,
-0.7270892262458801,
-0.03932088240981102,
-0.24560831487178802,
0.3817952871322632,
0.4770977795124054,
-0.9340893030166626,
0.05359617993235588,
0.8234180212020874,
0.8814892172813416,
-0.01909029856324196,
-0.2587474584579468,
-0.36879250407218933,
-0.06466330587863922,
-0.5791218876838684,
0.8406517505645752,
-0.4978428781032562,
-0.601100504398346,
0.43520352244377136,
0.13377590477466583,
0.12112544476985931,
-0.328640341758728,
0.44718626141548157,
-0.45911017060279846,
0.4332832992076874,
-0.5997304916381836,
-0.06854284554719925,
-0.23281577229499817,
0.47338631749153137,
-0.701480507850647,
1.1642948389053345,
0.2977581322193146,
-0.8937855362892151,
0.7429324388504028,
-0.23866179585456848,
-0.7880774140357971,
-0.053674958646297455,
-0.11497040092945099,
-0.2187345027923584,
-0.2210846245288849,
-0.11332553625106812,
0.2229631394147873,
-0.14638102054595947,
0.14091578125953674,
-0.498492032289505,
0.24196983873844147,
-0.140728160738945,
0.2280629426240921,
1.069110631942749,
0.131377175450325,
-0.5894169807434082,
-0.060468241572380066,
-0.3182718753814697,
-0.1712205857038498,
-0.2625913918018341,
-0.5419535040855408,
-0.2969069182872772,
-0.2173393964767456,
0.1285984367132187,
0.7851073145866394,
0.2295438051223755,
-0.6601150035858154,
0.16493013501167297,
-0.4676841199398041,
-0.19500964879989624,
0.44900572299957275,
-0.25737065076828003,
0.5852367281913757,
-0.1467471867799759,
0.6172071695327759,
0.02983802556991577,
0.12585929036140442,
0.35511237382888794,
-0.4917873740196228,
-0.6139505505561829,
0.150661900639534,
0.2509269714355469,
0.7162846922874451,
-0.6216748952865601,
0.1688362956047058,
-0.36479684710502625,
-0.7003302574157715,
-0.3263821601867676,
-0.0948299914598465,
0.3341621160507202,
0.47186416387557983,
0.4993407130241394,
-0.06471943855285645,
-0.8897302746772766,
-1.0745670795440674,
-0.3639686703681946,
-0.7223944067955017,
0.3603273332118988,
0.04264453426003456,
0.4470791816711426,
0.10346143692731857,
0.5553662776947021,
0.3946179449558258,
-0.028387373313307762,
-0.32904374599456787,
0.5010502934455872,
-0.13761956989765167,
0.1444391906261444,
1.074562907218933,
-0.6986556053161621,
-0.7619218826293945,
0.35532674193382263,
-0.6031945943832397,
0.1687166690826416,
0.1700412780046463,
-0.0952259972691536,
0.6882579922676086,
0.22741226851940155,
-0.7057554721832275,
0.13726910948753357,
0.5195677280426025,
-0.3769703507423401,
0.3888794183731079,
0.40968677401542664,
0.40305107831954956,
-1.3219314813613892,
0.03501209244132042,
0.409106969833374,
0.09261132776737213,
-0.6790307760238647,
-0.5913621187210083,
0.12388138473033905,
0.24817687273025513,
-0.7881190180778503,
0.6314578056335449,
-0.21576879918575287,
-0.20308874547481537,
0.15469911694526672,
-0.1599433422088623,
-0.5366151928901672,
-0.05616504326462746,
0.3344789743423462,
0.47709134221076965,
0.9120983481407166,
-0.3666120767593384,
0.3244505822658539,
0.258942186832428,
-0.15323708951473236,
0.7311378121376038,
-0.2441626489162445,
-0.1410989910364151,
-0.0992540493607521,
0.1437162607908249,
-0.9730209708213806,
-0.5974729657173157,
0.8723717331886292,
-0.7709974646568298,
0.24785172939300537,
-0.6793606281280518,
-0.7066795229911804,
-0.18643136322498322,
-0.6996219158172607,
-0.01048644632101059,
0.2881372272968292,
-0.5310512781143188,
0.5070341229438782,
0.8186389207839966,
-0.30401331186294556,
-1.359244704246521,
-0.8212279677391052,
0.2246706783771515,
-0.49463769793510437,
-0.4923543632030487,
0.18308283388614655,
0.47457146644592285,
-0.6464241147041321,
-0.12822338938713074,
-0.3518008589744568,
-0.10049425810575485,
-0.304532915353775,
0.12058328837156296,
-0.0827096477150917,
-0.26313355565071106,
0.35893917083740234,
0.22978895902633667,
0.22991718351840973,
0.1794351041316986,
-0.4731873869895935,
0.5763305425643921,
-0.1010507196187973,
0.006702312733978033,
-0.4219377636909485,
0.15900075435638428,
1.039387822151184,
0.11906374245882034,
0.854362428188324,
0.708852231502533,
-0.5361274480819702,
0.060312118381261826,
-0.31656989455223083,
0.23109380900859833,
-0.305483877658844,
0.12830506265163422,
-0.13917922973632812,
-0.49762481451034546,
0.6587222814559937,
0.11150423437356949,
0.029918739572167397,
0.8435157537460327,
0.47159579396247864,
-0.13808754086494446,
0.7605911493301392,
0.5425651669502258,
-0.32812216877937317,
0.30394163727760315,
-0.07519318163394928,
0.0000793853760114871,
-0.06263553351163864,
-0.6963059902191162,
-0.7392677068710327,
-0.41956862807273865,
-0.6337705254554749,
-0.4242195188999176,
-0.19677476584911346,
-0.08314596861600876,
0.05153607577085495,
0.5241568684577942,
-0.07401516288518906,
0.2893201410770416,
0.1584654450416565,
-0.43209177255630493,
-0.10274188965559006,
0.3368011713027954,
-0.22120819985866547,
-0.4753662049770355,
-0.5449198484420776,
-0.43485990166664124,
0.9893874526023865,
0.43202245235443115,
0.4334835112094879,
0.7648820281028748,
0.42431923747062683,
0.3962932527065277,
0.581805408000946,
-1.220604419708252,
0.43640220165252686,
-0.04644084721803665,
-0.6214197278022766,
-0.2902086675167084,
-0.049124155193567276,
-0.8715310096740723,
0.3367558717727661,
-0.15720383822917938,
-1.0028988122940063,
0.4800054132938385,
0.15595559775829315,
-0.22488272190093994,
0.2680521309375763,
-0.45579734444618225,
0.994296133518219,
-0.22657057642936707,
-0.31052663922309875,
-0.38016948103904724,
-0.7904012203216553,
0.21073664724826813,
0.07162482291460037,
0.19079233705997467,
-0.286732941865921,
-0.36981695890426636,
0.9145318269729614,
-0.32870933413505554,
1.0127594470977783,
-0.5452026724815369,
-0.2584058940410614,
0.18215498328208923,
0.30228421092033386,
0.15407602488994598,
0.2841233015060425,
-0.3465825021266937,
0.13545791804790497,
0.03411930426955223,
-0.3699878454208374,
-0.09276311844587326,
0.8003774285316467,
-0.9877467155456543,
-0.23182770609855652,
-0.7744654417037964,
-0.13475684821605682,
-0.36237090826034546,
0.30252721905708313,
0.41787633299827576,
-0.004179168958216906,
-0.5216554403305054,
0.25826939940452576,
0.49304336309432983,
-0.0711202621459961,
0.6035314798355103,
0.5040274858474731,
-0.2990887463092804,
-0.31096822023391724,
0.7731619477272034,
0.2853263318538666,
-0.1786508709192276,
0.44803163409233093,
0.07918402552604675,
-0.9305130243301392,
-0.4784587025642395,
-0.5058858394622803,
