id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10171v1 | Data Engineering for Scaling Language Models to 128K Context | 2024-02-15T18:19:16 | 2024-02-15T18:19:16 | Yao Fu, Rameswar Panda, Xinyao Niu, Xiang Yue, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Yoon Kim, Hao Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the continual pretraining recipe for scaling language models'
context lengths to 128K, with a focus on data engineering. We hypothesize that
long context modeling, in particular \textit{the ability to utilize information
at arbitrary input locations}, is a capability that is mostly already acquired
through large-scale pretraining, and that this capability can be readily
extended to contexts substantially longer than seen during training~(e.g., 4K
to 128K) through lightweight continual pretraining on appropriate data mixture.
We investigate the \textit{quantity} and \textit{quality} of the data for
continual pretraining: (1) for quantity, we show that 500 million to 5 billion
tokens are enough to enable the model to retrieve information anywhere within
the 128K context; (2) for quality, our results equally emphasize \textit{domain
balance} and \textit{length upsampling}. Concretely, we find that naively
upsampling longer data on certain domains like books, a common practice of
existing work, gives suboptimal performance, and that a balanced domain mixture
is important. We demonstrate that continual pretraining of the full model on
1B-5B tokens of such data is an effective and affordable strategy for scaling
the context length of language models to 128K. Our recipe outperforms strong
open-source long-context models and closes the gap to frontier models like
GPT-4 128K. | [
-0.3581060767173767,
-0.5829440355300903,
0.509641170501709,
0.3977586328983307,
-0.3270450830459595,
-0.07894288748502731,
-0.4650392234325409,
-0.5099726915359497,
0.09305092692375183,
0.6057035326957703,
-0.3995567858219147,
-0.14630728960037231,
-0.5210576057434082,
-0.1266079694032669,
-0.42060407996177673,
0.974777340888977,
-0.1735667586326599,
-0.08680666983127594,
-0.17591914534568787,
-0.10350735485553741,
-0.7834725975990295,
-0.6594159007072449,
-0.526544988155365,
-0.05829261615872383,
0.4841659367084503,
0.4980621337890625,
0.8253734111785889,
0.9289763569831848,
0.14655698835849762,
0.24199096858501434,
0.08123830705881119,
-0.1930675059556961,
-0.911075234413147,
0.18797504901885986,
-0.07029283791780472,
-0.21322040259838104,
-0.7027769088745117,
0.14386850595474243,
1.0135865211486816,
1.1707009077072144,
-0.03073902055621147,
0.17354850471019745,
0.32774433493614197,
0.8411697745323181,
-0.4367254674434662,
0.022298168390989304,
-0.6294348239898682,
-0.24317266047000885,
-0.42701438069343567,
-0.07009502500295639,
-0.4141269624233246,
0.244222953915596,
0.2649623155593872,
-0.6899904608726501,
0.07013659924268723,
0.20227712392807007,
0.9208922982215881,
-0.008781809359788895,
-0.43734562397003174,
-0.17742623388767242,
-0.8461511731147766,
1.0745818614959717,
-0.5721054077148438,
0.6391106843948364,
0.5477955341339111,
0.16139791905879974,
-0.06265252828598022,
-0.7976363301277161,
-0.3959043025970459,
-0.3667135536670685,
0.07208030670881271,
-0.16384421288967133,
0.1597626656293869,
0.21755023300647736,
0.29348793625831604,
0.42840343713760376,
-0.5224794149398804,
0.04851613566279411,
-0.36942246556282043,
-0.12038859724998474,
0.5326040387153625,
0.146521657705307,
0.2731446921825409,
0.2698024809360504,
-0.3095340132713318,
-0.14384298026561737,
-0.7592494487762451,
-0.14032861590385437,
0.2713456153869629,
0.22350193560123444,
0.06909593939781189,
0.465546190738678,
-0.2582681477069855,
0.8630170822143555,
-0.17792975902557373,
0.0615457184612751,
0.07722143828868866,
-0.7824217081069946,
-0.3067929148674011,
-0.10908297449350357,
0.4197903573513031,
0.18992304801940918,
0.23397162556648254,
-0.5102584958076477,
-0.37273064255714417,
-0.2127707451581955,
0.6132445931434631,
-1.0092545747756958,
-0.12215106189250946,
0.15297120809555054,
-0.2792128920555115,
0.15722185373306274,
-0.08143981546163559,
-0.680918276309967,
0.1284119337797165,
-0.8200621008872986,
0.5320762395858765,
-0.5058685541152954,
-0.40585842728614807,
0.45936304330825806,
0.04065284878015518,
0.09260918200016022,
0.003853671485558152,
-1.0888903141021729,
0.3996710181236267,
0.7460760474205017,
0.9609290361404419,
-0.22741860151290894,
-0.541593611240387,
-0.27088701725006104,
0.057051900774240494,
-0.6112737059593201,
0.4202640652656555,
-0.5342521071434021,
-0.4649658799171448,
-0.26589614152908325,
0.02474714070558548,
-0.10628879070281982,
-0.4078232944011688,
0.2511291205883026,
-0.6708383560180664,
-0.058498919010162354,
-0.2236291468143463,
-0.8004920482635498,
0.22358523309230804,
0.06416220963001251,
-0.7627686858177185,
1.0198917388916016,
0.47018638253211975,
-0.5654653906822205,
0.6123940944671631,
-0.6361146569252014,
-0.3852095305919647,
0.19369816780090332,
-0.04222148284316063,
-0.21993553638458252,
0.1156320795416832,
-0.03476940095424652,
0.29810237884521484,
-0.29521986842155457,
0.5937893986701965,
-0.41321831941604614,
-0.36757954955101013,
-0.05026167631149292,
-0.4880899488925934,
0.6492125988006592,
0.3733534514904022,
-0.23791436851024628,
0.07163263857364655,
-0.7404158711433411,
0.11025445908308029,
-0.006814433261752129,
-0.44188132882118225,
-0.5273101329803467,
-0.16531996428966522,
0.1710532009601593,
0.05026985704898834,
0.3369496464729309,
-0.5934358835220337,
0.22229790687561035,
-0.4593702256679535,
0.382955402135849,
0.6940845847129822,
-0.23833054304122925,
0.6745595932006836,
-0.280391126871109,
0.5601646304130554,
-0.03379972651600838,
0.15359841287136078,
-0.20862945914268494,
-0.13192009925842285,
-0.7219107151031494,
-0.20281445980072021,
0.6519443392753601,
0.15166981518268585,
-0.5754052996635437,
0.6689032912254333,
-0.7945740222930908,
-0.3565749228000641,
-0.3023637533187866,
0.1827162653207779,
0.035235077142715454,
0.6079185009002686,
0.5229807496070862,
-0.4855004549026489,
-0.6007072329521179,
-0.8443425297737122,
-0.11048826575279236,
0.11850106716156006,
-0.30142688751220703,
0.19264020025730133,
0.3634411692619324,
-0.4566643238067627,
1.378088116645813,
-0.2989448606967926,
0.11265876889228821,
-0.316201776266098,
0.09384091943502426,
0.2538737952709198,
0.7802515029907227,
0.6884769797325134,
-0.816892683506012,
-0.4456217586994171,
-0.10469859093427658,
-0.5437173247337341,
0.07596320658922195,
-0.13856929540634155,
-0.44035160541534424,
-0.021673524752259254,
0.4984823167324066,
-0.4831944406032562,
0.22693277895450592,
0.6618815064430237,
-0.3331541419029236,
0.6511124968528748,
-0.23096881806850433,
0.13348181545734406,
-1.2537366151809692,
0.1588578224182129,
-0.03483191505074501,
-0.365693062543869,
-0.7200681567192078,
0.0017218905268236995,
0.2156616598367691,
-0.34476855397224426,
-0.187970370054245,
0.684320330619812,
-0.47610339522361755,
0.11800728738307953,
-0.43277180194854736,
-0.19300661981105804,
-0.020587950944900513,
0.31958526372909546,
0.07666346430778503,
0.763160228729248,
0.6979863047599792,
-0.6577402353286743,
0.23701980710029602,
-0.2308320254087448,
-0.6011707186698914,
0.4349340796470642,
-0.6752814054489136,
0.06561607867479324,
0.10308679193258286,
0.3266356885433197,
-0.9021527767181396,
-0.20649053156375885,
-0.23583847284317017,
-0.2393122762441635,
0.4197319746017456,
-0.33603718876838684,
-0.5808460712432861,
-0.3123939335346222,
-0.113467276096344,
0.6763117909431458,
0.4256559908390045,
-0.5914220809936523,
0.5126433372497559,
0.5624083280563354,
-0.5496422052383423,
-0.45259031653404236,
-0.44714900851249695,
0.3033628761768341,
-0.2928123474121094,
-0.8995965719223022,
0.4823845624923706,
-0.30627527832984924,
0.0303188469260931,
0.01953028328716755,
-0.3429233729839325,
-0.29904818534851074,
0.10500705987215042,
0.017435714602470398,
0.21416997909545898,
-0.4244002103805542,
0.13646863400936127,
-0.028331158682703972,
-0.15783002972602844,
0.023971909657120705,
-0.7158632874488831,
0.6184914708137512,
-0.11802004277706146,
-0.12575671076774597,
-0.12102491408586502,
0.40010878443717957,
0.5885456204414368,
0.10273829102516174,
0.8858636617660522,
0.15703311562538147,
-0.43132284283638,
-0.08221390098333359,
-0.44948840141296387,
-0.17291077971458435,
-0.5053662061691284,
0.5221436023712158,
-0.45598575472831726,
-1.0020376443862915,
0.3932332694530487,
-0.19195546209812164,
0.23581969738006592,
0.47592419385910034,
0.21628418564796448,
0.04056132957339287,
0.919492781162262,
1.007677674293518,
-0.5448408126831055,
0.70427405834198,
-0.2075720876455307,
0.1154470145702362,
-0.6375839710235596,
0.2487751543521881,
-0.45418012142181396,
-0.3167242407798767,
-0.20591235160827637,
-0.2940026521682739,
0.12379716336727142,
0.27325722575187683,
-0.28799325227737427,
0.3308870196342468,
-0.11656822264194489,
0.7789987325668335,
0.29405009746551514,
-0.04106948524713516,
-0.04830893501639366,
0.0529659241437912,
0.12688186764717102,
-0.022910285741090775,
-0.781210720539093,
-0.34185555577278137,
1.2686069011688232,
0.480263352394104,
0.7998208403587341,
-0.19719110429286957,
0.5064835548400879,
-0.010186501778662205,
0.40023133158683777,
-0.6381361484527588,
0.294892281293869,
-0.09536824375391006,
-0.7104331254959106,
-0.6814430356025696,
-0.7492260336875916,
-1.0093611478805542,
-0.022760890424251556,
0.19355858862400055,
-0.48093950748443604,
0.1548227220773697,
0.3750344216823578,
-0.1784617006778717,
0.13479599356651306,
-0.7920969724655151,
1.1375033855438232,
-0.32096341252326965,
-0.22668100893497467,
-0.18821300566196442,
-0.6937562227249146,
0.15842501819133759,
-0.46595218777656555,
0.20791883766651154,
0.04584599286317825,
0.14446549117565155,
0.9923681020736694,
-0.5908320546150208,
0.6715551614761353,
-0.23556934297084808,
-0.16825491189956665,
0.1358674168586731,
0.05465003848075867,
0.3262585997581482,
0.06914537400007248,
0.0013337661512196064,
0.15467305481433868,
0.1300787329673767,
-0.8680333495140076,
-0.5296568274497986,
0.6028538942337036,
-0.6708806157112122,
-0.3504543900489807,
0.019684208557009697,
-0.5638921856880188,
-0.607574999332428,
0.3776858448982239,
0.28339388966560364,
0.6257994174957275,
-0.0957460030913353,
0.7750827670097351,
0.5514169931411743,
0.09760066121816635,
0.1866750568151474,
0.42333734035491943,
-0.08417907357215881,
-0.1921323984861374,
1.044830560684204,
0.38486504554748535,
0.4679586589336395,
0.14315035939216614,
0.13988684117794037,
-0.40229567885398865,
-0.6022875308990479,
-0.525475800037384,
0.040224023163318634,
-0.5624847412109375,
-0.04994555935263634,
-0.5637511014938354,
-0.30881956219673157,
-0.4800488352775574,
-0.13455380499362946,
-0.6912680268287659,
-0.2488265186548233,
-0.06997265666723251,
-0.14917218685150146,
0.16251243650913239,
0.4967460632324219,
-0.036673255264759064,
0.5872049331665039,
-0.7914692759513855,
0.15289708971977234,
0.22799916565418243,
0.7200523018836975,
0.1660984754562378,
-0.8836508989334106,
-0.8026465773582458,
0.2885797619819641,
-0.05042590573430061,
-0.46160435676574707,
0.22049224376678467,
0.1824478656053543,
0.3910010755062103,
0.2586020529270172,
-0.1346919983625412,
0.930866539478302,
-0.6535223722457886,
0.9034873247146606,
0.05156613886356354,
-0.9033156037330627,
0.33364954590797424,
-0.2679269015789032,
0.36827829480171204,
0.8127832412719727,
0.6925908327102661,
-0.7531706690788269,
-0.2529633343219757,
-0.6305748224258423,
-1.1628875732421875,
0.6441054940223694,
0.06838372349739075,
0.5196366906166077,
0.012833008542656898,
0.546791672706604,
0.2525258958339691,
0.07014385610818863,
-0.6690273284912109,
0.05601581931114197,
-0.3282468914985657,
-0.32889726758003235,
-0.3432212471961975,
-0.4104706645011902,
-0.036676935851573944,
-0.3884047865867615,
0.668433666229248,
-0.15529797971248627,
-0.039160601794719696,
-0.2585850656032562,
-0.39453601837158203,
0.15773645043373108,
0.15457138419151306,
0.47895491123199463,
1.1644517183303833,
-0.19583995640277863,
0.01344588864594698,
0.0074801016598939896,
-0.6622392535209656,
0.12240473181009293,
0.06839454174041748,
0.21189457178115845,
-0.2345881164073944,
0.34467071294784546,
0.8791408538818359,
0.28792130947113037,
-0.589179515838623,
0.38015297055244446,
-0.08861355483531952,
-0.10327620059251785,
-0.07768707722425461,
0.09967661648988724,
0.04031527414917946,
-0.11247042566537857,
0.3643215596675873,
-0.23776115477085114,
-0.1390189230442047,
-0.38861513137817383,
0.5125418901443481,
0.13133010268211365,
-0.3042201101779938,
-0.44658955931663513,
0.5124410390853882,
0.1695806384086609,
0.1387147605419159,
0.9206712245941162,
0.07080554962158203,
-0.14449237287044525,
0.6431233286857605,
0.6840061545372009,
0.5869618654251099,
-0.09548655152320862,
-0.13149279356002808,
0.25479844212532043,
0.23630456626415253,
-0.5480602979660034,
-0.004707160405814648,
-0.14801304042339325,
-0.7969486713409424,
-0.573631227016449,
-0.8809049129486084,
-0.33131471276283264,
0.39820030331611633,
-0.6212742328643799,
0.10704416036605835,
-0.24061666429042816,
-0.033020276576280594,
-0.12937532365322113,
0.043111152946949005,
-0.7327643036842346,
0.4681161046028137,
-0.042491890490055084,
0.9174610376358032,
-0.7940776944160461,
1.118249773979187,
0.2723458409309387,
-0.18845593929290771,
-0.8674773573875427,
0.08046213537454605,
-0.18600799143314362,
-0.597990870475769,
0.6413624286651611,
0.29389506578445435,
0.0359589084982872,
0.17275521159172058,
-0.6579874157905579,
-0.9304285049438477,
0.8770416975021362,
0.3680233657360077,
-0.7982076406478882,
-0.09536182135343552,
0.23624323308467865,
0.5276923179626465,
-0.49830907583236694,
-0.2282838374376297,
0.7520708441734314,
0.24078412353992462,
-0.03790724650025368,
-0.8320362567901611,
-0.0834629237651825,
-0.25283220410346985,
0.13298338651657104,
0.16513946652412415,
-0.2888498306274414,
0.7806965708732605,
0.2020484060049057,
-0.27843526005744934,
0.04280606657266617,
0.8595849871635437,
0.09003797918558121,
0.04715609923005104,
0.7109194397926331,
0.6470797061920166,
0.7175202369689941,
0.15849508345127106,
1.1022372245788574,
-0.602753221988678,
0.4629783630371094,
1.187699556350708,
-0.27832192182540894,
0.6085411310195923,
0.2533135712146759,
-0.1501840353012085,
0.16616332530975342,
0.8981115221977234,
0.3480299711227417,
0.4778946340084076,
0.2008984386920929,
-0.1935543268918991,
-0.26998645067214966,
0.1518731713294983,
-0.4614320397377014,
0.06008416414260864,
0.36552610993385315,
-0.15514527261257172,
-0.0797053650021553,
0.18292507529258728,
-0.029722532257437706,
-0.40974169969558716,
-0.23368282616138458,
0.47908395528793335,
0.18466679751873016,
-0.6028009653091431,
0.6631051301956177,
0.028821446001529694,
0.6099100708961487,
-0.762352705001831,
0.4136548936367035,
-0.4520096778869629,
-0.06945861130952835,
0.2830934226512909,
-0.7095047831535339,
0.3344688415527344,
-0.015637094154953957,
-0.29507187008857727,
-0.5238834023475647,
0.4747660458087921,
-0.5418746471405029,
-0.3559799790382385,
0.2208443284034729,
0.1636904627084732,
0.15818071365356445,
-0.24053148925304413,
-0.515142023563385,
0.06368431448936462,
-0.22624610364437103,
-0.46201735734939575,
0.6281576752662659,
0.7159057855606079,
-0.02950693666934967,
0.4224117398262024,
0.5223515629768372,
0.23774178326129913,
0.17949464917182922,
0.10265535861253738,
1.0030345916748047,
-0.7324990630149841,
-0.6925266981124878,
-0.8672917485237122,
0.38007718324661255,
-0.06653395295143127,
-0.3063424825668335,
0.4916394352912903,
0.8100518584251404,
0.9645773768424988,
0.03737913444638252,
0.6481972336769104,
0.017815006896853447,
0.24931925535202026,
-0.643748939037323,
0.6397049427032471,
-0.6756414771080017,
0.09143519401550293,
-0.048359110951423645,
-1.022836685180664,
-0.0985548198223114,
0.30303362011909485,
-0.27990227937698364,
0.24734261631965637,
0.5559369921684265,
0.6011607050895691,
-0.42699241638183594,
0.042323287576436996,
0.3752427101135254,
0.15678930282592773,
0.41906169056892395,
0.43677079677581787,
0.5745275616645813,
-0.10037035495042801,
0.39966344833374023,
-0.06158243864774704,
-0.4954354465007782,
-0.11280009150505066,
-0.7576850652694702,
-0.5792818665504456,
-0.6614534854888916,
0.010212798602879047,
-0.18988801538944244,
-0.13291986286640167,
0.7265216112136841,
1.0819437503814697,
-0.5501766204833984,
-0.37967437505722046,
-0.09352907538414001,
-0.29987651109695435,
-0.06896476447582245,
-0.21448427438735962,
0.21380649507045746,
-0.7439923882484436,
-0.5299696922302246,
0.5407278537750244,
0.27515479922294617,
0.11759615689516068,
-0.1693708300590515,
-0.17146891355514526,
0.149428591132164,
0.25014054775238037,
0.6812155246734619,
0.3136100769042969,
-0.11310622841119766,
-0.41174623370170593,
-0.04058896377682686,
-0.16991163790225983,
0.10460860282182693,
1.0020334720611572,
-0.5140641927719116,
0.5030409693717957,
0.34106701612472534,
1.0602092742919922,
0.5573638081550598,
0.08600320667028427,
0.8257947564125061,
-1.0481719970703125,
0.21479813754558563,
0.18754912912845612,
0.35267749428749084,
0.12566372752189636,
-0.26818370819091797,
0.3899815082550049,
0.25182780623435974,
-0.7343034148216248,
-0.7854867577552795,
0.20044709742069244,
-0.7730714082717896,
-0.39710673689842224,
1.04521644115448,
-0.1189512386918068,
-0.21546700596809387,
-0.07665789127349854,
-0.07608877122402191,
0.07635371387004852,
-0.05741973966360092,
0.6730902194976807,
1.1108603477478027,
-0.03820446506142616,
0.15610480308532715,
-0.7051845192909241,
0.5215154886245728,
0.557266354560852,
-0.8028175234794617,
0.46253567934036255,
0.4249051511287689,
0.5104746222496033,
0.03181370347738266,
0.9359325170516968,
-0.061528630554676056,
0.0024528473149985075,
0.10582126677036285,
-0.19985851645469666,
0.23355410993099213,
-0.7760507464408875,
-0.14815421402454376,
-0.023014158010482788,
0.10943930596113205,
0.028525957837700844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10153v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10153v2 | Knowledge-Infused LLM-Powered Conversational Health Agent: A Case Study for Diabetes Patients | 2024-02-15T18:00:02 | 2024-02-28T19:40:13 | Mahyar Abbasian, Zhongqi Yang, Elahe Khatibi, Pengfei Zhang, Nitish Nagesh, Iman Azimi, Ramesh Jain, Amir M. Rahmani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Effective diabetes management is crucial for maintaining health in diabetic
patients. Large Language Models (LLMs) have opened new avenues for diabetes
management, facilitating their efficacy. However, current LLM-based approaches
are limited by their dependence on general sources and lack of integration with
domain-specific knowledge, leading to inaccurate responses. In this paper, we
propose a knowledge-infused LLM-powered conversational health agent (CHA) for
diabetic patients. We customize and leverage the open-source openCHA framework,
enhancing our CHA with external knowledge and analytical capabilities. This
integration involves two key components: 1) incorporating the American Diabetes
Association dietary guidelines and the Nutritionix information and 2) deploying
analytical tools that enable nutritional intake calculation and comparison with
the guidelines. We compare the proposed CHA with GPT4. Our evaluation includes
100 diabetes-related questions on daily meal choices and assessing the
potential risks associated with the suggested diet. Our findings show that the
proposed agent demonstrates superior performance in generating responses to
manage essential nutrients. | [
0.009578365832567215,
-0.8614681959152222,
0.8835134506225586,
0.06939245015382767,
-0.2174965888261795,
0.20539622008800507,
-0.20041103661060333,
-0.7012593150138855,
0.914819598197937,
0.8820381760597229,
-0.029369274154305458,
-0.5484508275985718,
-0.4296973943710327,
-0.016711018979549408,
0.051999278366565704,
0.8768704533576965,
-0.1217435821890831,
0.5223398804664612,
-0.5734714269638062,
0.06613697111606598,
-0.525633692741394,
-0.13804082572460175,
-0.7684215903282166,
-0.5507933497428894,
0.6284962892532349,
0.665126383304596,
0.7080324292182922,
0.2549908757209778,
0.6326910853385925,
0.2032366842031479,
0.1640070080757141,
0.36884766817092896,
-0.11789481341838837,
0.3112008273601532,
-0.2055138647556305,
-0.671201765537262,
-0.9117627143859863,
-0.11139141023159027,
-0.0599181242287159,
0.5682550668716431,
-0.1526147872209549,
0.12906183302402496,
0.03984006121754646,
0.5973408222198486,
-0.5213736295700073,
0.39171892404556274,
-0.3563452959060669,
0.1104385033249855,
-0.11885728687047958,
-0.29028618335723877,
-0.15500257909297943,
-0.2816721498966217,
0.1435900181531906,
-0.7169613242149353,
-0.2239304929971695,
-0.022252723574638367,
0.5407050848007202,
0.36613160371780396,
-0.32300272583961487,
-0.48032906651496887,
-0.8660749793052673,
0.11719126999378204,
-0.843439519405365,
0.16855262219905853,
0.7637103796005249,
0.6304352879524231,
0.10566449165344238,
-0.6745362281799316,
-0.5070433616638184,
-0.3636745810508728,
-0.28695565462112427,
0.5513567328453064,
-0.0735965371131897,
0.23000258207321167,
-0.26176804304122925,
0.20190830528736115,
-0.3810577988624573,
0.22123956680297852,
0.02663327567279339,
0.031490471214056015,
0.39013776183128357,
0.363486647605896,
0.3579527735710144,
-0.3175504505634308,
-0.33174315094947815,
0.40206387639045715,
-0.4325716495513916,
-0.13269641995429993,
-0.225712850689888,
0.2818582355976105,
-0.3442591428756714,
0.7578980326652527,
0.02182650938630104,
0.5032848715782166,
0.10883165895938873,
-0.18949885666370392,
0.019948014989495277,
-0.572069525718689,
-0.29691118001937866,
0.40080517530441284,
0.6432055234909058,
0.5565735697746277,
0.1451096385717392,
-0.3367978632450104,
-0.17054785788059235,
-0.4632846415042877,
0.43091630935668945,
-0.874385416507721,
-0.47907400131225586,
0.6658778190612793,
-0.09629639238119125,
-0.11630710959434509,
-0.12689164280891418,
-0.9716242551803589,
-0.902213454246521,
-0.00338546559214592,
0.318263977766037,
-0.5443916916847229,
-0.23113428056240082,
0.19067397713661194,
0.03562392294406891,
0.08229900151491165,
0.5713095664978027,
-0.9971836805343628,
0.38305988907814026,
0.4119231402873993,
0.9111846685409546,
0.004141021519899368,
0.4728463292121887,
-0.7079902291297913,
0.5544143915176392,
-0.1071586012840271,
0.6821329593658447,
-0.5395524501800537,
-0.5137253403663635,
-0.022854609414935112,
-0.13276083767414093,
-0.057596758008003235,
-0.6257824301719666,
0.36173444986343384,
-0.5092535614967346,
-0.10526884347200394,
-0.4610976278781891,
-0.6588424444198608,
0.1177758052945137,
0.26156118512153625,
-0.6744053959846497,
0.42227280139923096,
0.3759708106517792,
-0.5549150705337524,
0.3192610442638397,
-0.8153446316719055,
-0.3773519992828369,
0.8438440561294556,
-0.24947497248649597,
-0.2322339415550232,
-0.1462838351726532,
0.2942492365837097,
0.36402952671051025,
-0.42055895924568176,
0.27078068256378174,
-0.24596458673477173,
0.22185081243515015,
0.13062526285648346,
0.0728958323597908,
0.36091575026512146,
0.14442993700504303,
-0.1611199826002121,
0.4369759261608124,
-0.6151424050331116,
0.01319078728556633,
0.2915140390396118,
-0.017376311123371124,
-0.7886931896209717,
-0.11469367146492004,
-0.19293171167373657,
-0.26607516407966614,
0.4219270944595337,
-0.3508400022983551,
0.04338756576180458,
-0.35765400528907776,
0.42282333970069885,
0.6477711796760559,
0.22927363216876984,
0.33630263805389404,
-0.32757413387298584,
0.6075223684310913,
-0.05855051428079605,
0.3283710181713104,
-0.0009287696448154747,
-0.7168177366256714,
-0.519974410533905,
-0.4031137526035309,
0.22309993207454681,
0.7622407078742981,
-0.6585232615470886,
0.8172263503074646,
-0.28638577461242676,
-0.560758650302887,
-0.5907667279243469,
0.054723821580410004,
0.039393506944179535,
0.9895868301391602,
0.6294350624084473,
-0.2251231074333191,
-0.19677293300628662,
-0.6327455639839172,
0.1643001139163971,
-0.09922395646572113,
0.0027862791903316975,
0.6553913950920105,
0.39777442812919617,
-0.4467065632343292,
1.1024032831192017,
-0.5405660271644592,
-0.2371041476726532,
-0.5760246515274048,
-0.43155983090400696,
-0.061353184282779694,
0.17604121565818787,
0.5913936495780945,
-0.6332100033760071,
-0.5315268039703369,
0.3564966917037964,
-0.892607569694519,
-0.25154879689216614,
0.04271018132567406,
-0.09691577404737473,
-0.5104354619979858,
0.08790113776922226,
-0.7026380896568298,
0.47209540009498596,
0.49383294582366943,
-0.47998735308647156,
0.5606762766838074,
-0.16035833954811096,
-0.015775613486766815,
-1.4152460098266602,
0.2997688949108124,
0.12998370826244354,
-0.5095952749252319,
-0.6915223598480225,
-0.3631375730037689,
0.25064539909362793,
-0.126728355884552,
-0.43106988072395325,
1.0061662197113037,
-0.015064236707985401,
0.07684024423360825,
-0.3073417544364929,
0.11410535126924515,
0.07565794885158539,
0.07657891511917114,
-0.002729995409026742,
0.6827825307846069,
0.3901098370552063,
-0.7046356797218323,
0.6840416789054871,
0.46068617701530457,
-0.4375641644001007,
0.8345267176628113,
-0.8087113499641418,
0.004621171858161688,
-0.024933213368058205,
0.19242432713508606,
-0.7820479273796082,
-0.49634450674057007,
0.6956427693367004,
-0.18414293229579926,
0.0441628023982048,
0.2739243507385254,
-0.348859965801239,
-0.21528340876102448,
-0.004877824801951647,
0.1572645902633667,
0.24473609030246735,
-0.39660489559173584,
0.5481094717979431,
0.5515984296798706,
-0.38069063425064087,
0.0671372339129448,
-0.5341182351112366,
0.2631250023841858,
-0.2138301134109497,
-0.5714995265007019,
0.39111024141311646,
-0.1753343641757965,
-0.6144080758094788,
0.2269725650548935,
-0.10992773622274399,
-0.010122005827724934,
0.008032436482608318,
0.24940457940101624,
0.12450828403234482,
0.026760749518871307,
0.23470091819763184,
-0.1351228952407837,
0.03815377876162529,
-0.030840672552585602,
-0.19758978486061096,
0.5667102932929993,
0.15573936700820923,
-0.3426792323589325,
-0.6197367310523987,
0.3751138746738434,
0.5586820840835571,
-0.3930218517780304,
0.7851789593696594,
0.4788760840892792,
-0.2741069495677948,
0.08840367943048477,
-0.3662099540233612,
-0.32959553599357605,
-0.43037375807762146,
0.2466023713350296,
-0.052766188979148865,
-0.5725539326667786,
0.6446606516838074,
0.01183786429464817,
0.014467057771980762,
0.0594983771443367,
0.5735586285591125,
-0.03017919883131981,
0.666678786277771,
0.4697688817977905,
-0.06248285248875618,
0.536813497543335,
0.06330134719610214,
-0.05741062015295029,
-0.8116746544837952,
-0.6769897937774658,
-0.28219345211982727,
-0.25089821219444275,
-0.014081776142120361,
-0.3873065412044525,
0.7625574469566345,
-0.2647542357444763,
-0.2233973741531372,
0.1525864154100418,
-0.03413879871368408,
0.10164846479892731,
0.29180893301963806,
0.6801844835281372,
0.23779937624931335,
-0.3166753947734833,
-0.23725296556949615,
0.20698872208595276,
-0.5260381102561951,
-0.3389433026313782,
0.8999319076538086,
0.31469660997390747,
1.049323558807373,
0.29858872294425964,
0.433401882648468,
0.49767887592315674,
0.46696028113365173,
-0.9934905171394348,
0.39470231533050537,
0.029481377452611923,
-0.26476696133613586,
-0.1679287999868393,
-0.7162487506866455,
-1.0128437280654907,
-0.05033539980649948,
-0.007102795876562595,
-0.8301377296447754,
-0.23572561144828796,
-0.0049613844603300095,
-0.7158792018890381,
0.23095804452896118,
-0.9940152764320374,
0.7348506450653076,
-0.7196635603904724,
-0.44045376777648926,
0.060513462871313095,
-0.6235438585281372,
0.16779769957065582,
-0.19303183257579803,
0.01467079482972622,
-0.07199923694133759,
-0.10689827054738998,
0.5127069354057312,
-0.7508447170257568,
0.9937233924865723,
-0.19146260619163513,
-0.3232748806476593,
0.06166860833764076,
-0.11652462184429169,
0.5970314145088196,
0.4852088391780853,
-0.11447840929031372,
-0.019176248461008072,
-0.15394173562526703,
-0.3450617790222168,
-0.8718671798706055,
0.7066054344177246,
-0.698205828666687,
-0.8315356373786926,
-0.08223532885313034,
-0.07748252153396606,
-0.7356317043304443,
0.2480924278497696,
-0.17021799087524414,
0.016326231881976128,
-0.3406434655189514,
-0.023749247193336487,
0.40406396985054016,
-0.25376370549201965,
0.042715851217508316,
0.7497048377990723,
-0.02115449868142605,
-0.6986348032951355,
0.4597921669483185,
-0.2538888156414032,
0.37363505363464355,
0.5961959362030029,
0.5237023830413818,
-0.1938759684562683,
-0.1872515082359314,
-0.3728877902030945,
0.24664191901683807,
-0.41184958815574646,
-0.276615709066391,
-0.5136926770210266,
-0.3600786626338959,
-0.5545431971549988,
-0.05162418633699417,
-0.20899207890033722,
0.13298271596431732,
-0.5967508554458618,
-0.23708531260490417,
0.5265836715698242,
0.6496797800064087,
0.1938856989145279,
0.3080599009990692,
-0.9334303736686707,
0.19916591048240662,
0.4510973393917084,
0.2657026946544647,
0.022996744140982628,
-0.031019220128655434,
-0.5039058327674866,
0.1298583447933197,
-0.24113591015338898,
-1.231459379196167,
0.519313633441925,
0.1732225865125656,
0.6153598427772522,
0.5438609719276428,
-0.09551256895065308,
0.5150938630104065,
-0.4296736419200897,
0.8383097052574158,
0.47134825587272644,
-0.6216323375701904,
0.7241801023483276,
0.015241417102515697,
0.4607528746128082,
0.5954887270927429,
0.35373422503471375,
-0.6540929675102234,
-0.33050960302352905,
-0.2228679060935974,
-0.5793840289115906,
0.2380811870098114,
0.08945706486701965,
0.07780848443508148,
0.004887833259999752,
0.38756972551345825,
0.19939735531806946,
0.21725952625274658,
-0.30559462308883667,
-0.0872155949473381,
-0.38781803846359253,
-0.34030386805534363,
-0.029744219034910202,
-0.07659419625997543,
-0.128936305642128,
-0.33040744066238403,
0.42595943808555603,
-0.29755187034606934,
0.1303146481513977,
0.3854018747806549,
0.137565016746521,
-0.20436984300613403,
0.2217865288257599,
0.3736906051635742,
0.5880575180053711,
-0.2424185872077942,
0.21438466012477875,
-0.10948958247900009,
-0.7847585082054138,
-0.31928256154060364,
0.150297611951828,
-0.030926253646612167,
-0.06976541876792908,
0.18049998581409454,
0.72196364402771,
0.35839036107063293,
-0.8000656366348267,
0.30035367608070374,
-0.1812897026538849,
-0.04098496586084366,
-0.24713218212127686,
0.23707281053066254,
0.09637980908155441,
0.20312146842479706,
0.06057964265346527,
-0.20158693194389343,
-0.07905171066522598,
-0.17765896022319794,
0.41575130820274353,
0.4864087700843811,
-0.6510006785392761,
-0.511090874671936,
0.8090365529060364,
0.719537079334259,
-0.2760692238807678,
0.3700195550918579,
-0.0027488048654049635,
-0.245454803109169,
0.5305153131484985,
0.5969839096069336,
0.7439635396003723,
-0.47558122873306274,
0.5644216537475586,
0.12471123039722443,
0.15635310113430023,
0.3114486336708069,
0.13084003329277039,
-0.07370156049728394,
-0.7579317688941956,
-0.2441026121377945,
-0.6433369517326355,
-0.7647849321365356,
0.3579792082309723,
-0.28722521662712097,
0.20907996594905853,
-0.4131318926811218,
-0.28979408740997314,
0.3798706829547882,
0.009905524551868439,
-0.6763306260108948,
-0.07294243574142456,
0.021658968180418015,
0.9733604192733765,
-0.4223732054233551,
0.7471824288368225,
0.8747903108596802,
-0.5698254108428955,
-0.5995700359344482,
0.1944543421268463,
-0.08299509435892105,
-1.1351690292358398,
0.23682555556297302,
-0.16589900851249695,
0.11532798409461975,
-0.13784553110599518,
-0.40503719449043274,
-0.6402302384376526,
1.1657829284667969,
0.6146140694618225,
-0.4131944477558136,
-0.02327623963356018,
0.38269904255867004,
0.5114585161209106,
-0.29772186279296875,
0.38229069113731384,
0.44328391551971436,
0.6982496380805969,
0.31884893774986267,
-1.0906797647476196,
0.019890472292900085,
-0.05134163051843643,
-0.46954336762428284,
0.012279185466468334,
-0.9154002070426941,
0.4587912857532501,
-0.42509716749191284,
-0.020745771005749702,
0.011147835291922092,
0.5032066106796265,
-0.07508573681116104,
0.4395817518234253,
0.3361585736274719,
0.39740636944770813,
1.0776338577270508,
0.47687917947769165,
0.8745599389076233,
-0.44827499985694885,
-0.021883513778448105,
1.035630226135254,
-0.6741283535957336,
0.18747146427631378,
0.2428295910358429,
-0.1412770003080368,
0.26383695006370544,
0.6852080225944519,
0.22276541590690613,
0.5797977447509766,
0.02022692747414112,
-0.7381616830825806,
-0.22691483795642853,
-0.5117542147636414,
-0.22013379633426666,
0.5506981611251831,
0.5404931902885437,
-0.5463492274284363,
-0.3566924035549164,
0.05603208392858505,
0.18667873740196228,
-0.06540422141551971,
-0.46197617053985596,
0.8855146169662476,
0.2816753089427948,
-0.31077831983566284,
0.3642924129962921,
-0.15144412219524384,
0.15526528656482697,
-0.8142809867858887,
-0.167693629860878,
-0.32483208179473877,
-0.10025136172771454,
-0.2892321050167084,
-0.6887211203575134,
0.17611832916736603,
-0.02705252729356289,
0.10326790809631348,
-0.06727854907512665,
0.7028796672821045,
-0.5039852261543274,
-0.21528039872646332,
0.09751772880554199,
0.8424211740493774,
-0.02666802704334259,
-0.06717785447835922,
-0.569115400314331,
-0.31993013620376587,
-0.26036524772644043,
0.021725427359342575,
0.22275128960609436,
0.38370153307914734,
0.20018203556537628,
0.7590007781982422,
0.45746302604675293,
0.44817250967025757,
-0.45961374044418335,
0.08690480887889862,
0.8721140027046204,
-0.5962690114974976,
-0.5038054585456848,
-0.881544828414917,
0.14626692235469818,
-0.136625275015831,
-0.1439780294895172,
0.8052521347999573,
0.499074786901474,
0.008379301987588406,
-0.07102592289447784,
0.9862009882926941,
0.08321913331747055,
0.09535982459783554,
-0.6607694625854492,
0.863117516040802,
-0.6072649955749512,
0.20326808094978333,
-0.0035611989442259073,
-0.48783883452415466,
-0.298164427280426,
0.1941300630569458,
-0.3329189121723175,
0.15328562259674072,
0.5640134811401367,
0.4702497124671936,
0.02504820004105568,
0.19286757707595825,
0.50673508644104,
0.23426365852355957,
0.6973474621772766,
0.5508855581283569,
0.31274133920669556,
0.2893413007259369,
0.03455016762018204,
0.1715867519378662,
-0.467121958732605,
-0.43602344393730164,
-0.42833003401756287,
-0.7513551115989685,
-0.4102139472961426,
-0.053839925676584244,
-0.2543325424194336,
0.17600023746490479,
0.9511329531669617,
0.7930071353912354,
-0.5788840651512146,
0.2068762183189392,
-0.03814099729061127,
0.19911357760429382,
-0.22787366807460785,
-0.22350174188613892,
0.19703727960586548,
-0.2456217110157013,
-0.42084208130836487,
0.6229198575019836,
0.3259681165218353,
0.10354964435100555,
-0.4922170639038086,
-0.02665102481842041,
0.1515905112028122,
0.23317086696624756,
0.5152080059051514,
0.24289971590042114,
-0.11555148661136627,
-0.28687500953674316,
0.02358611673116684,
-0.2729407846927643,
0.24232269823551178,
0.694992184638977,
-0.6680042147636414,
0.7295958399772644,
-0.08735613524913788,
0.6664193868637085,
0.3107498586177826,
0.056668221950531006,
0.44080305099487305,
-0.6332768201828003,
-0.17262199521064758,
0.6516537070274353,
0.35773205757141113,
0.23282372951507568,
-0.6186832189559937,
0.27051323652267456,
0.31581518054008484,
-0.48109889030456543,
-0.16350653767585754,
0.11809199303388596,
-1.224134922027588,
-0.003993011079728603,
1.679451823234558,
-0.00511195557191968,
-0.5418190956115723,
-0.2606290578842163,
-0.32312679290771484,
-0.01562958024442196,
-0.7801173329353333,
0.7601271271705627,
0.44189250469207764,
-0.4788050651550293,
0.03196147456765175,
-0.7748426198959351,
0.4952600300312042,
0.11210054159164429,
-1.5050157308578491,
-0.015575308352708817,
0.4058240056037903,
0.38054656982421875,
0.024768998846411705,
0.9795060753822327,
0.11946844309568405,
-0.06145874410867691,
-0.3307853043079376,
-0.03662314638495445,
-0.1267036497592926,
-0.061763424426317215,
0.27617087960243225,
-0.04399969056248665,
-0.19430126249790192,
-0.20056205987930298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10151v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10151v1 | ControlLM: Crafting Diverse Personalities for Language Models | 2024-02-15T17:58:29 | 2024-02-15T17:58:29 | Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Shengping Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | As language models continue to scale in size and capability, they display an
array of emerging behaviors, both beneficial and concerning. This heightens the
need to control model behaviors. We hope to be able to control the personality
traits of language models at the inference-time so as to have various character
features, on top of which the requirements of different types of tasks can be
met. Personality is a higher-level and more abstract behavioral representation
for language models. We introduce ControlLM, which leverages differential
activation patterns, derived from contrasting behavioral prompts in the model's
latent space, to influence the model's personality traits at inference. This
approach allows for the precise, real-time adjustment of model behavior. First,
we demonstrate ControlLM's capacity to elicit diverse persona behaviors without
any training, while precision control allows personality traits to closely
match average human values. Subsequently, we showcase improved reasoning and
question answering through selective amplification of beneficial attributes
like conscientiousness and friendliness. We hope that this work will inspire
research on controlling human-like behaviors of language models and provide
insights for future research. Our code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/wengsyx/ControlLM. | [
-0.27514025568962097,
-0.8885374665260315,
0.41782987117767334,
0.6432509422302246,
0.15334805846214294,
0.41265591979026794,
-0.1553533375263214,
-0.3001617193222046,
0.15334472060203552,
0.48900607228279114,
-0.5515486001968384,
-0.3556756377220154,
-0.5183662176132202,
-0.266387403011322,
-0.18519803881645203,
0.8352593779563904,
0.05646122992038727,
0.07499081641435623,
0.007299997843801975,
-0.1180950477719307,
-0.3692818880081177,
-0.9083066582679749,
-0.7301265001296997,
-0.5049776434898376,
0.9320639967918396,
0.18547409772872925,
0.6669746041297913,
0.37223392724990845,
0.15367121994495392,
0.22068369388580322,
-0.04714910686016083,
0.08776850253343582,
-0.5340676307678223,
0.4019031822681427,
-0.30970942974090576,
-0.34594711661338806,
-0.7096892595291138,
0.06683224439620972,
0.6550664305686951,
0.7499620318412781,
-0.1284637749195099,
-0.059152379631996155,
-0.027773752808570862,
0.4851056635379791,
-0.4915808141231537,
0.030912965536117554,
-0.4122958481311798,
-0.14733915030956268,
-0.4144124388694763,
0.1562320739030838,
-0.5871735215187073,
-0.35283762216567993,
-0.08355756849050522,
-0.2770776152610779,
-0.09534836560487747,
0.26252153515815735,
0.5519641637802124,
0.0833439975976944,
-0.5399072170257568,
0.08542128652334213,
-0.956540584564209,
1.0162124633789062,
-0.6541328430175781,
0.3547848165035248,
0.4798746407032013,
0.36165347695350647,
-0.11422236263751984,
-0.3968692123889923,
-0.47942882776260376,
-0.38415226340293884,
-0.20397575199604034,
-0.11949606239795685,
-0.05635492503643036,
-0.04214615002274513,
0.3867528438568115,
0.06610102206468582,
-0.6058977842330933,
0.23796045780181885,
0.05836882069706917,
-0.22864149510860443,
0.8134037256240845,
0.46311286091804504,
0.3941290080547333,
0.3562542200088501,
0.22331278026103973,
-0.05448167771100998,
-0.5289250016212463,
0.3530922830104828,
0.6679064631462097,
0.3087042570114136,
-0.3024844229221344,
0.5304263234138489,
-0.3884405195713043,
0.6587167978286743,
0.21651843190193176,
0.043526843190193176,
0.06450379639863968,
0.07043211162090302,
-0.26642847061157227,
-0.343680202960968,
0.4561721384525299,
0.125625878572464,
0.17265687882900238,
-0.045220181345939636,
-0.13167200982570648,
0.04003500938415527,
0.3772421181201935,
-0.584614098072052,
-0.27428707480430603,
0.46034008264541626,
-0.5591066479682922,
-0.5120870471000671,
-0.0485570915043354,
-0.8425140976905823,
-0.49593257904052734,
-0.5275787711143494,
0.05135241523385048,
-0.38471248745918274,
-0.588444173336029,
-0.09813202917575836,
-0.06292961537837982,
0.38818877935409546,
0.4404405951499939,
-1.1883795261383057,
0.5065558552742004,
0.4812127351760864,
0.5433022379875183,
-0.5931769609451294,
-0.2848148047924042,
-0.7194015979766846,
0.06753220409154892,
-0.29900509119033813,
0.29624199867248535,
-1.1238094568252563,
-0.36946573853492737,
-0.11096734553575516,
-0.19405421614646912,
0.020029237493872643,
-0.4535179138183594,
0.14983853697776794,
-0.7043018341064453,
0.10967323184013367,
-0.3488742709159851,
-0.293163925409317,
-0.010740173980593681,
0.20855793356895447,
-0.5462630391120911,
0.8643755316734314,
0.4148167073726654,
-0.5374231934547424,
0.07662738114595413,
-0.8225893974304199,
-0.5786452293395996,
0.026592211797833443,
-0.17750556766986847,
-0.22218139469623566,
0.11337301880121231,
-0.20380210876464844,
0.31661751866340637,
0.12742483615875244,
0.3357098400592804,
-0.46382585167884827,
-0.03698517754673958,
0.5321542024612427,
-0.07718271017074585,
0.9605056047439575,
0.16489434242248535,
-0.2638981342315674,
0.6814754009246826,
-0.6729332804679871,
0.15236249566078186,
0.06597956269979477,
-0.19769321382045746,
-0.4130411744117737,
0.17840418219566345,
0.27920183539390564,
0.3364892303943634,
0.3843376934528351,
-0.3070114850997925,
0.27447354793548584,
-0.0553998164832592,
0.11347772181034088,
0.7318581342697144,
-0.08315130323171616,
0.6862534284591675,
-0.519916832447052,
0.6404592990875244,
-0.03962066397070885,
0.3862609565258026,
0.24829986691474915,
-0.32219141721725464,
-0.5231389999389648,
-0.3580314517021179,
-0.19778025150299072,
0.603980541229248,
-0.2653465270996094,
0.6091338992118835,
0.32109344005584717,
-0.7531707286834717,
-0.26585182547569275,
0.21674877405166626,
0.4503462314605713,
0.30848413705825806,
0.3037976324558258,
-0.25815823674201965,
-0.5434996485710144,
-0.6299912929534912,
-0.34598153829574585,
-0.10121536254882812,
-0.26050302386283875,
0.41217657923698425,
0.27684593200683594,
-0.18938730657100677,
0.9746006727218628,
-0.5280659198760986,
0.19233158230781555,
-0.6084729433059692,
0.010968891903758049,
0.008746600709855556,
0.6396801471710205,
0.6890947222709656,
-0.9562644362449646,
-0.5653226375579834,
-0.12450968474149704,
-0.466659277677536,
-0.48162052035331726,
-0.14537370204925537,
-0.5060328245162964,
0.19529742002487183,
0.46338579058647156,
-0.4412066340446472,
0.22151049971580505,
0.6062712669372559,
-0.8223323822021484,
0.9064576625823975,
-0.0473216287791729,
-0.17414137721061707,
-0.564271867275238,
0.4043866991996765,
-0.19683849811553955,
-0.2690069377422333,
-0.8832091093063354,
0.08688430488109589,
0.05554933100938797,
0.15732385218143463,
-0.3978275954723358,
0.9393592476844788,
-0.13713568449020386,
0.10821401327848434,
-0.12387906014919281,
-0.2140287607908249,
0.1499834656715393,
0.731478750705719,
0.14319048821926117,
0.41701963543891907,
0.6516232490539551,
-0.8041552305221558,
0.5039463043212891,
0.122703418135643,
-0.04422835633158684,
0.6060508489608765,
-0.6086475253105164,
0.13369473814964294,
-0.15739604830741882,
-0.016856931149959564,
-0.7127091884613037,
-0.36104339361190796,
0.19248010218143463,
-0.17327184975147247,
0.43997922539711,
0.26403912901878357,
-0.27319231629371643,
-0.08164624124765396,
-0.0074342601001262665,
-0.16234660148620605,
0.737388014793396,
-0.11104470491409302,
0.8304633498191833,
0.3801915943622589,
-0.4229539632797241,
-0.24486199021339417,
-0.6334087252616882,
-0.30981066823005676,
-0.30500394105911255,
-0.029933171346783638,
0.34883370995521545,
-0.6434486508369446,
-0.8398783206939697,
-0.29180237650871277,
0.0017274668207392097,
0.03684482350945473,
0.3427605628967285,
0.24208831787109375,
0.17728663980960846,
0.11590662598609924,
0.17868995666503906,
0.46648186445236206,
0.01364232785999775,
-0.11877799779176712,
-0.2609224021434784,
0.9841189980506897,
-0.11446923017501831,
-0.47211524844169617,
-0.2803623676300049,
0.6021904349327087,
0.7862427830696106,
-0.5662710666656494,
0.7567539811134338,
0.4294854402542114,
-0.06798320263624191,
-0.1458526998758316,
-0.38525861501693726,
-0.3928612172603607,
-0.4522300362586975,
0.3372783064842224,
-0.4769422709941864,
-1.0726490020751953,
0.8647277355194092,
0.17894276976585388,
0.06199733167886734,
0.018715092912316322,
0.8160601854324341,
-0.02924683690071106,
1.249561071395874,
0.7125311493873596,
0.00881247129291296,
0.7773628830909729,
0.25088033080101013,
0.058710768818855286,
-0.8021862506866455,
-0.3102136552333832,
-0.42920762300491333,
-0.525981068611145,
-0.4748656451702118,
-0.2424226850271225,
-0.11313830316066742,
-0.02139684185385704,
-0.6612846255302429,
-0.02214558981359005,
-0.3553757667541504,
0.19937236607074738,
0.5161487460136414,
0.09115367382764816,
0.17348279058933258,
-0.32181787490844727,
-0.28676626086235046,
-0.3184802532196045,
-0.27868276834487915,
-0.619010865688324,
0.8696692585945129,
0.3711787164211273,
1.059024691581726,
0.39441949129104614,
0.31517738103866577,
0.3733251690864563,
0.475341260433197,
-0.49407848715782166,
0.4803432524204254,
-0.27792322635650635,
-0.6529909372329712,
-0.48819202184677124,
-0.20834898948669434,
-0.6364165544509888,
0.13002486526966095,
-0.00456889858469367,
-1.015634536743164,
0.15124893188476562,
0.40553516149520874,
-0.25204211473464966,
0.16001102328300476,
-0.5747392773628235,
0.9355340600013733,
-0.562610924243927,
-0.5009116530418396,
-0.18800103664398193,
-0.750617265701294,
0.2626533508300781,
-0.10794389992952347,
-0.13987062871456146,
-0.33436504006385803,
-0.024339836090803146,
0.33983325958251953,
-0.18684911727905273,
1.205942153930664,
-0.3255399763584137,
-0.16422238945960999,
-0.07763472944498062,
0.5365965962409973,
0.49131983518600464,
0.023568689823150635,
-0.33259737491607666,
0.001058823661878705,
0.06461106240749359,
-0.6105459332466125,
-0.7562471628189087,
0.6128213405609131,
-0.7987546324729919,
-0.5026123523712158,
-0.04293389618396759,
-0.7107370495796204,
-0.37341222167015076,
0.33595508337020874,
-0.04181757941842079,
0.2680569589138031,
-0.4019436836242676,
0.07822616398334503,
0.6580053567886353,
-0.3488829731941223,
0.3233531415462494,
0.6471623778343201,
-0.7431829571723938,
0.01546790823340416,
0.7100842595100403,
-0.26256197690963745,
0.5728586316108704,
0.654780387878418,
0.24878744781017303,
-0.20352977514266968,
-0.41695958375930786,
-0.07124968618154526,
0.08233990520238876,
-0.43188658356666565,
0.2909923791885376,
-0.7929156422615051,
-0.1521867960691452,
-0.5558454990386963,
-0.19707390666007996,
-0.21883846819400787,
-0.22242394089698792,
-0.3230113089084625,
0.17272980511188507,
0.3208129107952118,
0.6543283462524414,
0.353353351354599,
0.5748141407966614,
-0.4802565574645996,
0.12547236680984497,
0.5131251811981201,
0.4776030480861664,
-0.0558454692363739,
-0.36393463611602783,
0.08957865089178085,
-0.14442473649978638,
-0.21268408000469208,
-0.8781227469444275,
0.6371643543243408,
0.15133225917816162,
0.8346243500709534,
0.5032991766929626,
0.0637100413441658,
0.19806846976280212,
-0.4461100995540619,
0.649106502532959,
-0.21692828834056854,
-1.1149218082427979,
0.6237694621086121,
-0.3298459053039551,
0.487336128950119,
0.2712537944316864,
0.2829691469669342,
-0.8480247855186462,
-0.8737912178039551,
-0.6340538263320923,
-0.2964842617511749,
0.6271035671234131,
-0.00807615090161562,
0.4154376685619354,
0.22434227168560028,
0.24691542983055115,
0.22522617876529694,
0.3865881562232971,
-0.5999570488929749,
-0.3123938739299774,
-0.4077269434928894,
-0.33811405301094055,
-0.007145005743950605,
-0.28568610548973083,
-0.2951054573059082,
-0.28315556049346924,
0.43522533774375916,
-0.29309239983558655,
-0.003998374566435814,
-0.1265941560268402,
0.0707944855093956,
-0.06534459441900253,
0.33233755826950073,
0.8043336868286133,
0.6551150679588318,
-0.1950484961271286,
0.315308541059494,
0.004433368798345327,
-0.45228272676467896,
0.031702131032943726,
-0.015308666974306107,
-0.2587565779685974,
-0.12649968266487122,
0.11556693911552429,
0.9799439311027527,
0.009743571281433105,
-0.7084694504737854,
0.11230143159627914,
-0.11380328238010406,
0.06571649014949799,
-0.1573757380247116,
0.5142619013786316,
0.11542156338691711,
0.3303249180316925,
0.20116569101810455,
0.1678275465965271,
-0.2075449526309967,
-0.22614015638828278,
0.11004159599542618,
0.46137765049934387,
-0.3747486472129822,
-0.5089147686958313,
0.7083086967468262,
0.20377197861671448,
-0.47578078508377075,
0.4335794746875763,
-0.3715939223766327,
-0.41888460516929626,
0.5714383721351624,
0.7318747043609619,
0.8118702173233032,
-0.5013364553451538,
0.3159015476703644,
0.12064765393733978,
0.13804128766059875,
0.1832864135503769,
0.5115662813186646,
-0.008222782053053379,
-1.0818558931350708,
-0.478514701128006,
-0.7331445813179016,
-0.6672802567481995,
0.27800875902175903,
-0.4518510699272156,
0.21723859012126923,
-0.8265078663825989,
0.0778178796172142,
-0.22744157910346985,
0.008599509485065937,
-0.4006776809692383,
0.07091536372900009,
0.03946329280734062,
0.9818083643913269,
-0.884576141834259,
1.1727793216705322,
0.7430774569511414,
-0.1742449551820755,
-0.7330520153045654,
-0.09052293747663498,
0.22179031372070312,
-0.4646759033203125,
0.9179526567459106,
-0.0666046291589737,
0.016605036333203316,
0.2671513855457306,
-0.8234352469444275,
-0.761443555355072,
0.8128484487533569,
0.26048702001571655,
-0.5405058860778809,
-0.06515670567750931,
-0.28802135586738586,
0.5927184224128723,
-0.5646862387657166,
0.05481189116835594,
0.7028694152832031,
0.6665971279144287,
0.1681467741727829,
-0.7579107880592346,
0.018421782180666924,
-0.375950425863266,
0.05961675941944122,
0.01499298308044672,
-0.5010219812393188,
0.91434645652771,
-0.13493798673152924,
0.11218919605016708,
-0.0638822540640831,
0.5736542344093323,
0.6131011247634888,
0.03520452231168747,
0.47740721702575684,
0.1302698254585266,
0.9869554042816162,
0.03404660150408745,
0.9440996646881104,
-0.21725104749202728,
-0.024130254983901978,
1.294985055923462,
-0.6744840741157532,
0.678229808807373,
0.4896060526371002,
-0.28615322709083557,
0.7822896242141724,
0.4649309515953064,
0.023184360936284065,
0.4555843770503998,
0.1476098895072937,
-0.4526229500770569,
-0.3840419054031372,
-0.05749177932739258,
0.061998434364795685,
0.5269108414649963,
0.5742496848106384,
-0.1935684084892273,
0.061411499977111816,
0.24328084290027618,
0.13735869526863098,
0.2892577052116394,
-0.13161486387252808,
0.5405898690223694,
-0.1528797298669815,
-0.5974231362342834,
0.07759778201580048,
-0.060288917273283005,
0.7543129324913025,
-0.9128782153129578,
0.11997473984956741,
-0.32694292068481445,
0.1036079153418541,
-0.03538365289568901,
-0.6464763879776001,
0.5662811994552612,
-0.12548299133777618,
-0.23191632330417633,
-0.6632681488990784,
0.737903356552124,
-0.6550023555755615,
-0.1470717340707779,
0.30146241188049316,
0.5643742084503174,
0.0693998783826828,
-0.21343548595905304,
-0.5194946527481079,
0.19805458188056946,
-0.00006460236909333616,
-0.25826704502105713,
0.314073771238327,
0.10764583945274353,
-0.514885663986206,
0.7444818019866943,
0.6877570748329163,
0.3649410903453827,
0.08662550896406174,
0.30503028631210327,
0.7176497578620911,
-0.5908310413360596,
-0.5748016238212585,
-1.020231008529663,
0.6824153661727905,
-0.24427641928195953,
-0.1929960697889328,
0.6064110994338989,
0.24875754117965698,
0.6678523421287537,
-0.45689448714256287,
0.9232075810432434,
-0.5332130789756775,
0.585360586643219,
-0.2993794083595276,
1.0112907886505127,
-0.4051004946231842,
-0.07833597809076309,
-0.025963932275772095,
-0.6449933052062988,
-0.553726315498352,
0.4063572287559509,
-0.38429924845695496,
0.16990423202514648,
0.4502771496772766,
0.8344151973724365,
0.17765049636363983,
-0.31615909934043884,
0.5810720920562744,
0.24349772930145264,
0.7457804679870605,
0.34701791405677795,
0.6891065239906311,
0.4040052592754364,
0.11736227571964264,
-0.20553405582904816,
-0.407571017742157,
-0.4071640372276306,
-0.9623829126358032,
-0.8905421495437622,
-0.49327608942985535,
-0.2768810987472534,
-0.24085725843906403,
-0.3992250859737396,
0.8645968437194824,
0.8657310605049133,
-1.0758056640625,
-0.24975843727588654,
-0.22843457758426666,
0.4787726104259491,
-0.5113717913627625,
-0.28526708483695984,
-0.05441579222679138,
-0.5060536861419678,
-0.954620897769928,
0.14030182361602783,
0.43400171399116516,
0.21906183660030365,
-0.5354734063148499,
-0.2533603310585022,
-0.22047723829746246,
0.003046663710847497,
0.6228543519973755,
0.5169894695281982,
-0.8120023012161255,
-0.277397483587265,
0.30214923620224,
-0.4351882040500641,
-0.20369194447994232,
1.0895851850509644,
-0.45873984694480896,
0.4305737018585205,
0.5770647525787354,
0.3427581787109375,
0.22268761694431305,
-0.051620468497276306,
0.7725322246551514,
-0.998525857925415,
0.369221031665802,
0.35345515608787537,
0.07418616861104965,
0.3588218092918396,
-0.43165305256843567,
0.07482872158288956,
0.14221808314323425,
-0.4577018916606903,
-0.5085904598236084,
0.5727896094322205,
-1.1229203939437866,
-0.2800561487674713,
1.012608289718628,
-0.021403754130005836,
-0.09870998561382294,
-0.23612140119075775,
-0.553154706954956,
0.2832603454589844,
-0.4060213267803192,
0.6872455477714539,
0.7594537734985352,
-0.5527430772781372,
-0.47797122597694397,
-0.3569372892379761,
0.693681538105011,
0.4594951570034027,
-1.0477691888809204,
0.30993494391441345,
0.44795453548431396,
0.1736341416835785,
0.2002059370279312,
0.6814939975738525,
-0.11913849413394928,
-0.1163809671998024,
-0.30750638246536255,
0.3090614676475525,
0.04027490317821503,
-0.22141169011592865,
-0.4117256700992584,
0.08002402633428574,
0.32397565245628357,
0.18466299772262573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10137v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10137v3 | TOAD: Task-Oriented Automatic Dialogs with Diverse Response Styles | 2024-02-15T17:40:02 | 2024-06-06T20:18:11 | Yinhong Liu, Yimai Fang, David Vandyke, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL | In light of recent advances in large language models (LLMs), the expectations
for the next generation of virtual assistants include enhanced naturalness and
adaptability across diverse usage scenarios. However, the creation of
high-quality annotated data for Task-Oriented Dialog (TOD) is recognized to be
slow and costly. To address these challenges, we introduce Task-Oriented
Automatic Dialogs (TOAD), a novel and scalable TOD dataset along with its
automatic generation pipeline. The TOAD dataset simulates realistic app context
interaction and provide a variety of system response style options. Two aspects
of system response styles are considered, verbosity level and users' expression
mirroring. We benchmark TOAD on two response generation tasks, and the results
show that modeling more verbose responses or responses without user expression
mirroring is more challenging. | [
-0.37535712122917175,
-0.805473268032074,
0.34678661823272705,
0.4610867202281952,
-0.09839042276144028,
-0.011696298606693745,
0.09087896347045898,
-0.3637952506542206,
0.35741886496543884,
0.8231143355369568,
-0.854499101638794,
-0.1565716564655304,
-0.25297078490257263,
0.3866110146045685,
-0.3094741702079773,
0.976946234703064,
0.11396899074316025,
-0.016690876334905624,
-0.24873028695583344,
-0.07149921357631683,
-0.8976492285728455,
-0.38568341732025146,
-0.8365288376808167,
0.062453482300043106,
0.22998110949993134,
0.4503666162490845,
0.4805954396724701,
0.4625045657157898,
0.4232633709907532,
0.36109715700149536,
0.4984533488750458,
0.4181605279445648,
-0.2992927134037018,
0.7599854469299316,
0.09482309967279434,
-0.13745591044425964,
-0.8473040461540222,
-0.34415319561958313,
0.3423435091972351,
0.3536839187145233,
-0.05762171000242233,
0.1379723995923996,
0.028371315449476242,
0.49673277139663696,
-0.3661949336528778,
0.43059778213500977,
-0.7353523373603821,
-0.0314650759100914,
-0.0597471222281456,
-0.030821572989225388,
-0.44216910004615784,
0.023389523848891258,
0.3833627700805664,
-0.8181549906730652,
0.09649504721164703,
0.25269487500190735,
0.6344591379165649,
0.18742454051971436,
-0.609131932258606,
-0.38541391491889954,
-0.6566736698150635,
0.6830923557281494,
-0.6316899657249451,
0.15654145181179047,
0.1428501307964325,
0.45449015498161316,
-0.10289913415908813,
-0.4993363320827484,
-0.7222110033035278,
-0.09462188929319382,
-0.07683856785297394,
0.0946873351931572,
-0.040631361305713654,
0.09168413281440735,
0.122801274061203,
0.20896032452583313,
-0.6829094886779785,
-0.14900924265384674,
0.02632720023393631,
-0.3387446105480194,
0.7074946761131287,
0.7706884741783142,
0.21672025322914124,
-0.41581016778945923,
-0.2389409989118576,
-0.09789209067821503,
-0.30885443091392517,
-0.053627368062734604,
0.17507584393024445,
0.696031391620636,
0.0049682180397212505,
0.5272316932678223,
-0.5191530585289001,
0.9919509291648865,
0.004459348041564226,
-0.053044699132442474,
0.058235034346580505,
-0.6591200828552246,
-0.23391316831111908,
-0.22014372050762177,
0.9173937439918518,
0.7312818765640259,
0.253927081823349,
-0.08221220970153809,
-0.518857479095459,
-0.17551742494106293,
0.443782776594162,
-0.5494418740272522,
-0.08187799900770187,
0.366678386926651,
-0.21014975011348724,
-0.2028428614139557,
-0.3227740526199341,
-1.0376758575439453,
-0.5829254984855652,
-0.5156916379928589,
0.36000874638557434,
-0.2527458965778351,
-0.08828103542327881,
-0.23368073999881744,
0.15035195648670197,
0.17105108499526978,
0.8516732454299927,
-0.6917139887809753,
0.6315351128578186,
0.579264223575592,
0.7956722378730774,
-0.43508651852607727,
-0.06687704473733902,
-0.9839521050453186,
0.20085106790065765,
-0.14580197632312775,
0.6500061750411987,
-0.6575109958648682,
-0.8315169811248779,
-0.07135479152202606,
0.06636612117290497,
-0.0010267052566632628,
-0.4817304015159607,
0.22514870762825012,
-0.33872750401496887,
0.4623960852622986,
-0.3638596534729004,
-0.24101869761943817,
0.10763474553823471,
0.2419876903295517,
-0.45257577300071716,
0.8684470653533936,
0.2719445824623108,
-0.5799268484115601,
0.43123915791511536,
-0.8786470890045166,
-0.45795077085494995,
0.0719352662563324,
0.12516997754573822,
-0.19944977760314941,
0.13345901668071747,
0.14194607734680176,
0.3069072961807251,
-0.444040983915329,
0.14347289502620697,
-0.3639046847820282,
-0.15459808707237244,
-0.019545795395970345,
-0.09743989259004593,
0.511476457118988,
0.3719871938228607,
-0.38901376724243164,
0.377223938703537,
-0.8725573420524597,
0.11151279509067535,
0.15302565693855286,
0.04127915948629379,
-0.3056778311729431,
-0.07235087454319,
0.13937611877918243,
0.2573007047176361,
0.3510804772377014,
-0.7206358313560486,
0.5530980825424194,
0.024938251823186874,
0.38439682126045227,
0.9614749550819397,
-0.19887109100818634,
0.1407213807106018,
-0.09639881551265717,
0.302941232919693,
0.1269160658121109,
0.26679447293281555,
-0.3111216723918915,
-0.44492173194885254,
-0.721775233745575,
-0.33722883462905884,
-0.1396213322877884,
0.6395785212516785,
-0.8175790905952454,
-0.010341494344174862,
-0.3295851945877075,
-0.24830570816993713,
-0.3295530080795288,
0.11886750161647797,
0.5435342192649841,
0.8537793755531311,
0.06589140743017197,
-0.595853328704834,
-0.6022483706474304,
-1.0685478448867798,
-0.16221381723880768,
-0.5746813416481018,
-0.18477682769298553,
1.0126861333847046,
0.21998600661754608,
-0.29723721742630005,
1.2362123727798462,
-0.46855905652046204,
-0.11687463521957397,
-0.12694934010505676,
0.33204588294029236,
-0.20475885272026062,
0.18492554128170013,
0.5148226022720337,
-0.8023986220359802,
-0.6050655841827393,
-0.11613036692142487,
-0.48648878931999207,
-0.5332848429679871,
-0.0951835885643959,
-0.10492420941591263,
0.5304147601127625,
-0.028684595599770546,
-0.6382553577423096,
0.019103042781352997,
0.5049397349357605,
-0.457405686378479,
0.4681731164455414,
0.012741677463054657,
0.34267333149909973,
-1.2957290410995483,
-0.0277105662971735,
0.12579424679279327,
-0.3623155355453491,
-0.7389148473739624,
-0.2848174571990967,
-0.19857710599899292,
-0.3309149146080017,
-0.39026641845703125,
1.0426572561264038,
-0.2931375205516815,
-0.5065334439277649,
-0.2906821072101593,
0.07629407197237015,
0.014394895173609257,
0.6048779487609863,
0.2963961958885193,
1.159544825553894,
0.41471248865127563,
-0.5396320223808289,
0.5576285719871521,
0.24825721979141235,
0.33218833804130554,
0.790248692035675,
-0.9120238423347473,
0.21566224098205566,
0.049523357301950455,
0.43349459767341614,
-1.1209793090820312,
-0.7052022814750671,
0.11309508979320526,
-0.13316398859024048,
0.12468171119689941,
-0.058748405426740646,
-0.6807906031608582,
-0.36480605602264404,
-0.350988507270813,
0.06913810968399048,
0.4471431076526642,
-0.22302548587322235,
0.8440355062484741,
0.35780608654022217,
-0.4182996153831482,
-0.1790618896484375,
-0.21475592255592346,
0.22116173803806305,
-0.31948891282081604,
-0.5449169278144836,
-0.16530799865722656,
-0.027139754965901375,
-0.37840667366981506,
-0.36643627285957336,
-0.10264080762863159,
-0.2902834117412567,
0.0033677516039460897,
0.41068771481513977,
0.41526973247528076,
-0.0766020268201828,
0.06845776736736298,
-0.07328889518976212,
0.10621215403079987,
-0.05997461825609207,
-0.19328659772872925,
0.6461553573608398,
-0.31319519877433777,
-0.33300361037254333,
-0.47201311588287354,
0.535358190536499,
1.0057134628295898,
-0.058028075844049454,
0.33992910385131836,
0.36383941769599915,
-0.078083835542202,
0.20062485337257385,
-0.4814845025539398,
-0.3117261230945587,
-0.47543781995773315,
0.32628342509269714,
-0.5344575047492981,
-0.5536788105964661,
0.4704784154891968,
0.1541322022676468,
0.5830029845237732,
0.1652028113603592,
0.5859069228172302,
-0.11392106860876083,
1.3013542890548706,
0.44981685280799866,
0.05442167446017265,
0.5503894686698914,
0.1938304752111435,
0.1525965929031372,
-0.8034808039665222,
-0.09457337111234665,
-0.37986475229263306,
-0.1365819126367569,
-0.6199209690093994,
-0.2682406008243561,
0.3903115689754486,
-0.36316412687301636,
-0.36442500352859497,
0.47331154346466064,
-0.4763447642326355,
-0.15228502452373505,
0.6192508339881897,
-0.11824192106723785,
0.38878539204597473,
-0.20437030494213104,
0.4749928116798401,
-0.05427185446023941,
-0.394308865070343,
-0.7338674664497375,
1.2759270668029785,
0.07503240555524826,
0.8120449781417847,
0.23320618271827698,
0.6547898650169373,
0.31454288959503174,
0.3859085440635681,
-0.6589331030845642,
0.8805729746818542,
-0.06602568924427032,
-0.42032602429389954,
-0.463511198759079,
-0.37608054280281067,
-0.6632360816001892,
0.1254795640707016,
0.018097085878252983,
-1.0926531553268433,
-0.139396071434021,
0.5489089488983154,
-0.1814681440591812,
0.03589184582233429,
-1.0309348106384277,
0.607109010219574,
-0.1138983741402626,
-0.5328424572944641,
0.1950303614139557,
-0.7087162137031555,
0.21748152375221252,
-0.11929886043071747,
0.011664233170449734,
-0.1209421381354332,
-0.11613775789737701,
0.4523480236530304,
-0.6352479457855225,
0.864528477191925,
-0.4164533019065857,
-0.07433942705392838,
0.3708447813987732,
0.4304130971431732,
0.7976456880569458,
0.17183822393417358,
0.062225572764873505,
-0.34128499031066895,
0.09435494989156723,
-0.443839430809021,
-0.6592460870742798,
0.8117592334747314,
-0.546891987323761,
-0.8525010347366333,
-0.15546001493930817,
-0.9174580574035645,
-0.841551661491394,
0.07733563333749771,
0.013459626585245132,
0.512744665145874,
0.06943213194608688,
-0.13858182728290558,
0.5818082094192505,
-0.012702141888439655,
0.3782389760017395,
0.5815739631652832,
-0.3064722716808319,
-0.15507738292217255,
0.878917396068573,
-0.05034586414694786,
0.3476215600967407,
0.03427940607070923,
-0.07909953594207764,
-0.26983723044395447,
-0.12000131607055664,
-0.8106023073196411,
-0.06602657586336136,
-0.19455963373184204,
-0.04053275287151337,
-0.933659017086029,
0.15847545862197876,
-0.5585449934005737,
-0.039570409804582596,
-0.4632143974304199,
-0.5568910241127014,
-0.11119229346513748,
0.3524931073188782,
0.5172365307807922,
0.779985249042511,
0.34143659472465515,
0.2623436450958252,
-0.8365901112556458,
0.3116646707057953,
0.7829811573028564,
0.3255399167537689,
-0.10428512096405029,
-0.18961139023303986,
0.18488526344299316,
0.27942225337028503,
-0.3999798595905304,
-0.7560349106788635,
0.4053089916706085,
0.21700182557106018,
0.2317202240228653,
0.05441765859723091,
0.1416703462600708,
0.6575528979301453,
-0.4809228479862213,
1.1793004274368286,
0.03211222589015961,
-0.7637501955032349,
0.8214600086212158,
-0.6360838413238525,
0.3072514832019806,
0.23372964560985565,
0.11962005496025085,
-0.5586696267127991,
-0.4393579959869385,
-0.38249310851097107,
-0.8867828845977783,
0.7321813106536865,
0.20419932901859283,
0.4525951147079468,
-0.04196081683039665,
0.1512944996356964,
0.5362106561660767,
0.43071049451828003,
-0.4531359374523163,
-0.00965794362127781,
-0.49299851059913635,
-0.17484159767627716,
0.043806977570056915,
-0.04292246699333191,
-0.3651036322116852,
0.16424374282360077,
0.35294342041015625,
-0.5024283528327942,
0.5440893769264221,
0.1612023413181305,
0.0011814074823632836,
0.03136926144361496,
0.3080892860889435,
0.5745871067047119,
0.3219975233078003,
-0.11663919687271118,
-0.20389090478420258,
0.17664852738380432,
-0.3449971675872803,
0.014578310772776604,
-0.12191978842020035,
0.06661330908536911,
0.07180175185203552,
0.21416302025318146,
0.9806322455406189,
-0.124949149787426,
-0.9889309406280518,
0.3120274245738983,
-0.32817840576171875,
0.14129063487052917,
0.1226823553442955,
0.2749701142311096,
-0.2488919198513031,
0.06245270371437073,
0.3238964080810547,
-0.3588445782661438,
0.5633425712585449,
-0.7694106698036194,
-0.06394494324922562,
0.5648980140686035,
-0.32177332043647766,
-0.42458054423332214,
0.5806887149810791,
0.600391685962677,
-0.5104230642318726,
0.627621591091156,
-0.08019547164440155,
-0.2597047984600067,
0.5396637916564941,
0.4488891363143921,
1.0738742351531982,
0.021451812237501144,
0.25045162439346313,
0.18371346592903137,
-0.2691199779510498,
0.2688458263874054,
0.38939255475997925,
-0.48765790462493896,
-0.21787412464618683,
-0.08853113651275635,
-0.5049887895584106,
-0.7714670300483704,
-0.06930886954069138,
-0.6294867992401123,
0.14517517387866974,
-0.30675697326660156,
-0.4812789559364319,
-0.3649681806564331,
-0.15993450582027435,
-0.5837363600730896,
0.2553976774215698,
-0.18355268239974976,
0.6408685445785522,
-0.833593487739563,
0.48028022050857544,
0.8864138126373291,
-0.09815970808267593,
-0.6019786596298218,
0.3439072072505951,
0.363712340593338,
-0.6891720294952393,
0.9452810883522034,
-0.02732892893254757,
-0.14604660868644714,
-0.24933640658855438,
-0.2997307777404785,
-0.6864415407180786,
0.9331299066543579,
0.18693271279335022,
-0.48502036929130554,
-0.312593936920166,
0.12337527424097061,
0.7437039017677307,
-0.5739123821258545,
0.3272199034690857,
0.33207497000694275,
0.2172761708498001,
0.08899028599262238,
-1.4742555618286133,
-0.09568755328655243,
-0.42380914092063904,
0.3285980522632599,
0.08350878953933716,
-1.0088624954223633,
0.811571478843689,
0.07277838885784149,
0.05319803208112717,
0.12718325853347778,
0.3833414316177368,
0.4143272042274475,
0.4806668758392334,
0.6718265414237976,
0.20545123517513275,
0.3307154178619385,
-0.34217244386672974,
1.034903645515442,
-0.5150909423828125,
0.09420562535524368,
1.2516003847122192,
-0.5696384906768799,
0.56194007396698,
0.7082455158233643,
-0.018413972109556198,
0.3661286532878876,
0.7981791496276855,
0.4375341534614563,
0.5146259665489197,
0.007272818591445684,
-0.18513251841068268,
-0.20457065105438232,
-0.39412376284599304,
-0.11678635329008102,
0.4144219160079956,
0.2521566152572632,
-0.007188112940639257,
-0.04901914298534393,
0.16083523631095886,
-0.14689430594444275,
-0.12389915436506271,
-0.1967715471982956,
1.0571399927139282,
-0.3440881073474884,
-0.8061255812644958,
0.2669883668422699,
-0.5497538447380066,
0.5959501266479492,
-0.4374401271343231,
-0.08361107856035233,
-0.38886940479278564,
-0.2896338999271393,
-0.08673509210348129,
-0.9178301095962524,
0.22146549820899963,
0.26695239543914795,
-0.1976630687713623,
-0.4567425847053528,
0.4577432870864868,
-0.021861722692847252,
-0.19537793099880219,
-0.05639689788222313,
0.4526166617870331,
0.006132176611572504,
0.31340280175209045,
-0.5484084486961365,
0.1544458419084549,
-0.0989510789513588,
-0.6835856437683105,
0.279756098985672,
0.5657568573951721,
-0.45577144622802734,
1.060747742652893,
0.2510858476161957,
-0.09978284686803818,
0.15182127058506012,
-0.22323518991470337,
0.8667349815368652,
-0.1819574534893036,
-0.32795029878616333,
-0.29895463585853577,
0.6006540060043335,
-0.4253981411457062,
-0.4126659035682678,
0.7834526896476746,
0.42767587304115295,
0.49258822202682495,
-0.20962810516357422,
0.7277721166610718,
-0.18457406759262085,
0.6397539973258972,
-0.2716119885444641,
0.16025254130363464,
-0.6285837292671204,
0.25461268424987793,
-0.5515139102935791,
-0.8941144347190857,
0.1543150097131729,
0.3303220868110657,
-0.24548809230327606,
0.3461173474788666,
0.20755615830421448,
0.7068151831626892,
-0.07705503702163696,
0.08685315400362015,
0.04171954095363617,
0.12049245834350586,
0.5101194381713867,
0.48004576563835144,
0.39128318428993225,
-0.1438264548778534,
0.37402501702308655,
-0.249391108751297,
-0.0908876433968544,
-0.4830949604511261,
-0.643621563911438,
-0.5515151023864746,
-0.9424576759338379,
-0.24326078593730927,
-0.29655757546424866,
0.22184503078460693,
0.8440137505531311,
0.9318478107452393,
-0.7260880470275879,
-0.2844647169113159,
-0.25603508949279785,
-0.25409749150276184,
0.22075682878494263,
-0.3476989269256592,
-0.13763566315174103,
-0.4843035340309143,
-1.0277019739151,
0.026010319590568542,
0.5145745277404785,
0.28025147318840027,
-0.39116522669792175,
-0.09402492642402649,
0.40176767110824585,
0.30877238512039185,
0.6565086841583252,
0.3752775490283966,
-0.7456023097038269,
-0.40524420142173767,
0.29102322459220886,
-0.35726720094680786,
-0.07709350436925888,
0.7887548804283142,
-0.858107328414917,
0.9047979712486267,
0.33737289905548096,
0.4383763372898102,
0.30712607502937317,
-0.003446959424763918,
0.9311500191688538,
-0.6943628191947937,
0.05784207582473755,
0.2948102653026581,
0.11922585219144821,
0.2542113959789276,
-0.390440434217453,
0.5292879343032837,
0.12321709841489792,
-0.3784027099609375,
-1.1544023752212524,
0.3712983727455139,
-1.0804966688156128,
0.004128016997128725,
0.9782083034515381,
-0.1336352378129959,
-0.17111912369728088,
-0.051813989877700806,
-0.6643743515014648,
-0.05780109390616417,
-0.746829092502594,
0.8529667258262634,
0.712903618812561,
-0.7411894798278809,
-0.10945835709571838,
-0.5080935955047607,
0.40835803747177124,
0.45628395676612854,
-1.1098406314849854,
0.41728639602661133,
0.8273459672927856,
0.08909186720848083,
0.1827998161315918,
0.686262845993042,
0.16502749919891357,
0.3745008707046509,
0.04255899414420128,
-0.22877129912376404,
-0.08099109679460526,
-0.29382234811782837,
0.06632289290428162,
0.07012736052274704,
0.04296105355024338,
-0.15785202383995056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10110v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10110v2 | Selective Reflection-Tuning: Student-Selected Data Recycling for LLM Instruction-Tuning | 2024-02-15T17:06:21 | 2024-06-07T20:23:21 | Ming Li, Lichang Chen, Jiuhai Chen, Shwai He, Jiuxiang Gu, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction tuning is critical to large language models (LLMs) for achieving
better instruction following and task adaptation capabilities but its success
heavily relies on the training data quality. Many recent methods focus on
improving the data quality but often overlook the compatibility of the data
with the student model being finetuned. This paper introduces Selective
Reflection-Tuning, a novel paradigm that synergizes a teacher LLM's reflection
and introspection for improving existing data quality with the data selection
capability of the student LLM, to automatically refine existing
instruction-tuning data. This teacher-student collaboration produces
high-quality and student-compatible instruction-response pairs, resulting in
sample-efficient instruction tuning and LLMs of superior performance. Selective
Reflection-Tuning is a data augmentation and synthesis that generally improves
LLM finetuning and self-improvement without collecting brand-new data. We apply
our method to Alpaca and WizardLM data and achieve much stronger and top-tier
7B and 13B LLMs. | [
-0.5375924706459045,
-0.7301879525184631,
0.26875314116477966,
0.06226476654410362,
-0.37320107221603394,
0.3589063882827759,
-0.31096720695495605,
-0.26690399646759033,
0.23509354889392853,
0.9174888730049133,
-0.4370676875114441,
-0.4679495096206665,
-0.32984381914138794,
-0.03513564169406891,
-0.6575735807418823,
0.9682042598724365,
-0.056912846863269806,
0.5179433226585388,
-0.11772988736629486,
-0.08064214140176773,
-0.670087993144989,
-0.03616536036133766,
-0.4126506447792053,
-0.3533424139022827,
0.4107460379600525,
0.8616803288459778,
0.5365021228790283,
0.8969205021858215,
0.3870495855808258,
0.22916369140148163,
0.25254836678504944,
0.5952325463294983,
-0.6834494471549988,
0.2577444612979889,
-0.3211807310581207,
-0.4319528043270111,
-0.568825900554657,
0.3486681580543518,
0.9422503113746643,
0.7555970549583435,
-0.32874491810798645,
0.3388735353946686,
0.471930593252182,
0.8496779203414917,
-0.5976051688194275,
-0.169592022895813,
-0.8786047101020813,
-0.10913806408643723,
-0.2713629901409149,
-0.3468732535839081,
-0.5598912239074707,
-0.6516941785812378,
-0.17089781165122986,
-0.44780629873275757,
0.7081197500228882,
0.06481228768825531,
0.5268003940582275,
0.33374306559562683,
-0.2897684872150421,
-0.20793624222278595,
-0.6200944185256958,
0.6682764291763306,
-0.4637325406074524,
0.47044751048088074,
0.48615026473999023,
0.25235170125961304,
-0.23490720987319946,
-0.320181667804718,
-0.36084750294685364,
0.04021431505680084,
0.1929640918970108,
0.29613250494003296,
0.5767197608947754,
0.07335372269153595,
0.000654921808745712,
0.6532487869262695,
-0.43224504590034485,
0.0766039565205574,
-0.4496682584285736,
-0.0325026698410511,
0.6096926927566528,
0.34330514073371887,
0.007867983542382717,
0.18020260334014893,
-0.2877495586872101,
-0.08761918544769287,
-0.9669604301452637,
-0.10534895956516266,
0.581987738609314,
0.5567658543586731,
0.3346787989139557,
0.323984831571579,
-0.2598574161529541,
0.9751344323158264,
0.06517872959375381,
-0.13199278712272644,
0.1403835415840149,
-0.27709832787513733,
-0.08545736968517303,
0.1688154935836792,
0.30470553040504456,
0.170329287648201,
0.019717823714017868,
-0.3118988573551178,
-0.39589381217956543,
0.10716786235570908,
0.25341761112213135,
-0.6084235906600952,
-0.352977991104126,
-0.20651006698608398,
-0.41333362460136414,
-0.2212478369474411,
0.18645037710666656,
-0.8157764673233032,
-0.13021835684776306,
-0.7452360391616821,
0.3527665436267853,
-0.07726164162158966,
-0.14251501858234406,
0.2516178488731384,
0.20697660744190216,
0.2840217351913452,
0.34657829999923706,
-1.088392734527588,
0.40763136744499207,
0.8028672337532043,
0.448000967502594,
-0.5986740589141846,
-0.4696561098098755,
-0.6751642823219299,
0.3601810336112976,
-0.5822327136993408,
0.7463874220848083,
-0.7952353358268738,
-0.43490129709243774,
-0.20890754461288452,
0.05165444314479828,
-0.15452241897583008,
-0.9264863133430481,
0.4444364309310913,
-0.5263049602508545,
0.1544308066368103,
-0.47879818081855774,
-0.5123715400695801,
-0.03217737004160881,
-0.05296856909990311,
-0.6434510350227356,
1.1220372915267944,
0.39670559763908386,
-0.18888665735721588,
0.5213169455528259,
-0.011469111777842045,
-0.37368202209472656,
0.0478859506547451,
0.0191867183893919,
-0.4920012950897217,
0.18197815120220184,
0.09828495979309082,
0.20235009491443634,
-0.2945309579372406,
0.12458469718694687,
-0.31832337379455566,
-0.7475970983505249,
-0.04869833216071129,
-0.428031861782074,
0.4102238416671753,
0.21322107315063477,
0.03283634036779404,
-0.06861240416765213,
-1.0698299407958984,
0.11515319347381592,
-0.05727284774184227,
-0.5600613951683044,
-0.2410246729850769,
0.06343336403369904,
-0.20562340319156647,
-0.0852818414568901,
0.3348512053489685,
-0.41177037358283997,
0.39336660504341125,
-0.22831133008003235,
0.11361910402774811,
0.9738105535507202,
-0.14144885540008545,
0.4866611659526825,
-0.46658360958099365,
0.4867708683013916,
-0.22634153068065643,
0.2645675241947174,
0.012468084692955017,
-0.17571938037872314,
-1.0355473756790161,
-0.14607182145118713,
0.23605389893054962,
0.48105382919311523,
-0.7093267440795898,
0.14613372087478638,
0.06429488211870193,
-0.28787869215011597,
-1.027080774307251,
0.5814837217330933,
0.2390049397945404,
0.7690958976745605,
0.508215069770813,
-0.38983389735221863,
-0.6439369916915894,
-0.7015813589096069,
-0.2559932470321655,
0.2535678744316101,
0.12661516666412354,
0.24147291481494904,
-0.06575711071491241,
0.014248090796172619,
0.8053436875343323,
-0.466524600982666,
-0.39329469203948975,
-0.1910420060157776,
-0.3036843538284302,
0.26505687832832336,
0.6172251105308533,
0.3740112781524658,
-0.38978660106658936,
-0.7781634330749512,
-0.31358158588409424,
-0.4016784429550171,
-0.16812516748905182,
0.006550223100930452,
-0.5164235234260559,
0.14229482412338257,
0.2519245445728302,
-0.016982832923531532,
0.04599135369062424,
0.5705456137657166,
-0.23400621116161346,
0.3337469696998596,
-0.13255277276039124,
0.23079244792461395,
-0.759413480758667,
-0.3112781345844269,
-0.25556960701942444,
-0.27077677845954895,
-0.4807784855365753,
0.1088763102889061,
0.12277112156152725,
0.1991731822490692,
-0.23898252844810486,
0.2910757064819336,
-0.5713552236557007,
-0.054214224219322205,
-0.5495643019676208,
-0.005803190637379885,
-0.06866919994354248,
0.2587891221046448,
-0.03458397090435028,
0.9715095162391663,
0.5117113590240479,
-0.4899466633796692,
0.33264556527137756,
0.29616597294807434,
-0.4633624851703644,
0.5275422930717468,
-0.38821059465408325,
0.3973434269428253,
0.07705990225076675,
-0.07756355404853821,
-0.7559430599212646,
-0.11659236252307892,
0.22988270223140717,
-0.007200558204203844,
0.38089072704315186,
-0.009897281415760517,
-0.46146541833877563,
-0.1731702834367752,
-0.24257703125476837,
0.2729742228984833,
0.45174720883369446,
-0.9229174256324768,
0.4884750247001648,
0.13240255415439606,
0.05438213050365448,
-0.48602908849716187,
-0.46578192710876465,
-0.028346698731184006,
0.002542556030675769,
-0.3376772999763489,
0.3750109076499939,
-0.14139677584171295,
0.10114429891109467,
-0.028823180124163628,
-0.2869475185871124,
0.129408061504364,
0.036162324249744415,
-0.13257060945034027,
0.5645977854728699,
-0.04263433441519737,
-0.16604763269424438,
0.32936903834342957,
-0.1555502712726593,
-0.11975903809070587,
-0.021886248141527176,
0.5549115538597107,
0.12879014015197754,
-0.3953988552093506,
-0.14664074778556824,
0.1991385519504547,
0.09531287848949432,
-0.0971624031662941,
0.7444018125534058,
0.5218956470489502,
0.13847315311431885,
-0.7914581298828125,
-0.8155947923660278,
-0.5464218854904175,
-0.5806213021278381,
0.1215699315071106,
-0.3017273247241974,
-0.7685328722000122,
0.36265620589256287,
0.059749990701675415,
0.20016446709632874,
-0.1675519347190857,
0.26369842886924744,
-0.09927233308553696,
1.3162245750427246,
0.444308340549469,
-0.06193220242857933,
0.6792286038398743,
-0.1149388998746872,
-0.04470853507518768,
-1.022848129272461,
-0.2113552689552307,
-0.45129069685935974,
-0.40465420484542847,
-0.5573912262916565,
-0.02280096337199211,
0.1582440733909607,
-0.1220615953207016,
-0.14358505606651306,
0.14647553861141205,
-0.8969717025756836,
0.7678561806678772,
0.6365968585014343,
0.3585743010044098,
0.41931310296058655,
0.03609781339764595,
0.19959884881973267,
-0.021967358887195587,
-0.3683837056159973,
-0.5341131687164307,
1.212360143661499,
-0.02994968369603157,
0.8923562169075012,
-0.16011960804462433,
0.8976958990097046,
-0.0633259266614914,
0.3569967746734619,
-0.422859787940979,
0.8348838090896606,
-0.471537321805954,
-0.4783160984516144,
-0.1282757669687271,
-0.5215429663658142,
-0.8917989730834961,
0.44353383779525757,
-0.1284898966550827,
-0.2995811700820923,
-0.1366526186466217,
0.15505269169807434,
-0.016854383051395416,
0.20074573159217834,
-0.5982198715209961,
0.5162298083305359,
0.06881676614284515,
-0.5399208068847656,
-0.3931131064891815,
-0.28643420338630676,
0.2732982933521271,
-0.1008390262722969,
-0.1478060483932495,
-0.25079548358917236,
0.013310044072568417,
0.6486861705780029,
-0.2615344226360321,
0.6215559840202332,
-0.2793671190738678,
-0.2783793807029724,
0.31814080476760864,
0.24846987426280975,
0.4754168391227722,
0.039670076221227646,
-0.1665395349264145,
-0.2310725301504135,
-0.06802067905664444,
-0.5119985342025757,
-0.6269252300262451,
0.8667405247688293,
-0.7524433135986328,
-0.9821344614028931,
-0.03003610670566559,
-0.6188961863517761,
-0.4635471701622009,
0.026448234915733337,
-0.005319739691913128,
0.18136043846607208,
0.029177192598581314,
0.15855656564235687,
0.7907618284225464,
0.27199289202690125,
0.29679933190345764,
0.9000676870346069,
-0.14355787634849548,
-0.5791727304458618,
1.493480920791626,
0.3550252318382263,
0.3287839889526367,
0.014878157526254654,
-0.04556577280163765,
-0.041345395147800446,
-0.7548279166221619,
-0.24255160987377167,
0.28899139165878296,
-0.6106141209602356,
-0.1230711042881012,
-0.04090939462184906,
-0.23224498331546783,
-0.11225282400846481,
-0.27889853715896606,
-0.5260834693908691,
-0.3757381737232208,
-0.599626362323761,
-0.03130512684583664,
-0.04066695272922516,
0.5975944399833679,
0.17595542967319489,
0.21493388712406158,
-0.6631818413734436,
0.2470744252204895,
0.39944639801979065,
0.546878457069397,
-0.010491038672626019,
-0.5670828819274902,
-0.30090633034706116,
-0.04996206611394882,
-0.46062877774238586,
-0.6655876040458679,
0.26530691981315613,
0.3450007736682892,
0.5949109196662903,
0.34680694341659546,
-0.04865952208638191,
0.5568636059761047,
-0.4014037549495697,
0.4984428584575653,
-0.18115518987178802,
-0.8155994415283203,
0.7482679486274719,
-0.20570656657218933,
0.17105768620967865,
0.952389121055603,
-0.0790565013885498,
-0.2669929265975952,
-0.61669921875,
-0.26453283429145813,
-0.7145748138427734,
0.8387510776519775,
-0.3095138967037201,
0.23977340757846832,
0.12747082114219666,
0.643307626247406,
0.6188966631889343,
0.2119518369436264,
-0.4418025016784668,
-0.3005315959453583,
-0.24935604631900787,
-0.4489002227783203,
-0.06877691298723221,
0.024930885061621666,
-0.24748654663562775,
-0.5054224729537964,
0.8345171213150024,
-0.3338054418563843,
-0.0825231596827507,
-0.2332504689693451,
0.00375870568677783,
-0.30610495805740356,
0.0305414367467165,
0.20338472723960876,
0.6040881276130676,
-0.12033979594707489,
0.10519217699766159,
0.4369487464427948,
-0.7181252837181091,
0.34544849395751953,
-0.1369243711233139,
-0.48072218894958496,
-0.20724068582057953,
0.15101556479930878,
0.5759725570678711,
0.16490264236927032,
-0.23548947274684906,
0.07101720571517944,
0.05435006320476532,
-0.04229523241519928,
-0.04907204210758209,
0.9348329305648804,
-0.26064208149909973,
0.13675066828727722,
0.48766282200813293,
0.04792550951242447,
0.22329023480415344,
-0.3864707052707672,
0.13856445252895355,
0.5427525639533997,
-0.16747251152992249,
-0.3500952124595642,
0.5350741744041443,
0.23283442854881287,
-0.1948511302471161,
0.7131107449531555,
-0.07989796996116638,
-0.00792315136641264,
0.5314468145370483,
0.735319197177887,
0.6456657648086548,
-0.4852418601512909,
0.31377869844436646,
0.39843693375587463,
-0.019170260056853294,
-0.38132786750793457,
0.5449491143226624,
-0.15804935991764069,
-0.794895589351654,
-0.3547685146331787,
-0.4889043867588043,
-0.46151989698410034,
0.042240679264068604,
-1.1055265665054321,
0.3990602493286133,
-0.6257644295692444,
-0.03324995934963226,
-0.4990769922733307,
0.14612475037574768,
-0.4741748571395874,
0.13906148076057434,
-0.05705155059695244,
0.731302797794342,
-0.7332156300544739,
1.0283873081207275,
0.4263206124305725,
-0.1244734600186348,
-0.7785285711288452,
-0.09140325337648392,
-0.20236195623874664,
-0.8949624300003052,
0.3355778753757477,
-0.0009947929065674543,
-0.12044163793325424,
0.17129212617874146,
-0.6357007622718811,
-0.8765829801559448,
1.0970425605773926,
0.6442890167236328,
-0.846340000629425,
0.007818115875124931,
0.3347513675689697,
0.4046842157840729,
-0.2798094153404236,
0.10929596424102783,
0.9134723544120789,
0.28567805886268616,
0.23402239382266998,
-0.5925110578536987,
0.02486276626586914,
0.022634977474808693,
0.02327287755906582,
0.3084624707698822,
-1.1710909605026245,
0.5235980749130249,
0.10818580538034439,
-0.065081886947155,
-0.02838241308927536,
0.7995378971099854,
0.25933223962783813,
0.2154223471879959,
0.3990199863910675,
0.60471510887146,
0.7504098415374756,
-0.31947222352027893,
0.3819301426410675,
-0.5093996524810791,
0.2848837375640869,
1.1513055562973022,
-0.4364791512489319,
0.7646174430847168,
0.4509851038455963,
-0.16140013933181763,
0.33323583006858826,
0.6840260624885559,
-0.3591071367263794,
0.740980327129364,
-0.1385638564825058,
-0.36280614137649536,
-0.5503789782524109,
-0.06677252799272537,
-0.45964276790618896,
0.5835353136062622,
0.21330814063549042,
-0.24483394622802734,
-0.06371839344501495,
0.10838616639375687,
-0.30687499046325684,
0.13732853531837463,
-0.45667803287506104,
0.7077555060386658,
0.0039706663228571415,
-0.8728514909744263,
0.7893428802490234,
-0.28014758229255676,
0.566001296043396,
-0.2967313230037689,
-0.08969895541667938,
-0.3733803629875183,
0.2630557119846344,
-0.41805577278137207,
-0.7243323922157288,
0.13523660600185394,
-0.36826765537261963,
-0.12020335346460342,
-0.42754924297332764,
0.5683990120887756,
-0.8033784031867981,
-0.29687124490737915,
0.1882353574037552,
0.3137126564979553,
-0.09375715255737305,
0.4729991555213928,
-0.5331544280052185,
0.24385546147823334,
0.07670462131500244,
-0.3963005542755127,
0.5558845400810242,
0.040494613349437714,
0.35191991925239563,
0.6851367950439453,
0.5650109052658081,
0.4871063232421875,
0.0017294473946094513,
0.3949478268623352,
0.9934716820716858,
-0.43300876021385193,
-0.27126097679138184,
-0.6234204769134521,
0.1913882941007614,
0.1139611303806305,
-0.2905360162258148,
0.8286346793174744,
0.7762206196784973,
1.0591474771499634,
0.1992001086473465,
0.5337947607040405,
0.5214928388595581,
0.8112165927886963,
-0.7023375034332275,
0.4942360818386078,
-0.3246880769729614,
0.43253231048583984,
-0.14066609740257263,
-1.2692310810089111,
0.01762622408568859,
0.639767587184906,
-0.25066426396369934,
0.13958854973316193,
0.3628208041191101,
0.9257497191429138,
-0.18321986496448517,
0.31472349166870117,
0.14535552263259888,
-0.11851570755243301,
0.26835939288139343,
0.5169035792350769,
0.8874514698982239,
-0.28736644983291626,
0.40831947326660156,
-0.21313998103141785,
-0.24532248079776764,
-0.12829966843128204,
-0.3208884000778198,
-0.8451257944107056,
-0.6070084571838379,
-0.40185073018074036,
-0.27633392810821533,
0.21081170439720154,
0.8645101189613342,
0.6785284280776978,
-0.7791869044303894,
-0.27471956610679626,
-0.15757785737514496,
0.15864866971969604,
-0.3350050151348114,
-0.26873859763145447,
0.2325301468372345,
-0.648859977722168,
-0.9110478162765503,
0.6396798491477966,
-0.000690914923325181,
0.1425580233335495,
-0.46077707409858704,
-0.17358916997909546,
0.3560583293437958,
0.24541768431663513,
0.26991331577301025,
0.036849379539489746,
-0.437473326921463,
-0.27295857667922974,
0.0020367607939988375,
-0.22059060633182526,
0.17375871539115906,
0.7993284463882446,
-0.7536641359329224,
0.44712650775909424,
0.30576851963996887,
0.5177485346794128,
0.6336669921875,
0.04259954392910004,
0.35757994651794434,
-0.530659019947052,
0.05618879944086075,
0.2744748890399933,
0.1572476327419281,
0.24473024904727936,
-0.31173646450042725,
0.5439368486404419,
0.07530170679092407,
-0.7403619885444641,
-1.051117181777954,
0.022235125303268433,
-0.6855493783950806,
-0.22182300686836243,
0.9784507751464844,
0.09899977594614029,
-0.13656115531921387,
0.1025264635682106,
-0.3433276116847992,
0.23088893294334412,
-0.39761245250701904,
1.0955452919006348,
0.6967607736587524,
-0.21764153242111206,
-0.25748690962791443,
-0.5788889527320862,
0.4932548701763153,
0.6581698656082153,
-0.6583564877510071,
0.07593123614788055,
0.41063305735588074,
0.3897134065628052,
-0.3855608403682709,
0.32299208641052246,
0.052647627890110016,
0.27558523416519165,
-0.035836927592754364,
-0.19086812436580658,
-0.33591705560684204,
-0.6080413460731506,
-0.011909028515219688,
0.2711094617843628,
0.16834014654159546,
-0.15674221515655518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10109v2 | Towards Reducing Diagnostic Errors with Interpretable Risk Prediction | 2024-02-15T17:05:48 | 2024-03-19T16:43:09 | Denis Jered McInerney, William Dickinson, Lucy C. Flynn, Andrea C. Young, Geoffrey S. Young, Jan-Willem van de Meent, Byron C. Wallace | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Many diagnostic errors occur because clinicians cannot easily access relevant
information in patient Electronic Health Records (EHRs). In this work we
propose a method to use LLMs to identify pieces of evidence in patient EHR data
that indicate increased or decreased risk of specific diagnoses; our ultimate
aim is to increase access to evidence and reduce diagnostic errors. In
particular, we propose a Neural Additive Model to make predictions backed by
evidence with individualized risk estimates at time-points where clinicians are
still uncertain, aiming to specifically mitigate delays in diagnosis and errors
stemming from an incomplete differential. To train such a model, it is
necessary to infer temporally fine-grained retrospective labels of eventual
"true" diagnoses. We do so with LLMs, to ensure that the input text is from
before a confident diagnosis can be made. We use an LLM to retrieve an initial
pool of evidence, but then refine this set of evidence according to
correlations learned by the model. We conduct an in-depth evaluation of the
usefulness of our approach by simulating how it might be used by a clinician to
decide between a pre-defined list of differential diagnoses. | [
0.07865605503320694,
-0.4531290829181671,
0.9262568950653076,
-0.035789355635643005,
-0.23166349530220032,
-0.20963919162750244,
0.219877228140831,
-0.8219365477561951,
0.2677117586135864,
0.3508087694644928,
-0.42952612042427063,
-0.6000581383705139,
-0.7952659726142883,
-0.10859113186597824,
-0.11901229619979858,
0.8568530678749084,
0.035561490803956985,
0.5539343357086182,
-0.3983330726623535,
0.16056250035762787,
-0.39439040422439575,
-0.429502010345459,
-1.0005850791931152,
-0.6963371634483337,
0.7316927313804626,
0.24039581418037415,
0.6250908970832825,
0.9005117416381836,
0.7809426784515381,
0.21647068858146667,
-0.3646696209907532,
0.05325760319828987,
0.0682038739323616,
0.2089190036058426,
0.2533645033836365,
-0.7677128911018372,
-0.9230414628982544,
-0.5426212549209595,
0.37275218963623047,
0.9025923609733582,
-0.30822378396987915,
0.11068109422922134,
-0.09022989124059677,
0.40404653549194336,
-0.4704383611679077,
0.0796794667840004,
-0.31945735216140747,
0.2985254228115082,
-0.10004443675279617,
-0.4720526337623596,
-0.34974995255470276,
-0.34443286061286926,
0.31156137585639954,
-0.5171601176261902,
0.23872636258602142,
-0.332826167345047,
0.5689185261726379,
0.39061662554740906,
-0.35990840196609497,
-0.10409795492887497,
-0.8250030279159546,
0.3465791940689087,
-0.6958277821540833,
0.26776599884033203,
0.4107578694820404,
0.3352460563182831,
-0.08707738667726517,
-0.7499035596847534,
-0.20546069741249084,
-0.035905636847019196,
-0.31171339750289917,
0.2547973096370697,
-0.20158271491527557,
0.29621422290802,
0.2582012712955475,
0.01844090037047863,
-0.21560359001159668,
0.5385386943817139,
-0.27983346581459045,
-0.4188046157360077,
0.5844321846961975,
0.6989710330963135,
0.3802117109298706,
0.006956696510314941,
-0.49068790674209595,
0.25460800528526306,
-0.9514436721801758,
0.07554909586906433,
0.01113226916640997,
0.04114871099591255,
0.021963076665997505,
0.5440939664840698,
0.06937048584222794,
0.5410937070846558,
0.2041766196489334,
-0.3050011396408081,
0.2867916524410248,
0.04617680236697197,
-0.16053327918052673,
0.586762547492981,
0.38282155990600586,
0.4866269528865814,
-0.13871586322784424,
0.024468740448355675,
-0.2663361728191376,
0.1838977187871933,
0.2133762687444687,
-0.602519690990448,
-0.2861878275871277,
0.5756158828735352,
-0.5873878598213196,
-0.5210925936698914,
-0.32765159010887146,
-0.77720046043396,
-0.7380602955818176,
-0.2667509913444519,
0.5134865045547485,
-0.5031875371932983,
-0.026341287419199944,
0.3627620041370392,
0.11485398560762405,
-0.3813678026199341,
0.563607394695282,
-0.5501754283905029,
0.5258172154426575,
0.3983396589756012,
0.6516991257667542,
-0.015223455615341663,
0.013504370115697384,
-0.542759358882904,
0.28409162163734436,
-0.4894699156284332,
0.7675159573554993,
-0.11219556629657745,
-0.4704023599624634,
-0.03835923597216606,
-0.06075400859117508,
0.04491530358791351,
-0.4676136374473572,
0.581694483757019,
-0.5082248449325562,
-0.12604214251041412,
0.014925123192369938,
-0.6690149903297424,
-0.3806608021259308,
0.2340477555990219,
-0.7966670393943787,
0.579095721244812,
0.1146196499466896,
-0.6707881093025208,
0.556994616985321,
-0.48541465401649475,
-0.5507189035415649,
-0.043321654200553894,
-0.0687909871339798,
-0.7065349221229553,
0.17262321710586548,
0.28527364134788513,
0.5112941265106201,
-0.268932580947876,
0.5048205256462097,
-0.3539324402809143,
-0.09458943456411362,
0.24737319350242615,
-0.3991558849811554,
0.4323867857456207,
0.02143269218504429,
-0.19041135907173157,
0.20918209850788116,
-0.952401340007782,
-0.1636262685060501,
0.08241332322359085,
-0.4014810621738434,
-0.5691125988960266,
0.3165382742881775,
-0.391445517539978,
0.14160461723804474,
0.14534811675548553,
-0.36366117000579834,
-0.12287189811468124,
-0.46452027559280396,
-0.08781362324953079,
0.8985533118247986,
0.2662975490093231,
0.12720945477485657,
-0.8469839692115784,
0.58073490858078,
0.6897069215774536,
0.3388392925262451,
-0.18785911798477173,
-0.5772903561592102,
-0.9079010486602783,
-0.065748430788517,
0.3212681710720062,
0.7542768120765686,
-0.33951041102409363,
0.5493501424789429,
-0.4239886701107025,
-0.24266040325164795,
-0.5045539140701294,
-0.18576057255268097,
0.240386500954628,
1.021054983139038,
0.5966189503669739,
-0.30436035990715027,
-0.6588442325592041,
-0.7470951080322266,
0.1601838767528534,
-0.33095234632492065,
-0.28143107891082764,
0.2586076557636261,
-0.035036973655223846,
-0.5215985178947449,
0.4706283211708069,
-0.5855895280838013,
-0.384252667427063,
-0.0615251287817955,
-0.08774914592504501,
0.4837430417537689,
0.41261622309684753,
0.10038221627473831,
-0.307023286819458,
-0.3121739625930786,
0.19656990468502045,
-1.0418906211853027,
-0.019354481250047684,
-0.26321929693222046,
0.10265703499317169,
-0.07329657673835754,
0.4230577051639557,
-0.5947577953338623,
0.7733100652694702,
0.27100539207458496,
-0.39325448870658875,
0.06733280420303345,
-0.7324053049087524,
-0.022051049396395683,
-0.7981292605400085,
-0.3221951425075531,
0.18926258385181427,
-0.2624744176864624,
-0.7327825427055359,
-0.5334370732307434,
0.08239287883043289,
0.2289985716342926,
-0.2450757771730423,
0.5943341255187988,
-0.35098475217819214,
0.1440984457731247,
0.005971145816147327,
-0.2696051299571991,
0.12008108198642731,
-0.10795172303915024,
0.0112378541380167,
0.28848031163215637,
0.6890869140625,
-0.9132094383239746,
-0.10429832339286804,
0.36346566677093506,
-0.35079067945480347,
0.372907817363739,
-0.7338012456893921,
-0.09014507383108139,
-0.34971362352371216,
-0.08451239764690399,
-0.7447423338890076,
-0.13315659761428833,
0.1882428526878357,
-0.4089616537094116,
0.6979668736457825,
-0.052592579275369644,
-0.08024250715970993,
-0.3955405354499817,
-0.08548290282487869,
0.31071677803993225,
0.525307834148407,
-0.5634499788284302,
0.9019206166267395,
0.35984906554222107,
-0.4510524570941925,
-0.6323248744010925,
-0.9334234595298767,
-0.03548252582550049,
-0.3403000831604004,
-0.7395111918449402,
0.6054882407188416,
-0.03554275631904602,
-0.4322652816772461,
0.13799141347408295,
0.06540651619434357,
-0.13472753763198853,
0.3985046148300171,
0.48324906826019287,
0.5612336993217468,
-0.35747870802879333,
0.576798677444458,
0.33157485723495483,
-0.36224889755249023,
0.31587347388267517,
-0.16994406282901764,
0.1032782718539238,
0.2806897461414337,
-0.672054648399353,
-0.5475778579711914,
0.2757517099380493,
0.3544556498527527,
0.3589193820953369,
0.5153858065605164,
0.31855863332748413,
-0.8166429996490479,
-0.12813320755958557,
-0.5809040069580078,
-0.33207517862319946,
-0.40549567341804504,
0.284199595451355,
0.04517318308353424,
-0.43243706226348877,
0.8317221999168396,
-0.03939228877425194,
-0.16771550476551056,
0.490541934967041,
0.5529638528823853,
-0.3053295910358429,
0.9533670544624329,
0.4618473947048187,
0.034164972603321075,
0.022393284365534782,
-0.030124511569738388,
0.05104927718639374,
-0.8264226317405701,
-0.48732972145080566,
-0.1352863758802414,
-0.17251433432102203,
-0.46314379572868347,
-0.47607940435409546,
0.717059850692749,
-0.07058971375226974,
-0.28029799461364746,
-0.23153100907802582,
-0.5795136094093323,
0.04594346135854721,
0.4451744556427002,
0.9892273545265198,
0.41356056928634644,
-0.2530543804168701,
-0.13587069511413574,
-0.10270042717456818,
-1.054900050163269,
-0.3574465811252594,
1.6387749910354614,
0.6913765668869019,
0.7322533130645752,
0.12096735090017319,
0.7014922499656677,
0.36759090423583984,
0.6795814037322998,
-0.8954454660415649,
0.090622179210186,
-0.09974049776792526,
-0.5541084408760071,
-0.12987975776195526,
-0.28455305099487305,
-0.9835628867149353,
-0.10863872617483139,
-0.3444918394088745,
-0.5550599694252014,
0.4645152688026428,
0.4991919994354248,
-0.878669023513794,
0.3473663330078125,
-0.4944155812263489,
0.4644277095794678,
-0.6076582074165344,
-0.20102450251579285,
-0.11402817070484161,
-0.6706271767616272,
0.4100317358970642,
-0.34714755415916443,
0.2774120271205902,
-0.0647745430469513,
-0.3034210801124573,
0.6323332786560059,
-0.30479466915130615,
1.0090365409851074,
-0.022181842476129532,
0.12351176887750626,
0.15753114223480225,
0.16035830974578857,
0.7128758430480957,
0.28809285163879395,
-0.20892678201198578,
0.3007700443267822,
-0.13223427534103394,
-0.03434257581830025,
-0.28676724433898926,
0.5287331342697144,
-0.6965604424476624,
-0.5639883279800415,
-0.6304941177368164,
-0.3940097689628601,
-0.2582276165485382,
0.1344352811574936,
0.19431869685649872,
0.5703040361404419,
-0.10235155373811722,
-0.2063189446926117,
0.8129545450210571,
-0.2960701584815979,
0.3944343328475952,
0.45902130007743835,
0.31100738048553467,
-0.310433954000473,
0.31387364864349365,
0.10079046338796616,
0.06092698872089386,
0.39824989438056946,
0.5401950478553772,
-0.3163609504699707,
-1.1959985494613647,
0.15527160465717316,
0.004371347837150097,
-1.1670377254486084,
-0.4959303140640259,
-0.6637226343154907,
-0.2673451006412506,
-0.07959732413291931,
-0.018383920192718506,
-0.10602321475744247,
-0.17551791667938232,
-0.6730179786682129,
-0.3878984749317169,
0.5626804828643799,
0.7015416622161865,
-0.2546311914920807,
0.4586174488067627,
-0.9012020230293274,
0.23671430349349976,
0.1759641468524933,
0.4086986184120178,
-0.015607723966240883,
-0.5563251972198486,
-0.19363509118556976,
-0.05882037803530693,
-0.11764521896839142,
-0.6407291293144226,
0.5864675045013428,
0.18322397768497467,
0.8615935444831848,
0.554405927658081,
0.10701892524957657,
0.7623234391212463,
-0.6592857241630554,
0.4304257929325104,
0.6048751473426819,
-0.7186511158943176,
0.6500165462493896,
-0.27004772424697876,
-0.3006901443004608,
0.3689827620983124,
0.5521461963653564,
-0.2956934869289398,
0.20302607119083405,
-0.8756232857704163,
-0.8414725065231323,
0.3021640479564667,
-0.27051764726638794,
-0.3067115247249603,
-0.12541723251342773,
0.5250339508056641,
0.003799695987254381,
-0.16372962296009064,
-0.5626505613327026,
-0.5010468363761902,
0.12630216777324677,
-0.31766945123672485,
-0.2543095648288727,
-0.486605703830719,
-0.5044986009597778,
-0.4774279296398163,
0.49379318952560425,
-0.19928033649921417,
0.48724955320358276,
0.5930661559104919,
0.012982139363884926,
-0.5046444535255432,
0.03651972487568855,
0.6180580258369446,
0.7688408493995667,
-0.3488512635231018,
0.3168797791004181,
0.44745808839797974,
-0.5084444284439087,
0.20064964890480042,
0.1619858741760254,
-0.04361983761191368,
0.22347237169742584,
0.37674659490585327,
0.7618541717529297,
0.17606550455093384,
-0.5266743898391724,
0.3447059392929077,
-0.08354250341653824,
-0.1461857706308365,
-0.6667369604110718,
-0.050940413028001785,
0.1664750576019287,
0.23394210636615753,
0.012462954968214035,
0.4693974554538727,
0.13965767621994019,
-0.06956671178340912,
0.6371020078659058,
0.20593903958797455,
-0.7208760976791382,
-0.3447034955024719,
0.7014684081077576,
0.19092264771461487,
-0.3617831766605377,
0.4605439305305481,
0.35339078307151794,
-0.2842053472995758,
0.8957555890083313,
0.4795621633529663,
0.7410569190979004,
-0.2517983615398407,
0.048254869878292084,
0.3642464578151703,
0.3436242938041687,
-0.23361560702323914,
0.20957592129707336,
0.6726510524749756,
-0.875787615776062,
-0.5082581639289856,
-0.2924709618091583,
-0.4037149250507355,
0.3715815544128418,
-0.7013723254203796,
0.5252419710159302,
-0.6658711433410645,
-0.4542631506919861,
0.06143870949745178,
-0.45671623945236206,
-0.7171193957328796,
0.49247199296951294,
0.21642127633094788,
0.6926172971725464,
-0.6697964072227478,
0.6467622518539429,
0.364128977060318,
-0.14903061091899872,
-0.8339388370513916,
-0.1343993991613388,
0.22202850878238678,
-0.9021539092063904,
0.6876256465911865,
-0.11779015511274338,
0.3304121494293213,
-0.2657760977745056,
0.026972627267241478,
-1.0040661096572876,
1.2126100063323975,
0.20633608102798462,
-0.6033130288124084,
-0.08193472027778625,
-0.10971923917531967,
0.6086656451225281,
-0.3531172275543213,
0.3752717971801758,
0.40345415472984314,
0.42685627937316895,
0.06957202404737473,
-0.6223706007003784,
0.34250906109809875,
-0.03746827319264412,
-0.23779109120368958,
0.36118051409721375,
0.12539492547512054,
0.9576042890548706,
-0.5503866672515869,
-0.01617143489420414,
-0.11289134621620178,
0.16148577630519867,
0.12474454939365387,
0.6256609559059143,
0.2771761119365692,
0.5604149103164673,
0.9191552996635437,
-0.09274153411388397,
1.3683431148529053,
-0.2427096664905548,
0.05558232218027115,
1.2334293127059937,
-0.19850392639636993,
0.688156008720398,
0.3546298146247864,
-0.43750661611557007,
0.3416202962398529,
0.9278908371925354,
0.04792459309101105,
0.5088345408439636,
0.1817810982465744,
-0.612339437007904,
-0.41021963953971863,
-0.09411977976560593,
-0.4581342935562134,
0.13766515254974365,
0.7846203446388245,
-0.6941735148429871,
-0.09842364490032196,
-0.30790090560913086,
-0.2113453894853592,
-0.12067413330078125,
-0.4514482915401459,
0.7972084283828735,
0.20856980979442596,
-0.43043699860572815,
0.4712132215499878,
-0.30447888374328613,
0.6149179935455322,
-0.6251567006111145,
-0.050768282264471054,
-0.04875410348176956,
0.5394399762153625,
-0.4010831117630005,
-0.5552484393119812,
0.3833347260951996,
-0.4404793381690979,
-0.15161317586898804,
0.02564343251287937,
0.8503826856613159,
-0.18187321722507477,
-0.751880407333374,
0.48193100094795227,
0.5057123303413391,
-0.1956706941127777,
0.23967577517032623,
-0.4953463673591614,
-0.42183828353881836,
-0.20060163736343384,
-0.14181672036647797,
0.4387926459312439,
0.46369805932044983,
-0.046600308269262314,
0.9263896942138672,
0.6256794929504395,
0.6428103446960449,
-0.16663429141044617,
-0.01635458506643772,
0.9086194038391113,
-0.4116487503051758,
-0.3061772286891937,
-0.8222861289978027,
0.7065764665603638,
0.13473199307918549,
-0.2789190709590912,
0.13470244407653809,
0.018391743302345276,
0.3884255588054657,
-0.07064608484506607,
0.7939031720161438,
0.45844316482543945,
0.6808148622512817,
-0.7106712460517883,
0.675087571144104,
-0.577973484992981,
0.6945794820785522,
0.015057822689414024,
-0.17073534429073334,
-0.7229913473129272,
0.41608116030693054,
-0.1646052449941635,
-0.17321176826953888,
0.6712314486503601,
0.49139052629470825,
0.14381428062915802,
-0.32237109541893005,
0.4613853991031647,
0.21995896100997925,
0.25747203826904297,
0.7353314757347107,
0.742168128490448,
-0.5006306767463684,
0.22604647278785706,
-0.6109051704406738,
-0.24248947203159332,
-0.24691812694072723,
-1.2242070436477661,
-0.82841956615448,
0.018670588731765747,
-0.5118339657783508,
-0.6366407871246338,
0.11308960616588593,
0.8456447124481201,
0.6217678785324097,
-0.784683883190155,
0.11891449987888336,
-0.1755676418542862,
0.32450664043426514,
-0.35420459508895874,
-0.02877320721745491,
0.503764808177948,
-0.03525374084711075,
-0.11839328706264496,
0.44115379452705383,
0.11434906721115112,
0.4883386492729187,
0.23328018188476562,
-0.023622730746865273,
-0.04851176589727402,
-0.15610648691654205,
0.3880717158317566,
-0.014684016816318035,
-0.5621423721313477,
-0.3573915362358093,
0.010324222967028618,
0.07706675678491592,
0.4155240058898926,
0.4745638072490692,
-0.7424544095993042,
0.5684142112731934,
0.38744837045669556,
0.6140803694725037,
0.44018301367759705,
-0.16319364309310913,
0.6338908076286316,
-0.2561929225921631,
0.07043852657079697,
0.7372676730155945,
0.574845552444458,
0.11882656067609787,
-1.1821210384368896,
0.3991555869579315,
0.1267222911119461,
-0.40637829899787903,
-0.4963440001010895,
-0.022153500467538834,
-0.8821033835411072,
-0.11121419072151184,
0.9491855502128601,
-0.349198579788208,
-0.08966904878616333,
-0.46483272314071655,
0.3738184869289398,
0.166905477643013,
-0.26441675424575806,
0.9710391759872437,
0.2279333621263504,
-0.3955122232437134,
-0.04471486806869507,
-0.526946485042572,
0.6402509808540344,
0.35872983932495117,
-0.9721980094909668,
-0.32776349782943726,
0.41659197211265564,
0.6311445832252502,
0.21340660750865936,
0.5546523332595825,
-0.17974378168582916,
0.6119600534439087,
-0.07540193945169449,
0.09906476736068726,
-0.1412436068058014,
-0.31639134883880615,
-0.6535283327102661,
-0.022539889439940453,
0.2001517415046692,
-0.2817777395248413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10107v1 | Quantized Embedding Vectors for Controllable Diffusion Language Models | 2024-02-15T17:02:48 | 2024-02-15T17:02:48 | Cheng Kang, Xinye Chen, Yong Hu, Daniel Novak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improving the controllability, portability, and inference speed of diffusion
