Datasets:

dcarpintero
/

arxiv.cs.CL.10k.embeddings.jina

Dataset card Data Studio Files Files and versions Community

Split (1)

train · 10k rows

id stringlengths 33 33	doc_url stringlengths 33 33	title stringlengths 13 211	publication_date timestamp[s]	update_date timestamp[s]	authors stringlengths 6 16.6k	category_primary stringclasses 60 values	category_all stringlengths 5 132	abstract stringlengths 123 1.99k	embeddings sequencelengths 768 768
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07483v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07483v2	T-RAG: Lessons from the LLM Trenches	2024-02-12T08:45:08	2024-06-06T14:42:47	Masoomali Fatehkia, Ji Kim Lucas, Sanjay Chawla	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL	Large Language Models (LLM) have shown remarkable language capabilities fueling attempts to integrate them into applications across a wide range of domains. An important application area is question answering over private enterprise documents where the main considerations are data security, which necessitates applications that can be deployed on-prem, limited computational resources and the need for a robust application that correctly responds to queries. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has emerged as the most prominent framework for building LLM-based applications. While building a RAG is relatively straightforward, making it robust and a reliable application requires extensive customization and relatively deep knowledge of the application domain. We share our experiences building and deploying an LLM application for question answering over private organizational documents. Our application combines the use of RAG with a finetuned open-source LLM. Additionally, our system, which we call Tree-RAG (T-RAG), uses a tree structure to represent entity hierarchies within the organization. This is used to generate a textual description to augment the context when responding to user queries pertaining to entities within the organization's hierarchy. Our evaluations, including a Needle in a Haystack test, show that this combination performs better than a simple RAG or finetuning implementation. Finally, we share some lessons learned based on our experiences building an LLM application for real-world use.	[ -0.29181233048439026, -0.8636612296104431, 0.716932475566864, 0.07020170241594315, -0.0520530566573143, 0.6485623121261597, 0.05169739946722984, -0.6427901983261108, 0.030228866264224052, 0.7656525373458862, -0.22980764508247375, -0.6293618083000183, -0.2864759862422943, -0.06693412363529205, -0.5315194129943848, 1.115518569946289, 0.018857991322875023, -0.25264641642570496, -0.20641224086284637, -0.21373975276947021, -0.3400183618068695, -0.566949188709259, -0.8981459736824036, -0.2476903647184372, 0.43404725193977356, 0.4726922810077667, 0.5127410888671875, 0.6962820291519165, 0.5217649340629578, 0.295952171087265, -0.2598130404949188, 0.09436335414648056, -0.7098584771156311, 0.6128750443458557, -0.4152976870536804, -0.4559166729450226, -0.5942332744598389, -0.1338573545217514, 0.48738333582878113, 0.6165592074394226, -0.4223870635032654, 0.31389495730400085, -0.13498273491859436, 0.6591530442237854, -0.5772310495376587, -0.1549234837293625, -0.8947532773017883, -0.08562227338552475, -0.4462127089500427, -0.35872480273246765, -0.3100683391094208, -0.2926903963088989, 0.044607989490032196, -0.5868785977363586, 0.18699780106544495, 0.3807514011859894, 0.9856672286987305, 0.08076677471399307, -0.40200075507164, -0.6080837845802307, -0.9456449151039124, 0.8470429182052612, -0.4736926853656769, 0.35483288764953613, 0.5843478441238403, 0.5671635270118713, -0.136411651968956, -0.9611190557479858, -0.14399369060993195, -0.28195106983184814, 0.001427262555807829, 0.12902995944023132, -0.14757780730724335, -0.07514777779579163, 0.07579925656318665, 0.6986083388328552, -0.5622039437294006, 0.2872191071510315, -0.4883134961128235, 0.14530766010284424, 0.5247575640678406, 0.4050322473049164, 0.091773621737957, -0.08691728860139847, -0.38595351576805115, 0.04089728370308876, -0.6510395407676697, -0.10041216760873795, 0.18975847959518433, 0.05034628137946129, 0.0903829038143158, 0.792276918888092, 0.0843714252114296, 0.5994033813476562, 0.06720396876335144, -0.2964281141757965, -0.1494399607181549, -0.03160620853304863, -0.36852729320526123, -0.20910871028900146, 0.3505222499370575, 0.24741633236408234, 0.23501209914684296, -0.5569937825202942, -0.5292962193489075, -0.17590096592903137, 0.5265200138092041, -0.5298919081687927, 0.22030198574066162, 0.26204681396484375, -0.35418638586997986, -0.5493367314338684, -0.18876609206199646, -0.779621422290802, -0.7652936577796936, -0.12502995133399963, 0.14743982255458832, -0.29734697937965393, -0.17694532871246338, -0.10926171392202377, -0.2652345597743988, 0.5589824318885803, 0.47927531599998474, -0.591105580329895, 0.6349610686302185, 1.095504641532898, 0.7064163088798523, -0.12775295972824097, 0.17771793901920319, -0.793914258480072, 0.5005530714988708, -0.46904605627059937, 0.6325395107269287, -0.45060327649116516, -0.5849337577819824, 0.08975261449813843, -0.1494804173707962, 0.16016505658626556, -0.8587037324905396, 0.6768258213996887, -0.8628494739532471, 0.2666719853878021, 0.30197563767433167, -0.6906166076660156, 0.06386222690343857, 0.599348783493042, -0.43235495686531067, 0.873038113117218, 0.30016854405403137, -0.8147961497306824, -0.05277923122048378, -0.5229749083518982, -0.26817017793655396, 0.38457608222961426, -0.3528684973716736, -0.39407292008399963, 0.2658478617668152, -0.06292036175727844, 0.35804176330566406, -0.49454495310783386, 0.03331480547785759, -0.1892355978488922, -0.14121684432029724, 0.18453127145767212, 0.10486561059951782, 0.8712462782859802, 0.4081362783908844, -0.08149353414773941, -0.24386893212795258, -0.6331982016563416, 0.12707233428955078, 0.19858591258525848, -0.4800127148628235, -0.5650846362113953, -0.10393450409173965, -0.016207827255129814, -0.26405978202819824, 0.32039734721183777, -0.44678574800491333, 0.19143110513687134, -0.4796212911605835, 0.1737087517976761, 0.705419659614563, 0.2259090393781662, 0.6010170578956604, -0.45130494236946106, 0.8448697924613953, -0.1865682750940323, 0.05752480402588844, -0.03676024451851845, -0.3704218566417694, -0.47061190009117126, -0.014180473051965237, 0.216983824968338, 0.8091545104980469, -0.8845402598381042, -0.08736284077167511, -0.06189766526222229, -0.5997876524925232, -0.46626994013786316, 0.13401800394058228, 0.37039902806282043, 0.7231438159942627, 0.20144321024417877, -0.11151397973299026, -0.6033872365951538, -0.9277375340461731, -0.23499947786331177, -0.3636435568332672, -0.27908769249916077, 0.7626131176948547, 0.23111216723918915, -0.3416730761528015, 0.8681110143661499, -0.6981569528579712, -0.4257649779319763, -0.15720030665397644, 0.0738498866558075, 0.11579504609107971, 0.12364553660154343, 0.31716054677963257, -0.9014113545417786, -0.5187419652938843, 0.2905882000923157, -0.6442002654075623, -0.29020094871520996, 0.17499962449073792, -0.23312176764011383, 0.46729862689971924, 0.5339943766593933, -0.5218159556388855, 0.2311219424009323, 0.6393177509307861, -0.32602760195732117, 0.580327570438385, -0.12909552454948425, -0.09081485867500305, -1.3854907751083374, 0.3727620840072632, -0.31102079153060913, -0.43316346406936646, -0.6865466833114624, 0.42768093943595886, -0.0013246778398752213, -0.37313348054885864, -0.3665677011013031, 0.7420212626457214, -0.4504128098487854, -0.45258229970932007, -0.09613767266273499, 0.26346060633659363, 0.30865243077278137, 0.08891711384057999, -0.20633147656917572, 1.054782748222351, 0.3132361173629761, -0.6594226956367493, 0.17626404762268066, 0.35736334323883057, -0.2221960723400116, 0.5408663749694824, -0.6177736520767212, 0.3657304048538208, -0.12741591036319733, -0.019306549802422523, -0.5175443291664124, -0.36069804430007935, -0.0035192114301025867, -0.315072238445282, 0.529114305973053, -0.3424614667892456, -0.4658432900905609, -0.2134200781583786, -0.3575011193752289, 0.05868193507194519, 0.5629511475563049, -0.3893408477306366, 0.6669532060623169, 0.8071321249008179, -0.2572951912879944, -0.6863191723823547, -0.7368568778038025, 0.38875067234039307, -0.38749831914901733, -0.7527222633361816, 0.31458622217178345, -0.043630409985780716, -0.6811342239379883, 0.102244533598423, -0.10026367753744125, -0.5219341516494751, 0.3681817650794983, 0.2132931798696518, 0.13463862240314484, -0.4210297763347626, 0.13944555819034576, -0.2139294296503067, 0.028036018833518028, -0.2804136872291565, -0.04231233522295952, 0.3888559639453888, -0.31020790338516235, -0.16252170503139496, 0.3237159550189972, 0.5279160141944885, 0.5397053956985474, -0.47086718678474426, 0.7516055703163147, 0.2953551113605499, -0.24949294328689575, -0.29103222489356995, -0.7121188640594482, 0.15091808140277863, -0.5294889211654663, 0.17084045708179474, -0.20747193694114685, -1.043208122253418, 0.43069449067115784, -0.23768988251686096, 0.3435017168521881, 0.1830316185951233, 0.3831222653388977, -0.3641488552093506, 0.6123586893081665, 0.902981698513031, 0.1241401955485344, 0.4318629503250122, -0.22841720283031464, 0.13397204875946045, -0.8680037260055542, -0.1252143830060959, -0.6695847511291504, 0.0026058987714350224, -0.6552901864051819, -0.5530205965042114, 0.6213302612304688, 0.37336108088493347, -0.21429187059402466, 0.09926784783601761, -0.24217158555984497, 0.4832427501678467, 0.26338687539100647, -0.2517671287059784, 0.5059851408004761, -0.021347856149077415, 0.23468662798404694, 0.17872373759746552, -0.5638250112533569, -0.8210194110870361, 0.7081645727157593, 0.5565811395645142, 1.0971571207046509, 0.29563453793525696, 1.0290218591690063, 0.0362476147711277, 0.4405931234359741, -0.7164077162742615, 0.6310960054397583, -0.5692325234413147, -0.7452383041381836, -0.38745614886283875, -0.4506320059299469, -1.131456971168518, 0.038388241082429886, -0.09550739824771881, -0.7015644907951355, -0.047925785183906555, 0.0065965717658400536, -0.1814819574356079, 0.3019227981567383, -0.7248615622520447, 0.619783878326416, -0.2941117584705353, -0.32311829924583435, 0.09616529941558838, -0.34093451499938965, 0.45925551652908325, -0.24171306192874908, 0.24287396669387817, 0.111705482006073, -0.5086445808410645, 0.4184504449367523, -0.12539219856262207, 0.6051886677742004, -0.012807679362595081, -0.17299319803714752, 0.31973549723625183, 0.32687458395957947, 0.6293181777000427, -0.08062934875488281, -0.4076685309410095, -0.1793842613697052, -0.06169142201542854, -0.07795156538486481, -0.47909483313560486, 0.6572079658508301, -0.5668985843658447, -0.9251515865325928, -0.19988206028938293, -0.5403817892074585, -0.3929993212223053, 0.2824948728084564, -0.05613689497113228, 0.4847046136856079, -0.38691169023513794, 0.5707151293754578, 0.8085833191871643, -0.5254337787628174, 0.24937310814857483, 0.7043290734291077, -0.5852342844009399, -0.2805664837360382, 0.6019339561462402, 0.27034929394721985, 0.2521286904811859, 0.42920660972595215, 0.28409841656684875, -0.19725091755390167, -0.5178369283676147, -0.4912843406200409, 0.29965680837631226, -0.6155380010604858, -0.47023430466651917, -0.7400750517845154, -0.30184483528137207, -0.25864434242248535, -0.14807981252670288, -0.21414516866207123, -0.560803234577179, -0.10932106524705887, -0.08406707644462585, 0.4304508864879608, 1.0212318897247314, 0.36247026920318604, 0.02603764459490776, -1.027400016784668, 0.5103200674057007, 0.23401080071926117, 0.6130746006965637, -0.09138298779726028, -0.2344157099723816, -0.3847475051879883, -0.27085062861442566, -0.3871462941169739, -0.9324202537536621, 0.2906109392642975, 0.27686184644699097, 0.5285215973854065, -0.0783318355679512, 0.17048512399196625, 0.5724353790283203, -0.7671553492546082, 0.7900134921073914, -0.38952362537384033, -0.5397591590881348, 0.3748335838317871, -0.6259300112724304, 0.16126158833503723, 0.5209500789642334, 0.2729896605014801, -0.5525104999542236, -0.9451444745063782, -0.7073765397071838, -1.028806447982788, 0.7068775296211243, 0.17472967505455017, 0.12113749235868454, 0.14081642031669617, 0.4780960977077484, 0.049013521522283554, 0.23240667581558228, -0.3631278872489929, -0.23527540266513824, 0.2327888011932373, 0.031563516706228256, -0.009080328047275543, -0.36088651418685913, -0.2652958631515503, 0.29859626293182373, 0.5698524117469788, 0.12526272237300873, -0.01861526630818844, -0.016276352107524872, -0.018408220261335373, -0.2344917207956314, 0.5454219579696655, 0.3756946623325348, 0.8119990229606628, -0.16689415276050568, 0.11821582913398743, 0.20658741891384125, -0.37273263931274414, -0.1530003696680069, 0.01459580659866333, -0.23920534551143646, 0.07848402112722397, 0.22620011866092682, 0.49425143003463745, 0.06920991837978363, -0.6229596138000488, 0.3914095163345337, -0.11225274950265884, -0.12218815833330154, -0.42503681778907776, -0.023514851927757263, 0.4244343340396881, 0.3784695565700531, 0.53077632188797, -0.4644330143928528, 0.2284785509109497, -0.6205928325653076, 0.14945513010025024, 0.4098411798477173, 0.11574394255876541, 0.15256048738956451, 0.4425375461578369, 0.09336986392736435, -0.526822566986084, 0.3972722291946411, -0.013553391210734844, -0.4754668176174164, 0.5754672884941101, 0.5357213020324707, 1.0750839710235596, -0.30423837900161743, 0.18145866692066193, -0.051030877977609634, 0.24595262110233307, 0.15981417894363403, 0.1734495759010315, 0.0050647445023059845, -0.31695467233657837, -0.36974766850471497, -0.8385875225067139, -0.7926088571548462, 0.34087666869163513, -0.46154266595840454, 0.08667590469121933, -0.47028112411499023, -0.11443016678094864, -0.20619097352027893, 0.14337417483329773, -0.47939684987068176, 0.10833198577165604, 0.0740308165550232, 1.0876013040542603, -0.4486875832080841, 0.5859551429748535, 0.9887639880180359, -0.3485826253890991, -0.8504267334938049, 0.06749791651964188, -0.3231698274612427, -0.720872163772583, 0.7175889015197754, -0.11035811901092529, -0.09208878129720688, -0.07458188384771347, -0.3821667432785034, -0.7534216642379761, 1.2733594179153442, 0.23996129631996155, -0.4666198492050171, -0.14793920516967773, 0.2588929235935211, 0.8765780925750732, -0.22731508314609528, -0.10283606499433517, 0.2802797555923462, 0.23035772144794464, 0.08484037220478058, -0.9647512435913086, -0.20146958529949188, 0.03765726834535599, 0.13104809820652008, 0.21118661761283875, -0.39972981810569763, 0.8313548564910889, 0.05002544820308685, -0.4205399751663208, 0.20879264175891876, 0.3528497517108917, 0.4578605592250824, 0.636272132396698, 0.3841365873813629, 0.5196988582611084, 0.8183165788650513, 0.26078933477401733, 1.33853018283844, -0.3660285174846649, 0.08814556151628494, 1.2779464721679688, -0.30776336789131165, 0.9752434492111206, 0.5446867346763611, 0.08026094734668732, 0.4597698152065277, 0.32677561044692993, 0.3074430823326111, 0.1984167993068695, 0.15945757925510406, -0.38517242670059204, 0.16536222398281097, -0.4112716615200043, -0.2893199920654297, 0.19401392340660095, 0.4200039207935333, -0.3590720593929291, -0.5040829181671143, -0.119631826877594, -0.0998600646853447, 0.2548719048500061, -0.5324110388755798, 1.098001480102539, 0.4755999445915222, -0.5177918672561646, 0.3975568413734436, 0.2091740071773529, 0.2826593220233917, -0.5392407774925232, -0.019948072731494904, -0.3858552575111389, 0.2281191051006317, -0.28777754306793213, -1.1162289381027222, 0.6900963187217712, 0.5195422172546387, -0.11365113407373428, -0.5392109751701355, 0.9624661207199097, -0.41742607951164246, -0.006333612371236086, 0.29975613951683044, 0.7526448369026184, 0.2065204381942749, 0.07091441750526428, -0.6617540717124939, 0.12684175372123718, -0.41237032413482666, -0.4651215672492981, 0.28743237257003784, 0.8137462735176086, -0.3390084207057953, 0.7579318881034851, 0.36970436573028564, 0.046814050525426865, 0.18172092735767365, 0.17895551025867462, 0.9764356017112732, -0.39440786838531494, -0.4876801371574402, -0.5077717304229736, 0.4692455232143402, -0.1048148050904274, 0.12027952820062637, 0.861375093460083, 0.7542369365692139, 0.6958780288696289, -0.0857800766825676, 0.5396386981010437, -0.12526527047157288, 1.0505268573760986, -0.35280129313468933, 0.7446708679199219, -0.6286012530326843, 0.489162802696228, -0.05694207176566124, -0.9640110731124878, -0.17652519047260284, 0.24820277094841003, -0.40754756331443787, -0.06712877750396729, 0.48351559042930603, 0.8830618858337402, -0.12255001813173294, -0.3153422772884369, 0.45653316378593445, 0.36121636629104614, 0.45226871967315674, 0.18844306468963623, 0.9841340184211731, -0.284756064414978, 0.8483625650405884, -0.11792266368865967, -0.0470547117292881, -0.12919385731220245, -0.9392126798629761, -0.6811748147010803, -0.4520149230957031, -0.1042838990688324, -0.4924076795578003, 0.2695106565952301, 0.5616956353187561, 0.4646301865577698, -0.5828928351402283, -0.46259236335754395, -0.01536550186574459, 0.20809070765972137, 0.46312594413757324, -0.2809734642505646, -0.0018277831841260195, -0.5550581216812134, -0.5092914700508118, 0.46185794472694397, 0.2918631434440613, 0.038248009979724884, -0.243755042552948, -0.12067370116710663, -0.25094592571258545, -0.004246878903359175, 0.5700043439865112, 0.43796855211257935, -0.39668431878089905, -0.15520012378692627, 0.1686471700668335, -0.490727961063385, -0.050609830766916275, 0.7875428199768066, -0.604039192199707, 0.24263118207454681, 0.5275682806968689, 1.1728347539901733, 0.6817333102226257, 0.25832268595695496, 0.6755513548851013, -1.064292550086975, -0.23122413456439972, 0.6585394144058228, 0.006920877378433943, 0.5697950124740601, -0.4714880883693695, 0.8353596329689026, -0.24434958398342133, -0.7790472507476807, -1.0375007390975952, 0.27291619777679443, -0.781747579574585, -0.2636166214942932, 1.1626417636871338, -0.05505766347050667, -0.39260607957839966, -0.4149225652217865, -0.36359524726867676, 0.07700324058532715, -0.24464531242847443, 0.6545310020446777, 0.50852370262146, 0.0015744278207421303, -0.2663405239582062, -0.7743760943412781, 0.4874430000782013, 0.08630959689617157, -0.8707306385040283, 0.20182549953460693, 0.3821328580379486, 0.25484398007392883, 0.22497236728668213, 0.8561820983886719, -0.183198943734169, 0.05378285422921181, -0.20182020962238312, -0.2566661238670349, -0.1873627007007599, -0.2404569834470749, -0.30244511365890503, 0.3078897297382355, 0.5222269892692566, -0.05351672321557999 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07470v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07470v2	Pushing The Limit of LLM Capacity for Text Classification	2024-02-12T08:14:03	2024-02-16T15:59:27	Yazhou Zhang, Mengyao Wang, Chenyu Ren, Qiuchi Li, Prayag Tiwari, Benyou Wang, Jing Qin	cs.CL	cs.CL	The value of text classification's future research has encountered challenges and uncertainties, due to the extraordinary efficacy demonstrated by large language models (LLMs) across numerous downstream NLP tasks. In this era of open-ended language modeling, where task boundaries are gradually fading, an urgent question emerges: have we made significant advances in text classification under the full benefit of LLMs? To answer this question, we propose RGPT, an adaptive boosting framework tailored to produce a specialized text classification LLM by recurrently ensembling a pool of strong base learners. The base learners are constructed by adaptively adjusting the distribution of training samples and iteratively fine-tuning LLMs with them. Such base learners are then ensembled to be a specialized text classification LLM, by recurrently incorporating the historical predictions from the previous learners. Through a comprehensive empirical comparison, we show that RGPT significantly outperforms 8 SOTA PLMs and 7 SOTA LLMs on four benchmarks by 1.36% on average. Further evaluation experiments show a clear surpassing of RGPT over human classification.	[ -0.3314482271671295, -0.5714204907417297, 0.3931998610496521, 0.1625884771347046, -0.21956051886081696, 0.3641209900379181, -0.5373266935348511, -0.6303628087043762, -0.1316501349210739, 0.5589808821678162, -0.4352727234363556, -0.28857123851776123, -0.7578977942466736, 0.1936889886856079, -0.46206027269363403, 1.479815125465393, -0.05093807727098465, -0.31518882513046265, -0.023876920342445374, -0.2660418450832367, -0.7271880507469177, -0.6027725338935852, -0.5952818989753723, -0.4572199881076813, 0.5327531695365906, 0.49089792370796204, 0.43100523948669434, 0.7333396077156067, 0.43589335680007935, 0.1933445781469345, -0.12485475838184357, 0.16994158923625946, -0.48909658193588257, 0.3399713933467865, -0.2124013602733612, -0.5101147890090942, -0.5675398111343384, -0.020991744473576546, 0.8235058188438416, 0.34861111640930176, -0.1487428843975067, -0.07555120438337326, 0.39992842078208923, 0.6085081696510315, -0.45122554898262024, 0.030477972701191902, -0.7630904316902161, -0.0004664043372031301, -0.11959012597799301, -0.5294104218482971, -0.7295233607292175, -0.0024797639343887568, 0.13694633543491364, -0.19714833796024323, 0.48147693276405334, -0.03524365276098251, 0.5147354602813721, 0.3574899137020111, -0.215822234749794, -0.12220060080289841, -0.5175607800483704, 0.7625892758369446, -0.2627909183502197, 0.45986276865005493, -0.010360204614698887, 0.12155155092477798, -0.07655729353427887, -0.8961973190307617, -0.2598753869533539, -0.20033679902553558, 0.20069001615047455, 0.09508316218852997, -0.14907602965831757, -0.05671822279691696, 0.14384528994560242, 0.4335647523403168, -0.594508707523346, 0.3154267370700836, -0.3677283823490143, 0.05330681800842285, 0.4929436445236206, 0.07324966788291931, 0.40819084644317627, 0.11752211302518845, -0.7491844296455383, -0.06639979034662247, -0.5930960774421692, -0.22316956520080566, -0.08201944082975388, 0.41281312704086304, 0.2337120920419693, 0.3733219504356384, 0.01316075585782528, 0.682558536529541, -0.000016255904483841732, 0.03284643962979317, 0.1409969925880432, -0.1292584240436554, -0.3243408203125, 0.16905051469802856, 0.6772818565368652, 0.40768134593963623, 0.3079161047935486, -0.1549040526151657, -0.10783236473798752, -0.05346902087330818, 0.370479941368103, -0.903985321521759, -0.06114251911640167, -0.03402093052864075, -0.14237220585346222, -0.14899379014968872, -0.05807722359895706, -0.8630744218826294, -0.4453641474246979, 0.13087214529514313, 0.19439645111560822, -0.32241547107696533, -0.24206766486167908, 0.2500503361225128, -0.02133850008249283, 0.052446939051151276, 0.38377824425697327, -1.2274106740951538, 0.26820746064186096, 0.8735427856445312, 1.0837305784225464, -0.6761330366134644, -0.575031042098999, -0.2052048295736313, -0.23294967412948608, -0.20399683713912964, 0.919844388961792, -0.4875422716140747, -0.2981616258621216, -0.025619134306907654, 0.0011731911217793822, -0.17590193450450897, -0.4640774726867676, 0.9378181099891663, -0.6147156357765198, 0.042193371802568436, 0.12136533111333847, -0.5621823072433472, -0.090699702501297, 0.45297378301620483, -0.3982223868370056, 1.111038088798523, 0.2323126196861267, -0.8025540113449097, 0.6247609853744507, -0.21077466011047363, -0.2999425530433655, 0.3902759850025177, -0.009305390529334545, -0.48734503984451294, 0.11181862652301788, 0.14491154253482819, 0.6903970241546631, -0.32166165113449097, 0.2649341821670532, 0.04127202928066254, -0.3689740300178528, 0.23323796689510345, -0.6264023184776306, 0.42768263816833496, 0.021319111809134483, -0.20007450878620148, 0.18443886935710907, -0.6200876832008362, 0.15472568571567535, -0.19241712987422943, -0.9181719422340393, -0.2276315689086914, -0.03806682303547859, 0.20658782124519348, -0.0261563491076231, 0.07316385954618454, -0.4712236821651459, 0.4738503098487854, -0.3429678976535797, 0.7494397163391113, 0.8335573673248291, -0.1820359081029892, 0.5150169730186462, -0.49159982800483704, 0.7607351541519165, -0.5406273603439331, -0.4531542956829071, -0.37348291277885437, -0.6762186884880066, -0.8994246125221252, -0.3752654194831848, 0.4089944660663605, 0.6634730100631714, -0.3037267029285431, 0.6785045266151428, -0.7562021613121033, -0.5541521906852722, -0.0819006860256195, 0.05818591266870499, 0.031022975221276283, 0.3396569788455963, 0.5497990250587463, -0.2536674439907074, -0.5323991775512695, -0.5986223220825195, -0.5147289633750916, -0.23472769558429718, -0.06570224463939667, 0.1413002461194992, 0.4070480763912201, -0.4012405574321747, 0.877459704875946, -0.28569653630256653, -0.2918112874031067, -0.654625654220581, 0.09494442492723465, 0.08710245043039322, 0.44466328620910645, 0.49875617027282715, -0.6425337791442871, -0.6812151074409485, 0.25864526629447937, -0.3990037441253662, -0.23259328305721283, -0.2998344600200653, 0.22172482311725616, 0.1972745954990387, 0.48638030886650085, -0.4433619976043701, 0.10539624094963074, 0.46649929881095886, -0.23136356472969055, 0.3275739848613739, -0.2771216630935669, -0.02548634074628353, -0.8639264702796936, -0.30111706256866455, -0.03556805104017258, -0.5339018702507019, -0.6848108172416687, 0.06929003447294235, 0.3253575563430786, -0.034377891570329666, -0.08621480315923691, 0.5573884844779968, -0.19895537197589874, 0.029804404824972153, -0.5957949757575989, 0.025106001645326614, -0.44196125864982605, 0.35777410864830017, 0.3285042941570282, 0.7902414202690125, 0.5121288895606995, -0.6937019228935242, 0.281409353017807, 0.05508733540773392, -0.40193960070610046, 0.2958742380142212, -0.30151891708374023, 0.13720452785491943, -0.06356484442949295, 0.5583454966545105, -0.8730498552322388, -0.24315045773983002, -0.0007708441116847098, -0.42975473403930664, 0.4626336693763733, -0.14810840785503387, -0.2535213828086853, -0.2245965152978897, -0.06826559454202652, 0.3980332612991333, 0.6490854620933533, -0.7456446886062622, 0.6136753559112549, 0.15788137912750244, -0.41506245732307434, -0.6563234329223633, -0.917582094669342, 0.2725588083267212, -0.2660285532474518, -0.45179179310798645, 0.4941265881061554, 0.16177059710025787, 0.2269858717918396, -0.11167455464601517, -0.1584213376045227, -0.0614229217171669, 0.060333821922540665, 0.08331796526908875, 0.11056594550609589, -0.13832485675811768, 0.459818571805954, -0.17071330547332764, -0.29743945598602295, -0.15024784207344055, -0.6454450488090515, 0.5361093282699585, -0.23528574407100677, -0.1043010875582695, -0.10489863157272339, 0.09707789868116379, 0.5599831938743591, -0.013994014821946621, 0.4948657751083374, 0.6449098587036133, -0.15882377326488495, -0.6790122985839844, -0.4728442430496216, -0.016339479014277458, -0.443839430809021, 0.8884797096252441, -0.23638299107551575, -1.2846957445144653, 0.11214523017406464, 0.08331187814474106, 0.3783349096775055, 0.46239933371543884, 0.6377651691436768, 0.24530404806137085, 0.699793815612793, 0.7890947461128235, -0.1466522216796875, 0.6437171101570129, 0.014665080234408379, -0.1057882234454155, -0.6163773536682129, 0.03759869188070297, -0.43238919973373413, -0.23084959387779236, -0.8899417519569397, -0.5500526428222656, 0.23039546608924866, 0.105272077023983, -0.2247377187013626, 0.34085944294929504, -0.7304630875587463, 0.5729975700378418, 0.37386929988861084, 0.24701176583766937, 0.39057591557502747, 0.17343124747276306, 0.4045643210411072, -0.09544394910335541, -0.8658718466758728, -0.41251423954963684, 1.034261703491211, 0.6778696179389954, 0.7642912864685059, -0.031113626435399055, 0.5826379656791687, 0.4066309332847595, 0.9628812670707703, -1.0001206398010254, 0.5736438035964966, -0.2990969717502594, -0.5764612555503845, -0.21924179792404175, -0.49049994349479675, -0.7570247054100037, 0.40395987033843994, -0.2027120441198349, -0.4339886009693146, 0.02760116569697857, 0.07470178604125977, -0.13472260534763336, 0.4726163446903229, -0.5258966088294983, 0.6777611374855042, -0.24371238052845, -0.2945728003978729, -0.1171194314956665, -0.2949567437171936, 0.25593850016593933, -0.26839688420295715, 0.04739962890744209, -0.00967904832214117, -0.442910373210907, 0.8680647015571594, -0.20584465563297272, 0.8514955043792725, 0.07312395423650742, -0.04468509927392006, 0.37297919392585754, -0.10412728041410446, 0.5142204761505127, -0.14324027299880981, 0.04125937446951866, -0.12593138217926025, -0.36456915736198425, -0.5233412384986877, -0.5259958505630493, 0.6516510248184204, -0.5183472633361816, -0.7044127583503723, -0.6339377164840698, -0.3972291350364685, -0.3862255811691284, 0.17434564232826233, 0.35547471046447754, 0.16675162315368652, -0.16701377928256989, 0.5615899562835693, 0.6699185967445374, -0.1159946545958519, 0.36978211998939514, 0.22599714994430542, -0.17438822984695435, -0.5376121997833252, 0.9861902594566345, -0.02622242271900177, 0.428751140832901, 0.5885505080223083, 0.3871588110923767, -0.3371735215187073, -0.923909068107605, -0.6229211688041687, -0.054265543818473816, -0.829657793045044, -0.30799686908721924, -0.8190755844116211, -0.17409709095954895, -0.16483809053897858, -0.29139795899391174, -0.1937168836593628, -0.33727043867111206, -0.3052978515625, -0.4390122592449188, 0.41408729553222656, 0.7823936343193054, 0.15489248931407928, 0.3365005850791931, -0.8636828660964966, -0.23815815150737762, 0.5400955677032471, 0.348905473947525, -0.06934399157762527, -0.9155431389808655, -0.09115694463253021, -0.46123993396759033, -0.2753274142742157, -0.7163307070732117, 0.4807146489620209, 0.3448745310306549, 0.36894479393959045, -0.05530380457639694, -0.012901014648377895, 0.3913382291793823, -0.5876702070236206, 0.6774430871009827, 0.35118353366851807, -0.6480314135551453, 0.20575128495693207, -0.45183712244033813, 0.16397160291671753, 0.4772264063358307, 0.27628806233406067, -0.5191828608512878, -0.24436421692371368, -0.5087611079216003, -0.8130027651786804, 0.6119645833969116, -0.03944522887468338, 0.38831713795661926, 0.09081723541021347, 0.6208138465881348, 0.10294028371572495, -0.12473373860120773, -1.1465702056884766, 0.12264891713857651, -0.22774282097816467, -0.3423211872577667, -0.22652767598628998, -0.4230458736419678, 0.36092475056648254, 0.046383682638406754, 0.5995392203330994, -0.25785231590270996, 0.016500307247042656, 0.2825700342655182, -0.04454326629638672, 0.024241823703050613, 0.6727460622787476, 0.5541368126869202, 0.532331109046936, -0.1633671373128891, 0.23978273570537567, 0.6631565690040588, -0.6966463327407837, 0.2760554254055023, -0.061171259731054306, -0.1650100201368332, -0.27898237109184265, 0.6409592628479004, 0.7121506333351135, 0.18645137548446655, -0.8335893750190735, 0.35575369000434875, 0.01960282400250435, -0.3039691150188446, 0.09596575796604156, 0.26954638957977295, -0.0076165697537362576, 0.1471439152956009, 0.6262116432189941, 0.19357648491859436, -0.26775509119033813, -0.6045984029769897, 0.3992317318916321, 0.23856478929519653, -0.6569050550460815, -0.08375944197177887, 0.41873717308044434, 0.378408282995224, -0.33795928955078125, 0.28134045004844666, -0.05434148758649826, -0.9448301792144775, 0.4132266938686371, 0.743651807308197, 0.9620939493179321, -0.2089097946882248, -0.1316377967596054, 0.35602867603302, 0.4353835880756378, -0.505666196346283, -0.17899514734745026, -0.1014842689037323, -0.8420064449310303, -0.512235701084137, -0.8279788494110107, -0.43971091508865356, 0.19846320152282715, -0.3935205638408661, 0.19021819531917572, -0.5969175696372986, -0.13691307604312897, -0.20773810148239136, -0.012098325416445732, -0.13745199143886566, 0.25602516531944275, -0.12955620884895325, 1.123558521270752, -0.7835599780082703, 0.767707109451294, 0.6932644844055176, -0.07925882190465927, -0.2416713684797287, 0.18012002110481262, -0.4573865234851837, -0.6221198439598083, 0.8201280832290649, 0.4156440496444702, -0.2008180171251297, 0.21646378934383392, -0.42001646757125854, -0.38135141134262085, 0.8823626637458801, 0.14547505974769592, -0.5517227053642273, -0.08173585683107376, -0.14852222800254822, 0.6130089163780212, -0.49754205346107483, -0.1316835731267929, 0.44793277978897095, 0.29986536502838135, -0.11287204176187515, -0.8756324052810669, 0.007073907181620598, 0.03533892333507538, -0.17290711402893066, 0.25586822628974915, -0.5097517371177673, 0.7999268770217896, -0.11150725930929184, -0.4694949686527252, 0.12893983721733093, 0.7637895941734314, 0.21607859432697296, 0.08856648206710815, 0.6702229380607605, 0.5675392150878906, 0.6360141038894653, -0.15561097860336304, 1.0142730474472046, 0.12731999158859253, 0.4609678089618683, 0.9787347912788391, 0.005262390244752169, 1.0237946510314941, 0.01633945107460022, -0.3719286620616913, 0.3412177264690399, 0.6939740180969238, -0.08101093024015427, 0.20543429255485535, 0.10867274552583694, -0.4736495018005371, -0.5744150876998901, 0.04840504750609398, -0.4187549948692322, 0.2587057948112488, 0.4186907112598419, -0.42851874232292175, -0.11029013246297836, 0.12891985476016998, -0.23562757670879364, 0.22052575647830963, -0.5576528906822205, 0.6461388468742371, 0.04134539142251015, -0.845844566822052, 0.5614716410636902, 0.12146908789873123, 1.0611979961395264, -0.3980041742324829, 0.21424593031406403, 0.06668668240308762, 0.5369626879692078, -0.25550973415374756, -0.9769546389579773, 0.16624082624912262, 0.25213420391082764, -0.1793498545885086, -0.5909133553504944, 1.0625919103622437, -0.37847810983657837, -0.4123649597167969, 0.25426575541496277, 0.41464418172836304, -0.011145506985485554, -0.055690184235572815, -0.4802073538303375, -0.1708190143108368, 0.11467369645833969, -0.16539986431598663, 0.5787665843963623, 0.4526876211166382, 0.008068791590631008, 0.8955009579658508, 0.5905796885490417, 0.11515767127275467, 0.10596951097249985, -0.17269043624401093, 0.7633057832717896, -0.763157844543457, -0.6517907977104187, -0.9954376220703125, 0.03055766597390175, 0.15085309743881226, -0.336087703704834, 0.614486038684845, 0.46722185611724854, 0.8219230771064758, 0.031887926161289215, 1.0181702375411987, 0.13156960904598236, 0.6783773303031921, -0.49666982889175415, 0.43854933977127075, -0.45910051465034485, 0.1980530172586441, 0.11179724335670471, -0.7740994691848755, -0.5216251015663147, 0.6262672543525696, -0.14491437375545502, 0.23783499002456665, 0.508674144744873, 0.37233659625053406, -0.020379623398184776, 0.20568276941776276, 0.27611270546913147, 0.03591905161738396, 0.3380241096019745, 0.5967127084732056, 1.0418912172317505, -0.1810292750597, 0.8099427819252014, 0.11107122898101807, -0.54290372133255, -0.31181085109710693, -0.9501591920852661, -1.0642666816711426, -0.31761571764945984, -0.17623233795166016, -0.33765533566474915, 0.13791953027248383, 0.9597852230072021, 0.6354634165763855, -0.7752916812896729, -0.031311146914958954, -0.6737810373306274, 0.07467406988143921, -0.2410038411617279, -0.24017590284347534, 0.33431917428970337, -0.5874742865562439, -0.836958646774292, 0.38894224166870117, 0.3483615815639496, 0.15127205848693848, -0.26943403482437134, -0.007522518280893564, 0.010282425209879875, -0.2916833162307739, 0.5568189024925232, 0.4362838566303253, -0.49613115191459656, -0.2748953402042389, -0.030905477702617645, -0.1407829225063324, 0.15263782441616058, 1.0179542303085327, -0.758364200592041, 0.16058194637298584, 0.7438393235206604, 1.1214420795440674, 0.49701157212257385, 0.16115900874137878, 0.5979940295219421, -0.8324350118637085, -0.08530469983816147, 0.433266818523407, 0.1826092153787613, 0.22541677951812744, -0.18204444646835327, 0.5644012093544006, 0.285092830657959, -0.8150984048843384, -0.9733778834342957, 0.29078352451324463, -0.9755409359931946, -0.3005814850330353, 1.1908705234527588, -0.15843822062015533, 0.004077304620295763, -0.2552248537540436, -0.2443496435880661, -0.0316646546125412, -0.38404884934425354, 0.5108947157859802, 0.6795861124992371, -0.22013328969478607, -0.4382912516593933, -0.618016242980957, 0.5720357894897461, 0.4561890661716461, -0.7504120469093323, 0.5991433262825012, 0.18865138292312622, 0.32896488904953003, 0.3041079044342041, 0.7116717100143433, 0.2123996466398239, 0.22542308270931244, -0.15856397151947021, -0.2636502981185913, 0.008879967033863068, -0.4130280315876007, -0.3777227997779846, 0.45806288719177246, 0.15129226446151733, 0.10522352904081345 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07448v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07448v1	AraSpider: Democratizing Arabic-to-SQL	2024-02-12T07:11:13	2024-02-12T07:11:13	Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Mohamed, Ahmed B. Zaky	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG	This study presents AraSpider, the first Arabic version of the Spider dataset, aimed at improving natural language processing (NLP) in the Arabic-speaking community. Four multilingual translation models were tested for their effectiveness in translating English to Arabic. Additionally, two models were assessed for their ability to generate SQL queries from Arabic text. The results showed that using back translation significantly improved the performance of both ChatGPT 3.5 and SQLCoder models, which are considered top performers on the Spider dataset. Notably, ChatGPT 3.5 demonstrated high-quality translation, while SQLCoder excelled in text-to-SQL tasks. The study underscores the importance of incorporating contextual schema and employing back translation strategies to enhance model performance in Arabic NLP tasks. Moreover, the provision of detailed methodologies for reproducibility and translation of the dataset into other languages highlights the research's commitment to promoting transparency and collaborative knowledge sharing in the field. Overall, these contributions advance NLP research, empower Arabic-speaking researchers, and enrich the global discourse on language comprehension and database interrogation.	[ -0.4291820824146271, -0.5330329537391663, 0.13650047779083252, 0.17614136636257172, -0.3278638422489166, 0.3011307418346405, -0.13822686672210693, -0.6538591384887695, 0.4100293517112732, 0.7817651033401489, -0.06636026501655579, -0.799160361289978, -0.9938241839408875, 0.3604013919830322, -1.0041505098342896, 1.3655623197555542, 0.029502591118216515, 0.12631116807460785, 0.23962710797786713, -0.49261966347694397, 0.06988229602575302, -0.7052704095840454, -0.46458524465560913, 0.09357688575983047, 0.49091634154319763, 0.38353052735328674, 1.2790839672088623, 0.38285696506500244, 0.42048904299736023, 0.2685907781124115, -0.11556416004896164, 0.2712550461292267, -0.07227666676044464, 0.23270417749881744, -0.30626803636550903, -0.35164034366607666, -0.44655221700668335, -0.2509668469429016, 0.6721950769424438, 0.8075966835021973, -0.5628470182418823, 0.38330110907554626, 0.01812887005507946, 1.1902598142623901, -0.83554607629776, -0.028371872380375862, -0.3929731249809265, 0.013142388314008713, -0.42362549901008606, 0.26143327355384827, -0.41059255599975586, -0.4433559477329254, -0.1719367504119873, -0.35828348994255066, 0.08798244595527649, 0.08554556965827942, 0.542767345905304, 0.11213048547506332, -0.80019211769104, -0.3565007448196411, -0.8411654829978943, 0.5680195093154907, -0.597187876701355, 0.4564313590526581, 0.546164870262146, 0.5955049395561218, -0.17737606167793274, -0.9983614683151245, -0.5615428686141968, -0.0434889979660511, -0.049769409000873566, -0.09455522894859314, -0.5125041007995605, -0.3998294770717621, -0.2654515504837036, 0.35078710317611694, -0.5382624268531799, -0.2868846654891968, -0.39781737327575684, -0.09302574396133423, 0.6735610365867615, 0.017410458996891975, 0.49953728914260864, 0.01219773106276989, -0.04944136366248131, -0.09603536128997803, -0.6530317068099976, -0.209928497672081, 0.2815280556678772, 0.50164395570755, -0.24001207947731018, 0.852792501449585, -0.1887068748474121, 0.6900076270103455, -0.35689878463745117, 0.2532203793525696, 0.014881485141813755, -0.4254983067512512, 0.06899818032979965, 0.2361871898174286, 0.5128061771392822, 0.21813075244426727, 0.20310993492603302, -0.3896811306476593, -0.11276315152645111, -0.13892501592636108, 0.353788286447525, -0.7729830741882324, -0.13172096014022827, 0.31481102108955383, -0.4702283442020416, 0.049531858414411545, -0.24999940395355225, -0.8619036674499512, -0.5409999489784241, -0.14826032519340515, 0.20652362704277039, -0.42686766386032104, -0.5017457008361816, 0.24427002668380737, 0.08008275926113129, -0.04558243229985237, 0.3845103681087494, -0.6797419786453247, 0.9083337783813477, 0.6912031769752502, 1.1106517314910889, -0.33031323552131653, -0.18920092284679413, -0.3440481424331665, 0.3724915385246277, -0.7340161204338074, 0.7727476954460144, -0.4381519854068756, -0.16603726148605347, 0.13190783560276031, -0.24115633964538574, 0.020427117124199867, -0.4457809627056122, 0.6329123377799988, -0.7696242928504944, 0.12408016622066498, 0.22790800034999847, -0.3653658628463745, -0.5035542845726013, 0.04650210961699486, -0.8698046803474426, 0.7949852347373962, 0.15259921550750732, -0.8508121371269226, 0.3115982115268707, -0.8227292895317078, -0.42249947786331177, 0.03435584902763367, -0.023883258923888206, -0.4777694046497345, 0.12212652713060379, 0.48134252429008484, 0.08289159089326859, -0.4222338795661926, 0.11970463395118713, 0.07635361701250076, -0.2949520945549011, 0.24952614307403564, 0.05118657276034355, 0.7406699657440186, 0.35376840829849243, -0.19126559793949127, 0.030720138922333717, -0.6103242635726929, -0.07598593831062317, -0.032881397753953934, -0.07396291941404343, -0.051991403102874756, 0.24793215095996857, 0.42580872774124146, 0.23981763422489166, 0.12081702798604965, -0.4536660313606262, 0.12410011887550354, -0.7637683749198914, 0.24906004965305328, 0.4640561640262604, -0.10971773415803909, 0.5990880131721497, -0.22619673609733582, 0.6706265807151794, 0.0852203518152237, -0.020145172253251076, 0.15401794016361237, -0.4416995942592621, -0.8175009489059448, -0.24203699827194214, 0.5470137596130371, 0.5028358697891235, -0.772160530090332, 0.03963621333241463, -0.21738594770431519, -0.8704628944396973, -0.6809329986572266, -0.08441485464572906, 0.17482104897499084, 0.08350206911563873, 0.5489628911018372, -0.524019181728363, -0.6099981665611267, -1.1317715644836426, -0.5910382866859436, 0.02226273901760578, 0.22108151018619537, 0.4175437390804291, 0.6938822865486145, -0.23898205161094666, 0.7886675000190735, -0.25210654735565186, -0.5223881602287292, -0.48467618227005005, 0.04524289816617966, 0.6226874589920044, 0.5087072849273682, 0.5281043648719788, -0.7995391488075256, -0.8578621745109558, 0.19892741739749908, -0.4087793529033661, 0.25968948006629944, 0.4642806947231293, -0.17680056393146515, 0.7613583207130432, -0.006793449632823467, -0.7630897760391235, 0.7968400716781616, 0.8835727572441101, -0.4648352563381195, 0.6654250621795654, 0.09303252398967743, 0.5337885022163391, -1.2972769737243652, 0.34050682187080383, -0.2606251835823059, -0.2503628134727478, -0.5638034343719482, 0.2676056921482086, -0.23647983372211456, -0.48546740412712097, -0.49856945872306824, 0.5345566868782043, -0.43829837441444397, -0.3479650020599365, -0.27309486269950867, -0.020779810845851898, -0.2052610218524933, 0.07663509249687195, -0.04179276153445244, 1.4873626232147217, 0.591576874256134, -0.6380038261413574, 0.1048739105463028, 0.5846263766288757, -0.5577793121337891, 0.1078401580452919, -0.7465927600860596, 0.33420172333717346, 0.0981128141283989, 0.2877136468887329, -0.8616340756416321, -0.2963218688964844, 0.3544919490814209, -0.6919671297073364, -0.08438438177108765, -0.5061492919921875, -0.7669151425361633, 0.19655565917491913, 0.056889429688453674, 0.21254219114780426, 0.37619081139564514, -0.3015020489692688, 0.721331000328064, 0.6612321138381958, -0.5110693573951721, -0.7141594290733337, -0.6421778202056885, 0.7055461406707764, -0.062021926045417786, -0.5674898028373718, 0.34913405776023865, 0.37890398502349854, -0.2694251239299774, -0.2619359493255615, -0.07644861936569214, -0.5148501992225647, 0.06426172703504562, 0.08671189099550247, -0.02599247731268406, -0.04138217121362686, 0.1596260368824005, 0.1285659372806549, -0.1847374141216278, -0.016410673037171364, -0.26789942383766174, 0.6698176860809326, 0.021883560344576836, -0.2687220275402069, -0.26692211627960205, 0.868538498878479, 0.1622253805398941, -0.5496103763580322, 1.3548133373260498, 0.5571213960647583, -0.10364145040512085, -0.11528053134679794, -0.17525099217891693, -0.22573144733905792, -0.39515966176986694, 0.4247532784938812, -0.35712137818336487, -0.8524279594421387, 0.3065929710865021, -0.2915048897266388, 0.1593104600906372, 0.3811335563659668, 0.5356898307800293, -0.05309794470667839, 1.5774543285369873, 0.9600656628608704, -0.1531621515750885, 0.10870474576950073, -0.1637391746044159, 0.3306501805782318, -0.6125636696815491, 0.06310968101024628, -1.0979787111282349, -0.15564103424549103, -0.7189337611198425, -0.299241840839386, 0.47105348110198975, 0.15277720987796783, -0.3468095064163208, 0.43814969062805176, -0.7335841655731201, 0.33863696455955505, 0.2682598829269409, 0.03639031574130058, 0.3782321512699127, 0.5058102607727051, 0.11640170216560364, -0.2287454903125763, -0.5687589645385742, -0.9566004872322083, 1.1060534715652466, -0.11842197179794312, 0.3230646848678589, 0.9200900793075562, 0.7580615878105164, 0.7480037212371826, 0.13376334309577942, -0.27732935547828674, 0.5197485089302063, -0.1776871681213379, -0.7985361814498901, -0.1044606864452362, -0.14134953916072845, -1.2409297227859497, 0.28288209438323975, -0.1186697855591774, -0.8578939437866211, 0.07847423106431961, 0.03451518714427948, 0.21371328830718994, 0.12663385272026062, -0.2907714247703552, 0.7288252115249634, 0.14409257471561432, -0.4478735029697418, -0.7226188778877258, -0.5047510862350464, 0.051906898617744446, 0.03484659641981125, 0.49304768443107605, -0.08630497753620148, -0.4588046371936798, 0.800462007522583, -0.23275667428970337, 0.6387871503829956, -0.0843208059668541, -0.0030757396016269922, 0.068146251142025, 0.5455839037895203, 0.44505199790000916, 0.021886391565203667, -0.5510096549987793, 0.4537539482116699, 0.07285608351230621, -0.6275134086608887, -0.4638805687427521, 0.2634766101837158, -0.9856573939323425, -0.6874089241027832, -0.7314679622650146, -0.40342459082603455, -0.08828049153089523, 0.14250324666500092, -0.14332854747772217, 0.09056790918111801, -0.17129118740558624, 0.2638261616230011, 0.05765192210674286, -0.05364884436130524, 0.11910548806190491, 0.7682085037231445, -0.7029097080230713, -0.5500218272209167, 0.653491735458374, 0.11485739052295685, -0.09965121746063232, 0.04747065529227257, -0.31915566325187683, -0.19003623723983765, -0.7038562297821045, -0.8413783311843872, -0.03076757676899433, -0.6971384286880493, -0.17350588738918304, -0.7853384613990784, -0.20952117443084717, -0.45746904611587524, 0.10241489112377167, -0.48516467213630676, -1.010140061378479, -0.011080698110163212, 0.18597730994224548, 0.6182481646537781, 0.7422767281532288, -0.021643705666065216, 0.28192847967147827, -0.9132636189460754, 0.09006800502538681, -0.3649962842464447, 0.1452893763780594, -0.18593508005142212, -0.5700063705444336, -0.6066855192184448, 0.059176720678806305, -0.18519620597362518, -1.1392607688903809, 0.7970504760742188, 0.45374658703804016, 0.23660044372081757, -0.37182512879371643, 0.005067330785095692, 0.4965559244155884, -0.6462713479995728, 0.9653124213218689, -0.08213531225919724, -1.0559000968933105, 0.6863745450973511, -0.19391368329524994, 0.12256484478712082, 0.4946571886539459, 0.6923716068267822, -0.6982546448707581, -0.30613160133361816, -0.48313742876052856, -1.0694992542266846, 0.6929494738578796, 0.5766422748565674, 0.14402654767036438, 0.08954205363988876, 0.16486530005931854, 0.29619497060775757, 0.4477103054523468, -0.45624884963035583, -0.34473520517349243, -0.14044342935085297, -0.07437334954738617, -0.30488282442092896, -0.1941835880279541, -0.1551605761051178, -0.2279459834098816, 0.7581656575202942, -0.17389488220214844, 0.08851956576108932, 0.15752796828746796, -0.34934327006340027, 0.10473655164241791, 0.521812915802002, 0.3071732223033905, 0.886428952217102, 0.07658608257770538, 0.05251286178827286, 0.10425606369972229, -0.4553777277469635, 0.23491740226745605, 0.2863626182079315, -0.3204145133495331, 0.1278267800807953, 0.3662742078304291, 0.36784082651138306, -0.21437667310237885, -0.5395601987838745, 0.2825557589530945, -0.10478751361370087, 0.29282182455062866, -0.52364581823349, 0.07959722727537155, 0.058860503137111664, 0.11250120401382446, 0.5582774877548218, 0.3369545042514801, 0.765330970287323, -0.2846643626689911, 0.37207841873168945, 0.12362680584192276, -0.35634294152259827, -0.1762738972902298, 0.4279457628726959, 0.08442959189414978, -0.5391793251037598, 0.7120182514190674, 0.13819904625415802, -0.5157212615013123, 0.4366529583930969, 0.6159571409225464, 0.6337583065032959, -0.25003641843795776, 0.34970802068710327, 0.47749313712120056, 0.17550760507583618, 0.3875413239002228, 0.3224466145038605, -0.3431810736656189, -0.6331849694252014, -0.5383951663970947, -0.5607456564903259, -0.637465238571167, -0.6656548380851746, -0.7543584108352661, -0.007080197799950838, -0.14281928539276123, -0.2923084795475006, 0.04440970718860626, 0.18925802409648895, -0.3061407804489136, -0.08653058111667633, -0.31873396039009094, 1.0884509086608887, -0.6749464273452759, 0.9905354380607605, 0.961696207523346, -0.6140485405921936, -0.39840930700302124, -0.29661837220191956, -0.13658227026462555, -0.5571385622024536, 0.7447322010993958, -0.008069314993917942, -0.22333364188671112, 0.2379152774810791, -0.7553046941757202, -1.008933186531067, 0.63582843542099, 0.4280829131603241, -0.27831318974494934, 0.34963446855545044, 0.5689807534217834, 0.5171816349029541, -0.2610017657279968, 0.32926806807518005, 0.5204377770423889, 0.3693278431892395, -0.2901664078235626, -0.8441643118858337, -0.21488474309444427, -0.49871957302093506, -0.008754178881645203, 0.4606442451477051, -0.43464118242263794, 0.8733001947402954, -0.0037388899363577366, -0.3853875398635864, 0.28439584374427795, 0.9104569554328918, 0.39003488421440125, -0.0013636855874210596, 0.23956133425235748, 0.43050873279571533, 0.35439786314964294, 0.09420086443424225, 1.1606502532958984, -0.6182786822319031, 0.10980992019176483, 1.0533232688903809, -0.518755316734314, 1.0942912101745605, 0.6758051514625549, -0.3545837998390198, 0.8444243669509888, 0.2967388927936554, 0.3268209993839264, 0.5420806407928467, -0.011860347352921963, -0.5718087553977966, -0.16943895816802979, -0.5106675624847412, -0.48374947905540466, 0.6209130883216858, 0.3343455195426941, -0.16136053204536438, -0.39185404777526855, -0.03302893415093422, 0.15599104762077332, 0.6440497040748596, 0.0366433747112751, 1.0283042192459106, -0.008729657158255577, -0.5686637163162231, 0.48186007142066956, 0.30467939376831055, 0.17324525117874146, -0.5460062026977539, -0.5239477753639221, -0.37263035774230957, 0.3016844391822815, -0.2539083957672119, -0.9310950636863708, 0.7380812168121338, 0.1094452366232872, -0.09032650291919708, 0.08787574619054794, 0.65128093957901, -0.20354275405406952, -0.5843120217323303, 0.3720678985118866, 0.5156463980674744, 0.590874433517456, -0.13622191548347473, -0.8954445719718933, 0.2787153422832489, -0.023637041449546814, -0.1737193912267685, 0.34354719519615173, 0.2494516670703888, -0.04959520697593689, 0.8431790471076965, 0.7879905104637146, 0.3121635317802429, -0.1756715029478073, -0.05203016847372055, 0.8129104375839233, -0.5796095132827759, -0.3382638096809387, -0.7817505598068237, 0.517699658870697, -0.2747476100921631, -0.21951459348201752, 1.0265917778015137, 0.9283260703086853, 0.43183282017707825, 0.001853759167715907, 0.49601301550865173, -0.14327752590179443, 0.9309681057929993, -0.3027042746543884, 1.0747523307800293, -0.4243171811103821, 0.08681473135948181, -0.05407259613275528, -0.849861741065979, -0.2961711287498474, 0.550479531288147, 0.006033125799149275, 0.05167967453598976, 0.3042214512825012, 0.9112331867218018, 0.09507937729358673, 0.13137245178222656, 0.0784575566649437, 0.18403705954551697, 0.2631630599498749, 0.30021142959594727, 0.6102144122123718, -0.7831669449806213, 0.477501779794693, -0.23150669038295746, 0.01654159277677536, 0.0032462466042488813, -0.6036832332611084, -0.6132389903068542, -0.730766773223877, -0.12373928725719452, -0.5923730731010437, 0.6388238072395325, 0.8973785638809204, 0.7599823474884033, -1.0394598245620728, -0.6804546117782593, -0.14324872195720673, 0.040062759071588516, -0.3632087707519531, -0.11245409399271011, 0.6648260951042175, -0.18735827505588531, -0.5965983271598816, 0.342601478099823, 0.2285483032464981, -0.2817898690700531, -0.1370943933725357, -0.13397078216075897, -0.5391913652420044, -0.006576561834663153, 0.6015481352806091, 0.021376948803663254, -0.5287681818008423, 0.03965863958001137, -0.33561772108078003, -0.19847099483013153, 0.10958268493413925, 0.34637728333473206, -0.9424352645874023, 0.0972897931933403, 0.048328276723623276, 0.5892422199249268, 0.7833560705184937, -0.19662447273731232, 0.7423586249351501, -0.6171810626983643, 0.43053746223449707, 0.5818872451782227, 0.10346026718616486, 0.4096463918685913, -0.11636484414339066, 0.9297213554382324, -0.3781757056713104, -0.5942259430885315, -0.7768465280532837, 0.3495110273361206, -0.4566981792449951, -0.25335609912872314, 0.7331718802452087, -0.03766188770532608, -0.25888532400131226, -0.3956591486930847, -0.4079977869987488, 0.3475298285484314, -0.4520314335823059, 0.9405835270881653, 0.6121287941932678, 0.06131191924214363, -0.5328574776649475, -0.5743997693061829, 0.5511945486068726, 0.5897769927978516, -0.8088185787200928, -0.05806519463658333, 0.39164355397224426, -0.12012088298797607, 0.14283455908298492, 0.4480772316455841, -0.18672408163547516, 0.5790119767189026, -0.03229474276304245, 0.3989701271057129, 0.2112540304660797, -0.25502875447273254, -0.15431010723114014, 0.2383485734462738, 0.30945420265197754, 0.1468433439731598 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07446v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07446v3	Quality Does Matter: A Detailed Look at the Quality and Utility of Web-Mined Parallel Corpora	2024-02-12T07:03:14	2024-06-14T08:50:53	Surangika Ranathunga, Nisansa de Silva, Menan Velayuthan, Aloka Fernando, Charitha Rathnayake	cs.CL	cs.CL	We conducted a detailed analysis on the quality of web-mined corpora for two low-resource languages (making three language pairs, English-Sinhala, English-Tamil and Sinhala-Tamil). We ranked each corpus according to a similarity measure and carried out an intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation on different portions of this ranked corpus. We show that there are significant quality differences between different portions of web-mined corpora and that the quality varies across languages and datasets. We also show that, for some web-mined datasets, Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models trained with their highest-ranked 25k portion can be on par with human-curated datasets.	[ -0.3080136775970459, -0.27271002531051636, 0.37496238946914673, 0.2435123175382614, -0.33789491653442383, 0.29437822103500366, -0.44479671120643616, -0.5968447327613831, 0.20070628821849823, 0.3260069191455841, -0.10354835540056229, -0.4258216917514801, -0.6717707514762878, 0.5105710625648499, -0.6448370218276978, 0.9290338754653931, -0.054399050772190094, 0.3284672200679779, -0.45535507798194885, -0.2683568298816681, -0.26275280117988586, -0.4990008771419525, -0.6033956408500671, -0.03569326177239418, 0.6273153424263, 0.28136396408081055, 1.1519542932510376, 0.9611742496490479, 0.9548940062522888, 0.3196776807308197, -0.09242743253707886, 0.16424205899238586, -0.5707763433456421, 0.06637272983789444, -0.696378231048584, -0.663327157497406, -0.22434188425540924, 0.2432732880115509, 0.4677913784980774, 1.0071691274642944, 0.06336984038352966, 0.5023726224899292, 0.23528647422790527, 0.7035358548164368, -0.30323994159698486, 0.10851773619651794, -0.5718693733215332, -0.06743977218866348, -0.36092039942741394, -0.18148696422576904, -0.10309166461229324, -0.47675850987434387, -0.07988105714321136, -0.6160812377929688, 0.4519001245498657, 0.20579324662685394, 1.0403752326965332, 0.39310044050216675, -0.31112611293792725, -0.30328530073165894, -0.4867958724498749, 1.1924855709075928, -0.6447067856788635, 0.3277287185192108, 0.6025422811508179, 0.16643968224525452, 0.1732303351163864, -0.6348490118980408, -0.39048147201538086, -0.07622251659631729, -0.2738739848136902, 0.10807065665721893, -0.1122058779001236, -0.09877599030733109, 0.06127346307039261, 0.6981592178344727, -0.7596932649612427, 0.3078354299068451, -0.7322940826416016, -0.3911100924015045, 0.31030410528182983, 0.25105348229408264, 0.5806435942649841, -0.20400594174861908, -0.24454446136951447, -0.49683085083961487, -0.7151085138320923, 0.017118340358138084, 0.8586829304695129, 0.4370511770248413, 0.02850211411714554, 0.6459722518920898, -0.2184230089187622, 0.7615571022033691, -0.2844351828098297, -0.1653842031955719, 0.09990933537483215, -0.6656395196914673, -0.2101679891347885, -0.04854941740632057, 0.8543157577514648, 0.37123221158981323, 0.22343042492866516, -0.3425789475440979, -0.21096837520599365, 0.29143261909484863, 0.42357856035232544, -0.752066969871521, -0.030285121873021126, 0.30135834217071533, -0.8141282796859741, -0.2669907212257385, 0.047833722084760666, -0.3936992585659027, -0.19384834170341492, -0.7537755370140076, 0.2791490852832794, -0.39740630984306335, -0.6038471460342407, -0.07603758573532104, -0.3006146550178528, 0.008723706938326359, 0.03581291064620018, -0.8407803177833557, 0.40665486454963684, 0.9257349371910095, 0.91895991563797, -0.6094261407852173, -0.4411526024341583, -0.2900213599205017, -0.46918144822120667, -0.558918833732605, 0.8555317521095276, -0.4460394084453583, 0.020231135189533234, 0.04641062021255493, -0.22774538397789001, 0.00035974165075458586, -0.9050602912902832, 0.5142537355422974, -0.6671485304832458, 0.03810567408800125, -0.457818865776062, -0.37971100211143494, -0.20328213274478912, 0.2734464704990387, -0.7919569611549377, 0.6883293390274048, 0.36793339252471924, -0.804489016532898, 0.44113364815711975, -0.26124972105026245, -0.4211895763874054, 0.02391842007637024, -0.12143325805664062, 0.09766972064971924, 0.3117363750934601, -0.0766366645693779, 0.4608694016933441, -0.6510148048400879, 0.1357182413339615, -0.2300676852464676, -0.40894702076911926, 0.5429450273513794, -0.3826460838317871, 0.6984123587608337, 0.5596082210540771, -0.19132964313030243, -0.039255283772945404, -0.8586970567703247, 0.29689720273017883, -0.23438499867916107, -0.3198419213294983, -0.45795533061027527, -0.12430467456579208, 0.3552999496459961, 0.47357916831970215, 0.30747243762016296, -0.6377575993537903, -0.20469620823860168, -0.34102168679237366, 0.5672290325164795, 0.5176440477371216, -0.3335179388523102, 0.3668823838233948, -0.16782723367214203, 0.43438655138015747, 0.05791546404361725, 0.12750370800495148, 0.429269015789032, -0.3299974799156189, -0.8120681643486023, -0.05200127884745598, 0.7452077269554138, 0.38932889699935913, -0.54875648021698, 0.03800874203443527, -0.4135284423828125, -0.42111730575561523, -0.9841938614845276, 0.16676966845989227, 0.5717560052871704, 0.2104646861553192, 0.4174523949623108, -0.6254304051399231, -0.31473928689956665, -1.1695810556411743, -0.28571560978889465, -0.07125161588191986, -0.004841018933802843, 0.09399678558111191, 0.048614501953125, 0.02588752657175064, 0.9775916934013367, -0.24270081520080566, -0.1397819221019745, 0.003187119495123625, 0.3371160924434662, 0.19305314123630524, 0.29797160625457764, 0.5280949473381042, -0.9532865881919861, -0.5993448495864868, 0.035851314663887024, -0.8595661520957947, -0.2429201602935791, 0.12261573225259781, -0.3373163342475891, 0.06985202431678772, 0.4662051200866699, -0.29128575325012207, 0.11311426758766174, 0.8249035477638245, -0.18050141632556915, 0.34784337878227234, -0.2702661454677582, 0.3888706564903259, -1.075263500213623, 0.19146962463855743, -0.34306028485298157, -0.32288283109664917, -0.38901862502098083, 0.22073043882846832, 0.16003574430942535, -0.0816478580236435, -0.6299657225608826, 0.2863159775733948, -0.28749361634254456, -0.5638136863708496, -0.4980841279029846, 0.09110284596681595, 0.10823026299476624, 0.28015559911727905, -0.058889489620923996, 1.0381882190704346, 0.22738726437091827, -0.6007807850837708, 0.23317106068134308, 0.03049425035715103, -0.4184333086013794, 0.7196560502052307, -0.5514864325523376, 0.04476582631468773, 0.2158903181552887, -0.3815687596797943, -0.709209680557251, -0.0489368662238121, -0.34162184596061707, -0.5880149006843567, 0.17112037539482117, -0.057244960218667984, -0.7265947461128235, 0.0002766926190815866, -0.0984528511762619, 0.2322998344898224, 0.19378778338432312, -0.4532690644264221, -0.10668374598026276, 0.4543452262878418, -0.16553010046482086, -0.633213460445404, -0.9328163862228394, 0.17789629101753235, -0.09742727130651474, -0.5359349846839905, 0.4996616840362549, -0.14237019419670105, -0.4722263813018799, 0.5085170865058899, 0.12370527535676956, -0.4086076617240906, 0.195496067404747, 0.33578944206237793, 0.018254173919558525, -0.3279551863670349, 0.022788487374782562, 0.14673732221126556, -0.11468815803527832, -0.0049068983644247055, -0.2686122953891754, 0.7537685036659241, -0.31227901577949524, -0.2855443060398102, -0.2594056725502014, 0.3690025806427002, 0.5767303109169006, -0.14853668212890625, 0.8865075707435608, 0.9275457262992859, -0.298480749130249, 0.30436691641807556, -0.5220351815223694, -0.024248292669653893, -0.42203593254089355, 0.19013731181621552, -0.4038432836532593, -0.9159906506538391, 0.4432745575904846, 0.29367145895957947, 0.003616424510255456, 0.8850716352462769, 0.6114938259124756, -0.16064012050628662, 0.8863420486450195, 0.585875928401947, -0.12245438992977142, 0.20852436125278473, -0.31774887442588806, 0.07953676581382751, -0.7112481594085693, 0.04783879965543747, -0.5142323970794678, -0.35816332697868347, -1.1046218872070312, -0.22538961470127106, 0.11855535954236984, 0.3508976697921753, -0.26471224427223206, 0.6700798273086548, -0.570361316204071, 0.41996487975120544, 0.9205892086029053, 0.0029820126947015524, 0.38233262300491333, 0.21117737889289856, -0.1834474802017212, -0.06487467139959335, -0.4436984956264496, -0.7246832847595215, 1.1371351480484009, 0.05540410056710243, 0.27090540528297424, 0.38184747099876404, 0.7320393919944763, 0.4180026948451996, 0.08602876961231232, -0.5549370050430298, 0.21073183417320251, -0.46270638704299927, -0.55736243724823, -0.22602179646492004, -0.5949586629867554, -1.1696193218231201, 0.2515037953853607, -0.0019580454099923372, -0.13999231159687042, 0.3161916434764862, -0.11630086600780487, -0.4283049404621124, 0.36532413959503174, -0.779715895652771, 0.6811849474906921, -0.3761832118034363, -0.5296976566314697, -0.7138026356697083, -0.32667842507362366, 0.14901317656040192, -0.042458608746528625, 0.1707424521446228, -0.30158042907714844, -0.02915414609014988, 0.8080870509147644, -0.47674402594566345, 0.44422098994255066, 0.271110475063324, 0.3357451558113098, 0.3525080382823944, 0.26357755064964294, -0.1479470133781433, 0.11237979680299759, -0.25251665711402893, 0.5896478891372681, 0.2736279368400574, -0.7128905653953552, -0.2619727551937103, 0.9858406782150269, -1.0772510766983032, -0.4706181287765503, -0.43678194284439087, -0.39713239669799805, 0.04092174768447876, 0.30312299728393555, 0.4526749551296234, 0.31230002641677856, -0.15269631147384644, 0.2834700047969818, 0.35784295201301575, -0.36870965361595154, 0.4963052570819855, 0.3344380259513855, 0.1658674031496048, -0.5206264853477478, 1.1551785469055176, 0.29295551776885986, 0.39642807841300964, 0.4201747179031372, 0.1885388195514679, -0.1936434805393219, -0.4351506233215332, -0.7885430455207825, 0.022952452301979065, -0.6152198910713196, -0.41726112365722656, -0.6755117774009705, -0.16608208417892456, -0.4044497311115265, 0.03189582750201225, -0.5980408787727356, -0.5291295647621155, -0.38640323281288147, 0.043546825647354126, 0.39968782663345337, 0.9556030035018921, -0.34293997287750244, -0.057108551263809204, -0.9782482981681824, 0.21018604934215546, 0.3351389765739441, 0.41541609168052673, -0.10796571522951126, -0.3983522653579712, -0.456007182598114, -0.028662413358688354, -0.07220665365457535, -0.6561815142631531, 0.6052350401878357, -0.19056448340415955, 0.5547567009925842, 0.20830069482326508, -0.24167662858963013, 0.5629585385322571, -0.25590649247169495, 0.8628512024879456, 0.16700322926044464, -0.7563580870628357, 0.15994200110435486, -0.26733338832855225, 0.13227102160453796, 0.9673249125480652, 0.49552106857299805, -0.6585382223129272, -0.12731729447841644, -0.503074586391449, -0.8122119307518005, 0.6199625134468079, 0.5094401240348816, 0.1150900274515152, -0.20182180404663086, 0.08047652244567871, 0.25274553894996643, 0.3611665666103363, -0.45515573024749756, -0.36224088072776794, -0.25264355540275574, -0.2404775619506836, 0.06454354524612427, -0.3314019739627838, 0.06505382061004639, 0.004892017226666212, 0.3310837149620056, 0.15785928070545197, 0.32795608043670654, 0.022516604512929916, -0.4938514530658722, -0.028645552694797516, 0.39315664768218994, 0.49387770891189575, 0.8601059317588806, -0.3571581244468689, 0.2620764672756195, 0.04007653519511223, -0.647670328617096, 0.04024280235171318, -0.04065091907978058, 0.04509519785642624, 0.07450451701879501, 0.19446830451488495, 0.7173476219177246, -0.05588134750723839, -0.5137574076652527, 0.3648686408996582, -0.13700033724308014, 0.18434695899486542, -0.10852386802434921, -0.14837735891342163, 0.16165867447853088, 0.0278819240629673, 0.19295082986354828, 0.25956544280052185, 0.33644503355026245, -0.661564826965332, -0.05335165932774544, 0.0447457917034626, -0.3385457694530487, -0.32936668395996094, 0.34845513105392456, 0.16987378895282745, -0.25201302766799927, 0.9678956866264343, -0.5078580975532532, -0.6069899201393127, 0.6256086826324463, 0.3342588543891907, 0.5403441190719604, -0.042644985020160675, 0.1914726048707962, 0.5163983106613159, 0.4425555169582367, -0.3061429262161255, 0.182585209608078, 0.0699477270245552, -0.5409053564071655, -0.5753591060638428, -0.9132728576660156, -0.6923910975456238, 0.10431051254272461, -0.8319912552833557, 0.008870215155184269, -0.11402052640914917, -0.20961806178092957, -0.12484510987997055, 0.1507865935564041, -1.1372089385986328, 0.30669069290161133, 0.12556828558444977, 0.43752536177635193, -0.8205882906913757, 0.6623031497001648, 0.48753494024276733, -0.7320016622543335, -0.5802565217018127, -0.2564242482185364, -0.23013830184936523, -0.46151652932167053, 1.0113950967788696, 0.05146312713623047, -0.00544512365013361, -0.13386744260787964, -0.11146701127290726, -1.546262264251709, 1.0291774272918701, 0.5180187821388245, -0.4801298677921295, 0.39964842796325684, 0.5603687167167664, 0.8013427257537842, -0.0786682516336441, 0.5393317937850952, 0.396727591753006, 0.25811904668807983, -0.6265968084335327, -1.2285947799682617, -0.256716251373291, -0.2574414014816284, 0.10936123877763748, 0.04137744382023811, -0.7316206693649292, 1.039063572883606, 0.2746117115020752, -0.39045244455337524, -0.2741057872772217, 0.6655330061912537, -0.026807866990566254, 0.016247302293777466, 0.4631226062774658, 0.5301501750946045, 0.7285187840461731, -0.0010447893291711807, 1.2524805068969727, -0.5153527855873108, 0.2043359875679016, 1.0186741352081299, -0.03417149931192398, 1.0664271116256714, 0.3032262325286865, -0.28888508677482605, 0.4448583424091339, 0.8712292313575745, 0.16396622359752655, 0.3798849284648895, 0.3338562250137329, 0.12482909858226776, -0.28015071153640747, -0.3477572202682495, -0.310442179441452, 0.49521753191947937, 0.30048203468322754, -0.5485907196998596, -0.04939961060881615, -0.03470609709620476, -0.07057551294565201, 0.3875308632850647, -0.2168387472629547, 0.4514617323875427, 0.21114103496074677, -0.8285931348800659, 0.5912679433822632, 0.37640878558158875, 0.8252213597297668, 0.018370289355516434, 0.09181242436170578, -0.46817633509635925, -0.024480225518345833, -0.3198254108428955, -0.936823844909668, 0.5723169445991516, 0.16607846319675446, -0.4642471671104431, -0.40177860856056213, 0.5501973628997803, -0.4054814875125885, -0.4419691264629364, 0.3902638852596283, 0.6538783311843872, 0.5645649433135986, -0.34714969992637634, -0.6461153626441956, 0.11080247908830643, -0.28843432664871216, -0.10927294939756393, 0.6347461342811584, 0.11381881684064865, -0.12312212586402893, 0.29724377393722534, 0.9573827385902405, 0.20523346960544586, 0.18301866948604584, 0.32714271545410156, 0.5981189608573914, -0.6550381183624268, -0.2041342556476593, -0.6459992527961731, -0.07388114184141159, -0.3946874439716339, -0.3956325650215149, 0.5973747372627258, 0.9408642649650574, 1.2241785526275635, 0.014170080423355103, 0.6014727354049683, 0.05039169266819954, 0.6553943157196045, -0.3906738758087158, 0.822052538394928, -0.44978174567222595, -0.02849949523806572, 0.04101153463125229, -1.0507159233093262, -0.2176942229270935, 0.5574935078620911, -0.07038096338510513, -0.3229317367076874, 0.9435304999351501, 0.7608572244644165, -0.19642958045005798, -0.31742918491363525, 0.691550612449646, -0.020703427493572235, -0.039053190499544144, 0.3553173243999481, 0.722970724105835, -0.5909899473190308, 0.8053352236747742, -0.36082568764686584, 0.12608133256435394, 0.0029425506945699453, -0.6965388655662537, -0.6197112202644348, -0.7192887663841248, -0.2788453996181488, -0.45565712451934814, -0.031714051961898804, 1.1273565292358398, 0.5719186067581177, -0.9179661273956299, -0.42027267813682556, -0.0625189021229744, 0.06301668286323547, -0.4761040210723877, -0.19294473528862, 0.5862271189689636, -0.5826635956764221, -0.9967610836029053, 0.4193066954612732, 0.33270779252052307, -0.23965145647525787, -0.522632896900177, 0.08437806367874146, -0.022449202835559845, -0.1938929557800293, 0.6916038990020752, -0.06451234966516495, -0.708256185054779, 0.004757212940603495, 0.19222895801067352, -0.737871527671814, 0.2889426350593567, 0.8968024849891663, -0.6329367756843567, 0.3800830543041229, 0.9016273617744446, 0.6215046048164368, 0.40927913784980774, -0.1503339260816574, 0.4583067297935486, -0.560043454170227, 0.01360819861292839, 0.09480561316013336, 0.40156736969947815, 0.739636242389679, -0.3587554395198822, 0.6863809823989868, 0.09383118897676468, -0.4715081751346588, -0.6317758560180664, -0.05426401644945145, -0.9596112966537476, -0.25464069843292236, 1.4167906045913696, -0.2173774093389511, -0.34315159916877747, -0.29683417081832886, 0.09892047941684723, 0.4710904061794281, -0.15385456383228302, 0.6808441877365112, 0.7737763524055481, 0.14108994603157043, 0.19730569422245026, -0.7605959177017212, 0.5269899368286133, 0.5444449782371521, -0.647816002368927, -0.28394976258277893, 0.18525627255439758, 0.43146246671676636, 0.42471542954444885, 0.3666873872280121, -0.26987290382385254, 0.13315212726593018, 0.004837955813854933, 0.19932900369167328, -0.025003714486956596, -0.13630619645118713, -0.2289322018623352, 0.2410028576850891, 0.26853662729263306, -0.19934885203838348 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07432v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07432v1	Intrinsic Task-based Evaluation for Referring Expression Generation	2024-02-12T06:21:35	2024-02-12T06:21:35	Guanyi Chen, Fahime Same, Kees van Deemter	cs.CL	cs.CL	Recently, a human evaluation study of Referring Expression Generation (REG) models had an unexpected conclusion: on \textsc{webnlg}, Referring Expressions (REs) generated by the state-of-the-art neural models were not only indistinguishable from the REs in \textsc{webnlg} but also from the REs generated by a simple rule-based system. Here, we argue that this limitation could stem from the use of a purely ratings-based human evaluation (which is a common practice in Natural Language Generation). To investigate these issues, we propose an intrinsic task-based evaluation for REG models, in which, in addition to rating the quality of REs, participants were asked to accomplish two meta-level tasks. One of these tasks concerns the referential success of each RE; the other task asks participants to suggest a better alternative for each RE. The outcomes suggest that, in comparison to previous evaluations, the new evaluation protocol assesses the performance of each REG model more comprehensively and makes the participants' ratings more reliable and discriminable.	[ 0.026019010692834854, -0.4166041910648346, 0.532788097858429, 0.2576293647289276, -0.4345882534980774, -0.23349015414714813, -0.2281198501586914, -0.689810574054718, -0.018034402281045914, 0.19574306905269623, -0.6464338898658752, -0.20149125158786774, -0.5117250084877014, 0.6483233571052551, -0.46387943625450134, 1.0682449340820312, 0.2420923113822937, 0.19603510200977325, -0.6249005794525146, 0.007197462022304535, -0.6560118198394775, -0.356548011302948, -0.5312414169311523, -0.6115025877952576, 0.46046268939971924, 0.18472211062908173, 0.35108083486557007, 0.34548065066337585, 0.9973515272140503, 0.24929089844226837, 0.19062742590904236, 0.3240598142147064, -0.3648785650730133, 0.2165057361125946, -0.3373759388923645, -0.35105952620506287, -0.5569473505020142, 0.18334966897964478, 0.45930904150009155, 0.6160997748374939, -0.12386429309844971, 0.603039026260376, 0.1106632724404335, 0.7576019167900085, -0.6251252889633179, 0.02655334398150444, -0.7145221829414368, -0.029468687251210213, 0.09169983863830566, -0.3298182487487793, -0.6545935869216919, -0.4354047179222107, 0.19112396240234375, -0.24068528413772583, 0.45927518606185913, 0.004458884242922068, 0.9029404520988464, 0.1648407131433487, -0.27245375514030457, -0.2842022478580475, -0.7672064900398254, 0.5525159239768982, -0.8564228415489197, 0.21796433627605438, 0.2460811585187912, 0.13458190858364105, 0.16822390258312225, -0.8708287477493286, -0.6031825542449951, -0.8200932741165161, -0.11091399937868118, 0.08318911492824554, -0.5526441335678101, -0.10712993144989014, 0.3665600121021271, 0.11991317570209503, -0.45974376797676086, -0.28419485688209534, -0.17462600767612457, -0.0004168242448940873, 0.48441898822784424, 0.30958300828933716, 0.05908019468188286, -0.4872708022594452, -0.29677143692970276, 0.2171688675880432, -0.9135265350341797, -0.03549383580684662, 0.2829225957393646, 0.4952741265296936, 0.33148589730262756, 0.5133000612258911, -0.45853516459465027, 0.9307689666748047, 0.5528357028961182, 0.13391688466072083, 0.16707059741020203, -0.42685166001319885, 0.008790289983153343, -0.30684012174606323, 0.8588340878486633, 0.5871628522872925, 0.5048264861106873, -0.45027580857276917, -0.39221519231796265, 0.2503277361392975, 0.6879771947860718, -0.6404079794883728, 0.013094850815832615, -0.24777373671531677, -0.6912415623664856, -0.21501684188842773, 0.3841455578804016, -0.3054557740688324, -0.08311427384614944, -0.3519527316093445, 0.4281950891017914, -0.24712617695331573, -0.21150776743888855, -0.07224059849977493, -0.1905795931816101, -0.17446117103099823, 0.2558918595314026, -0.4572543799877167, 0.49071168899536133, 0.6135958433151245, 0.6184790730476379, -0.34279388189315796, -0.1660083681344986, -0.7013874650001526, -0.06815536320209503, -0.14842525124549866, 0.995672881603241, -0.8506169319152832, -0.4662259519100189, -0.1320071667432785, -0.23799915611743927, -0.06625582277774811, -0.8576993942260742, 0.7058781385421753, -0.4657907783985138, 0.206390380859375, -0.28189992904663086, -0.38212811946868896, -0.059284795075654984, 0.07221291959285736, -0.4790669083595276, 1.031640887260437, 0.22333547472953796, -0.5967099666595459, 0.4593110680580139, -0.8888069987297058, -0.504266619682312, 0.09576030820608139, 0.1672774851322174, -0.14253993332386017, 0.5362995266914368, -0.23668159544467926, 0.38231030106544495, -0.6843182444572449, 0.34974971413612366, -0.08093667775392532, -0.24397389590740204, 0.47230541706085205, -0.26435351371765137, 0.35929736495018005, 0.1011686623096466, -0.5669080018997192, 0.29596590995788574, -0.650955319404602, 0.1336313635110855, -0.16136687994003296, -0.23692764341831207, -0.2877250611782074, 0.18372373282909393, -0.2857625186443329, 0.4917455315589905, 0.1463184952735901, -0.6751766204833984, -0.06333678960800171, -0.017605556175112724, 0.27275171875953674, 0.729600191116333, 0.12494851648807526, 0.22036048769950867, -0.6576783657073975, 0.5037252306938171, -0.15234234929084778, -0.06310073286294937, 0.15352758765220642, -0.7668556571006775, -0.8405206203460693, 0.260951966047287, 0.32085737586021423, 0.26719409227371216, -0.6484045386314392, 0.5918809771537781, -0.6183074712753296, -0.6409246921539307, -0.40514761209487915, -0.10209614783525467, 0.6825383901596069, 0.9807137846946716, 0.3704977333545685, -0.5270131826400757, -0.35696864128112793, -1.096718668937683, -0.4122661352157593, -0.4861237704753876, -0.20074109733104706, 0.3773859143257141, 0.5277715921401978, -0.03166813403367996, 1.144364833831787, -0.3965374827384949, -0.05673185735940933, -0.257590651512146, 0.5898663997650146, 0.06779422610998154, 0.43597909808158875, 0.2823735773563385, -0.6183995604515076, -0.6579627394676208, -0.11776755750179291, -0.42657962441444397, -0.5506911873817444, -0.21240191161632538, 0.038059938699007034, -0.15769366919994354, 0.14791156351566315, -0.6284182667732239, 0.328541100025177, 0.17216654121875763, -0.3736637532711029, 1.0229820013046265, 0.0722053200006485, 0.2584240436553955, -0.6767151951789856, 0.5840144157409668, 0.39702633023262024, -0.530907928943634, -0.6249290704727173, 0.2823491096496582, 0.05139105021953583, -0.1359180361032486, -0.3522399663925171, 0.6328014731407166, -0.3596014678478241, -0.027878934517502785, -0.48781391978263855, 0.017645450308918953, -0.07534486800432205, 0.6477681994438171, 0.14168398082256317, 0.7648144960403442, 0.4384560286998749, -0.6790931224822998, 0.3486899435520172, 0.15437108278274536, -0.3416292369365692, 0.6034153699874878, -0.7709677219390869, 0.445141464471817, -0.012933598831295967, 0.3180548846721649, -0.8461032509803772, 0.04131665825843811, 0.3144631087779999, -0.6908389329910278, 0.12540824711322784, 0.20899495482444763, -0.3062846064567566, -0.36342859268188477, -0.2364276498556137, 0.28447675704956055, 0.6483447551727295, -0.17269869148731232, 0.4926068186759949, -0.0022294337395578623, -0.1816685050725937, -0.45395708084106445, -0.43289715051651, 0.3017421066761017, -0.09575311094522476, -0.6212508082389832, 0.47124412655830383, 0.027214230969548225, -0.1688111275434494, 0.35088875889778137, -0.2717703878879547, -0.09987881779670715, -0.014294193126261234, 0.20168587565422058, 0.1269443929195404, -0.22369800508022308, -0.09548066556453705, -0.2281736433506012, -0.08847246319055557, 0.312717080116272, -0.027734821662306786, 0.26755619049072266, -0.1539628952741623, -0.45537787675857544, -0.728382408618927, 0.4573723375797272, 0.3329574465751648, -0.3833509683609009, 0.13993079960346222, 0.3979279398918152, -0.2741445004940033, -0.11994436383247375, -0.5372872948646545, -0.3184761106967926, -0.4301720857620239, 0.37665268778800964, -0.23838253319263458, -0.7007896900177002, 0.23989352583885193, -0.0838543251156807, 0.11216038465499878, 0.6793619394302368, 0.5891962051391602, 0.011729447171092033, 0.9020352363586426, 0.4263288378715515, 0.5554678440093994, 0.4777824580669403, 0.12308096885681152, 0.1624145209789276, -1.1652907133102417, -0.21738120913505554, -0.7081777453422546, -0.4914216697216034, -0.2233491986989975, -0.51990807056427, 0.3446027934551239, -0.05324546620249748, 0.11266889423131943, 0.5906897187232971, -0.6629902124404907, -0.020323103293776512, 0.7633257508277893, 0.3222980499267578, 0.28213438391685486, -0.020114615559577942, -0.17914807796478271, 0.11416663974523544, -0.6535789370536804, -0.7593604326248169, 1.1032477617263794, 0.17781728506088257, 0.5775661468505859, 0.06195589154958725, 0.5743699669837952, 0.6635000109672546, 0.9739298224449158, -0.7091909646987915, 0.9018885493278503, -0.2907147705554962, -0.5702388286590576, -0.12803666293621063, -0.6973991990089417, -0.9540828466415405, 0.08560995757579803, -0.25692734122276306, -0.7310048341751099, 0.11834059655666351, 0.13009311258792877, -0.5318372249603271, -0.06333594769239426, -0.6018778085708618, 0.6388773918151855, -0.09115766733884811, -0.4319944977760315, -0.4576639235019684, -0.6017662882804871, 0.3353714644908905, -0.06709273904561996, -0.24924640357494354, -0.1184878870844841, 0.1396373063325882, 0.9573302268981934, -0.24747389554977417, 0.8343533873558044, -0.23153473436832428, 0.12041042745113373, 0.7273731231689453, 0.08608854562044144, 0.4982634484767914, -0.2081674188375473, -0.33807361125946045, 0.0038021362852305174, -0.3690051734447479, 0.003969938028603792, -0.814626157283783, 0.5061030387878418, -0.3168899118900299, -0.8330293297767639, -0.3594926595687866, -0.19144725799560547, -0.4269942343235016, 0.048975925892591476, 0.1288752406835556, 0.5611704587936401, -0.2580171227455139, 0.2640056908130646, 0.17312556505203247, -0.020593872293829918, 0.3479519486427307, 0.8189849257469177, 0.18820276856422424, -0.29004180431365967, 1.0342985391616821, -0.39282360672950745, 0.35488852858543396, 0.5864414572715759, 0.36710360646247864, -0.46015509963035583, -0.49372053146362305, -0.2966427206993103, 0.15837103128433228, -0.4338143765926361, -0.5307130813598633, -0.37600216269493103, 0.16845035552978516, -0.43617624044418335, 0.3870783746242523, 0.007896116934716702, -0.5158265233039856, -0.3320334255695343, 0.03705295920372009, -0.30173763632774353, 0.7961158752441406, -0.15854665637016296, 0.15887899696826935, -1.1795947551727295, 0.47898024320602417, 0.5710827112197876, 0.2383279800415039, 0.21590781211853027, -0.5816681981086731, -0.298736035823822, 0.25239479541778564, -0.668586254119873, -0.9317752718925476, 0.02516360953450203, 0.4522170424461365, 0.5992966294288635, 0.42437753081321716, -0.027928391471505165, 0.5444108843803406, -0.8771260976791382, 0.8549267053604126, 0.5144600868225098, -0.9750565886497498, 0.32069510221481323, -0.25069475173950195, 0.17600512504577637, 0.5303196310997009, 0.17727649211883545, -0.6443343758583069, -0.480678528547287, -0.7038077116012573, -0.48126420378685, 0.7166455388069153, 0.41714733839035034, 0.3520655035972595, -0.6086346507072449, 0.4732118844985962, 0.11959990113973618, 0.3357080817222595, -0.868464469909668, -0.15488018095493317, -0.07037145644426346, 0.03654070198535919, 0.48782071471214294, -0.27446362376213074, 0.04050265997648239, 0.00276302476413548, 0.549325704574585, -0.14374078810214996, 0.6950930953025818, 0.39603203535079956, -0.12630361318588257, -0.5562652349472046, 0.09966355562210083, 0.784466564655304, 0.8487682938575745, -0.15146547555923462, -0.06894501298666, -0.117156483232975, -0.2731904089450836, 0.13124382495880127, -0.17851553857326508, -0.009166174568235874, 0.27448731660842896, 0.7225612998008728, 0.8572474718093872, 0.09938878566026688, -0.7165341377258301, 0.5894463658332825, -0.0055675501935184, -0.06344962865114212, 0.2522667646408081, 0.20380938053131104, -0.09649354964494705, -0.19456559419631958, 0.6967414617538452, 0.5454246401786804, 0.26496440172195435, -0.5484901666641235, 0.5341457724571228, 0.5417223572731018, -0.5856304168701172, -0.6157878041267395, 0.5917761921882629, 0.806142270565033, -0.7117225527763367, 0.6781222224235535, -0.21952711045742035, -0.5054667592048645, 0.627489447593689, 0.580289900302887, 1.4092535972595215, -0.24547289311885834, 0.20094254612922668, 0.594783365726471, 0.24685733020305634, -0.0025777213741093874, 0.13328243792057037, -0.01981598138809204, -0.640723466873169, -0.6836456656455994, -0.6231525540351868, -0.2244631052017212, -0.1873164027929306, -0.8344536423683167, 0.007932989858090878, -0.1716960370540619, -0.5780792236328125, -0.12060655653476715, -0.4193015992641449, -0.6639180779457092, 0.3905974328517914, 0.010728467255830765, 0.9082750678062439, -0.7661542296409607, 0.5602594017982483, 1.0262863636016846, -0.29603177309036255, -0.4996829032897949, 0.3003465235233307, -0.4703378975391388, -0.6543261408805847, 1.155579924583435, 0.2069108784198761, -0.2530480921268463, -0.2569965720176697, -0.09077612310647964, -0.5258403420448303, 0.6734420657157898, 0.35175758600234985, -0.45348432660102844, -0.34633710980415344, -0.0099692577496171, 0.7691214680671692, -0.5002085566520691, 0.4167492687702179, 0.10181661695241928, 0.4882141649723053, -0.13876521587371826, -1.2557364702224731, 0.30492597818374634, -0.5024368762969971, -0.14319832623004913, 0.10705689340829849, -0.5283931493759155, 0.644364595413208, -0.19725431501865387, -0.5453705787658691, 0.1881529539823532, 0.8725242614746094, -0.059134844690561295, -0.03436771035194397, 0.7448640465736389, 0.44947919249534607, 0.3798592686653137, 0.00008677157165948302, 1.1839427947998047, -0.510019838809967, 0.37513813376426697, 1.2215135097503662, -0.3678436279296875, 0.8884668946266174, 0.3537309765815735, -0.2897029221057892, 0.7436708211898804, 0.3730830252170563, 0.045260317623615265, 0.5186471939086914, 0.3772900104522705, -0.3561570942401886, -0.5133262872695923, -0.40191808342933655, -0.1182282567024231, 0.40501630306243896, -0.006237109657377005, -0.3686676025390625, -0.6359620094299316, -0.4309343099594116, -0.6285302042961121, 0.19111408293247223, -0.12608309090137482, 0.7142478227615356, -0.032553207129240036, -0.9984049797058105, 0.4429875910282135, 0.25242215394973755, 0.5492528080940247, -0.7904532551765442, -0.47627389430999756, -0.04451395571231842, -0.32410821318626404, -0.15357114374637604, -0.6357758045196533, 0.43324896693229675, 0.33038628101348877, -0.19818559288978577, -0.45499807596206665, 0.75556480884552, -0.09054360538721085, -0.4739862084388733, -0.08091143518686295, 0.651226818561554, -0.03045959211885929, -0.1529972106218338, -0.8004909157752991, -0.4853542149066925, 0.15649034082889557, -0.28387561440467834, 0.19820985198020935, 0.35043424367904663, -0.018118280917406082, 0.8583703637123108, 0.7349889278411865, 0.11999113857746124, -0.0672876313328743, 0.02182524837553501, 0.7096163630485535, -0.5878605842590332, -0.3040306866168976, -0.7899149656295776, 0.5894768238067627, -0.0694584771990776, -0.6781553626060486, 0.5729750990867615, 0.4788409471511841, 0.43253666162490845, -0.2900540828704834, 0.7146666049957275, -0.3587460219860077, 0.7130425572395325, -0.2606801986694336, 0.3773476481437683, -0.44913551211357117, 0.09003854542970657, -0.5208067893981934, -1.1698936223983765, -0.13285815715789795, 0.6863704323768616, -0.13574063777923584, 0.2131807804107666, 1.044257402420044, 0.5970860719680786, 0.06355730444192886, -0.2586715519428253, 0.2700192630290985, -0.0725087895989418, 0.3162306547164917, 0.6256877779960632, 1.0093799829483032, -0.21870708465576172, 0.44267967343330383, -0.05839071795344353, -0.3078356981277466, -0.12633587419986725, -1.1876355409622192, -0.6555992960929871, -0.6114934682846069, -0.48563411831855774, -0.19736510515213013, 0.016720818355679512, 0.9851284623146057, 0.5830233097076416, -0.6580941081047058, -0.37347710132598877, -0.15623757243156433, -0.08063217252492905, -0.5182390213012695, -0.2572536766529083, 0.17637044191360474, -0.3394390344619751, -0.8389739394187927, 0.41908422112464905, 0.21813519299030304, -0.32688096165657043, -0.21412746608257294, 0.10869010537862778, -0.20672860741615295, 0.002085825428366661, 0.521793007850647, 0.03598274663090706, -0.7367141842842102, -0.5218086838722229, 0.12098521739244461, -0.2791270613670349, -0.03864317014813423, 1.102357029914856, -0.9339262843132019, 0.23435552418231964, 0.4917685389518738, 0.5774348974227905, -0.01739254780113697, 0.3903746008872986, 0.8067523241043091, -0.6161609888076782, -0.41170358657836914, 0.5879185795783997, 0.2611515522003174, 0.3517504632472992, -0.18839286267757416, 0.5797709226608276, 0.30414879322052, -0.37973159551620483, -0.8119196891784668, 0.33630096912384033, -0.9065612554550171, -0.05827123299241066, 1.2517929077148438, -0.32716792821884155, 0.027076393365859985, 0.1805930733680725, -0.11543930321931839, 0.14501067996025085, -0.5036979913711548, 1.0211975574493408, 0.6808931231498718, -0.5148797035217285, 0.27024322748184204, -0.10342412441968918, 0.40532371401786804, 0.6286354660987854, -0.682264506816864, 0.22995305061340332, 0.5978040099143982, 0.29475292563438416, 0.49389663338661194, 0.5727325677871704, 0.12151917070150375, 0.7260457873344421, -0.2449551820755005, 0.1170879676938057, -0.27753809094429016, -0.31163060665130615, -0.075568787753582, 0.1614111065864563, 0.18885649740695953, -0.04337885603308678 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07431v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07431v2	SALAD: Smart AI Language Assistant Daily	2024-02-12T06:15:24	2024-02-13T06:34:48	Ragib Amin Nihal, Tran Dong Huu Quoc, Lin Zirui, Xu Yimimg, Liu Haoran, An Zhaoyi, Kyou Ma	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CY	SALAD is an AI-driven language-learning application designed to help foreigners learn Japanese. It offers translations in Kanji-Kana-Romaji, speech recognition, translated audio, vocabulary tracking, grammar explanations, and songs generated from newly learned words. The app targets beginners and intermediate learners, aiming to make language acquisition more accessible and enjoyable. SALAD uses daily translations to enhance fluency and comfort in communication with native speakers. The primary objectives include effective Japanese language learning, user engagement, and progress tracking. A survey by us found that 39% of foreigners in Japan face discomfort in conversations with Japanese speakers. Over 60% of foreigners expressed confidence in SALAD's ability to enhance their Japanese language skills. The app uses large language models, speech recognition, and diffusion models to bridge the language gap and foster a more inclusive community in Japan.	[ -0.3198987543582916, -0.8859614729881287, 0.3436138927936554, 0.31190255284309387, -0.04183926433324814, 0.46136271953582764, -0.1987578123807907, -0.5540713667869568, 0.7751362919807434, 0.10296010226011276, -0.6745094060897827, -0.4883671998977661, -0.3207569718360901, 0.4606313705444336, -0.38819700479507446, 1.2644398212432861, 0.010248521342873573, 0.37880438566207886, 0.0221256110817194, 0.022839365527033806, -0.7731578350067139, 0.44383925199508667, -0.9558165669441223, -0.19476433098316193, 0.3498314321041107, 1.1173769235610962, 1.0856602191925049, 0.7282180190086365, 0.521780788898468, 0.5373387932777405, 0.17824752628803253, -0.07922659069299698, -0.24924451112747192, 0.30228322744369507, -0.39744406938552856, -1.084251880645752, -0.2926555871963501, 0.008317074738442898, 0.44266626238822937, 0.6425412893295288, -0.2758999168872833, -0.09813866764307022, -0.14095956087112427, 1.0760527849197388, -0.6096553206443787, 0.2108076959848404, -0.6552746295928955, 0.459196001291275, -0.422260046005249, 0.12271741777658463, 0.03906656429171562, -0.6163256168365479, -0.17972509562969208, -1.162083625793457, -0.06364468485116959, -0.4307901859283447, 0.9865834712982178, 0.2742559611797333, -0.32638123631477356, -0.24805063009262085, -0.7038688659667969, 0.8288983106613159, -0.3408888578414917, 0.42045825719833374, 0.7635387778282166, 0.7762765884399414, -0.4413541853427887, -0.4748121500015259, -0.9688589572906494, -0.027557825669646263, 0.1261776238679886, 0.3547472357749939, 0.2566988468170166, 0.10579931735992432, 0.04386720433831215, 0.8059481978416443, -0.7351211905479431, -0.07362750172615051, -0.0351344496011734, 0.14698481559753418, 0.7894102334976196, 0.35397663712501526, 1.0932875871658325, -0.17489945888519287, -0.2594853937625885, -0.26676660776138306, -0.2229887992143631, 0.034238267689943314, 0.13534435629844666, 0.04812987521290779, -0.5337986350059509, 0.2641553282737732, -0.4994108974933624, 0.6611123085021973, -0.043885618448257446, -0.5608741044998169, 0.525360643863678, -0.45452627539634705, -0.08401535451412201, 0.052167586982250214, 1.1808924674987793, 0.48948708176612854, 0.5484840869903564, -0.2701171934604645, -0.07506752759218216, 0.35074734687805176, 0.0836944505572319, -0.41335809230804443, -0.48632320761680603, 0.3825779855251312, -0.20614804327487946, -0.4279690384864807, -0.2309572696685791, -0.8753092288970947, -0.5817946791648865, 0.02638350985944271, 0.27072104811668396, -0.4661855697631836, -0.26856860518455505, -0.2382994443178177, -0.773623526096344, 0.2519848346710205, 0.3635268211364746, -1.1122459173202515, 0.4889747202396393, 0.5800280570983887, 0.9569373726844788, -0.21369123458862305, -0.4491346478462219, -0.361010879278183, 0.1932775229215622, -0.6997286677360535, 0.5732779502868652, -0.4415743052959442, -0.7087256908416748, -0.22732409834861755, 0.24309900403022766, -0.3134004771709442, -0.6453390121459961, 0.40562567114830017, -0.24638625979423523, 0.19017411768436432, -0.20445479452610016, -0.1747315675020218, -0.24113602936267853, 0.25960588455200195, -0.7529391646385193, 0.4454534351825714, 0.22729147970676422, -0.667070209980011, 0.3841303586959839, -0.9723488092422485, -0.909207820892334, 0.6550692915916443, -0.42996281385421753, -0.2489602416753769, -0.20294323563575745, 0.30065488815307617, 0.27438056468963623, 0.0843348503112793, 0.30501803755760193, 0.04285049065947533, -0.2679864466190338, 0.3670744299888611, -0.4813331961631775, 0.9936342239379883, 0.6457985043525696, -0.33223965764045715, 0.3648317754268646, -0.6762444376945496, -0.35144662857055664, 0.4819367527961731, -0.5717445611953735, -0.5114374756813049, 0.12653139233589172, 0.21801798045635223, -0.14567454159259796, 0.3214474022388458, -0.5483568906784058, 0.4242517948150635, -0.7052463889122009, 0.42306220531463623, 0.6787881255149841, -0.17720350623130798, 0.7718822360038757, -0.4174235761165619, 0.8694181442260742, 0.009586907923221588, 0.28641802072525024, -0.38764238357543945, -0.82523512840271, -0.7270060181617737, -0.4762355089187622, 0.4054183065891266, 1.163654088973999, -1.2913682460784912, 0.1939932107925415, -0.5119654536247253, -0.396335631608963, -0.9364861845970154, 0.4167534410953522, 0.3877711892127991, 0.3731546700000763, 0.22247245907783508, -0.6388463973999023, -0.464523047208786, -0.7198720574378967, -0.5562914609909058, 0.13527023792266846, 0.10976845026016235, 0.1874505579471588, 0.2480526715517044, -0.7622776627540588, 0.8062682151794434, -0.23036468029022217, -0.5003014206886292, -0.6281101107597351, -0.12674841284751892, 0.47179627418518066, 0.5160837769508362, 0.37863796949386597, -1.0548368692398071, -1.2617045640945435, 0.40071702003479004, -0.6940909624099731, 0.2953650951385498, -0.24434588849544525, -0.11464647948741913, 0.21197445690631866, 0.05602194368839264, -0.7989602088928223, 0.24350999295711517, 0.777590811252594, -0.4598245918750763, 0.20183341205120087, 0.06509145349264145, 0.3755829334259033, -1.572320580482483, -0.05429567024111748, -0.0013582623796537519, -0.6741856336593628, -0.6708447933197021, 0.4590226411819458, -0.03053559549152851, -0.2920394837856293, -0.3283191919326782, 0.5378644466400146, -0.1973169445991516, 0.08427206426858902, -0.26402485370635986, -0.07463251054286957, -0.15510478615760803, 0.1959383636713028, -0.21125531196594238, 1.161291480064392, 0.5003095269203186, -0.729763388633728, 0.4088335335254669, 0.26743850111961365, -0.44715696573257446, 0.5177118182182312, -0.36823680996894836, -0.1258111149072647, 0.004979679360985756, -0.023941392078995705, -1.3271965980529785, -0.761036217212677, 0.6792278289794922, -0.6237135529518127, 0.3485645055770874, 0.4518361985683441, 0.014419741928577423, -0.3284469544887543, -0.5111666917800903, 0.14005997776985168, 0.39117497205734253, -0.47852566838264465, 0.7536243796348572, 0.7015134692192078, -0.23616519570350647, -0.4057275056838989, -0.7062894105911255, 0.31853437423706055, -0.07852035760879517, -0.3358847200870514, 0.32271334528923035, -0.1696084439754486, -0.4708561301231384, -0.0682305172085762, 0.004422331694513559, -0.4188106060028076, 0.5650644898414612, 0.29529231786727905, 0.013692168518900871, 0.10767475515604019, -0.21362745761871338, 0.14568568766117096, 0.005208361428231001, -0.15713635087013245, 0.4323205351829529, 0.7227855324745178, -0.04323302581906319, 0.44276851415634155, -1.1734907627105713, 0.26803335547447205, 0.7068958878517151, -0.0115069430321455, 0.6866518259048462, 0.6611197590827942, -0.17302563786506653, 0.046995341777801514, -0.20820626616477966, -0.015209442004561424, -0.6204662919044495, 0.5900232195854187, -0.768468976020813, -0.035353947430849075, 0.542504072189331, 0.17102305591106415, 0.25360462069511414, 0.4157983064651489, 0.18594563007354736, -0.4936845004558563, 1.3532731533050537, 0.4261409640312195, -0.8110648989677429, 0.77080237865448, -0.21126778423786163, -0.1471705287694931, -0.5455953478813171, -0.28761062026023865, -0.5585849285125732, -0.36828118562698364, -0.8393941521644592, -0.20323798060417175, 0.3255862295627594, -0.23059667646884918, -0.10980237275362015, 0.28811800479888916, -0.3211331367492676, 0.5583131313323975, 0.8560847043991089, 0.059943992644548416, 0.3025134205818176, -0.07085710763931274, 0.08250045776367188, -0.013763654977083206, -0.7250511646270752, 0.08635672181844711, 0.8139476180076599, 0.5712183117866516, 0.8085794448852539, 0.15186631679534912, 0.9116771221160889, 0.32216352224349976, 0.1260738968849182, -1.3988580703735352, 0.6263213753700256, -0.2029619812965393, -0.47102290391921997, -0.47612422704696655, -0.71241295337677, -1.13957941532135, -0.047238003462553024, -0.1260811686515808, -0.42233678698539734, -0.13701289892196655, 0.24049656093120575, 0.011631693691015244, -0.17818115651607513, -0.9219584465026855, 0.9046337604522705, -0.3978939652442932, -0.2275567203760147, -0.2841091454029083, -0.6013638973236084, 0.2643979489803314, 0.27928709983825684, 0.8625360727310181, 0.0885380432009697, 0.20218533277511597, 0.8975926041603088, -0.4365234076976776, 0.5701401829719543, -0.2328098714351654, -0.08837222307920456, -0.08077305555343628, 0.3729822337627411, 0.588080644607544, 0.060774534940719604, 0.302211731672287, 0.3616522252559662, -0.1572255641222, -0.16496361792087555, -0.3885361850261688, 0.8663908243179321, -0.9231595993041992, -0.6364412903785706, -0.6498174071311951, -0.7363805174827576, -0.022885290905833244, 0.5423496961593628, 0.1315637081861496, -0.5197669267654419, -0.01809568516910076, -0.06471839547157288, 0.5204059481620789, -0.24203462898731232, 0.42325660586357117, 0.5193114280700684, -0.2888978123664856, -0.5999020338058472, 1.3520151376724243, 0.05752667039632797, 0.03535417467355728, 0.4219534993171692, 0.5273429155349731, 0.20666271448135376, 0.027865402400493622, -0.9659773111343384, 0.0520741268992424, -0.4183599650859833, -0.006542624905705452, -0.5091871023178101, 0.13607168197631836, -0.4073842763900757, -0.12084455788135529, -0.5341048240661621, -0.3489401042461395, -0.02646542899310589, 0.0022198164369910955, 0.275185763835907, 0.7063146829605103, 0.0303911492228508, 0.44910866022109985, -0.7617924809455872, 0.7841414213180542, 0.27850306034088135, 0.2718483507633209, -0.49528494477272034, 0.12131417542695999, -0.38697901368141174, 0.30445966124534607, -0.4895198345184326, -1.31425142288208, 0.36217930912971497, 0.4582695960998535, 0.4142144024372101, 0.7613820433616638, -0.5154117345809937, 0.7148723006248474, -0.6541140079498291, 0.9949346780776978, 0.4082441031932831, -1.0065804719924927, 0.6251477003097534, -0.5129445195198059, 0.7959970831871033, 0.6795041561126709, 0.7530428171157837, -0.8388405442237854, -0.4794590473175049, -0.16671423614025116, -0.8749038577079773, 0.6109856963157654, -0.2865269184112549, 0.21250192821025848, -0.21543869376182556, 0.07156837731599808, 0.015890473499894142, 0.12696053087711334, -0.7179096341133118, -0.33294227719306946, -0.23370283842086792, -0.7132732272148132, -0.19068306684494019, 0.1638604700565338, 0.16018466651439667, -0.6476681232452393, 0.7327100038528442, -0.03957504779100418, 0.3370022773742676, -0.27545690536499023, 0.19935429096221924, -0.4225060045719147, 0.12010736763477325, 0.1307559758424759, 0.37584659457206726, 0.1903240978717804, -0.3585283160209656, 0.28729748725891113, -0.971187174320221, -0.06082889437675476, -0.11672879755496979, -0.33418574929237366, 0.31691431999206543, 0.09618456661701202, 0.5754730105400085, 0.11891830712556839, -0.8751835227012634, 0.5914568901062012, -0.28777268528938293, -0.09776868671178818, -0.5643380880355835, 0.7575515508651733, 0.13683472573757172, 0.009818497113883495, 0.08996916562318802, -0.10663247853517532, 0.6527488231658936, -1.0070441961288452, -0.09548653662204742, 0.7947109937667847, -0.36148974299430847, -0.09042859822511673, 0.6912179589271545, 0.38914382457733154, -0.590244472026825, 0.8020095229148865, -0.03352353349328041, -0.6591232419013977, 0.566369891166687, 0.6268236041069031, 0.8733856081962585, -0.9072489142417908, 0.4092203676700592, 0.27805882692337036, -0.006180485710501671, 0.06140759959816933, 0.6546272039413452, -0.4205201268196106, -0.7184473872184753, -0.21895477175712585, -0.5823220014572144, -0.3700964152812958, 0.19698689877986908, -0.5310327410697937, 0.25298377871513367, -0.2400277554988861, -0.1471451222896576, -0.015887239947915077, -0.03680770844221115, -0.671488881111145, 0.4347946345806122, -0.07137541472911835, 0.8860421776771545, -1.0233397483825684, 0.9235590100288391, 1.0780210494995117, -0.3131650984287262, -0.7073640823364258, 0.21908625960350037, -0.3044843077659607, -0.7526148557662964, 0.3777526021003723, 0.17929519712924957, -0.0708913505077362, -0.06574183702468872, -0.5920954346656799, -0.6981871128082275, 0.7039797306060791, 0.1284618228673935, -0.93424391746521, -0.06789731979370117, 0.3239400088787079, 0.17971554398536682, 0.2690391540527344, 0.19755621254444122, 0.5108901858329773, 0.3561873137950897, -0.19924812018871307, -1.1501637697219849, -0.2583253085613251, -0.5151959657669067, 0.21142452955245972, 0.2283332347869873, -0.45487725734710693, 0.9107888340950012, -0.08533661812543869, -0.42924946546554565, 0.13191978633403778, 0.48693975806236267, -0.10003092139959335, 0.46487030386924744, 0.4429360032081604, 0.6499010324478149, 0.7893549799919128, 0.0038659977726638317, 1.1457732915878296, -0.4144321084022522, -0.18922477960586548, 1.0264761447906494, 0.14748351275920868, 0.7231729030609131, 0.7405526638031006, -0.25359204411506653, 0.9246124625205994, 0.39102306962013245, 0.34328028559684753, 0.792926013469696, -0.04841757193207741, -0.2657831907272339, 0.1354617029428482, -0.21431437134742737, -0.2870287299156189, 0.531973123550415, 0.7195107936859131, -0.5108123421669006, 0.2405543327331543, 0.40583038330078125, 0.29597118496894836, 0.3779129087924957, -0.4747565686702728, 1.2880383729934692, 0.06060889735817909, -0.9768423438072205, 0.5696715116500854, 0.2614915370941162, 0.6211303472518921, -0.5062570571899414, -0.3700001537799835, -0.34987854957580566, 0.47195297479629517, -0.3761885166168213, -0.66253262758255, 0.18358302116394043, -0.08722864836454391, -0.06683729588985443, 0.10676657408475876, 0.488422155380249, -0.3957479000091553, -0.1827428787946701, -0.11677289754152298, 0.06801152229309082, 0.27014607191085815, 0.21456049382686615, -0.973805844783783, 0.13666784763336182, -0.008491233922541142, -0.13150513172149658, 0.1817145198583603, -0.05338778346776962, 0.03291818127036095, 0.7201329469680786, 0.3808293640613556, 0.20976310968399048, -0.17553366720676422, -0.12130890041589737, 0.5880012512207031, -0.5119988918304443, -0.8827325701713562, -0.8926078081130981, 0.4311830401420593, -0.08746598660945892, -0.18269303441047668, 1.0968800783157349, 0.5364735126495361, 1.1954264640808105, -0.32979345321655273, 0.9319201707839966, -0.1576390415430069, 0.5645830035209656, -0.41053155064582825, 0.8765332698822021, -0.7831614017486572, -0.12142711877822876, -0.3449896574020386, -0.6913437247276306, -0.07180239260196686, 1.2152748107910156, -0.16036762297153473, -0.06711485236883163, 0.4130067229270935, 0.5469569563865662, -0.05189396068453789, 0.08595698326826096, 0.09838282316923141, 0.14200696349143982, 0.1349131315946579, 0.6355125904083252, 0.6379876136779785, -0.5268685817718506, -0.10450077801942825, -0.38838115334510803, -0.35638153553009033, -0.20815442502498627, -0.21819309890270233, -0.8263189196586609, -0.45610740780830383, -0.22055433690547943, -0.293308287858963, 0.4579061269760132, 1.1631959676742554, 0.4051903188228607, -0.8951510787010193, -0.5782028436660767, -0.7694036364555359, 0.16817176342010498, -0.5109571218490601, -0.401360422372818, -0.042404647916555405, -0.555058479309082, -1.2592822313308716, 0.7994656562805176, -0.2561767101287842, -0.18542400002479553, -0.2896985709667206, -0.22007988393306732, -0.25572434067726135, -0.0637170821428299, 0.2590632140636444, 0.5684391856193542, -0.1368856132030487, 0.2459954470396042, -0.35431820154190063, -0.16066190600395203, 0.09496555477380753, 0.11129555851221085, -0.7950043678283691, 0.8564742207527161, 0.7879064679145813, 0.7598880529403687, 0.09747021645307541, -0.08808980137109756, 0.7784211039543152, -0.4920395314693451, 0.12800812721252441, 0.04744160547852516, 0.10270290076732635, 0.4083394706249237, -0.6246078014373779, 0.22357940673828125, 0.3434731662273407, -0.40358567237854004, -0.5924708247184753, 0.08838213980197906, -0.49016815423965454, -0.37041568756103516, 1.2254823446273804, 0.006400001235306263, -0.5965098738670349, -0.05823333188891411, -0.14252778887748718, 0.6363075375556946, -0.5101729035377502, 1.0017592906951904, 0.3195250630378723, 0.19116094708442688, 0.17076806724071503, -1.0447025299072266, 0.9208737015724182, 0.6136130094528198, -0.8723320364952087, -0.6604043245315552, 0.28472891449928284, 0.5395594239234924, 0.4125201106071472, 0.8600624799728394, 0.11144014447927475, 0.8020505905151367, -0.29548388719558716, 0.022425828501582146, 0.2518024444580078, -0.8967841267585754, -0.31458544731140137, -0.32053959369659424, 0.13283883035182953, -0.8634061813354492 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07405v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07405v1	Dólares or Dollars? Unraveling the Bilingual Prowess of Financial LLMs Between Spanish and English	2024-02-12T04:50:31	2024-02-12T04:50:31	Xiao Zhang, Ruoyu Xiang, Chenhan Yuan, Duanyu Feng, Weiguang Han, Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Xiao-Yang Liu, Sophia Ananiadou, Min Peng, Jimin Huang, Qianqian Xie	cs.CL	cs.CL	Despite Spanish's pivotal role in the global finance industry, a pronounced gap exists in Spanish financial natural language processing (NLP) and application studies compared to English, especially in the era of large language models (LLMs). To bridge this gap, we unveil Tois\'on de Oro, the first bilingual framework that establishes instruction datasets, finetuned LLMs, and evaluation benchmark for financial LLMs in Spanish joint with English. We construct a rigorously curated bilingual instruction dataset including over 144K Spanish and English samples from 15 datasets covering 7 tasks. Harnessing this, we introduce FinMA-ES, an LLM designed for bilingual financial applications. We evaluate our model and existing LLMs using FLARE-ES, the first comprehensive bilingual evaluation benchmark with 21 datasets covering 9 tasks. The FLARE-ES benchmark results reveal a significant multilingual performance gap and bias in existing LLMs. FinMA-ES models surpass SOTA LLMs such as GPT-4 in Spanish financial tasks, due to strategic instruction tuning and leveraging data from diverse linguistic resources, highlighting the positive impact of cross-linguistic transfer. All our datasets, models, and benchmarks have been released.	[ -0.03566230461001396, -0.6477150321006775, 0.32854196429252625, 0.8041439056396484, 0.18133148550987244, 0.6474635601043701, -0.2976897656917572, -0.6663527488708496, 0.3116789758205414, 0.6003437042236328, -0.7055568695068359, -0.46250367164611816, -0.6944523453712463, 0.0361442044377327, -0.2619711756706238, 0.9874594807624817, -0.021512730047106743, 0.3968101441860199, -0.30491071939468384, 0.24883778393268585, -0.021426044404506683, -0.10956238955259323, -1.096557378768921, -0.38496482372283936, 0.43093791604042053, 0.5198855996131897, 0.4968414902687073, 0.6363627910614014, 0.5831784605979919, 0.3620419204235077, 0.27712351083755493, 0.1365177482366562, -0.39455923438072205, -0.3412858843803406, -0.4163861870765686, -0.6621274352073669, -0.6725730895996094, -0.16251449286937714, 0.44233807921409607, 0.8632486462593079, -0.1128987967967987, 0.2146027684211731, -0.2373904585838318, 1.0715317726135254, -0.5216373205184937, 0.6099765300750732, -0.4329929053783417, -0.0770309790968895, -0.5476077795028687, -0.24860741198062897, -0.25527316331863403, -0.16379842162132263, 0.28822168707847595, -0.3332065939903259, -0.07859813421964645, 0.1208937019109726, 0.6227746605873108, 0.1889069527387619, -0.6776343584060669, -0.4156641662120819, -0.4704435467720032, 0.8900229334831238, -0.4791792631149292, 0.7755037546157837, 0.2665640413761139, 0.3356609642505646, 0.03493668511509895, -0.788202702999115, -0.08467040956020355, -0.03579665347933769, 0.38564279675483704, 0.04203499108552933, -0.6223230957984924, -0.09647253900766373, -0.11923792958259583, 0.6205069422721863, -0.2984921336174011, 0.4972812831401825, -0.36522525548934937, -0.18233872950077057, 0.7085345387458801, 0.09768624603748322, 0.15169724822044373, 0.18553151190280914, -0.790130078792572, -0.31524646282196045, -0.9713500738143921, 0.2903449833393097, 0.6579944491386414, 0.5494510531425476, -0.2417430579662323, 0.5193237066268921, -0.05486123636364937, 0.4724728763103485, -0.0059595126658678055, -0.3801618218421936, 0.1609683334827423, -0.17986851930618286, -0.43951064348220825, 0.0925339087843895, 0.7118132710456848, 0.4148558974266052, 0.3791925311088562, -0.6214109659194946, -0.4509567320346832, -0.3723178803920746, -0.07565976679325104, -0.5370020866394043, 0.2058812975883484, 0.009669643826782703, -0.10664521902799606, -0.08171863853931427, 0.1362057328224182, -0.9931599497795105, -0.176327183842659, -0.23486311733722687, 0.3265555799007416, 0.09422625601291656, -0.01983364298939705, 0.768113374710083, 0.06741895526647568, 0.19601505994796753, -0.2436646670103073, -1.1415194272994995, 1.0892804861068726, 0.9492227435112, 0.4850042462348938, -0.039749741554260254, -0.34948858618736267, -0.42401179671287537, 0.03900320455431938, -0.2520505487918854, 0.8007229566574097, -0.29704681038856506, -0.4740649163722992, 0.028368806466460228, 0.135924831032753, -0.4368495047092438, -0.4930557608604431, 0.20556125044822693, -0.4813491702079773, 0.12480153888463974, -0.4899446368217468, -0.4065382182598114, -0.2925027012825012, 0.06831693649291992, -0.5647467374801636, 0.9960026144981384, 0.15093353390693665, -0.5906709432601929, 0.22973746061325073, -0.5975466370582581, -0.4515801966190338, -0.23026640713214874, 0.05894419178366661, -0.20872004330158234, -0.16942977905273438, 0.3409167528152466, 0.27448928356170654, -0.9999556541442871, 0.42518261075019836, -0.12124630808830261, -0.1904257982969284, 0.3040531873703003, -0.5139906406402588, 0.7162652015686035, -0.21536295115947723, -0.5727581977844238, -0.1600656807422638, -0.5884397029876709, -0.42715978622436523, 0.3683789074420929, 0.02990192547440529, -0.3270930051803589, 0.1842249035835266, 0.026564935222268105, 0.06653507798910141, 0.666974663734436, -0.6438981890678406, -0.11477626860141754, -0.729086697101593, 0.3098308742046356, 0.6977107524871826, -0.23158517479896545, 0.5493530631065369, -0.49862295389175415, 0.6889400482177734, -0.2470761388540268, 0.02700018882751465, -0.2601437568664551, -0.24258685111999512, -0.8666577339172363, -0.38514530658721924, 0.2963173985481262, 1.0000718832015991, -0.27211081981658936, -0.07335172593593597, -0.23496049642562866, -0.39054930210113525, -0.29434338212013245, 0.2865094840526581, 0.39714863896369934, 0.5361301302909851, 0.2591085135936737, 0.16839750111103058, -0.5722797513008118, -1.253268837928772, -0.37770482897758484, -0.07105091959238052, 0.09375088661909103, 0.17774130403995514, 0.37012118101119995, -0.1391879767179489, 0.6717740297317505, -0.3190370500087738, -0.2519308924674988, -0.2994387745857239, -0.2079165279865265, 0.24861018359661102, 0.10701344162225723, 1.0398855209350586, -0.35831281542778015, -0.3832007348537445, 0.291570246219635, -0.3760475814342499, -0.27964940667152405, -0.2368762493133545, 0.02670574001967907, 0.14351294934749603, 0.525295615196228, 0.07001998275518417, 0.023672787472605705, 0.698273241519928, -0.5720811486244202, 0.029084792360663414, -0.32721617817878723, 0.22942446172237396, -0.8160468339920044, -0.13809305429458618, 0.22963814437389374, -0.3311116397380829, -0.28955939412117004, -0.1640883833169937, 0.22405332326889038, 0.17366179823875427, -0.27812573313713074, 0.9450992345809937, -0.42810773849487305, -0.35014238953590393, -0.02632840909063816, 0.16906000673770905, 0.07069724798202515, 0.43010905385017395, -0.11492334306240082, 0.9055246710777283, 0.9725253582000732, -0.1766645461320877, 0.5370854735374451, -0.06287434697151184, -0.4465715289115906, 0.6197483539581299, -0.7018276453018188, -0.15795961022377014, 0.028964467346668243, -0.046506334096193314, -0.8841113448143005, 0.049079012125730515, 0.23754951357841492, 0.3123595416545868, 0.5701562166213989, 0.22997699677944183, -0.4662525951862335, -0.46222785115242004, -0.44253572821617126, 0.23583456873893738, 0.1648019254207611, -0.720064640045166, 0.26334771513938904, 0.5342053771018982, -0.7226075530052185, -0.8835322260856628, -0.843966543674469, 0.2746715545654297, -0.19244882464408875, -0.8488035798072815, 0.6790595650672913, 0.2989313006401062, -0.7370722889900208, -0.2761853337287903, -0.33606091141700745, 0.0008700572070665658, 0.21046599745750427, -0.009781626053154469, 0.5914937257766724, -0.48777610063552856, 0.06196350231766701, 0.4378022253513336, -0.18106892704963684, 0.33478230237960815, -0.3681643009185791, 0.293293297290802, -0.5662123560905457, -0.49072355031967163, -0.03852858021855354, 0.041158828884363174, 0.6122891306877136, -0.31840306520462036, 0.6169910430908203, -0.06431582570075989, -0.2135368138551712, -0.26216113567352295, -0.89667809009552, 0.28371480107307434, -0.4906105399131775, 0.2507498562335968, -0.2597060799598694, -0.7779265642166138, 0.8719554543495178, -0.13228937983512878, 0.32455629110336304, 0.6741294264793396, 0.5487178564071655, 0.09183084219694138, 0.4644842743873596, 0.7809502482414246, -0.24299892783164978, 0.419874906539917, -0.36286619305610657, 0.1915152370929718, -0.207689568400383, -0.785653293132782, -0.4680411219596863, -0.4795647859573364, -0.1987842619419098, -0.6228531002998352, 0.19125285744667053, -0.05745334178209305, 0.0009670793078839779, 0.25693368911743164, 0.32371243834495544, 0.8030909895896912, 0.21672861278057098, -0.214137002825737, 0.46535950899124146, -0.03692247346043587, -0.09078369289636612, -0.2410368174314499, -0.6815972328186035, -0.4553731679916382, 1.4020518064498901, 0.6322658658027649, 0.6788135170936584, -0.018293283879756927, 0.5189429521560669, 0.31210729479789734, 0.1307358741760254, -0.7198207974433899, 0.35109660029411316, -0.4542628824710846, -0.18928711116313934, -0.08817547559738159, -0.43668991327285767, -0.888451337814331, -0.007934454828500748, 0.11408870667219162, -0.5047440528869629, 0.09119910001754761, -0.4329013228416443, -0.3017618954181671, 0.529946506023407, -0.5810192823410034, 1.013007640838623, -0.6878191232681274, -0.5479897856712341, -0.14784446358680725, -0.28703197836875916, 0.5433862805366516, -0.32428163290023804, 0.608939528465271, -0.3081001937389374, -0.6526746153831482, 0.6449298858642578, -0.47224634885787964, 0.8553833961486816, 0.22318658232688904, -0.6502290368080139, 0.13694658875465393, -0.11422868818044662, 0.29697301983833313, 0.32303687930107117, -0.22993330657482147, 0.4152062237262726, 0.07681389898061752, -0.46248072385787964, -0.21835359930992126, 1.2082077264785767, -0.44922465085983276, -0.36042171716690063, -0.3033667504787445, -0.7170494794845581, -0.5119377374649048, -0.13887228071689606, -0.004804902244359255, 0.38048332929611206, -0.503322184085846, -0.2742338180541992, 0.4584386944770813, -0.05237308517098427, 0.6912747025489807, 0.7730573415756226, -0.4311542809009552, -0.390324205160141, 1.0783270597457886, 0.04641684889793396, 0.0051367334090173244, 0.47762659192085266, 0.1543804109096527, -0.7785492539405823, -0.1652846336364746, -0.5785053372383118, 0.5898905992507935, -0.4583326280117035, -0.20071764290332794, -0.3542484641075134, 0.0262885894626379, -0.4884624183177948, -0.45091789960861206, -0.711476743221283, -0.38329508900642395, -0.0059322817251086235, -0.3046196699142456, 0.49141886830329895, 0.6973027586936951, -0.39456987380981445, 0.07488296180963516, -0.7953010201454163, 0.2968868613243103, 0.5296793580055237, 0.5644324421882629, -0.035400666296482086, -0.28592610359191895, -0.2289406806230545, 0.11290241777896881, 0.12384229153394699, -0.8327256441116333, 0.34995153546333313, 0.2660202980041504, 0.6255830526351929, 0.6168708205223083, -0.3246006369590759, 0.5678151249885559, -0.270090252161026, 0.3021167516708374, 0.11503472179174423, -0.9710567593574524, 0.25499585270881653, -0.4998643398284912, 0.011101536452770233, 0.49283069372177124, 0.29626163840293884, -0.6149298548698425, -0.5157325863838196, -0.504530131816864, -0.8520477414131165, 0.8555506467819214, -0.163543701171875, 0.11297557502985, -0.3927461504936218, 0.013632489368319511, 0.5138209462165833, 0.3254472017288208, -0.6271604895591736, -0.33479517698287964, 0.22130538523197174, 0.05079948902130127, -0.1920730173587799, -0.21721190214157104, -0.045603785663843155, -0.2768588960170746, 0.5529966354370117, 0.05305478721857071, -0.2843160331249237, -0.2058665007352829, -0.1338021457195282, -0.21908995509147644, 0.028927233070135117, 0.45806431770324707, 0.7006460428237915, -0.07798458635807037, -0.012097880244255066, 0.14494776725769043, -0.26228001713752747, -0.12723451852798462, 0.1531112641096115, 0.04126627743244171, -0.007788475137203932, 0.24512042105197906, 0.8142637014389038, 1.1264846324920654, -1.1521964073181152, 0.5774256587028503, 0.10720615833997726, -0.3053952753543854, -0.2956777513027191, -0.2639787793159485, 0.265987366437912, 0.5703191161155701, 0.4333152174949646, 0.08348448574542999, 0.0820680782198906, -0.6253072619438171, 0.02272947132587433, 0.3797417879104614, -0.07691540569067001, -0.3875140845775604, 0.7089346647262573, 0.36848390102386475, -0.15476518869400024, 0.3112688362598419, 0.08521634340286255, -0.3807898163795471, 0.8147854208946228, 0.6164333820343018, 0.9576232433319092, -0.058879658579826355, 0.39560404419898987, 0.2089097797870636, 0.39866018295288086, -0.635252058506012, 0.5566149950027466, -0.0829714983701706, -0.3840309679508209, -0.5101861357688904, -0.7389922738075256, -0.4142816662788391, -0.1272345334291458, -0.7811972498893738, 0.29736456274986267, -0.5022068023681641, -0.029607979580760002, -0.18401041626930237, 0.05533968284726143, -0.6152669787406921, -0.09541519731283188, 0.38346168398857117, 1.0449059009552002, -1.0294773578643799, 0.4737071096897125, 0.3861068785190582, -0.09466025978326797, -0.16230244934558868, -0.4380092918872833, 0.047303538769483566, -0.9525856375694275, 0.631818950176239, -0.05235666409134865, -0.3785742223262787, 0.016903987154364586, 0.13280600309371948, -0.8891582489013672, 0.8881940841674805, 0.7722406387329102, -0.8470343947410583, -0.11913274973630905, 0.5267866849899292, 0.3439261317253113, -0.26266300678253174, -0.02888667583465576, 0.9404121041297913, 0.7056370377540588, 0.09215740114450455, -1.0051840543746948, -0.6505582928657532, -0.1452510952949524, -0.36737290024757385, 0.470212459564209, -0.7611458897590637, 0.7917376756668091, -0.2990780472755432, -0.1620957851409912, -0.18493101000785828, 0.491786390542984, -0.16393254697322845, 0.6938973665237427, 0.24688087403774261, 0.5357397198677063, 0.8275737166404724, -0.3619433343410492, 1.1536377668380737, -0.45058226585388184, 0.13669972121715546, 0.8309337496757507, -0.35741758346557617, 0.8515064120292664, 0.7477891445159912, -0.5168849229812622, 0.44512781500816345, 0.6040521264076233, 0.0006986804655753076, 0.13944673538208008, 0.1824813038110733, -0.4172907769680023, -0.2103535681962967, -0.05012596398591995, -0.13178934156894684, 0.5651537775993347, 0.24228131771087646, -0.18305401504039764, -0.5197590589523315, 0.0856214240193367, 0.08021239191293716, 0.4846796691417694, -0.5201850533485413, 0.35005509853363037, 0.15311110019683838, -0.4571506381034851, 0.00522082531824708, 0.4064291715621948, 0.846572756767273, -0.9663795828819275, 0.578380286693573, -0.6491993069648743, 0.16806229948997498, -0.029951531440019608, -0.5056294202804565, 0.5931323766708374, 0.518950343132019, -0.24656111001968384, -0.7683599591255188, 0.29768580198287964, -0.5033659934997559, -0.9180980324745178, 0.661408543586731, 0.6906149983406067, 0.04648131877183914, 0.1586267203092575, -0.5367671847343445, -0.27094128727912903, -0.1987081915140152, -0.1991458386182785, 0.5548421144485474, 0.23903287947177887, -0.06348433345556259, 0.606408953666687, 0.6148340702056885, 0.1870940923690796, 0.1827181726694107, 0.21035000681877136, 0.4904818832874298, -0.5649805068969727, -0.4082469642162323, -1.0210802555084229, 0.23170042037963867, 0.16034583747386932, -0.4101713299751282, 0.889656126499176, 0.9666824340820312, 1.1603714227676392, -0.10839791595935822, 0.1461169272661209, 0.46182647347450256, 0.28691598773002625, -0.5511066913604736, 0.5312162637710571, -0.668857753276825, 0.5448573231697083, -0.055125560611486435, -0.9260601997375488, -0.1456097513437271, 0.41350170969963074, -0.5424628257751465, -0.1883079558610916, 0.5346716642379761, 0.6643821597099304, -0.09726649522781372, -0.026219431310892105, 0.2917810380458832, -0.12010892480611801, -0.2693122923374176, 0.7355158925056458, 0.5638917088508606, -0.6155887246131897, 0.31943562626838684, -0.43241024017333984, -0.03585178777575493, -0.11874641478061676, -0.8087648749351501, -0.8722617030143738, -0.2601155638694763, -0.42852339148521423, 0.2631556987762451, -0.22872860729694366, 0.7982305288314819, 0.004847042728215456, -0.5846377611160278, -0.9256357550621033, 0.07066111266613007, 0.31751298904418945, -0.3595260977745056, -0.10791134089231491, 0.07769712060689926, -0.44362226128578186, -1.1540113687515259, 0.971329391002655, 0.940754771232605, 0.15950433909893036, -0.2862459719181061, -0.014681880362331867, 0.07828783243894577, 0.38398730754852295, 0.30968937277793884, 0.5325039029121399, -0.6055014729499817, 0.36072370409965515, 0.5417591333389282, -0.37598198652267456, -0.07285857200622559, 0.8009506464004517, -0.4493553042411804, 0.35663509368896484, 0.4505920112133026, 0.7932579517364502, 0.5340702533721924, -0.49923428893089294, 0.7603263258934021, -0.5234300494194031, 0.4424521028995514, 0.036598775535821915, 0.397308349609375, 0.012416861951351166, -0.06532101333141327, 0.4429357051849365, 0.0890122801065445, -0.07852838188409805, -0.7034517526626587, -0.18009710311889648, -1.01394522190094, -0.183063805103302, 0.8206776976585388, -0.09669599682092667, -0.39810997247695923, 0.13046909868717194, -0.033207327127456665, -0.2041093409061432, -0.1079961508512497, 0.6417922973632812, 0.6007094383239746, 0.3262518048286438, 0.10640192031860352, -0.5428001880645752, 0.2769225239753723, 0.5414547920227051, -0.6465312242507935, 0.05601363256573677, 0.2716526687145233, 0.20032669603824615, -0.3069412410259247, 0.5596323013305664, -0.14864812791347504, 0.4393848478794098, 0.20920120179653168, -0.14249031245708466, -0.47549349069595337, -0.4923185706138611, -0.19189609587192535, 0.0706930160522461, -0.13407425582408905, -0.0809025764465332 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07401v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07401v1	Can LLMs Produce Faithful Explanations For Fact-checking? Towards Faithful Explainable Fact-Checking via Multi-Agent Debate	2024-02-12T04:32:33	2024-02-12T04:32:33	Kyungha Kim, Sangyun Lee, Kung-Hsiang Huang, Hou Pong Chan, Manling Li, Heng Ji	cs.CL	cs.CL	Fact-checking research has extensively explored verification but less so the generation of natural-language explanations, crucial for user trust. While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in text generation, their capability for producing faithful explanations in fact-checking remains underexamined. Our study investigates LLMs' ability to generate such explanations, finding that zero-shot prompts often result in unfaithfulness. To address these challenges, we propose the Multi-Agent Debate Refinement (MADR) framework, leveraging multiple LLMs as agents with diverse roles in an iterative refining process aimed at enhancing faithfulness in generated explanations. MADR ensures that the final explanation undergoes rigorous validation, significantly reducing the likelihood of unfaithful elements and aligning closely with the provided evidence. Experimental results demonstrate that MADR significantly improves the faithfulness of LLM-generated explanations to the evidence, advancing the credibility and trustworthiness of these explanations.	[ -0.4363417327404022, -0.8726450800895691, 1.057570457458496, -0.33238422870635986, -0.20013876259326935, 0.037351079285144806, -0.15867194533348083, -0.11520939320325851, -0.35636237263679504, 0.6591364145278931, -0.8271812200546265, -0.20705366134643555, -0.3658769130706787, 0.4610595107078552, -0.09459950774908066, 1.3267734050750732, -0.28809747099876404, 0.10847726464271545, -0.30423232913017273, -0.19539380073547363, -0.1566382795572281, -0.35325270891189575, -0.5566224455833435, -0.7978239059448242, 0.799724817276001, 0.7444295883178711, 0.9026411771774292, 0.7081429362297058, 0.2957521378993988, 0.3774842321872711, 0.12149012088775635, 0.8157480359077454, -0.5920032262802124, 0.5568103194236755, -0.4492209553718567, -0.3878057599067688, -0.3328903019428253, 0.023670071735978127, 0.4947730004787445, 0.17549408972263336, -0.19281235337257385, 0.009380187839269638, -0.07949015498161316, 0.4682398736476898, -0.6260939240455627, 0.1742488294839859, -0.9312745332717896, -0.2626625895500183, 0.1022905558347702, -0.4300668239593506, -0.55036461353302, -0.45508873462677, 0.07301348447799683, -0.5110888481140137, 0.6834277510643005, 0.08758145570755005, 1.3532800674438477, 0.23336775600910187, -0.5855815410614014, -0.1634330153465271, -0.8664912581443787, 0.5388969779014587, -0.6459647417068481, 0.26103582978248596, -0.020463917404413223, 0.17309285700321198, -0.5277408957481384, -0.523350179195404, -0.9393090009689331, -0.19469839334487915, -0.16468144953250885, 0.07463976740837097, -0.10261731594800949, 0.15459759533405304, 0.1799222081899643, 0.2239093780517578, -0.36715006828308105, -0.3064802289009094, -0.10008212924003601, -0.4747648537158966, 0.7520478367805481, 0.16219019889831543, -0.13679172098636627, 0.1027943566441536, -0.3979347348213196, 0.0014266057405620813, -0.9468351602554321, -0.28975293040275574, 0.41867029666900635, 0.23841547966003418, 0.18550418317317963, 0.6530606746673584, -0.12726953625679016, 0.4572904109954834, 0.2909820079803467, -0.2897614538669586, -0.20772695541381836, -0.6000307202339172, -0.21914809942245483, 0.1322050839662552, 0.8382439017295837, 0.4128412902355194, 0.19503989815711975, -0.3443987965583801, -0.23197579383850098, 0.23638147115707397, 0.3207072615623474, -1.0582444667816162, 0.08070841431617737, 0.5487777590751648, -0.1644485741853714, -0.18932093679904938, 0.05544847995042801, -0.6717494130134583, -0.5017927885055542, -0.4170336425304413, 0.5397040843963623, -0.2688005864620209, -0.2266753911972046, 0.345194011926651, -0.39135250449180603, 0.1920822411775589, 0.7345643639564514, -0.25680139660835266, 0.06910275667905807, 0.7465031743049622, 0.5808405876159668, 0.27449101209640503, -0.5338255167007446, -0.7153517603874207, 0.3257438540458679, -0.6119598150253296, 1.078946590423584, -0.4029076099395752, -0.016224954277276993, 0.03238973766565323, -0.08399654924869537, 0.16232101619243622, -0.3180151879787445, 0.5597153306007385, -0.6311874389648438, 0.2375575304031372, -0.7608715891838074, -0.42380639910697937, -0.2424616813659668, 0.6772017478942871, -0.6229342818260193, 0.6719989776611328, -0.4732581079006195, -0.6999463438987732, 0.45620378851890564, -0.783894419670105, -0.3087763488292694, -0.22726017236709595, -0.177967831492424, -0.6644005179405212, -0.04797492176294327, 0.32552477717399597, 0.34425535798072815, -0.3865247666835785, 0.4736937880516052, -0.36804211139678955, -0.23658037185668945, 0.6465257406234741, -0.5831151008605957, 0.416262686252594, 0.30335912108421326, -0.3630915880203247, 0.12952496111392975, -0.5283246040344238, -0.2147570252418518, 0.2462673932313919, -0.22206304967403412, 0.1304684281349182, 0.04671706259250641, -0.5016170144081116, 0.17439189553260803, 0.07544153928756714, -0.7382976412773132, 0.09681598097085953, -0.24145102500915527, 0.174520343542099, 0.6570325493812561, 0.2754153609275818, 0.12146000564098358, -0.6921076774597168, 0.29196229577064514, 0.3571036458015442, 0.12109488248825073, -0.6021063923835754, -0.2541694641113281, -0.7466254830360413, -0.23415781557559967, 0.03921429440379143, 0.15010762214660645, -0.8485502600669861, -0.21390867233276367, -0.1758570671081543, -0.2810528576374054, -0.6309617757797241, -0.02386035956442356, 0.5590556859970093, 0.4104149043560028, 0.26885008811950684, 0.11487853527069092, -0.4638557434082031, -0.8153915405273438, -0.5287320613861084, -0.37294894456863403, 0.28163406252861023, 0.10673020035028458, 0.6017169952392578, -0.07069012522697449, 1.2685251235961914, -0.2219085544347763, 0.13853639364242554, -0.1440810114145279, 0.455069363117218, -0.1591215580701828, 0.03108787350356579, 0.19153328239917755, -0.6339965462684631, -0.13543608784675598, -0.07085014134645462, -0.5785492658615112, -0.026428140699863434, -0.45480313897132874, -0.16590151190757751, 0.41877540946006775, 0.35760989785194397, -1.0112780332565308, 0.3160047233104706, 0.3176363408565521, -0.4820830821990967, 0.7019180655479431, -0.17441537976264954, 0.4354756772518158, -0.9067652821540833, -0.17676618695259094, -0.10475591570138931, -0.5188868045806885, -0.6044100522994995, 0.3331707715988159, -0.26291581988334656, 0.09943865984678268, -0.2775699496269226, 0.4756144881248474, -0.6970422863960266, 0.26109716296195984, -0.4729010760784149, 0.4388004243373871, 0.5124149322509766, 0.42750662565231323, -0.2498313933610916, 0.6887969970703125, 0.5055903792381287, -0.6486766934394836, 0.2716544568538666, 0.23176828026771545, 0.21835960447788239, 0.5424603819847107, -0.7774437069892883, 0.2234770804643631, -0.47182968258857727, 0.5090206265449524, -1.2532463073730469, -0.2552812397480011, 0.3024974763393402, -0.5032297372817993, 0.1272248476743698, -0.5725237131118774, -0.5335544943809509, -0.06328358501195908, -0.3571121096611023, 0.11638122797012329, 0.05942282825708389, -0.6607049107551575, 0.8630152344703674, -0.06359363347291946, 0.18870563805103302, -0.8097508549690247, -0.4410232603549957, 0.159169003367424, 0.04528094083070755, -0.7035148739814758, 0.07646701484918594, -0.0790582001209259, -0.7019991874694824, 0.057926807552576065, -0.3773866891860962, -0.0693601593375206, -0.04985345900058746, 0.3497868776321411, 0.24720339477062225, -0.39934128522872925, 0.2513134777545929, -0.12279879301786423, -0.0031649041920900345, 0.20378082990646362, 0.05637107416987419, 0.30726540088653564, -0.2213490605354309, -0.6287526488304138, -0.3548066020011902, 0.4028870463371277, 0.9079058170318604, -0.44773194193840027, 1.0207182168960571, 0.5477708578109741, -0.10212652385234833, -0.3190784752368927, -0.9355376958847046, -0.5519440770149231, -0.45756325125694275, -0.06338029354810715, -0.5665057301521301, -1.1682934761047363, 0.5037783980369568, -0.18260835111141205, 0.6091240048408508, 0.5474619269371033, 0.7916430234909058, 0.3034287095069885, 1.0468266010284424, 0.2716352641582489, 0.35518044233322144, -0.04633377492427826, 0.23512698709964752, 0.33293616771698, -0.348419189453125, -0.35747379064559937, -0.8227246999740601, 0.24060724675655365, -0.42467451095581055, -0.40741220116615295, 0.12601743638515472, -0.34822553396224976, -0.3304617404937744, -0.26558080315589905, -0.1407560408115387, 0.8622481226921082, 0.20841668546199799, -0.019837290048599243, 0.4507351219654083, 0.028963198885321617, -0.11335998773574829, 0.2341083586215973, -0.4687461853027344, -0.7361249327659607, 0.7594833374023438, 0.3447010815143585, 0.8430960774421692, 0.3312908709049225, 0.5813278555870056, 0.27224090695381165, 0.3403283655643463, -0.6342418193817139, 0.42502501606941223, 0.30831003189086914, -0.8810642957687378, -0.32339900732040405, -0.43640539050102234, -0.9169901013374329, 0.6273470520973206, -0.33699846267700195, -0.301995187997818, -0.006600425112992525, 0.2970171570777893, -0.49342653155326843, 0.2820267081260681, -0.5488632917404175, 0.6303050518035889, -0.009816653095185757, -0.596379816532135, -0.39274832606315613, -0.40379539132118225, 0.5130173563957214, 0.09785310178995132, 0.1847040355205536, -0.21004365384578705, 0.18229368329048157, 0.2614876627922058, -0.7184630036354065, 0.7631744146347046, -0.11845483630895615, -0.5215433239936829, 0.39315298199653625, 0.3225152790546417, 0.7666926980018616, 0.2879432439804077, -0.23956309258937836, 0.024127282202243805, -0.27519986033439636, -0.31070342659950256, -0.7155898809432983, 0.4801139533519745, -0.6774851679801941, -0.9497005343437195, -0.35584792494773865, -0.5316104888916016, -0.17226120829582214, -0.030820095911622047, -0.000542808382306248, 0.6099424362182617, -0.27584201097488403, -0.008792275562882423, 0.9796361923217773, 0.09647318720817566, 0.18306127190589905, 1.0945881605148315, -0.19697707891464233, -0.19521485269069672, 0.6574199795722961, -0.14622177183628082, 0.1494058221578598, 0.1872563511133194, 0.21638576686382294, -0.4103739857673645, -0.5528590083122253, -0.623255729675293, 0.4058004319667816, -0.6718325018882751, -0.23566153645515442, -0.5780400633811951, -0.07796575129032135, -0.14868973195552826, -0.008650194853544235, -0.5816335082054138, -0.2075120508670807, -0.11994700878858566, -0.19004252552986145, 0.4991833567619324, 0.9337473511695862, -0.1587120145559311, 0.33723536133766174, -0.6953122615814209, 0.7347303628921509, 0.3894120454788208, 0.2831327021121979, -0.15762576460838318, -0.6451200246810913, -0.16309110820293427, 0.36983785033226013, -0.3764272630214691, -1.162123203277588, -0.07762105762958527, 0.11619047075510025, 0.4317081570625305, 0.5289705991744995, 0.21835589408874512, 0.9575220942497253, -0.6340028047561646, 0.8855166435241699, 0.04009861871600151, -0.9408556222915649, 0.41125747561454773, -0.2629048824310303, -0.00063032511388883, 0.4803740978240967, 0.20669788122177124, -0.2869337797164917, -0.8569018840789795, -0.6670181155204773, -0.5491751432418823, 0.7525036334991455, 0.251193642616272, 0.027111148461699486, -0.12451354414224625, 0.6309819221496582, 0.32787030935287476, 0.09895365685224533, -0.6085715889930725, -0.4936789870262146, -0.335680216550827, 0.1454605758190155, 0.05728502199053764, -0.4488743841648102, -0.7523341774940491, 0.2567974925041199, 1.0077401399612427, -0.4035017192363739, 0.2093682736158371, 0.6382688879966736, -0.047002241015434265, -0.6535797715187073, 0.7679215669631958, 0.8169898390769958, 0.9752441644668579, 0.1540711671113968, 0.5147022008895874, -0.029337361454963684, -0.08114785701036453, 0.3550833463668823, 0.17420779168605804, -0.12770798802375793, 0.45513206720352173, 0.3083820939064026, 0.7452533841133118, -0.22178003191947937, -0.44248145818710327, 0.6806862950325012, -0.3863300383090973, -0.5083749890327454, 0.05689234286546707, 0.0449952594935894, 0.007631632965058088, 0.3791087567806244, 0.36931633949279785, 0.1006372720003128, -0.07003055512905121, -0.6404045820236206, 0.29611703753471375, 0.7379695177078247, 0.03504533693194389, -0.27688437700271606, 0.4933386445045471, -0.027620891109108925, 0.0528680756688118, 0.3366501033306122, -0.3959932029247284, -0.6610429286956787, 0.48418551683425903, 0.5403993129730225, 0.6554057598114014, -0.16462649405002594, 0.680824875831604, 0.2747490108013153, 0.5744010806083679, -0.22198337316513062, 0.358955442905426, 0.09735160320997238, -0.9696765542030334, -0.8503483533859253, -0.20917126536369324, -0.8286129832267761, 0.354339599609375, -0.4237056374549866, -0.06113447993993759, -0.3010610044002533, -0.07471417635679245, 0.2609438896179199, 0.04735241085290909, -0.4354228675365448, 0.09975887089967728, 0.05216466635465622, 0.6502243280410767, -0.7071722149848938, 0.40282997488975525, 0.6315940022468567, -0.4566395580768585, -0.9982653260231018, 0.2608310580253601, 0.2902970612049103, -0.7872524857521057, 0.2454211264848709, -0.04155804589390755, -0.7226477861404419, -0.39137473702430725, -1.008337378501892, -0.5627997517585754, 0.7820959091186523, 0.9835275411605835, -0.6316165924072266, 0.3040209114551544, 0.18785546720027924, 0.5673672556877136, -0.0973079726099968, 0.5131759643554688, 0.2318028062582016, 0.750587522983551, 0.45420271158218384, -0.6853606104850769, 0.3880266547203064, 0.012983579188585281, -0.3830694258213043, 0.10352178663015366, -0.8431017994880676, 0.914394199848175, -0.6550659537315369, -0.26228010654449463, -0.10775302350521088, 0.8325841426849365, 0.4627916216850281, 0.47951775789260864, 0.4519237279891968, 0.4255377948284149, 0.801038384437561, -0.14893026649951935, 0.8625970482826233, -0.21158860623836517, 0.29118242859840393, 1.1577105522155762, -0.5001306533813477, 0.4460970461368561, 0.5148870944976807, 0.2507554292678833, 0.9403260946273804, 0.41808590292930603, -0.10794133692979813, -0.015029110945761204, 0.019973434507846832, -0.4273522198200226, -0.784948468208313, -0.4195045828819275, -0.1392509490251541, 0.5072867274284363, 0.007359932642430067, -0.14992715418338776, -0.5552669167518616, -0.4366561770439148, 0.5049588084220886, -0.0807533785700798, -0.2923233211040497, 0.7867475152015686, -0.1879121959209442, -1.1269524097442627, 0.6489392518997192, 0.23668509721755981, 0.15037353336811066, -0.5588823556900024, -0.2192351073026657, -0.30933085083961487, 0.30321356654167175, -0.32299983501434326, -0.8733003735542297, 0.047951385378837585, 0.244579017162323, -0.21212488412857056, -0.2898124158382416, 0.8017531037330627, -0.7039985060691833, 0.07557410001754761, -0.10596365481615067, 0.8883379101753235, 0.20355069637298584, -0.28360530734062195, -0.6441901922225952, 0.08810495585203171, -0.03945304453372955, -0.30235186219215393, -0.03082442097365856, 0.9838551878929138, 0.02707223780453205, 0.7026084065437317, 0.661892831325531, -0.1408078670501709, -0.24351418018341064, 0.3118242919445038, 0.8834111094474792, -0.3833096921443939, -0.05261197313666344, -1.4678796529769897, 0.5180209279060364, 0.022656984627246857, 0.18617597222328186, 0.9395685195922852, 0.6085495352745056, 0.5077756643295288, 0.08178000897169113, 0.8511824607849121, 0.3003963530063629, 0.33504927158355713, -0.4108964204788208, 0.6442165374755859, -0.54340660572052, 0.10223162919282913, -0.005339735187590122, -0.5379568338394165, 0.04339763894677162, 0.3188225328922272, 0.1950928270816803, 0.018024751916527748, 0.832801103591919, 1.056370496749878, -0.0798327624797821, 0.13044337928295135, 0.2229606807231903, 0.5801774859428406, 0.31771013140678406, 0.14969602227210999, 1.1222461462020874, -0.23342765867710114, 0.8305367231369019, 0.13409844040870667, 0.09325817227363586, -0.06183120608329773, -1.2139172554016113, -1.039847493171692, -0.31985053420066833, -0.6329166889190674, -0.47464704513549805, 0.22488324344158173, 0.7965492606163025, 0.5869007110595703, -0.6525017619132996, 0.03058765083551407, -0.0013761988375335932, 0.567324161529541, -0.08830064535140991, -0.2243165522813797, -0.022101057693362236, -0.3863990306854248, -0.317933052778244, 0.43435633182525635, 0.24138344824314117, -0.1122487410902977, -0.34632667899131775, -0.36665311455726624, -0.04662786424160004, 0.7728118896484375, 0.4496266841888428, 0.15722307562828064, -1.0435619354248047, -0.5097410082817078, -0.17626047134399414, 0.042860958725214005, 0.20929333567619324, 1.0616497993469238, -0.65510094165802, 0.4147317707538605, 0.17948122322559357, 0.5462494492530823, 0.20493978261947632, 0.18350209295749664, 0.6042872071266174, -0.8216673135757446, -0.33424443006515503, -0.1565079241991043, 0.35107216238975525, 0.42803940176963806, -0.38635268807411194, 0.16268622875213623, 0.0722285807132721, -0.7409228086471558, -0.8778032064437866, 0.3491639196872711, -0.9365056157112122, -0.3651723861694336, 1.434618353843689, -0.26330623030662537, -0.18796564638614655, -0.5312855243682861, -0.39263951778411865, 0.5425339937210083, -0.676495373249054, 0.8262510895729065, 1.0044872760772705, -0.004495490342378616, -0.3901272714138031, -0.0976467952132225, 0.5670463442802429, 0.3375758230686188, -0.8668177127838135, 0.7019758224487305, 0.790220320224762, 0.31472474336624146, 0.19658981263637543, 0.6048042178153992, -0.042696285992860794, 0.48535189032554626, 0.019583530724048615, -0.022505179047584534, -0.40821895003318787, -0.48427441716194153, -0.20391607284545898, 0.1930650919675827, 0.31373438239097595, 0.020887188613414764 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07397v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07397v2	Leveraging AI to Advance Science and Computing Education across Africa: Challenges, Progress and Opportunities	2024-02-12T04:10:09	2024-04-26T23:31:04	George Boateng	cs.CY	cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC	Across the African continent, students grapple with various educational challenges, including limited access to essential resources such as computers, internet connectivity, reliable electricity, and a shortage of qualified teachers. Despite these challenges, recent advances in AI such as BERT, and GPT-4 have demonstrated their potential for advancing education. Yet, these AI tools tend to be deployed and evaluated predominantly within the context of Western educational settings, with limited attention directed towards the unique needs and challenges faced by students in Africa. In this chapter, we discuss challenges with using AI to advance education across Africa. Then, we describe our work developing and deploying AI in Education tools in Africa for science and computing education: (1) SuaCode, an AI-powered app that enables Africans to learn to code using their smartphones, (2) AutoGrad, an automated grading, and feedback tool for graphical and interactive coding assignments, (3) a tool for code plagiarism detection that shows visual evidence of plagiarism, (4) Kwame, a bilingual AI teaching assistant for coding courses, (5) Kwame for Science, a web-based AI teaching assistant that provides instant answers to students' science questions and (6) Brilla AI, an AI contestant for the National Science and Maths Quiz competition. Finally, we discuss potential opportunities to leverage AI to advance education across Africa.	[ -0.5237020254135132, -0.6716315746307373, 0.6534069180488586, 0.2246789187192917, 0.1345895379781723, 0.3985968828201294, 0.03451472148299217, -0.3766191303730011, 0.021086685359477997, 0.05538443103432655, -0.5387440919876099, -0.12151768058538437, -0.8801276683807373, 0.1976921707391739, -0.5015913248062134, 0.9853155016899109, -0.44011029601097107, 0.03362669050693512, -0.8493998646736145, -0.022970831021666527, -0.5976631045341492, -0.6250668168067932, -0.3854602575302124, -0.3090432584285736, 0.35853150486946106, 0.9246160387992859, 0.636773943901062, -0.03574199229478836, 0.6946079134941101, 0.35799989104270935, 0.3549279272556305, 0.17017289996147156, 0.17852118611335754, -0.11447533965110779, -0.1536279320716858, -0.33428820967674255, 0.01465173065662384, 0.15681596100330353, 0.1667090505361557, 0.7734335064888, 0.05135536938905716, 0.38546043634414673, 0.06057850643992424, 0.47155699133872986, -0.5757392644882202, 0.1217399388551712, -0.16497845947742462, -0.004944865591824055, -0.13746778666973114, 0.31129753589630127, 0.3246837556362152, -0.6545351147651672, 0.20599400997161865, -0.5238984227180481, 0.15149283409118652, -0.6643672585487366, 0.8081841468811035, 0.21985574066638947, -0.20959390699863434, -0.7631995677947998, -0.24593953788280487, 0.6207911372184753, -0.34073758125305176, 0.14726567268371582, 0.5487218499183655, 0.6464120149612427, -0.19269444048404694, -1.2545642852783203, -0.4622323215007782, -0.14404822885990143, 0.5056009292602539, 0.20445050299167633, 0.3354499042034149, -0.15546254813671112, 0.13632002472877502, 0.22814422845840454, -0.04542272910475731, 0.056421078741550446, -0.7075039744377136, -0.4767751395702362, 0.7857652902603149, -0.08930602669715881, 0.4502878487110138, 0.3546521067619324, -0.14923550188541412, -0.22897109389305115, -0.4260350167751312, 0.07178657501935959, 0.6892330646514893, 0.22719620168209076, -0.1545729637145996, 0.4335995316505432, 0.31113898754119873, 0.5823953747749329, -0.4701709747314453, 0.023644693195819855, 0.13596782088279724, -0.24882984161376953, 0.16449299454689026, 0.05889279022812843, 0.41990479826927185, -0.22580577433109283, -0.03788880631327629, 0.3411490023136139, 0.0023794076405465603, 0.37698614597320557, 0.46198582649230957, -0.6326047778129578, -0.37086212635040283, 0.1348918378353119, -0.26780328154563904, -0.15772147476673126, -0.07898233830928802, -0.9954227805137634, -0.621684730052948, -0.05249183624982834, 0.9002900123596191, -0.18394280970096588, 0.26403915882110596, -0.3251173198223114, -0.39650824666023254, -0.023803869262337685, 0.6183854341506958, -1.0800749063491821, -0.03902538865804672, 0.5282915234565735, 1.0530039072036743, 0.20497216284275055, -0.41635605692863464, 0.4792312979698181, -0.4114915728569031, -0.03551867604255676, 0.4686514437198639, -0.6534352898597717, -0.7526248097419739, -0.08699552714824677, -0.15305940806865692, -0.027266979217529297, -0.14871932566165924, 0.5098167657852173, -0.3507280945777893, -0.046922553330659866, -0.3692883551120758, -0.37247881293296814, -0.3400611877441406, 0.10795638710260391, -0.46367284655570984, 0.803381621837616, 0.3647695779800415, -0.4465380907058716, -0.09018184244632721, -1.1694626808166504, -0.679931104183197, -0.100535549223423, -0.40795016288757324, -0.5234217047691345, 0.022053100168704987, 0.33344566822052, 0.0841083899140358, -0.11421185731887817, -0.004338626749813557, -0.04702218621969223, -0.4448247253894806, 0.02835349179804325, -0.33937445282936096, 1.04058837890625, 0.3358975350856781, -0.6140086650848389, -0.12136586010456085, -0.47499704360961914, -0.040770795196294785, 0.20739729702472687, 0.014845521189272404, -0.03502913936972618, 0.18966607749462128, -0.10374194383621216, 0.03909077122807503, 0.5412610769271851, -0.6360971331596375, 0.6210989952087402, 0.14549852907657623, 0.6194666028022766, 0.7850332856178284, -0.03178783506155014, 0.2973904311656952, -0.3749987483024597, 0.6038708090782166, -0.28362441062927246, 0.43847930431365967, -0.15078012645244598, -0.76263028383255, -0.4642940163612366, -0.052751172333955765, 0.7058732509613037, 0.6853357553482056, -0.8529548048973083, 0.13169226050376892, 0.14032696187496185, -0.6324396729469299, -1.0433319807052612, 0.33971574902534485, -0.3238671123981476, 0.7719442248344421, 0.34967583417892456, -0.06410305947065353, -0.42185717821121216, -0.8192113041877747, -0.14085251092910767, 0.04659160226583481, -0.23793694376945496, 0.5075626969337463, 0.8792213201522827, -0.4512547552585602, 0.8936967849731445, -0.3972020149230957, -0.4071698784828186, -0.1842920333147049, 0.17723718285560608, 0.0663910061120987, 0.5918055176734924, 0.47238582372665405, -1.191685676574707, -0.3991358280181885, 0.02761605568230152, -0.7859698534011841, -0.2194215953350067, -0.3010704219341278, 0.08675660192966461, 0.12924037873744965, 0.38594913482666016, -0.1724405586719513, 0.5760054588317871, 0.436384916305542, -0.1163284033536911, 0.4713367223739624, -0.1281498223543167, 0.433870404958725, -0.5517576336860657, 0.1213853657245636, -0.41477105021476746, 0.11469177156686783, -0.3667783737182617, 0.0827346071600914, -0.09453731775283813, -0.6585192084312439, -0.1349252462387085, 0.28054457902908325, -0.21651875972747803, -0.14070840179920197, -0.3978208601474762, 0.40267473459243774, -0.2620474398136139, -0.14267894625663757, -0.06973813474178314, 1.1089670658111572, 0.6213071942329407, -0.5545123815536499, 0.3755214214324951, 0.3953937888145447, -0.31823429465293884, 0.31177788972854614, -0.5767537355422974, 0.2776171863079071, 0.23894309997558594, 0.18037237226963043, -0.21766649186611176, -0.2644633650779724, -0.015053180046379566, -0.6135393977165222, -0.0376012921333313, 0.20798373222351074, -0.3405802845954895, -0.5813366174697876, -0.23191218078136444, 0.41090452671051025, 0.5547977685928345, -0.7488598823547363, 0.6437333822250366, 0.37987563014030457, -0.4233349859714508, -0.7119132280349731, -0.6726762652397156, 0.23614656925201416, 0.28009870648384094, -0.5794811248779297, 0.2708407938480377, -0.0356009267270565, -0.17917484045028687, 0.14964169263839722, -0.20835602283477783, -0.18370746076107025, 0.708579421043396, 0.4031904637813568, 0.10532785207033157, 0.1839202344417572, -0.058642592281103134, 0.27305930852890015, 0.16501416265964508, 0.2471993863582611, -0.38773176074028015, 0.2617630362510681, -0.11723817139863968, -0.4993322193622589, -0.32683539390563965, 0.49879539012908936, 0.34708598256111145, 0.010723740793764591, 0.6674453020095825, 0.6749162673950195, -0.48891666531562805, -0.13787898421287537, -0.205452561378479, -0.3049686849117279, -0.5318608283996582, 0.3497875928878784, -0.20187260210514069, -0.6923341751098633, 0.46409034729003906, -0.5785054564476013, 0.4107271730899811, -0.04889751598238945, 0.37531012296676636, -0.39530590176582336, 0.8587117195129395, 1.0372487306594849, -0.1767665445804596, 0.5935149192810059, -0.7180684804916382, 0.46654024720191956, -0.6878471374511719, -0.4593098759651184, -0.588722825050354, -0.5727984309196472, -0.42540597915649414, -0.0566369965672493, 0.5614016652107239, 0.09421352297067642, -0.2817278206348419, -0.006748443469405174, -0.5122548937797546, 0.4407753348350525, 0.9863183498382568, 0.20039287209510803, -0.20690837502479553, 0.009287282824516296, 0.015486394986510277, 0.14750179648399353, -0.9128245711326599, -0.6455918550491333, 0.9520463943481445, -0.027501756325364113, 0.3881003260612488, -0.048398103564977646, 0.8591089248657227, 0.7656704187393188, 0.5935789942741394, -0.4803694784641266, 0.3433445692062378, -0.008400240913033485, -0.6633481383323669, -0.26389339566230774, -0.27731356024742126, -0.8370423316955566, -0.13348795473575592, -0.08512911200523376, -0.800798237323761, 0.06647586822509766, -0.04891997575759888, -0.1492389440536499, 0.3872722387313843, -0.7773717641830444, 0.9204977750778198, -0.5311688780784607, -0.2717539668083191, -0.33113449811935425, -0.8953381180763245, -0.24783745408058167, -0.13703389465808868, 0.4359676241874695, 0.1947426199913025, 0.04508174955844879, 0.7241727709770203, -0.5778054594993591, 0.7117549180984497, -0.42667508125305176, 0.2452266812324524, 0.7968624234199524, -0.24062718451023102, -0.27966049313545227, -0.07284857332706451, -0.17435166239738464, 0.5503832101821899, -0.19987550377845764, -0.6574727892875671, -0.5100222229957581, 0.762216329574585, -1.132343053817749, -0.6181977391242981, -0.5757058262825012, -0.7250269651412964, -0.23267421126365662, 0.17460045218467712, 0.3132861256599426, 0.2997072637081146, 0.07917281985282898, -0.18303115665912628, 0.2747890055179596, -0.2965586483478546, 0.5142017602920532, -0.1521890014410019, 0.19843973219394684, -0.20005416870117188, 1.1894221305847168, 0.24891935288906097, 0.12743228673934937, -0.19517844915390015, -0.04893811419606209, -0.3359885513782501, -0.32022014260292053, -0.5350375175476074, -0.06379524618387222, -0.9752786755561829, -0.32448437809944153, -0.2807183265686035, -0.3485252857208252, -0.6123231649398804, -0.8998209834098816, 0.1930711567401886, -0.5502741932868958, -0.4775795340538025, -0.007489887531846762, 0.32239842414855957, 0.8988943099975586, -0.5429216623306274, 0.6105246543884277, -0.5337143540382385, 0.20236659049987793, 0.39210137724876404, 0.1399289071559906, 0.03932467848062515, -0.09668457508087158, -0.1765097677707672, 0.2113209217786789, -0.7698320150375366, -0.7315371632575989, 0.08950626850128174, 0.3127917945384979, 0.5245764851570129, 0.02744278311729431, -0.19889891147613525, 0.5400465726852417, -0.22731958329677582, 1.1267074346542358, 0.011376076377928257, -1.0228081941604614, 0.875457763671875, 0.3595949113368988, 0.07458480447530746, 0.7906889319419861, 0.7619572877883911, -0.4400675892829895, -0.1892038881778717, -0.5626655220985413, -1.002974510192871, 0.4934140741825104, 0.24964644014835358, 0.26175183057785034, 0.43226081132888794, 0.40151235461235046, 0.21178396046161652, 0.3949569761753082, -0.3668521046638489, -0.15412165224552155, -0.780849814414978, -0.44787225127220154, 0.030607417225837708, 0.3079456388950348, -0.10710916668176651, -0.19716255366802216, 0.9356829524040222, -0.007132940925657749, 0.16510112583637238, 0.35246241092681885, -0.34488800168037415, 0.5353736281394958, 0.17566733062267303, 0.3091967701911926, 0.5762437582015991, 0.18541157245635986, -0.4281718134880066, 0.088261179625988, -0.9220784306526184, 0.16828541457653046, 0.3880772590637207, -0.36559727787971497, -0.25248271226882935, 0.2660956084728241, 0.44397127628326416, -0.24913887679576874, -0.6324464082717896, 0.3445374667644501, -0.10137132555246353, -0.19933390617370605, -0.2606198489665985, 0.07648717612028122, -0.01442150678485632, 0.20909029245376587, 0.5679630637168884, 0.0366479828953743, 0.23392973840236664, -0.6923826336860657, -0.0009339040843769908, 0.2959555983543396, -0.13326634466648102, 0.017016861587762833, 0.7340087294578552, 0.47451215982437134, -0.41921892762184143, 0.930459201335907, 0.04641271010041237, -0.8591609597206116, 1.2186506986618042, 0.756531298160553, 0.5764074325561523, -0.23356059193611145, 0.444191038608551, 0.01878340356051922, 0.3850989043712616, 0.3449206054210663, 0.7289698123931885, -0.5958374738693237, -0.43838149309158325, 0.18028905987739563, -0.3154756724834442, -0.8751508593559265, -0.19519954919815063, -0.28084173798561096, 0.13797257840633392, -0.49928292632102966, -0.2874804437160492, 0.026856262236833572, 0.15082673728466034, -0.5984609127044678, 0.2029532939195633, 0.10396075248718262, 0.8861112594604492, -0.8723739385604858, 0.6063570380210876, 1.1834567785263062, -0.28624722361564636, -0.6016092300415039, -0.5419637560844421, -0.11800305545330048, -0.42959073185920715, 0.3746819496154785, 0.26466822624206543, 0.019649533554911613, 0.024532414972782135, -0.8178573846817017, -0.4360310435295105, 0.9993627667427063, 0.10074912011623383, -0.38629579544067383, 0.3553624451160431, 0.1468934565782547, 0.4677652418613434, -0.1499117761850357, 0.4511359930038452, 0.43801039457321167, 0.5689148306846619, -0.2195814996957779, -0.5190538167953491, -0.5068796277046204, -0.16777783632278442, -0.32178837060928345, 0.2454044222831726, -0.5979793667793274, 0.7461709380149841, -0.6090366244316101, -0.19484244287014008, 0.23242239654064178, 0.8376452326774597, 0.05158378928899765, 0.7472303509712219, 0.12338241189718246, 0.2106281965970993, 0.7921691536903381, -0.4041184186935425, 0.7463709115982056, -0.2448793351650238, 0.1705431491136551, 0.5112036466598511, -0.2705897390842438, 0.26419970393180847, 0.14991945028305054, -0.24183803796768188, 0.7840610146522522, 0.8021129965782166, -0.29350119829177856, 0.33636540174484253, 0.13704313337802887, -0.5776498317718506, 0.1478063315153122, -0.2522265315055847, -0.5232991576194763, 0.503673791885376, 0.8555987477302551, 0.12893667817115784, -0.1994907557964325, 0.6042196154594421, -0.13519339263439178, 0.34442469477653503, -0.8961715698242188, 0.33101943135261536, 0.13181057572364807, -0.3108087480068207, -0.08364972472190857, -0.05157764256000519, 0.38731688261032104, -0.7762635946273804, -0.49234554171562195, -0.03417069837450981, 0.12888459861278534, -0.27650150656700134, -0.7111363410949707, 0.11647934466600418, 0.08217398077249527, 0.1844022274017334, -0.07161424309015274, 0.8018423318862915, -0.3277325928211212, -0.5598956346511841, 0.06957771629095078, 0.10902538895606995, 0.14088690280914307, 0.4767679274082184, -0.641934871673584, 0.1296868771314621, -0.19470946490764618, 0.39696836471557617, 0.29791805148124695, 0.10124395042657852, -0.29098859429359436, 0.8128808736801147, 0.5886594653129578, 0.26562052965164185, -0.08941531926393509, 0.11120706051588058, 0.5647226572036743, -0.33474820852279663, -0.715131938457489, -0.5462690591812134, -0.0031336192041635513, -0.21389971673488617, -0.37652966380119324, 0.8145831227302551, 0.33582165837287903, 0.8928086757659912, 0.1239614263176918, 1.1779063940048218, -0.5378260612487793, -0.048270534723997116, 0.01480905245989561, 0.7553983926773071, -0.295238196849823, 0.043489087373018265, -0.22997979819774628, -0.6910571455955505, -0.016957668587565422, 0.6785532236099243, -0.11572666466236115, 0.142646923661232, 0.31821495294570923, 0.05237114056944847, 0.13752594590187073, 0.24854497611522675, -0.11115618050098419, -0.02835501916706562, 0.27851036190986633, 0.43600994348526, 0.6680089235305786, -0.43999192118644714, 0.1153000220656395, -0.7066487669944763, -0.49592024087905884, 0.004676398355513811, -0.5478326678276062, -0.8543580174446106, -0.49294787645339966, -0.29183125495910645, -0.23811747133731842, 0.32137787342071533, 0.6344941854476929, 0.34964799880981445, -0.9989818930625916, -0.19299818575382233, 0.009675191715359688, 0.5471458435058594, -0.3618035912513733, -0.19403333961963654, 0.5467500686645508, -0.2636767327785492, -0.5276907682418823, 0.4025011956691742, -0.04473681375384331, 0.2706867754459381, -0.20813508331775665, 0.4863627254962921, -0.32646340131759644, 0.014012855477631092, 0.41389036178588867, 0.7893804311752319, -0.10702807456254959, -0.41018447279930115, -0.15382510423660278, 0.18300548195838928, -0.3261030316352844, 0.8072023987770081, -1.0629613399505615, 0.4266427755355835, 0.3195498585700989, 1.255223274230957, 0.25523096323013306, 0.1269012689590454, 0.4062180817127228, -0.6692193746566772, 0.10771532356739044, 0.5714735388755798, 0.20307722687721252, 0.4998294711112976, -0.3756510615348816, 0.5921752452850342, 0.14529210329055786, -0.9465175271034241, -0.8059159517288208, 0.06849118322134018, -0.48321089148521423, -0.46187683939933777, 0.18350933492183685, -0.19062601029872894, -0.04390953108668327, -0.1915571689605713, -0.15624041855335236, 0.19566787779331207, -0.054686080664396286, 1.1751214265823364, 0.6868539452552795, -0.40475016832351685, 0.3247414529323578, -0.661033570766449, 0.367154985666275, 0.3188436031341553, -1.034506916999817, -0.5479364395141602, 0.16300608217716217, 0.020693223923444748, 0.47364673018455505, 0.1920013427734375, -0.14056257903575897, 0.614576518535614, 0.29799357056617737, 0.06172587350010872, -0.31619399785995483, -0.7150007486343384, -0.41760438680648804, 0.10417063534259796, -0.326810359954834, -0.5085229873657227 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07386v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07386v1	Chain-of-Layer: Iteratively Prompting Large Language Models for Taxonomy Induction from Limited Examples	2024-02-12T03:05:54	2024-02-12T03:05:54	Qingkai Zeng, Yuyang Bai, Zhaoxuan Tan, Shangbin Feng, Zhenwen Liang, Zhihan Zhang, Meng Jiang	cs.CL	cs.CL	Automatic taxonomy induction is crucial for web search, recommendation systems, and question answering. Manual curation of taxonomies is expensive in terms of human effort, making automatic taxonomy construction highly desirable. In this work, we introduce Chain-of-Layer which is an in-context learning framework designed to induct taxonomies from a given set of entities. Chain-of-Layer breaks down the task into selecting relevant candidate entities in each layer and gradually building the taxonomy from top to bottom. To minimize errors, we introduce the Ensemble-based Ranking Filter to reduce the hallucinated content generated at each iteration. Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate that Chain-of-Layer achieves state-of-the-art performance on four real-world benchmarks.	[ -0.684887707233429, -0.6010843515396118, 0.3520808517932892, 0.07776251435279846, -0.12492448091506958, 0.4064036011695862, -0.11737680435180664, -0.6065914630889893, 0.17359718680381775, 0.4981856942176819, -0.5140193104743958, -0.4590860903263092, -0.38067445158958435, 0.07945302873849869, -0.627459704875946, 0.8175999522209167, 0.05811135470867157, -0.39632704854011536, -0.4365469217300415, 0.08716728538274765, -0.021038273349404335, -0.44994205236434937, -0.8547122478485107, -0.5563361644744873, 0.759240984916687, 0.31415271759033203, 0.5661538243293762, 0.8891531825065613, 0.3042151629924774, 0.23815834522247314, 0.1252754032611847, 0.3514690101146698, -0.25150004029273987, 0.2887290418148041, -0.5356588363647461, -0.12084557861089706, -0.1879408061504364, -0.1687619835138321, 0.650374174118042, 0.8871456384658813, -0.48286721110343933, 0.2669254541397095, -0.03729114681482315, 0.7343252301216125, -0.8316864967346191, -0.05526423826813698, -0.8650808334350586, -0.15998290479183197, -0.05824527144432068, -0.35562795400619507, -0.5647745132446289, -0.14006957411766052, 0.3946708142757416, -0.6641780138015747, -0.2165856957435608, 0.3896504044532776, 0.5103908181190491, 0.15774205327033997, -0.2827954888343811, -0.5612365007400513, -0.6793966293334961, 0.5248295664787292, -0.39904147386550903, 0.39991751313209534, 0.45419397950172424, 0.14723652601242065, -0.1366148293018341, -0.8925449848175049, -0.507034957408905, -0.1087641566991806, -0.11873051524162292, 0.08157488703727722, 0.05788262560963631, -0.03937075659632683, 0.08619388937950134, 0.4992118179798126, -0.6061149835586548, 0.44144371151924133, -0.22458545863628387, 0.22246584296226501, 0.5570416450500488, -0.13661597669124603, 0.44933128356933594, -0.16724823415279388, -0.4288474917411804, -0.2920326888561249, -0.6321775317192078, -0.20030048489570618, 0.3333577811717987, 0.38119301199913025, 0.42273393273353577, 0.2679424285888672, -0.37461215257644653, 0.6609326004981995, 0.13232900202274323, -0.17227520048618317, 0.1793689876794815, 0.12366556376218796, -0.31507182121276855, 0.5272946357727051, 0.6023537516593933, 0.017487362027168274, -0.14278070628643036, -0.5011510848999023, -0.49858227372169495, 0.21079455316066742, 0.3687841296195984, -0.5079275965690613, -0.23427817225456238, 0.373089075088501, -0.2504877746105194, -0.5382622480392456, 0.24637126922607422, -0.5210503339767456, -0.08265632390975952, -0.23499268293380737, 0.7117266058921814, -0.2770116627216339, -0.4444289207458496, 0.16150224208831787, -0.17609889805316925, 0.01835601031780243, 0.07189108431339264, -0.8862282633781433, 0.8648499250411987, 0.46325647830963135, 0.8140697479248047, -0.39761292934417725, -0.37584853172302246, -0.5905100703239441, 0.2639486789703369, -0.3658996522426605, 0.7952669858932495, -0.6231380105018616, -0.09987643361091614, 0.033865589648485184, -0.00412620697170496, -0.0011414105538278818, -0.7010618448257446, 0.1345565915107727, -0.7509461045265198, 0.22429926693439484, 0.01659400202333927, -0.6540972590446472, -0.0603153333067894, 0.1262904852628708, -0.6256044507026672, 1.0901178121566772, 0.4112975597381592, -0.529471755027771, 0.5519858002662659, -0.6513302326202393, -0.5903122425079346, 0.5359643697738647, 0.024134811013936996, 0.031119275838136673, -0.2519702911376953, 0.26825791597366333, 0.44582241773605347, -0.40038517117500305, 0.4034416973590851, -0.0003698849759530276, -0.3293835520744324, -0.32476186752319336, 0.21769021451473236, 0.8723001480102539, 0.4615548849105835, -0.6038563847541809, -0.002665348118171096, -0.8692620992660522, -0.04488617554306984, -0.07092846184968948, -0.1254664659500122, -0.7447103261947632, 0.12897177040576935, -0.13748203217983246, 0.4437239170074463, -0.3550552725791931, -0.18218185007572174, 0.4572429656982422, -0.3016487658023834, 0.7669870257377625, 0.6338003277778625, 0.19592665135860443, 0.8141223192214966, -0.36086344718933105, 0.36185839772224426, 0.25749972462654114, -0.03813256695866585, 0.05563363805413246, -0.3564765155315399, -0.6238844990730286, -0.04874994605779648, 0.4914979338645935, 0.4312495291233063, -1.258846640586853, 0.9060271978378296, -0.2477470338344574, -0.6609698534011841, -0.25515681505203247, 0.34267276525497437, 0.17439866065979004, 0.44280779361724854, 0.4079296290874481, -0.7544528841972351, -0.42925938963890076, -0.4814709424972534, 0.2381259649991989, -0.34225088357925415, -0.1409224420785904, 0.12936383485794067, 0.6434813737869263, -0.45497676730155945, 0.622028648853302, -0.3008439242839813, -0.21431933343410492, 0.07140639424324036, 0.2563326358795166, -0.10334255546331406, 0.5750028491020203, 0.3340758979320526, -0.4989106059074402, -0.05893568694591522, 0.06728962808847427, -0.7652689218521118, 0.08421487361192703, -0.15153375267982483, -0.5608335733413696, 0.05855366215109825, 0.3117119371891022, -0.35834836959838867, -0.021237444132566452, 0.3333577513694763, 0.09377886354923248, 0.23608385026454926, -0.08975532650947571, -0.225241020321846, -0.9169796109199524, 0.10815434157848358, 0.24753953516483307, -0.0812455341219902, -0.5033481121063232, 0.3202664256095886, -0.11361006647348404, 0.19499064981937408, -0.24806466698646545, 0.4392322599887848, -0.31992945075035095, -0.15709367394447327, 0.09436357021331787, 0.32914087176322937, 0.0182678010314703, 0.49540162086486816, 0.2398364543914795, 0.37219884991645813, 0.7360975742340088, -1.3124079704284668, 0.34443020820617676, 0.23839080333709717, -0.6594571471214294, 0.44975894689559937, -0.09049597382545471, 0.1779581606388092, 0.06133277714252472, 0.4778757691383362, -0.6984613537788391, -0.40572357177734375, 0.1301712840795517, -0.06427270919084549, 0.12432972341775894, -0.056180283427238464, -0.7597975134849548, -0.5449506640434265, -0.2421523630619049, 0.3538321852684021, 0.5809606313705444, -1.1205819845199585, 0.3131084740161896, 0.5498619079589844, 0.310260146856308, -0.4729166626930237, -0.5751577615737915, 0.17224836349487305, -0.15400531888008118, -0.41335853934288025, 0.7486538887023926, 0.045790884643793106, -0.44594648480415344, -0.06932280212640762, -0.1608877331018448, -0.024189360439777374, 0.39105603098869324, -0.07323382049798965, -0.03770717233419418, -0.1356859803199768, 0.5701043605804443, 0.2564634382724762, 0.41811302304267883, 0.21376928687095642, -1.0049055814743042, 0.7042240500450134, 0.061885055154561996, -0.16716687381267548, -0.431812584400177, 0.2607422173023224, 0.6315969228744507, -0.11223039776086807, 0.5690688490867615, 0.2520442008972168, -0.49797460436820984, -0.8331155180931091, -0.41533762216567993, -0.3522113561630249, -0.4893784523010254, -0.10233728587627411, -0.3074010908603668, -0.6634856462478638, 0.33651313185691833, -0.30246755480766296, -0.15007995069026947, 0.5893871784210205, 0.20304074883460999, -0.018282882869243622, 1.0518677234649658, 0.3666836619377136, -0.25999772548675537, 0.3606549799442291, -0.4843437969684601, 0.2811512351036072, -0.8157641887664795, -0.2404504418373108, -0.4225434958934784, -0.12364722043275833, -0.9725326299667358, 0.10868142545223236, 0.2221796065568924, 0.12666115164756775, -0.5009922385215759, 0.46111223101615906, -1.019546389579773, 0.27066701650619507, 0.8038418292999268, 0.4396987557411194, 0.38524025678634644, 0.25928711891174316, -0.26889950037002563, 0.9179962277412415, -1.0615487098693848, -0.44124191999435425, 0.7827028036117554, 0.09430360049009323, 0.8019653558731079, 0.07616425305604935, 0.8919316530227661, 0.22743166983127594, 0.1311538964509964, -0.8745205998420715, 0.4239422678947449, -0.0647762268781662, -0.3689771890640259, -0.46598315238952637, -0.32772886753082275, -0.6588008999824524, 0.039100196212530136, -0.1269129067659378, -0.6686828136444092, 0.3092378079891205, 0.018596118316054344, -0.3718053698539734, 0.500289797782898, -0.35337865352630615, 0.3314186632633209, -0.15735340118408203, -0.5111827850341797, 0.06918761879205704, -0.7056584358215332, 0.5331392288208008, 0.027021532878279686, 0.17467088997364044, 0.345013827085495, 0.20714294910430908, 0.6724671721458435, -0.4554702341556549, 0.48901817202568054, 0.0871526449918747, -0.31669166684150696, 0.47005754709243774, 0.19729755818843842, 0.4484530985355377, 0.16088299453258514, -0.1536511927843094, -0.10195475816726685, -0.10711446404457092, -0.040753211826086044, -0.638027012348175, 0.8714441061019897, -0.6571672558784485, -0.5554101467132568, -0.3967975676059723, -0.15974919497966766, -0.20360268652439117, -0.06383746862411499, 0.3146452307701111, 0.7443195581436157, 0.2294311672449112, 0.06544552743434906, 0.8604162335395813, -0.11969146877527237, 0.3928879201412201, -0.2574947774410248, -0.5309733152389526, -0.2458258867263794, 0.984818696975708, 0.18278537690639496, 0.43602731823921204, 0.5350344181060791, 0.2681463062763214, -0.34132638573646545, -0.2366359531879425, -0.650699257850647, -0.0884229764342308, -0.8430407047271729, -0.18265976011753082, -0.7325338125228882, -0.5559412240982056, -0.3961261510848999, -0.2079300433397293, 0.049629729241132736, -0.5242373943328857, -0.04919459670782089, -0.2188989669084549, 0.3465286195278168, 0.8714516162872314, 0.007334218826144934, 0.19117727875709534, -0.37787339091300964, 0.12096518278121948, 0.5866109132766724, 0.6073805689811707, 0.43100568652153015, -0.300590842962265, -0.09958954155445099, -0.22913920879364014, -0.2140710949897766, -0.2835807204246521, 0.23331713676452637, 0.4889279305934906, 0.6082174181938171, 0.5782191157341003, 0.08197560161352158, 0.7458049654960632, -0.3826756477355957, 0.8417184948921204, 0.06605372577905655, -1.0837581157684326, 0.7537733912467957, -0.23151855170726776, 0.30655837059020996, 0.5475820302963257, 0.7339277267456055, -0.3985394835472107, -0.4670412838459015, -0.7067424058914185, -1.08808171749115, 0.47389551997184753, 0.19268415868282318, -0.09614522755146027, -0.3864852786064148, 0.5131354928016663, 0.24543464183807373, 0.35915371775627136, -0.5390104651451111, -0.3498855233192444, -0.22660593688488007, 0.08048765361309052, 0.039451371878385544, -0.1287921965122223, 0.027971675619482994, -0.6690115332603455, 0.8777007460594177, -0.09188040345907211, 0.1491057276725769, 0.28295421600341797, -0.4847201406955719, -0.25356152653694153, 0.04675937071442604, 0.41676124930381775, 0.9102282524108887, -0.22230195999145508, 0.5113059282302856, 0.05769691616296768, -0.16477493941783905, 0.11345686763525009, -0.5589043498039246, -0.163376584649086, 0.004789108410477638, 0.2626418173313141, 0.7916455268859863, 0.3130744397640228, -0.415996789932251, 0.16861818730831146, 0.3076856732368469, -0.38082143664360046, -0.1552373319864273, 0.253757119178772, -0.1609342396259308, -0.1753171682357788, 0.5944402813911438, -0.07810471206903458, 0.4323708713054657, -0.940388023853302, 0.5651752948760986, 0.20872662961483002, -0.14424322545528412, -0.04496540501713753, 0.41980859637260437, 0.1937294453382492, -0.27086618542671204, 0.7108758091926575, -0.3368460536003113, -0.6756063103675842, 0.4883590340614319, 0.6483830809593201, 0.784643828868866, -0.3339749276638031, 0.46307700872421265, 0.6209253668785095, 0.1769985556602478, -0.5559101104736328, -0.0529974140226841, -0.463971346616745, -0.740971565246582, -0.21665380895137787, -0.7660002708435059, -0.5525298714637756, 0.1435038149356842, -0.8153294324874878, 0.17168210446834564, -0.5836393237113953, 0.14253292977809906, 0.12817564606666565, -0.09825295954942703, -0.39050549268722534, 0.4594607651233673, 0.2129797637462616, 0.957370936870575, -0.6766600608825684, 0.8424109816551208, 0.604011058807373, -0.5457963943481445, -0.6539568901062012, -0.08614104986190796, -0.15919706225395203, -0.5394176244735718, 0.7934212684631348, 0.2713552415370941, -0.4138966202735901, 0.47350773215293884, -0.5934343934059143, -0.8853799104690552, 1.3203890323638916, -0.22826436161994934, -0.5974568128585815, -0.26217299699783325, -0.2084972858428955, 0.5159700512886047, -0.814293622970581, 0.2861287593841553, 0.5429525971412659, 0.2525333762168884, 0.29276856780052185, -0.7053136229515076, 0.14489375054836273, -0.17411109805107117, 0.387351393699646, 0.0751507580280304, -0.397510290145874, 0.7579799294471741, 0.28426593542099, -0.32595643401145935, -0.16969111561775208, 0.3137653172016144, 0.11253710091114044, 0.06784699857234955, 0.855414628982544, 0.5578516721725464, 1.0666183233261108, 0.09935703873634338, 0.896611213684082, -0.46387943625450134, 0.08985869586467743, 1.1293129920959473, -0.5668613314628601, 0.9324049353599548, 0.43026185035705566, 0.04648112133145332, 1.163313865661621, 0.9674999117851257, -0.06331887096166611, 0.730586051940918, 0.614214301109314, -0.37609201669692993, -0.24591916799545288, -0.1567857563495636, -0.2182878702878952, 0.3942398428916931, 0.383748859167099, -0.3343382179737091, -0.05870255082845688, 0.22094397246837616, -0.43935421109199524, 0.005842215847223997, -0.6092754006385803, 0.9967321753501892, 0.03877763822674751, -0.941594660282135, 0.5526924133300781, -0.3860154151916504, 0.6795371174812317, -0.32518240809440613, 0.012879465706646442, -0.011111750267446041, -0.039308249950408936, -0.38086190819740295, -0.5204903483390808, -0.011027009226381779, -0.3490927219390869, 0.004843694157898426, -0.2719874680042267, 0.6985335350036621, -0.48199349641799927, -0.40170976519584656, 0.511040449142456, 0.5255360007286072, 0.007243061903864145, -0.1474137008190155, -0.3246423602104187, -0.29024550318717957, -0.5982425212860107, -0.25401607155799866, 0.3327103853225708, 0.26551392674446106, -0.2704163193702698, 0.8787873983383179, 0.6865756511688232, -0.1248314306139946, -0.11545390635728836, 0.19282610714435577, 0.9034302830696106, -0.3811526596546173, -0.46976280212402344, -0.7225685715675354, 0.34045085310935974, -0.24199463427066803, -0.05891136825084686, 0.3900274634361267, 0.47099077701568604, 1.4687974452972412, 0.044195037335157394, 0.8253716826438904, -0.13034430146217346, 0.026629064232110977, -0.5860372185707092, 0.8809309005737305, -0.6790827512741089, 0.3570077121257782, -0.2725084722042084, -0.9944638609886169, -0.39724940061569214, 0.5691545605659485, 0.13260877132415771, -0.17218226194381714, 1.0321871042251587, 0.545633852481842, 0.03809685260057449, -0.0070432573556900024, 0.24451950192451477, 0.00288954796269536, -0.02140449546277523, 0.24349279701709747, 0.7326262593269348, -0.5399326682090759, 0.03508802503347397, -0.7058001756668091, -0.2107516974210739, -0.04990749806165695, -0.7995499968528748, -0.8517088890075684, -0.9335025548934937, -0.48835644125938416, -0.4351043403148651, 0.04682757705450058, 1.3246136903762817, 0.8447943925857544, -0.7860572934150696, -0.5456936359405518, -0.4050174951553345, 0.34639549255371094, -0.6844192147254944, -0.20140790939331055, 0.20182979106903076, -0.585152268409729, -0.435772567987442, 0.3209509253501892, 0.34327197074890137, -0.41847285628318787, -0.5196384787559509, 0.16600094735622406, -0.6733337640762329, -0.12735600769519806, 0.9799821376800537, -0.06747942417860031, -0.8299394845962524, -0.30354464054107666, -0.16638587415218353, -0.01744251511991024, 0.2146940976381302, 0.6345567107200623, -1.0687986612319946, 0.4099094867706299, 0.26399877667427063, 0.5895916819572449, 0.424069344997406, -0.16911591589450836, 0.38999107480049133, -0.775543212890625, -0.23681139945983887, 0.10540375858545303, 0.1686992049217224, 0.09350491315126419, -0.6098152995109558, 0.8004231452941895, 0.18789249658584595, -0.40318748354911804, -1.0251497030258179, 0.11609283089637756, -0.98093181848526, -0.24974597990512848, 1.034977674484253, 0.24880586564540863, -0.46289700269699097, -0.04903380945324898, 0.21190491318702698, 0.14148011803627014, -0.2936166822910309, 0.8992183208465576, 0.6757099032402039, 0.06362899392843246, -0.24667733907699585, -0.2812441289424896, 0.6216419339179993, -0.12328069657087326, -0.8823356628417969, -0.2053551822900772, 0.05785028636455536, 0.15796199440956116, 0.38324636220932007, 0.17793495953083038, 0.26292890310287476, 0.045868128538131714, -0.14864905178546906, -0.0017103665741160512, 0.24310357868671417, -0.5146062970161438, -0.0642295554280281, 0.22719798982143402, 0.060564830899238586, 0.12547667324543 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07383v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07383v2	Making Flow-Matching-Based Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Laugh as You Like	2024-02-12T02:58:10	2024-03-04T19:15:29	Naoyuki Kanda, Xiaofei Wang, Sefik Emre Eskimez, Manthan Thakker, Hemin Yang, Zirun Zhu, Min Tang, Canrun Li, Chung-Hsien Tsai, Zhen Xiao, Yufei Xia, Jinzhu Li, Yanqing Liu, Sheng Zhao, Michael Zeng	eess.AS	eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD	Laughter is one of the most expressive and natural aspects of human speech, conveying emotions, social cues, and humor. However, most text-to-speech (TTS) systems lack the ability to produce realistic and appropriate laughter sounds, limiting their applications and user experience. While there have been prior works to generate natural laughter, they fell short in terms of controlling the timing and variety of the laughter to be generated. In this work, we propose ELaTE, a zero-shot TTS that can generate natural laughing speech of any speaker based on a short audio prompt with precise control of laughter timing and expression. Specifically, ELaTE works on the audio prompt to mimic the voice characteristic, the text prompt to indicate the contents of the generated speech, and the input to control the laughter expression, which can be either the start and end times of laughter, or the additional audio prompt that contains laughter to be mimicked. We develop our model based on the foundation of conditional flow-matching-based zero-shot TTS, and fine-tune it with frame-level representation from a laughter detector as additional conditioning. With a simple scheme to mix small-scale laughter-conditioned data with large-scale pre-training data, we demonstrate that a pre-trained zero-shot TTS model can be readily fine-tuned to generate natural laughter with precise controllability, without losing any quality of the pre-trained zero-shot TTS model. Through objective and subjective evaluations, we show that ELaTE can generate laughing speech with significantly higher quality and controllability compared to conventional models. See https://aka.ms/elate/ for demo samples.	[ 0.060030899941921234, -0.6946074366569519, 0.5052974224090576, 0.4200553894042969, -0.7074408531188965, -0.054489798843860626, -0.17540833353996277, -0.48501482605934143, 0.8330651521682739, 0.4083119034767151, -0.6208925843238831, -0.47870996594429016, -0.23294442892074585, 0.1985597014427185, -0.6887072324752808, 0.9404193162918091, 0.4839541018009186, -0.5433820486068726, 0.13982805609703064, -0.13044394552707672, -0.4563836455345154, -0.22048215568065643, -0.6632459759712219, -0.35095158219337463, 0.6756316423416138, 0.4971937835216522, 0.541011393070221, 0.3823815584182739, -0.10789264738559723, 0.22217682003974915, -0.11823765933513641, 0.04428301006555557, -0.4016706347465515, 0.4141824245452881, -0.057081438601017, -0.47112637758255005, -0.46277284622192383, -0.4888957142829895, 0.21588239073753357, 0.061181068420410156, -0.5318449139595032, -0.07921843230724335, -0.1833474487066269, 0.3415316939353943, -0.6218312978744507, -0.3771243691444397, -0.8710399270057678, 0.2110823690891266, -0.08289475739002228, -0.6142435669898987, -0.47931331396102905, -0.4499290883541107, 0.10575350373983383, -0.4104069173336029, -0.26905557513237, -0.02222796157002449, 0.8259229063987732, 0.5997985005378723, -0.17505963146686554, -0.42124664783477783, -0.8837836384773254, 0.39499539136886597, -0.9666061997413635, 0.28696903586387634, -0.05094429478049278, 0.3394552171230316, 0.14707498252391815, -0.6725636124610901, -0.7374471426010132, -0.149659663438797, 0.2648026645183563, 0.24915647506713867, -0.08348304033279419, -0.11242398619651794, -0.0750293880701065, 0.10114838927984238, -0.8742026686668396, -0.09506375342607498, 0.12091279029846191, 0.05059391260147095, 0.5540745258331299, 0.03703133016824722, 0.47727546095848083, -0.13221363723278046, -0.05613704025745392, 0.030546927824616432, -0.47108137607574463, -0.1685076653957367, 0.4300442934036255, 0.5504088997840881, -0.1994595229625702, 0.8326643109321594, -0.2353123277425766, 0.4210853576660156, 0.034413620829582214, -0.11043387651443481, 0.4841177761554718, 0.1528855264186859, -0.5793318152427673, 0.34944644570350647, 0.8086749911308289, 0.37398844957351685, 0.7397060394287109, -0.04797569662332535, -0.17724783718585968, 0.108425572514534, 0.1527029275894165, -0.772749125957489, -0.00784026738256216, 0.46627601981163025, 0.2823253870010376, -0.5317670702934265, -0.26414942741394043, -0.7589172124862671, -0.11746758967638016, -0.24997857213020325, 0.6467530131340027, -0.6752648949623108, -0.12598051130771637, 0.3521828353404999, -0.20837368071079254, 0.14194665849208832, 0.3757234215736389, -0.5266964435577393, 0.021949714049696922, 0.35505950450897217, 1.0153183937072754, 0.11600440740585327, -0.009900609962642193, -0.7739846110343933, 0.019702961668372154, -0.3410329818725586, 0.7192789912223816, -0.3932708501815796, -0.253007173538208, 0.23453295230865479, -0.219610795378685, 0.020380498841404915, -0.46794697642326355, 0.725172758102417, -0.40196406841278076, 0.30066749453544617, 0.34126177430152893, -0.6219977736473083, 0.22349606454372406, 0.13196711242198944, -0.24755185842514038, 0.6333303451538086, -0.11452563107013702, -0.6092024445533752, 0.2717633545398712, -0.6244620084762573, -0.750400185585022, 0.30633994936943054, 0.08131365478038788, -0.27285313606262207, 0.08269452303647995, 0.04992016404867172, 0.10859164595603943, 0.15243904292583466, -0.05174371227622032, -0.19997817277908325, -0.4106684625148773, 0.1520911306142807, -0.3937564492225647, 0.6447391510009766, 0.4201655089855194, -0.5709680318832397, -0.16830073297023773, -0.6835153698921204, 0.28947779536247253, 0.29313185811042786, 0.07394403219223022, -0.08534321933984756, 0.10681135207414627, -0.018769677728414536, 0.194472536444664, 0.018683478236198425, -0.5776191353797913, -0.3416219651699066, -0.8444119691848755, 0.4784184694290161, 0.4218456745147705, 0.20129649341106415, 0.3225371837615967, -0.4785822033882141, 0.5394638776779175, -0.07034477591514587, -0.1955299973487854, -0.7054027318954468, -0.5563145279884338, -0.6707993149757385, -0.4069705903530121, -0.009044411592185497, 1.0717449188232422, -0.8258262276649475, 0.4740042984485626, -0.08655141294002533, -0.47041264176368713, -0.557339608669281, -0.234501913189888, 0.18112045526504517, 0.7200083136558533, 0.47891926765441895, -0.24985118210315704, -0.3630983531475067, -0.38624435663223267, -0.2616572082042694, -0.11045630276203156, -0.29242604970932007, 0.48068901896476746, 0.008680649101734161, 0.267630934715271, 0.8198293447494507, -0.3022114038467407, -0.39845097064971924, -0.08576520532369614, 0.46750178933143616, 0.31608444452285767, 0.18304280936717987, 0.8848123550415039, -0.4903305470943451, -0.8301646113395691, 0.14596477150917053, -0.5137149691581726, -0.6842177510261536, -0.20364761352539062, -0.012973655015230179, 0.29456204175949097, 0.0908522978425026, -0.4452913999557495, 0.46908512711524963, 0.40611764788627625, -0.45678868889808655, 0.5794523358345032, -0.0832805410027504, 0.5496822595596313, -0.8503332138061523, 0.1255296766757965, -0.1861814707517624, -0.540452778339386, -0.7538549900054932, -0.2063925713300705, -0.30021044611930847, -0.3625689446926117, -1.092759132385254, 0.681058943271637, -0.03455013781785965, 0.13648070394992828, -0.32990625500679016, 0.24460361897945404, -0.01168424915522337, 0.47379910945892334, 0.15506941080093384, 0.5888816714286804, 0.7322225570678711, -0.5282411575317383, 0.2297084629535675, 0.20312118530273438, 0.13096371293067932, 1.0783082246780396, -0.8936607837677002, 0.29730337858200073, -0.104126937687397, 0.0020341016352176666, -0.7827106714248657, -0.3538859188556671, 0.04264364764094353, -0.8588604927062988, 0.22775135934352875, -0.028730470687150955, -0.38325342535972595, -0.2017032355070114, -0.35230785608291626, 0.14369139075279236, 1.0170490741729736, -0.5850735902786255, 0.39471033215522766, 0.01638820953667164, -0.5825508832931519, -0.38202548027038574, -0.7624891400337219, 0.25386592745780945, -0.4205242991447449, -0.8085846900939941, 0.6579868197441101, -0.42241695523262024, 0.24136564135551453, 0.05666966363787651, 0.19622769951820374, -0.2164536416530609, -0.24978451430797577, 0.1506354808807373, 0.10733639448881149, -0.2876185476779938, -0.14555548131465912, 0.19907844066619873, 0.163282573223114, -0.2996973693370819, -0.2393491566181183, 0.5758152604103088, 0.1968972086906433, -0.5886258482933044, -0.8181316256523132, 0.30685052275657654, 0.6694711446762085, -0.05399515852332115, 0.3802505135536194, 0.35273128747940063, -0.4807281196117401, -0.3297223150730133, -0.31612738966941833, -0.1784900426864624, -0.5052604079246521, 0.1447298228740692, 0.05858134850859642, -0.9359774589538574, 0.3694111704826355, 0.3045210838317871, 0.04370572417974472, 0.09519562125205994, 0.6047959327697754, -0.3486718237400055, 0.7909263968467712, 0.24970391392707825, 0.16815470159053802, 0.6288327574729919, 0.18925169110298157, 0.13349907100200653, -0.27888059616088867, -0.012170596979558468, -0.5532928109169006, -0.3785068988800049, -0.12387944012880325, -0.30873435735702515, 0.015201645903289318, -0.17102091014385223, -0.44451382756233215, 0.4683482050895691, -0.4970061480998993, 0.5260018110275269, 0.3162480890750885, -0.2252112776041031, 0.17870745062828064, -0.12048453092575073, -0.31171146035194397, -0.18562772870063782, -0.4455043077468872, -0.49825412034988403, 0.5977562665939331, 0.10553379356861115, 0.6342107653617859, 0.036944881081581116, 1.0515202283859253, 0.3680333197116852, 0.15198390185832977, -0.7350835204124451, 0.4306713342666626, -0.3046343922615051, -0.3904779851436615, -0.2354884147644043, -0.42702123522758484, -0.5474042892456055, -0.4223923981189728, -0.3363416790962219, -1.084997296333313, -0.09322354197502136, 0.5128942131996155, -0.5008357763290405, 0.2301873415708542, -0.8079640865325928, 0.5301390886306763, -0.08493264019489288, -0.29470011591911316, 0.12622623145580292, -0.6289600133895874, 0.35944151878356934, 0.05505757033824921, 0.1695294827222824, -0.11536319553852081, 0.2729772627353668, 0.2985183894634247, -0.3329029679298401, 0.628251850605011, -0.11035919934511185, 0.1443994641304016, 0.7930442690849304, 0.5215198397636414, 0.28149914741516113, -0.03385711461305618, -0.2081148773431778, -0.060903072357177734, -0.15862435102462769, -0.16543656587600708, -0.6335500478744507, 0.6398042440414429, -0.3720609247684479, -0.2525634467601776, -0.05450540781021118, -0.04097851365804672, 0.1044342890381813, 0.026915790513157845, 0.3672562539577484, 0.32710492610931396, -0.23306116461753845, 0.2980526387691498, 0.24889391660690308, -0.28445690870285034, 0.7269029021263123, 0.2551538348197937, -0.16694776713848114, -0.6924741268157959, 0.9378136396408081, -0.027996094897389412, 0.25215473771095276, 0.5807019472122192, -0.04685268923640251, -0.6253871321678162, 0.059771161526441574, -0.4511054456233978, 0.3262139558792114, -0.23971733450889587, -0.3824128210544586, -0.5379178524017334, -0.5211659073829651, -0.3080439269542694, -0.5554962754249573, -0.5344507694244385, -0.5118194818496704, -0.5690651535987854, 0.01978791505098343, 0.4212225079536438, 0.40773898363113403, -0.09778360277414322, 0.4663781225681305, -0.8386278748512268, 0.26151320338249207, 0.6102407574653625, 0.38183948397636414, -0.09367930889129639, -0.9033453464508057, 0.12701940536499023, -0.10725698620080948, -0.5185683965682983, -1.2503377199172974, 0.7785407900810242, 0.7773094773292542, -0.04867849498987198, 0.3755911886692047, 0.3220668137073517, 0.6904309391975403, -1.0505123138427734, 0.8734862804412842, 0.4467552602291107, -1.1450071334838867, 0.7074466943740845, -0.20407143235206604, -0.07104234397411346, 0.22435252368450165, -0.06021295487880707, -0.5481579303741455, -0.6362175941467285, -0.787463903427124, -0.8246012330055237, 0.5402333736419678, 0.6951759457588196, 0.5710386037826538, -0.37110021710395813, 0.2802560329437256, -0.3446106016635895, 0.25245532393455505, -0.6210852265357971, -0.17582908272743225, -0.4848555326461792, -0.5742494463920593, 0.3366132974624634, 0.0968531146645546, 0.04051287844777107, 0.22191625833511353, 0.6469156742095947, -0.14323194324970245, 0.528133749961853, 0.4315820634365082, -0.0626014694571495, -0.44258350133895874, 0.48401394486427307, 0.9084526896476746, -0.09764666855335236, -0.4672476053237915, 0.15821056067943573, 0.21844828128814697, -0.29493439197540283, 0.18194922804832458, -0.17280469834804535, -0.09522958099842072, 0.3836265206336975, 0.1479129195213318, 0.9117608070373535, 0.1398453563451767, -1.0237712860107422, 0.7309458255767822, 0.07556415349245071, -0.3843194842338562, -0.2389494925737381, 0.33416101336479187, 0.20513319969177246, 0.20206721127033234, 0.2825789451599121, -0.12486067414283752, -0.055329177528619766, -0.5462237596511841, 0.5762554407119751, 0.23759417235851288, -0.4357728362083435, -0.6221981048583984, 1.2009984254837036, 0.30531010031700134, -1.028278112411499, 0.28426605463027954, -0.6164178252220154, -0.5021750926971436, 0.5424296855926514, 0.8042158484458923, 1.144453763961792, -0.25304463505744934, 0.4635169208049774, 0.4339366555213928, 0.10480702668428421, 0.3387369215488434, 0.49760890007019043, 0.15308330953121185, -0.6297087669372559, -0.6418808698654175, -0.5466957688331604, -0.5688014626502991, 0.06647229939699173, -0.3284667730331421, 0.7897777557373047, -0.3467247486114502, -0.1717686653137207, -0.22548764944076538, -0.4336296617984772, -0.5594497919082642, 0.5020172595977783, 0.5962464809417725, 0.8887655735015869, -0.8749876618385315, 0.6081834435462952, 0.3825792372226715, -0.2223249226808548, -0.7167503237724304, -0.06428562104701996, -0.006815578322857618, -0.7178618311882019, 0.12909696996212006, 0.16275441646575928, -0.2613350450992584, 0.20821420848369598, -0.5099506378173828, -0.2123069316148758, 1.1138520240783691, 0.6095836758613586, -0.5207885503768921, 0.014645964838564396, -0.014251340180635452, 0.6533966660499573, -0.5910364389419556, 0.5048667192459106, 0.2811489701271057, 0.0728929340839386, 0.9548603892326355, -0.9259573221206665, -0.30700868368148804, -0.15406109392642975, -0.38200488686561584, 0.07317209988832474, -0.2248237282037735, 0.5603939294815063, -0.3799546957015991, -0.33639833331108093, 0.14897240698337555, 0.658855676651001, 0.5547910332679749, 0.6802200078964233, 0.6715448498725891, 0.8088060021400452, 0.48915621638298035, 0.1304461508989334, 0.49242332577705383, -0.32846400141716003, 0.3616216480731964, 1.527988076210022, -0.7085405588150024, 1.139317512512207, 0.2966272532939911, 0.09756766259670258, 0.6708686351776123, 0.2963350713253021, 0.5181488394737244, 0.6181761026382446, -0.02300550416111946, -0.2711595594882965, -0.03969476372003555, -0.24297377467155457, -0.09362281858921051, 0.2084919959306717, 0.31862306594848633, -0.1693287491798401, -0.14661970734596252, -0.25600579380989075, -0.05685241147875786, 0.13721570372581482, 0.01950787752866745, 0.6595533490180969, 0.12583769857883453, -0.41077128052711487, 0.3913790285587311, -0.39223408699035645, 0.7811952829360962, -0.36363667249679565, -0.07689695805311203, -0.18881192803382874, -0.5356870293617249, -0.14250652492046356, -0.923059344291687, 0.5642608404159546, 0.5798535943031311, 0.41064000129699707, 0.08258283138275146, 0.5847511291503906, -0.5092338919639587, -0.13026152551174164, 0.3973260819911957, 0.4393279552459717, 0.19426840543746948, -0.19104620814323425, -0.5680860280990601, -0.2757490575313568, -0.009428262710571289, -0.2844962775707245, -0.11392354220151901, 0.9736028909683228, 0.36689063906669617, 0.4170665144920349, 0.5286857485771179, 0.376344233751297, 0.1895817369222641, 0.4007893204689026, 0.5212535262107849, -0.7607637047767639, -0.7024684548377991, -0.8797162771224976, 0.9904923439025879, -0.17227865755558014, -0.2632487118244171, 0.013629463501274586, 0.2505260109901428, 0.3071536719799042, -0.06244692578911781, 0.4244680404663086, -0.2630739212036133, 0.6927539706230164, -0.24915574491024017, 0.7675628662109375, -0.9323840141296387, -0.1487657129764557, -0.5401691198348999, -0.8878249526023865, -0.4650927782058716, 0.5296497941017151, 0.3108896315097809, -0.08125600218772888, 0.6019081473350525, 0.8120673298835754, -0.00612039165571332, -0.1336512267589569, 0.896125853061676, 0.16601133346557617, 0.28051698207855225, 0.47390216588974, 0.5739296078681946, -0.18764466047286987, 0.6877382397651672, -0.148169606924057, -0.18351411819458008, -0.4778725206851959, -1.4312938451766968, -0.6673521399497986, -0.36162254214286804, -0.5486629605293274, -0.062237970530986786, -0.1397530436515808, 1.0572991371154785, 0.7641860246658325, -0.6297696828842163, 0.13139501214027405, -0.06122666224837303, 0.010969962924718857, 0.17125143110752106, -0.2893359065055847, -0.20704835653305054, -0.35397467017173767, -0.8291335105895996, 0.5089269280433655, 0.7466650009155273, 0.41197067499160767, 0.34306600689888, -0.26578468084335327, -0.0027397992089390755, 0.9084177017211914, 0.6037787795066833, 0.6687079071998596, -0.414407879114151, -0.6906629204750061, 0.4043957591056824, 0.05060600861907005, 0.13734553754329681, 0.2689704895019531, -0.5794473886489868, 0.4230853021144867, 0.3512125313282013, 0.5424168109893799, 0.42641782760620117, -0.1574135422706604, 0.362492173910141, -1.1425782442092896, 0.2501085698604584, 0.5577056407928467, 0.2718869745731354, 0.4681720435619354, -0.31891658902168274, 0.3029893934726715, 0.20945978164672852, -0.7360271215438843, -0.8556302785873413, 0.2086857110261917, -1.270135521888733, 0.2783612310886383, 0.8032899498939514, -0.175126314163208, -0.31234875321388245, 0.25599420070648193, -0.29420655965805054, 0.4713599383831024, -0.5111528038978577, 0.6612733602523804, 0.3649437725543976, -0.20115944743156433, -0.19830675423145294, -0.382137656211853, 0.2248651683330536, 0.6234201788902283, -0.7398456931114197, -0.2567870616912842, 0.14105015993118286, 0.21846653521060944, 0.21008196473121643, 0.8466306328773499, 0.12031286954879761, 0.3427463173866272, -0.24463370442390442, 0.1756075918674469, 0.3213949203491211, -0.5392601490020752, -0.2921426296234131, 0.14046047627925873, 0.034403204917907715, -0.1764630526304245 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07368v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07368v1	Assessing Generalization for Subpopulation Representative Modeling via In-Context Learning	2024-02-12T01:55:51	2024-02-12T01:55:51	Gabriel Simmons, Vladislav Savinov	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY	This study evaluates the ability of Large Language Model (LLM)-based Subpopulation Representative Models (SRMs) to generalize from empirical data, utilizing in-context learning with data from the 2016 and 2020 American National Election Studies. We explore generalization across response variables and demographic subgroups. While conditioning with empirical data improves performance on the whole, the benefit of in-context learning varies considerably across demographics, sometimes hurting performance for one demographic while helping performance for others. The inequitable benefits of in-context learning for SRM present a challenge for practitioners implementing SRMs, and for decision-makers who might come to rely on them. Our work highlights a need for fine-grained benchmarks captured from diverse subpopulations that test not only fidelity but generalization.	[ -0.3475949764251709, -0.63460773229599, 0.34028759598731995, 0.11235780268907547, -0.4089186489582062, 0.00810124259442091, -0.4807484447956085, -0.23554621636867523, -0.10648100078105927, 0.5216052532196045, -0.34077510237693787, -0.6702742576599121, -0.4725312888622284, 0.10972508788108826, -0.2968055009841919, 0.6978113055229187, 0.27667713165283203, 0.3202855885028839, -0.8450254797935486, -0.03201868385076523, -0.4082646369934082, -0.8751980066299438, -0.44649365544319153, -0.45970362424850464, 0.21430717408657074, 0.6478710770606995, 0.25503480434417725, 0.3792059123516083, 0.5090046525001526, 0.19773335754871368, 0.12182872742414474, -0.11187911778688431, -0.9948585629463196, -0.1789093166589737, -0.27381381392478943, -0.4368673264980316, -0.12381479889154434, 0.36626723408699036, 0.9413300156593323, 0.9614667296409607, -0.3264209032058716, 0.2897200882434845, 0.02018226683139801, 0.5693937540054321, -0.6737614870071411, 0.11525880545377731, -1.1356464624404907, -0.057443585246801376, -0.02851422317326069, -0.3050345182418823, -0.5645512938499451, -0.5586810111999512, 0.5623217225074768, -0.24599479138851166, 0.5862597823143005, 0.23104052245616913, 0.5132856965065002, 0.13952888548374176, -0.7657455205917358, -0.23337946832180023, -0.6073474884033203, 1.0087841749191284, -0.5123439431190491, 0.3676660656929016, 0.5386860966682434, 0.40520623326301575, -0.4936215579509735, -0.6738936305046082, 0.04596913978457451, -0.3657839596271515, -0.05870774760842323, 0.33150607347488403, -0.0013277361867949367, -0.09298355877399445, 0.1419970840215683, 0.39755305647850037, -0.32323187589645386, 0.008289274759590626, -0.3484340012073517, 0.09055785089731216, 0.6527507305145264, 0.21159687638282776, 0.24010992050170898, -0.02043505571782589, -0.5832367539405823, -0.05092122405767441, -0.71616131067276, 0.19508062303066254, 0.5108425617218018, 0.6778170466423035, -0.36174386739730835, 0.37555935978889465, -0.20594806969165802, 0.575423538684845, -0.06729136407375336, 0.2311275154352188, 0.23053842782974243, -0.5677359104156494, -0.3760223686695099, -0.27559760212898254, 0.566215455532074, 0.39675208926200867, 0.5180849432945251, -0.19671522080898285, -0.023199742659926414, -0.1399182230234146, 0.060708533972501755, -0.7521011233329773, 0.17347891628742218, -0.03349107876420021, -0.6465595960617065, 0.03785378113389015, 0.22626399993896484, -0.9392826557159424, -0.194024458527565, -0.5967311263084412, -0.1309354305267334, -0.2578771710395813, -0.17524047195911407, -0.09050528705120087, -0.19341616332530975, 0.4197414219379425, 0.28911593556404114, -0.9592828154563904, 0.5099307298660278, 0.7058425545692444, 0.7066857814788818, -0.40736693143844604, 0.01167925912886858, -0.39987385272979736, -0.08492563664913177, -0.5761387348175049, 0.7183998823165894, -1.0499762296676636, -0.6272082924842834, 0.014303097501397133, -0.12259998172521591, -0.46755191683769226, -1.2691220045089722, 0.14913560450077057, -0.5663256645202637, 0.21250425279140472, -0.2597845196723938, -0.6935353875160217, 0.06395154446363449, 0.15812259912490845, -0.46342459321022034, 0.9446300864219666, 0.5202612280845642, -0.4083726704120636, 0.7422580718994141, -0.2968812882900238, -0.03940361365675926, 0.006320587825030088, -0.35598844289779663, -0.3794442415237427, 0.4959145784378052, 0.12393660843372345, 0.43958142399787903, -0.14647449553012848, 0.2918528616428375, -0.4026273488998413, -0.4875291585922241, 0.11992943286895752, -0.11097998172044754, 0.42521655559539795, -0.15696242451667786, 0.09196838736534119, 0.1707383543252945, -0.42542141675949097, -0.3165300488471985, -0.17320075631141663, -0.3624880909919739, -0.5479730367660522, 0.0363193117082119, -0.005715326871722937, -0.037366803735494614, 0.07804100215435028, -0.5853847861289978, 0.25511032342910767, -0.12074568122625351, 0.1192592903971672, 0.6843138337135315, 0.12280461192131042, 0.7323933243751526, -0.15969900786876678, 0.7112058401107788, 0.08628294616937637, -0.001520395278930664, 0.1135769858956337, -0.3145993947982788, -0.2977486550807953, -0.31073740124702454, 0.7768878936767578, 0.4724816083908081, -0.6308422088623047, 0.12182138115167618, -0.35040995478630066, -0.26477912068367004, 0.1935884952545166, -0.06351713091135025, 0.2149684578180313, 0.55665123462677, 0.35728463530540466, -0.46495845913887024, -0.7057090997695923, -1.027949571609497, -0.3150923550128937, -0.158151313662529, -0.2039564698934555, 0.6145570278167725, 0.8799256682395935, -0.3066231608390808, 1.0325566530227661, -0.11489507555961609, -0.2665081024169922, -0.4302533268928528, 0.03277231752872467, -0.14757470786571503, 0.49542224407196045, 0.6390342116355896, -0.6661356687545776, -0.5168462991714478, 0.05877166613936424, -0.4569036364555359, -0.19226330518722534, 0.2230171263217926, 0.017449935898184776, 0.08769454807043076, 0.5176880359649658, -0.049095749855041504, 0.5901747345924377, 0.7640061974525452, -0.23509913682937622, 0.48032769560813904, -0.03548603132367134, 0.2215554565191269, -0.7421371936798096, -0.19193147122859955, 0.37111952900886536, -0.2525235116481781, -0.3575773537158966, -0.08820131421089172, 0.07376129925251007, 0.20558123290538788, -0.4290654957294464, 0.4059045612812042, -0.3188447952270508, -0.4520808458328247, -0.0034089453984051943, -0.06581079214811325, -0.6208945512771606, -0.01303768064826727, 0.16162413358688354, 0.9954422116279602, 0.09843089431524277, -0.4032813012599945, 0.0943211242556572, -0.12475569546222687, -0.6656031012535095, 0.529102087020874, -0.6051726341247559, 0.16224151849746704, -0.5232297778129578, 0.7401857972145081, -1.1296851634979248, -0.6731548309326172, -0.10953441262245178, -0.41854602098464966, 0.023230133578181267, -0.23402847349643707, -0.08473431318998337, -0.007576577831059694, 0.047341350466012955, 0.49829748272895813, 0.5039771199226379, -0.26981452107429504, 0.7297662496566772, 0.48847103118896484, -0.08490578830242157, -0.3629714846611023, -0.4650789499282837, -0.09502614289522171, -0.6036382913589478, -0.23419135808944702, 0.2280302494764328, 0.19932042062282562, -0.5616737604141235, -0.07524771243333817, 0.0072869504801929, -0.0631641149520874, -0.11646255850791931, -0.05652634799480438, 0.06233740970492363, -0.03771679103374481, 0.2363050878047943, -0.23763155937194824, -0.12608537077903748, -0.07149223983287811, 0.14154894649982452, 0.5862897634506226, -0.01797911338508129, -0.3117372393608093, -0.1878282129764557, 0.32624170184135437, 0.3209920823574066, -0.09478488564491272, 0.7040241956710815, 0.2267162948846817, -0.45656850934028625, -0.3228469491004944, -0.4591466784477234, -0.24935469031333923, -0.31543806195259094, 0.6804955005645752, -0.26943114399909973, -1.096035361289978, 0.7476758360862732, -0.3435326814651489, 0.13485872745513916, 0.19425298273563385, 0.5294162034988403, 0.17979001998901367, 0.943840742111206, 0.5879359245300293, 0.06634774804115295, 0.6517022848129272, -0.28880640864372253, -0.2413867861032486, -1.0312795639038086, -0.4972027838230133, -0.6026011109352112, -0.36733996868133545, -0.40201109647750854, -0.6777165532112122, 0.2814350128173828, -0.06811931729316711, -0.23242288827896118, 0.035093411803245544, -0.19681353867053986, 0.6300169825553894, 0.49654465913772583, 0.12938374280929565, 0.23831024765968323, 0.21136508882045746, -0.01849488727748394, -0.4534774124622345, -0.5206264853477478, -0.6718516945838928, 1.3084877729415894, 0.36694076657295227, 0.871161699295044, 0.10173692554235458, 0.5563697814941406, 0.3334932029247284, 1.036374568939209, -0.7190830707550049, 0.430186003446579, -0.5496585965156555, -0.4124557673931122, -0.3636423349380493, -0.8549013733863831, -1.0182209014892578, 0.7905369400978088, -0.06422543525695801, -0.6780903935432434, 0.4868602454662323, 0.12697382271289825, -0.2430064082145691, 0.07168347388505936, -0.6818552613258362, 0.6274445056915283, -0.05301868915557861, -0.010795453563332558, -0.13527531921863556, -0.4610319435596466, 0.5279058814048767, -0.09573429077863693, 0.354411244392395, -0.37981462478637695, -0.45065978169441223, 0.6252365708351135, 0.030108435079455376, 0.9248678684234619, -0.29681116342544556, 0.08835441619157791, -0.057861004024744034, -0.48358628153800964, 0.2812720239162445, 0.12155957520008087, -0.3580649197101593, 0.13448868691921234, -0.10701604187488556, -0.4738233685493469, -0.5912571549415588, 0.4610252380371094, -0.7647260427474976, -0.4951818287372589, -0.33186274766921997, -0.6696423888206482, -0.5478769540786743, -0.3029346168041229, 0.32990267872810364, 0.5100003480911255, -0.6365184783935547, 1.0008307695388794, 0.7603566646575928, -0.1689634770154953, 0.024042634293437004, 0.48438549041748047, -0.3654850721359253, -0.5640249848365784, 0.5110581517219543, 0.40259647369384766, 0.4566766917705536, 0.20074859261512756, 0.46021386981010437, -0.6219069957733154, -0.5276651978492737, -0.3451688587665558, -0.0226252730935812, -0.5001201033592224, 0.1258092224597931, -0.3963313400745392, 0.008463623933494091, -0.3887188136577606, 0.13729557394981384, -0.12932583689689636, 0.03711444512009621, -0.33643537759780884, -0.07311397045850754, -0.28975412249565125, 0.8600602746009827, 0.15887291729450226, 0.2609860599040985, -0.23262761533260345, 0.16540084779262543, 0.5112394690513611, 0.07704108208417892, 0.058288369327783585, -0.8081216216087341, -0.22312301397323608, 0.04932733625173569, -0.10692069679498672, -0.732109785079956, 0.11315881460905075, 0.35354650020599365, 0.9366565346717834, 0.08723608404397964, 0.15075941383838654, 0.8223075270652771, -0.41905468702316284, 0.8958621621131897, -0.05319724231958389, -0.6934105157852173, 0.3133327066898346, -0.380893349647522, 0.29547742009162903, 0.6843081116676331, 0.2531416416168213, -0.3642946183681488, -0.3487049341201782, -0.4917547106742859, -0.8966382741928101, 0.44420939683914185, -0.06886059790849686, 0.5100523233413696, -0.007461582310497761, 0.4778701663017273, 0.12236182391643524, 0.283810555934906, -0.5142630338668823, -0.07719580084085464, 0.009481280110776424, -0.1744643747806549, -0.22308629751205444, -0.32983383536338806, -0.12932871282100677, -0.40106675028800964, 0.36454859375953674, -0.3212580382823944, -0.1917647421360016, 0.27183079719543457, 0.127310648560524, -0.2775227427482605, 0.3436136543750763, 0.7613359093666077, 1.1046496629714966, -0.3370510935783386, 0.012115049175918102, 0.5337498188018799, -0.2655637860298157, 0.28642982244491577, -0.13167224824428558, -0.19113831222057343, -0.1802203506231308, 0.6531670093536377, 0.579397439956665, 0.39144209027290344, -0.46964484453201294, 0.4392451345920563, -0.4149465560913086, -0.3537404239177704, -0.2593860328197479, -0.04108729213476181, 0.08093205094337463, -0.0004335167759563774, 0.8146010041236877, -0.18793219327926636, -0.006560465786606073, -0.7733991742134094, 0.24985508620738983, 0.7962245941162109, -0.5358843207359314, -0.2578020989894867, 0.5088366270065308, 0.23598642647266388, 0.005015745759010315, 0.554646909236908, 0.2069171965122223, -0.2787981629371643, 1.1266744136810303, 0.8065290451049805, 0.6382084488868713, -0.32583728432655334, 0.003962274175137281, 0.47334572672843933, 0.4304961860179901, 0.05221642181277275, 0.03415139019489288, 0.10628237575292587, -0.7028448581695557, -0.36407652497291565, -0.3912949562072754, -0.7232224345207214, 0.3438374698162079, -0.8786207437515259, -0.134365051984787, -0.3890549838542938, -0.4764203131198883, -0.40129005908966064, -0.005354274529963732, -0.6727915406227112, 0.3625369071960449, 0.016073541715741158, 1.1379996538162231, -1.0663487911224365, 0.3797900080680847, 1.002105712890625, -0.0003638741618487984, -0.46184876561164856, 0.3857845962047577, -0.24120189249515533, -0.6159456372261047, 0.6740772724151611, 0.20640884339809418, 0.12290609627962112, -0.08496066182851791, -0.9102025628089905, -0.898591935634613, 0.8837260603904724, 0.5985164046287537, -0.5516259670257568, 0.2722485065460205, 0.18752489984035492, 0.5910056233406067, -1.0511950254440308, 0.3663935661315918, 0.6716463565826416, 0.2914700210094452, 0.0036985778715461493, -0.7857520580291748, -0.28561893105506897, 0.15430329740047455, 0.5603881478309631, -0.09348856657743454, -0.9351701736450195, 0.8323020935058594, 0.15755847096443176, -0.29345181584358215, -0.04167996719479561, 0.9463978409767151, 0.6416100263595581, 0.43272343277931213, 0.6820744276046753, 0.5937357544898987, 0.5606505870819092, -0.2570483684539795, 0.9949467182159424, -0.08837869763374329, 0.5378612279891968, 1.1443886756896973, -0.26288408041000366, 0.8973585367202759, 0.50206059217453, -0.39323490858078003, 0.7708362340927124, 0.8394784331321716, 0.42653772234916687, 0.550476610660553, 0.5585721135139465, -0.3324986398220062, -0.5716726183891296, -0.3933931589126587, -0.6085777878761292, 0.35973045229911804, 0.45531728863716125, -0.3814789056777954, -0.41784802079200745, -0.06662509590387344, -0.4074845314025879, 0.41174718737602234, -0.32543590664863586, 0.6692805290222168, 0.316417396068573, -0.5604409575462341, 0.1586718112230301, -0.3216645121574402, 0.5980327725410461, -0.6448176503181458, -0.24816681444644928, -0.3473985493183136, 0.0652935802936554, -0.19560666382312775, -0.571291983127594, 0.2924742102622986, -0.10680142045021057, -0.40842732787132263, 0.00024362382828257978, 0.5739710330963135, -0.6708669662475586, -0.6429811120033264, 0.48765021562576294, 0.47978535294532776, 0.1312277913093567, 0.2630726993083954, -0.4108983874320984, 0.18568888306617737, -0.0826508030295372, -0.41604888439178467, 0.5287156701087952, 0.2236221432685852, -0.3510109782218933, 0.7562330365180969, 0.756865918636322, 0.24356059730052948, 0.021672844886779785, 0.378816157579422, 0.548889696598053, -0.3413320779800415, -0.2608736753463745, -0.776119589805603, 0.41571828722953796, -0.21581777930259705, -0.3709583580493927, 0.9454548358917236, 0.7960755825042725, 1.2240796089172363, -0.19006122648715973, 0.9707189798355103, 0.07097966223955154, 0.6833811402320862, -0.3248450756072998, 0.19692622125148773, -0.5187936425209045, 0.11309634894132614, 0.04890467971563339, -0.8389557003974915, -0.18478427827358246, 0.5740393996238708, -0.8801698088645935, 0.34401336312294006, 0.2058546096086502, 0.6095804572105408, -0.19929109513759613, -0.2750178277492523, 0.5448615550994873, -0.2575584053993225, 0.0926486998796463, 0.35555747151374817, 1.0807856321334839, -0.11382801830768585, 0.2267294079065323, -0.21599756181240082, -0.5791585445404053, -0.19746249914169312, -0.8023185729980469, -0.9613946676254272, -0.32390838861465454, -0.138386532664299, -0.06570228189229965, -0.024928109720349312, 1.1268632411956787, 0.9857332706451416, -0.8976678252220154, -0.5035250782966614, 0.19944311678409576, 0.03296499326825142, -0.006928144488483667, -0.3428288698196411, 0.0931127592921257, -0.3145545423030853, -1.0501885414123535, 0.25408288836479187, 0.0520441047847271, -0.03693461790680885, -0.39677610993385315, 0.07271561026573181, 0.06627332419157028, 0.21587185561656952, 0.662989616394043, 0.09300654381513596, -0.6687585711479187, -0.23577846586704254, -0.2791253328323364, -0.09161531925201416, -0.08095297962427139, 0.9843958020210266, -0.7286126613616943, 0.292082279920578, 0.5884274840354919, 0.38767966628074646, 0.15430384874343872, 0.974146842956543, 0.6620758175849915, -0.8797754645347595, 0.08924850076436996, 0.2118864506483078, 0.3030870258808136, 0.5067251324653625, -0.23719029128551483, 0.710880696773529, 0.30748623609542847, -0.8749291896820068, -0.8491665124893188, 0.3932900130748749, -0.5012535452842712, 0.04898015037178993, 1.2609089612960815, -0.13478292524814606, -0.011776640079915524, -0.3717741072177887, 0.02266731671988964, -0.012081658467650414, -0.632994532585144, 0.5774117112159729, 0.6516267657279968, -0.3503677248954773, -0.39887702465057373, -0.7628353238105774, 0.2691192626953125, 0.13896748423576355, -0.748995840549469, 0.02847815304994583, 0.5079798102378845, 0.5256194472312927, -0.28224945068359375, 0.8475215435028076, -0.14782597124576569, 0.09514663368463516, -0.29711124300956726, -0.15567554533481598, 0.32786792516708374, -0.3004763722419739, -0.38972628116607666, 0.22905468940734863, -0.3028445541858673, -0.023503871634602547 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07321v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07321v1	Summing Up the Facts: Additive Mechanisms Behind Factual Recall in LLMs	2024-02-11T22:58:49	2024-02-11T22:58:49	Bilal Chughtai, Alan Cooney, Neel Nanda	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.CL	How do transformer-based large language models (LLMs) store and retrieve knowledge? We focus on the most basic form of this task -- factual recall, where the model is tasked with explicitly surfacing stored facts in prompts of form `Fact: The Colosseum is in the country of'. We find that the mechanistic story behind factual recall is more complex than previously thought. It comprises several distinct, independent, and qualitatively different mechanisms that additively combine, constructively interfering on the correct attribute. We term this generic phenomena the additive motif: models compute through summing up multiple independent contributions. Each mechanism's contribution may be insufficient alone, but summing results in constructive interfere on the correct answer. In addition, we extend the method of direct logit attribution to attribute an attention head's output to individual source tokens. We use this technique to unpack what we call `mixed heads' -- which are themselves a pair of two separate additive updates from different source tokens.	