0.2947360873222351,
-1.021822452545166,
-0.1336640864610672,
-0.588728129863739,
0.37995001673698425,
-0.6769360303878784,
0.05681246891617775,
-0.46357855200767517,
-0.7942125797271729,
-0.2854025363922119,
-0.31029951572418213,
0.2776201665401459,
0.47907382249832153,
-0.41262421011924744,
0.37554728984832764,
-0.384952574968338,
0.17193469405174255,
0.0659971535205841,
0.24330033361911774,
-0.5956454277038574,
-0.4642515778541565,
0.03846150264143944,
-0.014508113265037537,
-0.15042194724082947,
-1.3682043552398682,
0.39212703704833984,
0.08976297080516815,
0.6996824145317078,
0.4505232274532318,
-0.0912262499332428,
0.47984564304351807,
-0.04681456834077835,
0.755912184715271,
0.5334804654121399,
-0.9325448870658875,
0.6065256595611572,
-0.5815197825431824,
-0.01337696798145771,
0.4070409834384918,
1.077538251876831,
-0.774451732635498,
-0.04267985373735428,
-0.7110857367515564,
-0.5517540574073792,
1.023614525794983,
-0.17720840871334076,
0.19315320253372192,
-0.1363477110862732,
-0.12929579615592957,
0.3829523026943207,
0.0984138548374176,
-0.8049325942993164,
-0.10046038776636124,
-0.879603922367096,
-0.14838914573192596,
0.17080295085906982,
-0.038157206028699875,
-0.3346700072288513,
-0.4608937203884125,
0.4612438976764679,
-0.3329625725746155,
0.054359883069992065,
-0.08707260340452194,
-0.5481041669845581,
-0.41914525628089905,
0.3137747049331665,
0.6591314673423767,
0.8108611106872559,
0.08591776341199875,
0.2879936397075653,
0.15777207911014557,
-0.582339346408844,
-0.05727372691035271,
0.18983551859855652,
-0.06749290227890015,
0.4496002793312073,
0.009920371696352959,
0.37697315216064453,
0.21632404625415802,
-0.4557805061340332,
0.5187658071517944,
0.09717102348804474,
-0.5157821178436279,
-0.35692206025123596,
-0.4103270471096039,
0.05578050762414932,
0.11738398671150208,
0.23414333164691925,
0.4416441321372986,
-0.04503590986132622,
-0.8520500659942627,
0.14261488616466522,
0.3152310848236084,
-0.43488433957099915,
-0.8934619426727295,
0.08435152471065521,
0.2042153775691986,
0.06286017596721649,
0.16276516020298004,
-0.2043181210756302,
-0.4255419075489044,
0.5139409303665161,
0.3673001527786255,
0.4145965576171875,
-0.553623616695404,
0.9681605100631714,
0.6899481415748596,
0.21324744820594788,
-0.21225203573703766,
0.5438921451568604,
0.1366156041622162,
-0.853705883026123,
-0.17959748208522797,
-0.5856353640556335,
-0.2230697125196457,
0.3015840947628021,
-0.5389191508293152,
0.4202485680580139,
-0.7630637288093567,
-0.1768197864294052,
0.3170124590396881,
-0.07648380845785141,
-0.19368307292461395,
0.07917536050081253,
0.2941913902759552,
0.8652929663658142,
-0.9267957210540771,
0.8001198768615723,
1.0814640522003174,
-0.3731444478034973,
-0.4094177484512329,
0.25929906964302063,
0.6023033857345581,
-0.7909825444221497,
0.6581004858016968,
0.1405654400587082,
-0.442588210105896,
-0.36955371499061584,
-0.3453868329524994,
-0.7348946332931519,
0.7681236863136292,
0.5764657855033875,
-0.1243436187505722,
0.3871365189552307,
0.3297055959701538,
0.6618014574050903,
-0.2668984532356262,
-0.1998428851366043,
0.4770725667476654,
0.8208566904067993,
0.14159561693668365,
-1.123572826385498,
-0.14441192150115967,
-0.30687475204467773,
-0.5305608510971069,
0.19610589742660522,
-0.7210953235626221,
0.7001217603683472,
-0.009358920156955719,
-0.46314695477485657,
-0.10535438358783722,
0.465431809425354,
-0.09508668631315231,
0.15058980882167816,
0.5430036783218384,
0.3530958890914917,
0.8079372644424438,
-0.37715020775794983,
0.9121459126472473,
-0.2627284526824951,
0.22161832451820374,
0.6054617762565613,
-0.12702028453350067,
0.8949823975563049,
0.8218982815742493,
-0.03875847905874252,
0.5117637515068054,
0.9723814129829407,
0.046790868043899536,
0.4677327275276184,
-0.1365882158279419,
-0.14274071156978607,
-0.16022920608520508,
-0.40356576442718506,
-0.284473180770874,
0.638655960559845,
0.588718593120575,
-0.17611850798130035,
-0.4775669574737549,
-0.19233626127243042,
0.5526754260063171,
0.019494200125336647,
-0.3255971074104309,
0.5259559750556946,
-0.30301299691200256,
-0.943010151386261,
0.27369579672813416,
0.19648611545562744,
0.5358847975730896,
-0.34961414337158203,
0.279549777507782,
-0.230514258146286,
-0.03423257917165756,
-0.3759922981262207,
-1.2512294054031372,
0.5212753415107727,
0.09773921221494675,
0.03819197788834572,
-0.43486133217811584,
0.6754766702651978,
-0.31941312551498413,
-0.1957131326198578,
0.44185230135917664,
0.6991099119186401,
0.12992390990257263,
0.2366531491279602,
-0.7244775891304016,
-0.08749845623970032,
0.020739935338497162,
0.01050480455160141,
0.32614076137542725,
0.4276488721370697,
-0.33643680810928345,
0.39520350098609924,
0.4172675907611847,
-0.03454611822962761,
0.18694357573986053,
0.3142387270927429,
0.7868993282318115,
-0.48551145195961,
-0.4715788960456848,
-0.7167665958404541,
0.5098104476928711,
-0.258118212223053,
-0.6550645232200623,
0.9453089237213135,
0.600734293460846,
0.7215341329574585,
-0.10661771893501282,
0.9177358746528625,
-0.532968282699585,
0.5457241535186768,
-0.2247365117073059,
0.664269208908081,
-0.5808888077735901,
-0.10317970812320709,
0.005609125830233097,
-0.6034265756607056,
-0.5993251204490662,
0.5593360066413879,
-0.3709419071674347,
-0.16522662341594696,
0.5372886061668396,
0.6103830337524414,
-0.18060442805290222,
-0.14267165958881378,
-0.09634247422218323,
0.13938875496387482,
0.008696718141436577,
0.14300942420959473,
1.011586308479309,
-0.19940434396266937,
1.0072768926620483,
-0.41109737753868103,
0.22522656619548798,
-0.5436647534370422,
-0.6128122210502625,
-0.8383071422576904,
-0.4758157432079315,
-0.39670926332473755,
-0.6259742975234985,
-0.08633723855018616,
0.9438078999519348,
0.805552065372467,
-0.8877979516983032,
-0.237266406416893,
0.03817969933152199,
0.20236530900001526,
0.15724903345108032,
-0.1793365627527237,
0.07799769937992096,
-0.07445249706506729,
-0.771902859210968,
0.3795858323574066,
0.40353065729141235,
0.3989456593990326,
-0.14265672862529755,
-0.33791935443878174,
-0.3129945397377014,
-0.12071128189563751,
0.44161489605903625,
1.0653023719787598,
-0.9759282469749451,
-0.4260254204273224,
0.3497122526168823,
-0.2440328747034073,
0.28538933396339417,
0.5938192009925842,
-0.35383841395378113,
0.34050625562667847,
0.5829526782035828,
0.18946458399295807,
0.2798703610897064,
-0.03776118904352188,