language models (DLMs) is a key challenge in natural language generation. While
recent research has shown significant success in complex text generation with
language models, the memory and computational power are still very demanding
and fall short of expectations, which naturally results in low portability and
instability for the models. To mitigate these issues, numerous well-established
methods were proposed for neural network quantization. To further enhance their
portability of independent deployment as well as improve their stability
evaluated by language perplexity, we propose a novel approach called the
Quantized Embedding Controllable Diffusion Language Model (QE-CDLM). QE-CDLM
builds upon the recent successful controllable DLMs by remodeling the
task-specific embedding space via quantization. This leads to a gradient-based
controller for the generation tasks, and more stable intermediate latent
variables are obtained, which naturally brings in an accelerated convergence as
well as better controllability. Additionally, the adaption fine-tuning method
is employed to reduce tunable weights. Experimental results on five challenging
fine-grained control tasks demonstrate that QE-CDLM compares favorably to
existing methods in terms of quality and feasibility, achieving better
perplexity and lightweight fine-tuning. | [
-0.29941606521606445,
-0.8669215440750122,
0.24060724675655365,
0.460530161857605,
-0.102897509932518,
0.13105230033397675,
-0.31672748923301697,
0.31126150488853455,
-0.10601683706045151,
0.2770955264568329,
-0.0779883936047554,
-0.6077679395675659,
-0.6675823330879211,
-0.1362432986497879,
-0.32211679220199585,
0.828585684299469,
-0.2592754065990448,
-0.11154013872146606,
-0.2178104668855667,
-0.3648732900619507,
-0.19291825592517853,
-0.4310488998889923,
-1.051161289215088,
-0.21300482749938965,
0.5583339929580688,
-0.11277413368225098,
0.9012579917907715,
0.5074172616004944,
0.12227929383516312,
0.303252249956131,
-0.35037171840667725,
0.02021532878279686,
-0.23591940104961395,
0.21488253772258759,
-0.06846047192811966,
-0.5217528939247131,
-0.6386883854866028,
-0.19258084893226624,
0.701092004776001,
0.624005913734436,
-0.5376271605491638,
-0.21815206110477448,
0.20631462335586548,
0.635364830493927,
-0.8469051718711853,
-0.20471684634685516,
-0.4495343565940857,
0.237298846244812,
0.007767039816826582,
-0.13280144333839417,
-0.2357294112443924,
-0.5067936182022095,
0.17827244102954865,
-0.6504001617431641,
0.09527706354856491,
-0.22108915448188782,
0.4909454882144928,
0.35755980014801025,
-0.5604950785636902,
-0.14703920483589172,
-0.9012352824211121,
0.8823992013931274,
-0.8959853053092957,
0.2835598587989807,
0.34826409816741943,
0.27339914441108704,
-0.05745237320661545,
-0.8038027286529541,
-0.4428063929080963,
-0.1818641573190689,
0.24609361588954926,
-0.09250375628471375,
-0.37130531668663025,
0.11509832739830017,
0.1190091148018837,
0.040167659521102905,
-0.6066898107528687,
0.0808737501502037,
0.1572790890932083,
-0.2508346438407898,
0.47644883394241333,
0.2888186275959015,
0.23619309067726135,
0.09955631196498871,
-0.200017511844635,
-0.04027145728468895,
-0.696006178855896,
0.0733112096786499,
0.4002460539340973,
0.046194981783628464,
-0.06352142244577408,
0.42799022793769836,
-0.26537519693374634,
0.5924882888793945,
0.09875795990228653,
0.14993314445018768,
0.10354597866535187,
-0.30638083815574646,
-0.306477427482605,
-0.17128247022628784,
0.7706034183502197,
0.10363940894603729,
0.1433834284543991,
-0.1447400003671646,
-0.4229185879230499,
-0.09686030447483063,
0.2720249891281128,
-0.936775267124176,
-0.35912710428237915,
0.417304664850235,
-0.4754737615585327,
-0.3904728889465332,
-0.4498942196369171,
-0.29164057970046997,
-0.09193963557481766,
-0.12096675485372543,
0.5067120790481567,
-0.6860503554344177,
-0.34792351722717285,
0.16758008301258087,
-0.005199919454753399,
0.04865143075585365,
0.4065656065940857,
-0.8190304636955261,
0.16365978121757507,
0.4816965162754059,
0.8956379890441895,
-0.35757288336753845,
0.0533340685069561,
-0.5382190346717834,
0.31647080183029175,
-0.3481476306915283,
0.33139166235923767,
-0.4841683506965637,
-0.3188186287879944,
0.1494620144367218,
-0.20924046635627747,
0.03985226899385452,
-0.6116029620170593,
0.23792052268981934,
-0.6996151208877563,
0.009267163462936878,
0.15124525129795074,
-0.5931367874145508,
0.000896783487405628,
0.32906824350357056,
-0.46021920442581177,
0.6425038576126099,
0.13082091510295868,
-0.729063093662262,
0.12022647261619568,
-0.449080228805542,
-0.37813621759414673,
-0.09470115602016449,
-0.12589485943317413,
-0.6015127897262573,
0.158115416765213,
-0.002662491286173463,
0.510897696018219,
-0.17078569531440735,
0.5188585519790649,
-0.11686837673187256,
-0.1137465089559555,
0.24695271253585815,
-0.6642550230026245,
0.7401891946792603,
0.265132337808609,
-0.3422395884990692,
0.2803918719291687,
-0.8547534346580505,
0.15204693377017975,
-0.030541805550456047,
-0.6587631702423096,
-0.6087383031845093,
0.1895732432603836,
-0.006373956333845854,
0.07350955158472061,
0.20242837071418762,
-0.39577966928482056,
0.09421014040708542,
-0.3950631618499756,
0.6327703595161438,
0.6270158290863037,
-0.09794352203607559,
0.9240042567253113,
-0.1418660432100296,
0.7862336039543152,
0.36645346879959106,
0.10675561428070068,
0.06616971641778946,
-0.34662801027297974,
-0.7547038793563843,
-0.18823875486850739,
0.5551567673683167,
0.494963675737381,
-1.1154297590255737,
0.43506819009780884,
-0.06202833727002144,
-0.27293267846107483,
-0.464397132396698,
-0.006786105688661337,
0.5080825686454773,
0.1556280553340912,
0.22192741930484772,
-0.1364206075668335,
0.031176676973700523,
-0.7848147749900818,
-0.05096333846449852,
0.378894567489624,
-0.21690824627876282,
0.1343296468257904,
0.29262712597846985,
-0.21065188944339752,
0.9541983604431152,
-0.38743847608566284,
0.07421234250068665,
0.12164777517318726,
0.2959950268268585,
-0.15403154492378235,
1.025916576385498,
0.3450441062450409,
-0.8597154021263123,
-0.37599799036979675,
0.05328678339719772,
-0.5607784986495972,
0.049280375242233276,
0.009397461079061031,
-0.1799408346414566,
0.31342414021492004,
0.6174854040145874,
-0.41212308406829834,
0.4948437213897705,
0.7108768820762634,
-0.41094809770584106,
0.23438532650470734,
-0.642605721950531,
-0.2786816656589508,
-1.011400580406189,
-0.01456165686249733,
-0.047847215086221695,
-0.4184737503528595,
-0.566404402256012,
-0.056996963918209076,
0.3120626211166382,
-0.059666115790605545,
-0.5418807864189148,
0.43025246262550354,
-0.248748779296875,
0.2734566628932953,
-0.3345807194709778,
0.1744481325149536,
0.024707835167646408,
0.4860352575778961,
-0.22766070067882538,
0.5687937140464783,
0.7013394832611084,
-0.8901413083076477,
0.18023933470249176,
0.12144352495670319,
-0.02176053635776043,
0.5932520031929016,
-0.8405492901802063,
-0.027653910219669342,
-0.28834226727485657,
0.15118388831615448,
-0.7522104382514954,
0.42505529522895813,
0.13508175313472748,
-0.2068549245595932,
0.47559675574302673,
-0.08838960528373718,
-0.31572574377059937,
0.023559411987662315,
-0.2284453809261322,
0.6867268085479736,
0.602916955947876,
-0.19508790969848633,
0.6008177399635315,
0.12406960129737854,
-0.08866483718156815,
-0.22454363107681274,
-0.6424771547317505,
-0.19226224720478058,
-0.2979643642902374,
-0.4717493951320648,
0.4725002944469452,
-0.3083547055721283,
-0.12839943170547485,
0.08756806701421738,
-0.008429775014519691,
-0.03520195931196213,
0.2906681299209595,
0.09453229606151581,
-0.28194570541381836,
-0.2021361142396927,
0.2901563346385956,
0.7015320062637329,
-0.3810741901397705,
-0.10631104558706284,
-0.5968974232673645,
0.42315587401390076,
0.14418081939220428,
-0.01626112312078476,
-0.30774199962615967,
0.34145665168762207,
0.23456475138664246,
-0.4708635210990906,
0.8614336252212524,
0.7154304385185242,
-0.31699469685554504,
-0.5245617628097534,
-0.05320427939295769,
0.06830941140651703,
-0.512175440788269,
0.24862493574619293,
-0.42103925347328186,
-1.2377135753631592,
0.4032060205936432,
-0.4022026062011719,
-0.09837216883897781,
0.15649056434631348,
0.6077873110771179,
-0.1028200089931488,
1.0171538591384888,
0.538167417049408,
0.2344890683889389,
0.48141753673553467,
-0.4619363248348236,
-0.025206906720995903,
-0.9349233508110046,
0.029444076120853424,
-0.4120301306247711,
-0.5166969299316406,
-0.6885346174240112,
-0.6930229067802429,
0.3096865713596344,
0.4253162443637848,
-0.4485355317592621,
0.13611766695976257,
-0.42384734749794006,
0.09920794516801834,
0.44343215227127075,
-0.004137350246310234,
0.18143330514431,
-0.0947989672422409,
-0.3596896231174469,
0.03430097550153732,
-0.8767155408859253,
-0.5109233856201172,
0.918587863445282,
0.3220500349998474,
0.7737380266189575,
0.3298301696777344,
0.6198964715003967,
0.3424277901649475,
0.09236828982830048,
-0.46104955673217773,
0.442402720451355,
-0.5370256900787354,
-0.12236002832651138,
-0.5091297030448914,
-0.46506914496421814,
-1.0464353561401367,
0.37973541021347046,
-0.07458332180976868,
-0.48447930812835693,
0.25459763407707214,
0.1726514846086502,
-0.6105488538742065,
0.06440868973731995,
-0.4895069897174835,
0.7611907124519348,
0.16831450164318085,
-0.3627737760543823,
-0.20229963958263397,
-0.30875954031944275,
0.23026403784751892,
-0.2001669853925705,
0.12607331573963165,
-0.15531717240810394,
-0.4257524013519287,
0.6246816515922546,
-0.7419814467430115,
0.7463786005973816,
-0.3579248785972595,
-0.7222715616226196,
0.18427467346191406,
0.3459620475769043,
0.7243250608444214,
0.21871644258499146,
-0.12866678833961487,
-0.10170800238847733,
-0.09651414304971695,
-0.5600770711898804,
-0.8212313652038574,
0.9933456778526306,
-0.5265046954154968,
-0.4933285415172577,
0.027866575866937637,
-0.6234888434410095,
-0.20814533531665802,
0.01119166612625122,
0.23021475970745087,
0.5556268692016602,
-0.03749321028590202,
0.14863334596157074,
0.8811532855033875,
-0.5963984727859497,
0.7601792812347412,
0.4238206744194031,
-0.23802712559700012,
-0.6416033506393433,
1.1751594543457031,
0.23710308969020844,
0.4983053207397461,
0.5209168791770935,
0.15476979315280914,
0.11763601750135422,
-0.7588967680931091,
-0.23802177608013153,
-0.11340484768152237,
-0.2950766980648041,
-0.28574976325035095,
-0.6290440559387207,
-0.1988263875246048,
-0.1503210961818695,
-0.21528804302215576,
-0.5309098958969116,
-0.6511739492416382,
-0.5461578965187073,
0.12448909878730774,
0.2802112400531769,
0.5562416911125183,
0.03254839405417442,
0.6774994134902954,
-0.7612873315811157,
0.29372596740722656,
0.37836018204689026,
0.4349421560764313,
0.1469210684299469,
-0.4730091392993927,
-0.4304271936416626,
0.20087191462516785,
-0.36504268646240234,
-0.6426151990890503,
0.4978349208831787,
0.18194179236888885,
0.28750723600387573,
0.34442463517189026,
-0.0323815681040287,
0.3523324131965637,
-0.6076485514640808,
0.6383938193321228,
0.004634722601622343,
-1.01638925075531,
0.5373899936676025,
-0.36715269088745117,
0.3083556890487671,
0.003514761570841074,
0.38474541902542114,
-0.12138322740793228,
-0.5261319279670715,
-0.5087019801139832,
-0.8861287832260132,
0.45284321904182434,
0.4911089837551117,
0.40544772148132324,
-0.039724163711071014,
0.3162399232387543,
-0.065142422914505,
0.4068969786167145,
-0.29877009987831116,
-0.3818339705467224,
-0.16643577814102173,
-0.18490302562713623,
0.024875694885849953,
-0.29445159435272217,
-0.054504428058862686,
-0.20939069986343384,
0.5183069705963135,
-0.16274704039096832,
0.2430531531572342,
0.09985488653182983,
0.0697469636797905,
-0.07236329466104507,
0.06648578494787216,
0.7925739884376526,
0.34535419940948486,
0.01774332858622074,
0.2576304078102112,
0.012064667418599129,
-0.2904096245765686,
0.4250553548336029,
0.0214824415743351,
-0.490357905626297,
0.02787204086780548,
-0.04656717926263809,
0.9905219674110413,
0.17238035798072815,
-0.4524860978126526,
0.5702637434005737,
-0.23456761240959167,
-0.2976500988006592,
-0.13726763427257538,
0.1579001396894455,
0.2622247338294983,
0.5230898857116699,
0.17070706188678741,
0.11106845736503601,
-0.048859719187021255,
0.10928545147180557,
0.08444809168577194,
0.6766812205314636,
-0.19979459047317505,
-0.3390445411205292,
0.9787040948867798,
0.3259868323802948,
-0.3806282877922058,
0.3935846984386444,
-0.47414785623550415,
-0.16215664148330688,
0.6730583310127258,
0.6741929650306702,
1.0619193315505981,
-0.34275010228157043,
0.4893747568130493,
0.19841787219047546,
0.14280596375465393,
0.014159616082906723,
0.343452125787735,
-0.17428772151470184,
-0.8949287533760071,
-0.4507216513156891,
-0.7579030990600586,
0.0036898881662636995,
-0.2949052155017853,
-0.5262727737426758,
-0.24195899069309235,
-0.6200483441352844,
-0.4563997983932495,
-0.37307339906692505,
-0.32515886425971985,
-0.43695592880249023,
0.25511619448661804,
-0.023646386340260506,
0.8385342359542847,
-0.5914903283119202,
1.212389349937439,
0.5087687969207764,
-0.21614070236682892,
-0.7187935709953308,
0.05565657094120979,
-0.549094557762146,
-0.35014742612838745,
0.7536989450454712,
-0.4064110815525055,
0.21690674126148224,
0.5164084434509277,
-0.4281884729862213,
-0.8410497903823853,
1.387511134147644,
0.40721699595451355,
-0.7394089102745056,
-0.04785284772515297,
-0.07740722596645355,
0.5306057333946228,
-0.1520513892173767,
0.04583963006734848,
0.49447497725486755,
0.35873183608055115,
-0.08455857634544373,
-0.6471803784370422,
0.13367018103599548,
0.02580222114920616,
0.6807793378829956,
0.33733513951301575,
-0.6473793387413025,
0.9219619631767273,
0.042657800018787384,
-0.1424420177936554,
0.13282057642936707,
0.8256359100341797,
0.279826283454895,
0.13489101827144623,
0.3270476460456848,
0.7316480278968811,
0.7982699275016785,
0.005716502666473389,
0.9734991788864136,
-0.27161169052124023,
0.36606186628341675,
0.9132620692253113,
-0.16999810934066772,
0.8936913013458252,
0.5948817729949951,
-0.37504616379737854,
0.42577409744262695,
0.07694925367832184,
0.2919170558452606,
0.6376560926437378,
0.6825141906738281,
-0.5294191837310791,
-0.1394626498222351,
0.01965215802192688,
-0.14538080990314484,
0.0930253267288208,
0.35828763246536255,
-0.29668524861335754,
-0.17667989432811737,
0.5953413844108582,
-0.06529365479946136,
0.09701507538557053,
-0.35617178678512573,
0.5935165882110596,
0.1540887951850891,
-0.2171703428030014,
0.9584271311759949,
0.19960817694664001,
0.9759431481361389,
-0.5613940954208374,
0.07908923178911209,
-0.45421725511550903,
0.045445144176483154,
-0.08975955098867416,
-0.42130976915359497,
0.31217628717422485,
-0.09341837465763092,
-0.19293376803398132,
-0.40753307938575745,
0.4255319833755493,
-0.684922993183136,
-0.29686006903648376,
0.22845587134361267,
0.48126840591430664,
-0.16479577124118805,
-0.1165618747472763,
-0.5502856373786926,
0.14499831199645996,
0.01308547891676426,
-0.5886976718902588,
0.560972273349762,
0.7725118398666382,
-0.16335798799991608,
0.8260297775268555,
0.41608843207359314,
0.1839662492275238,
0.48165881633758545,
-0.03768109157681465,
0.841004490852356,
-0.5607960224151611,
-0.2869299650192261,
-0.7512800097465515,
0.5675168633460999,
0.39811602234840393,
-0.1800505369901657,
0.6311405897140503,
0.35194292664527893,
0.6250470280647278,
-0.21506845951080322,
0.765800416469574,
-0.15366922318935394,
-0.0034917546436190605,
-0.6333374977111816,
0.9909827709197998,
-0.6243210434913635,
0.1617857962846756,
-0.049925919622182846,
-0.7517164349555969,
-0.3940960168838501,
0.49570783972740173,
0.05613567680120468,
0.12943577766418457,
0.6785011887550354,
0.8193141222000122,
0.16342273354530334,
-0.5097277760505676,
0.6016700267791748,
0.2586477994918823,
0.44299963116645813,
0.6886757016181946,
0.6247778534889221,
-0.504062831401825,
0.5082572102546692,
-0.30347204208374023,
-0.0010950573487207294,
0.07377443462610245,
-0.9676238298416138,
-0.624826192855835,
-0.5990692377090454,
-0.7501659989356995,
-0.3616376519203186,
0.06082010641694069,
0.5195367932319641,
0.5512650609016418,
-0.8564164638519287,
0.036810778081417084,
-0.6768902540206909,
0.15616929531097412,
-0.05277204513549805,
-0.2250545620918274,
0.4385387897491455,
-0.4731422960758209,
-0.9727022051811218,
0.28442350029945374,
0.328421413898468,
0.3049227297306061,
-0.42783892154693604,
-0.41830575466156006,
-0.0883793756365776,
0.05897616222500801,
0.6710891127586365,
0.09038230031728745,
-0.5401571989059448,
0.002047067042440176,
-0.3337813913822174,
-0.3996334969997406,
-0.23272734880447388,
0.8794443011283875,
-0.8263397812843323,
0.3309652507305145,
0.5206020474433899,
0.843619704246521,
0.23255835473537445,
-0.10245782881975174,
0.8458918333053589,
-0.9545236825942993,
0.23858819901943207,
0.3045949935913086,
0.1602260023355484,
0.09787066280841827,
-0.0930255874991417,
0.15177546441555023,
0.0738709419965744,
-0.5927321314811707,
-0.5529548525810242,
0.05816882103681564,
-0.9216814041137695,
-0.3167829215526581,
1.074844241142273,
-0.395873099565506,
-0.25265219807624817,
0.08101867884397507,
-0.3321114182472229,
0.4620317816734314,
-0.33657604455947876,
0.3339824378490448,
0.3976854085922241,
0.175254225730896,
-0.2007320523262024,
-0.30844467878341675,
0.6593602299690247,
0.6401805281639099,
-0.5963132381439209,
-0.003673975123092532,
0.18838408589363098,
0.20262500643730164,
-0.011568548157811165,
0.6636636257171631,
0.07873046398162842,
0.07337845861911774,
-0.200871542096138,
0.11664792895317078,
-0.08856125921010971,
-0.04974454268813133,
-0.7748867273330688,
0.3416045010089874,
0.1805342584848404,
-0.28158894181251526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10104v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10104v2 | GeoEval: Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs and Multi-Modal Models on Geometry Problem-Solving | 2024-02-15T16:59:41 | 2024-05-17T11:42:09 | Jiaxin Zhang, Zhongzhi Li, Mingliang Zhang, Fei Yin, Chenglin Liu, Yashar Moshfeghi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) and multi-modal models
(MMs) have demonstrated their remarkable capabilities in problem-solving. Yet,
their proficiency in tackling geometry math problems, which necessitates an
integrated understanding of both textual and visual information, has not been
thoroughly evaluated. To address this gap, we introduce the GeoEval benchmark,
a comprehensive collection that includes a main subset of 2,000 problems, a 750
problems subset focusing on backward reasoning, an augmented subset of 2,000
problems, and a hard subset of 300 problems. This benchmark facilitates a
deeper investigation into the performance of LLMs and MMs in solving geometry
math problems. Our evaluation of ten LLMs and MMs across these varied subsets
reveals that the WizardMath model excels, achieving a 55.67\% accuracy rate on
the main subset but only a 6.00\% accuracy on the hard subset. This highlights
the critical need for testing models against datasets on which they have not
been pre-trained. Additionally, our findings indicate that GPT-series models
perform more effectively on problems they have rephrased, suggesting a
promising method for enhancing model capabilities. | [
-0.23772016167640686,
-0.9278768301010132,
0.7012929320335388,
0.3144916892051697,
0.09543875604867935,
0.0006788623286411166,
-0.18020035326480865,
-0.1809075027704239,
-0.19573724269866943,
0.2052580565214157,
-0.7033903002738953,
-0.762083888053894,
-0.6578078866004944,
0.08155152201652527,
-0.4235105812549591,
0.7437692284584045,
-0.22440661489963531,
0.2936617434024811,
-0.5293574929237366,
-0.14474773406982422,
-0.5268060564994812,
-0.6987797021865845,
0.016116458922624588,
-0.10030611604452133,
0.1973448097705841,
0.02171850949525833,
0.8796852827072144,
0.38450562953948975,
0.8512820601463318,
0.3492511510848999,
-0.1376497745513916,
0.3680482506752014,
-0.640993058681488,
0.15578745305538177,
-0.04137025028467178,
-0.2965397834777832,
-0.49240511655807495,
0.15434306859970093,
0.6798781156539917,
1.045512080192566,
-0.38052940368652344,
0.44728562235832214,
0.14271357655525208,
0.6998240947723389,
-0.7122665047645569,
0.24507789313793182,
-0.45720478892326355,
-0.13222524523735046,
-0.09189935028553009,
-0.07891569286584854,
-0.10589399933815002,
-0.6259911060333252,
0.35510414838790894,
-1.126222014427185,
0.31659138202667236,
0.19378283619880676,
0.57265704870224,
0.3805876672267914,
-0.28672555088996887,
-0.30828729271888733,
-0.7987512350082397,
0.7513517737388611,
-0.29707908630371094,
0.758008599281311,
0.40167325735092163,
0.47623753547668457,
-0.3627336323261261,
-0.5030181407928467,
-0.07091548293828964,
-0.32705724239349365,
0.1295449286699295,
0.21415171027183533,
-0.1297985464334488,
-0.30319544672966003,
0.5517076253890991,
0.30035629868507385,
-0.8088955879211426,
-0.3440461754798889,
-0.6126022934913635,
-0.22692354023456573,
0.5006103515625,
0.4690323770046234,
0.0718216598033905,
-0.38877853751182556,
-0.34459343552589417,
0.05614856630563736,
-0.8784237504005432,
-0.004733203444629908,
0.24208854138851166,
0.2653023302555084,
0.040406350046396255,
0.8431551456451416,
-0.27160587906837463,
0.604069709777832,
-0.44423708319664,
-0.27069732546806335,
0.16251979768276215,
-0.37526145577430725,
-0.35237276554107666,
-0.46673548221588135,
0.27817821502685547,
0.2886585593223572,
0.3861965537071228,
-0.006531327031552792,
-0.063203826546669,
0.08953285962343216,
0.021007169038057327,
-0.7652738690376282,
-0.2832913398742676,
-0.04048284515738487,
-0.345899760723114,
0.22717580199241638,
-0.28202301263809204,
-0.7598254084587097,
-0.5341702103614807,
-0.7684497237205505,
0.31692221760749817,
-0.47153332829475403,
-0.197730153799057,
0.251944363117218,
0.15363013744354248,
0.08738021552562714,
0.5105754137039185,
-0.5801935195922852,
0.21020133793354034,
1.0271925926208496,
0.88920658826828,
0.07174676656723022,
-0.6230841279029846,
-0.6759157776832581,
-0.0488661527633667,
-0.4940636456012726,
1.0061945915222168,
-0.6686547994613647,
-0.7243393063545227,
0.013777513056993484,
-0.1891542375087738,
-0.20672520995140076,
-0.5649672150611877,
0.5698000192642212,
-0.39518046379089355,
0.2559814751148224,
-0.5827693343162537,
-0.5350933074951172,
-0.3045973777770996,
0.6118704080581665,
-0.5791055560112,
1.2718660831451416,
0.13475476205348969,
-0.3224320113658905,
0.36371690034866333,
-0.21015436947345734,
0.09656894207000732,
0.11658970266580582,
-0.26054826378822327,
-0.2752601206302643,
0.602615475654602,
0.47086089849472046,
-0.050124507397413254,
-0.655251681804657,
0.26243171095848083,
-0.5082399845123291,
-0.4111168086528778,
-0.10345064103603363,
-0.6139999628067017,
0.2592979073524475,
-0.047517646104097366,
0.013866066932678223,
0.02140825241804123,
-0.6519513726234436,
0.32775551080703735,
0.06948240101337433,
-0.2668174207210541,
-0.27092230319976807,
0.06496389955282211,
0.11664116382598877,
0.17660726606845856,
0.3294898271560669,
-0.1515337973833084,
0.1263365000486374,
-0.182697132229805,
-0.11722166836261749,
0.7481431365013123,
-0.360439270734787,
-0.04763219505548477,
-0.15095126628875732,
0.49761489033699036,
-0.36648815870285034,
0.1901053488254547,
-0.11638643592596054,
-0.5757319927215576,
-0.5286656022071838,
-0.39051729440689087,
0.0682128295302391,
0.6044515371322632,
-0.40784743428230286,
0.0026632784865796566,
-0.3898010551929474,
-0.7156749367713928,
-0.2018350064754486,
0.2324073761701584,
0.49663129448890686,
0.5524425506591797,
0.6797528266906738,
-0.02738053910434246,
-0.009606399573385715,
-0.8180282711982727,
-0.6658811569213867,
-0.09721435606479645,
-0.1584114134311676,
0.4776231050491333,
0.5937620997428894,
0.2732289135456085,
0.7770233750343323,
-0.6000319719314575,
-0.1070532351732254,
0.14907188713550568,
0.28353554010391235,
0.1940799355506897,
0.08642352372407913,
0.40242594480514526,
-0.5571879744529724,
-0.3982107937335968,
-0.11887070536613464,
-0.9908209443092346,
-0.211297869682312,
0.4186391830444336,
0.0830579474568367,
0.11710570007562637,
0.3593462407588959,
-0.47605395317077637,
0.885266900062561,
0.5691198706626892,
-0.5214162468910217,
0.8004651665687561,
-0.40414461493492126,
0.36768636107444763,
-0.7815907597541809,
0.09531236439943314,
0.263908714056015,
-0.09371662139892578,
-0.34653353691101074,
-0.11879438906908035,
0.06686731427907944,
-0.48297542333602905,
-0.43228879570961,
0.4153863191604614,
-0.7131320238113403,
-0.4666149914264679,
-0.09101328998804092,
0.1596428006887436,
0.057933177798986435,
0.3818839490413666,
0.004238883964717388,
1.0550189018249512,
0.5917216539382935,
-0.3074861168861389,
0.6059055924415588,
0.25110384821891785,
-0.4748183488845825,
1.0744725465774536,
-0.9157620072364807,
-0.018637914210557938,
-0.2027098536491394,
0.022787151858210564,
-0.9484687447547913,
-0.01628347486257553,
-0.11703607439994812,
-0.046396005898714066,
-0.07041697204113007,
-0.2873412072658539,
-0.6111867427825928,
-0.2920376658439636,
-0.2408272922039032,
0.6057778596878052,
0.3729158639907837,
-0.6602129936218262,
0.8823651671409607,
0.04506606608629227,
-0.3288268446922302,
-0.5087756514549255,
-0.23714818060398102,
-0.11817966401576996,
-0.2746770977973938,
-0.7647095918655396,
0.19114796817302704,
-0.02752736583352089,
-0.23884376883506775,
0.10058121383190155,
-0.26430678367614746,
0.08502127975225449,
0.009728762321174145,
0.23774410784244537,
0.5448572635650635,
-0.4239700436592102,
0.19771264493465424,
-0.4091619551181793,
-0.47075918316841125,
0.10064730793237686,
-0.1937236785888672,
0.4997823238372803,
-0.6731489300727844,
-0.9767990112304688,
-0.38378801941871643,
0.37656939029693604,
0.6131687164306641,
-0.4507637023925781,
0.5775042772293091,
0.13757167756557465,
-0.5997182130813599,
0.19515085220336914,
-0.7305898666381836,
0.14373686909675598,
-0.44500207901000977,
0.6554529666900635,
-0.6522306799888611,
-0.3896924555301666,
0.5225384831428528,
-0.32162484526634216,
-0.06579329818487167,
0.406236469745636,
0.527687668800354,
0.268703818321228,
1.0946472883224487,
0.6167613863945007,
-0.1525019407272339,
0.09030478447675705,
-0.1408260017633438,
0.07937953621149063,
-0.7951334118843079,
-0.5042327046394348,
-0.5593875646591187,
-0.1898600459098816,
-0.4972558617591858,
-0.5478435158729553,
0.7769047617912292,
0.3451496958732605,
-0.3416264057159424,
0.2028268426656723,
-0.37856525182724,
0.8345959186553955,
0.2947096824645996,
-0.14640195667743683,
0.707615852355957,
0.14763693511486053,
-0.07505734264850616,
-0.2778087556362152,
-0.3595845103263855,
-0.5756433606147766,
1.381210207939148,
0.054060399532318115,
1.0184361934661865,
0.45959994196891785,
0.1062045693397522,
-0.07382015138864517,
0.48518508672714233,
-0.5452738404273987,
0.3733389675617218,
0.007068573497235775,
-0.7234005331993103,
-0.15409040451049805,
-0.47698545455932617,
-0.7100640535354614,
0.6088590621948242,
-0.1342599093914032,
-0.8493881225585938,
-0.012336743995547295,
-0.02811199240386486,
-0.3576923608779907,
0.3499370813369751,
-0.6628426909446716,
0.8967550992965698,
-0.4012402892112732,
-0.5279562473297119,
-0.4053243398666382,
-0.15319642424583435,
0.25289538502693176,
0.10283853858709335,
0.14084291458129883,
-0.4477047026157379,
-0.1175088882446289,
0.3261701464653015,
-0.41513490676879883,
0.3675757050514221,
-0.0902978703379631,
0.07800363004207611,
0.10978367179632187,
0.3954834043979645,
0.26085638999938965,
0.46434909105300903,
0.031004494056105614,
0.3051801025867462,
0.2009073793888092,
-0.531497061252594,
-0.680786669254303,
0.7387514114379883,
-0.8876283168792725,
-0.7040995955467224,
-0.5902260541915894,
-0.7014642953872681,
-0.3783758580684662,
0.10068031400442123,
0.07784096151590347,
1.0408722162246704,
-0.4412001073360443,
0.02357342094182968,
0.5784632563591003,
-0.011128244921565056,
0.292815238237381,
0.4242064356803894,
-0.5958104729652405,
-0.624115526676178,
0.6860634088516235,
0.18388956785202026,
0.1976257562637329,
-0.06375979632139206,
0.07178665697574615,
-0.5594774484634399,
-0.4970148205757141,
-0.5920782685279846,
0.323707640171051,
-0.8874594569206238,
-0.17436483502388,
-0.21707507967948914,
-0.24274715781211853,
-0.033016979694366455,
-0.046531226485967636,
-0.5557643175125122,
-0.345468133687973,
-0.09710864722728729,
0.2758360207080841,
0.2684118449687958,
0.9944599866867065,
0.08497115224599838,
0.0994776263833046,
-0.6475269794464111,
0.17735342681407928,
0.3451055884361267,
0.5245378613471985,
-0.17415525019168854,
-0.3699245750904083,
0.039214957505464554,
-0.23220837116241455,
-0.4482291042804718,
-0.6252787113189697,
0.2628926634788513,
-0.016551246866583824,
0.5599170327186584,
-0.0005433863261714578,
-0.46425142884254456,
0.9824374318122864,
-0.750137984752655,
0.6388687491416931,
0.02163117192685604,
-0.9689568877220154,
0.44710132479667664,
-0.44398924708366394,
0.1651155948638916,
0.6239681839942932,
0.5155611038208008,
-0.5299325585365295,
0.13560719788074493,
-0.34971627593040466,
-0.5206860303878784,
0.2987063527107239,
0.09303537011146545,
-0.16673053801059723,
0.22755563259124756,
0.3629186451435089,
0.03156999126076698,
0.17312075197696686,
-0.3654952645301819,
-0.010664560832083225,
-0.1986432522535324,
-0.13046161830425262,
-0.18267972767353058,
-0.20115028321743011,
-0.25545012950897217,
-0.3474443256855011,
0.4599846303462982,
-0.21167856454849243,
0.0018839541589841247,
0.26049140095710754,
-0.42347046732902527,
0.05460016056895256,
0.09839826077222824,
0.8784334063529968,
1.2837063074111938,
-0.1656705141067505,
-0.12224950641393661,
0.47886839509010315,
-0.5456811189651489,
-0.11159060895442963,
0.632802426815033,
0.1937699168920517,
-0.19615675508975983,
0.37808436155319214,
0.3391920030117035,
0.09257933497428894,
-0.4571857452392578,
0.53105229139328,
-0.11109107732772827,
-0.13560719788074493,
-0.24529269337654114,
-0.2717709243297577,
0.11828324943780899,
0.3104574680328369,
0.5090281367301941,
0.04021550342440605,
0.12691602110862732,
-0.16225503385066986,
-0.03886823356151581,
0.6867252588272095,
-0.18082056939601898,
-0.46333804726600647,
0.5755136609077454,
0.14967656135559082,
-0.28359970450401306,
0.8667407631874084,
0.026135984808206558,
-0.6505577564239502,
0.6085135340690613,
0.4615161120891571,
0.5929714441299438,
-0.03208830580115318,
0.06530597060918808,
0.4767759144306183,
0.2971832752227783,
0.06633620709180832,
0.3954218029975891,
0.0836922898888588,
-0.22721025347709656,
-0.5147278308868408,
-0.42830008268356323,
-0.6613840460777283,
0.02159949578344822,
-0.5686500072479248,
0.3294151723384857,
-0.5822553038597107,
0.03947804868221283,
-0.2741933763027191,
0.18981467187404633,
-0.9621061086654663,
-0.0037205955013632774,
0.20952247083187103,
0.962351381778717,
-0.6969975829124451,
0.23017805814743042,
0.5245814919471741,
-0.215669646859169,
-0.67973792552948,
-0.1064659133553505,
0.4768502116203308,
-0.9283944964408875,
0.6028915643692017,
0.29378917813301086,
-0.4789363741874695,
-0.15448732674121857,
-0.2612934708595276,
-1.2123398780822754,
1.2664579153060913,
0.33207929134368896,
-0.37153083086013794,
0.04419897496700287,
0.3704719543457031,
0.45927321910858154,
-0.16890767216682434,
0.6798100471496582,
0.5603986382484436,
0.39248669147491455,
0.17747583985328674,
-1.1554625034332275,
-0.18639090657234192,
-0.19859589636325836,
0.20089299976825714,
0.3746630549430847,
-0.6224936246871948,
0.9417195320129395,
-0.08634582906961441,
-0.20810596644878387,
0.41680046916007996,
0.6501587629318237,
0.608101487159729,
0.3677211105823517,
0.2886786162853241,
0.7839221358299255,
1.0644291639328003,
-0.43216198682785034,
1.1347044706344604,
-0.2858068645000458,
0.764658510684967,
0.9382315278053284,
-0.477090984582901,
0.7695496678352356,
0.16923944652080536,
-0.3714481294155121,
0.4394322633743286,
0.6518880724906921,
0.01426305528730154,
0.4375578463077545,
0.3733254671096802,
-0.1514827311038971,
-0.5292840003967285,
-0.12724797427654266,
-1.0574458837509155,
0.35751479864120483,
0.4108779728412628,
0.29943376779556274,
-0.8114835023880005,
-0.3045397698879242,
-0.11370357871055603,
0.1994810402393341,
-0.4672698676586151,
0.3836284875869751,
-0.04601304978132248,
-0.37646856904029846,
0.4963254928588867,
-0.19428223371505737,
0.33201172947883606,
-0.5655819177627563,
0.0037454760167747736,
-0.32283422350883484,
0.2727486789226532,
-0.11544907093048096,
-0.5702062845230103,
0.30738121271133423,
-0.038484565913677216,
-0.19573652744293213,
0.054372191429138184,
0.5328699946403503,
-0.22176232933998108,
-1.0270862579345703,
0.014969159848988056,
0.9745479822158813,
0.02627168782055378,
-0.1515788733959198,
-0.6813603639602661,
-0.04326452314853668,
-0.683620810508728,
-0.2951849400997162,
-0.06353305280208588,
0.4406511187553406,
-0.13341237604618073,
0.715153694152832,
0.7945718169212341,
-0.0315885990858078,
0.16886338591575623,
0.11623687297105789,
1.046776294708252,
-0.7251009941101074,
-0.37380537390708923,
-0.8793628811836243,
0.4227854609489441,
-0.15622524917125702,
-0.7024790048599243,
0.918368399143219,
0.9253435730934143,
0.5854536294937134,
0.19084379076957703,
0.3931882083415985,
0.42147091031074524,
0.4461570084095001,
-0.6353627443313599,
0.4017646610736847,
-0.6262128353118896,
0.2995772063732147,
-0.16494786739349365,
-1.2855439186096191,
-0.44849202036857605,
0.43059027194976807,
-0.9459745287895203,
0.30883145332336426,
0.938057005405426,
0.7071594595909119,
-0.27125635743141174,
0.3969956636428833,
0.29541727900505066,
-0.27524682879447937,
0.4424982964992523,
0.8029472231864929,
1.3875386714935303,
-0.34341365098953247,
0.6330628395080566,
0.0475575216114521,
-0.36240556836128235,
0.005671139806509018,
-1.03243887424469,
-1.0440562963485718,
-0.15912002325057983,
-0.06624332070350647,
-0.3141683340072632,
0.0041930885054171085,
0.879072368144989,
0.7859291434288025,
-0.5309633016586304,
-0.1601230502128601,
0.04388975724577904,
0.19534486532211304,
-0.07012844830751419,
-0.08735576272010803,
0.6243908405303955,
-0.35469919443130493,
-0.7010292410850525,
0.5109487771987915,
0.4336388409137726,
-0.06302335858345032,
-0.44857707619667053,
0.12847363948822021,
0.11146007478237152,
0.02306918427348137,
0.386675626039505,
0.06046140193939209,
-0.7149809002876282,
-0.2858665883541107,
0.34057581424713135,
-0.01629667542874813,
0.09844232350587845,
0.9833036661148071,
-0.856387734413147,
0.3276076912879944,
0.4484514892101288,
0.7357071042060852,
0.5024165511131287,
0.25379088521003723,
0.3168334662914276,
-0.33092013001441956,
-0.006052662618458271,
-0.05302353948354721,
0.4358387887477875,
0.477154403924942,
-0.07028375566005707,
0.5182738304138184,
0.5039876699447632,
-0.6807458996772766,
-0.7025222778320312,
0.2508337199687958,
-0.4618317484855652,
-0.13252098858356476,
0.8038989901542664,
0.03733542189002037,
-0.28247755765914917,
0.07648824155330658,
0.05730687081813812,
-0.35420945286750793,
0.05088552460074425,
0.5952504873275757,
1.0148686170578003,
-0.18292012810707092,
0.24065299332141876,
-0.8761541247367859,
0.31701359152793884,
0.7831026315689087,
-0.9980185031890869,
0.14002196490764618,
0.8338524103164673,
0.44339391589164734,
0.23959119617938995,
0.3583594560623169,
-0.1818535476922989,
0.40057528018951416,
-0.010643627494573593,
-0.3142368495464325,
-0.23551176488399506,
-0.8272499442100525,
-0.39333632588386536,
0.20957905054092407,
-0.11411603540182114,
0.05196421965956688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10076v1 | QUICK: Quantization-aware Interleaving and Conflict-free Kernel for efficient LLM inference | 2024-02-15T16:38:41 | 2024-02-15T16:38:41 | Taesu Kim, Jongho Lee, Daehyun Ahn, Sarang Kim, Jiwoong Choi, Minkyu Kim, Hyungjun Kim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce QUICK, a group of novel optimized CUDA kernels for the efficient
inference of quantized Large Language Models (LLMs). QUICK addresses the shared
memory bank-conflict problem of state-of-the-art mixed precision matrix
multiplication kernels. Our method interleaves the quantized weight matrices of
LLMs offline to skip the shared memory write-back after the dequantization. We
demonstrate up to 1.91x speedup over existing kernels of AutoAWQ on larger
batches and up to 1.94x throughput gain on representative LLM models on various
NVIDIA GPU devices. | [
-0.2768253982067108,
-1.0812808275222778,
0.5178358554840088,
0.5643438696861267,
-0.3020986020565033,
0.20682933926582336,
-0.15108442306518555,
-0.22082193195819855,
0.08426088839769363,
0.22712677717208862,
-0.1248004361987114,
-0.32656586170196533,
-0.6561648845672607,
-0.15716521441936493,
-0.5753082036972046,
0.6441569328308105,
0.02266933210194111,
-0.04607074707746506,
-0.474400132894516,
-0.3889523148536682,
0.012743572704494,
-0.6255629062652588,
-0.7846447229385376,
0.07958303391933441,
0.6029863357543945,
0.40855541825294495,
0.9516502618789673,
0.6945170760154724,
0.49000510573387146,
0.3334541320800781,
-0.24760280549526215,
0.10449476540088654,
-0.2538783848285675,
0.25393611192703247,
0.27585774660110474,
-0.5700973272323608,
-0.7206028699874878,
-0.12019647657871246,
0.7518193125724792,
0.3682343363761902,
-0.30330318212509155,
0.16163378953933716,
0.020837606862187386,
0.6138978600502014,
-1.042185664176941,
-0.08835731446743011,
-0.38375282287597656,
0.2072766125202179,
-0.3406604826450348,
0.04724834859371185,
-0.4938809871673584,
-0.8229666352272034,
-0.1434594690799713,
-0.9413549900054932,
0.1852882206439972,
0.07630573958158493,
0.5165480971336365,
0.6204656362533569,
-0.7396571636199951,
-0.10956647992134094,
-0.5778914093971252,
0.8518285751342773,
-0.7493853569030762,
0.5790635943412781,
0.36307185888290405,
0.34235429763793945,
-0.07062327861785889,
-1.1454188823699951,
-0.8151162266731262,
0.265846848487854,
0.0003880903241224587,
0.02125324122607708,
-0.3960108160972595,
0.36769968271255493,
0.4896080195903778,
0.5470912456512451,
-0.26918497681617737,
0.158869206905365,
0.02312791533768177,
-0.3168313503265381,
0.31497469544410706,
0.2699497938156128,
0.00003971149635617621,
0.07714388519525528,
-0.39247798919677734,
-0.10315485298633575,
-0.7647409439086914,
0.1913232058286667,
0.27952656149864197,
-0.280992716550827,
-0.22775468230247498,
0.2878160774707794,
-0.10932079702615738,
0.6853227019309998,
0.24965178966522217,
-0.034436579793691635,
-0.1847507208585739,
-0.4176238179206848,
-0.5942968130111694,
0.035669539123773575,
0.7523664832115173,
0.1008373275399208,
-0.1462656706571579,
-0.1569788157939911,
-0.23478694260120392,
0.26831063628196716,
-0.24393266439437866,
-0.949996829032898,
-0.43392032384872437,
0.3459039032459259,
-0.39143985509872437,
0.012577529065310955,
-0.4976508915424347,
-0.5849837064743042,
-0.10518444329500198,
-0.08634291589260101,
0.8491443395614624,
-0.5090067982673645,
-0.14107440412044525,
0.002212859457358718,
0.16594955325126648,
0.24803605675697327,
0.3011445999145508,
-0.8547928929328918,
0.27089229226112366,
0.7554364800453186,
0.6926108598709106,
0.02394765056669712,
0.08380819857120514,
-1.1714744567871094,
0.21975941956043243,
-0.3277798295021057,
0.5770343542098999,
-0.3046181797981262,
-0.395859956741333,
-0.28852251172065735,
-0.3184729814529419,
0.07134085148572922,
-0.6508510112762451,
0.5465220808982849,
-0.7656237483024597,
-0.08650844544172287,
-0.3989918529987335,
-0.7680341601371765,
-0.18234005570411682,
0.027334509417414665,
-0.7922355532646179,
1.1333426237106323,
0.11864591389894485,
-0.7705222368240356,
0.38374626636505127,
-0.1487400382757187,
-0.30194222927093506,
0.1378987431526184,
-0.08652433753013611,
-0.537628173828125,
0.2281094789505005,
0.1617073267698288,
0.4352888762950897,
-0.19888073205947876,
0.6372333765029907,
-0.6043521761894226,
-0.43081843852996826,
0.11406046152114868,
-0.12211122363805771,
0.911255955696106,
0.6190412044525146,
-0.01765444315969944,
0.38897234201431274,
-0.6740937829017639,
0.16511234641075134,
-0.14442132413387299,
-0.4234568178653717,
-0.5840208530426025,
-0.06422298401594162,
-0.3666287958621979,
0.019632305949926376,
0.34269723296165466,
-0.35660529136657715,
0.28168073296546936,
0.22210125625133514,
0.6175434589385986,
0.73458331823349,
-0.310075044631958,
0.5742713809013367,
-0.08871670067310333,
0.4279651641845703,
0.4496758282184601,
0.49426203966140747,
-0.056762974709272385,
-0.5281103253364563,
-1.0948835611343384,
-0.7094593644142151,
0.5560705065727234,
0.5234038829803467,
-1.1182748079299927,
0.09321514517068863,
0.08520151674747467,
-0.19258010387420654,
-0.869184136390686,
0.06100395321846008,
0.687162458896637,
0.5821412205696106,
0.2518281638622284,
-0.0657905787229538,
-0.44231268763542175,
-1.118667721748352,
-0.34564727544784546,
0.08579429984092712,
0.13524791598320007,
0.0830761268734932,
0.033039651811122894,
-0.3266647160053253,
0.9163719415664673,
-0.3295772671699524,
0.2184053361415863,
0.1040666475892067,
0.22862422466278076,
0.14932774007320404,
0.4407370984554291,
0.4333427846431732,
-0.6636121869087219,
-0.7942224144935608,
-0.3425051271915436,
-0.6875748038291931,
-0.22581882774829865,
0.11373855173587799,
-0.2835143208503723,
0.28314948081970215,
0.7230553030967712,
-0.42733025550842285,
0.3877130150794983,
0.8090611100196838,
-0.480037659406662,
0.12635251879692078,
-0.5092604160308838,
0.18538478016853333,
-0.9220384359359741,
-0.22267040610313416,
-0.0031407331116497517,
-0.5128122568130493,
-0.7268133759498596,
0.10717243701219559,
0.7466722726821899,
0.35785147547721863,
-0.5886783599853516,
0.556654155254364,
-0.26842400431632996,
-0.26640719175338745,
0.07095202058553696,
-0.10228326916694641,
0.11516443639993668,
0.3887147903442383,
-0.2255295366048813,
1.1748991012573242,
0.5106780529022217,
-0.8813964128494263,
0.043688978999853134,
0.22668352723121643,
-0.3825884163379669,
0.44773614406585693,
-0.46781742572784424,
0.05653033033013344,
-0.045277468860149384,
0.10537149757146835,
-0.8597243428230286,
0.1911524534225464,
-0.12199346721172333,
-0.10942138731479645,
0.07261136174201965,
0.0276801697909832,
-0.6706709861755371,
-0.09366047382354736,
-0.22516727447509766,
0.8685281872749329,
0.43867766857147217,
-0.8087710738182068,
0.6764620542526245,
0.37941741943359375,
-0.025725893676280975,
-0.6093848943710327,
-0.6100994944572449,
-0.030969832092523575,
-0.3163919746875763,
-0.6592256426811218,
0.19048486649990082,
-0.48386237025260925,
-0.6500318646430969,
-0.023245157673954964,
0.10573004186153412,
-0.4808357059955597,
0.24907340109348297,
0.26328223943710327,
0.12613248825073242,
-0.2284383326768875,
0.08838815987110138,
0.45417243242263794,
-0.2107192873954773,
-0.29564613103866577,
0.188280388712883,
0.2627485394477844,
-0.3997651934623718,
0.04179522395133972,
-0.4264368414878845,
0.5248392820358276,
0.23084545135498047,
-0.03902648016810417,
0.5264766216278076,
0.6522091627120972,
-0.28116846084594727,
0.054258085787296295,
-0.7395332455635071,
-0.10680998861789703,
-0.526684045791626,
0.009491047821938992,
-0.4646875262260437,
-1.317872405052185,
0.7229107618331909,
-0.07930613309144974,
-0.011505809612572193,
0.4582631587982178,
0.5060592889785767,
-0.1315060406923294,
0.7333895564079285,
0.704137921333313,
0.22429250180721283,
0.38674822449684143,
-0.31765517592430115,
0.364780068397522,
-0.8258941769599915,
-0.08798866719007492,
-0.27452513575553894,
-0.5122249126434326,
-0.33257874846458435,
-0.6855223774909973,
0.46876126527786255,
0.5316731333732605,
-0.24273300170898438,
0.2189899981021881,
-0.1536131203174591,
0.5197881460189819,
0.9146882891654968,
0.03635261952877045,
0.5306949615478516,
-0.2876798212528229,
-0.34791889786720276,
-0.16492792963981628,
-0.8414585590362549,
0.03543034568428993,
0.9019010663032532,
0.07160919159650803,
0.7341292500495911,
0.09427991509437561,
0.6142707467079163,
0.3499142825603485,
0.33616548776626587,
-0.6086013317108154,
0.7105677127838135,
-0.2697902321815491,
-0.34592458605766296,
0.015350256115198135,
-0.6427852511405945,
-0.5973835587501526,
0.2711164057254791,
-0.21109607815742493,
-0.24613790214061737,
0.32023629546165466,
0.40190961956977844,
-1.0426292419433594,
0.48689690232276917,
-1.0759282112121582,
0.6276437640190125,
0.01078119594603777,
-0.43697595596313477,
-0.554791271686554,
-0.4374643862247467,
0.9659183621406555,
-0.41296032071113586,
0.10559007525444031,
-0.1593029499053955,
-0.1636945754289627,
0.8383395075798035,
-0.5174607634544373,
0.45630261301994324,
-0.009539916180074215,
-0.2520555257797241,
0.5209668278694153,
0.3318397104740143,
0.5439131259918213,
0.26647576689720154,
-0.02424796298146248,
0.49998539686203003,
0.09107641130685806,
-0.2886757254600525,
-0.347739577293396,
0.9286285638809204,
-0.6072673797607422,
-0.5260217189788818,
-0.2081626057624817,
-0.8579255938529968,
-0.18316633999347687,
-0.07458622008562088,
0.1326473355293274,
0.2746118903160095,
0.20499645173549652,
0.024458477273583412,
0.9239158034324646,
-0.3862801194190979,
1.0969157218933105,
0.5721367001533508,
-0.05818035453557968,
-0.7240666151046753,
0.6277999877929688,
0.0800844356417656,
0.33511990308761597,
0.35444724559783936,
0.06555253267288208,
-0.16269545257091522,
-0.3802177906036377,
-0.15378084778785706,
0.12595105171203613,
-0.5436722040176392,
-0.5184935331344604,
-0.8644574880599976,
-0.06117861717939377,
-0.33610835671424866,
-0.1872856467962265,
-0.5077973008155823,
-0.8586369752883911,
-0.213836669921875,
0.1603195071220398,
0.6191789507865906,
0.5249543190002441,
-0.42728060483932495,
0.9864552617073059,
-0.980222225189209,
0.6278668642044067,
0.6246190071105957,
0.46303218603134155,
0.04277753829956055,
-0.34866127371788025,
-0.5193749666213989,
-0.18550069630146027,
-0.3601396381855011,
-0.4853532612323761,
0.40398579835891724,
0.25058427453041077,
0.36093607544898987,
0.5530232787132263,
0.057901009917259216,
1.0287983417510986,
-0.001977956388145685,
0.41141656041145325,
0.28132185339927673,
-1.319583773612976,
0.11037047207355499,
0.11061640828847885,
0.2418633997440338,
0.34440699219703674,
0.40420982241630554,
-0.5473373532295227,
-0.27686887979507446,
-0.44816720485687256,
-0.8188285827636719,
0.4369426965713501,
-0.03209244832396507,
-0.556897759437561,
-0.16984787583351135,
0.37316611409187317,
0.2244691252708435,
0.169824481010437,
-0.428712397813797,
-0.3702101707458496,
0.2455814778804779,
-0.12558060884475708,
0.14273640513420105,
-0.7868058681488037,
-0.027619102969765663,
-0.615279495716095,
0.5288015007972717,
-0.10667947679758072,
0.2503555715084076,
0.15158024430274963,
-0.3456723392009735,
-0.15084631741046906,
0.008308809250593185,
0.6366151571273804,
0.4164462983608246,
-0.22012822329998016,
0.32942116260528564,
0.28451821208000183,
-0.5509491562843323,
0.16266538202762604,
-0.0923902690410614,
-0.09068389236927032,
-0.12729372084140778,
-0.052172690629959106,
0.8115271329879761,
0.512203574180603,
-0.35990095138549805,
0.41020750999450684,
-0.702023983001709,
-0.2984672784805298,
-0.0018878902774304152,
0.007154489867389202,
0.2832491397857666,
0.74009108543396,
0.32892850041389465,
-0.2911566197872162,
0.0009326745639555156,
-0.08532045781612396,
0.41746047139167786,
0.5743751525878906,
0.032040148973464966,
-0.2976571023464203,
0.9565107822418213,
0.20173023641109467,
-0.15756918489933014,
0.7507263422012329,
-0.2969948947429657,
-0.23134709894657135,
0.478495329618454,
0.3149748742580414,
0.8744145631790161,
-0.3954342007637024,
-0.2701268792152405,
0.3112689256668091,
-0.12591435015201569,
0.05312899500131607,
0.5151170492172241,
-0.40988609194755554,
-0.5532636046409607,
-0.9072319269180298,
-0.7172614932060242,
-0.5921460390090942,
-0.05203992873430252,
-0.6090205907821655,
0.1280081868171692,
-0.4968463182449341,
-0.33257994055747986,
-0.169611856341362,
0.016378888860344887,
-0.4862062633037567,
0.09899528324604034,
0.1174972876906395,
0.853236973285675,
-0.46839195489883423,
1.5673104524612427,
0.018243571743369102,
0.29241278767585754,
-0.6616199612617493,
-0.5527488589286804,
-0.2774795591831207,
-0.8828717470169067,
0.8446327447891235,
-0.2262769490480423,
0.2951792776584625,
0.3033757507801056,
-0.397085040807724,
-0.8300002813339233,
1.123632788658142,
0.5635449290275574,
-1.067866563796997,
-0.06670603156089783,
0.026304708793759346,
-0.18155747652053833,
0.12184970825910568,
0.41575944423675537,
0.6496369242668152,
0.3845821022987366,
-0.12584136426448822,
-0.871827244758606,
-0.12365391105413437,
0.11586155742406845,
-0.1233656108379364,
0.7367371916770935,
-0.8093907833099365,
1.2975788116455078,
-0.40503430366516113,
-0.18761853873729706,
-0.04033100977540016,
1.0781545639038086,
0.10848676413297653,
0.4651106894016266,
0.5343287587165833,
1.271963119506836,
0.8111688494682312,
-0.1386891007423401,
0.7161310911178589,
-0.5471159815788269,
0.3053372800350189,
1.091686725616455,
-0.18235798180103302,
0.8024274706840515,
0.7484291195869446,
-0.1726647913455963,
0.06084353104233742,
0.6187013387680054,
0.46314913034439087,
0.5639415979385376,
0.012450921349227428,
-0.8665100336074829,
-0.5434960722923279,
0.2684665620326996,
-0.3680931627750397,
0.19983059167861938,
0.4441392719745636,
-0.07759580761194229,
-0.367063969373703,
-0.1120530515909195,
0.024150321260094643,
-0.3209167420864105,
-0.47291100025177,
0.6483690142631531,
0.2888798415660858,
-0.48034289479255676,
0.6104636788368225,
0.0844368040561676,
1.0878024101257324,
-0.4883745610713959,
0.10434925556182861,
-0.5693972706794739,
0.3862580358982086,
-0.09603263437747955,
-0.5805527567863464,
0.3829319179058075,
-0.2119416892528534,
-0.1393122375011444,
-0.3221283555030823,
0.4479217529296875,
-0.6239101886749268,
-0.301596462726593,
0.27844133973121643,
0.4337502419948578,
-0.16146329045295715,
-0.16133545339107513,
-0.35634222626686096,
0.2705320417881012,
-0.1345362514257431,
-0.2047490030527115,
0.6133869886398315,
0.42888233065605164,
-0.2994115352630615,
0.783937931060791,
0.5741226077079773,
-0.1664390116930008,
0.5652797222137451,
-0.40848013758659363,
0.7160958051681519,
-0.8650144934654236,
-0.4885064959526062,
-0.9981064200401306,
0.13575732707977295,
0.37701109051704407,
-0.12085914611816406,
0.8202173709869385,
0.77744460105896,
0.5918928384780884,
0.08507457375526428,
0.39741355180740356,
0.24024516344070435,
0.2107774317264557,
-0.47383230924606323,
0.7941352725028992,
-0.34461846947669983,
-0.09124338626861572,
0.24156078696250916,
-0.7669224143028259,
-0.23902978003025055,
0.36512041091918945,
0.024837341159582138,
-0.36583665013313293,
0.6126053333282471,
0.610693097114563,
-0.17610295116901398,
-0.09966114163398743,
0.6512271761894226,
0.3085653483867645,
0.2985427677631378,
1.0528900623321533,
0.578269898891449,
-0.5536027550697327,
0.3759913146495819,
-0.6643213033676147,
-0.07090354710817337,
-0.21091358363628387,
-1.2916842699050903,
-0.39376717805862427,
-0.586286187171936,
-0.6206424832344055,
-0.2747676372528076,
-0.04108889400959015,
0.5887652635574341,
0.591041088104248,
-0.5007980465888977,
-0.2162429243326187,
0.09929630160331726,
0.18701446056365967,
0.10909054428339005,
-0.21970601379871368,
0.33806174993515015,
-0.22187259793281555,
-0.7648696303367615,
0.3247995376586914,
0.4303900897502899,
0.18470126390457153,
-0.15454721450805664,
-0.3611113727092743,
-0.15194007754325867,
0.3267960846424103,
0.8263291716575623,
0.3098742365837097,
-0.4745185077190399,
0.034815359860658646,
-0.19388067722320557,
-0.2783854603767395,
0.2331724464893341,
1.073823094367981,
-1.182448387145996,
0.21074283123016357,
0.4882386028766632,
0.6164122223854065,
0.5457215905189514,
-0.3355165719985962,
0.3326418697834015,
-0.5244185328483582,
0.49210283160209656,
0.20926529169082642,
0.5134158134460449,
0.13017810881137848,
-0.30869683623313904,
0.230100616812706,
0.2150474190711975,
-0.6597492694854736,
-0.8303263783454895,
-0.11000609397888184,
-1.1667382717132568,
-0.036272305995225906,
0.886516809463501,
-0.10371385514736176,
-0.5374196171760559,
0.2507157325744629,
0.246185302734375,
0.6093046069145203,
-0.25372353196144104,
0.6256719827651978,
0.5088717937469482,
0.061749450862407684,
-0.2248547375202179,
-0.585609495639801,
0.669288158416748,
0.6617944240570068,
-0.6722541451454163,
0.05645943433046341,
0.3165534734725952,
0.11844345927238464,
-0.3850865066051483,
0.7745872735977173,
0.05728965997695923,
0.2713451385498047,
-0.22192098200321198,
0.23398789763450623,
-0.1227279081940651,
-0.2061326950788498,
-0.468249648809433,
0.025784187018871307,
-0.044233862310647964,
-0.140710711479187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10073v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10073v3 | Both Matter: Enhancing the Emotional Intelligence of Large Language Models without Compromising the General Intelligence | 2024-02-15T16:36:04 | 2024-06-12T04:13:17 | Weixiang Zhao, Zhuojun Li, Shilong Wang, Yang Wang, Yulin Hu, Yanyan Zhao, Chen Wei, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotional Intelligence (EI), consisting of emotion perception, emotion
cognition and emotion expression, plays the critical roles in improving user
interaction experience for the current large language model (LLM) based
conversational general AI assistants. Previous works mainly focus on raising
the emotion perception ability of them via naive fine-tuning on EI-related
classification or regression tasks. However, this leads to the incomplete
enhancement of EI and catastrophic forgetting of the general intelligence (GI).
To this end, we first introduce \textsc{EiBench}, a large-scale collection of
EI-related tasks in the text-to-text formation with task instructions that
covers all three aspects of EI, which lays a solid foundation for the
comprehensive EI enhancement of LLMs. Then a novel \underline{\textbf{Mo}}dular
\underline{\textbf{E}}motional \underline{\textbf{I}}ntelligence enhancement
method (\textbf{MoEI}), consisting of Modular Parameter Expansion and
intra-inter modulation, is proposed to comprehensively enhance the EI of LLMs
without compromise their GI. Extensive experiments on two representative
LLM-based assistants, Flan-T5 and LLaMA-2-Chat, demonstrate the effectiveness
of MoEI to improving EI while maintain GI. | [
-0.2768835127353668,
-0.8163630962371826,
0.4010411500930786,
0.07254153490066528,
0.18156835436820984,
0.05771235004067421,
-0.48857682943344116,
-0.6554075479507446,
0.4346952736377716,
0.052651748061180115,
-0.6532190442085266,
-0.33451735973358154,
-0.37275591492652893,
0.022802766412496567,
-0.04204035922884941,
0.8778237104415894,
0.20220880210399628,
-0.09291782975196838,
-0.22503915429115295,
-0.17077326774597168,
-0.2368767261505127,
-0.7299252152442932,
-0.7398647665977478,
-0.28237175941467285,
0.6263664364814758,
0.44340789318084717,
0.32063454389572144,
0.17751914262771606,
0.4603123068809509,
0.34580978751182556,
0.032941728830337524,
0.5363710522651672,
-0.7599098682403564,
0.24344801902770996,
-0.05597251281142235,
-0.6847840547561646,
-0.9067957997322083,
-0.24317318201065063,
0.23285536468029022,
0.21858413517475128,
-0.31439197063446045,
-0.32502222061157227,
-0.05603945627808571,
1.0155792236328125,
-0.8911502957344055,
0.11545463651418686,
-0.3189869821071625,
-0.16405752301216125,
0.048131149262189865,
-0.2429223507642746,
-0.40464261174201965,
0.03649093583226204,
0.080231674015522,
-0.6215185523033142,
-0.27659958600997925,
0.1776333898305893,
0.7794023752212524,
0.2781936526298523,
-0.49237632751464844,
-0.4913972318172455,
-0.7990647554397583,
0.8859564065933228,
-0.5799232721328735,
0.2664629817008972,
0.2511635422706604,
-0.23630279302597046,
0.0613960325717926,
-0.27744024991989136,
-0.615003764629364,
-0.3792645335197449,
0.06359989941120148,
0.5841653943061829,
-0.36605116724967957,
0.5446826815605164,
0.3016264736652374,
0.3543087840080261,
-0.3365422785282135,
0.25080767273902893,
-0.2858288288116455,
0.10863219201564789,
0.6778916120529175,
0.2821243405342102,
0.5531976222991943,
0.2844642698764801,
0.2566538155078888,
-0.04092984274029732,
-0.5382450819015503,
-0.02483273670077324,
0.339587539434433,
-0.09802428632974625,
-0.20605692267417908,
0.28550729155540466,
-0.3359066843986511,
0.22027407586574554,
0.2908851206302643,
0.045137643814086914,
0.4019153118133545,
-0.27288496494293213,
-0.31071802973747253,
-0.2688482701778412,
0.685895562171936,
0.3651723563671112,
0.6093936562538147,
-0.24325530230998993,
0.10226873308420181,
-0.13337461650371552,
0.29759371280670166,
-0.7952713966369629,
-0.11650790274143219,
0.3464558720588684,
-0.3680546283721924,
-0.00918782688677311,
0.25133752822875977,
-0.6717304587364197,
-0.2640717327594757,
-0.57972252368927,
0.19258952140808105,
-0.5219233632087708,
-0.46520763635635376,
-0.17423902451992035,
0.1530303806066513,
0.2920542359352112,
0.4345942735671997,
-1.145229697227478,
0.1568867415189743,
0.9385853409767151,
0.6277509927749634,
0.04449617862701416,
-0.23668712377548218,
-0.22863896191120148,
0.296842098236084,
-0.33096009492874146,
0.6210535168647766,
-0.8466074466705322,
-0.4638635814189911,
0.28042203187942505,
-0.25037088990211487,
-0.24916952848434448,
-0.47388219833374023,
0.5118817090988159,
-0.3842340111732483,
0.22470074892044067,
-0.18174348771572113,
-0.45704299211502075,
-0.48116636276245117,
0.19617317616939545,
-0.38904687762260437,
0.8032706379890442,
0.0869828462600708,
-0.3879854083061218,
0.025498252362012863,
-1.1353391408920288,
-0.5942113399505615,
-0.258512943983078,
0.013130958192050457,
-0.26485559344291687,
0.42650267481803894,
0.3819347321987152,
0.5551892518997192,
-0.3458503484725952,
-0.012679792009294033,
-0.47738274931907654,
-0.4220380485057831,
0.3083887994289398,
-0.3468283414840698,
0.284402459859848,
-0.23182101547718048,
-0.30430564284324646,
0.12080519646406174,
-0.5821912884712219,
0.2242259681224823,
-0.13497529923915863,
-0.40235990285873413,
-0.2304791957139969,
0.05555099993944168,
-0.2013368457555771,
-0.03424200415611267,
0.13123777508735657,
-0.3026445806026459,
0.1046622022986412,
-0.44451606273651123,
0.4980155825614929,
0.6870573163032532,
0.007994062267243862,
0.6396406888961792,
-0.47412505745887756,
0.28461432456970215,
0.0024397196248173714,
0.11866451054811478,
-0.32099753618240356,
-0.27220678329467773,
-1.1819276809692383,
-0.4817206859588623,
-0.12776242196559906,
0.9312540888786316,
-0.6025524735450745,
0.4841860830783844,
-0.48195555806159973,
-0.54188072681427,
-0.5976381301879883,
0.24873661994934082,
0.45019522309303284,
0.17581114172935486,
0.29784172773361206,
0.017152797430753708,
-0.4128246605396271,
-0.9159897565841675,
-0.05734853446483612,
-0.37020090222358704,
-0.36573344469070435,
0.6491159200668335,
0.3197862207889557,
-0.4766876697540283,
0.5601903796195984,
-0.0650840699672699,
-0.24411557614803314,
-0.20645727217197418,
0.3644412159919739,
-0.05589911714196205,
0.39544641971588135,
0.6280606985092163,
-0.6905080676078796,
-0.4428350031375885,
0.1892760694026947,
-0.8095643520355225,
-0.41715651750564575,
-0.07551810890436172,
-0.2935502231121063,
0.48409146070480347,
0.27165117859840393,
-0.5412866473197937,
0.43406781554222107,
0.3953624367713928,
-0.1951492875814438,
0.23310859501361847,
-0.2828308939933777,
0.7657039165496826,
-0.8872901201248169,
-0.0049340128898620605,
0.0725540965795517,
0.13196776807308197,
-1.1885465383529663,
-0.07210206240415573,
0.12280400842428207,
0.07502253353595734,
-0.3936648368835449,
0.2996688783168793,
-0.5933499932289124,
0.095636747777462,
-0.4216597080230713,
0.07427792996168137,
-0.00991108175367117,
0.8124969005584717,
-0.29566696286201477,
0.7834973931312561,
0.5479844808578491,
-0.7620747685432434,
0.3296262323856354,
-0.01217716746032238,
0.14651860296726227,
1.0149707794189453,
-0.6826367974281311,
0.6297439336776733,
-0.30022940039634705,
0.049222417175769806,
-0.628862202167511,
-0.26214298605918884,
0.23372815549373627,
-0.4654649794101715,
0.6822786927223206,
0.46035757660865784,
-0.19484058022499084,
-0.18469862639904022,
-0.4285387694835663,
0.04847623035311699,
0.7239677309989929,
-0.4744586944580078,
1.202915072441101,
0.08340063691139221,
-0.33345744013786316,
-0.3383621275424957,
-0.7166977524757385,
0.19511504471302032,
-0.22803151607513428,
-0.6916674375534058,
0.24182502925395966,
-0.36563125252723694,
-0.43795883655548096,
-0.1320335865020752,
0.15453465282917023,
-0.12872204184532166,
0.27596724033355713,
0.46531862020492554,
0.34416091442108154,
-0.29233208298683167,
0.4150090515613556,
0.15000435709953308,
0.02936353161931038,
0.07351808995008469,
0.09144952148199081,
0.4296618402004242,
-0.42994317412376404,
-0.5003401041030884,
-0.8252335786819458,
0.7192339301109314,
0.83742356300354,
-0.27964267134666443,
0.8117399215698242,
0.554336428642273,
-0.19575022161006927,
0.10332109779119492,
-0.8365340828895569,
-0.08268849551677704,
-0.4392777979373932,
0.8564640879631042,
-0.49306535720825195,
-0.9886717796325684,
0.30039963126182556,
-0.0907277837395668,
-0.032428640872240067,
0.36884698271751404,
0.5037948489189148,
-0.3132410943508148,
1.2278884649276733,
0.7450559735298157,
-0.5724550485610962,
0.7233096957206726,
-0.11506371945142746,
0.4764865040779114,
-1.2047594785690308,
-0.2599482238292694,
-0.5042380094528198,
-0.6373761892318726,
-0.15526899695396423,
-0.11287400871515274,
0.04386696219444275,
0.04392945393919945,
-0.47469356656074524,
-0.31879910826683044,
-0.3692658543586731,
0.4156739115715027,
0.5206454396247864,
0.31922388076782227,
-0.06999137252569199,
0.11333340406417847,
0.5730854272842407,
-0.07840736210346222,
-0.5946982502937317,
-0.430520236492157,
1.0347375869750977,
0.33153945207595825,
0.6117467284202576,
0.3698546886444092,
0.5246624946594238,
0.28899404406547546,
0.5322687029838562,
-0.7279826998710632,
0.6647250652313232,
-0.10602343082427979,
-0.21175971627235413,
-0.22063209116458893,
-0.38306981325149536,
-0.5874689221382141,
-0.0006303400732576847,
-0.3004637658596039,
-1.0823346376419067,
0.2549745738506317,
0.1633869707584381,
-0.20193974673748016,
0.1894504725933075,
-0.9601556062698364,
0.2810264229774475,
-0.5212914347648621,
-0.43447354435920715,
-0.801555335521698,
-0.2208435982465744,
0.16024170815944672,
0.0742449015378952,
-0.05299853906035423,
-0.0683034211397171,
-0.3728935122489929,
0.7174695134162903,
-0.13618357479572296,
0.7908953428268433,
-0.1425042748451233,
0.10171797126531601,
0.19366730749607086,
-0.17428146302700043,
0.5635654330253601,
-0.19107994437217712,
-0.3299533724784851,
0.2964945435523987,
-0.6359821557998657,
-0.4116336703300476,
-1.0119138956069946,
0.7108739614486694,
-0.9026068449020386,
-0.9760305881500244,
0.06972949206829071,
-0.6575812697410583,
-0.24482494592666626,
-0.336253821849823,
-0.0451192744076252,
0.2794733941555023,
-0.2615988850593567,
0.3823201060295105,
0.6920569539070129,
-0.1509239375591278,
0.4006745517253876,
0.35641318559646606,
0.25468510389328003,
-0.42986926436424255,
0.8750288486480713,
-0.08086761087179184,
0.4741479456424713,
0.5995829105377197,
-0.08040650188922882,
0.021588360890746117,
-0.22947950661182404,
-0.11246393620967865,
0.39405104517936707,
-0.6598058342933655,
-0.0433887243270874,
-0.798652172088623,
-0.047486357390880585,
-0.3378604054450989,
-0.5026625990867615,
0.10824243724346161,
-0.10057490319013596,
-0.6598502397537231,
-0.23214484751224518,
0.6370484828948975,
0.5279174447059631,
-0.11867328733205795,
0.20067816972732544,
-0.7301313877105713,
0.09330711513757706,
0.4597054421901703,
-0.05499730259180069,
0.3119426965713501,
-0.49128562211990356,
-0.27736377716064453,
0.40650686621665955,
-0.18481653928756714,
-0.7278567552566528,
0.335755854845047,
0.8375187516212463,
0.5221226811408997,
0.9096675515174866,
-0.04436230659484863,
0.8649440407752991,
-0.24395427107810974,
0.7596387267112732,
0.37627094984054565,
-1.0848444700241089,
0.5434147119522095,
-0.1589219719171524,
0.21841180324554443,
0.3572673499584198,
0.2752993702888489,
-0.4726386070251465,
-0.4622020125389099,
-0.42897599935531616,
-0.9377738237380981,
0.7164633274078369,
0.12634919583797455,
0.34191200137138367,
-0.09355232119560242,
0.2593284845352173,
-0.309696763753891,
0.22746846079826355,
-0.5226646661758423,
-0.10362254083156586,
-0.04027336463332176,
-0.4966306984424591,
0.11108313500881195,
-0.6253756284713745,
-0.049042195081710815,
-0.21849805116653442,
0.9379518628120422,
-0.11871281266212463,
0.6257685422897339,
0.27451643347740173,
-0.0933246836066246,
-0.02410079911351204,
0.45235782861709595,
0.6273950934410095,
0.3339560627937317,
0.06092612072825432,
-0.24417823553085327,
0.5838371515274048,
-0.33058518171310425,
0.05959499254822731,
-0.4226056635379791,
0.08833020180463791,
-0.35236769914627075,
0.4576883018016815,
1.0763390064239502,
0.27472519874572754,
-0.6993905901908875,
0.34664735198020935,
0.1482890248298645,
-0.3434576988220215,
-0.17031970620155334,
0.42216959595680237,
0.18859611451625824,
0.5452342629432678,
0.40375062823295593,
-0.14378449320793152,
0.05247652903199196,
-0.8438364267349243,
-0.20833683013916016,
0.33847159147262573,
-0.38527822494506836,
-0.39672282338142395,
0.4179593026638031,
0.5432771444320679,
-0.5655074715614319,
0.8703184127807617,
-0.14364702999591827,
-0.7586310505867004,
0.8230713605880737,
0.48317527770996094,
1.0655075311660767,
-0.3775525391101837,
-0.055582594126462936,
0.27160683274269104,
0.4136248528957367,
0.2300206571817398,
0.40037909150123596,
-0.04221948981285095,
-0.5812101364135742,
-0.23728851974010468,
0.058475520461797714,
-0.3548263907432556,
-0.13482765853405,
-0.5878261923789978,
-0.13812176883220673,
-0.442392498254776,
0.09582709521055222,
-0.5217093825340271,
-0.04785360023379326,
-0.7798577547073364,
0.19844211637973785,
0.325797975063324,
0.6032641530036926,
-0.6633409261703491,
0.6090925335884094,
0.7596492171287537,
-0.17589804530143738,
-0.7527714371681213,
0.1711055189371109,
-0.019489124417304993,
-0.5983566045761108,
0.6424447298049927,
0.3013894259929657,
-0.14147143065929413,
0.01853840798139572,
-0.4179905951023102,
-0.7364075183868408,
1.3027327060699463,
0.12084182351827621,
-0.7118139266967773,
0.11933144927024841,
0.047369666397571564,
0.7045686841011047,
-0.632477343082428,
0.9637742042541504,
0.48577815294265747,
0.5768725872039795,
-0.04032282531261444,
-0.7367020845413208,
-0.2639935314655304,
-0.6020993590354919,
0.07799208909273148,
0.26363104581832886,
-0.9069602489471436,
0.5044854879379272,
-0.324629008769989,
-0.25569677352905273,
0.07839316129684448,
0.9245790839195251,
0.008615294471383095,
0.3929697871208191,
0.49991828203201294,
0.6172258257865906,
1.1037349700927734,
-0.282703697681427,
1.0072253942489624,
-0.3719012141227722,
-0.024848779663443565,
0.8089475631713867,
-0.5571180582046509,
0.8618584871292114,
0.3120373487472534,
-0.05499204248189926,
0.4821034371852875,
0.3307023346424103,
0.15925155580043793,
0.3174225091934204,
0.0432695671916008,
-0.40527811646461487,
-0.15460333228111267,
-0.23768724501132965,
-0.1681760847568512,
0.11258189380168915,
0.6868261694908142,
-0.13659384846687317,
0.3624960780143738,
0.3153395652770996,
0.20342488586902618,
0.029582655057311058,
-0.572176992893219,
0.8547036051750183,
0.010403325781226158,
-0.4693779945373535,
0.37126198410987854,
-0.1305323988199234,
0.8621621131896973,
-0.5063217282295227,
0.08351363986730576,
-0.36439359188079834,
0.02891453541815281,
-0.27637621760368347,
-0.34733307361602783,
0.16510948538780212,
0.16107390820980072,
-0.3078327476978302,
0.036653485149145126,
0.8027878999710083,
-0.37874579429626465,
-0.3057168424129486,
0.5655814409255981,
0.345271497964859,
-0.004840446636080742,
-0.06882026046514511,
-0.5340700745582581,
-0.058307066559791565,
0.104789137840271,
-0.5687389969825745,
0.18408069014549255,
0.6185729503631592,
0.24888113141059875,
0.8600494861602783,
0.5501020550727844,
-0.011801434680819511,
-0.08556115627288818,
0.24517348408699036,
0.8181954622268677,
-0.5449937582015991,
-0.3159967362880707,
-0.9023962020874023,
0.6346465349197388,
-0.33069494366645813,
-0.22838568687438965,
0.2579715847969055,
0.0982200875878334,
0.30367016792297363,
-0.12354537844657898,
0.8163401484489441,
-0.20020727813243866,
0.2590517997741699,
-0.5909410715103149,
0.5922219157218933,
-0.6167604327201843,
0.035448819398880005,
-0.21405500173568726,
-0.887041449546814,
-0.22776861488819122,
0.47249773144721985,
-0.5065976977348328,
0.2689216434955597,
0.7770881652832031,
0.9557722806930542,
0.18994799256324768,
-0.009414434432983398,
0.6903128027915955,
0.36533036828041077,
0.28014421463012695,
1.0594195127487183,
0.8977586030960083,
-0.20237936079502106,
0.5259968638420105,
0.029743680730462074,
-0.4132536053657532,
-0.4669186770915985,
-0.5660713315010071,
-1.0902596712112427,
-0.338961124420166,
-0.5034330487251282,
0.069227434694767,
0.36581605672836304,
0.9340092539787292,
0.6771400570869446,
-0.6582749485969543,
0.03894064202904701,
-0.0191236212849617,
-0.13505952060222626,
-0.1924113929271698,
-0.20498067140579224,
0.12359052151441574,
-0.269557386636734,
-0.9918290972709656,
0.3732481300830841,
0.8091882467269897,
-0.026723479852080345,
0.040386512875556946,
-0.4207862317562103,
-0.04264992102980614,
0.4796614348888397,
0.5094005465507507,
0.33519190549850464,
-0.6800053715705872,
-0.3569985032081604,
0.11590010672807693,
-0.14638391137123108,
0.16983647644519806,
0.4957355260848999,
-0.3270849287509918,
0.25243401527404785,
0.35702353715896606,
0.7866838574409485,
-0.00767640070989728,
0.02823256514966488,
0.5962854623794556,
-0.38231879472732544,
0.1667589545249939,
0.14945513010025024,
0.417878121137619,
0.1325957328081131,
-0.5839182138442993,
0.5514209270477295,
0.06409286707639694,
-0.6498706936836243,
-0.3906753957271576,
0.2997523546218872,
-0.930978536605835,
0.021094635128974915,
1.041043758392334,
-0.2924104630947113,
-0.40207910537719727,
0.3221197724342346,
-0.5244935750961304,
0.17798662185668945,
-0.671915590763092,
0.8462812304496765,
0.7639896273612976,
-0.17186324298381805,
-0.42995578050613403,
-0.3930939733982086,
-0.05625264719128609,
0.775944709777832,
-1.1919735670089722,
-0.22180335223674774,
0.47312813997268677,
-0.42346182465553284,
0.22998079657554626,
0.3602139353752136,
0.29304978251457214,
0.2769336402416229,
-0.290628045797348,
0.33444491028785706,
-0.2687007188796997,
-0.31215038895606995,
-0.28107237815856934,
0.13694879412651062,
-0.11145713180303574,
-0.12287964671850204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10058v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10058v2 | Towards Safer Large Language Models through Machine Unlearning | 2024-02-15T16:28:34 | 2024-06-05T04:57:09 | Zheyuan Liu, Guangyao Dou, Zhaoxuan Tan, Yijun Tian, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has demonstrated their
vast potential across various domains, attributed to their extensive
pretraining knowledge and exceptional generalizability. However, LLMs often
encounter challenges in generating harmful content when faced with problematic
prompts. To address this problem, existing work attempted to implement a
gradient ascent based approach to prevent LLMs from producing harmful output.
While these methods can be effective, they frequently impact the model utility
in responding to normal prompts. To address this gap, we introduce Selective
Knowledge negation Unlearning (SKU), a novel unlearning framework for LLMs,
designed to eliminate harmful knowledge while preserving utility on normal
prompts. Specifically, SKU is consisted of two stages: harmful knowledge
acquisition stage and knowledge negation stage. The first stage aims to
identify and acquire harmful knowledge within the model, whereas the second is
dedicated to remove this knowledge. SKU selectively isolates and removes
harmful knowledge in model parameters, ensuring the model's performance remains
robust on normal prompts. Our experiments conducted across various LLM
architectures demonstrate that SKU identifies a good balance point between
removing harmful information and preserving utility. | [
-0.12931577861309052,
-0.7438492774963379,
0.2786543369293213,
-0.18965935707092285,
-0.47078874707221985,
0.30445608496665955,
-0.26111677289009094,
-0.17901447415351868,
-0.4379023313522339,
0.9925550818443298,
-0.4168742299079895,
-0.6061301231384277,
-0.5543140172958374,
-0.47251173853874207,
-0.24312563240528107,
1.1384919881820679,
0.3338077962398529,
-0.020149268209934235,
-0.328398734331131,
-0.08624842762947083,
-0.5773310661315918,
-0.5132195353507996,
-0.9123337268829346,
-0.47292715311050415,
0.5938240885734558,
0.41908591985702515,
0.5239812731742859,
0.4509735703468323,
0.1514623612165451,
0.24731576442718506,
-0.23512881994247437,
0.016176924109458923,
-0.7535207271575928,
0.4558497667312622,
-0.20438554883003235,
-0.46343329548835754,
-0.2847275733947754,
-0.027606068179011345,
0.5126643180847168,
0.7529614567756653,
-0.3286100924015045,
-0.0003188634873367846,
0.49942561984062195,
0.7528620362281799,
-0.6432020664215088,
-0.011741794645786285,
-1.0089011192321777,
-0.20603053271770477,
-0.18148061633110046,
-0.007533924654126167,
-0.7223529815673828,
-0.14129450917243958,
-0.05294147878885269,
-0.5347609519958496,
-0.10165861994028091,
-0.09323295205831528,
0.550328254699707,
0.4150828719139099,
-0.4503619372844696,
-0.17461638152599335,
-0.6305081844329834,
1.1625310182571411,
-0.7207905054092407,
0.4480380117893219,
0.48553940653800964,
0.356172651052475,
-0.4426831901073456,
-0.40064167976379395,
-0.3726537823677063,
-0.09969291090965271,
0.061229024082422256,
-0.03556074947118759,
-0.48610982298851013,
0.1208377555012703,
0.13092440366744995,
-0.18142694234848022,
-0.6036196351051331,
0.6494677662849426,
-0.44489923119544983,
-0.3694680631160736,
0.5052322149276733,
0.040978506207466125,
0.36226409673690796,
-0.33071884512901306,
-0.4507308602333069,
0.2101854532957077,
-1.044834852218628,
0.11988581717014313,
0.6020205616950989,
0.3075806200504303,
0.24214020371437073,
0.4794209599494934,
-0.009672882966697216,
0.4809887409210205,
-0.2174718677997589,
-0.32877349853515625,
0.3589147627353668,
0.2270168513059616,
-0.29155081510543823,
-0.15425871312618256,
0.732096254825592,
0.297573983669281,
0.3813062012195587,
-0.5426098704338074,
-0.3702758848667145,
0.0037955825682729483,
0.41303253173828125,
-0.6035209894180298,
-0.04045475646853447,
0.06468367576599121,
-0.459989994764328,
-0.5364512205123901,
-0.397652268409729,
-0.8688390851020813,
-0.6417218446731567,
-0.342102587223053,
0.38796958327293396,
-0.5266132950782776,
-0.2732837200164795,
-0.016162116080522537,
0.08601101487874985,
-0.036782409995794296,
0.27862662076950073,
-0.5087236762046814,
-0.09607197344303131,
0.616607129573822,
0.3287492096424103,
-0.2515624165534973,
0.08261307328939438,
-0.7372575998306274,
0.33195820450782776,
-0.3024449348449707,
0.33477309346199036,
-0.655247688293457,
-0.40649858117103577,
-0.07750975340604782,
0.016333788633346558,
0.07899689674377441,
-0.7445083260536194,
0.6014929413795471,
-0.7744388580322266,
0.210503488779068,
0.057740118354558945,
-0.3683481812477112,
-0.5179442763328552,
0.06261696666479111,
-0.31551462411880493,
0.8566154837608337,
0.014846757985651493,
-0.5267143249511719,
0.31314608454704285,
-0.3889799118041992,
-0.5897493362426758,
0.24629920721054077,
-0.016734035685658455,
-0.2940117418766022,
0.0197135079652071,
-0.06523536145687103,
0.6777144074440002,
-0.26003244519233704,
0.6103944778442383,
-0.34380438923835754,
-0.10445863753557205,
-0.0605769082903862,
-0.681512713432312,
0.9044850468635559,
0.4465039372444153,
-0.22731681168079376,
0.33145973086357117,
-0.9632492661476135,
0.014051503501832485,
0.02047303132712841,
-0.4306522011756897,
-0.864955484867096,
-0.12881489098072052,
-0.37958359718322754,
0.3659391701221466,
0.09718434512615204,
-0.6739282011985779,
-0.016649678349494934,
-0.2913554310798645,
0.4761001765727997,
1.061712622642517,
-0.031527966260910034,
0.7127176523208618,
-0.2664353847503662,
0.5590173602104187,
0.16785229742527008,
0.19335469603538513,
0.020006002858281136,
-0.5841262340545654,
-0.6710095405578613,
-0.37751469016075134,
0.07559061795473099,
0.5537452101707458,
-1.0044912099838257,
0.5222908854484558,
0.053236667066812515,
-0.5141324996948242,
-0.4265437424182892,
0.660042405128479,
0.6147260069847107,
0.7875171303749084,
0.3123124837875366,
0.12297006696462631,
-0.5144138932228088,
-0.7507573962211609,
-0.33677080273628235,
-0.1554168313741684,
-0.19870644807815552,
0.17904582619667053,
0.11237592995166779,
-0.4786648154258728,
0.526566207408905,
-0.3129764497280121,
-0.1471075713634491,
-0.512535810470581,
0.1126239076256752,
0.23885023593902588,
0.5457973480224609,
0.34024322032928467,
-0.633819043636322,
-0.2757556140422821,
-0.018154148012399673,
-0.8621674180030823,
-0.1587853878736496,
-0.0710344910621643,
-0.24478769302368164,
0.34957149624824524,
0.7006993889808655,
-0.568231463432312,
0.5563099384307861,
0.3417140543460846,
0.09158724546432495,
0.2777768671512604,
-0.19015370309352875,
-0.34230586886405945,
-0.9937698841094971,
0.09222463518381119,
-0.04545458033680916,
-0.08654822409152985,
-0.8547503352165222,
0.07282767444849014,
0.03550373390316963,
0.02784673124551773,
-0.5229709148406982,
0.6348938941955566,
-0.24030433595180511,
0.39408087730407715,
-0.32270607352256775,
0.023773660883307457,
-0.06935428082942963,
0.4533522427082062,
-0.07209271937608719,
0.3408041000366211,
0.5088449716567993,
-0.9112172722816467,
-0.05351836606860161,
0.036537520587444305,
-0.24877779185771942,
0.177090123295784,
-0.473932683467865,
0.17399676144123077,
-0.40094879269599915,
-0.07615821063518524,
-0.8632792234420776,
0.1491289734840393,
0.2655872404575348,
-0.42837458848953247,
0.39904290437698364,
-0.25732123851776123,
-0.37655994296073914,
-0.32982292771339417,
-0.06070664897561073,
0.3757368326187134,
0.9344972372055054,
-0.5951107144355774,
0.6491478681564331,
0.5382574200630188,
-0.2067045420408249,
-0.7740024924278259,
-0.42206528782844543,
-0.20701223611831665,
-0.4913731813430786,
-0.4590035080909729,
-0.1179894506931305,
-0.11604470759630203,
-0.3444535434246063,
-0.11845055222511292,
-0.07871028035879135,
0.009653838351368904,
0.35015249252319336,
0.5030072927474976,
0.5859277248382568,
0.0716857984662056,
0.2997729778289795,
0.10888483375310898,
-0.3607983887195587,
0.14048200845718384,
-0.22201725840568542,
0.6781815886497498,
0.4568615257740021,
-0.17307573556900024,
-0.2774536907672882,
0.20639319717884064,
0.6670859456062317,
-0.24712568521499634,
0.8321552872657776,
0.5737741589546204,
-0.5179861783981323,
-0.5852624177932739,
-0.48491472005844116,
-0.12315593659877777,
-0.5470981001853943,
0.38034504652023315,
0.049237724393606186,
-0.9657822847366333,
0.373157799243927,
-0.13647785782814026,
0.4344525635242462,
0.16271328926086426,
0.4095415472984314,
-0.06339070200920105,
1.0900827646255493,
0.6056031584739685,
-0.29569029808044434,
0.2962271571159363,
-0.1327485740184784,
0.5466901659965515,
-0.7931934595108032,
-0.4924754202365875,
-0.5075423717498779,
-0.18383817374706268,
-0.28125646710395813,
-0.4403148293495178,
0.25352180004119873,
0.5416848063468933,
-0.4878496825695038,
0.17329487204551697,
-0.2922193109989166,
0.5353291630744934,
0.5064329504966736,
0.019920645281672478,
0.27640238404273987,
0.12101467698812485,
-0.5313188433647156,
0.008984614163637161,
-0.6105599999427795,
-0.7121255993843079,
1.2497375011444092,
0.3440100848674774,
0.9040430188179016,
0.09909602999687195,
0.5801560282707214,
0.09751494973897934,
0.4308967888355255,
-0.6602924466133118,
0.7063615322113037,
-0.2962527871131897,
-0.6153106689453125,
-0.48829886317253113,
-0.7220841646194458,
-0.911142885684967,
0.30137893557548523,
-0.11986460536718369,
-0.9040537476539612,
-0.12780888378620148,
0.0756765604019165,
-0.4260152280330658,
0.7184889912605286,
-0.6961405873298645,
0.3717080354690552,
-0.24567534029483795,
-0.36209431290626526,
-0.1714753955602646,
-0.5850617289543152,
0.5684626698493958,
-0.4054485559463501,
0.5451223850250244,
-0.14756155014038086,
0.07963487505912781,
0.7851114869117737,
-0.011851822026073933,
1.029628038406372,
-0.33283138275146484,
-0.21372976899147034,
0.21876081824302673,
0.3357009291648865,
0.6057032942771912,
0.019740574061870575,
-0.2961718440055847,
0.17104960978031158,
-0.4417605698108673,
-0.3298182189464569,
-0.5406744480133057,
0.6726087331771851,
-0.6766712665557861,
-0.7538340091705322,
-0.1393776834011078,
-0.730869710445404,
-0.35111507773399353,
0.43368223309516907,
0.23932409286499023,
0.1699426919221878,
0.028400059789419174,
0.3408319056034088,
0.8650804758071899,
-0.64960116147995,
0.645354151725769,
0.7374451756477356,
-0.26603081822395325,
-0.2516130208969116,
1.1648746728897095,
0.023993220180273056,
0.5570943355560303,
0.21295048296451569,
0.18257692456245422,
-0.36025872826576233,
-0.8132779598236084,
-0.21420833468437195,
0.1351340413093567,
-0.7813648581504822,
-0.39131245017051697,
-0.6964447498321533,
-0.36482927203178406,
-0.44608235359191895,
-0.06833542138338089,
-0.140786811709404,
-0.12039162218570709,
-0.4650951623916626,
-0.3356122076511383,
0.09359225630760193,
0.8697333335876465,
-0.05839812755584717,
0.21408893167972565,
-0.8471985459327698,
0.16931034624576569,
0.26791703701019287,
0.2143121212720871,
0.3810141682624817,
-0.638735830783844,
0.09880654513835907,
0.08650373667478561,
-0.33829641342163086,
-0.22898335754871368,
0.6314907073974609,
-0.15742501616477966,
1.0165387392044067,
0.9485291242599487,
0.4950493574142456,
0.448295921087265,
-0.3246059715747833,
0.563713788986206,
0.48133793473243713,
-0.6429396867752075,
0.37438052892684937,
-0.4119824171066284,
0.09210944175720215,
0.4289766848087311,
0.5848883390426636,
-0.5592011213302612,
-0.46737104654312134,
-0.5776169300079346,
-1.0634297132492065,
0.4986704885959625,
-0.10796290636062622,
0.2625839114189148,
-0.040864247828722,
0.30487266182899475,
0.4721754193305969,
0.3748762309551239,
-0.6838715672492981,
-0.23276957869529724,
0.040956608951091766,
-0.05730801820755005,
-0.30033546686172485,
-0.30839547514915466,
-0.10143887996673584,
-0.18848037719726562,
0.9119240641593933,
0.1181088387966156,
-0.28721025586128235,
-0.524105429649353,
-0.3539271354675293,
-0.30459514260292053,
0.48730671405792236,
0.20963558554649353,
0.29852747917175293,
-0.014921585097908974,
0.24458035826683044,
0.1626254767179489,
-0.4542270600795746,
0.16069546341896057,
-0.4350429177284241,
-0.5649325251579285,
-0.4117956757545471,
0.19819767773151398,
0.5087689757347107,
0.2883082628250122,
-0.7414613962173462,
0.3253704607486725,
0.1891404688358307,
-0.20534759759902954,
0.10465268045663834,
0.2976584732532501,
0.030404916033148766,
-0.09617588669061661,
0.36132076382637024,
0.2246517539024353,
-0.2038147747516632,
-0.41840246319770813,
0.28918513655662537,
0.5772395730018616,
-0.5489694476127625,
-0.16319088637828827,
0.49890297651290894,
0.38961049914360046,
-0.2367819994688034,
0.7541031241416931,
-0.26298680901527405,
-0.5218401551246643,
0.36130863428115845,
0.6839246153831482,
0.5912315845489502,
-0.36795035004615784,
0.3959510028362274,
0.2272043526172638,
0.46779105067253113,
0.16772443056106567,
0.09947504848241806,
0.24195200204849243,
-0.8613987565040588,
-0.21944740414619446,
-0.7878129482269287,
0.10615617781877518,
0.7108603119850159,
-0.6366534233093262,
0.014572844840586185,
-0.6979888677597046,
0.13557705283164978,
-0.23069624602794647,
-0.20813961327075958,
-0.40985581278800964,
0.11210113018751144,
0.0290420763194561,
0.6400023698806763,
-0.7930818200111389,
0.930745542049408,
0.4058976471424103,
-0.19037969410419464,
-0.9260704517364502,
-0.1215888261795044,
0.2683953046798706,
-0.9998714327812195,
0.5787262916564941,
0.17681384086608887,
-0.04900452122092247,
-0.06867647916078568,
-0.45006588101387024,
-0.6545067429542542,
0.9063684344291687,
0.5710000395774841,
-0.8269098997116089,
0.04738990217447281,
0.1503947675228119,
0.2071518748998642,
-0.11516543477773666,
-0.06820547580718994,
0.4096578061580658,
0.3973633050918579,
0.40637943148612976,
-0.4979812502861023,
0.1687477082014084,
-0.20848329365253448,
-0.26690852642059326,
0.3440552055835724,
-0.38869503140449524,
0.7509674429893494,
-0.4649440050125122,
-0.23872818052768707,
0.1557878702878952,
0.3188895285129547,
0.31149953603744507,
0.33111947774887085,
0.7061237096786499,
0.6464233994483948,
1.1245285272598267,
0.11057161539793015,
0.6559658050537109,
-0.051394034177064896,
-0.185869500041008,
1.0390686988830566,
-0.37628787755966187,
0.678126871585846,
0.46074414253234863,
0.22967790067195892,
0.2231919914484024,
0.3897741138935089,
0.30355238914489746,
0.6266440153121948,
0.46661826968193054,
-0.33015868067741394,
-0.6284580826759338,
-0.11539308726787567,
-0.2610180974006653,
0.3373377323150635,
0.2823255956172943,
-0.3937605023384094,
-0.3236803114414215,
0.2662879228591919,
0.2761251628398895,
0.023260507732629776,
-0.4472030997276306,
0.8258992433547974,
0.18113628029823303,
-0.5366770625114441,
0.4883096218109131,
-0.09567885845899582,
0.7714284658432007,
-0.6304660439491272,
0.028843380510807037,
-0.1419643610715866,
0.38274791836738586,
-0.17151647806167603,
-0.5125318169593811,
0.09780536592006683,
0.11170526593923569,
-0.19189785420894623,
-0.2121780514717102,
0.9089825749397278,
-0.39359158277511597,
-0.43599843978881836,
0.6255583763122559,
0.5687131881713867,
0.08876851201057434,
-0.016062112525105476,
-0.5435493588447571,
-0.25653114914894104,
0.18464361131191254,
-0.15716668963432312,
0.7449418902397156,
0.5451955199241638,
-0.35086381435394287,
1.0152093172073364,
1.0446903705596924,
-0.08328958600759506,
0.13476291298866272,
0.31333038210868835,
1.1134072542190552,
-0.3244227468967438,
-0.4388907253742218,
-0.6256800293922424,
0.5449915528297424,
0.07006625086069107,
-0.2304726392030716,
0.8884767889976501,
0.4894627332687378,
0.8330596685409546,
0.2806697189807892,
0.9009758234024048,
0.37517210841178894,
0.4276089668273926,
-0.4805822968482971,
1.223044753074646,
-0.4743749499320984,
0.6737073659896851,
-0.24703893065452576,
-0.7879835963249207,
-0.39367789030075073,
0.3338182270526886,
-0.2932693064212799,
0.02530093677341938,
0.3612731397151947,
0.9288977384567261,
0.23669633269309998,
0.09310896694660187,
0.7256528735160828,
0.31623563170433044,
0.3728772699832916,
0.4391986131668091,
0.9902270436286926,
0.13408517837524414,
0.7067108750343323,
-0.1701088696718216,
-0.3126722276210785,
0.1383572518825531,
-0.8424345850944519,
-1.1513108015060425,
-0.3686661720275879,
0.033677417784929276,
-0.3027432858943939,
0.1404799073934555,
0.6770106554031372,
0.5992467403411865,
-0.7461665272712708,
-0.12286031246185303,
-0.06206028535962105,
0.3908618688583374,
0.08204121142625809,
-0.17349039018154144,
0.06917683035135269,
-0.4585050344467163,
-0.3606996536254883,
0.6079027056694031,
0.16303299367427826,
-0.0046772100031375885,
-0.24109528958797455,
-0.4212086498737335,
-0.015912815928459167,
0.014594814740121365,
0.5255632400512695,
0.2281835377216339,
-0.6178810000419617,
-0.20136728882789612,
-0.08550602942705154,
0.0340990386903286,
-0.2597583532333374,
0.7185025811195374,
-0.8439396619796753,
0.19024279713630676,
0.39845210313796997,
0.6285490989685059,
-0.01845456101000309,
-0.3106268644332886,
0.5552929639816284,
-0.7833986282348633,
0.09110825508832932,
0.25634968280792236,
0.38227206468582153,
0.19933980703353882,
-0.5606693625450134,
0.31351420283317566,
0.1426241546869278,
-0.4390888810157776,
-1.0342284440994263,
0.17086191475391388,
-0.7165464758872986,
-0.6131318807601929,
1.417246699333191,
-0.19251547753810883,
-0.28977519273757935,
-0.5111113786697388,
0.008209720253944397,
0.3917105197906494,
-0.6462528109550476,
0.6863791942596436,
0.39246341586112976,
0.21058884263038635,
0.013114295899868011,
-0.5403607487678528,
0.33096233010292053,
0.31698310375213623,
-0.6352548599243164,
0.3686861991882324,
0.32916077971458435,
0.6015149354934692,
-0.042553942650556564,
0.22798974812030792,
-0.28641214966773987,
0.04592828452587128,
-0.4205623269081116,
0.07752251625061035,
-0.3358438014984131,
-0.6937077641487122,
-0.4106445014476776,
0.24249018728733063,
-0.12852945923805237,
-0.12101104855537415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10052v1 | Unmemorization in Large Language Models via Self-Distillation and Deliberate Imagination | 2024-02-15T16:21:14 | 2024-02-15T16:21:14 | Yijiang River Dong, Hongzhou Lin, Mikhail Belkin, Ramon Huerta, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While displaying impressive generation capabilities across many tasks, Large
Language Models (LLMs) still struggle with crucial issues of privacy violation
and unwanted exposure of sensitive data. This raises an essential question: how
should we prevent such undesired behavior of LLMs while maintaining their
strong generation and natural language understanding (NLU) capabilities? In
this work, we introduce a novel approach termed deliberate imagination in the
context of LLM unlearning. Instead of trying to forget memorized data, we
employ a self-distillation framework, guiding LLMs to deliberately imagine
alternative scenarios. As demonstrated in a wide range of experiments, the
proposed method not only effectively unlearns targeted text but also preserves
the LLMs' capabilities in open-ended generation tasks as well as in NLU tasks.
Our results demonstrate the usefulness of this approach across different models
and sizes, and also with parameter-efficient fine-tuning, offering a novel
pathway to addressing the challenges with private and sensitive data in LLM
applications. | [
-0.2208254188299179,
-0.8644283413887024,
0.7294414639472961,
0.0317717120051384,
-0.4029983878135681,
0.2969718277454376,
-0.4825275242328644,
-0.10355951637029648,
-0.26771607995033264,
0.9362755417823792,
-0.6552800536155701,
-0.3444373309612274,
-0.27607256174087524,
-0.1571718156337738,
-0.3053308129310608,
1.029308557510376,
-0.2131710946559906,
-0.3592231571674347,
-0.12625639140605927,
0.06703025102615356,
-0.24673610925674438,
-0.6041706204414368,
-0.46949249505996704,
-0.3596256673336029,
0.4554230570793152,
0.37578895688056946,
0.4048541784286499,
0.7080615758895874,
0.07046405225992203,
0.3894813358783722,
0.055080000311136246,
0.45763564109802246,
-0.8792047500610352,
0.4030081331729889,
-0.5006549954414368,
-0.4762449562549591,
0.02581169083714485,
0.09732188284397125,
0.7461727857589722,
0.6832635402679443,
-0.24348343908786774,
0.26428893208503723,
0.464800626039505,
0.7865465879440308,
-0.7479310631752014,
0.07495301961898804,
-0.9873979091644287,
0.17694954574108124,
-0.2323879897594452,
-0.2868320941925049,
-0.5741957426071167,
0.1395759880542755,
-0.22169262170791626,
-0.356121301651001,
0.3150578439235687,
0.0026646344922482967,
0.4662854075431824,
0.44222307205200195,
-0.2663325369358063,
-0.10530367493629456,
-1.2283328771591187,
0.8894438743591309,
-0.7887254357337952,
0.17908094823360443,
0.3767983913421631,
0.22578230500221252,
-0.5634105801582336,
-0.8016144633293152,
-0.6914737224578857,
0.111981101334095,
0.11896155774593353,
0.1113063171505928,
-0.26470932364463806,
-0.04658329486846924,
0.23053035140037537,
0.4727044403553009,
-0.4019812345504761,
0.3586426377296448,
-0.4219698905944824,
-0.15291160345077515,
0.7049713134765625,
0.17729081213474274,
0.11069979518651962,
-0.006928618066012859,
-0.4173333942890167,
0.15337349474430084,
-0.7133973836898804,
-0.23231764137744904,
0.5495556592941284,
0.15948258340358734,
0.286037802696228,
0.733532726764679,
-0.20265059173107147,
0.2749994695186615,
0.08220263570547104,
0.05776779353618622,
0.1741477996110916,
-0.14001698791980743,
-0.44727709889411926,
-0.04697776213288307,
0.9212614893913269,
0.029857290908694267,
0.3010363280773163,
-0.42343202233314514,
-0.3057757318019867,
0.0556953065097332,
0.3697548508644104,
-0.6887169480323792,
-0.19657514989376068,
0.3532070219516754,
-0.34860214591026306,
-0.3354496657848358,
-0.4290946424007416,
-0.8104833364486694,
-0.4133196771144867,
-0.44687092304229736,
0.21715523302555084,
-0.32634517550468445,
-0.3329375982284546,
0.28971290588378906,
0.11431034654378891,
-0.3883510231971741,
0.028357727453112602,
-1.1423677206039429,
0.16439288854599,
0.5766742825508118,
0.41310253739356995,
-0.025026367977261543,
-0.42881542444229126,
-0.15666617453098297,
0.5052614212036133,
-0.24080780148506165,
0.3889501988887787,
-0.3512457311153412,
-0.4078585207462311,
-0.21981437504291534,
-0.2425089031457901,
-0.03065861389040947,
-0.5342589020729065,
0.43104273080825806,
-0.37530046701431274,
0.37046265602111816,
0.12134881317615509,
-0.6791279911994934,
-0.2223551720380783,
0.130740687251091,
-0.5289921760559082,
0.8799339532852173,
-0.189935103058815,
-0.6509639620780945,
0.3182811439037323,
-0.4361710250377655,
-0.10308670997619629,
-0.05966465547680855,
-0.38062000274658203,
-0.4279523193836212,
0.6515900492668152,
0.23431329429149628,
0.4619549810886383,
-0.16924315690994263,
0.5504706501960754,
-0.15973114967346191,
-0.06251709908246994,
0.4920775592327118,
-1.033226728439331,
0.5820237398147583,
0.5653928518295288,
-0.26602521538734436,
-0.023582905530929565,
-0.8176058530807495,
0.2227277159690857,
0.325764536857605,
-0.3343820571899414,
-0.4319763481616974,
0.03556912764906883,
-0.28798672556877136,
0.31658732891082764,
0.42179811000823975,
-0.6080617308616638,
0.26524609327316284,
-0.5167479515075684,
0.5247204899787903,
0.852025032043457,
0.2150571644306183,
0.4941040575504303,
-0.258053183555603,
0.35820385813713074,
0.1354617178440094,
0.10838769376277924,
-0.24899932742118835,
-0.1600680947303772,
-0.7659395933151245,
-0.20629625022411346,
0.19156061112880707,
0.18930579721927643,
-0.6722506880760193,
0.37450721859931946,
-0.07624317705631256,
-0.4255107343196869,
-0.5908569097518921,
0.5711973905563354,
0.4200115203857422,
0.3734948933124542,
0.24412263929843903,
0.018835198134183884,
-0.5069864988327026,
-0.862358570098877,
-0.4759686589241028,
-0.005272353067994118,
-0.10779587924480438,
0.17288167774677277,
0.3156049847602844,
-0.24522064626216888,
1.0087450742721558,
-0.44451987743377686,
-0.30753740668296814,
-0.4456802308559418,
0.5052703619003296,
0.1285843849182129,
0.6381875276565552,
0.2892967760562897,
-0.8061280250549316,
-0.2952849566936493,
-0.185469388961792,
-0.86826092004776,
-0.10127926617860794,
-0.6173698902130127,
-0.10631629824638367,
0.1696004867553711,
0.6585711240768433,
-0.5700678825378418,
0.47811782360076904,
0.44931066036224365,
-0.1504959762096405,
0.28152358531951904,
-0.7072017192840576,
-0.18654663860797882,
-1.167487621307373,
-0.00775253726169467,
-0.3395078182220459,
-0.07561404258012772,
-0.7107897996902466,
0.15607726573944092,
0.10761374235153198,
0.04197874665260315,
-0.561750590801239,
0.5334701538085938,
-0.8511050939559937,
0.3907957375049591,
-0.563099205493927,
0.01094040647149086,
0.07272841781377792,
0.5630577802658081,
-0.06424549221992493,
0.5347610116004944,
0.4723201096057892,
-0.4670346677303314,
-0.022014016285538673,
0.08562294393777847,
-0.4476214647293091,
-0.12903092801570892,
-0.30347928404808044,
0.4450107514858246,
-0.594477653503418,
0.048528674989938736,
-0.8725550770759583,
0.004011132754385471,
-0.05114112049341202,
-0.2200058102607727,
0.39342620968818665,
-0.08984117954969406,
-0.7227123379707336,
-0.2851473391056061,
-0.1861715018749237,
0.4781143367290497,
0.6468481421470642,
-0.7466240525245667,
0.689913809299469,
0.5063081383705139,
0.07109437137842178,
-0.6261608004570007,
-0.794166088104248,
0.17551419138908386,
-0.6178918480873108,
-0.3713727295398712,
0.25477179884910583,
-0.2646123766899109,
-0.35744261741638184,
-0.10493259876966476,
-0.10544949769973755,
0.014039892703294754,
0.21615272760391235,
0.39270803332328796,
0.13245940208435059,
0.11742869019508362,
-0.06391480565071106,
0.1986277550458908,
-0.07977822422981262,
0.139133483171463,
-0.4107058346271515,
0.6836745142936707,
0.255370557308197,
-0.2939525246620178,
-0.17516960203647614,
0.2528859078884125,
0.4116398096084595,
-0.3008795380592346,
0.7829210162162781,
0.3994077742099762,
-0.4162207543849945,
-0.7332131266593933,
-0.6562362313270569,
-0.03553244099020958,
-0.6375526785850525,
0.16165316104888916,
-0.24640779197216034,
-0.96915602684021,
0.501169741153717,
-0.34848806262016296,
0.34319132566452026,
0.09412655979394913,
0.7603658437728882,
-0.06642244011163712,
0.8307089805603027,
0.6988795399665833,
-0.03222072124481201,
0.2595950961112976,
-0.11356113851070404,
0.3478242754936218,
-0.9521257877349854,
-0.20179662108421326,
-0.14486734569072723,
-0.5294669270515442,
-0.4684758484363556,
-0.6188162565231323,
0.03252843767404556,
0.34724974632263184,
0.040896281599998474,
0.0853535607457161,
-0.3291352093219757,
0.9083918929100037,
0.36511513590812683,
-0.01931043714284897,
0.39838936924934387,
0.043238747864961624,
-0.36986401677131653,
-0.17595644295215607,
-0.503254771232605,
-0.6212854385375977,
1.2773246765136719,
0.32543042302131653,
0.8917087316513062,
0.08146781474351883,
1.1691104173660278,
-0.08067905902862549,
0.20169055461883545,
-0.33546072244644165,
0.6246815919876099,
-0.20949044823646545,
-0.7660036683082581,
-0.5531072616577148,
-0.526443600654602,
-1.203500509262085,
0.4387941360473633,
-0.11405612528324127,
-1.0868133306503296,
0.06650333851575851,
0.22523193061351776,
-0.3847828507423401,
0.537764310836792,
-0.6467702388763428,
0.7627279162406921,
-0.2819680869579315,
-0.6057831048965454,
-0.23668645322322845,
-0.2303086668252945,
0.4888423979282379,
-0.5137477517127991,
0.40260517597198486,
-0.3096143901348114,
0.011303999461233616,
0.43157029151916504,
-0.2528499364852905,
1.1060080528259277,
0.019329331815242767,
-0.32556167244911194,
0.5393874049186707,
0.3774675726890564,
0.6054559350013733,
0.11930886656045914,
-0.019176151603460312,
0.09416641294956207,
-0.42795494198799133,
-0.14371104538440704,
-0.6119349598884583,
0.9117258191108704,
-0.44857457280158997,
-0.8461188673973083,
-0.18289485573768616,
-0.8176169395446777,
-0.3333154618740082,
0.40110504627227783,
0.35605838894844055,
0.0879475399851799,
-0.4249081611633301,
0.13435326516628265,
0.7669561505317688,
-0.2539612054824829,
0.7509461045265198,
0.7380348443984985,
-0.3924785554409027,
-0.05387476086616516,
0.9681572318077087,
0.14673103392124176,
0.33995890617370605,
0.26268795132637024,
0.3670516610145569,
-0.5063315629959106,
-0.907721996307373,
-0.25872528553009033,
0.19756372272968292,
-0.6419193148612976,
0.0554465614259243,
-0.7063968777656555,
-0.17892518639564514,
-0.2841218411922455,
0.008998937904834747,
-0.46756377816200256,
-0.44457873702049255,
-0.5323632955551147,
-0.25209617614746094,
0.08677032589912415,
0.5880550742149353,
-0.1991042196750641,
0.16217653453350067,
-0.7665567994117737,
0.39966830611228943,
0.18656088411808014,
0.25648990273475647,
0.10852675139904022,
-0.6674129366874695,
-0.04820948839187622,
0.16903753578662872,
-0.3328191041946411,
-0.35073772072792053,
0.7855138182640076,
0.1080608144402504,
0.6140527725219727,
0.4519056975841522,
0.2145351618528366,
0.5965520143508911,
-0.8282711505889893,
0.4803389012813568,
0.05954758822917938,
-0.7385075092315674,
0.4391185939311981,
-0.4908917546272278,
0.4688492715358734,
0.8190394639968872,
0.2413581758737564,
-0.436052531003952,
-0.6257616877555847,
-0.7193713784217834,
-1.106170654296875,
0.369588166475296,
0.2897430658340454,
0.4034484624862671,
-0.03984352946281433,
0.33535999059677124,
0.23818258941173553,
0.3193075656890869,
-0.8011882901191711,
-0.09356393665075302,
0.1409692019224167,
-0.242559552192688,
-0.25290486216545105,
-0.3223302960395813,
-0.14709389209747314,
-0.12404783070087433,
0.47428327798843384,
-0.003387167351320386,
-0.20041994750499725,
-0.17670458555221558,
-0.19896486401557922,
-0.19114474952220917,
0.3710399866104126,
0.20525628328323364,
0.5292329788208008,
0.1596498042345047,
0.32734087109565735,
0.12995322048664093,
-0.4616662561893463,
0.08826909959316254,
-0.17330457270145416,
-0.219266876578331,
-0.36368945240974426,
-0.052960947155952454,
0.584291398525238,
0.321519672870636,
-0.7987030744552612,
0.13229797780513763,
-0.1529955416917801,
-0.2117534726858139,
-0.4176338016986847,
0.33328109979629517,
0.3127709627151489,
0.1905060112476349,
0.21748366951942444,
-0.08290331065654755,
0.08527583628892899,
-0.6596396565437317,
0.14856699109077454,
0.3529413342475891,
0.07394953817129135,
-0.2016686499118805,
0.9045335054397583,
-0.09684140980243683,
-0.06025717779994011,
0.6582197546958923,
-0.2282271683216095,
-0.20449446141719818,
0.3592551052570343,
0.7607840895652771,
1.1080539226531982,
-0.3777520954608917,
0.04339783266186714,
0.193786159157753,
0.3725959062576294,
-0.2351183146238327,
0.3075389564037323,
-0.02973281778395176,
-0.9043204188346863,
-0.3464089632034302,
-0.719883143901825,
0.0026975604705512524,
0.585274875164032,
-0.5217501521110535,
-0.11938481032848358,
-0.6439688801765442,
0.0711931437253952,
0.1283266544342041,
-0.22488515079021454,
-0.5405595898628235,
0.15480586886405945,
0.3441351652145386,
0.4760109782218933,
-0.5731492638587952,
1.0328655242919922,
0.16579744219779968,
-0.15669028460979462,
-0.7712247967720032,
0.03505299240350723,
0.10969559848308563,
-0.7147229313850403,
0.40610137581825256,
0.19646331667900085,
-0.0811162069439888,
0.04408714547753334,
-0.38528719544410706,
-0.8506880402565002,
0.9334834218025208,
0.39756885170936584,
-0.9281759858131409,
0.07592419534921646,
0.5874680280685425,
0.6424190998077393,
-0.08149256557226181,
-0.30303242802619934,
0.7017918229103088,
0.3172667622566223,
-0.0025806922931224108,
-0.6289687156677246,
0.04310153052210808,
-0.23197536170482635,
-0.05747806653380394,
0.3733105957508087,
-0.6295781135559082,
0.8168413043022156,
-0.3722170889377594,
-0.5017091631889343,
-0.009618413634598255,
0.7206684350967407,
0.13938945531845093,
0.11834357678890228,
0.3704974055290222,
0.5189449787139893,
0.8855406045913696,
0.14918012917041779,
0.6402057409286499,
-0.16397495567798615,
0.19492480158805847,
1.5158742666244507,
-0.42487242817878723,
0.7363842129707336,
0.5719956159591675,
0.20007945597171783,
-0.020343856886029243,
0.21347591280937195,
0.017926985397934914,
0.5565705895423889,
0.4366361200809479,
-0.5147837400436401,
-0.27723005414009094,
0.056858889758586884,
0.022015411406755447,
0.7144176363945007,
0.4134586453437805,
-0.45900875329971313,
-0.3392351269721985,
0.14002728462219238,
0.045542795211076736,
0.5274626612663269,
-0.2244366556406021,
0.8234344124794006,
0.13576437532901764,
-0.6745290756225586,
0.5986505746841431,
0.01109855342656374,
0.5678368210792542,
-0.4331493377685547,
0.14721760153770447,
-0.13219565153121948,
0.4550172984600067,
-0.034328244626522064,
-0.7560151815414429,
0.33530446887016296,
0.2167883813381195,
-0.09597588330507278,
-0.6000727415084839,
0.564622163772583,
-0.7319279313087463,
-0.6119701266288757,
0.1863994002342224,
0.6099718809127808,
0.21067656576633453,
-0.10920608043670654,
-0.6017413139343262,
-0.02652519941329956,
0.1890704184770584,
-0.5165696144104004,
0.6810776591300964,
0.974291980266571,
0.007975483313202858,
0.7904199957847595,
0.7707799673080444,
0.023755483329296112,
-0.006094729527831078,
0.1594834178686142,
1.0691289901733398,
-0.6604297161102295,
-0.6240594983100891,
-1.2081923484802246,
0.38959431648254395,
0.025027461349964142,
-0.28720906376838684,
0.9856206774711609,
0.7279618978500366,
0.9064652323722839,
0.06939084827899933,
0.8265018463134766,
0.34981366991996765,
0.4191950857639313,
-0.6081432104110718,
1.0074634552001953,
-0.3612104058265686,
0.47612422704696655,
-0.13560886681079865,
-0.7839057445526123,
-0.1177644357085228,
0.38229602575302124,
-0.24476924538612366,
-0.07655183225870132,
0.5952376127243042,
0.5388203859329224,
-0.0382220596075058,
0.028317490592598915,
0.5602114796638489,
0.32961657643318176,
0.29820340871810913,
0.5551766753196716,
0.9684615731239319,
0.0667041689157486,
0.3160015940666199,
-0.3973902761936188,
-0.1997377723455429,
0.34581688046455383,
-1.008437156677246,
-1.1992987394332886,
-0.47242024540901184,
-0.13364501297473907,
-0.031621307134628296,
-0.15301793813705444,
0.747726559638977,
0.2718304991722107,
-0.5296106338500977,
-0.18314260244369507,
-0.24885834753513336,
-0.23457016050815582,
-0.04223186522722244,
-0.11287245899438858,
0.10889976471662521,
-0.37252286076545715,
-0.8707060217857361,
0.7713350057601929,
0.3114604651927948,
0.35648322105407715,
-0.6166618466377258,
0.2517699897289276,
-0.010386615991592407,
0.3730514645576477,
0.39066484570503235,
0.3589729070663452,
-0.46418625116348267,
-0.08116944879293442,
-0.3318342864513397,
0.07443655282258987,
-0.0886182188987732,
0.9388713836669922,
-0.9007107019424438,
0.585951030254364,
0.2036670297384262,
0.5334031581878662,
0.6288760304450989,
0.028662150725722313,
0.6124734282493591,
-1.0145899057388306,
0.4670572876930237,
0.393253356218338,
0.4781603515148163,
0.12746837735176086,
-0.6189119219779968,
0.3442133665084839,
-0.23923295736312866,
-0.5367584228515625,
-0.9534009695053101,
0.2760440409183502,
-0.5945715308189392,
-0.7961681485176086,
1.1352556943893433,
-0.09422655403614044,
-0.35474541783332825,
-0.24067343771457672,
-0.1889270544052124,
0.24397650361061096,
-0.11264313757419586,
1.1872498989105225,
0.527172863483429,
0.03173919767141342,
0.04272763431072235,
-0.4837086796760559,
0.5092617273330688,
0.33979347348213196,
-0.7830947041511536,
0.8635100722312927,
0.512121319770813,
0.21494729816913605,
-0.06244400516152382,
0.7391042113304138,
-0.20482970774173737,
-0.2276279777288437,
-0.048233434557914734,
-0.08656438440084457,
-0.32059305906295776,
-0.5279068350791931,
-0.32039207220077515,
0.09082826226949692,
-0.033886250108480453,
-0.10829038172960281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10051v1 | SwissNYF: Tool Grounded LLM Agents for Black Box Setting | 2024-02-15T16:15:38 | 2024-02-15T16:15:38 | Somnath Sendhil Kumar, Dhruv Jain, Eshaan Agarwal, Raunak Pandey | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated enhanced capabilities in
function-calling, these advancements primarily rely on accessing the functions'
responses. This methodology is practical for simpler APIs but faces scalability
issues with irreversible APIs that significantly impact the system, such as a
database deletion API. Similarly, processes requiring extensive time for each
API call and those necessitating forward planning, like automated action
pipelines, present complex challenges. Furthermore, scenarios often arise where
a generalized approach is needed because algorithms lack direct access to the
specific implementations of these functions or secrets to use them. Traditional
tool planning methods are inadequate in these cases, compelling the need to
operate within black-box environments. Unlike their performance in tool
manipulation, LLMs excel in black-box tasks, such as program synthesis.