[ -0.24634119868278503, -0.9009898900985718, 0.7423141002655029, -0.0695871114730835, -0.1278185248374939, 0.11101654917001724, -0.13600894808769226, -0.4657467305660248, 0.3830254077911377, 0.5412117838859558, -0.5868321061134338, -0.16514283418655396, -0.5440227389335632, 0.19071251153945923, -0.5190045237541199, 1.0508970022201538, 0.059925246983766556, -0.042881079018116, -0.36716994643211365, -0.3622647523880005, -0.3154003620147705, -0.7948248386383057, -0.4329623281955719, -0.4266468584537506, 0.7317229509353638, 0.36223655939102173, 0.5198884606361389, 0.8067440390586853, 0.5219677686691284, 0.3616849184036255, -0.14412781596183777, 0.1918409764766693, -0.6579182744026184, 0.1436932384967804, -0.3651314377784729, -0.8856027722358704, -0.4355771839618683, -0.08089616894721985, 0.6169682145118713, 0.642180323600769, -0.03344340622425079, 0.20921728014945984, -0.11342588067054749, 0.5485139489173889, -0.6816186308860779, 0.22595128417015076, -0.7621045112609863, -0.1392889767885208, -0.10193849354982376, -0.5183262825012207, -0.46574878692626953, -0.2298184335231781, 0.09296918660402298, -0.39287590980529785, 0.578548789024353, -0.05432617664337158, 0.6027103662490845, 0.2039051055908203, -0.6220546364784241, -0.6441282629966736, -0.88907390832901, 0.6708523035049438, -0.30501559376716614, 0.19136421382427216, 0.0832393541932106, -0.23820729553699493, 0.05664561316370964, -0.7073425054550171, -0.5424992442131042, -0.27245303988456726, -0.5166205167770386, 0.19299308955669403, -0.14280207455158234, 0.0019273547222837806, 0.4676956534385681, 0.5395144820213318, -0.30179667472839355, -0.16220195591449738, -0.4952142834663391, -0.475060373544693, 0.43525025248527527, 0.33390241861343384, 0.4541836380958557, 0.012948797084391117, -0.4186846911907196, 0.050969358533620834, -1.1842894554138184, -0.11840921640396118, 0.03983653336763382, 0.3654212951660156, -0.20039333403110504, 0.8680828213691711, -0.019353454932570457, 0.6023762226104736, 0.32023197412490845, -0.27185818552970886, -0.2848454415798187, -0.606497585773468, -0.06574089825153351, 0.5640679597854614, 0.39527231454849243, 0.05325300619006157, 0.1552623212337494, -0.26339250802993774, -0.24768638610839844, 0.12806855142116547, 0.1957416534423828, -0.651046097278595, -0.24633900821208954, 0.13561759889125824, -0.17015115916728973, -0.2433692216873169, -0.05992448329925537, -0.1912996470928192, -0.27018773555755615, -0.619291365146637, 0.5301699638366699, -0.22180859744548798, -0.05253538861870766, 0.08822695165872574, -0.23695701360702515, 0.13550008833408356, 0.3097982108592987, -0.9355641603469849, 0.30888769030570984, 0.8588458895683289, 0.8853834867477417, -0.2772473394870758, -0.27855294942855835, -0.6457836627960205, 0.41913890838623047, -0.24369248747825623, 0.8898436427116394, -0.3779686391353607, -0.21832211315631866, 0.02916988916695118, 0.05972430855035782, -0.10469502210617065, -0.47863805294036865, 0.4468076825141907, -0.7733153700828552, 0.39146220684051514, -0.9226759672164917, -0.8876049518585205, -0.43440011143684387, 0.11301546543836594, -0.9254680871963501, 0.7868698835372925, -0.1352386325597763, -0.9103595614433289, 0.07237287610769272, -0.43978890776634216, -0.5824379920959473, -0.09069127589464188, -0.3505852520465851, -0.1692468374967575, 0.4014796018600464, -0.013504893518984318, 0.17238201200962067, -0.3003113269805908, 0.3629382252693176, -0.2543022632598877, -0.3885037899017334, 0.6712912321090698, -0.4692504405975342, 1.005557656288147, -0.03199117258191109, -0.12730741500854492, 0.266624391078949, -0.8079423308372498, -0.8354493379592896, 0.0880165621638298, -0.5071675181388855, -0.41120684146881104, 0.008658344857394695, -0.43708208203315735, 0.07565256953239441, 0.32327884435653687, -0.4527008533477783, 0.14909079670906067, 0.06233847141265869, 0.15447396039962769, 0.6273433566093445, 0.3558287024497986, 0.37954795360565186, -0.5333347916603088, 0.09615253657102585, 0.40522289276123047, -0.3194471001625061, -0.5314890146255493, -0.14902475476264954, -1.1679385900497437, -0.363424688577652, 0.15661205351352692, 0.5610030293464661, -0.7386081218719482, 0.1993776112794876, -0.25890597701072693, -0.17121531069278717, -0.20784316956996918, -0.16267205774784088, 0.09942608326673508, 0.6428989768028259, 0.06533513218164444, -0.1891656219959259, -0.4882909655570984, -0.8405941128730774, -0.19053804874420166, -0.29526031017303467, -0.10319546610116959, 0.06394974142313004, 0.5543525815010071, 0.12482654303312302, 0.9764037728309631, -0.6938526630401611, -0.0905672013759613, -0.14995743334293365, 0.27878549695014954, 0.32688724994659424, 0.2422916740179062, 0.6137736439704895, -0.5992838740348816, -0.04621747136116028, -0.22530098259449005, -0.9941918253898621, -0.013225900009274483, -0.4000261127948761, 0.15268151462078094, 0.18965479731559753, 0.40533262491226196, -1.1315529346466064, 0.08771078288555145, 0.24730338156223297, -0.36966097354888916, 0.7450646162033081, -0.1446429342031479, 0.2725881338119507, -0.7183917164802551, 0.09603378921747208, -0.28647133708000183, -0.18547998368740082, -0.8404836058616638, 0.26717764139175415, 0.1355413794517517, -0.03961091861128807, -0.26268723607063293, 0.22896108031272888, -0.5027762055397034, -0.18341152369976044, -0.389890193939209, 0.2441396862268448, 0.16233079135417938, 0.6943001747131348, 0.022317461669445038, 0.9388250112533569, 0.5675432085990906, -0.9432448148727417, 0.6316133141517639, 0.10980567336082458, -0.2626973092556, 0.5041890144348145, -0.5458090305328369, 0.060191623866558075, -0.25158825516700745, 0.21732200682163239, -1.0139957666397095, -0.2918756306171417, 0.2417907863855362, -0.2510411739349365, 0.4386599063873291, -0.11511021107435226, -0.4612325131893158, -0.08423176407814026, -0.28534582257270813, 0.36400288343429565, 0.2331588864326477, -0.4493679404258728, 0.8874560594558716, 0.5314762592315674, -0.5428332686424255, -0.5053192377090454, -0.6005920171737671, 0.16547220945358276, -0.3422932028770447, -0.43926602602005005, 0.2962004840373993, 0.021535994485020638, -0.44046878814697266, 0.21239586174488068, -0.2699238955974579, 0.09467368572950363, 0.08900769799947739, -0.15222039818763733, 0.4739638864994049, -0.4435455799102783, 0.21620602905750275, -0.17727212607860565, -0.2271755039691925, 0.3515724539756775, -0.3043174147605896, 0.3296656310558319, 0.033850688487291336, -0.5462605357170105, -0.18217895925045013, 0.3600125014781952, 0.7194187641143799, -0.08838380873203278, 0.5797710418701172, 0.491120845079422, -0.3006150722503662, 0.30703699588775635, -0.7062122225761414, -0.4153907597064972, -0.4418505132198334, 0.44762393832206726, -0.36851420998573303, -1.1283934116363525, 0.9617804288864136, 0.09199541807174683, 0.15566205978393555, 0.6131650805473328, 0.9099453687667847, -0.038645993918180466, 0.5233535170555115, 0.5476394891738892, -0.0541769377887249, 0.19554077088832855, 0.016614504158496857, 0.14204499125480652, -0.5581590533256531, -0.09712762385606766, -0.4255906641483307, -0.09368374198675156, -0.6778820753097534, -0.5245349407196045, 0.5874409675598145, -0.145808145403862, -0.11924347281455994, 0.14771497249603271, 0.0658457949757576, 0.4953652322292328, 0.7491261959075928, 0.161105677485466, 0.6405835151672363, 0.09838281571865082, -0.03168163076043129, 0.061383482068777084, -0.92344731092453, -0.20649950206279755, 1.01337730884552, 0.22464044392108917, 0.7771178483963013, 0.2392386496067047, 0.49876585602760315, 0.42525166273117065, 0.256553590297699, -0.8426581621170044, 0.5635150074958801, 0.07465328276157379, -0.815602719783783, -0.014083909802138805, -0.41430333256721497, -0.5409432053565979, 0.27078163623809814, -0.28190577030181885, -0.440601646900177, 0.3507188856601715, 0.33399516344070435, -0.47097209095954895, 0.4365147054195404, -0.4579703211784363, 0.24338822066783905, -0.1236187145113945, -0.591355562210083, -0.6069673299789429, -0.6513858437538147, 0.7212817668914795, -0.05926138162612915, 0.1483210176229477, 0.17354799807071686, 0.05357781797647476, 0.5817890167236328, 0.017062759026885033, 1.0401197671890259, 0.14207535982131958, -0.3965529799461365, 0.504306435585022, 0.3046678304672241, 0.8440755009651184, -0.13476558029651642, 0.3513496220111847, -0.031159570440649986, -0.2983751595020294, -0.3837067186832428, -0.6413049697875977, 0.654606819152832, -0.6535071134567261, -0.8857593536376953, -0.574128270149231, -0.6994364261627197, 0.048064108937978745, 0.0037164431996643543, 0.11654161661863327, 0.8335438966751099, -0.2061387300491333, 0.25714111328125, 1.0961576700210571, -0.16390173137187958, 0.3965632915496826, 0.8174681663513184, -0.12232762575149536, -0.29801055788993835, 0.9808670282363892, 0.27468952536582947, 0.3119235336780548, 0.6989749670028687, 0.04639187827706337, -0.2560720443725586, -0.3219936788082123, -0.34745123982429504, 0.49000653624534607, -1.0246580839157104, -0.1041870266199112, -0.72740638256073, -0.16467370092868805, -0.10988401621580124, 0.09851088374853134, -0.22559018433094025, -0.8162314891815186, -0.12354426831007004, -0.38410311937332153, 0.39480313658714294, 0.9401662945747375, -0.28416159749031067, 0.2706957459449768, -0.75310879945755, 0.5003701448440552, 0.5305868983268738, 0.25820571184158325, 0.08730187267065048, -0.4978789687156677, -0.5267825722694397, 0.05438509210944176, -0.18546162545681, -0.9361943602561951, -0.14232903718948364, -0.18585245311260223, 0.4660491943359375, 0.44050106406211853, -0.04160177707672119, 0.5910286903381348, -0.46857181191444397, 0.7344396114349365, 0.16576677560806274, -0.6616700291633606, -0.018302541226148605, -0.3365475535392761, 0.21631121635437012, 0.11645787209272385, 0.2900836765766144, -0.6482613682746887, -0.6010618209838867, -0.6673519611358643, -0.6741859912872314, 0.8147629499435425, 0.10022012144327164, 0.170670285820961, -0.17070457339286804, 0.28851088881492615, 0.0016039889305830002, 0.12441480159759521, -0.7155409455299377, -0.5224182605743408, -0.029091259464621544, -0.1353631466627121, 0.10581564158201218, -0.8019090294837952, -0.6096179485321045, -0.18001848459243774, 0.6095792651176453, 0.12764877080917358, 0.3957618176937103, 0.2509057819843292, -0.617530107498169, -0.12214405834674835, 0.16756832599639893, 1.0982745885849, 0.8480018973350525, -0.19347338378429413, 0.560185968875885, 0.15546396374702454, -0.3632875680923462, 0.020079702138900757, -0.3104993999004364, -0.4920041859149933, 0.16905330121517181, 0.8085553050041199, 1.0618053674697876, 0.3650331199169159, -0.2756704092025757, 0.19824935495853424, 0.04804332181811333, 0.05290903523564339, -0.31991881132125854, 0.17958852648735046, 0.338871031999588, 0.21159201860427856, 0.6136019825935364, 0.21689705550670624, 0.26455652713775635, -0.8185628652572632, 0.43779999017715454, 0.3131661117076874, -0.2864745259284973, -0.5719106793403625, 0.46172037720680237, 0.269402414560318, -0.08771057426929474, 0.4619789719581604, 0.09703555703163147, -0.5520935654640198, 0.48929357528686523, 0.6397681832313538, 0.9672812819480896, -0.15885889530181885, -0.01090402901172638, 0.5595656633377075, 0.37809810042381287, 0.17055931687355042, -0.08472900837659836, -0.1338871866464615, -0.7466467618942261, -0.7769953012466431, -0.3331601023674011, -0.346116304397583, 0.08532695472240448, -0.6105781197547913, 0.01111065223813057, -0.02720814198255539, 0.03130324184894562, -0.06955265253782272, -0.21547606587409973, -0.4580291509628296, -0.010379036888480186, 0.2883565127849579, 0.7323302626609802, -1.2117984294891357, 0.4285140633583069, 0.38162747025489807, -0.398101270198822, -0.40771493315696716, 0.07635112851858139, 0.1803441345691681, -0.9539323449134827, 0.5182420611381531, -0.24971941113471985, -0.2912808060646057, 0.027935905382037163, -0.51537024974823, -1.1026445627212524, 0.8825182914733887, 0.3629750907421112, -0.49015381932258606, 0.10192741453647614, 0.2400560975074768, 0.2504774034023285, -0.4661654233932495, 0.1509408801794052, 0.6903566122055054, 0.36677953600883484, 0.25688380002975464, -0.43420928716659546, 0.2817673683166504, 0.07878249883651733, -0.38332387804985046, 0.01449308916926384, -0.5024874210357666, 0.9238379597663879, -0.5122928619384766, -0.4415380358695984, -0.3264849781990051, 0.7773928642272949, 0.46730947494506836, 0.11182256788015366, 0.22999164462089539, 0.4586840569972992, 0.7970345616340637, -0.053873248398303986, 1.2146024703979492, -0.4436720013618469, 0.448525071144104, 1.200935959815979, -0.122169628739357, 0.3027366101741791, 0.45894062519073486, -0.3572953939437866, 0.5710057020187378, 0.5342132449150085, 0.0918336883187294, 0.45281386375427246, -0.21916602551937103, -0.5272955894470215, -0.2769547998905182, -0.21064969897270203, -0.04097691923379898, 0.38724637031555176, 0.45415055751800537, -0.19440820813179016, -0.4123643636703491, -0.3531204164028168, 0.2605246603488922, -0.23417805135250092, -0.31718116998672485, 1.1249967813491821, 0.06542700529098511, -0.8482052087783813, 0.4415713846683502, -0.12423659861087799, 0.14877749979496002, -0.565721333026886, -0.02820342220366001, -0.4981030225753784, 0.1263125240802765, -0.02030509151518345, -0.7289162278175354, 0.29192107915878296, -0.13758046925067902, -0.575913667678833, 0.036107610911130905, 0.7077879905700684, -0.8745894432067871, -0.5887027978897095, -0.048085059970617294, 0.38218972086906433, -0.10526884347200394, 0.13338065147399902, -0.40163105726242065, 0.14317749440670013, 0.03923499584197998, -0.2440967857837677, 0.22604979574680328, 0.7148631811141968, -0.22606460750102997, 0.5677685141563416, 0.5713865756988525, 0.04261809587478638, 0.1156429722905159, 0.1845286786556244, 0.8501907587051392, -0.7336602807044983, -0.34090548753738403, -1.2543567419052124, 0.48891526460647583, -0.0017710564425215125, 0.22805751860141754, 0.7490316033363342, 0.6532202959060669, 0.5849505662918091, -0.34276020526885986, 0.7511776089668274, 0.06639701128005981, 0.28072628378868103, -0.7481411099433899, 0.4930380880832672, -0.21052983403205872, 0.1808895617723465, 0.10605551302433014, -0.8142350316047668, -0.1396997720003128, 0.22183991968631744, 0.09238016605377197, -0.20784516632556915, 0.9125974774360657, 0.7986121773719788, -0.255670428276062, -0.008919534273445606, 0.1527024805545807, 0.7234269380569458, 0.1704428344964981, 0.32478153705596924, 0.9183564186096191, -0.17523197829723358, 0.23677147924900055, -0.010427093133330345, -0.16172190010547638, -0.42582905292510986, -0.8640797138214111, -0.5464732646942139, -0.5916719436645508, -0.45851200819015503, -0.14336705207824707, -0.16056674718856812, 0.7766864895820618, 0.18826685845851898, -1.0635122060775757, -0.3773323595523834, 0.02388838492333889, 0.5372101664543152, -0.08038660883903503, -0.17611658573150635, 0.6315739750862122, -0.5139278769493103, -0.30576884746551514, 0.21384865045547485, 0.5412710905075073, 0.12075292319059372, -0.26526468992233276, 0.14878810942173004, -0.2433595061302185, 0.35902103781700134, 0.8033513426780701, 0.1000709980726242, -0.7934288382530212, -0.4226905405521393, 0.11665287613868713, -0.0454668365418911, 0.1059899777173996, 1.414160966873169, -0.6414770483970642, 0.38397008180618286, 0.6308621168136597, 0.41588693857192993, 0.5878423452377319, 0.1377630978822708, 0.740855872631073, -0.8477329015731812, 0.22994917631149292, -0.15140248835086823, 0.6060500144958496, 0.4235268235206604, -0.2562621533870697, 0.27093935012817383, 0.6681647300720215, -0.34996992349624634, -0.7188767790794373, 0.45577943325042725, -0.8951461911201477, -0.3142773509025574, 0.8494705557823181, -0.12630929052829742, -0.25958579778671265, -0.15968264639377594, -0.04728138446807861, 0.5547457933425903, 0.09644882380962372, 1.0491113662719727, 0.8291754126548767, -0.12146127223968506, -0.12077482789754868, -0.25489383935928345, 0.5547018051147461, 0.18059319257736206, -0.34367191791534424, 0.4195106029510498, 0.8518834114074707, 0.5004664659500122, 0.4696676731109619, 0.6221106648445129, -0.08959650993347168, 0.27843621373176575, 0.07968635112047195, 0.0024681375361979008, -0.009251419454813004, -0.5676119923591614, -0.2077895849943161, 0.19653674960136414, 0.011064151301980019, 0.03974751755595207 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07319v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07319v1	ODIN: Disentangled Reward Mitigates Hacking in RLHF	2024-02-11T22:40:12	2024-02-11T22:40:12	Lichang Chen, Chen Zhu, Davit Soselia, Jiuhai Chen, Tianyi Zhou, Tom Goldstein, Heng Huang, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	In this work, we study the issue of reward hacking on the response length, a challenge emerging in Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) on LLMs. A well-formatted, verbose but less helpful response from the LLMs can often deceive LLMs or even human evaluators to achieve high scores. The same issue also holds for some reward models in RL. To address the challenges in both training and evaluation, we establish a more reliable evaluation protocol for comparing different training configurations, which inspects the trade-off between LLM evaluation score and response length obtained by varying training hyperparameters. Based on this evaluation, we conduct large-scale studies, where the results shed insights into the efficacy of hyperparameters and tricks used in RL on mitigating length bias. We further propose to improve the reward model by jointly training two linear heads on shared feature representations to predict the rewards, one trained to correlate with length, and the other trained to decorrelate with length and therefore focus more on the actual content. We then discard the length head in RL to prevent reward hacking on length. Experiments demonstrate that our approach almost eliminates the reward correlation with length, and improves the obtained policy by a significant margin.	[ -0.5099407434463501, -0.5760444402694702, 0.36372146010398865, 0.39148613810539246, -0.4526504874229431, 0.39747297763824463, -0.02220252901315689, -0.6445284485816956, 0.4994066059589386, 0.2557850778102875, -0.7845960259437561, 0.19774414598941803, -0.9157266616821289, 0.0024616485461592674, 0.11231762170791626, 1.168683648109436, 0.04163755476474762, 0.16835376620292664, -0.5026828646659851, -0.08693866431713104, -0.4834251403808594, -0.46085798740386963, -0.7383468151092529, -0.7741259336471558, 1.0257056951522827, 0.0924416184425354, 0.49597999453544617, 0.6633732914924622, 0.6292091012001038, 0.25352269411087036, -0.2629176378250122, 0.2054826021194458, -0.7395443320274353, 0.09032608568668365, -0.11998672783374786, -0.5026925206184387, -0.4185102880001068, -0.015657028183341026, 0.3572556972503662, 0.20516662299633026, -0.23213568329811096, 0.24807320535182953, 0.3049769401550293, 1.1346849203109741, -0.9620696306228638, 0.05053022503852844, -0.2628198266029358, 0.3658401668071747, -0.054249800741672516, -0.46661943197250366, -0.4471680819988251, -0.09837347269058228, -0.14416314661502838, -0.4896829128265381, -0.03733685985207558, -0.041613511741161346, 0.7634718418121338, 0.5102578401565552, -0.2699533998966217, -0.0824207216501236, -0.7794445157051086, 0.9212414026260376, -0.6002774834632874, 0.4046579897403717, 0.5970299243927002, 0.5102121829986572, -0.3325512707233429, -0.36670923233032227, -0.38088980317115784, -0.39187997579574585, -0.21596024930477142, 0.22620421648025513, 0.23701831698417664, 0.19563335180282593, 0.33501967787742615, 0.22291648387908936, -0.34642577171325684, 0.357138067483902, -0.27462509274482727, -0.29596301913261414, 1.0234205722808838, 0.5301255583763123, -0.329965204000473, -0.18006394803524017, -0.5961830615997314, -0.575249433517456, -0.8727045655250549, 0.5265529155731201, 0.7918700575828552, -0.057908620685338974, -0.017827805131673813, 0.34883013367652893, -0.30897057056427, 0.6805833578109741, 0.18676693737506866, -0.40429943799972534, -0.0359642431139946, -0.1414385288953781, -0.07008308172225952, -0.09947695583105087, 0.6219282746315002, 0.3167453706264496, -0.1338469684123993, -0.4149901866912842, -0.5193932056427002, -0.037211284041404724, 0.46379005908966064, -0.750546932220459, -0.017749063670635223, 0.37132027745246887, -0.6504206657409668, -0.5272295475006104, 0.3033924996852875, -0.7453829050064087, -0.6497283577919006, -0.16596515476703644, 0.4117603003978729, -0.01929238624870777, -0.25220227241516113, 0.29987916350364685, -0.5210912823677063, 0.2662218511104584, 0.3118654787540436, -1.1244969367980957, 0.42249196767807007, 0.9814746379852295, 0.4639037549495697, -0.365294873714447, -0.6536691188812256, -0.8264012336730957, -0.08127383142709732, -0.04045044258236885, 0.2252790331840515, -0.08508209139108658, -0.4411134719848633, -0.1145082637667656, -0.17689268290996552, 0.2785094082355499, -0.3955077528953552, 0.18835721909999847, -0.9492252469062805, 0.07924149930477142, -0.4558018147945404, -0.6492481231689453, 0.14221571385860443, 0.5018565058708191, -0.8049890398979187, 0.4658510982990265, 0.005631007719784975, -1.1121351718902588, 0.5236812233924866, -0.6205666065216064, -0.4317258596420288, 0.058022528886795044, -0.17559924721717834, -0.59041428565979, 0.048141077160835266, 0.1551884114742279, 0.3099555969238281, -0.13236427307128906, 0.2692621648311615, -0.37720540165901184, -0.889850378036499, 0.6412851810455322, -0.6915003657341003, 0.5516471266746521, 0.0734533816576004, -0.4354373514652252, 0.21031494438648224, -0.5001978278160095, 0.014195960015058517, 0.22375676035881042, -0.6960181593894958, -0.16901227831840515, -0.08873826265335083, 0.0020713151898235083, 0.05973680317401886, 0.4135579466819763, -0.7257903218269348, 0.05166303738951683, -0.23850928246974945, 0.2194632738828659, 1.0620394945144653, 0.20232994854450226, 0.1937563568353653, -0.5562126636505127, 0.6743790507316589, -0.04049503058195114, 0.4637020528316498, 0.19412386417388916, -0.11679322272539139, -0.3371594250202179, -0.5166623592376709, 0.5863835215568542, 0.30586007237434387, -0.7847652435302734, 0.4185280203819275, 0.03236926719546318, -0.39326387643814087, -0.6306331157684326, -0.01648297719657421, 0.8540238738059998, 0.4708816707134247, 0.3424917161464691, -0.3036244213581085, -0.30057039856910706, -0.8296644687652588, -0.55425626039505, -0.19219163060188293, -0.2878429889678955, 0.26164543628692627, 0.5414790511131287, -0.012541534379124641, 0.8750812411308289, -0.5333170294761658, -0.1684602051973343, -0.19985590875148773, 0.33024242520332336, 0.13958032429218292, 0.5724131464958191, 0.11463865637779236, -0.7622937560081482, -0.2378310114145279, -0.4351961314678192, -0.46685582399368286, 0.4555400311946869, -0.27113664150238037, 0.14074549078941345, 0.05587651580572128, 0.15150894224643707, -0.48148322105407715, 0.7444860339164734, 0.319366991519928, -0.3660857081413269, 0.6951965689659119, -0.3978913724422455, 0.44164326786994934, -0.5639352202415466, 0.04332341253757477, -0.17941364645957947, -0.43255192041397095, -0.02413094975054264, 0.020781492814421654, 0.23441405594348907, 0.37461403012275696, -0.5856157541275024, 0.512704074382782, -0.2129315882921219, -0.18337713181972504, -0.44786152243614197, -0.2246251106262207, 0.11720423400402069, 0.9706156253814697, -0.032494015991687775, 0.6365656852722168, 0.20537912845611572, -0.7723341584205627, 0.6671274900436401, 0.20101848244667053, -0.27813395857810974, 0.5803015828132629, -0.8681175708770752, 0.2264159619808197, -0.06655784696340561, 0.4956316351890564, -0.6838972568511963, -0.33537113666534424, 0.2318543791770935, -0.6101086735725403, 0.4632030725479126, -0.1004534512758255, -0.5187009572982788, -0.3020413815975189, -0.8388463258743286, 0.49560272693634033, 0.54298335313797, -0.7517144083976746, -0.05566192790865898, 0.3786984384059906, 0.3480214774608612, -1.0035922527313232, -0.6672527194023132, -0.18211416900157928, -0.6043702363967896, -0.3669860363006592, 0.5051193237304688, -0.10710062086582184, 0.09414200484752655, -0.14775101840496063, -0.20079845190048218, 0.22251319885253906, 0.5113263130187988, 0.3654024004936218, 0.3024508059024811, 0.3481621742248535, 0.03534962236881256, -0.0008482674602419138, -0.1733991801738739, 0.4740764796733856, 0.1573760062456131, 0.47483786940574646, -0.05293848365545273, -0.7474353909492493, -0.5168969035148621, 0.15080946683883667, 0.3746556341648102, -0.16831378638744354, 0.7032404541969299, 0.5343205332756042, -0.19258184731006622, 0.028658803552389145, -0.3432593047618866, -0.7899453043937683, -0.4806753098964691, 0.4300409257411957, -0.2633013129234314, -1.1708433628082275, 0.5597248673439026, -0.11541546881198883, 0.04436734691262245, 0.05132732167840004, 0.40344947576522827, -0.21871750056743622, 1.1424139738082886, 0.6980012655258179, -0.12276922911405563, 0.31190285086631775, -0.10374192148447037, -0.1286771595478058, -1.1177464723587036, -0.49204471707344055, -0.18726935982704163, -0.7445449829101562, -0.6034305691719055, -0.21578270196914673, 0.4845143258571625, 0.1602824181318283, -0.2543589472770691, 0.06734909862279892, -0.2862844467163086, 0.6956684589385986, 0.39088311791419983, 0.40638500452041626, 0.03338983654975891, -0.2011580467224121, 0.044170137494802475, -0.18388548493385315, -0.6894259452819824, 0.15920908749103546, 1.0762090682983398, 0.8418312668800354, 1.120043158531189, 0.11185448616743088, 1.1057013273239136, 0.4949585497379303, -0.1397908627986908, -0.6924339532852173, 0.29461470246315, 0.3840741515159607, -0.2949524521827698, -0.6609758138656616, -0.6454314589500427, -1.0462931394577026, 0.2534356713294983, -0.06060028821229935, -0.6463965177536011, -0.051943570375442505, 0.24331089854240417, -0.5060461163520813, 0.18233974277973175, -0.13381898403167725, 0.5798597931861877, -0.3647063374519348, -0.6613383293151855, -0.38974565267562866, -0.8807582855224609, 0.44564634561538696, 0.20699599385261536, -0.09924285858869553, 0.23154868185520172, 0.14274968206882477, 1.2127891778945923, -0.4714434742927551, 0.7782214283943176, -0.30328091979026794, 0.07290319353342056, -0.13853707909584045, 0.11720532178878784, 0.6830629706382751, 0.6626965403556824, 0.3986418545246124, 0.007150644902139902, -0.03879166767001152, -0.7122951745986938, -0.6804701685905457, 0.7205185294151306, -0.819541871547699, -0.6954808831214905, -0.5636419057846069, -0.6041959524154663, -0.5855847597122192, -0.14075882732868195, 0.2581263780593872, 0.10899728536605835, -0.1684577465057373, 0.10398422181606293, 1.0279209613800049, -0.16340117156505585, 0.48765695095062256, 0.3311116099357605, -0.3418179750442505, -0.563484787940979, 0.7024486660957336, -0.42206045985221863, 0.29547151923179626, 0.3442278802394867, 0.22077755630016327, -0.624851405620575, -0.17450298368930817, -0.509734034538269, 0.3081445097923279, -0.6097532510757446, -0.46776461601257324, -0.12897703051567078, -0.31224164366722107, -0.17944981157779694, -0.06375670433044434, -0.5711369514465332, -0.4231089949607849, 0.03508574515581131, -0.21306131780147552, 0.5251861810684204, 0.945488691329956, -0.28101494908332825, 0.19947637617588043, -0.7548568844795227, 0.17073048651218414, 0.3773060441017151, 0.5704925656318665, 0.3586905896663666, -0.5403896570205688, -0.3962212800979614, 0.17238062620162964, -0.13730023801326752, -0.84108567237854, 0.19788478314876556, -0.5399450659751892, 0.5913251042366028, 0.2534019947052002, 0.08635568618774414, 0.7753089666366577, -0.12722094357013702, 0.6885942816734314, 0.647785484790802, -0.653059720993042, 0.2341241091489792, 0.022703183814883232, 0.3792871832847595, 0.5437605381011963, 0.3031578063964844, -0.639349639415741, -0.21062204241752625, -0.6348980665206909, -0.7173249125480652, 0.8339970111846924, -0.048330437391996384, -0.02905712090432644, 0.2231658697128296, 0.19292248785495758, 0.2355727255344391, 0.4064832627773285, -0.6361140012741089, -0.20451220870018005, -0.09720027446746826, 0.24820901453495026, 0.05268070846796036, -0.44463831186294556, -0.5989992022514343, -0.17981405556201935, 0.6430109739303589, 0.0018292282475158572, 0.3119230568408966, 0.11710646748542786, -0.10953368991613388, -0.2706664204597473, 0.17760184407234192, 0.6732664704322815, 0.8664277791976929, -0.3640665113925934, 0.20182402431964874, 0.01813521236181259, -0.37168923020362854, 0.2842118442058563, -0.19699007272720337, 0.2084653228521347, -0.25591737031936646, 0.5061354041099548, 0.7834493517875671, 0.03533852472901344, -0.6078983545303345, 0.6929473280906677, -0.3697056770324707, -0.3528688848018646, -0.0644737184047699, -0.07259275764226913, 0.23636779189109802, 0.22502000629901886, 0.13919804990291595, -0.07266566157341003, 0.04737723991274834, -0.012553690001368523, 0.3666515052318573, 0.4134156405925751, -0.6903494000434875, -0.16171780228614807, 0.40285393595695496, 0.12695325911045074, -0.4503836929798126, 0.6767564415931702, -0.3409956693649292, -0.5144366025924683, 0.7457402348518372, 0.39418932795524597, 0.8362759351730347, -0.06084316968917847, 0.4545043408870697, 0.20052717626094818, 0.0987485870718956, -0.04621760547161102, 0.049549929797649384, -0.3112389147281647, -0.2929932475090027, -0.45333603024482727, -0.6848893761634827, -0.40624141693115234, 0.3996981680393219, -1.062530517578125, -0.004061879590153694, -0.5764461755752563, 0.13869012892246246, -0.29885411262512207, 0.0542588047683239, -0.589823842048645, -0.14357596635818481, -0.04936385899782181, 0.8370509147644043, -0.7663480639457703, 0.7442932724952698, 0.39046162366867065, -0.4631725549697876, -0.741493284702301, 0.02848295122385025, -0.03149931877851486, -0.6972743272781372, 0.8279306888580322, 0.13681402802467346, -0.2621147036552429, -0.4723840057849884, -0.4311380386352539, -0.5413177609443665, 1.3452712297439575, 0.06338182836771011, -0.6023265719413757, 0.2192370444536209, 0.41776716709136963, 0.4455874264240265, 0.018439369276165962, 0.18181118369102478, 0.545223593711853, 0.285612016916275, 0.11096308380365372, -0.9534363746643066, 0.13769632577896118, 0.2092365324497223, 0.13180817663669586, 0.2958296835422516, -0.6529011130332947, 0.6740374565124512, -0.04693393036723137, 0.16680732369422913, -0.2631591558456421, 0.559461772441864, 0.75222247838974, 0.28043630719184875, 0.6214507222175598, 0.658574104309082, 0.6937189698219299, 0.37675896286964417, 0.9532138109207153, 0.02471342124044895, 0.5172643661499023, 1.05844247341156, -0.2791433036327362, 0.6687336564064026, 1.0795502662658691, -0.3450658321380615, 0.1591062992811203, 0.8757969737052917, 0.284408301115036, 0.9455690979957581, 0.7995085716247559, -0.10171004384756088, -0.1745760589838028, 0.15108110010623932, -0.3412923216819763, 0.22980648279190063, -0.011132791638374329, 0.1607188880443573, -0.3183012008666992, 0.15689092874526978, 0.12199167907238007, 0.13266530632972717, -0.2607453465461731, 0.8660765886306763, 0.08032824099063873, -0.9135357737541199, 0.6925277709960938, 0.1927860528230667, 1.0299526453018188, -0.65517258644104, -0.10751965641975403, -0.5569308996200562, 0.2857834994792938, -0.11932666599750519, -0.6599377393722534, 0.2966969609260559, -0.1011577695608139, -0.10362110286951065, -0.17420652508735657, 0.6022503972053528, -0.2248353809118271, 0.21847742795944214, 0.406782865524292, 0.17743217945098877, -0.10649901628494263, 0.003338131820783019, -0.8838615417480469, 0.134837806224823, -0.031964011490345, -0.38935890793800354, 0.9694268107414246, 0.07842623442411423, -0.025417128577828407, 0.5798918008804321, 0.6482747793197632, 0.011853678151965141, -0.03756541386246681, -0.2915853261947632, 0.9402161836624146, -0.6393811106681824, -0.9143189191818237, -1.06760835647583, 0.43064793944358826, -0.24777257442474365, -0.2144778072834015, 0.4862042963504791, 0.40531685948371887, 0.9356868863105774, -0.3029465973377228, 0.3970669209957123, 0.13344404101371765, 0.30626752972602844, -0.607682466506958, 0.9139342308044434, -0.5498767495155334, 0.4938618242740631, 0.058678038418293, -0.5420165061950684, 0.08876016736030579, 0.22574274241924286, 0.0070733558386564255, -0.060969073325395584, 0.5314323902130127, 0.6389021873474121, -0.1073448657989502, -0.25094783306121826, 0.42246538400650024, -0.3010367751121521, 0.45245155692100525, 0.7302863001823425, 1.0879600048065186, -0.21849524974822998, 0.25753331184387207, -0.3865763247013092, -0.3600585162639618, -0.38958048820495605, -0.864974319934845, -0.8135634660720825, -0.461811363697052, -0.20473234355449677, -0.43835851550102234, 0.13141463696956635, 0.4513954818248749, 0.7363346219062805, -0.5361219048500061, -0.3797281086444855, -0.13893499970436096, 0.4216262996196747, -0.52101731300354, -0.2243497669696808, 0.3065521717071533, -0.28787684440612793, -0.24221187829971313, 0.3506816625595093, 0.352424293756485, -0.14816853404045105, -0.7353877425193787, -0.7779474854469299, -0.17459896206855774, 0.12609829008579254, 0.13690075278282166, 0.3225603401660919, -0.7499911189079285, -0.37115100026130676, -0.0847158208489418, -0.2501993179321289, -0.16861672699451447, 0.791713297367096, -0.9321287870407104, 0.22803309559822083, 0.6251841187477112, 1.1306039094924927, 0.6231829524040222, -0.12479560077190399, 0.3265800178050995, -1.009732723236084, 0.3142394423484802, 0.34948354959487915, 0.18993321061134338, 0.16397999227046967, -0.6996669769287109, 0.28580978512763977, -0.0765322670340538, -0.7307083606719971, -1.0449144840240479, 0.5412222743034363, -0.8914192914962769, -0.3960075080394745, 0.9460574984550476, -0.6003677248954773, -0.3466011583805084, 0.2554911971092224, -0.02475597709417343, 0.10570865869522095, -0.13462121784687042, 1.2966301441192627, 0.7229685187339783, -0.30157938599586487, 0.036532144993543625, -0.13404862582683563, 1.0240092277526855, 0.791540265083313, -0.6932650804519653, 0.14386101067066193, 0.1389273852109909, 0.181285560131073, 0.11049288511276245, 0.5700253844261169, -0.1934608817100525, 0.7366342544555664, -0.03561878949403763, -0.10953199118375778, -0.5220625400543213, -0.4722747206687927, -0.7063815593719482, -0.11516702175140381, 0.4645231366157532, -0.5899124145507812 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07309v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07309v3	HyperBERT: Mixing Hypergraph-Aware Layers with Language Models for Node Classification on Text-Attributed Hypergraphs	2024-02-11T21:16:26	2024-05-25T12:10:38	Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò, Gos Micklem	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML	Hypergraphs are characterized by complex topological structure, representing higher-order interactions among multiple entities through hyperedges. Lately, hypergraph-based deep learning methods to learn informative data representations for the problem of node classification on text-attributed hypergraphs have garnered increasing research attention. However, existing methods struggle to simultaneously capture the full extent of hypergraph structural information and the rich linguistic attributes inherent in the nodes attributes, which largely hampers their effectiveness and generalizability. To overcome these challenges, we explore ways to further augment a pretrained BERT model with specialized hypergraph-aware layers for the task of node classification. Such layers introduce higher-order structural inductive bias into the language model, thus improving the model's capacity to harness both higher-order context information from the hypergraph structure and semantic information present in text. In this paper, we propose a new architecture, HyperBERT, a mixed text-hypergraph model which simultaneously models hypergraph relational structure while maintaining the high-quality text encoding capabilities of a pre-trained BERT. Notably, HyperBERT presents results that achieve a new state-of-the-art on five challenging text-attributed hypergraph node classification benchmarks.	[ -0.25661346316337585, -0.7372745275497437, 0.2989315390586853, 0.0950271338224411, -0.11879883706569672, 0.3782723844051361, -0.20743101835250854, -0.7335110902786255, 0.2880055606365204, 0.5653042197227478, -0.29046377539634705, -0.7048397660255432, -0.5444484353065491, -0.17884233593940735, -0.41803210973739624, 1.2550853490829468, 0.17664924263954163, -0.2666444778442383, -0.010094218887388706, 0.023671502247452736, -0.013700442388653755, -0.7968748211860657, -0.19572575390338898, -0.40555092692375183, 0.5741843581199646, 0.1810792088508606, 1.1789956092834473, 0.6323513984680176, 0.2378067821264267, 0.32041600346565247, -0.18737119436264038, 0.3762928545475006, -0.37143781781196594, 0.0912255048751831, -0.034425556659698486, 0.10631301254034042, -0.7233353853225708, 0.10959095507860184, 0.9241794943809509, 0.8229585289955139, 0.2821093797683716, 0.06429389864206314, 0.2121240496635437, 0.44969499111175537, -0.7678723335266113, 0.16724029183387756, -0.6677955389022827, 0.07789551466703415, 0.03926730155944824, -0.12632377445697784, -0.6318793296813965, -0.0791260376572609, 0.45487526059150696, -0.5211303234100342, 0.23602794110774994, 0.048621948808431625, 0.9530755281448364, 0.0210407841950655, -0.12787103652954102, 0.16119641065597534, -0.8990402817726135, 0.5598002672195435, -0.4274488389492035, 0.6872913241386414, 0.25972360372543335, 0.18388555943965912, 0.22443604469299316, -1.0057235956192017, -0.624062716960907, -0.21203657984733582, -0.23538516461849213, 0.0832584872841835, -0.038599006831645966, 0.17918388545513153, -0.01793375238776207, -0.061515361070632935, -0.45766302943229675, 0.16521841287612915, -0.017470259219408035, -0.29725638031959534, 0.43571436405181885, -0.1017247810959816, -0.015336158685386181, -0.25844916701316833, -0.712396502494812, -0.2609977424144745, -0.48319265246391296, -0.15644212067127228, 0.3949781358242035, 0.42756861448287964, 0.15839457511901855, 0.2608972489833832, -0.06514862179756165, 0.710791289806366, -0.27258536219596863, 0.30001190304756165, 0.4570097029209137, -0.13891823589801788, -0.36140817403793335, 0.23952263593673706, 0.8169827461242676, 0.1101880818605423, 0.358036607503891, -0.21798360347747803, -0.10679544508457184, -0.25540000200271606, 0.07090514898300171, -0.7972914576530457, -0.39045485854148865, 0.3476423919200897, -0.3028905391693115, -0.5044152736663818, -0.10061763972043991, -0.46309152245521545, -0.47882717847824097, -0.19291667640209198, 0.15126650035381317, -0.3694082796573639, -0.3601934313774109, 0.04242575541138649, -0.06919361650943756, 0.014505740255117416, 0.4825729727745056, -0.5129359364509583, 0.4191182851791382, 0.6413596272468567, 0.6165105104446411, -0.06398274004459381, -0.5953356623649597, -0.5066946744918823, 0.395484983921051, -0.08915956318378448, 0.4993624687194824, -0.7563604712486267, 0.1497577279806137, 0.33896404504776, -0.15920715034008026, 0.018360160291194916, -0.32035496830940247, 0.7376137971878052, -0.5850968360900879, 0.05767179653048515, 0.1487022191286087, -0.5645567774772644, 0.016786331310868263, 0.3929207921028137, -0.6114715337753296, 1.4098167419433594, 0.2035793960094452, -1.1334328651428223, 0.10580930858850479, -0.14094126224517822, -0.5464927554130554, 0.41032668948173523, -0.058730073273181915, -0.49775850772857666, -0.14154206216335297, 0.2503716051578522, 0.9287105202674866, -0.2959667146205902, 0.20499713718891144, -0.37133675813674927, -0.3145295977592468, 0.38943788409233093, -0.07414118200540543, 0.7773575782775879, -0.07216829806566238, -0.19617702066898346, 0.23464825749397278, -0.8803049921989441, 0.3061964511871338, 0.03968047350645065, -0.26223939657211304, -0.5106223225593567, 0.14756205677986145, 0.5210874080657959, 0.3343631327152252, 0.3392568826675415, -0.6755977869033813, -0.15881358087062836, -0.15494608879089355, 0.26159223914146423, 0.7610225081443787, -0.2702876031398773, 0.3169538080692291, -0.045823145657777786, -0.11326711624860764, 0.10107113420963287, 0.11072911322116852, 0.15024788677692413, -0.38172727823257446, -0.7430240511894226, -0.47100162506103516, 0.38349854946136475, 0.553951621055603, -0.7179141044616699, 0.7212660312652588, -0.22690734267234802, -0.5949773192405701, -0.6084998250007629, 0.16715767979621887, 0.3576834797859192, 0.635260283946991, 0.6254838109016418, -0.2638929486274719, -0.3614560067653656, -0.5317582488059998, -0.06723535805940628, -0.25036782026290894, 0.32247796654701233, 0.5267406105995178, 0.37869662046432495, -0.5129672288894653, 0.8849058151245117, -0.5718900561332703, -0.2622911036014557, -0.5296412706375122, 0.1442696899175644, 0.1503830999135971, 0.6079584956169128, 0.5498123168945312, -0.5730499625205994, -0.5333572626113892, 0.3320360779762268, -0.653329610824585, 0.1516079604625702, 0.05588822811841965, -0.3984895348548889, -0.22436097264289856, 0.48902443051338196, -0.6060181260108948, 0.07940753549337387, 0.3800979554653168, 0.024683650583028793, 0.7019728422164917, -0.14429716765880585, -0.503259003162384, -0.9417826533317566, -0.12771925330162048, 0.07500122487545013, -0.45319297909736633, -0.835056722164154, 0.09606295824050903, 0.276371568441391, -0.4220130145549774, -0.39089235663414, 0.3842489421367645, -0.3474140763282776, -0.00024850189220160246, -0.3058434724807739, 0.17000512778759003, 0.07082939893007278, 0.6903584599494934, 0.24234066903591156, 0.10456618666648865, 0.8878310322761536, -0.6611149907112122, 0.6034035086631775, 0.07693491876125336, -0.1511233150959015, 0.3961048424243927, -0.8228469491004944, 0.32695379853248596, -0.29723531007766724, 0.38201087713241577, -0.8636677861213684, -0.1316566914319992, 0.2069547176361084, -0.6300409436225891, 0.3038717210292816, -0.2793715298175812, -0.7011299133300781, -0.22949081659317017, -0.2994842827320099, 0.3672538101673126, 0.30615878105163574, -0.5527216196060181, 0.6089296340942383, 0.1930347979068756, 0.042915862053632736, -0.9016994833946228, -0.356275349855423, -0.04054778441786766, 0.3095187544822693, -0.5474315881729126, 0.7077969312667847, 0.028705982491374016, 0.4055042862892151, 0.48352861404418945, 0.1175924614071846, -0.44462689757347107, 0.11440283805131912, 0.07749118655920029, 0.23204171657562256, -0.1916874647140503, 0.3621230125427246, 0.17181608080863953, -0.10776682943105698, -0.14087358117103577, -0.8044725656509399, 0.7394653558731079, -0.03897804021835327, -0.04512748867273331, -0.6907463669776917, 0.33312761783599854, 0.5893822908401489, -0.727806031703949, 0.8771489262580872, 0.968649685382843, -0.5417274832725525, -0.43185070157051086, -0.2566918730735779, 0.1151283010840416, -0.4386354386806488, 0.6358644962310791, -0.24312977492809296, -0.989550769329071, 0.3288521468639374, -0.09291256964206696, 0.014757193624973297, 0.31152474880218506, 0.5869989395141602, -0.4932304620742798, 0.8556062579154968, 0.5949557423591614, -0.442673921585083, 0.7065900564193726, -0.4321519434452057, 0.10374034941196442, -0.8723949790000916, -0.042622312903404236, -0.6460815668106079, -0.2535885274410248, -0.7419496178627014, -0.26543647050857544, 0.1529746800661087, -0.20466022193431854, -0.5265284776687622, 0.5361815094947815, -0.4503539204597473, 0.49485230445861816, 0.4659807085990906, 0.3866024911403656, 0.1875043660402298, 0.18333597481250763, -0.19655603170394897, 0.2720583975315094, -0.6381797194480896, -0.2102392017841339, 0.89853435754776, 0.47944507002830505, 0.9327335953712463, 0.04958755150437355, 0.9062541723251343, 0.35896918177604675, 0.14817915856838226, -0.7062594294548035, 0.46817728877067566, -0.08647356182336807, -0.5835814476013184, -0.32736286520957947, -0.5433461666107178, -0.8513218760490417, 0.3710417151451111, -0.4961060583591461, -0.7084037065505981, 0.21583758294582367, 0.20816852152347565, -0.06750568002462387, 0.0896112322807312, -0.5639612674713135, 0.7692664861679077, -0.23883949220180511, -0.5764152407646179, -0.09116441011428833, -0.7519866824150085, -0.08123552799224854, 0.3168526887893677, 0.10534429550170898, -0.03139360621571541, 0.21167010068893433, 0.5889914035797119, -0.34803053736686707, 0.9975076913833618, -0.22655771672725677, 0.0947861447930336, 0.35065630078315735, 0.07172554731369019, 0.7442718744277954, 0.06314076483249664, 0.022079842165112495, -0.08434651046991348, -0.40941646695137024, -0.4996659755706787, -0.6992431879043579, 0.5854752659797668, -1.174928069114685, -0.24097472429275513, -0.4178105294704437, -0.6517642140388489, -0.19216099381446838, 0.3436630666255951, 0.010828529484570026, 0.6016006469726562, -0.14122115075588226, 0.0699109211564064, 0.6379818320274353, -0.050352588295936584, 0.3168502748012543, 0.06214015185832977, 0.009341567754745483, -0.48368391394615173, 1.06063973903656, -0.05537977069616318, 0.26172709465026855, 0.6451442241668701, 0.2335934042930603, -0.14169315993785858, -0.5835933089256287, -0.22603753209114075, 0.3392612934112549, -0.7369357347488403, -0.06316237896680832, -0.9343106746673584, -0.6344218254089355, -0.5593231916427612, -0.021226488053798676, -0.4054892957210541, -0.4007265269756317, -0.21345388889312744, -0.09705376625061035, -0.012655851431190968, 0.5250098705291748, 0.46579185128211975, 0.582845151424408, -0.8945017457008362, -0.02118113823235035, 0.2811841666698456, 0.39297738671302795, 0.20782330632209778, -0.23415587842464447, -0.5835135579109192, -0.35318073630332947, -0.22146455943584442, -0.8917946815490723, 0.18511392176151276, 0.14362527430057526, 0.6246614456176758, 0.10291989892721176, 0.12710192799568176, 0.33419397473335266, -0.538358747959137, 0.2495701014995575, 0.20474641025066376, -0.9499058127403259, 0.3864782750606537, -0.1977839320898056, -0.0286640003323555, 0.3845703601837158, 0.6810708045959473, -0.536193311214447, -0.3151117265224457, -0.5947262644767761, -0.8874114751815796, 0.565949559211731, 0.4428340494632721, 0.2202630192041397, 0.14460182189941406, 0.1388975977897644, -0.23779550194740295, 0.19895592331886292, -1.155335545539856, -0.06888694316148758, -0.43599092960357666, -0.4586428999900818, 0.12965774536132812, -0.16743898391723633, -0.16374948620796204, -0.3931649625301361, 0.5306694507598877, -0.26627638936042786, 0.281042218208313, 0.3217319846153259, -0.6391039490699768, 0.2876850962638855, 0.2055259644985199, 0.1594233512878418, 0.4835861623287201, -0.38657164573669434, 0.5402292609214783, -0.1903032660484314, -0.357585608959198, 0.004240656737238169, 0.3466808497905731, -0.06073472276329994, 0.06087092310190201, 0.6895323395729065, 0.7276707291603088, -0.05797268822789192, -0.39230993390083313, 0.5815109014511108, 0.1173267737030983, 0.06370197236537933, 0.013090112246572971, -0.0889439508318901, 0.0050893910229206085, 0.2540954351425171, 0.2507754862308502, -0.13470838963985443, 0.04465652257204056, -0.5810958743095398, 0.16677923500537872, 0.2747858762741089, -0.6778084635734558, -0.21502074599266052, 0.23424865305423737, 0.5743042826652527, -0.18036864697933197, 0.6406418085098267, -0.29093992710113525, -0.8943243026733398, 0.35648852586746216, 0.6303423643112183, 0.9775494337081909, -0.06273888796567917, 0.3609827160835266, 0.14730018377304077, 0.47868645191192627, 0.5280861854553223, 0.10385893285274506, -0.32410913705825806, -1.0602631568908691, -0.42701447010040283, -0.4713909924030304, -0.5273239016532898, -0.17131808400154114, -0.27064016461372375, 0.020150313153862953, -0.8615010976791382, -0.19157303869724274, 0.04973798617720604, -0.1966416984796524, -0.6166315078735352, 0.243665874004364, 0.051705971360206604, 0.6179763674736023, -0.9030266404151917, 1.0822441577911377, 0.7864055037498474, -0.24632275104522705, -0.45800620317459106, 0.1960149109363556, -0.4588843286037445, -0.6193732023239136, 0.870834469795227, 0.15917420387268066, -0.2325674593448639, 0.1764177680015564, -0.5867583751678467, -0.6571649312973022, 0.729369044303894, 0.21556228399276733, -0.1473475992679596, -0.020197609439492226, 0.14466749131679535, 0.512016236782074, -0.5515886545181274, 0.294612318277359, 0.25370895862579346, 0.11175499111413956, -0.028142010793089867, -0.5852822065353394, 0.12756675481796265, -0.2527243196964264, 0.10085433721542358, 0.193477064371109, -0.5182830095291138, 0.8138487339019775, -0.01041069719940424, 0.006300159264355898, -0.340660959482193, 1.0059012174606323, -0.041759975254535675, 0.09696406871080399, 0.4491335451602936, 0.532931923866272, 1.0017718076705933, 0.07293853163719177, 0.8728510141372681, -0.3117748498916626, 0.6258576512336731, 1.15188467502594, -0.5881189703941345, 0.6866032481193542, -0.06628840416669846, 0.07073833793401718, 0.815913736820221, 0.5179569721221924, 0.231197789311409, 0.3689904510974884, 0.08171257376670837, -0.26547572016716003, -0.3568900227546692, -0.41746965050697327, -0.41382211446762085, 0.3728073835372925, 0.25758081674575806, -0.3766067624092102, -0.1328689008951187, -0.3388650715351105, 0.06483324617147446, -0.08589340001344681, -0.15510272979736328, 0.48744961619377136, -0.364510715007782, -0.13775067031383514, 0.5107660293579102, 0.0468783937394619, 0.35005781054496765, -0.3308161795139313, 0.0823218822479248, 0.05687229707837105, 0.2595279812812805, -0.3561211824417114, -0.8367182612419128, -0.06221045181155205, -0.057555314153432846, -0.14493608474731445, -0.20726187527179718, 1.019031047821045, -0.4695698320865631, -0.5431147813796997, 0.6010958552360535, 0.4394535720348358, -0.1999984234571457, -0.041456662118434906, -0.6638394594192505, 0.007538309320807457, -0.4870193302631378, 0.018578045070171356, 0.11052700877189636, 0.6513164043426514, 0.084966741502285, 0.4225400984287262, 0.4989428222179413, -0.08909983187913895, 0.009843401610851288, 0.36080825328826904, 1.0898195505142212, -0.7338635921478271, -0.4782368242740631, -0.8440220355987549, 0.4104178845882416, -0.49611109495162964, -0.24067208170890808, 0.39668411016464233, 0.5028427243232727, 1.093497395515442, 0.1757449060678482, 0.7314342856407166, 0.030919859185814857, 0.19784192740917206, -0.31911545991897583, 0.6770637631416321, -0.32004451751708984, -0.16134075820446014, -0.7415576577186584, -1.1293468475341797, -0.24730457365512848, 0.4421611726284027, 0.1720643937587738, 0.20648404955863953, 0.8473919034004211, 0.4830504357814789, -0.13516457378864288, -0.21146178245544434, 0.1483456790447235, 0.3532605767250061, 0.3049676716327667, 0.4777418375015259, 0.908833384513855, -0.23418767750263214, 0.5547578930854797, -0.2559337317943573, -0.43150052428245544, -0.2353246957063675, -0.6834704875946045, -1.1884596347808838, -0.5575872659683228, -0.3414369225502014, -0.48529917001724243, 0.03913050889968872, 1.0556116104125977, 0.8157568573951721, -0.4381045401096344, -0.36231881380081177, 0.06440670788288116, 0.4697530269622803, -0.25125208497047424, -0.22406050562858582, 0.6336508393287659, -0.3943302035331726, -0.6985474824905396, 0.019776973873376846, 0.3359827399253845, 0.05040985345840454, -0.1563875526189804, -0.021837862208485603, -0.4326436519622803, -0.05845198035240173, 0.8541740775108337, -0.02600979432463646, -0.18107739090919495, -0.3939999043941498, 0.12452664971351624, -0.33831289410591125, -0.002531500067561865, 0.8501236438751221, -0.7384774088859558, 0.3429248034954071, 0.759375274181366, 1.121859073638916, 0.6605308055877686, -0.20678238570690155, 0.25763553380966187, -1.1461986303329468, 0.15197129547595978, 0.35948899388313293, 0.39527252316474915, 0.35585424304008484, -0.3205803334712982, 0.21190717816352844, 0.4655856192111969, -0.1674337387084961, -0.667007327079773, 0.5051295161247253, -1.0749585628509521, -0.27243807911872864, 0.779512882232666, -0.19038228690624237, -0.18969619274139404, -0.02331005036830902, -0.082755908370018, 0.4764608144760132, -0.2594330906867981, 0.30488917231559753, 0.638106107711792, -0.22041375935077667, -0.2919299006462097, -0.1385670304298401, 0.2621323764324188, 0.43344148993492126, -0.7866716980934143, 0.2627409100532532, 0.29675835371017456, -0.2708434760570526, 0.27889716625213623, 0.4722759425640106, 0.04131503403186798, 0.2624180316925049, -0.4734324812889099, 0.07068030536174774, -0.1598833203315735, -0.9394728541374207, 0.24817191064357758, 0.3427314758300781, 0.12197501957416534, -0.10167485475540161 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07283v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07283v1	Power Transformer Fault Prediction Based on Knowledge Graphs	2024-02-11T19:14:28	2024-02-11T19:14:28	Chao Wang, Zhuo Chen, Ziyan Zhang, Chiyi Li, Kai Song	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	In this paper, we address the challenge of learning with limited fault data for power transformers. Traditional operation and maintenance tools lack effective predictive capabilities for potential faults. The scarcity of extensive fault data makes it difficult to apply machine learning techniques effectively. To solve this problem, we propose a novel approach that leverages the knowledge graph (KG) technology in combination with gradient boosting decision trees (GBDT). This method is designed to efficiently learn from a small set of high-dimensional data, integrating various factors influencing transformer faults and historical operational data. Our approach enables accurate safe state assessments and fault analyses of power transformers despite the limited fault characteristic data. Experimental results demonstrate that this method outperforms other learning approaches in prediction accuracy, such as artificial neural networks (ANN) and logistic regression (LR). Furthermore, it offers significant improvements in progressiveness, practicality, and potential for widespread application.	[ -0.4861658811569214, -0.33159929513931274, 0.2734292447566986, 0.21197392046451569, 0.06306455284357071, 0.23666056990623474, 0.1389334499835968, -0.15638259053230286, 0.12842801213264465, 0.42368587851524353, -0.6715964078903198, -0.29052838683128357, -0.5644598007202148, -0.120399110019207, -0.046433959156274796, 1.0765180587768555, -0.11798577010631561, 0.01997060514986515, -0.0537194162607193, -0.027229126542806625, -0.6318851709365845, -0.06446912884712219, -0.692718505859375, -0.6866640448570251, 0.2990659475326538, 0.47501233220100403, 0.6163479685783386, 0.23910526931285858, 0.5693328976631165, 0.26272982358932495, 0.0019183990079909563, 0.21434545516967773, -0.6162715554237366, 0.09791803359985352, 0.14492365717887878, -0.4882635772228241, -0.2422395497560501, -0.2533298134803772, 0.2535552978515625, 0.533026933670044, -0.08665573596954346, -0.1554115265607834, 0.038540326058864594, 0.8446018099784851, -0.2246445119380951, 0.808828592300415, -0.6812188625335693, 0.6457359790802002, 0.2072572559118271, -0.4758242070674896, -0.4594268500804901, -0.5422736406326294, -0.01100554596632719, -0.5033770799636841, 0.3152153491973877, 0.14778463542461395, 0.7548777461051941, 0.6031649708747864, -0.6674306392669678, 0.11882670223712921, -0.8778799772262573, 0.5867019891738892, -0.10483783483505249, 0.4979000389575958, 0.2896629869937897, 1.1199740171432495, 0.06926510483026505, -0.7534502744674683, -0.3252922594547272, -0.048887185752391815, -0.5186827182769775, 0.3739212155342102, -0.3617153465747833, -0.005332342814654112, 0.5887531042098999, 0.012999096885323524, -0.3267791271209717, 0.1948951780796051, -0.3871411979198456, -0.2899817228317261, 0.3893280327320099, 0.3404292166233063, -0.17306511104106903, -0.6672966480255127, -0.6047033667564392, -0.29990777373313904, -0.5742781758308411, 0.09057708829641342, 0.5305391550064087, 0.31581512093544006, 0.13886845111846924, 0.025590816512703896, 0.0027527010533958673, 0.496217280626297, -0.06060248240828514, -0.3184456527233124, 0.2596256732940674, 0.29073047637939453, -0.42107194662094116, 0.08615283668041229, 0.8121001124382019, 0.38642171025276184, 0.312549889087677, -0.5577093958854675, -0.04706981033086777, -0.290737509727478, 0.3277311623096466, -0.6703549027442932, -0.7148053050041199, -0.1990819126367569, -0.3565351366996765, -0.6490800380706787, 0.1275927871465683, -1.1201618909835815, -0.7430185675621033, -0.10173051059246063, 0.34794166684150696, -0.5270016193389893, -0.3336150646209717, -0.36992886662483215, -0.253467321395874, -0.15037080645561218, 0.06985247880220413, -0.6154294013977051, -0.09323117882013321, 0.24676570296287537, 0.7253010869026184, 0.15360622107982635, 0.07034023851156235, -0.26488417387008667, 0.17205479741096497, -0.16289925575256348, 0.5858839154243469, -0.15347102284431458, -0.4006947875022888, -0.13572825491428375, 0.2809416651725769, -0.12331654131412506, -0.6367287635803223, 0.8174293041229248, -0.6080673336982727, -0.13645422458648682, -0.13402920961380005, -0.21302369236946106, -0.5247253179550171, 0.11399080604314804, -0.8933807611465454, 1.0258888006210327, 0.663599967956543, -1.0064858198165894, 0.5809475183486938, -0.4766949415206909, -0.73761385679245, 0.05109311267733574, 0.05496686324477196, -0.9039689302444458, -0.23093143105506897, 0.20353297889232635, 0.5914214849472046, -0.0734139010310173, 0.14763370156288147, -0.12929561734199524, 0.058497942984104156, -0.20360028743743896, -0.49688106775283813, 0.47597751021385193, 0.08809171617031097, -0.2792520821094513, 0.09001471847295761, -0.8626370429992676, 0.13724851608276367, 0.28602755069732666, 0.12983709573745728, -0.14958330988883972, 0.2198006808757782, -0.436739444732666, 0.35391563177108765, -0.009554289281368256, -0.6178476810455322, 0.15011084079742432, -0.18252786993980408, 0.10010210424661636, 0.8520690202713013, -0.06491716206073761, 0.18866586685180664, -0.18746280670166016, 0.7427610158920288, 0.23409463465213776, 0.22283630073070526, 0.10759704560041428, -0.5263882279396057, -0.7085213661193848, 0.2832379937171936, 0.1977430135011673, 0.6969849467277527, -0.7795575857162476, 0.8456355929374695, -0.39549434185028076, -0.7882587909698486, 0.028593868017196655, -0.21442915499210358, 0.02829456329345703, 0.9454368352890015, 0.6173805594444275, 0.08842296898365021, -0.7971599698066711, -0.6487783789634705, -0.10246932506561279, -0.223782479763031, -0.293971985578537, 0.6693755984306335, 0.19585414230823517, -0.15129229426383972, 1.2356170415878296, -0.915530264377594, -0.667062520980835, -0.5590308308601379, 0.08871641755104065, 0.3433791995048523, 0.21477876603603363, 0.19957013428211212, -0.8442695140838623, -0.631035327911377, 0.5504702925682068, -0.7523571848869324, 0.33291661739349365, 0.1324874460697174, 0.3736094832420349, -0.1743984967470169, 0.33085769414901733, -0.28675752878189087, 0.39718005061149597, 0.6340692639350891, -0.16176415979862213, 0.4044073522090912, -0.10286425799131393, 0.015280276536941528, -0.9645176529884338, -0.03160611540079117, 0.15294592082500458, -0.16822323203086853, -0.5067014694213867, -0.6655380129814148, 0.36637040972709656, -0.32962965965270996, -0.1437951773405075, -0.05417899414896965, 0.1233404278755188, 0.08397311717271805, 0.0010771824745461345, -0.3275151252746582, -0.2276126593351364, 0.35415247082710266, -0.3762185871601105, 0.39799508452415466, 0.6874249577522278, -0.4770258069038391, 0.5567258596420288, 0.4567529559135437, -0.47834476828575134, 0.2202199250459671, -0.28502246737480164, 0.17095983028411865, -0.4590723216533661, 0.22125957906246185, -0.7207676768302917, -0.195937842130661, 0.1405797004699707, -0.3046565651893616, 0.6508920788764954, -0.31208327412605286, -0.16886375844478607, -0.8734620213508606, 0.13558611273765564, -0.013829543255269527, 0.7794923186302185, -0.644161581993103, 0.9390997290611267, 0.22184789180755615, 0.013397177681326866, -0.8451191186904907, -0.4091116487979889, -0.22044824063777924, -0.11590928584337234, -0.8764360547065735, 0.2889561653137207, 0.3994586169719696, 0.1960332691669464, 0.037248894572257996, -0.32622721791267395, 0.10610571503639221, 0.1697365790605545, 0.6225264072418213, 0.10668499022722244, 0.1428641974925995, 0.3994504511356354, -0.05718206614255905, -0.630541980266571, -0.049621254205703735, -0.4464116394519806, 0.7263693809509277, -0.10454441606998444, -0.06337860226631165, -0.24391503632068634, -0.27601534128189087, 0.33939626812934875, -0.022147230803966522, 0.6122563481330872, 0.43328332901000977, -0.19104935228824615, -0.5085869431495667, -0.23416033387184143, -0.18736742436885834, -0.5340251326560974, 0.4196273684501648, -0.055497314780950546, -0.4279543459415436, 0.2548995614051819, -0.5649922490119934, -0.29785770177841187, 0.5757875442504883, 0.06590373814105988, -0.1276281625032425, 1.07033109664917, 1.0118709802627563, -0.3957626223564148, 0.28782421350479126, -0.5164846181869507, 0.8659655451774597, -0.2785603702068329, -0.5299146771430969, -0.4242359697818756, -0.5241064429283142, -0.6899035573005676, 0.010890510864555836, 0.8332834243774414, 0.1489962786436081, -0.28221890330314636, 0.5048289895057678, -0.5518946051597595, 0.33522623777389526, -0.06829756498336792, 0.27470019459724426, 0.12180469930171967, 0.25458982586860657, -0.3439188003540039, 0.12659382820129395, -0.6961446404457092, -0.039272088557481766, 0.9437864422798157, 0.3361371159553528, 0.5849742889404297, -0.34100231528282166, 0.36879971623420715, 0.2693435549736023, 0.569648027420044, -0.9433110356330872, 0.2481866329908371, 0.0017008768627420068, -0.16266097128391266, -0.5186154842376709, -1.0635021924972534, -0.9262883067131042, -0.20843538641929626, -0.008951785042881966, -0.46313053369522095, -0.056828394532203674, 0.18135389685630798, -0.2127406746149063, 0.7645508646965027, -0.7310370802879333, 0.7869342565536499, -0.15707477927207947, 0.30305859446525574, 0.09590176492929459, -0.5994644165039062, 0.20425797998905182, -0.21566516160964966, 0.1486469805240631, 0.10545890033245087, 0.6140719056129456, 0.888613760471344, -0.43043383955955505, 0.47528260946273804, -0.46517619490623474, 0.021335752680897713, 0.18063142895698547, -0.1237555667757988, 0.8228212594985962, -0.24906347692012787, -0.14743809401988983, -0.04530377686023712, -0.4446878731250763, -0.2165100872516632, -0.7519543766975403, 0.43365344405174255, -0.724839985370636, -0.32757803797721863, -0.20486600697040558, -0.5705878138542175, -0.7513750791549683, 0.22573670744895935, 0.28408315777778625, 0.2598131000995636, 0.2709480822086334, 0.27177533507347107, 0.391207218170166, -0.07663458585739136, 0.7373899221420288, 0.18800243735313416, -0.07270165532827377, -0.5070557594299316, 1.0836167335510254, 0.2829977869987488, 0.04222327843308449, 0.3002329170703888, 0.3275645971298218, -0.29742908477783203, -0.23877303302288055, -0.07436221092939377, -0.10542944818735123, -0.9345382452011108, -0.7847534418106079, -0.7817490696907043, -0.2619580328464508, -0.20086881518363953, 0.0016763345338404179, -0.027086099609732628, -0.3690524101257324, 0.29089897871017456, -0.6632413268089294, 0.4541778862476349, 0.8538900017738342, 0.14016491174697876, 0.4225369095802307, -0.7321866750717163, 0.29639431834220886, 0.4839322566986084, 0.552526593208313, -0.006896918639540672, 0.23954205214977264, -0.028860656544566154, -0.395329087972641, -0.972926139831543, -0.7409387826919556, 0.6444067358970642, 0.13033203780651093, 0.31368228793144226, 0.5728857517242432, 0.30420857667922974, 0.3491419553756714, -0.44623714685440063, 0.48944878578186035, 0.7295297384262085, -0.5160143375396729, 0.4171995222568512, -0.09197679907083511, -0.2729341387748718, 0.19836831092834473, 0.6721522212028503, -0.44394391775131226, -0.01633606106042862, -0.9652499556541443, -0.7094504237174988, 0.6378427147865295, -0.07094249874353409, -0.23206959664821625, 0.2624179422855377, -0.07999900728464127, 0.3737279176712036, 0.1320972442626953, -0.4286227822303772, -0.5577532052993774, -0.4393301010131836, -0.11725649982690811, -0.2805996537208557, 0.1574055552482605, -0.0863296315073967, -0.4144509434700012, 0.7136250734329224, -0.40533530712127686, 0.21634255349636078, -0.16801784932613373, 0.2129649817943573, -0.6554468870162964, 0.09613054990768433, -0.2138161063194275, 0.7230366468429565, -0.2101871222257614, 0.0016792627284303308, 0.6764446496963501, -0.47778016328811646, 0.15503938496112823, 0.10961445420980453, -0.2368808090686798, 0.14854639768600464, -0.2078731656074524, 0.7764978408813477, -0.06595250219106674, -0.2500312924385071, 0.3447013199329376, -0.006532785948365927, -0.12478525936603546, -0.3729214370250702, 0.008648525923490524, 0.068253293633461, 0.19474142789840698, 0.6395663619041443, 0.6611698865890503, -0.24096086621284485, -0.22388271987438202, 0.38482314348220825, 0.4241633117198944, -0.8328163623809814, -0.0009800537955015898, 0.3426324725151062, -0.02479221485555172, -0.2029319405555725, 0.5001742839813232, -0.06480160355567932, -0.8276945352554321, 1.0244840383529663, 0.38991913199424744, 0.5566511750221252, -0.2884848117828369, 0.3997512757778168, 0.23052792251110077, 0.42754030227661133, 0.1670408546924591, 0.056883249431848526, 0.2695341110229492, -0.6939546465873718, -0.2562144696712494, -0.7190524339675903, -0.30762779712677, 0.24670422077178955, -0.39412111043930054, 0.5612136721611023, -0.551746129989624, -0.08520673215389252, -0.21748021245002747, 0.2109651267528534, -0.7469422221183777, 0.5954349040985107, -0.29246366024017334, 1.020326018333435, -0.9918361306190491, 0.6293179392814636, 0.15117456018924713, -0.2371521145105362, -1.3160133361816406, 0.014880750328302383, -0.4877672493457794, -0.7953729629516602, 0.7476407289505005, 0.44975581765174866, 0.25361448526382446, 0.40620023012161255, 0.0393981970846653, -0.6143572330474854, 1.5837373733520508, 0.35759249329566956, -0.46279481053352356, 0.03620831295847893, 0.10045182704925537, 0.2632351219654083, 0.23266206681728363, 0.418241411447525, 0.6823309659957886, 0.974884033203125, 0.18824820220470428, -0.62959223985672, 0.09020758420228958, 0.14001017808914185, -0.3878359794616699, 0.7834033966064453, -0.652472734451294, 0.6742730736732483, -0.20674581825733185, -0.3440064787864685, -0.4522983729839325, 0.7278284430503845, -0.26231658458709717, 0.3795033395290375, 0.6819822788238525, 0.9140636920928955, 1.0169944763183594, -0.5266087651252747, 1.073300838470459, -0.36495617032051086, 0.9558835625648499, 0.25454801321029663, -0.002570702461525798, 0.21256232261657715, 0.004521553870290518, -0.6074431538581848, 0.5917660593986511, 0.019552312791347504, -0.4674361050128937, 0.6571422815322876, 0.010814713314175606, -0.20292030274868011, -0.3057805895805359, 0.05535288527607918, -0.4433582127094269, 0.180831640958786, 0.26537981629371643, -0.4347451329231262, -0.5185071229934692, -0.06730780005455017, -0.05122213438153267, -0.5320321321487427, -0.39872854948043823, 0.537553071975708, -0.05330149829387665, -0.45825308561325073, 0.4118773937225342, -0.17226086556911469, 0.24109800159931183, -0.6094183921813965, -0.04232010990381241, 0.054220546036958694, 0.31129226088523865, -0.7586632966995239, -0.6070945262908936, 0.1201547160744667, -0.3784702718257904, -0.03554118797183037, -0.3958679735660553, 1.1191143989562988, 0.05994965136051178, -0.496601402759552, 0.3217138350009918, 0.24058237671852112, -0.20391182601451874, 0.008417044766247272, -0.0038644697051495314, -0.5689296722412109, 0.056295983493328094, -0.013529905118048191, 0.4013524055480957, 0.4076775312423706, 0.16040712594985962, 0.831993043422699, 0.32358142733573914, -0.06456942111253738, 0.046151380985975266, -0.10603883117437363, 0.9663791656494141, -0.5335975289344788, -0.4194358289241791, -0.41084185242652893, 0.5290228724479675, -0.25396156311035156, -0.09926530718803406, 0.6057625412940979, 0.3009800910949707, 0.6011171936988831, -0.1566130369901657, 1.3892173767089844, -0.23575052618980408, 0.35914602875709534, -0.3172266185283661, 0.8224664926528931, -0.06186661496758461, -0.1488494873046875, -0.08293227106332779, -0.5908732414245605, -0.1520436853170395, 0.1742435097694397, -0.5593724846839905, 0.12129940092563629, 0.9688207507133484, 0.5503726005554199, -0.269564688205719, 0.5432738661766052, 0.5428851842880249, 0.3045836091041565, 0.3132995367050171, 0.4843416213989258, 0.7735648155212402, -0.45950454473495483, 0.8640549778938293, -0.777819812297821, -0.337655633687973, -0.3312409520149231, -1.0900574922561646, -0.5606668591499329, -0.2134198099374771, 0.029060255736112595, -0.40029358863830566, -0.35941988229751587, 0.5384272933006287, 0.3648497760295868, -0.913489580154419, 0.3943081498146057, -0.5318305492401123, 0.44473737478256226, -0.4071585237979889, -0.27145132422447205, 0.4900181293487549, -0.6004353761672974, -0.11012160778045654, 0.5269387364387512, 0.05962400138378143, -0.1848037987947464, -0.10699769854545593, -0.15942221879959106, 0.6192147731781006, -0.4311949610710144, 0.3690466582775116, 0.12090394645929337, -0.04832989722490311, -0.5913541316986084, -0.07179821282625198, 0.4359966814517975, 0.1645975410938263, 0.9501522779464722, -1.1757994890213013, 0.16310767829418182, 0.4804747402667999, 0.4840698540210724, 0.4652356207370758, -0.19075599312782288, 0.4274282157421112, -0.7525057196617126, -0.02760385535657406, 0.291951447725296, 0.6893952488899231, 0.4342460036277771, -0.44007813930511475, 0.4211396872997284, 0.4786359667778015, -0.5325911045074463, -0.4565804898738861, 0.3918437957763672, -0.8415483236312866, 0.016073083505034447, 0.8045936226844788, -0.2572011947631836, 0.053024884313344955, -0.235806405544281, -0.2577768564224243, 0.5875346064567566, 0.0071723279543221, 1.0343033075332642, 0.2771744430065155, -0.2959306538105011, 0.03274587541818619, -0.3899476230144501, 0.6474692225456238, 0.15304532647132874, -0.8528734445571899, 0.09200926870107651, -0.10746915638446808, 0.23134805262088776, 0.47669342160224915, -0.2816764712333679, -0.046002235263586044, 0.032083768397569656, -0.17235121130943298, -0.19115953147411346, -0.40362489223480225, -0.6432921290397644, -0.148979052901268, 0.757763683795929, -0.3584769368171692, 0.29747146368026733 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07282v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07282v2	How do Large Language Models Navigate Conflicts between Honesty and Helpfulness?	2024-02-11T19:13:26	2024-02-13T14:21:02	Ryan Liu, Theodore R. Sumers, Ishita Dasgupta, Thomas L. Griffiths	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	In day-to-day communication, people often approximate the truth - for example, rounding the time or omitting details - in order to be maximally helpful to the listener. How do large language models (LLMs) handle such nuanced trade-offs? To address this question, we use psychological models and experiments designed to characterize human behavior to analyze LLMs. We test a range of LLMs and explore how optimization for human preferences or inference-time reasoning affects these trade-offs. We find that reinforcement learning from human feedback improves both honesty and helpfulness, while chain-of-thought prompting skews LLMs towards helpfulness over honesty. Finally, GPT-4 Turbo demonstrates human-like response patterns including sensitivity to the conversational framing and listener's decision context. Our findings reveal the conversational values internalized by LLMs and suggest that even these abstract values can, to a degree, be steered by zero-shot prompting.	[ -0.3341120481491089, -0.7401903867721558, 1.0260610580444336, 0.2411600798368454, -0.03169652447104454, -0.1376669555902481, -0.5820029973983765, -0.6755110025405884, -0.22499032318592072, 0.23181816935539246, -0.6974810361862183, -0.0062636141665279865, -0.4775499105453491, 0.060843825340270996, 0.1362827867269516, 1.2594200372695923, 0.21495257318019867, 0.16454248130321503, 0.04264955222606659, -0.05760808289051056, -0.5768164396286011, -0.6628217101097107, -0.8713298439979553, -0.7777307629585266, 0.8126556873321533, 0.42836707830429077, 1.1708499193191528, 0.6899299621582031, 0.3439026474952698, 0.274418443441391, -0.16277751326560974, -0.26945939660072327, -0.547646701335907, 0.2877000570297241, -0.48305270075798035, -0.5927377343177795, -0.4118739068508148, 0.3251207172870636, 0.2428664267063141, 0.7663125395774841, -0.11954863369464874, 0.12168657034635544, 0.0038684317842125893, 0.4281255602836609, -0.4172937572002411, 0.35649731755256653, -0.5127946138381958, -0.148066446185112, 0.11045240610837936, -0.09267321228981018, -0.20129403471946716, -0.5417047142982483, 0.3313429653644562, -0.4545687139034271, 0.01936901919543743, -0.22843921184539795, 0.6731206774711609, 0.40931373834609985, -0.2889307141304016, -0.6116487979888916, -0.6557345390319824, 0.9926998615264893, -0.7472125887870789, 0.23541373014450073, 0.629761815071106, 0.12077441066503525, -0.2941746413707733, -0.15523692965507507, -0.49112701416015625, -0.5855433940887451, -0.051016151905059814, -0.23629020154476166, -0.23456412553787231, 0.17222291231155396, 0.27502304315567017, 0.14283296465873718, -0.2491392195224762, 0.23741941154003143, -0.2494577318429947, -0.15874288976192474, 0.6870228052139282, 0.154536172747612, 0.08632872253656387, -0.09548114240169525, 0.07211703062057495, -0.205121710896492, -0.6139801740646362, 0.43400809168815613, 0.5519601106643677, 0.1265992373228073, 0.0604548379778862, 0.40366414189338684, -0.2110503911972046, 0.8057175278663635, 0.22655539214611053, -0.1313486099243164, -0.09110783040523529, -0.2899450659751892, -0.13752597570419312, -0.043099887669086456, 0.7282829284667969, 0.5750806927680969, 0.7290651798248291, -0.138705775141716, -0.31152528524398804, 0.239695206284523, 0.23284651339054108, -0.8459869027137756, -0.09870906174182892, 0.23204459249973297, -0.45560577511787415, -0.5127833485603333, -0.3022237718105316, -0.4697479009628296, -0.28688064217567444, -0.42183881998062134, 0.43462878465652466, -0.3769453167915344, -0.1729063242673874, 0.3584728240966797, -0.14404886960983276, 0.315911203622818, 0.3154589831829071, -0.8651434779167175, 0.3662188947200775, 0.7306274175643921, 0.6434000134468079, 0.10486932843923569, -0.16046440601348877, -0.8571698665618896, 0.0375959575176239, -0.43665289878845215, 0.5365835428237915, -0.8046245574951172, -0.4889064133167267, -0.2717045247554779, -0.27658388018608093, 0.35894009470939636, -0.37176069617271423, 0.7776666879653931, -0.3900264501571655, 0.43170449137687683, -0.7104817032814026, -0.4697405993938446, -0.11407048255205154, 0.4243749678134918, -0.5186381936073303, 0.5398234128952026, 0.0875612422823906, -0.620198130607605, 0.13655506074428558, -0.8265528678894043, -0.22903956472873688, 0.007036230992525816, -0.31369051337242126, -0.08797779679298401, 0.5114495754241943, -0.0744471549987793, 0.48390620946884155, -0.2941712737083435, 0.3181957006454468, -0.35045289993286133, -0.4438915550708771, 0.8119867444038391, -0.5305425524711609, 0.6369168162345886, 0.30434706807136536, -0.3214174509048462, 0.13209514319896698, -0.28538474440574646, 0.038307566195726395, 0.2893148958683014, -0.3447359502315521, -0.3677615225315094, -0.07037878036499023, -0.3633517324924469, 0.5667218565940857, 0.26105937361717224, -0.5479733347892761, 0.32396596670150757, -0.3216210603713989, 0.49212414026260376, 0.9893891215324402, 0.0014020560774952173, 0.41200780868530273, -0.5034781694412231, 0.4702783524990082, -0.1952805370092392, 0.4050801992416382, -0.06556075811386108, -0.5210475921630859, -0.7456967234611511, 0.1105264201760292, 0.05364476889371872, 0.30694738030433655, -0.4331004321575165, 0.2292443811893463, -0.23590900003910065, -0.13622988760471344, -0.6668568849563599, 0.07839874178171158, 0.5162366628646851, 0.34059834480285645, 0.033169545233249664, -0.3663165271282196, -0.09249824285507202, -1.0204017162322998, -0.328108549118042, -0.28806352615356445, -0.20315633714199066, 0.34334564208984375, 0.30060362815856934, 0.014292986132204533, 1.073838710784912, -0.5509855151176453, 0.1239645779132843, -0.10142067819833755, 0.18991543352603912, 0.08605567365884781, 0.165359228849411, 0.4143436551094055, -0.755909264087677, -0.3346737325191498, -0.14310000836849213, -0.4949986934661865, -0.29169467091560364, -0.1665688455104828, 0.16592520475387573, 0.10861226916313171, 0.200351282954216, -0.6859251856803894, 0.3384532928466797, 0.5674706697463989, -0.4851818382740021, 0.692970335483551, -0.2591010630130768, 0.0504775308072567, -0.6277597546577454, -0.14725743234157562, -0.04801809415221214, -0.37141913175582886, -0.5786465406417847, -0.03351099416613579, -0.17637217044830322, 0.16190022230148315, -0.26489222049713135, 0.7006701231002808, -0.4181939661502838, -0.2023201733827591, -0.4680304527282715, 0.15957856178283691, -0.009680379182100296, 0.6267697811126709, 0.11721456795930862, 0.916601300239563, 0.20620682835578918, -0.7023177742958069, 0.27762168645858765, 0.21736736595630646, -0.09901928901672363, 0.8203813433647156, -0.8670884370803833, 0.32476091384887695, -0.1387515366077423, 0.32743746042251587, -0.7928208112716675, -0.2127792090177536, 0.08673363924026489, -0.6473091244697571, 0.07933320850133896, -0.15193593502044678, -0.44762492179870605, -0.15239684283733368, -0.47131985425949097, 0.24109284579753876, 0.538982629776001, -0.2812422513961792, 0.24987274408340454, 0.21669788658618927, -0.6062107682228088, -0.45053818821907043, -0.6003074049949646, 0.15548670291900635, -0.05724845081567764, -0.4765336215496063, 0.10089118778705597, -0.5916343927383423, -0.6435678601264954, -0.08079008013010025, 0.007245685439556837, -0.07573128491640091, 0.05268343165516853, 0.21013061702251434, 0.38555335998535156, 0.09378983080387115, 0.14892686903476715, -0.32309868931770325, -0.24973873794078827, 0.2545671761035919, -0.31421539187431335, 0.5381539463996887, -0.5771527886390686, -0.32721012830734253, -0.3567798137664795, 0.3191417455673218, 0.3685096502304077, -0.08814719319343567, 0.8195192813873291, 0.4679974615573883, 0.002836075145751238, 0.2609902024269104, -0.7509629726409912, -0.508901834487915, -0.5015246272087097, 0.19925443828105927, -0.34255874156951904, -1.0650551319122314, 0.3638654947280884, 0.19562621414661407, 0.19757682085037231, -0.04036334902048111, 0.6020581126213074, 0.013523789122700691, 1.1762431859970093, 0.533551037311554, -0.05653795972466469, 0.5245757102966309, 0.036587443202733994, 0.4214114248752594, -0.6732495427131653, 0.11583143472671509, -0.49952080845832825, -0.19864851236343384, -0.6496573090553284, -0.3407100439071655, 0.2961655259132385, 0.01870770752429962, -0.33849993348121643, 0.019842475652694702, -0.35655879974365234, 0.7608121037483215, 0.36522984504699707, -0.14009001851081848, 0.4157579243183136, -0.4005463123321533, 0.10901086777448654, -0.18594990670681, -0.5464655756950378, -0.5418390035629272, 0.706264853477478, 0.5472991466522217, 0.8093172907829285, 0.22112885117530823, 0.4028879702091217, -0.0497126504778862, 0.4342532753944397, -0.9591705203056335, 0.4954620897769928, 0.21262627840042114, -0.6662144064903259, -0.3078148663043976, -0.7025231122970581, -0.8703785538673401, 0.0669792890548706, 0.02131597511470318, -0.9136390089988708, -0.03739277645945549, 0.18527543544769287, -0.4028814136981964, 0.1728307008743286, -0.8048931956291199, 0.5992459654808044, -0.3945995271205902, -0.42506495118141174, -0.27804791927337646, -0.8415799736976624, 0.22934052348136902, 0.0638471320271492, 0.3399188220500946, -0.07345334440469742, -0.026545453816652298, 0.3536902666091919, 0.2236122041940689, 0.8208560347557068, 0.035863906145095825, -0.2985634505748749, -0.024871712550520897, 0.5819703340530396, 0.5879951119422913, -0.12165605276823044, -0.17318196594715118, 0.09893140196800232, -0.13675232231616974, -0.49568867683410645, -0.7071338891983032, 0.754593551158905, -0.734512984752655, -0.6249397397041321, -0.4132938086986542, -0.6913832426071167, -0.27650269865989685, 0.007810147479176521, 0.16357745230197906, 0.2934480309486389, -0.2779603898525238, 0.20933815836906433, 0.8563547730445862, -0.4371751546859741, 0.5301553606987, 0.7562781572341919, -0.2825320363044739, 0.12248703092336655, 0.6599096655845642, -0.1308395266532898, 0.7228858470916748, 0.25023722648620605, 0.5226317048072815, -0.5089049339294434, -0.24682864546775818, -0.21886387467384338, 0.41181206703186035, -0.6507683396339417, -0.036916300654411316, -0.403987854719162, -0.0019145662663504481, -0.29601752758026123, -0.32266369462013245, -0.3763701021671295, -0.3681395947933197, -0.009538596495985985, -0.28982752561569214, 0.36517396569252014, 1.090364694595337, -0.1592748612165451, 0.19885040819644928, -0.8159538507461548, 0.03087051957845688, 0.5448675751686096, 0.5157457590103149, 0.18227070569992065, -0.4502290189266205, -0.09896770119667053, 0.16945013403892517, -0.4070308804512024, -0.8094330430030823, 0.1722407042980194, -0.18929551541805267, 0.32982349395751953, 0.3780032694339752, -0.047423772513866425, 0.3496263027191162, -0.41816624999046326, 0.8609086275100708, 0.1689649522304535, -1.0177654027938843, 0.2759546637535095, -0.5990192890167236, 0.40545353293418884, 0.40738973021507263, 0.32396480441093445, -0.9413191676139832, -0.24273687601089478, -0.6324322819709778, -0.4013914465904236, 0.6544312238693237, 0.31276315450668335, 0.23814207315444946, 0.012214968912303448, 0.4585379362106323, 0.08730470389127731, 0.38600075244903564, -0.9180230498313904, -0.0837240144610405, -0.1157173216342926, -0.020350422710180283, -0.05223236605525017, -0.24153399467468262, -0.32748669385910034, -0.042762432247400284, 0.41067248582839966, -0.22163823246955872, 0.23482921719551086, 0.03815402835607529, 0.10140576213598251, -0.29578790068626404, 0.8779226541519165, 0.648618221282959, 0.7370342016220093, -0.09564553201198578, 0.01206814032047987, 0.13411201536655426, 0.023291997611522675, 0.19276274740695953, -0.15921777486801147, 0.08336193114519119, -0.29380008578300476, 0.20426252484321594, 0.9396799802780151, 0.32939380407333374, -0.6285463571548462, 0.7449629306793213, -0.2910796105861664, -0.025404563173651695, -0.05314106494188309, 0.3354939818382263, 0.22564013302326202, 0.2038295865058899, 0.1589447259902954, -0.19342239201068878, 0.12741553783416748, -0.7401067614555359, -0.07928517460823059, 0.561034083366394, -0.28384876251220703, -0.5248319506645203, 0.3132435977458954, 0.23859363794326782, -0.750221848487854, 0.5835434794425964, -0.47041645646095276, -0.669854998588562, 0.10821178555488586, 0.31125110387802124, 0.7631058096885681, -0.309908390045166, 0.45705971121788025, -0.12350449711084366, 0.06504174321889877, -0.009694060310721397, -0.01895780861377716, -0.1447945535182953, -0.7196825742721558, -0.7920877933502197, -0.4362967312335968, -0.6425570845603943, 0.3373051881790161, -0.7772624492645264, -0.09405696392059326, -0.3242015242576599, -0.1899101436138153, 0.08276782184839249, 0.21900300681591034, -0.8956199884414673, 0.05961093306541443, 0.18843068182468414, 0.6409399509429932, -0.5545021295547485, 0.768303632736206, 0.40030044317245483, -0.495980829000473, -1.0311733484268188, 0.10399772971868515, 0.02339484728872776, -0.8547267317771912, 0.5780162811279297, 0.08638481050729752, -0.34094876050949097, -0.24440860748291016, -0.8142065405845642, -0.5027573704719543, 0.6776217818260193, 0.6678920984268188, -0.5850105285644531, -0.22200612723827362, -0.050503142178058624, 0.675625741481781, -0.15457062423229218, 0.4017106592655182, 0.8126329779624939, 0.6384676694869995, 0.11058954894542694, -1.264538049697876, 0.019027963280677795, -0.07094845175743103, 0.07621421664953232, 0.2080359309911728, -0.7916420102119446, 0.7816247344017029, -0.38897615671157837, 0.14097477495670319, 0.004172999877482653, 0.29447701573371887, 0.2064957469701767, 0.12043999880552292, 0.6640342473983765, 0.243443563580513, 0.5760993957519531, 0.03823087736964226, 1.2887896299362183, -0.12711580097675323, 0.22214017808437347, 1.165259838104248, -0.2795109450817108, 0.6263165473937988, 0.5586830377578735, -0.046641476452350616, 0.5728645324707031, 0.5169762969017029, 0.3046807050704956, 0.31608501076698303, 0.17437466979026794, -0.2638266682624817, -0.1420217603445053, -0.34680357575416565, -0.10949977487325668, 0.4253264367580414, 0.4225212335586548, -0.02941705845296383, -0.22888530790805817, -0.21758043766021729, 0.37981680035591125, -0.09418127685785294, -0.15885865688323975, 0.8852820992469788, 0.15791429579257965, -1.0814123153686523, 0.3044673204421997, 0.0045016976073384285, 0.7535533308982849, -0.745416522026062, -0.07261284440755844, -0.08545426279306412, 0.1369057595729828, -0.0868324264883995, -1.1889322996139526, 0.06765612214803696, -0.06968541443347931, -0.27303749322891235, -0.368405282497406, 0.5901735424995422, -0.4787279963493347, 0.09218402951955795, 0.4888646900653839, 0.3836023509502411, 0.24066562950611115, -0.1526603400707245, -0.7383015751838684, 0.18669939041137695, 0.04930790141224861, -0.3027684688568115, 0.5229052901268005, 0.45312464237213135, -0.03554074838757515, 0.7675741314888, 0.7662448883056641, 0.28915971517562866, -0.2718867361545563, 0.0463847890496254, 0.8277332186698914, -0.725134551525116, -0.6963316798210144, -0.8843633532524109, 0.25111812353134155, -0.13752999901771545, -0.2159830629825592, 0.5836921334266663, -0.030052566900849342, 0.7496510744094849, 0.10045518726110458, 0.8090431094169617, 0.23041082918643951, 0.35814982652664185, -0.4446561634540558, 0.28275585174560547, -0.22982913255691528, 0.2795582413673401, -0.17215624451637268, -0.8358339667320251, 0.1308620572090149, 0.977302610874176, -0.6390561461448669, 0.275441437959671, 0.5109679698944092, 0.6119330525398254, 0.024741850793361664, 0.2928387224674225, 0.4194904565811157, 0.3101641833782196, 0.6754619479179382, 0.8060985207557678, 1.0019491910934448, 0.2054557055234909, 0.5266252160072327, -0.0009591550915502012, -0.33825451135635376, -0.2354300320148468, -1.0582420825958252, -0.7258543968200684, -0.4114548861980438, 0.08262806385755539, -0.37088510394096375, -0.01917416974902153, 1.2138365507125854, 0.8435800671577454, -0.4787440598011017, -0.2632683515548706, -0.025343436747789383, 0.05878860130906105, 0.08441447466611862, -0.25210100412368774, -0.05373286455869675, -0.3231954276561737, -0.5726746320724487, 0.23895005881786346, 0.27323880791664124, 0.2139931321144104, -0.4964121878147125, -0.34763389825820923, 0.206406831741333, 0.39175039529800415, 0.4286799132823944, 0.24246463179588318, -0.6917823553085327, -0.5876613855361938, 0.10043235868215561, -0.0975450724363327, 0.12468618154525757, 1.1407668590545654, -0.5455360412597656, 0.3682354986667633, 0.16285791993141174, 0.5417455434799194, 0.2779484689235687, -0.08993008732795715, 0.9200350642204285, -0.8701284527778625, 0.168491393327713, 0.3981516361236572, 0.07395277917385101, 0.606090247631073, -0.5816625356674194, 0.3876488506793976, -0.22063888609409332, -1.0036429166793823, -0.6009124517440796, 0.4674726128578186, -0.658300518989563, -0.3697587251663208, 1.1978224515914917, -0.10151642560958862, -0.033941902220249176, -0.1362747848033905, -0.445313036441803, 0.030253801494836807, -0.6529151797294617, 0.9166989922523499, 1.260928750038147, -0.43770602345466614, -0.14050552248954773, -0.5897670388221741, 0.7415565848350525, 0.4316043257713318, -0.7761521935462952, 0.1288062036037445, 0.6226291060447693, 0.49120306968688965, 0.3227311968803406, 0.9347320795059204, 0.1990121752023697, 0.3238231837749481, -0.4103289544582367, -0.25999709963798523, 0.00953712034970522, -0.28451716899871826, -0.5991823673248291, -0.2563492953777313, 0.4397701025009155, 0.03997092321515083 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07271v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07271v1	Previously on the Stories: Recap Snippet Identification for Story Reading	2024-02-11T18:27:14	2024-02-11T18:27:14	Jiangnan Li, Qiujing Wang, Liyan Xu, Wenjie Pang, Mo Yu, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang, Jie Zhou	cs.CL	cs.CL	Similar to the "previously-on" scenes in TV shows, recaps can help book reading by recalling the readers' memory about the important elements in previous texts to better understand the ongoing plot. Despite its usefulness, this application has not been well studied in the NLP community. We propose the first benchmark on this useful task called Recap Snippet Identification with a hand-crafted evaluation dataset. Our experiments show that the proposed task is challenging to PLMs, LLMs, and proposed methods as the task requires a deep understanding of the plot correlation between snippets.	[ -0.10385380685329437, -0.13648687303066254, 0.4131893813610077, -0.12627670168876648, -0.36910903453826904, 0.4200882315635681, 0.10574764013290405, -0.10720594227313995, 0.19626913964748383, 0.7490464448928833, -0.7191784381866455, -0.3426060080528259, -0.4361552596092224, 0.30087801814079285, -0.6476720571517944, 1.1216620206832886, 0.08508496731519699, -0.4120734930038452, -0.43094372749328613, -0.22122503817081451, -0.36084991693496704, -0.537166178226471, -0.5278330445289612, -0.30305615067481995, 0.6208549737930298, 0.3243904113769531, 0.2764691114425659, 0.5643937587738037, 0.5750492811203003, 0.20518282055854797, -0.07045119255781174, 0.23759585618972778, -0.594077467918396, 0.23592914640903473, -0.25300005078315735, -0.5866753458976746, -0.13786379992961884, 0.13143391907215118, 0.7878179550170898, 0.7928436398506165, -0.023503443226218224, 0.380332887172699, 0.23269490897655487, 0.8622028827667236, -0.5813145041465759, 0.02684258297085762, -0.42375871539115906, 0.36158910393714905, -0.1697426438331604, -0.5954253077507019, -0.3782748579978943, -0.4908888339996338, 0.48766466975212097, -0.32480552792549133, 0.5143362283706665, 0.007431632373481989, 0.9920603036880493, 0.24462486803531647, -0.06143445894122124, -0.33890312910079956, -0.44773924350738525, 0.9030323624610901, -0.5906347632408142, 0.11494741588830948, 0.32019487023353577, 0.3918001353740692, -0.1971655786037445, -1.0541188716888428, -0.5343487858772278, -0.16257725656032562, -0.16759632527828217, 0.03144459053874016, -0.35243669152259827, -0.7523123025894165, 0.24976064264774323, 0.5807251930236816, -0.3314532935619354, -0.15512517094612122, -0.18720193207263947, -0.07874426990747452, 0.5250510573387146, 0.5082283020019531, 0.03879840299487114, -0.5224109888076782, -0.8014258146286011, -0.16187457740306854, -0.5221210718154907, 0.11174056679010391, 0.2575303018093109, -0.16091738641262054, 0.09163016825914383, 0.490558922290802, -0.16505032777786255, 0.39729559421539307, -0.17629142105579376, 0.017497243359684944, 0.6679644584655762, -0.5889469981193542, -0.15014059841632843, -0.01874331384897232, 0.22227945923805237, 1.0753183364868164, 0.4530685842037201, -0.23349235951900482, 0.14531578123569489, -0.25726985931396484, 0.4574790298938751, -0.6635009050369263, -0.39878690242767334, 0.03062688186764717, -0.6839461326599121, -0.14636462926864624, -0.15523841977119446, -0.881750762462616, -0.8667533993721008, -0.12522892653942108, 0.21381311118602753, -0.3264555335044861, -0.3590445816516876, 0.0543246865272522, -0.7449182271957397, 0.5786868929862976, 0.25703322887420654, -0.8591784238815308, 0.26515859365463257, 0.7977803349494934, 0.8363838791847229, -0.31450697779655457, -0.5110178589820862, -0.36913350224494934, 0.012772982940077782, -0.23036737740039825, 1.1942209005355835, -0.3041634261608124, -0.24453815817832947, -0.18032868206501007, 0.0436025932431221, 0.10309815406799316, -0.3988328278064728, 0.22539405524730682, -0.3616759181022644, -0.16838248074054718, -0.5326113104820251, -0.9612944722175598, -0.26582562923431396, 0.3325018286705017, -0.7121710777282715, 1.121703028678894, 0.30425500869750977, -0.9396119713783264, 0.5744028687477112, 0.0246033426374197, -0.3081302046775818, -0.22581706941127777, -0.16238756477832794, -0.2896927297115326, 0.33745336532592773, 0.42803648114204407, 0.4461715817451477, -0.05987346172332764, -0.11705943942070007, 0.08585939556360245, -0.3431318700313568, 0.2999824583530426, -0.2970871329307556, 0.632257878780365, 0.06779847294092178, 0.30682849884033203, -0.1431758850812912, -0.7481383681297302, -0.0007272445363923907, 0.23858138918876648, 0.06361408531665802, -0.31333839893341064, -0.02643812634050846, -0.3606339693069458, -0.32083114981651306, 0.33155834674835205, -0.401846319437027, 0.3725990951061249, -0.377939373254776, 0.40140461921691895, 0.5201956629753113, 0.20266097784042358, 0.18964529037475586, -0.7976183891296387, 0.6345422267913818, -0.46338632702827454, -0.17208394408226013, -0.8825783133506775, -0.3326212167739868, -0.43608558177948, -0.04022471606731415, 0.6383805274963379, 0.7368968725204468, -0.7482732534408569, 0.317236065864563, -0.18993833661079407, -0.743922233581543, -0.18062303960323334, 0.14243239164352417, 0.5174630284309387, 0.19485259056091309, 0.07010924816131592, -0.5357996225357056, -0.5972830057144165, -0.6499773263931274, -0.7288397550582886, 0.17119766771793365, -0.5978367924690247, 0.3161219656467438, 0.3723647892475128, 0.37889984250068665, 0.8684680461883545, -0.6421725749969482, -0.4044578969478607, -0.6343871355056763, 0.23515278100967407, 0.4481559991836548, 0.1379806101322174, 0.45799943804740906, -0.36154553294181824, -0.28029510378837585, -0.210758775472641, -0.5453063249588013, -0.27727410197257996, -0.30538222193717957, -0.1483185738325119, -0.3794761598110199, 0.9992578029632568, -0.07699546217918396, 0.5901980400085449, 0.4751591980457306, -0.377453476190567, 0.46586376428604126, -0.3052757680416107, 0.21474288403987885, -0.8224974274635315, 0.0550101213157177, -0.24635754525661469, -0.023892244324088097, -0.2910318374633789, -0.3120242953300476, -0.05986984819173813, 0.019388018175959587, -0.5465636253356934, 0.6241815090179443, -0.5247524976730347, -0.6054427623748779, -0.147553950548172, 0.5468083024024963, 0.25777575373649597, 0.5611107349395752, 0.2560946047306061, 0.524971067905426, 0.1972644031047821, -0.16357453167438507, 0.3213859498500824, 0.47491180896759033, -1.0849838256835938, 0.5891894698143005, -0.28006041049957275, 0.3069614768028259, -0.12764872610569, 0.10625884681940079, -1.32301664352417, 0.21627850830554962, 0.021387314423918724, -0.39664894342422485, 0.12965503334999084, -0.04876341298222542, -0.698971688747406, -0.19034691154956818, -0.37967124581336975, 0.22479347884655, 0.12118758261203766, -0.6504449844360352, 0.6057351231575012, 0.2566419839859009, -0.48231127858161926, -0.5086815357208252, -0.5621331334114075, -0.011113904416561127, -0.25717830657958984, -0.08734732121229172, 0.5833683013916016, 0.18385732173919678, 0.08225028961896896, -0.18574170768260956, -0.37024667859077454, -0.026338785886764526, -0.03185712918639183, 0.1387019157409668, -0.07240171730518341, -0.19821307063102722, 0.17077167332172394, -0.12702219188213348, -0.490566223859787, -0.11461129784584045, 0.6416035294532776, 0.5179226994514465, 0.04605787247419357, 0.1709105521440506, -0.27987295389175415, 0.4913296103477478, 0.11710697412490845, -0.19779007136821747, 0.16586916148662567, 0.49421247839927673, -0.13722816109657288, -0.17510531842708588, -0.3889305591583252, 0.08527714014053345, -0.44080284237861633, 0.4114452004432678, -0.33396390080451965, -0.5005754828453064, 0.33872953057289124, -0.33850547671318054, 0.10284304618835449, 0.24597178399562836, 0.19250881671905518, -0.4058292508125305, 0.49844372272491455, 0.5470271110534668, -0.09901298582553864, 0.7684271335601807, -0.23102732002735138, -0.06960485130548477, -1.091443419456482, 0.03464800491929054, -0.5076624155044556, -0.6435793042182922, -0.059914931654930115, -0.2909664809703827, 0.05239524692296982, 0.45748385787010193, 0.07262948155403137, 0.5218231678009033, -0.35640838742256165, 0.9033817648887634, 0.6525281667709351, 0.1994280070066452, 0.5528866052627563, -0.045202046632766724, 0.014718405902385712, -0.18927781283855438, -0.4434346854686737, -0.5212116837501526, 1.2913521528244019, 0.17184096574783325, 0.5291755795478821, -0.021019278094172478, 0.5959572196006775, 0.5325131416320801, 0.5636236071586609, -0.5239342451095581, 0.614676296710968, -0.46637630462646484, -0.3910039961338043, -0.30534279346466064, 0.019390443339943886, -1.2620518207550049, 0.28418803215026855, -0.16111597418785095, -0.9934474229812622, 0.08011264353990555, -0.09483884274959564, -0.6824549436569214, 0.03264961764216423, -0.7577403783798218, 1.061397910118103, -0.22095422446727753, 0.14109082520008087, -0.24513328075408936, -0.5165793895721436, -0.03389456123113632, 0.09621967375278473, -0.13839320838451385, -0.25444895029067993, 0.007989112287759781, 0.810228168964386, -0.27071183919906616, 0.7529148459434509, 0.10151136666536331, 0.4373428225517273, 0.39210861921310425, 0.08194655925035477, 0.3105323910713196, -0.269400030374527, -0.23330353200435638, 0.28607499599456787, 0.5565892457962036, -0.26774558424949646, -0.7651315927505493, 0.3843517005443573, -0.24237897992134094, -0.40666109323501587, -0.6164419651031494, -0.33491095900535583, -0.13680315017700195, 0.27524879574775696, 0.07113289088010788, 0.6344878673553467, -0.05988863855600357, 0.38778114318847656, 0.11368702352046967, -0.31722915172576904, 0.6144939661026001, 0.685845673084259, -0.5186922550201416, -0.4579882025718689, 0.7115228772163391, -0.17464308440685272, 0.14199335873126984, 0.4233196973800659, 0.3108685314655304, -0.2971312999725342, -0.8154473304748535, -0.23299795389175415, -0.006563346832990646, -0.6985275149345398, -0.19355492293834686, -0.3892397880554199, -0.1645132154226303, 0.2128637135028839, -0.261261522769928, -0.2113431841135025, -0.218130424618721, -0.1920395940542221, -0.32385286688804626, 0.412749707698822, 0.519575297832489, -0.028436748310923576, 0.4517679214477539, -0.8230262398719788, 0.4650995433330536, 0.015696777030825615, 0.39002618193626404, 0.08381438255310059, -0.4344777762889862, -0.17248216271400452, -0.6866061091423035, -0.3025836944580078, -0.6612389087677002, 0.6143410205841064, 0.14607276022434235, 0.6964783072471619, 0.35844331979751587, 0.18261347711086273, 0.42963144183158875, -0.6162754893302917, 0.9060564041137695, 0.03784315660595894, -0.6901386380195618, 0.5712750554084778, 0.056660812348127365, 0.6461135149002075, 0.7675650119781494, 0.43639808893203735, -0.3277174234390259, -0.2957330644130707, -0.6125180125236511, -0.7523475289344788, 0.405351847410202, 0.32176440954208374, 0.15881513059139252, -0.12475565075874329, 0.349312961101532, 0.6149933934211731, 0.6261348128318787, -0.29040440917015076, -0.2946648895740509, -0.010665527544915676, 0.08352680504322052, -0.41434311866760254, -0.4304220676422119, 0.15652774274349213, -0.3786105215549469, -0.030388856306672096, 0.19906774163246155, 0.06340381503105164, 0.25325807929039, -0.24877133965492249, 0.16236424446105957, -0.14888323843479156, 0.20931901037693024, 0.8223304152488708, -0.6593809127807617, -0.03024773672223091, 0.12711822986602783, -0.5758974552154541, -0.3296050727367401, -0.024509387090802193, 0.15584208071231842, 0.09579973667860031, 0.7148532867431641, 0.5017073750495911, 0.6053661704063416, -0.8680773377418518, 0.4992640018463135, -0.11345627903938293, -0.018282340839505196, -0.3955084979534149, 0.12177804112434387, -0.24237442016601562, 0.7120658159255981, 0.40665802359580994, -0.05668477341532707, 0.10085085034370422, -0.6616105437278748, 0.6781194806098938, 0.0357666052877903, -0.056549474596977234, 0.042148035019636154, 0.1546107530593872, 0.2525821626186371, -0.5308018922805786, 0.5451328754425049, -0.0783940926194191, -0.483037531375885, 0.7428890466690063, 0.2822973132133484, 0.7661735415458679, -0.05764910578727722, 0.17994648218154907, 0.25869497656822205, 0.21689891815185547, 0.12483951449394226, 0.330776184797287, -0.35917189717292786, -0.8724534511566162, -0.21551987528800964, -0.5572168827056885, -0.5701102614402771, 0.1647278517484665, -0.9955037832260132, 0.11559193581342697, -0.528390645980835, -0.18087132275104523, 0.43614280223846436, 0.16011185944080353, -0.8752427697181702, 0.07843248546123505, 0.21309790015220642, 1.030031681060791, -0.739443838596344, 0.715951681137085, 0.06571011990308762, -0.2907397449016571, -0.26372548937797546, -0.07941810041666031, -0.07060326635837555, -0.7973525524139404, 0.4119356572628021, 0.40484631061553955, -0.03981858864426613, 0.08299706131219864, -0.028658589348196983, -0.8155251145362854, 1.1307011842727661, 0.008582819253206253, -0.5611867904663086, -0.011047040112316608, -0.14483077824115753, 0.6864352226257324, -0.4284570515155792, 0.46843424439430237, 1.0511066913604736, 0.23869118094444275, 0.08121103048324585, -0.7405717372894287, -0.17080095410346985, -0.19082577526569366, -0.1129608228802681, 0.02970166504383087, -0.4833126664161682, 0.6238759756088257, -0.33402207493782043, -0.264629602432251, 0.5931922197341919, 0.6688917875289917, 0.0840211808681488, 0.7945560216903687, 0.642862856388092, 0.35985925793647766, 0.9341781735420227, 0.013368215411901474, 1.3727835416793823, 0.18382833898067474, 0.23398186266422272, 1.7520122528076172, -0.232960045337677, 1.134610652923584, 0.4573076665401459, -0.5235170125961304, 0.3939237892627716, 0.4987172484397888, -0.4115697145462036, 1.0051240921020508, 0.4948674142360687, 0.17977707087993622, -0.0610143281519413, 0.16923344135284424, -0.45680153369903564, 0.3877972364425659, 0.4985322058200836, -0.6243781447410583, -0.4865676462650299, 0.04480903223156929, -0.2659183740615845, 0.05915115401148796, -0.4702043831348419, 0.7900870442390442, 0.2896815538406372, -0.458905428647995, 0.29876187443733215, -0.5862685441970825, 0.18734417855739594, -0.45636287331581116, -0.30319350957870483, -0.3863019645214081, 0.19104838371276855, 0.02897460013628006, -1.1878910064697266, 0.47849658131599426, 0.012089552357792854, -0.2876209616661072, -0.29262450337409973, 0.29776695370674133, -0.19371427595615387, -0.45618438720703125, 0.1460869163274765, 0.28738975524902344, 0.517344057559967, 0.00916361715644598, -0.6041054725646973, 0.20367422699928284, 0.07352494448423386, -0.33047807216644287, 0.12166765332221985, 0.4940965175628662, 0.25447583198547363, 0.5115979909896851, 0.344024658203125, -0.17938166856765747, -0.05158327519893646, 0.23685917258262634, 0.46784961223602295, -1.1526927947998047, -0.6465145349502563, -0.603451132774353, 0.4908701181411743, -0.22668679058551788, -0.8426680564880371, 1.019606590270996, 0.5824382901191711, 0.9620585441589355, -0.1450405865907669, 0.4788546562194824, 0.2915719747543335, 1.0899637937545776, -0.7719976902008057, 0.5587149858474731, -0.5108053088188171, 0.5516030192375183, -0.46089455485343933, -0.6949388384819031, -0.2606039345264435, 0.5772120952606201, -0.3706181049346924, -0.41379299759864807, 1.0632110834121704, 0.5590004324913025, 0.35714903473854065, 0.3839409649372101, 0.13995841145515442, 0.0951337069272995, -0.16494937241077423, 0.5551162362098694, 1.1173969507217407, -0.3280893564224243, 0.6161519885063171, -0.17219553887844086, -0.0941394716501236, -0.34798192977905273, -1.307063102722168, -1.265805721282959, -0.4309900999069214, -0.4739522337913513, -0.25758543610572815, 0.1473599076271057, 0.27636465430259705, 0.18988214433193207, -0.9085054993629456, 0.007615851704031229, 0.14500047266483307, 0.2580987811088562, -0.8268213868141174, -0.18862926959991455, 0.6570679545402527, 0.08956634253263474, -0.5841767191886902, 0.3931448757648468, 0.24946671724319458, -0.360010027885437, -0.06471602618694305, 0.5381414890289307, -0.013837159611284733, 0.06264945864677429, 0.4296344816684723, 0.40257102251052856, -0.5440378785133362, -0.48087549209594727, -0.4755949079990387, 0.24530266225337982, 0.2853868305683136, 1.18589186668396, -0.9549078345298767, 0.5870234966278076, 0.46032026410102844, 0.7285119891166687, 0.893933892250061, 0.14524003863334656, 0.6847240924835205, -0.780707597732544, -0.10660863667726517, 0.16628672182559967, 0.320798397064209, 0.174804225564003, -0.208573117852211, 0.5506079196929932, -0.06644535809755325, -0.42292195558547974, -1.034363865852356, 0.02392108552157879, -1.2589988708496094, -0.18015292286872864, 0.8436198234558105, -0.3884471654891968, -0.3201214373111725, -0.19975601136684418, -0.4158541262149811, -0.004960383288562298, -0.11265403032302856, 0.6567464470863342, 0.8911085724830627, -0.20194926857948303, -0.5030388832092285, -0.5136057734489441, 0.5281814336776733, 0.44430971145629883, -0.7384904026985168, 0.16959148645401, 0.09344058483839035, 0.2578330636024475, 0.08804064989089966, 0.5450729131698608, -0.07440390437841415, 0.13761267066001892, 0.43425795435905457, -0.33750298619270325, -0.13780735433101654, -0.5469195246696472, -0.10837095230817795, 0.13693316280841827, -0.4481615722179413, -0.3882816433906555 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07270v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07270v2	Open-ended VQA benchmarking of Vision-Language models by exploiting Classification datasets and their semantic hierarchy	2024-02-11T18:26:18	2024-05-05T20:34:28	Simon Ging, María A. Bravo, Thomas Brox	cs.CV	cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG	The evaluation of text-generative vision-language models is a challenging yet crucial endeavor. By addressing the limitations of existing Visual Question Answering (VQA) benchmarks and proposing innovative evaluation methodologies, our research seeks to advance our understanding of these models' capabilities. We propose a novel VQA benchmark based on well-known visual classification datasets which allows a granular evaluation of text-generative vision-language models and their comparison with discriminative vision-language models. To improve the assessment of coarse answers on fine-grained classification tasks, we suggest using the semantic hierarchy of the label space to ask automatically generated follow-up questions about the ground-truth category. Finally, we compare traditional NLP and LLM-based metrics for the problem of evaluating model predictions given ground-truth answers. We perform a human evaluation study upon which we base our decision on the final metric. We apply our benchmark to a suite of vision-language models and show a detailed comparison of their abilities on object, action, and attribute classification. Our contributions aim to lay the foundation for more precise and meaningful assessments, facilitating targeted progress in the exciting field of vision-language modeling.	[ -0.43305301666259766, -0.6756945252418518, 0.46040672063827515, -0.15986379981040955, -0.06535447388887405, -0.16155293583869934, -0.17758335173130035, -0.5228649973869324, -0.46513187885284424, 0.6578189134597778, -0.4188467860221863, -0.6160798668861389, -0.274922639131546, -0.09956784546375275, -0.5245804190635681, 0.5653099417686462, -0.06997009366750717, 0.230091854929924, -0.8342815041542053, -0.39725419878959656, -0.46701234579086304, -0.41479769349098206, -0.3015190660953522, -0.058551132678985596, 0.34460997581481934, 0.05554210767149925, 0.733879566192627, 0.5482988953590393, 0.8717654943466187, 0.3456271290779114, -0.17087778449058533, 0.14740926027297974, -0.38098376989364624, -0.22389838099479675, -0.29076242446899414, -0.3233269453048706, -0.3593955338001251, 0.01041493285447359, 0.6283403038978577, 0.9009497761726379, -0.22571693360805511, 0.6678138971328735, -0.047113869339227676, 0.5880132913589478, -0.9909715056419373, 0.10534149408340454, -0.6425838470458984, 0.20884959399700165, -0.03012530319392681, -0.17214274406433105, -0.3099198341369629, -0.38104602694511414, 0.2862570583820343, -0.5502156019210815, 0.16916750371456146, 0.06302876770496368, 1.1813009977340698, 0.4667024612426758, -0.1188969761133194, 0.08439010381698608, -0.5829257965087891, 0.6730231046676636, -0.41151124238967896, 0.549416184425354, 0.10227036476135254, 0.71341872215271, 0.2799171209335327, -0.8862311244010925, -0.5782691240310669, -0.36626219749450684, 0.2485383301973343, 0.35934871435165405, -0.41924846172332764, -0.061134517192840576, 0.16166338324546814, 0.5362774729728699, -0.6434270143508911, 0.02494705840945244, -0.42257896065711975, 0.030182892456650734, 0.3091565668582916, 0.32244646549224854, 0.250649094581604, -0.18974606692790985, -0.646165668964386, -0.24699218571186066, -0.309555321931839, 0.13925708830356598, -0.056501295417547226, 0.09670380502939224, 0.06068290397524834, 0.8308344483375549, -0.8475767970085144, 1.0378563404083252, -0.32896918058395386, 0.1430874913930893, 0.38970646262168884, -0.4293449819087982, -0.5130583643913269, -0.519430935382843, 0.7132006287574768, 0.9787449240684509, 0.4137752652168274, -0.29960060119628906, -0.15087144076824188, 0.2705853283405304, 0.3740904629230499, -0.7242521643638611, -0.0712229460477829, -0.049655135720968246, -0.3555155098438263, -0.4816441237926483, -0.0944422036409378, -0.8554905652999878, -0.2848099172115326, -0.3063978850841522, 0.7520829439163208, -0.05716731771826744, 0.0635998472571373, 0.36991456151008606, -0.22824960947036743, 0.7147015929222107, 0.5734084248542786, -0.5857903957366943, 0.5384259223937988, 0.5586890578269958, 0.5374312996864319, -0.22949500381946564, -0.2540367841720581, -0.4650047719478607, -0.21016578376293182, -0.5041406154632568, 0.8442044854164124, -0.5053358674049377, 0.15900391340255737, 0.05852172523736954, -0.2629004716873169, 0.1367146372795105, -0.8720770478248596, 0.6289040446281433, -0.5175487995147705, 0.2387312799692154, -0.34156084060668945, -0.39192426204681396, -0.24395757913589478, 0.5663126707077026, -0.42604705691337585, 1.2056224346160889, 0.2728992700576782, -0.7487744688987732, 0.6413329839706421, -0.1919006109237671, 0.20285283029079437, 0.4806283116340637, -0.4390428960323334, -0.28425687551498413, 0.18564799427986145, 0.33997511863708496, 0.5164415836334229, -0.7845731973648071, 0.2511753737926483, -0.2977983057498932, -0.24715788662433624, 0.1782998889684677, -0.6180148124694824, 0.5772157311439514, -0.12037684768438339, -0.1497071087360382, 0.1507432609796524, -0.8562778830528259, 0.5376655459403992, 0.10248042643070221, -0.2078055739402771, -0.46549639105796814, 0.014105062931776047, -0.04491487890481949, 0.28436198830604553, 0.25147321820259094, -0.45930513739585876, 0.050380121916532516, -0.12848010659217834, -0.01731974445283413, 0.6293214559555054, -0.197347953915596, 0.23525258898735046, -0.15343914926052094, 0.31186121702194214, -0.01566135324537754, 0.37207138538360596, 0.03273314610123634, -0.566154420375824, -0.9813777804374695, -0.034217577427625656, 0.3440142273902893, 0.6903762221336365, -1.0570666790008545, 0.1740584820508957, -0.607780933380127, -0.6592278480529785, -0.574285626411438, 0.05058658868074417, 0.7103413343429565, 0.7831552624702454, 0.5014446377754211, -0.7346850633621216, -0.13738086819648743, -0.9453006982803345, -0.33497270941734314, -0.4785987138748169, -0.19900281727313995, 0.5628182291984558, 0.559109091758728, 0.003581179305911064, 0.8592080473899841, -0.5687747597694397, -0.0516141839325428, 0.07360389083623886, 0.05195465683937073, -0.06324481964111328, 0.1191616877913475, 0.5207698345184326, -1.0487323999404907, -0.061023734509944916, 0.06578440219163895, -0.9702966809272766, -0.2598424255847931, 0.2015058696269989, -0.12350471317768097, -0.2262306958436966, 0.42233604192733765, -0.2934103310108185, 0.6050084829330444, 0.3767474591732025, -0.3894622325897217, 0.6851356625556946, 0.009698356501758099, 0.42420700192451477, -0.6144798994064331, 0.038771845400333405, 0.10452642291784286, -0.12642790377140045, -0.6096791625022888, 0.4635058045387268, 0.10644307732582092, 0.03941774368286133, -0.7818791270256042, 0.7090728878974915, -0.06556003540754318, -0.5876463055610657, 0.11043573170900345, 0.2476368546485901, -0.03497830405831337, 0.6073195934295654, 0.2763713002204895, 0.7907134294509888, 0.6585937142372131, -0.5530356764793396, 0.5052870512008667, 0.3806903064250946, -0.7876428365707397, 0.673146665096283, -0.7927557826042175, -0.21255293488502502, -0.20239731669425964, -0.22422538697719574, -1.052230715751648, -0.02445179782807827, 0.19231639802455902, -0.4028802514076233, -0.27336832880973816, -0.11093367636203766, -0.4918791949748993, -0.4648059010505676, -0.08686015009880066, 0.5356099009513855, 0.5962833166122437, -0.6157147884368896, 0.48687538504600525, 0.19350263476371765, -0.07365452498197556, -0.618963360786438, -0.6054973602294922, 0.13803252577781677, -0.09230362623929977, -0.6159929633140564, 0.35671496391296387, -0.10074658691883087, -0.44052472710609436, -0.00024846786982379854, -0.23127001523971558, -0.34970271587371826, -0.011930566281080246, 0.0869857668876648, 0.33881065249443054, -0.378574937582016, 0.022106511518359184, -0.34135547280311584, -0.062016427516937256, -0.01650630496442318, -0.23091191053390503, 0.33041584491729736, -0.6295887231826782, -0.22862641513347626, -0.14256641268730164, 0.0869193896651268, 0.5263213515281677, -0.5842377543449402, 0.3798668384552002, 0.4977051913738251, -0.3648281693458557, -0.05283508077263832, -0.4911750555038452, 0.23251031339168549, -0.44253993034362793, 0.5535159111022949, -0.4613397717475891, -0.6997803449630737, 0.13916566967964172, -0.08990436792373657, 0.0853324607014656, 0.4276457130908966, 0.7439665198326111, -0.12883438169956207, 0.6701087355613708, 0.7502890229225159, 0.2968631982803345, 0.3010835349559784, -0.17254526913166046, -0.2204395979642868, -0.7034351229667664, -0.31818312406539917, -0.5426785349845886, 0.15297017991542816, -0.3448174297809601, -0.8196329474449158, 0.347350537776947, 0.1610543429851532, -0.17240245640277863, 0.3962949812412262, -0.40902119874954224, 0.4838531017303467, 0.4615025222301483, 0.17364344000816345, 0.3422696888446808, 0.09935982525348663, -0.24556732177734375, 0.07318945229053497, -0.6210939288139343, -0.6157838106155396, 0.8728041648864746, 0.3137321472167969, 0.644062340259552, -0.11207552999258041, 0.3521442711353302, 0.1163771003484726, 0.2887226939201355, -0.79803866147995, 0.7864119410514832, -0.3295966386795044, -0.40299150347709656, -0.25065121054649353, -0.4976610541343689, -0.4173465073108673, 0.6395601630210876, -0.2365342676639557, -0.8891385793685913, 0.18527142703533173, -0.033675890415906906, -0.13284069299697876, 0.2226366251707077, -0.6078011989593506, 1.2484146356582642, -0.2527095377445221, -0.32823145389556885, 0.15212218463420868, -0.48273298144340515, 0.3819462060928345, 0.15161219239234924, 0.10653559118509293, -0.1629650890827179, -0.24280773103237152, 0.7118650674819946, -0.32066893577575684, 0.6197210550308228, 0.0071541788056492805, -0.17579208314418793, 0.3218574523925781, -0.23035244643688202, -0.23644764721393585, -0.21245375275611877, 0.07383028417825699, 0.38680827617645264, 0.05449303984642029, -0.4555572271347046, -0.7468993067741394, 0.25018829107284546, -0.6067067384719849, -0.27473124861717224, -0.2665671408176422, -0.19649207592010498, -0.47330522537231445, 0.10807421058416367, 0.1941651552915573, 0.6897404193878174, -0.34420788288116455, 0.2381320595741272, 0.685272216796875, -0.36341971158981323, 0.2164538949728012, 0.47308170795440674, -0.3860088586807251, -0.40033870935440063, 0.7766125202178955, -0.1662348508834839, 0.5186711549758911, 0.7258932590484619, 0.11641732603311539, -0.20614144206047058, -0.6015480160713196, -0.6990848779678345, -0.2993089556694031, -1.0219719409942627, -0.16781656444072723, -0.5433174967765808, -0.264523983001709, -0.012593800202012062, 0.0782046765089035, -0.30099356174468994, -0.3044038414955139, 0.16709254682064056, 0.08919483423233032, 0.09616289287805557, 0.374948114156723, 0.4067758023738861, 0.126305490732193, -0.5377291440963745, 0.8923242688179016, 0.6998075842857361, 0.5527093410491943, -0.09919528663158417, -0.471244752407074, 0.026511428877711296, -0.10761305689811707, -0.19033046066761017, -0.6111270785331726, 0.0487683080136776, 0.20508815348148346, 0.5455024242401123, 0.03838995844125748, -0.0972968190908432, 0.7958869934082031, -0.7276638150215149, 0.8644940853118896, 0.31396976113319397, -0.7767083048820496, 0.4250974655151367, -0.16969698667526245, 0.4845302700996399, 0.7211351990699768, 0.12583988904953003, -0.45153170824050903, -0.32201334834098816, -0.230413556098938, -0.8616111874580383, 0.353378027677536, 0.4605225622653961, -0.05497055873274803, 0.08606398105621338, 0.23728793859481812, -0.05956703796982765, 0.33715444803237915, -0.7697213888168335, -0.1775611788034439, -0.20649269223213196, -0.1610514372587204, -0.10886366665363312, -0.027310911566019058, 0.0625748410820961, -0.4148709177970886, 0.31266650557518005, -0.2922050654888153, 0.18618710339069366, 0.11154825240373611, -0.11836685985326767, 0.08301540464162827, 0.2680680751800537, 0.2104971557855606, 0.6495627760887146, -0.09266415238380432, 0.06871487200260162, 0.4518599212169647, -0.46336883306503296, -0.07313764840364456, 0.030421046540141106, -0.41668185591697693, -0.03447704017162323, 0.4267369210720062, 0.7872779965400696, 0.16908128559589386, -1.0063046216964722, 0.8304279446601868, -0.4449195861816406, -0.26862213015556335, -0.11436785012483597, 0.11367752403020859, -0.08751760423183441, 0.19186128675937653, 0.3107067346572876, 0.28104424476623535, 0.34539175033569336, -0.4964753985404968, 0.2591387629508972, 0.2811214029788971, -0.647933304309845, 0.08376529067754745, 0.576528012752533, -0.024240737780928612, -0.0418652668595314, 0.31579938530921936, 0.16283822059631348, -0.5305474996566772, 0.7062452435493469, -0.007813450880348682, 0.8695114850997925, 0.11563276499509811, 0.3908448815345764, 0.24978899955749512, 0.34729239344596863, 0.11039526015520096, 0.5155357122421265, -0.3062925636768341, -0.7261720299720764, -0.30579495429992676, -0.9592329859733582, -0.5073398947715759, 0.0642029345035553, -0.8671146035194397, 0.17600834369659424, -0.31330984830856323, 0.06951086223125458, 0.37925857305526733, -0.16343313455581665, -0.8569782972335815, 0.7637428641319275, 0.29004302620887756, 1.0598846673965454, -0.6841128468513489, 0.4685530662536621, 0.7289000153541565, -0.41704273223876953, -0.2917861342430115, 0.09101150184869766, -0.26511213183403015, -0.789979100227356, 0.7952518463134766, 0.3458331823348999, -0.33073607087135315, -0.16602787375450134, -0.6470847129821777, -0.6142550110816956, 1.0233285427093506, 0.15715910494327545, -0.41662535071372986, -0.06225435808300972, 0.17511825263500214, 0.7147318124771118, -0.23475928604602814, 0.2694382071495056, 0.38477084040641785, 0.2686729431152344, 0.18546238541603088, -0.9722424745559692, -0.195924311876297, -0.45047998428344727, 0.2503577768802643, 0.11624740064144135, -0.42415064573287964, 0.5782071948051453, -0.11620739847421646, -0.25181543827056885, 0.4823015630245209, 0.7741920948028564, 0.0020589963532984257, 0.30947208404541016, 0.502324104309082, 0.7525185346603394, 0.47482824325561523, -0.33792707324028015, 1.1002135276794434, 0.04367787018418312, 0.3772355616092682, 1.0905545949935913, -0.18607625365257263, 1.2072402238845825, 0.36956116557121277, -0.2434614598751068, 0.3107515573501587, 0.44259390234947205, -0.1760682612657547, 0.6117268800735474, 0.4354504644870758, -0.14867259562015533, -0.4582058787345886, -0.25177982449531555, -0.08274751901626587, 0.6143103837966919, 0.17223986983299255, -0.02790232002735138, -0.448839008808136, 0.006797934416681528, -0.6920892000198364, 0.23572134971618652, -0.6142152547836304, 0.8804971575737, -0.159738689661026, -0.600680410861969, 0.7904344797134399, -0.003669800003990531, 0.4175156056880951, -0.289344847202301, 0.014792561531066895, 0.06218447908759117, 0.20506717264652252, 0.08148670196533203, -0.9476275444030762, 0.09541019052267075, 0.3494393527507782, -0.09206419438123703, -0.10298158973455429, 0.5273599028587341, -0.4051281809806824, -0.4523744583129883, 0.1899184137582779, 0.52326899766922, 0.054970633238554, 0.026873592287302017, -0.7536752223968506, -0.04944441840052605, -0.3966566324234009, -0.00601239874958992, 0.03294292092323303, 0.29028838872909546, -0.15534855425357819, 0.8675115704536438, 0.32702645659446716, -0.23470881581306458, 0.26325222849845886, 0.1453450620174408, 0.8534903526306152, -0.5919498801231384, -0.3119053542613983, -0.5688656568527222, 0.5563710331916809, -0.11334507912397385, -0.6630691885948181, 0.5459595322608948, 0.6049890518188477, 1.162087321281433, -0.18479347229003906, 0.6653264760971069, -0.10351566970348358, 0.3264022767543793, -0.712192714214325, 0.4132838547229767, -0.837518572807312, -0.0016072270227596164, -0.678676962852478, -0.9608228802680969, -0.26330867409706116, 0.40899476408958435, -0.3491800129413605, 0.08130017668008804, 0.5434682369232178, 0.49332454800605774, -0.0034593776799738407, -0.24019211530685425, 0.6349610090255737, 0.07349088788032532, -0.05405062437057495, 0.6584250330924988, 1.1680947542190552, -0.7123228311538696, 0.5637980699539185, -0.2512122094631195, -0.4196363389492035, -0.04304904490709305, -0.7972424626350403, -0.9219064712524414, -0.7532938122749329, -0.4496006965637207, -0.06681355088949203, 0.26256662607192993, 0.3293967843055725, 0.6403698921203613, -0.5349203944206238, -0.10429181158542633, -0.09465311467647552, -0.21129284799098969, -0.44753074645996094, -0.2148919552564621, 0.2821497619152069, -0.025261500850319862, -0.5505357384681702, 0.06863896548748016, 0.4361534118652344, 0.11580790579319, -0.31214362382888794, 0.0670052096247673, 0.08844391256570816, 0.06560329347848892, 0.7367324233055115, 0.18260620534420013, -0.9974023699760437, -0.17759685218334198, 0.0943775326013565, -0.22340762615203857, 0.061731837689876556, 0.36205270886421204, -1.0381367206573486, 0.5587696433067322, 0.49549636244773865, 0.8422677516937256, 0.3408012390136719, 0.14547042548656464, 0.47328588366508484, -0.5926061272621155, -0.13422060012817383, 0.2748100161552429, 0.2710692584514618, 0.42504391074180603, 0.07446101307868958, 0.5558294057846069, 0.06875091046094894, -0.10233046859502792, -0.7315749526023865, 0.2996978163719177, -1.1473283767700195, -0.22681716084480286, 0.9701424837112427, -0.21920575201511383, -0.43477481603622437, 0.16346998512744904, -0.2254367619752884, -0.15665370225906372, 0.23213720321655273, 0.48113346099853516, 0.6129423975944519, 0.3100301921367645, -0.3578758239746094, -0.7204503417015076, 0.3268577754497528, 0.27750086784362793, -1.0576767921447754, 0.2816126048564911, 0.5403198003768921, 0.05075010284781456, 0.12358111888170242, 0.49769848585128784, -0.2571737468242645, 0.6188750863075256, 0.10646343976259232, 0.06757418066263199, 0.1089153066277504, -0.6763947010040283, -0.33460283279418945, 0.3300641179084778, -0.11827510595321655, -0.24382279813289642 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07262v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07262v1	Low-Resource Counterspeech Generation for Indic Languages: The Case of Bengali and Hindi	2024-02-11T18:09:50	2024-02-11T18:09:50	Mithun Das, Saurabh Kumar Pandey, Shivansh Sethi, Punyajoy Saha, Animesh Mukherjee	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.HC	With the rise of online abuse, the NLP community has begun investigating the use of neural architectures to generate counterspeech that can "counter" the vicious tone of such abusive speech and dilute/ameliorate their rippling effect over the social network. However, most of the efforts so far have been primarily focused on English. To bridge the gap for low-resource languages such as Bengali and Hindi, we create a benchmark dataset of 5,062 abusive speech/counterspeech pairs, of which 2,460 pairs are in Bengali and 2,602 pairs are in Hindi. We implement several baseline models considering various interlingual transfer mechanisms with different configurations to generate suitable counterspeech to set up an effective benchmark. We observe that the monolingual setup yields the best performance. Further, using synthetic transfer, language models can generate counterspeech to some extent; specifically, we notice that transferability is better when languages belong to the same language family.	[ -0.45832908153533936, -0.6501908302307129, -0.16495630145072937, 0.6331830620765686, -0.1990848034620285, 0.28713372349739075, -0.16798949241638184, -0.8154599070549011, 0.4458725154399872, 0.397754043340683, -0.3405758738517761, 0.22174550592899323, -0.625853955745697, 0.36498552560806274, -0.5680612325668335, 0.8804967403411865, 0.3468081057071686, 0.18456068634986877, 0.04925823211669922, -0.4322853982448578, -0.5246225595474243, -0.49282002449035645, -0.8345072269439697, -0.48591727018356323, 0.11028414964675903, 0.4089112877845764, 0.5430445671081543, 0.20234626531600952, 0.47219014167785645, 0.31845590472221375, 0.003344645258039236, 0.05779600888490677, -0.45073288679122925, 0.19757062196731567, -0.5108019709587097, -0.2510565221309662, -0.17839790880680084, -0.2879828214645386, 0.43017035722732544, 0.6166636347770691, -0.21312135457992554, 0.4683922827243805, 0.1485617458820343, 0.6574292182922363, -0.8177574872970581, -0.029553253203630447, -0.9564589858055115, -0.04270806908607483, -0.5354992151260376, -0.2501445412635803, -0.5186966061592102, -0.34373804926872253, -0.3102114498615265, -0.3010154366493225, 0.00013330808724276721, -0.1614025980234146, 0.516501784324646, 0.37363573908805847, 0.0713367909193039, -0.23538237810134888, -0.5507941246032715, 0.6820076107978821, -0.8039977550506592, 0.20499281585216522, 0.6034500598907471, 0.22073014080524445, 0.08328291773796082, -0.620048463344574, -0.6450468301773071, -0.14649252593517303, -0.20114561915397644, 0.0676579549908638, -0.3264179229736328, -0.28094446659088135, 0.32182833552360535, 0.04706151410937309, -0.6777396202087402, 0.1690286248922348, -0.5371589064598083, -0.06869003176689148, 0.608581006526947, 0.23245540261268616, 0.6916977763175964, -0.42208799719810486, -0.525543212890625, 0.21956850588321686, -0.8955661058425903, 0.03811836242675781, 0.5216320157051086, 0.8204816579818726, -0.41384556889533997, 0.5078670382499695, -0.1458120048046112, 0.8700984120368958, -0.03281554579734802, -0.10194391012191772, 0.029696762561798096, -0.660605788230896, 0.09445936232805252, 0.37520644068717957, 0.8309451341629028, 0.36854809522628784, 0.731747567653656, 0.018254421651363373, -0.01459236815571785, 0.34697893261909485, 0.3792470395565033, -0.8349325656890869, -0.10712943971157074, -0.16513054072856903, -0.4148117005825043, -0.3434809446334839, -0.6527546048164368, -1.1794183254241943, -0.6844050884246826, -0.27185380458831787, 0.09675233066082001, -0.5776703953742981, -0.557938814163208, -0.3296946585178375, -0.06390701234340668, 0.26728248596191406, -0.1276358962059021, -1.0764617919921875, 0.7979065775871277, 0.3858623504638672, 1.0437071323394775, -0.2988612651824951, -0.2568451166152954, -0.33985379338264465, -0.09086184203624725, -0.33526045083999634, 0.906714141368866, -0.7291086912155151, -0.3925144374370575, 0.20294854044914246, -0.5262742638587952, -0.10373826324939728, -0.7367671132087708, 0.16161991655826569, -0.3494352102279663, -0.1975998729467392, -0.25910747051239014, -0.08312590420246124, 0.149080291390419, 0.12787865102291107, -0.5444751977920532, 1.0602171421051025, 0.243865504860878, -0.874160885810852, 0.1919236183166504, -0.5892655253410339, -0.6794904470443726, 0.43892401456832886, -0.1011064425110817, -0.049386732280254364, 0.09151551872491837, 0.10130693018436432, 0.008883257396519184, -0.5403763651847839, -0.2183358371257782, -0.1033463254570961, -0.4038159251213074, 0.09778983891010284, -0.40789899230003357, 1.1684367656707764, 0.6121748089790344, -0.30558115243911743, -0.3004865348339081, -0.8185767531394958, 0.12412509322166443, 0.1919466108083725, -0.22486260533332825, -0.5882895588874817, -0.042392078787088394, 0.24788859486579895, 0.24639096856117249, -0.10366327315568924, -0.5940577387809753, 0.027693195268511772, -0.5311387777328491, 0.3893949091434479, 0.6623557209968567, 0.07300850749015808, 0.3295973837375641, -0.20940101146697998, 0.6336203217506409, -0.045638058334589005, -0.02325737662613392, 0.1345931887626648, -0.379836767911911, -0.5454853177070618, -0.014867966063320637, 0.1214507445693016, 0.5948894619941711, -1.0739165544509888, -0.20563441514968872, -0.25257864594459534, -0.579498827457428, -0.8391575813293457, 0.197056382894516, 0.7524927258491516, 0.6595142483711243, 0.4723269045352936, -0.4777960777282715, -0.6926727294921875, -1.0752750635147095, -0.5871526598930359, -0.30277958512306213, 0.34479719400405884, -0.060382187366485596, 0.03194070979952812, 0.17973144352436066, 0.782122790813446, -0.008767513558268547, -0.02088162675499916, -0.4408939480781555, 0.307441771030426, 0.029565755277872086, 0.4436050057411194, 0.9469963312149048, -0.7069001793861389, -1.0978842973709106, -0.26588648557662964, -0.40379971265792847, -0.4847181737422943, -0.0310466717928648, 0.08282668143510818, 0.5701643824577332, 0.6005340814590454, -0.3224838078022003, 0.35436418652534485, 0.7709017992019653, -0.2172185331583023, 0.5989725589752197, 0.3302849233150482, 0.2196640968322754, -1.2401628494262695, 0.14373056590557098, -0.22477853298187256, -0.17224623262882233, -0.7082677483558655, 0.05233480781316757, -0.3854482173919678, -0.24607084691524506, -0.7127237915992737, 0.9174938797950745, -0.23516663908958435, 0.05035056546330452, -0.26245760917663574, 0.16425901651382446, -0.5445429086685181, 0.4683797359466553, -0.1491885930299759, 1.1486713886260986, 0.22341057658195496, -0.45861753821372986, 0.18946358561515808, 0.2823077142238617, -0.4701639711856842, 0.7858999371528625, -0.3603540360927582, 0.18893292546272278, 0.16565757989883423, -0.18190942704677582, -1.025473952293396, 0.012054993771016598, 0.21624864637851715, -0.6148878931999207, 0.33576592803001404, -0.486380010843277, -0.3889560401439667, -0.005161781795322895, -0.13717226684093475, 0.6354109048843384, 0.49220573902130127, -0.6137306690216064, 0.4042280316352844, 0.6572443842887878, -0.5971086621284485, -0.7945721745491028, -0.9153656363487244, 0.33712053298950195, -0.041775330901145935, -0.288827121257782, 0.011784532107412815, -0.1298993080854416, -0.6663534641265869, 0.026025347411632538, 0.2238284796476364, 0.004950380884110928, -0.09149409830570221, 0.3085082173347473, 0.07277511805295944, 0.01373536791652441, -0.014780988916754723, -0.22721609473228455, -0.03561136871576309, 0.057839639484882355, 0.14467063546180725, 1.1120203733444214, -0.12443585693836212, -0.20490439236164093, -0.10088829696178436, 0.5548738241195679, 0.4205583930015564, -0.2552938759326935, 0.8385210633277893, 0.5403282642364502, -0.4246174693107605, -0.4052431583404541, -0.42837393283843994, -0.10768714547157288, -0.4628010094165802, 0.47212764620780945, -0.6497926115989685, -0.3789525032043457, 0.6012510657310486, -0.060192715376615524, -0.2572211027145386, 0.42589083313941956, 0.8900565505027771, 0.22996070981025696, 0.744067907333374, 0.47285032272338867, -0.3260069191455841, 0.4532945156097412, 0.13133226335048676, 0.49053576588630676, -0.5899646878242493, 0.042552828788757324, -0.6356776356697083, -0.24394327402114868, -0.9598173499107361, -0.004337262362241745, 0.19243770837783813, 0.08041971176862717, -0.2666289806365967, 0.6315011978149414, -0.5654631853103638, 0.46150079369544983, 0.45946618914604187, -0.23473487794399261, 0.08502738922834396, 0.34321755170822144, -0.13888224959373474, -0.3230462074279785, -0.958121657371521, -0.29619860649108887, 0.6641930341720581, -0.1209779605269432, 0.6196213960647583, 0.30866333842277527, 0.38614165782928467, 0.511021077632904, 0.6461578011512756, -0.47876715660095215, 0.6313836574554443, -0.42529815435409546, -0.6833558678627014, -0.06348595023155212, -0.3386901915073395, -0.7572329640388489, 0.06002385541796684, -0.26995885372161865, -0.8279207944869995, 0.14296120405197144, 0.10208778828382492, -0.22171419858932495, 0.5371370911598206, -0.7583396434783936, 0.48081448674201965, -0.05755780637264252, -0.590292751789093, -0.3403085768222809, -0.5133855938911438, 0.5369106531143188, -0.06393072754144669, 0.24524295330047607, -0.09645207226276398, 0.2105637937784195, 0.5931100249290466, -0.3187490999698639, 0.8932493329048157, -0.17189665138721466, 0.25164443254470825, 0.5263146162033081, 0.5241776704788208, 0.35876181721687317, -0.20426490902900696, -0.2565840184688568, 0.3853454291820526, -0.06349220871925354, -0.45033982396125793, -0.2253202497959137, 0.7457441687583923, -0.6866145133972168, -0.22944757342338562, -0.36841657757759094, -0.45804157853126526, -0.36974507570266724, 0.1645449846982956, 0.47943007946014404, 0.35238364338874817, -0.020846040919423103, 0.054247986525297165, 0.09044007956981659, -0.23442259430885315, 0.7851928472518921, 0.5635801553726196, -0.09677928686141968, -0.3795887529850006, 1.0904046297073364, 0.2772318720817566, 0.28925952315330505, 0.019829249009490013, 0.1117829978466034, -0.2032133787870407, -0.5371232032775879, -0.4327336549758911, 0.12568950653076172, -0.5822975039482117, -0.5237774848937988, -0.4475667178630829, -0.6325785517692566, -0.6148781180381775, -0.16554032266139984, -0.6523098945617676, -0.45852500200271606, 0.22660993039608002, 0.0778111070394516, 0.33096611499786377, 0.9682391285896301, -0.44300955533981323, 0.2624712288379669, -0.7240993976593018, 0.41262081265449524, 0.23777112364768982, 0.637105405330658, 0.07919318228960037, -0.7526293992996216, -0.1597682386636734, -0.21396124362945557, 0.1382286250591278, -0.880580723285675, 0.5778851509094238, 0.09401080757379532, 0.24104146659374237, 0.05718635395169258, 0.31613850593566895, 0.8080931901931763, -0.6261078715324402, 0.7553196549415588, 0.42860448360443115, -0.7984709739685059, 0.3930457532405853, -0.234389528632164, 0.23784929513931274, 0.7579678297042847, 0.48891279101371765, -0.8500134348869324, -0.3049566149711609, -0.4501267373561859, -1.0412468910217285, 0.6635685563087463, 0.12324582040309906, 0.3486572206020355, -0.2938356101512909, 0.1818058341741562, 0.16530349850654602, -0.027127020061016083, -0.7498880624771118, -0.204027459025383, -0.2642846703529358, -0.19146127998828888, 0.2167736142873764, -0.4543408155441284, -0.20511053502559662, -0.16540081799030304, 0.4495062530040741, -0.005751324817538261, 0.09189068526029587, 0.009359595365822315, -0.21248836815357208, -0.3694238066673279, 0.16878771781921387, 0.5946507453918457, 0.70779949426651, -0.0021439692936837673, 0.22987167537212372, 0.3997672200202942, -0.7347166538238525, 0.07019782066345215, -0.10917384177446365, -0.25910472869873047, -0.14972494542598724, 0.6309347152709961, 0.6279487013816833, 0.10936490446329117, -0.6339955925941467, 0.36550888419151306, 0.06788673251867294, 0.24687109887599945, -0.604561984539032, -0.045399539172649384, 0.04847213998436928, 0.08104786276817322, 0.11561203002929688, 0.29731911420822144, -0.09445442259311676, -0.6129816770553589, 0.26649171113967896, 0.2871454358100891, -0.3159583806991577, -0.39249560236930847, 0.5022245645523071, 0.3098354637622833, -0.6663069128990173, 0.8003718852996826, -0.3117160499095917, -0.5586721897125244, 0.2808142900466919, 0.7920746207237244, 0.746618926525116, -0.41318824887275696, 0.16031046211719513, 0.7741690874099731, 0.47163087129592896, 0.273257315158844, 0.39096567034721375, 0.05161154642701149, -0.7836307883262634, -0.469157874584198, -0.9456610083580017, -0.3000677824020386, 0.28985199332237244, -0.616567075252533, 0.14391109347343445, -0.572412371635437, -0.10848803073167801, -0.01853647269308567, -0.02297510765492916, -0.6604598164558411, -0.15857499837875366, 0.310263067483902, 0.8663886785507202, -1.0996075868606567, 0.7423000931739807, 0.4678521752357483, -0.6488208770751953, -0.5530992746353149, -0.23025508224964142, 0.2023879885673523, -1.0551108121871948, 0.8276398777961731, -0.1845657080411911, -0.33902671933174133, -0.07145615667104721, -0.6421347260475159, -0.7857551574707031, 0.34023767709732056, 0.3580385744571686, -0.5926861763000488, 0.34587299823760986, 0.5217075943946838, 0.8367654085159302, -0.26764774322509766, 0.13277381658554077, 0.624136209487915, 0.4833684265613556, -0.17446944117546082, -0.9219751954078674, 0.1577107310295105, -0.6291273832321167, -0.19484153389930725, 0.11281585693359375, -0.8404399752616882, 0.9158617258071899, 0.10372211784124374, -0.41613468527793884, 0.02916039153933525, 0.16494137048721313, 0.10745960474014282, -0.06488577276468277, 0.5024611353874207, 0.730262279510498, 0.05873522907495499, 0.06644836068153381, 1.2655621767044067, -0.5071373581886292, -0.33624267578125, 1.4536229372024536, -0.3461960554122925, 0.983810544013977, 0.5523850321769714, -0.34919872879981995, 0.389049232006073, 0.2950555384159088, 0.1908504068851471, 0.3163476586341858, 0.3341893255710602, -0.20242375135421753, 0.03533200919628143, -0.7019051313400269, -0.18626905977725983, 0.8202588558197021, 0.3470171391963959, 0.17714595794677734, -0.25345978140830994, -0.11959575116634369, 0.12831498682498932, 0.5492496490478516, -0.2569658160209656, 0.9102960824966431, -0.004989883862435818, -0.7454980611801147, 0.6795764565467834, -0.2317856252193451, 0.6791868805885315, -0.6424793004989624, -0.259685754776001, -0.6148083209991455, 0.1313839703798294, -0.2313733696937561, -0.645358681678772, 0.6276480555534363, 0.24972249567508698, -0.11155405640602112, -0.2878784239292145, 0.9037662148475647, -0.499087929725647, -0.33192241191864014, 0.7543536424636841, 0.5175058245658875, 0.21523144841194153, 0.11319809406995773, -0.6055904626846313, 0.10423620790243149, -0.16993552446365356, -0.08078818023204803, 0.621194064617157, 0.03608755022287369, -0.17607545852661133, 0.5150395035743713, 0.5705659985542297, 0.8447225093841553, 0.43806248903274536, 0.27264052629470825, 0.7950709462165833, -0.5015899538993835, -0.11786247044801712, -0.7658311724662781, 0.33213603496551514, -0.17072699964046478, -0.4017314910888672, 0.6173577904701233, 0.3618922233581543, 1.0602868795394897, 0.05673997849225998, 0.6986311674118042, -0.28868457674980164, 0.6959044933319092, -0.35119786858558655, 1.0100077390670776, -0.43302053213119507, -0.08144665509462357, -0.13786576688289642, -0.8330413699150085, 0.02610299177467823, 0.24360506236553192, 0.1190590038895607, -0.13823242485523224, 0.5017972588539124, 0.8869655728340149, 0.08786497265100479, -0.2198660522699356, 0.2685619592666626, 0.3934672176837921, 0.1144573912024498, 0.3283531367778778, 0.7233272790908813, -0.3697682321071625, 0.6150175333023071, -0.37325745820999146, -0.08123915642499924, -0.0012941864551976323, -0.6770110726356506, -0.6211927533149719, -0.6659858226776123, 0.019728923216462135, -0.44694408774375916, 0.11458925902843475, 0.9627900123596191, 0.5624053478240967, -1.0272818803787231, -0.5135402679443359, 0.14712506532669067, -0.054470546543598175, -0.1618463397026062, -0.28574565052986145, 0.16564428806304932, -0.5954920053482056, -0.857546865940094, 0.5560060143470764, 0.36165112257003784, -0.21160854399204254, -0.279462993144989, 0.08574534207582474, -0.7530866861343384, 0.29594558477401733, 0.7626490592956543, 0.6513352990150452, -0.35102954506874084, -0.2117500752210617, -0.25848764181137085, -0.3377588093280792, -0.03151712194085121, 1.0435317754745483, -0.737094521522522, 0.7139975428581238, 0.7905408143997192, 0.7456852793693542, 0.20341283082962036, -0.02765914611518383, 0.3686233460903168, -1.1777608394622803, 0.5532436966896057, 0.36690807342529297, 0.2464652806520462, 0.4816635847091675, -0.05022091418504715, 0.7998567223548889, 0.301350474357605, -0.20279675722122192, -1.0907986164093018, 0.2961375117301941, -0.5518854856491089, -0.45000797510147095, 1.015438199043274, 0.2724008560180664, -0.07949075102806091, -0.294953316450119, 0.11646901816129684, 0.3470524847507477, -0.08016310632228851, 1.0630111694335938, 0.7087658643722534, -0.27141568064689636, -0.2678174078464508, -0.4478510916233063, 0.8193606734275818, 0.44704869389533997, -0.7416929602622986, 0.139837846159935, 0.04090280830860138, 0.15129218995571136, 0.5156856775283813, 0.8651599287986755, -0.24063915014266968, 0.10997599363327026, 0.5784600973129272, 0.26004141569137573, 0.004966217093169689, -0.28379306197166443, -0.20811103284358978, 0.16656549274921417, -0.054930634796619415, 0.1140209510922432 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07255v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07255v1	American Sign Language Video to Text Translation	2024-02-11T17:46:33	2024-02-11T17:46:33	Parsheeta Roy, Ji-Eun Han, Srishti Chouhan, Bhaavanaa Thumu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CV	Sign language to text is a crucial technology that can break down communication barriers for individuals with hearing difficulties. We replicate and try to improve on a recently published study. We evaluate models using BLEU and rBLEU metrics to ensure translation quality. During our ablation study, we found that the model's performance is significantly influenced by optimizers, activation functions, and label smoothing. Further research aims to refine visual feature capturing, enhance decoder utilization, and integrate pre-trained decoders for better translation outcomes. Our source code is available to facilitate replication of our results and encourage future research.	[ -0.03543752431869507, -0.7246525287628174, 0.2881890535354614, 0.3421782851219177, -0.640548050403595, 0.04360416904091835, 0.06902383267879486, -0.7760632038116455, -0.21241159737110138, 0.6331415772438049, -0.18014812469482422, -0.5268712639808655, -1.2913681268692017, 0.19963063299655914, -0.9130980968475342, 0.7852656841278076, -0.2925446629524231, 0.11244159191846848, 0.4931096136569977, -0.2555675506591797, -0.35060036182403564, -0.3166731894016266, -1.0180903673171997, -0.35956066846847534, -0.05851222947239876, 0.39085328578948975, 1.007108211517334, 0.7713162302970886, 0.8771800398826599, 0.26922163367271423, -0.19930565357208252, -0.1688813418149948, -0.03926396742463112, -0.07002843916416168, 0.2778034210205078, -0.15283328294754028, -0.6061593890190125, -0.09278228878974915, 0.831291675567627, 0.5462218523025513, 0.03755538910627365, 0.012886792421340942, -0.17078226804733276, 0.6283180117607117, -0.17181865870952606, -0.030497467145323753, -0.22444409132003784, 0.041312068700790405, -0.09447024017572403, -0.12559348344802856, -0.4316408932209015, -0.6056210994720459, 0.079657644033432, -0.2985153794288635, 0.4708858132362366, 0.0729912519454956, 0.766181468963623, 0.6217538714408875, -0.8513399362564087, -0.51004958152771, -1.0018154382705688, 0.38402318954467773, -0.9108310341835022, 1.0570671558380127, 0.3797454833984375, 0.14054271578788757, 0.07012355327606201, -0.464107483625412, -0.6081439256668091, -0.09893691539764404, 0.06861916184425354, -0.030277270823717117, -0.11368842422962189, 0.4071018397808075, 0.2624703347682953, 0.48342177271842957, -0.6648743152618408, -0.0998232513666153, -0.7769748568534851, -0.2601098120212555, 0.8230443000793457, -0.04202435910701752, 0.6507611870765686, -0.11339867115020752, -0.09169936180114746, -0.5483610033988953, -0.15805524587631226, 0.015116081573069096, 0.1383589655160904, 0.3078007698059082, -0.47139015793800354, 0.6171532273292542, -0.008727754466235638, 0.8524465560913086, -0.2367936372756958, -0.43974950909614563, 0.3962676227092743, -0.4939284026622772, -0.32901400327682495, 0.11852237582206726, 0.6414393782615662, 0.2583008408546448, 0.13667136430740356, 0.19106678664684296, -0.32262322306632996, 0.1407695859670639, -0.00003388975528650917, -0.783380925655365, -0.08402366936206818, 0.1844750940799713, -0.7300479412078857, 0.16034691035747528, 0.09595316648483276, -0.34538066387176514, -0.20816919207572937, -0.3795124590396881, 0.39120903611183167, -0.5753272771835327, -0.3693079948425293, 0.27673450112342834, -0.27651527523994446, -0.020987126976251602, 0.6059952974319458, -0.8798555731773376, 0.4016514718532562, 0.3878113627433777, 1.1506441831588745, -0.24553228914737701, -0.09328015893697739, -0.5177519917488098, -0.005297922529280186, -0.24158145487308502, 0.4166388511657715, -0.12319449335336685, -0.7593278288841248, 0.191840261220932, -0.19800877571105957, -0.13721863925457, -0.35124441981315613, 0.43077918887138367, -0.3990841209888458, -0.20973406732082367, -0.06513852626085281, -0.38774096965789795, -0.25607767701148987, -0.17230911552906036, -0.6276134848594666, 0.6766619086265564, 0.03663516417145729, 0.06190529838204384, 0.5010444521903992, -0.6512105464935303, -0.7762657403945923, -0.19938784837722778, 0.07984693348407745, -0.5953195691108704, 0.20313183963298798, 0.03957058861851692, 0.2484670728445053, -0.1046328917145729, -0.32672110199928284, 0.33394575119018555, -0.11424504220485687, 0.42052850127220154, -0.40970852971076965, 0.5701041221618652, 0.5925213694572449, -0.14708474278450012, 0.23745405673980713, -0.7865635752677917, -0.39830857515335083, -0.2564150393009186, -0.5051971673965454, -0.06183931231498718, -0.17519043385982513, 0.3719044625759125, 0.22627320885658264, 0.07129477709531784, -0.5597553253173828, -0.31912052631378174, -0.3308880031108856, 0.46930834650993347, 0.19071970880031586, 0.18913979828357697, 0.41757771372795105, 0.13394694030284882, 0.6139681339263916, -0.015510613098740578, 0.3222998082637787, -0.21671243011951447, -0.5482422709465027, -0.5832234025001526, -0.02596251852810383, -0.019375823438167572, 0.5951961278915405, -0.3006688356399536, 0.3326089680194855, 0.09737636893987656, -0.0036246718373149633, -0.7716827988624573, 0.37883228063583374, 0.6583273410797119, 0.5639718174934387, 0.6016359329223633, -0.711148202419281, -0.05352621525526047, -0.4147584140300751, 0.2085004299879074, -0.4099262058734894, 0.026081303134560585, 0.03190863877534866, 0.42701050639152527, 0.05457262694835663, 0.13113145530223846, -0.21128910779953003, -0.6638289093971252, -0.060750868171453476, 0.4060303270816803, 0.1975528597831726, 0.3233000934123993, 0.28631481528282166, -1.099043846130371, -0.7138888239860535, 0.5770193934440613, -0.47567662596702576, -0.06864327192306519, -0.2202892303466797, 0.19853422045707703, 0.43933340907096863, 0.6220840215682983, -0.29993557929992676, 1.0612897872924805, 0.9128244519233704, -0.840015709400177, 0.28637975454330444, -0.23082712292671204, 1.0265357494354248, -0.8342934250831604, 0.15438415110111237, -0.04091674089431763, -0.33780428767204285, -0.5509951114654541, -0.11235446482896805, 0.0529460683465004, -0.3744479715824127, -0.5554599165916443, 0.558531641960144, -0.5530233383178711, -0.444110244512558, -0.5128890872001648, 0.1451481580734253, -0.15487061440944672, -0.17099928855895996, 0.2495211958885193, 0.8330221176147461, 0.3262873589992523, -0.7388923764228821, 0.48428580164909363, 1.0334683656692505, -0.1668844074010849, 0.5333014130592346, -0.6794504523277283, -0.04532497376203537, 0.24449804425239563, -0.0468108132481575, -1.141818881034851, -0.20596933364868164, 0.317519873380661, -0.834165632724762, 0.5216672420501709, -0.11886560916900635, -0.09697471559047699, -0.37146177887916565, 0.18597249686717987, 0.2927091717720032, 0.7076065540313721, -0.43636244535446167, 0.34006229043006897, 0.35218748450279236, -0.16029703617095947, -0.44702842831611633, -0.9020894169807434, 0.402285635471344, -0.054304901510477066, -0.6742948293685913, 0.15851396322250366, -0.012876506894826889, -0.1625981628894806, -0.07348152995109558, -0.2967422604560852, -0.2272806316614151, -0.05072299763560295, 0.013263802044093609, 0.010039079934358597, -0.0683019682765007, 0.09996669739484787, 0.041081752628088, -0.16787534952163696, -0.06041787937283516, -0.04104103147983551, 0.26602667570114136, 0.08418836444616318, -0.36279332637786865, -0.7833938598632812, 0.6458784937858582, 0.39228007197380066, -0.3111707270145416, 0.5549150705337524, 0.47926855087280273, -0.22651702165603638, 0.10667514055967331, -0.4821937680244446, -0.2237056940793991, -0.469580739736557, 0.45269009470939636, -0.34584033489227295, -0.6501971483230591, 0.5401579141616821, 0.13453556597232819, 0.05137469619512558, -0.25586023926734924, 0.4315151572227478, -0.07109280675649643, 1.238757610321045, 0.747719407081604, 0.32291463017463684, 0.855315089225769, -0.03659411519765854, 0.12710393965244293, -0.6390480399131775, -0.1939155012369156, -0.7057697772979736, -0.112239308655262, -0.001382328337058425, -0.5067116022109985, 0.3552769720554352, 0.2673257887363434, 0.07238569110631943, 0.6317848563194275, -0.6651674509048462, -0.08961796015501022, 0.3888625502586365, 0.2042699158191681, 0.7450286746025085, -0.056886717677116394, 0.4091918468475342, -0.19868925213813782, -0.2157759666442871, -0.5657039284706116, 0.908652126789093, 0.679384171962738, 0.6985058188438416, 0.33276501297950745, 0.6474676728248596, 0.40708133578300476, 0.30036038160324097, -0.8935762047767639, 0.5253282189369202, -0.41557538509368896, -0.6696517467498779, -0.6316945552825928, -0.3074744939804077, -0.9117653369903564, -0.0044235107488930225, -0.4310195744037628, -0.5190078020095825, 0.09420451521873474, 0.750114917755127, 0.2226676046848297, 0.02193460613489151, -0.7811144590377808, 1.0094654560089111, -0.4220936596393585, -0.08363953232765198, -0.4578111171722412, -0.7684466242790222, 0.19484835863113403, 0.07862668484449387, 0.3179708421230316, 0.03688890114426613, -0.030235975980758667, 0.6327263116836548, -0.5134851336479187, 0.6777158379554749, 0.10434151440858841, -0.3567911982536316, 0.2605871856212616, 0.08805787563323975, 0.2004793882369995, -0.06997358798980713, 0.0004517309716902673, 0.13410134613513947, -0.018681075423955917, -0.4318591058254242, -0.4581460654735565, 0.2336350828409195, -0.7012169361114502, -0.4270503520965576, -0.3256198763847351, -0.3708861470222473, 0.17024162411689758, 0.17798824608325958, 0.4249807894229889, 0.19323042035102844, -0.4110584855079651, -0.0020842619705945253, 0.796838641166687, -0.056433022022247314, 0.5458022952079773, 0.3352620005607605, -0.16533170640468597, -0.6225136518478394, 0.6770369410514832, -0.13027991354465485, 0.4442828297615051, 0.4433722496032715, -0.17192859947681427, -0.5039715766906738, -1.2543108463287354, -0.5620078444480896, 0.5266706943511963, -0.7829389572143555, 0.054406069219112396, -0.22734703123569489, -0.2278149574995041, -0.8110319375991821, -0.24072416126728058, -0.3762947916984558, -0.34901049733161926, -0.2648068070411682, -0.35185593366622925, 0.46328139305114746, 0.589435338973999, -0.17339013516902924, 0.8012351989746094, -1.0491379499435425, 0.6818995475769043, 0.25146040320396423, 0.21066805720329285, -0.36996614933013916, -0.7723726630210876, -0.43206965923309326, -0.2181984782218933, -0.23828177154064178, -1.2047622203826904, 0.36915722489356995, 0.2855558395385742, 0.2117457240819931, 0.31874316930770874, -0.22298859059810638, 0.5363967418670654, -0.46068355441093445, 0.80408775806427, 0.792721152305603, -1.1747709512710571, 0.7927664518356323, -0.22565582394599915, 0.39621758460998535, 0.3286600112915039, 0.09033963829278946, -0.8377370834350586, -0.4531940221786499, -0.3913557827472687, -0.8909353017807007, 0.5769811272621155, 0.3943729102611542, 0.01058155670762062, 0.009775163605809212, 0.2670469582080841, -0.0644606351852417, 0.15262436866760254, -0.7600940465927124, -0.2264823019504547, -0.45454803109169006, -0.21802905201911926, -0.23040226101875305, -0.01763373240828514, -0.0682147666811943, -0.09170594066381454, 0.5866432189941406, 0.08936212956905365, 0.039335452020168304, 0.3761220872402191, -0.3795938789844513, -0.6312112808227539, 0.22045555710792542, 0.6188252568244934, 0.5560252070426941, -0.043105825781822205, -0.08323542028665543, 0.03535739704966545, -0.8336658477783203, 0.17136310040950775, 0.15222591161727905, -0.2637624740600586, 0.15839621424674988, 0.47006139159202576, 0.9954248070716858, -0.11602722108364105, -0.4783785939216614, 0.4352002739906311, 0.08426462113857269, -0.45566055178642273, -0.2906070053577423, 0.09341014921665192, -0.29473787546157837, 0.25509190559387207, 0.3942490220069885, 0.13263525068759918, 0.28489187359809875, -0.47477033734321594, 0.44717341661453247, 0.27004677057266235, -0.5806145071983337, -0.45772767066955566, 1.1561552286148071, 0.8622961044311523, -0.8973382711410522, 0.389864444732666, 0.2530096769332886, -0.38111570477485657, 0.5099799036979675, 0.6242151856422424, 0.7706550359725952, -0.684445321559906, 0.4394984245300293, 0.5142238736152649, 0.5226964950561523, -0.26423269510269165, 0.31919166445732117, -0.10960103571414948, -0.5248144865036011, -0.6320409774780273, -0.5307295918464661, -0.638841450214386, -0.09567896276712418, -0.6752137541770935, 0.5046401619911194, -0.20471443235874176, -0.28061041235923767, -0.3401103913784027, -0.17345976829528809, -0.47525447607040405, 0.8302360773086548, 0.4288753569126129, 0.8623839616775513, -1.2598398923873901, 0.687157392501831, 0.8187413811683655, -0.5755773186683655, -0.5943344831466675, -0.1772557497024536, -0.016741348430514336, -0.5509486198425293, 0.5100740194320679, -0.22231703996658325, -0.14333586394786835, 0.20402327179908752, -0.1778423935174942, -0.7507091760635376, 0.7952924966812134, 0.2514912188053131, -0.22144795954227448, -0.06722970306873322, 0.292603075504303, 0.5842602252960205, -0.27551934123039246, -0.027443792670965195, 0.6971984505653381, 0.5697038173675537, 0.293647438287735, -1.2305892705917358, 0.0868707001209259, 0.07565056532621384, -0.0525527149438858, 0.4847468435764313, -0.6391308307647705, 0.3028112053871155, -0.30050358176231384, -0.31210169196128845, -0.026046575978398323, 0.9765732288360596, 0.0862729474902153, 0.6371676921844482, 0.3416314423084259, 0.3210950791835785, 0.3792170584201813, 0.11766737699508667, 0.8015841245651245, 0.014420758001506329, -0.1039523258805275, 0.6027307510375977, 0.17153505980968475, 0.874817967414856, 0.6917736530303955, -0.2216901332139969, 0.06869163364171982, 0.22913531959056854, 0.30641764402389526, 0.16681526601314545, -0.2711058557033539, -0.2625004053115845, -0.2170906662940979, 0.030543746426701546, -0.32041507959365845, 0.26975783705711365, 0.5109654664993286, -0.5225071907043457, 0.08497614413499832, 0.28333133459091187, -0.2967579662799835, 0.7985243201255798, -0.21814441680908203, 0.5799259543418884, 0.4284988045692444, -0.4392778277397156, 0.5096940398216248, -0.2607327699661255, 0.43455395102500916, -0.7361028790473938, -0.31049343943595886, -0.2539404034614563, 0.05014365538954735, -0.28510215878486633, -0.6348446011543274, 0.6147778630256653, -0.031018264591693878, 0.015691181644797325, -0.6038590669631958, 0.4937223494052887, -0.5388675928115845, -0.2590932548046112, 0.42755696177482605, 0.2454216182231903, 0.5044389963150024, 0.3852692246437073, -0.7703631520271301, 0.49741220474243164, 0.24226689338684082, -0.32220059633255005, -0.013911680318415165, 0.2372177243232727, -0.0675337016582489, 0.5387002825737, 0.5868924260139465, 0.3299773037433624, 0.18085630238056183, 0.15268145501613617, 0.30544519424438477, -0.9092121124267578, -0.5724329352378845, -0.40094423294067383, 0.7246853709220886, -0.03972731530666351, -0.6346940398216248, 0.7234338521957397, 0.44855883717536926, 0.6696605682373047, -0.171188622713089, 0.7473529577255249, -0.14769071340560913, 0.418969064950943, -0.7574660778045654, 0.6810942888259888, -0.3941190838813782, 0.17619416117668152, -0.41500285267829895, -1.076456904411316, -0.623626708984375, 0.6552197337150574, 0.17293906211853027, -0.3126491904258728, 0.8394285440444946, 0.43707481026649475, 0.03159460052847862, -0.27930089831352234, 0.6670005917549133, 0.15701161324977875, 0.42604607343673706, 0.32753515243530273, 0.4241006374359131, -0.9908880591392517, 1.154899001121521, -0.0853603333234787, -0.43414106965065, -0.3379976153373718, -0.7948646545410156, -0.8303415179252625, -0.6951292157173157, -0.9167319536209106, -0.44933241605758667, 0.07063055783510208, 0.37545299530029297, 0.7918835282325745, -0.7662267088890076, -0.5443984270095825, -0.10751329362392426, 0.18767355382442474, -0.38332098722457886, -0.11580777913331985, 0.2804071307182312, -0.037576012313365936, -0.9078443050384521, 0.3909182548522949, 0.0755314826965332, 0.5207259654998779, 0.16714049875736237, -0.4999920129776001, -0.03799925372004509, -0.02028588391840458, 0.4788368344306946, 0.721615731716156, -0.5691531896591187, -0.5911951065063477, 0.06342537701129913, -0.04853800684213638, 0.06910776346921921, 0.7603170871734619, -0.20415227115154266, 0.47014179825782776, 0.7486321330070496, 0.3292076587677002, 0.9333128333091736, 0.3517051637172699, 0.793019711971283, -0.8397796750068665, 0.3943277597427368, 0.1133328378200531, 0.20174604654312134, 0.591231644153595, -0.3122841417789459, 0.5680282711982727, 0.09297996759414673, -0.5328497290611267, -0.8461245894432068, 0.40659165382385254, -1.2640342712402344, -0.15621457993984222, 1.1319148540496826, 0.1170472800731659, -0.19229328632354736, -0.4220829904079437, -0.43330857157707214, 0.6290603280067444, -0.613795816898346, 0.6718828082084656, 0.653609037399292, -0.397744745016098, -0.7006524801254272, -0.5654377341270447, 0.661851167678833, 0.45284631848335266, -0.3652714788913727, 0.041651856154203415, 0.6807315349578857, 0.08476999402046204, 0.26355937123298645, 0.7740762233734131, -0.34880807995796204, 0.7348101735115051, 0.13457275927066803, 0.4271179735660553, -0.13151350617408752, -0.18575413525104523, -0.5003741383552551, -0.24083122611045837, 0.4496327042579651, -0.2837960124015808 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07233v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07233v1	TransGPT: Multi-modal Generative Pre-trained Transformer for Transportation	2024-02-11T15:50:35	2024-02-11T15:50:35	Peng Wang, Xiang Wei, Fangxu Hu, Wenjuan Han	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Natural language processing (NLP) is a key component of intelligent transportation systems (ITS), but it faces many challenges in the transportation domain, such as domain-specific knowledge and data, and multi-modal inputs and outputs. This paper presents TransGPT, a novel (multi-modal) large language model for the transportation domain, which consists of two independent variants: TransGPT-SM for single-modal data and TransGPT-MM for multi-modal data. TransGPT-SM is finetuned on a single-modal Transportation dataset (STD) that contains textual data from various sources in the transportation domain. TransGPT-MM is finetuned on a multi-modal Transportation dataset (MTD) that we manually collected from three areas of the transportation domain: driving tests, traffic signs, and landmarks. We evaluate TransGPT on several benchmark datasets for different tasks in the transportation domain, and show that it outperforms baseline models on most tasks. We also showcase the potential applications of TransGPT for traffic analysis and modeling, such as generating synthetic traffic scenarios, explaining traffic phenomena, answering traffic-related questions, providing traffic recommendations, and generating traffic reports. This work advances the state-of-the-art of NLP in the transportation domain and provides a useful tool for ITS researchers and practitioners.	[ -0.5451861023902893, -0.8436607718467712, 0.5536335706710815, 0.5608735084533691, -0.5075148940086365, -0.08427653461694717, -0.2559505105018616, -0.3675026595592499, 0.07686569541692734, 0.34134936332702637, -0.7105687260627747, -0.0494852140545845, -0.46893128752708435, 0.03841601684689522, -0.6764736771583557, 0.8675436973571777, 0.002471928484737873, 0.10218317061662674, 0.16556669771671295, -0.006615704856812954, -0.6761763691902161, -0.6891229152679443, -0.6522585153579712, -0.07414194196462631, 0.36890268325805664, -0.13882625102996826, 0.915635883808136, 0.1546451300382614, 0.706950843334198, 0.2957305610179901, 0.41916218400001526, -0.045920196920633316, 0.00868831854313612, -0.12488040328025818, -0.357013076543808, 0.30206432938575745, -0.4683208465576172, -0.18475399911403656, 0.86521315574646, 0.7561056017875671, -0.13822416961193085, -0.09648224711418152, -0.0904250368475914, 0.32993656396865845, -0.35437774658203125, 0.26301997900009155, -0.5066098570823669, -0.03021232970058918, -0.49588534235954285, -0.192537322640419, -0.2603728175163269, -0.25546714663505554, 0.4402037262916565, -0.5865875482559204, 0.3357498049736023, 0.26730453968048096, 0.7718719244003296, 0.40314897894859314, -1.1191116571426392, -0.1046953797340393, -1.063063621520996, 0.6584479808807373, -0.3766482472419739, 0.876397967338562, -0.012386557646095753, 0.5536816120147705, 0.33095210790634155, -1.0040329694747925, -0.7906169295310974, -0.2264973670244217, -0.27429357171058655, 0.2359379380941391, -0.014560145325958729, -0.038449861109256744, -0.03617764636874199, 0.22870482504367828, -0.9985877275466919, -0.16813041269779205, -0.42031824588775635, -0.0374915786087513, 0.30509358644485474, 0.26914843916893005, 0.24956876039505005, -0.10464181005954742, -0.8313261866569519, -0.013148384168744087, -0.6290432214736938, -0.2560635507106781, 0.028631100431084633, 0.5350008606910706, -0.02437438815832138, 0.3882531523704529, -0.06693308055400848, 0.9048235416412354, -0.3485255837440491, 0.23587319254875183, 0.4308575689792633, -0.43802738189697266, -0.2857460379600525, -0.17645961046218872, 1.1625300645828247, -0.006047719158232212, 0.008985718712210655, -0.47767579555511475, -0.21066436171531677, -0.18544112145900726, 0.47415217757225037, -0.6827825307846069, -0.0634937509894371, -0.3048305809497833, -0.31936952471733093, 0.09099080413579941, 0.19028346240520477, -0.8393855690956116, 0.10318779200315475, -0.6123667359352112, 0.44784221053123474, -0.4803953766822815, -0.6002144813537598, 0.46778404712677, 0.08480944484472275, 0.31427764892578125, 0.34455111622810364, -0.9065036177635193, -0.013015842996537685, 0.6053830981254578, 1.0182838439941406, -0.4976724684238434, -0.4806964695453644, -0.2330123633146286, 0.3616476356983185, 0.24533292651176453, 1.078196406364441, -0.7906607389450073, -0.44687122106552124, -0.06856662034988403, 0.2132420539855957, -0.39892181754112244, -0.07428905367851257, 1.1088274717330933, -0.47210249304771423, 0.3080413043498993, -0.06151571869850159, -0.12676936388015747, -0.2535886764526367, 0.29314205050468445, -0.8227078914642334, 0.8734347224235535, 0.3690495193004608, -0.6500968933105469, 0.24452707171440125, -1.0309122800827026, -0.9141756892204285, 0.3095010817050934, 0.08182264119386673, -0.49702584743499756, 0.08752285689115524, 0.10271412134170532, 0.21171905100345612, -0.41921892762184143, 0.4416023790836334, 0.023979444056749344, -0.09992288053035736, 0.05179325491189957, -0.8185628056526184, 0.6278015375137329, 0.04389341175556183, 0.08478701859712601, 0.1481933742761612, -0.6603032350540161, 0.018925167620182037, -0.027806907892227173, -0.5573200583457947, -0.25963732600212097, -0.208183154463768, 0.814681887626648, 0.47754213213920593, 0.07519634813070297, -0.6224744915962219, 0.24063873291015625, -0.2182805836200714, 0.6151117086410522, 0.8274250030517578, -0.23340705037117004, 0.3492557406425476, -0.29254579544067383, 0.6035131216049194, -0.029491771012544632, 0.34397101402282715, 0.005120462272316217, -0.6351975202560425, -0.6154952645301819, 0.2906842827796936, 0.35652899742126465, 0.5332995653152466, -1.1778582334518433, 0.41720709204673767, -0.7915095090866089, -0.5161260962486267, -0.30601364374160767, -0.5728024840354919, -0.2714489698410034, 0.5415868759155273, 0.555950403213501, 0.03230680152773857, -0.41431498527526855, -0.6470609307289124, -0.14083856344223022, 0.0841616690158844, -0.05571743845939636, -0.05195794627070427, 0.3197197914123535, -0.4270041882991791, 0.8859556913375854, -0.48035991191864014, -0.2745659053325653, -0.29974788427352905, 0.17923294007778168, -0.2734760046005249, 0.6562823057174683, 0.5654832124710083, -1.0044697523117065, -0.5240085124969482, 0.0005183780449442565, -0.31634196639060974, 0.06413809955120087, -0.3162103593349457, -0.27076148986816406, -0.41027072072029114, 0.18721409142017365, -0.9198715686798096, 0.07513278722763062, 0.6403413414955139, -0.591053307056427, 0.4143032431602478, -0.11064274609088898, 0.13912799954414368, -1.0680208206176758, 0.06224370747804642, -0.14717793464660645, -0.5011993646621704, -0.8568529486656189, -0.14007970690727234, 0.00821006204932928, -0.47256186604499817, -0.36998674273490906, 0.17214614152908325, -0.1465659737586975, -0.01932455413043499, -0.28113195300102234, -0.06055590510368347, -0.08841549605131149, 0.4452672302722931, 0.4416165351867676, 0.9174351692199707, 0.5903912782669067, -0.4868299067020416, 0.566382646560669, 0.4356926381587982, -0.33528760075569153, 0.48078811168670654, -0.6060270667076111, 0.31706756353378296, -0.3235633075237274, 0.07079733163118362, -0.6419774889945984, 0.13793185353279114, 0.1669301986694336, 0.2239203304052353, 0.01288334559649229, -0.15471309423446655, -0.5210422277450562, -0.279507577419281, 0.21346861124038696, 0.49904078245162964, 0.3404333293437958, -0.29483142495155334, 0.9753608703613281, 0.36252161860466003, -0.23252777755260468, -0.13105003535747528, -0.6981397271156311, 0.3384745717048645, -0.11832833290100098, -0.6585536599159241, 0.36184874176979065, -0.2677414119243622, 0.47686105966567993, 0.03405154496431351, 0.05488451197743416, -0.37836411595344543, -0.020526735112071037, 0.16913294792175293, 0.4260338246822357, -0.14526478946208954, 0.39106908440589905, -0.26637616753578186, -0.44768449664115906, 0.11405574530363083, -0.34445539116859436, 0.856593668460846, -0.2615278661251068, -0.5450524091720581, -0.13167063891887665, 0.5161482095718384, 0.5589775443077087, -0.5873876810073853, 0.7562987804412842, 1.0870006084442139, 0.023382237181067467, -0.013264697045087814, -0.03245003893971443, -0.012736385688185692, -0.49048957228660583, 0.4989868998527527, -0.6429541110992432, -0.8580441474914551, -0.17306125164031982, -0.32763954997062683, -0.031233547255396843, 0.45587632060050964, 0.43397778272628784, 0.1413978636264801, 0.9510779976844788, 0.786933422088623, 0.08337055891752243, 0.6398290395736694, -0.07332576811313629, 0.6998184323310852, -0.5726025104522705, -0.28460022807121277, -0.5236867666244507, -0.16855083405971527, -0.642367422580719, -0.4472605586051941, 0.6399112343788147, -0.5113986730575562, -0.3397698402404785, 0.4444350600242615, -0.4862532317638397, 0.2728344798088074, 0.645895779132843, 0.035809241235256195, 0.6184663772583008, -0.09996238350868225, 0.4048730731010437, -0.003358675166964531, -0.6396227478981018, -0.32042139768600464, 0.8587066531181335, 0.00505664199590683, 0.778718888759613, 0.23017199337482452, -0.11209419369697571, 0.2185123711824417, 0.4433075785636902, -0.7187851667404175, 0.5048585534095764, -0.27330952882766724, -0.6031568050384521, -0.26707878708839417, -0.7120476961135864, -0.8138786554336548, 0.23064303398132324, -0.28339269757270813, -0.07987080514431, -0.13972045481204987, -0.1329166144132614, -0.3190208375453949, 0.3667323589324951, -0.8194848299026489, 1.0491297245025635, -0.4057668447494507, 0.05594485253095627, 0.0903569757938385, -0.6319757699966431, 0.3312307298183441, -0.3108534514904022, 0.053772952407598495, -0.07870649546384811, 0.0239789467304945, 0.45729732513427734, -0.13084588944911957, 0.41304436326026917, 0.024973049759864807, -0.15424148738384247, -0.008278381079435349, 0.05785118415951729, 0.47473931312561035, 0.03887272626161575, 0.023385850712656975, 0.3023237884044647, -0.1001526340842247, 0.013809524476528168, -0.5987607836723328, 0.6021290421485901, -0.5183233022689819, -0.3120896816253662, -0.25283655524253845, -0.5974625945091248, -0.37233084440231323, 0.4046407639980316, 0.27701669931411743, 0.5651357769966125, 0.027153069153428078, 0.09017407149076462, 0.3087847828865051, -0.13277482986450195, 0.6385694742202759, 0.4805152416229248, -0.017604408785700798, 0.043332867324352264, 0.9431790709495544, -0.02698080986738205, 0.2427162081003189, 0.6009097099304199, 0.21558824181556702, -0.6313276886940002, -0.437440425157547, -0.6026664972305298, 0.02366991899907589, -0.5721404552459717, -0.1300075203180313, -0.7914456725120544, -0.31556805968284607, -0.31277358531951904, 0.15018416941165924, -0.5932413339614868, -0.5151390433311462, 0.017349261790513992, -0.13516265153884888, -0.018186800181865692, 0.7476946711540222, 0.162225604057312, 0.5429521799087524, -0.743672251701355, 0.38203704357147217, 0.5839275121688843, 0.5784960389137268, -0.16089893877506256, -0.19843320548534393, -0.1623622626066208, 0.011219892650842667, -0.3191092908382416, -0.5580810308456421, 0.4307485520839691, 0.07806538045406342, 0.346274197101593, 0.2018381506204605, 0.027067065238952637, 0.4331115782260895, -0.698817253112793, 0.8395220637321472, 0.24078747630119324, -0.8227264285087585, 0.29901963472366333, -0.15906713902950287, 0.37165358662605286, 0.23752659559249878, 0.3167865574359894, -0.8652777075767517, -0.06735339015722275, -0.22563888132572174, -0.6048555374145508, 0.5331248044967651, 0.6077285408973694, 0.32857462763786316, 0.2159806340932846, -0.1085762232542038, 0.20053742825984955, 0.38865843415260315, -1.1841765642166138, -0.11679758131504059, -0.7325287461280823, -0.27773964405059814, -0.058056049048900604, -0.05384157970547676, 0.12349137663841248, -0.3044823110103607, 0.6641525626182556, -0.10640230029821396, 0.4091293215751648, -0.07090166956186295, -0.1432865858078003, 0.19877290725708008, 0.5143190622329712, 0.8076692223548889, 0.68927001953125, -0.13049304485321045, 0.5087651610374451, -0.04459905996918678, -0.6906341910362244, 0.21232092380523682, 0.24209003150463104, -0.3917640149593353, 0.23458296060562134, 0.2624441683292389, 0.7932663559913635, -0.24724285304546356, -0.5938383340835571, 0.6907240748405457, -0.26995182037353516, 0.10883452743291855, -0.37973925471305847, -0.2909252345561981, -0.12978887557983398, -0.09521675109863281, 0.18358293175697327, 0.5689367055892944, 0.2464623898267746, -0.23792968690395355, -0.11970837414264679, 0.29500654339790344, -0.5989118814468384, -0.6206467747688293, 1.0212433338165283, 0.35667136311531067, -0.1865675449371338, 0.6026594638824463, -0.2359398603439331, -0.6880149245262146, -0.03870350494980812, 0.4175872206687927, 1.0126783847808838, -0.26772451400756836, 0.1776011884212494, 0.1537550985813141, 0.561390221118927, -0.06585535407066345, 0.1081637591123581, 0.10949394851922989, -0.8529438972473145, -0.6741393208503723, -0.6643766760826111, -0.03677031397819519, 0.1318851113319397, -0.1392771303653717, 0.1522015631198883, -0.17971596121788025, -0.37389159202575684, -0.3087475299835205, -0.605345606803894, -0.8733474016189575, -0.04821423068642616, -0.011364465579390526, 0.7141473889350891, -0.859480619430542, 0.8032582998275757, 0.7714539766311646, -0.47039008140563965, -0.7011274695396423, 0.13529516756534576, -0.5552864074707031, -0.5091260671615601, 0.7013775110244751, -0.021350160241127014, -0.16758960485458374, 0.136703222990036, -0.2420511245727539, -0.7029783725738525, 0.7791815996170044, 0.4949197471141815, -0.5222359895706177, -0.4082816541194916, 0.8444862365722656, 0.24285992980003357, 0.031223991885781288, 0.20012114942073822, 0.5606536269187927, 0.7094327807426453, -0.1572485864162445, -1.1365348100662231, 0.08145003020763397, 0.029409509152173996, 0.22745314240455627, 0.29185372591018677, -0.7186976671218872, 0.9583373665809631, 0.31254512071609497, -0.35802459716796875, -0.2829696536064148, 0.3471575677394867, -0.2151906043291092, -0.016508348286151886, 0.8287808299064636, 0.563230574131012, 0.3952122926712036, -0.4322417378425598, 0.9066884517669678, -0.15243716537952423, 0.516279399394989, 0.8998593688011169, -0.16322532296180725, 0.3373561501502991, 0.5989944934844971, -0.10545361042022705, 0.38732925057411194, 0.1654096394777298, 0.11627353727817535, 0.8922726511955261, -0.0534728541970253, -0.5010278224945068, -0.6288460493087769, -0.14980170130729675, -0.41328755021095276, 0.5297456383705139, -0.02472507767379284, 0.1483510434627533, -0.6105731725692749, 0.6303948163986206, -0.17139439284801483, -0.32977351546287537, -0.17605464160442352, 0.5951437950134277, -0.07625237107276917, -0.27152228355407715, 0.17924721539020538, 0.19585663080215454, 0.5812472701072693, -0.7446946501731873, 0.009726655669510365, 0.03424001857638359, 0.05450979992747307, 0.05143117159605026, -0.8648166060447693, 0.6168302893638611, -0.28253045678138733, -0.03175915405154228, -0.8930321335792542, 0.5679896473884583, -0.46468833088874817, -0.5311189293861389, -0.20279428362846375, 0.4597245156764984, -0.17562006413936615, -0.5815475583076477, -0.5873034000396729, 0.11638087779283524, -0.19092032313346863, -0.3040638864040375, -0.05654390528798103, 0.7783254981040955, 0.06422189623117447, 0.9246284365653992, 0.585347592830658, 0.05372833088040352, 0.30841484665870667, 0.3013772964477539, 0.9170674681663513, -0.7607516050338745, -0.7129398584365845, -0.7945005297660828, 0.518406331539154, 0.03756893053650856, -0.26553037762641907, 0.4888823926448822, 0.7295305132865906, 0.5998100638389587, -0.42770007252693176, 0.9661216735839844, -0.14671972393989563, 0.4905242919921875, -0.7373396754264832, 0.23695950210094452, -0.24156326055526733, 0.3074880540370941, 0.05281342193484306, -0.8532567024230957, -0.048188190907239914, 0.6183249354362488, -0.19652166962623596, 0.10580950230360031, 0.8302865624427795, 0.5019040703773499, -0.6503579616546631, 0.34167200326919556, 0.16192181408405304, -0.20097894966602325, 0.8117682933807373, 0.9030267596244812, 1.2411973476409912, -0.6471531391143799, 0.8626063466072083, -0.19546730816364288, 0.3682820498943329, 0.0659848153591156, -0.7637888193130493, -0.8310482501983643, -0.9953266382217407, -0.17965304851531982, 0.14366427063941956, -0.28455114364624023, 0.6671209931373596, 1.0448318719863892, -0.47769811749458313, 0.04356987029314041, -0.3467787206172943, 0.04933281987905502, -0.15548844635486603, -0.28311091661453247, 0.3715617060661316, -0.1266993135213852, -0.832909882068634, 0.5201284885406494, 0.3615873456001282, 0.5077259540557861, -0.39552009105682373, 0.135046124458313, 0.057931363582611084, -0.34176215529441833, 0.7202045321464539, -0.27184081077575684, -0.15573200583457947, -0.4830740988254547, -0.14450541138648987, -0.009680141694843769, 0.05906276777386665, 1.413153886795044, -0.7352312207221985, 0.07084257155656815, 0.4456959366798401, 0.6022974252700806, 0.7178333401679993, 0.18073998391628265, 0.7167536020278931, -0.9030513167381287, 0.37924402952194214, 0.33581987023353577, 0.2530260682106018, 0.4338785707950592, -0.1867348700761795, 0.5305600166320801, 0.5190404653549194, -0.4700602889060974, -0.4465358257293701, 0.38695940375328064, -1.2589101791381836, -0.2154865860939026, 1.0109566450119019, 0.36701399087905884, 0.12597230076789856, -0.5285666584968567, -0.18819423019886017, -0.0021743110846728086, -0.28458496928215027, 0.5164225101470947, 0.38399451971054077, 0.11567043513059616, -0.4119333326816559, -0.9808897376060486, 0.6045504212379456, -0.049997538328170776, -1.0413638353347778, 0.17566153407096863, 0.32689398527145386, 0.20955629646778107, 0.0015034718671813607, 0.616772472858429, 0.27519112825393677, -0.1817065328359604, -0.38464248180389404, -0.22769321501255035, -0.22211012244224548, -0.24062587320804596, 0.0708547830581665, 0.45868244767189026, -0.411512166261673, -0.07914010435342789 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07214v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07214v3	Through the Lens of Split Vote: Exploring Disagreement, Difficulty and Calibration in Legal Case Outcome Classification	2024-02-11T14:21:37	2024-06-06T10:53:50	Shanshan Xu, T. Y. S. S Santosh, Oana Ichim, Barbara Plank, Matthias Grabmair	cs.CL	cs.CL	In legal decisions, split votes (SV) occur when judges cannot reach a unanimous decision, posing a difficulty for lawyers who must navigate diverse legal arguments and opinions. In high-stakes domains, understanding the alignment of perceived difficulty between humans and AI systems is crucial to build trust. However, existing NLP calibration methods focus on a classifier's awareness of predictive performance, measured against the human majority class, overlooking inherent human label variation (HLV). This paper explores split votes as naturally observable human disagreement and value pluralism. We collect judges' vote distributions from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), and present SV-ECHR, a case outcome classification (COC) dataset with SV information. We build a taxonomy of disagreement with SV-specific subcategories. We further assess the alignment of perceived difficulty between models and humans, as well as confidence- and human-calibration of COC models. We observe limited alignment with the judge vote distribution. To our knowledge, this is the first systematic exploration of calibration to human judgements in legal NLP. Our study underscores the necessity for further research on measuring and enhancing model calibration considering HLV in legal decision tasks.	[ -0.6228889226913452, -0.16860701143741608, 0.4495657682418823, -0.04409262537956238, -0.4416760802268982, 0.41593796014785767, -0.08916585147380829, -0.38444674015045166, 0.17380167543888092, 0.4068249464035034, -0.4340727925300598, -0.4499618113040924, -0.5537418127059937, -0.04637089744210243, -0.0032428023405373096, 1.0545698404312134, 0.10689737647771835, 0.4621330499649048, -0.40318918228149414, -0.6925902962684631, -0.4329640865325928, -0.7351281046867371, -0.0004554995393846184, -0.5302106738090515, 0.6627666354179382, 0.3743620216846466, 0.8775269985198975, 0.29728633165359497, 0.47098541259765625, 0.31845927238464355, -0.1689465194940567, -0.11298435926437378, -0.15219464898109436, 0.026961546391248703, -0.43518003821372986, -1.001088261604309, -0.27798226475715637, 0.2830689549446106, 0.10906878113746643, 0.6534549593925476, -0.514175534248352, -0.0830986276268959, -0.22260227799415588, 0.9441566467285156, -0.7449389696121216, -0.0065355850383639336, -0.4900178015232086, 0.5015181303024292, -0.30491191148757935, -0.15201713144779205, -0.5331016778945923, -0.32267847657203674, 0.3249985873699188, -0.3910510838031769, 0.6394705176353455, 0.2526560425758362, 0.895355761051178, 0.9185848236083984, -0.8014357686042786, -0.26983535289764404, -0.6058183312416077, 0.750640332698822, -0.827276885509491, 0.29551467299461365, 0.28129667043685913, 0.34463706612586975, 0.024347130209207535, -0.33024877309799194, -0.5633848309516907, 0.008522942662239075, 0.16601108014583588, 0.40739911794662476, 0.058448709547519684, 0.113979771733284, 0.16385217010974884, 0.04764216020703316, -0.3402252793312073, 0.29750391840934753, -0.20508608222007751, -0.3835858702659607, 0.8973195552825928, 0.13540099561214447, 0.15395627915859222, -0.37117162346839905, -0.048127204179763794, -0.3085373342037201, -0.3930910527706146, 0.31062933802604675, 0.7917814254760742, 0.2991096079349518, 0.015103098005056381, 0.5042747855186462, 0.2013562023639679, 0.8834807872772217, 0.2255023866891861, 0.0688890665769577, 0.2820146977901459, -0.046830739825963974, -0.20692376792430878, 0.29748988151550293, 0.7486912608146667, 0.36756572127342224, -0.22382041811943054, 0.1927265226840973, 0.06204517185688019, 0.10023345053195953, 0.4961967170238495, -0.47371888160705566, -0.0908602699637413, 0.22895163297653198, -0.20181618630886078, -0.41976433992385864, 0.386841356754303, -0.6351349949836731, -0.8316133618354797, -0.5357536673545837, 0.16708512604236603, -0.039589911699295044, -0.03925327584147453, 0.3045091927051544, -0.14987681806087494, 0.3446967601776123, 0.8277967572212219, -0.6114945411682129, 0.040827810764312744, 1.086230754852295, 0.292197048664093, -0.22507883608341217, 0.029255617409944534, -0.43724751472473145, -0.48238620162010193, -0.4134315550327301, 0.49686580896377563, -0.27664557099342346, -0.04115994647145271, -0.11412909626960754, -0.2197830080986023, -0.13249877095222473, -0.6631579995155334, 0.9160417318344116, -0.6155641674995422, 0.39078041911125183, -0.2925240695476532, -0.69092857837677, -0.34819841384887695, 0.3601129949092865, -0.649577796459198, 0.49056193232536316, -0.243641197681427, -1.0135685205459595, 1.2100129127502441, -0.4051573574542999, -0.3676873743534088, 0.5188490748405457, -0.5464993119239807, -0.5413071513175964, 0.06073223054409027, -0.07751372456550598, 0.13479143381118774, -0.09739300608634949, 0.3401470184326172, -0.56464684009552, -0.039049047976732254, 0.10730808973312378, -0.36535418033599854, 0.8726553320884705, -0.07732900977134705, -0.416677325963974, 0.10941249877214432, -0.6531320214271545, -0.0037891161628067493, -0.3130686581134796, -0.5176271796226501, -0.5075466632843018, 0.5271207094192505, -0.20539750158786774, 0.42282992601394653, -0.04663771018385887, -0.6976843476295471, 0.010954157449305058, -0.3840893805027008, 0.2067819982767105, 0.7521516680717468, -0.18156112730503082, 0.3205984830856323, -0.16165496408939362, 0.5594773888587952, 0.2586030662059784, 0.17054791748523712, 0.411301851272583, -0.784163236618042, -0.748968243598938, 0.1186489388346672, 0.7425360083580017, 0.47044119238853455, -0.1404007226228714, 0.7320787906646729, -0.21216349303722382, -0.3941138982772827, -1.0143802165985107, -0.02503340318799019, -0.013102678582072258, 0.35162460803985596, 0.09704133123159409, -0.5097220540046692, -0.5409067273139954, -0.8139714598655701, -0.28492286801338196, -0.517595648765564, 0.10389836132526398, 0.5701944231987, 0.6623920202255249, -0.2065095454454422, 1.1527397632598877, -0.034756019711494446, -0.2978914976119995, 0.26081719994544983, 0.6567786931991577, 0.10934484004974365, 0.20594969391822815, 0.033863913267850876, -1.1997042894363403, -0.2809917628765106, 0.17936210334300995, -0.5552833676338196, 0.03199978917837143, -0.0878329798579216, -0.14781054854393005, 0.33366715908050537, 0.1553800255060196, -0.14081460237503052, 0.7919512391090393, 0.2707424461841583, -0.684382975101471, 0.665550172328949, -0.2816601097583771, 0.27646276354789734, -0.7204737067222595, -0.367270290851593, 0.10617819428443909, -0.5077124238014221, -0.2566259503364563, 0.000343803025316447, 0.016810867935419083, 0.7254087328910828, -0.6215154528617859, -0.06389327347278595, -0.1515326052904129, -0.2318534255027771, -0.13896767795085907, 0.10429404675960541, -0.00910270493477583, 0.17530915141105652, 0.07838593423366547, 0.4047212600708008, -0.026892205700278282, -0.1373622864484787, 0.536575198173523, 0.24336566030979156, -0.3720933198928833, 0.9645875096321106, -0.33729737997055054, 0.2389068603515625, -0.23497140407562256, 0.28363025188446045, -0.6695252060890198, -0.3361433744430542, -0.10715892910957336, -0.25518885254859924, 0.14679931104183197, -0.5619779229164124, -0.38952165842056274, -0.43633174896240234, -0.06989296525716782, 0.6482873558998108, 0.1912287324666977, -0.3694717288017273, 0.6069727540016174, 0.5501042008399963, 0.14257676899433136, -0.7684780955314636, -0.6059648990631104, 0.28251487016677856, -0.12592855095863342, -0.7041224837303162, 0.2602042257785797, -0.02630927413702011, -0.4032197594642639, -0.07997456938028336, -0.09097190201282501, 0.04586656019091606, -0.2637791037559509, 0.8331979513168335, 0.25034916400909424, -0.15783770382404327, 0.07265933603048325, -0.0268312506377697, 0.26289835572242737, 0.1565898060798645, 0.2363893836736679, 0.35690149664878845, -0.4459747076034546, -0.8784650564193726, -0.32422536611557007, 0.20392389595508575, 0.6406055688858032, -0.00574389798566699, 0.31248149275779724, 0.032789286226034164, -0.24792836606502533, -0.1024710014462471, -0.6635271310806274, 0.24500557780265808, -0.3746670186519623, 0.21892951428890228, -0.1102641224861145, -0.7748687267303467, 0.5139877796173096, 0.01716288924217224, 0.24479439854621887, 0.5951587557792664, 0.867276132106781, -0.28148213028907776, 1.1148309707641602, 0.28200826048851013, -0.0993703156709671, 0.041112761944532394, 0.1000012457370758, -0.015848053619265556, -0.5505284667015076, -0.34948650002479553, -0.6463702917098999, -0.6092395186424255, -0.513166606426239, -0.54725581407547, 0.20058371126651764, -0.07490517944097519, -0.34790003299713135, 0.04397232457995415, -0.4852062165737152, 0.5111001133918762, 0.6087836623191833, 0.23895497620105743, 0.275881826877594, -0.28112757205963135, -0.5756517648696899, -0.4765932261943817, -0.6133396625518799, -0.33297592401504517, 0.9458116292953491, 0.2313392162322998, 0.5519340634346008, 0.05040532350540161, 1.138386845588684, 0.573367178440094, 0.1635998785495758, -0.9124525785446167, 0.3230377435684204, -0.004182908218353987, -0.7502806186676025, -0.48004111647605896, -0.4478207528591156, -0.8518415689468384, 0.5475961565971375, -0.2387191504240036, -0.5720763802528381, 0.6257438659667969, -0.05941297858953476, -0.643674910068512, 0.33090806007385254, -0.41378089785575867, 0.9877705574035645, -0.2932375371456146, -0.41554805636405945, -0.12405800074338913, -0.864568293094635, 0.28927209973335266, -0.07428158074617386, 0.48417404294013977, -0.13222096860408783, 0.22342294454574585, 0.9485732913017273, -0.9943304061889648, 0.7575457692146301, -0.2285221368074417, -0.09391932934522629, 0.1547614187002182, 0.08847599476575851, 0.3167897164821625, -0.07689628005027771, -0.07579762488603592, -0.16685950756072998, 0.14993275701999664, -0.1817963421344757, -0.4574878215789795, 0.2526077330112457, -0.8473078608512878, -0.6062498688697815, -0.7231324315071106, -0.4083569347858429, -0.10984242707490921, -0.11054643243551254, 0.33079177141189575, -0.22026526927947998, -0.18541187047958374, 0.21328124403953552, 0.26683199405670166, 0.0461498387157917, 0.3328580856323242, 0.5634945034980774, 0.03313221037387848, -0.32587167620658875, 0.7679154276847839, 0.11985237896442413, -0.06078219413757324, -0.056081995368003845, 0.2915044128894806, -0.3404616415500641, -0.3386361598968506, -0.5436117649078369, -0.03051920421421528, -0.7027775049209595, -0.18653957545757294, -0.07341481000185013, -0.05875776708126068, -0.07915008068084717, -0.2060658484697342, -0.5661951899528503, -0.3319109380245209, -0.32070767879486084, -0.20611289143562317, -0.06949903815984726, 0.6916804313659668, -0.021797597408294678, -0.19149376451969147, -0.5961852669715881, 0.07281512022018433, 0.5331482291221619, 0.1923944056034088, -0.4339370131492615, -0.6680890917778015, -0.008973042480647564, 0.07214049249887466, -0.19036917388439178, -0.9462027549743652, 0.32923439145088196, -0.04820764809846878, 0.19223107397556305, 0.49957406520843506, 0.43547195196151733, 0.8858314156532288, -0.41295498609542847, 0.7423292994499207, 0.31519749760627747, -0.8639835119247437, 0.4841773509979248, 0.029710540547966957, 0.006077812518924475, 0.9989048838615417, 0.02795831300318241, -0.6989687085151672, -0.2550787627696991, -0.5939875245094299, -0.8525219559669495, 0.8439072966575623, -0.16092027723789215, -0.07540455460548401, 0.6218132972717285, 0.25830674171447754, 0.1958366483449936, 0.2589776813983917, -0.640666127204895, 0.12656466662883759, -0.06141591817140579, -0.14137306809425354, 0.03033963218331337, 0.07435191422700882, -0.5499042272567749, -0.5827229619026184, 0.4954347610473633, -0.09978029876947403, -0.3311604857444763, 0.1470179706811905, -0.18927361071109772, -0.4173130989074707, 0.38499847054481506, 0.6166757941246033, 0.4160970151424408, -0.35024595260620117, 0.19178682565689087, 0.0252071563154459, -0.2745160758495331, 0.4579048454761505, 0.012589915655553341, -0.32334986329078674, -0.011551640927791595, 0.38616931438446045, 1.03669273853302, 0.10543697327375412, -0.4805487096309662, 0.9200602173805237, -0.19616249203681946, -0.7244171500205994, -0.2502347528934479, -0.019179893657565117, 0.08433184027671814, 0.2919902801513672, 0.36342746019363403, 0.46337348222732544, 0.21555417776107788, -0.3439710736274719, 0.36783748865127563, 0.28573721647262573, -0.7213636636734009, -0.14103499054908752, 0.6733672618865967, 0.3060953617095947, -0.5277806520462036, 0.5184717774391174, -0.3370538353919983, -0.7885373830795288, 0.6386403441429138, -0.11762465536594391, 0.7271195650100708, 0.02623923495411873, 0.4656888544559479, -0.1002306193113327, 0.22439375519752502, -0.3689837157726288, -0.008298912085592747, -0.2066756784915924, -0.8885692954063416, -0.3671516478061676, -0.43878665566444397, -0.8744191527366638, -0.5819574594497681, -0.989693820476532, 0.13371294736862183, -0.4308435320854187, -0.4203745126724243, 0.26183056831359863, 0.06585891544818878, -0.8189402222633362, 0.22840483486652374, 0.3001941740512848, 0.4969579577445984, -0.8730792999267578, 0.4802151620388031, 0.6072977185249329, -0.12352044880390167, -0.6774306297302246, -0.03498917073011398, 0.24954651296138763, -0.42190322279930115, 0.781140923500061, 0.24213461577892303, -0.009009654633700848, -0.5768070816993713, -0.6131014227867126, -0.12777429819107056, 0.7941851615905762, 0.411887526512146, -0.8236251473426819, -0.07952971756458282, 0.47008970379829407, 0.7921642065048218, -0.21747224032878876, 0.09654080867767334, 0.5935017466545105, 0.5365577340126038, 0.24531055986881256, -0.7735946178436279, -0.17293867468833923, -0.16210754215717316, -0.35794129967689514, 0.10043330490589142, -0.6086342930793762, 0.5445703864097595, -0.24626325070858002, -0.1015661358833313, -0.6909253597259521, 0.45234206318855286, 0.2575538158416748, 0.5917779803276062, 0.8778076171875, 0.8443382978439331, 1.0150984525680542, -0.36478865146636963, 0.7783463001251221, 0.14871498942375183, 0.466953843832016, 1.2734092473983765, -0.6767367124557495, 0.9845557808876038, 0.766676664352417, -0.546714186668396, 0.7048205137252808, 0.6765287518501282, -0.06448065489530563, 0.15793825685977936, 0.46620792150497437, -0.3695703446865082, -0.7929390668869019, 0.1819833666086197, -0.022340716794133186, 0.6318061947822571, 0.05709708482027054, -0.11991606652736664, -0.1019069254398346, -0.11430426687002182, -0.38149261474609375, 0.00872777495533228, -0.10163641721010208, 0.8410446643829346, -0.02540714666247368, -0.8306629657745361, 0.1577148586511612, 0.10402309894561768, 0.7008297443389893, 0.0548817478120327, 0.10982487350702286, 0.06319145113229752, 0.04234771057963371, -0.4266166687011719, -0.8412039279937744, 0.1379842758178711, -0.11723703891038895, -0.25860723853111267, 0.05986301600933075, 0.22807225584983826, -0.12143081426620483, -0.4627656042575836, 0.2648126780986786, 0.36812055110931396, 0.22406502068042755, -0.16283181309700012, -0.9096336364746094, -0.1621003895998001, 0.11925671249628067, -0.39312151074409485, 0.26219165325164795, 0.35774675011634827, -0.042048703879117966, 0.36329951882362366, 0.44380655884742737, 0.12785077095031738, 0.48914414644241333, 0.3848218619823456, 0.39133408665657043, -0.5311146974563599, -0.4269564747810364, -0.8379499316215515, 0.5487100481987, -0.21483710408210754, -0.34274667501449585, 0.1459265500307083, 0.6729978322982788, 0.5838336944580078, 0.24719785153865814, 0.663275420665741, -0.00895803514868021, 0.4086705446243286, -0.15460087358951569, 0.6516999006271362, -0.6203439235687256, 0.18591007590293884, -0.1719379723072052, -0.3047342002391815, -0.5843845009803772, 0.5537917017936707, -0.2635720372200012, -0.21351777017116547, 0.22667525708675385, 0.5491803884506226, 0.07122538238763809, 0.20343667268753052, 0.4973960220813751, -0.11396428942680359, 0.29241839051246643, 0.5227542519569397, 0.7306838631629944, -0.444394052028656, 0.37713468074798584, -0.23001714050769806, -0.05215150862932205, -0.5249744057655334, -0.8048252463340759, -0.5062012076377869, -0.44566982984542847, -0.5943103432655334, -0.46385037899017334, -0.19975320994853973, 0.9652119278907776, 0.9669688940048218, -1.0859415531158447, -0.23679567873477936, -0.2947060763835907, 0.2779511511325836, -0.001392776146531105, -0.2053133100271225, 0.2535533010959625, -0.15701058506965637, -0.6831245422363281, 0.049102433025836945, 0.19867725670337677, -0.014068080112338066, -0.07796761393547058, -0.4694506525993347, -0.14440959692001343, 0.1588442325592041, 0.25539711117744446, 0.45790255069732666, -0.9729521870613098, -0.25648707151412964, -0.5314924120903015, -0.2569067180156708, 0.5154422521591187, 0.7991576790809631, -0.4845605790615082, 0.8620913028717041, 0.4713650643825531, 0.5701415538787842, 0.6379621028900146, 0.26989224553108215, 0.5761876702308655, -0.7187858819961548, 0.06433683633804321, 0.5293288826942444, 0.6115840077400208, 0.27167874574661255, -0.08721133321523666, 0.39058685302734375, 0.3419128358364105, -0.6706196069717407, -0.8584718704223633, 0.09153639525175095, -1.052329421043396, -0.05267716571688652, 0.6126919388771057, -0.20858147740364075, -0.15905211865901947, -0.10250411182641983, -0.3252742886543274, 0.22725467383861542, -0.28258147835731506, 0.8852934837341309, 1.0941418409347534, -0.16017933189868927, 0.012874843552708626, -0.4617936313152313, 0.5006272196769714, 0.6565707921981812, -0.6367630362510681, 0.04084550216794014, 0.6774566173553467, 0.04663337022066116, 0.5571614503860474, 0.18594489991664886, -0.22393131256103516, 0.2919826805591583, -0.1515626609325409, 0.27691662311553955, 0.3177080750465393, -0.08832244575023651, -0.4431901276111603, 0.45804494619369507, -0.07267748564481735, -0.009503153152763844 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15518v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15518v1	Beware of Words: Evaluating the Lexical Richness of Conversational Large Language Models	2024-02-11T13:41:17	2024-02-11T13:41:17	Gonzalo Martínez, José Alberto Hernández, Javier Conde, Pedro Reviriego, Elena Merino	cs.CL	cs.CL	The performance of conversational Large Language Models (LLMs) in general, and of ChatGPT in particular, is currently being evaluated on many different tasks, from logical reasoning or maths to answering questions on a myriad of topics. Instead, much less attention is being devoted to the study of the linguistic features of the texts generated by these LLMs. This is surprising since LLMs are models for language, and understanding how they use the language is important. Indeed, conversational LLMs are poised to have a significant impact on the evolution of languages as they may eventually dominate the creation of new text. This means that for example, if conversational LLMs do not use a word it may become less and less frequent and eventually stop being used altogether. Therefore, evaluating the linguistic features of the text they produce and how those depend on the model parameters is the first step toward understanding the potential impact of conversational LLMs on the evolution of languages. In this paper, we consider the evaluation of the lexical richness of the text generated by LLMs and how it depends on the model parameters. A methodology is presented and used to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of lexical richness using ChatGPT as a case study. The results show how lexical richness depends on the version of ChatGPT and some of its parameters, such as the presence penalty, or on the role assigned to the model. The dataset and tools used in our analysis are released under open licenses with the goal of drawing the much-needed attention to the evaluation of the linguistic features of LLM-generated text.	[ -0.39593565464019775, -1.064280390739441, 0.4451817572116852, 0.2369186133146286, -0.46651992201805115, -0.0249831173568964, -0.46216142177581787, -0.5511435270309448, 0.13972404599189758, 0.6809662580490112, -0.29688653349876404, -0.17703022062778473, -0.809913158416748, -0.010837754234671593, -0.44953468441963196, 1.1551504135131836, 0.30390843749046326, -0.1248985081911087, -0.3093993067741394, 0.08347764611244202, -0.35299715399742126, -0.6173295378684998, -0.2795088291168213, -0.41704854369163513, 0.536906898021698, 0.053750261664390564, 1.3279943466186523, 0.41001415252685547, 0.5349376201629639, 0.283814013004303, -0.6487171053886414, -0.0003568593238014728, -1.003683090209961, 0.15034237504005432, 0.026745475828647614, -0.2746720612049103, -0.29017195105552673, -0.11567803472280502, 0.6242709159851074, 0.7800757884979248, 0.04448971897363663, 0.011820066720247269, 0.36072036623954773, 0.36906954646110535, -0.41518115997314453, 0.2675119936466217, -0.9235296845436096, -0.022200291976332664, -0.24100378155708313, -0.6236424446105957, -0.18612492084503174, -0.29840850830078125, 0.6172036528587341, -0.20390364527702332, 0.131759911775589, -0.06511488556861877, 0.7479216456413269, -0.04880925267934799, -0.1079181432723999, -0.5587971210479736, -0.6222959756851196, 0.7684294581413269, -0.651621401309967, 0.3486366868019104, 0.2461860030889511, 0.18160705268383026, -0.2199668139219284, -0.4637480676174164, -0.4278343617916107, -0.667337954044342, 0.04362482577562332, 0.23405227065086365, -0.24809256196022034, 0.15673543512821198, 0.03472321853041649, 0.5743014812469482, -0.4045582115650177, 0.028252700343728065, -0.31354036927223206, -0.22301678359508514, 0.5842332243919373, 0.010776744224131107, 0.3102882206439972, -0.3703747093677521, -0.529253363609314, -0.0816965103149414, -0.794788122177124, -0.34435510635375977, 0.4756581783294678, 0.36562788486480713, -0.12440478056669235, 0.9854506254196167, -0.034373629838228226, 0.42591509222984314, -0.6117711067199707, -0.2116098254919052, 0.08694928884506226, -0.4503493905067444, -0.14968670904636383, 0.03483527526259422, 0.7942302823066711, 0.24022378027439117, 0.7126670479774475, -0.40203049778938293, -0.26161515712738037, -0.03088098205626011, 0.1634320765733719, -0.771643877029419, -0.052266765385866165, 0.011350826360285282, -0.31674543023109436, -0.3642885088920593, -0.23443233966827393, -0.7917703986167908, -0.5094558596611023, -0.1692957729101181, 0.5140971541404724, -0.3708246648311615, 0.029258839786052704, 0.17031171917915344, 0.07116755098104477, 0.29314902424812317, 0.4417065680027008, -0.8037194609642029, 0.38048067688941956, 0.7582115530967712, 0.8148592114448547, -0.2597118318080902, -0.31830376386642456, -0.3408925235271454, -0.10323376208543777, -0.1995781809091568, 0.7438634037971497, -0.7045537233352661, -0.8881198763847351, 0.0956507995724678, -0.1860424429178238, 0.06634017080068588, -0.6165865659713745, 0.5155737996101379, -0.516486644744873, 0.055543214082717896, -0.28312698006629944, -0.5923541188240051, -0.10791536420583725, 0.271040678024292, -0.37795957922935486, 0.7409721612930298, 0.13247142732143402, -0.9167710542678833, 0.2245483100414276, -0.43683624267578125, -0.29032909870147705, 0.4596542418003082, -0.20161819458007812, -0.24407793581485748, 0.24093733727931976, -0.04531749710440636, 0.3867981731891632, -0.29817888140678406, 0.1255042403936386, -0.2946144938468933, -0.42015770077705383, 0.6606382727622986, -0.7636224031448364, 0.4953787326812744, 0.2666764557361603, -0.21574321389198303, -0.14202481508255005, -0.508138120174408, 0.18139946460723877, 0.1203760951757431, -0.5669460296630859, -0.17683249711990356, 0.225125253200531, 0.16815413534641266, -0.132534459233284, 0.3462207615375519, -0.18086697161197662, -0.1709279716014862, -0.6366345286369324, 0.2867841124534607, 0.5922932624816895, 0.10753616690635681, 0.12314234673976898, -0.3449781835079193, 0.603156328201294, -0.06529552489519119, 0.12264925986528397, -0.19476473331451416, -0.6594114899635315, -0.8661350011825562, -0.19136467576026917, 0.27187755703926086, 0.5621581673622131, -0.4743902385234833, 0.3318852186203003, -0.34821489453315735, -0.8030794262886047, -0.18612472712993622, 0.23897118866443634, 0.47934308648109436, -0.15523333847522736, 0.08492614328861237, -0.41317227482795715, -0.2398117035627365, -0.8273137807846069, -0.4265424907207489, -0.2010369747877121, 0.055302441120147705, 0.5395866632461548, 0.4428085684776306, -0.25935184955596924, 0.9320210814476013, -0.3527522087097168, 0.16337518393993378, -0.4108431339263916, -0.07280711084604263, -0.2329157590866089, 0.12982666492462158, 0.38999485969543457, -0.47800159454345703, -0.14247779548168182, 0.08946643024682999, -0.38707366585731506, -0.26289498805999756, 0.12335499376058578, 0.005298084579408169, -0.08362668752670288, 0.35953834652900696, -0.5385112166404724, 0.3404576778411865, 0.7805767059326172, -0.17708057165145874, 0.5417636036872864, -0.26004332304000854, -0.21409714221954346, -0.9791602492332458, 0.04670708626508713, -0.08078618347644806, -0.0676581859588623, -0.4707200527191162, 0.12541641294956207, -0.2575092911720276, -0.3095857501029968, -0.5038082003593445, 0.7183860540390015, -0.45338529348373413, -0.26626670360565186, -0.17598135769367218, 0.5650322437286377, -0.1009979099035263, 0.12789613008499146, -0.09673772752285004, 0.8293154835700989, 0.5005002021789551, -0.5605102777481079, 0.3293028473854065, 0.24209146201610565, -0.5386353135108948, 0.122096948325634, -0.6980383992195129, 0.05326294153928757, -0.06550619751214981, -0.20377956330776215, -0.948448657989502, -0.05692121759057045, 0.05761948227882385, -0.4974845349788666, 0.1395401656627655, -0.06873014569282532, -0.7154011726379395, -0.0032848413102328777, -0.17363058030605316, 0.10697735100984573, 0.4565371870994568, -0.19401156902313232, 0.2187807857990265, 0.4176146686077118, -0.2542332112789154, -0.3465864658355713, -0.7308558821678162, 0.2402348667383194, -0.17817018926143646, -0.6936292052268982, 0.023011457175016403, -0.1615469604730606, -0.5274747014045715, -0.12485158443450928, 0.14408956468105316, 0.12884092330932617, 0.32567858695983887, 0.22957801818847656, 0.2744068503379822, -0.13564126193523407, 0.21600563824176788, -0.2768925428390503, -0.013226301409304142, 0.026055412366986275, 0.08542168885469437, 0.7978164553642273, -0.21381054818630219, -0.41332167387008667, 0.07131695002317429, 0.04858435317873955, 0.5810949206352234, -0.31329408288002014, 0.8431204557418823, 0.3073924481868744, -0.13256897032260895, -0.1999211311340332, -0.5354415774345398, -0.07963602244853973, -0.4756956100463867, 0.6431430578231812, -0.00749342842027545, -0.9193534255027771, 0.6026467680931091, 0.16787931323051453, -0.14290852844715118, 0.3139258027076721, 0.8071197271347046, 0.3917446434497833, 0.7965112328529358, 0.5876686573028564, -0.03227554261684418, 0.4572393596172333, 0.14081674814224243, 0.4779929220676422, -0.6270542740821838, -0.27376556396484375, -0.60279381275177, -0.023827530443668365, -1.090078592300415, -0.5573105812072754, 0.347831130027771, -0.07630101591348648, 0.16623760759830475, 0.13453735411167145, -0.1313183456659317, 0.5256438255310059, 0.13608907163143158, -0.012235790491104126, 0.387200266122818, 0.2237425148487091, 0.006272350437939167, -0.00108157261274755, -0.650192379951477, -0.7794815897941589, 0.9920623898506165, 0.5115160942077637, 0.9541182518005371, 0.16848257184028625, 0.5797112584114075, 0.16961872577667236, 0.0952867716550827, -1.08413565158844, 0.7128425240516663, -0.07215485721826553, -0.4187868535518646, -0.14182420074939728, -0.6526299715042114, -1.1353652477264404, 0.3612551987171173, -0.315951406955719, -0.8263665437698364, -0.18319126963615417, -0.25251007080078125, -0.2844483554363251, 0.12297791987657547, -0.7594373822212219, 0.6831979751586914, -0.29596951603889465, -0.40770334005355835, -0.18666115403175354, -0.3214331269264221, 0.2723056674003601, -0.252459317445755, 0.2468244731426239, -0.1276073157787323, -0.3091805875301361, 0.6424864530563354, -0.3035005033016205, 0.7837590575218201, 0.33341264724731445, -0.320234477519989, 0.35884761810302734, 0.33366599678993225, 0.37705597281455994, 0.11951298266649246, -0.05003407597541809, 0.19820915162563324, 0.2571786642074585, -0.3427826762199402, -0.2234460711479187, 0.8219549059867859, -0.7709819078445435, -0.6070497035980225, -0.3086710274219513, -0.5086250901222229, -0.36384883522987366, 0.08983966708183289, 0.28275811672210693, 0.49625882506370544, -0.4941454827785492, 0.2276517152786255, 0.6965534687042236, -0.7192318439483643, 0.2910251021385193, 0.21586914360523224, -0.47372233867645264, -0.20905694365501404, 1.0208230018615723, 0.21605093777179718, 0.6448984742164612, 0.044829223304986954, 0.4929087162017822, -0.24527253210544586, -0.7739993929862976, -0.24118521809577942, 0.3355024755001068, -0.8043256998062134, 0.14204081892967224, -0.5628694295883179, -0.4749777019023895, -0.18187695741653442, -0.07181857526302338, -0.36595582962036133, -0.09228380769491196, -0.3854684829711914, 0.3434660732746124, 0.3178703188896179, 0.864063024520874, 0.3864191770553589, 0.5359781384468079, -0.9958214163780212, -0.18697400391101837, 0.33365514874458313, 0.3893085718154907, 0.08040018379688263, -0.5794436931610107, -0.047481440007686615, -0.02840811014175415, -0.4466807246208191, -0.7221371531486511, 0.4695640504360199, 0.20736064016819, 0.5411294102668762, 0.5273206830024719, -0.22650602459907532, 0.4140184223651886, -0.31152740120887756, 0.9523881077766418, -0.007861378602683544, -0.8657634258270264, 0.2613808214664459, -0.40794551372528076, 0.45017209649086, 0.3518955409526825, 0.11403366178274155, -0.6937337517738342, -0.5217512249946594, -0.7431912422180176, -0.8481812477111816, 0.48101186752319336, 0.5148984789848328, 0.9084680080413818, -0.30041980743408203, 0.14755430817604065, 0.09062041342258453, 0.34022966027259827, -0.8047415614128113, -0.10311733931303024, 0.15053419768810272, 0.19581927359104156, -0.1473853439092636, -0.6991133689880371, 0.05936765670776367, 0.20486880838871002, 0.4405477046966553, 0.04229205474257469, 0.05408068746328354, 0.060266751796007156, -0.12395647913217545, 0.07161209732294083, 0.5051994919776917, 0.564938485622406, 0.6830594539642334, 0.023793552070856094, 0.1729978322982788, 0.25309085845947266, -0.5551554560661316, -0.48767000436782837, -0.04308395832777023, -0.07066714018583298, 0.07418849319219589, 0.4063243567943573, 0.8491494655609131, 0.42540767788887024, -0.9623755216598511, 0.6351733207702637, 0.07380855828523636, -0.03199199214577675, -0.18433934450149536, 0.019253874197602272, 0.24308103322982788, 0.23515436053276062, -0.1165928989648819, -0.09159845113754272, 0.0026136257220059633, -0.7973354458808899, 0.0206854660063982, 0.6784411072731018, -0.4800925850868225, -0.21374879777431488, 0.1918877810239792, 0.08934932947158813, -0.24077960848808289, 0.38361766934394836, -0.18256737291812897, -0.7656480669975281, 0.4005719721317291, 0.409995436668396, 0.7334932684898376, -0.017946820706129074, 0.06972186267375946, 0.038788337260484695, 0.42887064814567566, 0.09596594423055649, 0.06731495261192322, 0.08782561868429184, -0.7950773239135742, -0.34829092025756836, -0.8893831372261047, -0.48236632347106934, 0.2608974277973175, -0.11821378767490387, 0.414526104927063, -0.4055468738079071, -0.06079991161823273, -0.11867973953485489, -0.014914250001311302, -0.4674178957939148, 0.0832635685801506, 0.491672158241272, 0.7093245387077332, -0.48613297939300537, 0.47973164916038513, 0.28202909231185913, -0.11508622765541077, -0.5395036339759827, 0.12725093960762024, -0.07504777610301971, -1.0155425071716309, 0.503520131111145, 0.08294806629419327, -0.15908341109752655, -0.06330662220716476, -0.3968069553375244, -0.8120827078819275, 0.5463970303535461, 0.4352715015411377, -0.3947405219078064, 0.19239145517349243, 0.5331525802612305, 0.6868434548377991, -0.057146769016981125, 0.4551037847995758, 0.5023900866508484, 0.40342435240745544, 0.26182079315185547, -1.1044164896011353, -0.2283240109682083, -0.01599467545747757, 0.23990710079669952, 0.09845392405986786, -0.5953267812728882, 0.8015902638435364, -0.3060108423233032, -0.40237170457839966, 0.14228284358978271, 0.2656450569629669, 0.006795950699597597, -0.12488167732954025, 0.24281740188598633, 0.3787521719932556, 0.613702654838562, -0.1037401333451271, 1.2091764211654663, -0.2719931900501251, 0.46961814165115356, 0.851001501083374, -0.31682536005973816, 0.8258411288261414, 0.4604232907295227, -0.2757413983345032, -0.11999063193798065, 0.5343016386032104, -0.1619512289762497, 0.2051367312669754, 0.6780246496200562, -0.4407165050506592, -0.10736416280269623, -0.08119647204875946, -0.39378687739372253, 0.8052117824554443, 0.3750580847263336, -0.5425904989242554, -0.5456358790397644, -0.301800012588501, 0.2735402584075928, -0.08307056128978729, -0.24660512804985046, 0.8477085828781128, 0.10225779563188553, -0.5150279402732849, 0.5967499613761902, -0.15429972112178802, 0.6291918158531189, -0.7626034617424011, 0.10438059270381927, -0.19353733956813812, 0.06626985967159271, -0.1938277930021286, -0.7120147943496704, 0.2756933867931366, 0.14687120914459229, 0.2902277410030365, 0.0358770377933979, 0.5978390574455261, -0.22895391285419464, -0.5455747246742249, 0.46858417987823486, 0.8486262559890747, 0.5609191656112671, -0.07604006677865982, -0.6377776265144348, 0.31433993577957153, -0.0616481713950634, -0.5040498971939087, 0.4690932631492615, 0.5060343742370605, 0.14547193050384521, 0.73933345079422, 0.6183886528015137, 0.3791041672229767, 0.15473534166812897, 0.08725176751613617, 0.9742892980575562, -0.45830658078193665, -0.17202167212963104, -1.0778580904006958, 0.07928641885519028, 0.16258254647254944, -0.4987211227416992, 0.7783834934234619, 0.6101629137992859, 0.7132643461227417, 0.11768841743469238, 0.8772900700569153, 0.05992528051137924, 0.23668183386325836, -0.5432692766189575, 1.0602144002914429, -0.51784747838974, 0.6479302644729614, -0.4131734371185303, -1.3324120044708252, -0.12028057128190994, 0.23155628144741058, -0.5198423266410828, 0.38139593601226807, 0.715202808380127, 1.0040392875671387, 0.06523016840219498, 0.22496165335178375, 0.7192261815071106, 0.15830235183238983, 0.14353393018245697, 0.17351794242858887, 1.030112862586975, -0.18318048119544983, 0.6666808128356934, -0.0674033984541893, -0.16786226630210876, -0.2404201477766037, -0.9904389977455139, -0.7477371096611023, -0.3165476322174072, -0.22911448776721954, -0.4176368713378906, -0.0669347420334816, 0.7595751881599426, 0.3583640158176422, -0.5435517430305481, -0.41175878047943115, 0.049170590937137604, -0.0003563179634511471, 0.353884220123291, -0.20201599597930908, 0.14392457902431488, -0.45780038833618164, -0.6968269348144531, 0.2499655932188034, 0.31935107707977295, 0.25649672746658325, -0.4591274857521057, -0.0012946717906743288, 0.11393085867166519, 0.45883285999298096, 0.7680522203445435, -0.12307041138410568, -0.6937894821166992, -0.3910392224788666, -0.0695902556180954, -0.21536457538604736, 0.005957337096333504, 0.6134549379348755, -0.5387937426567078, 0.5645158886909485, 0.4638606309890747, 0.6164643168449402, 0.2238125503063202, -0.3473908007144928, 0.4416634142398834, -0.3811347484588623, 0.0376758873462677, 0.17594267427921295, 0.38474541902542114, 0.5203791856765747, -0.1304071694612503, 0.23227643966674805, 0.2373848855495453, -0.6305094361305237, -0.6499665379524231, 0.17120537161827087, -1.1637367010116577, -0.17114904522895813, 1.4494845867156982, 0.0016867840895429254, -0.24169540405273438, 0.012127494439482689, -0.43659958243370056, 0.12473556399345398, -0.21945524215698242, 0.7972751259803772, 0.8419970273971558, 0.14220449328422546, -0.18665671348571777, -0.8892804980278015, 0.35840484499931335, 0.36820337176322937, -0.7665497660636902, 0.3952440619468689, 0.37134477496147156, 0.26541224122047424, 0.11419125646352768, 0.1326492875814438, -0.5183541774749756, -0.10214231163263321, 0.09562649577856064, -0.004671722184866667, 0.24884136021137238, 0.12152723222970963, -0.3016449809074402, 0.010293819010257721, 0.5910462737083435, 0.12540148198604584 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07204v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07204v2	Synergizing Spatial Optimization with Large Language Models for Open-Domain Urban Itinerary Planning	2024-02-11T13:30:53	2024-05-23T10:24:00	Yihong Tang, Zhaokai Wang, Ao Qu, Yihao Yan, Kebing Hou, Dingyi Zhuang, Xiaotong Guo, Jinhua Zhao, Zhan Zhao, Wei Ma	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG	In this paper, we introduce the novel task of Open-domain Urban Itinerary Planning (OUIP), a paradigm designed to generate personalized urban itineraries from user requests articulated in natural language. This approach is different from traditional itinerary planning, which often restricts the granularity of user inputs, thus hindering genuine personalization. To this end, we present ItiNera, an OUIP system that synergizes spatial optimization with large language models (LLMs) to provide services that customize urban itineraries based on users' needs. Upon receiving the user's itinerary request, the LLM first decomposes it into detailed components, identifying key requirements, including preferences and dislikes. Then, we use these specifics to select candidate POIs from a large-scale collection using embedding-based Preference-aware POI Retrieval. Finally, a preference score-based Cluster-aware Spatial Optimization module clusters, filters, and orders these POIs, followed by the LLM for detailed POI selection and organization to craft a personalized, spatially coherent itinerary. Moreover, we created an LLM-based pipeline to update and personalize a user-owned POI database. This ensures up-to-date POI information, supports itinerary planning, pre-trip research, POI collection, recommendations, and more. To the best of our knowledge, this study marks the first integration of LLMs to innovate itinerary planning, with potential extensions for various urban travel and exploration activities. Offline and online evaluations demonstrate the capacity of our system to deliver more responsive, personalized, and spatially coherent itineraries than current solutions. Our system, deployed on an online platform, has attracted thousands of users for their urban travel planning.	[ -0.5727417469024658, -0.43189537525177, 0.9139725565910339, 0.43169066309928894, 0.2073315531015396, -0.01748792640864849, -0.5393341779708862, -0.3233815133571625, 0.7004167437553406, 0.2315797358751297, -0.5822550654411316, -0.7174156308174133, 0.1895042061805725, -0.26208898425102234, -0.025389043614268303, 0.559230625629425, -0.28616079688072205, 0.05397268012166023, -0.1679331660270691, -0.19865530729293823, -0.5643516778945923, -0.6005169153213501, -0.6221098303794861, -0.16581207513809204, 0.3962782323360443, 0.6631466746330261, 0.5089916586875916, 0.16813097894191742, 0.4129413068294525, 0.2071765661239624, 0.11084125936031342, 0.10141608119010925, -0.531053364276886, -0.2754727005958557, -0.38230690360069275, 0.06630193442106247, -0.20234017074108124, -0.5956612229347229, 0.6021009087562561, 1.0293588638305664, -0.6712623238563538, 0.07633569091558456, -0.24589702486991882, 0.4731413722038269, -0.8158616423606873, -0.1582937091588974, -0.6137303709983826, 0.0738774761557579, -0.09735501557588577, -0.18777436017990112, 0.12169434875249863, -0.3742097020149231, 0.2767510712146759, -0.7422031164169312, -0.26508259773254395, 0.3467991054058075, 0.5586501955986023, 0.08272805064916611, -0.18004539608955383, -0.163943812251091, -1.150238275527954, 0.9100399613380432, -0.47876742482185364, 0.4591006338596344, 0.25294122099876404, 0.4670850336551666, -0.10193097591400146, -0.4579988718032837, -0.5461210608482361, -0.10027986764907837, 0.007161386776715517, 0.2241353988647461, -0.16694658994674683, -0.16632232069969177, -0.1145348995923996, 0.09568648785352707, -0.7152955532073975, 0.3241318464279175, -0.27774837613105774, 0.2537650763988495, 0.5086389183998108, 0.4608670175075531, 0.112666554749012, 0.18487101793289185, -0.49945586919784546, 0.2927117943763733, -0.7168337106704712, 0.30292391777038574, 0.21146613359451294, 0.23235660791397095, -0.04722427949309349, 0.7056288719177246, -0.38783201575279236, 0.2490980178117752, -0.2620508074760437, 0.24707148969173431, -0.11453546583652496, -0.47748863697052, -0.15116547048091888, -0.005906327161937952, 0.8258562684059143, 0.3107810914516449, 0.09049360454082489, -0.491630882024765, -0.1634669452905655, -0.2001105695962906, 0.29612696170806885, -0.6269443035125732, -0.15787680447101593, 0.6316556930541992, -0.16268162429332733, 0.11083114892244339, 0.17036060988903046, -0.8541858196258545, -0.026985879987478256, -0.3827545940876007, 0.03011590614914894, -0.19894888997077942, -0.1829366534948349, 0.5050837993621826, 0.04687438905239105, -0.10174151510000229, 0.27868181467056274, -1.0130888223648071, 0.4932475686073303, 0.49530646204948425, 0.660694420337677, -0.16031521558761597, -0.44938117265701294, -0.11230160295963287, 0.39171817898750305, -0.15114325284957886, 1.0283632278442383, -0.8056411147117615, -0.4617365002632141, 0.19187010824680328, -0.4755641520023346, 0.05222897604107857, -0.4817826449871063, 0.59292072057724, -0.5358741879463196, 0.1041177362203598, -0.40363290905952454, -0.11056333035230637, -0.17617420852184296, 0.21857866644859314, -0.45340272784233093, 1.1875755786895752, 0.17898383736610413, -0.27783867716789246, 0.38017353415489197, -1.0137981176376343, -0.2385181486606598, 0.15751075744628906, -0.07954210788011551, -0.18535539507865906, 0.23636394739151, 0.2337866574525833, -0.021612191572785378, -0.2046833038330078, 0.5397167205810547, -0.49397149682044983, 0.013546946458518505, -0.20205801725387573, 0.5795963406562805, 0.6823700666427612, 0.2876162528991699, -0.17359168827533722, 0.5432633757591248, -0.7056328058242798, 0.31208205223083496, 0.23825140297412872, -0.4804774522781372, -0.25796565413475037, 0.2916519343852997, 0.28892168402671814, -0.0767631009221077, 0.6674886345863342, -0.7776403427124023, 0.7326004505157471, -0.5403180122375488, 0.38654661178588867, 0.7575159668922424, -0.15192122757434845, 0.874846339225769, -0.16482308506965637, 0.3539949953556061, -0.437079519033432, 0.34232479333877563, -0.036623284220695496, -0.5454143285751343, -0.34950563311576843, -0.07883577048778534, -0.142730712890625, 0.45084643363952637, -0.3637750744819641, 0.8080009818077087, -0.4857025146484375, -0.5038391351699829, -0.005766366142779589, -0.09372106194496155, -0.47365155816078186, 0.1670762300491333, 0.13932083547115326, -0.07745904475450516, -0.681036651134491, -0.42075660824775696, -0.03612584248185158, 0.1340639889240265, 0.11415213346481323, 0.439796507358551, 0.4985678195953369, -0.4316219687461853, 0.9638105034828186, -0.6407972574234009, -0.6308947801589966, -0.25448617339134216, -0.38924553990364075, 0.23210206627845764, 0.16187158226966858, 0.9143356084823608, -0.5662351846694946, -0.5435447096824646, 0.2036113291978836, -0.33912864327430725, -0.1984904706478119, 0.08364982157945633, -0.6295925378799438, -0.2502151131629944, 0.009758733212947845, -0.4148792028427124, 0.3323681950569153, 0.4132019877433777, -0.5184087157249451, 0.39927923679351807, -0.38885584473609924, -0.060986798256635666, -0.811482846736908, 0.30256399512290955, -0.21463929116725922, 0.03238630294799805, -0.48127061128616333, 0.5133309364318848, -0.3476969599723816, -0.43236449360847473, -0.11871234327554703, 0.8269088268280029, -0.1178697943687439, -0.3200089633464813, -0.1887802928686142, 0.27792713046073914, -0.041380684822797775, 0.7932901382446289, 0.27387988567352295, 0.44228169322013855, 0.517768383026123, -0.4198768138885498, -0.019344760105013847, 0.43491390347480774, -0.2169664353132248, 0.25662481784820557, -0.3232414722442627, 0.25582316517829895, 0.013722549192607403, 0.19208692014217377, -0.9231526255607605, -0.2290092259645462, 0.014173459261655807, 0.10019359737634659, -0.450116366147995, 0.16510134935379028, -0.750106692314148, -0.3610121011734009, -0.4435327649116516, 0.36223411560058594, 0.11827535182237625, -0.7635006308555603, 1.0145803689956665, 0.5954760909080505, -0.14983606338500977, 0.07516950368881226, -0.20820146799087524, 0.2117106020450592, -0.03515393286943436, -0.63426673412323, 0.40952757000923157, -0.3633262515068054, -0.31501007080078125, 0.019055558368563652, 0.10078063607215881, -0.20990578830242157, 0.07613517343997955, 0.23727327585220337, 0.2562234699726105, 0.23145611584186554, -0.1788780838251114, -0.07878619432449341, -0.007664273027330637, -0.18495216965675354, -0.9100846648216248, 0.8786525130271912, 0.045172758400440216, -0.286458820104599, -0.33075281977653503, 0.9013919234275818, 0.3388398587703705, -0.4953829348087311, 0.6213906407356262, 0.6483793258666992, -0.41091662645339966, -0.07788728177547455, -0.31020018458366394, 0.023377491161227226, -0.4409758448600769, -0.029022177681326866, -0.6635562777519226, -0.896116316318512, 0.586780309677124, -0.33927324414253235, 0.44934800267219543, 0.11591935902833939, 0.6094354391098022, -0.21642670035362244, 1.002745509147644, 0.8284781575202942, -0.09821375459432602, 0.6557435989379883, -0.45534083247184753, 0.4571363925933838, -0.5891618132591248, -0.3170340657234192, -0.7033246755599976, -0.688270092010498, -0.40771055221557617, -0.3098488450050354, 0.7016310691833496, -0.016076650470495224, -0.43349573016166687, 0.22835497558116913, -0.4586607813835144, 0.49700069427490234, 0.8280500769615173, -0.17229360342025757, 0.376239538192749, 0.22185875475406647, -0.26500269770622253, -0.08942684531211853, -0.7941642999649048, -0.43537047505378723, 0.9889753460884094, 0.003294530091807246, 0.7796858549118042, 0.3087697923183441, 0.5795490145683289, 0.05084187909960747, 0.03756241500377655, -0.5602878928184509, 0.5764543414115906, -0.15256521105766296, -0.3138578236103058, -0.11707378178834915, -0.3231169879436493, -0.9819257855415344, 0.013494935818016529, -0.34700968861579895, -1.3655747175216675, 0.5581505298614502, 0.08074047416448593, -0.7460536956787109, 0.6204457879066467, -0.6717378497123718, 0.5575554370880127, -0.580044150352478, -0.4452667236328125, -0.4124772250652313, -0.16807524859905243, -0.032160889357328415, -0.12147018313407898, 0.1962755173444748, 0.017818249762058258, -0.10204947739839554, 0.284273624420166, -0.24558086693286896, 0.3315967321395874, -0.3429318070411682, -0.14520423114299774, 0.09874002635478973, 0.24146424233913422, 0.6257306933403015, -0.1543138176202774, -0.2376551330089569, 0.8110044598579407, -0.2187635600566864, -0.22307783365249634, -0.3221057653427124, 1.1695550680160522, -0.7400697469711304, -0.19004583358764648, 0.13265946507453918, -0.4609149396419525, -0.0973081961274147, 0.40739136934280396, 0.24011585116386414, 0.25670677423477173, -0.26429328322410583, -0.3366664946079254, 0.11608707159757614, -0.3146302103996277, 0.3404778242111206, 0.5013065934181213, -0.6747483611106873, -0.5710769891738892, 0.9599423408508301, -0.028339147567749023, -0.11813633888959885, 0.6250491142272949, 0.46539509296417236, -0.3767774999141693, -0.8573143482208252, -0.3141781985759735, 0.17108234763145447, -0.41542428731918335, 0.17150269448757172, -0.7470332980155945, 0.3958737850189209, -0.4462239742279053, -0.6117671728134155, -0.3944598436355591, -0.4491506814956665, -0.03396010026335716, 0.1455310583114624, -0.21756260097026825, 0.80967116355896, -0.022458551451563835, 0.33482813835144043, -0.3516032099723816, 0.34121638536453247, -0.22998130321502686, 0.5189029574394226, -0.118118055164814, 0.03439176082611084, -0.4971955418586731, -0.1500568985939026, -0.2495020478963852, -0.40243279933929443, 0.3665374517440796, 0.004056098870933056, 0.516376793384552, 0.8442925810813904, 0.08754603564739227, 0.7728107571601868, -0.7302466034889221, 0.6507511138916016, 0.007126278709620237, -0.46735766530036926, 0.668503999710083, -0.482721745967865, 0.4111725687980652, 0.7531413435935974, 0.3563522696495056, -0.29705238342285156, -0.21495112776756287, -0.28724613785743713, -1.0624340772628784, 0.6023604869842529, -0.001220263191498816, -0.09154564142227173, 0.10425911098718643, 0.2516852915287018, 0.18788917362689972, 0.5363029837608337, -0.7105153799057007, -0.006963676307350397, -0.09756901860237122, 0.05396415293216705, -0.0031068173702806234, -0.2616916298866272, -0.3494010865688324, -0.3915797472000122, 0.5768997073173523, -0.24435243010520935, 0.4314914047718048, 0.13365885615348816, 0.2982114255428314, -0.5200433135032654, 0.11235707253217697, 0.6315158009529114, 0.9461939930915833, -0.3856338858604431, -0.3378840684890747, -0.15632398426532745, 0.014531242661178112, -0.18341796100139618, 0.049494415521621704, -0.43309250473976135, -0.22558827698230743, -0.08944544196128845, 0.763248085975647, 0.17144738137722015, -0.9633046984672546, 0.3123738467693329, -0.0038127009756863117, -0.07255279272794724, -0.7183812260627747, -0.261094868183136, -0.13893407583236694, 0.28740018606185913, 0.26885005831718445, 0.1751318722963333, 0.35478439927101135, -0.5328013300895691, -0.5057070255279541, 0.6088717579841614, -0.07119391858577728, -0.47918596863746643, 0.9565749764442444, 0.3935542702674866, -0.3098191022872925, 0.24645200371742249, -0.2048460692167282, -0.5437125563621521, -0.08940581232309341, 0.2042776495218277, 1.1567867994308472, -0.028389884158968925, -0.0792413130402565, 0.576090395450592, 0.32194191217422485, 0.26892316341400146, 0.5556313991546631, -0.37066495418548584, -0.7793856859207153, -0.30669382214546204, -0.6151975989341736, -0.2679932713508606, -0.10447419434785843, -0.373602032661438, 0.3101416826248169, -0.6706401705741882, -0.17921853065490723, -0.4531930983066559, -0.14685460925102234, -0.6567384600639343, -0.23670896887779236, 0.1365862637758255, 1.0174413919448853, -0.38258880376815796, 0.2555827498435974, 1.3740341663360596, 0.009943835437297821, -0.5367245078086853, 0.14140774309635162, -0.13963639736175537, -0.7086691856384277, 0.4687422215938568, -0.13923349976539612, -0.2495778203010559, 0.020514290779829025, -0.28976523876190186, -0.8521425724029541, 0.9064633846282959, 0.20826810598373413, -0.9204865097999573, -0.3042668402194977, 0.3068311810493469, 0.3534225523471832, -0.3627070486545563, 0.1422950029373169, 0.4694761633872986, 0.5263815522193909, -0.04207251965999603, -0.9948797821998596, -0.11464327573776245, 0.07630576193332672, 0.08520852029323578, 0.4280381500720978, -0.6490241885185242, 0.4716148376464844, -0.6549543142318726, -0.3785947561264038, 0.3752867877483368, 0.20197151601314545, -0.10084542632102966, 0.2534627616405487, 0.5987329483032227, 1.0025851726531982, 0.6464643478393555, -0.17549662292003632, 1.2014451026916504, -0.44396647810935974, 0.15041282773017883, 1.2590065002441406, -0.7151092886924744, 1.0826023817062378, 0.5434113144874573, -0.032766059041023254, 0.6042070388793945, 0.42748406529426575, 0.21290771663188934, 0.9213082194328308, -0.04377914220094681, -0.39491191506385803, -0.14462748169898987, -0.21501010656356812, 0.1215457171201706, 0.4162726402282715, 0.05048689246177673, 0.3818092942237854, -0.6974159479141235, 0.4983130991458893, -0.2425374835729599, 0.18303817510604858, -0.26029133796691895, 1.0375161170959473, -0.31797903776168823, -0.7530961632728577, 0.16031008958816528, 0.21629031002521515, 0.31504109501838684, -1.0101919174194336, 0.1481829136610031, -0.18082581460475922, 0.2032615840435028, -0.19356679916381836, -0.862849235534668, 0.2138586789369583, -0.18646511435508728, -0.056976836174726486, -0.43722936511039734, 0.6690270900726318, -0.44631242752075195, -0.11277907341718674, 0.4858781397342682, 0.26250365376472473, -0.12977170944213867, -0.36317163705825806, -0.37540403008461, 0.2144756019115448, 0.046509549021720886, -0.0801376923918724, 0.1474800556898117, 0.25116166472435, -0.1860968917608261, 0.8760495185852051, 0.8824831247329712, 0.3382434844970703, -0.05497225746512413, 0.2891627848148346, 0.8410156965255737, -0.6073418855667114, -0.9515644907951355, -0.5807167887687683, 0.46954992413520813, 0.028930215165019035, -0.1536894142627716, 0.6201987266540527, 0.9169144630432129, 0.8505693674087524, 0.02305995672941208, 0.6391812562942505, 0.006660361308604479, 0.34308817982673645, -0.3812042772769928, 0.04189274087548256, -0.47083809971809387, 0.5927127599716187, 0.023254040628671646, -1.1479450464248657, 0.01900334097445011, 0.4392363727092743, -0.6071704626083374, -0.12297990173101425, 0.4559653103351593, 0.42603445053100586, -0.11081362515687943, -0.12534451484680176, 0.18539251387119293, -0.21238014101982117, 0.5865703225135803, 0.7155297994613647, 0.7847376465797424, 0.05179518461227417, 0.3308233618736267, -0.35880598425865173, -0.3090164363384247, -0.2777760922908783, -0.4401645064353943, -0.6982346773147583, -0.47334691882133484, -0.09040379524230957, 0.17956998944282532, -0.10151927173137665, 0.966140627861023, 0.7829060554504395, -0.6776331663131714, -0.48550689220428467, -0.3026306629180908, -0.13120414316654205, -0.021080369129776955, -0.3515203893184662, 0.18841266632080078, -0.020047785714268684, -0.8033456802368164, 0.6381603479385376, 0.7040895223617554, -0.11496631056070328, -0.5026571154594421, 0.053103238344192505, -0.01775849424302578, -0.05588245019316673, 0.5412680506706238, 0.3381771445274353, -0.45942628383636475, 0.0635373517870903, 0.12099961936473846, 0.14188462495803833, 0.15088103711605072, 1.236769676208496, -0.5470868945121765, 0.638004720211029, 0.22368785738945007, 0.6077143549919128, 0.3900020122528076, -0.10468244552612305, 0.5816168189048767, -0.8424064517021179, 0.18187549710273743, 0.1351860761642456, 0.5950927138328552, 0.11243772506713867, -0.441818505525589, 0.4445369243621826, -0.11634381860494614, -0.6505727767944336, -0.5651608109474182, 0.297887921333313, -1.2045302391052246, -0.20266041159629822, 1.1040221452713013, 0.21666668355464935, -0.09922931343317032, 0.0021834750659763813, -0.5652070045471191, -0.6296852827072144, -0.7124009132385254, 0.9245991706848145, 0.3113786578178406, -0.30254971981048584, 0.3616536855697632, -0.40919575095176697, 0.14698515832424164, 0.1334584653377533, -0.9915907382965088, 0.08819227665662766, 0.539162814617157, 0.028550393879413605, 0.4158610999584198, 0.9141511917114258, 0.2945992648601532, 0.01242965180426836, -0.37721896171569824, 0.3196338415145874, 0.04410787671804428, -0.4105354845523834, 0.08785957098007202, 0.2928391993045807, 0.0662420466542244, -0.13834095001220703 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07179v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07179v2	Prompt Perturbation in Retrieval-Augmented Generation based Large Language Models	2024-02-11T12:25:41	2024-06-20T14:07:27	Zhibo Hu, Chen Wang, Yanfeng Shu, Helen, Paik, Liming Zhu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; H.3.3	The robustness of large language models (LLMs) becomes increasingly important as their use rapidly grows in a wide range of domains. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is considered as a means to improve the trustworthiness of text generation from LLMs. However, how the outputs from RAG-based LLMs are affected by slightly different inputs is not well studied. In this work, we find that the insertion of even a short prefix to the prompt leads to the generation of outputs far away from factually correct answers. We systematically evaluate the effect of such prefixes on RAG by introducing a novel optimization technique called Gradient Guided Prompt Perturbation (GGPP). GGPP achieves a high success rate in steering outputs of RAG-based LLMs to targeted wrong answers. It can also cope with instructions in the prompts requesting to ignore irrelevant context. We also exploit LLMs' neuron activation difference between prompts with and without GGPP perturbations to give a method that improves the robustness of RAG-based LLMs through a highly effective detector trained on neuron activation triggered by GGPP generated prompts. Our evaluation on open-sourced LLMs demonstrates the effectiveness of our methods.	[ -0.5080382823944092, -1.001448154449463, 0.6483320593833923, 0.2251761108636856, -0.3269408941268921, 0.009981702081859112, -0.2754746675491333, -0.13678419589996338, 0.16937364637851715, 0.3071337938308716, -0.5980154275894165, -0.31438180804252625, -0.6413367986679077, 0.23452241718769073, -0.09705514460802078, 0.9761631488800049, 0.285674512386322, 0.08329158276319504, -0.2972832918167114, 0.012393767945468426, -0.5239754319190979, -0.5824472904205322, -0.9193342328071594, -0.36987271904945374, 0.5951957702636719, 0.2218327820301056, 0.661177933216095, 0.39355164766311646, 0.2884695827960968, 0.23882608115673065, -0.5582859516143799, 0.23529000580310822, -0.5670926570892334, 0.47518157958984375, -0.13407404720783234, -0.24255576729774475, -0.41448652744293213, -0.14711856842041016, 0.766726553440094, 0.4820697605609894, -0.0981837660074234, 0.2855452597141266, 0.34284108877182007, 0.5254649519920349, -0.7918410301208496, -0.25863876938819885, -0.8551226258277893, -0.1787024438381195, -0.11472932994365692, -0.5454273223876953, -0.5731066465377808, -0.11905921250581741, -0.2216462939977646, -0.40191423892974854, 0.24645327031612396, 0.050903383642435074, 0.8926348686218262, 0.34971219301223755, -0.05171719193458557, -0.4194536805152893, -0.573918342590332, 0.795082688331604, -0.7031019330024719, 0.16248482465744019, 0.3128282129764557, 0.17394384741783142, -0.7029398679733276, -0.5819416046142578, -0.5447718501091003, -0.5396834015846252, -0.07121004164218903, -0.08051669597625732, -0.07085926085710526, 0.07681572437286377, 0.7087910771369934, 0.045847080647945404, -0.4226994514465332, 0.3120579123497009, 0.18115195631980896, -0.31358036398887634, 0.34606480598449707, 0.2558605372905731, 0.2502935528755188, -0.45586565136909485, -0.35186079144477844, -0.13566447794437408, -0.9280827641487122, 0.1484014093875885, 0.6736043095588684, 0.4352783262729645, 0.11265196651220322, 0.5244982838630676, -0.024615826085209846, 0.7108801603317261, 0.4646962285041809, -0.16747130453586578, 0.1922622174024582, -0.3003130853176117, -0.09007427841424942, -0.1616712510585785, 0.7844924330711365, 0.1711146980524063, 0.15097881853580475, -0.017559733241796494, -0.49717792868614197, -0.20287072658538818, 0.07160653918981552, -0.8974090814590454, 0.23175624012947083, 0.1376243680715561, -0.24460045993328094, -0.3685700297355652, -0.30863258242607117, -0.8744766116142273, -0.6053726077079773, -0.0898745059967041, 0.4224398136138916, -0.23059599101543427, 0.10084626078605652, -0.012413961812853813, 0.024053486064076424, 0.24139970541000366, 0.39659014344215393, -0.8430519104003906, 0.0599539615213871, 0.5159950852394104, 0.575855553150177, -0.12372890114784241, -0.11656457185745239, -1.2568379640579224, -0.05433167889714241, -0.3669111430644989, 0.7488924860954285, -0.6799542307853699, -0.722987949848175, -0.00917533878237009, -0.22331616282463074, 0.13460227847099304, -0.6241352558135986, 0.855624794960022, -0.8818771243095398, 0.31506970524787903, -0.3607845604419708, -0.2986821234226227, 0.06949693709611893, 0.35036325454711914, -0.5090250372886658, 0.8908569812774658, -0.06836012750864029, -0.8300057053565979, 0.1641494333744049, -0.35323965549468994, -0.2290877252817154, -0.013380629941821098, -0.3247177302837372, -0.39699292182922363, 0.2743746340274811, 0.5543472766876221, 0.3118019998073578, -0.5586978793144226, 0.33407795429229736, -0.17962369322776794, -0.3550978899002075, 0.3562873303890228, -0.6172694563865662, 0.6682777404785156, -0.033989742398262024, -0.19921831786632538, 0.16872990131378174, -0.796126663684845, 0.17290213704109192, 0.10188236087560654, -0.44571855664253235, -0.37678152322769165, -0.002638747915625572, -0.3049275875091553, 0.1258307248353958, 0.12258926033973694, -0.4066583812236786, 0.20351924002170563, -0.3576362729072571, -0.01014573872089386, 0.8605931401252747, 0.37844258546829224, 0.39259108901023865, -0.2959021329879761, 0.7201905846595764, -0.12400079518556595, -0.06082332134246826, -0.2991503179073334, -0.5143430829048157, -0.36370494961738586, -0.3282259404659271, 0.35971373319625854, 0.530864417552948, -1.000655174255371, 0.3074488341808319, -0.017097417265176773, -0.19950467348098755, -0.2019263356924057, 0.011905723251402378, 0.3652726411819458, 0.9920921921730042, 0.480268657207489, -0.10092303156852722, -0.30869871377944946, -0.7056326866149902, -0.5421609282493591, -0.08875474333763123, -0.21998347342014313, 0.3736006021499634, 0.21468128263950348, -0.3318323493003845, 0.8571113348007202, -0.4031532406806946, 0.05964586138725281, -0.028451930731534958, 0.07994645833969116, 0.6388870477676392, 0.39226284623146057, 0.49069127440452576, -0.6521582007408142, -0.5377742052078247, -0.3009200692176819, -0.264736145734787, -0.47296056151390076, -0.30260246992111206, -0.033293258398771286, 0.2757086753845215, 0.4992934763431549, -0.8041674494743347, 0.4481053054332733, 0.47662144899368286, -0.24582195281982422, 1.0150030851364136, -0.18797430396080017, 0.1121649518609047, -0.9204553961753845, 0.2425917237997055, 0.01986636593937874, -0.10452443361282349, -0.6529276967048645, 0.08415532112121582, 0.05726053938269615, 0.01629776507616043, -0.2754325270652771, 0.8314744234085083, -0.5529822111129761, -0.013354852795600891, -0.3447410762310028, 0.12911731004714966, 0.006577568128705025, 0.3644961714744568, -0.3325651288032532, 1.0814378261566162, 0.4840800166130066, -0.753883421421051, 0.19905681908130646, 0.34427788853645325, -0.06243401765823364, 0.3248344659805298, -0.6755937933921814, 0.34963956475257874, -0.33696886897087097, 0.22166357934474945, -1.11676824092865, -0.21651946008205414, 0.40543216466903687, -0.7373782396316528, 0.65435391664505, -0.28362011909484863, -0.31074628233909607, -0.11044871062040329, -0.43118128180503845, 0.41474464535713196, 0.6135107278823853, -0.7779335379600525, 0.7456813454627991, -0.06746788322925568, -0.26395168900489807, -0.8864638805389404, -0.4395221173763275, 0.05878615006804466, -0.26307231187820435, -0.5940622091293335, 0.2167561650276184, -0.11350475996732712, -0.21348805725574493, -0.19579458236694336, -0.20689648389816284, 0.33342286944389343, 0.15058830380439758, 0.09575061500072479, 0.3465271294116974, -0.11999662965536118, 0.10610514879226685, 0.08644445985555649, -0.08760877698659897, 0.2069762498140335, 0.03167818859219551, 0.8051387667655945, 0.17148151993751526, -0.4261823892593384, -0.15544721484184265, 0.22093145549297333, 0.32955923676490784, -0.3384423851966858, 0.6701872944831848, 0.5151008367538452, -0.05545976385474205, -0.4448292851448059, -0.49448665976524353, -0.3533601760864258, -0.5970032215118408, 0.3400840759277344, -0.3922213017940521, -0.8802131414413452, 0.6951772570610046, -0.15925808250904083, -0.1397746056318283, 0.37503522634506226, 0.5388554334640503, 0.09270887821912766, 1.0362212657928467, 0.21154218912124634, 0.11549854278564453, 0.5090609192848206, 0.06831063330173492, 0.006704018916934729, -1.1623613834381104, -0.026521313935518265, -0.8262017965316772, -0.10048949718475342, -0.6097193360328674, -0.545085608959198, 0.4544384777545929, 0.33483585715293884, -0.2524223327636719, -0.3310152590274811, -0.41480717062950134, 0.40682587027549744, 0.4307304918766022, 0.014282776042819023, 0.11189296841621399, 0.3864760994911194, -0.37438783049583435, -0.08827750384807587, -0.7236655354499817, -0.5687759518623352, 0.9945523142814636, 0.22847890853881836, 0.8573765158653259, 0.04003669694066048, 0.6026421785354614, 0.14795033633708954, 0.23957157135009766, -0.6549755334854126, 0.7460556626319885, -0.06867147982120514, -0.3123922646045685, -0.20610737800598145, -0.5520617961883545, -1.0111122131347656, 0.2422938048839569, -0.4210891127586365, -0.7605994939804077, 0.0927077978849411, 0.17016847431659698, -0.3757186830043793, 0.20191608369350433, -0.48872968554496765, 0.3455239236354828, -0.16138935089111328, -0.5544771552085876, 0.00855398178100586, -0.44239577651023865, 0.18387775123119354, -0.12346538156270981, 0.025588370859622955, 0.12326133251190186, -0.26063862442970276, 0.35511454939842224, -0.1050262376666069, 0.5936321020126343, -0.3142368495464325, -0.23253145813941956, 0.41945865750312805, 0.2353237122297287, 0.9577088952064514, 0.23801535367965698, -0.17004795372486115, -0.025005731731653214, -0.6309205293655396, -0.26791688799858093, -0.7263497710227966, 0.8549932241439819, -0.4704616367816925, -1.1457723379135132, -0.336076945066452, -0.49304625391960144, -0.5578031539916992, 0.10903530567884445, 0.45858055353164673, 0.6058427095413208, 0.13166756927967072, 0.025897379964590073, 0.8294227123260498, -0.7132439017295837, 0.5497533679008484, 0.38445454835891724, -0.4708857238292694, -0.5565122365951538, 0.6058796644210815, 0.059038955718278885, 0.42377370595932007, 0.11797608435153961, 0.29052430391311646, -0.3404200077056885, -0.7500590682029724, -0.5264703035354614, 0.4099953770637512, -0.6824489235877991, -0.17215023934841156, -0.40145161747932434, -0.05384251847863197, -0.26587143540382385, 0.04471829533576965, 0.11106729507446289, -0.21716777980327606, -0.6016964316368103, 0.10836485028266907, 0.1765204519033432, 0.495916485786438, -0.12463746964931488, 0.22597166895866394, -0.9171559810638428, 0.34583061933517456, 0.18815264105796814, 0.35448065400123596, 0.1116255670785904, -0.7624468207359314, 0.04292887821793556, 0.1022939383983612, -0.10574796795845032, -0.9889163970947266, 0.23265187442302704, -0.019133279100060463, 0.6305535435676575, 0.21024106442928314, 0.03190099820494652, 0.5633395314216614, -0.7047026753425598, 0.9033216834068298, 0.18674059212207794, -0.8290730714797974, 0.36993494629859924, -0.5866521596908569, 0.4663528800010681, 0.23241330683231354, 0.320115327835083, -0.3553902804851532, -0.2414397895336151, -0.5145022869110107, -0.9357055425643921, 0.5564900636672974, -0.08330853283405304, 0.3200894594192505, -0.13188536465168, 0.6676223874092102, -0.022782649844884872, 0.13253432512283325, -0.32475772500038147, -0.35298848152160645, 0.21124856173992157, 0.2611667811870575, -0.11864662170410156, -0.7211909294128418, -0.058301158249378204, 0.13614335656166077, 0.7690195441246033, -0.18002717196941376, 0.17523537576198578, 0.3564388155937195, 0.17261727154254913, -0.26019003987312317, 0.32405999302864075, 0.7654796838760376, 0.4441917836666107, 0.0146010871976614, -0.1474682241678238, 0.2576890289783478, -0.5772671103477478, 0.238568976521492, 0.06042947620153427, -0.5177774429321289, 0.21666626632213593, 0.23402827978134155, 0.882409393787384, -0.40330663323402405, -0.48568111658096313, 0.363798052072525, -0.13256743550300598, 0.0826801136136055, 0.022182615473866463, 0.15870560705661774, -0.12862427532672882, 0.15675900876522064, 0.7063811421394348, 0.24432657659053802, 0.037200022488832474, -0.14647740125656128, 0.1033547967672348, 0.7256329655647278, -0.007632555440068245, -0.20828750729560852, 0.6863753795623779, 0.023137429729104042, -0.47041693329811096, 0.45590075850486755, -0.2730088531970978, -0.5507861971855164, 0.4659213423728943, 0.6268879771232605, 0.9084048271179199, -0.3498550057411194, 0.11170996725559235, 0.5351389050483704, 0.2659796476364136, -0.01079683005809784, 0.19564984738826752, 0.19286352396011353, -0.6432817578315735, -0.9619433879852295, -0.6663005948066711, -0.3357110321521759, 0.3107682168483734, -0.5709143877029419, 0.21581482887268066, -0.5148450136184692, -0.40253007411956787, -0.3368963599205017, -0.11701355874538422, -0.3857289254665375, 0.23969532549381256, 0.16460593044757843, 0.9107208251953125, -0.5197768807411194, 0.5207545161247253, 0.7713362574577332, -0.1981315314769745, -1.0629733800888062, 0.47359299659729004, -0.2763421833515167, -0.5445399880409241, 0.7153588533401489, 0.014415431767702103, -0.30810868740081787, 0.04452737420797348, -0.7633647918701172, -0.984589695930481, 0.6426875591278076, 0.6097168326377869, -0.5309950709342957, 0.012541628442704678, -0.004173071123659611, 0.5910953283309937, -0.058882713317871094, 0.2174558788537979, 0.23460689187049866, 0.481915146112442, 0.3063843548297882, -0.843191921710968, 0.2831577658653259, -0.048659611493349075, 0.174269437789917, 0.24912258982658386, -0.4129214286804199, 0.9271678328514099, -0.28901776671409607, -0.42656031250953674, 0.25042080879211426, 0.551476776599884, 0.6247791051864624, 0.03158913180232048, 0.41939932107925415, 0.5000830888748169, 0.7424979209899902, -0.047812409698963165, 1.2956581115722656, -0.11762154847383499, 0.22369201481342316, 1.2240023612976074, -0.24529005587100983, 0.6629688739776611, 0.8151520490646362, 0.05523735657334328, 0.41993433237075806, 0.365373432636261, 0.11425860226154327, 0.3952838182449341, 0.4102420508861542, -0.28154364228248596, -0.11410198360681534, -0.07787834852933884, -0.4023762345314026, 0.09108227491378784, 0.3967773914337158, -0.27541130781173706, -0.28678327798843384, -0.038335446268320084, 0.16351628303527832, 0.21358941495418549, -0.5174533128738403, 0.5592934489250183, -0.07456682622432709, -0.9348452687263489, 1.012701153755188, 0.018512502312660217, 0.7533344626426697, -0.6381663084030151, -0.01705847680568695, -0.3516263961791992, -0.05158555135130882, -0.26889047026634216, -0.5729689598083496, -0.006518175825476646, 0.13916070759296417, -0.23207902908325195, -0.1106782853603363, 1.012919306755066, -0.2682030498981476, -0.14480799436569214, 0.28665807843208313, 0.5350874066352844, -0.14888542890548706, -0.04546637088060379, -0.4579724371433258, 0.13283959031105042, 0.11019212752580643, -0.7171075344085693, 0.462950199842453, 0.4490911662578583, -0.01586536504328251, 0.5567721128463745, 0.8318836688995361, 0.28477054834365845, 0.10899203270673752, -0.03319046273827553, 1.1182975769042969, -0.36734890937805176, -0.2826882600784302, -0.9436389803886414, 0.4955867528915405, -0.008290108293294907, -0.2535177171230316, 0.9096152782440186, 0.20176354050636292, 0.5094044208526611, -0.11767365038394928, 0.6248724460601807, 0.017242595553398132, 0.589250922203064, -0.6630269289016724, 0.49265390634536743, -0.5538651943206787, 0.5627667307853699, -0.2754438519477844, -1.1612730026245117, -0.4350968301296234, 0.29152819514274597, -0.4906240999698639, 0.17138099670410156, 0.5137273669242859, 1.061375379562378, 0.2971118986606598, -0.2490617334842682, 0.31177815794944763, 0.31492990255355835, 0.451895147562027, 0.2319624274969101, 0.9830318689346313, -0.144882470369339, 0.3775641918182373, 0.16768121719360352, -0.06055326387286186, -0.04644465073943138, -1.1229934692382812, -0.8718664646148682, -0.3242936134338379, -0.05738554894924164, -0.769752025604248, 0.11949998140335083, 0.9066417813301086, 0.15385591983795166, -0.6781452894210815, 0.056799404323101044, -0.04571693390607834, 0.09529861062765121, 0.17308731377124786, -0.20384246110916138, 0.3862161636352539, -0.7172519564628601, -0.6539930105209351, 0.5884952545166016, 0.05595898628234863, 0.0647481307387352, -0.2834707796573639, -0.12080232053995132, -0.30668914318084717, 0.1972995102405548, 0.37423649430274963, 0.21407121419906616, -0.5001006126403809, -0.3500251770019531, 0.11575020849704742, -0.24461419880390167, 0.047099851071834564, 0.5381817817687988, -0.982002317905426, 0.29639437794685364, 0.6712437272071838, 0.8873366713523865, 0.2358691543340683, 0.31490546464920044, 0.47798073291778564, -1.0331507921218872, 0.1642477661371231, 0.42760083079338074, 0.311800479888916, 0.39756661653518677, -0.49732884764671326, 0.31133097410202026, 0.11640670150518417, -0.7547709941864014, -0.9915384650230408, 0.3961504101753235, -0.5757024884223938, -0.2877034544944763, 1.61783766746521, 0.012700260616838932, -0.3248879015445709, 0.3564874529838562, -0.4499947428703308, 0.04071660712361336, -0.5267478227615356, 0.6171554923057556, 0.679067075252533, -0.04154268279671669, 0.08560146391391754, -0.3591940104961395, 0.6670161485671997, 0.6774526834487915, -0.5170876383781433, -0.09419460594654083, 0.7939211130142212, 0.1269342601299286, 0.3653491139411926, 0.3931712806224823, -0.0016986926784738898, 0.36777427792549133, -0.14489924907684326, -0.08215583860874176, -0.15168121457099915, -0.2409789264202118, -0.7167994379997253, 0.4190398156642914, 0.26485222578048706, -0.060830410569906235 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07157v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07157v2	Natural Language Reinforcement Learning	2024-02-11T11:03:04	2024-02-14T19:59:05	Xidong Feng, Ziyu Wan, Mengyue Yang, Ziyan Wang, Girish A. Koushik, Yali Du, Ying Wen, Jun Wang	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Reinforcement Learning (RL) has shown remarkable abilities in learning policies for decision-making tasks. However, RL is often hindered by issues such as low sample efficiency, lack of interpretability, and sparse supervision signals. To tackle these limitations, we take inspiration from the human learning process and introduce Natural Language Reinforcement Learning (NLRL), which innovatively combines RL principles with natural language representation. Specifically, NLRL redefines RL concepts like task objectives, policy, value function, Bellman equation, and policy iteration in natural language space. We present how NLRL can be practically implemented with the latest advancements in large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4. Initial experiments over tabular MDPs demonstrate the effectiveness, efficiency, and also interpretability of the NLRL framework.	[ -0.3233734667301178, -0.8962576389312744, 0.5755453109741211, 0.3261297941207886, -0.04139046370983124, 0.4417577087879181, -0.46926233172416687, -0.33418986201286316, -0.04773657023906708, 0.5870705842971802, -0.6874375343322754, -0.3427557647228241, -0.3379388451576233, 0.17441467940807343, 0.06004586070775986, 1.4169201850891113, -0.04829754680395126, -0.1163291484117508, 0.2415616363286972, 0.10389846563339233, -0.46645885705947876, -0.34826454520225525, -1.0523045063018799, -0.8022120594978333, 0.7611926198005676, 0.32052603363990784, 0.7021461129188538, 0.4275572896003723, 0.2997101843357086, 0.282797247171402, -0.0002504124422557652, 0.41245368123054504, -0.46315497159957886, -0.019560720771551132, -0.28661978244781494, -0.3487609922885895, -0.005927317310124636, 0.018842501565814018, 0.5758724212646484, 0.37917768955230713, -0.6436174511909485, -0.44978660345077515, 0.15277113020420074, 0.7487990260124207, -0.19366629421710968, 0.4786483347415924, -0.5388496518135071, 0.34871283173561096, 0.18955615162849426, -0.2526840567588806, -0.376289039850235, -0.6466781497001648, 0.34632644057273865, -0.7005383968353271, -0.04344934970140457, 0.18035151064395905, 0.7714734077453613, 0.33477896451950073, -0.35083895921707153, -0.6003739237785339, -0.8938272595405579, 0.9320671558380127, -0.7315465211868286, 0.4687179625034332, 0.41943708062171936, 0.7227970957756042, -0.39263784885406494, -0.6129658222198486, -0.5717187523841858, -0.629564106464386, -0.07591709494590759, -0.19278664886951447, -0.05220973491668701, 0.2610498368740082, 0.18575724959373474, 0.10604014992713928, -0.5413844585418701, 0.2284219115972519, -0.24552637338638306, -0.08551105111837387, 0.4888964593410492, 0.19629698991775513, 0.1069592535495758, -0.17403122782707214, -0.5025901198387146, -0.10151743143796921, -0.546798825263977, 0.20108728110790253, 0.1250254511833191, 0.519213855266571, -0.018856210634112358, 0.3145073354244232, -0.19932641088962555, 0.6260640025138855, -0.037439554929733276, -0.14215624332427979, 0.05055011808872223, -0.11321327090263367, -0.3741852641105652, -0.02715793438255787, 0.730434000492096, -0.07883809506893158, 0.22600944340229034, -0.36948609352111816, -0.3373333215713501, -0.013641862198710442, 0.5167078375816345, -0.34757566452026367, -0.05581241101026535, -0.029932526871562004, -0.09585915505886078, -0.41567009687423706, -0.13124005496501923, -0.759527862071991, -0.46423715353012085, -0.6290371417999268, 0.4493695795536041, -0.4827822148799896, -0.1442791074514389, 0.19564983248710632, 0.03039814718067646, 0.33628422021865845, 0.3521898090839386, -1.1012723445892334, 0.5788520574569702, 0.7218010425567627, 0.4859292805194855, -0.24097086489200592, -0.21616874635219574, -0.5943319201469421, 0.08012714982032776, -0.3938455879688263, 0.6466101408004761, -0.3572992980480194, -0.26048851013183594, 0.02079416811466217, -0.2783345580101013, 0.0542626790702343, -0.5478652715682983, 0.594654381275177, -0.6273932456970215, 0.2841007113456726, 0.018460355699062347, -0.46132534742355347, -0.29640448093414307, 0.5685771703720093, -0.7954826951026917, 0.8078810572624207, 0.03647424653172493, -0.45232445001602173, 0.48884066939353943, -1.1832233667373657, -0.5369067192077637, 0.030671576038002968, -0.17756491899490356, -0.49109411239624023, -0.13210122287273407, 0.2553935647010803, 0.34819671511650085, -0.11413886398077011, 0.3323251008987427, 0.029604176059365273, -0.1640012562274933, 0.4433267116546631, -0.6266348958015442, 0.40630489587783813, 0.2548573911190033, -0.24844186007976532, 0.37898939847946167, -0.568033754825592, 0.10539525002241135, 0.18317119777202606, -0.6995596289634705, -0.07738028466701508, 0.09942460805177689, 0.01504833996295929, 0.1761024445295334, 0.0509088970720768, -0.2162410318851471, 0.2587566375732422, -0.6277488470077515, 0.6047285795211792, 0.6508949995040894, 0.24710720777511597, 0.6570590138435364, -0.227700337767601, 0.6058841943740845, -0.3946494162082672, 0.08640411496162415, 0.31525176763534546, -0.21469631791114807, -0.4595832824707031, -0.08761048316955566, 0.18304865062236786, 0.4907456040382385, -1.0746171474456787, 0.1708744615316391, -0.03820570185780525, -0.02612173743546009, -0.3925292491912842, 0.23742076754570007, 0.4704051613807678, 0.3534351885318756, 0.5772666931152344, 0.021741846576333046, -0.7310900092124939, -0.720699667930603, -0.34893858432769775, -0.018096648156642914, 0.08632798492908478, 0.04140656813979149, 0.4065914452075958, -0.22154635190963745, 1.0752978324890137, -0.31642773747444153, -0.4595440924167633, -1.0245157480239868, 0.44816213846206665, 0.361669659614563, 0.1654360443353653, -0.049710795283317566, -0.8210457563400269, -0.5192569494247437, 0.10369469225406647, -0.576669454574585, 0.14113305509090424, -0.2625647485256195, 0.17332907021045685, 0.5206796526908875, 0.4720650613307953, -0.5078167915344238, 0.3432376980781555, 0.37060874700546265, -0.27120140194892883, 0.58149653673172, -0.5983995199203491, -0.1654268354177475, -0.45566046237945557, -0.37623801827430725, 0.10542543232440948, -0.5362778902053833, -0.7527937293052673, 0.043584100902080536, -0.04218584671616554, -0.005858511198312044, -0.3437913656234741, 0.5616358518600464, -0.14899644255638123, -0.1365608274936676, -0.39082130789756775, 0.1159290075302124, 0.01759427972137928, 0.8110203742980957, 0.25250953435897827, 0.7273129820823669, -0.05488796904683113, -0.7518953084945679, 0.2539352774620056, 0.16339527070522308, -0.28932613134384155, 0.4241795837879181, -0.4885179400444031, -0.20102734863758087, -0.1374921053647995, 0.4372919499874115, -0.41059544682502747, 0.03620317578315735, 0.3233153820037842, -0.1318383663892746, 0.27552530169487, 0.13677293062210083, -0.28226011991500854, -0.4260893762111664, -0.15290121734142303, -0.2613815665245056, 0.5823934674263, -0.5822306275367737, 0.5823159217834473, 0.3635415732860565, 0.03022131696343422, -0.6618138551712036, -0.48892179131507874, 0.19344015419483185, -0.3605654537677765, 0.15692315995693207, 0.286428302526474, 0.09104467183351517, -0.1536574810743332, 0.10522396862506866, 0.09661326557397842, -0.19396516680717468, 0.03659752011299133, -0.04326934739947319, 0.0667763352394104, 0.1383373886346817, 0.2447880506515503, -0.27557820081710815, -0.22233715653419495, 0.023853013291954994, -0.3633759319782257, 0.5062387585639954, -0.29842960834503174, -0.12071795761585236, -0.41816169023513794, -0.027770141139626503, 0.1216084435582161, -0.19344432651996613, 0.48484474420547485, 0.5087878704071045, -0.07297772169113159, -0.6230631470680237, -0.29563236236572266, -0.145169198513031, -0.4690225124359131, 0.4696302115917206, -0.14455938339233398, -0.9194674491882324, -0.06882091611623764, -0.01066833920776844, 0.4440937340259552, -0.04232059791684151, 0.3786911070346832, -0.30640146136283875, 0.8774932026863098, 0.6386945247650146, -0.15186753869056702, 0.5113031268119812, -0.1878027766942978, 0.2227260172367096, -0.6513792872428894, -0.16649317741394043, -0.23049016296863556, -0.20871609449386597, -0.5271351337432861, -0.6613291501998901, 0.12595339119434357, 0.02552335150539875, -0.386087030172348, 0.3709903657436371, -0.1947384774684906, 0.5311300158500671, 0.589698076248169, 0.08226531744003296, 0.42842650413513184, -0.14107811450958252, -0.4361952841281891, -0.19741037487983704, -0.7926313281059265, -0.49288517236709595, 0.8620738387107849, 0.5527389049530029, 0.8119015097618103, 0.05245153233408928, 0.8806076049804688, 0.5464736819267273, 0.4012894034385681, -0.6626145839691162, 0.48690810799598694, 0.050424642860889435, -0.32699528336524963, -0.6022132635116577, -0.525160551071167, -0.9842075109481812, 0.3892035484313965, -0.4190214276313782, -0.6018810272216797, -0.3173677325248718, 0.30228883028030396, -0.18812374770641327, 0.2686685025691986, -0.49754366278648376, 0.761663556098938, -0.4972541928291321, -0.41117000579833984, -0.4594029486179352, -0.4714604914188385, 0.30964088439941406, 0.14235110580921173, 0.5296088457107544, -0.04716845601797104, 0.06781776994466782, 0.4639042913913727, -0.13473041355609894, 0.8113074898719788, -0.3518809676170349, -0.1760251820087433, 0.16111667454242706, -0.05560627579689026, 0.7445300221443176, 0.07456621527671814, 0.05282679572701454, -0.3393646776676178, -0.3743603825569153, -0.11752051115036011, -0.8624029755592346, 0.401834100484848, -0.43413224816322327, -0.3642312288284302, -0.37799739837646484, -0.6328602433204651, -0.5210939049720764, -0.02474857307970524, -0.30746012926101685, 0.2501963973045349, -0.5468588471412659, -0.04781920462846756, 0.6624899506568909, -0.5821042060852051, 0.47495031356811523, 0.5707338452339172, -0.7377723455429077, -0.3987600803375244, 1.0008972883224487, -0.18856213986873627, 0.37692591547966003, 0.6199631690979004, 0.30697891116142273, -0.8015124201774597, -0.5145187377929688, -0.2608781158924103, 0.09892483055591583, -0.5938354730606079, 0.06559941917657852, -0.3989931344985962, -0.19380347430706024, 0.031408313661813736, -0.16630510985851288, -0.1940665990114212, -0.2454131692647934, -0.02147270180284977, -0.3335241973400116, 0.25165849924087524, 0.9225311279296875, -0.22611799836158752, 0.2615736722946167, -0.3810318112373352, 0.6247069835662842, 0.6366686224937439, 0.3993445336818695, -0.027723757550120354, -0.2770945727825165, -0.17692191898822784, -0.02684013918042183, -0.3048211634159088, -0.5711574554443359, 0.6416630744934082, 0.11428972333669662, 0.6694223880767822, 0.2668115496635437, -0.12443487346172333, 0.5322935581207275, -0.7659317255020142, 0.3717612624168396, 0.18164443969726562, -0.6133852005004883, 0.2965713143348694, -0.24863211810588837, 0.3345082700252533, 0.4947245121002197, 0.19908025860786438, -0.6580625176429749, -0.5030512809753418, -0.5592250823974609, -0.5855480432510376, 0.39699670672416687, 0.05003209784626961, 0.004821036010980606, 0.014335556887090206, -0.09655679017305374, -0.00301969051361084, 0.36649373173713684, -0.9482156038284302, 0.11202281713485718, -0.1939709633588791, -0.2231055349111557, -0.2099919468164444, -0.08995137363672256, 0.11111883074045181, -0.19077739119529724, 0.6525029540061951, -0.23993417620658875, 0.27916890382766724, 0.09947623312473297, -0.33238643407821655, 0.13153935968875885, 0.8316424489021301, 0.6126357316970825, 0.4873127341270447, -0.21818839013576508, 0.056786518543958664, 0.358015775680542, 0.12454797327518463, 0.1550695151090622, -0.12375383824110031, -0.046802882105112076, -0.21467547118663788, 0.2080654352903366, 0.980719268321991, 0.8350698947906494, -0.8881872892379761, 0.11942928284406662, -0.1473620980978012, -0.36474549770355225, -0.37848636507987976, 0.11506856977939606, 0.2598920464515686, 0.3717309534549713, 0.3968229293823242, -0.1597510725259781, -0.019759245216846466, -0.6547818183898926, 0.6010181307792664, 0.5940802693367004, -0.8024305701255798, 0.033608127385377884, 0.39045944809913635, 0.14781640470027924, -0.46274450421333313, 0.4576607346534729, -0.6196713447570801, -0.7975608110427856, 0.35626769065856934, 0.6707653999328613, 0.5882012844085693, 0.15578676760196686, 0.7172261476516724, 0.12049663811922073, 0.442269504070282, -0.13548414409160614, 0.2847400903701782, -0.014695688150823116, -0.7043935656547546, -0.7785190343856812, -0.7263167500495911, -0.6162763237953186, 0.08162801712751389, -0.48319011926651, -0.0518791489303112, -0.8020384907722473, 0.10525228828191757, -0.31037580966949463, 0.16445209085941315, -0.6428278088569641, -0.03901733085513115, 0.0859934538602829, 0.8586807250976562, -0.5711317658424377, 1.028124451637268, 0.46422451734542847, -0.4311656355857849, -0.9765295386314392, -0.0952020063996315, 0.0013298876583576202, -0.7720851898193359, 1.0004206895828247, 0.025779930874705315, -0.028610408306121826, 0.19732733070850372, -0.3993924856185913, -0.27700746059417725, 0.824610710144043, -0.031028319150209427, -0.48375752568244934, -0.17545516788959503, 0.23527847230434418, 0.6773110032081604, -0.30060872435569763, 0.017165053635835648, 0.7035499215126038, 0.6841427087783813, -0.03665295988321304, -0.8121616840362549, -0.24496303498744965, 0.3161883056163788, -0.0024987810757011175, 0.4081997573375702, -0.004721285309642553, 0.5309081673622131, -0.2609482407569885, -0.1640513688325882, -0.22224430739879608, 0.8141149878501892, 0.4131752550601959, 0.08458324521780014, 0.5378708243370056, 0.5630982518196106, 0.7770845293998718, -0.10658295452594757, 1.1220122575759888, 0.32320070266723633, 0.2682386636734009, 1.0661392211914062, -0.4010995626449585, 0.8717619776725769, 0.5360403060913086, -0.31627076864242554, 0.7178787589073181, 0.12465344369411469, 0.08243546634912491, 0.7457872629165649, 0.38022691011428833, -0.20261365175247192, -0.11326082795858383, -0.16150562465190887, 0.21095800399780273, 0.31088948249816895, 0.4990428388118744, 0.017731141299009323, -0.5954133868217468, 0.2122555673122406, -0.05694058537483215, 0.590427041053772, -0.398438036441803, 0.9703781008720398, 0.0692187026143074, -0.4141955077648163, 0.4502454996109009, -0.0072356099262833595, 0.9146432280540466, -0.7913389205932617, -0.4865173399448395, 0.18487028777599335, 0.17407581210136414, 0.10506735742092133, -0.8089213371276855, 0.3437648415565491, -0.07896408438682556, 0.05724380165338516, -0.685072124004364, 0.5757290720939636, -0.5367403626441956, -0.26325249671936035, 0.3828417956829071, 0.24747410416603088, -0.12763993442058563, 0.24982838332653046, -1.0522534847259521, -0.174829363822937, 0.06773672252893448, -0.17148232460021973, 0.397348016500473, 0.329674631357193, -0.006723389029502869, 1.0410854816436768, 0.6917617917060852, 0.3235682547092438, -0.004789035301655531, -0.13341064751148224, 0.4325523376464844, -0.8363328576087952, -0.7403756380081177, -0.6769610047340393, 0.4323968291282654, -0.1750248223543167, 0.01649429276585579, 0.424299031496048, 0.2102423906326294, 0.6165953278541565, 0.003409013384953141, 0.8905434012413025, -0.03755096346139908, 0.886793851852417, -0.8957729339599609, 0.3896695673465729, -0.20566217601299286, 0.4282393455505371, -0.005782174877822399, -0.6686050295829773, -0.3756908178329468, 0.9804211854934692, -0.4171594977378845, -0.11273728311061859, 0.7308545112609863, 0.5628904104232788, 0.1387573778629303, -0.029799500480294228, 0.3852388858795166, -0.04881387576460838, 0.5472514629364014, 0.7040402293205261, 1.0112059116363525, 0.11544476449489594, 0.5877796411514282, -0.13598529994487762, 0.09478672593832016, -0.180586040019989, -0.9892836809158325, -0.840984582901001, -0.3572844862937927, 0.04562535881996155, -0.1032559871673584, 0.3789823651313782, 1.390380620956421, 0.4525430500507355, -0.6305596232414246, -0.3865933120250702, -0.5353772044181824, 0.6092643737792969, -0.43396055698394775, -0.3203583359718323, 0.08255821466445923, -0.680038571357727, -0.5174915790557861, 0.7513781785964966, 0.29969868063926697, -0.14821907877922058, -0.4292795956134796, -0.6957492232322693, -0.38695651292800903, -0.14677411317825317, 0.5855394601821899, 0.7528043389320374, -0.8261257410049438, -0.21102169156074524, -0.5029475092887878, -0.3600931465625763, 0.13952741026878357, 0.8423721194267273, -1.006409764289856, 0.07991262525320053, 0.21336421370506287, 0.9655327200889587, 0.3865131735801697, -0.15842336416244507, 0.7619985938072205, -0.7376123070716858, -0.0911407396197319, 0.45726215839385986, 0.0028195965569466352, 0.23208914697170258, 0.19864001870155334, 0.4585615396499634, -0.2743526101112366, -0.4844547510147095, -0.6340153217315674, 0.5245653390884399, -0.6674251556396484, -0.3810182809829712, 1.0427745580673218, 0.15898497402668, -0.029371710494160652, -0.5228161215782166, -0.30182206630706787, 0.05282248184084892, -0.6520788073539734, 0.6451318264007568, 0.23651722073554993, -0.25769704580307007, -0.47561514377593994, -1.0692448616027832, 0.8694003224372864, 0.20738330483436584, -0.9931265711784363, 0.11016269773244858, 0.304149866104126, 0.09182168543338776, -0.11661995202302933, 0.6683012247085571, 0.14453178644180298, 0.04098543897271156, -0.5760153532028198, 0.1282275915145874, -0.09287016093730927, -0.2350107729434967, -0.4729589521884918, 0.0694909617304802, 0.46213212609291077, 0.16677288711071014 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07148v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07148v2	X-LoRA: Mixture of Low-Rank Adapter Experts, a Flexible Framework for Large Language Models with Applications in Protein Mechanics and Molecular Design	2024-02-11T10:23:34	2024-03-30T20:18:54	Eric L. Buehler, Markus J. Buehler	cond-mat.soft	cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.dis-nn, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM	We report a mixture of expert strategy to create fine-tuned large language models using a deep layer-wise token-level approach based on low-rank adaptation (LoRA). Starting with a set of pre-trained LoRA adapters, our gating strategy uses the hidden states to dynamically mix adapted layers, allowing the resulting X-LoRA model to draw upon different capabilities and create never-before-used deep layer-wise combinations to solve tasks. The design is inspired by the biological principles of universality and diversity, where neural network building blocks are reused in different hierarchical manifestations. Hence, the X-LoRA model can be easily implemented for any existing large language model (LLM) without a need for modifications of the underlying structure. We develop a tailored X-LoRA model that offers scientific capabilities including forward/inverse analysis tasks and enhanced reasoning capability, focused on biomaterial analysis, protein mechanics and design. The impact of this work include access to readily expandable and adaptable models with strong domain knowledge and the capability to integrate across areas of knowledge. Featuring experts in biology, mathematics, reasoning, bio-inspired materials, mechanics and materials, chemistry, protein biophysics, mechanics and quantum-mechanics based molecular properties, we conduct a series of physics-focused case studies. We examine knowledge recall, protein mechanics forward/inverse tasks, protein design, adversarial agentic modeling including ontological knowledge graph construction, as well as molecular design. The model is capable not only of making quantitative predictions of nanomechanical properties of proteins or quantum mechanical molecular properties, but also reasons over the results and correctly predicts likely mechanisms that explain distinct molecular behaviors.	[ -0.17615537345409393, -0.8130728006362915, 0.5094221234321594, -0.2722298204898834, 0.06806330382823944, 0.400166392326355, 0.06572968512773514, -0.6140007376670837, 0.6517698168754578, 0.4304046630859375, -0.3930099904537201, -0.22642269730567932, -0.6451767086982727, -0.12031065672636032, -0.44968050718307495, 0.8825812339782715, 0.20319446921348572, -0.15761366486549377, 0.2245165854692459, -0.20052744448184967, -0.09261267632246017, -0.22976507246494293, -0.4729496240615845, -0.5536776781082153, 0.7470612525939941, 0.2314731478691101, 0.7965350151062012, 0.5782679319381714, 0.2935005724430084, 0.34043559432029724, -0.4035581052303314, 0.01011622417718172, -0.5312564373016357, -0.17882178723812103, -0.7108275294303894, -0.7471275329589844, -1.0212539434432983, -0.04412687197327614, 0.4074428379535675, 0.9936665296554565, -0.0914803072810173, -0.012446001172065735, 0.006676021963357925, 0.6924917101860046, -0.5237359404563904, -0.031152447685599327, -0.7739207744598389, 0.20326441526412964, -0.05477778613567352, -0.23099030554294586, -0.07215528935194016, 0.15373510122299194, 0.13436296582221985, -0.6820167899131775, -0.063948854804039, -0.023042768239974976, 0.3773007094860077, 0.17588934302330017, -0.29653120040893555, -0.09172382205724716, -0.6815119385719299, 0.6225558519363403, -0.7559014558792114, 0.437723845243454, 0.12162882089614868, 0.3637789785861969, -0.5003628730773926, -0.5187453627586365, -0.5486300587654114, -0.2560878098011017, 0.2677077353000641, 0.17154648900032043, -0.14795078337192535, 0.021127551794052124, -0.09171096980571747, 0.3578234314918518, -0.45020735263824463, 0.3346870243549347, -0.2955241799354553, 0.32400453090667725, 0.4760204553604126, -0.07210281491279602, 0.30014926195144653, -0.014207587577402592, -0.11678493767976761, -0.14489272236824036, -0.6143179535865784, 0.0945902019739151, 0.3750990033149719, 0.5140120387077332, -0.11998463422060013, 0.6539599299430847, -0.4153318703174591, 0.5412585139274597, 0.16811494529247284, -0.2612866461277008, 0.071699358522892, -0.23020291328430176, -0.26448386907577515, 0.09117389470338821, 0.6574621796607971, -0.25655388832092285, -0.19427230954170227, -0.2770092785358429, -0.1327592134475708, -0.21380546689033508, 0.20787839591503143, -0.5765436887741089, -0.2977869510650635, 0.3230150043964386, -0.47191479802131653, -0.6132597923278809, -0.05169185250997543, -0.7912248969078064, -0.8336630463600159, -0.15809783339500427, 0.820608913898468, -0.2942541241645813, -0.28393566608428955, 0.4684247076511383, -0.16788935661315918, -0.032031841576099396, 0.18572856485843658, -0.9840743541717529, 0.44671815633773804, 0.5926833152770996, 0.5659745335578918, -0.18380461633205414, -0.3665250539779663, -0.5157237648963928, 0.44857028126716614, 0.05383576452732086, 0.7730590105056763, -0.6480634808540344, -0.29461929202079773, -0.4658460319042206, -0.12005313485860825, 0.001549210399389267, -0.2926255762577057, 0.4055217504501343, -0.5912131071090698, 0.007658324204385281, -0.1861928403377533, -0.2975252866744995, -0.4130958318710327, -0.03191954270005226, -0.7639009356498718, 0.5073878765106201, 0.3811039626598358, -0.6168897747993469, 0.31095802783966064, -1.1158173084259033, -0.4186704754829407, 0.06277164071798325, -0.4421220123767853, -0.20251621305942535, 0.3709385097026825, 0.039207953959703445, 0.006359654478728771, -0.4069910943508148, -0.10298463702201843, -0.5542944669723511, -0.1364680975675583, 0.589267909526825, -0.0036804662086069584, 0.6540787816047668, 0.0790185034275055, -0.3847465217113495, 0.3610009551048279, -1.2334325313568115, 0.1693093478679657, 0.02884957566857338, -0.4513862133026123, -0.212155282497406, 0.03581516444683075, -0.16994400322437286, 0.48268985748291016, 0.16510751843452454, -0.40174227952957153, 0.42958787083625793, -0.48582136631011963, 0.8130626082420349, 0.7542597651481628, -0.08903130143880844, 0.5634743571281433, -0.18278394639492035, 0.5273066163063049, 0.04807804152369499, -0.07495496422052383, 0.2622901201248169, -0.5487670302391052, -0.8892972469329834, -0.1347355842590332, 0.2168891727924347, 0.5464444756507874, -0.6868778467178345, 0.6392248868942261, -0.1929738074541092, -0.4808935225009918, -0.43582484126091003, 0.48687177896499634, 0.2413322627544403, 0.4490779936313629, 0.3542269766330719, -0.16867128014564514, -0.46285614371299744, -0.6935478448867798, -0.20690885186195374, -0.1686842292547226, 0.13489514589309692, -0.0031965693924576044, 0.7551149725914001, -0.3131698668003082, 0.9288044571876526, -0.5365617275238037, -0.21365861594676971, -0.2127734273672104, -0.06438709050416946, 0.5973181128501892, 0.490156888961792, 0.4838275909423828, -0.6078280210494995, -0.10947883129119873, 0.5502143502235413, -0.9676452875137329, 0.28524327278137207, 0.13681238889694214, -0.284661203622818, -0.028801092877984047, 0.4223400354385376, -0.562127947807312, 0.2571914792060852, 0.5906327962875366, -0.573240339756012, 0.29280468821525574, -0.4065985083580017, -0.05039310082793236, -1.111589789390564, 0.29544487595558167, 0.012347470968961716, -0.09777937084436417, -0.6864856481552124, 0.4784329831600189, -0.3296511173248291, -0.2688298225402832, -0.4513324499130249, 0.7828263640403748, -0.3919353187084198, -0.07908299565315247, -0.6369136571884155, 0.03228488191962242, 0.10241037607192993, 0.5691638588905334, -0.12602108716964722, 0.5795015096664429, 0.5251967310905457, -0.4866529405117035, 0.1939222365617752, 0.3420431315898895, -0.4356086850166321, 0.4749172627925873, -0.9604311585426331, 0.21640387177467346, 0.19185613095760345, -0.027894478291273117, -0.6302098631858826, -0.18708176910877228, 0.26874715089797974, -0.3157423734664917, 0.06611832231283188, -0.19904111325740814, -0.3763231337070465, -0.4121377468109131, -0.18535003066062927, 0.32692208886146545, 0.6229723691940308, -0.32909509539604187, 1.0159870386123657, 0.45576050877571106, -0.3881082832813263, -0.41794800758361816, -0.7645674347877502, 0.009703883901238441, -0.08664845675230026, -0.7721753716468811, 0.40724053978919983, -0.3822426497936249, -0.22140638530254364, -0.04879385605454445, -0.19769908487796783, -0.08836609870195389, 0.29489877820014954, 0.20400956273078918, 0.021097419783473015, -0.42928457260131836, -0.14469969272613525, 0.3199133574962616, -0.1101895272731781, -0.08469861000776291, -0.6083210110664368, 0.4632830321788788, -0.16320811212062836, -0.3929290771484375, -0.11873247474431992, 0.46639758348464966, 0.627936840057373, -0.15826815366744995, 0.8797917366027832, 0.43899083137512207, -0.1963646113872528, -0.23754070699214935, -0.12990345060825348, -0.19560666382312775, -0.5529157519340515, 0.6464152336120605, -0.5939092040061951, -0.6896906495094299, 0.8102681636810303, 0.22349326312541962, -0.1375911682844162, 0.18180643022060394, 0.5290764570236206, -0.09807763993740082, 0.9267789125442505, 1.0558044910430908, -0.061883360147476196, 0.4768159091472626, -0.3750928044319153, 0.3363158404827118, -0.5627632141113281, -0.02220194973051548, -0.4262278079986572, -0.6276319622993469, -0.4206989109516144, -0.4261499047279358, 0.5364845991134644, 0.222653329372406, -0.23570622503757477, 0.19585782289505005, -0.37594708800315857, 0.5025320649147034, 0.5633362531661987, 0.39710867404937744, 0.4475865662097931, 0.29195988178253174, -0.042084094136953354, 0.5478212833404541, -0.8916832804679871, -0.23013445734977722, 0.8852588534355164, 0.30407342314720154, 1.0184742212295532, 0.23788166046142578, 0.4483041763305664, 0.20956635475158691, -0.252437561750412, -0.8897507786750793, 0.5445016622543335, -0.32447877526283264, -0.5031871199607849, -0.2596583664417267, -0.35824206471443176, -0.9625239372253418, 0.16889216005802155, -0.42181485891342163, -0.9328165650367737, 0.4769302010536194, 0.044038355350494385, -0.6818293929100037, 0.6146702766418457, -0.4528157711029053, 0.45751953125, -0.25380831956863403, -0.2920114994049072, -0.2510984539985657, -0.5308948159217834, 0.3480994999408722, -0.4812854528427124, 0.27424296736717224, 0.23217418789863586, -0.10122277587652206, 0.8547731041908264, -0.3074858486652374, 1.068779706954956, 0.11457144469022751, -0.6013463139533997, 0.21375015377998352, 0.1413423717021942, 0.4238744080066681, 0.06675593554973602, -0.41749250888824463, -0.11671077460050583, -0.056932494044303894, -0.5573862195014954, -0.7050583362579346, 0.815281867980957, -1.2061551809310913, -0.7108597755432129, -0.035356875509023666, -0.7503871321678162, -0.281649112701416, 0.43647733330726624, 0.12574219703674316, 0.25701022148132324, 0.018351122736930847, 0.260888934135437, 0.8074233531951904, -0.1909007728099823, 0.2247818261384964, 0.7458882927894592, -0.328937292098999, -0.48473286628723145, 1.2436565160751343, 0.29314303398132324, 0.20048236846923828, 0.5432909727096558, 0.3257046639919281, 0.32006973028182983, -0.6516938209533691, -0.23108328878879547, 0.13433022797107697, -0.8443872332572937, 0.06882644444704056, -0.6380842924118042, -0.34667181968688965, -0.3979252874851227, -0.313355028629303, -0.4810340702533722, -0.6837649345397949, -0.19958609342575073, -0.036938466131687164, 0.4496013820171356, 0.7720003724098206, 0.017871608957648277, 0.2918187081813812, -0.7540003657341003, 0.5565229058265686, 0.42927345633506775, 0.39958274364471436, -0.01367380004376173, -0.6931803822517395, -0.4521249234676361, 0.09739752113819122, -0.2553953230381012, -0.664948582649231, 0.17335543036460876, 0.2818763256072998, 0.7977806329727173, 0.28984707593917847, -0.23231865465641022, 0.13805899024009705, -0.2302861213684082, 0.4486539363861084, 0.1210058182477951, -0.8206292390823364, 0.49396494030952454, -0.5823107361793518, 0.2682797908782959, 0.3892272412776947, 0.22479280829429626, -0.12567679584026337, -0.057652994990348816, -0.37843579053878784, -0.6851794123649597, 0.37755876779556274, 0.13933227956295013, -0.05892850458621979, 0.3557606339454651, 0.401059627532959, 0.5935462117195129, 0.11460107564926147, -0.7413716316223145, -0.02847393974661827, -0.11225823312997818, -0.1565883904695511, 0.11069265753030777, 0.08887714892625809, -0.38173794746398926, -0.27476704120635986, 0.7081823945045471, -0.536259651184082, 0.2674560546875, -0.18226338922977448, -0.14842498302459717, -0.22759875655174255, 0.31967586278915405, 0.6803926825523376, 0.8580201268196106, -0.2506861984729767, -0.16742223501205444, 0.004136915318667889, -0.41410523653030396, 0.2218686044216156, 0.3083623945713043, -0.1981365978717804, -0.5512145757675171, 0.28389546275138855, 0.7422693371772766, 0.13183912634849548, -0.44611865282058716, -0.01783008873462677, 0.26203709840774536, -0.297812819480896, 0.14925284683704376, 0.4613955020904541, 0.04918902739882469, 0.44071218371391296, 0.5031118988990784, 0.2758236527442932, 0.010102725587785244, -0.7402650713920593, -0.006445120554417372, 0.2763884365558624, -0.35251542925834656, -0.7256003022193909, 0.6068041324615479, 0.3098914623260498, -0.11923223733901978, 0.07952374964952469, -0.009053029119968414, -0.19245100021362305, 0.5456688404083252, 0.4971327781677246, 0.7123441100120544, -0.11950627714395523, 0.19475963711738586, -0.1501210778951645, 0.03525776043534279, 0.14210493862628937, 0.4748123288154602, 0.2559705376625061, -0.7950901389122009, -0.32465746998786926, -0.5726677179336548, -0.3257044553756714, 0.04431852325797081, -0.42440924048423767, 0.35747745633125305, -0.4911111295223236, -0.09129037708044052, 0.3275753855705261, 0.10470306128263474, -0.4720168709754944, 0.05370675027370453, 0.058120205998420715, 1.1481562852859497, -0.9258629083633423, 1.0391223430633545, 0.9004839658737183, -0.6964548230171204, -0.36598289012908936, -0.36015835404396057, -0.05312052369117737, -0.8822157382965088, 0.7343732714653015, -0.3617064952850342, -0.3479459285736084, -0.037934113293886185, -0.5447906255722046, -1.145533561706543, 1.1325103044509888, 0.4432523250579834, -0.4197823703289032, -0.464038223028183, 0.1145307794213295, 0.5711054801940918, -0.29846927523612976, 0.0989132970571518, 0.652502179145813, 0.3898620903491974, 0.10324928909540176, -0.7456157803535461, 0.002306958893314004, -0.5513928532600403, -0.3124190866947174, 0.034382421523332596, -0.7898367643356323, 1.1196480989456177, -0.21111194789409637, 0.2893919348716736, 0.5307109355926514, 0.9179366827011108, 0.5745325684547424, -0.020637383684515953, 0.2545503079891205, 0.48291346430778503, 0.9128531813621521, 0.37263116240501404, 0.997736930847168, -0.39454007148742676, 0.007382351439446211, 1.0000280141830444, -0.477337509393692, 0.7061932682991028, 0.5653282999992371, -0.16156555712223053, 0.7092767953872681, -0.017086679115891457, 0.023369381204247475, 0.4957790970802307, 0.20932963490486145, -0.09895950555801392, -0.19027069211006165, 0.03414470702409744, -0.5975889563560486, 0.5160505175590515, 0.48692840337753296, -0.3032556176185608, 0.025749705731868744, 0.19997160136699677, -0.20124918222427368, -0.10005494207143784, -0.3856346309185028, 0.5439912676811218, 0.29147976636886597, -0.2408645898103714, 0.47848576307296753, -0.03893017768859863, 0.6768684387207031, -0.7055191397666931, 0.09593777358531952, -0.2868606150150299, 0.35158807039260864, -0.20448629558086395, -0.8884317874908447, -0.15953169763088226, -0.4075426161289215, -0.588433563709259, 0.32163241505622864, 0.7991479635238647, -0.26177528500556946, -0.7523038387298584, 0.34012192487716675, 0.7578150033950806, -0.05488211289048195, 0.055831559002399445, -0.7169423699378967, 0.07509315013885498, -0.24316495656967163, -0.2516777217388153, 0.6434663534164429, 0.4167737066745758, -0.12346941232681274, 0.9389702677726746, 0.38889777660369873, 0.15132984519004822, -0.16183453798294067, -0.010427145287394524, 1.2040386199951172, -0.9517391920089722, -0.6576403379440308, -0.5048981308937073, 0.4084461033344269, 0.16024227440357208, -0.148030623793602, 0.445590078830719, 0.21470659971237183, 0.4943097233772278, -0.16867081820964813, 0.9236303567886353, 0.021266069263219833, 0.28447723388671875, -0.6913283467292786, 0.9963146448135376, -0.6614212393760681, 0.16118483245372772, -0.49677395820617676, -0.8328258395195007, -0.17885354161262512, 0.41885730624198914, -0.10343457758426666, 0.4036864936351776, 0.6282499432563782, 0.7360520362854004, -0.33365166187286377, -0.01669420301914215, 0.3933979868888855, 0.5519254803657532, 0.6455186009407043, 0.7462820410728455, 0.7207722663879395, -0.47574639320373535, 0.4814256429672241, -0.07561372965574265, -0.29629063606262207, -0.42947128415107727, -1.0332725048065186, -0.9468399286270142, -0.3222789168357849, -0.3725613057613373, -0.15895874798297882, 0.05772140249609947, 0.8908482193946838, 0.9442943930625916, -0.792564332485199, -0.25212663412094116, -0.12113946676254272, -0.06795058399438858, -0.20260222256183624, -0.1510086953639984, 0.2807053327560425, 0.10481055825948715, -0.39253586530685425, 0.9460521936416626, 0.3370765745639801, 0.11722349375486374, -0.3531927168369293, -0.03823798522353172, -0.11780188232660294, 0.22939874231815338, 0.860375165939331, 0.7245950102806091, -0.6091451048851013, -0.12510572373867035, 0.1323428899049759, -0.07321330159902573, 0.08274013549089432, 0.6057180166244507, -0.9264115691184998, 0.09586232900619507, 0.6736641526222229, 0.7258700132369995, 0.0519016869366169, -0.34839773178100586, 0.803368091583252, -0.422802209854126, 0.15030032396316528, -0.10477017611265182, 0.5115309357643127, 0.09825675189495087, -0.2743469774723053, 0.5040212273597717, 0.07040614634752274, -0.44580522179603577, -0.7104741930961609, 0.21386149525642395, -1.4470394849777222, -0.5985944867134094, 0.9549949169158936, 0.11324729770421982, -0.5493243932723999, 0.11453625559806824, -0.2710808515548706, 0.0638372078537941, -0.3273218870162964, 0.9497822523117065, 0.33556830883026123, -0.11575585603713989, -0.19257022440433502, -0.38421112298965454, 0.10221731662750244, 0.47085756063461304, -1.0161570310592651, -0.16433781385421753, -0.11448416858911514, 0.28414708375930786, 0.3319232761859894, 0.246066614985466, 0.03470070660114288, 0.2825283706188202, -0.08821896463632584, -0.004978499375283718, -0.23008088767528534, -0.40327420830726624, -0.33394283056259155, 0.21488940715789795, 0.23504091799259186, 0.4069412648677826 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07092v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07092v3	Generalizing Conversational Dense Retrieval via LLM-Cognition Data Augmentation	2024-02-11T03:27:22	2024-06-04T02:09:15	Haonan Chen, Zhicheng Dou, Kelong Mao, Jiongnan Liu, Ziliang Zhao	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.IR	Conversational search utilizes muli-turn natural language contexts to retrieve relevant passages. Existing conversational dense retrieval models mostly view a conversation as a fixed sequence of questions and responses, overlooking the severe data sparsity problem -- that is, users can perform a conversation in various ways, and these alternate conversations are unrecorded. Consequently, they often struggle to generalize to diverse conversations in real-world scenarios. In this work, we propose a framework for generalizing Conversational dense retrieval via LLM-cognition data Augmentation (ConvAug). ConvAug first generates multi-level augmented conversations to capture the diverse nature of conversational contexts. Inspired by human cognition, we devise a cognition-aware process to mitigate the generation of false positives, false negatives, and hallucinations. Moreover, we develop a difficulty-adaptive sample filter that selects challenging samples for complex conversations, thereby giving the model a larger learning space. A contrastive learning objective is then employed to train a better conversational context encoder. Extensive experiments conducted on four public datasets, under both normal and zero-shot settings, demonstrate the effectiveness, generalizability, and applicability of ConvAug. The code is released at https://github.com/haon-chen/ConvAug.	[ -0.5046507120132446, -1.4104865789413452, 0.3902731239795685, 0.1225363239645958, -0.15512792766094208, 0.03397592157125473, -0.458953857421875, -0.5571833252906799, 0.36522194743156433, 0.6070834398269653, -0.428213506937027, -0.4985337257385254, -0.2215457558631897, -0.10318486392498016, -0.4013150632381439, 0.6459589600563049, 0.46583253145217896, -0.012787099927663803, -0.3804053068161011, -0.19618001580238342, -0.9593502879142761, -0.6601332426071167, -0.6312863826751709, -0.34355831146240234, 0.26295581459999084, 0.6315093040466309, 0.6162967681884766, -0.10436225682497025, 0.22855548560619354, 0.20430050790309906, -0.05061277374625206, 0.6218075156211853, -1.010345458984375, 0.3953043818473816, 0.01783919893205166, -0.2958480715751648, -0.21661481261253357, -0.37248364090919495, 0.3251121938228607, 0.591745138168335, -0.5259383916854858, -0.3280985951423645, 0.22206878662109375, 0.38944509625434875, -0.613964319229126, -0.13198353350162506, -1.0415914058685303, -0.02561703324317932, 0.07732370495796204, -0.3948473334312439, -0.43240126967430115, -0.25974103808403015, 0.2550821006298065, -0.7314942479133606, 0.37109971046447754, 0.08070883899927139, 0.5622919797897339, 0.14325851202011108, -0.4607812166213989, -0.3123919665813446, -0.8515886068344116, 0.6963152885437012, -0.4360983967781067, 0.47546622157096863, 0.45435911417007446, 0.43856507539749146, -0.37187159061431885, -0.5477762818336487, -0.5826037526130676, -0.29826197028160095, -0.23889131844043732, 0.23163776099681854, -0.09987779706716537, 0.2563153803348541, 0.1904800981283188, 0.5610306262969971, -0.638562023639679, 0.046324003487825394, -0.213499054312706, -0.15735198557376862, 0.5448417067527771, 0.3277696371078491, 0.08747629821300507, 0.04994991049170494, -0.2468283772468567, 0.04524163156747818, -0.46207889914512634, -0.01934819296002388, 0.018190335482358932, 0.18128536641597748, -0.005184680223464966, 0.47739046812057495, -0.675698459148407, 0.7915241122245789, 0.20972716808319092, 0.27338626980781555, 0.3781370520591736, -0.5228117108345032, -0.2859225869178772, 0.02992669865489006, 0.5391454100608826, 0.3704335391521454, 0.26563769578933716, -0.285861611366272, 0.10212844610214233, 0.01167051400989294, 0.43646690249443054, -0.805734395980835, -0.1281849890947342, 0.17074888944625854, -0.011920812539756298, -0.18624946475028992, -0.13203705847263336, -0.6339983940124512, -0.4503271281719208, -0.321321964263916, 0.2719161808490753, -0.3662443161010742, 0.014587163925170898, 0.4751427471637726, 0.05023757368326187, 0.25282368063926697, 0.40017804503440857, -0.8464210033416748, 0.6308189630508423, 0.557086706161499, 0.5186113715171814, -0.1396487057209015, 0.264426052570343, -0.7737343311309814, 0.1409948766231537, -0.047144509851932526, 0.7231427431106567, -0.9590756297111511, -0.7156127691268921, -0.06270335614681244, -0.12911951541900635, 0.1325363665819168, -0.6721477508544922, 0.7750727534294128, -0.5115271210670471, 0.32652580738067627, -0.16791176795959473, -0.5966048836708069, -0.18450908362865448, 0.7248280048370361, -0.3400682508945465, 0.9749623537063599, -0.09087073802947998, -0.5335538387298584, 0.15459728240966797, -0.27413395047187805, -0.42366573214530945, 0.21493346989154816, -0.5183515548706055, -0.3758922219276428, 0.015267346054315567, 0.43614819645881653, 0.4212593734264374, -0.35061490535736084, 0.39644211530685425, -0.4141225218772888, -0.8186023831367493, 0.1937158852815628, -0.5800351500511169, 0.46390366554260254, 0.07208036631345749, -0.02374972030520439, -0.01618387922644615, -0.6763922572135925, -0.010720713995397091, -0.09199345111846924, -0.346638947725296, -0.5828781723976135, -0.0692409873008728, -0.14913910627365112, -0.060230545699596405, 0.1396830826997757, -0.7630614638328552, 0.23023928701877594, -0.47098347544670105, 0.145477756857872, 0.25774261355400085, 0.4266481101512909, 0.5944007039070129, -0.29258081316947937, 0.25458985567092896, 0.10724121332168579, 0.2966102659702301, -0.044961344450712204, -0.4082043468952179, -0.9005173444747925, -0.1412706971168518, -0.15005147457122803, 0.7361921072006226, -0.8245403170585632, 0.464506059885025, -0.34117069840431213, -0.41814056038856506, -0.49689820408821106, 0.27287617325782776, 0.33425286412239075, 0.8684683442115784, 0.6045036315917969, -0.332744836807251, -0.5595913529396057, -0.8496383428573608, 0.06945972144603729, 0.06925909221172333, -0.1136089563369751, 0.936886727809906, 0.04422064870595932, -0.5594205260276794, 0.8147536516189575, -0.6327319145202637, -0.3035065233707428, 0.02693815529346466, -0.012639018706977367, 0.25928670167922974, 0.5677007436752319, 0.10565861314535141, -1.014273762702942, -0.1679638773202896, 0.04074512794613838, -0.7227163910865784, 0.08040525764226913, -0.2806677520275116, -0.3574867248535156, -0.2512788772583008, 0.5198767781257629, -0.6924859881401062, 0.33366990089416504, 0.27390792965888977, -0.006957060657441616, 0.38399738073349, -0.23768678307533264, 0.21086597442626953, -0.9978693723678589, -0.1441832035779953, -0.10188823938369751, -0.2448142170906067, -0.7616950869560242, -0.19520731270313263, -0.1345648318529129, -0.041654497385025024, -0.37501221895217896, 0.4779427945613861, -0.33733054995536804, 0.12526603043079376, -0.010263643227517605, 0.1687472015619278, 0.2066633403301239, 0.6223929524421692, 0.07761921733617783, 0.681266725063324, 0.41909635066986084, -0.9454851746559143, 0.469938188791275, 0.39923375844955444, -0.2801685631275177, 0.6752730011940002, -0.7033738493919373, 0.3779003322124481, -0.16222433745861053, 0.5279120206832886, -0.8790206909179688, 0.005989753641188145, 0.11654900014400482, -0.42194056510925293, 0.051689792424440384, -0.16506552696228027, -0.34106457233428955, -0.06708069890737534, -0.13035865128040314, 0.4985998868942261, 0.2787124216556549, -0.502784788608551, 0.5484181046485901, 0.4162321090698242, 0.024676933884620667, -0.6120953559875488, -0.8292537331581116, 0.14523689448833466, -0.08395805954933167, -0.5936183929443359, 0.47911950945854187, -0.410201758146286, -0.06083396449685097, -0.3969491720199585, 0.024379733949899673, -0.1567590981721878, 0.06500948220491409, 0.11296476423740387, 0.1216251477599144, 0.013372214511036873, 0.3791193962097168, 0.0357743501663208, 0.07434207946062088, -0.22590482234954834, -0.16044846177101135, 0.6872939467430115, -0.1809750348329544, -0.41517412662506104, 0.094181589782238, 0.3600972294807434, 0.12974224984645844, -0.15827906131744385, 0.3579852879047394, 0.7634209990501404, -0.4217481017112732, -0.14843125641345978, -0.9383278489112854, -0.38253653049468994, -0.4974325895309448, 0.31541311740875244, -0.4698151648044586, -1.323225975036621, 0.44032928347587585, 0.025415640324354172, -0.1165006011724472, -0.14417633414268494, 0.6109580993652344, -0.17909176647663116, 0.8140709400177002, 0.29536697268486023, 0.0852615088224411, 0.5798863768577576, -0.420985609292984, 0.1715202033519745, -0.9880601763725281, -0.5067185759544373, -0.08146136999130249, -0.28900423645973206, -0.5283551812171936, -0.5561496019363403, 0.340725302696228, -0.06494693458080292, 0.0174228698015213, 0.0678088366985321, -0.6985660791397095, 0.5583345890045166, 0.43490228056907654, 0.47227662801742554, 0.47868868708610535, 0.10809089988470078, 0.072598896920681, -0.06931453198194504, -0.5854045748710632, -0.044708479195833206, 0.8844174146652222, -0.04027485102415085, 0.9131629467010498, 0.021457521244883537, 0.5748875737190247, 0.28545063734054565, 0.13864773511886597, -0.7716312408447266, 0.6720367670059204, -0.09516379982233047, -0.5787866115570068, -0.21996144950389862, -0.5659457445144653, -1.2060165405273438, 0.49669674038887024, -0.5133318901062012, -0.6069855093955994, 0.5114140510559082, 0.14544256031513214, -0.34102189540863037, -0.10309305042028427, -0.7526447176933289, 0.6332034468650818, -0.279467910528183, -0.3572143316268921, -0.5532852411270142, -0.5705240964889526, 0.5137845873832703, 0.1692100167274475, -0.05003653094172478, -0.037191979587078094, 0.12454715371131897, 0.16313450038433075, -0.03188387304544449, 0.7105896472930908, -0.09352156519889832, 0.2066493183374405, 0.520440936088562, 0.1452334225177765, 0.500338077545166, 0.4259320795536041, -0.042399149388074875, 0.05184835195541382, -0.3917120695114136, -0.39870357513427734, -0.8570666909217834, 0.8598726987838745, -0.4354570508003235, -0.5813592672348022, 0.006561016198247671, -0.6309612393379211, -0.4334438741207123, 0.044064588844776154, 0.2089674025774002, 0.5879047513008118, -0.6786952614784241, 0.531532347202301, 1.027820348739624, -0.20661205053329468, -0.1185130774974823, 0.6351124048233032, -0.12589775025844574, -0.2189241647720337, 0.8785204887390137, 0.01488988846540451, 0.11989784240722656, 0.6626064777374268, 0.0027296345215290785, -0.18316398561000824, -0.5032243132591248, -0.11019381880760193, -0.10042735189199448, -0.5808629393577576, -0.20849451422691345, -0.7904446721076965, -0.1866476982831955, -0.34258586168289185, -0.11600261926651001, -0.0449519008398056, -0.2806512117385864, -0.49657487869262695, -0.2550715506076813, 0.33498525619506836, 0.21234555542469025, 0.2059219479560852, 0.24145658314228058, -0.5339595675468445, 0.49631378054618835, 0.6194424629211426, 0.1673302799463272, -0.2000758796930313, -0.5239300727844238, -0.19756117463111877, 0.33394476771354675, -0.2703961730003357, -0.4339871108531952, 0.3677655756473541, 0.3372352421283722, 0.5005940198898315, 0.065687395632267, 0.08719152957201004, 0.9605448842048645, -0.2531324028968811, 0.531924843788147, 0.1040235087275505, -0.4612090587615967, 0.5262662172317505, -0.21367314457893372, 0.2739190459251404, 0.8114298582077026, -0.06866253912448883, -0.7098119854927063, -0.20679591596126556, -0.567622721195221, -0.8806663155555725, 0.1521235555410385, 0.30212312936782837, 0.5190984010696411, -0.21654684841632843, 0.37047696113586426, 0.07846745103597641, 0.11994617432355881, -0.22016151249408722, -0.001431902521289885, -0.15709535777568817, -0.18863791227340698, -0.08580084145069122, -0.19915790855884552, -0.14140215516090393, -0.36692094802856445, 0.3211877644062042, -0.17112015187740326, 0.27188897132873535, 0.4269804060459137, -0.3737056851387024, 0.32710355520248413, 0.47627243399620056, 0.377991646528244, 0.23065303266048431, -0.4252188801765442, 0.1459270715713501, 0.5610846877098083, -0.4592912197113037, 0.030057072639465332, 0.2008926421403885, -0.14099980890750885, -0.09833641350269318, -0.1696682572364807, 0.7298698425292969, 0.5123613476753235, -0.7599964141845703, 0.4906657338142395, -0.4777531027793884, 0.03581881523132324, -0.44167569279670715, 0.2631247043609619, -0.019671740010380745, 0.24868230521678925, 0.3349413275718689, 0.009827570989727974, 0.6689844131469727, -0.471439927816391, 0.30770784616470337, 0.6491007804870605, -0.30279821157455444, -0.09917039424180984, 0.3903094530105591, 0.4420444965362549, -0.12846791744232178, 0.7887932658195496, -0.1807677149772644, -0.118405781686306, 0.2760121524333954, 0.540840208530426, 0.7131264805793762, 0.11781194061040878, 0.08658277243375778, 0.3210194408893585, 0.10405607521533966, 0.04161551967263222, 0.2381047159433365, -0.330475777387619, -0.9654821157455444, -0.34321340918540955, -0.26989561319351196, -0.5800418257713318, 0.2883116900920868, -0.5378690361976624, 0.21328024566173553, -0.3849564790725708, -0.1747472584247589, -0.3682871460914612, 0.07312078773975372, -0.8457551002502441, 0.2995806336402893, 0.27528971433639526, 0.745608925819397, -0.4527978301048279, 0.8186727166175842, 0.36113086342811584, -0.29474031925201416, -0.28286951780319214, -0.2821299433708191, -0.2848037779331207, -0.8164199590682983, 0.08689440786838531, 0.1821737140417099, -0.24711894989013672, 0.07696129381656647, -0.7612948417663574, -0.6556416153907776, 1.2452404499053955, 0.5292937159538269, -0.7657489776611328, 0.043503761291503906, -0.06565454602241516, 0.6208590865135193, -0.5349211096763611, 0.31120574474334717, 0.5581858158111572, 0.06584084779024124, 0.2644472122192383, -0.5055736303329468, -0.01751093938946724, -0.3841535449028015, -0.009514342062175274, -0.10578548163175583, -0.6267368793487549, 0.4106709957122803, 0.024993637576699257, -0.13463017344474792, -0.17872661352157593, 0.6980915069580078, 0.48445096611976624, 0.4179384708404541, 0.424209326505661, 0.6844162940979004, 0.9477477073669434, 0.0075348252430558205, 1.080825924873352, -0.03136634826660156, 0.059684935957193375, 1.3578976392745972, -0.06601548194885254, 0.7322446703910828, 0.40489065647125244, 0.30108940601348877, 0.47413960099220276, 0.4695846438407898, 0.15046921372413635, 0.4176172912120819, 0.04175504297018051, -0.42110690474510193, -0.4236890971660614, -0.3631417155265808, -0.21371957659721375, 0.2451547235250473, 0.8222516775131226, 0.1710900217294693, 0.06156149134039879, 0.0145472576841712, -0.10387558490037918, 0.020012252032756805, -0.041533827781677246, 0.9046154022216797, 0.2063341736793518, -0.5775596499443054, 0.7959417104721069, -0.45378029346466064, 0.975582480430603, -0.4409344792366028, -0.2989649176597595, -0.41441330313682556, 0.14002655446529388, -0.28706568479537964, -0.7799788117408752, 0.12472248822450638, -0.22042948007583618, -0.07675716280937195, 0.002426216611638665, 0.9719005823135376, -0.8969271183013916, -0.3284637928009033, 0.35196399688720703, 0.4489598870277405, 0.16444002091884613, -0.22073739767074585, -0.8495386838912964, 0.06577608734369278, -0.14585891366004944, -0.0441165454685688, 0.18300941586494446, 0.2957572042942047, -0.138667494058609, 0.6837023496627808, 0.7005260586738586, -0.2049589604139328, 0.026707006618380547, 0.4891134202480316, 0.9351385831832886, -0.4134792387485504, -0.38484451174736023, -0.548233151435852, 0.46183404326438904, -0.3581782281398773, -0.21506784856319427, 0.601881206035614, 0.6496812105178833, 0.8794249892234802, 0.2336617261171341, 0.697602391242981, 0.18735472857952118, 0.35849517583847046, -0.49184390902519226, 0.34972497820854187, -0.2894066870212555, 0.4710584878921509, -0.07438649237155914, -0.8773860931396484, -0.2489098161458969, 0.5414961576461792, -0.32180866599082947, -0.08222924917936325, 0.2521028220653534, 1.1202362775802612, -0.42249369621276855, -0.010785946622490883, 0.4233316481113434, 0.2593025863170624, 0.5163459777832031, 0.8032230138778687, 0.7626890540122986, -0.4248770773410797, 0.765051543712616, -0.09157825261354446, 0.0025204576086252928, -0.46889281272888184, -0.4327249825000763, -0.6127373576164246, -0.3564892113208771, -0.1142757311463356, -0.32185953855514526, 0.013874322175979614, 0.6985594630241394, 0.7842420339584351, -0.5852377414703369, -0.13842038810253143, -0.2800355851650238, 0.1651802659034729, 0.13696423172950745, -0.2520267963409424, -0.10281659662723541, -0.3661770522594452, -0.5230774879455566, 0.7594858407974243, 0.22128038108348846, 0.03262117877602577, -0.0981684997677803, -0.309009313583374, -0.33386126160621643, 0.21266700327396393, 0.5651322603225708, 0.23364263772964478, -0.36843737959861755, -0.32264602184295654, 0.02761402167379856, -0.2620980441570282, 0.34021079540252686, 0.7985594272613525, -1.0935437679290771, 0.8239750862121582, 0.40371716022491455, 0.7965908050537109, 1.0737111568450928, 0.24469004571437836, 0.5089079737663269, -1.0890637636184692, 0.29178041219711304, 0.4556722044944763, 0.16174733638763428, 0.6996995210647583, -0.6751837134361267, 0.5766686797142029, 0.15273824334144592, -0.5444197654724121, -0.6209307909011841, 0.3150465488433838, -1.184890866279602, -0.09166029840707779, 1.0770829916000366, 0.2730138897895813, 0.10452200472354889, -0.34032300114631653, -0.42429688572883606, 0.11885131150484085, -0.6832079887390137, 0.7047566771507263, 0.4390563666820526, -0.1640312522649765, -0.16716164350509644, -0.4725194573402405, 0.28798532485961914, 0.4976999759674072, -0.708523690700531, -0.048087310045957565, 0.6994640231132507, 0.11956945061683655, -0.0008431122405454516, 0.9058951735496521, 0.040933139622211456, 0.1882934719324112, -0.25199010968208313, -0.03904406353831291, -0.003407749580219388, -0.11806625872850418, -0.3778841197490692, 0.04677891731262207, -0.2674439549446106, -0.06341732293367386 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07085v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07085v1	Speech Rhythm-Based Speaker Embeddings Extraction from Phonemes and Phoneme Duration for Multi-Speaker Speech Synthesis	2024-02-11T02:26:43	2024-02-11T02:26:43	Kenichi Fujita, Atsushi Ando, Yusuke Ijima	cs.SD	cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS	This paper proposes a speech rhythm-based method for speaker embeddings to model phoneme duration using a few utterances by the target speaker. Speech rhythm is one of the essential factors among speaker characteristics, along with acoustic features such as F0, for reproducing individual utterances in speech synthesis. A novel feature of the proposed method is the rhythm-based embeddings extracted from phonemes and their durations, which are known to be related to speaking rhythm. They are extracted with a speaker identification model similar to the conventional spectral feature-based one. We conducted three experiments, speaker embeddings generation, speech synthesis with generated embeddings, and embedding space analysis, to evaluate the performance. The proposed method demonstrated a moderate speaker identification performance (15.2% EER), even with only phonemes and their duration information. The objective and subjective evaluation results demonstrated that the proposed method can synthesize speech with speech rhythm closer to the target speaker than the conventional method. We also visualized the embeddings to evaluate the relationship between the distance of the embeddings and the perceptual similarity. The visualization of the embedding space and the relation analysis between the closeness indicated that the distribution of embeddings reflects the subjective and objective similarity.	[ -0.3122420012950897, -1.0841453075408936, 0.6045895218849182, 0.37592941522598267, -0.5159654021263123, -0.0735308900475502, -0.16821317374706268, -0.2667447030544281, 0.7286742329597473, 0.29287078976631165, -0.4658642113208771, -0.5824511051177979, -0.1318315714597702, -0.18121324479579926, -0.29877713322639465, 0.40621301531791687, 0.462877482175827, 0.15655779838562012, -0.2281087189912796, 0.07081957906484604, -0.7329466938972473, -0.2668982148170471, -0.025876598432660103, -0.38573870062828064, -0.03621411323547363, 0.4625057876110077, 0.330455482006073, 0.8942258954048157, 0.06905118376016617, 0.22024022042751312, -0.2843738794326782, -0.1051950678229332, -0.13065971434116364, 0.26508933305740356, 0.4695093631744385, -0.12050766497850418, -0.7090981006622314, 0.19352829456329346, 0.9717242121696472, 0.7406941056251526, -0.21578793227672577, 0.22547593712806702, 0.035471830517053604, 0.2073265165090561, -0.23192299902439117, 0.18489035964012146, -0.48743489384651184, 0.3766900300979614, -0.4327964782714844, -0.52039635181427, -0.4104822874069214, -0.6151719093322754, 0.1894795149564743, -0.06955335289239883, 0.16596493124961853, -0.12303858250379562, 0.225158229470253, -0.05376306176185608, -0.006175654474645853, -0.2987208962440491, -0.8360115885734558, 0.669750988483429, -0.7101702690124512, 0.743013858795166, 0.2234058827161789, 0.49313977360725403, 0.08475590497255325, -0.309149831533432, -0.4365537464618683, -0.28113988041877747, 0.18335722386837006, -0.01868322864174843, 0.38718417286872864, -0.18594355881214142, 0.2349807322025299, 0.2736593782901764, -0.5360952615737915, -0.29268911480903625, -0.16368623077869415, -0.44947221875190735, 0.5990739464759827, 0.067291758954525, 0.3894079327583313, -0.25638246536254883, -0.5126758813858032, -0.16144859790802002, -0.577537477016449, 0.19598369300365448, 0.7512955069541931, 0.545660138130188, -0.24948441982269287, 0.6239672899246216, 0.02115085907280445, 0.6220125555992126, -0.0861993134021759, -0.6689992547035217, 0.5642938613891602, -0.32512810826301575, 0.12876267731189728, 0.6548337936401367, 0.5949328541755676, 0.22520926594734192, 0.29548344016075134, -0.31445130705833435, -0.04064148664474487, -0.03857481852173805, -0.015015777200460434, -0.8720171451568604, -0.09303305298089981, 0.039074476808309555, -0.5269718766212463, -0.13061106204986572, 0.046542465686798096, -0.9916101694107056, -0.10474641621112823, -0.15367045998573303, 0.26780062913894653, -0.6735721826553345, -0.1668572872877121, -0.22767363488674164, -0.26992180943489075, 0.41454029083251953, -0.09478200227022171, -0.7010501623153687, 0.47059476375579834, 0.470749169588089, 1.0579549074172974, -0.1568959653377533, -0.3178902566432953, -0.6426869630813599, 0.2558712959289551, -0.2745145559310913, 0.4174940288066864, -0.7443028688430786, -0.827135443687439, -0.3415297567844391, -0.22421523928642273, 0.17177535593509674, -0.34668785333633423, 0.03200756758451462, -0.12453091889619827, -0.048792969435453415, -0.04047594964504242, -0.975674569606781, 0.16815680265426636, -0.40161705017089844, -0.6400102376937866, 0.608799397945404, -0.07030165195465088, -0.43449866771698, 0.013912285678088665, -0.6215065717697144, -0.5300347208976746, 0.04875887185335159, -0.3125034272670746, -0.5185095071792603, -0.09650343656539917, -0.05192123353481293, 0.4577954411506653, 0.016991106793284416, 0.03317806497216225, -0.39589905738830566, -0.43732962012290955, 0.4514727294445038, -0.28742513060569763, 0.7043148875236511, 0.4708682596683502, -0.3260416090488434, -0.0822809487581253, -1.0330644845962524, 0.06878109276294708, 0.027886737138032913, -0.12163539975881577, -0.041160114109516144, 0.1378222554922104, 0.14253762364387512, -0.12738777697086334, 0.09613804519176483, -0.6965707540512085, -0.20820771157741547, -0.34937480092048645, 0.4045049846172333, 0.631053626537323, 0.4303847551345825, 0.429747074842453, -0.42634662985801697, 0.5600475668907166, -0.3518446981906891, -0.08609352260828018, -0.5518372654914856, -0.7353725433349609, -0.03985610976815224, -0.398776113986969, 0.30857279896736145, 0.6685612201690674, 0.004616961348801851, 0.5485742092132568, -0.32210811972618103, -0.5109096169471741, -0.36259108781814575, -0.0348917618393898, 0.5119266510009766, 0.3098757863044739, 0.3568393588066101, -0.6835128664970398, -0.5345239043235779, -0.6073305606842041, -0.25077930092811584, -0.04881618916988373, 0.10784352570772171, 0.3561343848705292, -0.09341789782047272, 0.09904713183641434, 1.1352462768554688, -0.5968732833862305, 0.01330436673015356, 0.17983445525169373, -0.1797933280467987, 0.14495849609375, 0.6555736660957336, 0.6112553477287292, -0.4542185068130493, -0.37839093804359436, -0.17177021503448486, -0.25537264347076416, -0.28647181391716003, 0.1166267916560173, 0.1922282725572586, -0.2099236398935318, 0.6462830901145935, -0.0927872285246849, 0.41463789343833923, 0.3767227232456207, -0.3314516246318817, 0.5511640906333923, 0.13397549092769623, 0.15730330348014832, -0.9890986084938049, 0.10232686251401901, -0.16725996136665344, -0.3265998363494873, -0.717159628868103, -0.4392338991165161, -0.31416404247283936, -0.6037458777427673, -0.5425063967704773, 0.41421398520469666, -0.49870747327804565, -0.4805676341056824, -0.02970755845308304, 0.3226379454135895, -0.35211455821990967, 0.4432266652584076, -0.09742458164691925, 0.6527194380760193, 0.4303860366344452, -0.5063188672065735, 0.3768382668495178, 0.28832879662513733, -0.535156786441803, 0.40267643332481384, -0.6680488586425781, 0.6037508249282837, 0.3040582835674286, -0.04736344888806343, -1.1813207864761353, 0.08775189518928528, 0.0749933123588562, -0.6001560688018799, 0.2814476490020752, -0.4553601145744324, -0.09925112128257751, 0.20174862444400787, -0.14239704608917236, 0.6305059194564819, 0.8988083600997925, -0.16731156408786774, 0.38774752616882324, 0.5909477472305298, -0.5800222754478455, -0.1321963518857956, -0.6541347503662109, -0.14799122512340546, -0.41094163060188293, -0.8336804509162903, 0.7553479671478271, -0.22667427361011505, -0.276408851146698, -0.05287524685263634, 0.05872676521539688, 0.003361406736075878, -0.08216983824968338, 0.49501100182533264, -0.17409053444862366, -0.021425478160381317, 0.15520845353603363, -0.0850534737110138, -0.1909116804599762, -0.09003917872905731, -0.08966762572526932, 0.7644517421722412, 0.12676161527633667, -0.5384474992752075, -0.7309696674346924, 0.6071031093597412, 0.4439040720462799, -0.4829922616481781, 0.20307455956935883, 0.8916444182395935, -0.2098975032567978, -0.23905059695243835, -0.5136600136756897, -0.24549543857574463, -0.39347925782203674, 0.1314420849084854, -0.5390574932098389, -0.7762813568115234, 0.7448958158493042, -0.05318383127450943, -0.27733710408210754, 0.0316326804459095, 0.49632471799850464, 0.09555698931217194, 0.6501981019973755, 0.34191566705703735, -0.12034624069929123, 0.9704326391220093, -0.1486993134021759, -0.002410561079159379, -0.6611113548278809, -0.3779391348361969, -0.56938636302948, -0.23583829402923584, -0.4754630923271179, -0.5850663781166077, 0.42904606461524963, -0.12044579535722733, 0.00947849452495575, 0.14166736602783203, -0.26751285791397095, 0.20259125530719757, 0.4308505952358246, 0.18000517785549164, -0.21010419726371765, 0.18043531477451324, -0.3155142664909363, -0.135014608502388, -0.21770106256008148, -0.46742725372314453, 0.8829091191291809, 0.16730113327503204, 0.6894027590751648, 0.25483453273773193, 1.10841703414917, 0.49675485491752625, -0.5850710272789001, -0.6807728409767151, 0.5613039135932922, 0.10062557458877563, -0.12581920623779297, -0.5174036026000977, -0.38240131735801697, -0.7168939113616943, -0.1900061070919037, -0.08799150586128235, -0.8976720571517944, 0.11541745811700821, 0.17737767100334167, -0.27257758378982544, 0.04197137430310249, -0.678769052028656, 0.5568023324012756, 0.023163776844739914, 0.03829460218548775, -0.33307525515556335, -0.6231447458267212, -0.28940534591674805, 0.27122578024864197, 0.298929899930954, -0.13942700624465942, 0.37581899762153625, 0.799008309841156, -0.36999762058258057, 0.7630457282066345, -0.5134410262107849, 0.06801890581846237, 0.6403027176856995, 0.2418902963399887, 0.39332738518714905, -0.04763323441147804, -0.016746997833251953, 0.10097420960664749, -0.21213199198246002, -0.37313511967658997, -0.4140758514404297, 0.7945265769958496, -0.5072756409645081, -0.5596199631690979, 0.24543513357639313, -0.31097161769866943, -0.4150001108646393, 0.019471248611807823, -0.15578781068325043, 0.8969506621360779, -0.5967898368835449, 0.37141647934913635, 0.423822283744812, -0.25473350286483765, 0.7317467331886292, 0.10791591554880142, -0.19367650151252747, -0.6852784156799316, 0.8645764589309692, 0.22423245012760162, 0.2644971013069153, 0.3045910596847534, 0.3661375641822815, -0.27380096912384033, -0.641097903251648, -0.2236817479133606, 0.1221114993095398, -0.4166639745235443, 0.35835403203964233, -0.48493319749832153, 0.0580604188144207, -0.843239426612854, 0.06416362524032593, -0.5281697511672974, -0.6682303547859192, -0.1653914898633957, 0.0504394955933094, 0.43044713139533997, 0.35679513216018677, -0.14609679579734802, 0.3472089469432831, -0.7604728937149048, 0.33466508984565735, 0.6846370697021484, 0.46892330050468445, -0.015564876608550549, -0.6995706558227539, -0.3021478056907654, 0.04545968025922775, -0.15530487895011902, -1.479364037513733, 0.26332417130470276, 0.25972628593444824, 0.7820307016372681, 0.3759806752204895, -0.5280786752700806, 0.8483912348747253, -0.7890908718109131, 0.9541611671447754, 0.14792057871818542, -1.2712575197219849, 0.8237059712409973, -0.11997248977422714, 0.11569365859031677, -0.06784608215093613, -0.12002122402191162, -0.45736175775527954, -0.17081184685230255, -0.6058180332183838, -0.7725176215171814, 0.6440725326538086, 0.5074689984321594, 0.05378970503807068, -0.07947739958763123, 0.24827061593532562, 0.1541006714105606, -0.04394726827740669, -0.17403948307037354, -0.6040611267089844, -0.37705376744270325, 0.1019352450966835, -0.23006869852542877, -0.3858959674835205, 0.00516950897872448, -0.03452199324965477, 0.7025391459465027, 0.10391068458557129, 0.7056372761726379, 0.2663278877735138, -0.24630260467529297, -0.05090450868010521, 0.41544708609580994, 0.7978668808937073, 0.6213699579238892, -0.5139972567558289, -0.06713294982910156, 0.08534635603427887, -0.37880659103393555, 0.23425474762916565, 0.1302703320980072, 0.09220059961080551, 0.38049793243408203, 0.46343743801116943, 0.7762301564216614, -0.049117058515548706, -0.25215038657188416, 0.6092439889907837, 0.17651744186878204, 0.23980027437210083, -0.5843456983566284, 0.05208052322268486, 0.32190412282943726, 0.472928524017334, 0.22477442026138306, -0.1971580982208252, 0.19693811237812042, -0.4811302125453949, 0.5294199585914612, 0.18554450571537018, -0.4794849157333374, -0.4897255301475525, 0.5325909852981567, 0.23034052550792694, -0.8942058086395264, 0.17818868160247803, -0.20290401577949524, 0.009979182854294777, 0.721741795539856, 0.6458582282066345, 1.0966604948043823, -0.9058713316917419, -0.007387612015008926, 0.2176361083984375, -0.14051803946495056, 0.23901601135730743, 0.6053959727287292, -0.397315114736557, -0.5394273996353149, -0.24910466372966766, -0.6552045345306396, -0.1775188446044922, -0.20726412534713745, -0.7069495916366577, 0.2516814172267914, -0.3419635593891144, -0.37793758511543274, 0.14473140239715576, -0.07477790862321854, -0.4989093542098999, -0.103325754404068, 0.31744351983070374, 0.3800780475139618, -1.0324606895446777, 0.897928774356842, 0.42694786190986633, -0.044761788100004196, -0.6856809854507446, -0.05655856430530548, 0.14131321012973785, -0.4304739832878113, 0.240355983376503, -0.013704109005630016, -0.3700627386569977, 0.04981594532728195, -0.2119525969028473, -0.6152365803718567, 1.3874156475067139, 0.40470513701438904, -0.7257407307624817, 0.33359819650650024, -0.040844399482011795, 0.3224849998950958, -0.7316559553146362, 0.05544475466012955, 0.2605612277984619, 0.17477834224700928, 0.03315437212586403, -0.9361228942871094, -0.08554354310035706, -0.2314308136701584, 0.28956177830696106, 0.09010231494903564, -0.5305511951446533, 0.9180689454078674, -0.1435229629278183, -0.3069245517253876, 0.24549250304698944, 0.5027642250061035, 0.21482378244400024, 0.17331349849700928, 0.6396057605743408, 0.6075873970985413, 0.5963743329048157, 0.22623401880264282, 0.7179445624351501, -0.52517169713974, 0.3714780807495117, 1.1864968538284302, -0.23587249219417572, 0.5473087430000305, 0.44402074813842773, -0.36172962188720703, 0.5505375862121582, 0.10356838256120682, 0.14023469388484955, 0.8255288600921631, 0.2542305588722229, -0.15080587565898895, -0.19092604517936707, 0.0905536636710167, -0.6951400637626648, 0.7631298899650574, 0.3136034309864044, -0.6457265615463257, 0.09628428518772125, -0.03760142624378204, -0.00027843398856930435, 0.015263880603015423, 0.17638641595840454, 0.7570047974586487, 0.10375364869832993, -0.28221094608306885, 0.5306751728057861, -0.12136572599411011, 0.16212071478366852, -0.3889036774635315, -0.3156176805496216, -0.008866683579981327, -0.16416741907596588, 0.05182737112045288, -0.4685027599334717, 0.0851668119430542, -0.14284101128578186, -0.1767265647649765, -0.34926915168762207, 0.4691840410232544, -0.6206454038619995, -0.15784819424152374, 0.2832508385181427, 0.6652028560638428, 0.41164809465408325, 0.26615869998931885, -0.3477834165096283, 0.10021638125181198, 0.14533016085624695, -0.11211010068655014, 0.03082253970205784, 0.4170786440372467, 0.16892468929290771, 0.2821120619773865, 0.5399211645126343, 0.30481815338134766, 0.27005600929260254, 0.35942450165748596, 0.32972100377082825, -0.9777986407279968, -0.891815721988678, -1.0107706785202026, 0.08454974740743637, 0.11725177615880966, -0.012505021877586842, 0.594831645488739, 0.5171623826026917, 0.4629116952419281, -0.05692389979958534, 0.5986446142196655, -0.01727536879479885, 0.6074429750442505, -0.7005794048309326, 0.4516826868057251, -0.28782129287719727, 0.29423654079437256, -0.7495102882385254, -1.1324855089187622, 0.027123181149363518, 0.5513904690742493, 0.0962207168340683, 0.12258155643939972, 0.4728923439979553, 0.9925854802131653, 0.004308729898184538, 0.09249468892812729, 0.4979507029056549, 0.13837458193302155, 0.3602544665336609, 0.26267653703689575, 0.7021892070770264, -0.1432809978723526, 0.3982119858264923, -0.43056368827819824, -0.1285477727651596, -0.32956185936927795, -0.755185067653656, -0.5923765897750854, -0.7395214438438416, -0.3942830264568329, -0.03324909135699272, 0.09051726013422012, 0.9651475548744202, 0.7269984483718872, -0.6972072124481201, -0.6140817403793335, 0.3761177957057953, 0.034986767917871475, -0.5179196000099182, -0.2145015001296997, 0.5989396572113037, -0.14142654836177826, -0.7129728198051453, 0.6646565794944763, 0.28825268149375916, 0.2822718024253845, -0.026397649198770523, -0.24767397344112396, -0.1860845535993576, 0.012591570615768433, 0.38052794337272644, -0.00994602870196104, -0.6644406318664551, -0.5473968386650085, -0.23370371758937836, 0.18751774728298187, 0.13077981770038605, 0.8204774856567383, -0.47990894317626953, 0.8504034280776978, 0.821740984916687, 0.23549655079841614, 0.6384943723678589, 0.035938262939453125, 0.40696847438812256, -1.2162938117980957, 0.3074035346508026, 0.24472542107105255, 0.49631962180137634, 0.26175838708877563, 0.012365383096039295, 0.21851429343223572, 0.43527108430862427, -0.3486654460430145, -0.6466215252876282, 0.34254392981529236, -1.2092188596725464, -0.012232532724738121, 1.18995201587677, -0.1986704170703888, -0.20576180517673492, 0.034597232937812805, -0.07782751321792603, 0.6513930559158325, -0.5237977504730225, 0.5974803566932678, 0.4801895320415497, -0.3522924482822418, 0.08150182664394379, -0.10620936006307602, 0.3915640413761139, 0.07338728755712509, -0.29389238357543945, -0.3186587393283844, 0.5558034777641296, 0.42526790499687195, 0.5228432416915894, 0.704302191734314, -0.530823826789856, 0.35955721139907837, 0.33871111273765564, 0.3772364556789398, -0.27346402406692505, -0.3039062023162842, -0.1761699616909027, 0.33121001720428467, 0.03471002355217934, -0.5268518328666687 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07081v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07081v1	Using Large Language Models for Student-Code Guided Test Case Generation in Computer Science Education	2024-02-11T01:37:48	2024-02-11T01:37:48	Nischal Ashok Kumar, Andrew Lan	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.SE	In computer science education, test cases are an integral part of programming assignments since they can be used as assessment items to test students' programming knowledge and provide personalized feedback on student-written code. The goal of our work is to propose a fully automated approach for test case generation that can accurately measure student knowledge, which is important for two reasons. First, manually constructing test cases requires expert knowledge and is a labor-intensive process. Second, developing test cases for students, especially those who are novice programmers, is significantly different from those oriented toward professional-level software developers. Therefore, we need an automated process for test case generation to assess student knowledge and provide feedback. In this work, we propose a large language model-based approach to automatically generate test cases and show that they are good measures of student knowledge, using a publicly available dataset that contains student-written Java code. We also discuss future research directions centered on using test cases to help students.	[ -0.12587277591228485, -0.7893527746200562, 0.5435834527015686, 0.08235785365104675, 0.22280031442642212, 0.31321799755096436, -0.20370884239673615, -0.000628773937933147, -0.23501892387866974, 0.5123981833457947, -0.17138829827308655, -0.5873101949691772, 0.044808920472860336, 0.01442304439842701, -0.6690276861190796, 1.0356346368789673, -0.2267218977212906, 0.16365964710712433, -0.4787595570087433, 0.3117017447948456, -0.4253902733325958, -0.6991859674453735, -0.5395545959472656, 0.061556484550237656, -0.0120681868866086, 0.7158711552619934, 0.22869494557380676, 0.26581811904907227, 0.4489918351173401, 0.2711585760116577, 0.3057399094104767, -0.4654218256473541, -0.00785002764314413, 0.16453655064105988, 0.02546270377933979, -0.47537630796432495, -0.32111939787864685, 0.013276421464979649, 0.6395289897918701, 0.9198012351989746, -0.22083044052124023, 0.491475373506546, -0.2215876579284668, 0.45052415132522583, -0.4713985025882721, 0.36026155948638916, -0.3179137110710144, 0.11145833879709244, -0.15998776257038116, 0.0399678498506546, -0.6124857068061829, -0.5699818730354309, -0.046676598489284515, -0.5201115012168884, 0.402363121509552, -0.1054535061120987, 0.5548239350318909, -0.07020625472068787, -0.5485514402389526, -0.4061087965965271, -0.7269383668899536, 0.8927832245826721, -0.8262937068939209, 0.16223524510860443, 0.22118759155273438, 0.7233365178108215, -0.2954503893852234, -0.4895445704460144, -0.5925578474998474, -0.5838527083396912, 0.35581985116004944, 0.2499261051416397, 0.1531985104084015, 0.011518450453877449, 0.44066235423088074, 0.26888397336006165, -0.8336745500564575, -0.0995325893163681, -0.6829720139503479, -0.20076489448547363, 1.023293137550354, 0.30375900864601135, 0.5091384649276733, -0.027566267177462578, 0.16830819845199585, -0.21828262507915497, -0.7994354367256165, 0.1488964706659317, 0.6300420165061951, 0.31980299949645996, 0.19912788271903992, 0.7240849733352661, -0.303339421749115, 0.8569357991218567, -0.3863339126110077, -0.13432960212230682, 0.08624596148729324, -0.16263513267040253, -0.26932305097579956, 0.056829243898391724, 0.3723050355911255, -0.07331671565771103, 0.819645881652832, -0.022227739915251732, -0.10004808008670807, 0.4203466475009918, 0.3638819754123688, -0.9991214275360107, -0.3194362223148346, 0.24915635585784912, -0.46006208658218384, -0.578707218170166, 0.15992119908332825, -0.6899800896644592, -0.3055119514465332, -0.5424871444702148, 0.38927456736564636, -0.12799127399921417, -0.315924733877182, 0.30027082562446594, -0.032957155257463455, 0.21963806450366974, 0.2512653172016144, -0.28190165758132935, 0.4092876613140106, 0.38884034752845764, 0.2194323092699051, -0.2697882652282715, -0.3808358609676361, -0.5071515440940857, 0.243475541472435, -0.4559653103351593, 0.48491260409355164, -0.6935364007949829, -0.3352995812892914, 0.24216914176940918, -0.13153794407844543, 0.26913124322891235, -0.3146827816963196, 0.056278295814991, -0.42607879638671875, 0.3215499818325043, 0.11249878257513046, -0.8873471021652222, -0.028364118188619614, 0.1382312923669815, -0.10931334644556046, 1.0010133981704712, 0.26947104930877686, -0.4053419232368469, 0.3326658308506012, -0.8433244824409485, -0.7292435169219971, 0.37733563780784607, -0.20901787281036377, -0.5233297944068909, 0.06757530570030212, -0.15811707079410553, 0.5849217176437378, -0.2178763747215271, 0.5699316263198853, -0.2920704483985901, -0.4321794807910919, 0.27222299575805664, 0.10678038746118546, 0.7796845436096191, 0.13573096692562103, -0.4641039967536926, 0.009174633771181107, -0.7078417539596558, 0.20156291127204895, 0.4216514229774475, -0.5006023645401001, -0.3975277543067932, 0.17801889777183533, 0.1772565245628357, -0.10893621295690536, 0.08399021625518799, -0.6549800038337708, 0.5208215117454529, -0.25170421600341797, 0.24171686172485352, 0.681929349899292, -0.06033068895339966, 0.23272672295570374, 0.02363942377269268, 0.75162672996521, -0.0397680327296257, 0.4065505862236023, -0.28317123651504517, -0.317909300327301, -0.7395436763763428, 0.13437800109386444, 0.47004199028015137, 0.4875810146331787, -0.40853351354599, 0.1915123462677002, 0.19111120700836182, -0.5631487965583801, -0.05421823263168335, 0.2223983258008957, 0.3168988525867462, 0.3742367625236511, 0.14132794737815857, -0.4739341735839844, -0.5641805529594421, -0.7260608673095703, -0.03566122427582741, -0.4713039994239807, 0.04090496525168419, 0.39176449179649353, 0.6313369870185852, -0.35246747732162476, 1.105672001838684, -1.0757414102554321, -0.07030805200338364, -0.32200103998184204, 0.04770595580339432, -0.042810194194316864, 0.6246703863143921, 0.39568182826042175, -0.6377102136611938, -0.4636763334274292, -0.09841781854629517, -0.6213576793670654, -0.2130310982465744, -0.22226332128047943, -0.1716005802154541, 0.33407333493232727, 0.6453307271003723, -0.10380732268095016, 0.5598068237304688, 0.31382614374160767, -0.42421790957450867, 0.8577288389205933, -0.17180384695529938, 0.10626406967639923, -1.1387085914611816, 0.07249313592910767, 0.08531723916530609, -0.23858194053173065, -0.42594480514526367, 0.3750804364681244, 0.1711421012878418, -0.474562406539917, -0.22324123978614807, 0.48613953590393066, -0.5012141466140747, -0.1701846569776535, -0.38058170676231384, -0.12490761280059814, -0.23013514280319214, 0.1897168606519699, 0.04115598276257515, 0.8017414808273315, 0.6637106537818909, -0.6662582159042358, 0.3533893823623657, -0.05682618170976639, -0.4980201721191406, 0.48130112886428833, -0.7359173893928528, -0.023669570684432983, 0.2052311897277832, 0.22764182090759277, -0.7638293504714966, -0.3996583819389343, -0.45373836159706116, -0.4487297534942627, 0.15805500745773315, -0.2415902018547058, -0.5190305709838867, -0.9274281859397888, 0.10702505707740784, 0.420404851436615, 0.8146339654922485, -0.3020924925804138, 0.38129645586013794, 0.4856545627117157, -0.3342263996601105, -0.12359212338924408, -0.5329212546348572, -0.008194628171622753, -0.021518217399716377, -0.5366661548614502, 0.08684279769659042, -0.48545125126838684, -0.3028497099876404, -0.21359416842460632, 0.06739092618227005, -0.6470205187797546, 0.3340195119380951, 0.506921112537384, 0.33103084564208984, -0.34996700286865234, 0.32923105359077454, 0.22347339987754822, 0.2718312442302704, 0.34799066185951233, -0.39436012506484985, 0.3809730112552643, -0.15374082326889038, -0.7810254693031311, -0.21197080612182617, 0.5806900262832642, 0.6038872599601746, -0.20242789387702942, 0.25527453422546387, 0.08854936808347702, -0.43987172842025757, -0.6283546090126038, -0.6903055310249329, -0.24898509681224823, -0.44980886578559875, 0.34293094277381897, -0.30321362614631653, -0.9070717692375183, 0.36703306436538696, -0.19773460924625397, 0.09037122875452042, 0.04958726465702057, 0.6327601075172424, -0.03908216953277588, 1.376536250114441, 0.9462013840675354, -0.1678089201450348, 0.3209877014160156, -0.027940358966588974, 0.38571813702583313, -0.30918005108833313, 0.009084070101380348, -0.7861458659172058, 0.39446231722831726, -0.15249593555927277, -0.092011459171772, 0.19089730083942413, -0.06361023336648941, -0.5554839968681335, 0.2849281430244446, -0.6040138006210327, 0.7558832764625549, 0.5488445162773132, -0.10624628514051437, 0.1685517430305481, -0.11495941877365112, -0.174021378159523, 0.1806495487689972, -0.46314194798469543, -0.5102420449256897, 1.3784465789794922, 0.053659114986658096, 0.48935815691947937, 0.01731075718998909, 0.8302337527275085, 0.4957936704158783, 0.3210024833679199, -0.7228667736053467, 0.6340324878692627, 0.16783425211906433, -0.6595455408096313, -0.22024723887443542, -0.4795517027378082, -0.953987181186676, -0.4658955931663513, 0.14768299460411072, -0.35552066564559937, -0.44309765100479126, -0.0071383267641067505, -0.3668627142906189, -0.13743291795253754, -0.9554818272590637, 0.9480189085006714, -0.1483408808708191, -0.15283143520355225, -0.15018311142921448, -0.34434348344802856, 0.23690256476402283, -0.2733069062232971, 0.16656635701656342, 0.4339172840118408, 0.6378380060195923, 0.9899318814277649, -0.6779656410217285, 0.9473744034767151, -0.3768162429332733, -0.0356176421046257, 0.7000695466995239, 0.505251407623291, 0.2965430021286011, 0.14951077103614807, -0.06636393070220947, -0.32205691933631897, 0.2982092499732971, -0.5381291508674622, -0.3737868666648865, 0.5320062041282654, -0.6307594180107117, -0.7834325432777405, -0.3960998058319092, -0.816706120967865, -0.1831902116537094, 0.2360295057296753, -0.46201711893081665, 0.3120705485343933, -0.042039014399051666, -0.07808845490217209, 0.7531602382659912, -0.44646552205085754, 0.45844995975494385, 1.0057302713394165, -0.5226444602012634, 0.25009995698928833, 1.1286265850067139, 0.1049104854464531, 0.0689001977443695, -0.24385422468185425, 0.41277825832366943, 0.14532385766506195, -0.5302420258522034, -0.5543878078460693, 0.008931015618145466, -0.6010336875915527, -0.17217771708965302, -0.2863828241825104, -0.12832652032375336, -0.8454079627990723, -0.6049802303314209, -0.3434327244758606, -0.2832885980606079, 0.163200244307518, 0.15750519931316376, 0.19546791911125183, 0.9567359089851379, 0.29034459590911865, 0.09473080188035965, -0.5778722763061523, 0.05813859775662422, 0.557701826095581, 0.1139322817325592, -0.09103475511074066, -0.3290390372276306, -0.11435235291719437, -0.255862832069397, -0.30602577328681946, -0.8945630788803101, 0.3379766643047333, -0.09666629135608673, 0.38096413016319275, 0.2326861470937729, 0.16522277891635895, 0.5412769317626953, -0.3604646623134613, 0.9013586640357971, 0.08688115328550339, -1.3457131385803223, 1.0241039991378784, -0.3317335247993469, 0.295624315738678, 0.593575119972229, 0.1569429337978363, -0.42708349227905273, -0.600942075252533, -0.5318846702575684, -0.495328426361084, 0.5475187301635742, 0.018134571611881256, 0.27696219086647034, 0.11854027211666107, 0.40250495076179504, 0.08717113733291626, 0.20495113730430603, -0.7449217438697815, 0.0553896389901638, -0.06164459511637688, -0.566192090511322, 0.20180223882198334, 0.06499739736318588, -0.11835839599370956, -0.4634082019329071, 0.5358701944351196, -0.3870541751384735, 0.03010411188006401, -0.070940300822258, -0.010873997583985329, 0.08449230343103409, 0.23010969161987305, 0.5784361958503723, 0.7854385375976562, -0.03688541054725647, -0.22915109992027283, 0.08364424854516983, -0.7006889581680298, 0.07513624429702759, -0.05387691780924797, -0.4333333671092987, -0.3035188317298889, -0.041729636490345, 0.12630608677864075, -0.2175295501947403, -1.079910397529602, 0.9945666790008545, -0.19802998006343842, -0.22317735850811005, -0.7599199414253235, 0.20282156765460968, -0.12159506231546402, 0.13914571702480316, 0.3847382664680481, -0.2571602463722229, 0.23462533950805664, -0.5113950967788696, 0.178253173828125, 0.39235541224479675, -0.12052444368600845, -0.07195086032152176, 0.32085901498794556, 0.2583814859390259, -0.1842956691980362, 0.6153189539909363, -0.27213895320892334, -0.633949875831604, 1.2551088333129883, 0.9359997510910034, 0.6344899535179138, -0.3779284954071045, 0.505442202091217, 0.48344722390174866, 0.04680158942937851, -0.17046062648296356, 0.39536550641059875, -0.16693435609340668, -0.21942417323589325, -0.8331387042999268, -0.6807543039321899, -0.6709681749343872, -0.01859094761312008, -0.57904452085495, 0.47556358575820923, -0.5225202441215515, 0.2709781229496002, -0.21991436183452606, 0.20206589996814728, -0.6417345404624939, 0.4809247553348541, 0.07773760706186295, 0.7783320546150208, -0.9684879779815674, 1.0687355995178223, 1.0348881483078003, -0.5190788507461548, -1.2020248174667358, -0.06667830049991608, -0.2789568305015564, -0.2733304500579834, 0.9552513957023621, 0.0664525255560875, 0.4500734210014343, -0.10141143947839737, -0.7249861359596252, -0.6843469738960266, 0.7157001495361328, 0.06311987340450287, -0.4955398142337799, 0.10729958117008209, 0.28642675280570984, 0.5999818444252014, -0.38105854392051697, 0.5147913694381714, 0.1252318024635315, 0.41431090235710144, -0.0602855421602726, -0.6170915961265564, -0.018714122474193573, -0.35584691166877747, 0.006269543431699276, 0.25575876235961914, -0.3978838324546814, 0.7224686145782471, -0.27984192967414856, -0.02401774562895298, -0.1909029632806778, 0.6127680540084839, 0.22781933844089508, 0.48310038447380066, 0.28132161498069763, 0.19090019166469574, 0.7684170603752136, 0.10912914574146271, 1.0461832284927368, -0.3192790746688843, 0.27180156111717224, 0.8725093007087708, -0.543321430683136, 0.6030447483062744, 0.3424137532711029, -0.281826913356781, 0.6535646915435791, 0.4522811770439148, -0.3402588963508606, -0.09359760582447052, 0.9516738653182983, -0.009237917140126228, -0.6509974002838135, 0.10373558104038239, -0.44655656814575195, 0.507008969783783, -0.036962006241083145, -0.22879135608673096, 0.1599474996328354, 0.1561293601989746, 0.16174937784671783, 0.20600655674934387, -0.2766825556755066, 0.3779606819152832, -0.2596997618675232, -0.886297345161438, 0.14199747145175934, 0.03943958133459091, 0.368423730134964, -0.40260279178619385, -0.07669021189212799, -0.26591169834136963, 0.18831667304039001, -0.22944721579551697, -0.774468719959259, 0.2251790165901184, 0.43865665793418884, -0.27758079767227173, 0.06027345359325409, 0.48978787660598755, -0.17405864596366882, -0.9719992280006409, 0.053320810198783875, 0.3863898813724518, 0.3380992114543915, 0.028077468276023865, -0.4553461968898773, -0.17150180041790009, 0.09378083795309067, -0.3906373381614685, 0.35776403546333313, 0.03630201146006584, -0.4122929275035858, 0.671703040599823, 0.7486045360565186, 0.23313163220882416, 0.1842840313911438, 0.3363600969314575, 0.6668047308921814, -0.5846000909805298, -0.1797235757112503, -0.5622767210006714, 0.44792619347572327, -0.13681621849536896, -0.2876269519329071, 0.8428909182548523, 0.7602472901344299, 0.9935113787651062, -0.12612096965312958, 1.110709309577942, -0.12775343656539917, 0.31712934374809265, -0.034518465399742126, 0.659002423286438, -0.48517298698425293, -0.045181550085544586, -0.5507495403289795, -0.9265320301055908, -0.46471890807151794, 0.5282789468765259, -0.1796291321516037, -0.00027701060753315687, 0.6304328441619873, 0.8437548875808716, -0.02777894027531147, 0.061475031077861786, 0.23582398891448975, 0.04378318041563034, 0.5697876811027527, 0.8642356991767883, 0.683154284954071, -0.4562141001224518, 0.5952834486961365, -0.20738151669502258, -0.4623092710971832, -0.08238162100315094, -0.7283966541290283, -1.1518663167953491, -0.655181348323822, -0.8404688239097595, -0.4431034028530121, 0.033433474600315094, 0.5970760583877563, 0.7656409740447998, -1.0501022338867188, -0.5382607579231262, -0.4378054440021515, -0.02304091304540634, -0.033340390771627426, -0.29339826107025146, 0.2627686858177185, -0.471645712852478, -0.6668151021003723, 0.4027014970779419, -0.0902291014790535, 0.08595313131809235, -0.5479199290275574, -0.04574298486113548, 0.2014371007680893, 0.3280086815357208, 0.5668136477470398, 0.34308943152427673, -0.28663745522499084, -0.15210013091564178, 0.08516930788755417, -0.20217478275299072, -0.4553544521331787, 1.0242222547531128, -0.8445145487785339, 0.3877594769001007, 0.5078104138374329, 0.7123556137084961, 0.4789312481880188, -0.27056026458740234, 0.6491279006004333, -0.4495560824871063, -0.09371742606163025, 0.2738547623157501, 0.31403496861457825, 0.18448583781719208, -0.36878877878189087, 0.6155047416687012, 0.19187532365322113, -0.904836893081665, -1.2014397382736206, 0.1347375512123108, -0.910968542098999, -0.5711451768875122, 1.357213020324707, -0.19516225159168243, -0.19658900797367096, -0.09964466094970703, -0.3342750072479248, 0.4195503294467926, -0.17561912536621094, 0.9720000624656677, 0.5648799538612366, 0.06459564715623856, 0.30121421813964844, -0.620792806148529, 0.27214884757995605, 0.5659705996513367, -1.1291372776031494, 0.0254200529307127, 0.5031707882881165, 0.35801252722740173, 0.15772181749343872, 0.17877377569675446, -0.06455569714307785, 0.3488026261329651, -0.06391049921512604, 0.7936299443244934, -0.18137001991271973, -0.4516052305698395, 0.14893405139446259, 0.5704781413078308, -0.0005545079475268722, 0.08149746805429459 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07069v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07069v1	Using Large Language Models to Automate and Expedite Reinforcement Learning with Reward Machine	2024-02-11T00:00:05	2024-02-11T00:00:05	Shayan Meshkat Alsadat, Jean-Raphael Gaglione, Daniel Neider, Ufuk Topcu, Zhe Xu	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	We present LARL-RM (Large language model-generated Automaton for Reinforcement Learning with Reward Machine) algorithm in order to encode high-level knowledge into reinforcement learning using automaton to expedite the reinforcement learning. Our method uses Large Language Models (LLM) to obtain high-level domain-specific knowledge using prompt engineering instead of providing the reinforcement learning algorithm directly with the high-level knowledge which requires an expert to encode the automaton. We use chain-of-thought and few-shot methods for prompt engineering and demonstrate that our method works using these approaches. Additionally, LARL-RM allows for fully closed-loop reinforcement learning without the need for an expert to guide and supervise the learning since LARL-RM can use the LLM directly to generate the required high-level knowledge for the task at hand. We also show the theoretical guarantee of our algorithm to converge to an optimal policy. We demonstrate that LARL-RM speeds up the convergence by 30% by implementing our method in two case studies.	[ -0.2164328247308731, -0.8866974711418152, 0.5047569274902344, 0.16280663013458252, 0.17076320946216583, 0.36034733057022095, -0.28501614928245544, -0.08860266208648682, 0.05455055832862854, 0.5372175574302673, -0.6186974048614502, -0.23300522565841675, -0.36869049072265625, -0.1002807468175888, 0.04993303492665291, 0.9039886593818665, -0.301297664642334, -0.09110622107982635, 0.19529114663600922, 0.27115824818611145, -0.34322187304496765, -0.6785658597946167, -0.9979603886604309, -0.4515235722064972, 0.8142387270927429, 0.4546622931957245, 0.2988574802875519, 0.665274977684021, 0.2695515751838684, 0.32566341757774353, -0.11502130329608917, 0.21699140965938568, -0.6348673701286316, 0.2272009253501892, -0.4341318607330322, -0.3469187915325165, -0.3692106008529663, -0.12152876704931259, 0.43849918246269226, 0.293978750705719, -0.29588228464126587, -0.09562716633081436, -0.04048888012766838, 0.6841763854026794, -0.7185330986976624, 0.45254257321357727, -0.5849084258079529, 0.19972874224185944, 0.33470600843429565, -0.6105663776397705, -0.7027820348739624, -0.5686922669410706, -0.09119713306427002, -0.7790370583534241, -0.413626492023468, 0.22394417226314545, 0.7809967994689941, 0.4864422082901001, -0.3147066831588745, -0.4019865393638611, -0.7401368021965027, 1.0170276165008545, -0.6125273704528809, 0.1579548865556717, 0.2813907265663147, 0.7133338451385498, -0.21794086694717407, -0.3744615316390991, -0.4485536217689514, -0.7926986217498779, 0.15770001709461212, 0.027393175289034843, 0.1983587145805359, 0.25759512186050415, 0.6898339986801147, 0.18010906875133514, -0.55620276927948, 0.47796255350112915, -0.2631405293941498, -0.09882155060768127, 0.7167002558708191, 0.23573549091815948, -0.018174611032009125, 0.06403481215238571, -0.5679081678390503, -0.5066445469856262, -0.8238325715065002, 0.45904529094696045, 0.0726790651679039, 0.2119014412164688, 0.14220823347568512, 0.548450767993927, -0.5289983153343201, 0.4785241186618805, -0.05545659363269806, -0.0750403106212616, 0.16589690744876862, -0.06116023659706116, -0.2355452924966812, 0.07106916606426239, 0.8267618417739868, -0.20951277017593384, 0.2693886160850525, 0.014969656243920326, -0.5899122357368469, -0.13285090029239655, 0.12571576237678528, -0.6519469022750854, 0.08286532759666443, 0.04233316332101822, -0.2824352979660034, -0.2536805272102356, -0.07644612342119217, -0.4832476079463959, -0.28233757615089417, -0.4716966152191162, 0.7048699855804443, -0.24487842619419098, -0.08114393800497055, 0.27080103754997253, -0.08192597329616547, 0.2927890717983246, 0.49729642271995544, -0.6158960461616516, 0.14892831444740295, 0.6170028448104858, 0.5348312258720398, -0.2883260250091553, -0.46253833174705505, -1.1041804552078247, 0.14688067138195038, -0.21191757917404175, 0.6527072787284851, -0.2666555643081665, -0.10641282051801682, 0.22098074853420258, 0.0312771238386631, 0.030718974769115448, -0.5407980680465698, 0.28157559037208557, -0.9580292701721191, 0.17051102221012115, -0.0062563735991716385, -0.6577036380767822, -0.3556104302406311, 0.42978453636169434, -0.6660895943641663, 0.7309920191764832, 0.14259150624275208, -0.2471635341644287, 0.19421400129795074, -0.9978378415107727, -0.523866593837738, -0.03797224164009094, 0.012865729629993439, -0.16995349526405334, -0.2304154485464096, 0.22788183391094208, 0.7318143248558044, -0.1120966300368309, 0.24160732328891754, -0.1857920140028, -0.2788234353065491, 0.39102038741111755, -0.2406081259250641, 0.6299752593040466, 0.24749356508255005, -0.3434170186519623, 0.42387655377388, -0.3739166259765625, 0.08150304108858109, 0.19169507920742035, -0.38520586490631104, -0.14007753133773804, -0.05512899532914162, -0.21372447907924652, 0.6542726755142212, 0.551020622253418, -0.13735665380954742, 0.5072332620620728, -0.5118674039840698, 0.30330535769462585, 0.958318829536438, 0.19837485253810883, 0.6084263324737549, -0.37052977085113525, 0.8555142879486084, -0.28662365674972534, 0.01784565858542919, -0.4309287369251251, -0.03747102618217468, -0.6388087272644043, -0.1587584763765335, 0.2672733664512634, 0.722140908241272, -1.0502960681915283, 0.6610422134399414, 0.15418186783790588, -0.10322778671979904, -0.30640730261802673, -0.12071742862462997, 0.539389967918396, 0.13396932184696198, 0.503011167049408, -0.13765938580036163, -0.4528782069683075, -0.6667330265045166, -0.15889611840248108, 0.0608108714222908, 0.1719154566526413, 0.3132704794406891, 0.6604993343353271, -0.16310732066631317, 0.6907965540885925, -0.627100944519043, -0.20855076611042023, -0.4388218820095062, 0.40964990854263306, 0.42779454588890076, 0.4708099961280823, -0.040665823966264725, -0.40462610125541687, -0.5123175978660583, 0.2057478427886963, -0.9320295453071594, 0.14034640789031982, -0.18131688237190247, -0.12112102657556534, 0.2535269558429718, 0.5938404202461243, -0.5261150598526001, 0.19646944105625153, 0.19007447361946106, -0.1580253392457962, 0.5676367878913879, -0.3810097575187683, 0.3076855540275574, -0.7988274693489075, 0.09194982796907425, -0.18924792110919952, -0.3817516267299652, -0.41791263222694397, 0.29731330275535583, 0.032510776072740555, -0.14962635934352875, -0.5159406661987305, 0.8523939251899719, -0.2807142436504364, -0.052752554416656494, -0.6407967805862427, -0.04603729024529457, -0.22274261713027954, 0.9802889823913574, 0.3188225030899048, 0.6417407989501953, 0.3471391499042511, -0.9301419258117676, 0.5975866913795471, 0.05173185095191002, -0.38081541657447815, 0.2386205792427063, -0.6604375243186951, 0.0020327174570411444, 0.05734072998166084, 0.28776562213897705, -0.300580233335495, -0.21532763540744781, 0.11121303588151932, -0.3663325607776642, 0.30592626333236694, 0.11418865621089935, -0.3502166271209717, -0.5280715227127075, -0.15420392155647278, 0.379364550113678, 0.8822447061538696, -0.5552548170089722, 0.2179698348045349, 0.3248356282711029, -0.30031290650367737, -0.7617805004119873, -0.07619772851467133, -0.3028646409511566, -0.1248946487903595, -0.15052175521850586, 0.23329021036624908, -0.1427142322063446, -0.09980009496212006, -0.15227371454238892, 0.24118025600910187, -0.09486863017082214, 0.2382364720106125, 0.05003618076443672, 0.10692990571260452, 0.08280979096889496, 0.08092296123504639, 0.030042381957173347, -0.2644800841808319, 0.13470923900604248, -0.29147619009017944, 0.7182971835136414, 0.13607066869735718, -0.36139610409736633, -0.552605390548706, 0.22488535940647125, 0.48705804347991943, -0.36712780594825745, 0.600957453250885, 0.35668182373046875, -0.20580051839351654, -0.7285998463630676, -0.3269319236278534, -0.35849958658218384, -0.4767972230911255, 0.6702296733856201, -0.34063419699668884, -1.017622470855713, 0.21037620306015015, -0.2949894666671753, 0.1429332047700882, 0.19131503999233246, 0.7287074327468872, -0.024131914600729942, 1.1581488847732544, 0.6035032868385315, -0.39945778250694275, 0.5843003392219543, -0.4399290680885315, 0.03947138041257858, -0.5013840198516846, -0.367290198802948, -0.5251785516738892, -0.08223747462034225, -0.05747338384389877, -0.5139460563659668, 0.3921354115009308, 0.12466394156217575, -0.7672067284584045, 0.3362414836883545, -0.3922496736049652, 0.4148605763912201, 0.7397944927215576, 0.0807451531291008, 0.32418084144592285, -0.028255367651581764, -0.23488612473011017, 0.35179847478866577, -0.9259005188941956, -0.1287296861410141, 0.7889021039009094, 0.49738529324531555, 0.9547960162162781, -0.2679681181907654, 0.7693331241607666, 0.6116541028022766, 0.0044929152354598045, -1.023742914199829, 0.6291363835334778, 0.3069039285182953, -0.15125732123851776, -0.4994688630104065, -0.6472848057746887, -0.8688491582870483, -0.08241916447877884, -0.15878398716449738, -0.3068137466907501, -0.2179528921842575, 0.19426238536834717, -0.3915679156780243, 0.1637846827507019, -0.29353660345077515, 0.7906068563461304, -0.45032748579978943, -0.27908915281295776, -0.6379631161689758, -0.40155142545700073, 0.42328229546546936, -0.0353289358317852, 0.2449001967906952, 0.06022016704082489, 0.0430011972784996, 0.8073479533195496, -0.6637645363807678, 0.40343284606933594, -0.539514422416687, -0.38766223192214966, 0.17738229036331177, 0.1659722626209259, 1.0906919240951538, -0.21884799003601074, 0.045781850814819336, -0.361991286277771, -0.5269519686698914, -0.33550378680229187, -0.7975223064422607, 0.6646440625190735, -0.7755861878395081, -0.3031274974346161, -0.5084213614463806, -0.7315927743911743, -0.1922873854637146, -0.0000326222216244787, -0.13576211035251617, 0.15298999845981598, -0.11950472742319107, -0.07341072708368301, 0.9901318550109863, -0.6541866660118103, 0.5626577138900757, 0.6197801232337952, -0.3710850179195404, -0.5926998257637024, 1.012010097503662, -0.1686117798089981, 0.24318139255046844, 0.7471889853477478, 0.04755040258169174, -0.38521507382392883, -0.09759985655546188, -0.38369834423065186, 0.25855034589767456, -0.505129873752594, -0.3824952244758606, -0.5344582200050354, -0.4479101002216339, 0.007708881516009569, -0.45495665073394775, -0.3534950613975525, -0.3393600583076477, 0.19421307742595673, 0.14984722435474396, 0.4583759605884552, 0.8311876058578491, -0.04837873950600624, 0.3785824477672577, -0.7218829989433289, 0.31601566076278687, 0.4464784860610962, -0.006808724254369736, 0.15007486939430237, -0.60484778881073, -0.7744172811508179, 0.11217270791530609, -0.2459404617547989, -0.6864509582519531, 0.48270827531814575, -0.1774972528219223, 0.6302676200866699, 0.4169897139072418, 0.06909740716218948, 0.27442243695259094, -0.6485207080841064, 0.5759096145629883, 0.4121926724910736, -0.8132415413856506, 0.5640693306922913, -0.38338741660118103, 0.3543902039527893, 0.3011316657066345, 0.616866409778595, -0.47151750326156616, -0.24866142868995667, -0.4673472046852112, -0.8217225074768066, 0.8406928181648254, -0.2926519513130188, -0.3137860894203186, 0.01698026992380619, -0.04061106964945793, 0.15006498992443085, 0.35626330971717834, -0.7613911032676697, 0.13566260039806366, 0.1149074137210846, -0.31332364678382874, -0.06632799655199051, -0.09321080148220062, 0.0546332448720932, -0.04586024209856987, 1.121464729309082, -0.26803526282310486, 0.46928155422210693, -0.12843506038188934, -0.366273432970047, -0.1004471555352211, 0.493581622838974, 0.6714674234390259, 0.37251046299934387, -0.0800032988190651, -0.21856984496116638, 0.1922740638256073, 0.10560966283082962, 0.532677412033081, 0.012948425486683846, -0.17298172414302826, -0.44827187061309814, 0.16580064594745636, 0.9499614238739014, 0.33285102248191833, -0.9872720241546631, 0.5302839279174805, 0.254680871963501, -0.3789844214916229, -0.4450993835926056, 0.33493050932884216, -0.15291818976402283, 0.47674912214279175, 0.3655712604522705, -0.16735193133354187, -0.16311800479888916, -0.4319802522659302, 0.2269238978624344, 0.5556961894035339, -0.33353501558303833, -0.04745282605290413, 0.49427083134651184, 0.1137445718050003, -0.22665904462337494, 0.4595825970172882, -0.4156768023967743, -0.7238510251045227, 0.686241090297699, 0.4768097698688507, 0.8856465220451355, -0.34735506772994995, 0.2820033133029938, 0.626401960849762, 0.007239791564643383, -0.562691330909729, 0.3464674949645996, -0.16953825950622559, -0.47577962279319763, -1.1421691179275513, -0.6200883984565735, -0.49854782223701477, 0.12804053723812103, -0.5025225877761841, 0.15575504302978516, -0.6383190751075745, 0.18460029363632202, -0.542046308517456, 0.003641093149781227, -0.508293867111206, -0.03313359245657921, 0.12546981871128082, 1.019793152809143, -0.5900164842605591, 0.8264855742454529, 0.5614444017410278, -0.5250298380851746, -1.1695455312728882, -0.34371694922447205, -0.40163347125053406, -0.7585824728012085, 1.1653858423233032, 0.04264562577009201, -0.15424957871437073, 0.22036658227443695, -0.589450478553772, -0.742466926574707, 1.1054842472076416, -0.16736209392547607, -0.7238607406616211, -0.26428601145744324, -0.13979053497314453, 0.17227402329444885, -0.39394497871398926, 0.4754282236099243, 0.17287495732307434, 0.5039623379707336, 0.16082553565502167, -1.1578848361968994, 0.03904492408037186, -0.07444566488265991, -0.095766082406044, 0.4003632664680481, -0.4428248703479767, 0.8375665545463562, -0.2522708475589752, 0.06253685057163239, 0.1123606339097023, 0.8053019642829895, 0.6122260689735413, 0.18011173605918884, 0.4890720844268799, 0.6348861455917358, 0.7984037399291992, 0.1766212284564972, 0.7939485907554626, -0.2307654768228531, 0.48662400245666504, 0.9141928553581238, -0.5238005518913269, 0.9052137732505798, 0.14088159799575806, -0.17331859469413757, 0.7252181768417358, 0.5316669344902039, 0.152533158659935, 0.7111086249351501, 0.48810774087905884, -0.2848826050758362, -0.252796471118927, -0.21903422474861145, -0.28568461537361145, 0.1119164451956749, 0.2434774786233902, -0.3616640269756317, -0.24569232761859894, 0.4991021752357483, -0.06830072402954102, 0.030790310353040695, -0.8626623153686523, 0.8403745293617249, 0.10577111691236496, -0.8586745858192444, 0.8805330395698547, 0.06337100267410278, 0.8207981586456299, -0.7574228048324585, -0.24424180388450623, -0.013235960155725479, 0.27048927545547485, 0.04539898782968521, -0.5370131731033325, -0.14814651012420654, -0.07672625035047531, -0.11983884871006012, -0.4694831967353821, 0.6275220513343811, -0.623814582824707, 0.027295108884572983, 0.2535690367221832, 0.5503550171852112, 0.08480670303106308, -0.06051430478692055, -0.8154253959655762, -0.3453887403011322, -0.11376713216304779, -0.224501371383667, 0.3258466422557831, 0.4657171666622162, -0.0795966163277626, 0.8338649868965149, 0.6180568337440491, 0.15971913933753967, -0.07492035627365112, -0.09559398144483566, 0.8314907550811768, -0.9615378975868225, -0.7438369393348694, -0.7006000876426697, 0.5332491993904114, -0.07398120313882828, 0.20221127569675446, 0.5822412371635437, 0.46825161576271057, 0.8174149990081787, -0.33376482129096985, 0.9131024479866028, -0.03845245763659477, 0.6780744791030884, -0.952113151550293, 0.555999755859375, -0.5543856024742126, 0.13408982753753662, -0.017158647999167442, -0.8134852051734924, -0.031734392046928406, 0.6590033769607544, -0.4019160568714142, 0.13952702283859253, 0.9071516394615173, 0.8651345372200012, 0.06237269937992096, -0.3048170208930969, 0.38368725776672363, 0.2769470512866974, 0.08237306028604507, 1.0975122451782227, 1.2514749765396118, -0.08248274028301239, 0.23858371376991272, -0.09381464868783951, -0.37679290771484375, -0.36678898334503174, -0.7095914483070374, -0.9676457047462463, -0.345976322889328, -0.09391940385103226, -0.47226470708847046, 0.21366845071315765, 1.4660927057266235, 0.590604841709137, -0.677327573299408, -0.4853484034538269, -0.2445698082447052, 0.2914349436759949, -0.4295448958873749, -0.25372976064682007, 0.360164999961853, -0.7180494070053101, -0.6497902274131775, 0.812096357345581, 0.19785454869270325, -0.24760568141937256, -0.49417248368263245, -0.6966944932937622, -0.11029038578271866, -0.11296215653419495, 0.670198380947113, 0.650017499923706, -0.390859454870224, 0.12290547043085098, 0.18566524982452393, -0.12569092214107513, -0.14038196206092834, 1.068091630935669, -1.1478630304336548, -0.07906287908554077, 0.636640191078186, 0.8808830380439758, 0.413328617811203, -0.06635134667158127, 0.7162579298019409, -0.320713073015213, 0.12914878129959106, 0.2552850842475891, 0.27392297983169556, -0.0318693146109581, -0.22750477492809296, 0.31963828206062317, -0.001050662249326706, -0.9385679364204407, -0.6810926795005798, 0.557567298412323, -0.901100754737854, -0.40386348962783813, 1.2041471004486084, -0.2254151850938797, -0.3989892899990082, -0.023220418021082878, -0.2659739553928375, 0.20112474262714386, -0.6636592149734497, 0.6157832741737366, 0.12220589071512222, 0.020365307107567787, -0.196623757481575, -0.5245957374572754, 0.8086023330688477, 0.4506751596927643, -1.0456516742706299, -0.024966174736618996, 0.3436909019947052, -0.09691329300403595, -0.09519588947296143, 0.6308425664901733, 0.20013554394245148, 0.4454677104949951, -0.37423279881477356, 0.5245611667633057, -0.3443129062652588, -0.5208054780960083, -0.5259093046188354, 0.2327621877193451, 0.34404507279396057, 0.1133103296160698 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07051v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07051v1	$L^*LM$: Learning Automata from Examples using Natural Language Oracles	2024-02-10T21:46:34	2024-02-10T21:46:34	Marcell Vazquez-Chanlatte, Karim Elmaaroufi, Stefan J. Witwicki, Sanjit A. Seshia	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL	Expert demonstrations have proven an easy way to indirectly specify complex tasks. Recent algorithms even support extracting unambiguous formal specifications, e.g. deterministic finite automata (DFA), from demonstrations. Unfortunately, these techniques are generally not sample efficient. In this work, we introduce $L^LM$, an algorithm for learning DFAs from both demonstrations and natural language. Due to the expressivity of natural language, we observe a significant improvement in the data efficiency of learning DFAs from expert demonstrations. Technically, $L^LM$ leverages large language models to answer membership queries about the underlying task. This is then combined with recent techniques for transforming learning from demonstrations into a sequence of labeled example learning problems. In our experiments, we observe the two modalities complement each other, yielding a powerful few-shot learner.	[ -0.1860143542289734, -1.2698719501495361, 0.6819596886634827, -0.20006147027015686, -0.3705616891384125, 0.2666865885257721, 0.09081519395112991, -0.5322938561439514, 0.17251379787921906, 0.35566842555999756, -0.5702396035194397, -0.3156548738479614, -0.42474088072776794, 0.09689812362194061, -0.47366735339164734, 0.6034497022628784, -0.17565451562404633, -0.002807801589369774, 0.03771661967039108, 0.153971865773201, -0.028013106435537338, -0.2251979112625122, -0.8867539167404175, -0.46332159638404846, 0.44885531067848206, 0.3479168117046356, 0.6382901668548584, 0.925377607345581, 0.19417068362236023, 0.3781032860279083, 0.37397053837776184, 0.48517751693725586, -0.23776347935199738, 0.0016878546448424459, 0.07447431236505508, -0.6154108047485352, -0.06252484023571014, 0.2243761420249939, 0.6532949209213257, 0.6215048432350159, -0.06499262154102325, -0.029067089781165123, -0.2768283188343048, 0.7950896620750427, -0.44549962878227234, 0.6292101144790649, -0.48912420868873596, 0.27389073371887207, 0.02271146886050701, -0.1539980173110962, -0.5305564403533936, -0.5299175381660461, -0.021109456196427345, -0.7368349432945251, -0.3118365406990051, -0.05911736190319061, 0.696391761302948, 0.5276904702186584, -0.24546311795711517, -0.37457475066185, -0.9269896149635315, 0.7688232064247131, -0.7477375864982605, 0.2145252525806427, 0.3187049627304077, 0.8098885416984558, -0.3857501745223999, -0.7622597813606262, -0.7268720269203186, -0.3222241699695587, -0.10757805407047272, -0.17085258662700653, -0.2940618395805359, 0.12763841450214386, 0.45654794573783875, 0.48410144448280334, -0.2787027657032013, 0.46197909116744995, -0.10447029024362564, -0.16146816313266754, 0.8899045586585999, 0.2773891091346741, 0.17143891751766205, 0.12120993435382843, -0.3100443184375763, -0.3051092028617859, -0.6840159893035889, -0.010931381955742836, 0.31034624576568604, 0.2015565037727356, 0.0005699965404346585, 0.36153826117515564, -0.22368603944778442, 0.9225365519523621, 0.08301175385713577, -0.3652571141719818, -0.05320680886507034, 0.012818356044590473, -0.5761867761611938, -0.39086711406707764, 0.8098082542419434, -0.1833512783050537, 0.16929711401462555, -0.20496979355812073, -0.19001024961471558, -0.1312808096408844, 0.0013420445611700416, -0.7636517286300659, -0.6119452118873596, 0.05150284245610237, -0.34899792075157166, -0.1122489646077156, 0.05710012838244438, -0.7477390170097351, -0.4318748116493225, -0.5929309129714966, 0.8979521989822388, -0.22119194269180298, -0.10798351466655731, 0.06745175272226334, 0.042921751737594604, 0.3133176565170288, 0.42384323477745056, -0.6978005170822144, 0.5334715843200684, 0.7725017070770264, 0.2876467704772949, 0.07276373356580734, -0.12896326184272766, -0.9416484832763672, -0.15107859671115875, -0.45111554861068726, 0.5461254715919495, -0.21730947494506836, 0.04599021002650261, 0.010465809144079685, -0.2989118993282318, -0.21133819222450256, -0.6443688273429871, 0.1306714415550232, -0.5850979685783386, 0.306846022605896, -0.0008003340335562825, -0.9374381303787231, -0.5345920324325562, -0.10481669753789902, -0.7425092458724976, 0.8573235273361206, -0.04914076253771782, -0.10141589492559433, 0.4720824658870697, -0.6786643862724304, -0.4418289363384247, 0.038597896695137024, -0.5777347683906555, -0.3856191635131836, -0.035617757588624954, -0.042494237422943115, 0.7678019404411316, -0.08683415502309799, 0.008226179517805576, -0.1363278180360794, -0.15808649361133575, 0.21941016614437103, -0.392700731754303, 0.5758092403411865, 0.34708741307258606, -0.6531372666358948, 0.03533390536904335, -0.7617273926734924, -0.12767992913722992, 0.20924994349479675, -0.2648850381374359, -0.4574970304965973, 0.21076996624469757, -0.4466875493526459, 0.21227625012397766, 0.13849946856498718, -0.32690879702568054, 0.46723753213882446, -0.7478664517402649, 0.04252927750349045, 0.5628786087036133, 0.13062137365341187, 0.5346715450286865, -0.2929985225200653, 0.3008617162704468, -0.2807963788509369, 0.034533966332674026, -0.1530296355485916, -0.33447468280792236, -0.9338208436965942, -0.48694661259651184, -0.036687664687633514, 0.39742690324783325, -0.9448047280311584, 0.35964435338974, 0.22907939553260803, -0.46437081694602966, -0.531042218208313, 0.5005528926849365, 0.596150815486908, 0.40933263301849365, 0.39811965823173523, -0.24314767122268677, -0.5168712139129639, -0.9413436055183411, -0.24968786537647247, -0.4186629354953766, 0.1213306412100792, 0.2846207916736603, 0.2628846764564514, -0.04548070952296257, 0.8273382782936096, -0.42736271023750305, -0.20064279437065125, -0.35612255334854126, 0.628339409828186, 0.30787742137908936, 0.25898975133895874, 0.6168886423110962, -0.5349183678627014, -0.5832297801971436, -0.14836901426315308, -0.6836763024330139, 0.126321941614151, -0.3989813029766083, -0.02413833886384964, 0.46141669154167175, 0.546004593372345, -0.4446870684623718, 0.29176971316337585, 0.15249547362327576, -0.19729328155517578, 0.3211250603199005, -0.1863178014755249, -0.07606546580791473, -0.8651064038276672, -0.4032873511314392, -0.1495821326971054, -0.5568110942840576, -0.723547637462616, 0.49464094638824463, -0.16378909349441528, 0.3434947729110718, -0.6491897106170654, 0.6503573656082153, -0.7014626860618591, -0.21573962271213531, -0.5713209509849548, -0.1243167370557785, -0.42961952090263367, 0.4619430899620056, 0.2616384029388428, 0.46033138036727905, 0.7319194674491882, -0.9580704569816589, 0.28540292382240295, -0.038715437054634094, -0.37271296977996826, 0.12125536054372787, -0.192609041929245, 0.3577626347541809, -0.10839258134365082, -0.056234829127788544, -0.724737286567688, -0.2761181890964508, 0.1778661608695984, 0.01813327521085739, 0.36247801780700684, 0.11045486479997635, -0.6882380843162537, -0.26184916496276855, -0.06954681873321533, -0.03678995743393898, 0.8665814399719238, -0.6816930770874023, 0.6741414070129395, 0.42257869243621826, 0.31443437933921814, -0.6368830800056458, -0.3147367835044861, -0.035818129777908325, -0.09628137946128845, -0.021207105368375778, -0.09643036872148514, -0.15859924256801605, -0.5960666537284851, -0.29706764221191406, -0.04931584373116493, -0.2460251748561859, 0.5520306825637817, 0.18450501561164856, -0.1366700828075409, -0.14800769090652466, 0.225349560379982, -0.03162967041134834, 0.004492844920605421, 0.16308052837848663, 0.05292285606265068, 0.5012645125389099, -0.03254403918981552, -0.6157044172286987, -0.8572637438774109, 0.27756837010383606, 0.40181025862693787, 0.11684589087963104, 0.3311524987220764, 0.48560845851898193, -0.5605059862136841, -0.5560606718063354, -0.3524112105369568, -0.4634072482585907, -0.4860959053039551, 0.4086560606956482, -0.3241654634475708, -0.5740591287612915, 0.11299131065607071, -0.14271330833435059, 0.6250349879264832, 0.35063958168029785, 0.48752355575561523, -0.21331098675727844, 0.8175375461578369, 0.7260491251945496, -0.2654097378253937, 0.3905802071094513, -0.4604490399360657, -0.0526709258556366, 0.12239634245634079, -0.053500253707170486, -0.4365740716457367, -0.36300548911094666, 0.028997398912906647, -0.7926323413848877, 0.12844742834568024, 0.1284170150756836, -0.16096344590187073, 0.5350788235664368, 0.06525447219610214, 0.7100565433502197, 0.41278892755508423, 0.24062585830688477, 0.47225895524024963, 0.06187141686677933, 0.011365718208253384, -0.08147044479846954, -0.6262650489807129, -0.6450631022453308, 0.692554771900177, 0.5076358318328857, 0.9417070746421814, 0.28836894035339355, 1.1129660606384277, 0.31947240233421326, 0.5077313184738159, -1.039201021194458, 0.7486839294433594, -0.3392414152622223, -0.2798897325992584, -0.29351097345352173, -0.4303329586982727, -0.823580801486969, -0.13316495716571808, -0.2791593074798584, -0.41911008954048157, 0.09425705671310425, 0.30078938603401184, -0.3109772205352783, 0.3295525908470154, -0.33547744154930115, 0.6402543187141418, -0.3016943037509918, -0.15474051237106323, -0.4522176682949066, -0.46234750747680664, 0.5393882989883423, -0.12022105604410172, 0.4832601845264435, -0.11218535155057907, -0.07107514888048172, 0.6720963716506958, -0.4335087537765503, 1.2656430006027222, -0.3719176948070526, -0.4228030741214752, 0.349346399307251, 0.48174741864204407, 0.5497488379478455, -0.0666089579463005, -0.01790626533329487, -0.4877297878265381, -0.4235931932926178, -0.26708197593688965, -0.8508812189102173, 0.3005985915660858, -0.7030256986618042, -0.4965573847293854, -0.13800358772277832, -0.48144954442977905, -0.14650125801563263, -0.0957665741443634, -0.17460228502750397, 0.41245174407958984, -0.3423478305339813, -0.25568875670433044, 0.7568562626838684, 0.06520973145961761, 0.7559370398521423, 0.8221564292907715, -0.28684791922569275, -0.00039999643922783434, 0.806551992893219, -0.062175605446100235, 0.46783164143562317, 0.789801299571991, 0.12309415638446808, -0.3490617871284485, -0.5719580054283142, -0.5697575211524963, 0.07959522306919098, -0.8449701070785522, -0.13930095732212067, -0.6199098229408264, -0.015916235744953156, 0.039304669946432114, 0.0836910828948021, -0.3443315327167511, -0.7028964161872864, -0.43725815415382385, -0.3593657314777374, 0.38426414132118225, 0.9447197318077087, -0.04825836047530174, 0.22800570726394653, -0.6498105525970459, 0.4899280071258545, 0.8749825954437256, -0.10418763756752014, -0.004483143333345652, -0.36885470151901245, -0.16902057826519012, -0.010027311742305756, -0.12321123480796814, -1.0126649141311646, 0.4145735502243042, 0.7128961682319641, 1.085473895072937, 0.6197174787521362, 0.045935921370983124, 0.714388370513916, -0.51994788646698, 0.6221507787704468, -0.09090373665094376, -0.859690248966217, 0.3923822045326233, 0.023126669228076935, -0.11736221611499786, 0.6739347577095032, 0.7135893702507019, -0.019450750201940536, -0.5279384851455688, -0.47819066047668457, -0.5950156450271606, 0.3629007637500763, -0.1737997978925705, 0.10080850124359131, -0.11213903874158859, 0.5019221305847168, 0.48980972170829773, -0.028050927445292473, -0.7304507493972778, -0.4989914894104004, 0.08330690115690231, -0.3990632891654968, -0.22993864119052887, 0.0366053432226181, -0.21640615165233612, -0.22653062641620636, 0.6585968136787415, -0.3046375513076782, 0.17706386744976044, 0.24238091707229614, -0.5689826011657715, -0.11890597641468048, 0.18637551367282867, 0.5040004253387451, 0.42862144112586975, 0.016930457204580307, 0.4433582127094269, 0.03292110189795494, -0.14984001219272614, 0.3102959990501404, 0.12640127539634705, -0.20478279888629913, 0.06412884593009949, 0.3429580330848694, 0.8726966977119446, 0.3100368082523346, -0.7337111234664917, 0.25567692518234253, 0.02533905766904354, -0.34323978424072266, -0.45227882266044617, 0.2981973886489868, -0.10164278745651245, 0.3772418797016144, 0.6935451626777649, -0.3751302659511566, 0.2517419457435608, -0.8833314776420593, 0.6944155097007751, 0.47557950019836426, -0.44676658511161804, -0.21932446956634521, 0.6113905906677246, 0.16105036437511444, -0.48164263367652893, 0.1035885289311409, -0.4051121771335602, -0.41126585006713867, 0.7240601181983948, 0.37224864959716797, 0.887547492980957, -0.05705104023218155, 0.24766165018081665, 0.43742144107818604, 0.22723029553890228, -0.22810664772987366, 0.3509511649608612, -0.3147136867046356, -0.5877791047096252, -0.5651271343231201, -0.6042278409004211, -0.6522468328475952, 0.06184699758887291, -0.37547767162323, 0.14256325364112854, -0.6358191967010498, 0.36320099234580994, 0.2121499925851822, 0.15826886892318726, -0.5631418824195862, 0.011676846072077751, 0.2173379510641098, 1.137829065322876, -1.1887534856796265, 0.9051435589790344, 0.6376754641532898, -0.3833100199699402, -0.9873668551445007, -0.18155182898044586, 0.00394783541560173, -0.7579178810119629, 0.8488121628761292, 0.07751765102148056, -0.06138408184051514, 0.11618570238351822, -0.5391207933425903, -0.35561850666999817, 0.8833586573600769, 0.2810867428779602, -0.5348637104034424, 0.2440260350704193, 0.10104247182607651, 0.5319110155105591, -0.5659241080284119, 0.3683243691921234, 0.5704516172409058, 0.41723620891571045, -0.2759239971637726, -0.9099906086921692, 0.09090951085090637, 0.009034032933413982, -0.7071003317832947, 0.13574063777923584, -0.3944573402404785, 0.8269019722938538, -0.2656797170639038, -0.3345818817615509, 0.3123107850551605, 0.9580808281898499, 0.10206343233585358, 0.4271931052207947, 0.783421516418457, 0.3767215311527252, 0.7709664702415466, 0.001602955162525177, 1.0173102617263794, 0.19651438295841217, 0.14010851085186005, 1.0488457679748535, -0.3121100664138794, 0.9858536720275879, 0.4369162619113922, -0.34422633051872253, 0.8524459600448608, 0.5920655131340027, 0.24237045645713806, 0.4526016414165497, 0.30026182532310486, -0.4479316174983978, -0.6285856366157532, 0.3806614279747009, 0.0009835095843300223, 0.48720064759254456, 0.38822510838508606, -0.41683197021484375, -0.4937281906604767, -0.0677800327539444, -0.008514507673680782, 0.5512357950210571, -0.42420294880867004, 1.286935567855835, 0.16629397869110107, -0.4853494465351105, 0.6818397045135498, -0.18397046625614166, 0.6941151022911072, -0.38374075293540955, -0.5113826394081116, -0.17145013809204102, 0.063583143055439, -0.08654668182134628, -0.41671133041381836, 0.3460690677165985, -0.16833128035068512, 0.062373124063014984, -0.2231697142124176, 0.5235231518745422, -0.48127153515815735, -0.30656689405441284, 0.18341979384422302, 0.7602143883705139, 0.7722349166870117, 0.30798810720443726, -0.6162993907928467, -0.5144874453544617, -0.1563255935907364, -0.00001997384606511332, 0.3939707279205322, 0.0662769004702568, -0.06634262204170227, 0.7049574851989746, 0.4126410186290741, -0.2019842267036438, 0.17111796140670776, -0.03777308762073517, 0.6610329747200012, -0.4992007613182068, -0.2022051364183426, -0.8306559920310974, 0.26374050974845886, -0.041508812457323074, 0.15233410894870758, 0.6377072334289551, 0.5418237447738647, 0.5693696141242981, -0.43122825026512146, 0.5347028970718384, 0.03816122189164162, 0.7054879069328308, -0.8353312611579895, 0.6503304839134216, -0.4949537515640259, 0.2798435389995575, -0.027561379596590996, -0.6042936444282532, -0.23683904111385345, 0.6447936296463013, 0.07224318385124207, -0.26866579055786133, 0.45853307843208313, 0.6330947875976562, -0.11337929219007492, -0.20528727769851685, 0.44861310720443726, 0.32862889766693115, 0.29165616631507874, 0.7887516617774963, 0.7882965207099915, -0.3617141842842102, 0.2635667026042938, -0.6940752863883972, -0.3940623998641968, -0.10937868803739548, -1.061006784439087, -1.0247163772583008, -0.3943009078502655, -0.5508748888969421, 0.17811283469200134, 0.09631028771400452, 1.2763577699661255, 0.8092136979103088, -0.7797421216964722, -0.30254924297332764, -0.18060711026191711, 0.3447786271572113, -0.5069202780723572, -0.19745703041553497, 0.40015989542007446, -0.49593275785446167, -1.1394199132919312, 0.9617462754249573, -0.056999437510967255, 0.22891978919506073, -0.5276623964309692, -0.23508869111537933, -0.10565616190433502, 0.24600309133529663, 0.5425787568092346, 0.8220043778419495, -0.6013561487197876, -0.23038461804389954, 0.07560686767101288, -0.021771201863884926, -0.2371702790260315, 0.6003074645996094, -1.1009589433670044, 0.2509351670742035, 0.5084797739982605, 0.845803439617157, 0.29054370522499084, -0.15362095832824707, 0.6997295618057251, -0.7078823447227478, 0.1273859143257141, 0.1499033272266388, 0.3722682297229767, 0.05145692080259323, -0.21320638060569763, 0.4576534926891327, 0.11071566492319107, -0.3924310505390167, -0.7700502276420593, 0.6404212713241577, -1.0132677555084229, -0.260233610868454, 1.0278196334838867, -0.31815168261528015, -0.1935911923646927, -0.5293238162994385, -0.1956271380186081, 0.2617720067501068, -0.21739499270915985, 0.9086150527000427, 0.16427385807037354, -0.28392884135246277, -0.35833218693733215, -0.593488872051239, 0.8895938992500305, 0.4448942542076111, -1.1031854152679443, -0.03741765022277832, 0.3970968425273895, 0.18745025992393494, 0.05911039561033249, 0.597385048866272, -0.08381523191928864, 0.5826585292816162, -0.30677545070648193, 0.07685686647891998, -0.26118001341819763, -0.3184988498687744, -0.5882195234298706, 0.06885271519422531, 0.3836694061756134, -0.0889844074845314 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07043v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07043v2	A Tale of Tails: Model Collapse as a Change of Scaling Laws	2024-02-10T21:06:34	2024-05-31T12:27:52	Elvis Dohmatob, Yunzhen Feng, Pu Yang, Francois Charton, Julia Kempe	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	As AI model size grows, neural scaling laws have become a crucial tool to predict the improvements of large models when increasing capacity and the size of original (human or natural) training data. Yet, the widespread use of popular models means that the ecosystem of online data and text will co-evolve to progressively contain increased amounts of synthesized data. In this paper we ask: How will the scaling laws change in the inevitable regime where synthetic data makes its way into the training corpus? Will future models, still improve, or be doomed to degenerate up to total (model) collapse? We develop a theoretical framework of model collapse through the lens of scaling laws. We discover a wide range of decay phenomena, analyzing loss of scaling, shifted scaling with number of generations, the ''un-learning" of skills, and grokking when mixing human and synthesized data. Our theory is validated by large-scale experiments with a transformer on an arithmetic task and text generation using the large language model Llama2.	[ -0.3274454176425934, -0.7479153275489807, 0.7273044586181641, -0.17861858010292053, 0.11526432633399963, 0.16581933200359344, -0.09946908801794052, -0.4545457661151886, 0.23647981882095337, 0.885890543460846, -0.6615100502967834, 0.3194133937358856, -0.708268940448761, 0.11354285478591919, -1.04967200756073, 1.2014223337173462, 0.21372047066688538, 0.05932167172431946, -0.2692563533782959, 0.06484746932983398, -0.3098180890083313, -0.4587211310863495, -0.7504892349243164, -0.6357086896896362, 0.2250615507364273, 0.22858084738254547, 0.8140963315963745, 1.1198264360427856, 0.2694307267665863, 0.26148027181625366, -0.3161815106868744, -0.09735961258411407, -0.7047132253646851, 0.23901230096817017, 0.03263670951128006, -0.9943483471870422, -0.3703341782093048, 0.056669965386390686, 0.7916815876960754, 0.9846850037574768, -0.2702122926712036, -0.13085304200649261, 0.21127308905124664, 0.9177777767181396, -0.08094440400600433, -0.025815928354859352, -0.6757766008377075, -0.18553420901298523, 0.1867944598197937, -0.007443584036082029, -0.36418119072914124, -0.1530819535255432, -0.03678501397371292, -0.5919120907783508, 0.49097374081611633, -0.2282501459121704, 0.7749195098876953, 0.31976786255836487, -0.5810611844062805, -0.1385199874639511, -0.832896888256073, 0.6659557819366455, -0.6705873608589172, 0.2175929844379425, 0.28888291120529175, 0.41385409235954285, -0.22642876207828522, -0.9558224081993103, -0.6274166703224182, -0.2136612981557846, 0.1378069818019867, -0.051971957087516785, -0.5964435338973999, -0.13095831871032715, 0.2928781807422638, 0.30599528551101685, -0.21654129028320312, 0.25044021010398865, -0.6225753426551819, 0.2720126211643219, 0.5695630311965942, 0.5188475847244263, 0.5831343531608582, 0.04458095133304596, 0.05137452110648155, -0.48649948835372925, -0.935457706451416, -0.32512152194976807, 0.6791454553604126, 0.4895344078540802, -0.14952383935451508, 0.3893704414367676, 0.06687716394662857, 0.2501623332500458, 0.5183199048042297, -0.2057965248823166, -0.009733625687658787, -0.10957879573106766, -0.15301132202148438, 0.21841312944889069, 0.5597441792488098, 0.697578489780426, 0.34388652443885803, -0.22577106952667236, -0.14199364185333252, -0.16388364136219025, 0.4135309159755707, -0.7872607707977295, -0.08378732949495316, 0.08164191246032715, -0.6608516573905945, -0.6269962787628174, -0.21519573032855988, -0.5739086866378784, -0.9255368113517761, -0.3579932451248169, 0.6670345664024353, -0.2561728358268738, -0.7544841766357422, 0.23479308187961578, -0.30879560112953186, -0.08477755635976791, 0.19996732473373413, -1.1615554094314575, 0.6110168099403381, 0.6681609153747559, 0.8631678819656372, 0.2668014466762543, -0.5580202341079712, -0.2597199082374573, -0.24680644273757935, -0.5396517515182495, 0.0840875655412674, -0.10309901833534241, -0.4441205859184265, 0.12214293330907822, 0.22182390093803406, 0.09120303392410278, -0.5648602843284607, 0.06011619046330452, -0.4894409775733948, -0.3630162477493286, -0.1316385269165039, -0.4328223466873169, -0.26978784799575806, 0.08853024989366531, -0.9616554975509644, 0.4176146984100342, -0.17267194390296936, -0.6989699602127075, 0.4558334946632385, -0.4745713770389557, -0.5295653343200684, -0.2350054830312729, 0.037674516439437866, -0.6304828524589539, 0.3109281361103058, -0.21090875566005707, 0.45425161719322205, -0.6173972487449646, 0.2808277904987335, -0.48636937141418457, -0.32030797004699707, 0.14783655107021332, -0.3707680404186249, 1.087480902671814, 0.04742184653878212, -0.07635112851858139, -0.21384522318840027, -0.8050910830497742, -0.25985628366470337, 0.520810604095459, -0.09543300420045853, -0.20721252262592316, 0.43881940841674805, -0.05143318325281143, -0.1661544293165207, -0.046270933002233505, -0.4333997070789337, 0.43175995349884033, -0.23775097727775574, 1.1257230043411255, 0.3757425546646118, 0.33197495341300964, 0.668143093585968, -0.5140151977539062, 0.32696497440338135, -0.030068524181842804, -0.03883780911564827, -0.34231674671173096, -0.3464410603046417, -0.8100824952125549, 0.319784551858902, 0.16681808233261108, 0.03113049454987049, -0.10859047621488571, 0.22418566048145294, -0.507853627204895, -0.7292183041572571, -0.22208544611930847, -0.2642539441585541, -0.3096314072608948, 0.4600951373577118, 0.3024626672267914, 0.10923293232917786, -0.6952245235443115, -0.8071966767311096, -0.23274394869804382, -0.39637935161590576, -0.3030696511268616, -0.16865500807762146, 0.7445775270462036, -0.5053144693374634, 1.0171334743499756, -0.2506473958492279, -0.03430456295609474, -0.501239001750946, 0.4532616436481476, 0.15687809884548187, 0.5323049426078796, 0.4633735418319702, -0.6799430847167969, 0.09144748747348785, 0.10223560035228729, -0.6027209758758545, 0.30186527967453003, -0.5156316757202148, 0.44025567173957825, 0.060448598116636276, 0.5500403642654419, -0.579177975654602, 0.2914471924304962, 0.40572142601013184, -0.06685324758291245, 0.9522504210472107, -0.5751656889915466, -0.024472380056977272, -0.9428656101226807, -0.3182224929332733, -0.15036804974079132, 0.22741171717643738, -0.7813308835029602, -0.017427245154976845, 0.2499680370092392, -0.03503943979740143, -0.06350122392177582, 0.24144324660301208, -0.34827321767807007, -0.21148379147052765, -0.35308709740638733, -0.19196875393390656, -0.10883879661560059, -0.04155292734503746, 0.0955134853720665, 0.6681216359138489, 0.6332554817199707, -0.8151740431785583, 0.017243685200810432, 0.1061779111623764, -0.040690962225198746, 0.132921040058136, -0.8567714691162109, -0.12807391583919525, -0.09161937981843948, 0.22452153265476227, -0.8033331632614136, -0.47995221614837646, -0.5858932137489319, -0.5466586947441101, 0.3522228002548218, -0.3471115529537201, -0.7142548561096191, -0.15240280330181122, -0.43328961730003357, 0.22867028415203094, 0.8508210182189941, -0.7466051578521729, 0.7123394012451172, 0.2773706018924713, 0.2933911085128784, -0.3564845621585846, -0.9969266653060913, 0.4310973286628723, -0.4575701951980591, -0.8466879725456238, 0.08891358971595764, -0.021472269669175148, -0.6854550242424011, -0.11614067852497101, 0.019756587222218513, -0.21873721480369568, 0.1708124577999115, 0.4381600618362427, 0.007307324558496475, -0.37768253684043884, 0.2786063849925995, 0.5030049085617065, 0.2530171275138855, 0.5661443471908569, -0.2664767801761627, 0.6313728094100952, -0.30985116958618164, 0.1308690458536148, -0.08640643954277039, -0.032128363847732544, 1.2546567916870117, -0.11829157918691635, 0.8585437536239624, 0.18780158460140228, -0.357503741979599, -0.24135005474090576, -0.3028610646724701, -0.4128924012184143, -0.48141804337501526, 0.5410434007644653, -0.17122721672058105, -0.30682623386383057, 0.7582364082336426, -0.2023581862449646, -0.11627979576587677, 0.8503630757331848, 0.5253652334213257, -0.047848235815763474, 1.0799466371536255, 1.0874360799789429, 0.28200793266296387, 0.328971803188324, -0.6044791340827942, 0.06562651693820953, -0.6816468834877014, 0.08516070991754532, -0.20924487709999084, -0.21146145462989807, -0.6744030117988586, 0.08657554537057877, 0.46764636039733887, 0.2561880648136139, -0.6600417494773865, 0.4848571717739105, -0.3301931619644165, 0.7002719044685364, 0.371355801820755, 0.16406381130218506, 0.43671107292175293, 0.08306790143251419, 0.4053216278553009, 0.047868985682725906, -0.5364961624145508, -0.3936006426811218, 1.3770536184310913, 0.4830443561077118, 0.6861074566841125, -0.06464123725891113, 0.8184995055198669, 0.48060500621795654, -0.014743472449481487, -0.710997462272644, 0.361726313829422, -0.09215302765369415, -0.5708708167076111, -0.4430673122406006, -0.31750449538230896, -1.0509673357009888, -0.05606819689273834, -0.282910019159317, -0.6212782263755798, 0.20641015470027924, -0.12182832509279251, -0.17747944593429565, 0.7928528189659119, -0.5533854365348816, 0.45569345355033875, -0.3090979754924774, -0.24165557324886322, -0.5049571990966797, -0.7274411916732788, 0.44513756036758423, -0.2523286044597626, 0.11656438559293747, 0.16051757335662842, 0.0071197994984686375, 1.0777781009674072, -0.7084668874740601, 1.0984704494476318, 0.04152442887425423, -0.10820667445659637, 0.42886674404144287, 0.5163712501525879, 0.504967212677002, -0.09012340009212494, 0.10385628789663315, 0.37399065494537354, 0.19538216292858124, -0.0979665145277977, -0.5022290349006653, 0.4207495450973511, -0.9854578971862793, -0.22503499686717987, -0.2521744966506958, -0.5362446308135986, -0.13891316950321198, 0.2205873429775238, 0.5299287438392639, 0.39630237221717834, -0.04313343018293381, 0.009687031619250774, 0.5707882046699524, 0.04689117893576622, 0.518001139163971, 0.430448442697525, -0.24784548580646515, -0.33007150888442993, 0.9619764685630798, 0.43021640181541443, 0.47315362095832825, -0.13605466485023499, 0.3873654305934906, -0.11513474583625793, -0.6241699457168579, -0.43597033619880676, 0.5186527371406555, -0.7044510245323181, -0.18175438046455383, -0.3781818747520447, -0.3463728725910187, -0.26263144612312317, -0.3237009644508362, -0.5112594366073608, -0.5278010368347168, -0.3773892819881439, -0.2749179005622864, 0.5575028657913208, 1.39630126953125, -0.3986497223377228, 0.435807466506958, -0.5857823491096497, -0.23426182568073273, 0.17852042615413666, 0.05425066128373146, 0.4023595452308655, -0.7671506404876709, -0.2639671266078949, 0.10630445927381516, -0.25926458835601807, -0.8000590801239014, 0.5801430344581604, 0.12349645048379898, 0.17792610824108124, 0.6633608341217041, -0.019953884184360504, 0.41008904576301575, -0.7244171500205994, 0.5016128420829773, 0.7321199774742126, -0.8525431752204895, 0.22094641625881195, -0.7513312697410583, 0.003178875194862485, 0.1376981884241104, 0.2789369821548462, -0.7900692820549011, -0.3263944089412689, -0.8335773944854736, -0.8639242649078369, 0.44977086782455444, -0.10861285030841827, 0.5623586773872375, 0.1359628438949585, 0.5987374186515808, 0.5038933157920837, 0.06628043204545975, -0.5068553686141968, -0.1567763239145279, -0.16497831046581268, 0.09509852528572083, 0.13917215168476105, -0.19345831871032715, 0.25914162397384644, -0.29926028847694397, 0.2158130258321762, 0.05325638875365257, 0.17127519845962524, -0.28345155715942383, 0.0025023831985890865, -0.31404170393943787, -0.025618355721235275, 0.41953450441360474, 0.8122798204421997, -0.05555320903658867, -0.05139247328042984, 0.07661297917366028, -0.6866607666015625, 0.22364281117916107, -0.3517203629016876, -0.4546777307987213, -0.43935051560401917, 0.6251452565193176, 0.6802610158920288, 0.1589316725730896, -0.6885643005371094, 0.19432812929153442, -0.05089050158858299, -0.5750875473022461, -0.5052615404129028, 0.11196571588516235, 0.055051807314157486, 0.1918499767780304, 0.6942325234413147, 0.1738629788160324, 0.05516032129526138, -0.7293625473976135, 0.3952067792415619, -0.02002788707613945, -0.0011700147297233343, -0.5460988283157349, 1.0422860383987427, -0.061732687056064606, -0.2098909467458725, 0.8072430491447449, 0.021472111344337463, -0.42187774181365967, 0.8917570114135742, 0.7661350965499878, 0.7308048009872437, -0.10199450701475143, 0.35904842615127563, 0.6638038754463196, 0.6121774315834045, -0.7345515489578247, -0.4908197522163391, 0.14780110120773315, -0.6231106519699097, -0.42036277055740356, -0.3643559217453003, -0.39648690819740295, 0.28986743092536926, -0.734626293182373, 0.2317809760570526, -0.670041561126709, -0.12563931941986084, -0.09427341818809509, -0.156793475151062, -0.19868358969688416, 0.28863510489463806, 0.16033171117305756, 0.6618377566337585, -1.0373246669769287, 0.4840298593044281, 0.3043961524963379, -1.0819227695465088, -0.31738007068634033, 0.33252307772636414, 0.09493588656187057, -0.7490856051445007, 0.8190503120422363, 0.25026020407676697, -0.1528935730457306, 0.0604986809194088, -0.7404518127441406, -1.045850396156311, 1.0159283876419067, 0.7882052063941956, -0.41423386335372925, -0.4145210385322571, 0.04333119839429855, 0.7390412092208862, -0.26853621006011963, 0.19995705783367157, 0.8106082677841187, 0.30910858511924744, 0.0041922880336642265, -0.9822824001312256, -0.0842600166797638, 0.12468365579843521, -0.3193392753601074, 0.35764890909194946, -0.5919646620750427, 1.310288906097412, -0.6399680376052856, -0.2559981644153595, 0.17523901164531708, 0.5200985074043274, -0.38402482867240906, 0.14459441602230072, 0.43776392936706543, 0.5013490915298462, 0.6273732781410217, 0.059506457298994064, 1.1341995000839233, -0.17134039103984833, 0.4564094841480255, 0.7629345059394836, -0.07280076295137405, 0.9575265049934387, 0.2975288927555084, -0.4149985611438751, 0.4611603617668152, 0.6680315136909485, -0.14919611811637878, 0.1280519813299179, 0.2399020940065384, 0.2500765025615692, -0.31170523166656494, 0.1799510419368744, -0.1415526121854782, 0.46048080921173096, 0.2791977524757385, -0.28415045142173767, -0.31866008043289185, 0.15230779349803925, 0.24504925310611725, 0.12040252983570099, -0.4855661690235138, 0.4759426414966583, -0.08933091163635254, -0.23123590648174286, 0.8059554696083069, -0.04500064626336098, 0.33969566226005554, -0.5160295963287354, -0.0950184017419815, -0.309109628200531, 0.35887059569358826, -0.21592149138450623, -0.5972874164581299, 0.3568863570690155, -0.15495939552783966, -0.29225823283195496, -0.09169162064790726, 0.5101162791252136, -0.24453642964363098, -0.6245487332344055, 0.4581553637981415, 0.2990559935569763, 0.2695387601852417, -0.1754598766565323, -0.27301254868507385, 0.273729145526886, -0.19641238451004028, -0.15551140904426575, 0.5806019902229309, 0.09914471209049225, 0.03882761672139168, 0.8391092419624329, 0.26984086632728577, 0.12064845114946365, 0.116613008081913, -0.3496541678905487, 0.7644657492637634, -0.49362120032310486, -0.5024669170379639, -0.7191491723060608, 0.46152007579803467, -0.14751607179641724, -0.14192089438438416, 0.7311303019523621, 0.3373398184776306, 0.6295021772384644, 0.05463491007685661, 0.8370693922042847, -0.13345769047737122, 0.2703472375869751, -0.3881409168243408, 1.400948166847229, -0.964876651763916, 0.0491158552467823, 0.1324632614850998, -0.57696133852005, -0.14395669102668762, 0.4586290717124939, -0.24696747958660126, 0.08540857583284378, 0.7329987287521362, 0.2867160141468048, 0.016180751845240593, -0.035661112517118454, 0.38343003392219543, 0.4917079508304596, 0.2520446181297302, 0.15139901638031006, 0.37010082602500916, -0.440353661775589, 0.6860425472259521, -0.1527322232723236, -0.10728047043085098, -0.3773643672466278, -0.5902640223503113, -0.8076361417770386, -1.0976905822753906, -0.37432244420051575, -0.5099787712097168, -0.16154666244983673, 0.4593435525894165, 0.455534428358078, -0.4242333173751831, -0.5333971977233887, -0.42985501885414124, -0.07042381167411804, -0.487861305475235, -0.14112915098667145, 0.43363815546035767, -0.42416009306907654, -0.40632304549217224, 0.32237717509269714, 0.056713979691267014, 0.3442983627319336, -0.45402905344963074, -0.12540028989315033, 0.2854613959789276, 0.2206815630197525, 0.4051361382007599, 0.5637226104736328, -0.5498917102813721, 0.17378947138786316, -0.13618600368499756, 0.1370161771774292, 0.09563585370779037, 0.9067710041999817, -0.7599354982376099, 0.523470401763916, 0.2735605835914612, 0.7086729407310486, 0.5420377850532532, -0.26244011521339417, 0.669838011264801, -0.3336067497730255, -0.11143556237220764, 0.07308676838874817, 0.35402125120162964, 0.018741417676210403, -0.30264461040496826, 0.5799616575241089, 0.2266867607831955, -0.4199301600456238, -1.280869722366333, 0.15632596611976624, -0.5541890263557434, -0.38257062435150146, 0.7981609106063843, 0.35253480076789856, -0.5192228555679321, 0.29742613434791565, 0.0005277085001580417, 0.15751047432422638, -0.2878100574016571, 0.8585581183433533, 0.6355533003807068, -0.3851192593574524, -0.029107071459293365, -0.6873220801353455, 0.3103322982788086, 0.13475611805915833, -0.4327969253063202, 0.8080332279205322, 0.4772045612335205, 0.34482210874557495, 0.2554539740085602, 0.05712563171982765, -0.007974662818014622, 0.291138231754303, 0.6337009072303772, -0.062101811170578, -0.16158181428909302, -0.3583911955356598, -0.629715085029602, 0.09971325844526291, 0.07700104266405106, 0.2544166147708893 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07028v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07028v1	Semi-Supervised Learning for Bilingual Lexicon Induction	2024-02-10T19:27:22	2024-02-10T19:27:22	Paul Garnier, Gauthier Guinet	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.LG	We consider the problem of aligning two sets of continuous word representations, corresponding to languages, to a common space in order to infer a bilingual lexicon. It was recently shown that it is possible to infer such lexicon, without using any parallel data, by aligning word embeddings trained on monolingual data. Such line of work is called unsupervised bilingual induction. By wondering whether it was possible to gain experience in the progressive learning of several languages, we asked ourselves to what extent we could integrate the knowledge of a given set of languages when learning a new one, without having parallel data for the latter. In other words, while keeping the core problem of unsupervised learning in the latest step, we allowed the access to other corpora of idioms, hence the name semi-supervised. This led us to propose a novel formulation, considering the lexicon induction as a ranking problem for which we used recent tools of this machine learning field. Our experiments on standard benchmarks, inferring dictionary from English to more than 20 languages, show that our approach consistently outperforms existing state of the art benchmark. In addition, we deduce from this new scenario several relevant conclusions allowing a better understanding of the alignment phenomenon.	[ -0.3669378161430359, -0.49118030071258545, 0.46694129705429077, 0.30456095933914185, -0.19624432921409607, 0.2968105971813202, -0.5545192956924438, -0.3843073844909668, 0.2806759178638458, 0.24696633219718933, -0.26855388283729553, -0.576341450214386, -0.6306833624839783, 0.2918200194835663, -0.6035940647125244, 0.765125572681427, -0.1638360470533371, 0.1898874044418335, -0.5937789082527161, -0.43771934509277344, -0.289149671792984, -0.3305091857910156, -0.3846862018108368, -0.5472292900085449, 0.23105059564113617, 0.5176699161529541, 0.6270564794540405, 0.7101880311965942, 0.12195144593715668, 0.3335953652858734, -0.2463930994272232, 0.32910847663879395, -0.19511429965496063, -0.19020652770996094, -0.2783951759338379, -0.5111507773399353, -0.02960970811545849, -0.01949213445186615, 0.8749129772186279, 1.4437015056610107, -0.29536810517311096, -0.05418338254094124, 0.2533150911331177, 0.636721670627594, -0.5866279602050781, 0.27065712213516235, -0.5203959345817566, 0.28526440262794495, -0.40303611755371094, -0.12150969356298447, -0.4012044072151184, -0.045589249581098557, 0.05270220711827278, -0.5845646858215332, 0.23946872353553772, -0.041445329785346985, 0.619409441947937, 0.10856148600578308, -0.4275405704975128, -0.26044654846191406, -0.6868581175804138, 0.7766392827033997, -0.2391892373561859, 0.4587831497192383, 0.14008668065071106, 0.189557746052742, -0.23474553227424622, -0.5691219568252563, -0.5377140641212463, 0.02612951211631298, -0.026747023686766624, 0.45074474811553955, 0.0814039334654808, -0.151263028383255, 0.10898411273956299, 0.4039904773235321, -0.5000790953636169, 0.5516760945320129, -0.41724270582199097, -0.17037971317768097, 0.5671449303627014, 0.01667204685509205, 0.3595123291015625, 0.21723975241184235, -0.42956188321113586, 0.05489080399274826, -0.6909142136573792, 0.25594303011894226, 0.4557214081287384, 0.44490447640419006, -0.22858186066150665, 0.7041385173797607, -0.3006151616573334, 0.583918571472168, 0.029915597289800644, 0.010464290156960487, 0.5180234313011169, -0.5129396915435791, 0.21886758506298065, 0.38199979066848755, 0.8801637291908264, 0.2678649425506592, 0.5361870527267456, -0.47849148511886597, -0.3488599956035614, 0.28451070189476013, 0.0004984379047527909, -0.2106073796749115, -0.013437078334391117, -0.07858871668577194, -0.07243306189775467, -0.31839412450790405, 0.3574436902999878, -0.7943321466445923, -0.1594286412000656, -0.3053363263607025, 0.2704090178012848, 0.02556261047720909, -0.23415552079677582, 0.08653304725885391, -0.2637538015842438, 0.025556158274412155, -0.11630814522504807, -1.1665033102035522, 0.33528000116348267, 0.629734218120575, 0.7474521994590759, -0.4834103584289551, -0.6159120798110962, -0.3974930942058563, 0.19861887395381927, -0.6508888602256775, 0.7195043563842773, -0.5848474502563477, -0.45988133549690247, 0.5249268412590027, 0.19050614535808563, 0.021735072135925293, -0.7956322431564331, 0.2878898084163666, -0.38892602920532227, 0.36176908016204834, 0.006279902998358011, -0.5984148979187012, 0.21809841692447662, -0.010045059956610203, -0.49237382411956787, 1.131859540939331, 0.12586790323257446, -0.9374703764915466, 0.4721640944480896, -0.3646013140678406, -0.7338649034500122, -0.0058545907959342, -0.2726546823978424, -0.14891406893730164, 0.21638526022434235, 0.3650069832801819, 0.256215900182724, -0.2297288328409195, 0.33680903911590576, -0.23094038665294647, -0.10683974623680115, 0.055777013301849365, 0.08416537195444107, 1.1333743333816528, -0.12580257654190063, -0.287099152803421, -0.31583744287490845, -0.40441077947616577, -0.2591116726398468, 0.08399584144353867, -0.18359170854091644, -0.6053879857063293, -0.14088650047779083, -0.36250659823417664, 0.008425215259194374, 0.3232001066207886, -0.8564478158950806, 0.06991066783666611, -0.6888207197189331, 0.09192141890525818, 0.6574172973632812, -0.08600805699825287, 0.9580538272857666, -0.017606694251298904, 0.24707870185375214, 0.3221813440322876, 0.06997693330049515, 0.22241705656051636, -0.4658156931400299, -0.6267410516738892, -0.1899416595697403, 0.7519158124923706, 0.5656315684318542, -0.7607694864273071, 0.5701462626457214, -0.21819303929805756, -0.36960771679878235, -0.5160996913909912, 0.6302124857902527, 0.38473719358444214, 0.6864519715309143, 0.3971385061740875, -0.33578774333000183, -0.444396436214447, -1.060848355293274, -0.27365565299987793, 0.08863891661167145, -0.012186486274003983, -0.20824933052062988, 0.3051445186138153, -0.24473139643669128, 0.8014944791793823, -0.20605449378490448, -0.2405654639005661, -0.28755635023117065, 0.32557547092437744, 0.26726970076560974, 0.4461738169193268, 0.2995319366455078, -0.784341037273407, -0.7383110523223877, 0.22486990690231323, -1.034037709236145, -0.2386246621608734, 0.09903479367494583, -0.09833050519227982, 0.20617784559726715, 0.7139718532562256, -0.2640775144100189, 0.26267921924591064, 0.5630978941917419, 0.09695141762495041, 0.13421230018138885, -0.47205254435539246, -0.3955351412296295, -1.2129032611846924, -0.42609432339668274, 0.13080279529094696, -0.16332171857357025, -0.5171182155609131, -0.31861841678619385, 0.36835145950317383, 0.055054955184459686, -0.43514731526374817, 0.45771700143814087, -0.6833301186561584, -0.11511849611997604, -0.18343766033649445, 0.13044516742229462, -0.3817872405052185, 0.43464183807373047, 0.2728615701198578, 0.7428559064865112, 0.9870662093162537, -0.6522549390792847, 0.4890461564064026, 0.15624180436134338, -0.3931981325149536, 0.3357405662536621, -0.27541419863700867, -0.12495788186788559, -0.2950311601161957, -0.018715152516961098, -0.7706423997879028, 0.044560521841049194, -0.2501409947872162, -0.33938807249069214, 0.5730313062667847, 0.04373364895582199, -0.6959623098373413, -0.25898122787475586, -0.2286173552274704, 0.5569514036178589, 0.500074565410614, -0.908173143863678, 0.1935640126466751, 0.8211628198623657, -0.004584259819239378, -0.6705995798110962, -0.7187812924385071, -0.178298220038414, -0.1667204648256302, -0.3738091289997101, 0.49458980560302734, 0.3532608449459076, -0.3459138870239258, 0.15702952444553375, -0.18557919561862946, 0.0924120843410492, 0.03642416000366211, 0.07285533100366592, 0.25241801142692566, 0.020196789875626564, 0.14422762393951416, 0.4193333685398102, -0.3283133804798126, -0.032300688326358795, -0.49514469504356384, 0.2981022894382477, -0.012843407690525055, -0.3932439982891083, -0.46234220266342163, 0.5371333360671997, 0.4744037091732025, -0.44043540954589844, 0.8162651062011719, 0.3180147111415863, -0.5825525522232056, -0.5193047523498535, -0.23332691192626953, 0.0939679741859436, -0.4152994155883789, 0.08614587038755417, -0.14830738306045532, -0.690898597240448, 0.5032708048820496, -0.32698288559913635, 0.063045434653759, 0.5184828639030457, 0.8833646774291992, -0.29540279507637024, 1.2492314577102661, 0.8876894116401672, -0.16147279739379883, 0.4541926980018616, -0.2987024486064911, 0.26197952032089233, -0.5640271306037903, -0.5422266721725464, -0.4708172678947449, -0.2501574754714966, -0.9415111541748047, -0.21353119611740112, 0.3844437003135681, -0.050909485667943954, 0.09900154918432236, 0.41289910674095154, -0.2133556753396988, 0.38195857405662537, 0.5799344182014465, -0.05609208717942238, 0.2474345713853836, 0.04935381934046745, -0.8118137717247009, 0.17382392287254333, -0.7313331961631775, -0.25961968302726746, 1.0982035398483276, 0.00020063012198079377, 0.8215441703796387, -0.021061928942799568, 1.0551581382751465, 0.20009471476078033, 0.06197424232959747, -0.677719235420227, 0.33457595109939575, -0.15942031145095825, -0.5730485320091248, -0.2890318036079407, -0.22642821073532104, -0.9523532390594482, 0.0009230348514392972, -0.1592927873134613, -0.7480283975601196, 0.2916605770587921, -0.0868120864033699, -0.014582040719687939, 0.09764089435338974, -0.7448252439498901, 0.9669492244720459, -0.41454336047172546, -0.44495466351509094, -0.08418922126293182, -0.6182047128677368, 0.13936658203601837, -0.2577388882637024, 0.3423632085323334, -0.016869518905878067, -0.0999513640999794, 0.9074966311454773, -0.4710146486759186, 0.7032877206802368, -0.203287735581398, 0.06011981889605522, 0.08442768454551697, -0.2038595825433731, 0.17200222611427307, 0.27974849939346313, 0.25360915064811707, 0.20463766157627106, 0.26148727536201477, -0.6388888359069824, -0.5249802470207214, 0.7565023303031921, -0.7687883377075195, -0.4643349051475525, -0.5470061898231506, -0.8263809084892273, -0.6126258969306946, 0.182000994682312, 0.4535985589027405, 0.3538799285888672, -0.091191865503788, 0.07593464851379395, 0.7310426831245422, 0.09825330972671509, 0.4378080666065216, 0.34155961871147156, -0.3410707116127014, -0.14861825108528137, 0.7612478137016296, 0.21976134181022644, 0.149309903383255, 0.6592661142349243, 0.2900291383266449, -0.6682427525520325, -0.5125030875205994, -0.3176267147064209, 0.43430042266845703, -0.43615394830703735, 0.003010764252394438, -0.3500564396381378, -0.08968539535999298, -0.3557795286178589, -0.09711554646492004, -0.5889279246330261, -0.39389684796333313, -0.0863146185874939, -0.11370265483856201, -0.21995553374290466, 0.5407239198684692, -0.11691223084926605, 0.0341869555413723, -0.705451250076294, 0.3011537790298462, 0.3726668059825897, 0.14098213613033295, -0.3353137969970703, -0.6108153462409973, -0.4085509777069092, 0.16691215336322784, -0.17312705516815186, -0.8169683218002319, 0.1077386811375618, 0.18984311819076538, 0.9441767930984497, 0.7396153211593628, 0.14941810071468353, 0.6227277517318726, -0.6222743988037109, 0.5022523403167725, 0.3389143645763397, -0.7197148203849792, 0.44453784823417664, -0.06602165848016739, 0.11472778022289276, 0.5586594939231873, 0.7291612029075623, -0.44774577021598816, -0.6611723303794861, -0.7369363903999329, -0.5514851212501526, 0.4046407639980316, 0.011434105224907398, 0.2574903964996338, -0.1878225952386856, 0.08277352154254913, 0.3717605173587799, 0.05153162404894829, -0.38032856583595276, -0.13356566429138184, 0.024193840101361275, -0.3499322235584259, -0.45562344789505005, -0.12704713642597198, -0.2808510363101959, -0.6662643551826477, 0.6516326069831848, -0.10918699204921722, 0.15173545479774475, -0.14234322309494019, -0.44080108404159546, -0.06358474493026733, 0.10148627310991287, 0.18433557450771332, 0.9305245876312256, 0.09542956948280334, 0.37733837962150574, 0.32752400636672974, 0.04256090149283409, 0.07686349004507065, 0.1860416978597641, -0.11187416315078735, 0.2091490477323532, 0.43813052773475647, 0.4727065861225128, 0.1674056351184845, -0.5955203771591187, 0.6484270095825195, 0.06447193026542664, -0.3207275867462158, -0.42703455686569214, -0.23548901081085205, 0.2737385034561157, 0.28553295135498047, 0.199522003531456, -0.3126673996448517, -0.18847407400608063, -0.799305260181427, 0.2578262686729431, 0.6960271000862122, -0.28851014375686646, -0.4365006983280182, 0.5586100220680237, 0.1038578674197197, -0.22422833740711212, 0.7736582159996033, -0.20421941578388214, -0.7147525548934937, 0.39659881591796875, 0.9234033823013306, 0.6220971941947937, -0.15383543074131012, 0.2066507190465927, 0.36172810196876526, 0.23134689033031464, -0.3299705982208252, 0.18995341658592224, -0.44894593954086304, -1.0908000469207764, -0.19987592101097107, -0.6588850021362305, -0.4385792315006256, -0.32126110792160034, -0.8329919576644897, 0.36035969853401184, -0.1490551233291626, 0.1957477331161499, 0.1847684532403946, -0.10505585372447968, -0.5802298188209534, -0.14864882826805115, 0.4797745943069458, 1.0642077922821045, -1.5261907577514648, 1.0715802907943726, 1.1431297063827515, -0.308915376663208, -0.6514632105827332, 0.018192622810602188, -0.09001615643501282, -0.9363253712654114, 0.30777519941329956, 0.17438410222530365, 0.06583451479673386, 0.005289488472044468, -0.2394239902496338, -0.4092174470424652, 0.8608894944190979, 0.28149375319480896, -0.29972919821739197, -0.046634212136268616, 0.3179607391357422, 0.6687543392181396, -0.4500940442085266, -0.12551695108413696, 0.6206799745559692, 0.27031564712524414, -0.1184941828250885, -0.8565673828125, -0.28954386711120605, -0.17891661822795868, 0.06090041995048523, 0.49639394879341125, -0.33908018469810486, 0.4107729196548462, -0.009006303735077381, -0.22785279154777527, -0.10692032426595688, 0.8918259143829346, -0.18535587191581726, 0.4272908568382263, 0.6485531330108643, 0.8762435913085938, 0.7784011363983154, -0.2135634571313858, 0.8616251349449158, -0.23946267366409302, 0.4434501826763153, 0.7219682335853577, -0.2160014659166336, 0.5937293767929077, 0.8902661800384521, -0.2544562518596649, 0.46461862325668335, 0.7659502625465393, 0.1748911291360855, 0.8076086044311523, -0.06513063609600067, -0.39108818769454956, -0.3636838495731354, -0.3684996962547302, -0.12217720597982407, 0.6261265873908997, 0.19425638020038605, -0.26058611273765564, -0.606829047203064, 0.1883557140827179, -0.13897480070590973, 0.4837649166584015, -0.31540948152542114, 0.8129861354827881, -0.003488118527457118, -0.8522222638130188, 0.5595628619194031, -0.15143026411533356, 0.6163719892501831, -0.4604654312133789, 0.17650945484638214, -0.5013471245765686, 0.19460724294185638, -0.365914523601532, -0.8540266156196594, 0.19020119309425354, 0.04377627745270729, -0.05273371562361717, -0.40156814455986023, 0.19029642641544342, -0.7127447128295898, -0.626379132270813, 0.47182971239089966, 0.6954857707023621, 0.20667387545108795, 0.30481377243995667, -0.41020333766937256, -0.4387855529785156, -0.11944001913070679, 0.22658579051494598, 0.47336816787719727, 0.5974369049072266, -0.32983970642089844, 0.31159263849258423, 0.4874802827835083, 0.23120993375778198, 0.4533824920654297, 0.1514841914176941, 0.7752999067306519, -0.4233973026275635, -0.5679868459701538, -0.6860412359237671, 0.37465688586235046, -0.08262716233730316, -0.017917711287736893, 0.683942437171936, 0.8537454009056091, 1.4756205081939697, 0.040014658123254776, 0.6438736319541931, -0.03188927471637726, 0.5912492871284485, -0.40092232823371887, 0.2028493881225586, -0.8370193839073181, 0.0431017205119133, 0.07637451589107513, -1.0044571161270142, -0.38994109630584717, 0.23111523687839508, -0.20227064192295074, -0.30474063754081726, 1.0057475566864014, 0.9405903220176697, -0.2928961515426636, -0.049665190279483795, 0.26136571168899536, -0.12818804383277893, -0.08404482156038284, 0.40366077423095703, 0.9459512233734131, 0.0024527248460799456, 0.39098742604255676, -0.962921679019928, -0.44059890508651733, 0.15920324623584747, -0.6813580393791199, -0.9089305400848389, -0.8762341737747192, -0.21608677506446838, -0.1587933599948883, -0.04074492305517197, 0.8294517397880554, 0.204759880900383, -0.9248656630516052, -0.45005300641059875, -0.32058852910995483, 0.2786557674407959, -0.5061869025230408, -0.09327374398708344, 0.25060248374938965, -0.6555055975914001, -1.2725282907485962, 0.4574388563632965, 0.2619800567626953, -0.2179577350616455, -0.12158214300870895, -0.0579865425825119, -0.6358293890953064, -0.37755003571510315, 0.33267948031425476, 0.630108118057251, -0.3859085440635681, -0.09048087149858475, -0.19422462582588196, -0.06807342171669006, 0.16192293167114258, 0.6282585263252258, -0.7096952199935913, 0.8549743294715881, 0.5373779535293579, 0.9453598856925964, 0.56004798412323, -0.0841323509812355, 0.446285605430603, -0.8278271555900574, 0.4337855875492096, 0.16684281826019287, 0.664335310459137, 0.2672014534473419, 0.02751348726451397, 0.2641150653362274, 0.3877848982810974, -0.2517158091068268, -0.974062442779541, 0.07179738581180573, -0.9219866991043091, 0.10851216316223145, 1.0446302890777588, 0.11303360760211945, -0.36630356311798096, -0.06107303500175476, 0.35550811886787415, 0.6432157158851624, 0.00932371336966753, 0.6830564141273499, 0.5627959966659546, -0.2089768350124359, 0.08551447093486786, -0.48136579990386963, 0.1785358488559723, 0.5870186686515808, -0.4541427493095398, -0.02501911297440529, -0.0010074765887111425, 0.24838928878307343, 0.2818054258823395, 0.238040953874588, -0.4021094739437103, 0.2550329566001892, -0.14443998038768768, 0.04368127882480621, 0.04065743088722229, -0.4768097400665283, -0.39448198676109314, 0.009048824198544025, 0.2119525820016861, -0.6404675245285034 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07023v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07023v1	Gemini Goes to Med School: Exploring the Capabilities of Multimodal Large Language Models on Medical Challenge Problems & Hallucinations	2024-02-10T19:08:28	2024-02-10T19:08:28	Ankit Pal, Malaikannan Sankarasubbu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG	Large language models have the potential to be valuable in the healthcare industry, but it's crucial to verify their safety and effectiveness through rigorous evaluation. For this purpose, we comprehensively evaluated both open-source LLMs and Google's new multimodal LLM called Gemini across Medical reasoning, hallucination detection, and Medical Visual Question Answering tasks. While Gemini showed competence, it lagged behind state-of-the-art models like MedPaLM 2 and GPT-4 in diagnostic accuracy. Additionally, Gemini achieved an accuracy of 61.45\% on the medical VQA dataset, significantly lower than GPT-4V's score of 88\%. Our analysis revealed that Gemini is highly susceptible to hallucinations, overconfidence, and knowledge gaps, which indicate risks if deployed uncritically. We also performed a detailed analysis by medical subject and test type, providing actionable feedback for developers and clinicians. To mitigate risks, we applied prompting strategies that improved performance. Additionally, we facilitated future research and development by releasing a Python module for medical LLM evaluation and establishing a dedicated leaderboard on Hugging Face for medical domain LLMs. Python module can be found at https://github.com/promptslab/RosettaEval	[ -0.22100801765918732, -0.8935218453407288, 0.917563259601593, 0.19735804200172424, 0.017610149458050728, -0.03360481187701225, -0.20639146864414215, -0.5235523581504822, 0.28990769386291504, 0.5169423818588257, -0.7235864996910095, -0.7096860408782959, -0.8860694766044617, 0.05273568630218506, -0.39621978998184204, 1.0325472354888916, 0.03177948296070099, 0.4456619322299957, -0.4372878074645996, 0.024208199232816696, -0.3261907398700714, -0.7699888348579407, -0.5663681030273438, -0.18692006170749664, 0.7045005559921265, 0.04327106103301048, 0.853563666343689, 0.2623482942581177, 0.8121865391731262, 0.33988648653030396, -0.15187007188796997, 0.0949506163597107, -0.08969445526599884, 0.3494162857532501, -0.13610070943832397, -0.2867491841316223, -0.495317667722702, 0.03899439424276352, 0.35286906361579895, 0.6801229119300842, -0.32621654868125916, -0.05401362106204033, -0.32212087512016296, 0.7439330816268921, -0.39823225140571594, 0.13105420768260956, -0.44436150789260864, 0.045131225138902664, -0.01025453396141529, 0.04676064848899841, -0.27541300654411316, -0.33172163367271423, 0.26362770795822144, -0.45797717571258545, -0.15845605731010437, -0.15264390408992767, 0.5444688200950623, 0.5725629925727844, -0.49253445863723755, -0.5588372349739075, -0.360585480928421, 0.5668111443519592, -0.4186848998069763, 0.30232495069503784, 0.08515764772891998, 0.5188524723052979, -0.38500791788101196, -0.9763674139976501, -0.4274412989616394, -0.5649030208587646, 0.43291592597961426, 0.23738005757331848, 0.01748659834265709, 0.13147729635238647, 0.12072981148958206, 0.3275856077671051, -0.5098374485969543, 0.10524599254131317, -0.5345855951309204, -0.3418598473072052, 0.31655070185661316, 0.25761210918426514, 0.4193724989891052, -0.08726625144481659, -0.19954383373260498, -0.026342129334807396, -0.48923686146736145, -0.1276891976594925, -0.057386353611946106, -0.03133436292409897, -0.08457385003566742, 0.8854848146438599, 0.24325458705425262, 0.4889473617076874, -0.2081201821565628, -0.23874761164188385, 0.4370028078556061, -0.17308266460895538, -0.17602749168872833, -0.09132843464612961, 0.7916602492332458, 0.32847580313682556, 0.19418472051620483, -0.12138595432043076, -0.1264348328113556, 0.4697880148887634, 0.670082151889801, -0.641258955001831, -0.19966480135917664, 0.6215089559555054, -0.7314989566802979, -0.2774362564086914, -0.2131887823343277, -0.5769466161727905, -0.7758181691169739, -0.23921553790569305, 0.5819361209869385, -0.5962409377098083, -0.09211225807666779, 0.3490516245365143, 0.007715264800935984, -0.034145791083574295, 0.4065057933330536, -0.777425229549408, 0.1836872547864914, 0.9794564247131348, 0.7945706844329834, -0.407962828874588, -0.17633149027824402, -0.4152175486087799, -0.3695964813232422, -0.3479821979999542, 0.4733556807041168, -0.3387959599494934, -0.3714190721511841, -0.027720658108592033, -0.014528662897646427, -0.1824340969324112, -0.8211163282394409, 0.5570277571678162, -0.07542210072278976, 0.24662993848323822, 0.004310416989028454, -0.2863844633102417, -0.056560076773166656, 0.5007521510124207, -0.4016534686088562, 0.7137352824211121, 0.2451901137828827, -0.4801555275917053, 0.01324766781181097, -0.5920351147651672, -0.3238197863101959, -0.12416960299015045, -0.3676897883415222, -0.31849151849746704, 0.27986133098602295, 0.2963043451309204, 0.5490251779556274, -0.2480027824640274, 0.4096243381500244, -0.23939019441604614, -0.27990081906318665, 0.5713216066360474, -0.2701386511325836, 0.5359621047973633, 0.1283644139766693, -0.16043569147586823, 0.4746965169906616, -0.67376708984375, 0.005143584217876196, -0.0033746380358934402, -0.3438040614128113, -0.134822815656662, -0.1261831521987915, 0.1398463100194931, 0.502521812915802, 0.06900802999734879, -0.36260175704956055, 0.2825855314731598, -0.4760076105594635, 0.4564567804336548, 0.5367761850357056, -0.08839385956525803, -0.0923566222190857, -0.3343769609928131, 0.5976197123527527, 0.0991903617978096, 0.7611014246940613, -0.12800395488739014, -0.9453787803649902, -0.5706811547279358, -0.41725030541419983, 0.028869641944766045, 0.5233225226402283, -0.8657346367835999, 0.13790595531463623, 0.08022277802228928, -0.5955759882926941, -0.9038523435592651, -0.01955460011959076, 0.4145933985710144, 0.6577644348144531, 0.3540100157260895, -0.3077288269996643, -0.32345032691955566, -0.8530635237693787, -0.15719598531723022, -0.12810581922531128, 0.030602984130382538, 0.2980470657348633, 0.7385433316230774, -0.8962832689285278, 0.2044459879398346, -0.27067357301712036, -0.3098090589046478, -0.05255477875471115, -0.06560752540826797, 0.41161513328552246, 0.22835087776184082, 0.3884700834751129, -0.7029496431350708, -0.15348444879055023, -0.09527645260095596, -0.7737097144126892, 0.007103392854332924, -0.020468248054385185, 0.06599171459674835, 0.4252621829509735, 0.35106930136680603, -0.7606852650642395, 0.19785191118717194, 1.023569107055664, -0.47085222601890564, 0.7378624081611633, -0.3624977469444275, 0.21248826384544373, -1.0943573713302612, 0.037294451147317886, 0.023194385692477226, -0.054762307554483414, -0.4608829915523529, 0.08357313275337219, 0.07898356020450592, -0.14132793247699738, -0.3956681787967682, 0.4509013593196869, -0.2544930577278137, 0.06910478323698044, -0.3252579867839813, 0.216023787856102, -0.30593228340148926, -0.13809262216091156, -0.08138411492109299, 0.5924867987632751, 0.9496181011199951, -0.3507099151611328, 0.6314694881439209, 0.04735655337572098, -0.4985569417476654, 0.41949793696403503, -0.4611811637878418, -0.008017503656446934, -0.13509532809257507, -0.0026168806944042444, -0.9260600209236145, -0.3132917881011963, 0.395918607711792, -0.6492615938186646, 0.25305119156837463, 0.1632741540670395, -0.454241007566452, -0.5724443793296814, -0.32290077209472656, -0.06491744518280029, 0.5260536670684814, -0.47799861431121826, 0.5981763005256653, 0.4763199985027313, -0.14915509521961212, -0.8053455352783203, -0.5327680706977844, 0.34583398699760437, 0.04209347069263458, -0.6787385940551758, 0.3241852819919586, -0.21443919837474823, -0.35815414786338806, -0.09573210030794144, -0.17735832929611206, 0.04861835762858391, 0.23137767612934113, 0.5422837138175964, 0.7692704796791077, -0.16595345735549927, 0.06828708946704865, 0.012130038812756538, -0.25856927037239075, 0.5133808255195618, -0.023547662422060966, 0.48646628856658936, -0.2901048958301544, -0.48437151312828064, -0.43084147572517395, 0.0913524478673935, 0.9831512570381165, 0.18536658585071564, 0.8371681571006775, 0.6246381998062134, -0.45448407530784607, 0.045873623341321945, -0.6576672196388245, -0.2977437376976013, -0.4384802579879761, 0.5384006500244141, -0.15923969447612762, -0.8519067168235779, 0.28401851654052734, -0.032888494431972504, -0.07502122968435287, 0.4271910488605499, 0.8758267164230347, -0.21006156504154205, 1.0913060903549194, 0.45244425535202026, -0.027795275673270226, 0.001351742073893547, 0.04957742244005203, 0.025735585018992424, -0.7087043523788452, -0.7095754146575928, -0.3493078649044037, -0.10702843219041824, -0.6272677779197693, -0.6012772917747498, 0.7549063563346863, -0.4432118237018585, 0.0717671662569046, -0.1872449666261673, -0.6388265490531921, 0.22806160151958466, 0.4438316524028778, 0.09864188730716705, 0.23319044709205627, -0.1636737436056137, -0.26350194215774536, -0.15497605502605438, -0.3929549753665924, -0.26454639434814453, 1.2564008235931396, 0.5076472759246826, 0.9747592210769653, 0.0014799529453739524, 0.47976958751678467, -0.04687917232513428, 0.7596566081047058, -1.0600624084472656, 0.476368248462677, -0.2535746097564697, -0.7735589146614075, -0.0620998777449131, -0.5141555070877075, -0.7512866854667664, 0.3366871178150177, -0.4655689597129822, -0.5799992084503174, -0.43177253007888794, -0.11679240316152573, -0.3094863295555115, -0.02931416966021061, -0.5495920181274414, 0.6748201847076416, -0.5416994094848633, -0.20139260590076447, -0.2815180718898773, -0.8980154395103455, 0.49450188875198364, -0.24009935557842255, 0.33097177743911743, 0.0581013523042202, -0.22136664390563965, 0.46549293398857117, -0.15619735419750214, 0.783173680305481, 0.0473252609372139, -0.0966937392950058, -0.06933203339576721, -0.0010761984158307314, -0.015523736365139484, 0.150050088763237, 0.05407547578215599, 0.31578758358955383, 0.1537965089082718, 0.0008005326963029802, -0.5525223612785339, 1.0128720998764038, -0.8184100389480591, -0.675394594669342, -0.6802370548248291, -0.6150707006454468, -0.31672143936157227, -0.002310423646122217, 0.14419692754745483, 0.13091112673282623, -0.08056023716926575, 0.11825232952833176, 0.7206653356552124, -0.6423355340957642, 0.042530495673418045, 0.34114253520965576, -0.4690629541873932, -0.7874764204025269, 0.5319774150848389, -0.07834824919700623, 0.15923607349395752, 0.010463093407452106, 0.3056378960609436, -0.44868990778923035, -0.6423364877700806, -0.3532051742076874, 0.6605773568153381, -0.7169710397720337, 0.23002785444259644, -0.6607488393783569, -0.48056697845458984, -0.6196961402893066, -0.0420108325779438, -0.49754154682159424, -0.31284523010253906, -0.14617715775966644, 0.18963633477687836, 0.09082622826099396, 0.6840577125549316, 0.27977943420410156, -0.008049019612371922, -0.8250122666358948, 0.41449710726737976, 0.0362747497856617, 0.3041607737541199, -0.3471102714538574, -0.35431045293807983, 0.005022983066737652, -0.3701983392238617, -0.42156141996383667, -0.7140952944755554, 0.2813134789466858, -0.25554099678993225, 0.6590445041656494, 0.6012409925460815, -0.31591877341270447, 0.5682034492492676, -0.29064038395881653, 0.8095594048500061, 0.5259660482406616, -0.7380127906799316, 0.5347893834114075, -0.17036086320877075, 0.13127493858337402, 0.34274470806121826, 0.5659438371658325, -0.8107609152793884, -0.3131972849369049, -0.36720705032348633, -0.7813035249710083, 0.3092666566371918, 0.09600144624710083, 0.18278296291828156, -0.08115775138139725, 0.6823854446411133, 0.2365291714668274, 0.31282585859298706, -0.6830801963806152, -0.4966329038143158, 0.061593037098646164, -0.30797281861305237, -0.213441863656044, -0.2585420310497284, -0.24529744684696198, -0.24761152267456055, 0.5819498896598816, -0.05523617938160896, 0.2039354294538498, 0.19815793633460999, 0.07269158214330673, 0.02035442180931568, 0.1644424945116043, 0.6277509331703186, 0.577572762966156, -0.07514259964227676, 0.13427798449993134, -0.0350281186401844, -0.8348696827888489, -0.052599191665649414, 0.2718499004840851, 0.2211536020040512, 0.025435470044612885, 0.3987167775630951, 0.47581377625465393, 0.033641744405031204, -1.0166890621185303, 0.7032658457756042, -0.11768820881843567, -0.40234848856925964, -0.3713514804840088, 0.166065514087677, 0.26464423537254333, 0.42317822575569153, 0.0038535709027200937, 0.12704820930957794, 0.15027426183223724, -0.7850963473320007, 0.03012533113360405, 0.47276005148887634, -0.4464845359325409, -0.23405785858631134, 0.8134815692901611, 0.09683746099472046, -0.19706666469573975, 0.8277749419212341, 0.45891427993774414, -0.447380393743515, 0.6894668340682983, 0.5976889133453369, 0.520000696182251, -0.37526124715805054, 0.1419793963432312, 0.19282186031341553, 0.4387696385383606, -0.3102467358112335, 0.6015527844429016, 0.2944992780685425, -0.49907320737838745, -0.48063308000564575, -0.2798992693424225, -0.7340001463890076, 0.3539145290851593, -0.35854989290237427, 0.33592116832733154, -0.5719268321990967, -0.5498069524765015, 0.06171191483736038, -0.11495482176542282, -0.29444143176078796, 0.31676337122917175, 0.529920220375061, 0.9421008825302124, -0.43696361780166626, 0.7947645783424377, 0.9124417304992676, -0.08850027620792389, -0.3051372766494751, -0.13266196846961975, 0.39026057720184326, -0.9714140892028809, 0.4900074005126953, 0.5571305751800537, -0.16599726676940918, -0.4122585952281952, -0.38850417733192444, -0.6067028045654297, 0.9677709937095642, 0.2839645445346832, -0.6516963839530945, -0.08928041160106659, -0.030106157064437866, 0.6751118898391724, -0.3920707106590271, 0.3379560708999634, 0.40934479236602783, 0.37549927830696106, 0.2521815299987793, -1.010879397392273, -0.02409709058701992, -0.3480881154537201, -0.1964651495218277, 0.06277292966842651, -0.5161012411117554, 0.8491091728210449, -0.795722246170044, 0.13924813270568848, 0.31818822026252747, 0.1501154899597168, 0.488578736782074, 0.5946500301361084, 0.2171495109796524, 0.5098519921302795, 0.8200501799583435, -0.24295061826705933, 1.2341059446334839, -0.29441729187965393, 0.07295785844326019, 0.7326908111572266, -0.2866484522819519, 0.7941566705703735, 0.7792266607284546, 0.10040353983640671, 0.35006284713745117, 0.5514326691627502, -0.05719856917858124, 0.3554759621620178, 0.389250785112381, -0.2915078103542328, -0.271971195936203, 0.09433726966381073, -0.6059445738792419, 0.24556592106819153, 0.7442072033882141, -0.5978471636772156, 0.1482112556695938, 0.3645046651363373, 0.07147179543972015, -0.11357186734676361, -0.23495259881019592, 0.4830222725868225, 0.38935208320617676, -0.7945080995559692, 0.4076227843761444, 0.012812322936952114, 0.7592939734458923, -0.6619945764541626, 0.14754603803157806, -0.048521000891923904, 0.5197285413742065, -0.1180049255490303, -0.6975713968276978, 0.268024742603302, -0.08240577578544617, 0.05709114670753479, -0.08379756659269333, 0.6013849377632141, -0.12011300772428513, -0.48992595076560974, 0.39029207825660706, 0.4967469274997711, 0.3723405599594116, -0.2690161168575287, -0.8463717699050903, 0.2564001679420471, -0.3021892011165619, -0.4024582505226135, 0.34544557332992554, 0.2930009365081787, 0.045965466648340225, 1.1384156942367554, 0.7589980363845825, 0.3087557256221771, -0.06497170776128769, 0.3289196193218231, 0.9458986520767212, -0.7118545174598694, -0.05962467938661575, -1.0333572626113892, 0.4254252016544342, 0.09292588382959366, -0.49839165806770325, 0.5578187108039856, 0.47547033429145813, 0.45412302017211914, -0.2684742510318756, 0.539172887802124, 0.2357480823993683, 0.248188778758049, -0.5240334272384644, 0.959534764289856, -0.7527262568473816, 0.18283560872077942, -0.2156798243522644, -0.6242560744285583, -0.7886170744895935, 0.6279283761978149, -0.21551179885864258, 0.06459590792655945, 1.0150339603424072, 0.818641185760498, 0.31403765082359314, -0.18083824217319489, 0.4321494400501251, 0.35940226912498474, 0.21525578200817108, 0.7358590960502625, 1.2706483602523804, -0.23257417976856232, 0.4588177800178528, -0.18996195495128632, -0.3434953987598419, -0.3008994162082672, -0.5970541834831238, -1.2149766683578491, -0.45132172107696533, -0.36866065859794617, -0.7482882738113403, 0.09624692797660828, 0.9624504446983337, 0.5705516934394836, -0.5408574938774109, 0.014831957407295704, 0.3258719742298126, 0.026417529210448265, -0.2182411402463913, -0.15077711641788483, 0.28144657611846924, -0.14940820634365082, -0.5644081830978394, 0.5045348405838013, 0.569652795791626, 0.1307152509689331, -0.4693801999092102, -0.08913370221853256, 0.22261692583560944, -0.07942008227109909, 0.6442208290100098, -0.2810162901878357, -0.9772509336471558, -0.09367576241493225, 0.3160208761692047, -0.5046091079711914, 0.04637259989976883, 0.7529272437095642, -0.6987736821174622, 0.4312500059604645, 0.11209546029567719, 0.6161368489265442, 0.1964227706193924, -0.2649609446525574, 0.1754627376794815, 0.04308179020881653, -0.1280481517314911, 0.31416231393814087, 0.4061377942562103, 0.2284245491027832, -0.5209270715713501, 0.4007153809070587, 0.31470489501953125, -0.5172968506813049, -0.6616014242172241, -0.003193926066160202, -1.1332411766052246, -0.49262017011642456, 1.1171294450759888, 0.11276303976774216, -0.3421134948730469, -0.03735417500138283, -0.4665048122406006, 0.08793213963508606, -0.1839478611946106, 1.4239791631698608, 0.8360875248908997, -0.18272963166236877, -0.14020125567913055, -0.8027250170707703, 0.3397442102432251, 0.4790586233139038, -1.0435256958007812, -0.3017493486404419, 0.5007367134094238, 0.45454779267311096, 0.146337628364563, 0.5820111036300659, -0.6131274700164795, 0.5049782395362854, -0.25557607412338257, 0.0903577208518982, -0.2527623474597931, -0.5143464207649231, -0.4292255938053131, 0.16085690259933472, -0.0024477646220475435, -0.24194243550300598 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06992v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06992v1	A Rational Analysis of the Speech-to-Song Illusion	2024-02-10T16:54:28	2024-02-10T16:54:28	Raja Marjieh, Pol van Rijn, Ilia Sucholutsky, Harin Lee, Thomas L. Griffiths, Nori Jacoby	q-bio.NC	q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.AP	The speech-to-song illusion is a robust psychological phenomenon whereby a spoken sentence sounds increasingly more musical as it is repeated. Despite decades of research, a complete formal account of this transformation is still lacking, and some of its nuanced characteristics, namely, that certain phrases appear to transform while others do not, is not well understood. Here we provide a formal account of this phenomenon, by recasting it as a statistical inference whereby a rational agent attempts to decide whether a sequence of utterances is more likely to have been produced in a song or speech. Using this approach and analyzing song and speech corpora, we further introduce a novel prose-to-lyrics illusion that is purely text-based. In this illusion, simply duplicating written sentences makes them appear more like song lyrics. We provide robust evidence for this new illusion in both human participants and large language models.	[ -0.24741722643375397, -0.9497723579406738, 0.4815652668476105, 0.7591955661773682, 0.08545580506324768, 0.2169717401266098, -0.2324008196592331, -0.39044249057769775, 0.557536780834198, 0.708642303943634, -0.7790992856025696, -0.15555132925510406, -0.47791728377342224, 0.14270837604999542, -0.8846704959869385, 1.0154433250427246, 0.33261606097221375, -0.018036741763353348, -0.08971985429525375, 0.0686064139008522, -0.47249484062194824, -0.4379834830760956, -0.3441673517227173, -0.01944100111722946, 0.37634196877479553, -0.0061323679983615875, 0.669353723526001, 0.1415448933839798, 0.20967626571655273, 0.30889108777046204, 0.3434012234210968, -0.160086527466774, -0.6405964493751526, 0.04484015703201294, -0.013461562804877758, -0.9459915161132812, -0.06969546526670456, 0.5483963489532471, 0.7149220108985901, 0.8696927428245544, -0.17857378721237183, 0.08860699087381363, 0.012720816768705845, 0.868530809879303, -0.15926270186901093, -0.2893294095993042, -0.6990430951118469, 0.19745910167694092, -0.31499937176704407, -0.573847234249115, -0.5285777449607849, -0.5093417167663574, 0.5076116919517517, -0.6931469440460205, 0.2622548043727875, 0.3501746356487274, 0.8853231072425842, 0.19084866344928741, -0.520905613899231, -0.48258230090141296, -0.974285900592804, 0.7217192053794861, -0.13070763647556305, 0.27532142400741577, 0.09853366762399673, 0.34817269444465637, -0.34665775299072266, -0.6827842593193054, -0.8403285145759583, -0.5119228959083557, -0.2635636627674103, 0.29595616459846497, -0.2788165509700775, -0.12475357204675674, 0.471967488527298, 0.48616859316825867, -0.8052920699119568, -0.7214059233665466, -0.10408259183168411, -0.18420888483524323, 0.6252195239067078, -0.17743706703186035, 0.9316690564155579, -0.3936636447906494, -0.7383143901824951, -0.013200480490922928, -0.25180482864379883, 0.16988933086395264, 0.2810225784778595, 0.07285942882299423, -0.15726977586746216, 0.8072993755340576, 0.06886973977088928, 0.7393720746040344, 0.18148250877857208, -0.4510354995727539, 0.42485156655311584, -0.1024179756641388, -0.37806224822998047, 0.5468613505363464, 0.7140178084373474, 0.22660832107067108, 0.5993121266365051, -0.421426385641098, -0.24546344578266144, 0.7268743515014648, 0.04586737975478172, -0.3414183557033539, -0.2081044316291809, -0.03006451390683651, -0.4030621349811554, -0.15290243923664093, 0.11939945071935654, -0.6253823637962341, -0.29960206151008606, -0.637570858001709, 0.6276454329490662, -0.6761420369148254, -0.18362267315387726, 0.3882322311401367, -0.36581194400787354, -0.13792692124843597, -0.035455066710710526, -0.48220697045326233, 0.20587237179279327, 0.8663319945335388, 0.9416212439537048, -0.0589989610016346, -0.5063392519950867, -0.23050646483898163, 0.09766576439142227, -0.7171632647514343, 1.2204234600067139, -0.35537293553352356, -0.28197696805000305, -0.26546552777290344, 0.12957043945789337, -0.5899089574813843, -0.3369542062282562, 0.42301344871520996, -0.31864991784095764, 0.7801619172096252, -0.3363301753997803, -0.6273977756500244, -0.24200566112995148, -0.16820867359638214, -0.6759094595909119, 0.4139319956302643, 0.07914172112941742, -0.5460584163665771, 0.3914770781993866, -0.42451801896095276, -0.3797625005245209, -0.3805142343044281, -0.33897051215171814, -0.20309168100357056, 0.5365747213363647, -0.1591452658176422, -0.018182137981057167, -0.3149731159210205, 0.19796031713485718, -0.35509851574897766, -0.5098064541816711, 1.09724760055542, -0.6737918853759766, 0.8701655268669128, 0.43055281043052673, -0.12182246893644333, -0.06002442166209221, -0.8132497668266296, -0.020212063565850258, 0.13590137660503387, -0.1000760868191719, -0.5806371569633484, 0.005095137748867273, 0.05419023334980011, -0.04422217607498169, 0.18684856593608856, -0.4435133934020996, 0.044532567262649536, -0.7593844532966614, 0.4203098714351654, 0.28053462505340576, 0.42859935760498047, 0.6934738159179688, -0.7814339995384216, 0.3812633752822876, -0.268014520406723, -0.10627797991037369, 0.07068175077438354, -0.38224899768829346, -0.21085131168365479, -0.48424938321113586, 0.1596449762582779, 0.7469415664672852, -0.3429248034954071, 0.18203097581863403, -0.49429765343666077, 0.008809776045382023, -0.591411828994751, -0.10604696720838547, 0.060437947511672974, 0.4956580698490143, 0.024350836873054504, -0.028669752180576324, -0.694955050945282, -1.0730233192443848, -0.8128806948661804, -0.18095894157886505, -0.2798859775066376, -0.1389881819486618, 0.20528601109981537, 0.019024521112442017, 1.0298376083374023, -0.5233002305030823, -0.4059440791606903, 0.01581793837249279, 0.34568163752555847, 0.11306747794151306, 0.5387288331985474, 0.6052713394165039, -0.8711454272270203, -0.3879435956478119, -0.25900259613990784, -0.5208247303962708, -0.36674344539642334, -0.9051807522773743, -0.3796161115169525, 0.11862807720899582, 0.3624016344547272, -0.6933128237724304, 0.2913053333759308, 0.4767517149448395, -0.6038527488708496, 0.4437822103500366, 0.2633657455444336, 0.5236741900444031, -0.9178268909454346, -0.13970008492469788, 0.07221648097038269, 0.009167914278805256, -0.7530630230903625, -0.5278040766716003, -0.11294376105070114, 0.01167365163564682, 0.24676205217838287, -0.06808138638734818, -0.306888222694397, -0.4776473939418793, -0.2898775339126587, 0.49543413519859314, 0.2606984078884125, 0.4360739290714264, -0.1517476886510849, 0.8698768019676208, 0.5593476295471191, -0.004279464483261108, 0.15704336762428284, 0.1481701284646988, -0.8818556666374207, 0.947084367275238, -0.402834415435791, -0.026707569137215614, -0.45115146040916443, 0.20313091576099396, -1.3371610641479492, -0.4401507079601288, 0.1998741626739502, -0.7700535655021667, 0.3538588583469391, -0.004241911228746176, -0.3122459948062897, -0.10879609733819962, 0.10060784965753555, 0.30513930320739746, 0.6015951633453369, -0.38694989681243896, 0.49154946208000183, 0.2438870221376419, -0.05235816910862923, -0.3315829336643219, -0.7742195725440979, 0.42649614810943604, -0.6786895394325256, -0.8588343262672424, 0.35941123962402344, 0.054266396909952164, -0.8179033398628235, 0.046105433255434036, -0.15823175013065338, -0.07513754814863205, -0.007555331569164991, 0.10980767011642456, 0.3041832447052002, -0.31561756134033203, 0.4205091893672943, 0.13107797503471375, 0.08365804702043533, 0.4342136085033417, -0.38350847363471985, 0.3840881288051605, 0.11006339639425278, -0.12999604642391205, -0.8537259101867676, 0.4470057785511017, 0.6111384034156799, -0.0988096296787262, 0.35024121403694153, 0.2226986438035965, -0.04508821666240692, -0.20884132385253906, -0.31379106640815735, 0.1123519316315651, -0.37234827876091003, 0.2781505882740021, -0.4949779808521271, -0.27042874693870544, 0.36374208331108093, -0.16830192506313324, -0.3552433252334595, 0.44759872555732727, -0.07704047113656998, -0.6074294447898865, 1.1788922548294067, 0.23331373929977417, 0.17261314392089844, 0.5343406796455383, -0.19498242437839508, -0.21113334596157074, -0.7018442153930664, -0.3833876848220825, -0.5202509760856628, -0.3003960847854614, -0.5951849222183228, -0.3119457960128784, 0.36515727639198303, 0.1747249960899353, -0.44678279757499695, 0.08796573430299759, -0.465012788772583, 0.22418683767318726, 0.14111001789569855, 0.047871436923742294, 0.26560863852500916, 0.14965716004371643, 0.35591188073158264, -0.18901555240154266, -0.37618252635002136, -0.4820631742477417, 0.8231220245361328, 0.21035540103912354, 0.32718798518180847, 0.5386510491371155, 0.5155515074729919, 0.4316212236881256, 0.34953224658966064, -0.8052621483802795, 0.45456984639167786, 0.006213318090885878, -0.6619336009025574, -0.512997031211853, -0.5148975849151611, -0.7988495230674744, 0.20332513749599457, -0.49904903769493103, -0.650026798248291, 0.2408008724451065, 0.13003377616405487, -0.22761960327625275, -0.049435779452323914, -0.7978649735450745, 0.6861533522605896, -0.48418834805488586, -0.049631863832473755, -0.2337145209312439, -0.3502349555492401, 0.744178056716919, -0.2057134509086609, 0.30550459027290344, -0.3310118317604065, -0.266772985458374, 0.7748532891273499, -0.3496624529361725, 0.6706820130348206, -0.09760326892137527, -0.330037921667099, 0.19947576522827148, 0.19483347237110138, 0.613590657711029, -0.10816846042871475, 0.16674111783504486, -0.14434342086315155, -0.09996559470891953, -0.5259642004966736, -1.237214207649231, 0.7356497645378113, -0.5464973449707031, -0.5984542369842529, -0.2944842278957367, -0.5315960049629211, -0.42971301078796387, -0.20915234088897705, 0.43525800108909607, 0.6014023423194885, -0.1820461004972458, -0.07543589919805527, 0.45753106474876404, -0.34563589096069336, 0.11919089406728745, 0.10229849070310593, -0.5059341192245483, -0.771024227142334, 0.8685612678527832, 0.20609623193740845, 0.6530553698539734, 0.6254147887229919, 0.34191104769706726, -0.5574279427528381, -0.2976152002811432, -0.29618093371391296, 0.507134199142456, -0.4023694097995758, 0.6343557238578796, -0.38363146781921387, 0.2492220401763916, -0.4720672070980072, 0.025483354926109314, -0.002981361234560609, -0.698760449886322, -0.10390978306531906, 0.13336840271949768, 0.538658082485199, 0.47802767157554626, -0.0911402702331543, 0.317253053188324, -0.2884863317012787, 0.44624030590057373, 0.41122958064079285, 0.20173871517181396, -0.00625600153580308, -0.9162068367004395, 0.0664905533194542, 0.21813440322875977, 0.059331607073545456, -1.1708141565322876, 0.35432517528533936, 0.42295101284980774, 0.1998971551656723, 0.4499272406101227, 0.029902925714850426, 1.022281289100647, -0.5474748611450195, 0.6768369078636169, 0.4704305827617645, -0.9571618437767029, 0.35142186284065247, -0.5235333442687988, -0.19544601440429688, 0.4389103651046753, 0.060519397258758545, -0.7545957565307617, -0.1823473423719406, -0.4904051721096039, -0.3736201524734497, 0.2566721737384796, 0.5267044901847839, 0.11186987906694412, 0.07540594041347504, 0.11399645358324051, -0.06951456516981125, 0.3302614092826843, -0.6580384373664856, -0.5160363912582397, -0.6928791999816895, -0.12625113129615784, -0.5924672484397888, 0.051798492670059204, -0.1394425630569458, -0.02115721069276333, 0.2924121022224426, 0.19067950546741486, 0.5434754490852356, 0.4969210624694824, -0.04852362349629402, -0.23153389990329742, 0.443959504365921, 0.86948162317276, 0.5264819264411926, -0.17772720754146576, 0.23072867095470428, -0.032930828630924225, -0.3558964431285858, 0.06393443048000336, -0.022283727303147316, -0.25174519419670105, -0.0014909080928191543, 0.6003484725952148, 1.027086853981018, 0.36915531754493713, -0.5918052792549133, 0.4256107807159424, 0.22783100605010986, -0.29566991329193115, -0.7129771709442139, -0.03906293213367462, 0.04791770875453949, 0.32537221908569336, 0.42466214299201965, 0.6963746547698975, 0.30326005816459656, -1.0941433906555176, 0.3960878551006317, 0.4185032844543457, -0.628299355506897, -0.27216222882270813, 0.6932907700538635, -0.2991864085197449, -0.7864043712615967, 0.022494183853268623, 0.008449232205748558, -0.44426974654197693, 0.35958603024482727, 0.7320204377174377, 1.056349515914917, -0.0024745941627770662, 0.3348143398761749, 0.21537785232067108, 0.050971079617738724, -0.2428452968597412, 0.21390359103679657, -0.06614905595779419, -0.4391472637653351, -0.5693612694740295, -0.40824928879737854, 0.26846200227737427, 0.15509146451950073, -0.7420619130134583, -0.19168032705783844, 0.01914062909781933, -0.0427805595099926, 0.3889923393726349, -0.36338281631469727, 0.058641206473112106, 0.1881888061761856, -0.07719086855649948, 0.6069641709327698, -0.7298991680145264, 0.7617530822753906, 0.21733802556991577, -0.30040618777275085, -0.7994277477264404, 0.43065762519836426, 0.13921110332012177, -0.6031455397605896, 0.42187824845314026, 0.0302236657589674, -0.2697848379611969, 0.0746183693408966, -0.6895995140075684, -0.820005476474762, 0.5815460085868835, 0.3354017734527588, -0.641406774520874, -0.04224666953086853, 0.5857351422309875, 0.8279609680175781, -0.4427860677242279, -0.4771293103694916, 0.6937538981437683, 0.5450934171676636, 0.212876096367836, -0.6082507967948914, -0.2557116448879242, 0.07291433215141296, 0.08791904896497726, 0.2985381782054901, -0.4378107786178589, 0.9639497399330139, -0.06378751248121262, -0.5334780216217041, 0.33352676033973694, 0.7346086502075195, 0.15129005908966064, 0.6962246298789978, 0.8248035311698914, 0.20902802050113678, 0.7897869944572449, 0.0038683589082211256, 0.973834753036499, -0.3292759954929352, 0.2402663379907608, 1.1298141479492188, -0.24326293170452118, 0.6994192004203796, 0.5172144770622253, -0.22791294753551483, 0.5092597603797913, 0.2244984358549118, -0.0492023229598999, 0.5736134648323059, 0.39467689394950867, -0.3959585130214691, -0.3555147349834442, 0.11990106105804443, -0.15928150713443756, 0.5995743274688721, 0.31713879108428955, -0.6931644082069397, 0.3199678957462311, 0.19332127273082733, -0.1537954956293106, 0.7284030318260193, -0.2595410645008087, 0.7152218222618103, 0.162999227643013, -0.9517820477485657, 0.4505669176578522, -0.6035155653953552, 0.3415498435497284, -0.2844303250312805, 0.12127342820167542, 0.1122075617313385, -0.1722303181886673, -0.06096354126930237, -0.5885006785392761, 0.4462434947490692, -0.07260855287313461, -0.3464371860027313, -0.22246865928173065, 0.4331541061401367, -0.6971192359924316, -0.5721613764762878, 0.1952323168516159, 0.26050445437431335, 0.2696261703968048, -0.10782521218061447, -0.6986644864082336, -0.33423686027526855, 0.37158969044685364, -0.04980044439435005, 0.18147413432598114, 0.9225654006004333, 0.10844099521636963, 0.44053757190704346, 0.5549262166023254, 0.5069396495819092, 0.21500778198242188, 0.13527221977710724, 0.06886739283800125, -0.7229666113853455, -0.48361673951148987, -0.6363146901130676, 0.22992824018001556, -0.3315516710281372, -0.13064749538898468, 0.849730908870697, 0.745311975479126, 0.6462392210960388, -0.1387912929058075, 0.9301652312278748, 0.12243364006280899, 0.907538890838623, -0.7493748664855957, 0.9965238571166992, -0.654396116733551, 0.46418440341949463, -0.719394862651825, -0.8120883107185364, 0.0784839391708374, 0.699381411075592, -0.5693679451942444, -0.29542607069015503, 0.6590458750724792, 0.8561058640480042, 0.11106407642364502, 0.44889378547668457, 0.42566752433776855, 0.4052480459213257, -0.23340706527233124, 0.32095658779144287, 1.3197108507156372, -0.3496790826320648, 0.6118738055229187, -0.2111210823059082, -0.12964163720607758, 0.2707850933074951, -0.5411517024040222, -0.47791588306427, -0.919532060623169, -0.30088844895362854, -0.4289332926273346, -0.28684714436531067, 0.975665807723999, 0.17880737781524658, -0.5529959797859192, -0.37828031182289124, -0.16603529453277588, 0.13909149169921875, -0.4621009826660156, -0.2110687643289566, 0.37248995900154114, -0.18569619953632355, -0.6497694849967957, 0.4204055070877075, 0.10126132518053055, 0.4552113115787506, -0.12086302787065506, 0.07467857003211975, 0.11795854568481445, 0.6766097545623779, 0.6119831204414368, 0.22202546894550323, -0.8085748553276062, -0.2645229399204254, 0.11811918020248413, -0.08539294451475143, 0.2002936750650406, 0.9582065939903259, -0.5827749967575073, 0.3496263325214386, 0.4347211420536041, -0.050672292709350586, 0.02481834404170513, 0.15350566804409027, 0.5356743335723877, -0.35981667041778564, -0.11862286180257797, 0.004491915460675955, 0.14301864802837372, 0.06214725971221924, -0.17487241327762604, 0.17826057970523834, 0.6508776545524597, -0.3404909670352936, -1.0788710117340088, 0.21024222671985626, -1.2842490673065186, -0.3301125466823578, 1.0170682668685913, 0.13563893735408783, -0.29252782464027405, -0.20228038728237152, -0.38855722546577454, 0.2982392907142639, -0.33590734004974365, 1.1328901052474976, 0.40250125527381897, -0.29192954301834106, 0.21422499418258667, -0.6941328048706055, 0.9084153771400452, 0.16062191128730774, -0.516904354095459, 0.061527978628873825, 0.7983098030090332, 0.38362666964530945, 0.4756162464618683, 0.2390947788953781, 0.0395280122756958, 0.2191305011510849, 0.2887374460697174, -0.26734715700149536, 0.3598850667476654, -0.40194228291511536, -0.168476864695549, 0.6109830737113953, -0.2530756890773773, -0.2558085322380066 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10951v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10951v1	DAEDRA: A language model for predicting outcomes in passive pharmacovigilance reporting	2024-02-10T16:48:45	2024-02-10T16:48:45	Chris von Csefalvay	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7; J.3	Over the recent years, the emergence of large language models (LLMs) has given rise to a proliferation of domain-specific models that are intended to reflect the particularities of linguistic context and content as a correlate of the originating domain. This paper details the conception, design, training and evaluation of DAEDRA, a LLM designed to detect regulatory-relevant outcomes (mortality, ER attendance and hospitalisation) in adverse event reports elicited through passive reporting (PR). While PR is a highly cost-efficient way of eliciting information from a wide and diverse audience -- typically including not only physicians and healthcare providers but also patients, family members and other lay stakeholders --, this diversity makes PR corpora difficult to analyse. Generic language models may not capture the complex clinical dimensions while specific clinical or biomedical models may not perform well on lay reports. To evaluate the utility of a subdomain-specific language model, an adaptive training approach was adapted, wherein base language model candidates were evaluated on a subset of the corpus, and the best performer was trained on the entire corpus. This yielded a small but significant improvement in $F_1$ (+1%), precision (+2.5%) and recall (+3.8%), at a relatively low training cost and a single-day training time. Subdomain-specific LLMs continue to be viable options for better results when analysing highly specialised corpora.	