0.5839520692825317,
-0.9429844617843628,
0.38529953360557556,
0.475841224193573,
0.43443092703819275,
0.5970739722251892,
-0.21239547431468964,
0.12963174283504486,
0.47251856327056885,
0.2334553748369217,
-0.6302452683448792,
0.18719352781772614,
-1.1669681072235107,
-0.22607740759849548,
1.3312065601348877,
0.04537304490804672,
-0.12275158613920212,
-0.49793586134910583,
-0.060005124658346176,
0.2865951955318451,
-0.6340121030807495,
0.8967839479446411,
1.054298758506775,
-0.09330600500106812,
-0.2506706118583679,
-0.3888173997402191,
0.6725457310676575,
0.4004087448120117,
-0.9039210677146912,
-0.16225266456604004,
0.5580717325210571,
0.4006975293159485,
0.6877397298812866,
0.2827887535095215,
-0.2701907753944397,
0.7465882301330566,
0.05379391461610794,
-0.026466941460967064,
0.46683022379875183,
-0.4661962687969208,
-0.25624823570251465,
0.3129085302352905,
-0.17984530329704285,
-0.08825155347585678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03628v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03628v1 | Professional Agents -- Evolving Large Language Models into Autonomous Experts with Human-Level Competencies | 2024-02-06T01:48:53 | 2024-02-06T01:48:53 | Zhixuan Chu, Yan Wang, Feng Zhu, Lu Yu, Longfei Li, Jinjie Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, PaLM, and GPT-4
has catalyzed remarkable advances in natural language processing, demonstrating
human-like language fluency and reasoning capacities. This position paper
introduces the concept of Professional Agents (PAgents), an application
framework harnessing LLM capabilities to create autonomous agents with
controllable, specialized, interactive, and professional-level competencies. We
posit that PAgents can reshape professional services through continuously
developed expertise. Our proposed PAgents framework entails a tri-layered
architecture for genesis, evolution, and synergy: a base tool layer, a middle
agent layer, and a top synergy layer. This paper aims to spur discourse on
promising real-world applications of LLMs. We argue the increasing
sophistication and integration of PAgents could lead to AI systems exhibiting
professional mastery over complex domains, serving critical needs, and
potentially achieving artificial general intelligence. | [
-0.40958914160728455,
-0.42783987522125244,
0.5479621887207031,
0.019264401867985725,
0.2588432729244232,
0.7319358587265015,
0.014521126635372639,
-0.578047513961792,
0.1287200003862381,
0.9125522971153259,
-0.20335209369659424,
-0.2032819241285324,
-0.3907192051410675,
0.003694825107231736,
-0.38789695501327515,
0.9301044344902039,
0.24769072234630585,
-0.007144884672015905,
0.027195271104574203,
-0.09877150505781174,
-0.04300375655293465,
-0.4708561301231384,
-1.1340609788894653,
-0.47930386662483215,
0.43156924843788147,
0.22549308836460114,
1.072500228881836,
0.6168609857559204,
0.30557674169540405,
0.4670655429363251,
0.23198871314525604,
0.41235455870628357,
-0.1509416103363037,
0.34617868065834045,
-0.48876187205314636,
-0.5444097518920898,
-0.9511939883232117,
0.17705433070659637,
0.4969867765903473,
0.7885770201683044,
0.011189271695911884,
-0.27095842361450195,
-0.10965998470783234,
0.5105111598968506,
-0.254987508058548,
0.34500646591186523,
-0.4131680428981781,
-0.2932437062263489,
0.096328966319561,
-0.5311525464057922,
-0.2996075451374054,
-0.14024831354618073,
0.28454580903053284,
-0.555626630783081,
0.13306203484535217,
-0.0980139970779419,
0.35038310289382935,
0.10087904334068298,
-0.30665847659111023,
-0.21961893141269684,
-0.7195383310317993,
0.3657246530056,
-0.4338063895702362,
0.32004907727241516,
0.12629014253616333,
0.5345280170440674,
-0.3932734727859497,
-0.7558241486549377,
-0.5919386148452759,
-0.6049286127090454,
0.4342014193534851,
0.09189572930335999,
0.01641167886555195,
0.22342389822006226,
-0.2815573215484619,
0.20935088396072388,
-0.38283923268318176,
0.4590880274772644,
-0.21809875965118408,
-0.024892384186387062,
0.8146831393241882,
0.3266383707523346,
0.5651267766952515,
0.38566476106643677,
-0.06575312465429306,
0.15535536408424377,
-0.6637187004089355,
0.007448496297001839,
0.43057557940483093,
0.3310728371143341,
0.09217728674411774,
0.3771760165691376,
-0.09134169667959213,
0.6368278861045837,
-0.026051614433526993,
-0.3588818609714508,
-0.07879771292209625,
-0.04368458688259125,
-0.06487607955932617,
-0.31790891289711,
0.7308108806610107,
-0.03145388886332512,
0.6176238059997559,
-0.5954065918922424,
-0.5382130742073059,
0.07825283706188202,
0.3965936601161957,
-0.3444098234176636,
-0.30005961656570435,
0.2954554557800293,
-0.18953630328178406,
-0.601801872253418,
-0.10307057201862335,
-0.41749370098114014,
-0.9707555770874023,
-0.6086446642875671,
0.3365013301372528,
-0.40896254777908325,
-0.4457216262817383,
0.060044970363378525,
0.03509770333766937,
0.23226667940616608,
0.5759449601173401,
-0.7570720314979553,
0.4982914328575134,
0.9696008563041687,
0.5465602874755859,
-0.16839361190795898,
-0.6005042195320129,
-0.3535245656967163,
0.02962925098836422,
-0.5980066061019897,
0.8790166974067688,
-0.6833735108375549,
-0.3539944291114807,
0.2304292470216751,
-0.10403861850500107,
0.0279090516269207,
-0.6849346160888672,
0.194340318441391,
-1.0742619037628174,
-0.16304443776607513,
-0.06356152147054672,
-0.3247375190258026,
0.12851634621620178,
0.29352810978889465,
-0.5002954602241516,
0.6668040156364441,
0.21740998327732086,
-0.35252541303634644,
0.014214069582521915,
-0.868943452835083,
-0.3155075013637543,
0.6185672283172607,
-0.49522677063941956,
0.24243584275245667,
-0.10531356185674667,
-0.17267492413520813,
0.4160463213920593,
-0.45896172523498535,
0.19472764432430267,
0.06021939590573311,
-0.10365051031112671,
0.707125723361969,
-0.3989992141723633,
0.8607980608940125,
0.06588003039360046,
-0.3444403409957886,
0.26833730936050415,
-0.6948767900466919,
-0.19479413330554962,
-0.006751545239239931,
-0.41296035051345825,
0.09860553592443466,
0.11385106295347214,
-0.02764996327459812,
0.36539289355278015,
0.4000774621963501,
-0.2139221429824829,
0.30603256821632385,
-0.4486977756023407,
0.6521285772323608,
0.758701503276825,
0.10754343122243881,
0.7527784705162048,
-0.5329011082649231,
0.8213524222373962,
-0.0032251449301838875,
-0.30508938431739807,
0.06146562099456787,
-0.4791087806224823,
-0.8436992168426514,