Therefore, we harness the program synthesis capabilities of LLMs to strategize
tool usage in black-box settings, ensuring solutions are verified prior to
implementation. We introduce TOPGUN, an ingeniously crafted approach leveraging
program synthesis for black box tool planning. Accompanied by SwissNYF, a
comprehensive suite that integrates black-box algorithms for planning and
verification tasks, addressing the aforementioned challenges and enhancing the
versatility and effectiveness of LLMs in complex API interactions. The public
code for SwissNYF is available at https://github.com/iclr-dummy-user/SwissNYF. | [
-0.2823624610900879,
-0.8383697867393494,
0.6217221617698669,
0.4011506140232086,
-0.34055957198143005,
0.4848082959651947,
-0.14697006344795227,
-0.37163427472114563,
0.177535280585289,
0.7767316699028015,
-0.9299321174621582,
-0.7170196771621704,
-0.4153567850589752,
0.03239165246486664,
-0.4815841317176819,
0.8281677961349487,
-0.05327700078487396,
-0.32183387875556946,
-0.07849907875061035,
-0.18180717527866364,
-0.4193122982978821,
-0.55091792345047,
-0.4592874348163605,
-0.896492063999176,
0.19241665303707123,
0.2952239215373993,
0.7312253713607788,
0.621649444103241,
0.10872677713632584,
0.3642408549785614,
0.05468101054430008,
0.09327717870473862,
-0.7409929633140564,
0.18996596336364746,
-0.30960801243782043,
-0.48426553606987,
-0.5306662917137146,
-0.2932676374912262,
0.13238045573234558,
0.6036195755004883,
-0.23957699537277222,
0.16945326328277588,
-0.37280693650245667,
0.3879595100879669,
-0.6190944314002991,
0.02805713564157486,
-0.7331504225730896,
0.2093847543001175,
0.34848979115486145,
-0.22747570276260376,
-0.11227035522460938,
-0.07332461327314377,
0.184835284948349,
-0.5682446360588074,
0.09466920793056488,
0.011245491914451122,
0.8057202100753784,
0.3693840205669403,
-0.08061878383159637,
-0.1558840423822403,
-1.0473114252090454,
0.815743088722229,
-0.6762648820877075,
0.19011351466178894,
0.31778278946876526,
0.2395937293767929,
-0.5391586422920227,
-0.6202496886253357,
-0.3001648187637329,
-0.16835586726665497,
0.022533416748046875,
0.0050606210716068745,
-0.3354226052761078,
0.09150479733943939,
0.45866259932518005,
0.1622174084186554,
-0.4432487189769745,
0.13346482813358307,
-0.3737841546535492,
-0.32631129026412964,
0.5112234950065613,
0.17630557715892792,
0.0009704839903861284,
0.2345193326473236,
-0.31995123624801636,
0.10367289930582047,
-1.0862805843353271,
-0.06407303363084793,
0.5764294266700745,
0.17146183550357819,
-0.10789134353399277,
0.7394247055053711,
-0.20810960233211517,
0.7472615242004395,
0.21535617113113403,
-0.18872946500778198,
-0.1093325987458229,
-0.3822445869445801,
-0.4868205189704895,
0.18434593081474304,
0.5717630982398987,
0.44455721974372864,
0.18741987645626068,
-0.3762247860431671,
-0.4621705710887909,
0.10298055410385132,
0.5685045123100281,
-1.1460524797439575,
0.0840032547712326,
0.6969497203826904,
-0.1093975380063057,
-0.4199620485305786,
-0.2367396354675293,
-0.4908173978328705,
-0.21183212101459503,
-0.3460248112678528,
0.3374081552028656,
0.1004357859492302,
-0.47885027527809143,
0.08950361609458923,
-0.20006206631660461,
0.26475274562835693,
0.10134872049093246,
-0.5421088933944702,
0.28428664803504944,
0.8988659381866455,
0.8143141269683838,
0.0651254653930664,
-0.2599867880344391,
-0.8783025741577148,
0.518903911113739,
-0.8037900328636169,
0.645898163318634,
-0.2623392343521118,
-0.7738445997238159,
0.18432068824768066,
0.09638000279664993,
0.6949425339698792,
-0.6108835339546204,
0.2635832130908966,
-0.42007976770401,
-0.3716295063495636,
-0.15665596723556519,
-0.14455777406692505,
0.0005214456468820572,
0.45248934626579285,
-0.43510502576828003,
0.9709266424179077,
0.24526424705982208,
-0.4807951748371124,
0.3397758901119232,
-0.4790303111076355,
-0.5227985978126526,
0.14488132297992706,
-0.2647362947463989,
-0.3162713646888733,
0.17332710325717926,
0.13309118151664734,
0.6602761149406433,
-0.20254859328269958,
0.28990423679351807,
-0.66890549659729,
-0.6255960464477539,
0.37263137102127075,
0.23877160251140594,
0.8316518068313599,
0.16484665870666504,
-0.5322405695915222,
0.4655735194683075,
-0.9027892351150513,
0.1319987028837204,
0.013044931925833225,
-0.03633338585495949,
-0.32835444808006287,
0.029217176139354706,
-0.004677198827266693,
0.18858596682548523,
0.02716992236673832,
-0.6040393114089966,
0.018455637618899345,
-0.7467498779296875,
0.5801355838775635,
0.8362583518028259,
-0.012247629463672638,
0.31291070580482483,
-0.15590424835681915,
0.663129985332489,
-0.34786170721054077,
-0.07188556343317032,
-0.045942436903715134,
-0.02709309570491314,
-0.7031282782554626,
-0.2734748423099518,
0.07859310507774353,
0.8323500156402588,
-0.8509008288383484,
0.5461885333061218,
0.07943441718816757,
-0.4111939072608948,
-0.5208191871643066,
0.47820764780044556,
0.46950024366378784,
0.2597294747829437,
-0.15808911621570587,
-0.2291930466890335,
-0.42680874466896057,
-1.0430985689163208,
0.18005253374576569,
-0.2625552713871002,
-0.023305276408791542,
0.0045083556324243546,
0.38361144065856934,
-0.34381502866744995,
0.8223314881324768,
-0.5991343259811401,
-0.09980618953704834,
-0.4056101143360138,
-0.01826334558427334,
0.3406156897544861,
0.19653861224651337,
0.6204184889793396,
-0.5398666858673096,
-0.130268856883049,
0.07723179459571838,
-0.7314215898513794,
-0.39837685227394104,
0.029415996745228767,
-0.5284397602081299,
0.07492334395647049,
0.6106351017951965,
-0.5969719290733337,
0.4245631992816925,
0.6337132453918457,
-0.16486461460590363,
0.6744165420532227,
-0.15948054194450378,
-0.16191722452640533,
-0.8645836710929871,
0.1201678141951561,
0.01821971870958805,
-0.3176659345626831,
-0.679401159286499,
0.2671724557876587,
-0.051150355488061905,
-0.3879973590373993,
-0.5840687155723572,
0.8321078419685364,
-0.39916977286338806,
-0.43847477436065674,
-0.565005898475647,
-0.16637757420539856,
-0.17818427085876465,
0.4912113845348358,
-0.0025434743147343397,
1.1091158390045166,
0.5697354078292847,
-0.6180983781814575,
0.2710343301296234,
-0.0013071568682789803,
-0.009529661387205124,
0.8337927460670471,
-0.9877420663833618,
0.15085697174072266,
0.2607271671295166,
-0.13482306897640228,
-0.7713518738746643,
-0.06378791481256485,
0.42394599318504333,
-0.09821286052465439,
0.45742011070251465,
-0.6288477182388306,
-0.7145904898643494,
-0.15171438455581665,
-0.3612138628959656,
0.034253403544425964,
0.4066859185695648,
-0.28880348801612854,
0.751574695110321,
0.4212648570537567,
-0.22161619365215302,
-0.983905553817749,
-0.7965264916419983,
0.18846172094345093,
-0.01322001963853836,
-0.46389004588127136,
0.21964791417121887,
-0.3586169183254242,
-0.4710293114185333,
0.04494703561067581,
-0.30691424012184143,
0.038624927401542664,
0.22311091423034668,
0.5442821383476257,
0.30050215125083923,
0.05962935835123062,
-0.26640796661376953,
0.07506026327610016,
-0.4179145097732544,
0.1339472383260727,
-0.5177536010742188,
0.24002842605113983,
0.028741830959916115,
-0.41475337743759155,
0.08347784727811813,
0.49079298973083496,
0.6922004222869873,
-0.24691379070281982,
0.3082735538482666,
0.60084068775177,
-0.41577184200286865,
-0.7083187103271484,
-0.5271698236465454,
-0.06389627605676651,
-0.5808686017990112,
0.1464909017086029,
-0.30862316489219666,
-0.9295517206192017,
0.5975489616394043,
-0.27449357509613037,
0.46385422348976135,
-0.2623564600944519,
0.9542665481567383,
0.2572402060031891,
0.8049922585487366,
0.8685699105262756,
0.13787603378295898,
0.42545056343078613,
-0.47671377658843994,
0.3544348478317261,
-0.6484231352806091,
0.061615534126758575,
-0.4107203483581543,
-0.24048112332820892,
-0.35464292764663696,
-0.2655940353870392,
0.3496689796447754,
-0.017235111445188522,
-0.03502869978547096,
0.28296127915382385,
-0.5890771150588989,
0.5699822902679443,
0.4299665093421936,
-0.2581629455089569,
0.1612861156463623,
0.2675670385360718,
-0.508396327495575,
0.21736007928848267,
-0.4662334620952606,
-0.5190737843513489,
1.1729326248168945,
0.1939069777727127,
0.9020013809204102,
-0.23947283625602722,
1.000105857849121,
0.10391374677419662,
0.3861914575099945,
-1.0250340700149536,
0.8280332088470459,
0.13037186861038208,
-0.6529591679573059,
-0.3165417015552521,
-0.14120596647262573,
-0.8640060424804688,
0.3397228717803955,
-0.020858047530055046,
-0.6362520456314087,
0.07525616884231567,
0.0919465646147728,
-0.26760348677635193,
0.14287051558494568,
-0.768241286277771,
0.5784434080123901,
-0.3589347004890442,
-0.7077447772026062,
-0.11206099390983582,
-0.3013651967048645,
0.2924281656742096,
-0.10521969199180603,
0.22654153406620026,
-0.3376748859882355,
-0.10255129635334015,
0.33712369203567505,
-0.3957304358482361,
0.8688458800315857,
-0.1589932143688202,
-0.2434765100479126,
0.22526995837688446,
0.5416450500488281,
0.6349200010299683,
0.1898965984582901,
-0.14507268369197845,
0.3375321924686432,
0.16352535784244537,
-0.3493511974811554,
-0.4350965619087219,
0.8962858319282532,
-0.7230234742164612,
-0.8378414511680603,
-0.4761812686920166,
-0.6017013788223267,
-0.19752195477485657,
0.5239194631576538,
-0.1645604819059372,
0.47157561779022217,
-0.26988840103149414,
0.03869548439979553,
0.6055903434753418,
-0.15376171469688416,
0.5005630850791931,
0.7049069404602051,
-0.34730517864227295,
-0.5648198127746582,
0.6661245822906494,
0.29657918214797974,
0.25734788179397583,
0.22987642884254456,
-0.024634359404444695,
-0.1168651357293129,
-1.0948824882507324,
-0.7024999260902405,
0.3426743447780609,
-0.7613446116447449,
-0.27356526255607605,
-0.35445377230644226,
-0.11083704233169556,
-0.05097438395023346,
-0.5510838031768799,
-0.14855904877185822,
-0.4119793474674225,
-0.22830753028392792,
-0.4458155930042267,
0.18650424480438232,
0.6203349232673645,
0.00973441917449236,
0.26240548491477966,
-0.4772009551525116,
0.4066886603832245,
0.25611579418182373,
0.5330567955970764,
-0.17387156188488007,
0.12551607191562653,
-0.23911260068416595,
-0.197365403175354,
-0.21352486312389374,
-0.666499137878418,
0.3970964550971985,
-0.21193264424800873,
0.797120213508606,
0.15365837514400482,
0.17495432496070862,
0.6861396431922913,
-0.4975801110267639,
0.6341261863708496,
-0.001279080519452691,
-0.7035515308380127,
0.5015497207641602,
-0.37490764260292053,
0.3809157609939575,
0.24866776168346405,
0.14482180774211884,
-0.11747745424509048,
-0.8335784077644348,
-0.4655965268611908,
-0.778134822845459,
0.7569802403450012,
0.23053428530693054,
0.11220482736825943,
0.32763051986694336,
0.41384005546569824,
0.13862566649913788,
0.4990996718406677,
-0.5693445205688477,
-0.24054238200187683,
-0.25418540835380554,
-0.10139793902635574,
-0.16209881007671356,
-0.2315511703491211,
-0.7851305603981018,
0.174582377076149,
0.5399887561798096,
-0.3330482840538025,
0.312719464302063,
0.01335999183356762,
-0.1223674863576889,
-0.47088778018951416,
0.5520803332328796,
0.6691457033157349,
1.3063024282455444,
-0.27074235677719116,
-0.06923176348209381,
0.045343559235334396,
-0.1522863209247589,
0.43031302094459534,
0.3369397521018982,
-0.6198335289955139,
-0.1855783611536026,
0.41857725381851196,
0.48504483699798584,
0.44606754183769226,
-0.8181524276733398,
0.23139528930187225,
0.13749191164970398,
-0.42097902297973633,
-0.42360204458236694,
0.4053674042224884,
0.31104058027267456,
0.5554755330085754,
0.4438706636428833,
-0.32141268253326416,
-0.0602475143969059,
-0.5414184331893921,
0.17095063626766205,
0.5604297518730164,
-0.22660845518112183,
-0.3346497714519501,
0.3353859782218933,
0.12998665869235992,
-0.6060490608215332,
0.09591016918420792,
-0.3503512740135193,
-0.39619025588035583,
0.5605605244636536,
0.6012125015258789,
1.1195164918899536,
0.13116669654846191,
0.3265376091003418,
0.014122294262051582,
0.48514795303344727,
0.09609972685575485,
0.4173814654350281,
0.10550173372030258,
-0.5051984190940857,
-0.6252575516700745,
-0.7181921005249023,
-0.47792237997055054,
0.19328676164150238,
-0.24629496037960052,
0.23119217157363892,
-0.9919171333312988,
-0.3122444152832031,
-0.10510773956775665,
0.22455132007598877,
-0.6663813591003418,
-0.3136870265007019,
-0.33684027194976807,
0.7987886667251587,
-0.538236677646637,
0.653849720954895,
0.9620953798294067,
-0.12869825959205627,
-0.48090603947639465,
-0.2622022032737732,
0.3314040005207062,
-0.7899758815765381,
0.4412762224674225,
-0.0585118792951107,
-0.42566797137260437,
-0.031668324023485184,
-0.6289113759994507,
-0.5255623459815979,
1.1971263885498047,
0.5873997807502747,
-0.44748470187187195,
0.10250896960496902,
-0.07507283240556717,
0.6299238204956055,
-0.4025927782058716,
-0.12073355168104172,
0.4513654410839081,
0.5033155679702759,
0.41465190052986145,
-0.8697443604469299,
0.19913305342197418,
-0.008348331786692142,
-0.0030912982765585184,
0.36591506004333496,
-0.4607492983341217,
0.3881050646305084,
-0.23503537476062775,
-0.2392050325870514,
-0.0007862700731493533,
0.33461612462997437,
0.5339980125427246,
0.3020530939102173,
0.37151220440864563,
0.5618199110031128,
0.325612872838974,
-0.04003262519836426,
0.8639911413192749,
-0.1319628804922104,
-0.14572054147720337,
0.7233295440673828,
-0.6728686094284058,
0.7670028209686279,
0.5329321622848511,
-0.14963671565055847,
0.316034734249115,
0.46618783473968506,
-0.10948238521814346,
0.5316877961158752,
0.2565992474555969,
-0.15656080842018127,
-0.26210394501686096,
-0.02850971184670925,
0.017390836030244827,
0.16137418150901794,
0.57314133644104,
0.06737561523914337,
-0.49808838963508606,
-0.07904350757598877,
-0.002962312428280711,
-0.00010783086327137426,
-0.30639833211898804,
0.7783650755882263,
0.23069508373737335,
-0.6863669157028198,
0.6542075276374817,
0.25316914916038513,
0.47954240441322327,
-0.9358470439910889,
-0.21027496457099915,
-0.06670623272657394,
0.29260334372520447,
-0.07857054471969604,
-0.7446482181549072,
0.21826153993606567,
-0.13396506011486053,
-0.01492295227944851,
-0.34071269631385803,
1.1027283668518066,
-0.4714430868625641,
-0.5387041568756104,
0.5074992179870605,
0.591138482093811,
-0.21524113416671753,
0.22878830134868622,
-0.9779344797134399,
0.49356940388679504,
-0.17149485647678375,
-0.0001202040002681315,
0.42338627576828003,
0.5826927423477173,
-0.07223498821258545,
1.0163326263427734,
0.9153480529785156,
0.5544586181640625,
-0.031036745756864548,
-0.12161680310964584,
0.8206126689910889,
-0.525646984577179,
-0.6453404426574707,
-0.5946923494338989,
0.3875638246536255,
0.04348023980855942,
-0.07050545513629913,
0.4827142357826233,
0.24623215198516846,
0.973982036113739,
-0.09519364684820175,
0.7213039994239807,
0.2304149866104126,
0.36581945419311523,
-0.6132432818412781,
0.4989902675151825,
-0.3869987428188324,
0.4007396399974823,
-0.16347505152225494,
-0.8497217297554016,
-0.22955822944641113,
0.5555186867713928,
-0.04503608122467995,
-0.2645888030529022,
0.37871843576431274,
1.1838245391845703,
-0.21740135550498962,
-0.39464396238327026,
0.5256838798522949,
-0.030607054010033607,
0.6459898948669434,
0.4294050335884094,
0.7268007397651672,
0.11934185028076172,
0.8052002191543579,
-0.3121033310890198,
-0.16772626340389252,
-0.3231438100337982,
-1.1685545444488525,
-1.2909626960754395,
-0.2235090434551239,
-0.3348216116428375,
-0.19487953186035156,
0.23378150165081024,
1.189300537109375,
0.9973675608634949,
-0.6243383884429932,
-0.7590044140815735,
0.22430232167243958,
0.3698244094848633,
-0.41164737939834595,
-0.17439080774784088,
0.07596012949943542,
-0.13323764503002167,
-0.4846917688846588,
0.3723582327365875,
0.5880941152572632,
0.16696186363697052,
-0.7241628766059875,
-0.2624630331993103,
-0.024420512840151787,
0.09406761080026627,
0.7443051934242249,
0.4547126591205597,
-0.9730998277664185,
-0.2985997796058655,
-0.0821831226348877,
0.15681962668895721,
-0.23286543786525726,
1.1717921495437622,
-0.7854886054992676,
0.6655431985855103,
0.19348178803920746,
0.9521518349647522,
0.6740791201591492,
-0.2113034427165985,
0.9433963894844055,
-0.9493020176887512,
0.4558272063732147,
0.14488574862480164,
0.23161821067333221,
0.29281309247016907,
-0.4742707908153534,
0.6539173126220703,
-0.03039325587451458,
-0.3383614420890808,
-1.1522579193115234,
0.26382023096084595,
-0.9346867799758911,
-0.3973899185657501,
1.1464803218841553,
-0.15530970692634583,
-0.27925771474838257,
-0.3311860263347626,
-0.2954694628715515,
-0.06356444209814072,
-0.4916035532951355,
0.5599882006645203,
1.256603479385376,
0.019315272569656372,
-0.3425780236721039,
-0.912840723991394,
0.30110418796539307,
-0.0188852958381176,
-0.6902495622634888,
0.283015638589859,
0.7920352220535278,
0.4748947024345398,
0.19917096197605133,
0.711699903011322,
-0.051366157829761505,
0.24282409250736237,
-0.20579931139945984,
-0.2150122970342636,
-0.7370368242263794,
-0.35266929864883423,
-0.25999686121940613,
0.2556995451450348,
0.25665998458862305,
0.20323430001735687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10038v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10038v2 | RS-DPO: A Hybrid Rejection Sampling and Direct Preference Optimization Method for Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T16:00:58 | 2024-03-30T16:10:47 | Saeed Khaki, JinJin Li, Lan Ma, Liu Yang, Prathap Ramachandra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has been extensively
employed to align large language models with user intent. However, proximal
policy optimization (PPO) based RLHF is occasionally unstable requiring
significant hyperparameter finetuning, and computationally expensive to
maximize the estimated reward during alignment. Recently, direct preference
optimization (DPO) is proposed to address those challenges. However, DPO relies
on contrastive responses generated from human annotator and alternative LLM,
instead of the policy model, limiting the effectiveness of the RLHF. In this
paper, we addresses both challenges by systematically combining rejection
sampling (RS) and DPO. Our proposed method, RS-DPO, initiates with the
development of a supervised fine-tuned policy model (SFT). A varied set of k
responses per prompt are sampled directly from the SFT model. RS-DPO identifies
pairs of contrastive samples based on their reward distribution. Finally, we
apply DPO with the contrastive samples to align the model to human preference.
Our experiments indicate that our proposed method effectively fine-tunes LLMs
with limited resource environments, leading to improved alignment with user
intent. Furthermore, it outperforms existing methods, including RS, PPO, and
DPO. | [
-0.36540475487709045,
-0.37675735354423523,
0.5269352793693542,
0.0831589475274086,
-0.23057636618614197,
0.26891395449638367,
-0.5316524505615234,
-0.08504306524991989,
0.09272469580173492,
0.5885577201843262,
-0.9426314830780029,
-0.2330353856086731,
-0.1352836638689041,
0.26936787366867065,
0.31762102246284485,
0.952975869178772,
-0.07187003642320633,
0.03323390334844589,
-0.07220497727394104,
0.2501506805419922,
-0.29027459025382996,
-0.16662785410881042,
-0.6150822043418884,
-0.5444604754447937,
0.45944133400917053,
0.6980484127998352,
0.650141179561615,
0.552702009677887,
0.33806440234184265,
0.3181970715522766,
-0.2030341476202011,
0.5050740838050842,
-0.5653548240661621,
-0.02114773727953434,
-0.3006575107574463,
-0.13057474792003632,
-0.2924855351448059,
0.007991938851773739,
0.7036014795303345,
0.48449522256851196,
-0.2949086129665375,
-0.13270823657512665,
0.24625630676746368,
0.6993968486785889,
-0.7716923952102661,
-0.19479885697364807,
-0.6007798910140991,
0.12435735017061234,
0.11699093878269196,
-0.28171584010124207,
-0.5518565773963928,
-0.4611153304576874,
0.30284416675567627,
-0.918857991695404,
-0.00031717168167233467,
0.15768666565418243,
0.6944606900215149,
0.26008808612823486,
-0.21964257955551147,
-0.1582058072090149,
-0.8576287627220154,
1.1498758792877197,
-0.4600122272968292,
0.11958306282758713,
0.42080703377723694,
0.18231651186943054,
-0.5332275032997131,
0.014055016450583935,
-0.9668868184089661,
-0.491489976644516,
-0.09582272917032242,
0.1155773475766182,
0.13024725019931793,
0.2531375288963318,
0.004213237203657627,
0.3644513785839081,
-0.5129513144493103,
0.5271030068397522,
-0.0800982341170311,
-0.2981005311012268,
0.6801889538764954,
0.169478639960289,
0.08496000617742538,
-0.19302068650722504,
-0.6578708291053772,
-0.4278087913990021,
-0.5623912215232849,
0.12228281795978546,
0.7506250739097595,
0.5245800018310547,
-0.008270532824099064,
0.40486064553260803,
-0.42523396015167236,
0.9513143301010132,
0.2941167652606964,
-0.3161437213420868,
0.21966150403022766,
-0.34147003293037415,
0.025447137653827667,
-0.15452323853969574,
1.050957202911377,
0.3691481947898865,
0.19204692542552948,
0.021516842767596245,
-0.4263160824775696,
-0.059341538697481155,
0.1389698088169098,
-0.4962117373943329,
0.06438541412353516,
0.2500694990158081,
-0.2592897117137909,
-0.6364700794219971,
-0.14005644619464874,
-0.9640153646469116,
-0.4949762523174286,
-0.5228427052497864,
0.12374190241098404,
-0.2209307998418808,
-0.3861732482910156,
0.14453212916851044,
0.04887240752577782,
0.03580929711461067,
0.28778406977653503,
-1.2523257732391357,
0.3579583466053009,
0.741228461265564,
0.4717332422733307,
-0.44736191630363464,
-0.34008514881134033,
-0.6998357176780701,
0.12137088924646378,
-0.2121814489364624,
0.5394424200057983,
-0.6573246717453003,
-0.48531657457351685,
0.057575225830078125,
-0.24421165883541107,
0.02508804202079773,
-0.7189639210700989,
0.8616876602172852,
-0.513523280620575,
0.2604694068431854,
-0.3471315801143646,
-0.22360120713710785,
0.011713840067386627,
0.27718931436538696,
-0.5059747695922852,
0.8572985529899597,
0.24838103353977203,
-0.6714388132095337,
0.41680872440338135,
-0.5227166414260864,
-0.24783939123153687,
0.010599498637020588,
-0.30307498574256897,
-0.5198367238044739,
-0.07790213078260422,
0.22673644125461578,
0.12669812142848969,
-0.19704556465148926,
0.4839654862880707,
-0.4438701868057251,
-0.5191246271133423,
0.33447742462158203,
-0.1704384684562683,
0.47804519534111023,
0.34743180871009827,
-0.24309895932674408,
0.5669175386428833,
-0.8882797360420227,
-0.14484132826328278,
0.19265711307525635,
-0.5301896333694458,
-0.47279417514801025,
0.21597380936145782,
0.06724440306425095,
0.33718207478523254,
0.02163787931203842,
-0.6739218831062317,
0.2879672646522522,
-0.4462890028953552,
0.4794694483280182,
1.0328325033187866,
-0.3153017461299896,
0.6953757405281067,
-0.18046601116657257,
0.694911777973175,
-0.1914714127779007,
0.14297688007354736,
0.4502739906311035,
0.07930499315261841,
-0.2702823281288147,
-0.4190719425678253,
0.2809370458126068,
0.49777907133102417,
-0.6117144227027893,
0.7659289836883545,
-0.19266507029533386,
-0.04729770869016647,
-0.5789647698402405,
0.08677603304386139,
0.5084118247032166,
0.8740423917770386,
0.25429990887641907,
-0.1422964185476303,
-0.5722119808197021,
-1.1577491760253906,
0.04505332186818123,
-0.20964159071445465,
-0.0244903601706028,
0.5033537745475769,
0.07874888181686401,
-0.06906146556138992,
0.8985200524330139,
-0.5919123291969299,
-0.2833949327468872,
-0.37329962849617004,
-0.11117930710315704,
0.09624779224395752,
0.4567068815231323,
0.38614708185195923,
-0.7271683216094971,
-0.46114879846572876,
0.03619520738720894,
0.019507037475705147,
-0.11815748363733292,
-0.020585598424077034,
-0.23741403222084045,
0.1356116384267807,
-0.08160857111215591,
-0.2649967074394226,
-0.1717338263988495,
0.8092727661132812,
-0.14515508711338043,
0.5963260531425476,
-0.1904730349779129,
0.18342193961143494,
-0.9573540091514587,
0.04817163944244385,
0.12190999835729599,
-0.11758279800415039,
-0.2270805984735489,
-0.13967549800872803,
-0.0622025765478611,
-0.30090439319610596,
-0.2358635663986206,
0.5960266590118408,
-0.2368658185005188,
0.00662210863083601,
-0.36267587542533875,
0.10639865696430206,
-0.04555001109838486,
0.6297751665115356,
0.47825297713279724,
0.8907069563865662,
0.16568611562252045,
-0.7122877836227417,
0.20766131579875946,
0.3599287271499634,
-0.13461211323738098,
0.44905155897140503,
-0.4518381357192993,
0.19399455189704895,
-0.10794879496097565,
0.43379056453704834,
-1.1217758655548096,
-0.24104894697666168,
0.5399171710014343,
-0.09519580751657486,
0.28987619280815125,
-0.08720177412033081,
-0.17766578495502472,
-0.40208613872528076,
-0.5601733326911926,
0.3599199056625366,
0.4794619381427765,
-0.5428315997123718,
0.3278602361679077,
0.3604540228843689,
-0.10625594109296799,
-0.8177732825279236,
-0.1784925013780594,
-0.39416253566741943,
-0.16498756408691406,
-0.22427718341350555,
0.6417246460914612,
0.016022343188524246,
-0.16665612161159515,
-0.1189064085483551,
-0.18087121844291687,
0.1956886649131775,
0.0024444370064884424,
0.010481503792107105,
0.4986475706100464,
0.20457257330417633,
-0.1371382623910904,
-0.02887178584933281,
-0.230057492852211,
-0.296687513589859,
-0.1605442762374878,
0.6922270059585571,
0.17820662260055542,
-0.16745886206626892,
-0.7651528120040894,
0.20006097853183746,
0.19984500110149384,
-0.10242345929145813,
0.30270057916641235,
0.3664499819278717,
0.15881957113742828,
-0.35227611660957336,
-0.29661571979522705,
-0.3414301574230194,
-0.49581655859947205,
0.41890642046928406,
-0.43707334995269775,
-0.8386244773864746,
0.12795330584049225,
-0.13575299084186554,
0.1444019079208374,
0.13311482965946198,
0.4980115592479706,
0.027713946998119354,
0.9673358201980591,
0.5056008100509644,
-0.26789286732673645,
0.8648842573165894,
0.01602385938167572,
-0.023036057129502296,
-0.8524963855743408,
-0.021516911685466766,
-0.5449853539466858,
-0.5318977236747742,
-0.6710860133171082,
-0.13864757120609283,
0.12462159991264343,
0.044727224856615067,
-0.1496250480413437,
0.25158455967903137,
-0.6564283967018127,
0.3900340497493744,
0.7595043182373047,
0.36644247174263,
0.2347690314054489,
0.20401440560817719,
-0.18739360570907593,
-0.2660181522369385,
-0.507070004940033,
-0.44444331526756287,
1.0177466869354248,
0.22454798221588135,
0.7818306684494019,
-0.06898961216211319,
0.8482735753059387,
0.09120141714811325,
0.06633380800485611,
-0.8126052021980286,
0.6568374633789062,
-0.1300853192806244,
-0.2020333856344223,
-0.37469154596328735,
-0.5628471374511719,
-0.8492847681045532,
0.394687682390213,
-0.47985967993736267,
-0.5428895950317383,
0.2587941884994507,
0.6449670791625977,
-0.627514123916626,
0.08697061985731125,
-0.6312968134880066,
0.6366773843765259,
-0.24951738119125366,
-0.5088338851928711,
-0.49922847747802734,
-0.4425615966320038,
0.32420283555984497,
0.1849920153617859,
0.11275561153888702,
-0.2022135853767395,
-0.03934707120060921,
0.5471532344818115,
-0.27289971709251404,
0.6364588141441345,
-0.24274857342243195,
-0.1721818745136261,
0.15255290269851685,
0.15129117667675018,
0.8116781711578369,
-0.05416940897703171,
-0.21335189044475555,
-0.3946508467197418,
-0.2109348028898239,
-0.25826573371887207,
-0.45988938212394714,
0.7585774064064026,
-0.908112645149231,
-0.5724742412567139,
-0.305568128824234,
-0.5647068619728088,
-0.42799991369247437,
0.14841914176940918,
-0.11344466358423233,
0.15674322843551636,
-0.14223778247833252,
-0.20903219282627106,
0.506820559501648,
-0.3913925886154175,
0.21649006009101868,
0.7733298540115356,
-0.1227358877658844,
-0.629189670085907,
0.975802481174469,
-0.3977418839931488,
0.4346310794353485,
0.5970913171768188,
0.6341956853866577,
-0.4225917160511017,
-0.6889054179191589,
-0.4115786850452423,
0.32818883657455444,
-0.2609858512878418,
0.025919951498508453,
-0.21666604280471802,
0.220262348651886,
-0.4171314835548401,
-0.0805644616484642,
-0.36116114258766174,
-0.11793004721403122,
-0.124137282371521,
0.13291804492473602,
0.16677317023277283,
0.28274112939834595,
-0.08143776655197144,
0.1869942545890808,
-0.468156635761261,
0.3394205868244171,
0.289479523897171,
0.4964722990989685,
-0.21082156896591187,
-0.48101213574409485,
0.22706200182437897,
0.08483003079891205,
-0.3582710027694702,
-0.6187825202941895,
0.21904315054416656,
-0.1508813053369522,
0.49561065435409546,
0.3158172369003296,
0.428103506565094,
0.5486703515052795,
-0.42188504338264465,
0.401429146528244,
0.17774498462677002,
-0.5676701664924622,
0.6286212205886841,
-0.43340829014778137,
-0.0008032743353396654,
0.8735865950584412,
0.45291197299957275,
-0.43957778811454773,
0.11577010154724121,
-0.3426487147808075,
-0.7634974122047424,
0.9810372591018677,
-0.24349345266819,
0.07578049600124359,
0.1160145178437233,
0.3760170042514801,
0.18362611532211304,
0.11788530647754669,
-0.6217901110649109,
-0.027078252285718918,
0.31969162821769714,
-0.2237161546945572,
-0.019561508670449257,
-0.31622186303138733,
-0.4366813898086548,
-0.0724039375782013,
0.8363937139511108,
-0.24013328552246094,
-0.14436087012290955,
0.15652526915073395,
0.09516140073537827,
-0.3036113381385803,
0.454807847738266,
0.8903144001960754,
0.6013585925102234,
-0.39592549204826355,
-0.2473229467868805,
-0.1652236133813858,
-0.3571047782897949,
0.3013591766357422,
0.08650605380535126,
-0.5590762495994568,
-0.26862633228302,
-0.14990085363388062,
0.9787393808364868,
0.21453987061977386,
-0.8581099510192871,
0.39969733357429504,
0.05789106339216232,
-0.3651258051395416,
-0.1581314653158188,
0.09564358741044998,
-0.23980343341827393,
0.09603133797645569,
0.060092125087976456,
-0.07844880223274231,
0.12644697725772858,
-0.31097736954689026,
0.01709401234984398,
0.5427135825157166,
-0.38731029629707336,
-0.21882666647434235,
0.4221682846546173,
0.5445641875267029,
-0.40966907143592834,
0.4883396327495575,
-0.2374311238527298,
-0.4402198791503906,
0.2469642609357834,
0.566402018070221,
0.7140450477600098,
0.03406364098191261,
0.40741676092147827,
0.47374242544174194,
-0.046089716255664825,
-0.21696268022060394,
0.1400267630815506,
-0.38269948959350586,
-0.9572275280952454,
-0.5546973347663879,
-0.6726075410842896,
-0.7321982383728027,
0.3242083191871643,
-0.6698594093322754,
0.38163188099861145,
-0.574198305606842,
-0.009816037490963936,
-0.1162782683968544,
0.2531448304653168,
-0.4248593747615814,
0.010768389329314232,
0.093898244202137,
0.44647684693336487,
-0.9419739246368408,
0.7704757452011108,
0.7002531886100769,
-0.3520614206790924,
-0.7842523455619812,
0.1886577308177948,
0.13640812039375305,
-0.9503970742225647,
0.6318129301071167,
-0.31181585788726807,
-0.24719880521297455,
0.08186689764261246,
-0.21879824995994568,
-0.6467089056968689,
0.7266528606414795,
0.3468158543109894,
-0.9866154193878174,
0.1790132224559784,
-0.13980238139629364,
0.3438221216201782,
-0.1681486964225769,
0.07457128167152405,
0.6077062487602234,
0.4348107874393463,
0.1937018185853958,
-0.9372543692588806,
0.18879270553588867,
0.2443813979625702,
0.20086175203323364,
0.3052746057510376,
-0.7958883047103882,
0.41361042857170105,
-0.23542015254497528,
-0.049435146152973175,
-0.06133498623967171,
0.5097336769104004,
0.7790563702583313,
-0.061779871582984924,
0.8403263688087463,
0.5914239287376404,
0.4400511384010315,
0.10555620491504669,
1.0317182540893555,
-0.04671437293291092,
0.23364777863025665,
1.1337872743606567,
-0.5994452238082886,
1.0064353942871094,
0.8476489186286926,
-0.5442945957183838,
0.3291192948818207,
0.7736496925354004,
0.21693900227546692,
0.8089141249656677,
0.5115357637405396,
-0.283094197511673,
-0.22896459698677063,
-0.15643100440502167,
-0.10196500271558762,
0.3061399459838867,
-0.01700657606124878,
-0.20332235097885132,
-0.1401592642068863,
-0.16555896401405334,
-0.11050800234079361,
0.6219502091407776,
-0.18741922080516815,
0.9123241901397705,
-0.27305078506469727,
-1.1474263668060303,
0.5466938614845276,
-0.010445009917020798,
1.0678017139434814,
-0.5914964079856873,
-0.01819160394370556,
-0.15398657321929932,
0.4789820611476898,
-0.18883226811885834,
-0.7353059649467468,
0.09471288323402405,
-0.26073214411735535,
-0.24652643501758575,
-0.4120268225669861,
0.4862135052680969,
-0.5758500695228577,
-0.06125202029943466,
0.2523020803928375,
-0.02934768982231617,
-0.20350393652915955,
0.18442684412002563,
-0.7400227189064026,
0.19874480366706848,
0.1763676106929779,
-0.29584187269210815,
0.6239561438560486,
0.010687765665352345,
-0.05945543199777603,
0.4672645628452301,
0.6651090383529663,
0.4122053384780884,
-0.5250641107559204,
0.19944697618484497,
0.7508558630943298,
-0.4301023483276367,
-0.6320345997810364,
-0.8220245838165283,
0.2658812403678894,
-0.12754352390766144,
-0.4263055622577667,
0.36802423000335693,
0.37933748960494995,
1.0329493284225464,
-0.07405182719230652,
0.8008018136024475,
0.011881097219884396,
0.8313645720481873,
-0.4599398672580719,
0.1776943951845169,
-0.5603882074356079,
0.16975603997707367,
-0.3541925549507141,
-0.9501487016677856,
0.033751051872968674,
0.5435221195220947,
-0.5009674429893494,
-0.17329679429531097,
0.2727358341217041,
0.8981224894523621,
0.023098601028323174,
-0.25083276629447937,
0.047434840351343155,
-0.4391780495643616,
0.12719540297985077,
0.6363619565963745,
0.8710516095161438,
0.001935129868797958,
0.5626315474510193,
-0.41281741857528687,
-0.35291022062301636,
-0.33260783553123474,
-0.8278412222862244,
-0.555730938911438,
-0.5001585483551025,
-0.26352813839912415,
-0.4388848841190338,
0.05735104903578758,
1.3495343923568726,
0.732009768486023,
-0.8600640892982483,
-0.29585081338882446,
-0.14681921899318695,
0.20280559360980988,
-0.3894232213497162,
-0.24503205716609955,
0.27230361104011536,
-0.28847652673721313,
-1.0502395629882812,
0.3671343922615051,
0.20418581366539001,
0.0968509316444397,
-0.3830045163631439,
-0.44542255997657776,
-0.13434402644634247,
-0.331015020608902,
0.3425430357456207,
0.5049951672554016,
-0.8826923966407776,
-0.3133990168571472,
-0.008219001814723015,
-0.1898641586303711,
-0.11401410400867462,
0.9885154962539673,
-0.6171041131019592,
0.44355449080467224,
0.7278971076011658,
0.8206179738044739,
0.2705349326133728,
0.22099164128303528,
0.9488765001296997,
-0.672207772731781,
0.3423411548137665,
0.4437861740589142,
0.07050363719463348,
0.178815558552742,
-0.4132787585258484,
0.30340272188186646,
0.197740837931633,
-0.5398319959640503,
-0.8815627098083496,
0.5653663277626038,
-1.0019593238830566,
-0.2753019332885742,
1.3363335132598877,
0.12119696289300919,
-0.14680343866348267,
0.1812102347612381,
-0.551806628704071,
-0.016104336827993393,
-0.6675329208374023,
0.8367921113967896,
0.5439749956130981,
-0.28109991550445557,
-0.1786440759897232,
-0.17958585917949677,
0.8554365038871765,
0.7164055705070496,
-0.45942336320877075,
0.1263807862997055,
0.5554305911064148,
0.3040839433670044,
-0.0641610249876976,
0.8985809683799744,
-0.01875004917383194,
0.1368706226348877,
-0.2887221574783325,
0.20020198822021484,
-0.19315195083618164,
-0.04341653361916542,
-0.4614694118499756,
-0.11946213990449905,
0.3367668390274048,
-0.5172311663627625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10024v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10024v2 | Self-Augmented In-Context Learning for Unsupervised Word Translation | 2024-02-15T15:43:05 | 2024-06-05T13:38:42 | Yaoyiran Li, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Recent work has shown that, while large language models (LLMs) demonstrate
strong word translation or bilingual lexicon induction (BLI) capabilities in
few-shot setups, they still cannot match the performance of 'traditional'
mapping-based approaches in the unsupervised scenario where no seed translation
pairs are available, especially for lower-resource languages. To address this
challenge with LLMs, we propose self-augmented in-context learning (SAIL) for
unsupervised BLI: starting from a zero-shot prompt, SAIL iteratively induces a
set of high-confidence word translation pairs for in-context learning (ICL)
from an LLM, which it then reapplies to the same LLM in the ICL fashion. Our
method shows substantial gains over zero-shot prompting of LLMs on two
established BLI benchmarks spanning a wide range of language pairs, also
outperforming mapping-based baselines across the board. In addition to
achieving state-of-the-art unsupervised BLI performance, we also conduct
comprehensive analyses on SAIL and discuss its limitations. | [
-0.1660154014825821,
-0.38826480507850647,
0.5797173976898193,
0.4236733913421631,
-0.5721974968910217,
0.3242957592010498,
-0.4732952117919922,
-0.38070109486579895,
0.07931815832853317,
0.4784313142299652,
-0.5762515664100647,
-0.589368462562561,
-0.5571718215942383,
0.20451131463050842,
-0.40795737504959106,
0.9127711653709412,
-0.07509861886501312,
-0.10372777283191681,
-0.3090679347515106,
-0.4176252484321594,
-0.6915208101272583,
-0.3328064978122711,
-0.3432627022266388,
-0.41373148560523987,
0.26994574069976807,
0.7840917110443115,
0.13232934474945068,
0.2480429857969284,
0.18981721997261047,
0.2170822024345398,
-0.06759708374738693,
0.44793203473091125,
-0.38961261510849,
0.222894549369812,
-0.34894227981567383,
-0.07202185690402985,
-0.3043718934059143,
-0.03989308699965477,
0.757202684879303,
0.7985599040985107,
-0.09356314688920975,
0.2722805440425873,
0.5406684279441833,
0.5379725098609924,
-0.9062693119049072,
0.2517167627811432,
-0.7218849658966064,
-0.13383501768112183,
-0.35437989234924316,
-0.37736523151397705,
-0.45212072134017944,
0.3216978907585144,
0.01381498109549284,
-0.7067045569419861,
-0.02663135901093483,
0.324807345867157,
0.1865086704492569,
0.2735566794872284,
-0.705660879611969,
-0.3202521800994873,
-0.6251189112663269,
0.8299607038497925,
-0.6845107674598694,
0.391214519739151,
0.22522073984146118,
0.07568369060754776,
-0.41613054275512695,
-0.5927120447158813,
-0.6180031299591064,
0.01790192909538746,
-0.04826591908931732,
0.36174753308296204,
0.03205439820885658,
-0.10628907382488251,
0.03822440281510353,
0.17797809839248657,
-0.5016427040100098,
0.3110610544681549,
-0.1450282484292984,
0.11026519536972046,
0.8087109327316284,
0.17637145519256592,
0.2746712863445282,
-0.14583122730255127,
-0.6192087531089783,
-0.022269094362854958,
-0.9960970282554626,
0.21000391244888306,
-0.3112684488296509,
0.65369713306427,
-0.45672959089279175,
0.6339566111564636,
-0.21385855972766876,
0.8074900507926941,
0.2554742097854614,
-0.06577044725418091,
0.2458539456129074,
-0.24695976078510284,
-0.06234787404537201,
0.43323463201522827,
0.7656210064888,
0.3402564227581024,
0.015959251672029495,
-0.2393023669719696,
-0.3325720727443695,
-0.37445756793022156,
-0.0335719920694828,
-0.6129036545753479,
0.2439185231924057,
0.10501941293478012,
0.021972760558128357,
-0.04571642726659775,
-0.08820338547229767,
-0.506625771522522,
-0.27667927742004395,
-0.05982046201825142,
0.7144331336021423,
-0.2663387060165405,
-0.08862560987472534,
0.026631195098161697,
0.10616883635520935,
0.4231014847755432,
0.13014672696590424,
-0.9725534319877625,
-0.042984992265701294,
0.4226042628288269,
0.8958867788314819,
-0.5499305725097656,
-0.6607518196105957,
-0.6578088402748108,
0.46348750591278076,
-0.7316081523895264,
0.7119724154472351,
-0.29971781373023987,
-0.662326991558075,
0.21516209840774536,
-0.049220990389585495,
-0.003933597356081009,
-0.24229416251182556,
0.2256452739238739,
-0.47617441415786743,
0.23556910455226898,
-0.3077464997768402,
-0.786751389503479,
-0.1554284393787384,
0.12987974286079407,
-0.045866940170526505,
1.2019366025924683,
0.13287386298179626,
-0.5869430899620056,
0.5497874617576599,
-0.7391190528869629,
-0.7536072134971619,
0.41028350591659546,
-0.10701017081737518,
-0.0019524676026776433,
0.3983704149723053,
0.4316923916339874,
0.5610731840133667,
-0.22400909662246704,
0.1678003966808319,
-0.21070963144302368,
-0.5987433791160583,
-0.057416971772909164,
-0.23645544052124023,
0.7292871475219727,
-0.060776934027671814,
-0.5675438046455383,
-0.08911312371492386,
-0.32950377464294434,
-0.06913673877716064,
0.01997133158147335,
-0.27203038334846497,
-0.6169164180755615,
-0.11883832514286041,
-0.021506447345018387,
0.1541280448436737,
0.3446153998374939,
-0.8555963039398193,
0.5092481970787048,
-0.946819543838501,
0.02263207733631134,
0.5171555876731873,
0.04218200966715813,
0.7344964742660522,
0.26015806198120117,
0.24295374751091003,
0.11965225636959076,
-0.21655482053756714,
-0.505646288394928,
-0.41518938541412354,
-0.58952397108078,
-0.2661295235157013,
0.14444105327129364,
0.40498194098472595,
-1.022343635559082,
0.45496588945388794,
-0.18457457423210144,
-0.30262064933776855,
-0.4109237790107727,
0.4378001391887665,
0.6418417692184448,
0.7178859114646912,
0.8098284602165222,
-0.3170378804206848,
-0.23775984346866608,
-0.30020663142204285,
-0.33225345611572266,
-0.005161852575838566,
0.08973655849695206,
0.34206193685531616,
0.44015663862228394,
-0.32097625732421875,
0.915148913860321,
-0.30729940533638,
-0.6221166849136353,
-0.5881165266036987,
0.45489081740379333,
0.1372895985841751,
0.38175368309020996,
0.41632896661758423,
-0.44996318221092224,
-0.6888969540596008,
0.22493402659893036,
-0.906448245048523,
-0.23374369740486145,
0.004214339889585972,
0.16042250394821167,
0.39725056290626526,
0.6385207176208496,
-0.18309512734413147,
0.6571230888366699,
0.8037902116775513,
-0.45846861600875854,
0.32023754715919495,
-0.7135009169578552,
0.14999037981033325,
-1.3181672096252441,
0.004637802019715309,
-0.14408467710018158,
-0.15785296261310577,
-0.45489734411239624,
0.020788632333278656,
0.4156886339187622,
-0.06321825832128525,
-0.632546603679657,
1.1037521362304688,
-0.6257052421569824,
-0.37576478719711304,
-0.7622312307357788,
0.25365522503852844,
-0.17227204144001007,
0.3724006414413452,
0.186153843998909,
0.9865812659263611,
0.6841973066329956,
-0.7685875296592712,
0.24866828322410583,
0.47553566098213196,
-0.42857247591018677,
0.5169599652290344,
-0.41347062587738037,
-0.012775315903127193,
-0.23082637786865234,
0.3558185398578644,
-1.0370508432388306,
-0.21476775407791138,
0.04187455400824547,
-0.3620171546936035,
0.5442060232162476,
-0.0948377475142479,
-0.12656369805335999,
-0.15438959002494812,
-0.07705981284379959,
0.825164794921875,
0.29528751969337463,
-1.211793303489685,
0.3720915615558624,
0.22549614310264587,
0.13360098004341125,
-0.7082845568656921,
-0.799401581287384,
0.2012416124343872,
-0.12866586446762085,
-0.11008063703775406,
0.5946930646896362,
-0.09575755149126053,
0.07276452332735062,
-0.10011234134435654,
-0.069455586373806,
0.025386234745383263,
0.06823449581861496,
0.26140403747558594,
0.15294606983661652,
-0.041054341942071915,
0.12604036927223206,
0.36126387119293213,
-0.24539749324321747,
-0.2671665847301483,
-0.5638589262962341,
0.14374898374080658,
-0.06626610457897186,
-0.445708692073822,
-0.3291849195957184,
0.31199079751968384,
0.6194669008255005,
-0.5475396513938904,
0.5639193058013916,
0.26175811886787415,
-0.2263219803571701,
-0.5465624928474426,
-0.3515722155570984,
-0.17022749781608582,
-0.506511926651001,
0.06590817868709564,
-0.32769641280174255,
-1.0703774690628052,
0.2507782280445099,
-0.2888807952404022,
-0.06689818203449249,
0.30970266461372375,
0.5366122722625732,
-0.519829273223877,
0.7384954690933228,
0.7992917895317078,
-0.37809550762176514,
0.22489508986473083,
-0.3505609631538391,
0.2037138193845749,
-1.0810198783874512,
-0.1620938777923584,
-0.036955684423446655,
-0.2346738576889038,
-0.5098515152931213,
-0.5486225485801697,
0.6977514624595642,
0.08786365389823914,
-0.10382723808288574,
0.3943231701850891,
-0.22950182855129242,
0.5466533303260803,
0.5355536341667175,
-0.08963534235954285,
0.33635038137435913,
-0.038566190749406815,
-0.5866404175758362,
-0.012886581011116505,
-0.9884627461433411,
0.10473941266536713,
1.2608919143676758,
-0.21914635598659515,
0.6717328429222107,
-0.04667624458670616,
0.9651231169700623,
0.26015472412109375,
0.37143808603286743,
-0.6905055642127991,
0.40506428480148315,
-0.10088670998811722,
-0.5888146758079529,
-0.489927738904953,
-0.20891378819942474,
-0.9351570010185242,
0.15589937567710876,
-0.3976815938949585,
-0.593873143196106,
0.18306037783622742,
0.2585473358631134,
-0.33205080032348633,
0.1847662776708603,
-0.1892562210559845,
0.8907773494720459,
-0.5694640874862671,
-0.49682876467704773,
-0.21563465893268585,
-0.45454078912734985,
0.31555113196372986,
-0.2631853520870209,
0.22381502389907837,
0.10319840908050537,
-0.15955832600593567,
0.20741356909275055,
-0.13428938388824463,
0.8790931701660156,
-0.1712294965982437,
-0.14151325821876526,
0.3427042067050934,
0.28045815229415894,
0.33930060267448425,
0.013782979920506477,
0.22977373003959656,
0.2484356015920639,
-0.19525277614593506,
-0.42383813858032227,
-0.6466695070266724,
0.8156656622886658,
-0.4144148826599121,
-0.5040453672409058,
-0.5777649283409119,
-0.6258522272109985,
-0.32857030630111694,
0.07139670103788376,
0.5615373849868774,
0.5806314945220947,
-0.17650502920150757,
0.21746069192886353,
0.3748098611831665,
-0.1812804937362671,
0.9204196929931641,
0.8589592576026917,
-0.25777432322502136,
-0.3386648893356323,
0.8687334656715393,
0.0858292356133461,
-0.0734250396490097,
0.3617788851261139,
0.2437838762998581,
-0.6629313826560974,
-0.5680885910987854,
-0.7826698422431946,
0.26344430446624756,
-0.3344492018222809,
-0.31444650888442993,
-0.16744105517864227,
-0.05117885023355484,
-0.27176105976104736,
-0.5022218227386475,
-0.7233002781867981,
-0.16551947593688965,
-0.10079815238714218,
0.06274919956922531,
0.051366835832595825,
0.7978336811065674,
-0.12643161416053772,
0.46593326330184937,
-0.633685290813446,
0.055394355207681656,
0.3210066556930542,
0.2160463035106659,
-0.21269746124744415,
-0.9780175089836121,
-0.4593961536884308,
-0.03406749665737152,
-0.12512370944023132,
-0.7890124320983887,
0.4807685911655426,
0.36107271909713745,
0.4925951659679413,
0.5244857668876648,
0.1196192130446434,
0.8580919504165649,
-0.6509329676628113,
0.788825511932373,
0.22062371671199799,
-1.0871671438217163,
0.6549312472343445,
-0.35631105303764343,
0.548992395401001,
0.536073625087738,
0.5387266874313354,
-0.6339914202690125,
-0.364648699760437,
-0.3584497570991516,
-0.7250069975852966,
0.5117363929748535,
-0.12166556715965271,
0.1654982715845108,
-0.10596595704555511,
0.5919699668884277,
-0.18458396196365356,
0.14015860855579376,
-0.7252160310745239,
-0.13833710551261902,
-0.01687576249241829,
-0.1055770069360733,
-0.6298967599868774,
-0.33475765585899353,
0.2569960951805115,
-0.5181202292442322,
0.7084136605262756,
-0.5993451476097107,
-0.15204952657222748,
0.37354686856269836,
-0.45329397916793823,
-0.13926808536052704,
0.06449972093105316,
0.473091721534729,
0.4807124435901642,
0.08178222924470901,
0.11656001210212708,
0.7009351253509521,
0.05380793288350105,
0.2526125907897949,
-0.23021945357322693,
-0.24469022452831268,
-0.23208878934383392,
0.6515349745750427,
0.5951098799705505,
0.8634006381034851,
-0.5282094478607178,
0.8873540759086609,
0.25952067971229553,
0.015108413994312286,
-0.02863355167210102,
-0.2298537939786911,
0.01637030392885208,
0.3502063751220703,
0.36708998680114746,
-0.41377073526382446,
-0.05805250629782677,
-0.4500461518764496,
0.22309119999408722,
0.7838111519813538,
-0.5543702840805054,
-0.3335150480270386,
0.684878945350647,
0.3327798843383789,
-0.1639588177204132,
0.4588596820831299,
-0.4666747450828552,
-0.5387431979179382,
-0.013767842203378677,
1.1058237552642822,
0.9755735397338867,
-0.6378013491630554,
0.1207183375954628,
0.6053250432014465,
0.3406994640827179,
-0.1668051779270172,
0.18411266803741455,
-0.5987215638160706,
-0.8021349310874939,
-0.7007023096084595,
-0.6628773808479309,
-0.4227054715156555,
-0.03769940510392189,
-0.3730439841747284,
0.20100615918636322,
-0.12411180138587952,
0.3381032347679138,
-0.6502119898796082,
-0.09957358241081238,
-0.3980167508125305,
0.17039243876934052,
0.3794727623462677,
0.8485926985740662,
-1.0081021785736084,
1.0698357820510864,
0.7663787603378296,
-0.27090874314308167,
-0.6460403800010681,
0.21509850025177002,
0.11642218381166458,
-0.6096170544624329,
0.6180450916290283,
0.11960113048553467,
-0.4587150812149048,
0.3054081201553345,
-0.38591721653938293,
-0.9598314762115479,
1.347700834274292,
0.2129293829202652,
-0.40465930104255676,
0.18266168236732483,
0.2520582675933838,
0.4235864579677582,
-0.6864516139030457,
-0.007446595001965761,
0.28534096479415894,
0.2760428786277771,
0.226398304104805,
-0.8355112671852112,
-0.21572245657444,
0.27970489859580994,
0.07569525390863419,
-0.06266031414270401,
-0.5173963904380798,
0.33292198181152344,
-0.24294611811637878,
-0.22501446306705475,
-0.07206478714942932,
1.0316829681396484,
0.1462656557559967,
0.5985016226768494,
0.3448854386806488,
0.5460614562034607,
0.5045821666717529,
0.23933124542236328,
0.8655179142951965,
-0.5593827366828918,
0.34064286947250366,
1.341883897781372,
-0.42331594228744507,
1.1339503526687622,
0.5293158888816833,
0.3082897365093231,
0.545720636844635,
0.34313443303108215,
0.38556230068206787,
0.5437827706336975,
-0.2544403374195099,
-0.5360768437385559,
-0.4365466833114624,
-0.11713649332523346,
-0.18306732177734375,
0.9768645763397217,
0.34131941199302673,
-0.07544952630996704,
-0.533646285533905,
0.4374239444732666,
-0.22807416319847107,
0.3229023218154907,
-0.47152966260910034,
0.7659953236579895,
0.2539413273334503,
-0.7639032006263733,
0.5548627376556396,
0.11420613527297974,
0.766462504863739,
-0.5692529082298279,
0.04388679936528206,
-0.5853491425514221,
0.03513535484671593,
-0.05435922369360924,
-0.7430856227874756,
0.1691145896911621,
0.18138456344604492,
0.21970324218273163,
-0.35733410716056824,
0.7748523950576782,
-0.7924600839614868,
-0.5119072198867798,
0.650749921798706,
0.7672767639160156,
0.02232147753238678,
-0.09048676490783691,
-0.42325645685195923,
-0.2603287398815155,
-0.2749579846858978,
-0.24462731182575226,
0.3900795876979828,
0.4412982165813446,
-0.05910356342792511,
0.7279592156410217,
0.48138126730918884,
-0.04063435271382332,
-0.006828914862126112,
-0.3038647174835205,
0.6620845198631287,
-0.6928961873054504,
-0.5216005444526672,
-0.8214151859283447,
0.39303573966026306,
0.18416164815425873,
-0.44580021500587463,
1.0816514492034912,
0.6913604736328125,
1.0169854164123535,
-0.08058017492294312,
0.5656213164329529,
0.23453634977340698,
0.2927130460739136,
-0.4815400540828705,
0.7446941137313843,
-1.0113457441329956,
0.07474187761545181,
-0.18399807810783386,
-0.8586598634719849,
-0.4147818386554718,
0.4200117588043213,
-0.21213838458061218,
-0.2968282997608185,
0.7430957555770874,
0.8566058278083801,
-0.2992232143878937,
-0.13512589037418365,
0.6556466221809387,
-0.02066587097942829,
-0.03961522504687309,
0.4673430621623993,
0.7697827816009521,
-0.24416407942771912,
0.24439476430416107,
-0.24669703841209412,
-0.42125174403190613,
-0.224491149187088,
-1.1343806982040405,
-0.9537916779518127,
-0.874898374080658,
-0.19066596031188965,
-0.12620416283607483,
0.039618365466594696,
1.123931884765625,
0.7316344976425171,
-0.6690685749053955,
-0.6344901919364929,
-0.14028270542621613,
0.08809096366167068,
-0.3350299596786499,
-0.06644584983587265,
0.23206768929958344,
-0.7646655440330505,
-0.6586266160011292,
1.2868043184280396,
0.6414039731025696,
-0.10953745990991592,
-0.26525557041168213,
-0.25423938035964966,
-0.265095978975296,
0.06872206181287766,
0.8070437908172607,
0.6415963172912598,
-0.5458399057388306,
-0.3286816477775574,
-0.27634692192077637,
-0.01915821246802807,
-0.048817623406648636,
0.6905250549316406,
-0.9713280200958252,
0.7201822400093079,
0.23127129673957825,
0.9621460437774658,
0.8080697655677795,
-0.021193234249949455,
0.4865338206291199,
-1.0806639194488525,
0.28924423456192017,
-0.02950718253850937,
0.27445513010025024,
0.26418763399124146,
-0.2251882404088974,
0.39220115542411804,
0.2944881021976471,
-0.5025244355201721,
-0.6366875767707825,
0.19539089500904083,
-0.7896825075149536,
-0.2575942277908325,
1.1495311260223389,
-0.08053804934024811,
-0.37371668219566345,
0.12310741096735,
-0.026835894212126732,
0.15932486951351166,
0.05144704505801201,
0.7261534333229065,
0.4345017373561859,
-0.09459826350212097,
0.14335188269615173,
-0.14962725341320038,
0.6493353247642517,
0.6113879680633545,
-0.5842868089675903,
0.1431330442428589,
0.35572683811187744,
0.2847899794578552,
-0.09752952307462692,
0.6171427369117737,
0.06671087443828583,
0.30905142426490784,
-0.4185676872730255,
0.2342858612537384,
-0.1641552895307541,
-0.7260832190513611,
-0.6575249433517456,
-0.06961902230978012,
0.1210453063249588,
-0.23321275413036346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10013v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10013v2 | Bridging the Empirical-Theoretical Gap in Neural Network Formal Language Learning Using Minimum Description Length | 2024-02-15T15:25:30 | 2024-06-06T16:16:12 | Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Roni Katzir | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | Neural networks offer good approximation to many tasks but consistently fail
to reach perfect generalization, even when theoretical work shows that such
perfect solutions can be expressed by certain architectures. Using the task of
formal language learning, we focus on one simple formal language and show that
the theoretically correct solution is in fact not an optimum of commonly used
objectives -- even with regularization techniques that according to common
wisdom should lead to simple weights and good generalization (L1, L2) or other
meta-heuristics (early-stopping, dropout). On the other hand, replacing
standard targets with the Minimum Description Length objective (MDL) results in
the correct solution being an optimum. | [
-0.31049153208732605,
-0.7561128735542297,
0.6674163341522217,
0.1922610104084015,
-0.20667998492717743,
-0.06643092632293701,
-0.5737372636795044,
-0.37742170691490173,
0.09940623492002487,
-0.11265470087528229,
-0.47453999519348145,
-0.28202497959136963,
-0.4661691188812256,
0.16411028802394867,
-0.39179542660713196,
0.8623305559158325,
-0.08576860278844833,
-0.14252915978431702,
-0.1254047453403473,
0.04668572545051575,
-0.09113731980323792,
-0.06288495659828186,
-1.1451630592346191,
-0.6894386410713196,
0.9313937425613403,
0.3807733654975891,
0.5345897078514099,
1.0195626020431519,
0.5209393501281738,
0.33173713088035583,
-0.17569191753864288,
0.3156783878803253,
-0.14639036357402802,
-0.18214385211467743,
0.1606823056936264,
-0.6273691654205322,
-0.158630833029747,
-0.012709279544651508,
0.8263117671012878,
1.4117252826690674,
-0.3349270224571228,
0.04768264293670654,
0.26228782534599304,
0.8911339640617371,
-0.536345362663269,
0.24885646998882294,
-0.4618144631385803,
0.5395578145980835,
-0.281377911567688,
-0.13741545379161835,
-0.18129219114780426,
-0.21386635303497314,
0.23912622034549713,
-0.7184493541717529,
0.17590318620204926,
0.019972456619143486,
1.1130331754684448,
0.11526522785425186,
-0.2934209704399109,
-0.12985147535800934,
-1.017654299736023,
0.960376501083374,
-0.8590264320373535,
0.12435400485992432,
0.6455205082893372,
0.5116198062896729,
0.10412853211164474,
-0.7063389420509338,
-0.2101137638092041,
-0.3712698221206665,
-0.1603550910949707,
-0.17008540034294128,
-0.1048651784658432,
0.5168651342391968,
0.41612276434898376,
0.23263654112815857,
-0.5024685859680176,
0.22147713601589203,
-0.8564161062240601,
-0.18524214625358582,
0.727968156337738,
0.2537486255168915,
0.05149007961153984,
0.21271538734436035,
-0.26144087314605713,
0.4223352372646332,
-0.6274362206459045,
0.07658424228429794,
0.3815719485282898,
0.4331820011138916,
-0.12342296540737152,
0.11580782383680344,
-0.3870130777359009,
0.8776407837867737,
-0.1493648737668991,
0.1310889720916748,
-0.002530642319470644,
-0.41535499691963196,
-0.3547275960445404,
0.02825617417693138,
0.845264196395874,
0.11430350691080093,
0.46063151955604553,
-0.3873542547225952,
-0.36735183000564575,
0.14794696867465973,
-0.01649467647075653,
-0.4878850281238556,
-0.0737922340631485,
0.03554333373904228,
-0.4720625877380371,
-0.33656877279281616,
-0.12166061997413635,
-0.49483931064605713,
0.23874841630458832,
-0.6299934983253479,
0.10316173732280731,
-0.22764891386032104,
0.061161383986473083,
0.26446962356567383,
0.024244200438261032,
0.20731320977210999,
0.0386517196893692,
-0.9593692421913147,
0.8044269680976868,
0.5668643712997437,
0.8868305087089539,
0.2647879123687744,
-0.24224220216274261,
-0.18500620126724243,
-0.07763754576444626,
-0.7953873872756958,
0.2501418888568878,
-0.2724382281303406,
0.05493444204330444,
0.0025991417933255434,
-0.4205233156681061,
-0.19843123853206635,
-0.18826048076152802,
0.5931066870689392,
-0.3710181713104248,
0.3547377586364746,
-0.3291764259338379,
-0.5140856504440308,
-0.1765938252210617,
0.21763750910758972,
-0.39661887288093567,
0.7165120840072632,
-0.1788913607597351,
-0.5533796548843384,
0.22794178128242493,
-0.8418392539024353,
-0.5770089030265808,
-0.04811220243573189,
-0.24317578971385956,
-0.12131012231111526,
0.3109164535999298,
-0.2965411841869354,
0.4180060029029846,
-0.3252590000629425,
0.17113296687602997,
-0.03883637860417366,
-0.49544668197631836,
0.08758272230625153,
-0.38396134972572327,
0.5458535552024841,
0.6041408181190491,
-0.41173872351646423,
-0.06955312192440033,
-0.8535017967224121,
0.14536185562610626,
0.31182536482810974,
-0.4739243984222412,
-0.5123014450073242,
0.16986259818077087,
-0.11868669837713242,
0.23799759149551392,
0.3577646315097809,
-0.4676166772842407,
0.07008545845746994,
-0.712265133857727,
0.63077712059021,
0.8771368265151978,
-0.35642480850219727,
0.7092378735542297,
-0.3617185354232788,
0.3731345534324646,
-0.25951671600341797,
0.032648105174303055,
0.12086920440196991,
-0.2642829120159149,
-0.8570177555084229,
0.014906462281942368,
0.8567485809326172,
0.4763984978199005,
-0.4251624643802643,
0.26119503378868103,
-0.22611188888549805,
-0.006585719995200634,
-0.2828192412853241,
0.3034699559211731,
0.7283528447151184,
0.5319183468818665,
0.1696590930223465,
-0.22260357439517975,
-0.6754851341247559,
-1.3281335830688477,
-0.29010382294654846,
-0.05488056689500809,
0.03617358207702637,
0.2176549732685089,
0.32673606276512146,
-0.10202436149120331,
0.6986421942710876,
-0.25854676961898804,
-0.2205798476934433,
-0.17587369680404663,
0.15380163490772247,
0.3366437256336212,
0.3483128845691681,
0.29842233657836914,
-0.6788643598556519,
-0.5335082411766052,
0.234952911734581,
-1.0210672616958618,
0.042082663625478745,
-0.21376997232437134,
0.2566232979297638,
0.03025701828300953,
0.3736742436885834,
-0.461870938539505,
0.3050757348537445,
0.27222776412963867,
0.11484545469284058,
0.4572761356830597,
-0.2850531339645386,
-0.21486671268939972,
-0.8213934302330017,
0.07375123351812363,
0.26606979966163635,
-0.2395094633102417,
-0.9844021797180176,
0.15408971905708313,
-0.17427724599838257,
0.015219048596918583,
-0.3219844102859497,
0.528651237487793,
-0.6202021241188049,
-0.019402731209993362,
-0.27116331458091736,
0.2691158652305603,
-0.06639403104782104,
0.5800854563713074,
-0.05827703699469566,
0.37471747398376465,
0.6951526403427124,
-1.0125031471252441,
0.2257765233516693,
-0.07222582399845123,
-0.11206836253404617,
0.17242476344108582,
-0.8489299416542053,
0.1388774961233139,
-0.2777545154094696,
-0.12503640353679657,
-0.6060847640037537,
-0.3113585412502289,
0.48668965697288513,
-0.39779335260391235,
0.5420520901679993,
-0.1682588905096054,
-0.23329074680805206,
-0.24891537427902222,
-0.06769175827503204,
0.6376007199287415,
0.5804316997528076,
-0.16416455805301666,
0.35451313853263855,
-0.14357680082321167,
0.25654515624046326,
-0.7506215572357178,
-1.1299432516098022,
0.21594876050949097,
-0.16212870180606842,
-0.701436460018158,
0.2620295286178589,
0.14829561114311218,
-0.45908820629119873,
0.030908575281500816,
-0.24828355014324188,
-0.32631683349609375,
0.24035580456256866,
-0.19465409219264984,
-0.13955101370811462,
-0.4771689772605896,
0.2066197544336319,
-0.0999956876039505,
-0.2284119576215744,
0.26712721586227417,
-0.35768091678619385,
0.4036678969860077,
-0.4378776252269745,
-0.32511499524116516,
-0.46176204085350037,
0.19444839656352997,
0.14643216133117676,
-0.12899430096149445,
0.5067629814147949,
0.21479158103466034,
-0.689615786075592,
-0.30120283365249634,
-0.14611218869686127,
-0.3530305325984955,
-0.4649302363395691,
0.3299823999404907,
-0.5207980275154114,
-0.592268168926239,
0.4740445613861084,
0.0964665338397026,
0.1531027853488922,
0.4195498824119568,
0.03490227833390236,
-0.24600078165531158,
1.0358550548553467,
0.4097118079662323,
0.06982995569705963,
0.29702407121658325,
-0.49989742040634155,
0.2546716034412384,
-0.7214298248291016,
-0.046951647847890854,
-0.5546719431877136,
-0.6611903309822083,
-0.17329558730125427,
0.05262206494808197,
-0.0124765420332551,
0.3725411891937256,
-0.052216630429029465,
0.2591705918312073,
-0.40282920002937317,
0.6408832669258118,
0.577388346195221,
0.069757841527462,
0.024665452539920807,
0.1861046850681305,
-0.3366432189941406,
-0.19415844976902008,
-1.0265883207321167,
-0.44784560799598694,
0.8512076735496521,
0.4287150204181671,
0.5054622888565063,
-0.07616899907588959,
0.9794962406158447,
0.16501136124134064,
-0.24603676795959473,
-0.8131794333457947,
0.6178007125854492,
-0.010586390271782875,
-0.5620099306106567,
-0.49372512102127075,
-0.7617596983909607,
-1.249765396118164,
0.20605523884296417,
0.05148443207144737,
-0.5181244015693665,
0.16987474262714386,
0.27484971284866333,
-0.2796674072742462,
0.31900936365127563,
-0.19906260073184967,
0.7788008451461792,
-0.3304710388183594,
-0.23299260437488556,
-0.17258217930793762,
-0.8485599160194397,
0.525314450263977,
0.19183245301246643,
0.48021915555000305,
0.014985042624175549,
-0.18096300959587097,
0.7798336148262024,
-0.5758812427520752,
0.891667902469635,
-0.19565165042877197,
0.16584116220474243,
0.2592586874961853,
0.05205344408750534,
0.4346699118614197,
-0.32933396100997925,
0.20054477453231812,
-0.03921835497021675,
-0.1818571388721466,
-0.8536418676376343,
-0.8567107915878296,
0.4014667868614197,
-0.47385725378990173,
-0.28321951627731323,
-0.5156818628311157,
-0.31355932354927063,
0.01162148080766201,
0.2410767823457718,
0.4056524336338043,
0.5600459575653076,
-0.21957099437713623,
0.14556066691875458,
0.9095485806465149,
0.30155038833618164,
0.635222852230072,
0.18025179207324982,
-0.136410653591156,
-0.12163230776786804,
0.8911888003349304,
0.1484440118074417,
0.3778805136680603,
0.36336490511894226,
0.5564574003219604,
-0.1624460220336914,
-0.8120279908180237,
-0.3295016884803772,
0.12026260793209076,
-0.789461076259613,
0.08786962926387787,
-0.3069523274898529,
-0.42750173807144165,
0.0001368639204883948,
-0.14481575787067413,
-0.26797810196876526,
-0.538894772529602,
-0.22890214622020721,
-0.16907034814357758,
-0.10021816194057465,
0.6201697587966919,
-0.43155086040496826,
0.2770523726940155,
-0.6199285387992859,
0.07500222325325012,
0.3580528199672699,
0.2214634120464325,
0.08162035048007965,
-0.598274827003479,
-0.44535428285598755,
0.3491823673248291,
-0.010612964630126953,
-0.6850263476371765,
-0.026554826647043228,
0.7361852526664734,
0.683725893497467,
0.7584435939788818,
-0.2792438864707947,
0.4766784906387329,
-0.5852773189544678,
0.5278024673461914,
0.4914001524448395,
-0.7270498871803284,
0.5087956786155701,
-0.41486236453056335,
0.17403613030910492,
0.5778321027755737,
0.3305428922176361,
-0.7277873754501343,
0.025265326723456383,
-0.574600338935852,
-0.7363870143890381,
0.32692334055900574,
0.3246108591556549,
0.2914179265499115,
-0.18809975683689117,
0.5376877188682556,
-0.23349887132644653,
0.18931619822978973,
-0.7628949880599976,
-0.6273633241653442,
0.20060303807258606,
-0.373119056224823,
-0.004697538446635008,
-0.06820960342884064,
-0.3806697428226471,
-0.15861158072948456,
0.6998524069786072,
-0.22674737870693207,
0.34686756134033203,
0.08157014846801758,
-0.17401880025863647,
-0.1876622438430786,
0.4062511920928955,
0.9968846440315247,
0.9054785370826721,
-0.027700167149305344,
0.2901214361190796,
0.25929832458496094,
-0.12693466246128082,
0.11459840834140778,
-0.03138761222362518,
-0.3638402223587036,
0.09991414844989777,
0.6536547541618347,
0.9837251305580139,
0.521573543548584,
-0.36180487275123596,
0.4068370759487152,
0.03453385457396507,
-0.6368733048439026,
-0.2101791501045227,
-0.03370736539363861,
-0.08116159588098526,
-0.008416105061769485,
0.37110021710395813,
0.4449273943901062,
0.3285856246948242,
-0.375284880399704,
0.26491859555244446,
0.45300060510635376,
-0.6220939755439758,
-0.3702704906463623,
0.44886472821235657,
0.04479394480586052,
-0.5265700817108154,
0.46431964635849,
-0.35690683126449585,
-0.6400383710861206,
0.791089653968811,
0.5593643188476562,
0.9358019232749939,
0.010223282501101494,
0.17792072892189026,
0.24297428131103516,
0.5916456580162048,
-0.26594310998916626,
0.1842166632413864,
-0.09135447442531586,
-0.5574360489845276,
-0.6582236289978027,
-0.5772283673286438,
-0.05221187323331833,
-0.11067438870668411,
-0.6651846170425415,
0.06341782212257385,
-0.9014129638671875,
0.04533300921320915,
-0.11103899031877518,
0.14061696827411652,
-0.6084561944007874,
0.30733662843704224,
0.20204536616802216,
0.8683854341506958,
-0.8521543741226196,
0.6253811120986938,
0.5359389781951904,
-0.5051764249801636,
-1.03902268409729,
-0.514099657535553,
-0.06170063093304634,
-0.47433510422706604,
0.8564417362213135,
-0.007332793902605772,
-0.11428603529930115,
-0.21912327408790588,
-0.6524402499198914,
-0.6142114400863647,
0.8899766206741333,
0.22696520388126373,
-0.8412490487098694,
-0.4245145916938782,
0.1747891902923584,
0.5756301283836365,
-0.48133641481399536,
-0.11125113070011139,
0.3349858522415161,
0.6661249995231628,
-0.000988982617855072,
-0.8002673983573914,
-0.08986308425664902,
-0.2346654087305069,
0.013705241493880749,
0.35135573148727417,
-0.47443151473999023,
0.9426628947257996,
-0.10555633157491684,
-0.23700344562530518,
0.15073615312576294,
0.6087661981582642,
-0.06460554152727127,
0.5646795630455017,
0.4023391902446747,
0.7566241025924683,
0.828677237033844,
-0.16466733813285828,
1.2885327339172363,
-0.09178291261196136,
0.35625842213630676,
0.9304091930389404,
0.08840744197368622,
0.37352296710014343,
0.3000137507915497,
-0.33835482597351074,
0.32527822256088257,
0.8986281156539917,
0.19687679409980774,
0.5554794669151306,
0.6179870963096619,
-0.2039148509502411,
-0.2791026532649994,
0.23912903666496277,
-0.42445388436317444,
0.21134576201438904,
0.31374987959861755,
-0.5676420331001282,
-0.28447824716567993,
-0.2026652991771698,
-0.02937600389122963,
0.3389108180999756,
-0.4528806805610657,
0.6006552577018738,
0.4257974922657013,
-0.2907763421535492,
0.7878398299217224,
0.23439018428325653,
0.5571009516716003,
-0.7260399460792542,
0.05166161060333252,
-0.3490070402622223,
0.03928457573056221,
-0.290776789188385,
0.006736328359693289,
0.3486858010292053,
-0.4789515435695648,
-0.3133854568004608,
0.13114917278289795,
0.8826465606689453,
-0.5653821229934692,
-0.41155460476875305,
0.2041635513305664,
0.3316730558872223,
0.3430401086807251,
0.20811277627944946,
-0.8621661067008972,
-0.314606636762619,
-0.2686227262020111,
0.07723748683929443,
0.22831986844539642,
0.35795044898986816,
0.08694008737802505,
0.6816989779472351,
0.5326046943664551,
0.37224695086479187,
0.3940750062465668,
-0.22282008826732635,
0.43223851919174194,
-0.5293741822242737,
-0.45311376452445984,
-1.0835893154144287,
0.3168065845966339,
-0.13420076668262482,
-0.3100104331970215,
0.6376521587371826,
0.5488225817680359,
0.7106629014015198,
-0.038780372589826584,
0.7621655464172363,
0.06139072775840759,
0.09799609333276749,
-0.8459223508834839,
0.4423173666000366,
-0.6515504121780396,
0.29455944895744324,
-0.030312007293105125,
-1.1783145666122437,
-0.4845777750015259,
0.9097691774368286,
-0.1900322139263153,
0.19351796805858612,
1.0177301168441772,
0.5460960865020752,
-0.3651832044124603,
-0.23400980234146118,
0.5802268385887146,
-0.0032738479785621166,
-0.1444147527217865,
0.7746266722679138,
0.8587310314178467,
-0.6056778430938721,
0.3790913224220276,
-0.39204949140548706,
-0.21183456480503082,
-0.16267725825309753,
-0.8201083540916443,
-0.8894956707954407,
-0.4130241572856903,
-0.4389747977256775,
-0.37091800570487976,
0.44731053709983826,
1.070711374282837,
0.9485352039337158,
-0.7459502816200256,
-0.34606122970581055,
-0.38640186190605164,
0.2928036153316498,
-0.41044673323631287,
-0.16725386679172516,
0.21129189431667328,
-0.847362756729126,
-0.5574387907981873,
0.5164008736610413,
0.21647615730762482,
-0.11348995566368103,
-0.378156453371048,
-0.45399096608161926,
-0.3241918981075287,
0.21323683857917786,
0.31424760818481445,
0.8884918689727783,
-0.7625414729118347,
-0.29684701561927795,
-0.1052580177783966,
-0.311299592256546,
0.07689227908849716,
0.9418985247612,
-0.2890405058860779,
0.09986845403909683,
0.40404438972473145,
0.9740790128707886,
0.3429153263568878,
-0.33662429451942444,
0.5565411448478699,
-1.1099858283996582,
0.10748282819986343,
0.304524689912796,
0.42484092712402344,
0.21381177008152008,
-0.11747328191995621,
0.6300421357154846,
0.36936506628990173,
-0.46751442551612854,
-0.8529165387153625,
0.5455693006515503,
-0.6605387926101685,
-0.3141147196292877,
0.9823370575904846,
-0.033229291439056396,
-0.4565955698490143,
-0.15447653830051422,
0.07304452359676361,
0.04331604763865471,
-0.11830686777830124,
0.5833045244216919,
0.6928503513336182,
0.07338062673807144,
-0.10016834735870361,
-0.5653833746910095,
0.625869870185852,
0.47347861528396606,
-0.3744393587112427,
-0.34590932726860046,
0.29780229926109314,
0.2640010416507721,
0.35334327816963196,
0.5507701635360718,
0.3373936414718628,
0.40000492334365845,
-0.019509058445692062,
-0.08805007487535477,
-0.28315219283103943,
-0.7135753631591797,
-0.6124059557914734,
-0.08176911622285843,
0.32169368863105774,
-0.3730921745300293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03676v1 | Neural Information Organizing and Processing -- Neural Machines | 2024-02-15T15:15:11 | 2024-02-15T15:15:11 | Iosif Iulian Petrila | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.LG | The informational synthesis of neural structures, processes, parameters and
characteristics that allow a unified description and modeling as neural
machines of natural and artificial neural systems is presented. The general
informational parameters as the global quantitative measure of the neural
systems computing potential as absolute and relative neural power were
proposed. Neural information organizing and processing follows the way in which
nature manages neural information by developing functions, functionalities and
circuits related to different internal or peripheral components and also to the
whole system through a non-deterministic memorization, fragmentation and
aggregation of afferent and efferent information, deep neural information
processing representing multiple alternations of fragmentation and aggregation
stages. The relevant neural characteristics were integrated into a neural
machine type model that incorporates unitary also peripheral or interface
components as the central ones. The proposed approach allows overcoming the
technical constraints in artificial computational implementations of neural
information processes and also provides a more relevant description of natural
ones. | [
-0.3814680278301239,
-0.824154794216156,
0.31209248304367065,
0.22213439643383026,
-0.06101623922586441,
-0.17748500406742096,
-0.20835193991661072,
-0.5589728355407715,
0.5817641615867615,
0.11780942231416702,
-0.3573800027370453,
-0.030106626451015472,
-0.19220702350139618,
-0.17305493354797363,
-0.4672146737575531,
0.7887793183326721,
0.1711963713169098,
0.5433009266853333,
-0.05540681257843971,
-0.25915980339050293,
-0.4496162533760071,
-0.9042077660560608,
-0.5406214594841003,
-0.5257401466369629,
0.536141574382782,
-0.157455176115036,
0.4602409899234772,
0.9167479872703552,
0.6458611488342285,
0.5335612297058105,
-0.2658268213272095,
-0.04200821742415428,
0.2417348474264145,
0.3575928807258606,
-0.3507019877433777,
-0.7336729168891907,
-0.6291729807853699,
0.003203202039003372,
0.8564950227737427,
1.016980767250061,
0.0491727851331234,
0.25608643889427185,
0.15011906623840332,
0.5922510027885437,
-0.28945595026016235,
0.2701992988586426,
-0.4051259756088257,
0.4334985911846161,
0.23118947446346283,
-0.6849642992019653,
-0.21467465162277222,
-0.47752758860588074,
-0.04519544541835785,
-0.2982787489891052,
0.23602066934108734,
-0.15119265019893646,
0.3007350265979767,
0.23223434388637543,
-0.12719768285751343,
-0.2413232922554016,
-1.1147940158843994,
0.5069652795791626,
-0.24832908809185028,
0.12155433744192123,
0.09500325471162796,
0.3948882520198822,
-0.0977812334895134,
-0.5484747886657715,
-0.11980661749839783,
-0.22289341688156128,
-0.113446906208992,
0.01648706942796707,
-0.3158662021160126,
0.39159512519836426,
-0.017429040744900703,
0.23623725771903992,
-0.40482068061828613,
-0.09501248598098755,
-0.5666286945343018,
-0.26581183075904846,
0.4766300320625305,
0.3839837610721588,
0.35531505942344666,
0.09072204679250717,
-0.252776175737381,
0.2766631543636322,
-0.2674548029899597,
-0.22043229639530182,
0.4695729911327362,
0.3901689946651459,
0.33076757192611694,
0.6224024891853333,
-0.341078519821167,
0.8415893316268921,
-0.08944372832775116,
0.10872185975313187,
-0.24345631897449493,
-0.46535524725914,
-0.644277036190033,
0.16151542961597443,
0.5160983800888062,
0.20548275113105774,
-0.09725106507539749,
-0.4890621304512024,
-0.22711753845214844,
-0.04248325154185295,
0.40167298913002014,
-0.6266941428184509,
-0.060140952467918396,
-0.019368596374988556,
-0.9242534637451172,
-0.36221203207969666,
0.005835314281284809,
-0.6321339011192322,
-0.29873281717300415,
-1.1129757165908813,
0.5533570647239685,
-0.459963321685791,
-0.3886203169822693,
-0.34356775879859924,
-0.22980503737926483,
-0.16872061789035797,
0.05141010880470276,
-0.9116054177284241,
0.7067238092422485,
0.3110913634300232,
0.8433648943901062,
0.019241346046328545,
-0.30332350730895996,
0.24618937075138092,
-0.10090277343988419,
-0.1397811770439148,
0.3588901460170746,
-0.1729060858488083,
0.15572087466716766,
-0.3043794631958008,
-0.11896970123052597,
-0.1809529811143875,
-0.6591686010360718,
0.2058085799217224,
-0.7905529737472534,
-0.09435158222913742,
-0.09504253417253494,
-0.37823575735092163,
-0.4829505383968353,
0.06876612454652786,
-0.7856392860412598,
0.19581590592861176,
0.0349959060549736,
-0.4920773506164551,
-0.15914838016033173,
-1.1415820121765137,
-0.4717647433280945,
-0.18408584594726562,
0.19359153509140015,
0.3603716492652893,
0.348360151052475,
-0.45339667797088623,
0.35154345631599426,
-0.4569506347179413,
0.44882670044898987,
-0.07429197430610657,
-0.2227519452571869,
0.6726213693618774,
-0.6590679883956909,
0.7927834391593933,
0.3190493583679199,
-0.10369739681482315,
0.5388250350952148,
-0.9046922922134399,
0.34064239263534546,
-0.001381800975650549,
-0.5283744931221008,
-0.03511403128504753,
0.10457751899957657,
-0.022518998011946678,
0.18510961532592773,
0.7551079988479614,
-0.04497623071074486,
0.30174392461776733,
-0.18300427496433258,
1.0657881498336792,
0.6518058180809021,
0.025221731513738632,
0.8667578101158142,
-0.03090853802859783,
0.04799724370241165,
0.03635184466838837,
0.5118935108184814,
0.03062509000301361,
-0.1805448681116104,
-0.6475146412849426,
0.19117622077465057,
0.5380440354347229,
0.46923962235450745,
-0.2868809103965759,
0.7376571297645569,
-0.05581386387348175,
-0.28002601861953735,
-0.1584664136171341,
-0.3060830533504486,
0.18147903680801392,
0.47199469804763794,
0.2288157343864441,
-0.09498002380132675,
-0.8276894688606262,
-1.1456658840179443,
0.06979010999202728,
-0.313206285238266,
-0.21390759944915771,
-0.19224253296852112,
0.298124760389328,
0.18743276596069336,
0.4791703224182129,
-0.1509675830602646,
0.009635549038648605,
0.2836233377456665,
0.37749651074409485,
0.7012569904327393,
0.4605717957019806,
-0.03324728086590767,
-0.8664916753768921,
0.18667639791965485,
0.04317054525017738,
-1.0496286153793335,
0.328906387090683,
0.061910416930913925,
-0.14876684546470642,
0.016315851360559464,
0.30867037177085876,
-0.8873819708824158,
0.5702972412109375,
-0.054665230214595795,
-0.1631544679403305,
0.5401210784912109,
-0.6038000583648682,
0.31351757049560547,
-0.6820163726806641,
0.4097316265106201,
-0.4160696566104889,
0.4435950219631195,
-0.8503098487854004,
0.2652454674243927,
-0.22959931194782257,
0.20821911096572876,
-0.017679303884506226,
-0.02469855174422264,
-0.5743592381477356,
-0.3170103132724762,
-0.5154389142990112,
-0.312485009431839,
-0.014552081003785133,
0.662512481212616,
-0.31630846858024597,
0.3597266674041748,
0.5735045075416565,
-0.947754979133606,
0.7375882267951965,
-0.3220231831073761,
-0.146011620759964,
0.8430696725845337,
-0.7581652402877808,
0.03239086642861366,
-0.2599068582057953,
-0.21394453942775726,
-0.8009787201881409,
-0.5971740484237671,
0.1151425838470459,
-0.5984175801277161,
0.3908030390739441,
-0.12144617736339569,
-0.574548602104187,
-0.03674719110131264,
0.14274998009204865,
0.43923860788345337,
0.26517438888549805,
-0.14379869401454926,
0.7216721177101135,
0.5009195804595947,
-0.08376957476139069,
-0.23939013481140137,
-0.9433019757270813,
0.22990195453166962,
-0.1327531486749649,
-0.693863570690155,
0.7510707378387451,
-0.053743280470371246,
-0.592065691947937,
0.2870127856731415,
0.15376751124858856,
-0.5795762538909912,
-0.01988908275961876,
0.41712579131126404,
0.304408460855484,
-0.41106417775154114,
0.6716813445091248,
-0.08819210529327393,
-0.033054180443286896,
0.20025770366191864,
-0.6891540288925171,
0.6401963233947754,
-0.2538334131240845,
-0.19507351517677307,
-0.39960914850234985,
0.36111846566200256,
0.7625259160995483,
0.14284974336624146,
0.7331668138504028,
0.2552627921104431,
-0.7158470749855042,
0.09288620948791504,
-0.13990160822868347,
-0.24948696792125702,
-0.3994196057319641,
0.39431294798851013,
-0.30276453495025635,
-0.1760246753692627,
0.6836255192756653,
0.2129458338022232,
-0.1813593953847885,
0.45299848914146423,
0.309709370136261,
-0.13471481204032898,
1.0796916484832764,
0.43622809648513794,
-0.1968613862991333,
0.5246008038520813,
-0.1749182492494583,
0.13005636632442474,
-0.847501277923584,
-0.4743868112564087,
-0.43007513880729675,
-0.9328948259353638,
-0.3272075951099396,
-0.21611258387565613,
0.32243919372558594,
0.5430763363838196,
-0.5454766154289246,
0.21969647705554962,
-1.2556965351104736,
0.4844081997871399,
0.8273721933364868,
0.2629345953464508,
-0.04486590251326561,
0.12452571094036102,
-0.2613804340362549,
0.08883491903543472,
-0.6490455865859985,
-0.3531859517097473,
0.8509728908538818,
0.08196324110031128,
0.5815348029136658,
-0.1416381299495697,
0.1899581253528595,
0.18685466051101685,
-0.02106430195271969,
-0.6968363523483276,
0.6031367778778076,
-0.036548513919115067,
-0.6130908131599426,
-0.17191576957702637,
-0.37994369864463806,
-0.7941884398460388,
0.1087602898478508,
0.11420760303735733,
-0.9472245573997498,
0.20480775833129883,
-0.0778789073228836,
-0.4446108043193817,
0.6422585248947144,
-0.887427806854248,
0.11558683216571808,
-0.5492900013923645,
-0.14522631466388702,
-0.3405359387397766,
-0.7518787384033203,
0.22535471618175507,
0.2829715609550476,
-0.1220899298787117,
0.2642802596092224,
-0.1995040327310562,
0.7082694172859192,
-0.28087925910949707,
0.7812264561653137,
-0.26163724064826965,
0.7438773512840271,
0.4939940571784973,
0.14690802991390228,
-0.19183748960494995,
-0.2147843986749649,
-0.4252314269542694,
0.2480982095003128,
-0.16097474098205566,
-0.03331221640110016,
-0.5437890887260437,
0.7698696851730347,
-0.7575189471244812,
-0.24623888731002808,
-0.007943172939121723,
-0.9093541502952576,
0.13061122596263885,
0.2772159278392792,
0.434372216463089,
0.423840194940567,
-0.26193392276763916,
0.2072916328907013,
0.3897644877433777,
0.07786358147859573,
0.7014364004135132,
-0.03311670571565628,
-0.09949418902397156,
-0.7911970615386963,
0.7170506119728088,
0.7840377688407898,
-0.0966440737247467,
0.5088363885879517,
-0.13303697109222412,
-0.33051204681396484,
-0.719079852104187,
-0.05047143995761871,
-0.2902832329273224,
-0.904528021812439,
-0.310806006193161,
-0.37454283237457275,
-0.7341633439064026,
0.012156500481069088,
0.38927721977233887,
0.06281046569347382,
-0.6527970433235168,
-0.48156046867370605,
-0.017583902925252914,
0.22531890869140625,
1.0697221755981445,
-0.3595999777317047,
0.4145714342594147,
-0.5122703909873962,
0.3356441259384155,
0.4148450493812561,
0.3889996111392975,
0.14450985193252563,
-0.19037413597106934,
-0.36656150221824646,
0.4497661292552948,
-0.35701149702072144,
-0.9280107617378235,
0.26289334893226624,
-0.02218608558177948,
0.6525303721427917,
0.2506170868873596,
-0.45531585812568665,
0.44642332196235657,
-0.18990011513233185,
0.4343215823173523,
0.33784064650535583,
-0.739018440246582,
0.5697025656700134,
-0.14839333295822144,
0.26642584800720215,
0.24602405726909637,
0.08868052065372467,
-0.16530963778495789,
0.3855678141117096,
-0.6364921927452087,
-0.7091531157493591,
0.6856390833854675,
0.26441922783851624,
0.0679301992058754,
0.3586086332798004,
0.4336184859275818,
-0.2625424563884735,
0.39711031317710876,
-0.49504974484443665,
-0.1612689346075058,
-0.020751314237713814,
-0.13775566220283508,
0.5192434787750244,
0.03541014343500137,
-0.303202360868454,
-0.39724427461624146,
0.33411797881126404,
-0.041122354567050934,
0.8302268385887146,
0.17143088579177856,
0.06124943867325783,
-0.02247699350118637,
-0.048421770334243774,
0.6807335019111633,
0.6647197008132935,
-0.07073798775672913,
0.3912186324596405,
-0.13987930119037628,
-0.1636945903301239,
0.3984479308128357,
-0.06229521706700325,
-0.2703765034675598,
-0.04059235751628876,
0.27649474143981934,
0.7257289290428162,
-0.02055080607533455,
0.13558247685432434,
-0.20584611594676971,
-0.17576821148395538,
-0.06707313656806946,
-0.2504987120628357,
0.5169304013252258,
0.3213517367839813,
0.39059585332870483,
0.4458734095096588,
0.8294234871864319,
0.37568846344947815,
-0.5601267218589783,
0.04156198352575302,
0.2728327810764313,
-0.43762099742889404,
-0.7082170844078064,
0.2889387905597687,
-0.29282432794570923,
-0.8064359426498413,
0.7533325552940369,
0.13840971887111664,
-0.3462813198566437,
1.2065646648406982,
0.4156525731086731,
0.8601633310317993,
-0.46181029081344604,
0.04269398748874664,
0.38520798087120056,
0.3577626943588257,
0.17961496114730835,
0.3309343755245209,
-0.31756192445755005,
-0.5035994052886963,
-0.2198045253753662,
-0.8104461431503296,
0.008219040930271149,
0.23270581662654877,
-0.5202937722206116,
-0.054385311901569366,
-1.0424997806549072,
-0.6081293225288391,
0.6240257620811462,
-0.30945146083831787,
-0.574756383895874,
0.3122335970401764,
0.024798568338155746,
0.7050820589065552,
-0.30350708961486816,
0.596015214920044,
0.812872052192688,
-0.5535248517990112,
-0.5363874435424805,
-0.4255930185317993,
-0.2902851998806,
-0.4099065959453583,
0.8853917121887207,
0.07657265663146973,
0.1057693213224411,
-0.2583634853363037,
-0.5999188423156738,
-0.9386168718338013,
0.8965626358985901,
0.5004374980926514,
-0.007963527925312519,
-0.23413914442062378,
0.2920275330543518,
0.8360844850540161,
-0.5233358144760132,
0.6743725538253784,
0.3248031437397003,
0.6847512125968933,
0.12637872993946075,
-0.5808026194572449,
-0.11345463991165161,
-0.6917498111724854,
0.004398368764668703,
0.2658786177635193,
-0.47656041383743286,
1.1500433683395386,
0.16309916973114014,
-0.23754069209098816,
0.37604600191116333,
0.18136820197105408,
-0.2285720258951187,
0.024441955611109734,
0.185532808303833,
0.21071060001850128,
0.8296067714691162,
-0.2834264636039734,
0.6488791108131409,
-0.5558618903160095,
-0.24532274901866913,
0.8373177647590637,
0.21396788954734802,
0.37351444363594055,
0.5196898579597473,
-0.2135491520166397,
0.06260205805301666,
0.5327180027961731,
0.05589113384485245,
0.1773059070110321,
0.4656899869441986,
-0.2880285382270813,
0.26003530621528625,
-0.3030821681022644,
-0.20676885545253754,
0.45072218775749207,
0.4256008565425873,
-0.9383758306503296,
-0.007519979029893875,
-0.10276792198419571,
-0.5254762172698975,
-0.3881020247936249,
-0.4738534092903137,
0.8172496557235718,
-0.027437761425971985,
-0.9757978320121765,
0.685560941696167,
0.14028704166412354,
0.2567756175994873,
-0.5685694813728333,
-0.25049763917922974,
0.1345033496618271,
0.07078254967927933,
-0.43971678614616394,
-0.5792736411094666,
0.6777511239051819,
-0.33472034335136414,
-0.7826736569404602,
-0.15803366899490356,
1.0192750692367554,
-0.1893254965543747,
-0.23492331802845,
0.44069069623947144,
-0.003121395595371723,
0.16869796812534332,
-0.30404597520828247,
-0.5650558471679688,
-0.11894231289625168,
-0.1426520049571991,
-0.1499994546175003,
0.20588019490242004,
0.30533862113952637,
0.001733623561449349,
0.368960440158844,
0.5431456565856934,
0.2797887623310089,
0.4903637170791626,
-0.13691262900829315,
0.629946768283844,
-0.9149680137634277,
-0.29492273926734924,
-0.9211287498474121,
0.4787274897098541,
-0.28181612491607666,
-0.29563745856285095,
0.2197151631116867,
0.10422687232494354,
0.27214890718460083,
-0.02704678848385811,
0.641797661781311,
-0.2666570842266083,
-0.21887151896953583,
-0.36997801065444946,
0.8096476793289185,
-0.17334090173244476,
0.00004469733903533779,
0.47846028208732605,
-1.3427016735076904,
-0.21709157526493073,
0.3434979021549225,
0.04924721643328667,
0.12523414194583893,
0.571215808391571,
0.5352967381477356,
-0.16999883949756622,
0.520111620426178,
0.3632943332195282,
0.3670004606246948,
-0.12111421674489975,
0.4809422194957733,
0.941317081451416,
-0.3948434293270111,
0.2406986802816391,
-0.3752870559692383,
-0.21855920553207397,
-0.16454842686653137,
-0.475507527589798,
-0.35987213253974915,
-0.7704772353172302,
-0.01665485091507435,
-0.02710873633623123,
-0.3150081932544708,
0.5982632040977478,
1.1419519186019897,
-0.7400079965591431,
-0.3904480040073395,
-0.6703537702560425,
0.21096360683441162,
-0.14816109836101532,
-0.25023624300956726,
0.12608197331428528,
-0.47155603766441345,
-0.3919655978679657,
0.5444414019584656,
0.6540178656578064,
0.036425236612558365,
-0.5255711674690247,
0.04527176916599274,
-0.12101394683122635,
0.2537557780742645,
0.4785357117652893,
0.3032647967338562,
-0.3858826756477356,
0.17701418697834015,
0.1857578307390213,
-0.20750537514686584,
0.22451432049274445,
0.569667398929596,
-0.3135937452316284,
0.5863791108131409,
0.985603392124176,
0.426772803068161,
0.18266749382019043,
-0.3645935356616974,
0.5530595183372498,
-0.5706733465194702,
0.07326646149158478,
0.3695482611656189,
0.5431097745895386,
0.23031818866729736,
-0.5909698605537415,
0.41913679242134094,
0.03572341054677963,
-0.637428879737854,
-0.5444017648696899,
0.20962542295455933,
-0.5085448026657104,
-0.5117691159248352,
0.5114186406135559,
-0.05477308854460716,
-0.6638564467430115,
-0.019470248371362686,
-0.08468927443027496,
0.7904646396636963,
0.248585045337677,
0.7082990407943726,
0.6746975779533386,
-0.5216266512870789,
0.37427055835723877,
-0.340457946062088,
-0.057296980172395706,
0.12489056587219238,
-0.8596797585487366,
-0.252157062292099,
0.4806031584739685,
0.08702263236045837,
0.8926167488098145,
0.31910240650177,
-0.2745077311992645,
0.10346133261919022,
0.2499309629201889,
0.37730616331100464,
-0.016061266884207726,
-0.8968156576156616,
-0.5161836743354797,
0.7330939173698425,
-0.3083539605140686,
-0.4751643240451813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09997v1 | LoraRetriever: Input-Aware LoRA Retrieval and Composition for Mixed Tasks in the Wild | 2024-02-15T15:02:46 | 2024-02-15T15:02:46 | Ziyu Zhao, Leilei Gan, Guoyin Wang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Hongxia Yang, Kun Kuang, Fei Wu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) provides an effective yet efficient solution for
fine-tuning large language models (LLM). The modular and plug-and-play nature
of LoRA enables the integration of diverse domain-specific LoRAs to enhance the
capabilities of LLMs. Previous research on exploiting multiple LoRAs either
focuses on specific isolated downstream tasks or fixes the selection of LoRAs
during training. However, in real-world scenarios, LLMs receive diverse prompts
covering different tasks, and the pool of candidate LoRAs is often dynamically
updated. To bridge this gap, we propose LoraRetriever, a retrieve-then-compose
framework that adaptively retrieves and composes multiple LoRAs according to
the input prompts. LoraRetriever contains three main components: firstly,
identifying and retrieving LoRAs relevant to the given input; secondly,
formulating strategies for effectively integrating the retrieved LoRAs; and
thirdly, developing efficient batch inference to accommodate heterogeneous
requests. Experimental results indicate that LoraRetriever consistently
outperforms the baselines, highlighting its practical effectiveness and
versatility. | [
-0.3924010694026947,
-0.8463245630264282,
0.419730007648468,
0.44341957569122314,
-0.008848276920616627,
0.15605655312538147,
-0.5415332317352295,
-0.5515653491020203,
0.40438517928123474,
0.6198403835296631,
-0.5823115706443787,
-0.3599192202091217,
-0.6331350207328796,
0.13639599084854126,
-0.3820643126964569,
0.823994517326355,
-0.008891336619853973,
-0.34587356448173523,
0.10203386098146439,
-0.3521774411201477,
-0.79777592420578,
-0.09594755619764328,
-0.6434805393218994,
-0.5018259286880493,
1.03953218460083,
0.7177154421806335,
0.3835272490978241,
0.26417315006256104,
0.4599068760871887,
0.3861185312271118,
-0.008126167580485344,
0.44668683409690857,
-0.72355055809021,
0.6744555234909058,
-0.49067381024360657,
-0.5219771265983582,
-0.41192367672920227,
-0.2749673128128052,
0.7170339226722717,
0.6835786700248718,
-0.2927039861679077,
0.11139553785324097,
0.23698115348815918,
0.44933804869651794,
-1.049144983291626,
-0.2652662396430969,
-0.7746286392211914,
0.17970994114875793,
-0.14931680262088776,
-0.166278675198555,
-0.4808667004108429,
-0.3001163899898529,
0.0015315134078264236,
-0.6396931409835815,
-0.19463036954402924,
-0.15619561076164246,
0.361367404460907,
0.41752904653549194,
-0.06660392880439758,
-0.02900095283985138,
-0.8189911246299744,
0.7565606236457825,
-0.6257600784301758,
0.20390315353870392,
0.42514580488204956,
0.5685593485832214,
-0.3142905533313751,
-0.684603214263916,
-0.45553791522979736,
0.30509522557258606,
0.11858297884464264,
0.07635154575109482,
-0.3885488212108612,
-0.3013092875480652,
-0.07922669500112534,
0.3124851584434509,
-0.41562530398368835,
0.5957346558570862,
0.05310239642858505,
-0.022424904629588127,
0.10814280807971954,
0.10692223161458969,
0.18384963274002075,
-0.027923185378313065,
0.07732179760932922,
-0.1385907381772995,
-0.5335004329681396,
-0.10904660075902939,
0.218336820602417,
0.7365273833274841,
-0.18773601949214935,
0.6603597402572632,
-0.3002520799636841,
0.8113124370574951,
0.2776009738445282,
-0.3330332040786743,
0.21901503205299377,
-0.2359529435634613,
-0.2841093838214874,
0.0001356281281914562,
0.74989914894104,
-0.2703520655632019,
-0.16985531151294708,
-0.13824012875556946,
-0.30443885922431946,
-0.15857957303524017,
0.154277965426445,
-0.7741215229034424,
0.06329608708620071,
0.2407948076725006,
-0.12104972451925278,
-0.36538970470428467,
-0.21419160068035126,
-0.8455524444580078,
-0.7238543629646301,
-0.06497636437416077,
0.5115014314651489,
-0.2521291971206665,
0.020581604912877083,
0.2521621584892273,
-0.05196143686771393,
0.21560832858085632,
0.6334193348884583,
-0.9459720253944397,
0.3082256615161896,
0.6154660582542419,
0.6615758538246155,
-0.46813586354255676,
-0.5364410877227783,
-1.3885916471481323,
0.12776173651218414,
0.043328456580638885,
1.1604576110839844,
-0.5562379956245422,
-0.37168875336647034,
-0.02442537248134613,
0.27974939346313477,
-0.2998782694339752,
-0.6618425250053406,
0.44975656270980835,
-0.6892916560173035,
0.30188024044036865,
-0.20867647230625153,
-0.09940654039382935,
0.1553150862455368,
0.3642113208770752,
-0.9496234655380249,
1.3239370584487915,
0.46388161182403564,
-0.7459850311279297,
0.14798271656036377,
-0.9374261498451233,
-0.6704114675521851,
0.1319248229265213,
-0.12298461049795151,
-0.20497016608715057,
0.2518218457698822,
0.3105265498161316,
0.27681657671928406,
-0.3086419105529785,
-0.17150646448135376,
-0.2229444533586502,
-0.5620668530464172,
0.20936466753482819,
-0.11720605939626694,
0.4570569396018982,
0.02534673362970352,
-0.18990086019039154,
0.30527088046073914,
-0.7300381064414978,
-0.08657053858041763,
0.19904650747776031,
-1.0321695804595947,
-0.2718832492828369,
0.15895184874534607,
0.23596595227718353,
-0.0689125806093216,
0.23862224817276,
-0.6521053910255432,
0.3945631980895996,
-0.3238908350467682,
0.41743600368499756,
0.6768181920051575,
-0.13845911622047424,
0.5185834169387817,
-0.3780200779438019,
0.5834524035453796,
-0.1549752801656723,
-0.11157707124948502,
0.11572671681642532,
-0.08276641368865967,
-0.7957038879394531,
-0.604922354221344,
0.30469048023223877,
0.5913386344909668,
-0.9284468293190002,
0.41037774085998535,
-0.38979777693748474,
-0.37277987599372864,
-0.5221798419952393,
0.4228835701942444,
0.10894539207220078,
0.34754258394241333,
0.2153574824333191,
-0.1289723664522171,
-0.5221163630485535,
-0.5501646995544434,
-0.2559652030467987,
0.15651428699493408,
0.24445024132728577,
0.2879226505756378,
0.3865058422088623,
-0.6090514659881592,
0.9599624872207642,
-0.5134581327438354,
-0.49308088421821594,
-0.664844810962677,
0.03271138295531273,
0.38836270570755005,
0.39252158999443054,
0.4366289973258972,
-0.49422165751457214,
-0.40168362855911255,
0.32173797488212585,
-0.5412462949752808,
-0.07790178060531616,
0.30962732434272766,
-0.4052642285823822,
0.0006054889527149498,
0.4910639226436615,
-0.4447307288646698,
-0.028608594089746475,
0.9211530089378357,
-0.16048048436641693,
0.11752203106880188,
-0.2827468514442444,
-0.0010174197377637029,
-1.2378476858139038,
0.21644321084022522,
-0.4531742334365845,
-0.4984099566936493,
-0.48006460070610046,
0.18151336908340454,
-0.1268509179353714,
0.0035053237807005644,
-0.6595916152000427,
0.8310926556587219,
-0.18137399852275848,
-0.23797918856143951,
-0.349650502204895,
0.3429030478000641,
0.1763962060213089,
0.4316871166229248,
-0.28905805945396423,
0.8516535758972168,
0.3802942931652069,
-0.4741567075252533,
0.3855864107608795,
0.27949637174606323,
-0.3283974528312683,
0.6264911890029907,
-0.5644176602363586,
0.3776596486568451,
-0.2966083586215973,
0.23487824201583862,
-0.760773777961731,
-0.5889174342155457,
0.13647881150245667,
0.054119013249874115,
0.013551468029618263,
-0.4542329013347626,
-0.5574911832809448,
-0.152124285697937,
-0.1446102261543274,
0.3506719172000885,
0.5338395833969116,
-0.6812166571617126,
1.143663763999939,
0.3525727391242981,
-0.3869694769382477,
-0.6555821895599365,
-0.7518290281295776,
-0.14333543181419373,
-0.25752541422843933,
-0.19500581920146942,
0.07677297294139862,
-0.13447454571723938,
-0.13407069444656372,
-0.06719668209552765,
-0.002851014956831932,
0.020806998014450073,
0.43199944496154785,
0.2901008725166321,
-0.022602055221796036,
-0.25222426652908325,
-0.09109636396169662,
0.043400779366493225,
0.015097268857061863,
-0.4732067883014679,
-0.3292648494243622,
0.6340076923370361,
0.05471579357981682,
-0.6801859736442566,
-0.020585767924785614,
0.43689271807670593,
0.4985717535018921,
-0.37354105710983276,
0.5811891555786133,
0.7350131869316101,
-0.34179767966270447,
-0.7750199437141418,
-0.46465158462524414,
-0.04162496328353882,
-0.5441223978996277,
0.5019282698631287,
-0.41945764422416687,
-1.099113941192627,
0.6215296983718872,
-0.14533254504203796,
0.27880555391311646,
0.26102060079574585,
0.6364506483078003,
-0.1373242288827896,
0.5596184730529785,
0.6763791441917419,
-0.2431344985961914,
0.8304806351661682,
-0.13149544596672058,
0.05582185834646225,
-0.8141610622406006,
-0.03258756920695305,
-0.6785611510276794,
-0.5417662262916565,
-0.39406710863113403,
-0.6095353364944458,
0.398507684469223,
-0.06447643786668777,
-0.003682238282635808,
0.2904423475265503,
-0.25679510831832886,
0.7424920797348022,
0.4189029037952423,
0.12546485662460327,
0.4529740810394287,
0.21388985216617584,
0.04240330681204796,
0.1857077181339264,
-0.6434805989265442,
-0.11671511828899384,
0.7318376898765564,
0.06996303796768188,
1.075621247291565,
0.6455934643745422,
0.8401561379432678,
0.39455917477607727,
0.18933919072151184,
-1.1038684844970703,
0.5186734199523926,
-0.575984537601471,
-0.3049777150154114,
-0.3269823491573334,
-0.26357483863830566,
-1.1881240606307983,
0.5798637270927429,
-0.10068659484386444,
-0.8095957040786743,
0.3212846517562866,
0.17498232424259186,
-0.581179678440094,
0.05325017496943474,
-0.32040923833847046,
0.7050276398658752,
-0.15512511134147644,
-0.44380155205726624,
-0.07765938341617584,
-0.31941044330596924,
0.2533300817012787,
-0.47486162185668945,
0.19404003024101257,
-0.23297803103923798,
0.10510873794555664,
0.7024438381195068,
-0.1714552491903305,
0.9077098369598389,
-0.2161116898059845,
-0.4119126498699188,
0.06329990923404694,
0.306318998336792,
0.6536528468132019,
-0.08878637105226517,
-0.35330334305763245,
-0.5333326458930969,
0.06532664597034454,
-0.367051362991333,
-0.605214536190033,
1.0400118827819824,
-0.9977124333381653,
-0.37196409702301025,
-0.31160563230514526,
-0.6610453724861145,
-0.45913809537887573,
0.5028704404830933,
-0.06680943071842194,
0.43094301223754883,
-0.43850475549697876,
0.23556049168109894,
0.821097731590271,
-0.2338070124387741,
0.5144316554069519,
0.5884196758270264,
-0.37274661660194397,
-0.24350763857364655,
0.9083442091941833,
-0.41090768575668335,
0.28192636370658875,
0.5181013941764832,
0.14908196032047272,
0.16101492941379547,
-0.45247164368629456,
-0.3894369304180145,
0.08956339955329895,
-1.0709413290023804,
-0.16487234830856323,
-0.7006656527519226,
0.029309332370758057,
0.006746053695678711,
-0.10626750439405441,
-0.5605796575546265,
-0.23014093935489655,
-0.4741687774658203,
0.2686083912849426,
0.61833655834198,
0.6597142815589905,
0.041149772703647614,
0.4825693368911743,
-0.623313844203949,
0.647148609161377,
0.4846654534339905,
0.32685422897338867,
-0.23883870244026184,
-0.7744103074073792,
-0.2675461173057556,
-0.10492487996816635,
0.13106666505336761,
-0.2623291015625,
0.24455346167087555,
0.4235830307006836,
0.5150750279426575,
0.08214832842350006,
-0.07306381314992905,
0.7285209894180298,
-0.515933632850647,
0.5010622143745422,
-0.12142499536275864,
-0.6229261159896851,
0.4447183907032013,
-0.4007738530635834,
0.5729880928993225,
1.0118409395217896,
-0.12194360047578812,
-0.5320152640342712,
-0.08430084586143494,
0.07118655741214752,
-0.7572733163833618,
0.8627071380615234,
-0.20216839015483856,
0.14351330697536469,
0.21725432574748993,
0.03585952892899513,
0.3271348774433136,
-0.06457622349262238,
-0.48417776823043823,
0.13169842958450317,
-0.09336430579423904,
-0.31612730026245117,
-0.1204136535525322,
0.11001721024513245,
-0.3861303925514221,
0.026744062080979347,
0.4795094430446625,
-0.47682562470436096,
0.32983827590942383,
-0.11468227952718735,
-0.41539978981018066,
-0.1737004965543747,
0.6868343949317932,
0.5276768207550049,
0.4212837517261505,
-0.30822911858558655,
0.39589744806289673,
0.11843550205230713,
-0.5104278326034546,
0.14186719059944153,
0.2841396927833557,
0.08746275305747986,
-0.07060118019580841,
0.39544540643692017,
0.743945300579071,
0.5304356813430786,
-0.9674350023269653,
0.3854758143424988,
-0.20847754180431366,
-0.1102772057056427,
-0.13196931779384613,
0.40791767835617065,
0.08821932971477509,
0.3034209907054901,
0.20212729275226593,
0.2005554437637329,
-0.1323038935661316,
-0.6140562891960144,
-0.05648173391819,
0.21451039612293243,
-0.26700523495674133,
-0.22585168480873108,
0.37101954221725464,
0.21183806657791138,
-0.14896909892559052,
0.3571718633174896,
-0.010882538743317127,
-0.18281486630439758,
0.17353864014148712,
0.5573630928993225,
0.7858529090881348,
-0.04286454617977142,
0.12339780479669571,
-0.16044089198112488,
-0.034764353185892105,
-0.27598848938941956,
0.5786101818084717,
0.1612735241651535,
-0.8494107723236084,
-0.581419050693512,
-0.8106970191001892,
-0.3922526240348816,
0.14601105451583862,
-0.6243732571601868,
0.0384034663438797,
-0.3364225924015045,
-0.17872440814971924,
0.12877550721168518,
-0.3121843934059143,
-0.7418889403343201,
-0.30797532200813293,
-0.007070820312947035,
0.8395721316337585,
-0.7746784090995789,
0.9014239311218262,
0.7944265007972717,
-0.210989847779274,
-0.6656134128570557,
-0.05672469735145569,
-0.09409358352422714,
-0.9554355144500732,
0.653897225856781,
-0.40771484375,
-0.48471856117248535,
0.1927272379398346,
-0.3266090154647827,
-1.0342166423797607,
0.9308300614356995,
0.43827179074287415,
-0.3091624081134796,
-0.06429405510425568,
0.07108990103006363,
0.3707914352416992,
-0.2923067510128021,
-0.04605187848210335,
0.612312912940979,
0.49349263310432434,
0.22615256905555725,
-0.9456341862678528,
-0.12146637588739395,
-0.2352171391248703,
-0.026163090020418167,
0.1622312217950821,
-0.37010911107063293,
0.8380669951438904,
0.00045247841626405716,
0.12956693768501282,
0.3780726194381714,
0.26247966289520264,
0.45674780011177063,
-0.3288174867630005,
0.4735492765903473,
0.3636224567890167,
0.6632351875305176,
-0.04046260938048363,
0.9925020933151245,
0.11783640086650848,
-0.011997134424746037,
1.4934581518173218,
-0.6680709719657898,
1.0729278326034546,
0.6224343180656433,
0.15726564824581146,
0.5991011261940002,
0.38620609045028687,
0.23703181743621826,
0.8698040246963501,
0.07952442020177841,
-0.33666667342185974,
-0.1818723827600479,
-0.2771666944026947,
-0.07590417563915253,
0.6728363037109375,
0.33367204666137695,
-0.0009425412281416357,
-0.3129640817642212,
0.3661542534828186,
-0.0009582457132637501,
-0.06313718110322952,
-0.1750766932964325,
0.9154497981071472,
-0.1233915388584137,
-0.8959484100341797,
0.6437386870384216,
0.2213129699230194,
0.5549388527870178,
-0.6677412390708923,
-0.054607242345809937,
-0.432665079832077,
0.4394338130950928,
-0.2985202968120575,
-0.49746081233024597,
-0.2291327565908432,
0.07017414271831512,
-0.2656790316104889,
-0.07178550958633423,
0.7649372816085815,
-0.3669767677783966,
-0.43449896574020386,
0.32230210304260254,
0.8378069400787354,
-0.19975601136684418,
0.12392452359199524,
-0.4326978325843811,
0.6857321858406067,
-0.20656195282936096,
-0.19454863667488098,
0.5132099986076355,
0.452769011259079,
-0.0829801857471466,
0.5692665576934814,
0.4934585690498352,
0.12356121093034744,
0.09892863780260086,
0.5933937430381775,
1.117667317390442,
-0.4167979657649994,
-0.4646884500980377,
-0.568018913269043,
0.4316025972366333,
0.24851186573505402,
-0.00870819017291069,
0.5270031690597534,
0.36274823546409607,
0.4897196292877197,
-0.08531878888607025,
1.0239896774291992,
-0.1434139758348465,
0.6088380813598633,
-0.5853318572044373,
0.42082032561302185,
-0.48052629828453064,
0.27923130989074707,
-0.22007830440998077,
-1.039747714996338,
-0.2318827211856842,
0.5193601846694946,
-0.20876723527908325,
-0.02405695430934429,
0.588861882686615,
0.6487235426902771,
-0.6196813583374023,
-0.2152501344680786,
0.14494429528713226,
0.16944517195224762,
0.2609574794769287,
0.5143232345581055,
0.9235496520996094,
-0.26349762082099915,
0.17367935180664062,
0.14546695351600647,
0.0008044487913139164,
-0.5220511555671692,
-0.8255449533462524,
-0.777755081653595,
-0.16548916697502136,
-0.19199536740779877,
-0.18862585723400116,
0.1738804131746292,
0.9720402359962463,
0.7150837779045105,
-0.7305474281311035,
-0.3405190110206604,
0.22673529386520386,
0.0632290169596672,
-0.1310974508523941,
-0.14963002502918243,
0.14277569949626923,
-0.18201473355293274,
-0.6835227012634277,
0.9236947298049927,
0.24188293516635895,
-0.11859730631113052,
-0.2337770015001297,
-0.013273998163640499,
-0.19033384323120117,
0.07290871441364288,
0.8204220533370972,
0.5127272009849548,
-0.6737133264541626,
-0.27621349692344666,
0.014947484247386456,
-0.24995853006839752,
0.08205265551805496,
0.7158597111701965,
-0.8741384148597717,
0.2511817514896393,
0.4475530683994293,
1.0320531129837036,
0.4910924732685089,
-0.11363200098276138,
0.27418413758277893,
-0.88773113489151,
0.3058118224143982,
0.18462932109832764,
0.5117793679237366,
0.3730572760105133,
-0.11152768135070801,
0.3211272656917572,
-0.12794087827205658,
-0.28256574273109436,
-0.8720137476921082,
0.20823253691196442,
-1.2220219373703003,
-0.3208235800266266,
1.1946998834609985,
-0.007409046869724989,
-0.10772884637117386,
-0.058481499552726746,
-0.28277257084846497,
-0.2044820338487625,
-0.463152676820755,
0.2937788963317871,
0.338838666677475,
-0.10245326906442642,
-0.27519288659095764,
-0.4786395728588104,
0.09339867532253265,
0.3321434557437897,
-1.1240856647491455,
0.1674952507019043,
0.4625818133354187,
0.392917662858963,
-0.014383958652615547,
0.6870178580284119,
0.17768707871437073,
0.17626285552978516,
-0.4251466393470764,
-0.07161876559257507,
0.08450368791818619,
-0.13721369206905365,
-0.3467214107513428,
0.2116745412349701,
0.5730165839195251,
0.04877440631389618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09989v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09989v4 | LLMs as Bridges: Reformulating Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition | 2024-02-15T14:54:33 | 2024-05-29T16:59:59 | Jinyuan Li, Han Li, Di Sun, Jiahao Wang, Wenkun Zhang, Zan Wang, Gang Pan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (GMNER) is a nascent multimodal
task that aims to identify named entities, entity types and their corresponding
visual regions. GMNER task exhibits two challenging properties: 1) The weak
correlation between image-text pairs in social media results in a significant
portion of named entities being ungroundable. 2) There exists a distinction
between coarse-grained referring expressions commonly used in similar tasks
(e.g., phrase localization, referring expression comprehension) and
fine-grained named entities. In this paper, we propose RiVEG, a unified
framework that reformulates GMNER into a joint MNER-VE-VG task by leveraging
large language models (LLMs) as a connecting bridge. This reformulation brings
two benefits: 1) It maintains the optimal MNER performance and eliminates the
need for employing object detection methods to pre-extract regional features,
thereby naturally addressing two major limitations of existing GMNER methods.