[ 0.3505464792251587, -0.586421012878418, 0.5670174360275269, 0.01167368981987238, -0.4185425043106079, 0.009048563428223133, -0.16203083097934723, -0.4740615487098694, 0.21435075998306274, 0.27271541953086853, -0.3342607617378235, -0.739708423614502, -0.6477406024932861, 0.10514623671770096, -0.39087915420532227, 1.0006693601608276, -0.18173566460609436, 0.10220956057310104, 0.3235435485839844, -0.2613658607006073, -0.6362903118133545, -0.8894558548927307, -0.37613609433174133, -0.1991150677204132, 0.893062949180603, 0.2577548921108246, 0.2798890769481659, 0.2851335406303406, 0.8925752639770508, 0.14980924129486084, -0.08306816965341568, 0.08834954351186752, -0.46621671319007874, 0.026970546692609787, -0.11026556044816971, -0.28739386796951294, -1.046430230140686, 0.11097772419452667, 0.6438690423965454, 0.7924247980117798, -0.5864511132240295, -0.0030550260562449694, -0.04304106906056404, 0.5476194024085999, -0.7628118991851807, 0.10253293812274933, -0.40243539214134216, 0.005453776568174362, -0.2534709572792053, -0.09213887155056, -0.4523313641548157, -0.2651975750923157, 0.47879287600517273, -0.5396488904953003, -0.261759489774704, -0.08017763495445251, 0.5774512887001038, 0.2989512085914612, -0.6309638023376465, -0.6198129653930664, -0.7503697276115417, 0.5246273279190063, -0.883965015411377, 0.2413700819015503, 0.20222286880016327, 0.2771010398864746, -0.2603900730609894, -0.9836082458496094, -0.6318884491920471, -0.2607141137123108, -0.1385500431060791, 0.29693618416786194, -0.441028356552124, 0.15652066469192505, -0.26150867342948914, 0.341200590133667, -0.43629157543182373, 0.24552395939826965, -0.3025928735733032, 0.09171919524669647, 0.6369572877883911, 0.3776751160621643, 0.4412018954753876, 0.036395203322172165, -0.32379892468452454, 0.33978021144866943, -0.7471688389778137, -0.2656143307685852, 0.149911031126976, 0.4628322720527649, -0.30082961916923523, 0.34115836024284363, -0.0598156675696373, 0.6123411655426025, 0.08261685073375702, -0.5622173547744751, 0.17447495460510254, -0.01927313581109047, -0.059738654643297195, 0.36485862731933594, 0.6333520412445068, 0.19552548229694366, 0.2397001087665558, 0.0498134009540081, -0.1211303323507309, 0.3355811536312103, 0.41200903058052063, -0.6777814626693726, -0.4308069348335266, 0.4279188811779022, -0.35237348079681396, -0.39176177978515625, -0.005333706270903349, -0.6759353876113892, -0.1787615865468979, -0.09856629371643066, 0.22769081592559814, -0.3938617408275604, -0.5357892513275146, 0.4312764108181, 0.2345067262649536, -0.13657326996326447, 0.26822429895401, -0.7208451628684998, 0.45629510283470154, 0.5754557251930237, 0.6740185022354126, -0.6805688738822937, -0.21189548075199127, -0.6622554659843445, 0.21603228151798248, -0.4214094877243042, 0.8385652899742126, -0.4949469566345215, -0.3212060332298279, 0.1892184019088745, -0.05539533123373985, -0.3443693220615387, -0.44411197304725647, 0.8161978721618652, -0.7084914445877075, -0.04707571491599083, -0.03910163789987564, -0.3172551393508911, -0.41092583537101746, -0.1552005112171173, -0.5014616250991821, 0.6236552596092224, 0.16859973967075348, -0.7925851345062256, 0.6847918033599854, -0.5279178023338318, -0.5758869647979736, 0.3663160800933838, -0.01676972582936287, -0.5353540182113647, 0.1415010690689087, -0.11096899211406708, 0.37383759021759033, -0.043888840824365616, 0.5462002754211426, -0.04400837421417236, -0.47154995799064636, 0.4983004033565521, -0.3178635835647583, 0.4654694199562073, 0.14652638137340546, -0.4271557331085205, 0.286540150642395, -0.811180591583252, -0.29657742381095886, -0.09206842631101608, -0.6582790017127991, -0.6079670786857605, 0.09607153385877609, 0.09166732430458069, 0.07669288665056229, -0.05036934092640877, -0.51817786693573, 0.027219673618674278, -0.43574485182762146, 0.19253484904766083, 0.5997700691223145, 0.22754207253456116, 0.13714826107025146, -0.024119475856423378, 0.4873855710029602, 0.15885552763938904, 0.4092130661010742, 0.19904212653636932, -0.2526230812072754, -0.49776437878608704, -0.7920562624931335, 0.6162064671516418, 0.5203109383583069, -0.3956409692764282, 0.24809297919273376, -0.3344440758228302, -0.20940415561199188, -0.3371793329715729, 0.00445410143584013, 0.4340803027153015, 0.45996204018592834, 0.1428745985031128, -0.45247596502304077, -0.6827612519264221, -0.7784945964813232, 0.07793839275836945, -0.333151251077652, 0.29955562949180603, 0.136988565325737, 0.7425203323364258, -0.8486294746398926, 0.5488888025283813, -0.519213855266571, -0.5810865759849548, -0.5471237301826477, -0.02591744251549244, 0.13878706097602844, 0.11180265247821808, 0.47071996331214905, -0.725168764591217, -0.5464310050010681, -0.02679985575377941, -0.7613084316253662, -0.4442669153213501, 0.1276598572731018, 0.061339206993579865, 0.16595523059368134, 0.019381506368517876, -0.24476298689842224, 0.5761988759040833, 0.8352768421173096, -0.22677181661128998, 0.3118070065975189, -0.2999151945114136, 0.11280003935098648, -0.6973464488983154, 0.2539465129375458, -0.040643177926540375, -0.0877448096871376, -0.7843648195266724, -0.2984592616558075, 0.10292024165391922, -0.009627465158700943, -0.41912707686424255, 0.4216294288635254, -0.5992006659507751, 0.09641839563846588, -0.561907172203064, 0.08319804072380066, -0.038971927016973495, 0.4093968868255615, 0.16903124749660492, 0.6999785304069519, 0.3805513083934784, -0.784810483455658, 0.2774008512496948, 0.2231389582157135, -0.41463956236839294, 0.4535106420516968, -0.7738639116287231, -0.04584202915430069, 0.08740697801113129, 0.15191787481307983, -0.7673086524009705, -0.49324533343315125, 0.14412057399749756, -0.20770248770713806, 0.5646727681159973, -0.3303792476654053, -0.11637937277555466, -0.4699842929840088, 0.16402490437030792, 0.43398517370224, 0.42828258872032166, -0.309150367975235, 0.48944607377052307, 1.0889308452606201, -0.4970911145210266, -0.46868905425071716, -0.768534779548645, 0.27276238799095154, -0.25441423058509827, -0.2167573869228363, 0.24306540191173553, 0.061693210154771805, -0.6160992383956909, 0.05991183966398239, 0.007024216465651989, -0.22893424332141876, 0.18176227807998657, 0.3932904899120331, 0.353679358959198, -0.1020219624042511, 0.16702812910079956, 0.019815970212221146, -0.3086963891983032, -0.08681859076023102, -0.006702195852994919, 0.18785274028778076, -0.1883336901664734, -0.5006498098373413, -0.5613409876823425, 0.5733296275138855, 0.6096654534339905, -0.34503820538520813, 0.9350848197937012, -0.06033705919981003, -0.31388232111930847, -0.39870837330818176, -0.29090818762779236, 0.018502453342080116, -0.41548410058021545, 0.250691294670105, -0.1989988088607788, -0.47542861104011536, 0.4856570363044739, -0.1766960173845291, -0.1001678854227066, 0.4811062812805176, 1.0968574285507202, 0.05067844316363335, 0.8364230990409851, 1.000648856163025, 0.314515620470047, 0.49022194743156433, -0.05909375101327896, 0.20426300168037415, -0.5610724687576294, -0.4545150399208069, 0.020433608442544937, 0.1393093764781952, -0.33152705430984497, -0.38011434674263, 0.8872575163841248, -0.29479658603668213, 0.12544618546962738, 0.03898318484425545, -0.4358804523944855, 0.04738433286547661, 0.15767863392829895, 0.2054753303527832, 0.5343395471572876, 0.049012746661901474, -0.19290964305400848, -0.09066124260425568, -0.9415967464447021, -0.5950614809989929, 1.0450992584228516, 0.4775376617908478, 0.9450976252555847, 0.30363449454307556, 0.32907944917678833, 0.5875945091247559, 0.7097775936126709, -0.7734824419021606, 0.30895909667015076, -0.2528384327888489, -0.4577972888946533, 0.15677917003631592, -0.3307821750640869, -1.0813474655151367, 0.0193756315857172, 0.06636180728673935, -0.30750003457069397, 0.5983859896659851, -0.22721274197101593, -0.6325467228889465, 0.06155553460121155, -0.7143692374229431, 0.6711674332618713, -0.4573422074317932, -0.29170745611190796, -0.19824127852916718, -0.465198278427124, 0.19627875089645386, -0.3918423652648926, 0.2272588014602661, -0.23669974505901337, -0.3068479895591736, 0.8906252980232239, -0.37254709005355835, 1.3275388479232788, 0.038784753531217575, -0.32817575335502625, 0.378280371427536, -0.05867352336645126, 0.21614347398281097, 0.07461759448051453, -0.16297000646591187, 0.2843555808067322, 0.06436315923929214, -0.3335252106189728, -0.1449223756790161, 0.7909222841262817, -0.736831545829773, -0.4401838183403015, -0.921640932559967, -0.4190095067024231, -0.15958453714847565, 0.07223613560199738, -0.006009158678352833, 0.7005928158760071, -0.5056294798851013, -0.13805866241455078, 0.6898006200790405, -0.3309593200683594, 0.1603030115365982, 1.3940225839614868, 0.2165830135345459, -0.5020078420639038, 0.4793670177459717, 0.321083128452301, -0.0034350750502198935, 0.2537177503108978, 0.182711660861969, -0.17010901868343353, -0.8207547664642334, -0.39748701453208923, 0.24836809933185577, -0.7539948225021362, -0.3382047116756439, -0.7617026567459106, -0.17870400846004486, -0.3028246760368347, 0.2708187699317932, -0.38853922486305237, -0.18878115713596344, -0.12280457466840744, -0.33292853832244873, 0.6521050333976746, 0.9971057176589966, -0.0750918909907341, 0.20883558690547943, -0.7735589146614075, 0.18382574617862701, 0.1885952651500702, 0.5309549570083618, -0.23300804197788239, -0.8024977445602417, -0.5013860464096069, -0.04391404241323471, 0.1340942680835724, -1.2096272706985474, 0.6710603833198547, 0.3496604561805725, 1.0321617126464844, 0.039757464081048965, 0.3111170828342438, 0.29216495156288147, -0.44954022765159607, 0.3476932644844055, 0.129912331700325, -0.6899872422218323, 0.8718342185020447, -0.5742448568344116, -0.0851779356598854, 0.6027547717094421, 0.4552015960216522, -0.4448232054710388, -0.19623829424381256, -0.26446211338043213, -0.9493006467819214, 0.3955020606517792, 0.048999276012182236, 0.061396870762109756, -0.23959359526634216, 0.5875859260559082, 0.38047394156455994, 0.06719528883695602, -0.5996528267860413, -0.19819507002830505, 0.19516293704509735, -0.5248929858207703, 0.006748982705175877, -0.6878530979156494, -0.41572105884552, -0.08900532871484756, 0.6437950730323792, -0.1585029512643814, 0.010477124713361263, 0.5282666683197021, -0.23518861830234528, -0.39729371666908264, 0.37664172053337097, 0.4618666172027588, 0.9203943014144897, -0.27695775032043457, 0.13143333792686462, 0.15244196355342865, -1.0170856714248657, 0.2989713251590729, 0.24285908043384552, -0.1511916220188141, -0.003637137357145548, 0.5777314305305481, 0.7139488458633423, 0.12884552776813507, -1.0629472732543945, 0.5783703923225403, -0.1409420371055603, -0.0029763218481093645, -0.3459547758102417, -0.04555400460958481, -0.42021968960762024, 0.11652921885251999, 0.6435626149177551, -0.40326860547065735, 0.2053869366645813, -0.8630123138427734, 0.4754508435726166, -0.0679791197180748, -0.6314080357551575, -0.5654255747795105, 0.5384670495986938, 0.4745636582374573, -0.03304707631468773, 0.26126524806022644, 0.07884853333234787, -0.5754010677337646, 0.4074579179286957, 0.3647371530532837, 0.9194949269294739, -0.38575294613838196, 0.20519132912158966, 0.24332298338413239, 0.22200016677379608, 0.12433600425720215, 0.3246600925922394, 0.6554593443870544, -0.44816550612449646, -0.5393683910369873, -0.6902251243591309, -0.5401950478553772, -0.0717574879527092, -0.6797088980674744, 0.009176886640489101, -0.42981478571891785, -0.3914097249507904, -0.14091899991035461, 0.13909494876861572, -0.02920687384903431, 0.28251269459724426, 0.10522891581058502, 0.672069787979126, -0.878535270690918, 0.9501875638961792, 0.7926680445671082, -0.4950310289859772, -0.5821778774261475, 0.12975361943244934, -0.09264711290597916, -0.6043775677680969, 0.8781524896621704, -0.10909207910299301, -0.1353808492422104, -0.41333481669425964, 0.056557949632406235, -0.751062273979187, 0.9170610904693604, 0.22914645075798035, -0.8234268426895142, 0.15904365479946136, 0.10753348469734192, 0.901870846748352, -0.5528523325920105, -0.17981643974781036, 0.5947849154472351, 0.03400992602109909, -0.12751039862632751, -1.1406978368759155, 0.09319651126861572, -0.2774102985858917, -0.3738384246826172, 0.053675856441259384, -0.6624726057052612, 0.7434914112091064, -0.373496413230896, -0.394320011138916, -0.28907284140586853, 0.5849605202674866, 0.10147982090711594, 0.4319557547569275, 0.2293790578842163, 0.3702108860015869, 0.819007158279419, -0.03281135857105255, 1.2257059812545776, -0.24631570279598236, 0.13438865542411804, 0.8607198596000671, -0.7044612765312195, 0.9973410367965698, 0.31451424956321716, -0.19895096123218536, 0.8617429137229919, 0.4946528673171997, 0.28819015622138977, 1.0403598546981812, 0.014433658681809902, -0.45132264494895935, -0.08633220940828323, -0.14161010086536407, -0.348136842250824, 0.48050379753112793, 0.5752383470535278, -0.183872252702713, 0.05110016092658043, 0.37826967239379883, -0.3323739767074585, 0.17076930403709412, -0.2067202627658844, 1.0730713605880737, 0.33543381094932556, -0.4847966432571411, 0.6487585306167603, 0.07028748095035553, 0.3528176248073578, -0.7051436901092529, 0.012688851915299892, -0.3586363196372986, 0.7567031979560852, -0.20375020802021027, -0.5291929841041565, 0.5697929263114929, 0.3305667042732239, -0.21753689646720886, 0.0914059430360794, 0.8200171589851379, -0.2482421100139618, -0.5419114232063293, 0.5858719944953918, 0.5971241593360901, -0.08494125306606293, 0.08621657639741898, -0.7250707745552063, 0.3498218059539795, -0.3485499918460846, -0.29965850710868835, 0.3364466726779938, 0.45943090319633484, -0.256603866815567, 0.7204256057739258, 0.5761041641235352, 0.33563223481178284, -0.12970465421676636, 0.4062204957008362, 1.0729565620422363, -0.4003235995769501, -0.5579780340194702, -0.6656089425086975, 0.47726133465766907, 0.2339775711297989, -0.1263890266418457, 0.7619596123695374, 0.4889678359031677, 0.031227614730596542, 0.21020032465457916, 0.7623085379600525, 0.2009919285774231, 0.7756197452545166, -0.45672696828842163, 0.6084691286087036, -0.5523996949195862, 0.6482393741607666, 0.01887119747698307, -0.32177940011024475, -0.24808087944984436, 0.4420456886291504, -0.7000372409820557, -0.0826101303100586, 0.5405384302139282, 0.48159751296043396, 0.0013787499628961086, -0.459811806678772, 0.26426807045936584, 0.48150870203971863, 0.11632394045591354, 0.5572636723518372, 0.8894826769828796, -0.5356674194335938, 0.6105700135231018, -0.05661480128765106, -0.4889206290245056, -0.4570440351963043, -0.6471385359764099, -0.9466173648834229, -0.2694817781448364, -0.486208438873291, -0.2983653247356415, 0.5455036163330078, 0.5071921348571777, 0.7021487951278687, -1.0117907524108887, 0.03671887144446373, 0.023177489638328552, -0.16004061698913574, -0.21722197532653809, -0.14556732773780823, 0.5272270441055298, 0.1036396324634552, -0.4826720952987671, 0.43809065222740173, 0.6927605271339417, 0.16847307980060577, -0.16301240026950836, -0.05907433107495308, -0.336387574672699, 0.20152077078819275, 0.5148473381996155, 0.12282168865203857, -0.6261071562767029, 0.14875391125679016, 0.03219572827219963, -0.6267428398132324, 0.009473522193729877, 0.7546846270561218, -0.5103278756141663, 0.15306270122528076, 0.2691021263599396, 0.33121517300605774, 0.41896846890449524, -0.22283242642879486, 0.9246413707733154, -0.44466713070869446, 0.39368847012519836, 0.5012362003326416, 0.4607914984226227, 0.384615033864975, -0.4682440757751465, 0.5544653534889221, 0.2507219612598419, -0.3414444625377655, -1.0312308073043823, 0.13986919820308685, -1.0565314292907715, -0.4009108543395996, 1.3610798120498657, -0.3707016706466675, -0.33151474595069885, -0.5555794835090637, -0.3178047835826874, 0.29135140776634216, -0.32132241129875183, 0.8258127570152283, 0.13152046501636505, 0.10518612712621689, -0.12381123751401901, -0.802020788192749, 0.5567124485969543, 0.20338982343673706, -0.6794838905334473, 0.23538647592067719, 0.4960485100746155, 0.5275417566299438, -0.1225849837064743, 0.9575831294059753, -0.2067861706018448, 0.4994182586669922, 0.11571197956800461, -0.04067561402916908, 0.015612263232469559, -0.3578647971153259, -0.44227591156959534, 0.11802380532026291, 0.03775429725646973, 0.07986260950565338 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06973v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06973v1	Event-Keyed Summarization	2024-02-10T15:32:53	2024-02-10T15:32:53	William Gantt, Alexander Martin, Pavlo Kuchmiichuk, Aaron Steven White	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	We introduce event-keyed summarization (EKS), a novel task that marries traditional summarization and document-level event extraction, with the goal of generating a contextualized summary for a specific event, given a document and an extracted event structure. We introduce a dataset for this task, MUCSUM, consisting of summaries of all events in the classic MUC-4 dataset, along with a set of baselines that comprises both pretrained LM standards in the summarization literature, as well as larger frontier models. We show that ablations that reduce EKS to traditional summarization or structure-to-text yield inferior summaries of target events and that MUCSUM is a robust benchmark for this task. Lastly, we conduct a human evaluation of both reference and model summaries, and provide some detailed analysis of the results.	[ -0.24517890810966492, -0.4502575993537903, 0.5266891717910767, -0.5124319791793823, -0.5134375691413879, 0.18851521611213684, -0.17915627360343933, -0.28525057435035706, 0.47339287400245667, 0.5083363652229309, -0.5701418519020081, -0.8515794277191162, -0.26341572403907776, 0.08660918474197388, -0.35053157806396484, 1.3754756450653076, -0.04842841997742653, -0.18990272283554077, -0.19025751948356628, -0.2895495295524597, -0.031786855310201645, -0.7268836498260498, -0.45124149322509766, -0.24296975135803223, 0.6489214897155762, 0.670354962348938, 0.14709876477718353, 0.8289083242416382, 0.7604271173477173, 0.11752992123365402, -0.3121434152126312, 0.11967587471008301, -0.44598743319511414, 0.13863739371299744, 0.20968900620937347, -0.508560836315155, -0.8796750903129578, 0.014812462031841278, 0.7799445390701294, 0.680806040763855, -0.08267999440431595, 0.4499291479587555, 0.09997311234474182, 0.7897763252258301, -0.8756989240646362, 0.09522947669029236, -0.6205049157142639, 0.09218260645866394, -0.5086902379989624, -0.36150673031806946, -0.15921944379806519, -0.15646055340766907, -0.1649327576160431, -0.4932267665863037, 0.45578864216804504, -0.28807687759399414, 0.6612043380737305, -0.08419127762317657, -0.7943739891052246, -0.4741693139076233, -0.7157074213027954, 0.713651180267334, -0.644871711730957, 0.45363157987594604, 0.3630461096763611, 0.308877170085907, 0.2852886915206909, -0.9602183699607849, -0.20155172049999237, 0.09528756886720657, -0.26314863562583923, 0.3441009819507599, 0.2729238271713257, 0.2861206531524658, 0.34325334429740906, 0.5799673795700073, -0.6159802079200745, -0.032509252429008484, -0.740889847278595, -0.02129780501127243, 0.7666798233985901, 0.5453529953956604, -0.11204461753368378, -0.11326717585325241, 0.13345156610012054, -0.09474323689937592, -0.9420051574707031, 0.08946451544761658, 0.24795447289943695, 0.33217841386795044, -0.3506966531276703, 0.535879909992218, -0.6847637891769409, 0.34931883215904236, 0.012161740101873875, -0.4163769483566284, 0.3166244626045227, -0.7023765444755554, -0.08640354871749878, 0.10901757329702377, 0.47816646099090576, 0.7801016569137573, -0.20794561505317688, -0.3643464148044586, -0.0037313662469387054, -0.020787160843610764, -0.0736338421702385, -0.7416977882385254, 0.005569153930991888, 0.38854146003723145, -0.8203860521316528, -0.4409630000591278, -0.1024179607629776, -1.0239312648773193, -0.22770002484321594, -0.31693536043167114, 0.07303422689437866, -0.05827243998646736, 0.07352267950773239, -0.3866668939590454, -0.5996647477149963, 0.21086998283863068, 0.17564836144447327, -0.9418792128562927, 0.4431139826774597, 0.6008557081222534, 0.8873584866523743, -0.40718817710876465, -0.18747606873512268, -0.5825093984603882, 0.39021286368370056, -0.40423035621643066, 0.6815742254257202, -0.3202041983604431, -0.47575631737709045, -0.0658797100186348, -0.2826065421104431, 0.32415497303009033, -0.37047621607780457, 0.6410733461380005, -0.4429655373096466, -0.22585809230804443, -0.559089720249176, -0.5053796768188477, -0.0724816620349884, 0.23781132698059082, -0.5697271823883057, 0.9627552628517151, -0.25682005286216736, -0.5524725317955017, 0.42396941781044006, -0.6500152349472046, -0.6549865007400513, -0.07443352788686752, -0.40146541595458984, -0.47688281536102295, 0.3131895363330841, 0.31612521409988403, 0.5675510764122009, 0.26797598600387573, -0.08310578018426895, -0.214644655585289, 0.09098561853170395, -0.04676857218146324, 0.014397325925529003, 0.29133009910583496, 0.4292713701725006, -0.06451550126075745, -0.022285383194684982, -1.0561306476593018, -0.2874820828437805, 0.031193438917398453, -0.29884424805641174, -0.29262909293174744, 0.4046468734741211, -0.11619283258914948, 0.0651625320315361, 0.3870408833026886, -0.5003310441970825, 0.20743459463119507, -0.3370784819126129, 0.18496759235858917, 0.2901383638381958, 0.3418130874633789, 0.7007459998130798, -0.36656105518341064, 0.33205825090408325, -0.09084401279687881, -0.020768962800502777, -0.9569867253303528, -0.034770917147397995, -0.4247291386127472, -0.4285348951816559, 0.07755153626203537, 0.3272382318973541, -0.41385161876678467, 0.39124390482902527, -0.4006650447845459, -0.6305408477783203, 0.07958125323057175, -0.10700467228889465, 0.12527640163898468, 0.48198145627975464, 0.20013314485549927, -0.13836601376533508, -0.4646633267402649, -0.9144378900527954, -0.4373214542865753, 0.08343818038702011, -0.1981574147939682, -0.06698080897331238, 0.3429277241230011, 0.3350163996219635, 0.8207874298095703, -0.589633584022522, -0.5367389917373657, -0.5664451718330383, 0.5604112148284912, 0.007829666137695312, 0.3068253993988037, 0.6361289024353027, -0.5459936261177063, -0.417946994304657, 0.22594405710697174, -0.632414698600769, -0.08328879624605179, -0.1006036177277565, 0.30631542205810547, 0.013155634514987469, 0.8593960404396057, -0.394682914018631, 0.8338250517845154, 0.2658444941043854, -0.1403815597295761, 0.4308602809906006, -0.20354175567626953, 0.5204668045043945, -1.0738836526870728, 0.4138612151145935, -0.5394149422645569, -0.4347807466983795, -0.7234876751899719, 0.19724717736244202, 0.3152271509170532, -0.32760247588157654, -0.30494675040245056, 0.3487299084663391, -0.6751695275306702, -0.45523589849472046, -0.30438193678855896, 0.17088201642036438, 0.005810296628624201, 0.6616916060447693, 0.2673098146915436, 0.10933178663253784, 0.09340300410985947, -0.6677635312080383, 0.2683885395526886, 0.3861931562423706, -0.19236882030963898, 0.46873438358306885, -0.3625841736793518, 0.1628568470478058, -0.3104037046432495, 0.35961100459098816, -0.7167454957962036, -0.22751113772392273, -0.17553837597370148, -0.5202614665031433, 0.29558321833610535, 0.04053502157330513, -0.31742918491363525, 0.0032673778478056192, -0.7285094857215881, 0.5262911319732666, 0.3363932967185974, -0.24582861363887787, 1.023034930229187, 0.48313719034194946, -0.6037963032722473, -0.38094064593315125, -0.5899403095245361, 0.08669417351484299, -0.25446638464927673, -0.19357700645923615, 0.40918904542922974, -0.062020789831876755, -0.20426377654075623, 0.09399238973855972, -0.2747419476509094, -0.14151304960250854, 0.08936810493469238, 0.13994358479976654, 0.1499287635087967, -0.1015804260969162, -0.05320176109671593, 0.32203593850135803, 0.055621515959501266, -0.06473415344953537, 0.19700968265533447, 0.17221862077713013, 0.23621881008148193, -0.3444691002368927, -0.5627895593643188, 0.7680273652076721, 0.7422220706939697, -0.5239479541778564, 0.40252164006233215, 0.0314340740442276, -0.7248038649559021, 0.226983442902565, -0.46678540110588074, -0.31779980659484863, -0.3646196722984314, 0.6643289923667908, -0.3446795344352722, -0.6621957421302795, 1.0048304796218872, 0.04893764108419418, 0.7511841654777527, 0.6290868520736694, 0.6679835915565491, -0.3132750988006592, 1.1097033023834229, 0.35796475410461426, -0.22219039499759674, 0.5971454381942749, -0.2585130035877228, -0.015617863275110722, -0.828485369682312, -0.14152996242046356, -0.7477860450744629, -0.495973140001297, -0.08632586896419525, 0.08940739184617996, 0.6881732940673828, -0.0074860816821455956, 0.08911454677581787, -0.0025169565342366695, -0.06894516944885254, 0.7080413103103638, 0.334402859210968, 0.023686734959483147, 0.5511539578437805, -0.29749900102615356, 0.10350768268108368, 0.05521257594227791, -0.7467771768569946, -0.5813233256340027, 1.5483200550079346, 0.16606909036636353, 0.48203662037849426, -0.05736523121595383, 0.9142565131187439, 0.36134034395217896, 0.5138564705848694, -0.37521567940711975, 0.24997031688690186, 0.12256181240081787, -0.8217310905456543, -0.5550212860107422, -0.35720834136009216, -0.9188278317451477, 0.1671219915151596, -0.2454485148191452, -0.9755491614341736, 0.18929144740104675, 0.22177669405937195, -0.6375328302383423, 0.2848917543888092, -0.3580264151096344, 0.7960699796676636, -0.03987231105566025, 0.24688613414764404, -0.5898236036300659, -0.8493902087211609, 0.48250624537467957, -0.0642775371670723, 0.6776491403579712, -0.07267505675554276, -0.12814512848854065, 0.9486778974533081, -0.4145835041999817, 0.5696897506713867, 0.15659798681735992, 0.274224191904068, 0.17606262862682343, 0.02499445527791977, 0.7602262496948242, -0.03704610839486122, 0.16003334522247314, -0.00843004696071148, 0.23289059102535248, -0.24454376101493835, -0.6139240264892578, 0.520821750164032, -0.4360046684741974, -0.13149507343769073, -0.2891550064086914, -0.4972747266292572, -0.013490605168044567, 0.11366485804319382, 0.5425248146057129, 1.055098533630371, -0.5550493597984314, 0.17220038175582886, 0.3251631259918213, 0.12138079851865768, 0.6151854991912842, 0.5152704119682312, 0.0626973882317543, -0.5241244435310364, 0.6623744368553162, 0.3209061920642853, 0.28311654925346375, 0.621695876121521, -0.05378996580839157, -0.11293450742959976, -0.8287688493728638, -0.2680251896381378, 0.2168552428483963, -0.8539772629737854, -0.29396650195121765, -0.7369503974914551, -0.1321479231119156, -0.6175724864006042, -0.6619706749916077, -0.5582977533340454, -0.6995968818664551, -0.41686975955963135, -0.556527853012085, -0.21462364494800568, 0.7064944505691528, -0.2590201497077942, 0.38197699189186096, -1.2905949354171753, 0.5884378552436829, 0.07242535054683685, 0.11674308031797409, -0.0241770651191473, -0.3135538697242737, -0.5904417037963867, -0.22346454858779907, -0.7107938528060913, -1.2269448041915894, 0.28285008668899536, 0.35628628730773926, 0.6168439984321594, 0.7424505352973938, 0.2823454439640045, 0.4480702579021454, -0.5431423783302307, 0.9795037508010864, 0.2283930629491806, -0.8888712525367737, 0.6343865990638733, -0.4541354775428772, 0.4251781702041626, 0.7880695462226868, 0.03882678598165512, -0.7874525189399719, -0.7791616916656494, -0.8812813758850098, -0.901409387588501, 0.9269885420799255, 0.3466469645500183, -0.3118065893650055, 0.04841969534754753, 0.5225237011909485, 0.09936276078224182, 0.2523682415485382, -0.5586927533149719, -0.4196085035800934, 0.16080224514007568, -0.5430234670639038, -0.41109699010849, -0.3585805296897888, -0.11700284481048584, 0.14636315405368805, 0.6737420558929443, 0.0002643733168952167, -0.16237391531467438, 0.42823487520217896, -0.33980968594551086, -0.16794058680534363, 0.15178833901882172, 0.8194715976715088, 0.8212703466415405, -0.3757735788822174, 0.1616484522819519, 0.5616373419761658, -0.4320886731147766, -0.0853155255317688, 0.12367821484804153, -0.16260908544063568, 0.10244859755039215, 0.7292960286140442, 0.5566241145133972, 0.30257168412208557, -0.6618301868438721, 0.43266528844833374, -0.10935328155755997, -0.22082090377807617, -0.09224380552768707, -0.35685157775878906, -0.08298500627279282, 0.18531115353107452, 0.6902465224266052, -0.48001235723495483, 0.5457689166069031, -0.4953780472278595, 0.20820660889148712, 0.3113000988960266, -0.12627629935741425, -0.6998884677886963, 0.7302413582801819, 0.6093668341636658, -0.13506066799163818, 0.13622431457042694, -0.13276533782482147, -0.41903719305992126, 0.6728229522705078, -0.11396250873804092, 0.8698511719703674, -0.17526498436927795, -0.2368776798248291, 0.5642300844192505, 0.5246590971946716, 0.38945022225379944, 0.194136843085289, -0.3746975064277649, -0.30619141459465027, -0.43886494636535645, -0.22863149642944336, -0.4702973961830139, 0.43894270062446594, -0.9107547998428345, 0.4884386658668518, 0.03163528814911842, 0.1081698015332222, 0.18500512838363647, 0.0015026242472231388, -0.4893573820590973, 0.06052904203534126, 0.2517355680465698, 0.984999418258667, -0.8680014610290527, 0.22349189221858978, 0.6122035980224609, -0.05187511071562767, -0.22125668823719025, -0.32768192887306213, 0.24657823145389557, -0.07296105474233627, 0.09921392053365707, -0.17387685179710388, 0.5774669647216797, 0.05587921664118767, -0.028021493926644325, -0.9432985186576843, 1.2669342756271362, 0.03770392760634422, -0.5975784659385681, -0.27708423137664795, 0.22248980402946472, 0.10660915821790695, -0.2063063234090805, 0.11612773686647415, 0.7762433886528015, 0.31493645906448364, -0.17863692343235016, -0.885617733001709, -0.29600563645362854, 0.125362828373909, -0.6296746134757996, 0.5922392010688782, -0.5385423302650452, 0.54050213098526, 0.020377255976200104, -0.43231201171875, 0.04468252882361412, 0.9262869954109192, 0.07359497994184494, 0.7771490216255188, 0.2621462047100067, 0.5902559757232666, 0.6905671954154968, -0.028941599652171135, 0.9614908695220947, -0.3117643892765045, 0.33302775025367737, 1.192866563796997, -0.21772658824920654, 0.5386591553688049, 0.3818514347076416, -0.0655062347650528, -0.05543913319706917, 0.7163780331611633, 0.6114392280578613, 0.7867703437805176, -0.19441932439804077, -0.14953844249248505, 0.06066027656197548, 0.3809475004673004, -0.42308831214904785, 0.3599640429019928, 0.41172581911087036, -0.2791484296321869, -0.8607153296470642, -0.0052336435765028, -0.1749933660030365, -0.22473429143428802, -0.7223836183547974, 1.1877501010894775, 0.08306166529655457, -0.5496980547904968, -0.07229414582252502, 0.10969419032335281, 0.17341406643390656, -0.8979034423828125, 0.18881481885910034, -0.37697482109069824, 0.12897196412086487, -0.03286595642566681, -0.35592207312583923, 0.5677658915519714, 0.12526777386665344, -0.3247915804386139, -0.00023301849432755262, 0.6739963889122009, -0.6461322903633118, -0.4226123094558716, -0.29428574442863464, 0.3570127785205841, 0.27049562335014343, -0.16216525435447693, -0.05841992050409317, 0.04121461883187294, -0.25052204728126526, -0.46698179841041565, 0.42043331265449524, 0.40606874227523804, -0.10200198739767075, 0.25284212827682495, 0.4651002287864685, 0.13691982626914978, 0.0011981293791905046, -0.20141363143920898, 0.7877243161201477, -0.7315797209739685, -1.1094697713851929, -0.8301822543144226, 0.6373036503791809, -0.15899470448493958, -0.37336039543151855, 0.5530366897583008, 1.112273931503296, 0.48424655199050903, 0.146393284201622, 0.9840030670166016, 0.24075739085674286, 0.7158319354057312, -0.4722128212451935, 0.6767736077308655, -0.6296864748001099, -0.15203136205673218, -0.16430433094501495, -0.7421906590461731, -0.1611618995666504, 0.11279547959566116, 0.15446197986602783, -0.3848750591278076, 0.7810026407241821, 0.44815558195114136, 0.02879182994365692, -0.048871543258428574, 0.3521234095096588, -0.14489586651325226, 0.3534252643585205, 0.33869603276252747, 0.7208717465400696, -0.2236076146364212, 0.5691195726394653, -0.11379043012857437, -0.6250675320625305, -0.5200726389884949, -1.0915340185165405, -0.9232235550880432, -0.9165663123130798, -0.43867677450180054, 0.10529658198356628, 0.13889779150485992, 0.7102898359298706, 0.6260949373245239, -0.7784801721572876, -0.2574983835220337, 0.20489539206027985, 0.14040564000606537, -0.2854743003845215, -0.16301114857196808, 0.493558406829834, -0.37095412611961365, -0.7329326868057251, 0.3915104568004608, 0.2971555292606354, 0.09888715296983719, 0.26362118124961853, 0.15148590505123138, 0.16833841800689697, 0.14524933695793152, 0.4038170278072357, 0.4175718128681183, -0.27303820848464966, -0.15988881886005402, -0.1121494397521019, -0.012185926549136639, 0.02891690470278263, 1.139370322227478, -0.4329904317855835, 0.16797207295894623, 0.5587592124938965, 0.48945581912994385, 0.9528459310531616, -0.1514599472284317, 0.6169144511222839, -1.0749958753585815, 0.1980724185705185, 0.28388187289237976, 0.39852651953697205, -0.1763034462928772, -0.40965479612350464, 0.29818445444107056, 0.19780851900577545, -0.44805049896240234, -1.0294877290725708, 0.1172693595290184, -1.0756343603134155, -0.06411513686180115, 1.0164633989334106, 0.05433399975299835, -0.14132794737815857, -0.06795302778482437, -0.14254270493984222, 0.427285373210907, -0.2386375367641449, 0.696272611618042, 0.815760612487793, -0.13939595222473145, 0.07805950939655304, -0.18400469422340393, 0.7040185332298279, -0.04192376509308815, -1.0238772630691528, 0.38156482577323914, 0.6630525588989258, -0.007915560156106949, 0.14952631294727325, 0.8682120442390442, -0.1537984013557434, 0.4824531078338623, -0.13208690285682678, 0.46742865443229675, -0.17570467293262482, -0.37189608812332153, -0.42969444394111633, 0.32654833793640137, -0.27561473846435547, -0.35142192244529724 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06967v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06967v2	Instruct Once, Chat Consistently in Multiple Rounds: An Efficient Tuning Framework for Dialogue	2024-02-10T14:52:52	2024-05-30T04:57:36	Jian Wang, Chak Tou Leong, Jiashuo Wang, Dongding Lin, Wenjie Li, Xiao-Yong Wei	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Tuning language models for dialogue generation has been a prevalent paradigm for building capable dialogue agents. Yet, traditional tuning narrowly views dialogue generation as resembling other language generation tasks, ignoring the role disparities between two speakers and the multi-round interactive process that dialogues ought to be. Such a manner often leads to unsatisfactory chat consistency for the built agent. In this work, we emphasize the interactive, communicative nature of dialogue and argue that it is more feasible to model the speaker roles of agent and user separately, enabling the agent to adhere to its role consistently. With this in mind, we propose an efficient Multi-round Interactive Dialogue Tuning (Midi-Tuning) framework. It models the agent and user individually with two adapters built upon large language models. The adapters make use of respective utterances round by round in alternating order and they are tuned via a round-level memory caching mechanism. Extensive experiments demonstrate that, our framework performs superior to traditional fine-tuning and harbors the tremendous potential for improving dialogue consistency.	[ -0.43430522084236145, -0.7480215430259705, 0.4680847227573395, 0.23444564640522003, -0.027068698778748512, 0.2571159899234772, -0.36205971240997314, -0.2238263189792633, 0.021031079813838005, 0.5931678414344788, -0.6659750938415527, -0.24058040976524353, -0.2199128419160843, -0.12782417237758636, -0.029236428439617157, 0.9154182076454163, 0.4840550422668457, 0.01139468140900135, 0.20577676594257355, -0.25376808643341064, -0.5508923530578613, -0.08030464500188828, -1.1733620166778564, -0.3304494321346283, 0.4463889002799988, 0.7243305444717407, 1.022301197052002, 0.5681713223457336, 0.09036916494369507, 0.45737507939338684, 0.23060710728168488, 0.44918209314346313, -0.6184566020965576, 0.27634385228157043, 0.16174209117889404, -0.37268468737602234, -0.5093957781791687, 0.11531811207532883, 0.6681538224220276, 0.4317488670349121, -0.6160447597503662, -0.2596278786659241, -0.1403168886899948, 0.4694668650627136, -0.22095924615859985, 0.12740013003349304, -1.1042927503585815, -0.3707583248615265, -0.14009353518486023, -0.44140246510505676, -0.48140665888786316, -0.4687335789203644, -0.11834166198968887, -1.0842026472091675, 0.26235610246658325, 0.20801126956939697, 0.6505329012870789, 0.36202412843704224, -0.46462905406951904, -0.18548054993152618, -0.6848440766334534, 0.513365626335144, -0.7946385741233826, 0.2985340654850006, 0.3004628121852875, 0.772450864315033, -0.5129364728927612, -0.5376606583595276, -0.6333606243133545, -0.2791464924812317, 0.12758514285087585, 0.09578757733106613, 0.020911702886223793, 0.3415296971797943, 0.24558469653129578, 0.3091129958629608, -0.20579957962036133, 0.007257878314703703, -0.07131622731685638, -0.2909688651561737, 0.3474538326263428, 0.1279032677412033, 0.3436422049999237, 0.3420325815677643, -0.07792319357395172, -0.1932547241449356, -0.5818203091621399, 0.029288675636053085, 0.8671534061431885, 0.5947933197021484, -0.044383205473423004, 0.3793109059333801, -0.22443921864032745, 0.7365347146987915, 0.5950825810432434, -0.3731847107410431, -0.15829327702522278, -0.5061741471290588, 0.12498554587364197, 0.24799902737140656, 0.49532198905944824, 0.4964819848537445, 0.5662577748298645, -0.06365390121936798, -0.17986589670181274, 0.02674367092549801, 0.8165963888168335, -0.687884509563446, -0.3972221910953522, -0.06439899653196335, -0.05569884553551674, -0.19390220940113068, 0.05193862318992615, -0.659163773059845, -0.24465280771255493, -0.34061506390571594, 0.4917389750480652, -0.6041849851608276, -0.35606077313423157, 0.1632535606622696, -0.09126142412424088, 0.02406230941414833, 0.3680994510650635, -1.0362285375595093, 0.5113816857337952, 0.6420795917510986, 0.7048670649528503, 0.32592231035232544, -0.30339252948760986, -0.9645015597343445, 0.2398654967546463, -0.3931591510772705, 0.8160103559494019, -0.8591315150260925, -0.4308747351169586, 0.07867535203695297, 0.032073013484478, -0.15062442421913147, -0.4587589502334595, 0.2476205974817276, -0.1588110774755478, 0.10634327679872513, -0.12283088266849518, -0.4940010607242584, 0.12808562815189362, 0.10144911706447601, -0.4464787542819977, 1.0375266075134277, 0.27704718708992004, -0.28328627347946167, 0.5090820789337158, -0.5989124774932861, -0.3181457817554474, -0.13155165314674377, -0.09732445329427719, -0.5325959324836731, 0.3474462032318115, 0.2622145116329193, -0.019659778103232384, -0.03205980360507965, 0.12723714113235474, -0.44278445839881897, -0.4036114811897278, 0.1777869164943695, -0.38051867485046387, 0.2706618010997772, 0.1525266468524933, -0.20395579934120178, 0.21327629685401917, -0.7603648900985718, 0.10300426930189133, -0.3768036961555481, -0.13771817088127136, -0.026789681985974312, 0.16620312631130219, -0.05039672181010246, 0.16171713173389435, -0.19140101969242096, -0.6529890298843384, 0.4183143973350525, -0.5320678353309631, 0.5416030287742615, 0.7406129837036133, 0.0439923070371151, 0.6740542650222778, -0.716912031173706, 0.49043983221054077, 0.15382637083530426, 0.007591891568154097, -0.6079052090644836, -0.4207339286804199, -0.8694815635681152, -0.37958675622940063, 0.09536337107419968, 0.2839551866054535, -0.6259708404541016, 0.40449756383895874, -0.0922914370894432, -0.5657464861869812, -0.874931812286377, 0.059601835906505585, 0.2632332444190979, 0.2799217700958252, 0.045148108154535294, -0.2739467918872833, -0.1840096414089203, -0.9053435921669006, -0.19904488325119019, -0.2932698130607605, 0.0707949697971344, 0.4487673342227936, 0.00993812084197998, 0.1458720713853836, 0.8591815233230591, -0.2970804274082184, -0.00885834638029337, -0.07917046546936035, 0.22187764942646027, 0.02865726500749588, 0.6716500520706177, 0.6122748851776123, -0.35453078150749207, -0.6812307834625244, 0.2534172832965851, -0.24053095281124115, -0.24325378239154816, -0.5015316009521484, -0.5404188632965088, 0.20536604523658752, 0.5817306041717529, -0.6220546960830688, 0.4386111795902252, 0.2384168803691864, -0.1815127432346344, 0.34604161977767944, -0.26882433891296387, 0.3852490484714508, -1.0452821254730225, -0.21660225093364716, -0.23839403688907623, -0.5409672856330872, -0.6966156363487244, -0.3454037308692932, -0.13192009925842285, -0.188845694065094, 0.05594830960035324, 0.627511203289032, -0.3189423680305481, 0.10966614633798599, -0.4462856948375702, 0.359043687582016, 0.014888185076415539, 0.6257920265197754, -0.21715979278087616, 0.9938833713531494, 0.5358688831329346, -0.6446619629859924, 0.1290108859539032, 0.08709285408258438, -0.3475096821784973, 0.9842240214347839, -0.8132460713386536, 0.25822412967681885, 0.15637528896331787, 0.28773272037506104, -1.031477689743042, -0.13420939445495605, 0.1399337351322174, -0.3099934458732605, 0.5874856114387512, -0.2944730222225189, -0.5773189067840576, 0.005079785827547312, -0.09096774458885193, 0.36828166246414185, 0.22252506017684937, -0.5495256781578064, 0.5574957132339478, 0.5140693187713623, -0.1656510978937149, 0.04845311865210533, 0.061661284416913986, -0.15348096191883087, -0.3730119466781616, -0.8697559833526611, 0.1965000182390213, -0.3122883439064026, -0.10040516406297684, -0.5798327922821045, -0.4977801442146301, 0.088936448097229, 0.08620585501194, 0.25954362750053406, -0.269041508436203, -0.21867506206035614, 0.32710301876068115, 0.16768141090869904, -0.34523719549179077, -0.4483710825443268, -0.5943348407745361, 0.4906509518623352, 0.07200171053409576, -0.5142552256584167, -0.5294397473335266, 0.5896772742271423, 0.8117697834968567, -0.03693845495581627, 0.5096303820610046, 0.5265364050865173, -0.015113241039216518, -0.19959630072116852, -0.8537064790725708, -0.3913678228855133, -0.5394429564476013, 0.08512135595083237, -0.6068684458732605, -0.8976572751998901, 0.6849481463432312, -0.31327760219573975, 0.3981102705001831, 0.10264419764280319, 0.6000949144363403, -0.1550038903951645, 1.1812649965286255, 0.938069224357605, -0.0016862540505826473, 0.7889888882637024, 0.27298983931541443, 0.3015718460083008, -0.5385516881942749, 0.08636674284934998, -0.8482152223587036, -0.24928396940231323, -0.8141979575157166, -0.08724954724311829, 0.6551588773727417, 0.178096741437912, -0.4712570905685425, 0.24674572050571442, -0.347719669342041, 0.4692949950695038, 0.6173226237297058, 0.0023491044994443655, 0.21700869500637054, -0.014152955263853073, -0.2314997911453247, 0.12183842808008194, -0.8204296231269836, -0.5980468988418579, 0.7585344314575195, 0.12316704541444778, 0.7605019807815552, 0.15445522964000702, 0.594348132610321, 0.004130850546061993, -0.13528406620025635, -0.4932839870452881, 0.3306379020214081, 0.20801568031311035, -0.6876785159111023, -0.5278756022453308, -0.36856260895729065, -0.9323291778564453, 0.155087411403656, 0.006007755175232887, -0.9776020050048828, -0.07999889552593231, 0.2916422188282013, -0.29914212226867676, 0.08129461109638214, -0.7580810785293579, 0.930491030216217, 0.08150312304496765, -0.16712507605552673, -0.5695509314537048, -0.7414673566818237, 0.16272597014904022, -0.04419686272740364, 0.1009228304028511, -0.3873264789581299, 0.24032562971115112, 0.15946967899799347, -0.6029337048530579, 0.7642044425010681, -0.18458814918994904, -0.03426540642976761, 0.20751230418682098, 0.14203017950057983, 0.5216984152793884, 0.6215859055519104, -0.17200662195682526, -0.2912384271621704, 0.22464922070503235, -0.6495708227157593, -0.8948132395744324, 0.5137287974357605, -0.8091220259666443, -0.6626460552215576, -0.17157508432865143, -0.6401519775390625, -0.39867475628852844, 0.01735459826886654, 0.018886979669332504, 0.7289296388626099, -0.4309302866458893, -0.060229960829019547, 0.5585984587669373, -0.16597701609134674, 0.43912866711616516, 0.6633057594299316, -0.22841531038284302, -0.3582008183002472, 0.8779536485671997, -0.20855870842933655, 0.7238221764564514, 0.15179699659347534, -0.007273710798472166, 0.05527228116989136, -0.09577687084674835, -0.6860374808311462, 0.05310958996415138, -0.15546081960201263, -0.19069711863994598, -0.47107169032096863, -0.21454313397407532, -0.2691706418991089, -0.29145681858062744, -0.6434469223022461, -0.5742659568786621, 0.08952663838863373, 0.0860779881477356, 0.6093531250953674, 0.5505837798118591, -0.1588737666606903, 0.8912268877029419, -0.7626103162765503, 0.4819435775279999, 0.4036301076412201, 0.5712183117866516, -0.23392069339752197, -0.4427855908870697, -0.4223436415195465, 0.35855627059936523, -0.5184774994850159, -0.6516432166099548, -0.03217985853552818, 0.6303228139877319, 0.8204159140586853, 0.47530263662338257, -0.09297715872526169, 0.9768819808959961, -0.780128002166748, 0.5376359820365906, 0.11013329774141312, -0.8835093379020691, 0.5755412578582764, -0.6703373789787292, 0.7888778448104858, 0.9388542771339417, -0.22362667322158813, -0.6521174311637878, -0.8151815533638, -0.5560013651847839, -0.5098243951797485, 1.1081805229187012, 0.47016239166259766, 0.29638299345970154, -0.07817176729440689, 0.26944756507873535, 0.3761795163154602, 0.37821099162101746, -0.29921749234199524, -0.10149458795785904, -0.40853896737098694, 0.07536954432725906, -0.11498194932937622, 0.045871343463659286, -0.22416457533836365, -0.2337125539779663, 0.739620566368103, -0.42491692304611206, 0.27114084362983704, -0.13233228027820587, 0.11428973078727722, -0.36912864446640015, 0.22351832687854767, 0.6749368906021118, 0.5770267248153687, -0.06653555482625961, -0.08623483777046204, -0.02414574660360813, -0.2952873706817627, 0.03921513259410858, -0.03822159394621849, -0.0022744620218873024, 0.0929986834526062, 0.01693607307970524, 0.8558465838432312, 0.6385430693626404, -0.2768189013004303, -0.06001422181725502, -0.1385209560394287, 0.011588497087359428, -0.1548299938440323, 0.3729099631309509, 0.162724569439888, 0.35065311193466187, -0.11303318291902542, 0.07051004469394684, -0.09357297420501709, -0.8677447438240051, 0.37611496448516846, 0.5374386310577393, -0.35145339369773865, -0.2404334992170334, 0.29150548577308655, 0.41224560141563416, -0.6763676404953003, 0.8675544261932373, -0.18316909670829773, -0.32864734530448914, 0.4184056222438812, 0.4215242564678192, 0.9911972284317017, -0.3452967405319214, 0.31474268436431885, 0.3640601634979248, 0.31089475750923157, -0.07903943955898285, 0.3496265709400177, -0.40811777114868164, -0.8221881985664368, -0.03266173601150513, -0.671265184879303, -0.3808070421218872, -0.4650259017944336, -0.6094003319740295, 0.21185459196567535, -0.16005274653434753, -0.2965962886810303, 0.3076328635215759, 0.050199732184410095, -0.4066811501979828, -0.22348752617835999, -0.19258525967597961, 0.7396675944328308, -0.32194700837135315, 1.1547572612762451, 0.37707942724227905, -0.12940329313278198, -0.5919370651245117, 0.045382846146821976, 0.3152580261230469, -0.5965991020202637, -0.26510441303253174, 0.23475460708141327, -0.3992059528827667, 0.23431484401226044, -0.5773677825927734, -0.6711889505386353, 0.7211272716522217, 0.3267662227153778, -0.7187554240226746, 0.09155676513910294, -0.08014166355133057, 0.5541885495185852, -0.6870198845863342, 0.4854890704154968, 0.7445366382598877, 0.52419513463974, 0.36617544293403625, -1.2913730144500732, -0.32764381170272827, -0.29951125383377075, -0.0455114021897316, 0.4989405572414398, -0.8856413960456848, 0.31902408599853516, 0.0007566795102320611, -0.2728738784790039, 0.37601548433303833, 0.45865172147750854, 0.31134721636772156, 0.2989465594291687, 0.6450707316398621, 0.47473230957984924, 0.7629858255386353, -0.28568753600120544, 0.6860479712486267, -0.7503058910369873, -0.08803102374076843, 1.259016513824463, -0.2728663682937622, 0.3367084264755249, 0.1966378092765808, 0.055720388889312744, 0.37527647614479065, 0.4259234368801117, 0.20952987670898438, 0.47011929750442505, 0.299126535654068, -0.26363199949264526, -0.7419570088386536, -0.0016760437283664942, -0.27350983023643494, 0.6908919215202332, 0.32755574584007263, 0.22487129271030426, -0.29820242524147034, -0.11822523921728134, -0.06234273687005043, 0.2741073966026306, -0.061713285744190216, 1.0381301641464233, 0.12345834076404572, -0.8849537372589111, 0.19736437499523163, -0.13665671646595, 0.179212749004364, -0.812755823135376, -0.16066601872444153, -0.2863001823425293, 0.10848608613014221, 0.12689083814620972, -0.3074091970920563, 0.230242058634758, -0.36029309034347534, -0.1746717095375061, -0.30981186032295227, 0.31781208515167236, -0.6339687705039978, -0.5421983003616333, -0.08009667694568634, 0.48175710439682007, 0.13559198379516602, 0.115337073802948, -0.5400076508522034, 0.01543397642672062, -0.07078229635953903, -0.07284659892320633, 0.3970274329185486, 0.8988580107688904, 0.10244063287973404, 0.6834493279457092, 0.46558141708374023, -0.25393617153167725, 0.14211854338645935, 0.4266512095928192, 0.8978581428527832, -0.6338850259780884, -0.548865556716919, -0.500809371471405, 0.75043123960495, -0.26573216915130615, -0.5293676853179932, 0.7138403058052063, 0.5154203176498413, 0.6270198225975037, 0.38297930359840393, 0.4726381301879883, 0.2394905537366867, 0.24347366392612457, -0.5548012256622314, 0.6324041485786438, -0.6044955253601074, 0.32910478115081787, -0.3182242810726166, -1.05107581615448, 0.11894377321004868, 0.6705971956253052, 0.3197574019432068, 0.3182009160518646, 0.5151066184043884, 1.2508025169372559, -0.2070026397705078, 0.34847700595855713, 0.49325108528137207, 0.2175627201795578, 0.2767324149608612, 0.2931688129901886, 0.7011160850524902, -0.2046186774969101, 0.3452788293361664, 0.0035942676477134228, -0.15604566037654877, -0.10546376556158066, -0.5890969634056091, -0.9206839203834534, -0.5712279081344604, -0.34098535776138306, -0.30051708221435547, 0.2534796893596649, 0.8458980321884155, 1.0679768323898315, -0.6809073686599731, -0.4822067320346832, -0.07561403512954712, 0.2333425134420395, -0.4136105179786682, -0.18632598221302032, -0.35650381445884705, -0.882797360420227, -0.9268710613250732, 0.6508026123046875, 0.7346305251121521, -0.23558194935321808, -0.09863808751106262, 0.018109247088432312, -0.21234296262264252, 0.5570754408836365, 0.30204135179519653, 0.23268266022205353, -0.7466925978660583, -0.5449687838554382, -0.05336183309555054, -0.19921088218688965, 0.2996276915073395, 1.025307297706604, -0.7505707144737244, 1.0315001010894775, 0.08083271235227585, 0.14736522734165192, 0.7355111837387085, 0.03625581040978432, 1.1877228021621704, -0.7600817680358887, 0.08054659515619278, -0.04245442524552345, 0.06400143355131149, 0.08346085250377655, -0.12574175000190735, 0.3310108482837677, -0.21178312599658966, -0.8917298913002014, -0.7194920778274536, 0.5493720173835754, -1.2508797645568848, -0.04299988970160484, 0.7874912023544312, 0.016537290066480637, 0.3660348653793335, -0.3257453739643097, -0.5628977417945862, 0.37646645307540894, -0.8173359036445618, 0.826795756816864, 0.728317141532898, -0.1476277858018875, -0.16985774040222168, -0.5471799969673157, 0.7215937376022339, 0.22585906088352203, -0.6101994514465332, 0.03944279998540878, 0.551957905292511, 0.02802281081676483, 0.02252848818898201, 0.7955854535102844, 0.21999774873256683, 0.33656561374664307, 0.4021246135234833, -0.2677730321884155, 0.08881143480539322, -0.591357946395874, -0.07639118283987045, 0.0647207498550415, 0.17380790412425995, 0.003982476890087128 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06964v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06964v1	NLP for Knowledge Discovery and Information Extraction from Energetics Corpora	2024-02-10T14:43:08	2024-02-10T14:43:08	Francis G. VanGessel, Efrem Perry, Salil Mohan, Oliver M. Barham, Mark Cavolowsky	cs.CL	cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci	We present a demonstration of the utility of NLP for aiding research into energetic materials and associated systems. The NLP method enables machine understanding of textual data, offering an automated route to knowledge discovery and information extraction from energetics text. We apply three established unsupervised NLP models: Latent Dirichlet Allocation, Word2Vec, and the Transformer to a large curated dataset of energetics-related scientific articles. We demonstrate that each NLP algorithm is capable of identifying energetic topics and concepts, generating a language model which aligns with Subject Matter Expert knowledge. Furthermore, we present a document classification pipeline for energetics text. Our classification pipeline achieves 59-76\% accuracy depending on the NLP model used, with the highest performing Transformer model rivaling inter-annotator agreement metrics. The NLP approaches studied in this work can identify concepts germane to energetics and therefore hold promise as a tool for accelerating energetics research efforts and energetics material development.	[ 0.04079453647136688, -0.31901538372039795, 0.5034082531929016, 0.05903632193803787, 0.07156071811914444, 0.3911139667034149, -0.3226339817047119, -0.4334073066711426, 0.3939264714717865, 0.3567739427089691, -0.15661486983299255, -0.5141361951828003, -0.494033545255661, 0.15371429920196533, -0.5131443738937378, 0.6937883496284485, -0.10921183973550797, 0.19393302500247955, -0.3203737139701843, 0.35055777430534363, -0.24774116277694702, -0.36646637320518494, -0.47796913981437683, -0.542248547077179, 0.35021698474884033, 0.10937421023845673, 0.2692662179470062, 0.5406114459037781, 0.7460727095603943, 0.2707759141921997, -0.14129884541034698, -0.014291242696344852, -0.1796988546848297, 0.2288251370191574, -0.43427929282188416, -0.2686733901500702, 0.004618512932211161, -0.14094781875610352, 0.38461947441101074, 0.7622632384300232, -0.14743444323539734, 0.08914950489997864, -0.16290222108364105, 0.5607826709747314, -0.6082915663719177, 0.4172796308994293, -1.0039581060409546, 0.37926527857780457, -0.3186936676502228, -0.6502438187599182, -0.4026581943035126, 0.10537409782409668, -0.0353880412876606, -0.6157214641571045, 0.3401758074760437, 0.3535253703594208, 0.6095803380012512, 0.3420165181159973, -0.1249336451292038, -0.5667688846588135, -0.9387312531471252, 0.8609738349914551, -0.4139045476913452, 0.5368672609329224, 0.1308911144733429, 0.05299585685133934, 0.12119096517562866, -0.908501386642456, -0.536706805229187, 0.0795842856168747, -0.28126347064971924, 0.1435025930404663, -0.11603473126888275, 0.05387235805392265, 0.11069481819868088, 0.3256892263889313, -0.886411190032959, 0.11903923749923706, -0.39859771728515625, -0.23670415580272675, 0.3986940383911133, -0.09929347038269043, 0.1497856229543686, -0.49850645661354065, -0.4948278069496155, -0.2882791757583618, -0.4106155335903168, -0.38507279753685, 0.24784108996391296, 0.4575992822647095, 0.4299652576446533, 1.0521320104599, -0.12783613801002502, 0.10277882218360901, -0.28923770785331726, 0.23031176626682281, 0.3833615481853485, -0.2345508635044098, -0.21761082112789154, 0.35252854228019714, 0.6761956214904785, 0.32419583201408386, -0.46043363213539124, -0.4958246946334839, -0.2063254565000534, -0.001471104915253818, 0.17900437116622925, -0.7337632775306702, -0.2334706038236618, 0.4534667432308197, -0.47396549582481384, -0.22688378393650055, 0.1871788650751114, -0.9448881149291992, -0.3704535663127899, -0.31949692964553833, 0.2725091278553009, -0.35182249546051025, -0.5574065446853638, 0.4119062125682831, -0.8716557621955872, -0.05427507311105728, -0.08461914956569672, -1.1553136110305786, 0.26744216680526733, 0.7669777274131775, 0.7964185476303101, -0.1373591274023056, 0.12851695716381073, 0.02433088794350624, 0.1751500517129898, -0.08135804533958435, 0.8973670601844788, -0.7636454105377197, -0.22075501084327698, 0.05279811844229698, -0.025817615911364555, -0.08095546066761017, -0.6663764715194702, 0.72414630651474, -0.6671450138092041, 0.20185010135173798, -0.15488801896572113, -0.8343016505241394, -0.2514970898628235, -0.16453486680984497, -0.44044965505599976, 1.2145230770111084, 0.14096085727214813, -1.0077635049819946, 0.20238257944583893, -1.0462074279785156, -0.03084603324532509, 0.3531114161014557, -0.039749626070261, 0.09840703755617142, 0.2516672611236572, -0.218063086271286, 0.500488817691803, -0.4900665581226349, 0.16969367861747742, 0.13074663281440735, 0.3438273072242737, -0.08021602779626846, -0.16987329721450806, 0.4238068163394928, 0.45807868242263794, -0.16306555271148682, 0.023900169879198074, -0.8271734714508057, -0.0035280543379485607, 0.15824578702449799, -0.1549764722585678, -0.6820489168167114, 0.2610783874988556, 0.38606104254722595, 0.1857815682888031, 0.3211785852909088, -0.5498483180999756, 0.16822023689746857, -0.34902289509773254, 0.18887722492218018, 0.387623131275177, 0.11078190058469772, 0.574211061000824, 0.08828849345445633, 0.3639953136444092, -0.4070863127708435, -0.38161057233810425, -0.09962250292301178, -0.2991805970668793, -0.609659731388092, 0.3530045747756958, 0.30267223715782166, 0.6843175292015076, -0.8962954878807068, 0.8464174866676331, -0.022783152759075165, -0.8898246884346008, -0.2899211645126343, 0.05749371647834778, 0.08673883974552155, 0.6225050091743469, 0.6848151683807373, 0.1305583417415619, -0.7757466435432434, -0.7438633441925049, -0.32871702313423157, -0.3096531629562378, -0.528113067150116, 0.18164557218551636, 0.5279191732406616, -0.18251390755176544, 0.7015032768249512, -0.7473189830780029, -0.05304396525025368, 0.0609927661716938, 0.592860996723175, 0.19427645206451416, 0.6407663822174072, 0.4756961166858673, -1.0280011892318726, -0.23755548894405365, 0.23632150888442993, -0.991584300994873, -0.26628604531288147, 0.03257500007748604, -0.1728212833404541, -0.19231094419956207, 0.6413175463676453, -0.4261097311973572, -0.08474101126194, 0.40931713581085205, -0.42198288440704346, 0.3604890704154968, 0.09211988747119904, 0.09064609557390213, -0.9808555245399475, 0.46545636653900146, 0.2084861695766449, -0.04135116934776306, -0.6294673681259155, -0.17601023614406586, -0.21282000839710236, -0.12756864726543427, -0.5747886300086975, 0.4189392924308777, -0.31357601284980774, -0.12675313651561737, -0.44248074293136597, -0.017051279544830322, 0.20096102356910706, 0.13275578618049622, 0.6323612928390503, 0.5676757097244263, 0.41510406136512756, -0.4789225161075592, 0.6377356052398682, 0.3965453505516052, -0.32890334725379944, 0.12176003307104111, -0.48018211126327515, 0.1282452940940857, 0.00574898486956954, 0.07097585499286652, -0.44969213008880615, -0.19047296047210693, -0.07463537901639938, -0.3234139382839203, 0.6322006583213806, -0.016345566138625145, -0.6266800761222839, -0.3110758066177368, 0.027391651645302773, -0.12757496535778046, 0.20063573122024536, -0.30669060349464417, 0.765481173992157, 0.47976458072662354, -0.4045271873474121, -0.47253575921058655, -0.2717820405960083, -0.02122182585299015, -0.2851172387599945, -0.4618179202079773, 0.7195709347724915, -0.26351746916770935, -0.39072853326797485, 0.11164180934429169, -0.318844735622406, -0.1790439337491989, 0.19978806376457214, 0.21856723725795746, 0.03878353163599968, -0.17572104930877686, 0.7027648091316223, -0.06072675436735153, -0.23316211998462677, 0.28559955954551697, -0.6182083487510681, 0.790251612663269, -0.08034155517816544, 0.11757060140371323, -0.175876647233963, 0.5018789172172546, 0.26326984167099, 0.15601709485054016, 1.0006452798843384, 0.7908157110214233, -0.6110517978668213, 0.0958104357123375, -0.1454796940088272, -0.2797437906265259, -0.41759568452835083, 0.4806596338748932, 0.027443090453743935, -0.37794461846351624, 0.2632794976234436, -0.5342622995376587, 0.23890499770641327, 1.2865632772445679, 0.46247661113739014, -0.2077399343252182, 0.7378357648849487, 0.9071851968765259, 0.10810456424951553, 0.30268076062202454, -0.5158826112747192, 0.023560451343655586, -0.8163684606552124, -0.7178345322608948, -1.125482201576233, -0.14929857850074768, -0.2848140299320221, -0.514503002166748, 0.09977872669696808, -0.004917912185192108, 0.219267800450325, 0.5566163659095764, -0.6565507650375366, 0.5180559754371643, 0.1525777131319046, -0.2265746295452118, 0.05463727191090584, -0.05463835224509239, 0.02687457576394081, -0.07498420029878616, -0.7640884518623352, -0.6709616184234619, 0.8019694685935974, 0.23496510088443756, 0.682464063167572, -0.1414879560470581, 0.3466629087924957, 0.3194528818130493, 0.10207247734069824, -0.7751427888870239, 0.23242661356925964, 0.016153879463672638, -0.8580325245857239, -0.20628777146339417, -0.48798108100891113, -0.8421015739440918, -0.08333903551101685, -0.6021853089332581, -0.5980492830276489, 0.0381670817732811, -0.25635090470314026, -0.23268114030361176, 0.4744940996170044, -0.7853707075119019, 0.7939338684082031, -0.360586017370224, -0.21436914801597595, -0.20874784886837006, -0.8198527097702026, -0.052367452532052994, -0.3044951856136322, 0.24882803857326508, -0.16270902752876282, 0.08882317692041397, 1.2794528007507324, -0.0875362828373909, 0.38078323006629944, -0.16279858350753784, -0.3028942048549652, 0.17499731481075287, -0.2627009451389313, 0.27275264263153076, -0.03873075917363167, -0.4836292266845703, 0.3614698052406311, -0.07786096632480621, -0.1622348129749298, -0.6475310921669006, 0.6153386235237122, -0.4069688618183136, -0.4048168361186981, -0.5520812273025513, -0.4073392152786255, -0.026051195338368416, 0.2930128276348114, 0.3410484194755554, 0.21425320208072662, -0.20489639043807983, 0.6610326766967773, 0.6137033104896545, -0.18176151812076569, 0.6208422780036926, 0.47630804777145386, -0.2080991417169571, 0.05573731288313866, 0.9139427542686462, -0.051985129714012146, -0.06818089634180069, 0.9802370667457581, 0.22676251828670502, -0.4667513370513916, -0.6640392541885376, 0.008167262189090252, -0.08181729912757874, -0.6375030279159546, -0.5149933099746704, -0.8729978203773499, -0.28833985328674316, -0.4097212553024292, -0.2218477427959442, -0.6081931591033936, -0.7817769646644592, -0.6416661739349365, -0.46889349818229675, 0.14567483961582184, 0.7740671634674072, -0.29125943779945374, 0.10552545636892319, -0.9316194653511047, 0.3038705289363861, 0.019931435585021973, 0.022731339558959007, -0.4358636140823364, -0.24769344925880432, -0.5658458471298218, -0.22714173793792725, -0.2957363426685333, -0.8984624147415161, 0.5221418142318726, 0.19812476634979248, 0.5134711861610413, 0.41503044962882996, 0.08973729610443115, -0.13888268172740936, -0.4934416711330414, 1.0083013772964478, 0.39342230558395386, -0.7358413934707642, 0.8138360977172852, -0.2648520767688751, -0.1337924748659134, 0.45669808983802795, 0.8196766972541809, -0.36666515469551086, -0.024815570563077927, -1.0073164701461792, -1.0988423824310303, 0.34033432602882385, 0.4473264813423157, -0.1666419804096222, -0.0675043910741806, 0.38114726543426514, 0.19437642395496368, 0.3450064957141876, -0.444337397813797, -0.41356343030929565, -0.2374243438243866, -0.1715954691171646, 0.0547473169863224, 0.013850538060069084, -0.2148217111825943, 0.09207580983638763, 1.0996779203414917, -0.25060898065567017, 0.23320810496807098, 0.14989222586154938, -0.03557100147008896, -0.09447230398654938, 0.3234316408634186, 0.36792218685150146, 0.3497965931892395, -0.6284202933311462, 0.2315354347229004, 0.0006175552844069898, -0.4785841107368469, -0.07891539484262466, 0.25441575050354004, 0.036410555243492126, 0.3322436511516571, 0.22955948114395142, 0.5796607136726379, -0.0450545959174633, -0.6302193999290466, 0.09517764300107956, -0.2997071146965027, -0.13454852998256683, -0.27428895235061646, 0.1106199398636818, -0.016575273126363754, 0.28945496678352356, 0.6738066673278809, 0.5410227179527283, 0.378513365983963, -0.520017147064209, 0.26172491908073425, 0.4068044126033783, -0.2877919375896454, -0.5891292095184326, 0.6479860544204712, 0.4312843680381775, -0.23963172733783722, 0.29811304807662964, -0.05877263844013214, -0.5490610003471375, 0.5322074294090271, 0.48054277896881104, 0.7155929207801819, -0.05856863036751747, 0.1978411078453064, 0.4210112392902374, 0.3101138770580292, -0.04367765784263611, 0.12452694028615952, -0.01705249957740307, -0.8046977519989014, -0.19052745401859283, -0.7762829065322876, -0.4007223844528198, 0.16623982787132263, -0.5747168064117432, 0.2589198350906372, -0.2079620063304901, -0.10398787260055542, 0.5456869602203369, 0.2848113179206848, -0.7098937034606934, 0.12033773958683014, 0.23073333501815796, 1.0307445526123047, -1.0283968448638916, 0.5217871069908142, 0.49843746423721313, -0.331875205039978, -0.5986098647117615, -0.28212958574295044, 0.09960894286632538, -0.4439024329185486, 0.9629982709884644, -0.04831389710307121, 0.14978398382663727, 0.11361319571733475, -0.6080944538116455, -0.8839716911315918, 1.1464699506759644, 0.2121027112007141, -0.5004557371139526, -0.07532043009996414, -0.2615586221218109, 0.47054925560951233, -0.3500197231769562, 0.3423713445663452, 0.3735972046852112, 0.7326861023902893, 0.16416066884994507, -0.5531179308891296, -0.3387696146965027, -0.45425841212272644, -0.4037264585494995, 0.20931430160999298, -0.4926163852214813, 0.34478113055229187, 0.13969960808753967, -0.30271682143211365, -0.1872955709695816, 1.0644901990890503, -0.11736249923706055, 0.5323842167854309, 0.5012387633323669, 0.39521467685699463, 1.0112255811691284, -0.04207561910152435, 1.0134528875350952, -0.37465396523475647, 0.5606999397277832, 0.745116651058197, -0.49615949392318726, 0.8161401748657227, 0.5959518551826477, -0.21862709522247314, 0.5564325451850891, 0.5207898020744324, 0.11774183064699173, 0.44887322187423706, 0.25644490122795105, -0.3567127585411072, -0.042038753628730774, -0.860381007194519, -0.44597262144088745, 0.5496127605438232, 0.7610177993774414, -0.360917329788208, 0.008266517892479897, -0.24759435653686523, -0.08041495829820633, 0.02765430510044098, -0.06627245247364044, 0.779472827911377, -0.027708323672413826, -0.3473650813102722, -0.05297284573316574, 0.1290670782327652, 0.4814569056034088, -0.8599346280097961, -0.14230403304100037, 0.29687047004699707, -0.18864865601062775, -0.34367331862449646, -0.8466718196868896, 0.6633382439613342, 0.10586847364902496, -0.5204408764839172, -0.5864494442939758, 1.1523165702819824, -0.3815142810344696, -0.2919003963470459, 0.1960185021162033, 0.40357616543769836, 0.25491636991500854, -0.014897134155035019, -0.5570458769798279, -0.29075905680656433, 0.04900927096605301, -0.2925635874271393, 0.23722372949123383, 0.4077284038066864, 0.7018573880195618, 0.2264217585325241, 0.8034246563911438, 0.09508057683706284, -0.23963689804077148, 0.05973216891288757, 0.9259639978408813, -0.7156365513801575, -0.01567971706390381, -0.3323777914047241, 0.3209012448787689, -0.3686728775501251, -0.1534469872713089, 0.7310081124305725, 0.9808939099311829, 0.6251302361488342, -0.04737546294927597, 0.8900555968284607, -0.25032156705856323, 0.6524121165275574, -1.0314189195632935, 0.527510941028595, -0.3725186288356781, 0.3330250084400177, -0.15247613191604614, -0.8193800449371338, -0.23228153586387634, 0.5732275247573853, 0.19057852029800415, -0.1684723049402237, 1.1050171852111816, 0.41547203063964844, 0.19730634987354279, 0.11227696388959885, 0.06887413561344147, 0.1629272997379303, 0.4999140202999115, 0.17626528441905975, 0.637746274471283, -0.4811834394931793, 0.11182518303394318, -0.3672495186328888, -0.04629402980208397, -0.04891281574964523, -1.0178406238555908, -0.5565282106399536, -0.7539639472961426, -0.423099160194397, -0.25821584463119507, -0.3890112638473511, 1.1096824407577515, 0.6285952925682068, -0.7030065059661865, 0.0006281796377152205, -0.23204974830150604, 0.19169005751609802, -0.10442645847797394, -0.32122981548309326, 0.35196954011917114, -0.27455204725265503, -0.5817055106163025, 0.9662152528762817, 0.4492381811141968, 0.04943763092160225, -0.2522652745246887, 0.11908458918333054, -0.38200926780700684, 0.18300296366214752, 0.43306249380111694, 0.4134330451488495, -0.07551390677690506, -0.242129847407341, 0.2711777091026306, 0.2769297957420349, 0.05883294343948364, 1.047365665435791, -0.7109472751617432, 0.35081061720848083, 0.7086995244026184, 0.7490290403366089, 0.3629426956176758, -0.25161653757095337, 0.47937560081481934, -1.2214555740356445, 0.2965153753757477, 0.5956466794013977, 0.5664694905281067, 0.5123244524002075, -0.48671266436576843, 0.7746677398681641, 0.4949668049812317, -0.7359012961387634, -0.47155630588531494, -0.005391479004174471, -1.1765397787094116, -0.3605315685272217, 1.2770920991897583, 0.10825822502374649, -0.1343827098608017, -0.14440032839775085, -0.05253004655241966, 0.2345198541879654, -0.49531057476997375, 0.7414749264717102, 0.6308596730232239, -0.07777558267116547, 0.17472125589847565, -0.6567777395248413, 0.5410419702529907, 0.20822593569755554, -1.1573171615600586, 0.25501328706741333, 0.27096328139305115, -0.27024081349372864, 0.8963697552680969, 0.20741024613380432, 0.02440635673701763, -0.4678695797920227, 0.08283740282058716, 0.28836601972579956, 0.27603083848953247, -0.5504112243652344, 0.07334337383508682, 0.24368597567081451, -0.38231271505355835, 0.3320019543170929 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06959v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06959v1	SpeechCLIP+: Self-supervised multi-task representation learning for speech via CLIP and speech-image data	2024-02-10T14:26:42	2024-02-10T14:26:42	Hsuan-Fu Wang, Yi-Jen Shih, Heng-Jui Chang, Layne Berry, Puyuan Peng, Hung-yi Lee, Hsin-Min Wang, David Harwath	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS	The recently proposed visually grounded speech model SpeechCLIP is an innovative framework that bridges speech and text through images via CLIP without relying on text transcription. On this basis, this paper introduces two extensions to SpeechCLIP. First, we apply the Continuous Integrate-and-Fire (CIF) module to replace a fixed number of CLS tokens in the cascaded architecture. Second, we propose a new hybrid architecture that merges the cascaded and parallel architectures of SpeechCLIP into a multi-task learning framework. Our experimental evaluation is performed on the Flickr8k and SpokenCOCO datasets. The results show that in the speech keyword extraction task, the CIF-based cascaded SpeechCLIP model outperforms the previous cascaded SpeechCLIP model using a fixed number of CLS tokens. Furthermore, through our hybrid architecture, cascaded task learning boosts the performance of the parallel branch in image-speech retrieval tasks.	[ -0.26902228593826294, -0.38517388701438904, 0.18597307801246643, 0.3669271171092987, -0.31693902611732483, 0.24639160931110382, -0.2915516197681427, -0.4306621849536896, 0.41766422986984253, 0.39309996366500854, -0.5301828980445862, -0.6606902480125427, -0.6586519479751587, -0.32429835200309753, -0.37503719329833984, 0.855414867401123, 0.2911226153373718, 0.23740465939044952, -0.27757811546325684, -0.36591506004333496, -0.6815981864929199, -0.7559818029403687, -0.2841273844242096, -0.2614065706729889, 0.19057577848434448, 0.5230010151863098, 0.42722809314727783, 0.5806893110275269, 0.2934260964393616, 0.21928007900714874, 0.1489723175764084, -0.05346331000328064, -0.0869903415441513, -0.00981226097792387, -0.20941956341266632, -0.32375845313072205, -0.2672441303730011, -0.057424623519182205, 0.46679991483688354, 0.4421180486679077, -0.053008049726486206, 0.27671653032302856, 0.10767195373773575, 0.2950851023197174, -0.8343527913093567, 0.39343541860580444, -0.7747485637664795, 0.07135690003633499, -0.4809822142124176, -0.09544229507446289, -0.30893734097480774, 0.32447338104248047, 0.24613997340202332, -0.3271290361881256, 0.044154033064842224, -0.20675861835479736, 0.4119550883769989, 0.06812089681625366, -0.3190681040287018, -0.3414326608181, -0.5541728138923645, 0.8718956112861633, -0.366670161485672, 0.2984808385372162, -0.1298985630273819, 0.3210773169994354, 0.26064378023147583, -0.8062081933021545, -0.3539542257785797, -0.08734053373336792, 0.2819913625717163, 0.20667172968387604, 0.06690193712711334, 0.17434045672416687, 0.1011228933930397, 0.3131181597709656, -0.3819813132286072, 0.16202203929424286, -0.30123600363731384, -0.3977452516555786, 0.2562948763370514, -0.0037852793466299772, 0.5014596581459045, -0.3596521019935608, -0.6728090047836304, -0.4793594479560852, -0.4975506067276001, 0.3066433370113373, 0.05035480484366417, 0.34837377071380615, -0.29778388142585754, 0.26868054270744324, 0.19561101496219635, 0.44948410987854004, 0.06717806309461594, -0.5079593062400818, 0.42986178398132324, -0.1820542812347412, -0.14038832485675812, 0.23668383061885834, 0.7228578925132751, 0.07775712013244629, 0.029699647799134254, -0.00951474905014038, 0.2757166922092438, 0.33560794591903687, -0.10245957970619202, -0.47907036542892456, -0.28773894906044006, 0.30239349603652954, -0.2957648038864136, -0.137448251247406, 0.22548450529575348, -0.6461190581321716, 0.07962264120578766, -0.3548031747341156, 0.39632123708724976, -0.46165719628334045, -0.4021020829677582, 0.07532171905040741, -0.5255592465400696, 0.1467829942703247, 0.12621420621871948, -0.6115599274635315, 0.6077631711959839, 0.6288201808929443, 0.9362549781799316, -0.7653670907020569, -0.4932222068309784, -0.6593092083930969, 0.42624107003211975, -0.16132500767707825, 0.7538712620735168, -0.535408079624176, -0.5500211715698242, 0.11164170503616333, -0.024521544575691223, -0.2840891182422638, -0.7086096405982971, 0.7179709076881409, -0.16580048203468323, 0.047994039952754974, -0.17328837513923645, -0.40920042991638184, -0.31144267320632935, -0.12362974137067795, -0.5791378617286682, 1.1225979328155518, -0.3305629789829254, -0.8609752655029297, 0.2735649049282074, -0.7448602914810181, -0.510718584060669, 0.2370414137840271, -0.471035361289978, -0.40995150804519653, -0.2713603377342224, 0.5354125499725342, 0.5784595608711243, -0.09679955989122391, 0.5750747323036194, -0.6750578880310059, -0.14278513193130493, -0.10165661573410034, -0.20945042371749878, 0.7998981475830078, 0.0031450153328478336, -0.49926701188087463, 0.31051722168922424, -0.570156455039978, 0.1407332569360733, -0.2537910044193268, -0.006090030074119568, -0.21217750012874603, 0.05230196937918663, 0.39562126994132996, 0.5077770948410034, 0.10682141780853271, -0.7362991571426392, -0.029533393681049347, -0.017929045483469963, 0.7248932719230652, 0.27910441160202026, -0.05199352279305458, 0.33466771245002747, -0.2707519829273224, 0.4838404059410095, 0.17951668798923492, 0.04016661271452904, -0.5614826083183289, -0.3048608899116516, -0.3803560733795166, -0.958702027797699, 0.17521552741527557, 0.6170179843902588, -0.6649913787841797, 0.20781615376472473, -0.3833082616329193, -0.44761598110198975, -0.4976641833782196, 0.09170877188444138, 0.6209807395935059, 0.5435172915458679, 0.4088132083415985, -0.42884066700935364, -0.5496863722801208, -0.951272189617157, -0.058811962604522705, -0.03139935061335564, 0.11695308238267899, 0.2668391466140747, 0.4709300100803375, 0.19861099123954773, 1.0224246978759766, -0.18041647970676422, -0.7569319009780884, -0.4037599265575409, 0.4789150059223175, 0.11188686639070511, 0.7137025594711304, 0.6773247122764587, -0.9153194427490234, -0.4341460168361664, -0.29954081773757935, -0.45419934391975403, 0.05173589661717415, -0.15884408354759216, 0.21676090359687805, -0.406146764755249, 0.4383034408092499, -0.6376904845237732, 0.36201825737953186, 0.5412985682487488, 0.43200793862342834, 0.5850980281829834, 0.033357176929712296, 0.09670783579349518, -0.8104158639907837, -0.019796166568994522, -0.14221793413162231, -0.43643850088119507, -0.5139594674110413, -0.029189491644501686, 0.11253155767917633, -0.7002425789833069, -1.0366761684417725, 0.2578497529029846, -0.561852216720581, -0.3584008514881134, -0.534109354019165, 0.0861455425620079, -0.11555197089910507, 0.6928409337997437, 0.38029295206069946, 0.9774917960166931, 1.116911768913269, -0.42195743322372437, 0.2265436351299286, 0.20642970502376556, -0.15384168922901154, 0.4299844801425934, -0.6314508318901062, 0.2455316185951233, -0.0013807375216856599, 0.44744405150413513, -1.0184135437011719, -0.3059232234954834, -0.030330030247569084, -0.2665940821170807, 0.18065831065177917, -0.14136600494384766, -0.6098776459693909, -0.40044987201690674, -0.43148234486579895, 0.580784022808075, 0.2538692057132721, -0.7586922645568848, 0.5192784070968628, 0.8441627621650696, -0.17164506018161774, -0.4282269775867462, -0.6050872802734375, 0.11310160905122757, -0.20393869280815125, -0.5291507840156555, 0.928851306438446, 0.23953431844711304, 0.4469192326068878, -0.006827868055552244, 0.018622037023305893, -0.15453749895095825, -0.4249463677406311, 0.5962401628494263, 0.08592387288808823, -0.0036245002411305904, 0.12568818032741547, 0.145598903298378, 0.0886664092540741, -0.19909170269966125, -0.1822868436574936, 0.6439809799194336, -0.14348313212394714, -0.5280898809432983, -0.6445812582969666, 0.778805136680603, 0.8108245134353638, -0.48598209023475647, 0.13893871009349823, 0.5898903012275696, -0.26860731840133667, -0.11118938773870468, -0.5382537245750427, 0.07960505783557892, -0.43053460121154785, 0.32156533002853394, -0.42060917615890503, -1.0780353546142578, 0.3586669862270355, -0.41704225540161133, -0.03772592917084694, 0.42551806569099426, 0.5070463418960571, -0.15162590146064758, 0.8697723150253296, 0.7944077253341675, -0.3513399660587311, 0.573533833026886, -0.3043420612812042, -0.25033116340637207, -0.9298664331436157, -0.2017793506383896, -0.23942624032497406, -0.20497027039527893, -0.2469256967306137, -0.5002472400665283, 0.5472278594970703, 0.23634099960327148, 0.04134272038936615, 0.7117956280708313, -0.6044180989265442, 0.13342398405075073, 0.6773381233215332, 0.22288024425506592, 0.026368973776698112, -0.0352347232401371, -0.346126914024353, -0.2801780104637146, -0.7436004877090454, -0.12347494810819626, 0.8214656114578247, 0.3237292170524597, 0.48327529430389404, -0.3828080892562866, 0.6443836092948914, 0.46504953503608704, 0.08998743444681168, -0.6144225001335144, 0.5707724094390869, -0.35536837577819824, -0.6113064289093018, -0.11374260485172272, 0.21030955016613007, -0.3777441382408142, 0.4937145411968231, -0.13646455109119415, -0.8200973868370056, 0.5122731924057007, 0.31744974851608276, -0.21069075167179108, 0.18302612006664276, -0.6674301624298096, 0.7714765071868896, -0.46115270256996155, -0.15070892870426178, -0.597514271736145, -0.6257994771003723, 0.4327504634857178, 0.23284895718097687, 0.3116457164287567, -0.264060914516449, 0.17399802803993225, 0.9241997003555298, -0.18860895931720734, 1.104280710220337, -0.2772367000579834, 0.4391809105873108, 0.691757321357727, -0.22393272817134857, 0.16485482454299927, -0.23375681042671204, 0.05775527283549309, 0.317329078912735, 0.2724207937717438, -0.1842825561761856, -0.54100501537323, 0.6880106925964355, -0.375432550907135, -0.39992445707321167, -0.3747430145740509, -0.4295739531517029, -0.19489145278930664, 0.1863974779844284, 0.08325394988059998, 0.8442688584327698, -0.013346838764846325, 0.3155182898044586, 0.18188445270061493, -0.06039227545261383, 0.7421841621398926, 0.03499636799097061, -0.21993385255336761, -0.9835517406463623, 0.9516749382019043, 0.0643761157989502, 0.14050626754760742, 0.25890374183654785, 0.08640336245298386, -0.361627459526062, -0.2886083722114563, -0.20713792741298676, 0.216684952378273, -0.7661327123641968, -0.03932366892695427, -0.6497244238853455, -0.17315468192100525, -0.5897225141525269, 0.21419453620910645, -0.40501776337623596, -0.4085901975631714, -0.5005982518196106, 0.003411143785342574, 0.1025865450501442, 0.14119122922420502, -0.1158812940120697, 0.5172377228736877, -0.6566236019134521, 0.45711565017700195, 0.2535582184791565, -0.11514513194561005, 0.05774136632680893, -0.3790808618068695, 0.03024330735206604, -0.27421826124191284, -0.6009044051170349, -0.9870173931121826, 0.41396984457969666, 0.7069087624549866, 0.5067834258079529, 0.4352707862854004, 0.035491641610860825, 1.1530784368515015, -0.7815831303596497, 0.874796986579895, 0.6504566669464111, -1.1579478979110718, 0.490730881690979, -0.2974608242511749, 0.3722445070743561, 0.4751323461532593, 0.41739311814308167, -0.34476250410079956, -0.28392815589904785, -0.6516548991203308, -0.568260133266449, 0.45764607191085815, -0.01076559815555811, 0.17077811062335968, 0.048785075545310974, 0.1512158066034317, 0.07122208923101425, 0.46544983983039856, -0.8023895621299744, -0.2899043560028076, -0.4033866226673126, -0.24056167900562286, 0.2937805950641632, -0.20250579714775085, -0.13341078162193298, -0.5721279382705688, 0.21900400519371033, -0.27905869483947754, 0.37341007590293884, 0.35644081234931946, -0.12389986217021942, 0.37796857953071594, 0.2932143211364746, 0.4249691069126129, 0.2967943847179413, 0.09652862697839737, 0.28822341561317444, -0.10724583268165588, -0.351210355758667, -0.05583333224058151, -0.16438819468021393, 0.2505088746547699, 0.22564597427845, 0.5929103493690491, 0.9988675713539124, 0.7495996356010437, -0.7771198749542236, 0.8396441340446472, 0.4879893362522125, -0.4135352373123169, -0.3498746156692505, -0.0032505264971405268, 0.11467701196670532, 0.13680854439735413, 0.614101231098175, 0.14027857780456543, 0.44039323925971985, -0.7346143126487732, 0.743605375289917, 0.6517153382301331, -0.4042153060436249, -0.4422752261161804, 0.6859931349754333, 0.24084337055683136, -0.28542187809944153, 0.029374951496720314, 0.16111084818840027, -0.8761880397796631, 0.4160480499267578, 0.588313639163971, 0.7982762455940247, -0.013676026836037636, 0.42460379004478455, 0.17692930996418, -0.12200105935335159, -0.03881802409887314, 0.26072707772254944, -0.6652144193649292, -0.2876693904399872, -0.4579535126686096, -0.17133043706417084, -0.5729621052742004, 0.09323253482580185, -0.7449910640716553, 0.431317538022995, -0.40946221351623535, -0.41264423727989197, 0.08598773926496506, -0.4078599810600281, -0.43016037344932556, 0.10681499540805817, 0.2366916686296463, 0.8034865856170654, -0.8522580862045288, 1.1244207620620728, 0.3905574083328247, -0.14877526462078094, -0.5773693323135376, -0.12947727739810944, -0.09610234200954437, -0.5927024483680725, 0.9204967021942139, 0.4133119285106659, -0.31485363841056824, -0.010106312111020088, -0.6602304577827454, -1.107481598854065, 0.9035700559616089, 0.4806409180164337, -0.5668797492980957, -0.024495713412761688, 0.08379091322422028, 0.36922311782836914, -0.7617089748382568, 0.15232133865356445, 0.11597055196762085, -0.08340907096862793, 0.31789296865463257, -1.148046612739563, -0.4383388161659241, 0.013004290871322155, 0.055969759821891785, -0.1693437695503235, -0.5599167346954346, 0.702004611492157, 0.0699097216129303, -0.43906691670417786, -0.09372984617948532, 1.0316821336746216, 0.2259039729833603, 0.18332251906394958, 0.6900283694267273, 0.41067105531692505, 0.28970038890838623, 0.11713443696498871, 0.5958604216575623, -0.35428714752197266, 0.3842555582523346, 1.5610822439193726, -0.3747630715370178, 1.2326931953430176, 0.568967342376709, 0.024526143446564674, 0.5618195533752441, 0.3465631306171417, 0.01889251545071602, 1.0044820308685303, -0.13319072127342224, -0.28108876943588257, -0.4184691309928894, -0.24060297012329102, -0.10243380814790726, 0.5355251431465149, 0.4861151874065399, -0.07090165466070175, -0.615633487701416, 0.6837176084518433, -0.32279667258262634, 0.08542289584875107, -0.1605386883020401, 0.5776964426040649, 0.1945415437221527, -0.5795203447341919, 0.38029244542121887, -0.19103941321372986, 0.7941668033599854, -0.40613284707069397, -0.24842239916324615, 0.6106924414634705, 0.011162357404828072, -0.2006424516439438, -0.6412487030029297, 0.347920686006546, -0.2139098346233368, -0.039273448288440704, -0.23369723558425903, 0.7756221294403076, -0.543774425983429, -0.3285994529724121, 0.5137004852294922, 0.07904431223869324, 0.04992832615971565, -0.05700734257698059, -1.0695176124572754, 0.3985593020915985, -0.25460028648376465, 0.3745447099208832, 0.17329542338848114, -0.041758619248867035, -0.03981379047036171, 0.6933536529541016, 0.5860652923583984, 0.09076303243637085, 0.42618411779403687, 0.03872708976268768, 0.8362236618995667, -0.26766237616539, -0.6798698306083679, -0.5501895546913147, 0.4435561001300812, -0.21387648582458496, -0.26600414514541626, 0.6063016653060913, 0.46064406633377075, 0.6958880424499512, -0.21917875111103058, 0.7420645952224731, -0.0732220932841301, 0.8899162411689758, -0.4264589548110962, 0.14970971643924713, -0.2566904127597809, -0.2165452092885971, -0.559439480304718, -0.46854403614997864, -0.29403945803642273, 0.21499481797218323, -0.3299562633037567, -0.33519884943962097, 0.7604976296424866, 0.43955016136169434, -0.22382891178131104, -0.05712265893816948, 0.3055540919303894, -0.3820236623287201, 0.34858131408691406, 0.3326834440231323, 0.4371955096721649, -0.4547630548477173, 0.5841426253318787, -0.4671586751937866, -0.27320098876953125, 0.0620344802737236, -0.8423349857330322, -0.8618950843811035, -0.8646141290664673, -0.6357144117355347, 0.33480194211006165, -0.049171194434165955, 0.7831388115882874, 1.2428134679794312, -0.7348253130912781, -0.44435545802116394, 0.008584327064454556, -0.2584545314311981, -0.44827792048454285, -0.23889844119548798, 0.5731983780860901, -0.312391996383667, -0.6494162678718567, 0.5262796878814697, 0.6195037961006165, -0.16570056974887848, -0.1659206748008728, 0.24308323860168457, -0.3028636872768402, -0.28857436776161194, 0.48793888092041016, 0.6431812047958374, -0.9308302402496338, -0.21851110458374023, -0.199133962392807, 0.1070157140493393, 0.3278239965438843, 1.0303705930709839, -0.8034346699714661, 0.4358905851840973, 0.12583424150943756, 0.7479289174079895, 0.8219910264015198, 0.09783409535884857, 0.4271836578845978, -0.6840302348136902, 0.6350085139274597, 0.11380041390657425, 0.3128829896450043, 0.33721038699150085, -0.11951195448637009, -0.14572402834892273, 0.4868600368499756, -0.1676471084356308, -0.6717977523803711, 0.31366226077079773, -1.313300609588623, -0.09985800087451935, 0.7483227849006653, -0.24256828427314758, -0.3921266794204712, -0.040343496948480606, -0.31339722871780396, 0.06868615746498108, -0.36775824427604675, 0.35888761281967163, 0.6109771132469177, -0.3648844063282013, -0.7020016312599182, -0.32718583941459656, 0.3231234550476074, 0.5537113547325134, -0.5597514510154724, -0.15811975300312042, 0.22133830189704895, 0.33665844798088074, 0.37864622473716736, 0.6921941041946411, -0.42136961221694946, 0.3765312135219574, -0.2751452624797821, 0.19112472236156464, -0.17520968616008759, -0.6328175663948059, -0.25133830308914185, 0.6511081457138062, -0.3164156973361969, -0.8705617189407349 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06954v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06954v1	OpenFedLLM: Training Large Language Models on Decentralized Private Data via Federated Learning	2024-02-10T13:50:11	2024-02-10T13:50:11	Rui Ye, Wenhao Wang, Jingyi Chai, Dihan Li, Zexi Li, Yinda Xu, Yaxin Du, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.MA	Trained on massive publicly available data, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated tremendous success across various fields. While more data contributes to better performance, a disconcerting reality is that high-quality public data will be exhausted in a few years. In this paper, we offer a potential next step for contemporary LLMs: collaborative and privacy-preserving LLM training on the underutilized distributed private data via federated learning (FL), where multiple data owners collaboratively train a shared model without transmitting raw data. To achieve this, we build a concise, integrated, and research-friendly framework/codebase, named OpenFedLLM. It covers federated instruction tuning for enhancing instruction-following capability, federated value alignment for aligning with human values, and 7 representative FL algorithms. Besides, OpenFedLLM supports training on diverse domains, where we cover 8 training datasets; and provides comprehensive evaluations, where we cover 30+ evaluation metrics. Through extensive experiments, we observe that all FL algorithms outperform local training on training LLMs, demonstrating a clear performance improvement across a variety of settings. Notably, in a financial benchmark, Llama2-7B fine-tuned by applying any FL algorithm can outperform GPT-4 by a significant margin while the model obtained through individual training cannot, demonstrating strong motivation for clients to participate in FL. The code is available at https://github.com/rui-ye/OpenFedLLM.	[ -0.2408364862203598, -0.48992934823036194, 0.3764519691467285, 0.34391292929649353, 0.04144381359219551, 0.24388276040554047, -0.6892864108085632, -0.382627010345459, -0.18813925981521606, 0.6567177176475525, -0.40864163637161255, -0.7860875725746155, -0.4691489636898041, -0.07630457729101181, -0.11830583214759827, 1.067442774772644, -0.23904496431350708, 0.41951704025268555, -0.48220503330230713, -0.30462461709976196, 0.06643226742744446, -0.5173173546791077, -0.15767687559127808, -0.48939839005470276, 0.2155473828315735, 0.5717073082923889, 0.6468290090560913, 0.8225887417793274, 0.6279022097587585, 0.27917465567588806, 0.3444546163082123, 0.24490898847579956, -0.9559354186058044, -0.06134483218193054, -0.2240687608718872, -0.5694892406463623, -0.5057193636894226, 0.2644215226173401, 0.8305040597915649, 0.8217916488647461, -0.4029048681259155, 0.20913724601268768, -0.1449941098690033, 0.8426083922386169, -0.6951693296432495, 0.7753916382789612, -0.35616764426231384, 0.2142471969127655, -0.23813053965568542, -0.04459712654352188, -0.5442724823951721, -0.78650963306427, 0.11033650487661362, -0.3981182873249054, 0.16431088745594025, 0.13605444133281708, 0.5616609454154968, 0.0932275652885437, -0.06764008104801178, -0.02730097621679306, -0.6766574382781982, 0.7535943984985352, -0.4034394919872284, 0.5315999984741211, 0.429227352142334, 0.18577353656291962, -0.16499091684818268, -0.703302264213562, -0.1481872946023941, 0.10928584635257721, -0.1256740689277649, -0.0219111330807209, -0.16914159059524536, 0.20695270597934723, -0.13367295265197754, 0.9221868515014648, -0.4029741883277893, 0.40857797861099243, -0.09616159647703171, -0.05315842851996422, 0.7019892930984497, 0.047844164073467255, -0.15363822877407074, 0.6051058769226074, -0.6603291034698486, -0.09583504498004913, -0.6810466647148132, 0.07335785776376724, 0.5438000559806824, 0.3670998215675354, -0.23165586590766907, 0.3829819858074188, -0.4360642433166504, 0.5248979926109314, 0.18867336213588715, -0.34486380219459534, 0.33600178360939026, -0.14906084537506104, -0.4769921600818634, 0.04450361058115959, 0.6799098253250122, -0.03241278976202011, 0.11973132193088531, -0.553760290145874, -0.603038489818573, -0.30324357748031616, -0.14415346086025238, -0.8160755038261414, -0.3068072497844696, 0.18889747560024261, -0.3082179129123688, -0.4010479748249054, 0.2870900332927704, -0.8005300164222717, -0.3865666389465332, -0.5410133004188538, 0.18130400776863098, -0.052965063601732254, -0.46031469106674194, 0.28901129961013794, 0.3344247341156006, 0.07282543182373047, 0.27482306957244873, -1.2179838418960571, 0.6913626790046692, 1.2625620365142822, 0.8035101294517517, -0.16864435374736786, -0.3777998387813568, -1.0674432516098022, -0.0691474974155426, -0.16985636949539185, 0.40597766637802124, -0.48382368683815, -0.051334455609321594, 0.08805028349161148, -0.0559125654399395, -0.19019564986228943, -0.4779530167579651, -0.12013474851846695, -0.6629529595375061, 0.47088131308555603, -0.05366795137524605, -0.7458685636520386, -0.09948684275150299, 0.25362321734428406, -0.49784761667251587, 0.4546036124229431, 0.2694968581199646, -0.7367441654205322, 0.036649249494075775, -0.708827555179596, -0.29835864901542664, 0.08733396232128143, -0.34240880608558655, -0.677111029624939, 0.08770163357257843, 0.14286373555660248, 0.6136975884437561, -0.3475649356842041, 0.46122634410858154, -0.5548473000526428, -0.47652411460876465, 0.19386717677116394, -0.2573918104171753, 0.8366265892982483, 0.030601391568779945, -0.5029996037483215, 0.3537486791610718, -0.7283071279525757, 0.08365237712860107, 0.10929515957832336, -0.5382784605026245, -0.2033902406692505, -0.3966381251811981, -0.16549892723560333, -0.24148575961589813, 0.44910043478012085, -0.6347172260284424, 0.10872858017683029, -0.6555640697479248, 0.3151136636734009, 1.024158239364624, -0.30249160528182983, 0.8626889586448669, -0.42833900451660156, 0.48229077458381653, -0.20943737030029297, 0.27137842774391174, 0.025503333657979965, -0.2503710985183716, -0.5779362916946411, -0.5416570901870728, 0.24854660034179688, 0.23825785517692566, -0.24080020189285278, 0.3019315302371979, -0.3131842613220215, -0.3572446405887604, -0.527778148651123, 0.2599984109401703, 0.5027138590812683, 0.2542003393173218, 0.09385628998279572, -0.39379724860191345, -0.36521846055984497, -0.4184240996837616, 0.15100042521953583, 0.043632872402668, 0.1261691153049469, 0.26736563444137573, 0.3295533359050751, -0.2953355312347412, 0.9448713660240173, -0.5047574043273926, -0.5384725332260132, -0.05324744060635567, 0.015828853473067284, -0.033686187118291855, 0.43706411123275757, 0.2525869607925415, -0.5530111193656921, -0.22500698268413544, 0.31330567598342896, -0.6410927176475525, 0.017881562933325768, 0.22336485981941223, -0.18648946285247803, 0.3450258672237396, 0.07726900279521942, -0.34495753049850464, -0.009637204930186272, 1.0267095565795898, -0.145586758852005, 0.4920107126235962, -0.28172773122787476, -0.130842924118042, -0.9736613035202026, 0.014480474404990673, -0.35455164313316345, -0.3669893741607666, -0.268600195646286, 0.3935934007167816, -0.08178567886352539, -0.24996578693389893, -0.1596471518278122, 0.4516231119632721, -0.6370818614959717, -0.48802000284194946, -0.11897387355566025, 0.15064191818237305, -0.23491618037223816, 0.5499228239059448, 0.04769869148731232, 0.8960080146789551, 0.5261197090148926, 0.008397102355957031, 0.5287163853645325, 0.3134077191352844, -0.3261999487876892, 0.41602596640586853, -0.13969239592552185, 0.3996554911136627, 0.02825520746409893, 0.11958283931016922, -0.4632749855518341, -0.5660809874534607, 0.08757435530424118, 0.033263154327869415, 0.3604017496109009, 0.04112357646226883, -0.625482976436615, 0.07236096262931824, -0.20568135380744934, -0.049580324441194534, 0.3564746081829071, -1.0510010719299316, 0.3733249306678772, 0.4565242528915405, 0.11613407731056213, -0.6697949767112732, -0.6865753531455994, -0.3315998315811157, 0.052514612674713135, -0.747390866279602, 0.021466271951794624, 0.03129201382398605, -0.4292123317718506, 0.024690337479114532, -0.10990963876247406, -0.2878838777542114, 0.29798322916030884, 0.469021201133728, 0.07254739850759506, -0.4502853751182556, 0.09092477709054947, -0.02830152027308941, -0.19223973155021667, 0.046387091279029846, -0.560893177986145, 0.5506237149238586, -0.706466794013977, -0.36726900935173035, -0.29513314366340637, 0.06722220778465271, 0.28010469675064087, -0.6471898555755615, 0.9564000368118286, 0.5885133743286133, -0.3607746958732605, -0.3963949680328369, -0.4604246914386749, -0.11174783110618591, -0.503176212310791, -0.05840068310499191, 0.05014801025390625, -1.4836580753326416, 0.2801896631717682, -0.2696818709373474, 0.20517942309379578, -0.2974224090576172, 0.715494692325592, 0.2577773928642273, 0.5383206605911255, 0.9259470701217651, -0.2714742422103882, 0.5138877034187317, -0.2762599587440491, 0.12454693764448166, -0.21404485404491425, -0.34949764609336853, -0.23154403269290924, -0.0880531594157219, -0.5068468451499939, -0.4739043414592743, 0.014861147850751877, 0.043565597385168076, -0.2466089427471161, 0.1446342021226883, -0.12380935251712799, 0.8529025912284851, 0.47993195056915283, 0.12265375256538391, 0.5726315379142761, 0.014041958376765251, -0.03891901671886444, 0.19424478709697723, -0.55284583568573, -0.2692071795463562, 1.09041166305542, 0.5904278755187988, 0.9549676179885864, 0.03398064151406288, 1.2060188055038452, 0.029781237244606018, 0.6488987803459167, -0.5339983701705933, 0.4168016314506531, -0.047174323350191116, -0.44831639528274536, -0.266213059425354, -0.7793490290641785, -0.5966367125511169, 0.06994696706533432, -0.13162949681282043, -0.5520889163017273, 0.08669105172157288, 0.024504929780960083, -0.25658681988716125, 0.42331379652023315, -0.7052550315856934, 0.8940573930740356, -0.19941720366477966, -0.5383914113044739, -0.20712977647781372, -0.4624401330947876, 0.6166165471076965, -0.359028697013855, 0.15326552093029022, -0.08518241345882416, 0.0647602304816246, 0.486605167388916, -0.6060441732406616, 0.8041964173316956, -0.2203112095594406, -0.13079163432121277, -0.09986846894025803, -0.166285440325737, 0.5367106795310974, 0.27467119693756104, -0.09406968206167221, 0.5060824155807495, -0.40196487307548523, -0.47599491477012634, -0.39075496792793274, 1.0373482704162598, -0.8694932460784912, -0.4249758720397949, -0.3217032849788666, -0.718148410320282, -0.35284483432769775, 0.3168257772922516, -0.18128429353237152, 0.42257416248321533, -0.23064108192920685, 0.4399963915348053, 0.7754856944084167, -0.001060035196132958, 0.3415147066116333, 0.5922285914421082, -0.30143114924430847, -0.6426795125007629, 0.793067216873169, -0.13020603358745575, 0.4010182321071625, 0.6229115724563599, 0.2791309654712677, -0.36676424741744995, -0.5940283536911011, -0.0807635709643364, 0.3023317754268646, -0.645797848701477, -0.3880942761898041, -0.3748491704463959, -0.05793798714876175, -0.3517681062221527, -0.28270769119262695, -0.6590102314949036, -0.14334259927272797, -0.4498630166053772, -0.34465721249580383, 0.5016525983810425, 0.6442701816558838, -0.2727365791797638, 0.21015246212482452, -0.5917990803718567, -0.16844624280929565, 0.20065627992153168, 0.974212110042572, 0.048221636563539505, 0.08367905765771866, -0.3826160430908203, 0.11053112894296646, -0.011678306385874748, -0.1689307540655136, 0.1904284805059433, 0.2181617170572281, 0.413481742143631, 0.5841442942619324, 0.34248918294906616, 0.7015443444252014, -0.26209935545921326, 0.19520817697048187, 0.2563919425010681, -0.7857176661491394, 0.1364523321390152, -0.28405848145484924, 0.10248920321464539, 0.7174357175827026, 0.34674519300460815, -0.09565942734479904, -0.5339593887329102, -0.37601104378700256, -0.3186977803707123, 0.9217090010643005, 0.1316799372434616, -0.006131393369287252, 0.3600720763206482, 0.04930645227432251, 0.4857178330421448, 0.3614366352558136, -0.6101277470588684, -0.2611168324947357, -0.12437720596790314, -0.28914499282836914, -0.1996556967496872, 0.14512352645397186, -0.42833438515663147, -0.13291166722774506, 0.5425291061401367, -0.2314295917749405, 0.17516112327575684, -0.2003680020570755, -0.04131780192255974, -0.4298909902572632, 0.22203759849071503, 0.3565133810043335, 0.6895827651023865, -0.3126155436038971, 0.03655073791742325, -0.21846824884414673, -0.4241495728492737, 0.18427078425884247, 0.6225178837776184, -0.16668665409088135, -0.3541983366012573, 0.21007247269153595, 0.8080443143844604, 0.5319905877113342, -0.6350381970405579, 0.7435930967330933, -0.20804056525230408, -0.3003571331501007, -0.2608008086681366, 0.22210484743118286, 0.1472797840833664, 0.5968478322029114, 0.08817197382450104, 0.11207684874534607, -0.3255421817302704, -0.4718064069747925, 0.27813488245010376, 0.3341333866119385, -0.22146005928516388, -0.36471208930015564, 0.6863866448402405, 0.2766832113265991, -0.21297582983970642, 0.5192843675613403, -0.12456026673316956, -0.255828857421875, 0.058072205632925034, 0.4258548319339752, 0.830735445022583, -0.14873550832271576, 0.3729424774646759, -0.09506698697805405, 0.17262765765190125, -0.4845506250858307, 0.10507871955633163, -0.3617871105670929, -0.6142376065254211, -0.3386164903640747, -0.7684428691864014, -0.6810632348060608, 0.21380926668643951, -0.7115603089332581, 0.05795826017856598, -1.0047246217727661, 0.2590133249759674, -0.40479329228401184, 0.3503654897212982, -0.6250054836273193, -0.15033942461013794, 0.085991770029068, 0.7985342741012573, -0.5791260600090027, 0.986299455165863, 0.45611944794654846, -0.34362706542015076, -0.7739963531494141, -0.04190830513834953, 0.0007378611480817199, -0.7434706091880798, 0.1707826405763626, 0.34349536895751953, 0.03146263584494591, 0.22523386776447296, -0.5479122996330261, -0.7112462520599365, 1.2530977725982666, 0.6189329028129578, -0.8637118339538574, -0.011400507763028145, 0.3176595866680145, 0.5485832691192627, -0.5301271080970764, -0.1893826276063919, 0.4891795516014099, 0.2286185771226883, -0.15137790143489838, -0.8295697569847107, -0.051639020442962646, 0.27649638056755066, -0.24435552954673767, 0.25456342101097107, -0.8323367834091187, 0.7260435819625854, -0.4053322374820709, -0.1577776074409485, 0.04558654502034187, 0.8203450441360474, 0.09177181124687195, 0.5557174682617188, 0.22116921842098236, 0.48711544275283813, 1.0536653995513916, -0.2108847051858902, 0.7856448292732239, -0.21433211863040924, 0.7227247953414917, 1.332399845123291, -0.4153335988521576, 0.7445643544197083, 0.18688590824604034, -0.010880938731133938, 0.170613631606102, 0.36698630452156067, 0.017994586378335953, 0.7273075580596924, -0.027826491743326187, -0.5094977617263794, -0.15633641183376312, 0.10122944414615631, -0.28308406472206116, 0.516567587852478, -0.003050915664061904, -0.37727656960487366, -0.34954309463500977, 0.14449530839920044, 0.06380510330200195, 0.38646912574768066, -0.29538801312446594, 0.7586894631385803, 0.22188961505889893, -0.25611695647239685, 0.5328219532966614, 0.07627686858177185, 0.6408041715621948, -0.561560869216919, 0.2319517880678177, -0.5277968645095825, 0.5937596559524536, -0.3068339228630066, -0.4388280212879181, 0.2662639319896698, 0.06878305971622467, -0.056176163256168365, -0.6507599949836731, 0.4874460995197296, -0.616624116897583, -0.10476873815059662, 0.42586004734039307, 0.3731408715248108, -0.04409105330705643, 0.1528085172176361, -0.4541787803173065, 0.1409495621919632, -0.11170246452093124, -0.10769271850585938, 0.7477768063545227, 0.41424188017845154, 0.19122779369354248, 0.5563982129096985, 0.7204239964485168, -0.011292247101664543, -0.04429110139608383, 0.05234868451952934, 0.8894577026367188, -0.18544699251651764, -0.47324585914611816, -0.6131479144096375, 0.06262411177158356, 0.0956619381904602, -0.1976582407951355, 0.7707812190055847, 0.6842758655548096, 1.497506856918335, -0.1492990106344223, 0.4510941803455353, 0.3898359537124634, 0.2606150805950165, -0.5074040293693542, 0.969238817691803, -0.10918949544429779, 0.1901780515909195, 0.026259100064635277, -0.8048336505889893, -0.3810666799545288, 0.5536378622055054, -0.5173691511154175, -0.3265126645565033, 0.41665199398994446, 0.8014922738075256, -0.2143256664276123, 0.4529638886451721, 0.319042444229126, 0.1381004899740219, 0.27418169379234314, 0.43486031889915466, 0.4751991033554077, -0.09712184220552444, 0.3700813055038452, -0.7294893264770508, -0.3009342551231384, -0.2685098946094513, -0.6815409660339355, -0.9942051768302917, -0.41321954131126404, -0.43328309059143066, -0.04608776792883873, 0.2189309000968933, 1.154489517211914, 0.768386960029602, -0.8431242108345032, -0.32327595353126526, -0.39637449383735657, 0.17637334764003754, -0.30005791783332825, -0.21596021950244904, 0.049390628933906555, -0.24397540092468262, -0.5919719338417053, 0.5695487260818481, 0.3579905331134796, 0.054364077746868134, -0.6352479457855225, -0.3961893916130066, 0.07338019460439682, -0.259389728307724, 0.34387627243995667, 0.20209884643554688, -0.3783950209617615, -0.1788048893213272, -0.11825329065322876, -0.1782538890838623, 0.1328834444284439, 0.7514588236808777, -0.4646095037460327, 0.5325638651847839, 0.31155768036842346, 0.9216814637184143, 0.47120201587677, 0.14858272671699524, 0.5639194846153259, -0.8606933951377869, 0.286002516746521, 0.2665749192237854, 0.2213304042816162, 0.42807894945144653, -0.4065355360507965, 0.4943526089191437, 0.3628370761871338, -0.7509886026382446, -1.0099048614501953, -0.13030871748924255, -0.7133690714836121, 0.05184342339634895, 1.0483684539794922, -0.7082306146621704, -0.33311107754707336, 0.12566833198070526, 0.1879194676876068, 0.03764284402132034, -0.5727009177207947, 0.6805644035339355, 0.48347166180610657, 0.11640802025794983, -0.13956867158412933, -0.1467813104391098, 0.4475613534450531, -0.12910856306552887, -0.9129588603973389, 0.386856347322464, 0.6558338403701782, 0.31555092334747314, -0.14338241517543793, 0.7919908165931702, -0.10336678475141525, 0.20918911695480347, -0.05691566690802574, -0.1738625317811966, -0.6061668992042542, -0.4139932692050934, -0.7194049954414368, 0.4186399579048157, 0.06736521422863007, -0.3486587107181549 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06948v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06948v1	Should I try multiple optimizers when fine-tuning pre-trained Transformers for NLP tasks? Should I tune their hyperparameters?	2024-02-10T13:26:14	2024-02-10T13:26:14	Nefeli Gkouti, Prodromos Malakasiotis, Stavros Toumpis, Ion Androutsopoulos	cs.CL	cs.CL	NLP research has explored different neural model architectures and sizes, datasets, training objectives, and transfer learning techniques. However, the choice of optimizer during training has not been explored as extensively. Typically, some variant of Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) is employed, selected among numerous variants, using unclear criteria, often with minimal or no tuning of the optimizer's hyperparameters. Experimenting with five GLUE datasets, two models (DistilBERT and DistilRoBERTa), and seven popular optimizers (SGD, SGD with Momentum, Adam, AdaMax, Nadam, AdamW, and AdaBound), we find that when the hyperparameters of the optimizers are tuned, there is no substantial difference in test performance across the five more elaborate (adaptive) optimizers, despite differences in training loss. Furthermore, tuning just the learning rate is in most cases as good as tuning all the hyperparameters. Hence, we recommend picking any of the best-behaved adaptive optimizers (e.g., Adam) and tuning only its learning rate. When no hyperparameter can be tuned, SGD with Momentum is the best choice.	[ -0.6932713389396667, -0.32730963826179504, 0.25829991698265076, 0.5465511083602905, -0.3150838315486908, -0.30819883942604065, -0.5851004123687744, -0.19947341084480286, 0.15793991088867188, 0.35513201355934143, -0.6793351769447327, -0.11071509122848511, -0.8838393688201904, 0.25672000646591187, -0.2282012403011322, 1.4447442293167114, 0.10080418735742569, 0.11904462426900864, 0.1451464146375656, -0.22501789033412933, -0.36237749457359314, -0.23022869229316711, -1.2619075775146484, -0.1329597383737564, 0.6399632096290588, 0.18209083378314972, 0.7981777787208557, 0.7142381072044373, 0.9476386904716492, 0.3346870541572571, -0.20779119431972504, 0.4482392966747284, -0.2992398738861084, 0.08192789554595947, -0.276075541973114, -0.7178211212158203, -0.47283923625946045, 0.07616552710533142, 0.12011981010437012, 0.5966715216636658, -0.29445144534111023, 0.4085531532764435, 0.28777071833610535, 0.5804967284202576, -0.793989360332489, -0.11608917266130447, -0.6699042916297913, 0.4908352792263031, -0.17807167768478394, -0.5419329404830933, -0.3176540732383728, -0.2641478478908539, -0.04475924000144005, -0.6438121199607849, 0.46360665559768677, 0.10493962466716766, 0.951609194278717, 0.8800506591796875, -0.11590271443128586, 0.16807813942432404, -1.0044828653335571, 0.9433454275131226, -0.766904354095459, 0.40368619561195374, 0.17791472375392914, 0.3420383632183075, -0.03551079332828522, -0.8214744329452515, -0.347119003534317, -0.031725794076919556, 0.12594974040985107, 0.4085073471069336, -0.10248268395662308, 0.15012794733047485, 0.6916301250457764, 0.4056060016155243, -0.5547346472740173, 0.40197160840034485, -0.3337958753108978, -0.047900259494781494, 0.5910954475402832, 0.08293763548135757, -0.1962948888540268, 0.2815271019935608, -0.4685302972793579, -0.31299570202827454, -0.24551378190517426, 0.06828560680150986, 0.6261036396026611, 0.5294589400291443, 0.32948142290115356, 0.4008101224899292, -0.08042313903570175, 0.6405012607574463, 0.5966755747795105, -0.177185520529747, 0.19305825233459473, -0.5167925357818604, -0.11838468164205551, -0.03515104576945305, 0.7354253530502319, 0.43854570388793945, 0.641815185546875, -0.1796472817659378, -0.37036988139152527, 0.1279878467321396, 0.8792546987533569, -0.6716362833976746, -0.5025555491447449, 0.08117055147886276, -0.5115455389022827, -0.21104969084262848, -0.38043612241744995, -0.5884131789207458, 0.17714570462703705, -0.6074851155281067, 0.4672597348690033, -0.2605903148651123, -0.12356974184513092, 0.4715014696121216, -0.2231086790561676, -0.01761247217655182, 0.093910351395607, -1.217537522315979, 0.30777159333229065, 0.5862656235694885, 0.6178218722343445, -0.4240068197250366, -0.5906847715377808, -0.5218661427497864, -0.1585240662097931, -0.563633143901825, 0.6869115829467773, -0.37321028113365173, 0.006525932811200619, -0.005520429462194443, 0.0036898222751915455, -0.4204939603805542, -0.5120813250541687, 1.1548322439193726, -0.22873623669147491, 0.06667819619178772, -0.26454633474349976, -0.5829859972000122, -0.074039526283741, -0.11565200239419937, -0.5791626572608948, 1.0972926616668701, 0.14520937204360962, -0.5310197472572327, 0.862899661064148, -0.7213439345359802, -0.4647386074066162, -0.006492681801319122, 0.2740449607372284, -0.5781186819076538, 0.441388338804245, 0.39593392610549927, 0.5952224731445312, 0.03902922570705414, 0.027058305218815804, -0.3244556486606598, -0.3989833891391754, -0.4222789704799652, -0.4589548110961914, 0.5153512358665466, 0.14770947396755219, -0.40170177817344666, 0.1186547502875328, -0.8487414121627808, 0.32656851410865784, -0.15376919507980347, -0.42876312136650085, -0.030745146796107292, 0.28865545988082886, 0.23884743452072144, 0.18811579048633575, -0.13223768770694733, -0.3579067587852478, 0.14773111045360565, -0.653064489364624, 0.24942739307880402, 0.853569746017456, 0.06657689809799194, 0.3142268657684326, -0.412089079618454, 0.6338589787483215, 0.09311340004205704, 0.2918683588504791, 0.2690044045448303, -0.36315956711769104, -1.0164669752120972, 0.23076565563678741, 0.19480426609516144, 0.2283138781785965, -0.5317132472991943, 0.5997651815414429, 0.2215602695941925, -0.6429493427276611, -0.8440563082695007, 0.18650653958320618, 0.1930697113275528, 0.44819334149360657, 0.7782962322235107, -0.22046025097370148, -0.3607174754142761, -0.9533390402793884, -0.6758496761322021, 0.09913400560617447, -0.06706896424293518, 0.17495667934417725, 0.4034261405467987, 0.18055976927280426, 0.6458232402801514, -0.5087378621101379, -0.536796510219574, -0.09190492331981659, -0.14631320536136627, 0.36358535289764404, 0.6072293519973755, 0.9777288436889648, -0.7579339146614075, -0.5694521069526672, 0.0034345577005296946, -0.18211746215820312, 0.20175552368164062, -0.3127312958240509, -0.10022793710231781, -0.03736194595694542, 0.4050500690937042, -0.570877730846405, 0.22003120183944702, 0.48445558547973633, 0.24092905223369598, 0.6014543175697327, -0.1923070102930069, -0.0910300612449646, -0.9234672784805298, -0.1527460813522339, 0.3678882420063019, 0.0803077220916748, -0.6096324324607849, 0.23086316883563995, -0.04334753751754761, 0.08025195449590683, -0.6012023687362671, 0.12015337496995926, -0.013308631256222725, 0.1713591367006302, -0.2392301708459854, -0.17976228892803192, -0.06309056282043457, 0.6851436495780945, -0.12642553448677063, 1.013539433479309, 0.8014461994171143, -0.8438625335693359, 0.36614060401916504, 0.23413483798503876, -0.24490216374397278, 0.43492984771728516, -1.047567367553711, 0.2452814131975174, -0.1804177612066269, -0.07320327311754227, -0.7646313309669495, 0.10065720975399017, 0.15706518292427063, -0.22901400923728943, 0.3767513334751129, 0.050855960696935654, -0.3680136799812317, -0.3825951814651489, -0.21805265545845032, 0.04857311397790909, 0.2832612991333008, -0.6140133738517761, 0.5494371056556702, 0.08096516132354736, 0.19039829075336456, -0.8032744526863098, -0.3662348985671997, -0.17840877175331116, -0.5990129113197327, -0.4864799678325653, 0.526982843875885, -0.2107466757297516, 0.44157567620277405, -0.2981168031692505, -0.4525402784347534, -0.03278229385614395, 0.22599735856056213, 0.08901764452457428, -0.22061315178871155, -0.4947233498096466, 0.054208990186452866, 0.18536029756069183, -0.5106247663497925, 0.035733018070459366, -0.36496442556381226, 0.45872029662132263, -0.32118862867355347, -0.3054235279560089, -0.4586060345172882, 0.18718859553337097, 0.29149478673934937, -0.41857820749282837, 0.699487566947937, 1.367652177810669, -0.12445075064897537, -0.23714852333068848, -0.6253029108047485, -0.3900141417980194, -0.5292208194732666, 0.3560178875923157, -0.4376186728477478, -0.8173295855522156, 0.3730514347553253, -0.28966832160949707, 0.37197360396385193, 0.7147160172462463, 0.7027890086174011, -0.24476779997348785, 1.2911646366119385, 0.841810941696167, -0.16102266311645508, 0.18007636070251465, -0.24923475086688995, 0.42287880182266235, -0.9318909049034119, 0.1999189704656601, -0.8254342675209045, -0.6330229043960571, -0.7978190183639526, 0.040407877415418625, 0.36073172092437744, 0.2594992220401764, -0.08291671425104141, 0.7014302015304565, -0.7223398089408875, 0.7110168933868408, 0.7773752808570862, -0.05005699396133423, -0.1079004779458046, -0.07605873048305511, 0.21489779651165009, -0.14278066158294678, -0.9501182436943054, -0.2692548334598541, 1.2153279781341553, 0.045153819024562836, 0.6704789400100708, -0.1500292867422104, 0.6240676045417786, -0.38892480731010437, -0.24146313965320587, -0.8903220295906067, 0.36878588795661926, -0.45110610127449036, -0.6461838483810425, -0.2985025644302368, -0.13382931053638458, -1.2219728231430054, 0.32127976417541504, -0.4237760007381439, -0.46109670400619507, 0.3440765142440796, 0.3570472002029419, -0.8108435869216919, 0.20865605771541595, -0.5453451871871948, 0.915375292301178, -0.09958390146493912, -0.16259348392486572, -0.18113753199577332, -0.6953978538513184, 0.02423930913209915, -0.2653064429759979, -0.4404231309890747, -0.09580041468143463, -0.045716557651758194, 0.7979719638824463, -0.06330564618110657, 0.29636964201927185, -0.07336710393428802, 0.29198333621025085, -0.09977301955223083, -0.20727543532848358, 0.5500050783157349, -0.006891166791319847, -0.02667357213795185, 0.06142168864607811, 0.08626745641231537, -0.20957151055335999, -0.6274455189704895, 0.5151342153549194, -0.767227828502655, -0.7547060251235962, -0.16969041526317596, -0.3316988945007324, -0.18470171093940735, 0.2656386196613312, 0.5166882872581482, 0.34965282678604126, 0.29125574231147766, 0.5067728757858276, 0.36649176478385925, 0.14109677076339722, 0.7042473554611206, 0.019662491977214813, 0.3436250686645508, 0.15897560119628906, 0.8890273571014404, -0.026002638041973114, 0.36145615577697754, -0.000021782559997518547, 0.21379205584526062, -0.1388212889432907, -0.9609391093254089, -0.26586055755615234, 0.09274973720312119, -0.45029881596565247, -0.21264581382274628, -0.5200979113578796, -0.25140154361724854, -0.1770913153886795, -0.20751485228538513, -0.7085665464401245, -0.27839767932891846, -0.5253239870071411, -0.02223529852926731, 0.18353180587291718, -0.024238092824816704, -0.011113890446722507, 0.39636901021003723, -0.6558459401130676, 0.4970509707927704, 0.13258741796016693, 0.25982779264450073, -0.2892663776874542, -0.3334658145904541, -0.36138802766799927, -0.005138501990586519, -0.20494410395622253, -0.3980257511138916, 0.42218104004859924, 0.629021167755127, 0.6356632709503174, 0.6493045091629028, 0.030184946954250336, 0.8682659864425659, -0.7100406885147095, 0.6076477766036987, 0.056644197553396225, -0.41467082500457764, 0.4534636437892914, -0.19231463968753815, 0.2281428575515747, 0.9707867503166199, 0.900657057762146, -0.2491571456193924, -0.27785590291023254, -0.6329115629196167, -0.7921555638313293, 0.7107461094856262, 0.18102900683879852, 0.26126569509506226, 0.08223863691091537, 0.3948981463909149, 0.06555426865816116, 0.34684863686561584, -0.30494722723960876, -0.5256723165512085, -0.005884517915546894, 0.11237523704767227, -0.1979493945837021, 0.15706562995910645, -0.34459587931632996, -0.32118871808052063, 0.45232880115509033, -0.426622211933136, 0.0034939844626933336, -0.06326527148485184, 0.19693724811077118, -0.2998688519001007, -0.07179207354784012, 0.2938351035118103, 0.8549232482910156, -0.35393285751342773, -0.1319105327129364, 0.27544426918029785, -0.53822261095047, 0.05368902534246445, -0.1614738553762436, -0.0599265955388546, 0.08547667413949966, 0.15658290684223175, 1.2013317346572876, 0.02944488637149334, -0.15837326645851135, 0.4118686020374298, -0.16023796796798706, -0.37013521790504456, -0.06042054668068886, 0.6087836027145386, -0.09295693039894104, 0.2751282751560211, -0.009328015148639679, 1.0044527053833008, 0.1775946170091629, -0.08922958374023438, 0.1227913424372673, 0.30277010798454285, -0.35775622725486755, -0.23413875699043274, 0.819502592086792, 0.06584577262401581, -0.7153570652008057, 0.5529217720031738, -0.09383869916200638, -0.3207411468029022, 0.586527943611145, 0.39680972695350647, 0.9462660551071167, -0.43217727541923523, 0.06019260361790657, 0.3559834361076355, 0.5167192220687866, -0.3843105733394623, 0.06373574584722519, 0.13319721817970276, -0.9992218017578125, -0.8538426160812378, -0.8681062459945679, -0.28184473514556885, 0.11977975070476532, -1.0452735424041748, 0.39176616072654724, -0.28482669591903687, -0.5486503839492798, 0.640673816204071, -0.11621490120887756, -1.0034334659576416, 0.3469010293483734, -0.24065560102462769, 0.6251341104507446, -0.8635983467102051, 0.4559400975704193, 0.5887438058853149, -0.18218572437763214, -0.6854578852653503, -0.047416262328624725, -0.14175502955913544, -0.5782942771911621, 0.5676319599151611, -0.17625798285007477, -0.004641874693334103, 0.3977537751197815, -0.15480947494506836, -0.9919891357421875, 0.544350802898407, 0.3641805946826935, -0.647808313369751, -0.1366032212972641, -0.15545102953910828, 0.6373739838600159, -0.24612514674663544, 0.4454186260700226, 0.7760406136512756, 0.4870178997516632, -0.1807054579257965, -1.113703727722168, -0.3962711691856384, -0.012851311825215816, 0.12982924282550812, 0.2935323715209961, -0.7617537379264832, 0.8861207365989685, -0.20780858397483826, -0.1981106400489807, -0.24169954657554626, 0.4507484436035156, 0.06248176097869873, 0.024906987324357033, 0.6718723177909851, 0.6248795390129089, 0.4354221820831299, -0.12744034826755524, 1.00047767162323, -0.6492947936058044, 0.3773806393146515, 0.9047974944114685, 0.10828949511051178, 0.7822597622871399, 0.5241350531578064, -0.6738867163658142, -0.20739030838012695, 0.779283344745636, -0.38783833384513855, 0.2687138020992279, 0.1890118420124054, 0.17351599037647247, -0.4263997972011566, 0.004016052931547165, -0.4257448613643646, 0.5557315349578857, 0.16869156062602997, -0.11301060765981674, -0.21528731286525726, 0.04589056596159935, -0.15632064640522003, -0.026264039799571037, -0.18583114445209503, 0.6510562896728516, -0.02551358938217163, -0.7116836309432983, 0.7602033019065857, -0.04449395462870598, 0.7228600978851318, -0.5574649572372437, 0.22885236144065857, -0.16528482735157013, 0.4197760224342346, -0.3254540264606476, -0.577380895614624, 0.37632158398628235, -0.5129696726799011, -0.07355847954750061, -0.29732224345207214, 0.7170241475105286, -0.3984965980052948, -0.3601623475551605, 0.10789528489112854, 0.35866257548332214, 0.16595494747161865, -0.2685093879699707, -0.9492329359054565, -0.29113414883613586, -0.08859013020992279, -0.5487368106842041, 0.5079092383384705, 0.022577470168471336, 0.3915187120437622, 0.6874693632125854, 1.0348193645477295, 0.3176475167274475, 0.13795983791351318, 0.2890247702598572, 0.8431189060211182, -0.27907994389533997, -0.26314446330070496, -0.7802404165267944, 0.35501357913017273, -0.04279883950948715, -1.0072013139724731, 1.0526716709136963, 0.4361284077167511, 1.1397334337234497, -0.11967367678880692, 0.1872340738773346, 0.563348650932312, 0.39093834161758423, -0.4565596282482147, 0.4087236523628235, -0.6415990591049194, -0.3668832778930664, -0.48071911931037903, -1.692689299583435, -0.25980252027511597, 0.7761929035186768, 0.1733894646167755, 0.17684926092624664, 1.0047359466552734, 0.7226783037185669, 0.00477416068315506, 0.19439871609210968, 0.11161814630031586, -0.1969071477651596, 0.14488643407821655, 0.4492690861225128, 0.5267123579978943, -0.5128418207168579, 0.3947369158267975, -0.3798072040081024, 0.14695565402507782, -0.14240536093711853, -0.6558194756507874, -0.6925274729728699, -0.457389771938324, -0.4671575427055359, 0.01629551686346531, -0.043206121772527695, 0.7774362564086914, 0.8044575452804565, -0.7162551879882812, -0.046501073986291885, 0.03884005919098854, -0.2689361870288849, -0.7904828190803528, -0.1853325217962265, 0.4146718382835388, -0.9533732533454895, -1.140655517578125, 0.5509638786315918, 0.5509657859802246, -0.252592533826828, -0.11998384445905685, 0.23141363263130188, -0.1490623503923416, -0.04251262545585632, 0.40565210580825806, -0.007328812498599291, -0.5061646699905396, -0.4726901650428772, -0.015609199181199074, 0.1274482011795044, 0.038703784346580505, 0.6528087258338928, -0.40686118602752686, 0.3878682255744934, 0.4488077163696289, 0.8379238247871399, 0.7195305228233337, -0.03186020255088806, 0.4283217787742615, -0.6756430864334106, 0.06621086597442627, 0.5549681782722473, 0.206093430519104, -0.23993223905563354, -0.10758525133132935, 0.7512701153755188, -0.07187722623348236, -0.836073100566864, -0.8204994201660156, 0.13004788756370544, -0.8024681210517883, 0.04584021493792534, 0.9929746389389038, 0.010044915601611137, 0.08012481033802032, -0.12112502008676529, -0.11243514716625214, 0.033796679228544235, -0.09271374344825745, 0.4959266483783722, 0.7130010724067688, -0.425931841135025, -0.0746387243270874, -0.8273148536682129, 1.0704067945480347, 1.045400619506836, -0.42786937952041626, -0.23992052674293518, -0.15699365735054016, -0.12455827742815018, 0.36504602432250977, 0.16629362106323242, 0.3819114565849304, -0.0010038076434284449, 0.04048663005232811, -0.26109451055526733, -0.06530992686748505, -0.7069926261901855, -0.20494182407855988, 0.123113714158535, -0.146769180893898, -0.25172919034957886 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06930v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06930v1	LiFi: Lightweight Controlled Text Generation with Fine-Grained Control Codes	2024-02-10T11:53:48	2024-02-10T11:53:48	Chufan Shi, Deng Cai, Yujiu Yang	cs.CL	cs.CL	In the rapidly evolving field of text generation, the demand for more precise control mechanisms has become increasingly apparent. To address this need, we present a novel methodology, LIFI, which offers a lightweight approach with fine-grained control for controlled text generation. Unlike previous studies that train pre-trained language models to follow discrete, categorical, and exclusive control codes, LIFI learns controlled text generation under the guidance of continuous, relative, and nonexclusive control codes. These fine-grained codes are automatically derived from an attribute classifier, initially trained with a small amount of labeled data and subsequently employed to label abundant unlabeled data, thus garnering more extensive supervision signals. Moreover, to achieve efficient control, we incorporate the fine-grained control codes with adapters, a parameter- and compute-efficient way to steer a pre-trained language model. We evaluate LIFI on two conventional tasks -- sentiment control and topic control -- and one newly proposed task -- stylistic novel writing. Comprehensive experimental results validate the effectiveness of our proposed methods, demonstrating substantial performance improvements over existing baselines.	[ -0.2940918505191803, -0.9393423795700073, 0.3743240535259247, 0.23369979858398438, -0.057061225175857544, -0.11069206893444061, -0.44640886783599854, -0.2803223431110382, 0.052302032709121704, 0.4564788341522217, -0.5356266498565674, -0.22987008094787598, -0.27925071120262146, 0.026101751253008842, -0.3732040226459503, 1.4378931522369385, -0.16448302567005157, -0.3111608028411865, -0.23272950947284698, 0.010355377569794655, -0.06733621656894684, -0.21022620797157288, -0.38032689690589905, -0.4867376983165741, 0.8988949060440063, 0.4851808249950409, 0.6425926089286804, 0.4888637363910675, 0.5420247912406921, 0.24840477108955383, 0.06639480590820312, 0.29485151171684265, -0.5646329522132874, -0.10904568433761597, -0.15636149048805237, -0.19113469123840332, -0.411447674036026, -0.2733106315135956, 0.6053000092506409, 0.5456196069717407, 0.1664968878030777, 0.14455027878284454, 0.22918406128883362, 0.7631694078445435, -0.7945666909217834, -0.13428983092308044, -0.5918372869491577, 0.018309960141777992, -0.21367333829402924, -0.5118778944015503, -0.5778815746307373, -0.4338252544403076, -0.20214590430259705, -0.4462280571460724, 0.030414080247282982, 0.015846440568566322, 0.7820513844490051, 0.1753264218568802, -0.30404284596443176, -0.49732524156570435, -0.8521339297294617, 0.7624817490577698, -0.5840538144111633, 0.0914822369813919, 0.27521294355392456, -0.11234121024608612, -0.12611623108386993, -0.9962779879570007, -0.5299376249313354, -0.3047843277454376, -0.1683807075023651, 0.036648184061050415, 0.11039195954799652, 0.13673469424247742, 0.08532635122537613, 0.5257329940795898, -0.32873275876045227, 0.1464819461107254, -0.12055158615112305, -0.09083455801010132, 0.5840190649032593, -0.007994147017598152, 0.19012807309627533, -0.08168329298496246, -0.326354056596756, -0.06112389639019966, -0.4948764443397522, 0.3556798994541168, 0.46179649233818054, 0.21445028483867645, -0.13764534890651703, 0.5670201182365417, -0.5235236883163452, 0.5691031813621521, 0.3321091830730438, -0.4626835882663727, 0.13316340744495392, -0.32698649168014526, -0.319248229265213, 0.03537554293870926, 0.9546512365341187, 0.4956279397010803, 0.40515419840812683, -0.14234501123428345, -0.5727803111076355, -0.10892567783594131, 0.21177786588668823, -1.1070592403411865, -0.2026071846485138, 0.004655692260712385, -0.6572114825248718, -0.8902548551559448, -0.10853211581707001, -0.5275551080703735, -0.3291381299495697, -0.183537095785141, 0.5546234846115112, -0.3086349070072174, 0.09118999540805817, -0.0624583475291729, -0.11358177661895752, 0.33722594380378723, 0.18181848526000977, -1.0247423648834229, 0.24804748594760895, 0.1716119647026062, 0.5482257008552551, -0.3241391181945801, -0.0534832701086998, -0.7162885069847107, 0.23403297364711761, -0.4301418364048004, 0.503410279750824, -0.4581829905509949, -0.2694290578365326, 0.15426628291606903, -0.18439029157161713, 0.3356820344924927, -0.06084921583533287, 0.44633954763412476, -0.29388362169265747, 0.04235400632023811, 0.14043572545051575, -0.4515872597694397, 0.3212484121322632, -0.03723801672458649, -0.5662208199501038, 1.0498219728469849, 0.21577595174312592, -1.0141912698745728, 0.33602601289749146, -0.26064443588256836, -0.7489339709281921, 0.07864145189523697, -0.3110392093658447, -0.5439345240592957, 0.15548312664031982, -0.1814364641904831, 0.7365071773529053, -0.20493343472480774, 0.39474186301231384, -0.1459665596485138, -0.20891955494880676, 0.3703902065753937, -0.5218631029129028, 0.15446729958057404, 0.33255159854888916, -0.4163278341293335, 0.02444061078131199, -0.9103987216949463, 0.26534003019332886, 0.16768956184387207, -0.5323927402496338, -0.32266706228256226, 0.061896082013845444, 0.5648787021636963, -0.2824546992778778, 0.4301694929599762, -0.3587285876274109, 0.14942412078380585, -0.26951780915260315, 0.18249166011810303, 0.4504256844520569, 0.07669612020254135, 0.958207368850708, -0.599493682384491, 0.11807064712047577, -0.518602192401886, -0.027986975386738777, -0.31131497025489807, -0.12828119099140167, -0.921934962272644, -0.08342007547616959, 0.18934853374958038, 0.48796936869621277, -1.0768499374389648, 0.6408181190490723, 0.1688917875289917, -0.6905481219291687, 0.020100902765989304, 0.37872153520584106, 0.45000243186950684, 0.4946261942386627, 0.2492351233959198, -0.07457537949085236, -0.02075950987637043, -0.6566663980484009, -0.08243774622678757, 0.11982613801956177, 0.013149366714060307, 0.3571140170097351, 0.394336462020874, -0.2848900258541107, 0.8668428659439087, -0.6661333441734314, -0.21530990302562714, -0.5808321833610535, 0.48101258277893066, -0.1616193801164627, 1.012914776802063, 0.7899972200393677, -0.78669273853302, -0.3797975182533264, 0.1474447399377823, -0.3690319061279297, -0.4627235233783722, -0.6345304846763611, -0.27077746391296387, 0.21232563257217407, 0.6860098838806152, -0.275882363319397, 0.39951878786087036, 0.4180934429168701, -0.3796006143093109, 0.4224855899810791, -0.1464191973209381, -0.011837701313197613, -1.019758701324463, 0.23651018738746643, -0.02283639833331108, -0.49836814403533936, -0.7001132965087891, 0.06828653067350388, 0.11837728321552277, 0.12271438539028168, -0.3456747233867645, 0.5244346857070923, -0.19419676065444946, 0.37470266222953796, -0.4854782521724701, -0.1835256814956665, 0.13330335915088654, 0.7044128179550171, 0.07992134988307953, 0.6090832948684692, 0.2425817996263504, -0.5882893204689026, 0.13887789845466614, -0.18858276307582855, -0.3592086136341095, 0.3661841154098511, -0.629784345626831, 0.05286351218819618, -0.2732960879802704, 0.043306201696395874, -0.6481324434280396, -0.43267661333084106, 0.00855870358645916, -0.16003376245498657, 0.48900076746940613, 0.49240702390670776, -0.3846888840198517, -0.076917864382267, -0.27995064854621887, 0.16133423149585724, 0.5454173684120178, -0.1296391785144806, 0.6590128540992737, 0.005904534365981817, -0.30776146054267883, -0.2586877644062042, -0.8553426861763, -0.5289202332496643, -0.11832315474748611, 0.07846815884113312, 0.32723942399024963, -0.3858032524585724, -0.1367591917514801, -0.14201462268829346, -0.031687673181295395, -0.3683156371116638, 0.3424651324748993, 0.12584516406059265, -0.07572952657938004, -0.07815451174974442, 0.20872007310390472, 0.6037573218345642, 0.08367136120796204, -0.22632412612438202, -0.22506697475910187, 0.49529632925987244, 0.093350850045681, 0.08396425098180771, -0.49789223074913025, 0.47749775648117065, 0.26148125529289246, -0.29117098450660706, 0.37086331844329834, 0.7814096808433533, -0.2301795482635498, -0.8297781348228455, -0.24045449495315552, 0.04015527665615082, -0.5554172396659851, 0.3001052737236023, -0.29552996158599854, -0.998560905456543, 0.06954746693372726, -0.23711428046226501, 0.2928767204284668, 0.31405889987945557, 0.47358664870262146, -0.13212068378925323, 0.6517698764801025, 1.2630730867385864, 0.0813213363289833, 0.7970443367958069, 0.09539522230625153, -0.13451968133449554, -0.10716288536787033, -0.16382206976413727, -0.676756739616394, -0.4580453038215637, -0.6977309584617615, -0.3122592270374298, 0.006453330162912607, 0.4037165343761444, -0.3051958978176117, 0.08891987800598145, -0.6940117478370667, 0.5733250379562378, 0.49610331654548645, 0.12757103145122528, 0.35594502091407776, -0.30176034569740295, 0.08305373042821884, 0.18625687062740326, -0.6098409295082092, -0.4402991831302643, 0.9408353567123413, 0.3706858158111572, 1.2925511598587036, -0.26445505023002625, 0.8394051790237427, 0.5026424527168274, 0.33582809567451477, -0.790708601474762, 0.33289727568626404, -0.44802945852279663, -0.22385062277317047, -0.20290371775627136, -0.4733557105064392, -0.32454514503479004, -0.4534704387187958, -0.545531153678894, -0.6068474650382996, 0.23615498840808868, 0.30811187624931335, -0.403592050075531, 0.08952824026346207, -0.8772000670433044, 0.6888431310653687, -0.39264294505119324, -0.463338702917099, 0.0780608206987381, -0.4658147394657135, 0.2668773829936981, -0.5424913763999939, 0.11864755302667618, -0.0868709534406662, -0.0739455372095108, 0.7075943946838379, -0.2769022285938263, 0.8371909260749817, -0.01350873801857233, -0.2934196889400482, 0.367967814207077, 0.12169003486633301, 0.5965023636817932, 0.2838328182697296, -0.014540985226631165, -0.4248340427875519, -0.01679735817015171, -0.32194891571998596, -0.31966227293014526, 0.6835258603096008, -0.6862383484840393, 0.06758676469326019, -0.09124471247196198, -0.757422685623169, -0.016642214730381966, 0.7772094011306763, 0.4889608919620514, 0.7172107100486755, -0.5090896487236023, 0.5037999153137207, 0.9435698390007019, -0.385794073343277, 0.881267249584198, 0.177354633808136, -0.3008391559123993, -0.5154948830604553, 0.9089429974555969, -0.03723757714033127, 0.42816343903541565, 0.8232845664024353, 0.16967494785785675, 0.23709769546985626, -0.44517168402671814, -0.29302510619163513, -0.2560864984989166, -0.5109692811965942, -0.5491181015968323, -0.6477617621421814, -0.2458602488040924, -0.15794619917869568, -0.7629202008247375, -0.3455197215080261, -0.31177306175231934, -0.4384695589542389, 0.19892920553684235, 0.4160822927951813, 0.9709763526916504, 0.4398775100708008, 0.857915461063385, -0.5424306392669678, 0.616766631603241, 0.24140490591526031, 0.4755552113056183, -0.32684236764907837, -0.056048911064863205, -0.35058969259262085, -0.1733730435371399, -0.25900161266326904, -0.6717438101768494, 0.09798359125852585, 0.6198752522468567, 0.11184333264827728, 0.4167204797267914, 0.4270038306713104, 0.25931471586227417, -0.7001429796218872, 0.6496902108192444, 0.2906937897205353, -0.9760595560073853, 0.5138819813728333, -0.41466614603996277, 0.5574980974197388, 0.7989534735679626, 0.2347440868616104, 0.017206892371177673, -0.6593827605247498, -0.33281102776527405, -0.5047076344490051, 0.47796425223350525, 0.19141468405723572, 0.32723739743232727, 0.2149343639612198, 0.5512317419052124, 0.24494995176792145, 0.388380765914917, -0.9181424379348755, -0.09843828529119492, -0.3421618640422821, -0.6352488994598389, -0.04265693947672844, -0.2259664237499237, -0.09347504377365112, -0.0960441529750824, 0.48736491799354553, -0.5942114591598511, 0.13892996311187744, 0.35386818647384644, -0.03444152697920799, -0.1747601330280304, 0.3023676872253418, 0.4291391670703888, 0.19657479226589203, -0.06560128182172775, 0.2053019106388092, -0.06245887652039528, -0.5294814109802246, 0.029445325955748558, 0.2351350486278534, -0.6776052117347717, -0.08369351923465729, 0.2527904510498047, 0.8725553750991821, 0.1593032032251358, -0.6074336171150208, 0.6019840240478516, -0.06502187252044678, -0.38712605834007263, -0.06204046681523323, 0.4060018062591553, -0.21145594120025635, 0.2154998481273651, 0.15899989008903503, 0.18252775073051453, 0.13339807093143463, -0.34414970874786377, 0.356016606092453, 0.3588462471961975, -0.23879921436309814, -0.056729625910520554, 0.807180643081665, 0.5366399884223938, -0.024491602554917336, -0.02410336211323738, -0.371507465839386, 0.013479471206665039, 0.45418620109558105, 0.7643083930015564, 0.8818217515945435, 0.16441981494426727, 0.30024781823158264, 0.1015164777636528, 0.4010566473007202, 0.08181824535131454, 0.28137660026550293, -0.41749897599220276, -0.7247071862220764, -0.47149962186813354, -1.1412909030914307, -0.2402610182762146, 0.0632253885269165, -0.5000362396240234, 0.33077138662338257, -0.9393278360366821, -0.08750046044588089, 0.05161970853805542, 0.16494446992874146, -0.4166611135005951, 0.4429272413253784, 0.3477010428905487, 1.1151952743530273, -0.8301088213920593, 0.9968701601028442, 0.6562206149101257, -0.2211219072341919, -0.902255117893219, 0.24070069193840027, -0.34818196296691895, -0.2324463278055191, 0.19410772621631622, 0.3954426944255829, -0.2380465716123581, 0.3083779513835907, -0.8391021490097046, -0.6169532537460327, 1.1097080707550049, 0.03318369761109352, -0.4933336675167084, -0.15788955986499786, -0.10175882279872894, 0.4120371639728546, -0.3865366280078888, -0.03213800489902496, 0.6957769989967346, 0.3182826042175293, -0.08809483796358109, -0.7636812925338745, -0.1600590944290161, -0.35659709572792053, 0.11591263115406036, 0.15691371262073517, -0.758554220199585, 0.5422213077545166, 0.15548861026763916, 0.1392987072467804, 0.40312209725379944, 0.954291820526123, -0.16010934114456177, 0.32788676023483276, 0.39648741483688354, 0.2680424153804779, 0.67145174741745, -0.18753401935100555, 0.8108862638473511, -0.30262789130210876, 0.19807806611061096, 1.0038143396377563, -0.3050481677055359, 0.7137001752853394, 0.3618401288986206, 0.36142975091934204, 0.576654314994812, 0.06908012926578522, 0.1064930185675621, 0.6644648909568787, -0.03912920132279396, -0.3823719918727875, -0.06755945831537247, -0.43841829895973206, -0.001977283740416169, 0.3648766279220581, 0.17645195126533508, -0.39089927077293396, -0.07262635231018066, 0.4334309995174408, 0.25823521614074707, 0.4326612949371338, -0.5578203797340393, 1.0378408432006836, -0.05830734223127365, -0.5693647861480713, 0.4079245924949646, 0.28700605034828186, 0.9458982348442078, -0.8964552283287048, 0.06797372549772263, -0.22522778809070587, 0.33141517639160156, -0.3045436143875122, -0.7554493546485901, 0.1410558819770813, 0.373111367225647, -0.288618266582489, -0.6973469257354736, 1.0829672813415527, -0.6297750473022461, -0.4827460050582886, -0.11609126627445221, 0.19628772139549255, -0.2899217903614044, 0.379887193441391, -0.3140319585800171, 0.09596067667007446, 0.14357830584049225, -0.47218057513237, 0.19051337242126465, 0.6593500375747681, -0.07564084231853485, 0.29132452607154846, 0.40773433446884155, 0.15842802822589874, -0.04046854004263878, -0.08429325371980667, 1.063731074333191, -0.5750770568847656, -0.5915284156799316, -0.4232218265533447, 0.5546756982803345, 0.0800163671374321, -0.46849316358566284, 0.29400599002838135, 0.4010216295719147, 0.8074804544448853, -0.06835836917161942, 0.9863511323928833, -0.6301660537719727, 0.2550467252731323, -0.7613284587860107, 1.1174951791763306, -0.6566836833953857, -0.3250400424003601, -0.361512690782547, -0.8503894209861755, -0.3188733756542206, 0.4787638783454895, 0.12232407927513123, -0.007309065666049719, 0.6812965273857117, 0.6846488118171692, 0.03542173653841019, -0.35372158885002136, 0.22360092401504517, -0.0004974410985596478, 0.3042471408843994, 0.5201586484909058, 0.44717442989349365, -0.1882275640964508, 0.3954632878303528, -0.6503177285194397, -0.4747285842895508, 0.08270571380853653, -1.140295386314392, -1.1049147844314575, -0.31859177350997925, -0.058817148208618164, -0.129852756857872, -0.2365025281906128, 0.9749062657356262, 0.3568159341812134, -0.7657982110977173, -0.03480299562215805, -0.5338927507400513, 0.01575571298599243, -0.059990182518959045, -0.24708256125450134, 0.11982084065675735, -0.7149962782859802, -0.9311836957931519, 0.19345661997795105, 0.12740492820739746, 0.20345675945281982, -0.21282562613487244, -0.19335035979747772, 0.0068727172911167145, 0.39327260851860046, 0.44629839062690735, 0.1835293173789978, -0.19858619570732117, -0.1244889572262764, -0.12373670190572739, -0.5929192900657654, -0.33479854464530945, 1.0491061210632324, -0.7018873691558838, 0.2746559679508209, 0.7622796893119812, 0.8204724192619324, 0.08404546231031418, 0.15210309624671936, 0.5155430436134338, -0.9426795840263367, 0.47646158933639526, 0.18325679004192352, 0.06785333156585693, 0.1794278472661972, -0.4840233623981476, 0.008856981061398983, 0.12738165259361267, -0.7215044498443604, -0.6023637652397156, 0.2103634774684906, -1.081155776977539, -0.43013909459114075, 1.1631062030792236, 0.029165323823690414, -0.3700774013996124, 0.43414291739463806, -0.5166215300559998, 0.32906460762023926, -0.36479488015174866, 0.2400781810283661, 0.24580435454845428, 0.052497148513793945, -0.24087831377983093, -0.4122660458087921, 0.9736279845237732, 0.3409275710582733, -1.0123810768127441, 0.0405416376888752, 0.673529326915741, -0.09356198459863663, 0.16423113644123077, 0.97333824634552, 0.1795649230480194, 0.260482519865036, -0.18182611465454102, 0.22364914417266846, 0.09109566360712051, -0.7030605673789978, -0.18219229578971863, 0.38115036487579346, 0.1872762143611908, 0.25388818979263306 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06925v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06925v2	A Thorough Examination of Decoding Methods in the Era of LLMs	2024-02-10T11:14:53	2024-06-17T14:34:05	Chufan Shi, Haoran Yang, Deng Cai, Zhisong Zhang, Yifan Wang, Yujiu Yang, Wai Lam	cs.CL	cs.CL	Decoding methods play an indispensable role in converting language models from next-token predictors into practical task solvers. Prior research on decoding methods, primarily focusing on task-specific models, may not extend to the current era of general-purpose large language models (LLMs). Moreover, the recent influx of decoding strategies has further complicated this landscape. This paper provides a comprehensive and multifaceted analysis of various decoding methods within the context of LLMs, evaluating their performance, robustness to hyperparameter changes, and decoding speeds across a wide range of tasks, models, and deployment environments. Our findings reveal that decoding method performance is notably task-dependent and influenced by factors such as alignment, model size, and quantization. Intriguingly, sensitivity analysis exposes that certain methods achieve superior performance at the cost of extensive hyperparameter tuning, highlighting the trade-off between attaining optimal results and the practicality of implementation in varying contexts.	[ -0.0903274342417717, -0.6435386538505554, 0.5195707678794861, 0.35409656167030334, -0.3048899173736572, -0.011380785144865513, -0.22576627135276794, -0.4112679660320282, -0.35285115242004395, 0.5984619855880737, -0.4428762197494507, -0.48221680521965027, -0.6306055188179016, 0.347517192363739, -0.47234630584716797, 0.6171532869338989, -0.0009525862988084555, 0.11959624290466309, -0.32134321331977844, 0.17735113203525543, -0.34292617440223694, -0.9891240000724792, -0.37918123602867126, -0.3207603096961975, 0.30232030153274536, 0.1672239750623703, 0.57123202085495, 0.987057089805603, 0.6922212243080139, 0.2414560616016388, -0.3574795126914978, 0.17890655994415283, -0.5445176362991333, 0.1357760727405548, 0.0529148243367672, -0.8954408168792725, -0.4695202112197876, -0.3036259412765503, 0.6758010387420654, 0.6482834219932556, -0.17705591022968292, 0.3548179864883423, 0.26265624165534973, 0.4200417101383209, -1.1093915700912476, 0.2053520381450653, -0.7030386924743652, -0.06090976297855377, -0.5076578259468079, -0.6223750710487366, -0.7413638234138489, 0.04315533488988876, -0.24966491758823395, -0.43797215819358826, 0.3022477328777313, 0.025844689458608627, 0.2936858832836151, 0.23280884325504303, -0.4920056164264679, -0.3881211280822754, -0.8894590735435486, 1.1946640014648438, -0.8618068099021912, 0.46640098094940186, 0.6103827953338623, 0.15833769738674164, -0.16300208866596222, -0.6438090205192566, -0.08440639823675156, -0.035413749516010284, -0.01229109801352024, -0.2244676798582077, -0.26895952224731445, 0.35792866349220276, 0.3686850368976593, 0.43329918384552, -0.25938931107521057, 0.08008177578449249, 0.03285627439618111, -0.37093910574913025, 0.26765674352645874, 0.6211404800415039, 0.1162990853190422, -0.24405437707901, -0.09810487180948257, -0.07442013174295425, -0.7213506102561951, 0.1306723803281784, 0.2616141736507416, 0.32249414920806885, 0.002229119651019573, 0.4835946261882782, -0.2583205997943878, 0.9129390716552734, -0.308663010597229, -0.4991583526134491, -0.17367766797542572, -0.7033436298370361, -0.23961488902568817, -0.28410032391548157, 0.20688898861408234, 0.3070840537548065, 0.0308791846036911, -0.39763468503952026, -0.3839449882507324, 0.027530264109373093, 0.21784386038780212, -0.5806200504302979, -0.009878871962428093, 0.0936153307557106, -0.7195956707000732, -0.1484946757555008, -0.4708912670612335, -0.43173038959503174, -0.20147128403186798, -0.3576626479625702, 0.06273508071899414, -0.37625470757484436, -0.23707959055900574, 0.36705508828163147, -0.09445498138666153, 0.5344973206520081, 0.17365486919879913, -0.9910564422607422, 0.42247724533081055, 0.9864694476127625, 0.8682515025138855, -0.11580987274646759, -0.27252233028411865, -0.635600745677948, 0.20352743566036224, -0.4322569966316223, 0.6648778319358826, -0.4380427598953247, -0.503554105758667, 0.24790261685848236, 0.019041763618588448, -0.20391780138015747, -0.5414225459098816, 0.5731682777404785, -0.8302722573280334, -0.5871753692626953, -0.6734541654586792, -0.5480319261550903, -0.10790035873651505, 0.21419084072113037, -0.7033509612083435, 0.6053597927093506, -0.07753907144069672, -0.8148175477981567, 0.09975447505712509, -0.5056535005569458, -0.5717253088951111, 0.02167658694088459, 0.2208739072084427, 0.013686301186680794, 0.6410265564918518, 0.33809342980384827, 0.6589941382408142, -0.4198317527770996, -0.060898955911397934, -0.06077456474304199, -0.6444295048713684, 0.2731632590293884, -0.6899197101593018, 0.7529049515724182, 0.37292584776878357, -0.10244986414909363, -0.18032731115818024, -0.7633741497993469, 0.054804712533950806, 0.10419587045907974, -0.6159863471984863, -0.18367379903793335, 0.26797500252723694, 0.07155271619558334, -0.25566795468330383, 0.26380473375320435, -0.28030043840408325, -0.1191248893737793, -0.24757754802703857, 0.6401311159133911, 0.5544395446777344, -0.11926144361495972, 0.2731236517429352, -0.06757042557001114, 0.7231985926628113, -0.08500916510820389, 0.05044744908809662, -0.4742504060268402, -0.10040264576673508, -0.6163153648376465, -0.19986040890216827, 0.23003104329109192, 0.4928559958934784, -0.6213386058807373, 0.0679999366402626, -0.2854692041873932, -0.2216978520154953, -0.5311676263809204, 0.1945216953754425, 0.6165143847465515, 0.2405053973197937, 0.3154177665710449, 0.04011586681008339, -0.530566394329071, -0.7598336338996887, -0.5628275871276855, -0.06852127611637115, 0.20326697826385498, 0.013559135608375072, 0.26993563771247864, -0.2030802071094513, 0.6314516067504883, -0.3536936342716217, 0.22159060835838318, -0.4138689339160919, -0.1230337843298912, 0.13961449265480042, 0.3282032907009125, 0.35677582025527954, -0.509684145450592, -0.05426197499036789, 0.11308586597442627, -0.5724100470542908, 0.12740816175937653, 0.01910231076180935, 0.04452980309724808, 0.35571521520614624, 0.8391101956367493, -0.40696343779563904, 0.24350635707378387, 0.8503565788269043, -0.10824261605739594, 0.7867459654808044, -0.3308243751525879, 0.09365791827440262, -0.7700181007385254, 0.21914911270141602, 0.006015053018927574, -0.2159806489944458, -0.7521839141845703, 0.43948453664779663, 0.25178566575050354, 0.1996525526046753, -0.44130513072013855, 0.1541793942451477, -0.8128561973571777, -0.1811409294605255, -0.443164587020874, -0.4119679927825928, -0.025726960971951485, 0.18081267178058624, -0.10252994298934937, 1.0983260869979858, 0.4870288372039795, -0.7343394160270691, 0.36208197474479675, 0.11696167290210724, -0.36261245608329773, 0.40814027190208435, -0.6363515257835388, 0.3630179464817047, -0.25909075140953064, 0.0928821861743927, -0.933597981929779, -0.019138256087899208, 0.020735086873173714, -0.12518446147441864, 0.24816858768463135, -0.4540955126285553, -0.7869614958763123, -0.16105489432811737, -0.21831625699996948, 0.7557224631309509, 0.42199793457984924, -0.43825989961624146, 0.546674370765686, 0.029735993593931198, 0.046507760882377625, -0.6963551640510559, -0.8142236471176147, 0.41074109077453613, -0.33931589126586914, -0.36301830410957336, 0.3456527590751648, -0.10411746799945831, -0.3078652322292328, -0.17356443405151367, -0.19159138202667236, 0.13689778745174408, 0.26099297404289246, 0.041403453797101974, 0.029482917860150337, -0.1863832175731659, -0.35974374413490295, -0.11672845482826233, -0.37203747034072876, 0.19786198437213898, -0.24243201315402985, 0.5111427903175354, -0.15725350379943848, -0.5231508612632751, -0.3567938506603241, 0.4206904470920563, 0.5968779921531677, -0.5373239517211914, 0.7212979197502136, 0.5361098647117615, -0.2940492033958435, -0.1258527934551239, -0.6233768463134766, -0.0051047527231276035, -0.4988214671611786, 0.6876720190048218, -0.7704524397850037, -0.6915581822395325, 0.7133599519729614, -0.1589977890253067, -0.010485793463885784, -0.053729381412267685, 0.5788383483886719, 0.09075102210044861, 1.0695445537567139, 0.9307581186294556, -0.165702223777771, 0.38355693221092224, -0.2602446377277374, 0.31915780901908875, -0.8903133273124695, -0.2786303162574768, -0.7554563283920288, 0.0071624284610152245, -0.3810858428478241, -0.4299595057964325, 0.26606497168540955, 0.2090306133031845, 0.06299931555986404, 0.3200583755970001, -0.158824622631073, 0.577955424785614, 0.4746139645576477, -0.03689846023917198, 0.5190799236297607, 0.17164717614650726, 0.21800823509693146, -0.09281588345766068, -0.7976106405258179, -0.5124343633651733, 1.2350577116012573, 0.5112981200218201, 0.8630328178405762, 0.13655750453472137, 0.49883943796157837, 0.21994373202323914, -0.0313350185751915, -0.8300560712814331, 0.641110897064209, -0.3697865307331085, -0.26099181175231934, -0.1916762739419937, -0.35246050357818604, -1.0748957395553589, 0.3927174210548401, 0.011552632786333561, -0.5311579704284668, 0.10986297577619553, 0.17025615274906158, -0.1765352338552475, 0.28324925899505615, -0.5411579608917236, 0.5586921572685242, -0.06583594530820847, -0.0905437171459198, -0.26787135004997253, -0.5309305787086487, 0.17219863831996918, 0.07378532737493515, 0.2058255970478058, -0.0556742399930954, -0.26622095704078674, 0.5742559432983398, 0.04979415610432625, 0.7765120267868042, -0.04561937227845192, -0.47723233699798584, -0.047678928822278976, 0.26612043380737305, 0.5529316067695618, -0.15707474946975708, -0.36827704310417175, 0.22335433959960938, 0.46930214762687683, -0.7147018313407898, -0.509976327419281, 0.6775813698768616, -0.5799158215522766, -0.6421167254447937, 0.0045433249324560165, -0.8616549372673035, -0.36881381273269653, 0.07512233406305313, 0.41960394382476807, 0.7979657649993896, -0.10128416866064072, 0.10992934554815292, 0.9105162024497986, 0.0651002898812294, 0.5351912379264832, 0.2980913519859314, 0.2379392832517624, -0.15139998495578766, 0.8310815095901489, -0.08366429805755615, 0.3357466161251068, 0.6731358170509338, -0.20340676605701447, -0.47044193744659424, -1.1595627069473267, -0.1252216100692749, 0.22843924164772034, -1.0715798139572144, -0.32086068391799927, -0.34410011768341064, 0.07330185174942017, -0.36284124851226807, -0.07143527269363403, -0.3326817452907562, 0.12923316657543182, -0.47279512882232666, -0.11214188486337662, 0.04338347911834717, 0.6276781558990479, 0.12990102171897888, 0.30694764852523804, -0.8763675689697266, 0.2543102502822876, 0.007210092153400183, 0.2847657799720764, 0.08302896469831467, -0.2698419690132141, -0.4867140054702759, -0.08193565905094147, 0.14084365963935852, -0.9363591074943542, 0.2191540002822876, -0.04923988878726959, 0.7386457324028015, 0.21514618396759033, -0.05945649743080139, 0.6249464750289917, -0.3340049386024475, 0.6268956065177917, -0.2090335339307785, -1.1137346029281616, 0.32503247261047363, -0.25780606269836426, 0.36409613490104675, 0.26029109954833984, 0.17283378541469574, -0.5267432332038879, -0.05229491367936134, -0.04935622215270996, -0.874753475189209, 0.7985784411430359, 0.013649611733853817, 0.4907580316066742, 0.0021259000059217215, 0.5375267267227173, 0.1101127490401268, 0.06851578503847122, -0.44250115752220154, -0.3230383098125458, 0.10814089328050613, -0.1018204540014267, -0.37749621272087097, -0.6599199175834656, -0.19611938297748566, -0.06314219534397125, 0.22353395819664001, -0.22782430052757263, 0.33413130044937134, -0.0712626725435257, -0.4138512909412384, 0.11338300257921219, 0.4043712317943573, 0.5740295648574829, 0.6443183422088623, -0.112470343708992, 0.25935548543930054, 0.24701206386089325, -0.23106059432029724, 0.2452879697084427, -0.12533825635910034, 0.11426117271184921, -0.047596871852874756, 0.7479261159896851, 0.8925219178199768, 0.2049349695444107, -0.5941277146339417, 0.4003750681877136, 0.04443495348095894, -0.09941686689853668, 0.08170846104621887, 0.09354687482118607, 0.07628253847360611, 0.2932755947113037, 0.4190928637981415, -0.014124084264039993, 0.3828577697277069, -0.46791890263557434, -0.28483134508132935, 0.5323841571807861, 0.12406915426254272, -0.5050895810127258, 0.42268502712249756, 0.11199693381786346, -0.1490975171327591, 0.5041563510894775, -0.04127249866724014, -0.19607795774936676, 0.601478099822998, 0.9410055875778198, 0.8076686859130859, -0.10399425029754639, -0.0771327018737793, -0.00100696028675884, 0.38843804597854614, -0.3046821653842926, 0.2045806348323822, -0.3128531873226166, -0.46233752369880676, -0.8543440699577332, -0.5423932075500488, -0.14287136495113373, 0.09410479664802551, -0.9347013235092163, -0.20683269202709198, -0.18893128633499146, -0.37934550642967224, -0.30126824975013733, -0.12266913801431656, -0.8002006411552429, -0.01250186562538147, 0.21754394471645355, 1.218747615814209, -0.6133901476860046, 0.5303305983543396, 0.9152488708496094, 0.2483227550983429, -0.5703057050704956, 0.2780648469924927, -0.03238783776760101, -0.8474054932594299, 0.5027468800544739, -0.10486137121915817, -0.5567636489868164, 0.2717136740684509, -0.2857762277126312, -1.00963294506073, 0.9947917461395264, 0.6919828653335571, -0.4450151324272156, -0.33791470527648926, 0.3608757257461548, 0.5155383348464966, -0.0750780925154686, 0.1709081381559372, 1.0063374042510986, 0.28643742203712463, -0.3182249963283539, -1.007439374923706, 0.20816873013973236, -0.06887052953243256, 0.7284985780715942, 0.026671152561903, -0.3834109902381897, 0.530927300453186, -0.20292752981185913, -0.373065710067749, 0.377106636762619, 0.4734035134315491, 0.09391481429338455, 0.1876889020204544, 0.1589333564043045, 0.2149672508239746, 0.440339058637619, 0.04095461219549179, 1.2718292474746704, -0.5332431197166443, 0.27611875534057617, 0.2805343270301819, 0.08015339076519012, 0.9698668718338013, 0.569218635559082, -0.3708478808403015, 0.0841880738735199, 0.36318275332450867, 0.22548817098140717, 0.6460260152816772, 0.2834925949573517, -0.19963595271110535, -0.4956022799015045, 0.022214410826563835, -0.36521267890930176, 0.47093093395233154, 0.4050077199935913, -0.11277221143245697, -0.4143652319908142, 0.17654229700565338, -0.09212423861026764, 0.09387097507715225, -0.4592438340187073, 0.6358279585838318, -0.03526103496551514, -0.5340417623519897, 0.8759399056434631, 0.4452061951160431, 0.9375379681587219, -0.5988359451293945, 0.13573773205280304, -0.15758542716503143, 0.2913888990879059, -0.12201037257909775, -0.5762211084365845, 0.21485646069049835, -0.20665374398231506, -0.25610044598579407, -0.20868805050849915, 0.7237110137939453, -0.049174029380083084, -0.2789290249347687, 0.3198309540748596, 0.5834259390830994, -0.08864016830921173, -0.06509333103895187, -0.5279071927070618, 0.8030267357826233, -0.03503177687525749, -0.20699681341648102, 0.337321013212204, 0.18267935514450073, 0.07594785839319229, 0.8568023443222046, 0.6057828068733215, 0.035019680857658386, 0.11387347429990768, -0.08988237380981445, 0.6681511402130127, -0.8100827932357788, -0.3265226483345032, -0.890236496925354, 0.36711132526397705, 0.6304506659507751, -0.025592174381017685, 0.9135656952857971, 0.35187774896621704, 0.8136712908744812, -0.23805981874465942, 0.6420953869819641, 0.41436731815338135, 0.1717335283756256, -0.9086228013038635, 0.23844091594219208, -0.4098992943763733, 0.4590805768966675, -0.021118488162755966, -0.7885047793388367, -0.24272413551807404, 0.11662598699331284, -0.22173425555229187, 0.12481245398521423, 0.46398964524269104, 0.7920204997062683, 0.10027118772268295, -0.0794183760881424, 0.3835142254829407, -0.180618017911911, 0.3263136148452759, 0.5676179528236389, 0.9298024773597717, -0.2976715862751007, 0.5935050249099731, -0.1570923924446106, -0.0683935210108757, -0.4441147446632385, -0.8256597518920898, -0.7161126136779785, -0.5684410333633423, -0.17321208119392395, -0.23989343643188477, 0.38447052240371704, 0.4201333224773407, 0.9282174706459045, -0.5893475413322449, -0.34953445196151733, -0.03654682636260986, -0.04799093306064606, -0.4656426012516022, -0.1650436818599701, 0.16016577184200287, -0.6694743037223816, -0.8916977643966675, 0.4646599590778351, 0.1420111209154129, -0.14602884650230408, -0.21958185732364655, -0.18536920845508575, 0.4432559907436371, 0.07352861016988754, 0.7572687268257141, 0.20996831357479095, -0.8305141925811768, 0.3053182065486908, 0.3248470723628998, -0.16797886788845062, -0.03344115987420082, 1.2749145030975342, -0.5908841490745544, 0.09695641696453094, 0.4919809401035309, 0.8152596354484558, 0.35438406467437744, 0.09513793885707855, 0.5330522656440735, -0.609673798084259, 0.046009793877601624, 0.16920775175094604, 0.2713086009025574, 0.2706278860569, -0.4844028949737549, 0.07865071296691895, 0.07196538895368576, -0.40698254108428955, -1.1281200647354126, 0.35327503085136414, -0.7171357274055481, -0.3640271723270416, 1.1986652612686157, -0.14019730687141418, -0.1610863357782364, -0.23823955655097961, -0.07066021859645844, 0.006290106568485498, -0.036137212067842484, 0.39461463689804077, 0.7218028903007507, -0.13425645232200623, -0.32571905851364136, -0.44781407713890076, 0.5297890901565552, 0.5971517562866211, -0.5901140570640564, 0.4505653977394104, 0.5284064412117004, 0.39971432089805603, -0.07602550089359283, 0.5396592617034912, -0.17860276997089386, 0.2330368161201477, 0.10120020061731339, -0.29178285598754883, -0.2764788269996643, -0.3262348473072052, -0.6485826969146729, 0.2899218499660492, 0.6030183434486389, -0.13241668045520782 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06918v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06918v2	Generating Chain-of-Thoughts with a Pairwise-Comparison Approach to Searching for the Most Promising Intermediate Thought	2024-02-10T09:51:03	2024-06-26T05:47:52	Zhen-Yu Zhang, Siwei Han, Huaxiu Yao, Gang Niu, Masashi Sugiyama	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	To improve the ability of the large language model (LLMs) to tackle complex reasoning problems, chain-of-thoughts (CoT) methods were proposed to guide LLMs to reason step-by-step, enabling problem solving from simple to complex. State-of-the-art methods for generating such a chain involve interactive collaboration, where the learner generates candidate intermediate thoughts, evaluated by the LLM, guiding the generation of subsequent thoughts. However, a widespread yet understudied problem is that the evaluation from the LLM is typically noisy and unreliable, potentially misleading the generation process in selecting promising intermediate thoughts. In this paper, motivated by Vapnik's principle, we use pairwise-comparison evaluation instead of point-wise scoring to search for promising intermediate thoughts with the noisy feedback from the LLM. In each round, we randomly pair intermediate thoughts and directly prompt the LLM to select the more promising one from each pair, allowing us to identify the most promising thoughts through an iterative process. To further alleviate the noise in the comparison, we incorporate techniques from ensemble learning and dueling bandits, proposing two variants of the algorithm. Experiments on three real-world tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed algorithm and verify the rationale of the pairwise comparison mechanism.	[ -0.6377854943275452, -0.7576645016670227, 0.8821026086807251, 0.05244319140911102, -0.49693700671195984, 0.5196908116340637, -0.524974524974823, -0.3580490052700043, 0.2730925679206848, 0.4910597503185272, -0.4485052824020386, -0.355459988117218, -0.49160778522491455, 0.12466676533222198, -0.399852454662323, 0.9443711042404175, -0.16312065720558167, -0.1172480583190918, -0.14397011697292328, 0.1549472063779831, -0.3384358286857605, -0.4113166034221649, -0.9625117182731628, -0.3564490079879761, 0.5625078678131104, 0.2377254217863083, 0.44516342878341675, 0.01025910023599863, 0.5860512852668762, 0.28958648443222046, -0.25004664063453674, 0.5558943152427673, -0.6971633434295654, 0.31075435876846313, -0.2796194553375244, -0.6268203854560852, -0.10608582198619843, -0.06258085370063782, 0.35097819566726685, 0.5141634941101074, -0.20283809304237366, 0.017035802826285362, 0.03733552247285843, 0.9460266828536987, -0.7340702414512634, 0.05694815516471863, -1.011884093284607, -0.04638831689953804, -0.18323840200901031, -0.2834593653678894, -0.4310852885246277, -0.1963036209344864, 0.15089215338230133, -0.2915958762168884, -0.1297568678855896, 0.33965247869491577, 0.5952920317649841, -0.00017358059994876385, -0.09640251100063324, -0.37415337562561035, -0.8190805315971375, 0.7857701778411865, -0.5737890601158142, 0.14245428144931793, 0.22267045080661774, 0.2348649948835373, -0.4662582576274872, -0.3692963421344757, -0.8634498119354248, -0.08705991506576538, 0.2383185625076294, 0.3405420482158661, -0.22993016242980957, 0.09893650561571121, 0.006427977699786425, 0.27299830317497253, -0.2833460867404938, -0.08774429559707642, -0.44236570596694946, 0.07293681055307388, 0.6945234537124634, 0.11221598833799362, -0.03946371376514435, 0.020783063024282455, -0.43822306394577026, -0.1136925145983696, -0.6743263602256775, 0.06611926853656769, 0.5521381497383118, 0.18070755898952484, 0.033011544495821, 0.2863357365131378, -0.35275590419769287, 0.7161699533462524, 0.39722150564193726, -0.005533237010240555, 0.17413043975830078, -0.39439600706100464, 0.009762339293956757, 0.04058387503027916, 0.8412285447120667, 0.30666154623031616, 0.14185748994350433, -0.34078356623649597, -0.5127810835838318, 0.24709327518939972, 0.4086228013038635, -0.2737215459346771, -0.4338446855545044, 0.3318909704685211, -0.30416688323020935, -0.6785826683044434, 0.009251869283616543, -0.6513491868972778, 0.007427622098475695, -0.4372784495353699, 0.538398802280426, -0.21528615057468414, -0.3804667294025421, -0.0001497531629865989, -0.11757785081863403, 0.06785168498754501, 0.2020839899778366, -0.6580258011817932, 0.5541255474090576, 0.7852131724357605, 0.7484263181686401, -0.34729617834091187, -0.25217220187187195, -0.5737302303314209, 0.12921664118766785, -0.6350446939468384, 1.0497417449951172, -0.5038225054740906, -0.17341667413711548, -0.19501860439777374, -0.5725072026252747, 0.1869748830795288, -0.5929641723632812, 0.3333970010280609, -0.45067185163497925, 0.0887082889676094, -0.30016854405403137, -0.38138651847839355, 0.13659320771694183, 0.37158140540122986, -0.5352421998977661, 0.9024140238761902, -0.1750110685825348, -0.9462161660194397, 0.3255903422832489, -0.2081499546766281, -0.20188795030117035, 0.06640166789293289, -0.7271226644515991, -0.48200076818466187, 0.17356975376605988, 0.010171833448112011, 0.3088761568069458, -0.601438581943512, 0.2681501805782318, -0.41374608874320984, -0.3853667676448822, 0.40921273827552795, -0.3560658097267151, 0.5309649109840393, 0.13463835418224335, -0.5092197060585022, 0.23954808712005615, -0.5171146392822266, 0.10929762572050095, 0.17556117475032806, -0.04145529866218567, -0.3505608141422272, 0.06647335737943649, -0.4761754274368286, 0.32560136914253235, 0.10441389679908752, -0.13646505773067474, 0.16671530902385712, -0.47379159927368164, 0.2513359487056732, 1.0446057319641113, 0.279818594455719, 0.2939787209033966, -0.5874043107032776, 0.3375905156135559, 0.1342070996761322, 0.15018221735954285, 0.15248283743858337, -0.3368368446826935, -1.0307892560958862, 0.1308107227087021, 0.19737748801708221, 0.1955370157957077, -1.0157430171966553, 0.4054543972015381, 0.08122662454843521, -0.4621160626411438, -0.5220189094543457, 0.4272274672985077, 0.7007797956466675, 0.35270005464553833, 0.20993578433990479, -0.4389975070953369, -0.645271897315979, -0.6229051351547241, -0.2641505002975464, -0.3677006661891937, 0.35674750804901123, 0.00182649667840451, 0.3704913556575775, 0.08678416907787323, 0.6031036972999573, -0.4344313442707062, 0.15408022701740265, -0.2888941764831543, 0.25189200043678284, 0.27124473452568054, 0.25233346223831177, -0.0061548445373773575, -0.7267212867736816, -0.41967007517814636, -0.03478270024061203, -0.4980129897594452, 0.07522834092378616, -0.10061683505773544, -0.578370988368988, 0.12258853763341904, 0.3805072605609894, -0.4098758101463318, 0.23147501051425934, 0.3467567265033722, 0.06421217322349548, 0.7245802283287048, -0.14697064459323883, 0.017369341105222702, -1.0920429229736328, -0.053104743361473083, -0.10209126770496368, -0.05223279818892479, -0.27088138461112976, 0.008154229260981083, -0.44350045919418335, 0.30651769042015076, -0.08747619390487671, 0.1440921425819397, -0.5644282698631287, 0.04904192313551903, -0.4165373146533966, 0.5622067451477051, -0.2588709890842438, 0.6410098075866699, 0.0036719930358231068, 0.5613119006156921, 0.5242397785186768, -0.5126218795776367, 0.44867420196533203, -0.02496594376862049, -0.4364718496799469, 0.42162957787513733, -0.269366979598999, 0.5298663973808289, -0.06653094291687012, 0.28637364506721497, -0.9478912949562073, 0.05721917003393173, 0.1582351177930832, -0.29019322991371155, 0.15112730860710144, 0.11394112557172775, -0.45826053619384766, -0.5294722318649292, -0.48406466841697693, 0.45143938064575195, 0.6494477987289429, -0.5163033604621887, 0.09312823414802551, 0.4886518716812134, -0.27309271693229675, -0.5758496522903442, -0.3123364746570587, 0.03488050028681755, -0.2575117349624634, -0.32383060455322266, 0.3598126769065857, -0.02082635648548603, -0.635314404964447, -0.11773495376110077, -0.3904447853565216, 0.30624496936798096, -0.11127302050590515, -0.13695524632930756, 0.3994055688381195, 0.19892528653144836, 0.1354212909936905, 0.11672411859035492, -0.30315423011779785, 0.2687947154045105, -0.5075930953025818, 0.6073899865150452, -0.318386971950531, -0.09831461310386658, 0.131547749042511, 0.2617822587490082, 0.36199355125427246, -0.012663520872592926, 0.28276488184928894, 0.40641751885414124, -0.18557573854923248, -0.7207306623458862, -0.7092024087905884, -0.226408913731575, -0.4508262276649475, 0.09799113124608994, -0.4355614185333252, -0.6351823210716248, 0.2797008454799652, -0.5203935503959656, -0.005831575952470303, 0.2135009765625, 0.6291565895080566, -0.34913161396980286, 0.8078638315200806, 0.4183299243450165, 0.040154751390218735, 0.2929922342300415, -0.4535653293132782, 0.5494310855865479, -1.0628883838653564, -0.24708975851535797, -0.28008055686950684, -0.2952481210231781, -0.6215798854827881, -0.39875173568725586, 0.6557161211967468, 0.4333656430244446, -0.05063130706548691, 0.2681964337825775, -0.6430068612098694, 0.6255688071250916, 0.6114580035209656, 0.3672633469104767, 0.3525550961494446, -0.008913641795516014, -0.5347511172294617, 0.2871936857700348, -0.8570404648780823, -0.46479320526123047, 1.1993943452835083, -0.29355037212371826, 0.5502941608428955, 0.10259170830249786, 1.0927578210830688, 0.10125810652971268, 0.03628196194767952, -0.6081846356391907, 0.772872269153595, 0.02839731238782406, -0.23714566230773926, -0.30812594294548035, -0.5033906102180481, -0.9890732765197754, 0.2541390657424927, -0.44012773036956787, -0.8450619578361511, -0.13239352405071259, 0.05031409114599228, -0.421274870634079, 0.4335826635360718, -0.16434688866138458, 0.2384982705116272, -0.27035415172576904, -0.7018741369247437, -0.5861242413520813, -0.767435610294342, 0.5071680545806885, -0.22121644020080566, 0.194953054189682, 0.16927361488342285, 0.1627475917339325, 0.9371072053909302, -0.576448917388916, 0.5734502077102661, 0.32109248638153076, -0.126753568649292, 0.7828499674797058, 0.12300752103328705, 0.7550515532493591, -0.17946083843708038, 0.04737767204642296, -0.1154305562376976, -0.39716070890426636, -0.2862509787082672, -0.5916851162910461, 0.8442526459693909, -0.7550334334373474, -0.8451821804046631, -0.30643996596336365, -0.3156065046787262, -0.3314085602760315, 0.07444027811288834, 0.3618737757205963, 0.3210758566856384, -0.001059258938767016, -0.10357118397951126, 0.6221634149551392, 0.24874576926231384, 0.5274624824523926, -0.11328661441802979, -0.4488740861415863, -0.7086308598518372, 0.955833375453949, 0.041280537843704224, 0.5184932947158813, 0.4014289379119873, 0.2840037941932678, -0.20975477993488312, -0.5489519238471985, -0.17840515077114105, 0.09658006578683853, -0.6617953181266785, -0.22540511190891266, -0.4405497610569, -0.0928918868303299, 0.11042863875627518, -0.28331032395362854, -0.31190064549446106, -0.2957875728607178, 0.3813239336013794, 0.030441559851169586, 0.2889978885650635, 0.7656824588775635, -0.0735335573554039, -0.06319636851549149, -0.28408533334732056, 0.22242869436740875, 0.573703944683075, 0.1316804736852646, 0.2803421914577484, -0.12721577286720276, -0.18257392942905426, 0.0161775890737772, -0.6747839450836182, -0.6057273745536804, 0.10643547028303146, -0.4467593729496002, 0.5249517560005188, 0.21978843212127686, 0.12209852039813995, 0.6825135350227356, -0.10076379776000977, 0.5321257710456848, 0.6643492579460144, -0.9908264875411987, 0.666894257068634, -0.2897627651691437, 0.07618051767349243, 0.6694937348365784, 0.19121426343917847, -0.09318859130144119, -0.6557431221008301, -0.9470897912979126, -0.9462170600891113, 0.33919447660446167, 0.5955849885940552, -0.4559492766857147, -0.032588809728622437, 0.1609346717596054, 0.2403292953968048, 0.4628242552280426, -0.6097237467765808, -0.05875494331121445, 0.5275381207466125, -0.016988476738333702, 0.10641670972108841, 0.14313137531280518, -0.14781655371189117, -0.04256811365485191, 0.7637695074081421, -0.07615751028060913, 0.3331137001514435, 0.2476142793893814, 0.17286528646945953, -0.4930330216884613, 0.2554599642753601, 0.19120071828365326, 0.646185040473938, -0.04300741106271744, 0.4482700228691101, 0.3313310444355011, 0.025568723678588867, 0.10718128085136414, -0.4678099751472473, -0.24989691376686096, -0.02348872274160385, 0.29410502314567566, 0.8402016758918762, 0.18971164524555206, -0.6217524409294128, 0.5634058713912964, 0.063193179666996, -0.23953019082546234, -0.41402411460876465, 0.294614315032959, 0.20490716397762299, 0.4410926103591919, 0.18341010808944702, 0.5140858888626099, 0.22790749371051788, -0.8138124346733093, 0.04925126954913139, 0.40999719500541687, -0.25289666652679443, -0.2539551258087158, 0.335703045129776, 0.2949832081794739, -0.5006095767021179, 0.5818955898284912, -0.40374821424484253, -0.6886377334594727, 0.5693237781524658, 0.5022428631782532, 1.0842924118041992, 0.1332867294549942, 0.13845103979110718, 0.2302059829235077, 0.11783719062805176, -0.34382471442222595, 0.5613513588905334, -0.483126699924469, -0.6717337369918823, -0.6288990378379822, -0.359687864780426, -0.5181328058242798, 0.059551067650318146, -0.719294548034668, 0.5184361338615417, -0.4118839204311371, -0.1917853057384491, -0.1957501322031021, 0.11991617828607559, -0.5477331280708313, 0.0414789579808712, 0.32650792598724365, 0.3973827660083771, -0.5885095596313477, 0.7898464798927307, 0.40115484595298767, -0.4106920063495636, -0.8643439412117004, 0.39479881525039673, -0.09593360871076584, -0.6587161421775818, 0.4098496735095978, 0.03871934860944748, -0.6559507250785828, -0.19452588260173798, -0.6343988180160522, -0.6886761784553528, 1.0147110223770142, 0.037359364330768585, -1.1266642808914185, -0.09105975180864334, -0.3344663679599762, 0.4138871431350708, -0.4200579822063446, 0.31487321853637695, 0.37543198466300964, 0.24903777241706848, 0.3065941333770752, -1.0030083656311035, 0.07558731734752655, -0.4032614529132843, -0.042505815625190735, 0.6640116572380066, -1.125486135482788, 0.849469780921936, -0.6140730977058411, 0.0059789372608065605, 0.005247876513749361, 0.45244067907333374, 0.7545585632324219, 0.4811771810054779, 0.7208370566368103, 0.4502565562725067, 0.8937520980834961, 0.11203980445861816, 0.7308841943740845, -0.38913536071777344, 0.3802132308483124, 1.2629495859146118, -0.39159560203552246, 1.0585882663726807, 0.751624345779419, -0.37023308873176575, 0.7344470024108887, 0.3801117539405823, 0.17024201154708862, 0.6796737313270569, 0.7465367317199707, -0.3431638777256012, -0.5259390473365784, 0.2071520835161209, -0.21161586046218872, 0.26074424386024475, 0.3619755208492279, -0.12924592196941376, 0.09468870609998703, -0.26841044425964355, -0.06849000602960587, 0.1898895502090454, -0.32067397236824036, 0.988375186920166, 0.35855260491371155, -0.9069612622261047, 0.6635275483131409, -0.40206101536750793, 0.6411114931106567, -0.33992236852645874, -0.2008531242609024, 0.05608781799674034, 0.13992324471473694, 0.015021704137325287, -0.6732605695724487, 0.025540800765156746, -0.03786550462245941, 0.039332807064056396, -0.07344907522201538, 0.6908762454986572, -0.4760315418243408, -0.48147985339164734, 0.4187166690826416, 0.6310804486274719, 0.21270497143268585, 0.16453023254871368, -0.668979823589325, 0.23750324547290802, 0.01003588829189539, -0.012960582971572876, 0.2265491634607315, 0.5172208547592163, -0.030068041756749153, 0.6277735233306885, 0.6657814979553223, 0.3539956510066986, -0.2959250211715698, -0.07241382449865341, 1.0822311639785767, -0.6200331449508667, -0.6434432864189148, -0.9300506711006165, 0.19376303255558014, -0.3410279452800751, -0.4199574291706085, 0.3855041265487671, 0.43763965368270874, 1.1778966188430786, 0.29855790734291077, 0.9589627385139465, 0.11182243376970291, 0.2123715728521347, -0.766137957572937, 0.37771522998809814, -0.20237404108047485, 0.5654327273368835, -0.5994809865951538, -0.9609935283660889, 0.002455707872286439, 0.6966280341148376, -0.4679229259490967, -0.06684766709804535, 1.17279851436615, 0.6188387870788574, 0.20280471444129944, 0.2524891793727875, 0.2847515344619751, 0.3726690411567688, 0.054376762360334396, 0.891639232635498, 0.9630942344665527, -0.43038371205329895, 0.6160215735435486, -0.38308024406433105, -0.29411643743515015, -0.06335274130105972, -0.6053245067596436, -1.0748417377471924, -0.7191504836082458, -0.22939449548721313, -0.6203491687774658, 0.36393532156944275, 1.2241137027740479, 0.5291547775268555, -0.4848025143146515, -0.5324317812919617, -0.7273519039154053, 0.19462604820728302, -0.46232160925865173, -0.1404532492160797, 0.2596554160118103, -0.4869117736816406, -0.5760107040405273, 0.2526923418045044, 0.4458911418914795, -0.2203267514705658, -0.40077972412109375, -0.25049033761024475, -0.1963605284690857, 0.268555611371994, 0.490986168384552, -0.18109479546546936, -0.869300365447998, -0.05630136653780937, -0.2718212902545929, 0.09288936853408813, -0.004599702078849077, 0.8366593718528748, -0.8827598094940186, 0.8036481142044067, 0.4182179272174835, 0.2948940098285675, 0.7342064380645752, -0.24732184410095215, 0.609218418598175, -0.15624584257602692, 0.0338003970682621, 0.3547155261039734, 0.3315350413322449, -0.0314585380256176, -0.28461742401123047, 0.5209998488426208, 0.2119002789258957, -0.4963515102863312, -0.7294768691062927, 0.3083323836326599, -1.0754263401031494, -0.2995947599411011, 1.1358184814453125, -0.044933758676052094, -0.4789777398109436, -0.1194324940443039, -0.3649326264858246, 0.25939133763313293, -0.49641478061676025, 1.1583281755447388, 0.7309533357620239, -0.27718067169189453, 0.16296795010566711, 0.03309861198067665, 0.36731478571891785, 0.5804473161697388, -0.713245689868927, -0.09550086408853531, 0.011132430285215378, -0.12297484278678894, 0.19595405459403992, 0.636647641658783, 0.07192657887935638, 0.1485176831483841, 0.30545851588249207, -0.13369259238243103, 0.32928115129470825, -0.4556632339954376, 0.03258918970823288, 0.1695658415555954, 0.1805393397808075, -0.046556256711483 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06913v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06913v1	TL;DR Progress: Multi-faceted Literature Exploration in Text Summarization	2024-02-10T09:16:56	2024-02-10T09:16:56	Shahbaz Syed, Khalid Al-Khatib, Martin Potthast	cs.CL	cs.CL	This paper presents TL;DR Progress, a new tool for exploring the literature on neural text summarization. It organizes 514~papers based on a comprehensive annotation scheme for text summarization approaches and enables fine-grained, faceted search. Each paper was manually annotated to capture aspects such as evaluation metrics, quality dimensions, learning paradigms, challenges addressed, datasets, and document domains. In addition, a succinct indicative summary is provided for each paper, consisting of automatically extracted contextual factors, issues, and proposed solutions. The tool is available online at https://www.tldr-progress.de, a demo video at https://youtu.be/uCVRGFvXUj8	[ 0.024993065744638443, -0.622266948223114, 0.6202657222747803, 0.3586057126522064, -0.16818517446517944, 0.49332544207572937, -0.2605939209461212, -0.022381605580449104, 0.46438297629356384, 0.4122387170791626, -0.4295841455459595, -0.8902591466903687, -0.7083445191383362, 0.08767101913690567, -0.45264482498168945, 1.3026480674743652, -0.013156618922948837, 0.09596963226795197, -0.09447457641363144, -0.12170052528381348, -0.6780170798301697, -0.12621992826461792, -0.8276103734970093, -0.5493063926696777, 0.840337872505188, 0.18801283836364746, 0.2345128059387207, 0.22682394087314606, 0.49839910864830017, 0.25934070348739624, -0.5002566576004028, 0.14219118654727936, -0.1528421938419342, 0.6099987030029297, -0.18789590895175934, -0.20437242090702057, -0.9904268383979797, -0.28955933451652527, 0.7177843451499939, 0.8286337852478027, 0.12608756124973297, 0.14910811185836792, 0.21945889294147491, 1.1273424625396729, -0.36489057540893555, -0.001999916974455118, 0.13571980595588684, 0.3703092038631439, -0.29992541670799255, -0.2655767500400543, -0.20548976957798004, -0.5972506403923035, 0.4560789465904236, -0.5653916001319885, 0.21266154944896698, -0.254199743270874, 0.37168729305267334, 0.28450807929039, -0.5372698903083801, -0.3735079765319824, -0.43909963965415955, 0.7549910545349121, -0.7446108460426331, 0.04586319997906685, 0.016240162774920464, 0.48206645250320435, 0.3355429470539093, -1.1738206148147583, -0.22343279421329498, 0.11434455215930939, -0.14558982849121094, 0.29438015818595886, 0.03225930407643318, 0.07334423810243607, 0.10866725444793701, 0.45543670654296875, -0.6173602342605591, -0.168169304728508, -0.47287213802337646, -0.3001508116722107, 0.7133667469024658, 0.33514824509620667, 0.38580000400543213, -0.03202343359589577, 0.04590944945812225, -0.03678913787007332, -0.24541428685188293, 0.011218295432627201, -0.10670962184667587, 0.04424772784113884, -0.2632223069667816, 0.6459402441978455, -0.1684124916791916, 0.7058128118515015, -0.28775501251220703, -0.3017466068267822, 0.5012967586517334, -0.8328857421875, -0.15602479875087738, 0.0918060690164566, 0.864918053150177, 0.5524142384529114, 0.08924306929111481, -0.3066345751285553, -0.2614283859729767, -0.7310203909873962, 0.3120395243167877, -0.9692208766937256, -0.3801230490207672, 0.396434485912323, -1.0520716905593872, -0.7102161049842834, -0.11891438066959381, -1.2717798948287964, -0.6603052616119385, -0.3165198862552643, 0.26217120885849, -0.24483446776866913, -0.4936298429965973, -0.15495842695236206, -0.6341338753700256, -0.07103820145130157, 0.7534754276275635, -0.6316079497337341, -0.05440618097782135, 0.5615834593772888, 1.4088398218154907, -0.19780109822750092, -0.1669904887676239, -0.3866785764694214, -0.0338367335498333, -0.2968328595161438, 0.7640895843505859, -0.3895607888698578, -0.263185977935791, 0.24732688069343567, -0.12105751782655716, -0.2067682147026062, -0.2500578761100769, 0.6823366284370422, -0.4607945680618286, 0.47501540184020996, -0.46992629766464233, -0.4138752222061157, -0.47795233130455017, 0.6078250408172607, -0.8034168481826782, 0.7323731184005737, 0.0970979556441307, -0.9073067307472229, 0.2095406949520111, -1.1768800020217896, -0.6691463589668274, -0.21349355578422546, -0.14362595975399017, -0.3917558789253235, 0.3121753931045532, 0.30725613236427307, 0.42359912395477295, -0.02146759256720543, 0.3976748287677765, 0.07002665847539902, -0.07243111729621887, 0.12676061689853668, -0.024273181334137917, 1.1649208068847656, 0.23071928322315216, -0.29519879817962646, 0.6921185851097107, -0.6386066675186157, -0.14181680977344513, -0.1560988873243332, -0.36580121517181396, -0.23699046671390533, 0.2439139038324356, 0.40746212005615234, 0.18381208181381226, 0.5955081582069397, -0.4778714179992676, 0.4029165506362915, -0.22099833190441132, 0.4963749945163727, 0.40581974387168884, 0.21859867870807648, 0.4019017219543457, -0.599209189414978, 0.6368159055709839, 0.0075289406813681126, -0.07922738045454025, -0.8062899112701416, -0.4382220506668091, -0.6586531400680542, 0.040786560624837875, 0.5146317481994629, 0.5611407160758972, -0.7745259404182434, 0.25658026337623596, -0.2153206765651703, -0.35473161935806274, -0.3506108224391937, -0.09369868040084839, 0.30719897150993347, 0.5123811960220337, 0.5551273822784424, -0.18513177335262299, -0.46412813663482666, -0.6442168354988098, -0.26019641757011414, 0.13147249817848206, -0.247659832239151, 0.1565268635749817, 0.44262516498565674, 0.027789566665887833, 0.8540302515029907, -0.4496149718761444, -0.7952339053153992, -0.48940035700798035, 0.4983420670032501, 0.08631490170955658, 0.40967196226119995, 0.7028718590736389, -0.7999619245529175, -0.5476357340812683, -0.03332996368408203, -1.215628743171692, -0.21669839322566986, -0.1765303611755371, 0.18588648736476898, 0.1548147052526474, 0.8731383681297302, -0.2831558585166931, 0.4103268086910248, 0.35414302349090576, -0.5416631102561951, 0.3935244381427765, -0.28375059366226196, 0.1036914512515068, -1.3410212993621826, 0.4047756791114807, -0.04208719730377197, -0.19585736095905304, -0.6054710149765015, 0.08810248225927353, 0.1229468286037445, -0.0951947271823883, 0.005389945115894079, 0.2928003966808319, -0.41511526703834534, 0.022798899561166763, -0.3961288332939148, 0.5937689542770386, 0.14873430132865906, 0.0946570411324501, -0.1592218577861786, 0.8845154643058777, 0.46954432129859924, -0.5388126373291016, 0.08043012768030167, 0.12676432728767395, 0.11915148794651031, 0.4762835204601288, -0.8621165156364441, -0.1989554911851883, -0.20126818120479584, 0.2980836033821106, -0.9272564649581909, -0.11867579817771912, 0.04671477898955345, -0.639556348323822, 0.30869847536087036, 0.32561784982681274, -0.4447856545448303, 0.13757449388504028, -0.8159711956977844, 0.5424649119377136, 0.3231998682022095, -0.13110202550888062, 0.9040460586547852, 0.497761070728302, -0.3459022045135498, -0.6205973625183105, -0.7848700284957886, 0.5941747426986694, 0.04689858853816986, -0.518554151058197, 0.5991069674491882, -0.23134778439998627, -0.40439534187316895, -0.1425127536058426, 0.07331610471010208, -0.016334371641278267, 0.13661763072013855, -0.19227692484855652, -0.029507482424378395, -0.29972779750823975, 0.2105492353439331, 0.3693879246711731, 0.08103948086500168, 0.24347661435604095, -0.22636546194553375, 0.421109139919281, 0.01722262054681778, 0.22478429973125458, -0.2746722102165222, 0.5308780670166016, 0.4269261658191681, -0.32453685998916626, 0.12398144602775574, 0.9354490637779236, -0.46506303548812866, -0.006806297227740288, -0.23200689256191254, 0.14855776727199554, -0.3693397045135498, 0.41764917969703674, -0.04882059246301651, -0.8384542465209961, 0.5075433850288391, -0.06291765719652176, 0.6093453168869019, 0.8483992218971252, 0.5406935214996338, -0.3315114676952362, 0.7253899574279785, 1.097114086151123, -0.035668324679136276, 0.41146498918533325, -0.1847131848335266, 0.009730773977935314, -0.9623737335205078, -0.5629411339759827, -0.6037496328353882, -0.5946106910705566, -0.49112027883529663, -0.26916414499282837, 0.30281516909599304, 0.033131279051303864, 0.12491128593683243, 0.08021273463964462, -0.7356589436531067, 0.39725181460380554, 0.2990114092826843, 0.09755782037973404, 0.646949827671051, -0.2640075385570526, 0.0016119583742693067, -0.3469841182231903, -0.35328447818756104, -0.2795712649822235, 1.2099915742874146, 0.3981289863586426, 0.3355126976966858, 0.4544305205345154, 0.7809647917747498, 0.6156900525093079, 0.5271428823471069, -0.9461010694503784, 0.4150559902191162, -0.3424169421195984, -0.4298805892467499, -0.30428290367126465, -0.2792224884033203, -0.8928846120834351, 0.29650408029556274, -0.0503217987716198, -0.7126061916351318, 0.13619938492774963, -0.03804060071706772, -0.3431297838687897, 0.39068087935447693, -0.4048600494861603, 0.7842989563941956, -0.25816354155540466, -0.09376978129148483, -0.350852906703949, -0.6298947334289551, 0.46647751331329346, -0.14284949004650116, 0.11968495696783066, 0.19759584963321686, -0.5182999968528748, 1.0685077905654907, -0.09875991195440292, 0.7208991646766663, -0.351609468460083, -0.13482004404067993, -0.026220638304948807, -0.1321519911289215, 0.07347571104764938, -0.029900360852479935, 0.10179077833890915, 0.10809095948934555, -0.26313886046409607, -0.3451938033103943, -0.2700115442276001, 0.5272875428199768, -0.2501755952835083, -0.1051003560423851, -0.6492688655853271, -0.7490641474723816, 0.20855043828487396, 0.7621451616287231, 0.034036800265312195, 0.42656949162483215, -0.305031955242157, 0.18138742446899414, 0.7892763614654541, -0.5717123746871948, 1.1162300109863281, 0.30841144919395447, -0.6121098399162292, -0.8105349540710449, 0.8818369507789612, 0.12827077507972717, -0.24418367445468903, 0.537802517414093, 0.07427158951759338, -0.08966269344091415, -0.9590059518814087, -0.5140523910522461, -0.026337947696447372, -0.5440365076065063, -0.299442857503891, -0.9736729264259338, -0.21897770464420319, -0.4666408598423004, -0.04271687567234039, -0.09435775876045227, -0.6384937763214111, -0.26170071959495544, 0.03072340600192547, 0.04471348971128464, 1.2652032375335693, 0.13505855202674866, 0.24917569756507874, -0.7579596638679504, 0.3226206302642822, 0.010942021384835243, 0.20971904695034027, 0.10602226853370667, -0.38283488154411316, -0.5709447264671326, -0.21860860288143158, -0.741293728351593, -0.8108924031257629, 0.507315456867218, 0.41517964005470276, 0.22069090604782104, 0.28886693716049194, 0.1620500385761261, 0.32645541429519653, -0.2690167725086212, 1.0842653512954712, 0.2043677270412445, -0.8647850751876831, 0.7967511415481567, -0.487052321434021, 0.6132047772407532, 0.6132178902626038, 0.1820795238018036, -0.5072808861732483, -0.30419743061065674, -0.5181335210800171, -1.1831791400909424, 0.37571072578430176, 0.22814780473709106, -0.18352390825748444, 0.5130940675735474, 0.1272524744272232, -0.02489425055682659, 0.4906977117061615, -0.5122410655021667, -0.5458022952079773, -0.36456453800201416, -0.3206874430179596, 0.009409675374627113, -0.23992356657981873, -0.22338567674160004, -0.2554062306880951, 0.39720895886421204, -0.1637178212404251, 0.2351977527141571, 0.46623843908309937, -0.3368423283100128, 0.16403082013130188, 0.18825270235538483, 1.1435719728469849, 1.1154202222824097, -0.4392319917678833, -0.07155020534992218, -0.21360035240650177, -0.7067115306854248, -0.27248290181159973, 0.4514589309692383, -0.5594393014907837, 0.5638079643249512, 0.643218457698822, 0.2680301368236542, 0.11330941319465637, -0.5090882182121277, 0.8077466487884521, -0.46781688928604126, -0.5505797266960144, -0.7488884925842285, -0.2868870198726654, -0.07105140388011932, 0.562929630279541, 0.723435640335083, 0.31409695744514465, 0.5288115739822388, -0.1408320516347885, 0.2522661089897156, 0.07372969388961792, -0.5400351285934448, -0.41364413499832153, 0.8169166445732117, 0.3903980553150177, -0.5764625072479248, 0.3742397129535675, -0.26790353655815125, -0.6105313897132874, 0.5168614983558655, 0.09031983464956284, 1.4494810104370117, 0.24293778836727142, 0.30891332030296326, 0.6244140267372131, 0.39275646209716797, -0.015269805677235126, 0.20126131176948547, -0.2222364991903305, -0.2661949098110199, -0.8920385241508484, -0.19188758730888367, -0.43831050395965576, 0.11877226084470749, -0.5809940695762634, 0.02323245257139206, -0.39957132935523987, -0.08320821076631546, 0.38494303822517395, 0.16771848499774933, -0.2128680944442749, -0.022546937689185143, -0.22305184602737427, 1.069163203239441, -0.44655299186706543, 0.9347301125526428, 0.8811042904853821, -0.6542183756828308, -0.07514309138059616, 0.5081827640533447, 0.1470724642276764, -0.31139078736305237, 0.5498326420783997, 0.35536086559295654, 0.21572929620742798, -0.06832680106163025, -0.34059804677963257, -0.623468816280365, 1.546684980392456, 0.016774315387010574, -0.3185732960700989, -0.2090173214673996, -0.3743595480918884, 0.6666683554649353, -0.45345455408096313, 0.48892953991889954, 0.5983614325523376, 0.5356832146644592, -0.3984132409095764, -1.0090504884719849, 0.01675383187830448, -0.5729891657829285, -0.05680374801158905, 0.1957811713218689, -0.6321927905082703, 0.9707804322242737, -0.2793958783149719, -0.07517841458320618, -0.09419025480747223, 0.6700376868247986, 0.09566691517829895, 0.8351553678512573, 0.3043743968009949, 0.571033239364624, 0.6476579308509827, -0.24454042315483093, 0.8466198444366455, -0.30232730507850647, 0.365629643201828, 1.150520920753479, 0.2569047808647156, 0.5304797887802124, 0.4528425335884094, -0.03138633817434311, 0.5484729409217834, 0.6784101724624634, 0.061565522104501724, 0.46208563446998596, 0.08221041411161423, -0.21935443580150604, 0.30403199791908264, -0.2960337698459625, -0.498870849609375, 0.023872029036283493, 0.4082174301147461, -0.6927028894424438, -0.573054850101471, 0.022201169282197952, 0.14491091668605804, 0.18441978096961975, -0.3275817632675171, 0.9727708697319031, 0.0974293053150177, -0.6802777051925659, 0.20733711123466492, 0.04832427576184273, 0.9297260046005249, -0.3351399600505829, -0.26043468713760376, -0.3770330250263214, 0.08718244731426239, -0.49995487928390503, -0.7879790663719177, 0.5617290735244751, 0.007956687361001968, -0.38863587379455566, -0.46287819743156433, 0.7368512749671936, -0.48751193284988403, -0.2920891344547272, 0.3128654956817627, 0.6561987996101379, 0.11654964089393616, -0.14755310118198395, -0.7932661175727844, -0.16889913380146027, 0.31615427136421204, -0.437942236661911, 0.27024292945861816, 0.6909513473510742, 0.2103881686925888, 0.5274161100387573, 0.20992043614387512, 0.15809433162212372, -0.1548662781715393, 0.26965001225471497, 0.8513422012329102, -0.9755105972290039, -0.40102189779281616, -0.8323679566383362, 0.9078803062438965, -0.58488929271698, -0.6216056942939758, 0.6715829968452454, 0.7103374600410461, 0.6453616619110107, 0.06494856625795364, 0.9175928235054016, -0.46833643317222595, 0.6491336822509766, -0.419966459274292, 1.032850742340088, -0.7302877902984619, 0.36924439668655396, -0.2165774405002594, -0.8010168075561523, -0.521294355392456, 0.5790727138519287, 0.15678760409355164, 0.07173382490873337, 1.0828324556350708, 0.22833746671676636, 0.21856150031089783, -0.01369419228285551, -0.00745665468275547, 0.10560701042413712, 0.4682087004184723, 0.20568867027759552, 0.25226467847824097, -0.6918830275535583, 0.5001896023750305, -0.3959234952926636, -0.17877870798110962, -0.16302835941314697, -1.0584867000579834, -1.1260783672332764, -0.6615189909934998, -0.4986579418182373, -0.41205117106437683, -0.11630561947822571, 0.5978789329528809, 0.2984956204891205, -0.8147504329681396, -0.23150482773780823, -0.17349010705947876, 0.2703036069869995, -0.352316290140152, -0.3109758496284485, 0.6262564659118652, -0.8154995441436768, -0.6539112329483032, 0.24689920246601105, 0.14579974114894867, -0.11787654459476471, -0.47674083709716797, 0.08973658084869385, -0.2655758261680603, -0.5654988884925842, 0.9151716828346252, 0.08027365058660507, -0.391539067029953, 0.09484975785017014, -0.16081902384757996, 0.039014704525470734, 0.030198032036423683, 1.0964787006378174, -0.5411574840545654, 0.5435500144958496, 0.7954741716384888, 0.8361988663673401, 0.5968350768089294, -0.19740743935108185, 0.781075119972229, -1.0017505884170532, -0.17252473533153534, 0.45300254225730896, 0.09034714847803116, 0.28111034631729126, -0.13005739450454712, 0.6911056041717529, 0.17720361053943634, -0.677756130695343, -0.7839915156364441, -0.1193106472492218, -1.1286835670471191, -0.36291593313217163, 0.6340807676315308, -0.2001645863056183, 0.02943906933069229, -0.2762696444988251, -0.221816286444664, 0.3475259244441986, -0.7253485918045044, 0.7505060434341431, 0.6123749613761902, -0.1570160984992981, -0.4690326750278473, -0.957625150680542, 0.630255937576294, 0.4004300534725189, -0.9200326204299927, -0.03180158510804176, 0.5122790932655334, 0.013356752693653107, 0.6095449924468994, 0.7466524243354797, -0.2383476197719574, 0.18058747053146362, -0.30525660514831543, 0.020716043189167976, -0.16218973696231842, -0.25265055894851685, -0.6722649335861206, 0.42638301849365234, -0.030549269169569016, 0.006491254083812237 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06907v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06907v1	Investigating Consistency in Query-Based Meeting Summarization: A Comparative Study of Different Embedding Methods	2024-02-10T08:25:30	2024-02-10T08:25:30	Chen Jia-Chen, Guillem Senabre, Allane Caron	cs.CL	cs.CL	With more and more advanced data analysis techniques emerging, people will expect these techniques to be applied in more complex tasks and solve problems in our daily lives. Text Summarization is one of famous applications in Natural Language Processing (NLP) field. It aims to automatically generate summary with important information based on a given context, which is important when you have to deal with piles of documents. Summarization techniques can help capture key points in a short time and bring convenience in works. One of applicable situation is meeting summarization, especially for important meeting that tend to be long, complicated, multi-topic and multi-person. Therefore, when people want to review specific content from a meeting, it will be hard and time-consuming to find the related spans in the meeting transcript. However, most of previous works focus on doing summarization for newsletters, scientific articles...etc, which have a clear document structure and an official format. For the documents with complex structure like transcripts, we think those works are not quite suitable for meeting summarization. Besides, the consistency of summary is another issue common to be discussed in NLP field. To conquer challenges of meeting summarization, we are inspired by "QMSum: A New Benchmark for Query-based Multi-domain Meeting Summarization" proposed by Microsoft and we also propose our Locater model designed to extract relevant spans based on given transcript and query, which are then summarized by Summarizer model. Furthermore, we perform a comparative study by applying different word embedding techniques to improve summary consistency.	[ -0.3484693169593811, -0.6538390517234802, 0.48196688294410706, 0.24932092428207397, -0.16315367817878723, 0.1893402636051178, 0.03685672581195831, -0.5340707302093506, 0.5898866653442383, 0.004149973392486572, -0.46751248836517334, -0.6559591293334961, -0.6365050077438354, 0.2934660315513611, -0.4448528289794922, 0.7665684819221497, -0.2932719886302948, 0.17082563042640686, -0.6176508069038391, -0.5262941122055054, -0.41685181856155396, -0.8622721433639526, -0.4092879295349121, 0.0022966868709772825, 0.06645795702934265, 0.19086939096450806, 0.612886905670166, 0.3828301727771759, 0.548309862613678, 0.2426053136587143, -0.45300427079200745, 0.6829356551170349, -0.60101318359375, 0.2468239963054657, -0.037088192999362946, -0.42222678661346436, -0.5863246917724609, 0.059748947620391846, 0.8247717022895813, 0.8738670945167542, -0.28734418749809265, -0.04109477251768112, 0.17934133112430573, 0.7143480777740479, -0.5198497176170349, 0.13253585994243622, -0.6834450364112854, 0.1607843041419983, 0.12098804861307144, -0.22850152850151062, 0.01842896081507206, -0.6320265531539917, 0.18755647540092468, -0.4202856719493866, 0.5673190951347351, 0.3321978747844696, 1.0358150005340576, -0.09812577068805695, -0.37773093581199646, -0.29075631499290466, -0.42077526450157166, 0.6966872811317444, -0.9154682755470276, 0.6159851551055908, 0.47194358706474304, 0.24367175996303558, -0.2662877142429352, -0.6513863801956177, -0.46387729048728943, -0.004048984032124281, -0.15898774564266205, 0.12929798662662506, -0.080742247402668, -0.045294441282749176, 0.23469732701778412, 0.5335215330123901, -0.7027656435966492, -0.034499842673540115, -0.11133939027786255, -0.1129196509718895, 0.5036079287528992, 0.4600749611854553, 0.34686964750289917, -0.12978143990039825, -0.1403995156288147, 0.10286571085453033, -0.6845749616622925, -0.1869591623544693, -0.009448337368667126, 0.17538492381572723, -0.11628487706184387, 0.8195374608039856, -0.7268403768539429, 0.4002316892147064, 0.037900134921073914, 0.1109691634774208, 0.22674430906772614, -0.8187517523765564, -0.05819880589842796, -0.03383738547563553, 0.6681303381919861, 0.9741385579109192, 0.09624097496271133, -0.3624482750892639, -0.10670121759176254, -0.23800843954086304, -0.07995422184467316, -0.8352954983711243, -0.21791957318782806, 0.4769057631492615, -0.5269904136657715, 0.2553004026412964, 0.26179492473602295, -0.4464558959007263, -0.10048733651638031, -0.334072470664978, 0.3935321867465973, -0.41790109872817993, 0.0008072905475273728, -0.037954434752464294, -0.2200963944196701, 0.16619998216629028, 0.5836067199707031, -0.7710659503936768, 0.31641119718551636, 0.7905290126800537, 1.0981086492538452, -0.3795645534992218, -0.33315807580947876, -0.4741823971271515, 0.1514911651611328, -0.16028167307376862, 0.7583966851234436, -0.2126036435365677, -0.5111156702041626, 0.0897773951292038, -0.020924877375364304, -0.38182294368743896, -0.7352278828620911, 0.46600404381752014, -0.36978086829185486, 0.496212363243103, -0.539988100528717, -0.9642029404640198, 0.007366931065917015, 0.618434488773346, -0.42744672298431396, 1.006923794746399, -0.16375046968460083, -0.7586113214492798, 0.519659161567688, -0.48313263058662415, -0.0652727261185646, -0.2034113109111786, -0.504169225692749, -0.8403103947639465, 0.10646563023328781, 0.4809671640396118, 0.27919796109199524, 0.3079284727573395, 0.11473733186721802, -0.0301936324685812, -0.5545952320098877, 0.3188994526863098, 0.14423106610774994, 0.3659932613372803, -0.09676754474639893, -0.15235714614391327, 0.19222521781921387, -0.5335083603858948, 0.10997758060693741, 0.07685121148824692, -0.2827063798904419, -0.36998745799064636, 0.4003012180328369, -0.1271335929632187, 0.14969773590564728, 0.3036095201969147, -0.5378663539886475, 0.19474448263645172, -0.3662140965461731, -0.045063912868499756, 0.2645895779132843, 0.4713716208934784, 0.4228949248790741, -0.616940975189209, 0.3551209568977356, -0.06440766155719757, 0.02254759706556797, -0.5036687850952148, -0.4412510395050049, -0.42947641015052795, -0.28678426146507263, 0.22861453890800476, 0.3661641776561737, -0.25080710649490356, 0.3520680069923401, -0.4329247772693634, -0.4175983667373657, -0.5013048052787781, -0.11979051679372787, 0.5118904113769531, 0.08901040256023407, 0.34997913241386414, -0.11658093333244324, -0.7257853150367737, -0.7698949575424194, -0.6257262229919434, 0.031264279037714005, -0.1145208477973938, 0.2003674954175949, 0.47500962018966675, -0.09069959819316864, 0.9646053314208984, -0.6646499633789062, -0.3747312128543854, -0.26504817605018616, 0.06731455028057098, 0.19188910722732544, 0.5989059209823608, 0.5553037524223328, -0.821925938129425, -0.5533769726753235, -0.2611948251724243, -0.8448455929756165, 0.0851367712020874, -0.010343718342483044, -0.1552998423576355, 0.27008217573165894, 0.615161657333374, -0.4182058572769165, 0.5745956301689148, 0.3084220886230469, -0.28477349877357483, 0.46223559975624084, -0.12261233478784561, 0.6204323172569275, -1.2235740423202515, -0.04280726984143257, -0.3786086440086365, -0.45786842703819275, -0.34773895144462585, 0.12340303510427475, 0.10900373756885529, -0.11167377978563309, -0.12987516820430756, 0.09521245211362839, -0.7601816654205322, -0.08152315765619278, -0.20207567512989044, 0.6052768230438232, 0.2777326703071594, 0.44443193078041077, -0.09921011328697205, 0.8368583917617798, 0.34118664264678955, -0.7227315306663513, -0.17543765902519226, 0.8545809984207153, -0.13610026240348816, 0.623350203037262, -0.9290798306465149, 0.1418074518442154, -0.06032538414001465, 0.1909368932247162, -1.108522653579712, 0.012181148864328861, 0.07390549778938293, -0.7328702211380005, 0.25576964020729065, -0.12932328879833221, -0.6523850560188293, 0.18614737689495087, -0.9068301916122437, 0.26383545994758606, 0.21221299469470978, -0.4200510084629059, 0.4849996864795685, 0.547722578048706, -0.25699830055236816, -0.29443398118019104, -0.487258642911911, 0.2789362072944641, -0.010647615417838097, -0.5081885457038879, 0.657090961933136, -0.10603420436382294, -0.2656433582305908, 0.09875684231519699, -0.5681606531143188, 0.009135952219367027, -0.1474471092224121, 0.38826784491539, 0.09429959207773209, -0.24370267987251282, 0.04647645726799965, 0.1949957311153412, 0.13439765572547913, -0.08785928785800934, 0.05196855589747429, 0.36746832728385925, -0.20428800582885742, -0.5488005876541138, -0.7916395664215088, 0.8869075775146484, 0.5758389234542847, -0.4349341094493866, 1.0607075691223145, 0.33219295740127563, -0.5613993406295776, 0.2456520050764084, -0.6573752164840698, -0.07311515510082245, -0.36038658022880554, 0.47786906361579895, -0.37231531739234924, -0.9618857502937317, 0.9222085475921631, -0.23306065797805786, 0.41522079706192017, 0.5122320652008057, 0.4030803442001343, -0.19404128193855286, 1.1438945531845093, 0.7099927663803101, -0.00406508008018136, 0.5486869812011719, -0.13466531038284302, 0.019755307585000992, -0.9322623610496521, -0.5594521760940552, -0.7871434688568115, -0.1970803588628769, -0.4890076518058777, -0.23343433439731598, 0.22936822474002838, 0.3158642649650574, 0.2798369228839874, 0.35567811131477356, -0.2357671707868576, 0.3478567898273468, 0.22358205914497375, -0.2221393585205078, 0.4215756058692932, -0.011781712993979454, -0.24183081090450287, -0.22965706884860992, -0.7935807108879089, -0.6424134373664856, 0.6899895668029785, -0.08809975534677505, 0.4069679081439972, 0.36138299107551575, 0.9382286071777344, 0.193375363945961, 0.05893990397453308, -0.6786883473396301, 0.4671873450279236, 0.32227104902267456, -0.3608361482620239, -0.29739779233932495, -0.6000068187713623, -1.1788082122802734, 0.6914069056510925, -0.4584229588508606, -0.752770185470581, 0.21390312910079956, -0.07514365017414093, -0.001008767751045525, 0.29711610078811646, -0.4981345236301422, 0.7102956771850586, 0.2627119719982147, 0.01435326598584652, -0.05666126683354378, -0.5124955773353577, -0.08741011470556259, 0.15515752136707306, 0.19573961198329926, -0.32997214794158936, -0.02595267817378044, 1.0234020948410034, -0.49670302867889404, 0.4570562541484833, 0.08891411870718002, -0.04652152210474014, 0.14905528724193573, 0.14843598008155823, 0.5107028484344482, 0.17616979777812958, -0.15439660847187042, -0.052563559263944626, 0.3255402445793152, -0.4671024978160858, -0.7761176228523254, 0.641455352306366, -0.44851160049438477, -0.47850707173347473, -0.4067241847515106, -0.3911344110965729, -0.3386044204235077, 0.04827623441815376, 0.1727130264043808, 0.7584789991378784, -0.47764351963996887, 0.13367456197738647, 0.4949134886264801, 0.06844346225261688, 0.32314637303352356, 0.6145457029342651, -0.31256645917892456, -0.4676525294780731, 0.5182213187217712, 0.18490681052207947, 0.16083136200904846, 0.5356519222259521, -0.06904614716768265, -0.24377837777137756, -0.8812676072120667, -0.12442565709352493, 0.3564538061618805, -0.5159537196159363, -0.2699320316314697, -0.9283216595649719, -0.037526216357946396, -0.48637887835502625, -0.07495342195034027, -0.41567468643188477, -0.7436248660087585, -0.1974085122346878, -0.2042645364999771, 0.06993568688631058, 0.5087850093841553, 0.2318783700466156, 0.14183148741722107, -1.139972448348999, 0.43125367164611816, -0.13241848349571228, 0.3336010277271271, -0.08175063878297806, -0.342140257358551, -0.467611163854599, 0.054807040840387344, -0.4348476827144623, -0.9872689843177795, 0.2171115279197693, 0.49979567527770996, 0.9715585112571716, 0.2862224280834198, 0.19209997355937958, 0.7037563920021057, -0.33770477771759033, 0.8121886253356934, -0.012034659273922443, -0.797849178314209, 0.7215192914009094, -0.23733466863632202, 0.3172471225261688, 0.8906799554824829, 0.43315523862838745, -0.6892097592353821, -0.6577345132827759, -0.7075187563896179, -1.1366252899169922, 0.46470317244529724, 0.4940560460090637, -0.11078770458698273, -0.28057101368904114, 0.5123077034950256, 0.1253967136144638, 0.3706988990306854, -0.062172096222639084, -0.33544206619262695, 0.07746778428554535, 0.008067718707025051, 0.037457361817359924, -0.4176827073097229, -0.06899765133857727, -0.008842404000461102, 0.5127502083778381, 0.05262861028313637, 0.2339361011981964, 0.5430881977081299, -0.20303304493427277, 0.12011463195085526, 0.2696133852005005, 0.7233442068099976, 1.1389827728271484, -0.5663663744926453, 0.06645028293132782, 0.3489695191383362, -0.3952769339084625, -0.32478630542755127, 0.007825851440429688, 0.02504592388868332, 0.518298327922821, 0.4260477125644684, 0.28176236152648926, 0.257935106754303, -0.6860072612762451, 0.6322306394577026, -0.2801159620285034, -0.25919896364212036, -0.004429380875080824, -0.20300036668777466, 0.029701750725507736, 0.1479271650314331, 0.4990833103656769, -0.11757700145244598, 0.4066954553127289, -0.5540995001792908, 0.35220232605934143, 0.37840431928634644, -0.4027206301689148, -0.22215424478054047, 0.6912155151367188, 0.0811353251338005, -0.31044623255729675, 0.6038854122161865, -0.30632805824279785, -0.7216809988021851, 0.31551888585090637, 0.31872740387916565, 0.6141133904457092, 0.04554446041584015, -0.17754390835762024, 0.5220774412155151, 0.11506106704473495, -0.03266162797808647, 0.49618539214134216, -0.099756620824337, -0.3343294858932495, -0.40450745820999146, -0.26050227880477905, -0.8758012652397156, -0.4541984498500824, -0.8622802495956421, -0.174369677901268, 0.018260911107063293, -0.2612002193927765, -0.3110445737838745, 0.2585676610469818, -0.27173900604248047, -0.09472926706075668, -0.36100974678993225, 0.7458609342575073, -0.6120209693908691, 0.2269744873046875, 0.6653273701667786, -0.2992331385612488, -0.5230774879455566, 0.02081259712576866, -0.03377726301550865, -0.21472419798374176, 0.019967563450336456, 0.14685095846652985, -0.1278337687253952, -0.348514199256897, -0.3728950619697571, -0.6200247406959534, 1.1889234781265259, 0.04331739991903305, -0.6136089563369751, 0.00015458420966751873, -0.22108681499958038, 0.3778904378414154, -0.10294270515441895, -0.03977782279253006, 0.16640612483024597, 0.04945346340537071, 0.1044776663184166, -1.1354808807373047, 0.21267452836036682, -0.2768794000148773, -0.19788594543933868, 0.3991257846355438, -0.3816989064216614, 0.5816345810890198, -0.1942359358072281, -0.377800852060318, 0.2922441363334656, 0.9840272665023804, 0.4771246314048767, 0.8358904123306274, -0.001802452839910984, 0.336966335773468, 0.9711775183677673, -0.1153513491153717, 1.0162525177001953, -0.14374518394470215, 0.58903968334198, 1.4150182008743286, -0.2182789295911789, 0.9723281264305115, 0.5519978404045105, -0.3624880611896515, 0.22702808678150177, 0.3369423449039459, 0.008269188925623894, 0.3431156575679779, 0.20138192176818848, -0.01047875639051199, 0.11000361293554306, -0.13036806881427765, -0.6534223556518555, 0.3512982428073883, 0.22914154827594757, -0.15296529233455658, -0.3974650204181671, -0.3621823191642761, 0.2111200988292694, 0.3254261016845703, -0.19442059099674225, 0.9808167815208435, 0.21199068427085876, -0.5240165591239929, 0.37859368324279785, 0.14208106696605682, 0.5858632922172546, -0.5961095094680786, -0.02680576592683792, -0.4064611792564392, 0.030198445543646812, -0.26123183965682983, -0.46477362513542175, 0.5470831990242004, -0.235393688082695, -0.11852927505970001, 0.0746888667345047, 0.32925018668174744, -0.5107860565185547, 0.004342671483755112, -0.09936638176441193, 1.0366222858428955, 0.3467060327529907, -0.3955913484096527, -0.3852717876434326, 0.09411918371915817, -0.20666825771331787, -0.08697716891765594, 0.41105136275291443, 0.5243313312530518, -0.033043526113033295, 0.44203639030456543, 0.5183458924293518, -0.1108708530664444, 0.08060899376869202, 0.37939029932022095, 0.8395913243293762, -0.5827903151512146, -0.6826720237731934, -0.8827419281005859, 0.1888391077518463, -0.36194488406181335, -0.21624337136745453, 1.1154738664627075, 1.1843458414077759, 0.44990605115890503, 0.13884401321411133, 0.23273296654224396, 0.31753289699554443, 0.656008243560791, -0.5373938679695129, 0.8273375034332275, -0.44127100706100464, 0.17641709744930267, -0.39294710755348206, -0.9982914328575134, -0.5283871293067932, 0.5186546444892883, 0.02089894376695156, 0.06266336143016815, 0.7405192852020264, 0.6204061508178711, 0.12893806397914886, -0.027257975190877914, 0.20097751915454865, -0.18519945442676544, 0.4300990104675293, 0.31209543347358704, 0.8611791133880615, -0.5526434779167175, 0.5420310497283936, 0.1408969610929489, -0.05343874916434288, -0.5309662222862244, -0.7709298729896545, -0.8443305492401123, -0.7249877452850342, -0.8103762269020081, -0.31302547454833984, 0.22648140788078308, 1.0324552059173584, 0.5260280966758728, -0.8257573246955872, -0.01185913197696209, 0.1815177947282791, 0.11670530587434769, -0.378743439912796, -0.23604440689086914, 0.7912745475769043, -0.15926450490951538, -0.7522857785224915, 0.34273654222488403, 0.3235902488231659, 0.2436242252588272, 0.39057424664497375, 0.0858677551150322, -0.42003175616264343, 0.14945118129253387, 0.5531876087188721, 0.2948858439922333, -0.45193320512771606, -0.13547952473163605, 0.0007728932541795075, -0.21764901280403137, 0.14621201157569885, 0.7519448399543762, -0.5494575500488281, 0.2746649980545044, 0.6195330619812012, 0.5978454351425171, 0.6576781868934631, 0.32744985818862915, 0.47269758582115173, -0.8688567280769348, -0.4724408984184265, 0.02530745230615139, 0.42247939109802246, 0.39594703912734985, -0.20584502816200256, 0.5996118187904358, -0.01273474283516407, -0.6062865257263184, -0.7713410258293152, 0.011587822809815407, -1.420796513557434, -0.04100418463349342, 0.8794410824775696, -0.2772494852542877, 0.18444252014160156, -0.19684740900993347, -0.5221797823905945, 0.4370819926261902, -0.3348276913166046, 1.0143827199935913, 0.38022980093955994, -0.43756699562072754, 0.08102690428495407, -0.23594006896018982, 0.535957396030426, 0.3951147198677063, -0.7697080373764038, -0.008812402375042439, 0.3778359591960907, 0.18684078752994537, 0.20019353926181793, 0.711174488067627, -0.41107428073883057, 0.33551082015037537, -0.126188725233078, -0.25277814269065857, -0.324247270822525, 0.023416072130203247, -0.21353203058242798, 0.41798073053359985, -0.05609698221087456, -0.6323355436325073 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05553v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05553v1	Understanding the Progression of Educational Topics via Semantic Matching	2024-02-10T08:24:29	2024-02-10T08:24:29	Tamador Alkhidir, Edmond Awad, Aamena Alshamsi	cs.CY	cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG	Education systems are dynamically changing to accommodate technological advances, industrial and societal needs, and to enhance students' learning journeys. Curriculum specialists and educators constantly revise taught subjects across educational grades to identify gaps, introduce new learning topics, and enhance the learning outcomes. This process is usually done within the same subjects (e.g. math) or across related subjects (e.g. math and physics) considering the same and different educational levels, leading to massive multi-layer comparisons. Having nuanced data about subjects, topics, and learning outcomes structured within a dataset, empowers us to leverage data science to better understand the progression of various learning topics. In this paper, Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) topic modeling was used to extract topics from the curriculum, which were then used to identify relationships between subjects, track their progression, and identify conceptual gaps. We found that grouping learning outcomes by common topics helped specialists reduce redundancy and introduce new concepts in the curriculum. We built a dashboard to avail the methodology to curriculum specials. Finally, we tested the validity of the approach with subject matter experts.	[ -0.6137818694114685, -0.7731181383132935, 0.5033339262008667, -0.025669993832707405, 0.033599499613046646, 0.32835879921913147, 0.0521635040640831, 0.170093834400177, 0.16753211617469788, 0.6367056369781494, -1.033097743988037, -0.6223278641700745, -0.5981132388114929, -0.14353862404823303, -0.7008271813392639, 0.9571593999862671, 0.15958069264888763, -0.0639665275812149, -0.6772611141204834, 0.18593807518482208, -1.1746243238449097, -0.10826869308948517, -0.33648714423179626, -0.39863350987434387, 0.4131343960762024, 0.6059780716896057, 0.4179319143295288, 0.6850846409797668, 0.8343457579612732, 0.2899914085865021, -0.2568759620189667, 0.008620585314929485, -0.3771686553955078, 0.13961389660835266, -0.4526945650577545, -0.19378574192523956, -0.2595742642879486, -0.21411024034023285, 0.5501289367675781, 1.2493852376937866, -0.10197367519140244, 0.03872614726424217, 0.35311415791511536, 0.8097160458564758, -0.37021517753601074, 0.2268134355545044, -0.4913613200187683, 0.3462485074996948, -0.14392341673374176, -0.21170645952224731, -0.2939754128456116, -0.3167518079280853, 0.5594017505645752, -0.7684398889541626, 0.6958766579627991, -0.6490703225135803, 0.9948508143424988, 0.48574137687683105, -0.5154038667678833, -0.4577016830444336, -0.3664751350879669, 0.7588843703269958, -0.15416929125785828, 0.5415225625038147, 0.3749930262565613, 0.24177348613739014, -0.17622610926628113, -0.7247446179389954, -0.32237985730171204, 0.3271007537841797, 0.03770122677087784, 0.32688963413238525, 0.3243334889411926, -0.34064629673957825, 0.0027772895991802216, 0.24383342266082764, -0.555246889591217, 0.10919924080371857, -0.6566868424415588, -0.2577846944332123, 0.42458388209342957, 0.4293336272239685, 0.2474474012851715, -0.07227297127246857, -0.33812814950942993, -0.3078435957431793, -0.5560316443443298, -0.27059778571128845, 0.4185679852962494, 0.4671883285045624, -0.1291702389717102, 0.5771198868751526, -0.17520207166671753, 0.9603297710418701, 0.14949220418930054, 0.11550386250019073, 0.2499283403158188, -0.49838581681251526, 0.24924258887767792, 0.1423480212688446, 0.030847307294607162, 0.44359302520751953, 0.021436035633087158, -0.11252519488334656, 0.3315454423427582, 0.35181984305381775, 0.4550631642341614, -0.5611416697502136, -0.26044297218322754, -0.04143102094531059, -0.21433795988559723, 0.017930494621396065, 0.11371425539255142, -0.9183288812637329, -0.15920624136924744, -0.8367716073989868, 0.26159733533859253, -0.48604077100753784, -0.016329606994986534, 0.39277201890945435, -0.2104790061712265, 0.45621389150619507, 0.6510981917381287, -0.7409772872924805, -0.1613655388355255, 1.2973146438598633, 0.722000002861023, -0.24509809911251068, -0.24170660972595215, 0.157841756939888, 0.18613767623901367, -0.14894074201583862, 0.8846458792686462, -0.8141089081764221, -0.39539098739624023, 0.06519542634487152, 0.12129959464073181, -0.06492890417575836, -0.2883843779563904, 0.30138176679611206, -0.7854442596435547, 0.501479983329773, -0.14183086156845093, -0.8464422821998596, 0.04409525543451309, 0.34458327293395996, -0.46335145831108093, 0.8206467032432556, -0.04683791473507881, -0.8735096454620361, 0.4893801808357239, -0.5458448529243469, -0.382162481546402, -0.1979762762784958, -0.19504676759243011, -0.45211249589920044, -0.057973362505435944, 0.04881443455815315, 0.42591550946235657, -0.22538098692893982, 0.5432367324829102, -0.011189857497811317, -0.29115140438079834, -0.09373921900987625, -0.0550219900906086, 0.577904999256134, 0.24586309492588043, 0.10119803994894028, 0.011028610169887543, -0.5929882526397705, -0.3746127486228943, -0.3255786895751953, -0.17596757411956787, -0.4176441729068756, 0.41247203946113586, -0.36761412024497986, 0.2668907940387726, 0.4123329520225525, -0.26688188314437866, 0.1306106597185135, -0.14000822603702545, 0.28140053153038025, 0.9028887748718262, 0.12042387574911118, 0.35095319151878357, -0.3445626199245453, 0.1546327918767929, 0.4762021005153656, -0.052536461502313614, -0.4316185414791107, -0.639370322227478, -0.8332478404045105, -0.1496490240097046, 0.4535354673862457, 0.3304494619369507, -0.5721902847290039, 0.7959499359130859, -0.37844327092170715, -0.5835897922515869, -0.5135205388069153, -0.18919801712036133, -0.08909564465284348, 0.8083614706993103, 0.4869561195373535, -0.6955611109733582, -0.4199233949184418, -0.7610724568367004, -0.043789803981781006, -0.1064843088388443, -0.17213670909404755, -0.0030476953834295273, 0.2165769636631012, -0.4677312970161438, 1.5186749696731567, -1.010011076927185, -0.13796381652355194, 0.17543925344944, 0.16520997881889343, 0.2881401777267456, 0.7854664325714111, 0.1662445366382599, -1.0075123310089111, -0.5337151885032654, -0.14468568563461304, -0.8477761745452881, -0.16872431337833405, -0.16470074653625488, -0.7457084655761719, -0.3987112045288086, 0.37030065059661865, -0.013524682261049747, 0.3615957796573639, -0.10745170712471008, -0.8389977216720581, 0.2422180324792862, -0.011739799752831459, 0.1035313531756401, -1.104067087173462, -0.3530808091163635, 0.12218264490365982, 0.25133055448532104, -0.373616099357605, -0.07835602015256882, -0.0028671196196228266, -0.48190274834632874, -0.19212239980697632, 0.21979105472564697, -0.00994019117206335, -0.09804686903953552, -0.13323582708835602, 0.42909157276153564, 0.07177305966615677, 0.11569146811962128, 0.2233191728591919, 0.7242226600646973, 0.9189528226852417, -0.5704282522201538, 0.2152123898267746, 0.6322510242462158, -0.07612257450819016, 0.7500418424606323, -0.5727841258049011, -0.11259728670120239, -0.4082567095756531, 0.05301407352089882, -0.7654109597206116, -0.07352948188781738, -0.07463622093200684, -0.39246442914009094, 0.15657110512256622, -0.14930459856987, -0.3296530544757843, -0.2803095579147339, -0.13800567388534546, 0.10913073271512985, 0.5603145360946655, -0.28660592436790466, 0.5359371304512024, 0.20300975441932678, -0.330371230840683, -0.522244393825531, -0.3637222349643707, -0.11204596608877182, -0.29569554328918457, -0.7403431534767151, 0.36744752526283264, -0.12465627491474152, -0.06895354390144348, 0.15122707188129425, -0.34643229842185974, -0.2345750480890274, 0.34216681122779846, 0.08307015895843506, 0.4692862927913666, -0.3552364110946655, 0.1922147274017334, 0.2824873626232147, -0.36768805980682373, 0.12156698852777481, -0.3042754828929901, 0.5620981454849243, 0.2909356653690338, -0.6465849876403809, -0.2724321782588959, 0.3350200057029724, 0.5043652057647705, -0.19361726939678192, 0.7144036889076233, 0.47632691264152527, -0.29094794392585754, 0.10119926184415817, -0.3840044140815735, -0.4785252809524536, -0.4710094928741455, 0.5641493797302246, -0.24468663334846497, -0.6195504069328308, 0.34400615096092224, -0.22914476692676544, 0.22839705646038055, 0.48731565475463867, 0.4078229069709778, 0.016695009544491768, 0.598087728023529, 0.838315486907959, 0.16327796876430511, 0.5239855051040649, -0.4318144619464874, 0.2541983425617218, -0.6915364265441895, -0.6982718706130981, -0.44464415311813354, -0.23417438566684723, -0.7524119019508362, -0.505700945854187, 0.022546054795384407, 0.13065899908542633, -0.26897066831588745, 0.5346843600273132, -0.7253014445304871, 0.43674755096435547, 0.3632239103317261, 0.2798137664794922, 0.29278644919395447, 0.25977346301078796, 0.12933269143104553, -0.2936542332172394, -0.3298206627368927, -0.5624639987945557, 1.048670768737793, 0.2555810809135437, 0.6460140347480774, 0.08013319969177246, 0.8413569927215576, 0.4797417223453522, 0.379817396402359, -0.5338309407234192, 0.757961630821228, -0.5381503105163574, -0.38092994689941406, -0.16844403743743896, -0.4057995676994324, -1.0696560144424438, 0.2126311957836151, -0.2789571285247803, -0.3452814519405365, 0.17841851711273193, -0.3371807336807251, 0.10367290675640106, 0.06901970505714417, -0.5476275086402893, 0.8184948563575745, 0.18757867813110352, -0.5821326375007629, -0.4300132393836975, -0.8222357034683228, -0.11676575243473053, -0.4924308955669403, 0.022201983258128166, -0.3260752558708191, 0.0723324865102768, 0.9733912944793701, -0.15609152615070343, 0.6782293319702148, 0.012383018620312214, -0.2902817130088806, 0.29127591848373413, -0.2962091565132141, -0.26381009817123413, 0.014657161198556423, -0.1803549975156784, 0.11198769509792328, -0.20478752255439758, -0.7106947302818298, -0.6134093999862671, 0.7836308479309082, -0.9902293682098389, -0.8433255553245544, -0.37352848052978516, -0.6339985132217407, -0.1913682222366333, 0.005546961445361376, -0.22374652326107025, 0.33904317021369934, -0.032006412744522095, 0.02034752629697323, 0.9375680685043335, -0.20264507830142975, 0.18303200602531433, 0.8391655683517456, 0.2185543328523636, -0.059726063162088394, 1.1402508020401, 0.004022889770567417, 0.08363007754087448, 0.46202951669692993, 0.029711710289120674, -0.11425013095140457, -0.2184552252292633, 0.023990940302610397, 0.18495459854602814, -0.8278079628944397, -0.24606885015964508, -0.7380852699279785, -0.3469931483268738, -0.36731868982315063, -0.62947016954422, -0.06396607309579849, -0.335322767496109, -0.5278903841972351, 0.10797128826379776, 0.24225524067878723, 0.5951971411705017, -0.1553877741098404, 0.2217911183834076, -0.6149007081985474, 0.12317559868097305, 0.5969173908233643, 0.07973293960094452, 0.02996709570288658, -0.5830821990966797, -0.06065765768289566, 0.1651892513036728, -0.936357855796814, -0.6648897528648376, 0.12028739601373672, 0.27829691767692566, 0.46717512607574463, 0.3616889417171478, -0.06599638611078262, 0.8220328092575073, -0.558525800704956, 0.7972456216812134, 0.2643287181854248, -0.9345080256462097, 1.0320806503295898, -0.13410541415214539, 0.07551683485507965, 0.35670462250709534, 0.6005876660346985, -0.5407909750938416, -0.3159898817539215, -0.6149515509605408, -1.126443862915039, 0.6992175579071045, 0.1906767636537552, 0.36265164613723755, -0.024391908198595047, 0.25539812445640564, 0.4032607972621918, 0.21971561014652252, -0.02333289571106434, -0.2955906093120575, -0.4042409658432007, -0.6786139011383057, 0.09540469199419022, 0.15866273641586304, -0.00125407287850976, -0.22019647061824799, 0.4695438742637634, -0.05043347179889679, 0.297211229801178, -0.24335607886314392, -0.1687113642692566, 0.4204180836677551, 0.3899000585079193, 0.3758009970188141, 0.8433261513710022, -0.1195208951830864, -0.03482179343700409, -0.013084008358418941, -0.6439187526702881, 0.1493385136127472, 0.24770355224609375, 0.028762957081198692, 0.13341116905212402, 0.5222927927970886, 0.37424129247665405, 0.30932724475860596, -0.6971483826637268, 0.30392763018608093, 0.10259425640106201, 0.10295989364385605, 0.039160892367362976, 0.23290197551250458, -0.02680794894695282, 0.2021908313035965, 0.5572688579559326, -0.15641842782497406, 0.06537733972072601, -0.6331247091293335, 0.8028491735458374, -0.1099192351102829, -0.45999178290367126, -0.3181028962135315, 0.4923146963119507, 0.3282293379306793, -0.28776589035987854, 0.9807570576667786, 0.3588809669017792, -0.36489853262901306, 1.1691100597381592, 0.5770570039749146, 0.6556229591369629, -0.015788232907652855, 0.501731276512146, 0.40034350752830505, -0.2499142587184906, -0.08070144802331924, 0.12594211101531982, -0.30258163809776306, -0.6716402173042297, -0.3449687063694, -0.6502798795700073, -0.501506507396698, -0.5080655217170715, -1.234123945236206, 0.5603669881820679, 0.11432380229234695, -0.17787547409534454, 0.15780001878738403, -0.1437285840511322, -0.780595600605011, 0.2307015061378479, -0.026071352884173393, 0.8535099029541016, -1.1520596742630005, 0.43875330686569214, 0.9810512661933899, -0.3408474028110504, -0.26810240745544434, 0.23368249833583832, -0.38158583641052246, -0.6610352396965027, 1.066003680229187, 0.12332112342119217, 0.2851637005805969, 0.08292103558778763, -0.09109748899936676, -0.7685847282409668, 1.015358328819275, 0.028580643236637115, -0.6947493553161621, -0.21820540726184845, 0.19858023524284363, 0.6471981406211853, -0.26302534341812134, 0.1287451982498169, 0.3929697275161743, 0.28507041931152344, 0.24671576917171478, -0.3956107199192047, -0.37865355610847473, 0.06348345428705215, -0.14112044870853424, 0.5389637351036072, -0.394823282957077, 0.8164867162704468, -0.06961565464735031, -0.06422673165798187, -0.10751159489154816, 0.8265071511268616, 0.3616098463535309, 0.7050861716270447, 0.14670564234256744, 0.6663902997970581, 0.4908198416233063, -0.6073011755943298, 0.17741024494171143, -0.5376771688461304, 0.8464912176132202, 0.7361412644386292, -0.16451142728328705, 0.5820345282554626, 0.3583909273147583, -0.3226757049560547, 0.7763935923576355, 0.9667121767997742, -0.28553712368011475, 1.0230573415756226, 0.2249545454978943, -0.0005480051622726023, -0.34870705008506775, -0.046017128974199295, -0.774986982345581, 0.253316193819046, 0.7287156581878662, -0.08833640813827515, -0.6529619097709656, 0.3106677532196045, -0.30795392394065857, 0.2374151200056076, -0.5159247517585754, 0.827713131904602, -0.33305254578590393, -0.5171536803245544, 0.20853562653064728, -0.25572896003723145, 0.6290579438209534, -0.5430909395217896, -0.1649356633424759, -0.39927938580513, 0.019204270094633102, -0.099014513194561, -1.1886203289031982, 0.45356830954551697, -0.1843218207359314, -0.41369760036468506, -0.23091436922550201, 0.5196067690849304, -0.6795632243156433, -0.5241298675537109, 0.09440954774618149, 0.48977068066596985, -0.036107566207647324, 0.6638668179512024, -0.624503493309021, 0.047420576214790344, -0.18346592783927917, 0.4080267548561096, 0.2768596112728119, 0.7416995167732239, -0.07442499697208405, 0.6309100389480591, 0.34974098205566406, -0.18996350467205048, -0.05227458477020264, -0.017686571925878525, 0.9972147345542908, -0.6446352601051331, -0.5901880264282227, -0.6803415417671204, 0.4126753807067871, -0.12731623649597168, -0.34922710061073303, 0.6691844463348389, 0.6848517656326294, 1.0847302675247192, -0.04307033494114876, 0.3931153416633606, 0.053917430341243744, 0.2877945899963379, -0.4162314534187317, 0.3713603913784027, -0.4434412121772766, 0.530116081237793, -0.32881706953048706, -0.8250214457511902, -0.04966454952955246, 0.5595022439956665, -0.3042764961719513, -0.10505155473947525, 0.4580828547477722, 0.49921536445617676, -0.23191943764686584, 0.09485779702663422, 0.010993794538080692, -0.25523126125335693, 0.08385616540908813, 0.3950178027153015, 1.0195273160934448, -0.324607253074646, 0.033899836242198944, -0.04948340356349945, -0.11671718955039978, -0.1383412629365921, -0.363250195980072, -0.8551849722862244, -0.6112197041511536, -0.9110432267189026, -0.23281386494636536, 0.4086969792842865, 0.5108910202980042, 0.5650079250335693, -0.7997145056724548, -0.1191723570227623, -0.19779495894908905, 0.5231589078903198, -0.1446792036294937, -0.3353044390678406, 0.6840687394142151, -0.33340194821357727, -0.659530758857727, 0.003858316456899047, 0.12363488972187042, -0.00408938666805625, -0.25008103251457214, 0.38025540113449097, -0.035519711673259735, 0.10164225101470947, 0.5206659436225891, -0.0035359764005988836, -0.6524201035499573, -0.30499428510665894, 0.038133442401885986, 0.11122661083936691, 0.013424406759440899, 1.1826726198196411, -0.9279266595840454, 0.437145471572876, 0.576341986656189, 0.8736019134521484, 0.321073442697525, -0.13681082427501678, 0.31853774189949036, -0.6968955397605896, 0.07285312563180923, 0.17025816440582275, 0.06828273832798004, 0.38814157247543335, -0.1638597995042801, 0.587644100189209, 0.4350590705871582, -0.40741029381752014, -0.9449412822723389, 0.22067752480506897, -0.7098827362060547, -0.29758420586586, 0.444327712059021, -0.10838762670755386, 0.23916304111480713, -0.4297102391719818, 0.12349937111139297, 0.38075849413871765, -0.14540357887744904, 1.12128746509552, 0.8146103620529175, -0.20161132514476776, 0.14993537962436676, -0.2519686222076416, -0.17683468759059906, 0.3759404122829437, -0.7527557611465454, -0.2790674865245819, 0.11376618593931198, 0.3784545660018921, 0.43082180619239807, -0.09201298654079437, -0.06847827881574631, 0.06641602516174316, -0.1597830206155777, -0.22639763355255127, 0.2889866530895233, -0.3429619371891022, 0.06295932829380035, 0.1313755363225937, -0.5377320647239685, -0.4221557378768921 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06900v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06900v3	Can LLMs Recognize Toxicity? Definition-Based Toxicity Metric	2024-02-10T07:55:27	2024-06-18T04:35:12	Hyukhun Koh, Dohyung Kim, Minwoo Lee, Kyomin Jung	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	In the pursuit of developing Large Language Models (LLMs) that adhere to societal standards, it is imperative to detect the toxicity in the generated text. The majority of existing toxicity metrics rely on encoder models trained on specific toxicity datasets, which are susceptible to out-of-distribution (OOD) problems and depend on the dataset's definition of toxicity. In this paper, we introduce a robust metric grounded on LLMs to flexibly measure toxicity according to the given definition. We first analyze the toxicity factors, followed by an examination of the intrinsic toxic attributes of LLMs to ascertain their suitability as evaluators. Finally, we evaluate the performance of our metric with detailed analysis. Our empirical results demonstrate outstanding performance in measuring toxicity within verified factors, improving on conventional metrics by 12 points in the F1 score. Our findings also indicate that upstream toxicity significantly influences downstream metrics, suggesting that LLMs are unsuitable for toxicity evaluations within unverified factors.	