-0.13056765496730804,
-0.08569589257240295,
0.7454614639282227,
-1.044765830039978,
0.5047190189361572,
-0.40005365014076233,
-0.7057498693466187,
-0.527984082698822,
0.1423606425523758,
0.30626118183135986,
0.19121871888637543,
0.14313443005084991,
-0.2323371320962906,
-0.0854889377951622,
-0.9217551350593567,
-0.38454124331474304,
-0.10570831596851349,
-0.0010703050065785646,
0.1322597861289978,
0.23571406304836273,
-0.37137943506240845,
1.087052583694458,
-0.02293161116540432,
-0.12396959215402603,
-0.37571367621421814,
0.06754056364297867,
-0.11380083858966827,
0.3222599923610687,
0.48746025562286377,
-0.9166607856750488,
-0.48552098870277405,
0.21684803068637848,
-0.6150718331336975,
-0.20619753003120422,
-0.14874814450740814,
0.023504555225372314,
0.08041799068450928,
0.5093931555747986,
-0.8082038164138794,
-0.044063501060009,
0.3016994297504425,
-0.23473630845546722,
0.8403639197349548,
-0.4039017856121063,
-0.21502460539340973,
-1.019356608390808,
-0.0330379419028759,
0.07546482235193253,
-0.3228614926338196,
-0.9729705452919006,
0.04193037748336792,
-0.3239855468273163,
-0.27881696820259094,
-0.05426856130361557,
0.8646740317344666,
-0.43993163108825684,
-0.434380441904068,
-0.6031603217124939,
0.4888683259487152,
-0.07287206500768661,
0.25769636034965515,
-0.12187980860471725,
1.2407523393630981,
0.49196937680244446,
-0.6949281096458435,
0.5456277132034302,
-0.03424853831529617,
0.0743013247847557,
0.7264219522476196,
-0.2744194269180298,
0.12154083698987961,
-0.08858021348714828,
0.34674596786499023,
-0.6196083426475525,
-0.27626222372055054,
0.08728136867284775,
-0.3028915524482727,
0.26386693120002747,
0.2759699821472168,
-0.6907187700271606,
-0.4494769275188446,
0.08550179749727249,
0.011440685018897057,
0.2843351662158966,
-0.222133070230484,
0.5564596056938171,
0.626927375793457,
-0.44015011191368103,
-0.3855271637439728,
-0.5010090470314026,
0.5186083912849426,
0.21166358888149261,
-0.6346425414085388,
0.5053812861442566,
0.10498955100774765,
-0.5501275062561035,
0.04846656322479248,
-0.07710012793540955,
-0.2639467120170593,
0.07088925689458847,
0.030570462346076965,
0.022268852218985558,
-0.3001292943954468,
0.06875809282064438,
-0.14613717794418335,
-0.3840397000312805,
0.16281388700008392,
-0.7473174333572388,
0.5572144389152527,
-0.6218931078910828,
-0.37003159523010254,
-0.4745763838291168,
0.09435082226991653,
1.0140647888183594,
-0.6254045963287354,
0.6188330054283142,
0.49180662631988525,
-0.224843367934227,
-0.3021948039531708,
-0.7228108048439026,
0.004478189628571272,
-0.5459321737289429,
0.5548871755599976,
-0.3325088620185852,
-0.8192827701568604,
0.6251450181007385,
-0.09196046739816666,
0.1023331955075264,
0.4564656913280487,
0.5095859169960022,
0.030538104474544525,
0.7948402762413025,
0.6348106265068054,
-0.08259192109107971,
0.4749275743961334,
-0.3990287482738495,
0.3203534185886383,
-0.6328386068344116,
-0.13301122188568115,
-0.29713544249534607,
-0.19057513773441315,
-0.800615668296814,
-0.5807865858078003,
0.2309981733560562,
-0.07811149954795837,
-0.5026589632034302,
0.16480016708374023,
-0.5243222117424011,
0.4062434434890747,
0.36059340834617615,
-0.018952015787363052,
0.24611423909664154,
-0.22187039256095886,
0.06603489816188812,
0.35464024543762207,
-0.4760988652706146,
-1.081631064414978,
0.7395305633544922,
0.5766135454177856,
0.48082801699638367,
0.26309487223625183,
0.6666809320449829,
0.4622122645378113,
0.4441601634025574,
-0.741399884223938,
0.9705230593681335,
-0.2912788689136505,
-0.6026970148086548,
-0.4299861490726471,
-0.0070489151403307915,
-0.7840900421142578,
0.14050708711147308,
0.0649787038564682,
-0.8442597389221191,
0.23302341997623444,
-0.15329723060131073,
-0.4131065309047699,
0.27559372782707214,
-0.38156595826148987,
0.6904848217964172,
-0.49055129289627075,
-0.5553789138793945,
-0.26233959197998047,
-0.5891051888465881,
-0.16354627907276154,
-0.0833444595336914,
0.21557602286338806,
-0.1654699295759201,
-0.5738140940666199,
0.6595971584320068,
-0.3427025377750397,
1.0165008306503296,
-0.37500250339508057,
-0.20116741955280304,
0.6153237819671631,
0.26831865310668945,
0.3980162441730499,
-0.08506090193986893,
-0.3062536418437958,
-0.3946932554244995,
-0.20201565325260162,
-0.4373529851436615,
-0.5280771851539612,
0.5052553415298462,
-1.0299575328826904,
-0.7456643581390381,
-0.13098455965518951,
-0.6293618679046631,
-0.6315739154815674,
0.45478132367134094,
-0.1759870946407318,
0.35015422105789185,
-0.19852611422538757,
-0.018732812255620956,
0.6234776973724365,
0.1410105675458908,
0.3519051671028137,
0.6888270378112793,
0.025166485458612442,
-0.302514910697937,
1.1142992973327637,
0.1779172271490097,
0.2527352571487427,
0.36905011534690857,
0.0655328556895256,
-0.09911904484033585,
-0.8294680714607239,
-0.12952065467834473,
0.19284948706626892,
-0.8121930956840515,
-0.04128633439540863,
-0.6520717740058899,
-0.5449038743972778,
-0.4351067543029785,
-0.5150934457778931,
-0.47442102432250977,
-0.11989139765501022,
-0.37405216693878174,
0.11615979671478271,
0.10654611885547638,
0.8943097591400146,
0.06903038173913956,
0.42499175667762756,
-0.854317843914032,
0.1441488265991211,
0.3868298828601837,
0.30754634737968445,
0.002027801238000393,
-0.33303549885749817,
-0.2313232719898224,
0.04291589558124542,
-0.41143494844436646,
-0.7814189791679382,
0.4960727393627167,
0.09720569103956223,
1.023006558418274,
0.5050351619720459,
-0.18834605813026428,
0.14144086837768555,
-0.3208656311035156,
0.7310954332351685,
-0.07553775608539581,
-0.7192385792732239,
-0.02136554941534996,
-0.9608685970306396,
0.028916586190462112,
0.5059503316879272,
0.28561121225357056,
-0.49320197105407715,
-0.3000650107860565,
-0.6702725291252136,
-0.6332142949104309,
0.5651737451553345,
-0.0598798468708992,
0.1979418843984604,
0.0950452983379364,
0.5117130875587463,
0.03473688289523125,
0.35224127769470215,
-0.6086052060127258,
0.18553714454174042,
0.062032874673604965,
-0.10758932679891586,
-0.15120182931423187,
-0.030321849510073662,
-0.15024705231189728,
0.23090524971485138,
0.5788748264312744,
-0.30832624435424805,
0.34905150532722473,
0.053473904728889465,
-0.09621637314558029,
0.0899447575211525,
0.4175998568534851,
0.5060989856719971,
1.0015889406204224,
0.22391565144062042,
0.16601377725601196,
-0.05450305715203285,
-0.3869125545024872,
0.3393092155456543,
0.11427173763513565,