2) The introduction of entity expansion expression and Visual Entailment (VE)
module unifies Visual Grounding (VG) and Entity Grounding (EG). It enables
RiVEG to effortlessly inherit the Visual Entailment and Visual Grounding
capabilities of any current or prospective multimodal pretraining models.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that RiVEG outperforms state-of-the-art
methods on the existing GMNER dataset and achieves absolute leads of 10.65%,
6.21%, and 8.83% in all three subtasks. | [
-0.5403300523757935,
-0.8192546367645264,
0.5025769472122192,
0.0017484856070950627,
-0.3473234474658966,
0.06449230015277863,
-0.3480653166770935,
-0.2657487690448761,
0.02684960700571537,
0.5342451333999634,
-0.5730738639831543,
-0.5304824113845825,
-0.8323448300361633,
-0.03610823303461075,
-0.1422347128391266,
0.9093511700630188,
-0.24657827615737915,
0.1419384628534317,
-0.3882739543914795,
-0.25195586681365967,
-0.6312497854232788,
-0.05193004757165909,
-0.6007156372070312,
-0.6060930490493774,
0.6498422622680664,
0.36211663484573364,
0.4632960557937622,
0.6738473773002625,
0.7271046042442322,
0.38675832748413086,
0.000034757562389131635,
0.3261004090309143,
-0.7187780141830444,
0.2788327932357788,
-0.30932822823524475,
-0.2991947531700134,
-0.3754071295261383,
-0.008795782923698425,
0.5989224910736084,
0.5695165395736694,
0.020518992096185684,
0.04135764390230179,
0.1004427894949913,
0.5888921022415161,
-0.534837543964386,
0.4316951632499695,
-0.8011085987091064,
-0.007998266257345676,
-0.2027001827955246,
-0.45163416862487793,
-0.27328604459762573,
0.07230166345834732,
0.04661211743950844,
-0.6405171751976013,
0.4089965224266052,
0.14784415066242218,
1.2581737041473389,
0.3368920683860779,
-0.6185377836227417,
-0.19335578382015228,
-0.5340495705604553,
0.668662428855896,
-0.34692463278770447,
0.7433966398239136,
-0.06801405549049377,
0.35562217235565186,
-0.3920418620109558,
-0.8515043258666992,
-0.406870573759079,
-0.3739638924598694,
-0.12555503845214844,
0.1636749505996704,
-0.09820200502872467,
0.34731993079185486,
0.29960161447525024,
0.5662180781364441,
-0.3634001910686493,
-0.06317483633756638,
-0.5092973113059998,
-0.08721613138914108,
0.3487749397754669,
0.05642054229974747,
0.44774436950683594,
-0.279483824968338,
-0.7435206174850464,
0.07089847326278687,
-0.7811425924301147,
0.18052329123020172,
-0.042360592633485794,
0.2626529633998871,
0.00043193571036681533,
0.7056452035903931,
-0.24026349186897278,
0.46733537316322327,
0.3527444899082184,
-0.41324150562286377,
0.33020567893981934,
-0.10407479107379913,
-0.4933709502220154,
-0.18636612594127655,
0.7130992412567139,
0.7372735738754272,
0.4555312693119049,
-0.48113614320755005,
-0.38887372612953186,
0.03926195576786995,
0.2909162938594818,
-0.7748593688011169,
-0.42039957642555237,
-0.20275911688804626,
-0.4007350206375122,
-0.15028293430805206,
0.21664372086524963,
-0.6975524425506592,
-0.5617768168449402,
-0.7001101970672607,
0.3057033121585846,
-0.4003804922103882,
-0.24822048842906952,
0.02217736467719078,
0.014189542271196842,
0.5182420015335083,
0.5839774012565613,
-0.5423449277877808,
0.07683280110359192,
0.6797653436660767,
0.7231888771057129,
-0.12002132833003998,
-0.1907367706298828,
-0.6073485612869263,
0.22980430722236633,
-0.05474367365241051,
0.7956957221031189,
-0.5215407609939575,
-0.4655897319316864,
-0.24333076179027557,
0.5923115611076355,
-0.15471039712429047,
-0.4335063099861145,
0.42526230216026306,
-0.6477341651916504,
0.07941235601902008,
-0.14696349203586578,
-0.48554250597953796,
-0.22080980241298676,
0.6057594418525696,
-0.6864523887634277,
0.7290998101234436,
-0.15379537642002106,
-0.8508902192115784,
0.44743186235427856,
-0.3240998387336731,
-0.23537640273571014,
0.09681450575590134,
-0.6010493040084839,
-0.3685532212257385,
0.12139376997947693,
0.47145381569862366,
0.6690320372581482,
-0.42637619376182556,
0.593767523765564,
-0.24701648950576782,
-0.2244948446750641,
-0.1334863156080246,
-0.34681886434555054,
0.27147427201271057,
-0.058022089302539825,
-0.12341973185539246,
0.2012178599834442,
-0.7479510307312012,
0.12581203877925873,
0.13032570481300354,
-0.6071435213088989,
-0.30723682045936584,
-0.11406674236059189,
0.14943400025367737,
0.13075070083141327,
-0.04952108860015869,
-0.3578405976295471,
0.22204017639160156,
-0.18641303479671478,
0.3566800653934479,
0.7510950565338135,
0.1861812174320221,
0.8365925550460815,
-0.1330087035894394,
0.6352772116661072,
0.22253195941448212,
-0.22707583010196686,
-0.5380592942237854,
-0.4059104919433594,
-1.0457252264022827,
-0.6046274304389954,
0.5003098249435425,
0.6298220753669739,
-0.9592536091804504,
0.07464157789945602,
-0.693290114402771,
-0.428067147731781,
-0.5865713953971863,
0.06979917734861374,
0.43492498993873596,
0.5245761275291443,
0.3951064944267273,
-0.13430611789226532,
-0.5536181926727295,
-1.0904513597488403,
-0.2919420003890991,
0.014206764288246632,
0.04154463857412338,
0.4352034032344818,
0.44540876150131226,
-0.5810597538948059,
1.0201610326766968,
-0.30587804317474365,
-0.47389042377471924,
-0.1707286387681961,
0.24758970737457275,
0.17590166628360748,
0.5521873831748962,
0.25059762597084045,
-1.1564621925354004,
-0.42756354808807373,
0.24015945196151733,
-0.8409427404403687,
0.011137858964502811,
-0.2697676420211792,
0.08045780658721924,
-0.3795715570449829,
0.839594841003418,
-0.7876689434051514,
0.23367655277252197,
0.4226813316345215,
-0.04814818128943443,
0.35631266236305237,
-0.07221904397010803,
0.23186036944389343,
-1.1452020406723022,
-0.23398901522159576,
0.16001878678798676,
-0.4141978919506073,
-0.6578047275543213,
0.3120712637901306,
0.02342303656041622,
-0.1698966920375824,
-0.2957944869995117,
0.7117618322372437,
-1.0408039093017578,
0.12292657047510147,
-0.31628257036209106,
0.25217798352241516,
0.007602022960782051,
0.3432433307170868,
-0.2682856619358063,
0.8038945198059082,
0.8899708390235901,
-0.5763165354728699,
0.5021328926086426,
-0.03438493609428406,
-0.07118269801139832,
0.5647748708724976,
-0.7952406406402588,
0.0587378665804863,
-0.723908007144928,
0.1351615935564041,
-0.9512753486633301,
-0.4161401689052582,
0.38428235054016113,
-0.5193210244178772,
0.6284135580062866,
-0.6709238886833191,
-0.2021539807319641,
0.004473119042813778,
-0.059131789952516556,
0.34265372157096863,
0.3730767071247101,
-0.5590553283691406,
1.3429937362670898,
0.39252108335494995,
-0.10044194012880325,
-0.5538633465766907,
-0.4994439482688904,
0.2407841682434082,
-0.38239115476608276,
-0.7307478785514832,
0.5600141286849976,
0.3537292778491974,
-0.1707558035850525,
0.20185302197933197,
-0.3026721477508545,
-0.020042814314365387,
-0.06714310497045517,
0.702268123626709,
0.20038698613643646,
-0.34131500124931335,
0.20346051454544067,
-0.25497546792030334,
-0.45806747674942017,
-0.07123252749443054,
-0.0066253188997507095,
0.3375689387321472,
-0.2567555010318756,
-0.4572410583496094,
-0.10679453611373901,
0.24728147685527802,
0.690706729888916,
-0.5547755360603333,
0.4304238557815552,
0.8524332046508789,
-0.40540921688079834,
0.007971268147230148,
-0.6820406317710876,
-0.027460306882858276,
-0.468116819858551,
0.34798121452331543,
-0.8404194712638855,
-1.3262522220611572,
0.4139255881309509,
-0.5456085205078125,
0.03271402418613434,
0.2912265956401825,
0.3479003310203552,
-0.18952161073684692,
0.5701457262039185,
0.8206573724746704,
-0.004889386706054211,
0.376797616481781,
-0.06720404326915741,
0.4954884946346283,
-0.9205836653709412,
-0.44863104820251465,
-0.09061052650213242,
-0.28471559286117554,
-0.8193576335906982,
-0.7041232585906982,
0.17646414041519165,
0.4667602777481079,
0.2639714479446411,
0.31745094060897827,
-0.24335120618343353,
0.5455154776573181,
0.3599252998828888,
0.07043763995170593,
0.0850273072719574,
0.022006571292877197,
-0.23042577505111694,
-0.29684320092201233,
-0.3625141978263855,
-0.6018479466438293,
0.852997362613678,
0.5370733141899109,
0.9468333125114441,
-0.09661338478326797,
0.7800002694129944,
0.17855075001716614,
0.5267561674118042,
-0.9599723219871521,
0.7281743288040161,
0.08948539197444916,
-0.3559308350086212,
-0.02566930651664734,
-0.2921491861343384,
-0.7834082245826721,
0.6674584746360779,
-0.41912174224853516,
-0.6220026612281799,
0.16132372617721558,
0.21036197245121002,
-0.005335177760571241,
0.2636573910713196,
-0.6000797152519226,
0.8172134757041931,
-0.06826882809400558,
-0.1828296035528183,
0.09907438606023788,
-0.49348801374435425,
0.4707968831062317,
0.10653343796730042,
0.23931261897087097,
-0.22186104953289032,
0.13791118562221527,
0.4469538927078247,
0.16258546710014343,
0.7376144528388977,
-0.2600487172603607,
0.01709797792136669,
0.127886563539505,
-0.13228069245815277,
0.7037425637245178,
0.2224244773387909,
0.6036362051963806,
0.061588678508996964,
-0.611714243888855,
-0.0829465389251709,
-0.716984748840332,
0.8405935764312744,
-0.3880842626094818,
-0.7765900492668152,
-0.3089209794998169,
-0.4226910471916199,
-0.1288457214832306,
0.35112684965133667,
0.09981843084096909,
0.29175513982772827,
-0.22846025228500366,
0.5413946509361267,
0.979820728302002,
0.051845114678144455,
0.060001812875270844,
0.32022079825401306,
-0.36985740065574646,
-0.7000138759613037,
0.7055644392967224,
-0.10716168582439423,
-0.06741448491811752,
0.39990317821502686,
-0.3106214106082916,
-0.13324779272079468,
-0.45832765102386475,
-0.3210310935974121,
0.4258735477924347,
-0.8831436038017273,
-0.120494544506073,
-0.9830652475357056,
-0.2429760992527008,
-0.29090988636016846,
-0.25280091166496277,
-0.2943062484264374,
0.1116635799407959,
-0.30126968026161194,
-0.28445449471473694,
0.0560198649764061,
0.44667017459869385,
0.15571731328964233,
0.330036997795105,
-0.7220327258110046,
0.7696091532707214,
0.41774070262908936,
0.11045774072408676,
-0.3513603210449219,
-0.5382835268974304,
-0.00023570648045279086,
-0.12426895648241043,
-0.03901582211256027,
-0.8430060148239136,
-0.001197303761728108,
0.1675320416688919,
0.7296139001846313,
0.6279747486114502,
-0.3184962570667267,
1.1219136714935303,
-1.0551657676696777,
0.39087042212486267,
0.40152278542518616,
-0.5667201280593872,
0.3355196416378021,
-0.3221936523914337,
-0.0020037987269461155,
0.4914420545101166,
0.3036780059337616,
-0.6459237933158875,
-0.1442302018404007,
-0.43146076798439026,
-1.1464314460754395,
0.27517348527908325,
0.15562310814857483,
0.23498748242855072,
-0.043878208845853806,
0.28263047337532043,
-0.22000907361507416,
0.04405662417411804,
-1.02687668800354,
-0.2258497178554535,
-0.010601690039038658,
-0.01805366761982441,
-0.11544249951839447,
-0.40416911244392395,
-0.17154724895954132,
-0.06909676641225815,
0.4941840171813965,
-0.10813093930482864,
0.2903127670288086,
0.07845042645931244,
-0.3445531725883484,
0.2013145238161087,
0.5760898590087891,
0.344109445810318,
0.40589621663093567,
-0.04719085991382599,
0.34928005933761597,
0.16216997802257538,
-0.2212885022163391,
0.25456497073173523,
0.11392917484045029,
-0.252713143825531,
0.21124820411205292,
0.4371451139450073,
0.9002333879470825,
0.5047202110290527,
-0.5078134536743164,
0.47321903705596924,
0.03252306580543518,
-0.17305882275104523,
-0.3250367343425751,
0.1067710816860199,
0.23785120248794556,
0.5222329497337341,
0.1848670095205307,
0.19773757457733154,
0.041535813361406326,
-0.2468620091676712,
0.36074844002723694,
0.5449663400650024,
-0.5528624057769775,
-0.16004961729049683,
0.5784732103347778,
0.1746462732553482,
-0.13008937239646912,
0.4728350043296814,
-0.2544621527194977,
-0.4233538508415222,
0.41103219985961914,
0.48920801281929016,
1.0138684511184692,
-0.06264771521091461,
-0.06120253726840019,
0.39292582869529724,
0.4994056820869446,
-0.21294082701206207,
0.1375662237405777,
-0.010331766679883003,
-0.8774901628494263,
-0.3535676896572113,
-0.4816701114177704,
0.03429489955306053,
0.22010394930839539,
-0.6922368407249451,
0.3836452066898346,
-0.3609575927257538,
-0.36190471053123474,
0.010322343558073044,
-0.5756149291992188,
-0.8322168588638306,
0.46696797013282776,
0.30759197473526,
0.7321711182594299,
-0.8368064761161804,
0.5835220217704773,
1.2911632061004639,
-0.3605503737926483,
-0.6312770843505859,
0.09847508370876312,
0.08327198028564453,
-0.5859181880950928,
0.9285538792610168,
0.5215530395507812,
-0.35086485743522644,
0.2322026789188385,
-0.37160128355026245,
-0.9330502152442932,
1.425154209136963,
0.09698688983917236,
-0.6054204702377319,
-0.32094231247901917,
-0.08155317604541779,
0.13458438217639923,
-0.5910259485244751,
0.13353200256824493,
0.11491197347640991,
0.5926823616027832,
0.07298120856285095,
-0.7488198280334473,
-0.022752773016691208,
-0.23666508495807648,
0.43556544184684753,
0.4000297784805298,
-0.3977518677711487,
0.8390583395957947,
-0.23366375267505646,
-0.6523978114128113,
-0.24614305794239044,
0.9496392011642456,
0.2931906580924988,
0.20191393792629242,
0.6696029305458069,
0.87726891040802,
0.624386191368103,
-0.32650017738342285,
0.5858309864997864,
-0.18422548472881317,
0.5527713894844055,
1.1263182163238525,
-0.21201950311660767,
0.5188243985176086,
0.7388489842414856,
0.10345742851495743,
0.18161402642726898,
0.28679898381233215,
-0.13810577988624573,
0.734021782875061,
0.2740115523338318,
-0.24891501665115356,
-0.5137999653816223,
-0.12779340147972107,
-0.2345210313796997,
0.5528331995010376,
0.23796024918556213,
-0.4261479675769806,
-0.7742226123809814,
0.28906598687171936,
0.20008866488933563,
-0.0031928671523928642,
-0.38965433835983276,
0.6175950169563293,
0.1512160301208496,
-0.24095213413238525,
0.2990627884864807,
0.35898345708847046,
0.7417696714401245,
-0.3934004604816437,
-0.24444690346717834,
0.001390285324305296,
0.24909134209156036,
-0.04968518763780594,
-0.6531435251235962,
-0.0043034423142671585,
0.014527694322168827,
-0.3597985506057739,
-0.3743324875831604,
1.1738373041152954,
-0.5884847044944763,
-0.3285449743270874,
0.4036669135093689,
0.5890244841575623,
0.047905437648296356,
-0.09361931681632996,
-0.7530685067176819,
-0.06771788746118546,
0.09044423699378967,
-0.42468321323394775,
0.09458129107952118,
0.7600269317626953,
-0.09075315296649933,
0.9261457920074463,
0.6999544501304626,
-0.1918354481458664,
0.22210583090782166,
0.1478419303894043,
1.2085894346237183,
-0.7220653295516968,
-0.2555992901325226,
-0.9300462603569031,
0.8644352555274963,
-0.012362027540802956,
-0.0780719667673111,
0.8405481576919556,
0.42833176255226135,
0.9519473910331726,
-0.28455451130867004,
0.5796040892601013,
-0.1899120807647705,
0.2302478402853012,
-0.8445371985435486,
0.5600592494010925,
-0.5225504636764526,
-0.07021982222795486,
-0.185575470328331,
-0.9668962359428406,
-0.23822614550590515,
0.5440492630004883,
-0.30054163932800293,
0.051763493567705154,
0.6125529408454895,
0.9256085753440857,
-0.5256643891334534,
-0.4699026048183441,
0.49478796124458313,
0.11037248373031616,
0.4904245436191559,
0.33817747235298157,
0.8721137642860413,
-0.4873141348361969,
0.2864198386669159,
0.05535835400223732,
-0.13651837408542633,
-0.18619777262210846,
-0.9649112224578857,
-1.188819169998169,
-0.40498584508895874,
-0.4518835246562958,
-0.14212335646152496,
0.09713570773601532,
0.9651690125465393,
0.7022573351860046,
-0.6563367247581482,
0.2490955889225006,
-0.04751066863536835,
-0.10351161658763885,
0.1979127675294876,
-0.2659904658794403,
-0.03655814379453659,
-0.40661731362342834,
-0.5446500778198242,
0.6627374887466431,
0.4635724723339081,
0.030639106407761574,
-0.14089585840702057,
-0.06211245805025101,
-0.046087756752967834,
-0.16427406668663025,
0.5240001678466797,
0.10496046394109726,
-1.0968555212020874,
-0.23455263674259186,
0.003099593333899975,
-0.10002521425485611,
0.10159774869680405,
0.8608064651489258,
-0.7507747411727905,
0.4083053469657898,
0.24955902993679047,
0.9955592751502991,
0.2940748929977417,
0.36052700877189636,
0.23998482525348663,
-0.7776857614517212,
0.1289072185754776,
0.07115183770656586,
0.7427228093147278,
0.4387585520744324,
-0.13624487817287445,
0.35751432180404663,
0.4717653691768646,
-0.49044451117515564,
-0.6524195671081543,
0.4686910808086395,
-1.0283758640289307,
0.12859906256198883,
1.1412577629089355,
-0.3711089491844177,
-0.21830648183822632,
0.09704791754484177,
-0.28480568528175354,
0.07978542149066925,
-0.24387146532535553,
0.3329969644546509,
0.7034194469451904,
0.2357480674982071,
-0.764825701713562,
-0.6400455236434937,
0.17034165561199188,
-0.03854646533727646,
-0.6236541271209717,
-0.14552441239356995,
0.6636784672737122,
0.6172353625297546,
0.2413078099489212,
0.688542902469635,
-0.08949771523475647,
0.00663395319133997,
-0.18615686893463135,
0.36483848094940186,
-0.3511711359024048,
-0.626385509967804,
-0.26706117391586304,
0.2259397804737091,
-0.10407082736492157,
-0.36502212285995483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09977v1 | Fast Vocabulary Transfer for Language Model Compression | 2024-02-15T14:37:07 | 2024-02-15T14:37:07 | Leonidas Gee, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Paolo Torroni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Real-world business applications require a trade-off between language model
performance and size. We propose a new method for model compression that relies
on vocabulary transfer. We evaluate the method on various vertical domains and
downstream tasks. Our results indicate that vocabulary transfer can be
effectively used in combination with other compression techniques, yielding a
significant reduction in model size and inference time while marginally
compromising on performance. | [
-0.504111111164093,
-0.6976296901702881,
0.08231110870838165,
0.43429386615753174,
-0.27132782340049744,
0.012332177720963955,
-0.23726223409175873,
-0.9666506052017212,
0.1438971608877182,
0.571483850479126,
-0.32351091504096985,
0.10353033989667892,
-0.6770563125610352,
-0.33751094341278076,
-0.5931617021560669,
0.5086012482643127,
0.193081796169281,
-0.33239755034446716,
-0.1850990653038025,
0.20330359041690826,
-0.6832553744316101,
-0.7287210822105408,
-1.0663491487503052,
-0.3576525151729584,
0.18071900308132172,
0.1780095249414444,
0.9638652205467224,
0.6643238067626953,
0.8008190393447876,
0.26411357522010803,
-0.10703766345977783,
-0.06770338863134384,
-0.4245401620864868,
0.0036987229250371456,
-0.4484975039958954,
-0.30469226837158203,
-0.568179726600647,
-0.14408062398433685,
0.6729592680931091,
0.9046040177345276,
-0.26314955949783325,
0.5842232704162598,
-0.21256496012210846,
0.5927128195762634,
-0.7496742010116577,
0.13540752232074738,
-0.5269480347633362,
0.0524224154651165,
-0.15290962159633636,
-0.24017204344272614,
-0.5624412298202515,
-0.12436369061470032,
0.25103580951690674,
-0.4112399220466614,
0.05553480237722397,
0.20569095015525818,
1.255642056465149,
0.16450439393520355,
-0.15207701921463013,
0.10247557610273361,
-0.9337480664253235,
0.7628898620605469,
-0.6148814558982849,
0.42954742908477783,
0.2547740638256073,
0.4336051046848297,
0.32828202843666077,
-1.004287600517273,
-0.6087315678596497,
-0.16133210062980652,
0.09918642789125443,
-0.21151810884475708,
-0.3928849995136261,
0.022350406274199486,
0.29843375086784363,
0.2682686150074005,
-0.35546553134918213,
0.2464761883020401,
-0.6465146541595459,
-0.228290855884552,
0.6064949035644531,
-0.03386371582746506,
0.2574980854988098,
0.02440992183983326,
-0.541026771068573,
-0.3638381063938141,
-0.7080902457237244,
-0.09187255054712296,
0.146427720785141,
0.4821241497993469,
0.10378856211900711,
0.32616057991981506,
-0.02843794971704483,
1.1620042324066162,
-0.46440237760543823,
-0.28636643290519714,
-0.2322232574224472,
-0.4810112714767456,
-0.4000176191329956,
0.005930291023105383,
0.3808281123638153,
0.4538300633430481,
0.2777599096298218,
-0.21989135444164276,
-0.2709617614746094,
0.22138379514217377,
0.28847360610961914,
-1.117795467376709,
-0.3200104534626007,
0.07291856408119202,
-0.6368651986122131,
-0.1684398055076599,
-0.15720535814762115,
-0.9222471714019775,
0.055137768387794495,
-0.2860047519207001,
0.6523242592811584,
-0.09287452697753906,
-0.10211112350225449,
0.5017395615577698,
-0.4439522624015808,
0.03489745035767555,
0.2830176055431366,
-0.7736011147499084,
0.7424514889717102,
0.5037142038345337,
1.3432461023330688,
-0.10709396004676819,
-0.035573411732912064,
-0.684128999710083,
0.32978555560112,
-0.25451117753982544,
0.8993121981620789,
-0.37478020787239075,
-0.36527711153030396,
-0.1496111899614334,
-0.2649606466293335,
0.003866380313411355,
-0.5777738094329834,
0.45400866866111755,
-0.4172452986240387,
-0.09714734554290771,
0.017629263922572136,
-0.68100506067276,
-0.07729382067918777,
-0.03126030042767525,
-0.7410029768943787,
0.8943334221839905,
0.3173370659351349,
-0.33421215415000916,
0.09048276394605637,
-0.47272396087646484,
-0.6205401420593262,
0.13350825011730194,
0.30320975184440613,
0.044482845813035965,
0.12016839534044266,
0.1066083014011383,
0.6609134674072266,
-0.5170655846595764,
-0.2693186104297638,
-0.2411651760339737,
-0.37662097811698914,
0.13728521764278412,
-0.14975674450397491,
0.6755209565162659,
0.5674140453338623,
0.1050049364566803,
-0.3609049618244171,
-0.7275167107582092,
0.0450158528983593,
0.029149388894438744,
-0.26219961047172546,
-0.6971638798713684,
-0.2901609539985657,
0.22200678288936615,
0.44995659589767456,
0.3498494625091553,
-0.381382554769516,
0.7082458138465881,
-0.2813619375228882,
0.46022331714630127,
0.5300469994544983,
-0.29960137605667114,
0.634586751461029,
-0.49643218517303467,
0.7647766470909119,
-0.3291158378124237,
0.07738896459341049,
0.4708370864391327,
-0.3873479664325714,
-0.8218297958374023,
-0.4883725345134735,
0.8872364163398743,
0.6526750922203064,
-0.8633487224578857,
0.26862096786499023,
-0.8369026184082031,
-0.6306739449501038,
-0.5400785207748413,
-0.06381852179765701,
0.21561841666698456,
0.43840378522872925,
0.35067111253738403,
-0.6191907525062561,
-0.4155406951904297,
-0.9895913600921631,
-0.4201693832874298,
-0.14022916555404663,
-0.10376298427581787,
0.30701592564582825,
0.26167890429496765,
0.24451111257076263,
0.727630615234375,
-0.674282968044281,
-0.26055198907852173,
-0.6001896262168884,
0.5662055015563965,
0.11541199684143066,
0.6196587085723877,
0.7958185076713562,
-0.7721338272094727,
-0.3904777467250824,
-0.10825684666633606,
0.05055377259850502,
-0.2677280604839325,
-0.506328821182251,
-0.22893713414669037,
0.05851426348090172,
0.5571103096008301,
-1.0010842084884644,
0.37301376461982727,
1.0076123476028442,
-0.3639528453350067,
0.5043262243270874,
-0.2629207372665405,
-0.0958610326051712,
-1.1820940971374512,
0.06549309939146042,
-0.1162605807185173,
-0.4765181839466095,
-0.7780314087867737,
0.2272072732448578,
0.08183830231428146,
-0.032223884016275406,
-0.8304293155670166,
0.9753482937812805,
-0.7100685238838196,
-0.30577054619789124,
-0.2582486867904663,
0.14919163286685944,
0.07742412388324738,
0.14979702234268188,
0.10496603697538376,
1.1004397869110107,
0.6026245355606079,
-1.0785456895828247,
0.254765123128891,
0.4014795124530792,
-0.656554639339447,
0.38284704089164734,
-0.48234179615974426,
0.07706237584352493,
0.09961476176977158,
0.1739625185728073,
-0.6450133919715881,
0.12188775837421417,
-0.09975357353687286,
-0.28198859095573425,
0.588356077671051,
-0.39499521255493164,
-0.5208551287651062,
-0.4138086140155792,
-0.08778457343578339,
0.2210717648267746,
0.8514506816864014,
-0.5176270008087158,
0.4593309462070465,
0.32910850644111633,
-0.2313036322593689,
-0.332224577665329,
-1.3594813346862793,
0.44679373502731323,
-0.28726544976234436,
-0.8147487640380859,
0.9283023476600647,
-0.011454036459326744,
-0.1748555302619934,
0.07924839854240417,
-0.11174590140581131,
-0.4108063876628876,
0.19844022393226624,
-0.36866438388824463,
0.2680976092815399,
-0.062417030334472656,
0.1326507180929184,
0.028560234233736992,
0.19860361516475677,
-0.15001386404037476,
-0.35428300499916077,
0.44931742548942566,
0.13882564008235931,
0.19734840095043182,
-0.4054116904735565,
0.3286123275756836,
0.5989297032356262,
-0.06566967815160751,
1.219810962677002,
0.3618713617324829,
-0.34513333439826965,
-0.3866090476512909,
-0.2842811942100525,
-0.23930241167545319,
-0.48007136583328247,
0.3089153468608856,
-0.537231981754303,
-0.8040460348129272,
0.4787972569465637,
-0.40935012698173523,
-0.131654754281044,
0.24597950279712677,
0.3570488691329956,
0.49654504656791687,
0.8645917773246765,
0.978806734085083,
-0.23284131288528442,
0.6518873572349548,
-0.3118560314178467,
0.7468030452728271,
-0.5034717917442322,
0.20570220053195953,
-0.891689121723175,
-0.2807835638523102,
-0.29252341389656067,
-0.5838596820831299,
-0.1070970743894577,
0.2996010184288025,
0.12894275784492493,
0.7957631945610046,
-0.3607400059700012,
0.3222958743572235,
0.31986746191978455,
-0.27748042345046997,
0.1899704784154892,
0.2460283786058426,
0.2141469419002533,
0.11209079623222351,
-0.9361485838890076,
-0.26760557293891907,
0.597080409526825,
0.25920021533966064,
0.8077196478843689,
0.6716311573982239,
0.2549622058868408,
0.41953790187835693,
0.2963518798351288,
-1.187170147895813,
0.601767361164093,
-0.4759131371974945,
-0.46707457304000854,
-0.22146372497081757,
-0.6479799747467041,
-1.1185232400894165,
0.25101473927497864,
-0.1616206169128418,
-0.982145369052887,
0.07135242223739624,
0.06359568238258362,
-0.5671542882919312,
0.3352496922016144,
-0.8441108465194702,
0.6643348932266235,
0.10573738068342209,
-0.27231550216674805,
-0.24477466940879822,
-0.47925710678100586,
0.3867879807949066,
-0.1008373275399208,
0.40817487239837646,
-0.08047284185886383,
-0.16293196380138397,
0.776219367980957,
-0.595859944820404,
0.5356382727622986,
0.14334294199943542,
0.011825778521597385,
0.019113225862383842,
0.519086480140686,
0.4652271568775177,
-0.4115539789199829,
-0.027594273909926414,
0.35593387484550476,
0.1621069759130478,
-0.49163153767585754,
-0.9193553924560547,
0.43223831057548523,
-0.2935919463634491,
-0.3784438371658325,
-0.23786240816116333,
-0.797817587852478,
-0.2604478597640991,
0.10502614825963974,
0.19480600953102112,
0.5349530577659607,
0.13892336189746857,
0.1613616794347763,
0.33317455649375916,
0.09441690891981125,
0.45774176716804504,
0.21282094717025757,
-0.06224871799349785,
0.25982725620269775,
0.7431715130805969,
0.3956871032714844,
0.558012068271637,
0.525312602519989,
0.24241381883621216,
-0.32191210985183716,
-0.6770763993263245,
-0.47702667117118835,
0.0985528752207756,
-0.6029682159423828,
-0.44679033756256104,
-0.4208388328552246,
-0.30847224593162537,
-0.6732463240623474,
-0.4108871519565582,
-0.7573904395103455,
-0.8399970531463623,
-0.08598659187555313,
0.2384788542985916,
0.44267651438713074,
0.48285773396492004,
-0.05615570768713951,
0.5622380375862122,
-1.3304368257522583,
0.2733649015426636,
0.12263274937868118,
0.22698907554149628,
-0.03307473659515381,
-0.8316358327865601,
-0.35515689849853516,
-0.23892106115818024,
0.17829616367816925,
-0.8456424474716187,
0.9200491309165955,
0.662781298160553,
0.3720414936542511,
0.22812260687351227,
0.22360111773014069,
0.8575214147567749,
-0.3226955235004425,
1.0397789478302002,
0.18433643877506256,
-1.2311652898788452,
0.2125847488641739,
0.17901989817619324,
0.14277362823486328,
0.2890832722187042,
0.6033843755722046,
-0.6141484975814819,
0.026330066844820976,
-0.6439951658248901,
-1.015751838684082,
0.40302297472953796,
0.22872906923294067,
0.28469446301460266,
0.08286746591329575,
0.5095199942588806,
-0.08306268602609634,
0.11463789641857147,
-0.23776067793369293,
-0.11768121272325516,
0.406725138425827,
0.024645930156111717,
-0.03083144500851631,
-0.09266655147075653,
0.06880971789360046,
-0.5012369751930237,
0.5463315844535828,
-0.24637208878993988,
0.6155271530151367,
0.15279553830623627,
-0.1654481738805771,
0.30964231491088867,
0.14693409204483032,
0.5179874897003174,
0.6008830666542053,
-0.07568565756082535,
0.27772530913352966,
0.10660979896783829,
-0.5527148842811584,
0.12067704647779465,
0.007442330941557884,
0.04775730520486832,
-0.0709618404507637,
0.30027884244918823,
0.7860708832740784,
0.1751294881105423,
-0.7017139792442322,
0.500335156917572,
-0.1650102436542511,
-0.26054710149765015,
0.1408514529466629,
-0.04658917337656021,
0.004583682399243116,
0.11752747744321823,
-0.1950872838497162,
0.29492616653442383,
0.42189663648605347,
-0.5890920758247375,
0.01675334759056568,
0.1791771799325943,
-0.09309542179107666,
-0.07257746905088425,
0.358266681432724,
-0.07845122367143631,
-0.28056684136390686,
0.7071855068206787,
-0.021413981914520264,
-0.500340461730957,
0.4264307916164398,
0.5848639607429504,
0.6250728368759155,
-0.27157503366470337,
-0.11163633316755295,
0.20131684839725494,
0.19183732569217682,
-0.6206340789794922,
0.24530653655529022,
-0.05133747681975365,
-0.7648817300796509,
-0.959589421749115,
-0.602508544921875,
-0.5958250761032104,
0.13260038197040558,
-0.798109769821167,
0.2689795196056366,
-0.24263383448123932,
-0.3895564079284668,
0.1351936012506485,
-0.12614208459854126,
-0.6311522126197815,
0.02911987714469433,
0.17771995067596436,
1.394266128540039,
-0.6310479640960693,
1.0918035507202148,
0.4850568473339081,
-0.2651846706867218,
-0.8814592361450195,
-0.22912615537643433,
-0.1779819130897522,
-0.4129566252231598,
1.0015333890914917,
-0.10335154831409454,
-0.42985183000564575,
-0.0020455406047403812,
-0.451645165681839,
-1.1829402446746826,
0.668975293636322,
0.44735831022262573,
-0.5187215209007263,
-0.1186162456870079,
-0.21495376527309418,
0.4836339056491852,
-0.3065366744995117,
-0.2053106725215912,
0.6288433074951172,
0.45267170667648315,
0.2140093445777893,
-1.2244001626968384,
0.1985366940498352,
-0.08076081424951553,
0.3588695228099823,
0.12919564545154572,
-0.5459946990013123,
1.0245312452316284,
0.25475549697875977,
-0.26413682103157043,
0.32734718918800354,
0.8271888494491577,
-0.21658183634281158,
-0.26697680354118347,
0.5482515692710876,
0.47544386982917786,
0.7947983145713806,
0.3085481822490692,
1.4361870288848877,
-0.49982184171676636,
0.45690906047821045,
0.9044218063354492,
-0.29771170020103455,
1.328663945198059,
0.6210262179374695,
-0.21163111925125122,
0.4201129078865051,
0.3794149160385132,
0.1844320446252823,
0.42516764998435974,
0.5418547987937927,
-0.1577119529247284,
-0.26516661047935486,
-0.3221167027950287,
-0.28531643748283386,
0.632997989654541,
0.5557093024253845,
0.019983232021331787,
0.039735402911901474,
-0.08743643760681152,
0.21561236679553986,
-0.16988548636436462,
-0.2751910388469696,
0.220228910446167,
0.058337774127721786,
-0.841122567653656,
0.8347361087799072,
0.2508092522621155,
0.8739644885063171,
-0.6637028455734253,
-0.06901690363883972,
-0.03320373594760895,
0.23575140535831451,
0.19191573560237885,
-0.5776242613792419,
0.7464805841445923,
-0.24197886884212494,
0.16993631422519684,
-0.7138871550559998,
1.1410211324691772,
-0.4782705307006836,
-0.16273516416549683,
0.45282217860221863,
0.5464563965797424,
0.5537455081939697,
-0.231600821018219,
-0.6364657878875732,
-0.05937035009264946,
-0.4034379720687866,
-0.2790038287639618,
0.41611507534980774,
0.11391999572515488,
-0.1304907500743866,
0.7939424514770508,
0.8390731811523438,
0.6834194660186768,
0.15748201310634613,
0.1265050321817398,
0.7743379473686218,
-0.4889977276325226,
-0.6806817650794983,
-0.4696378707885742,
-0.02595626190304756,
-0.2561658024787903,
-0.1453741490840912,
0.8176727890968323,
0.258558988571167,
0.8376996517181396,
-0.07125437259674072,
0.597565770149231,
-0.14882463216781616,
0.3197731673717499,
-0.8806819319725037,
0.7851190567016602,
-0.6604878902435303,
0.10446455329656601,
-0.11869365721940994,
-0.8429145812988281,
-0.46904584765434265,
0.7745879888534546,
-0.028087155893445015,
-0.1352706104516983,
0.798201322555542,
0.6191995143890381,
-0.13674518465995789,
-0.2895868420600891,
0.5431311726570129,
0.1341177076101303,
0.20351558923721313,
0.46140870451927185,
0.4274228811264038,
-0.44523003697395325,
0.5158918499946594,
-0.45788514614105225,
-0.1932695060968399,
-0.349662184715271,
-1.2931932210922241,
-0.553563117980957,
-0.46248167753219604,
-0.6230804920196533,
-0.5502768754959106,
0.0032940669916570187,
0.7081237435340881,
1.3421072959899902,
-0.38508445024490356,
-0.42877092957496643,
-0.0017499164678156376,
-0.13416101038455963,
-0.6573694944381714,
-0.23012317717075348,
0.2970559000968933,
-0.13576219975948334,
-0.7558160424232483,
0.36969539523124695,
0.10980768501758575,
0.1566830426454544,
-0.2646043002605438,
0.11991920322179794,
-0.28791680932044983,
0.6004632115364075,
0.8644130825996399,
0.2679789066314697,
-0.3481074273586273,
-0.37700024247169495,
-0.16099591553211212,
0.09229977428913116,
-0.21238504350185394,
1.1307660341262817,
-0.7465894818305969,
0.09886156767606735,
0.9309532046318054,
0.8242336511611938,
0.6256751418113708,
-0.15885601937770844,
0.6294516921043396,
-1.0200165510177612,
0.5832771062850952,
0.11782181262969971,
0.34910595417022705,
0.24417950212955475,
-0.560617208480835,
0.5427472591400146,
0.4250040352344513,
-0.24948829412460327,
-0.6525107622146606,
0.25885772705078125,
-1.1910027265548706,
-0.7996978163719177,
1.1577874422073364,
-0.12412337958812714,
-0.5129284858703613,
-0.04059306159615517,
-0.18753844499588013,
0.11582333594560623,
-0.283307284116745,
0.47108614444732666,
0.9507333636283875,
-0.11930475383996964,
-0.24396705627441406,
-0.7940739989280701,
0.5058343410491943,
0.4897606074810028,
-0.8529891967773438,
0.08204733580350876,
0.204865500330925,
-0.08460037410259247,
0.25152966380119324,
0.5024013519287109,
0.11809074878692627,
0.2050115466117859,
0.32974788546562195,
0.41684791445732117,
0.030892033129930496,
-0.5234507918357849,
-0.4394282102584839,
0.18650731444358826,
0.12783123552799225,
-0.02941998839378357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09967v1 | Case Study: Testing Model Capabilities in Some Reasoning Tasks | 2024-02-15T14:21:30 | 2024-02-15T14:21:30 | Min Zhang, Sato Takumi, Jack Zhang, Jun Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in generating personalized content and
facilitating interactive dialogues, showcasing their remarkable aptitude for a
myriad of applications. However, their capabilities in reasoning and providing
explainable outputs, especially within the context of reasoning abilities,
remain areas for improvement. In this study, we delve into the reasoning
abilities of LLMs, highlighting the current challenges and limitations that
hinder their effectiveness in complex reasoning scenarios. | [
-0.4418737590312958,
-0.7146354913711548,
1.17648446559906,
0.020045863464474678,
0.10868801176548004,
0.19061627984046936,
-0.36630964279174805,
-0.29133710265159607,
-0.34569650888442993,
0.7178987264633179,
-0.5412220358848572,
-0.27229902148246765,
-0.7232078313827515,
0.34948232769966125,
-0.6077548265457153,
0.5759092569351196,
-0.3575201630592346,
0.04488484561443329,
-0.4376046657562256,
-0.052812688052654266,
-0.5996955037117004,
-0.7298332452774048,
-0.7485511898994446,
-0.4752287268638611,
0.5094726085662842,
0.6669214963912964,
0.8239564895629883,
0.20094797015190125,
0.42172279953956604,
0.3740825653076172,
-0.09935033321380615,
0.41814732551574707,
-0.37711045145988464,
0.47249412536621094,
-0.2587762475013733,
-0.6387670636177063,
-0.2618768811225891,
-0.22318121790885925,
0.7068759202957153,
0.8327018618583679,
-0.06823047995567322,
0.03293038532137871,
-0.24418824911117554,
0.4123837947845459,
-0.16593067348003387,
0.17759297788143158,
-0.7874643206596375,
-0.15081073343753815,
-0.13279679417610168,
-0.07049983739852905,
-0.47662827372550964,
-0.1907763034105301,
0.15212517976760864,
-0.3066863715648651,
-0.0300945695489645,
0.13264146447181702,
0.8671376705169678,
0.17685894668102264,
-0.6060266494750977,
-0.5973308086395264,
-1.1242576837539673,
0.8861218690872192,
-0.9988168478012085,
0.2935161292552948,
0.29660454392433167,
0.6650886535644531,
-0.40288031101226807,
-0.5870974659919739,
-0.4694516062736511,
-0.5954344868659973,
0.05587596818804741,
-0.28051549196243286,
-0.1147313341498375,
-0.025907237082719803,
0.5190802216529846,
0.37459108233451843,
-0.36531659960746765,
0.4070236384868622,
-0.1519135683774948,
-0.07853846997022629,
0.7968332767486572,
0.5028628706932068,
0.3807459771633148,
-0.14503756165504456,
0.22145582735538483,
0.21378859877586365,
-0.7016070485115051,
0.06646996736526489,
0.36774665117263794,
0.13389945030212402,
0.0905517041683197,
0.9850680232048035,
-0.09471794962882996,
0.8056686520576477,
-0.38533836603164673,
-0.29881611466407776,
-0.2650696635246277,
-0.1277228593826294,
-0.32462820410728455,
-0.26150089502334595,
0.36582791805267334,
-0.021354151889681816,
0.4482058584690094,
-0.024920770898461342,
-0.29418447613716125,
-0.25434431433677673,
0.07869140058755875,
-0.5739986896514893,
0.08063438534736633,
0.4170418083667755,
-0.3918132781982422,
0.21521969139575958,
-0.12795859575271606,
-0.3694216012954712,
-0.4728908836841583,
-0.45063209533691406,
0.3952849507331848,
-0.3411804437637329,
-0.22789238393306732,
0.2902417778968811,
-0.21908466517925262,
0.3089869022369385,
0.5599887371063232,
-0.9235957264900208,
0.26440125703811646,
0.7082550525665283,
0.5736709833145142,
-0.21632206439971924,
-0.08267055451869965,
-0.3344186246395111,
0.24382604658603668,
-0.3071008324623108,
0.6848695874214172,
-0.6298463940620422,
-0.42262864112854004,
0.057416897267103195,
0.07181490212678909,
-0.12770256400108337,
-0.8159599900245667,
0.33598199486732483,
-0.3495154082775116,
-0.17402249574661255,
-0.46023422479629517,
-0.6649877429008484,
-0.15175554156303406,
0.3883402347564697,
-0.507840633392334,
0.6471006274223328,
0.21709716320037842,
-0.4466078579425812,
-0.02478191815316677,
-0.6398076415061951,
-0.4272089898586273,
0.14366543292999268,
-0.32926252484321594,
-0.20173189043998718,
0.14028435945510864,
0.003112595295533538,
0.7714676260948181,
-0.5680480003356934,
0.311053991317749,
-0.46282243728637695,
-0.3556141257286072,
0.6640276312828064,
-0.25232863426208496,
0.5483909249305725,
0.33685731887817383,
-0.325087308883667,
0.310635507106781,
-0.6930534839630127,
-0.10763013362884521,
0.48682668805122375,
-0.3794615864753723,
-0.11941631138324738,
0.31542259454727173,
-0.21180662512779236,
0.06610755622386932,
0.14123612642288208,
-0.13578562438488007,
0.3911491334438324,
-0.15960532426834106,
0.8492180705070496,
0.6309877634048462,
-0.31205806136131287,
0.3210340738296509,
-0.4078465700149536,
0.8019973039627075,
-0.08290475606918335,
0.04714328423142433,
-0.20122426748275757,
-0.5109389424324036,
-0.893554151058197,
-0.2758847177028656,
0.1924273818731308,
0.6180417537689209,
-0.6536957621574402,
0.006683157291263342,
-0.057398490607738495,
-0.5201327800750732,
-0.06866111606359482,
0.5723623633384705,
0.2096434086561203,
0.24154289066791534,
-0.07630380988121033,
-0.008090516552329063,
-0.5454772114753723,
-1.062209129333496,
-0.3527756631374359,
-0.1703692525625229,
-0.1202893853187561,
0.5768818259239197,
0.6387499570846558,
-0.32415613532066345,
0.694256067276001,
-0.41840773820877075,
0.12235674262046814,
-0.833800733089447,
-0.20200234651565552,
0.23934267461299896,
0.12473064661026001,
0.3453376591205597,
-0.8842679262161255,
-0.2444026917219162,
0.014210566878318787,
-0.8902948498725891,
-0.27582845091819763,
-0.2887418270111084,
0.0036380502860993147,
0.19211062788963318,
0.6472861170768738,
-0.9239795207977295,
0.17596761882305145,
0.558312177658081,
-0.3401557505130768,
0.8660445809364319,
-0.3495027720928192,
-0.013266257010400295,
-0.8029236793518066,
-0.3429044187068939,
0.11343034356832504,
-0.28422126173973083,
-0.5043874979019165,
0.043131690472364426,
-0.12994134426116943,
-0.1382824033498764,
-0.3915764093399048,
0.7286222577095032,
-0.6992141008377075,
-0.3663704991340637,
-0.2182191014289856,
0.25559771060943604,
-0.07330324500799179,
-0.0988951250910759,
0.035760167986154556,
0.7099326252937317,
0.5032224059104919,
-0.741588830947876,
0.6239315867424011,
0.21783703565597534,
-0.5355973243713379,
0.4823969602584839,
-0.6919304132461548,
-0.16563260555267334,
0.057785939425230026,
0.10582968592643738,
-1.049159288406372,
-0.746131420135498,
-0.23087820410728455,
-0.16223183274269104,
0.27736184000968933,
0.16334541141986847,
-0.8748212456703186,
-0.7038746476173401,
-0.03453527018427849,
0.06849447637796402,
0.5286828875541687,
-0.4265432059764862,
0.8245397806167603,
0.24070747196674347,
-0.20428085327148438,
-0.20866629481315613,
-0.5868188142776489,
0.22438035905361176,
-0.4749319851398468,
-0.8139169812202454,
0.01971406303346157,
-0.25899407267570496,
-0.7930914163589478,
-0.15904377400875092,
0.20675237476825714,
-0.06727994978427887,
0.38248977065086365,
0.4018697440624237,
0.12364142388105392,
-0.3446786105632782,
0.3267631530761719,
0.0793994665145874,
0.17563356459140778,
0.1547563374042511,
0.13758021593093872,
0.4860740303993225,
-0.29639527201652527,
-0.8483006358146667,
-0.2518356144428253,
0.38853567838668823,
0.7865860462188721,
-0.1213025450706482,
0.8066466450691223,
0.18966808915138245,
-0.3555307984352112,
-0.39193689823150635,
-0.8985254764556885,
-0.08039207011461258,
-0.47023439407348633,
0.46244290471076965,
-0.6077643632888794,
-1.321117639541626,
0.7116431593894958,
-0.32466039061546326,
0.0541570708155632,
0.25263312458992004,
0.9149587154388428,
-0.034334175288677216,
1.3521555662155151,
0.3829784393310547,
0.3248027563095093,
0.19744773209095,
-0.08287319540977478,
0.6147367358207703,
-0.8980526328086853,
-0.41278329491615295,
-0.40735185146331787,
0.021883593872189522,
-0.3708747923374176,
-0.3287624418735504,
0.19770126044750214,
0.1630251109600067,
-0.4703885316848755,
0.03840741142630577,
-0.14002130925655365,
0.3100835680961609,
0.4531538188457489,
-0.09643334150314331,
0.5018967390060425,
-0.2707858085632324,
0.00902235135436058,
-0.06502988189458847,
-0.6758372783660889,
-0.9736711978912354,
0.7966336011886597,
0.6346570253372192,
0.8841058611869812,
0.3070580065250397,
0.2575584948062897,
0.033468157052993774,
0.1691836714744568,
-0.8591238260269165,
0.7876640558242798,
-0.07539888471364975,
-0.7275004982948303,
-0.4254392981529236,
-0.4077084958553314,
-0.7778823971748352,
0.17205511033535004,
-0.2153456211090088,
-0.843561589717865,
-0.41563376784324646,
0.18240806460380554,
-0.2738323211669922,
0.6434076428413391,
-0.8636815547943115,
0.7369796633720398,
-0.4803376793861389,
-0.09992463886737823,
-0.023499654605984688,
-0.20028312504291534,
0.5912426710128784,
-0.1187807023525238,
0.2941897511482239,
-0.22011682391166687,
0.03313460201025009,
0.32377925515174866,
-0.24087312817573547,
0.9275189638137817,
0.3021562397480011,
-0.15622054040431976,
0.3743874430656433,
0.38002192974090576,
0.3192780017852783,
-0.028605423867702484,
-0.19426681101322174,
-0.060172416269779205,
-0.01141364686191082,
-0.4060579538345337,
-0.45124584436416626,
0.7578881978988647,
-0.5365102291107178,
-1.3938566446304321,
-0.11360152065753937,
-1.0224640369415283,
-0.5801606774330139,
-0.0010393495904281735,
-0.20684880018234253,
0.21997952461242676,
-0.06573348492383957,
0.26174935698509216,
0.7628771662712097,
-0.6015568971633911,
0.4523922801017761,
0.4616909325122833,
-0.4194600284099579,
0.17930281162261963,
0.6396847367286682,
0.29572516679763794,
0.5407679677009583,
0.13608306646347046,
0.22501727938652039,
-0.28913041949272156,
-0.916642963886261,
-0.47286033630371094,
0.42154645919799805,
-1.0517090559005737,
0.18925540149211884,
-0.7086957693099976,
-0.3797534704208374,
-0.3840356171131134,
-0.2441663295030594,
-0.22935160994529724,
-0.43209874629974365,
-0.3061120808124542,
-0.17845644056797028,
0.18369042873382568,
1.1064256429672241,
0.18608571588993073,
0.17150139808654785,
-0.7369559407234192,
0.08990529179573059,
0.6409935355186462,
0.10129226744174957,
0.20785358548164368,
-0.5813468098640442,
0.04274802282452583,
-0.37773022055625916,
-0.3916590213775635,
-0.7985727787017822,
0.30322685837745667,
-0.17993998527526855,
0.8108383417129517,
0.32893452048301697,
-0.24816718697547913,
0.4121864438056946,
-0.4091944694519043,
0.9932424426078796,
-0.11499583721160889,
-1.0376619100570679,
0.5332895517349243,
-0.4637717306613922,
0.3844568729400635,
-0.04757068678736687,
0.54805988073349,
-0.2382580041885376,
-0.47949570417404175,
-0.40593716502189636,
-0.6909517645835876,
0.24951736629009247,
0.2390712946653366,
0.423683762550354,
0.06767676770687103,
0.6447234153747559,
0.11351562291383743,
0.11093311011791229,
-0.5985130667686462,
0.01258237473666668,
0.26747745275497437,
-0.07061717659235,
-0.10509821772575378,
-0.6020505428314209,
-0.07864511013031006,
-0.4280235767364502,
0.6473959684371948,
-0.05072951689362526,
-0.11402855068445206,
0.17668356001377106,
0.06138144060969353,
0.03104260005056858,
0.5304766893386841,
0.9008857011795044,
1.0646952390670776,
0.10892848670482635,
0.20452742278575897,
0.4780527353286743,
0.09332004189491272,
0.09553158283233643,
0.0192918349057436,
0.15335474908351898,
-0.12533873319625854,
0.594810426235199,
0.7348454594612122,
0.12618038058280945,
-1.2782789468765259,
0.3622616231441498,
-0.10505735874176025,
-0.2790586054325104,
-0.5509285926818848,
0.30631139874458313,
0.6999462842941284,
0.560055673122406,
0.3645133078098297,
-0.4707409143447876,
-0.12169220298528671,
-0.8581289052963257,
-0.18015369772911072,
0.6851555705070496,
-0.1989491581916809,
-0.08264709264039993,
0.6702245473861694,
-0.003687875112518668,
-0.5456278920173645,
0.5797715187072754,
-0.1936572939157486,
-0.6099690794944763,
0.8177978992462158,
0.6680280566215515,
0.41448986530303955,
-0.22148624062538147,
0.08196838200092316,
0.008210844360291958,
0.4123489260673523,
-0.2530566155910492,
0.2469727098941803,
0.24246537685394287,
-0.9686924815177917,
-0.5923932790756226,
-0.3472207188606262,
-0.8769795894622803,
0.3439250588417053,
-0.31607624888420105,
0.16462409496307373,
-0.5058947801589966,
-0.18703295290470123,
0.11002276092767715,
-0.1662531942129135,
-0.5861138105392456,
0.16424143314361572,
0.2953953146934509,
0.9139597415924072,
-0.6715915203094482,
0.6618120670318604,
0.7032524347305298,
-0.31971946358680725,
-0.9290462136268616,
-0.47861671447753906,
0.034638211131095886,
-0.715282142162323,
1.0135945081710815,
0.15023741126060486,
0.07712240517139435,
-0.2895705997943878,
-0.6097072958946228,
-0.5550957322120667,
1.0458060503005981,
0.6259077191352844,
-0.7871411442756653,
-0.060605552047491074,
0.38214462995529175,
0.5905005931854248,
-0.7084089517593384,
0.27495846152305603,
0.7733405232429504,
0.7074056267738342,
0.07102905958890915,
-1.172688364982605,
0.048216838389635086,
-0.04981636628508568,
0.1897728145122528,
-0.16751322150230408,
-0.584323525428772,
0.968849778175354,
-0.4630696177482605,
0.06745963543653488,
0.22020375728607178,
0.6010803580284119,
0.389843225479126,
0.3722345530986786,
0.5627169013023376,
0.38424527645111084,
0.8104376792907715,
-0.21370171010494232,
1.5266884565353394,
0.2052651196718216,
-0.09279461950063705,
1.104971170425415,
-0.6362938284873962,
0.7989531755447388,
0.40914565324783325,
-0.00936589203774929,
0.579220712184906,
0.7043365836143494,
-0.10334009677171707,
-0.12872762978076935,
0.5157629251480103,
-0.3977769613265991,
-0.8559108376502991,
-0.15162266790866852,
-0.0366501584649086,
0.3783804476261139,
0.4105718433856964,
-0.41039660573005676,
0.061491742730140686,
0.13580559194087982,
0.003195601049810648,
0.3870636224746704,
-0.4331585168838501,
0.46349355578422546,
0.36023980379104614,
-0.5163183808326721,
0.20678821206092834,
-0.01313972007483244,
0.4021742641925812,
-0.46031510829925537,
-0.21533745527267456,
0.12410043925046921,
0.30214744806289673,
-0.1612248718738556,
-0.9511571526527405,
0.4483284056186676,
-0.034487683326005936,
-0.08905140310525894,
-0.11206793040037155,
0.8656184077262878,
-0.07181789726018906,
-0.43993884325027466,
0.47648391127586365,
0.7368919253349304,
0.2114570587873459,
-0.14327707886695862,
-0.6759414076805115,
0.4365052282810211,
-0.16137823462486267,
-0.43969205021858215,
0.3821761906147003,
0.5919325947761536,
-0.2666088342666626,
1.3097352981567383,
0.47129398584365845,
0.17418436706066132,
0.05488540604710579,
0.24840375781059265,
0.7249622941017151,
-0.7953765392303467,
0.0315132699906826,
-0.9747397899627686,
0.3136218190193176,
-0.0360109843313694,
-0.1267073154449463,
0.9794884324073792,
0.5436694025993347,
0.6999297738075256,
-0.22304853796958923,
0.9036096930503845,
0.18977968394756317,
0.5256999135017395,
-0.5474326014518738,
0.3917439877986908,
-0.5015093088150024,
0.5102407932281494,
0.17166540026664734,
-0.7501229047775269,
-0.29569554328918457,
0.4630562961101532,
-0.5847861766815186,
0.12973402440547943,
0.6733351945877075,
0.6964523792266846,
-0.0022089846897870302,
-0.004435247741639614,
0.7383483648300171,
0.5769796371459961,
0.6044371724128723,
0.7250997424125671,
1.255671501159668,
0.09167991578578949,
0.4983072578907013,
0.05118197947740555,
-0.01044487301260233,
-0.17974542081356049,
-1.0779075622558594,
-1.4988195896148682,
-0.5050263404846191,
-0.265313982963562,
-0.3502902686595917,
-0.11910656839609146,
0.7447577714920044,
0.7067945003509521,
-0.7331230044364929,
-0.33748769760131836,
0.043796565383672714,
0.5041533708572388,
0.29252684116363525,
-0.22167351841926575,
-0.029489779844880104,
-0.24983283877372742,
-0.7523790597915649,
0.30724963545799255,
0.34575241804122925,
0.19676299393177032,
-0.6700925827026367,
-0.1000329852104187,
-0.013139588758349419,
0.5010982155799866,
0.8913425803184509,
0.2511080801486969,
-0.9886143207550049,
-0.47232237458229065,
-0.13411729037761688,
0.019631395116448402,
-0.2872644066810608,
0.8897162675857544,
-0.264814168214798,
0.19812226295471191,
0.34313249588012695,
0.7894625663757324,
0.48049023747444153,
-0.31280118227005005,
0.7199289798736572,
0.021740898489952087,
-0.03648819029331207,
0.20050661265850067,
0.6707985401153564,
0.6654203534126282,
-0.31920313835144043,
0.422372043132782,
-0.031733348965644836,
-0.6691820025444031,
-1.0183569192886353,
0.515272319316864,
-1.1258445978164673,
-0.5198285579681396,
1.465914011001587,
-0.32903483510017395,
-0.1315467208623886,
-0.24645085632801056,
-0.3599955439567566,
-0.03814917057752609,
0.08697241544723511,
0.6093341112136841,
1.1361051797866821,
-0.41777876019477844,
-0.329050213098526,
-1.127137303352356,
0.3213046193122864,
0.42961767315864563,
-0.9767789244651794,
-0.03466297313570976,
0.38965415954589844,
0.5690488815307617,
-0.06542230397462845,
0.529643714427948,
-0.14019058644771576,
-0.018622200936079025,
-0.3293253481388092,
-0.27083998918533325,
-0.11777215451002121,
-0.22701632976531982,
-0.30278176069259644,
0.1535804718732834,
0.7102523446083069,
0.5815105438232422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09954v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09954v2 | Crafting a Good Prompt or Providing Exemplary Dialogues? A Study of In-Context Learning for Persona-based Dialogue Generation | 2024-02-15T14:03:33 | 2024-02-17T06:11:58 | Jiashu Pu, Yajing Wan, Yuru Zhang, Jing Chen, Ling Cheng, Qian Shao, Yongzhu Chang, Tangjie Lv, Rongsheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Previous in-context learning (ICL) research has focused on tasks such as
classification, machine translation, text2table, etc., while studies on whether
ICL can improve human-like dialogue generation are scarce. Our work fills this
gap by systematically investigating the ICL capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) in persona-based dialogue generation, conducting extensive
experiments on high-quality real human Chinese dialogue datasets. From
experimental results, we draw three conclusions: 1) adjusting prompt
instructions is the most direct, effective, and economical way to improve
generation quality; 2) randomly retrieving demonstrations (demos) achieves the
best results, possibly due to the greater diversity and the amount of effective
information; counter-intuitively, retrieving demos with a context identical to
the query performs the worst; 3) even when we destroy the multi-turn
associations and single-turn semantics in the demos, increasing the number of
demos still improves dialogue performance, proving that LLMs can learn from
corrupted dialogue demos. Previous explanations of the ICL mechanism, such as
$n$-gram induction head, cannot fully account for this phenomenon. | [
-0.3395657241344452,
-0.5447526574134827,
0.8339758515357971,
0.23047849535942078,
-0.3543819487094879,
0.019586743786931038,
-0.1809333860874176,
-0.20741590857505798,
-0.3554149270057678,
0.4314654469490051,
-0.709280252456665,
-0.39470547437667847,
-0.09557114541530609,
0.15979833900928497,
-0.12328708916902542,
1.05135977268219,
0.4443250298500061,
0.3949330449104309,
-0.24784758687019348,
-0.030621543526649475,
-0.6136821508407593,
-0.4416167736053467,
-0.9170506000518799,
-0.35332751274108887,
0.4874497354030609,
0.7309059500694275,
0.35152849555015564,
0.3363938331604004,
-0.06281492114067078,
0.24803970754146576,
-0.043587204068899155,
0.3121882975101471,
-0.5410260558128357,
0.2513613998889923,
-0.04923929646611214,
-0.43440744280815125,
-0.061764273792505264,
0.10493868589401245,
0.7567883729934692,
0.7691035270690918,
0.013821521773934364,
-0.16097697615623474,
0.47451597452163696,
0.4019021987915039,
-0.43134891986846924,
0.1449769288301468,
-0.5460367798805237,
-0.1192583218216896,
-0.16462060809135437,
-0.37658318877220154,
-0.8291534781455994,
-0.4239041805267334,
0.44438880681991577,
-0.285371333360672,
0.10763917118310928,
0.2235528528690338,
0.5471065044403076,
0.020444689318537712,
-0.304084837436676,
-0.4281596541404724,
-0.6547737121582031,
0.8195099234580994,
-0.8473181128501892,
0.028028173372149467,
0.24791191518306732,
0.3880082964897156,
-0.3546566665172577,
-0.641095757484436,
-0.45599788427352905,
-0.4975498914718628,
-0.14015591144561768,
0.07448787987232208,
0.08823945373296738,
0.2699741721153259,
0.5693480372428894,
0.2268066555261612,
-0.26598992943763733,
0.26046884059906006,
-0.01419307105243206,
-0.16594049334526062,
0.5196737051010132,
0.3638089597225189,
0.4000754654407501,
-0.34067851305007935,
-0.33898311853408813,
-0.20084790885448456,
-1.1523475646972656,
0.5747494101524353,
0.35392874479293823,
0.42200377583503723,
0.02082972601056099,
0.17887775599956512,
-0.1233217641711235,
0.5880292057991028,
0.4303897023200989,
-0.4665508568286896,
-0.11959098279476166,
-0.301460325717926,
-0.03315655142068863,
0.11003290116786957,
0.719679594039917,
0.4338151216506958,
-0.04367590323090553,
-0.14696304500102997,
-0.33427000045776367,
-0.3881879150867462,
-0.05777692049741745,
-1.0109795331954956,
-0.2264232039451599,
0.170174703001976,
-0.4893254041671753,
-0.04984096810221672,
0.2520661950111389,
-0.5994356274604797,
-0.40022048354148865,
-0.5450417995452881,
0.23296551406383514,
-0.6407369375228882,
0.11083036661148071,
-0.21312622725963593,
-0.06224494054913521,
0.5450671315193176,
0.5791923403739929,
-0.8129676580429077,
0.07726067304611206,
0.5289524793624878,
0.533351480960846,
-0.16928531229496002,
-0.2535251975059509,
-0.9554102420806885,
-0.10206089168787003,
-0.3987049460411072,
0.7093889713287354,
-0.46168628334999084,
-0.5446134805679321,
0.13562637567520142,
-0.2276751846075058,
-0.04984189569950104,
-0.7454707026481628,
0.3488025665283203,
-0.09257643669843674,
0.5304360389709473,
-0.6014529466629028,
-0.5117955803871155,
0.13022014498710632,
-0.017064493149518967,
-0.1893579661846161,
0.628847599029541,
0.07147103548049927,
-0.44830122590065,
0.5354151129722595,
-0.6471492648124695,
-0.3412598669528961,
0.2386275976896286,
-0.3341326117515564,
-0.1311570703983307,
0.14326021075248718,
0.2862395942211151,
0.5876896977424622,
-0.4452793598175049,
0.4504223167896271,
-0.07643860578536987,
-0.5347800254821777,
0.7712631225585938,
-0.5551263093948364,
0.7727685570716858,
0.30550089478492737,
-0.5154473781585693,
0.1411958634853363,
-0.4667419195175171,
-0.14517882466316223,
-0.12146902829408646,
-0.23372432589530945,
-0.029361581429839134,
0.12202154099941254,
-0.1563348025083542,
0.32737407088279724,
-0.2133062183856964,
-0.5839511752128601,
0.21040043234825134,
-0.5931703448295593,
0.3379928171634674,
0.7807109355926514,
0.2616773247718811,
0.4884282648563385,
-0.4605761468410492,
0.32765164971351624,
0.1854121834039688,
-0.01902143657207489,
-0.8497021198272705,
-0.405426949262619,
-0.7934101223945618,
-0.14684264361858368,
0.1823309361934662,
0.3364821672439575,
-0.9896393418312073,
0.24813945591449738,
0.057383909821510315,
-0.28544920682907104,
-0.47109749913215637,
-0.023583967238664627,
0.7082372903823853,
0.7849034070968628,
0.11139281839132309,
-0.2875968813896179,
-0.1612931489944458,
-0.8503764867782593,
-0.21104036271572113,
-0.3708864152431488,
-0.33645790815353394,
0.6667174100875854,
0.07789815962314606,
0.14067092537879944,
1.0444128513336182,
-0.29570111632347107,
0.12474214285612106,
-0.6108338236808777,
0.288779616355896,
-0.04669767618179321,
0.3332616090774536,
0.6055665612220764,
-0.5707732439041138,
-0.8277701735496521,
-0.4087091386318207,
-0.5523961782455444,
-0.3978785276412964,
-0.4795772433280945,
-0.0014623021706938744,
0.10887989401817322,
0.563380241394043,
-0.577458918094635,
0.27504783868789673,
-0.057331427931785583,
-0.16430440545082092,
0.6537706851959229,
-0.11140439659357071,
0.23796656727790833,
-1.0034608840942383,
-0.15339091420173645,
0.13184112310409546,
-0.21792882680892944,
-0.8607431054115295,
-0.02218000963330269,
0.06207225099205971,
-0.2535100281238556,
-0.7159589529037476,
0.6566858887672424,
-0.274819552898407,
0.02022603340446949,
-0.45519131422042847,
0.31612396240234375,
-0.08097836375236511,
0.7614171504974365,
-0.08714211732149124,
1.0447297096252441,
0.546147346496582,
-0.8276828527450562,
0.03628307580947876,
0.3323417007923126,
-0.5635460615158081,
0.6730031371116638,
-0.4733506143093109,
0.3212953507900238,
-0.3932993710041046,
0.6717447638511658,
-1.2428523302078247,
-0.4889935851097107,
0.3910849392414093,
-0.27073562145233154,
0.3254775404930115,
0.00916614942252636,
-0.5305226445198059,
0.029331712052226067,
-0.1710387021303177,
0.13762204349040985,
0.669826090335846,
-0.9505829811096191,
0.2046644687652588,
0.10788249969482422,
-0.26008203625679016,
-0.2518528997898102,
-0.3092401921749115,
0.1525498628616333,
-0.42989063262939453,
-0.42654019594192505,
0.43108606338500977,
-0.4165884256362915,
-0.5386599898338318,
-0.5734713077545166,
0.2569398581981659,
0.23784542083740234,
-0.018938813358545303,
0.03697366639971733,
-0.09624718874692917,
-0.04576888680458069,
0.17709030210971832,
0.0839962512254715,
-0.07242407649755478,
0.1838085949420929,
-0.25267425179481506,
0.5924797058105469,
0.10040262341499329,
-0.40805763006210327,
-0.8692077994346619,
0.4806582033634186,
0.5270764231681824,
-0.044858165085315704,
0.5018378496170044,
0.23458200693130493,
-0.013018066063523293,
-0.3331705629825592,
-0.4398709535598755,
-0.3791202902793884,
-0.48323410749435425,
0.08533964306116104,
-0.3365000784397125,
-0.6152764558792114,
0.46608975529670715,
-0.23942598700523376,
0.31082087755203247,
0.11243791878223419,
0.4030868709087372,
-0.28042492270469666,
1.3167250156402588,
0.34059396386146545,
-0.016674628481268883,
0.6023512482643127,
-0.04383176565170288,
0.2045196294784546,
-0.884788453578949,
-0.23208646476268768,
-0.445909321308136,
-0.2286757081747055,
-0.2536063492298126,
-0.10559815168380737,
0.4343818128108978,
-0.12452902644872665,
-0.1635170876979828,
0.09902066737413406,
-0.15715350210666656,
0.39653074741363525,
0.7061518430709839,
0.30493682622909546,
0.07377530634403229,
-0.14856554567813873,
-0.1572265923023224,
-0.3648240566253662,
-0.6140198707580566,
-0.498537540435791,
0.747723400592804,
0.1964661031961441,
0.6689772605895996,
0.11704704165458679,
0.5691487789154053,
0.02172069624066353,
0.2523218095302582,
-0.5721946954727173,
0.7574663162231445,
0.10990447551012039,
-0.14010512828826904,
-0.23639380931854248,
-0.29479101300239563,
-0.7981764674186707,
0.2513713836669922,
-0.0019519692286849022,
-0.8086870908737183,
0.057719990611076355,
0.3427121639251709,
-0.5541658997535706,
0.1290351152420044,
-0.5250033736228943,
0.6028419733047485,
-0.37502169609069824,
-0.44392234086990356,
-0.024565035477280617,
-0.8143746852874756,
0.3197653293609619,
0.11718261241912842,
-0.1692262887954712,
0.16773943603038788,
0.2855744957923889,
0.31274086236953735,
-0.3720685541629791,
0.9093538522720337,
-0.48938363790512085,
-0.22011035680770874,
0.41928526759147644,
-0.040489308536052704,
0.6206020712852478,
0.26799196004867554,
-0.015370248816907406,
-0.4962986707687378,
-0.4198664426803589,
-0.2870570421218872,
-0.9467711448669434,
0.377890020608902,
-0.5880330801010132,
-0.8148232698440552,
-0.076092429459095,
-0.4400876760482788,
-0.3809971511363983,
-0.2302115559577942,
0.633247971534729,
0.8858890533447266,
-0.22856010496616364,
0.41687920689582825,
1.0247173309326172,
-0.651924729347229,
0.48741453886032104,
0.44002029299736023,
-0.15251187980175018,
-0.11229545623064041,
0.8605625629425049,
0.0065099578350782394,
0.5293049216270447,
0.4557819068431854,
0.26590049266815186,
-0.3058065176010132,
-0.5112658739089966,
-0.6886923313140869,
0.03575695678591728,
-0.6978331804275513,
-0.07323355227708817,
-0.6634529232978821,
-0.23543781042099,
-0.316069096326828,
-0.08142782747745514,
0.01580827310681343,
-0.09921243786811829,
-0.46232667565345764,
0.026821497827768326,
-0.09530272334814072,
0.462116539478302,
0.24203148484230042,
0.6089687347412109,
-0.4900851249694824,
0.1047399491071701,
0.4240075349807739,
-0.00815458782017231,
0.20128992199897766,
-0.6525635719299316,
-0.12238718569278717,
0.19469574093818665,
-0.506560206413269,
-0.7953791618347168,
0.31400665640830994,
0.21772059798240662,
0.6443262100219727,
0.7801184058189392,
0.1537943184375763,
0.7407165765762329,
-0.5364794731140137,
1.1803476810455322,
0.05244600027799606,
-0.6663392186164856,
0.6545628905296326,
-0.5878837704658508,
0.7072473168373108,
0.6222503185272217,
0.12242835760116577,
-0.6924050450325012,
-0.5561057925224304,
-0.5911380648612976,
-0.6137323379516602,
0.8125460147857666,
0.016596119850873947,
0.3898454010486603,
-0.04665550962090492,
0.4906750023365021,
0.3757185935974121,
0.20076145231723785,
-0.6287305355072021,
-0.2254108190536499,
-0.08344161510467529,
-0.03455352783203125,
-0.0712592676281929,
-0.3498353958129883,
0.030205652117729187,
-0.20810741186141968,
0.6344635486602783,
-0.32454898953437805,
0.27659866213798523,
0.15127305686473846,
-0.11752676218748093,
-0.06276734173297882,
0.3337876796722412,
0.7109068632125854,
0.6506801247596741,
0.00903095118701458,
-0.20030327141284943,
0.2074534296989441,
-0.003918614238500595,
0.07349024713039398,
-0.2569971978664398,
-0.357455313205719,
-0.08603031188249588,
0.16105912625789642,
1.1194839477539062,
0.4060106873512268,
-0.8757562637329102,
0.6385539770126343,
-0.23473457992076874,
-0.12084898352622986,
-0.2786290645599365,
0.40645909309387207,
-0.24088901281356812,
0.1388806849718094,
0.623744010925293,
-0.0035898778587579727,
0.29143133759498596,
-0.7421243190765381,
0.18988241255283356,
0.5362080931663513,
-0.2919098734855652,
-0.3027036786079407,
0.5221031308174133,
0.37637054920196533,
-0.6026749610900879,
0.8966357707977295,
-0.26308706402778625,
-0.40394487977027893,
0.31830835342407227,
0.6690007448196411,
1.0246763229370117,
-0.18544237315654755,
0.4046076536178589,
0.3982008099555969,
-0.1134035587310791,
-0.015416037291288376,
-0.08035072684288025,
-0.3578255772590637,
-0.4789190888404846,
-0.47021329402923584,
-0.25427699089050293,
-0.7434612512588501,
0.4134870767593384,
-0.47135552763938904,
0.29163411259651184,
-0.46527284383773804,
0.23454323410987854,
-0.29411080479621887,
-0.07371549308300018,
-0.48762011528015137,
-0.004080517217516899,
0.029000135138630867,
0.78978031873703,
-0.6124674677848816,
0.6553056836128235,
0.3107120990753174,
-0.22432458400726318,
-0.8502470254898071,
0.43183183670043945,
0.1181962713599205,
-0.26913660764694214,
0.4885275959968567,
0.43880364298820496,
-0.026037797331809998,
-0.04412592574954033,
-0.9997714757919312,
-0.5242507457733154,
0.9319798946380615,
0.4333072304725647,
-0.35226207971572876,
-0.11131070554256439,
0.11684177815914154,
0.4914535880088806,
-0.6189602613449097,
0.3650292754173279,
0.3665386140346527,
0.27072176337242126,
0.10313752293586731,
-0.6142832040786743,
-0.16639800369739532,
-0.205878347158432,
0.0656512975692749,
-0.10482487827539444,
-0.8269891142845154,
0.7132893204689026,
-0.043876126408576965,
-0.3810080885887146,
0.5104179382324219,
0.8183780908584595,
0.42934033274650574,
0.3753947913646698,
0.5414724946022034,
0.05784298852086067,
0.7061460614204407,
-0.10601963102817535,
1.144924283027649,
-0.2264203280210495,
-0.3054443895816803,
1.112192988395691,
-0.39657649397850037,
0.34309297800064087,
0.3156968951225281,
0.16302043199539185,
0.6439095139503479,
0.8830121755599976,
0.24480925500392914,
0.5674848556518555,
0.08311273902654648,
-0.4824833273887634,
-0.33185309171676636,
-0.26819461584091187,
0.035926442593336105,
0.34145790338516235,
0.3905404508113861,
-0.3653183877468109,
-0.13190288841724396,
0.4198315739631653,
-0.06844241172075272,
0.21792349219322205,
-0.08451490104198456,
1.1024950742721558,
0.07420646399259567,
-1.3106040954589844,
0.186353862285614,
-0.05467505007982254,
0.4083065986633301,
-0.46050164103507996,
-0.23877643048763275,
-0.4580497741699219,
-0.12429981678724289,
0.11967743933200836,
-0.5141735076904297,
-0.3258192837238312,
0.006352696567773819,
-0.11314114928245544,
-0.4250098466873169,
0.5906804203987122,
-0.4663967490196228,
-0.0009608035907149315,
-0.10740464180707932,
0.4473605453968048,
0.35048532485961914,
0.14864103496074677,
-0.5491852760314941,
-0.3011288642883301,
0.1253366470336914,
-0.08244940638542175,
0.6284838318824768,
0.5497374534606934,
-0.06075219810009003,
0.7509948015213013,
0.5255889892578125,
-0.19279755651950836,
-0.18903231620788574,
0.27953463792800903,
0.7750043272972107,
-0.5453525185585022,
-0.5733218789100647,
-0.8083149790763855,
0.8298021554946899,
-0.21595437824726105,
-0.4081525504589081,
0.8509170413017273,
0.4283806085586548,
0.8802158832550049,
-0.04033195972442627,
0.8803468942642212,
0.12030083686113358,
0.5881946682929993,
-0.6515123248100281,
0.3034137487411499,
-0.24060089886188507,
0.37808433175086975,
-0.4574125409126282,
-0.9591038823127747,
-0.09459594637155533,
0.4693354368209839,
-0.12169138342142105,
0.12454196810722351,
0.6055351495742798,
0.8628714680671692,
-0.0166896004229784,
0.14260777831077576,
0.4477645456790924,
-0.030090756714344025,
0.6024508476257324,
0.37392574548721313,
1.2300426959991455,
-0.11131865531206131,
0.33371788263320923,
-0.15488311648368835,
-0.28125834465026855,
-0.23887963593006134,
-0.6613830924034119,
-1.0187233686447144,
-0.7397919297218323,
-0.09943325817584991,
-0.2620209753513336,
-0.006446170154958963,
1.2294343709945679,
0.5861145853996277,
-0.49336057901382446,
-0.33814114332199097,
-0.0444936528801918,
-0.0844513475894928,
-0.2530800402164459,
-0.19822311401367188,
0.17666339874267578,
-0.682833731174469,
-1.070611596107483,
0.6179425120353699,
0.2665775418281555,
-0.03303767368197441,
-0.3858070373535156,
-0.334963321685791,
0.16242487728595734,
0.10436764359474182,
0.685951828956604,
0.2921198010444641,
-0.9128649234771729,
-0.3749628961086273,
0.05184122547507286,
-0.20400166511535645,
0.22766871750354767,
1.1810472011566162,
-0.7417134642601013,
0.4999985098838806,
0.43131542205810547,
0.4964808225631714,
0.23746095597743988,
0.24499358236789703,
0.8497759699821472,
-0.8491909503936768,
-0.018602367490530014,
0.13707222044467926,
0.40573257207870483,
0.5014066696166992,
-0.39759060740470886,
0.13046211004257202,
-0.09694614261388779,
-0.7452804446220398,
-0.7348511219024658,
0.5052785277366638,
-0.701497495174408,
-0.3083997666835785,
1.2218492031097412,
-0.10115285217761993,
-0.00209704227745533,
-0.1559726446866989,
-0.7474417090415955,
0.05473259091377258,
-0.6182816028594971,
0.7349970936775208,
0.6091458797454834,
-0.5919731855392456,
-0.37877359986305237,
-0.34545421600341797,
0.7948169112205505,
0.40698108077049255,
-0.6991058588027954,
0.18601517379283905,
0.651550829410553,
-0.003647229168564081,
-0.043403465300798416,
0.7219458818435669,
0.04854432865977287,
0.4932912290096283,
-0.3785851001739502,
-0.3946589529514313,
0.21884799003601074,
-0.6061489582061768,
-0.3703627288341522,
0.11929625272750854,
0.35449644923210144,
0.21201778948307037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09949v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09949v2 | Multi-word Tokenization for Sequence Compression | 2024-02-15T13:52:23 | 2024-04-04T22:50:25 | Leonidas Gee, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Ernandes, Andrea Zugarini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models have proven highly successful at modelling a variety of
tasks. However, this comes at a steep computational cost that hinders wider
industrial uptake. In this paper, we present MWT: a Multi-Word Tokenizer that
goes beyond word boundaries by representing frequent multi-word expressions as
single tokens. MWTs produce a more compact and efficient tokenization that
yields two benefits: (1) Increase in performance due to a greater coverage of
input data given a fixed sequence length budget; (2) Faster and lighter
inference due to the ability to reduce the sequence length with negligible
drops in performance. Our results show that MWT is more robust across shorter
sequence lengths, thus allowing for major speedups via early sequence
truncation. | [
-0.39010608196258545,
-0.2944132089614868,
0.41760969161987305,
0.2870705723762512,
-0.6997464299201965,
0.11000131070613861,
-0.17482571303844452,
-0.3898388743400574,
0.2912449538707733,
0.061745282262563705,
-0.34263530373573303,
-0.149840846657753,
-0.8824172616004944,
0.2436353862285614,
-0.4718913733959198,
0.6452863216400146,
0.21759426593780518,
-0.30170702934265137,
0.32204118371009827,
-0.23026348650455475,
-0.6635292768478394,
-0.8364301323890686,
-0.33871346712112427,
-0.029675493016839027,
0.8402499556541443,
0.08560921996831894,
0.7457877397537231,
0.7254209518432617,
0.48782339692115784,
0.29472482204437256,
-0.05941148102283478,
0.30966901779174805,
-0.148951917886734,
0.17559804022312164,
0.3839973509311676,
-0.17100059986114502,
-0.24973922967910767,
-0.2489416003227234,
0.736099898815155,
0.6049680709838867,
-0.021532561630010605,
0.24266445636749268,
0.0014111081836745143,
0.6135704517364502,
-0.5170621275901794,
0.17442403733730316,
-0.535828709602356,
0.05181123688817024,
-0.4237285256385803,
-0.11502651125192642,
-0.5663903951644897,
-0.14088074862957,
-0.19465503096580505,
-0.2622600793838501,
0.06945570558309555,
0.08460519462823868,
0.6249858736991882,
0.21376226842403412,
-0.6590408086776733,
0.26284173130989075,
-0.6153034567832947,
0.7045941948890686,
-0.7941142916679382,
0.5999077558517456,
-0.23323552310466766,
-0.05548969283699989,
-0.1162433996796608,
-1.009696125984192,
-0.6007192730903625,
0.14900127053260803,
-0.23628824949264526,
0.14414796233177185,
-0.1168220266699791,
0.36380553245544434,
0.36417844891548157,
0.3386181592941284,
-0.5110987424850464,
-0.05976070463657379,
-0.36327895522117615,
-0.3776518404483795,
0.24322614073753357,
-0.046048086136579514,
0.00970568135380745,
-0.3570585250854492,
-0.573460578918457,
-0.05841972678899765,
-0.5961673259735107,
-0.06911727041006088,
0.1889071762561798,
0.5035844445228577,
0.18112578988075256,
0.7980977892875671,
0.003590489737689495,
0.723807156085968,
-0.558509349822998,
-0.022156372666358948,
0.011468738317489624,
-0.21384702622890472,
-0.10662367939949036,
-0.020414071157574654,
0.5859265923500061,
0.14587369561195374,
-0.1013772115111351,
-0.18427592515945435,
-0.14116507768630981,
0.32017022371292114,
0.10976395756006241,
-1.2357518672943115,
0.04071902111172676,
0.42231741547584534,
-0.5924341678619385,
-0.02721821703016758,
0.6798166036605835,
-0.7169252634048462,
-0.20032018423080444,
-0.06046734005212784,
0.42396029829978943,
-0.4012434184551239,
-0.09125716239213943,
0.48490849137306213,
-0.7233259081840515,
0.043875645846128464,
-0.07482656091451645,
-0.39526280760765076,
0.007982166483998299,
0.7461685538291931,
1.4378443956375122,
-0.14219263195991516,
-0.19984734058380127,
-0.9852895736694336,
0.14406487345695496,
-0.217339888215065,
0.686433732509613,
-0.4181065857410431,
-0.6258098483085632,
-0.2092452198266983,
-0.22974491119384766,
0.10016848891973495,
-0.04381536692380905,
0.34502145648002625,
-0.5460926294326782,
-0.06900542974472046,
-0.2052755206823349,
-0.5503191947937012,
-0.11997958272695541,
0.16315814852714539,
-0.7393472194671631,
1.0385533571243286,
-0.11145788431167603,
-0.8447924256324768,
0.4766213893890381,
-1.0735089778900146,
-0.8956674337387085,
0.12282771617174149,
0.12103307247161865,
-0.20266009867191315,
0.6432288289070129,
0.3002360165119171,
0.5157960057258606,
-0.02345685102045536,
0.06905455887317657,
-0.22765329480171204,
-0.555729329586029,
0.08355555683374405,
-0.6652565002441406,
0.2788901925086975,
0.3086645305156708,
-0.11317531764507294,
0.28310728073120117,
-0.7738513350486755,
0.03673635050654411,
-0.07673342525959015,
-0.7267624139785767,
-0.2635950446128845,
-0.014049023389816284,
0.11323806643486023,
0.43891575932502747,
0.015466404147446156,
-0.7763102054595947,
0.680088996887207,
-0.37818488478660583,
0.748455822467804,
0.785356342792511,
-0.1858677715063095,
-0.020158568397164345,
-0.3474093973636627,
0.5896404385566711,
0.1215403750538826,
-0.044491544365882874,
-0.47104546427726746,
-0.7565778493881226,
-0.5118623971939087,
-0.7930898070335388,
0.5588273406028748,
0.4058692455291748,
-0.8654621243476868,
0.3830661475658417,
-0.5238426327705383,
-0.29763612151145935,
-0.4621194899082184,
-0.4551134407520294,
0.12349941581487656,
0.1181575357913971,
0.5254013538360596,
-0.5309826135635376,
-0.7386032938957214,
-0.4779641330242157,
-0.42599448561668396,
-0.07388360053300858,
-0.3039892315864563,
-0.021043334156274796,
0.3291466236114502,
-0.07967773824930191,
0.969405472278595,
-0.7417661547660828,
-0.061869870871305466,
-0.1958887279033661,
0.6894577741622925,
0.17471374571323395,
0.5433129668235779,
0.0756792426109314,
-0.8836443424224854,
-0.18891392648220062,
-0.09484279900789261,
-0.016780711710453033,
-0.06514348834753036,
-0.16185368597507477,
0.11420225352048874,
-0.11377014964818954,
0.4173657298088074,
-0.8056621551513672,
0.6452082395553589,
0.7195528745651245,
-0.3354247510433197,
0.5644086599349976,
-0.29211485385894775,
0.12122391164302826,
-1.268811583518982,
0.18065860867500305,
-0.3808949291706085,
-0.411256343126297,
-0.6510754823684692,
0.14368462562561035,
0.10878070443868637,
-0.28605160117149353,
-0.5921230316162109,
0.3751429319381714,
-0.5211998820304871,
-0.1523546725511551,
-0.24307981133460999,
-0.015847472473978996,
0.21525751054286957,
0.2631289064884186,
-0.040062274783849716,
1.0560280084609985,
0.12944449484348297,
-0.6384280323982239,
-0.021263940259814262,
0.2464272677898407,
-0.1717657893896103,
0.023054514080286026,
-0.6851800084114075,
0.40332576632499695,
-0.10551624745130539,
0.5552745461463928,
-1.0520133972167969,
0.12075415998697281,
-0.4645098149776459,
-0.3062135875225067,
0.19041036069393158,
-0.14477990567684174,
-0.898539662361145,
-0.7027365565299988,
-0.6070289015769958,
0.516018271446228,
0.38918182253837585,
-0.6909433007240295,
0.570361852645874,
0.022674869745969772,
0.2891335189342499,
-0.4485337734222412,
-1.0819050073623657,
0.21649307012557983,
-0.31658637523651123,
-0.5075774192810059,
0.5747377276420593,
-0.15128035843372345,
0.2938520312309265,
-0.36699315905570984,
-0.21478816866874695,
0.0022370994556695223,
0.027102770283818245,
0.11278843134641647,
0.02926607057452202,
-0.2378821223974228,
0.36858466267585754,
-0.10474435985088348,
-0.10237842053174973,
-0.5579192042350769,
-0.8562109470367432,
0.921707808971405,
-0.001002953271381557,
-0.31830325722694397,
-0.2362493872642517,
0.7291263341903687,
0.7678672075271606,
-0.424587607383728,
0.844955325126648,
0.8621723651885986,
-0.41053250432014465,
0.15153801441192627,
-0.38165557384490967,
-0.13129693269729614,
-0.4835277199745178,
0.2787025272846222,
-0.7191156148910522,
-1.0382109880447388,
0.5110840201377869,
-0.2998366355895996,
0.2845364212989807,
0.5630022883415222,
0.22465816140174866,
0.5013389587402344,
1.1692547798156738,
0.4078775644302368,
-0.11427650600671768,
0.45154812932014465,
-0.029584307223558426,
0.5593385100364685,
-0.748796284198761,
0.19518230855464935,
-0.638787567615509,
-0.356067419052124,
-0.5143202543258667,
-0.6537063717842102,
0.3448045253753662,
0.04534492641687393,
-0.00025446436484344304,
0.6551021337509155,
-0.6021077632904053,
0.40951505303382874,
0.595337450504303,
0.19063392281532288,
0.20729714632034302,
-0.48336324095726013,
-0.22687388956546783,
0.11298316717147827,
-0.8845518231391907,
-0.20307841897010803,
0.7011318206787109,
0.10705430060625076,
0.3573444187641144,
0.5132064819335938,
0.7476850152015686,
0.2690894901752472,
0.2405853271484375,
-0.9167070984840393,
0.41247043013572693,
-0.475018173456192,
-0.44353145360946655,
-0.21259982883930206,
-0.48317238688468933,
-1.0853980779647827,
0.5465072989463806,
-0.150057852268219,
-0.7007279396057129,
0.000006199438303156057,
0.04609508067369461,
-0.4362289309501648,
0.5466222167015076,
-0.7948397397994995,
0.5788013339042664,
0.20669835805892944,
0.023068001493811607,
-0.217594712972641,
-0.717453122138977,
0.2942892611026764,
-0.2585600018501282,
0.30336636304855347,
0.021325379610061646,
-0.2855880558490753,
0.6997789144515991,
-0.9019528031349182,
0.6725727319717407,
-0.15357732772827148,
0.23425598442554474,
0.14848338067531586,
-0.058430708944797516,
0.5987029671669006,
-0.18863777816295624,
-0.10318027436733246,
0.1349106878042221,
0.17714184522628784,
-0.5877555012702942,
-0.3840736448764801,
0.17585307359695435,
0.17350664734840393,
-0.3525684177875519,
-0.20907364785671234,
-0.6254779696464539,
-0.2042866051197052,
0.43035149574279785,
0.32637423276901245,
0.8715945482254028,
0.044110555201768875,
0.16223551332950592,
0.06520181149244308,
-0.2871597111225128,
0.7367875576019287,
-0.06080930307507515,
-0.025729747489094734,
-0.3915555477142334,
0.6502470970153809,
0.26224061846733093,
0.2549535632133484,
0.3952956199645996,
0.6770783066749573,
-0.40094316005706787,
-0.5410831570625305,
-0.43182477355003357,
-0.1606893539428711,
-0.6483844518661499,
-0.6228886246681213,
-0.6489331126213074,
0.08655061572790146,
-0.5769334435462952,
-0.07612389326095581,
-0.33259502053260803,
-0.7971320152282715,
0.038351792842149734,
-0.1510719209909439,
0.4803904592990875,
0.7820290327072144,
-0.14958862960338593,
0.559036135673523,
-1.1409380435943604,
0.4650239050388336,
0.2420484870672226,
0.4542076289653778,
0.09903224557638168,
-0.21320849657058716,
-0.0703122615814209,
-0.48264867067337036,
-0.10597975552082062,
-0.8446232676506042,
0.24325396120548248,
0.42438259720802307,
-0.06252158433198929,
0.35894855856895447,
0.19376564025878906,
1.273716926574707,
-0.8162104487419128,
1.1194292306900024,
0.4154896140098572,
-1.2281635999679565,
0.08797508478164673,
0.031088948249816895,
0.7632013559341431,
0.295684814453125,
-0.06870880722999573,
-0.9553313851356506,
-0.3655819892883301,
-0.4684341549873352,
-1.184363842010498,
0.3350802958011627,
0.09624014049768448,
0.29747721552848816,
-0.5794776082038879,
0.20675057172775269,
0.24852584302425385,
0.3408278226852417,
-0.4659678339958191,
-0.22723890841007233,
-0.07603985071182251,
-0.2097063660621643,
0.15860936045646667,
-0.3503080904483795,
0.2841322422027588,
-0.27407723665237427,
0.6007815599441528,
-0.3603675365447998,
0.5638335347175598,
0.33859482407569885,
-0.20335902273654938,
0.45315006375312805,
0.44204118847846985,
0.7077140808105469,
0.22377410531044006,
0.13023944199085236,
0.36524689197540283,
0.17608767747879028,
-0.5704307556152344,
0.10263103991746902,
0.2369685024023056,
0.2456579953432083,
0.27708324790000916,
0.4170931577682495,
0.5857852697372437,
0.34665676951408386,
-0.37557047605514526,
0.6449260711669922,
-0.08124320954084396,
-0.12268972396850586,
0.4122147262096405,
-0.4716647267341614,
-0.04296775907278061,
0.10576196014881134,
0.25588294863700867,
0.23012720048427582,
0.3259502053260803,
-0.3641148507595062,
0.5125076174736023,
0.4033835232257843,
-0.16001765429973602,
-0.17525355517864227,
0.7860825061798096,
0.10533376783132553,
-0.2222464382648468,
0.3376782238483429,
-0.0888461321592331,
-0.8885818123817444,
0.3367744982242584,
0.45066237449645996,
0.7665749788284302,
0.05068931356072426,
-0.33812880516052246,
0.1680542230606079,
0.2869946360588074,
-0.411088228225708,
0.4040014147758484,
-0.28049302101135254,
-0.4269070327281952,
-0.7889707684516907,
-0.5256850123405457,
-0.14100010693073273,
-0.22633574903011322,
-0.36845600605010986,
0.2634285092353821,
-0.21917608380317688,
-0.45020830631256104,
-0.039317939430475235,
-0.3238558769226074,
-0.6309365630149841,
-0.090220607817173,
0.03874416649341583,
1.117434024810791,
-0.4133221507072449,
0.9921010732650757,
0.18820632994174957,
-0.24158646166324615,
-0.8619590401649475,
-0.007255876436829567,
-0.01037324033677578,
-0.4989013671875,
0.35756370425224304,
0.7881152629852295,
-0.25323647260665894,
0.13109053671360016,
0.0017046695575118065,
-0.7223456501960754,
0.8728070259094238,
0.23647062480449677,
-0.4921935796737671,
-0.12127872556447983,
0.18361371755599976,
0.19817036390304565,
-0.02034834772348404,
-0.01482423022389412,
0.5647231936454773,
0.731195867061615,
-0.005896501708775759,
-0.8265702128410339,
0.1935228556394577,
0.09531944990158081,
0.18914051353931427,
0.7455547451972961,
-0.5345371961593628,
0.6995182633399963,
-0.19281765818595886,
-0.47220051288604736,
0.35444507002830505,
0.7758094072341919,
-0.12243302911520004,
-0.06030838564038277,
0.6191402673721313,
0.39132407307624817,
0.9126585721969604,
-0.3145802319049835,
1.096460223197937,
-0.3928464353084564,
0.33559897541999817,
0.8055222034454346,
0.005442020483314991,
0.8423104882240295,
0.7486125230789185,
-0.2703051269054413,
0.17533136904239655,
0.3721664547920227,
0.1514449119567871,
0.30906644463539124,
0.5546649694442749,
-0.27971985936164856,
0.032670289278030396,
-0.030129041522741318,
-0.1842666119337082,
0.2968441843986511,
0.04017212614417076,
-0.034783877432346344,
0.06226082891225815,
0.1286294311285019,
0.09148245304822922,
-0.1974780112504959,
-0.23447257280349731,
0.6162489652633667,
0.0931578204035759,
-0.46805253624916077,
0.25629523396492004,
0.22433945536613464,
1.1885461807250977,
-0.7593367695808411,
0.06408325582742691,
0.08784022182226181,
0.024792958050966263,
-0.03204737976193428,
-0.45697930455207825,
0.524056077003479,
-0.0005377264460548759,
0.1417400985956192,
-0.44063135981559753,
0.7659221291542053,
-0.4092958867549896,
-0.3633268475532532,
0.10907654464244843,
0.4538998305797577,
0.12160652130842209,
-0.34262222051620483,
-0.3036779463291168,
-0.02639090269804001,
-0.3565528392791748,
-0.4632647931575775,
-0.07179021835327148,
0.43880775570869446,
0.13450480997562408,
0.23069199919700623,
0.880488395690918,
0.20648454129695892,
0.3967612385749817,
0.27391114830970764,
0.677035927772522,
-0.8318653702735901,
-0.7136538624763489,
-1.0742971897125244,
0.71722412109375,
-0.11116409301757812,
-0.3057875633239746,
0.48563772439956665,
0.6014644503593445,
0.32266801595687866,
0.007501794490963221,
0.6308316588401794,
-0.20883066952228546,
0.07204706966876984,
-0.5930392742156982,
0.4101017415523529,
-0.5591769218444824,
0.05896025896072388,
-0.23982958495616913,
-0.6230461597442627,
-0.9552510976791382,
0.2953539192676544,
0.24275563657283783,
-0.18258744478225708,
0.781328558921814,
0.3018130362033844,
0.005445767194032669,
0.06564152240753174,
0.5408846139907837,
-0.1643475592136383,
0.6658024191856384,
0.28115323185920715,
0.4916754364967346,
-0.47084224224090576,
0.543541431427002,
-0.19344519078731537,
0.11064539104700089,
-0.008116702549159527,
-1.2659984827041626,
-0.659144401550293,
-0.6478954553604126,
-0.060574982315301895,
-0.3446268141269684,
-0.23607493937015533,
1.1185981035232544,
1.1299750804901123,
-0.5617731213569641,
0.14578962326049805,
-0.1243247538805008,
0.0016597725916653872,
-0.5386688113212585,
-0.1867881715297699,
0.5081197619438171,
-0.3308544158935547,
-0.4664647877216339,
0.5168418884277344,
0.4382840394973755,
0.11771679669618607,
0.0346655510365963,
0.08173973113298416,
-0.14806848764419556,
0.5321341753005981,
1.0060834884643555,
0.031170357018709183,
-0.5741025805473328,
-0.7196739912033081,
-0.2396163046360016,
0.25651371479034424,
0.4004266858100891,
1.3595476150512695,
-0.7082145810127258,
0.30400633811950684,
0.5133287310600281,
0.796126663684845,
0.6211094856262207,
0.12194979190826416,
0.6437780261039734,
-1.331322431564331,
0.5052793622016907,
0.11241023242473602,
0.705922544002533,
0.26262471079826355,
-0.4107304513454437,
0.5485504269599915,
0.3588891327381134,
-0.2308860421180725,
-0.8517308235168457,
0.4401426613330841,
-0.8593717813491821,
-0.49991118907928467,
0.9873284101486206,
-0.06959545612335205,
-0.014594928361475468,
-0.0653490200638771,
-0.36864787340164185,
0.5216429233551025,
-0.41002318263053894,
0.4810255169868469,
0.9990628361701965,
-0.086476631462574,
0.1241505816578865,
-0.38296762108802795,
0.2440016120672226,
0.4130197763442993,
-0.6928661465644836,
0.309089332818985,
0.2351909875869751,
-0.11893001198768616,
0.24954962730407715,
0.47212153673171997,
-0.2041616439819336,
0.07177253067493439,
0.0639093741774559,
-0.11998915672302246,
-0.13669981062412262,
-0.2615051865577698,
-0.4843848645687103,
0.4374273121356964,
0.23440274596214294,
-0.5529714822769165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09939v1 | Generative AI in the Construction Industry: A State-of-the-art Analysis | 2024-02-15T13:39:55 | 2024-02-15T13:39:55 | Ridwan Taiwo, Idris Temitope Bello, Sulemana Fatoama Abdulai, Abdul-Mugis Yussif, Babatunde Abiodun Salami, Abdullahi Saka, Tarek Zayed | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | The construction industry is a vital sector of the global economy, but it
faces many productivity challenges in various processes, such as design,
planning, procurement, inspection, and maintenance. Generative artificial
intelligence (AI), which can create novel and realistic data or content, such
as text, image, video, or code, based on some input or prior knowledge, offers
innovative and disruptive solutions to address these challenges. However, there
is a gap in the literature on the current state, opportunities, and challenges
of generative AI in the construction industry. This study aims to fill this gap
by providing a state-of-the-art analysis of generative AI in construction, with
three objectives: (1) to review and categorize the existing and emerging
generative AI opportunities and challenges in the construction industry; (2) to
propose a framework for construction firms to build customized generative AI
solutions using their own data, comprising steps such as data collection,
dataset curation, training custom large language model (LLM), model evaluation,
and deployment; and (3) to demonstrate the framework via a case study of
developing a generative model for querying contract documents. The results show
that retrieval augmented generation (RAG) improves the baseline LLM by 5.2,
9.4, and 4.8% in terms of quality, relevance, and reproducibility. This study
provides academics and construction professionals with a comprehensive analysis
and practical framework to guide the adoption of generative AI techniques to
enhance productivity, quality, safety, and sustainability across the
construction industry. | [
-0.25647205114364624,
-0.8501163721084595,
0.5001329183578491,
0.1157039999961853,
-0.2909468412399292,
0.3363751173019409,
0.3061524033546448,
-0.5592641830444336,
0.13071788847446442,
0.2766972482204437,
-0.09704705327749252,
-0.506924569606781,
-0.5938547253608704,
-0.004831715952605009,
-0.6242159605026245,
0.6336687803268433,
-0.15463848412036896,
-0.2538151443004608,
-0.6670780777931213,
-0.007071707863360643,
-0.4503345787525177,
-0.5827823877334595,
-0.5093069672584534,
-0.06853432208299637,
0.0007609500316902995,
-0.1312459111213684,
0.7660830616950989,
0.6845169067382812,
0.47160741686820984,
0.4204555153846741,
-0.1113087460398674,
0.2370857149362564,
-0.2126200944185257,
-0.050457559525966644,
0.035434968769550323,
-0.3137451410293579,
-0.3489876091480255,
-0.042459551244974136,
0.6813843250274658,
0.5573247671127319,
-0.3480764627456665,
0.13062222301959991,
-0.02788984589278698,
0.8126470446586609,
-0.5604300498962402,
0.38836193084716797,
-0.5319363474845886,
0.01965666189789772,
-0.3690847158432007,
-0.43734991550445557,
0.05373123288154602,
-0.22302132844924927,
-0.13197724521160126,
-0.47032374143600464,
0.49670302867889404,
0.11114774644374847,
0.8148296475410461,
0.4801642894744873,
-0.17963431775569916,
-0.38527318835258484,
-0.6704443693161011,
0.21922144293785095,
-0.5233417749404907,
0.30351054668426514,
0.017214149236679077,
0.1481315940618515,
-0.15179239213466644,
-0.639850378036499,
-0.4054238498210907,
-0.4746352434158325,
0.08715115487575531,
0.4988531768321991,
0.05597939342260361,
0.12755605578422546,
0.21827465295791626,
0.9466261863708496,
-0.7458743453025818,
0.34228190779685974,
-0.4738803505897522,
-0.01694193109869957,
0.6723709106445312,
0.25623607635498047,
0.543484628200531,
0.0014921777183189988,
-0.5152459144592285,
-0.07541480660438538,
-0.5605757832527161,
-0.13447660207748413,
0.5832831859588623,
-0.028450245037674904,
-0.10667776316404343,
0.5888113379478455,
-0.2997611165046692,
0.6770414113998413,
-0.3585818111896515,
0.028442785143852234,
0.3119352161884308,
-0.2679414749145508,
-0.3451252281665802,
-0.14285717904567719,
0.7890561819076538,
-0.18526087701320648,
-0.24651284515857697,
-0.40105217695236206,
-0.4416751265525818,
0.3492780029773712,
0.5759641528129578,
-0.43024691939353943,
-0.09385746717453003,
0.22158953547477722,
-0.35662326216697693,
-0.41155579686164856,
0.24967233836650848,
-0.43933603167533875,
-0.2978634238243103,
-0.26577016711235046,
0.010696621611714363,
-0.1100412905216217,
-0.5028523802757263,
0.08160615712404251,
-0.5979729890823364,
0.5836220979690552,
0.3086943030357361,
-0.5808307528495789,
-0.2596146762371063,
0.7547058463096619,
0.7851102352142334,
0.004857311025261879,
-0.11750398576259613,
-0.21363432705402374,
0.06272273510694504,
-0.5866062641143799,
0.8182318806648254,
-0.16467872262001038,
-0.704348623752594,
0.301358163356781,
-0.5702466368675232,
-0.1676652729511261,
-0.6705158352851868,
0.3598204553127289,
-0.7164837718009949,
0.08021777123212814,
0.4744246006011963,
-0.45671096444129944,
0.10281907767057419,
0.6041768193244934,
-0.8449658751487732,
0.7371366620063782,
0.6403464674949646,
-0.5311475396156311,
0.32199686765670776,
-0.6162605881690979,
-0.3814987540245056,
0.6675562858581543,
-0.5554285049438477,
-0.8515868782997131,
0.4371291697025299,
-0.06973204761743546,
0.025904210284352303,
-0.4047592580318451,
0.35111990571022034,
0.162027969956398,
-0.22738254070281982,
0.2133735865354538,
-0.4706507921218872,
0.7146344780921936,
0.41840246319770813,
-0.3533378541469574,
0.06882612407207489,
-0.569972574710846,
-0.10684114694595337,
0.034624043852090836,
-0.47429925203323364,
0.07713702321052551,
0.07500603795051575,
-0.11173499375581741,
0.05693991854786873,
0.3484005033969879,
-0.3534003496170044,
0.015241754241287708,
-0.6158890724182129,
0.06088242679834366,
0.5545565485954285,
0.018030770123004913,
0.26005300879478455,
-0.6029064655303955,
0.9448785781860352,
-0.08751783519983292,
0.15878652036190033,
0.027375612407922745,
-0.2042376846075058,
-0.6363545060157776,
-0.3632086217403412,
0.41939225792884827,
0.5419316291809082,
-0.8849024772644043,
0.15042506158351898,
-0.3787405788898468,
-0.604572057723999,
-0.7762941122055054,
0.13377009332180023,
0.4105977714061737,
0.23645900189876556,
0.01531378272920847,
-0.4362918436527252,
-0.5980897545814514,
-0.5258840918540955,
-0.1319248229265213,
-0.3200094699859619,
-0.05696173384785652,
0.10388079285621643,
0.31600549817085266,
-0.23175838589668274,
0.6428811550140381,
-0.5477685928344727,
-0.4711964428424835,
-0.28850749135017395,
0.3053572177886963,
0.22760087251663208,
0.45965278148651123,
0.5293691158294678,
-1.3044259548187256,
-0.3830951750278473,
0.1777486652135849,
-1.1016825437545776,
0.437851220369339,
-0.43448641896247864,
-0.031848762184381485,
0.20734426379203796,
0.754048764705658,
-0.6954713463783264,
0.5200538039207458,
0.2651839554309845,
-0.17943301796913147,
0.7063820362091064,
-0.1698315292596817,
-0.0026015378534793854,
-1.0543168783187866,
0.2858102321624756,
-0.13922248780727386,
0.12934713065624237,
-0.49737873673439026,
0.5173182487487793,
-0.32276883721351624,
-0.30001741647720337,
-0.2615829408168793,
0.2574927508831024,
-0.7258390188217163,
0.0027122695464640856,
-0.32616010308265686,
0.0009972688276320696,
0.06189652904868126,
0.4544532299041748,
-0.011662228964269161,
0.9082261323928833,
0.43515461683273315,
-0.5982951521873474,
0.4123775064945221,
0.5392738580703735,
-0.7237755656242371,
0.3418392539024353,
-0.48745572566986084,
0.28150391578674316,
-0.34390610456466675,
-0.08216358721256256,
-0.5357597470283508,
-0.10528954863548279,
0.16747653484344482,
-0.6212654709815979,
0.2417708933353424,
0.08356346935033798,
-0.5657007098197937,
-0.40837952494621277,
-0.2516078054904938,
0.2485310286283493,
0.6359906196594238,
-0.32240572571754456,
0.7396751046180725,
0.3750673830509186,
-0.2633974552154541,
-0.4905809462070465,
-0.39544135332107544,
0.2627609074115753,
-0.05242781341075897,
-0.34874817728996277,
0.7273087501525879,
-0.002098456956446171,
-0.20102110505104065,
0.16485030949115753,
-0.24966983497142792,
-0.2747305631637573,
0.39942583441734314,
0.22217856347560883,
0.35591921210289,
-0.007320293691009283,
-0.14662304520606995,
-0.3351207971572876,
-0.13326793909072876,
0.27475130558013916,
-0.08852976560592651,
0.22179409861564636,
-0.02820431999862194,
-0.2765096426010132,
-0.352659672498703,
0.392385870218277,
0.7127569913864136,
-0.5452095866203308,
0.8381890058517456,
0.49112775921821594,
-0.26693665981292725,
-0.09572906792163849,
-0.4564116299152374,
0.5177205204963684,
-0.47110244631767273,
0.4699704349040985,
-0.5144515633583069,
-0.7267319560050964,
0.14353036880493164,
-0.3643011152744293,
0.20641663670539856,
0.5824401378631592,
0.5509377717971802,
-0.3453068435192108,
0.8978690505027771,
0.9057352542877197,
-0.1054350957274437,
0.6064196228981018,
-0.6399953961372375,
0.32405951619148254,
-0.7424055337905884,
-0.5429237484931946,
-0.5836376547813416,
0.19826477766036987,
-0.6429803967475891,
-0.15018752217292786,
0.5674565434455872,
-0.013096613809466362,
0.04534466564655304,
0.22524243593215942,
-0.5299833416938782,
0.08742588013410568,
0.5462964773178101,
-0.008643798530101776,
0.3434184193611145,
-0.060112327337265015,
0.07676174491643906,
0.6318772435188293,
-0.9437663555145264,
-0.469005823135376,
0.5750139951705933,
0.1552191823720932,
0.3435739278793335,
0.2165972888469696,
0.5499138236045837,
0.5985575914382935,
0.5367080569267273,
-0.7102047801017761,
0.35442957282066345,
-0.11591436713933945,
-0.4957352876663208,
-0.374722421169281,
-0.48449936509132385,
-1.0132516622543335,
0.08079259842634201,
-0.27887964248657227,
0.010702669620513916,
0.11113078147172928,
0.2033434510231018,
-0.1977250874042511,
0.45658209919929504,
-0.4072093963623047,
0.7440049052238464,
-0.3125952184200287,
-0.015314308926463127,
-0.2616226375102997,
-0.2687448263168335,
0.11720293760299683,
-0.1307826191186905,
0.27150002121925354,
0.026798423379659653,
0.1406281441450119,
0.4235144257545471,
-0.393465131521225,
0.6209945678710938,
-0.042104341089725494,
-0.29988935589790344,
0.6890336275100708,
-0.2394293248653412,
0.5385034680366516,
-0.13510124385356903,
-0.3174351155757904,
0.24564076960086823,
-0.19424626231193542,
-0.2769283652305603,
-0.6473378539085388,
0.36522048711776733,
-0.7172554731369019,
-0.8233463168144226,
-0.40681135654449463,
-0.31237542629241943,
-0.26718246936798096,
-0.05049663782119751,
0.5285983681678772,
0.32472944259643555,
-0.6830867528915405,
0.1468926966190338,
0.256007581949234,
-0.11550273001194,
0.3361535966396332,
0.03296070173382759,
0.473552942276001,
-0.44975388050079346,
0.9615816473960876,
0.05909168720245361,
-0.13273267447948456,
0.5001962780952454,
-0.26504799723625183,
-0.3778343200683594,
-0.9346023797988892,
-0.5549324154853821,
-0.13128744065761566,
-0.3461959660053253,
-0.4097553491592407,
-0.3374456763267517,
-0.61212557554245,
-0.14894939959049225,
-0.2860344350337982,
-0.12519332766532898,
-0.09906653314828873,
-0.2781261205673218,
-0.14491194486618042,
-0.1805344820022583,
0.7082632184028625,
0.3610862195491791,
-0.02266518585383892,
-0.8288994431495667,
0.48690518736839294,
0.36040642857551575,
0.7595481276512146,
-0.050408098846673965,
0.09142742305994034,
-0.6003652215003967,
0.059845153242349625,
-0.40869802236557007,
-0.38573119044303894,
0.31264445185661316,
-0.0019491787534207106,
0.8219019770622253,
0.36011314392089844,
0.13522954285144806,
0.20509637892246246,
-0.2813616394996643,
0.6733675599098206,
0.24871522188186646,
-0.5573854446411133,
0.49694904685020447,
-0.31579944491386414,
0.25060194730758667,
0.40626388788223267,
0.19547787308692932,
-0.2868563234806061,
-0.36911118030548096,
-0.9688103199005127,
-0.9346909523010254,
0.23348836600780487,
0.5388370156288147,
0.25901174545288086,
-0.006604664493352175,
0.29421427845954895,
-0.21857649087905884,
0.3884415030479431,
-0.4000256359577179,
0.03586152568459511,
-0.18578258156776428,
-0.23870225250720978,
0.16229592263698578,
-0.43749383091926575,
-0.10875950753688812,
0.24886800348758698,
0.6073542237281799,
0.03877504914999008,
0.4571548104286194,
0.03196559101343155,
-0.25521916151046753,
-0.00279435352422297,
0.4681393802165985,
0.3941097557544708,
0.9008433818817139,
-0.1579376608133316,
-0.2768864035606384,
0.1412607878446579,
-0.43583381175994873,
0.19110609591007233,
0.18140128254890442,
-0.316011518239975,
0.0629437267780304,
0.48526281118392944,
0.717931866645813,
-0.5098286867141724,
-0.5641990303993225,
0.510397732257843,
0.35803189873695374,
-0.5096555352210999,
-0.8454969525337219,
0.15861529111862183,
-0.34510552883148193,
0.2603428363800049,
0.3588058054447174,
0.11191380769014359,
0.29591819643974304,
-0.38657253980636597,
-0.10322319716215134,
0.6061707139015198,
-0.22957633435726166,
-0.11972600221633911,
0.7543348073959351,
0.40894854068756104,
-0.37511351704597473,
0.9153712391853333,
-0.1917913854122162,
-0.43805456161499023,
0.8674843311309814,
0.33359846472740173,
1.1030908823013306,
0.2542862892150879,
0.19772712886333466,
0.19889654219150543,
0.2858152389526367,
0.18034909665584564,
0.251543253660202,
-0.04209992289543152,
-0.8452774286270142,
-0.4416545629501343,
-0.6918901205062866,
-0.4034508168697357,
0.1311488151550293,
-0.5123172998428345,
-0.26180317997932434,
-0.49314454197883606,
-0.20514993369579315,
-0.30886295437812805,
-0.01223570667207241,
-0.7780081629753113,
0.335151731967926,
0.20949126780033112,
0.7931506633758545,
-0.47681543231010437,
0.3500722646713257,
0.9817986488342285,
-0.7014806866645813,
-0.2921878397464752,
0.004120378289371729,
-0.3843405842781067,
-0.6034603118896484,
0.299635648727417,
0.008141480386257172,
-0.27229398488998413,
0.17862750589847565,
-0.48135673999786377,
-0.5888790488243103,
1.122391939163208,
0.3241617977619171,
-0.3810761272907257,
-0.29742175340652466,
0.31791505217552185,
0.5936412215232849,
-0.11688639968633652,
-0.18705835938453674,
0.29794833064079285,
0.18160885572433472,
-0.043276648968458176,
-0.5812590718269348,
-0.12175610661506653,
-0.582779586315155,
0.5483959913253784,
0.3206962049007416,
-0.6845489144325256,
0.14372272789478302,
-0.09321578592061996,
-0.5266823172569275,
0.35204774141311646,
0.8861024975776672,
0.33043554425239563,
0.3840620815753937,
0.6556568741798401,
0.6073055863380432,
0.3974842429161072,
-0.05187785625457764,
1.1062947511672974,
-0.45994409918785095,
0.083676278591156,
0.6862968802452087,
0.21730870008468628,
0.7310702204704285,
0.2273917943239212,
-0.36754176020622253,
0.7374784350395203,
0.399759441614151,
-0.24101506173610687,
0.38375940918922424,
0.3660826086997986,
-0.4641607403755188,
-0.06377262622117996,
-0.3600127696990967,
-0.5494509339332581,
0.5604241490364075,
0.31045272946357727,
-0.14491571485996246,
0.13072890043258667,
0.0507018081843853,
-0.2561955749988556,
0.32734987139701843,
-0.20463837683200836,
0.9450041651725769,
0.04737498611211777,
-0.6404874920845032,
0.3847547471523285,
0.046451080590486526,
0.3550703823566437,
-0.4491048753261566,
-0.40334978699684143,
-0.2045406550168991,
-0.010786021128296852,
-0.19021297991275787,
-0.40018120408058167,
0.5291537046432495,
-0.10273413360118866,
-0.12266230583190918,
-0.5910714268684387,
0.27318498492240906,
-0.21751537919044495,
-0.33314910531044006,
-0.14208385348320007,
0.5296775698661804,
-0.09340682625770569,
-0.21293006837368011,
-0.5045447945594788,
-0.07994627207517624,
-0.2512485086917877,
0.23179151117801666,
0.1859917789697647,
0.37340885400772095,
0.03752247989177704,
0.42946845293045044,
0.7423744797706604,
0.11127184331417084,
-0.2677944302558899,
0.21275359392166138,
0.9928789734840393,
-0.7305614948272705,
-0.5928778648376465,
-0.5355940461158752,
0.8590611219406128,
-0.1955418735742569,
-0.29571330547332764,
0.47713664174079895,
0.704742431640625,
0.917887270450592,
-0.19177386164665222,
0.80987149477005,
-0.2039431780576706,
0.04058724641799927,
-0.6648551225662231,
0.6792292594909668,
-0.5011299848556519,
0.27400273084640503,
-0.26442116498947144,
-0.8092320561408997,
-0.21813204884529114,
0.20186391472816467,
0.09910542517900467,
-0.025474263355135918,
0.33538568019866943,
0.6808894872665405,
0.37675583362579346,
-0.2591434419155121,
0.3697311580181122,
-0.03810309246182442,
0.24606353044509888,
0.21446309983730316,
1.0606251955032349,
-0.4998008608818054,
0.6719195246696472,
0.047881513833999634,
-0.17680564522743225,
-0.24935172498226166,
-0.6232747435569763,
-0.441471666097641,
-0.6565468311309814,
-0.6712905168533325,
-0.11760050803422928,
0.12660688161849976,
0.4712790548801422,
0.4538581967353821,
-0.7008488178253174,
-0.2745652198791504,
-0.45505595207214355,
0.14750881493091583,
-0.5562785267829895,
-0.21040327847003937,
0.5420710444450378,
-0.4114280343055725,
-0.5179407000541687,
0.49127197265625,
0.30641141533851624,
0.27093616127967834,
-0.1996033936738968,
-0.05959147587418556,
-0.15081386268138885,
-0.0638393983244896,
0.5408602356910706,
0.3323836624622345,
-0.39635151624679565,
0.09222923964262009,
-0.24778616428375244,
-0.239444762468338,
0.20991986989974976,
0.6987429857254028,
-0.5816974639892578,
0.542779266834259,
0.609140157699585,
0.8970940709114075,
0.5014932155609131,
0.27191779017448425,
0.7012621760368347,
-0.8175995945930481,
0.003908153157681227,
0.2596280872821808,
0.30834320187568665,
0.31031379103660583,
-0.756313145160675,
0.72878098487854,
0.27629444003105164,
-0.30204764008522034,
-0.47883519530296326,
0.2134445756673813,
-0.4989023506641388,
-0.25405704975128174,
0.4944208860397339,
0.14579568803310394,
0.049586597830057144,
-0.26335278153419495,
-0.020461319014430046,
0.4713577628135681,
0.1420484036207199,
1.0440270900726318,
0.27982082962989807,
-0.19785451889038086,
-0.1401839256286621,
-0.43139970302581787,
0.5808220505714417,
0.26841971278190613,
-0.9073184728622437,
-0.27740412950515747,
0.6566178798675537,
-0.19646519422531128,
0.15172937512397766,
0.8370797634124756,
-0.1764828860759735,
0.4426000118255615,
0.2816026508808136,
0.13170945644378662,
-0.29502278566360474,
-0.3924291133880615,
-0.21782328188419342,
0.5097702145576477,
0.39053693413734436,
-0.4207603335380554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09934v1 | Paying Attention to Deflections: Mining Pragmatic Nuances for Whataboutism Detection in Online Discourse | 2024-02-15T13:34:19 | 2024-02-15T13:34:19 | Khiem Phi, Noushin Salek Faramarzi, Chenlu Wang, Ritwik Banerjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Whataboutism, a potent tool for disrupting narratives and sowing distrust,
remains under-explored in quantitative NLP research. Moreover, past work has
not distinguished its use as a strategy for misinformation and propaganda from
its use as a tool for pragmatic and semantic framing. We introduce new datasets
from Twitter and YouTube, revealing overlaps as well as distinctions between
whataboutism, propaganda, and the tu quoque fallacy. Furthermore, drawing on
recent work in linguistic semantics, we differentiate the `what about' lexical
construct from whataboutism. Our experiments bring to light unique challenges
in its accurate detection, prompting the introduction of a novel method using
attention weights for negative sample mining. We report significant
improvements of 4% and 10% over previous state-of-the-art methods in our
Twitter and YouTube collections, respectively. | [
-0.8614369034767151,
-0.8825070261955261,
0.49102309346199036,
0.18739618360996246,
-0.27163875102996826,
0.2522667944431305,
0.009140267968177795,