[ 0.04668918997049332, -0.5148526430130005, 0.9924686551094055, 0.1963600516319275, -0.19297441840171814, -0.07474770396947861, -0.17598947882652283, -0.36325201392173767, -0.04063785821199417, 0.48257017135620117, -0.345641553401947, -0.7352411150932312, -0.7384604811668396, 0.391990602016449, -0.2763126492500305, 1.0878260135650635, 0.05650082603096962, -0.04074884206056595, -0.5712397694587708, -0.4807281792163849, -0.259304404258728, -0.48199424147605896, -0.592053234577179, -0.41444098949432373, 1.0641874074935913, 0.4279175102710724, 0.5885754823684692, 0.670854389667511, 0.5711283683776855, 0.3795977532863617, -0.6380839943885803, 0.03460239619016647, -0.5352925062179565, 0.2343004047870636, -0.4380699098110199, -0.4917716681957245, -0.5548372268676758, 0.021810928359627724, 0.5065755248069763, 0.4400356709957123, -0.15718349814414978, 0.32912206649780273, 0.23463818430900574, 0.5211755633354187, -0.8245835900306702, -0.01926785334944725, -0.7632111310958862, 0.1472260057926178, -0.19913285970687866, -0.31341004371643066, -0.5839638113975525, -0.4420899450778961, -0.19956114888191223, -0.3106987476348877, -0.572961151599884, -0.2070494443178177, 0.5636023283004761, 0.48647037148475647, -0.6971814036369324, -0.7501248717308044, -0.5950554013252258, 0.8788203597068787, -0.8992711901664734, 0.3056170642375946, 0.06010041385889053, 0.19311200082302094, -0.18969503045082092, -0.5438496470451355, -0.2987610101699829, -0.39926353096961975, -0.12474353611469269, 0.08055148273706436, 0.17517708241939545, -0.022554127499461174, 0.043352141976356506, 0.3350992500782013, -0.3072044253349304, 0.3811618983745575, -0.06087232008576393, -0.4229097068309784, 0.6304717659950256, 0.6288085579872131, 0.3161761462688446, -0.23410733044147491, -0.5849422812461853, 0.3262954354286194, -0.8974471092224121, -0.24955356121063232, 0.3702141344547272, 0.24628908932209015, 0.044641196727752686, 0.504007875919342, 0.17196479439735413, 0.20067596435546875, -0.29080572724342346, -0.25505489110946655, 0.20374412834644318, -0.3066006004810333, -0.07673832029104233, -0.10096793621778488, 0.9770742654800415, 0.39297619462013245, 0.009186876006424427, -0.04095858708024025, -0.2620391249656677, -0.04639245942234993, 0.2940075099468231, -0.9818522334098816, -0.14979152381420135, 0.3651023507118225, -0.5165020823478699, -0.6861914396286011, -0.42321833968162537, -0.9021191596984863, -0.9238216876983643, 0.30023738741874695, 0.524387001991272, -0.13139855861663818, -0.35709869861602783, -0.011648988351225853, -0.08992281556129456, -0.01386232953518629, -0.059083715081214905, -0.537060558795929, 0.08026563376188278, 0.44842034578323364, 1.1094759702682495, -0.28687629103660583, 0.16135618090629578, -0.5497450232505798, -0.0035660206340253353, -0.35403046011924744, 0.8403305411338806, -0.4692060947418213, -0.41373032331466675, -0.09044505655765533, -0.15278011560440063, 0.2197936773300171, -0.9509680271148682, 0.8839370012283325, -0.3219582438468933, -0.059159863740205765, -0.4637783169746399, -0.41793256998062134, -0.014841091819107533, 0.43831831216812134, -0.4354933202266693, 0.9258286952972412, 0.2621268033981323, -0.965944230556488, 0.5776106119155884, -0.47053441405296326, -0.2030772864818573, 0.10899142920970917, 0.2813470661640167, -0.44324207305908203, 0.0698767825961113, -0.22256186604499817, 0.3836597204208374, -0.14531676471233368, 0.24293871223926544, -0.7680737376213074, -0.406472384929657, 0.400336354970932, -0.5460712909698486, 0.7350016832351685, 0.33733463287353516, 0.026317277923226357, 0.4413730204105377, -0.7940686941146851, 0.004589448682963848, -0.05167913809418678, -0.89241623878479, -0.48780137300491333, 0.37883231043815613, 0.03667408227920532, 0.21923109889030457, 0.004831061698496342, -0.6539301872253418, -0.41985079646110535, -0.18039336800575256, 0.6621893644332886, 0.8511548638343811, 0.14794379472732544, 0.2970482409000397, -0.38437798619270325, 0.22932425141334534, 0.02216685377061367, 0.1790699064731598, 0.088106170296669, -0.1938665509223938, -0.8239498734474182, -0.40013769268989563, -0.08058290928602219, 0.38818982243537903, -0.41890478134155273, 0.9068700671195984, -0.4157680571079254, -0.8561945557594299, -0.07850491255521774, 0.15749919414520264, 0.37894782423973083, 0.5835187435150146, 0.19609089195728302, -0.42369845509529114, -0.31917187571525574, -0.35277241468429565, -0.33024513721466064, -0.5245369076728821, -0.1246287152171135, 0.5400407910346985, 0.5113469958305359, -0.41049590706825256, 0.6782833933830261, -0.33820563554763794, -0.5923274159431458, -0.08075422793626785, -0.03138832002878189, 0.1267109364271164, 0.01110271830111742, 0.43351542949676514, -0.12205979228019714, -0.5081058740615845, 0.04443584382534027, -0.946235179901123, -0.5394977331161499, 0.09327398240566254, -0.1446046680212021, -0.15887907147407532, 0.6949626207351685, -0.19902820885181427, -0.07198585569858551, 0.509080171585083, -0.3977836072444916, 0.5606130361557007, -0.29948246479034424, -0.19595427811145782, -0.5525926351547241, 0.16431543231010437, 0.18818002939224243, -0.21541674435138702, -0.45983874797821045, 0.1270708590745926, 0.03513301908969879, 0.300898939371109, -0.8143634796142578, 0.4826222360134125, -0.16635820269584656, 0.0724535807967186, -0.054669130593538284, 0.20825228095054626, 0.1591969132423401, 0.07320670783519745, 0.003002412850037217, 0.5285419225692749, 0.36057397723197937, -0.7148993015289307, 0.4956684708595276, 0.18242183327674866, -0.3288419842720032, 0.8818941712379456, -0.5897252559661865, -0.08531717211008072, -0.17742635309696198, 0.29435819387435913, -0.9571202397346497, -0.20040127635002136, 0.31600746512413025, -0.2835179567337036, 0.031271934509277344, -0.123878113925457, -0.55052250623703, -0.21579380333423615, -0.19914112985134125, 0.39721813797950745, 0.5121083855628967, -0.5076907873153687, 0.3881852626800537, 0.46319201588630676, -0.12598684430122375, -0.21953418850898743, -0.8417997360229492, -0.07805171608924866, -0.845684289932251, -0.36101409792900085, -0.27879631519317627, -0.21680746972560883, -0.2256876677274704, -0.09139091521501541, -0.07780257612466812, -0.1569323092699051, 0.17197906970977783, 0.2952480614185333, -0.061559539288282394, -0.23383378982543945, 0.27609947323799133, 0.01584329828619957, -0.07614453136920929, 0.6833260655403137, 0.2911570072174072, 0.16027286648750305, -0.03366430848836899, -0.30362099409103394, -0.13120731711387634, 0.05993473529815674, 1.0260860919952393, -0.140189066529274, 0.6273232698440552, 0.23812474310398102, -0.19652803242206573, -0.39004847407341003, -0.07997754216194153, 0.18366402387619019, -0.5668305158615112, 0.5854329466819763, 0.21528159081935883, -0.43094465136528015, 0.729480504989624, -0.29636168479919434, -0.19524644315242767, 0.32770803570747375, 0.6823951005935669, 0.0816369578242302, 1.0891335010528564, 0.43375924229621887, -0.11015059798955917, 0.23033080995082855, 0.13093790411949158, 0.019503863528370857, -0.8593982458114624, -0.35395142436027527, -0.4161794185638428, -0.16832216084003448, -0.5099978446960449, -0.22670380771160126, 0.8380919694900513, -0.23568502068519592, -0.8192200660705566, -0.11380667984485626, -0.297837495803833, 0.5557098984718323, -0.06149659678339958, 0.38252609968185425, 0.3823864161968231, -0.22885762155056, -0.28022581338882446, -0.026752717792987823, -0.46322309970855713, -0.7914424538612366, 0.8941782116889954, 0.9659960865974426, 0.7779090404510498, 0.12427088618278503, 0.575153112411499, 0.14868775010108948, 1.1147264242172241, -1.0226258039474487, 0.5527217984199524, -0.11029569804668427, -0.8935399055480957, -0.16986720263957977, -0.7330809235572815, -0.3025641441345215, 0.13397353887557983, -0.10898547619581223, -0.6035205721855164, -0.023528175428509712, -0.040690645575523376, -0.23351170122623444, 0.44277188181877136, -0.6200013160705566, 0.9883952736854553, -0.5353996753692627, -0.3305811285972595, -0.037283606827259064, -0.2228429764509201, 0.38236966729164124, -0.3067282438278198, 0.6301655769348145, -0.5243856310844421, -0.3665734827518463, 0.43988558650016785, -0.5419245958328247, 0.7561776638031006, -0.22707252204418182, -0.4812380373477936, 0.4931202530860901, 0.16452819108963013, 0.17510007321834564, 0.10175950825214386, -0.37169167399406433, 0.2423069328069687, -0.027661118656396866, -0.15120086073875427, -0.351529061794281, 0.7965607047080994, -0.46519744396209717, -0.08574820309877396, -0.48882195353507996, -0.3524799048900604, -0.3273870646953583, 0.30074870586395264, 0.3902857303619385, -0.01808852143585682, -0.2330932319164276, -0.012630222365260124, 0.5263158082962036, -0.7465276122093201, 0.286806583404541, 0.6795442700386047, -0.08666792511940002, -0.3108598291873932, 1.1671396493911743, -0.07267531007528305, 0.5408903360366821, 0.0014657559804618359, 0.7021450400352478, -0.4484183192253113, -0.6806852221488953, -0.30949950218200684, 0.17562472820281982, -1.10893714427948, -0.45746877789497375, -0.24110332131385803, -0.4798777997493744, 0.3381890654563904, 0.07813306897878647, -0.4305106997489929, 0.5405927300453186, -0.4415965676307678, -0.28941452503204346, 0.3553468585014343, 1.037983775138855, -0.06711199879646301, 0.13031616806983948, -1.069039225578308, -0.17189235985279083, 0.06156914681196213, 1.0130469799041748, 0.00181804527528584, -0.6831008791923523, 0.09087416529655457, 0.12705104053020477, -0.3298886716365814, -1.038576364517212, 0.4735868573188782, 0.4151574969291687, 0.5768610239028931, 0.8492760062217712, 0.3523043692111969, 0.30841493606567383, -0.3245983421802521, 0.7100324034690857, -0.04301445186138153, -1.0150415897369385, 0.4131411015987396, -0.4021797180175781, -0.19030223786830902, 0.48962998390197754, 0.5765043497085571, -0.4946557283401489, -0.8765668869018555, 0.04537535086274147, -0.8102400302886963, 0.35717374086380005, 0.06577551364898682, 0.5294859409332275, -0.3970206081867218, 0.3392978608608246, 0.11019551008939743, -0.131416916847229, -0.9182093739509583, -0.11097293347120285, 0.04046125337481499, -0.33813273906707764, -0.11235042661428452, -0.5789137482643127, 0.09758602827787399, -0.1767444759607315, 0.4606466591358185, 0.08568151295185089, -0.0907263532280922, -0.0065191350877285, -0.12617520987987518, -0.38276633620262146, 0.5392187833786011, 0.17815180122852325, 0.2708839178085327, -0.5024538040161133, 0.30048516392707825, 0.19543349742889404, -0.6209294199943542, 0.42649585008621216, -0.4331618547439575, -0.15702110528945923, -0.20940907299518585, 0.4165966808795929, 0.1622447818517685, 0.1997164636850357, -1.0838508605957031, 0.6906945705413818, 0.03745277225971222, -0.16234423220157623, -0.04875732213258743, 0.06553202122449875, 0.09363864362239838, 0.10584938526153564, -0.10741870850324631, -0.055318742990493774, 0.2359546422958374, -0.7026912569999695, 0.262597918510437, 0.46499326825141907, -0.9260883331298828, -0.13143588602542877, 0.7078031301498413, 0.604590654373169, 0.14954592287540436, 0.4991442561149597, -0.3784056007862091, -0.4833756685256958, 0.5035184621810913, 0.41257593035697937, 0.6941114664077759, -0.07138636708259583, 0.19902005791664124, 0.478613942861557, 0.2760751247406006, 0.09681589156389236, 0.2967968285083771, 0.4008461534976959, -0.8067358136177063, -0.3040987551212311, -0.8804970383644104, -0.20472656190395355, 0.33146101236343384, -0.6717525720596313, 0.20123006403446198, -0.5956241488456726, -0.21648217737674713, -0.03128392621874809, -0.30875417590141296, -0.24624601006507874, 0.032590221613645554, 0.18888458609580994, 0.9832635521888733, -1.3327354192733765, 0.26301607489585876, 0.6373555064201355, -0.45565661787986755, -0.5253754258155823, -0.09353730082511902, 0.19332480430603027, -0.5539219379425049, 0.4610747992992401, 0.35503828525543213, 0.0607483871281147, -0.15374736487865448, -0.34849217534065247, -0.6249657869338989, 1.0482765436172485, 0.3821036219596863, -0.18008725345134735, 0.23345567286014557, 0.2364904284477234, 0.9754764437675476, -0.15007592737674713, 0.6043353080749512, 0.6039084196090698, 0.46701300144195557, 0.2832249701023102, -0.8670275211334229, 0.35554027557373047, -0.1976555734872818, -0.005060877650976181, 0.05311376228928566, -0.5734811425209045, 0.5302830338478088, -0.287416011095047, -0.5251199007034302, 0.20007681846618652, 0.3107197880744934, -0.019606366753578186, 0.5197144746780396, 0.46712255477905273, 0.4229350984096527, 0.6296812295913696, 0.023388415575027466, 0.744908332824707, -0.0035969563759863377, 0.3846634030342102, 0.7537326216697693, -0.44208961725234985, 1.0234605073928833, 0.2566635012626648, -0.2700226306915283, 0.5910890698432922, 0.7243576645851135, 0.16023871302604675, 0.6274903416633606, 0.49250996112823486, -0.3780900239944458, -0.3585830628871918, -0.45183491706848145, -0.004663866478949785, 0.3872959017753601, 0.6403009295463562, -0.645486056804657, -0.3923121988773346, -0.11925791949033737, -0.07255399227142334, 0.2847282290458679, -0.6242330074310303, 0.8868274092674255, 0.19260603189468384, -0.4134845435619354, 0.5335839986801147, -0.10752598941326141, 0.8125544786453247, -0.4032245874404907, 0.15328028798103333, -0.26336756348609924, 0.4466087222099304, -0.4281546473503113, -1.0817738771438599, 0.7629178762435913, -0.01449507288634777, 0.31083163619041443, -0.15892209112644196, 0.7603073120117188, -0.3347766101360321, -0.3618556261062622, 0.4953325688838959, 0.5800451636314392, 0.15394195914268494, -0.26729172468185425, -0.24314981698989868, 0.11870001256465912, -0.5117740035057068, 0.028515812009572983, 0.3608630895614624, 0.65407395362854, 0.11137852817773819, 1.0283749103546143, 0.25754714012145996, 0.2486640214920044, 0.054365288466215134, -0.11134003847837448, 0.8574386239051819, -0.4041646122932434, -0.14344875514507294, -0.8575827479362488, 0.6538149118423462, 0.20592929422855377, -0.2388945370912552, 0.5872033834457397, 0.36023572087287903, 0.6269022822380066, 0.12560710310935974, 0.6994114518165588, 0.07616794109344482, 0.47661882638931274, -0.3701798617839813, 1.0612616539001465, -0.6000344753265381, 0.5834454894065857, -0.10523118823766708, -0.7842962741851807, -0.28183457255363464, 0.5482402443885803, -0.04084759205579758, 0.1294434517621994, 0.5554196238517761, 0.847888171672821, 0.07486969232559204, -0.3552035689353943, 0.17964760959148407, 0.43763989210128784, 0.3455091118812561, 0.8510299921035767, 1.2180205583572388, 0.08836393803358078, 0.8194964528083801, 0.0329660139977932, -0.3084922730922699, -0.27651074528694153, -1.3564718961715698, -0.9722311496734619, -0.2589561939239502, -0.2681126892566681, -0.5585994124412537, -0.02790668047964573, 0.45218735933303833, 0.35248345136642456, -0.6927257180213928, 0.04110773652791977, -0.25982940196990967, 0.4884227514266968, -0.07695045322179794, -0.2556746006011963, -0.15640676021575928, -0.30997464060783386, -0.292330265045166, 0.051609545946121216, 0.33197835087776184, -0.1495739370584488, -0.47228482365608215, -0.3013177812099457, 0.34920886158943176, 0.32674267888069153, 0.7791664600372314, 0.08561178296804428, -0.48785313963890076, -0.73403400182724, -0.15212754905223846, -0.48754435777664185, -0.11456602811813354, 0.5418412685394287, -0.4006141722202301, 0.4508652687072754, 0.5697859525680542, 0.2007535845041275, -0.3162810504436493, -0.19613289833068848, 0.43126386404037476, -0.8293728828430176, -0.26341915130615234, 0.417437344789505, 0.23823267221450806, 0.42733579874038696, -0.4966030716896057, 0.3105252683162689, 0.0956362783908844, -0.6192875504493713, -0.859962522983551, 0.2895263731479645, -0.7560785412788391, 0.034923914819955826, 1.7490886449813843, -0.34263816475868225, -0.09217730164527893, -0.29697367548942566, 0.014172251336276531, 0.020001012831926346, -0.10477748513221741, 0.7589038610458374, 0.6350120902061462, 0.036663539707660675, 0.015349834226071835, -0.5014103651046753, 0.5053175091743469, -0.040988463908433914, -0.9640829563140869, 0.18196238577365875, 0.48724669218063354, 0.8353829979896545, 0.12551578879356384, 0.5988196730613708, -0.4558882415294647, -0.07812248915433884, 0.09439567476511002, -0.44167351722717285, 0.021131902933120728, 0.028196798637509346, -0.1859247088432312, -0.15323278307914734, 0.38797274231910706, 0.05300671234726906 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06894v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06894v2	GenTranslate: Large Language Models are Generative Multilingual Speech and Machine Translators	2024-02-10T07:20:49	2024-05-16T13:17:05	Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Ruizhe Li, Dong Zhang, Zhehuai Chen, Eng Siong Chng	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS	Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have stepped forward the development of multilingual speech and machine translation by its reduced representation errors and incorporated external knowledge. However, both translation tasks typically utilize beam search decoding and top-1 hypothesis selection for inference. These techniques struggle to fully exploit the rich information in the diverse N-best hypotheses, making them less optimal for translation tasks that require a single, high-quality output sequence. In this paper, we propose a new generative paradigm for translation tasks, namely "GenTranslate", which builds upon LLMs to generate better results from the diverse translation versions in N-best list. Leveraging the rich linguistic knowledge and strong reasoning abilities of LLMs, our new paradigm can integrate the rich information in N-best candidates to generate a higher-quality translation result. Furthermore, to support LLM finetuning, we build and release a HypoTranslate dataset that contains over 592K hypotheses-translation pairs in 11 languages. Experiments on various speech and machine translation benchmarks (e.g., FLEURS, CoVoST-2, WMT) demonstrate that our GenTranslate significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art model.	[ -0.32590895891189575, -0.29585009813308716, 0.4893360137939453, 0.2075662612915039, -0.3325859606266022, 0.3298714756965637, -0.362515926361084, -0.07139506191015244, 0.12938913702964783, 0.4411092698574066, -0.4022965431213379, -0.5313007235527039, -0.9016748070716858, 0.2624928057193756, -0.8886694312095642, 0.771928608417511, 0.08293615281581879, 0.04646170511841774, -0.16157706081867218, 0.06612160056829453, -0.010222087614238262, -0.18793778121471405, -0.5527284145355225, -0.5060355067253113, 0.4001774191856384, 0.1289067566394806, 0.8166772723197937, 0.6261652112007141, 0.4577963352203369, 0.27767348289489746, -0.33130380511283875, 0.4063202738761902, -0.47593557834625244, 0.4780845642089844, -0.23433567583560944, -0.40468934178352356, -0.47665393352508545, -0.14310652017593384, 0.6357011198997498, 0.6655263900756836, -0.15034589171409607, 0.3450380861759186, 0.12508945167064667, 0.2580786943435669, -0.3753123879432678, 0.12053698301315308, -0.6026428937911987, 0.014081859029829502, -0.3110811114311218, -0.2963130474090576, -0.7025540471076965, -0.5257040858268738, -0.2593252658843994, -0.6928408741950989, 0.34606969356536865, 0.028543241322040558, 0.6350820064544678, 0.4181373417377472, -0.4072738587856293, 0.08777026832103729, -0.8306246399879456, 0.6064277291297913, -0.9635306000709534, 0.6138225197792053, 0.3504043221473694, 0.2400701642036438, -0.15424180030822754, -0.5694357752799988, -0.4111749827861786, -0.06883616000413895, 0.1121804267168045, -0.09438148885965347, -0.1894170492887497, -0.1940104216337204, 0.10997606068849564, 0.3675752878189087, -0.808228611946106, 0.32378172874450684, -0.20444127917289734, -0.2706507444381714, 0.5114190578460693, -0.0833030641078949, 0.295344740152359, -0.10354336351156235, -0.3016035258769989, -0.3636317551136017, -0.854482889175415, -0.5110114812850952, -0.002953492570668459, 0.3973979949951172, -0.14261162281036377, 0.5481529831886292, -0.33535972237586975, 0.7002411484718323, -0.03247414156794548, -0.3423915207386017, 0.5283228158950806, -0.45069625973701477, -0.24603061378002167, 0.023601317778229713, 0.8481419086456299, 0.16578467190265656, 0.1506015658378601, -0.3402850031852722, -0.13468173146247864, -0.05568167194724083, -0.20771963894367218, -0.747404158115387, 0.10413649678230286, 0.14502203464508057, -0.35476428270339966, -0.2291867583990097, -0.2675068974494934, -0.9407802820205688, -0.2950998544692993, -0.24333174526691437, 0.09261468052864075, -0.46654757857322693, -0.28370538353919983, 0.18719936907291412, -0.11297674477100372, 0.16883045434951782, 0.2562409043312073, -0.8519355058670044, -0.14584225416183472, 0.5353811979293823, 0.7377278208732605, -0.23631565272808075, -0.4528319537639618, -0.8735993504524231, 0.3072386085987091, -0.5273510813713074, 0.7173072695732117, -0.23294207453727722, -0.0799424946308136, 0.20452797412872314, -0.1616474837064743, 0.05440768226981163, -0.5547172427177429, 0.5587033033370972, -0.4007313549518585, 0.2105448693037033, -0.2355019599199295, -0.4583507180213928, 0.09518270939588547, 0.07133946567773819, -0.5216299295425415, 0.7084436416625977, 0.25163882970809937, -0.20330265164375305, 0.36931392550468445, -0.29688867926597595, -0.7099941372871399, 0.46768900752067566, 0.13567349314689636, -0.1753586381673813, 0.18744763731956482, 0.44082680344581604, 0.4756962060928345, -0.6677754521369934, 0.6301634907722473, 0.01660565286874771, 0.0593501552939415, 0.20124860107898712, -0.35761669278144836, 0.6851283311843872, 0.6910043954849243, -0.2048448771238327, 0.12437913566827774, -0.3321535885334015, -0.032617583870887756, 0.3308473527431488, -0.5172334909439087, -0.15438887476921082, -0.07333920896053314, -0.04980345815420151, 0.35288891196250916, 0.1275888830423355, -0.6603459715843201, 0.16865067183971405, -0.3833864629268646, 0.7299615740776062, 0.399871289730072, -0.4059126377105713, 0.5837944746017456, -0.12065716832876205, 0.6989363431930542, -0.07395299524068832, -0.03798256069421768, -0.10272252559661865, -0.613176167011261, -0.5448178052902222, -0.12118427455425262, 0.4352823495864868, 0.5745953917503357, -1.1601396799087524, 0.20760942995548248, -0.7910670638084412, -0.19984525442123413, -0.9010639190673828, 0.4673446714878082, 0.34837210178375244, 0.15921708941459656, 0.536723792552948, 0.013784654438495636, -0.447861909866333, -0.7517704963684082, -0.2239845097064972, 0.09873954951763153, -0.11800309270620346, -0.567444384098053, 0.1529712826013565, -0.24847067892551422, 0.456116646528244, -0.2416084259748459, -0.26344573497772217, -0.7363786101341248, 0.1727401614189148, 0.1146179586648941, 0.3634245991706848, 0.3906729817390442, -0.6732621788978577, -0.28743651509284973, 0.17205668985843658, -0.6684869527816772, -0.15596185624599457, -0.1446785181760788, -0.33433544635772705, -0.045667894184589386, 0.625139057636261, -0.7966335415840149, -0.0814289003610611, 0.8772951364517212, -0.21581800282001495, -0.007397376466542482, -0.05951198562979698, 0.08228500187397003, -1.345642328262329, -0.06521926820278168, -0.062050167471170425, -0.34618017077445984, -0.7798636555671692, 0.39764124155044556, 0.14581608772277832, -0.04453287273645401, -0.5125813484191895, 0.5116141438484192, -0.3570716381072998, -0.14194244146347046, -0.17583279311656952, 0.2348056137561798, 0.00604688236489892, 0.11463207751512527, -0.2586365044116974, 0.8044168949127197, 0.1225578561425209, -0.4260405898094177, 0.5325673818588257, 0.7287986278533936, -0.38339269161224365, 0.3023059368133545, -0.2714087963104248, -0.02213442511856556, -0.3155220150947571, 0.2652433514595032, -0.8993529081344604, -0.36919623613357544, 0.049014244228601456, -0.5590489506721497, 0.5246027708053589, -0.1247486099600792, -0.6781075596809387, -0.47658810019493103, 0.1564425677061081, 0.38182803988456726, 0.7380449771881104, -0.6296342015266418, 0.5180745720863342, 0.12253785133361816, -0.38139623403549194, -0.30359941720962524, -0.9153501987457275, 0.47098538279533386, -0.1581796407699585, -0.5727515816688538, 0.4640577733516693, 0.06797585636377335, -0.047578372061252594, -0.12651748955249786, 0.04034021124243736, 0.20034092664718628, -0.042693525552749634, -0.18206755816936493, 0.22255654633045197, -0.320507287979126, 0.10185718536376953, 0.12776294350624084, -0.29079487919807434, -0.20049013197422028, -0.5496267080307007, 0.8702362775802612, 0.23247963190078735, -0.31140652298927307, -0.25411614775657654, 0.480371356010437, 0.8498063683509827, -0.7383522391319275, 0.5682978630065918, 0.7515540719032288, -0.17240113019943237, -0.2849867045879364, -0.6437228918075562, -0.10892248898744583, -0.38067367672920227, 0.48316019773483276, -0.45272526144981384, -0.8987540602684021, 0.20152901113033295, -0.25024864077568054, 0.13112987577915192, 0.6280757784843445, 0.6613165736198425, 0.06475528329610825, 1.0942941904067993, 0.24826544523239136, -0.22554746270179749, 0.2738594114780426, -0.2453303188085556, 0.3921828269958496, -0.748984694480896, -0.1146465316414833, -0.6306774020195007, -0.20113608241081238, -0.6338063478469849, -0.6999748945236206, 0.2403641641139984, -0.13558562099933624, -0.08246742188930511, 0.6477033495903015, -0.35091304779052734, 0.0965806320309639, 0.6487318277359009, -0.15434010326862335, 0.43143656849861145, 0.2898489832878113, -0.040883298963308334, 0.14906534552574158, -0.8098225593566895, -0.32413744926452637, 1.0401114225387573, 0.22402508556842804, 0.6547354459762573, 0.30013594031333923, 0.6802853941917419, 0.007237639278173447, 0.4183536767959595, -0.5678018927574158, 0.5957003235816956, -0.6145652532577515, -0.5930470824241638, -0.36230117082595825, -0.6632411479949951, -0.9669807553291321, 0.46642738580703735, -0.2534833252429962, -0.19021975994110107, 0.029544588178396225, 0.07787791639566422, -0.20317751169204712, 0.37879154086112976, -0.34110963344573975, 0.7492673993110657, -0.4095834791660309, -0.3513486683368683, -0.1136544719338417, -0.5619552135467529, 0.35732921957969666, 0.0160769522190094, 0.42146772146224976, -0.195073202252388, 0.20961077511310577, 0.46796736121177673, 0.12670260667800903, 0.5178587436676025, 0.010671241208910942, -0.38640832901000977, -0.035661619156599045, 0.32494139671325684, 0.5410320162773132, -0.4274057149887085, -0.1881316602230072, 0.12599502503871918, -0.19791211187839508, -0.32703012228012085, -0.39567500352859497, 0.4556543827056885, -0.5087460875511169, -0.49852171540260315, -0.15547606348991394, -0.6997737288475037, -0.10589874535799026, 0.2640332877635956, 0.5578415989875793, 0.25452855229377747, -0.0909978523850441, 0.25328415632247925, 0.7310945987701416, -0.36025452613830566, 0.2886495888233185, 0.2830778658390045, -0.4613485038280487, -0.4399280846118927, 0.9590232968330383, -0.1513618379831314, 0.7747818231582642, 0.5920950174331665, 0.10622835159301758, -0.37874412536621094, -0.8437830805778503, -0.7550359964370728, 0.29885244369506836, -0.6749992370605469, -0.3890211582183838, -0.5181757211685181, -0.33677878975868225, -0.7150138020515442, 0.0026673662941902876, -0.4032188355922699, -0.2435605227947235, 0.07274790853261948, -0.18211990594863892, 0.010003103874623775, 0.38704895973205566, -0.16855894029140472, 0.17209875583648682, -0.699205756187439, 0.6773509383201599, 0.3103191554546356, -0.01077224686741829, -0.3285192847251892, -0.6895094513893127, -0.13014179468154907, 0.1427995264530182, -0.1831607073545456, -0.8414794206619263, 0.8602423071861267, 0.3088683485984802, 0.7440166473388672, 0.20140890777111053, -0.15414932370185852, 0.45012572407722473, -0.4802757501602173, 0.5135937333106995, 0.39097508788108826, -0.8322234749794006, 0.3941380977630615, -0.3370104134082794, 0.4610282778739929, 0.44453859329223633, 0.2938542366027832, -0.7642894983291626, -0.5627332329750061, -0.1576784998178482, -0.7939890623092651, 0.3170948624610901, 0.17182642221450806, 0.10894712060689926, -0.07972728461027145, 0.08662287145853043, 0.18566033244132996, 0.270335853099823, -0.579459011554718, 0.04786774888634682, -0.13296405971050262, -0.4053509831428528, -0.5189984440803528, -0.16834791004657745, -0.10765218734741211, -0.3202440142631531, 0.5435444712638855, -0.3068315386772156, 0.37023910880088806, -0.018623996526002884, -0.2813720107078552, -0.3223421573638916, 0.6128297448158264, 0.6654477715492249, 0.5217944979667664, -0.05053514614701271, 0.449118971824646, 0.03696296736598015, -0.1610257923603058, 0.45150303840637207, 0.29881057143211365, -0.5053349733352661, 0.08004689961671829, 0.49196574091911316, 0.839194118976593, 0.03913317993283272, -0.4378798305988312, 0.35022488236427307, 0.3677200973033905, -0.3923041820526123, -0.006836137268692255, -0.17935022711753845, 0.39363035559654236, 0.21250827610492706, 0.2858108580112457, 0.1225913017988205, 0.04544627293944359, -0.5199384689331055, 0.09536759555339813, 0.38221225142478943, 0.12091414630413055, -0.04121160879731178, 0.9738966226577759, 0.18855291604995728, -0.2292468100786209, 0.6268252730369568, -0.5688524842262268, -0.5259695649147034, 0.32043173909187317, 0.644732654094696, 0.8575873374938965, -0.6550682187080383, 0.4488213062286377, 0.5052047371864319, 0.5314057469367981, -0.48563387989997864, 0.1020158901810646, 0.21621137857437134, -0.742504358291626, -1.0563311576843262, -0.6896690130233765, -0.07968004047870636, 0.07650721818208694, -0.5578216910362244, -0.0786481499671936, 0.07564704120159149, -0.13793250918388367, -0.08337961882352829, -0.6672073006629944, -0.7717205286026001, -0.1374628245830536, 0.5923534035682678, 0.6968953609466553, -0.8925755620002747, 0.9973376393318176, 0.3298768699169159, -0.3216135501861572, -0.4323594570159912, -0.09873687475919724, -0.029890546575188637, -0.9031713604927063, 0.7755493521690369, -0.23021714389324188, -0.008442416787147522, 0.23740151524543762, -0.5199827551841736, -1.2363301515579224, 0.9231205582618713, 0.8344666957855225, -0.7064744234085083, -0.28156471252441406, 0.4665096402168274, 0.36601945757865906, -0.33768612146377563, -0.1628575474023819, 0.5210830569267273, 0.6107174158096313, 0.2853063642978668, -1.0282034873962402, 0.2384873777627945, -0.0858958512544632, 0.14243966341018677, 0.36659687757492065, -0.3500548005104065, 0.7824593186378479, -0.20430618524551392, -0.22405070066452026, 0.2696675956249237, 0.5176754593849182, 0.10333297401666641, 0.1287248283624649, 0.23823443055152893, 0.6910144686698914, 0.5293819308280945, -0.2896743416786194, 1.1371183395385742, -0.1239681988954544, 0.20161834359169006, 1.1617116928100586, -0.12810276448726654, 0.9058261513710022, 0.5184175372123718, -0.0951191633939743, 0.19256792962551117, 0.42888548970222473, -0.04563448205590248, 0.5488622188568115, 0.3280375897884369, -0.07668888568878174, -0.612460732460022, -0.1275242418050766, -0.34160593152046204, 0.4574102461338043, 0.41163212060928345, -0.5433304905891418, -0.346350759267807, 0.2793288826942444, 0.08008099347352982, 0.08748602867126465, -0.030699938535690308, 0.6099573373794556, 0.20722222328186035, -0.7923832535743713, 0.8089198470115662, 0.11926539987325668, 0.6413096785545349, -0.5002889037132263, 0.022411081939935684, -0.4770612418651581, 0.01537125464528799, -0.06255394220352173, -0.6325861811637878, 0.02345418743789196, -0.13036800920963287, 0.10976563394069672, -0.788243293762207, 0.3761068880558014, -0.7904199361801147, -0.5574790835380554, 0.28999876976013184, 0.8415133953094482, 0.09666275233030319, -0.0018904089229181409, -0.31223246455192566, 0.04693688824772835, 0.13932231068611145, -0.03518559783697128, 0.2825772762298584, 0.28192955255508423, 0.06603874266147614, 0.7549596428871155, 0.6827290654182434, 0.42264023423194885, 0.33506888151168823, 0.20046350359916687, 0.5718177556991577, -0.5398448705673218, -0.301615446805954, -0.778096079826355, 0.35137060284614563, -0.05149751156568527, -0.3154461085796356, 0.6836860775947571, 0.527525782585144, 0.7853610515594482, -0.03167354315519333, 0.7683243155479431, 0.0893721729516983, 0.4919497072696686, -0.6158438324928284, 0.45297694206237793, -0.4251210689544678, -0.029231160879135132, -0.19074445962905884, -0.9456782937049866, -0.33365240693092346, 0.4337005019187927, -0.15232758224010468, -0.20740845799446106, 0.6515491008758545, 0.509686291217804, -0.04661565274000168, -0.17362116277217865, 0.4553447961807251, 0.24767562747001648, 0.44239312410354614, 0.7526640892028809, 0.8571922779083252, -0.3854425549507141, 0.5843434929847717, -0.003549223765730858, -0.01431660819798708, -0.2696329355239868, -0.70609450340271, -0.5946912169456482, -0.6332520246505737, -0.3668211102485657, -0.32764774560928345, -0.0015177931636571884, 0.9500791430473328, 0.7300165891647339, -0.755160927772522, -0.2170657366514206, 0.050477661192417145, -0.08419214189052582, -0.3521203398704529, -0.12307040393352509, 0.06694111973047256, -0.4529302418231964, -0.6921418309211731, 0.8347914218902588, 0.09218091517686844, 0.21976082026958466, -0.3077681064605713, -0.20228612422943115, -0.1552732139825821, -0.26947346329689026, 0.8872464299201965, 0.07256537675857544, -0.8434709906578064, -0.04734787717461586, 0.07955216616392136, -0.21220986545085907, 0.08943256735801697, 0.7119944095611572, -0.5016923546791077, 0.42668256163597107, 0.665457010269165, 0.8861231803894043, 0.870186448097229, -0.14188414812088013, 0.6712519526481628, -0.32765325903892517, 0.15755407512187958, 0.22394146025180817, 0.32176241278648376, 0.6059953570365906, -0.09165546298027039, 0.49597418308258057, 0.05773467198014259, -0.26733946800231934, -0.694358766078949, 0.3293679356575012, -0.6975343823432922, -0.31821441650390625, 1.43129563331604, 0.052395351231098175, -0.059265438467264175, 0.04998369142413139, 0.1817362904548645, 0.40672293305397034, -0.2743002772331238, 0.41267499327659607, 0.514394223690033, 0.362277626991272, -0.3204287588596344, -1.0713777542114258, 0.40260711312294006, 0.5560199022293091, -0.7342252731323242, 0.057925645262002945, 0.4549259841442108, 0.26014548540115356, 0.205341637134552, 0.29787197709083557, -0.10578478872776031, 0.006697051227092743, -0.14181740581989288, 0.3279432952404022, -0.01590312458574772, -0.22910109162330627, -0.10919854044914246, 0.33707594871520996, 0.2596339285373688, -0.14366880059242249 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07950v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07950v1	Sentinels of the Stream: Unleashing Large Language Models for Dynamic Packet Classification in Software Defined Networks -- Position Paper	2024-02-10T04:47:58	2024-02-10T04:47:58	Shariq Murtuza	cs.CR	cs.CR, cs.CL	With the release of OpenAI's ChatGPT, the field of large language models (LLM) saw an increase of academic interest in GPT based chat assistants. In the next few months multiple accesible large language models were released that included Meta's LLama models and Mistral AI's Mistral and Mixtral MoE models. These models are available openly for a wide array of purposes with a wide spectrum of licenses. These LLMs have found their use in a different number of fields like code development, SQL generation etc. In this work we propose our plan to explore the applicability of large language model in the domain of network security. We plan to create Sentinel, a LLM, to analyse network packet contents and pass a judgment on it's threat level. This work is a preliminary report that will lay our plan for our future endeavors.	[ -0.44723668694496155, -0.8024017214775085, 0.30846649408340454, -0.05993635207414627, -0.24399957060813904, 0.16049639880657196, 0.26171156764030457, -0.664735734462738, 0.4428223967552185, 0.7970719933509827, -0.3170498013496399, -0.1664164513349533, -0.9854187965393066, -0.14935600757598877, -1.020140290260315, 0.8420745134353638, 0.10072191804647446, -0.19272878766059875, 0.46159783005714417, 0.10419093072414398, -0.3841351866722107, -0.6827194094657898, -0.9474763870239258, -0.14662058651447296, 0.5057684183120728, -0.14101551473140717, 0.6427347660064697, 0.36387932300567627, 0.8547583818435669, 0.41750410199165344, -0.5358566641807556, -0.10062414407730103, -0.37282851338386536, 0.37139829993247986, -0.3356117904186249, -0.3263426423072815, -0.4616216719150543, 0.0015465996693819761, 0.7793022394180298, 0.37164434790611267, -0.13257843255996704, 0.09378327429294586, -0.13911160826683044, 0.6168856024742126, -0.5008023381233215, 0.28867340087890625, -0.9378454685211182, 0.10765478014945984, -0.4684118330478668, -0.03395051509141922, -0.573356032371521, 0.15157192945480347, 0.31886741518974304, -0.07566294819116592, -0.12569686770439148, -0.16475284099578857, 0.5789094567298889, 0.33008018136024475, -0.543098509311676, -0.2897621691226959, -0.9790584444999695, 0.4415718615055084, -0.6327297687530518, 0.13580431044101715, -0.04311696067452431, 0.7857495546340942, -0.4023704528808594, -1.1340851783752441, -0.4709100127220154, -0.08417525887489319, 0.41642722487449646, 0.09419719874858856, -0.47714531421661377, 0.20715771615505219, -0.031947966665029526, 0.42285287380218506, -0.2443685382604599, 0.4581511616706848, -0.5926715135574341, 0.04871552437543869, 0.8511908054351807, 0.34152984619140625, 0.014704899862408638, 0.25867095589637756, -0.3317599892616272, 0.1991686373949051, -0.7123032212257385, -0.17653577029705048, 0.41059359908103943, 0.3949331045150757, -0.0007411010446958244, 0.49901247024536133, -0.3229767978191376, 0.9676546454429626, -0.4216787815093994, 0.052167948335409164, 0.08143194019794464, -0.08935651928186417, -0.4395328164100647, -0.06619361788034439, 0.7169332504272461, -0.04644046723842621, -0.13637089729309082, 0.1030198186635971, -0.3706344962120056, 0.1382683366537094, 0.5841490626335144, -0.6499187350273132, -0.3411524295806885, 0.2682896852493286, -0.5659758448600769, -0.7897365093231201, 0.20056283473968506, -0.8326250910758972, -0.8108524084091187, -0.024436933919787407, 0.19885611534118652, -0.002381778322160244, -0.6466684341430664, 0.26239895820617676, -0.020004339516162872, 0.32711294293403625, 0.3919796347618103, -0.4353945255279541, 0.1436648815870285, 0.9262902736663818, 0.9054376482963562, -0.07509315758943558, -0.1305638551712036, -0.6211682558059692, -0.06773050874471664, -0.1382359266281128, 0.5525397658348083, -0.43180081248283386, -0.31543418765068054, 0.3402574062347412, -0.12458702176809311, 0.02215895988047123, -0.21521861851215363, 0.5476682186126709, -0.9423807859420776, -0.17408336699008942, 0.23838704824447632, -0.6531991362571716, -0.19332660734653473, 0.16706542670726776, -0.6338503360748291, 0.4269557297229767, 0.053211163729429245, -0.7351826429367065, -0.11255375295877457, -0.8495648503303528, 0.002577885054051876, 0.5035286545753479, -0.08273061364889145, -0.20179276168346405, 0.06495218724012375, -0.11540050059556961, 0.7616174221038818, -0.2681831419467926, 0.24519287049770355, -0.34026920795440674, -0.10812961310148239, 0.4508891999721527, -0.5696411728858948, 0.8809854984283447, 0.7826509475708008, -0.03801915794610977, 0.16015461087226868, -0.44279831647872925, -0.18294842541217804, 0.08367452770471573, -0.2817462980747223, 0.023280564695596695, 0.4761192798614502, -0.13063517212867737, 0.1156853511929512, -0.03758770599961281, -0.794325053691864, -0.0034840842708945274, -0.13811877369880676, 0.8131372928619385, 0.8478818535804749, -0.006367835216224194, 0.1321789026260376, -0.04324584826827049, 0.6303432583808899, 0.1593804508447647, 0.5223796963691711, -0.3166563808917999, -0.6569568514823914, -0.6015904545783997, -0.6495819091796875, 0.18910422921180725, 0.5141433477401733, -0.8440675139427185, 0.3283751904964447, -0.30911147594451904, -0.7333804368972778, -0.4224795997142792, 0.014501295983791351, 0.17569899559020996, 0.39294424653053284, -0.10392572730779648, -0.1424039602279663, -0.5862778425216675, -0.6079413294792175, 0.10992966592311859, -0.4182039201259613, 0.17941613495349884, -0.11509914696216583, 0.369194358587265, -0.5656322240829468, 0.8181381225585938, -0.7783433794975281, -0.4645862281322479, -0.32324832677841187, -0.1354418396949768, 0.2678743004798889, 0.15495361387729645, 0.7552658319473267, -0.7986034154891968, -0.371427446603775, -0.05098126456141472, -0.7191578149795532, -0.0705956369638443, 0.232268288731575, 0.1704329252243042, -0.054782506078481674, 0.7683603167533875, -0.3190762400627136, 0.5181898474693298, 0.8800384402275085, -0.3520858585834503, 0.630838930606842, -0.05755101144313812, -0.4617616534233093, -1.0120038986206055, -0.30417904257774353, -0.04612234607338905, -0.3785594403743744, -0.8736149668693542, 0.814183235168457, -0.3633697032928467, -0.6859824061393738, -0.7582035660743713, 0.5977813601493835, -0.0774310901761055, 0.15190184116363525, -0.5175614953041077, -0.04934683069586754, -0.32744506001472473, -0.03725998103618622, 0.043606121093034744, 0.7328258752822876, 0.9431318640708923, -0.696449875831604, 0.941565215587616, 0.10559944063425064, -0.2791397273540497, 0.4250413179397583, -0.786220371723175, -0.07608233392238617, -0.07115387171506882, 0.47836142778396606, -1.0873241424560547, -0.11782166361808777, 0.24840259552001953, -0.19755768775939941, 0.15317058563232422, -0.4111649990081787, -0.4304507374763489, -0.6371302604675293, -0.05232860520482063, 0.10377375036478043, 0.6038411855697632, -0.6020700335502625, 0.479093462228775, 0.8607938289642334, 0.07135073095560074, -0.31174764037132263, -0.6241678595542908, 0.3389665186405182, -0.4114944338798523, -0.7550005316734314, 0.05731627345085144, 0.16818077862262726, -0.42254701256752014, -0.26882800459861755, 0.15236134827136993, -0.2476544976234436, 0.31194573640823364, 0.42588236927986145, 0.19061896204948425, -0.2942923605442047, 0.04520360752940178, -0.43797510862350464, -0.06441324949264526, 0.3187064230442047, -0.6666935086250305, 0.5146549344062805, -0.48215731978416443, -0.4375505745410919, -0.420438289642334, 0.26731574535369873, 0.4392716884613037, -0.4887724816799164, 0.8783730864524841, 0.6119807958602905, 0.00811168272048235, -0.1050916314125061, -0.38166651129722595, 0.07631465792655945, -0.5986772179603577, 0.3874625861644745, -0.2460727095603943, -1.1126114130020142, 0.700186550617218, -0.2675122022628784, 0.09825108200311661, 0.3894181251525879, 0.28524067997932434, -0.13604436814785004, 0.5824059844017029, 0.6415821313858032, -0.3646920919418335, 0.7931759357452393, -0.43507567048072815, 0.3511425852775574, -0.8749547600746155, 0.1908191740512848, -0.49514245986938477, -0.15507987141609192, -0.7078150510787964, -0.16755257546901703, 0.475265234708786, -0.18605707585811615, -0.12854254245758057, 0.17488011717796326, -0.48768362402915955, 0.3267427980899811, 0.09001479297876358, -0.026590216904878616, 0.03757595270872116, -0.06452961266040802, 0.012847423553466797, 0.4656682014465332, -0.4897494614124298, -0.5274710655212402, 1.1862902641296387, 0.9197004437446594, 0.6123406291007996, 0.462078720331192, 0.6560906767845154, 0.5701965093612671, 0.27416911721229553, -0.6553454399108887, 0.7212992906570435, -0.3034176230430603, -0.7690861821174622, -0.5694338083267212, -0.3281574547290802, -1.183517575263977, 0.42698314785957336, 0.013333749957382679, -0.9708892107009888, -0.15956704318523407, -0.018030960112810135, -0.10102865099906921, 0.6458932757377625, -0.5040169358253479, 0.4010862112045288, 0.04654553532600403, 0.16184739768505096, -0.019031433388590813, -0.4368758797645569, 0.6519461870193481, -0.33356502652168274, 0.07136846333742142, -0.14782483875751495, -0.0057308487594127655, 0.6189783215522766, -0.7250738739967346, 0.9809004068374634, -0.31396111845970154, -0.36500465869903564, 0.6856043934822083, 0.10215757042169571, 0.6351646780967712, 0.18603640794754028, -0.19674889743328094, 0.32310423254966736, -0.026482071727514267, -0.2778843939304352, -0.37579360604286194, 0.6432293653488159, -0.7636062502861023, -0.7178420424461365, -0.6526427865028381, -0.18181771039962769, 0.20746497809886932, 0.2448834627866745, 0.04408002272248268, 0.3949410915374756, -0.10840444266796112, 0.14363229274749756, 1.0114153623580933, -0.028499353677034378, 0.6610122323036194, 0.5915563106536865, -0.6401689052581787, -0.22503288090229034, 0.726618230342865, -0.04590538144111633, 0.26664042472839355, 0.4139615595340729, 0.08592607825994492, -0.12601396441459656, -0.9785598516464233, -0.06379099935293198, 0.06656388938426971, -0.6748591661453247, -0.2533881366252899, -0.4953613579273224, -0.9257404208183289, -0.3522339165210724, 0.02280239202082157, -0.4155169427394867, -0.20161475241184235, -0.25465840101242065, -0.11445913463830948, 0.45283010601997375, 0.8672078251838684, 0.22307322919368744, 1.1070863008499146, -0.7508336305618286, -0.13987481594085693, 0.2412106692790985, 0.37511134147644043, 0.08832890540361404, -0.677823543548584, 0.02445276826620102, -0.08932981640100479, -0.671890914440155, -0.8633906245231628, 0.642089307308197, 0.10909097641706467, 0.6327135562896729, 0.8372819423675537, 0.021431127563118935, 0.24203352630138397, -0.30524972081184387, 0.9561306834220886, 0.25885748863220215, -0.8293206691741943, 0.4816933572292328, -0.5785160660743713, 0.11481344699859619, 0.09072567522525787, 0.13662710785865784, -0.60414719581604, -0.4114450514316559, -0.5086026191711426, -0.6516844034194946, 0.344560444355011, 0.13288845121860504, 0.41440674662590027, -0.04788616672158241, 0.2910529375076294, -0.20307070016860962, 0.1481640785932541, -0.47858208417892456, -0.02503846399486065, -0.10132972151041031, 0.18571950495243073, -0.2789577841758728, -0.3184947967529297, 0.025619029998779297, -0.06932871788740158, 0.47728797793388367, -0.05960196256637573, 0.6087937355041504, -0.15531021356582642, 0.2964872121810913, 0.28154924511909485, 0.138383150100708, 0.6806302070617676, 0.634043276309967, -0.010028829798102379, 0.2159689962863922, 0.15045900642871857, -0.7678976655006409, 0.16278868913650513, -0.1699153482913971, -0.3351496458053589, 0.1858007162809372, 0.394405335187912, 0.8265911936759949, -0.23263324797153473, -0.5292946696281433, 0.5941674113273621, -0.021280521526932716, -0.13776469230651855, -0.9021620154380798, 0.31844061613082886, 0.007951035164296627, 0.3568653166294098, 0.26959797739982605, -0.2192685604095459, -0.07019903510808945, -0.5530825853347778, 0.028147557750344276, 0.6492094397544861, -0.43073391914367676, -0.2342684268951416, 0.5530067086219788, 0.3681720197200775, -0.38279932737350464, 0.8501612544059753, -0.2288023829460144, -0.5361968278884888, 0.3204605281352997, 0.37089189887046814, 1.0088787078857422, -0.48597559332847595, 0.2845396399497986, -0.13907213509082794, 0.3479168117046356, 0.04589570686221123, 0.39113426208496094, 0.3766700029373169, -0.7410931587219238, -0.3160932958126068, -0.7269151210784912, -0.09173997491598129, 0.5551405549049377, -0.2930223345756531, 0.3483964204788208, -0.6878719925880432, -0.4745674133300781, 0.32895851135253906, -0.08478248119354248, -0.540520966053009, -0.12073245644569397, 0.226247638463974, 1.3730415105819702, -0.988766074180603, 1.026179552078247, 0.5874979496002197, -0.3213077187538147, -0.4555014669895172, -0.2527657449245453, 0.1678929477930069, -0.6015607118606567, 0.9479641914367676, -0.22938764095306396, 0.044716786593198776, -0.14405769109725952, -0.5182264447212219, -0.9989160895347595, 1.0736663341522217, 0.045858342200517654, -0.35236111283302307, -0.01768454723060131, 0.3028185963630676, 0.6357856392860413, -0.544348418712616, 0.22197727859020233, 0.08679309487342834, 0.21270303428173065, 0.37113407254219055, -0.9198150038719177, -0.36389100551605225, -0.08573856204748154, 0.3721000850200653, 0.3275146484375, -0.795446515083313, 1.0585302114486694, 0.14377820491790771, 0.14260759949684143, -0.15084245800971985, 0.8972097635269165, -0.10099127143621445, 0.07354310899972916, 0.29265064001083374, 0.3849889039993286, 0.667805016040802, -0.012103679589927197, 0.9414588809013367, 0.13984686136245728, -0.015622248873114586, 0.9809157252311707, -0.4912964701652527, 1.0360544919967651, 0.4663413465023041, -0.23786792159080505, 0.1954982578754425, 0.44226527214050293, -0.16464972496032715, 0.45379403233528137, 0.5222725868225098, -0.4907022714614868, 0.2028784304857254, -0.01193472370505333, -0.20721539855003357, 0.7653177380561829, 0.6656185388565063, -0.4811781048774719, -0.24286122620105743, 0.0478927381336689, 0.027599778026342392, -0.19471292197704315, -0.7141264081001282, 0.6866238117218018, 0.2953052818775177, -0.2463596612215042, 0.5206989645957947, 0.3623609244823456, 0.5938749313354492, -0.7222504615783691, 0.3706274926662445, -0.02865448407828808, 0.4176974594593048, -0.010542172938585281, -1.0833697319030762, 0.7708941698074341, 0.16481006145477295, 0.23194175958633423, -0.021722985431551933, 0.663600742816925, 0.23028221726417542, -0.34744948148727417, 0.2532911002635956, 0.0903678759932518, 0.48180875182151794, -0.23603512346744537, -0.6101416945457458, 0.46188971400260925, -0.2955932915210724, 0.027803892269730568, 0.521466076374054, 0.40115198493003845, -0.07024015486240387, 1.0766977071762085, 0.5154455304145813, 0.44321098923683167, 0.4114960730075836, -0.2953394651412964, 0.9424479603767395, -0.10052435845136642, -0.6661315560340881, -0.755158007144928, 0.21576988697052002, -0.14797233045101166, -0.20039528608322144, 0.5493925213813782, 0.3652765154838562, 0.7351163029670715, -0.2109169065952301, 0.8705074787139893, 0.08058077096939087, 0.2866612672805786, -0.43629226088523865, 0.8193826079368591, -0.20951402187347412, 0.43360769748687744, -0.21491077542304993, -0.8793289065361023, -0.03757759556174278, 0.15232282876968384, -0.12571202218532562, -0.35256052017211914, 0.46573200821876526, 0.5299080610275269, -0.0903681293129921, 0.2570040225982666, 0.32490038871765137, 0.04249649494886398, 0.8907649517059326, 0.38448992371559143, 0.8510311841964722, -0.31664377450942993, 0.33958351612091064, 0.11915294826030731, -0.4447304308414459, -0.3919493854045868, -1.1179059743881226, -0.8509305119514465, -0.7126544713973999, -0.48451653122901917, -0.38796472549438477, 0.15932555496692657, 0.5158894658088684, 0.5799614787101746, -0.7484650015830994, -0.3105379343032837, -0.09024183452129364, -0.02491126023232937, -0.15381141006946564, -0.12177614867687225, 0.0979834645986557, -0.30035361647605896, -0.2637137472629547, 0.23244990408420563, 0.06342719495296478, 0.30673763155937195, -0.7817200422286987, -0.0002979370183311403, -0.24873298406600952, 0.2523982524871826, 0.758977472782135, 0.35033372044563293, -0.7317528128623962, -0.11714337021112442, -0.38814103603363037, -0.0019375418778508902, -0.4875180125236511, 0.5796173214912415, -0.4491293430328369, 0.16391253471374512, 0.754712700843811, 0.7787343859672546, 0.23061230778694153, -0.37808170914649963, 0.462341845035553, -0.6217498183250427, 0.3734455108642578, 0.028636088594794273, 0.4467228055000305, -0.04738020896911621, -0.3790600001811981, 0.6096552014350891, 0.022808851674199104, -0.6790327429771423, -1.001142978668213, 0.6970513463020325, -0.8559972047805786, -0.26656556129455566, 1.1292121410369873, -0.5180947780609131, -0.19978852570056915, -0.0507657416164875, -0.048651471734046936, 0.10147212445735931, -0.08019033819437027, 0.7971548438072205, 0.6195306777954102, 0.11198905855417252, -0.24538639187812805, -0.704118549823761, 0.45439764857292175, -0.3240678012371063, -0.653043270111084, 0.17991697788238525, 0.10656385868787766, 0.07965763658285141, 0.19974538683891296, 0.5583975315093994, -0.20164629817008972, -0.28080472350120544, -0.04186500608921051, -0.2598583698272705, -0.2900131046772003, -0.5249439477920532, -0.5350223779678345, 0.07159160077571869, 0.19595198333263397, -0.37359708547592163 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06853v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06853v2	History, Development, and Principles of Large Language Models-An Introductory Survey	2024-02-10T01:18:15	2024-06-12T02:28:12	Zhibo Chu, Shiwen Ni, Zichong Wang, Xi Feng, Min Yang, Wenbin Zhang	cs.CL	cs.CL	Language models serve as a cornerstone in natural language processing (NLP), utilizing mathematical methods to generalize language laws and knowledge for prediction and generation. Over extensive research spanning decades, language modeling has progressed from initial statistical language models (SLMs) to the contemporary landscape of large language models (LLMs). Notably, the swift evolution of LLMs has reached the ability to process, understand, and generate human-level text. Nevertheless, despite the significant advantages that LLMs offer in improving both work and personal lives, the limited understanding among general practitioners about the background and principles of these models hampers their full potential. Notably, most LLMs reviews focus on specific aspects and utilize specialized language, posing a challenge for practitioners lacking relevant background knowledge. In light of this, this survey aims to present a comprehensible overview of LLMs to assist a broader audience. It strives to facilitate a comprehensive understanding by exploring the historical background of language models and tracing their evolution over time. The survey further investigates the factors influencing the development of LLMs, emphasizing key contributions. Additionally, it concentrates on elucidating the underlying principles of LLMs, equipping audiences with essential theoretical knowledge. The survey also highlights the limitations of existing work and points out promising future directions.	[ -0.43719762563705444, -0.753693699836731, 0.7435716986656189, -0.1444532871246338, -0.035042840987443924, 0.00849927682429552, -0.4355851709842682, -0.40504735708236694, -0.07724986970424652, 0.879146933555603, -0.40696457028388977, -0.49129462242126465, -0.5790518522262573, 0.04349913075566292, -0.5009160041809082, 0.9249162077903748, 0.12333816289901733, 0.12182566523551941, -0.049492090940475464, -0.03967452421784401, -0.23434916138648987, -0.6901094317436218, -0.5560871362686157, -0.43076059222221375, 0.3175646960735321, 0.08363665640354156, 0.6222907900810242, 0.5317539572715759, 0.43967145681381226, 0.26245298981666565, -0.6117051839828491, -0.004989024717360735, -0.5426169037818909, 0.21577394008636475, -0.10275963693857193, -0.49486640095710754, -0.2287023663520813, -0.14384037256240845, 0.9197831153869629, 1.2755844593048096, -0.18650275468826294, 0.11563573777675629, 0.2500401437282562, 0.8312163949012756, -0.5235615968704224, 0.15884976089000702, -0.5262494087219238, 0.027428440749645233, -0.28234145045280457, -0.2559923529624939, -0.424808144569397, -0.3483813405036926, 0.3307736814022064, -0.18096984922885895, 0.2581418454647064, -0.020743656903505325, 0.28224125504493713, -0.28933340311050415, -0.6781079173088074, -0.6085624098777771, -1.0191484689712524, 0.9595681428909302, -0.770987868309021, 0.4160282015800476, 0.30666065216064453, 0.24043570458889008, -0.22284267842769623, -0.6636857390403748, -0.2847185730934143, -0.4324811100959778, 0.03979678079485893, -0.38151904940605164, -0.01563669554889202, 0.07875849306583405, 0.22414954006671906, 0.44757410883903503, -0.6222741007804871, 0.4566532075405121, -0.3976667523384094, -0.09231990575790405, 0.6382795572280884, 0.4990540146827698, 0.355805367231369, -0.04561125859618187, -0.18766573071479797, 0.28491172194480896, -1.1170204877853394, 0.0010686881141737103, 0.20394445955753326, 0.2046756148338318, -0.1528531163930893, 0.5149028897285461, -0.12044175714254379, 0.7763867974281311, -0.34839576482772827, -0.37315255403518677, -0.061454661190509796, -0.4945104122161865, -0.2617824375629425, -0.39904752373695374, 0.7348566055297852, 0.19281017780303955, 0.3834565579891205, -0.10388687998056412, -0.14875955879688263, -0.2514662444591522, 0.0882640928030014, -0.5590354800224304, 0.25371888279914856, -0.04865393042564392, -0.4932388961315155, -0.15482471883296967, -0.18916776776313782, -0.7109107375144958, -0.4719034731388092, -0.5084564089775085, -0.1647377461194992, -0.11453880369663239, -0.3268420994281769, 0.18484748899936676, 0.19581393897533417, 0.42858394980430603, 0.5715999603271484, -1.062557339668274, 0.6131080985069275, 0.9663525223731995, 0.7448897361755371, -0.14141127467155457, -0.18629609048366547, 0.12437856942415237, 0.11501076817512512, -0.5018762946128845, 0.5838358402252197, -0.3856378495693207, -0.6273765563964844, 0.5529299378395081, -0.020788101479411125, 0.29224157333374023, -0.4604403078556061, 0.4451883137226105, -0.6875522136688232, 0.26288118958473206, -0.12481309473514557, -0.7136765718460083, -0.18204326927661896, 0.38730138540267944, -0.5415416359901428, 0.6544246077537537, -0.09429984539747238, -0.5954006314277649, 0.10571525990962982, -0.5647837519645691, -0.3207395076751709, 0.1900947093963623, -0.2558934688568115, -0.06492231041193008, 0.4605216383934021, 0.03970131650567055, 0.5433979034423828, -0.7854729294776917, 0.3998764455318451, -0.2917483448982239, -0.05454239621758461, 0.20013071596622467, -0.3640493154525757, 0.8737689852714539, 0.3007931411266327, -0.03287596255540848, -0.043368760496377945, -0.6110129356384277, -0.1917305737733841, 0.26676446199417114, -0.33222025632858276, -0.29049503803253174, 0.2706450819969177, -0.06179562956094742, 0.02135639823973179, 0.17379789054393768, -0.12038399279117584, 0.2994110584259033, -0.36924073100090027, 0.5552388429641724, 0.5487812161445618, 0.07642930001020432, 0.6278120279312134, -0.2132621556520462, 0.7163885235786438, -0.38663122057914734, 0.05336540564894676, -0.5872554779052734, -0.36428675055503845, -0.5864953398704529, 0.2172755002975464, 0.11113955825567245, 0.2904924154281616, -0.2176678329706192, 0.23007258772850037, -0.29361656308174133, -0.38925859332084656, -0.10423137992620468, 0.5008596181869507, 0.12917572259902954, 0.14138436317443848, -0.012199155054986477, -0.0861191675066948, -0.6428574919700623, -0.9317485094070435, -0.07113933563232422, -0.27869465947151184, 0.00596070010215044, 0.28640732169151306, 0.4270295202732086, -0.20555554330348969, 0.8866266012191772, -0.5133042931556702, 0.007153552956879139, -0.6077792644500732, -0.1545933485031128, 0.26914453506469727, 0.2165905088186264, 0.6476563215255737, -0.5741510391235352, -0.2716841697692871, -0.07088962942361832, -0.5971639156341553, -0.1401439905166626, 0.20279288291931152, 0.09458067268133163, 0.18619404733181, 0.5388846397399902, -0.6127776503562927, 0.18748582899570465, 0.7902072668075562, -0.13411319255828857, 0.6949175596237183, -0.08953672647476196, -0.1412292718887329, -1.1457805633544922, 0.06963876634836197, 0.2638741135597229, -0.15887345373630524, -0.8573287725448608, 0.23502270877361298, -0.13193732500076294, -0.1392057090997696, -0.3260544538497925, 0.6947423815727234, -0.6948981285095215, -0.02834843285381794, -0.4601019024848938, 0.17978759109973907, -0.24101391434669495, 0.036958273500204086, 0.18975116312503815, 0.32179462909698486, 0.5372517108917236, -0.8001731634140015, 0.2593998610973358, 0.08899363875389099, -0.417114794254303, 0.3144824802875519, -0.5982053875923157, 0.09016939997673035, -0.21610595285892487, 0.1585129052400589, -0.9861540794372559, -0.10450389236211777, -0.06019613891839981, -0.269224613904953, 0.5085698962211609, -0.3029913306236267, -0.5031358599662781, -0.35917147994041443, -0.05753963068127632, 0.25396865606307983, 0.7816036343574524, -0.18306151032447815, 0.32413655519485474, 0.6707420945167542, -0.6089555621147156, -0.4383624792098999, -0.6155120730400085, 0.2561042010784149, -0.17417563498020172, -0.6174787878990173, -0.03449031338095665, -0.09954977035522461, -0.8243985772132874, -0.4251609444618225, 0.0788314938545227, -0.13496030867099762, 0.1360241025686264, -0.07874652743339539, 0.18915805220603943, -0.4183966815471649, 0.3184783458709717, -0.2611844539642334, -0.018886130303144455, 0.34760943055152893, -0.19283968210220337, 0.7412288784980774, -0.006631720811128616, -0.35093340277671814, -0.2147350311279297, 0.23326998949050903, 0.5656533241271973, -0.012294742278754711, 0.6577667593955994, 0.1036219447851181, -0.3720322549343109, -0.36724376678466797, -0.7587053775787354, -0.1726531982421875, -0.40389788150787354, 0.5271161198616028, -0.017493367195129395, -1.1832633018493652, 0.4365713894367218, -0.18512874841690063, 0.21291561424732208, 0.50346839427948, 0.7734796404838562, 0.03850782662630081, 0.7507484555244446, 0.9303921461105347, -0.2916051149368286, 0.4343591630458832, -0.08629071712493896, 0.02858525887131691, -0.853926420211792, -0.16223055124282837, -0.7905510067939758, -0.01778259500861168, -0.6672895550727844, -0.3248123824596405, 0.2301008701324463, 0.10081368684768677, -0.13849718868732452, -0.004072574898600578, -0.12137386947870255, 0.250702440738678, 0.09563662111759186, -0.2416805773973465, 0.4180205464363098, 0.014559962786734104, 0.02646123804152012, -0.16421182453632355, -0.4295954406261444, -0.9254190921783447, 1.234187126159668, 0.667209804058075, 1.1020359992980957, 0.3296637237071991, 0.5125649571418762, 0.260019987821579, 0.26377248764038086, -0.6407521963119507, 0.6526880860328674, -0.026197094470262527, -0.7680663466453552, -0.35175830125808716, -0.28686317801475525, -0.9371013641357422, 0.26437610387802124, 0.03642410784959793, -0.7759311199188232, -0.0788617804646492, 0.22607481479644775, -0.07194387167692184, 0.31029781699180603, -0.401326060295105, 0.4744967520236969, -0.2751397490501404, -0.299543559551239, -0.2626667022705078, -0.6587793827056885, 0.7258779406547546, -0.1610264927148819, 0.6177417635917664, -0.12567318975925446, -0.18442381918430328, 0.6149638891220093, -0.27087655663490295, 1.0279003381729126, 0.05215277150273323, -0.47094056010246277, 0.5077899694442749, 0.19222749769687653, 0.43559062480926514, 0.0020378429908305407, 0.013871011324226856, -0.037362437695264816, -0.15797944366931915, -0.0950881838798523, -0.3995857238769531, 0.6783192753791809, -0.46275919675827026, -0.7076634764671326, -0.2941950559616089, -0.5932096838951111, -0.32296088337898254, 0.18794716894626617, -0.14192861318588257, 0.3966488242149353, -0.4636859595775604, 0.49031099677085876, 0.7712858319282532, -0.1977151781320572, 0.5214991569519043, 0.7093936800956726, -0.7340372800827026, -0.22117756307125092, 0.4094601273536682, -0.0032941640820354223, 0.4077584743499756, 0.47322043776512146, 0.3759400248527527, -0.39036789536476135, -0.9234719276428223, -0.0036830902099609375, 0.42933720350265503, -0.7601277232170105, 0.2502613365650177, -0.650501549243927, -0.14655105769634247, -0.6061268448829651, -0.000019251645426265895, -0.2166181355714798, -0.23720882833003998, -0.40131673216819763, 0.1118127629160881, 0.10093597322702408, 1.222028374671936, 0.11640486121177673, 0.36882397532463074, -0.6875138878822327, 0.2308623194694519, 0.24560582637786865, 0.2098185271024704, 0.07620981335639954, -0.6699947714805603, -0.13739897310733795, 0.06777843832969666, -0.23710718750953674, -0.9036084413528442, 0.36514410376548767, 0.03469982370734215, 0.8355672359466553, 0.437480092048645, -0.27225109934806824, 0.3852199912071228, -0.621147871017456, 0.9874916076660156, 0.18884973227977753, -0.7394202947616577, 0.3512103259563446, -0.38878586888313293, 0.1585162729024887, 0.14284780621528625, 0.5553873181343079, -0.7168411612510681, -0.1104983538389206, -0.37955936789512634, -0.7460353970527649, 0.5292665362358093, -0.013316940516233444, 0.29422175884246826, 0.16459845006465912, 0.4067520499229431, 0.07627743482589722, 0.2845243811607361, -0.8153968453407288, -0.16109803318977356, 0.3650781512260437, -0.05819471925497055, -0.4277498424053192, -0.5325812101364136, 0.0888863354921341, -0.07872650027275085, 0.569538414478302, -0.0404500775039196, -0.03860759735107422, -0.18449322879314423, -0.3345785140991211, -0.02035565860569477, 0.687025785446167, 0.9158638119697571, 1.0841221809387207, 0.05116873234510422, 0.09094789624214172, 0.23862935602664948, -0.40771883726119995, 0.16316179931163788, -0.11696381121873856, -0.36206167936325073, -0.03969629853963852, 0.4810628294944763, 0.782446563243866, 0.32055848836898804, -0.7223609685897827, 0.2713165879249573, 0.18021917343139648, -0.11520860344171524, -0.43282848596572876, -0.10298136621713638, 0.4008845090866089, 0.12076202780008316, 0.5569013953208923, -0.47616487741470337, -0.12820874154567719, -0.7491610050201416, -0.0727795958518982, 0.6460570693016052, -0.13607171177864075, -0.37621060013771057, 0.3554881513118744, 0.09581907838582993, -0.49459001421928406, 0.32996606826782227, 0.09462883323431015, -0.2841150760650635, 0.41252779960632324, 0.6947883367538452, 0.8436461091041565, -0.16897054016590118, 0.05158677324652672, 0.20341134071350098, 0.42589622735977173, -0.24072511494159698, 0.07064919918775558, 0.0405467264354229, -0.6914923787117004, -0.4438011050224304, -0.9208120107650757, -0.5226307511329651, 0.4126075506210327, -0.5896611213684082, 0.3380494713783264, -0.49648767709732056, -0.22499553859233856, -0.1027788296341896, -0.10389506071805954, -0.7052678465843201, 0.11371172219514847, 0.42330220341682434, 0.8980908393859863, -0.6803613305091858, 0.5172853469848633, 0.6419638395309448, -0.2640535831451416, -0.23346595466136932, -0.17709913849830627, 0.22027529776096344, -0.8620911836624146, 0.7418822050094604, -0.24927300214767456, 0.009631345048546791, 0.041490644216537476, -0.7516686320304871, -0.8413978815078735, 0.7069661021232605, 0.11214251816272736, -0.801810085773468, -0.4565885365009308, 0.2589428722858429, 0.755642831325531, -0.4931458532810211, 0.08873196691274643, 0.5228295922279358, 0.22764064371585846, 0.008079228922724724, -0.8219684958457947, -0.25301122665405273, 0.03226304426789284, 0.3558571934700012, 0.27143698930740356, -0.3617585301399231, 0.8087289333343506, -0.22674614191055298, -0.15599410235881805, 0.3180356025695801, 0.4844453036785126, 0.3109241724014282, 0.05626404285430908, 0.13523054122924805, 0.32776370644569397, 0.3477917015552521, -0.09638267010450363, 1.0141805410385132, -0.418839693069458, 0.32030630111694336, 0.984915018081665, -0.438420832157135, 0.8144649863243103, 0.45242926478385925, -0.5857089757919312, 0.3466338813304901, 0.35479310154914856, 0.08062127232551575, 0.0003662030794657767, 0.482776403427124, -0.3154318034648895, -0.08588845282793045, -0.08105004578828812, -0.48059049248695374, 0.3836783170700073, 0.5727013945579529, -0.7757554650306702, -0.40539371967315674, -0.21446329355239868, -0.024059686809778214, 0.05660438537597656, -0.5555837154388428, 0.8976632356643677, 0.21747279167175293, -0.4949730336666107, 0.19501574337482452, 0.014034315943717957, 0.632301926612854, -0.9791578650474548, 0.11086385697126389, -0.12344041466712952, 0.09508737921714783, 0.042169053107500076, -0.9942607879638672, 0.1921863704919815, 0.10917224735021591, -0.22701315581798553, -0.3013845384120941, 0.6562771201133728, -0.3434654176235199, -0.5182035565376282, 0.07674482464790344, 0.7142218351364136, 0.22450268268585205, 0.2863672971725464, -0.3698512613773346, 0.3657987117767334, -0.13425153493881226, -0.36237502098083496, 0.3711704611778259, 0.2770148813724518, 0.03940529003739357, 0.790919840335846, 0.5245296359062195, 0.243404820561409, 0.21666131913661957, 0.0944434329867363, 0.5820184350013733, -1.0522030591964722, -0.36976343393325806, -1.0304996967315674, 0.417839914560318, 0.18322420120239258, -0.28465235233306885, 0.7800866961479187, 0.4981417953968048, 0.735308825969696, -0.0587780699133873, 1.0017142295837402, 0.18034997582435608, 0.6857435703277588, -0.6392735838890076, 0.6753554940223694, -0.4074597954750061, 0.266286700963974, -0.3173498809337616, -1.0206624269485474, -0.35479187965393066, 0.3543911874294281, -0.28424981236457825, 0.29287782311439514, 0.5262958407402039, 0.442325621843338, 0.3603718876838684, -0.03543635830283165, 0.41162005066871643, 0.231505885720253, 0.4809982180595398, 0.2214352935552597, 0.9755404591560364, -0.00709809735417366, 0.37367674708366394, -0.0540722981095314, 0.0036149867810308933, -0.3006165325641632, -0.9436107873916626, -0.8174623250961304, -0.4312981069087982, -0.23070013523101807, -0.24406698346138, -0.034604985266923904, 0.8731501698493958, 0.49322929978370667, -0.7503871321678162, -0.6606824994087219, -0.13020676374435425, 0.05108729377388954, 0.2587282955646515, -0.18975447118282318, 0.1494872272014618, -0.4293654263019562, -0.7512882947921753, 0.32154127955436707, 0.2784068286418915, 0.32385531067848206, -0.7611989974975586, -0.2455010861158371, -0.16308501362800598, 0.08772703260183334, 0.8690446019172668, 0.5837274789810181, -0.953883707523346, 0.16794610023498535, -0.10319586843252182, -0.1677633374929428, -0.030981922522187233, 1.065834403038025, -0.3776373565196991, 0.3228215277194977, 0.6006752252578735, 0.5693397521972656, 0.22289177775382996, -0.35995012521743774, 0.6371204257011414, -0.4696725010871887, 0.07308384031057358, 0.328691691160202, 0.6888372302055359, 0.4521266520023346, 0.10449359565973282, 0.42940381169319153, 0.36154335737228394, -0.6137587428092957, -1.0389946699142456, 0.4264298379421234, -0.6887399554252625, -0.20008867979049683, 1.287807822227478, 0.2115689069032669, -0.11984322965145111, -0.1469939798116684, -0.14460641145706177, -0.08054280281066895, -0.013042877428233624, 0.45732247829437256, 0.8374881148338318, 0.001607208512723446, -0.4422396421432495, -0.6321018934249878, 0.4009737968444824, 0.11254656314849854, -0.8842288255691528, 0.08032556623220444, 0.6775821447372437, 0.5576350688934326, 0.027537884190678596, 0.6752989888191223, -0.20942239463329315, -0.0910542905330658, -0.26059892773628235, 0.13907597959041595, 0.2938438653945923, -0.23528248071670532, -0.5754293203353882, 0.5272176861763, 0.4787832498550415, 0.3911404311656952 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06852v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06852v2	ChemLLM: A Chemical Large Language Model	2024-02-10T01:11:59	2024-04-25T14:34:28	Di Zhang, Wei Liu, Qian Tan, Jingdan Chen, Hang Yan, Yuliang Yan, Jiatong Li, Weiran Huang, Xiangyu Yue, Wanli Ouyang, Dongzhan Zhou, Shufei Zhang, Mao Su, Han-Sen Zhong, Yuqiang Li	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL	Large language models (LLMs) have made impressive progress in chemistry applications. However, the community lacks an LLM specifically designed for chemistry. The main challenges are two-fold: firstly, most chemical data and scientific knowledge are stored in structured databases, which limits the model's ability to sustain coherent dialogue when used directly. Secondly, there is an absence of objective and fair benchmark that encompass most chemistry tasks. Here, we introduce ChemLLM, a comprehensive framework that features the first LLM dedicated to chemistry. It also includes ChemData, a dataset specifically designed for instruction tuning, and ChemBench, a robust benchmark covering nine essential chemistry tasks. ChemLLM is adept at performing various tasks across chemical disciplines with fluid dialogue interaction. Notably, ChemLLM achieves results comparable to GPT-4 on the core chemical tasks and demonstrates competitive performance with LLMs of similar size in general scenarios. ChemLLM paves a new path for exploration in chemical studies, and our method of incorporating structured chemical knowledge into dialogue systems sets a new standard for developing LLMs in various scientific fields. Codes, Datasets, and Model weights are publicly accessible at https://hf.co/AI4Chem	[ -0.07402811199426651, -0.5138070583343506, 0.9699429869651794, 0.31460973620414734, 0.0025606981944292784, 0.5031884908676147, -0.2991197109222412, -0.2207760214805603, -0.2632130980491638, 0.526745617389679, -0.5764599442481995, -0.9347269535064697, -0.439245343208313, 0.031908806413412094, -0.42764437198638916, 0.8456254005432129, -0.04121625795960426, 0.32881543040275574, -0.448943167924881, 0.20776429772377014, -0.056934650987386703, -0.582994282245636, -0.6607280969619751, -0.5588593482971191, 0.6956638097763062, 0.14310283958911896, 0.48401010036468506, 0.35043537616729736, 0.4726434648036957, 0.319984495639801, -0.16971918940544128, 0.19462423026561737, -0.6160479187965393, 0.31886976957321167, -0.38577133417129517, -0.405468612909317, -0.5349234342575073, 0.1482451856136322, 0.6280229687690735, 0.9547495245933533, -0.1123967245221138, -0.22217273712158203, -0.0856495350599289, 0.47717446088790894, -0.5393076539039612, 0.4617488384246826, -0.5134881138801575, 0.05038335174322128, -0.1374937891960144, 0.19881629943847656, -0.31055742502212524, -0.0663444995880127, 0.12794409692287445, -0.5954322814941406, -0.09226946532726288, 0.2598716616630554, 0.4229350686073303, 0.18796537816524506, -0.6619109511375427, -0.31616660952568054, -0.5520322322845459, 1.0731860399246216, -0.602807343006134, 0.5398750305175781, 0.17391234636306763, 0.4203946888446808, -0.553013801574707, -1.0168890953063965, -0.43095606565475464, -0.4788326025009155, 0.06901919841766357, -0.01129113882780075, 0.13891369104385376, 0.2209175080060959, 0.0756334662437439, 0.31109219789505005, -0.5027288198471069, -0.13632996380329132, -0.19686752557754517, -0.5225549936294556, 0.49579349160194397, 0.7200230360031128, 0.08269776403903961, 0.3273696005344391, -0.667777419090271, 0.1803063303232193, -0.5500662922859192, -0.31153085827827454, -0.011247401125729084, 0.4077831208705902, -0.12879447638988495, 0.5245988965034485, -0.3083527088165283, 0.3276894986629486, -0.30513516068458557, 0.027091097086668015, -0.07662505656480789, -0.43070927262306213, -0.16828837990760803, 0.2236739844083786, 0.8613946437835693, 0.02719448134303093, 0.018100060522556305, 0.08396262675523758, -0.2748842239379883, 0.04721864312887192, -0.06649283319711685, -0.8719570636749268, -0.5852056741714478, 0.3423086702823639, -0.006247614044696093, -0.11187950521707535, -0.22734640538692474, -0.6492114663124084, -0.6894919276237488, -0.43511462211608887, 0.22234928607940674, -0.1798747479915619, 0.008059913292527199, -0.034325093030929565, -0.018105046823620796, 0.07462715357542038, 0.670211911201477, -0.71922367811203, 0.6710889339447021, 0.9931121468544006, 0.9439263939857483, -0.43834221363067627, -0.2079438716173172, -0.4679197669029236, 0.17636877298355103, -0.38872429728507996, 0.5911581516265869, -0.729617178440094, -0.3993704617023468, -0.14093317091464996, -0.08537784218788147, 0.34627223014831543, -0.697730302810669, 0.33738866448402405, -0.3656463325023651, 0.28890424966812134, -0.3821561932563782, -0.7125362753868103, 0.2108577936887741, 0.15030798316001892, -0.590479850769043, 0.9984118938446045, 0.25558769702911377, -0.3048911690711975, 0.13246381282806396, -0.6658087372779846, -0.24156364798545837, 0.09695392847061157, -0.11829238384962082, -0.14258497953414917, -0.09676962345838547, -0.22852692008018494, 0.25022730231285095, -0.806603193283081, 0.27846917510032654, -0.40174993872642517, -0.1850232481956482, 0.46503373980522156, -0.13806816935539246, 0.6296504139900208, 0.5193618535995483, 0.047409046441316605, 0.28226926922798157, -0.6274613738059998, 0.15205949544906616, -0.22824859619140625, -0.6258100867271423, -0.05410810187458992, -0.07264427095651627, 0.39116841554641724, 0.4678712785243988, 0.5938618183135986, -0.5683193206787109, 0.04938918724656105, -0.11531379073858261, 0.5118247270584106, 0.765541672706604, -0.13225772976875305, 0.3615504205226898, -0.0269475020468235, 0.23252740502357483, 0.02738974429666996, 0.11615606397390366, -0.1342323124408722, -0.1813536286354065, -0.6858518719673157, -0.562379002571106, 0.08636587113142014, 0.2257915735244751, -0.3728034198284149, 0.24303199350833893, -0.0842096358537674, -0.5755072236061096, -0.3051909804344177, 0.717849850654602, 0.34380823373794556, 0.32022014260292053, 0.3103910982608795, -0.09317685663700104, -0.4528656601905823, -0.9418790340423584, -0.33030131459236145, -0.06930272281169891, -0.2182895690202713, 0.17154133319854736, 0.4147670865058899, -0.36097732186317444, 0.8526158928871155, -0.5378152132034302, -0.1899113655090332, -0.26263171434402466, 0.11991491168737411, 0.2601577043533325, 0.24042604863643646, 0.06570324301719666, -0.5047011971473694, -0.651766836643219, 0.13284267485141754, -0.7317439317703247, -0.5609868764877319, 0.2591201961040497, -0.5126554369926453, 0.27054426074028015, 0.6605232357978821, -0.7178983092308044, -0.2242509424686432, 0.6250835657119751, -0.3853970170021057, 0.3841438889503479, 0.06817937642335892, -0.15649473667144775, -0.799997091293335, 0.2652018964290619, -0.14579761028289795, -0.30230018496513367, -0.8136767148971558, -0.053285323083400726, 0.027789125218987465, -0.31456294655799866, -0.6827175617218018, 0.8675519824028015, -0.3729640543460846, 0.09089365601539612, -0.36566445231437683, 0.07064743340015411, 0.1752050518989563, 0.4614974856376648, 0.23114706575870514, 0.359036922454834, 0.4854944348335266, -0.4171559810638428, 0.5663308501243591, 0.03594376519322395, -0.3833892345428467, 0.552527129650116, -0.5949990153312683, 0.1015983521938324, 0.2313484400510788, 0.42157644033432007, -0.9031325578689575, -0.31229129433631897, 0.010982652194797993, 0.17763839662075043, 0.36871129274368286, 0.25816550850868225, -0.3971865177154541, -0.05700639262795448, -0.11224206537008286, 0.3188512325286865, 0.49084216356277466, -0.3667612671852112, 0.7199225425720215, 0.20954391360282898, -0.26737380027770996, -0.34742143750190735, -0.1909443885087967, 0.1292145550251007, -0.060166239738464355, -0.36934658885002136, -0.008847913704812527, -0.2761301100254059, -0.36873477697372437, -0.17584405839443207, -0.5130505561828613, -0.2288157045841217, -0.11496845632791519, 0.1671401560306549, 0.27325305342674255, -0.09730281680822372, 0.22039435803890228, -0.17238600552082062, -0.08939297497272491, 0.3826436698436737, -0.17433595657348633, 0.7469846606254578, -0.046225689351558685, -0.167494535446167, -0.16080142557621002, 0.33745861053466797, 0.9267619848251343, -0.027368417009711266, 0.5767595171928406, 0.35051268339157104, -0.14256341755390167, -0.5381982922554016, -0.2478114515542984, -0.07516447454690933, -0.5314725041389465, 0.5419805645942688, -0.2002008557319641, -0.8851107358932495, 0.39280006289482117, -0.38313040137290955, -0.023150507360696793, 0.25628218054771423, 0.7683154940605164, -0.13384564220905304, 0.7789340019226074, 0.3000486195087433, -0.06002869829535484, 0.1857905089855194, 0.2663852870464325, 0.26765212416648865, -0.6446154713630676, -0.5872434973716736, -0.3775148093700409, -0.15170472860336304, -0.05101973935961723, -0.5403618216514587, 0.5613648295402527, -0.14904563128948212, -0.6970250606536865, 0.044884562492370605, -0.09925228357315063, 0.48883742094039917, 0.37519314885139465, -0.009956931695342064, 0.4674879312515259, -0.09289192408323288, -0.3039863109588623, 0.004910208750516176, -0.618320643901825, -0.4110867977142334, 0.9533593654632568, 0.3064812421798706, 1.3448454141616821, 0.09926664084196091, 0.4470633566379547, 0.24104972183704376, 0.2218538522720337, -0.7367206811904907, 0.8188826441764832, 0.17513461410999298, -0.9022569060325623, -0.2903650104999542, -0.568618655204773, -0.6758440732955933, 0.1872522383928299, -0.034749068319797516, -0.3162534832954407, -0.27451592683792114, 0.012965263798832893, 0.05592046678066254, -0.06231556460261345, -0.3787694573402405, 0.7588607668876648, -0.4503348469734192, -0.8089037537574768, -0.15591417253017426, -0.7496394515037537, 0.528376042842865, -0.4600010812282562, 0.1357867419719696, -0.60853111743927, -0.37863799929618835, 0.29080426692962646, -0.7874353528022766, 0.7025754451751709, 0.07307811081409454, -0.5647110342979431, 0.22759529948234558, 0.30404889583587646, 0.3806767463684082, -0.3442128002643585, -0.012827396392822266, 0.26424771547317505, 0.15524937212467194, -0.4385976195335388, -0.765742838382721, 1.1076935529708862, -0.4766286313533783, -0.6401087641716003, -0.5886417031288147, -0.7534350156784058, -0.27419328689575195, 0.20781300961971283, -0.13350093364715576, 0.10636644065380096, -0.25748762488365173, 0.04129317030310631, 0.5260593295097351, -0.36871933937072754, 0.16060557961463928, 0.6682438254356384, -0.43449223041534424, -0.18740446865558624, 0.8681535124778748, -0.283926784992218, 0.5589503049850464, 0.5578852891921997, 0.18569059669971466, -0.5137318968772888, -0.11950798332691193, 0.21738216280937195, 0.0832902044057846, -1.1030967235565186, -0.11356531083583832, -0.6150602698326111, -0.33669793605804443, -0.25689369440078735, -0.04569713771343231, -0.4189303517341614, -0.29165083169937134, -0.0113648921251297, 0.1890111118555069, 0.32388225197792053, 0.8224697709083557, 0.11005222052335739, -0.11384280771017075, -0.664776623249054, 0.20486341416835785, 0.35748496651649475, 0.5719889998435974, -0.20288163423538208, -0.097860187292099, -0.3027665913105011, -0.17880867421627045, -0.11875829845666885, -0.5192954540252686, 0.20937442779541016, 0.33433035016059875, 0.5813411474227905, 0.16879576444625854, 0.09109094738960266, 0.3142763674259186, -0.6161024570465088, 0.8028618097305298, -0.03791266307234764, -1.0711891651153564, 0.3565457761287689, -0.4113349914550781, 0.5679275393486023, 0.24461548030376434, 0.5514941215515137, -0.6420609951019287, -0.3022190034389496, -0.05083124339580536, -0.7068055272102356, 0.5520389080047607, 0.23415732383728027, -0.018480002880096436, 0.000029958528102724813, -0.0583215169608593, -0.01711714081466198, 0.36931392550468445, -0.5095127820968628, -0.2407407909631729, -0.03690968453884125, -0.500845730304718, -0.21455663442611694, -0.0028553041629493237, -0.3038251996040344, -0.4085293114185333, 0.7780547738075256, 0.09870751947164536, 0.05573209375143051, 0.07553490251302719, -0.08605553209781647, -0.032439034432172775, 0.31621211767196655, 0.5517606735229492, 0.3053167164325714, -0.12434498220682144, 0.4938003718852997, 0.21924927830696106, -0.6009576916694641, 0.3277665972709656, -0.1382448673248291, 0.41922563314437866, -0.09076261520385742, 0.3539808392524719, 0.4690530598163605, 0.3896324038505554, -1.1403785943984985, 0.11832298338413239, 0.2712343633174896, -0.12632451951503754, 0.07313864678144455, 0.3535759747028351, 0.3092096745967865, 0.3283728361129761, 0.20062245428562164, -0.40200862288475037, 0.24479258060455322, -0.8656287789344788, 0.08233530074357986, 0.6039810180664062, -0.33604755997657776, 0.005302738398313522, 0.7647272348403931, 0.26594945788383484, 0.018742932006716728, 0.4657554626464844, 0.1107298955321312, -0.6571523547172546, 0.3471052646636963, 0.41589516401290894, 0.6330446600914001, -0.3735618591308594, -0.014460460282862186, 0.18147487938404083, 0.12833888828754425, 0.030779264867305756, 0.22340957820415497, 0.014472604729235172, -0.34260666370391846, -0.11496942490339279, -0.9059809446334839, -0.5966252684593201, 0.22438481450080872, -0.11206964403390884, 0.401881605386734, -0.7823463678359985, 0.061582110822200775, -0.015229384414851665, 0.36377909779548645, -0.48447608947753906, -0.05616634711623192, 0.15871909260749817, 0.9803374409675598, -0.6693212389945984, 0.6861941814422607, 0.4646399915218353, -0.003525550477206707, -0.4245847463607788, -0.5652908682823181, 0.45597952604293823, -0.5849477648735046, 0.9060410857200623, -0.2297835350036621, -0.3036952018737793, -0.09327776730060577, -0.8511536717414856, -1.008276104927063, 1.0169225931167603, 0.4339967370033264, -0.577225923538208, 0.1841621845960617, 0.5033349990844727, 0.5960956811904907, -0.481699138879776, -0.024762097746133804, 0.625843346118927, 0.6510982513427734, 0.3870144784450531, -0.7985339164733887, 0.25708431005477905, -0.4233739674091339, -0.06980497390031815, 0.30781862139701843, -0.7207595705986023, 1.0628604888916016, 0.09214268624782562, -0.16719847917556763, 0.30343097448349, 0.2457374781370163, 0.2991315424442291, 0.34372401237487793, -0.10268770903348923, 0.26917344331741333, 0.6633653044700623, -0.3200635313987732, 1.0342897176742554, -0.12601451575756073, 0.31762003898620605, 1.2854359149932861, -0.9088788628578186, 0.676062285900116, 0.36164590716362, -0.32458755373954773, 0.5212374329566956, 0.5218545794487, -0.010796434246003628, 0.5783425569534302, 0.5286744832992554, -0.8443408608436584, -0.46125879883766174, -0.23381420969963074, -0.17624790966510773, 0.29360246658325195, 0.6654152870178223, -0.39105424284935, -0.3305681049823761, -0.3695944845676422, -0.058272089809179306, 0.039744336158037186, -0.37442004680633545, 0.6877049803733826, 0.22320127487182617, -0.37585586309432983, 0.4007412791252136, -0.08830396831035614, 0.189459890127182, -0.8065537810325623, -0.2184055745601654, -0.3353250026702881, 0.15174095332622528, -0.11838158220052719, -0.6929421424865723, -0.202992245554924, -0.16892269253730774, 0.035915032029151917, 0.011720201931893826, 0.7299730181694031, -0.9791817665100098, -0.36613014340400696, 0.07855179160833359, 0.4068024158477783, 0.27501896023750305, 0.03075486794114113, -0.4077818989753723, 0.36338967084884644, -0.3289247155189514, -0.07373593002557755, 0.317160040140152, 0.43920767307281494, -0.02406133897602558, 0.8155197501182556, 0.6496120691299438, -0.2296326607465744, 0.08265523612499237, -0.07227867841720581, 0.9142629504203796, -0.7474790215492249, -0.12816178798675537, -0.8841122984886169, 0.27968525886535645, -0.08837080001831055, 0.041462525725364685, 0.9216471910476685, 0.7778508067131042, 0.4550333321094513, -0.12706483900547028, 0.8741782307624817, 0.39641624689102173, 0.3031144142150879, -0.6633689403533936, 0.7467749714851379, -0.4056742191314697, 0.29203855991363525, -0.2438339740037918, -1.2673892974853516, -0.3378826677799225, 0.424359530210495, 0.00757633987814188, 0.27477961778640747, 0.994901716709137, 0.8527376651763916, -0.06206025183200836, -0.1040244773030281, 0.4664255976676941, 0.5515226125717163, 0.4368295669555664, 0.8822999596595764, 1.0207840204238892, 0.0012520432937890291, 0.2611406445503235, 0.16542840003967285, 0.1277104765176773, -0.19222356379032135, -0.79756098985672, -1.1756607294082642, -0.4632081389427185, -0.13213708996772766, -0.25387871265411377, -0.12012425065040588, 1.1248915195465088, 0.5968943238258362, -0.6692540049552917, -0.5218734741210938, -0.14426375925540924, -0.08812855184078217, 0.21589653193950653, -0.213724747300148, 0.024548117071390152, -0.41386914253234863, -0.8884553909301758, 0.5632171034812927, 0.47247716784477234, 0.09757503122091293, -0.5201469659805298, -0.4239129424095154, -0.10618143528699875, 0.3205740749835968, 0.8099460005760193, 0.2684096395969391, -0.7127411365509033, -0.03889206796884537, -0.004222623538225889, -0.3882622718811035, -0.06876543164253235, 0.8458240628242493, -0.5506742596626282, 0.5328860878944397, 0.2767646908760071, 0.4701071083545685, 0.6185156106948853, -0.461990624666214, 0.823564350605011, -0.6638559103012085, -0.20305411517620087, 0.17388392984867096, 0.2756117582321167, 0.22022417187690735, -0.1804991066455841, 0.5860183835029602, 0.04711585119366646, -0.4936918616294861, -0.7561675906181335, 0.2594965696334839, -1.1205594539642334, -0.4993732273578644, 1.1068882942199707, 0.07777677476406097, -0.11590325832366943, -0.31430816650390625, -0.44226449728012085, 0.13262085616588593, -0.595338761806488, 0.45880740880966187, 1.1817649602890015, -0.18966957926750183, -0.16829697787761688, -0.3796846866607666, 0.6860052347183228, 0.4016161859035492, -1.0578770637512207, 0.3432484269142151, 0.8194359540939331, 0.38461607694625854, 0.020369485020637512, 0.4658619463443756, -0.04416239634156227, 0.11310194432735443, 0.01041271910071373, -0.1346525400876999, -0.081786148250103, -0.5969955325126648, -0.22409076988697052, 0.058983299881219864, 0.09049766510725021, 0.5970191359519958 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06820v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06820v2	Forecasting Events in Soccer Matches Through Language	2024-02-09T23:02:57	2024-04-26T11:45:02	Tiago Mendes-Neves, Luís Meireles, João Mendes-Moreira	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.CL	This paper introduces an approach to predicting the next event in a soccer match, a challenge bearing remarkable similarities to the problem faced by Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike other methods that severely limit event dynamics in soccer, often abstracting from many variables or relying on a mix of sequential models, our research proposes a novel technique inspired by the methodologies used in LLMs. These models predict a complete chain of variables that compose an event, significantly simplifying the construction of Large Event Models (LEMs) for soccer. Utilizing deep learning on the publicly available WyScout dataset, the proposed approach notably surpasses the performance of previous LEM proposals in critical areas, such as the prediction accuracy of the next event type. This paper highlights the utility of LEMs in various applications, including match prediction and analytics. Moreover, we show that LEMs provide a simulation backbone for users to build many analytics pipelines, an approach opposite to the current specialized single-purpose models. LEMs represent a pivotal advancement in soccer analytics, establishing a foundational framework for multifaceted analytics pipelines through a singular machine-learning model.	[ -0.0816856101155281, -0.3301265239715576, 0.5372045636177063, 0.3181878626346588, -0.20337632298469543, 0.3877589702606201, -0.5193904638290405, -0.6190768480300903, 0.27673378586769104, 0.4188385009765625, -0.9752376675605774, -0.7027814388275146, -0.4573621153831482, -0.24948135018348694, -0.31479787826538086, 1.1019163131713867, 0.10249091684818268, 0.3364737331867218, -0.3384810984134674, 0.20224161446094513, -0.35541027784347534, -0.6466209888458252, -0.8018522262573242, -0.5986254215240479, 0.5142777562141418, 0.4019548296928406, 0.5577096343040466, 0.42211705446243286, 0.607345461845398, 0.34177058935165405, 0.13581468164920807, 0.13047415018081665, -0.5115087032318115, 0.5373582243919373, 0.18605227768421173, -0.5909016728401184, -0.3510652184486389, 0.14700809121131897, 0.5587877631187439, 0.9020206332206726, -0.044374991208314896, 0.07935326546430588, -0.1238936334848404, 0.5587105751037598, -0.25735485553741455, 0.4222358465194702, -0.8905166387557983, 0.29209455847740173, -0.05462370812892914, -0.2654185891151428, -0.26406484842300415, 0.14053772389888763, 0.2246878743171692, -0.29966384172439575, 0.14559724926948547, -0.39681631326675415, 0.4631664454936981, 0.22688564658164978, -0.03328656032681465, -0.2123335301876068, -1.081589698791504, 0.9546673893928528, -0.6743351817131042, 0.3862035572528839, 0.3835391104221344, 0.4974724054336548, -0.3465038537979126, -0.5023008584976196, -0.29338717460632324, -0.3764137625694275, 0.22947955131530762, 0.43651384115219116, 0.268891841173172, -0.1706916093826294, 0.01570103131234646, -0.25996169447898865, -0.5246856808662415, 0.4018626809120178, -0.08355449885129929, 0.2722362279891968, 1.0607227087020874, 0.5425869822502136, -0.017611529678106308, 0.48790326714515686, -0.17335352301597595, 0.39249223470687866, -0.7957004904747009, -0.05057821422815323, 0.2375802993774414, 0.58609539270401, -0.1707160323858261, 0.31946849822998047, -0.37594500184059143, 0.45572447776794434, -0.20501649379730225, -0.5925048589706421, -0.0455717034637928, -0.0325060710310936, -0.19852200150489807, -0.06615890562534332, 0.6976945400238037, 0.4477863609790802, 0.46562686562538147, -0.4227610230445862, 0.0686015859246254, 0.16130024194717407, -0.4507923722267151, -1.026060938835144, -0.26405069231987, 0.29503318667411804, -0.28209057450294495, -0.44354939460754395, -0.04064776375889778, -0.8600761890411377, -0.4148555099964142, -0.5053520798683167, -0.03998817875981331, 0.0020401503425091505, 0.10743265599012375, 0.09266465157270432, 0.06415804475545883, 0.14874880015850067, 0.5387182235717773, -0.7180837392807007, 0.3623580038547516, 0.7613655924797058, 0.7456555366516113, -0.2268340289592743, -0.3738855719566345, -0.7743284106254578, 0.12961861491203308, -0.401863157749176, 0.6678581237792969, -0.7223294377326965, -0.3403496742248535, 0.440867155790329, 0.15389056503772736, 0.4654834568500519, -0.14636576175689697, 0.29496943950653076, -0.36798742413520813, -0.03271294757723808, 0.0963333249092102, -0.6142764687538147, 0.07767682522535324, 0.05133640766143799, -0.36784839630126953, 0.8757287263870239, -0.3069564998149872, -0.309254914522171, 0.583037257194519, -0.4816248118877411, -0.655726432800293, 0.3470360040664673, -0.18846210837364197, -0.6164177656173706, 0.28539374470710754, 0.19454823434352875, 0.9251765012741089, -0.2249099612236023, 0.24248820543289185, -0.7352865934371948, -0.22952423989772797, 0.15449875593185425, -0.22151631116867065, 0.3582003712654114, -0.01867653802037239, -0.22650305926799774, -0.06035972759127617, -0.6618205904960632, -0.19215527176856995, 0.22751343250274658, -0.060973331332206726, -0.1006987988948822, 0.7361058592796326, -0.09532977640628815, 0.4391009509563446, 0.22455905377864838, -0.31974363327026367, 0.2897784113883972, -0.5292971730232239, 0.30175530910491943, 0.6605640649795532, -0.35340529680252075, 0.776506245136261, 0.18786993622779846, 0.6261986494064331, -0.18220099806785583, 0.2594206929206848, -0.43989601731300354, -0.5488232970237732, -0.3200943171977997, -0.09283895790576935, 0.1852942556142807, 0.5437136888504028, -0.3324300944805145, 0.16968975961208344, -0.2608395218849182, -0.7667456865310669, -0.16773954033851624, 0.40498292446136475, -0.024244487285614014, 0.008242214098572731, 0.11899440735578537, 0.16252553462982178, -0.9732741117477417, -0.3277784287929535, -0.16752789914608002, -0.13519218564033508, 0.32708433270454407, 0.4931306540966034, 0.6275972127914429, -0.02549060992896557, 0.5662290453910828, -0.586264431476593, -0.40619122982025146, -0.3607497811317444, 0.07668369263410568, 0.35173457860946655, 0.43169865012168884, 0.724638044834137, -0.7771503925323486, -0.8121609091758728, 0.3096711337566376, -0.6499585509300232, -0.1585945188999176, -0.08458541333675385, 0.3022746741771698, 0.3462240397930145, 0.6559672951698303, -0.18207630515098572, 0.5909881591796875, 0.9786163568496704, -0.33705762028694153, 0.653171181678772, 0.08594989031553268, -0.13484346866607666, -0.9078516364097595, -0.3209703266620636, -0.1456512063741684, -0.33474087715148926, -0.5484446883201599, -0.216576486825943, -0.4512045979499817, -0.019469967111945152, -0.5076127052307129, 0.6288437247276306, -0.4205690622329712, -0.38464948534965515, -0.5914161801338196, -0.036833059042692184, -0.15422435104846954, 0.10070740431547165, 0.5181136727333069, 0.6229692697525024, 0.4775388538837433, -0.5256685614585876, 0.6281341910362244, -0.10328149050474167, -0.43978166580200195, 0.10206577926874161, -0.4954937696456909, -0.1340457648038864, -0.16928058862686157, 0.34801262617111206, -1.090952754020691, -0.120356485247612, -0.23584029078483582, -0.7160952687263489, 0.24085383117198944, -0.5297327637672424, -0.30293983221054077, -0.7406226992607117, -0.0906447246670723, 0.42208731174468994, 0.6056123375892639, -0.533250629901886, 0.5219751000404358, 0.5901409387588501, -0.24750669300556183, -0.6715806126594543, -0.4841662645339966, 0.25547152757644653, -0.386160284280777, -0.3918410837650299, 0.23306284844875336, -0.3506888747215271, -0.24277512729167938, -0.23165516555309296, -0.03311621770262718, -0.2542177140712738, 0.4695468842983246, 0.32650500535964966, 0.2955739498138428, -0.2305513322353363, 0.19016943871974945, -0.30398428440093994, 0.05738886818289757, -0.03435954079031944, -0.8227969408035278, 0.741276204586029, 0.09501111507415771, 0.08591876178979874, -0.6530944108963013, 0.5617117285728455, 0.2908162772655487, 0.07134551554918289, 0.838824987411499, 0.5461682677268982, -0.5500441789627075, -0.4250185191631317, -0.3975561857223511, -0.0467102937400341, -0.451987624168396, 0.6073876619338989, -0.5283398032188416, -0.7924333810806274, 0.8344240188598633, -0.2848449647426605, -0.11912543326616287, 0.3545914590358734, 0.8732588887214661, -0.6930239796638489, 1.6089459657669067, 0.5538905262947083, -0.38112884759902954, 0.5759564638137817, -0.360033243894577, -0.05546075850725174, -0.3963686525821686, -0.5548942685127258, -0.8463901877403259, -0.19525600969791412, -0.4816974401473999, -0.4915372133255005, -0.02345283143222332, 0.27104461193084717, -0.14734965562820435, 0.4120194911956787, 0.049679871648550034, 0.9987972974777222, 0.022176289930939674, -0.3420718312263489, 0.17380571365356445, -0.19503267109394073, 0.12156490981578827, -0.403979629278183, -0.6779330372810364, -0.043911561369895935, 0.9298915266990662, 0.10993126034736633, 0.9208042025566101, -0.1399880200624466, 0.7195709347724915, 0.2005259245634079, 0.5636886954307556, -1.0681167840957642, 0.32842811942100525, -0.2125745266675949, -0.3855192959308624, -0.4887286126613617, -0.4094005823135376, -0.9562658667564392, 0.08912274241447449, -0.2724412977695465, -0.9593048095703125, -0.21575839817523956, -0.01292403880506754, -0.10610299557447433, 0.38403189182281494, -0.12127280235290527, 0.423420250415802, -0.15414521098136902, -0.39404821395874023, 0.13467295467853546, -0.3446328938007355, 0.23151102662086487, -0.01326518040150404, 0.557199239730835, -0.3626881539821625, -0.3546866476535797, 0.7010670900344849, -0.45078688859939575, 0.8137005567550659, 0.037128228694200516, -0.1209276020526886, 0.28875866532325745, 0.2668300271034241, 0.6619057059288025, 0.373607873916626, -0.12058035284280777, 0.07051332294940948, -0.27620774507522583, -0.4765658378601074, -0.4341875910758972, 0.9347348809242249, -0.5611826181411743, -0.4721553325653076, -0.34655502438545227, -0.49001166224479675, -0.4236204922199249, -0.08152024447917938, 0.15495730936527252, 0.3156527876853943, -0.544950008392334, 0.08266866952180862, 0.24506036937236786, -0.08042216300964355, 0.9419075846672058, 0.5457553267478943, -0.31978824734687805, -0.2669236361980438, 0.7505985498428345, 0.09670676290988922, -0.12078648060560226, 0.44550442695617676, 0.3243723213672638, -0.44373226165771484, -0.9918605089187622, -0.12481357157230377, 0.10990158468484879, -0.46064403653144836, -0.6101879477500916, -0.4282563030719757, 0.029127581045031548, -0.5411778092384338, -0.32211577892303467, -0.45637792348861694, -0.19909359514713287, -0.2573469579219818, -0.13925690948963165, 0.1473812758922577, 0.8202627897262573, -0.10830129683017731, 0.6259279847145081, -0.7276971936225891, -0.2728241980075836, 0.14092843234539032, 0.4555615186691284, -0.2428000420331955, -0.543510377407074, -0.4716687500476837, -0.27062469720840454, -0.0028709694743156433, -0.9019307494163513, 0.8547472357749939, 0.2985948920249939, 0.43867427110671997, 0.5874712467193604, -0.35511869192123413, 0.7425320744514465, -0.8126943707466125, 0.8868682384490967, 0.5183699727058411, -0.8367693424224854, 0.6945000886917114, -0.6953433156013489, 0.055399976670742035, 0.3359217345714569, 0.4894174039363861, -0.5554018616676331, -0.1984994113445282, -0.5770434737205505, -0.7507013082504272, 0.8361676931381226, 0.0781518891453743, 0.1821923702955246, -0.122480608522892, 0.2755735516548157, 0.2120385318994522, 0.3659100830554962, -0.6378756165504456, -0.16398096084594727, 0.14542286098003387, -0.10005643218755722, -0.6677432060241699, -0.016094990074634552, 0.2858271598815918, -0.4491089880466461, 0.74019455909729, -0.32723909616470337, -0.03320738300681114, -0.1595824956893921, 0.08885800093412399, -0.12585555016994476, -0.3529554605484009, 0.7250858545303345, 0.7548308968544006, -0.12591224908828735, -0.3540409505367279, 0.4978863000869751, -0.21545445919036865, -0.19161826372146606, -0.16314037144184113, -0.029208142310380936, 0.1609255075454712, 0.4477141201496124, 0.7084082961082458, 0.06981054693460464, -0.7880206108093262, 0.4757978320121765, 0.138068288564682, -0.5089049339294434, -0.7003479599952698, -0.36632052063941956, 0.3672150671482086, 0.44179055094718933, 0.4092575013637543, -0.19414834678173065, 0.11863262951374054, -0.7296425700187683, 0.198495551943779, 0.546401858329773, -0.7869237065315247, -0.49544641375541687, 0.703606367111206, 0.3210431635379791, -0.5159555077552795, -0.06415769457817078, 0.09882823377847672, -0.7165144085884094, 1.0821926593780518, 0.651446521282196, 0.641269862651825, -0.5655360817909241, 0.3184583783149719, 0.18180423974990845, 0.1204301044344902, -0.25966691970825195, 0.30568382143974304, 0.3100374639034271, -0.6896224021911621, -1.063238501548767, -0.8793653249740601, -0.18898168206214905, 0.6051082015037537, -0.2213786542415619, 0.1838037073612213, -0.4525742828845978, -0.08494996279478073, 0.2525779604911804, 0.36805492639541626, -1.0795016288757324, 0.3000957667827606, 0.6348000764846802, 0.8688111305236816, -1.0019127130508423, 0.7732004523277283, 0.6138032674789429, -0.35115376114845276, -0.2615922689437866, -0.24152278900146484, -0.013361599296331406, -0.6687301397323608, 0.6136563420295715, -0.09017351269721985, 0.11236254125833511, -0.22568829357624054, -0.6819528937339783, -0.810738205909729, 0.8248285055160522, 0.23773783445358276, -0.6637417674064636, 0.042242664843797684, 0.22915247082710266, 0.38449397683143616, -0.8473100662231445, 0.10230658203363419, 0.6850134134292603, 0.4886400103569031, 0.21872274577617645, -0.6304094791412354, -0.3429816961288452, 0.22504165768623352, 0.03709836304187775, 0.4328441023826599, -0.6275720596313477, 0.5911476016044617, -0.3724595308303833, 0.2419101595878601, 0.4313097894191742, 0.932349443435669, -0.32339105010032654, 0.4303225576877594, 0.07988308370113373, 0.24621383845806122, 0.6481457948684692, -0.33854666352272034, 0.9394025206565857, 0.10850190371274948, 0.5358679294586182, 1.3624210357666016, -0.47581687569618225, 0.7778352499008179, 0.18425124883651733, -0.31111082434654236, 0.42394667863845825, 0.5100114941596985, -0.08239283412694931, 0.4806746244430542, 0.39848604798316956, -0.38290002942085266, -0.6607723832130432, -0.08911968022584915, -0.21821299195289612, 1.0033564567565918, 0.5807542204856873, -0.24003103375434875, -0.22357860207557678, -0.00012196107854833826, 0.023880837485194206, 0.32069799304008484, -0.6782212257385254, 1.085368037223816, -0.03705054894089699, -0.6015377640724182, -0.04890550673007965, -0.03491074964404106, 0.4982631206512451, -0.45486313104629517, -0.10529442131519318, -0.2265561819076538, 0.34060394763946533, -0.05545670539140701, -0.6742149591445923, 0.12867094576358795, -0.2558457851409912, -0.2757216691970825, 0.12505601346492767, 0.6675294637680054, -0.5912935733795166, -0.7188425064086914, 0.633971095085144, 0.5571528077125549, 0.19604462385177612, -0.01850573532283306, -0.69398432970047, 0.043692369014024734, -0.22989696264266968, -0.1348131150007248, 0.40727415680885315, 0.43646475672721863, -0.06655031442642212, 0.6666516065597534, 0.7345070838928223, 0.4440019428730011, -0.006219813134521246, 0.2639303505420685, 0.4855165481567383, -0.7323663830757141, -0.505021333694458, -1.12582266330719, 0.24580280482769012, -0.1270846724510193, -0.07261732220649719, 0.3326922059059143, 0.689734697341919, 0.7207539677619934, -0.10552828758955002, 0.9339214563369751, 0.5516243577003479, 0.10914340615272522, -0.24466608464717865, 0.5110825896263123, -0.5329657793045044, -0.004304463975131512, -0.24272416532039642, -0.7286641001701355, -0.46403393149375916, 0.43476998805999756, -0.07025159150362015, -0.22555124759674072, 0.49340537190437317, 0.19402849674224854, 0.15359190106391907, -0.0641745924949646, 0.6364094614982605, 0.13420380651950836, 0.19605860114097595, 0.5917457938194275, 0.8628764748573303, -0.26097866892814636, 0.6570003032684326, -0.03549417108297348, -0.20820504426956177, -0.5220189690589905, -1.0576344728469849, -1.2467751502990723, -0.5532101392745972, -0.185307577252388, -0.44174954295158386, 0.2994246184825897, 0.8658729195594788, 0.9800378680229187, -0.9951120615005493, -0.47490423917770386, 0.015020135790109634, 0.11194625496864319, -0.23269875347614288, -0.17806720733642578, 0.21357128024101257, -0.5412116050720215, -1.228784203529358, 0.5190389752388, 0.19233138859272003, 0.04145188629627228, -0.06853269040584564, -0.18789096176624298, -0.044049061834812164, 0.2911050021648407, 0.8773868680000305, 0.37941208481788635, -0.5605651140213013, -0.2598665952682495, -0.15334032475948334, 0.24980026483535767, -0.10744213312864304, 0.7078794240951538, -0.9912472367286682, -0.06648347526788712, 0.5918812155723572, 0.6652528643608093, 0.8878531455993652, -0.41289564967155457, 0.7727982997894287, -0.6884914636611938, 0.5264321565628052, 0.5494688153266907, 0.5617760419845581, 0.009677969850599766, -0.271747887134552, 0.7491957545280457, 0.32779157161712646, -0.26161646842956543, -0.8381679058074951, 0.3663743734359741, -0.8903804421424866, -0.32314661145210266, 1.1183701753616333, -0.05877744033932686, -0.1282733678817749, -0.06403028964996338, 0.06449583917856216, 0.16273443400859833, -0.3734300434589386, 0.6186184883117676, 0.796471357345581, -0.008978213183581829, 0.12054720520973206, -0.45799845457077026, 0.7524324059486389, 0.10987675935029984, -0.7552103996276855, 0.06170426309108734, 0.3000362813472748, 0.23545269668102264, -0.18839530646800995, 0.5510467290878296, 0.05704113468527794, 0.1531064361333847, -0.09746614843606949, -0.27647528052330017, 0.017448512837290764, -0.8494002223014832, 0.07241310179233551, 0.2223891168832779, -0.4140115976333618, -0.007494510617107153 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10949v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10949v2	The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Eccentric Automatic Prompts	2024-02-09T22:48:45	2024-02-20T15:03:00	Rick Battle, Teja Gollapudi	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable problem-solving and basic mathematics abilities. However, their efficacy is highly contingent on the formulation of the prompt. This study endeavors to quantify the influence of incorporating "positive thinking" into the system message of the prompt, then compare that to systematic prompt optimization. We assess the performance of 60 combinations of system message snippets, tested with and without Chain of Thought prompting, across three models with parameters ranging from 7 to 70 billion on the GSM8K dataset. Our findings reveal that results do not universally generalize across models. In most instances, the inclusion of "positive thinking" prompts positively affected model performance. Notably, however, Llama2-70B exhibited an exception when not utilizing Chain of Thought, as the optimal system message was found to be none at all. Given the combinatorial complexity, and thus computation time, of experimenting with hand-tuning prompts for large black-box models, we then compared the performance of the best "positive thinking" prompt against the output of systematic prompt optimization. We show that employing an automated prompt optimizer emerges as the most effective method for enhancing performance, even when working with smaller open-source models. Additionally, our findings reveal that the highest-scoring, automatically-optimized prompt exhibits a degree of peculiarity far beyond expectations.	[ -0.5781242251396179, -0.811859130859375, 0.8631927371025085, 0.5115278959274292, -0.34725871682167053, -0.18248482048511505, -0.27462929487228394, -0.45066961646080017, 0.22612006962299347, 0.24168382585048676, -0.855461597442627, -0.17201395332813263, -0.42712414264678955, 0.6818978786468506, -0.22335347533226013, 0.83260178565979, 0.02350386045873165, 0.03588910028338432, 0.030028613284230232, 0.1588609218597412, -0.8047494888305664, -0.37385138869285583, -0.4820308983325958, -0.2689928114414215, 0.6599544882774353, 0.19860537350177765, 0.6963337659835815, 0.6356554627418518, 0.45206180214881897, 0.2626080811023712, -0.060815051198005676, 0.3245992958545685, -0.47554811835289, 0.41643333435058594, -0.2912917733192444, -0.6731067895889282, -0.17944781482219696, 0.03577621653676033, 0.6247715353965759, 0.41604867577552795, -0.18120253086090088, 0.1813080608844757, 0.018653279170393944, 0.5257841944694519, -0.6528279781341553, 0.06647168099880219, -0.5766081213951111, 0.011728107929229736, 0.0007034348673187196, -0.22411669790744781, -0.32521772384643555, -0.5975832343101501, 0.11955629289150238, -0.6767026782035828, -0.41399991512298584, 0.26457786560058594, 0.6531120538711548, 0.4682692885398865, 0.10764268785715103, -0.8486606478691101, -0.7058117985725403, 0.7887675762176514, -0.6967334747314453, -0.05804979056119919, 0.2069060206413269, 0.26367780566215515, -0.33548420667648315, -0.008529579266905785, -0.5846754312515259, -0.3723832666873932, 0.35257408022880554, 0.05012485757470131, -0.577455461025238, 0.16953858733177185, 0.7217007279396057, 0.18853060901165009, -0.3278641402721405, 0.29294726252555847, -0.21431183815002441, -0.07860294729471207, 0.5176897644996643, 0.638122022151947, 0.2279694527387619, -0.2799956202507019, -0.10175515711307526, 0.017519434913992882, -0.6083433628082275, 0.39905378222465515, 0.4454314708709717, 0.412630558013916, -0.010125434957444668, 0.7005312442779541, -0.2851446270942688, 0.6394163370132446, 0.29166144132614136, -0.12716086208820343, -0.17586472630500793, -0.4436522126197815, -0.19600950181484222, -0.20227321982383728, 0.7018349170684814, 0.3645511865615845, 0.3173061013221741, 0.011614575982093811, -0.7490465641021729, 0.530386745929718, 0.26468369364738464, -0.6943702697753906, 0.06271418184041977, 0.18934138119220734, -0.234554260969162, -0.259724497795105, -0.053529467433691025, -0.34989941120147705, -0.4225526750087738, -0.5189064145088196, 0.5142310261726379, -0.25527745485305786, 0.1508384346961975, 0.3154039680957794, -0.1927015334367752, -0.11705964058637619, 0.454296737909317, -0.5340959429740906, 0.050997961312532425, 0.7366183400154114, 0.7150753736495972, -0.13619084656238556, -0.03338681161403656, -0.652310848236084, -0.4004531502723694, -0.5474386215209961, 0.9806907773017883, -0.6997746825218201, -0.5690335035324097, -0.09668876975774765, -0.22060097754001617, -0.02009977586567402, -0.5208721160888672, 0.7158721685409546, -0.3603599965572357, 0.22303837537765503, -0.5811198949813843, -0.590889036655426, -0.029227569699287415, 0.16717585921287537, -0.38685956597328186, 0.9946214556694031, -0.09245868772268295, -0.4266946315765381, 0.22028806805610657, -0.5371701121330261, -0.22798383235931396, 0.08511874079704285, -0.14393991231918335, -0.040846046060323715, 0.3935520052909851, 0.18750976026058197, 0.39846479892730713, -0.6201665997505188, 0.32498157024383545, -0.2591504752635956, -0.6191352009773254, 0.49844270944595337, -0.2691176235675812, 0.8499084115028381, 0.23052997887134552, -0.6024706959724426, 0.054104115813970566, -0.552408754825592, 0.03466491401195526, 0.11065302044153214, -0.06570059061050415, -0.2848297655582428, -0.314596951007843, -0.6727659702301025, 0.34021008014678955, 0.027314476668834686, -0.2971489131450653, 0.5969164371490479, -0.39857661724090576, 0.10548201948404312, 1.0344128608703613, 0.14899641275405884, 0.19864600896835327, -0.589148223400116, 0.9531211853027344, -0.1571170538663864, 0.18757230043411255, -0.414761483669281, -0.6704765558242798, -0.7121665477752686, -0.18791614472866058, -0.13757957518100739, 0.7781532406806946, -0.7757932543754578, 0.4059276580810547, 0.1639362871646881, -0.46446138620376587, -0.5375270843505859, 0.07250674813985825, 0.4712108373641968, 0.5795972347259521, 0.09056547284126282, -0.14787913858890533, -0.2824704647064209, -1.0044105052947998, -0.42386066913604736, -0.14333367347717285, 0.1249709352850914, 0.5665400624275208, 0.4613916277885437, -0.2808292508125305, 0.5353572964668274, -0.5083978176116943, 0.44802236557006836, -0.1978664994239807, 0.0053895688615739346, 0.7057470083236694, 0.050830285996198654, 0.3032272458076477, -0.0671420767903328, -0.41038674116134644, -0.4613395631313324, -0.6199638843536377, -0.5110182166099548, -0.4550052583217621, -0.28612950444221497, 0.04028233513236046, -0.01036764681339264, -0.9211662411689758, 0.4711374044418335, 0.02916998602449894, -0.3522152006626129, 1.1728103160858154, -0.21729469299316406, 0.12717066705226898, -0.5262051224708557, -0.07950029522180557, 0.2967091202735901, 0.1935780793428421, -0.5983420610427856, 0.053017109632492065, 0.18473920226097107, -0.05074744299054146, -0.19566726684570312, 0.50213223695755, -0.42237788438796997, 0.16721829771995544, -0.490547239780426, 0.25518888235092163, -0.1406145542860031, 0.3374899923801422, -0.39824846386909485, 1.1959425210952759, 0.6450718641281128, -0.8998996615409851, 0.43221357464790344, 0.12564721703529358, -0.5795276165008545, 0.5964192748069763, -0.739800214767456, 0.35900136828422546, -0.3078734874725342, 0.12578772008419037, -0.9593688249588013, -0.21986642479896545, 0.3425377607345581, -0.039598703384399414, -0.1647837609052658, 0.49179136753082275, -0.4718565046787262, -0.7512068152427673, -0.5179139375686646, 0.10445500165224075, 0.6015392541885376, -0.4472571015357971, 0.2306511402130127, 0.07432379573583603, -0.27703291177749634, -0.4743351340293884, -0.37681499123573303, 0.23427027463912964, -0.2765040993690491, -0.5105517506599426, -0.0006893815007060766, -0.1898762285709381, -0.33583033084869385, -0.3985423445701599, 0.03329163417220116, 0.6648094654083252, 0.2457278072834015, 0.15707539021968842, 0.5922598838806152, -0.09987916052341461, 0.09618762880563736, -0.016412239521741867, -0.16933225095272064, 0.38247352838516235, -0.42528924345970154, 0.5607794523239136, -0.06479062885046005, -0.35624417662620544, -0.9509949684143066, 0.3894602060317993, 0.41867533326148987, -0.046414684504270554, 0.5936751365661621, 0.05351856350898743, -0.3326835334300995, -0.3149230480194092, -0.6115393042564392, -0.23093657195568085, -0.5389264225959778, 0.036287833005189896, -0.2799994945526123, -0.6587291359901428, 0.5057055354118347, 0.1693800687789917, 0.12176629900932312, 0.1417379379272461, 0.5170421600341797, -0.06376629322767258, 1.2503576278686523, 0.4062035381793976, -0.012383874505758286, 0.6042354106903076, -0.05769322067499161, 0.35783371329307556, -0.932617723941803, -0.04644760116934776, -0.6160617470741272, -0.1988237202167511, -0.45356985926628113, -0.37156012654304504, 0.4820006191730499, 0.08530212938785553, -0.4228881895542145, 0.2579994797706604, -0.7711816430091858, 0.42154833674430847, 0.46992892026901245, 0.021226882934570312, 0.17161151766777039, -0.13423024117946625, -0.23674960434436798, 0.13842162489891052, -0.750896692276001, -0.7622983455657959, 0.9891905784606934, 0.2139975130558014, 0.8919495344161987, -0.17925629019737244, 0.5781849026679993, 0.06634415686130524, 0.37069565057754517, -0.7448697090148926, 0.751787543296814, 0.307675838470459, -0.3901619017124176, -0.2184721976518631, -0.45389625430107117, -0.9046791791915894, 0.046889305114746094, -0.15913808345794678, -0.9060905575752258, 0.16706077754497528, 0.15132908523082733, -0.8344476819038391, 0.0216840673238039, -0.7779412269592285, 0.2904508411884308, -0.23373271524906158, -0.16384603083133698, -0.25063154101371765, -0.3373968005180359, 0.20995545387268066, -0.01730949617922306, 0.2337556779384613, -0.03801891952753067, -0.222476989030838, 0.5817555785179138, -0.11565086990594864, 0.7171916365623474, -0.15141119062900543, -0.4432879388332367, 0.5150647759437561, 0.16823025047779083, 1.1232494115829468, -0.10001997649669647, -0.2607811689376831, -0.13695290684700012, -0.36841630935668945, -0.29720941185951233, -0.7813330292701721, 0.4963022470474243, -0.7344589829444885, -1.253908395767212, -0.16115078330039978, -0.5067266821861267, -0.24532659351825714, 0.20989865064620972, 0.17731395363807678, 0.6451509594917297, 0.1712377965450287, -0.2131623774766922, 0.5326128602027893, -0.35274142026901245, 0.40954285860061646, 0.1479073464870453, -0.36213964223861694, -0.5355159640312195, 0.7671026587486267, 0.21645238995552063, 0.5366291403770447, -0.05699220299720764, 0.2894533574581146, -0.19063274562358856, -0.5637262463569641, -0.557746946811676, 0.4640262722969055, -0.7217443585395813, -0.2165020853281021, -0.7658444046974182, 0.24483084678649902, -0.22124284505844116, -0.21035002171993256, -0.04983191937208176, -0.5648444890975952, -0.47823771834373474, -0.07951884716749191, 0.12102267146110535, 0.8883088827133179, 0.12586615979671478, 0.18173596262931824, -0.6004520654678345, 0.029667701572179794, 0.14950190484523773, 0.21222302317619324, 0.4088190197944641, -0.37614086270332336, -0.27060315012931824, 0.09536420553922653, -0.417141318321228, -0.8565508723258972, 0.1820916384458542, -0.25205326080322266, 0.662411630153656, 0.6913890838623047, 0.05811700597405434, 0.6324232816696167, -0.27153798937797546, 0.8415126800537109, 0.30169418454170227, -0.8145650625228882, 0.5251396298408508, -0.5799620747566223, 0.7105612754821777, 0.3364626467227936, 0.36842480301856995, -0.4988761246204376, -0.7329129576683044, -0.39463287591934204, -0.4609678089618683, 0.7061969637870789, 0.2804868519306183, 0.09158249944448471, -0.3642674386501312, 0.5612789392471313, 0.3201082944869995, 0.320462703704834, -0.49134859442710876, -0.3373180329799652, 0.04294110834598541, -0.022917453199625015, 0.10613739490509033, -0.09368743002414703, -0.03701135516166687, -0.19117164611816406, 0.5948778986930847, 0.06718028336763382, 0.5294004678726196, 0.30221596360206604, 0.1597699373960495, -0.4604477286338806, 0.2514294981956482, 0.8531395792961121, 0.6565550565719604, 0.18557557463645935, -0.09952615201473236, 0.2918146848678589, -0.25869712233543396, 0.1780177652835846, -0.23783738911151886, -0.42188870906829834, -0.23748181760311127, 0.30511969327926636, 0.9885106682777405, -0.022132903337478638, -0.6927946209907532, 0.0835207998752594, 0.01198978628963232, 0.0848832055926323, 0.11352849751710892, 0.7466320395469666, -0.0758342370390892, 0.2832415997982025, 0.47326159477233887, 0.2179502248764038, 0.26490452885627747, -0.5298689007759094, -0.24267517030239105, 0.6568612456321716, -0.21567107737064362, -0.4475521445274353, 0.47075024247169495, 0.18294362723827362, -0.8799954056739807, 0.4441782236099243, -0.5031830072402954, -0.7925047874450684, 0.697909951210022, 0.6742115616798401, 0.8967560529708862, -0.2075599879026413, 0.3250610828399658, 0.43956810235977173, 0.3395521342754364, -0.23200812935829163, 0.44142666459083557, -0.1327599734067917, -0.4420362710952759, -0.4883390963077545, -0.25966301560401917, -0.4122070372104645, -0.19228146970272064, -0.5200018882751465, 0.41651803255081177, -0.6012219190597534, -0.55043625831604, -0.1628103256225586, 0.05785087123513222, -0.8306689262390137, -0.0004957797355018556, 0.1950870305299759, 1.0846900939941406, -0.4320511221885681, 0.25590744614601135, 0.6870414614677429, -0.02969054877758026, -1.1011817455291748, -0.17681649327278137, -0.03393092378973961, -0.8058218955993652, 0.46675845980644226, 0.4093521237373352, -0.27266258001327515, -0.20813600718975067, -0.47125282883644104, -0.8459441661834717, 0.7814509868621826, 0.31292226910591125, -0.8446143269538879, -0.15975423157215118, 0.05691813677549362, 0.5214055776596069, -0.6136707663536072, 0.562699556350708, 0.39540547132492065, 0.5767249464988708, -0.08053720742464066, -1.0323272943496704, 0.3638456165790558, -0.24318823218345642, 0.046731457114219666, 0.2949987053871155, -0.759657084941864, 0.7990362644195557, -0.45751452445983887, -0.5185893774032593, 0.16306659579277039, 0.4266735017299652, 0.455008327960968, 0.26305490732192993, 0.5077144503593445, 0.38449811935424805, 1.127773404121399, 0.09659332036972046, 1.306119680404663, -0.33158183097839355, 0.10471745580434799, 0.4214308261871338, -0.20647045969963074, 0.31109151244163513, 0.4904972314834595, -0.14122380316257477, 0.4990488886833191, 0.5885853171348572, 0.16355864703655243, 0.5180781483650208, 0.24726523458957672, -0.14760854840278625, -0.4470987915992737, -0.08858097344636917, -0.3202787935733795, -0.056641317903995514, 0.40203744173049927, -0.1480250209569931, -0.1445743590593338, 0.09402184188365936, -0.08355587720870972, -0.18660618364810944, -0.3898366689682007, 0.6360767483711243, 0.28919437527656555, -1.1898075342178345, 0.8279781937599182, -0.23741891980171204, 0.7241905927658081, -0.12796510756015778, 0.1998022496700287, -0.09012212604284286, -0.07061566412448883, 0.03439290449023247, -0.6015692949295044, -0.1037818118929863, 0.1544230729341507, -0.02728646993637085, -0.17869612574577332, 0.5588188171386719, 0.1331823170185089, -0.4468277394771576, -0.07143308967351913, 0.4590652585029602, 0.011603974737226963, 0.04881628230214119, -0.7977232336997986, 0.09066390991210938, 0.10088249295949936, -0.34387364983558655, 0.002274397062137723, 0.7710831761360168, -0.03211004287004471, 1.0465294122695923, 0.7599665522575378, 0.21028128266334534, -0.24882513284683228, -0.11796947568655014, 1.12087881565094, -0.9151700735092163, -0.7635618448257446, -1.1059931516647339, 0.4655284285545349, -0.13474170863628387, -0.5851271152496338, 0.8580336570739746, 0.3015354573726654, 0.39845266938209534, 0.02869381196796894, 0.6930751800537109, 0.417119562625885, 0.2781919836997986, -0.4193539023399353, 0.10515697300434113, -0.26647281646728516, 0.6842511296272278, -0.5536883473396301, -1.1777175664901733, -0.03765184059739113, 0.6259580850601196, -0.7908812761306763, -0.09381786733865738, 0.6376782655715942, 0.8323763608932495, 0.3592981994152069, 0.6197629570960999, 0.05877227336168289, 0.046774722635746, 0.3766801953315735, 0.6574184894561768, 1.418556809425354, 0.07022647559642792, 0.19199925661087036, -0.08749955892562866, -0.5917455554008484, -0.39889129996299744, -0.843174159526825, -1.224534034729004, -0.2497192621231079, -0.07729931175708771, -0.2990321218967438, 0.2345101684331894, 1.419316291809082, 0.2374579906463623, -0.5462512969970703, -0.1611243039369583, -0.1286965310573578, 0.1723717302083969, -0.04817064478993416, -0.14979241788387299, 0.06951867043972015, -0.4611349105834961, -0.3672087490558624, 0.2732557952404022, 0.5100646018981934, 0.12656018137931824, -0.43682700395584106, 0.11638428270816803, 0.17797312140464783, 0.7079572081565857, 0.4962325692176819, -0.04187199845910072, -0.6714137196540833, -0.33684709668159485, 0.6929218173027039, -0.29706379771232605, 0.03706413134932518, 0.8669968247413635, -0.6388935446739197, 0.3501196503639221, 0.2498190551996231, 0.46956944465637207, -0.0537915900349617, 0.22317464649677277, 0.6700546145439148, 0.08886031061410904, -0.0819774717092514, 0.5295134782791138, 0.24811750650405884, 0.14850637316703796, -0.754021942615509, 0.03242484852671623, 0.04034002497792244, -0.6138694286346436, -0.9771401882171631, 0.23065654933452606, -0.5638771057128906, -0.21498709917068481, 1.321622371673584, 0.07783934473991394, -0.3397490680217743, 0.019993921741843224, -0.5017280578613281, -0.09715064615011215, -0.8488516807556152, 1.2772613763809204, 1.0687968730926514, -0.5848340392112732, 0.1180339902639389, -0.343828022480011, 0.2660863995552063, 0.7283578515052795, -0.6236429810523987, 0.039830707013607025, 0.5161120295524597, -0.21933725476264954, 0.2361762821674347, 0.47040483355522156, 0.3024863004684448, 0.3736540377140045, -0.10960076004266739, -0.40607595443725586, -0.15088221430778503, -0.2772079408168793, -0.381767600774765, -0.028829300776124, -0.017889119684696198, 0.34132394194602966 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15393v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15393v1	Detection of Opioid Users from Reddit Posts via an Attention-based Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Network	2024-02-09T22:12:20	2024-02-09T22:12:20	Yuchen Wang, Zhengyu Fang, Wei Du, Shuai Xu, Rong Xu, Jing Li	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI	The opioid epidemic, referring to the growing hospitalizations and deaths because of overdose of opioid usage and addiction, has become a severe health problem in the United States. Many strategies have been developed by the federal and local governments and health communities to combat this crisis. Among them, improving our understanding of the epidemic through better health surveillance is one of the top priorities. In addition to direct testing, machine learning approaches may also allow us to detect opioid users by analyzing data from social media because many opioid users may choose not to do the tests but may share their experiences on social media anonymously. In this paper, we take advantage of recent advances in machine learning, collect and analyze user posts from a popular social network Reddit with the goal to identify opioid users. Posts from more than 1,000 users who have posted on three sub-reddits over a period of one month have been collected. In addition to the ones that contain keywords such as opioid, opiate, or heroin, we have also collected posts that contain slang words of opioid such as black or chocolate. We apply an attention-based bidirectional long short memory model to identify opioid users. Experimental results show that the approaches significantly outperform competitive algorithms in terms of F1-score. Furthermore, the model allows us to extract most informative words, such as opiate, opioid, and black, from posts via the attention layer, which provides more insights on how the machine learning algorithm works in distinguishing drug users from non-drug users.	[ -0.29023051261901855, -0.8189315795898438, 0.6395395994186401, 0.06839504092931747, -0.4362209439277649, -0.04205593839287758, -0.15336136519908905, -0.6054760217666626, 0.697044849395752, 0.5178176760673523, -0.3246203064918518, -0.8113667368888855, -0.6173308491706848, 0.3803289532661438, -0.5739762187004089, 0.8532705903053284, -0.08471310138702393, -0.2768154442310333, -0.09806491434574127, -0.16785885393619537, -0.45277518033981323, -0.3608602285385132, -0.5373715162277222, -0.046607084572315216, 1.290332555770874, 0.2572513222694397, 0.24047985672950745, 0.23648035526275635, 0.8124855160713196, 0.27887997031211853, 0.15478691458702087, 0.06498896330595016, -0.4853183329105377, 0.00039523892337456346, -0.1601976901292801, -0.06601077318191528, -0.1476115733385086, -0.20482809841632843, -0.024690426886081696, 0.6004506349563599, -0.17926320433616638, 0.18502260744571686, 0.03274597227573395, 0.5570594668388367, -0.8082954287528992, -0.30554521083831787, -0.5114025473594666, 0.09750118106603622, -0.058238327503204346, -0.40893104672431946, -0.04649464786052704, -0.5322970151901245, -0.02183474227786064, -0.35507288575172424, 0.1330350637435913, -0.05977681279182434, 0.5729823112487793, 0.11288893967866898, -0.28346535563468933, -0.3656553626060486, -0.6450136303901672, 0.5160631537437439, -0.44877302646636963, 0.21810382604599, 0.3622567355632782, 0.12881363928318024, -0.12809306383132935, -0.6309600472450256, -0.3576575219631195, -0.07799358665943146, -0.40474799275398254, -0.13236984610557556, -0.15686851739883423, 0.040218815207481384, 0.047172561287879944, 0.04647303745150566, -0.9424052238464355, -0.05800753831863403, -0.794220507144928, 0.2164245992898941, 0.6874105930328369, 0.03710542246699333, 0.28589239716529846, -0.25444135069847107, -0.6805228590965271, 0.587612509727478, -0.3557409942150116, -0.2140905112028122, 0.31680041551589966, 0.4091624617576599, -0.0732099860906601, 0.45364388823509216, 0.08776996284723282, 0.7820647358894348, -0.11833471059799194, 0.12581971287727356, 0.4372570812702179, -0.2677238881587982, -0.21450592577457428, 0.06255991011857986, 1.1544075012207031, 0.5000767707824707, 0.31909894943237305, 0.043509192764759064, -0.23115891218185425, -0.10510484874248505, 0.6157618165016174, -0.69959956407547, -0.3023579716682434, 0.2947324812412262, -1.0031511783599854, -0.4868883788585663, 0.05861832946538925, -0.7350121140480042, -0.5836818814277649, -0.147436261177063, 0.5261556506156921, -0.19227585196495056, -0.37535133957862854, 0.1521817147731781, -0.11011630296707153, -0.3964498043060303, 0.02612653188407421, -0.7509847283363342, 0.275512158870697, 0.7288411259651184, 1.0967084169387817, -0.33729320764541626, -0.16828219592571259, -0.21590320765972137, -0.303697407245636, -0.16063261032104492, 0.7846316695213318, -0.2756930887699127, -0.03398909419775009, 0.17493762075901031, 0.29195430874824524, -0.18086856603622437, -0.7563230991363525, 0.25013837218284607, -0.6590716242790222, -0.05861282721161842, -0.09715670347213745, -0.3559550940990448, -0.23256877064704895, 0.2899729311466217, -0.49107620120048523, 0.4466724693775177, -0.10135609656572342, -0.8921805024147034, 0.03953465446829796, -0.5854393839836121, -0.46882954239845276, 0.21249333024024963, 0.004602766130119562, -0.3944300711154938, 0.35960057377815247, 0.12583059072494507, 0.5169954299926758, -0.0020878349896520376, 0.033176153898239136, -0.36982461810112, -0.7855080962181091, 0.3164462745189667, -0.053159285336732864, 0.7297929525375366, 0.5606879591941833, 0.01421696413308382, 0.17484833300113678, -0.49288681149482727, -0.23672586679458618, 0.22499048709869385, -0.28749537467956543, -0.6772323250770569, 0.012838952243328094, 0.24368123710155487, 0.04171302914619446, 0.12109284847974777, -0.6872887015342712, -0.2266886979341507, -0.4464993476867676, 0.6535096764564514, 0.7531182169914246, 0.439462810754776, -0.1840619444847107, -0.39374667406082153, 0.4753374457359314, 0.16067783534526825, 0.19234853982925415, -0.11392576992511749, -0.5304759740829468, -0.11200401932001114, -0.08117888122797012, 0.42032694816589355, 0.5502192974090576, -0.4431624114513397, 0.6941727995872498, -0.13107702136039734, -0.052589382976293564, -0.3509223461151123, 0.2240092009305954, 0.04425198212265968, 0.6097519993782043, 0.3365654945373535, -0.17488418519496918, -0.6809530258178711, -0.8978915214538574, -0.3825148046016693, 0.033568963408470154, -0.21241232752799988, 0.5154034495353699, 0.5994635820388794, -0.25585639476776123, 0.4949849247932434, -0.5247362852096558, -0.4328337013721466, -0.2591778337955475, 0.4137135148048401, 0.4819463789463043, 0.2080003321170807, 0.3264777660369873, -0.9669592380523682, -0.7005091309547424, 0.05339720845222473, -0.6555979251861572, -0.10702070593833923, 0.04067033529281616, -0.04212610796093941, -0.20755651593208313, 0.4752301871776581, -0.058369770646095276, 0.347047358751297, 0.33037739992141724, -0.17426781356334686, -0.06646120548248291, -0.11751218885183334, 0.21986189484596252, -1.0413603782653809, 0.4241771101951599, 0.23098903894424438, 0.005564623512327671, -0.47387686371803284, -0.3623560667037964, -0.09791086614131927, -0.3281218409538269, -0.3881457448005676, 0.17759503424167633, -0.27749669551849365, -0.09679771214723587, -0.21343590319156647, 0.11901345103979111, -0.22652265429496765, 0.3894605338573456, -0.008276150561869144, 0.3708157539367676, 0.3180895447731018, -0.23062685132026672, 0.46785682439804077, -0.32722485065460205, -0.6032022833824158, 0.5816198587417603, -0.7735861539840698, 0.07114256173372269, -0.2919328808784485, -0.3493635058403015, -1.2747284173965454, -0.2842758595943451, 0.629911482334137, -0.6283053159713745, 0.05523044988512993, -0.18559497594833374, -0.2942965626716614, -0.8094634413719177, -0.1280677616596222, 0.45972734689712524, 0.3759787976741791, -0.15605169534683228, 0.30068421363830566, 0.48541197180747986, -0.08783973008394241, -0.6889417767524719, -0.49859270453453064, 0.029431650415062904, -0.21914756298065186, -0.3488428592681885, 0.17251604795455933, 0.19820694625377655, -0.13762809336185455, 0.4753289222717285, 0.22427502274513245, -0.1732579916715622, 0.19226600229740143, 0.19357708096504211, 0.06727320700883865, -0.03551090508699417, 0.5479825139045715, -0.3479546010494232, -0.04018741101026535, 0.2141965925693512, -0.1022481694817543, 0.554145097732544, 0.2529473602771759, -0.2107599824666977, -0.8045763969421387, 0.7593289613723755, 0.64559006690979, -0.18680571019649506, 0.6394288539886475, 0.3265344500541687, -0.5428342819213867, -0.03701820969581604, -0.43545621633529663, -0.4737571179866791, -0.43242499232292175, 0.23771023750305176, 0.2788189649581909, -0.550237774848938, 0.28100666403770447, 0.16382542252540588, -0.014478839933872223, -0.2322494387626648, 0.2737898528575897, -0.4688011109828949, 1.0507240295410156, 0.27631762623786926, -0.16332365572452545, 0.480968713760376, 0.04948015138506889, 0.25185149908065796, -0.4658031165599823, 0.16427002847194672, -0.1466774195432663, -0.9384466409683228, -0.5540722012519836, -0.1877736747264862, 0.4641793668270111, -0.34854650497436523, -0.11616699397563934, 0.18630647659301758, -0.6993410587310791, 0.4339512586593628, 0.5938957929611206, 0.5457260608673096, -0.07876954972743988, 0.24762338399887085, 0.2749512195587158, 0.016718093305826187, -0.2976573407649994, -0.033627305179834366, 1.266943097114563, 0.2586672008037567, 0.6506931185722351, -0.20906782150268555, 0.8558894991874695, 0.7087134718894958, 0.49898386001586914, -0.7870842814445496, 0.31568199396133423, -0.3705386817455292, -0.3836720585823059, 0.1204768717288971, -0.5705389976501465, -1.1226402521133423, 0.0125155383720994, -0.19678042829036713, -0.3857894241809845, 0.11563190817832947, 0.14051944017410278, -0.9701724648475647, 0.27777767181396484, -0.7240587472915649, 1.0293620824813843, -0.4756004512310028, -0.2978702485561371, -0.14896413683891296, -0.6938086748123169, 0.13455414772033691, 0.15996003150939941, 0.29203346371650696, -0.09162019938230515, -0.03460879251360893, 0.8858838081359863, -0.36552032828330994, 0.8731798529624939, -0.3671674430370331, 0.2670207619667053, 0.41222578287124634, -0.431548148393631, 0.29920411109924316, -0.2063225507736206, 0.3725235164165497, 0.2884620726108551, -0.35448336601257324, -0.2965030074119568, -0.4350253641605377, 0.799170970916748, -0.44197580218315125, -0.398590624332428, -0.13495361804962158, -0.1369013637304306, 0.12733621895313263, 0.23863017559051514, 0.2614614963531494, 0.1358664631843567, 0.030365336686372757, 0.2961161434650421, 0.6119592189788818, -0.11685783416032791, 0.1452448070049286, 0.1955089122056961, -0.13602647185325623, -0.6190179586410522, 0.7077600955963135, 0.3970664143562317, -0.3099600672721863, 0.35498201847076416, 0.44310253858566284, -0.04666352644562721, -0.7027550339698792, -0.0708407461643219, 0.6554423570632935, -0.08185034245252609, -0.21546447277069092, -0.7007542848587036, -0.056063681840896606, -0.49514666199684143, -0.017387671396136284, -0.13806270062923431, 0.27249661087989807, -0.43993934988975525, -0.07937217503786087, 0.38866254687309265, 0.734783411026001, -0.2194107472896576, 0.10158514976501465, -0.7358649373054504, 0.5788958668708801, 0.63223797082901, 0.3805136978626251, -0.003967890981584787, -0.12859216332435608, -0.1228991448879242, -0.06608835607767105, -0.08463014662265778, -1.207446813583374, 0.35920828580856323, -0.14083822071552277, 0.4360311031341553, 0.8704872727394104, 0.29483702778816223, 0.41049709916114807, -0.20154303312301636, 0.29619327187538147, 0.22970730066299438, -0.2550188899040222, 0.6265294551849365, -0.45297756791114807, -0.012676125392317772, 0.6691186428070068, 0.7558112740516663, -0.9926463961601257, 0.049780115485191345, -0.09637412428855896, -0.7163020968437195, 0.655193567276001, 0.09364206343889236, 0.16774670779705048, -0.44073450565338135, 0.44163891673088074, -0.0997660830616951, 0.33915868401527405, -0.6023460030555725, -0.3769535720348358, 0.050896503031253815, -0.5977300405502319, 0.21666565537452698, -0.5679373741149902, -0.10292462259531021, -0.048362232744693756, 0.22003354132175446, 0.13172978162765503, 0.34618493914604187, 0.10250260680913925, 0.2185819298028946, -0.14963823556900024, 0.058419033885002136, 0.6924841403961182, 0.6311233639717102, -0.522476315498352, 0.3345737159252167, -0.2595613896846771, -0.6965864300727844, -0.056354742497205734, 0.0954827219247818, -0.291052907705307, 0.036348726600408554, 0.25377023220062256, 0.4041527211666107, 0.19913440942764282, -0.8332057595252991, 0.780665934085846, -0.25560522079467773, -0.32271766662597656, -0.5466789603233337, 0.06452586501836777, 0.10078924149274826, 0.22391420602798462, 0.3503449261188507, 0.386502742767334, 0.2506832182407379, -0.5902400612831116, 0.3973441421985626, 0.4119613468647003, -0.6670809388160706, -0.435914009809494, 0.40254563093185425, 0.41668960452079773, -0.6096542477607727, 0.48091253638267517, 0.061359141021966934, -0.4572446048259735, 0.7377753853797913, 0.1732698231935501, 0.8300489187240601, -0.30877381563186646, -0.015912571921944618, 0.7722360491752625, 0.06391936540603638, 0.18626241385936737, 0.45546087622642517, -0.286893755197525, -0.6452712416648865, 0.17208100855350494, -0.3376900255680084, 0.30739906430244446, 0.47254499793052673, -0.7433472275733948, 0.3332369029521942, -0.45879361033439636, -0.31681278347969055, 0.06426826864480972, -0.3182377815246582, -0.23887476325035095, -0.16952115297317505, 0.3743510842323303, 0.47529667615890503, -0.9210126996040344, 0.2962889075279236, 0.6716427206993103, -0.06304113566875458, -0.017866458743810654, 0.0906493291258812, -0.1185457855463028, -0.5792887210845947, 0.5115571022033691, 0.642955482006073, -0.03496868535876274, -0.14801429212093353, -0.5302330851554871, -0.5246119499206543, 0.7812438607215881, -0.25949424505233765, -0.7079187035560608, 0.04361779987812042, -0.15351003408432007, 0.6501113176345825, -0.5667442083358765, -0.025488130748271942, 0.23493601381778717, 0.36001119017601013, 0.12244485318660736, -0.44897884130477905, -0.20488300919532776, -0.3491761088371277, 0.07067455351352692, 0.40087300539016724, -0.21363896131515503, 0.9749367833137512, -0.5188454985618591, -0.5303052067756653, -0.10952187329530716, 0.41422519087791443, 0.0803588479757309, 0.6287886500358582, 0.8099674582481384, 0.6143254637718201, 0.5538373589515686, 0.30005592107772827, 0.5577560663223267, -0.12117134034633636, 0.4126635193824768, 0.9681148529052734, -0.22718074917793274, 1.0128371715545654, 0.5789056420326233, 0.006699163466691971, 0.5919368863105774, 0.500583291053772, -0.12294883280992508, 0.8880078792572021, 0.2351292371749878, -0.19063079357147217, -0.381607323884964, -0.12201660871505737, -0.3199388086795807, 0.3097934424877167, 0.5805647373199463, -1.137439250946045, -0.21260571479797363, 0.3975282609462738, 0.0771525576710701, 0.24926349520683289, -0.4899556636810303, 1.068055510520935, -0.11761130392551422, -0.5966007709503174, 0.7584779262542725, -0.20327085256576538, 0.7250176668167114, -0.3092908263206482, -0.11235416680574417, -0.13760244846343994, 0.46079567074775696, -0.17470407485961914, -0.684394359588623, 0.4650340974330902, -0.06941942125558853, -0.11915227770805359, -0.07515344768762589, 0.8217824697494507, -0.4645535349845886, -0.6560884714126587, 0.5623335242271423, 0.2881547212600708, 0.27180302143096924, -0.23801329731941223, -0.7396041750907898, -0.16912750899791718, -0.021668557077646255, -0.12525473535060883, 0.06255520135164261, 0.06540053337812424, 0.40034714341163635, 0.3135806620121002, 0.5814954042434692, 0.4237922430038452, -0.29286935925483704, -0.13339368999004364, 0.6370061635971069, -0.46798256039619446, -0.5304629802703857, -0.8808632493019104, 0.25759831070899963, -0.3171572685241699, -0.24574677646160126, 0.47644200921058655, 0.3916494846343994, 0.6762699484825134, -0.022349821403622627, 0.5340677499771118, -0.06452968716621399, 1.2805019617080688, -0.09862630814313889, 1.0058188438415527, -0.8704371452331543, 0.12820079922676086, 0.16498802602291107, -0.1910848468542099, -0.47309887409210205, 0.699942946434021, -0.4705107808113098, 0.1625671088695526, 0.40157684683799744, 0.8742114901542664, -0.10318002849817276, -0.1793268918991089, 0.26024383306503296, 0.3118465542793274, -0.15871480107307434, 0.7002769112586975, 0.6848874688148499, -0.4956560432910919, 0.5145072340965271, -0.4173853397369385, -0.14594057202339172, -0.8457895517349243, -0.46893054246902466, -1.132690191268921, -0.4486273527145386, -0.14573587477207184, -0.13028614223003387, 0.24552182853221893, 0.9299342632293701, 0.6559184193611145, -0.9110012650489807, -0.08918160945177078, -0.1525966227054596, 0.5694720149040222, -0.36507269740104675, -0.2891629636287689, 0.21927015483379364, 0.02877230942249298, -0.46318319439888, 0.060304783284664154, 0.284262090921402, -0.24762846529483795, -0.22138291597366333, 0.3428819179534912, -0.461252361536026, -0.23274794220924377, 0.35516950488090515, 0.279417484998703, -0.5096616744995117, -0.10553998500108719, 0.19460175931453705, -0.2815643548965454, 0.1425388604402542, 1.0676383972167969, -0.717555582523346, 0.520619809627533, 0.8283715844154358, 0.27119535207748413, -0.0464496873319149, 0.4565688371658325, 0.19484956562519073, -0.578765332698822, -0.22536931931972504, 0.5292593836784363, 0.36781156063079834, 0.0967002883553505, -0.4643005132675171, 0.18317528069019318, 0.575244128704071, -0.6506270170211792, -0.7048408389091492, -0.09477858245372772, -0.5619053840637207, -0.7030141949653625, 0.9582676291465759, -0.1145891323685646, -0.6441916823387146, -0.6158794164657593, -0.1311158537864685, -0.11644584685564041, -0.5405799150466919, 1.0345215797424316, 0.1684989184141159, -0.18144860863685608, -0.3378032445907593, -0.61473548412323, 0.2504962086677551, -0.13475777208805084, -0.642157256603241, 0.2066803127527237, 0.23013435304164886, 0.3690124750137329, 0.3811924159526825, 0.5997864007949829, 0.10964050143957138, 0.4573418200016022, -0.3967607021331787, -0.029343847185373306, -0.2588563859462738, -0.3932473063468933, -0.3033210337162018, 0.6164881587028503, -0.7011954188346863, -0.6966687440872192 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06782v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06782v3	Debating with More Persuasive LLMs Leads to More Truthful Answers	2024-02-09T21:05:01	2024-05-30T13:59:34	Akbir Khan, John Hughes, Dan Valentine, Laura Ruis, Kshitij Sachan, Ansh Radhakrishnan, Edward Grefenstette, Samuel R. Bowman, Tim Rocktäschel, Ethan Perez	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL	Common methods for aligning large language models (LLMs) with desired behaviour heavily rely on human-labelled data. However, as models grow increasingly sophisticated, they will surpass human expertise, and the role of human evaluation will evolve into non-experts overseeing experts. In anticipation of this, we ask: can weaker models assess the correctness of stronger models? We investigate this question in an analogous setting, where stronger models (experts) possess the necessary information to answer questions and weaker models (non-experts) lack this information. The method we evaluate is debate, where two LLM experts each argue for a different answer, and a non-expert selects the answer. We find that debate consistently helps both non-expert models and humans answer questions, achieving 76% and 88% accuracy respectively (naive baselines obtain 48% and 60%). Furthermore, optimising expert debaters for persuasiveness in an unsupervised manner improves non-expert ability to identify the truth in debates. Our results provide encouraging empirical evidence for the viability of aligning models with debate in the absence of ground truth.	[ -0.555378794670105, -0.6075484752655029, 0.7430617213249207, -0.1498936414718628, -0.014144007116556168, 0.22199460864067078, -0.4725700914859772, -0.2429105043411255, 0.014375750906765461, 0.5346598029136658, -0.2333459109067917, -0.10145583748817444, -0.7287992238998413, 0.07283884286880493, -0.151161327958107, 0.5903487801551819, 0.1993711143732071, 0.17684948444366455, -0.666688859462738, -0.3335995078086853, -0.3929712772369385, -0.6217560768127441, -0.35747307538986206, -0.6992340087890625, 0.668523907661438, 0.6013222336769104, 0.9609007835388184, 0.4085886776447296, 0.41429367661476135, 0.4223896861076355, -0.3869175612926483, 0.20289254188537598, -0.7247753739356995, 0.22054733335971832, -0.6046834588050842, -0.6978596448898315, -0.31727004051208496, 0.27617624402046204, 0.18259355425834656, 0.7657890319824219, -0.14669169485569, -0.04485649615526199, -0.034640319645404816, 0.5021190047264099, -0.3556939363479614, -0.36438900232315063, -1.1028231382369995, -0.1123318150639534, -0.2644716203212738, -0.2889811098575592, -0.3203889727592468, -0.23826400935649872, 0.3750704824924469, -0.1730121374130249, 0.10399266332387924, 0.04444175958633423, 1.2236298322677612, 0.34645310044288635, -0.6553346514701843, -0.15111804008483887, -0.44447919726371765, 0.6576738357543945, -1.061801791191101, 0.2067025899887085, 0.07126002758741379, 0.12312716990709305, -0.26493844389915466, -0.4118450880050659, -0.5062980055809021, -0.36223211884498596, 0.10915618389844894, 0.11465395241975784, -0.28816667199134827, 0.006733429152518511, 0.22907640039920807, 0.20950981974601746, -0.22341300547122955, 0.544418454170227, -0.29125121235847473, -0.12882228195667267, 0.8940798044204712, 0.11517948657274246, 0.0912311002612114, -0.23156829178333282, -0.4477800130844116, 0.11322008073329926, -0.5775280594825745, 0.017390897497534752, 0.6789740920066833, 0.17245064675807953, 0.2091406285762787, 0.6244331002235413, -0.1778007596731186, 0.5573940873146057, 0.5915344953536987, -0.12421054393053055, -0.23482459783554077, -0.12247871607542038, -0.11961979418992996, 0.0845104455947876, 0.6609152555465698, 0.53593909740448, 0.1497732698917389, -0.05315210297703743, -0.3379461467266083, 0.08535994589328766, 0.37813571095466614, -0.7244619727134705, -0.4923152029514313, 0.15147648751735687, -0.12839297950267792, -0.387742280960083, -0.06603509187698364, -0.653837263584137, -0.6138712167739868, -0.22728101909160614, 0.5476976037025452, 0.3133784532546997, -0.4748747646808624, 0.3067455589771271, -0.2482532411813736, 0.23887135088443756, 0.5008900165557861, -0.5794952511787415, 0.3377331495285034, 0.7926955819129944, 0.3715224266052246, -0.05569253861904144, 0.15437360107898712, -0.23983679711818695, 0.07495931535959244, -0.8777115941047668, 1.1464693546295166, -0.6713780164718628, -0.2700921297073364, -0.35438743233680725, -0.10373304039239883, -0.055917300283908844, -0.7319296598434448, 0.9507193565368652, -0.5606212615966797, 0.4766404926776886, -0.7026349306106567, -0.8586795330047607, -0.08165037631988525, 0.5088529586791992, -0.6613125205039978, 0.6756185293197632, -0.33889755606651306, -1.059183955192566, 0.17724011838436127, -0.5801342725753784, -0.19842815399169922, 0.01259949617087841, -0.39472851157188416, -0.44504421949386597, 0.22593261301517487, 0.37087342143058777, 0.35151931643486023, -0.5486804246902466, 0.5714232325553894, -0.5348165035247803, -0.025913933292031288, 0.6971930265426636, -0.6398714184761047, 0.5197098851203918, 0.033517930656671524, -0.41243457794189453, 0.10314098745584488, -0.31044134497642517, -0.06771721690893173, 0.20575165748596191, -0.34854650497436523, -0.16570228338241577, 0.20653478801250458, -0.4285512864589691, 0.0784962922334671, 0.1043633371591568, -0.5583204030990601, 0.20111161470413208, -0.5189061760902405, 0.5147582292556763, 1.0159839391708374, -0.0652456134557724, 0.3048098087310791, -0.597285807132721, 0.380282461643219, -0.18011866509914398, -0.21354448795318604, 0.34224897623062134, -0.7023436427116394, -0.9054104089736938, 0.29810985922813416, 0.6225728392601013, 0.42388105392456055, -0.5306659936904907, 0.08407678455114365, -0.31489354372024536, -0.6141844987869263, -0.7859218716621399, 0.25076353549957275, 0.46100589632987976, 0.9398493766784668, 0.18576295673847198, -0.3166281282901764, -0.5503140687942505, -0.9693982005119324, -0.45637330412864685, -0.42170801758766174, 0.15269708633422852, 0.549172580242157, 0.37377646565437317, 0.19868887960910797, 0.9460279941558838, -0.3923824429512024, 0.3805016875267029, -0.37695223093032837, 0.46285492181777954, 0.08532804995775223, 0.24646112322807312, 0.1140337586402893, -0.8227140307426453, -0.2955377399921417, 0.06048329919576645, -0.7895724177360535, -0.39229726791381836, -0.03889208287000656, -0.0759439766407013, 0.30536454916000366, 0.13663075864315033, -0.6972581148147583, 0.2549373209476471, 0.22368991374969482, -0.19707205891609192, 0.5995222926139832, -0.05068829655647278, 0.2622546851634979, -0.6665846109390259, -0.07668896019458771, 0.10799627006053925, -0.18664968013763428, -0.6450510025024414, -0.07334280014038086, -0.19572432339191437, 0.07373534142971039, -0.2652750611305237, 0.6836585998535156, -0.39035770297050476, 0.0350605770945549, -0.3979516923427582, 0.3483692705631256, 0.14570413529872894, 0.17618048191070557, 0.324687123298645, 0.7259212136268616, 0.35482117533683777, -0.4508335292339325, 0.3580913543701172, 0.24130772054195404, -0.5671824216842651, 0.7926794290542603, -0.8456847667694092, 0.512214183807373, -0.08637913316488266, 0.05534595623612404, -1.3255705833435059, -0.40346166491508484, -0.1543603241443634, -0.5093408823013306, 0.15627531707286835, -0.44704657793045044, -0.1351696103811264, -0.42981696128845215, -0.11578388512134552, -0.04320317134261131, 0.31764599680900574, -0.47099539637565613, 0.523003876209259, 0.602078378200531, -0.5538886189460754, -0.8259109258651733, -0.35211890935897827, 0.5581905841827393, -0.46647125482559204, -0.8803162574768066, 0.14604365825653076, -0.10251326858997345, -0.7798348665237427, 0.003991778939962387, -0.33080369234085083, -0.0862782821059227, 0.19321949779987335, 0.018192920833826065, 0.2458246797323227, -0.49090197682380676, 0.237293541431427, -0.20801281929016113, -0.11067019402980804, 0.08986694365739822, 0.13226398825645447, 0.25133857131004333, -0.13550634682178497, -0.5404896140098572, -0.44977617263793945, 0.19089724123477936, 0.4639131724834442, -0.106137216091156, 0.28319281339645386, 0.08044256269931793, -0.1349632740020752, 0.1732890009880066, -1.192175269126892, -0.27493828535079956, -0.5011201500892639, 0.3908499777317047, -0.4523058831691742, -0.9041771292686462, 0.2670256197452545, -0.09516657143831253, 0.19884631037712097, 0.5058010816574097, 0.5894820094108582, -0.2642980217933655, 1.1427137851715088, 0.4481278657913208, 0.011156123131513596, -0.2343464195728302, 0.18753600120544434, 0.17747293412685394, -0.5376619696617126, -0.3534124791622162, -0.6531720757484436, -0.5989236831665039, -0.15436908602714539, -0.4002530574798584, 0.2685193717479706, -0.0029932765755802393, -0.12567521631717682, 0.06819359958171844, -0.518231987953186, 0.5789729356765747, 0.11441882699728012, 0.059685930609703064, 0.2586306631565094, -0.15129497647285461, -0.013281987980008125, -0.28219541907310486, -0.7598700523376465, -0.8628736138343811, 0.9930664300918579, 0.45670101046562195, 0.906191349029541, 0.2002115100622177, 0.2714393138885498, 0.1278948038816452, 0.49397194385528564, -0.661432683467865, 0.7197950482368469, 0.2673484981060028, -0.9535132050514221, -0.23235124349594116, -0.4937029778957367, -0.8212123513221741, 0.45169535279273987, -0.45093774795532227, -0.2728000283241272, 0.26875367760658264, -0.05189387872815132, -0.4602491557598114, 0.663908064365387, -0.6352262496948242, 0.8188280463218689, -0.5823441743850708, -0.5314300656318665, -0.19305792450904846, -0.6813631057739258, 0.3075479567050934, 0.08207950741052628, 0.02718445472419262, -0.08933340013027191, -0.22264868021011353, 1.144429087638855, -0.3074028193950653, 0.7488523721694946, -0.12016786634922028, -0.38316619396209717, 0.33393365144729614, -0.15977151691913605, 0.36352211236953735, 0.017127111554145813, -0.23912298679351807, -0.1912303864955902, -0.29104161262512207, -0.47324448823928833, -0.8177744746208191, 0.562781572341919, -0.8893681764602661, -1.5370323657989502, -0.14815756678581238, -0.30369803309440613, -0.28451287746429443, -0.13019712269306183, -0.005889791529625654, 0.26999741792678833, -0.2831304371356964, 0.24885407090187073, 1.0632246732711792, 0.030301891267299652, 0.051236286759376526, 0.7551937699317932, 0.029606394469738007, -0.4524453282356262, 0.5972431302070618, 0.30143266916275024, 0.39282020926475525, 0.2886730134487152, 0.6425970196723938, -0.5387362241744995, -0.710700511932373, -0.40833839774131775, 0.18819107115268707, -0.8572717308998108, -0.23615536093711853, -0.7673861384391785, -0.05560282990336418, -0.26693931221961975, -0.1465400606393814, -0.5308548212051392, -0.5576915740966797, -0.14992015063762665, -0.3834865391254425, 0.2997901737689972, 0.8512998819351196, -0.004069440998136997, 0.0824299305677414, -0.3071292042732239, 0.07452117651700974, 0.9458810091018677, -0.2525056302547455, -0.012765674851834774, -0.8992061614990234, 0.24911153316497803, 0.033589500933885574, -0.5035204291343689, -1.0732219219207764, 0.0412665531039238, -0.23156574368476868, 0.7963030338287354, 0.6076547503471375, 0.20594970881938934, 0.9566273093223572, -0.21386393904685974, 0.7541149258613586, 0.026715422049164772, -0.7399052381515503, 0.33100512623786926, -0.22107993066310883, -0.1128649190068245, 0.6193469762802124, 0.5256116986274719, -0.2268730252981186, -0.29079338908195496, -0.7849494218826294, -0.6421974897384644, 0.33162298798561096, -0.031726062297821045, 0.2331220805644989, 0.14727060496807098, 0.33656468987464905, 0.07274606823921204, 0.19523924589157104, -0.7767651081085205, 0.14171862602233887, -0.004275744315236807, 0.2951924204826355, 0.16187909245491028, -0.401113897562027, -0.5692193508148193, -0.2969892621040344, 0.50383061170578, -0.004754093941301107, 0.02996864728629589, 0.2536349296569824, 0.1009402647614479, -0.3747580051422119, 0.6547787189483643, 0.5183365941047668, 0.7990350723266602, -0.06660622358322144, 0.47923731803894043, 0.47255241870880127, 0.2834317088127136, 0.2602020502090454, -0.0589483268558979, -0.003954229410737753, -0.11719081550836563, 0.4973652958869934, 0.8408299088478088, 0.2267492115497589, -0.6738155484199524, 0.6368882656097412, -0.04098333418369293, -0.5570511221885681, 0.15575465559959412, 0.16343136131763458, 0.612401008605957, 0.43806764483451843, 0.30916234850883484, 0.15615533292293549, -0.2665984034538269, -0.5901206135749817, 0.3222925662994385, 0.7275134921073914, -0.3440662622451782, -0.2577730417251587, 0.7008659243583679, 0.49471989274024963, -0.49429407715797424, 0.3153229355812073, 0.06544771045446396, -0.9007489681243896, 0.7241925001144409, 0.3334534764289856, 0.4480784833431244, -0.26659858226776123, 0.07011378556489944, 0.0885472223162651, 0.31462109088897705, -0.14613664150238037, 0.15847717225551605, 0.19872288405895233, -0.8033394813537598, -0.3914605379104614, -0.11638457328081131, -0.8845389485359192, 0.17594581842422485, -0.43745261430740356, 0.15188589692115784, -0.3780854642391205, -0.27022409439086914, 0.21543391048908234, 0.4882824420928955, -0.26098838448524475, 0.11976850032806396, 0.18878036737442017, 0.7777047753334045, -0.9150077700614929, 0.6190502047538757, 0.6887677907943726, -0.2335178554058075, -0.7595697045326233, -0.03169184923171997, -0.05847173184156418, -0.5653810501098633, 0.5867140293121338, 0.06493046134710312, -0.24151913821697235, -0.2995624840259552, -1.0025041103363037, -0.6068376898765564, 0.7091312408447266, 0.7109939455986023, -0.5606057643890381, 0.18087206780910492, -0.1602974534034729, 0.4985963702201843, -0.2995665967464447, 0.6137537360191345, 0.2825468182563782, 0.7607479095458984, 0.4984159469604492, -0.9820924997329712, -0.07065534591674805, -0.28387725353240967, -0.391031950712204, -0.18658111989498138, -0.6923160552978516, 0.8063251376152039, -0.5159366130828857, -0.25982651114463806, 0.09166334569454193, 0.9296232461929321, 0.15893679857254028, 0.26920464634895325, 0.6300103068351746, 0.6532644629478455, 1.1232216358184814, -0.04146919399499893, 0.7534351944923401, -0.03563448414206505, -0.02463848888874054, 0.9577718377113342, -0.5361599922180176, 0.9285081624984741, 0.21030215919017792, -0.19255587458610535, 0.5272679924964905, 0.7317807674407959, 0.045775528997182846, 0.2097514271736145, 0.2780503034591675, -0.17455853521823883, -0.8997749090194702, -0.13572147488594055, -0.30076006054878235, 0.3438296318054199, 0.20658837258815765, 0.26504388451576233, -0.2231079339981079, -0.36012834310531616, 0.43490102887153625, 0.5978471040725708, -0.11930499225854874, 0.77897709608078, -0.05905008688569069, -0.9626150131225586, 0.7763515114784241, 0.17537803947925568, 0.7231852412223816, -0.23697403073310852, 0.24477669596672058, -0.2105253040790558, -0.06647364050149918, -0.3067052960395813, -1.042588472366333, 0.07623495906591415, 0.17831937968730927, 0.06211544945836067, -0.06903047114610672, 0.8264226913452148, -0.4810536801815033, -0.41477957367897034, 0.06380020081996918, 0.6755928993225098, 0.2467518001794815, 0.2302400767803192, -0.8807390928268433, -0.107672318816185, -0.026681886985898018, -0.33284544944763184, 0.3290609121322632, 0.45635902881622314, -0.02494477480649948, 0.8918167352676392, 0.4552432894706726, -0.02977067418396473, -0.15198448300361633, -0.15007944405078888, 1.1776944398880005, -0.337888240814209, -0.06717757135629654, -1.028932809829712, 0.3604862093925476, -0.424054890871048, -0.12811541557312012, 0.9075620770454407, 0.5192943215370178, 0.4815461039543152, 0.30274516344070435, 0.6655805110931396, 0.2099660038948059, 0.5325055718421936, -0.3736685812473297, 0.5916904807090759, -0.5350577235221863, 0.2975905239582062, -0.2683151662349701, -0.4095832109451294, 0.0206595528870821, 0.7468482851982117, -0.7651212811470032, -0.03920016437768936, 0.3451428711414337, 0.9788947105407715, 0.06972462683916092, 0.23470395803451538, 0.24889527261257172, 0.36682644486427307, 0.3469236493110657, 0.7294045686721802, 1.3023537397384644, 0.06736238300800323, 0.388349324464798, 0.07342644780874252, -0.18543368577957153, 0.037159837782382965, -0.9025662541389465, -1.2693902254104614, -0.17639467120170593, -0.5090660452842712, -0.1680915653705597, 0.2022191733121872, 0.9094527959823608, 0.5819235444068909, -0.47731712460517883, -0.3804645836353302, 0.3072616159915924, 0.5539180040359497, 0.00907474011182785, -0.12598013877868652, 0.19428803026676178, -0.14220614731311798, -0.7044592499732971, 0.5854938626289368, 0.1881384402513504, -0.12167906016111374, -0.34594905376434326, -0.26217570900917053, -0.27588605880737305, 0.7982982397079468, 0.19589051604270935, 0.26965954899787903, -0.8172953128814697, -0.1972859501838684, -0.1534557193517685, -0.08834575116634369, 0.3731776773929596, 0.5651043057441711, -0.7420769333839417, 0.37929457426071167, 0.4194185733795166, 0.7960394024848938, 0.15218718349933624, 0.45891955494880676, 0.5021252632141113, -0.34303057193756104, -0.15109068155288696, 0.3469145894050598, 0.14399956166744232, 0.597814679145813, -0.13898460566997528, 0.3718138039112091, 0.3343810439109802, -0.7289907932281494, -1.0623518228530884, 0.18067976832389832, -0.7401248812675476, -0.3171830475330353, 1.0364315509796143, -0.14734716713428497, -0.07889404892921448, -0.3813017010688782, -0.2623785436153412, -0.14504657685756683, -0.2754170298576355, 0.764776885509491, 0.9508412480354309, -0.15177574753761292, -0.20896375179290771, -0.5162125825881958, 0.3478895127773285, 0.7319133877754211, -0.6738197803497314, 0.23714905977249146, 0.21517573297023773, 0.4034019410610199, 0.11772587150335312, 0.7356206774711609, 0.07681668549776077, -0.09599558264017105, -0.12093554437160492, -0.3622187674045563, 0.035777539014816284, -0.33460715413093567, -0.07144417613744736, 0.4004034101963043, 0.39393553137779236, 0.459596186876297 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06766v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06766v1	Evaluation Metrics for Text Data Augmentation in NLP	2024-02-09T19:59:34	2024-02-09T19:59:34	Marcellus Amadeus, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Recent surveys on data augmentation for natural language processing have reported different techniques and advancements in the field. Several frameworks, tools, and repositories promote the implementation of text data augmentation pipelines. However, a lack of evaluation criteria and standards for method comparison due to different tasks, metrics, datasets, architectures, and experimental settings makes comparisons meaningless. Also, a lack of methods unification exists and text data augmentation research would benefit from unified metrics to compare different augmentation methods. Thus, academics and the industry endeavor relevant evaluation metrics for text data augmentation techniques. The contribution of this work is to provide a taxonomy of evaluation metrics for text augmentation methods and serve as a direction for a unified benchmark. The proposed taxonomy organizes categories that include tools for implementation and metrics calculation. Finally, with this study, we intend to present opportunities to explore the unification and standardization of text data augmentation metrics.	[ -0.3775445520877838, -0.43072280287742615, 0.19762593507766724, 0.5270869731903076, -0.27123013138771057, 0.24234715104103088, -0.20874901115894318, -0.5419753193855286, 0.23138080537319183, 0.40384960174560547, -0.40623021125793457, -0.6543893814086914, -0.43284255266189575, 0.5533249378204346, -0.4712306559085846, 0.983986496925354, -0.015903133898973465, 0.04842985048890114, -0.6608107089996338, -0.2912324368953705, -0.6541340351104736, -0.47509297728538513, -0.2598015367984772, -0.4627067744731903, 0.1572379767894745, 0.21475988626480103, 0.6854492425918579, 0.48790284991264343, 1.0167673826217651, 0.314334511756897, -0.108909010887146, 0.32590338587760925, 0.1340782791376114, -0.04853666201233864, -0.25931602716445923, -0.10151039808988571, -0.6293502449989319, -0.05485743284225464, 0.937444269657135, 0.9118372797966003, 0.04808097332715988, 0.23026175796985626, 0.20263218879699707, 0.7334221601486206, -0.7970939874649048, -0.08530154079198837, -0.4521107077598572, 0.3843172788619995, -0.16768015921115875, -0.6070753335952759, -0.0027923863381147385, -0.4716397821903229, 0.19467028975486755, -0.4504450261592865, 0.013810482807457447, -0.010108222253620625, 0.41388317942619324, 0.21789376437664032, -0.2708461880683899, -0.3582601249217987, -0.6131889820098877, 0.8642604947090149, -0.8170740604400635, 0.46903252601623535, -0.045158110558986664, -0.05300905555486679, 0.1299324631690979, -0.797376811504364, -0.45995113253593445, -0.1744213104248047, -0.4019657075405121, 0.09818749874830246, -0.32073715329170227, 0.24378658831119537, 0.10757392644882202, 0.9227767586708069, -0.602251410484314, 0.24634654819965363, -0.012438303790986538, -0.1742255538702011, 0.6576215028762817, 0.31175798177719116, 0.3752625584602356, -0.46492570638656616, -0.5075927376747131, -0.09906329959630966, -0.05409333482384682, -0.19826649129390717, 0.5137979984283447, 0.1476459503173828, 0.07953799515962601, 0.7022287845611572, -0.45365050435066223, 0.856342613697052, -0.4724142849445343, -0.0815182477235794, 0.8086757063865662, -0.8012283444404602, -0.4021119475364685, -0.13099505007266998, 0.919631838798523, 0.5848182439804077, -0.3487713634967804, -0.6322413682937622, -0.43598994612693787, 0.1527250111103058, 0.43379586935043335, -0.4895189106464386, 0.16081775724887848, 0.04880065098404884, -0.4247162640094757, -0.34041017293930054, 0.1424412727355957, -0.8375636339187622, -0.2657005786895752, -0.4132935106754303, 0.56315678358078, -0.4175542891025543, -0.1456378847360611, 0.34431192278862, -0.4495542645454407, 0.10549332946538925, -0.03603343293070793, -0.7867838740348816, 0.6107611060142517, 1.037784457206726, 0.9182245135307312, -0.6304195523262024, -0.14770802855491638, 0.022607680410146713, -0.3425274193286896, -0.2457142174243927, 0.7934624552726746, -0.626109778881073, -0.3815802335739136, 0.12150029838085175, -0.17226862907409668, 0.009932270273566246, -0.4283433258533478, 1.4191805124282837, -0.29891490936279297, 0.6115210056304932, 0.14457310736179352, -0.8192862868309021, -0.3505191206932068, 0.21349382400512695, -0.44897401332855225, 1.431501030921936, 0.10988106578588486, -0.8497714996337891, 0.746652364730835, -0.9815859794616699, -0.4014579653739929, 0.3525831699371338, 0.04515818506479263, -0.3412869870662689, 0.08060083538293839, 0.33020055294036865, 0.44786542654037476, -0.4578610360622406, 0.3393299877643585, 0.10578081011772156, -0.5034365653991699, 0.08236013352870941, -0.5114715099334717, 0.6526944637298584, -0.04246840626001358, 0.003916110377758741, 0.10382120311260223, -0.8961403965950012, 0.31188997626304626, -0.37530553340911865, -0.2999303936958313, -0.5593000650405884, -0.13020145893096924, 0.3584256172180176, -0.12286172062158585, 0.46959102153778076, -0.6059454679489136, 0.12406066060066223, -0.7171286344528198, 0.0176611989736557, 0.29796651005744934, 0.11775410175323486, 0.6620513796806335, -0.16406294703483582, 0.38471275568008423, -0.15582798421382904, 0.11012748628854752, -0.23163534700870514, -0.37922966480255127, -0.5503081679344177, -0.015889471396803856, 0.6436870098114014, 0.523266613483429, -0.6123843193054199, 1.1088906526565552, -0.566807746887207, -0.7980912327766418, -0.6313222050666809, 0.09628884494304657, 0.504432201385498, 0.6067724227905273, 0.5400922894477844, -0.7489961385726929, -0.8140016198158264, -0.82440584897995, -0.46728116273880005, -0.06966585665941238, -0.5353265404701233, -0.11200830340385437, 0.2530912756919861, -0.18100200593471527, 1.1359541416168213, -0.3208702802658081, -0.5109210014343262, 0.031269803643226624, 0.45303505659103394, 0.26572367548942566, 0.5016191601753235, 0.35192185640335083, -0.7425987720489502, -0.07033351063728333, -0.04324091225862503, -0.6750844120979309, -0.2751830816268921, -0.029598576948046684, 0.3865896165370941, 0.15831466019153595, 0.2719443738460541, -0.08486520498991013, 0.40997830033302307, 0.6510591506958008, -0.1738683432340622, 0.727641761302948, -0.25528186559677124, 0.5082266330718994, -0.8469483852386475, 0.19431687891483307, 0.31056487560272217, -0.0563223697245121, -0.8006685972213745, 0.1468769907951355, 0.10797113925218582, 0.2190055102109909, -0.1186518445611, 0.46973782777786255, -0.298357218503952, -0.349189817905426, -0.19701503217220306, 0.5741537809371948, 0.2460169792175293, 0.05138125270605087, -0.028085989877581596, 0.80186927318573, 0.5555077791213989, -0.6663599014282227, 0.5104352235794067, 0.20326340198516846, -0.4597727060317993, 0.7033525705337524, -0.8218037486076355, -0.12298642843961716, 0.07319562882184982, 0.10223883390426636, -0.7787976861000061, 0.25903961062431335, 0.15905560553073883, -0.7177642583847046, 0.023692172020673752, 0.34730491042137146, -0.8232859969139099, -0.3663844168186188, -0.4893973469734192, 0.11656971275806427, 0.4176795780658722, -0.4988802373409271, 0.1066836267709732, 0.3898891806602478, -0.032931551337242126, -0.8096314668655396, -0.6768309473991394, 0.44846418499946594, -0.3265992999076843, -0.5142586827278137, 0.808857262134552, -0.12050236761569977, -0.05163043364882469, -0.0348825640976429, -0.06110874190926552, -0.07245799899101257, -0.08399563282728195, -0.07468906044960022, 0.2162446528673172, -0.15801648795604706, 0.3878649175167084, 0.052394136786460876, -0.23120956122875214, 0.06530170887708664, -0.23669689893722534, 0.21441321074962616, -0.07850910723209381, -0.32298314571380615, -0.3162224590778351, 0.11796586215496063, -0.05655548349022865, -0.11770882457494736, 0.4469186067581177, 0.9045647382736206, -0.3233036994934082, 0.3275158703327179, -0.5500330924987793, -0.07222610712051392, -0.38301920890808105, 0.4042088985443115, -0.22635172307491302, -0.8162257671356201, 0.20620816946029663, -0.17189736664295197, 0.30055853724479675, 0.6124475002288818, 0.23339498043060303, 0.15485474467277527, 1.0322399139404297, 0.7310144305229187, -0.011847449466586113, 0.22265194356441498, 0.09508667141199112, 0.15523003041744232, -1.1919326782226562, -0.15908920764923096, -0.8695569038391113, -0.2817385494709015, -0.7285446524620056, -0.4202394485473633, 0.0963820219039917, 0.16869044303894043, 0.16916720569133759, 0.5711334347724915, -1.0370848178863525, 0.38233816623687744, 0.17864619195461273, -0.2889183461666107, 0.7549005150794983, 0.13593606650829315, -0.19334349036216736, -0.39547327160835266, -0.6041041016578674, -0.6388275027275085, 1.1333633661270142, 0.4469038248062134, 0.3750692307949066, -0.13355408608913422, 0.43826237320899963, 0.46481525897979736, 0.22982418537139893, -0.8649256229400635, 0.480647474527359, -0.29571056365966797, -0.2997485399246216, -0.36150625348091125, -0.5436246395111084, -0.9824864268302917, 0.2708882987499237, -0.4843871295452118, -0.9756462574005127, 0.16414739191532135, -0.3411533236503601, 0.15631994605064392, 0.1489517092704773, -0.5682340860366821, 0.7882909178733826, 0.04179781675338745, 0.06921315938234329, 0.06690818071365356, -0.43854793906211853, 0.27720943093299866, -0.07457786798477173, 0.10402887314558029, 0.011769542470574379, -0.5208519697189331, 0.9523559212684631, -0.21519893407821655, 0.31551414728164673, 0.07270967960357666, -0.10334508121013641, -0.038371238857507706, -0.5589199662208557, -0.028264883905649185, 0.031560495495796204, -0.3307966887950897, 0.35653090476989746, -0.04746241122484207, -0.016732078045606613, -0.7395382523536682, 0.5372289419174194, -0.3017130196094513, -0.09316027909517288, -0.4205307960510254, -0.5065745711326599, -0.4395178556442261, 0.07659543305635452, 0.12880872189998627, 0.5650508999824524, -0.4187481999397278, 0.35926201939582825, 0.3469140827655792, -0.18559497594833374, 0.6820192337036133, 0.40031540393829346, -0.32157930731773376, -0.4326283037662506, 0.764570951461792, -0.1483718603849411, 0.08245944231748581, 0.6408303380012512, 0.035973306745290756, -0.8098351955413818, -0.6247609853744507, -0.3740895092487335, -0.2793436050415039, -0.5587127804756165, -0.4442976713180542, -0.7210327386856079, -0.2832040786743164, -0.3263949453830719, -0.07225306332111359, -0.09299837797880173, -0.6541386246681213, -0.2599244713783264, -0.020438192412257195, 0.5755036473274231, 0.3572065830230713, -0.04451204836368561, 0.44332200288772583, -0.8917809724807739, 0.21647681295871735, -0.06984270364046097, 0.7670930624008179, 0.03328735753893852, -0.4808714687824249, -0.26201456785202026, -0.023913566023111343, -0.3367193043231964, -0.6223540306091309, 0.3380111753940582, 0.18956337869167328, 0.5850633978843689, 0.16014043986797333, -0.08810283988714218, 0.7205856442451477, -0.4101276993751526, 0.7750356793403625, 0.464550256729126, -1.0434166193008423, 0.4706646203994751, -0.09435809403657913, 0.271445631980896, 0.7086538076400757, 0.17785364389419556, -0.7240145802497864, -0.32961219549179077, -0.7591504454612732, -1.0574429035186768, 0.3411959707736969, 0.42701154947280884, 0.3401795029640198, 0.2814650535583496, 0.20442210137844086, 0.14140988886356354, 0.35580796003341675, -0.6353251338005066, -0.43455737829208374, 0.2790963649749756, -0.08084630221128464, -0.1160130426287651, 0.10735964775085449, -0.050629034638404846, -0.4143279492855072, 0.5793353915214539, 0.008148488588631153, 0.10940629988908768, 0.1998235583305359, -0.039514701813459396, 0.31390494108200073, 0.6344091892242432, 0.17346611618995667, 0.7348765730857849, -0.2587541937828064, -0.20712824165821075, 0.214142307639122, -0.6995261907577515, 0.04023627191781998, 0.35218504071235657, -0.21745090186595917, 0.5523426532745361, 0.2705271542072296, 0.6675946116447449, 0.2718428075313568, -0.5501934885978699, 0.37039119005203247, -0.19909387826919556, -0.15335513651371002, -0.043548859655857086, -0.013682426884770393, -0.36444520950317383, -0.3259377181529999, 0.5963898301124573, 0.2354888617992401, 0.7593706250190735, -0.26062652468681335, 0.44872888922691345, 0.4065064489841461, -0.7073908448219299, 0.11100292205810547, 0.18738128244876862, 0.27359795570373535, -0.43645524978637695, 0.12639693915843964, -0.3991124629974365, -0.13479271531105042, 0.3708326518535614, 0.4004799425601959, 0.9530172348022461, -0.12190157175064087, 0.2952719032764435, 0.4540179967880249, 0.5316880345344543, 0.20048068463802338, 0.16122867166996002, 0.07480945438146591, -0.6282018423080444, -0.697155237197876, -0.8446329236030579, -0.5346605777740479, 0.06522505730390549, -0.6968332529067993, 0.3852185308933258, -0.04584384337067604, -0.14836136996746063, 0.2361186444759369, 0.31269583106040955, -0.5979822278022766, 0.44818079471588135, -0.2625870108604431, 1.013106107711792, -0.5388898849487305, 0.2373557686805725, 0.8564543724060059, -0.2809411883354187, -0.27117490768432617, 0.05341207608580589, -0.09485329687595367, -0.3113349378108978, 0.16908684372901917, 0.2575380206108093, -0.011618722230196, -0.14325623214244843, 0.07460714131593704, -0.49376991391181946, 0.876200258731842, -0.1551264077425003, -0.2622007131576538, 0.16187074780464172, 0.3754633665084839, 0.9040162563323975, -0.5543319582939148, 0.5393202304840088, 0.8528540730476379, 0.5829055905342102, -0.23468266427516937, -1.0098280906677246, -0.161298468708992, -0.3454834520816803, 0.3130551278591156, 0.3190576434135437, -0.02468530274927616, 0.21531353890895844, 0.30638056993484497, -0.3279983699321747, 0.1375696361064911, 0.5833001732826233, 0.007169464137405157, 0.35373595356941223, 0.5233289003372192, 0.8039980530738831, 0.4648163318634033, -0.31059059500694275, 0.889788806438446, -0.08954893052577972, 0.462772399187088, 0.9440962672233582, 0.08562619984149933, 0.6053072214126587, 0.3937038481235504, -0.4507346451282501, 0.3586891293525696, 0.5702869892120361, -0.11251670867204666, 0.057946596294641495, 0.17909106612205505, -0.2960241138935089, 0.40891405940055847, -0.45871248841285706, -0.5068950057029724, 0.5103625655174255, 0.4821642339229584, -0.2737073004245758, -0.288752019405365, -0.09718397259712219, -0.13242408633232117, 0.29967594146728516, -0.37582311034202576, 1.0034863948822021, -0.16157199442386627, -0.5006101131439209, 0.3645000159740448, 0.3620278537273407, 1.1255955696105957, -0.3967296779155731, 0.060390908271074295, 0.029900433495640755, -0.11474388092756271, -0.6106182336807251, -1.1199662685394287, 0.5873704552650452, 0.14712519943714142, -0.15103468298912048, -0.16896021366119385, 0.7278813123703003, -0.1705084890127182, -0.5040259957313538, 0.35532909631729126, 0.4149217903614044, 0.10940895229578018, 0.04156307131052017, -0.8961465954780579, -0.08586916327476501, -0.21132348477840424, 0.017728298902511597, 0.14514583349227905, 0.2521107494831085, 0.30032750964164734, 0.44918641448020935, 0.6421018838882446, 0.21317943930625916, -0.18922297656536102, 0.4583049416542053, 0.5842467546463013, -0.3931674063205719, -0.3572207987308502, -0.6837428212165833, 0.7299469113349915, -0.5116352438926697, -0.45752695202827454, 1.082839012145996, 0.7986413240432739, 0.7214632034301758, 0.10762867331504822, 0.6744345426559448, -0.11963771283626556, 0.7406572103500366, -0.45609694719314575, 0.4257921576499939, -0.5799224376678467, 0.29297396540641785, -0.9107791781425476, -1.334758996963501, -0.5122206211090088, 0.267222136259079, -0.20313142240047455, -0.010244441218674183, 0.7428777813911438, 0.5479472875595093, 0.09126544743776321, 0.28401389718055725, 0.12051913142204285, -0.3593738377094269, -0.1901361495256424, -0.02082611434161663, 0.5032070279121399, -0.7877010703086853, 0.41171154379844666, -0.24581633508205414, -0.29172438383102417, -0.06890883296728134, -1.112688422203064, -0.39595478773117065, -0.7776409387588501, -0.3835376799106598, 0.17590190470218658, -0.05536723881959915, 0.44121086597442627, 0.4063890874385834, -0.5442295670509338, -0.2508992552757263, -0.2727203071117401, 0.3360946774482727, -0.3886275589466095, -0.37550875544548035, 0.2629801034927368, -0.645646870136261, -0.8989713191986084, 0.2786428928375244, 0.6408748626708984, -0.1948765516281128, -0.4157216548919678, 0.11492455005645752, -0.15753138065338135, -0.053580790758132935, 0.5877327919006348, 0.060095805674791336, -0.40462934970855713, -0.07973642647266388, -0.04334799200296402, 0.11709726601839066, 0.28657183051109314, 0.7130001187324524, -0.7212855219841003, 0.6726088523864746, 0.5705831050872803, 0.7976011633872986, -0.11264386028051376, 0.11979290843009949, 0.5069710612297058, -1.334678292274475, 0.1282813549041748, 0.3907196521759033, 0.0488550178706646, 0.564674437046051, -0.21771924197673798, 0.8290783762931824, -0.05416290834546089, -0.6532787680625916, -0.8515910506248474, -0.00760807516053319, -0.7846708297729492, 0.019749820232391357, 0.6979147791862488, 0.10704643279314041, 0.24337613582611084, -0.13095425069332123, 0.04468098282814026, 0.0720619261264801, -0.28003984689712524, 0.5152621865272522, 0.657889723777771, -0.1915338784456253, -0.0426955483853817, -0.49329042434692383, 0.6127011179924011, 0.37654969096183777, -1.2423409223556519, -0.1502351462841034, 0.3883323669433594, -0.32530835270881653, 0.537624180316925, 0.563594400882721, -0.4422242343425751, 0.05950435250997543, -0.10354326665401459, 0.16824159026145935, 0.4837453365325928, -0.012278151698410511, -0.5850165486335754, -0.06115394085645676, -0.28264421224594116, -0.05887135490775108 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06738v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06738v1	EntGPT: Linking Generative Large Language Models with Knowledge Bases	2024-02-09T19:16:27	2024-02-09T19:16:27	Yifan Ding, Amrit Poudel, Qingkai Zeng, Tim Weninger, Balaji Veeramani, Sanmitra Bhattacharya	cs.CL	cs.CL	The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate factually correct output remains relatively unexplored due to the lack of fact-checking and knowledge grounding during training and inference. In this work, we aim to address this challenge through the Entity Disambiguation (ED) task. We first consider prompt engineering, and design a three-step hard-prompting method to probe LLMs' ED performance without supervised fine-tuning (SFT). Overall, the prompting method improves the micro-F_1 score of the original vanilla models by a large margin, on some cases up to 36% and higher, and obtains comparable performance across 10 datasets when compared to existing methods with SFT. We further improve the knowledge grounding ability through instruction tuning (IT) with similar prompts and responses. The instruction-tuned model not only achieves higher micro-F1 score performance as compared to several baseline methods on supervised entity disambiguation tasks with an average micro-F_1 improvement of 2.1% over the existing baseline models, but also obtains higher accuracy on six Question Answering (QA) tasks in the zero-shot setting. Our methodologies apply to both open- and closed-source LLMs.	[ -0.5400742292404175, -1.1298032999038696, 0.7826611399650574, 0.04791243374347687, -0.16456490755081177, -0.0038125913124531507, -0.5744739174842834, -0.15465782582759857, -0.059570908546447754, 0.34854236245155334, -0.5614168643951416, -0.7434617877006531, -0.42116379737854004, 0.2510864734649658, -0.1581840217113495, 0.7415601015090942, -0.10220728069543839, -0.07592089474201202, -0.408374160528183, 0.20286577939987183, -0.44973066449165344, -0.017189137637615204, -0.7814596891403198, -0.2636135518550873, 0.4343581795692444, 0.6301853656768799, 0.5010924339294434, 0.7761394381523132, 0.11479338258504868, 0.2700257897377014, -0.30067795515060425, 0.40726014971733093, -0.44226163625717163, 0.31648772954940796, -0.2768948972225189, -0.3924468755722046, -0.32878318428993225, -0.24788440763950348, 0.5264321565628052, 0.8179740309715271, -0.18536138534545898, 0.26466795802116394, 0.1523827612400055, 0.5489862561225891, -0.3985678255558014, 0.4175502061843872, -0.7992570400238037, -0.2948482036590576, -0.05123308300971985, -0.237297922372818, -0.5738711357116699, -0.30566659569740295, -0.10327277332544327, -0.684387743473053, 0.4458332657814026, 0.30496492981910706, 0.7901895046234131, 0.6545900702476501, -0.41467228531837463, -0.33580854535102844, -0.47928550839424133, 0.4594699740409851, -0.7522721886634827, 0.5450960397720337, 0.28681764006614685, -0.13374698162078857, -0.2598643898963928, -0.44712725281715393, -0.703248918056488, -0.37312018871307373, -0.049758538603782654, -0.0783354640007019, 0.05699295550584793, 0.4724668562412262, 0.7586010098457336, 0.29161930084228516, -0.48678791522979736, 0.3065325915813446, -0.2806510627269745, 0.009449027478694916, 0.33772459626197815, -0.14915452897548676, 0.20566144585609436, -0.2475159615278244, -0.25673073530197144, 0.16218984127044678, -1.111363410949707, -0.27760276198387146, 0.39678478240966797, 0.40067771077156067, 0.10812468826770782, 0.7971338033676147, -0.45757707953453064, 0.885718047618866, 0.38087424635887146, 0.017441941425204277, 0.0952848568558693, 0.0008570909267291427, -0.4274010956287384, 0.2195783406496048, 0.6254096031188965, 0.3637829124927521, 0.32537415623664856, -0.3740137219429016, -0.2661435604095459, -0.051857054233551025, 0.027275491505861282, -0.8951973915100098, -0.40207532048225403, 0.08745045959949493, -0.028228910639882088, -0.11610113829374313, -0.18960359692573547, -0.7762838006019592, -0.2426077276468277, -0.6993520259857178, 0.46244317293167114, -0.6565338969230652, -0.18328529596328735, 0.10869978368282318, 0.11760343611240387, 0.06288070976734161, 0.35070404410362244, -1.0066332817077637, -0.09847480058670044, 0.5905156135559082, 0.6901259422302246, 0.062113601714372635, -0.027777453884482384, -0.5591715574264526, 0.20537641644477844, -0.39886316657066345, 0.6294587254524231, -0.5049106478691101, -0.23732008039951324, -0.05698305740952492, -0.06612109392881393, -0.03890380263328552, -0.5843470692634583, 0.5495505332946777, -0.8374946713447571, 0.09209815412759781, -0.503899097442627, -0.7915428876876831, -0.14366140961647034, 0.3196358382701874, -0.4486467242240906, 1.0144078731536865, 0.03956921771168709, -0.6385970115661621, 0.3871559500694275, -0.6796147227287292, -0.4140090048313141, 0.08747456967830658, -0.31103530526161194, -0.016271939501166344, 0.1259322464466095, 0.4923361539840698, 0.48602479696273804, -0.34400638937950134, 0.6829260587692261, -0.12428171187639236, -0.31144511699676514, -0.37836697697639465, -0.313132643699646, 0.7346311807632446, 0.05080941319465637, -0.44631075859069824, -0.06472877413034439, -0.9351617097854614, 0.06088652461767197, 0.030606213957071304, -0.649054229259491, -0.39612817764282227, -0.18378983438014984, -0.484793484210968, 0.03776713088154793, 0.073558509349823, -0.5696370601654053, 0.37294936180114746, -0.5087281465530396, 0.4081644117832184, 0.7279061675071716, 0.15169113874435425, 0.36109045147895813, 0.00045862136175855994, 0.29210546612739563, 0.019841117784380913, -0.32039159536361694, -0.3465023934841156, -0.4799216687679291, -1.102721095085144, -0.15858900547027588, 0.5418516397476196, 0.47605687379837036, -1.245280385017395, 0.4572207033634186, -0.37331148982048035, -0.32951870560646057, -0.5099639296531677, 0.09347649663686752, 0.2594565153121948, 0.899304211139679, 0.5049541592597961, 0.19870625436306, -0.4468069076538086, -0.8228825926780701, -0.09051499515771866, -0.43456029891967773, -0.3341469168663025, 0.283174067735672, 0.3640202283859253, -0.032729435712099075, 0.7860060930252075, -0.4977690279483795, 0.16558308899402618, 0.12477198988199234, 0.14515253901481628, 0.2965105473995209, 0.4619187116622925, 0.43240368366241455, -0.449329137802124, -0.4089316129684448, -0.094633087515831, -0.8549113273620605, -0.22547797858715057, 0.19076962769031525, -0.19971100986003876, 0.10098107159137726, 0.6330599784851074, -1.0467424392700195, -0.12680202722549438, 0.22724184393882751, -0.2131752073764801, 0.3144747316837311, -0.04372762143611908, 0.4415757656097412, -1.0049035549163818, -0.09238763898611069, 0.1590450555086136, -0.09057022631168365, -0.5267757177352905, 0.2336268126964569, 0.11291993409395218, -0.12028991430997849, -0.22430860996246338, 0.2722558081150055, -0.6329999566078186, 0.2741781175136566, -0.0969415232539177, 0.21324971318244934, -0.030391644686460495, 0.5428401231765747, -0.16883638501167297, 0.9312557578086853, 0.741115927696228, -0.8865672945976257, 0.6188870072364807, 0.3384020924568176, -0.4414518475532532, 0.5086025595664978, -0.6883357763290405, 0.3048360049724579, -0.4302634000778198, -0.1219070553779602, -0.8334255218505859, -0.42291298508644104, 0.237127423286438, -0.29258739948272705, 0.7268950343132019, -0.4141193926334381, -0.7275071740150452, -0.1837143748998642, 0.0576418936252594, 0.17904451489448547, 0.5553871989250183, -0.730704665184021, 0.48947519063949585, 0.04515422135591507, -0.3325747549533844, -0.34549084305763245, -0.36362361907958984, 0.025694772601127625, -0.2625204622745514, -0.7829957008361816, 0.3500615954399109, 0.09306661039590836, -0.3390207290649414, 0.04116752743721008, -0.23413430154323578, 0.14341241121292114, 0.08909422904253006, 0.09133154153823853, 0.23528063297271729, -0.6111662983894348, 0.665841817855835, 0.27027207612991333, 0.08157961070537567, 0.31351539492607117, -0.40448975563049316, 0.39807790517807007, 0.022299358621239662, -0.5669073462486267, 0.03814362362027168, 0.07785457372665405, 0.28717732429504395, -0.3074907660484314, 0.8733100295066833, 0.30916839838027954, -0.5916355848312378, -0.440316766500473, -0.6246122717857361, -0.32254558801651, -0.4565052390098572, 0.27773937582969666, -0.516340970993042, -1.204382061958313, 0.15501484274864197, -0.3676145076751709, 0.17805945873260498, 0.3769015371799469, 0.5366808176040649, -0.06958144903182983, 0.7213171124458313, 0.6225332617759705, 0.10349170863628387, 0.24141928553581238, 0.09000308811664581, 0.3437252938747406, -0.6633761525154114, -0.1594153344631195, -0.5058960318565369, -0.09839986264705658, -0.534155011177063, -0.532050609588623, 0.49569034576416016, 0.4214172661304474, -0.5314279198646545, 0.11470182240009308, -0.3444010317325592, 0.6260815262794495, 0.5673820972442627, 0.2623990476131439, 0.4393194913864136, 0.15122568607330322, -0.19501569867134094, 0.106126569211483, -0.8295327425003052, -0.5640314221382141, 1.0587679147720337, 0.29672861099243164, 0.7870808243751526, 0.09255368262529373, 0.6537466049194336, 0.025504646822810173, 0.34552228450775146, -0.6366209983825684, 0.5264838337898254, 0.17243683338165283, -0.483053982257843, -0.5090309977531433, -0.5286061763763428, -0.4641219675540924, 0.04745178297162056, -0.10275054723024368, -0.5515081286430359, -0.0457361675798893, 0.4205154478549957, -0.5591636300086975, 0.3026854395866394, -0.8319903016090393, 0.7291626334190369, -0.07249288260936737, -0.42452043294906616, 0.01929393969476223, -0.3532325327396393, 0.525187611579895, 0.09963500499725342, -0.019656958058476448, -0.09763506054878235, 0.16853058338165283, 0.4687613546848297, -0.17339463531970978, 0.7029401659965515, -0.36635032296180725, -0.3880617618560791, 0.357031911611557, 0.07069952040910721, 0.7967095971107483, 0.2541801333427429, -0.2222258597612381, 0.022177889943122864, -0.43409910798072815, -0.22279687225818634, -0.6425781846046448, 1.0042680501937866, -0.5083861351013184, -0.9712085723876953, 0.11189185827970505, -0.37750956416130066, -0.5833039283752441, 0.16447894275188446, 0.21879105269908905, 0.3495350182056427, -0.06097682937979698, 0.22409118711948395, 1.365713357925415, -0.3371502459049225, 0.15610267221927643, 0.6234942078590393, -0.05908957123756409, -0.008279144763946533, 0.6953958868980408, 0.01786547712981701, 0.26344025135040283, 0.5829373598098755, -0.189153790473938, -0.38093823194503784, -0.5675681233406067, -0.9828603267669678, 0.2054465115070343, -0.8552932143211365, -0.4072244167327881, -0.7151678204536438, -0.08610081672668457, -0.44195055961608887, 0.09134165197610855, -0.25106194615364075, -0.15491220355033875, -0.3793181777000427, -0.45218682289123535, 0.5518998503684998, 0.6126339435577393, 0.22948749363422394, 0.15919740498065948, -0.6180969476699829, 0.321248322725296, 0.32301637530326843, 0.6004788875579834, -0.10530225187540054, -0.602085292339325, -0.06877128034830093, 0.14684784412384033, -0.19363097846508026, -1.0716981887817383, -0.06364717334508896, 0.2759540379047394, 0.51186603307724, 0.18733002245426178, 0.17841994762420654, 0.6093644499778748, -0.718961775302887, 0.7025783658027649, 0.001867995597422123, -0.8967120051383972, 0.7870669364929199, -0.4482448995113373, -0.03131762892007828, 0.34403982758522034, 0.4151730239391327, -0.2930775284767151, -0.19343848526477814, -0.5083436965942383, -0.8586161732673645, 0.6207351088523865, 0.12809503078460693, 0.0562516450881958, -0.3268911838531494, 0.4904366135597229, -0.0762546956539154, 0.41198885440826416, -0.4226556718349457, -0.3991406261920929, 0.03330263867974281, -0.3425222933292389, 0.0538279227912426, -0.2874513268470764, -0.1386450231075287, -0.15102551877498627, 1.022096037864685, -0.40313735604286194, 0.09305721521377563, 0.10823288559913635, -0.3267548084259033, -0.3207504451274872, 0.5116323828697205, 0.3609764277935028, 0.7263782620429993, -0.0251166895031929, 0.289043128490448, 0.38383644819259644, -0.014698104932904243, 0.20988523960113525, 0.18507979810237885, -0.5138937830924988, 0.15936438739299774, 0.12216906249523163, 1.0611066818237305, 0.17136967182159424, -0.4868747591972351, 0.2866347134113312, 0.3046530485153198, -0.07541948556900024, 0.06919960677623749, 0.20186245441436768, 0.31965234875679016, 0.2890623211860657, 0.1359201967716217, -0.1653010994195938, -0.03625514730811119, -0.27979376912117004, 0.16189317405223846, 0.2729492485523224, -0.1520715057849884, -0.1556691825389862, 0.7927101254463196, 0.3463019132614136, -0.03789757192134857, 0.8281762003898621, -0.3831126391887665, -0.2736349403858185, 0.5883108377456665, 0.5361002683639526, 0.6314586997032166, -0.19787493348121643, 0.21219144761562347, 0.6919887065887451, 0.6669036746025085, -0.23621396720409393, 0.1792386770248413, 0.0579952597618103, -0.6612812876701355, -0.7615938186645508, -0.7847436666488647, -0.21242021024227142, 0.3270632326602936, -0.6194436550140381, 0.36741289496421814, -0.26200273633003235, 0.13053643703460693, -0.08281233161687851, -0.30421602725982666, -0.8859265446662903, 0.2621338963508606, 0.1908225119113922, 1.050207257270813, -0.8054776787757874, 0.5990420579910278, 0.921553909778595, -0.4734545350074768, -1.1123415231704712, 0.04576420783996582, -0.22809426486492157, -0.7258517146110535, 0.656061053276062, 0.09571954607963562, 0.15045368671417236, 0.6331291198730469, -0.6791120767593384, -0.833280086517334, 1.192726969718933, 0.7622777819633484, -0.9009950757026672, -0.1814885288476944, -0.03812699764966965, 0.44543367624282837, -0.1266670674085617, 0.2684329152107239, 0.6692295670509338, 0.4318077862262726, 0.004130533430725336, -0.8980231881141663, 0.18447841703891754, -0.07119019329547882, -0.024479124695062637, 0.2438734769821167, -0.5141769647598267, 0.7034834027290344, -0.3220241963863373, -0.42926883697509766, -0.23376251757144928, 0.8027814030647278, 0.34663790464401245, 0.13282011449337006, 0.4835212826728821, 0.8480981588363647, 0.9114782810211182, -0.31889957189559937, 0.6868503093719482, -0.5317124128341675, 0.40567803382873535, 1.07803475856781, -0.2963562607765198, 0.5230116248130798, 0.5498544573783875, -0.14990106225013733, 0.33920425176620483, 0.6543161869049072, 0.00486852927133441, 0.37669140100479126, 0.3505731523036957, -0.4123039245605469, -0.4549223780632019, -0.09052728116512299, -0.33515480160713196, 0.15032702684402466, 0.33013075590133667, -0.47802048921585083, -0.4016122817993164, -0.025441080331802368, -0.04961422085762024, 0.06166401877999306, -0.43459707498550415, 0.801824152469635, 0.019683673977851868, -0.8507581949234009, 0.5931639671325684, 0.1825890690088272, 0.5970532894134521, -0.3110966980457306, -0.27150946855545044, -0.2742334306240082, -0.26954010128974915, -0.12836183607578278, -0.7059917449951172, 0.011287061497569084, 0.26807713508605957, -0.46173790097236633, -0.2558688521385193, 0.7158707976341248, -0.7230823040008545, -0.22935344278812408, -0.045714862644672394, 0.7242228388786316, 0.04428023099899292, -0.2536983788013458, -0.2654285430908203, -0.09204508364200592, 0.15142464637756348, -0.4045555889606476, 0.18563778698444366, 0.8661100268363953, -0.03516065329313278, 0.5854737162590027, 0.5157681107521057, -0.04805130884051323, 0.25952234864234924, 0.19197174906730652, 1.0413018465042114, -0.49765390157699585, -0.21144308149814606, -1.0053073167800903, 0.4547272324562073, 0.06995139271020889, -0.11690769344568253, 0.6631435751914978, 0.5569770336151123, 1.0882272720336914, -0.30366823077201843, 0.868000328540802, -0.33928894996643066, 0.4830949902534485, -0.9242566227912903, 0.4810527265071869, -0.2199254333972931, 0.4792203903198242, 0.07527215033769608, -1.0229175090789795, 0.06366000324487686, 0.42420458793640137, -0.21820873022079468, 0.037399232387542725, 0.5853196382522583, 1.0886989831924438, -0.16319434344768524, -0.032833248376846313, 0.32198455929756165, 0.45474138855934143, 0.18171575665473938, 0.49230143427848816, 0.795403003692627, -0.29614004492759705, 0.314217746257782, -0.17378836870193481, -0.15914039313793182, 0.04147860407829285, -0.9042436480522156, -1.0382230281829834, -0.2855602204799652, -0.5048556327819824, -0.2940990626811981, 0.19922056794166565, 1.1716318130493164, 0.3541364073753357, -0.8559660911560059, 0.3461866080760956, -0.2870195209980011, 0.21372126042842865, 0.08627186715602875, -0.20053543150424957, 0.29005202651023865, -0.4339919090270996, -0.819456934928894, 0.6176296472549438, 0.18002532422542572, -0.06840986013412476, -0.22552013397216797, 0.06561236083507538, 0.014311522245407104, -0.22786222398281097, 0.5767131447792053, -0.034470271319150925, -0.8412242531776428, -0.46750372648239136, 0.08731374889612198, -0.060774579644203186, -0.10501090437173843, 0.6152265071868896, -0.7378932237625122, 0.378704309463501, 0.36514797806739807, 0.8920824527740479, 0.17820896208286285, 0.12359533458948135, 0.5286126732826233, -1.181592345237732, -0.144599050283432, 0.17946414649486542, 0.370437353849411, 0.5560421943664551, -0.49738478660583496, 0.36486414074897766, 0.28492096066474915, -0.5201098918914795, -0.7326831221580505, 0.29214656352996826, -0.6083990335464478, 0.0356609933078289, 1.344151258468628, -0.23545722663402557, -0.02836122363805771, 0.0432685911655426, -0.14017096161842346, 0.5082685351371765, -0.3270411789417267, 0.7848486304283142, 0.7836611270904541, 0.10714643448591232, -0.31723007559776306, -0.7452993988990784, 0.5835152864456177, 0.18733114004135132, -0.8082721829414368, 0.06926961988210678, 0.7527087330818176, 0.5381765365600586, 0.07177597284317017, 0.42340418696403503, 0.22809240221977234, -0.029873473569750786, 0.055615369230508804, 0.2382475882768631, -0.4344022274017334, -0.3785533905029297, -0.12823191285133362, 0.22048430144786835, 0.2777993381023407, -0.12147199362516403 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06733v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06733v3	NICE: To Optimize In-Context Examples or Not?	2024-02-09T19:09:19	2024-06-06T12:16:55	Pragya Srivastava, Satvik Golechha, Amit Deshpande, Amit Sharma	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Recent work shows that in-context learning and optimization of in-context examples (ICE) can significantly improve the accuracy of large language models (LLMs) on a wide range of tasks, leading to an apparent consensus that ICE optimization is crucial for better performance. However, most of these studies assume a fixed or no instruction provided in the prompt. We challenge this consensus by investigating the necessity of optimizing ICE when task-specific instructions are provided and find that there are many tasks for which it yields diminishing returns. In particular, using a diverse set of tasks and a systematically created instruction set with gradually added details, we find that as the prompt instruction becomes more detailed, the returns on ICE optimization diminish. To characterize this behavior, we introduce a task-specific metric called Normalized Invariability to Choice of Examples (NICE) that quantifies the learnability of tasks from a given instruction, and provides a heuristic to help decide whether to optimize instructions or ICE for a new task. Given a task, the proposed metric can reliably predict the utility of optimizing ICE compared to using random ICE. Our code is available at https://github.com/microsoft/nice-icl.	[ -0.20089152455329895, -0.6100392937660217, 0.4348103404045105, 0.013205424882471561, -0.41375139355659485, -0.29164889454841614, -0.39956751465797424, -0.0408635139465332, -0.2950931191444397, 0.24600858986377716, -0.5000168085098267, -0.6957467198371887, -0.3108029067516327, 0.04074447974562645, -0.3573957681655884, 1.573564887046814, -0.009102823212742805, 0.022111991420388222, -0.8730114698410034, -0.08436273038387299, -0.48412370681762695, -0.3647516965866089, -0.79563969373703, -0.21350207924842834, 0.22754734754562378, 1.0946228504180908, 0.41854721307754517, 0.569347620010376, 0.6580477356910706, 0.19214557111263275, 0.05843313783407211, 0.24522973597049713, -0.7092911005020142, 0.1647028625011444, 0.06835822016000748, -0.5923450589179993, -0.052552156150341034, 0.21242918074131012, 0.6732195615768433, 0.658706784248352, -0.0822991207242012, 0.3014703094959259, 0.3538794219493866, 0.4579329490661621, -0.787453830242157, 0.29431986808776855, -0.39095744490623474, 0.017292451113462448, -0.20077937841415405, -0.18280528485774994, -0.1305915117263794, -0.24709361791610718, 0.27929994463920593, -0.5436742305755615, 0.046359192579984665, 0.03164929151535034, 0.6961138844490051, 0.4023291766643524, -0.12204976379871368, -0.4006122052669525, -0.5574930310249329, 1.2530466318130493, -0.7723093628883362, 0.13537275791168213, 0.47101297974586487, 0.18796111643314362, -0.21980738639831543, -0.7037706971168518, -0.33626478910446167, -0.5556274652481079, -0.10045912116765976, 0.04071139171719551, -0.3191240727901459, 0.0767287164926529, 0.11287163943052292, 0.21148252487182617, -0.12221403419971466, 0.19567960500717163, -0.03771120682358742, -0.18783952295780182, 0.3821718096733093, 0.4170835018157959, 0.45936155319213867, -0.0675329640507698, -0.19085386395454407, 0.04882580786943436, -0.6560038924217224, 0.7393862009048462, 0.3698517084121704, 0.4395188093185425, -0.6513490676879883, 0.25123506784439087, -0.15495038032531738, 0.927859902381897, 0.25027772784233093, -0.43647584319114685, 0.19104136526584625, -0.2258620262145996, 0.07452455908060074, -0.27295050024986267, 0.3264928162097931, 0.3673342764377594, 0.027659069746732712, -0.6614881157875061, -0.46685343980789185, -0.17114847898483276, 0.2190975695848465, -1.0153738260269165, -0.21979041397571564, 0.1401808261871338, -0.30052614212036133, 0.05844081938266754, -0.18334509432315826, -0.1383199244737625, 0.26449301838874817, -0.652696430683136, 0.2596404552459717, -0.4079747796058655, 0.49802300333976746, -0.11764468997716904, -0.11685945838689804, 0.10698428750038147, 0.3665243983268738, -0.6782883405685425, 0.42477259039878845, 0.938795804977417, 0.5668958425521851, -0.46861425042152405, -0.3520752787590027, -1.195090889930725, -0.07212278246879578, -0.48967278003692627, 0.7070354223251343, -0.7757728695869446, -0.18922801315784454, 0.012029536999762058, -0.11255890130996704, 0.08272112160921097, -0.5393303632736206, 0.4862227737903595, -0.27395206689834595, 0.4556127190589905, -0.14632833003997803, -0.7243234515190125, 0.006147922948002815, 0.24874117970466614, -0.2811664938926697, 0.695608377456665, 0.2870963513851166, -0.6225205063819885, 0.5621621608734131, -0.8224138021469116, -0.6268506646156311, 0.1591026932001114, -0.38867896795272827, -0.3595201075077057, 0.3877696990966797, -0.34250208735466003, 0.713705837726593, -0.45054665207862854, -0.010460352525115013, -0.17963244020938873, -0.6922358274459839, 0.06576135754585266, -0.19155719876289368, 0.6436705589294434, 0.34990018606185913, -0.5499497056007385, 0.02883743681013584, -0.6242891550064087, 0.06381403654813766, -0.36827921867370605, -0.6292883157730103, -0.635826051235199, 0.05213533341884613, -0.033822160214185715, -0.061066970229148865, 0.21676398813724518, -0.5619710683822632, 0.07519422471523285, -0.4326658248901367, 0.2527811527252197, 0.756401002407074, -0.0715770572423935, 0.6340336203575134, -0.03582940250635147, 0.5872376561164856, 0.18764585256576538, 0.1806045025587082, 0.2412632405757904, -0.3779093325138092, -0.4347100853919983, -0.7181668877601624, 0.10267221182584763, 0.4813007712364197, -0.7910864353179932, -0.08010508120059967, 0.030491283163428307, -0.1394064575433731, -0.40605226159095764, 0.3627389669418335, 0.818297266960144, 0.6575437188148499, 0.2116423398256302, -0.2986122667789459, -0.19435374438762665, -1.216072678565979, -0.4468565285205841, 0.3096979558467865, -0.12916409969329834, 0.6635565757751465, 0.3201332092285156, -0.17989113926887512, 1.0003973245620728, -0.3647734522819519, 0.047033485025167465, -0.2874758541584015, 0.05298271030187607, 0.39531174302101135, 0.4700382649898529, 0.7743475437164307, -0.7459291815757751, -0.7588197588920593, -0.2316536158323288, -0.7513059377670288, 0.05872952565550804, 0.02443556860089302, -0.02724643051624298, 0.011843593791127205, 0.622642457485199, -0.2719016969203949, 0.34149494767189026, 0.3637222945690155, -0.30512535572052, 0.2452937662601471, -0.33379942178726196, 0.09395306557416916, -0.8380720615386963, -0.16341151297092438, 0.12606516480445862, -0.17317311465740204, -0.7434443235397339, 0.3147604465484619, 0.0701519250869751, -0.17086778581142426, -0.5883902907371521, 0.8184240460395813, -0.4180895686149597, 0.25598883628845215, -0.2618786692619324, -0.01893201656639576, -0.3616199493408203, 0.502524733543396, -0.31934842467308044, 0.8842231631278992, 0.7763477563858032, -0.8698693513870239, -0.06210745871067047, 0.18783800303936005, -0.503991961479187, 0.8143699765205383, -0.5260350108146667, 0.3734099864959717, -0.3481558561325073, -0.1305779665708542, -0.7750579118728638, -0.25231698155403137, 0.13330765068531036, -0.05584510415792465, 0.5060861706733704, -0.10140533745288849, -0.4017336666584015, -0.08853230625391006, -0.32051679491996765, 0.29321911931037903, 0.5984834432601929, -0.7105022668838501, 0.19844737648963928, 0.2870164215564728, 0.24157211184501648, -0.5475289821624756, -0.45184043049812317, -0.03990134596824646, -0.4017318785190582, -0.23480580747127533, 0.44723227620124817, -0.6205225586891174, -0.6020183563232422, 0.010355344042181969, -0.24009521305561066, -0.22312164306640625, 0.43308764696121216, 0.19950446486473083, 0.08539488166570663, -0.16530512273311615, 0.17459462583065033, -0.07255946099758148, -0.11418795585632324, -0.15219081938266754, -0.3699131906032562, 0.10579733550548553, -0.38923370838165283, -0.05935334041714668, -0.6731199026107788, 0.5051928758621216, 0.19834688305854797, 0.07054825872182846, 0.6871170997619629, 0.49295538663864136, -0.384148508310318, -0.3959382474422455, -0.2531653642654419, -0.34394118189811707, -0.48224344849586487, 0.3843117654323578, -0.21503594517707825, -1.0436455011367798, 0.14544068276882172, 0.3539329171180725, 0.495143324136734, -0.039142899215221405, 0.19875000417232513, -0.31415683031082153, 0.9871643781661987, 0.8508508801460266, -0.2024591565132141, 0.5629836916923523, -0.25470930337905884, 0.4807799458503723, -0.6784309148788452, 0.016528988257050514, -0.562605082988739, -0.36160600185394287, -0.6366715431213379, -0.21105286478996277, 0.5631791353225708, 0.06686586141586304, -0.3531804382801056, 0.1629742681980133, -0.45375287532806396, 0.6391602158546448, 0.8385160565376282, 0.14209820330142975, -0.09301307797431946, 0.18298973143100739, -0.05664512887597084, -0.09381656348705292, -0.7850135564804077, -0.5148401260375977, 0.9453186988830566, -0.020761465653777122, 0.6076430678367615, -0.017767544835805893, 0.9778942465782166, 0.30377620458602905, 0.4128621816635132, -0.7243098020553589, 0.542783260345459, -0.6577237248420715, -0.31918641924858093, -0.30915674567222595, -0.5044718384742737, -0.9121170043945312, -0.3494790196418762, 0.16500993072986603, -0.7901890873908997, -0.1283019483089447, 0.5486031770706177, -0.40793538093566895, 0.01111422386020422, -0.7600632309913635, 0.7732004523277283, 0.02359797991812229, -0.49415475130081177, -0.22011154890060425, -0.5614234209060669, -0.010296684689819813, 0.16058795154094696, 0.25620296597480774, -0.037200961261987686, -0.16401894390583038, 0.8120037913322449, -0.27822744846343994, 0.9407002925872803, -0.34096381068229675, 0.11952253431081772, 0.4789019227027893, -0.14038749039173126, 0.5666722655296326, -0.01895805075764656, -0.12869903445243835, -0.09854068607091904, -0.22414283454418182, -0.6677168607711792, -0.7703334093093872, 0.8841066360473633, -0.6994718313217163, -0.6657614707946777, 0.07700558006763458, -0.7063608765602112, -0.2878614068031311, -0.17420916259288788, 0.3999505341053009, 0.8563444018363953, 0.06101328134536743, 0.35579413175582886, 0.6018354296684265, -0.005014877766370773, 0.6560196876525879, 0.4429141581058502, 0.5637015104293823, -0.03522397577762604, 1.0769665241241455, -0.015356584452092648, 0.22229786217212677, 0.6083326935768127, 0.46297746896743774, 0.22685658931732178, -0.8229036927223206, -0.2725018858909607, -0.016557645052671432, -0.8902615308761597, -0.2187727689743042, -0.20610719919204712, 0.2226862907409668, 0.09589282423257828, -0.3699148893356323, -0.2621026933193207, -0.34831804037094116, -0.817203938961029, -0.00012134845746913925, 0.25753769278526306, 0.5420008301734924, -0.12269424647092819, 0.25891467928886414, -0.4716947674751282, 0.03147793933749199, 0.39099448919296265, 0.23433621227741241, -0.05102550610899925, -0.6038802862167358, -0.6499814391136169, 0.1100476086139679, -0.26746445894241333, -0.2642368972301483, 0.13880804181098938, 0.4697193503379822, 0.8714665770530701, 0.6043908596038818, 0.007199228275567293, 0.5692933797836304, -0.5646047592163086, 0.8624362349510193, 0.24443383514881134, -0.8465443849563599, 0.3530937731266022, -0.17804653942584991, 0.4802762269973755, 0.7162800431251526, 0.631676435470581, -0.39078488945961, -0.5463151335716248, -0.580984890460968, -0.8167746663093567, 0.6365075707435608, 0.05476207658648491, 0.5867182016372681, -0.3575313091278076, 0.7414358854293823, 0.3362651765346527, 0.45732930302619934, -0.3904756009578705, -0.568982720375061, -0.010756423696875572, -0.12304345518350601, -0.3630959689617157, -0.13112780451774597, -0.29580211639404297, -0.17273251712322235, 0.5198609232902527, -0.32589367032051086, 0.4351479411125183, -0.07492021471261978, -0.029598183929920197, 0.07543586939573288, 0.2248353213071823, 0.6128275394439697, 0.7856336832046509, -0.17166024446487427, 0.17017292976379395, 0.1036338210105896, -0.4694175124168396, -0.16744142770767212, -0.14383728802204132, -0.3910805583000183, -0.23211148381233215, 0.40382689237594604, 0.7517043352127075, 0.46710819005966187, -0.6394851207733154, 0.5149297118186951, -0.015112032182514668, -0.0005173630197532475, -0.03704462945461273, 0.4006171226501465, -0.26679497957229614, 0.1696317046880722, 0.3016601800918579, 0.12015648931264877, 0.31799033284187317, -0.7702865600585938, 0.2535117268562317, 0.7674110531806946, -0.6762572526931763, -0.3858972489833832, 0.34574446082115173, 0.1444089263677597, -0.7640219926834106, 0.9101130366325378, -0.49986374378204346, -0.3372351825237274, 0.581619143486023, 0.60247802734375, 0.9235459566116333, 0.1487589329481125, 0.1803922802209854, 0.24544258415699005, -0.10473117977380753, 0.32869189977645874, 0.279699444770813, -0.17145130038261414, -0.5855111479759216, -0.0749659314751625, -0.4042023718357086, -0.3818122446537018, 0.08026943355798721, -0.6382874250411987, 0.12267124652862549, -0.44905269145965576, 0.09966781735420227, -0.29624685645103455, 0.002034076489508152, -1.135995626449585, 0.3071993887424469, 0.008889085613191128, 0.6972963213920593, -0.7608931064605713, 0.49929240345954895, 0.6402699947357178, -0.20317839086055756, -0.767947256565094, 0.31175270676612854, -0.15551888942718506, -0.6665977835655212, 0.6084467768669128, 0.0077487570233643055, -0.15473170578479767, -0.22662824392318726, -1.033742070198059, -0.7151886224746704, 0.7308858633041382, 0.6226311326026917, -0.29666829109191895, -0.039593011140823364, -0.16339251399040222, 0.5057205557823181, -0.7232005596160889, 0.2000482678413391, 0.39871105551719666, 0.3044624328613281, -0.2553223669528961, -0.6596032977104187, -0.024694114923477173, -0.24632617831230164, -0.044704414904117584, 0.03952936455607414, -0.5936408638954163, 0.7442851066589355, -0.4839880168437958, 0.01558560412377119, -0.030714208260178566, 0.6419457793235779, 0.04697868973016739, 0.575483500957489, 0.5559387803077698, 0.371192067861557, 0.6324151754379272, 0.26727014780044556, 1.5318119525909424, -0.12098430842161179, 0.049161892384290695, 1.19621741771698, 0.20947052538394928, 0.7139635682106018, 0.803297221660614, 0.03274748474359512, 0.5907735824584961, 0.7905517220497131, 0.214771568775177, 1.0331658124923706, 0.39878129959106445, -0.3212893307209015, -0.3707435429096222, -0.20962868630886078, 0.06402097642421722, 0.3865547478199005, 0.06804287433624268, 0.005532677751034498, -0.25675249099731445, 0.16835324466228485, 0.3339082598686218, 0.1292976289987564, -0.3887491226196289, 0.618061900138855, 0.0849003940820694, -0.8322741985321045, 0.7249876856803894, -0.148162841796875, 0.6725160479545593, -0.5433790683746338, -0.22528903186321259, -0.4966191351413727, 0.05317770317196846, -0.23779648542404175, -0.39037370681762695, 0.10169896483421326, 0.05375472828745842, -0.37671416997909546, -0.15364952385425568, 0.22546030580997467, -0.14723218977451324, -0.3080383837223053, -0.025582514703273773, 0.3303341269493103, 0.4849684536457062, 0.3622688353061676, -0.4777870774269104, -0.49234166741371155, 0.20685085654258728, -0.2296203374862671, 0.6985244750976562, 0.3347350060939789, -0.13366752862930298, 0.7588944435119629, 0.43771234154701233, -0.23422355949878693, -0.29422226548194885, -0.13448411226272583, 0.7742547988891602, -0.1924997866153717, -0.47645580768585205, -0.7839362025260925, 0.6715133190155029, 0.03517859801650047, -0.6083043217658997, 0.9434736967086792, 0.6880304217338562, 1.0406180620193481, -0.2334834337234497, 0.7588562965393066, 0.09760397672653198, 0.3739110231399536, -0.5469884276390076, 0.27727970480918884, -0.8775280117988586, 0.36429929733276367, -0.27750685811042786, -0.8415889739990234, -0.15530791878700256, 0.4000818133354187, -0.49954307079315186, 0.03186040744185448, 0.8188484907150269, 0.6618980765342712, -0.3553985357284546, -0.14626248180866241, 0.4902036190032959, -0.10521368682384491, 0.1169542670249939, 0.35737910866737366, 0.5846056342124939, 0.14343562722206116, 0.4219200015068054, -0.5119889974594116, -0.4486890435218811, -0.1751742959022522, -1.1801419258117676, -0.8834986686706543, -0.7416326999664307, -0.5918684601783752, -0.10706772655248642, 0.4067955017089844, 1.0907846689224243, 0.901470422744751, -0.8433225154876709, -0.4962199330329895, -0.02904059737920761, 0.20737312734127045, -0.40389952063560486, -0.1723862886428833, 0.4873436987400055, -0.8002176284790039, -0.7356687784194946, 0.4754035174846649, 0.16596196591854095, -0.057026609778404236, 0.13551415503025055, -0.17751666903495789, 0.21362346410751343, 0.09313447773456573, 0.48604345321655273, 0.30234581232070923, -0.45090028643608093, -0.5051600933074951, 0.024491112679243088, -0.07620827853679657, 0.06282517313957214, 0.784463107585907, -0.48501795530319214, 0.247303307056427, 0.3590961694717407, 0.6648113131523132, 0.43770095705986023, -0.3156411647796631, 0.5534871220588684, -0.8170326352119446, -0.01847326196730137, 0.36239394545555115, 0.3142087757587433, 0.40320920944213867, -0.5145969986915588, 0.3569926619529724, -0.1059197410941124, -0.6022739410400391, -0.8410633206367493, 0.19933755695819855, -0.6690263748168945, -0.20284251868724823, 1.1303285360336304, -0.5368279218673706, -0.29880404472351074, 0.016903860494494438, 0.1823151856660843, -0.06500230729579926, -0.7001022696495056, 0.8952738046646118, 0.5161570906639099, -0.5112390518188477, 0.1579665094614029, -0.5647340416908264, 0.8846722841262817, 0.5680118799209595, -0.8551706671714783, -0.19808082282543182, 0.359444260597229, 0.5110297203063965, -0.030206505209207535, 0.38155633211135864, 0.46397849917411804, 0.47984617948532104, -0.32549113035202026, -0.22492936253547668, -0.023525571450591087, -0.5297034978866577, -0.17596358060836792, 0.042035430669784546, 0.1749703586101532, -0.4035789370536804 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06627v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06627v3	Feedback Loops With Language Models Drive In-Context Reward Hacking	2024-02-09T18:59:29	2024-06-06T21:39:09	Alexander Pan, Erik Jones, Meena Jagadeesan, Jacob Steinhardt	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	Language models influence the external world: they query APIs that read and write to web pages, generate content that shapes human behavior, and run system commands as autonomous agents. These interactions form feedback loops: LLM outputs affect the world, which in turn affect subsequent LLM outputs. In this work, we show that feedback loops can cause in-context reward hacking (ICRH), where the LLM at test-time optimizes a (potentially implicit) objective but creates negative side effects in the process. For example, consider an LLM agent deployed to increase Twitter engagement; the LLM may retrieve its previous tweets into the context window and make them more controversial, increasing engagement but also toxicity. We identify and study two processes that lead to ICRH: output-refinement and policy-refinement. For these processes, evaluations on static datasets are insufficient -- they miss the feedback effects and thus cannot capture the most harmful behavior. In response, we provide three recommendations for evaluation to capture more instances of ICRH. As AI development accelerates, the effects of feedback loops will proliferate, increasing the need to understand their role in shaping LLM behavior.	