0.19730491936206818,
-0.6496632099151611,
0.48929980397224426,
0.5938879251480103,
0.2821407616138458,
-0.5597658753395081,
0.3360646069049835,
0.5032473206520081,
-0.15226680040359497,
-0.49772587418556213,
0.3855174779891968,
0.3474062383174896,
0.6630008220672607,
0.5905514359474182,
0.13555790483951569,
-0.1384000927209854,
-0.7158351540565491,
0.22835394740104675,
0.23158255219459534,
-0.2652427554130554,
-0.4434974491596222,
0.3883307874202728,
0.5886169075965881,
-0.9578834772109985,
0.15591676533222198,
-0.37532201409339905,
-0.6131400465965271,
0.6574009656906128,
0.502975344657898,
0.9787340760231018,
-0.313239723443985,
0.24336938560009003,
-0.5160552263259888,
0.15923139452934265,
-0.19998562335968018,
0.09963534027338028,
0.13624230027198792,
-1.0168004035949707,
-0.15225526690483093,
-0.4900120794773102,
-0.5817607641220093,
0.08611498028039932,
-0.09823011606931686,
0.08185708522796631,
-0.6434363722801208,
-0.14691662788391113,
0.2515871822834015,
0.16503383219242096,
-0.7675403356552124,
0.2709614634513855,
0.1596660614013672,
1.0610029697418213,
-0.6167777180671692,
1.0158530473709106,
1.1053240299224854,
-0.6848569512367249,
-0.5171933174133301,
0.22200803458690643,
-0.11486408114433289,
-0.7290772795677185,
0.7892140746116638,
0.12787503004074097,
-0.2984766960144043,
0.2481410950422287,
-0.34476780891418457,
-0.5080777406692505,
1.1965011358261108,
0.3034172058105469,
-0.18657000362873077,
-0.576754629611969,
0.3893549144268036,
0.9135850071907043,
-0.8600760698318481,
0.0446133129298687,
0.6878321766853333,
0.1949204057455063,
-0.08328372985124588,
-1.0121562480926514,
-0.1945960819721222,
-0.16852089762687683,
0.015053736977279186,
-0.14385952055454254,
-0.5771932005882263,
1.0084632635116577,
0.07735351473093033,
0.1855330914258957,
0.014415943063795567,
0.5068113803863525,
0.28491681814193726,
0.14233113825321198,
0.32290589809417725,
0.03246231749653816,
0.7075526118278503,
0.25897523760795593,
0.7506231069564819,
-0.5658963918685913,
-0.13644425570964813,
0.8214516043663025,
-0.36175668239593506,
0.7082489728927612,
0.11073748022317886,
-0.26375001668930054,
0.5856440663337708,
0.3916207551956177,
0.0893692597746849,
0.1819498986005783,
0.09098219126462936,
-0.56064772605896,
-0.2979775667190552,
-0.11279183626174927,
-0.05773710831999779,
0.7462432980537415,
0.6341453194618225,
-0.22430945932865143,
-0.1652715653181076,
-0.04692663997411728,
-0.04084838554263115,
0.2891247570514679,
-0.2923889756202698,
0.7000292539596558,
0.14526718854904175,
-0.753582239151001,
0.11963014304637909,
0.16622857749462128,
0.42665231227874756,
-0.3277377486228943,
0.11409696936607361,
0.005391930229961872,
0.2534833550453186,
-0.17616397142410278,
-0.9547073245048523,
0.08070623129606247,
-0.23200616240501404,
0.10075324028730392,
-0.41593363881111145,
0.9593815207481384,
-0.09756559878587723,
-0.15083450078964233,
0.339089959859848,
0.826785147190094,
0.0957065001130104,
-0.08539889007806778,
-0.7816728353500366,
-0.3147970139980316,
-0.43499380350112915,
-0.29881298542022705,
0.28051790595054626,
0.6805755496025085,
-0.18747884035110474,
0.860101580619812,
0.45054006576538086,
0.23328571021556854,
-0.1307235211133957,
0.014994866214692593,
1.0444345474243164,
-0.5841093063354492,
-0.755442202091217,
-0.4496266841888428,
0.6426912546157837,
-0.19042496383190155,
0.010427081026136875,
0.2841845452785492,
0.34976106882095337,
0.4637238383293152,
0.1306883543729782,
1.0853081941604614,
0.05496005341410637,
0.3668995499610901,
0.003697682172060013,
0.9903913736343384,
-0.3188631534576416,
0.3426773250102997,
-0.024801544845104218,
-0.8293576836585999,
-0.13933701813220978,
0.6120551228523254,
-0.740537703037262,
0.39338335394859314,
0.2600865066051483,
0.705376386642456,
0.04595452547073364,
-0.0793607160449028,
0.39412617683410645,
0.12997008860111237,
0.757881224155426,
0.12001822143793106,
0.7136731147766113,
-0.017591828480362892,
0.23759379982948303,
0.10891254991292953,
-0.5418998599052429,
-0.48947107791900635,
-0.5389821529388428,
-0.9483228325843811,
-0.5995795130729675,
-0.17603008449077606,
-0.2637167274951935,
0.1889452338218689,
0.9780163168907166,
0.547258198261261,
-0.5798304080963135,
-0.43816521763801575,
-0.5815128684043884,
-0.22060777246952057,
0.00981429684907198,
-0.1998993158340454,
-0.009712470695376396,
-0.5615249872207642,
-0.5643589496612549,
0.7342831492424011,
0.451040655374527,
0.026580510661005974,
-0.8946241140365601,
-0.2422923892736435,
-0.0777800902724266,
0.23411931097507477,
0.5816875696182251,
0.5217012763023376,
-0.7823234796524048,
-0.13793054223060608,
-0.04233521968126297,
-0.4517156183719635,
-0.06135669723153114,
0.7591519355773926,
-0.6970524787902832,
0.32418063282966614,
0.32158371806144714,
0.9497559666633606,
-0.06943688541650772,
-0.15715353190898895,
0.6710953116416931,
-0.27722352743148804,
0.15862663090229034,
0.6308313012123108,
0.05067400261759758,
0.2961479127407074,
-0.15757231414318085,
0.31715354323387146,
0.2743183672428131,
-0.7241697907447815,
-0.6336910128593445,
0.3721027970314026,
-0.7736102938652039,
-0.19008557498455048,
1.0425630807876587,
-0.0218683909624815,
0.1072610542178154,
-0.3976897597312927,
-0.20552264153957367,
0.3987743556499481,
-0.3414505124092102,
0.6263411045074463,
0.393836110830307,
-0.4733376204967499,
-0.27383142709732056,
-0.845557689666748,
0.47152474522590637,
0.023601436987519264,
-0.9887356162071228,
0.17614951729774475,
0.31836003065109253,
0.26257264614105225,
0.5413669943809509,
0.9408798217773438,
0.036341216415166855,
0.14558245241641998,
0.3376103937625885,
0.040367402136325836,
-0.13285180926322937,
-0.5580753684043884,
0.014028927311301231,
0.31420451402664185,
0.6430703997612,
0.13943783938884735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03627v1 | Partially Recentralization Softmax Loss for Vision-Language Models Robustness | 2024-02-06T01:44:38 | 2024-02-06T01:44:38 | Hao Wang, Xin Zhang, Jinzhe Jiang, Yaqian Zhao, Chen Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | As Large Language Models make a breakthrough in natural language processing
tasks (NLP), multimodal technique becomes extremely popular. However, it has
been shown that multimodal NLP are vulnerable to adversarial attacks, where the
outputs of a model can be dramatically changed by a perturbation to the input.