-0.08534468710422516,
0.5460142493247986,
0.45403003692626953,
-0.6140903830528259,
-0.3673821687698364,
-0.9431387186050415,
-0.02352089434862137,
-0.8194103837013245,
1.0232511758804321,
0.24816595017910004,
-0.044103726744651794,
0.0848986804485321,
-0.32912927865982056,
-0.48113545775413513,
-0.37250232696533203,
-0.30887341499328613,
-0.21128638088703156,
0.5063483119010925,
0.263247013092041,
0.7126518487930298,
0.2822476625442505,
0.39460092782974243,
0.319656103849411,
-0.1535068303346634,
0.19605928659439087,
-0.6437960863113403,
-0.01254774909466505,
-0.6311016082763672,
-0.37581387162208557,
0.16480045020580292,
0.12751086056232452,
0.4952694773674011,
0.5572828650474548,
-0.19200190901756287,
0.3737090826034546,
0.01699948124587536,
0.500128448009491,
-0.8717975616455078,
0.07456228137016296,
-0.8145908117294312,
-0.11485151201486588,
-0.29354992508888245,
-0.1314377784729004,
-0.03404587134718895,
-0.6746370196342468,
0.11161267757415771,
-0.528383731842041,
0.3467411398887634,
-0.19978195428848267,
0.8990728855133057,
0.5129135251045227,
-0.5027487277984619,
-0.42987021803855896,
-0.37924760580062866,
0.8850710988044739,
-0.7971000075340271,
0.3281188905239105,
0.7676115036010742,
-0.0011683411430567503,
0.09868836402893066,
-0.8058058619499207,
-0.7941930890083313,
0.26226484775543213,
-0.08425923436880112,
0.1462123692035675,
-0.44382598996162415,
0.011382266879081726,
0.39864885807037354,
0.35950160026550293,
-0.4274730086326599,
-0.35966646671295166,
-0.28424766659736633,
-0.2952519953250885,
0.46341654658317566,
-0.4807044267654419,
0.14038260281085968,
-0.5826956033706665,
-0.3398265838623047,
0.16033419966697693,
-0.4721875488758087,
-0.400919109582901,
0.3102319836616516,
-0.09322759509086609,
0.05785391107201576,
0.6014290452003479,
-0.16501109302043915,
0.2683793604373932,
0.20237553119659424,
0.055775225162506104,
0.21575863659381866,
-0.22503167390823364,
-0.18921472132205963,
0.34239837527275085,
0.5888208150863647,
0.60218745470047,
0.5375291705131531,
0.07347650825977325,
0.19125066697597504,
0.44917425513267517,
0.41265541315078735,
-0.521140992641449,
-0.1464950442314148,
0.12570379674434662,
-0.13067595660686493,
-0.3092555105686188,
0.08865957707166672,
-0.7046298980712891,
-0.6964138150215149,
-0.09925892949104309,
0.26103895902633667,
-0.6506804823875427,
-0.4645352363586426,
0.1441778540611267,
-0.7103486061096191,
0.4813489317893982,
0.05201457440853119,
-0.41900014877319336,
0.23332519829273224,
1.035500168800354,
0.9727436304092407,
0.0009365158621221781,
0.12672488391399384,
-0.74544757604599,
0.04740842059254646,
-0.5720987915992737,
1.0102208852767944,
-0.5601723790168762,
-0.13502156734466553,
0.32612496614456177,
-0.10140351951122284,
0.2578742504119873,
-0.43018895387649536,
0.7502281069755554,
-0.3887103199958801,
0.3040323853492737,
-0.5464527010917664,
-0.6673609018325806,
-0.5419943332672119,
0.6888536810874939,
-0.6950454115867615,
1.0153865814208984,
-0.02571786381304264,
-0.9755747318267822,
0.2944221496582031,
-0.398335725069046,
-0.6206263303756714,
0.1385149210691452,
-0.13955068588256836,
-0.35297155380249023,
0.3854423761367798,
0.03649783879518509,
0.14709459245204926,
-0.17135348916053772,
0.5294222235679626,
-0.3234378695487976,
-0.14816132187843323,
0.4283326268196106,
-0.36062178015708923,
0.8786441683769226,
0.08590025454759598,
-0.5947725772857666,
-0.2441994547843933,
-0.6694465279579163,
-0.06796915829181671,
-0.03509695082902908,
0.18564756214618683,
-0.6871470808982849,
0.2652184069156647,
-0.036933533847332,
0.2739774286746979,
-0.22092707455158234,
-0.5956571102142334,
-0.14895863831043243,
-0.6266652941703796,
0.6988369226455688,
0.42793411016464233,
0.31462472677230835,
0.11478140205144882,
-0.4550190269947052,
0.3331001102924347,
-0.3169688284397125,
-0.055377885699272156,
-0.0025559947825968266,
-0.6063647866249084,
-0.5348674058914185,
-0.10940193384885788,
0.1821213662624359,
0.23740166425704956,
-1.0475215911865234,
0.12977249920368195,
-0.12941141426563263,
-0.5244898200035095,
-0.6022610664367676,
-0.06366399675607681,
0.37333986163139343,
0.5848460793495178,
0.41409483551979065,
-0.3338071405887604,
-0.6541340351104736,
-0.8614701628684998,
-0.815294623374939,
-0.4039572775363922,
-0.09775224328041077,
-0.21406880021095276,
0.37459102272987366,
0.20109067857265472,
0.9718388915061951,
-0.4532381594181061,
-0.6820757389068604,
-0.23572811484336853,
0.5505903959274292,
-0.11975887417793274,
-0.001112637808546424,
0.5202555060386658,
-1.1497595310211182,
-0.3956878185272217,
-0.39622732996940613,
-0.4418128728866577,
-0.18491029739379883,
-0.0819331705570221,
0.21144403517246246,
0.07098552584648132,
0.5049516558647156,
-0.5941373109817505,
0.43190237879753113,
0.39450803399086,
-0.40343669056892395,
0.24317403137683868,
0.4326270520687103,
0.34652167558670044,
-0.956836462020874,
-0.1163315549492836,
0.31033092737197876,
-0.5255508422851562,
-0.6471589207649231,
-0.0448431596159935,
-0.16501358151435852,
0.32461974024772644,
-0.6844688653945923,
0.2650192975997925,
-0.22822122275829315,
0.1480538249015808,
-0.332514226436615,
0.560371458530426,
0.29015448689460754,
0.256041556596756,
0.17337167263031006,
0.2962810695171356,
0.24720236659049988,
-0.4729943871498108,
0.421063631772995,
0.43626102805137634,
-0.42089638113975525,
0.9705350399017334,
-0.4741840362548828,
-0.08592035621404648,
-0.33534517884254456,
0.16179914772510529,
-1.3390779495239258,
-0.3065284788608551,
0.3636951446533203,
-0.8851460218429565,
0.03461296483874321,
-0.40447914600372314,
-0.4901665151119232,
-0.0941229984164238,
-0.9666999578475952,
0.2790222465991974,
0.4532603919506073,
-0.2069309502840042,
0.6566721796989441,
0.9190107583999634,
0.00501278368756175,
-0.62766033411026,
-0.9750359654426575,
-0.006609914358705282,
-0.36564120650291443,
-0.2433456927537918,
0.6257055997848511,
0.3245403468608856,
-0.7819468379020691,
0.0023257031571120024,
-0.20997141301631927,
-0.22088734805583954,
-0.03867150843143463,
0.08989333361387253,
-0.22065255045890808,
-0.05356014892458916,
0.34804385900497437,
-0.1733258068561554,
0.08353143185377121,
0.35378649830818176,
-0.1324155181646347,
0.6616848707199097,
0.10471802204847336,
-0.24884247779846191,
-0.5107998251914978,
0.19388332962989807,
0.14570921659469604,
-0.005007595755159855,
0.6121323108673096,
0.7833235859870911,
-0.46973806619644165,
-0.1707618236541748,
-0.8870342373847961,
-0.49850621819496155,
-0.4760875701904297,
0.4137555658817291,
0.22227437794208527,
-0.41756436228752136,
0.15139783918857574,
0.028986508026719093,
0.23402974009513855,
0.375008225440979,
0.6883974075317383,
-0.2978593707084656,
0.702612042427063,
0.3231847882270813,
0.11659128963947296,
0.562309741973877,
-0.31442001461982727,
0.22218993306159973,
-0.4511054456233978,
-0.06119851395487785,
-0.4567549526691437,
-0.4154156446456909,
-0.687755823135376,
-0.47937747836112976,
-0.04890044778585434,
-0.4191244840621948,
-0.17466682195663452,
0.3389781415462494,
-0.4227190911769867,
0.5353776812553406,
0.30438223481178284,
-0.2965430021286011,
0.46546727418899536,
-0.07944764196872711,
0.5343601107597351,
-0.5538433194160461,
-0.6327852606773376,
-0.3685249090194702,
0.8392542600631714,
0.21387365460395813,
0.6010308265686035,
0.2963772416114807,
0.1554749310016632,
0.872316300868988,
0.479115754365921,
-0.9439415335655212,
0.49714186787605286,
0.2083771675825119,
-0.8492067456245422,
0.018692621961236,
-0.2680518329143524,
-0.9211589097976685,
0.2707378566265106,
0.0018835257505998015,
-0.6909528970718384,
0.2106505036354065,
0.2954750657081604,
-0.026667632162570953,
0.48786526918411255,
-0.8191772699356079,
0.7046433687210083,
-0.011050179600715637,
-0.4695466458797455,
-0.46556296944618225,
-0.4948822557926178,
0.4968375563621521,
-0.04788677394390106,
0.6000403761863708,
-0.2385183870792389,
-0.10395637154579163,
0.6523522734642029,
-0.19047024846076965,
1.0207589864730835,
-0.06255409121513367,
-0.28224173188209534,
0.47419947385787964,
0.24178433418273926,
0.29845350980758667,
0.07820789515972137,
0.1156536117196083,
0.5411703586578369,
0.16800323128700256,
-0.2999182641506195,
-0.3496324121952057,
0.6034975647926331,
-0.29701295495033264,
-0.6508575677871704,
-0.5820478200912476,
-0.32108423113822937,
-0.32570868730545044,
0.1500500738620758,
0.23880897462368011,
0.39982491731643677,
-0.31573253870010376,
0.401987761259079,
0.8635236620903015,
0.032556965947151184,
0.45440614223480225,
0.3839426338672638,
0.08404472470283508,
-0.20475436747074127,
1.1516252756118774,
0.46764129400253296,
0.252413272857666,
0.4252265691757202,
0.10734562575817108,
-0.6368958353996277,
-0.2419336587190628,
-0.18446296453475952,
0.38912156224250793,
-0.6182079911231995,
-0.2962344288825989,
-0.37762072682380676,
-0.16158123314380646,
-0.4524928629398346,
0.051602549850940704,
-0.44932228326797485,
-0.5670974850654602,
0.05751572921872139,
-0.14657120406627655,
0.2796514332294464,
0.6325223445892334,
-0.022845899686217308,
0.51362544298172,
-0.4796646535396576,
0.49280211329460144,
0.03736798092722893,
0.30615222454071045,
-0.08892961591482162,
-0.7077944874763489,
0.01193329319357872,
-0.01966766081750393,
-0.815825879573822,
-1.380888819694519,
0.5550702214241028,
0.12047451734542847,
0.4000019133090973,
0.8138930797576904,
0.4642636179924011,
0.42371174693107605,
-0.1320168375968933,
0.5649321675300598,
0.0998312458395958,
-1.0445952415466309,
0.42289191484451294,
-0.27737951278686523,
0.11661781370639801,
0.3185303807258606,
0.9187567234039307,
-0.8227353692054749,
-0.665763258934021,
-1.0797863006591797,
-0.8360152244567871,
0.5726456642150879,
0.5356375575065613,
0.14841529726982117,
-0.3048979341983795,
-0.03097730688750744,
-0.0388905294239521,
0.7264771461486816,
-0.9500182271003723,
-0.3281031847000122,
-0.3105325400829315,
-0.2736692726612091,
0.36539971828460693,
-0.21582794189453125,
-0.37535691261291504,
0.10274158418178558,
0.6795884370803833,
-0.2655853033065796,
-0.22052183747291565,
0.2903158664703369,
-0.39003750681877136,
0.08796726167201996,
-0.0006572197889909148,
0.261178582906723,
0.8686382174491882,
0.06753939390182495,
0.29998779296875,
0.22182293236255646,
-0.4800364077091217,
-0.2029394656419754,
0.056058064103126526,
-0.5236003398895264,
0.5288424491882324,
0.5453641414642334,
0.33930665254592896,
0.3869882822036743,
-0.9450286626815796,
0.6182611584663391,
0.08933249861001968,
-0.4348417818546295,
-0.574174165725708,
-0.16676725447177887,
0.07808726280927658,
0.12597303092479706,
0.4376136064529419,
-0.11279382556676865,
0.33351773023605347,
-0.8232510685920715,
0.30978792905807495,
0.6097492575645447,
-0.5614667534828186,
-0.3446703851222992,
0.48609480261802673,
0.08398280292749405,
-0.4679594933986664,
0.08206602185964584,
-0.13240675628185272,
-0.5825077295303345,
0.5250489115715027,
-0.021903160959482193,
0.5696464776992798,
-0.1260915845632553,
0.6516737341880798,
0.23892588913440704,
0.47518521547317505,
0.025230901315808296,
0.08079889416694641,
-0.1505679488182068,
-0.7765224575996399,
-0.6042302846908569,
-0.18744616210460663,
-0.2842629551887512,
0.3347899913787842,
-0.8222332000732422,
0.47950267791748047,
-0.5901457667350769,
-0.4839208424091339,
0.2585206627845764,
-0.06191681697964668,
-0.24345937371253967,
-0.028400719165802002,
0.3574881851673126,
0.717100203037262,
-0.7219115495681763,
0.3937361240386963,
0.5791702270507812,
-0.4590991139411926,
-0.26577499508857727,
0.48559749126434326,
0.43303239345550537,
-0.7157933712005615,
0.10785427689552307,
0.23547731339931488,
-0.12223431468009949,
0.09580454975366592,
-0.4873254895210266,
-0.9451026916503906,
0.4313974976539612,
0.34256038069725037,
-0.4615507125854492,
0.01969069242477417,
0.15548959374427795,
0.39543667435646057,
0.20248983800411224,
0.12499929964542389,
0.8762152194976807,
0.6394939422607422,
0.12099696695804596,
-0.5641405582427979,
0.05791808292269707,
0.13039585947990417,
-0.36000436544418335,
0.3462841808795929,
-0.9736621975898743,
0.21514593064785004,
0.06159790977835655,
-0.5300533771514893,
-0.594843327999115,
0.42446404695510864,
-0.09291210770606995,
0.40572717785835266,
0.4967336654663086,
0.43706732988357544,
0.575879693031311,
-0.24046427011489868,
0.9785625338554382,
-0.06649523973464966,
0.31233856081962585,
0.9672513604164124,
-0.09799408167600632,
0.5472838282585144,
0.6350859999656677,
-0.16572818160057068,
0.5962463021278381,
0.44092878699302673,
-0.09704070538282394,
0.4751572608947754,
0.09582453221082687,
0.18203262984752655,
-0.16577063500881195,
-0.3891712427139282,
-0.018031030893325806,
0.24362744390964508,
0.68019038438797,
-0.08238037675619125,
-0.494329035282135,
-0.004950891248881817,
0.2496679723262787,
0.49507269263267517,
-0.39662086963653564,
0.8934112191200256,
0.20990926027297974,
-0.9601062536239624,
0.7183341979980469,
0.1374899446964264,
0.5389722585678101,
-0.6115737557411194,
0.0015620447229593992,
-0.22577445209026337,
0.1448613554239273,
-0.33910897374153137,
-0.9193142652511597,
0.7043834328651428,
0.03875712677836418,
0.17875447869300842,
-0.1362142264842987,
0.6148694157600403,
-0.32031404972076416,
-0.2535838484764099,
0.23391228914260864,
0.5405721068382263,
-0.07630957663059235,
-0.3330841064453125,
-0.7904736995697021,
0.019147220999002457,
0.11994830518960953,
-0.18655741214752197,
0.21934571862220764,
0.5791891813278198,
-0.14785830676555634,
0.8271956443786621,
0.6045517921447754,
0.21599330008029938,
0.013732940889894962,
0.14750775694847107,
0.879828155040741,
-0.6559396386146545,
-0.32664695382118225,
-1.1460505723953247,
0.21291901171207428,
-0.5881249308586121,
-0.5238280296325684,
1.0329896211624146,
0.5175731778144836,
1.143302083015442,
0.32809045910835266,
0.7226423025131226,
-0.18186618387699127,
0.6591426134109497,
-0.2546830475330353,
0.42779695987701416,
-0.6063404679298401,
0.18659092485904694,
-0.3813658356666565,
-0.6696434020996094,
-0.17134612798690796,
0.7370865345001221,
-0.5842918753623962,
-0.19167004525661469,
0.7652954459190369,
0.6459147334098816,
0.03519073873758316,
0.17894434928894043,
0.27437224984169006,
0.4398592412471771,
0.3139120042324066,
0.1172315701842308,
0.8727152943611145,
-0.3207038342952728,
0.9954273104667664,
-0.1256338655948639,
-0.09645459800958633,
-0.32922086119651794,
-0.7402754426002502,
-0.9682052135467529,
-0.6329781413078308,
-0.5911460518836975,
-0.7209931015968323,
-0.03774282708764076,
0.7116479277610779,
0.5109495520591736,
-0.7348918914794922,
0.08364004641771317,
-0.1507284790277481,
0.6700699925422668,
-0.35321059823036194,
-0.3116300106048584,
0.2424742430448532,
-0.3267671465873718,
-1.0346753597259521,
-0.08642216771841049,
0.2362564653158188,
-0.30133357644081116,
-0.6151750683784485,
0.3804531991481781,
-0.552259624004364,
0.5561171174049377,
0.5327663421630859,
0.3102557957172394,
-0.6971229910850525,
-0.03410825505852699,
-0.3062482178211212,
0.19360016286373138,
0.15815407037734985,
0.8865216970443726,
-0.8459351658821106,
0.27862676978111267,
0.5104274153709412,
0.6718953251838684,
0.5235417485237122,
0.5025061368942261,
0.4748041331768036,
-0.9546098113059998,
0.23935171961784363,
0.5512179732322693,
0.22128142416477203,
0.6270841360092163,
0.03558681905269623,
0.46694138646125793,
0.6572431325912476,
-0.10447414964437485,
-1.0822056531906128,
0.4519442319869995,
-0.6916631460189819,
-0.38903138041496277,
1.14649498462677,
0.08277823776006699,
-0.36385127902030945,
-0.6273931264877319,
-0.30931612849235535,
-0.040880415588617325,
-0.4260372817516327,
1.2774767875671387,
0.8921350240707397,
0.31037265062332153,
0.005352065432816744,
-0.6117819547653198,
0.708604097366333,
0.4261215031147003,
-0.6090378165245056,
0.038294240832328796,
0.5426375269889832,
0.33012962341308594,
0.27656102180480957,
0.409079372882843,
0.09652487188577652,
0.22648078203201294,
-0.0684145912528038,
-0.2122577428817749,
0.29947397112846375,
0.10142295062541962,
0.15399156510829926,
0.24822428822517395,
-0.35057222843170166,
-0.15096770226955414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09923v1 | A Dataset of Open-Domain Question Answering with Multiple-Span Answers | 2024-02-15T13:03:57 | 2024-02-15T13:03:57 | Zhiyi Luo, Yingying Zhang, Shuyun Luo, Ying Zhao, Wentao Lyu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multi-span answer extraction, also known as the task of multi-span question
answering (MSQA), is critical for real-world applications, as it requires
extracting multiple pieces of information from a text to answer complex
questions. Despite the active studies and rapid progress in English MSQA
research, there is a notable lack of publicly available MSQA benchmark in
Chinese. Previous efforts for constructing MSQA datasets predominantly
emphasized entity-centric contextualization, resulting in a bias towards
collecting factoid questions and potentially overlooking questions requiring
more detailed descriptive responses. To overcome these limitations, we present
CLEAN, a comprehensive Chinese multi-span question answering dataset that
involves a wide range of open-domain subjects with a substantial number of
instances requiring descriptive answers. Additionally, we provide established
models from relevant literature as baselines for CLEAN. Experimental results
and analysis show the characteristics and challenge of the newly proposed CLEAN
dataset for the community. Our dataset, CLEAN, will be publicly released at
zhiyiluo.site/misc/clean_v1.0_ sample.json. | [
-0.4085889160633087,
-0.7461110949516296,
0.1475846767425537,
0.06912163645029068,
0.09824573248624802,
-0.259633868932724,
-0.12887690961360931,
-0.4819726049900055,
0.05171821266412735,
0.3877733051776886,
-0.688667893409729,
-0.26059240102767944,
-0.09844973683357239,
0.12999336421489716,
-0.21859478950500488,
1.0315501689910889,
-0.1446077674627304,
-0.016736680641770363,
0.13566820323467255,
-0.2783687114715576,
-0.40922221541404724,
-0.24999423325061798,
-0.6078556776046753,
0.2933386564254761,
0.6377972364425659,
0.45913004875183105,
0.551328182220459,
0.6155585050582886,
0.13833275437355042,
0.18631745874881744,
0.11408834159374237,
0.6282323002815247,
-0.1476772278547287,
0.10574983805418015,
0.00892164371907711,
-0.13017600774765015,
-0.30948707461357117,
0.1351422220468521,
0.587942361831665,
0.7598920464515686,
-0.1806631237268448,
0.4843252897262573,
-0.013982162810862064,
0.30935442447662354,
-0.9296332597732544,
-0.2276613712310791,
-0.691206693649292,
-0.14521338045597076,
-0.40735042095184326,
-0.003055562498047948,
-0.23561447858810425,
-0.4902326762676239,
-0.09931593388319016,
-0.9610036015510559,
0.08816810697317123,
-0.13164207339286804,
1.461633563041687,
0.09922392666339874,
-0.8125306963920593,
0.06614066660404205,
-0.5270487666130066,
0.7909958958625793,
-0.6274026036262512,
0.045012857764959335,
0.23845970630645752,
0.5607708096504211,
0.20909419655799866,
-0.6518762707710266,
-0.42542603611946106,
0.45066869258880615,
-0.09334075450897217,
0.44990530610084534,
0.062150392681360245,
-0.10533305257558823,
0.0009167917887680233,
0.34859392046928406,
-0.538080632686615,
-0.14234770834445953,
-0.828278124332428,
-0.3495508134365082,
0.6738914251327515,
0.3522088825702667,
0.643671989440918,
-0.2491445392370224,
-0.863281786441803,
0.33237335085868835,
-0.7379488348960876,
0.5227440595626831,
0.14590799808502197,
0.6003494262695312,
0.19252797961235046,
0.5806750059127808,
-0.557349681854248,
0.4703253507614136,
-0.5159958600997925,
-0.05372285470366478,
0.4108686149120331,
-0.799707293510437,
-0.28365424275398254,
-0.2389514148235321,
0.6887788772583008,
0.12217968702316284,
0.46561068296432495,
0.08848211914300919,
-0.24026772379875183,
-0.3409378230571747,
0.23405423760414124,
-0.8749260306358337,
-0.4749675691127777,
0.6904330849647522,
-0.5032575726509094,
0.08083398640155792,
0.32625487446784973,
-0.7170459628105164,
-0.3491051197052002,
-0.3294583261013031,
0.3577282428741455,
-0.3824036419391632,
-0.5560694336891174,
0.2658809721469879,
-0.2864217758178711,
0.37048792839050293,
0.6424432396888733,
-0.4774022102355957,
0.26471126079559326,
0.43298348784446716,
0.49480941891670227,
-0.04188285395503044,
-0.3320353627204895,
-0.778932511806488,
0.016904955729842186,
-0.397636353969574,
0.5499715209007263,
-0.10371343046426773,
0.3104735314846039,
0.13568216562271118,
0.022445615381002426,
-0.34184515476226807,
-0.6938961148262024,
0.6317745447158813,
-0.5667478442192078,
0.39223918318748474,
-0.4982590973377228,
-0.26916149258613586,
-0.09060689061880112,
0.36259007453918457,
-0.9805706739425659,
1.2658954858779907,
-0.281189888715744,
-0.7912986874580383,
0.42052972316741943,
-0.6571741700172424,
-0.28203150629997253,
0.016628220677375793,
0.07518590986728668,
-0.23284727334976196,
-0.19048187136650085,
0.445993572473526,
0.3307105600833893,
0.0705043375492096,
0.3176599442958832,
-0.36022090911865234,
-0.46123966574668884,
0.08363614231348038,
-0.5489120483398438,
1.2766903638839722,
0.6321039795875549,
0.0013433486456051469,
0.22814011573791504,
-0.5875760316848755,
0.41635462641716003,
-0.03826376423239708,
-0.3846016526222229,
-0.5009925961494446,
-0.1203983798623085,
0.042272988706827164,
0.6844460368156433,
0.34098926186561584,
-0.717517077922821,
-0.024683479219675064,
-0.01688094064593315,
0.13195639848709106,
0.790806770324707,
0.056573763489723206,
-0.14690633118152618,
-0.4791979491710663,
0.23806193470954895,
0.13733841478824615,
0.11402052640914917,
-0.4812508523464203,
-0.4351693093776703,
-0.48196062445640564,
-0.7610152959823608,
0.16488970816135406,
0.4577849805355072,
-0.8302962779998779,
0.05966152995824814,
-0.2622782289981842,
-0.3288089632987976,
-0.8982190489768982,
0.038384586572647095,
0.5529769062995911,
0.26091793179512024,
0.7686260938644409,
0.2963862419128418,
-0.2051251381635666,
-0.9881131649017334,
-0.37849414348602295,
0.2744755148887634,
-0.3556695282459259,
0.30738168954849243,
0.6416810750961304,
0.6102308034896851,
0.8184957504272461,
-0.7851249575614929,
-0.24477916955947876,
0.032749008387327194,
-0.10817399621009827,
0.05110721290111542,
0.11400727182626724,
0.1835155040025711,
-0.9871881604194641,
-0.30934280157089233,
-0.1600969284772873,
-0.7487168312072754,
0.10550620406866074,
0.01687009632587433,
-0.3943832814693451,
-0.37119704484939575,
0.411731481552124,
-0.38931477069854736,
0.13835442066192627,
0.3117738962173462,
-0.3012625575065613,
0.9638704657554626,
0.17215514183044434,
0.31472229957580566,
-1.2409886121749878,
0.63116854429245,
0.11008201539516449,
0.11547999829053879,
-1.074454665184021,
0.3696233034133911,
0.37279725074768066,
0.1365678459405899,
-0.7843849658966064,
0.5957218408584595,
-0.42897072434425354,
0.06113502383232117,
-0.06510400027036667,
0.43427249789237976,
0.35847872495651245,
0.5913366079330444,
0.03606726601719856,
0.9430760145187378,
0.14821328222751617,
-0.6479291915893555,
-0.037203360348939896,
0.44767144322395325,
-0.09055135399103165,
0.2228206843137741,
-0.8714098334312439,
-0.07711635529994965,
-0.17781779170036316,
0.0934954360127449,
-1.1318795680999756,
-0.35645732283592224,
0.020884593948721886,
-0.3197457492351532,
-0.17782163619995117,
0.1812310665845871,
-0.5073282718658447,
-0.26931706070899963,
-0.6818796396255493,
0.3627461791038513,
-0.09291323274374008,
-0.6530760526657104,
0.042702656239271164,
0.2752366364002228,
-0.1936805695295334,
-1.0884697437286377,
-0.2694622576236725,
-0.3126713037490845,
-0.16077803075313568,
-0.721308708190918,
0.005147002171725035,
-0.04004509001970291,
-0.07063859701156616,
-0.09214971214532852,
-0.45493730902671814,
-0.5918425917625427,
0.3682054877281189,
-0.1361394077539444,
0.39247262477874756,
-0.35393092036247253,
0.3860813081264496,
0.07388831675052643,
0.28253188729286194,
0.059753429144620895,
0.11112814396619797,
0.22812019288539886,
-0.08028150349855423,
-0.05031607300043106,
-0.2209368199110031,
0.3763706088066101,
0.2858816087245941,
-0.9238135814666748,
0.5716794729232788,
0.4778672158718109,
-0.9303129315376282,
-0.36045417189598083,
0.030756637454032898,
0.014871683903038502,
-0.42813122272491455,
0.3738026022911072,
-0.7306906580924988,
-0.7455072402954102,
0.45451581478118896,
0.08134078979492188,
0.6738179922103882,
0.45126551389694214,
0.2695956230163574,
-0.21191886067390442,
0.6681145429611206,
0.05498697608709335,
0.02899664081633091,
-0.01025382149964571,
0.2611851692199707,
-0.24157334864139557,
-0.8386527299880981,
-0.22219079732894897,
-0.8740999102592468,
0.0358927845954895,
-0.15492083132266998,
-0.04060344770550728,
0.2011042684316635,
0.31487801671028137,
-0.7518377304077148,
0.250042200088501,
-0.3351553678512573,
0.3009342849254608,
0.6674025058746338,
0.29743021726608276,
0.4072496294975281,
-0.39413607120513916,
0.006327278446406126,
0.18669389188289642,
-0.22481946647167206,
-0.5467216968536377,
0.8815922737121582,
0.16511473059654236,
0.32256603240966797,
0.3041459321975708,
0.43149855732917786,
-0.0719834491610527,
0.13756337761878967,
-0.32278013229370117,
0.2631942927837372,
-0.2730599045753479,
-1.1313055753707886,
-0.7139852643013,
-0.44504350423812866,
-1.037569522857666,
0.7500125765800476,
-0.11820715665817261,
-0.7164542078971863,
-0.3365147113800049,
-0.1503799855709076,
-0.49695339798927307,
0.4058164656162262,
-0.3768908679485321,
0.9641927480697632,
0.03158760443329811,
-0.13198304176330566,
0.6047452688217163,
-0.9556700587272644,
0.9788766503334045,
-0.1523849368095398,
0.26413944363594055,
-0.330706387758255,
0.0628659799695015,
0.7295681238174438,
-0.2643548846244812,
0.6526228785514832,
-0.390910804271698,
-0.2962202727794647,
0.3200366795063019,
-0.18044805526733398,
0.0683101937174797,
-0.07034068554639816,
-0.05537934973835945,
-0.013492287136614323,
0.36855408549308777,
-0.6543022990226746,
-0.22677373886108398,
0.3146636188030243,
-0.7935822606086731,
-0.34700867533683777,
-0.0830899327993393,
-0.4825074374675751,
-0.39011460542678833,
0.5493084788322449,
-0.019815336912870407,
0.4041418135166168,
-0.13169613480567932,
-0.012766683474183083,
0.7718703150749207,
-0.47973814606666565,
0.4679628610610962,
0.2164802849292755,
0.018745871260762215,
-0.33603739738464355,
0.665410578250885,
0.0013113482855260372,
0.34639212489128113,
0.3272240161895752,
0.06970753520727158,
-0.3289753198623657,
-0.18515022099018097,
-0.7795469164848328,
0.1168503388762474,
-0.631946861743927,
-0.2694167494773865,
-0.5656450390815735,
-0.39819565415382385,
-0.24039329588413239,
0.25135406851768494,
-0.3543948233127594,
-0.35922953486442566,
-0.015692228451371193,
-0.162563756108284,
-0.11763254553079605,
0.44753769040107727,
0.32502058148384094,
-0.19268469512462616,
-0.980957567691803,
0.8924728035926819,
-0.027021119371056557,
0.37213215231895447,
-0.0972287729382515,
-0.13102398812770844,
-0.32616811990737915,
0.3642711043357849,
-0.23024898767471313,
-0.8451454639434814,
0.11755440384149551,
0.3739681839942932,
0.6355623602867126,
0.45651277899742126,
0.512868344783783,
0.7374793291091919,
-0.5073477625846863,
1.0377016067504883,
0.006295889150351286,
-0.8045140504837036,
0.43946364521980286,
-0.4040755331516266,
0.3547966778278351,
0.8941788077354431,
0.5656222105026245,
-0.8060104846954346,
-0.3970176577568054,
-0.1415470689535141,
-0.8191603422164917,
0.6320244073867798,
0.11165159195661545,
-0.012977704405784607,
0.1667415201663971,
0.10872449725866318,
0.34062719345092773,
0.2967208921909332,
-0.47124314308166504,
-0.5698997378349304,
-0.36924824118614197,
-0.12896282970905304,
0.3357013165950775,
0.2981491684913635,
-0.33110737800598145,
0.1149403527379036,
0.558871865272522,
-0.18059559166431427,
0.11859862506389618,
0.025356268510222435,
0.014643881469964981,
0.24600805342197418,
0.41773781180381775,
0.44643643498420715,
0.3679044842720032,
-0.0024673198349773884,
0.26256299018859863,
0.01198508683592081,
-0.44646283984184265,
-0.03212811052799225,
0.19469362497329712,
-0.26903748512268066,
-0.11265743523836136,
0.19305886328220367,
0.05691276863217354,
-0.25733980536460876,
-0.6793671250343323,
0.7766210436820984,
0.0765010192990303,
-0.503696858882904,
-0.15501810610294342,
-0.16523998975753784,
0.11962243914604187,
-0.2832128703594208,
0.5420515537261963,
0.16628842055797577,
0.4784783720970154,
-0.2599353790283203,
0.5735616683959961,
0.2929384112358093,
-0.4883255958557129,
-0.18527103960514069,
0.9631011486053467,
0.13877500593662262,
0.49781519174575806,
0.9810732007026672,
0.11153636127710342,
-0.3742786645889282,
0.6258153915405273,
0.26297351717948914,
0.49003151059150696,
-0.021279485896229744,
0.2444063276052475,
0.6778720021247864,
0.30797770619392395,
0.19833877682685852,
0.6884339451789856,
0.1101367399096489,
-0.8702991008758545,
-0.44179171323776245,
-0.2993174195289612,
-0.22792178392410278,
0.29377856850624084,
-0.9181788563728333,
0.22507770359516144,
-0.07870768755674362,
0.3006913959980011,
0.17180341482162476,
0.3182123303413391,
-0.3849929869174957,
0.6664956212043762,
0.26500919461250305,
1.1846184730529785,
-0.7950595617294312,
0.8766762614250183,
0.5831275582313538,
-0.6652665138244629,
-1.129988193511963,
-0.07749291509389877,
0.20313216745853424,
-0.4935087561607361,
0.20736147463321686,
0.5544089674949646,
-0.0862099751830101,
-0.5200170278549194,
-0.6733279824256897,
-0.7268469929695129,
1.1687061786651611,
0.042190853506326675,
0.37235236167907715,
-0.05625591799616814,
0.11383181810379028,
0.3062448501586914,
0.06192079558968544,
0.3552301228046417,
0.18523381650447845,
0.5465194582939148,
-0.28590911626815796,
-1.0110048055648804,
0.4207632839679718,
-0.7404539585113525,
-0.37548941373825073,
0.2549278140068054,
-0.9706131815910339,
1.0798544883728027,
-0.1991240233182907,
-0.5014758706092834,
0.3377247154712677,
0.6344597339630127,
0.6429301500320435,
0.3940134644508362,
0.3233283758163452,
0.09703068435192108,
1.0708866119384766,
-0.3467906713485718,
0.5729910135269165,
-0.13068115711212158,
0.1883341521024704,
1.2295769453048706,
-0.4333434998989105,
0.9093700647354126,
0.25037533044815063,
0.05575141683220863,
0.2632960379123688,
0.7404645681381226,
0.03211308643221855,
0.4056694507598877,
0.521467924118042,
-0.29891151189804077,
-0.1938183754682541,
-0.08000405877828598,
-0.1994704008102417,
0.4605071246623993,
0.12064912915229797,
0.013929955661296844,
-0.3918662369251251,
-0.31120842695236206,
0.3574715256690979,
0.17229077219963074,
-0.3166043758392334,
0.4789455533027649,
-0.16025041043758392,
-0.6980419158935547,
0.30755966901779175,
0.16534793376922607,
0.6550657749176025,
-0.6427397131919861,
-0.24982444941997528,
-0.26441070437431335,
-0.06657861173152924,
-0.35910433530807495,
-0.8760165572166443,
0.18288321793079376,
-0.19025154411792755,
-0.06204627454280853,
-0.10606159269809723,
0.5881880521774292,
-0.6223097443580627,
0.23158004879951477,
-0.0019198240479454398,
1.0859180688858032,
0.2298254817724228,
-0.172567218542099,
-0.527586817741394,
-0.6130594611167908,
-0.10804528743028641,
-0.41615134477615356,
0.12032988667488098,
0.6599723696708679,
-0.20093655586242676,
0.5630673170089722,
0.6697183847427368,
-0.15866020321846008,
0.45408642292022705,
-0.03462746739387512,
0.7870806455612183,
-0.5520492196083069,
-0.21922847628593445,
-0.28873029351234436,
0.8354596495628357,
-0.17713573575019836,
-0.7617970705032349,
0.8921793699264526,
0.8885456919670105,
0.7031044960021973,
-0.016773859038949013,
0.9655676484107971,
-0.006761899683624506,
0.6968214511871338,
-0.36238449811935425,
0.7599396705627441,
-0.8059327006340027,
-0.07838119566440582,
-0.21167512238025665,
-0.37325790524482727,
-0.30365633964538574,
-0.2312743216753006,
0.3255312442779541,
0.12126871943473816,
0.5984305739402771,
0.5150283575057983,
-0.054429005831480026,
0.31453150510787964,
0.30243736505508423,
-0.19523124396800995,
0.33976614475250244,
0.7624946236610413,
0.7724791169166565,
-0.6269974112510681,
0.8032318949699402,
-0.18953828513622284,
-0.10173384845256805,
0.4204743206501007,
-0.4217197000980377,
-0.6057835817337036,
-0.6478708982467651,
-0.03341250121593475,
-0.3568742871284485,
-0.030296893790364265,
0.6020991206169128,
0.6071329116821289,
-1.0465562343597412,
0.051714107394218445,
0.5646751523017883,
-0.11608006805181503,
-0.7930997610092163,
-0.28670424222946167,
0.8007183074951172,
-0.5838661789894104,
-0.8494129776954651,
0.26353099942207336,
-0.15062440931797028,
-0.47080332040786743,
0.17144402861595154,
0.223063126206398,
-0.4543454647064209,
0.20209014415740967,
0.3990369737148285,
0.3689158260822296,
-0.4390839636325836,
-0.41961175203323364,
0.6235405206680298,
-0.5159713625907898,
0.17829251289367676,
0.4841948449611664,
-0.33735185861587524,
0.28422224521636963,
0.1667718142271042,
0.7441595196723938,
0.11963320523500443,
0.46028780937194824,
0.39055243134498596,
-1.1260168552398682,
-0.6763182282447815,
-0.08396963030099869,
0.4374217689037323,
-0.10140454769134521,
-0.21169178187847137,
0.4987906217575073,
-0.14067940413951874,
-0.2738908529281616,
-0.43977078795433044,
0.1677124947309494,
-0.8920924067497253,
-0.7097325325012207,
1.3214890956878662,
-0.4779130220413208,
0.06785064935684204,
-0.6659967303276062,
-0.25199565291404724,
0.11075472086668015,
-0.32795247435569763,
0.2495008409023285,
0.6285315155982971,
-0.05510924011468887,
-0.023144369944930077,
-0.6726129651069641,
0.46485644578933716,
0.18137936294078827,
-1.3611005544662476,
0.4517323672771454,
0.6590337157249451,
0.37975579500198364,
0.07023579627275467,
0.8752789497375488,
-0.3449077308177948,
0.49342799186706543,
0.1359001249074936,
0.19975194334983826,
-0.19346314668655396,
-0.6784399151802063,
-0.23051665723323822,
0.7400215268135071,
-0.2596946656703949,
-0.6878711581230164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09916v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09916v1 | BUSTER: a "BUSiness Transaction Entity Recognition" dataset | 2024-02-15T12:39:57 | 2024-02-15T12:39:57 | Andrea Zugarini, Andrew Zamai, Marco Ernandes, Leonardo Rigutini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Albeit Natural Language Processing has seen major breakthroughs in the last
few years, transferring such advances into real-world business cases can be
challenging. One of the reasons resides in the displacement between popular
benchmarks and actual data. Lack of supervision, unbalanced classes, noisy data
and long documents often affect real problems in vertical domains such as
finance, law and health. To support industry-oriented research, we present
BUSTER, a BUSiness Transaction Entity Recognition dataset. The dataset consists
of 3779 manually annotated documents on financial transactions. We establish
several baselines exploiting both general-purpose and domain-specific language
models. The best performing model is also used to automatically annotate 6196
documents, which we release as an additional silver corpus to BUSTER. | [
-0.39084187150001526,
-0.9068256616592407,
0.31575241684913635,
0.030131615698337555,
-0.39777836203575134,
0.10284851491451263,
0.16457104682922363,
-1.1811610460281372,
0.2489619255065918,
0.8752423524856567,
-0.003977129235863686,
-0.20338957011699677,
-0.6622126698493958,
0.234024316072464,
-0.683488130569458,
1.3295822143554688,
0.2301565706729889,
-0.23523147404193878,
0.043187592178583145,
-0.11043399572372437,
-0.8042418360710144,
-0.46989232301712036,
-1.100426435470581,
-0.5497137904167175,
0.2630971372127533,
-0.03284012898802757,
0.4148584008216858,
0.7385074496269226,
0.5572919845581055,
0.3601192831993103,
-0.012907186523079872,
0.023973392322659492,
-0.21247825026512146,
-0.12405858188867569,
-0.42982202768325806,
-0.17852027714252472,
-0.5308403372764587,
-0.13329178094863892,
0.657841682434082,
0.9240999817848206,
-0.16003641486167908,
0.1995193213224411,
-0.316886305809021,
0.7524036169052124,
-0.4033541679382324,
0.3843117952346802,
-0.3737608790397644,
-0.20384730398654938,
-0.5296033620834351,
0.2530563771724701,
-0.6793754696846008,
-0.30196207761764526,
0.2996441125869751,
-0.4173017740249634,
0.13695858418941498,
0.33082008361816406,
1.4213026762008667,
-0.025076165795326233,
-0.732418954372406,
-0.4827735424041748,
-1.037074327468872,
0.3924884796142578,
-0.13132837414741516,
0.43387526273727417,
0.34904295206069946,
0.36773186922073364,
-0.364841103553772,
-0.8805339932441711,
-0.204793781042099,
0.180507630109787,
-0.44594672322273254,
-0.05521196499466896,
-0.7065229415893555,
-0.1027635782957077,
0.4756801128387451,
0.24124109745025635,
-0.2600095272064209,
0.16655340790748596,
-0.7158268690109253,
-0.32216987013816833,
0.5857186913490295,
0.19810548424720764,
-0.24635249376296997,
0.01892939582467079,
-0.3495073914527893,
0.0878102257847786,
-0.4050367474555969,
0.20588316023349762,
0.19719402492046356,
0.23769979178905487,
0.12387676537036896,
0.1867261528968811,
-0.09133075177669525,
1.2482320070266724,
0.17456163465976715,
-0.36822548508644104,
0.2820282578468323,
-0.04895607382059097,
-0.7019327878952026,
0.43852698802948,
0.34873059391975403,
0.044689226895570755,
0.11330999433994293,
-0.36450883746147156,
-0.3895460367202759,
0.04166925325989723,
0.4506065249443054,
-0.7320399284362793,
-0.19523538649082184,
0.37575292587280273,
-0.2709363102912903,
0.03327401727437973,
0.3271985352039337,
-0.6607840061187744,
-0.733493447303772,
-0.8104231953620911,
0.26797574758529663,
-0.34498336911201477,
-0.1782916933298111,
0.1454688459634781,
-0.5028049349784851,
0.21903389692306519,
0.3395671248435974,
-0.5479217767715454,
0.3638038635253906,
0.9532409310340881,
0.6115927696228027,
0.30809852480888367,
0.017455628141760826,
-0.7138137221336365,
0.7544357180595398,
-0.5826650857925415,
1.0412546396255493,
-0.45583534240722656,
-0.29517561197280884,
-0.2199225127696991,
-0.019243551418185234,
0.06092270091176033,
-0.9727891683578491,
0.46423104405403137,
-0.43240225315093994,
-0.1731623113155365,
-0.08092297613620758,
-0.8734513521194458,
-0.07784613966941833,
0.32472917437553406,
-0.8269951343536377,
0.6125398874282837,
0.29565584659576416,
-0.7164366245269775,
0.8970013856887817,
-0.5616133213043213,
-0.65107661485672,
0.6129837036132812,
-0.10887806117534637,
-0.5904448628425598,
0.1629783809185028,
-0.18899644911289215,
0.38686126470565796,
-0.2688256502151489,
0.4674528241157532,
0.009273369796574116,
-0.5512503981590271,
0.4474314749240875,
-0.03809240832924843,
0.9155059456825256,
0.04425227269530296,
0.035822607576847076,
-0.4739346504211426,
-1.181704044342041,
-0.6354500651359558,
0.12277143448591232,
-0.3360409438610077,
-0.8065001964569092,
-0.23868083953857422,
-0.12330760806798935,
-0.14729389548301697,
0.24438029527664185,
-0.5456497669219971,
0.42850732803344727,
-0.24542078375816345,
0.12749657034873962,
0.7180656790733337,
0.16916649043560028,
0.030651293694972992,
-0.3425474166870117,
0.19890283048152924,
0.4943718910217285,
-0.03554338589310646,
0.06613148003816605,
-0.4736156165599823,
-0.7841812372207642,
-0.8112047910690308,
0.6425945162773132,
0.5958955883979797,
-0.25231650471687317,
0.5309486389160156,
-0.43582117557525635,
-0.5467230677604675,
-0.6880791187286377,
-0.04330599308013916,
0.11368672549724579,
0.8817096948623657,
0.21743392944335938,
-0.45257842540740967,
-0.7437555193901062,
-1.3311635255813599,
-0.36209380626678467,
-0.2582807242870331,
-0.0963430106639862,
0.19764353334903717,
0.28078410029411316,
-0.6696394681930542,
1.0955405235290527,
-0.568496584892273,
-0.6258631348609924,
-0.16464151442050934,
0.6748456358909607,
0.4410172998905182,
0.3242875635623932,
0.44753846526145935,
-0.8101299405097961,
-0.25531190633773804,
0.15660186111927032,
-0.4826866090297699,
0.0027085174806416035,
-0.6199208498001099,
-0.3780582845211029,
0.5468401312828064,
0.551040768623352,
-0.3857038915157318,
0.642765462398529,
-0.12677717208862305,
-0.5687291622161865,
0.22016550600528717,
-0.03966926410794258,
-0.15742796659469604,
-1.0216467380523682,
0.31527042388916016,
0.16290955245494843,
-0.552361249923706,
-0.8009101152420044,
-0.6145145297050476,
0.24780584871768951,
-0.007088277488946915,
-0.021073991432785988,
0.49345162510871887,
-0.36050504446029663,
-0.34772059321403503,
-0.1275724619626999,
0.09048053622245789,
0.2599915564060211,
0.1295868307352066,
0.1866724193096161,
0.4579869210720062,
0.6090701222419739,
-0.8604112267494202,
0.4403128921985626,
0.41732674837112427,
-0.3404221534729004,
1.302230954170227,
-0.3257068395614624,
0.030082665383815765,
-0.358916699886322,
0.08675700426101685,
-0.4853367209434509,
-0.16033650934696198,
0.23430417478084564,
-0.17318597435951233,
0.6337761282920837,
-0.724007248878479,
-0.5347950458526611,
-0.23192454874515533,
0.17249862849712372,
-0.16524532437324524,
0.37479496002197266,
-0.4197395443916321,
0.9674437046051025,
0.594961941242218,
0.023125767707824707,
-0.44785070419311523,
-0.7037166357040405,
0.4779997169971466,
-0.32141444087028503,
-0.33631280064582825,
0.14124102890491486,
0.45483067631721497,
-0.3263600766658783,
0.15436942875385284,
-0.13217981159687042,
-0.1946369856595993,
0.2635917067527771,
0.21714036166667938,
0.6061893701553345,
0.14492662250995636,
0.16355763375759125,
-0.2909175157546997,
-0.5007115602493286,
0.20438911020755768,
-0.44351232051849365,
0.08229922503232956,
-0.09742554277181625,
0.18487423658370972,
-0.049267321825027466,
0.28160202503204346,
0.2519093453884125,
-0.1921369582414627,
0.7952288389205933,
0.5281393527984619,
-0.8404247760772705,
-0.046632587909698486,
-0.5926346778869629,
0.41108438372612,
-0.4976746737957001,
0.05528969317674637,
-0.4574469029903412,
-0.47936776280403137,
0.4508054852485657,
-0.22202475368976593,
0.21203197538852692,
0.3344316780567169,
0.43887731432914734,
0.020237604156136513,
0.5045883655548096,
0.6454651355743408,
-0.2870507538318634,
0.5094926953315735,
-0.14546532928943634,
0.8610824346542358,
-0.5300385355949402,
-0.44969895482063293,
-0.7148242592811584,
-0.19898562133312225,
-0.44217807054519653,
0.1175537258386612,
0.23456907272338867,
0.10038785636425018,
-0.05593115836381912,
0.7862448692321777,
-0.2940375804901123,
0.5320173501968384,
0.4758871793746948,
-0.40348151326179504,
0.3308902382850647,
-0.11819253861904144,
0.07673141360282898,
0.1526816040277481,
-0.003124762326478958,
-0.4841979742050171,
0.6232550740242004,
0.14637407660484314,
0.6650739908218384,
0.24688774347305298,
0.8076277375221252,
0.46872761845588684,
0.4944503605365753,
-0.5687239766120911,
0.5341808795928955,
-0.09651771932840347,
-0.8983131647109985,
0.03386655077338219,
-0.771346390247345,
-1.489962100982666,
-0.2297128587961197,
-0.07799600809812546,
-0.9584786891937256,
0.396726131439209,
0.15191777050495148,
-0.13290496170520782,
0.09373672306537628,
-0.9643163681030273,
0.8920777440071106,
0.06071578338742256,
-0.2265917956829071,
0.1831321269273758,
-0.3612559139728546,
0.26099586486816406,
-0.257791131734848,
0.34340235590934753,
-0.15654219686985016,
0.08919604867696762,
0.5735728144645691,
-0.2335653156042099,
0.5424988269805908,
-0.15801919996738434,
-0.030815405771136284,
0.30482980608940125,
0.3369755744934082,
0.5596565008163452,
0.10563403367996216,
0.23619574308395386,
0.2123904526233673,
0.04336027428507805,
-0.4264298975467682,
-0.42206838726997375,
0.2096177488565445,
-0.21009321510791779,
-0.2407887727022171,
-0.8699620962142944,
-0.2432687133550644,
-0.1921486258506775,
0.3618590533733368,
0.05367221310734749,
0.5916759967803955,
-0.0775008574128151,
0.08059781789779663,
0.3907667100429535,
0.2948056161403656,
0.45916685461997986,
0.8616905212402344,
-0.12083064019680023,
-0.1747250258922577,
1.0377451181411743,
0.47511765360832214,
-0.20427305996418,
0.12635698914527893,
-0.17545688152313232,
-0.3930928111076355,
-0.396597683429718,
-0.6506651639938354,
0.29835450649261475,
-0.7475964426994324,
-0.5618308782577515,
-0.6086544394493103,
-0.09896288812160492,
-0.500599205493927,
-0.3495377004146576,
-0.20017215609550476,
-0.24708566069602966,
-0.21586322784423828,
-0.25136303901672363,
0.3571002781391144,
0.9308204650878906,
-0.053880464285612106,
-0.15712790191173553,
-0.9934069514274597,
0.5461757779121399,
0.1945878267288208,
0.7533938884735107,
-0.25745412707328796,
-0.22910939157009125,
-0.6790323853492737,
-0.3495679795742035,
0.11329429596662521,
-0.7849609851837158,
0.3060195744037628,
0.07390838116407394,
0.464083194732666,
0.7017797827720642,
0.011629140004515648,
1.0140104293823242,
-0.10583052784204483,
0.3263571858406067,
-0.02565818466246128,
-0.9712482690811157,
0.4630158543586731,
-0.06339409202337265,
-0.0991181805729866,
0.6257836222648621,
0.5275716185569763,
-0.7639446258544922,
-0.2758788466453552,
-0.8451716899871826,
-0.8412452936172485,
0.7223209738731384,
0.08102241903543472,
-0.28271403908729553,
-0.09010061621665955,
0.46583792567253113,
0.07044163346290588,
0.3360154330730438,
-0.5719773769378662,
-0.07049351930618286,
0.07521897554397583,
-0.17787352204322815,
0.27530014514923096,
0.08811521530151367,
-0.013729862868785858,
-0.2135322391986847,
0.8707807064056396,
0.18098841607570648,
0.14837104082107544,
-0.026956617832183838,
-0.17288726568222046,
0.05298212170600891,
0.056738149374723434,
-0.021036988124251366,
0.7242858409881592,
-0.4093893766403198,
0.024921797215938568,
-0.06442220509052277,
-0.7731055021286011,
0.07580865919589996,
0.49135762453079224,
-0.4098479449748993,
0.016056735068559647,
0.2980840504169464,
0.666752278804779,
-0.18635571002960205,
-0.8264144659042358,
0.20482516288757324,
-0.20128832757472992,
0.19048888981342316,
-0.7354711294174194,
0.028635041788220406,
-0.028343239799141884,
0.13937166333198547,
0.26888856291770935,
0.0622883141040802,
0.5266106128692627,
-0.7000236511230469,
0.1587623506784439,
0.013596780598163605,
-0.30931004881858826,
0.008884446695446968,
0.2785879373550415,
0.0763215497136116,
-0.3578141927719116,
0.9110687971115112,
-0.7151791453361511,
-0.16281558573246002,
0.5478549003601074,
0.4716639816761017,
0.7861447334289551,
0.24901708960533142,
-0.12652629613876343,
0.3986963629722595,
0.33321765065193176,
-0.1953926384449005,
0.06767908483743668,
0.21487216651439667,
-0.5805515050888062,
-0.2278810292482376,
-0.6101289391517639,
-0.6184171438217163,
0.16299909353256226,
-0.8437050580978394,
0.6420542597770691,
-0.5947136282920837,
-0.41785380244255066,
0.48492613434791565,
0.09614256769418716,
-0.6727416515350342,
0.18409773707389832,
0.23752373456954956,
0.5683435797691345,
-0.6885678172111511,
0.8488616943359375,
0.7121163010597229,
-0.45836347341537476,
-0.3798905909061432,
-0.3671892583370209,
-0.010935642756521702,
-0.27946051955223083,
0.285709410905838,
0.4810708463191986,
0.20510482788085938,
-0.08029952645301819,
-0.30914127826690674,
-0.4937053918838501,
0.8398610949516296,
0.30193012952804565,
-0.6429556012153625,
0.13780458271503448,
0.26109427213668823,
0.5206568241119385,
-0.228458434343338,
-0.28089895844459534,
1.3105343580245972,
0.4927431344985962,
-0.03823783993721008,
-0.5436757802963257,
-0.3063586950302124,
-0.3062650263309479,
-0.1862802952528,
0.717808723449707,
-0.483812153339386,
0.6741604208946228,
0.43383079767227173,
-0.11873161792755127,
-0.6469442248344421,
0.4382990896701813,
0.10201064497232437,
0.5936310887336731,
0.5651333332061768,
0.9014171957969666,
1.056350827217102,
-0.32232677936553955,
0.9965947866439819,
0.058566924184560776,
0.06789929419755936,
1.0777286291122437,
-0.5165108442306519,
0.4828375577926636,
0.11110983788967133,
-0.06583001464605331,
0.6009290218353271,
0.4002416431903839,
-0.47300422191619873,
-0.04974306374788284,
0.2783829867839813,
-0.09089307487010956,
-0.1062304675579071,
-0.3264181911945343,
0.11619048565626144,
0.41367751359939575,
0.6217080354690552,
-0.06279107183218002,
0.06243213638663292,
-0.19118955731391907,
0.35700175166130066,
-0.233298197388649,
-0.45976632833480835,
1.1046653985977173,
-0.08476661145687103,
-0.562190592288971,
0.15965799987316132,
0.27697208523750305,
0.3879735767841339,
-0.7264191508293152,
-0.11711912602186203,
-0.39684152603149414,
0.23046423494815826,
-0.2132393717765808,
-0.493974894285202,
0.6534369587898254,
0.2799994945526123,
0.005241746548563242,
-0.1600375473499298,
1.0092447996139526,
-0.19284260272979736,
-0.6178930997848511,
0.3246017396450043,
-0.03849887475371361,
0.3584107756614685,
-0.0369301401078701,
-0.3775571286678314,
-0.11527558416128159,
-0.35258471965789795,
-0.0478220097720623,
0.2950732409954071,
0.8069787621498108,
-0.24871760606765747,
0.386984646320343,
0.45745009183883667,
0.003868176368996501,
-0.07690563797950745,
0.025496263056993484,
0.6700924038887024,
-0.9584032893180847,
-0.5863440036773682,
-0.6232925653457642,
0.45936504006385803,
-0.5083510875701904,
-0.32009589672088623,
0.42721495032310486,
0.9415097832679749,
0.9261448383331299,
0.2229442000389099,
0.5528172850608826,
-0.09743878990411758,
0.8204517960548401,
-0.27247291803359985,
0.36383581161499023,
-0.19574372470378876,
0.16486594080924988,
-0.3308453857898712,
-0.6937227249145508,
-0.18885131180286407,
0.6979745030403137,
-0.040607351809740067,
-0.16565102338790894,
0.3121936619281769,
0.385541170835495,
-0.10047938674688339,
0.050594352185726166,
0.13170932233333588,
0.29946163296699524,
0.3912009000778198,
0.42377445101737976,
0.38673874735832214,
-0.37151092290878296,
0.6620952486991882,
-0.2921237051486969,
0.11633283644914627,
-0.4857269525527954,
-0.9326598644256592,
-0.9200579524040222,
-0.562493085861206,
-0.7020847797393799,
-0.57054203748703,
-0.30924731492996216,
0.96659916639328,
0.39421772956848145,
-0.7409119009971619,
-0.16652686893939972,
0.12475522607564926,
0.02068195305764675,
-0.38714686036109924,
-0.1826283186674118,
0.1785680055618286,
-0.1674661636352539,
-0.6480860710144043,
0.18202956020832062,
0.6063228845596313,
0.5680361986160278,
0.04263855889439583,
0.3073555827140808,
-0.08710373938083649,
0.4230779707431793,
0.44245681166648865,
0.31750479340553284,
0.04060135409235954,
-0.17678958177566528,
-0.370121568441391,
-0.1273311972618103,
0.12818995118141174,
0.9343771934509277,
-0.776972770690918,
0.3554006814956665,
0.1567976474761963,
0.8170878291130066,
0.6476160287857056,
0.11955134570598602,
0.22273382544517517,
-0.8901498317718506,
0.3680435121059418,
0.2999803125858307,
0.5171480178833008,
0.4064434766769409,
-0.48711130023002625,
0.8305978178977966,
0.4769076406955719,
-0.2886792719364166,
-0.8696866631507874,
0.06981996446847916,
-1.0093895196914673,
-0.29695388674736023,
0.6061321496963501,
-0.016954220831394196,
-0.32440394163131714,
-0.9614145159721375,
-0.22621287405490875,
0.13422386348247528,
-0.4330427646636963,
0.7286571860313416,
0.8602573871612549,
-0.12060123682022095,
0.16169330477714539,
-0.5156453251838684,
0.3856310546398163,
-0.06838981062173843,
-0.8645954132080078,
0.2562302052974701,
0.8560989499092102,
0.019081970676779747,
0.21259120106697083,
0.8524193167686462,
-0.14768438041210175,
0.2638060748577118,
0.11812260746955872,
-0.01994505524635315,
-0.2325407862663269,
-0.46902719140052795,
-0.3864609897136688,
-0.0010126871056854725,
0.11312967538833618,
0.21137070655822754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09911v1 | Enhancing Large Language Models with Pseudo- and Multisource- Knowledge Graphs for Open-ended Question Answering | 2024-02-15T12:20:02 | 2024-02-15T12:20:02 | Jiaxiang Liu, Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mitigating the hallucinations of Large Language Models (LLMs) and enhancing
them is a crucial task. Although some existing methods employ model
self-enhancement techniques, they fall short of effectively addressing unknown
factual hallucinations. Using Knowledge Graph (KG) enhancement approaches fails
to address the generalization across different KG sources and the enhancement
of open-ended answer questions simultaneously. To tackle these limitations,
there is a framework that combines Pseudo-Graph Generation and Atomic Knowledge
Verification proposed. The enhancement of LLM using KG in an open-ended
question-answering setting is implemented by leveraging the Pseudo-Graph
Generation. Atomic Knowledge Verification utilizes atomic-level knowledge
querying and verification to achieve generalizability under different KG
sources. Compared to the baseline, this approach yields a minimum improvement
of 11.5 in the ROUGE-L score for open-ended questions. For precise questions,
we observe a minimum accuracy improvement of 7.5. Moreover, there is also
demonstration that this framework exhibits generalizability across different KG
sources. In summary, our results pave the way for enhancing LLMs by
incorporating Pseudo- and Multisource-KGs, particularly in the context of
open-ended questions. | [
-0.4630592167377472,
-1.1498769521713257,
0.8501744866371155,
-0.34960901737213135,
-0.16214080154895782,
0.1417301744222641,
-0.29263317584991455,
-0.39214593172073364,
0.18415091931819916,
0.7308393716812134,
-0.22310613095760345,
-0.575080931186676,
-0.30780330300331116,
0.30961108207702637,
-0.1507435142993927,
0.8679898381233215,
0.020927367731928825,
-0.09827034920454025,
-0.37210604548454285,
-0.06675761193037033,
-0.10331327468156815,
-0.5936963558197021,
-0.5348418951034546,
-0.2243911623954773,
0.376573771238327,
0.26998022198677063,
0.948004961013794,
0.48141545057296753,
0.2858585715293884,
0.35493946075439453,
-0.03010173887014389,
0.7489272356033325,
-0.6712554097175598,
0.11108804494142532,
-0.11464790999889374,
-0.3168661892414093,
-0.6241270899772644,
-0.359279990196228,
0.73562091588974,
0.7446594834327698,
0.03619527071714401,
-0.06903502345085144,
-0.17455343902111053,
0.5571331977844238,
-0.739703357219696,
0.1717953234910965,
-0.5232399702072144,
-0.2609722316265106,
0.0330316461622715,
-0.163715660572052,
-0.5098013281822205,
-0.45313501358032227,
-0.04217865690588951,
-0.5521525144577026,
-0.13634242117404938,
0.21061357855796814,
0.7076237797737122,
0.12603095173835754,
-0.406030535697937,
-0.36456093192100525,
-0.84452223777771,
0.46544718742370605,
-0.6949635148048401,
0.6457589268684387,
0.48267173767089844,
0.3245738446712494,
-0.15864689648151398,
-0.9236705899238586,
-0.6003575921058655,
-0.5041794180870056,
-0.3878505527973175,
0.07062559574842453,
-0.26955753564834595,
0.34074679017066956,
0.31765618920326233,
0.49945196509361267,
-0.7821940779685974,
-0.08934857696294785,
-0.24631647765636444,
-0.5607790946960449,
0.43013447523117065,
0.17603512108325958,
0.6091272234916687,
-0.21237188577651978,
0.06700652092695236,
-0.21103739738464355,
-0.7008755803108215,
-0.1903838962316513,
0.4331202805042267,
0.3125733733177185,
0.14703251421451569,
0.7029807567596436,
-0.4618920683860779,
1.0287835597991943,
-0.28253990411758423,
-0.060914769768714905,
0.24300701916217804,
-0.5078874826431274,
0.019401811063289642,
-0.01627972163259983,
0.6872296333312988,
0.3300948739051819,
0.502384603023529,
-0.44570618867874146,
-0.009535511955618858,
-0.11608856916427612,
0.18303479254245758,
-0.9919168949127197,
-0.3482710123062134,
0.26903724670410156,
-0.2784755229949951,
0.00376841495744884,
0.039982862770557404,
-0.8371889591217041,
-0.2950945794582367,
-0.1814749538898468,
0.5324867963790894,
-0.33515021204948425,
-0.5093967318534851,
0.12120424956083298,
-0.2647666931152344,
-0.014161147177219391,
0.2340060919523239,
-0.5036202073097229,
0.2577793002128601,
0.46873900294303894,
0.8040891289710999,
0.30253085494041443,
-0.24682769179344177,
-0.2921786308288574,
0.4518962502479553,
-0.772253692150116,
0.7359297871589661,
-0.4878596365451813,
-0.2173561453819275,
-0.13366058468818665,
-0.3346714377403259,
0.13776397705078125,
-0.6426758170127869,
0.13153861463069916,
-0.8593726754188538,
0.27800530195236206,
-0.46168798208236694,
-0.5024431943893433,
-0.11990084499120712,
0.4295717477798462,
-0.5044830441474915,
1.0233787298202515,
0.4607107937335968,
-0.7353355288505554,
-0.10868920385837555,
-0.696150004863739,
-0.43817219138145447,
0.050043847411870956,
-0.2191912978887558,
-0.16163893043994904,
-0.04206152260303497,
0.45839568972587585,
0.1929677575826645,
-0.34359976649284363,
-0.014033596962690353,
-0.47947564721107483,
-0.20632506906986237,
0.19340664148330688,
-0.03440685197710991,
0.5450184941291809,
0.16355957090854645,
-0.05002648010849953,
0.2881077527999878,
-0.797012209892273,
0.3898065388202667,
0.16933339834213257,
-0.045648496598005295,
-0.518603503704071,
-0.30831655859947205,
-0.7275469303131104,
0.1383088380098343,
0.323569118976593,
-0.4417080283164978,
0.012529900297522545,
-0.6119385361671448,
0.4069165885448456,
0.8184618353843689,
0.28907185792922974,
0.3722595274448395,
-0.3179260194301605,
0.5118008255958557,
0.058552514761686325,
0.04988986253738403,
-0.02925172820687294,
-0.381094366312027,
-0.709950864315033,
-0.28748831152915955,
0.1288130283355713,
0.443631112575531,
-1.1189281940460205,
0.3538867235183716,
-0.3409419655799866,
-0.5746384263038635,
-0.5938003659248352,
0.18353600800037384,
0.3896218538284302,
0.8502300381660461,
0.7930014133453369,
-0.04671614244580269,
-0.4782976806163788,
-0.9288840293884277,
-0.18149246275424957,
-0.4512055516242981,
0.03712092339992523,
0.5571846961975098,
0.3387158513069153,
-0.10748834908008575,
1.0789060592651367,
-0.7930554151535034,
-0.046964459121227264,
-0.321272611618042,
0.012732507660984993,
0.1458366960287094,
-0.003485508728772402,
0.34542685747146606,
-0.6512801647186279,
-0.5660445690155029,
0.09111281484365463,
-0.9077185988426208,
-0.14846721291542053,
0.2484218329191208,
-0.18942713737487793,
0.08609501272439957,
0.5883684754371643,
-0.6583566069602966,
0.20897050201892853,
0.3501873016357422,
-0.2318853884935379,
0.8149183988571167,
-0.26376041769981384,
0.40180885791778564,
-1.0802512168884277,
-0.029749492183327675,
-0.23993481695652008,
-0.30006396770477295,
-0.8657131195068359,
0.27078914642333984,
0.1179809495806694,
-0.09067103266716003,
-0.265962153673172,
0.7150603532791138,
-0.41783297061920166,
-0.2027832567691803,
-0.4796951711177826,
0.41433626413345337,
-0.09049097448587418,
0.32167187333106995,
0.056777141988277435,
0.963086724281311,
0.6937535405158997,
-0.6097583174705505,
0.43012353777885437,
0.044854309409856796,
-0.3493671715259552,
0.34356018900871277,
-0.5889590382575989,
0.4292745292186737,
-0.41896894574165344,
0.22824031114578247,
-1.0657051801681519,
-0.19182495772838593,
0.35161086916923523,
-0.48965245485305786,
0.11980601400136948,
0.007139881141483784,
-0.6800301671028137,
-0.5100488662719727,
-0.25464335083961487,
0.3052583336830139,
0.6242993474006653,
-0.5352795124053955,
0.8626207113265991,
0.02876933105289936,
-0.01749420538544655,
-0.6532992720603943,
-0.33907032012939453,
0.05913807079195976,
-0.040607064962387085,
-0.7345508933067322,
-0.010553929023444653,
-0.33016204833984375,
-0.5263378620147705,
0.18288080394268036,
-0.06875347346067429,
0.10378289967775345,
0.0166767705231905,
-0.22120216488838196,
0.26784053444862366,
-0.44451645016670227,
0.18529744446277618,
0.17792390286922455,
-0.08788827806711197,
0.10757705569267273,
-0.3708157241344452,
0.7581616044044495,
-0.10129740834236145,
-0.19309179484844208,
-0.25784897804260254,
0.1229873076081276,
0.4718848764896393,
-0.3877478539943695,
0.8777372241020203,
0.33673417568206787,
-0.29301345348358154,
-0.44512131810188293,
-0.5159095525741577,
-0.6544005274772644,
-0.5365824103355408,
0.6840524673461914,
-0.607455313205719,
-1.14251708984375,
0.592132568359375,
-0.29805558919906616,
-0.32088136672973633,
0.420453816652298,
0.6321997046470642,
0.11703354120254517,
1.0918693542480469,
0.23606041073799133,
-0.0843646377325058,
0.016463570296764374,
-0.08759244531393051,
0.5101626515388489,
-0.8733522295951843,
-0.08060896396636963,
-0.5184895992279053,
0.15121594071388245,
-0.27471724152565,
-0.4017680585384369,
0.5988945364952087,
0.3605327606201172,
-0.12674658000469208,
0.12725499272346497,
-0.37378910183906555,
0.5931127071380615,
0.1346280723810196,
0.2084198296070099,
0.3886260986328125,
-0.11262892186641693,
-0.25664108991622925,
0.21870221197605133,
-0.7401555180549622,
-0.33335360884666443,
1.2788268327713013,
0.10835640132427216,
0.5325177311897278,
0.2972836196422577,
0.5477597713470459,
0.1725509911775589,
0.28064075112342834,
-0.3933461904525757,
0.7881435751914978,
0.12133841961622238,
-0.7006962299346924,
-0.6680538058280945,
-1.0387623310089111,
-0.5821977257728577,
0.4649314880371094,
-0.05268663913011551,
-0.7927922606468201,
-0.28653037548065186,
0.26541540026664734,
-0.2706585228443146,
0.29906153678894043,
-0.6056655049324036,
0.7620954513549805,
-0.21050110459327698,
-0.1613294631242752,
-0.1817755550146103,
-0.48325154185295105,
0.5025051832199097,
-0.13713793456554413,
0.5093705058097839,
0.25492629408836365,
0.11638715863227844,
0.5523966550827026,
-0.4774559438228607,
0.72087562084198,
-0.18657264113426208,
-0.22367091476917267,
0.47969746589660645,
0.16041739284992218,
0.7385717034339905,
-0.07222548872232437,
-0.15006102621555328,
0.0523623451590538,
-0.22110502421855927,
-0.16108070313930511,
-0.9551355242729187,
0.6129440665245056,
-0.9812828302383423,
-0.8601313829421997,
0.010307209566235542,
-0.7968290448188782,
-0.4508037865161896,
0.487247496843338,
-0.01574023626744747,
0.41242703795433044,
0.07424589991569519,
0.08130236715078354,
0.6770959496498108,
-0.21128609776496887,
0.045482337474823,
0.448072612285614,
-0.5205762386322021,
-0.777003824710846,
0.9488247632980347,
0.20664465427398682,
0.6812503337860107,
0.2585611939430237,
0.4998075067996979,
-0.6457884907722473,
-0.6583219766616821,
-0.5490122437477112,
0.6072090268135071,
-1.0616286993026733,
-0.19619083404541016,
-0.8244926929473877,
-0.35792461037635803,
-0.9883633852005005,
0.10419555008411407,
-0.1455271691083908,
-0.3564276099205017,
-0.1965426355600357,
-0.26363182067871094,
0.42886611819267273,
0.5782592296600342,
-0.18154796957969666,
0.2771986722946167,
-0.6863681077957153,
0.7305195331573486,
0.45841744542121887,
0.24301697313785553,
0.27989423274993896,
-0.5864099860191345,
-0.2611874043941498,
0.12725301086902618,
0.10009299963712692,
-1.0670104026794434,
-0.027054812759160995,
0.10994381457567215,
0.6829767823219299,
0.4802643954753876,
0.4117469787597656,
0.9073095917701721,
-0.42547109723091125,
0.6783801317214966,
0.08176768571138382,
-0.9789423942565918,
0.48470377922058105,
-0.2952382266521454,
0.11388793587684631,
0.37816840410232544,
0.6127386093139648,
-0.45570480823516846,
-0.8158367276191711,
-0.47200584411621094,
-0.6928533911705017,
0.6545960307121277,
0.18766474723815918,
0.11781714111566544,
-0.15268643200397491,
0.6645243167877197,
-0.2109183371067047,
0.12167412787675858,
-0.8823319673538208,
-0.38658270239830017,
-0.34319233894348145,
-0.20667168498039246,
-0.17331229150295258,
-0.25141441822052,
-0.18454168736934662,
-0.22707422077655792,
0.8499402403831482,
-0.3103509545326233,
-0.03471990302205086,
0.29987773299217224,
-0.22654423117637634,
-0.22600829601287842,
0.1849471777677536,
0.45876261591911316,
0.8672168850898743,
-0.1519724726676941,
0.48216477036476135,
0.26603615283966064,
-0.17446553707122803,
-0.030765525996685028,
-0.042535483837127686,
-0.2573665380477905,
-0.36587095260620117,
0.49423766136169434,
0.7846220135688782,
-0.20449768006801605,
-0.6092787384986877,
0.19708092510700226,
0.1831681728363037,
-0.073025181889534,
0.05610219016671181,
0.24878185987472534,
0.25984489917755127,
0.2689405679702759,
0.2950451076030731,
-0.5231250524520874,
-0.01179785281419754,
-0.7538295984268188,
0.21599043905735016,
0.5886092782020569,
-0.0706288143992424,
-0.1089891865849495,
0.4206659495830536,
-0.24837905168533325,
-0.30306869745254517,
0.8298901915550232,
-0.3415725529193878,
-0.6919377446174622,
0.4590547978878021,
0.8814617395401001,
0.4427349865436554,
-0.42288386821746826,
0.20292387902736664,
0.6085258722305298,
0.5459215044975281,
0.10094378888607025,
0.36619868874549866,
-0.13963079452514648,
-0.9465341567993164,
-0.35275086760520935,
-0.5160226225852966,
-0.41746440529823303,
0.23917348682880402,
-0.49031418561935425,
0.18920613825321198,
-0.3910001218318939,
0.011896359734237194,
-0.2540954053401947,
-0.07919905334711075,
-0.069876529276371,
0.33858832716941833,
-0.05016014724969864,
0.597396731376648,
-0.8544551134109497,
0.7742285132408142,
0.6152359247207642,
-0.4926488399505615,
-0.766502857208252,
-0.026691146194934845,
-0.394224613904953,
-0.9081114530563354,
0.35110554099082947,
-0.00826179701834917,
-0.25174060463905334,
0.379871666431427,
-0.24077720940113068,
-0.9686387777328491,
0.9937695860862732,
0.30785781145095825,
-0.34004348516464233,
-0.03725162521004677,
0.6034289002418518,
0.7303581237792969,
-0.1944243460893631,
0.4576455354690552,
0.4062162935733795,
0.675180971622467,
0.2709001302719116,
-0.7255368828773499,
0.20775996148586273,
-0.023553524166345596,
-0.19539642333984375,
0.396959513425827,
-0.42519742250442505,
0.7754036784172058,
-0.27423015236854553,
-0.09673712402582169,
-0.0968618392944336,
0.8823316097259521,
0.4562667906284332,
0.15343961119651794,
0.6952297687530518,
0.7451499700546265,
0.8795161247253418,
0.14304670691490173,
0.9858717322349548,
-0.5585631728172302,
0.24627117812633514,
1.0906076431274414,
-0.3941148817539215,
0.49953681230545044,
0.1979718953371048,
-0.17547455430030823,
0.6294615864753723,
0.4926060438156128,
0.14977765083312988,
0.4531152546405792,
0.3027719259262085,
0.005171516444534063,
-0.5996040105819702,
-0.1063324585556984,
-0.5346459746360779,
0.28705334663391113,
0.268984854221344,
-0.2666260302066803,
-0.4801364243030548,
0.030542898923158646,
0.14024795591831207,
0.04051819443702698,
-0.37174341082572937,
0.906921923160553,
0.0036325769033282995,
-0.6534253358840942,
0.5477166175842285,
0.07352308928966522,
0.11326730996370316,
-0.8122252225875854,
-0.10794347524642944,
-0.2077649086713791,
-0.02830948680639267,
-0.10930947214365005,
-0.5862390995025635,
0.197969451546669,
-0.06720336526632309,
-0.03642144426703453,
0.05158090591430664,
1.0248749256134033,
-0.471789687871933,
-0.4451562762260437,
0.5644752979278564,
0.7203308939933777,
0.2082265168428421,
-0.2009417861700058,
-0.4203413426876068,
-0.027248015627264977,
-0.10764443874359131,
-0.25292208790779114,
0.29283350706100464,
0.35862815380096436,
-0.061983101069927216,
0.5792272686958313,
0.8709014058113098,
0.24054503440856934,
0.015003873966634274,
0.16597779095172882,
1.051277995109558,
-0.3699116110801697,
-0.6134468913078308,
-1.0287253856658936,
0.27940696477890015,
-0.12420739233493805,
0.051300544291734695,
1.049904465675354,
0.6610683798789978,
0.8624725937843323,
0.18381308019161224,
0.7236524820327759,
0.08391015976667404,
0.5030955672264099,
-0.6152454018592834,
0.869009256362915,
-0.7014533877372742,
0.06022942066192627,
-0.3553316295146942,
-1.0445564985275269,
-0.2628609836101532,
0.526258111000061,
-0.4788852035999298,
0.3471071124076843,
0.9068887233734131,
1.1330509185791016,
0.1394655704498291,
-0.014656443148851395,
0.4803944528102875,
0.5754621028900146,
0.2374064177274704,
0.36417916417121887,
1.0443071126937866,
-0.05178165063261986,
0.6568856239318848,
-0.3976042866706848,
-0.3592033386230469,
0.14516256749629974,
-0.5824853181838989,
-1.0559685230255127,
-0.4685993790626526,
-0.28873515129089355,
-0.6224526166915894,
0.11516712605953217,
0.6389097571372986,
0.601222813129425,
-0.4984821677207947,
-0.21158957481384277,
0.06786485761404037,
0.2233833372592926,
-0.11513576656579971,
-0.2352491021156311,
0.5894981026649475,
-0.39249080419540405,
-0.40491238236427307,
0.6112591624259949,
0.22919093072414398,
-0.05937784165143967,
-0.41420191526412964,
-0.23150168359279633,
-0.017837394028902054,
0.28144630789756775,
0.6508960723876953,
0.13562944531440735,
-0.5373407006263733,
-0.4672586917877197,
0.10884671658277512,
0.16222317516803741,
0.10245394706726074,
0.8302192091941833,
-0.6888365745544434,
0.5064777135848999,
0.33008936047554016,
0.516796350479126,
0.3282715976238251,
0.15039889514446259,
0.1952536404132843,
-0.6149851679801941,
-0.11535827070474625,
0.3042326271533966,
0.19423829019069672,
0.16953691840171814,
-0.4436432719230652,
0.29868224263191223,
0.2584998607635498,
-0.42883577942848206,
-1.0027706623077393,
0.45802178978919983,
-0.6115918755531311,
-0.709504246711731,
1.246267318725586,
-0.040086399763822556,
-0.22618770599365234,
-0.2321527749300003,
0.024994486942887306,
0.3735528588294983,
-0.0639428198337555,
0.8165408372879028,
0.8585595488548279,
-0.32893168926239014,
-0.29581984877586365,
-0.23672856390476227,
0.3742856979370117,
0.26502251625061035,
-1.320113182067871,
0.34693145751953125,
0.7730053663253784,
0.18493536114692688,
0.2907184958457947,
0.8565638065338135,
-0.17333358526229858,
0.235407754778862,
-0.16587746143341064,
-0.08594384789466858,
-0.4196680784225464,
-0.6934176683425903,
-0.043000590056180954,
0.47634875774383545,
0.2388024777173996,
0.22504504024982452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09910v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09910v2 | DE-COP: Detecting Copyrighted Content in Language Models Training Data | 2024-02-15T12:17:15 | 2024-06-25T10:33:41 | André V. Duarte, Xuandong Zhao, Arlindo L. Oliveira, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2 | How can we detect if copyrighted content was used in the training process of
a language model, considering that the training data is typically undisclosed?
We are motivated by the premise that a language model is likely to identify
verbatim excerpts from its training text. We propose DE-COP, a method to
determine whether a piece of copyrighted content was included in training.
DE-COP's core approach is to probe an LLM with multiple-choice questions, whose
options include both verbatim text and their paraphrases. We construct
BookTection, a benchmark with excerpts from 165 books published prior and
subsequent to a model's training cutoff, along with their paraphrases. Our
experiments show that DE-COP surpasses the prior best method by 9.6% in
detection performance (AUC) on models with logits available. Moreover, DE-COP
also achieves an average accuracy of 72% for detecting suspect books on fully
black-box models where prior methods give approximately 4% accuracy. The code
and datasets are available at https://github.com/LeiLiLab/DE-COP. | [
-0.19912073016166687,
-0.696574330329895,
0.4841175675392151,
-0.24973420798778534,
-0.4843160808086395,
0.11946898698806763,
-0.08334403485059738,
-0.30109965801239014,
-0.27745330333709717,
0.9008809924125671,
-0.2599906623363495,
-0.6059293150901794,
-0.7993635535240173,
0.043773431330919266,
-0.813755214214325,
0.7181516289710999,
0.13371385633945465,
0.2331523448228836,
-0.3642430305480957,
-0.14713110029697418,
-0.3085154592990875,
-0.8403170108795166,
-0.5381800532341003,
-0.08278132975101471,
0.1862514168024063,
0.3467010259628296,
0.4179277718067169,
0.7734676599502563,
0.20436708629131317,
0.19732744991779327,
-0.42004361748695374,
-0.021762851625680923,
-0.4369472563266754,
0.3313644826412201,
-0.21400971710681915,
-0.5626538991928101,
-0.21894405782222748,
-0.07106354087591171,
0.7325894832611084,
0.00039897780516184866,
0.06513559818267822,
0.02673661708831787,
0.0513945110142231,
0.8240174651145935,
-0.9205701351165771,
0.006238903850317001,
-0.7448861002922058,
-0.07216975092887878,
-0.15860490500926971,
-0.142288938164711,
-0.5492855310440063,
-0.15711244940757751,
-0.3486280143260956,
-0.21735963225364685,
0.44491276144981384,
-0.31249380111694336,
0.7307672500610352,
0.269271582365036,
-0.4206655025482178,
-0.39581772685050964,
-0.7300923466682434,
0.8210040330886841,
-0.8465068936347961,
0.6461939215660095,
0.875669002532959,
0.0417330376803875,
-0.023664237931370735,
-0.6109514832496643,
-0.8349307179450989,
-0.315207302570343,
0.10387517511844635,
0.07596791535615921,
-0.37857621908187866,
-0.25400862097740173,
0.4390057623386383,
0.40232938528060913,
-0.5001921653747559,
0.14195556938648224,
-0.2149047702550888,
-0.13059267401695251,
0.7354047894477844,
-0.20971977710723877,
0.3736526668071747,
-0.17686836421489716,
-0.4328250288963318,
-0.32772061228752136,
-0.6736869215965271,
-0.10043587535619736,
0.9505630135536194,
0.01850433088839054,
0.02075544185936451,
0.5894313454627991,
-0.13830912113189697,
0.5137090086936951,
-0.13520579040050507,
0.06566872447729111,
0.20513349771499634,
-0.3333113193511963,
-0.06789134442806244,
0.05269711837172508,
0.7667527198791504,
0.20542484521865845,
0.5473546981811523,
-0.03914172202348709,
-0.38850876688957214,
-0.39046168327331543,
0.2754424810409546,
-0.8288810849189758,
-0.1821231096982956,
0.32114875316619873,
-0.23992200195789337,
-0.35164138674736023,
0.08915455639362335,
-0.6421234607696533,
-0.45269647240638733,
-0.5376407504081726,
0.18167206645011902,
-0.40151679515838623,
-0.48710763454437256,
0.1995963156223297,
-0.41264984011650085,
0.22736291587352753,
0.04974306747317314,
-0.7171972393989563,
0.21919748187065125,
0.8109979629516602,
0.7792445421218872,
-0.27856165170669556,
-0.40589162707328796,
-0.7072651982307434,
0.23161253333091736,
-0.26021257042884827,
0.8454582691192627,
-0.5347589254379272,
-0.4170522093772888,
0.00566551648080349,
0.21744631230831146,
0.03714599087834358,
-0.57408607006073,
0.5261193513870239,
-0.713358998298645,
-0.09371251612901688,
-0.17130447924137115,
-0.9549227356910706,
0.004964605439454317,
0.4031398892402649,
-0.9633433818817139,
1.257560133934021,
-0.03076017089188099,
-0.9159933924674988,
0.265195369720459,
-0.184028759598732,
-0.27641117572784424,
-0.05675211176276207,
-0.2535754144191742,
-0.574766993522644,
-0.07276644557714462,
0.30716410279273987,
0.3932477831840515,
0.0033074570819735527,
0.34068283438682556,
-0.2028140276670456,
-0.33100512623786926,
0.5450730323791504,
-0.6281147003173828,
0.9983635544776917,
0.24803073704242706,
-0.32220980525016785,
-0.19320780038833618,
-0.6682623624801636,
-0.09881927073001862,
0.2604798972606659,
-0.29123803973197937,
-0.733108401298523,
0.09596367925405502,
-0.022123854607343674,
0.013079660013318062,
0.17387785017490387,
-0.6002691388130188,
0.16249212622642517,
-0.07864699512720108,
0.054681938141584396,
0.6209962964057922,
0.1821141541004181,
0.3752301037311554,
-0.4700787663459778,
0.7841780781745911,
0.040010347962379456,
0.30368417501449585,
0.0017347888788208365,
-0.505215048789978,
-0.3381976783275604,
-0.40849408507347107,
0.49797144532203674,
0.46517643332481384,
-0.4944825768470764,
0.6421643495559692,
-0.09893066436052322,
-0.5875911712646484,
-0.11628639698028564,
0.18078163266181946,
0.41901519894599915,
0.3038903772830963,
0.2544361650943756,
-0.33710798621177673,
-0.18739882111549377,
-0.687292218208313,
-0.3909335732460022,
-0.1570143848657608,
0.06197705119848251,
0.10554660856723785,
0.7367898225784302,
0.0020501851104199886,
0.9360036849975586,
-0.4619212746620178,
-0.25472548604011536,
-0.24321840703487396,
0.16486148536205292,
-0.13631896674633026,
0.7200693488121033,
0.8285162448883057,
-1.077147364616394,
-0.558224618434906,
-0.27701863646507263,
-0.5159664750099182,
-0.2422131448984146,
-0.006689668167382479,
-0.08129943162202835,
0.27866506576538086,
0.7615461349487305,
-0.12555047869682312,
0.6041947603225708,
0.47519439458847046,
-0.1697710007429123,
0.6153980493545532,
-0.30518969893455505,
0.2735016644001007,
-0.8348127603530884,
0.2183135449886322,
-0.4010365307331085,
-0.26635032892227173,
-0.4661601185798645,
0.13811081647872925,
0.273832231760025,
-0.04185648635029793,
-0.531560480594635,
0.648661196231842,
-0.3122199475765228,
-0.004992086905986071,
-0.5097665190696716,
0.08347129821777344,
0.0913352370262146,
0.4473212957382202,
0.32297372817993164,
0.7257367968559265,
0.5339418649673462,
-0.4956326484680176,
0.08775247633457184,
0.32139354944229126,
-0.5222534537315369,
0.4119674563407898,
-0.41664236783981323,
0.5488711595535278,
-0.2008020132780075,
0.025788618251681328,
-0.9552551507949829,
0.15015563368797302,
0.361743301153183,
-0.3227933943271637,
0.18905511498451233,
-0.9882417321205139,
-0.8371989130973816,
0.11469444632530212,
-0.33628466725349426,
0.4079757630825043,
0.39321044087409973,
-0.34334638714790344,
0.1682041734457016,
0.48405808210372925,
-0.16812317073345184,
-0.8881076574325562,
-0.624224841594696,
-0.17326126992702484,
0.03700892999768257,
-0.02118268422782421,
0.20164355635643005,
-0.4069992005825043,
-0.017710868269205093,
0.10452166944742203,
-0.3185449242591858,
-0.6849649548530579,
0.40272971987724304,
0.0031702204141765833,
-0.020547199994325638,
0.05547187849879265,
0.10669838637113571,
0.29910820722579956,
0.06486772745847702,
0.03152487426996231,
-0.23922517895698547,
0.719918429851532,
0.07954934239387512,
-0.5885456800460815,
-0.053448669612407684,
0.3014695644378662,
0.5471408367156982,
-0.38136738538742065,
0.5707730650901794,
0.43414774537086487,
-0.5207949280738831,
-0.3305828869342804,
-0.35769152641296387,
0.021052999421954155,
-0.4338190257549286,
0.09951291978359222,
-0.03294912725687027,
-0.3243515193462372,
0.4963715970516205,
0.25879335403442383,
-0.16080249845981598,
0.19260777533054352,
0.40528538823127747,
0.3328753411769867,
0.648919939994812,
0.47757038474082947,
-0.10743147879838943,
0.9646939635276794,
-0.5620508790016174,
-0.09586023539304733,
-0.509168803691864,
-0.26891908049583435,
-0.6756075620651245,
-0.1790464073419571,
-0.27174654603004456,
-0.4793223440647125,
-0.00018733477918431163,
0.5268316268920898,
0.05751560628414154,
0.6117292642593384,
-0.519755482673645,
1.0370014905929565,
0.7622475028038025,
0.20498840510845184,
0.807020366191864,
-0.09534689784049988,
-0.18979376554489136,
0.1396801620721817,
-0.40822601318359375,
-0.7055131196975708,
1.2609540224075317,
0.18753871321678162,
0.4915655553340912,
0.13711820542812347,
0.92054682970047,
0.5843958854675293,
0.09353356063365936,
-1.0090631246566772,
0.45929819345474243,
-0.13898231089115143,
-0.9994714856147766,
-0.334523469209671,
-0.3580209016799927,
-0.9530046582221985,
0.06891820579767227,
-0.0030630319379270077,
-0.5547281503677368,
0.3446923792362213,
-0.05587296187877655,
0.20577730238437653,
0.4754819869995117,
-0.3243769705295563,
1.0191271305084229,
-0.5273417830467224,
-0.34378913044929504,
-0.15833847224712372,
-0.28210562467575073,
0.10713648796081543,
-0.4940347373485565,
0.35222628712654114,
-0.2356361299753189,
-0.10774701833724976,
0.9507405161857605,
-0.2319086492061615,
0.7385236620903015,
-0.23852650821208954,
-0.3361281752586365,
0.4858764111995697,
0.3121350407600403,
0.3750380575656891,
0.10630612820386887,
-0.09680422395467758,
0.17654654383659363,
0.42306429147720337,
-0.36326849460601807,
-0.44993719458580017,
0.3496095836162567,
-0.47312209010124207,
-0.24923014640808105,
-0.4770016670227051,
-0.40787985920906067,
0.009804070927202702,
0.6012216210365295,
0.36665815114974976,
0.5823312997817993,
-0.16581785678863525,
0.19431130588054657,
0.48983821272850037,
-0.14571578800678253,
0.35337159037590027,
0.8576571345329285,
-0.08523543179035187,
-0.34699535369873047,
0.6926144361495972,
-0.07562641054391861,
0.25608715415000916,
0.5561192631721497,
0.4531771242618561,
-0.38053974509239197,
-1.093244194984436,
-0.4765377938747406,
0.14517419040203094,
-1.1090683937072754,
-0.29888975620269775,
-0.46126285195350647,
-0.25644978880882263,
-0.37196943163871765,
0.2769019305706024,
-0.5231651067733765,
-0.3059219419956207,
-0.3069256544113159,
0.022981228306889534,
0.45344045758247375,
0.7973539233207703,
-0.010932439006865025,
0.24095143377780914,
-0.9574264883995056,
0.31244808435440063,
0.032957710325717926,
0.4202275574207306,
-0.15779919922351837,
-0.7679586410522461,
-0.27707818150520325,
0.2477322220802307,
-0.41623881459236145,
-0.921055793762207,
0.5097059607505798,
-0.036875855177640915,
0.6601694822311401,
0.31816861033439636,
0.45022034645080566,
0.1747327744960785,
-0.45341670513153076,
0.7133731245994568,
-0.20442721247673035,
-1.0425450801849365,
0.5955889821052551,
-0.2321397364139557,
-0.14942045509815216,
0.7212605476379395,
0.735020101070404,
-0.2442491352558136,
-0.7950052618980408,
-0.8564614057540894,
-0.6315590143203735,
0.5855318903923035,
0.2840772569179535,
0.23238317668437958,
-0.1389927715063095,
0.2783200740814209,
0.17095738649368286,
0.44685953855514526,
-0.9177922010421753,
-0.1845780611038208,
-0.030432438477873802,
-0.2524230480194092,
0.003167258109897375,
-0.2181273251771927,
-0.028360411524772644,
-0.13770343363285065,
0.4845817983150482,
-0.03716321289539337,
0.10286786407232285,
0.3211124837398529,
-0.5268108248710632,
0.06286303699016571,
0.2938697338104248,
0.45155078172683716,
0.7275800704956055,
-0.3676339089870453,
0.16076762974262238,
-0.23728415369987488,
-0.6589072942733765,
0.2146448940038681,
0.07334400713443756,
-0.23094844818115234,
0.14740793406963348,
0.4754836857318878,
0.26812878251075745,
0.12426572293043137,
-0.9951658844947815,
1.0030511617660522,
-0.060924820601940155,
-0.23698808252811432,
-0.4271872341632843,
0.13302090764045715,
-0.24136516451835632,
0.35000452399253845,
0.1427679806947708,
-0.16025769710540771,
0.18348711729049683,
-0.32849183678627014,
0.51541668176651,
0.29114243388175964,
-0.17969492077827454,
-0.2782094478607178,
0.6054582595825195,
-0.20626600086688995,
-0.22544610500335693,
0.37707069516181946,
-0.2784482538700104,
-0.8346109390258789,
0.7933011054992676,
0.338879257440567,
0.9515790343284607,
-0.03677487373352051,
0.20204414427280426,
0.2346862405538559,
0.2788701057434082,
-0.36703482270240784,
0.2469072788953781,
-0.21031628549098969,
-0.8758155703544617,
-0.3191653788089752,
-0.3785727918148041,
-0.5824857354164124,
0.5128522515296936,
-0.8491261005401611,
0.4500444829463959,
-0.30902165174484253,
0.04470201954245567,
-0.11722725629806519,
-0.11862118542194366,
-0.5395533442497253,
-0.020325295627117157,
0.31787872314453125,
0.8214695453643799,
-0.9674990773200989,
1.1523289680480957,
0.4607055187225342,
-0.58903568983078,
-0.5329793691635132,
0.281909704208374,
-0.2562072277069092,
-0.5454989075660706,
0.7163194417953491,
-0.007470099255442619,
-0.12031562626361847,
0.14713314175605774,
-0.5731363892555237,
-0.6050569415092468,
0.8035555481910706,
0.6621376872062683,
-0.5743131637573242,
0.20240703225135803,
0.10934668034315109,
0.31869247555732727,
0.08039319515228271,
0.08352327346801758,
0.5732632875442505,
0.23473450541496277,
-0.014816934242844582,
-0.575297474861145,
-0.0975157842040062,
-0.13321039080619812,
-0.49396026134490967,
0.13398906588554382,
-0.17174620926380157,
0.6465511918067932,
0.2053557187318802,
-0.2005022019147873,
0.1672220081090927,
-0.034803230315446854,
0.20049111545085907,
0.4705067574977875,
0.7022414207458496,
0.39262068271636963,
0.8786904811859131,
0.2637542188167572,
1.0913587808609009,
-0.3295873701572418,
0.6561025381088257,
1.089449167251587,
-0.21487371623516083,
0.9878241419792175,
0.26207253336906433,
-0.051446154713630676,
0.3656517267227173,
0.27152854204177856,
-0.26521989703178406,
0.6455641984939575,
0.31935223937034607,
-0.18187947571277618,
-0.13936524093151093,
0.0765661969780922,
-0.23644237220287323,
0.4274318814277649,
0.06717771291732788,
-0.29560962319374084,
0.007155998609960079,
0.08560481667518616,
-0.020998172461986542,
0.19543179869651794,
0.0032426617108285427,
0.8320505023002625,
0.013726714067161083,
-0.6237929463386536,
0.8809559345245361,
-0.057204168289899826,
0.33739179372787476,
-0.5381876230239868,
0.07496974617242813,
-0.43220803141593933,
0.22940512001514435,
0.04082830995321274,
-0.8168642520904541,
0.3676663637161255,
0.3567722737789154,
-0.09284798055887222,
-0.3410583436489105,
0.7453150749206543,
-0.6900650858879089,
-0.34734907746315,
0.3989134132862091,
0.6531707048416138,
0.36333173513412476,
-0.489663302898407,
-0.7274116277694702,
0.03725006431341171,
-0.1752774864435196,
-0.14869681000709534,
0.32037410140037537,
0.5097428560256958,
0.04198596626520157,
0.5501300692558289,
0.6091089248657227,
0.1312524378299713,
-0.014624131843447685,
0.12370183318853378,
0.7103299498558044,
-0.5311578512191772,
-0.49062392115592957,
-0.9175184965133667,
0.22374406456947327,
-0.09908593446016312,
-0.13883811235427856,
0.6578070521354675,
0.9091798067092896,
1.1955633163452148,
-0.3046267628669739,
0.7905412316322327,
0.12372337281703949,
0.23893684148788452,
-0.9388694167137146,
0.8605211973190308,
-0.6547965407371521,
0.4522048532962799,
-0.4111936390399933,
-0.6620628833770752,
-0.1695837527513504,
0.4243772625923157,
-0.2444578856229782,
-0.2910192310810089,
0.8941275477409363,
0.9209214448928833,
-0.45929422974586487,
0.0640433132648468,
0.2842942178249359,
-0.43056392669677734,
0.4123634696006775,
0.1398768424987793,
1.243317723274231,
-0.5057502388954163,
0.8520187735557556,
-0.605027437210083,
-0.04371711611747742,
-0.03450906649231911,
-1.2590981721878052,
-1.078528642654419,
-0.6022841334342957,
-0.6009986400604248,
-0.18747206032276154,
-0.17431354522705078,
0.5541642308235168,
0.5421847701072693,
-0.9071316123008728,
-0.2697906494140625,
-0.3217557668685913,
0.4655698239803314,
-0.3760914206504822,
-0.16806770861148834,
0.4129834473133087,
-0.1473802775144577,
-1.0196781158447266,
0.45313265919685364,
-0.3881398141384125,
0.44878506660461426,
0.10719699412584305,
0.03610701858997345,
-0.29682809114456177,
-0.06899572163820267,
0.20394648611545563,
0.10237535089254379,
-0.43165847659111023,
-0.19742053747177124,
-0.11162591725587845,
-0.07319767773151398,
0.013505062088370323,
1.2151504755020142,
-0.4725149869918823,
0.4148884117603302,
0.5776576399803162,
0.7424600720405579,
0.7790895104408264,
-0.019351646304130554,
0.364007830619812,
-1.2003147602081299,
0.40623199939727783,
0.4078502953052521,
0.35146406292915344,
0.21532000601291656,
-0.31896090507507324,
0.5403784513473511,
0.48705238103866577,
-0.5743236541748047,
-1.0180577039718628,
0.2337629497051239,
-0.9677877426147461,
-0.6380550861358643,
1.2721842527389526,
-0.3899860978126526,
-0.041499391198158264,
-0.17027172446250916,
-0.2057255357503891,
0.44619452953338623,
-0.33198773860931396,
0.47980475425720215,
0.686305046081543,
0.38245689868927,
-0.10712570697069168,
-0.8579813241958618,
0.4301082193851471,
0.12406595796346664,
-0.7082827091217041,
0.5160238146781921,
0.46866554021835327,
0.5857732892036438,
-0.07715139538049698,
0.5933828353881836,
-0.25727805495262146,
0.2487393021583557,
-0.08705756813287735,
-0.051054030656814575,
-0.4208999276161194,
-0.3483368456363678,
-0.5839009284973145,
-0.14882661402225494,
0.10784932971000671,
-0.3785806894302368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09906v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09906v2 | Generative Representational Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-15T12:12:19 | 2024-04-17T17:12:05 | Niklas Muennighoff, Hongjin Su, Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Furu Wei, Tao Yu, Amanpreet Singh, Douwe Kiela | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | All text-based language problems can be reduced to either generation or
embedding. Current models only perform well at one or the other. We introduce
generative representational instruction tuning (GRIT) whereby a large language
model is trained to handle both generative and embedding tasks by
distinguishing between them through instructions. Compared to other open
models, our resulting GritLM 7B sets a new state of the art on the Massive Text
Embedding Benchmark (MTEB) and outperforms all models up to its size on a range
of generative tasks. By scaling up further, GritLM 8x7B outperforms all open
generative language models that we tried while still being among the best
embedding models. Notably, we find that GRIT matches training on only
generative or embedding data, thus we can unify both at no performance loss.
Among other benefits, the unification via GRIT speeds up Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) by > 60% for long documents, by no longer requiring separate
retrieval and generation models. Models, code, etc. are freely available at
https://github.com/ContextualAI/gritlm. | [
-0.18114987015724182,
-0.7894694805145264,
0.6015273928642273,
0.18176494538784027,
-0.36764729022979736,
0.2737578749656677,
-0.4446365237236023,
-0.1794075071811676,
0.012731796130537987,
0.49745696783065796,
-0.4117836654186249,
-0.7794575095176697,
-0.7218132615089417,
-0.36298346519470215,
-0.3135603368282318,
1.1814610958099365,
0.06912817060947418,
0.4751630127429962,
-0.4490906000137329,
-0.35547351837158203,
-0.6599795818328857,
-0.1124207004904747,
-0.6818791031837463,
-0.5156185030937195,
0.4373146593570709,
0.264496773481369,
0.8612150549888611,
1.1810317039489746,
0.719914436340332,
0.2884843051433563,
-0.06063224375247955,
0.3178194463253021,
-0.8069084882736206,
0.1886001080274582,
-0.4092375338077545,
-0.4566420018672943,
-0.4710101783275604,
-0.23648928105831146,
0.6263189315795898,
0.6391379833221436,
-0.32916179299354553,
0.019203748553991318,
0.03469063714146614,
0.6228508353233337,
-0.8114525675773621,
0.1421491652727127,
-0.7657660245895386,
-0.20030207931995392,
-0.26219817996025085,
-0.26093077659606934,
-0.621684730052948,
-0.2554132342338562,
-0.38342082500457764,
-0.45199936628341675,
0.8716707229614258,
0.20071741938591003,
1.0524338483810425,
0.24075685441493988,
-0.11342187970876694,
-0.3848382532596588,
-0.5845078229904175,
0.7914196252822876,
-0.320860892534256,
0.4271313548088074,
0.4232008457183838,
0.28568920493125916,
-0.05810818448662758,
-0.8475428223609924,
-0.17254889011383057,
-0.0009544701897539198,
0.17112599313259125,
0.032163798809051514,
0.08577299118041992,
0.4062137305736542,
0.27380138635635376,
0.891371488571167,
-0.6113767027854919,
0.2236841320991516,
-0.31224116683006287,
-0.13761447370052338,
0.4885295331478119,
0.24162696301937103,
0.19462797045707703,
0.1267019659280777,
-0.37121203541755676,
-0.5603046417236328,
-0.873421847820282,
-0.2766692638397217,
0.27864977717399597,
0.3483196198940277,
-0.038226619362831116,
0.3132842779159546,
0.11795470863580704,
0.8320255279541016,
0.018548402935266495,
-0.20128853619098663,
0.16288799047470093,
-0.07817156612873077,
-0.32906046509742737,
0.07680616527795792,
0.5529452562332153,
0.3606341481208801,
-0.017531830817461014,
-0.40506288409233093,
-0.7674524784088135,
0.07280250638723373,
0.6074621677398682,
-0.8580092787742615,
-0.15326446294784546,
-0.20567137002944946,
-0.3682725727558136,
-0.1784730702638626,
0.14487773180007935,
-0.6938541531562805,
-0.5402459502220154,
-0.47867703437805176,
0.5630332827568054,
-0.5316078066825867,
-0.017149560153484344,
0.05150977522134781,
-0.2530457377433777,
0.41088443994522095,
0.3331817388534546,
-1.3130322694778442,
0.1404227465391159,
0.963290274143219,
0.9809349179267883,
0.07271776348352432,
-0.2982615828514099,
-0.6858377456665039,
0.21280710399150848,
-0.5439794063568115,
0.9378919005393982,
-0.8075913786888123,
-0.520851731300354,
0.15168346464633942,
-0.02334405481815338,
-0.14521607756614685,
-0.6703914999961853,
0.34078335762023926,
-0.5242461562156677,
-0.11451999098062515,
-0.4498513340950012,
-0.5634946823120117,
-0.07012009620666504,
0.13841386139392853,
-0.7257248759269714,
1.2220549583435059,
0.54561847448349,
-0.4347725808620453,
0.38976165652275085,
-0.4826064109802246,
-0.4608498215675354,
0.2698843479156494,
-0.2811507284641266,
-0.51922208070755,
0.5096042156219482,
0.21824461221694946,
0.20332220196723938,
-0.6455956101417542,
0.5067729353904724,
-0.3445124924182892,
-0.6540465950965881,
-0.36441609263420105,
-0.3583678603172302,
0.4619888961315155,
0.2115393579006195,
-0.47199609875679016,
0.36511480808258057,
-0.4012173116207123,
0.11325781792402267,
0.14192689955234528,
-0.21249833703041077,
-0.13620850443840027,
-0.18746986985206604,
0.2215084731578827,
-0.015995558351278305,
0.3127061426639557,
-0.47095435857772827,
0.17770017683506012,
-0.2674283981323242,
0.34829556941986084,
0.9221059083938599,
-0.3077648878097534,
0.4220893979072571,
-0.5432015657424927,
0.5451193451881409,
-0.06512828916311264,
-0.012480953708291054,
-0.4517349600791931,
-0.41511040925979614,
-1.073470115661621,
-0.2552683651447296,
0.6096548438072205,
0.2877792716026306,
-0.9206104874610901,
0.23846864700317383,
-0.5632022023200989,
-0.31040817499160767,
-1.2459909915924072,
0.22504954040050507,
0.8559625148773193,
0.1960439682006836,
0.44855669140815735,
-0.24821442365646362,
-0.3149152100086212,
-0.8221055269241333,
-0.144502654671669,
0.18368373811244965,
-0.02631167694926262,
0.34130316972732544,
0.3612065017223358,
0.04206201061606407,
0.6484094858169556,
-0.5652737021446228,
-0.24735067784786224,
-0.13172708451747894,
0.33615049719810486,
-0.19973580539226532,
0.48488420248031616,
0.4282229244709015,
-0.8251076340675354,
-0.6243985891342163,
0.3186737596988678,
-0.7858965396881104,
0.02290845662355423,
-0.0009366893791593611,
-0.14879216253757477,
0.32839250564575195,
0.714849054813385,
-0.2973456084728241,
0.476528525352478,
0.6257681846618652,
-0.32059842348098755,
0.19092798233032227,
-0.5617364645004272,
0.24009597301483154,
-1.083608627319336,
-0.05423374101519585,
-0.34944412112236023,
-0.44594433903694153,
-0.2627814710140228,
0.5378088355064392,
0.4152711033821106,
-0.21222400665283203,
-0.1406385898590088,
0.5268592238426208,
-0.6647202968597412,
-0.16595761477947235,
-0.5600156188011169,
0.11684928089380264,
0.23389969766139984,
0.4297938346862793,
-0.2772722840309143,
1.1930855512619019,
0.5189123153686523,
-0.44676870107650757,
0.11145759373903275,
0.04770111292600632,
-0.3424414098262787,
0.48384761810302734,
-0.7041177749633789,
0.3875994086265564,
-0.4108675420284271,
-0.09203821420669556,
-0.6286492943763733,
-0.058673687279224396,
-0.19536744058132172,
-0.2190091609954834,
0.8004878163337708,
-0.19666339457035065,
-0.5609688758850098,
-0.11504217982292175,
-0.33895331621170044,
0.057814519852399826,
0.6385284066200256,
-0.8568878173828125,
0.6292135119438171,
0.32067805528640747,
0.007170159835368395,
-0.43807923793792725,
-0.3794935643672943,
-0.048032891005277634,
0.06263145059347153,
-0.5183477401733398,
0.8123272657394409,
0.017097970470786095,
0.001844797981902957,
0.06166011095046997,
-0.13570700585842133,
0.04956949129700661,
-0.022525085136294365,
0.22286175191402435,
0.08257607370615005,
-0.47585198283195496,
0.429440975189209,
0.4751426577568054,
-0.23096928000450134,
-0.3191312551498413,
-0.19193916022777557,
0.7319650650024414,
-0.21717150509357452,
-0.35093584656715393,
0.24434134364128113,
0.519361674785614,
0.5119456648826599,
-0.48217204213142395,
1.0377999544143677,
1.0066803693771362,
-0.07876614481210709,
-0.2907870411872864,
-0.5962105393409729,
-0.13222558796405792,
-0.5358796119689941,
0.46958214044570923,
-0.49258285760879517,
-0.9854725003242493,
0.30239930748939514,
-0.05251007899641991,
0.23498578369617462,
0.41461753845214844,
0.5541827082633972,
0.04857417568564415,
1.1861743927001953,
0.8232617378234863,
0.08175523579120636,
0.5667151808738708,
-0.30457013845443726,
0.14151589572429657,
-0.9906526803970337,
-0.1985723078250885,
-0.5453263521194458,
-0.2962285578250885,
-0.7036843299865723,
-0.6166560649871826,
0.15073975920677185,
0.37554579973220825,
-0.14347396790981293,
0.278470903635025,
-0.5778077244758606,
0.6576118469238281,
0.5392925143241882,
0.22817197442054749,
-0.06545216590166092,
-0.03543255850672722,
-0.17902906239032745,
-0.02040334977209568,
-0.6934129595756531,
-0.5677483081817627,
1.0733948945999146,
0.15250764787197113,
0.7433207631111145,
0.03596818074584007,
0.6992936134338379,
0.2714783847332001,
0.6151279211044312,
-0.6809269189834595,
0.2947813868522644,
-0.6580548882484436,
-0.4531848430633545,
-0.09332644939422607,
-0.3509345054626465,
-1.0283403396606445,
0.4071492552757263,
-0.10453619807958603,
-0.4178192615509033,
-0.18803365528583527,
0.2209930121898651,
0.03643253818154335,
0.4609566926956177,
-0.7995202541351318,
0.8128066658973694,
0.12963727116584778,
-0.4087728261947632,
-0.26836371421813965,
-0.33867406845092773,
0.05048085004091263,
0.19736897945404053,
0.05525336042046547,
-0.29797667264938354,
0.06438083201646805,
0.5110754370689392,
-0.206804558634758,
0.500176727771759,
-0.15867722034454346,
-0.0465298630297184,
0.05568692088127136,
-0.1813919097185135,
0.512340247631073,
-0.04607528820633888,
-0.09990667551755905,
0.06735413521528244,
-0.3310546278953552,
-0.6266345977783203,
-0.831548273563385,
0.9309951663017273,
-0.5739120244979858,
-0.7909428477287292,
-0.13001792132854462,
-0.7923768758773804,
-0.07323060929775238,
0.1788870245218277,
0.48388975858688354,
0.6859755516052246,
-0.16152481734752655,
0.4611077606678009,
1.0348416566848755,
0.023762254044413567,
0.5747560858726501,
0.3861730396747589,
-0.2580386698246002,
-0.43561407923698425,
1.312516450881958,
-0.06468360126018524,
0.2546193301677704,
0.5641947984695435,
0.08430825173854828,
-0.2853322923183441,
-0.6903855204582214,
-0.7139095067977905,
0.27159518003463745,
-0.8831501603126526,
-0.4774971604347229,
-0.49972498416900635,
-0.21785737574100494,
-0.5179005861282349,
-0.39885085821151733,
-0.45503613352775574,
0.019598092883825302,
-0.39741891622543335,
0.05694449320435524,
0.3156210482120514,
0.929230272769928,
0.2994966208934784,
0.5613770484924316,
-0.8099722266197205,
0.25114646553993225,
0.11196661740541458,
0.7023178935050964,
-0.011715767905116081,
-0.6235191226005554,
-0.4752456843852997,
0.14661793410778046,
-0.5803272724151611,
-0.6109026670455933,
0.280309796333313,
0.35449665784835815,
0.4587722420692444,
0.46926039457321167,
-0.08726735413074493,
0.77159184217453,
-0.6918855905532837,
0.4914131760597229,
-0.021676309406757355,
-0.930313229560852,
0.3717336058616638,
-0.46145203709602356,
0.5485435724258423,
0.7387391328811646,
0.27279090881347656,
-0.2898330092430115,
-0.37496402859687805,
-0.5185578465461731,
-0.6832524538040161,
0.6564118266105652,
-0.017695851624011993,
0.26140397787094116,
-0.12266654521226883,
0.21636013686656952,
0.17002010345458984,
0.269064724445343,
-0.3110412657260895,
-0.26714614033699036,
-0.2626367509365082,
-0.371406614780426,
-0.19194258749485016,
-0.331233412027359,
-0.10049501061439514,
-0.1439615786075592,
0.6639229655265808,
-0.34072446823120117,
0.42134350538253784,
-0.242025688290596,
-0.3948933482170105,
-0.07207675278186798,
0.10082387924194336,
0.77901691198349,
0.7817543148994446,
-0.1293223798274994,
0.07184633612632751,
-0.003200315171852708,
-0.6963543891906738,
-0.017507590353488922,
0.03636375069618225,
-0.26093029975891113,
0.09352296590805054,
0.39948487281799316,
1.372588038444519,
0.5429138541221619,
-0.4748322665691376,
0.3934267461299896,
0.0016566982958465815,
-0.18901237845420837,
0.2329578846693039,
0.33770567178726196,
0.08643219619989395,
-0.07788030803203583,
0.07424730062484741,
-0.14608903229236603,
0.0462552085518837,
-0.34684208035469055,
0.02095990814268589,
0.4068957567214966,
-0.5755857229232788,
-0.15441913902759552,
0.47143492102622986,
0.13361218571662903,
-0.6113119125366211,
0.8491597175598145,
-0.37616145610809326,
-0.382170706987381,
0.5320061445236206,
0.9025481343269348,
0.9162033796310425,
-0.28587231040000916,
0.37632787227630615,
0.31040969491004944,
0.3378041684627533,
-0.02438652701675892,
0.2534831762313843,
0.018432144075632095,
-0.4444252848625183,
-0.3325253427028656,
-0.9596635699272156,
-0.26741886138916016,
0.11152062565088272,
-1.1477220058441162,
0.2197984755039215,
-0.5094554424285889,
0.018511105328798294,
0.15992696583271027,
-0.1653544306755066,
-0.6521140933036804,
0.1567317545413971,
-0.15898466110229492,
0.6809644103050232,
-0.7572510242462158,
0.9248272776603699,
0.8227052092552185,
-0.2785036861896515,
-0.447039932012558,
-0.13681671023368835,
-0.2240203619003296,
-0.8263901472091675,
0.1511221081018448,
0.4838632345199585,
-0.055201951414346695,
0.29295045137405396,
-0.47000232338905334,
-0.7958027124404907,
1.185908555984497,
0.7246896028518677,
-0.6649870872497559,
-0.09492384642362595,
-0.11295799911022186,
0.4245382249355316,
-0.35103583335876465,
0.10861053317785263,
0.66057288646698,
0.2920970618724823,
0.18187502026557922,
-0.6957417130470276,
-0.09827543050050735,
-0.22082850337028503,
0.539325475692749,
0.8904281258583069,
-0.5854532718658447,
0.9550108909606934,
-0.13220177590847015,
-0.32808393239974976,
-0.017025839537382126,
0.7555477023124695,
0.12870757281780243,
0.28436630964279175,
0.24154424667358398,
0.8668864369392395,
0.7902311682701111,
-0.4229682981967926,
1.2906162738800049,
-0.34241095185279846,
0.39938241243362427,
1.1698249578475952,
-0.05931125208735466,
0.6422439813613892,
0.251104474067688,
-0.09058131277561188,
0.5149696469306946,
0.45628705620765686,
-0.08581473678350449,
0.5092441439628601,
0.040711186826229095,
-0.4546683728694916,
-0.32133498787879944,
-0.22246474027633667,
-0.46215564012527466,
0.5251052975654602,
0.4970766007900238,
-0.5355313420295715,
-0.5350878834724426,
0.23537710309028625,
0.0633356124162674,
0.3796370029449463,
-0.46464449167251587,
0.8442437648773193,
-0.08090762794017792,
-0.8240079283714294,
0.6952576041221619,
0.37311550974845886,
0.5886135101318359,
-0.6668000221252441,
-0.33931511640548706,
-0.3357849419116974,
0.19705194234848022,
0.10908392816781998,
-0.5898436903953552,
0.27981701493263245,
-0.2075098156929016,
-0.6199017763137817,
-0.33407169580459595,
0.590842068195343,
-0.6455010771751404,
-0.396592378616333,
0.20441396534442902,
0.06119557470083237,
0.08956680446863174,
-0.025499524548649788,
-0.666293740272522,
0.32342013716697693,
-0.06034008413553238,
0.11599226295948029,
0.7291727662086487,
0.2866044342517853,
-0.16798177361488342,
0.5036152005195618,
0.55035001039505,
-0.20693691074848175,
0.08518384397029877,
0.3334168791770935,
1.0091500282287598,
-0.6607263088226318,
-0.3954506516456604,
-0.7035636305809021,
0.29120635986328125,
-0.1033037081360817,
-0.34618067741394043,
0.6392356753349304,
0.5575814843177795,
0.8577519655227661,
-0.10633636265993118,
0.34778618812561035,
-0.012120208702981472,
0.08972938358783722,
-0.8282119035720825,
0.8970134258270264,
-0.4738621711730957,
-0.10749921947717667,
0.10478749126195908,
-1.0533199310302734,
-0.022378092631697655,
0.4898449182510376,
-0.18110041320323944,
0.3388063609600067,
0.9383816123008728,
1.0526009798049927,
-0.04074104130268097,
0.05734303593635559,
0.60313481092453,
-0.28378579020500183,
0.3397528827190399,
0.37854886054992676,
0.23747938871383667,
-0.47561001777648926,
0.30866703391075134,
-0.23797260224819183,
-0.14821089804172516,
-0.20356503129005432,
-0.8056631088256836,
-0.9533121585845947,
-0.6595208644866943,
-0.17382511496543884,
-0.26869696378707886,
0.3782322108745575,
0.6419909000396729,
0.6930773258209229,
-0.7958548665046692,
-0.03858155012130737,
-0.2622852921485901,
0.24407906830310822,
-0.25779253244400024,
-0.22468052804470062,
0.46962353587150574,
-0.9205757975578308,
-0.8977645039558411,
0.46488478779792786,
0.46349209547042847,
0.024788986891508102,
-0.2589632272720337,
-0.017359869554638863,
-0.11921725422143936,
0.021968908607959747,
0.534892737865448,
-0.000051960651035187766,
-0.6686710119247437,
-0.10859764367341995,
-0.09094426035881042,
-0.4134448170661926,
0.23862694203853607,
1.0873219966888428,
-0.4959457516670227,
0.806722104549408,
0.3004195988178253,
0.8226222991943359,
0.6230224967002869,
-0.10037046670913696,
0.6168164014816284,
-0.9423501491546631,
0.1402338296175003,
0.15282230079174042,
0.17283758521080017,
0.5549948215484619,
-0.3159150183200836,
0.3202439248561859,
-0.0506741926074028,
-0.46163210272789,
-0.9188914895057678,
0.04749346524477005,
-0.5732375383377075,
-0.16281551122665405,
0.9528279304504395,
-0.31758785247802734,
-0.3098081648349762,
0.08105771988630295,
-0.0801265612244606,
0.2577058672904968,
-0.23553892970085144,
0.7321968078613281,
0.673581600189209,
0.4039839208126068,
-0.17848321795463562,
-0.44337522983551025,
0.5109110474586487,
0.4356672465801239,
-0.8034874200820923,
-0.0755888894200325,
0.27580201625823975,
-0.040569793432950974,
0.01835521124303341,
0.44645553827285767,
-0.122409388422966,
0.5318779945373535,
0.40115079283714294,
0.20968955755233765,
-0.40180498361587524,
-0.6923765540122986,
-0.4537191390991211,
0.13157013058662415,
0.21559005975723267,
-0.20349065959453583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09894v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09894v2 | Not Just Novelty: A Longitudinal Study on Utility and Customization of an AI Workflow | 2024-02-15T11:39:11 | 2024-05-31T16:00:05 | Tao Long, Katy Ilonka Gero, Lydia B. Chilton | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Generative AI brings novel and impressive abilities to help people in
everyday tasks. There are many AI workflows that solve real and complex
problems by chaining AI outputs together with human interaction. Although there
is an undeniable lure of AI, it is uncertain how useful generative AI workflows
are after the novelty wears off. Additionally, workflows built with generative
AI have the potential to be easily customized to fit users' individual needs,
but do users take advantage of this? We conducted a three-week longitudinal
study with 12 users to understand the familiarization and customization of
generative AI tools for science communication. Our study revealed that there
exists a familiarization phase, during which users were exploring the novel
capabilities of the workflow and discovering which aspects they found useful.