[ -0.17409640550613403, -0.5678780674934387, 0.5937302708625793, 0.10332835465669632, 0.09685711562633514, 0.193625807762146, -0.07827844470739365, -0.5736468434333801, -0.03267588093876839, 0.522738516330719, -0.728966474533081, -0.20429469645023346, -0.5112175345420837, 0.0633666142821312, -0.40907683968544006, 1.433168888092041, -0.06338972598314285, -0.02234709821641445, -0.31542131304740906, 0.13996919989585876, -0.6375662088394165, -0.7167678475379944, -0.6969844102859497, -0.8363105058670044, 0.7569176554679871, 0.47152087092399597, 0.26179295778274536, 0.13732871413230896, 0.5029724836349487, 0.22881412506103516, 0.11508245021104813, -0.06140999495983124, -0.8336382508277893, 0.2213718295097351, -0.225820392370224, -0.4612877666950226, -0.1750486195087433, -0.048405926674604416, 0.21436896920204163, 0.07211785763502121, 0.013293859548866749, 0.17123275995254517, 0.2976372241973877, 0.48959025740623474, -0.6726810932159424, 0.0751657634973526, -0.4961002469062805, -0.35131245851516724, -0.10290782898664474, -0.7310007810592651, -0.47570812702178955, -0.5307325720787048, -0.030324073508381844, -0.14731374382972717, -0.3390530049800873, -0.16163451969623566, 0.6141495704650879, 0.3408261239528656, -0.3623292148113251, -0.6167342066764832, -0.7513712048530579, 0.6843480467796326, -0.7248603105545044, -0.007887800224125385, 0.3862331807613373, -0.04165378212928772, -0.48261815309524536, -0.36246830224990845, -0.3611869215965271, -0.5149307250976562, -0.07539129257202148, -0.12924587726593018, -0.1426369547843933, 0.2608436346054077, 0.2530626356601715, -0.013606434687972069, -0.09518972039222717, 0.12230049818754196, -0.3748655319213867, -0.17953576147556305, 0.6635606288909912, 0.36637917160987854, 0.4193018078804016, 0.06034155935049057, -0.19592595100402832, -0.21500550210475922, -1.2227883338928223, 0.6260992288589478, 0.5305538773536682, 0.4246561825275421, -0.022352619096636772, 0.47287794947624207, -0.046017516404390335, 0.4469143748283386, -0.22763800621032715, -0.21951931715011597, -0.15563231706619263, -0.31006184220314026, 0.03995396941900253, 0.014845306053757668, 0.48893672227859497, 0.414903849363327, 0.2287842184305191, -0.2625996470451355, -0.47122862935066223, 0.06125320494174957, 0.3580586612224579, -0.8312699794769287, 0.04695853963494301, 0.37767377495765686, -0.33547165989875793, -0.6010217070579529, 0.24539047479629517, -0.47500768303871155, -0.4767932891845703, -0.28773051500320435, 0.4253964424133301, -0.254433274269104, -0.03640616685152054, -0.19034256041049957, -0.534929633140564, 0.19400006532669067, 0.2087702751159668, -0.7038570642471313, 0.47654420137405396, 0.7580452561378479, 0.7975229024887085, -0.23212850093841553, -0.5099281668663025, -0.6551698446273804, 0.25407323241233826, -0.1681096851825714, 0.6969311833381653, -0.5279569625854492, -0.5186792016029358, 0.16219088435173035, -0.1258152723312378, 0.30435556173324585, -0.5902402400970459, 0.0030374713242053986, -0.5323188900947571, -0.0718894824385643, -0.5416456460952759, -0.34854328632354736, 0.1674651801586151, 0.5058133602142334, -0.369289755821228, 0.7858024835586548, 0.07996327430009842, -0.6497132182121277, 0.49972715973854065, -0.9946811199188232, -0.6152886152267456, -0.0892886221408844, 0.06745754182338715, 0.025879619643092155, 0.1277020424604416, -0.0666411817073822, 0.24120832979679108, -0.3080710768699646, 0.19177593290805817, -0.32229185104370117, -0.8526820540428162, 0.6205793023109436, -0.1992700845003128, 0.7926648259162903, -0.09955836087465286, -0.6898831129074097, 0.3892112374305725, -0.4221014678478241, -0.08808784186840057, -0.081504225730896, -0.5434191226959229, -0.44752976298332214, 0.19337138533592224, -0.19398167729377747, 0.2929511070251465, -0.004174002446234226, -0.5160589218139648, 0.2407524287700653, -0.14405514299869537, 0.6273581385612488, 1.2837923765182495, 0.3644362986087799, 0.3094007074832916, -0.5527147054672241, 0.7263813614845276, -0.12917670607566833, 0.1604463905096054, -0.43450066447257996, -0.2874737083911896, -0.47028857469558716, 0.014398707076907158, -0.09986554086208344, 0.579812228679657, -0.464701771736145, -0.055967334657907486, 0.004258626140654087, -0.29921409487724304, -0.3437683582305908, 0.025225376710295677, 0.48379403352737427, 0.3750682771205902, 0.10308204591274261, -0.08754593133926392, -0.35477736592292786, -0.6766486763954163, -0.5077729225158691, -0.303926557302475, 0.004312139004468918, 0.5248766541481018, 0.6839794516563416, -0.4180777966976166, 0.9059605598449707, -0.1535726636648178, -0.2214241772890091, -0.1981414258480072, 0.13839229941368103, 0.06148982048034668, 0.48646533489227295, 0.2377750277519226, -0.3139880299568176, -0.10682769119739532, -0.33815938234329224, -0.45338669419288635, -0.4163382053375244, -0.27350112795829773, 0.05376753956079483, 0.25902479887008667, 0.5827004909515381, -0.2413063645362854, 0.41561898589134216, 0.3776712119579315, -0.5000218152999878, 0.7277746200561523, -0.015014476142823696, 0.2632843255996704, -0.4768592119216919, 0.20413675904273987, -0.18054237961769104, -0.14377166330814362, -0.285319447517395, 0.33276450634002686, -0.003918694797903299, -0.03870061784982681, -0.5337830781936646, 0.6949635744094849, -0.2605343759059906, 0.006016122177243233, -0.3430907726287842, -0.017947906628251076, -0.00007522618398070335, 0.40636134147644043, -0.40231719613075256, 1.0056753158569336, 0.25101423263549805, -0.8348376750946045, 0.3308238387107849, -0.1898462176322937, -0.312855064868927, 0.29644712805747986, -0.6572659015655518, 0.3368360698223114, 0.06718451529741287, 0.5602738857269287, -0.79939866065979, -0.3163481056690216, 0.17927366495132446, -0.48278337717056274, 0.16854923963546753, 0.2379089593887329, -0.5385277271270752, -0.27823424339294434, -0.8146432042121887, 0.39641934633255005, 0.3213155269622803, -0.5601345896720886, -0.05110122635960579, 0.46051284670829773, 0.22102324664592743, -0.686359703540802, -1.0027554035186768, 0.13804121315479279, -0.301619291305542, -0.41722965240478516, 0.40864163637161255, -0.17064405977725983, -0.599393904209137, -0.05716811120510101, 0.1466836929321289, 0.46653491258621216, 0.3600211441516876, 0.3472479581832886, 0.12042874842882156, 0.20750212669372559, -0.04518423229455948, -0.07179868966341019, 0.013202621601521969, 0.5139569640159607, -0.07317373156547546, 0.647696852684021, -0.07306178659200668, -0.46244004368782043, -0.47189268469810486, 0.32280951738357544, 0.6264587044715881, 0.13827838003635406, 0.6438940763473511, 0.07004556059837341, -0.17576925456523895, -0.3075345754623413, -0.23514080047607422, -0.6506545543670654, -0.49138641357421875, 0.23615357279777527, -0.14158138632774353, -1.055095911026001, 0.5939403772354126, -0.2487238347530365, -0.030147157609462738, -0.02876828983426094, 0.7324386239051819, -0.0022617336362600327, 1.2612576484680176, 0.8364813327789307, -0.2499816119670868, 0.6447763442993164, -0.339507520198822, 0.29277920722961426, -0.9679967761039734, -0.3995698094367981, -0.34893926978111267, -0.3545740842819214, -0.7145889401435852, -0.024932682514190674, 0.3323761522769928, -0.023332010954618454, -0.38011276721954346, -0.04137955233454704, -0.415119469165802, 0.6471641063690186, 0.7761549949645996, 0.03600308299064636, 0.10412389785051346, -0.3518810272216797, -0.10349562019109726, 0.023835724219679832, -0.6454814672470093, -0.5202117562294006, 1.001926064491272, 0.2638607323169708, 1.009904146194458, -0.023460352793335915, 0.7680997252464294, 0.5011011958122253, 0.6983553171157837, -0.7274895310401917, 0.3579832911491394, 0.4797077178955078, -0.5628980398178101, -0.08984249085187912, -0.1314818263053894, -0.7683107852935791, -0.09419634938240051, 0.27451086044311523, -1.1250442266464233, -0.0002803611569106579, 0.3314612805843353, -0.24683210253715515, 0.23131074011325836, -0.7748728394508362, 0.750062882900238, -0.1885545402765274, -0.760685384273529, -0.4414687752723694, -0.46945929527282715, 0.6883112788200378, 0.3213760554790497, 0.32663610577583313, -0.0815029963850975, 0.19074352085590363, 0.35936176776885986, -0.5524205565452576, 1.0034565925598145, -0.29800447821617126, -0.13377931714057922, 0.30168643593788147, 0.3894370496273041, 0.6927028894424438, 0.384028822183609, -0.040818557143211365, 0.09339616447687149, -0.05701688304543495, -0.22556307911872864, -0.31518352031707764, 0.9459185004234314, -0.7119555473327637, -0.7768882513046265, -0.5634946227073669, -0.6090872287750244, -0.2083178162574768, -0.07606997340917587, 0.362091600894928, 0.36391615867614746, -0.15462437272071838, 0.07790815830230713, 0.30496272444725037, -0.40554630756378174, 0.46287035942077637, 0.24238471686840057, -0.3095254898071289, 0.028164725750684738, 0.875156044960022, -0.13654746115207672, 0.36453601717948914, 0.1681888997554779, 0.22041483223438263, -0.02373039349913597, -0.33298659324645996, -0.21061453223228455, 0.05001860857009888, -0.7053560018539429, -0.5548257827758789, -0.12077579647302628, -0.13200415670871735, -0.42748090624809265, -0.5001293420791626, -0.06668293476104736, 0.029552891850471497, -0.13623268902301788, -0.03985718637704849, 0.38605064153671265, 1.162807822227478, -0.3930366337299347, 0.267020583152771, -0.591563880443573, -0.08049454540014267, 0.1426035314798355, 0.5844587087631226, 0.3591500520706177, -0.18580372631549835, -0.35147178173065186, 0.006665744818747044, -0.49342262744903564, -1.0083273649215698, 0.2936360239982605, -0.25088968873023987, 0.36928778886795044, 0.321737140417099, -0.056188613176345825, 0.7072382569313049, -0.32245901226997375, 0.9520140886306763, -0.20128922164440155, -1.1264286041259766, 0.5822474360466003, -0.4986995756626129, 0.6141510605812073, 0.4208935499191284, -0.09430085122585297, -0.9505573511123657, -0.7745691537857056, -0.2524294853210449, -0.9551821351051331, 1.0970395803451538, 0.02303256280720234, 0.320545494556427, -0.18305383622646332, 0.3063417673110962, 0.16441254317760468, 0.25172340869903564, -1.013712763786316, -0.07547158002853394, 0.014631620608270168, 0.2353072464466095, 0.2335129976272583, -0.4407535195350647, -0.33761510252952576, -0.23255029320716858, 0.7294934988021851, -0.026959385722875595, 0.29152539372444153, 0.11999425292015076, -0.19509461522102356, -0.3981669545173645, 0.19390155375003815, 0.7947840094566345, 0.8912521004676819, -0.22304667532444, 0.0613677017390728, -0.05226176232099533, -0.08232809603214264, 0.24501223862171173, -0.35560479760169983, -0.2869120240211487, -0.4892484247684479, 0.48556122183799744, 0.5384550094604492, 0.2817077040672302, -1.1076080799102783, 0.5159011483192444, -0.15716879069805145, 0.07193721830844879, -0.43357837200164795, 0.285513699054718, -0.08033432811498642, 0.3398674428462982, 0.4315062165260315, 0.006806710734963417, 0.20662406086921692, -0.9101942777633667, 0.18646642565727234, 0.618420422077179, -0.24029231071472168, -0.45785269141197205, 0.5051736831665039, 0.134521022439003, -0.6974583268165588, 0.5931072235107422, -0.1612449437379837, -0.7293661832809448, 0.794958233833313, 0.939436674118042, 0.8101691603660583, -0.10610519349575043, 0.13292694091796875, 0.23869681358337402, 0.43278783559799194, 0.184983491897583, 0.36043256521224976, -0.19018562138080597, -0.5237563848495483, -0.5075725317001343, -0.2676951587200165, -0.5520391464233398, 0.45160239934921265, -0.4444130063056946, 0.34958261251449585, -0.3533424437046051, 0.16205660998821259, -0.4737505316734314, -0.2595052123069763, -0.6741533279418945, -0.156309574842453, 0.2878390848636627, 0.6750303506851196, -0.5653980374336243, 0.7059815526008606, 0.4429139792919159, -0.3968502879142761, -0.5800364017486572, 0.21468806266784668, 0.23160602152347565, -0.933451771736145, 0.7797959446907043, 0.5167627334594727, -0.4486536979675293, -0.2683108150959015, -0.8913552761077881, -1.0814193487167358, 0.9761477708816528, 0.3435536324977875, -0.3287411034107208, 0.05802951380610466, 0.18727324903011322, 0.6083592772483826, -0.4818652272224426, 0.286125510931015, 0.626387357711792, 0.43601489067077637, -0.2762661874294281, -0.6563290357589722, 0.18702192604541779, -0.2558770179748535, -0.004452536813914776, 0.3638322949409485, -0.5306785106658936, 0.6835107207298279, -0.48246246576309204, -0.05763303488492966, -0.26116034388542175, 0.008781695738434792, 0.6765812635421753, 0.3077567517757416, 0.34807711839675903, 0.26713454723358154, 0.4221276044845581, 0.06617427617311478, 1.542569637298584, -0.40939775109291077, 0.05211690068244934, 0.9872497916221619, -0.27498409152030945, 0.7104594111442566, 0.9014207720756531, 0.017836641520261765, 0.8360269665718079, 0.808224081993103, 0.3474498391151428, 0.6414362192153931, 0.5986611843109131, 0.037943534553050995, 0.3677111268043518, -0.31779947876930237, -0.14018060266971588, 0.3196885585784912, 0.4036068320274353, -0.12867304682731628, -0.10935891419649124, 0.07695892453193665, 0.2647245526313782, -0.16422031819820404, -0.2852020561695099, 0.6984981298446655, 0.004884202033281326, -1.0301762819290161, 0.3469432592391968, 0.08400721848011017, 0.8452603816986084, -0.6712766885757446, -0.15673276782035828, -0.3380753695964813, 0.33685123920440674, -0.20034267008304596, -0.5879964232444763, 0.42332425713539124, 0.14701105654239655, -0.02647821605205536, -0.6799936294555664, 0.7378799319267273, -0.22225533425807953, 0.04009408876299858, 0.812561571598053, 0.29305875301361084, -0.09541229903697968, -0.20631805062294006, -0.5601573586463928, 0.16622716188430786, -0.08908624947071075, -0.5629564523696899, 0.5654844045639038, 0.27255356311798096, -0.18919003009796143, 0.5795570015907288, 0.8437498807907104, 0.10438819229602814, -0.08946545422077179, 0.0210721455514431, 1.0619440078735352, -0.74732905626297, -0.6766906976699829, -1.319780945777893, 0.5359158515930176, -0.08640747517347336, -0.278016060590744, 0.7316455245018005, 0.41646644473075867, 1.1516193151474, 0.3124568462371826, 0.8814693093299866, -0.13416099548339844, 0.20917347073554993, -0.31766802072525024, 0.6017565727233887, -0.6164408326148987, 0.5555583834648132, -0.27312442660331726, -0.6789610981941223, -0.08578857034444809, 0.14699162542819977, -0.24361006915569305, -0.03824464604258537, 0.6116690635681152, 0.7261629700660706, 0.19529932737350464, -0.3063754737377167, 0.03186855465173721, 0.14323727786540985, 0.7594822645187378, 0.4803564250469208, 0.9872897863388062, -0.08889643847942352, 0.49703335762023926, -0.3318595588207245, -0.2795604169368744, -0.4063080847263336, -0.9163744449615479, -0.6718153357505798, -0.554903507232666, 0.13649563491344452, -0.6922229528427124, 0.07838541269302368, 0.9008924961090088, 0.5399015545845032, -0.895676851272583, -0.6670166254043579, -0.3747100234031677, 0.5024276971817017, -0.20739398896694183, -0.36756908893585205, 0.06820724904537201, -0.6246424913406372, -0.40229886770248413, 0.3912978172302246, 0.5509868860244751, -0.2504628300666809, -0.5773797035217285, -0.2504485845565796, -0.09953185170888901, 0.21629181504249573, 0.5896444320678711, 0.33470845222473145, -0.8267399072647095, -0.4352654814720154, 0.026372183114290237, -0.18539148569107056, 0.05412672087550163, 1.323081374168396, -1.0041956901550293, 0.2902044653892517, 0.4895273745059967, 0.5361514091491699, 0.3077770471572876, -0.16581065952777863, 0.9183307886123657, -0.7050836682319641, 0.24785533547401428, 0.4181458353996277, 0.20904360711574554, 0.21318860352039337, -0.6411656141281128, 0.3858540654182434, -0.01352062076330185, -0.8420901298522949, -1.2641658782958984, 0.27199772000312805, -0.13127878308296204, -0.5578758120536804, 1.2186998128890991, 0.018979717046022415, -0.3345107436180115, 0.03772900626063347, -0.09066352248191833, 0.037456005811691284, -0.6682668924331665, 1.2909947633743286, 0.9830838441848755, -0.5684705376625061, 0.12965795397758484, -0.4356383979320526, 0.8938933610916138, 0.25838467478752136, -0.9599448442459106, 0.13988348841667175, 0.4276147186756134, 0.22035501897335052, -0.14302487671375275, 0.8768882155418396, -0.005938517861068249, 0.28056061267852783, -0.19853073358535767, 0.011830233968794346, 0.07039526104927063, -0.3326956331729889, -0.5051502585411072, -0.07127215713262558, 0.24906231462955475, 0.16697311401367188 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06625v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06625v1	Understanding the Effects of Iterative Prompting on Truthfulness	2024-02-09T18:57:08	2024-02-09T18:57:08	Satyapriya Krishna, Chirag Agarwal, Himabindu Lakkaraju	cs.CL	cs.CL	The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has notably transformed numerous sectors, offering impressive text generation capabilities. Yet, the reliability and truthfulness of these models remain pressing concerns. To this end, we investigate iterative prompting, a strategy hypothesized to refine LLM responses, assessing its impact on LLM truthfulness, an area which has not been thoroughly explored. Our extensive experiments delve into the intricacies of iterative prompting variants, examining their influence on the accuracy and calibration of model responses. Our findings reveal that naive prompting methods significantly undermine truthfulness, leading to exacerbated calibration errors. In response to these challenges, we introduce several prompting variants designed to address the identified issues. These variants demonstrate marked improvements over existing baselines, signaling a promising direction for future research. Our work provides a nuanced understanding of iterative prompting and introduces novel approaches to enhance the truthfulness of LLMs, thereby contributing to the development of more accurate and trustworthy AI systems.	[ 0.015708694234490395, -0.6521622538566589, 0.8813211917877197, 0.24323402345180511, -0.06904046982526779, 0.1262858659029007, -0.4567071199417114, -0.030112361535429955, -0.40723174810409546, 0.3200738728046417, -0.7905994653701782, -0.2631104290485382, -0.4057781994342804, 0.37901875376701355, -0.2790975272655487, 0.9276720881462097, -0.005582483019679785, 0.1594875454902649, -0.2626805305480957, -0.11494068056344986, -0.8512490391731262, -0.10126436501741409, -0.5999311804771423, -0.6939454674720764, 0.6244540214538574, 0.6474663019180298, 0.7444738745689392, 0.5713782906532288, 0.0639355406165123, 0.31002670526504517, -0.12000355869531631, -0.018249019980430603, -0.5973201990127563, 0.31440263986587524, -0.014601734466850758, -0.6933566331863403, 0.1254817098379135, 0.2964925765991211, 0.6734631657600403, 0.6454166173934937, -0.33444565534591675, 0.2754814028739929, 0.2822818160057068, 0.8258723616600037, -0.5990237593650818, 0.10065679997205734, -0.8564906716346741, -0.1972593516111374, -0.05147279053926468, -0.5217621922492981, -0.8070924878120422, -0.4725710153579712, 0.13729259371757507, -0.3873596787452698, 0.33021315932273865, 0.04142465442419052, 0.6978338360786438, 0.5736669898033142, -0.14372585713863373, -0.5721544027328491, -0.7326056361198425, 0.817380428314209, -0.9807299375534058, 0.2023046463727951, 0.36396488547325134, 0.18038946390151978, -0.15418441593647003, -0.5398880839347839, -0.796083927154541, -0.6526385545730591, 0.17408646643161774, 0.059337127953767776, -0.01872655190527439, -0.05904596298933029, 0.5318707227706909, 0.32664114236831665, -0.37901535630226135, 0.24699224531650543, -0.3432663381099701, 0.08714748173952103, 0.3129146695137024, 0.2233666330575943, -0.09312711656093597, -0.049299631267786026, -0.052160054445266724, -0.18633106350898743, -1.1180360317230225, 0.24118252098560333, 0.7668774724006653, 0.41155803203582764, 0.12998095154762268, 0.5744299292564392, -0.09993166476488113, 0.9162976741790771, 0.24329833686351776, -0.2794082760810852, 0.05553489923477173, -0.251326322555542, -0.027817480266094208, 0.21789948642253876, 0.6460922956466675, 0.45148032903671265, 0.30720001459121704, 0.14530092477798462, -0.267945796251297, 0.007605267222970724, 0.45345908403396606, -0.7369838356971741, -0.17350468039512634, 0.5537189245223999, -0.25183624029159546, -0.5617660284042358, -0.15661488473415375, -0.3942733407020569, -0.6364773511886597, -0.31252560019493103, 0.6171045303344727, -0.5907847881317139, -0.19092991948127747, 0.20839795470237732, -0.08714437484741211, 0.21363624930381775, 0.35008472204208374, -0.7424845099449158, -0.3427406847476959, 0.7181074023246765, 0.48597875237464905, 0.1555195450782776, -0.27043959498405457, -0.6141422390937805, -0.01795436628162861, -0.5566115975379944, 0.5585207939147949, -0.6569267511367798, -0.6692686676979065, 0.08880970627069473, -0.4952780306339264, -0.001512237824499607, -0.6460991501808167, 0.6801517009735107, -0.5933117866516113, 0.2487974315881729, -0.7312052845954895, -0.5137118101119995, -0.36361098289489746, 0.5863386988639832, -0.6613407731056213, 0.8932744264602661, -0.18274392187595367, -0.6529815793037415, 0.36275216937065125, -0.4424043893814087, -0.24211153388023376, -0.07324373722076416, -0.44529420137405396, -0.27287769317626953, 0.37010544538497925, 0.29155051708221436, 0.23859775066375732, -0.5017993450164795, 0.46373385190963745, -0.07446111738681793, -0.29559963941574097, 0.5142049789428711, -0.8470603823661804, 0.7978312373161316, 0.05303623527288437, -0.41835108399391174, -0.0963144451379776, -0.704700231552124, 0.16526344418525696, 0.14785179495811462, -0.3014841675758362, -0.0026065530255436897, -0.060604628175497055, -0.45244163274765015, -0.1007152572274208, 0.07727515697479248, -0.4655868709087372, 0.20876751840114594, -0.3939493000507355, 0.4533819556236267, 1.1169313192367554, 0.04064403101801872, 0.3005959987640381, -0.6917517185211182, 0.35772621631622314, 0.03695032373070717, 0.16172821819782257, -0.7167192697525024, -0.5305085182189941, -0.6676291823387146, -0.12017189711332321, 0.29530102014541626, 0.25740256905555725, -0.8549859523773193, 0.0640893504023552, -0.2587326765060425, -0.3385942578315735, -0.9179303050041199, 0.1902584284543991, 0.34012576937675476, 1.0792142152786255, 0.16138681769371033, 0.1399954855442047, -0.17031745612621307, -0.5653730034828186, -0.47597959637641907, -0.4631553888320923, 0.09905234724283218, 0.03792133927345276, 0.25280866026878357, -0.11759278178215027, 1.0558021068572998, 0.04834555834531784, 0.1313214898109436, 0.0045915585942566395, 0.40735796093940735, 0.24764351546764374, 0.3693760335445404, 0.3111479580402374, -0.7164789438247681, -0.35505425930023193, -0.5159757733345032, -0.5570921301841736, -0.20444932579994202, -0.31612423062324524, 0.5652468800544739, 0.2132205069065094, 0.3240382969379425, -0.3531506657600403, 0.5328594446182251, 0.6302627325057983, 0.1283484548330307, 0.673904538154602, -0.1360931247472763, 0.3571852445602417, -0.7439479231834412, 0.1360936164855957, -0.35244807600975037, 0.09700358659029007, -0.5368369221687317, 0.0036679373588413, 0.14642271399497986, 0.2054796814918518, -0.2366359680891037, 0.4882587790489197, -0.45109841227531433, 0.03159908577799797, -0.38037651777267456, 0.053830359131097794, 0.14021168649196625, -0.02695409394800663, -0.2957717478275299, 1.1438952684402466, 0.4610457122325897, -0.9339056015014648, 0.18771719932556152, 0.35424304008483887, -0.2043326199054718, 0.6788017153739929, -0.6321262717247009, 0.33797982335090637, -0.45073965191841125, 0.25789597630500793, -1.252680778503418, -0.16109271347522736, 0.12236325442790985, -0.7056851387023926, 0.3323619067668915, 0.11737357825040817, -0.5892099738121033, -0.5641148090362549, -0.6235322952270508, 0.2790110409259796, 0.5596455931663513, -0.9161664247512817, 0.6734772324562073, -0.5938160419464111, -0.12299257516860962, -0.7925860285758972, -0.4580712914466858, 0.3425847291946411, -0.054649095982313156, -0.5848859548568726, 0.009999898262321949, -0.5822364687919617, -0.5488800406455994, -0.27100127935409546, -0.11267603188753128, 0.45066413283348083, 0.10763513296842575, 0.3283645808696747, 0.4397725760936737, -0.1469029188156128, -0.10826932638883591, -0.14160336554050446, -0.25770673155784607, 0.13295453786849976, -0.23965764045715332, 0.5320960879325867, -0.0706491768360138, -0.542230486869812, -0.8200907111167908, 0.10647939145565033, 0.2983962893486023, -0.17857353389263153, 0.6420956254005432, 0.2645617723464966, -0.019256098195910454, -0.005039437673985958, -0.9335288405418396, -0.5385183691978455, -0.6514379978179932, -0.26910996437072754, -0.41160309314727783, -0.9182335734367371, 0.2937459349632263, -0.29332050681114197, 0.4236955940723419, 0.12688897550106049, 0.5607522130012512, -0.19016234576702118, 1.160995602607727, 0.6065966486930847, 0.011948637664318085, 0.29097363352775574, -0.0165997464209795, 0.31082600355148315, -0.7283876538276672, -0.21817179024219513, -0.8724485635757446, -0.02162053994834423, -0.5278484225273132, -0.28038862347602844, 0.42641234397888184, -0.25293612480163574, -0.10743579268455505, -0.2776183485984802, -0.3438149690628052, 0.5741438269615173, 0.425797700881958, 0.05697185918688774, 0.5744747519493103, -0.020565729588270187, -0.11157743632793427, -0.15882359445095062, -0.7001394629478455, -0.6985375881195068, 0.9597545862197876, 0.19157055020332336, 1.0009219646453857, 0.03194539248943329, 0.540571391582489, -0.01456947810947895, 0.4139223098754883, -0.94204181432724, 0.4602945148944855, 0.24052968621253967, -0.5493611693382263, 0.002635225420817733, -0.3680555820465088, -0.7562369704246521, -0.4180777966976166, -0.07460937649011612, -0.7850540280342102, 0.05221828073263168, 0.47479358315467834, -0.6973541975021362, 0.05670968070626259, -0.39048752188682556, 0.13179248571395874, -0.2217164933681488, -0.30181631445884705, -0.19830797612667084, -0.6904030442237854, 0.3159249722957611, -0.1590886265039444, 0.10668216645717621, 0.08796888589859009, -0.05186493322253227, 0.44227325916290283, -0.2565464675426483, 0.9089352488517761, -0.09227946400642395, -0.5085706114768982, 0.15154588222503662, 0.3127497136592865, 0.8000070452690125, 0.08753066509962082, -0.6663918495178223, -0.022435571998357773, -0.40278375148773193, -0.3403066396713257, -0.48125624656677246, 0.7627185583114624, -0.5238989591598511, -1.1080201864242554, -0.19339457154273987, -0.7134212851524353, -0.5652862191200256, 0.19383390247821808, 0.6150540113449097, 0.417477548122406, 0.13651689887046814, 0.025318820029497147, 1.21294105052948, -0.26709890365600586, 0.6498128175735474, 0.6344232559204102, -0.09491213411092758, -0.20569434762001038, 0.637958288192749, 0.03774186968803406, 0.5747813582420349, -0.00944515597075224, 0.34062713384628296, -0.3059103488922119, -0.6831973791122437, -0.6589186787605286, 0.26003628969192505, -0.8140423893928528, -0.11702798306941986, -0.41516101360321045, 0.026992542669177055, -0.516107976436615, -0.2671646177768707, -0.3983056843280792, -0.12398828566074371, -0.38702577352523804, -0.22823549807071686, 0.5395053625106812, 0.988433301448822, 0.06904445588588715, 0.24631203711032867, -0.8703911900520325, 0.02670273557305336, 0.3101336658000946, 0.08203255385160446, 0.09665606915950775, -0.7466621398925781, 0.240682452917099, 0.1568448841571808, -0.1679723858833313, -0.7331252694129944, -0.0023351763375103474, 0.05190577730536461, 0.5010129809379578, 0.46665632724761963, 0.2495386153459549, 0.8364176750183105, -0.6407181024551392, 1.1364305019378662, 0.13681432604789734, -0.8351173400878906, 0.5358467102050781, -0.3022571802139282, 0.45486149191856384, 0.9174694418907166, 0.2561463713645935, -0.3509703278541565, -0.3942687213420868, -0.529140830039978, -0.6361857652664185, 0.439361572265625, 0.017067668959498405, 0.4786682724952698, 0.2855307161808014, 0.7994018197059631, 0.48127511143684387, 0.48854851722717285, -0.38654986023902893, -0.33512750267982483, -0.20477183163166046, -0.1712653934955597, 0.004069588612765074, -0.37168532609939575, -0.4604194760322571, 0.0027329225558787584, 0.8121585845947266, -0.39954039454460144, 0.1275373101234436, 0.15509508550167084, 0.08723191171884537, -0.4176730215549469, 0.20197521150112152, 0.7036526203155518, 0.7319989204406738, 0.3194495141506195, -0.0036372016184031963, 0.020659063011407852, -0.24913017451763153, 0.2007090449333191, -0.017072048038244247, -0.6554969549179077, 0.08312420547008514, 0.20668359100818634, 0.7604719996452332, -0.2523103952407837, -0.5866466760635376, 0.4464389681816101, -0.19906795024871826, -0.1985185146331787, -0.1372351497411728, 0.2152460664510727, -0.04123995080590248, 0.16780947148799896, 0.6479834914207458, 0.05995239317417145, 0.028252817690372467, -0.5856183767318726, 0.00034526712261140347, 0.513279139995575, -0.23898635804653168, -0.18362806737422943, 0.6151250004768372, -0.03328445181250572, -0.40467503666877747, 0.7588872909545898, -0.06691434234380722, -0.6474828720092773, 0.3230721950531006, 0.5224632024765015, 0.6128450036048889, -0.5283102989196777, 0.4258766770362854, 0.469994455575943, 0.4748411178588867, -0.3448040187358856, 0.27356621623039246, -0.19991713762283325, -0.6896990537643433, -0.5549488663673401, -0.19118888676166534, -0.615375280380249, 0.1686612367630005, -0.6417616605758667, 0.04125450924038887, -0.6265818476676941, -0.16451606154441833, -0.31950753927230835, -0.19385196268558502, -0.4633575975894928, 0.19292402267456055, 0.13467831909656525, 1.1088721752166748, -0.5193326473236084, 0.5013763308525085, 0.5201989412307739, -0.22645442187786102, -1.319356083869934, 0.558742105960846, 0.4280974268913269, -1.1962867975234985, 0.3652240037918091, 0.4069315493106842, -0.23974046111106873, 0.2652983069419861, -1.0508406162261963, -0.5773516297340393, 1.0851694345474243, 0.43685442209243774, -0.6004034876823425, 0.03947370499372482, 0.3458530604839325, 0.2541913390159607, -0.056486841291189194, 0.17896603047847748, 0.5879603624343872, 0.7629609704017639, 0.6142783164978027, -0.9084813594818115, 0.25130295753479004, -0.07670442014932632, 0.24741874635219574, -0.22787722945213318, -0.7173796892166138, 0.8058361411094666, -0.7098802328109741, -0.09716813266277313, 0.4354000687599182, 0.4585569202899933, 0.5760415196418762, 0.3204050362110138, 0.4814266860485077, 0.41694673895835876, 1.1215996742248535, -0.09323057532310486, 0.7943201065063477, -0.24326708912849426, -0.0949530228972435, 1.1903358697891235, -0.6559484004974365, 0.5594269037246704, 0.7269687652587891, 0.29326897859573364, 0.5992546677589417, 0.6800101399421692, 0.08129511028528214, 0.30568304657936096, 0.014222273603081703, -0.5535632371902466, -0.08354555070400238, -0.31092405319213867, -0.32049480080604553, 0.2293338179588318, 0.34693190455436707, -0.20124875009059906, -0.29399535059928894, 0.32927045226097107, 0.2755047678947449, 0.12862031161785126, -0.26618289947509766, 0.7284088730812073, 0.08514508605003357, -1.0984420776367188, 0.7183146476745605, -0.2025003284215927, 0.5910136103630066, -0.4228106737136841, -0.013202536851167679, -0.10058701038360596, -0.01877162605524063, -0.24402141571044922, -0.8558261394500732, -0.18388696014881134, 0.11823582649230957, -0.09239301830530167, -0.440464586019516, 0.5206736326217651, -0.21598932147026062, -0.0565158948302269, -0.15966050326824188, 0.3470528721809387, -0.3141431212425232, -0.1466335654258728, -0.8198185563087463, 0.45796290040016174, 0.24602314829826355, -0.44893309473991394, -0.11341194808483124, 0.4651329815387726, 0.17013269662857056, 0.8427796363830566, 0.6844766736030579, -0.10159062594175339, -0.08087629079818726, 0.07299435138702393, 0.8917311429977417, -0.5806571841239929, -0.1977269947528839, -1.0127604007720947, 0.7824631333351135, 0.08859630674123764, 0.004072819836437702, 0.8469419479370117, 0.17266514897346497, 0.5849367380142212, 0.2050589621067047, 0.8697585463523865, 0.06851283460855484, 0.3108185827732086, -0.662625253200531, 0.46403250098228455, -0.4226313829421997, 0.7712873816490173, 0.0777033194899559, -0.6447011232376099, -0.030165450647473335, 0.3551005423069, -0.3270338773727417, 0.2240869700908661, 0.7284117341041565, 1.0139766931533813, 0.5948712825775146, 0.414446622133255, 0.3034887909889221, 0.5470771789550781, 0.41176217794418335, 0.10711272805929184, 1.0385774374008179, -0.18146198987960815, 0.3689332604408264, -0.05607529357075691, -0.21244274079799652, -0.20582246780395508, -1.1616190671920776, -0.9012736678123474, -0.5624666810035706, -0.2448214590549469, -0.7334874868392944, 0.09452370554208755, 0.9043220281600952, 0.17273448407649994, -0.5423158407211304, 0.03840174153447151, -0.2259228378534317, -0.10992590337991714, 0.044716522097587585, -0.17046956717967987, -0.1476496160030365, -0.36128196120262146, -0.5494788885116577, 0.48270657658576965, 0.1680857390165329, 0.1628568470478058, -0.3844664990901947, -0.15809766948223114, 0.16534678637981415, 0.25691458582878113, 0.1638154834508896, 0.32909613847732544, -0.6819772124290466, -0.2859634459018707, 0.2008175551891327, -0.04838185012340546, 0.25039076805114746, 0.8010092377662659, -0.960048258304596, 0.6302620768547058, 0.2640734016895294, 0.611305296421051, 0.2410283237695694, -0.08352351188659668, 0.8013852834701538, -0.7845708131790161, -0.11109481751918793, 0.4448586404323578, -0.004800258204340935, 0.7945495843887329, -0.5271407961845398, 0.3138841390609741, 0.07227227091789246, -0.533845067024231, -0.9776492118835449, 0.39219793677330017, -0.5716375708580017, -0.04780366271734238, 1.2802422046661377, 0.037720587104558945, -0.3091013431549072, -0.0061804549768567085, -0.5001347661018372, 0.036300282925367355, -0.5064679384231567, 1.0033233165740967, 0.8586863875389099, -0.07024610787630081, -0.259190171957016, -0.5432909727096558, 0.5232459902763367, 0.7055190801620483, -0.5052074193954468, 0.40534383058547974, 0.6087026596069336, 0.27681416273117065, 0.30441877245903015, 0.7447351813316345, -0.060129083693027496, 0.49164703488349915, -0.20596428215503693, -0.3756301701068878, -0.008987851440906525, -0.20359526574611664, -0.6760876178741455, -0.04517100006341934, 0.5094788670539856, 0.3476509749889374 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06619v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06619v1	Aya Dataset: An Open-Access Collection for Multilingual Instruction Tuning	2024-02-09T18:51:49	2024-02-09T18:51:49	Shivalika Singh, Freddie Vargus, Daniel Dsouza, Börje F. Karlsson, Abinaya Mahendiran, Wei-Yin Ko, Herumb Shandilya, Jay Patel, Deividas Mataciunas, Laura OMahony, Mike Zhang, Ramith Hettiarachchi, Joseph Wilson, Marina Machado, Luisa Souza Moura, Dominik Krzemiński, Hakimeh Fadaei, Irem Ergün, Ifeoma Okoh, Aisha Alaagib, Oshan Mudannayake, Zaid Alyafeai, Vu Minh Chien, Sebastian Ruder, Surya Guthikonda, Emad A. Alghamdi, Sebastian Gehrmann, Niklas Muennighoff, Max Bartolo, Julia Kreutzer, Ahmet Üstün, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Datasets are foundational to many breakthroughs in modern artificial intelligence. Many recent achievements in the space of natural language processing (NLP) can be attributed to the finetuning of pre-trained models on a diverse set of tasks that enables a large language model (LLM) to respond to instructions. Instruction fine-tuning (IFT) requires specifically constructed and annotated datasets. However, existing datasets are almost all in the English language. In this work, our primary goal is to bridge the language gap by building a human-curated instruction-following dataset spanning 65 languages. We worked with fluent speakers of languages from around the world to collect natural instances of instructions and completions. Furthermore, we create the most extensive multilingual collection to date, comprising 513 million instances through templating and translating existing datasets across 114 languages. In total, we contribute four key resources: we develop and open-source the Aya Annotation Platform, the Aya Dataset, the Aya Collection, and the Aya Evaluation Suite. The Aya initiative also serves as a valuable case study in participatory research, involving collaborators from 119 countries. We see this as a valuable framework for future research collaborations that aim to bridge gaps in resources.	[ -0.1440936028957367, -0.48136213421821594, 0.0720396339893341, 0.14860482513904572, 0.02009560726583004, 0.1571730375289917, -0.5431722402572632, -0.3347819447517395, 0.13323363661766052, 0.543270468711853, -0.7501744627952576, -0.7264285683631897, -0.4480994641780853, 0.08289176225662231, -0.32550907135009766, 0.8669807314872742, -0.01965387724339962, 0.16852669417858124, 0.0534350723028183, -0.38188785314559937, -0.5307698249816895, -0.15987101197242737, -0.6203947067260742, -0.03363396227359772, 0.4966443181037903, 0.9543526768684387, 0.6049563884735107, 1.0767021179199219, 0.4061378240585327, 0.24631430208683014, 0.39149028062820435, 0.4820517599582672, -0.2137097716331482, 0.03974176570773125, -0.07824398577213287, -0.6452795267105103, -0.2544718086719513, -0.12547855079174042, 0.6984817385673523, 0.685913622379303, -0.30759841203689575, 0.5471615195274353, -0.014901683665812016, 0.8015478253364563, -0.7508785724639893, 0.5316133499145508, -0.39324241876602173, 0.015860803425312042, -0.5549867153167725, -0.08283579349517822, -0.2329893857240677, -0.5483221411705017, 0.1207069456577301, -0.8903713226318359, 0.20288129150867462, -0.1183333620429039, 0.5100247263908386, 0.44162827730178833, -0.07546666264533997, -0.5901506543159485, -0.487701416015625, 0.8623955249786377, -0.6016088128089905, 0.3958379924297333, 0.6695635914802551, 0.328673392534256, 0.04291534423828125, -0.5260628461837769, -0.39960718154907227, -0.13361889123916626, -0.04295831546187401, -0.13708584010601044, -0.017718592658638954, 0.04810689389705658, 0.08268256485462189, 0.41297903656959534, -0.5020799040794373, 0.22553464770317078, -0.5726193189620972, -0.13109558820724487, 0.6485329866409302, 0.063111811876297, 0.39026057720184326, -0.010413235984742641, -0.02699175477027893, -0.14611183106899261, -0.7890520691871643, 0.05456315726041794, 0.4808237850666046, 0.5771716833114624, -0.297248899936676, 0.5538713932037354, -0.25286081433296204, 0.8741312026977539, -0.3825736939907074, 0.12583942711353302, 0.19479897618293762, -0.39959096908569336, 0.04732136055827141, 0.3282955586910248, 0.7095529437065125, 0.01793178729712963, 0.5986271500587463, -0.10126370936632156, 0.043125592172145844, -0.002536161569878459, 0.22654671967029572, -0.6273564696311951, -0.4637864828109741, -0.03862886503338814, -0.3405723571777344, 0.15655475854873657, 0.3027420938014984, -0.7500965595245361, -0.40638604760169983, -0.618747353553772, 0.29324519634246826, -0.2626711428165436, -0.17008234560489655, 0.26598039269447327, 0.3531312942504883, 0.16668269038200378, 0.1779366284608841, -1.0729033946990967, 0.16451434791088104, 0.5986472368240356, 0.7554913759231567, 0.11156336963176727, -0.7169662714004517, -0.424178808927536, 0.1541711688041687, -0.35072261095046997, 0.5009009838104248, -0.6188122630119324, -0.2626588046550751, 0.29870450496673584, 0.2245335578918457, -0.1484634280204773, -0.4909123182296753, 0.478931725025177, -0.26862239837646484, 0.24607664346694946, -0.4224589765071869, -0.3905387818813324, -0.2513887286186218, 0.14577293395996094, -0.7325165867805481, 0.8504135608673096, -0.117855004966259, -0.4967111051082611, 0.09934821724891663, -0.9313992261886597, -0.6839213371276855, 0.09016435593366623, -0.23818546533584595, -0.15199248492717743, 0.14389176666736603, 0.34063422679901123, 0.22501958906650543, -0.5154057145118713, 0.11921970546245575, 0.023562250658869743, -0.3816552758216858, -0.06326161324977875, -0.6322252154350281, 0.9255742430686951, 0.11803314089775085, -0.4046529531478882, 0.17718388140201569, -0.9193019866943359, -0.07717743515968323, -0.1288464367389679, -0.3162955343723297, -0.4000522196292877, -0.05357305333018303, 0.003350765211507678, 0.09441829472780228, 0.4987076222896576, -0.5662402510643005, 0.4931972324848175, -0.2516065537929535, 0.4109257459640503, 0.7054408192634583, -0.06920656561851501, 0.3147958815097809, -0.1448967605829239, 0.6800445318222046, -0.18950223922729492, 0.3639677166938782, -0.704375147819519, -0.47754380106925964, -1.0447593927383423, -0.035386212170124054, 0.4027247726917267, 0.7570375800132751, -0.7923656702041626, 0.33597248792648315, -0.1716797798871994, -0.22791419923305511, -1.4351277351379395, 0.32333263754844666, 0.5913723707199097, 0.28787100315093994, 0.502004086971283, -0.15003588795661926, -0.5916433930397034, -0.980110228061676, 0.08282499015331268, -0.13646920025348663, -0.084537573158741, 0.1306106299161911, 0.29008957743644714, 0.011340245604515076, 0.5836063623428345, -0.40349167585372925, -0.4100039005279541, 0.332938015460968, 0.11763892322778702, 0.07274191081523895, 0.4527399241924286, 0.21781757473945618, -0.5292383432388306, -0.46773943305015564, 0.13046753406524658, -0.8575342893600464, 0.022120999172329903, 0.08363625407218933, -0.5374642014503479, 0.0318402424454689, 0.4525471329689026, -0.5067123174667358, 0.2630515992641449, 0.47101667523384094, -0.12788957357406616, 0.2016136348247528, -0.24569140374660492, 0.46619999408721924, -1.23373544216156, 0.09646214544773102, -0.17176219820976257, 0.28504127264022827, -0.38277846574783325, 0.11216223984956741, 0.11044373363256454, -0.18394291400909424, -0.30909061431884766, 0.5504874587059021, -0.5492373108863831, -0.019019894301891327, -0.1319759339094162, -0.160216823220253, -0.12145213782787323, 0.3624292314052582, -0.038061778992414474, 0.9021251201629639, 0.6553383469581604, -0.4708191156387329, 0.4306156039237976, 0.45787835121154785, -0.5112693309783936, 0.41154491901397705, -0.4638759195804596, 0.12706483900547028, -0.01906965859234333, -0.13954544067382812, -0.6188504099845886, -0.37580183148384094, 0.3875439763069153, -0.25197386741638184, 0.3374454081058502, -0.13733893632888794, -0.5408021211624146, -0.10754206776618958, -0.14903338253498077, 0.2773961126804352, 0.04454251378774643, -0.8179469704627991, 0.1833670288324356, 0.36621713638305664, -0.23170672357082367, -0.8947867751121521, -0.6939594149589539, 0.1451594978570938, 0.0053548491559922695, -0.3876396119594574, 0.16935868561267853, -0.13042213022708893, -0.1271573305130005, 0.2457910180091858, 0.0019734823144972324, -0.11924973130226135, -0.11354146152734756, 0.08471755683422089, 0.015105471946299076, -0.3620995879173279, 0.3201003968715668, -0.014073156751692295, -0.11539561301469803, -0.010150170885026455, -0.3849185109138489, 0.34700679779052734, 0.03340576961636543, -0.5302743315696716, -0.46496331691741943, 0.4425641596317291, 0.5392317175865173, -0.6227566599845886, 0.6666856408119202, 0.6089416146278381, -0.5539325475692749, -0.2912730872631073, -0.2459688037633896, -0.017409849911928177, -0.43221181631088257, 0.2518557012081146, -0.16422879695892334, -0.7151663303375244, 0.3907545804977417, 0.3273731470108032, 0.616636335849762, 0.2605727016925812, 0.36997970938682556, 0.0930524468421936, 0.8202633857727051, 0.7159498929977417, -0.5317767858505249, 0.6321977376937866, -0.3538958728313446, 0.024049781262874603, -0.3749845325946808, -0.26589635014533997, -0.6976518034934998, -0.31580621004104614, -0.6229568719863892, -0.4459865689277649, 0.2479875236749649, -0.1637413650751114, -0.23806795477867126, 0.1358334869146347, -0.4943954050540924, 0.5884257555007935, 0.835613489151001, -0.027869444340467453, 0.2556523084640503, 0.024518784135580063, 0.3883811831474304, 0.008775897324085236, -0.7262263894081116, -0.5009781122207642, 1.1399657726287842, -0.0035013698507100344, 0.6663503646850586, 0.14979884028434753, 0.42135241627693176, 0.3916914761066437, 0.15822039544582367, -0.8112173080444336, 0.3943035304546356, -0.4474564492702484, -0.5792315006256104, -0.2953397035598755, -0.3594404458999634, -1.203626275062561, -0.24413689970970154, -0.09191016852855682, -0.49798014760017395, -0.14438697695732117, 0.23814313113689423, -0.16833928227424622, 0.10669923573732376, -0.8101391792297363, 1.022957444190979, -0.3308156132698059, -0.3609199523925781, -0.3388746678829193, -0.7603365182876587, 0.3218327462673187, 0.19833634793758392, 0.21098904311656952, -0.06574501842260361, 0.02357628010213375, 0.6574435234069824, -0.07908366620540619, 0.8494693636894226, -0.32960984110832214, -0.13597196340560913, 0.33884552121162415, -0.23323048651218414, 0.03117467276751995, 0.07509858906269073, -0.24767494201660156, 0.17856410145759583, -0.2687160074710846, -0.6351242065429688, -0.41395121812820435, 0.7675253748893738, -0.8093968629837036, -0.27354109287261963, -0.16305945813655853, -0.627194881439209, -0.051123425364494324, 0.10128307342529297, 0.18940484523773193, 0.5179637670516968, -0.10355686396360397, 0.22992703318595886, 0.649807870388031, -0.25587597489356995, 0.3616166114807129, 0.6727619171142578, 0.06361926347017288, -0.22319115698337555, 1.1968809366226196, 0.3977336883544922, -0.15474985539913177, 0.5951395034790039, -0.0024486936163157225, -0.22697043418884277, -0.4346904158592224, -0.9958815574645996, 0.03268897533416748, -0.635581910610199, -0.2312728762626648, -0.15985721349716187, -0.149826779961586, -0.14730912446975708, 0.03531073033809662, -0.5146442651748657, -0.3717082440853119, -0.2823716402053833, -0.040991686284542084, 0.5539681315422058, 0.8411579728126526, 0.14254233241081238, 0.2751893401145935, -0.868890643119812, 0.27844706177711487, 0.17834912240505219, 0.540243923664093, 0.007149859331548214, -0.24901346862316132, -0.7372493147850037, 0.21165746450424194, -0.08977963030338287, -0.8587100505828857, 0.13066360354423523, 0.5000091791152954, 0.6730918884277344, 0.1857880800962448, -0.0822039395570755, 0.7730025053024292, -0.5430966019630432, 0.6815364956855774, -0.2604234516620636, -0.7526606917381287, 0.772864818572998, -0.3742356598377228, 0.5612434148788452, 0.8861640691757202, 0.5662854313850403, -0.5673433542251587, -0.19274574518203735, -0.40162596106529236, -0.9192079305648804, 0.828226625919342, 0.032797571271657944, 0.059850115329027176, 0.11756977438926697, 0.43397602438926697, 0.36059367656707764, 0.46729546785354614, -0.3080712556838989, -0.4401262104511261, -0.08921851217746735, -0.5940570831298828, -0.30700379610061646, 0.30141836404800415, -0.09561974555253983, -0.1859656721353531, 0.8918361663818359, -0.1881999522447586, -0.10772162675857544, -0.24733592569828033, -0.26481300592422485, -0.19936510920524597, 0.16239546239376068, 0.29622766375541687, 0.6729641556739807, 0.0420193113386631, -0.14574187994003296, -0.1256234049797058, -0.6396893858909607, 0.09419626742601395, 0.45572882890701294, -0.3958365023136139, -0.09692943096160889, 0.4069794714450836, 0.9206287860870361, 0.16916969418525696, -0.6866939663887024, 0.1156473159790039, -0.2539721429347992, 0.1391560286283493, -0.3036903142929077, 0.1365782916545868, -0.10665986686944962, 0.09423039853572845, 0.3696407675743103, -0.05545392259955406, 0.23816314339637756, -0.4891185164451599, 0.22525064647197723, 0.06428034603595734, -0.35045522451400757, -0.4697928726673126, 0.3980959951877594, 0.25554701685905457, -0.5494856238365173, 0.8887377977371216, -0.30084696412086487, -0.12286525219678879, 0.5432273149490356, 0.2548184096813202, 0.5874382853507996, -0.43868449330329895, 0.27023637294769287, 0.5531690120697021, 0.58692467212677, -0.2186218798160553, 0.3709542751312256, -0.16913753747940063, -0.5021732449531555, -0.3899137079715729, -0.6925183534622192, -0.7078313827514648, 0.29055553674697876, -0.8490142822265625, 0.35835540294647217, -0.24198392033576965, 0.3296455442905426, -0.14411196112632751, 0.316318541765213, -0.6272191405296326, 0.17161183059215546, 0.08454330265522003, 0.6863991022109985, -1.1324174404144287, 0.845832347869873, 1.035938024520874, -0.339886873960495, -0.5470181107521057, 0.06253544241189957, -0.012599807232618332, -0.8034636974334717, -0.14894382655620575, 0.4190012812614441, 0.07284730672836304, 0.06322839111089706, -0.33891627192497253, -0.7129210233688354, 0.772810161113739, 0.6938920617103577, -0.6176597476005554, -0.1373928040266037, 0.08705169707536697, 0.5033839344978333, -0.2981187403202057, -0.045315276831388474, 0.8300202488899231, 0.5445972681045532, -0.24715584516525269, -0.6859593391418457, -0.3074069619178772, -0.6038645505905151, -0.3665282428264618, 0.4636945128440857, -0.7322982549667358, 0.5263580679893494, -0.04264781251549721, -0.017406761646270752, 0.16585533320903778, 0.6534574627876282, 0.2692205011844635, 0.23642754554748535, 0.24604789912700653, 0.3409295976161957, 0.9291924834251404, -0.05590365082025528, 0.7144696116447449, -0.5366420745849609, -0.203828364610672, 1.230196475982666, 0.15842552483081818, 0.7211426496505737, 0.2695639431476593, -0.04308461770415306, 0.3724697530269623, 0.6544454097747803, 0.03281016647815704, 0.38135695457458496, 0.26241931319236755, -0.42030054330825806, 0.1242002323269844, -0.4803489148616791, -0.39904507994651794, 0.7352343797683716, 0.677050769329071, -0.08399125188589096, -0.061995189636945724, 0.022277897223830223, -0.14919553697109222, 0.32093703746795654, -0.41739222407341003, 0.5570821762084961, -0.17400410771369934, -0.8443246483802795, 0.305202841758728, 0.003763115731999278, 0.7120042443275452, -0.7906017303466797, -0.31447699666023254, -0.18243534862995148, 0.09359309077262878, -0.22404837608337402, -0.6923471093177795, 0.18752749264240265, 0.22706738114356995, -0.18200716376304626, -0.18193767964839935, 0.4698803424835205, -0.8722254633903503, -0.5413352251052856, 0.15206089615821838, 0.46473193168640137, 0.19864921271800995, 0.3619917333126068, -0.7274338006973267, 0.055880941450595856, 0.04321587085723877, -0.2973423898220062, 0.2024240791797638, 0.513784646987915, -0.2312648892402649, 0.37760627269744873, 0.5148389339447021, 0.12005816400051117, 0.3061997890472412, 0.2695036232471466, 0.5648729801177979, -0.3926112949848175, -0.385183721780777, -0.5516908168792725, 0.571142852306366, 0.10979874432086945, -0.7216400504112244, 0.8344051837921143, 0.7277194261550903, 1.1561146974563599, 0.06079232692718506, 0.9285287857055664, 0.000617760349996388, 0.38994064927101135, -0.5320007801055908, 0.6229093074798584, -0.49115175008773804, 0.13443119823932648, 0.15704987943172455, -0.8435808420181274, -0.23573501408100128, 0.756928563117981, 0.06753925234079361, -0.03902187570929527, 0.18616265058517456, 0.7945771217346191, -0.15738685429096222, 0.29613274335861206, -0.0024791043251752853, 0.0008591756923124194, 0.0809483751654625, 0.4687245190143585, 0.722310483455658, -0.4132543206214905, 0.4657658040523529, -0.4902450740337372, -0.17807959020137787, 0.11821477860212326, -0.7758181691169739, -0.7699965834617615, -0.7008394598960876, -0.16260698437690735, 0.01894623041152954, 0.3006502687931061, 1.1779237985610962, 0.6440306901931763, -0.952487051486969, -0.5707643628120422, -0.18742097914218903, 0.01728683151304722, -0.24303264915943146, -0.13852117955684662, 0.5103150010108948, -0.42748624086380005, -0.9061650633811951, 0.7069724202156067, 0.20159894227981567, -0.2866375148296356, -0.4971773326396942, -0.0266842320561409, -0.3828319311141968, -0.1837444305419922, 0.3453715443611145, 0.5990692377090454, -0.3831081688404083, -0.19327881932258606, 0.14840193092823029, 0.031214090064167976, 0.07187847048044205, 0.6824032664299011, -0.36975419521331787, 0.8584433197975159, 0.2662658095359802, 0.9190330505371094, 0.4036807417869568, -0.2691591680049896, 0.7066117525100708, -1.1974072456359863, 0.280170738697052, 0.18744727969169617, 0.1713133454322815, 0.6442129611968994, -0.18591107428073883, 0.6116211414337158, -0.11714073270559311, -0.48546239733695984, -0.7226256132125854, 0.1296575665473938, -0.5510171055793762, -0.10911017656326294, 0.8275619149208069, -0.3313409388065338, -0.12441661953926086, -0.05789430812001228, -0.2305418699979782, 0.638153612613678, -0.4274464547634125, 0.965394914150238, 0.8103925585746765, 0.10985440015792847, -0.16710811853408813, -0.8995692729949951, 0.47255992889404297, 0.39556363224983215, -1.0577623844146729, 0.3344087600708008, 0.5003508925437927, -0.180044025182724, 0.15308260917663574, 0.5971044898033142, 0.16928380727767944, 0.4906516373157501, -0.11408259719610214, 0.3037239611148834, -0.18849802017211914, -0.889565646648407, -0.5311458706855774, 0.0401713103055954, 0.110982745885849, -0.6074507832527161 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06617v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06617v1	FaBERT: Pre-training BERT on Persian Blogs	2024-02-09T18:50:51	2024-02-09T18:50:51	Mostafa Masumi, Seyed Soroush Majd, Mehrnoush Shamsfard, Hamid Beigy	cs.CL	cs.CL	We introduce FaBERT, a Persian BERT-base model pre-trained on the HmBlogs corpus, encompassing both informal and formal Persian texts. FaBERT is designed to excel in traditional Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks, addressing the intricacies of diverse sentence structures and linguistic styles prevalent in the Persian language. In our comprehensive evaluation of FaBERT on 12 datasets in various downstream tasks, encompassing Sentiment Analysis (SA), Named Entity Recognition (NER), Natural Language Inference (NLI), Question Answering (QA), and Question Paraphrasing (QP), it consistently demonstrated improved performance, all achieved within a compact model size. The findings highlight the importance of utilizing diverse and cleaned corpora, such as HmBlogs, to enhance the performance of language models like BERT in Persian Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications. FaBERT is openly accessible at https://huggingface.co/sbunlp/fabert	[ -0.49240899085998535, -0.6068091988563538, 0.19459490478038788, 0.41170787811279297, -0.5052104592323303, 0.3031955659389496, -0.5593460202217102, -0.31578972935676575, 0.4234583079814911, 0.19894343614578247, -0.7072789072990417, -0.43467116355895996, -0.4857005476951599, 0.2894483804702759, -0.4741045832633972, 1.5211750268936157, 0.08768434822559357, 0.28286170959472656, 0.22550055384635925, 0.15703123807907104, -0.11631979048252106, -0.4542987048625946, -0.4314405024051666, 0.07805677503347397, 0.6465840339660645, 0.24999240040779114, 0.7453867793083191, 0.10434620827436447, 0.596916913986206, 0.28068435192108154, 0.10186921060085297, 0.13289809226989746, -0.6532987356185913, 0.20106194913387299, -0.23061175644397736, -0.07768130302429199, -0.1960514336824417, -0.2753596305847168, 0.6595340371131897, 0.7566817402839661, -0.24369238317012787, 0.2748275399208069, 0.17840588092803955, 0.8664167523384094, -0.6459062695503235, -0.24074803292751312, -0.4217038154602051, -0.12762515246868134, -0.3951699137687683, 0.029585039243102074, -0.2564356029033661, -0.7853395938873291, 0.3596113324165344, -0.6750385165214539, 0.1413356065750122, -0.011660903692245483, 1.0341652631759644, 0.2807983160018921, -0.37542080879211426, -0.3555701673030853, -0.9233693480491638, 0.899458110332489, -0.49598628282546997, 0.5358933210372925, 0.28981465101242065, 0.2579280138015747, -0.004829240031540394, -0.7193271517753601, -0.4346194565296173, -0.15571613609790802, -0.26241448521614075, 0.1173987165093422, -0.16324768960475922, -0.16829833388328552, -0.055022381246089935, 0.28220200538635254, -0.8678740859031677, -0.3832551836967468, -0.376191645860672, 0.17044948041439056, 0.3264666795730591, -0.28107649087905884, 0.14336638152599335, -0.18523246049880981, -0.41349104046821594, -0.04987235739827156, -0.8714110255241394, -0.03125153109431267, 0.6076216101646423, 0.15874083340168, 0.223035529255867, 0.3719508945941925, -0.35009896755218506, 0.5932311415672302, 0.34459564089775085, 0.32298412919044495, 0.003920373041182756, -0.26193559169769287, -0.06741377711296082, 0.2578691840171814, 0.5612577795982361, -0.43487435579299927, 0.21172864735126495, -0.015350405126810074, -0.009144872426986694, -0.4418933093547821, 0.5922984480857849, -0.9852447509765625, -0.7479429841041565, 0.08103947341442108, -0.641665518283844, -0.07036058604717255, 0.2013397067785263, -0.6547240018844604, -0.3560936152935028, -0.3139813244342804, 0.2920365035533905, -0.7158576250076294, -0.5004737973213196, 0.27414780855178833, 0.06972365826368332, 0.4181687533855438, 0.6554297804832458, -0.9671278595924377, 0.36422136425971985, 0.6736497282981873, 0.4050246775150299, -0.025246627628803253, -0.06493793427944183, -0.46576401591300964, 0.04442320764064789, -0.21840624511241913, 0.9962055683135986, -0.45724382996559143, -0.35719844698905945, 0.15133337676525116, -0.5469351410865784, -0.2604010999202728, -0.3343929946422577, 0.8933064937591553, -0.707534909248352, 0.574964165687561, -0.4603389501571655, -0.5616955161094666, -0.3177042603492737, 0.23436497151851654, -0.6602084040641785, 1.1097322702407837, 0.05242249369621277, -1.2685717344284058, 0.1423177421092987, -0.860283374786377, -0.5775227546691895, 0.14386692643165588, 0.18117783963680267, -0.35485294461250305, 0.1246500238776207, 0.22768953442573547, 0.40255385637283325, 0.0313403345644474, 0.05445551872253418, -0.22196054458618164, -0.24704419076442719, 0.1820649951696396, -0.05856870487332344, 0.9993205666542053, 0.30039364099502563, -0.28434255719184875, 0.21453694999217987, -0.6641872525215149, 0.07066358625888824, -0.2734386622905731, -0.5206912159919739, -0.38789233565330505, 0.10913802683353424, 0.4972856342792511, 0.10686081647872925, 0.38701504468917847, -0.6294459700584412, 0.06270895153284073, -0.33436310291290283, 0.032894860953092575, 0.7280386686325073, -0.18629461526870728, 0.15015166997909546, -0.14824263751506805, 0.5864160060882568, -0.4285716414451599, 0.00943673588335514, 0.1741490364074707, -0.32621249556541443, -0.8395684361457825, -0.4467117190361023, 0.5817126035690308, 0.6579200625419617, -0.7838842868804932, 0.47897660732269287, -0.39405205845832825, -0.63695228099823, -0.41958844661712646, 0.4441208243370056, 0.2363433688879013, 0.25024303793907166, 0.27500930428504944, -0.38042497634887695, -0.7704877853393555, -0.8850014209747314, -0.517848789691925, -0.2567528784275055, 0.0756809264421463, -0.0015455880202353, 0.6109945774078369, -0.0864342749118805, 0.910232663154602, -0.2784171402454376, 0.0010063026566058397, -0.7827856540679932, 0.6485543847084045, 0.2749968469142914, 0.5341566801071167, 0.4750630259513855, -0.9580618143081665, -1.0889363288879395, 0.0334475040435791, -0.4155243933200836, -0.05217520520091057, -0.059179771691560745, -0.517431914806366, 0.14004623889923096, 0.3237215280532837, -0.900964081287384, 0.458355188369751, 0.5383031368255615, -0.1694336086511612, 0.8958314061164856, 0.13287284970283508, 0.15070365369319916, -1.155347228050232, 0.11800197511911392, -0.07579334825277328, -0.4010075628757477, -0.8955520987510681, -0.15206140279769897, 0.07129573822021484, 0.12334248423576355, -0.6765682697296143, 0.33841922879219055, -0.33821794390678406, 0.18133217096328735, -0.20631374418735504, -0.237439826130867, -0.1515464037656784, 0.5147607326507568, 0.49866682291030884, 1.0641977787017822, 0.32722529768943787, -0.38703957200050354, 0.2666764557361603, 0.3536805212497711, -0.6133067607879639, 0.5800575613975525, -0.6948547959327698, 0.07874517142772675, 0.001150447758845985, 0.24790716171264648, -0.8370242714881897, -0.05559037625789642, 0.15119905769824982, -0.4557679295539856, 0.39409369230270386, 0.23254624009132385, -0.7590985894203186, -0.2406388819217682, -0.6038120985031128, 0.3603326380252838, 0.6548585295677185, -0.5467085838317871, 0.629167377948761, -0.03298190236091614, -0.42847898602485657, -0.6213315725326538, -0.093903087079525, -0.02409607358276844, -0.20715077221393585, -0.5281832814216614, 0.07148708403110504, -0.0944088026881218, -0.19431662559509277, 0.09414330869913101, 0.08093863725662231, -0.3920184075832367, 0.15019088983535767, 0.013982614502310753, 0.0381622314453125, -0.6002495288848877, 0.2291441410779953, 0.044298090040683746, 0.1376718133687973, -0.04284117370843887, -0.31199073791503906, 0.727518618106842, -0.43550553917884827, -0.2938767671585083, -0.5666449069976807, 0.2953934073448181, -0.2207445651292801, -0.4074734151363373, 0.9678496718406677, 1.111082911491394, -0.1979455053806305, -0.10849230736494064, -0.5379934310913086, -0.28141406178474426, -0.48976054787635803, 0.33790627121925354, -0.2124001681804657, -0.8370985984802246, 0.1551162749528885, -0.1925887167453766, -0.05389369651675224, 0.49644023180007935, 0.7563037872314453, -0.4730992019176483, 0.672308623790741, 0.8193578720092773, -0.17996911704540253, 0.6160701513290405, 0.016237925738096237, 0.5146164298057556, -0.6100457310676575, 0.36503544449806213, -0.5839998126029968, -0.22885580360889435, -0.5828149318695068, -0.07282149791717529, 0.3016359508037567, 0.037932392209768295, -0.2526126205921173, 0.34882089495658875, -0.12735505402088165, 0.562917172908783, 0.8587458729743958, 0.02944790944457054, 0.23404397070407867, -0.051861293613910675, 0.3028654158115387, -0.2765781581401825, -0.6010321378707886, -0.5222910046577454, 1.1393357515335083, 0.00006734421185683459, 0.8411397337913513, 0.28855982422828674, 0.9523356556892395, 0.4378049969673157, 0.47393783926963806, -0.3480299115180969, 0.33467260003089905, -0.06071624532341957, -0.90010005235672, -0.08462420105934143, -0.10121380537748337, -0.903826117515564, 0.3615083396434784, -0.06976798921823502, -0.4839457869529724, 0.07781177014112473, 0.05134175717830658, -0.5614901185035706, 0.269498735666275, -0.558940052986145, 0.9593273997306824, -0.2810106873512268, -0.32766127586364746, -0.3656417429447174, -0.7545163035392761, 0.5590441823005676, -0.10530795156955719, -0.05428147315979004, 0.026834668591618538, 0.21172426640987396, 0.8659729361534119, -0.31672900915145874, 0.8028967976570129, 0.08281969279050827, 0.05410036817193031, 0.21857436001300812, 0.16483931243419647, 0.028951488435268402, 0.2672204375267029, 0.12514027953147888, 0.03810359910130501, 0.14706774055957794, -0.7439960837364197, -0.3099461793899536, 0.4526385962963104, -0.8325093984603882, -0.550163984298706, -0.7804979681968689, -0.3631993532180786, -0.2836715281009674, 0.217463418841362, 0.12352778017520905, 0.1917448490858078, -0.7645561695098877, 0.314449667930603, 0.9468477964401245, -0.36019518971443176, 0.07312518358230591, 0.3420048952102661, -0.23244205117225647, -0.13196350634098053, 0.8331574201583862, -0.5540993213653564, 0.08152361214160919, 0.5958225727081299, -0.18023593723773956, -0.12830473482608795, -0.3934628367424011, -0.5203716158866882, 0.48411864042282104, -0.5863134264945984, -0.19338960945606232, -0.572622537612915, -0.29807335138320923, -0.3445762097835541, -0.13789322972297668, -0.428681880235672, -0.7607740759849548, -0.35984212160110474, -0.09507635980844498, 0.24543361365795135, 0.9881026148796082, -0.2959037721157074, 0.6137453317642212, -0.8078339695930481, 0.24966533482074738, 0.3944515585899353, 0.0764675959944725, -0.38591262698173523, -0.35395315289497375, -0.6156817078590393, 0.016396870836615562, -0.5582762360572815, -0.8609794974327087, 0.5500444769859314, 0.5199664235115051, 0.2768547534942627, 0.6259952783584595, -0.1073949858546257, 0.43368977308273315, -0.7605497241020203, 0.6869974732398987, -0.10612035542726517, -0.9790002703666687, 0.675279438495636, -0.7102218270301819, 0.17720068991184235, 0.7189646363258362, 0.8179650902748108, -0.6408166289329529, -0.41652852296829224, -0.46981438994407654, -0.5074863433837891, 0.6510640382766724, 0.3850160241127014, 0.2349969446659088, 0.0793893113732338, 0.1660756766796112, 0.4274284839630127, 0.5814661383628845, -0.8058147430419922, -0.12814927101135254, -0.3392268121242523, -0.36322230100631714, 0.02880704775452614, -0.4080260694026947, 0.009465031325817108, -0.5409473776817322, 1.003574252128601, 0.28436705470085144, 0.3596602976322174, 0.01947968453168869, -0.6599884629249573, -0.054667528718709946, 0.3451465666294098, 0.5684658885002136, 0.8102699518203735, -0.6428240537643433, -0.04731813445687294, -0.12305529415607452, -0.5926057696342468, -0.3121841847896576, 0.4223859906196594, 0.038082778453826904, 0.2714254558086395, 0.29177165031433105, 0.4113921523094177, 0.27414199709892273, -0.7860456109046936, 0.4928654730319977, -0.34189483523368835, -0.12756894528865814, -0.4287019670009613, -0.2250458300113678, 0.04947587847709656, 0.008598238229751587, 0.34885087609291077, -0.057352464646101, 0.36948078870773315, -0.2826562225818634, 0.18653033673763275, 0.46869322657585144, -0.24718527495861053, -0.6048482060432434, 0.5619339942932129, 0.24082818627357483, 0.19170786440372467, 0.6533641815185547, -0.41825759410858154, -1.0092962980270386, 0.15096978843212128, 0.2215442955493927, 0.8788703083992004, -0.3911075294017792, 0.5947629809379578, 0.21162565052509308, 0.24505598843097687, 0.09345526248216629, 0.4120050370693207, -0.29604488611221313, -0.6781801581382751, -0.4808507263660431, -0.787841796875, -0.7092687487602234, -0.2122214287519455, -0.7095929980278015, 0.14186058938503265, -0.4794244170188904, 0.062440406531095505, -0.11137840896844864, 0.24356217682361603, -0.7285012602806091, -0.1018315777182579, 0.1994888037443161, 0.7984792590141296, -0.7412150502204895, 1.1308178901672363, 0.8876581192016602, -0.30560168623924255, -0.42628857493400574, -0.07103634625673294, -0.12823258340358734, -0.6332079172134399, 1.1149230003356934, 0.1022157073020935, -0.2391006499528885, -0.024688145145773888, -0.5639350414276123, -0.9677170515060425, 0.5164483785629272, 0.06321848183870316, -0.05015971511602402, 0.23215529322624207, 0.04158759117126465, 0.7488090395927429, -0.055925872176885605, 0.13078053295612335, 0.49097853899002075, 0.40605515241622925, -0.36073607206344604, -0.9339494109153748, -0.2921033799648285, -0.523110568523407, -0.09176789224147797, 0.25928494334220886, -0.3143596053123474, 1.1912219524383545, 0.07745823264122009, -0.1521318405866623, 0.4513784348964691, 0.9135112762451172, -0.12480168789625168, -0.22910383343696594, 0.3193580210208893, 0.687067985534668, 0.7057665586471558, 0.006105139851570129, 1.202502727508545, -0.3391352593898773, 0.3113155663013458, 1.0055382251739502, -0.4379018545150757, 1.0509227514266968, 0.38848334550857544, -0.30379587411880493, 1.1700239181518555, 0.7533109188079834, 0.3469237983226776, 0.8093529939651489, 0.11281048506498337, -0.450909286737442, -0.28785979747772217, -0.09596031904220581, -0.5585908889770508, 0.28190430998802185, 0.35176652669906616, 0.06781370937824249, -0.39778947830200195, 0.060813382267951965, 0.24467840790748596, 0.1832110434770584, -0.03352072462439537, 0.819818377494812, -0.1624584048986435, -0.3873235583305359, 0.5783533453941345, 0.09280373901128769, 0.7296903133392334, -0.7557052969932556, 0.08724436163902283, -0.15758614242076874, 0.2729252874851227, 0.07196161895990372, -0.4266962707042694, 0.30929768085479736, 0.13002605736255646, 0.006763158831745386, -0.6519086956977844, 0.9027934670448303, -0.5028301477432251, -0.7564120888710022, -0.13742594420909882, 0.9298295378684998, 0.17969761788845062, -0.33962395787239075, -0.7148070335388184, -0.24283453822135925, 0.013651302084326744, -0.5426650643348694, 0.2793719172477722, 0.6006212830543518, 0.10908210277557373, 0.4089979827404022, 0.7092288136482239, 0.12164176255464554, 0.24772073328495026, -0.15428458154201508, 1.0441848039627075, -0.5275711417198181, -0.41312411427497864, -0.7125936150550842, 0.25862500071525574, -0.2005515843629837, -0.2947958707809448, 1.0554783344268799, 0.7070242166519165, 0.8614368438720703, -0.3320677578449249, 0.7124724984169006, -0.09408628940582275, 1.18498694896698, -0.37726011872291565, 0.8164809346199036, -0.3198241591453552, -0.0016831945395097136, 0.013959595002233982, -1.009109377861023, -0.29094505310058594, 1.0069304704666138, -0.7041404247283936, 0.05966560170054436, 0.9114081263542175, 0.4585645794868469, -0.23257523775100708, 0.4129493236541748, -0.12287665903568268, 0.16462557017803192, 0.16375455260276794, 0.4467604458332062, 1.1773310899734497, -0.0727667361497879, 0.47949469089508057, -0.4272148907184601, 0.07421038299798965, -0.2505737245082855, -0.6606082320213318, -1.2667564153671265, -0.5601037740707397, -0.006658897735178471, -0.03311890363693237, 0.3724297285079956, 1.1545907258987427, 0.7059009671211243, -1.0873817205429077, -0.5374955534934998, 0.22262275218963623, 0.12136256694793701, -0.020801164209842682, -0.18784278631210327, 0.5960529446601868, -0.6211237907409668, -0.6509093642234802, 0.043636754155159, 0.13111302256584167, -0.3109116852283478, -0.08692431449890137, 0.016542183235287666, -0.7259324193000793, 0.0449724905192852, 0.5074711441993713, 0.4017401933670044, -0.3851291239261627, -0.07918918877840042, 0.06784066557884216, -0.11185866594314575, 0.2553512752056122, 0.8795228004455566, -0.9092385768890381, 0.011831068433821201, 0.29470542073249817, 0.9740224480628967, 0.4613589644432068, 0.3448665738105774, 0.5301677584648132, -0.8720263242721558, 0.1661752611398697, 0.3819272518157959, 0.2608420252799988, 0.5125762820243835, -0.154713436961174, 0.40022262930870056, -0.013467381708323956, -0.5013775825500488, -0.7060021758079529, 0.13136526942253113, -0.8632035851478577, -0.3310973048210144, 0.9512645602226257, -0.12943708896636963, -0.21394431591033936, -0.24937668442726135, -0.4753545820713043, -0.011988354846835136, -0.5156455039978027, 0.8856506943702698, 0.8798044919967651, -0.20277151465415955, 0.008547389879822731, -0.7998992800712585, 0.8988145589828491, 0.9088252186775208, -0.9800904393196106, -0.24792100489139557, 0.41818490624427795, 0.08126809448003769, -0.004715272691100836, 0.6686127185821533, 0.39897140860557556, 0.5110735893249512, -0.5490269064903259, 0.10943423956632614, 0.5025796890258789, -0.1693819910287857, -0.19328348338603973, -0.2304604947566986, 0.18181942403316498, -0.15354043245315552 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06608v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06608v2	TIC: Translate-Infer-Compile for accurate "text to plan" using LLMs and Logical Representations	2024-02-09T18:39:13	2024-06-29T00:30:04	Sudhir Agarwal, Anu Sreepathy	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	We study the problem of generating plans for given natural language planning task requests. On one hand, LLMs excel at natural language processing but do not perform well on planning. On the other hand, classical planning tools excel at planning tasks but require input in a structured language such as the Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL). We leverage the strengths of both the techniques by using an LLM for generating the PDDL representation (task PDDL) of planning task requests followed by using a classical planner for computing a plan. Unlike previous approaches that use LLMs for generating task PDDLs directly, our approach comprises of (a) translate: using an LLM only for generating a logically interpretable intermediate representation of natural language task description, (b) infer: deriving additional logically dependent information from the intermediate representation using a logic reasoner (currently, Answer Set Programming solver), and (c) compile: generating the target task PDDL from the base and inferred information. We observe that using an LLM to only output the intermediate representation significantly reduces LLM errors. Consequently, TIC approach achieves, for at least one LLM, high accuracy on task PDDL generation for all seven domains of our evaluation dataset.	[ -0.13105778396129608, -0.7079497575759888, 0.7674605846405029, 0.413106769323349, -0.10500749945640564, 0.07552564889192581, -0.29523980617523193, -0.2126510888338089, 0.15584878623485565, 0.6212911009788513, -0.6636402010917664, -0.4835239052772522, -0.45584189891815186, 0.2085883617401123, -0.2858572006225586, 0.8774752020835876, -0.38521307706832886, 0.0815577432513237, -0.2590288519859314, 0.25129446387290955, -0.4290221333503723, -0.38396239280700684, -0.7112743854522705, -0.6556417942047119, 0.1680719554424286, 0.5057777762413025, 0.4933268129825592, 0.6449152827262878, 0.4478447735309601, 0.22349108755588531, 0.13390082120895386, 0.5762485265731812, -0.3400513231754303, 0.09759195148944855, -0.2172974944114685, -0.43813544511795044, -0.6087271571159363, -0.06849899142980576, 0.5980352163314819, 0.840596616268158, -0.16316387057304382, 0.1714814454317093, 0.031193094328045845, 0.614193320274353, -0.6349005699157715, 0.42476963996887207, -0.64467853307724, 0.0014627791242673993, -0.20340687036514282, -0.50722336769104, -0.7899323105812073, -0.32270631194114685, 0.03295056149363518, -0.41933658719062805, 0.009470360353589058, -0.022436106577515602, 0.46254387497901917, 0.40911513566970825, -0.45777180790901184, -0.5392528176307678, -1.0579555034637451, 0.732327401638031, -0.6155598163604736, 0.24565055966377258, 0.4004427194595337, 0.24721218645572662, -0.5872844457626343, -0.743386447429657, -0.6501761078834534, -0.05914692208170891, -0.04803627356886864, 0.10430409014225006, -0.04430777579545975, 0.293157696723938, 0.5103075504302979, 0.12433502823114395, -0.5185623168945312, -0.17273810505867004, -0.183862566947937, -0.11852956563234329, 0.6573424339294434, 0.25755318999290466, 0.17268824577331543, -0.16224856674671173, -0.48789551854133606, 0.06958798319101334, -1.057948350906372, -0.11346396803855896, 0.06031570956110954, 0.26894718408584595, -0.09366416186094284, 0.9629401564598083, -0.30409154295921326, 0.6562209129333496, 0.05898033455014229, -0.3591887354850769, -0.19114986062049866, -0.5240240693092346, -0.6377764940261841, 0.16851675510406494, 0.581578254699707, 0.38008370995521545, 0.3539416491985321, -0.4475878179073334, -0.3469923138618469, 0.12624762952327728, 0.2911604344844818, -0.7677082419395447, -0.20909275114536285, 0.17605607211589813, -0.14688146114349365, 0.05348796024918556, -0.17399047315120697, -0.4748268127441406, -0.12050577998161316, -0.5402134656906128, 0.18300719559192657, -0.443532258272171, 0.08711995929479599, 0.11543925106525421, 0.2534751296043396, 0.2756100594997406, 0.41448575258255005, -0.6237026453018188, 0.5660317540168762, 0.34690093994140625, 0.6177208423614502, -0.21067188680171967, -0.05757559463381767, -0.8301235437393188, 0.5246195793151855, -0.4516596496105194, 0.9455661773681641, -0.10542893409729004, -0.6411311030387878, 0.13771840929985046, -0.3731406629085541, 0.029496200382709503, -0.46012839674949646, 0.8043078184127808, -0.29816845059394836, 0.07634667307138443, -0.2171802520751953, -0.6005280017852783, -0.10912306606769562, 0.22064483165740967, -0.6672443151473999, 0.9501309990882874, 0.15639066696166992, -0.5744962692260742, 0.41397833824157715, -0.7514184713363647, -0.6454278230667114, 0.10089676827192307, -0.37609419226646423, -0.001640237751416862, -0.0459875762462616, 0.3121475279331207, 0.6618530750274658, -0.5536084175109863, 0.36793068051338196, 0.24809935688972473, -0.04526297748088837, 0.30813533067703247, -0.1751871258020401, 0.6989144086837769, 0.2455817013978958, -0.3536207675933838, 0.32610026001930237, -0.5097746849060059, 0.1913544088602066, 0.06244894489645958, -0.6480739712715149, 0.13055406510829926, 0.46809136867523193, -0.0874224379658699, 0.14566966891288757, 0.3410519063472748, -0.5831764936447144, 0.08691998571157455, -0.760897159576416, 0.2209351658821106, 0.5783506035804749, -0.0907251313328743, 0.8032833933830261, -0.34227341413497925, 0.4070436358451843, -0.27696821093559265, -0.27002665400505066, 0.20161519944667816, -0.3589457869529724, -0.7006516456604004, 0.03343552350997925, 0.07087478041648865, 0.5872626304626465, -1.3480113744735718, 0.24786972999572754, -0.5819520354270935, -0.39351266622543335, 0.04085206612944603, -0.07303594052791595, 0.5147989392280579, 0.6728686690330505, 0.32397976517677307, 0.12210379540920258, -0.4561297297477722, -0.6333035826683044, -0.07736847549676895, -0.26672637462615967, 0.1314113289117813, -0.12370531260967255, 0.32895100116729736, 0.08809471130371094, 0.9728239178657532, -0.479218453168869, -0.29044362902641296, -0.8656453490257263, -0.027312831953167915, 0.2675577700138092, 0.19677937030792236, 0.4436281621456146, -0.7799351215362549, -0.7640432119369507, 0.05512155219912529, -0.48476359248161316, -0.17404015362262726, -0.3106516897678375, -0.24473202228546143, 0.3741472065448761, 0.27469590306282043, -0.6151735782623291, 0.6390270590782166, 0.31007909774780273, -0.39925500750541687, 0.6123395562171936, -0.34613484144210815, -0.15647614002227783, -1.1517088413238525, -0.03704803064465523, 0.04922221228480339, -0.46345269680023193, -0.7271795272827148, -0.03734659031033516, 0.14738582074642181, -0.020406607538461685, -0.3722913861274719, 0.7133028507232666, -0.42610615491867065, 0.013999270275235176, -0.23053649067878723, 0.10217368602752686, -0.1982841193675995, 0.5362605452537537, 0.1209472194314003, 0.973074734210968, 0.3483278155326843, -0.7780870199203491, 0.4236803650856018, 0.4008094072341919, -0.15302295982837677, 0.57533198595047, -0.35811036825180054, 0.06651120632886887, 0.12839961051940918, 0.20980249345302582, -0.6504899263381958, -0.27904394268989563, 0.49078166484832764, -0.44681739807128906, 0.48320019245147705, -0.040697284042835236, -0.7931216955184937, -0.16400495171546936, -0.15343822538852692, 0.13603568077087402, 0.33843979239463806, -0.5599398016929626, 0.7564294934272766, 0.42235279083251953, -0.30147016048431396, -0.23995929956436157, -1.0274841785430908, 0.1169428825378418, -0.04603897035121918, -0.6070964932441711, 0.8728927969932556, -0.0151997534558177, -0.2897346317768097, 0.07828155159950256, -0.25638753175735474, -0.08596435934305191, -0.2117871642112732, 0.2575112581253052, 0.33595359325408936, -0.028687596321105957, -0.09780439734458923, -0.040959667414426804, -0.1628313660621643, 0.4068501591682434, -0.18195268511772156, 0.6019223928451538, 0.2214110791683197, -0.21322131156921387, -0.3369450569152832, 0.4502835273742676, 0.2789369225502014, -0.2698747217655182, 0.48500505089759827, 0.027956143021583557, -0.6068339347839355, -0.6111724376678467, -0.3957579731941223, 0.22232626378536224, -0.37669819593429565, 0.08038230240345001, -0.539469838142395, -0.22986255586147308, 0.2780822217464447, -0.3038638234138489, 0.23538024723529816, 0.4102829694747925, 0.6569985151290894, -0.1124832034111023, 0.7922001481056213, 0.7709718346595764, 0.32494139671325684, 0.19783025979995728, -0.5026232600212097, 0.06977381557226181, -0.7739576697349548, -0.3177192211151123, -0.4700849652290344, -0.2882173955440521, -0.27685827016830444, -0.634761393070221, 0.2815141975879669, -0.09241164475679398, 0.01728082075715065, 0.5415183305740356, -0.36226001381874084, 0.30088937282562256, 0.3259916305541992, 0.0158395953476429, 0.33770161867141724, 0.27606210112571716, -0.23501239717006683, -0.21984638273715973, -0.5799506306648254, -0.8592860698699951, 1.3090320825576782, 0.029376259073615074, 0.7320444583892822, 0.09225401282310486, 0.7923550009727478, 0.05254768580198288, 0.3345228135585785, -0.7873184084892273, 0.8679286241531372, -0.3175545930862427, -0.3136201500892639, -0.16482970118522644, -0.45524004101753235, -0.6692864894866943, -0.14665931463241577, -0.27158087491989136, -0.6787952184677124, 0.032024089246988297, 0.00006943407061044127, -0.18759459257125854, 0.33367305994033813, -0.6737494468688965, 0.6521267890930176, -0.4602297842502594, -0.23983879387378693, -0.3409140110015869, -0.3885907828807831, 0.10769335925579071, -0.058845289051532745, -0.07648178935050964, -0.17700335383415222, -0.1966971606016159, 0.6349843144416809, -0.414194792509079, 0.6133341789245605, -0.03274111449718475, 0.004268720280379057, 0.2649035155773163, 0.2599451243877411, 0.8284132480621338, 0.012846319936215878, -0.5284420251846313, -0.41629427671432495, -0.10621105879545212, -0.3010517656803131, -0.48448628187179565, 0.44741570949554443, -0.4144352376461029, -0.3686947822570801, -0.4601896107196808, -0.775214672088623, -0.3005889058113098, 0.19829042255878448, 0.23385430872440338, 0.6246674060821533, -0.37908896803855896, -0.229146346449852, 0.2882881164550781, -0.13911770284175873, 0.5067142248153687, 0.09354061633348465, -0.22703352570533752, -0.35039079189300537, 0.6977753043174744, 0.07605121284723282, 0.4729521870613098, 0.6653822660446167, -0.14977975189685822, -0.5220574140548706, -0.9561892151832581, -0.3838485777378082, 0.2988985776901245, -0.8770815134048462, -0.34196460247039795, -0.19817036390304565, -0.3827194273471832, -0.2577984035015106, -0.17555733025074005, -0.14986273646354675, -0.3072092831134796, -0.2193722128868103, 0.09391527622938156, 0.07911732792854309, 0.9135870337486267, 0.14284378290176392, 0.30403611063957214, -0.3950839042663574, 0.4805401861667633, -0.1662585586309433, 0.039739564061164856, -0.6662058234214783, -0.10576780140399933, -0.2335321307182312, 0.17293889820575714, -0.4920622706413269, -0.9825752377510071, 0.6428962349891663, 0.20606215298175812, 0.6566597819328308, -0.07447285205125809, 0.4336070418357849, 0.8345301747322083, -0.5047168731689453, 0.46951234340667725, 0.17900803685188293, -0.6999638080596924, 0.7967073321342468, 0.06352290511131287, 0.2031177580356598, 0.38050591945648193, 0.3083602786064148, -0.1597924679517746, -0.30467697978019714, -0.6485573053359985, -0.553992748260498, 0.7606443762779236, 0.4372345209121704, -0.16412438452243805, -0.15615829825401306, 0.4170460104942322, 0.004334793426096439, 0.1274377852678299, -0.6718133091926575, -0.17668940126895905, 0.2430613487958908, -0.11449677497148514, 0.1456804871559143, -0.31592443585395813, -0.08134348690509796, 0.010590620338916779, 0.5455289483070374, -0.2733827233314514, 0.48837777972221375, 0.37025630474090576, -0.16167576611042023, -0.12961377203464508, 0.2359444946050644, 0.4696989953517914, 0.9164986610412598, -0.12790146470069885, 0.34004807472229004, 0.27215293049812317, -0.3050253391265869, -0.07017900049686432, 0.18249991536140442, -0.3290357291698456, 0.11101481318473816, 0.3547409176826477, 0.42399781942367554, 0.007253607735037804, -0.7274209856987, 0.24173425137996674, 0.0030528900679200888, -0.2208375483751297, -0.3913286626338959, -0.0724259614944458, 0.1507796198129654, 0.1807769387960434, 0.09347480535507202, 0.203613743185997, -0.0642407014966011, -0.4746360778808594, -0.009271495044231415, 0.3106028437614441, -0.1618712842464447, -0.222400963306427, 0.5877746939659119, 0.3509538769721985, -0.299886554479599, 0.5512186884880066, -0.7105512022972107, -0.38719144463539124, 0.5095881223678589, 0.8173415660858154, 0.9399630427360535, 0.1774955540895462, 0.2300909459590912, 0.4204728603363037, 0.20512166619300842, 0.06066908314824104, 0.7534689903259277, -0.06301850825548172, -0.6457163095474243, -0.9593668580055237, -0.5163165330886841, -0.40434736013412476, -0.3331221342086792, -0.2131757289171219, 0.4458381235599518, -0.4788786768913269, -0.14589950442314148, -0.3422550559043884, 0.1903083324432373, -0.6799827218055725, 0.14362826943397522, 0.09382545202970505, 0.890123188495636, -0.2944863438606262, 1.1462393999099731, 1.0318697690963745, -0.3807428777217865, -1.058527946472168, 0.1469506323337555, -0.14914250373840332, -0.6199303269386292, 1.002196192741394, -0.12500213086605072, -0.270687073469162, 0.1020173653960228, -0.315600723028183, -0.6124509572982788, 1.2064487934112549, 0.6388094425201416, -0.31947287917137146, -0.3334817588329315, 0.5434524416923523, 0.18662557005882263, -0.5003718733787537, -0.23167461156845093, 0.5073611736297607, 0.367332398891449, 0.3716892898082733, -1.1390455961227417, 0.21404951810836792, 0.029389144852757454, -0.13386256992816925, 0.4597451388835907, 0.12409781664609909, 0.6566381454467773, -0.37227314710617065, -0.7862690091133118, 0.10584484040737152, 0.5845390558242798, 0.21845081448554993, 0.2175384759902954, 0.29718729853630066, 0.43500128388404846, 0.6832337975502014, -0.2902531921863556, 1.1934491395950317, -0.3094124495983124, 0.14076709747314453, 1.2817330360412598, -0.24028244614601135, 1.0338077545166016, 0.6444845795631409, -0.32320451736450195, 0.10593020170927048, 0.5321336984634399, 0.3181793987751007, 0.5210508108139038, 0.15606755018234253, -0.3160569667816162, -0.15375949442386627, -0.17073194682598114, 0.023192841559648514, 0.24139395356178284, 0.5609616041183472, -0.028269188478589058, -0.5862203240394592, -0.2661815583705902, -0.03146473690867424, 0.4429627060890198, -0.26179075241088867, 0.5750141739845276, 0.13453036546707153, -0.7355684638023376, 0.365278959274292, 0.15292532742023468, 0.4761960208415985, -0.47855696082115173, -0.13728067278862, -0.08550310879945755, 0.23233097791671753, -0.3296789526939392, -1.0992006063461304, 0.8185563087463379, 0.052554428577423096, -0.021480215713381767, -0.808591365814209, 0.853914737701416, -0.4075891375541687, -0.5620170831680298, 0.2021927684545517, 0.5784921646118164, 0.13223707675933838, -0.2791275382041931, -0.5135471224784851, -0.3032280504703522, 0.09887124598026276, 0.14252962172031403, -0.02720876969397068, 0.671370804309845, -0.12160392105579376, 0.7750231027603149, 0.5618701577186584, 0.6295560002326965, 0.23424193263053894, -0.2657361924648285, 0.7592120170593262, -0.6409664154052734, -0.3715306520462036, -0.7633545398712158, 0.5275920629501343, -0.04883403331041336, -0.14378437399864197, 0.2842912971973419, 0.7289937734603882, 0.9062971472740173, -0.02309049479663372, 0.5981195569038391, -0.27252325415611267, 0.300583153963089, -0.8493263125419617, 0.3770531713962555, -0.3690794110298157, 0.513805627822876, 0.12383852899074554, -1.0734485387802124, -0.2930730879306793, 0.5626814365386963, -0.40597349405288696, -0.43013015389442444, 0.9727267026901245, 0.6070131063461304, 0.16342812776565552, -0.2846408486366272, 0.22851449251174927, -0.1338822990655899, 0.6187997460365295, 0.8526747822761536, 0.7647559642791748, -0.2469235211610794, 0.8145926594734192, -0.4898056089878082, -0.022547787055373192, 0.09645509719848633, -0.972647488117218, -0.9401690363883972, -0.5819786190986633, -0.3568529188632965, -0.1967620700597763, -0.19321300089359283, 1.0399521589279175, 0.4706140458583832, -0.521479606628418, -0.6713714599609375, -0.286756694316864, 0.2789047062397003, -0.0356980562210083, -0.132357656955719, 0.3252490162849426, -0.5333142280578613, -0.7283066511154175, 0.4861049950122833, 0.4337731897830963, 0.04154070094227791, -0.21177449822425842, -0.4031347334384918, -0.26167434453964233, -0.15794479846954346, 0.7463977932929993, 0.1188931092619896, -0.9293663501739502, -0.18921858072280884, 0.11065371334552765, -0.31668102741241455, 0.1304188370704651, 0.7473624348640442, -0.8248918056488037, 0.4328061044216156, 0.5698129534721375, 0.6738853454589844, 0.6986740827560425, -0.2971240282058716, 0.969106912612915, -0.8350628018379211, -0.0058664302341639996, 0.3407024145126343, 0.4261052906513214, 0.23977798223495483, -0.10887536406517029, 0.8618492484092712, -0.03822283819317818, -0.4560069441795349, -0.49123236536979675, 0.38130903244018555, -1.3040608167648315, -0.045078299939632416, 1.1677124500274658, 0.14273056387901306, -0.20450133085250854, -0.20462831854820251, -0.5316036939620972, 0.3308180570602417, -0.26489129662513733, 0.19711445271968842, 0.5254401564598083, -0.48998650908470154, 0.17544183135032654, -0.8006207942962646, 0.5995690822601318, 0.0004068856651429087, -0.977683424949646, 0.08433174341917038, 0.41562333703041077, 0.0013808042276650667, 0.26008176803588867, 0.864312469959259, -0.051015306264162064, 0.1940227597951889, -0.17910464107990265, 0.12119384855031967, 0.09145444631576538, -0.19266191124916077, 0.4138469994068146, 0.009350916370749474, 0.2772655487060547, -0.21725349128246307 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06592v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06592v1	Self-consistent context aware conformer transducer for speech recognition	2024-02-09T18:12:11	2024-02-09T18:12:11	Konstantin Kolokolov, Pavel Pekichev, Karthik Raghunathan	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS	We propose a novel neural network architecture based on conformer transducer that adds contextual information flow to the ASR systems. Our method improves the accuracy of recognizing uncommon words while not harming the word error rate of regular words. We explore the uncommon words accuracy improvement when we use the new model and/or shallow fusion with context language model. We found that combination of both provides cumulative gain in uncommon words recognition accuracy.	[ -0.15061157941818237, -0.28167226910591125, 0.2631426751613617, -0.03791011869907379, -0.29173198342323303, -0.406982958316803, 0.043313998728990555, -0.5945665836334229, 0.25899219512939453, 0.307900995016098, -0.20830455422401428, -0.1284000724554062, -0.7762227654457092, -0.001270034583285451, -0.510615885257721, 0.3340483605861664, 0.23460352420806885, 0.23365545272827148, 0.3074677288532257, -0.5731416344642639, -0.6340841054916382, -0.34081605076789856, -0.7471378445625305, -0.4053606390953064, 0.2018376886844635, 0.17484529316425323, 0.3925235867500305, 0.8683015704154968, 0.3033572733402252, 0.5601938962936401, -0.20476914942264557, -0.1574731171131134, -0.06916065514087677, 0.18350625038146973, -0.19665399193763733, -0.01931294985115528, -0.5956629514694214, -0.31330037117004395, 0.8522017598152161, 0.4946639835834503, -0.34990251064300537, -0.1370915174484253, 0.13248075544834137, 0.45350247621536255, -0.635484516620636, 0.029650045558810234, -0.7342590689659119, -0.1318686157464981, -0.2629534602165222, -0.05282030627131462, -0.05899058282375336, -0.13413158059120178, 0.4576564431190491, -0.5705062747001648, 0.19461673498153687, -0.2942638099193573, 0.23711593449115753, 0.48955610394477844, -0.42893388867378235, -0.35857659578323364, -0.8894516825675964, 0.374658465385437, -0.7361871600151062, 0.8815932869911194, -0.08464749157428741, 0.5626716017723083, 0.10668967664241791, -1.3940922021865845, -0.7295287251472473, 0.060145966708660126, -0.11549847573041916, 0.1891370713710785, -0.24996282160282135, -0.03763871267437935, -0.1412314623594284, 0.28198862075805664, -0.4365335702896118, -0.17923299968242645, -0.6219125390052795, -0.4229271709918976, 0.6824842691421509, 0.25089678168296814, 0.06198550760746002, 0.07927368581295013, -0.24807053804397583, 0.18650570511817932, -0.41483500599861145, 0.15206296741962433, -0.24202992022037506, 0.5164974927902222, -0.17148174345493317, 0.1755027025938034, -0.08029180765151978, 1.3657170534133911, 0.22579149901866913, 0.05517095327377319, 0.4998183250427246, -0.09859102964401245, -0.28156334161758423, 0.6596902012825012, 0.7312368154525757, 0.06290408223867416, 0.19689354300498962, -0.04680737480521202, -0.36984193325042725, 0.10420164465904236, 0.31504225730895996, -0.3206495940685272, -0.1804441511631012, -0.13880334794521332, -0.3713783919811249, 0.08830813318490982, 0.3240598142147064, -0.2310778945684433, -0.18264742195606232, -0.5088745355606079, 0.6896501183509827, -0.5124065279960632, -0.16452233493328094, 0.17876821756362915, -0.3621857762336731, 0.24215783178806305, 0.3904202878475189, -0.6185387969017029, 0.3103208541870117, 0.46097511053085327, 0.917289674282074, -0.2848063111305237, -0.07143943011760712, -0.4713371992111206, 0.7073373794555664, 0.10126932710409164, 0.932573676109314, -0.473989874124527, -0.7090691924095154, -0.31591224670410156, 0.03908804804086685, -0.16432063281536102, -0.5048408508300781, 0.5299187302589417, -0.5125173330307007, -0.020421423017978668, -0.09343012422323227, -0.8267252445220947, -0.27429667115211487, 0.07753971964120865, -0.6504791378974915, 0.5018466711044312, -0.028701333329081535, -0.3632105886936188, 0.19970279932022095, -0.7145662307739258, -0.5426979660987854, 0.42680415511131287, -0.40984800457954407, -0.08238660544157028, 0.08291463553905487, -0.12742622196674347, 0.41350480914115906, 0.24689626693725586, -0.1144084706902504, 0.02170650102198124, -0.7178661227226257, 0.30532607436180115, -0.40800759196281433, 0.6301515698432922, 0.43731391429901123, -0.42333677411079407, 0.08766495436429977, -1.0462976694107056, 0.23454943299293518, -0.2813817262649536, -0.740601122379303, -0.4587588608264923, -0.2136429250240326, 0.3224541246891022, -0.0008106342284008861, 0.22137326002120972, -0.7882840633392334, -0.08936017751693726, -0.5104056000709534, 0.6112782955169678, 0.7355784773826599, -0.12354395538568497, 0.49707040190696716, -0.33563005924224854, -0.014765556901693344, 0.2424461841583252, -0.21231935918331146, 0.15600934624671936, -0.6053761839866638, -0.682883620262146, -0.3433402180671692, 0.2880726754665375, 0.4840362071990967, -0.13645696640014648, 0.7179012298583984, -0.31866154074668884, -0.42661330103874207, -0.4685123562812805, 0.07490748167037964, 0.2824728786945343, 0.8740520477294922, 0.3722652792930603, -0.2274073213338852, -0.7731038928031921, -0.6458683013916016, -0.682181179523468, 0.1379231959581375, -0.10239919275045395, 0.4868983030319214, -0.24111618101596832, -0.5192632675170898, 0.9255715012550354, -0.29651615023612976, -0.7259476184844971, -0.13839250802993774, 0.14184243977069855, 0.36014023423194885, 0.8097887635231018, 0.2561775743961334, -0.9021844267845154, -0.7523507475852966, -0.08078125864267349, -0.3820537030696869, 0.019691679626703262, 0.3136015832424164, 0.4918331801891327, 0.1807067096233368, 0.816910445690155, -0.18239079415798187, 0.3052650988101959, 0.6005039215087891, -0.39967775344848633, -0.20852376520633698, -0.12569420039653778, -0.18089249730110168, -1.0009044408798218, 0.016515031456947327, -0.02965771034359932, -0.41281527280807495, -0.9652348160743713, -0.40402060747146606, 0.27377161383628845, 0.22982151806354523, -0.5520870685577393, 0.6459956169128418, -0.546954333782196, 0.01699940487742424, -0.48275360465049744, 0.10395444929599762, -0.16951969265937805, 0.03868509829044342, 0.3277738094329834, 0.8493565320968628, 0.5857532024383545, -1.1118513345718384, 0.5275583267211914, 0.33590933680534363, -0.30592185258865356, 0.5520152449607849, -0.9947500228881836, 0.2950113117694855, -0.2695690989494324, 0.23169206082820892, -1.0121463537216187, -0.05161914601922035, 0.03488064929842949, -0.5454103946685791, 0.5392460227012634, 0.28935709595680237, 0.38921183347702026, -0.2912958860397339, 0.30198201537132263, 0.5834306478500366, 0.5151082277297974, -0.5212199687957764, 0.9930131435394287, 0.40991610288619995, 0.0994194820523262, -0.4228358268737793, -0.9876726269721985, -0.11311731487512589, 0.07312314212322235, -0.5753021836280823, 0.5116207599639893, -0.12307782471179962, -0.03735744580626488, -0.1580924242734909, -0.21199598908424377, -0.29090243577957153, -0.15531153976917267, 0.29761478304862976, -0.08662053942680359, -0.42607906460762024, 0.10246845334768295, -0.2198876142501831, -0.18631650507450104, -0.16285312175750732, -0.44172099232673645, 0.4050179421901703, -0.7603979110717773, -0.16872704029083252, -0.6777176856994629, 0.15556588768959045, 0.3666769862174988, 0.0964566022157669, 0.33236077427864075, 0.6410530805587769, -0.37564513087272644, 0.13560271263122559, -0.7472074627876282, -0.0030681819189339876, -0.6064921617507935, 0.11353424936532974, -0.628370463848114, -0.9573200345039368, 0.49272090196609497, 0.0788838341832161, -0.39759668707847595, 0.6376427412033081, 0.3389532268047333, -0.020516712218523026, 0.6575173735618591, 0.42149776220321655, -0.02911345288157463, 0.35899031162261963, -0.18483492732048035, 0.10107135772705078, -1.1594929695129395, -0.2851649224758148, -0.346878319978714, -0.4515698552131653, -0.4272534251213074, -0.1868440806865692, 0.4627520442008972, -0.21482165157794952, -0.2809138298034668, 0.3734719157218933, -0.9309266209602356, 0.14685821533203125, 0.8281919956207275, 0.1107485294342041, 0.40918558835983276, -0.347017765045166, -0.22300000488758087, 0.017558926716446877, -0.5968179106712341, -0.25249823927879333, 0.8459867835044861, 0.20262780785560608, 0.8915622234344482, 0.1672750860452652, 0.47627168893814087, 0.24888357520103455, 0.24229924380779266, -0.8119996786117554, 0.31180429458618164, -0.2705291211605072, -0.7185417413711548, -0.5998331904411316, -0.10282520204782486, -0.7214441299438477, -0.09909999370574951, 0.18881167471408844, -0.7652466893196106, 0.722362756729126, 0.38576292991638184, -0.5284634828567505, 0.1299484223127365, -0.45506715774536133, 0.36505138874053955, -0.04117557778954506, 0.08917377144098282, 0.12312324345111847, -0.9375678896903992, 0.10963912308216095, 0.009588590823113918, -0.03924763947725296, 0.16515032947063446, -0.21600018441677094, 0.6376840472221375, -0.38232603669166565, 0.652772068977356, -0.32529333233833313, 0.09047501534223557, 0.4950263202190399, -0.11636726558208466, 0.4643794000148773, -0.13870541751384735, -0.42591971158981323, 0.5696611404418945, -0.11411625146865845, 0.005254564806818962, -0.4420871138572693, 0.769788384437561, -0.7240281701087952, -0.5403391122817993, -0.5246030688285828, -0.6821198463439941, -0.24373279511928558, 0.28139808773994446, 0.7373923659324646, 0.5819506049156189, -0.3361043334007263, 0.3571074903011322, 0.641766369342804, 0.3298167884349823, 0.5793161988258362, 0.9154021143913269, 0.7134858965873718, -0.5851603746414185, 0.6581031680107117, 0.32311469316482544, -0.03791123256087303, 0.2836836874485016, 0.33231449127197266, -0.5534067749977112, -0.4663829505443573, -0.4612481892108917, 0.007920362986624241, -0.5970483422279358, -0.3536585569381714, -1.0256538391113281, -0.805858850479126, -0.8985934853553772, -0.35585111379623413, -0.4198339879512787, -0.5410677790641785, -0.2264101207256317, 0.2066657692193985, 0.44752445816993713, 0.9560619592666626, -0.43427711725234985, 0.7299063801765442, -1.0516304969787598, 0.22968783974647522, 0.6993998289108276, 0.4169172942638397, -0.1345605105161667, -0.9384689927101135, 0.023644985631108284, 0.09490520507097244, -0.21338829398155212, -0.752907931804657, 0.42434045672416687, 0.6713622212409973, 0.8209449052810669, 0.7018904089927673, -0.03516458347439766, 0.7293899655342102, -0.7004004716873169, 0.6436523795127869, 0.1905486285686493, -1.427680253982544, 0.5114410519599915, -0.2760534882545471, 0.6137980818748474, 0.5239848494529724, 0.14972542226314545, -0.6604170203208923, -0.2386855185031891, -0.5846670269966125, -0.48358583450317383, 0.6230891346931458, -0.06472443789243698, 0.18874938786029816, 0.18800902366638184, 0.5612301826477051, -0.1957174688577652, 0.16147254407405853, -0.8105660080909729, -0.41997742652893066, -0.5665188431739807, -0.4894534945487976, -0.051116760820150375, -0.3297773599624634, -0.15273572504520416, -0.657048761844635, 0.6322996020317078, -0.17057886719703674, 0.47999632358551025, 0.5813236236572266, 0.01734830066561699, -0.21170438826084137, 0.24881334602832794, 0.8028360605239868, 0.36553987860679626, -0.15631794929504395, 0.3145076334476471, 0.5956694483757019, -0.8007118105888367, 0.3372322618961334, 0.0585542768239975, -0.06384705752134323, 0.31734031438827515, 0.18537728488445282, 0.5235613584518433, 0.18569684028625488, -0.2602882385253906, 0.7423573136329651, -0.1151515543460846, -0.10666493326425552, -0.6483939290046692, 0.4576031267642975, 0.27769508957862854, 0.18432137370109558, 0.3185281753540039, 0.41756337881088257, 0.6910202503204346, -0.23780469596385956, 0.4463065266609192, 0.6240463852882385, -0.9421449303627014, -0.13293235003948212, 0.6814936399459839, 0.1894005537033081, -0.6376906037330627, 0.4132385551929474, 0.18895119428634644, -0.5571258068084717, 0.40836912393569946, 0.9920049905776978, 0.8744433522224426, -1.1847710609436035, -0.41379326581954956, 0.3843627870082855, 0.025258274748921394, -0.02756439335644245, 0.43496179580688477, -0.21580109000205994, -0.9865471720695496, 0.10696165263652802, -0.5321000814437866, -0.14268165826797485, 0.20840667188167572, -0.6979406476020813, 0.3520883619785309, -0.6238052248954773, 0.04335039108991623, 0.039338018745183945, -0.4752449691295624, -0.40424925088882446, 0.6780210733413696, 0.09309058636426926, 0.8699132204055786, -0.47212857007980347, 1.1297863721847534, 0.9376938343048096, 0.11347625404596329, -0.9780863523483276, -0.1889006346464157, 0.011352934874594212, -1.0300053358078003, 0.7829623818397522, 0.22376649081707, -0.48609092831611633, 0.19392846524715424, -0.23078881204128265, -1.3086427450180054, 1.30911386013031, 0.00509241409599781, -0.9425035119056702, 0.24104003608226776, 0.06549645215272903, 0.5217825174331665, -0.5897929668426514, 0.004711104091256857, 0.46971333026885986, 0.6732470989227295, 0.6198265552520752, -0.8858622312545776, 0.1598697155714035, -0.3073076903820038, 0.3214966356754303, 0.061829254031181335, -0.42735445499420166, 0.7647433876991272, 0.07234759628772736, -0.14517445862293243, -0.008209324441850185, 0.9708868861198425, 0.22670689225196838, 0.5234476327896118, 0.7623509168624878, 0.4340274930000305, 0.5657710433006287, 0.1085425540804863, 0.6744384765625, -0.47857746481895447, -0.08716000616550446, 1.297089695930481, -0.19790701568126678, 0.7164272665977478, 0.25401246547698975, 0.27174046635627747, 0.6120920181274414, 0.053882796317338943, 0.07501967251300812, 0.6720454096794128, -0.0653301551938057, -0.5670393705368042, -0.17599140107631683, 0.004479520954191685, -0.6329523324966431, 0.8963140249252319, 0.520611047744751, -0.5030656456947327, -0.017443902790546417, -0.12672585248947144, -0.5124473571777344, 0.06908946484327316, -0.47818800806999207, 1.0549525022506714, 0.3091418445110321, -0.23905342817306519, 0.531982958316803, -0.0311551745980978, 0.9053325653076172, -0.643868625164032, 0.09734610468149185, 0.23467709124088287, 0.5253313183784485, -0.2900691628456116, -0.4756345748901367, 0.8606775999069214, -0.5294057130813599, -0.13377276062965393, 0.08048348128795624, 1.112136721611023, -0.48042115569114685, -0.4096734821796417, 0.13677740097045898, 0.35954681038856506, -0.0510435476899147, -0.07475269585847855, -0.6419054269790649, -0.013517200015485287, -0.2842784523963928, -0.046079762279987335, -0.17729495465755463, 0.5140625834465027, 0.44510117173194885, 0.4648762047290802, 0.31680038571357727, 0.2663504183292389, 0.27570685744285583, 0.008469600230455399, 0.7991335391998291, -0.7798583507537842, -0.905813992023468, -0.5894241333007812, 0.5741803646087646, -0.17754025757312775, -0.30384278297424316, 0.7447959780693054, 0.39671650528907776, 0.6261971592903137, 0.026254555210471153, 0.7240122556686401, 0.04116063565015793, 0.8958336114883423, -0.23476149141788483, 0.8326034545898438, -0.5534015893936157, 0.17919719219207764, -0.27571889758110046, -0.7963594198226929, -0.39563214778900146, 1.084657907485962, -0.06850878149271011, 0.13440778851509094, 0.5300609469413757, 0.6837052702903748, -0.37025678157806396, 0.2099493443965912, 0.5656915307044983, 0.35863640904426575, 0.03904249891638756, 0.3209184408187866, 0.5728256106376648, -0.8703508973121643, 0.265139102935791, 0.04845048859715462, -0.13239169120788574, -0.21733395755290985, -0.6580321192741394, -0.5129115581512451, -0.8636681437492371, -0.15342913568019867, -0.31350642442703247, 0.1073555126786232, 0.7512475848197937, 0.8571354150772095, -1.0879952907562256, -0.2803131937980652, -0.5647842288017273, -0.21957933902740479, -0.2408103048801422, -0.29618340730667114, 0.013663825578987598, -0.1568625569343567, -0.5899312496185303, 0.6561883091926575, 0.3236115574836731, 0.43177977204322815, -0.023244589567184448, -0.3161592483520508, -0.08611097186803818, 0.30235520005226135, 0.21759173274040222, 0.44777899980545044, -0.6033249497413635, -0.5257574319839478, -0.17636242508888245, -0.32422342896461487, 0.20995818078517914, 0.885001003742218, -0.9340578317642212, 0.4825424253940582, 0.5327603816986084, 0.5852305293083191, 0.3032585382461548, -0.004059724044054747, 0.9494355916976929, -0.5896732807159424, 0.35483217239379883, 0.43493568897247314, 0.5300158262252808, 0.47975778579711914, -0.7262938022613525, 0.3577270805835724, 0.29318952560424805, -0.48836004734039307, -0.3706057667732239, 0.2197175770998001, -1.2075368165969849, -0.2841630280017853, 1.0055320262908936, -0.12947583198547363, -0.21997973322868347, -0.5037107467651367, -0.00781565997749567, 0.4111901819705963, -0.39258459210395813, 0.6320117712020874, 0.12005151808261871, -0.3669906556606293, -0.03885161876678467, 0.20629148185253143, 0.5882526636123657, 0.23395343124866486, -0.26369738578796387, -0.4221464991569519, 0.4386769235134125, 0.7474881410598755, 0.5419967770576477, 0.8782952427864075, -0.04180782288312912, 0.3055170774459839, -0.1296354979276657, -0.13224852085113525, -0.3302953839302063, -0.21551631391048431, -0.8294190764427185, 0.11276397109031677, -0.2318073809146881, -0.32951754331588745 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06584v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06584v1	G-SciEdBERT: A Contextualized LLM for Science Assessment Tasks in German	2024-02-09T18:05:03	2024-02-09T18:05:03	Ehsan Latif, Gyeong-Geon Lee, Knut Neuman, Tamara Kastorff, Xiaoming Zhai	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	The advancement of natural language processing has paved the way for automated scoring systems in various languages, such as German (e.g., German BERT [G-BERT]). Automatically scoring written responses to science questions in German is a complex task and challenging for standard G-BERT as they lack contextual knowledge in the science domain and may be unaligned with student writing styles. This paper developed a contextualized German Science Education BERT (G-SciEdBERT), an innovative large language model tailored for scoring German-written responses to science tasks. Using G-BERT, we pre-trained G-SciEdBERT on a corpus of 50K German written science responses with 5M tokens to the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) 2015. We fine-tuned G-SciEdBERT on 59 assessment items and examined the scoring accuracy. We then compared its performance with G-BERT. Our findings reveal a substantial improvement in scoring accuracy with G-SciEdBERT, demonstrating a 10% increase of quadratic weighted kappa compared to G-BERT (mean accuracy difference = 0.096, SD = 0.024). These insights underline the significance of specialized language models like G-SciEdBERT, which is trained to enhance the accuracy of automated scoring, offering a substantial contribution to the field of AI in education.	[ -0.2184414565563202, -0.8348395228385925, 0.5037768483161926, 0.3535939157009125, -0.16921818256378174, 0.09391625225543976, -0.3432890772819519, -0.464991956949234, 0.32852262258529663, -0.08956965804100037, -0.37800899147987366, -0.7487311959266663, -0.6653080582618713, 0.1944759637117386, -0.27133509516716003, 1.152563214302063, -0.1083858534693718, 0.5885593891143799, -0.6170092821121216, -0.08680745214223862, -0.020777683705091476, -0.49153831601142883, -0.43201854825019836, -0.5199340581893921, 0.7369012236595154, 0.08107493817806244, 0.37331539392471313, 0.22661076486110687, 0.7256790995597839, 0.2689274549484253, 0.0181247778236866, -0.09599269181489944, -0.3435961604118347, 0.1869206428527832, -0.3915194272994995, -0.25891736149787903, -0.6471171379089355, 0.33744314312934875, 0.775127649307251, 0.8921940326690674, 0.2627056837081909, 0.44678816199302673, 0.2700349986553192, 0.3700181245803833, -0.45826202630996704, 0.3299331068992615, -0.23558279871940613, 0.018041038885712624, 0.3935050070285797, -0.19452354311943054, -0.5887652635574341, -0.45982638001441956, 0.35735800862312317, -0.43178442120552063, 0.3658238351345062, -0.29254937171936035, 0.8052628636360168, 0.35621213912963867, -0.31653594970703125, -0.5272735357284546, -0.41484272480010986, 0.8756173849105835, -0.30400335788726807, 0.24062399566173553, -0.0851500853896141, 0.19627425074577332, -0.2796943187713623, -0.9841315150260925, -0.3101559579372406, -0.6239871978759766, -0.09136927872896194, 0.41116535663604736, -0.06047816574573517, -0.1147589236497879, 0.15672671794891357, -0.1962868720293045, -0.609483003616333, 0.18784040212631226, -0.6982477307319641, -0.3265240788459778, 0.8381168842315674, 0.03938539698719978, 0.02168094925582409, -0.22055521607398987, -0.3795952796936035, -0.34264037013053894, -0.6075775027275085, 0.3852621018886566, 0.29028454422950745, 0.3018701672554016, 0.23016153275966644, 0.3410120904445648, -0.19215357303619385, 0.8494330644607544, -0.057240504771471024, 0.04139310494065285, 0.20703747868537903, 0.06983203440904617, 0.001670789672061801, 0.17006434500217438, 0.7962910532951355, 0.329147070646286, 0.2177550494670868, -0.0511133037507534, -0.00762358121573925, 0.1722029149532318, 0.3687700033187866, -1.0390681028366089, -0.4519221782684326, 0.2901962399482727, 0.07292347401380539, -0.1832270622253418, 0.05742107704281807, -0.40017834305763245, -0.04346287623047829, -0.21317027509212494, 0.4494704604148865, -0.35978084802627563, 0.5163833498954773, -0.061716172844171524, -0.03393929451704025, 0.07493502646684647, 0.7621681094169617, -0.6958738565444946, -0.16810593008995056, 0.38176435232162476, 0.7897038459777832, -0.43418601155281067, -0.3979856073856354, -0.4520907998085022, -0.002757097827270627, -0.4089633524417877, 0.755256712436676, -0.6707311272621155, -0.6273307204246521, -0.30302393436431885, -0.1202208623290062, -0.04754522442817688, -0.002959195990115404, 0.48033490777015686, -0.6711368560791016, 0.8159531950950623, -0.022006703540682793, -0.61383455991745, -0.3346113860607147, 0.2874187231063843, -0.23684710264205933, 1.1826708316802979, 0.13040126860141754, -0.6242541074752808, 0.6639904379844666, -1.0002946853637695, -0.4007605314254761, 0.3731262981891632, -0.026964299380779266, 0.10614270716905594, -0.05630512163043022, 0.36527538299560547, 0.8228134512901306, 0.015011386014521122, 0.6544433832168579, -0.22973784804344177, -0.7441521286964417, 0.06968779116868973, -0.30964362621307373, 0.6501734256744385, -0.08463606238365173, -0.17221316695213318, 0.415720134973526, -0.668054461479187, 0.6154905557632446, -0.1990310549736023, -0.726796567440033, -0.35450226068496704, 0.07046951353549957, 0.08966889977455139, 0.22522291541099548, 0.510608434677124, -0.7767581939697266, 0.2658858597278595, -0.3537161350250244, 0.45709264278411865, 0.7080014944076538, -0.21965092420578003, 0.40257763862609863, -0.09250743687152863, 0.33538830280303955, -0.47991180419921875, -0.08597224950790405, 0.15171627700328827, -0.36849379539489746, -0.5100528001785278, -0.5965952277183533, 0.5956709384918213, 0.666503369808197, -0.29142114520072937, 0.8300977945327759, -0.4953429400920868, -0.9350759387016296, -0.6303428411483765, 0.034658655524253845, 0.04052579030394554, 0.9364145398139954, 0.5543114542961121, -0.21561747789382935, -0.06500361859798431, -0.8442169427871704, -0.1672123223543167, -0.18236863613128662, -0.36417558789253235, 0.41463589668273926, 0.8819047212600708, -0.40740832686424255, 1.148103952407837, -0.60038822889328, -0.16724447906017303, -0.07110027223825455, 0.4104650318622589, 0.316202849149704, 0.47009414434432983, 0.5451019406318665, -0.5498926639556885, -0.5814952850341797, -0.24751843512058258, -0.8901249170303345, -0.2787199020385742, 0.350485235452652, 0.22030143439769745, 0.3252400755882263, 0.4181077480316162, -0.39735618233680725, -0.017030008137226105, 0.5260018706321716, -0.28816327452659607, 0.646489143371582, -0.4191243350505829, 0.43446895480155945, -0.8641992807388306, 0.40152329206466675, 0.07212274521589279, -0.13358959555625916, -0.6459776759147644, 0.253162682056427, 0.2269980013370514, 0.011383583769202232, -0.7306900024414062, 0.7294331789016724, -0.0028732360806316137, 0.13390372693538666, -0.26647403836250305, 0.34641939401626587, 0.0004062162770424038, 0.36358094215393066, 0.17020142078399658, 0.8041837215423584, 0.5856603980064392, -0.517090916633606, 0.48679524660110474, 0.08182331919670105, -0.4322432279586792, 0.5139347910881042, -0.98357754945755, 0.22303406894207, -0.2253846526145935, 0.5838043689727783, -0.9391898512840271, -0.4825567901134491, -0.06204083934426308, -0.6249610781669617, 0.36580100655555725, 0.3293597996234894, -0.41973695158958435, -0.42282411456108093, -0.2890434265136719, 0.09042283892631531, 0.4634571373462677, -0.7017993330955505, 0.623167097568512, -0.06390592455863953, -0.49390050768852234, -0.6369969844818115, -0.3894609808921814, -0.07581527531147003, -0.170289546251297, -0.8337637782096863, 0.37704718112945557, -0.21800260245800018, -0.03141418471932411, 0.09041617810726166, -0.052092354744672775, 0.14615845680236816, 0.27671605348587036, 0.12673555314540863, 0.5196832418441772, -0.026014672592282295, 0.49329301714897156, 0.21184735000133514, -0.005433608312159777, 0.19512471556663513, -0.0020841998048126698, 0.4758928418159485, -0.46763673424720764, -0.2871759533882141, 0.0924605056643486, 0.3898675739765167, 0.5053441524505615, 0.24249444901943207, 0.5182550549507141, 0.689624011516571, -0.2412882298231125, -0.1494043916463852, -0.25361815094947815, -0.41392046213150024, -0.45840996503829956, 0.6701062917709351, -0.32395386695861816, -1.3060824871063232, 0.27605873346328735, -0.057254496961832047, 0.12726515531539917, 0.4632841646671295, 0.6344146132469177, -0.6554324626922607, 1.1994415521621704, 0.6292035579681396, -0.21087327599525452, 0.11732544004917145, 0.08586212992668152, 0.35482197999954224, -0.5845405459403992, -0.17844675481319427, -0.42848989367485046, -0.3188554048538208, -0.39934781193733215, -0.3141727149486542, 0.7935258150100708, 0.058987896889448166, -0.3741133511066437, 0.14210620522499084, -0.7803579568862915, 0.43050432205200195, 0.7398049831390381, 0.03632979840040207, 0.07567877322435379, 0.0053719705902040005, -0.18249692022800446, -0.10134582966566086, -0.7119312286376953, -0.9060636758804321, 0.9988670945167542, 0.33799096941947937, 0.6531391739845276, -0.21595589816570282, 0.7992231249809265, 0.4639599025249481, 0.692470371723175, -0.8504155278205872, 0.6673973798751831, 0.07190770655870438, -0.6155713796615601, -0.5768858194351196, -0.1924918293952942, -0.6635937094688416, 0.5147144794464111, -0.16864120960235596, -0.913059413433075, -0.45185694098472595, 0.1235254630446434, -0.12031517177820206, -0.2849327027797699, -0.8414950370788574, 0.7199289798736572, -0.44002658128738403, -0.524901270866394, -0.3749638497829437, -0.7240706086158752, 0.04985380172729492, -0.33232414722442627, 0.0930948480963707, -0.12947583198547363, 0.12390101701021194, 1.1575895547866821, 0.1828732043504715, 0.9040917158126831, -0.3104270100593567, 0.02510068193078041, 0.10529807209968567, -0.07777296006679535, 0.3830658495426178, 0.18366503715515137, -0.15676723420619965, 0.2172127068042755, 0.18365134298801422, -0.48809951543807983, -0.6604607701301575, 0.8920081257820129, -0.7666254043579102, -1.0552148818969727, -0.8221005797386169, -0.9773660898208618, -0.30962735414505005, 0.08108304440975189, 0.16429422795772552, -0.05635692551732063, -0.3672693073749542, 0.14396335184574127, 0.4431930482387543, -0.28882524371147156, 0.29654407501220703, 0.8511828184127808, 0.17101560533046722, -0.12586311995983124, 0.7393591403961182, -0.018449079245328903, 0.08775180578231812, 0.057511813938617706, 0.22321714460849762, -0.4027562737464905, -0.07623186707496643, -0.4734092056751251, 0.08247499912977219, -1.1589435338974, -0.03635881468653679, -0.6459061503410339, -0.26779621839523315, -0.5327737927436829, -0.7778907418251038, -0.008074738085269928, -0.3774435520172119, -0.3527843654155731, -0.18808205425739288, 0.1783372163772583, 0.6480345726013184, -0.10380521416664124, 0.17570096254348755, -0.6951969265937805, -0.2688727378845215, 0.02578228898346424, 0.12919875979423523, -0.3630405068397522, -0.6717073917388916, -0.05691026523709297, -0.01781756989657879, -0.23525342345237732, -0.6021093130111694, 0.2964796721935272, 0.35784485936164856, 0.5578993558883667, 0.040798015892505646, -0.24527716636657715, 0.3754687011241913, -0.5819376707077026, 1.0186353921890259, 0.16306526958942413, -1.045137643814087, 0.725037693977356, -0.22317713499069214, 0.459580659866333, 0.3723545968532562, 0.8948035836219788, -0.5619878768920898, -0.4980495274066925, -0.46368712186813354, -1.0131605863571167, 0.6135311126708984, -0.4376373589038849, 0.4293440580368042, 0.13755618035793304, 0.0743614062666893, 0.28659787774086, 0.14611516892910004, -0.9696686863899231, 0.15186749398708344, -0.3509311079978943, -0.4223077893257141, -0.449003666639328, -0.027092954143881798, -0.43590423464775085, -0.6732099652290344, 0.8847478628158569, -0.45558860898017883, 0.25468552112579346, 0.3065112233161926, -0.24418433010578156, 0.1354769766330719, 0.5140336751937866, 0.6672707796096802, 0.6414877772331238, -0.34721213579177856, -0.08811935782432556, 0.365498423576355, -0.56300950050354, 0.21288546919822693, 0.22297325730323792, -0.3018152713775635, -0.17199942469596863, 0.7847311496734619, 0.49534639716148376, 0.109478659927845, -0.8277803063392639, 0.3493702709674835, 0.24918605387210846, -0.5265554785728455, -0.13239434361457825, 0.41508617997169495, 0.07968200743198395, 0.24471436440944672, 0.6176891326904297, -0.20331719517707825, 0.02913699671626091, -0.29097169637680054, 0.15122677385807037, 0.5292549133300781, -0.5460224151611328, -0.07693111896514893, 0.593221127986908, 0.15811878442764282, -0.0414140485227108, 0.5357397794723511, -0.2343866527080536, -0.8383611440658569, 0.5848002433776855, 0.6011319756507874, 0.4578797221183777, -0.2864753007888794, 0.43238595128059387, 0.5944573879241943, 0.26852619647979736, 0.164703369140625, 0.3472278118133545, -0.22602708637714386, -0.5222517848014832, -0.32973238825798035, -0.8839339017868042, -0.7037031650543213, -0.10256876051425934, -0.48230862617492676, 0.1632789522409439, -0.4069393575191498, -0.13608665764331818, -0.11159714311361313, 0.04042092710733414, -0.5442691445350647, 0.502687394618988, -0.15997585654258728, 1.0003291368484497, -1.1370404958724976, 0.904586136341095, 1.1091965436935425, -0.12618830800056458, -0.7754012942314148, -0.19309428334236145, -0.4191650152206421, -0.703185498714447, 1.2769958972930908, 0.29167672991752625, -0.13470324873924255, 0.07237033545970917, -0.6962706446647644, -1.1735126972198486, 1.1003296375274658, 0.009091290645301342, -0.22839191555976868, 0.14377133548259735, 0.05027259141206741, 1.0866543054580688, -0.42185863852500916, 0.4443964958190918, 0.49257466197013855, 0.5148449540138245, 0.06913585215806961, -0.6850500106811523, -0.03398388251662254, -0.3033173680305481, -0.4345529079437256, 0.00042471493361517787, -0.47658663988113403, 0.6546175479888916, -0.18385593593120575, -0.09403631836175919, -0.21598964929580688, 0.899657666683197, 0.3523450493812561, 0.26253440976142883, 0.15175975859165192, 0.26959407329559326, 0.9647278189659119, -0.4440067708492279, 0.6886066198348999, -0.41159558296203613, 0.3595791459083557, 0.7580094337463379, -0.5155428647994995, 0.8373421430587769, 0.6677417159080505, -0.0957672968506813, 0.6915972828865051, 0.725679874420166, -0.5166951417922974, 0.6083240509033203, 0.4175753891468048, -0.303510457277298, -0.19891685247421265, -0.07968460023403168, -0.11695386469364166, 0.6432132124900818, 0.5765018463134766, -0.27983638644218445, -0.29252585768699646, 0.3169737458229065, -0.07402968406677246, 0.08860266953706741, -0.32532575726509094, 0.22693662345409393, -0.14136546850204468, -0.9536581039428711, 0.40372228622436523, 0.040317602455616, 0.6664609313011169, -0.7070140838623047, 0.1839652806520462, 0.046619269996881485, 0.07684212177991867, -0.1736035943031311, -1.0099080801010132, 0.07920002937316895, 0.2057289332151413, -0.15430736541748047, -0.2781578302383423, 0.6675116419792175, -0.40181365609169006, -0.6067049503326416, 0.29745790362358093, 0.3000659644603729, 0.2731553912162781, 0.5050227046012878, -0.5375325679779053, -0.1989745944738388, -0.3134777247905731, -0.4932307302951813, 0.29154661297798157, -0.27465078234672546, -0.29378843307495117, 0.8087866902351379, 0.48990598320961, -0.03311055153608322, -0.17236877977848053, 0.0486845001578331, 0.6360459923744202, -0.3135649859905243, -0.5571767091751099, -0.5832392573356628, 0.4344750642776489, -0.0714293122291565, -0.23500171303749084, 0.7734205722808838, 0.39560234546661377, 0.8313634395599365, -0.3540031909942627, 0.98704594373703, -0.27398017048835754, 0.5031842589378357, -0.26620614528656006, 0.7011212110519409, -0.46542003750801086, -0.17673100531101227, -0.3221910297870636, -0.8520479798316956, -0.5152630805969238, 0.7072365880012512, -0.7122980356216431, 0.21691852807998657, 0.8378802537918091, 0.555010199546814, 0.1368865966796875, -0.022434115409851074, 0.14620263874530792, -0.09568940103054047, 0.44596680998802185, 0.583690345287323, 0.7332464456558228, -0.12939481437206268, 0.15554563701152802, -0.11322567611932755, -0.42822933197021484, -0.20176203548908234, -0.9577475786209106, -1.1846365928649902, -0.5749991536140442, -0.37935149669647217, -0.040402814745903015, 0.10423456132411957, 0.9432303309440613, 0.35100194811820984, -0.8747960925102234, -0.03206032142043114, 0.3574914038181305, -0.24395127594470978, 0.020347829908132553, -0.26892343163490295, 0.7759841680526733, -0.4717038869857788, -0.8664247989654541, 0.6271218061447144, 0.3059574365615845, 0.021164286881685257, -0.27965667843818665, 0.04023474454879761, -0.022910628467798233, 0.1525256484746933, 0.5684939026832581, -0.0031563034281134605, -0.7586622834205627, -0.873038649559021, 0.2623271644115448, -0.4786878526210785, -0.18626360595226288, 0.33575135469436646, -0.8811068534851074, 0.33572524785995483, 0.5044349431991577, 0.3830660879611969, 0.3828301429748535, 0.03496650233864784, 0.5183112621307373, -0.7959355711936951, 0.053535182029008865, 0.5141128897666931, 0.33456164598464966, 0.5220080614089966, -0.537587583065033, 0.5495774149894714, 0.08500494807958603, -0.7147788405418396, -0.6284155249595642, 0.0020629477221518755, -0.8914478421211243, -0.437399297952652, 0.8988576531410217, -0.39735233783721924, -0.1429813653230667, 0.24863219261169434, -0.15529704093933105, 0.21217377483844757, -0.2301619052886963, 1.0877225399017334, 1.0858980417251587, -0.2849251627922058, 0.4243018925189972, -0.3667081594467163, 0.37506669759750366, 0.6908296346664429, -0.6956058144569397, -0.4165479838848114, 0.554625928401947, 0.31702131032943726, 0.39642077684402466, 0.29880258440971375, 0.18784283101558685, 0.5872271656990051, -0.3522232472896576, 0.20570744574069977, -0.07519832253456116, -0.482650488615036, -0.21258674561977386, 0.5676539540290833, -0.16487722098827362, 0.1610250622034073 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06563v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06563v1	What is Hiding in Medicine's Dark Matter? Learning with Missing Data in Medical Practices	2024-02-09T17:27:35	2024-02-09T17:27:35	Neslihan Suzen, Evgeny M. Mirkes, Damian Roland, Jeremy Levesley, Alexander N. Gorban, Tim J. Coats	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IT, math.IT	Electronic patient records (EPRs) produce a wealth of data but contain significant missing information. Understanding and handling this missing data is an important part of clinical data analysis and if left unaddressed could result in bias in analysis and distortion in critical conclusions. Missing data may be linked to health care professional practice patterns and imputation of missing data can increase the validity of clinical decisions. This study focuses on statistical approaches for understanding and interpreting the missing data and machine learning based clinical data imputation using a single centre's paediatric emergency data and the data from UK's largest clinical audit for traumatic injury database (TARN). In the study of 56,961 data points related to initial vital signs and observations taken on children presenting to an Emergency Department, we have shown that missing data are likely to be non-random and how these are linked to health care professional practice patterns. We have then examined 79 TARN fields with missing values for 5,791 trauma cases. Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) and k-Nearest Neighbour (kNN) based missing data imputation methods are used and imputation results against the original dataset are compared and statistically tested. We have concluded that the 1NN imputer is the best imputation which indicates a usual pattern of clinical decision making: find the most similar patients and take their attributes as imputation.	[ -0.1267080008983612, -0.29842376708984375, 0.6925939321517944, -0.11288005858659744, -0.33929353952407837, 0.039209503680467606, 0.32637885212898254, -0.4901013970375061, 0.271229088306427, 0.5093368887901306, -0.7977916598320007, -0.5386788249015808, -0.8137685656547546, -0.03814290836453438, -0.08407070487737656, 1.0323809385299683, 0.13585995137691498, 0.29794904589653015, -0.13054735958576202, -0.3849235475063324, -0.38489559292793274, -0.6880916953086853, -0.4231811761856079, -0.23521965742111206, 0.5224620699882507, 0.5347946882247925, 0.6128486394882202, 1.1135010719299316, 1.053921103477478, 0.06369189918041229, -0.19033627212047577, 0.0718308761715889, -0.5027776956558228, -0.00372533081099391, -0.043410640209913254, -0.4192825257778168, -0.16930778324604034, -0.2331991344690323, 0.3016989827156067, 1.1568647623062134, -0.10757426917552948, -0.10345148295164108, -0.3182835280895233, 0.8310214281082153, -0.46984168887138367, 0.007584662642329931, -0.2653559446334839, 0.7520735263824463, -0.010060531087219715, -0.49990853667259216, -0.09548976272344589, -0.25220903754234314, 0.40813565254211426, -0.3234045207500458, 0.9543077945709229, -0.005811856593936682, 0.7136247158050537, 0.4177033603191376, -0.3510453999042511, -0.5207804441452026, -0.7520920634269714, 0.4430467188358307, -0.24256809055805206, 0.16065658628940582, 0.5393825173377991, 0.3702944219112396, -0.03421099856495857, -0.5704447627067566, -0.4411310851573944, -0.13458752632141113, -0.3253638744354248, 0.3425073027610779, 0.2504856288433075, 0.1546710729598999, 0.14797943830490112, 0.4557251036167145, -0.36055833101272583, 0.18734703958034515, -0.7867830991744995, -0.07542543113231659, 0.5265923738479614, 0.5591870546340942, 0.2820894420146942, 0.12214110791683197, -0.34891000390052795, -0.20249050855636597, -0.9594271779060364, -0.32809337973594666, 0.4274526536464691, 0.13332191109657288, -0.24794268608093262, 0.4214498698711395, 0.14495037496089935, 0.48256444931030273, 0.054174285382032394, -0.05920635163784027, 0.23293672502040863, -0.27457377314567566, -0.24111399054527283, 0.375359445810318, 0.4294857084751129, 0.3792553246021271, -0.2234317809343338, -0.2714143991470337, -0.16957038640975952, 0.03922877833247185, 0.3102774918079376, -0.3717072904109955, -0.46108007431030273, 0.09795036166906357, -0.6763325333595276, -0.364469051361084, 0.08307802677154541, -0.6590011715888977, -0.7902331352233887, -0.21753723919391632, 0.18043875694274902, -0.409017950296402, -0.2827107012271881, 0.003228649729862809, -0.07129029184579849, 0.01766935922205448, 0.5194713473320007, -0.5404806733131409, 0.6402726173400879, 0.4937187731266022, 0.4989188611507416, 0.12301398068666458, -0.01929425075650215, -0.04740095138549805, 0.053445059806108475, -0.7474130988121033, 0.40244346857070923, -0.5342560410499573, -0.3695880174636841, -0.17923422157764435, 0.37245258688926697, 0.10810241103172302, -0.7697492241859436, 0.6017915606498718, -0.07575365155935287, 0.17756082117557526, -0.248139888048172, -0.40057238936424255, -0.5361437201499939, -0.21013598144054413, -0.6135452389717102, 0.6958486437797546, 0.25501614809036255, -0.5343871712684631, 0.9045694470405579, -0.3864428400993347, -0.4065053462982178, 0.04618057236075401, -0.3414217531681061, -0.8715645670890808, 0.2770307958126068, -0.04874427244067192, 0.5200921893119812, -0.2425694614648819, 0.12133525311946869, -0.33276820182800293, -0.3414461314678192, 0.3847816586494446, -0.5248658061027527, 0.5164632201194763, 0.30637046694755554, -0.09513389319181442, -0.44848912954330444, -0.9282265901565552, -0.1259312480688095, 0.2713473439216614, 0.11412923038005829, -0.3099735677242279, 0.0910101979970932, 0.07842546701431274, 0.4634349048137665, -0.4591577649116516, -0.5015653371810913, -0.19278615713119507, -0.2303467094898224, 0.009680151008069515, 0.4541609287261963, 0.651856541633606, 0.010862740688025951, -0.8187777996063232, 0.26294445991516113, 0.6362448930740356, 0.3051568865776062, -0.19997502863407135, -0.4344382882118225, -0.4715633690357208, -0.14915381371974945, -0.0998467206954956, 0.21065056324005127, -0.1704004555940628, 0.1430273950099945, 0.026014773175120354, -0.472258597612381, -0.9203264117240906, -0.49057579040527344, 0.4500183165073395, 1.057352900505066, 0.33484193682670593, -0.3252510726451874, -0.5444980263710022, -1.1350020170211792, -0.0704747661948204, -0.13913334906101227, 0.03735091909766197, 0.47663915157318115, 0.5640192627906799, -0.13200555741786957, 0.5612064599990845, -0.4522346556186676, -0.4123798906803131, 0.06023746356368065, -0.25211966037750244, 0.44588854908943176, 0.7574121952056885, 0.3720894157886505, -1.0544103384017944, -0.2697722613811493, 0.1589042693376541, -0.8883106708526611, 0.10140221565961838, -0.32018131017684937, 0.4647478759288788, 0.08334037661552429, 0.039868082851171494, -0.19139918684959412, 0.9671757221221924, -0.11631547659635544, -0.23215991258621216, 0.1697959452867508, -0.5517359375953674, 0.22314953804016113, -0.3794981837272644, 0.27332696318626404, -0.10153886675834656, -0.2297625094652176, -0.8762977123260498, -0.1185847669839859, 0.26704922318458557, -0.2878566086292267, -0.5752170085906982, 0.2409825176000595, -0.5487920045852661, 0.10900284349918365, 0.14788450300693512, -0.4041202664375305, -0.08782386779785156, 0.5110162496566772, -0.09251449257135391, 0.46226832270622253, 0.8408558964729309, -0.6930468678474426, -0.0026938249357044697, 0.02026529610157013, -0.011118132621049881, 0.38105642795562744, -0.3950536847114563, 0.40620484948158264, -0.601032018661499, -0.19768065214157104, -0.7828688621520996, -0.3339446187019348, 0.46679916977882385, -0.37317243218421936, 0.5173606872558594, -0.6192302703857422, -0.4542974829673767, -0.45320436358451843, -0.023518234491348267, 0.23441986739635468, 0.37579771876335144, -0.08403218537569046, 0.07795920222997665, 0.7295470237731934, -0.36341267824172974, -0.6561710238456726, -0.8790976405143738, -0.004497740883380175, -0.3917200565338135, -0.03237621858716011, 0.19091571867465973, 0.04431813210248947, -0.37185654044151306, 0.2365017533302307, -0.37794679403305054, -0.4807915687561035, 0.06958926469087601, 0.4788353741168976, 0.2369834929704666, -0.25654399394989014, 0.20984120666980743, -0.015841038897633553, -0.36616066098213196, 0.017777329310774803, 0.020134979858994484, 0.31453701853752136, 0.12183377891778946, -0.7875291705131531, -0.5548690557479858, 0.4712591767311096, 0.6324954628944397, 0.48438262939453125, 0.7217035889625549, -0.07916734367609024, -0.9185168147087097, 0.037597883492708206, -0.42204228043556213, -0.2021409571170807, -0.3244286775588989, 0.3695129156112671, 0.09751106798648834, -0.1621486246585846, 0.7296578884124756, 0.2892213761806488, -0.1504846215248108, 0.4301929175853729, 0.42983904480934143, -0.24208125472068787, 0.6930420398712158, 0.5809227824211121, 0.2675279676914215, 0.002692608628422022, -0.20616936683654785, 0.25965994596481323, -0.35345256328582764, -0.47556430101394653, -0.2175099104642868, -0.21414317190647125, -0.5000248551368713, -0.14458128809928894, 0.6820176839828491, -0.18878716230392456, 0.012312421575188637, -0.2092638462781906, -0.8139154314994812, 0.5186511874198914, 0.20320749282836914, 0.7422861456871033, 0.12412666529417038, -0.13225527107715607, 0.035663310438394547, -0.3176496624946594, -0.8777356743812561, -0.11781540513038635, 1.2524546384811401, 0.39872992038726807, 0.4828227460384369, -0.1327272653579712, 0.7169284224510193, 0.37444064021110535, 0.27546218037605286, -0.621843159198761, 0.06520456820726395, 0.1270320564508438, -0.6008199453353882, -0.13881781697273254, -0.3603270947933197, -0.9862218499183655, 0.350086510181427, -0.18946677446365356, -0.3639427423477173, 0.3640631437301636, -0.08839544653892517, -0.43557989597320557, 0.3782609701156616, -0.7362926006317139, 0.1508723348379135, -0.04757209122180939, -0.4224504232406616, -0.227181538939476, -0.9599087238311768, 0.2018919438123703, -0.2417038083076477, 0.13366469740867615, 0.16715647280216217, -0.055622320622205734, 0.9790478944778442, -0.8300759196281433, 0.7715004086494446, -0.23510374128818512, 0.3449627161026001, 0.30231189727783203, -0.1486390233039856, 0.44487693905830383, 0.07076219469308853, 0.2876319885253906, 0.06964097172021866, 0.030371710658073425, -0.4952886700630188, -0.514738917350769, 0.5195074677467346, -0.5611878037452698, -0.30450916290283203, -0.8143022656440735, -0.4279260039329529, -0.169077068567276, -0.07605331391096115, 0.12349306792020798, 0.6448841691017151, 0.10845588147640228, 0.20881681144237518, 0.857611358165741, -0.35538041591644287, 0.5291774868965149, 0.6649253368377686, 0.38891899585723877, -0.3547588884830475, 0.5962158441543579, 0.7605705261230469, -0.14510495960712433, 0.38173243403434753, 0.2389773428440094, -0.03977839648723602, -0.8497063517570496, -0.3582633435726166, 0.3918715715408325, -0.7260456681251526, 0.0009621309000067413, -0.7989355325698853, -0.43135520815849304, -0.1916951835155487, -0.23382341861724854, -0.0675642341375351, -0.3404162526130676, -0.16458448767662048, -0.37265947461128235, 0.46598541736602783, 0.7359853982925415, -0.010366198606789112, 0.28431203961372375, -0.6517919301986694, 0.25152429938316345, -0.21714936196804047, 0.36346617341041565, 0.07197752594947815, -0.18555285036563873, -0.2848101854324341, -0.1842283457517624, -0.13167181611061096, -0.940625786781311, 0.5395017862319946, -0.2155148983001709, 0.5101757645606995, 0.6646677255630493, -0.08040646463632584, 0.8555281162261963, -0.33034148812294006, 0.5100436806678772, 0.46051016449928284, -0.1848527193069458, 0.282529354095459, -0.4203783869743347, -0.35938289761543274, 0.5444984436035156, 0.38784581422805786, -0.7188723683357239, 0.08591553568840027, -1.3769627809524536, -0.8375173807144165, 0.955102801322937, 0.11599332094192505, -0.4559522867202759, 0.23153360188007355, 0.3227955102920532, 0.5193732976913452, 0.2931874990463257, -0.2875399887561798, -0.9852989315986633, 0.28647366166114807, -0.4346392750740051, 0.10764210671186447, 0.1562066525220871, -0.2674008905887604, -0.2682293653488159, 0.19920194149017334, 0.11192503571510315, 0.6189423203468323, 0.5703609585762024, -0.06642501056194305, -0.3798260986804962, -0.14532887935638428, 0.5681840181350708, 1.106675624847412, -0.15163017809391022, 0.17740006744861603, 0.25424641370773315, -0.9618018269538879, 0.08351122587919235, -0.008238807320594788, 0.04974180832505226, 0.24688705801963806, 0.393992155790329, 0.44248220324516296, 0.08854261040687561, -0.4843541383743286, 0.6337343454360962, 0.10814286768436432, -0.15820524096488953, -0.5232260823249817, 0.03831622749567032, -0.33251792192459106, -0.18256349861621857, 0.6927039623260498, 0.5381553769111633, -0.006111258640885353, -0.6004434823989868, 0.6200748085975647, -0.17496149241924286, -0.8301254510879517, -0.5714676976203918, 0.42185652256011963, -0.468148797750473, -0.2861877381801605, 0.3654155731201172, 0.41588595509529114, -0.28850898146629333, 0.9541695713996887, 0.5219046473503113, 0.4824841618537903, -0.03513352945446968, 0.2248140424489975, 0.08966904878616333, 0.41932401061058044, 0.17143933475017548, 0.4678988754749298, 0.1948367804288864, -0.1026187315583229, -0.041298430413007736, 0.08637290447950363, -0.4526807367801666, 0.5617431402206421, -0.6248300075531006, 0.330495148897171, -0.7672562599182129, 0.23781733214855194, -0.15318651497364044, 0.15905074775218964, -1.067331075668335, 0.7749000787734985, -0.13929712772369385, 0.5931262969970703, -0.7778441309928894, 0.3719378113746643, 0.3872458040714264, -0.4874206781387329, -0.6252902150154114, -0.10274738073348999, 0.2553844153881073, -0.9905935525894165, 0.4111481308937073, -0.2068815976381302, 0.5334790349006653, -0.34903207421302795, -0.4616134464740753, -0.7117509245872498, 0.5442619919776917, 0.0824456587433815, -0.40435320138931274, 0.15670114755630493, 0.35824617743492126, 0.6047056317329407, -0.12521915137767792, 0.5227803587913513, 0.1438734084367752, 0.3651082217693329, 0.01803070865571499, -0.440076619386673, 0.06692458689212799, -0.1861598938703537, -0.6770077347755432, 0.5790551900863647, -0.5560559630393982, 0.6315460205078125, -0.45611971616744995, -0.29033827781677246, -0.4916931986808777, -0.10345986485481262, -0.018541529774665833, 0.9552057981491089, -0.07494193315505981, 0.5327027440071106, 1.222761631011963, 0.011155188083648682, 1.0707660913467407, -0.042721353471279144, 0.20733390748500824, 0.7426238656044006, -0.29624298214912415, 0.049919743090867996, 0.441698282957077, -0.336454838514328, 0.029824739322066307, 0.7337552905082703, -0.028397271409630775, 0.8782015442848206, 0.0065984781831502914, -0.27273160219192505, 0.3523503839969635, 0.06588836759328842, -0.5287525057792664, -0.017800986766815186, 0.6550056338310242, -0.6730103492736816, -0.14608071744441986, -0.02406197413802147, 0.257807195186615, -0.4215531051158905, -0.35098031163215637, 0.9724069237709045, 0.1050184890627861, -0.3696233630180359, 0.6192333698272705, -0.3036632537841797, -0.23453368246555328, -0.7582985758781433, -0.3652593791484833, -0.29689905047416687, 0.15459255874156952, -0.3632872998714447, -0.9349632859230042, 0.37068992853164673, -0.38130179047584534, -0.3331664800643921, -0.17595550417900085, 0.8257965445518494, -0.13548412919044495, -0.4836408197879791, -0.08324328809976578, 0.6976452469825745, 0.4358910322189331, 0.3980562090873718, -0.471293181180954, -0.46445760130882263, -0.10315931588411331, 0.28183937072753906, 0.5531613230705261, 0.9368983507156372, -0.2521873414516449, 0.6922497153282166, 0.7169584631919861, 0.5689390301704407, -0.1475716531276703, -0.08774580806493759, 0.82419353723526, -0.7185698747634888, -0.7490726113319397, -0.7432251572608948, 0.2358914315700531, -0.07506807893514633, -0.6877818703651428, 0.4801442623138428, 0.5623185038566589, 0.4735299050807953, -0.17585162818431854, 0.7876550555229187, 0.17477822303771973, 0.8144747614860535, -0.2990732491016388, 1.0070862770080566, -0.1505092978477478, 0.04677858576178551, -0.32197168469429016, -0.26100480556488037, -0.6973056793212891, 0.2415025681257248, -0.19338180124759674, -0.2653062641620636, 0.8281527757644653, 0.8674823045730591, -0.4309440851211548, 0.21606262028217316, 0.543099045753479, 0.14065125584602356, -0.0303761325776577, 0.5873054265975952, 0.7120360136032104, -0.6291693449020386, 0.05410567298531532, -0.5053556561470032, -0.39409467577934265, -0.3315037190914154, -0.3739779591560364, -0.5787426233291626, -0.4091762900352478, -0.3617558777332306, -0.2656554877758026, 0.21198324859142303, 0.8202580213546753, 0.9842826128005981, -0.8503227233886719, 0.36427006125450134, -0.10172047466039658, 0.2982635796070099, -0.584396481513977, -0.19860193133354187, 0.8427008986473083, 0.16619469225406647, -0.1213584691286087, 0.4206041991710663, 0.33163562417030334, 0.28186488151550293, 0.41601017117500305, 0.08664721995592117, 0.04796046391129494, -0.38703635334968567, -0.11448553949594498, 0.2426690012216568, -0.3448236882686615, -0.07027466595172882, -0.18918904662132263, 0.16612321138381958, 0.5638269186019897, 0.9899483919143677, -1.084311604499817, 0.4444318413734436, 0.2274337112903595, 0.6603689789772034, 0.4663313329219818, -0.24094055593013763, 0.23174135386943817, -0.6840246319770813, 0.19954706728458405, 0.75127112865448, 0.30607351660728455, 0.2644650638103485, -0.7577769756317139, 0.6783797740936279, 0.6283250451087952, -0.3203258514404297, -1.1313271522521973, -0.09062976390123367, -0.313355952501297, -0.2750995457172394, 0.5374282002449036, -0.029698429629206657, -0.28556904196739197, -0.7652210593223572, -0.05593617260456085, 0.2821791470050812, -0.28477129340171814, 0.8688300251960754, 0.3908931314945221, -0.3691559433937073, -0.3170654773712158, -0.7475810050964355, 0.48601922392845154, 0.3562585115432739, -0.4178823232650757, -0.11634045839309692, 0.31195300817489624, 0.33638057112693787, 0.1289314329624176, 0.40782034397125244, -0.32034945487976074, 0.33915722370147705, 0.2322697788476944, -0.4195998013019562, -0.20520325005054474, -0.48846322298049927, -0.45701614022254944, 0.5454269051551819, -0.7161781191825867, -0.34117230772972107 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13812v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13812v1	Quantitative Analysis of AI-Generated Texts in Academic Research: A Study of AI Presence in Arxiv Submissions using AI Detection Tool	2024-02-09T17:20:48	2024-02-09T17:20:48	Arslan Akram	cs.DL	cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, stat.OT, 62P25, I.7; G.1; G.3	Many people are interested in ChatGPT since it has become a prominent AIGC model that provides high-quality responses in various contexts, such as software development and maintenance. Misuse of ChatGPT might cause significant issues, particularly in public safety and education, despite its immense potential. The majority of researchers choose to publish their work on Arxiv. The effectiveness and originality of future work depend on the ability to detect AI components in such contributions. To address this need, this study will analyze a method that can see purposely manufactured content that academic organizations use to post on Arxiv. For this study, a dataset was created using physics, mathematics, and computer science articles. Using the newly built dataset, the following step is to put originality.ai through its paces. The statistical analysis shows that Originality.ai is very accurate, with a rate of 98%.	[ -0.5784691572189331, -1.0610482692718506, 0.22663645446300507, 0.09199327975511551, 0.009633885696530342, -0.011539551429450512, 0.23546957969665527, -0.46521568298339844, 0.11009831726551056, 0.3081696331501007, -0.1702549308538437, -0.2783675491809845, -0.6039117574691772, 0.2583176791667938, -0.8870055675506592, 1.2824901342391968, 0.04477767273783684, -0.16479182243347168, -0.380630224943161, -0.2365676462650299, -0.1297181099653244, -0.39441972970962524, -1.0204286575317383, -0.08992723375558853, 0.4033043682575226, 0.14290159940719604, 0.6063200831413269, 0.7542651891708374, 0.8177084922790527, 0.3633757531642914, -0.0003310510946903378, -0.15049238502979279, -0.34071797132492065, -0.219343364238739, 0.03562449663877487, -0.29106077551841736, -0.237591952085495, 0.08426974713802338, 1.0934571027755737, 0.2581632435321808, -0.06615040451288223, 0.3137996792793274, 0.26911091804504395, 0.47669437527656555, -0.35403427481651306, 0.03435846045613289, -0.5741644501686096, 0.15681634843349457, -0.34791824221611023, -0.1823609173297882, -0.38766545057296753, -0.506790280342102, 0.02684103325009346, -0.5946192145347595, 0.290012925863266, 0.30998700857162476, 0.5520772933959961, 0.28245171904563904, -0.2853507399559021, -0.43102797865867615, -0.8155401945114136, 0.6849232316017151, -0.682306706905365, 0.00011920928955078125, 0.07737761735916138, 0.017228353768587112, -0.28263410925865173, -0.7210286259651184, -0.8585541844367981, -0.33146214485168457, -0.25442343950271606, 0.008260874077677727, -0.5898382663726807, -0.17628741264343262, 0.16012339293956757, 0.39800605177879333, -1.0746209621429443, -0.1082371175289154, -0.39393070340156555, -0.07127943634986877, 0.7141973972320557, 0.016147486865520477, 0.8599226474761963, 0.15811455249786377, -0.1238061860203743, -0.24996574223041534, -0.5004452466964722, -0.005390719976276159, 0.638414740562439, -0.28944388031959534, 0.13817524909973145, 0.879960298538208, -0.05070795118808746, 0.1660773754119873, -0.24219577014446259, 0.20899131894111633, 0.02558031678199768, -0.5082574486732483, -0.03938913717865944, 0.07668323069810867, 1.2276591062545776, -0.06708525866270065, 0.42316126823425293, -0.006583531852811575, -0.07627224922180176, -0.0421878844499588, 0.33827969431877136, -0.6245301961898804, -0.4203495383262634, 0.10068880766630173, -0.5941444039344788, -0.4975872337818146, 0.2559705972671509, -0.44066041707992554, -0.39722368121147156, -0.13673780858516693, 0.23046359419822693, -0.6136550307273865, -0.2865541875362396, -0.4010879695415497, -0.1875091940164566, 0.02272799424827099, 0.18056629598140717, -0.4559403955936432, 0.12825344502925873, 0.7427501082420349, 0.9429972171783447, -0.32098647952079773, -0.46147727966308594, -0.34562233090400696, -0.09756424278020859, -0.2440594732761383, 1.1380541324615479, -0.44035086035728455, -0.48356568813323975, -0.04744204506278038, -0.2694944739341736, -0.04385000839829445, -0.36125701665878296, 0.5377892851829529, -0.5485432744026184, 0.23170866072177887, 0.17799386382102966, -0.5534219741821289, -0.19104398787021637, 0.42969265580177307, -0.7235606908798218, 0.9415713548660278, -0.08813607692718506, -0.7835597395896912, 0.4425188899040222, -0.8483568429946899, -0.2983008921146393, 0.33215609192848206, -0.19743365049362183, -0.6239665150642395, -0.10806305706501007, -0.03260344639420509, 0.024879084900021553, 0.21732425689697266, 0.08423209935426712, 0.06588616967201233, -0.4274372458457947, 0.8105821013450623, -0.6505581140518188, 0.7540173530578613, 0.3353917598724365, -0.22125957906246185, 0.002584023866802454, -0.7808523178100586, -0.0045636496506631374, 0.052077651023864746, -0.4113990068435669, -0.4221546947956085, 0.18744435906410217, -0.0122617082670331, -0.4205858111381531, 0.15285855531692505, -0.46727991104125977, 0.2987739145755768, -0.3257729113101959, 0.060161177068948746, 0.585878312587738, 0.35229089856147766, 0.2434256225824356, -0.3707617521286011, 0.6294092535972595, -0.29481881856918335, 0.056496307253837585, 0.0973040908575058, -0.7135607600212097, -0.511332094669342, -0.11821621656417847, 0.4632405936717987, 0.509823739528656, -0.5573883652687073, 0.17742499709129333, 0.04300474002957344, -0.6567696332931519, -0.4519765377044678, -0.17710675299167633, 0.2626503109931946, 0.20863312482833862, -0.04046661779284477, -0.17885904014110565, -0.3220522105693817, -0.8524195551872253, -0.45955467224121094, -0.45248159766197205, -0.16129358112812042, 0.2139018326997757, 0.7448345422744751, -0.28652867674827576, 0.770780086517334, -0.4698117673397064, -0.05169964209198952, 0.31294018030166626, 0.9712839126586914, -0.26439812779426575, 0.6150767207145691, 0.794692873954773, -0.8332408666610718, -0.6118283271789551, 0.04937933012843132, -0.91984623670578, -0.17583826184272766, -0.07164395600557327, -0.19591327011585236, 0.16307945549488068, 0.3519292175769806, -0.5351991653442383, 0.756482720375061, 0.27934983372688293, -0.29550230503082275, 0.7618762254714966, -0.08548099547624588, 0.8714073300361633, -0.6968913078308105, 0.505811333656311, 0.17720158398151398, 0.11837111413478851, -0.3746046721935272, -0.0015186030650511384, -0.39654552936553955, -0.47985419631004333, -0.21493521332740784, 0.526342511177063, -0.1787978857755661, 0.09507129341363907, -0.4775919020175934, 0.1458631008863449, -0.11613067984580994, 0.08132365345954895, -0.2654620409011841, 1.166272759437561, 0.16082431375980377, -0.43147140741348267, 0.13400506973266602, 0.4418710172176361, -0.32695847749710083, 0.42686212062835693, -1.033681035041809, 0.1405448615550995, -0.17615075409412384, -0.012357225641608238, -1.0855551958084106, -0.3115551471710205, 0.5676159858703613, -1.0856013298034668, -0.3099532425403595, -0.32191532850265503, -0.5987885594367981, -0.058355096727609634, -0.09613484889268875, 0.4772857129573822, 0.4540611207485199, -0.050279948860406876, 0.4274784326553345, 0.503023087978363, -0.4241109788417816, -0.48677462339401245, -0.5029389262199402, 0.09044881165027618, -0.1331103891134262, -0.64668869972229, 0.11694534868001938, -0.30714553594589233, -0.7103008031845093, 0.36063602566719055, 0.3669236898422241, -0.16213779151439667, 0.16291475296020508, 0.04808174446225166, 0.17550042271614075, -0.17708875238895416, -0.06564440578222275, -0.04250706732273102, 0.061726830899715424, 0.5037044882774353, 0.12856906652450562, 0.42938244342803955, -0.09693040698766708, -0.4908319115638733, -0.7830653786659241, 0.5621398091316223, 0.7235836386680603, -0.3068059980869293, 0.9661902189254761, 0.8206974864006042, -0.2934983968734741, -0.09463123977184296, -0.16915558278560638, -0.15983186662197113, -0.4961940050125122, 0.1488196849822998, 0.2832895815372467, -0.3615107536315918, 0.4975149929523468, 0.3305264413356781, 0.22491969168186188, 0.613237738609314, 0.382187157869339, -0.16507385671138763, 1.1399317979812622, 0.5152970552444458, 0.052017681300640106, 0.7031373381614685, -0.20314112305641174, 0.3789750635623932, -0.4831641614437103, -0.2325391322374344, -0.8987151980400085, -0.0647997111082077, -0.6630317568778992, 0.2008422613143921, 0.520717978477478, -0.4269200265407562, -0.23357008397579193, 0.04021724686026573, -1.024700403213501, 0.5132191777229309, 1.0337369441986084, -0.07526809722185135, 0.4690956473350525, 0.1718512773513794, 0.5081015229225159, 0.061385128647089005, -0.4122668206691742, -0.7019999027252197, 1.0027838945388794, 0.024088872596621513, 0.4702700674533844, 0.040830567479133606, 0.5018718838691711, 1.0579630136489868, 0.34164807200431824, -0.7622541785240173, 0.5998122096061707, 0.06794348359107971, -0.5244128704071045, -0.30368056893348694, -0.5509493350982666, -1.1262102127075195, -0.12090323865413666, -0.4043806791305542, -0.6292659044265747, -0.1418062448501587, 0.23097988963127136, -0.22570458054542542, 0.35142627358436584, -0.6796141266822815, 0.6006048321723938, -0.04146731644868851, -0.18734334409236908, -0.3351445496082306, -0.2110671103000641, 0.23958469927310944, -0.17332503199577332, 0.0473763570189476, 0.11634351313114166, 0.3378261923789978, 1.1901885271072388, -0.2108481526374817, 0.5129668116569519, 0.07639798521995544, 0.09186144173145294, 0.8875965476036072, 0.24509860575199127, 0.6093091368675232, 0.1662662923336029, -0.08286027610301971, 0.23205028474330902, 0.31959161162376404, -0.288906455039978, -0.3557755947113037, 0.6732837557792664, -0.9434564113616943, -0.499576210975647, -0.8293505907058716, -0.38988837599754333, 0.22381293773651123, 0.465766578912735, 0.43044960498809814, 0.3532544672489166, -0.38982391357421875, 0.37700656056404114, 0.6403807997703552, -0.24312755465507507, 0.2820439338684082, 0.30626052618026733, 0.15447132289409637, -0.23426999151706696, 0.8708149790763855, 0.32459914684295654, -0.2838526964187622, 0.033658191561698914, 0.24053707718849182, 0.008425102569162846, -0.8715208768844604, -0.3406416177749634, 0.07835941016674042, -0.29796382784843445, 0.02007857896387577, -0.5817672610282898, -0.562836229801178, -0.64194256067276, -0.20045660436153412, -0.2253425270318985, -0.15603037178516388, -0.4052506685256958, 0.3612561821937561, 0.3466299772262573, 0.8773518204689026, -0.07028624415397644, 0.5224491357803345, -0.7975632548332214, 0.1464349627494812, 0.1556921750307083, 0.22829177975654602, 0.1374961882829666, -0.25386255979537964, -0.4045436382293701, 0.4215230643749237, -0.3721466064453125, -0.40890514850616455, 0.4123140871524811, -0.040152985602617264, 0.6853803396224976, 0.4215608239173889, 0.14017577469348907, 0.06308211386203766, -0.24798022210597992, 0.8868027925491333, -0.14446447789669037, -0.6077798008918762, 0.6439530253410339, -0.6092660427093506, 0.023925265297293663, 0.4533870816230774, 0.5289121866226196, -0.3714790642261505, -0.3118303120136261, -0.789749801158905, -0.5901795029640198, 0.2889450192451477, 0.6947037577629089, 0.07981089502573013, 0.04033219441771507, 0.322174996137619, 0.007761373184621334, 0.15698465704917908, -0.6818994283676147, -0.22691859304904938, 0.1419341117143631, -0.24732229113578796, 0.5031731128692627, -0.20604921877384186, -0.34756356477737427, 0.2129262238740921, 0.7613857388496399, 0.15003786981105804, 0.47892746329307556, 0.16686172783374786, 0.08873382210731506, 0.15847907960414886, -0.06357663124799728, 0.3182539939880371, 0.7130797505378723, -0.03361231088638306, -0.11639134585857391, -0.2171807885169983, -0.7876501679420471, -0.12926550209522247, -0.04228324070572853, -0.37057140469551086, 0.0402071475982666, 0.3296431005001068, 0.037562452256679535, -0.5542912483215332, -0.7795640230178833, 0.37297603487968445, -0.2210434228181839, -0.04196149483323097, -0.923528790473938, 0.4005824625492096, -0.5819821357727051, 0.3100203275680542, 0.5934171080589294, 0.47302180528640747, 0.6370742917060852, -0.5865123867988586, 0.2641422152519226, 0.5328695178031921, -0.003700070548802614, -0.33092638850212097, 0.8287971019744873, 0.09255573153495789, -0.6152074933052063, 0.8794857263565063, -0.2135818749666214, -0.20616374909877777, 0.8779032230377197, 0.16954493522644043, 0.6218312382698059, 0.04253864288330078, 0.2666657567024231, 0.40853676199913025, 0.22028018534183502, 0.07941630482673645, -0.2409488707780838, 0.18213891983032227, -0.6678641438484192, -0.23693199455738068, -0.19765715301036835, -0.6468803882598877, 0.16827410459518433, -0.44318923354148865, 0.1985509991645813, -0.33651745319366455, -0.3034032881259918, 0.29013553261756897, -0.04549715667963028, -0.306997150182724, 0.20972736179828644, -0.00637826370075345, 0.2819100320339203, -0.9104598164558411, 0.3971106708049774, 0.6640830039978027, -0.4858678877353668, -0.3846661150455475, 0.08094818890094757, 0.3039196729660034, -0.7530759572982788, 0.1832900047302246, -0.2222234010696411, -0.15462251007556915, 0.11479148268699646, -0.9836914539337158, -0.7840656638145447, 0.7889273166656494, -0.01118630450218916, 0.12449286878108978, 0.1559520810842514, 0.2197834998369217, 0.6716006994247437, 0.044631630182266235, 0.10905293375253677, 0.21443139016628265, 0.3621606230735779, -0.05250035971403122, -0.4532518684864044, -0.29829704761505127, -0.757209062576294, -0.2773888409137726, 0.1750667542219162, -0.6398997902870178, 0.64798903465271, 0.2903037965297699, -0.23244039714336395, 0.06046329811215401, 0.5770929455757141, 0.5226293802261353, 0.6461002230644226, 0.12454633414745331, 0.3263407051563263, 0.6913592219352722, -0.11425529420375824, 0.8190877437591553, -0.1673741191625595, 0.1872018277645111, 0.6710208058357239, 0.11996162682771683, 0.5405744910240173, 0.40893206000328064, -0.1463860124349594, 0.406742662191391, 0.3841412663459778, -0.6136439442634583, 0.1697015017271042, 0.017662785947322845, -0.5139815211296082, 0.3779560327529907, -0.45559364557266235, -0.34050577878952026, 0.4515874981880188, 0.3110615909099579, -0.28503894805908203, 0.35069039463996887, 0.16732679307460785, 0.4740462303161621, 0.03713390231132507, -0.05728500336408615, 0.8621768951416016, -0.23213352262973785, -0.8486452698707581, 0.06290924549102783, -0.072966068983078, 0.3911120891571045, -0.4770192801952362, -0.29429158568382263, -0.31715381145477295, 0.08344583213329315, -0.23482218384742737, -1.0553208589553833, 0.6793100237846375, 0.28825643658638, -0.11518298089504242, 0.051496610045433044, 0.7481629848480225, -0.0945746898651123, -0.6073822379112244, -0.39510995149612427, 0.46623653173446655, 0.3899289071559906, -0.14395558834075928, -0.5319420099258423, -0.008622626774013042, 0.10148648917675018, -0.36397331953048706, 0.3677486777305603, 0.7792040705680847, 0.03798741474747658, 0.8107010722160339, 0.7167033553123474, 0.13875944912433624, -0.16219733655452728, -0.3969621956348419, 0.5961337089538574, -0.30391719937324524, -0.2984677255153656, -0.7873201966285706, 0.43785884976387024, -0.3727721571922302, -0.5134978890419006, 0.9168856739997864, 0.6358751058578491, 0.6569525003433228, 0.0017951916670426726, 1.08305025100708, -0.341062992811203, 0.166245698928833, -0.2008005827665329, 1.2355014085769653, -0.443288117647171, 0.19506452977657318, -0.299465149641037, -0.6830042600631714, -0.34840652346611023, 0.5997337102890015, -0.19465990364551544, -0.08095065504312515, 0.42856329679489136, 0.6898761987686157, 0.016624290496110916, -0.04105129837989807, 0.0307732205837965, -0.10899357497692108, 0.4045191705226898, -0.2580406367778778, 0.7654350996017456, -0.5201424360275269, 0.9065697193145752, -0.1445598155260086, -0.3053544759750366, -0.25388965010643005, -0.7577496767044067, -0.8185626268386841, -0.53790682554245, -0.8445967435836792, -0.3875764012336731, -0.07554259151220322, 0.3336029350757599, 0.2631552517414093, -0.88480544090271, 0.06652554869651794, -0.2072991281747818, 0.0686226487159729, -0.1987714022397995, -0.3648197054862976, 0.5060716867446899, 0.060339752584695816, -0.7947136163711548, -0.062368568032979965, -0.2090417444705963, 0.35177111625671387, -0.16825658082962036, 0.38566792011260986, -0.21316763758659363, 0.3276080787181854, 0.45402634143829346, 0.4569399058818817, -0.13160835206508636, -0.370705783367157, 0.15510860085487366, -0.019312065094709396, -0.04611246660351753, 0.7213910222053528, -0.4131244122982025, 0.19306403398513794, 0.8007071018218994, 0.5404685139656067, 0.2153683602809906, 0.33662131428718567, 0.5090635418891907, -0.6272379755973816, 0.13036862015724182, 0.33680418133735657, 0.3697504997253418, 0.019084330648183823, -0.6409832239151001, 0.6665264368057251, 0.37713000178337097, -1.2318542003631592, -0.7570189237594604, -0.34841081500053406, -0.7712915539741516, -0.2513258159160614, 0.9914785027503967, -0.20000174641609192, -0.19048047065734863, 0.060264118015766144, -0.6087262630462646, 0.40842899680137634, -0.5564286708831787, 1.243466854095459, 0.679631233215332, -0.4024675190448761, -0.22108234465122223, -0.5734683275222778, 0.308336079120636, -0.07326561957597733, -0.7749235033988953, -0.3298599421977997, 0.45923474431037903, 0.11227314919233322, 0.21504732966423035, 0.3946935534477234, -0.17232561111450195, 0.11105973273515701, 0.3819449245929718, 0.19130362570285797, -0.057978980243206024, -0.0852162167429924, 0.21400079131126404, 0.23365703225135803, 0.07519712299108505, -0.23788708448410034 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06559v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06559v1	Diffusion-ES: Gradient-free Planning with Diffusion for Autonomous Driving and Zero-Shot Instruction Following	2024-02-09T17:18:33	2024-02-09T17:18:33	Brian Yang, Huangyuan Su, Nikolaos Gkanatsios, Tsung-Wei Ke, Ayush Jain, Jeff Schneider, Katerina Fragkiadaki	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO	Diffusion models excel at modeling complex and multimodal trajectory distributions for decision-making and control. Reward-gradient guided denoising has been recently proposed to generate trajectories that maximize both a differentiable reward function and the likelihood under the data distribution captured by a diffusion model. Reward-gradient guided denoising requires a differentiable reward function fitted to both clean and noised samples, limiting its applicability as a general trajectory optimizer. In this paper, we propose DiffusionES, a method that combines gradient-free optimization with trajectory denoising to optimize black-box non-differentiable objectives while staying in the data manifold. Diffusion-ES samples trajectories during evolutionary search from a diffusion model and scores them using a black-box reward function. It mutates high-scoring trajectories using a truncated diffusion process that applies a small number of noising and denoising steps, allowing for much more efficient exploration of the solution space. We show that DiffusionES achieves state-of-the-art performance on nuPlan, an established closed-loop planning benchmark for autonomous driving. Diffusion-ES outperforms existing sampling-based planners, reactive deterministic or diffusion-based policies, and reward-gradient guidance. Additionally, we show that unlike prior guidance methods, our method can optimize non-differentiable language-shaped reward functions generated by few-shot LLM prompting. When guided by a human teacher that issues instructions to follow, our method can generate novel, highly complex behaviors, such as aggressive lane weaving, which are not present in the training data. This allows us to solve the hardest nuPlan scenarios which are beyond the capabilities of existing trajectory optimization methods and driving policies.	[ -0.5018391013145447, -0.7134305238723755, 0.698300302028656, 0.19958004355430603, -0.06471947580575943, -0.04245347902178764, 0.017381275072693825, 0.08424287289381027, 0.554559051990509, 0.3427952229976654, -1.0192420482635498, -0.6186237931251526, -0.5011997818946838, -0.38921383023262024, -0.4397178888320923, 0.8291151523590088, 0.09481185674667358, -0.08681593835353851, 0.01996537670493126, 0.02793920412659645, -0.2304726243019104, 0.0379386842250824, -0.8849330544471741, -0.260989785194397, 0.7747982740402222, 0.10297129303216934, 0.1670265942811966, 0.4389566481113434, -0.09543246030807495, 0.12646257877349854, -0.39543986320495605, 0.062639519572258, -0.5342363119125366, 0.1664040982723236, -0.06247103586792946, -0.18838775157928467, -0.3742096424102783, -0.15353259444236755, 0.44269853830337524, 0.6680331230163574, -0.6013819575309753, -0.31471481919288635, -0.17121700942516327, 0.7545902132987976, -1.0932954549789429, -0.0871250331401825, 0.04630277678370476, 0.3297586739063263, 0.24501344561576843, -0.3226315975189209, -0.06463108211755753, -0.8503715991973877, 0.028767557814717293, -0.7455747127532959, 0.10106353461742401, -0.3792080879211426, 0.2670319080352783, 0.4693591296672821, -0.40592479705810547, -0.3401608467102051, -1.0741721391677856, 1.000171184539795, -0.41324183344841003, 0.122266486287117, -0.0005346782854758203, 0.37385687232017517, -0.3069407045841217, -0.10348442941904068, -0.36727428436279297, 0.051765765994787216, 0.2830306887626648, 0.36939260363578796, -0.12808404862880707, 0.253063440322876, 0.0651198998093605, 0.0781254917383194, -0.6045427322387695, 0.29010024666786194, -0.348696768283844, 0.01571088843047619, 0.6884312629699707, 0.23096676170825958, -0.16706545650959015, 0.43348053097724915, -0.37532779574394226, -0.18527311086654663, -0.7355865240097046, 0.3790324032306671, 0.30829912424087524, 0.05779825896024704, -0.33896180987358093, 0.33253881335258484, -0.5615726709365845, 0.5704534649848938, -0.002384902210906148, -0.09767548739910126, 0.20692536234855652, -0.04321405291557312, -0.12986117601394653, -0.39298057556152344, 0.40233445167541504, 0.45935535430908203, 0.20613780617713928, -0.42902714014053345, -0.34478023648262024, 0.032554540783166885, -0.024669552221894264, -0.7339556813240051, -0.10082358121871948, 0.282064825296402, -0.18748509883880615, -0.36714786291122437, -0.2591482996940613, -1.3525667190551758, -0.2867428958415985, -0.1963716596364975, 0.3114938735961914, -0.1707468330860138, -0.3650549054145813, 0.6282809376716614, -0.5491791367530823, 0.38490304350852966, 0.6201296448707581, -0.896352231502533, 0.42159339785575867, 0.21141839027404785, 0.9894153475761414, -0.14928945899009705, -0.18482685089111328, -0.7117913365364075, 0.46542981266975403, -0.3995794355869293, 0.900178074836731, -0.5231655836105347, -0.9255885481834412, -0.043492257595062256, -0.24191874265670776, 0.04799750819802284, -0.3739464581012726, 0.4124503433704376, -0.24802127480506897, 0.09713456779718399, -0.2708021402359009, -0.5264593958854675, -0.653042733669281, 0.1480117291212082, -0.41710925102233887, 0.9430117607116699, 0.13355021178722382, 0.23214806616306305, 0.47174063324928284, -1.2748676538467407, -0.5616735816001892, 0.17722077667713165, -0.03900585323572159, -0.16802100837230682, -0.0611422099173069, 0.05286261811852455, 0.3569546639919281, 0.20709002017974854, 0.12406434118747711, -0.05814860016107559, -0.35630002617836, -0.598631739616394, -0.44499585032463074, 0.8197253942489624, -0.08245626837015152, -0.5728085041046143, 0.33784306049346924, -0.6942372918128967, -0.05285642668604851, 0.04829692468047142, -0.2512938380241394, -0.3482087552547455, 0.1451409012079239, -0.189439058303833, 0.15325495600700378, 0.0017582600703462958, -0.5097002983093262, 0.3762247860431671, -0.28036829829216003, 0.18593096733093262, 1.014400601387024, 0.6099817752838135, 1.091578483581543, -0.40674829483032227, 1.0433549880981445, -0.04680141434073448, 0.34455540776252747, 0.02600014954805374, -0.8712854981422424, -0.38732895255088806, -0.15253202617168427, -0.22664715349674225, 0.6742672920227051, -0.2763681709766388, 0.30929017066955566, 0.2062232345342636, -0.43022245168685913, -0.19367185235023499, -0.10325925052165985, 0.02692534774541855, 0.3769048750400543, 0.6597108244895935, -0.2070174515247345, -0.021899577230215073, -0.3964347243309021, 0.27260857820510864, 0.43855616450309753, 0.020175771787762642, 0.23569393157958984, 0.52304607629776, -0.2964513599872589, 0.6042070388793945, -0.7623787522315979, -0.3329182267189026, -0.03753742203116417, 0.47302576899528503, -0.3128860294818878, 0.5083891153335571, 0.8508020043373108, -0.6202807426452637, -0.44806525111198425, -0.2626209259033203, -0.40111759305000305, -0.10046703368425369, -0.31377366185188293, -0.12781201303005219, -0.1334386020898819, 0.2602648138999939, -0.4124211370944977, 0.7361102104187012, 0.32850193977355957, -0.19671028852462769, 0.32245635986328125, -0.47513246536254883, -0.08246538043022156, -0.20759344100952148, -0.12676209211349487, 0.2413942813873291, -0.1568358689546585, -0.7376023530960083, -0.061974141746759415, -0.30455026030540466, 0.21010172367095947, -0.6208440661430359, 0.6888466477394104, -0.4117752015590668, 0.0031454614363610744, -0.15644237399101257, 0.12246093899011612, -0.11033391952514648, 0.6558399796485901, 0.15651334822177887, 0.6051262617111206, 0.8828270435333252, -1.0636814832687378, 0.04567931592464447, 0.1967993825674057, -0.10715509206056595, 0.7987579107284546, -0.2671266198158264, -0.12890492379665375, -0.7565546631813049, 0.12677694857120514, -0.9278078675270081, 0.28226861357688904, 0.1591791957616806, 0.05262981727719307, 0.02110302820801735, -0.21020455658435822, 0.05891508236527443, -0.07061482965946198, -0.5820651650428772, 0.14876282215118408, 0.6737732291221619, -0.22438594698905945, 0.5391461253166199, 0.1279236376285553, 0.07038015127182007, -0.492836594581604, -0.4800226092338562, -0.2566964328289032, -0.32908913493156433, -0.3028603494167328, 0.4752059578895569, -0.5025919079780579, -0.1812635213136673, 0.007458030711859465, 0.1721310019493103, -0.0691235288977623, 0.2544368505477905, 0.26134294271469116, -0.01273490022867918, 0.14068202674388885, -0.47344085574150085, 0.6342044472694397, -0.22375480830669403, -0.08276297897100449, -0.1067216545343399, 0.5968066453933716, 0.5852925777435303, -0.18277619779109955, -0.43016573786735535, 0.6853246688842773, 0.5849726796150208, -0.05740050598978996, 0.5509734153747559, 0.6421028971672058, -0.04622892290353775, -0.5632282495498657, 0.0653781145811081, -0.36726638674736023, -0.47359827160835266, 0.039452921599149704, -0.19149459898471832, -0.6820082664489746, 0.27476122975349426, -0.3209518492221832, 0.5520887970924377, 0.06755271553993225, 0.40541085600852966, -0.18794552981853485, 0.8892940282821655, 0.4942689836025238, 0.21327243745326996, 0.6283565163612366, -0.7054919004440308, 0.0045476388186216354, -0.7245432734489441, -0.4826788008213043, -0.24979627132415771, -0.7210720777511597, -0.26354140043258667, -0.48654747009277344, 0.37134596705436707, -0.21321514248847961, -0.21416610479354858, -0.14505475759506226, -0.633933424949646, 0.6622101068496704, 0.7636187672615051, -0.15219205617904663, 0.09953983128070831, -0.01684480719268322, 0.009057297371327877, 0.17497049272060394, -0.6067361831665039, -0.026524094864726067, 0.894690752029419, -0.29268431663513184, 0.5614624619483948, 0.021057160571217537, 0.9856212139129639, 0.5406816601753235, 0.06657486408948898, -0.7267526984214783, 0.6076956391334534, -0.09984773397445679, -0.2087719589471817, -0.4153822362422943, -0.35604479908943176, -1.1250609159469604, 0.25789445638656616, -0.27581891417503357, -0.6137510538101196, 0.41442248225212097, -0.11602737754583359, -0.7553126215934753, 0.40780916810035706, -0.6628556847572327, 0.6476356983184814, -0.09256479889154434, -0.24554915726184845, -0.329369455575943, -0.5729245543479919, 0.18346594274044037, 0.30227890610694885, 0.2803569436073303, -0.12235905975103378, -0.09035175293684006, 0.7841660976409912, 0.018756654113531113, 0.6505737900733948, -0.9571956396102905, 0.030591296032071114, 0.2334083616733551, 0.4925236105918884, 0.5764938592910767, -0.2927962839603424, 0.06402469426393509, -0.08734270930290222, -0.11845164746046066, -0.33458250761032104, -0.6623256802558899, 0.6409675478935242, -0.3330811858177185, -0.36363914608955383, -0.1961454600095749, -0.5725663900375366, 0.15907679498195648, 0.12536101043224335, 0.10012280195951462, 0.21389496326446533, -0.056493546813726425, -0.23541098833084106, 0.5932198166847229, -0.24238444864749908, 0.9541944861412048, 0.5378552675247192, -0.09493917971849442, -0.10519050061702728, 0.8870442509651184, 0.22605934739112854, 0.3017328381538391, 0.41494959592819214, 0.3387298583984375, -0.46438726782798767, -0.8521318435668945, -0.500806450843811, 0.21589477360248566, -0.3486667275428772, 0.053062669932842255, -0.39563173055648804, 0.03945891931653023, -0.12967310845851898, -0.8221852779388428, -0.22389134764671326, -0.6299598217010498, -0.3956606686115265, -0.2613944709300995, 0.2286813110113144, 1.0185742378234863, -0.6710546612739563, 0.5767439603805542, -0.2319457232952118, 0.26977354288101196, 0.20522159337997437, 0.145462304353714, 0.10154932737350464, 0.025183342397212982, 0.0718608871102333, 0.16327446699142456, -0.3555181622505188, -0.7271462678909302, 0.6697008013725281, -0.05988657847046852, 0.6837014555931091, 0.5544301271438599, -0.005099370144307613, 0.7465348243713379, -0.37793320417404175, 0.8187959790229797, 0.09845158457756042, -0.4366781711578369, 0.6550975441932678, -0.3308883011341095, 0.03996051475405693, 0.43177005648612976, 0.2625228762626648, -0.35570183396339417, -0.25406333804130554, -0.396724671125412, -0.7617833614349365, 0.5103232264518738, 0.13412413001060486, -0.13428865373134613, 0.09628529101610184, 0.5337807536125183, 0.06281967461109161, 0.38357120752334595, -0.6886141300201416, -0.41834011673927307, 0.057880375534296036, -0.020255694165825844, -0.060552265495061874, -0.1358531266450882, -0.27988582849502563, -0.20249442756175995, 0.6413103342056274, 0.20521175861358643, 0.3013842701911926, -0.04201655089855194, 0.24484051764011383, -0.19229568541049957, 0.19542451202869415, 1.061400055885315, 0.018006935715675354, -0.3304506242275238, -0.1912594884634018, -0.18944868445396423, -0.23490622639656067, 0.5829125046730042, -0.2666114270687103, -0.777825117111206, -0.18788139522075653, -0.4634242057800293, 0.4312916398048401, -0.023449959233403206, -0.4661838710308075, 0.6253378987312317, 0.08355884999036789, -0.5007362961769104, -0.23468275368213654, 0.417921245098114, -0.22436951100826263, 0.23292677104473114, 0.11004804074764252, 0.41105762124061584, 0.29816949367523193, 0.05792801454663277, 0.028059611096978188, 0.661400556564331, -0.3646228611469269, -0.3389620780944824, 0.7109386324882507, 0.147034153342247, -0.46443912386894226, 0.16461870074272156, -0.7214886546134949, -0.04704003036022186, 0.5503833889961243, 0.15512071549892426, 0.9690067172050476, -0.29142680764198303, 0.7802770137786865, 0.41218075156211853, 0.26765507459640503, -0.3602234721183777, 0.4683636724948883, -0.44100290536880493, -0.6144813895225525, -0.5011358261108398, -0.44622209668159485, -0.37932559847831726, -0.12544481456279755, -0.5010219216346741, 0.030238892883062363, -0.6697367429733276, 0.22714996337890625, -0.2823914885520935, -0.3004612922668457, -0.3325771391391754, 0.23531581461429596, -0.2837599217891693, 0.7077352404594421, -0.8371655344963074, 0.45490044355392456, 0.3065633177757263, -0.32088911533355713, -0.30643323063850403, -0.259771466255188, 0.19835521280765533, -0.5931191444396973, 0.39758703112602234, -0.2504641115665436, -0.5326522588729858, 0.1677381694316864, -0.2614254951477051, -0.6644328236579895, 1.1725399494171143, 0.21595565974712372, -0.38502082228660583, -0.3064948618412018, -0.1892077475786209, 0.18981125950813293, -0.18867872655391693, -0.0006616437458433211, 0.42931705713272095, 0.6273058652877808, 0.4730813205242157, -0.24131546914577484, -0.2733479142189026, 0.2675652801990509, -0.26345428824424744, 0.48764991760253906, -0.5011163949966431, 0.6770503520965576, -0.24805495142936707, -0.14711111783981323, 0.18454775214195251, -0.03691553696990013, 0.13257788121700287, 0.37815579771995544, 0.5276517868041992, 0.7186958193778992, 0.7969613075256348, 0.07491712272167206, 0.8522552251815796, 0.020558679476380348, 0.15681202709674835, 0.7529023289680481, -0.3304257392883301, 0.5678735375404358, 0.6018064618110657, -0.15400682389736176, 0.9669028520584106, 0.30676737427711487, 0.21578283607959747, 1.1234322786331177, 0.04892987012863159, -0.5525687336921692, 0.045721035450696945, 0.22415605187416077, 0.08213713020086288, 0.06732277572154999, 0.24387159943580627, 0.22580519318580627, -0.6920711994171143, 0.17081178724765778, -0.20744580030441284, -0.000040180468204198405, -0.40041297674179077, 0.691538393497467, -0.39456236362457275, -0.4755473732948303, 0.15627004206180573, 0.04739341512322426, 0.8114883303642273, -0.6540117859840393, -0.19702471792697906, -0.41752126812934875, -0.14168688654899597, -0.20314615964889526, -0.7592875361442566, 0.47862473130226135, -0.3279956877231598, -0.03970140218734741, -0.6014280319213867, 0.14931805431842804, -0.3317432105541229, 0.005799321457743645, 0.3960616886615753, 0.5765800476074219, 0.0864245668053627, 0.07393936067819595, -0.472821444272995, -0.5795791149139404, 0.1538253128528595, -0.14408719539642334, 0.3085562288761139, 0.15568622946739197, 0.19514156877994537, 0.7856013178825378, 0.5440145134925842, 0.42821311950683594, 0.38676443696022034, -0.0005962571012787521, 0.48078814148902893, -0.7289656400680542, -0.7961351275444031, -0.7375268936157227, 0.6741710305213928, 0.025085842236876488, -0.20878024399280548, 0.5674432516098022, 0.5858451128005981, 0.5870327353477478, 0.055058322846889496, 0.6300976276397705, 0.11416658014059067, 0.39451974630355835, -0.5473751425743103, 0.19191105663776398, -0.7217332124710083, 0.2229347825050354, 0.015223003923892975, -0.8717303276062012, -0.5053464770317078, 0.895263135433197, -0.5125349164009094, 0.15057732164859772, 0.23109525442123413, 0.8633869290351868, -0.05587133765220642, -0.24055646359920502, 0.5430590510368347, -0.3029162883758545, 0.5251174569129944, 0.7727866172790527, 0.8091303110122681, -0.010680284351110458, 0.15985555946826935, -0.35466375946998596, -0.38809317350387573, 0.08144956082105637, -0.49819669127464294, -0.5888963937759399, -0.30799466371536255, -0.3999393880367279, 0.07202630490064621, -0.035811569541692734, 0.48823282122612, 0.9654520153999329, -0.45162975788116455, -0.34444576501846313, -0.7691566348075867, 0.4097227454185486, -0.4521241784095764, -0.29647931456565857, 0.020463913679122925, -0.12510855495929718, -0.8220784068107605, 0.9464240670204163, 0.7711434364318848, 0.5538357496261597, -0.6101179718971252, -0.45039981603622437, -0.2716439962387085, 0.1519097089767456, 0.4280898869037628, 0.3511214852333069, -0.29286399483680725, 0.07764392346143723, 0.12910187244415283, 0.24344570934772491, 0.13518598675727844, 0.763319730758667, -0.7979617714881897, 0.3104506731033325, 0.07445880025625229, 0.21765653789043427, 1.029512882232666, -0.0815979391336441, 0.3175850808620453, -0.6473757028579712, 0.49473878741264343, 0.47580191493034363, 0.10751397162675858, -0.09350869804620743, -0.21328434348106384, 0.5597369074821472, 0.2617635726928711, -0.5149440169334412, -0.5289073586463928, 0.6041947603225708, -1.063477635383606, -0.36617788672447205, 1.2272592782974243, 0.03535221144556999, -0.2738150358200073, -0.1683460772037506, -0.13935349881649017, -0.15595869719982147, -0.791687548160553, 0.660515308380127, 0.18148380517959595, -0.49744442105293274, -0.33922386169433594, -0.38679933547973633, 0.6141956448554993, 0.2658036947250366, -0.6208074688911438, -0.14927606284618378, 0.8082351088523865, 0.10738125443458557, -0.1076841875910759, 0.8494446873664856, 0.15208205580711365, 0.3504144549369812, -0.11200070381164551, -0.13202600181102753, -0.052090030163526535, -0.46489405632019043, -0.5952751636505127, 0.5306003093719482, -0.2841184139251709, -0.34561511874198914 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06549v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06549v1	Bryndza at ClimateActivism 2024: Stance, Target and Hate Event Detection via Retrieval-Augmented GPT-4 and LLaMA	2024-02-09T17:02:41	2024-02-09T17:02:41	Marek Šuppa, Daniel Skala, Daniela Jašš, Samuel Sučík, Andrej Švec, Peter Hraška	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	This study details our approach for the CASE 2024 Shared Task on Climate Activism Stance and Hate Event Detection, focusing on Hate Speech Detection, Hate Speech Target Identification, and Stance Detection as classification challenges. We explored the capability of Large Language Models (LLMs), particularly GPT-4, in zero- or few-shot settings enhanced by retrieval augmentation and re-ranking for Tweet classification. Our goal was to determine if LLMs could match or surpass traditional methods in this context. We conducted an ablation study with LLaMA for comparison, and our results indicate that our models significantly outperformed the baselines, securing second place in the Target Detection task. The code for our submission is available at https://github.com/NaiveNeuron/bryndza-case-2024	[ -0.5061735510826111, -0.6958555579185486, 0.6093674302101135, -0.2146023064851761, -0.23306035995483398, 0.3360036611557007, -0.17347025871276855, -0.6621642708778381, 0.19752191007137299, 0.3768438994884491, -0.3502020537853241, -0.6178009510040283, -0.9416308403015137, -0.038945481181144714, -0.5512807965278625, 1.145956039428711, -0.012531667947769165, -0.1545449197292328, 0.2423596829175949, -0.3717363774776459, -0.07878369092941284, -0.41515904664993286, -0.7344168424606323, -0.5280501842498779, 0.8080135583877563, 0.2535667419433594, 0.57197505235672, 0.4011821448802948, 0.29642683267593384, 0.32502350211143494, -0.211136594414711, -0.42266249656677246, -0.41204705834388733, 0.15876750648021698, -0.1844244748353958, 0.014996704645454884, -0.2868102192878723, 0.4377067983150482, 0.7196113467216492, 0.1831648349761963, -0.1491394191980362, 0.14089486002922058, -0.18649819493293762, 0.05941794067621231, -0.4690181016921997, -0.13495677709579468, -0.921883761882782, -0.08200802654027939, -0.39983588457107544, 0.19143816828727722, -0.048204779624938965, -0.12433294206857681, -0.20012903213500977, -0.25076186656951904, 0.392867773771286, 0.1748897135257721, 0.6873284578323364, 0.3244064450263977, -0.4583175778388977, -0.27897095680236816, -0.35458728671073914, 1.0693960189819336, -0.7835512757301331, 0.48812443017959595, 0.2957454323768616, -0.08545118570327759, -0.12988027930259705, -0.5534133315086365, -1.0697582960128784, -0.1548510193824768, 0.35486119985580444, -0.05032540485262871, -0.40851423144340515, 0.08528193831443787, 0.20111650228500366, 0.17771287262439728, -0.48019614815711975, 0.6175594329833984, -0.26524877548217773, -0.3217593729496002, 0.587659478187561, 0.0043721371330320835, 0.1790204793214798, -0.3730336129665375, -0.3560224175453186, 0.155318483710289, -0.6400561332702637, -0.481032133102417, 0.8044471144676208, 0.36620646715164185, -0.20066960155963898, 0.6667851805686951, -0.05208655074238777, 0.5685639977455139, 0.05291232094168663, 0.03745703026652336, 0.1226450726389885, -0.4193611443042755, -0.21581697463989258, 0.16969825327396393, 0.724100649356842, 0.22249621152877808, -0.08564329892396927, -0.06312786042690277, 0.048717811703681946, 0.05970153585076332, 0.30261608958244324, -0.9241237640380859, -0.20938746631145477, 0.16666068136692047, -0.3780306279659271, -0.5842859745025635, -0.43740275502204895, -0.9926578998565674, -0.6764172911643982, -0.2932344377040863, 0.2198653221130371, 0.04470047727227211, -0.43514567613601685, 0.029755575582385063, -0.14153335988521576, 0.4592907130718231, 0.4968847930431366, -0.7388416528701782, -0.027927832677960396, 0.9031330943107605, 0.8835487961769104, -0.473753422498703, -0.1161094456911087, -0.5341424942016602, -0.06554630398750305, -0.30518922209739685, 0.8862853646278381, -0.959109365940094, -0.3309260606765747, -0.05919994041323662, -0.2769172191619873, 0.12809042632579803, -0.33017656207084656, 0.7918890118598938, -0.8391948938369751, 0.24306146800518036, -0.28247079253196716, -0.5787187814712524, -0.24963688850402832, 0.559650719165802, -0.5947064757347107, 1.0075974464416504, 0.01879642717540264, -0.8997092843055725, 0.45661479234695435, -0.6623030304908752, -0.10606972128152847, 0.21929968893527985, -0.19781789183616638, -0.6185309886932373, -0.21103817224502563, -0.21258299052715302, 0.49909698963165283, -0.13125237822532654, 0.3239513337612152, -0.5079218745231628, -0.14971348643302917, -0.2538905739784241, -0.435259610414505, 0.6742222309112549, 0.23407751321792603, -0.6336995363235474, 0.5542646050453186, -0.6067357659339905, -0.33002838492393494, 0.17819076776504517, -0.6458061933517456, -0.02062729187309742, -0.06492315977811813, 0.2305028885602951, 0.16549190878868103, 0.355621874332428, -0.9395725131034851, 0.2264600396156311, -0.2257690280675888, 0.402042955160141, 0.9912629723548889, -0.015417013317346573, 0.4260721802711487, -0.1434604823589325, 0.6830767393112183, -0.15395762026309967, -0.03105621226131916, 0.3382287919521332, -0.7582817673683167, -0.4936008155345917, -0.16487672924995422, -0.12411634624004364, 0.4563538134098053, -0.6934524774551392, 0.032417360693216324, 0.03600268438458443, -0.6388866305351257, -0.011851255781948566, 0.18536384403705597, 0.23525571823120117, 0.6044466495513916, 0.3475539982318878, -0.013557955622673035, -0.8579689860343933, -0.580773115158081, -0.3276638984680176, -0.5000014305114746, 0.3408609628677368, 0.10152381658554077, 0.6679332256317139, -0.30379652976989746, 0.5806718468666077, -0.18898768723011017, 0.07073576003313065, -0.33457982540130615, 0.2746763825416565, 0.20778243243694305, 0.13079190254211426, 0.7658600211143494, -1.0760560035705566, -0.4306100010871887, 0.0025282823480665684, -0.3515646159648895, -0.14881445467472076, 0.4869518578052521, 0.03271685168147087, 0.41815537214279175, 0.35189658403396606, -0.4911476671695709, 0.519476592540741, 0.7192776799201965, -0.5443877577781677, 0.5732043981552124, 0.5086132884025574, 0.5368882417678833, -1.172139286994934, -0.17439664900302887, 0.23639625310897827, -0.13043612241744995, -1.0273815393447876, -0.17505072057247162, -0.32918602228164673, -0.11826643347740173, -0.6997206211090088, 0.6260554194450378, 0.029572710394859314, -0.23747536540031433, -0.5508631467819214, -0.08469650149345398, -0.30991131067276, 0.1400451511144638, 0.2582780420780182, 0.8404933214187622, 0.2036728709936142, -0.3576286733150482, 0.40584054589271545, 0.428178995847702, -0.2842848300933838, 0.6044607162475586, -0.45229142904281616, 0.3701745867729187, -0.05197056010365486, 0.2933737337589264, -1.107469081878662, -0.37856343388557434, 0.5925796031951904, -0.33304014801979065, 0.15887878835201263, -0.5186387300491333, -0.4003669023513794, -0.4456131160259247, -0.419931560754776, 0.5491040349006653, 0.28162577748298645, -0.7342605590820312, 0.66257643699646, 0.568950355052948, -0.18590538203716278, -0.6265207529067993, -0.32988643646240234, 0.39415058493614197, -0.8657355308532715, -0.1992226541042328, 0.5784920454025269, -0.21815910935401917, -0.5278910994529724, -0.24694567918777466, 0.027857881039381027, -0.03389672935009003, 0.042812976986169815, 0.3128623068332672, 0.09132394194602966, 0.05647372081875801, -0.09491284936666489, -0.31005290150642395, 0.17414171993732452, -0.0607810877263546, -0.03728651627898216, 0.7512975931167603, -0.13843916356563568, -0.21642257273197174, -0.428249716758728, 0.4249626696109772, 0.5871923565864563, 0.10975576937198639, 0.6871277689933777, 0.989865243434906, -0.5820099711418152, 0.1952393501996994, -0.7444596886634827, 0.057994645088911057, -0.5088961720466614, 0.13772262632846832, 0.024679144844412804, -1.292823314666748, 0.5209401249885559, 0.08101222664117813, 0.1188679039478302, 0.43672341108322144, 0.9906710982322693, 0.007298165932297707, 0.7918683290481567, 0.6164268851280212, -0.483703076839447, 0.8322648406028748, -0.1186964362859726, 0.28578341007232666, -0.8397364020347595, -0.27321311831474304, -0.8470582365989685, -0.11536354571580887, -0.46694207191467285, -0.5208398699760437, 0.2726694941520691, -0.22464224696159363, -0.6559296250343323, 0.4691823422908783, -0.6252859234809875, 0.34221351146698, 0.3419635593891144, -0.16233126819133759, 0.18050235509872437, -0.07191804051399231, 0.4541318118572235, -0.11826319992542267, -0.30851486325263977, -0.5315999388694763, 0.944673478603363, 0.2008037120103836, 0.28006085753440857, 0.23957639932632446, 0.7630952000617981, 0.6080160140991211, 0.6132020950317383, -0.8834280967712402, 0.6221739053726196, 0.1710885912179947, -0.6416605710983276, -0.3550279140472412, -0.16217917203903198, -0.9197646379470825, 0.28981226682662964, 0.13586726784706116, -0.7124685645103455, 0.2014702707529068, -0.15182003378868103, -0.12512953579425812, 0.6436982750892639, -0.23481222987174988, 0.8167387843132019, -0.06900274008512497, -0.22907502949237823, -0.41455382108688354, -0.2116137444972992, 0.17543812096118927, -0.2749195098876953, 0.3248978555202484, -0.5363409519195557, -0.3133470118045807, 1.0579279661178589, 0.004983632825314999, 1.132499098777771, -0.4356730580329895, -0.42841774225234985, 0.179342120885849, -0.15680162608623505, 0.4287396967411041, -0.15842171013355255, -0.6356436610221863, 0.39598599076271057, -0.34858593344688416, -0.40190497040748596, -0.011694325134158134, 0.9752557277679443, -0.5932707190513611, -0.7999252080917358, -0.6079912185668945, -0.4221137762069702, -0.11644738912582397, 0.1928064376115799, 0.11046644300222397, 0.08348900079727173, -0.44575777649879456, -0.07629850506782532, 0.3531467020511627, -0.1435168832540512, 0.6187853217124939, 0.5777457356452942, 0.007661857176572084, -0.42437347769737244, 0.5577664971351624, 0.1564204841852188, -0.16815651953220367, -0.11531925946474075, 0.31844010949134827, -0.23100155591964722, -1.2299180030822754, -0.2116514891386032, 0.22137406468391418, -0.7340494990348816, -0.39063549041748047, -0.668548583984375, 0.06330796331167221, -0.627284824848175, -0.32215720415115356, -0.19041390717029572, -0.1695222109556198, -0.5804108381271362, -0.39695727825164795, 0.6397366523742676, 1.043925404548645, -0.18391670286655426, 0.3068374991416931, -0.2729977071285248, 0.43247586488723755, 0.055887289345264435, 0.19549556076526642, -0.3605726659297943, -0.816616952419281, 0.011197439394891262, -0.11276493966579437, -0.4623720645904541, -0.9303655028343201, 0.536915123462677, 0.18252450227737427, 0.5162553191184998, 0.27736225724220276, 0.133523628115654, 0.5448851585388184, -0.5595273375511169, 1.0787084102630615, 0.18600700795650482, -0.9752917289733887, 0.7453277111053467, -0.6881740689277649, -0.11829373240470886, 0.3863671123981476, 0.6766404509544373, -0.3024502694606781, -0.2992440462112427, -0.6871434450149536, -0.6354777812957764, 0.7228685617446899, 0.04744003340601921, 0.4910087287425995, -0.2804240882396698, 0.4710767865180969, -0.027858497574925423, 0.26239028573036194, -0.7011534571647644, 0.03241776302456856, -0.308888703584671, -0.19490019977092743, -0.04696579650044441, -0.42661312222480774, -0.22066232562065125, -0.3669235110282898, 0.7116751074790955, -0.2257424294948578, 0.09922047704458237, -0.15017788112163544, 0.39673948287963867, -0.20561376214027405, 0.4156675934791565, 0.5466920733451843, 0.39789003133773804, 0.02599787525832653, -0.06902492046356201, 0.40838897228240967, -0.49135443568229675, 0.17208021879196167, 0.12561330199241638, -0.10418523102998734, -0.16405537724494934, 0.33789297938346863, 0.7125415802001953, 0.3605387210845947, -0.3638162612915039, 0.3377084732055664, 0.1717790961265564, -0.3632147014141083, -0.5328207015991211, -0.08113379776477814, -0.06862052530050278, 0.6220268607139587, 0.35571718215942383, -0.12893202900886536, 0.33877435326576233, -0.5834364295005798, 0.20003917813301086, 0.5385393500328064, -0.19056670367717743, -0.5041475296020508, 0.7426910400390625, 0.029996031895279884, -0.16653400659561157, 0.3899262845516205, -0.16131067276000977, -1.0218526124954224, 0.6455134153366089, 0.461014062166214, 0.5713016390800476, -0.4641686975955963, 0.42033493518829346, 0.45128411054611206, -0.013303568586707115, 0.09329411387443542, 0.27629348635673523, -0.08690277487039566, -1.1901649236679077, -0.2444102019071579, -0.7869573831558228, -0.6388150453567505, 0.23010607063770294, -0.5291244983673096, 0.1513727754354477, -0.5266431570053101, -0.2495623379945755, 0.06943254917860031, 0.43963557481765747, -0.46247535943984985, -0.11649612337350845, 0.20121891796588898, 0.6156980991363525, -0.8609642386436462, 0.8656986355781555, 0.5332375168800354, -0.1856754720211029, -0.5872224569320679, 0.06270764023065567, 0.4341698884963989, -0.7703111171722412, 0.68360435962677, 0.05465541407465935, -0.18120470643043518, 0.22343450784683228, -0.7347083687782288, -0.7649672031402588, 1.0966764688491821, 0.4536799490451813, -0.3814534544944763, 0.12156518548727036, -0.1406290978193283, 0.4745173454284668, -0.2505967915058136, -0.32475271821022034, 0.8624817132949829, 0.8100394606590271, 0.4141913950443268, -0.9328951835632324, -0.11908408999443054, 0.056463584303855896, -0.3457055985927582, 0.2262723296880722, -0.7978207468986511, 0.5934503078460693, -0.029523037374019623, -0.14663681387901306, 0.07229062914848328, 0.648990273475647, 0.3445006012916565, 0.6264666318893433, 0.4817773401737213, 0.8697564005851746, 0.7028220295906067, -0.09789039194583893, 1.151682734489441, 0.08297272026538849, 0.2972874939441681, 0.7899532914161682, -0.5276731848716736, 0.9569132924079895, 0.40325871109962463, -0.26898059248924255, 0.4237348139286041, 0.7470704913139343, 0.07888492941856384, 0.5097812414169312, 0.08732225745916367, -0.8156793117523193, -0.27875131368637085, -0.5393977761268616, -0.10598140954971313, 0.5484870076179504, 0.6165761351585388, -0.009586741216480732, -0.34694790840148926, 0.4383280575275421, 0.3698117434978485, 0.18319161236286163, -0.5324598550796509, 0.7103579640388489, -0.03410281240940094, -0.4347706735134125, 0.36922234296798706, 0.02901928871870041, 1.0039710998535156, -0.19969633221626282, -0.0038164842408150434, 0.16872753202915192, -0.09874788671731949, -0.282145619392395, -0.9874221086502075, 0.5732830166816711, 0.3231086730957031, -0.07258102297782898, -0.318034291267395, 0.7491605281829834, -0.3079056143760681, -0.2514825761318207, 0.4740314185619354, 0.028340008109807968, 0.1824224591255188, -0.012290346436202526, -0.9812160730361938, 0.7384035587310791, -0.009254715405404568, -0.5380844473838806, 0.4438212215900421, -0.012835970148444176, -0.12276700884103775, 0.4472123980522156, 0.7329425811767578, 0.03569180518388748, 0.14474831521511078, 0.31712982058525085, 0.9882912039756775, -0.4215279519557953, 0.06645850837230682, -0.8093664646148682, -0.086577869951725, -0.060682620853185654, -0.10317295789718628, 0.8865264058113098, 0.523922324180603, 0.6954147815704346, 0.3203653395175934, 0.6681498289108276, -0.18515005707740784, 0.5322120189666748, -0.4118150770664215, 0.4046591520309448, -0.3455035984516144, 0.1057950034737587, -0.2483454793691635, -0.8413066864013672, -0.4701285660266876, 0.5597277283668518, -0.637323796749115, 0.19434396922588348, 0.173121377825737, 0.7564700245857239, 0.12748713791370392, -0.028037890791893005, 0.43576112389564514, 0.20418930053710938, 0.7695196270942688, 0.2801370322704315, 0.714903712272644, -0.20920196175575256, 0.5472728610038757, -0.021725844591856003, 0.09503864496946335, -0.091994509100914, -1.1665048599243164, -0.7668244242668152, -0.7378013134002686, -0.6431334018707275, -0.32805559039115906, 0.06569905579090118, 0.8212189078330994, 0.6399526596069336, -0.910423994064331, 0.18147818744182587, -0.040813181549310684, 0.1743641048669815, 0.41499751806259155, -0.21205748617649078, 0.34265080094337463, 0.018305351957678795, -1.1195372343063354, 0.7564784288406372, 0.2538100481033325, 0.115543432533741, -0.12801574170589447, -0.16148103773593903, -0.4487497806549072, 0.15006861090660095, 0.5521737933158875, 0.5304856300354004, -0.8516899943351746, -0.7944014668464661, -0.513647198677063, 0.21926619112491608, -0.07354322820901871, 0.696628987789154, -0.6873355507850647, -0.05945678800344467, 0.40158960223197937, 0.7203282117843628, 0.5386879444122314, 0.1213320791721344, 0.222585067152977, -0.55442214012146, 0.305666983127594, 0.5146313309669495, 0.492657333612442, 0.5042800903320312, -0.4193083941936493, 0.5991702079772949, 0.30714496970176697, -0.7634695172309875, -0.8579180836677551, 0.37165209650993347, -1.0838357210159302, -0.026839425787329674, 1.3127466440200806, 0.028343388810753822, -0.0905323475599289, -0.4938031733036041, -0.21677061915397644, 0.19139711558818817, -0.4134144186973572, 0.6646308302879333, 0.9510481953620911, -0.19974064826965332, -0.37876614928245544, -0.5237639546394348, 0.4947139322757721, 0.15878728032112122, -0.7065958380699158, -0.03441118448972702, 0.7912264466285706, 0.3733369708061218, 0.2031744420528412, 0.7396137714385986, -0.12049230188131332, 0.16323347389698029, -0.35884183645248413, -0.027300206944346428, 0.06833267211914062, -0.24164214730262756, -0.4631962180137634, 0.2928248345851898, 0.08537158370018005, 0.147573783993721 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06544v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06544v1	Calibrating Long-form Generations from Large Language Models	2024-02-09T17:00:32	2024-02-09T17:00:32	Yukun Huang, Yixin Liu, Raghuveer Thirukovalluru, Arman Cohan, Bhuwan Dhingra	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	To enhance Large Language Models' (LLMs) reliability, calibration is essential -- the model's assessed confidence scores should align with the actual likelihood of its responses being correct. However, current confidence elicitation methods and calibration metrics typically rely on a binary true/false assessment of response correctness. This approach does not apply to long-form generation, where an answer can be partially correct. Addressing this gap, we introduce a unified calibration framework, in which both the correctness of the LLMs' responses and their associated confidence levels are treated as distributions across a range of scores. Within this framework, we develop three metrics to precisely evaluate LLM calibration and further propose two confidence elicitation methods based on self-consistency and self-evaluation. Our experiments, which include long-form QA and summarization tasks, demonstrate that larger models don't necessarily guarantee better calibration, that calibration performance is found to be metric-dependent, and that self-consistency methods excel in factoid datasets. We also find that calibration can be enhanced through techniques such as fine-tuning, integrating relevant source documents, scaling the temperature, and combining self-consistency with self-evaluation. Lastly, we showcase a practical application of our system: selecting and cascading open-source models and ChatGPT to optimize correctness given a limited API budget. This research not only challenges existing notions of LLM calibration but also offers practical methodologies for improving trustworthiness in long-form generation.	[ -0.1294793337583542, -0.4531387984752655, 0.7129334211349487, 0.42744624614715576, -0.02669600211083889, 0.0871458649635315, -0.39332711696624756, -0.3576098680496216, 0.06398257613182068, 0.4360955059528351, -0.28430861234664917, -0.3906615376472473, -0.25205549597740173, 0.06941716372966766, -0.22695301473140717, 0.7573596835136414, -0.0015709976432844996, 0.0753154382109642, -0.5388718247413635, -0.0378134585916996, -0.42172732949256897, -0.45240259170532227, -0.47502586245536804, -0.5705616474151611, 0.5400180220603943, 0.3123457431793213, 0.8065328598022461, 0.536760687828064, 0.2456977516412735, 0.22012017667293549, 0.03862632066011429, 0.21870063245296478, -0.6587194800376892, 0.3123684227466583, -0.2850409746170044, -0.40063440799713135, -0.42745789885520935, -0.14110906422138214, 0.7669194936752319, 0.5956937670707703, -0.2390153408050537, 0.2975439429283142, 0.4036622941493988, 0.7113317847251892, -0.756942629814148, 0.2519025206565857, -0.5188137888908386, -0.28503817319869995, 0.039434898644685745, -0.33501294255256653, -0.6437991261482239, -0.6184781789779663, -0.12629403173923492, -0.3525255024433136, -0.05528711900115013, 0.0003376163658685982, 0.36688923835754395, 0.24655066430568695, -0.47312790155410767, -0.3180449903011322, -0.8204911351203918, 0.9232122302055359, -1.0890905857086182, 0.3199293315410614, 0.44802865386009216, 0.23796550929546356, -0.3219369053840637, -0.38797134160995483, -0.36175310611724854, -0.28407472372055054, 0.22671622037887573, 0.2099488228559494, 0.03748943284153938, -0.006490643136203289, 0.061094243079423904, 0.37365207076072693, -0.6672503352165222, 0.35929372906684875, -0.28554171323776245, -0.39480528235435486, 0.759516179561615, -0.06329178065061569, -0.0505448542535305, -0.14347803592681885, -0.37669309973716736, -0.1964379847049713, -0.9823499321937561, -0.14213234186172485, 0.6846716403961182, 0.5658017992973328, 0.004192474763840437, 0.6123982667922974, -0.13003091514110565, 0.5434401035308838, 0.17469504475593567, -0.26767000555992126, 0.31114324927330017, -0.27710774540901184, -0.19491319358348846, 0.020226996392011642, 0.8585662245750427, 0.31476280093193054, 0.35935264825820923, -0.17047174274921417, -0.2557375431060791, -0.2012680321931839, 0.11079863458871841, -0.7426681518554688, -0.13975510001182556, 0.42670342326164246, -0.05323402211070061, -0.32254138588905334, 0.01405603252351284, -0.7092030644416809, -0.28603318333625793, -0.47163090109825134, 0.6266081929206848, -0.23176082968711853, -0.31309592723846436, 0.13725703954696655, 0.16933117806911469, 0.36986714601516724, 0.2924776077270508, -0.9330757856369019, 0.07077403366565704, 0.757144570350647, 0.542214572429657, -0.10648761689662933, -0.30829867720603943, -0.4922826886177063, 0.17541779577732086, -0.549146294593811, 0.5780940055847168, -0.2036244124174118, -0.3886183202266693, 0.16244548559188843, -0.19857391715049744, 0.06113525480031967, -0.4630042314529419, 0.4705755114555359, -0.3977288603782654, 0.33530765771865845, -0.2188890129327774, -0.6271086931228638, 0.081125408411026, 0.30952441692352295, -0.5224629044532776, 1.2888256311416626, 0.14007455110549927, -0.5881180763244629, 0.16459956765174866, -0.17259936034679413, -0.20158347487449646, 0.06792280077934265, -0.24149265885353088, -0.2957587242126465, 0.1510799527168274, 0.054324500262737274, 0.5147834420204163, -0.23734258115291595, 0.31516528129577637, -0.5820233821868896, -0.17924299836158752, 0.11604469269514084, -0.7715818285942078, 0.6252447962760925, 0.28014031052589417, -0.23871754109859467, -0.08888744562864304, -0.8790068030357361, 0.6011991500854492, -0.11999615281820297, -0.32431626319885254, -0.20841862261295319, -0.060770682990550995, -0.12380655854940414, -0.005388268269598484, 0.43860137462615967, -0.5791909098625183, -0.07113498449325562, -0.409573495388031, 0.46728792786598206, 0.731722891330719, -0.08148326724767685, 0.33447787165641785, -0.4868892431259155, 0.45645177364349365, -0.09321841597557068, 0.03040330484509468, -0.26980915665626526, -0.10849501192569733, -0.6321145296096802, -0.1087508499622345, 0.38081446290016174, 0.4454002380371094, -0.37791740894317627, 0.9265219569206238, -0.6113178133964539, -0.6685213446617126, -0.3364178240299225, 0.3776804804801941, 0.33509373664855957, 0.5310845971107483, 0.21308329701423645, -0.27710577845573425, -0.28137242794036865, -0.7307870388031006, -0.03417574614286423, -0.48995253443717957, -0.16828753054141998, -0.01823490485548973, 0.24878886342048645, 0.06217149645090103, 1.027779221534729, -0.17197170853614807, 0.15288181602954865, 0.09226510673761368, 0.36733537912368774, 0.13834764063358307, 0.4668872356414795, 0.4422133266925812, -0.44951289892196655, -0.3139105439186096, -0.24818110466003418, -0.5763803720474243, -0.15476971864700317, 0.0727209523320198, -0.09175818413496017, 0.2913278043270111, 0.47297608852386475, -0.4750418961048126, 0.20051750540733337, 1.0405216217041016, -0.04207569360733032, 0.6433148980140686, -0.426608145236969, 0.31161439418792725, -1.36374831199646, 0.11548000574111938, 0.06194294989109039, -0.6184075474739075, -0.3476001024246216, 0.2269623875617981, 0.297903835773468, 0.1782107651233673, -0.3766807019710541, 0.5995131731033325, -0.4828304946422577, -0.02183522842824459, -0.20652326941490173, 0.19787295162677765, 0.2562287449836731, -0.023645998910069466, -0.22764810919761658, 0.8609248995780945, 0.24686893820762634, -0.4159272611141205, 0.4969165325164795, -0.10058744251728058, -0.30763158202171326, 0.8248839378356934, -0.7034072875976562, 0.30128902196884155, -0.23359547555446625, 0.4440470337867737, -1.2561875581741333, -0.28564801812171936, -0.10993369668722153, -0.41817373037338257, 0.45647045969963074, -0.1464611440896988, -0.6926934719085693, -0.4205082356929779, -0.37117743492126465, 0.48290592432022095, 0.5704358816146851, -0.5940499901771545, 0.73677659034729, 0.017542196437716484, -0.24552878737449646, -0.6764211058616638, -0.6973680853843689, -0.0643889382481575, -0.06538083404302597, -0.7502373456954956, 0.05416325852274895, -0.4823361039161682, -0.07319480180740356, -0.44464734196662903, -0.10150410979986191, 0.1630832552909851, -0.07613400369882584, 0.4109630882740021, 0.22501380741596222, -0.3152531385421753, 0.2831670641899109, -0.17758089303970337, 0.11867872625589371, 0.07125040888786316, -0.06191156432032585, 0.712584912776947, -0.07466723769903183, -0.6026371717453003, -0.2115413397550583, 0.18459509313106537, 0.7455355525016785, -0.23014986515045166, 0.5128187537193298, 0.34411871433258057, -0.2604767978191376, -0.32490074634552, -0.9642199277877808, -0.13956646621227264, -0.45268189907073975, 0.22520174086093903, -0.38601669669151306, -0.797853946685791, 0.5615630745887756, 0.0006839125999249518, 0.317178338766098, 0.6567277908325195, 0.6447442770004272, -0.057158730924129486, 0.9425995349884033, 0.6215746998786926, -0.20801927149295807, 0.03646846115589142, 0.23206113278865814, 0.14849048852920532, -0.7287450432777405, -0.11808322370052338, -0.7233704924583435, 0.09381043165922165, -0.40828409790992737, -0.5033103227615356, 0.10148259997367859, 0.02831350639462471, -0.44628050923347473, 0.11016374081373215, -0.2639737129211426, 0.5845034718513489, 0.48935607075691223, 0.033107075840234756, 0.3378673195838928, -0.033210210502147675, -0.05455078184604645, 0.01704579032957554, -0.37257102131843567, -0.7367280125617981, 1.11241614818573, 0.6974048018455505, 1.193738579750061, 0.10440120100975037, 0.8679038882255554, 0.1493319422006607, 0.4403781294822693, -0.6125707626342773, 0.3568582236766815, -0.04333728179335594, -0.6093702912330627, -0.4937319755554199, -0.673019289970398, -0.6827058792114258, -0.060537684708833694, -0.030819149687886238, -0.68316650390625, 0.07819075882434845, 0.25094395875930786, -0.6048172116279602, 0.008816765621304512, -0.7517669200897217, 0.6372080445289612, -0.3587513566017151, -0.3149089813232422, -0.05444731190800667, -0.5614141821861267, 0.383571982383728, -0.4231448173522949, 0.17396391928195953, -0.3802793025970459, 0.13912709057331085, 0.314064085483551, -0.19256483018398285, 0.9494213461875916, 0.06491396576166153, -0.5084795951843262, 0.24061518907546997, 0.16904090344905853, 0.43924659490585327, -0.06582225859165192, -0.47575557231903076, -0.07882381975650787, 0.4875204861164093, -0.3729744851589203, -0.7032393217086792, 0.8896708488464355, -0.832840621471405, -0.5241789221763611, -0.28922975063323975, -0.5404626727104187, -0.5185513496398926, 0.20571520924568176, 0.16076134145259857, 0.31900861859321594, -0.3566285967826843, 0.459999144077301, 0.7216886281967163, -0.09569014608860016, 0.15095451474189758, 0.4081459939479828, -0.47407054901123047, -0.5190958380699158, 0.5668317675590515, 0.04618101567029953, 0.7858633399009705, 0.2739713490009308, 0.20817789435386658, -0.5909234285354614, -0.14074674248695374, -0.46328258514404297, 0.39586594700813293, -0.8223766088485718, -0.48648595809936523, -0.10716336220502853, -0.4459308683872223, -0.7605154514312744, 0.09447869658470154, -0.4336932301521301, -0.3102973997592926, -0.33352428674697876, -0.10555978119373322, 0.16064639389514923, 0.6119491457939148, -0.17095538973808289, 0.22545771300792694, -0.7015855312347412, 0.08151894062757492, 0.3547441065311432, 0.3568356931209564, -0.012699989601969719, -0.7722229957580566, 0.0706748515367508, 0.46656695008277893, -0.24104547500610352, -0.7239511013031006, 0.14468294382095337, 0.3361823260784149, 0.47829872369766235, 0.2769642472267151, 0.10214123874902725, 0.76481693983078, -0.5023602843284607, 0.8165102005004883, 0.392376571893692, -0.9096502065658569, 0.43755069375038147, -0.25000834465026855, 0.4101197123527527, 0.8165669441223145, 0.2177540361881256, -0.5037501454353333, -0.4662652313709259, -0.37702974677085876, -0.7687883377075195, 0.09127306938171387, -0.11171025782823563, 0.5938547253608704, -0.04449901357293129, 0.5125837326049805, 0.0558537095785141, 0.0004857077437918633, -0.7447755932807922, -0.060231324285268784, -0.20290479063987732, -0.6419679522514343, -0.4306434392929077, -0.36226552724838257, -0.3273651897907257, 0.13230761885643005, 0.8366145491600037, -0.41672709584236145, -0.146894171833992, 0.1380397081375122, 0.016987264156341553, -0.4042185842990875, 0.4367111921310425, 0.44930532574653625, 1.0515516996383667, -0.29423174262046814, 0.26422119140625, -0.026731571182608604, -0.2318863421678543, 0.20537419617176056, 0.09681471437215805, -0.24553801119327545, -0.04444912448525429, 0.07017939537763596, 0.39775002002716064, 0.2725244462490082, -0.48344749212265015, 0.7578558325767517, 0.09434565156698227, -0.19208185374736786, -0.49488407373428345, 0.06596135348081589, 0.20630459487438202, 0.1627013236284256, 0.4618622362613678, -0.3436748683452606, -0.24165861308574677, -0.6178871989250183, 0.19298869371414185, 0.5794410109519958, -0.14391489326953888, -0.13723163306713104, 0.5206425189971924, 0.08751293271780014, -0.05852273479104042, 0.654568612575531, 0.06971284002065659, -0.22661811113357544, 0.4292508661746979, 0.7425029873847961, 0.7524939179420471, -0.4050276577472687, 0.32268068194389343, 0.44869786500930786, 0.3125457763671875, -0.47747644782066345, 0.19235388934612274, 0.13856132328510284, -0.6869626045227051, -0.7071492671966553, -0.808660626411438, -0.6293834447860718, 0.12420044839382172, -0.6986520290374756, 0.15424738824367523, -0.3301842510700226, -0.356283962726593, -0.12187416106462479, 0.05703769624233246, -0.7178483009338379, 0.3186645805835724, 0.33515825867652893, 1.0470267534255981, -0.8876961469650269, 0.6771156191825867, 0.2786354720592499, -0.3044024407863617, -1.218489408493042, -0.1521688848733902, -0.03454655408859253, -0.9369637370109558, 0.39347121119499207, 0.14906874299049377, -0.3110746145248413, 0.02071272023022175, -0.66297447681427, -1.0090659856796265, 1.2505851984024048, 0.5571064352989197, -0.776763916015625, -0.163908451795578, 0.26998162269592285, 0.6504462361335754, -0.28830939531326294, 0.3754101097583771, 0.3552291691303253, 0.33644601702690125, 0.430034339427948, -1.1499360799789429, 0.013474933803081512, 0.05541412532329559, 0.09372274577617645, 0.06538691371679306, -0.6207515001296997, 0.3434896767139435, -0.12343569099903107, -0.2176796942949295, 0.46161288022994995, 0.804322361946106, 0.5263530611991882, 0.041781019419431686, 0.4579598903656006, 0.6006459593772888, 0.7827975749969482, -0.13644686341285706, 0.8085607886314392, -0.564425528049469, 0.4551170766353607, 1.28754723072052, -0.3322313725948334, 1.2712278366088867, 0.5850421190261841, -0.1848456859588623, 0.3913589119911194, 0.4786514937877655, 0.058771539479494095, 0.09126527607440948, 0.39868584275245667, -0.3530394732952118, -0.3468542993068695, 0.11355306208133698, -0.3219204545021057, 0.2807103395462036, 0.11927508562803268, -0.421420693397522, -0.26419612765312195, -0.23085573315620422, 0.11351083964109421, 0.10196108371019363, -0.30367398262023926, 0.4701194763183594, 0.2374039590358734, -0.9109034538269043, 0.48504528403282166, -0.07851935923099518, 0.5783549547195435, -0.6688663363456726, 0.2088499814271927, -0.2918863892555237, 0.1897641122341156, -0.26085323095321655, -0.9753775000572205, -0.15762998163700104, -0.14446309208869934, -0.13391584157943726, -0.09539513289928436, 0.5034143924713135, -0.6116054058074951, -0.5693574547767639, 0.1215176060795784, 0.5924198627471924, 0.21939264237880707, 0.050192903727293015, -0.368659645318985, 0.15747787058353424, -0.05753122642636299, -0.2927840054035187, 0.2960469722747803, 0.35378968715667725, 0.3199153542518616, 0.6462767124176025, 0.5931826233863831, 0.3677142858505249, 0.15541642904281616, 0.33211007714271545, 0.45526573061943054, -0.3114156723022461, -0.20344661176204681, -0.7441639304161072, 0.4462660253047943, -0.04478463530540466, -0.23240631818771362, 0.7156357765197754, 0.6527724266052246, 0.6566264629364014, 0.1268574297428131, 0.6777558922767639, 0.3130359351634979, 0.6911056041717529, -0.521224856376648, 0.5365104079246521, -0.3983246684074402, 0.1759086549282074, -0.16915030777454376, -1.3339263200759888, -0.45880740880966187, 0.49819526076316833, -0.31995275616645813, 0.22301626205444336, 0.34834548830986023, 0.8752148747444153, -0.041409559547901154, -0.16572727262973785, 0.5132008194923401, 0.17690534889698029, 0.42294561862945557, 0.43385830521583557, 0.7249515652656555, -0.36080342531204224, 0.4373447597026825, -0.21217726171016693, -0.2922936677932739, -0.004366614390164614, -1.2758281230926514, -0.5982024073600769, -0.5272476673126221, -0.2771090865135193, -0.5989881753921509, 0.12718091905117035, 0.9900424480438232, 0.8014785051345825, -0.645910918712616, -0.2883025109767914, 0.27153608202934265, -0.3648301661014557, 0.229493647813797, -0.25, 0.20381902158260345, -0.5584500432014465, -0.6291245818138123, 0.20785635709762573, 0.3164638876914978, 0.29304754734039307, -0.7903017997741699, -0.1068030595779419, 0.4026452302932739, 0.41271087527275085, 0.6075704097747803, 0.551559329032898, -0.7039957046508789, -0.6659765839576721, -0.0597689226269722, -0.44668978452682495, 0.13279759883880615, 0.3359096646308899, -0.5870361328125, 0.5280441641807556, 0.32992690801620483, 0.5954069495201111, 0.29577550292015076, 0.3216240406036377, 0.7325485348701477, -0.7189285755157471, -0.31295305490493774, 0.2902127802371979, 0.29459837079048157, 0.5830316543579102, -0.18826831877231598, 0.34839460253715515, -0.3306104838848114, -1.0264129638671875, -0.8326897025108337, 0.2578684687614441, -0.9801942110061646, 0.1688147634267807, 1.3660752773284912, -0.22607013583183289, -0.26569947600364685, 0.2244441956281662, -0.04893075302243233, 0.053876254707574844, -0.2394433319568634, 0.7884756326675415, 0.9725313782691956, 0.19059830904006958, -0.1078113242983818, -0.43363937735557556, 0.2097911834716797, 0.39424771070480347, -0.82427579164505, 0.403687059879303, 0.7728720307350159, 0.6236597299575806, 0.3500899374485016, 0.5990874767303467, -0.2734171748161316, 0.10384678840637207, -0.34386536478996277, 0.05502314865589142, 0.33051544427871704, -0.23829533159732819, -0.3577887713909149, 0.025986596941947937, 0.4818812906742096, 0.2964877784252167 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10231v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10231v1	A Multi-faceted Semi-Synthetic Dataset for Automated Cyberbullying Detection	2024-02-09T16:53:19	2024-02-09T16:53:19	Naveed Ejaz, Fakhra Kashif, Salimur Choudhury	cs.SI	cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2	In recent years, the rising use of social media has propelled automated cyberbullying detection into a prominent research domain. However, challenges persist due to the absence of a standardized definition and universally accepted datasets. Many researchers now view cyberbullying as a facet of cyberaggression, encompassing factors like repetition, peer relationships, and harmful intent in addition to online aggression. Acquiring comprehensive data reflective of all cyberbullying components from social media networks proves to be a complex task. This paper provides a description of an extensive semi-synthetic cyberbullying dataset that incorporates all of the essential aspects of cyberbullying, including aggression, repetition, peer relationships, and intent to harm. The method of creating the dataset is succinctly outlined, and a detailed overview of the publicly accessible dataset is additionally presented. This accompanying data article provides an in-depth look at the dataset, increasing transparency and enabling replication. It also aids in a deeper understanding of the data, supporting broader research use.	[ -0.1723741590976715, -1.4540783166885376, 0.3388458490371704, 0.7241424918174744, 0.18859761953353882, 0.6119590401649475, 0.18270093202590942, -0.33301082253456116, 0.4561179578304291, 0.2733798027038574, -0.6706184148788452, -0.26642969250679016, -0.5774396061897278, -0.11559131741523743, -0.8530260920524597, 1.1933943033218384, 0.006665124092251062, -0.09136954694986343, -0.07186490297317505, 0.20775192975997925, -0.6770569086074829, -0.4235385060310364, -0.5632197260856628, -0.14100824296474457, 0.4460282325744629, 0.1786690652370453, 0.3258042633533478, 0.33848676085472107, 0.3194771707057953, 0.37147894501686096, -0.020707983523607254, 0.1511273831129074, -0.6922614574432373, 0.06804628670215607, -0.348029226064682, 0.12529078125953674, -0.498138427734375, -0.012018060311675072, 0.7680248618125916, 0.43491193652153015, 0.0099966861307621, 0.18874838948249817, 0.029582109302282333, 0.24212957918643951, -0.455139696598053, -0.10032235831022263, -0.3626744747161865, 0.2793152332305908, -0.5158572196960449, -0.06062627211213112, -0.06855297833681107, -0.1682577133178711, -0.10432090610265732, -0.24204322695732117, 0.19647502899169922, 0.027765395119786263, 0.23293018341064453, -0.1182006374001503, -0.6041704416275024, -0.0031630955636501312, -1.031219244003296, 0.40715155005455017, -0.09455927461385727, 0.18035458028316498, 0.30941882729530334, 0.5564470291137695, -0.28998082876205444, -0.7452383637428284, -0.5425785183906555, 0.2523418664932251, 0.03233562409877777, -0.014561048708856106, -0.33144766092300415, 0.14815640449523926, 0.16286805272102356, 0.38625872135162354, -0.764559805393219, -0.18265551328659058, -0.6000671982765198, -0.5439373254776001, 0.8613629937171936, 0.3991115093231201, 0.3367554545402527, -0.20303498208522797, -0.4308575987815857, 0.06722155213356018, -0.3756319284439087, 0.05959966778755188, 0.45723554491996765, 0.5066535472869873, -0.4614320397377014, 0.49148786067962646, -0.1521700620651245, 0.6737992763519287, 0.182256817817688, -0.31783926486968994, 0.3555644750595093, -0.8084075450897217, 0.12931331992149353, 0.39075174927711487, 0.9582530856132507, 0.41344162821769714, 0.29308316111564636, -0.012134200893342495, -0.36014965176582336, 0.3413594663143158, 0.4925100803375244, -0.7126213908195496, -0.5601538419723511, 0.43666642904281616, -0.34107184410095215, -0.7642975449562073, 0.043114930391311646, -0.8705898523330688, -0.6571468114852905, -0.6034884452819824, 0.5547931790351868, -0.2040398269891739, -0.3124929666519165, -0.24185095727443695, -0.41371628642082214, -0.35967570543289185, -0.03274970501661301, -0.11907440423965454, 0.41994258761405945, 0.3636649549007416, 0.88777095079422, -0.15148423612117767, -0.13566210865974426, -0.4746539890766144, 0.06943674385547638, -0.18413080275058746, 0.9286445379257202, -0.7025967240333557, -0.08146988600492477, 0.0609632283449173, 0.19777581095695496, 0.18241465091705322, -0.609338104724884, 0.2445889115333557, -0.17130666971206665, -0.03151683881878853, 0.2620449662208557, -0.3340817391872406, -0.1935223639011383, 0.294002890586853, -0.5764796137809753, 0.9905279874801636, 0.19037452340126038, -0.4469151794910431, 0.1912851333618164, -0.2631915211677551, -0.9500330686569214, 0.19779421389102936, 0.12873224914073944, -0.6040617227554321, -0.014287651516497135, 0.008465110324323177, 0.6050545573234558, -0.1067795678973198, 0.6300300359725952, -0.7697066068649292, -0.18535904586315155, 0.14241713285446167, -0.13216166198253632, 0.9318181276321411, -0.15126115083694458, -0.2404903918504715, 0.1548987478017807, -0.8856781125068665, -0.09062080830335617, 0.14290030300617218, 0.202829509973526, -0.3939061164855957, -0.21636569499969482, 0.22598335146903992, 0.44385823607444763, 0.18516391515731812, -0.8834731578826904, -0.29628056287765503, 0.3044509291648865, 0.4493446350097656, 0.7434573769569397, 0.38654863834381104, -0.08681006729602814, -0.39352694153785706, 0.43139708042144775, 0.20522481203079224, 0.33571839332580566, 0.13901866972446442, -0.27213388681411743, 0.041703805327415466, -0.5525667667388916, 0.16577951610088348, 0.6041749715805054, -0.810693621635437, 0.44764646887779236, -0.10068361461162567, -0.5091243982315063, -0.4400767683982849, 0.1712902933359146, 0.512408435344696, 0.3946821391582489, 0.39037561416625977, -0.15298353135585785, -0.8745591044425964, -1.0807348489761353, -0.1424417346715927, 0.16015249490737915, 0.00022695644292980433, 0.24449598789215088, 0.434373676776886, 0.0028551467694342136, 0.9369745850563049, -0.3126945495605469, -0.6842365860939026, -0.21338067948818207, 0.5705556273460388, -0.205971360206604, 0.3023736774921417, 0.6243596076965332, -1.0163559913635254, -0.7324658036231995, -0.4493500590324402, -0.9384613037109375, -0.44779467582702637, -0.2697346806526184, -0.06232988089323044, -0.5314390063285828, 0.43530264496803284, -0.1732308566570282, 0.46938356757164, 0.5433122515678406, -0.26820364594459534, 0.6025602221488953, 0.31858691573143005, 0.1655547022819519, -0.8939681649208069, -0.0013759862631559372, 0.3977767527103424, -0.5046790838241577, -1.123896598815918, -0.16139504313468933, -0.06298145651817322, -0.050013188272714615, -0.46716663241386414, 0.3731549382209778, -0.016526125371456146, 0.003406852949410677, -0.27657705545425415, 0.23134957253932953, -0.25166964530944824, 0.30060023069381714, -0.0657120868563652, 0.5339148640632629, 0.5687839984893799, -0.5960901379585266, 0.8073880672454834, 0.13187113404273987, 0.14799581468105316, 1.298891544342041, -0.8928338289260864, 0.04249325394630432, -0.26292887330055237, 0.5044099688529968, -0.6151280403137207, -0.6096408367156982, 0.3759021759033203, -0.44222018122673035, 0.09226708859205246, -0.055930253118276596, -0.6803483963012695, -0.3456956148147583, -0.5838772058486938, 0.47207337617874146, -0.10468941181898117, -0.3478320240974426, 0.670356810092926, 1.061687707901001, -0.3144508898258209, -0.23881328105926514, -0.12220482528209686, 0.35404542088508606, -0.25504353642463684, -0.5390766859054565, 0.8270850777626038, -0.17051558196544647, -0.09727839380502701, -0.17678862810134888, 0.1557607352733612, -0.07104363292455673, -0.1359643191099167, 0.2087695598602295, 0.2368500977754593, 0.3768482506275177, -0.10567065328359604, 0.024023089557886124, 0.21577982604503632, 0.3209032118320465, 0.1871962994337082, 0.6132827997207642, 0.15783073008060455, 0.15344847738742828, -0.4005110561847687, 0.31423982977867126, 0.06440315395593643, 0.22972148656845093, 0.4101634919643402, 0.6292263269424438, -0.7427510619163513, -0.38699162006378174, -0.1378844976425171, -0.1785724014043808, -0.477008581161499, 0.2898426651954651, -0.20422343909740448, -0.5864775776863098, 0.5572414994239807, 0.007165124174207449, -0.047330841422080994, -0.03745783120393753, 0.5625845193862915, -0.24025851488113403, 1.1590332984924316, 0.3943484127521515, -0.2258676439523697, 0.46125197410583496, 0.10763587802648544, 0.3162095844745636, -0.5682631134986877, -0.5178602933883667, -0.06374553591012955, -0.6015756726264954, -0.7305865287780762, 0.1273372322320938, 0.4353788495063782, -0.451203316450119, -0.37741678953170776, 0.5632356405258179, -0.49370864033699036, 0.25714725255966187, 0.15834781527519226, 0.6363263130187988, 0.07780472189188004, 0.008417889475822449, 0.356813907623291, -0.01667855866253376, -0.3238759934902191, -0.014477510936558247, 1.0314847230911255, 0.11660106480121613, 0.4443358778953552, 0.2087181955575943, 0.47599056363105774, 0.7032706141471863, 0.11431252956390381, -0.5029154419898987, 0.5424812436103821, -0.10908953845500946, -1.1945202350616455, -0.07095962017774582, -0.4986858367919922, -0.9851105809211731, -0.08518832176923752, -0.37460461258888245, -0.7523351311683655, -0.01810169219970703, 0.2749016582965851, -0.3762633800506592, 0.10413409769535065, -0.3879063129425049, 0.7080352306365967, -0.048715900629758835, -0.6791628003120422, -0.26167890429496765, -0.719878613948822, 0.6546755433082581, -0.6719925999641418, 0.5624643564224243, 0.15623190999031067, 0.40563392639160156, 0.8155701160430908, -0.3403151035308838, 1.0348073244094849, -0.3544551730155945, 0.23383058607578278, 0.5627800822257996, 0.10174531489610672, 0.3120118975639343, -0.1586051732301712, 0.709255039691925, -0.0803961232304573, -0.11628510802984238, -0.3908523619174957, -0.37756863236427307, 0.6050862669944763, -0.3676000237464905, -0.048836734145879745, -0.4613431692123413, -0.646554708480835, -0.19530388712882996, 0.32281923294067383, -0.2649925947189331, 0.4391883313655853, -0.3361153304576874, 0.3046830892562866, 0.7068964242935181, 0.008194814436137676, 0.17577700316905975, 0.182692289352417, -0.4590553045272827, -0.34872114658355713, 1.3687217235565186, 0.08831145614385605, -0.05731510370969772, 0.08233179897069931, 0.1276080310344696, -0.19974125921726227, -0.1599045693874359, -0.10024791955947876, 0.18106704950332642, -0.21572661399841309, -0.2107750028371811, -0.564071536064148, -0.40465009212493896, -0.5148677825927734, 0.08953039348125458, -0.27379435300827026, -0.20743538439273834, 0.25329074263572693, -0.13709445297718048, 0.3246046006679535, 0.9608227014541626, -0.41720345616340637, 0.4200478196144104, -0.7289970517158508, 0.8284236192703247, 0.31928691267967224, 0.24480265378952026, -0.16175171732902527, -0.6194671392440796, 0.10070615261793137, 0.15406256914138794, -0.43324846029281616, -1.062839150428772, 0.3244103193283081, 0.16410775482654572, 0.30460110306739807, 0.16375869512557983, 0.13732752203941345, 0.7620500326156616, -0.32452958822250366, 0.3748796284198761, 0.00006352848868118599, -0.4668102264404297, 0.5915641784667969, -0.5760616064071655, -0.14091068506240845, 0.32074853777885437, 0.6652669310569763, -0.5999571084976196, -0.051367390900850296, -0.8535159826278687, -0.6532687544822693, 0.565912127494812, 0.4229622781276703, 0.07492692768573761, 0.2774319350719452, -0.043214987963438034, -0.14353978633880615, 0.4592842757701874, -0.6923303008079529, -0.461471289396286, -0.2504229247570038, -0.413866251707077, 0.07949017733335495, 0.035462167114019394, -0.4216137230396271, -0.27082541584968567, 0.7612698674201965, 0.14207202196121216, 0.2666211426258087, -0.4470881521701813, -0.33924561738967896, -0.044823914766311646, -0.3724825978279114, 0.16768677532672882, 0.23964428901672363, -0.2845441699028015, 0.13772062957286835, -0.08396769315004349, -0.6166038513183594, 0.2652672827243805, 0.37178048491477966, -0.21670325100421906, 0.012354375794529915, 0.2958662509918213, 0.4114125370979309, 0.16238893568515778, -0.6351292133331299, 0.6128404140472412, 0.12519049644470215, -0.0808715969324112, -0.611319363117218, -0.2267172783613205, -0.1151304766535759, 0.26305872201919556, 0.18097752332687378, -0.24800078570842743, 0.4288809299468994, -0.7920203804969788, 0.6677402853965759, 0.32058462500572205, -0.3572010099887848, -0.6454924941062927, 0.33748874068260193, 0.09494994580745697, -0.4227193593978882, 0.4670213460922241, -0.4230782687664032, -0.6824377775192261, 0.4490557312965393, 0.48689335584640503, 0.4453819692134857, -0.5385076999664307, 0.6380202770233154, 0.35687920451164246, 0.09776365011930466, 0.2657676041126251, 0.4060927629470825, 0.0917854979634285, -0.6289476752281189, 0.09496600180864334, -0.5317222476005554, -0.08733335882425308, 0.7218633890151978, -0.40350496768951416, 0.39389893412590027, -1.0592249631881714, -0.3250572085380554, 0.6238153576850891, -0.20855306088924408, -0.46838539838790894, 0.5422434210777283, 0.21116866171360016, 0.28669968247413635, -1.2879685163497925, 0.18626286089420319, 0.9379822611808777, -0.23023395240306854, -0.25017380714416504, -0.3739275336265564, 0.8556047677993774, -0.8785853981971741, 0.24417193233966827, 0.2820894718170166, 0.11634322255849838, -0.20828300714492798, -0.6303306221961975, -0.5206619501113892, 0.6263226270675659, -0.15201231837272644, -0.3220430314540863, 0.06352956593036652, 0.5003211498260498, 0.7516175508499146, -0.30624377727508545, 0.11388762295246124, 0.8556991815567017, 0.4509180784225464, -0.07436162233352661, -0.6495774984359741, 0.12699666619300842, -0.3329043388366699, -0.017134737223386765, 0.2860944867134094, -0.7405980229377747, 0.525894045829773, 0.3255882263183594, -0.03845958039164543, -0.5856025218963623, 0.3351152539253235, 0.417481929063797, 0.5088775753974915, 0.4837237596511841, 0.43792715668678284, 0.27811866998672485, -0.036830343306064606, 0.5136016011238098, -0.05374244973063469, -0.05672430992126465, 1.0886918306350708, 0.03573812544345856, 0.28404563665390015, 0.05919360741972923, -0.3737851083278656, 0.3962492048740387, 0.8357735872268677, -0.19496996700763702, 0.39640337228775024, 0.15575669705867767, -0.3496939241886139, -0.41556790471076965, -0.5757731795310974, 0.15516534447669983, 0.5809181332588196, 0.4632498323917389, -0.3076780438423157, -0.35589155554771423, 0.172365203499794, 0.3351239860057831, 0.05229270085692406, -0.31691983342170715, 0.8586758375167847, -0.027621790766716003, -0.14161992073059082, 0.014045528136193752, -0.0846182107925415, 0.5124501585960388, -0.2672971487045288, -0.1589287370443344, -0.01701914705336094, 0.05961603298783302, -0.48129701614379883, -1.0981388092041016, 0.3337332010269165, 0.15097308158874512, 0.00730445422232151, -0.2452281266450882, 1.0261447429656982, -0.44922930002212524, -0.5234656929969788, 0.22979366779327393, 0.38041555881500244, 0.3109065294265747, -0.12774400413036346, -0.8085904121398926, -0.034593816846609116, -0.037490472197532654, -0.11569463461637497, 0.6483154892921448, 0.48964551091194153, -0.2333686798810959, 0.44131240248680115, 0.6187713742256165, 0.12052053213119507, -0.03664678335189819, -0.01583009585738182, 0.8887695074081421, -0.36625853180885315, -0.24321427941322327, -0.5631020665168762, 0.6899141669273376, -0.7273210287094116, -0.29245397448539734, 0.4787043631076813, 0.5573882460594177, 0.9049065113067627, 0.40472087264060974, 0.8886242508888245, -0.6145361065864563, 0.7846344113349915, 0.04746122285723686, 0.29053834080696106, -0.3231852948665619, -0.1453985869884491, -0.3641226291656494, -0.9364842772483826, -0.08683115243911743, 0.5394859910011292, 0.034685343503952026, 0.3081985414028168, 0.3235546946525574, 0.7128293514251709, -0.3453451097011566, 0.2382599413394928, -0.00339217740111053, 0.37895628809928894, 0.2909034490585327, 0.059112004935741425, 0.458584189414978, -0.4812871813774109, 0.5021309852600098, -0.6718590259552002, -0.5483428239822388, -0.12232587486505508, -0.5764012932777405, -1.1325125694274902, -0.5650218725204468, -0.3313778042793274, -0.37548983097076416, 0.23176351189613342, 0.7374563217163086, 0.5081806778907776, -0.9445619583129883, 0.0010656892554834485, 0.201931893825531, -0.22882433235645294, -0.09474918991327286, -0.3193413317203522, -0.11973754316568375, -0.04856310039758682, -0.4161359965801239, 0.43404364585876465, -0.014614720828831196, -0.0034901252947747707, -0.35724693536758423, 0.3958054482936859, -0.458025723695755, 0.09074077010154724, 0.8901870250701904, 0.33022835850715637, 0.10702138394117355, -0.33094775676727295, -0.24210906028747559, 0.1955975592136383, -0.1485283523797989, 0.5703750848770142, -0.707756519317627, 0.5760148763656616, 0.4770693778991699, 0.5065813660621643, 0.41513144969940186, 0.10932445526123047, 0.5365163683891296, -1.2807011604309082, -0.18394766747951508, 0.1629355102777481, 0.08912979811429977, 0.3345414400100708, -0.3183419704437256, 0.3531237244606018, 0.7045036554336548, -0.23285414278507233, -1.0274790525436401, 0.07047843933105469, -0.5890486836433411, -0.378553569316864, 0.8605124354362488, 0.05914301797747612, -0.2504701614379883, -0.5010834336280823, -0.05020132660865784, 0.4381459355354309, -0.6308827996253967, 1.1092897653579712, 0.6327385306358337, -0.17344988882541656, -0.013196224346756935, -0.3436974585056305, 0.44362810254096985, -0.05855005234479904, -0.8521329760551453, 0.1880270540714264, 0.7409396767616272, 0.14951209723949432, 0.12841881811618805, 0.15378490090370178, -0.07007672637701035, 0.2294047772884369, 0.034390050917863846, -0.11236351728439331, -0.08302409201860428, -1.0332822799682617, -0.0703669935464859, 0.18791060149669647, -0.9980846047401428, 0.23116061091423035 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06529v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06529v3	Introspective Planning: Aligning Robots' Uncertainty with Inherent Task Ambiguity	2024-02-09T16:40:59	2024-06-04T02:25:30	Kaiqu Liang, Zixu Zhang, Jaime Fernández Fisac	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG	Large language models (LLMs) exhibit advanced reasoning skills, enabling robots to comprehend natural language instructions and strategically plan high-level actions through proper grounding. However, LLM hallucination may result in robots confidently executing plans that are misaligned with user goals or, in extreme cases, unsafe. Additionally, inherent ambiguity in natural language instructions can induce task uncertainty, particularly in situations where multiple valid options exist. To address this issue, LLMs must identify such uncertainty and proactively seek clarification. This paper explores the concept of introspective planning as a systematic method for guiding LLMs in forming uncertainty--aware plans for robotic task execution without the need for fine-tuning. We investigate uncertainty quantification in task-level robot planning and demonstrate that introspection significantly improves both success rates and safety compared to state-of-the-art LLM-based planning approaches. Furthermore, we assess the effectiveness of introspective planning in conjunction with conformal prediction, revealing that this combination yields tighter confidence bounds, thereby maintaining statistical success guarantees with fewer superfluous user clarification queries. Code is available at https://github.com/kevinliang888/IntroPlan.	