While several defense techniques have been proposed both in computer vision and
NLP models, the multimodal robustness of models have not been fully explored.
In this paper, we study the adversarial robustness provided by modifying loss
function of pre-trained multimodal models, by restricting top K softmax
outputs. Based on the evaluation and scoring, our experiments show that after a
fine-tuning, adversarial robustness of pre-trained models can be significantly
improved, against popular attacks. Further research should be studying, such as
output diversity, generalization and the robustness-performance trade-off of
this kind of loss functions. Our code will be available after this paper is
accepted | [
-0.5941475033760071,
-1.1142284870147705,
0.23493699729442596,
-0.15536603331565857,
-0.13578321039676666,
-0.1819467544555664,
-0.4706316590309143,
-0.21080608665943146,
-0.1707330346107483,
0.7074514031410217,
-0.5232061147689819,
-0.4726444482803345,
-0.83152174949646,
0.0015730055747553706,
-0.3038237988948822,
1.2303135395050049,
0.03400764241814613,
0.12920574843883514,
-0.043427880853414536,
-0.42156922817230225,
-0.3162388205528259,
-0.7862237095832825,
-0.4967997372150421,
0.07328703999519348,
0.5789045691490173,
-0.21027281880378723,
1.1658748388290405,
0.19307208061218262,
0.8321088552474976,
0.4861348867416382,
-0.19427208602428436,
-0.1822410523891449,
-0.641054630279541,
0.26150768995285034,
0.045595817267894745,
-0.8653718829154968,
-0.6909934282302856,
-0.16115112602710724,
0.9778713583946228,
0.6361963152885437,
0.019681500270962715,
-0.21147853136062622,
0.1053716391324997,
0.5846728086471558,
-0.802699863910675,
-0.06617342680692673,
-0.9043634533882141,
0.3975233733654022,
-0.3771360218524933,
-0.31226831674575806,
-0.39125537872314453,
-0.2153264880180359,
0.21584700047969818,
-0.34922781586647034,
0.21830785274505615,
-0.38264700770378113,
0.9704353213310242,
0.3483811020851135,
-0.2736772894859314,
0.01954829879105091,
-0.6895626187324524,
1.07978093624115,
-0.6998012661933899,
0.2623524069786072,
0.432656466960907,
0.38709303736686707,
-0.12297334522008896,
-0.7703765034675598,
-0.4055168330669403,
-0.3134651482105255,
0.17937757074832916,
0.05081184580922127,
-0.4990984797477722,
0.2728642225265503,
0.18552246689796448,
0.32511478662490845,
-0.5779488682746887,
-0.05156409740447998,
-0.0369378924369812,
-0.48842719197273254,
0.22970958054065704,
0.04843875765800476,
0.3649628162384033,
0.10806029289960861,
-0.417136013507843,
-0.4779210686683655,
-0.6793826222419739,
0.07942864298820496,
0.6148480176925659,
0.1923421025276184,
0.03668913245201111,
0.5118952393531799,
-0.0724511593580246,
0.7034226059913635,
-0.07895468175411224,
-0.24592892825603485,
0.2424604743719101,
-0.8126742243766785,
-0.27949362993240356,
-0.43732714653015137,
0.5405222177505493,
0.5129050612449646,
0.34333956241607666,
-0.2498404085636139,
-0.2704564332962036,
0.09497744590044022,
0.22009281814098358,
-0.7179420590400696,
-0.021466588601469994,
0.056625280529260635,
-0.6302669644355774,
-0.6224240660667419,
-0.331171452999115,
-0.6069597601890564,
-0.5132110118865967,
0.05342332646250725,
0.47114241123199463,
-0.14312323927879333,
-0.2937573492527008,
0.03296642377972603,
-0.08011659979820251,
0.009424470365047455,
0.18098121881484985,
-0.6285024285316467,
0.22515344619750977,
0.3012838065624237,
0.8776884078979492,
-0.11825669556856155,
-0.41147083044052124,
-0.5429275631904602,
-0.15370424091815948,
-0.31411710381507874,
0.5518668293952942,
-0.4670198857784271,
-0.11655927449464798,
0.1898411065340042,
0.1287846565246582,
-0.20876669883728027,
-0.5519734621047974,
0.3551911413669586,
-0.7449891567230225,
0.17298029363155365,
0.2412029355764389,
0.019902123138308525,
-0.21213394403457642,
0.5837291479110718,
-0.8037059307098389,
0.2963332235813141,
-0.02414323389530182,
-1.0815422534942627,
0.3356631100177765,
-0.2238784283399582,
-0.4337298572063446,
-0.3670547306537628,
0.08844322711229324,
-0.7751481533050537,
0.028746353462338448,
0.2384539693593979,
0.570201575756073,
0.07271095365285873,
0.13020357489585876,
-0.7372875809669495,
-0.10433264821767807,
0.2781181335449219,
-0.8502795696258545,
0.8282768130302429,
0.17733265459537506,
-0.24451977014541626,
0.5855652689933777,
-0.89066481590271,
0.05835837125778198,
0.24209032952785492,
-0.3885299861431122,
-0.2901064157485962,
-0.0798841193318367,
-0.008072998374700546,
0.10330523550510406,
0.2478683590888977,
-0.15502364933490753,
0.15280303359031677,
-0.6144413948059082,
0.4383656084537506,
0.8898841738700867,
-0.1411391645669937,
0.9225670695304871,
-0.33279284834861755,
0.6998061537742615,
-0.06418736279010773,
0.7272252440452576,
-0.31761887669563293,
-0.5126718282699585,
-0.5317074060440063,
-0.29897478222846985,
0.3213668763637543,
0.6315861940383911,
-1.04816734790802,
-0.037728723138570786,
0.025295855477452278,
-0.39097508788108826,
-0.13972778618335724,
0.4988652169704437,
0.1935751885175705,
0.27868425846099854,
0.07378987222909927,
-0.5236257910728455,
-0.5730962753295898,
-0.9656164050102234,
-0.26218122243881226,
0.0732843205332756,
-0.015373792499303818,
0.08529709279537201,
0.2563055157661438,
-0.42722854018211365,
0.5268563628196716,
-0.41654449701309204,
-0.6008152961730957,
-0.5410871505737305,
-0.012832836247980595,
0.3171936571598053,
0.48702314496040344,
0.7634978890419006,
-1.0169060230255127,
-0.19533291459083557,
-0.28766563534736633,
-0.4604606032371521,
0.1904536485671997,
-0.3225384056568146,
-0.13957634568214417,
0.0023518346715718508,
0.4363273084163666,
-0.6130533814430237,
0.5089020729064941,
0.7348783612251282,