After this phase, users understood the workflow and were able to anticipate the
outputs. Surprisingly, after familiarization the perceived utility of the
system was rated higher than before, indicating that the perceived utility of
AI is not just a novelty effect. The increase in benefits mainly comes from
end-users' ability to customize prompts, and thus potentially appropriate the
system to their own needs. This points to a future where generative AI systems
can allow us to design for appropriation. | [
-0.48773083090782166,
-0.5279741883277893,
0.5687406659126282,
0.026003563776612282,
-0.3648315668106079,
0.20275095105171204,
-0.04659220948815346,
-0.6227405667304993,
0.40672770142555237,
0.05881672352552414,
-0.47019726037979126,
-0.20057183504104614,
-0.47778961062431335,
0.2833845615386963,
-0.3799525499343872,
0.9806820154190063,
0.3063197135925293,
-0.38217025995254517,
-0.46810388565063477,
-0.22962069511413574,
-0.5815743207931519,
-0.25478100776672363,
-0.6370126605033875,
-0.6125773787498474,
0.7612859010696411,
0.3993786871433258,
0.854922890663147,
0.47956904768943787,
0.3619401454925537,
0.38947832584381104,
-0.06619527190923691,
-0.16939038038253784,
-0.5099479556083679,
0.2241457998752594,
-0.12902775406837463,
-0.6174193620681763,
-0.07694198191165924,
-0.007180122192949057,
0.33847835659980774,
0.8766626715660095,
-0.18158969283103943,
0.10924352705478668,
0.18573211133480072,
0.659585177898407,
-0.40718215703964233,
0.17230291664600372,
-0.29926589131355286,
0.2531328797340393,
-0.457322359085083,
-0.354686439037323,
-0.16122961044311523,
-0.15874764323234558,
0.2020779550075531,
-0.9049482345581055,
0.27663546800613403,
0.05221283808350563,
0.7022333741188049,
0.341560959815979,
-0.18322759866714478,
-0.11038798093795776,
-1.1633232831954956,
0.4348093867301941,
-0.528193473815918,
0.07620887458324432,
-0.0010556328343227506,
0.6876562237739563,
-0.13016760349273682,
-0.9135043621063232,
-0.6420044302940369,
-0.44237878918647766,
-0.11800456047058105,
0.18305794894695282,
-0.42197850346565247,
-0.13627462089061737,
0.2886984944343567,
0.2977018356323242,
-0.46339377760887146,
0.4121622145175934,
-0.4942816495895386,
-0.086642786860466,
0.49417391419410706,
0.4870980978012085,
0.6317402124404907,
0.12823614478111267,
-0.31346824765205383,
-0.10539610683917999,
-0.4543320834636688,
0.3139471113681793,
0.08519434183835983,
-0.10354695469141006,
-0.21775922179222107,
0.6857789754867554,
-0.2642531394958496,
0.6357192993164062,
-0.039319198578596115,
0.27364620566368103,
0.30213260650634766,
-0.08985849469900131,
-0.21958854794502258,
-0.17745424807071686,
0.8036186695098877,
0.0456305630505085,
0.24980348348617554,
-0.5209878087043762,
0.12797458469867706,
-0.08910363167524338,
0.602499783039093,
-0.4616253674030304,
-0.3053325414657593,
0.04563827067613602,
-0.5242183804512024,
-0.4240587055683136,
-0.016290612518787384,
-0.4713049530982971,
-0.5952628254890442,
-0.3453616797924042,
0.23674450814723969,
-0.41898301243782043,
-0.1564711183309555,
-0.24411366879940033,
-0.48355406522750854,
-0.10360970348119736,
0.4021448493003845,
-1.0008480548858643,
-0.3512641191482544,
0.5894644260406494,
0.9639111757278442,
-0.3910839557647705,
-0.4762456715106964,
-0.13426755368709564,
-0.04210339114069939,
-0.32478734850883484,
0.9781490564346313,
-0.723347544670105,
-0.6775012016296387,
-0.32481732964515686,
-0.26228514313697815,
-0.03650374338030815,
-0.6174512505531311,
0.14132267236709595,
-0.6192274689674377,
-0.05933501571416855,
-0.10048770159482956,
-0.3360525667667389,
0.22651882469654083,
-0.03914343938231468,
-0.7284995317459106,
0.4121100902557373,
0.09816866368055344,
-0.4741362929344177,
0.8436985015869141,
-0.8262792229652405,
-0.5003528594970703,
0.672295331954956,
-0.20301157236099243,
-0.24389800429344177,
0.275214284658432,
-0.3594628870487213,
0.2675258219242096,
-0.00582885229960084,
0.1724008172750473,
-0.31824901700019836,
-0.3157370090484619,
0.504179835319519,
-0.3377542793750763,
0.6544596552848816,
0.6118670701980591,
-0.29468005895614624,
0.28272926807403564,
-0.5758805274963379,
-0.13764755427837372,
-0.2707573473453522,
-0.13064727187156677,
-0.44111067056655884,
-0.30813395977020264,
-0.03715662658214569,
-0.12051238119602203,
0.24019519984722137,
-0.3950950801372528,
0.15979711711406708,
-0.36076411604881287,
0.4877704083919525,
0.701620876789093,
0.06104091927409172,
0.6443575620651245,
-0.6974193453788757,
0.6685509085655212,
0.0348467119038105,
0.13957637548446655,
-0.31064867973327637,
-0.9266206622123718,
-0.30196914076805115,
-0.3825908601284027,
-0.03341875597834587,
0.3250276446342468,
-0.6554188132286072,
0.42043745517730713,
-0.03263946622610092,
-0.7332628965377808,
-0.21910516917705536,
0.07981499284505844,
0.013867064379155636,
0.44041869044303894,
0.041730232536792755,
-0.48673874139785767,
-0.3962627351284027,
-0.879985511302948,
-0.35806146264076233,
-0.22624637186527252,
-0.45399895310401917,
0.527627170085907,
0.37853655219078064,
-0.1690143495798111,
1.1048593521118164,
-0.5551295876502991,
-0.22074422240257263,
-0.24536077678203583,
0.7217944860458374,
0.1935747116804123,
0.21485696732997894,
0.429971307516098,
-0.9330362677574158,
-0.3601621687412262,
0.12261024117469788,
-1.0605145692825317,
0.01871410198509693,
-0.38665786385536194,
-0.02066206932067871,
-0.10745380818843842,
0.2088303565979004,
-0.7706984877586365,
0.41986343264579773,
0.10237777978181839,
-0.31548359990119934,
0.38790133595466614,
-0.4932044744491577,
0.15291590988636017,
-0.9858096837997437,
0.37490522861480713,
-0.0038565241266041994,
0.2098391354084015,
-0.7645341157913208,
-0.06333369761705399,
-0.27073124051094055,
-0.27033716440200806,
-0.33351874351501465,
0.500584065914154,
-0.34694141149520874,
0.11632943898439407,
-0.5192791223526001,
-0.2320842742919922,
-0.12394211441278458,
0.11396703124046326,
0.04988161846995354,
0.7533652186393738,
0.6635910272598267,
-0.7056758999824524,
0.31361284852027893,
0.11296948045492172,
-0.36190173029899597,
0.6860373020172119,
-0.710390031337738,
0.11556535959243774,
-0.434435099363327,
0.1483147293329239,
-0.7459770441055298,
-0.29551100730895996,
0.32265546917915344,
-0.5447875261306763,
0.005660446360707283,
0.24602055549621582,
-0.07725763320922852,
-0.32576704025268555,
-0.17979945242404938,
0.21550805866718292,
0.8043934106826782,
-0.5106539130210876,
0.610852837562561,
0.16815085709095,
-0.10287631303071976,
-0.21219368278980255,
-0.44596952199935913,
0.36482372879981995,
-0.564278244972229,
-0.486707866191864,
0.4240459203720093,
-0.2567756772041321,
-0.15956179797649384,
0.09641169756650925,
0.01935725472867489,
-0.05998900905251503,
0.37000423669815063,
0.4847717881202698,
0.045028530061244965,
0.029303275048732758,
0.04249471053481102,
-0.12634050846099854,
-0.24889971315860748,
-0.16232380270957947,
-0.20273350179195404,
0.3244403004646301,
-0.11823204904794693,
-0.3801115155220032,
-0.6134017705917358,
0.32585617899894714,
0.6054903268814087,
-0.03779693320393562,
0.6619889736175537,
0.9209129810333252,
-0.3561427593231201,
0.12104331701993942,
-0.32977262139320374,
-0.4234786927700043,
-0.5312685370445251,
0.0854821652173996,
-0.24505272507667542,
-0.8825238943099976,
0.4078499972820282,
-0.02274223603308201,
0.18794098496437073,
0.1650623083114624,
0.5786762237548828,
-0.4566880166530609,
0.7742087841033936,
0.7378157377243042,
-0.00825088657438755,
0.6240402460098267,
-0.18329906463623047,
0.38996759057044983,
-0.6901334524154663,
-0.6133494973182678,
-0.4559701383113861,
-0.5720303058624268,
-0.5308521389961243,
-0.011666507460176945,
0.5292737483978271,
-0.06977885216474533,
0.03442265838384628,
0.0889848992228508,
-0.49474483728408813,
0.36512959003448486,
0.7494396567344666,
-0.017725985497236252,
0.33445101976394653,
-0.03401736542582512,
0.5140131115913391,
-0.1744156777858734,
-0.579716682434082,
-0.5913056135177612,
0.9387218356132507,
-0.04037991911172867,
0.9176856279373169,
0.09147410094738007,
0.8617951273918152,
0.742754340171814,
0.5056930780410767,
-0.8027499318122864,
0.37115558981895447,
-0.021342821419239044,
0.08828357607126236,
-0.5511002540588379,
-0.2725038230419159,
-1.532247543334961,
0.0190071240067482,
-0.3148998022079468,
-0.9534969329833984,
0.30794277787208557,
0.5231912732124329,
-0.5162525177001953,
0.16437716782093048,
-0.7475419640541077,
0.48539915680885315,
0.08010279387235641,
-0.3483063280582428,
-0.22589033842086792,
-0.4453931152820587,
0.13398700952529907,
0.01045000646263361,
0.052590999752283096,
0.0005391179583966732,
0.11448705196380615,
0.6626418828964233,
-0.14732278883457184,
1.0685895681381226,
-0.037130098789930344,
0.11223011463880539,
0.22850970923900604,
-0.1192813366651535,
0.2199542224407196,
0.2666260004043579,
0.07248567789793015,
0.01568814180791378,
-0.12727510929107666,
-0.2700953185558319,
-0.9013020396232605,
0.789094090461731,
-0.5552076697349548,
-1.1123450994491577,
-0.5303126573562622,
-0.4422186017036438,
0.07008401304483414,
0.3491622805595398,
0.44369152188301086,
0.07715758681297302,
-0.4967929422855377,
0.19000184535980225,
0.4844062924385071,
0.12752829492092133,
0.4832048714160919,
0.3525043725967407,
0.47203969955444336,
0.2116306573152542,
0.8707118034362793,
-0.04442305490374565,
-0.02099633403122425,
0.31049394607543945,
0.45667746663093567,
0.10009505599737167,
-0.40044155716896057,
-0.6293535828590393,
-0.2641165852546692,
-0.39493951201438904,
0.0036690200213342905,
-0.6616764068603516,
0.043287768959999084,
-0.13229864835739136,
-0.297132670879364,
-0.08120723068714142,
-0.4538155496120453,
-0.6374225616455078,
0.13757070899009705,
0.13320821523666382,
0.8286247253417969,
-0.16446205973625183,
-0.10355238616466522,
-0.7557418346405029,
0.24348662793636322,
0.6259951591491699,
0.04335922375321388,
0.2275012582540512,
-0.31021708250045776,
-0.25411319732666016,
0.04077714681625366,
-0.5878469944000244,
-0.7638207077980042,
0.2504618167877197,
0.33781805634498596,
0.8396991491317749,
0.5430033802986145,
-0.05534336343407631,
0.09640588611364365,
-0.37151095271110535,
1.0489170551300049,
0.12591484189033508,
-0.49526700377464294,
0.28665560483932495,
-0.11525621265172958,
0.5294755697250366,
0.2499125599861145,
0.4399604797363281,
-0.6509637236595154,
-0.36086446046829224,
-0.5841358304023743,
-0.737429678440094,
0.47419649362564087,
0.3246189057826996,
0.6088523268699646,
0.2517012059688568,
0.4096745550632477,
0.32277393341064453,
0.35641640424728394,
-0.21334700286388397,
-0.3178395926952362,
-0.5818734765052795,
0.01622425951063633,
-0.12734559178352356,
0.12384790927171707,
-0.47827547788619995,
-0.10206165909767151,
0.08498094975948334,
-0.1349775791168213,
0.4470508396625519,
-0.1951453685760498,
0.3056437075138092,
0.00625011557713151,
0.532853901386261,
0.49051904678344727,
0.7862719297409058,
0.11330096423625946,
0.09921523928642273,
0.08341845870018005,
-0.40448781847953796,
0.14750394225120544,
0.059525538235902786,
-0.32269880175590515,
-0.2736034691333771,
0.2902248203754425,
0.8543416261672974,
-0.05546228587627411,
-0.5866928696632385,
0.1594054400920868,
0.08307301253080368,
-0.11354745179414749,
-0.26181140542030334,
0.6283763647079468,
0.06682942807674408,
0.35503292083740234,
0.4808463454246521,
0.5487295389175415,
0.5507251620292664,
-0.6145305037498474,
-0.061461035162210464,
0.5649237632751465,
0.0018533390248194337,
-0.6461105346679688,
0.9343559145927429,
0.04781334474682808,
-0.7183008193969727,
0.3947094976902008,
-0.149214506149292,
0.034626565873622894,
0.8560960292816162,
0.664065957069397,
0.8153499364852905,
-0.018909744918346405,
0.67514967918396,
0.08622989803552628,
-0.02109299786388874,
0.1914355456829071,
-0.03580300882458687,
-0.4223194420337677,
-0.649787187576294,
0.19061335921287537,
-0.26988884806632996,
-0.5280289649963379,
0.047924626618623734,
-0.677742063999176,
0.07798072695732117,
-0.2911163568496704,
-0.405862420797348,
0.35803523659706116,
-0.6455292105674744,
-0.9490878582000732,
0.14122804999351501,
-0.1574699431657791,
0.6594716906547546,
-0.8225910067558289,
0.532699465751648,
1.100145936012268,
-0.30752789974212646,
-0.39495861530303955,
0.08660677820444107,
0.008570967242121696,
-0.7518438100814819,
0.5558898448944092,
-0.05786711350083351,
-0.037414148449897766,
-0.06300138682126999,
-0.3566327393054962,
-0.7529559135437012,
1.3126338720321655,
-0.024624880403280258,
-0.2871881425380707,
0.06311243772506714,
0.08512909710407257,
1.1163080930709839,
-0.4407578706741333,
0.2745364308357239,
0.5195327997207642,
0.3619115948677063,
0.36214256286621094,
-0.5408521294593811,
0.004702135920524597,
-0.6600180268287659,
0.47854354977607727,
-0.005810927599668503,
-0.688317060470581,
0.5380710959434509,
-0.7663600444793701,
-0.3835272789001465,
0.1732649803161621,
0.7720475196838379,
0.2422158569097519,
0.8504505157470703,
0.47524428367614746,
0.20801006257534027,
0.7445298433303833,
0.1324804276227951,
0.9422704577445984,
-0.09084294736385345,
-0.13127772510051727,
0.6283535361289978,
-0.13250575959682465,
0.427282452583313,
0.6645782589912415,
-0.056241992861032486,
0.530630886554718,
0.3423481583595276,
-0.051106926053762436,
0.6665903329849243,
0.18333283066749573,
-0.38563695549964905,
-0.1316555291414261,
-0.3393907845020294,
-0.4618948698043823,
0.12158720195293427,
0.1631150245666504,
-0.17396001517772675,
0.015482097864151001,
0.5520715713500977,
-0.11159777641296387,
0.10219835489988327,
0.24827569723129272,
0.8893432021141052,
0.10222373157739639,
-0.7578012943267822,
0.36165663599967957,
-0.2429104745388031,
0.6746097803115845,
-0.5260137319564819,
-0.08971427381038666,
-0.3581259548664093,
-0.23066848516464233,
-0.34049949049949646,
-0.8294523358345032,
0.3180471956729889,
-0.07508743554353714,
-0.11382374912500381,
-0.2244463711977005,
0.555528998374939,
-0.022262418642640114,
-0.03156725689768791,
-0.36071670055389404,
0.47489243745803833,
0.11140625178813934,
0.32468464970588684,
-0.20543630421161652,
-0.18576009571552277,
-0.12497379630804062,
-0.16555432975292206,
0.434369295835495,
0.23658277094364166,
-0.2136073112487793,
0.988444447517395,
0.6499674320220947,
0.10531438142061234,
-0.1626187264919281,
0.21846456825733185,
0.9182880520820618,
-0.3814294636249542,
-0.5264228582382202,
-0.6702876687049866,
0.5751288533210754,
-0.16742141544818878,
-0.5899920463562012,
0.6369577646255493,
0.39084985852241516,
0.6696996688842773,
-0.3877197802066803,
1.0390710830688477,
-0.3579713702201843,
-0.12163940072059631,
-0.30116546154022217,
0.6054168939590454,
-0.6297899484634399,
0.49127981066703796,
0.005932216066867113,
-0.6131046414375305,
-0.2706717848777771,
0.24249906837940216,
-0.19441843032836914,
0.347410649061203,
0.4551325738430023,
0.5465703010559082,
-0.10051628947257996,
0.44381821155548096,
0.31345054507255554,
-0.15273156762123108,
0.609453558921814,
0.3811522126197815,
1.0060546398162842,
0.4293685257434845,
0.2535111606121063,
-0.3645395338535309,
-0.7630118727684021,
-0.3051648437976837,
-0.769639253616333,
-0.8723953366279602,
-0.7795551419258118,
-0.17375507950782776,
0.060870211571455,
0.19045810401439667,
0.7204552292823792,
0.5042651295661926,
-0.6481680274009705,
0.029405957087874413,
-0.18024460971355438,
-0.09293770045042038,
-0.5465471148490906,
-0.2627510130405426,
0.18577253818511963,
-0.4658547043800354,
-0.6567767858505249,
0.4030073285102844,
0.33541110157966614,
0.3347608745098114,
-0.3040636479854584,
-0.07643667608499527,
0.5189685821533203,
-0.19833707809448242,
0.3871038556098938,
0.8650936484336853,
-0.40650689601898193,
-0.13402114808559418,
0.218892440199852,
0.06232546269893646,
0.05337963625788689,
1.2205924987792969,
-0.8266304731369019,
0.6269190907478333,
0.6385251879692078,
0.5100052356719971,
0.5251743793487549,
0.020994966849684715,
0.6775450110435486,
-0.41907745599746704,
0.10695074498653412,
0.14171314239501953,
0.14972233772277832,
0.2989889085292816,
-0.862913191318512,
0.25718873739242554,
0.2653784155845642,
-0.4693397283554077,
-0.6173737049102783,
0.30333760380744934,
-0.6754993200302124,
-0.007458668667823076,
0.6549615859985352,
-0.2008286565542221,
0.11328671127557755,
-0.3041820526123047,
-0.2178443968296051,
0.13009576499462128,
-0.5046395063400269,
1.5491602420806885,
0.4539574980735779,
-0.8046144843101501,
-0.09802594780921936,
-0.17791324853897095,
0.6092069745063782,
0.5128048658370972,
-1.0585192441940308,
-0.4263734519481659,
0.1339140385389328,
0.2514685094356537,
0.3505726158618927,
0.6670201420783997,
0.24254481494426727,
0.46826210618019104,
-0.1620979905128479,
-0.3547970652580261,
-0.5186664462089539,
-0.3806759715080261,
-0.03703080117702484,
0.0900598019361496,
0.31130942702293396,
-0.27781689167022705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09880v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09880v1 | Inadequacies of Large Language Model Benchmarks in the Era of Generative Artificial Intelligence | 2024-02-15T11:08:10 | 2024-02-15T11:08:10 | Timothy R. McIntosh, Teo Susnjak, Tong Liu, Paul Watters, Malka N. Halgamuge | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | The rapid rise in popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs) with emerging
capabilities has spurred public curiosity to evaluate and compare different
LLMs, leading many researchers to propose their LLM benchmarks. Noticing
preliminary inadequacies in those benchmarks, we embarked on a study to
critically assess 23 state-of-the-art LLM benchmarks, using our novel unified
evaluation framework through the lenses of people, process, and technology,
under the pillars of functionality and security. Our research uncovered
significant limitations, including biases, difficulties in measuring genuine
reasoning, adaptability, implementation inconsistencies, prompt engineering
complexity, evaluator diversity, and the overlooking of cultural and
ideological norms in one comprehensive assessment. Our discussions emphasized
the urgent need for standardized methodologies, regulatory certainties, and
ethical guidelines in light of Artificial Intelligence (AI) advancements,
including advocating for an evolution from static benchmarks to dynamic
behavioral profiling to accurately capture LLMs' complex behaviors and
potential risks. Our study highlighted the necessity for a paradigm shift in
LLM evaluation methodologies, underlining the importance of collaborative
efforts for the development of universally accepted benchmarks and the
enhancement of AI systems' integration into society. | [
-0.41357421875,
-0.6613863706588745,
0.6191688776016235,
0.29931706190109253,
0.07334313541650772,
0.43158406019210815,
-0.3982771337032318,
-0.6484328508377075,
-0.2873285412788391,
0.3004259765148163,
-0.21296067535877228,
-0.3290887176990509,
-0.640878438949585,
0.19557012617588043,
-0.4813949763774872,
0.6308666467666626,
0.011017966084182262,
0.07802297174930573,
-0.44967782497406006,
-0.3982110917568207,
-0.33379024267196655,
-0.6733669638633728,
-0.4191097021102905,
-0.5273172855377197,
0.08934395015239716,
0.0603729709982872,
0.6092051267623901,
0.42440539598464966,
0.6950116753578186,
0.35797426104545593,
-0.12328595668077469,
0.12542465329170227,
-0.26025819778442383,
-0.06356317549943924,
0.012241538614034653,
-0.24753251671791077,
-0.6164831519126892,
0.0357193723320961,
0.6857284307479858,
0.9052013158798218,
-0.05625532194972038,
0.35732501745224,
0.1609106808900833,
0.712079644203186,
-0.8077822327613831,
0.18837371468544006,
-0.6379046440124512,
0.038104526698589325,
-0.3755427598953247,
0.05759782716631889,
-0.19847433269023895,
-0.3910023868083954,
0.07574547082185745,
-0.23700042068958282,
-0.14346134662628174,
-0.07869057357311249,
0.4112406373023987,
0.4364745318889618,
-0.319654643535614,
-0.11736801266670227,
-1.0451512336730957,
0.7911020517349243,
-0.6113530993461609,
0.41010773181915283,
0.09506148099899292,
0.18589486181735992,
-0.2198602706193924,
-0.611240804195404,
-0.42791852355003357,
-0.6073547601699829,
0.4474038779735565,
-0.1529882550239563,
-0.2012319713830948,
0.010208801366388798,
0.32722198963165283,
0.2776387333869934,
-0.39139220118522644,
0.49394068121910095,
-0.1643550544977188,
-0.21758303046226501,
0.82674241065979,
0.3209135830402374,
0.22047077119350433,
0.09614547342061996,
-0.3424356281757355,
0.01915060728788376,
-0.7904635667800903,
-0.0005581712466664612,
0.42961084842681885,
0.08862648159265518,
-0.08180686086416245,
0.3101396858692169,
-0.26392462849617004,
0.3181402087211609,
-0.3280841112136841,
0.05151236429810524,
0.46485021710395813,
-0.4677702486515045,
-0.22908861935138702,
-0.16822728514671326,
0.9871720671653748,
0.2741098999977112,
0.3659837543964386,
-0.3316004276275635,
-0.21364755928516388,
0.07709560543298721,
0.4548353850841522,
-0.4928104877471924,
0.04646826162934303,
0.23428058624267578,
-0.3346519470214844,
-0.2384515106678009,
0.13831737637519836,
-0.8034851551055908,
-0.5684517621994019,
-0.15563775599002838,
0.10359585285186768,
-0.13820980489253998,
-0.35524213314056396,
-0.06110785901546478,
0.04313790425658226,
0.42171138525009155,
0.3677569627761841,
-0.668501615524292,
0.30779829621315,
1.0409363508224487,
0.6269741654396057,
-0.3696868121623993,
-0.3175337016582489,
0.09719540178775787,
-0.1173240914940834,
-0.5534347891807556,
0.619053304195404,
-0.6004309058189392,
-0.5917665958404541,
0.05767153576016426,
-0.39436233043670654,
-0.020852183923125267,
-0.7591781616210938,
0.7440100908279419,
-0.3567533791065216,
-0.1838221251964569,
-0.2495974898338318,
-0.4316128194332123,
-0.03820895776152611,
0.3395577669143677,
-0.4698074162006378,
1.017381191253662,
-0.006122861988842487,
-0.4445856511592865,
0.3394266366958618,
-0.7646251916885376,
-0.37678518891334534,
0.46324360370635986,
-0.45507553219795227,
-0.32820409536361694,
0.22376154363155365,
0.01989329420030117,
0.17579959332942963,
-0.6354058384895325,
0.6168278455734253,
-0.4149465262889862,
-0.49188530445098877,
0.5366395115852356,
-0.867739200592041,
0.8865376114845276,
0.15749523043632507,
-0.46051719784736633,
0.2844543755054474,
-0.8237417936325073,
0.15401998162269592,
0.12063951790332794,
-0.37263980507850647,
-0.0830664187669754,
0.12354708462953568,
0.11283689737319946,
0.007652932778000832,
0.4396848976612091,
-0.348506361246109,
-0.08052050322294235,
-0.26867160201072693,
0.7227317690849304,
0.8595588803291321,
-0.30790725350379944,
0.37776699662208557,
-0.3816078007221222,
0.4313492774963379,
-0.3238353133201599,
0.2866310179233551,
0.11786817759275436,
-0.3161395192146301,
-0.7106319665908813,
-0.12884175777435303,
0.1252102553844452,
0.5490026473999023,
-0.1361822932958603,
0.7467200756072998,
-0.30638909339904785,
-0.7348326444625854,
-0.5358133316040039,
0.3017091751098633,
0.4239178001880646,
0.2253420054912567,
0.14941053092479706,
-0.34879952669143677,
-0.41887539625167847,
-0.9710727334022522,
-0.2715725302696228,
-0.5115386843681335,
-0.1859138160943985,
0.24717891216278076,
0.6104204058647156,
-0.3334009647369385,
0.7333590388298035,
0.06625596433877945,
0.0753050297498703,
-0.2871018946170807,
0.19483555853366852,
-0.034041035920381546,
0.4091329574584961,
0.403227299451828,
-0.7073890566825867,
-0.0779460072517395,
-0.03596413880586624,
-0.903165876865387,
-0.03588036447763443,
0.07333187758922577,
0.15612882375717163,
0.28960147500038147,
0.5387132167816162,
-0.6346771121025085,
0.1923639476299286,
0.3747800290584564,
0.10960137099027634,
0.622327446937561,
-0.16738982498645782,
0.1692294180393219,
-0.5973297357559204,
0.3582603931427002,
-0.026001742109656334,
0.16001857817173004,
-0.5520386695861816,
0.34841424226760864,
0.052834682166576385,
0.057312414050102234,
-0.1694643795490265,
0.472551167011261,
-0.42349717020988464,
-0.21165330708026886,
-0.15994754433631897,
0.04932871833443642,
-0.1343601644039154,
0.1850733608007431,
-0.5105521082878113,
0.9076385498046875,
0.5085660815238953,
-0.5372121334075928,
0.5036149621009827,
0.16454283893108368,
-0.5555384159088135,
0.5910845994949341,
-0.6539853811264038,
0.2866066098213196,
0.1306302398443222,
0.16520321369171143,
-0.652414083480835,
-0.15969882905483246,
0.23811876773834229,
-0.25464504957199097,
0.12104007601737976,
0.25705820322036743,
-0.5853663682937622,
-0.40965184569358826,
-0.39579764008522034,
0.5088046789169312,
0.5758723020553589,
-0.20410147309303284,
0.6379956007003784,
0.5094024538993835,
-0.11216364055871964,
-0.5555732846260071,
-0.47513899207115173,
0.4327893853187561,
-0.2907200753688812,
-0.5663498640060425,
0.2485657036304474,
-0.10732926428318024,
-0.6866374611854553,
-0.17500543594360352,
-0.23435063660144806,
0.0034318496473133564,
0.6280431151390076,
0.2208828628063202,
0.2320999652147293,
-0.2534126341342926,
0.1025632694363594,
-0.38483867049217224,
-0.024234749376773834,
0.45574092864990234,
-0.025189632549881935,
0.5513512492179871,
-0.44310063123703003,
-0.636154055595398,
-0.36653339862823486,
0.14139649271965027,
0.7655512094497681,
-0.36845532059669495,
0.4396016001701355,
0.4314592182636261,
-0.31784766912460327,
-0.08247064799070358,
-0.7476233839988708,
0.08220569789409637,
-0.43567731976509094,
0.6097795367240906,
-0.08921544253826141,
-0.8910648822784424,
0.5409343242645264,
-0.24089916050434113,
0.10491398721933365,
0.44990694522857666,
0.5500649809837341,
0.015638453885912895,
0.880732536315918,
0.5183039903640747,
-0.21962782740592957,
0.26361343264579773,
0.1404242068529129,
0.3693088889122009,
-0.9007341265678406,
-0.34229719638824463,
-0.7184454798698425,
-0.11254508793354034,
-0.8100045919418335,
-0.2913851737976074,
0.4730790853500366,
-0.05543862655758858,
-0.3820427358150482,
0.018145868554711342,
-0.1767650991678238,
0.23692186176776886,
0.363370418548584,
-0.24564258754253387,
0.43711724877357483,
-0.19619625806808472,
-0.008659090846776962,
0.1974683254957199,
-0.3925604224205017,
-0.824999213218689,
1.2833422422409058,
0.5221743583679199,
0.7221284508705139,
0.07866041362285614,
0.4900527000427246,
0.5041199326515198,
0.30687057971954346,
-0.6774360537528992,
0.7982004880905151,
-0.11043856292963028,
-0.5263267755508423,
-0.4075940251350403,
-0.4153090715408325,
-0.770313560962677,
0.13092879951000214,
-0.16840770840644836,
-0.8907286524772644,
-0.00301328650675714,
-0.20516864955425262,
-0.23105335235595703,
0.10442813485860825,
-0.5377992391586304,
0.7617791295051575,
-0.6239948868751526,
-0.24448314309120178,
-0.3329678475856781,
-0.47918200492858887,
0.4156392514705658,
-0.3278658390045166,
0.226339191198349,
-0.4984833598136902,
-0.009732034057378769,
0.7109644412994385,
-0.15640728175640106,
0.6670286059379578,
0.12071668356657028,
-0.11483489722013474,
0.10211967676877975,
-0.192026749253273,
0.16255639493465424,
-0.07754790037870407,
-0.23067869246006012,
0.5630373358726501,
-0.17231033742427826,
-0.3311147391796112,
-0.44927841424942017,
0.685927152633667,
-0.9163571000099182,
-0.9188086986541748,
-0.48473191261291504,
-0.48506230115890503,
-0.4864204525947571,
0.07447857409715652,
-0.018958501517772675,
0.258676677942276,
-0.6708510518074036,
0.2974439859390259,
0.5433423519134521,
-0.15395256876945496,
0.42992764711380005,
0.38389962911605835,
-0.0005478272214531898,
-0.18345795571804047,
0.7970686554908752,
0.10116516053676605,
0.20484712719917297,
0.11863719671964645,
-0.008511845022439957,
-0.25949764251708984,
-0.8170313835144043,
-0.36004015803337097,
-0.005437120795249939,
-0.6347344517707825,
0.10860864818096161,
-0.45632684230804443,
-0.4296376705169678,
-0.37596946954727173,
0.07210542261600494,
-0.5047027468681335,
-0.05645618960261345,
-0.16909293830394745,
0.06287139654159546,
0.044571083039045334,
0.8291128873825073,
0.2075616717338562,
-0.06060105189681053,
-0.6665316224098206,
0.12445154786109924,
0.1021270677447319,
0.4153655469417572,
0.15622879564762115,
-0.35510098934173584,
-0.057965733110904694,
-0.12983198463916779,
-0.37526753544807434,
-0.4334234297275543,
-0.13879765570163727,
-0.002114748116582632,
0.9541497230529785,
0.453667551279068,
0.07855149358510971,
0.501367449760437,
-0.43274831771850586,
0.6138567924499512,
0.029326120391488075,
-0.9971605539321899,
0.16161656379699707,
-0.19210323691368103,
0.1740027368068695,
0.5732693672180176,
0.2938402593135834,
-0.5234113335609436,
-0.33077698945999146,
-0.40077248215675354,
-1.0008288621902466,
0.3511311709880829,
0.1407041847705841,
0.3809478282928467,
0.14910493791103363,
0.14698448777198792,
0.060540489852428436,
0.3205711841583252,
-0.6487760543823242,
-0.2339182198047638,
0.06507178395986557,
-0.1218625083565712,
0.04073890671133995,
-0.08960924297571182,
-0.2919864356517792,
-0.11083149909973145,
0.4089028239250183,
-0.09590935707092285,
0.16758839786052704,
-0.09834115952253342,
-0.06531000882387161,
-0.02145625837147236,
0.591996967792511,
0.48368436098098755,
1.1564536094665527,
-0.06315478682518005,
0.01965116523206234,
0.23906907439231873,
-0.3410504162311554,
0.2517073452472687,
0.334885835647583,
-0.34666866064071655,
-0.4853579103946686,
0.44858118891716003,
0.6019562482833862,
0.18331880867481232,
-0.9530409574508667,
0.3222535252571106,
-0.054094601422548294,
-0.08505042642354965,
-0.5659346580505371,
0.30125609040260315,
0.030395349487662315,
0.3200564384460449,
0.5440160036087036,
0.2845429480075836,
0.08581186830997467,
-0.6387755274772644,
-0.07728976011276245,
0.7908533811569214,
-0.24358218908309937,
-0.1694735735654831,
0.5277445912361145,
0.45328715443611145,
-0.42487794160842896,
0.5716052055358887,
-0.10676165670156479,
-0.3517022430896759,
0.6586897373199463,
0.12061018496751785,
1.1196051836013794,
-0.10305516421794891,
0.20778986811637878,
-0.03644360229372978,
0.6748828291893005,
-0.2223048061132431,
0.021605655550956726,
-0.058568645268678665,
-0.8032552003860474,
-0.1930394470691681,
-0.6839712262153625,
-0.5393898487091064,
0.2812678813934326,
-0.5441135764122009,
0.028497440740466118,
-0.7304584980010986,
-0.247697651386261,
-0.05702482536435127,
0.07535799592733383,
-0.5964935421943665,
-0.14582833647727966,
0.41573217511177063,
0.9218059778213501,
-0.6804732084274292,
0.5129609704017639,
0.6475552916526794,
-0.31585198640823364,
-0.36194905638694763,
0.28407856822013855,
0.042331695556640625,
-0.9282034039497375,
0.47194942831993103,
0.2655283808708191,
-0.12770678102970123,
-0.28517600893974304,
-0.45408082008361816,
-0.758705735206604,
0.8968519568443298,
0.4057600796222687,
-0.6614475250244141,
0.0002666373911779374,
0.41385120153427124,
0.770523190498352,
-0.3373207449913025,
0.2875868082046509,
0.8590154647827148,
0.5754098892211914,
-0.23494553565979004,
-1.042601466178894,
0.13531549274921417,
-0.3157285749912262,
0.24217760562896729,
0.13727660477161407,
-0.7959337830543518,
0.6590591669082642,
-0.09862040728330612,
-0.33100271224975586,
0.3376574218273163,
0.38642752170562744,
0.26916059851646423,
0.45442286133766174,
0.2818930447101593,
0.4667665958404541,
0.6604783535003662,
-0.1827818900346756,
0.9700767993927002,
-0.32458147406578064,
-0.016252608969807625,
0.7707576751708984,
-0.7886917591094971,
0.832236647605896,
0.32643207907676697,
-0.4312407970428467,
0.19443292915821075,
0.45029476284980774,
-0.277180939912796,
-0.013453826308250427,
0.41597846150398254,
-0.3261353373527527,
-0.26888176798820496,
-0.3163871169090271,
-0.3129267692565918,
0.6641423106193542,
0.38946402072906494,
-0.10626532137393951,
-0.13506980240345,
-0.27618494629859924,
-0.1113472506403923,
0.24380835890769958,
-0.16406527161598206,
0.7563987970352173,
0.05819457024335861,
-0.6847883462905884,
0.3712220788002014,
0.0901639312505722,
0.6718676686286926,
-0.5139957666397095,
0.16359186172485352,
-0.23135723173618317,
0.08737899363040924,
-0.0189500879496336,
-0.739719033241272,
0.1488422453403473,
0.21750596165657043,
0.09986277669668198,
-0.24571169912815094,
0.3764691948890686,
0.04840230941772461,
-0.5129594802856445,
0.5064246654510498,
0.7980272173881531,
0.08153071254491806,
0.04505550488829613,
-0.7512288689613342,
0.5106282830238342,
-0.3401624262332916,
-0.06220337375998497,
0.41581782698631287,
0.21245934069156647,
-0.19543707370758057,
0.8233057260513306,
0.578789472579956,
0.04415984824299812,
-0.13107198476791382,
0.24820435047149658,
0.7870853543281555,
-0.5963894128799438,
-0.10693594813346863,
-1.093921422958374,
0.173280730843544,
-0.055202141404151917,
-0.5311804413795471,
0.6637161374092102,
0.37834206223487854,
0.9774687886238098,
0.30598199367523193,
0.9182600378990173,
0.03285594657063484,
0.14474618434906006,
-0.4764309227466583,
0.7870845794677734,
-0.3776140809059143,
0.5013434886932373,
-0.2123524248600006,
-1.031383991241455,
-0.1435217261314392,
0.2828061878681183,
-0.3232250511646271,
0.47120267152786255,
0.45884907245635986,
0.608626663684845,
0.35229501128196716,
0.003250299720093608,
0.34444350004196167,
0.32560256123542786,
0.3602792024612427,
0.36715033650398254,
1.095054030418396,
-0.23542343080043793,
0.42513710260391235,
0.035031791776418686,
-0.17693611979484558,
-0.39888113737106323,
-0.8976907730102539,
-0.69590824842453,
-0.45392388105392456,
-0.37707284092903137,
0.026119422167539597,
0.19561120867729187,
1.018209457397461,
0.4973622262477875,
-0.7472746968269348,
-0.4759257137775421,
-0.05441070720553398,
0.24039240181446075,
-0.0908021479845047,
-0.21013924479484558,
0.04404035210609436,
-0.13251543045043945,
-0.5550782084465027,
0.4001191556453705,
0.5484390258789062,
-0.07916798442602158,
-0.7706142067909241,
-0.163038969039917,
0.11132927983999252,
0.13258202373981476,
0.39085593819618225,
0.4124678075313568,
-1.072894811630249,
-0.3118045926094055,
-0.10533711314201355,
-0.24163980782032013,
0.0693444013595581,
0.6440520286560059,
-0.388604074716568,
0.26225781440734863,
0.34960177540779114,
0.9203505516052246,
-0.19688044488430023,
-0.06930172443389893,
0.584908127784729,
-0.31420645117759705,
-0.13609668612480164,
0.29967066645622253,
0.2678457796573639,
0.49516671895980835,
-0.1268455535173416,
0.39573511481285095,
0.17433509230613708,
-0.7042945623397827,
-1.0199233293533325,
0.27120891213417053,
-0.7879363894462585,
-0.10488764196634293,
0.7966489195823669,
-0.07403310388326645,
-0.11822263896465302,
-0.24091513454914093,
0.19725021719932556,
0.01333684753626585,
-0.38591015338897705,
1.0228160619735718,
0.7329021692276001,
-0.20256702601909637,
-0.04995507746934891,
-0.5708742141723633,
0.40470442175865173,
0.36476948857307434,
-0.9713997840881348,
0.1915634274482727,
0.3749348223209381,
0.07571711391210556,
0.2787402868270874,
0.4592442214488983,
-0.16150356829166412,
0.2595512270927429,
-0.04405581206083298,
-0.026361944153904915,
0.016648482531309128,
-0.34642651677131653,
-0.4921014904975891,
0.1576218605041504,
0.4436480700969696,
0.14718122780323029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09874v1 | Camouflage is all you need: Evaluating and Enhancing Language Model Robustness Against Camouflage Adversarial Attacks | 2024-02-15T10:58:22 | 2024-02-15T10:58:22 | Álvaro Huertas-García, Alejandro Martín, Javier Huertas-Tato, David Camacho | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adversarial attacks represent a substantial challenge in Natural Language
Processing (NLP). This study undertakes a systematic exploration of this
challenge in two distinct phases: vulnerability evaluation and resilience
enhancement of Transformer-based models under adversarial attacks.
In the evaluation phase, we assess the susceptibility of three Transformer
configurations, encoder-decoder, encoder-only, and decoder-only setups, to
adversarial attacks of escalating complexity across datasets containing
offensive language and misinformation. Encoder-only models manifest a 14% and
21% performance drop in offensive language detection and misinformation
detection tasks, respectively. Decoder-only models register a 16% decrease in
both tasks, while encoder-decoder models exhibit a maximum performance drop of
14% and 26% in the respective tasks.
The resilience-enhancement phase employs adversarial training, integrating
pre-camouflaged and dynamically altered data. This approach effectively reduces
the performance drop in encoder-only models to an average of 5% in offensive
language detection and 2% in misinformation detection tasks. Decoder-only
models, occasionally exceeding original performance, limit the performance drop
to 7% and 2% in the respective tasks. Although not surpassing the original
performance, Encoder-decoder models can reduce the drop to an average of 6% and
2% respectively.
Results suggest a trade-off between performance and robustness, with some
models maintaining similar performance while gaining robustness. Our study and
adversarial training techniques have been incorporated into an open-source tool
for generating camouflaged datasets. However, methodology effectiveness depends
on the specific camouflage technique and data encountered, emphasizing the need
for continued exploration. | [
-0.34380245208740234,
-0.7552451491355896,
0.022854529321193695,
0.2101198434829712,
-0.11330196261405945,
0.22212526202201843,
-0.15985900163650513,
-0.4684237539768219,
-0.07079605013132095,
0.48933422565460205,
-0.4230656027793884,
-0.21172592043876648,
-1.0254721641540527,
0.08635953813791275,
-0.6033446788787842,
0.9043921828269958,
0.48164552450180054,
-0.05068786442279816,
0.03922668471932411,
-0.3475315272808075,
-0.21655723452568054,
-0.7002673745155334,
-0.7687029838562012,
-0.10762185603380203,
0.20778758823871613,
-0.24717511236667633,
1.2174317836761475,
0.713586151599884,
0.5237422585487366,
0.3946438431739807,
-0.3302728533744812,
-0.024313392117619514,
-0.5733194947242737,
0.39303791522979736,
-0.24636095762252808,
-0.5760263204574585,
-0.09483424574136734,
-0.19619107246398926,
0.3717901110649109,
0.34612077474594116,
-0.040486834943294525,
-0.09740510582923889,
0.052194688469171524,
0.3959976136684418,
-1.0422641038894653,
-0.09162787348031998,
-0.830984890460968,
-0.008725675754249096,
-0.32857581973075867,
0.05714501813054085,
-0.5320066809654236,
0.02935635857284069,
0.009091999381780624,
-0.4596957266330719,
0.3904733955860138,
-0.32599759101867676,
0.7882730960845947,
0.26352304220199585,
-0.11288408190011978,
-0.31602776050567627,
-0.7828916311264038,
0.7705578207969666,
-0.7295063138008118,
0.33060261607170105,
0.32904326915740967,
0.38341930508613586,
-0.2542212903499603,
-0.7379582524299622,
-0.3928927779197693,
-0.22546695172786713,
-0.15623557567596436,
0.20539793372154236,
-0.7877968549728394,
-0.04932984709739685,
0.255206823348999,
0.39568793773651123,
-0.6454228758811951,
0.10236557573080063,
-0.1853259801864624,
-0.321416437625885,
0.4467618465423584,
0.06522192806005478,
0.4897434413433075,
-0.08882258832454681,
-0.26746833324432373,
-0.5244684815406799,
-0.4562789499759674,
0.03852817788720131,
0.6198172569274902,
0.24844472110271454,
0.13601244986057281,
0.5386896729469299,
0.08961533010005951,
0.5182719826698303,
-0.18788447976112366,
0.11538979411125183,
-0.16928395628929138,
-0.212315633893013,
-0.31796780228614807,
-0.4786907732486725,
0.9036612510681152,
0.02369401417672634,
-0.007697329856455326,
-0.616740882396698,
-0.4720638394355774,
0.44737404584884644,
0.83250492811203,
-0.6036054491996765,
-0.3665139973163605,
0.008832268416881561,
-0.21535497903823853,
-0.7375369668006897,
-0.04726084694266319,
-1.0673874616622925,
-0.5972018241882324,
0.18341661989688873,
0.44281941652297974,
-0.6068782806396484,
-0.2688717544078827,
0.2391442060470581,
-0.3435533940792084,
0.307616651058197,
-0.11692141741514206,
-0.8957194089889526,
0.4777182340621948,
0.7765929698944092,
0.8400586843490601,
-0.15018552541732788,
-0.20768257975578308,
-0.24263575673103333,
-0.04922112822532654,
-0.2954947352409363,
0.4612455666065216,
-0.4971352517604828,
-0.29300999641418457,
0.12223876267671585,
0.1272612065076828,
-0.3904663920402527,
-0.3128986656665802,
0.8866688013076782,
-0.8191896677017212,
0.11276165395975113,
0.1500207781791687,
-0.17373910546302795,
-0.07729694992303848,
0.5136580467224121,
-1.1160308122634888,
0.8493306636810303,
0.20546533167362213,
-0.9438459277153015,
-0.11240128427743912,
-0.7093287110328674,
-0.5667222142219543,
-0.03639664500951767,
0.13146662712097168,
-0.6188217997550964,
-0.10394622385501862,
0.49677368998527527,
0.14755873382091522,
-0.2069198340177536,
0.09255055338144302,
-0.22486723959445953,
-0.22136330604553223,
0.4737509489059448,
-0.8069543838500977,
1.1536405086517334,
0.16296187043190002,
-0.4919997751712799,
-0.02092154137790203,
-0.7544978857040405,
-0.05676558241248131,
0.3515646159648895,
-0.37971144914627075,
-0.18833206593990326,
-0.06329377740621567,
-0.02131308987736702,
-0.0962732806801796,
-0.01049005426466465,
-0.47487810254096985,
-0.07952675223350525,
-0.8958725929260254,
0.3655366599559784,
0.7515807747840881,
-0.17402613162994385,
0.6609551906585693,
-0.250126451253891,
0.8263500928878784,
-0.3047248125076294,
0.43359363079071045,
-0.16143707931041718,
-0.5016037821769714,
-0.8997367024421692,
-0.29124248027801514,
0.1727769821882248,
0.6779516935348511,
-1.1761269569396973,
0.154519721865654,
-0.21048502624034882,
-0.6108151078224182,
-0.5774441361427307,
-0.06531602144241333,
0.7877777814865112,
0.24419592320919037,
0.43828698992729187,
-0.07349051535129547,
-0.6595655083656311,
-0.8418636918067932,
-0.5572171211242676,
-0.11547791212797165,
-0.35100021958351135,
-0.0960158258676529,
0.6030283570289612,
-0.3494262993335724,
0.6935933828353882,
-0.37975433468818665,
-0.02270231954753399,
-0.34628158807754517,
0.2161853164434433,
-0.053655482828617096,
0.27307242155075073,
0.7905758619308472,
-0.9419811964035034,
-0.18890948593616486,
-0.02723369002342224,
-0.5607627034187317,
0.09338239580392838,
0.06520171463489532,
-0.14410710334777832,
0.3052298426628113,
0.16694886982440948,
-0.6718526482582092,
0.49968621134757996,
0.7021911144256592,
-0.09589890390634537,
0.38644739985466003,
-0.03959512710571289,
0.02205604873597622,
-0.9115350842475891,
0.10279036313295364,
-0.16312208771705627,
-0.12332641333341599,
-1.1206207275390625,
0.6754631400108337,
0.040502093732357025,
-0.27857640385627747,
-0.35930392146110535,
0.1940128058195114,
-0.30310457944869995,
0.1963355839252472,
-0.15444545447826385,
-0.09525987505912781,
0.16966211795806885,
0.36966854333877563,
-0.16683608293533325,
0.6563606858253479,
0.7340625524520874,
-0.585342526435852,
0.4849874675273895,
0.052084945142269135,
-0.2350596785545349,
0.09788025170564651,
-0.6891482472419739,
0.2438577264547348,
-0.14471177756786346,
-0.09599651396274567,
-0.7193956971168518,
-0.16943351924419403,
0.5525116324424744,
-0.6014679670333862,
0.6311427354812622,
-0.26593396067619324,
-0.18277722597122192,
-0.1877574920654297,
-0.575542151927948,
0.1709854006767273,
0.26562753319740295,
-0.636218249797821,
0.8054342865943909,
0.4094200134277344,
-0.016472822055220604,
-0.924519956111908,
-0.8194699287414551,
0.4560234546661377,
-0.15706254541873932,
-0.7713610529899597,
0.3773791193962097,
0.04242350161075592,
-0.1549782156944275,
-0.11616021394729614,
-0.003478574100881815,
-0.23224985599517822,
0.4225069284439087,
0.09718187153339386,
0.33657318353652954,
-0.22352935373783112,
-0.27014926075935364,
-0.5118709206581116,
-0.10529309511184692,
0.261652410030365,
0.0016847116639837623,
0.49906691908836365,
-0.2905254364013672,
-0.4561239182949066,
-0.05600114166736603,
0.36238694190979004,
0.7528741359710693,
-0.2926933169364929,
1.0567840337753296,
0.6718935966491699,
-0.4889445900917053,
-0.06310537457466125,
-0.3891485929489136,
-0.12337548285722733,
-0.486724853515625,
0.5114786624908447,
-0.151523157954216,
-0.4763973355293274,
0.5674794912338257,
0.4120554029941559,
0.1721649169921875,
0.36060184240341187,
0.1184116005897522,
0.31513097882270813,
1.0007095336914062,
0.7301532626152039,
-0.2869407534599304,
0.4251272678375244,
-0.23341155052185059,
0.41488343477249146,
-0.6686655282974243,
-0.3969983458518982,
-0.5400955080986023,
-0.05903647094964981,
-0.5575767755508423,
-0.3546185791492462,
0.12456601858139038,
-0.10766477882862091,
-0.05263965576887131,
0.6104592680931091,
-0.5869715213775635,
0.5614262223243713,
0.35269734263420105,
0.22208164632320404,
-0.07856877148151398,
-0.06669089198112488,
0.4546787440776825,
-0.260043203830719,
-0.8058844208717346,
-0.4258808493614197,
1.2416012287139893,
0.5062313079833984,
0.8892333507537842,
0.5269257426261902,
0.19083172082901,
0.22771669924259186,
0.27277132868766785,
-0.8147714138031006,
0.4483417272567749,
-0.4319644868373871,
-0.3170267641544342,
-0.2849961221218109,
-0.42962899804115295,
-1.0424017906188965,
0.4424472749233246,
-0.34722214937210083,
-0.4157334864139557,
0.1650170087814331,
-0.09130661189556122,
-0.15265856683254242,
0.37542182207107544,
-0.5255323648452759,
0.7469090819358826,
-0.24605168402194977,
-0.24206675589084625,
0.3535490334033966,
-0.5731204152107239,
0.5870128870010376,
-0.1399967521429062,
0.24548883736133575,
0.47564858198165894,
0.01855340041220188,
0.6327105164527893,
-0.01817125454545021,
0.7996014952659607,
0.05136154592037201,
0.02688693255186081,
-0.09205321222543716,
0.26518702507019043,
0.6487377882003784,
-0.1096063032746315,
-0.26176556944847107,
0.141482874751091,
-0.2526988983154297,
-0.2295827716588974,
-0.7693679928779602,
0.4704302251338959,
-0.7060278654098511,
-0.7841428518295288,
-0.4503119885921478,
-0.490386426448822,
0.013524023815989494,
0.1607876569032669,
0.46932652592658997,
0.4104292690753937,
-0.3930324614048004,
0.46040043234825134,
0.8504493236541748,
-0.29215824604034424,
0.4973342716693878,
0.5175508260726929,
0.1612873077392578,
-0.5193442106246948,
0.7870434522628784,
-0.15149424970149994,
0.5911450982093811,
0.3518708050251007,
0.18003202974796295,
-0.34051308035850525,
-0.5294055938720703,
-0.48956236243247986,
-0.13759396970272064,
-0.8934696316719055,
-0.48635607957839966,
-0.7736127376556396,
-0.6096054911613464,
-0.6943773031234741,
-0.10356618463993073,
-0.5841413140296936,
-0.4038357436656952,
-0.2791922390460968,
0.1163872554898262,
0.16188819706439972,
0.6540800929069519,
0.15194784104824066,
0.3488016426563263,
-0.4105852544307709,
0.5937550663948059,
0.3155295252799988,
0.08979170024394989,
-0.2814495861530304,
-0.8039734959602356,
-0.051952529698610306,
0.39028939604759216,
-0.4063850939273834,
-0.9743717908859253,
0.6899567246437073,
0.24779930710792542,
0.5461746454238892,
0.3535524010658264,
0.2606346011161804,
0.5541325807571411,
-0.1645774394273758,
0.7933838367462158,
-0.03693104162812233,
-0.7910380363464355,
0.5565893054008484,
-0.126640185713768,
0.36821413040161133,
0.20268292725086212,
0.2028091698884964,
-0.07621601969003677,
-0.8163167834281921,
-0.6298016309738159,
-0.9205037355422974,
0.8878511190414429,
0.7799548506736755,
0.1311538815498352,
0.08328063786029816,
0.09298732131719589,
-0.35194486379623413,
-0.10917415469884872,
-1.0202641487121582,
-0.35888826847076416,
-0.6925178170204163,
0.06876020133495331,
-0.005214578937739134,
-0.3242413103580475,
-0.46717774868011475,
0.13261336088180542,
0.7586351633071899,
-0.006858877371996641,
0.08550948649644852,
-0.10723356157541275,
-0.2164686918258667,
0.30904605984687805,
0.4715350568294525,
0.5281042456626892,
0.20781885087490082,
-0.018372580409049988,
0.22411227226257324,
0.18447300791740417,
-0.6591103076934814,
-0.025282874703407288,
0.16432519257068634,
-0.22273343801498413,
0.0737215206027031,
0.5855021476745605,
0.6818065047264099,
0.41448748111724854,
-0.39003080129623413,
0.868923008441925,
-0.4113925099372864,
0.04665210843086243,
-0.06589197367429733,
0.12208631634712219,
-0.15086351335048676,
0.20590651035308838,
0.07717711478471756,
0.5830337405204773,
0.10059677064418793,
-0.43156760931015015,
-0.005546181928366423,
0.7889304161071777,
-0.033744703978300095,
-0.17014969885349274,
0.5645570755004883,
-0.27415791153907776,
-0.4932413399219513,
0.4911747872829437,
-0.09223858267068863,
-0.8818608522415161,
0.7676016688346863,
0.8848327994346619,
0.9364192485809326,
-0.6681004762649536,
0.2693125605583191,
0.300449937582016,
0.9356420040130615,
-0.1694454550743103,
-0.3502369821071625,
0.06491252034902573,
-0.734032928943634,
0.009166566655039787,
-0.7288906574249268,
-0.36646905541419983,
0.39387914538383484,
-1.0004950761795044,
0.07878550887107849,
-0.35399365425109863,
-0.1168215423822403,
-0.058828048408031464,
-0.3877639174461365,
-0.387207567691803,
0.11117924749851227,
-0.07189822196960449,
0.7727376818656921,
-0.86075359582901,
0.5527961254119873,
0.48042333126068115,
-0.13261741399765015,
-0.23083344101905823,
-0.06216708570718765,
0.04228164628148079,
-0.7163549661636353,
0.27861011028289795,
0.15036749839782715,
-0.4338435232639313,
-0.3728426992893219,
-0.29458922147750854,
-0.7608092427253723,
0.9069738388061523,
0.8227113485336304,
-0.18700824677944183,
0.16156093776226044,
0.4095456898212433,
0.7213018536567688,
-0.077084481716156,
0.18237590789794922,
0.8463422656059265,
0.28765222430229187,
0.19873788952827454,
-0.4427970349788666,
0.015424208715558052,
-0.5438342690467834,
0.2475573718547821,
0.06825391203165054,
-0.16917885839939117,
0.8054002523422241,
0.17773886024951935,
-0.7371379733085632,
0.1477239429950714,
0.2872956693172455,
-0.06174353510141373,
0.01038624532520771,
0.39852043986320496,
0.5915225148200989,
0.5509849786758423,
-0.2284015566110611,
1.197986125946045,
-0.2767249345779419,
0.027954133227467537,
0.9054979085922241,
0.27246803045272827,
0.756536602973938,
0.26074808835983276,
-0.029096286743879318,
0.14771410822868347,
0.11668426543474197,
-0.16006048023700714,
0.5345520377159119,
0.03142518177628517,
-0.41187000274658203,
-0.0026589317712932825,
0.05355425551533699,
-0.35998278856277466,
0.4944896996021271,
0.35484108328819275,
-0.3778926432132721,
-0.20355096459388733,
0.19787557423114777,
0.11334685236215591,
0.2775701582431793,
-0.046708252280950546,
0.7454012632369995,
-0.26231443881988525,
-0.6213667988777161,
0.7047773003578186,
0.3185833990573883,
0.7537559866905212,
-1.0245715379714966,
0.22118745744228363,
-0.20407740771770477,
0.2672348916530609,
-0.18320751190185547,
-0.756818950176239,
0.6963457465171814,
0.25699788331985474,
-0.24956569075584412,
-0.26675906777381897,
0.9015945196151733,
-0.2764723300933838,
-0.52287757396698,
0.4566250443458557,
-0.18422533571720123,
-0.16619227826595306,
-0.27417001128196716,
-0.5817885398864746,
0.3369096517562866,
0.0052015031687915325,
-0.33640727400779724,
0.44249728322029114,
0.13612353801727295,
0.26887497305870056,
0.9639343023300171,
0.8497161269187927,
0.1496233493089676,
0.3030301034450531,
0.1614566594362259,
1.254420518875122,
-0.30342236161231995,
-0.19789014756679535,
-1.0526454448699951,
0.36002251505851746,
-0.18039695918560028,
0.04342533275485039,
0.9214036464691162,
0.4789321720600128,
0.6538301110267639,
-0.1179748997092247,
0.6730505228042603,
0.09583152830600739,
0.06384418904781342,
-0.5206298828125,
0.9876376390457153,
-0.056096307933330536,
0.5840516686439514,
-0.14277184009552002,
-0.5664843916893005,
-0.5359313488006592,
0.5385952591896057,
-0.08253519982099533,
-0.2829256057739258,
0.39538002014160156,
1.2016689777374268,
-0.12784843146800995,
0.1817174255847931,
0.4067511558532715,
0.07412394136190414,
0.64602130651474,
0.5892957448959351,
0.7694560289382935,
-0.8640140891075134,
0.962617814540863,
-0.4955381751060486,
-0.31604549288749695,
0.1829206794500351,
-0.7368530035018921,
-0.9250358939170837,
-0.2784256041049957,
-0.16550931334495544,
-0.3579429090023041,
0.29581281542778015,
-0.020182177424430847,
0.53169846534729,
-0.7361090183258057,
0.15754812955856323,
-0.19066688418388367,
0.06123161315917969,
-0.13285432755947113,
-0.29312336444854736,
0.19900092482566833,
-0.3055625259876251,
-0.640112042427063,
0.7766454219818115,
0.26141202449798584,
0.1460474580526352,
-0.38085809350013733,
-0.01125600840896368,
-0.11125483363866806,
0.12700015306472778,
0.48193222284317017,
0.4889959990978241,
-0.7092421054840088,
-0.05251983553171158,
0.014312831684947014,
-0.10585763305425644,
-0.2567381262779236,
0.5090588927268982,
-0.5957649946212769,
0.8003624081611633,
0.2688644230365753,
1.0008107423782349,
0.21271377801895142,
-0.10311845690011978,
0.6464387774467468,
-0.8596576452255249,
0.31142544746398926,
0.4619556665420532,
0.31735506653785706,
0.5042898654937744,
-0.48022374510765076,
0.37846094369888306,
-0.034759558737277985,
-0.4016410708427429,
-1.0154410600662231,
0.43233078718185425,
-0.4768151342868805,
-0.17695890367031097,
0.9451556205749512,
-0.48781946301460266,
-0.32844918966293335,
-0.2942240536212921,
-0.021294474601745605,
0.18535059690475464,
0.09489279240369797,
0.867721438407898,
0.6191201210021973,
0.30852046608924866,
-0.14310693740844727,
-0.40020301938056946,
0.5253167748451233,
0.351064532995224,
-0.6895888447761536,
0.1759299486875534,
0.03814353048801422,
0.11230360716581345,
0.4057115316390991,
0.13112689554691315,
-0.2753657400608063,
0.2324671447277069,
0.3897809386253357,
-0.3974251449108124,
-0.25371861457824707,
-0.31299856305122375,
-0.6596075296401978,
0.34239381551742554,
-0.3410581350326538,
-0.38307103514671326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09841v1 | LAPDoc: Layout-Aware Prompting for Documents | 2024-02-15T10:00:49 | 2024-02-15T10:00:49 | Marcel Lamott, Yves-Noel Weweler, Adrian Ulges, Faisal Shafait, Dirk Krechel, Darko Obradovic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Recent advances in training large language models (LLMs) using massive
amounts of solely textual data lead to strong generalization across many
domains and tasks, including document-specific tasks. Opposed to that there is
a trend to train multi-modal transformer architectures tailored for document
understanding that are designed specifically to fuse textual inputs with the
corresponding document layout. This involves a separate fine-tuning step for
which additional training data is required. At present, no document
transformers with comparable generalization to LLMs are available That raises
the question which type of model is to be preferred for document understanding
tasks. In this paper we investigate the possibility to use purely text-based
LLMs for document-specific tasks by using layout enrichment. We explore drop-in
modifications and rule-based methods to enrich purely textual LLM prompts with
layout information. In our experiments we investigate the effects on the
commercial ChatGPT model and the open-source LLM Solar. We demonstrate that
using our approach both LLMs show improved performance on various standard
document benchmarks. In addition, we study the impact of noisy OCR and layout
errors, as well as the limitations of LLMs when it comes to utilizing document
layout. Our results indicate that layout enrichment can improve the performance
of purely text-based LLMs for document understanding by up to 15% compared to
just using plain document text. In conclusion, this approach should be
considered for the best model choice between text-based LLM or multi-modal
document transformers. | [
-0.24065770208835602,
-0.8062899112701416,
1.0202549695968628,
0.27970513701438904,
-0.16958963871002197,
-0.05928120017051697,
-0.33088788390159607,
-0.16375800967216492,
-0.07534615695476532,
0.5292659401893616,
-0.5814298987388611,
-0.6071081757545471,
-0.404865026473999,
0.13583256304264069,
-0.3908402919769287,
0.7709327340126038,
-0.3087690472602844,
0.10040008276700974,
-0.6960334181785583,
0.206622913479805,
-0.6192256808280945,
-0.09903265535831451,
-0.22717522084712982,
-0.2551192343235016,
0.4153290390968323,
0.43096792697906494,
0.41074657440185547,
0.6266007423400879,
0.3606170117855072,
0.298062801361084,
-0.3553815484046936,
0.5513359308242798,
-0.12410052120685577,
0.3458370268344879,
-0.10769745707511902,
-0.4341616928577423,
-0.44819724559783936,
0.08200286328792572,
0.43755966424942017,
0.7103410363197327,
-0.07483396679162979,
-0.35780248045921326,
0.14779284596443176,
0.5169103741645813,
-0.6049048900604248,
-0.01059313677251339,
-0.4022700786590576,
0.13724066317081451,
-0.022389724850654602,
-0.4700157046318054,
-0.75827956199646,
-0.1340148001909256,
-0.06609081476926804,
-0.8871461749076843,
0.47943973541259766,
0.13215048611164093,
0.6068906784057617,
0.19689135253429413,
-0.35785239934921265,
-0.6005920767784119,
-0.5612800717353821,
0.5354661345481873,
-0.19855394959449768,
0.6098815202713013,
0.36516204476356506,
-0.173190638422966,
-0.08118089288473129,
-0.7809304594993591,
-0.5824961066246033,
-0.30541032552719116,
-0.37456920742988586,
0.5159046053886414,
0.23621492087841034,
0.19502709805965424,
0.4113420844078064,
0.6866686344146729,
-0.6298303008079529,
0.15411032736301422,
-0.32643815875053406,
-0.06918463110923767,
0.20917032659053802,
0.129116952419281,
0.5718400478363037,
-0.446600079536438,
-0.31442520022392273,
-0.2975282669067383,
-0.6435800790786743,
-0.03321148082613945,
0.3330741226673126,
0.09649699181318283,
-0.32077986001968384,
0.5722992420196533,
0.21097111701965332,
0.8992061018943787,
0.15759938955307007,
-0.1041351780295372,
-0.046729814261198044,
-0.3559168577194214,
-0.4058046042919159,
-0.08547533303499222,
0.8154381513595581,
0.11541102081537247,
-0.10089097917079926,
-0.21174229681491852,
-0.09822776913642883,
-0.21598704159259796,
0.5775951147079468,
-0.5866576433181763,
-0.18093469738960266,
0.26691386103630066,
-0.3553769886493683,
-0.40806323289871216,
-0.013209574855864048,
-0.5077164769172668,
-0.910176157951355,
-0.531855583190918,
0.2405281364917755,
-0.7078995108604431,
0.37561488151550293,
0.12662096321582794,
-0.4003261625766754,
0.2901313602924347,
1.0251017808914185,
-1.0579921007156372,
-0.00009663189121056348,
0.6967099905014038,
0.8262430429458618,
-0.22464989125728607,
-0.2938826084136963,
-0.7287756204605103,
0.20002661645412445,
-0.38031432032585144,
1.0595651865005493,
-0.5816827416419983,
-0.9258399605751038,
0.07999050617218018,
-0.002906806068494916,
-0.4134700298309326,
-0.351286917924881,
1.1493656635284424,
-0.3773219585418701,
0.9318302869796753,
-0.3058628737926483,
-0.5918257832527161,
0.25209254026412964,
0.31293511390686035,
-0.5645775198936462,
0.9886850714683533,
0.26862698793411255,
-0.9297117590904236,
0.3307054340839386,
-0.8517166376113892,
-0.6583235263824463,
0.0659458264708519,
-0.4397168755531311,
-0.22939848899841309,
0.07442852854728699,
0.593956470489502,
0.31758400797843933,
-0.059383735060691833,
-0.02318456582725048,
0.07840447872877121,
-0.2988465428352356,
0.05789290741086006,
-0.3238985240459442,
0.375451922416687,
0.3592260479927063,
0.07338055223226547,
0.33698534965515137,
-0.6873250007629395,
-0.3210408687591553,
-0.034732941538095474,
-0.6803278923034668,
-0.3431587219238281,
-0.17444714903831482,
0.22649697959423065,
0.04675927385687828,
0.28347837924957275,
-0.4726901352405548,
0.36574220657348633,
-0.37070900201797485,
0.10937785357236862,
0.7675774693489075,
-0.13328179717063904,
1.0480282306671143,
-0.47891655564308167,
0.7224653363227844,
-0.3302602767944336,
-0.08262216299772263,
-0.7660425901412964,
-0.2763713300228119,
-0.45677345991134644,
-0.6935163736343384,
0.23580949008464813,
0.5685726404190063,
-0.5095577836036682,
0.5122058987617493,
-0.21317271888256073,
-0.12232788652181625,
-0.2791160047054291,
0.2081720232963562,
0.10368876159191132,
0.8428192734718323,
0.19211158156394958,
-0.07073280960321426,
-0.47161298990249634,
-0.5913060307502747,
-0.20164158940315247,
0.1633419543504715,
-0.16304133832454681,
0.4480975568294525,
-0.02022586390376091,
0.03213026374578476,
0.7634679079055786,
-0.4804238975048065,
-0.3331850469112396,
-0.6562382578849792,
0.0008217442664317787,
0.19848592579364777,
0.22416889667510986,
0.20711490511894226,
-0.8121834993362427,
-0.8368247747421265,
0.07083474844694138,
-0.7000619769096375,
-0.25704091787338257,
-0.4264243245124817,
-0.10814555734395981,
0.02842543087899685,
0.8220636248588562,
-0.9433279633522034,
0.31195902824401855,
0.33050209283828735,
-0.0716279149055481,
0.3569720387458801,
-0.5619053840637207,
0.03564437851309776,
-1.367329716682434,
-0.04042528569698334,
0.055577877908945084,
-0.1778724193572998,
-0.8108405470848083,
0.042016319930553436,
0.66490238904953,
-0.3932633697986603,
-0.2672237753868103,
0.8109617233276367,
-0.606704831123352,
-0.040105726569890976,
-0.2927923798561096,
0.48120829463005066,
0.659410834312439,
0.05829606205224991,
0.37271326780319214,
1.0304718017578125,
0.19283637404441833,
-0.4072372019290924,
-0.0764211043715477,
0.6926393508911133,
-0.4302518665790558,
0.6801625490188599,
-0.48179352283477783,
0.1806439906358719,
-0.313240110874176,
0.57483971118927,
-1.1005057096481323,
-0.41634976863861084,
0.07404160499572754,
-0.1936149001121521,
0.7728907465934753,
-0.015977652743458748,
-0.38766273856163025,
-0.14366887509822845,
-0.6005142331123352,
-0.16465435922145844,
0.2980000078678131,
-0.848196804523468,
0.8658993244171143,
-0.17550227046012878,
-0.21973615884780884,
-0.5297453999519348,
-0.44928300380706787,
0.05151345953345299,
-0.22439038753509521,
-0.9979776740074158,
0.6572133302688599,
-0.02868073433637619,
-0.025477241724729538,
-0.5095004439353943,
-0.20541082322597504,
0.4279276728630066,
0.0992482453584671,
0.41824838519096375,
0.3319673240184784,
-0.02567666582763195,
0.19264449179172516,
0.21944987773895264,
0.05684920400381088,
-0.2043946534395218,
-0.24957191944122314,
0.7024173140525818,
0.23319889605045319,
-0.5296552181243896,
-0.4342432916164398,
0.36853793263435364,
0.45893144607543945,
-0.4272758364677429,
0.8036165833473206,
0.5951718688011169,
0.058019790798425674,
-0.24282178282737732,
-0.6005522012710571,
0.05466851219534874,
-0.5509785413742065,
0.19822221994400024,
-0.3788749575614929,
-0.7845115661621094,
0.4036978781223297,
-0.28104013204574585,
0.12557530403137207,
0.26249566674232483,
0.532581090927124,
-0.5631846785545349,
0.5943785905838013,
0.6839358806610107,
0.12384897470474243,
0.8511530160903931,
-0.1631060689687729,
0.1738782525062561,
-1.2745493650436401,
-0.37388914823532104,
-0.6333484649658203,
-0.13749107718467712,
-0.33670517802238464,
-0.6795239448547363,
0.4638517200946808,
0.042768001556396484,
0.18528501689434052,
0.03880523517727852,
-0.44408658146858215,
0.5905978083610535,
0.3910946846008301,
0.007808600086718798,
0.36747580766677856,
0.20041590929031372,
-0.25982236862182617,
0.05273142457008362,
-0.5231637954711914,
-0.6258041858673096,
0.8446954488754272,
0.23114679753780365,
1.132420301437378,
-0.09659069776535034,
0.7978541254997253,
0.10082380473613739,
0.030751841142773628,
-0.7650910019874573,
0.32704541087150574,
-0.22014108300209045,
-0.07596173882484436,
-0.30020877718925476,
-0.17280662059783936,
-1.1214066743850708,
0.2825339436531067,
0.026003563776612282,
-0.7974647879600525,
0.30533525347709656,
-0.08359481394290924,
-0.19639995694160461,
0.06156717985868454,
-0.7050828337669373,
0.6918046474456787,
-0.15005053579807281,
-0.21310117840766907,
0.011468985117971897,
-0.22912225127220154,
0.07333117723464966,
0.05543358251452446,
0.3597778379917145,
0.35186588764190674,
-0.06995999068021774,
0.29816141724586487,
-0.3835322856903076,
0.6914237141609192,
0.054769035428762436,
-0.5086640119552612,
-0.041371285915374756,
0.1694386601448059,
0.9416991472244263,
0.06403596699237823,
-0.2221694141626358,
-0.6984419822692871,
-0.36697620153427124,
-0.11563028395175934,
-0.6810734272003174,
0.8698202967643738,
-0.7818643450737,
-0.776576817035675,
-0.06770011782646179,
-0.8820973634719849,
-0.38291579484939575,
0.1647125780582428,
0.5369440317153931,
0.602481484413147,
-0.2528005838394165,
0.23362651467323303,
1.2240512371063232,
-0.37976548075675964,
0.24308359622955322,
0.34970414638519287,
-0.11486826092004776,
-0.0310970526188612,
0.6240562200546265,
-0.3813703656196594,
0.07331319153308868,
0.867833137512207,
0.2449614256620407,
-0.5275969505310059,
-0.6097385883331299,
-0.5060036778450012,
0.17474262416362762,
-0.9343990087509155,
0.12355129420757294,
-1.1000396013259888,
-0.18930116295814514,
-0.4322545826435089,
-0.6081703305244446,
-0.003183916676789522,
-0.525010347366333,
-0.511259138584137,
-0.25446319580078125,
0.18136025965213776,
0.6840298175811768,
0.1046023741364479,
0.38543856143951416,
-0.7391026020050049,
0.4327734708786011,
0.327227383852005,
0.21144545078277588,
-0.22793535888195038,
-0.7632114887237549,
-0.0656786561012268,
-0.3385358452796936,
-0.5457488894462585,
-0.7557481527328491,
0.12237541377544403,
0.03474487364292145,
0.6700674891471863,
0.3209238350391388,
-0.11084655672311783,
0.25685784220695496,
-0.35995984077453613,
0.8323220014572144,
0.01304957177489996,
-0.6784265041351318,
0.7668447494506836,
-0.8389453887939453,
0.48813968896865845,
0.4143035113811493,
0.20346082746982574,
-0.7474411725997925,
-0.32720866799354553,
-0.5509966015815735,
-0.6599173545837402,
1.0206958055496216,
0.06933100521564484,
0.2661339342594147,
0.09232313185930252,
0.36933591961860657,
0.15035204589366913,
0.03356955572962761,
-0.5028818249702454,
0.17901943624019623,
-0.17787691950798035,
-0.3739432096481323,
0.07994498312473297,
-0.1473369598388672,
-0.19790087640285492,
0.11769472062587738,
0.4588315486907959,
-0.0952286422252655,
0.04548650607466698,
0.32720109820365906,
-0.4711005389690399,
0.04789578542113304,
0.6281271576881409,
0.8157710433006287,
0.629612147808075,
-0.18712742626667023,
-0.0017344254301860929,
0.12599730491638184,
-0.4654470682144165,
0.02946268394589424,
0.11770361661911011,
-0.19672538340091705,
-0.04467857629060745,
0.39715006947517395,
0.8638103604316711,
0.047939978539943695,
-0.36601802706718445,
0.4340977370738983,
-0.316427618265152,
-0.35164782404899597,
0.11875554919242859,
0.17822973430156708,
0.18972083926200867,
-0.05583404377102852,
0.07742414623498917,
-0.143890842795372,
0.034201279282569885,
-0.3380979597568512,
-0.16195936501026154,
0.45802077651023865,
-0.22221603989601135,
0.04158226028084755,
0.48528385162353516,
0.2781026065349579,
-0.27756157517433167,
0.5376697182655334,
-0.032161612063646317,
-0.2713274359703064,
0.5033650398254395,
0.49525031447410583,
0.6721544861793518,
0.003818376688286662,
0.40147024393081665,
0.05536584556102753,
0.2248982936143875,
0.06450164318084717,
0.08480054140090942,
-0.4616740047931671,
-0.5333990454673767,
-0.35906070470809937,
-0.6162294149398804,
-0.5298966765403748,
0.22359570860862732,
-0.387848824262619,
0.3058103621006012,
-0.4823915660381317,
0.2713821828365326,
-0.044866375625133514,
-0.08277083933353424,
-0.5691916346549988,
0.13442645967006683,
0.2888565957546234,
1.138623833656311,
-0.6030744314193726,
0.6257543563842773,
1.0650262832641602,
-0.10224711149930954,
-0.6568626761436462,
0.10836058109998703,
0.03282744809985161,
-0.6994828581809998,
0.3038327991962433,
0.038426999002695084,
-0.04038626700639725,
-0.38022372126579285,
-0.3244681656360626,
-0.43689393997192383,
1.0426973104476929,
0.18444396555423737,
-0.41805315017700195,
-0.1668880730867386,
0.15233555436134338,
0.4594118297100067,
-0.31812694668769836,
0.3727681338787079,
0.2740669548511505,
0.5187560319900513,
0.2041385918855667,
-0.6919029355049133,
0.09594855457544327,
-0.18685615062713623,
0.3064611852169037,
0.26959115266799927,
-0.6073842644691467,
0.6887179613113403,
-0.008675913326442242,
-0.13724161684513092,
0.18754595518112183,
0.5126224160194397,
0.31492844223976135,
0.21970508992671967,
0.3424776792526245,
0.4364587366580963,
1.0886303186416626,
0.06100795418024063,
1.4763041734695435,
-0.19788514077663422,
-0.032056089490652084,
1.2514698505401611,
-0.26561984419822693,
0.3715830147266388,
0.44763705134391785,
-0.1184566393494606,
0.4828001856803894,
0.6163876056671143,
0.17042812705039978,
0.47371095418930054,
-0.14366641640663147,
-0.20902195572853088,
-0.27904847264289856,
-0.09402351081371307,
-0.4789576828479767,
0.3002828359603882,
0.5431481599807739,
-0.5368139743804932,
-0.2900754511356354,
0.015260506421327591,
-0.015681371092796326,
0.27648574113845825,
-0.07277139276266098,
0.8994777202606201,
0.13571833074092865,
-0.5972334742546082,
0.0631970688700676,
0.27901580929756165,
0.6092644333839417,
-0.7038692831993103,
0.3142673969268799,
-0.5394101142883301,
-0.040387630462646484,
-0.4084845185279846,
-0.8839417695999146,
0.0034483822528272867,
-0.08898042142391205,
-0.5554607510566711,
-0.62241131067276,
1.0194076299667358,
-0.2630785405635834,
-0.3518407642841339,
-0.07095062732696533,
0.5541025996208191,
-0.21423907577991486,
-0.17351801693439484,
-0.230362206697464,
0.0644083023071289,
0.04937119409441948,
-0.15145903825759888,
0.7718529105186462,
0.5406889915466309,
-0.08858877420425415,
0.3494674563407898,
0.7238456010818481,
-0.1659524142742157,
-0.12638133764266968,
0.4844723045825958,
0.9183765053749084,
-0.3440903425216675,
-0.7126623392105103,
-0.6458091139793396,
0.5088569521903992,
-0.31266674399375916,
-0.04046554118394852,
0.7362567186355591,
0.5688879489898682,
0.4008164703845978,
-0.17711128294467926,
0.9805504679679871,
0.17542524635791779,
0.3141181766986847,
-0.7875568866729736,
0.6687218546867371,
-0.5988109707832336,
0.4923013746738434,
-0.2949732542037964,
-1.068039894104004,
0.016639264300465584,
0.5777432918548584,
-0.5316281318664551,
-0.015475917607545853,
0.7817422747612,
0.6406786441802979,
-0.32094377279281616,
0.2897734045982361,
0.23706237971782684,
-0.254852294921875,
0.4985657334327698,
0.06237856298685074,
1.065186858177185,
-0.1168743297457695,
0.49824899435043335,
-0.08929233253002167,
-0.10154057294130325,
-0.1790073662996292,
-0.7852458357810974,
-1.0143955945968628,
-0.5473747849464417,
-0.22195284068584442,
-0.26070860028266907,
-0.24643880128860474,
0.6343345642089844,
0.47705140709877014,
-0.39036211371421814,
-0.038079146295785904,
-0.10106860101222992,
0.4259181320667267,
0.32212361693382263,
-0.2261970490217209,
0.5634210109710693,
-0.6970469355583191,
-0.6141726970672607,
0.8241443634033203,
0.4686940312385559,
0.21829818189144135,
0.06675802171230316,
-0.02186424285173416,
0.0633295401930809,
0.19698837399482727,
0.5044088363647461,
0.08774407207965851,
-0.4769010841846466,
0.09359382838010788,
0.14330534636974335,
-0.3059905469417572,
0.39921048283576965,
1.0357050895690918,
-0.5188276767730713,
0.5186778903007507,
0.7461591362953186,
0.5189706087112427,
0.6234650611877441,
0.20169837772846222,
0.6987794637680054,
-0.9666332602500916,
0.25164124369621277,
-0.12089195102453232,
0.4766552150249481,
0.611218273639679,
-0.730250358581543,
0.3449828326702118,
-0.2567489743232727,
-0.379845529794693,
-0.5430351495742798,
0.132913276553154,
-0.9770053625106812,
-0.3003871738910675,
1.180572748184204,
0.01871286705136299,
-0.21796588599681854,
0.06177158281207085,
-0.6370928287506104,
-0.05205607786774635,
-0.48724600672721863,
0.5905652046203613,
0.7367137670516968,
-0.279190331697464,
-0.3929290175437927,
-0.26525112986564636,
0.5507609248161316,
0.4397437870502472,
-1.0463297367095947,
0.08124864101409912,
0.48151978850364685,
0.022075314074754715,
0.2946775257587433,
0.7222722172737122,
-0.1624259054660797,
0.4460914731025696,
-0.21050941944122314,
-0.27243393659591675,
-0.23015058040618896,
-0.3004138469696045,
-0.3517249822616577,
0.10825876891613007,
0.1318814754486084,
0.07659327238798141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09808v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09808v2 | Knowledge of Pretrained Language Models on Surface Information of Tokens | 2024-02-15T09:14:53 | 2024-02-22T15:11:57 | Tatsuya Hiraoka, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do pretrained language models have knowledge regarding the surface
information of tokens? We examined the surface information stored in word or
subword embeddings acquired by pretrained language models from the perspectives
of token length, substrings, and token constitution. Additionally, we evaluated
the ability of models to generate knowledge regarding token surfaces. We
focused on 12 pretrained language models that were mainly trained on English
and Japanese corpora. Experimental results demonstrate that pretrained language
models have knowledge regarding token length and substrings but not token
constitution. Additionally, the results imply that there is a bottleneck on the
decoder side in terms of effectively utilizing acquired knowledge. | [
-0.30090242624282837,
-0.7613649964332581,
0.7505661845207214,
-0.22700870037078857,
-0.4226725101470947,
0.06397120654582977,
-0.14901623129844666,
-0.40642082691192627,
0.22532935440540314,
0.5312256813049316,
-0.23418812453746796,
-0.5963820815086365,
-0.8282470703125,
-0.17312872409820557,
-0.34394189715385437,
0.7220624685287476,
-0.0616472102701664,
0.19705845415592194,
-0.6182783842086792,
-0.09936805814504623,
-0.3609262704849243,
-0.9313932657241821,
-0.30741575360298157,
-0.18789814412593842,
0.29507818818092346,
0.21091938018798828,
0.43354952335357666,
0.6697940230369568,
0.3862678110599518,
0.2860603630542755,
-0.03609086200594902,
0.011978834867477417,
-0.39403656125068665,
-0.25465264916419983,
-0.17826710641384125,
-0.8058139681816101,
-0.21264247596263885,
0.09578623622655869,
0.4965936541557312,
1.0905390977859497,
0.028399929404258728,
0.10758676379919052,
-0.04660814628005028,
0.34969598054885864,
-0.6735758781433105,
0.09337297827005386,
-0.7553791999816895,
0.22160197794437408,
-0.2512585520744324,
-0.2225928008556366,
-0.39196062088012695,
0.005329350009560585,
0.2046392858028412,
-0.8793481588363647,
0.27215245366096497,
0.10085615515708923,
0.8229484558105469,
-0.015148595906794071,
-0.4332222640514374,
-0.3138040006160736,
-0.3940371572971344,
0.5358273983001709,
-0.5386641025543213,
0.832378625869751,
0.6339300274848938,
-0.018604988232254982,
-0.06343147903680801,
-0.9071366190910339,
-0.3239773213863373,
-0.39528241753578186,
-0.3119928538799286,
0.03705355525016785,
-0.18360380828380585,
0.23801299929618835,
0.3822743892669678,
0.17251983284950256,
-0.28084006905555725,
0.29706352949142456,
-0.5504289865493774,
-0.32883405685424805,
0.26280394196510315,
-0.11216171085834503,
0.5476852059364319,
-0.012671781703829765,
-0.6005118489265442,
0.20088225603103638,
-1.0194661617279053,
0.14968112111091614,
0.3460555672645569,
0.21238090097904205,
-0.1234128475189209,
0.7079927325248718,
0.008246514946222305,
0.5176980495452881,
-0.22878818213939667,
-0.08905073255300522,
0.1643042266368866,
-0.32416415214538574,
0.029281754046678543,
-0.09623914957046509,
0.5832912921905518,
-0.0521622933447361,
0.40602099895477295,
-0.6376293897628784,
-0.3761026859283447,
-0.24013105034828186,
0.1589118391275406,
-0.7399828433990479,
-0.1253487765789032,
-0.24430932104587555,
-0.5295823812484741,
0.1492943912744522,
0.43237224221229553,
-0.19635383784770966,
-0.2917306423187256,
-0.3494417667388916,
0.5088456869125366,
-0.5142115950584412,
-0.5646951794624329,
0.09801153838634491,
-0.6462389826774597,
0.08496320247650146,
0.012017310597002506,
-0.9046370387077332,
0.3774547874927521,
0.715516209602356,
0.7001091241836548,
-0.08413391560316086,
-0.5042558908462524,
-0.376740962266922,
-0.06059205159544945,
-0.39096489548683167,
0.6955565214157104,
-0.7653585076332092,
-0.6789478063583374,
0.05122721567749977,
-0.05367874354124069,
-0.3749668002128601,
-0.4357152283191681,
-0.1633281409740448,
-0.7321662902832031,
-0.041776325553655624,
-0.48076561093330383,
-1.0290899276733398,
0.14037472009658813,
0.07167592644691467,
-0.5246055722236633,
0.6286817789077759,
0.11878591775894165,
-1.0724414587020874,
0.6667155623435974,
-0.4596508741378784,
-0.5539602041244507,
0.045971933752298355,
-0.35467231273651123,
0.07722441107034683,
0.7153173089027405,
0.11483033001422882,
0.14741623401641846,
0.16525302827358246,
0.0885598435997963,
-0.10364456474781036,
-0.40547633171081543,
0.49234622716903687,
-0.18505443632602692,
0.5042869448661804,
0.22908438742160797,
-0.04709869250655174,
-0.12305068969726562,
-0.63796067237854,
-0.10973162204027176,
-0.15915679931640625,
-0.5150458812713623,
-0.5025535821914673,
-0.22936885058879852,
-0.23797611892223358,
0.05125533789396286,
0.586375892162323,
-0.7985548377037048,
0.2659444212913513,
-0.1543552726507187,
0.43931615352630615,
0.5313870906829834,
-0.07160032540559769,
0.2511395215988159,
-0.020235847681760788,
0.6225078701972961,
0.48620131611824036,
-0.12374157458543777,
-0.17921428382396698,
-0.35175010561943054,
-0.8715454339981079,
0.05358158051967621,
0.7002027630805969,
0.22388936579227448,
-0.6771333813667297,
0.3087807893753052,
-0.2675599157810211,
-0.4468505382537842,
-0.32048332691192627,
-0.01141387689858675,
0.6441085934638977,
0.21483127772808075,
0.21474383771419525,
-0.3715703785419464,
-0.5622074604034424,
-0.8401206135749817,
-0.6127855181694031,
-0.06784602999687195,
0.12343975156545639,
0.2833043038845062,
0.5706037878990173,
-0.10370424389839172,
1.0916061401367188,
-0.40092018246650696,
0.015248691663146019,
-0.33284634351730347,
0.5012749433517456,
-0.21946020424365997,
0.5796905159950256,
0.6187686920166016,
-0.42802104353904724,
-0.10269490629434586,
-0.09727659821510315,
-0.4581044018268585,
0.016658248379826546,
0.21880806982517242,
-0.08930986374616623,
0.15046438574790955,
1.0734487771987915,
-0.6872353553771973,
0.5370672941207886,
0.5519306659698486,
-0.4646304249763489,
0.40337303280830383,
-0.6106917858123779,
-0.3547945022583008,
-0.8844894766807556,
0.22612373530864716,
-0.4371965229511261,
-0.38274475932121277,
-0.7524672746658325,
-0.2179444432258606,
0.05500799044966698,
-0.0470617339015007,
-0.3581526279449463,
0.7077359557151794,
-0.6697036027908325,
-0.5094490051269531,
-0.5611960291862488,
0.2307511419057846,
-0.017169207334518433,
0.4802737832069397,
0.5255452394485474,
0.8717278242111206,
0.48268410563468933,
-0.771626889705658,
-0.23340833187103271,
0.041753195226192474,
-0.679011344909668,
-0.011131794191896915,
-0.4312201738357544,
0.4660203754901886,
-0.16233454644680023,
-0.0427897609770298,
-0.8459908366203308,
0.07798730581998825,
-0.3188795745372772,
-0.3084073066711426,
0.2542470395565033,
-0.14545796811580658,
-0.20718736946582794,
-0.24200977385044098,
0.3376621901988983,
0.45646214485168457,
0.42476344108581543,
-0.3272898197174072,
0.3646230399608612,
0.714302659034729,
0.054055631160736084,
-0.471233606338501,
-0.7501280903816223,
-0.24689102172851562,
0.02152589149773121,
-0.10485200583934784,
0.35494810342788696,
0.3714712858200073,
-0.04074997827410698,
0.189469113945961,
-0.09649801254272461,
-0.049149345606565475,
0.10142207890748978,
0.28584203124046326,
-0.111685611307621,
-0.22731344401836395,
0.31075596809387207,
-0.06017410755157471,
-0.10356446355581284,
0.07895790040493011,
-0.5220230221748352,
0.9253857135772705,
-0.2045680582523346,
-0.536078929901123,
-0.16381995379924774,
0.07767653465270996,
0.5447590351104736,
-0.4835072457790375,
1.007462501525879,
0.3808113932609558,
-0.5604252815246582,
0.1127917617559433,
-0.576244592666626,
-0.11849590390920639,
-0.41427361965179443,
0.5732730627059937,
-0.6848844885826111,
-0.959716796875,
0.791551947593689,
-0.18550226092338562,
-0.21859411895275116,
0.54140704870224,
0.12682020664215088,
0.1113809198141098,
1.0837329626083374,
1.1458507776260376,
0.18543970584869385,
0.652367115020752,
-0.3757927715778351,
0.018166402354836464,
-0.7434336543083191,
-0.4160681664943695,
-0.34662580490112305,
-0.2774517238140106,
-0.5518770813941956,
-0.2513055205345154,
0.05423761531710625,
0.5116308331489563,
-0.3310566246509552,
0.26402804255485535,
0.07140018045902252,
0.4788294732570648,
0.7319524884223938,
0.12585319578647614,
0.12222277373075485,
-0.07664373517036438,
-0.4462556540966034,
0.08917542546987534,
-0.9247215390205383,
-0.44196978211402893,
1.0282740592956543,
0.48842281103134155,
0.5848478674888611,
-0.2727072536945343,
0.5349648594856262,
-0.046260766685009,
0.05076296627521515,
-0.4600032866001129,
0.31471022963523865,
-0.2595261335372925,
-0.5613633990287781,
-0.17122256755828857,
-0.46818363666534424,
-0.8973495364189148,
-0.04700852558016777,
-0.1295476108789444,
-0.6248853802680969,
0.4605472683906555,
-0.014169097878038883,
-0.18165335059165955,
0.2930072546005249,
-0.5260686874389648,
0.9411988258361816,
-0.5298643708229065,
0.29726171493530273,
-0.2715386152267456,
-0.42318087816238403,
0.005073187407106161,
-0.1335216909646988,
0.270355224609375,
-0.00863298773765564,
-0.04733627662062645,
1.3512604236602783,
-0.7598397135734558,
0.6945568919181824,
-0.5584287643432617,
-0.007934591732919216,
0.3138684630393982,
-0.09731776267290115,
0.24000275135040283,
-0.10556498914957047,
0.17392577230930328,
0.33037227392196655,
0.27303171157836914,
-0.35097843408584595,
-0.45538339018821716,
0.21423795819282532,
-1.0078306198120117,
-0.6172045469284058,
-0.0697130411863327,
-0.19664961099624634,
-0.3711140751838684,
0.46244680881500244,
0.778520941734314,
0.6189637780189514,
-0.2973482012748718,
0.22964222729206085,
0.2588026523590088,
-0.3066699504852295,
0.23480843007564545,
0.49449610710144043,
-0.5270100831985474,
-0.112518809735775,
0.7232860326766968,
0.40643763542175293,
0.2361842393875122,
0.3184804320335388,
0.19852057099342346,
-0.3776949346065521,
-0.7030208110809326,
-0.20130112767219543,
0.19979740679264069,
-0.7665970325469971,
-0.16179722547531128,
-0.5289503931999207,
-0.41374409198760986,
-0.24228042364120483,
0.17840160429477692,
-0.6338793635368347,
-0.5985282063484192,
-0.13354070484638214,
-0.35340845584869385,
0.3233930468559265,
1.201606273651123,
-0.029480887576937675,
0.5866974592208862,
-0.9088805913925171,
0.04756094887852669,
0.07959874719381332,
0.4968629777431488,
-0.1898740530014038,
-0.6245570182800293,
-0.6058538556098938,
0.44230857491493225,
0.1779720038175583,
-0.6971799731254578,
0.06812578439712524,
0.12862014770507812,
0.7248637676239014,
0.5299198031425476,
-0.15299183130264282,
0.4847327470779419,
-0.5592424869537354,
0.9029727578163147,
0.19215738773345947,
-1.0555466413497925,
0.2935410439968109,
-0.09320642799139023,
0.22218848764896393,
0.5435029864311218,
0.46684199571609497,
-0.5415428280830383,
-0.5235947966575623,
-0.7307365536689758,
-0.4092520773410797,
0.6293371915817261,
-0.2129066288471222,
0.5059235692024231,
-0.20202724635601044,
0.46523454785346985,
0.3972502052783966,
0.4620767831802368,
-0.3993775546550751,
0.05380043387413025,
-0.4289954602718353,
-0.030929483473300934,
0.0291735976934433,
-0.27955713868141174,
0.08854963630437851,
-0.21746371686458588,
0.21680447459220886,
0.16754978895187378,
0.42134374380111694,
-0.04859071969985962,
-0.7097468376159668,
0.20118390023708344,
0.0693482756614685,
0.5387129187583923,
1.1285942792892456,
-0.02911868505179882,
0.4017777740955353,
0.31712883710861206,
-0.7423456311225891,
-0.00931312795728445,
-0.154244065284729,
0.044163934886455536,
0.037740547209978104,
0.6774453520774841,
1.2445720434188843,
0.10748899728059769,
-0.5756007432937622,
0.6542356610298157,
-0.20122770965099335,
-0.3632782995700836,
-0.14301209151744843,
-0.018067605793476105,
0.11087273061275482,
-0.0033410077448934317,
0.10156339406967163,
-0.1602480113506317,
-0.31079864501953125,
-0.642324686050415,
0.16795754432678223,
0.581474244594574,
-0.24458250403404236,
-0.5311390161514282,
0.44023481011390686,
0.17251482605934143,
-0.14360924065113068,
0.9532716274261475,
0.1652800291776657,
-0.9229457974433899,
0.5232846140861511,
0.7810609340667725,
0.4942779541015625,
-0.04749489948153496,
-0.08524175733327866,
0.18740247189998627,
0.18749545514583588,
0.15566137433052063,
0.2583540081977844,
-0.06408586353063583,
-1.0645772218704224,
-0.13716039061546326,
-0.7548737525939941,
-0.28793197870254517,
0.331835001707077,
-0.5948255658149719,
0.20653122663497925,
-0.6472395658493042,
-0.4167989492416382,
-0.3377927541732788,
-0.02194436453282833,
-1.1124755144119263,
0.25161558389663696,
0.24791592359542847,
1.0835531949996948,
-0.7677187919616699,
0.7731099128723145,
0.7541547417640686,
-0.5515437126159668,
-0.869247555732727,
-0.16919521987438202,
-0.7903796434402466,
-0.8900671005249023,
1.036737322807312,
0.3799007534980774,
-0.14954538643360138,
0.17886501550674438,
-0.30933719873428345,
-1.069999098777771,
0.749973475933075,
0.4027089774608612,
-0.5236604809761047,
-0.12839551270008087,
0.6072521209716797,
0.5806735157966614,
-0.43067583441734314,
0.30315101146698,
0.5291118025779724,
0.33154815435409546,
-0.2467113882303238,
-0.9017351865768433,
-0.146134153008461,
-0.42828041315078735,
0.06552468240261078,
-0.06546100229024887,
-0.37059807777404785,
0.942166805267334,
0.008218216709792614,
-0.47930359840393066,
-0.13536199927330017,
0.7994056940078735,
0.0276986975222826,
-0.1874566227197647,
0.5293952822685242,
0.8191721439361572,
0.8283145427703857,
-0.036675531417131424,
0.8793448805809021,
-0.6761424541473389,
0.11007212847471237,
0.6298282146453857,
-0.06107410043478012,
0.8589649796485901,
0.34597814083099365,
-0.09389684349298477,
0.6647473573684692,
0.5766534209251404,
0.40760910511016846,
0.7274570465087891,
0.3442646265029907,
0.10778748989105225,
-0.44517982006073,
-0.016621103510260582,
-0.5259243249893188,
0.7199569344520569,
0.479299396276474,
-0.28479158878326416,
-0.07458703219890594,
0.5338947772979736,
0.040473274886608124,
-0.19831089675426483,
-0.16500668227672577,
1.0106927156448364,
0.2516637146472931,
-0.83305424451828,
0.5197800993919373,
0.26104697585105896,
0.5127159357070923,
-0.4292707145214081,
0.2897181510925293,
-0.4118671417236328,
0.24865303933620453,
0.021795185282826424,
-0.5447460412979126,
0.27922341227531433,
0.036293305456638336,
0.18522870540618896,
-0.1364418864250183,
0.9060682058334351,
-0.5624865293502808,
-0.34955328702926636,
0.09583877772092819,
0.6677979230880737,
0.39393582940101624,
-0.04937618598341942,
-0.24013486504554749,
-0.044754792004823685,
-0.3362114131450653,
-0.35681307315826416,
0.24787114560604095,
0.5740925669670105,
-0.08387812972068787,
0.29530689120292664,
0.539281964302063,
0.15899160504341125,
0.5470953583717346,
0.26977500319480896,
0.8500131964683533,
-0.4840735197067261,
-0.4910110831260681,
-0.6788479685783386,
0.3696849048137665,
0.03980301320552826,
-0.31287509202957153,
0.6292720437049866,
0.7054920196533203,
0.9632627964019775,
-0.20980249345302582,
0.93814617395401,
0.1629120409488678,
0.45073914527893066,
-0.9576515555381775,
0.8081464767456055,
-0.5536573529243469,
-0.0668535828590393,
0.07742961496114731,
-0.9208984375,
0.020594168454408646,
0.734957218170166,
-0.5609050989151001,
0.16134051978588104,
0.6445643901824951,
0.5413549542427063,
-0.29827046394348145,
-0.011200428940355778,
0.09835384041070938,
-0.1209184005856514,
0.23401053249835968,
0.2859545648097992,
1.0666046142578125,
-0.17297643423080444,
0.14286436140537262,
-0.11488479375839233,
0.028479093685746193,
-0.1470562070608139,
-0.7127200961112976,
-1.2460238933563232,
-0.746651291847229,
0.044215284287929535,
0.14207823574543,
0.05437176674604416,
0.6110423803329468,
0.5866429805755615,
-0.6020271182060242,
-0.10112699866294861,
-0.6556706428527832,
-0.18790362775325775,
0.29223915934562683,
-0.09462723881006241,
0.6004828214645386,
-0.5801639556884766,
-0.33472442626953125,
0.32647642493247986,
-0.15112659335136414,
0.2226697951555252,
-0.1587010622024536,
-0.09107585996389389,
-0.09606798738241196,
0.21875640749931335,
0.2947380244731903,
0.1544521600008011,
-0.46842578053474426,
-0.4697244167327881,
0.14404986798763275,
-0.23135076463222504,
-0.13119915127754211,
1.1935813426971436,
-0.8267920613288879,
0.20315086841583252,
0.886127233505249,
0.5668529868125916,
0.5756186246871948,
0.1443246304988861,
0.7791715860366821,
-1.1167036294937134,
0.48402145504951477,
-0.16988559067249298,
0.7243143916130066,
0.32407069206237793,
-0.18604247272014618,
0.013755000196397305,
0.3065302073955536,
-0.14920006692409515,
-0.7637789249420166,
0.2662181556224823,
-0.2221183478832245,
-0.5341682434082031,
0.9819622039794922,
-0.3809898793697357,
-0.2920415997505188,
0.013948646374046803,
-0.06082945689558983,
0.7262942790985107,
0.332601934671402,
0.23797611892223358,
0.8710325360298157,
0.11291918158531189,
-0.17054332792758942,
-0.23711921274662018,
0.765796959400177,
0.3872797191143036,
-0.7183676958084106,
0.21239741146564484,
0.11480981111526489,
0.3939425051212311,
0.3552199602127075,
0.8204283118247986,
-0.07012446969747543,
0.09727661311626434,
0.32277533411979675,
-0.06511557102203369,
-0.5079222917556763,
-0.6719254851341248,
0.14288395643234253,
-0.19466504454612732,
0.285295307636261,
-0.19731956720352173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09801v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09801v2 | EFUF: Efficient Fine-grained Unlearning Framework for Mitigating Hallucinations in Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T08:58:03 | 2024-06-24T00:50:58 | Shangyu Xing, Fei Zhao, Zhen Wu, Tuo An, Weihao Chen, Chunhui Li, Jianbing Zhang, Xinyu Dai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have attracted increasing attention
in the past few years, but they may still generate descriptions that include
objects not present in the corresponding images, a phenomenon known as object
hallucination. To eliminate hallucinations, existing methods manually annotate
paired responses with and without hallucinations, and then employ various
alignment algorithms to improve the alignment capability between images and
text. However, they not only demand considerable computation resources during
the finetuning stage but also require expensive human annotation to construct
paired data needed by the alignment algorithms. To address these issues, we
borrow the idea of unlearning and propose an efficient fine-grained unlearning
framework (EFUF), which can eliminate hallucinations without the need for
paired data. Extensive experiments show that our method consistently reduces
hallucinations while preserving the generation quality with modest
computational overhead. Our code and datasets will be publicly available. | [
-0.5007461905479431,
-1.0209602117538452,
0.3083629310131073,
0.18032601475715637,
-0.32444247603416443,
-0.23215627670288086,
-0.4483155310153961,
-0.4954664707183838,
0.03846022114157677,
0.5807632803916931,
-0.4868263900279999,
-0.3928990662097931,
-0.2883606255054474,
-0.01720990240573883,
-0.4820348918437958,
0.9421263933181763,
0.14233586192131042,
0.11667044460773468,
-0.4968542456626892,
-0.07591688632965088,
-0.08725395798683167,
-0.5175046324729919,
-0.444139301776886,
-0.48085346817970276,
0.43412157893180847,
0.4068020284175873,
0.7938703894615173,
0.5861539244651794,
0.5983877778053284,
0.28524020314216614,
0.2437582165002823,
0.422102153301239,
-0.7737743258476257,
0.14769257605075836,
0.016817867755889893,
0.08784313499927521,
-0.17564444243907928,
-0.577475368976593,
0.3469441831111908,
0.8983723521232605,
-0.42659687995910645,
-0.180718332529068,
0.1402944177389145,
0.7461379766464233,
-0.6415467262268066,
0.20365329086780548,
-0.5307632684707642,
0.37640997767448425,
-0.026782158762216568,
-0.32577913999557495,
-0.41992881894111633,
0.1309819221496582,
0.031215587630867958,
-0.8059970140457153,
0.3376907706260681,
0.2348097264766693,
0.7373014092445374,
0.47721773386001587,
-0.11824557185173035,
-0.1837540715932846,
-0.6850262880325317,
0.8208784461021423,
-0.398054301738739,
0.6163436770439148,
0.5924031138420105,
0.1813749372959137,
-0.45954829454421997,
-0.7336002588272095,
-0.6322302222251892,
-0.14307253062725067,
-0.21278931200504303,
-0.1270942986011505,
0.04215027764439583,
0.34537842869758606,
0.1688510775566101,
0.34771835803985596,
-0.6827580332756042,
0.09991592168807983,
-0.3297120928764343,
-0.4732885956764221,
0.5833463668823242,
0.08729477971792221,
0.12411394715309143,
-0.10315056890249252,
-0.43469807505607605,
-0.08007261157035828,
-0.4395696818828583,
-0.18597181141376495,
0.2606607973575592,
0.27312326431274414,
0.11182675510644913,
0.675551176071167,
-0.22020378708839417,
0.6247400641441345,
-0.06778442859649658,
-0.24522535502910614,
0.45746245980262756,
-0.05049869418144226,
-0.453707218170166,
0.17982375621795654,
0.7382709383964539,
0.7367355823516846,
0.4196624755859375,
-0.6392584443092346,
-0.3248877227306366,
0.05666406452655792,
0.2595684230327606,
-0.9657607674598694,
-0.45951250195503235,
0.2691800892353058,
-0.6104708313941956,
-0.33096688985824585,
0.12724189460277557,
-1.4270272254943848,
-0.5943613052368164,
-0.29843297600746155,
0.49969935417175293,
-0.32187318801879883,
-0.11709262430667877,
0.09403332322835922,
0.0235951766371727,
0.06245806813240051,
0.21125584840774536,
-0.9603578448295593,
0.24614818394184113,
0.49478021264076233,
0.7179275155067444,
-0.12882596254348755,
-0.5370939373970032,
-0.8092629909515381,
0.24041570723056793,
-0.0685906782746315,
0.7619180679321289,
-0.6896061301231384,
-0.4992360472679138,
0.030173692852258682,
0.19091461598873138,
0.25110459327697754,
-0.4548937976360321,
0.4463229179382324,
-0.0000797076354501769,
0.12225964665412903,
-0.06125321984291077,
-0.48435699939727783,
-0.4286797046661377,
0.05620184168219566,
-0.5837730169296265,
0.9345979690551758,
-0.10700465738773346,
-0.42771589756011963,
0.057278938591480255,
-0.5244799852371216,
-0.6221486330032349,
-0.13690681755542755,
-0.26513078808784485,
-0.47844642400741577,
0.33124008774757385,
0.4543423652648926,
0.687981367111206,
-0.22232988476753235,
0.5739305019378662,
-0.5489745140075684,
-0.5489676594734192,
0.10488405078649521,
-0.4665291905403137,
0.30842268466949463,
0.4085997939109802,
-0.5253318548202515,
0.2504500150680542,
-0.9098333716392517,
-0.17860367894172668,
0.29910436272621155,
0.08248835802078247,
-0.29202327132225037,
0.10752671957015991,
0.6405340433120728,
0.07660841196775436,
-0.09137546271085739,
-0.36421898007392883,
-0.02686023712158203,
-0.41082140803337097,
0.2479735165834427,
0.7597273588180542,
-0.1441490203142166,
0.5393806099891663,
-0.4064367115497589,
0.05835232883691788,
0.3121192455291748,
0.20293326675891876,
-0.40046364068984985,
-0.32689815759658813,
-0.7741567492485046,
-0.2745031714439392,
-0.15563692152500153,
0.1139422133564949,
-0.6263871192932129,
0.36125117540359497,
0.061427850276231766,
-0.2247145175933838,
-0.576827347278595,
0.40819722414016724,
0.5706384778022766,
0.47836408019065857,
0.4821198880672455,
-0.10972181707620621,
-0.6169763803482056,
-0.9881368279457092,
0.16385550796985626,
0.22206944227218628,
0.13293354213237762,
0.17874197661876678,
0.38676196336746216,
-0.48919299244880676,
0.5461909770965576,
-0.6026020646095276,
-0.7041454315185547,
0.15198402106761932,
0.3051743507385254,
-0.6012625694274902,
0.6727824807167053,
0.4711816608905792,
-0.9634630680084229,
-0.004022825974971056,
0.08018328994512558,
-0.8666980862617493,
0.03813333436846733,
-0.26183396577835083,
-0.1250704973936081,
0.561877965927124,
0.5213116407394409,
-0.47824469208717346,
0.38842180371284485,
0.45070797204971313,
-0.3383472263813019,
0.17499886453151703,
-0.3602525293827057,
0.20552513003349304,
-1.0615499019622803,
0.05650711432099342,
-0.09230753779411316,
-0.12315939366817474,
-0.5925665497779846,
0.11554653942584991,
-0.27470749616622925,
-0.058691710233688354,
-0.24964328110218048,
0.4477340579032898,
-0.5494599938392639,
-0.07008466124534607,
-0.2658095359802246,
0.281059592962265,
0.12269485741853714,
0.8066011667251587,
0.20213629305362701,
0.3451678156852722,
0.5658981204032898,
-0.2603723406791687,
0.21258093416690826,
0.17096532881259918,
-0.06513110548257828,
0.5796980261802673,
-0.20069167017936707,
0.2808728814125061,
-0.4614918828010559,
-0.03031889721751213,
-0.9085302352905273,
-0.5252427458763123,
0.1568799614906311,
-0.1540629118680954,
0.25078555941581726,
0.33320608735084534,
-0.44614726305007935,
-0.13713376224040985,
-0.3969120383262634,
0.29126349091529846,
0.31090354919433594,
-0.8276113271713257,
0.7095694541931152,
0.47023525834083557,
0.2596123516559601,
-0.6472015380859375,
-0.7232662439346313,
0.01585753820836544,
-0.14948320388793945,
-0.3707396984100342,
0.39722710847854614,
-0.26409631967544556,
-0.10573557764291763,
0.06758321821689606,
0.04164452478289604,
-0.22370170056819916,
0.10590075701475143,
0.576363742351532,
0.04555772244930267,
-0.08864250034093857,
0.3911585211753845,
0.0033935613464564085,
0.0005972203216515481,
-0.08981801569461823,
-0.03930352255702019,
0.7704963088035583,
-0.17482426762580872,
-0.41252586245536804,
-0.38922956585884094,
0.5552866458892822,
0.6632649898529053,
-0.19661231338977814,
0.7265576124191284,
1.0745723247528076,
-0.9583844542503357,
-0.20970523357391357,
-0.6735780239105225,
-0.27186840772628784,
-0.45507362484931946,
0.586657702922821,
-0.3012327551841736,
-0.8481478095054626,
0.5540400743484497,
0.14722467958927155,
0.026432441547513008,
0.24152563512325287,
0.5453819036483765,
0.02658664621412754,
1.040959358215332,
0.5593161582946777,
0.17004963755607605,
0.22503402829170227,
0.012313834391534328,
0.24131044745445251,
-0.5923073291778564,
-0.7299801111221313,
-0.27247515320777893,
-0.33693161606788635,
-0.341143935918808,
-0.3940059542655945,
-0.11439214646816254,
0.30397865176200867,
-0.10919643938541412,
-0.1907494217157364,
-0.7253556251525879,
0.8097022175788879,
0.3710376024246216,
0.15386272966861725,
0.36373403668403625,
0.35622650384902954,
-0.00537071144208312,
0.04199710488319397,
-0.18964844942092896,
-0.38267144560813904,
1.1772834062576294,
0.06837210804224014,
0.8113188743591309,
-0.04124661907553673,
0.7110650539398193,
0.17045338451862335,
0.08383221924304962,
-0.8371358513832092,
0.4987494647502899,
-0.18956585228443146,
-0.3684147000312805,
-0.4855266511440277,
-0.46707192063331604,
-0.6166869401931763,
0.3105417788028717,
-0.525216281414032,
-0.9990553855895996,
0.1645725816488266,
0.20642097294330597,
-0.5465461015701294,
0.414408802986145,
-0.6875256299972534,
0.8734572529792786,
-0.2760345935821533,
-0.5098922252655029,
-0.2003178745508194,
-0.4973772168159485,
0.3634338676929474,
-0.4408131241798401,
0.12341201305389404,
0.02760029397904873,
0.15695974230766296,
0.8050960302352905,
-0.19942137598991394,
0.8313181400299072,
-0.2340848743915558,
0.026553049683570862,
0.19214752316474915,
0.06450460851192474,
0.4545583128929138,
0.048155222088098526,
0.18682950735092163,
0.14707358181476593,
0.0754965990781784,
-0.19142819941043854,
-0.4909419119358063,
0.9702700972557068,
-0.5601824522018433,
-0.30277323722839355,
-0.16476260125637054,
-0.7770401835441589,
-0.18444091081619263,
0.17486977577209473,
0.32970836758613586,
0.5311797261238098,
-0.4074493944644928,
0.5136181116104126,
0.5782750248908997,
-0.18871542811393738,
0.6679885983467102,
0.05655811354517937,
-0.7006199359893799,
-0.5488300323486328,
1.02426016330719,
0.06846470385789871,
-0.20481036603450775,
0.3423140347003937,
0.11114116758108139,
-0.3496047258377075,
-0.49922892451286316,
-0.34289610385894775,
0.047879453748464584,
-0.6611283421516418,
-0.29867520928382874,
-0.9143033623695374,
0.07788777351379395,
-0.38521015644073486,
-0.3989282548427582,
-0.3586289882659912,
-0.284940630197525,
-0.4715432822704315,
-0.06045948341488838,
0.45191386342048645,
0.7008377909660339,
-0.09019100666046143,
0.26956605911254883,
-0.696631669998169,
0.5102508664131165,
0.16179661452770233,
0.49873974919319153,
0.3145129978656769,
-0.202057346701622,
-0.15835052728652954,
0.18653541803359985,
-0.3371662199497223,
-0.539527952671051,
0.40279003977775574,
0.4025956988334656,
0.4478859603404999,
0.8749487400054932,
0.23138484358787537,
1.1524457931518555,
-0.3479231894016266,
0.5674638152122498,
0.5077710747718811,
-0.8581394553184509,
0.11877201497554779,
-0.10307175666093826,
-0.024265777319669724,
0.48485681414604187,
0.09254831820726395,
-0.4339147210121155,
-0.23540553450584412,
-0.283711701631546,
-0.7369228005409241,
0.5725440979003906,
0.22712817788124084,
0.0419967845082283,
0.00844066683202982,
0.17433665692806244,
0.397260457277298,
0.2599913775920868,
-0.6681562662124634,
-0.16718828678131104,
-0.36697447299957275,
-0.6125856637954712,
-0.3621758818626404,
-0.2474009096622467,
-0.2836195230484009,
-0.4409472942352295,
0.4905414283275604,
-0.22968198359012604,
0.32706505060195923,
0.19997958838939667,
-0.43262165784835815,
-0.5123170018196106,
0.02968880720436573,
0.7803289890289307,
0.18547239899635315,
-0.2545914351940155,
0.29586219787597656,
0.06918284296989441,
-0.5528734922409058,
0.07303716242313385,
0.19272983074188232,
-0.009761433117091656,
-0.1940382570028305,
0.10073383897542953,
0.711025595664978,
0.5274012684822083,
-0.9094666838645935,
0.4657231271266937,
0.02119264006614685,
-0.2300020307302475,
-0.3578384518623352,
-0.06911784410476685,
0.16067011654376984,
0.3898097276687622,
0.30133065581321716,
-0.026738401502370834,
0.23298387229442596,
-0.3795102536678314,
0.4977170526981354,
0.4279046058654785,
-0.3481551706790924,
-0.31346046924591064,
0.7456133365631104,
0.18066376447677612,
-0.4109163284301758,
0.6831112504005432,
-0.3082039952278137,
-0.18253213167190552,
0.3909291923046112,
0.7473176121711731,
1.0177761316299438,
-0.02954033389687538,
0.24313005805015564,
0.12493519484996796,
0.26575660705566406,
-0.35386550426483154,
0.08591628819704056,
-0.07146018743515015,
-0.6330271363258362,
-0.13843309879302979,
-0.9662267565727234,
-0.05677159130573273,
0.34145447611808777,
-0.6453450322151184,
0.1323525458574295,
-0.38068994879722595,
0.044288523495197296,
0.012114832177758217,
-0.30862775444984436,
-0.5270837545394897,
0.1296691745519638,
0.3524931073188782,
0.27074751257896423,
-0.7882243394851685,
0.7116948366165161,
0.5804433226585388,
-0.37087830901145935,
-0.5035719871520996,
0.046383365988731384,
0.16861680150032043,
-0.4644438624382019,
0.25324875116348267,
0.6444817185401917,
-0.22397470474243164,
0.13168761134147644,
-0.37786152958869934,
-0.5138850212097168,
0.84743332862854,
0.3781028687953949,
-0.7700201869010925,
-0.01572602242231369,
0.09664018452167511,
0.47661301493644714,
-0.5808910727500916,
-0.010250002145767212,
0.38176608085632324,
0.5076622366905212,
0.16811469197273254,
-0.5965270400047302,
0.06036447733640671,
-0.1585799604654312,
-0.13408952951431274,
0.3243037462234497,
-0.5483440160751343,
0.6703550815582275,
-0.5267943739891052,
-0.22153805196285248,
0.10363133251667023,
0.5999166965484619,
-0.11398927122354507,
0.6273689866065979,
0.46064242720603943,
0.7845559120178223,
0.9338738918304443,
-0.16054114699363708,
0.3849247694015503,
-0.15023685991764069,
0.4489067792892456,
1.2232065200805664,
-0.4393150508403778,
0.8195348381996155,
0.8183051347732544,
0.23999392986297607,
0.11255940049886703,
0.5057483315467834,
-0.23493604362010956,
0.691301703453064,
-0.03371194750070572,
-0.050373855978250504,
-0.43459150195121765,
-0.11351685225963593,
-0.3008202016353607,
0.7055485248565674,
0.11742716282606125,
-0.3540193736553192,
-0.36520031094551086,
0.6034332513809204,
-0.1107664629817009,
0.2416989803314209,
-0.20084312558174133,
0.8416432738304138,
0.0353395938873291,
-0.5092800855636597,
0.5400556921958923,
-0.21633002161979675,
0.7038043737411499,
-0.12282170355319977,
-0.22731684148311615,
-0.28152886033058167,
0.4312717020511627,
-0.3911327123641968,
-0.3851189911365509,
0.388370156288147,
-0.04653075337409973,
-0.12778747081756592,
0.058735355734825134,
0.49697014689445496,
-0.7546693682670593,
-0.5070792436599731,
0.6271757483482361,
0.33278658986091614,
0.23433184623718262,
-0.13382266461849213,
-0.6559072136878967,
0.0454263873398304,
0.04040339216589928,
-0.359983891248703,
0.4565875232219696,
0.3532995283603668,
-0.05197763815522194,
0.49378547072410583,
0.7332447171211243,
-0.27809640765190125,
-0.05486626178026199,
0.2480534166097641,
0.8228026032447815,
-0.6511317491531372,
-0.152194082736969,
-0.8894602656364441,
0.40671953558921814,
-0.012539619579911232,
-0.20129139721393585,
0.387802392244339,
0.5497903227806091,
0.9658039212226868,
-0.15505094826221466,
0.34990784525871277,
0.05571848154067993,
-0.07183634489774704,
-0.6029239892959595,
1.043285608291626,
-0.924322783946991,
-0.04659207910299301,
-0.3520653247833252,
-1.0780631303787231,
-0.5977182984352112,
0.7887203693389893,
0.2855903208255768,
0.006618014071136713,
0.7760518193244934,
1.2537224292755127,
-0.05276404321193695,
0.2518339157104492,
0.7905175089836121,
0.11940804123878479,
0.10126692056655884,
0.5371478199958801,
0.6429737210273743,
-0.2854529023170471,
0.5992957353591919,
-0.765964150428772,
-0.0025465490762144327,
-0.351536363363266,
-0.7917160391807556,
-1.2047059535980225,
-0.8488454222679138,
-0.1929570585489273,
-0.12714608013629913,
0.03639911487698555,
1.2387890815734863,
0.5244452357292175,
-0.9998354315757751,
-0.10599511861801147,
-0.11636944860219955,
-0.17612941563129425,
-0.18844489753246307,
-0.18308785557746887,
0.5136953592300415,
-0.3378947675228119,
-0.791398286819458,
0.05539916083216667,
0.41550135612487793,
0.306569904088974,
-0.49532753229141235,
-0.36250320076942444,
-0.14119897782802582,
-0.0692143365740776,
0.6781305074691772,
0.049061745405197144,
-0.9323079586029053,
-0.3569197356700897,
0.007539019919931889,
-0.09165556728839874,
0.08613241463899612,
0.6049716472625732,
-0.48914632201194763,
0.7438176274299622,
0.1821562498807907,
0.6358612775802612,
0.2583393454551697,
-0.07461265474557877,
0.2855930030345917,
-0.5483648777008057,
0.6383223533630371,
-0.017460905015468597,
0.573129415512085,
0.5063624978065491,
-0.5307472348213196,
0.3952290713787079,
0.22052627801895142,
-0.4455936551094055,
-1.339830994606018,
-0.06686984747648239,
-1.0072987079620361,
-0.43814343214035034,
1.0086216926574707,
0.12273922562599182,
-0.390443354845047,
-0.11573272198438644,
-0.31996047496795654,
0.3320244252681732,
-0.38005295395851135,
1.0573790073394775,
0.6332747936248779,
0.01584916189312935,
-0.16501109302043915,
-0.2645041346549988,
0.6133120656013489,
0.3347212076187134,
-0.8365969061851501,
0.3490974009037018,
0.7525444030761719,
-0.19176596403121948,
0.24832330644130707,
0.3075442612171173,
-0.05961534380912781,
0.10739148408174515,
0.07063313573598862,
0.29496416449546814,
-0.5133348703384399,
-0.7688919901847839,
-0.48970407247543335,
0.47383466362953186,
-0.28770121932029724,
-0.14980582892894745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09773v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09773v2 | NutePrune: Efficient Progressive Pruning with Numerous Teachers for Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T08:03:12 | 2024-06-27T04:49:11 | Shengrui Li, Junzhe Chen, Xueting Han, Jing Bai | cs.CL | cs.CL | The considerable size of Large Language Models (LLMs) presents notable
deployment challenges, particularly on resource-constrained hardware.
Structured pruning, offers an effective means to compress LLMs, thereby
reducing storage costs and enhancing inference speed for more efficient
utilization. In this work, we study data-efficient and resource-efficient
structure pruning methods to obtain smaller yet still powerful models.
Knowledge Distillation is well-suited for pruning, as the intact model can
serve as an excellent teacher for pruned students. However, it becomes
challenging in the context of LLMs due to memory constraints. To address this,
we propose an efficient progressive Numerous-teacher pruning method
(NutePrune). NutePrune mitigates excessive memory costs by loading only one
intact model and integrating it with various masks and LoRA modules, enabling
it to seamlessly switch between teacher and student roles. This approach allows
us to leverage numerous teachers with varying capacities to progressively guide
the pruned model, enhancing overall performance. Extensive experiments across
various tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of NutePrune. In LLaMA-7B zero-shot
experiments, NutePrune retains 97.17% of the performance of the original model
at 20% sparsity and 95.07% at 25% sparsity. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Lucius-lsr/NutePrune. | [
-0.27771931886672974,
-0.6913970708847046,
0.3394150137901306,
0.33503690361976624,
-0.2814374268054962,
0.25758546590805054,
-0.700053334236145,
-0.014490130357444286,
-0.11905062198638916,
0.46651262044906616,
-0.47818344831466675,
-0.510199785232544,
-0.3480849862098694,
-0.09183664619922638,
-0.6189582943916321,
0.7601311802864075,
0.0034035902936011553,
-0.007862395606935024,
0.032983310520648956,
0.08843044191598892,
-0.7400733232498169,
-0.33901187777519226,
-0.5331872701644897,
-0.4929732382297516,
0.38401666283607483,
0.6357175707817078,
0.2934119403362274,
0.5960524678230286,
0.2917163670063019,
0.34221938252449036,
-0.3926723301410675,
0.18360523879528046,
-0.674509584903717,
0.3880127966403961,
-0.2725633978843689,
-0.6345224380493164,
-0.15304695069789886,
-0.28462061285972595,
0.7625378370285034,
0.6801496148109436,
-0.633640468120575,
0.12477204948663712,
0.15295052528381348,
0.6461085081100464,
-0.7029561996459961,
-0.09462892264127731,
-0.7837854027748108,
0.07956138253211975,
-0.35651782155036926,
0.2618258595466614,
-0.45521894097328186,
-0.36280980706214905,
-0.06742949038743973,
-0.5072110295295715,
0.25216108560562134,
-0.12752947211265564,
0.7751719951629639,
0.2248544991016388,
0.017191343009471893,
0.13889899849891663,
-1.0410034656524658,
0.8925312757492065,
-0.5998849868774414,
0.18891632556915283,
0.3465525805950165,
0.449178546667099,
-0.13341280817985535,
-0.7707812190055847,
-0.4483194053173065,
-0.07365641742944717,
0.3905172049999237,
-0.0261894129216671,
0.0001237942633451894,
0.023497942835092545,
0.2805631458759308,
0.521447479724884,
-0.37756845355033875,
0.10884439200162888,
-0.6276325583457947,
0.002837202977389097,
0.22713753581047058,
-0.02754146233201027,
-0.04292444884777069,
0.08248132467269897,
-0.261822372674942,
-0.2052106112241745,
-0.7754650712013245,
-0.35739728808403015,
0.35733920335769653,
0.10082079470157623,
0.40894097089767456,
0.6230362057685852,
-0.09448366612195969,
0.8213607668876648,
-0.22350986301898956,
-0.5198503136634827,
-0.16065947711467743,
-0.24618785083293915,
-0.2176087200641632,
0.12138309329748154,
0.49092522263526917,
0.03063839301466942,
0.6629565954208374,
-0.09656670689582825,
-0.004088429268449545,
0.40788739919662476,
0.2644294500350952,
-1.0426489114761353,
-0.5284133553504944,
-0.0329124741256237,
-0.03766220808029175,
-0.2508506774902344,
-0.26735931634902954,
-0.7174957394599915,
-0.16065232455730438,
-0.2164735496044159,
-0.023449236527085304,
-1.0800150632858276,
-0.41573265194892883,
0.1927226334810257,
-0.09596601873636246,
0.028936535120010376,
0.4763827323913574,
-0.6364134550094604,
0.6204012632369995,
0.8332138061523438,
1.0545072555541992,
-0.03220348060131073,
-0.25643980503082275,
-0.27831247448921204,
0.3866070508956909,
-0.18919210135936737,
0.44877296686172485,
-0.7011337876319885,
-0.3709924519062042,
-0.4141218662261963,
-0.21430259943008423,
-0.23252476751804352,
-0.8307572603225708,
0.4708012342453003,
-0.35692504048347473,
-0.002548431744799018,
0.07859770953655243,
-0.6268675923347473,
-0.34929540753364563,
0.47065919637680054,
-0.6204531788825989,
1.055389165878296,
0.12452846020460129,
-0.716600239276886,
-0.05700812116265297,
-0.26137053966522217,
-0.37155306339263916,
-0.07341184467077255,
-0.09639956057071686,
-0.5063444972038269,
0.374808669090271,
0.1422376185655594,
0.37528058886528015,
-0.27674517035484314,
0.5706821084022522,
-0.1656804233789444,
-0.5733904242515564,
-0.056511346250772476,
-0.5477606058120728,
0.5492254495620728,
0.1685556173324585,
-0.13733917474746704,
-0.1215590238571167,
-0.6142083406448364,
-0.1388315111398697,
0.34928420186042786,
-0.3932031989097595,
-0.47518256306648254,
0.12142610549926758,
-0.08149564266204834,
0.060604676604270935,
-0.054794199764728546,
-0.36035215854644775,
0.6051168441772461,
-0.5053666830062866,
0.5607410073280334,
0.8204755783081055,
-0.09325393289327621,
0.29143989086151123,
-0.2946862578392029,
0.7669048309326172,
0.09225720912218094,
0.0865950956940651,
-0.2707638740539551,
-0.1886565089225769,
-0.7080210447311401,
-0.5372552871704102,
0.4848114550113678,
0.3842732012271881,
-0.5134233236312866,
0.16296090185642242,
-0.321738064289093,
-0.539442241191864,
-0.37692975997924805,
0.3020577132701874,
0.2642630636692047,
0.5617835521697998,
0.2070305347442627,
-0.36704614758491516,
-0.3463030159473419,
-0.8520451784133911,
0.03480366989970207,
-0.2099734991788864,
0.05453456938266754,
0.12150336802005768,
0.46828049421310425,
0.2699583172798157,
1.0331149101257324,
-0.8355135917663574,
-0.1916384994983673,
-0.22695808112621307,
-0.36681950092315674,
0.37725645303726196,
0.5206788778305054,
0.3097932040691376,
-0.5669847726821899,
-0.5348044037818909,
-0.10005214065313339,
-0.15090835094451904,
0.01696345955133438,
-0.027651753276586533,
-0.16736596822738647,
-0.06533010303974152,
0.055168237537145615,
-0.7507891654968262,
0.23394565284252167,
0.5229161381721497,
0.044809311628341675,
0.98616623878479,
0.050036437809467316,
-0.22535094618797302,
-0.954201340675354,
0.16723674535751343,
-0.059106409549713135,
-0.5273477435112,
-0.39881858229637146,
-0.04151000455021858,
-0.0913250520825386,
-0.2060856968164444,
-0.4634138345718384,
0.2726356089115143,
-0.7015178203582764,
0.06150098517537117,
-0.2733755111694336,
0.17955118417739868,
0.15966877341270447,
0.5043094754219055,
0.1623232066631317,
0.5492635369300842,
0.706694483757019,
-0.6293970942497253,
0.3553604781627655,
0.040691301226615906,
-0.5583592653274536,
0.46021318435668945,
-0.4778911769390106,
0.06927131116390228,
-0.0404655784368515,
0.3390323519706726,
-0.7115052938461304,
-0.09066589921712875,
0.23779071867465973,
0.1278601735830307,
0.5051819682121277,
-0.36270034313201904,
-0.5451064109802246,
-0.4621184468269348,
-0.37397363781929016,
0.27239394187927246,
0.5263954401016235,
-0.4836708605289459,
0.4099167287349701,
0.25111034512519836,
-0.18944202363491058,
-0.5014569163322449,
-0.5543078184127808,
0.11785808205604553,
-0.6721808314323425,
-0.5567294955253601,
0.5274972915649414,
0.0059811887331306934,
-0.13347792625427246,
0.019394883885979652,
-0.5343873500823975,
-0.24518081545829773,
0.21049201488494873,
0.0728481337428093,
0.1930427998304367,
-0.13349401950836182,
0.2210698425769806,
0.019973477348685265,
0.10666061192750931,
-0.28152111172676086,
-0.2648862302303314,
0.90838623046875,
0.06246506795287132,
-0.36846724152565,
-0.10053283721208572,
0.18424658477306366,
0.37532198429107666,
-0.42396828532218933,
0.863641083240509,
0.4722937047481537,
-0.3840036988258362,
-0.5796088576316833,
-0.7217713594436646,
-0.394072949886322,
-0.5082350969314575,
0.6748077273368835,
-0.32504701614379883,
-0.9103074669837952,
0.290654718875885,
-0.6477075815200806,
0.3249671161174774,
-0.02641119435429573,
0.4509698450565338,
0.2837893068790436,
0.5458617806434631,
0.4874473512172699,
-0.2650240957736969,
0.592071533203125,
-0.37822699546813965,
-0.044778354465961456,
-0.8682978749275208,
-0.10139520466327667,
-0.5272268056869507,
-0.36563384532928467,
0.03330962359905243,
-0.7166820764541626,
0.24961018562316895,
0.6072590947151184,
-0.2070414423942566,
0.34986352920532227,
-0.9471459984779358,
0.6919018626213074,
0.22685065865516663,
0.061994828283786774,
0.4583105444908142,
0.25302112102508545,
0.1265546977519989,
0.1251819133758545,
-1.0517841577529907,
-0.571243941783905,
0.7556442618370056,
0.371113121509552,
0.8449832201004028,
0.12225200235843658,
0.8187055587768555,
-0.4871066212654114,
0.4087887406349182,
-0.7294617891311646,
0.7753912210464478,
-0.15099656581878662,
-0.7242420315742493,
-0.23186913132667542,
-0.567869246006012,
-0.7510725855827332,
0.6005468964576721,
0.14417612552642822,
-0.9404573440551758,
-0.05617629736661911,
0.34058481454849243,
-0.3257824778556824,
0.5136346220970154,
-0.8464430570602417,
0.7511359453201294,
-0.12388832122087479,
-0.4259791374206543,
-0.6217324733734131,
-0.37429800629615784,
0.7760626673698425,
-0.2657182216644287,
0.0006806728197261691,
-0.3777264952659607,
-0.010788553394377232,
0.8296145796775818,
-0.6466194987297058,
1.0547795295715332,
-0.23716892302036285,
0.0890594944357872,
0.45817747712135315,
0.2440459430217743,
0.6439344882965088,
-0.09384739398956299,
-0.17365796864032745,
0.0801926851272583,
-0.03760559484362602,
-0.25766903162002563,
-0.46814805269241333,
0.8400622606277466,
-0.5290843844413757,
-0.7245528101921082,
-0.24101494252681732,
-0.35633188486099243,
-0.12247289717197418,
0.17092514038085938,
-0.08827687054872513,
0.16382266581058502,
-0.22258298099040985,
0.2012767344713211,
0.6256753206253052,
-0.17047953605651855,
0.624160885810852,
0.5257683992385864,
-0.3103596270084381,
-0.19775737822055817,
0.971665620803833,
0.46071645617485046,
0.14928682148456573,
0.1861906796693802,
0.35023581981658936,
0.006314381491392851,
-0.6218077540397644,
-0.15768085420131683,
0.3850780725479126,
-0.2619692385196686,
-0.48938652873039246,
-0.39852169156074524,
-0.1494860053062439,
-0.10168232768774033,
-0.07458624988794327,
-0.8214426040649414,
-0.6372951865196228,
-0.2411716729402542,
-0.003917299211025238,
0.5450500845909119,
0.257193922996521,
0.24222002923488617,
0.7538551092147827,
-0.5444819927215576,
0.02256689965724945,
-0.004868924617767334,
0.3325035870075226,
0.23670494556427002,
-0.3362593650817871,
-0.34529441595077515,
-0.28473135828971863,
-0.6543025374412537,
-1.0278197526931763,
0.3823757767677307,
0.5412103533744812,
0.18427647650241852,
0.44362035393714905,
0.11510282009840012,
0.988785445690155,
-0.696073055267334,
0.4274519979953766,
0.345389723777771,
-0.707133948802948,
0.47999870777130127,
-0.1075066402554512,
0.5077473521232605,
0.6165282130241394,
0.1940547078847885,
-0.5284327268600464,
-0.45963677763938904,
-0.4946702718734741,
-1.1104367971420288,
0.7828493118286133,
0.1693243831396103,
-0.07786758244037628,
0.07336253672838211,
0.4137400984764099,
0.10078148543834686,
0.2619161903858185,
-0.5381669998168945,
-0.1009829193353653,
-0.14570832252502441,
-0.062330104410648346,
0.08900284022092819,
-0.1950337141752243,
-0.17010997235774994,
-0.2608007788658142,
0.8258873224258423,
0.07206686586141586,
-0.2483033835887909,
-0.06434036791324615,
-0.06227629631757736,
0.32606467604637146,
0.38787606358528137,
0.21884757280349731,
0.7510327696800232,
-0.04891518875956535,
0.2503899931907654,
0.27531149983406067,
-0.6299861073493958,
0.34621715545654297,
0.02904951199889183,
-0.16583821177482605,
0.02809748239815235,
0.1925634741783142,
0.7528639435768127,
0.268144816160202,
-0.6089492440223694,
0.24392364919185638,
0.024351496249437332,
-0.0060558319091796875,
-0.35132843255996704,
0.42256271839141846,
0.4167128801345825,
0.16476929187774658,
0.18317045271396637,
-0.0545504204928875,
-0.26610249280929565,
-0.2578410804271698,
0.1088746041059494,
0.1992986649274826,
0.04710085690021515,
-0.37774959206581116,
0.30385351181030273,
0.07600074261426926,
-0.0948929414153099,
0.9634835720062256,
0.18859948217868805,
-0.49872490763664246,
0.4514521062374115,
0.6939112544059753,
0.6651241183280945,
-0.6746075749397278,
0.26657888293266296,
0.40824732184410095,
0.28868284821510315,
-0.5506475567817688,
-0.08409210294485092,
-0.1890859305858612,
-0.6572543382644653,
-0.8736135959625244,
-0.7758333086967468,
-0.23990829288959503,
0.029971227049827576,
-0.3594246208667755,
0.20185336470603943,
-0.4976382553577423,
-0.2500327229499817,
-0.12457704544067383,
0.12449020147323608,
-0.3879830837249756,
-0.040225230157375336,
0.011914363130927086,
1.1256330013275146,
-0.7184081673622131,
1.2673587799072266,
0.643487274646759,
0.083587646484375,
-1.0271494388580322,
-0.28759264945983887,
-0.12996633350849152,
-0.5396525263786316,
0.3456861972808838,
0.23791936039924622,
0.1239134818315506,
0.10265857726335526,
-0.3098549544811249,
-0.5547465085983276,
1.0361047983169556,
0.8938741683959961,
-1.2191188335418701,
-0.15206289291381836,
-0.14274027943611145,
0.17048808932304382,
0.040634334087371826,
0.25677382946014404,
0.5867042541503906,
0.6136375069618225,
0.46154671907424927,
-0.745101809501648,
-0.10953079164028168,
0.0073725017718970776,
0.04246770963072777,
0.4033816456794739,
-0.8558468818664551,
0.6286695599555969,
0.10943397879600525,
-0.3227546215057373,
-0.18424251675605774,
0.6396557688713074,
0.60209721326828,
-0.04238886013627052,
0.7889631986618042,
0.7044357657432556,
0.9262971878051758,
0.019154902547597885,
0.6921362280845642,
-0.37769851088523865,
0.32356125116348267,
1.1441389322280884,
-0.4471895396709442,
0.6596356630325317,
0.6397622227668762,
-0.44713082909584045,
0.3375718891620636,
0.5333144068717957,
-0.008896867744624615,
0.33567187190055847,
0.5303481817245483,
-0.48137450218200684,
-0.3466552197933197,
-0.12179741263389587,
-0.2616282105445862,
0.42129454016685486,
0.2190524786710739,
0.10966197401285172,
-0.47399064898490906,
0.032815515995025635,
0.34855034947395325,
-0.11900617182254791,
-0.25115537643432617,
0.43297576904296875,
0.3829677999019623,
-0.7971691489219666,
0.5909057855606079,
0.23486655950546265,
0.5867660045623779,
-0.8390538096427917,
0.021649697795510292,
-0.2360185980796814,
0.4606569707393646,
-0.21569159626960754,
-0.3647117614746094,
0.47534987330436707,
0.16109974682331085,
-0.15283142030239105,
-0.2391252964735031,
0.851591169834137,
-0.5272384881973267,
-0.6188751459121704,
0.019606944173574448,
0.1923246830701828,
0.40889257192611694,
-0.2600845396518707,
-0.5313228964805603,
0.3004153370857239,
0.14052164554595947,
-0.6200582981109619,
0.40459421277046204,
0.26755860447883606,
-0.300860732793808,
0.7257963418960571,
0.41862112283706665,
0.3489285707473755,
0.14860594272613525,
-0.16007085144519806,
1.276929259300232,
-0.5093392133712769,
-0.357360303401947,
-1.1987637281417847,
0.3726269006729126,
-0.0882372036576271,
-0.10693357139825821,
0.8676872253417969,
0.785374104976654,
0.645564615726471,
0.07994119077920914,
0.2509159445762634,
-0.021983180195093155,
0.34889453649520874,
-0.2487761229276657,
0.42837637662887573,
-0.28607869148254395,
0.4759792387485504,
-0.2767498195171356,
-1.2647857666015625,
0.01341287326067686,
0.8053173422813416,
-0.24480019509792328,
-0.05661807209253311,
0.4705665409564972,
0.7807607054710388,
-0.33472007513046265,
-0.04984497278928757,
0.18470558524131775,
0.2616147994995117,
0.37188297510147095,
0.7019602656364441,
0.7364424467086792,
0.10381532460451126,
0.6347962021827698,
-0.48789048194885254,
-0.2524084150791168,
0.1469617635011673,
-0.7165597677230835,
-0.7228158116340637,
-0.1961614340543747,
-0.7365260720252991,
-0.09401459246873856,
0.09282168000936508,
0.5532848834991455,
1.0896334648132324,
-0.496225506067276,
-0.35937076807022095,
-0.25763562321662903,
0.26629638671875,
-0.2721222937107086,
-0.2494523972272873,
0.4493577778339386,
-0.002766957739368081,
-0.7890306711196899,
0.6854224801063538,
0.08354564011096954,
-0.27332305908203125,
-0.4251053035259247,
0.0133637310937047,
-0.3311956524848938,
-0.017505260184407234,
0.4033223092556,
0.3012864887714386,
-0.2984960079193115,
0.08961160480976105,
-0.30327150225639343,
0.27984827756881714,
-0.08750756084918976,
0.7384681105613708,
-0.9698165655136108,
0.10430160909891129,
0.2711668312549591,
0.467233806848526,
1.1044148206710815,
0.19526143372058868,
0.5506037473678589,
-1.1097681522369385,
0.4413338601589203,
0.49270445108413696,
0.1960347443819046,
0.2967321276664734,
0.09742799401283264,
0.6083846688270569,
0.30647584795951843,
-0.4520927965641022,
-1.187273383140564,
0.22184592485427856,
-0.7711552381515503,
-0.6326737999916077,
0.9944451451301575,
-0.407806396484375,
-0.5166110396385193,
0.23944775760173798,
-0.24791644513607025,
0.24747295677661896,
-0.30709734559059143,
0.4921562075614929,
0.7818631529808044,
0.16345219314098358,
-0.3450188636779785,
-0.5170938968658447,
0.009669417515397072,
0.5610164999961853,
-0.47392717003822327,
0.14791961014270782,
0.6011590361595154,
0.4098118841648102,
-0.02785889245569706,
0.6632593870162964,
0.04985034838318825,
-0.2420593649148941,
-0.11737941205501556,
0.21311552822589874,
-0.40569061040878296,
-0.5207123160362244,
-0.1181129589676857,
0.6055803894996643,
-0.012398364022374153,
-0.26081547141075134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09760v1 | Grounding Language Model with Chunking-Free In-Context Retrieval | 2024-02-15T07:22:04 | 2024-02-15T07:22:04 | Hongjin Qian, Zheng Liu, Kelong Mao, Yujia Zhou, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | This paper presents a novel Chunking-Free In-Context (CFIC) retrieval
approach, specifically tailored for Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems. Traditional RAG systems often struggle with grounding responses using
precise evidence text due to the challenges of processing lengthy documents and
filtering out irrelevant content. Commonly employed solutions, such as document
chunking and adapting language models to handle longer contexts, have their
limitations. These methods either disrupt the semantic coherence of the text or
fail to effectively address the issues of noise and inaccuracy in evidence
retrieval.