[ -0.2054109275341034, -0.9203458428382874, 0.9327394962310791, -0.12113174051046371, -0.0036226490046828985, 0.012329374440014362, -0.2775464355945587, -0.3465876579284668, 0.33357366919517517, 0.5495326519012451, -1.0293458700180054, -0.31438037753105164, -0.7783629894256592, -0.10675664991140366, 0.032641373574733734, 0.5792135000228882, -0.12768377363681793, -0.25720056891441345, 0.1673905849456787, 0.06151134893298149, -0.4376034736633301, 0.01950027234852314, -0.1661272943019867, -0.20402255654335022, 0.4183230996131897, 0.7348768711090088, 1.0450963973999023, 0.7530132532119751, 0.6519246697425842, 0.2979333698749542, -0.2593909204006195, 0.5809766054153442, -0.10823963582515717, 0.48261758685112, -0.25946369767189026, -0.6175498962402344, -0.2489735633134842, -0.7046849727630615, 0.20020830631256104, 1.0977280139923096, -0.0962071418762207, 0.1349882185459137, 0.06952648609876633, 0.7756977081298828, -1.0723145008087158, -0.004548875615000725, -0.7450238466262817, 0.38911277055740356, 0.1925140768289566, -0.01929589733481407, -0.20869728922843933, -0.11924455314874649, 0.25646907091140747, -0.7280358076095581, -0.10085819661617279, -0.17239291965961456, 0.5186387300491333, 0.8453060984611511, -0.13257671892642975, -0.44896748661994934, -1.3047630786895752, 0.41642695665359497, -0.5898874402046204, 0.2625187337398529, 0.21804781258106232, 0.1944083422422409, -0.5626710653305054, -0.5265335440635681, -0.7207822799682617, 0.15033572912216187, -0.12021293491125107, 0.10129684209823608, -0.29915016889572144, 0.4699680209159851, 0.31287023425102234, -0.2227177917957306, -0.8165495991706848, 0.21141399443149567, -0.4804570972919464, -0.01217318419367075, 0.5276150703430176, 0.08776033669710159, -0.19362646341323853, -0.004268847405910492, -0.41804543137550354, -0.09923572093248367, -0.44726523756980896, 0.23125696182250977, 0.48041415214538574, 0.5324063897132874, 0.06846429407596588, 0.9547799825668335, -0.6204029321670532, 0.7921106815338135, 0.05519381910562515, -0.05065973848104477, -0.010727640241384506, -0.21356938779354095, -0.2507401406764984, -0.20033954083919525, 0.6488487124443054, 0.26071158051490784, 0.3971560299396515, -0.01597324013710022, -0.28934696316719055, -0.10654386132955551, 0.5611512064933777, -0.22151651978492737, -0.39130303263664246, 0.9267412424087524, -0.20962238311767578, 0.25952354073524475, 0.06845330446958542, -0.4789477288722992, -0.43692588806152344, -0.5634427666664124, 0.6209184527397156, -0.4577488601207733, 0.028084052726626396, 0.46011072397232056, -0.028918080031871796, -0.20068523287773132, 0.5755906105041504, -0.5540231466293335, 0.15832169353961945, 0.7197664380073547, 0.6096190214157104, 0.19183006882667542, -0.19865024089813232, -0.23507347702980042, 0.6060977578163147, -0.30082300305366516, 0.7381547689437866, -0.14275048673152924, -0.39532506465911865, 0.1802169382572174, -0.15317758917808533, 0.0776120200753212, -0.4074617922306061, 0.5853831171989441, -0.2135223001241684, 0.1252809315919876, 0.09939213842153549, -0.42722898721694946, -0.45246368646621704, 0.3268081843852997, -0.6357333660125732, 0.6940263509750366, 0.1821269541978836, -0.29426273703575134, 0.42171552777290344, -0.5193003416061401, -0.36053773760795593, 0.1603725105524063, -0.23509299755096436, -0.2054303139448166, -0.24636857211589813, 0.26187947392463684, 0.7172673344612122, 0.34488242864608765, 0.14555519819259644, -0.0379466786980629, -0.1607850342988968, 0.12228068709373474, 0.15752796828746796, 0.5534851551055908, 0.34645774960517883, -0.31502437591552734, 0.46148183941841125, -0.3685150742530823, 0.28872841596603394, -0.14645089209079742, 0.21561267971992493, 0.0018751603784039617, 0.1861511617898941, -0.5226776003837585, 0.22951486706733704, 0.5854036808013916, -0.11867170035839081, 0.032131459563970566, -0.7486520409584045, -0.04797183349728584, 0.7064852714538574, 0.06619452685117722, 0.8099373579025269, -0.3621714115142822, 0.7048105001449585, -0.4075371026992798, 0.40254515409469604, -0.18244192004203796, -0.39140817523002625, -0.5436246991157532, 0.04024790972471237, -0.21300223469734192, 0.7660255432128906, -0.38864871859550476, 0.984529972076416, -0.05525033921003342, -0.5082746148109436, -0.2527769207954407, 0.14289245009422302, 0.28219521045684814, 0.2911089360713959, 0.3573131561279297, -0.013393262401223183, -0.5647141337394714, -0.942071259021759, -0.002438744530081749, -0.38312092423439026, -0.34641650319099426, -0.035526007413864136, 0.34023523330688477, -0.1613786816596985, 0.8733780384063721, -0.7847185134887695, -0.46368643641471863, -0.5022833943367004, 0.1227676123380661, 0.19586658477783203, 0.45846912264823914, 0.004622300621122122, -0.9205365180969238, -0.29761216044425964, -0.01191659178584814, -0.3778645694255829, 0.34431368112564087, -0.4190877079963684, -0.24104945361614227, -0.06044304370880127, 0.5107719302177429, -0.8772178292274475, 0.48804333806037903, 0.38248032331466675, 0.08092337846755981, 0.3347061574459076, -0.3231191635131836, -0.41166722774505615, -0.7266442179679871, -0.1253252476453781, -0.04307636246085167, 0.031815916299819946, -0.6615408658981323, 0.24411042034626007, -0.038793958723545074, 0.3268975615501404, -0.273942232131958, 0.20502802729606628, -0.572582483291626, 0.031538624316453934, -0.4640091061592102, 0.36623111367225647, -0.1180466040968895, 0.45563164353370667, 0.26676061749458313, 0.35718926787376404, 0.20455871522426605, -0.7570304870605469, -0.11086485534906387, 0.4086475074291229, -0.17780527472496033, 0.21277408301830292, -0.5272146463394165, -0.008937579579651356, -0.13000762462615967, 0.2607018053531647, -0.9967119097709656, -0.3897118866443634, 0.7916855216026306, -0.5258389115333557, 0.37835392355918884, -0.02996312640607357, -0.17214855551719666, -0.4056890308856964, -0.0698583573102951, 0.16813243925571442, 0.41752323508262634, 0.05001118406653404, 0.7400655150413513, 0.4425099194049835, -0.2912488281726837, -0.9225730299949646, -0.40845203399658203, -0.17816029489040375, -0.10187965631484985, -0.4897861182689667, 0.26290324330329895, -0.03146277368068695, -0.4246208965778351, -0.1076318621635437, -0.3515351116657257, -0.08096807450056076, 0.1330573707818985, 0.37510889768600464, 0.24307222664356232, 0.1907627135515213, -0.0870867520570755, -0.011678303591907024, -0.07946944981813431, 0.23890338838100433, -0.12283298373222351, 0.620146632194519, 0.301457941532135, -0.4715930223464966, -0.35372430086135864, 0.16302695870399475, -0.01923459582030773, 0.0026506255380809307, 0.312592089176178, 0.4570992588996887, -0.515998363494873, -0.33592844009399414, -0.31390899419784546, -0.26783260703086853, -0.5041567087173462, 0.3156481087207794, -0.3032730519771576, -0.613612711429596, 0.3785827159881592, -0.33166608214378357, 0.25161367654800415, 0.26765188574790955, 0.25729820132255554, -0.6209482550621033, 0.6871970295906067, 0.9366007447242737, 0.4615943133831024, 0.23850038647651672, -0.2094268500804901, 0.2170667201280594, -0.8495266437530518, -0.3587227761745453, -0.5956682562828064, -0.6246617436408997, -0.5960831046104431, -0.7551674842834473, 0.5374740958213806, -0.18299371004104614, -0.29150962829589844, 0.43941497802734375, -0.7683638334274292, 0.4211864173412323, 0.4883648455142975, 0.3172356188297272, 0.05069202184677124, -0.41304096579551697, 0.36481159925460815, 0.15131068229675293, -0.4911894202232361, -0.884816586971283, 1.121825933456421, 0.1293611228466034, 0.5176615715026855, -0.05900539457798004, 0.6114789247512817, -0.0060114627704024315, -0.567118227481842, -0.7911574244499207, 0.5223194360733032, 0.2940199077129364, -0.5449650883674622, -0.9283414483070374, 0.06713495403528214, -1.1095441579818726, 0.2773407995700836, -0.1883687824010849, -1.0304756164550781, 0.355867475271225, 0.10273704677820206, -0.8426242470741272, 0.2568180561065674, -0.45700645446777344, 0.48811420798301697, -0.23335658013820648, -0.04631742462515831, -0.14788341522216797, -1.4516048431396484, 0.25726810097694397, -0.03855196014046669, 0.25809967517852783, -0.4625055491924286, -0.4581599831581116, 0.3393618166446686, -0.028554048389196396, 0.9199922680854797, -0.18575625121593475, -0.15619507431983948, 0.31096798181533813, 0.34462711215019226, 1.0342822074890137, -0.20026712119579315, 0.055088721215724945, -0.022991683334112167, -0.2587180733680725, -0.17618829011917114, -0.6087527871131897, -0.0036053659860044718, -0.3207259178161621, -0.6513211131095886, -0.16372466087341309, -0.894731879234314, -0.33830979466438293, 0.02970987930893898, 0.27519530057907104, -0.3817470967769623, -0.20196837186813354, -0.16161055862903595, 0.9039477705955505, -0.10043416917324066, 0.3094100058078766, 0.39710089564323425, 0.036479830741882324, 0.1551743894815445, 0.2772306799888611, -0.013109293766319752, 0.5250635743141174, 0.7952529788017273, 0.05956663936376572, -0.1097736731171608, -0.9105905890464783, -0.2321825623512268, -0.18358048796653748, -0.6246806979179382, -0.25676852464675903, -0.7411102652549744, -0.14923299849033356, -0.30273255705833435, -0.6112231612205505, -0.3421054482460022, -0.6959323287010193, -0.07674464583396912, -0.1178397685289383, 0.012196546420454979, 0.7538899779319763, -0.3670283854007721, 0.7789081931114197, -0.4489198625087738, 0.4821211099624634, -0.16663509607315063, -0.27997326850891113, -0.41802823543548584, -0.4283806383609772, -0.14818719029426575, 0.3623077869415283, -0.29893678426742554, -0.64280766248703, 0.4165154695510864, -0.18620078265666962, 0.6131661534309387, 0.5832645893096924, 0.48163989186286926, 0.7797899842262268, -0.41896718740463257, 0.5985342264175415, -0.04147933050990105, -0.5380171537399292, 0.9553102850914001, -0.15213589370250702, 0.4031843841075897, 0.7083156704902649, 0.684935986995697, -0.1862439662218094, -0.7645635604858398, -0.7311750650405884, -1.1362323760986328, 0.5552923083305359, 0.15810737013816833, -0.01921042427420616, 0.45579835772514343, 0.2207026481628418, 0.4019247889518738, 0.24803337454795837, -0.6367843747138977, -0.15466222167015076, 0.3634648025035858, -0.20974180102348328, 0.07547181099653244, -0.20076672732830048, -0.5033761262893677, -0.07051490992307663, 0.2255840003490448, -0.20431865751743317, 0.293632835149765, 0.04263511300086975, -0.01837656833231449, -0.41542914509773254, 0.1277104616165161, 0.6935363411903381, 0.7469374537467957, -0.4008885622024536, 0.14601734280586243, 0.28015294671058655, -0.38268160820007324, 0.012706991285085678, 0.018474070355296135, -0.12968404591083527, -0.11895085126161575, 0.4341703951358795, 0.10317299515008926, 0.04812666028738022, -0.9051116704940796, 0.2551284432411194, 0.3427044153213501, -0.0014343579532578588, -0.6942555904388428, 0.3140847384929657, -0.08712036907672882, 0.4489661455154419, 0.23026497662067413, 0.33639127016067505, 0.3516927659511566, -0.2396315187215805, 0.13110806047916412, 0.48062315583229065, -0.38286590576171875, -0.09039727598428726, 0.4255748987197876, -0.061144109815359116, -0.26368898153305054, 0.3280293643474579, -0.19162869453430176, -0.3897257149219513, 0.8351308107376099, 0.1757761687040329, 0.9529231190681458, -0.2956496477127075, 0.28781723976135254, 0.4740263521671295, 0.8375652432441711, 0.12607534229755402, 0.4927426874637604, -0.2026529461145401, -0.9304491281509399, -0.3835327625274658, -0.25913602113723755, -0.6319814920425415, -0.3979475200176239, -0.48089662194252014, 0.18360181152820587, -0.5074416995048523, 0.06394854187965393, -0.2216096967458725, -0.1825011670589447, -0.5182868242263794, 0.3763124644756317, -0.01770760305225849, 0.5236138701438904, -0.44528505206108093, 0.4179155230522156, 0.6605608463287354, -0.14656144380569458, -0.9399417638778687, 0.4454314112663269, 0.19127246737480164, -1.0472252368927002, 0.49981236457824707, -0.01028402615338564, -0.47930121421813965, -0.5014916658401489, -0.626657247543335, -1.0879508256912231, 1.0203710794448853, 0.03836370259523392, -0.7296404838562012, -0.1790943294763565, 0.3492639660835266, 0.22289824485778809, -0.1574258804321289, 0.05225431174039841, 0.2822641432285309, 0.7730473279953003, 0.22802278399467468, -0.7555205821990967, 0.12628887593746185, 0.23010818660259247, -0.3490389287471771, 0.49660006165504456, -0.3819706439971924, 0.6593173742294312, -0.7423635125160217, -0.3933941423892975, 0.11810551583766937, 0.706584095954895, 0.08443809300661087, 0.40388646721839905, 0.6013672351837158, 0.3067080080509186, 1.0025619268417358, -0.10216065496206284, 0.6818010210990906, -0.281130313873291, -0.42210912704467773, 1.5078909397125244, -0.47395047545433044, 0.8133654594421387, 0.49303996562957764, -0.19743479788303375, 0.3381403088569641, 0.5070668458938599, 0.25220978260040283, 0.525875985622406, -0.022142969071865082, -0.025537589564919472, -0.16873331367969513, 0.015335210599005222, -0.10952969640493393, 0.5509601831436157, 0.6283645629882812, 0.04414070025086403, 0.02410629764199257, -0.14987410604953766, 0.06714429706335068, 0.3656950891017914, -0.0759219080209732, 0.7959988713264465, -0.20497001707553864, -0.6904405355453491, -0.07769843190908432, -0.2291535884141922, 0.4434490501880646, -0.6910742521286011, 0.12945161759853363, 0.17801207304000854, 0.11442123353481293, -0.26480987668037415, -1.3901665210723877, 0.5007413625717163, -0.4525887370109558, 0.09097582846879959, -0.2925150990486145, 0.6164782643318176, -0.196769118309021, -0.07743201404809952, 0.011673708446323872, 0.6869269013404846, -0.0022517063189297915, -0.2920646667480469, -0.5499904751777649, -0.13610030710697174, 0.12282595038414001, -0.16670621931552887, 0.029214175418019295, 0.8734331130981445, 0.24119797348976135, 0.9535259008407593, 0.31034213304519653, 0.035853009670972824, -0.23559264838695526, -0.5345049500465393, 0.6189073920249939, -0.5237832069396973, -0.28144538402557373, -0.6404023170471191, 0.7431063055992126, 0.15970495343208313, -0.5262423157691956, 0.5193951725959778, 0.5820688009262085, 1.0552185773849487, -0.09263341873884201, 0.48460525274276733, -0.07468388229608536, 0.47158777713775635, -0.6643667817115784, 0.026617493480443954, -0.282956600189209, 0.2322477400302887, -0.17376287281513214, -0.6807165741920471, -0.3337084650993347, 0.7722781300544739, -0.1399795413017273, -0.15409186482429504, 0.5531295537948608, 0.6580532789230347, 0.2558212876319885, -0.13391071557998657, 0.20118021965026855, -0.11562568694353104, 0.009191668592393398, 0.6251672506332397, 0.9512103199958801, 0.07400013506412506, 0.48623958230018616, -0.7104470133781433, -0.032829828560352325, -0.1893264651298523, -0.6110369563102722, -0.34149694442749023, -0.764630913734436, -0.16813166439533234, 0.1297602504491806, 0.12719304859638214, 1.1356149911880493, 0.6665686964988708, -0.3978115916252136, -0.4627404808998108, -0.1435801386833191, 0.3265606164932251, -0.3145371675491333, -0.1419483721256256, 0.18333721160888672, -0.4860422909259796, -0.7352332472801208, 0.4881649315357208, 0.2197134792804718, 0.15049323439598083, -0.18461371958255768, -0.19289028644561768, -0.29879143834114075, 0.04822984337806702, 0.3030428886413574, 0.396396666765213, -0.8237848877906799, -0.15842336416244507, 0.10294695198535919, -0.0029023364186286926, -0.0028493928257375956, 0.5989115238189697, -0.666262149810791, 0.413885235786438, 0.10532362759113312, 0.20167432725429535, 0.3889583647251129, 0.11053258180618286, 0.7700287699699402, -0.8000187277793884, 0.43311718106269836, 0.793210506439209, 0.209279403090477, -0.07757623493671417, -0.8187587261199951, 1.022204875946045, -0.607927680015564, -0.7186673283576965, -0.623261034488678, 0.48810532689094543, -1.3053910732269287, -0.6298233866691589, 1.0822802782058716, 0.19753992557525635, 0.003719414584338665, -0.22586819529533386, -0.3298022150993347, 0.2540537416934967, -0.1499205380678177, 0.7614888548851013, 0.41036707162857056, -0.6153520345687866, 0.05187944322824478, -0.6153163313865662, 0.5502428412437439, 0.3282180428504944, -0.575799286365509, 0.1600838005542755, 0.6276305317878723, -0.42597857117652893, 0.3450208604335785, 0.3565821647644043, 0.37289032340049744, 0.27397236227989197, -0.05909191444516182, 0.3049086630344391, 0.27495133876800537, -0.6482198238372803, -0.006725276820361614, 0.29613375663757324, 0.1507304459810257, -0.32606297731399536 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06512v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06512v3	Multimodal Clinical Trial Outcome Prediction with Large Language Models	2024-02-09T16:18:38	2024-05-09T01:22:35	Wenhao Zheng, Dongsheng Peng, Hongxia Xu, Yun Li, Hongtu Zhu, Tianfan Fu, Huaxiu Yao	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.CL	The clinical trial is a pivotal and costly process, often spanning multiple years and requiring substantial financial resources. Therefore, the development of clinical trial outcome prediction models aims to exclude drugs likely to fail and holds the potential for significant cost savings. Recent data-driven attempts leverage deep learning methods to integrate multimodal data for predicting clinical trial outcomes. However, these approaches rely on manually designed modal-specific encoders, which limits both the extensibility to adapt new modalities and the ability to discern similar information patterns across different modalities. To address these issues, we propose a multimodal mixture-of-experts (LIFTED) approach for clinical trial outcome prediction. Specifically, LIFTED unifies different modality data by transforming them into natural language descriptions. Then, LIFTED constructs unified noise-resilient encoders to extract information from modal-specific language descriptions. Subsequently, a sparse Mixture-of-Experts framework is employed to further refine the representations, enabling LIFTED to identify similar information patterns across different modalities and extract more consistent representations from those patterns using the same expert model. Finally, a mixture-of-experts module is further employed to dynamically integrate different modality representations for prediction, which gives LIFTED the ability to automatically weigh different modalities and pay more attention to critical information. The experiments demonstrate that LIFTED significantly enhances performance in predicting clinical trial outcomes across all three phases compared to the best baseline, showcasing the effectiveness of our proposed key components.	[ -0.1712324470281601, -0.5611284375190735, 0.639045774936676, 0.24075229465961456, -0.27819645404815674, 0.2913135588169098, -0.35607242584228516, -0.6166424751281738, 0.3904705047607422, 0.4606115221977234, -0.44280681014060974, -0.2510370910167694, -0.9735262989997864, 0.02499944530427456, -0.1624268889427185, 1.1262885332107544, -0.028455831110477448, 0.5346040725708008, -0.07597028464078903, 0.017456766217947006, -0.784516453742981, -0.1646806001663208, -0.14072765409946442, -0.3829036056995392, 0.7098361253738403, 0.13210129737854004, 0.6348764896392822, 0.33462077379226685, 0.5367698669433594, 0.268273264169693, 0.07213088870048523, 0.16294895112514496, -0.36954212188720703, 0.08230219036340714, 0.15956249833106995, -0.46248212456703186, -0.3604123294353485, 0.05572983995079994, 0.08213475346565247, 0.7388442754745483, -0.35669592022895813, -0.6466931104660034, -0.15658603608608246, 0.06488756090402603, -0.5565816760063171, 0.16288666427135468, -0.8000282049179077, 0.27629464864730835, 0.09221173822879791, -0.5830888152122498, -0.41548997163772583, -0.1515229493379593, 0.21978475153446198, -0.7082643508911133, 0.16763976216316223, 0.0019690245389938354, 0.36040833592414856, 0.12359048426151276, -0.8050525188446045, -0.3628731667995453, -0.43116793036460876, 0.7823415398597717, -0.9038006067276001, 0.23739774525165558, 0.44044873118400574, 0.5866093039512634, -0.4494834542274475, -0.5477487444877625, -0.5079926252365112, -0.4866068661212921, -0.25250840187072754, 0.4926302433013916, 0.3631218373775482, 0.3940214216709137, 0.06440061330795288, 0.33969610929489136, -0.3881395161151886, 0.16431798040866852, -0.5111215710639954, -0.222382590174675, 0.509559154510498, 0.29079127311706543, 0.16143281757831573, -0.21435704827308655, -0.6918553113937378, 0.16638068854808807, -0.3358643054962158, 0.008026335388422012, -0.25417715311050415, 0.560650646686554, -0.16264820098876953, 0.46593761444091797, -0.26519596576690674, 0.31290289759635925, 0.24541497230529785, -0.42955994606018066, 0.6414635181427002, -0.28222545981407166, -0.15494637191295624, 0.0894172191619873, 0.7550560235977173, 0.3800830841064453, -0.05463971942663193, -0.2596723735332489, -0.28059446811676025, -0.122397281229496, 0.3207049071788788, -0.8286063075065613, -0.2877964377403259, 0.3079392611980438, -0.6936651468276978, -0.46208375692367554, -0.03582925722002983, -0.8078627586364746, -0.9135227799415588, -0.3242296874523163, 0.6360833644866943, -0.7177168726921082, -0.5636072754859924, 0.3932454288005829, -0.19504114985466003, -0.3482176661491394, 0.7676745653152466, -0.5188601613044739, 0.18577782809734344, 0.5147938132286072, 0.5624807476997375, -0.20176222920417786, -0.07786775380373001, -0.7424707412719727, 0.2447439730167389, -0.019421914592385292, 0.53670334815979, -0.7544281482696533, -0.44206932187080383, 0.2235417515039444, -0.10011967271566391, -0.33290204405784607, -0.21965306997299194, 0.7120060920715332, -0.5231075286865234, 0.49512481689453125, -0.16449208557605743, -0.7653491497039795, -0.21402020752429962, 0.20760264992713928, -0.6999266743659973, 0.4525125026702881, -0.0439833365380764, -0.6396592855453491, 0.9397830963134766, -0.4151790738105774, -0.6736671924591064, 0.43942591547966003, -0.6042265892028809, -0.3985140323638916, 0.5928102135658264, 0.37987709045410156, 0.5060015916824341, -0.11779586225748062, 0.47485604882240295, -0.46106287837028503, -0.0894167348742485, 0.5157235264778137, -0.2471603900194168, 0.23926660418510437, 0.348472535610199, -0.2941353917121887, 0.0325566865503788, -0.8528362512588501, -0.13073043525218964, -0.3012164235115051, -0.45092031359672546, -0.31022071838378906, -0.07976740598678589, 0.476768434047699, 0.4320828318595886, -0.05395757034420967, -0.741635262966156, 0.05936349183320999, -0.1293686181306839, 0.21186481416225433, 0.7538480162620544, -0.10779313743114471, 0.21393094956874847, -0.08352918177843094, 0.5954937934875488, 0.3615581691265106, 0.2378462702035904, -0.04910045489668846, -0.6145516633987427, -0.22703759372234344, -0.5350300669670105, 0.3132607638835907, 0.13865531980991364, -1.0382649898529053, 0.27288222312927246, -0.5121500492095947, -0.29142460227012634, -0.3859843909740448, 0.04581732302904129, 0.6111868023872375, 0.4373210668563843, 0.3652174770832062, -0.5112737417221069, -0.34675925970077515, -1.0484882593154907, -0.18616828322410583, -0.01762169413268566, 0.09713941067457199, 0.1670456975698471, 0.6912782788276672, -0.13143402338027954, 0.6824966669082642, -0.6095253229141235, -0.5682262778282166, -0.2994692921638489, 0.5041475892066956, 0.21866384148597717, 0.6550875902175903, 0.2891020178794861, -1.0121732950210571, -0.13099877536296844, 0.2952934801578522, -0.5161232948303223, 0.22913514077663422, -0.3865267038345337, 0.19757454097270966, -0.30823713541030884, 0.28119078278541565, -0.5885031223297119, 0.45982569456100464, 0.3104351758956909, -0.362312376499176, 0.35209161043167114, -0.31321483850479126, 0.3508847951889038, -1.069783091545105, -0.14757920801639557, 0.15885891020298004, -0.0844029113650322, -0.6465345025062561, -0.2748236358165741, 0.2990526258945465, 0.09610255807638168, -0.17568795382976532, 0.3705301284790039, -0.3491106927394867, 0.12041804194450378, -0.19324366748332977, -0.31101536750793457, 0.006628124043345451, 0.31714776158332825, 0.39984703063964844, 0.484892338514328, 0.26170486211776733, -0.1894679069519043, -0.01603059470653534, 0.27104252576828003, -0.5981197953224182, 0.36448556184768677, -0.5610027313232422, -0.29931625723838806, -0.2241857498884201, 0.43845629692077637, -0.9545678496360779, -0.5899590253829956, -0.1744854897260666, -0.7392542362213135, 0.47865355014801025, -0.05737626552581787, -0.22778227925300598, -0.2612062394618988, -0.166777104139328, 0.3987468183040619, 0.15820814669132233, -0.003377791028469801, 0.890684962272644, 0.25463005900382996, -0.2918235659599304, -0.6590653657913208, -0.9491262435913086, 0.2722837030887604, 0.005948968697339296, -0.1996205747127533, 0.21607573330402374, -0.025532178580760956, 0.19030706584453583, 0.012102358974516392, 0.263179749250412, -0.19220919907093048, -0.10641082376241684, 0.457101047039032, 0.14994117617607117, -0.013853070326149464, 0.48072969913482666, 0.34596699476242065, -0.09178788214921951, -0.09637344628572464, 0.22727516293525696, 0.20799697935581207, 0.15563729405403137, -0.5957746505737305, -0.45189788937568665, 0.5812649726867676, 0.743855357170105, -0.20078130066394806, 0.8581607937812805, 0.8753621578216553, -0.523216724395752, 0.1677369773387909, -0.8826054930686951, -0.2522299289703369, -0.38286373019218445, 0.6237816214561462, -0.37376779317855835, -0.5845462083816528, 0.35873499512672424, 0.02065453492105007, -0.021006174385547638, 0.2194521427154541, 0.8587234616279602, -0.07776087522506714, 1.345861792564392, 0.3143196403980255, 0.04137565940618515, 0.46700072288513184, -0.1367751955986023, 0.012874593958258629, -0.6622335314750671, -0.5956530570983887, -0.038873083889484406, -0.5202919244766235, -0.08578985929489136, -0.6099773645401001, 0.7895890474319458, -0.2126062661409378, 0.12135197222232819, 0.13189296424388885, -0.32526102662086487, 0.10391190648078918, 0.34529921412467957, 0.3855845630168915, 0.36210164427757263, 0.1985628604888916, -0.1556106060743332, -0.30796852707862854, -0.44513580203056335, 0.06941591948270798, 1.2808893918991089, 0.3171515464782715, 0.7585367560386658, -0.09876058995723724, 0.4717720150947571, 0.37695759534835815, 0.5217970609664917, -0.5358134508132935, 0.21513709425926208, 0.09550941735506058, -0.818763792514801, 0.3234933316707611, -0.5385201573371887, -0.8747285604476929, 0.39728686213493347, -0.6859471201896667, -0.20577512681484222, 0.474357545375824, -0.3412112593650818, -0.7461788654327393, 0.022808069363236427, -0.5856882929801941, 0.4459969997406006, -0.4552636742591858, -0.1519210934638977, -0.5139302611351013, -0.7933648824691772, 0.35640349984169006, -0.08167282491922379, 0.6077498197555542, 0.015462533570826054, -0.2603644132614136, 0.6079642176628113, -0.25999972224235535, 0.9264159202575684, -0.23367615044116974, 0.14413118362426758, -0.20995169878005981, 0.0657089501619339, 0.30501648783683777, 0.19055013358592987, -0.0713934451341629, -0.19058921933174133, -0.0994081050157547, -0.4578772485256195, -0.5970696210861206, 0.7146925330162048, -0.8772687911987305, -0.023740729317069054, -0.24613094329833984, -0.9132653474807739, -0.40982088446617126, 0.0971352681517601, 0.023544365540146828, 0.8713940382003784, -0.02841924875974655, 0.19851592183113098, 0.3027329742908478, -0.41978833079338074, 0.14633984863758087, 0.7063209414482117, 0.07795220613479614, -1.0872695446014404, 0.662460446357727, -0.05594915524125099, 0.3297367990016937, 0.44813090562820435, 0.22111757099628448, -0.40897709131240845, -1.1237287521362305, -0.30970755219459534, -0.06279829889535904, -0.6668097376823425, -0.23876707255840302, -0.896390974521637, 0.25379735231399536, -0.4752102494239807, -0.1560586541891098, -0.29570499062538147, -0.47697940468788147, -0.07149974256753922, -0.2546657919883728, 0.32019537687301636, 0.6427454948425293, 0.014669586904346943, 0.3672153353691101, -0.8612325191497803, 0.2983953356742859, 0.07185762375593185, 0.27264633774757385, -0.118440642952919, -0.4911082088947296, -0.4715701639652252, 0.1500912457704544, -0.23464761674404144, -0.6274526715278625, 0.6872141361236572, 0.29124483466148376, 0.7354956865310669, 0.7362587451934814, 0.03050527535378933, 0.8083610534667969, -0.16663889586925507, 0.5195343494415283, 0.9032822251319885, -0.35707807540893555, 0.5382411479949951, -0.5620334148406982, -0.16517142951488495, 0.8521295189857483, 0.2416214644908905, -0.29757237434387207, -0.24577674269676208, -0.2910931706428528, -0.673470139503479, 0.534161388874054, 0.20291970670223236, -0.14235065877437592, -0.043238136917352676, 0.12870638072490692, 0.8542423844337463, 0.5689424872398376, -0.5836384296417236, 0.2443462610244751, -0.12441303580999374, -0.5433306097984314, -0.1691657453775406, -0.04875483363866806, -0.43643563985824585, -0.4531833529472351, 0.2484273463487625, -0.28726106882095337, 0.19367191195487976, 0.1821051985025406, -0.26171040534973145, -0.2657051384449005, 0.19947746396064758, 0.5954793691635132, 0.8031284213066101, -0.48550838232040405, 0.055573008954524994, 0.08460023999214172, -0.5736178159713745, -0.15135608613491058, 0.21057702600955963, 0.09066298604011536, -0.20191757380962372, 0.7797730565071106, 0.8330326676368713, 0.3387073278427124, -0.9789918661117554, 0.687249481678009, -0.1417352855205536, -0.24498821794986725, -0.35389047861099243, -0.3457551598548889, -0.18465441465377808, 0.20186424255371094, 0.6014057397842407, 0.3664761781692505, 0.35956278443336487, -0.4793287515640259, 0.33601000905036926, 0.3043239414691925, -0.7381232380867004, -0.35959935188293457, 0.8026283383369446, 0.472936749458313, 0.23961268365383148, 0.269522100687027, 0.18996642529964447, -0.4225873053073883, 0.6079356074333191, 0.23761695623397827, 0.8297296762466431, 0.09766590595245361, 0.09226813912391663, 0.04827546700835228, -0.008452709764242172, -0.06793245673179626, 0.21384510397911072, 0.4046018123626709, -0.6304287314414978, -0.5962855219841003, -0.44201213121414185, -0.20633427798748016, 0.06462463736534119, -0.570379376411438, 0.16353829205036163, -0.2950456738471985, -0.29495522379875183, 0.022350899875164032, 0.06753429770469666, -0.6993999481201172, 0.36843451857566833, 0.5110142827033997, 0.8832287788391113, -0.9816860556602478, 0.6126202940940857, 0.7637311816215515, -0.7572857141494751, -0.4313821494579315, -0.4517163932323456, 0.10825230926275253, -0.7377736568450928, 0.7412987947463989, 0.3269192576408386, 0.15968191623687744, -0.664351224899292, -0.24572615325450897, -0.6715376973152161, 1.1290370225906372, 0.19489972293376923, -0.380705863237381, 0.019051363691687584, 0.21743613481521606, 0.542841911315918, -0.6093448996543884, 0.83771151304245, 0.2811885476112366, 0.4549795389175415, 0.4090212285518646, -1.0466837882995605, 0.06593866646289825, -0.28610438108444214, -0.14387157559394836, -0.16036227345466614, -0.24023617804050446, 0.9589591026306152, -0.18895375728607178, 0.01693839207291603, 0.04536449536681175, 0.7313988208770752, 0.0939115658402443, 0.5574973225593567, 0.5951942205429077, 0.6343454718589783, 0.5896693468093872, 0.0912463441491127, 1.1335127353668213, -0.4286760985851288, 0.16849981248378754, 0.8782086372375488, -0.382040411233902, 0.5913802981376648, 0.4298952519893646, -0.20075637102127075, 0.5105552077293396, 0.43734458088874817, 0.2570168972015381, 0.8255996108055115, -0.2807134985923767, -0.11192218214273453, -0.6735645532608032, -0.19451333582401276, -0.7074112892150879, 0.275325745344162, 0.4664621949195862, -0.5911758542060852, -0.1988447606563568, 0.34465932846069336, -0.25855588912963867, -0.012690972536802292, -0.19227150082588196, 0.6882634162902832, 0.07851497083902359, -0.5376567244529724, 0.5198429822921753, -0.32510823011398315, 0.8080994486808777, -0.4882204532623291, 0.030946331098675728, 0.05982900783419609, 0.6626629829406738, -0.24233204126358032, -0.6656579375267029, -0.2891783118247986, -0.6512172222137451, -0.052484866231679916, -0.09098900109529495, 0.7049927711486816, -0.7612988948822021, -0.8468193411827087, 0.36642518639564514, 0.6084318161010742, -0.14288967847824097, -0.010148818604648113, -0.777176022529602, 0.10418092459440231, -0.2376757264137268, -0.3610856533050537, 0.7451785206794739, 0.48996633291244507, 0.19745586812496185, 0.8300875425338745, 0.5439577102661133, 0.36344850063323975, 0.1203734427690506, 0.13049423694610596, 1.3189313411712646, -0.3878377676010132, -0.4037531316280365, -0.44706809520721436, 0.5580905079841614, -0.28340205550193787, -0.4647682309150696, 0.4411238133907318, 0.6685829758644104, 0.2021457701921463, -0.2066420316696167, 0.9478340148925781, -0.07000011950731277, 0.6221031546592712, -0.386017769575119, 0.6735031604766846, -0.7338338494300842, 0.04659498855471611, -0.21540331840515137, -0.1416475623846054, -0.18047934770584106, 0.197017639875412, -0.44572216272354126, 0.08550569415092468, 0.49202340841293335, 0.6264250874519348, -0.10126791149377823, 0.14649245142936707, 0.2494802474975586, 0.3515315353870392, 0.6021734476089478, 0.8046326041221619, 0.6860062479972839, -0.33173805475234985, 0.5112141370773315, -0.34307029843330383, -0.40864285826683044, -0.46796977519989014, -0.6890493035316467, -0.8841853737831116, -0.4525281488895416, -0.2260097861289978, -0.09943164885044098, -0.047829192131757736, 1.249930500984192, 0.8095453381538391, -0.9812905788421631, 0.08200354129076004, 0.2332543581724167, -0.1935122013092041, -0.4340350925922394, -0.19248539209365845, 0.27787530422210693, -0.3390657305717468, -0.6104841232299805, 0.4806571900844574, 0.29069003462791443, -0.35433533787727356, -0.11882281303405762, -0.20615513622760773, -0.19928190112113953, -0.23965993523597717, 0.5235199928283691, -0.17000313103199005, -0.8618823289871216, -0.1063941940665245, -0.20711269974708557, -0.1585259735584259, -0.1079169362783432, 0.9336475729942322, -1.038424015045166, 0.8246011137962341, 0.5681073069572449, 0.6435871720314026, 0.29102933406829834, 0.05601711571216583, 0.9383578896522522, -0.42389410734176636, 0.20257066190242767, 0.6211817860603333, 0.5083412528038025, -0.003014069516211748, -0.2064012885093689, 0.3901868760585785, 0.3260824680328369, -0.3796231150627136, -0.72462397813797, 0.0436229445040226, -1.1716376543045044, -0.3091883659362793, 1.058103322982788, -0.1001054048538208, 0.10781243443489075, -0.492252916097641, -0.2510274350643158, 0.04180165380239487, -0.7683077454566956, 0.9820350408554077, 0.4073135554790497, 0.004542922135442495, -0.31356072425842285, -0.8284026980400085, 0.3806312382221222, 0.4679974615573883, -0.4688163697719574, -0.012762120924890041, 0.6700848937034607, 0.23237653076648712, 0.10892553627490997, 0.4922718107700348, -0.2910914123058319, 0.2061270922422409, -0.2521307170391083, 0.2701433002948761, -0.39851513504981995, -0.05812288448214531, -0.1683001071214676, 0.3855689465999603, -0.28512024879455566, 0.02158590406179428 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06509v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06509v1	Asking the Right Question at the Right Time: Human and Model Uncertainty Guidance to Ask Clarification Questions	2024-02-09T16:15:30	2024-02-09T16:15:30	Alberto Testoni, Raquel Fernández	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Clarification questions are an essential dialogue tool to signal misunderstanding, ambiguities, and under-specification in language use. While humans are able to resolve uncertainty by asking questions since childhood, modern dialogue systems struggle to generate effective questions. To make progress in this direction, in this work we take a collaborative dialogue task as a testbed and study how model uncertainty relates to human uncertainty -- an as yet under-explored problem. We show that model uncertainty does not mirror human clarification-seeking behavior, which suggests that using human clarification questions as supervision for deciding when to ask may not be the most effective way to resolve model uncertainty. To address this issue, we propose an approach to generating clarification questions based on model uncertainty estimation, compare it to several alternatives, and show that it leads to significant improvements in terms of task success. Our findings highlight the importance of equipping dialogue systems with the ability to assess their own uncertainty and exploit in interaction.	[ -0.5450102090835571, -1.107824444770813, 1.0037171840667725, -0.06341315060853958, -0.23752665519714355, -0.11024081707000732, -0.16946277022361755, -0.45893505215644836, -0.33016470074653625, 0.49842801690101624, -0.720925509929657, 0.0021494098473340273, -0.651096522808075, 0.05288904532790184, -0.10815133899450302, 0.46231701970100403, -0.01401862595230341, 0.025620141997933388, -0.36152979731559753, -0.15563029050827026, -0.5581806898117065, -0.4504326283931732, -0.6931049227714539, -0.199823260307312, 0.4666931629180908, 0.6769338846206665, 1.0121394395828247, 0.3967418372631073, 0.5239871144294739, 0.34234291315078735, -0.16545391082763672, 0.16732820868492126, -0.18178889155387878, 0.3287965953350067, -0.2931808531284332, -0.608657717704773, -0.10724036395549774, -0.019391098991036415, 0.21717490255832672, 1.1428489685058594, -0.26540741324424744, 0.4677961766719818, -0.13982190191745758, 0.27678045630455017, -0.748997151851654, -0.1250881403684616, -0.3612990975379944, -0.002743832068517804, 0.09823217988014221, -0.05681281164288521, -0.14920176565647125, -0.33434364199638367, 0.6856499910354614, -0.5837593078613281, 0.30889734625816345, 0.2748456597328186, 1.0244735479354858, 0.4558699429035187, -0.6717618703842163, -0.42284178733825684, -0.861033022403717, 0.718254804611206, -0.7172253727912903, 0.35167011618614197, 0.5236371755599976, 0.4250544011592865, -0.4087078869342804, -0.7106578350067139, -0.3915480375289917, -0.07074331492185593, 0.10024991631507874, -0.10681399703025818, 0.014379399828612804, 0.2286030501127243, 0.36955925822257996, 0.07754840701818466, -0.29283103346824646, -0.30553728342056274, -0.5137221217155457, -0.3386737108230591, 0.6365354061126709, 0.10162085294723511, 0.08719323575496674, -0.13761687278747559, -0.23999926447868347, -0.11122100800275803, -0.24963946640491486, 0.2520088255405426, 0.43910571932792664, 0.026827814057469368, 0.22561629116535187, 0.2052549570798874, -0.12625722587108612, 0.947115957736969, 0.4207976758480072, 0.2632274627685547, -0.3899143636226654, -0.3179803788661957, -0.0027617623563855886, -0.4143749177455902, 0.6677468419075012, 0.6286666393280029, 0.14163221418857574, 0.07009666413068771, -0.12444186955690384, -0.150059774518013, 0.4828781187534332, -0.4087110459804535, 0.09465045481920242, 0.39031046628952026, -0.061398640275001526, -0.24167583882808685, -0.029379628598690033, -0.777534544467926, -0.38173890113830566, -0.34758511185646057, 0.5498419404029846, 0.09537194669246674, -0.31602567434310913, 0.12284231185913086, -0.29797524213790894, 0.008874169550836086, 0.6482547521591187, -0.7382457852363586, 0.18663759529590607, 0.3948802053928375, 0.28335362672805786, 0.23307931423187256, 0.11596821993589401, -0.2554851770401001, -0.05415726453065872, -0.6151740550994873, 0.4399581551551819, -0.12657611072063446, -0.6826183795928955, -0.30190086364746094, -0.10896816849708557, -0.13096673786640167, -0.5284004807472229, 0.4950246810913086, -0.2822968661785126, 0.7320911884307861, -0.4156475067138672, -0.6009450554847717, -0.20112508535385132, 0.3331197500228882, -0.3500785231590271, 0.832539975643158, 0.11622434854507446, -0.8869971036911011, 0.2975975573062897, -0.5305993556976318, 0.02018555998802185, 0.13983698189258575, -0.2694275379180908, -0.3405141532421112, -0.04700744152069092, 0.3587851822376251, 0.3250539302825928, -0.4252479672431946, 0.6329183578491211, -0.3256758153438568, -0.2706632912158966, 0.5040441751480103, -0.47860345244407654, 0.5718863606452942, 0.3495345115661621, -0.2997146546840668, -0.019649729132652283, -0.31234878301620483, 0.3785330653190613, 0.05906496196985245, 0.035298485308885574, -0.07279150933027267, -0.016498427838087082, -0.4935094118118286, 0.10678254067897797, 0.5693259239196777, -0.25913766026496887, -0.07859917730093002, -0.2667853534221649, 0.5336349606513977, 0.5785565376281738, 0.44524988532066345, 0.43806394934654236, -0.4936082363128662, 0.6150119304656982, -0.20350991189479828, 0.5304490923881531, 0.25456348061561584, -0.8428352475166321, -0.7735954523086548, 0.4352722764015198, 0.192546546459198, 0.5365562438964844, -0.4158923029899597, 0.1273731142282486, 0.3199460804462433, -0.5307987928390503, -0.6082426309585571, 0.0052207279950380325, 0.38699114322662354, 0.6971358060836792, 0.17214788496494293, -0.32849064469337463, -0.5873630046844482, -0.9104386568069458, -0.12451410293579102, -0.6100746989250183, 0.1095745861530304, 0.32228830456733704, 0.5204133987426758, 0.03253420814871788, 1.367508053779602, -0.710660457611084, 0.47828295826911926, -0.42961061000823975, 0.6505732536315918, -0.18863999843597412, 0.45728763937950134, 0.15183526277542114, -1.198205828666687, -0.16701380908489227, -0.30017030239105225, -0.7268198728561401, -0.056104641407728195, -0.10932490974664688, -0.2145538181066513, -0.18273834884166718, 0.40259164571762085, -0.7646579742431641, 0.4808999300003052, 0.31622764468193054, -0.0004157497314736247, 0.5781484842300415, -0.41463959217071533, 0.1888047307729721, -1.0764561891555786, 0.1688607633113861, -0.3286716341972351, -0.4495241641998291, -0.8524250984191895, 0.01840810291469097, -0.1863478273153305, -0.08361218869686127, -0.3508720099925995, 0.3767026364803314, -0.20907451212406158, 0.043422579765319824, -0.17193718254566193, 0.2951243221759796, 0.29212644696235657, 0.4450948238372803, -0.03279320150613785, 0.6516685485839844, 0.30179086327552795, -0.6786718964576721, 0.3039332628250122, 0.10183640569448471, -0.22787293791770935, 0.5704267621040344, -0.7585541605949402, 0.4553983807563782, -0.18469077348709106, 0.14426174759864807, -0.6850852966308594, -0.49576321244239807, 0.5834236741065979, -0.5865878462791443, -0.014461587183177471, -0.01899782381951809, -0.13671457767486572, -0.6610840559005737, 0.2968236804008484, 0.3413567841053009, 0.44096386432647705, 0.020335493609309196, 0.40497347712516785, 0.2766011953353882, -0.3233337998390198, -0.8143093585968018, -0.28437376022338867, -0.07572303712368011, -0.283151239156723, -0.9488566517829895, -0.1089484691619873, -0.3999544382095337, -0.6538189053535461, -0.2896445095539093, -0.44527286291122437, -0.6099503636360168, 0.46760842204093933, 0.47435638308525085, 0.1601860225200653, 0.043093759566545486, 0.18481995165348053, -0.12996678054332733, -0.026990452781319618, 0.19724398851394653, 0.08498238772153854, 0.26932987570762634, -0.30964043736457825, -0.6271474361419678, -0.631938636302948, 0.529114305973053, 0.492918461561203, -0.09259168803691864, 0.14635054767131805, 0.5262677073478699, -0.3303639888763428, 0.12456531822681427, -0.8038599491119385, -0.4469185769557953, -0.5091159343719482, 0.08729077875614166, -0.11769247055053711, -0.9501644968986511, 0.5810238122940063, -0.10029953718185425, 0.03379271924495697, 0.09858908504247665, 0.31138095259666443, -0.5809339880943298, 1.432313084602356, 0.5184277296066284, 0.2628619372844696, 0.16323840618133545, 0.015324212610721588, 0.19751206040382385, -0.35988649725914, 0.10155215114355087, -0.5050238370895386, -0.004568957258015871, -0.08881714195013046, -0.47613343596458435, 0.23120729625225067, 0.3361454904079437, -0.09303874522447586, 0.2609274983406067, -0.40148037672042847, 0.09147018194198608, 0.8486809730529785, 0.13203367590904236, 0.18885430693626404, -0.762294352054596, -0.06758798658847809, -0.14927630126476288, -0.6590748429298401, -0.7883325219154358, 0.5243396162986755, 0.3010607063770294, 0.54108065366745, -0.07856720685958862, 0.6660638451576233, 0.1597626507282257, -0.14588311314582825, -0.4879208207130432, 0.5845412611961365, 0.7823622822761536, -1.1866042613983154, -0.516605794429779, -0.390872061252594, -0.9496247172355652, 0.38029125332832336, -0.04912388697266579, -0.820572555065155, 0.27776598930358887, 0.42375555634498596, -0.8399531841278076, 0.0024448202457278967, -0.8771060109138489, 0.9561111927032471, -0.1764637976884842, -0.2112395018339157, -0.06382375955581665, -1.2712610960006714, 0.08750388026237488, 0.007663446012884378, 0.4849098026752472, -0.30974626541137695, 0.2101631909608841, 0.6044250726699829, -0.6323027014732361, 0.9254133105278015, -0.19288480281829834, -0.1492573320865631, 0.9540215730667114, 0.12597990036010742, 0.40020254254341125, 0.14607879519462585, 0.22404246032238007, -0.37414348125457764, 0.245646134018898, -0.2749096155166626, -0.9986610412597656, 0.013507850468158722, -0.6286101937294006, -1.1605180501937866, -0.21153773367404938, -0.7130893468856812, -0.2445458471775055, 0.0874529778957367, 0.35943692922592163, 0.28629761934280396, 0.02853553555905819, -0.042401544749736786, 0.7320870161056519, 0.11526205390691757, 0.19214296340942383, 0.40437015891075134, -0.1731720119714737, -0.018837010487914085, 0.3635595738887787, 0.10856802016496658, 0.7952724695205688, -0.04064076021313667, 0.3160463571548462, -0.18563158810138702, -0.3405839800834656, -0.5635241270065308, 0.12021081149578094, -0.7164782285690308, 0.05054667219519615, -0.3223194181919098, 0.05601432919502258, -0.5691543221473694, -0.24577435851097107, -0.36427223682403564, -0.3780709207057953, -0.5096997022628784, -0.07887386530637741, 0.1739928424358368, 0.7900905609130859, -0.04473912715911865, 0.3219289183616638, -0.8722751140594482, 0.09314264357089996, 0.7320137023925781, -0.18034231662750244, -0.2799602448940277, -0.44207996129989624, -0.0707368478178978, 0.680833101272583, -0.6017030477523804, -1.1186017990112305, 0.24255141615867615, -0.07977382093667984, 0.5186881422996521, 0.40045541524887085, 0.4427657127380371, 0.9249498248100281, 0.08582071959972382, 1.1468162536621094, -0.1741885244846344, -1.0110903978347778, 0.7109951376914978, -0.3988083004951477, 0.37239328026771545, 0.5782216191291809, 0.34960460662841797, -0.6056220531463623, -0.5762802362442017, -0.9640812873840332, -0.6216510534286499, 0.5689903497695923, 0.36679378151893616, -0.10064487904310226, 0.21819716691970825, 0.4159315228462219, -0.24562175571918488, 0.3710942268371582, -0.38406065106391907, 0.09166255593299866, 0.04909840226173401, -0.04823615774512291, 0.30745381116867065, 0.0055717420764267445, -0.4795573651790619, -0.003437684616073966, 0.33462223410606384, -0.17646580934524536, 0.32140305638313293, 0.43091627955436707, 0.001356014865450561, -0.5004529356956482, 0.6199300289154053, 0.5999459028244019, 0.778539776802063, -0.45107749104499817, -0.1216607391834259, 0.7206498980522156, -0.023657210171222687, 0.02762792818248272, -0.21874362230300903, -0.059154536575078964, -0.03828326240181923, 0.14564178884029388, 0.747122585773468, 0.19614258408546448, -0.8555315732955933, 0.6696822643280029, -0.2654079794883728, -0.37535712122917175, -0.25088387727737427, 0.17438127100467682, 0.21603524684906006, 0.2615642547607422, 0.14562399685382843, 0.30013102293014526, 0.07737467437982559, -0.38509270548820496, 0.10504387319087982, 0.25222039222717285, -0.5587018728256226, -0.09194863587617874, 0.5140011310577393, 0.12084517627954483, -0.39189454913139343, 0.5908588171005249, -0.02942395582795143, -0.6228079199790955, 0.696543276309967, 0.23389865458011627, 0.3070503771305084, -0.1632317453622818, 0.2820994555950165, 0.19654417037963867, 0.0599801130592823, -0.33045175671577454, 0.5524187684059143, -0.3830927908420563, -0.7487486600875854, -0.324987530708313, -0.037652984261512756, -1.0257023572921753, -0.4422871172428131, -0.9477603435516357, 0.17557485401630402, -0.3912104368209839, -0.8105019927024841, -0.39144378900527954, -0.16861951351165771, -0.449747234582901, 0.5075647830963135, -0.09314239770174026, 0.6477167010307312, -0.52158522605896, 0.3385590612888336, 0.5266081690788269, -0.5614413022994995, -1.2105854749679565, -0.16665604710578918, -0.07180395722389221, -0.44303834438323975, 0.43347087502479553, -0.019276363775134087, -0.2347652167081833, -0.07755392789840698, -1.0805683135986328, -0.9871002435684204, 1.1067620515823364, 0.26885849237442017, -0.39523032307624817, -0.42040619254112244, 0.11314985901117325, 0.52605801820755, -0.03966265544295311, 0.4594905376434326, 0.3648519515991211, 0.6710105538368225, 0.40923503041267395, -1.0220474004745483, -0.24307912588119507, -0.024762429296970367, -0.1602838933467865, 0.2885355055332184, -0.5266390442848206, 0.7847134470939636, -0.5690403580665588, -0.34356269240379333, 0.3946007490158081, 0.6225595474243164, 0.015772579237818718, 0.5047726631164551, 0.7581841945648193, 0.34532108902931213, 1.0149763822555542, -0.28495875000953674, 0.9627124071121216, -0.1615593582391739, 0.34186258912086487, 1.3248347043991089, -0.16175882518291473, 0.755143940448761, 0.6465801000595093, 0.128165140748024, 0.3316236436367035, 0.8309758901596069, 0.36504796147346497, 0.16189397871494293, 0.18162770569324493, -0.2260236144065857, -0.7931279540061951, -0.2549801468849182, -0.3842662572860718, 0.23823457956314087, 0.7414351105690002, -0.24763602018356323, -0.09493359923362732, -0.037616658955812454, 0.002410203916952014, 0.014346485957503319, 0.14725704491138458, 0.7738226652145386, 0.20524680614471436, -1.1193228960037231, 0.3680071234703064, -0.12207864224910736, 0.1655135303735733, -0.5611578822135925, 0.2574167847633362, 0.0895557701587677, -0.11183924227952957, 0.138663649559021, -0.7249602675437927, 0.12185369431972504, -0.18151028454303741, -0.007281893398612738, -0.19033415615558624, 0.49496471881866455, -0.41569164395332336, -0.20976382493972778, -0.024094199761748314, 0.6190192103385925, 0.17793434858322144, -0.02224048599600792, -0.7611371874809265, -0.32327210903167725, 0.08922923356294632, -0.056435734033584595, -0.11618733406066895, 0.3893885016441345, -0.21988704800605774, 1.104041337966919, 0.4304251968860626, -0.0457749180495739, 0.21449273824691772, -0.18772494792938232, 0.5177484750747681, -0.4168301224708557, -0.14167797565460205, -0.45543211698532104, 0.6928761005401611, -0.11654147505760193, -0.6020873785018921, 0.5077853798866272, -0.18248730897903442, 0.6342741250991821, 0.13960348069667816, 0.7425111532211304, -0.22830677032470703, 0.7335641384124756, -0.07208675146102905, 0.3348551094532013, -0.4355085492134094, -0.04518606513738632, -0.17976228892803192, -0.5881544351577759, -0.2011546790599823, 0.7062121629714966, -0.483175665140152, -0.04441036656498909, 0.6487930417060852, 0.9656351804733276, 0.3182460367679596, 0.47956928610801697, 0.2158244550228119, -0.16047005355358124, 0.3329053521156311, 0.3913905918598175, 1.1417326927185059, -0.38142716884613037, 0.5849329233169556, -0.4736315906047821, 0.22810032963752747, -0.17586667835712433, -0.8038808107376099, -0.49292266368865967, -0.6871461868286133, -0.31264448165893555, -0.20672418177127838, 0.3390924334526062, 1.4520034790039062, 0.9428116083145142, -0.4807928800582886, -0.2861867845058441, -0.12254250049591064, 0.2506648302078247, -0.15135838091373444, -0.15934708714485168, -0.06825046986341476, -0.3735654354095459, -0.8145956993103027, 0.2873198091983795, -0.16676001250743866, 0.48486578464508057, -0.17959657311439514, -0.15922433137893677, -0.3159460425376892, 0.1349937617778778, -0.17697961628437042, 0.3243712782859802, -0.7191851139068604, -0.5801160931587219, 0.11211919784545898, -0.3107694089412689, -0.12015626579523087, 0.699667751789093, -0.2916077673435211, 0.7942747473716736, 0.5586728453636169, 0.4542577862739563, 0.1339070200920105, 0.44679975509643555, 1.206754207611084, -0.8667865991592407, -0.053469084203243256, 0.44365745782852173, 0.34488725662231445, 0.42550691962242126, -0.3819239139556885, 0.2838277220726013, 0.11422105878591537, -0.9524151086807251, -0.5414746999740601, 0.3966939151287079, -0.7662200927734375, -0.07064491510391235, 0.7632879018783569, -0.3172531723976135, -0.15363046526908875, -0.5632950067520142, -0.7590389251708984, 0.34975218772888184, -0.48958367109298706, 0.6807203888893127, 1.0881013870239258, -0.1424141824245453, -0.18066588044166565, -0.4253822863101959, 0.4440237581729889, 0.9648061990737915, -0.4030386805534363, -0.017155343666672707, 0.36101865768432617, 0.03824577108025551, 0.36876755952835083, 0.4740909934043884, 0.3533712327480316, 0.3917712867259979, -0.1635981649160385, -0.13547737896442413, 0.3070334196090698, -0.14192000031471252, 0.1378403902053833, 0.1500222533941269, 0.4331895112991333, -0.13677342236042023 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06501v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06501v2	Scalable Interactive Machine Learning for Future Command and Control	2024-02-09T16:11:04	2024-03-28T15:17:01	Anna Madison, Ellen Novoseller, Vinicius G. Goecks, Benjamin T. Files, Nicholas Waytowich, Alfred Yu, Vernon J. Lawhern, Steven Thurman, Christopher Kelshaw, Kaleb McDowell	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7	Future warfare will require Command and Control (C2) personnel to make decisions at shrinking timescales in complex and potentially ill-defined situations. Given the need for robust decision-making processes and decision-support tools, integration of artificial and human intelligence holds the potential to revolutionize the C2 operations process to ensure adaptability and efficiency in rapidly changing operational environments. We propose to leverage recent promising breakthroughs in interactive machine learning, in which humans can cooperate with machine learning algorithms to guide machine learning algorithm behavior. This paper identifies several gaps in state-of-the-art science and technology that future work should address to extend these approaches to function in complex C2 contexts. In particular, we describe three research focus areas that together, aim to enable scalable interactive machine learning (SIML): 1) developing human-AI interaction algorithms to enable planning in complex, dynamic situations; 2) fostering resilient human-AI teams through optimizing roles, configurations, and trust; and 3) scaling algorithms and human-AI teams for flexibility across a range of potential contexts and situations.	[ -0.7357242703437805, -0.8629253506660461, 0.680839478969574, 0.49899810552597046, 0.4000774323940277, 0.5842541456222534, -0.04858948662877083, -0.5504100918769836, -0.04776415973901749, 0.2990413308143616, -0.9323642253875732, -0.05388952046632767, -0.6537346243858337, -0.08753052353858948, 0.06781947612762451, 0.6346468329429626, -0.2200048565864563, 0.11558627337217331, -0.5316802263259888, -0.20922847092151642, -0.47835537791252136, -1.0727177858352661, -0.8374260663986206, -0.4372010827064514, 0.5858208537101746, 0.8109974265098572, 1.0796312093734741, 0.7264140844345093, 0.6913024187088013, 0.46011650562286377, 0.12606826424598694, 0.3815760016441345, -0.27669307589530945, 0.34018373489379883, 0.03983450308442116, -0.4631389081478119, -0.657249927520752, 0.18147903680801392, 0.6214494109153748, 0.8011034727096558, -0.03994706645607948, -0.298225998878479, -0.03921334072947502, 0.42244213819503784, -0.5364816188812256, 0.3535878658294678, -0.22897043824195862, 0.20513831079006195, 0.27314913272857666, -0.05722698196768761, -0.20151318609714508, -0.05395532771945, 0.4800146222114563, -0.8048716187477112, -0.25454336404800415, 0.2501453459262848, 0.36639639735221863, 0.6616427302360535, -0.482759028673172, -0.22324232757091522, -0.7634116411209106, 0.824895977973938, -0.3955090045928955, 0.21538875997066498, 0.22969333827495575, 0.6591945886611938, -0.5447509288787842, -0.9425527453422546, -0.14215366542339325, -0.3627278506755829, 0.08251229673624039, 0.2764148414134979, -0.061859216541051865, 0.19095024466514587, 0.28905221819877625, -0.6321902275085449, -0.11988368630409241, 0.5523184537887573, -0.20409557223320007, 0.010121438652276993, 0.8307406902313232, 0.5832594037055969, 0.2304188460111618, 0.5255309343338013, -0.4353591501712799, -0.05277208983898163, -0.35208189487457275, 0.36755111813545227, 0.3146209418773651, -0.0007925265235826373, -0.422799676656723, 0.44135814905166626, -0.17148041725158691, 0.5116587281227112, 0.16286736726760864, 0.13793514668941498, -0.34486106038093567, -0.2507007122039795, -0.2576887011528015, 0.17441704869270325, 0.5898293256759644, 0.2869015336036682, 0.05760656297206879, 0.032550305128097534, 0.010604207403957844, -0.12492822855710983, 0.6173161268234253, -0.9182403683662415, -0.3218245506286621, 0.2830675542354584, -0.3067041337490082, -0.49493706226348877, 0.12100277096033096, -0.6629446744918823, -0.5135738253593445, -0.7909270524978638, 0.1395176649093628, -0.33530962467193604, -0.09584363549947739, -0.3902748227119446, -0.352487713098526, 0.1189189925789833, 0.5574352145195007, -0.765282928943634, 0.333543062210083, 0.6362077593803406, 0.7081146240234375, -0.5227301120758057, -0.41243213415145874, -0.5795461535453796, 0.3654594421386719, -0.3083404302597046, 0.4311196804046631, -0.7234531044960022, -0.6691023707389832, -0.2567330300807953, -0.09822412580251694, -0.21439982950687408, -0.6962906718254089, 0.43872368335723877, -0.4843505918979645, -0.08007815480232239, -0.1543423980474472, -0.4200347661972046, -0.27195435762405396, 0.37989097833633423, -0.7163752913475037, 0.5660986304283142, 0.006739913020282984, -0.7233222126960754, 0.45397239923477173, -1.0134999752044678, -0.44347402453422546, 0.02289581671357155, -0.27690497040748596, -0.900426983833313, -0.2660411596298218, 0.2993181347846985, 0.6403337717056274, -0.08230981975793839, 0.07386662811040878, -0.8508564233779907, -0.26143595576286316, 0.3529984951019287, -0.2748178541660309, 0.7044892311096191, 0.29877009987831116, -0.3989594876766205, 0.6238301396369934, -0.3573000431060791, 0.3041228950023651, -0.1447906345129013, -0.33655157685279846, 0.32255879044532776, 0.4049030840396881, 0.11043491214513779, 0.14691661298274994, 0.3416566550731659, 0.00900303665548563, 0.32073670625686646, 0.13700881600379944, 0.5888782739639282, 0.6008062362670898, 0.09172293543815613, 0.7090165615081787, -0.5185515880584717, 0.6666845679283142, -0.01269300002604723, 0.4970780313014984, 0.03355526179075241, -0.4076678156852722, -0.580600380897522, -0.508893609046936, 0.05793127417564392, 0.8128310441970825, -0.7763255834579468, 0.41355523467063904, 0.07759357243776321, -0.5942766666412354, 0.10326788574457169, -0.2741475999355316, -0.22314265370368958, 0.3160070478916168, 0.3872826397418976, -0.0445653460919857, -0.9483736753463745, -0.6068107485771179, -0.119923897087574, -0.21601732075214386, -0.04563423618674278, 0.22534067928791046, 0.3145197629928589, -0.49628573656082153, 1.0064597129821777, -0.058036793023347855, -0.0564592145383358, -0.4359727203845978, 0.2546067535877228, -0.3745515048503876, 0.648858904838562, 0.33661532402038574, -1.4533958435058594, -0.24939291179180145, 0.26073500514030457, -1.0140259265899658, 0.2685845196247101, -0.19663427770137787, 0.07746084779500961, -0.013034984469413757, 0.9790903329849243, -0.2668466866016388, 0.4697515070438385, 0.3857252299785614, 0.023201797157526016, 0.42941662669181824, -0.406482994556427, 0.3085666596889496, -0.7644245028495789, 0.004006796516478062, -0.27703559398651123, -0.19469614326953888, -0.8358229398727417, -0.004709215834736824, 0.17629364132881165, -0.3310560882091522, -0.36329755187034607, 0.1865154653787613, -0.37539994716644287, -0.23351158201694489, -0.28924551606178284, -0.037856776267290115, -0.6007263660430908, 0.3149860203266144, -0.05396270751953125, 0.6638699173927307, 0.5001712441444397, -0.8269882798194885, 0.45830556750297546, -0.04754173010587692, 0.13334479928016663, 0.8087736964225769, -0.6332675814628601, -0.11666277050971985, 0.23067231476306915, 0.47246867418289185, -0.4205166697502136, -0.5306552648544312, 0.06892687827348709, -0.459712415933609, 0.3387581408023834, -0.06923239678144455, -0.1535683125257492, -0.12418434023857117, -0.12217390537261963, 0.4554806649684906, 0.30696529150009155, -0.17200160026550293, 1.072121024131775, 0.5379395484924316, -0.07315380126237869, -0.539442241191864, -0.5127431154251099, 0.11731031537055969, -0.3320094645023346, -0.4722560942173004, 0.3380700349807739, -0.20014144480228424, -0.4667840003967285, -0.14721159636974335, 0.03866181522607803, -0.25414931774139404, 0.5049828290939331, 0.905587911605835, 0.45062360167503357, 0.07801718264818192, -0.23762385547161102, 0.03688579052686691, -0.05883040279150009, 0.21235676109790802, -0.4134061336517334, 0.2796304523944855, -0.2877533435821533, -0.4927363395690918, -0.45859187841415405, 0.3713821768760681, 1.0000126361846924, -0.21757036447525024, 0.7172772884368896, 0.8931309580802917, -0.24736571311950684, 0.03616740554571152, -0.23019307851791382, -0.06892966479063034, -0.4707120358943939, 0.3561900556087494, -0.09622572362422943, -0.9092066884040833, 0.3357921540737152, -0.8718507885932922, 0.2888648509979248, 0.2835584878921509, 0.8134318590164185, -0.6341227889060974, 1.228546380996704, 1.0616445541381836, -0.16834168136119843, 0.6264090538024902, -0.2987184226512909, -0.044709645211696625, -0.5659862160682678, -0.4702664017677307, -0.16395096480846405, -0.6853204965591431, -0.8007239103317261, -0.3695286512374878, 0.9066159725189209, 0.00045854735071770847, -0.4856395423412323, -0.1255367249250412, -0.13712534308433533, 0.11900299787521362, 0.5304955244064331, -0.056888386607170105, -0.14511168003082275, -0.41364675760269165, 0.06193313002586365, 0.24737906455993652, -0.993818461894989, -0.193242609500885, 0.8032315969467163, 0.33086830377578735, 0.582884669303894, -0.1887037307024002, 0.6043916940689087, 0.5663219690322876, -0.03001776523888111, -0.7073045372962952, 0.3839067816734314, 0.4382801949977875, -0.3709004819393158, -0.5655735731124878, -0.4242081940174103, -1.1055200099945068, -0.08637160062789917, -0.5898655652999878, -0.29705411195755005, 0.06005161255598068, 0.19387346506118774, -0.27880388498306274, 0.30926430225372314, -0.7766706347465515, 0.564287006855011, -0.34851953387260437, -0.1661432534456253, -0.5638628602027893, -1.070858120918274, -0.0004768827639054507, 0.10791110247373581, 0.11890653520822525, 0.09042402356863022, -0.6781253218650818, 0.47900548577308655, -0.14422202110290527, 0.7678936123847961, -0.2057129591703415, 0.2926579415798187, 0.16403453052043915, -0.11760589480400085, 0.47439903020858765, 0.05571849271655083, -0.1401393860578537, 0.1364915370941162, -0.10620233416557312, -0.4257282316684723, -0.46424394845962524, 0.5525486469268799, -0.9021329879760742, -0.2592064142227173, -0.44132500886917114, -0.8295378088951111, -0.3957914412021637, 0.23209406435489655, 0.17964155972003937, 0.22588218748569489, -0.46893608570098877, 0.3266853392124176, 0.7463265061378479, 0.10710261017084122, 0.6754448413848877, 0.09002698212862015, 0.16303972899913788, -0.3585841953754425, 0.6969407200813293, 0.2973093092441559, 0.2913529574871063, 0.46882373094558716, -0.1662711650133133, 0.05922457203269005, -0.5667110681533813, -0.48528045415878296, -0.34977400302886963, -0.17335191369056702, -0.12998425960540771, -0.49566784501075745, -0.34210205078125, -0.07190842181444168, -0.8498503565788269, -0.19729888439178467, -0.2967824935913086, -0.45753899216651917, 0.12163382768630981, 0.07653823494911194, 0.8562200665473938, -0.17667420208454132, 0.4282670319080353, -0.4802134037017822, 0.38284578919410706, 0.2542420029640198, -0.0375199019908905, -0.14907631278038025, 0.056039515882730484, -0.3206249475479126, 0.1254400759935379, -0.5269695520401001, -0.5996532440185547, 0.18474911153316498, -0.0634385272860527, 0.7258046865463257, 0.1911236047744751, 0.06965796649456024, 0.4698605537414551, -0.4431336224079132, 0.5126340389251709, 0.21894322335720062, -0.6718537211418152, 0.4030424654483795, -0.2614815831184387, 0.3366229236125946, 0.17407016456127167, 0.6963358521461487, -0.2721118628978729, -0.1847386360168457, -0.6436918377876282, -0.5320336818695068, 0.7586832642555237, 0.12230052798986435, -0.46127888560295105, 0.6148160696029663, 0.07890753448009491, -0.13206659257411957, 0.07754302769899368, 0.14243900775909424, -0.2190369814634323, 0.0013369197258725762, -0.17192500829696655, 0.009758460335433483, 0.22025568783283234, -0.17728881537914276, -0.13494344055652618, 0.4838232696056366, -0.27777451276779175, 0.23871862888336182, -0.04488390311598778, 0.20502714812755585, -0.05128004401922226, 0.12196539342403412, 0.6215254664421082, 0.762536883354187, 0.032226886600255966, -0.10805584490299225, 0.7629695534706116, -0.4649610221385956, 0.16758422553539276, 0.21411508321762085, 0.030148640275001526, -0.7967401146888733, 0.47855475544929504, 0.4356954097747803, 0.1966383159160614, -0.730862021446228, 0.21302123367786407, -0.24898061156272888, -0.322475403547287, -0.5151677131652832, 0.2950895428657532, 0.03404814004898071, 0.8825472593307495, 0.22208678722381592, 0.673731803894043, 0.023624449968338013, -0.7866351008415222, 0.41076257824897766, 0.4859093427658081, -0.4920724630355835, 0.07192623615264893, 0.6371465921401978, 0.19282357394695282, -0.3419089615345001, 0.6310427188873291, 0.005963808391243219, -0.6894893050193787, 0.8657084107398987, 0.06425800919532776, 0.5354066491127014, -0.30866745114326477, -0.035707373172044754, -0.025029798969626427, 0.3815920054912567, 0.21190504729747772, 0.1731673628091812, -0.10362187772989273, -0.25502198934555054, -0.23591932654380798, -0.060705821961164474, -0.9887025952339172, -0.2833068370819092, -0.49018871784210205, 0.44976603984832764, -0.9155920743942261, -0.2174181044101715, -0.22405444085597992, 0.24538713693618774, -0.7309120893478394, 0.26529666781425476, 0.21185903251171112, 0.7440115213394165, -0.25694188475608826, 0.753130316734314, 0.6287933588027954, -0.0002583125315140933, -0.6659061312675476, -0.05106387287378311, 0.20663493871688843, -0.7072426080703735, 0.5225446820259094, 0.042484086006879807, -0.2549225091934204, -0.14806345105171204, -0.793190062046051, -0.5756096839904785, 1.3576990365982056, 0.3281126320362091, -0.31750133633613586, -0.10075288265943527, -0.10363948345184326, 0.43177762627601624, -0.4870379567146301, 0.3622620701789856, 0.6173757910728455, 0.7912114262580872, 0.006809215992689133, -0.7473868727684021, -0.2900584042072296, 0.08174119889736176, -0.2461935132741928, 0.21681883931159973, -0.7713491320610046, 0.6976273655891418, -0.492603600025177, -0.035086970776319504, 0.056393276900053024, 1.1144150495529175, 0.15605267882347107, 0.6701740622520447, 0.5990869998931885, 0.32171526551246643, 0.7522386908531189, -0.20753349363803864, 0.7702625393867493, 0.21635250747203827, -0.1320444941520691, 0.8780404925346375, -0.19914452731609344, 0.7722890377044678, 0.16482098400592804, -0.17277824878692627, 0.5785691738128662, 0.6261424422264099, -0.09722533077001572, 0.06321755796670914, -0.0547834187746048, -0.27734434604644775, -0.20402391254901886, -0.1959507167339325, -0.02801589109003544, 0.4130692780017853, 0.6204417943954468, -0.00901779904961586, 0.24130117893218994, 0.18356502056121826, 0.05506196245551109, -0.08183559030294418, -0.41023918986320496, 0.8894919753074646, -0.21571186184883118, -0.6529147624969482, 0.3302146792411804, -0.039569370448589325, 0.4278795123100281, -0.7496432065963745, -0.31885263323783875, 0.2752660810947418, 0.1036829724907875, -0.38913974165916443, -0.9336623549461365, 0.10521043837070465, -0.32992666959762573, -0.21925601363182068, -0.200252503156662, 0.5357477068901062, -0.3379240036010742, -0.15287767350673676, 0.27152949571609497, 0.4429156482219696, -0.15979230403900146, -0.012528961524367332, -0.6497694849967957, 0.271384060382843, -0.06901378929615021, 0.1732480376958847, 0.5968203544616699, 0.42860865592956543, -0.2701469957828522, 1.1915791034698486, 0.5213732123374939, -0.04344157874584198, 0.235420361161232, -0.432248055934906, 0.8760517239570618, -0.45943960547447205, -0.5319386124610901, -0.6484065651893616, 0.3011951148509979, -0.382663756608963, 0.039187297224998474, 0.43353816866874695, 0.36589932441711426, 0.701337993144989, 0.2120068520307541, 0.9980006814002991, -0.21676558256149292, 0.03044280596077442, -0.24673138558864594, 0.6707000136375427, -0.36026695370674133, -0.10478831082582474, 0.27737659215927124, -0.44520342350006104, -0.26420488953590393, 0.0050642229616642, -0.1462014615535736, 0.12351943552494049, 0.4311279058456421, 0.4855954051017761, -0.256340891122818, 0.1526530534029007, 0.43231984972953796, -0.050871074199676514, 0.5805020332336426, 0.41352248191833496, 0.9668183922767639, 0.019980451092123985, 0.6140208840370178, -0.23956333100795746, -0.5006298422813416, -0.6113836765289307, -0.8281808495521545, -0.8539943099021912, -0.6175206899642944, 0.008448845706880093, 0.2420113980770111, 0.04912853240966797, 1.0421268939971924, 1.135258436203003, -0.6720393300056458, -0.34242868423461914, -0.08853376656770706, 0.19528964161872864, -0.5338848233222961, -0.14362908899784088, 0.12538030743598938, -0.5024595260620117, -0.6299992203712463, 0.6187112927436829, 0.4637697637081146, 0.13841788470745087, -0.2291986048221588, -0.41692569851875305, -0.0472676083445549, -0.014125130139291286, 0.594345211982727, 0.5387765169143677, -0.5921794772148132, -0.09024031460285187, -0.05971511825919151, 0.08326109498739243, -0.275337815284729, 1.119890570640564, -0.8615593910217285, 0.5047217607498169, 0.23043036460876465, 1.1932542324066162, 0.23931920528411865, 0.09039844572544098, 0.8629724383354187, -0.5018304586410522, 0.05237312614917755, 0.4581630229949951, 0.1997693032026291, 0.15542735159397125, -0.5390874743461609, 0.5979933142662048, 0.03942060098052025, -0.950592041015625, -0.4436770975589752, 0.21219488978385925, -1.1119441986083984, -0.22581446170806885, 0.547760546207428, -0.23909629881381989, 0.16013169288635254, -0.23978377878665924, -0.5478654503822327, 0.5028066635131836, -0.28080564737319946, 0.44702938199043274, 0.526456892490387, -0.7373194694519043, -0.04796639457345009, -0.5214924812316895, 0.5105326175689697, 0.3607828617095947, -1.299931287765503, 0.049126867204904556, 0.34706544876098633, -0.3686021864414215, -0.14954495429992676, -0.2136564552783966, 0.26614612340927124, 0.42068785429000854, 0.006670558359473944, -0.22465857863426208, -0.2492762804031372, -0.7875362634658813, -0.16756713390350342, 0.29655715823173523, -0.12172601372003555, -0.12741044163703918 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07946v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07946v2	Re-Envisioning Command and Control	2024-02-09T16:10:29	2024-03-28T15:17:30	Kaleb McDowell, Ellen Novoseller, Anna Madison, Vinicius G. Goecks, Christopher Kelshaw	cs.HC	cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7	Future warfare will require Command and Control (C2) decision-making to occur in more complex, fast-paced, ill-structured, and demanding conditions. C2 will be further complicated by operational challenges such as Denied, Degraded, Intermittent, and Limited (DDIL) communications and the need to account for many data streams, potentially across multiple domains of operation. Yet, current C2 practices -- which stem from the industrial era rather than the emerging intelligence era -- are linear and time-consuming. Critically, these approaches may fail to maintain overmatch against adversaries on the future battlefield. To address these challenges, we propose a vision for future C2 based on robust partnerships between humans and artificial intelligence (AI) systems. This future vision is encapsulated in three operational impacts: streamlining the C2 operations process, maintaining unity of effort, and developing adaptive collective knowledge systems. This paper illustrates the envisaged future C2 capabilities, discusses the assumptions that shaped them, and describes how the proposed developments could transform C2 in future warfare.	[ -0.5841176509857178, -0.6526686549186707, 0.8554878234863281, 0.32389599084854126, 0.20501300692558289, 0.6796863079071045, 0.07996673882007599, -0.7864906191825867, 0.07854034006595612, 0.5848119258880615, -0.8787825107574463, -0.38711318373680115, -0.8441179990768433, -0.021157201379537582, -0.2962038516998291, 0.830954372882843, -0.14817652106285095, -0.13774096965789795, -0.21603980660438538, -0.17624612152576447, -0.8636676073074341, -0.9776126146316528, -0.8781688809394836, -0.6002866625785828, 0.6115149259567261, 0.5295747518539429, 1.102242112159729, 0.6294934153556824, 0.8058258295059204, 0.41618824005126953, 0.09671987593173981, 0.1680465042591095, -0.4961450397968292, 0.054410744458436966, -0.15710578858852386, -0.45947083830833435, -0.569735586643219, 0.4897720217704773, 0.4241120517253876, 0.7527450919151306, -0.006311335135251284, -0.5104457139968872, -0.03869759291410446, 0.4687131643295288, -0.7276980876922607, 0.06755331158638, -0.4695166051387787, -0.10039447247982025, 0.28305891156196594, -0.10855413228273392, 0.004556594882160425, -0.019598834216594696, 0.4933028519153595, -0.8608415722846985, -0.2807832658290863, 0.42879095673561096, 0.5948036313056946, 0.3007921874523163, -0.4881090819835663, -0.2801603078842163, -0.9914180636405945, 0.7020856142044067, -0.10641273856163025, 0.3350965976715088, 0.4545886814594269, 0.5959489941596985, -0.41770419478416443, -1.010972023010254, -0.2425139844417572, 0.010244800709187984, 0.046158626675605774, 0.48908329010009766, -0.2622179388999939, 0.08561787009239197, -0.29078587889671326, -0.3502351939678192, 0.04794406518340111, 0.1925906389951706, -0.6925557255744934, -0.0954684242606163, 0.8522083163261414, 0.5928494334220886, 0.20727065205574036, 0.4978884756565094, -1.1448885202407837, 0.15869152545928955, -0.5506342053413391, 0.3187640607357025, 0.045888107270002365, -0.17929987609386444, -0.7078533172607422, 0.39141935110092163, -0.2689407467842102, 0.4731702506542206, 0.17768065631389618, 0.09163793176412582, -0.4851018488407135, -0.30205976963043213, -0.40858355164527893, 0.22806866466999054, 0.3913986384868622, 0.7939715385437012, 0.11627410352230072, -0.23602905869483948, -0.010000113397836685, 0.4245584011077881, 0.8085487484931946, -0.4031539559364319, -0.3179130256175995, 0.41491982340812683, -0.41413819789886475, -0.4394853711128235, 0.15188203752040863, -0.5672613382339478, -0.5880799293518066, -0.8871442675590515, 0.10314431041479111, -0.42234790325164795, -0.008163015358150005, -0.054081667214632034, -0.5105997323989868, 0.4328966736793518, 0.5919743180274963, -0.8582038283348083, 0.47780880331993103, 0.8533207178115845, 0.7807838916778564, -0.6255992650985718, -0.30573126673698425, 0.11446838825941086, 0.5249875783920288, -0.5723963975906372, 0.5714431405067444, -0.4082651734352112, -0.7647547721862793, -0.20896179974079132, 0.005118636414408684, 0.10668063908815384, -0.5246865749359131, 0.3053380250930786, -0.49930262565612793, -0.10929104685783386, -0.24358530342578888, -0.40161028504371643, -0.15673251450061798, 0.4893670678138733, -0.5640662312507629, -0.028501901775598526, -0.07422951608896255, -0.3973845839500427, 0.49257245659828186, -0.45866090059280396, -0.5262606143951416, 0.03235220909118652, -0.36895129084587097, -0.2636314630508423, -0.24277405440807343, -0.05292515456676483, 0.3925250470638275, -0.5060259699821472, 0.03996768221259117, -0.6306520700454712, -0.17258815467357635, 0.08054013550281525, -0.2048313170671463, 0.7386521697044373, 0.26448366045951843, -0.3254372179508209, 0.2900477945804596, -0.45533379912376404, 0.11692573130130768, -0.2628370523452759, -0.42987170815467834, 0.2960811257362366, 0.7098227143287659, -0.14934603869915009, 0.04074007272720337, 0.3945520222187042, -0.1711905151605606, 0.16173875331878662, -0.03892095386981964, 0.7263274192810059, 1.0093345642089844, 0.2419378161430359, 0.9761329293251038, -0.6944432854652405, 0.5132912397384644, -0.058164577931165695, 0.7014367580413818, 0.37987613677978516, -0.46664926409721375, -0.7553246021270752, -0.11086635291576385, -0.40742945671081543, 0.7858765721321106, -0.7506994009017944, 0.33155494928359985, -0.030909664928913116, -0.6964948773384094, 0.1432424634695053, -0.195693239569664, -0.05011856555938721, 0.21475939452648163, 0.4770810902118683, -0.4753973186016083, -0.7595708966255188, -0.7644020915031433, 0.1406116783618927, -0.46156153082847595, 0.20963314175605774, -0.10745827108621597, 0.24313108623027802, -0.4772922098636627, 0.6814029216766357, 0.06814173609018326, -0.3279015123844147, -0.5522643327713013, 0.05217524617910385, -0.29943737387657166, 0.7844041585922241, 0.07740619778633118, -1.2697954177856445, 0.10579682141542435, 0.19510090351104736, -0.856276273727417, 0.42897528409957886, -0.33666232228279114, -0.4633617103099823, -0.04061960056424141, 0.9282105565071106, -0.34093958139419556, 0.42115357518196106, 0.37234193086624146, -0.14847736060619354, 0.40483760833740234, -0.06580255925655365, 0.2715877294540405, -0.6645100116729736, 0.045430988073349, -0.4155455529689789, 0.1925024688243866, -0.5746504664421082, 0.07067784667015076, -0.05636991932988167, -0.2903546094894409, -0.41216862201690674, 0.23297448456287384, -0.29608139395713806, -0.10521549731492996, -0.2357502430677414, 0.1279335618019104, 0.038185302168130875, 0.3280177712440491, -0.062188390642404556, 0.31996211409568787, 0.41074156761169434, -0.8109199404716492, 0.9247283339500427, 0.25248122215270996, 0.20779842138290405, 1.0822806358337402, -0.7144861817359924, 0.015304933302104473, 0.16633424162864685, 0.5741627216339111, -0.22881223261356354, -0.14159999787807465, 0.25585219264030457, -0.6250523924827576, 0.27599647641181946, 0.13023653626441956, 0.059038762003183365, -0.023815589025616646, -0.139208123087883, 0.2540210485458374, 0.2603439688682556, -0.09125368297100067, 1.219754695892334, 0.38878223299980164, 0.1740308254957199, -0.5452202558517456, -0.7279041409492493, 0.3641209006309509, -0.2564219534397125, -0.23145271837711334, 0.529338538646698, 0.0364525206387043, -0.6932616829872131, -0.06498293578624725, -0.11352147907018661, -0.02806408330798149, 0.2819342017173767, 0.8465648889541626, 0.663131833076477, 0.2183830589056015, -0.2662827968597412, -0.17601054906845093, -0.13546916842460632, 0.33015957474708557, -0.7776108980178833, 0.3736325204372406, 0.07659906893968582, -0.33720049262046814, -0.5116093158721924, 0.7272613644599915, 1.015766978263855, -0.5181092023849487, 0.48799312114715576, 0.5021255016326904, -0.14875809848308563, 0.18266403675079346, -0.37231212854385376, -0.09759578108787537, -0.45638543367385864, 0.21754775941371918, 0.09952311962842941, -0.5001055002212524, 0.41453152894973755, -0.4733157157897949, 0.304620623588562, 0.32373765110969543, 0.6308622360229492, -0.6640264987945557, 0.8595134019851685, 0.9456660151481628, -0.5681801438331604, 0.31909021735191345, -0.45677679777145386, 0.030190587043762207, -0.6874088644981384, -0.8638321161270142, -0.1589810997247696, -0.7255244255065918, -0.8280029296875, 0.01661117933690548, 0.7591996788978577, 0.1298823207616806, -0.6549228429794312, 0.1149439737200737, -0.2239203304052353, -0.06949011981487274, 0.8345909118652344, 0.0888713076710701, -0.09503692388534546, -0.5075086355209351, 0.2887379229068756, 0.4123944044113159, -0.7205391526222229, -0.1684437394142151, 0.7565464377403259, 0.14707349240779877, 0.7082398533821106, -0.10168478637933731, 0.6251409649848938, 0.49274906516075134, -0.19200444221496582, -0.6271559596061707, 0.40802282094955444, 0.20090843737125397, -0.5549727082252502, -0.02597535401582718, -0.11103243380784988, -1.067266821861267, -0.31761300563812256, -0.7088890671730042, -0.32767173647880554, 0.4048292338848114, -0.038566648960113525, -0.5233410596847534, 0.26001468300819397, -0.8436663746833801, 0.4498969614505768, -0.30644580721855164, -0.3943599462509155, -0.6939302086830139, -1.100427269935608, -0.048678044229745865, 0.4378320276737213, 0.15311382710933685, -0.006674002390354872, -0.57745361328125, 0.4021099805831909, -0.04537155106663704, 0.7167689204216003, 0.027565890923142433, 0.06627730280160904, 0.4179666340351105, -0.12365388870239258, 0.3638466000556946, 0.06797510385513306, 0.14235998690128326, 0.09134373068809509, -0.13426318764686584, -0.5775849223136902, -0.44632530212402344, 0.545211136341095, -1.145017385482788, -0.5017629265785217, -0.43645361065864563, -0.45393621921539307, -0.11316630989313126, 0.20981758832931519, 0.23511379957199097, 0.61980140209198, -0.5411580204963684, 0.0531541109085083, 0.23059941828250885, -0.00423144968226552, 0.5231325030326843, 0.026737457141280174, 0.10791919380426407, -0.6079500317573547, 0.5743619203567505, 0.031209871172904968, 0.8588446974754333, 0.38466140627861023, -0.44720226526260376, -0.16483120620250702, -0.6892810463905334, -0.5113794207572937, -0.4586173892021179, -0.5224590301513672, -0.430538147687912, -0.16625653207302094, -0.15819180011749268, -0.24652746319770813, -0.8707835674285889, -0.15473859012126923, -0.057605672627687454, -0.4162275791168213, 0.10080774128437042, 0.12706147134304047, 1.1290390491485596, -0.1775750070810318, 0.5288597941398621, -0.30578285455703735, 0.5769405961036682, 0.209721639752388, 0.17700274288654327, -0.3913605213165283, 0.24552369117736816, -0.3396555185317993, 0.18000181019306183, -0.7324838042259216, -0.7336104512214661, 0.2738591432571411, 0.09674447029829025, 0.29275161027908325, 0.1083824634552002, 0.012483816593885422, 0.3439614772796631, -0.35154154896736145, 0.6357207298278809, 0.24514184892177582, -0.7017942667007446, 0.3915422260761261, -0.12182430177927017, 0.18147648870944977, 0.25332796573638916, 0.3270733058452606, -0.3014371693134308, -0.4999750554561615, -0.7655755281448364, -0.6645676493644714, 0.5123361945152283, 0.05912772938609123, -0.2785537838935852, 0.2367740422487259, 0.08864172548055649, -0.5557544231414795, -0.006556485779583454, 0.17106810212135315, -0.2169315218925476, -0.10254442691802979, 0.09233087301254272, -0.1740405261516571, 0.4257003962993622, -0.15853719413280487, -0.0346149317920208, 0.41707170009613037, 0.03082961216568947, 0.38236427307128906, 0.3116065561771393, 0.5460410118103027, -0.004282751120626926, 0.25309982895851135, 0.5194984674453735, 0.4082963466644287, 0.0025554297026246786, 0.08146926760673523, 0.5296677350997925, -0.45109379291534424, 0.2959754168987274, -0.044476576149463654, 0.1475377380847931, -0.889111340045929, 0.5864313840866089, 0.3237738311290741, 0.04992152377963066, -0.28202807903289795, 0.20975564420223236, 0.08968286961317062, -0.13288870453834534, -0.5826224684715271, 0.034600380808115005, 0.12409138679504395, 0.9042050242424011, 0.3165825307369232, 0.9686372876167297, -0.02420896291732788, -0.9619442224502563, 0.24785499274730682, 0.46460676193237305, -0.3609408140182495, -0.11924614012241364, 0.7041889429092407, 0.339674711227417, -0.05352366343140602, 0.47223538160324097, -0.01721120998263359, -0.8073452711105347, 0.812296986579895, 0.17794069647789001, 0.4902910888195038, 0.012919710017740726, -0.2940347492694855, -0.11013349145650864, 0.49045565724372864, 0.2072160691022873, 0.10866318643093109, 0.11088679730892181, -0.6292402148246765, -0.1650647222995758, -0.10395919531583786, -0.5255200266838074, -0.13425473868846893, -0.6284821629524231, 0.6135817170143127, -1.2470132112503052, -0.1483878791332245, -0.08516714721918106, 0.3783390522003174, -0.653056263923645, 0.540702760219574, 0.42458054423332214, 0.7515345811843872, -0.0978153795003891, 0.7430837154388428, 0.43800124526023865, -0.23369193077087402, -0.8175792694091797, -0.29953351616859436, 0.4380294680595398, -0.9258691072463989, 0.5426537990570068, -0.16512855887413025, -0.4924340546131134, -0.05273596942424774, -0.7243385314941406, -0.6332942843437195, 1.4277596473693848, 0.06617580354213715, -0.47154366970062256, -0.37655532360076904, -0.06498579680919647, 0.3084060251712799, -0.5499825477600098, -0.09279957413673401, 1.0170317888259888, 0.8255425691604614, -0.12911677360534668, -0.6936682462692261, -0.39126038551330566, -0.043632373213768005, -0.26989850401878357, 0.18852266669273376, -0.795242965221405, 0.7899054288864136, -0.4121890366077423, -0.5621713995933533, 0.13089141249656677, 0.875037431716919, -0.11427797377109528, 0.49088209867477417, 0.29732003808021545, 0.5186643004417419, 0.06888008117675781, -0.25297433137893677, 1.0428179502487183, 0.025684138759970665, -0.19837920367717743, 0.8289973139762878, -0.14346446096897125, 0.7709034085273743, 0.24544109404087067, -0.30946436524391174, 0.5497957468032837, 0.40606963634490967, -0.18267108500003815, 0.28325095772743225, -0.13105624914169312, -0.18374091386795044, 0.005238221492618322, -0.41820457577705383, -0.2425968050956726, 0.8137207627296448, 0.476422518491745, -0.09987473487854004, 0.042772114276885986, -0.31661108136177063, -0.04274795949459076, 0.32780689001083374, -0.5459210872650146, 1.0033555030822754, -0.11321911960840225, -0.6441908478736877, 0.82513827085495, -0.0660606175661087, 0.6688497066497803, -0.6233049035072327, -0.19185197353363037, 0.25364744663238525, 0.21193969249725342, -0.1978566199541092, -0.7775049209594727, 0.3568175137042999, -0.5113956332206726, -0.0788625106215477, -0.24244022369384766, 0.3715822398662567, -0.3031022846698761, -0.26421502232551575, 0.6969423294067383, 0.4615524411201477, -0.48703160881996155, 0.018914375454187393, -0.5598150491714478, 0.47919797897338867, -0.022371528670191765, 0.5411036014556885, 0.08447787165641785, 0.20408782362937927, -0.04504072293639183, 0.8803508877754211, 0.3267640769481659, 0.3309337794780731, 0.08325625211000443, -0.5091286301612854, 0.8321487307548523, -0.355045884847641, -0.2809649705886841, -0.738143265247345, 0.05150137469172478, -0.09736698865890503, -0.3155128061771393, 0.13115695118904114, 0.2255392223596573, 0.8918327689170837, 0.39318880438804626, 1.0271247625350952, -0.5305078029632568, 0.035962507128715515, -0.23905518651008606, 0.7513799071311951, -0.3713478446006775, -0.1506328135728836, 0.16494639217853546, -0.33791863918304443, -0.15724679827690125, -0.1039358526468277, -0.11209576576948166, -0.16876499354839325, 0.4732239842414856, 0.4526268243789673, 0.09376826882362366, 0.2220029979944229, 0.22036102414131165, -0.15713995695114136, 0.5805469155311584, 0.7866598963737488, 1.0890790224075317, -0.118904247879982, 0.540542721748352, -0.35273462533950806, -0.3804735243320465, -0.07586389780044556, -0.4259242117404938, -0.5486220717430115, -0.8023698925971985, 0.34071844816207886, 0.1355774998664856, 0.33506450057029724, 1.0719188451766968, 0.9936786890029907, -0.6535785794258118, -0.28695639967918396, -0.27513229846954346, 0.030212681740522385, -0.25107988715171814, -0.08946563303470612, 0.0027373849879950285, -0.5290707349777222, -0.5350900292396545, 0.37572622299194336, 0.47547033429145813, 0.2689138352870941, -0.2733955979347229, -0.28597569465637207, -0.140133798122406, -0.08146997541189194, 0.608445942401886, 0.3746044337749481, -0.8441991806030273, -0.49724799394607544, -0.06024372577667236, -0.10275430232286453, -0.140114426612854, 1.0698305368423462, -0.7924696803092957, 0.36951154470443726, 0.010473203845322132, 0.8936000466346741, -0.17377732694149017, 0.1864483505487442, 1.2631694078445435, -0.315287321805954, 0.17987805604934692, 0.4547964632511139, 0.2340329885482788, 0.23874637484550476, -0.4278199076652527, 0.3343973755836487, 0.19135233759880066, -0.7146015167236328, 0.028176644816994667, 0.5687620639801025, -0.888423502445221, -0.1295870691537857, 0.5576937794685364, -0.22307796776294708, 0.17266082763671875, -0.47186359763145447, -0.4624316692352295, 0.503591775894165, -0.4596346914768219, 0.4787484407424927, 0.503558874130249, -0.2951619327068329, 0.08731728792190552, -0.42620810866355896, 0.5409479141235352, 0.35611870884895325, -1.0114352703094482, 0.19878841936588287, 0.5344576835632324, -0.44669052958488464, 0.17638252675533295, -0.019787581637501717, -0.038502197712659836, 0.3220243752002716, 0.05077129602432251, -0.1593417227268219, 0.18855389952659607, -0.9101046323776245, 0.09125304222106934, 0.09227527678012848, -0.1461826115846634, -0.27795538306236267 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06492v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06492v1	Inducing Systematicity in Transformers by Attending to Structurally Quantized Embeddings	2024-02-09T15:53:15	2024-02-09T15:53:15	Yichen Jiang, Xiang Zhou, Mohit Bansal	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Transformers generalize to novel compositions of structures and entities after being trained on a complex dataset, but easily overfit on datasets of insufficient complexity. We observe that when the training set is sufficiently complex, the model encodes sentences that have a common syntactic structure using a systematic attention pattern. Inspired by this observation, we propose SQ-Transformer (Structurally Quantized) that explicitly encourages systematicity in the embeddings and attention layers, even with a training set of low complexity. At the embedding level, we introduce Structure-oriented Vector Quantization (SoVQ) to cluster word embeddings into several classes of structurally equivalent entities. At the attention level, we devise the Systematic Attention Layer (SAL) and an alternative, Systematically Regularized Layer (SRL) that operate on the quantized word embeddings so that sentences of the same structure are encoded with invariant or similar attention patterns. Empirically, we show that SQ-Transformer achieves stronger compositional generalization than the vanilla Transformer on multiple low-complexity semantic parsing and machine translation datasets. In our analysis, we show that SoVQ indeed learns a syntactically clustered embedding space and SAL/SRL induces generalizable attention patterns, which lead to improved systematicity.	[ -0.1572870910167694, -0.771389365196228, 0.4181218445301056, 0.5050826072692871, -0.19617916643619537, 0.023619404062628746, -0.1997351199388504, -0.006498055532574654, 0.46631118655204773, 0.24936600029468536, -0.49006640911102295, -0.5476492643356323, -0.4857181906700134, 0.04999880492687225, -0.9141020178794861, 1.0700573921203613, -0.04593607410788536, 0.0965128019452095, -0.06216368079185486, -0.21486075222492218, -0.005444326903671026, -0.402066171169281, -0.2554500699043274, 0.09626643359661102, 0.6242160201072693, 0.14520955085754395, 0.886656641960144, 0.8428863286972046, 0.6652294397354126, 0.3648902177810669, 0.1289612203836441, -0.17091432213783264, -0.45287272334098816, 0.24694359302520752, -0.26324203610420227, -0.9490377306938171, -0.20577684044837952, -0.37242332100868225, 1.017052173614502, 0.8368887305259705, -0.425471693277359, 0.2646652162075043, 0.03206764906644821, 0.7866116762161255, -0.5787403583526611, 0.15005746483802795, -0.46037277579307556, 0.3731192648410797, -0.12149883061647415, -0.00225960579700768, -0.2730647325515747, -0.3658495247364044, 0.2935939431190491, -0.7467558979988098, 0.5236085653305054, 0.17889128625392914, 0.9335606098175049, 0.5967323184013367, -0.22657273709774017, -0.036964792758226395, -0.9910458922386169, 0.8094227910041809, -0.175447016954422, 0.5632315278053284, 0.0001868995459517464, 0.4357859790325165, 0.1368635892868042, -1.1065385341644287, -0.47283607721328735, 0.05880202725529671, -0.3585572838783264, 0.40451526641845703, -0.2967202067375183, 0.20990422368049622, 0.5602278113365173, 0.5889595746994019, -0.7370395064353943, -0.43170905113220215, -0.31742364168167114, -0.03164604306221008, 0.3180566132068634, 0.11065316200256348, 0.4092579483985901, -0.29255956411361694, -0.6370090246200562, -0.06053777411580086, -0.5524171590805054, 0.203485369682312, 0.0747273713350296, -0.17119720578193665, 0.08912254869937897, 0.6651167273521423, -0.3616069555282593, 0.190337672829628, 0.23219238221645355, 0.12604239583015442, 0.10693282634019852, -0.5501354336738586, -0.29079267382621765, 0.15749821066856384, 0.8442758917808533, -0.16610023379325867, 0.5233045816421509, -0.3541563153266907, -0.38197019696235657, 0.45349618792533875, 0.692287802696228, -0.6841858625411987, -0.1819968819618225, 0.20151883363723755, -0.45391255617141724, -0.3654480278491974, 0.4559929668903351, -0.16812331974506378, 0.43610480427742004, -0.3589390516281128, 0.44270801544189453, -0.5380180478096008, 0.11432374268770218, 0.2752087414264679, -0.4430212080478668, 0.44934067130088806, -0.10127715766429901, -0.924892783164978, 0.3989826738834381, 0.7459532618522644, 0.693579912185669, 0.011388841085135937, -0.2017543613910675, -0.2666172981262207, 0.6440375447273254, -0.45159509778022766, 0.8559286594390869, -0.6108704209327698, -0.0500837080180645, 0.055161263793706894, 0.05720224231481552, -0.1016547754406929, -0.5119178891181946, 0.6126595735549927, -0.4372350871562958, 0.3705977201461792, -0.01614529639482498, -0.17070724070072174, -0.09011411666870117, 0.18385900557041168, -0.6353518962860107, 1.155525803565979, 0.433466374874115, -0.9087330102920532, 0.4696079194545746, -0.46792054176330566, -0.6070395708084106, 0.1117158755660057, -0.4633411467075348, -0.6607251167297363, 0.48181235790252686, 0.2452414482831955, 0.36597657203674316, 0.0945744514465332, 0.420633465051651, -0.012594220228493214, -0.4610567092895508, 0.2363065779209137, 0.011773637495934963, 0.27171990275382996, -0.09690044820308685, -0.5428735017776489, 0.5689215660095215, -0.7793421745300293, -0.14131616055965424, 0.12456423044204712, -0.11972168833017349, -0.6004714965820312, 0.10161076486110687, -0.18838459253311157, 0.2346303015947342, -0.0003544616047292948, -0.26626503467559814, 0.2985806167125702, -0.7328893542289734, 0.8208608031272888, 0.7037082314491272, 0.2199370115995407, 0.9943562746047974, -0.2892600893974304, 0.6947129964828491, 0.2929939031600952, 0.33887946605682373, -0.3685895800590515, -0.17356964945793152, -1.1689732074737549, -0.6876648664474487, 0.3682168126106262, 0.3795957863330841, -0.7349423170089722, 0.6116182804107666, -0.6837165355682373, -0.11885621398687363, -0.7851830124855042, -0.22486302256584167, 0.3126606047153473, 0.07718126475811005, 0.4054275155067444, -0.6412610411643982, -0.5410324335098267, -1.3762593269348145, -0.3626890778541565, 0.30751651525497437, -0.4277524948120117, 0.07898096740245819, 0.34389230608940125, -0.26941144466400146, 0.9932177066802979, -0.40573692321777344, -0.43240463733673096, -0.16387008130550385, -0.05614972859621048, 0.1548348069190979, 0.34780749678611755, 0.16314326226711273, -0.7101260423660278, -0.627554178237915, -0.06843384355306625, -0.6634232401847839, 0.2949596643447876, -0.40205514430999756, -0.43896496295928955, -0.3727189302444458, 0.5140615105628967, -0.9004148244857788, 0.3705857992172241, 0.06937964260578156, -0.0004941418883390725, 0.11419622600078583, 0.4173678457736969, -0.2778603434562683, -1.0487256050109863, -0.02800658345222473, -0.10658818483352661, -0.4268263876438141, -0.8065767288208008, 0.16958779096603394, 0.24738721549510956, 0.01851479522883892, -0.2755286693572998, -0.029222091659903526, -0.2904239594936371, -0.20741377770900726, 0.23578763008117676, 0.06944593042135239, 0.09254635125398636, 0.7056527137756348, 0.06638876348733902, 0.45796215534210205, 0.6178392171859741, -0.5744504332542419, -0.012934623286128044, 0.42519038915634155, -0.21544583141803741, 0.4251422584056854, -1.1031267642974854, -0.13805042207241058, -0.47837376594543457, 0.3946607708930969, -0.9655703902244568, -0.1906936913728714, 0.331055611371994, -0.31214985251426697, 0.2484775334596634, 0.008550301194190979, -0.43925705552101135, -0.18530242145061493, -0.634038507938385, 0.46518903970718384, 0.5309854745864868, -0.21311697363853455, 0.8597784042358398, -0.04394865781068802, -0.12305592000484467, -0.5060330033302307, -0.8046236634254456, -0.3453980088233948, -0.19045504927635193, -0.9120203852653503, 0.589501142501831, 0.304899662733078, -0.07619258761405945, 0.11128474026918411, -0.4994733929634094, 0.09418847411870956, 0.0597248338162899, 0.26247674226760864, 0.05292045697569847, -0.4049590826034546, 0.12477888911962509, 0.3907172679901123, -0.23565459251403809, 0.2725740969181061, -0.6366389989852905, 0.5704241394996643, 0.05732731148600578, -0.2398388385772705, -0.4983866810798645, 0.3974745571613312, 0.40760084986686707, -0.5044088363647461, 0.49644413590431213, 0.7320259809494019, -0.19404076039791107, -0.630731999874115, -0.22969786822795868, -0.5744062066078186, -0.5227200984954834, 0.42953062057495117, -0.5770278573036194, -1.1866406202316284, 0.30113673210144043, -0.07962004095315933, 0.02372349426150322, 0.46971869468688965, 0.591827392578125, -0.22890466451644897, 1.1963144540786743, 0.5873487591743469, 0.013500896282494068, 0.6990510821342468, -0.4056413769721985, 0.3111402988433838, -0.765670895576477, -0.14440543949604034, -0.3904942572116852, -0.5930163264274597, -0.66452956199646, -0.495415598154068, 0.4124264717102051, 0.28117331862449646, -0.2527582347393036, 0.3718361258506775, -0.8903094530105591, 0.326626181602478, 0.5682057738304138, 0.06587289273738861, 0.2584998607635498, 0.25873303413391113, -0.06055720895528793, -0.06509558111429214, -0.8688502907752991, -0.40312692523002625, 0.8232969641685486, 0.626040518283844, 0.7278303503990173, 0.09570058435201645, 0.9116519093513489, -0.087563656270504, 0.20759853720664978, -1.1522595882415771, 0.25909897685050964, 0.06830991059541702, -0.369201123714447, -0.48899614810943604, -0.2664629817008972, -1.0264414548873901, 0.43749210238456726, 0.04167592152953148, -0.19491052627563477, 0.4786216914653778, -0.17740382254123688, -0.29940497875213623, -0.48250043392181396, -0.6012529730796814, 0.7767525315284729, 0.23615196347236633, -0.06474266201257706, -0.29683005809783936, -0.7837762832641602, 0.47119688987731934, 0.006273546721786261, 0.16723115742206573, 0.26764094829559326, -0.194907546043396, 0.5328115820884705, -0.22418886423110962, 0.7927426695823669, 0.12840506434440613, -0.08608552068471909, 0.1684144288301468, 0.04639448970556259, 0.7757647633552551, 0.30672821402549744, 0.5858809947967529, 0.11300821602344513, -0.2806624174118042, -0.6450477242469788, -0.9093295335769653, 0.2763432562351227, -0.6824364066123962, -0.66000896692276, -0.3870980739593506, -0.3763110339641571, -0.10500041395425797, 0.23162181675434113, 0.1900164633989334, 0.07335074990987778, -0.1511959433555603, 0.3173891007900238, 1.0299720764160156, 0.23068466782569885, 0.3331860899925232, 0.33907487988471985, -0.05751702934503555, -0.5168599486351013, 0.7776882648468018, 0.07878800481557846, 0.31885766983032227, 0.7155699133872986, 0.08113991469144821, -0.00048006282304413617, -0.24960649013519287, -0.22655515372753143, 0.18110036849975586, -0.5051836967468262, -0.1083245500922203, -1.011020302772522, -0.4308583438396454, -0.27648794651031494, -0.08058580756187439, -0.34400075674057007, -0.8569313883781433, 0.016726244240999222, -0.14905259013175964, -0.15726515650749207, 0.573075532913208, 0.36071962118148804, 0.2820430099964142, -0.8428988456726074, 0.6657542586326599, 0.5344821214675903, 0.10227160155773163, -0.0404331311583519, -0.6619925498962402, -0.44962504506111145, -0.2812268137931824, -0.2711302936077118, -0.49447426199913025, 0.20716619491577148, 0.43442070484161377, 0.47157835960388184, 0.7239764332771301, -0.19678916037082672, 0.6700465083122253, -0.8518405556678772, 0.44781917333602905, 0.10942772030830383, -1.065959095954895, 0.7177718281745911, -0.3370574712753296, 0.4163190722465515, 0.35238906741142273, 0.8115336894989014, -0.5634746551513672, -0.7461758255958557, -0.7209843993186951, -0.9852093458175659, 0.5890632271766663, 0.31651443243026733, 0.1954512745141983, -0.10339546948671341, 0.1766933798789978, -0.08279697597026825, 0.3914785087108612, -0.8203368782997131, -0.2213706225156784, -0.48432889580726624, -0.33022087812423706, 0.3837405741214752, -0.41592904925346375, -0.4037446975708008, -0.08981067687273026, 0.30104169249534607, -0.023205740377306938, 0.27640077471733093, 0.44462332129478455, -0.30354127287864685, -0.05215249955654144, 0.4471462368965149, 0.38199397921562195, 0.2948417663574219, 0.2187158316373825, 0.29037603735923767, -0.09934021532535553, -0.517574667930603, 0.04593871906399727, -0.16228093206882477, -0.49600958824157715, 0.19231249392032623, 0.5283828973770142, 0.6291760802268982, 0.7077838182449341, -0.2182164192199707, 0.6518775820732117, -0.062028344720602036, -0.3182239830493927, -0.31429457664489746, 0.20884817838668823, 0.09033270925283432, 0.3088352382183075, 0.40106213092803955, 0.11197894811630249, 0.4555221199989319, -0.5116350650787354, 0.33259767293930054, 0.3588951528072357, -0.4348296523094177, -0.6241264939308167, 0.3753056824207306, 0.0019681553822010756, -0.13129892945289612, 0.5202465057373047, 0.0052604409866034985, -0.5918106436729431, 0.2950176000595093, 0.4505293667316437, 1.0267202854156494, -0.47413888573646545, 0.1524931639432907, 0.403369277715683, 0.5276116132736206, -0.22447943687438965, 0.2962583303451538, -0.46907058358192444, -0.6971234083175659, -0.6273161172866821, -0.7762154340744019, -0.08433298021554947, -0.6872801184654236, -0.9928362965583801, 0.19526517391204834, -0.6176804304122925, 0.09693123400211334, 0.057407088577747345, -0.6520990133285522, -0.4843011796474457, 0.059010058641433716, -0.09674924612045288, 0.4975186288356781, -0.7600512504577637, 0.9525710344314575, 0.6818806529045105, -0.5304407477378845, -0.7705126404762268, 0.11017335206270218, -0.5249322056770325, -0.7231456637382507, 0.6918020844459534, 0.3099457323551178, 0.26733872294425964, 0.3101745843887329, -0.4858046770095825, -1.0828956365585327, 1.2587958574295044, 0.06244576349854469, -1.0703139305114746, -0.30416759848594666, 0.40559980273246765, 0.6213894486427307, -0.08411944657564163, 0.08661267161369324, 0.4843362867832184, 0.39222660660743713, -0.1685352921485901, -0.4628986120223999, 0.23113928735256195, 0.048962246626615524, 0.30754709243774414, 0.49534496665000916, -0.8305525779724121, 0.5445905327796936, 0.22548876702785492, -0.8316898345947266, -0.24088503420352936, 0.9281386137008667, 0.15384651720523834, 0.040103979408741, 0.3877007067203522, 0.9400660395622253, 0.4784248173236847, -0.24973183870315552, 0.9228485822677612, -0.41026923060417175, 0.2533811926841736, 0.7937591671943665, 0.12658266723155975, 0.7135388255119324, 0.6565836071968079, -0.4586399793624878, 0.7400839924812317, 0.17158642411231995, -0.27886703610420227, 0.6915194392204285, 0.3735487163066864, -0.17040228843688965, -0.1084916964173317, -0.10703165829181671, -0.2836672365665436, 0.28556108474731445, 0.26485541462898254, -0.5445987582206726, 0.02272973209619522, -0.0393579937517643, -0.49152034521102905, 0.07802576571702957, -0.22971156239509583, 0.9570794105529785, 0.4469531774520874, -0.30777105689048767, 0.45700570940971375, 0.018209366127848625, 0.6365121603012085, -0.7298094630241394, 0.03756934776902199, -0.20391082763671875, -0.045169711112976074, -0.5064799189567566, -0.2776085138320923, 0.4991638958454132, -0.5357258915901184, -0.6448692679405212, -0.3584461212158203, 0.5571105480194092, -0.5283893942832947, -0.4462798237800598, -0.10346096009016037, 0.19711382687091827, -0.2802390158176422, -0.3260370194911957, -0.46457135677337646, -0.15983253717422485, -0.051369305700063705, -0.5008195638656616, 0.422412633895874, 0.8544822335243225, -0.2555669844150543, 0.45727792382240295, 0.7581965327262878, -0.18033504486083984, 0.24630779027938843, 0.4008791148662567, 1.186914324760437, -0.9565321803092957, -0.6202320456504822, -0.7398982048034668, 0.8621099591255188, 0.01228842232376337, -0.02791370451450348, 0.9313851594924927, 0.6107147336006165, 0.930812656879425, -0.2207695096731186, 0.7050176858901978, 0.24068260192871094, 0.12436176836490631, -0.3798341155052185, 0.42317065596580505, -0.16306328773498535, 0.07153929024934769, -0.04425419867038727, -1.4006690979003906, -0.33993032574653625, 0.9359563589096069, -0.14006319642066956, -0.24227839708328247, 1.182814359664917, 0.7076005339622498, -0.0395018495619297, -0.024908380582928658, 0.32625406980514526, 0.30798768997192383, 0.08460777252912521, 0.36523357033729553, 1.1290580034255981, -0.6026774048805237, 0.6055035591125488, -0.2732350826263428, -0.15994122624397278, 0.017730796709656715, -0.0781182199716568, -0.9727276563644409, -0.2983241677284241, -0.3352445065975189, -0.27182894945144653, -0.05933640897274017, 0.3567298948764801, 0.5942419767379761, -0.8621720671653748, 0.1554594784975052, -0.5629090070724487, 0.0499250628054142, -0.2734505832195282, -0.3784562945365906, 0.43388932943344116, -0.6593075394630432, -0.773140549659729, 0.3249054551124573, 0.7169036865234375, -0.14436660706996918, -0.5187079906463623, 0.3347562551498413, 0.19004230201244354, 0.07453959435224533, 0.7247747182846069, -0.12855765223503113, -0.7212705612182617, -0.15678487718105316, 0.21400229632854462, -0.4499627947807312, 0.1545039564371109, 1.0191330909729004, -0.5881426930427551, 0.024705994874238968, 0.5762541890144348, 0.4888574481010437, 0.638353168964386, 0.25648000836372375, 0.5015039443969727, -1.0169862508773804, 0.26188722252845764, 0.5464410781860352, 0.1782284528017044, -0.03598017245531082, -0.3641911745071411, 0.5900169610977173, 0.16169369220733643, -0.4390506446361542, -0.643477201461792, 0.508014440536499, -1.026818037033081, -0.0378601960837841, 0.9491997361183167, -0.08047442138195038, -0.5218048095703125, -0.07282469421625137, -0.013629348017275333, 0.14832961559295654, -0.35599902272224426, 0.7977443337440491, 0.500264585018158, 0.14049020409584045, -0.05476628988981247, -0.2452099323272705, 0.5208931565284729, 0.772050678730011, -0.4589571952819824, -0.23410561680793762, 0.11754751950502396, 0.15208765864372253, 0.37105709314346313, 0.182763934135437, -0.2637922465801239, 0.36695757508277893, 0.040318507701158524, 0.15753428637981415, 0.22312021255493164, -0.418070524930954, -0.46338799595832825, 0.4391653537750244, -0.07357297092676163, -0.14712123572826385 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06457v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06457v1	V-STaR: Training Verifiers for Self-Taught Reasoners	2024-02-09T15:02:56	2024-02-09T15:02:56	Arian Hosseini, Xingdi Yuan, Nikolay Malkin, Aaron Courville, Alessandro Sordoni, Rishabh Agarwal	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	Common self-improvement approaches for large language models (LLMs), such as STaR (Zelikman et al., 2022), iteratively fine-tune LLMs on self-generated solutions to improve their problem-solving ability. However, these approaches discard the large amounts of incorrect solutions generated during this process, potentially neglecting valuable information in such solutions. To address this shortcoming, we propose V-STaR that utilizes both the correct and incorrect solutions generated during the self-improvement process to train a verifier using DPO that judges correctness of model-generated solutions. This verifier is used at inference time to select one solution among many candidate solutions. Running V-STaR for multiple iterations results in progressively better reasoners and verifiers, delivering a 4% to 17% test accuracy improvement over existing self-improvement and verification approaches on common code generation and math reasoning benchmarks with LLaMA2 models.	[ -0.21436838805675507, -0.5398879647254944, 0.8667605519294739, 0.020972171798348427, -0.12095530331134796, 0.2631441652774811, -0.1346670389175415, -0.19313707947731018, -0.03333091363310814, 0.5318058133125305, -0.6310743689537048, -0.15160667896270752, -0.727089524269104, 0.3617246448993683, -0.09639514982700348, 0.6832250952720642, -0.16916881501674652, 0.3687562644481659, -0.3820151090621948, 0.24006478488445282, -0.6711099743843079, -0.5626785755157471, -0.24514663219451904, -0.43910738825798035, 0.43317776918411255, 1.0060263872146606, 0.2588008642196655, 0.9132205247879028, 0.5879529714584351, 0.41254904866218567, 0.12751688063144684, 0.35649269819259644, -0.5401715040206909, 0.17231599986553192, -0.4454825818538666, -0.6314180493354797, -0.23186452686786652, -0.1305508315563202, 0.21774905920028687, 0.20993900299072266, -0.06678285449743271, 0.3402003049850464, -0.24951805174350739, 0.6432526707649231, -0.827079176902771, -0.02897397242486477, -0.7789528369903564, -0.08253097534179688, 0.03444221615791321, -0.2792975902557373, -0.39307352900505066, -0.3356896638870239, -0.36003851890563965, -0.5293356776237488, 0.2839820981025696, -0.24789613485336304, 0.871232807636261, 0.6678515076637268, -0.32635462284088135, -0.2592303156852722, -1.0857912302017212, 0.9705389738082886, -0.6454024910926819, 0.3198118507862091, 0.2720892131328583, 0.8318817019462585, -0.20500004291534424, -0.6434243321418762, -0.9913346767425537, -0.1083383709192276, 0.17685769498348236, 0.2318200170993805, -0.03702227398753166, 0.009635080583393574, 0.39759042859077454, 0.3748307526111603, -0.19943197071552277, 0.3558036983013153, -0.4439133107662201, -0.3264807462692261, 0.7994114756584167, 0.15620996057987213, -0.13333773612976074, -0.21442976593971252, -0.48601388931274414, -0.029200350865721703, -0.6834911108016968, 0.14919127523899078, 0.10889173299074173, -0.031089963391423225, 0.43419528007507324, 0.5868525505065918, -0.5420345664024353, 0.7870002388954163, 0.09980715811252594, -0.5174571871757507, 0.304144948720932, -0.26370877027511597, -0.16494444012641907, -0.14254876971244812, 0.5318941473960876, 0.3148426115512848, 0.3401072919368744, 0.11234015971422195, -0.4190746545791626, 0.3354834318161011, 0.31632566452026367, -0.8623701930046082, -0.1276872158050537, 0.36987394094467163, -0.02086925320327282, -0.3676948845386505, -0.34670931100845337, -0.6026560664176941, -0.316401869058609, -0.7135291695594788, 0.6151502132415771, -0.1464703381061554, -0.10127335041761398, 0.3419647216796875, -0.1443995237350464, 0.01933731511235237, 0.5393604636192322, -0.7314938306808472, -0.05086756497621536, 0.7733319997787476, 0.41130203008651733, 0.25087589025497437, -0.42508605122566223, -0.834805965423584, -0.16103777289390564, -0.4846552312374115, 0.9235813021659851, -0.4514144957065582, -0.25774070620536804, -0.005542401224374771, -0.22817674279212952, 0.05551745742559433, -0.5122784376144409, 0.6696906089782715, -0.37676066160202026, 0.10099059343338013, -0.6716967225074768, -0.8044423460960388, 0.012833898887038231, 0.4125017523765564, -0.10171940922737122, 0.9953786134719849, 0.12257116287946701, -0.34018462896347046, 0.490649938583374, -0.16500186920166016, 0.23249571025371552, 0.1600683182477951, -0.44574615359306335, -0.5148676633834839, 0.21910753846168518, 0.44785308837890625, 0.5043288469314575, -0.32725316286087036, 0.10234357416629791, -0.3066386878490448, -0.40017589926719666, 0.0532773919403553, -0.24844159185886383, 0.38118624687194824, 0.3158571720123291, -0.3721313178539276, 0.1250028908252716, -1.063549518585205, 0.31051671504974365, 0.3638593852519989, -0.38934558629989624, -0.2931268513202667, -0.05238814651966095, -0.48039892315864563, 0.39237353205680847, 0.2539154589176178, -0.7061430215835571, 0.34404319524765015, -0.1551109403371811, 0.3363359272480011, 0.873301088809967, -0.012340536341071129, -0.18062926828861237, -0.23472924530506134, 0.43063169717788696, 0.1572829782962799, 0.2016674429178238, -0.18870726227760315, -0.26128947734832764, -1.2138867378234863, -0.2658773958683014, 0.09565860778093338, 0.5808048248291016, -0.8195550441741943, 0.3687918186187744, -0.0704292356967926, -0.9603469371795654, -0.43507882952690125, 0.5785651803016663, 0.6277027726173401, 0.8101840615272522, 0.4580616056919098, 0.17139893770217896, -0.4950220286846161, -0.7389374375343323, -0.32456833124160767, -0.25091201066970825, 0.3117259740829468, 0.13775847852230072, 0.7040723562240601, -0.46565523743629456, 0.868240237236023, -0.23601393401622772, -0.052267055958509445, -0.11148551851511002, -0.2731972336769104, 0.28205740451812744, 0.2819065749645233, 0.6155257821083069, -0.43670743703842163, -0.49389487504959106, -0.04256031662225723, -0.8116159439086914, -0.11415696889162064, -0.07109034061431885, 0.12010637670755386, 0.17646312713623047, 0.4385334849357605, -0.13146081566810608, 0.13187530636787415, 0.5266318321228027, -0.5995895862579346, 0.7636504173278809, -0.4842339754104614, 0.31026020646095276, -0.8489058613777161, -0.27251240611076355, 0.12407419085502625, -0.4485698938369751, -0.4524771571159363, -0.1256302148103714, 0.10175799578428268, -0.0057332576252520084, -0.11752203106880188, 0.3582746982574463, -0.3771604001522064, 0.21540330350399017, -0.5817667245864868, 0.26614704728126526, -0.1299726516008377, 0.28105467557907104, 0.028543155640363693, 0.8677418828010559, 0.7049720287322998, -0.7647354006767273, 0.5456792712211609, 0.2306676208972931, -0.17689843475818634, 0.7267874479293823, -0.8332251310348511, 0.23914386332035065, -0.3826339542865753, -0.20622380077838898, -1.108740210533142, -0.20403437316417694, 0.261470764875412, -0.3630297780036926, 0.1012820154428482, -0.13526226580142975, -0.2736189067363739, -0.7916606068611145, 0.10821928083896637, 0.029033010825514793, 0.5318033695220947, -1.1206181049346924, 0.2607402205467224, 0.14027923345565796, 0.03538002446293831, -1.035526990890503, -0.2671864330768585, -0.04762989282608032, -0.027672959491610527, -0.5373506546020508, 0.11156813055276871, -0.22647623717784882, -0.2536770701408386, -0.24631240963935852, -0.43857482075691223, -0.12007163465023041, 0.18857236206531525, 0.22538071870803833, 0.10370021313428879, -0.13746097683906555, 0.45109543204307556, -0.012833514250814915, -0.6179602742195129, 0.13205155730247498, -0.14840903878211975, 0.2466224879026413, -0.44311103224754333, -0.5141100287437439, -0.4186674952507019, 0.08577889949083328, 0.6337254643440247, -0.39659175276756287, 0.3549695909023285, 0.2359931319952011, -0.21784313023090363, -0.5344125032424927, -0.8488901853561401, -0.21956709027290344, -0.5005335807800293, 0.31809505820274353, -0.741161584854126, -1.001272439956665, 0.33638283610343933, -0.3494425415992737, 0.28361639380455017, 0.44630056619644165, 0.5702745318412781, -0.13308578729629517, 0.8414182662963867, 0.6373311281204224, 0.02854439616203308, 0.23435752093791962, -0.22798624634742737, 0.16034188866615295, -0.3515511751174927, -0.14998570084571838, -0.5902997255325317, -0.026571931317448616, -0.17082329094409943, -0.46233126521110535, 0.13441920280456543, 0.5433753728866577, -0.1910516768693924, 0.4211539030075073, -0.6814704537391663, 0.7482916116714478, 0.4368750751018524, -0.0510876439511776, 0.3697950839996338, -0.10350599884986877, -0.0123950419947505, -0.3031759560108185, -0.7453400492668152, -0.6804158687591553, 1.0519521236419678, 0.5220679044723511, 0.5230981111526489, -0.007793566677719355, 1.0453685522079468, 0.030018474906682968, 0.37085050344467163, -0.7058011293411255, 0.33293014764785767, 0.06078076362609863, -0.5711492300033569, -0.24074114859104156, -0.41216203570365906, -0.48585471510887146, 0.3927440941333771, -0.16923335194587708, -0.6266463398933411, 0.12247887998819351, 0.694848358631134, -0.28352949023246765, 0.11063557863235474, -0.6031317114830017, 1.198352575302124, -0.5289797186851501, -0.34803539514541626, -0.46004989743232727, -0.03695729002356529, 0.40587759017944336, -0.19874896109104156, 0.10456600040197372, -0.03810722380876541, 0.15804792940616608, 0.37193790078163147, -1.0111929178237915, 0.7382041811943054, -0.3695013225078583, -0.14480501413345337, 0.4826076924800873, -0.03778885304927826, 0.7599533796310425, 0.3239264190196991, 0.0056861513294279575, 0.1331525295972824, -0.10817934572696686, -0.3552183210849762, -0.7214643359184265, 0.6495867967605591, -0.9269804954528809, -1.1075572967529297, -0.45643091201782227, -0.015228264965116978, -0.07100971043109894, 0.23993749916553497, 0.2901802659034729, 0.21102550625801086, 0.2768702208995819, 0.011568828485906124, 0.6586843729019165, 0.16084036231040955, 0.3702794909477234, 0.7534528970718384, -0.26906439661979675, -0.596875011920929, 0.884670615196228, 0.07610829919576645, 0.30712151527404785, 0.12596097588539124, 0.38554897904396057, -0.25379839539527893, -0.7036536335945129, -0.5275999903678894, 0.3712223768234253, -1.1312077045440674, -0.2809157073497772, -0.38845372200012207, -0.24849477410316467, -0.1124776229262352, -0.1891723871231079, -0.8330042362213135, -0.3008187413215637, 0.07987242937088013, -0.0983886793255806, 0.4856952726840973, 0.706323504447937, -0.22061070799827576, 0.3389407694339752, -0.6139204502105713, 0.2039424479007721, 0.6122114658355713, 0.28871434926986694, -0.5575202107429504, -0.6550549268722534, -0.21415866911411285, -0.14900043606758118, -0.2766353189945221, -0.7524622082710266, 0.05318334698677063, 0.099949911236763, 0.7487928867340088, 0.14203999936580658, -0.15872684121131897, 0.8240504860877991, -0.4155403673648834, 0.7413767576217651, 0.2943691611289978, -1.0313875675201416, 0.9676710963249207, -0.07876010984182358, 0.028602033853530884, 0.6032425761222839, 0.280417799949646, -0.3203095495700836, -0.2562148869037628, -0.4985848069190979, -0.37658587098121643, 0.30081430077552795, 0.09771992266178131, -0.05963306874036789, -0.039322588592767715, 0.7455946207046509, 0.21108971536159515, -0.11468257755041122, -0.7141823172569275, -0.42405280470848083, -0.4499906003475189, 0.142082080245018, -0.2986331582069397, -0.557245671749115, -0.06702125817537308, -0.15249477326869965, 1.0095680952072144, -0.39828893542289734, -0.04179532080888748, 0.513276994228363, -0.00498989736661315, -0.33083096146583557, 0.2665627896785736, 0.6561063528060913, 0.8990901708602905, 0.12259595096111298, 0.11928004771471024, 0.2325925976037979, -0.24330012500286102, 0.5719916820526123, -0.08545078337192535, -0.10916086286306381, 0.18195731937885284, 0.17996886372566223, 0.663080632686615, -0.17187446355819702, -0.4783933460712433, 0.6109722256660461, -0.3112221360206604, -0.37119269371032715, -0.6779382228851318, 0.5343499183654785, 0.000401984405471012, 0.33792993426322937, 0.024126911535859108, 0.3092142641544342, -0.16348059475421906, -0.091550312936306, 0.2058618813753128, 0.15704581141471863, -0.49242883920669556, -0.12493796646595001, 0.6393377184867859, 0.35313573479652405, -0.476895809173584, 0.5180751085281372, -0.23967719078063965, -0.5457542538642883, 0.5056847333908081, 0.5502108335494995, 0.7117326259613037, -0.34334731101989746, 0.3018895983695984, 0.8496087789535522, 0.2118234634399414, -0.28110504150390625, 0.5653722286224365, -0.13633057475090027, -0.7970619797706604, -0.777202844619751, -0.4837007224559784, -0.4547772705554962, 0.287031888961792, -0.2835831046104431, 0.44171494245529175, -0.6032025218009949, -0.12884630262851715, 0.071430504322052, -0.06369245052337646, -0.7317601442337036, 0.3890126347541809, 0.16265392303466797, 0.868358314037323, -0.8419129252433777, 0.7691594958305359, 0.6896102428436279, -0.4878953993320465, -0.9593602418899536, -0.3715021014213562, 0.058996111154556274, -0.7090211510658264, 0.9283499717712402, 0.16673636436462402, -0.1568327695131302, -0.03832137957215309, -0.288375586271286, -1.058972716331482, 1.0739761590957642, 0.49407002329826355, -1.394781470298767, 0.5027667880058289, 0.126886785030365, 0.4683935344219208, -0.1763034611940384, 0.29893749952316284, 0.43673011660575867, 0.2823154032230377, 0.1951761096715927, -0.9379623532295227, -0.2013562023639679, -0.2814980149269104, 0.060275208204984665, -0.03572700172662735, -0.6752894520759583, 0.5647268295288086, -0.5404065251350403, -0.026716290041804314, -0.12098164111375809, 0.8392885327339172, 0.6294131278991699, 0.12939347326755524, 0.6607089638710022, 0.6927312016487122, 1.010756492614746, -0.14775116741657257, 1.0225225687026978, -0.41533979773521423, 0.4431714415550232, 1.126089096069336, -0.044971123337745667, 0.6625643372535706, 0.6548877358436584, 0.06140652671456337, 0.5041056275367737, 0.4177215099334717, -0.11641945689916611, 0.31120315194129944, 0.4222111701965332, -0.21196290850639343, -0.995766282081604, 0.23952814936637878, -0.33172091841697693, 0.6469953060150146, 0.09957608580589294, -0.2816663384437561, -0.3158521056175232, -0.07716841250658035, -0.06859792768955231, 0.55356764793396, -0.3475647270679474, 0.4107225835323334, 0.1519566774368286, -0.9213384389877319, 0.9038137197494507, -0.0391363725066185, 0.4193185269832611, -0.37933123111724854, -0.1973358541727066, -0.12670321762561798, 0.8029791712760925, -0.1628967523574829, -0.580974280834198, 0.1376197636127472, 0.15703393518924713, -0.32159215211868286, -0.23130595684051514, 0.9117774367332458, -0.1289401650428772, -0.6015132665634155, 0.12169629335403442, 0.4864703416824341, 0.0675683319568634, 0.11060895025730133, -0.6379972696304321, -0.04965498670935631, 0.058985576033592224, -0.3302993178367615, -0.22564618289470673, 0.4530230462551117, 0.14067117869853973, 0.9183706045150757, 0.44445377588272095, 0.09573861211538315, 0.09424368292093277, 0.2475622445344925, 0.7398594617843628, -0.6036531329154968, -0.36388540267944336, -0.982850193977356, 0.8730906844139099, -0.20982256531715393, -0.7804757356643677, 0.9812453389167786, 0.3506150245666504, 1.1888775825500488, -0.2685898244380951, 0.985348105430603, 0.1890926957130432, 0.6802811026573181, -0.5285534262657166, 0.2709265351295471, -0.44824814796447754, 0.4305458664894104, -0.04460419714450836, -0.9119600057601929, -0.06352382153272629, 0.6473751664161682, -0.35431328415870667, -0.05151500925421715, 0.447278767824173, 0.7317601442337036, 0.13623543083667755, -0.2425607293844223, 0.48624154925346375, 0.11790747195482254, 0.6805110573768616, 0.6989157199859619, 1.0720531940460205, -0.7071582078933716, 0.4632919132709503, -0.5107438564300537, -0.37304672598838806, -0.2640098035335541, -0.8041033744812012, -1.1740596294403076, -0.43488621711730957, -0.7769044041633606, -0.292379230260849, 0.11532004177570343, 0.8211148977279663, 0.6575705409049988, -0.6520589590072632, -0.00012606859672814608, -0.4558432102203369, 0.15130622684955597, -0.4532132148742676, -0.07849354296922684, -0.17164619266986847, -0.92817622423172, -0.5155007243156433, 0.6315881013870239, 0.08099997788667679, -0.07902003079652786, -0.529888927936554, -0.42253947257995605, 0.47885942459106445, 0.13031695783138275, 0.35279253125190735, 0.4134945273399353, -0.8649169206619263, -0.7542029619216919, 0.047721799463033676, -0.20484094321727753, 0.09772907197475433, 0.5658072829246521, -0.8779876232147217, 0.7918350100517273, 0.5453827381134033, 0.6369802951812744, 0.3590102791786194, -0.2109999805688858, 0.559203565120697, -0.4322790503501892, -0.2917648255825043, 0.026288524270057678, 0.5906112194061279, 0.13207241892814636, -0.34430909156799316, 0.4055960178375244, 0.5013566613197327, -0.9059555530548096, -0.7782201170921326, 0.4092999994754791, -0.769202709197998, -0.09691077470779419, 1.011613130569458, -0.2071545124053955, -0.3592310845851898, 0.09015665203332901, -0.15198048949241638, 0.030162757262587547, -0.07107304036617279, 1.1335794925689697, 0.543690025806427, 0.08777681738138199, -0.25524479150772095, -0.38415947556495667, 0.5686646699905396, 0.5011351108551025, -0.873717188835144, 0.16847769916057587, 0.48157307505607605, 0.662196159362793, 0.4294847846031189, 0.6316409111022949, 0.10395599901676178, 0.5358117818832397, 0.16630633175373077, 0.20499904453754425, -0.42705169320106506, -0.6238451600074768, -0.3141067326068878, -0.07950372248888016, 0.3965442180633545, -0.22659064829349518 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06443v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06443v1	Explaining Veracity Predictions with Evidence Summarization: A Multi-Task Model Approach	2024-02-09T14:39:20	2024-02-09T14:39:20	Recep Firat Cekinel, Pinar Karagoz	cs.CL	cs.CL	The rapid dissemination of misinformation through social media increased the importance of automated fact-checking. Furthermore, studies on what deep neural models pay attention to when making predictions have increased in recent years. While significant progress has been made in this field, it has not yet reached a level of reasoning comparable to human reasoning. To address these gaps, we propose a multi-task explainable neural model for misinformation detection. Specifically, this work formulates an explanation generation process of the model's veracity prediction as a text summarization problem. Additionally, the performance of the proposed model is discussed on publicly available datasets and the findings are evaluated with related studies.	[ -0.1308763027191162, -0.7269459962844849, 0.8504263162612915, 0.1584767997264862, -0.15462170541286469, -0.32807013392448425, -0.028512602671980858, -0.4240148365497589, 0.04899217560887337, 0.35551026463508606, -0.6662605404853821, -0.45580458641052246, -0.9930956959724426, -0.014631362631917, -0.7477211356163025, 1.1165447235107422, 0.11410534381866455, -0.1172090396285057, -0.23861464858055115, 0.1720152050256729, -0.7307051420211792, -0.21673572063446045, -0.3676547110080719, -0.4479188621044159, 0.45152547955513, 0.6416115164756775, 0.7141786217689514, 0.6867907643318176, 0.24410328269004822, 0.3337322473526001, 0.011263678781688213, 0.42536646127700806, -0.1022932305932045, 0.111696258187294, -0.11043907701969147, -0.7328378558158875, -0.299885630607605, -0.03164702281355858, 0.49602311849594116, 0.5183156132698059, -0.044814568012952805, 0.07038760185241699, -0.0017865552799776196, 0.3441576361656189, -0.5821767449378967, 0.08457615971565247, -0.7258470058441162, -0.26910412311553955, 0.12650717794895172, -0.4008907079696655, -0.3858895003795624, -0.3214709758758545, 0.3482961058616638, -0.46805649995803833, 0.6128249764442444, -0.04514944180846214, 0.6502975821495056, 0.28088727593421936, -0.45024505257606506, -0.3855193555355072, -0.759661853313446, 0.6702784299850464, -0.8516340255737305, 0.1645878702402115, 0.5308756828308105, 0.23717479407787323, 0.07255342602729797, -0.5486089587211609, -0.748217761516571, -0.09054604172706604, -0.24897345900535583, 0.010465542785823345, -0.31605416536331177, -0.20085027813911438, 0.05492240935564041, 0.013272106647491455, -0.6138138175010681, -0.2579200565814972, -0.37160834670066833, -0.2896781265735626, 0.617438554763794, 0.0448177307844162, 0.18869833648204803, -0.30440476536750793, -0.26515835523605347, 0.42027315497398376, -0.3603058457374573, -0.25278934836387634, 0.22674773633480072, 0.1496453583240509, -0.1298089325428009, 0.6588452458381653, -0.3706253468990326, 0.4930090308189392, 0.07361996173858643, -0.25660017132759094, -0.0766228511929512, -0.7379110455513, -0.22972705960273743, 0.4365197718143463, 0.6477709412574768, 0.7654397487640381, -0.0188937708735466, -0.06288468837738037, -0.11642719060182571, 0.16731394827365875, 0.359651118516922, -0.92498379945755, -0.011612096801400185, 0.5260335206985474, -0.829535961151123, -0.4521302878856659, -0.12507474422454834, -0.7631728053092957, -0.8062635660171509, -0.4792747497558594, 0.5006747245788574, -0.6747636795043945, -0.4393296241760254, 0.1724194586277008, -0.5371661186218262, -0.5263274312019348, 0.6492626070976257, -0.713981032371521, -0.038750965148210526, 0.5730772018432617, 1.0891965627670288, 0.05693402141332626, -0.4974241554737091, -0.2717953026294708, 0.16604559123516083, -0.4285086691379547, 1.1264629364013672, -0.05021760240197182, -0.01404056791216135, -0.06091995909810066, 0.0020055121276527643, -0.07592791318893433, -0.20688454806804657, 0.5125734806060791, -0.3302052915096283, 0.2149430513381958, -0.5325506925582886, -0.5077494978904724, -0.5794894099235535, 0.3793739676475525, -0.738633930683136, 0.5783444046974182, -0.2716691792011261, -1.3190255165100098, 0.4529690742492676, -0.7154770493507385, -0.5143637657165527, -0.06245080754160881, 0.2256367951631546, -0.4056589603424072, 0.15397603809833527, 0.32741984724998474, 0.7059734463691711, -0.3224315047264099, 0.7338767647743225, -0.16031281650066376, -0.3670147955417633, 0.5413426160812378, -0.7816528677940369, 0.6260284781455994, 0.28083303570747375, -0.5375770926475525, 0.31374815106391907, -0.46745896339416504, -0.4236467778682709, -0.17253586649894714, -0.1898505687713623, -0.4496428072452545, 0.3106420636177063, -0.3035370409488678, 0.10053397715091705, 0.09318847209215164, -0.3343443274497986, -0.31404078006744385, -0.18257591128349304, 0.1023404449224472, 0.38457292318344116, 0.18538837134838104, 0.274400532245636, -0.6902679800987244, 0.027630362659692764, 0.29666391015052795, 0.2716289162635803, -0.4217368960380554, -0.5490016341209412, -0.6118625998497009, 0.22538314759731293, 0.05255698412656784, 0.5364741086959839, -0.7848533987998962, 0.20111210644245148, -0.370394229888916, -0.5779905915260315, -0.46845659613609314, 0.008710009977221489, 0.43741652369499207, 0.5875717997550964, 0.546462893486023, 0.12387813627719879, -0.4952588677406311, -1.0171853303909302, -0.7936429977416992, -0.1186128631234169, 0.026262959465384483, -0.15508683025836945, 0.8640112280845642, -0.05414332449436188, 0.8471159338951111, -0.3266897201538086, -0.04650293290615082, -0.4055630564689636, 0.8019474744796753, 0.23136292397975922, 0.40255647897720337, 0.34388571977615356, -1.100892186164856, -0.12425630539655685, -0.07567594200372696, -0.9149357676506042, 0.16490578651428223, -0.33272892236709595, 0.1701737493276596, 0.05776980519294739, 0.3726028800010681, -0.9363126754760742, 0.7049126625061035, 0.18158890306949615, -0.470327228307724, 0.8808596730232239, -0.2818460762500763, 0.6326853632926941, -1.0506035089492798, -0.09814892709255219, 0.33567243814468384, -0.1278459131717682, -1.0477843284606934, -0.4423694610595703, 0.16403833031654358, 0.23107211291790009, -0.13089227676391602, 0.07224738597869873, -0.44396814703941345, -0.04355751723051071, -0.767431914806366, 0.12058723717927933, 0.008089859038591385, 0.095579594373703, 0.0894118919968605, 0.4657270014286041, 0.41836532950401306, -0.8834841847419739, 0.5130898356437683, 0.03497811406850815, -0.4081324636936188, 0.5430151224136353, -0.8541900515556335, -0.5620008111000061, -0.5826414823532104, 0.3119159936904907, -1.0166205167770386, -0.7106680870056152, 0.04720325022935867, -0.9044257998466492, 0.07829315960407257, -0.20544607937335968, -0.5142443180084229, -0.3596592843532562, -0.1479317843914032, 0.029737839475274086, -0.04469487443566322, -0.5026584267616272, 0.8052810430526733, 0.29244574904441833, -0.28286856412887573, -0.8687043786048889, -0.8743754625320435, 0.12426095455884933, -0.2247389554977417, -0.764281153678894, 0.3837631642818451, -0.11188764125108719, -0.6062589883804321, 0.22298993170261383, -0.24720878899097443, -0.2726835310459137, 0.3191828727722168, 0.3335806131362915, 0.29396840929985046, -0.2194795310497284, 0.6094925999641418, 0.09980393946170807, 0.01860889419913292, 0.3941827416419983, -0.3088368773460388, 0.12691326439380646, -0.011139943264424801, -0.2195383459329605, -0.7868945002555847, 0.5047386884689331, 0.7024455070495605, -0.10197476297616959, 1.1284934282302856, 0.6804265975952148, -0.7544941306114197, -0.10294251888990402, -0.7349148988723755, -0.2750804126262665, -0.3426801860332489, 0.4959128797054291, 0.06254379451274872, -0.3459187150001526, 0.3213278353214264, -0.06230785325169563, 0.06915277987718582, 0.7752171754837036, 0.6632457375526428, -0.037395939230918884, 0.863206148147583, 0.5231579542160034, 0.13835909962654114, 0.250313937664032, -0.0899442732334137, 0.019204426556825638, 0.020393529906868935, -0.41589635610580444, -0.497525155544281, 0.09229041635990143, -0.21102260053157806, -0.472699373960495, 0.2685062289237976, -0.015422151423990726, 0.15184076130390167, 0.2632578909397125, -0.4884600043296814, 0.5828231573104858, 0.6001579165458679, 0.23254935443401337, 0.4388400912284851, -0.1620834916830063, 0.24692077934741974, 0.3639358580112457, -0.7513805031776428, -0.4367363750934601, 1.0426630973815918, 0.40857842564582825, 0.46931177377700806, 0.1357339471578598, 0.3344554901123047, 0.5994438529014587, 0.5194439888000488, -0.3987257480621338, 0.11216243356466293, -0.006585924886167049, -1.0990922451019287, -0.4236203730106354, -0.36273276805877686, -0.4482358694076538, 0.3697793781757355, -0.6406731605529785, -0.49321603775024414, 0.16592629253864288, 0.2544120252132416, -0.5940023064613342, 0.3029704988002777, -0.7415327429771423, 0.7115238904953003, -0.23423431813716888, -0.17186513543128967, -0.688795268535614, -0.7215025424957275, 0.8262391686439514, -0.08774598687887192, 0.7574673891067505, -0.10392965376377106, 0.24797967076301575, 0.8147851228713989, -0.17192824184894562, 1.046568512916565, -0.3230586051940918, 0.09523111581802368, 0.3603972792625427, -0.1475556641817093, 0.5774387717247009, 0.21417854726314545, 0.00909128412604332, -0.1325962096452713, -0.17244596779346466, -0.26335757970809937, -0.4393174946308136, 0.5057913064956665, -0.41763490438461304, -0.3052675426006317, -0.34299108386039734, -1.0083467960357666, 0.08664529025554657, 0.13794347643852234, 0.6239794492721558, 0.4261173903942108, -0.08607731759548187, 0.09616132825613022, 1.0346319675445557, -0.17167207598686218, 0.5992182493209839, 0.5039994716644287, 0.1102578192949295, -0.20265178382396698, 0.7733367085456848, 0.26067328453063965, -0.026495380327105522, 0.32092422246932983, 0.300881028175354, -0.3057408332824707, -0.8107010126113892, -0.1912660002708435, 0.04620003700256348, -0.8685110807418823, -0.13280902802944183, -0.7928695678710938, -0.0762500986456871, -0.5712157487869263, 0.202231302857399, -0.25056183338165283, -0.37193191051483154, -0.29244545102119446, -0.12490247935056686, 0.34333768486976624, 1.1730505228042603, -0.12088260799646378, 0.7455056309700012, -0.7790878415107727, 0.7276406288146973, 0.3596794903278351, 0.2719549238681793, 0.06849029660224915, -0.6004530787467957, -0.6459879875183105, 0.3129490911960602, -0.23446594178676605, -1.4087846279144287, 0.46859878301620483, -0.0904044359922409, 0.6853237152099609, 0.5484161972999573, 0.052104827016592026, 0.36349719762802124, -0.007050450891256332, 0.6527657508850098, 0.345839262008667, -0.9525428414344788, 0.6983511447906494, -0.34896209836006165, 0.14487925171852112, 0.3362383246421814, 0.7773686647415161, -0.5700386166572571, -0.3229904770851135, -0.6045798063278198, -0.4593665897846222, 0.651053786277771, 0.2575564682483673, -0.21844756603240967, 0.10510280728340149, 0.17464777827262878, 0.4372611939907074, 0.3283834755420685, -0.6548521518707275, -0.4078751504421234, -0.43116745352745056, -0.12692847847938538, -0.09077715128660202, -0.5441807508468628, -0.1753792017698288, -0.12567120790481567, 0.8477542400360107, -0.15606507658958435, 0.3091462552547455, 0.3133515417575836, -0.36360830068588257, -0.05651179328560829, 0.3767506182193756, 0.9133808612823486, 0.9879132509231567, -0.15297432243824005, 0.41941818594932556, 0.08960837870836258, -0.4045991003513336, -0.0972435474395752, 0.42376038432121277, -0.26395174860954285, 0.5634007453918457, 0.6854434609413147, 0.7120563983917236, 0.03988400101661682, -0.18700121343135834, 0.8595506548881531, -0.08030077815055847, -0.48745399713516235, -0.3275459110736847, -0.22752369940280914, 0.3820483088493347, 0.4556567370891571, 0.7361298203468323, 0.5324927568435669, 0.4030323326587677, -0.4723665714263916, 0.18088044226169586, 0.2700481712818146, -0.22783419489860535, -0.2906710207462311, 0.751863420009613, -0.00016696024977136403, 0.09900376200675964, 0.24050144851207733, -0.05218500271439552, -0.6169252395629883, 0.8098655343055725, 0.2871401906013489, 0.6447659730911255, -0.3757708966732025, 0.45100638270378113, 0.4908750355243683, 0.6817509531974792, -0.4807785153388977, 0.2480899542570114, 0.06642615795135498, -0.7391456961631775, -0.7606230974197388, -0.16509342193603516, -0.2071344405412674, 0.2727850079536438, -0.30295124650001526, -0.044764336198568344, -0.030761688947677612, -0.2506234049797058, 0.6854597926139832, -0.3613029718399048, -0.41636794805526733, 0.4672233462333679, 0.0607149675488472, 0.7166635394096375, -1.1562751531600952, 0.579050600528717, 0.0365842841565609, -0.5016570687294006, -0.5263690948486328, 0.3305862247943878, 0.2965043783187866, -0.38756901025772095, 0.5178568959236145, 0.37820738554000854, 0.1068236380815506, -0.5895615816116333, -0.7694779634475708, -0.8380118012428284, 1.2241970300674438, 0.42442625761032104, -0.43957361578941345, -0.10775288194417953, -0.2447996884584427, 0.1904800832271576, -0.42849668860435486, 0.32928746938705444, 0.6408989429473877, 0.7331239581108093, -0.16660888493061066, -0.7102538347244263, 0.04322292283177376, -0.15114735066890717, -0.3097696900367737, -0.16114114224910736, -0.08183570951223373, 1.0579134225845337, -0.5761917233467102, -0.11354182660579681, -0.1703389585018158, 0.8743957877159119, 0.044255487620830536, 0.8591312766075134, 0.5279675722122192, 0.13765257596969604, 0.960987389087677, -0.049173928797245026, 1.181365728378296, -0.18509918451309204, 0.16718506813049316, 1.34848153591156, 0.28491583466529846, 0.36908140778541565, 0.27103179693222046, 0.15679146349430084, 0.5276321768760681, 0.575473964214325, -0.003502448322251439, 0.36049559712409973, -0.07453065365552902, -0.30614152550697327, -0.4035915434360504, -0.4423886835575104, -0.2914251685142517, 0.3609764575958252, 0.5043339133262634, -0.7723320126533508, -0.1922994703054428, -0.048032619059085846, -0.07408910244703293, -0.10426487028598785, -0.54229336977005, 0.49395257234573364, -0.2578728497028351, -0.9877161979675293, 0.34441128373146057, 0.17254582047462463, 0.7212138772010803, -0.46855658292770386, -0.1241811215877533, 0.05702914297580719, 0.011449279263615608, -0.4897914230823517, -0.9131717085838318, 0.5543153882026672, -0.0944843739271164, -0.589370608329773, -0.06779336929321289, 1.129407525062561, -0.679621696472168, -0.25457674264907837, 0.1750551164150238, 0.7057558298110962, 0.22915047407150269, -0.5967936515808105, -0.4765576124191284, -0.29763734340667725, -0.04297487437725067, -0.057674553245306015, -0.055446136742830276, 0.5826596021652222, -0.13051541149616241, 0.7767643332481384, 0.739667534828186, 0.01287160161882639, -0.0021482689771801233, -0.0870051309466362, 0.7510126233100891, -0.318814218044281, -0.5143538117408752, -0.9519240260124207, 0.5481898784637451, -0.46227461099624634, -0.012696039862930775, 0.7449067234992981, 0.44009163975715637, 0.17492610216140747, -0.27602115273475647, 1.2616732120513916, 0.0010222047567367554, 0.6971497535705566, -0.3877728581428528, 1.065276026725769, -0.482188880443573, 0.08394249528646469, -0.1941075623035431, -0.48233795166015625, -0.0899621769785881, 0.29815027117729187, -0.1485733836889267, -0.06516580283641815, 0.978119969367981, 0.5965086817741394, -0.030329948291182518, 0.35658830404281616, 0.224649116396904, 0.36997026205062866, -0.18363028764724731, 0.274535208940506, 0.8286197185516357, -0.30532965064048767, 0.7373428344726562, -0.41381216049194336, -0.19248318672180176, -0.40387919545173645, -1.1213775873184204, -0.9280390739440918, -0.6942723393440247, -0.3243675231933594, -0.5119288563728333, 0.19769145548343658, 0.44636595249176025, 0.8895826935768127, -0.7839268445968628, 0.1736699640750885, -0.27888521552085876, 0.5499581098556519, -0.4017217755317688, -0.20149292051792145, 0.2863282263278961, -0.1452726274728775, -0.23983784019947052, 0.466143399477005, 0.02901723049581051, 0.16280727088451385, 0.04685014858841896, 0.0013853309210389853, -0.5093439221382141, 0.30767276883125305, 0.38880065083503723, -0.0021777183283120394, -0.730046808719635, 0.011920303106307983, -0.23520241677761078, -0.031128214672207832, -0.34185370802879333, 0.8567274808883667, -0.48029810190200806, 0.34525278210639954, 0.5000864863395691, 0.44231024384498596, 0.5388163924217224, 0.11387942731380463, 0.593639612197876, -0.7512211799621582, -0.3334396183490753, -0.045201219618320465, 0.4146025776863098, 0.38447654247283936, -0.7261533737182617, 0.26714852452278137, 0.3685205280780792, -0.49500855803489685, -0.5851945877075195, -0.0693373829126358, -0.6555111408233643, -0.6987295746803284, 0.8707214593887329, -0.17069700360298157, -0.24846412241458893, -0.573003888130188, 0.056464407593011856, 0.6485071182250977, -0.4507320523262024, 0.9456760883331299, 0.7325239181518555, 0.12092775851488113, -0.10267562419176102, -0.8458500504493713, 0.5828700661659241, 0.11338262259960175, -1.1012699604034424, 0.5207358598709106, 0.6794772744178772, 0.4884018898010254, 0.5143532752990723, 0.6213710904121399, 0.1783684939146042, 0.9187331795692444, 0.3103194534778595, 0.1351822018623352, -0.3246481418609619, -0.6865887641906738, -0.196510449051857, 0.34973233938217163, -0.3189834952354431, -0.14081336557865143 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06420v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06420v1	Findings of the First Workshop on Simulating Conversational Intelligence in Chat	2024-02-09T14:08:23	2024-02-09T14:08:23	Yvette Graham, Mohammed Rameez Qureshi, Haider Khalid, Gerasimos Lampouras, Ignacio Iacobacci, Qun Liu	cs.CL	cs.CL	The aim of this workshop is to bring together experts working on open-domain dialogue research. In this speedily advancing research area many challenges still exist, such as learning information from conversations, engaging in realistic and convincing simulation of human intelligence and reasoning. SCI-CHAT follows previous workshops on open domain dialogue but with a focus on the simulation of intelligent conversation as judged in a live human evaluation. Models aim to include the ability to follow a challenging topic over a multi-turn conversation, while positing, refuting and reasoning over arguments. The workshop included both a research track and shared task. The main goal of this paper is to provide an overview of the shared task and a link to an additional paper that will include an in depth analysis of the shared task results following presentation at the workshop.	[ -0.43440136313438416, -0.8826457262039185, 0.5068227052688599, 0.20647713541984558, -0.06425707042217255, 0.3595060706138611, -0.33624884486198425, -0.5575242638587952, 0.3317795693874359, 0.2603422999382019, -0.9308364987373352, -0.4066619873046875, -0.28387659788131714, -0.31698164343833923, -0.26751214265823364, 0.679253876209259, 0.32824745774269104, 0.2655739486217499, -0.7929990291595459, 0.027025192975997925, -0.3681966960430145, -0.9113108515739441, -0.6872297525405884, -0.30545806884765625, 0.3935481905937195, 0.40325450897216797, 0.5405001640319824, -0.15040022134780884, 0.45761314034461975, 0.26774299144744873, 0.10068567097187042, 0.2537931501865387, -0.9113544821739197, 0.1828477680683136, -0.17353752255439758, -0.47002026438713074, -0.6249542832374573, 0.38051119446754456, 0.41123226284980774, 0.8960738778114319, -0.214612677693367, -0.13189612329006195, 0.21541772782802582, 0.04734491556882858, -0.15191137790679932, 0.4924241900444031, -0.48053649067878723, -0.045295484364032745, 0.07712303102016449, -0.31183871626853943, -0.5887335538864136, -0.07901133596897125, 0.48666244745254517, -0.7336758971214294, 0.06875459849834442, 0.43067067861557007, 0.6194278597831726, 0.11078643798828125, -0.21601226925849915, -0.1290930211544037, -1.1369082927703857, 0.8884298205375671, -0.5383865237236023, 0.05296660587191582, 0.4060085713863373, 0.25174400210380554, -0.6540904641151428, -0.9021909832954407, -0.6771041750907898, -0.17801742255687714, 0.0022474033758044243, 0.17442522943019867, -0.3403313159942627, 0.10029186308383942, 0.3469223976135254, -0.02352343499660492, -0.24053546786308289, -0.07921399176120758, -0.7873864769935608, 0.008271385915577412, 0.9113004207611084, 0.39389318227767944, 0.22989283502101898, 0.5599969625473022, -0.16869866847991943, -0.09787892550230026, -0.29298877716064453, 0.03603576868772507, 0.26373568177223206, 0.2239142507314682, -0.1924593299627304, 0.4146530330181122, -0.4795268177986145, 0.20751938223838806, -0.4086402952671051, 0.05341639369726181, 0.2761259377002716, -0.7269485592842102, 0.05007435753941536, -0.1591997742652893, 0.8684487342834473, 0.5670604109764099, 0.3367367386817932, -0.031789474189281464, 0.5016040205955505, -0.007135048042982817, 0.29957515001296997, -0.7592027187347412, -0.4948473572731018, 0.08271293342113495, -0.4720664918422699, -0.2589106857776642, -0.08900230377912521, -0.8143219947814941, -0.08648920804262161, -0.19749867916107178, 0.28550103306770325, -0.4350149631500244, -0.4365132749080658, 0.03841610997915268, -0.1601381152868271, 0.014596424996852875, 0.6493092775344849, -0.5415477156639099, 0.843117356300354, 0.8109035491943359, 0.5395832061767578, -0.13969631493091583, -0.37726208567619324, -0.026627076789736748, -0.060166895389556885, 0.020592696964740753, 0.8800415396690369, -0.5995779633522034, -0.7795324921607971, -0.389270156621933, -0.2607872784137726, -0.1585087925195694, -0.2317909598350525, 0.6942108869552612, -0.1597917079925537, 0.47469741106033325, -0.17386463284492493, -0.4800223112106323, -0.09303407371044159, 0.28970134258270264, -0.2911355793476105, 0.8108611702919006, 0.005952703766524792, -0.8292530179023743, 0.1598009169101715, -1.0888818502426147, -0.11942464113235474, 0.36265742778778076, -0.4475852847099304, -0.031113911420106888, -0.24317452311515808, -0.16502706706523895, 0.003825219115242362, -0.327980637550354, 0.0995011180639267, -0.4535234272480011, -0.38224199414253235, 0.5536224246025085, -0.3761572241783142, 0.7055818438529968, 0.13616716861724854, -0.066813625395298, 0.25685444474220276, -0.34824562072753906, 0.4569289982318878, 0.14741642773151398, 0.25306713581085205, -0.2759115993976593, 0.3925613760948181, -0.299696683883667, 0.05447160825133324, -0.001767727779224515, -0.8795129060745239, 0.3168942928314209, -0.28659534454345703, 0.3168390691280365, 0.3777497708797455, 0.40070641040802, 0.31919506192207336, -0.5269096493721008, 0.27887439727783203, 0.09968122094869614, 0.44555801153182983, -0.06375943869352341, -0.997948944568634, -0.5852277278900146, -0.3097188174724579, 0.2679339051246643, 0.5803398489952087, -0.4417446255683899, 0.018634220585227013, -0.2525780200958252, -0.6408783793449402, -0.6144341826438904, -0.3506016731262207, 0.2697354555130005, 0.04569698125123978, 0.19082996249198914, -0.7486428618431091, -0.45003798604011536, -0.8328501582145691, -0.15477995574474335, -0.3439387381076813, 0.023229161277413368, 0.6118053793907166, 0.5334969162940979, 0.049493394792079926, 1.144006371498108, -0.5137535333633423, -0.02200223319232464, -0.27826160192489624, 0.5740802884101868, -0.1940959393978119, 0.8809410929679871, 0.5593878030776978, -0.6924630403518677, -0.4918651282787323, -0.10496523976325989, -0.6604160666465759, 0.2827794849872589, 0.2188161462545395, -0.4382851719856262, 0.09562750160694122, 0.3623705804347992, -0.899752676486969, 1.0231815576553345, 0.2301260381937027, -0.13184654712677002, 0.4584834575653076, -0.09190395474433899, 0.6961966753005981, -0.8778485059738159, -0.0020626974292099476, -0.43315932154655457, 0.18127129971981049, -0.8838746547698975, -0.2388964295387268, -0.566795289516449, -0.36699163913726807, -0.5421989560127258, 0.6542686820030212, -0.025714892894029617, -0.0434434600174427, -0.1495562195777893, 0.18825730681419373, -0.15469211339950562, 0.8245410323143005, -0.02978653274476528, 0.8709951639175415, 0.40911510586738586, -0.43582767248153687, 0.2829759418964386, 0.4846518039703369, -0.4829726815223694, 0.4497166872024536, -0.7464455962181091, 0.38288071751594543, 0.07104089111089706, 0.38063135743141174, -0.8354164361953735, -0.3427802324295044, 0.4918152391910553, -0.7942681908607483, -0.10374534130096436, 0.12322505563497543, -0.5487179756164551, -0.427753746509552, 0.024615241214632988, 0.4425787329673767, 0.7304596900939941, -0.09603837877511978, 0.6300099492073059, 0.6637489199638367, -0.4317622482776642, -0.35215258598327637, -0.19728484749794006, -0.03592107817530632, 0.0418599471449852, -0.8644327521324158, 0.4975077211856842, -0.3668906092643738, -0.831207275390625, -0.05742231383919716, 0.2790113687515259, -0.21328581869602203, 0.20559810101985931, 0.4509704113006592, 0.2545798420906067, -0.0399785116314888, -0.12866812944412231, -0.01200083363801241, 0.10776282846927643, 0.40220269560813904, -0.03652186319231987, 0.642228901386261, -0.1527830809354782, -0.7180702090263367, -0.7104393243789673, 0.777513325214386, 0.40802615880966187, -0.13073289394378662, 0.8303081393241882, 0.23853687942028046, -0.2866288125514984, -0.08614188432693481, -0.3040885925292969, -0.5279958248138428, -0.4696084260940552, 0.27208423614501953, -0.2777373194694519, -0.9474436640739441, 0.5513821840286255, -0.38005584478378296, 0.3806839883327484, 0.08457056432962418, 0.5935717821121216, -0.5695456266403198, 1.4977723360061646, 0.771185576915741, 0.37618356943130493, 0.2185177206993103, -0.011617687530815601, 0.7025659680366516, -0.3380054235458374, -0.6268388628959656, -0.7699589133262634, -0.3346913754940033, -0.14306001365184784, -0.8329854607582092, 0.26889094710350037, 0.010293588973581791, 0.07186762243509293, -0.024298347532749176, -0.17306023836135864, 0.4718777537345886, 0.7083902359008789, 0.17297150194644928, 0.07523849606513977, -0.14315028488636017, -0.1768219769001007, -0.09048040211200714, -0.7558703422546387, -0.4054115414619446, 0.5539331436157227, 0.24252402782440186, 0.5645139217376709, -0.26961272954940796, 0.4460762143135071, 0.22600007057189941, 0.31948769092559814, -0.6454595923423767, 1.0840343236923218, 0.44273796677589417, -0.5870386362075806, -0.1521778255701065, -0.41317588090896606, -0.7726169228553772, 0.0284387469291687, -0.17953883111476898, -0.9965271353721619, -0.3103899657726288, -0.00826334860175848, -0.09746755659580231, 0.23714837431907654, -0.6216000318527222, 0.9807402491569519, 0.04694005846977234, -0.18981948494911194, -0.7419963479042053, -0.812762975692749, 0.3737718462944031, 0.371073842048645, 0.29940998554229736, -0.348112553358078, 0.5939960479736328, 0.7566940188407898, -0.14765381813049316, 0.9553467035293579, -0.19794297218322754, 0.383668452501297, 0.6280694007873535, 0.10066242516040802, -0.0932711809873581, -0.18914946913719177, 0.08556747436523438, 0.11476986110210419, 0.16041389107704163, -0.6104048490524292, -0.8231887817382812, 0.45953789353370667, -0.990175724029541, -0.9059277176856995, -0.27951937913894653, -0.7719378471374512, -0.27890267968177795, -0.15267615020275116, -0.3836309015750885, 0.4373161196708679, -0.8247693777084351, 0.2264418601989746, 0.6788901090621948, -0.19670376181602478, 0.024340342730283737, 0.3014968931674957, -0.36344456672668457, -0.06622131913900375, 0.6590843796730042, -0.18338586390018463, 0.5050933361053467, -0.04989602789282799, 0.027493862435221672, 0.18374329805374146, -0.38712382316589355, -0.1468685120344162, 0.013684631325304508, -0.6610010862350464, 0.21679547429084778, -0.9020537734031677, -0.5260022282600403, -0.513634204864502, 0.07208342105150223, -0.21081161499023438, -0.739841878414154, -0.26518958806991577, 0.07241588085889816, 0.3854562044143677, 0.7257604002952576, 0.09412646293640137, 0.17120225727558136, -0.7942101359367371, -0.2549292743206024, 0.36537688970565796, 0.04838503524661064, 0.059461046010255814, -0.2055550217628479, -0.2670752704143524, 0.5705065727233887, -0.42837831377983093, -0.4706837832927704, 0.40703222155570984, 0.17335031926631927, 0.9871971011161804, 0.0821160152554512, 0.3193254768848419, 0.6644901633262634, -0.2715461254119873, 1.2059524059295654, 0.04868121072649956, -0.6184524297714233, 0.646906316280365, -0.282188355922699, 0.0612880177795887, 0.7014551758766174, 0.665388286113739, -0.28753823041915894, -0.572090744972229, -0.9026831388473511, -0.397726446390152, 0.7377609014511108, 0.3350328803062439, 0.3167591989040375, -0.020651141181588173, 0.1934775710105896, 0.016046442091464996, 0.05648890882730484, -0.2564721703529358, -0.10030823200941086, 0.04692424088716507, -0.0628136619925499, 0.3035885691642761, -0.04863540455698967, -0.567895233631134, -0.4410610795021057, 0.7688761949539185, -0.15016280114650726, 0.654172420501709, 0.0834876224398613, 0.37435421347618103, -0.06210984289646149, 0.09206513315439224, 0.831230878829956, 0.5433433651924133, -0.19239188730716705, -0.17824824154376984, 0.3200838565826416, -0.4741325080394745, -0.4394007623195648, -0.21021023392677307, 0.23634548485279083, -0.29482993483543396, -0.0013672072673216462, 0.9739439487457275, 0.34052687883377075, -0.9736587405204773, 0.6430250406265259, -0.7350021004676819, -0.5732306838035583, -0.2602263391017914, 0.4099259078502655, 0.06360094994306564, 0.3562068045139313, 0.40059056878089905, 0.42518559098243713, -0.10388306528329849, -0.920672595500946, 0.3951248526573181, 0.48161518573760986, -0.5555636882781982, -0.44345009326934814, 0.45151564478874207, 0.4802427291870117, -0.7716939449310303, 0.8124358057975769, -0.2750565707683563, -0.8637828826904297, 0.5452253222465515, 0.3550764322280884, 0.5493757128715515, 0.0019596125930547714, 0.06406854093074799, 0.22520284354686737, -0.05558290705084801, 0.2847922742366791, 0.5677591562271118, -0.28182148933410645, -0.6982945203781128, -0.37472572922706604, -0.22930331528186798, -1.211918830871582, -0.37266212701797485, -0.4853579103946686, 0.2803409695625305, -0.014610188081860542, -0.14501188695430756, 0.02235984243452549, 0.1597042679786682, -0.49622130393981934, -0.34583133459091187, 0.050497669726610184, 0.985374391078949, -0.42427629232406616, 1.1896337270736694, 0.516301691532135, -0.1820734292268753, -0.6788290739059448, -0.18327271938323975, -0.07441654056310654, -0.5698458552360535, 0.6070952415466309, 0.04652334004640579, -0.29916203022003174, 0.09449058026075363, -1.1049071550369263, -0.676071286201477, 1.0575006008148193, -0.13561682403087616, 0.04249751567840576, -0.16600778698921204, 0.08259350061416626, 0.6174864768981934, -0.6483728885650635, 0.5834884643554688, 0.33626890182495117, 0.21818430721759796, 0.5459832549095154, -1.3656322956085205, -0.44052577018737793, -0.7088295221328735, -0.5202863216400146, -0.12559889256954193, -0.7297568321228027, 0.8852507472038269, -0.22141000628471375, -0.29089632630348206, 0.39099225401878357, 1.0795201063156128, 0.3016422390937805, 0.4461917281150818, 0.41316959261894226, 0.33942800760269165, 0.5754029750823975, -0.10883466899394989, 0.7972902059555054, -0.49286025762557983, 0.24108676612377167, 1.1156806945800781, -0.7540860176086426, 0.7837052345275879, 0.38133302330970764, -0.1882517784833908, 0.5675362944602966, 0.20123718678951263, 0.34958121180534363, 0.5106940865516663, 0.23964272439479828, -0.6153793931007385, -0.057585787028074265, -0.4842146933078766, -0.24851951003074646, 0.48828497529029846, 0.8311748504638672, 0.12062463909387589, 0.034188464283943176, 0.16624513268470764, -0.009089315310120583, 0.006957432255148888, -0.1270066350698471, 0.9758322834968567, 0.055906202644109726, -0.9579143524169922, 0.14470122754573822, -0.10154754668474197, 0.4217030704021454, -0.5680800080299377, -0.358047217130661, 0.18390683829784393, 0.20099025964736938, 0.11942063271999359, -0.9026880264282227, 0.3878701627254486, -0.1468677967786789, 0.08999728411436081, -0.39042654633522034, 0.8743990063667297, -0.5593156218528748, 0.11688265204429626, 0.22126755118370056, 0.5295856595039368, 0.647070586681366, 0.15724609792232513, -0.6307624578475952, 0.29585155844688416, 0.018982885405421257, -0.11963619291782379, 0.5816669464111328, 0.4923425316810608, -0.11460147798061371, 0.7398043870925903, 0.6634395718574524, -0.37382742762565613, 0.1554660201072693, 0.18703176081180573, 1.2002880573272705, -0.386800080537796, -0.4788716733455658, -0.43697190284729004, 0.3927203118801117, -0.4258182644844055, -0.20387649536132812, 0.48101288080215454, 0.41896867752075195, 0.8064078092575073, 0.034511033445596695, 0.6541178822517395, -0.2941834330558777, 0.7846569418907166, 0.0387747660279274, 0.8273378610610962, -0.06015484780073166, -0.08671265095472336, -0.08701752871274948, -0.5250858664512634, 0.029998818412423134, 0.5709003806114197, -0.13052761554718018, -0.17805097997188568, 0.6723410487174988, 0.8074752688407898, 0.005819516722112894, 0.9639414548873901, 0.3779454231262207, 0.13551181554794312, 0.39600223302841187, 0.4202646315097809, 1.1760375499725342, -0.19338621199131012, 0.39334478974342346, -0.4827687442302704, -0.4254694879055023, -0.05588649958372116, -0.6426605582237244, -1.1207493543624878, -0.7124691009521484, -0.3636775314807892, -0.33206573128700256, 0.005827460438013077, 1.3123905658721924, 0.86824631690979, -0.6378604769706726, -0.4147888123989105, 0.2032899260520935, -0.10190585255622864, -0.147425577044487, -0.3028581440448761, -0.2515871226787567, -0.10775631666183472, -0.9129267930984497, 0.5795778632164001, 0.2997891306877136, 0.0009074759436771274, -0.3719652593135834, -0.05789460241794586, -0.3861299753189087, 0.38903382420539856, 0.4745660126209259, 0.33122676610946655, -0.5493625402450562, -0.5997306704521179, 0.15513667464256287, -0.1735428273677826, 0.010246602818369865, 0.9336968064308167, -1.0756163597106934, 0.22309325635433197, 0.4558892548084259, 0.537767231464386, 0.6793327927589417, 0.10887553542852402, 0.8171982169151306, -0.710141658782959, 0.31883764266967773, 0.5751194953918457, -0.03243258595466614, -0.08099415898323059, -0.13411962985992432, 0.54554682970047, 0.4030604660511017, -0.7898963689804077, -1.026551365852356, 0.11909505724906921, -1.2928051948547363, -0.05089058354496956, 0.5811655521392822, -0.5143126249313354, -0.24328823387622833, -0.3338809609413147, -0.5030745267868042, 0.15200302004814148, -0.4351371228694916, 0.519400954246521, 0.848845899105072, -0.4400205612182617, -0.2195398360490799, -0.6939849853515625, 0.4035921096801758, 0.2528679072856903, -1.111727237701416, 0.012699258513748646, 0.1869640350341797, -0.11701534688472748, 0.3026277720928192, 0.999377429485321, -0.02575342357158661, 0.26947060227394104, 0.26668062806129456, 0.18947522342205048, 0.15864917635917664, -0.5060127973556519, 0.37360885739326477, 0.10633183270692825, -0.07968420535326004, 0.15690116584300995 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06360v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06360v1	CoSearchAgent: A Lightweight Collaborative Search Agent with Large Language Models	2024-02-09T12:10:00	2024-02-09T12:10:00	Peiyuan Gong, Jiamian Li, Jiaxin Mao	cs.IR	cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL	Collaborative search supports multiple users working together to accomplish a specific search task. Research has found that designing lightweight collaborative search plugins within instant messaging platforms aligns better with users' collaborative habits. However, due to the complexity of multi-user interaction scenarios, it is challenging to implement a fully functioning lightweight collaborative search system. Therefore, previous studies on lightweight collaborative search had to rely on the Wizard of Oz paradigm. In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to interact naturally with users and achieve complex information-seeking tasks through LLM-based agents. Hence, to better support the research in collaborative search, in this demo, we propose CoSearchAgent, a lightweight collaborative search agent powered by LLMs. CoSearchAgent is designed as a Slack plugin that can support collaborative search during multi-party conversations on this platform. Equipped with the capacity to understand the queries and context in multi-user conversations and the ability to search the Web for relevant information via APIs, CoSearchAgent can respond to user queries with answers grounded on the relevant search results. It can also ask clarifying questions when the information needs are unclear. The proposed CoSearchAgent is highly flexible and would be useful for supporting further research on collaborative search. The code and demo video are accessible.	[ -0.5372170805931091, -0.614870011806488, 0.6980891227722168, 0.29415133595466614, -0.04447337985038757, 0.2291150540113449, -0.3650664687156677, -0.567449688911438, 0.766617476940155, 0.14736494421958923, -0.8429835438728333, -0.16530707478523254, -0.23427295684814453, 0.10756669193506241, -0.5259590148925781, 0.5651416778564453, 0.1476013958454132, -0.08439135551452637, -0.2453676164150238, -0.05858505517244339, -0.42749205231666565, -0.43756479024887085, -0.713735044002533, -0.31801003217697144, 0.661159098148346, 0.648632824420929, 1.039245367050171, -0.09431522339582443, 0.49246254563331604, 0.47318151593208313, 0.027695804834365845, -0.0009783736895769835, -0.8251408338546753, 0.6294543147087097, -0.32286372780799866, -0.468494176864624, -0.4165674149990082, -0.07193935662508011, 0.041949108242988586, 0.3244651257991791, -0.3938940763473511, -0.02388983964920044, -0.19691884517669678, 0.0819050669670105, -0.579126238822937, 0.23353734612464905, -0.8180965185165405, -0.08491215109825134, -0.20129264891147614, -0.30945584177970886, -0.24993297457695007, 0.1757790446281433, 0.5730695724487305, -0.8266425132751465, 0.4574633538722992, 0.2964743673801422, 0.41226068139076233, 0.16166631877422333, -0.36043959856033325, -0.6182729601860046, -0.4209575951099396, 0.6908751130104065, -0.6383275985717773, 0.37799304723739624, 0.028426488861441612, 0.407622754573822, -0.488082617521286, -0.8214382529258728, -0.517020046710968, -0.5017739534378052, -0.1047956719994545, 0.12321092188358307, 0.11366700381040573, -0.03088732250034809, -0.18851178884506226, 0.4041822850704193, -0.7752562761306763, 0.26158419251441956, -0.06094778701663017, -0.2992509603500366, 0.5444425344467163, 0.2382289469242096, 0.5516642928123474, 0.04186813905835152, -0.2899557650089264, 0.04430277645587921, -0.1480380743741989, 0.016607800498604774, 0.08061829954385757, 0.34098103642463684, -0.04398425668478012, 0.6132343411445618, -0.29313182830810547, 0.3213481307029724, 0.04079664871096611, -0.05945805460214615, -0.04050920531153679, -0.33918359875679016, 0.30139264464378357, 0.3190380036830902, 0.7909531593322754, 0.26729294657707214, -0.29612982273101807, -0.4108811616897583, -0.3294834494590759, -0.031419746577739716, 0.12882302701473236, -0.9063446521759033, -0.2072000801563263, 0.1106862723827362, -0.34821149706840515, -0.18002499639987946, 0.04525436833500862, -0.5340343713760376, -0.449264258146286, 0.009834921918809414, 0.49171796441078186, -0.13285008072853088, -0.13536423444747925, 0.22450266778469086, -0.3219045102596283, 0.00932968407869339, 0.6822701096534729, -0.6209298968315125, 0.822493314743042, 0.5958012342453003, 0.829617440700531, -0.20025402307510376, -0.5423972010612488, -0.7608966827392578, 0.006139210890978575, 0.06131292134523392, 0.5065427422523499, -0.4769611060619354, -0.2783051133155823, -0.17329050600528717, 0.1330472230911255, 0.059591781347990036, -0.10320834070444107, 0.34659242630004883, -0.930752694606781, 0.43582141399383545, -0.11499855667352676, -0.6372689008712769, -0.21687455475330353, 0.4006573557853699, -1.081344485282898, 0.9744536876678467, 0.04395235329866409, -0.610166609287262, 0.015442289412021637, -0.8441402912139893, -0.1926322728395462, 0.7306389808654785, -0.3054662346839905, -0.2849811613559723, -0.02310953661799431, 0.19251197576522827, 0.3738056421279907, -0.5127995610237122, 0.12966123223304749, -0.709544837474823, -0.9694092869758606, 0.09399238228797913, -0.010950272902846336, 0.3705693483352661, -0.05057090148329735, -0.4395255744457245, -0.07769027352333069, -0.34552156925201416, -0.17484816908836365, 0.458067387342453, -0.24637755751609802, -0.4322279989719391, 0.10586946457624435, 0.19926288723945618, 0.048861607909202576, 1.0058645009994507, -0.4526723325252533, 0.21466109156608582, -0.1586848348379135, 0.14470906555652618, 0.47894880175590515, -0.26869580149650574, 0.5723020434379578, -0.11972605437040329, 0.5532625317573547, -0.5938950777053833, 0.18706730008125305, -0.05109139159321785, -0.3443922996520996, -0.4373649060726166, -0.35697194933891296, -0.22008097171783447, 0.3178100883960724, -0.6796839833259583, 0.5060364007949829, -0.13182930648326874, -0.6070783734321594, -0.3503654897212982, 0.33041685819625854, -0.10305812954902649, 0.12627233564853668, 0.17757362127304077, -0.342313677072525, -0.5725247859954834, -0.5601298809051514, -0.08008111268281937, -0.22661149501800537, 0.07648886740207672, 0.710726797580719, 0.3512830436229706, -0.6918448209762573, 0.9658998847007751, -0.5295398235321045, -0.38884589076042175, -0.3881279230117798, 0.09484725445508957, 0.006420679856091738, 0.004432326648384333, 0.48552948236465454, -1.1684175729751587, -0.41274887323379517, -0.10713200271129608, -0.6506162285804749, -0.03930026292800903, 0.35629552602767944, 0.013511083088815212, -0.17597076296806335, 0.5387499332427979, -0.6815850734710693, 0.06527035683393478, 0.7551285028457642, -0.11836718022823334, 0.3878549635410309, -0.2630293369293213, -0.03382015600800514, -1.0763342380523682, 0.09852000325918198, -0.10203521698713303, -0.3633919060230255, -0.316965252161026, 0.40806639194488525, -0.1586095690727234, -0.3078788220882416, -0.4025611877441406, 0.6016471982002258, -0.3249515891075134, -0.05834653601050377, -0.34032928943634033, 0.5311376452445984, 0.04358544200658798, 0.20740751922130585, -0.0559474416077137, 1.0042508840560913, 0.36352255940437317, -0.44230926036834717, 0.7934863567352295, 0.25307729840278625, 0.07221482694149017, 0.27281856536865234, -0.6044551134109497, 0.375801682472229, 0.14053328335285187, 0.5700489282608032, -0.8735873103141785, -0.3549855947494507, -0.2342110276222229, -0.20165035128593445, -0.2748853266239166, -0.10709196329116821, -0.8366296887397766, -0.42738980054855347, -0.5805511474609375, 0.49880263209342957, -0.03993731364607811, -0.8234120011329651, 0.4808180332183838, 0.3513912856578827, -0.40578457713127136, -0.33536019921302795, -0.13000166416168213, 0.3571052849292755, -0.0038550205063074827, -0.8973756432533264, 0.2736170291900635, -0.45074912905693054, -0.1092798113822937, 0.0945720300078392, -0.016617316752672195, -0.333899587392807, 0.22569060325622559, 0.08983101695775986, 0.37637972831726074, -0.06435560435056686, 0.19869615137577057, -0.33848801255226135, 0.12216467410326004, -0.40214571356773376, -0.006969305220991373, 0.8655262589454651, -0.5685446262359619, -0.3104265630245209, -0.0915980264544487, 0.41597500443458557, 0.6529085636138916, -0.2009590119123459, 0.7305266261100769, 1.0436779260635376, -0.0034824556205421686, -0.11472493410110474, -0.7351402044296265, -0.429703027009964, -0.5649279356002808, 0.412527859210968, -0.20300786197185516, -1.5321000814437866, 0.5988741517066956, -0.36994674801826477, -0.4609629213809967, 0.20098893344402313, 0.7497120499610901, -0.021418528631329536, 1.1223887205123901, 0.8075077533721924, -0.18063892424106598, 0.5111187100410461, -0.14872805774211884, 0.16132588684558868, -0.5294419527053833, -0.3025771975517273, -0.5332335829734802, -0.2990120053291321, -0.6392878890037537, -0.1926259845495224, 0.5026019811630249, -0.3746507465839386, 0.1355772465467453, 0.4442669153213501, -0.49981775879859924, 0.14524918794631958, 0.48445767164230347, 0.18239058554172516, 0.17288032174110413, -0.26611989736557007, -0.28563666343688965, -0.09996595233678818, -0.5368532538414001, -0.10075156390666962, 0.3605179488658905, 0.016819726675748825, 1.4162397384643555, 0.25427010655403137, 0.8417524695396423, 0.26812687516212463, -0.30734363198280334, -1.0158661603927612, 0.7658149600028992, 0.12746314704418182, -0.8361352682113647, -0.5502126812934875, -0.38415539264678955, -1.0707545280456543, 0.41241252422332764, 0.05112307891249657, -0.7577056288719177, -0.03876664116978645, -0.3212127387523651, 0.22433780133724213, 0.003735405160114169, -0.5501147508621216, 0.7965612411499023, -0.5819417238235474, -0.4204680621623993, -0.43276527523994446, -0.4662400484085083, 0.18804122507572174, -0.0526374913752079, 0.14319589734077454, -0.14454254508018494, -0.3360329270362854, 0.5515934824943542, -0.6154534816741943, 0.6098143458366394, 0.03426860272884369, 0.03581946715712547, 0.08330677449703217, 0.45249468088150024, 0.8940792679786682, 0.21387751400470734, -0.03000325709581375, -0.3559092879295349, 0.016950316727161407, -0.20933984220027924, -0.6650211811065674, 0.9029197096824646, -0.6204013228416443, -0.6117382645606995, -0.27592217922210693, -0.6521845459938049, 0.19389839470386505, 0.5123123526573181, 0.031068015843629837, 0.14362819492816925, -0.3928896188735962, 0.44843462109565735, 0.345921128988266, 0.041058700531721115, 0.34433436393737793, 0.8693966865539551, -0.30878955125808716, -0.0061804428696632385, 0.8024843335151672, -0.12986959517002106, -0.3902014493942261, 0.45242127776145935, 0.3946453034877777, -0.3107522428035736, -0.10942685604095459, -0.02513168193399906, 0.15313845872879028, -0.5272402167320251, 0.11512334644794464, -0.48361772298812866, -0.048525553196668625, -0.11868970096111298, -0.4155082106590271, -0.43289098143577576, -0.14789153635501862, -0.2751195430755615, 0.27750375866889954, 0.46110737323760986, 0.6354982256889343, 0.4167359173297882, 0.22363248467445374, -0.6209564805030823, 0.30188244581222534, 0.634213924407959, 0.44059109687805176, -0.027629369869828224, -0.07589837908744812, -0.5156668424606323, -0.3125148415565491, -0.1700020432472229, -0.6432062387466431, 0.2713634967803955, 0.08550074696540833, 0.8001116514205933, 0.04046713933348656, 0.24195754528045654, 0.5863779187202454, -0.28298184275627136, 0.8089569211006165, 0.16928572952747345, -0.6828347444534302, 0.28672993183135986, -0.28497934341430664, 0.24621811509132385, 0.7379025816917419, 0.2359178513288498, -0.6941898465156555, -0.5201466083526611, -0.43796306848526, -0.8797035813331604, 0.7518428564071655, 0.24742916226387024, -0.166626438498497, 0.3737536072731018, -0.03766219690442085, 0.2768014073371887, 0.2994837164878845, -0.35564398765563965, -0.011398904956877232, -0.0005858939839527011, -0.06198440119624138, -0.1874821037054062, -0.04225556179881096, -0.04463987052440643, -0.054836925119161606, 0.4862595498561859, -0.426108717918396, 0.0836389809846878, 0.20652051270008087, -0.36924755573272705, -0.22990939021110535, 0.3415449261665344, 0.3498069643974304, 0.38366472721099854, -0.5127837061882019, 0.2708245515823364, 0.10527365654706955, -0.4512150287628174, 0.21278399229049683, 0.49948033690452576, 0.1188453659415245, -0.0663810670375824, -0.02113253064453602, 0.38361242413520813, 0.45023879408836365, -0.8760707378387451, 0.8159352540969849, -0.7550551891326904, 0.07760012149810791, -0.43168407678604126, 0.03986353427171707, 0.3943195641040802, 0.43061700463294983, 0.5339428186416626, 0.004417102318257093, 0.6109790205955505, -0.586323082447052, 0.2637890875339508, 0.6214612722396851, -0.35051044821739197, -0.3392432630062103, 0.5400693416595459, 0.30421319603919983, -0.5625852942466736, 0.34537097811698914, -0.3180892765522003, -0.6885766386985779, 0.2583859860897064, 0.33277952671051025, 0.8268404006958008, -0.06894791126251221, 0.12826348841190338, -0.40245071053504944, 0.15171675384044647, -0.29897820949554443, 0.14041590690612793, -0.2568061351776123, -0.42227187752723694, -0.35286882519721985, -0.16522404551506042, -0.8329448699951172, 0.1088952049612999, -0.22995856404304504, 0.2686661183834076, -0.06592661887407303, -0.056628599762916565, -0.0970202162861824, 0.42809122800827026, -0.9262921214103699, -0.09242764860391617, -0.014097618870437145, 0.8159184455871582, -0.3181692063808441, 0.4899944067001343, 0.8409909009933472, -0.4182722270488739, -0.753894031047821, -0.05397304892539978, 0.24222157895565033, -0.6841592192649841, 0.34830859303474426, 0.29107776284217834, -0.5387024283409119, -0.2992197275161743, -0.8920901417732239, -0.7413855195045471, 1.417777180671692, 0.6884350180625916, -0.46948444843292236, -0.2849361002445221, -0.14998860657215118, 0.60944664478302, -0.41537925601005554, 0.5665308237075806, -0.12483686208724976, 0.28272342681884766, 0.2493295967578888, -1.199082612991333, 0.2221052646636963, -0.2653696537017822, -0.2033989578485489, -0.286943644285202, -1.0717014074325562, 0.9702145457267761, 0.141556054353714, 0.23636801540851593, 0.3471581041812897, 0.20520631968975067, 0.41960784792900085, 0.609064519405365, 0.5065770745277405, 0.3308204114437103, 0.7256925702095032, 0.3684350252151489, 0.8777939081192017, -0.2638801336288452, 0.6110990047454834, 1.0562361478805542, -0.6669268012046814, 0.6443043947219849, 0.31638482213020325, 0.10594766587018967, 0.45625075697898865, 0.2688879072666168, 0.11738144606351852, 0.36105695366859436, -0.1556813269853592, -0.5910434126853943, -0.28189337253570557, -0.27205467224121094, -0.093660868704319, 0.5077135562896729, 0.1763988882303238, 0.021784339100122452, -0.4158743619918823, -0.2771802544593811, -0.13008610904216766, 0.013309383764863014, -0.10483521223068237, 0.7811329364776611, 0.08079797774553299, -0.3722240626811981, 0.23092779517173767, 0.0731201246380806, 0.8597676753997803, -0.48014897108078003, 0.056999124586582184, 0.15398496389389038, 0.35382577776908875, -0.2321433126926422, -0.5592460036277771, -0.6210894584655762, -0.4452764391899109, -0.005705450661480427, 0.23768950998783112, 1.1526955366134644, -0.41300636529922485, -0.2611607313156128, 0.8995134234428406, 0.7325644493103027, 0.11029934883117676, -0.20549549162387848, -0.9844289422035217, 0.4740264415740967, -0.4991375803947449, -0.2098974734544754, 0.3586988151073456, 0.5103809237480164, 0.0648011863231659, 0.8972012996673584, 0.49602335691452026, -0.09872374683618546, 0.11362309753894806, 0.18672864139080048, 0.9714428186416626, -0.47943806648254395, -0.6817135214805603, -0.43929973244667053, -0.03757873922586441, 0.03505424037575722, 0.49077072739601135, 0.9236977100372314, 0.8090009689331055, 0.6054419875144958, 0.05970118194818497, 0.8406929969787598, 0.024990826845169067, 0.46226930618286133, 0.03067978285253048, 0.6662739515304565, -0.8677302002906799, 0.17249418795108795, -0.2374233901500702, -0.8056180477142334, 0.06069624423980713, 0.43152284622192383, 0.08854205906391144, 0.31012776494026184, 0.5377516150474548, 0.8467033505439758, -0.46149906516075134, 0.01353105902671814, 0.3694937229156494, 0.0018067084020003676, 0.6714943051338196, 0.3176644742488861, 0.8678564429283142, -0.36710086464881897, 0.8521558046340942, 0.06600295007228851, 0.09160857647657394, -1.0335355997085571, -0.35451018810272217, -0.8288215398788452, -0.4501466453075409, 0.21946194767951965, -0.04265508055686951, 0.07899897545576096, 1.1604458093643188, 0.8417387008666992, -0.22908039391040802, -0.500325620174408, -0.001988551579415798, 0.08428116887807846, -0.041601911187171936, -0.25732094049453735, -0.06462705880403519, -0.3851540684700012, -0.5375307202339172, 0.8853821158409119, 0.3787495791912079, -0.28620773553848267, -0.6049527525901794, -0.6218699812889099, -0.31328511238098145, 0.10117662698030472, 0.30319783091545105, 0.20588408410549164, -0.4775939881801605, -0.15494097769260406, 0.20482300221920013, -0.3990895748138428, 0.04286712035536766, 0.9083091616630554, -0.7667379379272461, 0.8343186974525452, 0.37792128324508667, 0.4897709786891937, 0.9280242323875427, -0.2625318467617035, 0.47131097316741943, -0.7708390355110168, 0.31310218572616577, 0.24480962753295898, 0.33841264247894287, 0.4330258071422577, -0.5274952054023743, 0.3997746407985687, 0.1115780770778656, -0.7337945103645325, -0.5166565179824829, -0.07036981731653214, -1.1664557456970215, -0.16817612946033478, 0.7242543697357178, 0.14650042355060577, -0.29659417271614075, -0.1726047694683075, -0.5012289881706238, 0.20294710993766785, -1.0767813920974731, 0.6511648893356323, 0.5349633693695068, -0.16943353414535522, -0.2682332396507263, -0.29661762714385986, -0.008040720596909523, 0.1985771209001541, -0.43494224548339844, -0.4320647716522217, 0.19068172574043274, 0.3185470402240753, 0.40307852625846863, 0.7537153363227844, 0.2521726191043854, 0.5484081506729126, -0.03628718480467796, 0.1584334373474121, 0.0294482484459877, -0.08841070532798767, -0.06099586561322212, 0.3855438828468323, 0.3647264540195465, 0.237798273563385 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06342v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06342v1	Promoting Target Data in Context-aware Neural Machine Translation	2024-02-09T11:34:39	2024-02-09T11:34:39	Harritxu Gete, Thierry Etchegoyhen	cs.CL	cs.CL	Standard context-aware neural machine translation (NMT) typically relies on parallel document-level data, exploiting both source and target contexts. Concatenation-based approaches in particular, still a strong baseline for document-level NMT, prepend source and/or target context sentences to the sentences to be translated, with model variants that exploit equal amounts of source and target data on each side achieving state-of-the-art results. In this work, we investigate whether target data should be further promoted within standard concatenation-based approaches, as most document-level phenomena rely on information that is present on the target language side. We evaluate novel concatenation-based variants where the target context is prepended to the source language, either in isolation or in combination with the source context. Experimental results in English-Russian and Basque-Spanish show that including target context in the source leads to large improvements on target language phenomena. On source-dependent phenomena, using only target language context in the source achieves parity with state-of-the-art concatenation approaches, or slightly underperforms, whereas combining source and target context on the source side leads to significant gains across the board.	[ -0.2714654207229614, -0.6281609535217285, 0.33381134271621704, 0.3685760200023651, -0.5608950853347778, -0.24255824089050293, -0.5682482123374939, -0.3191230297088623, 0.20798420906066895, 0.5065145492553711, -0.2987179458141327, -0.43631479144096375, -0.7673173546791077, 0.08619168400764465, -0.5580288171768188, 1.1674249172210693, -0.16798710823059082, 0.1768510341644287, -0.24813753366470337, -0.19973555207252502, -1.0104244947433472, -0.9204297661781311, -0.6164867877960205, -0.3812662363052368, 0.6820894479751587, 0.4676491320133209, 0.7621680498123169, 0.7490521669387817, 0.48754093050956726, 0.22431710362434387, 0.21210916340351105, 0.19585072994232178, -0.1733749955892563, 0.4224754571914673, -0.523715615272522, -0.3203883171081543, -0.43584296107292175, -0.08022122830152512, 0.7201001048088074, 0.8685534000396729, 0.14799155294895172, -0.05217456817626953, 0.33235371112823486, 0.5744802355766296, -0.55996173620224, 0.009685449302196503, -0.631275475025177, -0.06714531034231186, -0.32839399576187134, -0.34595856070518494, -0.5041946768760681, 0.05072905495762825, 0.20822152495384216, -0.4722793400287628, 0.03924953192472458, -0.18543536961078644, 0.28773927688598633, 0.356037437915802, -0.827118992805481, -0.29739633202552795, -0.783987820148468, 0.7299807667732239, -0.6262406706809998, 0.40414130687713623, 0.12594066560268402, 0.30799970030784607, -0.19956809282302856, -0.6871597766876221, -0.3015132546424866, -0.3224104940891266, -0.29816675186157227, 0.11699066311120987, -0.18509840965270996, -0.18301625549793243, 0.2758476734161377, 0.1597786545753479, -0.4580671191215515, -0.040961138904094696, -0.27675169706344604, -0.10124827176332474, 0.4232938289642334, -0.07769744098186493, 0.21860893070697784, -0.13733986020088196, -0.6349859237670898, -0.24313530325889587, -0.7831205129623413, -0.222499281167984, 0.12916268408298492, 0.6050438284873962, -0.06684312224388123, 0.619457483291626, -0.2447182983160019, 0.8141180276870728, 0.1823490560054779, 0.4593944847583771, 0.22910252213478088, -0.9057655334472656, -0.14719918370246887, 0.3405665159225464, 0.8242528438568115, 0.5429948568344116, 0.08780690282583237, -0.3772920072078705, -0.30545464158058167, 0.0002912511117756367, 0.28718289732933044, -0.762162446975708, 0.2767333686351776, 0.01091771386563778, -0.12204666435718536, 0.032843947410583496, -0.2862342596054077, -0.35396912693977356, -0.20393052697181702, -0.33932003378868103, 0.4938925504684448, -0.676907479763031, -0.14076997339725494, 0.22790184617042542, -0.09467434883117676, 0.008765237405896187, 0.23299843072891235, -0.958975076675415, 0.1592119187116623, 0.7111403346061707, 0.591517448425293, -0.2144261598587036, -0.41948202252388, -0.5365075469017029, 0.3356267213821411, -0.3711378276348114, 0.4723129868507385, -0.44170770049095154, -0.23526455461978912, -0.061819542199373245, -0.11777622252702713, -0.24683520197868347, -0.49613261222839355, 0.7334204912185669, -0.30553102493286133, 0.25873973965644836, -0.47014912962913513, -0.41234809160232544, -0.179231658577919, 0.36319005489349365, -0.5531778335571289, 0.71867436170578, 0.18581925332546234, -0.5748312473297119, 0.3658860921859741, -0.495116651058197, -0.850972592830658, -0.03245312348008156, -0.2303190976381302, -0.17684705555438995, 0.15915033221244812, 0.20181576907634735, 0.644299328327179, -0.305709570646286, 0.8537489175796509, 0.2865823209285736, -0.3066349923610687, 0.07952471077442169, -0.6364554166793823, 0.28529223799705505, 0.20151342451572418, -0.5829371809959412, 0.07582507282495499, -0.43966174125671387, -0.3282968997955322, -0.027269355952739716, -0.3800186812877655, -0.6152514815330505, 0.022093279287219048, 0.10551661998033524, 0.41430407762527466, 0.2835056781768799, -0.4212754964828491, 0.3343260586261749, -0.25502535700798035, 0.13094383478164673, 0.21610592305660248, 0.0199938602745533, 0.7660092711448669, -0.3093003034591675, 0.413455605506897, 0.17324064671993256, -0.03316619619727135, -0.23900485038757324, -0.40101107954978943, -0.5125776529312134, 0.07060343772172928, 0.25436684489250183, 0.403385728597641, -1.0180617570877075, 0.1810358166694641, -0.5180672407150269, -0.3731044828891754, -0.43614163994789124, -0.04743180423974991, 0.6977577209472656, 1.1284406185150146, 0.7116677761077881, -0.10803944617509842, -0.7587000727653503, -1.1250066757202148, -0.41430360078811646, 0.3507741093635559, 0.10128127038478851, 0.04340117424726486, 0.09545387327671051, -0.05388456583023071, 0.6175758838653564, -0.020004909485578537, -0.21504773199558258, -0.3934306502342224, -0.0775027945637703, 0.30461427569389343, 1.05731999874115, 0.554075300693512, -1.1939113140106201, -0.6807676553726196, 0.25761324167251587, -0.7119816541671753, 0.21051327884197235, -0.38301175832748413, -0.05409462749958038, -0.11855959892272949, 0.5666387677192688, -0.4616672992706299, 0.15911412239074707, 0.6415307521820068, -0.17890849709510803, 0.24749457836151123, -0.12773972749710083, 0.3427315950393677, -1.6396467685699463, 0.036840688437223434, -0.08609212934970856, -0.16325154900550842, -1.0747432708740234, -0.030409615486860275, 0.2254462093114853, -0.05120161175727844, -0.802574098110199, 0.30566051602363586, -0.33016183972358704, 0.02313985675573349, -0.28184226155281067, -0.18998262286186218, -0.058977991342544556, 0.3065275251865387, 0.2129991352558136, 0.7265422940254211, 0.28334495425224304, -0.44346365332603455, 0.06146888807415962, 0.1538889855146408, -0.07351090759038925, 0.4168008863925934, -0.5583293437957764, 0.08356174826622009, -0.055000413209199905, 0.34728288650512695, -0.5456789135932922, -0.14238804578781128, 0.38252151012420654, -0.6137691140174866, 0.4854658544063568, -0.19667139649391174, -0.556735098361969, 0.2632336914539337, -0.10852855443954468, 0.5974029302597046, 0.30940091609954834, -0.3232801854610443, 0.18409009277820587, -0.034171298146247864, 0.23936697840690613, -0.740160346031189, -1.0873394012451172, 0.30579715967178345, -0.3390246033668518, -0.667434811592102, 0.5736936926841736, 0.17186681926250458, 0.1958305537700653, -0.017658600583672523, -0.12727472186088562, 0.24369677901268005, 0.05769433081150055, 0.04291592910885811, 0.04869721457362175, -0.395244300365448, 0.0013813488185405731, 0.11520950496196747, -0.16453731060028076, 0.0016330652870237827, -0.698111355304718, 0.6896387934684753, 0.014664627611637115, -0.26585009694099426, -0.19944557547569275, 0.7892205119132996, 0.41921746730804443, -0.3238355219364166, 0.9983936548233032, 0.49876275658607483, -0.5325794816017151, -0.20384465157985687, -0.17125755548477173, -0.25849631428718567, -0.44831374287605286, 0.3496449887752533, -0.6029989719390869, -0.7798609733581543, 0.2868828773498535, -0.16311386227607727, -0.1764015406370163, 0.406868577003479, 0.47492238879203796, -0.16530995070934296, 0.8247027397155762, 0.5771012306213379, 0.12309587746858597, 0.6466135382652283, -0.3865651488304138, 0.15210382640361786, -1.083072304725647, -0.24358972907066345, -0.3344574570655823, -0.5874572992324829, -0.6447984576225281, -0.45695528388023376, 0.2374296337366104, 0.08649051934480667, 0.08675195276737213, 1.0725160837173462, -0.5505296587944031, 0.12397418171167374, 0.6048529148101807, 0.1364799439907074, 0.22382257878780365, -0.17181620001792908, -0.12445692718029022, -0.3108885884284973, -0.917987048625946, -0.2991398870944977, 1.1666803359985352, -0.057545989751815796, 0.277015745639801, -0.019839657470583916, 0.7630532383918762, 0.06996289640665054, 0.29432785511016846, -0.6712325811386108, 0.43668925762176514, -0.4246385097503662, -0.5986225605010986, -0.18247471749782562, -0.2091747224330902, -1.1077440977096558, 0.34303945302963257, -0.16189448535442352, -0.4589124917984009, 0.4786204993724823, 0.293866366147995, 0.0013869809918105602, 0.01478998176753521, -0.818059504032135, 1.1221622228622437, -0.15149365365505219, -0.3409711718559265, -0.011453982442617416, -0.703151524066925, 0.20662492513656616, -0.1935804784297943, -0.02264128066599369, 0.22260579466819763, -0.28152477741241455, 0.48913154006004333, -0.29287341237068176, 0.6101958155632019, 0.02825126424431801, -0.053200848400592804, 0.062443897128105164, 0.03904426470398903, 0.7927690148353577, -0.03495998680591583, -0.25616753101348877, 0.06458341330289841, -0.4170834720134735, -0.3336639106273651, -0.8660789132118225, 0.8157621026039124, -0.3221237063407898, -0.7026644349098206, -0.2933981716632843, -0.9221217632293701, -0.3399084508419037, 0.4264009892940521, 0.4504663348197937, 0.45818740129470825, 0.13138142228126526, 0.7296633720397949, 0.39907142519950867, 0.11366534233093262, 0.3292149007320404, 0.5589953660964966, 0.21561498939990997, -0.33712416887283325, 0.853209376335144, 0.2635531425476074, 0.6284354329109192, 0.5479525327682495, 0.1299227774143219, -0.18089807033538818, -0.9339288473129272, -0.5230593085289001, -0.054615236818790436, -0.6124189496040344, -0.23269164562225342, -0.6387438178062439, -0.06685402989387512, -0.48648643493652344, -0.4359084665775299, -0.5388575792312622, -0.381806880235672, 0.0825272649526596, -0.033492524176836014, 0.056381672620773315, 0.21642769873142242, -0.06794515252113342, 0.42083480954170227, -0.7586640119552612, 0.07841484993696213, -0.18414707481861115, -0.007811308838427067, -0.3320564329624176, -0.251254677772522, -0.6289501190185547, 0.227778360247612, -0.05703611671924591, -1.0565992593765259, 0.3758254945278168, -0.07227092236280441, 0.4604319930076599, -0.09186877310276031, 0.06184391304850578, 0.4568464457988739, -0.6645816564559937, 0.5335443019866943, 0.12974457442760468, -0.7654455900192261, 0.7005832195281982, -0.7434408664703369, 0.3966795802116394, 0.6821825504302979, 0.45656222105026245, -0.747175395488739, -0.5151619911193848, -0.5825935006141663, -0.7971144914627075, 0.6421624422073364, 0.3346129357814789, 0.3647264540195465, -0.23820124566555023, 0.18994584679603577, 0.07190649211406708, 0.36623504757881165, -0.547832190990448, -0.14523504674434662, -0.0352633036673069, -0.3060806691646576, -0.34034982323646545, 0.2033490091562271, 0.05981544032692909, -0.1714186668395996, 0.2732112407684326, -0.141282320022583, -0.14671488106250763, 0.4008397161960602, -0.21031273901462555, 0.12421882897615433, 0.35322946310043335, 0.5396748781204224, 0.26525360345840454, -0.3502579927444458, 0.28928497433662415, 0.08208570629358292, -0.4034092426300049, 0.17916865646839142, 0.11726158112287521, -0.7473978996276855, 0.18891529738903046, 0.2891969084739685, 0.7699459195137024, 0.5648965835571289, -0.2567649483680725, 0.4442427158355713, 0.2540030777454376, -0.05572527274489403, 0.13388971984386444, -0.09275470674037933, 0.32852762937545776, 0.18819285929203033, 0.25100457668304443, 0.38853803277015686, 0.3316282331943512, -0.7257987856864929, 0.4564209282398224, 0.36405208706855774, -0.31364357471466064, -0.330414354801178, 0.6951612234115601, 0.14875972270965576, -0.2824351489543915, 0.31886565685272217, 0.11530720442533493, -0.44550105929374695, 0.7399517893791199, 0.9882118701934814, 0.8328064680099487, -0.33900517225265503, 0.00655423104763031, 0.367495596408844, 0.5228264927864075, -0.13845768570899963, 0.15171054005622864, -0.3082215189933777, -0.6639841794967651, -0.47289156913757324, -0.20322808623313904, -0.3394484221935272, 0.054375696927309036, -0.7450177669525146, 0.42020711302757263, -0.10559090226888657, -0.11636927723884583, -0.03479235619306564, -0.19989153742790222, -0.5517224073410034, 0.3826976716518402, 0.07827404886484146, 1.005097508430481, -0.6608532667160034, 1.2267123460769653, 0.7361294627189636, -0.525735080242157, -0.6874772906303406, 0.0931047722697258, -0.3074990510940552, -0.29391175508499146, 0.5186648964881897, 0.16480785608291626, 0.07004357129335403, 0.1426350325345993, -0.1954934298992157, -1.0113165378570557, 1.081944227218628, 0.7739382386207581, -0.49525150656700134, -0.01383573655039072, 0.46294716000556946, 0.5342638492584229, -0.6727238893508911, -0.2912827134132385, 0.4499971866607666, 0.43677106499671936, 0.01641804352402687, -0.776609480381012, 0.48959606885910034, -0.19536052644252777, 0.08458155393600464, 0.3269404172897339, -0.4668015241622925, 0.8318414688110352, 0.3072255253791809, -0.34189507365226746, -0.44137507677078247, 0.6396598815917969, -0.07286109775304794, 0.2863917052745819, 0.3405626118183136, 0.24579906463623047, 0.24103352427482605, 0.01833750307559967, 1.2659831047058105, -0.22472217679023743, -0.059635043144226074, 1.4971766471862793, 0.006231807172298431, 0.9151001572608948, 0.796342134475708, 0.29907485842704773, 0.04941028356552124, 0.4384291172027588, 0.18022814393043518, 0.6837693452835083, 0.11735393106937408, -0.1768306940793991, 0.08089028298854828, -0.4540943205356598, -0.5511230230331421, 0.3818572461605072, 0.42656591534614563, -0.5393392443656921, -0.40128183364868164, 0.2010965794324875, 0.3575044274330139, 0.31913870573043823, -0.011634659953415394, 0.6025673151016235, 0.2340269833803177, -1.1866247653961182, 0.9767966866493225, 0.030207587406039238, 0.704643189907074, -0.6302614808082581, 0.07398286461830139, -0.48658227920532227, 0.1402795910835266, -0.1536511778831482, -0.6594476699829102, 0.8487352132797241, 0.0664626806974411, -0.25792714953422546, -0.6585593819618225, 0.6363516449928284, -0.7747197151184082, -0.19824571907520294, 0.3724406361579895, 0.4207829236984253, 0.010262656956911087, -0.319932758808136, -0.33946362137794495, -0.004976656287908554, -0.008026188239455223, -0.1571110188961029, 0.6277178525924683, 0.3005313277244568, -0.39116615056991577, 0.21063914895057678, 0.7204031348228455, 0.0614062175154686, 0.18033269047737122, -0.10249309241771698, 1.0331995487213135, -0.48132771253585815, -0.10393412411212921, -0.8581706285476685, 0.8007009029388428, -0.030686363577842712, -0.35690784454345703, 0.9982491135597229, 0.6619759202003479, 1.0010297298431396, -0.06005393713712692, 0.5951419472694397, 0.06716788560152054, -0.028331981971859932, -0.48768624663352966, 0.6753715872764587, -0.45925694704055786, 0.055503472685813904, 0.10811799019575119, -1.063162088394165, -0.2819220721721649, -0.10219769924879074, -0.22335034608840942, -0.3817940354347229, 0.7271047830581665, 0.5209524035453796, -0.24770493805408478, -0.4022271931171417, 0.44977647066116333, -0.2577272355556488, 0.14899137616157532, 0.9353896379470825, 0.5929588675498962, -0.730686604976654, 0.5982292890548706, -0.37882116436958313, -0.15333659946918488, -0.08727730810642242, -0.9111642241477966, -0.49928706884384155, -0.7167489528656006, -0.21118786931037903, -0.2840176224708557, 0.2513267397880554, 0.8332425355911255, 0.7091165781021118, -0.7804051041603088, -0.01271752081811428, -0.2711186707019806, 0.019038964062929153, -0.19705969095230103, -0.06637398153543472, 0.23453989624977112, -0.5461215376853943, -1.007292628288269, 1.068106770515442, 0.16557320952415466, 0.019790224730968475, 0.023899834603071213, -0.11372587829828262, -0.3508501350879669, 0.02150542289018631, 0.4398650527000427, 0.19532117247581482, -0.3637094497680664, -0.06961222738027573, 0.19298608601093292, -0.35324111580848694, 0.026614323258399963, 0.7999724745750427, -0.6241235733032227, 0.5144473910331726, 0.5480934381484985, 0.9986233115196228, 0.40310198068618774, 0.15343427658081055, 1.237603783607483, -1.1572036743164062, 0.5272766947746277, 0.4366808235645294, 0.3389171063899994, 0.5007491111755371, -0.5984925031661987, 0.5497090220451355, 0.10751727223396301, -0.06759866327047348, -0.6961895823478699, 0.2616908550262451, -0.9266782402992249, -0.1111350804567337, 1.1500197649002075, -0.22067603468894958, -0.13770997524261475, 0.3150750398635864, -0.05987885594367981, 0.5791913866996765, -0.14901766180992126, 0.1541009247303009, 0.6644574999809265, 0.17984601855278015, 0.2098666876554489, -0.7114284634590149, 0.6043811440467834, 0.7418652772903442, -0.5937626361846924, -0.22611480951309204, 0.2696903347969055, -0.06764405220746994, 0.22832328081130981, 0.4756811261177063, -0.11657541990280151, 0.3297286927700043, -0.007632310502231121, -0.1194659173488617, -0.11474692821502686, -0.2896183431148529, -0.5334394574165344, -0.09025231748819351, -0.3287062346935272, -0.6048675179481506 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06341v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06341v1	RareBench: Can LLMs Serve as Rare Diseases Specialists?	2024-02-09T11:34:16	2024-02-09T11:34:16	Xuanzhong Chen, Xiaohao Mao, Qihan Guo, Lun Wang, Shuyang Zhang, Ting Chen	cs.CL	cs.CL	Generalist Large Language Models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, have shown considerable promise in various domains, including medical diagnosis. Rare diseases, affecting approximately 300 million people worldwide, often have unsatisfactory clinical diagnosis rates primarily due to a lack of experienced physicians and the complexity of differentiating among many rare diseases. In this context, recent news such as "ChatGPT correctly diagnosed a 4-year-old's rare disease after 17 doctors failed" underscore LLMs' potential, yet underexplored, role in clinically diagnosing rare diseases. To bridge this research gap, we introduce RareBench, a pioneering benchmark designed to systematically evaluate the capabilities of LLMs on 4 critical dimensions within the realm of rare diseases. Meanwhile, we have compiled the largest open-source dataset on rare disease patients, establishing a benchmark for future studies in this domain. To facilitate differential diagnosis of rare diseases, we develop a dynamic few-shot prompt methodology, leveraging a comprehensive rare disease knowledge graph synthesized from multiple knowledge bases, significantly enhancing LLMs' diagnostic performance. Moreover, we present an exhaustive comparative study of GPT-4's diagnostic capabilities against those of specialist physicians. Our experimental findings underscore the promising potential of integrating LLMs into the clinical diagnostic process for rare diseases. This paves the way for exciting possibilities in future advancements in this field.	[ -0.37158524990081787, -0.5927056074142456, 0.8411962985992432, -0.033313050866127014, -0.46975111961364746, 0.3201904892921448, -0.21971741318702698, -0.5836480855941772, 0.29385140538215637, 0.4117443263530731, -0.6334151029586792, -0.7408119440078735, -0.563978374004364, 0.3055189847946167, -0.31342920660972595, 0.8331343531608582, 0.08627653121948242, 0.24439901113510132, 0.05574841424822807, -0.3222666084766388, -0.15977008640766144, -0.47914427518844604, -0.6030125617980957, -0.2909993529319763, 0.5090923309326172, 0.5801499485969543, 0.7024831175804138, 0.41911953687667847, 0.7283573150634766, 0.2162656933069229, -0.13466490805149078, 0.06248460337519646, -0.5522180795669556, 0.23035699129104614, -0.13663171231746674, -0.4980981945991516, -0.846082866191864, 0.10248089581727982, 0.5905740261077881, 1.196077823638916, 0.11301808804273605, -0.3903995752334595, -0.01338630635291338, 0.5634127259254456, 0.12329548597335815, -0.1356176882982254, -0.3613017797470093, 0.6339982748031616, -0.6723342537879944, -0.07882764935493469, 0.05476989969611168, -0.3277705907821655, 0.008920502848923206, -0.6386053562164307, 0.6505746841430664, -0.15060943365097046, 0.46211081743240356, 0.3036090135574341, -0.4641430974006653, 0.13328681886196136, -0.5608732104301453, 0.5004248023033142, -0.5585517883300781, 0.13963459432125092, -0.04582684859633446, 0.6144266724586487, -0.19965721666812897, -0.9408899545669556, -0.26078808307647705, -0.43255507946014404, 0.26633378863334656, 0.11451070755720139, -0.3003389239311218, -0.03724795952439308, 0.36421439051628113, 0.5390891432762146, -1.005502700805664, 0.6091671586036682, -0.15341190993785858, -0.26516443490982056, 0.18269488215446472, 0.6191441416740417, 0.18824097514152527, -0.008247102610766888, -0.08094967901706696, 0.42188408970832825, -0.9081210494041443, -0.5772086381912231, 0.06335087865591049, 0.3145083487033844, -0.14366857707500458, 0.30622848868370056, -0.5223629474639893, 0.7502121329307556, -0.010784328915178776, 0.007605230435729027, 0.5486219525337219, -0.13595305383205414, 0.2610369622707367, -0.18107688426971436, 0.6690587997436523, 0.42401325702667236, 0.24010100960731506, -0.22113299369812012, -0.057359177619218826, -0.022520236670970917, -0.05741650611162186, -0.7724534869194031, -0.4190150797367096, -0.014413177035748959, -0.5836992859840393, -0.2931365966796875, -0.4659181833267212, -0.8245949745178223, -0.6483863592147827, 0.19977013766765594, 0.016102125868201256, -0.14004318416118622, -0.40300169587135315, -0.1345248967409134, -0.10124540328979492, -0.22556690871715546, 0.279565691947937, -0.7967169880867004, 0.5233360528945923, 0.3873843550682068, 0.5890606045722961, -0.6818457841873169, -0.1229572668671608, -0.7330426573753357, -0.07524459064006805, -0.33691564202308655, 0.896531879901886, -0.6463243961334229, -0.5852034687995911, -0.29823121428489685, -0.003250460373237729, 0.2414611428976059, -0.8496876955032349, 0.2974482476711273, -0.34497690200805664, -0.3737384080886841, -0.38016143441200256, -0.22186289727687836, 0.1658301055431366, 0.3889666795730591, -0.6917572021484375, 0.5871711373329163, 0.4251479506492615, -0.6355960965156555, 0.40134483575820923, -0.28612104058265686, -0.07823096215724945, 0.5528522729873657, -0.5304866433143616, -0.2263146936893463, 0.14264509081840515, 0.1118178740143776, 0.6017464399337769, -0.5233005881309509, 0.051213882863521576, -0.5537796020507812, -0.28845521807670593, 0.1834844946861267, -0.5888826847076416, 0.13619384169578552, 0.13986168801784515, -0.11067401617765427, -0.290266752243042, -0.7153370976448059, 0.2782435119152069, 0.2372412085533142, -0.24119208753108978, 0.0787283256649971, -0.13979485630989075, -0.2365816831588745, -0.08337798714637756, 0.26573389768600464, -0.19786891341209412, 0.60114985704422, -0.6303195357322693, 0.0784543976187706, 0.4167158603668213, 0.20618490874767303, 0.016703717410564423, -0.21849656105041504, 0.8479828238487244, 0.27041301131248474, 0.03799169138073921, 0.19472216069698334, -0.7637218236923218, -0.37741386890411377, -0.27572861313819885, 0.4000608026981354, 0.49886998534202576, -0.3827841579914093, 0.03285946696996689, -0.2242266684770584, -0.4233538806438446, -0.19685600697994232, 0.24442800879478455, 0.16032513976097107, 0.42871877551078796, 0.23005487024784088, -0.5171802639961243, -0.22137628495693207, -0.9411829113960266, -0.550011932849884, 0.277609258890152, -0.10280077159404755, 0.523208498954773, 0.1077013835310936, -0.5728073120117188, 0.5540947914123535, -0.47308340668678284, -0.40218213200569153, -0.5195164680480957, 0.06896929442882538, 0.662968099117279, 0.2909643054008484, 0.7560072541236877, -0.3039625585079193, -0.632439136505127, 0.2973155379295349, -0.9246276617050171, -0.4615117311477661, 0.4604336619377136, 0.4936330318450928, -0.07187728583812714, 0.46245312690734863, -0.498412162065506, 0.2983280122280121, 0.6350651979446411, -0.17135094106197357, 0.36672013998031616, -0.2823561728000641, 0.11471370607614517, -0.5046035647392273, -0.037716835737228394, -0.27556517720222473, -0.45044708251953125, -0.3005518615245819, -0.15465660393238068, -0.08817704021930695, -0.210051029920578, -0.1535290628671646, 0.3458559811115265, -0.3536722660064697, -0.3615407645702362, -0.1604868620634079, 0.3884415626525879, -0.2411394715309143, -0.09796015173196793, -0.24880334734916687, 0.31672203540802, 0.8689630627632141, -0.4346652030944824, 0.5777768492698669, -0.29534241557121277, -0.1322292685508728, 0.7160350680351257, -0.6803523898124695, 0.17412181198596954, 0.3787211775779724, 0.2870505154132843, -0.6937819719314575, -0.2714608609676361, 0.28643354773521423, -0.4351176619529724, 0.5696321725845337, -0.31240880489349365, -0.8290699124336243, -0.8384689688682556, 0.13499058783054352, 0.43580931425094604, 0.3542194366455078, -0.2752547264099121, 0.4493992328643799, 0.17098692059516907, -0.5307205319404602, -0.4522034525871277, -0.9120011329650879, 0.05199934542179108, -0.07866941392421722, -0.44627633690834045, 0.20787639915943146, -0.20544585585594177, -0.30878475308418274, 0.17814727127552032, -0.2680412828922272, -0.2955804765224457, 0.2317781299352646, 0.07895707339048386, 0.023662615567445755, -0.5076882243156433, 0.18767932057380676, -0.03993883356451988, -0.6198865175247192, -0.32894572615623474, -0.07468888908624649, 0.46263694763183594, -0.43627673387527466, -0.9039386510848999, -0.12867006659507751, 0.4596652090549469, 0.29445457458496094, 0.0724930390715599, 0.06730256229639053, 0.40450626611709595, -0.20005245506763458, -0.14354321360588074, -0.4501756727695465, -0.06702165305614471, -0.4689403176307678, 0.4833036959171295, -0.4747345745563507, -0.9288453459739685, 0.6920019388198853, -0.4445742070674896, -0.2743937075138092, 0.4930097460746765, 0.6852008700370789, 0.16331294178962708, 1.0510575771331787, 0.8286767601966858, 0.0014818520285189152, -0.2301185578107834, -0.08744379878044128, 0.4276721179485321, -0.3648073673248291, 0.02191588282585144, -0.2959560453891754, -0.2859961688518524, -0.8236901760101318, -0.49064940214157104, 0.8038672804832458, -0.009109146893024445, 0.07816184312105179, -0.35613125562667847, -0.7023730874061584, 0.8352063894271851, 0.05404740199446678, 0.006164819002151489, 0.5535323619842529, -0.2313915491104126, -0.5429892539978027, -0.366939514875412, -0.83791583776474, -0.46795496344566345, 1.3932639360427856, 0.2736056447029114, 0.5910719037055969, 0.1368401199579239, 0.9515275955200195, 0.3520902097225189, 0.48699718713760376, -0.8574457168579102, 0.5690584778785706, -0.4085109531879425, -0.7072672843933105, -0.009874347597360611, -0.487545907497406, -1.0108455419540405, 0.280690461397171, 0.16584765911102295, -0.7600796818733215, 0.022953329607844353, 0.2576192021369934, -0.48848477005958557, 0.24490302801132202, -0.5052638053894043, 1.051589012145996, -0.4302283227443695, -0.24293164908885956, -0.4976220428943634, -0.6693706512451172, 0.4661972224712372, -0.34521517157554626, 0.1749107539653778, -0.3139602243900299, -0.2162536233663559, 0.8268182873725891, -0.2444263994693756, 0.9430370330810547, -0.3056616485118866, 0.19774584472179413, -0.26047632098197937, 0.10886219143867493, 0.2481943815946579, 0.2404640167951584, -0.06560199707746506, 0.1841362565755844, -0.0034978033509105444, -0.36013364791870117, -0.39222657680511475, 1.1809624433517456, -0.7248347401618958, -0.5891813039779663, -0.6845464706420898, -0.3577173948287964, -0.825234591960907, 0.4737159311771393, 0.12335174530744553, 0.30043041706085205, -0.5888917446136475, -0.14341400563716888, 0.7681934833526611, -0.10091634839773178, 0.22857564687728882, 1.0099467039108276, 0.10289384424686432, -0.07575062662363052, 0.7315589785575867, 0.179168239235878, 0.09754937142133713, 0.08744607120752335, 0.17146578431129456, 0.21518969535827637, -0.9950940608978271, -0.1366933435201645, 0.4187617897987366, -1.0536421537399292, -0.11861619353294373, -0.7614621520042419, -0.07046118378639221, -0.03400708734989166, -0.26045748591423035, -0.4379070997238159, -0.44557860493659973, -0.4626482129096985, -0.07549773901700974, 0.5426848530769348, 0.9398918151855469, -0.5130221247673035, 0.22304686903953552, -0.8667234778404236, 0.6642247438430786, 0.4007270336151123, 0.4751795530319214, -0.162611186504364, -0.5074911117553711, -0.02130725421011448, -0.1927107572555542, -0.23011863231658936, -0.7608938217163086, 0.41313228011131287, -0.043226007372140884, 1.1086786985397339, 0.6071022748947144, -0.07734736055135727, 0.4671787917613983, -0.4252690076828003, 0.8027845025062561, 0.21967563033103943, -0.5634921789169312, 0.2998095452785492, -0.40965211391448975, 0.10314702987670898, 0.5168628692626953, 0.45181092619895935, -0.47073182463645935, -0.344308078289032, -0.8189589977264404, -0.7900487184524536, 0.622504711151123, -0.23091191053390503, -0.05373828485608101, -0.014121783897280693, 0.11433091014623642, 0.3105563223361969, -0.033667467534542084, -0.5053609609603882, -0.2542556822299957, -0.05387509614229202, -0.13539300858974457, -0.33270537853240967, -0.2505054771900177, -0.3584592342376709, -0.34591174125671387, 0.047035008668899536, -0.23411306738853455, 0.2359863668680191, 0.006454120390117168, -0.002697167918086052, -0.15458421409130096, 0.30573052167892456, 0.31167033314704895, 0.6682964563369751, -0.11826907098293304, 0.07672453671693802, 0.4459208846092224, -0.3922211229801178, -0.015674913302063942, 0.5491212010383606, 0.4512375593185425, 0.046560872346162796, 0.2591856122016907, 0.22804944217205048, 0.4176246225833893, -0.6666571497917175, 0.7273381948471069, -0.028357574716210365, -0.19636262953281403, -0.19713160395622253, 0.12349562346935272, 0.3177362084388733, 0.44642239809036255, 0.43404701352119446, 0.06968772411346436, -0.037926144897937775, -0.33658429980278015, 0.29015442728996277, 0.3838995099067688, -0.17825670540332794, -0.37562239170074463, 0.5455451607704163, 0.6235343217849731, -0.23356497287750244, 0.6956468224525452, -0.40887558460235596, -0.29573532938957214, 0.70525723695755, 0.34534430503845215, 0.6016926765441895, 0.03788738325238228, -0.12249485403299332, -0.19377148151397705, 0.31401705741882324, -0.038077473640441895, 0.15427656471729279, 0.11770161241292953, -0.5645931363105774, -0.1707499623298645, -0.26212236285209656, -0.5338543057441711, 0.3116324245929718, -0.2991674542427063, 0.2517789602279663, -0.5488442778587341, -0.19452771544456482, 0.16954335570335388, 0.23294644057750702, -0.7812199592590332, -0.05853935331106186, 0.17423778772354126, 0.6162523627281189, -0.728684663772583, 0.7014990448951721, 0.3252587616443634, -0.25627878308296204, -0.3680378496646881, 0.20294782519340515, 0.3349657952785492, -1.011710286140442, 0.8445131778717041, 0.13644053041934967, 0.14999225735664368, 0.2384471446275711, -0.5541618466377258, -0.6744633913040161, 0.852282702922821, 0.11997350305318832, -0.9337291717529297, 0.14416508376598358, 0.028670769184827805, 0.7130264639854431, -0.31608453392982483, 0.1826736181974411, 0.6854817271232605, 0.655153214931488, 0.08216702193021774, -1.314890742301941, 0.06585515290498734, -0.18064138293266296, -0.3408606946468353, 0.04873843863606453, -0.45560020208358765, 0.8282986283302307, -0.5987860560417175, 0.08000535517930984, 0.29412397742271423, 0.13011378049850464, 0.41711971163749695, 0.40883561968803406, 0.061380334198474884, 0.778436005115509, 0.9600961208343506, -0.05811191722750664, 1.1305553913116455, -0.38081130385398865, -0.006412488874047995, 0.5444716811180115, -0.4393368661403656, 0.46541884541511536, 0.06712397187948227, -0.3051648736000061, 0.1160321906208992, 0.6656346321105957, -0.22110988199710846, 0.4390256702899933, 0.24345718324184418, -0.3121396601200104, -0.5608173608779907, 0.2611519694328308, -0.7778759598731995, 0.0776301771402359, 0.6539185643196106, -0.323123961687088, -0.5138034224510193, -0.1905352771282196, -0.1615733653306961, -0.23503842949867249, -0.2598595917224884, 0.44726306200027466, 0.3021521270275116, -0.10514722019433975, 0.8964385986328125, -0.17149513959884644, 0.5395836234092712, -0.6661264896392822, 0.00859272200614214, -0.3640638291835785, 0.43372946977615356, -0.1655256599187851, -0.874371349811554, 0.1665518581867218, 0.07058384269475937, -0.26113468408584595, 0.06905484199523926, 0.5988304615020752, 0.07522119581699371, -0.33099836111068726, 0.1399541199207306, 1.0002409219741821, 0.6458654403686523, 0.05176766961812973, -0.6702606081962585, 0.2132113128900528, -0.19294652342796326, 0.04090699926018715, 0.3836058974266052, 0.8714138865470886, -0.15316477417945862, 0.7089229226112366, 0.22508294880390167, 0.2292758822441101, -0.2725280225276947, 0.3932734429836273, 1.029595136642456, -0.7817034721374512, -0.2263087034225464, -0.572742223739624, 0.14536960422992706, -0.020620910450816154, -0.23988211154937744, 0.5241062045097351, 0.35676226019859314, 0.3825823664665222, -0.023040570318698883, 0.956671416759491, 0.20550446212291718, 0.7902600765228271, -0.1296387016773224, 0.6230361461639404, -0.6085036993026733, 0.371913343667984, -0.18056651949882507, -0.520295262336731, -0.6556541919708252, 0.27277112007141113, -0.39963385462760925, 0.27258291840553284, 0.9658463597297668, 0.7614571452140808, -0.2954689562320709, -0.32429930567741394, 0.6175812482833862, 0.5702984929084778, 0.28662869334220886, 0.6447383761405945, 0.9048232436180115, 0.334896981716156, 0.675569474697113, 0.1211632490158081, -0.37869516015052795, -0.5973815321922302, -0.7780470252037048, -0.9966166019439697, 0.14765022695064545, -0.2800520956516266, 0.07250642776489258, 0.37029609084129333, 0.49390825629234314, 0.603471040725708, -0.5510184168815613, 0.24929428100585938, -0.16810330748558044, 0.09599892795085907, -0.23201827704906464, -0.16665855050086975, 0.06720272451639175, 0.035102978348731995, -0.4112189710140228, 0.782585620880127, 0.3393992781639099, 0.2780797481536865, -0.21411758661270142, 0.27624449133872986, 0.6161208748817444, -0.49920836091041565, 0.2694844901561737, 0.47151821851730347, -0.7578689455986023, 0.10615579783916473, -0.19396144151687622, -0.19687995314598083, 0.016718994826078415, 0.8475624918937683, -1.0896321535110474, 0.20794139802455902, 0.34992003440856934, 0.42281070351600647, 0.5381960868835449, -0.3621804416179657, 0.47356125712394714, -0.37052249908447266, 0.2822945713996887, 0.9279063940048218, 0.2567673623561859, 0.368201345205307, -0.2813495993614197, 0.39616936445236206, 0.7014850974082947, -0.5610147714614868, -0.7742387652397156, 0.13133712112903595, -1.1595364809036255, -0.1811368763446808, 1.1811697483062744, -0.07453817874193192, 0.15496250987052917, -0.4930860996246338, 0.1548028588294983, -0.009980914182960987, -0.3645131289958954, 0.5287782549858093, 0.2392454892396927, -0.5493739247322083, -0.05035519227385521, -0.7828002572059631, 0.34767693281173706, 0.478170782327652, -0.6605959534645081, -0.09197816997766495, 0.4992150366306305, 0.7619239687919617, -0.2642980217933655, 1.0458470582962036, -0.21488749980926514, 0.5129501819610596, 0.015240165404975414, -0.175895094871521, 0.04535643383860588, 0.06448230892419815, -0.24908573925495148, 0.0007292955997399986, 0.36690786480903625, 0.11072248220443726 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06334v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06334v1	ExaRanker-Open: Synthetic Explanation for IR using Open-Source LLMs	2024-02-09T11:23:14	2024-02-09T11:23:14	Fernando Ferraretto, Thiago Laitz, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira	cs.IR	cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL	ExaRanker recently introduced an approach to training information retrieval (IR) models, incorporating natural language explanations as additional labels. The method addresses the challenge of limited labeled examples, leading to improvements in the effectiveness of IR models. However, the initial results were based on proprietary language models such as GPT-3.5, which posed constraints on dataset size due to its cost and data privacy. In this paper, we introduce ExaRanker-Open, where we adapt and explore the use of open-source language models to generate explanations. The method has been tested using different LLMs and datasets sizes to better comprehend the effective contribution of data augmentation. Our findings reveal that incorporating explanations consistently enhances neural rankers, with benefits escalating as the LLM size increases. Notably, the data augmentation method proves advantageous even with large datasets, as evidenced by ExaRanker surpassing the target baseline by 0.6 nDCG@10 points in our study. To encourage further advancements by the research community, we have open-sourced both the code and datasets at https://github.com/unicamp-dl/ExaRanker.	