-0.184721440076828,
0.4111174941062927,
-0.313163161277771,
0.11893022060394287,
-0.9098613262176514,
-0.22059854865074158,
-0.07706721872091293,
-0.348914235830307,
-0.6980202198028564,
0.2796103060245514,
-0.14784999191761017,
-0.20609159767627716,
-0.5824052095413208,
0.15172190964221954,
-0.27693066000938416,
0.21009455621242523,
-0.3099217414855957,
-0.1482963114976883,
-0.051765553653240204,
0.6395272016525269,
-0.013365617021918297,
0.433365136384964,
0.9831393361091614,
-0.5664976835250854,
0.5086413621902466,
-0.044949281960725784,
-0.15548153221607208,
0.2186502069234848,
-0.6499908566474915,
0.10451547056436539,
-0.3165932893753052,
0.3756781220436096,
-0.807658851146698,
-0.0736774131655693,
0.24623839557170868,
-0.48729804158210754,
0.6435642242431641,
-0.3528176546096802,
-0.36626842617988586,
0.06061987206339836,
-0.8550834059715271,
0.40179306268692017,
0.20534351468086243,
-0.2811688482761383,
0.6179713606834412,
0.3454224169254303,
-0.31937989592552185,
-0.7446439862251282,
-1.0055681467056274,
0.35196661949157715,
-0.14618049561977386,
-0.9847204089164734,
0.34832245111465454,
-0.31043991446495056,
-0.14326277375221252,
-0.13414402306079865,
0.2663690745830536,
-0.36969631910324097,
0.2816315293312073,
0.18401958048343658,
0.2722453773021698,
-0.31620579957962036,
-0.3789629340171814,
-0.17169973254203796,
-0.1899789273738861,
-0.1458435356616974,
0.1068708598613739,
0.650039792060852,
-0.31428831815719604,
-0.2821807563304901,
-0.4234347641468048,
0.47050270438194275,
0.5271092057228088,
-0.26157575845718384,
1.031785249710083,
0.9841212630271912,
-0.3883582055568695,
-0.21454231441020966,
-0.27420786023139954,
-0.273669570684433,
-0.5355269312858582,
0.9337430000305176,
-0.20662303268909454,
-0.9169504642486572,
0.5392571091651917,
0.11931753903627396,
-0.030525824055075645,
0.40504223108291626,
0.6795250177383423,
0.3157963156700134,
1.5485137701034546,
0.743698239326477,
0.017741799354553223,
0.6940147280693054,
-0.22599957883358002,
0.17028222978115082,
-0.32302212715148926,
-0.11920231580734253,
-0.37569454312324524,
-0.061860404908657074,
-0.7755168676376343,
-0.1797613650560379,
0.23893000185489655,
-0.021808795630931854,
0.25633537769317627,
0.16146738827228546,
-0.3569360375404358,
0.35427412390708923,
0.6393548846244812,
0.03622262179851532,
-0.10318300127983093,
0.09438914060592651,
0.08066300302743912,
-0.14395026862621307,
-0.8049365878105164,
-0.2052563726902008,
1.260938286781311,
0.5657865405082703,
1.0511208772659302,
0.3983922600746155,
0.3962876498699188,
0.4752947986125946,
0.10268979519605637,
-0.5830104947090149,
0.6261047720909119,
-0.2113981395959854,
-0.6326431035995483,
-0.13511843979358673,
-0.6538463830947876,
-0.8952866196632385,
0.26266708970069885,
-0.47910746932029724,
-0.4386708438396454,
0.015393772162497044,
0.31357336044311523,
-0.35897865891456604,
0.40643787384033203,
-0.9829264879226685,
0.9617998003959656,
-0.22190743684768677,
-0.5390639305114746,
-0.12346798926591873,
-0.5571610927581787,
0.3652070164680481,
-0.12047968059778214,
0.18423978984355927,
0.3206627368927002,
0.1120520755648613,
0.690900981426239,
-0.23338434100151062,
0.9214005470275879,
-0.25232550501823425,
0.03334203362464905,
0.01689041405916214,
0.05996675044298172,
0.5901871919631958,
0.14602069556713104,
0.34957584738731384,
0.17006915807724,
-0.10597840696573257,
-0.6229617595672607,
-0.4878034293651581,
0.9257818460464478,
-0.5019665956497192,
-0.7769063711166382,
-0.5660147666931152,
-0.4133206009864807,
-0.22601565718650818,
0.324746310710907,
0.41635194420814514,
0.6247323155403137,
0.12757955491542816,
0.3571763336658478,
0.7175033688545227,
-0.5512384176254272,
0.6837096810340881,
0.1316215693950653,
0.03006020374596119,
-0.6067439317703247,
1.0197348594665527,
0.1227855533361435,
0.40873900055885315,
0.2101147621870041,
0.11260257661342621,
-0.23993217945098877,
-0.941038191318512,
-0.38024580478668213,
-0.18725092709064484,
-0.9462023973464966,
-0.23470398783683777,
-0.20414415001869202,
-0.130234956741333,
-0.7022686004638672,
-0.19400256872177124,
-0.5562781691551208,
-0.4038025438785553,
-0.11710266768932343,
0.13626442849636078,
-0.22177891433238983,
0.6055706143379211,
0.04573260247707367,
0.1316933035850525,
-0.6708481907844543,
0.3318166434764862,
0.45931389927864075,
0.3209250271320343,
-0.08882405608892441,
-0.47374165058135986,
-0.12299095094203949,
-0.21064138412475586,
-0.32497188448905945,
-0.8794536590576172,
0.361488401889801,
0.41774365305900574,
0.46184882521629333,
0.7851095199584961,
0.02124091424047947,
0.4020048677921295,
-0.4585614800453186,
0.6670008897781372,
0.5029813647270203,
-0.6070601344108582,
0.44641631841659546,
-0.13937342166900635,
0.7535932660102844,
0.4520382285118103,
0.04262135922908783,
0.09803280979394913,
-0.45787563920021057,
-0.28137099742889404,
-0.8917943239212036,
0.7625696659088135,
0.4608555734157562,
0.4475230872631073,
0.281710147857666,
-0.038568295538425446,
0.0777074471116066,
0.10208237916231155,
-1.0426270961761475,
-0.4836534857749939,
-0.5762506127357483,
-0.15623565018177032,
-0.0014744056388735771,
-0.4764726459980011,
-0.225632905960083,
-0.09461338818073273,
0.6452404260635376,
0.0627637431025505,
0.15416355431079865,
0.10285072773694992,
-0.2955223619937897,
0.1507812738418579,
0.36046698689460754,
0.8502145409584045,
0.46801555156707764,
-0.3456740081310272,
0.49031227827072144,
0.21112322807312012,
-0.6079137325286865,
-0.08590143173933029,
0.4501672685146332,
-0.32878831028938293,
-0.11104688048362732,
0.7108542919158936,
0.8361690640449524,
0.0925242155790329,
-0.594957172870636,
0.9489858150482178,