CFIC addresses these challenges by circumventing the conventional chunking
process. It utilizes the encoded hidden states of documents for in-context
retrieval, employing auto-aggressive decoding to accurately identify the
specific evidence text required for user queries, eliminating the need for
chunking. CFIC is further enhanced by incorporating two decoding strategies,
namely Constrained Sentence Prefix Decoding and Skip Decoding. These strategies
not only improve the efficiency of the retrieval process but also ensure that
the fidelity of the generated grounding text evidence is maintained. Our
evaluations of CFIC on a range of open QA datasets demonstrate its superiority
in retrieving relevant and accurate evidence, offering a significant
improvement over traditional methods. By doing away with the need for document
chunking, CFIC presents a more streamlined, effective, and efficient retrieval
solution, making it a valuable advancement in the field of RAG systems. | [
-0.2423587441444397,
-0.6695058345794678,
0.5902011394500732,
0.276563823223114,
-0.5914058685302734,
0.10107996314764023,
-0.023403581231832504,
-0.4237830638885498,
0.3976321518421173,
0.45708167552948,
-0.09389844536781311,
-0.33484241366386414,
-0.4463123679161072,
-0.04584214463829994,
-0.6375433802604675,
0.7936455607414246,
0.11949165165424347,
-0.017286771908402443,
-0.4160124361515045,
-0.14398930966854095,
-0.7225093841552734,
-0.46397703886032104,
-0.5267692804336548,
-0.3443678617477417,
-0.14527000486850739,
0.6020604372024536,
0.7016854882240295,
0.6927326321601868,
0.2956361770629883,
0.16563236713409424,
-0.44312039017677307,
0.07783186435699463,
-0.5240190625190735,
0.10506229102611542,
-0.33637115359306335,
-0.20221839845180511,
-0.2764308452606201,
-0.007056358270347118,
0.6281200051307678,
0.4117617905139923,
-0.15932384133338928,
-0.10948378592729568,
-0.15560239553451538,
0.7196956276893616,
-1.0424509048461914,
-0.14078548550605774,
-0.8917253613471985,
-0.08659270405769348,
-0.2047933042049408,
-0.4716460704803467,
-0.6834931969642639,
0.021782437339425087,
-0.1329849511384964,
-0.6578235626220703,
0.2771191895008087,
0.02468584105372429,
0.9668170809745789,
0.17065311968326569,
-0.4778427481651306,
-0.6772368550300598,
-0.49641844630241394,
0.7063907384872437,
-0.6895908713340759,
0.5794853568077087,
0.6258609294891357,
0.24646911025047302,
-0.26347866654396057,
-0.6352747082710266,
-0.4728716313838959,
-0.23773348331451416,
-0.2820096015930176,
0.1900399923324585,
0.21382783353328705,
0.02088111825287342,
0.06036171689629555,
0.682451069355011,
-0.2856955826282501,
-0.3378836512565613,
-0.13452331721782684,
-0.08448360115289688,
0.4114511013031006,
-0.005734515376389027,
0.38245365023612976,
-0.30294933915138245,
-0.5103908181190491,
-0.0697721540927887,
-0.5765970945358276,
0.026588886976242065,
0.15154026448726654,
0.32706987857818604,
0.08188097923994064,
0.43838685750961304,
-0.48352470993995667,
0.6103571057319641,
0.5170188546180725,
-0.19963832199573517,
0.10367394983768463,
-0.1969379484653473,
-0.3320566415786743,
0.21001717448234558,
0.5944722890853882,
0.1910029500722885,
-0.46193936467170715,
-0.45959562063217163,
-0.35884371399879456,
-0.0668896958231926,
0.4141428470611572,
-0.8065800070762634,
0.21236446499824524,
0.27937060594558716,
-0.4909856617450714,
-0.5603152513504028,
0.3549526333808899,
-0.8045645952224731,
-0.25513336062431335,
-0.06666465848684311,
0.22460217773914337,
-0.727363646030426,
-0.32501843571662903,
0.05898823216557503,
-0.39228999614715576,
0.5986940860748291,
0.12357840687036514,
-0.8815467953681946,
0.6548024415969849,
0.8727837204933167,
0.8263338804244995,
-0.07188888639211655,
0.2917129695415497,
-0.7717486619949341,
0.22479303181171417,
-0.4464484453201294,
0.8854206800460815,
-0.6576340198516846,
-0.5435696244239807,
-0.1357894241809845,
-0.05698850005865097,
0.1788971871137619,
-0.8052276372909546,
1.0164874792099,
-0.8220463395118713,
0.2501314878463745,
-0.27320700883865356,
-0.6400274634361267,
-0.09399747103452682,
0.3345751166343689,
-0.5884257555007935,
1.2581796646118164,
0.17223340272903442,
-0.9902588129043579,
0.25547805428504944,
-0.3396952748298645,
-0.4098188281059265,
0.2958821952342987,
-0.327658087015152,
0.12691158056259155,
0.27964478731155396,
0.13366924226284027,
0.18266013264656067,
-0.3501812815666199,
0.6328096985816956,
-0.0003524631611071527,
-0.6618927717208862,
-0.1819978654384613,
-0.260267972946167,
0.6987115144729614,
0.42284369468688965,
-0.45404142141342163,
0.04099493473768234,
-0.8649153113365173,
0.18363627791404724,
0.09226619452238083,
-0.453250914812088,
-0.7980643510818481,
0.2319342941045761,
0.21586070954799652,
0.4642173945903778,
0.0894506499171257,
-0.5850780606269836,
-0.18242090940475464,
-0.7501128911972046,
-0.02594027668237686,
0.36370405554771423,
0.028230207040905952,
0.6898843050003052,
-0.19744740426540375,
0.22999027371406555,
0.10894202440977097,
-0.27345359325408936,
-0.3168294131755829,
-0.22513535618782043,
-0.5288471579551697,
-0.292177677154541,
0.3113945424556732,
0.7065719962120056,
-0.8128018379211426,
0.5247707962989807,
-0.3522709012031555,
-0.2774166464805603,
-0.43750375509262085,
-0.16817480325698853,
0.5265696048736572,
0.6811118125915527,
0.49317076802253723,
-0.44209024310112,
-0.4845486581325531,
-0.668451726436615,
-0.33099424839019775,
-0.030707474797964096,
-0.13023093342781067,
0.5099157094955444,
0.2868783473968506,
-0.14826396107673645,
1.1487770080566406,
-0.340101033449173,
-0.12074382603168488,
-0.2020791918039322,
0.07534343749284744,
0.1515333652496338,
0.6298832297325134,
0.38223129510879517,
-1.0958906412124634,
-0.4207552671432495,
0.02905983291566372,
-0.8908678293228149,
-0.08546848595142365,
-0.11633533239364624,
-0.3690614402294159,
0.30513709783554077,
0.5664544105529785,
-0.49761924147605896,
0.5273604393005371,
0.3363518714904785,
-0.7806085348129272,
0.4223704934120178,
-0.010222595185041428,
0.25072482228279114,
-1.0616408586502075,
0.49413421750068665,
-0.4578842520713806,
-0.43432778120040894,
-0.754615068435669,
0.5077117681503296,
0.3983887732028961,
-0.046215783804655075,
-0.288840651512146,
0.648099958896637,
-0.5634737014770508,
0.04501387104392052,
-0.6812113523483276,
0.23177699744701385,
-0.0038316226564347744,
0.21349447965621948,
0.08543119579553604,
0.8730514049530029,
0.1733155995607376,
-0.5750790238380432,
-0.3780369460582733,
0.34265342354774475,
-0.0980382040143013,
0.5550428032875061,
-0.3620491027832031,
0.22454749047756195,
-0.3537653982639313,
0.4732803702354431,
-0.5897436738014221,
-0.2966642379760742,
0.29618212580680847,
-0.564017653465271,
0.40553033351898193,
-0.10100361704826355,
-0.31312528252601624,
0.02627437189221382,
-0.30071499943733215,
0.5527968406677246,
0.342943012714386,
-0.6433390378952026,
0.6359949707984924,
0.49896785616874695,
0.27050551772117615,
-0.8770134449005127,
-0.34392648935317993,
0.3304995894432068,
-0.10607972741127014,
-0.4057144522666931,
0.6872520446777344,
-0.21801014244556427,
-0.33289384841918945,
0.03694944083690643,
-0.5269026756286621,
-0.3649959862232208,
0.2222839891910553,
0.13567610085010529,
0.029943004250526428,
-0.0482763946056366,
-0.1567748337984085,
0.34201711416244507,
-0.07622881978750229,
0.011290094815194607,
-0.26039987802505493,
0.46697962284088135,
0.06951892375946045,
0.007916998118162155,
-0.2108362466096878,
0.6452357769012451,
0.5455325245857239,
-0.2820078134536743,
0.8428210616111755,
0.38907691836357117,
-0.6972651481628418,
-0.03359314799308777,
-0.5758960247039795,
0.015598831698298454,
-0.4638357162475586,
-0.2196483165025711,
-0.5669659972190857,
-0.9536100029945374,
0.3633763790130615,
-0.1509837955236435,
-0.1593659669160843,
0.5037617087364197,
0.35387352108955383,
0.19222305715084076,
0.6303311586380005,
0.798524022102356,
-0.1100585088133812,
0.4237712323665619,
-0.15332452952861786,
0.01857828162610531,
-0.9408470988273621,
-0.1882125288248062,
-0.6001825332641602,
0.33186134696006775,
-0.0818062350153923,
-0.6003149747848511,
0.027041282504796982,
0.6075363159179688,
0.046527400612831116,
0.19424588978290558,
-0.5647626519203186,
0.6480715870857239,
0.23459585011005402,
0.05099780112504959,
0.3544069528579712,
-0.07401163876056671,
-0.49599239230155945,
0.27727988362312317,
-0.4376836121082306,
-0.4502648413181305,
0.7878435850143433,
0.11574899405241013,
0.19578643143177032,
0.13873714208602905,
0.6749261617660522,
0.21878880262374878,
0.5477719902992249,
-0.8002965450286865,
0.39552250504493713,
-0.08766307681798935,
-0.8613088130950928,
-0.08701860904693604,
-0.3873710632324219,
-0.6171073317527771,
0.7076682448387146,
-0.2606273591518402,
-0.6482183337211609,
0.1724136918783188,
-0.07456059008836746,
-0.12154562026262283,
0.37012842297554016,
-0.3088698387145996,
0.5387160778045654,
0.011940748430788517,
-0.3122842609882355,
-0.29764148592948914,
-0.76870197057724,
0.4908742904663086,
0.015227189287543297,
0.31092607975006104,
0.08204639703035355,
0.013482378795742989,
0.5447080731391907,
-0.39192062616348267,
0.3753279745578766,
-0.33023500442504883,
-0.11021966487169266,
0.6062932014465332,
0.15421703457832336,
0.5307514667510986,
0.24000144004821777,
-0.2991282045841217,
-0.11964729428291321,
0.1290023773908615,
-0.44004005193710327,
-0.544892430305481,
0.7729277014732361,
-0.3809586763381958,
-0.4965702295303345,
-0.5643284320831299,
-0.5236412882804871,
-0.16386713087558746,
0.5689422488212585,
0.22143734991550446,
0.46622434258461,
-0.5802422761917114,
0.2908484935760498,
0.9028599262237549,
-0.1736779808998108,
0.3723185658454895,
0.6367939710617065,
0.04546388238668442,
-0.6045331358909607,
0.8333002924919128,
-0.15852311253547668,
-0.03273770213127136,
0.7928723096847534,
0.07199382781982422,
-0.20179833471775055,
-0.6163073182106018,
-0.5517033934593201,
0.2716265916824341,
-0.598141074180603,
-0.4084259271621704,
-1.0046104192733765,
0.031756915152072906,
-0.6255006790161133,
-0.2868815064430237,
-0.22794339060783386,
-0.3162390887737274,
-0.33651912212371826,
-0.13168244063854218,
-0.17904385924339294,
0.5329160094261169,
0.1596369743347168,
0.25877827405929565,
-0.8699523210525513,
0.5841675996780396,
-0.18130387365818024,
0.5949591994285583,
0.06291305273771286,
-0.4919172525405884,
-0.3919629752635956,
-0.2552846372127533,
-0.2687588930130005,
-1.22030770778656,
0.47042006254196167,
0.042161162942647934,
0.41484642028808594,
0.2684170603752136,
0.20210246741771698,
0.8512104153633118,
-0.5747818946838379,
0.7081220746040344,
-0.14652284979820251,
-1.1623029708862305,
0.49159497022628784,
-0.5418310165405273,
0.27763137221336365,
0.8064336180686951,
0.19687022268772125,
-0.6240684390068054,
-0.28872108459472656,
-0.7453764081001282,
-1.3013324737548828,
0.7188566327095032,
0.16398026049137115,
0.011701690033078194,
-0.3832699656486511,
0.5943614840507507,
0.018046751618385315,
0.09823726117610931,
-0.3651672303676605,
-0.04514181986451149,
-0.2564859092235565,
-0.3421637713909149,
0.19291090965270996,
-0.6041820049285889,
-0.22070430219173431,
-0.04226754605770111,
0.84794682264328,
-0.4605483114719391,
0.363254189491272,
0.4860880970954895,
-0.34209418296813965,
-0.32282763719558716,
0.4832708239555359,
0.4970889687538147,
0.3482764661312103,
-0.45400744676589966,
-0.08878082782030106,
0.2904641926288605,
-0.5250906944274902,
0.14554758369922638,
0.13385923206806183,
-0.4781646728515625,
0.17083846032619476,
-0.023730039596557617,
0.5272781252861023,
0.3976874053478241,
-0.8643847703933716,
0.6320106983184814,
-0.24438884854316711,
-0.051226913928985596,
-0.6908577680587769,
-0.27719244360923767,
-0.13845615088939667,
-0.08841505646705627,
0.6295254826545715,
-0.15077316761016846,
0.5386912822723389,
-0.3433166444301605,
0.5298312902450562,
0.44941961765289307,
-0.468927800655365,
-0.1331033557653427,
0.6950827240943909,
-0.059463102370500565,
-0.022035982459783554,
0.5714221000671387,
-0.31491002440452576,
-0.13880494236946106,
0.5000191330909729,
0.9377118349075317,
0.9562246799468994,
-0.010780799202620983,
0.2010507732629776,
0.433671236038208,
0.10902223736047745,
-0.3844005763530731,
0.279220312833786,
-0.29541513323783875,
-0.5989064574241638,
-0.2843623161315918,
-0.79438316822052,
-0.321359246969223,
0.08475465327501297,
-0.9044021368026733,
0.09360966086387634,
-0.5836249589920044,
0.21685555577278137,
-0.5117442607879639,
0.050328221172094345,
-0.27855435013771057,
0.5431855916976929,
0.22163023054599762,
1.4906173944473267,
-0.583118736743927,
0.9142236113548279,
0.8003522753715515,
-0.28247764706611633,
-0.9501733183860779,
0.2243044227361679,
0.01766716130077839,
-0.056813761591911316,
0.337356299161911,
0.3723614811897278,
-0.3084924519062042,
-0.04104945436120033,
-0.5419309735298157,
-1.1998066902160645,
1.3350030183792114,
0.045954927802085876,
0.09273169934749603,
-0.08785994350910187,
-0.344078928232193,
0.5269306898117065,
-0.5493573546409607,
0.4012424647808075,
0.5592460036277771,
0.2108088731765747,
0.18529757857322693,
-0.7197360992431641,
0.5520426034927368,
-0.4033113718032837,
0.059195760637521744,
0.21240049600601196,
-0.7274221181869507,
0.5496626496315002,
0.29165735840797424,
-0.7666178345680237,
0.3493597209453583,
1.0125373601913452,
0.3737315833568573,
0.6436643600463867,
0.5946968197822571,
0.8678663969039917,
0.7450995445251465,
0.13278739154338837,
0.977954089641571,
-0.5029600858688354,
0.23708660900592804,
1.1212564706802368,
-0.25433728098869324,
1.0146219730377197,
0.5335435271263123,
0.34621191024780273,
0.7552021741867065,
0.18329282104969025,
0.5303625464439392,
0.5484487414360046,
0.0350196473300457,
-0.4224138557910919,
-0.02611609175801277,
-0.1938411146402359,
-0.208894744515419,
0.379599392414093,
0.533225417137146,
-0.3267708122730255,
-0.2873992621898651,
-0.2026318460702896,
0.17951840162277222,
0.30740368366241455,
-0.18588440120220184,
0.8292808532714844,
-0.14985312521457672,
-0.8600162863731384,
0.7155435681343079,
0.410814493894577,
0.8958526849746704,
-0.573152482509613,
-0.10629411041736603,
-0.41263347864151,
-0.09147713333368301,
-0.3399015963077545,
-0.2192183881998062,
0.6453307867050171,
0.10405626147985458,
-0.3747895658016205,
-0.25972780585289,
1.082610845565796,
-0.36300182342529297,
-0.11873438209295273,
0.3484314978122711,
0.43597662448883057,
0.224233478307724,
-0.13270923495292664,
-0.4711224138736725,
-0.028851067647337914,
-0.15441188216209412,
-0.14470358192920685,
0.4407062530517578,
0.4924014210700989,
-0.3774469196796417,
0.4711379110813141,
0.710198163986206,
-0.25081026554107666,
-0.12229081243276596,
-0.1624813675880432,
1.1572887897491455,
-1.0173012018203735,
-0.8115315437316895,
-0.3551974296569824,
0.5176100134849548,
-0.007987725548446178,
0.021192682906985283,
0.49836960434913635,
0.7318781614303589,
0.8186049461364746,
0.08223608881235123,
0.5503180623054504,
-0.5743404030799866,
0.48896393179893494,
-0.47852733731269836,
0.7556319236755371,
-0.5189897418022156,
0.06765955686569214,
-0.2994534969329834,
-0.5551996231079102,
-0.19596602022647858,
0.29800331592559814,
0.19339218735694885,
-0.16669288277626038,
0.896003782749176,
0.6407359838485718,
-0.06775293499231339,
0.16917553544044495,
0.29790976643562317,
0.025211472064256668,
0.3893490433692932,
0.18538285791873932,
0.45520108938217163,
-0.6914001703262329,
0.3897615671157837,
-0.19948677718639374,
-0.46428877115249634,
-0.009110141545534134,
-0.6679813861846924,
-0.5586725473403931,
-0.4349071979522705,
0.1695866733789444,
-0.5218098759651184,
0.12504296004772186,
0.9711601138114929,
0.6050569415092468,
-0.9977552890777588,
-0.21457314491271973,
-0.15974830090999603,
0.0671968013048172,
-0.34928324818611145,
-0.3203616440296173,
0.22142188251018524,
-0.5870725512504578,
-0.5386715531349182,
1.0459034442901611,
0.09075357764959335,
-0.0834553986787796,
0.12301337718963623,
-0.053448136895895004,
-0.590986967086792,
0.30772045254707336,
0.6457594633102417,
0.39503854513168335,
-0.6171454787254333,
-0.3315541446208954,
0.009896635077893734,
-0.17813371121883392,
0.10816754400730133,
1.1527507305145264,
-1.281873106956482,
0.2235066145658493,
0.6258791089057922,
0.7655099630355835,
0.3047757148742676,
0.4856061637401581,
0.48015692830085754,
-0.8704985976219177,
0.4126686751842499,
0.30405718088150024,
0.12949517369270325,
0.40062379837036133,
-0.8092447519302368,
0.6016345024108887,
0.3753455877304077,
-0.4330121576786041,
-0.8230504393577576,
0.15690794587135315,
-1.0415687561035156,
-0.4035634696483612,
1.0671744346618652,
-0.06294012069702148,
-0.307770311832428,
-0.14961223304271698,
-0.16768448054790497,
0.3165912926197052,
-0.5416840314865112,
0.7314174175262451,
0.6652997136116028,
0.13292331993579865,
0.04860283061861992,
-0.39717528223991394,
0.5576270222663879,
0.5690264701843262,
-0.62326580286026,
-0.001913849264383316,
0.751787006855011,
0.2929975688457489,
0.28353190422058105,
1.1434167623519897,
-0.5401394963264465,
0.11758098006248474,
0.005956348497420549,
-0.058587539941072464,
0.11635943502187729,
-0.48353835940361023,
-0.6835795640945435,
0.6055324077606201,
-0.11041182279586792,
0.17854443192481995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09759v1 | Efficient Language Adaptive Pre-training: Extending State-of-the-Art Large Language Models for Polish | 2024-02-15T07:17:10 | 2024-02-15T07:17:10 | Szymon Ruciński | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study explores the potential of fine-tuning foundational English Large
Language Models (LLMs) for generating Polish text. The first step involves
Language Adaptive Pre-training (LAPT) on a high-quality dataset of 3.11 GB,
consisting of 276 million Polish tokens. The LAPT is followed by additional
fine-tuning aimed at solving nine KLEJ challenges. Our trained model
Curie-7B-v1 not only generates Polish text with the lowest perplexity of 3.02
among decoder-based Polish models but also closely rivals the performance of
the best Polish encoder-decoder models with a less than 2% gap on 8 out of 9
tasks. Curie-7B-v1 used approximately 2-3% of a typical dataset size to learn
Polish. The LAPT was completed in less than five days using a consumer GPU,
highlighting the method's efficiency. The proficiency of the model in Polish
was significantly enhanced, demonstrating the viability of this approach for
adding new languages to existing LLMs by training just 1.2% of its parameters.
To contribute to the community's collaborative progress, the model has been
released as open-source. | [
-0.20503206551074982,
-0.782723069190979,
0.6644692420959473,
0.2651638984680176,
-0.42215120792388916,
0.1836249679327011,
-0.7505701184272766,
-0.5032514333724976,
0.003972822334617376,
0.5394682884216309,
-0.45565298199653625,
-0.5146508812904358,
-0.6386888027191162,
0.19173511862754822,
-0.2164650559425354,
0.6980950236320496,
-0.1671411395072937,
0.21680030226707458,
0.14469480514526367,
0.21347858011722565,
-0.4297223687171936,
-0.5637449622154236,
-0.4924299418926239,
-0.10363893955945969,
0.24540886282920837,
0.6832194328308105,
0.4181632399559021,
0.3621267080307007,
0.5520702004432678,
0.3219665288925171,
0.10620710998773575,
0.19679300487041473,
-0.7689367532730103,
0.12121321260929108,
-0.20312915742397308,
-0.2405988723039627,
-0.6250150203704834,
-0.09068793803453445,
0.6165405511856079,
0.7573568224906921,
-0.2324461191892624,
0.17223751544952393,
-0.05176115036010742,
0.8494645357131958,
-0.6139414310455322,
0.16900548338890076,
-1.0257405042648315,
-0.1978294402360916,
-0.4798460006713867,
0.028694506734609604,
-0.6447479128837585,
-0.03207915648818016,
-0.17216558754444122,
-0.9153270721435547,
0.11356249451637268,
0.1176118478178978,
0.5903942584991455,
-0.10456487536430359,
0.0859542116522789,
-0.5280676484107971,
-0.7677971124649048,
0.6579365730285645,
-0.7452684640884399,
0.5131455063819885,
0.30299443006515503,
0.139786958694458,
-0.312114417552948,
-0.8426361680030823,
-0.4991772770881653,
-0.3443618714809418,
0.30153557658195496,
0.22658108174800873,
-0.08237656950950623,
-0.04978734999895096,
0.23372125625610352,
0.42605066299438477,
-0.5430701375007629,
0.274385929107666,
-0.5748203992843628,
-0.11841557174921036,
0.5787959098815918,
0.18134352564811707,
0.3394611179828644,
0.35598239302635193,
-0.12798355519771576,
0.08968854695558548,
-0.8665479421615601,
-0.07409847527742386,
0.5074630379676819,
0.6796342134475708,
-0.1266472488641739,
0.4577358365058899,
-0.4780769944190979,
0.7476126551628113,
0.14839695394039154,
-0.046372704207897186,
0.4423367977142334,
-0.363861083984375,
-0.15983575582504272,
0.19914546608924866,
0.8118767738342285,
0.10501684993505478,
0.45397183299064636,
-0.21207231283187866,
-0.21380680799484253,
0.1742914468050003,
0.20255506038665771,
-0.819293200969696,
-0.42352360486984253,
-0.14501510560512543,
-0.2549867033958435,
-0.1974533647298813,
-0.10565713793039322,
-0.368897408246994,
-0.18104979395866394,
-0.16095302999019623,
0.42968085408210754,
-0.45829305052757263,
-0.30747485160827637,
0.7106361985206604,
0.32511329650878906,
0.012513672932982445,
0.4253328740596771,
-1.0324641466140747,
0.3990766406059265,
0.36864739656448364,
0.6063632965087891,
-0.17911182343959808,
-0.37821778655052185,
-0.574118971824646,
0.04988864064216614,
-0.6730908751487732,
0.6548548936843872,
-0.4882763624191284,
-0.2540576756000519,
-0.0604570172727108,
0.21435493230819702,
-0.0718185305595398,
-0.4060474932193756,
0.5430487990379333,
-0.6340551972389221,
0.24596291780471802,
-0.1259404867887497,
-0.6661435961723328,
0.16458344459533691,
0.1543155163526535,
-0.6617282629013062,
1.05436110496521,
0.38947463035583496,
-0.7120093107223511,
0.2699319124221802,
-0.6644955277442932,
-0.5351400971412659,
0.3449613153934479,
0.21163222193717957,
-0.21042901277542114,
0.34386128187179565,
0.16185951232910156,
0.4502622187137604,
-0.19484105706214905,
0.11511598527431488,
-0.29654955863952637,
-0.2138894647359848,
-0.12197481840848923,
-0.08075891435146332,
0.6208535432815552,
0.31064990162849426,
-0.11887215077877045,
0.21223171055316925,
-1.0151684284210205,
-0.046853676438331604,
0.22820214927196503,
-0.39492303133010864,
-0.22174473106861115,
-0.1584399938583374,
0.23363107442855835,
0.35451677441596985,
0.5487126111984253,
-0.8409352898597717,
0.06001868098974228,
-0.6766330599784851,
0.4187809228897095,
0.6684474349021912,
-0.35001102089881897,
0.44650888442993164,
0.10257605463266373,
0.4097253978252411,
-0.17968541383743286,
0.18112295866012573,
-0.12947389483451843,
-0.26823750138282776,
-0.5493259429931641,
0.014917248860001564,
0.5012915134429932,
0.49038246273994446,
-0.7867493629455566,
0.3963794410228729,
-0.35195451974868774,
-0.47677579522132874,
-0.44520530104637146,
0.33440303802490234,
0.27131757140159607,
0.554095983505249,
0.20760498940944672,
-0.34553900361061096,
-0.5691123604774475,
-0.8242747187614441,
-0.1358446180820465,
-0.03980501741170883,
0.0891149565577507,
-0.07987706363201141,
0.4461004436016083,
0.20755697786808014,
0.5518969893455505,
-0.2344525158405304,
-0.11358863115310669,
-0.5951802134513855,
-0.2825372815132141,
0.38782745599746704,
0.4896649718284607,
0.4864219129085541,
-0.570447564125061,
-0.9764612913131714,
0.34939098358154297,
-0.4992172420024872,
-0.10083213448524475,
0.27931663393974304,
-0.15061144530773163,
0.21022579073905945,
0.7519569993019104,
-0.46036094427108765,
0.050380028784275055,
0.6991742253303528,
-0.488422155380249,
0.5564217567443848,
-0.6287478804588318,
0.07866476476192474,
-1.1043450832366943,
0.05756993219256401,
-0.46318116784095764,
-0.3896833658218384,
-0.8770320415496826,
0.1971828192472458,
0.22652578353881836,
-0.09225235879421234,
-0.6601723432540894,
0.5406545996665955,
-0.5152041912078857,
0.01817016489803791,
-0.46950632333755493,
0.39068010449409485,
-0.17915299534797668,
0.2647072672843933,
0.10925158113241196,
0.9510232210159302,
0.4736468493938446,
-0.34181809425354004,
0.17783693969249725,
0.28764185309410095,
-0.7686001658439636,
0.037664398550987244,
-0.53163743019104,
0.19935846328735352,
-0.037990376353263855,
-0.11979209631681442,
-0.7855040431022644,
-0.2960423529148102,
0.051357220858335495,
-0.4197940528392792,
0.33558857440948486,
0.04401593282818794,
-0.4212642014026642,
-0.3787023723125458,
-0.07852097600698471,
0.07759518176317215,
0.6664813756942749,
-0.4586367905139923,
0.5594338178634644,
0.3537079691886902,
-0.5590883493423462,
-0.41220948100090027,
-0.46628686785697937,
0.15476711094379425,
0.1132545918226242,
-0.6567866802215576,
0.29083681106567383,
-0.24320659041404724,
-0.10504458099603653,
-0.1482376903295517,
0.12302333116531372,
0.05616779252886772,
0.29724687337875366,
-0.04240982234477997,
0.17507782578468323,
-0.262667179107666,
0.050497427582740784,
-0.07078995555639267,
-0.03734545782208443,
-0.10775814205408096,
-0.15385274589061737,
0.8080292344093323,
-0.2927505075931549,
-0.13803593814373016,
-0.12070465087890625,
0.2703448235988617,
0.5028274655342102,
-0.35265713930130005,
0.780841588973999,
0.5767748355865479,
-0.30886751413345337,
-0.12875573337078094,
-0.5458267331123352,
0.08011241257190704,
-0.4896579086780548,
0.755045473575592,
-0.5198616981506348,
-1.0587644577026367,
0.635943591594696,
-0.07480919361114502,
0.03275028616189957,
0.48456960916519165,
0.8545401692390442,
0.026408378034830093,
0.9062587022781372,
0.8618252277374268,
-0.13252869248390198,
0.6386304497718811,
0.14008302986621857,
0.18017733097076416,
-0.6496994495391846,
-0.002633459633216262,
-0.45994049310684204,
0.11844431608915329,
-0.45620420575141907,
-0.3078853487968445,
-0.013859331607818604,
0.45015817880630493,
-0.21800462901592255,
0.16299422085285187,
-0.17100712656974792,
0.6235570907592773,
0.3181063234806061,
0.24019694328308105,
0.30526620149612427,
0.12586714327335358,
0.025824548676609993,
0.09302332252264023,
-0.8779134154319763,
-0.4556649625301361,
1.299623727798462,
0.2764228880405426,
0.6467300653457642,
-0.12637010216712952,
0.5930233597755432,
-0.022350819781422615,
0.3786821961402893,
-0.4856477975845337,
0.39252522587776184,
-0.6490563154220581,
-0.5219979882240295,
-0.46833115816116333,
-0.1732751578092575,
-0.8232852816581726,
0.05298759788274765,
-0.44574132561683655,
-0.46226194500923157,
-0.11601284146308899,
0.4459816813468933,
-0.2574010491371155,
0.3024812936782837,
-0.693095862865448,
0.8538761138916016,
-0.10907546430826187,
-0.4726077616214752,
-0.2611640691757202,
-0.4951975345611572,
0.2257993519306183,
-0.45948272943496704,
0.5375822186470032,
-0.2657734453678131,
0.10304316133260727,
0.7364585399627686,
-0.32687896490097046,
0.573767900466919,
-0.3896401822566986,
-0.16418126225471497,
0.12290649861097336,
-0.09326748549938202,
0.7380598783493042,
-0.28329989314079285,
-0.17405131459236145,
-0.06997641175985336,
-0.34004732966423035,
-0.6377326250076294,
-0.279247909784317,
0.536990761756897,
-0.6167380213737488,
-0.5341812372207642,
0.11279086023569107,
-0.6433346271514893,
-0.48961490392684937,
0.5315840244293213,
0.41512322425842285,
0.4407464265823364,
-0.420919805765152,
0.29006558656692505,
0.7626667022705078,
-0.32251405715942383,
0.4164174199104309,
0.704804003238678,
-0.32815834879875183,
-0.4022912085056305,
0.7331404089927673,
-0.10343440622091293,
0.5415248870849609,
0.22625501453876495,
0.22278998792171478,
-0.17790505290031433,
-1.2069165706634521,
-0.5493429899215698,
0.1613747775554657,
-0.6930885314941406,
-0.07987622916698456,
-0.48202839493751526,
-0.014320988208055496,
-0.4286843538284302,
-0.22005370259284973,
-0.6969149708747864,
-0.3066183030605316,
-0.04101529344916344,
-0.10970327258110046,
0.33986949920654297,
0.9712225794792175,
0.09953418374061584,
0.5531198382377625,
-0.7362347841262817,
0.11695188283920288,
0.03315079212188721,
0.5968354344367981,
-0.2998311519622803,
-0.6204537153244019,
-0.6042571067810059,
0.003131990088149905,
0.040406592190265656,
-0.5197246670722961,
0.45888131856918335,
0.17869912087917328,
0.44228217005729675,
-0.09072790294885635,
0.033765990287065506,
0.4860661029815674,
-0.9288358688354492,
0.8514041900634766,
0.23921675980091095,
-0.8757737874984741,
0.38981398940086365,
-0.5601899027824402,
0.4290679693222046,
0.8280088901519775,
0.2784714102745056,
-0.1518966555595398,
-0.4772954285144806,
-0.42177316546440125,
-0.8170543313026428,
0.6636055707931519,
0.049642276018857956,
0.3692801296710968,
-0.11310920864343643,
0.46851447224617004,
0.16419373452663422,
0.12346050143241882,
-0.7549889087677002,
0.09002263844013214,
-0.02233109250664711,
-0.503577709197998,
-0.3933088481426239,
-0.31695684790611267,
0.27426889538764954,
-0.22139081358909607,
0.9674142599105835,
-0.06529279053211212,
-0.10220924764871597,
0.12206090241670609,
-0.6661630868911743,
-0.19458052515983582,
0.37739577889442444,
0.9073939919471741,
0.8484694361686707,
-0.19247297942638397,
-0.15277568995952606,
0.42975011467933655,
-0.9818394184112549,
0.035335879772901535,
0.031312357634305954,
0.0858759954571724,
-0.09058773517608643,
0.3794092833995819,
1.0018481016159058,
0.21296222507953644,
-0.745250403881073,
0.6505425572395325,
-0.09109601378440857,
-0.516463577747345,
-0.2351703941822052,
-0.08496508002281189,
0.2620859146118164,
0.09387243539094925,
0.1631474494934082,
-0.18234050273895264,
-0.04698755592107773,
-0.39118367433547974,
-0.02064199186861515,
0.3626914620399475,
-0.32563722133636475,
-0.3494657278060913,
0.5528991222381592,
0.18501196801662445,
-0.12296067178249359,
0.6128441095352173,
-0.03758108615875244,
-0.5428854823112488,
0.26380494236946106,
0.7952210307121277,
0.533570408821106,
-0.4655696153640747,
-0.1874849945306778,
0.3962637782096863,
0.4078775644302368,
-0.4157807528972626,
0.5281370878219604,
0.3674634099006653,
-0.9152311086654663,
-0.7222674489021301,
-0.8512272238731384,
-0.2149595320224762,
0.3109630048274994,
-0.6239402294158936,
0.2719026803970337,
-0.34339481592178345,
0.049323368817567825,
-0.15270817279815674,
0.14376172423362732,
-0.6383216977119446,
0.11972308158874512,
0.1522805392742157,
1.2510877847671509,
-1.0938975811004639,
1.1704719066619873,
0.6956142783164978,
-0.05176357924938202,
-0.8899426460266113,
-0.4523806869983673,
-0.7153741121292114,
-0.854669451713562,
0.5923097729682922,
-0.11286170780658722,
-0.26054924726486206,
0.21315838396549225,
-0.4902721345424652,
-0.774380624294281,
0.7318159937858582,
0.5928092002868652,
-1.1324760913848877,
-0.015178915113210678,
-0.0005943434662185609,
0.5622890591621399,
-0.5609861016273499,
-0.2837996780872345,
0.5019261240959167,
0.3551657199859619,
-0.27205848693847656,
-1.0348535776138306,
-0.17344515025615692,
-0.4199222922325134,
0.010618352331221104,
0.3520190715789795,
-0.36151817440986633,
0.9321244359016418,
-0.09340132772922516,
-0.1547289788722992,
0.1829865425825119,
0.5964986681938171,
0.1532585173845291,
-0.0759318545460701,
0.5054919719696045,
0.5244711637496948,
0.6908302307128906,
0.06479430198669434,
1.020147681236267,
-0.651360809803009,
0.2453494518995285,
1.2964646816253662,
-0.2696281969547272,
1.0575487613677979,
0.4052855670452118,
-0.2311159372329712,
0.5033840537071228,
0.5089328289031982,
0.18096275627613068,
0.5465330481529236,
0.03820861876010895,
-0.23368807137012482,
-0.6188768148422241,
0.4307708740234375,
-0.41043004393577576,
0.2654053866863251,
0.39182940125465393,
-0.3485507667064667,
-0.11235247552394867,
0.3643437623977661,
-0.18209989368915558,
0.36053159832954407,
-0.7022169828414917,
0.7969868183135986,
-0.1358257532119751,
-0.36844491958618164,
0.46225228905677795,
-0.03469139710068703,
0.6313698887825012,
-0.7072641253471375,
0.24700048565864563,
-0.04208345338702202,
0.28497233986854553,
-0.04692305251955986,
-0.6037255525588989,
0.0109991654753685,
0.027111327275633812,
-0.324077844619751,
-0.26990050077438354,
0.8704372048377991,
-0.6713778972625732,
-0.8068013787269592,
0.14173832535743713,
0.5563744306564331,
0.11189394444227219,
-0.02416352368891239,
-0.5191618800163269,
0.29182618856430054,
-0.037476252764463425,
-0.3030695617198944,
0.39967018365859985,
0.2985574007034302,
-0.16132554411888123,
0.36571940779685974,
0.5685323476791382,
0.4045862555503845,
0.20094987750053406,
0.11421216279268265,
0.8531429171562195,
-0.43096214532852173,
-0.5910232067108154,
-0.8023245334625244,
0.4610118269920349,
-0.032992299646139145,
-0.15951846539974213,
0.7184990644454956,
0.6306209564208984,
1.1118378639221191,
-0.4661177098751068,
0.8161198496818542,
0.09388451278209686,
0.7266514301300049,
-0.6883454918861389,
0.7494475245475769,
-0.32770484685897827,
0.12076252698898315,
-0.25832176208496094,
-0.768799364566803,
-0.29934754967689514,
0.6843194961547852,
-0.4166179597377777,
-0.12192443013191223,
0.5024362802505493,
0.6222273111343384,
-0.0758962482213974,
0.0016959412023425102,
0.4852519929409027,
0.3750876188278198,
0.12180013954639435,
0.6239057779312134,
0.8095994591712952,
-0.41547560691833496,
0.2897484302520752,
-0.28435438871383667,
-0.25416088104248047,
0.11732891201972961,
-0.99840247631073,
-0.8801114559173584,
-0.4462587535381317,
-0.05461740866303444,
-0.19843080639839172,
0.3086628019809723,
1.1496907472610474,
0.5634425282478333,
-0.9592120051383972,
-0.29959210753440857,
-0.28532275557518005,
-0.29303035140037537,
0.1724289059638977,
-0.06401805579662323,
0.31508535146713257,
-0.7406802177429199,
-0.6543749570846558,
0.6637609004974365,
0.23585273325443268,
-0.016361167654395103,
0.03614407032728195,
-0.2543187439441681,
0.0012531044194474816,
-0.14270251989364624,
0.9745904803276062,
0.04417605325579643,
-0.493779718875885,
-0.26835089921951294,
0.06699204444885254,
0.056290220469236374,
0.1808357685804367,
0.8350416421890259,
-0.5701014995574951,
0.5478604435920715,
0.3837184011936188,
0.5326685309410095,
0.6195685267448425,
-0.2611873745918274,
0.7523398995399475,
-0.5100876092910767,
0.31641238927841187,
0.0989932268857956,
0.3285103440284729,
0.43800416588783264,
-0.21217404305934906,
0.23067162930965424,
0.016427526250481606,
-0.37039995193481445,
-0.9351949095726013,
0.18371416628360748,
-0.8518630266189575,
-0.3846762776374817,
0.8297262787818909,
-0.23879405856132507,
-0.23761698603630066,
-0.1358918994665146,
-0.1854705959558487,
0.10794879496097565,
-0.1070028692483902,
0.5664923191070557,
0.9165443778038025,
0.014183525927364826,
-0.16589771211147308,
-0.6395497918128967,
0.6130863428115845,
0.06773742288351059,
-0.9151139855384827,
0.5316504240036011,
0.3825269043445587,
0.7107604742050171,
-0.043291423469781876,
0.9531652331352234,
-0.34539559483528137,
0.39928990602493286,
0.02263202890753746,
0.2529629170894623,
-0.3199487328529358,
-0.3984609544277191,
-0.4478634297847748,
0.1844530552625656,
0.5291521549224854,
0.28088968992233276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09748v1 | Model Compression and Efficient Inference for Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-15T06:58:30 | 2024-02-15T06:58:30 | Wenxiao Wang, Wei Chen, Yicong Luo, Yongliu Long, Zhengkai Lin, Liye Zhang, Binbin Lin, Deng Cai, Xiaofei He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PF | Transformer based large language models have achieved tremendous success.
However, the significant memory and computational costs incurred during the
inference process make it challenging to deploy large models on
resource-constrained devices. In this paper, we investigate compression and
efficient inference methods for large language models from an algorithmic
perspective. Regarding taxonomy, similar to smaller models, compression and
acceleration algorithms for large language models can still be categorized into
quantization, pruning, distillation, compact architecture design, dynamic
networks. However, Large language models have two prominent characteristics
compared to smaller models: (1) Most of compression algorithms require
finetuning or even retraining the model after compression. The most notable
aspect of large models is the very high cost associated with model finetuning
or training. Therefore, many algorithms for large models, such as quantization
and pruning, start to explore tuning-free algorithms. (2) Large models
emphasize versatility and generalization rather than performance on a single
task. Hence, many algorithms, such as knowledge distillation, focus on how to
preserving their versatility and generalization after compression. Since these
two characteristics were not very pronounced in early large models, we further
distinguish large language models into medium models and ``real'' large models.
Additionally, we also provide an introduction to some mature frameworks for
efficient inference of large models, which can support basic compression or
acceleration algorithms, greatly facilitating model deployment for users. | [
-0.3661627471446991,
-0.7597678899765015,
0.5799346566200256,
0.22061023116111755,
-0.11457543075084686,
-0.06534655392169952,
-0.5298863649368286,
-0.4408782124519348,
0.10685615241527557,
0.42761650681495667,
-0.5090315341949463,
-0.1253736913204193,
-0.557119607925415,
-0.1485988348722458,
-0.5558223724365234,
0.5183601379394531,
0.21816039085388184,
-0.07229848206043243,
-0.11680860072374344,
-0.025860494002699852,
-0.4940375089645386,
-0.6267143487930298,
-0.5981899499893188,
-0.30401918292045593,
0.26425445079803467,
0.03795773163437843,
0.7725810408592224,
0.905475378036499,
0.3322638273239136,
0.43587175011634827,
-0.42525771260261536,
0.048912860453128815,
-0.35513266921043396,
0.23918648064136505,
-0.0477985143661499,
-0.48556578159332275,
-0.07041919976472855,
-0.16246749460697174,
0.6990857124328613,
0.8874402046203613,
-0.30894356966018677,
0.3217819929122925,
-0.009873773902654648,
0.6153513789176941,
-0.7634950876235962,
0.17707760632038116,
-0.5449517369270325,
-0.07365301251411438,
-0.03913140296936035,
0.11090465635061264,
-0.5590725541114807,
-0.2861098349094391,
-0.03099728189408779,
-0.4236949384212494,
0.3166147470474243,
0.14963489770889282,
0.6024177670478821,
0.4634326994419098,
-0.43531090021133423,
-0.25244179368019104,
-1.2071506977081299,
1.115412950515747,
-0.7800150513648987,
0.5632003545761108,
0.20554019510746002,
0.4702158272266388,
-0.005733633413910866,
-0.9643345475196838,
-0.680780827999115,
-0.19338715076446533,
-0.022323232144117355,
-0.23437584936618805,
-0.44022515416145325,
0.24927690625190735,
0.5753782391548157,
0.6615272760391235,
-0.37468183040618896,
0.5520485639572144,
-0.11562173068523407,
-0.07781240344047546,
0.5960466265678406,
-0.03507151082158089,
0.07039529830217361,
0.07294172048568726,
-0.04313163459300995,
-0.3620215058326721,
-0.7012906670570374,
-0.27105778455734253,
0.4871865212917328,
0.14975954592227936,
0.019453130662441254,
0.39311107993125916,
-0.29238441586494446,
0.9289979338645935,
-0.253212034702301,
-0.27191635966300964,
0.09168986231088638,
-0.25584039092063904,
-0.28719016909599304,
-0.24220946431159973,
0.7579042315483093,
0.04437188431620598,
0.3152657449245453,
-0.224218487739563,
-0.41630351543426514,
0.062488362193107605,
0.1418936550617218,
-1.0387710332870483,
-0.3166046440601349,
0.25019147992134094,
-0.7248114347457886,
-0.08364760875701904,
-0.12532009184360504,
-0.9096919894218445,
-0.32849037647247314,
-0.3408105671405792,
0.41106116771698,
-0.23078107833862305,
-0.37117332220077515,
0.33314719796180725,
-0.08505186438560486,
0.16905702650547028,
0.1293606460094452,
-1.103458285331726,
0.3982812166213989,
0.9066348671913147,
0.8631221652030945,
0.19110271334648132,
0.061393145471811295,
-0.5143219232559204,
-0.25708794593811035,
-0.12460369616746902,
0.5923482775688171,
-0.47710564732551575,
-0.16132479906082153,
0.03377290815114975,
-0.07943855971097946,
0.03431298956274986,
-0.5953889489173889,
0.7684413194656372,
-0.7725037336349487,
0.0023168146144598722,
0.00633552111685276,
-0.8136408925056458,
-0.4298928380012512,
-0.07924366742372513,
-0.9885069131851196,
0.5631283521652222,
0.06192528456449509,
-0.6336020827293396,
-0.004854234401136637,
-0.5520402789115906,
-0.4764955937862396,
-0.06008048355579376,
0.049093954265117645,
-0.30260372161865234,
0.5182153582572937,
0.13136503100395203,
0.5362216234207153,
-0.8335136771202087,
0.49705770611763,
-0.26587966084480286,
-0.29484832286834717,
0.12457022070884705,
-0.7835288643836975,
0.7280406951904297,
0.5255998373031616,
-0.16210219264030457,
0.03756899759173393,
-0.6005250215530396,
-0.03734995052218437,
0.2537972033023834,
-0.16418170928955078,
-0.40017667412757874,
0.30920448899269104,
0.01982211135327816,
-0.05067383497953415,
0.09353738278150558,
-0.37417230010032654,
0.624597430229187,
-0.33205485343933105,
0.8179396390914917,
0.4889599084854126,
-0.11159905791282654,
0.4495554268360138,
0.08818753063678741,
0.5779673457145691,
-0.24780207872390747,
0.11739082634449005,
-0.15966373682022095,
-0.3194006681442261,
-0.6268543004989624,
-0.32892876863479614,
0.8167099952697754,
0.4663965106010437,
-0.7643976211547852,
0.491601824760437,
-0.566143810749054,
-0.5759871602058411,
-0.4051152765750885,
-0.053315456956624985,
0.31426602602005005,
0.1367720067501068,
0.20438221096992493,
0.027469592168927193,
-0.3335915505886078,
-0.9723137617111206,
-0.08013583719730377,
-0.11953702569007874,
-0.3484782874584198,
0.15526331961154938,
0.3361930251121521,
0.023552032187581062,
0.6915688514709473,
-0.7427852153778076,
0.37787219882011414,
-0.3240223824977875,
0.20059774816036224,
0.3855345547199249,
0.6047375798225403,
0.5746316313743591,
-1.0264102220535278,
-0.16398406028747559,
-0.2031196653842926,
-0.3548647165298462,
-0.24802623689174652,
-0.05668392777442932,
0.2450931966304779,
-0.07863103598356247,
0.46282944083213806,
-0.6998898983001709,
0.14153282344341278,
0.9079861044883728,
-0.05400095507502556,
0.7544386982917786,
-0.20322978496551514,
-0.07484044134616852,
-0.9786338210105896,
0.08136072754859924,
-0.010782584547996521,
-0.23703965544700623,
-0.8115661144256592,
0.28959017992019653,
0.009109122678637505,
-0.066796213388443,
-0.2874433994293213,
0.610072135925293,
-0.5603064298629761,
-0.02121163345873356,
-0.26827359199523926,
-0.21686720848083496,
0.003860252443701029,
0.411029577255249,
0.2420063465833664,
0.7049665451049805,
0.6736958026885986,
-0.6837663054466248,
0.45421791076660156,
-0.0013618827797472477,
-0.6756584644317627,
0.05620289966464043,
-0.841505765914917,
0.0032381045166403055,
-0.11608435213565826,
0.2090037763118744,
-0.8043104410171509,
-0.12948809564113617,
-0.12679728865623474,
0.019417766481637955,
0.4684429168701172,
-0.3226603865623474,
-0.7623024582862854,
-0.5384402275085449,
-0.1338692158460617,
0.6185321807861328,
0.7913614511489868,
-0.6522584557533264,
0.6260577440261841,
0.3746907413005829,
0.0939982458949089,
-0.4541510343551636,
-0.5228402018547058,
-0.054735589772462845,
-0.5499895215034485,
-0.49437832832336426,
0.3140289783477783,
-0.14107657968997955,
-0.3623179495334625,
-0.05519932508468628,
-0.055870167911052704,
-0.22970828413963318,
0.21145564317703247,
0.053258784115314484,
0.057684946805238724,
-0.2962630093097687,
0.3529079854488373,
0.02994120679795742,
0.028343016281723976,
-0.12911279499530792,
-0.5000682473182678,
0.7910892963409424,
-0.02402891218662262,
-0.2589360475540161,
-0.4561294913291931,
0.2736877202987671,
0.6810880899429321,
-0.32838088274002075,
1.0038862228393555,
0.48564013838768005,
-0.2625999450683594,
-0.22462978959083557,
-0.7803949117660522,
-0.21089676022529602,
-0.44475147128105164,
0.3146767318248749,
-0.38668084144592285,
-0.9938717484474182,
0.5558714270591736,
-0.4180780053138733,
0.1675599217414856,
0.5840291976928711,
0.5532931089401245,
0.36181244254112244,
1.1152725219726562,
0.6348942518234253,
-0.22968000173568726,
0.5723674297332764,
-0.38903483748435974,
0.2838614583015442,
-0.5996221303939819,
0.21284472942352295,
-0.9545837640762329,
-0.45354336500167847,
-0.6488646268844604,
-0.43157345056533813,
0.08103679120540619,
0.23343639075756073,
-0.19456565380096436,
0.38069722056388855,
-0.5581059455871582,
0.4864276647567749,
0.6158061027526855,
-0.17100831866264343,
0.246226966381073,
0.09493189305067062,
0.27324041724205017,
0.31385329365730286,
-0.9539675116539001,
-0.2655971646308899,
0.8059510588645935,
0.5186333060264587,
0.8352997899055481,
0.22699274122714996,
0.35085952281951904,
0.015132199972867966,
0.13239909708499908,
-1.0765072107315063,
0.385336309671402,
-0.3288988769054413,
-0.4896334111690521,
-0.2844254672527313,
-0.8714905977249146,
-0.8990321159362793,
0.17000870406627655,
-0.26428940892219543,
-0.7956117987632751,
0.3882087767124176,
0.3058169484138489,
-0.41032856702804565,
0.44983288645744324,
-0.9734646677970886,
0.9002715349197388,
-0.09161471575498581,
-0.16053082048892975,
-0.36927229166030884,
-0.5509473085403442,
0.5588017106056213,
-0.2725253105163574,
0.24479109048843384,
0.1921955794095993,
0.17375192046165466,
0.8061327934265137,
-0.5441179871559143,
0.7343986630439758,
-0.21390078961849213,
-0.06776656955480576,
0.3541333079338074,
0.24144482612609863,
0.5196345448493958,
-0.2963034212589264,
-0.23406314849853516,
0.21433871984481812,
0.23795099556446075,
-0.26830604672431946,
-0.9028555750846863,
0.44559797644615173,
-0.5045374035835266,
-0.6002432703971863,
0.14457163214683533,
-0.5324232578277588,
-0.21068722009658813,
0.12007748335599899,
0.260704904794693,
0.7079378962516785,
0.09084131568670273,
0.4635174870491028,
0.6919145584106445,
-0.38179507851600647,
0.48243048787117004,
0.262988418340683,
-0.13464723527431488,
-0.11308084428310394,
0.8095274567604065,
0.06878918409347534,
0.37797310948371887,
0.5250064730644226,
0.4560537040233612,
-0.4120919704437256,
-0.86138916015625,
-0.34364649653434753,
0.33686140179634094,
-0.4015098810195923,
-0.35891857743263245,
-0.46219196915626526,
-0.1870703548192978,
-0.39236345887184143,
0.17033226788043976,
-0.6073687672615051,
-0.6033494472503662,
-0.02816995233297348,
0.1950947791337967,
0.2860945165157318,
0.5392351150512695,
0.1467224359512329,
0.6594036817550659,
-0.9273714423179626,
0.26421037316322327,
0.2700751721858978,
0.3773006796836853,
0.36571288108825684,
-0.5435507893562317,
-0.2832225263118744,
0.07561980187892914,
-0.20687320828437805,
-0.7333902716636658,
0.29266175627708435,
0.4013872444629669,
0.39480310678482056,
0.6959203481674194,
0.21361614763736725,
0.6060410141944885,
-0.5461437106132507,
0.7752857804298401,
0.02708612009882927,
-0.9398528337478638,
0.17990198731422424,
0.08419980853796005,
0.3116300106048584,
0.2915799021720886,
0.4308289587497711,
-0.5465474724769592,
0.029315827414393425,
-0.6595258712768555,
-0.739365816116333,
0.3777332007884979,
0.04999812692403793,
0.35056766867637634,
0.015249812975525856,
0.47216665744781494,
-0.06149233505129814,
0.28295278549194336,
-0.5823025107383728,
-0.0899030864238739,
0.07868238538503647,
-0.2239800989627838,
-0.2150023728609085,
-0.5170475840568542,
0.017553633078932762,
-0.09977342933416367,
0.5753926038742065,
-0.10639729350805283,
0.22193264961242676,
-0.17136260867118835,
-0.10179325193166733,
0.26990222930908203,
0.2822748124599457,
0.4523537755012512,
0.41789013147354126,
0.13562071323394775,
0.22216582298278809,
-0.0653807669878006,
-0.25287798047065735,
0.18291744589805603,
0.14435702562332153,
-0.08555241674184799,
-0.2138930857181549,
0.5525330901145935,
1.1130614280700684,
0.1067536324262619,
-0.7645231485366821,
0.4790456295013428,
-0.17561495304107666,
-0.12162964046001434,
-0.0416220985352993,
0.10455583781003952,
0.09002131968736649,
0.41923391819000244,
0.1511368453502655,
-0.2839401960372925,
0.2252054214477539,
-0.3751690089702606,
-0.22646750509738922,
0.5822147130966187,
0.03315093740820885,
-0.3251549005508423,
0.5975232124328613,
-0.052508629858493805,
-0.2721134126186371,
0.8199479579925537,
-0.18995927274227142,
-0.4664437770843506,
0.4227031171321869,
0.5263880491256714,
0.8443440794944763,
-0.38486677408218384,
-0.0887741968035698,
0.3927753269672394,
0.12340275198221207,
-0.663420557975769,
-0.20373986661434174,
-0.26098185777664185,
-0.7496317625045776,
-1.0061733722686768,
-0.960469663143158,
-0.17959259450435638,
0.1689377725124359,
-0.4443657696247101,
0.02606506086885929,
-0.1404999941587448,
-0.10433228313922882,
0.19904160499572754,
-0.060058195143938065,
-0.46258869767189026,
0.07364771515130997,
0.1725287288427353,
1.230073094367981,
-0.8859787583351135,
0.8687391877174377,
0.29474374651908875,
-0.0007517096237279475,
-1.0960172414779663,
-0.15292391180992126,
-0.1283126324415207,
-0.4346503019332886,
0.6330927610397339,
0.1086253747344017,
0.044939447194337845,
0.14638911187648773,
-0.4291307032108307,
-0.7416231036186218,
0.7882633805274963,
0.5738193988800049,
-0.7348201274871826,
-0.2587471604347229,
-0.17138704657554626,
0.5668776035308838,
-0.0962841808795929,
0.1335381120443344,
0.5635783672332764,
0.4673178791999817,
0.3276875913143158,
-0.9823178648948669,
-0.01232535857707262,
-0.08276114612817764,
0.23304963111877441,
0.5071960091590881,
-0.3752478063106537,
0.7702136039733887,
0.15655827522277832,
-0.31722861528396606,
0.26002073287963867,
0.6717503070831299,
-0.024478698149323463,
-0.11454375088214874,
0.8329530954360962,
0.5862611532211304,
0.7603986263275146,
-0.05876007676124573,
1.1574029922485352,
-0.40792426466941833,
0.5368070006370544,
0.8733265995979309,
-0.15087802708148956,
0.7731195092201233,
0.3463931977748871,
-0.30465948581695557,
0.32158395648002625,
0.5182920694351196,
-0.11608819663524628,
0.23832480609416962,
0.3699342906475067,
-0.3237681984901428,
-0.25167587399482727,
0.003640678245574236,
-0.21597255766391754,
0.6419343948364258,
0.22340542078018188,
-0.40082770586013794,
-0.11641915142536163,
-0.000908537651412189,
0.0035944078117609024,
-0.1811646968126297,
-0.2962576746940613,
0.7161842584609985,
-0.0719374269247055,
-0.8635270595550537,
0.7668097019195557,
0.181197389960289,
0.536204993724823,
-0.5745150446891785,
0.037370000034570694,
-0.020131263881921768,
0.010797190479934216,
-0.049210503697395325,
-0.5220500230789185,
0.3871923089027405,
-0.12252694368362427,
-0.24088053405284882,
-0.24063414335250854,
0.6452720165252686,
-0.32158392667770386,
-0.46748101711273193,
-0.009165129624307156,
0.45213866233825684,
0.27068468928337097,
-0.4202251434326172,
-0.29984337091445923,
0.1728345900774002,
-0.014827494509518147,
-0.5534080266952515,
0.16523590683937073,
0.221541166305542,
-0.1783011257648468,
0.778544008731842,
0.5797434449195862,
0.3515242636203766,
-0.05629131942987442,
0.11676149070262909,
0.7338520884513855,
-0.3811120390892029,
-0.4650064706802368,
-0.9729058742523193,
0.29849737882614136,
0.04269954562187195,
0.2776429057121277,
0.5013787746429443,
0.40057483315467834,
0.4006494879722595,
-0.18996210396289825,
0.39848756790161133,
-0.1649629920721054,
0.30630865693092346,
-0.8162270188331604,
0.5230476260185242,
-0.5752554535865784,
0.23161537945270538,
-0.0776340663433075,
-1.117017149925232,
-0.4606020152568817,
0.4927479922771454,
-0.47155362367630005,
0.074409119784832,
0.4116213321685791,
0.7401505708694458,
-0.3095908463001251,
0.049520380795001984,
0.2418173998594284,
0.31092721223831177,
0.39144954085350037,
0.4257999062538147,
0.5740542411804199,
-0.13453197479248047,
0.3433949053287506,
-0.36337679624557495,
-0.37019991874694824,
-0.16851848363876343,
-1.0937392711639404,
-0.44271981716156006,
-0.6921878457069397,
-0.24966412782669067,
-0.14257220923900604,
-0.31704631447792053,
0.7616258263587952,
1.0261176824569702,
-0.6299448013305664,
-0.16683094203472137,
-0.16535039246082306,
0.19990643858909607,
-0.4097244441509247,
-0.17744022607803345,
0.47716158628463745,
-0.05330239608883858,
-0.9929827451705933,
0.3110644817352295,
-0.13229183852672577,
-0.05822937190532684,
-0.37532925605773926,
0.17121848464012146,
0.06622648984193802,
0.04815683513879776,
0.7150785326957703,
0.4646182060241699,
-0.43685728311538696,
-0.27394747734069824,
-0.2141755074262619,
0.33258262276649475,
-0.18129990994930267,
1.0093940496444702,
-0.7852816581726074,
0.2772741913795471,
0.5629894733428955,
0.7876111268997192,
0.5360731482505798,
0.07525297999382019,
0.5452970266342163,
-0.7197160124778748,
0.44272732734680176,
0.10076314955949783,
0.5329927206039429,
0.23498141765594482,
-0.1172543317079544,
0.46884119510650635,
0.17713133990764618,
-0.7190977334976196,
-1.0050052404403687,
0.5849547386169434,
-0.7994301319122314,
-0.469280481338501,
1.13383948802948,
-0.13870716094970703,
-0.31519144773483276,
0.2982126772403717,
-0.10182521492242813,
0.38113412261009216,
0.09491194039583206,
0.6360517144203186,
0.6406660079956055,
-0.0019268397009000182,
-0.2807404398918152,
-0.7187705636024475,
0.277492493391037,
0.2083609700202942,
-0.6051040887832642,
0.4487425982952118,
0.6370577216148376,
0.08974277228116989,
0.35142725706100464,
0.0056120664812624454,
0.1597277969121933,
-0.06998588889837265,
0.0874362513422966,
0.1502426117658615,
-0.062588632106781,
-0.31925681233406067,
-0.5587274432182312,
0.35728520154953003,
0.12933355569839478,
0.04296521842479706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09742v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09742v4 | AI Hospital: Benchmarking Large Language Models in a Multi-agent Medical Interaction Simulator | 2024-02-15T06:46:48 | 2024-06-28T03:11:48 | Zhihao Fan, Jialong Tang, Wei Chen, Siyuan Wang, Zhongyu Wei, Jun Xi, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial intelligence has significantly advanced healthcare, particularly
through large language models (LLMs) that excel in medical question answering
benchmarks. However, their real-world clinical application remains limited due
to the complexities of doctor-patient interactions. To address this, we
introduce \textbf{AI Hospital}, a multi-agent framework simulating dynamic
medical interactions between \emph{Doctor} as player and NPCs including
\emph{Patient}, \emph{Examiner}, \emph{Chief Physician}. This setup allows for
realistic assessments of LLMs in clinical scenarios. We develop the Multi-View
Medical Evaluation (MVME) benchmark, utilizing high-quality Chinese medical
records and NPCs to evaluate LLMs' performance in symptom collection,
examination recommendations, and diagnoses. Additionally, a dispute resolution
collaborative mechanism is proposed to enhance diagnostic accuracy through
iterative discussions. Despite improvements, current LLMs exhibit significant
performance gaps in multi-turn interactions compared to one-step approaches.
Our findings highlight the need for further research to bridge these gaps and
improve LLMs' clinical diagnostic capabilities. Our data, code, and
experimental results are all open-sourced at
\url{https://github.com/LibertFan/AI_Hospital}. | [
-0.17748971283435822,
-0.7392244935035706,
1.0729775428771973,
0.12476568669080734,
-0.07536319643259048,
0.022998660802841187,
-0.17370429635047913,
-0.7117473483085632,
0.1561519354581833,
0.38872581720352173,
-0.23611591756343842,
-0.44585901498794556,
-0.5175579190254211,
0.23079551756381989,
-0.21909645199775696,
0.5098069310188293,
-0.14248314499855042,
0.6324498653411865,
-0.6719173192977905,
-0.32570603489875793,
-0.1808643639087677,
-0.6868680119514465,
-1.0696567296981812,
-0.5173459053039551,
0.43763798475265503,
0.16948361694812775,
0.7873811721801758,
0.8334549069404602,
0.8333253860473633,
0.4527537524700165,
0.3850017488002777,
0.1815357655286789,
-0.10479745268821716,
0.37543365359306335,
0.1754966527223587,
-0.10874353349208832,
-0.6705089807510376,
-0.2203740030527115,
0.7618401050567627,
0.5921392440795898,
-0.29577162861824036,
-0.10289398580789566,
-0.4178377687931061,
0.363065630197525,
-0.4346531629562378,
0.26245632767677307,
-0.07375084608793259,
-0.05277998372912407,
0.04507480189204216,
-0.1112513616681099,
-0.2530912458896637,
-0.22940777242183685,
0.2929743826389313,
-0.36788275837898254,
-0.09561897814273834,
0.006532478611916304,
0.9604237079620361,
0.5005956888198853,
-0.6180661916732788,
0.06261325627565384,
-0.6204913258552551,
0.3746791183948517,
-0.8511350750923157,
0.26030537486076355,
0.24858000874519348,
0.648905336856842,
-0.09604229032993317,
-0.8388659954071045,
-0.5009688138961792,
-0.7182074189186096,
-0.02828769013285637,
0.24704012274742126,
-0.059777453541755676,
0.18511615693569183,
0.12984822690486908,
0.18965812027454376,
-0.4838455021381378,
0.17553474009037018,
0.025852983817458153,
0.07847850769758224,
0.6399387121200562,
0.5511911511421204,
0.5874056816101074,
0.14150825142860413,
-0.41851943731307983,
-0.07900777459144592,
-0.5734278559684753,
-0.1466384083032608,
-0.29360613226890564,
-0.13450412452220917,
-0.17490734159946442,
0.34039822220802307,
0.011841378174722195,
0.31783774495124817,
-0.29173171520233154,
-0.2635744512081146,
0.4720151722431183,
-0.2100595235824585,
-0.26628953218460083,
-0.006813753396272659,
0.9769130945205688,
0.5164288878440857,
0.13255098462104797,
-0.2715146839618683,
-0.17637570202350616,
0.18820607662200928,
0.6705189347267151,
-0.7653272151947021,
-0.2918620705604553,
0.5191020369529724,
-0.5556834936141968,
-0.23101307451725006,
-0.27660468220710754,
-0.7060912251472473,
-0.9297885894775391,
-0.21382515132427216,
0.3013859689235687,
-0.41758987307548523,
-0.4538074731826782,
-0.06758375465869904,
0.17680571973323822,
0.20374618470668793,
0.5080474019050598,
-0.42956650257110596,
0.5388072729110718,
0.6339964270591736,
0.6560909152030945,
-0.32801929116249084,
-0.5363254547119141,
-0.7926977872848511,
0.08815063536167145,
-0.34761345386505127,
0.7861667275428772,
-0.3628951609134674,
-0.448541522026062,
0.015609963797032833,
-0.2408088594675064,
-0.19718261063098907,
-0.983159065246582,
0.23480461537837982,
-0.06849133968353271,
-0.06265170127153397,
0.178133025765419,
-0.39235934615135193,
0.152601957321167,
0.6923127174377441,
-0.686678409576416,
0.5007632374763489,
0.3331630527973175,
-0.2573925256729126,
0.1329161375761032,
-0.7005616426467896,
-0.5491909980773926,
0.2157677710056305,
-0.585580587387085,
-0.622749924659729,
0.04544484242796898,
0.31223851442337036,
0.21977196633815765,
-0.6322525143623352,
0.48111429810523987,
-0.1607840657234192,
-0.38659223914146423,
0.2809275686740875,
-0.3446577191352844,
0.513224184513092,
0.08411921560764313,
-0.11382252722978592,
0.5307769775390625,
-0.8777065277099609,
-0.06941510736942291,
0.28222721815109253,
-0.3289988934993744,
-0.15486088395118713,
0.24333323538303375,
0.08933819085359573,
0.21120624244213104,
0.1210501566529274,
-0.1317121535539627,
0.37510836124420166,
-0.3531471788883209,
0.2473757565021515,
0.25800955295562744,
0.14894519746303558,
0.08024744689464569,
-0.7406291961669922,
0.8618650436401367,
0.2104491889476776,
0.4356880187988281,
-0.11692242324352264,
-0.49015405774116516,
-0.49571239948272705,
-0.4814092516899109,
0.2334510087966919,
0.53984135389328,
-0.8649699687957764,
-0.06004417687654495,
-0.12903934717178345,
-0.387034147977829,
-0.9299933314323425,
-0.48043888807296753,
0.3490007221698761,
0.5972338914871216,
0.37222355604171753,
-0.3844343423843384,
-0.24376654624938965,
-0.82005774974823,
0.005191469565033913,
-0.4717947542667389,
-0.09243036061525345,
0.6822503805160522,
0.20007430016994476,
-0.6502360105514526,
0.45922401547431946,
-0.11697442084550858,
-0.34777745604515076,
-0.24245105683803558,
0.05004308745265007,
0.14082016050815582,
0.41929861903190613,
0.8111032247543335,
-0.5697730183601379,
-0.30537641048431396,
0.0020386443939059973,
-0.9342781901359558,
-0.18109163641929626,
-0.14011678099632263,
0.13065195083618164,
0.19974097609519958,
0.41836851835250854,
-0.5676870942115784,
0.3678835332393646,
0.7386884689331055,
-0.22534896433353424,
0.6062605977058411,
-0.537047803401947,
0.6340824961662292,
-1.2680341005325317,
0.10885593295097351,
-0.043670181185007095,
-0.33925849199295044,
-0.6225241422653198,
0.3832572400569916,
-0.1159290000796318,
-0.10907452553510666,
-0.4596201479434967,
0.7155373096466064,
-0.4168975353240967,
-0.028426965698599815,
-0.29465988278388977,
0.09574564546346664,
-0.018891453742980957,
0.07646381855010986,
0.04582688957452774,
0.7362532019615173,
0.6798464059829712,
-0.3937564194202423,
0.5572755336761475,
0.01613902673125267,
-0.22235587239265442,
0.7351248264312744,
-0.6277096271514893,
0.013085516169667244,
0.21489611268043518,
0.17574699223041534,
-0.676606297492981,
-0.2824060022830963,
0.21977730095386505,
-0.35182470083236694,
0.10029631853103638,
-0.12441027164459229,
-0.9034384489059448,
-0.2423418015241623,
-0.21784257888793945,
0.6214085817337036,
0.37850648164749146,
-0.32218948006629944,
0.899127721786499,
0.503426730632782,
-0.18352438509464264,
-0.33390262722969055,
-0.44956907629966736,
0.4457774758338928,
-0.06526197493076324,
-0.41665756702423096,
0.02175655961036682,
-0.11181851476430893,
-0.5418847799301147,
0.02571781538426876,
0.25962403416633606,
-0.48538196086883545,
0.29714444279670715,
0.22024352848529816,
0.4954931139945984,
-0.5689886212348938,
0.2447156310081482,
0.026941241696476936,
-0.10940534621477127,
0.385968416929245,
0.18337410688400269,
0.680675745010376,
-0.2766963541507721,
-0.6763248443603516,
-0.47333264350891113,
0.5010994672775269,
0.9435341358184814,
-0.23999974131584167,
0.622044026851654,
0.22889739274978638,
-0.7052391171455383,
0.25452256202697754,
-0.4733828008174896,
-0.12253425270318985,
-0.40553173422813416,
0.5861281752586365,
-0.2985233664512634,
-0.4996166229248047,
0.5976377725601196,
-0.5618090033531189,
0.06463058292865753,
0.3529435098171234,
0.858074426651001,
-0.08902814984321594,
1.1857537031173706,
0.26118800044059753,
-0.15092593431472778,
-0.1042676642537117,
0.15952271223068237,
0.13774676620960236,
-0.6191062927246094,
-0.2715021073818207,
-0.5435919761657715,
-0.22493767738342285,
-0.6368707418441772,
-0.6161676645278931,
0.960689902305603,
-0.2065851390361786,
-0.1821681261062622,
-0.11504897475242615,
-0.25240951776504517,
0.3209919333457947,
0.37353917956352234,
0.012379658408463001,
0.5180843472480774,
-0.5673090219497681,
-0.22064131498336792,
0.1316405087709427,
-0.6868624687194824,
-0.28328096866607666,
0.6992498636245728,
0.45136526226997375,
0.7208155989646912,
0.14186999201774597,
0.7531845569610596,
0.033899519592523575,
0.4132491648197174,
-0.6854373216629028,
0.3792753517627716,
-0.1948602944612503,
-0.3615766763687134,
-0.0767829567193985,
-0.4477176070213318,
-1.0392475128173828,
0.3392774164676666,
-0.5333297252655029,
-0.5460238456726074,
-0.06970295310020447,
0.14199061691761017,
-0.40583115816116333,
0.2714829444885254,
-0.7110824584960938,
0.8961251378059387,
-0.5355870723724365,
-0.1591346710920334,
-0.3963872790336609,
-0.6704220175743103,
0.037071336060762405,
-0.0010095949983224273,
0.1800033301115036,
-0.03493403270840645,
0.03578419238328934,
0.031176747754216194,
-0.4181387722492218,
0.5197634100914001,
-0.011671904474496841,
0.07295335829257965,
-0.2521447539329529,
0.10026978701353073,
0.15951676666736603,
0.38349953293800354,
-0.12612394988536835,
0.4455776512622833,
0.1347718983888626,
-0.35389789938926697,
-0.36769306659698486,
0.795198917388916,
-0.9707064032554626,
-0.3633832037448883,
-0.7150328159332275,
-0.6927306652069092,
-0.6334133744239807,
0.3087327182292938,
-0.07612565904855728,
0.5831282138824463,
-0.4527398943901062,
-0.11743852496147156,
0.28383713960647583,
-0.45315295457839966,
0.014879927970468998,
0.6335607171058655,
-0.25819483399391174,
-0.21311424672603607,
0.6346318125724792,
-0.3549153208732605,
-0.016692765057086945,
0.30730265378952026,
0.4048077166080475,
-0.1264224350452423,
-0.6888744831085205,
-0.8683412075042725,
0.23471742868423462,
-0.4024524986743927,
-0.11620215326547623,
-0.6421074867248535,
-0.6454067230224609,
-0.43839016556739807,
-0.17317210137844086,
-0.4148384630680084,
0.22501808404922485,
0.0020439124200493097,
0.37356260418891907,
0.14137610793113708,
0.9305552244186401,
0.18888728320598602,
0.2939442992210388,
-0.8979899287223816,
0.36463505029678345,
-0.08243744820356369,
0.5608804225921631,
0.12615954875946045,
0.07710550725460052,
-0.3847614526748657,
-0.23383353650569916,
-0.012806220911443233,
-0.7406015992164612,
0.3084421455860138,
-0.1872379630804062,
0.6878576278686523,
0.6529390811920166,
0.006916619837284088,
0.6582657098770142,
-0.8935657739639282,
0.680586576461792,
0.2321508526802063,
-0.643888533115387,
0.2650684416294098,
-0.2080858200788498,
0.4348946511745453,
0.7341762781143188,
0.1469501554965973,
-0.5992459654808044,
-0.5646740794181824,
-0.5360094904899597,
-1.1759141683578491,
0.4508017301559448,
-0.0718822181224823,
-0.2593756318092346,
-0.030293943360447884,
0.35739442706108093,
-0.15483812987804413,
0.37263649702072144,
-0.3485170006752014,
-0.3898521661758423,
0.4044407904148102,
-0.44762107729911804,
-0.07428714632987976,
-0.0017729380633682013,
-0.4356032609939575,
-0.13328814506530762,
0.43736717104911804,
-0.010386177338659763,
0.4641251266002655,
0.17236490547657013,
0.12368734925985336,
-0.2529773414134979,
-0.017507152631878853,
0.5916739106178284,
0.8097783923149109,
0.030765797942876816,
0.024049004539847374,
0.15050484240055084,
-0.45441895723342896,
-0.058632977306842804,
0.5900033712387085,
0.09617677330970764,
-0.020313184708356857,
0.6061449646949768,
0.5788859724998474,
0.009319287724792957,
-1.0916717052459717,
0.60573410987854,
-0.46243980526924133,
-0.11788326501846313,
-0.40153732895851135,
0.05993955582380295,
0.12143141031265259,
0.6188695430755615,
0.039090752601623535,
0.00841703824698925,
0.32414427399635315,
-0.5215287208557129,
0.3881877064704895,
0.2720874547958374,
-0.35401058197021484,
0.12011221796274185,
0.7919944524765015,
0.27813857793807983,
-0.5383495092391968,
0.9204750061035156,
0.1185791864991188,
-0.31150293350219727,
0.9621698260307312,
0.3167266249656677,
0.7523208856582642,
-0.24872331321239471,
0.030199063941836357,
0.08262156695127487,
0.2317167967557907,
0.003625491401180625,
0.09502793103456497,
0.39884695410728455,
-0.4770793318748474,
-0.5815845727920532,
-0.1600603312253952,
-0.9857982397079468,
0.348895788192749,
-0.5096777677536011,
0.25721651315689087,
-0.3981231451034546,
-0.04009977728128433,
-0.18660910427570343,
0.06751640886068344,
-0.4613564908504486,
0.13545002043247223,
0.32599228620529175,
0.7062760591506958,
-0.48767659068107605,
0.932285726070404,
1.0337276458740234,
-0.2229706346988678,
-0.8648184537887573,
0.35642915964126587,
0.12613746523857117,
-0.9630131125450134,
-0.1881810873746872,
0.19416148960590363,
-0.0839623287320137,
-0.30263200402259827,
-0.31069639325141907,
-0.3920761048793793,
0.893161952495575,
0.37720221281051636,
-0.6436843872070312,
0.02945076674222946,
0.12898476421833038,
1.0363520383834839,
-0.6090720295906067,
0.5292584300041199,
0.4586139917373657,
0.3372151553630829,
-0.15180738270282745,
-1.1379696130752563,
0.009800213389098644,
-0.432525098323822,
-0.35855770111083984,
0.03771979734301567,
-0.7956997156143188,
0.7448344826698303,
-0.3757311701774597,
0.22390049695968628,
0.3447893559932709,
0.17566058039665222,
0.4943937361240387,
0.8127104640007019,
0.7051284909248352,
0.5202776789665222,
0.6879688501358032,
-0.11419278383255005,
1.3040615320205688,
-0.48503509163856506,
0.17340166866779327,
1.0337371826171875,
-0.7658045291900635,
0.6584033370018005,
0.3445359170436859,
-0.002292288700118661,
0.41074568033218384,
0.5116634368896484,
-0.05937545746564865,
0.2603381276130676,
0.41406500339508057,
-0.3545568883419037,
-0.12486366182565689,
-0.255550354719162,
-0.5619029998779297,
0.4252728223800659,
0.12083672732114792,
-0.16734717786312103,
-0.05065201222896576,
0.052828773856163025,
0.0887797474861145,
0.11532224714756012,
-0.112608902156353,
0.9591600894927979,
-0.00047725968761369586,
-0.5173379778862,
0.2683911919593811,
-0.056010983884334564,
0.16541674733161926,
-0.6843600869178772,
-0.32004499435424805,
-0.12726666033267975,
0.32503312826156616,
0.20190724730491638,
-0.3778781592845917,
-0.04643625020980835,
-0.13304582238197327,
-0.14238980412483215,
0.024728214368224144,
0.4013391435146332,
-0.565912663936615,
-0.35265108942985535,
0.48978930711746216,
0.7129707336425781,
0.31757020950317383,
0.07469207048416138,
-0.8676972985267639,
0.1180439218878746,
-0.5539656281471252,
-0.0007288006017915905,
0.582633376121521,
0.46779927611351013,
-0.13724283874034882,
0.6909862160682678,
0.4119996726512909,
0.5189480185508728,
-0.21533319354057312,
0.6654047966003418,
0.7971578240394592,
-0.39031845331192017,
-0.4651188552379608,
-0.8232370018959045,
0.13544662296772003,
-0.07353738695383072,
-0.40621352195739746,
0.05159943178296089,
0.5890266299247742,
0.523716926574707,
0.02291167341172695,
0.6095616817474365,
0.1496662199497223,
0.509515106678009,
-0.09974542260169983,
0.9975622892379761,
-1.0433162450790405,
0.08675579726696014,
-0.2200213521718979,
-0.3496890068054199,
-0.42899104952812195,
0.6084684729576111,
0.2186337262392044,
0.10457900166511536,
0.7394386529922485,
0.3688598871231079,
0.22778697311878204,
-0.314439058303833,
0.5508199334144592,
0.5386024713516235,
0.43787509202957153,
0.7520752549171448,
0.9680662155151367,
-0.2129717916250229,
0.21424627304077148,
-0.2557229697704315,
-0.32788991928100586,
-0.3331010937690735,
-0.5952382683753967,
-0.6979939937591553,
-0.31346961855888367,
-0.3759680688381195,
-0.500771164894104,
0.29021286964416504,
1.2336890697479248,
0.7378528118133545,
-0.7779116630554199,
-0.3345651626586914,
0.4077316224575043,
-0.041190505027770996,
-0.6682826280593872,
-0.1779700517654419,
0.45626765489578247,
0.06518591195344925,
-0.9221026301383972,
0.5170672535896301,
0.5675311088562012,
-0.12146897614002228,
-0.3179999589920044,
-0.038863714784383774,
-0.18889892101287842,
-0.09112609922885895,
0.44035351276397705,
-0.01754326932132244,
-0.5724050998687744,
-0.1302347630262375,
-0.07704225182533264,
-0.537053108215332,
0.3286629915237427,
0.8606582283973694,
-0.8293216228485107,
0.5354182720184326,
0.1245776116847992,
1.0900009870529175,
0.02035573124885559,
0.0685725063085556,
0.5074166059494019,
-0.25892508029937744,
-0.11180155724287033,
0.5401253700256348,
0.4158477187156677,
0.022580303251743317,
-0.609132707118988,
0.35006535053253174,
0.14775829017162323,
-0.7127830386161804,
-0.7643226385116577,
-0.03654133901000023,
-0.9869433641433716,
-0.3636307120323181,
0.853144109249115,
-0.1435856968164444,
-0.035090766847133636,
-0.13158740103244781,
0.0035793145652860403,
0.31323280930519104,
-0.3335988521575928,
1.084768295288086,
0.4486716389656067,
-0.5816559195518494,
-0.15148910880088806,
-0.8161859512329102,
0.24997839331626892,
0.43780598044395447,
-1.2321871519088745,
-0.37041643261909485,
0.6894849538803101,
0.13865531980991364,
-0.015114241279661655,
1.1227043867111206,
-0.22639106214046478,
0.5955792665481567,
-0.1821046769618988,
0.07484368979930878,
-0.06688584387302399,
-0.4856337010860443,
-0.3570084273815155,
0.03777843341231346,
0.10055626183748245,
-0.3527667820453644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09739v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09739v2 | QuRating: Selecting High-Quality Data for Training Language Models | 2024-02-15T06:36:07 | 2024-06-13T18:55:23 | Alexander Wettig, Aatmik Gupta, Saumya Malik, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Selecting high-quality pre-training data is important for creating capable
language models, but existing methods rely on simple heuristics. We introduce
QuRating, a method for selecting pre-training data that can capture human
intuitions about data quality. In this paper, we investigate four qualities -
writing style, required expertise, facts & trivia, and educational value - and
find that LLMs are able to discern these qualities, especially when making
pairwise judgments of texts. We train a QuRater model to learn scalar ratings
from pairwise judgments, and use it to annotate a 260B training corpus with
quality ratings for each of the four criteria. In our experiments, we select
30B tokens according to the different quality ratings and train 1.3B-parameter
language models on the selected data. We find that it is important to balance
quality and diversity. When we sample using quality ratings as logits over
documents, our models obtain lower perplexity and stronger in-context learning
performance than baselines. Our best model is based on educational value and
performs similarly to a model trained with uniform sampling for 50% more steps.
Beyond data selection, we use the quality ratings to construct a training
curriculum which improves performance without changing the training dataset. We
extensively analyze the quality ratings and discuss their characteristics,
biases, and wider implications. | [
-0.2597152292728424,
-0.29238444566726685,
0.2793131470680237,
0.21842807531356812,
-0.34240788221359253,
0.2750566303730011,
-0.018519345670938492,
-0.28009068965911865,
-0.17669302225112915,
0.5617921948432922,
-0.02785123698413372,
-0.6640451550483704,
-0.5873143672943115,
-0.03515356779098511,
-0.6940577030181885,
1.0468794107437134,
0.03101354092359543,
0.3645220994949341,
-0.3932493031024933,
-0.14560061693191528,
-0.16202668845653534,
-0.9154818058013916,
-0.5996327996253967,
-0.18212059140205383,
0.3356717824935913,
0.5705220699310303,
0.9103081226348877,
0.6799831390380859,
0.46283090114593506,
0.18943770229816437,
-0.03663773834705353,
0.2638714611530304,
-0.7283966541290283,
0.18320919573307037,
-0.1372850388288498,
-0.635578453540802,
-0.12078727781772614,
0.4597427546977997,
0.6755779385566711,
0.6950647830963135,
0.07680879533290863,
0.3257255554199219,
0.14934653043746948,
0.9617956876754761,
-0.4914097189903259,
-0.19430924952030182,
-0.42597657442092896,
0.1493282914161682,
-0.33746904134750366,
-0.22531837224960327,
-0.18261045217514038,
-0.7437562346458435,
0.0012731589376926422,
-0.38633471727371216,
0.27729442715644836,
0.33753398060798645,
1.190200686454773,
0.2022342085838318,
-0.4531703591346741,
-0.23412363231182098,
-0.4966309368610382,
0.939238429069519,
-0.6841447949409485,
0.7453336715698242,
1.0382311344146729,
0.2244465947151184,
0.05939829349517822,
-0.44232040643692017,
-0.40622463822364807,
-0.41638436913490295,
0.007335067726671696,
0.17550332844257355,
0.44079962372779846,
-0.14648818969726562,
0.15603487193584442,
0.6327657103538513,
-0.5245530605316162,
-0.017690271139144897,
-0.5369967222213745,
-0.25227266550064087,
0.6923546195030212,
-0.06698702275753021,
0.274664044380188,
-0.19843345880508423,
-0.23940198123455048,
-0.3132604658603668,
-0.9395672678947449,
0.5600221157073975,
0.8007422685623169,
0.18588539958000183,
0.16835467517375946,
0.6631861925125122,
-0.449930340051651,
0.4975696802139282,
-0.04242158681154251,
-0.2510233223438263,
0.2166859209537506,
-0.5106433033943176,
0.07944954931735992,
-0.28974252939224243,
0.7723638415336609,
0.18458887934684753,
0.25612005591392517,
-0.25192564725875854,
-0.5322162508964539,
-0.31186187267303467,
0.4128206670284271,
-0.8128474950790405,
-0.39794841408729553,
0.272420197725296,
-0.6580125093460083,
-0.42207071185112,
0.12623248994350433,
-0.42431989312171936,
-0.16923433542251587,
-0.49934086203575134,
0.33725106716156006,
-0.5910255312919617,
-0.240445077419281,
-0.006871044635772705,
-0.06614270061254501,
0.18134550750255585,
0.04197687655687332,
-1.0139498710632324,
0.1438867449760437,
0.4890744984149933,
0.6093186140060425,
-0.4516651928424835,
-0.4213912785053253,
-0.6647007465362549,
-0.11694387346506119,
-0.7149889469146729,
0.8094132542610168,
-0.6557323336601257,
-0.38400599360466003,
0.0019375929841771722,
-0.3394780158996582,
0.25441133975982666,
-0.5928157567977905,
0.9785277843475342,
-0.542416512966156,
0.2081579566001892,
-0.35232046246528625,
-0.7550224661827087,
-0.19933880865573883,
0.07093235850334167,
-0.8494970202445984,
1.3123475313186646,
0.5196982622146606,
-0.6948983669281006,
0.7084037661552429,
-0.15038137137889862,
-0.4488917589187622,
0.035999175161123276,
-0.1593555212020874,
-0.5438487529754639,
0.13272982835769653,
0.3194122612476349,
0.6646502614021301,
-0.14420479536056519,
0.36332783102989197,
-0.032778915017843246,
-0.34708839654922485,
0.45786795020103455,
-0.15255600214004517,
0.6570584774017334,
0.43012064695358276,
0.27391883730888367,
0.19580082595348358,
-0.7856298089027405,
0.2547656297683716,
-0.13324204087257385,
-0.646837592124939,
-0.20754127204418182,
0.030688157305121422,
-0.14183560013771057,
0.2321307361125946,
0.004187133628875017,
-0.2854870855808258,
0.04907754063606262,
-0.532721221446991,
0.10585570335388184,
0.49938467144966125,
-0.07932876795530319,
0.391784131526947,
-0.7427931427955627,
0.4627302885055542,
0.22637847065925598,
0.09389478713274002,
0.17615661025047302,
-0.09785725176334381,
-0.8047814965248108,
-0.13048262894153595,
0.5197929739952087,
0.24207653105258942,
-0.7944772243499756,
0.46743378043174744,
0.038907792419195175,
-0.5861448049545288,
-0.9020156860351562,
0.6201929450035095,
0.30232298374176025,
0.18174408376216888,
0.2945016622543335,
-0.3111570179462433,
-0.46989595890045166,
-0.5769622325897217,
-0.2364661693572998,
-0.24455295503139496,
0.06918643414974213,
-0.09209510684013367,
0.2987099587917328,
0.10075125098228455,
1.081947922706604,
-0.10690924525260925,
-0.013258291408419609,
-0.5387936234474182,
0.09431733191013336,
0.31765633821487427,
0.4955848455429077,
0.5656980872154236,
-0.7409880757331848,
-0.3646526038646698,
-0.2659338712692261,
-0.6030198335647583,
-0.15531903505325317,
-0.10139840096235275,
-0.4902791976928711,
0.038505833595991135,
0.39137160778045654,
-0.3712105453014374,
0.19215644896030426,
0.5198047757148743,
-0.138882115483284,
0.7999013662338257,
0.1297294944524765,
0.3780245780944824,
-0.9807220101356506,
-0.04807087779045105,
-0.008756568655371666,
-0.3043595552444458,
-0.6057586073875427,
0.013901297003030777,
0.05255516991019249,
0.1350729763507843,
-0.5335600972175598,
0.6872318983078003,
-0.26379159092903137,
0.05057694390416145,
-0.17216917872428894,
-0.1784081757068634,
0.1960827261209488,
0.4232994019985199,
0.09395812451839447,
0.969463586807251,
0.5422093868255615,
-0.741593599319458,
0.40919965505599976,
0.4300326108932495,
-0.7664430141448975,
0.5273833870887756,
-0.6081895232200623,
0.057450100779533386,
0.14365853369235992,
-0.19727438688278198,
-0.9472544193267822,
-0.12999175488948822,
0.0717993900179863,
-0.6727558970451355,
0.07499142736196518,
-0.13504894077777863,
-0.5784051418304443,
-0.19615821540355682,
-0.3117523789405823,
0.45372501015663147,
0.5330790877342224,
-0.6941754817962646,
0.22875314950942993,
0.46588313579559326,
-0.17162977159023285,
-0.5716948509216309,
-0.2748532295227051,
-0.1296750158071518,
-0.18308380246162415,
-0.24243657290935516,
0.0763433501124382,
-0.01370383333414793,
-0.10269144922494888,
-0.11885057389736176,
-0.2664373815059662,
-0.26837536692619324,
0.2817411422729492,
0.26671335101127625,
0.2718852758407593,
-0.08414105325937271,
0.08371453732252121,
0.2720465660095215,
-0.1808045655488968,
0.1022808849811554,
-0.311921089887619,
0.36164525151252747,
0.036839794367551804,
-0.4287886917591095,
-0.4036823511123657,
0.14921508729457855,
0.06761308759450912,
-0.356984406709671,
0.7467880249023438,
0.6957170367240906,
-0.12049015611410141,
-0.21034343540668488,
-0.6603938341140747,
-0.25369536876678467,
-0.4560464322566986,
0.3214651346206665,
-0.39919808506965637,
-0.8230450749397278,
0.04992259293794632,
0.07489429414272308,
0.16325201094150543,
0.20577597618103027,
0.45492124557495117,
-0.5001665353775024,
1.1042743921279907,
0.5112806558609009,
-0.21542811393737793,
0.5043644309043884,
-0.17287254333496094,
0.17390768229961395,
-0.6165947318077087,
0.009679323993623257,
-0.617378294467926,
0.08076371252536774,
-0.40585216879844666,
-0.15184704959392548,
0.222535640001297,
0.4745766818523407,
-0.20258648693561554,
-0.06595880538225174,
-0.2645985186100006,
0.6584716439247131,
0.7993308305740356,
0.11732092499732971,
0.34633854031562805,
0.006519716698676348,
-0.13803619146347046,
0.12636226415634155,
-0.5269403457641602,
-0.8755673170089722,
1.333985447883606,
0.3723079264163971,
0.7018100023269653,
0.03611785173416138,
0.7862663269042969,
0.20707528293132782,
0.28428465127944946,
-0.6346178650856018,
0.465819776058197,
-0.19249896705150604,
-0.5825391411781311,
-0.4522961974143982,
-0.6510416865348816,
-0.8373156189918518,
0.20323440432548523,
-0.577258825302124,
-0.31724870204925537,
-0.19269585609436035,
0.10570646822452545,
-0.40184205770492554,
0.1477707177400589,
-0.35401976108551025,
0.5858955979347229,
-0.420236736536026,
-0.2713111639022827,
-0.0791972205042839,
-0.6106534600257874,
0.36044174432754517,
-0.14233368635177612,
0.08895974606275558,
-0.31151819229125977,
0.29064324498176575,
1.0577876567840576,
-0.17420320212841034,
0.5752738118171692,
0.08837911486625671,
0.08003704249858856,
0.47786030173301697,
0.2765723466873169,
0.01332695223391056,
-0.019214525818824768,
-0.3884660601615906,
0.24740859866142273,
0.5672057867050171,
-0.6790982484817505,
-0.5707929134368896,
0.07200341671705246,
-1.2494053840637207,
-0.58616703748703,
-0.4091712534427643,
-0.34545519948005676,
-0.47996553778648376,
0.0807153731584549,
0.24486273527145386,
0.3253529667854309,
-0.27983495593070984,
0.2707310616970062,
0.44541454315185547,
-0.20340484380722046,
0.0017663916805759072,
0.13338305056095123,
-0.43417707085609436,
-0.43399322032928467,
1.306288242340088,
0.08098635077476501,
0.4696252644062042,
0.30768194794654846,
0.250696063041687,
-0.46729782223701477,
-0.8752959370613098,
-0.26771703362464905,
0.29162362217903137,
-0.7915375232696533,
-0.25917142629623413,
-0.43914705514907837,
-0.5953457355499268,
-0.39461803436279297,
0.047612741589546204,
-0.2960105538368225,
-0.48282453417778015,
-0.2933803200721741,
-0.22385944426059723,
0.07067740708589554,
0.6766582727432251,
0.05581967532634735,
0.5622583031654358,
-1.053001880645752,
0.38472384214401245,
0.2874475121498108,
0.28602051734924316,
-0.12002510577440262,
-0.8018835783004761,
-0.5601259469985962,
0.06304064393043518,
-0.4202389717102051,
-0.5876599550247192,
0.6052837371826172,
0.22359657287597656,
0.8367215991020203,
0.5198309421539307,
0.09159576147794724,
0.27440145611763,
-0.0718386247754097,
0.7478837370872498,
-0.10924848914146423,
-1.0006176233291626,
0.5330833196640015,
-0.09126917272806168,
-0.11476925015449524,
0.8969294428825378,
0.800527036190033,
-0.5325256586074829,
-0.6366982460021973,
-0.3647708296775818,
-0.5701974630355835,
0.5932452082633972,
0.19685448706150055,
0.09128404408693314,
0.1020415648818016,
0.5553727149963379,
0.4835456311702728,
0.42301928997039795,
-0.7150657773017883,
0.02043362334370613,
-0.5710269808769226,
-0.37074989080429077,
-0.04565375670790672,
-0.47378888726234436,
-0.04402180016040802,
-0.4385673999786377,
0.701259434223175,
-0.08103561401367188,
-0.10686695575714111,
-0.21013404428958893,
-0.36562901735305786,
0.14978420734405518,
0.26826298236846924,
0.028931869193911552,
0.7332115769386292,
-0.09670059382915497,
0.13358663022518158,
0.038913458585739136,
-0.46526506543159485,
0.35348421335220337,
-0.3098700940608978,
0.06158844754099846,
-0.14897862076759338,
0.3872816860675812,
0.6328743696212769,
0.0027000820264220238,
-0.6327558755874634,
0.6350156664848328,
-0.018474072217941284,
-0.1411111205816269,
-0.026871342211961746,
0.6108473539352417,
-0.13006551563739777,
0.08073359727859497,
0.29274389147758484,
-0.25979551672935486,
0.12020129710435867,
-0.484984815120697,
0.14332133531570435,
0.32821986079216003,
-0.12682095170021057,
-0.23613357543945312,
0.35309898853302,
0.29164254665374756,
-0.1259111613035202,
0.9390230178833008,
-0.3940686881542206,
-0.5226776599884033,
0.37008941173553467,
0.34435775876045227,
0.4534730911254883,
-0.26081275939941406,
0.33107468485832214,
0.5540610551834106,
0.08330100029706955,
-0.4577161967754364,
0.3560841977596283,
-0.18543893098831177,
-0.9982596635818481,
-0.3370012044906616,
-0.9682034254074097,
-0.7133409380912781,
-0.14076413214206696,
-0.7240912914276123,
0.2880599796772003,
-0.5025607943534851,
-0.14178214967250824,
-0.4617421329021454,
0.27033668756484985,
-0.7536452412605286,
0.4478470981121063,
-0.03370511159300804,
0.6932570338249207,
-0.9104543328285217,
0.9698702692985535,
0.3946076035499573,
-0.6346651911735535,
-1.0029784440994263,
-0.11023490875959396,
-0.21954384446144104,
-0.7904795408248901,
0.9489984512329102,
0.12229600548744202,
0.12235590815544128,
0.13722455501556396,
-0.7175717949867249,
-0.950810432434082,
0.7100685834884644,
0.20452451705932617,
-0.37452882528305054,
0.017395103350281715,
0.30024653673171997,
0.4170815050601959,
-0.2142638862133026,
0.5956308245658875,
0.7409646511077881,
0.11802622675895691,
0.1869376301765442,
-0.5817200541496277,
-0.24156628549098969,
-0.2966374158859253,
-0.14481526613235474,
-0.1543448567390442,
-0.5040356516838074,
0.7999802827835083,
-0.22329524159431458,
-0.40174633264541626,
0.18177223205566406,
1.029128909111023,
0.4127739667892456,
0.10014384239912033,
0.3757501244544983,
0.3320700526237488,
0.9772318601608276,
-0.12923067808151245,
0.8164768815040588,
-0.47059276700019836,
0.055195294320583344,
0.922447919845581,
-0.1845095306634903,
0.9734818935394287,
0.2819695472717285,
-0.35705074667930603,
0.3309153616428375,
0.9975769519805908,
0.04293893277645111,
0.4243534803390503,
0.21775013208389282,
-0.015023680403828621,
-0.5143160223960876,
-0.0774109810590744,
-0.2769341766834259,
0.4278334379196167,
0.27046555280685425,
-0.015758492052555084,
0.13589495420455933,
0.019681112840771675,
-0.179869145154953,
0.050430312752723694,
-0.11999049782752991,
0.6959537267684937,
0.0851658284664154,
-0.6456570029258728,
0.6085580587387085,
-0.1841406673192978,
0.5540763139724731,
-0.4022417664527893,
0.01409436296671629,
-0.35630205273628235,
-0.3885667622089386,
-0.40690481662750244,
-0.9838292598724365,
0.16975772380828857,
-0.07270973920822144,
-0.06596151739358902,
-0.2750340700149536,
0.24307195842266083,
-0.5498158931732178,
-0.6199362277984619,
-0.09675002843141556,
0.8745704293251038,
0.5594351291656494,
-0.03150232508778572,
-0.47310125827789307,
-0.03223885968327522,
-0.18951106071472168,
-0.22956663370132446,
0.3857998847961426,
0.5550010204315186,
0.013004083186388016,
0.7461434602737427,
1.0444705486297607,
0.46864640712738037,
-0.22109700739383698,
0.36940616369247437,
0.8400012850761414,
-0.8950590491294861,
-0.47162219882011414,
-0.7802255749702454,
0.2665286064147949,
-0.04203666001558304,
-0.4203377962112427,
0.6046627759933472,
0.5408847332000732,
0.9811004996299744,
0.25045958161354065,
0.8073469400405884,
0.5643859505653381,
0.8081268072128296,
-0.8148391246795654,
0.9161312580108643,
-0.3818293809890747,
0.2549246549606323,
-0.07421299815177917,
-0.8966131210327148,
-0.1152513176202774,
0.8226171135902405,
-0.31381428241729736,
0.12022331357002258,
0.75035160779953,
0.7153441905975342,
0.22132720053195953,
0.0914108082652092,
0.5450236797332764,
0.02002638578414917,
0.5322259664535522,
0.3368121087551117,
1.3121761083602905,
-0.1709849089384079,
0.3877422511577606,
-0.10811381042003632,
-0.13665978610515594,
-0.14090567827224731,
-0.6584882736206055,
-1.3794244527816772,
-0.7830308675765991,
-0.09124114364385605,
-0.31228259205818176,
0.02790447324514389,
1.2077412605285645,
0.8753316402435303,
-0.7397997975349426,
-0.3646691143512726,
0.2829645872116089,
0.4085390865802765,
-0.13552796840667725,
-0.16408079862594604,
0.3339519202709198,
-0.7836799025535583,
-0.41110748052597046,
0.17100007832050323,
-0.04048074409365654,
0.13982820510864258,
-0.27823132276535034,
-0.10461989790201187,
0.04898794740438461,
0.09547758102416992,
0.5605599880218506,
0.07415905594825745,
-0.43991854786872864,
-0.19243615865707397,
-0.17951597273349762,
-0.4897317886352539,
0.19407230615615845,
0.6861506104469299,
-0.6771015524864197,
0.21319156885147095,
0.41640064120292664,
0.8532059192657471,
0.27541279792785645,
0.20853137969970703,
0.5324558019638062,
-0.560602605342865,
-0.09906063973903656,
0.33109357953071594,
0.15678545832633972,
0.4238260090351105,
-0.2428973764181137,
0.44277098774909973,
0.03594030439853668,
-0.7916648387908936,
-0.812894344329834,
0.05584048479795456,
-0.7335283160209656,
-0.11080147325992584,
1.2215332984924316,
-0.2248922735452652,
-0.21720591187477112,
-0.3250405490398407,
-0.49677547812461853,
0.1867132931947708,
-0.304499089717865,
0.9929309487342834,
0.9607478380203247,
-0.14103002846240997,
-0.09832070022821426,
-0.6225926280021667,
0.782974362373352,
0.5359243750572205,
-0.9462111592292786,
-0.15898513793945312,
0.2546178102493286,
0.1961006224155426,
-0.3321233093738556,
0.544817328453064,
0.09831695258617401,
0.28751152753829956,
-0.13323605060577393,
0.019046133384108543,
-0.07770047336816788,
-0.37686121463775635,
-0.05749114230275154,
0.1370328813791275,
0.5698992013931274,
0.0032655249815434217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09738v1 | Align before Attend: Aligning Visual and Textual Features for Multimodal Hateful Content Detection | 2024-02-15T06:34:15 | 2024-02-15T06:34:15 | Eftekhar Hossain, Omar Sharif, Mohammed Moshiul Hoque, Sarah M. Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal hateful content detection is a challenging task that requires
complex reasoning across visual and textual modalities. Therefore, creating a
meaningful multimodal representation that effectively captures the interplay
between visual and textual features through intermediate fusion is critical.
Conventional fusion techniques are unable to attend to the modality-specific
features effectively. Moreover, most studies exclusively concentrated on
English and overlooked other low-resource languages. This paper proposes a
context-aware attention framework for multimodal hateful content detection and
assesses it for both English and non-English languages. The proposed approach
incorporates an attention layer to meaningfully align the visual and textual
features. This alignment enables selective focus on modality-specific features
before fusing them. We evaluate the proposed approach on two benchmark hateful
meme datasets, viz. MUTE (Bengali code-mixed) and MultiOFF (English).