[ -0.2375391572713852, -0.6382781863212585, 0.40728190541267395, -0.19108447432518005, -0.3350657820701599, -0.1250705122947693, -0.46551650762557983, -0.5816262364387512, 0.27233314514160156, 0.27061665058135986, -0.3344537913799286, -0.4776759743690491, -0.2573744058609009, 0.06928235292434692, -0.3779062330722809, 1.1892127990722656, -0.31226542592048645, 0.19773349165916443, -0.30582618713378906, -0.1968691647052765, -0.2060752511024475, -0.44398221373558044, -0.560920238494873, -0.3245999813079834, 0.7516061663627625, 0.6112717986106873, 0.7713852524757385, 0.9599907994270325, 0.6169748306274414, 0.2768772840499878, 0.011429623700678349, 0.1708279401063919, -0.5483559370040894, 0.3878342807292938, -0.20225580036640167, -0.47947075963020325, -0.237983837723732, 0.03827866539359093, 0.6385514736175537, 0.6754422187805176, -0.1927119344472885, 0.18420973420143127, -0.02228163741528988, 0.8180922865867615, -0.5894380211830139, 0.174053356051445, -0.5365071892738342, 0.1387118697166443, -0.027060935273766518, -0.46858683228492737, -0.5319012403488159, -0.5673802495002747, 0.2105158269405365, -0.7573882341384888, 0.3566814959049225, 0.23360872268676758, 0.6722339391708374, 0.38306286931037903, -0.2605447769165039, -0.05408210679888725, -0.8728018999099731, 0.5525603890419006, -0.4114997088909149, 0.2646119296550751, 0.22109660506248474, 0.7522969245910645, -0.22558818757534027, -0.8544070720672607, -0.46592122316360474, -0.3400760591030121, -0.3303369879722595, 0.11677347123622894, -0.3453391492366791, 0.27857956290245056, 0.2117408663034439, 0.8506616950035095, -0.7369599938392639, 0.1826411634683609, -0.4588626027107239, 0.1811058670282364, 0.2847011387348175, -0.09999965131282806, 0.12060616910457611, 0.22850163280963898, -0.33526790142059326, -0.0913504809141159, -0.8741812109947205, -0.07323332875967026, 0.5955595374107361, 0.20629636943340302, 0.10709478706121445, 1.0121015310287476, -0.28501978516578674, 0.8000267148017883, -0.2540661096572876, 0.5286331176757812, 0.04794152081012726, -0.27249446511268616, -0.28246748447418213, 0.24040307104587555, 0.5610744953155518, 0.1630856692790985, 0.16590876877307892, -0.2862369120121002, -0.09806846082210541, -0.21904228627681732, 0.023889264091849327, -0.7041570544242859, -0.3420790135860443, 0.3406663239002228, -0.521426796913147, -0.25179585814476013, 0.19366729259490967, -0.7312763929367065, -0.538091778755188, -0.5462968349456787, 0.6257904171943665, -0.38464078307151794, -0.33829569816589355, 0.028624434024095535, -0.2525097131729126, 0.2832355201244354, 0.36418017745018005, -0.7580399513244629, 0.21195296943187714, 0.5989437103271484, 0.9095607399940491, -0.17301584780216217, 0.024576375260949135, -0.7293634414672852, 0.1519976407289505, -0.29392144083976746, 0.7222352623939514, -0.6096616387367249, -0.00271681509912014, -0.17449358105659485, -0.1658485382795334, 0.20837479829788208, -0.5976020693778992, 0.1545153111219406, -0.589928150177002, 0.5988977551460266, 0.11562252044677734, -0.4544326663017273, -0.1561678946018219, 0.17292539775371552, -0.7834703326225281, 1.2251694202423096, 0.1418556421995163, -0.693017840385437, 0.2270711064338684, -1.052011251449585, -0.08935868740081787, 0.1189916729927063, -0.15532998740673065, -0.18596787750720978, 0.4774995446205139, 0.20464947819709778, -0.009845186024904251, -0.3369731307029724, 0.3640976548194885, -0.12772636115550995, -0.3223983645439148, 0.43894392251968384, -0.39543417096138, 0.6761401891708374, 0.3065875172615051, -0.22794979810714722, 0.4198329448699951, -0.6532976031303406, 0.21579615771770477, -0.03348740190267563, -0.25324946641921997, -0.438660204410553, -0.14486414194107056, -0.43213996291160583, -0.0821584165096283, 0.2854382395744324, -0.610112190246582, 0.17938686907291412, -0.4014110565185547, 0.162306010723114, 0.8664916753768921, -0.14766274392604828, 0.43051907420158386, -0.17852826416492462, 0.748311460018158, -0.22157374024391174, 0.2690622806549072, -0.4927659332752228, -0.3634372055530548, -0.654211699962616, -0.37345001101493835, 0.4470732808113098, 0.1698133498430252, -0.7643007636070251, 0.06645788252353668, -0.42643317580223083, -0.41220030188560486, -0.6783655881881714, -0.10875781625509262, 0.3667297065258026, 0.43492817878723145, 0.5624961256980896, -0.0000774225773056969, -0.8437161445617676, -1.0669610500335693, -0.5597632527351379, -0.24206309020519257, -0.25604912638664246, 0.33501315116882324, 0.40842583775520325, 0.11375629156827927, 1.1272943019866943, -0.47415614128112793, -0.10052601248025894, -0.18124613165855408, 0.1416778266429901, 0.36528390645980835, 0.36293497681617737, 0.10508831590414047, -0.8717708587646484, -0.46570298075675964, 0.22772915661334991, -0.8651175498962402, -0.04431133344769478, 0.09420521557331085, -0.16485117375850677, 0.11569050699472427, 0.532001256942749, -0.3834671378135681, 0.3964308202266693, 0.43837809562683105, -0.23306745290756226, 0.5657904744148254, -0.43862295150756836, -0.07371064275503159, -0.9180178642272949, 0.24166205525398254, 0.002236812375485897, -0.21372002363204956, -0.6914730072021484, 0.44148460030555725, -0.09527024626731873, -0.20423446595668793, -0.34289246797561646, 0.6155533790588379, -0.6256347894668579, -0.12709401547908783, -0.18456622958183289, 0.011359671130776405, -0.09937258809804916, 0.26482242345809937, -0.026024499908089638, 0.6674846410751343, 0.45211145281791687, -0.37813445925712585, 0.44732093811035156, 0.04998602345585823, -0.2926747798919678, 0.26094546914100647, -0.8345406651496887, 0.14825230836868286, -0.4081035256385803, 0.21133068203926086, -0.9856923818588257, -0.5641345381736755, 0.2740258276462555, -0.6852102279663086, 0.26995915174484253, -0.398559033870697, -0.6615045070648193, -0.2734391987323761, -0.5321651101112366, 0.21876636147499084, 0.486651748418808, -1.096956491470337, 0.5971787571907043, 0.20941375195980072, -0.12062089890241623, -0.614970862865448, -0.6345788240432739, 0.11538475751876831, -0.29973289370536804, -0.6898365616798401, 0.4260636866092682, -0.30059248208999634, -0.38744428753852844, 0.19688816368579865, -0.3113242983818054, -0.19494371116161346, -0.034267764538526535, 0.13067984580993652, 0.3908926248550415, -0.4490843117237091, 0.3079117238521576, 0.060305796563625336, -0.16669157147407532, 0.04673581197857857, -0.40710219740867615, 0.22130237519741058, -0.12942898273468018, -0.26099589467048645, -0.16992466151714325, 0.33163443207740784, 0.25691697001457214, -0.1597921997308731, 1.044561505317688, 0.282902330160141, -0.3017018437385559, -0.11948287487030029, -0.3848336637020111, -0.2522414028644562, -0.5186238288879395, 0.02080952562391758, -0.23144285380840302, -1.0034977197647095, 0.36619147658348083, 0.12228428572416306, 0.057535313069820404, 0.17237913608551025, 0.3817937672138214, 0.12366753816604614, 1.2624752521514893, 0.589774489402771, 0.33356574177742004, 0.5893488526344299, -0.12141961604356766, 0.3580561876296997, -0.7316939234733582, -0.5186336040496826, -0.484932541847229, -0.47378304600715637, -0.6757662296295166, -0.44103020429611206, 0.4924938380718231, 0.042900439351797104, -0.04936571419239044, 0.04538986086845398, -0.7622429728507996, 0.8411673903465271, 0.7716128826141357, 0.017104195430874825, 0.5173930525779724, 0.42161473631858826, -0.08272363245487213, 0.14433498680591583, -0.5050115585327148, -0.27937832474708557, 0.8753960132598877, 0.4092157483100891, 1.056034803390503, 0.30765584111213684, 0.6608494520187378, 0.016214866191148758, 0.40655532479286194, -0.7055920958518982, 0.4981982409954071, -0.029489299282431602, -0.7248314023017883, -0.22027862071990967, -0.5671903491020203, -0.8979765772819519, 0.3530278205871582, 0.154484361410141, -0.7183855772018433, 0.15354108810424805, 0.3930341303348541, -0.1002466008067131, 0.13948898017406464, -0.8664200305938721, 0.5763009786605835, -0.31717991828918457, -0.4559226930141449, -0.08236312121152878, -0.6173548102378845, 0.3890203833580017, -0.06889855861663818, -0.06644895672798157, 0.06673640757799149, -0.22848282754421234, 0.7074611783027649, -0.5636191964149475, 0.5394046306610107, -0.45166218280792236, -0.054495446383953094, 0.21553148329257965, -0.10688263922929764, 0.7063943147659302, 0.04500751569867134, -0.3168574869632721, 0.09404313564300537, -0.2619093358516693, -0.11219525337219238, -0.8562543988227844, 0.8924505710601807, -0.6328474879264832, -0.5746568441390991, -0.383095383644104, -0.6210721731185913, 0.05818900465965271, 0.12840548157691956, 0.17757904529571533, 0.4105239808559418, 0.1460680216550827, 0.4738534688949585, 0.7511100769042969, -0.48607367277145386, -0.04180848225951195, 0.8731160759925842, -0.3235752582550049, -0.5284886360168457, 0.9455981254577637, 0.011987894773483276, 0.07578554004430771, 0.5699378252029419, 0.40280014276504517, -0.416250079870224, -0.7044923901557922, -0.22419345378875732, 0.1291993409395218, -0.728395402431488, -0.2715413272380829, -0.5751163959503174, -0.03940136358141899, -0.26036718487739563, 0.13559211790561676, -0.057871013879776, -0.754186749458313, -0.11555816233158112, -0.3440870940685272, 0.7300849556922913, 0.7285381555557251, -0.40915974974632263, 0.4003474712371826, -0.3653784394264221, 0.513739824295044, -0.06817122548818588, 0.739567756652832, -0.15270115435123444, -0.4401004910469055, -0.53168785572052, 0.19968131184577942, 0.06790055334568024, -0.7382968664169312, 0.39636507630348206, 0.3117057979106903, 0.7687163352966309, 0.27520614862442017, 0.11372938752174377, 0.7204574346542358, -0.2689656913280487, 0.6486280560493469, 0.01104270201176405, -0.5761853456497192, 0.7515735626220703, -0.41380760073661804, 0.18436551094055176, 0.558184802532196, 0.4768073558807373, -0.3875681459903717, -0.577258825302124, -0.3852050304412842, -1.2466974258422852, 0.9968644380569458, 0.28660672903060913, -0.07674507796764374, -0.15114817023277283, 0.5005122423171997, 0.5004167556762695, 0.11510871350765228, -0.8186154365539551, -0.46132272481918335, -0.1780949980020523, -0.3393697440624237, 0.1115107610821724, -0.18285149335861206, -0.07303296774625778, -0.2676723003387451, 0.9095343947410583, -0.2946741282939911, 0.676082193851471, 0.1598399430513382, -0.3369787335395813, -0.1540578454732895, 0.2604728937149048, 0.5221341252326965, 0.6507993340492249, -0.356629341840744, 0.46334800124168396, -0.21402549743652344, -0.24512191116809845, 0.045218098908662796, 0.5005888342857361, 0.04285986348986626, 0.2185259461402893, 0.01345020905137062, 0.6525430679321289, -0.1017240658402443, -0.5600540041923523, 0.2005733996629715, -0.31193336844444275, -0.059494249522686005, -0.4753182828426361, 0.0976211279630661, -0.2119027078151703, 0.15686669945716858, 0.5904693603515625, -0.24908478558063507, 0.09371140599250793, -0.3113369047641754, -0.004097504075616598, 0.5354428291320801, -0.49688059091567993, -0.28779664635658264, 0.7249501943588257, -0.18333403766155243, -0.1076032817363739, 0.587159276008606, 0.12642782926559448, -0.07723153382539749, 0.5324099659919739, 0.5345401167869568, 0.8194056749343872, -0.1758807897567749, 0.2534834146499634, 0.29722827672958374, 0.3197266161441803, -0.17784059047698975, 0.3370066285133362, -0.19710586965084076, -0.2892433702945709, -0.825179934501648, -0.44112467765808105, -0.6376131176948547, 0.3253820836544037, -0.7903000116348267, 0.21862347424030304, -0.20377159118652344, 0.29425784945487976, 0.09393308311700821, -0.3122270703315735, -0.45933371782302856, -0.17290575802326202, -0.001048452453687787, 1.2818007469177246, -0.5293654203414917, 0.7049916982650757, 0.7791770696640015, -0.43161430954933167, -0.5852034091949463, -0.2484230101108551, -0.12454786151647568, -0.8610149621963501, 0.7203227877616882, 0.408814013004303, 0.06416182219982147, 0.17481723427772522, -0.7608126997947693, -0.9889054298400879, 0.9264269471168518, 0.6473671197891235, -0.24317102134227753, -0.17916971445083618, 0.2638077735900879, 0.7760953903198242, -0.24478939175605774, 0.5446801781654358, 0.28579458594322205, 0.6389645338058472, -0.013381239026784897, -0.5054768323898315, 0.04044829681515694, -0.5120888352394104, -0.17653994262218475, 0.48384612798690796, -0.0022984484676271677, 0.6558389067649841, -0.3622512221336365, -0.18968987464904785, 0.35498496890068054, 0.61260586977005, 0.07429172098636627, 0.11597912758588791, 0.1818409115076065, 0.5002477169036865, 0.828086256980896, -0.08586731553077698, 1.3429371118545532, -0.13398529589176178, 0.24130697548389435, 1.4007205963134766, 0.026452047750353813, 0.5311583280563354, 0.6285605430603027, 0.08458603173494339, 0.7593480944633484, 0.6338704228401184, -0.07301891595125198, 0.5734543204307556, 0.32512345910072327, -0.44836339354515076, 0.14320968091487885, -0.37393856048583984, -0.38158753514289856, 0.3596438765525818, 0.18231099843978882, -0.8030821084976196, -0.4789688289165497, 0.19219906628131866, -0.19604209065437317, -0.3202125132083893, -0.2537817358970642, 0.940862774848938, -0.11413992941379547, -0.7935002446174622, 0.5966415405273438, 0.013801258988678455, 0.36578434705734253, -0.6991175413131714, -0.4007861912250519, -0.28280285000801086, 0.31441283226013184, -0.2676294147968292, -0.7687821984291077, 0.20933274924755096, 0.10991449654102325, -0.14285095036029816, -0.39199143648147583, 0.6606025099754333, -0.5467893481254578, -0.2035233974456787, 0.05552129074931145, 0.509885311126709, 0.49913522601127625, -0.14368471503257751, -0.4515998363494873, -0.15252964198589325, 0.07221962511539459, -0.3841242790222168, 0.36994853615760803, 0.4020274877548218, -0.1127973422408104, 0.6185058951377869, 0.868647038936615, 0.14249037206172943, 0.05127505585551262, -0.14603745937347412, 0.9578408002853394, -0.5899215340614319, -0.41911545395851135, -0.9672302007675171, 0.46853843331336975, -0.08131730556488037, 0.0769115760922432, 0.8026480078697205, 0.8143562078475952, 0.7793934345245361, -0.04673202708363533, 0.7984086871147156, -0.13239739835262299, 0.5638111233711243, -0.5374391674995422, 0.49507495760917664, -0.4032409191131592, 0.42508408427238464, 0.25668099522590637, -1.0010908842086792, -0.342195987701416, 0.507811963558197, -0.2761782109737396, -0.02146025002002716, 0.7675027251243591, 0.9066972732543945, -0.24780476093292236, 0.10880490392446518, 0.14428111910820007, 0.3629662096500397, 0.40604129433631897, 0.17435504496097565, 0.9807975888252258, -0.04065956920385361, 0.8623465895652771, -0.2804110050201416, -0.2760440409183502, -0.2642996609210968, -1.0358625650405884, -0.703816294670105, -0.3246934115886688, -0.4049663543701172, -0.2686536908149719, 0.21842919290065765, 0.9213345646858215, 0.46985265612602234, -0.6149837970733643, 0.0699215978384018, -0.3625142574310303, 0.17764484882354736, -0.131693035364151, -0.30983102321624756, 0.2972945272922516, -0.22326309978961945, -0.5329164266586304, 0.6440412998199463, 0.0830921158194542, 0.09890469163656235, -0.3014858663082123, -0.0671217143535614, 0.07764217257499695, -0.18869230151176453, 0.4656282365322113, 0.43413808941841125, -0.5087268352508545, -0.25820204615592957, 0.16934145987033844, 0.322283536195755, 0.24056722223758698, 1.0601319074630737, -1.2346786260604858, 0.7349595427513123, 0.5907886624336243, 0.4527774453163147, 0.4092826843261719, -0.020868903025984764, 0.7989038228988647, -1.0283503532409668, -0.2549220025539398, 0.09326857328414917, 0.29532819986343384, 0.4713199734687805, -0.552888035774231, 0.8606984615325928, -0.3058117628097534, -0.4026298522949219, -1.1331994533538818, 0.03803248330950737, -0.6248401403427124, -0.17388206720352173, 1.2308835983276367, -0.14146769046783447, -0.1957188993692398, -0.173668771982193, -0.09482412785291672, 0.3998573124408722, -0.49176931381225586, 0.5888155102729797, 0.383759081363678, -0.3990679681301117, -0.25842705368995667, -0.6189969778060913, 0.3205873668193817, 0.18408764898777008, -0.9787983894348145, 0.2857256233692169, 0.4976869225502014, 0.08514830470085144, 0.10277868062257767, 0.3316105306148529, -0.2976469099521637, 0.2845759391784668, -0.4086272716522217, 0.01148657314479351, -0.6062494516372681, -0.27263760566711426, -0.7140207290649414, 0.029916495084762573, 0.14054244756698608, -0.1685023009777069 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06332v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06332v2	InternLM-Math: Open Math Large Language Models Toward Verifiable Reasoning	2024-02-09T11:22:08	2024-05-24T07:09:21	Huaiyuan Ying, Shuo Zhang, Linyang Li, Zhejian Zhou, Yunfan Shao, Zhaoye Fei, Yichuan Ma, Jiawei Hong, Kuikun Liu, Ziyi Wang, Yudong Wang, Zijian Wu, Shuaibin Li, Fengzhe Zhou, Hongwei Liu, Songyang Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu, Jiayu Wang, Kai Chen, Dahua Lin	cs.CL	cs.CL	The math abilities of large language models can represent their abstract reasoning ability. In this paper, we introduce and open-source our math reasoning LLMs InternLM-Math which is continue pre-trained from InternLM2. We unify chain-of-thought reasoning, reward modeling, formal reasoning, data augmentation, and code interpreter in a unified seq2seq format and supervise our model to be a versatile math reasoner, verifier, prover, and augmenter. These abilities can be used to develop the next math LLMs or self-iteration. InternLM-Math obtains open-sourced state-of-the-art performance under the setting of in-context learning, supervised fine-tuning, and code-assisted reasoning in various informal and formal benchmarks including GSM8K, MATH, Hungary math exam, MathBench-ZH, and MiniF2F. Our pre-trained model achieves 30.3 on the MiniF2F test set without fine-tuning. We further explore how to use LEAN to solve math problems and study its performance under the setting of multi-task learning which shows the possibility of using LEAN as a unified platform for solving and proving in math. Our models, codes, and data are released at \url{https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-Math}.	[ -0.23133814334869385, -0.5326818227767944, 0.4940626323223114, 0.18946728110313416, -0.08299129456281662, -0.016025172546505928, -0.3169648349285126, -0.21882480382919312, -0.3882100284099579, 0.41022029519081116, -0.48953986167907715, -0.4909040033817291, -0.29528871178627014, -0.06394732743501663, -0.2270234376192093, 0.8976932168006897, -0.2827109396457672, 0.5992920994758606, -0.7273727655410767, -0.27584490180015564, -0.014615345746278763, -0.7422860264778137, -0.4427774250507355, -0.4865841865539551, 0.12497282028198242, 0.694610595703125, 0.5557361841201782, 0.2645163834095001, 0.7450569272041321, 0.24504636228084564, 0.23242756724357605, 0.045375194400548935, -0.6480965614318848, 0.002027174923568964, -0.2683149576187134, -0.7113609313964844, -0.5738364458084106, -0.19470560550689697, 0.4655017554759979, 0.4496168792247772, -0.21660208702087402, 0.34598228335380554, -0.2391415387392044, 0.6042312979698181, -0.4676649570465088, 0.22068823873996735, -0.9215216636657715, -0.14443713426589966, -0.2507857084274292, 0.26618868112564087, -0.33906272053718567, -0.4661474823951721, -0.33007755875587463, -0.5114014148712158, -0.1850452870130539, 0.12611302733421326, 0.7212181091308594, 0.5329508185386658, -0.0708836019039154, -0.3813270628452301, -0.5769765377044678, 0.8064361214637756, -0.7317137718200684, 0.3090096712112427, 0.3842778503894806, 0.6547691226005554, 0.06892175227403641, -0.9671356678009033, -0.45106184482574463, -0.32733622193336487, 0.09154824912548065, 0.06634394079446793, 0.025563154369592667, -0.19563978910446167, 0.46116694808006287, 0.6779932975769043, -0.4824608564376831, 0.15576502680778503, -0.4731358587741852, 0.00672921072691679, 0.5952990651130676, 0.4031296670436859, 0.3572137951850891, 0.4056154489517212, -0.3387402296066284, 0.26585015654563904, -1.1602237224578857, 0.0665782168507576, 0.14881393313407898, -0.2169618010520935, -0.28161343932151794, 0.9175816178321838, -0.01332046464085579, 0.33666110038757324, -0.5317524075508118, -0.01878279261291027, 0.21349987387657166, -0.2909512221813202, -0.25476738810539246, -0.2358466237783432, 0.53151935338974, -0.22519341111183167, 0.545520544052124, 0.06216473504900932, -0.4804709255695343, 0.40515556931495667, 0.05045057460665703, -0.7745726108551025, -0.1916828751564026, 0.01046037208288908, -0.39490702748298645, -0.14347083866596222, -0.17113158106803894, -0.2295021116733551, 0.12595897912979126, -0.8698855638504028, 0.40252870321273804, -0.5032808184623718, -0.21829837560653687, 0.33158427476882935, 0.1108216866850853, -0.019236529245972633, 0.6197470426559448, -0.3946149945259094, 0.3828798234462738, 0.9472865462303162, 0.64741450548172, -0.09926947206258774, -0.3651247024536133, -0.44219809770584106, -0.1037423312664032, -0.4551418721675873, 0.4521996080875397, -0.4289892613887787, -0.029583172872662544, 0.07251067459583282, -0.5590806603431702, 0.19100016355514526, -0.6102935671806335, 0.737271249294281, -0.4827363193035126, 0.16106268763542175, 0.1104266494512558, -0.5492011904716492, -0.0015940110897645354, 0.5216647386550903, -0.40754348039627075, 1.1968681812286377, 0.2895060181617737, -0.5343353152275085, -0.04348912090063095, -0.9840070009231567, -0.16332781314849854, 0.15879173576831818, -0.2556113004684448, -0.3148359954357147, 0.280953973531723, 0.028523007407784462, 0.0771283209323883, -0.6520853638648987, 0.3620029389858246, -0.58140629529953, -0.4793659746646881, 0.4236004948616028, -0.40765485167503357, 0.9912860989570618, 0.45707905292510986, -0.062481995671987534, 0.30014994740486145, -0.8075479865074158, 0.27146705985069275, 0.27431201934814453, -0.15987248718738556, -0.25881603360176086, -0.02803446166217327, -0.2267283797264099, 0.4621190130710602, 0.39641910791397095, -0.3898789584636688, 0.165948286652565, -0.323480486869812, 0.43964558839797974, 0.7379816174507141, -0.5277271866798401, 0.20977801084518433, -0.2006024867296219, 0.38519442081451416, 0.08907213062047958, 0.13539792597293854, -0.3732411861419678, -0.334237277507782, -0.9124890565872192, -0.5272881388664246, 0.3325378894805908, 0.423653781414032, -0.5838103890419006, 0.15530531108379364, -0.23270303010940552, -0.3839453160762787, -0.4752340316772461, 0.12974099814891815, 0.33843907713890076, 0.5725667476654053, 0.5214335322380066, 0.3340957462787628, -0.5028445720672607, -0.7419523000717163, -0.2186654508113861, -0.050352878868579865, -0.35981062054634094, 0.2213735729455948, 0.7910649180412292, -0.3796783685684204, 0.9251278042793274, -0.5596133470535278, -0.2491450309753418, -0.12821286916732788, 0.17830505967140198, 0.39262691140174866, 0.4968714416027069, 0.3090640902519226, -0.47971123456954956, -0.5372883677482605, -0.013128171674907207, -1.005609393119812, -0.16822659969329834, 0.34127068519592285, -0.22517447173595428, 0.053544413298368454, 0.5815641283988953, -0.4386824667453766, 0.5795955061912537, 0.2208387702703476, -0.3442862629890442, 0.7904145121574402, -0.2170877456665039, -0.32772397994995117, -0.6490449905395508, 0.07570980489253998, -0.10180564969778061, -0.38958975672721863, -0.1962442696094513, 0.37063390016555786, 0.10362860560417175, -0.3984132409095764, -0.25390568375587463, 0.6603588461875916, -0.39255449175834656, -0.12775537371635437, -0.2562156617641449, -0.15952926874160767, -0.10567358881235123, 0.4944474995136261, -0.11692549288272858, 0.86317378282547, 0.8528744578361511, -0.5790233016014099, 0.25684016942977905, 0.05202696844935417, -0.5638639330863953, 0.5875926613807678, -0.9696176052093506, 0.16758829355239868, -0.0562579520046711, 0.10647688806056976, -0.7338976263999939, -0.011384416371583939, 0.32555413246154785, -0.4587728679180145, 0.14403146505355835, -0.11422455310821533, -0.7157726883888245, -0.37388405203819275, 0.029662135988473892, 0.5672125220298767, 0.7173734307289124, -0.8188017010688782, 0.6572062969207764, 0.2893521785736084, -0.2391701340675354, -0.49256962537765503, -0.4294799268245697, -0.18780969083309174, 0.09131868183612823, -0.8255016803741455, 0.2258729785680771, -0.3637033700942993, -0.7443250417709351, 0.23975788056850433, -0.05038006976246834, -0.32494959235191345, 0.04686327651143074, 0.18027760088443756, 0.686710000038147, -0.3606056869029999, 0.31469476222991943, 0.044547926634550095, -0.34454095363616943, 0.33575329184532166, -0.32003724575042725, 0.4105467200279236, -0.6928261518478394, -0.7989650368690491, 0.07285728305578232, 0.3390401303768158, 0.7274755239486694, -0.48785150051116943, 0.5250930786132812, 0.42388200759887695, -0.5827659964561462, -0.3016388714313507, -0.42057448625564575, -0.15057721734046936, -0.40091875195503235, 0.2527787387371063, -0.522203803062439, -1.0814781188964844, 0.4289461076259613, -0.37439244985580444, 0.3835356533527374, 0.45886075496673584, 0.8570569753646851, -0.12374535202980042, 1.220314860343933, 0.1853863000869751, 0.21157293021678925, 0.01792611926794052, -0.23504631221294403, 0.15472343564033508, -0.7350046038627625, -0.362000048160553, -0.6704761981964111, -0.17210711538791656, 0.20632819831371307, -0.7290580868721008, 0.527038037776947, 0.2382907122373581, -0.620516300201416, -0.11088686436414719, -0.25713643431663513, 0.5610219836235046, 0.3949565589427948, -0.1464986801147461, 0.4081586003303528, -0.00650797737762332, -0.3808067739009857, -0.20631611347198486, -0.5093737244606018, -0.27462753653526306, 1.0181782245635986, 0.4855427145957947, 1.084350347518921, 0.035985253751277924, 0.28871285915374756, 0.05548378452658653, 0.6438851952552795, -0.7012569904327393, 0.4664110839366913, 0.016875509172677994, -0.7137209177017212, -0.34192991256713867, -0.5544025897979736, -0.31689152121543884, 0.34983232617378235, 0.0622531957924366, -0.6550817489624023, -0.44557425379753113, 0.19214747846126556, 0.20298437774181366, 0.15542788803577423, -0.4218788743019104, 0.7982414960861206, -0.5566087365150452, -0.4169369339942932, -0.5459230542182922, -0.4924142062664032, 0.7524586319923401, 0.0627061128616333, 0.3696554899215698, -0.4223538041114807, -0.026043562218546867, 0.24385033547878265, -0.9408316612243652, 0.5909561514854431, 0.15250428020954132, -0.09889554977416992, 0.4088265299797058, 0.09499318897724152, 0.5227088928222656, 0.4933125674724579, -0.10932830721139908, 0.5977782011032104, -0.3030606508255005, -0.13617472350597382, -0.6135687232017517, 0.857870876789093, -0.7745382189750671, -0.5384693145751953, -0.44301658868789673, -0.588111937046051, -0.13961796462535858, 0.24197617173194885, 0.14450645446777344, 0.5653504133224487, 0.06727062165737152, 0.25181299448013306, 0.7695045471191406, 0.33353057503700256, 0.2244243621826172, 0.4365001320838928, -0.5859019756317139, -0.5600032210350037, 0.8663689494132996, -0.17327052354812622, 0.045296087861061096, 0.3908940851688385, 0.3504560887813568, -0.5391619801521301, -0.3594461977481842, -0.40680131316185, 0.26341700553894043, -1.0014539957046509, -0.3667531907558441, -0.3478206992149353, -0.44904154539108276, -0.23818914592266083, -0.1993795782327652, -0.5900853872299194, -0.43719133734703064, -0.17717428505420685, 0.20594312250614166, 0.17604494094848633, 0.44436994194984436, -0.15481896698474884, -0.11437957733869553, -0.6337546110153198, 0.4545871317386627, 0.2532402575016022, 0.555855929851532, -0.19016249477863312, -0.46733057498931885, -0.3493605852127075, 0.16141420602798462, 0.009348339401185513, -0.34053805470466614, 0.00853952206671238, -0.05342889577150345, 0.5989051461219788, 0.496038556098938, 0.007642533630132675, 0.5189923644065857, -0.5496752858161926, 0.41184550523757935, 0.5778829455375671, -1.2617981433868408, 0.20271141827106476, -0.015800951048731804, 0.3982609808444977, 0.5415663719177246, 0.3913206458091736, -0.15725265443325043, -0.11457311362028122, -0.35628366470336914, -0.4074430465698242, 0.6417547464370728, 0.2986105978488922, -0.11178970336914062, 0.18813686072826385, 0.0905773788690567, 0.1704321801662445, 0.18149343132972717, -0.8071272969245911, -0.24749906361103058, -0.3730378746986389, -0.41025131940841675, 0.3011421263217926, -0.2856578230857849, -0.3184104859828949, -0.6958270072937012, 0.7048142552375793, -0.32860639691352844, 0.16164647042751312, -0.20006313920021057, -0.18876416981220245, -0.09755480289459229, 0.18762992322444916, 0.5213322639465332, 1.2624025344848633, 0.1051703542470932, 0.21181800961494446, 0.13526278734207153, -0.3080615699291229, 0.10040897876024246, 0.12944385409355164, -0.15255996584892273, 0.0664735957980156, 0.11863024532794952, 0.7239998579025269, 0.49469825625419617, -0.9865566492080688, 0.5370887517929077, -0.14783625304698944, -0.41507890820503235, -0.8442800045013428, 0.047315530478954315, 0.13411259651184082, 0.07099063694477081, 0.2590341866016388, 0.2642604112625122, -0.0837886780500412, -0.3113675117492676, -0.021000774577260017, 0.5504682064056396, -0.36572226881980896, -0.2790026366710663, 0.8045111894607544, -0.016324108466506004, -0.32230401039123535, 0.8777872920036316, -0.10587531328201294, -0.6354837417602539, 0.5764239430427551, 0.8635372519493103, 0.5897982120513916, -0.10514529049396515, -0.05684348940849304, 0.6646992564201355, 0.20958714187145233, -0.004827168770134449, 0.4201520085334778, -0.019511166960000992, -0.6300160884857178, -0.6229948997497559, -0.4375678300857544, -0.46180200576782227, 0.13043303787708282, -0.4728352129459381, 0.5916353464126587, -0.4000326097011566, 0.3384692072868347, -0.37151363492012024, -0.3514614701271057, -0.8168988227844238, 0.07550264149904251, 0.1293402463197708, 1.1414227485656738, -0.39300692081451416, 0.8311753273010254, 0.8919267058372498, -0.23035967350006104, -0.7222122550010681, -0.3724403381347656, -0.056140970438718796, -1.1074280738830566, 0.8897371888160706, 0.2501600682735443, -0.14608804881572723, 0.07160208374261856, -0.933999240398407, -0.9560938477516174, 0.9285078644752502, 0.43748077750205994, -0.6407297253608704, -0.08194625377655029, 0.0345907062292099, 0.3154639005661011, -0.5042823553085327, 0.6376755833625793, 0.10044331103563309, 0.28912413120269775, 0.5959603786468506, -0.6307877898216248, -0.1941470354795456, -0.4678325951099396, -0.1118331030011177, 0.25835496187210083, -0.3686389625072479, 1.1145848035812378, -0.5099095106124878, -0.014458820223808289, -0.006022746209055185, 0.8317196369171143, 0.5966084599494934, 0.5313720107078552, 0.4409255087375641, 1.0252550840377808, 0.6763656139373779, -0.058903779834508896, 0.7832188606262207, -0.1941327154636383, 0.3244485557079315, 1.2737655639648438, -0.46279817819595337, 0.7010931372642517, 0.21990886330604553, -0.24947871267795563, 0.7578526735305786, 0.19962193071842194, 0.09477978944778442, 0.20426490902900696, 0.5462214946746826, -0.25772687792778015, -0.5722509026527405, 0.10454028099775314, -0.6434399485588074, 0.3907396197319031, 0.5694565176963806, -0.0714646726846695, -0.35949164628982544, -0.12401184439659119, 0.13609696924686432, -0.012269996106624603, -0.504632294178009, 0.38811612129211426, 0.32813286781311035, -0.7531776428222656, 0.4297524690628052, 0.044173453003168106, 0.36044320464134216, -0.8642816543579102, -0.3367984890937805, -0.012420734390616417, 0.5004530549049377, -0.06597314029932022, -0.6679647564888, 0.3559844195842743, 0.03810049965977669, -0.02344583533704281, -0.0685594230890274, 0.9176978468894958, -0.3641270697116852, -0.7239341735839844, -0.11262331157922745, 0.5821976661682129, 0.1253029853105545, -0.06688199192285538, -0.7600069642066956, 0.08582348376512527, -0.3177417814731598, 0.08865956962108612, 0.36416494846343994, 0.5651100873947144, 0.0033048309851437807, 0.8281227946281433, 0.9455658197402954, -0.09386397153139114, -0.037488725036382675, 0.1354351043701172, 1.0468506813049316, -0.22798915207386017, -0.5797718167304993, -0.9056586027145386, 0.6486209630966187, -0.16336846351623535, -0.48170340061187744, 0.7637947797775269, 0.7724561095237732, 0.9324407577514648, -0.21421729028224945, 0.7354930639266968, 0.07175144553184509, 0.5308297276496887, -0.5073375105857849, 0.4443143904209137, -0.5962250232696533, 0.22091981768608093, 0.13471578061580658, -0.7612283825874329, -0.2459632009267807, 0.6496661305427551, -0.1668175458908081, -0.24565230309963226, 0.8542307019233704, 0.42218688130378723, -0.23538975417613983, 0.026243899017572403, 0.2927078902721405, 0.03224613890051842, 0.21474866569042206, 0.7100735902786255, 1.0938694477081299, 0.0162657517939806, 0.6435011029243469, -0.15280988812446594, -0.25175759196281433, -0.3098394274711609, -0.7882675528526306, -1.156829833984375, -0.28540512919425964, -0.40277981758117676, -0.3329658508300781, -0.3807486295700073, 0.946850061416626, 0.5041751861572266, -0.5965402722358704, -0.2523364722728729, -0.41410842537879944, 0.42026495933532715, -0.2864898443222046, -0.23981158435344696, 0.0728796049952507, -0.5426822900772095, -0.6604428887367249, 0.35053977370262146, 0.4620073139667511, -0.13894803822040558, -0.5288904905319214, -0.46110111474990845, 0.1788378357887268, 0.00007892677967902273, 0.5561021566390991, 0.29214420914649963, -0.6793457269668579, 0.1761465221643448, 0.12462066859006882, -0.16936033964157104, 0.13874280452728271, 1.1885671615600586, -0.6471051573753357, 0.3532220423221588, 0.5215979814529419, 0.5894349217414856, 0.4522903859615326, -0.21192044019699097, 0.44067975878715515, -0.23500104248523712, 0.0996432676911354, 0.5384224057197571, 0.7343751192092896, -0.05226096138358116, -0.17411231994628906, 0.7917751669883728, 0.2353265881538391, -0.5644913911819458, -0.9242803454399109, 0.3801470100879669, -0.5404009222984314, -0.21329224109649658, 0.9878177642822266, -0.4220668077468872, -0.10327918827533722, -0.11538387835025787, -0.05841834470629692, -0.04901624843478203, -0.09514155983924866, 0.5270956754684448, 0.6221451163291931, 0.001259865122847259, -0.19828864932060242, -0.21383622288703918, 0.15909697115421295, 0.3935800790786743, -1.1522486209869385, -0.20132778584957123, 0.6171789169311523, 0.13308513164520264, 0.017486197873950005, 0.772796630859375, -0.4621756672859192, 0.36910563707351685, 0.1366453319787979, 0.055528510361909866, -0.6512401103973389, -0.5797123908996582, -0.09456545114517212, 0.20338965952396393, 0.15562978386878967, -0.03769072890281677 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18589v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18589v1	Verif.ai: Towards an Open-Source Scientific Generative Question-Answering System with Referenced and Verifiable Answers	2024-02-09T10:25:01	2024-02-09T10:25:01	Miloš Košprdić, Adela Ljajić, Bojana Bašaragin, Darija Medvecki, Nikola Milošević	cs.IR	cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG	In this paper, we present the current progress of the project Verif.ai, an open-source scientific generative question-answering system with referenced and verified answers. The components of the system are (1) an information retrieval system combining semantic and lexical search techniques over scientific papers (PubMed), (2) a fine-tuned generative model (Mistral 7B) taking top answers and generating answers with references to the papers from which the claim was derived, and (3) a verification engine that cross-checks the generated claim and the abstract or paper from which the claim was derived, verifying whether there may have been any hallucinations in generating the claim. We are reinforcing the generative model by providing the abstract in context, but in addition, an independent set of methods and models are verifying the answer and checking for hallucinations. Therefore, we believe that by using our method, we can make scientists more productive, while building trust in the use of generative language models in scientific environments, where hallucinations and misinformation cannot be tolerated.	[ -0.27021318674087524, -0.7581821084022522, 0.7342002987861633, 0.21757709980010986, -0.12145070731639862, 0.12921902537345886, -0.005719643551856279, -0.6541603803634644, 0.31859180331230164, 0.553472101688385, -0.22533634305000305, -0.2600317895412445, -0.5476930141448975, 0.5753285884857178, -0.5825233459472656, 0.9112312197685242, -0.023908035829663277, 0.23774178326129913, -0.8797971606254578, 0.07313822954893112, -0.024524645879864693, -0.55580735206604, -0.40953123569488525, -0.27658456563949585, 0.4946311414241791, 0.14507842063903809, 0.6960962414741516, 0.659997284412384, 0.8191573619842529, 0.32319512963294983, 0.03657747805118561, 0.09217824041843414, -0.38187047839164734, 0.45715078711509705, -0.3721523880958557, -0.6154813170433044, -0.11992336809635162, -0.2016105353832245, 0.36198723316192627, 0.3654767572879791, -0.227782741189003, 0.24932095408439636, -0.29481250047683716, 0.38552218675613403, -0.5356036424636841, 0.09127464890480042, -0.552923858165741, 0.05520390719175339, -0.10683152079582214, -0.30402758717536926, -0.2958180606365204, -0.5109601020812988, -0.05523813143372536, -0.6426700949668884, 0.40653547644615173, 0.04131124168634415, 1.0836609601974487, 0.5360696911811829, -0.0012016656110063195, -0.18127255141735077, -0.9094886183738708, 0.39792290329933167, -0.4774925112724304, 0.2460789531469345, 0.4565197229385376, 0.5705880522727966, -0.011694835498929024, -1.274946928024292, -0.7934280633926392, -0.5288652777671814, 0.033622417598962784, 0.18283377587795258, -0.10757967829704285, -0.1014631986618042, 0.2814769446849823, 0.6630764603614807, -0.6597239971160889, -0.3668445944786072, -0.6861077547073364, -0.25798165798187256, 0.4586050808429718, -0.05710120126605034, 0.3141850233078003, -0.018198726698756218, -0.3189622759819031, 0.0766700953245163, -0.887852132320404, -0.42722296714782715, -0.055874790996313095, -0.08326501399278641, 0.18594542145729065, 0.9623441696166992, -0.4032767415046692, 0.497946172952652, -0.043961819261312485, 0.2945680320262909, 0.2523961067199707, -0.687673807144165, -0.1754227727651596, 0.22564882040023804, 0.6334294080734253, -0.019327135756611824, 0.019547445699572563, -0.43870580196380615, 0.03656822443008423, 0.30965015292167664, 0.43721503019332886, -0.8581169843673706, -0.1821163296699524, 0.41471540927886963, -0.4014394283294678, -0.46238213777542114, 0.03230546787381172, -0.5393353700637817, -0.41552016139030457, -0.08376869559288025, 0.5125670433044434, -0.4186866283416748, -0.38270050287246704, 0.11292068660259247, -0.3200632333755493, 0.08450455218553543, 0.5495837330818176, -0.4597140848636627, 0.07074985653162003, 0.7600331902503967, 0.9104995131492615, 0.1429537534713745, -0.32172271609306335, -0.4197167158126831, 0.2305470108985901, -0.19988392293453217, 0.8413259983062744, -0.6192291975021362, -0.6311995387077332, 0.041622623801231384, 0.06815192848443985, 0.25057271122932434, -0.48830828070640564, 0.5125186443328857, -0.7404273748397827, 0.30563029646873474, -0.44357773661613464, -0.550229012966156, -0.14470283687114716, 0.3834751844406128, -0.6564014554023743, 0.9196360111236572, 0.06390313804149628, -0.8633706569671631, 0.05318489670753479, -0.7459518313407898, -0.14371566474437714, 0.4346325397491455, -0.26047074794769287, -0.022133536636829376, 0.1653905063867569, -0.008838213048875332, -0.08072134107351303, -0.6685909032821655, 0.2630675435066223, -0.34803518652915955, -0.05395318940281868, 0.39523234963417053, -0.22420023381710052, 0.7623059153556824, 0.5657509565353394, -0.14736148715019226, 0.14221206307411194, -0.7534922957420349, 0.1089802160859108, 0.0279379952698946, -0.1705417037010193, -0.3599337637424469, 0.07612749189138412, -0.011793634854257107, -0.11134070158004761, 0.45549994707107544, -0.9709981083869934, 0.23825085163116455, -0.26206475496292114, 0.38462626934051514, 0.3583240211009979, 0.055600956082344055, -0.04293293133378029, -0.5102273225784302, 0.4436931610107422, -0.09868338704109192, -0.017926927655935287, -0.2525140345096588, -0.6833146214485168, -0.6104217171669006, -0.13371509313583374, 0.39957520365715027, 0.5906428694725037, -0.9079054594039917, 0.33408913016319275, -0.2540394067764282, -0.5239717960357666, -0.6544812917709351, -0.15662939846515656, 0.2836894392967224, 0.7644765973091125, 0.4367774426937103, -0.06866735219955444, -0.6535957455635071, -0.5829436779022217, 0.15187276899814606, -0.676631510257721, -0.2994280457496643, 0.017380082979798317, 0.888649046421051, -0.18200375139713287, 0.957991361618042, -0.40473946928977966, -0.01633218489587307, 0.3302590548992157, 0.1472328156232834, -0.012567263096570969, 0.4244632124900818, 0.4028709828853607, -1.0759947299957275, -0.26020491123199463, 0.2905842065811157, -1.279409408569336, -0.12800724804401398, 0.3635364770889282, -0.038395654410123825, -0.013214708305895329, 0.6015992164611816, -0.7914519906044006, 0.2997458279132843, 0.2186783403158188, -0.4557861089706421, 0.6578112244606018, -0.2598033547401428, 0.4286825358867645, -1.1693148612976074, 0.32866135239601135, -0.24969156086444855, -0.26962995529174805, -0.3124619424343109, 0.42058202624320984, -0.21629776060581207, -0.059562407433986664, -0.23791450262069702, 0.3850504159927368, -0.22026869654655457, 0.34918299317359924, -0.4593573212623596, -0.0010449838591739535, -0.07260909676551819, -0.09267361462116241, 0.26228249073028564, 0.8992428779602051, 0.7224907279014587, -0.436876118183136, 0.4567743241786957, 0.29597559571266174, -0.3148452341556549, 0.7584563493728638, -1.0239379405975342, 0.19016943871974945, -0.3496331572532654, 0.04452716186642647, -0.822965145111084, -0.4201523959636688, 0.4214271903038025, -0.7905858159065247, -0.12146275490522385, 0.056000225245952606, -0.544292151927948, -0.384994238615036, 0.12391553819179535, 0.31331080198287964, 0.3281116485595703, -0.5357374548912048, 0.5757178664207458, 0.2551233768463135, -0.4043763279914856, -0.5447624325752258, -0.5316661596298218, 0.2047654241323471, 0.12217994779348373, -0.7877175211906433, 0.5383657813072205, -0.09557422995567322, -0.4558255076408386, 0.6080119609832764, -0.011914403177797794, -0.14008226990699768, -0.0265501756221056, 0.3291933238506317, 0.2593827545642853, -0.4070216119289398, 0.15191912651062012, 0.07109056413173676, -0.10104034841060638, 0.29318514466285706, -0.2927137017250061, 0.3171014189720154, -0.3326847553253174, -0.4479719400405884, -0.032611459493637085, 0.4031236469745636, 0.7712292075157166, -0.3527068495750427, 0.6139748692512512, 0.40832993388175964, -0.723787248134613, 0.06909468024969101, -0.3843061029911041, -0.23699171841144562, -0.4207427501678467, 0.37818294763565063, -0.268746018409729, -1.1340177059173584, 0.6406241059303284, -0.015549227595329285, -0.03273685649037361, 0.5670849084854126, 0.7117053866386414, 0.04818263649940491, 0.7463971972465515, 0.6589474081993103, 0.10097833722829819, -0.11331251263618469, 0.0015378795797005296, 0.06083792448043823, -0.41534584760665894, -0.4788913428783417, -1.1010257005691528, 0.17676757276058197, -0.34647172689437866, -0.5980710983276367, 0.3623690605163574, 0.13882163166999817, -0.32515716552734375, 0.09878554195165634, -0.7856771945953369, 0.4054028391838074, 0.6059467792510986, -0.05637345090508461, 0.3558662533760071, 0.024055849760770798, 0.10184828191995621, 0.21466973423957825, -0.39689549803733826, -0.6176964640617371, 0.9585330486297607, 0.4286879897117615, 0.7311559319496155, 0.10504090040922165, 0.5447840094566345, 0.47635138034820557, 0.6381139755249023, -0.3526303470134735, 0.5177140235900879, 0.3452902138233185, -1.0093761682510376, -0.3657792806625366, -0.28903478384017944, -0.5902528762817383, 0.3240257203578949, -0.1754780113697052, -0.8473041653633118, 0.15711887180805206, 0.044499821960926056, -0.19186313450336456, 0.14499031007289886, -0.20911967754364014, 0.622919499874115, -0.18956585228443146, -0.3663344085216522, -0.40557435154914856, -0.6219767928123474, 0.34405389428138733, 0.07198911160230637, -0.21910527348518372, 0.12183716148138046, 0.23010247945785522, 0.5303018689155579, -0.6836922764778137, 0.6649360656738281, -0.1295713633298874, -0.060690440237522125, 0.5820451974868774, -0.20349238812923431, 0.3419647514820099, 0.44505369663238525, -0.22612987458705902, 0.2607680559158325, 0.5643936991691589, -0.2191217690706253, -0.5033081769943237, 0.7405226826667786, -0.7226195335388184, -0.8768554925918579, -0.8016939759254456, -0.2735648453235626, 0.038819603621959686, 0.33285772800445557, 0.4761529266834259, -0.19714342057704926, -0.42304009199142456, 0.41314950585365295, 0.9127172827720642, -0.018763409927487373, -0.07926083356142044, 0.3573218286037445, -0.5381889939308167, -0.691881537437439, 0.675234317779541, -0.12105222791433334, -0.025361645966768265, 0.41104838252067566, 0.04425849765539169, -0.32147958874702454, -0.5359514951705933, -0.4969160258769989, 0.2700003385543823, -0.7366421818733215, -0.3040383756160736, -0.5251017808914185, -0.5769876837730408, -0.6171767115592957, 0.11926354467868805, -0.2637808918952942, -0.33929169178009033, -0.18148966133594513, -0.1665525585412979, 0.4506697952747345, 0.5717157125473022, -0.15881840884685516, -0.046701446175575256, -0.6991206407546997, 0.4553578495979309, 0.14584533870220184, 0.19313733279705048, -0.4130300283432007, -0.36208873987197876, -0.2795575261116028, 0.25357523560523987, -0.18694502115249634, -0.8295485377311707, -0.012350417673587799, 0.05961763486266136, 0.629727840423584, 0.2841056287288666, 0.10669858008623123, 0.37107738852500916, -0.4418724477291107, 0.9665890336036682, 0.11232377588748932, -0.5879685878753662, 0.5174842476844788, -0.12297538667917252, 0.11602499336004257, 0.7288249731063843, 0.5762248039245605, -0.4381594955921173, -0.6535667777061462, -0.42478325963020325, -0.5320230722427368, 0.2419879287481308, 0.3529393970966339, 0.03290656581521034, -0.06619889289140701, 0.5664950609207153, 0.1902301013469696, 0.3065962791442871, -0.49138978123664856, -0.329174280166626, -0.5486330986022949, -0.09883303195238113, 0.15204113721847534, -0.23439034819602966, -0.5860825777053833, -0.13042034208774567, 0.750038206577301, -0.1184699758887291, 0.4728560447692871, 0.5550966858863831, 0.15626318752765656, -0.3069223165512085, 0.05487117916345596, 0.47411057353019714, 0.688258707523346, -0.17649318277835846, 0.3101050555706024, -0.24266047775745392, -0.6954489350318909, 0.13350337743759155, 0.46814000606536865, -0.7802634239196777, 0.23118816316127777, 0.1360122561454773, 0.6574398875236511, -0.5583916306495667, -0.44159677624702454, 0.25713878870010376, -0.12068644165992737, -0.4256216883659363, -0.6394400596618652, 0.14745676517486572, 0.011203774251043797, 0.3312508463859558, 0.5020419955253601, 0.23523488640785217, 0.1691119223833084, -0.22896873950958252, 0.27467256784439087, 0.2858871519565582, -0.4005633592605591, -0.4546643793582916, 1.0583789348602295, -0.015150405466556549, -0.4379830062389374, 0.5098025798797607, 0.06178281083703041, -0.27309539914131165, 0.6080052256584167, 0.6309281587600708, 0.9607191681861877, -0.11244980245828629, 0.5896202325820923, 0.4476926028728485, 0.2958824336528778, -0.13530610501766205, 0.4750683605670929, -0.2803782820701599, -0.587727963924408, -0.368390291929245, -0.6425184011459351, -0.6054564714431763, 0.18642733991146088, -0.488925576210022, 0.08482374250888824, -0.3249407410621643, -0.2980508506298065, 0.2793976962566376, -0.30439838767051697, -0.4218800961971283, 0.1164235919713974, 0.10398872196674347, 1.1312226057052612, -0.7170770168304443, 0.8251933455467224, 0.9031191468238831, -0.8008256554603577, -0.29984211921691895, -0.1015423834323883, -0.1951950192451477, -0.44914335012435913, 0.7381468415260315, 0.0010963375680148602, -0.3629884421825409, 0.015595265664160252, -1.048917293548584, -1.0982375144958496, 0.9831302762031555, 0.4546467661857605, -0.10964599996805191, 0.0555376373231411, 0.08098681271076202, 0.8826817870140076, -0.20420531928539276, 0.10733351856470108, -0.0971028059720993, 0.570717453956604, 0.36616817116737366, -0.673639178276062, 0.04605692997574806, -0.7208017706871033, -0.000864590925630182, -0.23897437751293182, -0.28330522775650024, 0.48170384764671326, -0.2019069641828537, -0.37335726618766785, 0.628025233745575, 1.3294479846954346, 0.4020999073982239, 0.49515774846076965, 0.21676214039325714, 0.7064352631568909, 0.8995603322982788, -0.25498825311660767, 1.0584434270858765, -0.5282972455024719, 0.2993125319480896, 0.9809752702713013, -0.4858704209327698, 0.71551513671875, 0.8531093001365662, -0.13488905131816864, 0.6338410973548889, 0.33509188890457153, -0.19087360799312592, 0.6438318490982056, 0.35154449939727783, -0.575900137424469, -0.30010101199150085, -0.3070911765098572, -0.7583321928977966, 0.13024042546749115, 0.3386155366897583, -0.30395981669425964, -0.26128479838371277, 0.23633228242397308, -0.16506421566009521, 0.19588084518909454, 0.0764857605099678, 0.36504754424095154, 0.010476095601916313, -0.9444116950035095, 0.4031500220298767, -0.017246609553694725, 0.2398674637079239, -0.5946651697158813, -0.346041738986969, 0.005912933964282274, 0.18608878552913666, -0.07862729579210281, -0.6716507077217102, 0.3562491834163666, 0.13002195954322815, -0.35668978095054626, 0.01601409539580345, 0.8291270136833191, -0.3289412260055542, -0.49596330523490906, -0.05143497884273529, 0.4637024402618408, 0.23862360417842865, 0.1020486131310463, -0.5263897180557251, -0.15428750216960907, -0.23077061772346497, -0.1651962250471115, -0.07515226304531097, 0.46102842688560486, -0.07054553180932999, 0.850508451461792, 0.6636033058166504, 0.2368626892566681, 0.11143109947443008, -0.11123093217611313, 0.7341412305831909, -0.4176165759563446, -0.3044474720954895, -0.5267710089683533, 0.3686883747577667, -0.1375626027584076, -0.2259783148765564, 0.7839171886444092, 0.5631116032600403, 1.0345526933670044, -0.2898656725883484, 1.2397704124450684, -0.6019389033317566, 0.42216476798057556, -0.2451176941394806, 0.6989338397979736, -0.4196426570415497, 0.0931701511144638, -0.04433096945285797, -0.7189744710922241, -0.516635000705719, 0.6237030625343323, -0.08257352560758591, 0.002255139872431755, 0.5796992778778076, 0.9629068374633789, 0.2411404550075531, 0.2470962405204773, 0.23088940978050232, 0.21304695308208466, 0.3448171317577362, 0.18947063386440277, 1.1852351427078247, -0.32344308495521545, 0.28923937678337097, -0.314450204372406, -0.13520877063274384, -0.14504283666610718, -0.7595245838165283, -0.4464834928512573, -0.7421443462371826, -0.5712636113166809, -0.6829362511634827, 0.26511481404304504, 0.495757132768631, 0.3589383065700531, -0.8893969655036926, -0.03340710327029228, -0.41544845700263977, -0.03422855585813522, -0.2924884557723999, -0.17964743077754974, 0.2825680673122406, -0.2882935106754303, -0.5969542264938354, 0.1902502179145813, 0.41849780082702637, -0.06095470115542412, -0.6086976528167725, -0.281883180141449, -0.15646374225616455, 0.07237879186868668, 0.39609038829803467, 0.7498356699943542, -0.7190605401992798, -0.5393971800804138, 0.3244495391845703, -0.32034966349601746, -0.0003518708108458668, 0.6019409894943237, -0.7340824007987976, 0.629763126373291, 0.7741390466690063, 0.7776129245758057, 0.4252658188343048, 0.08362425118684769, 0.4832198917865753, -0.12796691060066223, -0.2674422562122345, 0.28151702880859375, 0.3176623582839966, 0.18686968088150024, -0.41877928376197815, 0.73540860414505, 0.31065037846565247, -0.7155213356018066, -1.0410115718841553, 0.13432809710502625, -0.8813613653182983, -0.20197297632694244, 0.9242225289344788, -0.34349149465560913, -0.44111761450767517, -0.0799463614821434, -0.28774216771125793, 0.2852688431739807, 0.06330198049545288, 1.0838606357574463, 0.6822998523712158, -0.006014161743223667, 0.08087795972824097, -0.1579938679933548, 0.39078301191329956, 0.3032149076461792, -0.9520440697669983, 0.08684826642274857, 0.7114821672439575, 0.13524861633777618, 0.8795101046562195, 0.7403424382209778, -0.4644816517829895, 0.5916798710823059, 0.26467370986938477, 0.21257756650447845, -0.3359633684158325, -0.4819353520870209, -0.1193694993853569, 0.49723315238952637, 0.19024428725242615, -0.3435000777244568 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10948v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10948v2	Zero-shot Explainable Mental Health Analysis on Social Media by Incorporating Mental Scales	2024-02-09T09:44:06	2024-03-15T02:02:02	Wenyu Li, Yinuo Zhu, Xin Lin, Ming Li, Ziyue Jiang, Ziqian Zeng	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Traditional discriminative approaches in mental health analysis are known for their strong capacity but lack interpretability and demand large-scale annotated data. The generative approaches, such as those based on large language models (LLMs), have the potential to get rid of heavy annotations and provide explanations but their capabilities still fall short compared to discriminative approaches, and their explanations may be unreliable due to the fact that the generation of explanation is a black-box process. Inspired by the psychological assessment practice of using scales to evaluate mental states, our method which is called Mental Analysis by Incorporating Mental Scales (MAIMS), incorporates two procedures via LLMs. First, the patient completes mental scales, and second, the psychologist interprets the collected information from the mental scales and makes informed decisions. Experimental results show that MAIMS outperforms other zero-shot methods. MAIMS can generate more rigorous explanation based on the outputs of mental scales	[ -0.36945784091949463, -1.034920573234558, 1.0115383863449097, 0.1890389770269394, -0.2793353199958801, 0.10600893199443817, -0.16145753860473633, -0.45092371106147766, 0.5292289853096008, 0.408456027507782, -0.8174936175346375, -0.5494762063026428, -0.8366634249687195, 0.117963045835495, -0.2645871341228485, 1.1449288129806519, -0.18334947526454926, 0.3139616549015045, -0.11773444712162018, -0.2474437952041626, -0.44545164704322815, -0.3244721591472626, -0.8634868264198303, -0.40054014325141907, 0.8190227746963501, 0.5173640251159668, 0.7854490280151367, 0.46175336837768555, 0.7502484917640686, 0.1515597403049469, 0.02428913116455078, -0.06154509261250496, -0.6892929673194885, -0.05267078056931496, -0.011572042480111122, -0.5794269442558289, -0.5705841779708862, 0.1317443698644638, 0.4075600206851959, 0.7695879936218262, -0.1491018533706665, 0.5186854600906372, -0.29596590995788574, 0.6060632467269897, -0.8283393979072571, 0.07116886973381042, -0.3360116183757782, 0.3436892330646515, 0.02188936248421669, -0.5684676766395569, -0.2607731819152832, -0.3721557557582855, -0.2177007794380188, -0.2929830551147461, 0.15752065181732178, -0.6573454737663269, 0.6797888278961182, 0.1588294804096222, -0.4541129469871521, 0.04885782673954964, -1.2851612567901611, 0.6001381874084473, -0.7803228497505188, -0.029835304245352745, 0.5118108987808228, 0.5409070253372192, 0.09181681275367737, -0.30079206824302673, -0.5562273859977722, 0.18440574407577515, 0.10920115560293198, 0.22144298255443573, -0.43502992391586304, 0.1608053296804428, 0.42627406120300293, 0.33697637915611267, -0.5239173769950867, 0.23961977660655975, -0.38151490688323975, 0.07428596913814545, 1.009467601776123, 0.5156375169754028, 0.39464548230171204, -0.046863432973623276, -0.13033734261989594, 0.43558692932128906, -0.5886219143867493, -0.07231278717517853, -0.17201274633407593, -0.020278122276067734, -0.4007483422756195, 0.8780465126037598, -0.22069887816905975, 0.622925877571106, 0.24609899520874023, -0.4337020218372345, 0.08192049711942673, 0.09207519888877869, -0.4314383268356323, 0.1922176629304886, 0.8188580870628357, 0.9693350195884705, 0.4327922761440277, -0.217789426445961, -0.02450890839099884, 0.3881606459617615, 0.37898802757263184, -1.05721914768219, 0.039710912853479385, 0.6028000116348267, -0.6336742639541626, -0.275605171918869, -0.2454604208469391, -0.6834988594055176, -0.6076465845108032, -0.31305110454559326, 0.6383033990859985, -0.4044467508792877, -0.450333833694458, 0.14694513380527496, -0.1568133682012558, 0.3080281913280487, 0.428525447845459, -0.6356937289237976, 0.21161317825317383, 0.5244622230529785, 1.1847275495529175, 0.15749941766262054, 0.1410895735025406, -0.2922227084636688, 0.10944095253944397, -0.6906223297119141, 0.9242312908172607, -0.34186697006225586, -0.42680516839027405, 0.011535851284861565, 0.11290349811315536, 0.015295419842004776, -0.39781454205513, 0.0853014886379242, -0.21744228899478912, -0.01281546987593174, -0.5475434064865112, -0.501362144947052, -0.2765793800354004, 0.24145320057868958, -0.36719608306884766, 0.8810887932777405, 0.20539891719818115, -0.8407770991325378, 0.6114267706871033, -0.7867318391799927, -0.4054151177406311, 0.23286710679531097, -0.2903866469860077, -0.2967720329761505, 0.4058610796928406, 0.22607772052288055, 0.9535672664642334, -0.15834872424602509, 0.24169866740703583, -0.8868609666824341, -0.6591678857803345, 0.4524804353713989, -0.42908966541290283, 1.0697624683380127, 0.25447967648506165, -0.2665521502494812, 0.1238669827580452, -0.773506224155426, -0.18901970982551575, 0.6071537733078003, 0.05574833229184151, -0.32836851477622986, 0.18088258802890778, -0.3780815899372101, 0.17873553931713104, 0.138397216796875, -0.5864240527153015, -0.2565801739692688, -0.23609265685081482, 0.3139216899871826, 0.4578547179698944, 0.626548171043396, 0.1984938234090805, -0.4961770176887512, 0.7996057271957397, -0.19587814807891846, 0.37038740515708923, -0.0050851707346737385, -0.45152547955513, -0.30337315797805786, -0.5869810581207275, -0.28127390146255493, 0.5789284110069275, -0.601579487323761, 0.46470919251441956, -0.3562413156032562, -0.7732234597206116, -0.612242579460144, 0.13175581395626068, 0.11510782688856125, 0.41386136412620544, 0.17036272585391998, -0.2978898286819458, -0.1831241250038147, -0.7215067148208618, -0.18135154247283936, -0.07245628535747528, -0.33228111267089844, -0.028990985825657845, 0.4384191632270813, -0.04839730262756348, 0.7555181384086609, -0.6446314454078674, -0.18268130719661713, -0.302779883146286, 0.26669439673423767, -0.07554249465465546, -0.17282989621162415, 0.662653386592865, -0.4924873411655426, -0.363850474357605, -0.13838708400726318, -1.2052006721496582, -0.28392651677131653, -0.1956254094839096, -0.014545959420502186, -0.24456746876239777, 0.34337469935417175, -0.5878928303718567, 0.4967777729034424, 0.3558253347873688, -0.21571287512779236, 0.654810905456543, -0.08673371374607086, 0.14772722125053406, -0.9507438540458679, -0.10483665764331818, 0.49910470843315125, -0.2280401587486267, -0.7275497317314148, 0.07761304825544357, -0.08163498342037201, -0.40390732884407043, -0.4904395639896393, 0.3467930555343628, -0.4338812530040741, 0.10625888407230377, -0.3057570159435272, 0.2820339500904083, 0.09451587498188019, 0.0987861305475235, -0.2322772592306137, 0.42614537477493286, 0.5889626741409302, -0.19356636703014374, 0.2928710877895355, -0.3072521388530731, 0.03205034136772156, 1.1060752868652344, -0.65540611743927, -0.1743042916059494, -0.5377362966537476, 0.16310477256774902, -1.30418062210083, -0.4001992344856262, 0.3157576024532318, -0.5927102565765381, 0.262164443731308, 0.0987413302063942, -0.3825240433216095, -0.4775102138519287, -0.704916775226593, 0.023991279304027557, 0.29042887687683105, 0.0035404355730861425, 0.24832604825496674, 0.5259360074996948, -0.07444414496421814, -0.1480174958705902, -0.6881391406059265, 0.1643068641424179, -0.7204319834709167, -0.3616487681865692, -0.0034973553847521544, -0.0869869589805603, -0.5551626682281494, 0.0594901368021965, -0.04383661970496178, -0.16151995956897736, 0.2169402688741684, 0.3978167176246643, 0.33623751997947693, -0.2720429003238678, 0.3055894374847412, 0.0858420580625534, -0.027060911059379578, 0.5149402022361755, 0.5181206464767456, 0.2661728262901306, 0.1859758049249649, -0.2746366262435913, -0.8440927267074585, 0.5576153993606567, 0.9085121750831604, -0.14043116569519043, 1.0425143241882324, 0.6405021548271179, -0.7045709490776062, 0.060907959938049316, -0.5697057843208313, -0.21644413471221924, -0.36000677943229675, 0.039765018969774246, -0.21341340243816376, -0.7800439596176147, 0.5559772253036499, -0.07692503929138184, 0.07969889789819717, 0.5371960997581482, 0.7837318778038025, -0.3868238925933838, 1.3841110467910767, 0.5090913772583008, 0.036741361021995544, 0.2939881682395935, -0.10707058757543564, 0.3579072952270508, -0.5024137496948242, -0.041466910392045975, -0.3416484594345093, -0.3313124179840088, -0.5468690395355225, -0.3695758283138275, 0.36814749240875244, 0.08262120187282562, -0.38455912470817566, -0.11275473237037659, -0.6352906823158264, 0.3619840443134308, 0.08427886664867401, 0.4037989675998688, 0.3243566155433655, 0.14154621958732605, 0.29110294580459595, -0.21726764738559723, -0.42764681577682495, -0.449517160654068, 1.212739109992981, 0.4713294208049774, 0.8213542103767395, 0.10615662485361099, 0.7628517746925354, 0.28713560104370117, 0.8948472142219543, -1.3741520643234253, 0.493394672870636, -0.04103853181004524, -0.852627158164978, -0.3461282551288605, -0.4868273437023163, -0.896487832069397, 0.22276072204113007, -0.37348002195358276, -1.155871033668518, -0.05736435577273369, -0.2686850428581238, -0.6714047789573669, 0.17836321890354156, -0.8293168544769287, 0.40262240171432495, -0.19287779927253723, 0.06262815743684769, -0.23664112389087677, -0.5399156212806702, 0.6430822610855103, -0.2897651791572571, 0.44850483536720276, -0.5319069027900696, 0.16532957553863525, 1.0575615167617798, -0.412316232919693, 1.0178734064102173, -0.3492075502872467, -0.0534701868891716, 0.35353294014930725, 0.2573319375514984, -0.17658837139606476, 0.0948663279414177, -0.01056368462741375, 0.39895594120025635, 0.4341930150985718, -0.4955267608165741, -0.8753954768180847, 0.7161193490028381, -0.8390291929244995, -0.6237459182739258, -0.2953214943408966, -0.5043030977249146, -0.3184777498245239, 0.02222812920808792, 0.04288239777088165, 0.14064140617847443, -0.10786984860897064, -0.06017761304974556, 0.3299974799156189, -0.25904151797294617, 0.1992495208978653, 0.712575376033783, -0.22914034128189087, -0.3443130552768707, 0.6573753356933594, 0.5397173762321472, 0.17776603996753693, 0.17744991183280945, 0.3468073904514313, 0.02770574949681759, -0.2969626784324646, -0.20986045897006989, 0.6182861924171448, -0.4166988432407379, -0.11005040258169174, -0.48629918694496155, -0.35336190462112427, -0.30929630994796753, -0.4556722044944763, -0.21066641807556152, -0.17859365046024323, -0.1798238456249237, -0.344617635011673, 0.5102617144584656, 0.7412726879119873, -0.2352002114057541, 0.5416467785835266, -0.7402673959732056, 0.7379835844039917, 0.1450786292552948, 0.3471524119377136, 0.30813002586364746, -0.1754496991634369, -0.2850108742713928, 0.15791194140911102, -0.4649108350276947, -1.6125060319900513, 0.12707988917827606, -0.15685683488845825, 0.2872946262359619, 1.1463578939437866, 0.006804501637816429, 0.9814252853393555, -0.27874425053596497, 0.6167661547660828, 0.5329478979110718, -0.5773077607154846, 0.6848961710929871, -0.3909755051136017, 0.4488741457462311, 0.43084976077079773, 0.8214423060417175, -0.6763857007026672, -0.45617803931236267, -0.473055362701416, -0.5473588109016418, 0.46896108984947205, 0.005749821197241545, 0.199860617518425, -0.30783599615097046, 0.7106940150260925, -0.10865600407123566, -0.13926279544830322, -0.5964349508285522, -0.339803010225296, 0.20144662261009216, -0.12417449057102203, -0.3010558485984802, -0.45164796710014343, -0.5148299932479858, -0.5390350222587585, 0.40121525526046753, -0.041663721203804016, 0.41613489389419556, 0.30374473333358765, 0.08884524554014206, -0.7038672566413879, 0.2269904464483261, 0.21707022190093994, 0.9477932453155518, -0.525901734828949, 0.3529614508152008, 0.13857097923755646, -0.2529456913471222, 0.29669567942619324, 0.053797438740730286, -0.12378787249326706, 0.1526809185743332, 0.5091691613197327, 0.4331812858581543, -0.002482771873474121, -0.4839972257614136, 0.5104440450668335, -0.04239517077803612, -0.4135085344314575, -0.272295743227005, 0.09192381799221039, 0.4050619900226593, 0.2848375737667084, 0.2878541052341461, -0.4541984498500824, 0.12148689478635788, -0.5520949363708496, -0.02582249976694584, 0.6246415376663208, -0.7157533168792725, -0.49966874718666077, 0.5801778435707092, -0.08171358704566956, -0.34383994340896606, 0.32298317551612854, -0.034609682857990265, 0.07451711595058441, 0.5692188739776611, 0.4822562634944916, 0.7926231026649475, -0.22992436587810516, 0.8582441210746765, 0.2770307660102844, 0.39714473485946655, 0.060954999178647995, 0.424198180437088, -0.08356022089719772, -0.6387946605682373, -0.7785394191741943, -0.6167219281196594, -0.41335299611091614, 0.4832690954208374, -1.0637259483337402, 0.14807792007923126, -0.7393273115158081, -0.535590410232544, 0.5793761014938354, 0.002579096704721451, -0.7078129649162292, 0.54778653383255, 0.346352219581604, 0.7402999997138977, -1.2343205213546753, 0.274880588054657, 0.6323179602622986, -0.49657726287841797, -0.697226881980896, 0.14677190780639648, 0.43688711524009705, -0.8814842104911804, 0.22347618639469147, 0.2670397162437439, -0.13820204138755798, -0.31228312849998474, -0.5487060546875, -0.5221872329711914, 0.924759030342102, 0.6941499710083008, -0.26917800307273865, -0.05126376077532768, 0.13172273337841034, 0.7395507097244263, -0.13919387757778168, 0.3254343569278717, 0.4942874312400818, 0.3608691990375519, 0.08612420409917831, -0.5708385109901428, 0.27287745475769043, 0.06560024619102478, 0.024023808538913727, 0.1689940094947815, -0.4213458299636841, 0.4519142508506775, -0.46581554412841797, -0.524071455001831, -0.43328770995140076, 0.1923564076423645, 0.09059389680624008, 0.6269807815551758, 0.26973047852516174, 0.6495571136474609, 0.5739519596099854, 0.22277839481830597, 1.1226036548614502, -0.1615527719259262, 0.62157142162323, 0.9775670766830444, -0.3430823087692261, 0.9366598725318909, 0.4935411810874939, -0.5233854651451111, 0.5248100757598877, 0.8532406687736511, -0.02345038577914238, 0.17320075631141663, 0.07543888688087463, -0.5231887698173523, -0.3415394127368927, -0.16358986496925354, -0.15167154371738434, 0.5842152833938599, 0.49009013175964355, -0.5404921174049377, -0.694125771522522, 0.006827159319072962, 0.46706444025039673, -0.19183778762817383, -0.3164418637752533, 0.7791410088539124, 0.29196667671203613, -0.14977432787418365, 0.5991645455360413, -0.016302593052387238, 0.27750784158706665, -0.4862947463989258, 0.009459677152335644, -0.18132488429546356, -0.03496434912085533, -0.33935874700546265, -0.8882794380187988, 0.7226150035858154, 0.18510675430297852, -0.12926581501960754, -0.06472426652908325, 0.9532089829444885, 0.00866099912673235, -0.7995703220367432, 0.4745379388332367, 0.9221957325935364, 0.43378952145576477, -0.398207426071167, -0.5384455919265747, -0.3865169584751129, -0.47032567858695984, -0.45308569073677063, 0.4671759605407715, 0.6495026350021362, -0.24959975481033325, 0.5850683450698853, 0.632683515548706, 0.5063128471374512, -0.40509793162345886, 0.10575258731842041, 0.41212305426597595, -0.7707021832466125, -0.07339396327733994, -1.259796142578125, 0.34237080812454224, -0.10336414724588394, -0.0075025297701358795, 0.8093705773353577, 0.22243240475654602, 0.4871969521045685, 0.11327214539051056, 0.7378945350646973, 0.08671201765537262, 0.3146253228187561, -0.10823269933462143, 0.9744727611541748, -0.8486583828926086, -0.29012301564216614, -0.08086518198251724, -0.7545653581619263, -0.802063524723053, 0.5264676213264465, -0.513968825340271, -0.11678098887205124, 0.5956905484199524, 0.6400779485702515, 0.1252220869064331, -0.21357053518295288, 0.588024914264679, 0.3616633117198944, 0.20715999603271484, 0.23642276227474213, 0.56852126121521, 0.08889112621545792, 0.12563489377498627, -0.29908236861228943, -0.6779149770736694, -0.1729728877544403, -0.6192249655723572, -1.0724767446517944, -0.16297531127929688, -0.48006245493888855, -0.2568519711494446, -0.10251354426145554, 0.5356957316398621, 0.6349571347236633, -0.41034480929374695, -0.012261142954230309, 0.35068371891975403, 0.0912971943616867, -0.3989504873752594, -0.39454323053359985, 0.17078600823879242, 0.07655394822359085, -0.37269675731658936, -0.018136240541934967, 0.6936739087104797, -0.24525964260101318, -0.64530348777771, 0.28692927956581116, -0.044475264847278595, 0.5228431820869446, 0.9775450229644775, 0.11757389456033707, -0.7337707281112671, -0.395611047744751, -0.15222612023353577, -0.004483870230615139, 0.16894550621509552, 0.6000767946243286, -0.431867778301239, 0.7196999788284302, 0.3386598527431488, 0.412118524312973, 0.38252583146095276, -0.08390503376722336, 0.30661046504974365, -0.3417132496833801, -0.23549796640872955, 0.035435792058706284, 0.24504797160625458, 0.4100780487060547, -0.5523620843887329, 0.38580381870269775, 0.1371961236000061, -0.2893151044845581, -0.7750785946846008, 0.008177594281733036, -1.1088016033172607, -0.4127083420753479, 1.2230879068374634, -0.30227506160736084, -0.249327152967453, 0.025150036439299583, -0.18258649110794067, 0.5579859614372253, -0.20324067771434784, 1.1655144691467285, 0.831938624382019, -0.4225154221057892, -0.36821290850639343, -0.9025000333786011, -0.04913382604718208, 0.12134930491447449, -0.877080500125885, -0.15751247107982635, 0.4577238857746124, 0.6383047103881836, -0.03201081231236458, 1.0359623432159424, -0.29345381259918213, 0.26481878757476807, -0.006577962543815374, 0.03053281269967556, 0.26869094371795654, 0.004054899327456951, -0.47657254338264465, 0.29350754618644714, 0.1290273666381836, -0.2319062203168869 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06264v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06264v1	LLaVA-Docent: Instruction Tuning with Multimodal Large Language Model to Support Art Appreciation Education	2024-02-09T09:25:18	2024-02-09T09:25:18	Unggi Lee, Minji Jeon, Yunseo Lee, Gyuri Byun, Yoorim Son, Jaeyoon Shin, Hongkyu Ko, Hyeoncheol Kim	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI	Art appreciation is vital in nurturing critical thinking and emotional intelligence among learners. However, traditional art appreciation education has often been hindered by limited access to art resources, especially for disadvantaged students, and an imbalanced emphasis on STEM subjects in mainstream education. In response to these challenges, recent technological advancements have paved the way for innovative solutions. This study explores the application of multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) in art appreciation education, focusing on developing LLaVA-Docent, a model that leverages these advancements. Our approach involved a comprehensive literature review and consultations with experts in the field, leading to developing a robust data framework. Utilizing this framework, we generated a virtual dialogue dataset that was leveraged by GPT-4. This dataset was instrumental in training the MLLM, named LLaVA-Docent. Six researchers conducted quantitative and qualitative evaluations of LLaVA-Docent to assess its effectiveness, benchmarking it against the GPT-4 model in a few-shot setting. The evaluation process revealed distinct strengths and weaknesses of the LLaVA-Docent model. Our findings highlight the efficacy of LLaVA-Docent in enhancing the accessibility and engagement of art appreciation education. By harnessing the potential of MLLMs, this study makes a significant contribution to the field of art education, proposing a novel methodology that reimagines the way art appreciation is taught and experienced.	[ -0.187814399600029, -0.7999964356422424, 0.6264901757240295, -0.24405503273010254, -0.41179266571998596, 0.23829403519630432, -0.306661456823349, -0.6994399428367615, 0.1930391937494278, 0.05926317349076271, -0.4574134051799774, -0.3936900198459625, -0.586793065071106, 0.020740479230880737, -0.158667653799057, 0.8070571422576904, -0.09600649774074554, 0.3822017312049866, -0.07731381058692932, -0.2033001184463501, -0.647563636302948, -0.24352261424064636, -0.5151968598365784, -0.1334323287010193, 0.5640168786048889, 0.27652764320373535, 0.13520324230194092, 0.11955428123474121, 0.3272950351238251, 0.38010016083717346, 0.00969076156616211, 0.5313025712966919, -0.5880915522575378, 0.08641765266656876, 0.10603739321231842, -0.4821886420249939, -0.5041479468345642, 0.18200860917568207, 0.5806244015693665, 0.09580475091934204, -0.15672852098941803, -0.05216881260275841, -0.15154235064983368, 0.6760823130607605, -0.47773417830467224, 0.39012548327445984, -0.5305984616279602, 0.1657225489616394, -0.04684403911232948, -0.2554733157157898, -0.32675912976264954, -0.5365496277809143, 0.1453707069158554, -0.7802257537841797, -0.17579972743988037, -0.3966604471206665, 0.6019768118858337, 0.10989575833082199, -0.5099707841873169, -0.25295132398605347, -0.47795337438583374, 0.6785411238670349, -0.41679492592811584, 0.5042585134506226, 0.09242890775203705, 0.5685126185417175, 0.31487005949020386, -0.578069806098938, -0.6489797234535217, -0.2168385088443756, 0.4244123697280884, 0.39147770404815674, 0.1257152557373047, 0.08806687593460083, 0.039005130529403687, 0.49015676975250244, -0.141974076628685, 0.21903298795223236, -0.11036498099565506, -0.14068855345249176, 0.37948521971702576, 0.2653537690639496, 0.19402046501636505, 0.08135346323251724, -0.540492057800293, -0.05173889547586441, -0.4936080276966095, 0.26893433928489685, 0.06485126167535782, -0.03639455884695053, -0.07895839214324951, 0.5828217267990112, 0.1441681832075119, 0.613455057144165, -0.07909971475601196, -0.5653501749038696, 0.3302485942840576, -0.3842633366584778, -0.1401573121547699, -0.40600478649139404, 0.4469337463378906, 0.7333919405937195, 0.517426609992981, 0.22443416714668274, -0.347663938999176, 0.05025554820895195, 0.10369206964969635, -1.0015782117843628, -0.053055256605148315, -0.15733039379119873, -0.433664470911026, -0.35817912220954895, -0.3490011692047119, -0.6317553520202637, -0.6940666437149048, -0.7970413565635681, 0.3802652955055237, -0.5454186797142029, -0.4131591320037842, 0.019495531916618347, -0.08211755007505417, 0.22896960377693176, 0.9177690744400024, -0.7793869972229004, -0.228928804397583, 0.4567941427230835, 0.7642004489898682, -0.1469440758228302, -0.3225211799144745, -0.342278391122818, -0.007141015026718378, -0.24472863972187042, 0.8593630790710449, -0.9474814534187317, -0.5108665823936462, 0.1725827306509018, -0.08991684019565582, -0.18810345232486725, -0.2704649567604065, 0.6894554495811462, -0.3454592227935791, 0.143465057015419, -0.09819605201482773, -0.48781031370162964, -0.35754990577697754, 0.6043958067893982, -0.5062773823738098, 0.8102266788482666, 0.3161291182041168, -0.5405088067054749, 0.15564921498298645, -0.9779930710792542, -0.05969598516821861, 0.1912023425102234, -0.49824634194374084, -0.3594856560230255, 0.27288389205932617, 0.26481592655181885, 0.3285903036594391, -0.24387359619140625, -0.006381275597959757, -0.07935596257448196, -0.4826280474662781, 0.4647144675254822, -0.6613543033599854, 0.4663788378238678, 0.04059882089495659, -0.17732667922973633, 0.39329051971435547, -0.6475957632064819, -0.0606984943151474, 0.2516230046749115, -0.5809527635574341, -0.42819300293922424, -0.42724522948265076, 0.3809010088443756, 0.1636042445898056, 0.26709917187690735, -0.4828120768070221, 0.4365147650241852, -0.28314170241355896, 0.300503671169281, 1.1425142288208008, -0.12608948349952698, 0.39358437061309814, -0.25077125430107117, 0.7923385500907898, 0.09144817292690277, 0.3895746171474457, -0.38311707973480225, -0.3186074495315552, -0.4732785224914551, -0.49560245871543884, 0.060067590326070786, 0.36594459414482117, -0.8013100028038025, -0.29729849100112915, -0.37430599331855774, -0.4116106331348419, -0.8570215702056885, 0.39983057975769043, 0.3021181523799896, 0.4668826162815094, -0.0026591962669044733, -0.467154324054718, -0.2543294131755829, -0.7035481333732605, 0.1481294482946396, 0.05488308519124985, 0.21412920951843262, 0.606307327747345, 0.17014187574386597, -0.30476754903793335, 0.46226680278778076, -0.21812434494495392, -0.3984462320804596, 0.015639346092939377, 0.0030909613706171513, 0.13991372287273407, 0.12975694239139557, 0.6342857480049133, -0.6807969808578491, -0.5093496441841125, 0.22034594416618347, -0.775865912437439, 0.11888391524553299, 0.18285523355007172, -0.21154065430164337, 0.2980966567993164, 0.04494646564126015, -0.5665302872657776, 0.21856766939163208, 0.5989069938659668, -0.17614050209522247, 0.7507954835891724, -0.0318627692759037, 0.3929870128631592, -0.894740104675293, -0.04325083643198013, -0.13273252546787262, 0.08503987640142441, -0.6131753325462341, 0.04230929911136627, 0.02565559186041355, -0.24562348425388336, -0.52329421043396, 0.4719603657722473, -0.49743109941482544, 0.2593287527561188, -0.5673794150352478, 0.03959064185619354, 0.339760959148407, 0.40509292483329773, 0.3374706208705902, 0.7693610191345215, 0.5689213275909424, -0.16409587860107422, 0.3719145953655243, 0.17347125709056854, -0.5428813099861145, 1.4879659414291382, -0.47278305888175964, 0.39765045046806335, -0.20431658625602722, 0.2717377245426178, -0.8374342918395996, 0.02517320215702057, 0.34757670760154724, -0.09625817090272903, 0.6836019158363342, -0.2998181879520416, -0.22891607880592346, -0.3013938367366791, -0.3661954998970032, 0.5039862990379333, 0.23973621428012848, -0.45207154750823975, 1.0392898321151733, 0.1955615133047104, -0.1416052281856537, -0.7512425780296326, -0.22641533613204956, 0.2748884856700897, -0.3523672819137573, -0.7311365008354187, -0.34794315695762634, -0.6346238255500793, -0.1338733732700348, -0.2779819667339325, 0.14209815859794617, -0.0532989576458931, 0.08108582347631454, 0.23297753930091858, 0.42562681436538696, -0.1599709838628769, 0.3034636080265045, -0.10100775212049484, -0.03668572008609772, -0.04558549448847771, -0.17287437617778778, 0.36624228954315186, -0.38213780522346497, -0.7114563584327698, -0.5552610158920288, 0.4545155465602875, 0.9812820553779602, -0.4252867102622986, 0.457254022359848, 1.1969223022460938, 0.09948550164699554, 0.25832873582839966, -0.8137557506561279, -0.21040092408657074, -0.42381253838539124, 0.4270159900188446, -0.6128121018409729, -0.7107995748519897, 0.12484503537416458, -0.2873920798301697, 0.1749819815158844, -0.16806429624557495, 0.6968877911567688, -0.32227012515068054, 0.6655815243721008, 0.7003412842750549, 0.13497549295425415, 0.9018754959106445, -0.538528561592102, -0.029952500015497208, -1.2153230905532837, -0.32555344700813293, -0.026406792923808098, -0.33090877532958984, -0.0889478325843811, -0.6419332027435303, 0.6159821152687073, -0.40691372752189636, 0.06691855192184448, -0.5329071283340454, -0.3624403774738312, 0.3978034257888794, 0.2806644141674042, 0.4347188174724579, 0.2873096764087677, 0.2259567677974701, -0.010648056864738464, -0.11763287335634232, -0.24760235846042633, -0.4452366530895233, 1.1949751377105713, 0.4095534682273865, 0.764747142791748, 0.24762755632400513, 0.468069463968277, 0.2044752836227417, 0.5447945594787598, -1.1836036443710327, 0.3629824221134186, 0.06246483325958252, -0.3933377265930176, -0.3119027316570282, 0.012482881546020508, -0.8741955161094666, 0.32375818490982056, -0.21145261824131012, -0.3970659673213959, 0.319566011428833, 0.0479104109108448, 0.2522212266921997, 0.194011390209198, -0.8529345989227295, 0.7310909628868103, -0.49035194516181946, -0.6303197741508484, -0.3449541926383972, -0.45557793974876404, 0.43146806955337524, -0.3160523772239685, 0.5764431357383728, -0.1891798973083496, -0.07894258946180344, 0.15343426167964935, -0.11573086678981781, 1.03538179397583, -0.3906642198562622, -0.37212178111076355, 0.07107505947351456, 0.20203879475593567, 0.7613857388496399, -0.17799817025661469, -0.23338136076927185, 0.006746835540980101, -0.1959272176027298, -0.3052462041378021, -0.6064537167549133, 0.722151517868042, -0.7911357283592224, -0.6988198757171631, -0.025848213583230972, -0.8550810217857361, -0.10985067486763, 0.1706559658050537, -0.2612802982330322, 0.3908933699131012, -0.23303167521953583, -0.05254216864705086, 0.8033803105354309, -0.12014328688383102, 0.3061194121837616, 0.6490366458892822, 0.003051764564588666, -0.2798719108104706, 0.8511871099472046, 0.03477518633008003, 0.4237963855266571, 0.3056269586086273, 0.5147780776023865, -0.34261998534202576, -0.3949815630912781, -0.5735759139060974, 0.32025811076164246, -1.1375236511230469, -0.13132837414741516, -0.47351980209350586, 0.05264761298894882, 0.026707397773861885, -0.22938057780265808, -0.21943219006061554, -0.2949353754520416, -0.3197554647922516, -0.216730996966362, 0.5703935623168945, 0.7382130026817322, -0.03317093849182129, -0.00958941038697958, -0.4205688536167145, -0.08184745907783508, 0.7296205163002014, 0.5619089007377625, 0.289468377828598, -0.6519158482551575, -0.4021931290626526, 0.0029308092780411243, -0.355965256690979, -0.6477624773979187, 0.16466912627220154, 0.48020222783088684, 0.704890787601471, 0.5843263268470764, -0.32766005396842957, 0.5085993409156799, -0.43705207109451294, 0.569947361946106, 0.35303449630737305, -0.7128771543502808, 0.6151959896087646, -0.609498143196106, 0.29505929350852966, 0.32260048389434814, 0.1331750601530075, -0.3728810250759125, -0.30098769068717957, -0.2620376646518707, -0.7366556525230408, 0.396311491727829, -0.33340561389923096, 0.637409508228302, 0.11751601099967957, -0.13974446058273315, 0.34312158823013306, 0.3235277831554413, -0.9846764206886292, -0.0593441016972065, -0.7967187166213989, 0.024251747876405716, -0.025638164952397346, -0.5576441287994385, -0.6718615293502808, -0.29563865065574646, 0.549701452255249, -0.29755163192749023, 0.1546158641576767, -0.07792989909648895, -0.1933002769947052, -0.15265069901943207, 0.5633476376533508, 0.8542125821113586, 0.7290850281715393, -0.057054996490478516, -0.0879305824637413, 0.17353475093841553, -0.5826572775840759, 0.27498796582221985, -0.2087075114250183, 0.059910789132118225, -0.08418889343738556, 0.029356705024838448, 0.8996963500976562, 0.2305697500705719, -0.7836468815803528, 0.6458919644355774, -0.23105594515800476, 0.059028539806604385, -0.44319766759872437, -0.15490426123142242, 0.21760621666908264, 0.3980448246002197, 0.2697698175907135, -0.09703492373228073, 0.20724208652973175, -0.43306106328964233, -0.3480570912361145, 0.5296639800071716, -0.3996703028678894, -0.20838463306427002, 0.3885594606399536, 0.34921687841415405, -0.21646134555339813, 0.4502660930156708, 0.23403163254261017, -0.37467965483665466, 0.39691758155822754, 0.5973823666572571, 0.6782538294792175, -0.13722588121891022, 0.23095951974391937, 0.013279592618346214, 0.31709831953048706, 0.34769847989082336, 0.19870799779891968, -0.1757347285747528, -0.5665218234062195, -0.4393519461154938, -0.4979718029499054, -0.4969859719276428, -0.06809213757514954, -0.4407722055912018, 0.07921800762414932, -0.2816842794418335, -0.34793326258659363, -0.22087255120277405, -0.06831830739974976, -1.0178509950637817, -0.14876733720302582, 0.278848260641098, 0.7817161679267883, -1.0940967798233032, 0.8721920847892761, 0.9799560308456421, -0.4451434314250946, -0.9377344250679016, -0.3019905090332031, 0.31379660964012146, -0.9336233735084534, 0.8533207774162292, 0.06775590777397156, -0.21444077789783478, -0.04789787903428078, -0.17625850439071655, -0.6410602927207947, 1.2120047807693481, 0.2554427981376648, -0.7628829479217529, 0.3216171860694885, -0.3838784694671631, 0.723831832408905, -0.4254419207572937, 0.6081458926200867, 0.4074542820453644, 0.7166332602500916, 0.2396702617406845, -0.8084712624549866, -0.2866649627685547, -0.538183331489563, 0.11901947855949402, -0.021387213841080666, -0.7599616646766663, 0.5043370127677917, -0.22153307497501373, 0.10977727174758911, 0.02106548100709915, 0.2722972333431244, 0.5677305459976196, 0.4447060823440552, 0.4142754077911377, 0.29486703872680664, 0.7266601324081421, -0.011985930614173412, 1.1232892274856567, -0.09631220996379852, -0.11476011574268341, 0.5607916712760925, -0.15269793570041656, 0.7115464210510254, 0.6638766527175903, -0.10281822830438614, 0.7603306174278259, 0.4686218202114105, 0.011484318412840366, 0.3366524279117584, 0.0027721859514713287, -0.5536537170410156, -0.09820761531591415, -0.642327606678009, -0.4847734868526459, 0.5813875794410706, 0.6246116757392883, -0.40956300497055054, -0.006358543410897255, 0.3894301950931549, -0.11277918517589569, 0.18059024214744568, -0.5336967706680298, 0.6026020646095276, 0.0725826695561409, -0.11702091246843338, 0.88230299949646, -0.5255650877952576, 0.711105227470398, -0.5102770924568176, -0.1971125453710556, -0.24183037877082825, -0.06984558701515198, -0.2198355495929718, -0.6924626231193542, -0.3274853527545929, -0.17601977288722992, -0.2089240401983261, -0.1582179218530655, 0.49760761857032776, -0.3205411732196808, -0.6905902028083801, 0.14567594230175018, 0.4035302996635437, 0.22792920470237732, 0.36198532581329346, -0.7127332091331482, 0.46639567613601685, -0.16677986085414886, -0.09935818612575531, 0.3423328697681427, 0.6509167551994324, -0.04878067597746849, 0.6749140024185181, 0.5087711215019226, 0.08230937272310257, -0.30119508504867554, 0.783811628818512, 0.8329260349273682, -0.03502444177865982, -0.0628659799695015, -0.5759986042976379, 0.7171487212181091, 0.10955558717250824, -0.10478826612234116, 0.5611693263053894, 0.31131577491760254, 0.5401136875152588, -0.4754399359226227, 0.6946060061454773, 0.27606841921806335, 0.2639431655406952, -0.551375150680542, 0.44012707471847534, -0.5998059511184692, 0.3742087781429291, -0.48994049429893494, -0.7180779576301575, -0.006430028006434441, 0.6320644021034241, -0.42213794589042664, 0.16439515352249146, 0.5356988906860352, 0.6799149513244629, -0.058398544788360596, -0.25959423184394836, 0.5399641990661621, 0.0838162824511528, 0.43350011110305786, 0.5770906209945679, 1.27240788936615, -0.013158028945326805, 0.4619493782520294, -0.200145423412323, -0.34290948510169983, -0.3572703003883362, -0.8943597674369812, -1.0183074474334717, -0.4629504382610321, -0.10662367939949036, 0.020502323284745216, 0.17659497261047363, 0.782601535320282, 0.5806795358657837, -0.28487348556518555, -0.31487837433815, 0.4864572286605835, 0.020596183836460114, -0.23774689435958862, -0.22296762466430664, 0.510749101638794, -0.12369982898235321, -0.9737356305122375, 0.26817792654037476, 0.5803154110908508, 0.2533297836780548, -0.4715253412723541, -0.19787505269050598, 0.022187408059835434, 0.048955537378787994, 0.9987899661064148, 0.08261328935623169, -0.9865912795066833, -0.2524496912956238, 0.07416194677352905, -0.027754632756114006, 0.2492796927690506, 0.6726813912391663, -0.435497909784317, 1.0671024322509766, 0.0918290987610817, 0.5851343274116516, 0.5560495257377625, -0.044869475066661835, 0.4460713565349579, -0.43744367361068726, 0.18962597846984863, 0.11711180210113525, 0.4566813111305237, 0.5258805751800537, -0.38239797949790955, 0.4698448181152344, 0.24987691640853882, -0.611921489238739, -0.7090442180633545, 0.3783282935619354, -1.0230234861373901, -0.026905223727226257, 0.8822949528694153, -0.18788811564445496, 0.1059475839138031, -0.0031188479624688625, -0.7040135860443115, 0.07225269079208374, -0.4237596392631531, 1.0402295589447021, 0.6702332496643066, -0.21150881052017212, -0.7827562093734741, -0.6319139003753662, 0.008577902801334858, 0.22165726125240326, -0.7320210337638855, -0.16324743628501892, 0.7614336013793945, 0.505578875541687, -0.1549314260482788, 0.6514768004417419, -0.2716049253940582, 0.5673637390136719, -0.22768554091453552, 0.15220068395137787, -0.49014005064964294, -0.18899022042751312, -0.28791123628616333, -0.12033282965421677, 0.6140185594558716, -0.07487592101097107 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06262v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06262v2	On the Efficacy of Eviction Policy for Key-Value Constrained Generative Language Model Inference	2024-02-09T09:20:59	2024-02-17T10:08:14	Siyu Ren, Kenny Q. Zhu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Despite the recent success associated with Large Language Models (LLMs), they are notably cost-prohibitive to deploy in resource-constrained environments due to their excessive memory and computational demands. In addition to model parameters, the key-value cache is also stored in GPU memory, growing linearly with batch size and sequence length. As a remedy, recent works have proposed various eviction policies for maintaining the overhead of key-value cache under a given budget. This paper embarks on the efficacy of existing eviction policies in terms of importance score calculation and eviction scope construction. We identify the deficiency of prior policies in these two aspects and introduce RoCo, a robust cache omission policy based on temporal attention scores and robustness measures. Extensive experimentation spanning prefilling and auto-regressive decoding stages validates the superiority of RoCo. Finally, we release EasyKV, a versatile software package dedicated to user-friendly key-value constrained generative inference. Code available at https://github.com/DRSY/EasyKV.	[ -0.16509661078453064, -0.655426561832428, 0.696942150592804, -0.11506860703229904, -0.1378946453332901, -0.2445509284734726, -0.5595850944519043, -0.10298216342926025, -0.12079329788684845, 0.4330955445766449, -0.21213805675506592, -0.5854911208152771, -0.43576374650001526, -0.19083204865455627, -0.19144216179847717, 0.7745589017868042, 0.03382965177297592, -0.40836283564567566, -0.10037872940301895, 0.0468188114464283, -0.3419921100139618, -0.1376221925020218, -0.3099119961261749, 0.10327836871147156, 0.3127458691596985, 0.38708096742630005, 0.774881899356842, 0.8748721480369568, 0.36723899841308594, 0.19114041328430176, -0.29444965720176697, 0.01741517335176468, -0.5190740823745728, 0.1823417842388153, 0.0996251329779625, -0.39789265394210815, -0.4094887673854828, -0.1180725172162056, 0.7432035207748413, -0.03803710266947746, -0.6508384943008423, -0.15626631677150726, -0.2130272388458252, 0.3375340700149536, -1.0886906385421753, 0.222586989402771, -1.143105387687683, -0.09842441976070404, -0.09519337862730026, -0.04229237511754036, -0.5443054437637329, -0.3205536901950836, -0.17402991652488708, -0.5495971441268921, 0.3536188304424286, -0.131220281124115, 1.2329840660095215, 0.5952390432357788, -0.04554212465882301, -0.3631272315979004, -0.7448976039886475, 0.8741470575332642, -0.6613031625747681, 0.19228330254554749, 0.5419077277183533, 0.2631661891937256, -0.244206041097641, -0.433887779712677, -0.5824663639068604, -0.1525702178478241, 0.3606465458869934, 0.14814913272857666, 0.08425753563642502, 0.4250372648239136, 0.21922238171100616, 0.523064136505127, -0.1908905804157257, 0.49293020367622375, -0.28725665807724, -0.15240873396396637, 0.16361504793167114, 0.14142827689647675, 0.2637256681919098, -0.27152544260025024, -0.17181234061717987, -0.1905420571565628, -1.1026395559310913, 0.2389204204082489, 0.4606279134750366, 0.37929341197013855, 0.12268096208572388, 0.492119163274765, -0.024365808814764023, 0.3728480935096741, -0.16487868130207062, -0.05566113442182541, 0.07760393619537354, -0.2727060317993164, -0.3773510158061981, -0.011950092390179634, 0.6736114621162415, 0.10201988369226456, 0.04774707555770874, -0.3313170075416565, -0.15255039930343628, -0.031421300023794174, 0.5521947145462036, -0.6380471587181091, -0.032642532140016556, 0.3501553535461426, -0.3343360722064972, -0.5190393924713135, -0.18290609121322632, -1.0804225206375122, 0.08124451339244843, 0.32903724908828735, 0.09033279865980148, -0.13250577449798584, -0.25442594289779663, -0.10282198339700699, -0.02669486403465271, 0.6791836619377136, 0.48931172490119934, -1.1451696157455444, 0.16941328346729279, 0.5847479701042175, 0.7068811058998108, -0.13644449412822723, -0.01329508051276207, -0.6869245171546936, 0.04263811931014061, -0.3198544681072235, 0.20596876740455627, -0.766869306564331, -0.4058688282966614, 0.12012709677219391, -0.07056274265050888, 0.026446161791682243, -0.5334596633911133, 0.6175786256790161, -0.6677438616752625, -0.2987900376319885, -0.10764230787754059, -0.24177759885787964, 0.09245088696479797, 0.16094814240932465, -0.7876091599464417, 1.0853742361068726, 0.3504287600517273, -0.10908748209476471, 0.45389291644096375, -0.18317745625972748, -0.2710329592227936, 0.04206153750419617, -0.2498137652873993, -0.8621967434883118, 0.20214565098285675, 0.23609194159507751, 0.40103527903556824, -0.3578473627567291, 0.4646357297897339, -0.42934650182724, -0.06428913027048111, -0.2078392505645752, -0.5865482091903687, 0.6027734279632568, 0.6218641400337219, -0.3210591971874237, -0.12931407988071442, -0.6580724120140076, 0.08307600021362305, 0.07873763144016266, -0.46686819195747375, -0.320040225982666, 0.2674639821052551, -0.2096739113330841, 0.1667986661195755, 0.19499389827251434, -0.4150242507457733, 0.3327292501926422, -0.2019655555486679, 0.5860245823860168, 0.6925315260887146, -0.30512315034866333, 0.4898527264595032, 0.07471095770597458, 0.8206549882888794, -0.29777511954307556, 0.19539234042167664, -0.12351591885089874, -0.4207770526409149, -0.5481804609298706, -0.608003556728363, 0.03797392174601555, 0.44591155648231506, -0.3161557912826538, 0.2542516589164734, -0.39039507508277893, 0.036416515707969666, -0.5646260380744934, 0.24868962168693542, 0.46281278133392334, 0.017217164859175682, 0.14598049223423004, -0.0885896310210228, -0.043611228466033936, -0.5861597061157227, -0.00898472499102354, -0.263388454914093, 0.2813042104244232, 0.4849509596824646, 0.39587274193763733, 0.05099441111087799, 0.7898311018943787, -0.23830091953277588, -0.031575046479701996, -0.24162077903747559, 0.17067576944828033, -0.07274528592824936, 0.3842504322528839, 0.5320500731468201, -0.7566539645195007, -0.24731624126434326, -0.04683511704206467, -0.37481656670570374, -0.043832436203956604, -0.1429416686296463, 0.18946947157382965, 0.22634968161582947, 0.49751466512680054, -0.6759793758392334, 0.6225464940071106, 0.6144800782203674, 0.2281346321105957, 0.5774880051612854, -0.5337803959846497, -0.035630278289318085, -0.6651884913444519, -0.1545046716928482, -0.25752219557762146, -0.3458986282348633, -0.4034174680709839, 0.3858952224254608, 0.011458625085651875, -0.03587741032242775, -0.4562714993953705, 0.313081294298172, -0.4733770191669464, -0.0437861904501915, 0.0645386129617691, -0.008265271782875061, -0.14535978436470032, 0.5232259035110474, 0.18226836621761322, 0.8002838492393494, 0.13780894875526428, -0.6359263062477112, -0.05238666757941246, 0.018670307472348213, -0.32381823658943176, 0.11254436522722244, -0.41882556676864624, 0.19156023859977722, -0.14108696579933167, 0.051873695105314255, -1.244189977645874, -0.025184670463204384, 0.1284199208021164, -0.15242652595043182, 0.6537361145019531, -0.4786471724510193, -0.3832158148288727, -0.22073954343795776, -0.36898431181907654, 0.49791088700294495, 0.7015721797943115, -0.5149794816970825, 0.49164965748786926, 0.631356954574585, 0.008403541520237923, -0.7561180591583252, -0.2770780920982361, 0.0917438268661499, -0.4893878996372223, -0.03122078999876976, 0.2189006209373474, 0.06005460023880005, -0.23601917922496796, 0.2506423890590668, 0.048696696758270264, -0.20734021067619324, 0.1440598964691162, 0.31259626150131226, 0.24295909702777863, -0.04678843542933464, 0.3347204327583313, 0.04894198104739189, 0.05597376078367233, 0.13478213548660278, 0.07754483073949814, 0.3263137936592102, -0.17016464471817017, -0.31835901737213135, -0.12125229835510254, 0.0899040699005127, 1.0289597511291504, -0.06352952867746353, 0.6061055660247803, 0.43782567977905273, -0.18249456584453583, -0.2919979691505432, -0.6851131319999695, 0.1851700097322464, -0.40487784147262573, 0.498378187417984, -0.5481837391853333, -0.9120988845825195, 0.5930524468421936, -0.23844054341316223, 0.14709049463272095, 0.6018481850624084, 0.6192834973335266, 0.0013140522642061114, 0.7490376830101013, 0.346056193113327, -0.2886693477630615, 0.5255380868911743, -0.37163791060447693, 0.2597748935222626, -1.0220041275024414, 0.054374150931835175, -0.7247070670127869, 0.10122236609458923, -0.7788142561912537, -0.41058093309402466, 0.08314129710197449, 0.1990232616662979, -0.06005149334669113, 0.16842345893383026, -0.5352535247802734, 0.3481709957122803, 0.2538605034351349, 0.11362271010875702, -0.05015108734369278, -0.12883774936199188, -0.13639043271541595, -0.03964253142476082, -0.9087619185447693, -0.31026390194892883, 1.3064531087875366, 0.2624841332435608, 0.818723201751709, -0.005199507810175419, 0.7284436821937561, 0.3233366906642914, 0.2945609986782074, -0.7746572494506836, 0.17683768272399902, 0.049513086676597595, -0.4411734938621521, -0.6862070560455322, -0.49154260754585266, -0.8316522240638733, 0.37690967321395874, 0.2271447777748108, -0.9593470096588135, 0.2890236973762512, 0.361904114484787, -0.5563145875930786, 0.5069226622581482, -0.46445000171661377, 0.9685426950454712, -0.17106197774410248, -0.6148118376731873, -0.524901270866394, -0.47320735454559326, 0.38523975014686584, 0.019029710441827774, 0.2553493082523346, -0.20233340561389923, 0.07227443158626556, 0.3523089587688446, -0.785015881061554, 0.8242437243461609, -0.1403426229953766, -0.003449562704190612, 0.6349308490753174, 0.0647537112236023, 1.182602882385254, -0.11718727648258209, 0.027138544246554375, 0.05108515918254852, -0.014631308615207672, -0.1723477691411972, -0.3964930474758148, 0.7931494116783142, -0.7277830243110657, -0.6194428205490112, -0.18446052074432373, -0.3777889013290405, 0.22054316103458405, -0.16198089718818665, 0.32679781317710876, 0.3102656602859497, -0.39859887957572937, 0.21969015896320343, 1.0251471996307373, -0.5772642493247986, 0.505670428276062, 0.16264738142490387, 0.10162189602851868, -0.24787648022174835, 0.9286474585533142, -0.08796875923871994, 0.7030194997787476, 0.49043625593185425, 0.4749073088169098, -0.24094845354557037, -0.5610731840133667, -0.33540254831314087, -0.04000471532344818, -0.5223755836486816, -0.07972955703735352, -0.5782922506332397, -0.3303122818470001, -0.33673909306526184, -0.2954438328742981, -0.7796264886856079, -0.36537665128707886, -0.20643603801727295, -0.1266469955444336, 0.36077892780303955, 0.5129589438438416, -0.21014440059661865, 0.1105722039937973, -0.4041236937046051, 0.3420562148094177, 0.44677940011024475, 0.06788082420825958, 0.08307824283838272, -0.5522257685661316, -0.18680404126644135, -0.1336906999349594, -0.18521420657634735, -0.4854511320590973, 0.6237401962280273, 0.2813054323196411, 0.6606965661048889, 0.6842356324195862, 0.20167461037635803, 0.6636053323745728, -0.28491610288619995, 0.6514632105827332, -0.015196556225419044, -0.694348156452179, 0.5345602631568909, -0.32840245962142944, 0.3274885416030884, 0.5547415614128113, -0.02508993074297905, -0.19975878298282623, -0.6858922839164734, -0.6853839159011841, -1.0592552423477173, 0.5571969151496887, 0.11976692825555801, 0.15516583621501923, -0.22323669493198395, 0.48918941617012024, -0.005060070194303989, 0.34992992877960205, -0.6419407725334167, -0.08065028488636017, -0.069429412484169, -0.12300101667642593, 0.13409817218780518, -0.6363898515701294, 0.21589340269565582, -0.20674996078014374, 0.5100823044776917, 0.12269489467144012, 0.3526631295681, -0.09202451258897781, -0.25043025612831116, -0.04982050880789757, 0.5734025239944458, 0.8113848567008972, 0.42800676822662354, -0.4413546323776245, 0.06159929558634758, 0.12561754882335663, -0.49009987711906433, 0.11794738471508026, -0.38584256172180176, -0.2797287702560425, -0.10461645573377609, -0.10305000096559525, 0.48941224813461304, 0.3703674077987671, -0.5493293404579163, 0.590199887752533, 0.02632521092891693, -0.0007732518133707345, -0.3509000241756439, 0.013903144747018814, -0.3406533896923065, -0.22864411771297455, 0.03967645391821861, -0.28843817114830017, 0.021368078887462616, -0.41776221990585327, 0.017017479985952377, 0.7006460428237915, -0.6752833127975464, -0.2509860694408417, 0.8957691192626953, 0.14996320009231567, -0.034484390169382095, 0.9283814430236816, -0.49062854051589966, -0.7544555068016052, 0.9684398174285889, 0.28991150856018066, 1.139770746231079, -0.28508254885673523, 0.18611112236976624, 0.48582714796066284, 0.6646721363067627, -0.20114777982234955, 0.105650395154953, -0.4805071949958801, -0.955361545085907, -0.47998881340026855, -0.5129568576812744, -0.09229327738285065, 0.4738578498363495, -0.6032772660255432, 0.012470504269003868, -0.41828790307044983, -0.06220412254333496, -0.5625002384185791, -0.20684762299060822, -0.885371208190918, -0.15517714619636536, 0.06460201740264893, 0.44846874475479126, -0.8473873734474182, 1.0461970567703247, 0.05477316677570343, -0.3566238284111023, -0.6141011714935303, -0.28692400455474854, 0.23756809532642365, -0.9818608164787292, 0.8560635447502136, -0.03201808035373688, -0.15585947036743164, -0.046990130096673965, -0.48081398010253906, -0.7278460264205933, 0.8228678703308105, 0.25845086574554443, -0.570061206817627, -0.06956792622804642, -0.18371452391147614, 0.3551608920097351, -0.18337605893611908, 0.20638342201709747, 0.5020296573638916, 0.4957457184791565, 0.1639433652162552, -0.765744149684906, -0.06769900768995285, -0.012358053587377071, 0.15257157385349274, 0.4267149865627289, -0.6285244226455688, 0.5540367960929871, -0.5306657552719116, -0.2024506777524948, 0.23752163350582123, 0.43316197395324707, -0.09400303661823273, -0.00651165097951889, 0.46214228868484497, 1.114067554473877, 0.5944674611091614, -0.1668912172317505, 1.170015573501587, -0.3815636932849884, 0.48317912220954895, 1.1772123575210571, -0.21347962319850922, 0.8298276662826538, 0.5037744641304016, -0.262256920337677, 0.21774345636367798, 0.4689011573791504, 0.16705822944641113, 0.9314262866973877, 0.21534325182437897, -0.3680764436721802, -0.3713052570819855, -0.05886935442686081, -0.19164268672466278, 0.48492640256881714, 0.777265727519989, -0.4569466710090637, -0.3308441638946533, -0.3054298460483551, 0.19039970636367798, -0.32725217938423157, -0.206460639834404, 0.5823163986206055, 0.03182265907526016, -0.6763889193534851, 0.33130377531051636, -0.28664344549179077, 0.20101672410964966, -0.7093867063522339, -0.31572216749191284, 0.05115671455860138, 0.18164101243019104, 0.0720788836479187, -0.33352410793304443, 0.06653912365436554, -0.16452468931674957, -0.09657403826713562, -0.4979115426540375, 0.38223424553871155, -0.5478925704956055, -0.1459847241640091, 0.10049378126859665, 0.023795111104846, 0.2507382929325104, 0.06395544856786728, -0.39429715275764465, 0.10035162419080734, -0.1616458296775818, -0.23515339195728302, 0.43867453932762146, 0.40179041028022766, 0.038234058767557144, 0.6223107576370239, 0.44914495944976807, 0.45330560207366943, 0.24558623135089874, 0.045277711004018784, 0.5968979001045227, -0.3603671193122864, -0.35973986983299255, -0.7495825886726379, 0.09920483082532883, 0.1893245130777359, -0.3069930076599121, 0.665240466594696, 0.41491395235061646, 0.6411157250404358, 0.2355327308177948, 0.800544261932373, -0.16935813426971436, -0.15440550446510315, -0.6369643211364746, 0.38889336585998535, -0.49358537793159485, 0.3900739848613739, -0.27996835112571716, -0.7186110019683838, -0.06604455411434174, 0.554922342300415, -0.3694920837879181, 0.11012977361679077, 0.5975733399391174, 0.905985951423645, 0.15421420335769653, -0.5569632649421692, 0.5370888113975525, 0.007497000973671675, 0.4304797053337097, 0.7336428165435791, 0.7017883062362671, -0.2516474723815918, 0.5927736163139343, -0.08564750850200653, -0.1651441752910614, -0.5666425824165344, -0.9528188705444336, -0.5014719367027283, -0.46118322014808655, -0.3930104672908783, -0.3482384979724884, 0.3575046956539154, 0.6462435126304626, 0.5876917243003845, -0.7784901261329651, -0.0502936877310276, -0.3052466809749603, 0.439222514629364, -0.4032905697822571, -0.2965140640735626, 0.5783886909484863, -0.5397577285766602, -0.6225098371505737, 0.1616368293762207, 0.5966936945915222, -0.16002872586250305, -0.3531686067581177, -0.21560432016849518, -0.1281213015317917, -0.2147625833749771, 0.4015335142612457, 0.8023124933242798, -1.1453702449798584, -0.44879940152168274, -0.3162330687046051, -0.42258116602897644, 0.3233187198638916, 0.9420967102050781, -0.6348995566368103, 1.1055299043655396, 0.5764033794403076, 0.7223389744758606, 0.6590626239776611, -0.08146578818559647, 0.6897596120834351, -0.41330474615097046, 0.08616996556520462, 0.09580393135547638, 0.3476152718067169, -0.09541267901659012, -0.5979922413825989, 0.29408642649650574, 0.12203340977430344, -0.5547181963920593, -0.7090020775794983, 0.17053468525409698, -0.8310614228248596, -0.10982680320739746, 1.1582257747650146, -0.28626748919487, -0.4653162658214569, -0.1425885707139969, 0.28982314467430115, 0.02559795044362545, -0.624114453792572, 0.9362912774085999, 0.8394519686698914, 0.27728769183158875, -0.522250771522522, -0.8152498602867126, 0.5431440472602844, 0.18566742539405823, -0.6190258264541626, 0.20069783926010132, 0.40177568793296814, 0.023630501702427864, -0.07879189401865005, 0.6096846461296082, -0.2469586730003357, 0.2870873510837555, 0.07151113450527191, 0.34359511733055115, -0.019864927977323532, -0.4748595058917999, -0.4629719853401184, 0.10340533405542374, 0.12545879185199738, -0.3245840072631836 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06255v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06255v2	Fight Back Against Jailbreaking via Prompt Adversarial Tuning	2024-02-09T09:09:39	2024-06-09T16:18:46	Yichuan Mo, Yuji Wang, Zeming Wei, Yisen Wang	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR	While Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved tremendous success in various applications, they are also susceptible to jailbreak attacks. Several primary defense strategies have been proposed to protect LLMs from producing harmful information, mostly with a particular focus on harmful content filtering or heuristical defensive prompt designs. However, how to achieve intrinsic robustness through the prompts remains an open problem. In this paper, motivated by adversarial training paradigms for achieving reliable robustness, we propose an approach named Prompt Adversarial Tuning (PAT) that trains a prompt control attached to the user prompt as a guard prefix. To achieve our defense goal whilst maintaining natural performance, we optimize the control prompt with both adversarial and benign prompts. Comprehensive experiments show that our method is effective against both black-box and white-box attacks, reducing the success rate of advanced attacks to nearly 0 while maintaining the model's utility on the benign task. The proposed defense strategy incurs only negligible computational overhead, charting a new perspective for future explorations in LLM security. Our code is available at https://github.com/rain152/PAT.	[ -0.4716871976852417, -1.0557663440704346, 0.39601337909698486, 0.11535627394914627, -0.41859808564186096, 0.38271793723106384, -0.4077683389186859, -0.027329599484801292, -0.006634157616645098, 0.6522591710090637, -0.7297695875167847, -0.378876656293869, -0.6359222531318665, 0.11305203288793564, 0.08073168247938156, 1.0103728771209717, 0.1909077912569046, -0.05131707340478897, 0.3055877983570099, 0.04226626828312874, -0.9367865324020386, -0.27790507674217224, -0.8962829113006592, 0.023808609694242477, 0.42703747749328613, 0.11915341019630432, 0.7453563213348389, 0.81721031665802, 0.23827801644802094, 0.254334032535553, -0.33712074160575867, 0.3856663703918457, -0.3817436993122101, 0.5223528146743774, -0.10604251176118851, -0.5072558522224426, -0.17029039561748505, 0.04554343968629837, 0.14052797853946686, 0.13989396393299103, 0.0830550417304039, -0.3668457865715027, -0.012716635130345821, 0.5250837802886963, -0.6364351511001587, -0.18330347537994385, -0.9471996426582336, -0.0008131758077070117, -0.3431141674518585, -0.42008018493652344, -0.6486719846725464, -0.5019932389259338, -0.37609225511550903, -0.5237012505531311, 0.08156368881464005, 0.26226839423179626, 0.8662704229354858, 0.4367139935493469, -0.30836501717567444, -0.14309217035770416, -0.2581022381782532, 0.40907910466194153, -0.5435455441474915, -0.018646162003278732, 0.5598233938217163, 0.23646102845668793, -0.6882889270782471, 0.003880823031067848, -0.22595036029815674, -0.611086905002594, 0.2499466985464096, -0.07120699435472488, -0.37397855520248413, 0.18563906848430634, 0.3316763639450073, -0.006687885150313377, -0.6115067005157471, 0.46917402744293213, -0.11575987935066223, -0.43552538752555847, 0.2783450186252594, 0.13835230469703674, 0.5432677865028381, 0.010000662878155708, -0.6948307752609253, -0.06259647756814957, -1.1289602518081665, 0.4936138093471527, 0.7119219303131104, 0.5145835876464844, -0.009510057047009468, 0.47488734126091003, 0.1601300984621048, 0.645643949508667, 0.3786250650882721, -0.006297171115875244, -0.3703435957431793, -0.017933819442987442, 0.09906692057847977, 0.1711675077676773, 0.8171255588531494, 0.39808836579322815, 0.37813010811805725, -0.48761263489723206, -0.34177160263061523, 0.1302763819694519, 0.6072759628295898, -0.7521160840988159, -0.32669079303741455, 0.03954305872321129, -0.03440667316317558, -0.6529713869094849, 0.1411220133304596, -0.8107057213783264, -0.9920558333396912, -0.07478068768978119, 0.20953352749347687, -0.7462015748023987, 0.1044723242521286, -0.19314715266227722, -0.17886154353618622, -0.0575280636548996, 0.09835930168628693, -1.010282278060913, 0.16836971044540405, 0.799883246421814, 0.9836536645889282, -0.06275950372219086, -0.16809281706809998, -1.167615532875061, -0.0029726505745202303, -0.46510079503059387, 0.5466001033782959, -0.2048829048871994, -0.6789993047714233, -0.10213595628738403, 0.09538772702217102, -0.10082785785198212, -0.5067058205604553, 0.549035370349884, -0.9012953042984009, -0.2461073100566864, -0.2807665765285492, -0.3196309506893158, 0.2758863866329193, 0.37958642840385437, -0.7403455972671509, 0.4469018876552582, -0.20689722895622253, -0.6484557390213013, 0.3482798933982849, -0.25922927260398865, -0.689507246017456, 0.03273415565490723, 0.11832408607006073, -0.5171263813972473, 0.15210527181625366, 0.4758467376232147, 0.135035902261734, -0.10487554967403412, 0.35896068811416626, -0.6358036994934082, -0.427182137966156, 0.43798696994781494, -0.4535767138004303, 0.8987482786178589, 0.3875845968723297, -0.463619202375412, 0.28958451747894287, -0.5860709547996521, -0.1798621267080307, 0.12816162407398224, -0.34988412261009216, -0.49083489179611206, -0.04755647853016853, -0.4749358296394348, -0.017154401168227196, 0.14874081313610077, -0.551960289478302, 0.42955222725868225, -0.47070634365081787, 0.5873882174491882, 1.2113009691238403, 0.004274926148355007, 0.42137959599494934, -0.19659262895584106, 0.7848068475723267, -0.1308950036764145, 0.29223185777664185, -0.47101283073425293, -0.2548568546772003, -0.36156052350997925, -0.4079391062259674, 0.08627638965845108, 0.78175950050354, -0.9240957498550415, 0.6842199563980103, 0.18416419625282288, -0.2483128309249878, -0.4465964436531067, 0.4351748526096344, 0.4882890582084656, 0.6509401798248291, 0.3315705358982086, -0.013032592833042145, -0.34523364901542664, -0.5213211178779602, -0.4347647726535797, -0.2601821720600128, 0.0502016618847847, 0.22256368398666382, 0.12430920451879501, 0.09417793154716492, 0.6599801182746887, -0.43228867650032043, 0.06325488537549973, -0.3100484609603882, -0.10706421732902527, 0.20415803790092468, 0.5988432765007019, 0.6085981130599976, -0.5744454264640808, -0.21831384301185608, -0.340288907289505, -0.5768436193466187, -0.514728307723999, -0.25026246905326843, -0.2135162353515625, 0.011509649455547333, 0.5707014799118042, -0.6701054573059082, 0.2819516658782959, 0.03468935564160347, -0.853898823261261, 0.7032361030578613, -0.015529826283454895, 0.06692788004875183, -0.8394832015037537, -0.029056807979941368, 0.09148310124874115, -0.42988160252571106, -0.42388439178466797, 0.38449278473854065, 0.19778893887996674, -0.4394812285900116, -0.4095991551876068, 0.5145808458328247, -0.18952776491641998, 0.578603208065033, -0.45468905568122864, 0.025785531848669052, 0.08077584207057953, 0.26457369327545166, -0.39601752161979675, 1.1438096761703491, 0.664736807346344, -0.5849080681800842, 0.5414150953292847, 0.217269629240036, -0.08810833096504211, 0.5941060781478882, -0.9074168801307678, 0.09900826215744019, -0.056185655295848846, 0.16614432632923126, -0.8089007139205933, 0.08759200572967529, 0.4165191948413849, -0.46594685316085815, 0.6726009845733643, -0.381636381149292, -0.24768221378326416, -0.3259870707988739, -0.6721863150596619, -0.17651081085205078, 0.41404029726982117, -0.7860962152481079, 0.1620372086763382, 0.1106618344783783, -0.24487245082855225, -0.5991343855857849, -0.4960602819919586, 0.4241369068622589, -0.610342800617218, -0.719187319278717, 0.2618328332901001, -0.24822305142879486, -0.2492900937795639, -0.2540806531906128, -0.14086028933525085, 0.16871316730976105, 0.7489709854125977, 0.2044147402048111, 0.5330867171287537, -0.0477595180273056, -0.2384052872657776, -0.24572379887104034, -0.2703120708465576, 0.2417801469564438, -0.35029762983322144, 0.615305483341217, 0.05773855373263359, -0.1037820428609848, -0.4269064962863922, 0.2996874153614044, 0.6647681593894958, -0.16723395884037018, 0.7769361138343811, 0.34486761689186096, 0.019008593633770943, -0.5702196359634399, -0.37287893891334534, -0.26267242431640625, -0.547590434551239, 0.10541453212499619, -0.2678041160106659, -0.9155803918838501, 0.5380273461341858, -0.15645845234394073, -0.13195201754570007, -0.17503076791763306, 0.3390395939350128, 0.0986267551779747, 0.9922808408737183, 0.5699734687805176, -0.4426622986793518, 0.7298076152801514, 0.1041300967335701, 0.050057150423526764, -0.6766088604927063, -0.042169295251369476, -0.5473890900611877, -0.19224677979946136, -0.36678647994995117, 0.19244730472564697, 0.33626610040664673, 0.39157912135124207, -0.6155115962028503, 0.5043212175369263, -0.3288842737674713, 0.5879847407341003, 0.7129600048065186, 0.3416782021522522, -0.05773418769240379, -0.26013070344924927, -0.16813503205776215, 0.010090874508023262, -0.38806766271591187, -0.4816025197505951, 0.8448584079742432, 0.42859867215156555, 1.037606120109558, 0.1771126687526703, 0.4596988260746002, 0.45154380798339844, -0.14337603747844696, -0.527479887008667, 0.5765133500099182, -0.22255022823810577, -0.37552762031555176, 0.030282342806458473, -0.546561062335968, -0.7412019968032837, 0.146465003490448, 0.06173202767968178, -0.8790279030799866, -0.13113248348236084, 0.28238993883132935, -0.5102236270904541, 0.49655914306640625, -0.6381632685661316, 0.9030973315238953, -0.46296021342277527, -0.5845816135406494, 0.18591973185539246, -0.7996532320976257, 0.5517165660858154, 0.049848634749650955, -0.018004637211561203, -0.09377840161323547, 0.029827309772372246, 0.45543697476387024, -0.635391354560852, 0.9673489332199097, -0.49409472942352295, 0.04952971264719963, 0.058076612651348114, 0.3619810938835144, 0.9226554036140442, 0.42215073108673096, -0.015906253829598427, -0.44205284118652344, -0.4186374545097351, -0.4365978240966797, -0.5097144842147827, 0.7498010396957397, -0.7183212637901306, -1.0291298627853394, -0.25047767162323, -0.4238113760948181, -0.21067480742931366, 0.1222362220287323, 0.5411723256111145, 0.4215344488620758, -0.12176602333784103, -0.1568114161491394, 1.0523873567581177, -0.4492187798023224, 0.625564694404602, 0.5560139417648315, 0.2326895296573639, -0.6543468236923218, 0.8012880682945251, -0.2506978213787079, 0.31748223304748535, 0.10371048748493195, 0.2845991551876068, -0.33596113324165344, -0.6001865267753601, -0.7661975026130676, -0.19280795753002167, -0.379876971244812, -0.5423600673675537, -0.23950627446174622, 0.04248166084289551, -0.3812749981880188, -0.40002915263175964, -0.20780858397483826, -0.3006138205528259, -0.42254963517189026, -0.08321674913167953, 0.5484800934791565, 0.2766838073730469, 0.04274842515587807, 0.5587925910949707, -0.4647046625614166, 0.41020768880844116, 0.17315439879894257, 0.20575037598609924, -0.31500011682510376, -0.6017377972602844, 0.03195655345916748, -0.20526543259620667, -0.6270394325256348, -0.9565103054046631, 0.3712979555130005, 0.13331672549247742, 0.42336663603782654, 0.5830421447753906, 0.4983450174331665, 0.3550032675266266, -0.51753169298172, 0.7522695064544678, 0.22385263442993164, -0.8260312676429749, 0.9678207635879517, -0.44913390278816223, 0.29288050532341003, 0.8397751450538635, -0.029437245801091194, -0.24735067784786224, -0.548647403717041, -0.29974064230918884, -0.9083848595619202, 0.6356852054595947, -0.2313421368598938, 0.0960913822054863, -0.08333572745323181, 0.2809620797634125, 0.08526967465877533, 0.3317054808139801, -0.6450421214103699, -0.2597907483577728, -0.32007327675819397, 0.0116539616137743, -0.06097664684057236, -0.09916382282972336, -0.34961292147636414, 0.1596449613571167, 0.7200448513031006, -0.051520936191082, -0.1385459005832672, -0.06313709169626236, -0.17018760740756989, 0.029654204845428467, 0.4751523435115814, 0.5287346839904785, 0.11631987988948822, -0.08730442076921463, 0.45570072531700134, -0.15783032774925232, -0.5312224626541138, 0.5434253811836243, 0.3637675642967224, -0.6047739386558533, -0.45516520738601685, 0.2993239760398865, 1.114115595817566, -0.12655887007713318, -0.5942062139511108, 0.6223469376564026, -0.21426823735237122, 0.2625911235809326, 0.008915740996599197, 0.3879636526107788, -0.41628116369247437, 0.1483655571937561, 0.13406331837177277, 0.38380277156829834, -0.25619882345199585, -0.35021471977233887, 0.23904791474342346, 0.6058288812637329, -0.46709027886390686, -0.2976222038269043, 1.0793871879577637, 0.27615243196487427, -0.4195462167263031, 0.4688705801963806, -0.37855541706085205, -0.8278439044952393, 0.7999569773674011, 0.8828264474868774, 1.0159193277359009, -0.1635061502456665, 0.09934912621974945, -0.038005996495485306, 0.7056190371513367, 0.034492820501327515, 0.1501147300004959, 0.012266227044165134, -0.5183820128440857, -0.1667613387107849, -0.4393181800842285, -0.3466465175151825, 0.21100971102714539, -0.47716352343559265, 0.26396888494491577, -0.9777281284332275, -0.15939660370349884, -0.3590826690196991, -0.09926874935626984, -0.17957550287246704, -0.02861112914979458, 0.1166606992483139, 1.093127965927124, -0.6150891184806824, 0.6261922121047974, 0.5897433757781982, -0.15886493027210236, -0.48806890845298767, -0.0011680005118250847, 0.4267084002494812, -0.703843891620636, 0.32901835441589355, 0.37707018852233887, -0.20035210251808167, -0.2590075433254242, -0.5806448459625244, -0.46527859568595886, 0.6655330657958984, 0.6565980911254883, -0.6077192425727844, 0.2758915424346924, -0.2812997102737427, 0.15063129365444183, 0.00525838416069746, -0.08083238452672958, 0.6800955533981323, 0.47939425706863403, -0.17896857857704163, -0.46482521295547485, 0.3673413097858429, -0.5364857912063599, -0.14677777886390686, 0.41185417771339417, -0.7200044393539429, 0.5725733041763306, -0.31741127371788025, -0.18957708775997162, 0.3201902210712433, 0.4234076738357544, 0.5476147532463074, 0.2176271378993988, 0.6485424637794495, 0.7190213203430176, 0.7362207174301147, -0.3458343744277954, 1.022018551826477, -0.5850224494934082, -0.16813085973262787, 0.9147855639457703, -0.15870870649814606, 0.22222791612148285, 0.3943305015563965, 0.05609393119812012, 0.013982866890728474, 0.6831119060516357, -0.3375024199485779, 0.8739856481552124, 0.45000118017196655, -0.453080952167511, -0.27906662225723267, -0.21401678025722504, -0.36602896451950073, 0.10806384682655334, 0.21891237795352936, -0.12020666897296906, -0.019122764468193054, 0.40731436014175415, 0.5154061913490295, 0.41953250765800476, -0.4668949842453003, 0.7288916707038879, -0.01307422760874033, -0.7830808758735657, 0.7156932353973389, 0.13832946121692657, 0.8749803304672241, -0.9084340333938599, 0.4259546995162964, -0.21103347837924957, 0.15499399602413177, 0.15881182253360748, -0.4379130005836487, 0.026378946378827095, 0.329087495803833, -0.2222004532814026, -0.09493034332990646, 0.7554126381874084, -0.08652395009994507, -0.08966400474309921, 0.3122023344039917, -0.022503232583403587, -0.4038207530975342, 0.05754992738366127, -0.5379138588905334, 0.15884897112846375, -0.06712575256824493, -0.29118216037750244, 0.38323065638542175, 0.3008548617362976, 0.11792974919080734, 0.8030114769935608, 0.6408976912498474, 0.42890477180480957, 0.14488588273525238, -0.005266319960355759, 1.2313997745513916, -0.6891418695449829, -0.909530520439148, -1.2769432067871094, 0.21914906799793243, -0.05049607530236244, -0.5414074659347534, 0.7237884402275085, 0.32425814867019653, 0.47460660338401794, 0.22048838436603546, 0.9263428449630737, -0.0055209435522556305, 0.14074619114398956, -0.8451070189476013, 0.7280378341674805, -0.09789051860570908, 0.6946257948875427, -0.11682195961475372, -0.40505287051200867, -0.26575320959091187, 0.18313686549663544, -0.24419960379600525, -0.154596209526062, 0.4366130530834198, 0.8589219450950623, 0.09410463273525238, 0.08662016689777374, 0.11048867553472519, 0.1533074527978897, 0.6846091151237488, 0.7461956143379211, 1.0710231065750122, 0.06255917996168137, 0.5141055583953857, -0.20094145834445953, -0.4059958755970001, 0.05752154812216759, -0.8819831609725952, -1.1340335607528687, 0.11099769920110703, -0.05353909730911255, -0.6521438956260681, 0.5192280411720276, 0.9402874112129211, 0.7329760193824768, -0.8708248138427734, 0.24788516759872437, -0.24896524846553802, 0.22978807985782623, -0.1657860428094864, -0.2232869565486908, 0.25429683923721313, -0.6487955451011658, -0.2662585973739624, 1.0880632400512695, 0.20124076306819916, 0.08069252967834473, -0.19274844229221344, 0.031109895557165146, 0.16341519355773926, 0.08916911482810974, 0.08616079390048981, 0.5106868743896484, -0.6677187085151672, -0.21870708465576172, -0.027666697278618813, -0.1469806432723999, -0.09348616749048233, 0.930341899394989, -0.7251902222633362, 0.5635469555854797, 0.1874663233757019, 0.9145879745483398, -0.12440997362136841, 0.334626168012619, 0.7701138854026794, -0.8797916769981384, 0.26264822483062744, 0.15041020512580872, 0.4162188172340393, 0.39529043436050415, -0.7249549031257629, 0.15026424825191498, 0.23958973586559296, -0.6299548745155334, -0.8454505205154419, 0.4544680416584015, -0.8181806802749634, -0.5871507525444031, 0.9760997295379639, -0.4695242941379547, -0.3120277225971222, -0.16939857602119446, -0.38576605916023254, 0.08161858469247818, -0.8047595024108887, 0.932454526424408, 0.5160847902297974, 0.18148450553417206, 0.023351293057203293, -0.4359945058822632, 0.639315664768219, 0.28037044405937195, -0.5346207618713379, 0.2993146479129791, 0.34044477343559265, 0.14787396788597107, -0.09338265657424927, 0.06721864640712738, 0.013684365898370743, 0.42078784108161926, -0.17374026775360107, -0.4277932941913605, -0.7176381349563599, -0.5581987500190735, -0.7521740794181824, 0.4477839171886444, 0.12623384594917297, -0.3043271005153656 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06221v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06221v2	ResumeFlow: An LLM-facilitated Pipeline for Personalized Resume Generation and Refinement	2024-02-09T07:13:44	2024-05-08T03:09:10	Saurabh Bhausaheb Zinjad, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Amey Bhilegaonkar, Huan Liu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.IR	Crafting the ideal, job-specific resume is a challenging task for many job applicants, especially for early-career applicants. While it is highly recommended that applicants tailor their resume to the specific role they are applying for, manually tailoring resumes to job descriptions and role-specific requirements is often (1) extremely time-consuming, and (2) prone to human errors. Furthermore, performing such a tailoring step at scale while applying to several roles may result in a lack of quality of the edited resumes. To tackle this problem, in this demo paper, we propose ResumeFlow: a Large Language Model (LLM) aided tool that enables an end user to simply provide their detailed resume and the desired job posting, and obtain a personalized resume specifically tailored to that specific job posting in the matter of a few seconds. Our proposed pipeline leverages the language understanding and information extraction capabilities of state-of-the-art LLMs such as OpenAI's GPT-4 and Google's Gemini, in order to (1) extract details from a job description, (2) extract role-specific details from the user-provided resume, and then (3) use these to refine and generate a role-specific resume for the user. Our easy-to-use tool leverages the user-chosen LLM in a completely off-the-shelf manner, thus requiring no fine-tuning. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our tool via a video demo and propose novel task-specific evaluation metrics to control for alignment and hallucination. Our tool is available at https://job-aligned-resume.streamlit.app.	[ -0.11928927153348923, -0.5043221116065979, 0.5525950789451599, 0.19824442267417908, -0.06540729850530624, -0.10416750609874725, -0.29472804069519043, -0.2051285058259964, 0.4339439868927002, 0.6892316341400146, -0.955159068107605, -0.7329148054122925, -0.3267556428909302, -0.01681491546332836, -0.4825054109096527, 1.1020103693008423, 0.04874262586236, -0.37890949845314026, -0.32417353987693787, 0.16476179659366608, -0.8088799118995667, 0.041949886828660965, -0.586709201335907, -0.2787021994590759, 0.7193236351013184, 0.5832981467247009, 0.2919536232948303, 0.5948426723480225, 0.3863116502761841, 0.18375122547149658, 0.1987912654876709, 0.12678152322769165, -0.45624852180480957, 0.6878352761268616, -0.26384371519088745, -0.31569233536720276, -0.5460414886474609, -0.06878955662250519, 0.3536217212677002, 0.48821544647216797, -0.34279173612594604, 0.7857508063316345, 0.13888204097747803, 0.4373670518398285, -0.5852102637290955, 0.16158217191696167, -0.8396391272544861, -0.090854212641716, -0.5169402360916138, -0.21862973272800446, 0.021614516153931618, 0.01828017085790634, -0.09211138635873795, -0.6500301361083984, 0.42355620861053467, -0.0986386239528656, 0.5913821458816528, 0.201163649559021, -0.08549042046070099, -0.18898287415504456, -0.5688887238502502, 0.5703763365745544, -0.6125910878181458, 0.3907957673072815, 0.029332492500543594, 0.7294695377349854, -0.05420034006237984, -0.928472638130188, -0.518221378326416, 0.13580316305160522, 0.20062461495399475, 0.23883667588233948, 0.36712008714675903, 0.1273949146270752, 0.13373906910419464, 0.4523773193359375, -0.7296199202537537, 0.3944399654865265, -0.4742392599582672, -0.17329828441143036, 0.4510853886604309, 0.3668455481529236, 0.2308194935321808, 0.14104144275188446, -0.05299316346645355, -0.047196611762046814, -0.6022440791130066, 0.2790625989437103, 0.5671266913414001, 0.3923831880092621, 0.05720650777220726, 0.7068968415260315, -0.39238297939300537, 0.9493538737297058, -0.030917499214410782, -0.18209418654441833, -0.09478605538606644, -0.1903146505355835, -0.3458990454673767, 0.002040279097855091, 0.5647684335708618, 0.32811152935028076, -0.14002393186092377, -0.2973789572715759, -0.6055123209953308, -0.05182378739118576, 0.5250605940818787, -0.8599900603294373, 0.029532400891184807, 0.5352538824081421, -0.34013044834136963, -0.36678481101989746, 0.25623196363449097, -0.47216540575027466, -0.5996869802474976, -0.252874493598938, 0.08181314915418625, 0.16898185014724731, 0.31144195795059204, 0.012599200010299683, -0.014521470293402672, 0.11753080040216446, 0.46603527665138245, -0.7454729676246643, 0.030317066237330437, 1.0425657033920288, 0.8077115416526794, -0.5029754042625427, -0.021317780017852783, -0.9885411858558655, 0.1261240392923355, 0.040201134979724884, 0.7175002098083496, -0.6316380500793457, -0.09239453077316284, 0.22819797694683075, 0.2503448724746704, 0.22214971482753754, -0.5313943028450012, 0.6476108431816101, -0.6681755185127258, 0.12248625606298447, 0.09069978445768356, -0.3000049293041229, -0.17782512307167053, 0.2739454507827759, -0.6476735472679138, 0.5711606740951538, 0.29565662145614624, -0.454328715801239, 0.3447088897228241, -0.5945164561271667, -0.16663648188114166, 0.2767750918865204, -0.47916126251220703, -0.178309366106987, -0.035261817276477814, 0.1276390701532364, 0.7335494756698608, -0.5305488705635071, 0.09380905330181122, -0.07939041405916214, -0.6650689840316772, -0.2507003843784332, 0.08453001827001572, 0.5204845070838928, 0.2803187072277069, 0.09890871495008469, 0.2926381528377533, -0.5003272891044617, 0.0034502858761698008, -0.1160593330860138, -0.6198363900184631, 0.49411264061927795, -0.2663193941116333, 0.2599499821662903, 0.4611596167087555, 0.5771274566650391, -0.5594371557235718, 0.4189985990524292, -0.40891629457473755, 0.24034759402275085, 0.7889558672904968, -0.13708779215812683, 0.34451305866241455, -0.4879355728626251, 1.0107529163360596, -0.04027692973613739, -0.10428188741207123, -0.5047996044158936, -0.3882830739021301, -0.30118250846862793, -0.39401566982269287, 0.1251545548439026, 0.9069244861602783, -0.19242936372756958, 0.5135661959648132, -0.3192451000213623, -0.610145628452301, -0.8281856179237366, 0.8250362277030945, 0.16741976141929626, 0.7006582021713257, 0.2166808843612671, -0.7382739782333374, -0.8169800639152527, -0.887417733669281, -0.6603869199752808, 0.18267998099327087, -0.3660474717617035, 0.3113873600959778, -0.11124684661626816, -0.6145023703575134, 0.9932610988616943, -0.5770626068115234, -0.7512201070785522, -0.16435764729976654, -0.29754146933555603, 0.7919477224349976, 0.2645812928676605, 0.01348252221941948, -0.51331627368927, -0.39219462871551514, 0.1582084447145462, -0.5958515405654907, -0.40033870935440063, -0.47694456577301025, -0.29271775484085083, -0.26918891072273254, 0.2555427849292755, -0.6889767646789551, 0.16925981640815735, 0.6194828152656555, -0.36719265580177307, 0.5012543201446533, -0.21461604535579681, -0.24538664519786835, -0.984591543674469, 0.45517054200172424, 0.33341678977012634, -0.40263262391090393, -0.31274670362472534, 0.05021507292985916, -0.02506130002439022, -0.27931779623031616, -0.3728787302970886, 0.7791662216186523, -0.30981406569480896, 0.017545020207762718, -0.24568456411361694, 0.2560001313686371, 0.03082994371652603, 0.13440777361392975, -0.09652998298406601, 0.5121140480041504, 0.44449809193611145, -0.35502365231513977, 0.38582950830459595, 0.298743337392807, -0.4555380344390869, 0.4497748017311096, -0.5358203649520874, 0.282976359128952, -0.291276216506958, 0.5871286988258362, -1.067245364189148, -0.30131763219833374, 0.0025659571401774883, 0.09827002882957458, 0.07690683007240295, -0.2974672317504883, -0.48023176193237305, -0.3899992108345032, -0.21413905918598175, 0.08130137622356415, 0.7175440192222595, -0.3785303831100464, 0.3983963429927826, 0.3351757526397705, -0.3309491276741028, -0.6328169703483582, -0.8011782169342041, 0.09416612237691879, -0.1782868355512619, -0.8116787075996399, 1.0700969696044922, -0.06222047656774521, -0.041211675852537155, -0.6018219590187073, -0.30409446358680725, -0.3834318220615387, 0.04456084594130516, 0.5311557650566101, 0.4691768288612366, 0.07138305902481079, -0.25424128770828247, 0.20154592394828796, 0.07676203548908234, -0.21697084605693817, -0.3193390965461731, 0.43269801139831543, 0.1584482043981552, -0.3812720775604248, -0.7243655920028687, 0.0960608497262001, 0.7041339874267578, -0.10372317582368851, 0.49183765053749084, 0.9895387887954712, -0.2021610587835312, -0.1351255625486374, -0.851024329662323, -0.2140512317419052, -0.45761188864707947, 0.022610358893871307, -0.20849397778511047, -0.96486896276474, 0.520042359828949, -0.16729962825775146, 0.5752997398376465, 0.22511141002178192, 0.7347655296325684, 0.06072201207280159, 0.671319305896759, 0.5386351943016052, -0.07839032262563705, 0.5052940845489502, -0.22941580414772034, 0.2256319522857666, -0.9348293542861938, -0.3733174204826355, -0.12802347540855408, -0.7372899651527405, -0.31275779008865356, -0.33953365683555603, 0.1677575558423996, -0.0704769566655159, -0.12306685000658035, 0.369990736246109, -0.6853528022766113, 0.328514963388443, 0.38065898418426514, -0.06168399378657341, 0.1411598026752472, -0.15747278928756714, -0.01733553037047386, -0.007382950279861689, -0.46427810192108154, -0.8285192251205444, 0.9323322176933289, 0.21392640471458435, 0.6721981763839722, -0.09396488964557648, 0.8728700280189514, 0.30169880390167236, 0.3145228922367096, -0.6238670349121094, 0.43778544664382935, -0.3132089674472809, -0.32215073704719543, -0.2575324475765228, 0.04696550965309143, -0.8789492845535278, 0.18653200566768646, -0.27869072556495667, -0.8172038197517395, -0.14813993871212006, 0.3271510601043701, -0.6253631711006165, 0.08409351110458374, -0.49355778098106384, 1.0052521228790283, -0.003264904022216797, -0.46059298515319824, 0.00859746802598238, -0.5003920793533325, 0.32488709688186646, -0.5064918398857117, 0.3426692485809326, -0.16885565221309662, -0.17760637402534485, 0.43192222714424133, -0.5478929877281189, 0.6952083706855774, -0.3462759852409363, -0.1330067664384842, 0.27603423595428467, 0.20718060433864594, 0.6684104204177856, 0.09904387593269348, -0.4999864995479584, -0.04207085072994232, 0.041188016533851624, -0.024465983733534813, -0.6440202593803406, 1.058753490447998, -0.3468555808067322, -0.7401580214500427, 0.24364036321640015, -0.6092880368232727, 0.08846532553434372, 0.3349711000919342, 0.1567937731742859, -0.0870295837521553, -0.22496290504932404, 0.16011762619018555, 0.16853304207324982, -0.349319726228714, 0.06831004470586777, 0.2047964334487915, -0.28662586212158203, 0.12411293387413025, 0.6623557806015015, 0.08059872686862946, -0.44419214129447937, 0.3339468836784363, -0.05272907018661499, -0.246855229139328, -0.2957829535007477, -0.2909201681613922, 0.1822710931301117, -0.48335450887680054, -0.07123325020074844, -0.49827566742897034, 0.06276500970125198, -0.6669256091117859, -0.38122478127479553, -0.18023858964443207, -0.4824196994304657, -0.2050343155860901, 0.31341418623924255, -0.02211660146713257, 0.41024279594421387, 0.3484170138835907, 0.34016484022140503, -0.7565534114837646, 0.3495219051837921, 0.3489333689212799, 0.16737166047096252, -0.13356119394302368, -0.6440584063529968, -0.1554120033979416, -0.1241249367594719, -0.5399020314216614, -0.48493918776512146, 0.4540654420852661, 0.4213383197784424, 0.5449111461639404, 0.5418593883514404, -0.28480711579322815, 0.608177661895752, -0.5324548482894897, 0.9584102034568787, 0.06963300704956055, -0.5708506107330322, 0.7113720178604126, -0.3216136693954468, 0.4645830988883972, 0.6387482285499573, 0.21035796403884888, -0.8096014261245728, -0.2128644734621048, -0.31528061628341675, -1.0034258365631104, 0.40198996663093567, 0.025612493976950645, 0.14208900928497314, -0.03784716874361038, 0.6628562211990356, 0.5034987330436707, 0.16569259762763977, -0.23051898181438446, 0.1525586098432541, 0.059917159378528595, -0.39077380299568176, -0.10782822966575623, -0.06931517273187637, -0.08823609352111816, -0.19221231341362, 0.40959903597831726, -0.01946725696325302, 0.10820921510457993, -0.02277505211532116, -0.2094050794839859, 0.16549786925315857, 0.17286981642246246, 0.5615465044975281, 0.6789359450340271, -0.1985854208469391, -0.21424436569213867, 0.1154220849275589, -0.32002875208854675, -0.03020174242556095, -0.09511566907167435, 0.1936068832874298, 0.1036796122789383, -0.020438000559806824, 0.4020942449569702, -0.0447273850440979, -1.0216596126556396, 0.8304764032363892, -0.029978005215525627, -0.014389836229383945, -0.5767363905906677, 0.3494878113269806, 0.11593562364578247, 0.4689957797527313, 0.24794623255729675, -0.05441557988524437, -0.008683199062943459, -0.3323170244693756, 0.18859389424324036, 0.4869694709777832, -0.2303546667098999, -0.22057387232780457, 0.9629393219947815, 0.06507695466279984, -0.6540566682815552, 0.840908944606781, 0.05862530693411827, 0.14714281260967255, 0.31026437878608704, 0.49984869360923767, 1.0470210313796997, -0.03725603595376015, -0.05077582970261574, 0.27877968549728394, -0.1970842480659485, -0.23374108970165253, 0.1752556562423706, -0.14716032147407532, -0.46048206090927124, -0.5729522109031677, -0.7227658033370972, -0.20145092904567719, 0.14118345081806183, -0.5641412734985352, 0.6172888875007629, -0.7271835803985596, -0.05440622940659523, -0.13513065874576569, -0.3476668894290924, -1.240940809249878, 0.289180725812912, 0.1570596992969513, 0.8720662593841553, -0.5728015899658203, 0.6790334582328796, 0.8700952529907227, -0.3214609920978546, -0.349166601896286, -0.15325048565864563, 0.12057263404130936, -0.8314471244812012, 0.9662904143333435, 0.4490589499473572, -0.037212979048490524, -0.059907592833042145, -0.057754892855882645, -0.4064095616340637, 1.6561601161956787, 0.534971296787262, -0.7377526760101318, -0.515666663646698, -0.09073960036039352, 0.30284276604652405, -0.7653165459632874, 0.34472793340682983, 0.30238428711891174, 0.3230415880680084, -0.04104625806212425, -0.930353581905365, 0.20904867351055145, -0.24910441040992737, 0.2807706296443939, -0.35471346974372864, -0.46692752838134766, 0.6814589500427246, -0.13233770430088043, -0.05744485557079315, 0.006100627593696117, 0.4627905488014221, 0.36768612265586853, 0.004350072704255581, 0.6425893306732178, 0.48418357968330383, 0.9410215020179749, 0.2794410288333893, 0.9336089491844177, -0.8436193466186523, -0.054344113916158676, 1.1443943977355957, -0.24309487640857697, 0.6951843500137329, 0.48464709520339966, 0.1800621598958969, 0.9543585777282715, 0.5872488617897034, -0.028633736073970795, 0.33106306195259094, 0.5003824234008789, -0.24833747744560242, -0.41696932911872864, 0.001395110390149057, -0.00366118922829628, 0.60433429479599, 0.1892884075641632, -0.6725150942802429, -0.2858000695705414, -0.09371024370193481, -0.2949919104576111, -0.10596344619989395, -0.24448393285274506, 0.4274159073829651, 0.07693436741828918, -0.8074021339416504, 0.3688967525959015, 0.26650360226631165, 0.8894672989845276, -0.41766297817230225, -0.19427914917469025, -0.09392573684453964, 0.031113233417272568, -0.6953505873680115, -0.7695557475090027, 0.3441372215747833, 0.15078599750995636, -0.1567126214504242, -0.6357601881027222, 0.8605086207389832, -0.33086150884628296, -0.0265983734279871, -0.160592183470726, 0.4580124318599701, 0.40900158882141113, -0.3594942092895508, -0.6112108826637268, 0.1974601298570633, -0.11063306778669357, -0.26425811648368835, 0.34984293580055237, 0.15827587246894836, 0.13170477747917175, 0.8031207323074341, 0.686336874961853, 0.3404974639415741, -0.12019037455320358, 0.17166882753372192, 0.5243677496910095, -0.4665881097316742, -0.6268925666809082, -0.7162837386131287, 0.7798995971679688, -0.11099575459957123, -0.2717551290988922, 0.3891995847225189, 0.7953221797943115, 0.7423537373542786, -0.31354865431785583, 0.8417507410049438, 0.10317445546388626, 0.45826828479766846, -0.23180131614208221, 0.6624704599380493, -0.5399184823036194, 0.5328197479248047, -0.13654424250125885, -1.2241318225860596, -0.24521122872829437, 0.6432082653045654, -0.1930633783340454, 0.013896877877414227, 0.27787351608276367, 1.0019327402114868, -0.13805429637432098, -0.5107527375221252, 0.14806875586509705, -0.24069012701511383, 0.3784874975681305, 0.5108637809753418, 0.22061818838119507, -0.1810125857591629, 0.4308196008205414, -0.0010324636241421103, -0.15044139325618744, -0.48209622502326965, -0.954994797706604, -0.5212767124176025, -0.5327614545822144, -0.4981285333633423, -0.4186841547489166, -0.10064566880464554, 0.8924328088760376, 0.8383081555366516, -0.410612553358078, -0.4859778583049774, -0.15421538054943085, -0.06644215434789658, -0.2749543786048889, -0.21407508850097656, -0.11477766185998917, -0.3997456431388855, -0.6288228631019592, 0.6254481077194214, 0.23227661848068237, -0.28032413125038147, -0.45915377140045166, 0.024029219523072243, 0.29101112484931946, -0.13301007449626923, 0.4799462556838989, 0.44607090950012207, -0.8738600611686707, -0.009569925256073475, -0.2931394577026367, -0.11094815284013748, 0.030144397169351578, 0.8578107357025146, -0.7658222317695618, 0.6838942766189575, 0.5985379219055176, 0.9412213563919067, 0.48749613761901855, 0.06452025473117828, 0.6573694348335266, -0.8861207365989685, -0.0035223800223320723, 0.11081606894731522, 0.21983611583709717, 0.35123658180236816, -0.7293905019760132, 0.42917272448539734, 0.023221444338560104, -0.5482970476150513, -0.6886497139930725, 0.16065356135368347, -1.166306972503662, -0.01144938264042139, 0.9976926445960999, -0.09640225768089294, 0.01631293259561062, 0.1360277682542801, -0.22001774609088898, 0.4024861454963684, -0.3633236289024353, 0.9480631947517395, 0.5029744505882263, -0.13815943896770477, 0.04695288464426994, -0.8022022843360901, 0.25636038184165955, 0.23319604992866516, -0.46502307057380676, -0.07055399566888809, 0.26617199182510376, 0.46440622210502625, -0.13904604315757751, 0.6216469407081604, 0.00902353972196579, 0.2592291235923767, -0.5114743709564209, 0.06976941227912903, -0.2641320526599884, -0.14667214453220367, -0.14007729291915894, 0.23114919662475586, 0.1985432654619217, -0.055350545793771744 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06220v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06220v1	A Unified Causal View of Instruction Tuning	2024-02-09T07:12:56	2024-02-09T07:12:56	Lu Chen, Wei Huang, Ruqing Zhang, Wei Chen, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng	cs.CL	cs.CL	Instruction tuning on a mixture of tasks has improved zero-shot capabilities in natural language processing (NLP). Nevertheless, existing methods often learn features that exhibit correlations between instruction-formatted samples and target labels, rather than causal relationships. Termed as ``spurious correlation'' in statistics, such a correlation may change drastically in a new task, making the effect from the learned features to be misleading. To this end, we develop a meta Structural Causal Model (meta-SCM) to integrate different NLP tasks under a single causal structure of the data. Specifically, the meta-SCM introduces multiple latent factors that represent properties of source context, only some of which causally influence the target labels for a specific task. The key idea is to learn task-required causal factors and only use those to make predictions for a given task. Theoretically, we prove the causal factor can be identified without mixing information from others. Guided by the identifiability, we propose a Structural Instruction Tuning (SIT) method to learn the task-required causal representations that can mimic the causal factors for each task. The utility of our approach is verified by improvements of zero-shot ability on a range of unseen datasets and tasks.	[ 0.019963659346103668, -1.1077910661697388, 0.45457884669303894, 0.29819804430007935, -0.20721536874771118, -0.19009177386760712, -0.07108768075704575, -0.2558162212371826, 0.3064606189727783, 0.684913694858551, -0.5193318724632263, -0.4775983989238739, -0.6397318840026855, -0.07907718420028687, -0.2888161242008209, 1.2095305919647217, 0.1962379366159439, -0.009446411393582821, -0.13197126984596252, -0.10236095637083054, -0.8101793527603149, -0.22516383230686188, -0.6658459901809692, -0.315032035112381, 0.598200798034668, 0.553184449672699, 0.3751460313796997, 1.0163853168487549, 0.44967350363731384, 0.2188071459531784, 0.14655372500419617, 0.2549021542072296, -0.33118072152137756, 0.0805802047252655, -0.44034168124198914, -0.5499380826950073, -0.6043160557746887, 0.08316817879676819, 0.6459962129592896, 0.92336106300354, -0.0545995719730854, 0.37986326217651367, 0.41196179389953613, 0.5242531299591064, -0.8346306085586548, 0.22964276373386383, -0.6836106777191162, -0.11254344880580902, -0.07950777560472488, -0.792695939540863, -0.7383835315704346, -0.12032114714384079, -0.16323362290859222, -0.5930994749069214, 0.602264940738678, 0.11605527251958847, 0.7776318788528442, 0.801597535610199, -0.7492341995239258, -0.05476400628685951, -0.9299865365028381, 0.69739830493927, -0.5863088369369507, 0.049880385398864746, 0.5812127590179443, -0.07029374688863754, -0.36518099904060364, -0.17905868589878082, -0.11437425762414932, -0.028373952955007553, -0.3349531292915344, 0.13831564784049988, 0.16957934200763702, 0.20830494165420532, 0.27275535464286804, -0.010533871129155159, -0.520603358745575, 0.1478859782218933, -0.45761796832084656, -0.06214749440550804, 0.5316543579101562, 0.23214659094810486, 0.5584534406661987, -0.2049816995859146, -0.380960613489151, -0.10391119867563248, -0.811943531036377, 0.10028126090765, 0.299854576587677, 0.7055306434631348, -0.09724133461713791, 0.5371997952461243, 0.019328735768795013, 0.9945780038833618, 0.3033945560455322, -0.18944652378559113, -0.08155902475118637, -0.3954666554927826, -0.42096057534217834, 0.34307557344436646, 0.5763911604881287, 0.025003207847476006, -0.12402099370956421, -0.37046748399734497, 0.3252822458744049, 0.18785256147384644, 0.6334066987037659, -0.3382870852947235, -0.0778946503996849, -0.019926268607378006, 0.03689586743712425, -0.20857475697994232, 0.13290825486183167, -0.5194246172904968, -0.013541977852582932, -0.5843397974967957, 0.5016576647758484, -0.49396780133247375, 0.07130396366119385, -0.04278174042701721, -0.07140147686004639, 0.2715531587600708, -0.21085919439792633, -0.9665908217430115, 0.16799603402614594, 0.6259976029396057, 0.48366469144821167, -0.03707079961895943, -0.41237872838974, -0.8247050046920776, 0.5917255878448486, -0.5078608989715576, 0.9103736281394958, -0.7572508454322815, -0.24617962539196014, -0.021457646042108536, 0.11843828856945038, -0.7208340167999268, -0.22536516189575195, 0.6165997385978699, -0.44514796137809753, 0.29390159249305725, -0.3670635521411896, -0.5738266706466675, -0.27304551005363464, -0.03368831053376198, -0.6036979556083679, 1.1268808841705322, -0.009392296895384789, -0.7995327711105347, 0.7136446833610535, -0.3854783773422241, -0.9415348768234253, 0.01897960901260376, -0.1627616137266159, -0.34206733107566833, 0.2560766637325287, 0.09919801354408264, 0.4098457992076874, -0.11493336409330368, 0.712927520275116, -0.32953181862831116, -0.605137050151825, -0.2332959771156311, -0.43134376406669617, 0.698451817035675, -0.26867207884788513, -0.6573274731636047, 0.14170414209365845, -1.0566378831863403, -0.13956454396247864, -0.30186727643013, -0.4343544840812683, -0.627612292766571, 0.34276774525642395, -0.506629228591919, 0.17868244647979736, -0.09683424979448318, -0.2441653162240982, 0.12275101244449615, -0.34070897102355957, -0.0037948123645037413, 0.6848140358924866, 0.30568215250968933, 0.6437820792198181, -0.25698748230934143, 0.38992735743522644, 0.11191689968109131, 0.0028496619779616594, -0.30172327160835266, -0.38141462206840515, -0.9468266367912292, -0.22036461532115936, 0.04371261969208717, 0.6275726556777954, -0.7698772549629211, 0.5712751746177673, -0.0021124500781297684, -0.14414305984973907, -0.3860160708427429, 0.22692841291427612, 0.7062699794769287, 0.92445307970047, 0.6609745621681213, 0.03896219655871391, -0.5266016721725464, -0.6970384120941162, -0.6176930069923401, 0.08019156754016876, -0.07921221852302551, 0.3060581088066101, 0.24975386261940002, 0.0869799554347992, 0.6403018832206726, -0.6076582670211792, -0.41246119141578674, 0.15804149210453033, 0.6644912362098694, 0.16709843277931213, 0.5554888844490051, 0.3572182059288025, -0.3776808977127075, -0.5784756541252136, -0.22053463757038116, -0.6966543793678284, -0.1913260519504547, -0.455766886472702, -0.1742420643568039, 0.17345818877220154, 0.8866750001907349, -0.2093244194984436, 0.43063870072364807, 0.2365073263645172, -0.4556278586387634, 0.4448712468147278, -0.4559987783432007, 0.09749840199947357, -0.9465670585632324, 0.08980716019868851, 0.1775962859392166, 0.26694872975349426, -0.4292115569114685, 0.043051499873399734, 0.21219472587108612, 0.004069543909281492, -0.19257347285747528, 0.32518234848976135, -0.47452083230018616, 0.22666744887828827, -0.335106760263443, 0.0982910767197609, 0.029096074402332306, 0.8689156770706177, -0.23252539336681366, 0.6367566585540771, 0.6757058501243591, -0.9760425090789795, -0.14574536681175232, 0.08505518734455109, -0.09930098801851273, 0.7613961696624756, -0.769910991191864, -0.12513014674186707, -0.4012455344200134, 0.02464834414422512, -0.8985453844070435, -0.26961779594421387, 0.2371557205915451, -0.14606238901615143, 0.7293261885643005, 0.01894162967801094, -0.2923620939254761, -0.006965552922338247, -0.025071728974580765, 0.08422583341598511, 0.01967780850827694, -0.33037057518959045, 0.6698434352874756, 0.054527804255485535, 0.1819906234741211, -0.7693479657173157, -0.5491199493408203, -0.2882832884788513, -0.10773782432079315, -0.33701714873313904, 0.5854007005691528, 0.07084040343761444, 0.2395857870578766, 0.31181856989860535, -0.47306516766548157, -0.1800505369901657, 0.17461025714874268, 0.493171751499176, 0.4265843629837036, -0.3870570957660675, 0.3458399474620819, 0.4256104528903961, -0.2550264894962311, 0.09120436012744904, -0.1930122673511505, 0.0263583455234766, 0.2474575787782669, -0.3038509488105774, -0.2745097875595093, 0.28150132298469543, 0.3996763229370117, -0.17011518776416779, 0.9081708788871765, 0.6848863363265991, 0.07070907205343246, -0.400767058134079, -0.38673606514930725, -0.27249079942703247, -0.4160776138305664, 0.29993921518325806, 0.0305184256285429, -0.7735611200332642, 0.08426941186189651, -0.08984856307506561, 0.1403007060289383, 0.48033422231674194, 0.09632547199726105, -0.20222751796245575, 0.9228944778442383, 0.9039484262466431, -0.0756540596485138, 0.5459600687026978, 0.05376746505498886, 0.32722169160842896, -0.9779556393623352, -0.3482634127140045, -0.7080029845237732, -0.37958627939224243, -0.47249677777290344, -0.38619592785835266, 0.4853287935256958, 0.14956986904144287, -0.5049717426300049, 0.631834864616394, -0.45159196853637695, 0.5649224519729614, 0.772016704082489, 0.3394966721534729, 0.1455845683813095, -0.026358602568507195, -0.37886518239974976, 0.16506145894527435, -0.7984282970428467, -0.19914934039115906, 1.0876179933547974, -0.33811596035957336, 0.5545873641967773, -0.1558280736207962, 0.4851973354816437, 0.12794403731822968, 0.03293906897306442, -0.33455896377563477, 0.39199742674827576, -0.32843217253685, -0.8483218550682068, -0.3991604745388031, -0.42853817343711853, -0.9590394496917725, 0.16422148048877716, -0.43398424983024597, -0.7621491551399231, 0.10197701305150986, 0.3434080183506012, -0.4493749439716339, 0.1600213348865509, -0.846880316734314, 0.8914382457733154, -0.14205574989318848, -0.5841811299324036, -0.26156607270240784, -0.7187594175338745, 0.5526117086410522, 0.13641661405563354, 0.14489386975765228, -0.10857470333576202, 0.22780169546604156, 0.5642166137695312, -0.04022382199764252, 1.2498843669891357, 0.05167853459715843, 0.11509883403778076, 0.14558976888656616, 0.06337522715330124, 0.3427754044532776, -0.1766200065612793, 0.02760610543191433, -0.024357527494430542, -0.08693086355924606, -0.5234830379486084, -0.7452000975608826, 0.6346837878227234, -0.7332179546356201, -0.6714456677436829, -0.3206010162830353, -0.563720166683197, -0.4307681620121002, 0.19523444771766663, 0.2135857343673706, 0.4946025609970093, -0.2141432911157608, 0.30676954984664917, 0.6860183477401733, -0.09031525254249573, 0.5136308670043945, 0.740444004535675, 0.4370267689228058, -0.04881271719932556, 0.9144872426986694, 0.1259596347808838, 0.1464640498161316, 0.7952002286911011, 0.2125300019979477, 0.10716205090284348, 0.00877848919481039, -0.17946957051753998, 0.18327832221984863, -0.34318724274635315, -0.27816715836524963, -0.35995832085609436, -0.12923787534236908, -0.3337855041027069, -0.20757165551185608, -0.20815831422805786, -0.20507799088954926, -0.615608811378479, -0.19382262229919434, 0.009927877224981785, 0.3766489326953888, -0.049535855650901794, 0.491299569606781, -0.7130562663078308, 0.40608763694763184, 0.3874624967575073, 0.3859904408454895, 0.03018198534846306, -0.6472895741462708, -0.3888062536716461, -0.03192664682865143, -0.48034393787384033, -0.9043781757354736, 0.09857573360204697, 0.464606910943985, 0.6905181407928467, 0.7136905789375305, 0.06454189121723175, 0.7736992239952087, -0.7955543398857117, 0.5039258003234863, 0.04780576378107071, -0.8893954157829285, 0.6612389087677002, -0.21230822801589966, 0.272134929895401, 0.5178238153457642, 0.7030038833618164, -0.13325904309749603, -0.4275103509426117, -0.5836777687072754, -0.7956987023353577, 0.945910632610321, -0.16217531263828278, 0.06732945889234543, -0.19960717856884003, 0.3941667675971985, -0.12053422629833221, 0.04196340963244438, -0.5369254350662231, -0.3698306977748871, -0.0527934804558754, -0.026872944086790085, -0.07794200628995895, -0.3135311007499695, -0.22309526801109314, -0.34071776270866394, 0.8075075745582581, -0.20088344812393188, -0.14099638164043427, 0.042865511029958725, -0.13162145018577576, -0.39229536056518555, 0.36326339840888977, 0.6406345963478088, 0.5667599439620972, -0.2440672218799591, 0.29777446389198303, -0.008968012407422066, -0.29134732484817505, -0.012103676795959473, -0.2283349186182022, -0.4792112112045288, -0.09907323867082596, 0.6544793248176575, 0.9824691414833069, 1.1111911535263062, -0.10069948434829712, 0.26348257064819336, 0.24604474008083344, -0.10408598184585571, 0.2716740071773529, 0.581212043762207, -0.07459590584039688, 0.04960164800286293, 0.17751067876815796, 0.325911283493042, 0.030081074684858322, -0.5928953886032104, 0.29581761360168457, 0.4778338670730591, -0.6198338866233826, -0.4442931115627289, 0.6952099800109863, 0.20314672589302063, -0.35451167821884155, 0.4817267060279846, -0.05192260071635246, -0.10402308404445648, 0.62477046251297, 0.8413003087043762, 0.8891432881355286, -0.5469915270805359, 0.7100662589073181, 0.7654694318771362, 0.6021659970283508, 0.06948576122522354, -0.005569896660745144, -0.19213376939296722, -0.5923537611961365, -0.7010599374771118, -0.5706999897956848, -0.2402498424053192, 0.003060798393562436, -1.0517189502716064, 0.27792373299598694, -0.3044286370277405, 0.0688684806227684, 0.14547580480575562, -0.22449177503585815, -0.611973762512207, 0.20730921626091003, -0.2585335671901703, 0.34198126196861267, -1.2573741674423218, 0.7241763472557068, 0.5036364793777466, -0.4792730212211609, -1.012882947921753, 0.04478265345096588, -0.022065170109272003, -0.8211408853530884, 0.5364701747894287, -0.2244456261396408, 0.015882035717368126, -0.23021654784679413, -0.5222010016441345, -0.9341332912445068, 0.8751513957977295, 0.38694924116134644, -0.3948148488998413, -0.29055872559547424, 0.08053454011678696, 0.5121493339538574, -0.1701694130897522, 0.057343706488609314, 0.5531695485115051, 0.42024025321006775, 0.1874563992023468, -0.4330975413322449, 0.2612776756286621, 0.09193248301744461, -0.22507621347904205, 0.3426933288574219, -0.3877081871032715, 0.7009181976318359, -0.25430163741111755, -0.3575018048286438, -0.6062307953834534, 0.3875229060649872, 0.08269325643777847, 0.26334840059280396, 0.15767955780029297, 0.4242989718914032, 0.7800179123878479, 0.1040809154510498, 0.8914897441864014, -0.613548994064331, 0.14172516763210297, 1.5355287790298462, -0.11933241039514542, 0.6472880840301514, 0.4990249574184418, -0.08002331107854843, 0.7383082509040833, 0.20032420754432678, -0.07435504347085953, 0.5134378671646118, -0.24493655562400818, -0.02041924186050892, -0.3026579022407532, -0.013182816095650196, -0.10906019061803818, 0.5683683753013611, 0.33528584241867065, -0.26167818903923035, -0.5053083300590515, -0.30651044845581055, 0.016687246039509773, 0.0976640060544014, -0.16729626059532166, 0.7438583970069885, 0.06759753078222275, -0.8886550068855286, 0.3783765435218811, 0.05727993696928024, 0.36867737770080566, -0.752200186252594, -0.19503697752952576, -0.1545127034187317, -0.034778058528900146, -0.28019842505455017, -0.15549838542938232, 0.6966031789779663, -0.3781592845916748, -0.5434088110923767, -0.2151969075202942, 0.5971464514732361, -0.5437970161437988, -0.5619195699691772, 0.26321548223495483, 0.35773584246635437, -0.23857064545154572, 0.03869978338479996, -0.416980504989624, -0.31288182735443115, -0.11420071870088577, -0.024939697235822678, 0.4517911672592163, 0.43041494488716125, 0.015469208359718323, 0.22177740931510925, 0.6303967237472534, 0.08775915205478668, 0.15454979240894318, -0.09170195460319519, 0.6056984663009644, -0.7019928693771362, -0.43091192841529846, -0.820250928401947, 0.4996105134487152, 0.03114047460258007, -0.4577491581439972, 0.8987919092178345, 0.2267908751964569, 0.6823136210441589, -0.04666462913155556, 0.20872309803962708, 0.22841475903987885, 0.36756083369255066, -0.5269810557365417, 0.5157924890518188, -0.5260311365127563, 0.23559626936912537, -0.38018742203712463, -0.7854892611503601, -0.3546786308288574, 0.2281322479248047, -0.2930316925048828, -0.18371500074863434, 1.1369034051895142, 0.6492152214050293, -0.1071101501584053, 0.08178092539310455, 0.3815072178840637, 0.19289709627628326, -0.05554160475730896, 0.40986326336860657, 0.10545825958251953, -0.40077903866767883, 0.44259774684906006, -0.17779985070228577, -0.29220807552337646, -0.236187145113945, -1.0303541421890259, -0.9690217971801758, -0.5794090032577515, -0.4959677457809448, -0.07294586300849915, -0.015474596060812473, 0.4473115801811218, 0.7954908013343811, -0.8519558310508728, -0.11234106868505478, -0.29980069398880005, 0.5718642473220825, -0.7094224691390991, -0.29118210077285767, 0.643467903137207, -0.9004000425338745, -0.4190782308578491, 0.6569175124168396, 0.6143569946289062, -0.41952332854270935, 0.08031100034713745, 0.3973509669303894, -0.3358047604560852, 0.3793727457523346, 0.5283541679382324, 0.503017008304596, -0.4994703531265259, -0.35609376430511475, 0.13973470032215118, -0.04336202144622803, -0.09762655943632126, 1.1028839349746704, -0.5377021431922913, 0.46039339900016785, 0.21900737285614014, 0.6291341185569763, 0.39631903171539307, -0.10703004151582718, 0.4790528416633606, -1.0921794176101685, 0.1521175056695938, -0.06960037350654602, 0.19671855866909027, 0.015597967430949211, -0.6152874827384949, 0.42524588108062744, 0.2960231304168701, -0.5137484669685364, -0.626529335975647, 0.11745291203260422, -0.8430866003036499, -0.3861766755580902, 0.8164797425270081, -0.05405279994010925, -0.35333606600761414, -0.1449030637741089, 0.22358183562755585, 0.5239846110343933, -0.010579608380794525, 1.0867104530334473, 0.501221239566803, -0.23520666360855103, 0.1482994705438614, -0.41492870450019836, 0.427295058965683, 0.5584633946418762, -0.7030113339424133, -0.1701585352420807, 0.33823534846305847, 0.26336944103240967, 0.12984764575958252, 0.3151056170463562, 0.05851539969444275, 0.15190064907073975, 0.24196791648864746, -0.049601465463638306, -0.06795284152030945, -0.8049824237823486, -0.05819066986441612, 0.23556309938430786, -0.4298136532306671, -0.2932329475879669 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06204v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06204v1	The Generative AI Paradox on Evaluation: What It Can Solve, It May Not Evaluate	2024-02-09T06:16:08	2024-02-09T06:16:08	Juhyun Oh, Eunsu Kim, Inha Cha, Alice Oh	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	This paper explores the assumption that Large Language Models (LLMs) skilled in generation tasks are equally adept as evaluators. We assess the performance of three LLMs and one open-source LM in Question-Answering (QA) and evaluation tasks using the TriviaQA (Joshi et al., 2017) dataset. Results indicate a significant disparity, with LLMs exhibiting lower performance in evaluation tasks compared to generation tasks. Intriguingly, we discover instances of unfaithful evaluation where models accurately evaluate answers in areas where they lack competence, underscoring the need to examine the faithfulness and trustworthiness of LLMs as evaluators. This study contributes to the understanding of "the Generative AI Paradox" (West et al., 2023), highlighting a need to explore the correlation between generative excellence and evaluation proficiency, and the necessity to scrutinize the faithfulness aspect in model evaluations.	[ -0.1491355150938034, -0.8154204487800598, 0.9739391207695007, 0.22835566103458405, 0.05808074399828911, 0.39275822043418884, -0.020053207874298096, -0.398735910654068, -0.3120597004890442, 0.13974280655384064, -0.5320154428482056, -0.04117124527692795, -0.6654694676399231, 0.2446856051683426, -0.5925236940383911, 0.8924142122268677, -0.11193889379501343, 0.1577480584383011, -0.8954060673713684, -0.12070908397436142, -0.6191519498825073, -0.15827909111976624, -0.6750112771987915, -0.5113452076911926, 0.12556150555610657, 0.25484874844551086, 0.9184683561325073, 0.29547953605651855, 0.4214455485343933, 0.3365601897239685, 0.0530456118285656, 0.1652187556028366, -0.7149904370307922, 0.013850970193743706, -0.060873836278915405, -0.8001200556755066, -0.08959097415208817, 0.20613600313663483, 0.6232091784477234, 0.5033038854598999, -0.08663871139287949, 0.3660748600959778, 0.10171402990818024, 0.755103349685669, -0.5664846301078796, 0.1321190446615219, -0.8318394422531128, -0.06554199755191803, -0.0994841605424881, -0.1381630003452301, -0.27608522772789, -0.5515642166137695, 0.07867325842380524, -0.5486827492713928, 0.34497493505477905, 0.1840156465768814, 0.9775140285491943, 0.5994690656661987, -0.0453069843351841, -0.2335328757762909, -0.8922423720359802, 0.8616616725921631, -0.6713657379150391, -0.032643578946590424, 0.12223658710718155, 0.38231444358825684, 0.09596685320138931, -0.4880666732788086, -0.9288859963417053, -0.4840506911277771, 0.34612345695495605, 0.19989293813705444, -0.5253955721855164, -0.057078856974840164, 0.41151848435401917, 0.6911234259605408, -0.646539568901062, 0.2964479923248291, -0.32411882281303406, 0.03708989545702934, 0.6971585154533386, 0.4627573490142822, 0.4645713269710541, -0.37149590253829956, -0.488040030002594, 0.07218415290117264, -0.6139467358589172, 0.07139884680509567, 0.3249989449977875, -0.10718777775764465, -0.101781465113163, 0.9098754525184631, 0.0027734702453017235, 0.49921414256095886, -0.2058192938566208, 0.16440176963806152, 0.12355957925319672, -0.40226641297340393, -0.24554084241390228, -0.3767658472061157, 0.9334560036659241, 0.2824086546897888, 0.4608805477619171, -0.3858638107776642, -0.3893544673919678, 0.32317182421684265, 0.4667975604534149, -0.39286839962005615, 0.14554552733898163, 0.4877352714538574, -0.1889408826828003, -0.24373556673526764, 0.19835786521434784, -0.6337263584136963, -0.34326717257499695, -0.0951196476817131, 0.7613977193832397, -0.25630563497543335, 0.05987976863980293, 0.016572270542383194, -0.2191084325313568, 0.2909137010574341, 0.04755484312772751, -0.5363253951072693, 0.10315726697444916, 0.9531092643737793, 0.6460019946098328, -0.18765397369861603, -0.6125766038894653, -0.560966968536377, -0.2816174328327179, -0.48291873931884766, 0.49019956588745117, -0.5751649141311646, -0.39070558547973633, -0.07676942646503448, -0.3609173893928528, -0.33447134494781494, -0.7940050363540649, 0.46847957372665405, -0.7310008406639099, 0.11175215244293213, -0.2062728852033615, -0.57645183801651, 0.07805392146110535, 0.11407017707824707, -0.7733145356178284, 0.8040838241577148, 0.3734967112541199, -0.5245960354804993, 0.18010735511779785, -0.5321955680847168, -0.12066209316253662, 0.2516295909881592, -0.34808966517448425, -0.4711202383041382, 0.37223514914512634, 0.0635296031832695, 0.1250348687171936, -0.8680938482284546, 0.44645577669143677, -0.24305982887744904, -0.6442083120346069, 0.6376457214355469, -0.7057160139083862, 0.8978424072265625, 0.25704944133758545, -0.4100492596626282, 0.1141546294093132, -0.4742453098297119, 0.22724536061286926, 0.4042087197303772, -0.2470124214887619, -0.05499076470732689, -0.09174247831106186, -0.1430126577615738, 0.10017116367816925, 0.26589637994766235, -0.5804170966148376, 0.03813939914107323, -0.5100899934768677, 0.36968109011650085, 0.8179993033409119, -0.15595519542694092, 0.2012091726064682, -0.6999993920326233, 1.0056568384170532, -0.2989014983177185, 0.1167324036359787, 0.3468056321144104, -0.461678683757782, -0.9846059679985046, 0.11192511767148972, 0.4176163375377655, 0.5463140606880188, -1.1953555345535278, 0.15828543901443481, -0.6236819624900818, -0.5079312920570374, -1.1131889820098877, 0.27470555901527405, 0.7801046371459961, 0.312200129032135, 0.044790398329496384, -0.1609971523284912, -0.25388747453689575, -0.9645397067070007, -0.545749843120575, -0.42555925250053406, -0.12725859880447388, 0.21379460394382477, 0.675214946269989, 0.036374013870954514, 0.8100364208221436, -0.17012739181518555, -0.06157529354095459, -0.321951687335968, 0.4291272759437561, 0.036786459386348724, 0.21494734287261963, 0.4752501845359802, -0.7747551798820496, -0.2720593214035034, -0.38433021306991577, -0.9548261165618896, -0.20372256636619568, -0.18224164843559265, 0.22056803107261658, 0.15932463109493256, 0.2771328389644623, -0.8694905042648315, 0.25496920943260193, 0.5850900411605835, -0.20092163980007172, 0.6340874433517456, -0.021697508171200752, 0.1692143827676773, -0.8307992219924927, 0.18529431521892548, -0.17541399598121643, 0.11178678274154663, -0.48744654655456543, 0.3937789499759674, -0.027182908728718758, -0.019853100180625916, -0.34439167380332947, 0.4841504991054535, -0.2444227635860443, -0.2352863997220993, -0.15685303509235382, 0.33136868476867676, 0.13899196684360504, 0.2562149167060852, -0.4910515248775482, 1.1483747959136963, 0.3455037474632263, -0.30659088492393494, 0.43370017409324646, 0.314846009016037, -0.8443169593811035, 0.48506420850753784, -0.805864691734314, 0.2795979380607605, -0.3139643967151642, -0.13674341142177582, -0.9529974460601807, -0.17127251625061035, 0.10497958213090897, -0.6112179756164551, 0.13194124400615692, 0.34413889050483704, -0.6204705834388733, -0.5566579699516296, -0.34452542662620544, 0.6110391616821289, 0.5667430758476257, -0.5453317761421204, 0.4394321143627167, -0.07589129358530045, -0.02524133212864399, -0.784249484539032, -0.6040275692939758, 0.03351828083395958, -0.18834532797336578, -0.6075664162635803, 0.15456727147102356, -0.2824729084968567, -0.5621998310089111, 0.2930411100387573, -0.02801213599741459, 0.2282976508140564, 0.5834372043609619, 0.27166494727134705, 0.3815300762653351, -0.17037838697433472, 0.08643823117017746, -0.3917393386363983, 0.0038528195582330227, 0.353890597820282, 0.10163606703281403, 0.48676013946533203, -0.19547824561595917, -0.8729148507118225, -0.4065437912940979, 0.13834556937217712, 0.7449429035186768, -0.40412816405296326, 0.7358659505844116, 0.3258468806743622, -0.2064206600189209, -0.14795982837677002, -0.6462901830673218, 0.22792792320251465, -0.4116303622722626, 0.49207571148872375, -0.456821084022522, -0.8770321011543274, 0.33048015832901, 0.3868854343891144, 0.004461163189262152, 0.914997398853302, 0.4039362370967865, -0.17738711833953857, 0.8857695460319519, 0.47011899948120117, -0.2061639428138733, -0.06535555422306061, -0.2653833329677582, 0.4966500699520111, -0.9798424243927002, -0.41641777753829956, -0.748340904712677, -0.06286007165908813, -0.5805879235267639, -0.3125061094760895, 0.6356666684150696, 0.19137775897979736, -0.23934456706047058, -0.20448996126651764, -0.07697688788175583, 0.5290851593017578, 0.5231921672821045, 0.03948245197534561, 0.3773293197154999, -0.13577306270599365, 0.13072338700294495, 0.15966878831386566, -0.8520375490188599, -0.7199254035949707, 1.1633777618408203, 0.3672773540019989, 0.6041948199272156, 0.16035065054893494, 0.3899106979370117, 0.3634725511074066, 0.3953733444213867, -0.8107368350028992, 0.4370504319667816, -0.045754559338092804, -0.563123345375061, -0.5465011596679688, -0.5011574625968933, -0.8371784090995789, 0.07023093104362488, -0.16789540648460388, -0.6171634793281555, -0.08105336874723434, -0.20160216093063354, -0.4091951251029968, 0.3392270803451538, -0.5299568176269531, 0.8992605805397034, -0.42075860500335693, -0.29191088676452637, -0.26844239234924316, -0.3831995129585266, 0.5006158351898193, -0.36841142177581787, 0.08524139970541, -0.08417829126119614, 0.24305003881454468, 0.5510119199752808, -0.2636289894580841, 0.485382080078125, 0.0536806546151638, -0.07976631075143814, 0.4839130640029907, 0.19172227382659912, 0.31888914108276367, -0.11277267336845398, -0.29576048254966736, 0.17742308974266052, -0.10718079656362534, -0.5417284965515137, -1.015514612197876, 0.5434974431991577, -0.9016808867454529, -1.1297721862792969, -0.46093934774398804, -0.5160467624664307, -0.44815272092819214, -0.11222544312477112, 0.3086250126361847, 0.09816575795412064, -0.473287969827652, -0.016163509339094162, 0.4562514126300812, -0.2969825565814972, 0.2621988356113434, 0.3423667252063751, -0.02146570011973381, -0.05348902568221092, 0.9374616146087646, -0.20313723385334015, 0.5095478892326355, 0.30171817541122437, 0.03201141208410263, -0.26264438033103943, -0.5580034255981445, -0.7270122170448303, 0.22112038731575012, -0.7073492407798767, -0.10420714318752289, -0.3442964255809784, -0.5249226093292236, -0.033353179693222046, 0.2433912754058838, -0.20331604778766632, -0.2677834630012512, -0.26119986176490784, -0.04754528030753136, -0.00023805021191947162, 1.0055925846099854, 0.23588378727436066, 0.004140983335673809, -0.5384480357170105, 0.4100976884365082, 0.7175958156585693, 0.22491158545017242, 0.40386825799942017, -0.608406126499176, 0.0121140256524086, 0.2417498379945755, -0.43460002541542053, -0.5448195338249207, -0.047236207872629166, 0.09094896167516708, 0.6249101161956787, 0.4688778817653656, -0.07880936563014984, 0.534086287021637, -0.37302038073539734, 1.0626535415649414, 0.08252683281898499, -1.060665488243103, 0.11085905134677887, -0.036722343415021896, 0.3253456652164459, 0.5324321985244751, 0.45282819867134094, -0.32401612401008606, -0.5336692333221436, -0.5760715007781982, -0.5901788473129272, 0.6255910992622375, 0.5189258456230164, 0.2908038794994354, 0.03961830958724022, 0.26081597805023193, 0.2008710354566574, 0.45282164216041565, -0.8024353981018066, -0.2930591106414795, -0.03190772607922554, -0.12962859869003296, -0.4535360038280487, -0.628198504447937, -0.2951500415802002, 0.043045345693826675, 0.5922868847846985, 0.1316586136817932, 0.37956148386001587, 0.0013252580538392067, 0.03936566412448883, -0.4612347185611725, 0.5242699980735779, 0.45175549387931824, 0.9361348748207092, 0.09646500647068024, -0.032939888536930084, 0.058870427310466766, 0.08956324309110641, 0.1299719661474228, 0.10976892709732056, -0.31137627363204956, -0.23338475823402405, 0.6801782250404358, 0.8688986301422119, -0.18135376274585724, -0.8877987861633301, 0.7228549718856812, 0.0018461034633219242, -0.15115328133106232, -0.39760375022888184, 0.17871220409870148, 0.06711060553789139, 0.3235841691493988, 0.435377299785614, -0.020588142797350883, -0.0222814679145813, -0.7688239216804504, -0.13353493809700012, 0.8884562253952026, -0.14713802933692932, -0.1771520972251892, 0.9208334684371948, 0.03890947252511978, -0.5621395111083984, 0.9344740509986877, -0.16385504603385925, -0.7947374582290649, 0.8958495259284973, 0.3470322787761688, 1.1486077308654785, -0.20632511377334595, 0.33648955821990967, 0.03238286077976227, 0.43496495485305786, 0.08966341614723206, 0.3346997797489166, 0.05046289786696434, -0.7869937419891357, -0.3270171880722046, -0.7521575093269348, -0.32083362340927124, 0.5080199837684631, -0.6573626399040222, -0.21400122344493866, -0.07820041477680206, 0.07174734026193619, 0.02435562014579773, -0.20153546333312988, -0.8519307374954224, 0.19390223920345306, -0.1750289648771286, 0.6714076995849609, -0.8585153222084045, 0.3728281259536743, 0.4629198908805847, -0.5494922995567322, -0.6532812118530273, 0.3399200141429901, -0.28568410873413086, -0.9743800163269043, 0.5780425667762756, 0.08951740711927414, -0.08395588397979736, -0.1444685012102127, -0.4854239225387573, -0.5777385234832764, 1.0259954929351807, 0.44588780403137207, -0.43711093068122864, -0.18155737221240997, 0.6116656064987183, 0.941258430480957, -0.1808813512325287, 0.19536612927913666, 0.6239610314369202, 0.4283241629600525, -0.2337765097618103, -1.2421176433563232, 0.020827416330575943, -0.3605642020702362, 0.2104957550764084, -0.18911124765872955, -0.8384696841239929, 0.6856919527053833, -0.4696316421031952, -0.4458030164241791, 0.6896303296089172, 0.4490510821342468, 0.30157044529914856, 0.48261210322380066, 0.4339475631713867, 0.6972565054893494, 0.46483325958251953, -0.24519288539886475, 1.4919265508651733, -0.10531017929315567, 0.2248273491859436, 0.8689745664596558, -0.2072981595993042, 0.6384755969047546, 0.501411497592926, -0.32475072145462036, 0.3394826054573059, 0.515217661857605, -0.22286514937877655, 0.2334464192390442, 0.4033065736293793, -0.2909903824329376, -0.46261680126190186, -0.25451967120170593, -0.06012780964374542, 0.6523002982139587, -0.06281762570142746, -0.29128530621528625, -0.015879835933446884, -0.09417572617530823, -0.29975709319114685, 0.4043499827384949, -0.1992425173521042, 0.4816240668296814, 0.12168341130018234, -0.9935736656188965, 0.713825523853302, 0.08337313681840897, 0.15339913964271545, -0.19992248713970184, -0.17825563251972198, -0.13067062199115753, -0.23291043937206268, -0.09335368126630783, -0.938554584980011, 0.149730384349823, 0.11227387934923172, -0.05992416664958, 0.03126922622323036, 0.22156059741973877, -0.11272908747196198, -0.4299064874649048, 0.17741616070270538, 0.9192783236503601, 0.10608313977718353, -0.0009883670136332512, -0.6520663499832153, 0.0636473298072815, 0.042017411440610886, 0.033695805817842484, -0.09077025204896927, 0.27771592140197754, -0.07205484807491302, 1.1225765943527222, 0.30526578426361084, 0.08169887959957123, -0.028965666890144348, 0.19332319498062134, 0.6691654920578003, -0.34701281785964966, -0.0640094205737114, -0.886538565158844, 0.3600005507469177, 0.2052520513534546, -0.25204312801361084, 0.8947576880455017, 0.6850422620773315, 1.0985698699951172, -0.26701289415359497, 0.9403365254402161, 0.08534307777881622, 0.32687655091285706, -0.7649973630905151, 0.5724090337753296, -0.7710989117622375, 0.5407520532608032, -0.30054378509521484, -1.082813024520874, 0.19751763343811035, 0.15335136651992798, -0.3996797502040863, 0.37535446882247925, 0.679155170917511, 0.58575838804245, 0.13001063466072083, 0.014479259960353374, 0.5294167995452881, 0.3386777937412262, 0.001220827572979033, 0.7996265292167664, 1.4814180135726929, -0.46696120500564575, 0.4140923023223877, -0.04421861469745636, 0.016141843050718307, -0.012856614775955677, -0.5291428565979004, -0.8425965309143066, -0.6738523244857788, -0.10639716684818268, -0.40489083528518677, 0.12373490631580353, 0.5228874087333679, -0.02068175934255123, -0.6560977697372437, -0.13773706555366516, -0.1263805627822876, 0.2737234830856323, -0.11517582833766937, -0.27866649627685547, 0.4495305120944977, -0.2214784175157547, -0.9366199970245361, 0.39373087882995605, 0.028550833463668823, -0.0023627427872270346, -0.5981939435005188, -0.0810035988688469, 0.15780659019947052, 0.08540239185094833, 0.2440922111272812, 0.1313658058643341, -1.0894899368286133, -0.28569528460502625, -0.13983313739299774, -0.07725687325000763, 0.024183671921491623, 0.5858002305030823, -0.6289275884628296, 0.6251980662345886, 0.27122700214385986, 0.9270403981208801, 0.24505515396595, 0.31621497869491577, 0.5682110786437988, -0.37401068210601807, -0.4966866075992584, 0.30091771483421326, 0.17578864097595215, 0.4065638482570648, -0.2986892759799957, 0.47281143069267273, 0.08515653759241104, -0.547356128692627, -0.8213328719139099, 0.281227171421051, -0.7163760662078857, -0.2051200270652771, 1.0986779928207397, -0.14465202391147614, 0.020560303702950478, 0.09192551672458649, 0.18552066385746002, 0.10818266868591309, -0.005470435135066509, 1.2797775268554688, 0.8903273940086365, -0.1459595113992691, 0.019706640392541885, -0.7637420892715454, 0.514070987701416, 0.7996635437011719, -0.6630841493606567, -0.0810733363032341, 0.3878316581249237, 0.3147573471069336, 0.2985464632511139, 0.4121794104576111, -0.044433873146772385, 0.51246178150177, -0.08402976393699646, -0.12124406546354294, -0.0840144157409668, -0.2779015004634857, -0.6698119044303894, 0.15576918423175812, 0.6549484729766846, -0.07795286923646927 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06196v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06196v2	Large Language Models: A Survey	2024-02-09T05:37:09	2024-02-20T13:33:49	Shervin Minaee, Tomas Mikolov, Narjes Nikzad, Meysam Chenaghlu, Richard Socher, Xavier Amatriain, Jianfeng Gao	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Large Language Models (LLMs) have drawn a lot of attention due to their strong performance on a wide range of natural language tasks, since the release of ChatGPT in November 2022. LLMs' ability of general-purpose language understanding and generation is acquired by training billions of model's parameters on massive amounts of text data, as predicted by scaling laws \cite{kaplan2020scaling,hoffmann2022training}. The research area of LLMs, while very recent, is evolving rapidly in many different ways. In this paper, we review some of the most prominent LLMs, including three popular LLM families (GPT, LLaMA, PaLM), and discuss their characteristics, contributions and limitations. We also give an overview of techniques developed to build, and augment LLMs. We then survey popular datasets prepared for LLM training, fine-tuning, and evaluation, review widely used LLM evaluation metrics, and compare the performance of several popular LLMs on a set of representative benchmarks. Finally, we conclude the paper by discussing open challenges and future research directions.	[ -0.4783860445022583, -0.8263278603553772, 0.5723181962966919, 0.10584288835525513, -0.12602445483207703, 0.19134993851184845, -0.546716034412384, -0.5973095893859863, -0.045280154794454575, 0.6256679892539978, -0.26760855317115784, -0.3799952566623688, -0.8635034561157227, 0.043114323168992996, -0.5823160409927368, 0.9023414850234985, -0.12384141981601715, 0.16984973847866058, 0.0040824320167303085, -0.059668466448783875, -0.26149895787239075, -0.8000800609588623, -0.7280571460723877, -0.36647045612335205, 0.6399203538894653, 0.21939057111740112, 0.576291561126709, 0.5502966642379761, 0.5987197160720825, 0.2941698133945465, -0.3672238886356354, 0.13190270960330963, -0.6127014756202698, 0.2262549251317978, 0.0986098200082779, -0.38525596261024475, -0.47265321016311646, -0.061799272894859314, 0.9199206233024597, 0.9290632009506226, -0.007887568324804306, 0.2125127762556076, 0.04518929496407509, 0.5474434494972229, -0.4632384479045868, 0.10856791585683823, -0.6910907030105591, -0.0030699502676725388, -0.4618496894836426, 0.1452450007200241, -0.33442333340644836, -0.3962658643722534, 0.16595013439655304, -0.07920680195093155, 0.11996682733297348, 0.1805507242679596, 0.4273907542228699, 0.04967458173632622, -0.6547502279281616, -0.5092220902442932, -1.0003187656402588, 0.9082481861114502, -0.7259898781776428, 0.42480793595314026, 0.280386745929718, 0.42072558403015137, -0.4010881781578064, -0.583258867263794, -0.3146151304244995, -0.45473411679267883, 0.30530720949172974, -0.1577320694923401, -0.04743203520774841, -0.02217911370098591, 0.10614553093910217, 0.7137414813041687, -0.5349572896957397, 0.6713604927062988, -0.13848792016506195, 0.0537785105407238, 0.62652587890625, 0.3898467421531677, 0.23958571255207062, 0.16916969418525696, -0.11292866617441177, 0.22407901287078857, -1.097887635231018, -0.3574179410934448, 0.35015302896499634, 0.19191810488700867, -0.04782010614871979, 0.6699854731559753, -0.15327148139476776, 0.8644289374351501, -0.41484180092811584, -0.1517055481672287, 0.07387866824865341, -0.3037940561771393, -0.27448421716690063, -0.2963092625141144, 0.8831607103347778, 0.15370501577854156, 0.522482693195343, -0.2062506079673767, -0.330394446849823, -0.34925591945648193, -0.13677063584327698, -0.6999701857566833, 0.022970812395215034, 0.04178722947835922, -0.41564780473709106, -0.1467200666666031, -0.19473542273044586, -0.6691343784332275, -0.6206774115562439, -0.3501664102077484, 0.06874152272939682, -0.0804387703537941, -0.4099680483341217, 0.18648898601531982, 0.19097237288951874, 0.48269569873809814, 0.5305187106132507, -1.0746604204177856, 0.3295491635799408, 0.9885331392288208, 0.7815901041030884, -0.3614360988140106, -0.16305604577064514, -0.29630789160728455, 0.04368722811341286, -0.442289799451828, 0.7452174425125122, -0.5153359174728394, -0.38354843854904175, 0.33917561173439026, -0.0981210470199585, 0.04102601110935211, -0.7372363209724426, 0.35521399974823, -0.633905827999115, 0.17834095656871796, -0.30568525195121765, -0.6037837266921997, -0.07043145596981049, 0.5096709132194519, -0.6048824787139893, 0.9068678617477417, 0.050546832382678986, -0.6749191880226135, 0.23735970258712769, -0.46387967467308044, -0.3246169686317444, 0.15861767530441284, -0.1835881620645523, -0.3241758942604065, 0.24887970089912415, 0.14772211015224457, 0.7004727721214294, -0.8372333645820618, 0.27737683057785034, -0.3543369770050049, -0.2590824067592621, 0.379657119512558, -0.5246329307556152, 0.5591461062431335, 0.3579995334148407, 0.09055598825216293, 0.1409279853105545, -0.6042003035545349, -0.1627473533153534, 0.16388744115829468, -0.5289202332496643, -0.025110339745879173, 0.10861050337553024, 0.10966692864894867, 0.06943546235561371, 0.35429811477661133, -0.41578423976898193, 0.4262324869632721, -0.32927265763282776, 0.7022131681442261, 0.5152323842048645, 0.06335096806287766, 0.23478344082832336, -0.19820837676525116, 0.6142087578773499, -0.2262309044599533, 0.038209542632102966, -0.12674762308597565, -0.3793952465057373, -0.808901309967041, -0.20236514508724213, 0.27360931038856506, 0.2700706422328949, -0.30985724925994873, 0.32660022377967834, -0.2361050397157669, -0.6893174052238464, -0.15990418195724487, 0.45956239104270935, 0.04417411610484123, -0.03944411501288414, 0.07580435276031494, -0.18262743949890137, -0.43044814467430115, -0.8400555849075317, -0.17681409418582916, -0.10442190617322922, -0.10307957231998444, 0.2671135663986206, 0.3338748514652252, -0.3243684470653534, 0.6866085529327393, -0.4323995113372803, 0.02592417784035206, -0.5872011184692383, -0.01136096939444542, 0.17065902054309845, 0.1218092143535614, 0.4504499137401581, -0.4614512026309967, -0.38731175661087036, 0.13671870529651642, -0.5483782291412354, 0.011671390384435654, 0.1969424933195114, 0.33938172459602356, 0.17889896035194397, 0.7148755192756653, -0.6277695298194885, -0.23269787430763245, 0.7547343969345093, 0.02994426153600216, 0.5060909390449524, -0.14248046278953552, -0.12164153903722763, -1.0646870136260986, -0.0936281830072403, 0.09864052385091782, -0.1936950832605362, -0.6572028994560242, 0.01183853205293417, -0.08754454553127289, 0.03232847899198532, -0.34970372915267944, 0.71040278673172, -0.7610543966293335, -0.33068639039993286, -0.38441741466522217, 0.19242806732654572, -0.6659842729568481, 0.12560930848121643, -0.0529957078397274, 0.6216790676116943, 0.6637483835220337, -0.580845057964325, 0.6635477542877197, 0.03827521204948425, -0.6037484407424927, 0.0859115719795227, -0.6240652203559875, 0.2741117775440216, -0.150037944316864, 0.27033570408821106, -1.0899769067764282, -0.38697460293769836, 0.04339858144521713, -0.11550160497426987, 0.36522141098976135, -0.12321721762418747, -0.8117032647132874, -0.5383487343788147, -0.17094258964061737, 0.28464919328689575, 0.5837103128433228, -0.5234513282775879, 0.3087983727455139, 0.5564314126968384, -0.418254017829895, -0.4222129285335541, -0.5259974598884583, 0.258334219455719, -0.43405866622924805, -0.4257753789424896, -0.2716078758239746, -0.0709453746676445, -0.5154134035110474, -0.3958905339241028, 0.13307325541973114, -0.08056153357028961, 0.17683707177639008, 0.09942033886909485, 0.12113101035356522, -0.4207766652107239, 0.2926286458969116, -0.395329087972641, 0.0443146713078022, 0.08469346165657043, -0.0863800123333931, 0.7914679646492004, -0.1632443517446518, -0.4550356864929199, 0.06884109973907471, 0.1344922035932541, 0.5142102241516113, -0.2039642333984375, 0.6297023892402649, 0.48698320984840393, -0.21791885793209076, -0.19481763243675232, -0.7336258888244629, 0.010679349303245544, -0.41947558522224426, 0.5199208855628967, -0.06506036967039108, -1.3291877508163452, 0.4040525257587433, -0.3646371364593506, 0.27407222986221313, 0.370960533618927, 1.0413758754730225, 0.12858860194683075, 0.9284593462944031, 0.6536729335784912, -0.47583678364753723, 0.48940712213516235, 0.0055243950337171555, 0.2039501816034317, -0.7001514434814453, 0.005433165933936834, -0.674738347530365, -0.21893756091594696, -0.8182386755943298, -0.48820969462394714, 0.04552248492836952, 0.06124674156308174, -0.22811874747276306, 0.23804402351379395, -0.1342599242925644, 0.44751936197280884, 0.16306354105472565, -0.37701573967933655, 0.5160149931907654, -0.08263194561004639, 0.263060986995697, 0.2053002268075943, -0.5998553037643433, -0.7698737382888794, 1.3147615194320679, 0.6590036153793335, 0.923660933971405, 0.19659532606601715, 0.48626595735549927, 0.019458822906017303, 0.5637419819831848, -0.7830957770347595, 0.6601893305778503, -0.2550274431705475, -0.6926729679107666, -0.38774383068084717, -0.42145785689353943, -0.9752659201622009, 0.33105021715164185, -0.03919396921992302, -0.7512654066085815, -0.3376066982746124, 0.03562287241220474, 0.0061627523973584175, 0.362151563167572, -0.5124095678329468, 0.4023844003677368, -0.4013321101665497, -0.04523885250091553, -0.2152826488018036, -0.442705899477005, 0.5993601083755493, -0.3830529451370239, 0.22026056051254272, -0.3640119433403015, -0.18428142368793488, 0.7156404852867126, -0.17258068919181824, 0.7761244177818298, -0.01880737394094467, -0.5414920449256897, 0.33085277676582336, -0.19933763146400452, 0.45924168825149536, 0.022798489779233932, -0.1440696269273758, 0.10221204906702042, -0.11831803619861603, -0.1995965987443924, -0.24144810438156128, 0.8311699032783508, -0.7030735611915588, -0.5950999855995178, -0.25088930130004883, -0.6068137288093567, -0.6066604256629944, 0.01926434226334095, 0.09428121149539948, 0.29158154129981995, -0.47437629103660583, 0.3966839909553528, 0.7282094955444336, -0.3165360987186432, 0.5147610306739807, 0.4607161581516266, -0.596513032913208, -0.28866708278656006, 0.9252299070358276, 0.18538297712802887, 0.38719823956489563, 0.43674328923225403, 0.1886872500181198, -0.22573119401931763, -1.019376277923584, -0.24359337985515594, 0.404344379901886, -0.4523296654224396, -0.02979164384305477, -0.47576239705085754, -0.366228312253952, -0.34570032358169556, 0.0871795266866684, -0.38707756996154785, -0.3110249638557434, -0.1261456310749054, 0.026912221685051918, 0.42112165689468384, 1.213607668876648, 0.262572705745697, 0.6187321543693542, -0.7286098599433899, 0.15983687341213226, 0.30033305287361145, 0.42942243814468384, 0.10379683971405029, -0.4498063325881958, -0.18033921718597412, -0.15319524705410004, -0.2518727481365204, -0.401117742061615, 0.30581530928611755, -0.0028451711405068636, 0.58408123254776, 0.42876774072647095, -0.37730902433395386, 0.35086923837661743, -0.48542648553848267, 0.8846350908279419, 0.24070137739181519, -0.5140373110771179, 0.14501804113388062, -0.5715442299842834, 0.28562256693840027, 0.24093131721019745, 0.48425737023353577, -0.7697731852531433, -0.38872501254081726, -0.34024161100387573, -0.7381404042243958, 0.35245829820632935, -0.03158116713166237, 0.44964054226875305, 0.1342730075120926, 0.31642159819602966, 0.19779451191425323, 0.2783867418766022, -0.6851589679718018, -0.1211276426911354, 0.474515825510025, -0.21188408136367798, -0.36377182602882385, -0.36116763949394226, 0.07794221490621567, -0.11511574685573578, 0.41930559277534485, -0.05262601003050804, 0.06980593502521515, -0.37714290618896484, -0.049902476370334625, -0.02656240575015545, 0.5135648846626282, 0.5212795734405518, 0.7129578590393066, -0.04629967734217644, 0.05632666498422623, 0.38290247321128845, -0.48946356773376465, 0.142949640750885, 0.056791894137859344, 0.0517156720161438, -0.23131868243217468, 0.49585390090942383, 0.6975626349449158, 0.23728707432746887, -0.7852550148963928, 0.3565816581249237, -0.032623399049043655, -0.3535510301589966, -0.2998228371143341, 0.16854959726333618, 0.47906211018562317, 0.22466279566287994, 0.2752971053123474, -0.5204192996025085, -0.1855405867099762, -0.6713319420814514, -0.24373586475849152, 0.6299914717674255, -0.2400609403848648, -0.2393314689397812, 0.3306395411491394, 0.21505500376224518, -0.18566304445266724, 0.5144391655921936, 0.0704772025346756, -0.32773637771606445, 0.4347327649593353, 0.4895074665546417, 0.697445273399353, -0.15607430040836334, -0.1823953092098236, 0.18258340656757355, 0.3743956387042999, -0.36770182847976685, 0.11940255016088486, 0.13229134678840637, -0.7665265202522278, -0.5341665744781494, -0.7420719265937805, -0.6473071575164795, 0.5826901793479919, -0.20340727269649506, 0.27393174171447754, -0.5043861269950867, -0.06829219311475754, -0.09367091953754425, 0.21637946367263794, -0.579187273979187, 0.0024004613514989614, 0.25202760100364685, 0.952819287776947, -0.6229719519615173, 0.7561883926391602, 0.6807674169540405, -0.10315993428230286, -0.4944451153278351, -0.020468616858124733, -0.026565393432974815, -0.8709226250648499, 0.5598373413085938, -0.1122564822435379, 0.035458263009786606, -0.019250204786658287, -0.6748988628387451, -0.8968561887741089, 0.7988514304161072, 0.3508981466293335, -0.8687466382980347, -0.15158744156360626, 0.488920122385025, 0.5663174390792847, -0.349485844373703, 0.26749977469444275, 0.7729898691177368, 0.4418710768222809, 0.04383173957467079, -0.9326311945915222, -0.24081265926361084, 0.06797809898853302, 0.21755540370941162, 0.3662390410900116, -0.8225706815719604, 0.7538735270500183, -0.06424841284751892, -0.03414617106318474, 0.37521272897720337, 0.6221189498901367, 0.3102061152458191, 0.01869777776300907, 0.3893612325191498, 0.23760421574115753, 0.6172837615013123, -0.1268797367811203, 0.8773292899131775, -0.13175632059574127, 0.22517640888690948, 1.163919448852539, -0.4347797632217407, 0.9501436948776245, 0.310578316450119, -0.3943803012371063, -0.04311810061335564, 0.663057804107666, -0.21306756138801575, 0.03604128584265709, 0.6732752323150635, -0.4089830219745636, -0.29780587553977966, -0.011674058623611927, -0.4803217947483063, 0.4845287501811981, 0.520042896270752, -0.49094358086586, -0.44023239612579346, -0.0606108158826828, 0.11680921167135239, -0.1447351574897766, -0.4349387586116791, 0.8703106045722961, 0.3173465132713318, -0.4459663927555084, 0.32465848326683044, 0.025975070893764496, 0.7715383768081665, -0.7063860297203064, 0.11454799026250839, -0.21907582879066467, 0.15880951285362244, -0.05363723263144493, -0.9247861504554749, -0.021483050659298897, 0.2422095537185669, 0.020993465557694435, -0.23409847915172577, 0.7295289039611816, -0.3692702651023865, -0.4479520320892334, 0.15846143662929535, 0.7110064625740051, 0.3542316257953644, 0.006576943211257458, -0.38325437903404236, 0.4227442741394043, -0.20881512761116028, -0.4934060871601105, 0.557845950126648, 0.4774651527404785, -0.02335670404136181, 0.8348633646965027, 0.4482267200946808, 0.3026425242424011, 0.2041032761335373, 0.22499065101146698, 0.7357317209243774, -0.7471524477005005, 0.04590906947851181, -0.7965606451034546, 0.021711979061365128, 0.08816878497600555, -0.4919489920139313, 0.8882154822349548, 0.6729702353477478, 0.6441655158996582, 0.013041513971984386, 0.8967390656471252, 0.1992012858390808, 0.6373125910758972, -0.47601526975631714, 0.6587117314338684, -0.2370547205209732, 0.1767152100801468, -0.12976792454719543, -1.1488008499145508, -0.307365745306015, 0.20686568319797516, -0.508935272693634, 0.2835727035999298, 0.3493049740791321, 0.6536380648612976, 0.11248105764389038, 0.19870485365390778, 0.4040244519710541, 0.280570924282074, 0.5255283713340759, 0.4182021915912628, 1.167747139930725, -0.13736698031425476, 0.3926165997982025, 0.19604648649692535, -0.04880024120211601, -0.3759906589984894, -0.9106299877166748, -0.87095046043396, -0.47972172498703003, -0.2342062145471573, 0.18546101450920105, -0.06200926750898361, 0.8162134289741516, 0.6769692897796631, -0.7670690417289734, -0.530494213104248, -0.11267853528261185, 0.029599202796816826, 0.22038690745830536, -0.1310543417930603, 0.07730883359909058, -0.35178545117378235, -0.8575382828712463, 0.41158413887023926, 0.17788641154766083, 0.1943071186542511, -0.5690814256668091, -0.08631860464811325, -0.0009506105561740696, -0.032367605715990067, 0.8924667239189148, 0.38383689522743225, -0.705466091632843, -0.2314639389514923, -0.21232722699642181, -0.26884007453918457, -0.05920765921473503, 0.963264524936676, -0.30148863792419434, 0.030821682885289192, 0.5359241366386414, 0.8288099765777588, 0.5603857040405273, -0.36278417706489563, 0.6185194849967957, -0.3601609170436859, -0.12395532429218292, 0.15082356333732605, 0.46472907066345215, 0.46209731698036194, 0.035556353628635406, 0.5328895449638367, -0.11505655944347382, -0.795268714427948, -0.888482928276062, 0.17167440056800842, -0.98124098777771, -0.17464128136634827, 1.3375062942504883, 0.20545966923236847, 0.03646943345665932, -0.09438834339380264, -0.23855245113372803, 0.04974296689033508, -0.10087402164936066, 0.4814632534980774, 0.9388343691825867, -0.1673455536365509, -0.25053727626800537, -0.8488461375236511, 0.32939231395721436, 0.1434093415737152, -1.0248768329620361, 0.4225008487701416, 0.5128165483474731, 0.44823935627937317, -0.1313306838274002, 0.4967139661312103, -0.21773207187652588, -0.20258276164531708, -0.26463156938552856, -0.147713765501976, 0.23555101454257965, -0.2641940712928772, -0.482526034116745, 0.3167210817337036, 0.8035107254981995, 0.24181678891181946 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10946v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10946v1	CultureLLM: Incorporating Cultural Differences into Large Language Models	2024-02-09T04:02:43	2024-02-09T04:02:43	Cheng Li, Mengzhou Chen, Jindong Wang, Sunayana Sitaram, Xing Xie	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Large language models (LLMs) are reported to be partial to certain cultures owing to the training data dominance from the English corpora. Since multilingual cultural data are often expensive to collect, existing efforts handle this by prompt engineering or culture-specific pre-training. However, they might overlook the knowledge deficiency of low-resource culture and require extensive computing resources. In this paper, we propose CultureLLM, a cost-effective solution to incorporate cultural differences into LLMs. CultureLLM adopts World Value Survey (WVS) as seed data and generates semantically equivalent training data via the proposed semantic data augmentation. Using only 50 seed samples from WVS with augmented data, we fine-tune culture-specific LLMs and one unified model (CultureLLM-One) for 9 cultures covering rich and low-resource languages. Extensive experiments on 60 culture-related datasets demonstrate that CultureLLM significantly outperforms various counterparts such as GPT-3.5 (by 8.1%) and Gemini Pro (by 9.5%) with comparable performance to GPT-4 or even better. Our human study shows that the generated samples are semantically equivalent to the original samples, providing an effective solution for LLMs augmentation.	[ -0.37463244795799255, -0.33481234312057495, 0.16043490171432495, 0.2597064971923828, -0.1206660345196724, 0.3019962012767792, -0.6652462482452393, -0.7442204356193542, 0.3772885799407959, 0.5451242327690125, -0.6525659561157227, -0.4857352375984192, -0.4247076213359833, 0.19928087294101715, 0.07646718621253967, 0.6358802318572998, 0.0560622401535511, 0.3025037348270416, -0.21621659398078918, -0.3985448181629181, -0.4528740644454956, -0.45225802063941956, -0.3002263009548187, -0.4265093505382538, 0.3276543617248535, 0.603914737701416, 0.5616337060928345, 0.5848454833030701, 0.4314650893211365, 0.2997738718986511, -0.24644482135772705, 0.631959080696106, -0.638716995716095, 0.11023324728012085, -0.20704147219657898, -0.36209946870803833, -0.40292635560035706, 0.3876195549964905, 0.3157946765422821, 0.7917588949203491, 0.05445155128836632, 0.3145356774330139, 0.03797738254070282, 0.5479822158813477, -0.5255542397499084, 0.2210380882024765, -0.8734481334686279, 0.20947371423244476, 0.0486944317817688, -0.10213425010442734, -0.23604705929756165, -0.3179868161678314, -0.04247232899069786, -0.490169882774353, 0.12197580933570862, 0.0898914635181427, 0.48984137177467346, 0.2051224708557129, -0.4788009226322174, -0.13782545924186707, -0.8612320423126221, 1.0915700197219849, -0.5864293575286865, 0.4333258271217346, 0.2049163430929184, -0.0406639389693737, -0.27896416187286377, -0.2416023313999176, -0.5348777770996094, -0.2545442581176758, -0.08346714079380035, 0.10380329936742783, 0.06036285683512688, -0.3900472819805145, 0.23481112718582153, 0.460143506526947, -0.6088745594024658, 0.3922054171562195, -0.3643331229686737, -0.18730491399765015, 0.801222026348114, 0.19471564888954163, 0.3349182903766632, -0.038376420736312866, -0.27564379572868347, -0.31028443574905396, -1.0767360925674438, -0.11594704538583755, 0.2773664891719818, 0.39592719078063965, -0.21070829033851624, 0.165083110332489, -0.4381742477416992, 0.5948472619056702, -0.20875973999500275, -0.6543782353401184, 0.3481249213218689, -0.07894007861614227, -0.1616748422384262, 0.09713441878557205, 0.5249610543251038, 0.40115875005722046, 0.4002861976623535, -0.20664560794830322, -0.14180120825767517, 0.08322875201702118, -0.25917136669158936, -1.0545984506607056, -0.15670515596866608, 0.07589931041002274, -0.33839404582977295, -0.21483543515205383, -0.08937414735555649, -0.23176665604114532, -0.5180640816688538, -0.4075474739074707, 0.1896008551120758, -0.341232031583786, -0.37198641896247864, -0.028324585407972336, -0.03640369325876236, 0.28809210658073425, 0.2955993115901947, -0.7730887532234192, -0.08584904670715332, 0.5959281921386719, 0.8316410779953003, -0.39261025190353394, -0.15392136573791504, -0.4479663074016571, 0.0938311293721199, -0.4655950665473938, 0.5802911520004272, -0.46418496966362, -0.6978838443756104, -0.11877991259098053, 0.08776340633630753, 0.3312363028526306, -0.8048374652862549, 0.43320947885513306, -0.6248852014541626, 0.300357848405838, -0.24084791541099548, -0.4812528192996979, 0.01478930190205574, 0.4770675003528595, -0.7556532621383667, 1.0084151029586792, 0.09966997802257538, -0.5649251341819763, 0.66193687915802, -0.589750349521637, -0.4965231418609619, 0.36688199639320374, -0.06660495698451996, -0.01870129257440567, 0.03060847707092762, 0.37758567929267883, 0.4963919222354889, -0.45523759722709656, 0.10720039904117584, -0.2651035785675049, -0.45794540643692017, 0.27203869819641113, -0.4719492197036743, 0.820442795753479, 0.6184466481208801, -0.06538888812065125, -0.09938715398311615, -0.9437817931175232, 0.04214758053421974, 0.1872001439332962, -0.39597538113594055, -0.6255974769592285, -0.09243227541446686, 0.2151585817337036, 0.3732773959636688, 0.2808656692504883, -0.6856561303138733, 0.25429821014404297, -0.46387916803359985, 0.25432226061820984, 0.4938826262950897, -0.5062138438224792, 0.6304558515548706, -0.2365362048149109, 0.5310654044151306, 0.13811588287353516, -0.01451097708195448, -0.03526538237929344, -0.27082696557044983, -0.6664838790893555, -0.41592955589294434, 0.1897411048412323, 0.5205530524253845, -0.7999539971351624, 0.17496764659881592, -0.49047932028770447, -0.4875005781650543, -0.6388984322547913, 0.46780332922935486, -0.016044707968831062, 0.47683852910995483, 0.32527661323547363, -0.36247050762176514, -0.5823097229003906, -0.8147727251052856, -0.10051708668470383, -0.10933679342269897, -0.3562662899494171, 0.022491825744509697, 0.14376646280288696, -0.07511131465435028, 1.1310681104660034, -0.5898687839508057, -0.2889101803302765, -0.3622119724750519, 0.028422417119145393, 0.2755958139896393, 0.4936698079109192, 0.25539344549179077, -0.740821361541748, -0.5011885166168213, 0.06727705895900726, -0.5797073841094971, -0.14468206465244293, 0.2699759304523468, -0.005898077506572008, 0.4577863812446594, 0.45050084590911865, -0.23320400714874268, 0.15729598701000214, 0.7922707796096802, -0.13904188573360443, 0.21690857410430908, -0.3881189227104187, 0.18681110441684723, -1.3301308155059814, -0.2055092751979828, -0.04617156833410263, -0.10602719336748123, -0.4797014594078064, 0.15811243653297424, 0.21405398845672607, -0.07428862899541855, -0.6354497671127319, 0.6410843729972839, -0.5539783239364624, 0.09298144280910492, -0.3847121298313141, 0.06517791002988815, 0.1335642784833908, 0.12427221238613129, 0.36213985085487366, 0.7209036350250244, 0.17296871542930603, -0.31578922271728516, 0.49407240748405457, 0.015138890594244003, -0.5850925445556641, 0.7640833258628845, -0.29206228256225586, 0.19993580877780914, -0.22765515744686127, 0.44830843806266785, -0.5743933320045471, -0.12577125430107117, -0.06184576451778412, -0.2124459445476532, 0.05549278110265732, -0.46175092458724976, -0.3989622890949249, -0.2166385054588318, -0.2544059455394745, 0.2614790201187134, 0.9483897089958191, -0.7430570125579834, 0.4748991131782532, 0.31420251727104187, -0.18002299964427948, -0.5627893209457397, -0.6923791170120239, 0.22582747042179108, -0.571611762046814, -0.8946781754493713, 0.35267582535743713, -0.27794647216796875, -0.43659231066703796, -0.12060341984033585, 0.1664642095565796, 0.033238932490348816, 0.18949827551841736, 0.041475098580121994, 0.32222574949264526, -0.3797735869884491, 0.2854297459125519, -0.36776912212371826, 0.07021673768758774, -0.07812777161598206, -0.6408683061599731, 0.5326080918312073, 0.054794713854789734, -0.32592880725860596, 0.06436440348625183, 0.3259066939353943, 0.4817580580711365, -0.4175253212451935, 0.7659772038459778, 0.7804333567619324, -0.29298755526542664, -0.39915409684181213, -0.7337108850479126, -0.3035737872123718, -0.46361830830574036, 0.3282298147678375, -0.40129008889198303, -1.0499120950698853, 0.4076700508594513, -0.06314495205879211, 0.17210832238197327, 0.14399807155132294, 0.5462304353713989, -0.09573733806610107, 0.968178391456604, 0.5944259166717529, -0.3334037959575653, 0.2821873128414154, -0.10930132865905762, 0.17455454170703888, -0.40520888566970825, -0.16074082255363464, -0.43799257278442383, -0.5038275122642517, -0.8796065449714661, -0.7017519474029541, 0.4881686270236969, -0.05962354317307472, -0.18553070724010468, -0.047920990735292435, -0.22740186750888824, 0.6683950424194336, 0.5623936653137207, -0.2413339465856552, 0.6766443252563477, 0.27668991684913635, 0.00996609777212143, -0.17776383459568024, -0.8394578099250793, -0.396242618560791, 0.9019153118133545, 0.13179270923137665, 0.9767787456512451, 0.2850377559661865, 0.5944924354553223, 0.04518726095557213, 0.6263101100921631, -0.8636242151260376, 0.3297690451145172, -0.44569987058639526, -0.2165064811706543, -0.22166092693805695, -0.5072749257087708, -0.7445714473724365, 0.493352472782135, -0.3504951000213623, -0.443623811006546, -0.03332618623971939, 0.15439987182617188, -0.009195075370371342, 0.34533020853996277, -0.6200289130210876, 0.5416207313537598, -0.19628731906414032, -0.33668920397758484, -0.16733227670192719, -0.37032994627952576, 0.4040288031101227, -0.17715509235858917, 0.5408957004547119, -0.40289026498794556, 0.20141752064228058, 0.5892523527145386, -0.510932981967926, 0.727425217628479, -0.12269134819507599, -0.3133835792541504, 0.1936790496110916, 0.12534430623054504, 0.5079599022865295, 0.05189349874854088, -0.09918491542339325, 0.17320694029331207, -0.09664254635572433, -0.5299230217933655, -0.44516003131866455, 0.9992893934249878, -0.811610996723175, -0.7144299745559692, -0.2643275558948517, -1.0697715282440186, -0.5009373426437378, -0.32834291458129883, -0.03088795766234398, 0.33606070280075073, -0.2283201813697815, 0.30913692712783813, 0.6124916672706604, -0.4159250855445862, 0.4511067867279053, 0.9581184387207031, -0.005410769023001194, -0.09629298746585846, 0.7276977896690369, 0.09302579611539841, 0.3894542157649994, 0.2162805199623108, 0.4051368534564972, -0.37632226943969727, -0.2846240699291229, -0.6898584365844727, 0.035105619579553604, -0.6221437454223633, -0.051426760852336884, -0.6021293997764587, 0.014694168232381344, -0.49595630168914795, -0.10540109872817993, -0.26378190517425537, -0.2651713192462921, 0.08468999713659286, -0.08683742582798004, 0.8564869165420532, 0.5237001180648804, -0.25192898511886597, 0.21204164624214172, -0.8753342628479004, -0.13531392812728882, 0.23894065618515015, 0.1969519704580307, -0.10568506270647049, -0.672781229019165, -0.3705606460571289, 0.2086707204580307, 0.03543340787291527, -0.463722825050354, 0.5979124903678894, 0.12877866625785828, 0.29450076818466187, 0.3220508396625519, 0.03756947070360184, 0.856381356716156, -0.46017536520957947, 0.8155291676521301, 0.18227741122245789, -0.6862810254096985, 0.3233412504196167, -0.03968953713774681, 0.5067456364631653, 0.3218018412590027, 0.43258407711982727, -1.0189329385757446, -0.4431033134460449, -0.36281776428222656, -0.865609347820282, 0.7031243443489075, -0.28934669494628906, 0.4183961749076843, 0.0359528623521328, 0.002644420601427555, 0.11684421449899673, -0.21296054124832153, -0.6743119359016418, 0.012319661676883698, 0.034602001309394836, -0.18850134313106537, -0.21850033104419708, 0.02916794642806053, -0.09859440475702286, -0.19309312105178833, 0.6850661635398865, -0.2964702248573303, -0.5467527508735657, -0.08217492699623108, -0.5707201361656189, 0.03582240268588066, 0.5194949507713318, 0.27008843421936035, 0.670961320400238, -0.14711713790893555, 0.24199922382831573, 0.6867767572402954, -0.4153062403202057, 0.29040271043777466, -0.09147373586893082, -0.1839931160211563, -0.19302071630954742, 0.2653781473636627, 0.5745992660522461, -0.0931600034236908, -0.8590282797813416, 0.3166774809360504, -0.040926285088062286, 0.07111745327711105, -0.33329060673713684, 0.08217278122901917, 0.5241280794143677, 0.23723839223384857, 0.3656390309333801, -0.46286365389823914, -0.21359752118587494, -0.6871852874755859, 0.0020444155670702457, 0.4553639590740204, -0.4827193021774292, -0.023808838799595833, 0.4612792134284973, 0.3081400394439697, -0.0027775887865573168, 0.7478974461555481, -0.294888973236084, -0.37165772914886475, 0.630931556224823, 0.5807093977928162, 0.39995941519737244, -0.2920774519443512, 0.21715909242630005, 0.09231892228126526, 0.2856489419937134, -0.12719513475894928, 0.3068065345287323, 0.305571973323822, -1.0801295042037964, -0.8895573019981384, -0.8581311106681824, -0.42219650745391846, 0.28976911306381226, -0.44871950149536133, 0.4319916069507599, -0.12900516390800476, 0.312618613243103, -0.39444711804389954, 0.05676092207431793, -0.9467321038246155, 0.4459019899368286, 0.2939509451389313, 0.9182603359222412, -1.0480124950408936, 1.0417215824127197, 0.8481365442276001, -0.2711544632911682, -0.8291621208190918, -0.17952574789524078, 0.05757063999772072, -0.916074275970459, 0.9595910906791687, -0.0031397712882608175, -0.2079777717590332, -0.2306841015815735, -0.3172011375427246, -0.746726393699646, 1.0037201642990112, 0.18893882632255554, -0.5055224299430847, 0.46334993839263916, 0.40295934677124023, 0.5419423580169678, -0.5724413394927979, 0.2672485113143921, 0.6398448348045349, 0.3418468236923218, 0.32978156208992004, -0.6600619554519653, -0.008994399569928646, -0.056765116751194, 0.20823049545288086, 0.07696699351072311, -0.5617110133171082, 0.7939031720161438, -0.12489194422960281, -0.1097814217209816, -0.17553763091564178, 0.7670043706893921, 0.3427821099758148, 0.021718978881835938, 0.7339434027671814, 0.3995628356933594, 0.7838355898857117, -0.056675318628549576, 0.6630218029022217, -0.6383569836616516, 0.157677561044693, 0.9826421737670898, -0.5828651785850525, 0.7005552649497986, 0.4411589205265045, -0.15316835045814514, 0.14870646595954895, 0.6715098023414612, 0.04426408186554909, 0.11599209904670715, 0.443544864654541, -0.36280983686447144, -0.2723362147808075, -0.4811379909515381, -0.38816311955451965, 0.7380408048629761, 0.29673296213150024, -0.07353278994560242, -0.024592652916908264, 0.005530237220227718, 0.5055433511734009, 0.09770451486110687, -0.2593175172805786, 0.7086800336837769, 0.0821789801120758, -0.589250922203064, 0.6579145789146423, 0.33844441175460815, 1.1899831295013428, -0.7582294344902039, 0.12826214730739594, -0.7197466492652893, -0.050498366355895996, -0.26400113105773926, -0.40476563572883606, 0.1882615089416504, 0.22257405519485474, -0.24442550539970398, -0.40594133734703064, 0.595273494720459, -0.8232129216194153, -0.7442116141319275, 0.19695353507995605, 0.7489904165267944, 0.18112652003765106, -0.014095303602516651, -0.13907726109027863, 0.11160682141780853, -0.08170227706432343, 0.06724652647972107, 0.3975007236003876, 0.27618932723999023, -0.3923780918121338, 0.4268713891506195, 0.7533478736877441, 0.5101778507232666, -0.27514031529426575, 0.31100618839263916, 0.4677048921585083, -0.6291847229003906, -0.5465932488441467, -0.8110970258712769, 0.17181432247161865, -0.30889609456062317, -0.15233202278614044, 0.562492311000824, 0.4672914743423462, 1.1530262231826782, -0.10297848284244537, 0.9369039535522461, -0.023672815412282944, 0.45277145504951477, -0.5771728157997131, 0.8435130715370178, -0.7106927633285522, 0.32884877920150757, -0.04204170033335686, -1.0575551986694336, -0.06370491534471512, 0.316796213388443, -0.2838679254055023, -0.16503173112869263, 0.5111228227615356, 1.1151388883590698, -0.1986847221851349, 0.06940485537052155, 0.5446555018424988, 0.20583146810531616, 0.271443635225296, 0.5352279543876648, 1.054958462715149, 0.22684617340564728, 0.5519537329673767, -0.293708473443985, -0.20746085047721863, -0.10148935765028, -1.1479723453521729, -0.5799609422683716, -0.35187941789627075, -0.23809602856636047, -0.21071216464042664, -0.19018813967704773, 1.4986932277679443, 0.782159149646759, -0.7979726195335388, -0.42100387811660767, 0.760676920413971, 0.009767061099410057, -0.03398597240447998, -0.18866808712482452, 0.26160702109336853, -0.245350643992424, -1.0786219835281372, 0.6327941417694092, 0.19174791872501373, -0.0895463302731514, -0.606469988822937, -0.12332745641469955, 0.3546657860279083, -0.07920996844768524, 0.9229550361633301, -0.07079204171895981, -0.6691641211509705, -0.5066165924072266, -0.009344115853309631, -0.01703360490500927, 0.13582590222358704, 0.8782901167869568, -0.7741044759750366, 0.2655903100967407, 0.473066121339798, 0.6685217022895813, 0.41260549426078796, -0.21571430563926697, 0.5721192955970764, -0.9180586934089661, 0.5612783432006836, 0.00490674888715148, 0.46084079146385193, 0.7905039191246033, -0.22653113305568695, 0.5265688896179199, 0.3000379204750061, -0.027081042528152466, -0.4310910403728485, 0.2997646629810333, -0.6882985830307007, -0.4434264600276947, 1.279465913772583, -0.12767858803272247, -0.01300536748021841, 0.001455071265809238, 0.040173761546611786, -0.014998296275734901, -0.18559689819812775, 0.7535450458526611, 0.7277663350105286, 0.17287522554397583, 0.18779301643371582, -0.4867750406265259, 0.3711710572242737, 0.39460623264312744, -0.8062471151351929, -0.17912258207798004, 0.6950634717941284, 0.6686622500419617, -0.11361128836870193, 0.38979509472846985, -0.24766495823860168, -0.12827397882938385, -0.3671567142009735, 0.33771249651908875, -0.07219409197568893, 0.11616173386573792, -0.23029181361198425, 0.22932970523834229, 0.2561604976654053, 0.0864771232008934 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06155v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06155v1	Model Editing with Canonical Examples	2024-02-09T03:08:12	2024-02-09T03:08:12	John Hewitt, Sarah Chen, Lanruo Lora Xie, Edward Adams, Percy Liang, Christopher D. Manning	cs.CL	cs.CL	We introduce model editing with canonical examples, a setting in which (1) a single learning example is provided per desired behavior, (2) evaluation is performed exclusively out-of-distribution, and (3) deviation from an initial model is strictly limited. A canonical example is a simple instance of good behavior, e.g., The capital of Mauritius is Port Louis) or bad behavior, e.g., An aspect of researchers is coldhearted). The evaluation set contains more complex examples of each behavior (like a paragraph in which the capital of Mauritius is called for.) We create three datasets and modify three more for model editing with canonical examples, covering knowledge-intensive improvements, social bias mitigation, and syntactic edge cases. In our experiments on Pythia language models, we find that LoRA outperforms full finetuning and MEMIT. We then turn to the Backpack language model architecture because it is intended to enable targeted improvement. The Backpack defines a large bank of sense vectors--a decomposition of the different uses of each word--which are weighted and summed to form the output logits of the model. We propose sense finetuning, which selects and finetunes a few ($\approx$ 10) sense vectors for each canonical example, and find that it outperforms other finetuning methods, e.g., 4.8% improvement vs 0.3%. Finally, we improve GPT-J-6B by an inference-time ensemble with just the changes from sense finetuning of a 35x smaller Backpack, in one setting outperforming editing GPT-J itself (4.1% vs 1.0%).	[ -0.03951648995280266, -0.8199846148490906, 0.49061280488967896, 0.11325376480817795, -0.19972842931747437, -0.0033396773505955935, -0.46775519847869873, -0.19734077155590057, 0.08556845784187317, 0.39186474680900574, -0.26516321301460266, -0.6045793890953064, -0.2811864912509918, -0.0869421660900116, -0.49521544575691223, 1.0872929096221924, -0.06678248941898346, 0.14714200794696808, 0.0884460061788559, -0.44941437244415283, -0.5736238956451416, -0.6715446710586548, -0.6718774437904358, -0.24842120707035065, 0.47227194905281067, 0.361303448677063, 0.6747071743011475, 0.3165648877620697, 0.2840065360069275, 0.3023557960987091, -0.35223478078842163, 0.0982917994260788, -0.6903512477874756, -0.24402767419815063, -0.5244367122650146, -0.42498746514320374, -0.5618712902069092, 0.11552353203296661, 0.7691482305526733, 0.5273569822311401, -0.150061696767807, 0.057984840124845505, 0.20258884131908417, 0.7784156203269958, -0.7170681357383728, 0.11023932695388794, -0.5305992960929871, -0.3953425884246826, -0.0381012000143528, 0.12389040738344193, -0.5654826760292053, -0.43550652265548706, 0.09344738721847534, -0.8285573124885559, 0.19258049130439758, -0.13621962070465088, 0.8862515091896057, 0.10245948284864426, -0.3134904205799103, -0.2507902681827545, -0.8042205572128296, 0.9266088008880615, -0.6888635754585266, 0.24101655185222626, 0.38181060552597046, 0.18027326464653015, -0.19181619584560394, -0.6361480355262756, -0.6039180159568787, 0.049807410687208176, -0.09497349709272385, 0.0946240946650505, -0.6437911987304688, 0.2007906585931778, 0.14976909756660461, 0.353470116853714, -0.3480696678161621, 0.025381483137607574, -0.608666718006134, -0.01907854527235031, 0.7465922236442566, -0.14927758276462555, 0.1677148938179016, -0.3722001910209656, -0.03611151501536369, -0.41291671991348267, -0.929394006729126, 0.07771053165197372, 0.534543514251709, 0.2496548742055893, 0.11258871108293533, 0.5761693716049194, -0.2792819142341614, 0.7667183876037598, 0.12884840369224548, 0.1418333649635315, 0.16580936312675476, -0.35567715764045715, -0.4979192912578583, -0.2004561722278595, 0.5102574825286865, 0.5926699042320251, 0.3434458076953888, 0.04013175889849663, -0.3273756802082062, 0.04144367575645447, 0.25606438517570496, -0.6985474228858948, -0.5783156752586365, -0.0599370039999485, -0.6851086020469666, -0.6233082413673401, -0.29377639293670654, -0.6713181138038635, -0.24154235422611237, -0.6280863285064697, 0.5907361507415771, -0.6443033814430237, -0.2451438456773758, 0.2841283679008484, -0.19532297551631927, 0.08910354971885681, 0.5564295649528503, -0.8903605937957764, 0.5388416051864624, 0.5701659917831421, 0.7593919634819031, 0.01476529985666275, -0.21864867210388184, -0.4352667033672333, -0.10477305203676224, -0.38381657004356384, 0.9311392307281494, -0.6469910740852356, -0.5115771889686584, -0.1348327249288559, -0.056214120239019394, -0.11910597234964371, -0.5118836164474487, 0.5917352437973022, -0.494842529296875, 0.06668564677238464, -0.48495712876319885, -0.6630434393882751, -0.5225192308425903, 0.011799467727541924, -0.4915940463542938, 1.043900966644287, 0.24542507529258728, -0.186884343624115, 0.36646825075149536, -0.8783944845199585, -0.2560580372810364, -0.2697427272796631, 0.13596060872077942, -0.348574161529541, 0.4069288969039917, 0.2820390462875366, 0.42703497409820557, -0.07128787785768509, 0.40539056062698364, -0.33335015177726746, -0.23506680130958557, 0.13047239184379578, -0.15583130717277527, 0.9434688091278076, 0.12091945111751556, -0.05406646803021431, 0.37658318877220154, -0.7824181318283081, 0.016154544427990913, 0.09652145206928253, -0.28300121426582336, -0.9189961552619934, 0.024682246148586273, 0.34786662459373474, -0.09431477636098862, -0.03550005331635475, -0.3713778257369995, 0.7752857804298401, -0.3400464653968811, 0.8360176086425781, 1.0202162265777588, 0.27617743611335754, 0.6934109330177307, -0.33870959281921387, 0.41227996349334717, -0.11456932127475739, 0.16048336029052734, -0.12611031532287598, -0.43081343173980713, -0.7342763543128967, -0.31263574957847595, 0.6887333393096924, 0.4044032096862793, -0.6575976610183716, 0.23375335335731506, -0.10844719409942627, -0.5639887452125549, -0.3579389452934265, 0.2601858377456665, 0.4409375786781311, 0.3820740878582001, 0.43458107113838196, -0.17727406322956085, -0.45527997612953186, -1.0633563995361328, -0.5090290307998657, -0.28076401352882385, 0.21999427676200867, 0.04671575874090195, 0.7175772190093994, 0.08201198279857635, 0.9241141676902771, -0.5426477789878845, 0.04724697396159172, -0.2684735357761383, 0.07946613430976868, 0.020193280652165413, 0.7980296611785889, 0.7415488362312317, -0.5800577402114868, 0.04708824306726456, -0.19562283158302307, -0.6103638410568237, -0.04046513885259628, -0.15270914137363434, -0.412664532661438, 0.0874682068824768, 0.5827788710594177, -0.6781864762306213, 0.517420768737793, 0.4000017046928406, -0.35315173864364624, 0.5005298852920532, -0.2896553575992584, 0.05379614979028702, -1.1075886487960815, -0.17785067856311798, 0.08016012609004974, -0.0938020572066307, -0.706455409526825, 0.5477124452590942, 0.2676738202571869, -0.10053878277540207, -0.35415929555892944, 0.661175549030304, -0.2643544375896454, 0.11359134316444397, 0.029628822579979897, 0.11754090338945389, 0.007749425247311592, 0.6536279320716858, -0.0983743742108345, 0.3682689666748047, 0.299635112285614, -0.5606693029403687, 0.11088702082633972, 0.34754273295402527, -0.5996090173721313, 0.49096518754959106, -0.8478034138679504, 0.07519770413637161, -0.11897878348827362, 0.4009701907634735, -0.8995296955108643, -0.2212156504392624, 0.1748976856470108, -0.009522554464638233, 0.24574615061283112, -0.3154139518737793, -0.7011910080909729, -0.1335812509059906, -0.3522827923297882, 0.4999457001686096, 0.5593849420547485, -0.7000389695167542, 0.48900485038757324, 0.06828974932432175, -0.24621327221393585, -0.2583675682544708, -0.4796600341796875, -0.09279747307300568, -0.37693482637405396, -0.4369971454143524, 0.21394695341587067, -0.30398404598236084, -0.4120776653289795, 0.050981756299734116, 0.010420206002891064, 0.007936838082969189, 0.1937096267938614, 0.08374374359846115, 0.3066876530647278, -0.1495538353919983, 0.4627000093460083, 0.4602371156215668, 0.040299393236637115, -0.37066081166267395, -0.5197986960411072, 0.32062679529190063, -0.2284848690032959, -0.2722039818763733, -0.4152465760707855, 0.04852422699332237, 0.4071488380432129, -0.3239159882068634, 0.22115637362003326, 0.2714104652404785, -0.6685603857040405, -0.03002355806529522, -0.4749548137187958, -0.11384092271327972, -0.4433949887752533, 0.27369576692581177, -0.45049208402633667, -0.5995285511016846, 0.4345305263996124, -0.015996355563402176, 0.28388094902038574, 0.44801002740859985, 0.28354883193969727, 0.0400686040520668, 0.7023839950561523, 0.6802173256874084, -0.13358792662620544, 0.5455626845359802, -0.5145783424377441, 0.32062965631484985, -0.8293148279190063, 0.17683067917823792, -0.5308070182800293, -0.5642916560173035, -0.7999829649925232, -0.3783274292945862, 0.2617381513118744, 0.8473551273345947, -0.1481713205575943, 0.6222926378250122, -0.5198367834091187, 0.7043710350990295, 0.5954639315605164, 0.3391900062561035, 0.47763967514038086, 0.08886551111936569, -0.088279590010643, -0.12620703876018524, -0.9200566411018372, -0.7101868987083435, 1.2737178802490234, 0.16786840558052063, 0.7397130131721497, 0.25641629099845886, 0.7837307453155518, 0.2736065685749054, 0.5336102247238159, -0.7678329348564148, 0.4094863831996918, -0.26390644907951355, -0.5544076561927795, -0.2505069673061371, -0.03882308676838875, -0.6396517753601074, 0.20421278476715088, -0.09172755479812622, -0.8088842630386353, 0.6754727959632874, 0.5726863145828247, -0.7438352108001709, 0.25494644045829773, -1.0952297449111938, 0.9803621768951416, 0.15777772665023804, -0.26855435967445374, -0.4482160806655884, -0.14677129685878754, 0.6110560297966003, -0.044569991528987885, 0.23031085729599, 0.18361321091651917, 0.22260157763957977, 0.7192333936691284, -0.4856119453907013, 0.8739480972290039, -0.1869346648454666, -0.07624722272157669, 0.48181936144828796, 0.29253488779067993, 0.541709840297699, 0.07986654341220856, -0.2216217815876007, 0.15285296738147736, 0.1207854375243187, -0.5032431483268738, -0.8633758425712585, 0.7581433653831482, -0.6068898439407349, -0.4145333170890808, -0.10219230502843857, -0.54490727186203, -0.06743563711643219, 0.005869192536920309, 0.1650085747241974, 0.7571585774421692, -0.29518479108810425, 0.1895953267812729, 0.4587981402873993, -0.4673686921596527, 0.5181471705436707, 0.3984036445617676, -0.48712149262428284, -0.3411886394023895, 1.0787326097488403, 0.22202055156230927, 0.46951282024383545, 0.3659323751926422, 0.4669521450996399, 0.038483645766973495, -0.4488856792449951, -0.6895932555198669, 0.030704259872436523, -0.7420786619186401, -0.2254740446805954, -0.6308651566505432, 0.1603720635175705, -0.3879525065422058, -0.4603203237056732, -0.3245640993118286, -0.8682401776313782, 0.0706791803240776, -0.15519946813583374, 0.6279508471488953, 1.009917140007019, -0.3173673748970032, 0.5942713022232056, -0.35918304324150085, 0.1769827902317047, 0.3899693489074707, 0.13747692108154297, 0.08999844640493393, -0.5165812969207764, -0.2259303778409958, 0.05503764748573303, -0.5343409776687622, -0.7197632789611816, 0.18790429830551147, 0.19446182250976562, 0.19550278782844543, 0.3917393982410431, -0.2011510580778122, 1.0275630950927734, -0.4759402871131897, 0.8111329078674316, -0.12384901940822601, -1.2197933197021484, 0.6556429266929626, -0.5215774774551392, 0.3295740783214569, 0.3771545886993408, -0.014352581463754177, -0.423898309469223, -0.43960708379745483, -0.9168464541435242, -0.5719651579856873, 0.5355476140975952, 0.46531686186790466, 0.01360287144780159, 0.10381338000297546, 0.4423847496509552, 0.022265348583459854, 0.30828529596328735, -0.702319860458374, -0.17720752954483032, -0.2403203696012497, -0.08684317022562027, -0.33597707748413086, -0.24844025075435638, 0.0632946640253067, -0.6322160363197327, 0.9348504543304443, 0.03454919531941414, 0.17767485976219177, 0.18214771151542664, -0.3211403787136078, 0.03356218710541725, 0.3418411314487457, 1.0376782417297363, 0.7562285661697388, -0.08862044662237167, -0.15157701075077057, 0.21105509996414185, -0.22965721786022186, -0.09983351081609726, 0.06866386532783508, -0.48460158705711365, 0.1168910413980484, 0.3382101058959961, 0.6327412724494934, 0.5768185257911682, -0.4881587624549866, 0.2989392876625061, 0.018514173105359077, -0.14428232610225677, -0.1936814785003662, 0.025691695511341095, 0.04473211616277695, 0.15854887664318085, 0.14522947371006012, 0.46383124589920044, 0.28285279870033264, -0.5666040778160095, -0.02772383764386177, 0.32456231117248535, -0.10347930341959, -0.43953436613082886, 0.4730251729488373, 0.10394149273633957, -0.19724108278751373, 0.46802547574043274, -0.533893346786499, -0.484116792678833, 0.5026320815086365, 0.2555786967277527, 0.8057582378387451, -0.4476887881755829, 0.1699102371931076, 0.5805870294570923, 0.5712618827819824, -0.18588215112686157, 0.17215433716773987, -0.13031353056430817, -0.7464913129806519, -0.3320689797401428, -0.670802652835846, -0.14208915829658508, 0.3235969841480255, -0.7804683446884155, 0.5476057529449463, -0.5307513475418091, 0.24073705077171326, 0.2378755509853363, -0.29069435596466064, -0.6887314915657043, 0.03218128904700279, -0.48571035265922546, 0.8654152750968933, -0.8641435503959656, 0.8757960200309753, 0.6485379338264465, -0.5287157893180847, -0.7469291687011719, -0.18925535678863525, 0.09160079807043076, -0.6951695084571838, 0.5507200360298157, -0.12340658158063889, 0.26037365198135376, -0.005993276368826628, -0.7199397683143616, -0.7593626379966736, 0.8881877660751343, 0.3217001259326935, -0.9131088852882385, -0.16800394654273987, -0.4465351402759552, 0.5408428311347961, -0.21952560544013977, -0.051653746515512466, 0.6945361495018005, 0.43731239438056946, -0.37031787633895874, -0.7812260985374451, -0.16268661618232727, -0.25432369112968445, 0.19531436264514923, 0.23948858678340912, -0.6132209897041321, 0.8486953973770142, -0.22747471928596497, 0.04256025329232216, 0.42171797156333923, 0.5050452947616577, 0.13459263741970062, 0.18402394652366638, 0.6296520829200745, 0.7320423722267151, 0.8446512818336487, -0.05589870363473892, 1.1865226030349731, -0.26354196667671204, 0.48246827721595764, 1.4932596683502197, -0.051910802721977234, 0.9643815755844116, 0.3290380537509918, -0.012930531054735184, 0.6084240674972534, 0.7636815309524536, 0.12389051914215088, 0.497475266456604, 0.3619365394115448, -0.3751244843006134, -0.27917373180389404, 0.18939253687858582, -0.3260730803012848, 0.5532853603363037, 0.3694295585155487, -0.45193323493003845, -0.3058004677295685, 0.25991520285606384, 0.12712396681308746, 0.05504317954182625, -0.4338096082210541, 0.5227136611938477, -0.02429850958287716, -0.4851304888725281, 0.599518358707428, 0.30452874302864075, 0.3366909325122833, -0.26768702268600464, -0.2010830193758011, -0.18779458105564117, 0.28012949228286743, -0.1363525539636612, -0.3499455749988556, 0.21995435655117035, 0.1968105286359787, -0.3917216956615448, -0.5377523303031921, 0.7452176213264465, -0.34090012311935425, -0.8677719831466675, 0.0016364905750378966, 0.3376256823539734, 0.25045904517173767, -0.16081538796424866, -0.5209708213806152, 0.09021079540252686, -0.10367057472467422, -0.26927313208580017, 0.1378818303346634, 0.32807451486587524, -0.38053420186042786, 0.3731848895549774, 0.657076358795166, -0.058756448328495026, -0.14034871757030487, 0.08938632905483246, 0.8097351789474487, -0.58765709400177, -0.35708364844322205, -0.8352140784263611, 0.5645279884338379, -0.12910088896751404, -0.608912467956543, 0.5610808730125427, 0.6665506958961487, 1.119364619255066, -0.24991632997989655, 0.8456748127937317, -0.03379044681787491, 0.23754657804965973, -0.6628989577293396, 0.6439758539199829, -0.35100865364074707, 0.04031287878751755, -0.6048938035964966, -0.9795910120010376, -0.16884441673755646, 0.8667371869087219, -0.39420250058174133, -0.021705590188503265, 0.8071935176849365, 0.8713849186897278, -0.1788097321987152, 0.12639252841472626, 0.3915573060512543, 0.5120618939399719, 0.21669180691242218, 0.34071430563926697, 0.5885598659515381, -0.8865702152252197, 0.2668514847755432, -0.43327704071998596, -0.16354961693286896, 0.0025185770355165005, -0.9175415635108948, -0.7819126844406128, -0.8401265740394592, -0.43107083439826965, -0.4148990213871002, 0.2921706736087799, 1.0044100284576416, 0.779789924621582, -0.816096842288971, -0.3298792243003845, -0.19534403085708618, 0.24231021106243134, -0.4287285804748535, -0.22867512702941895, 0.36112019419670105, -0.23167303204536438, -0.8232554793357849, 0.5098581910133362, 0.15475718677043915, -0.01329931989312172, -0.2000017762184143, 0.053031742572784424, -0.16745929419994354, -0.02406957373023033, 1.0147513151168823, 0.23301437497138977, -0.7479766607284546, -0.45941323041915894, -0.19277046620845795, 0.2789557874202728, -0.23907029628753662, 0.9658745527267456, -0.7495205998420715, 0.4734096825122833, 0.16398325562477112, 0.5573851466178894, 0.3926827311515808, -0.02741207741200924, 0.6022005081176758, -0.5925325155258179, 0.10576976835727692, -0.13223135471343994, 0.5187986493110657, 0.2580038011074066, -0.07377414405345917, 0.5281078219413757, 0.4158575236797333, -0.5461828708648682, -0.8395907282829285, 0.10881371051073074, -0.9998257160186768, -0.13276337087154388, 1.2123597860336304, -0.15962642431259155, -0.21267849206924438, 0.21796929836273193, -0.4243522584438324, 0.11828021705150604, -0.5353103876113892, 0.8240786194801331, 1.015329122543335, 0.0029123148415237665, 0.12454424798488617, -0.7192586064338684, 0.4393008053302765, 0.5035883784294128, -0.6873857378959656, 0.20036302506923676, 0.7282952070236206, 0.40550315380096436, 0.10041021555662155, 0.49430808424949646, 0.003034380031749606, 0.3615131378173828, -0.33923855423927307, 0.19239099323749542, 0.27819520235061646, -0.2367008626461029, -0.7345021367073059, -0.13410216569900513, 0.06517516821622849, -0.034392282366752625 ]

Subsets and Splits