-0.45841333270072937,
-0.05705198645591736,
-0.23454882204532623,
-0.0015684178797528148,
-0.3659263849258423,
0.3331879675388336,
0.3463357388973236,
0.9320414066314697,
0.2062910944223404,
-0.4420168697834015,
0.15331491827964783,
0.6461456418037415,
-0.37960439920425415,
-0.4726783037185669,
0.8161971569061279,
-0.11789100617170334,
0.04723827540874481,
-0.007290558889508247,
-0.05669964849948883,
-0.782700777053833,
0.4867731034755707,
0.42770054936408997,
0.6093034148216248,
-0.2593008577823639,
0.0951269194483757,
0.16608881950378418,
0.5897340178489685,
0.13162967562675476,
-0.18985767662525177,
-0.12802281975746155,
-0.5950396060943604,
-0.4227882921695709,
-0.47035977244377136,
-0.07156616449356079,
0.3140658438205719,
-0.48749372363090515,
0.12499306350946426,
-0.7213431596755981,
-0.8399889469146729,
0.028948049992322922,
-0.33088651299476624,
-0.6463530659675598,
0.3078325092792511,
0.4271191656589508,
0.30786803364753723,
-0.5354344248771667,
0.6515457630157471,
0.777136504650116,
-0.35692524909973145,
-0.021254757419228554,
-0.10655064135789871,
-0.050499167293310165,
-0.5276324152946472,
0.46513739228248596,
0.009195120073854923,
-0.2357911765575409,
-0.40719735622406006,
-0.5673714280128479,
-0.8066970705986023,
0.6185588836669922,
0.6511013507843018,
-0.4136234521865845,
-0.0702974870800972,
0.11871086061000824,
0.31918132305145264,
0.15643173456192017,
0.22619730234146118,
-0.0513857938349247,
0.323111355304718,
-0.19078974425792694,
-0.7839375138282776,
-0.1136162132024765,
-0.33578720688819885,
0.01995863951742649,
0.121932253241539,
-0.4596026539802551,
0.8960350155830383,
-0.2116243690252304,
-0.23911038041114807,
0.06962645053863525,
0.6816418766975403,
-0.1785772740840912,
0.4989931285381317,
0.7069677114486694,
0.363870769739151,
0.3240530788898468,
-0.0097237229347229,
1.2906278371810913,
-0.022213248535990715,
0.3259875774383545,
0.836558997631073,
0.12502920627593994,
0.6719099879264832,
0.464080274105072,
-0.16053050756454468,
-0.11107371747493744,
0.2551020085811615,
-0.05638817325234413,
0.9120723009109497,
0.0760878324508667,
-0.26403823494911194,
-0.3077383041381836,
0.04647105559706688,
-0.4625687599182129,
0.3788028657436371,
-0.13449770212173462,
-0.5358704328536987,
-0.10829436033964157,
0.4649144113063812,
0.3659185469150543,
0.004154374357312918,
-0.3779730200767517,
0.5010746717453003,
-0.11183171719312668,
-0.5368354320526123,
0.8327473998069763,
0.2496345192193985,
1.0693060159683228,
-0.9586441516876221,
0.1595906764268875,
-0.1708274781703949,
0.6238020658493042,
-0.2416134625673294,
-0.4299243986606598,
0.25279369950294495,
-0.020276155322790146,
-0.20059917867183685,
-0.1456541270017624,
0.9305734038352966,
-0.2888278365135193,
-0.5375925302505493,
0.3811603784561157,
0.10282042622566223,
-0.32663848996162415,
-0.2026521861553192,
-0.7984980940818787,
0.2018166035413742,
0.09885711222887039,
-0.5162755846977234,
0.6617748737335205,
-0.14281152188777924,
0.08998928964138031,
0.7290881872177124,
0.6902913451194763,
0.21478459239006042,
0.5099644064903259,
0.4110882878303528,
0.9609006643295288,
-0.3707718849182129,
-0.23577183485031128,
-0.9285540580749512,
0.07973030209541321,
-0.03680622950196266,
-0.4079180359840393,
0.8967055678367615,
0.27769163250923157,
0.8727439641952515,
-0.040277618914842606,
0.5681521892547607,
0.20624461770057678,
0.05404898151755333,
-0.6596928238868713,
0.9733023643493652,
-0.658289909362793,
0.19534160196781158,
-0.3941722512245178,
-0.8867254853248596,
-0.7029881477355957,
0.3252463936805725,
-0.03978712856769562,
0.1666409820318222,
0.5400120615959167,
1.012974500656128,
0.0276947058737278,
-0.2888076901435852,
0.6731948256492615,
0.3766161799430847,
0.26541098952293396,
0.6325807571411133,
0.7557554244995117,
-0.3010624349117279,
1.0511624813079834,
-0.548328697681427,
-0.3053937554359436,
0.12035958468914032,
-0.6971362829208374,
-1.2041505575180054,
-0.7044313549995422,
-0.4569094479084015,
-0.4275324046611786,
0.23524774610996246,
0.16447684168815613,
0.8613314032554626,
-0.9004197120666504,
0.4082406163215637,
0.05453867465257645,
0.004993825685232878,
-0.022784307599067688,
-0.20422746241092682,
0.45576030015945435,
-0.17848677933216095,
-0.6324949860572815,
0.5126705169677734,
0.1389320343732834,
0.023817863315343857,
-0.41874808073043823,
-0.1906319111585617,
-0.1588965654373169,
0.09801054000854492,
0.5369581580162048,
0.0326453298330307,
-0.5829944014549255,
0.06469600647687912,
-0.12774159014225006,
0.1303052455186844,
-0.027858305722475052,
0.6602343320846558,
-0.498928964138031,
0.6868929862976074,
0.5870384573936462,
0.7160860896110535,
0.25710535049438477,
-0.28971803188323975,
0.5423416495323181,
-0.6904436349868774,
0.4730336368083954,
0.27625617384910583,
0.5362586379051208,
0.5876185894012451,
-0.2186652570962906,
0.057286910712718964,
0.3768616020679474,
-0.350744366645813,
-0.9806475639343262,
0.23614169657230377,
-0.9871231317520142,
-0.43021225929260254,
1.033176302909851,
-0.25569671392440796,
-0.41388580203056335,
-0.018737975507974625,
-0.35320809483528137,
0.2511928677558899,
-0.24771450459957123,
0.5685118436813354,
0.7644298076629639,
0.26721885800361633,
-0.1688702404499054,
-0.4545089900493622,
0.5329777598381042,
0.7697029113769531,
-0.5595384240150452,
-0.40227678418159485,
0.30930402874946594,
0.11933176964521408,
0.18069519102573395,
0.3264484703540802,
-0.29483118653297424,
0.42565757036209106,
0.08210466057062149,
-0.28924334049224854,
-0.2057712823152542,
-0.22469548881053925,
-0.48484912514686584,
0.835265576839447,
0.15977369248867035,
-0.25942596793174744
] |
Subsets and Splits