Evaluation results demonstrate our proposed approach's effectiveness with
F1-scores of $69.7$% and $70.3$% for the MUTE and MultiOFF datasets. The scores
show approximately $2.5$% and $3.2$% performance improvement over the
state-of-the-art systems on these datasets. Our implementation is available at
https://github.com/eftekhar-hossain/Bengali-Hateful-Memes. | [
-0.5864840745925903,
-0.4390931725502014,
0.18607254326343536,
0.3243977129459381,
-0.29718998074531555,
-0.16484588384628296,
-0.22881363332271576,
-0.4700362980365753,
0.3498012125492096,
0.35952991247177124,
-0.6406576633453369,
-0.2560010552406311,
-0.6549749374389648,
0.12325455993413925,
-0.2684729993343353,
0.7933716773986816,
-0.03331853821873665,
-0.17360258102416992,
-0.1735096424818039,
-0.556679368019104,
-0.5615375638008118,
-0.1957402229309082,
-0.447346568107605,
0.34672248363494873,
0.7968424558639526,
0.38634827733039856,
0.6485958695411682,
0.5352726578712463,
0.7444801926612854,
0.2561599612236023,
0.47996461391448975,
0.31589433550834656,
-0.4300120770931244,
0.3659002184867859,
-0.4869101345539093,
0.11523424834012985,
-0.13546498119831085,
0.03705086559057236,
0.376868337392807,
0.013051311485469341,
0.2800189256668091,
0.17987138032913208,
0.0865616723895073,
0.33733826875686646,
-0.985313355922699,
-0.305210143327713,
-0.6751899719238281,
-0.03109639510512352,
-0.49969589710235596,
-0.256777822971344,
-0.5955669283866882,
0.03620471805334091,
-0.09037957340478897,
-0.5855361223220825,
-0.12561801075935364,
0.22063268721103668,
0.6078075170516968,
0.5519837141036987,
-0.5435943603515625,
-0.1859079897403717,
-0.21859726309776306,
1.221745252609253,
-0.5039563775062561,
0.7193019390106201,
0.32009947299957275,
0.18086214363574982,
0.17551234364509583,
-0.05231321603059769,
-0.8715220093727112,
0.26830384135246277,
-0.24555552005767822,
0.3039400279521942,
-0.28760355710983276,
-0.2950025200843811,
0.19285550713539124,
0.30760085582733154,
-0.9774974584579468,
0.040130890905857086,
-0.1802232563495636,
-0.4627377390861511,
0.5030625462532043,
-0.01542429719120264,
0.5187530517578125,
-0.46399447321891785,
-0.8887385725975037,
-0.18494467437267303,
-0.2667432427406311,
-0.2843635380268097,
0.27505066990852356,
0.3040340542793274,
-0.3966203033924103,
0.46486765146255493,
0.00023607465845998377,
0.7231400609016418,
-0.008390319533646107,
-0.47304826974868774,
0.31562384963035583,
-0.45206689834594727,
-0.14197033643722534,
-0.008449829183518887,
0.7471418976783752,
0.7732012867927551,
0.315848171710968,
0.009838431142270565,
-0.02589896321296692,
0.6153389811515808,
0.4643266797065735,
-0.6321401000022888,
0.07331033796072006,
0.2194601595401764,
-0.3237508237361908,
-0.1873806267976761,
-0.5048576593399048,
-0.9782766103744507,
-0.5425963997840881,
-0.15511158108711243,
0.39784741401672363,
-0.6017585396766663,
-0.5221143364906311,
-0.4145098626613617,
-0.1701742261648178,
0.18657921254634857,
0.329304039478302,
-0.6169410943984985,
-0.28797411918640137,
0.249629944562912,
0.6763057112693787,
-0.4534529149532318,
-0.34466224908828735,
-0.5123134255409241,
0.5060875415802002,
0.08518869429826736,
0.851116955280304,
-0.7052796483039856,
0.2926779091358185,
0.09417448192834854,
0.05218575894832611,
-0.10004846751689911,
-0.3929198682308197,
0.7187946438789368,
-0.5622397661209106,
0.1524306982755661,
-0.022278552874922752,
-0.18649213016033173,
-0.2569158673286438,
0.6941809058189392,
-0.713229775428772,
0.6435175538063049,
0.3072342276573181,
-1.0345567464828491,
0.3958670496940613,
-0.41894373297691345,
-0.545048177242279,
-0.058222487568855286,
-0.10789598524570465,
-0.5309304594993591,
-0.37410417199134827,
0.30910223722457886,
0.47326093912124634,
-0.01259353943169117,
0.044880468398332596,
-0.5344634652137756,
-0.1956360936164856,
0.1881689876317978,
-0.43417227268218994,
0.5793600678443909,
0.4869459569454193,
-0.6084794402122498,
0.2525154650211334,
-0.5977141261100769,
-0.06142238527536392,
0.07748439908027649,
-0.022456856444478035,
-0.6470954418182373,
0.03531624376773834,
0.6153791546821594,
0.5252816677093506,
0.005477536469697952,
-0.38187724351882935,
-0.25602757930755615,
-0.26266470551490784,
0.007824588567018509,
0.9587681293487549,
-0.3077824115753174,
0.4821506142616272,
-0.4795924723148346,
0.5637626647949219,
0.43258339166641235,
0.2793218493461609,
-0.3366807699203491,
-0.266875296831131,
-0.4319881796836853,
-0.5120400786399841,
-0.1261572241783142,
0.47089776396751404,
-0.8691353797912598,
0.09780536592006683,
0.010955422185361385,
-0.24784719944000244,
-0.5117431879043579,
0.2239137887954712,
0.5935316681861877,
0.4099529981613159,
0.639492392539978,
-0.29162561893463135,
-0.8330604434013367,
-1.1393144130706787,
-0.33713528513908386,
0.035059165209531784,
0.192337766289711,
0.3177570104598999,
0.09859634935855865,
-0.35159286856651306,
0.49577412009239197,
-0.29600659012794495,
-0.7886473536491394,
-0.0008582011214457452,
-0.05049048736691475,
-0.26827552914619446,
0.5243846774101257,
0.6986904740333557,
-1.2352477312088013,
-0.8291763663291931,
0.11426861584186554,
-0.6680545806884766,
-0.20275737345218658,
0.008294695988297462,
-0.3704107701778412,
0.3309738039970398,
0.31253135204315186,
0.08488591760396957,
0.32209908962249756,
0.7232897281646729,
-0.3913981318473816,
0.2452033907175064,
0.6293362379074097,
0.8778886795043945,
-1.238356351852417,
-0.1430240422487259,
0.10256510972976685,
-0.2576466202735901,
-0.4313240349292755,
-0.1016945019364357,
0.16826161742210388,
-0.08126232028007507,
-0.6612480282783508,
0.6060689687728882,
-0.5488227009773254,
0.32470789551734924,
-0.1354084014892578,
0.32362595200538635,
0.05517914891242981,
0.5972682237625122,
-0.06461405009031296,
0.6926223039627075,
0.19874680042266846,
-0.21350431442260742,
0.19940385222434998,
0.22468771040439606,
-0.25896868109703064,
1.1163103580474854,
0.11596184223890305,
-0.11744563281536102,
0.013702918775379658,
-0.23711475729942322,
-1.2135727405548096,
-0.46738409996032715,
0.6163570880889893,
-0.5294355154037476,
0.2911398410797119,
-0.09412205964326859,
-0.2228262722492218,
-0.1779996156692505,
-0.6210533380508423,
0.9821895360946655,
0.06008484214544296,
-0.33642154932022095,
0.6340956687927246,
0.7528005242347717,
-0.07191336899995804,
-0.7788774371147156,
-0.5855919122695923,
-0.07666757702827454,
-0.2752852141857147,
-0.7671911120414734,
0.44988906383514404,
-0.30957573652267456,
-0.14047420024871826,
-0.06615767627954483,
0.11105570197105408,
-0.35893750190734863,
-0.08360795676708221,
0.2594454288482666,
0.0006244246033020318,
-0.21343903243541718,
-0.07910267263650894,
0.19053566455841064,
0.036750417202711105,
-0.2697371542453766,
0.07753384113311768,
0.4300639033317566,
0.2110065072774887,
-0.4571208357810974,
-0.2939040958881378,
0.8382665514945984,
0.9758755564689636,
-0.3069551885128021,
0.4287950098514557,
1.0134445428848267,
-0.4760967493057251,
0.032433245331048965,
-0.9807900786399841,
-0.006817879155278206,
-0.40816840529441833,
0.3151240944862366,
-0.09027772396802902,
-0.9509091377258301,
0.38696515560150146,
0.49702388048171997,
-0.06022725626826286,
0.32118967175483704,
0.5993982553482056,
-0.09536423534154892,
0.9674644470214844,
0.6035205125808716,
-0.04551885649561882,
0.6507375836372375,
0.41771361231803894,
0.44172412157058716,
-0.7965524196624756,
-0.2108786404132843,
-0.25921061635017395,
-0.5418310761451721,
-0.2175382673740387,
-0.6255183219909668,
0.40950387716293335,
-0.34343138337135315,
0.1334085762500763,
0.39801841974258423,
-0.602272629737854,
0.4835191071033478,
0.17384709417819977,
0.14367736876010895,
0.0810733512043953,
0.19171898066997528,
0.11463432759046555,
-0.7234581708908081,
-0.4158293902873993,
-0.1827029436826706,
0.914737343788147,
0.01351336482912302,
0.7447444796562195,
0.49586042761802673,
0.30581650137901306,
0.5491932034492493,
0.513995349407196,
-0.6086881756782532,
0.2738552689552307,
-0.0939849466085434,
-0.7007482647895813,
-0.16336902976036072,
-0.18332111835479736,
-0.6406506896018982,
0.36811354756355286,
-0.16292108595371246,
-0.2892341911792755,
0.06321883946657181,
0.19068458676338196,
-0.17365048825740814,
0.21764333546161652,
-0.9882502555847168,
1.1155781745910645,
-0.1572553962469101,
-0.6307653784751892,
-0.4032650291919708,
-0.5950368642807007,
0.46435052156448364,
-0.13408738374710083,
0.7012561559677124,
-0.19232213497161865,
-0.06352680176496506,
0.8230725526809692,
0.10875407606363297,
0.8082121014595032,
-0.027710214257240295,
-0.1350448876619339,
0.04104366526007652,
0.10143696516752243,
0.10858789831399918,
-0.18074007332324982,
0.10055117309093475,
0.050456296652555466,
-0.2666769325733185,
-0.4268774092197418,
-0.44175058603286743,
0.8944259285926819,
-0.27851876616477966,
-0.4245753884315491,
-0.3228912353515625,
-0.8513770699501038,
-0.20467843115329742,
0.2764896750450134,
0.00654692854732275,
0.38714906573295593,
-0.03621146082878113,
0.16370889544487,
0.7755113840103149,
0.029250802472233772,
0.5668333172798157,
0.5607776641845703,
-0.051089245826005936,
-0.6954602599143982,
1.0391162633895874,
0.1912609189748764,
0.07199544459581375,
0.40497347712516785,
-0.17505116760730743,
-0.20023690164089203,
-0.37364768981933594,
-0.6233581304550171,
0.10498513281345367,
-0.6663614511489868,
-0.5903368592262268,
-0.9324657320976257,
0.008981289342045784,
-0.6529325246810913,
-0.5445853471755981,
-0.18679380416870117,
0.05193714797496796,
-0.11293192952871323,
0.40075919032096863,
0.15301743149757385,
0.23629596829414368,
-0.1620780974626541,
0.14143875241279602,
-0.7247876524925232,
0.45340046286582947,
0.21084831655025482,
0.2985154092311859,
0.10559749603271484,
-0.7313081622123718,
-0.3166927993297577,
-0.180406853556633,
-0.5215559005737305,
-1.0205656290054321,
0.3135910928249359,
-0.05142548680305481,
0.5387265086174011,
0.8535304069519043,
0.35533374547958374,
0.6626459956169128,
-0.3911009728908539,
0.4900680482387543,
0.33197933435440063,
-0.7368112206459045,
0.7380591630935669,
-0.3330543637275696,
0.20220531523227692,
0.49164289236068726,
0.8606591820716858,
-0.5400682687759399,
-0.785966157913208,
-0.4303703010082245,
-0.7373262047767639,
0.707781970500946,
0.15818220376968384,
0.0917249545454979,
-0.27802330255508423,
-0.35124990344047546,
0.08057581633329391,
0.12117590755224228,
-1.2124818563461304,
-0.32119837403297424,
-0.27662625908851624,
-0.48816201090812683,
0.19416412711143494,
-0.5246859192848206,
-0.1193232536315918,
-0.25672125816345215,
0.644585371017456,
-0.11245472729206085,
-0.06931190937757492,
0.09210961312055588,
-0.6964272260665894,
-0.19058994948863983,
0.2673393189907074,
0.7698470950126648,
0.5582499504089355,
-0.056051481515169144,
0.2550358176231384,
-0.13344988226890564,
-0.45690611004829407,
0.2406342327594757,
-0.01313810981810093,
0.036464471369981766,
-0.11585351824760437,
0.39763665199279785,
0.2418404370546341,
0.4998602569103241,
-0.890224039554596,
0.924553394317627,
0.059447214007377625,
0.09290483593940735,
-0.12124746292829514,
-0.1342824101448059,
-0.2976665794849396,
0.4827243685722351,
0.14185045659542084,
0.21272878348827362,
0.23830878734588623,
-0.24807246029376984,
0.6470394730567932,
0.4902564585208893,
-0.6922571063041687,
-0.24317525327205658,
0.5381649732589722,
0.2909948527812958,
0.044467318803071976,
0.12229780852794647,
-0.02088543027639389,
-0.8145545721054077,
0.42933329939842224,
0.6839621663093567,
0.5710959434509277,
-0.6377881169319153,
0.18302157521247864,
0.48792722821235657,
0.6221972703933716,
0.748070240020752,
0.10600771009922028,
-0.23523396253585815,
-0.8664314150810242,
-0.29665833711624146,
-0.8147321343421936,
-0.25400859117507935,
0.2472223937511444,
-0.5248528122901917,
0.33272626996040344,
-0.4174497425556183,
0.22537042200565338,
0.1569145768880844,
-0.39579617977142334,
-0.367465078830719,
0.393616646528244,
0.4695521891117096,
0.48118430376052856,
-1.0627923011779785,
0.2879639267921448,
0.6736520528793335,
-0.48019859194755554,
-0.5821455121040344,
0.0036311622243374586,
0.33501821756362915,
-0.8842623829841614,
0.21253128349781036,
0.5082372426986694,
-0.027071835473179817,
-0.07144208997488022,
-0.22757023572921753,
-0.7697153091430664,
0.5316070318222046,
0.2699277997016907,
-0.42698895931243896,
0.4335923492908478,
-0.2374430000782013,
0.056514397263526917,
-0.41546300053596497,
0.3572075068950653,
0.14840273559093475,
0.5900569558143616,
0.0241786427795887,
-0.55536288022995,
0.23065026104450226,
-0.3840038776397705,
-0.35721465945243835,
0.4951811134815216,
-0.8054041862487793,
0.5830076932907104,
0.0578765869140625,
-0.3895012140274048,
-0.5020874738693237,
0.538942277431488,
-0.1507907509803772,
0.46233513951301575,
0.7014695405960083,
0.8206160664558411,
0.3446577489376068,
0.0972805768251419,
0.7494896650314331,
0.07187458872795105,
0.05431973561644554,
0.9678254723548889,
-0.30194807052612305,
0.7341563701629639,
0.7367104887962341,
-0.07895293831825256,
0.37757161259651184,
0.4758646786212921,
0.06597286462783813,
0.7686296701431274,
-0.10877636075019836,
-0.3958098292350769,
-0.36568546295166016,
-0.6283991932868958,
-0.4769029915332794,
0.5494437217712402,
0.17913755774497986,
-0.33890190720558167,
-0.39704328775405884,
0.5566384792327881,
0.06302940100431442,
0.3731563091278076,
-0.2899457812309265,
0.9343286752700806,
-0.2073068469762802,
-0.5298917293548584,
0.6218088865280151,
-0.14713086187839508,
0.9406352043151855,
-0.4626026749610901,
0.015056392177939415,
0.0008317745523527265,
0.1381039321422577,
-0.3176445960998535,
-0.6324164867401123,
0.725324273109436,
0.0425165630877018,
-0.8223270773887634,
-0.2503678798675537,
0.619417130947113,
-0.7682044506072998,
-0.11534833908081055,
0.6794835925102234,
0.034089431166648865,
-0.02324821799993515,
-0.28028613328933716,
-0.5895749926567078,
0.5234456062316895,
0.2789204716682434,
0.07085443288087845,
0.5327825546264648,
0.26755231618881226,
-0.2611761689186096,
0.18113645911216736,
0.5762660503387451,
-0.42506399750709534,
0.06214277073740959,
0.204867884516716,
0.8940293192863464,
-0.5165437459945679,
-0.490271657705307,
-0.8245788812637329,
0.6910187005996704,
-0.1591293066740036,
-0.24175956845283508,
0.6665602326393127,
0.5840494632720947,
1.2446379661560059,
-0.07657397538423538,
0.6289275884628296,
-0.16869203746318817,
0.5983577370643616,
-0.33574941754341125,
0.8799925446510315,
-1.0485891103744507,
-0.42223450541496277,
-0.5479345917701721,
-0.9200950860977173,
-0.4161304235458374,
0.4564278721809387,
-0.10557009279727936,
-0.36374497413635254,
0.784923255443573,
0.9428460597991943,
-0.28410497307777405,
-0.20341716706752777,
0.6934994459152222,
0.16700479388237,
0.09959901869297028,
0.6468193531036377,
0.8373388648033142,
-0.6125404238700867,
0.7657508850097656,
-0.2900749444961548,
-0.5441747903823853,
-0.2896462380886078,
-0.8120280504226685,
-0.8437497019767761,
-0.7901563048362732,
-0.3260001242160797,
-0.3348105847835541,
-0.20316988229751587,
0.5981638431549072,
0.5879945158958435,
-1.0015275478363037,
0.2287234365940094,
0.7157034873962402,
0.4200233817100525,
-0.0664980411529541,
-0.29207634925842285,
0.1329362392425537,
-0.3357035517692566,
-0.7387658357620239,
0.3392212390899658,
0.8424467444419861,
-0.1358301043510437,
-0.022867869585752487,
0.027198083698749542,
-0.6931665539741516,
0.17797574400901794,
0.7247895002365112,
0.03813162073493004,
-0.7987362742424011,
-0.35828208923339844,
-0.17632290720939636,
-0.3290192782878876,
0.091525137424469,
0.6902981400489807,
-0.3915458917617798,
0.5142545104026794,
0.23969364166259766,
0.9160416126251221,
-0.016073817387223244,
-0.09422113746404648,
0.09314846247434616,
-0.8055515289306641,
0.5709811449050903,
0.3601045310497284,
0.35788530111312866,
0.5064743757247925,
-0.4768160879611969,
0.22916154563426971,
0.5040487051010132,
-0.2865549921989441,
-0.8979609608650208,
0.33233460783958435,
-1.3099181652069092,
0.06039902940392494,
0.7306535840034485,
-0.04008655250072479,
-0.4129171371459961,
-0.29564133286476135,
-0.2831905484199524,
0.10031719505786896,
-0.26802951097488403,
0.6740608215332031,
0.7903552651405334,
0.35721391439437866,
-0.3217813968658447,
-0.07237990945577621,
0.3782130479812622,
0.8435884714126587,
-0.580539882183075,
0.05871471017599106,
0.6936811208724976,
-0.018705235794186592,
0.38587647676467896,
0.5735377669334412,
-0.21480199694633484,
0.6017996668815613,
-0.14477446675300598,
0.1978536695241928,
0.03960873931646347,
-0.5991079807281494,
0.009006806649267673,
0.37663865089416504,
-0.6038680672645569,
-0.15856222808361053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09733v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09733v1 | Do LLMs Know about Hallucination? An Empirical Investigation of LLM's Hidden States | 2024-02-15T06:14:55 | 2024-02-15T06:14:55 | Hanyu Duan, Yi Yang, Kar Yan Tam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can make up answers that are not real, and this
is known as hallucination. This research aims to see if, how, and to what
extent LLMs are aware of hallucination. More specifically, we check whether and
how an LLM reacts differently in its hidden states when it answers a question
right versus when it hallucinates. To do this, we introduce an experimental
framework which allows examining LLM's hidden states in different hallucination
situations. Building upon this framework, we conduct a series of experiments
with language models in the LLaMA family (Touvron et al., 2023). Our empirical
findings suggest that LLMs react differently when processing a genuine response
versus a fabricated one. We then apply various model interpretation techniques
to help understand and explain the findings better. Moreover, informed by the
empirical observations, we show great potential of using the guidance derived
from LLM's hidden representation space to mitigate hallucination. We believe
this work provides insights into how LLMs produce hallucinated answers and how
to make them occur less often. | [
-0.3382474482059479,
-0.877921998500824,
1.1030848026275635,
0.07012224942445755,
-0.09294429421424866,
0.14444640278816223,
-0.19254231452941895,
-0.7597598433494568,
0.5319014191627502,
0.4684867858886719,
-0.8214019536972046,
-0.3909088969230652,
-0.43324992060661316,
0.2525821328163147,
-0.5589285492897034,
0.5159624814987183,
0.047000158578157425,
0.13248471915721893,
-0.21236521005630493,
0.05237441509962082,
-0.42569398880004883,
-0.800057590007782,
-0.24651378393173218,
-0.31919142603874207,
0.6484467387199402,
0.1747993379831314,
0.47884222865104675,
0.6190353631973267,
0.19119499623775482,
0.18673640489578247,
-0.2877812087535858,
0.007574055343866348,
-0.7338792681694031,
0.12036151438951492,
0.0712895318865776,
-0.8708066940307617,
-0.22527450323104858,
-0.022659868001937866,
0.40252986550331116,
0.8010579347610474,
-0.1253785640001297,
0.07850030809640884,
-0.03885582834482193,
0.5526669025421143,
-0.571368396282196,
-0.007741076406091452,
-0.8367589712142944,
0.44850441813468933,
0.22013139724731445,
-0.355510413646698,
-0.5485648512840271,
-0.5267223119735718,
-0.13544005155563354,
-0.21388007700443268,
0.4201403260231018,
0.2234397530555725,
0.6931253671646118,
0.5017197728157043,
-0.47280192375183105,
-0.5342867970466614,
-0.8931089043617249,
0.5823381543159485,
-0.6126667857170105,
0.43474626541137695,
0.5725590586662292,
0.1931827962398529,
-0.25738266110420227,
-0.41407549381256104,
-0.8231188058853149,
-0.5531217455863953,
-0.3723558485507965,
-0.060181524604558945,
0.025295691564679146,
-0.12712475657463074,
0.40829408168792725,
0.5438235998153687,
-0.6353241205215454,
0.15632036328315735,
-0.28512340784072876,
-0.3804406225681305,
0.3775627315044403,
0.15542249381542206,
0.30147290229797363,
-0.06760919839143753,
-0.23664210736751556,
0.0929495245218277,
-0.8686284422874451,
-0.34475329518318176,
0.35566356778144836,
0.043495189398527145,
0.09510786831378937,
0.9844949841499329,
0.019679639488458633,
0.350103497505188,
-0.02528834529221058,
0.20599135756492615,
-0.019851110875606537,
0.05205582454800606,
-0.21876055002212524,
0.3728899359703064,
0.49008792638778687,
0.0728939026594162,
0.09251143783330917,
-0.4409389793872833,
-0.5758727192878723,
0.32597747445106506,
0.31412678956985474,
-0.7906107306480408,
-0.06429247558116913,
0.3024798333644867,
-0.4988190531730652,
-0.323118656873703,
-0.15155388414859772,
-0.3883088231086731,
-0.9004772305488586,
-0.19524307548999786,
0.7152119278907776,
-0.19191130995750427,
-0.4366212785243988,
0.3040163516998291,
-0.06871914118528366,
0.4209411144256592,
0.1372103989124298,
-0.8829401731491089,
0.7197321057319641,
0.6913629770278931,
0.5320653915405273,
-0.18192283809185028,
-0.24315223097801208,
-0.40938323736190796,
-0.17768540978431702,
-0.5486941337585449,
0.8455120325088501,
-0.5447124242782593,
-0.335723340511322,
0.06100485473871231,
0.18186889588832855,
-0.12397091090679169,
-0.9860700964927673,
0.15691466629505157,
-0.6111047863960266,
0.03389331325888634,
-0.6875534057617188,
-0.6487061977386475,
-0.42656031250953674,
0.0895683616399765,
-0.7567533254623413,
0.8527524471282959,
-0.2978568971157074,
-0.5420702695846558,
0.21920475363731384,
-0.30456605553627014,
-0.07957297563552856,
-0.04588868468999863,
-0.4643838405609131,
-0.2239428162574768,
0.6539658308029175,
-0.002395511604845524,
0.47889986634254456,
0.04694422334432602,
0.06124858558177948,
-0.3261180520057678,
-0.7870196104049683,
0.9324176907539368,
-0.34626179933547974,
0.338228702545166,
0.0597827173769474,
-0.5603170394897461,
0.13076764345169067,
-0.7786605358123779,
-0.3793283998966217,
0.3906211853027344,
-0.16120751202106476,
-0.1296422928571701,
0.08827100694179535,
-0.35692909359931946,
-0.018736163154244423,
0.25157979130744934,
-0.5540557503700256,
0.2696932554244995,
-0.3650718927383423,
0.16643114387989044,
0.8272824883460999,
0.16299372911453247,
0.31412383913993835,
-0.35539379715919495,
0.4094392657279968,
-0.034423667937517166,
-0.17087800800800323,
0.1616123616695404,
-0.3491958975791931,
-1.1066228151321411,
-0.028757276013493538,
-0.02989654242992401,
0.2809962034225464,
-0.2186356782913208,
0.38676610589027405,
0.14811298251152039,
-0.09911306202411652,
-0.6081946492195129,
-0.10409200936555862,
0.2934560179710388,
0.4868321716785431,
0.16140222549438477,
0.022175734862685204,
-0.4947032034397125,
-0.964942455291748,
-0.09387395530939102,
-0.22883430123329163,
0.05055547133088112,
0.22892668843269348,
0.7003048062324524,
-0.29643377661705017,
0.6184586882591248,
-0.5863146185874939,
-0.24433179199695587,
-0.22904647886753082,
0.14365869760513306,
0.1575620025396347,
-0.11487837880849838,
0.2770792841911316,
-0.5698075294494629,
0.2508871555328369,
-0.1061149388551712,
-1.2509820461273193,
0.049488477408885956,
-0.24028508365154266,
0.14963363111019135,
0.16356584429740906,
0.5339901447296143,
-0.650879979133606,
0.6442698240280151,
0.515541672706604,
-0.34656378626823425,
0.5858896374702454,
-0.2459220290184021,
-0.034217603504657745,
-0.5457521677017212,
-0.20830437541007996,
-0.5425862073898315,
-0.08516848832368851,
-0.5666840672492981,
-0.018814748153090477,
0.02059372141957283,
0.04309898614883423,
-0.40171071887016296,
0.48413798213005066,
-0.6974576711654663,
-0.6343411803245544,
-0.47383031249046326,
0.16830527782440186,
-0.25788989663124084,
0.6495389342308044,
0.337177574634552,
0.8846156001091003,
0.5240134596824646,
-0.8089171051979065,
0.017829639837145805,
0.06484132260084152,
-0.4984562397003174,
-0.06546328216791153,
-0.5608106255531311,
0.3513801693916321,
-0.21258780360221863,
0.09309106320142746,
-1.1624553203582764,
-0.2990049123764038,
0.3625198304653168,
-0.48651301860809326,
-0.040553491562604904,
0.18952256441116333,
-0.6070992946624756,
-0.25931987166404724,
-0.17856481671333313,
0.14582505822181702,
0.5100215077400208,
-0.6346386671066284,
0.5144879221916199,
0.408231645822525,
0.04122285917401314,
-0.3773515224456787,
-0.8249725699424744,
0.05069988965988159,
-0.22865845263004303,
-0.2918955385684967,
0.07127083837985992,
-0.48190534114837646,
-0.5843381285667419,
-0.03812985122203827,
-0.301618754863739,
0.10690724104642868,
0.36602160334587097,
0.5979193449020386,
0.00344418128952384,
-0.25015726685523987,
0.2905886471271515,
0.05457009747624397,
0.11730577796697617,
0.5033813118934631,
0.23510922491550446,
0.9446609020233154,
-0.2227785736322403,
-0.6566024422645569,
-0.4797358810901642,
0.16085407137870789,
0.4121774733066559,
0.05660826712846756,
0.9894190430641174,
0.2725084125995636,
-0.8171868920326233,
-0.21663258969783783,
-0.6365197896957397,
-0.6748967170715332,
-0.4297410845756531,
0.15349045395851135,
-0.5772643089294434,
-0.9018997550010681,
0.9443779587745667,
0.1534607857465744,
-0.17992959916591644,
0.08808302879333496,
0.9211848974227905,
-0.05658024549484253,
1.1187853813171387,
0.6824368238449097,
0.22047388553619385,
-0.049751166254282,
-0.18526297807693481,
0.31702035665512085,
-0.8054842352867126,
-0.38715317845344543,
-0.36422377824783325,
-0.35661762952804565,
-0.5987167358398438,
-0.32778993248939514,
0.21146894991397858,
0.04224122315645218,
0.054406553506851196,
0.04479556530714035,
-0.38797327876091003,
0.5925478935241699,
-0.0005090255872346461,
0.27712154388427734,
0.34368425607681274,
-0.059645622968673706,
-0.1325402557849884,
0.00546080619096756,
-0.3080974817276001,
-0.6962446570396423,
0.7985503673553467,
0.45715606212615967,
0.7423017024993896,
0.19080998003482819,
0.9363503456115723,
0.28207212686538696,
0.23863141238689423,
-0.9215792417526245,
0.828896701335907,
0.595492422580719,
-0.606925904750824,
-0.29394829273223877,
-0.23807722330093384,
-0.9921604990959167,
0.39635032415390015,
-0.20914703607559204,
-0.8138020634651184,
0.07581345736980438,
-0.16231009364128113,
-0.2795701026916504,
0.2064344882965088,
-0.4636560380458832,
0.3821249306201935,
-0.2647177577018738,
-0.2632599174976349,
-0.2521984577178955,
-0.405582070350647,
0.6467401385307312,
-0.1902054250240326,
0.16749808192253113,
-0.1948375254869461,
0.09553948044776917,
0.7918973565101624,
-0.22075101733207703,
1.1285994052886963,
0.03877299278974533,
-0.6035784482955933,
0.17553657293319702,
0.4332115352153778,
0.5582491159439087,
0.12583662569522858,
-0.21379977464675903,
-0.024238184094429016,
-0.3039495348930359,
-0.14276614785194397,
-0.6360292434692383,
0.9092444777488708,
-0.7235783338546753,
-0.8829013109207153,
-0.5047488212585449,
-0.6078574657440186,
-0.11351035535335541,
0.023589862510561943,
0.16159072518348694,
0.04509695619344711,
-0.24416933953762054,
-0.1471235454082489,
1.0192816257476807,
-0.43129709362983704,
0.4662090837955475,
0.6853976249694824,
-0.7530302405357361,
0.09429168701171875,
0.6411848068237305,
0.23301784694194794,
0.03806626424193382,
0.3995434641838074,
0.29968225955963135,
-0.5101813673973083,
-0.4482450783252716,
-0.27572450041770935,
0.8551790714263916,
-0.9388153553009033,
0.34994813799858093,
-0.5924561619758606,
-0.3475244641304016,
-0.4348280131816864,
0.14447911083698273,
-0.2160523384809494,
-0.4087776839733124,
-0.5485552549362183,
-0.6226606965065002,
0.3317357003688812,
1.348412036895752,
0.02226989157497883,
0.013185360468924046,
-0.3960009217262268,
0.5923067331314087,
0.5203846096992493,
0.19695362448692322,
0.17008602619171143,
-0.6319183707237244,
0.21114589273929596,
0.12037970870733261,
0.12872761487960815,
-1.1290535926818848,
0.3785420060157776,
-0.1946401745080948,
0.6022448539733887,
0.4045639634132385,
0.21670855581760406,
0.7267255187034607,
-0.4816557466983795,
0.8169785737991333,
-0.1433059722185135,
-0.7876126170158386,
0.2837533950805664,
0.037229131907224655,
0.02430817298591137,
0.16961412131786346,
0.3568287491798401,
-0.4576300382614136,
-0.722780168056488,
-0.3826374411582947,
-0.36678391695022583,
0.3137381076812744,
0.12764889001846313,
0.40107282996177673,
-0.15676380693912506,
0.3413175940513611,
0.43497776985168457,
0.28698647022247314,
-1.023857593536377,
-0.2955082654953003,
0.19046971201896667,
0.24269498884677887,
0.08562630414962769,
-0.5717601776123047,
-0.2855563163757324,
-0.035788778215646744,
0.2257874459028244,
0.0839637741446495,
0.5572406649589539,
0.11747824400663376,
-0.41485822200775146,
-0.3644179105758667,
0.09397946298122406,
0.8972377777099609,
0.8571372628211975,
-0.43241292238235474,
0.5704385042190552,
0.2857878804206848,
-0.31325703859329224,
0.0774184912443161,
-0.49502548575401306,
-0.061606887727975845,
-0.005125583149492741,
0.449636310338974,
0.8925024271011353,
-0.027970261871814728,
-0.6880515217781067,
0.38859251141548157,
-0.3689723312854767,
-0.2806522846221924,
-0.6331672072410583,
0.1756867915391922,
0.26229074597358704,
0.21681565046310425,
0.4074786603450775,
-0.18916045129299164,
0.1406879723072052,
-0.8082927465438843,
0.2082855999469757,
0.3907444477081299,
-0.4119862914085388,
-0.5671151280403137,
0.7856971025466919,
-0.2649993598461151,
-0.49509379267692566,
0.5156222581863403,
-0.2615850269794464,
-0.6208423972129822,
0.6284496188163757,
0.7321808934211731,
0.8436896800994873,
-0.05832093954086304,
0.19286930561065674,
0.09092242270708084,
0.34491705894470215,
0.17701885104179382,
0.5687530040740967,
-0.1182994693517685,
-0.7518962025642395,
-0.30750784277915955,
-0.7492818236351013,
-0.36606365442276,
0.6085098385810852,
-0.7298546433448792,
0.02628292888402939,
-0.328943133354187,
0.14303117990493774,
-0.29593148827552795,
-0.17620301246643066,
-0.5311760902404785,
0.149469256401062,
0.40568989515304565,
0.5334222316741943,
-0.975601315498352,
0.6435182094573975,
0.2850797474384308,
-0.34865400195121765,
-0.5966863036155701,
0.4121122658252716,
0.007952176965773106,
-1.144913911819458,
0.6857583522796631,
0.41125020384788513,
-0.5094553828239441,
-0.05372840166091919,
-0.702045202255249,
-0.7203431129455566,
0.8000448346138,
0.20356108248233795,
-0.5308820605278015,
0.2659251093864441,
0.49429914355278015,
0.685840904712677,
-0.08034013211727142,
0.07091903686523438,
0.5925013422966003,
0.3708423376083374,
0.17104952037334442,
-0.5145360827445984,
0.31473419070243835,
0.0026188241317868233,
-0.22028210759162903,
0.006259423214942217,
-0.4712211787700653,
0.6291239261627197,
-0.5611361861228943,
-0.5433939695358276,
0.18030229210853577,
0.8889021277427673,
0.538393497467041,
0.4075366258621216,
0.35581010580062866,
0.4138294458389282,
1.0297964811325073,
0.17173048853874207,
0.9843451380729675,
-0.22714462876319885,
0.031021520495414734,
0.8758153915405273,
-0.6125704050064087,
0.9023499488830566,
0.7639496922492981,
0.09348853677511215,
0.34968888759613037,
0.805884063243866,
0.2554134726524353,
0.5324812531471252,
0.6108295917510986,
-0.2931439280509949,
-0.23670822381973267,
-0.2170080840587616,
-0.3279690146446228,
0.21995384991168976,
0.46886488795280457,
-0.17576904594898224,
0.25714680552482605,
0.22020073235034943,
0.11837008595466614,
0.027827387675642967,
-0.14053340256214142,
0.7689391374588013,
0.19759024679660797,
-0.5888407230377197,
0.9258105158805847,
-0.27231284976005554,
0.35495468974113464,
-0.30697667598724365,
-0.15597304701805115,
-0.669552743434906,
0.0724516436457634,
-0.29449793696403503,
-0.7855820655822754,
0.2862541079521179,
0.01741061545908451,
-0.19146838784217834,
-0.06642802059650421,
0.6247367262840271,
-0.3014221489429474,
-0.3815039396286011,
0.5028690099716187,
0.4542904794216156,
0.6816033124923706,
-0.14980195462703705,
-0.24089249968528748,
0.28924354910850525,
0.009459436871111393,
-0.3445364236831665,
0.43788737058639526,
0.48100101947784424,
-0.16439780592918396,
0.8654579520225525,
0.5593562722206116,
0.35391560196876526,
0.5085158348083496,
0.2667718827724457,
0.7808864116668701,
-0.7388753294944763,
-0.049483463168144226,
-0.7994459271430969,
0.16862063109874725,
0.17415376007556915,
-0.03735670447349548,
0.809763491153717,
0.5673693418502808,
0.7389017343521118,
-0.33927348256111145,
0.6255367398262024,
0.2638343572616577,
0.49851885437965393,
-0.7169111371040344,
0.7907394170761108,
-0.7680943012237549,
0.6472483277320862,
0.0991421788930893,
-1.0487887859344482,
-0.3141762912273407,
0.6940837502479553,
-0.39867645502090454,
-0.3184487521648407,
0.8060109615325928,
1.1974756717681885,
0.142855703830719,
0.04194929823279381,
0.7191386222839355,
0.5349577069282532,
0.04666701331734657,
0.3741437792778015,
1.5867795944213867,
-0.18915140628814697,
0.3605409562587738,
-0.30782604217529297,
0.13654661178588867,
-0.203749418258667,
-0.6191356182098389,
-0.9298532605171204,
-0.5658584833145142,
-0.28144651651382446,
-0.15255558490753174,
-0.0022778173442929983,
0.5465655326843262,
0.22316507995128632,
-0.7592072486877441,
-0.47525396943092346,
-0.08029641211032867,
0.23487135767936707,
-0.0429602786898613,
-0.21063169836997986,
0.43511781096458435,
-0.16641555726528168,
-0.46601760387420654,
0.6490756869316101,
0.29682615399360657,
0.23903672397136688,
-0.43664616346359253,
-0.1105555072426796,
0.009616869501769543,
0.355364054441452,
0.43328043818473816,
0.05245181545615196,
-0.9659009575843811,
-0.4163433313369751,
0.39548128843307495,
-0.23946429789066315,
0.12061881273984909,
0.7877775430679321,
-0.7850661277770996,
0.1989315301179886,
0.45268747210502625,
0.31124505400657654,
0.4161074161529541,
-0.2781636118888855,
0.18863464891910553,
-0.5719304084777832,
0.13648292422294617,
0.28792157769203186,
0.3311395049095154,
0.2030956745147705,
-0.4778832197189331,
0.3893645107746124,
0.12397085130214691,
-0.5707131028175354,
-1.1488105058670044,
0.3354593515396118,
-0.7511588335037231,
-0.5612064003944397,
1.3509398698806763,
0.31771913170814514,
-0.4839097857475281,
0.005106812343001366,
-0.29420652985572815,
0.31953203678131104,
-0.009974830783903599,
1.1285046339035034,
0.7682372331619263,
-0.344542920589447,
-0.1816958338022232,
-0.6053521633148193,
0.44527485966682434,
0.3879433274269104,
-0.7277745604515076,
0.3307168483734131,
0.4496408700942993,
0.21453356742858887,
0.04522468522191048,
0.5691418051719666,
0.1122560128569603,
-0.013033167459070683,
-0.04168692231178284,
0.10660770535469055,
0.2975957989692688,
-0.4097763001918793,
-0.4932483434677124,
0.041476596146821976,
0.2337128072977066,
-0.15203247964382172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09727v2 | A Human-Inspired Reading Agent with Gist Memory of Very Long Contexts | 2024-02-15T05:40:21 | 2024-02-23T18:21:28 | Kuang-Huei Lee, Xinyun Chen, Hiroki Furuta, John Canny, Ian Fischer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Current Large Language Models (LLMs) are not only limited to some maximum
context length, but also are not able to robustly consume long inputs. To
address these limitations, we propose ReadAgent, an LLM agent system that
increases effective context length up to 20x in our experiments. Inspired by
how humans interactively read long documents, we implement ReadAgent as a
simple prompting system that uses the advanced language capabilities of LLMs to
(1) decide what content to store together in a memory episode, (2) compress
those memory episodes into short episodic memories called gist memories, and
(3) take actions to look up passages in the original text if ReadAgent needs to
remind itself of relevant details to complete a task. We evaluate ReadAgent
against baselines using retrieval methods, using the original long contexts,
and using the gist memories. These evaluations are performed on three
long-document reading comprehension tasks: QuALITY, NarrativeQA, and QMSum.
ReadAgent outperforms the baselines on all three tasks while extending the
effective context window by 3-20x. | [
-0.26793572306632996,
-0.8219103813171387,
0.8591371774673462,
-0.142300084233284,
-0.4531410336494446,
0.2648817002773285,
-0.46406999230384827,
-0.5459363460540771,
0.253494530916214,
0.47593000531196594,
-0.5030490756034851,
-0.31060561537742615,
-0.3407401442527771,
0.2451019138097763,
-0.3856312930583954,
1.0478651523590088,
-0.13036629557609558,
-0.414814293384552,
-0.06516724824905396,
-0.06513442099094391,
-0.44674015045166016,
-0.24353352189064026,
-0.6822873950004578,
-0.5900397300720215,
0.855851948261261,
0.6215201616287231,
0.7405544519424438,
0.6100548505783081,
0.15783436596393585,
0.3262752890586853,
-0.1861591637134552,
0.2427104115486145,
-0.5603155493736267,
0.3845503330230713,
-0.29941749572753906,
-0.5582999587059021,
-0.4667914807796478,
-0.41070473194122314,
0.49654218554496765,
0.24658912420272827,
-0.025581516325473785,
-0.1729380190372467,
0.08135014027357101,
0.5729696750640869,
-0.4517662227153778,
0.10641906410455704,
-0.19428153336048126,
-0.08003488928079605,
0.14036397635936737,
-0.40409019589424133,
-0.6167387366294861,
-0.11943016201257706,
0.500272274017334,
-0.7167291641235352,
0.13318008184432983,
-0.005330453626811504,
0.7195905447006226,
0.14066378772258759,
-0.39555349946022034,
-0.48612499237060547,
-0.624807596206665,
0.4204607605934143,
-0.2453872561454773,
0.1833854615688324,
0.4462457597255707,
0.27155590057373047,
-0.005448725540190935,
-0.6500318050384521,
-0.641666054725647,
-0.4067419171333313,
-0.06664874404668808,
0.10966726392507553,
-0.07589222490787506,
-0.08371804654598236,
0.1985611915588379,
-0.13557307422161102,
-0.5830185413360596,
-0.28873422741889954,
-0.15149334073066711,
-0.10117447376251221,
0.12246614694595337,
0.1103472113609314,
0.43847912549972534,
-0.10694295912981033,
-0.6813578605651855,
-0.15809686481952667,
-0.32218796014785767,
-0.022255893796682358,
0.1289990097284317,
-0.15404397249221802,
0.15786734223365784,
0.2759953439235687,
-0.19527378678321838,
0.5604822039604187,
-0.14406068623065948,
0.022251609712839127,
0.0222649946808815,
0.057797327637672424,
0.015745997428894043,
0.11770473420619965,
0.42348653078079224,
0.4380396604537964,
0.5675865411758423,
-0.3191627860069275,
-0.4651957154273987,
-0.11195465177297592,
0.44251465797424316,
-0.8141813278198242,
-0.20211172103881836,
-0.021038619801402092,
-0.06795080006122589,
-0.020896708592772484,
0.14219029247760773,
-0.738395631313324,
-0.541481077671051,
-0.2564021050930023,
0.5384854674339294,
-0.8652332425117493,
0.06039615347981453,
0.24212664365768433,
-0.43356600403785706,
0.30114316940307617,
0.558133602142334,
-0.8955792784690857,
0.20262955129146576,
0.4765811860561371,
1.0495669841766357,
-0.1411636620759964,
-0.6022000908851624,
-0.3999781906604767,
0.35479244589805603,
-0.09560484439134598,
1.0599966049194336,
-0.48895543813705444,
-0.28565162420272827,
-0.1591014564037323,
0.22241581976413727,
0.028169184923171997,
-0.17580333352088928,
0.35486021637916565,
-0.884032666683197,
-0.019537024199962616,
-0.10672594606876373,
-0.5270102620124817,
-0.16200947761535645,
0.5207820534706116,
-0.6660414338111877,
0.7675527334213257,
0.36891236901283264,
-0.49768954515457153,
0.1595923900604248,
-0.7440196871757507,
-0.514335572719574,
0.2604670226573944,
0.2091347873210907,
0.020697811618447304,
0.0013621613616123796,
0.44369447231292725,
0.36474451422691345,
-0.04652988538146019,
0.05394689366221428,
0.14221937954425812,
-0.5973507761955261,
0.32609084248542786,
-0.7663177847862244,
0.3300689458847046,
0.09080137312412262,
-0.2729262709617615,
0.3088516294956207,
-0.47761058807373047,
0.003755237441509962,
0.2556818127632141,
-0.567878246307373,
-0.5177797675132751,
-0.08190873265266418,
-0.1364835947751999,
-0.22274599969387054,
0.3568043112754822,
-0.5736228823661804,
0.43429598212242126,
-0.1879315972328186,
0.6886115670204163,
0.7599732279777527,
0.05794629454612732,
0.6626277565956116,
-0.6773661971092224,
0.7066026329994202,
-0.20739391446113586,
-0.26794859766960144,
-0.7593815326690674,
0.07104489952325821,
-0.7899852395057678,
-0.4257717430591583,
-0.06830481439828873,
0.5817502737045288,
-0.8776338696479797,
0.4439893662929535,
-0.5044430494308472,
-0.3054022789001465,
-0.03219342976808548,
0.07021963596343994,
0.21233850717544556,
0.5116039514541626,
0.20722287893295288,
0.048525694757699966,
0.08369889110326767,
-0.4778546690940857,
-0.1669364720582962,
-0.31702369451522827,
-0.2686275541782379,
0.37072643637657166,
0.5456269383430481,
-0.4863271117210388,
1.0778108835220337,
-0.7297070622444153,
-0.07232396304607391,
-0.31283682584762573,
-0.10179995000362396,
0.08995998650789261,
0.15090137720108032,
0.2238304316997528,
-0.4019639790058136,
-0.4203639626502991,
0.10406311601400375,
-0.6812313199043274,
-0.11929073184728622,
-0.31520727276802063,
-0.2154606580734253,
0.05056195333600044,
0.6982936263084412,
-0.8571626543998718,
0.19100543856620789,
0.16155819594860077,
-0.7076036930084229,
0.5203245878219604,
-0.714570164680481,
0.06502077728509903,
-1.0730253458023071,
-0.002999855438247323,
-0.32316598296165466,
-0.6605817675590515,
-0.44229093194007874,
0.28749579191207886,
0.4982813596725464,
-0.2718122601509094,
-0.41631585359573364,
1.067188024520874,
-0.8906669616699219,
0.059653040021657944,
-0.4504722058773041,
0.2640362083911896,
0.2520752251148224,
0.4458330571651459,
-0.05535493418574333,
1.0279005765914917,
0.33535122871398926,
-0.4072263538837433,
0.4347771108150482,
0.2748706340789795,
-0.3884463310241699,
0.5992202162742615,
-0.48020225763320923,
0.43414506316185,
-0.26104220747947693,
0.6021393537521362,
-0.9302328824996948,
-0.3703303635120392,
0.17658142745494843,
-0.21615023910999298,
0.32404786348342896,
0.1971868872642517,
-0.5462867617607117,
-0.27233707904815674,
-0.16250640153884888,
0.031669046729803085,
0.4491178095340729,
-0.875740110874176,
0.7358091473579407,
-0.1744992583990097,
-0.45013627409935,
-0.30029037594795227,
-0.5809732675552368,
0.42658665776252747,
-0.2694697678089142,
-0.8078635931015015,
0.12117517739534378,
-0.10904815047979355,
0.022738037630915642,
-0.03321704640984535,
0.033707816153764725,
0.04971182346343994,
-0.11266770958900452,
0.08998822420835495,
0.09867013245820999,
-0.13558419048786163,
0.5051138997077942,
0.05218416079878807,
-0.1683703064918518,
-0.10651425272226334,
-0.47781550884246826,
0.6340784430503845,
-0.5002298355102539,
0.08543097227811813,
-0.1853167861700058,
0.554743766784668,
0.6644203066825867,
-0.11191941797733307,
0.5366712808609009,
0.37889349460601807,
-0.22616423666477203,
-0.44177812337875366,
-0.29874250292778015,
-0.25816676020622253,
-0.5370159149169922,
0.4710312485694885,
-0.6476584076881409,
-1.0755161046981812,
0.6390829086303711,
-0.1627432405948639,
-0.1902056336402893,
0.04229965806007385,
0.43263301253318787,
-0.16734954714775085,
0.6452347040176392,
0.2683858871459961,
-0.25770336389541626,
0.8557613492012024,
-0.1991712599992752,
-0.2740188539028168,
-0.7577031850814819,
0.19917359948158264,
-0.08638375997543335,
-0.4253099858760834,
0.23769748210906982,
-0.5136632919311523,
0.1771734207868576,
0.21790467202663422,
-0.35876232385635376,
0.22754459083080292,
-0.5010000467300415,
1.019661784172058,
0.2637024521827698,
0.3622753322124481,
0.29173463582992554,
-0.027289658784866333,
-0.31716203689575195,
0.3891121745109558,
-0.3969966471195221,
-0.8512823581695557,
0.7270532250404358,
0.4268239140510559,
1.0317789316177368,
0.26585206389427185,
0.5965173840522766,
0.5968217253684998,
0.26391056180000305,
-1.099852442741394,
0.792219877243042,
0.3022284209728241,
-0.6581025123596191,
-0.7097837924957275,
-0.024436522275209427,
-1.310043454170227,
0.2585998475551605,
0.382571816444397,
-0.7726941704750061,
-0.009206072427332401,
-0.26261118054389954,
-0.2760847210884094,
0.2126307636499405,
-0.6683545112609863,
0.5407090187072754,
-0.25015243887901306,
-0.2379673421382904,
-0.19863714277744293,
-0.753792405128479,
-0.12419191747903824,
-0.03809884563088417,
-0.23957757651805878,
0.10737431794404984,
-0.5815871357917786,
0.3768397867679596,
-0.5326467156410217,
0.8202497363090515,
0.05045551434159279,
-0.1404028981924057,
0.5945588946342468,
0.2777530550956726,
0.8708147406578064,
0.11914768069982529,
-0.1610816866159439,
-0.2925156354904175,
0.01942402496933937,
-0.5642757415771484,
-0.8830698132514954,
0.5451664924621582,
-0.8904266953468323,
-0.6441621780395508,
-0.4869033098220825,
-0.6078061461448669,
-0.10467904061079025,
0.48642680048942566,
0.13693521916866302,
0.36827707290649414,
-0.3860299587249756,
0.1771048903465271,
0.6049232482910156,
0.11117830872535706,
0.6374386548995972,
0.7059162855148315,
0.0628676638007164,
-0.44140470027923584,
0.7520070672035217,
-0.10853943228721619,
0.37086477875709534,
0.4246204197406769,
0.3269328474998474,
-0.28681185841560364,
-0.19747532904148102,
-0.7302098274230957,
0.15970855951309204,
-0.8596460223197937,
0.048660699278116226,
-0.6794738173484802,
-0.1440194696187973,
0.10292018204927444,
-0.6594168543815613,
0.1989799588918686,
0.09434932470321655,
-0.6313758492469788,
-0.11268515139818192,
0.5818510055541992,
0.6690167188644409,
0.25732654333114624,
0.7246730923652649,
-0.9128974676132202,
0.2522144615650177,
0.3314210772514343,
0.3618091940879822,
0.18683679401874542,
-0.5636197328567505,
-0.34621894359588623,
-0.2718607783317566,
-0.23359324038028717,
-1.0413974523544312,
0.6202404499053955,
0.06310564279556274,
0.30587223172187805,
0.6198074221611023,
0.10815635323524475,
0.4770009219646454,
-0.675183892250061,
0.5118622779846191,
-0.1245666891336441,
-0.7034087181091309,
0.24566902220249176,
-0.7955430746078491,
0.8167580366134644,
0.6565887928009033,
0.1265992969274521,
-0.7000594735145569,
-0.2790945768356323,
-0.2793370187282562,
-0.6956565976142883,
0.462427020072937,
-0.06555216759443283,
0.3883567452430725,
-0.2714216411113739,
0.5968716740608215,
0.10155117511749268,
-0.23888635635375977,
-0.30518224835395813,
0.4806338846683502,
-0.0006371396593749523,
-0.09151820093393326,
-0.31814613938331604,
-0.3158826231956482,
0.08287139981985092,
-0.04074633866548538,
0.27868524193763733,
-0.5290553569793701,
0.42090630531311035,
0.5735713839530945,
-0.5697711110115051,
-0.08138356357812881,
0.731381893157959,
0.7697111368179321,
0.8689796328544617,
-0.27464547753334045,
0.22898828983306885,
0.3305497467517853,
-0.8671336770057678,
0.6427890062332153,
-0.024009423330426216,
-0.10440029948949814,
-0.2199268490076065,
0.34771454334259033,
0.6191814541816711,
0.09436400234699249,
-0.8696840405464172,
0.3062160015106201,
-0.28343743085861206,
-0.04492936655879021,
-0.5338893532752991,
0.2168881893157959,
0.4590825140476227,
0.699690043926239,
0.509028971195221,
-0.21755319833755493,
-0.15976865589618683,
-0.42715519666671753,
0.4155927300453186,
-0.037434328347444534,
-0.7554261088371277,
-0.18238618969917297,
0.36640727519989014,
0.3871769905090332,
-0.6215986609458923,
0.6219571828842163,
-0.2984623312950134,
-0.5206620097160339,
0.5692405700683594,
0.7413104176521301,
0.8002176880836487,
0.11213404685258865,
0.13930490612983704,
-0.046442415565252304,
0.1888708770275116,
-0.3702746629714966,
0.3015987277030945,
-0.12633654475212097,
-0.7350941896438599,
-0.24560990929603577,
-0.4940652549266815,
-0.3645857274532318,
-0.04865722358226776,
-0.49691110849380493,
0.043096546083688736,
-0.3657803535461426,
-0.16860316693782806,
-0.24309886991977692,
0.28863149881362915,
-0.4138721227645874,
0.0964977815747261,
-0.11772547662258148,
0.9739989042282104,
-0.3319648504257202,
0.9873406291007996,
0.6748097538948059,
-0.22647324204444885,
-0.5175080895423889,
0.25101256370544434,
0.04530428722500801,
-0.5900852680206299,
0.4213849604129791,
0.3975788652896881,
-0.24443501234054565,
0.3349088430404663,
-0.3982493579387665,
-0.6377103328704834,
1.417284369468689,
0.2898598611354828,
-0.8725226521492004,
-0.2551422119140625,
-0.37948888540267944,
0.6959984302520752,
-0.503671407699585,
0.2571573555469513,
0.5824429392814636,
0.3505244851112366,
0.08639094978570938,
-0.4260028898715973,
0.24375806748867035,
-0.21974071860313416,
-0.30501076579093933,
0.32416030764579773,
-0.8658604621887207,
0.6814991235733032,
-0.527294933795929,
-0.2753506600856781,
0.40456363558769226,
0.7315751314163208,
0.2465326189994812,
0.29474136233329773,
0.6123997569084167,
0.400512158870697,
0.8745362162590027,
0.42567968368530273,
1.3580926656723022,
-0.172299325466156,
0.09033966064453125,
1.168246865272522,
-0.35878920555114746,
0.7514939308166504,
0.1941218376159668,
0.11743216216564178,
0.6559419631958008,
0.5452595353126526,
0.16056512296199799,
0.3012426197528839,
0.19151842594146729,
-0.6381450295448303,
-0.26710548996925354,
-0.024555332958698273,
-0.006959097925573587,
0.16866785287857056,
0.285808265209198,
-0.45214906334877014,
-0.2287915199995041,
0.24720343947410583,
0.18570354580879211,
-0.011061077937483788,
-0.1954427808523178,
0.6957221031188965,
0.1188991591334343,
-0.7148244380950928,
0.34500452876091003,
-0.13090567290782928,
0.5170342326164246,
-0.6004512906074524,
0.08728247880935669,
-0.11501710116863251,
0.4212600886821747,
0.36828944087028503,
-1.104745864868164,
-0.1670428365468979,
0.029295295476913452,
-0.3711882531642914,
-0.30752915143966675,
1.094151258468628,
-0.2562653124332428,
-0.17278166115283966,
0.4767525792121887,
0.554217517375946,
0.3300924301147461,
-0.21710173785686493,
-0.36524319648742676,
-0.24484483897686005,
-0.1912851780653,
-0.6703159213066101,
0.2536375820636749,
0.7217617630958557,
-0.32868722081184387,
0.8276748061180115,
0.6579168438911438,
0.06047125160694122,
-0.2487868368625641,
0.06933523714542389,
0.8550511598587036,
-1.1181060075759888,
-0.7840642929077148,
-0.8389161229133606,
0.2583337426185608,
0.10890624672174454,
-0.3821243345737457,
0.5008442997932434,
0.38672295212745667,
0.34835267066955566,
-0.01620522327721119,
0.7781686186790466,
0.29575520753860474,
0.42279648780822754,
-0.25781288743019104,
1.05763578414917,
-0.3555653989315033,
0.0867256447672844,
-0.0022899413015693426,
-0.8863144516944885,
0.0632702112197876,
0.5054418444633484,
-0.33701291680336,
-0.005628377664834261,
0.7682311534881592,
0.5608495473861694,
0.0016461792401969433,
-0.008085831999778748,
0.6056755781173706,
0.06729735434055328,
0.41144299507141113,
0.7092711925506592,
1.0917649269104004,
-0.007351854350417852,
0.6936538219451904,
0.5179264545440674,
-0.21337273716926575,
-0.325568288564682,
-0.7084883451461792,
-1.1952619552612305,
-0.2896213233470917,
0.2312925010919571,
-0.3507307469844818,
0.3206925690174103,
0.7099303603172302,
0.46069175004959106,
-0.21022619307041168,
-0.0728747546672821,
0.01462426409125328,
0.025171585381031036,
0.05109097436070442,
-0.23785856366157532,
0.27933865785598755,
-0.17964951694011688,
-0.6031186580657959,
0.3973010778427124,
0.5080646872520447,
0.1579185575246811,
-0.3798740804195404,
-0.3274945914745331,
-0.23602311313152313,
0.40666142106056213,
0.708770215511322,
0.351445734500885,
-0.6003151535987854,
-0.556585967540741,
0.19667045772075653,
-0.523702085018158,
0.1854446530342102,
0.6429377794265747,
-0.9602450132369995,
0.6838120222091675,
0.8016194105148315,
0.7544897198677063,
0.6847922801971436,
0.2668812870979309,
0.4405968487262726,
-0.3582860231399536,
0.05208342522382736,
0.43272268772125244,
0.16843020915985107,
0.03850023075938225,
-0.5985647439956665,
0.5160952210426331,
-0.18557322025299072,
-0.8193016648292542,
-0.2597271203994751,
0.023244306445121765,
-0.9839509725570679,
-0.5525771379470825,
1.298350214958191,
-0.260560542345047,
-0.6995477080345154,
-0.19523683190345764,
-0.6242477893829346,
0.05792531371116638,
-0.8098272681236267,
0.4367600679397583,
0.9122763872146606,
-0.12218695133924484,
-0.4082455039024353,
-0.44157612323760986,
0.12704528868198395,
0.21003517508506775,
-0.8480702638626099,
0.1124013289809227,
0.608323872089386,
0.4720522165298462,
0.03090326488018036,
0.6930640339851379,
0.2875266671180725,
0.36304226517677307,
0.17612051963806152,
0.08950314670801163,
-0.22790735960006714,
-0.5867591500282288,
-0.398775190114975,
0.10779222846031189,
-0.20238621532917023,
0.22416257858276367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09725v1 | Improving Non-autoregressive Machine Translation with Error Exposure and Consistency Regularization | 2024-02-15T05:35:04 | 2024-02-15T05:35:04 | Xinran Chen, Sufeng Duan, Gongshen Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Being one of the IR-NAT (Iterative-refinemennt-based NAT) frameworks, the
Conditional Masked Language Model (CMLM) adopts the mask-predict paradigm to
re-predict the masked low-confidence tokens. However, CMLM suffers from the
data distribution discrepancy between training and inference, where the
observed tokens are generated differently in the two cases. In this paper, we
address this problem with the training approaches of error exposure and
consistency regularization (EECR). We construct the mixed sequences based on
model prediction during training, and propose to optimize over the masked
tokens under imperfect observation conditions. We also design a consistency
learning method to constrain the data distribution for the masked tokens under
different observing situations to narrow down the gap between training and
inference. The experiments on five translation benchmarks obtains an average
improvement of 0.68 and 0.40 BLEU scores compared to the base models,
respectively, and our CMLMC-EECR achieves the best performance with a
comparable translation quality with the Transformer. The experiments results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. | [
-0.12591344118118286,
-0.4733439087867737,
0.14697623252868652,
0.20598065853118896,
-0.3633219003677368,
0.25313806533813477,
-0.39616096019744873,
-0.27402541041374207,
-0.019317684695124626,
0.4096601605415344,
-0.3265683054924011,
-0.5469532012939453,
-1.0245634317398071,
0.35119426250457764,
-0.30857017636299133,
0.825734555721283,
-0.38955485820770264,
0.05293150246143341,
0.2594565451145172,
-0.20402637124061584,
-0.7669000029563904,
-0.352610319852829,
-0.2225303053855896,
-0.07413699477910995,
0.10274748504161835,
0.3891555368900299,
0.6915158033370972,
0.9673870801925659,
0.38532117009162903,
0.25319990515708923,
0.28609248995780945,
0.7182332873344421,
-0.2698553204536438,
0.11888162046670914,
-0.005455809645354748,
-0.3923496901988983,
-0.17641416192054749,
-0.1965596079826355,
0.8331136107444763,
0.6542553305625916,
-0.17918621003627777,
-0.12874659895896912,
0.1956610530614853,
0.5903435349464417,
-0.6358913779258728,
0.11846423894166946,
-0.8472593426704407,
0.25830116868019104,
0.18077725172042847,
-0.05911913886666298,
-0.7163093090057373,
-0.15591859817504883,
-0.3283558189868927,
-0.5931873321533203,
0.39594751596450806,
0.4195449948310852,
0.8335390090942383,
0.5505232214927673,
-0.35863420367240906,
0.14420123398303986,
-0.7160667181015015,
1.0885577201843262,
-0.7249635457992554,
0.7211506962776184,
0.5385950803756714,
0.4156009256839752,
-0.19450348615646362,
-0.4879347085952759,
-0.47056639194488525,
0.060913607478141785,
-0.2771797478199005,
0.1896568387746811,
-0.06488558650016785,
0.016095371916890144,
-0.05440592020750046,
0.28525587916374207,
-0.6049988269805908,
0.04925786331295967,
-0.08758028596639633,
-0.48055920004844666,
0.62466961145401,
0.14331886172294617,
-0.04892541468143463,
0.0915527492761612,
-0.3578907549381256,
-0.12080864608287811,
-0.21068167686462402,
-0.2922039330005646,
0.1665583699941635,
0.3082561790943146,
-0.30248919129371643,
0.6407172679901123,
-0.20831012725830078,
0.7645125985145569,
0.36033758521080017,
-0.05445799604058266,
0.5810329914093018,
-0.2966769337654114,
-0.536948025226593,
-0.07680703699588776,
0.5874282121658325,
0.2753940224647522,
-0.08595315366983414,
-0.267318993806839,
-0.5425432920455933,
0.008718010038137436,
0.13977696001529694,
-0.4798247516155243,
-0.14349928498268127,
0.13949339091777802,
-0.5521805882453918,
-0.04028214514255524,
0.2505216598510742,
-0.6802651286125183,
0.10001720488071442,
-0.5465275049209595,
0.6544033885002136,
-0.3097767233848572,
-0.06925290077924728,
0.23313838243484497,
0.23606106638908386,
0.1466909646987915,
0.42539212107658386,
-0.6642675399780273,
0.36881253123283386,
0.3043387234210968,
0.7940171360969543,
-0.4051038324832916,
-0.07022099196910858,
-0.6702548861503601,
0.04171159118413925,
-0.5390851497650146,
0.44721880555152893,
-0.016591638326644897,
-0.12331705540418625,
-0.0664287731051445,
0.11864412575960159,
-0.6725422739982605,
-0.4752466082572937,
0.48385030031204224,
-0.4127430319786072,
0.21071858704090118,
0.3111116886138916,
-0.5729979276657104,
-0.13229678571224213,
0.2521383464336395,
-0.17659413814544678,
0.9406558275222778,
0.11422450840473175,
-0.7111780643463135,
0.15309351682662964,
-0.5047611594200134,
-0.39666253328323364,
-0.2860364019870758,
0.0768333300948143,
-0.7466110587120056,
0.20792974531650543,
0.27220407128334045,
0.12963558733463287,
0.07780881971120834,
0.6278955936431885,
0.19883184134960175,
-0.281257688999176,
0.25228744745254517,
-0.5798706412315369,
0.47202634811401367,
0.5308994650840759,
-0.7691643834114075,
0.028308389708399773,
-0.8440702557563782,
0.2807910442352295,
-0.07976889610290527,
-0.13346707820892334,
-0.012307621538639069,
-0.1677699089050293,
0.06462527066469193,
0.3398219645023346,
-0.026708146557211876,
-0.46260008215904236,
-0.06502770632505417,
-0.21313586831092834,
0.1856115609407425,
0.7587817311286926,
0.1385546624660492,
0.4200698137283325,
-0.2373911589384079,
0.34432342648506165,
0.3443535268306732,
0.31761932373046875,
-0.28134050965309143,
-0.37777388095855713,
-1.0840797424316406,
-0.44091737270355225,
0.5116074085235596,
0.6898953914642334,
-0.952129065990448,
0.6979066729545593,
-0.11641938239336014,
-0.1572125256061554,
-0.8297950625419617,
0.0736333578824997,
0.692222535610199,
0.7423511743545532,
0.68243408203125,
-0.3884946405887604,
-0.7958968281745911,
-0.9009285569190979,
-0.15642517805099487,
0.07529090344905853,
-0.0649254322052002,
0.12528055906295776,
0.3588569164276123,
-0.5622140169143677,
0.5987345576286316,
-0.218319833278656,
-0.22325575351715088,
0.06278856843709946,
0.2738896310329437,
0.1761728674173355,
0.8546605706214905,
-0.01628047041594982,
-0.7406554818153381,
-0.8036775588989258,
0.12466045469045639,
-0.5854814052581787,
-0.1896660327911377,
-0.14001673460006714,
-0.41584378480911255,
0.5260491371154785,
0.3578731417655945,
-0.00009854167728917673,
0.6709047555923462,
0.8306883573532104,
-0.11241041868925095,
0.19576391577720642,
-0.22871485352516174,
0.23551982641220093,
-0.9527031779289246,
0.10218394547700882,
-0.20011955499649048,
-0.6757509708404541,
-0.7134935259819031,
-0.24965178966522217,
0.3069896697998047,
0.07915850728750229,
-0.48035305738449097,
0.3402596116065979,
-0.5627624988555908,
-0.010086040943861008,
-0.3065396845340729,
-0.09493124485015869,
0.31104564666748047,
0.44079679250717163,
0.11843188852071762,
0.7341889142990112,
0.434704065322876,
-0.5273321866989136,
-0.3058030903339386,
0.38451460003852844,
-0.11751264333724976,
0.4248442053794861,
-0.36559420824050903,
0.4146585464477539,
-0.16211840510368347,
0.1781432032585144,
-0.8119502663612366,
-0.16677269339561462,
0.4577627182006836,
-0.47988101840019226,
0.7867130637168884,
-0.007470134645700455,
-0.44866836071014404,
-0.06490448117256165,
-0.015404410660266876,
0.22436442971229553,
0.7155076265335083,
-0.417133092880249,
0.5373877286911011,
0.09328751266002655,
0.3764740526676178,
-0.7654606699943542,
-0.8955470323562622,
0.16496288776397705,
0.08013051003217697,
-0.3818439543247223,
0.3863680064678192,
-0.22213129699230194,
-0.16719679534435272,
-0.09021090716123581,
-0.2056775540113449,
-0.04752897843718529,
0.07437168061733246,
-0.02718435972929001,
0.21079345047473907,
-0.25488170981407166,
-0.15700992941856384,
0.0003650324360933155,
-0.21163339912891388,
-0.4855623245239258,
-0.6168755292892456,
0.31362849473953247,
-0.10148928314447403,
-0.42965272068977356,
-0.5593841671943665,
0.3868485391139984,
0.15581616759300232,
-0.08788391947746277,
0.9909306764602661,
0.3853629231452942,
-0.39681220054626465,
-0.08799684047698975,
-0.6778847575187683,
-0.02897062711417675,
-0.38831627368927,
0.030523838475346565,
-0.34360694885253906,
-0.5090844035148621,
0.4827596843242645,
0.38447999954223633,
0.08223382383584976,
0.49229976534843445,
0.42423099279403687,
-0.06893841177225113,
1.0188955068588257,
0.8285644054412842,
-0.0019183567492291331,
0.26358380913734436,
-0.06834837049245834,
0.13185575604438782,
-0.8855863213539124,
-0.20391753315925598,
-0.33108648657798767,
-0.17385274171829224,
-0.5088987350463867,
-0.6432819366455078,
0.24594655632972717,
0.12511976063251495,
-0.15911845862865448,
0.5156163573265076,
-0.40825557708740234,
0.13674867153167725,
0.41072678565979004,
0.1941702663898468,
0.3796391189098358,
0.11613099277019501,
-0.34002676606178284,
-0.0865531712770462,
-0.7889291644096375,
-0.31584039330482483,
0.9440984725952148,
0.400621235370636,
0.5698849558830261,
-0.055048711597919464,
0.7432061433792114,
0.33076971769332886,
0.4435443878173828,
-0.3494173288345337,
0.030961714684963226,
0.048087961971759796,
-0.4387868344783783,
-0.06331159919500351,
-0.5317373275756836,
-0.6449324488639832,
0.3559977114200592,
-0.05538123473525047,
-0.3419956564903259,
0.5559288859367371,
0.38768303394317627,
0.275145560503006,
0.2478591948747635,
-0.6890577673912048,
0.7012975215911865,
-0.24360167980194092,
-0.307113379240036,
0.2532646954059601,
-1.2190922498703003,
0.24080447852611542,
-0.3618055582046509,
0.413429319858551,
0.09878330677747726,
-0.06114131212234497,
0.2006944864988327,
-0.4294564127922058,
0.7938881516456604,
-0.18353083729743958,
0.21514423191547394,
0.30558639764785767,
0.03426232188940048,
0.7563262581825256,
-0.2618843615055084,
-0.1847887933254242,
0.4455590546131134,
-0.5151548981666565,
-0.5703780055046082,
-0.391108900308609,
0.04593217745423317,
-0.7825266122817993,
-0.3565426766872406,
-0.29888278245925903,
-0.6518132090568542,
-0.2226857990026474,
0.22274057567119598,
0.5364881157875061,
0.04264094680547714,
0.06390807777643204,
0.04129317030310631,
0.8815526962280273,
-0.13901008665561676,
0.3635904788970947,
0.6546400785446167,
0.0315319299697876,
-0.8368139266967773,
0.7064539194107056,
-0.023692626506090164,
0.7323517203330994,
0.5372276902198792,
0.0935540720820427,
-0.19650454819202423,
-0.870762825012207,
-0.7071205973625183,
0.0732342079281807,
-0.7460753321647644,
-0.5302799344062805,
-0.9758223295211792,
-0.3592803478240967,
-0.5091723799705505,
-0.12747454643249512,
-0.4594002962112427,
-0.3749461770057678,
-0.12523014843463898,
-0.024385152384638786,
0.15531864762306213,
0.19790376722812653,
-0.2285199761390686,
0.3284866511821747,
-0.681767463684082,
0.15378539264202118,
-0.24655987322330475,
0.24409574270248413,
-0.3231545686721802,
-1.0882606506347656,
-0.5475592613220215,
0.08658535033464432,
-0.15000353753566742,
-0.5535941123962402,
0.6255577802658081,
0.41728881001472473,
0.6126336455345154,
0.1235077753663063,
0.13185803592205048,
0.7931786775588989,
-0.7015920877456665,
0.39838361740112305,
0.17073145508766174,
-1.0141255855560303,
0.36529484391212463,
-0.23788195848464966,
0.2073013037443161,
0.7303259372711182,
-0.04158022627234459,
-0.6345929503440857,
-0.6843672394752502,
-0.6999293565750122,
-0.7253469228744507,
0.4455488622188568,
0.6900607943534851,
-0.05951675772666931,
-0.21649675071239471,
0.14078770577907562,
0.2803204655647278,
0.5148008465766907,
-0.7155101895332336,
-0.5772979259490967,
-0.5943592190742493,
-0.5005130767822266,
-0.3157665431499481,
-0.005826885346323252,
0.14956152439117432,
-0.06809771806001663,
0.9704345464706421,
-0.24477873742580414,
0.4163323938846588,
0.501865804195404,
-0.45051127672195435,
-0.501461386680603,
0.03261633962392807,
0.8267300724983215,
0.4995533227920532,
-0.20688162744045258,
0.25050511956214905,
0.11767144501209259,
-0.5060999393463135,
0.3009340465068817,
0.034390561282634735,
-0.3447520434856415,
0.45399922132492065,
0.23738127946853638,
0.7632202506065369,
-0.024687515571713448,
-0.43014010787010193,
0.5043303370475769,
0.11684424430131912,
-0.1846737563610077,
-0.20480559766292572,
-0.22875350713729858,
-0.3515385687351227,
-0.05861013010144234,
0.40836241841316223,
0.4247179925441742,
0.00922644603997469,
-0.1399098038673401,
0.5124250650405884,
0.22828273475170135,
-0.3723908066749573,
-0.1728058159351349,
0.8303762674331665,
-0.132989302277565,
-0.2130315750837326,
0.5480601787567139,
-0.21217386424541473,
-0.6162351369857788,
0.5845857262611389,
0.7239914536476135,
0.9961753487586975,
-0.5687901377677917,
0.026862729340791702,
0.3933142423629761,
0.5508580207824707,
-0.26216956973075867,
0.043829843401908875,
0.13591121137142181,
-0.6209813356399536,
-0.5276347398757935,
-0.4654083847999573,
-0.34188511967658997,
-0.2729717493057251,
-0.6128560304641724,
0.449658066034317,
-0.2059936821460724,
0.27020955085754395,
-0.4603167772293091,
-0.2662351727485657,
-0.772651731967926,
0.3394733667373657,
-0.10294149816036224,
0.7010682225227356,
-1.0821946859359741,
0.989746630191803,
0.24856337904930115,
-0.2618163824081421,
-0.8315648436546326,
0.014583444222807884,
-0.1707090139389038,
-0.9007708430290222,
0.5433644652366638,
0.1432904601097107,
0.12071839720010757,
0.12186097353696823,
-0.2624061107635498,
-0.9792158007621765,
0.9127653241157532,
0.1613287627696991,
-0.8210533261299133,
0.4023458957672119,
0.14003895223140717,
0.40809911489486694,
-0.5763846635818481,
-0.08142480254173279,
0.2593606412410736,
0.5512151122093201,
0.00647245766595006,
-1.0421189069747925,
-0.1557048261165619,
-0.08947741985321045,
0.03604922443628311,
0.3489014208316803,
-0.4797327220439911,
0.5927323698997498,
0.035242464393377304,
-0.2368619441986084,
0.04216640815138817,
0.5821965336799622,
-0.009061136282980442,
0.5027722120285034,
0.42886850237846375,
0.3607914447784424,
0.6029763221740723,
0.1555960476398468,
0.8747766017913818,
-0.10884712636470795,
0.4335527718067169,
1.2439603805541992,
-0.268127977848053,
0.6637585163116455,
0.5703995823860168,
0.035909172147512436,
0.2643238604068756,
0.6845679879188538,
-0.17081044614315033,
0.878334641456604,
0.08986321836709976,
-0.24329836666584015,
0.043514568358659744,
-0.0337039940059185,
-0.19705967605113983,
0.08379372954368591,
0.1342780441045761,
-0.7596500515937805,
-0.07555939257144928,
0.2737404406070709,
-0.06948306411504745,
0.28366777300834656,
-0.20687027275562286,
0.7243739366531372,
0.173700749874115,
-0.6553195714950562,
0.9039761424064636,
0.3068958520889282,
0.5608276128768921,
-0.20841336250305176,
-0.07254960387945175,
-0.4887995719909668,
0.15291045606136322,
-0.22027942538261414,
-0.1093919426202774,
0.5550879240036011,
-0.024103567004203796,
-0.28620049357414246,
-0.3087921142578125,
0.6438632607460022,
-0.4829563498497009,
-0.6148017644882202,
-0.003146315459161997,
0.4826219081878662,
0.3124258518218994,
0.24992069602012634,
-0.701143205165863,
0.09409309923648834,
0.1568571776151657,
0.044999897480010986,
0.2659100592136383,
0.42590105533599854,
-0.210752934217453,
0.36831215023994446,
0.5064938068389893,
-0.18846693634986877,
0.46322712302207947,
-0.22790776193141937,
0.6022824048995972,
-0.38768240809440613,
-0.23213492333889008,
-0.8124919533729553,
0.7213881611824036,
0.08040185272693634,
0.07392394542694092,
0.789112389087677,
0.7281084656715393,
0.7214294075965881,
-0.12594862282276154,
0.6116205453872681,
0.031678058207035065,
0.4974580407142639,
-0.6521846055984497,
0.36144131422042847,
-0.13079868257045746,
0.25601065158843994,
-0.05693706497550011,
-1.0249851942062378,
-0.6553648710250854,
0.6128178834915161,
0.03980487957596779,
-0.06316237151622772,
0.8775202035903931,
0.754298985004425,
-0.20992642641067505,
-0.4366558790206909,
0.607621967792511,
0.0839638039469719,
0.09846005588769913,
0.43097230792045593,
0.45665407180786133,
-0.9671815037727356,
0.35434916615486145,
-0.31394946575164795,
-0.13351452350616455,
-0.3082452714443207,
-1.1037143468856812,
-0.6551575064659119,
-0.292125940322876,
-0.6601977348327637,
-0.5292917490005493,
0.28772208094596863,
1.0030171871185303,
0.6925427913665771,
-0.9849447011947632,
0.06103212386369705,
-0.3644261956214905,
0.12219119071960449,
-0.4093457758426666,
-0.18534894287586212,
0.37938255071640015,
-0.5079842209815979,
-0.736964225769043,
0.4000494182109833,
0.11692441254854202,
0.3744291067123413,
0.006683879531919956,
-0.15621858835220337,
-0.13682948052883148,
0.1273719221353531,
0.2429361492395401,
0.22066348791122437,
-0.6988321542739868,
-0.518456220626831,
0.19058847427368164,
-0.19372102618217468,
0.5138859152793884,
0.5281627178192139,
-0.5075634717941284,
0.6447023153305054,
0.08356369286775589,
0.8189745545387268,
0.5080894231796265,
0.02463468722999096,
0.6716910004615784,
-1.0213911533355713,
0.23870010673999786,
0.23892541229724884,
0.32645532488822937,
0.6160447001457214,
-0.5227550268173218,
0.60508793592453,
0.18290546536445618,
-0.5626408457756042,
-0.8671043515205383,
0.14421463012695312,
-0.6141523122787476,
-0.02129850722849369,
1.0549885034561157,
-0.36796829104423523,
-0.28586873412132263,
-0.3933204114437103,
0.08849816024303436,
0.4400024712085724,
-0.13682149350643158,
0.7630267143249512,
0.4445387125015259,
-0.020297253504395485,
-0.22429467737674713,
-0.8093064427375793,
0.1687006801366806,
0.5485528707504272,
-0.5578269362449646,
-0.11202006042003632,
0.36074596643447876,
0.3824269771575928,
0.006435042712837458,
0.43686148524284363,
-0.26076409220695496,
0.02807323820888996,
-0.17401258647441864,
0.24575403332710266,
-0.06840928643941879,
-0.25930964946746826,
-0.5273911952972412,
-0.384397953748703,
0.10500399023294449,
-0.6468076109886169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09723v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09723v3 | Efficient Prompt Optimization Through the Lens of Best Arm Identification | 2024-02-15T05:31:13 | 2024-05-30T19:40:21 | Chengshuai Shi, Kun Yang, Zihan Chen, Jundong Li, Jing Yang, Cong Shen | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The remarkable instruction-following capability of large language models
(LLMs) has sparked a growing interest in automatically finding good prompts,
i.e., prompt optimization. Most existing works follow the scheme of selecting
from a pre-generated pool of candidate prompts. However, these designs mainly
focus on the generation strategy, while limited attention has been paid to the
selection method. Especially, the cost incurred during the selection (e.g.,
accessing LLM and evaluating the responses) is rarely explicitly considered. To
overcome this limitation, this work provides a principled framework, TRIPLE, to
efficiently perform prompt selection under an explicit budget constraint.
TRIPLE is built on a novel connection established between prompt optimization
and fixed-budget best arm identification (BAI-FB) in multi-armed bandits (MAB);
thus, it is capable of leveraging the rich toolbox from BAI-FB systematically
and also incorporating unique characteristics of prompt optimization. Extensive
experiments on multiple well-adopted tasks using various LLMs demonstrate the
remarkable performance improvement of TRIPLE over baselines while satisfying
the limited budget constraints. As an extension, variants of TRIPLE are
proposed to efficiently select examples for few-shot prompts, also achieving
superior empirical performance. | [
-0.46993809938430786,
-0.8214126229286194,
0.786159098148346,
0.2976219952106476,
-0.1625055968761444,
0.20219367742538452,
-0.1351308673620224,
-0.14839839935302734,
-0.19799980521202087,
0.4008995294570923,
-0.8300340175628662,
-0.35453683137893677,
-0.31921127438545227,
0.36256739497184753,
0.08619886636734009,
0.8421457409858704,
-0.17927052080631256,
-0.16961610317230225,
0.24626481533050537,
-0.11856422573328018,
-0.696519136428833,
-0.23065072298049927,
-0.9768813848495483,
-0.00119340093806386,
0.7412185668945312,
0.5620428919792175,
0.3296557366847992,
0.8503664135932922,
0.3346778452396393,
0.20071688294410706,
-0.0070884679444134235,
0.5474073886871338,
-0.22631259262561798,
0.04260370135307312,
0.1661604344844818,
-0.3827105462551117,
0.058595024049282074,
-0.02146325260400772,
0.7361229658126831,
0.4541388154029846,
0.04277896136045456,
0.13100062310695648,
0.19913198053836823,
0.7716124057769775,
-0.8334617018699646,
0.34138983488082886,
-0.4448988437652588,
-0.1818952113389969,
-0.347685307264328,
-0.152595654129982,
-0.3611377775669098,
-0.6689892411231995,
0.21799629926681519,
-0.7296475768089294,
0.15124279260635376,
0.3568468391895294,
0.9134154915809631,
0.2552333474159241,
-0.1338655948638916,
-0.4404294490814209,
-0.44929060339927673,
0.9374921321868896,
-0.25068071484565735,
-0.03554825112223625,
0.2957253158092499,
0.3392021059989929,
-0.2091144472360611,
-0.08474133908748627,
-0.3623895049095154,
-0.3202120065689087,
0.08379165828227997,
-0.11129125207662582,
-0.322341650724411,
0.2522856891155243,
0.3223109543323517,
0.15029276907444,
-0.3782888948917389,
0.2692234218120575,
-0.1912546306848526,
-0.40309205651283264,
0.37174004316329956,
0.1310940533876419,
0.23910324275493622,
-0.16907961666584015,
-0.48932144045829773,
-0.01351958978921175,
-0.7989811897277832,
0.13770902156829834,
0.5171589255332947,
0.5306624174118042,
-0.049605049192905426,
0.44319629669189453,
-0.092067651450634,
0.9314743876457214,
0.4163784384727478,
-0.3439335823059082,
0.20686233043670654,
-0.43653228878974915,
0.22597931325435638,
-0.20948977768421173,
0.6420506834983826,
0.35289543867111206,
0.13571079075336456,
0.17599307000637054,
-0.5205397605895996,
-0.2962716519832611,
-0.14420129358768463,
-0.650620698928833,
0.2021421492099762,
0.21664732694625854,
-0.37984174489974976,
-0.1926259845495224,
-0.2461262345314026,
-0.7855943441390991,
-0.3435482084751129,
-0.18425729870796204,
0.577227771282196,
-0.3902803957462311,
0.047242794185876846,
-0.27289482951164246,
-0.12184345722198486,
0.3916570544242859,
0.052546385675668716,
-0.9747880101203918,
0.005842725746333599,
0.6576884388923645,
1.0794371366500854,
-0.2115289270877838,
-0.20915478467941284,
-1.1252427101135254,
0.25217705965042114,
-0.6899799704551697,
0.835493266582489,
-0.5417301654815674,
-0.3607277572154999,
0.025130154564976692,
-0.5054875016212463,
0.04519864544272423,
-0.38213464617729187,
0.59840327501297,
-0.7063389420509338,
0.08552256971597672,
-0.24356991052627563,
-0.25187885761260986,
-0.09166032820940018,
0.12015463411808014,
-0.9146680235862732,
0.86553555727005,
0.17135389149188995,
-0.6009416580200195,
0.5022823214530945,
-0.7881392240524292,
-0.3526528477668762,
0.17382216453552246,
-0.05382958799600601,
-0.3637721538543701,
0.03309685364365578,
0.5984721779823303,
0.4676154851913452,
-0.6778913140296936,
0.35690945386886597,
-0.3580905497074127,
-0.33232206106185913,
-0.16420455276966095,
-0.33659690618515015,
0.8060822486877441,
0.3434242606163025,
-0.24313583970069885,
0.263196736574173,
-0.5952576994895935,
-0.29672494530677795,
0.11549197137355804,
-0.15685461461544037,
-0.18843330442905426,
-0.07819665223360062,
-0.48264846205711365,
-0.3848765194416046,
0.2277590036392212,
-0.373678058385849,
0.2917201519012451,
-0.6401894092559814,
0.14584881067276,
0.9323594570159912,
0.19574271142482758,
0.4369303584098816,
-0.33741340041160583,
0.5645013451576233,
-0.35015514492988586,
0.21382944285869598,
-0.41835349798202515,
-0.2763480246067047,
-0.370188444852829,
-0.790177583694458,
0.16346904635429382,
0.7243261933326721,
-0.9512664675712585,
0.22841724753379822,
0.3122708201408386,
-0.1454170048236847,
-0.3944399952888489,
0.17664480209350586,
0.4553092420101166,
0.6143574714660645,
0.24794071912765503,
0.3258424997329712,
-0.33869919180870056,
-1.009151577949524,
-0.22961097955703735,
-0.3436833620071411,
-0.013687189668416977,
0.5084343552589417,
0.004299675114452839,
-0.015518848784267902,
0.8321334719657898,
-0.7504615783691406,
-0.1793047934770584,
-0.5872625112533569,
0.14137530326843262,
0.6787185668945312,
0.19247785210609436,
0.7452120184898376,
-0.5123274922370911,
-0.5497124195098877,
-0.37374642491340637,
-0.2992266118526459,
-0.7027403116226196,
-0.4653816521167755,
-0.291525661945343,
0.26273077726364136,
0.2229665219783783,
-0.5839964747428894,
0.3238636255264282,
0.21027201414108276,
0.11483587324619293,
0.5786547064781189,
-0.1181543692946434,
-0.053715240210294724,
-0.9118402004241943,
0.03747475519776344,
0.15582068264484406,
0.22842645645141602,
-0.396177738904953,
0.2518399655818939,
0.22399012744426727,
-0.07364917546510696,
-0.06109090894460678,
0.9461138844490051,
-0.7752670049667358,
0.14342501759529114,
-0.34197670221328735,
0.21017014980316162,
-0.04382340982556343,
0.6762109398841858,
-0.05859273299574852,
0.9838537573814392,
0.9693357944488525,
-0.7214537262916565,
0.43097442388534546,
0.15167167782783508,
-0.08044985681772232,
0.6110999584197998,
-0.6833044290542603,
-0.010429621674120426,
-0.2668560743331909,
0.19578886032104492,
-0.9243160486221313,
-0.3109075725078583,
0.5202183723449707,
-0.20364268124103546,
0.5048293471336365,
-0.20478381216526031,
-0.366131454706192,
-0.5765458941459656,
-0.6354923844337463,
0.2714140713214874,
0.31405919790267944,
-0.8828144073486328,
0.6329441070556641,
0.2232269048690796,
-0.3147571086883545,
-0.9195756316184998,
-0.14124475419521332,
-0.159153014421463,
-0.39677688479423523,
-0.27299973368644714,
0.1869955062866211,
-0.2432347536087036,
-0.1611553132534027,
-0.5051804780960083,
-0.29956141114234924,
0.09748568385839462,
0.22191151976585388,
-0.05573336035013199,
0.7687946557998657,
-0.16353397071361542,
0.10735385119915009,
0.2083158791065216,
-0.44070059061050415,
-0.0770815759897232,
-0.1689813733100891,
0.37683358788490295,
-0.0853024497628212,
-0.22836759686470032,
-0.5381878614425659,
0.6490396857261658,
0.07841771095991135,
-0.2237272411584854,
0.4683055579662323,
0.6193669438362122,
-0.1388510763645172,
-0.29290351271629333,
-0.8041224479675293,
-0.1701701581478119,
-0.5254325270652771,
0.11366014182567596,
-0.6083559393882751,
-0.7390767335891724,
0.23224738240242004,
0.0674629881978035,
0.4293867349624634,
0.3380097448825836,
0.39541691541671753,
0.13754916191101074,
1.008985996246338,
0.45729634165763855,
-0.28613123297691345,
0.5572067499160767,
0.03497309237718582,
0.051568567752838135,
-0.8518832325935364,
-0.026094308122992516,
-0.7857245206832886,
-0.033643316477537155,
-0.31714746356010437,
-0.25980427861213684,
0.7300912737846375,
0.2491401582956314,
-0.2775103747844696,
0.2931683659553528,
-0.33588480949401855,
0.6827400326728821,
0.9298890829086304,
0.05974240228533745,
-0.21323131024837494,
-0.16490517556667328,
-0.35383138060569763,
0.48769283294677734,
-0.5569184422492981,
-0.5633033514022827,
1.178700566291809,
0.0850345715880394,
0.585496187210083,
0.06363825500011444,
0.9930207133293152,
0.11107086390256882,
0.11740260571241379,
-0.6718170046806335,
0.6465451121330261,
0.2692258656024933,
-0.5922437906265259,
-0.19842150807380676,
-0.6483607888221741,
-1.1269876956939697,
0.021475423127412796,
-0.0961185023188591,
-0.849448561668396,
-0.025477470830082893,
0.37203267216682434,
-1.1180247068405151,
0.10885170847177505,
-0.7598196268081665,
0.5553163886070251,
-0.29158324003219604,
-0.433437705039978,
-0.2287796437740326,
-0.839124321937561,
0.15595482289791107,
-0.3236837387084961,
0.17203892767429352,
-0.388987272977829,
-0.46813589334487915,
0.4942346215248108,
-0.14109864830970764,
0.4637305438518524,
-0.4425530433654785,
0.15966899693012238,
0.45846089720726013,
-0.017630906775593758,
0.6113147735595703,
0.1614224910736084,
-0.17398886382579803,
-0.06822125613689423,
-0.20576289296150208,
-0.3824182450771332,
-0.3818151354789734,
0.6080650687217712,
-0.7900246977806091,
-0.8908363580703735,
-0.23748908936977386,
-0.4730716347694397,
-0.5214444994926453,
0.46555471420288086,
0.0525483563542366,
0.8698256611824036,
-0.06785547733306885,
-0.06495361030101776,
0.5531499981880188,
-0.3871113657951355,
0.9959480166435242,
0.35590940713882446,
-0.02182791754603386,
-0.5188654065132141,
0.829866886138916,
-0.2787659466266632,
0.24739035964012146,
0.6360551714897156,
0.6285849213600159,
-0.327419638633728,
-0.7250764966011047,
-0.7677448391914368,
0.30059632658958435,
-0.5233144164085388,
-0.5203016400337219,
-0.5582656860351562,
0.13092078268527985,
-0.2319907248020172,
-0.3349452018737793,
0.11733222752809525,
-0.16382458806037903,
-0.6680845618247986,
-0.08453991264104843,
0.2538715600967407,
0.36998388171195984,
-0.5569666624069214,
0.4829837381839752,
-0.8061715364456177,
0.7107890248298645,
0.38371118903160095,
0.18363399803638458,
-0.13693994283676147,
-0.18183474242687225,
0.005075004417449236,
-0.20381808280944824,
-0.3550073206424713,
-0.9784627556800842,
0.21540014445781708,
0.18590311706066132,
0.9790105223655701,
0.6113002896308899,
0.20854830741882324,
0.4348014295101166,
-0.44755977392196655,
0.6230272650718689,
0.14199814200401306,
-0.8337486982345581,
0.4441826045513153,
-0.3326188325881958,
0.3775402009487152,
0.5012668371200562,
0.43458080291748047,
0.08930965512990952,
-0.1877107471227646,
-0.2609224319458008,
-0.8640806674957275,
1.037966012954712,
0.009274599142372608,
-0.005417729262262583,
-0.1590179055929184,
0.28892239928245544,
0.277221143245697,
0.21954484283924103,
-0.38983577489852905,
-0.1954454630613327,
0.28664305806159973,
-0.2971867322921753,
0.1980813592672348,
-0.37497246265411377,
-0.28341057896614075,
0.24077530205249786,
0.6917889714241028,
-0.3897782266139984,
0.29473331570625305,
-0.10005843639373779,
0.01885056495666504,
-0.008198649622499943,
0.059047747403383255,
0.528146505355835,
0.41231587529182434,
-0.09787613153457642,
-0.2606610357761383,
0.12389884144067764,
-0.2057519406080246,
0.04978933930397034,
0.23358219861984253,
-0.22473452985286713,
-0.08766184002161026,
0.2818416655063629,
0.934888482093811,
0.011467593722045422,
-0.5881901979446411,
0.6034895777702332,
0.21430037915706635,
0.09386914223432541,
-0.05453434959053993,
0.17657285928726196,
-0.39959806203842163,
0.5820533037185669,
0.7577303051948547,
0.2028442770242691,
0.3119550347328186,
-0.2622726559638977,
0.12371035665273666,
0.730394184589386,
0.11483742296695709,
0.062302131205797195,
0.4532356262207031,
0.4615285396575928,
-0.47387221455574036,
0.4539620876312256,
-0.19123336672782898,
-0.4593972861766815,
0.538370668888092,
0.42224714159965515,
1.2495105266571045,
-0.09426432102918625,
0.23871973156929016,
0.6497100591659546,
0.2788694202899933,
-0.0913342610001564,
0.35964757204055786,
-0.2950418293476105,
-0.6315268278121948,
-0.36161547899246216,
-0.4230758845806122,
-0.3872099220752716,
-0.3268534541130066,
-0.7073046565055847,
0.5731161236763,
-0.569402813911438,
-0.20991824567317963,
-0.13797244429588318,
0.1481042504310608,
-0.6520661115646362,
-0.23022517561912537,
0.44005781412124634,
0.6741960644721985,
-0.3914988338947296,
0.4422171413898468,
0.14102189242839813,
-0.2640504539012909,
-0.9804038405418396,
0.03469213470816612,
0.3786811828613281,
-1.3342150449752808,
0.42420142889022827,
0.4627949595451355,
-0.39254581928253174,
0.0389535166323185,
-0.5467743277549744,
-0.9951415657997131,
0.7504619359970093,
0.27109938859939575,
-0.5360821485519409,
-0.31745535135269165,
-0.49869564175605774,
-0.021788807585835457,
-0.428804874420166,
0.5453834533691406,
0.6531009078025818,
0.5725262761116028,
0.4561803638935089,
-0.7952160239219666,
-0.10888008028268814,
0.21034881472587585,
0.1091349646449089,
0.4806394875049591,
-0.7395079135894775,
0.6373282074928284,
-0.6907533407211304,
-0.3658555746078491,
0.4128992557525635,
0.6117476224899292,
0.7947434186935425,
0.35988369584083557,
0.5822657942771912,
0.09169496595859528,
0.7362321615219116,
-0.04311172291636467,
0.9062185287475586,
-0.3709988296031952,
0.0175827294588089,
0.7322098612785339,
-0.32141736149787903,
0.5464828610420227,
0.4941402077674866,
-0.012268816120922565,
0.34495043754577637,
0.8336966633796692,
0.02414831705391407,
0.7638279795646667,
0.23927079141139984,
-0.23196735978126526,
-0.0725332573056221,
0.03489524498581886,
-0.06432289630174637,
0.05369526147842407,
0.34930282831192017,
-0.0675797164440155,
-0.2618959844112396,
0.12006495893001556,
0.22705325484275818,
-0.2991013824939728,
-0.5301916003227234,
1.0206959247589111,
-0.2142966389656067,
-0.8476114273071289,
0.556190013885498,
-0.07249504327774048,
0.5559738874435425,
-0.7315388917922974,
-0.08156681060791016,
-0.376468300819397,
-0.09478560835123062,
0.20461909472942352,
-0.5240064263343811,
-0.047507528215646744,
0.14232049882411957,
-0.05882091820240021,
-0.3290216624736786,
0.5340211987495422,
-0.18622758984565735,
-0.3284257650375366,
-0.18170756101608276,
0.2656085789203644,
0.0578790009021759,
0.030470555648207664,
-0.6616760492324829,
0.3520718514919281,
0.1168159693479538,
-0.27989462018013,
-0.05761666223406792,
0.40449389815330505,
0.07843410223722458,
0.7477148175239563,
0.5387088060379028,
0.17697365581989288,
-0.3059578239917755,
-0.17551901936531067,
0.7221344709396362,
-0.6710764169692993,
-0.4701491594314575,
-1.0809341669082642,
0.24250341951847076,
-0.15387850999832153,
-0.42453670501708984,
0.4194831848144531,
0.3907918334007263,
0.43752527236938477,
0.08514560759067535,
0.6974045634269714,
0.10505295544862747,
0.8622393608093262,
-0.6299425959587097,
0.1602611392736435,
-0.4343458116054535,
0.39282041788101196,
-0.4691157341003418,
-1.0076581239700317,
-0.39163967967033386,
0.5583151578903198,
-0.25091564655303955,
-0.10015799850225449,
0.7562888264656067,
0.9687021970748901,
0.3525178134441376,
0.06197322905063629,
0.03403659537434578,
-0.3202228546142578,
0.16282223165035248,
0.6748535633087158,
0.8028077483177185,
0.17921511828899384,
0.6124353408813477,
-0.07362368702888489,
-0.5841135382652283,
-0.3632708787918091,
-0.9773774147033691,
-1.0552924871444702,
-0.47901031374931335,
-0.25141608715057373,
-0.028421878814697266,
-0.04331696033477783,
1.3987292051315308,
0.6156684756278992,
-0.6543247699737549,
-0.2759529650211334,
0.15392020344734192,
0.39107558131217957,
-0.35731834173202515,
-0.1593245565891266,
0.4594285488128662,
-0.5965394973754883,
-0.7226316928863525,
0.6312636733055115,
0.42684653401374817,
-0.0820879191160202,
-0.1423480361700058,
0.10889393836259842,
-0.004063903819769621,
0.4813019335269928,
0.40190553665161133,
0.3748062252998352,
-0.8160802721977234,
-0.3716285228729248,
0.11598839610815048,
-0.0529964417219162,
-0.11037957668304443,
0.7796046733856201,
-0.690117597579956,
0.5192775130271912,
0.2776789665222168,
1.0109776258468628,
0.13293235003948212,
0.02655828930437565,
0.8258066177368164,
-0.6167550086975098,
-0.09349370747804642,
0.37320050597190857,
0.3159293830394745,
0.1768505871295929,
-0.2595973610877991,
0.4932461678981781,
0.1139788031578064,
-0.5496774911880493,
-0.9569950699806213,
0.24812200665473938,
-0.8910874724388123,
-0.10712448507547379,
1.3828119039535522,
-0.010468915104866028,
-0.14109773933887482,
0.045303650200366974,
-0.6917718648910522,
0.07977469265460968,
-0.6954113841056824,
0.5669174790382385,
0.6720137000083923,
-0.3032543957233429,
-0.3133614659309387,
-0.30553892254829407,
0.47887468338012695,
0.25123330950737,
-0.6162635684013367,
-0.06992045789957047,
0.9859125018119812,
-0.1599465012550354,
-0.08142762631177902,
0.3997786343097687,
0.37131795287132263,
0.263532429933548,
-0.09916204959154129,
-0.23797856271266937,
-0.0846022218465805,
-0.5648250579833984,
-0.1901569664478302,
0.36454468965530396,
0.2056892067193985,
-0.5303953289985657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09696v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09696v2 | An Analysis of Language Frequency and Error Correction for Esperanto | 2024-02-15T04:10:25 | 2024-02-16T02:19:49 | Junhong Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current Grammar Error Correction (GEC) initiatives tend to focus on major
languages, with less attention given to low-resource languages like Esperanto.
In this article, we begin to bridge this gap by first conducting a
comprehensive frequency analysis using the Eo-GP dataset, created explicitly
for this purpose. We then introduce the Eo-GEC dataset, derived from authentic
user cases and annotated with fine-grained linguistic details for error
identification. Leveraging GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, our experiments show that GPT-4
outperforms GPT-3.5 in both automated and human evaluations, highlighting its
efficacy in addressing Esperanto's grammatical peculiarities and illustrating
the potential of advanced language models to enhance GEC strategies for less
commonly studied languages. | [
-0.3040921688079834,
-0.955846905708313,
0.6328983306884766,
0.18678107857704163,
0.2363707274198532,
-0.12568596005439758,
-0.49397802352905273,
-0.500348687171936,
0.05529550835490227,
0.007592770271003246,
-0.29119864106178284,
-0.5419518947601318,
-0.7380288243293762,
0.667818009853363,
-0.504749059677124,
0.9613615274429321,
0.11067943274974823,
-0.17637859284877777,
-0.14410901069641113,
0.08802776038646698,
-0.4363570213317871,
-0.5904310345649719,
-0.7215152978897095,
-0.050962332636117935,
0.44653457403182983,
0.8208813071250916,
0.5621041655540466,
0.2952989935874939,
0.21654179692268372,
0.44339829683303833,
-0.2283230870962143,
0.14630207419395447,
-0.48016485571861267,
-0.2032243311405182,
0.21218189597129822,
-0.19867344200611115,
-0.5358942747116089,
-0.2840762436389923,
0.4401181936264038,
0.7412022352218628,
-0.5792779922485352,
-0.16940566897392273,
0.04525637626647949,
0.6451212763786316,
-0.4964068531990051,
0.41876283288002014,
-0.4872263967990875,
0.08230265229940414,
-0.7257109880447388,
0.2706112861633301,
-0.4283802807331085,
-0.2947784662246704,
-0.1757473647594452,
-0.9324917197227478,
0.2761227786540985,
-0.15485654771327972,
1.088209629058838,
0.033581625670194626,
-0.3372097611427307,
-0.26644572615623474,
-0.7509431838989258,
0.5848264098167419,
-0.3396609127521515,
0.18691709637641907,
0.507940411567688,
0.16706736385822296,
-0.06988082081079483,
-0.2490639090538025,
-0.3756847083568573,
-0.26894015073776245,
-0.18741852045059204,
0.41468802094459534,
-0.39017218351364136,
0.3251879811286926,
0.6322368383407593,
0.3797357678413391,
-0.5124169588088989,
-0.263925701379776,
-0.5116978287696838,
-0.1494772881269455,
0.23393851518630981,
-0.14032761752605438,
0.3598260283470154,
-0.030809689313173294,
0.19834989309310913,
0.15040023624897003,
-0.4905908405780792,
-0.15773124992847443,
0.656594455242157,
0.26844847202301025,
0.000825128925498575,
0.4814247190952301,
-0.39686915278434753,
0.914577305316925,
0.030574053525924683,
-0.018578629940748215,
0.33908942341804504,
-0.2560722231864929,
-0.19130060076713562,
-0.13532043993473053,
0.627369225025177,
0.4948086142539978,
0.7202865481376648,
-0.053720396012067795,
-0.2689068913459778,
0.0884096696972847,
0.36687883734703064,
-0.06664837896823883,
-0.08572985231876373,
-0.15114843845367432,
0.009715058840811253,
-0.1644628942012787,
0.5391312837600708,
-1.1753078699111938,
0.03961317613720894,
-0.17196613550186157,
0.3606858253479004,
-0.27459633350372314,
0.08321256935596466,
0.19986701011657715,
-0.12022621184587479,
-0.1990174800157547,
0.29869720339775085,
-1.2893059253692627,
0.7671003341674805,
0.7008910179138184,
0.7234699726104736,
0.36916399002075195,
-0.44562238454818726,
-0.28626108169555664,
0.1346418708562851,
-0.24367393553256989,
0.8480842709541321,
-0.6300458908081055,
-0.5847234129905701,
0.1501924991607666,
0.19061842560768127,
-0.321638286113739,
-0.28097036480903625,
0.5017989873886108,
-0.1289895623922348,
0.2567793130874634,
-0.4257185161113739,
-0.3577858805656433,
-0.14288602769374847,
-0.01471303403377533,
-0.7566072344779968,
1.3938249349594116,
0.45041021704673767,
-0.4651643633842468,
0.2812698483467102,
-0.6050488352775574,
-0.6069740056991577,
-0.15851426124572754,
-0.0742785707116127,
-0.5740218758583069,
0.35761380195617676,
0.15884506702423096,
0.009701958857476711,
-0.2237236201763153,
0.2515529692173004,
-0.03311552479863167,
-0.5279130935668945,
0.05443552881479263,
-0.4146018922328949,
0.31946295499801636,
0.30283114314079285,
-0.3810434937477112,
-0.2067236602306366,
-1.0587470531463623,
-0.23856589198112488,
-0.0378887839615345,
-0.15640440583229065,
-0.37029922008514404,
0.032779257744550705,
0.10023815184831619,
-0.10631629824638367,
-0.051509685814380646,
-0.44351688027381897,
0.14200937747955322,
-0.3085413873195648,
0.27680686116218567,
0.6540901064872742,
-0.2604142427444458,
0.4436201751232147,
-0.03815515711903572,
0.6644207239151001,
-0.5484279990196228,
0.4215438961982727,
0.0075906687416136265,
-0.9278226494789124,
-0.8264102339744568,
0.36897721886634827,
0.2862285077571869,
0.6687644124031067,
-0.5479247570037842,
0.288932204246521,
-0.19014212489128113,
-0.38253602385520935,
0.043560877442359924,
-0.05123826488852501,
0.5181480646133423,
0.5974806547164917,
0.39257490634918213,
-0.24276474118232727,
-0.5798490047454834,
-0.7710930705070496,
-0.5105220079421997,
-0.2677810788154602,
-0.17776508629322052,
0.3178492486476898,
0.247771754860878,
-0.04412319138646126,
0.6886193156242371,
-0.468075692653656,
-0.14731985330581665,
-0.08885764330625534,
0.2828367352485657,
0.2729254961013794,
0.16045784950256348,
0.6894382238388062,
-0.478490948677063,
-0.7397152185440063,
0.43666186928749084,
-0.30899423360824585,
-0.7116016745567322,
0.11627063900232315,
0.10416480153799057,
0.3509863018989563,
0.5244818329811096,
-0.08636465668678284,
0.1579248458147049,
0.8394831418991089,
-0.6468926072120667,
0.0245753712952137,
-0.21290458738803864,
0.5103664994239807,
-0.6054783463478088,
0.08279848098754883,
0.04852684959769249,
-0.16474919021129608,
-0.7809314131736755,
-0.46698078513145447,
0.1333223432302475,
-0.11925777792930603,
-0.058115992695093155,
-0.010297015309333801,
-0.3202080726623535,
-0.2620645761489868,
0.024062082171440125,
-0.06782171130180359,
-0.04745275527238846,
0.22779807448387146,
-0.40233251452445984,
0.7757725119590759,
0.2586199641227722,
-0.23399384319782257,
0.317632794380188,
0.018764641135931015,
0.014635572209954262,
0.5884226560592651,
-0.5604751706123352,
0.31249693036079407,
-0.12182236462831497,
-0.32449227571487427,
-0.7156621217727661,
-0.6676187515258789,
0.4178413450717926,
-0.3045886754989624,
0.48273009061813354,
-0.5680785179138184,
-0.15836460888385773,
-0.387650728225708,
-0.07654961198568344,
0.030751340091228485,
0.45570385456085205,
-0.1563131958246231,
0.6750860214233398,
0.482260525226593,
-0.3670729398727417,
-0.5797536373138428,
-0.4880897104740143,
0.08304525166749954,
0.008342810906469822,
-0.6474190950393677,
0.16498105227947235,
0.23288562893867493,
-0.5145755410194397,
-0.02964474819600582,
0.06818781793117523,
0.03010118566453457,
0.2846686542034149,
0.25628623366355896,
-0.029872896149754524,
-0.011023432947695255,
0.3266605734825134,
-0.1775423288345337,
-0.3761434853076935,
-0.2942538261413574,
-0.20095980167388916,
0.39360350370407104,
-0.5016050338745117,
-0.5252037644386292,
-0.00022640559473074973,
0.43458354473114014,
0.24037931859493256,
0.1825304478406906,
0.4058261811733246,
0.13538764417171478,
-0.46522438526153564,
0.06461033225059509,
-0.591135561466217,
0.2516275942325592,
-0.4430218040943146,
0.4512174725532532,
-0.4086012542247772,
-0.6106643080711365,
0.47145429253578186,
0.29001617431640625,
-0.39866045117378235,
0.7280290126800537,
0.35832899808883667,
-0.09428338706493378,
0.5445553660392761,
0.6096825003623962,
-0.03495725989341736,
0.6760019063949585,
0.44594255089759827,
-0.12382156401872635,
-0.03677760809659958,
-0.1755826622247696,
-0.895817756652832,
-0.0503435879945755,
-0.6273459792137146,
-0.17345605790615082,
0.3485029339790344,
-0.03943395987153053,
-0.20426373183727264,
0.4142754375934601,
-0.07379241287708282,
0.964165985584259,
0.4785248339176178,
-0.16849689185619354,
0.44498834013938904,
0.2002643197774887,
0.271750271320343,
0.05214435234665871,
-0.5594916343688965,
-0.4193996489048004,
0.9036167860031128,
0.18056835234165192,
0.5727856755256653,
0.11535105109214783,
0.5059885382652283,
0.17994706332683563,
0.26068955659866333,
-0.7769799828529358,
0.12826690077781677,
-0.6804398894309998,
-0.47131359577178955,
-0.544509768486023,
-0.44014671444892883,
-0.6078974008560181,
0.13286514580249786,
0.09768358618021011,
-0.44906267523765564,
0.16893956065177917,
0.4113112986087799,
-0.49432089924812317,
0.12341218441724777,
-1.0660243034362793,
0.9998361468315125,
-0.024248115718364716,
-0.0039809877052903175,
0.15827275812625885,
-0.3932614326477051,
-0.07915720343589783,
-0.20366522669792175,
0.4898332357406616,
-0.21762466430664062,
-0.11089764535427094,
0.3848782479763031,
-0.4942885935306549,
0.6937378644943237,
-0.17334766685962677,
-0.10909620672464371,
0.40982386469841003,
-0.24502874910831451,
0.6899321675300598,
-0.0806671679019928,
-0.11258188635110855,
0.35411179065704346,
-0.31250518560409546,
-0.4097821116447449,
-0.1975747048854828,
0.3867497742176056,
-0.7563942074775696,
-0.3727228343486786,
-0.6406771540641785,
-0.014548364095389843,
-0.44025593996047974,
-0.0753931999206543,
0.4082269072532654,
0.20682339370250702,
-0.5582653284072876,
-0.06295130401849747,
0.3434411883354187,
-0.10654604434967041,
0.3808833956718445,
0.6164276003837585,
0.08497397601604462,
-0.29193755984306335,
0.5231476426124573,
0.5334628820419312,
0.23514200747013092,
0.19508317112922668,
0.17151570320129395,
0.020466778427362442,
-0.4507415294647217,
-0.5081193447113037,
0.02190503478050232,
-0.6638057827949524,
-0.07691948860883713,
-0.606770932674408,
0.3130733370780945,
-0.318789541721344,
-0.1385250836610794,
-0.4640738070011139,
-0.3070847690105438,
-0.021221576258540154,
-0.2855432331562042,
0.6331081986427307,
1.025002121925354,
-0.18715310096740723,
0.6371690630912781,
-0.8435441851615906,
0.15355859696865082,
0.5097350478172302,
0.42332813143730164,
-0.5938816666603088,
-0.48307156562805176,
-0.20980247855186462,
-0.275831937789917,
0.013004998676478863,
-1.0848087072372437,
0.23701898753643036,
0.6815953850746155,
0.35917189717292786,
0.19272543489933014,
-0.6519792675971985,
0.7341844439506531,
-0.7243592739105225,
0.7512065172195435,
0.05614037439227104,
-1.3154852390289307,
0.744488537311554,
-0.6333930492401123,
0.01290412712842226,
0.6652489900588989,
0.038757696747779846,
-1.343023419380188,
-0.17463384568691254,
-0.6128427386283875,
-0.9370642900466919,
0.9008042812347412,
0.1258334219455719,
-0.116160549223423,
-0.2506047189235687,
0.4804900288581848,
-0.06691436469554901,
-0.051542844623327255,
-0.7203142046928406,
-0.07719050347805023,
-0.1418406367301941,
-0.5021061897277832,
-0.13405992090702057,
-0.4940764904022217,
-0.24094869196414948,
0.10427696257829666,
0.699629008769989,
-0.3301522433757782,
0.04128744453191757,
-0.019123706966638565,
-0.2479235976934433,
-0.4746667146682739,
0.5156031847000122,
0.6907762289047241,
0.6274193525314331,
0.12119246274232864,
0.08393358439207077,
0.5633639693260193,
-0.7639618515968323,
0.12214663624763489,
0.18887142837047577,
-0.2968865931034088,
0.02025674283504486,
0.3784775733947754,
0.4204866290092468,
0.41403457522392273,
-0.352768212556839,
0.6401585340499878,
-0.06836743652820587,
0.08636444807052612,
-0.49221351742744446,
-0.027294911444187164,
-0.018050625920295715,
-0.21998263895511627,
0.11277013272047043,
0.2737976312637329,
0.138702854514122,
-0.27584218978881836,
0.14653955399990082,
-0.17215292155742645,
-0.31145748496055603,
-0.6208611130714417,
0.3674760162830353,
0.5496286749839783,
0.17728495597839355,
0.6071189641952515,
-0.2864208221435547,
-0.4600920081138611,
1.0426454544067383,
0.3232968747615814,
0.7423728108406067,
-0.4126660227775574,
0.14676760137081146,
0.6229638457298279,
0.5006662607192993,
-0.5325189828872681,
0.5164013504981995,
0.4676845669746399,
-0.7211706638336182,
-0.6696717143058777,
-0.576350748538971,
-0.10216569900512695,
-0.2172061651945114,
-0.6727831959724426,
0.4337964355945587,
-0.2642219662666321,
-0.1578679233789444,
-0.23077303171157837,
-0.3844619691371918,
-0.44659847021102905,
0.036457039415836334,
0.34325265884399414,
0.24547603726387024,
-1.4647400379180908,
0.8289350867271423,
0.579099178314209,
-0.26380449533462524,
-0.6863765716552734,
-0.1604742556810379,
0.5719672441482544,
-0.7186160683631897,
0.419799268245697,
-0.03208635002374649,
-0.32136061787605286,
-0.08019006997346878,
-0.1424456089735031,
-0.8504976034164429,
0.8918011784553528,
0.29670000076293945,
-1.1943325996398926,
0.35646891593933105,
0.2022695094347,
0.6930665969848633,
0.16905134916305542,
0.3059289753437042,
0.8744831681251526,
0.9329783916473389,
-0.29745811223983765,
-1.1557203531265259,
-0.4150756299495697,
-0.26575514674186707,
0.21996855735778809,
0.44699206948280334,
-0.6828011274337769,
1.0431073904037476,
0.08207408338785172,
-0.48421093821525574,
0.09028889238834381,
0.41226765513420105,
-0.3097917437553406,
0.25442081689834595,
0.6028714179992676,
0.7245360612869263,
0.9462301731109619,
-0.8304035663604736,
1.240814208984375,
-0.13388265669345856,
0.6653583645820618,
0.875578761100769,
-0.15351194143295288,
0.4074116051197052,
0.4971206784248352,
-0.7531244158744812,
0.07519787549972534,
0.6094817519187927,
-0.3688395917415619,
0.14900551736354828,
-0.07998953014612198,
-0.2733120918273926,
-0.1167515367269516,
0.04922027140855789,
-0.41719746589660645,
0.37819573283195496,
0.3795320689678192,
-0.23440362513065338,
0.006496515590697527,
-0.13245932757854462,
0.34427616000175476,
0.37400296330451965,
-0.39203864336013794,
0.766451358795166,
-0.22669938206672668,
-0.5741703510284424,
0.053436730057001114,
0.031002692878246307,
0.6632333397865295,
-0.5910102128982544,
-0.10083410143852234,
-0.5147396326065063,
0.1523696482181549,
-0.3376149833202362,
-0.5833339691162109,
0.4585452675819397,
0.3247950077056885,
-0.17181648313999176,
-0.14479173719882965,
0.6699295043945312,
-0.42688748240470886,
-0.47504788637161255,
0.33410200476646423,
0.41345688700675964,
-0.07813848555088043,
-0.1418153941631317,
-0.28338685631752014,
0.07986094057559967,
-0.03042175993323326,
-0.06733137369155884,
-0.028841231018304825,
0.5504633784294128,
0.0034931653644889593,
0.0020874293986707926,
0.1756596714258194,
0.09798097610473633,
0.0972534716129303,
0.7151724696159363,
0.4572980999946594,
-0.7337652444839478,
-0.30118438601493835,
-0.8204331994056702,
0.22534717619419098,
-0.19379112124443054,
-0.511294424533844,
0.8437750339508057,
0.35590365529060364,
1.3276207447052002,
-0.5276238322257996,
0.7935287356376648,
-0.44270774722099304,
0.424580454826355,
-0.6436337828636169,
0.24414540827274323,
-0.1887873113155365,
0.2734605669975281,
-0.3352448642253876,
-0.8072383403778076,
-0.466307669878006,
0.7088163495063782,
-0.3454326391220093,
0.2860262393951416,
0.6728768944740295,
0.9337383508682251,
0.18418216705322266,
0.26876717805862427,
0.6277495622634888,
0.2730543315410614,
0.012827389873564243,
0.6863426566123962,
1.1160740852355957,
-0.5026703476905823,
0.6692683100700378,
-0.3835144340991974,
-0.33604753017425537,
-0.42322808504104614,
-0.6872707009315491,
-0.4065811038017273,
-0.22186338901519775,
-0.09579198807477951,
-0.17205263674259186,
0.5344825387001038,
0.9342020750045776,
0.13163115084171295,
-1.1224747896194458,
-0.20769695937633514,
-0.26158320903778076,
-0.06444193422794342,
-0.5190885066986084,
-0.11332486569881439,
0.09256989508867264,
-0.47212091088294983,
-1.3766440153121948,
0.374835342168808,
0.3360132575035095,
0.10056740790605545,
0.44221529364585876,
0.015567149966955185,
0.173931285738945,
-0.321772962808609,
0.5825703144073486,
0.4408746361732483,
-0.5074977874755859,
-0.6143929958343506,
0.05526648089289665,
-0.22755327820777893,
0.17719797790050507,
0.9668717384338379,
-0.19859394431114197,
0.5226383805274963,
0.5646318793296814,
0.20038674771785736,
0.1697618067264557,
0.004104215651750565,
0.6887548565864563,
-0.9515824913978577,
0.15837088227272034,
-0.014749361202120781,
0.6430535316467285,
0.2268953174352646,
-0.31714928150177,
0.9707850813865662,
0.6860330700874329,
-0.3636695146560669,
-0.17057889699935913,
0.10487092286348343,
-0.7362664937973022,
-0.1360512673854828,
1.3432835340499878,
-0.05679718032479286,
-0.21437415480613708,
-0.5406906008720398,
-0.36108601093292236,
0.09620801359415054,
-0.48312830924987793,
0.6863502264022827,
1.1496753692626953,
-0.05758112296462059,
0.2419363260269165,
-0.7689253687858582,
0.6737231612205505,
0.3676629662513733,
-0.899554431438446,
0.09144856035709381,
0.8499045372009277,
0.13651028275489807,
0.22194375097751617,
0.4962199330329895,
-0.46888458728790283,
0.4360214173793793,
0.3370753526687622,
0.05257761850953102,
-0.013970772735774517,
-0.532120943069458,
-0.6600816249847412,
0.1804359406232834,
0.25570622086524963,
0.2905237078666687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09674v1 | PAL: Proxy-Guided Black-Box Attack on Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T02:54:49 | 2024-02-15T02:54:49 | Chawin Sitawarin, Norman Mu, David Wagner, Alexandre Araujo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have surged in popularity in recent months, but
they have demonstrated concerning capabilities to generate harmful content when
manipulated. While techniques like safety fine-tuning aim to minimize harmful
use, recent works have shown that LLMs remain vulnerable to attacks that elicit
toxic responses. In this work, we introduce the Proxy-Guided Attack on LLMs
(PAL), the first optimization-based attack on LLMs in a black-box query-only
setting. In particular, it relies on a surrogate model to guide the
optimization and a sophisticated loss designed for real-world LLM APIs. Our
attack achieves 84% attack success rate (ASR) on GPT-3.5-Turbo and 48% on
Llama-2-7B, compared to 4% for the current state of the art. We also propose
GCG++, an improvement to the GCG attack that reaches 94% ASR on white-box
Llama-2-7B, and the Random-Search Attack on LLMs (RAL), a strong but simple
baseline for query-based attacks. We believe the techniques proposed in this
work will enable more comprehensive safety testing of LLMs and, in the long
term, the development of better security guardrails. The code can be found at
https://github.com/chawins/pal. | [
-0.3526252806186676,
-1.231712818145752,
0.4325504004955292,
0.2278851866722107,
-0.54378741979599,
0.2333533763885498,
0.07217627018690109,
-0.22696487605571747,
0.2401832789182663,
1.004872441291809,
-0.5631932020187378,
-0.5366907119750977,
-0.627555251121521,
-0.015082381665706635,
-0.4589724838733673,
0.7926576733589172,
0.19412389397621155,
0.024506453424692154,
0.24262291193008423,
0.20971904695034027,
-0.4951101541519165,
-0.759150505065918,
-0.9425617456436157,
0.012259540148079395,
0.29555466771125793,
-0.084208644926548,
0.5920228362083435,
0.44986215233802795,
0.37901219725608826,
0.21276868879795074,
-0.4139538109302521,
0.08925723284482956,
-0.7211236357688904,
0.2086023986339569,
-0.20627173781394958,
-0.510944664478302,
-0.5245751738548279,
-0.33720290660858154,
0.5685586333274841,
0.4789767861366272,
-0.2808590829372406,
-0.0016609446611255407,
-0.13867884874343872,
0.5491350889205933,
-0.6670873761177063,
0.07273154705762863,
-1.1969575881958008,
-0.06822778284549713,
-0.4721985459327698,
-0.3006688058376312,
-0.6075499057769775,
-0.06127963215112686,
-0.11033669859170914,
-0.25907519459724426,
0.10743875056505203,
0.3102719485759735,
0.6563031077384949,
0.38220950961112976,
-0.5971533060073853,
-0.15250582993030548,
-0.13023129105567932,
0.647689163684845,
-0.5777270197868347,
0.29811030626296997,
0.21350105106830597,
0.4118850827217102,
-0.9522597193717957,
-0.4474322497844696,
-0.45933207869529724,
-0.3278547525405884,
0.11307510733604431,
0.0011472670594230294,
-0.30777308344841003,
0.385934978723526,
0.16693444550037384,
0.13258326053619385,
-0.5382388830184937,
0.09181766211986542,
-0.26079827547073364,
-0.32417502999305725,
0.6528413891792297,
0.13225775957107544,
0.24498867988586426,
-0.07818009704351425,
-0.4778743088245392,
0.04368933290243149,
-1.1272855997085571,
-0.17659126222133636,
0.36595553159713745,
0.31754401326179504,
-0.3298511207103729,
0.5681854486465454,
-0.2983400821685791,
0.7229507565498352,
-0.08390398323535919,
-0.06792280077934265,
-0.18704931437969208,
-0.07631861418485641,
-0.1576056331396103,
0.17286376655101776,
0.8274940848350525,
0.506855845451355,
0.4911090135574341,
-0.07607702910900116,
-0.2150850147008896,
0.24924904108047485,
0.33928701281547546,
-0.8244885206222534,
-0.06438016146421432,
0.017536038532853127,
-0.18732693791389465,
-0.3509152829647064,
-0.21922248601913452,
-1.1300592422485352,
-0.6140720844268799,
0.1995449811220169,
0.20698413252830505,
-0.02530006133019924,
-0.15600381791591644,
0.5068235993385315,
0.10651030391454697,
0.39256536960601807,
0.2276129126548767,
-0.6657124161720276,
0.3467049300670624,
0.9934070110321045,
0.834896981716156,
-0.03355229273438454,
-0.06427307426929474,
-1.2172518968582153,
0.48523086309432983,
-0.4684211313724518,
0.5623962879180908,
-0.6975578665733337,
-0.8272488117218018,
0.2637326419353485,
0.09212716668844223,
0.2458948791027069,
-0.2712135314941406,
0.5251145362854004,
-0.7135290503501892,
-0.18713712692260742,
-0.2571077346801758,
-0.3617253601551056,
0.12938690185546875,
0.44741418957710266,
-0.5500609874725342,
0.6719143986701965,
-0.23510663211345673,
-0.705618679523468,
-0.1463637351989746,
-0.5148593783378601,
-0.38563597202301025,
0.055727291852235794,
-0.0036091837100684643,
-0.19885924458503723,
0.3337271511554718,
0.14897489547729492,
0.3695370852947235,
-0.4868397116661072,
0.08813513815402985,
-0.5609117746353149,
-0.4219164252281189,
0.12374775856733322,
-0.5009679198265076,
0.6133989095687866,
0.05766869708895683,
-0.27205753326416016,
-0.14505261182785034,
-0.5982059240341187,
-0.04868997633457184,
0.35033202171325684,
-0.30414342880249023,
-0.41152307391166687,
0.2818281650543213,
-0.4726930260658264,
-0.09262572228908539,
0.3269400894641876,
-0.6755260229110718,
0.28887099027633667,
-0.4770185947418213,
0.38010159134864807,
0.9954105615615845,
0.24490803480148315,
-0.016263751313090324,
-0.06773994117975235,
0.681276261806488,
-0.534248948097229,
0.38212937116622925,
0.1335422396659851,
-0.5170654654502869,
-0.5256262421607971,
-0.08812030404806137,
0.15321388840675354,
0.47864216566085815,
-0.8880783915519714,
0.13907097280025482,
-0.1905640810728073,
-0.43541738390922546,
-0.43572983145713806,
0.16315634548664093,
0.6901045441627502,
0.46266433596611023,
0.3000660240650177,
-0.2686159908771515,
-0.20006698369979858,
-0.7909648418426514,
-0.28223246335983276,
-0.46209681034088135,
0.13038839399814606,
0.22234751284122467,
0.36468759179115295,
-0.5596777200698853,
0.4132036566734314,
-0.851837694644928,
-0.1620103418827057,
0.04463913291692734,
-0.2876178026199341,
0.1378338634967804,
0.36363905668258667,
0.6145267486572266,
-0.5274743437767029,
-0.7151225805282593,
-0.010673954151570797,
-0.30944374203681946,
-0.5913841724395752,
0.050381410866975784,
-0.39154112339019775,
0.3021053671836853,
0.6235193610191345,
-0.7491785883903503,
0.16269972920417786,
0.606321394443512,
-0.19122909009456635,
0.7627512812614441,
-0.05601325258612633,
-0.29298296570777893,
-0.7536648511886597,
-0.19504740834236145,
0.17499767243862152,
-0.10195259004831314,
-0.9009950757026672,
0.41130179166793823,
0.06624084711074829,
0.031186478212475777,
-0.6404233574867249,
0.9778997898101807,
-0.14194877445697784,
0.20971885323524475,
-0.3242214322090149,
-0.07006829231977463,
-0.08151238411664963,
0.4631754457950592,
-0.10219576209783554,
0.7697915434837341,
0.620516836643219,
-0.32601356506347656,
0.23609425127506256,
0.09878498315811157,
-0.05714081972837448,
0.6383446455001831,
-0.7903688549995422,
0.32691776752471924,
-0.195253387093544,
0.3875654637813568,
-0.802795946598053,
-0.17949414253234863,
0.3989553451538086,
-0.35127508640289307,
0.49342718720436096,
-0.4084304869174957,
-0.5239565968513489,
-0.15160737931728363,
-0.7216333746910095,
0.10768665373325348,
0.43682506680488586,
-0.7669031620025635,
0.4217638373374939,
0.5352959632873535,
-0.24183572828769684,
-0.8522438406944275,
-0.6227465867996216,
0.30265507102012634,
-0.3130891025066376,
-0.4602689743041992,
0.30763721466064453,
-0.27906274795532227,
-0.30135539174079895,
-0.4005444347858429,
-0.42857369780540466,
0.11068970710039139,
0.31579580903053284,
-0.09167183935642242,
0.17525391280651093,
0.13637301325798035,
-0.25261610746383667,
0.1177075058221817,
-0.12794150412082672,
0.43247878551483154,
0.006704745348542929,
0.9197046160697937,
-0.20531189441680908,
-0.5226272940635681,
-0.2283637523651123,
0.35477331280708313,
0.5428457856178284,
-0.2102251946926117,
0.6158542633056641,
0.2820151150226593,
-0.12866643071174622,
-0.43122386932373047,
-0.6935921907424927,
0.024922465905547142,
-0.5890684723854065,
0.47107747197151184,
-0.44520050287246704,
-1.007066249847412,
0.48373109102249146,
-0.07839808613061905,
-0.07712576538324356,
0.0810609683394432,
0.4434059262275696,
0.0943632572889328,
1.2736438512802124,
0.533165454864502,
-0.3350834548473358,
0.34436142444610596,
-0.09272167086601257,
0.09347132593393326,
-0.8688449859619141,
-0.26789912581443787,
-0.48818299174308777,
0.2170160412788391,
-0.8355081677436829,
-0.10488995164632797,
0.4565335214138031,
0.13619115948677063,
-0.5745089650154114,
0.03402256593108177,
-0.4132687747478485,
0.5823116302490234,
0.3354443907737732,
0.04916900768876076,
0.10615480691194534,
-0.011499856598675251,
-0.193040132522583,
0.17003685235977173,
-0.35975199937820435,
-0.33327168226242065,
1.2680472135543823,
0.5107485055923462,
1.1790497303009033,
0.28693047165870667,
0.6249368190765381,
0.3059832751750946,
0.26048269867897034,
-0.4427432119846344,
0.8604245781898499,
-0.3513411581516266,
-0.4857051968574524,
0.08054312318563461,
-0.5889569520950317,
-0.9587135910987854,
0.4783777892589569,
0.16060391068458557,
-0.8423551321029663,
-0.18252547085285187,
-0.002530239522457123,
-0.008560288697481155,
0.39191609621047974,
-0.8917927145957947,
0.6981891989707947,
-0.7598556280136108,
-0.3362330496311188,
-0.08913205564022064,
-0.5824166536331177,
0.5357854962348938,
-0.42474207282066345,
0.16844917833805084,
-0.05161404237151146,
-0.2816579043865204,
0.32851478457450867,
-0.36588990688323975,
0.9580692648887634,
-0.2720697522163391,
-0.1836119145154953,
-0.06379149109125137,
0.4189450144767761,
0.8387688994407654,
0.26075783371925354,
-0.0577705055475235,
0.2875097990036011,
0.10345572233200073,
-0.5875223278999329,
-0.44664010405540466,
0.8163371682167053,
-0.5074957609176636,
-1.345658779144287,
-0.4497959315776825,
-0.2978471517562866,
-0.15975865721702576,
0.12953218817710876,
-0.316813200712204,
0.05680683255195618,
0.10586248338222504,
0.2108747810125351,
0.7801650762557983,
-0.5662031769752502,
0.28050512075424194,
0.9094242453575134,
-0.29836389422416687,
-0.4347231984138489,
0.9431876540184021,
-0.16688372194766998,
0.6202500462532043,
0.36578863859176636,
0.19945108890533447,
-0.4437253177165985,
-0.8736737966537476,
-0.3613484799861908,
0.546198844909668,
-0.6190428137779236,
-0.3867533802986145,
-0.19668632745742798,
-0.1997988373041153,
-0.2212814837694168,
-0.16427214443683624,
-0.23685666918754578,
0.14267945289611816,
-0.0872567892074585,
0.05154754966497421,
0.2559853494167328,
0.3430415987968445,
0.2838922142982483,
0.7046813368797302,
-0.6207664012908936,
0.31993013620376587,
0.3759356737136841,
0.5214214324951172,
-0.19409963488578796,
-0.1636161357164383,
0.19292764365673065,
-0.00270552234724164,
-0.21428164839744568,
-1.0026828050613403,
0.565187394618988,
0.06610123813152313,
0.6628327369689941,
0.34708166122436523,
0.21923042833805084,
0.539272129535675,
-0.5943053960800171,
0.7885906100273132,
0.07857605069875717,
-0.8567354083061218,
0.5433136820793152,
-0.39965009689331055,
0.1612064391374588,
0.49179723858833313,
0.17259149253368378,
-0.36315539479255676,
-0.3437894582748413,
-0.5328821539878845,
-0.5215333104133606,
0.5554730892181396,
-0.024902142584323883,
0.34885677695274353,
-0.2878689467906952,
0.5654277801513672,
-0.09379881620407104,
0.4726560413837433,
-0.9096327424049377,
-0.42581427097320557,
0.04002835601568222,
0.17139562964439392,
0.07992913573980331,
-0.38348957896232605,
-0.21983642876148224,
0.12543396651744843,
0.6883461475372314,
-0.1903650015592575,
-0.05585469678044319,
-0.07815784960985184,
0.03383582457900047,
-0.2074451446533203,
0.28780698776245117,
0.4957476854324341,
0.2143104076385498,
-0.3967125415802002,
0.1975097358226776,
0.38969308137893677,
-0.5402057766914368,
0.1225339025259018,
0.2442888617515564,
-0.2555873692035675,
-0.20863522589206696,
0.18817603588104248,
0.5894735455513,
-0.034955382347106934,
-0.9119539260864258,
0.49559810757637024,
-0.24113504588603973,
0.09836511313915253,
-0.08133773505687714,
0.24469034373760223,
-0.22079792618751526,
0.19451075792312622,
0.3129616975784302,
-0.4671074450016022,
-0.28685715794563293,
-0.5129139423370361,
-0.008073748089373112,
1.1281402111053467,
-0.11804041266441345,
-0.16166158020496368,
0.671532154083252,
0.13963446021080017,
-0.43922433257102966,
-0.022266220301389694,
-0.3010426163673401,
-0.761425793170929,
0.5488307476043701,
0.762972891330719,
0.6851745843887329,
-0.31179574131965637,
0.14935947954654694,
-0.17540569603443146,
0.6577200293540955,
-0.12007591128349304,
0.25965073704719543,
0.05760037153959274,
-0.3877776265144348,
-0.5429369807243347,
-0.8999099731445312,
-0.6764885187149048,
0.5576335787773132,
-0.15556448698043823,
0.3213123083114624,
-0.617798388004303,
0.0899852067232132,
-0.2902730703353882,
0.33147695660591125,
-0.15167661011219025,
-0.01682557351887226,
0.0943838357925415,
0.9376899003982544,
-0.5310089588165283,
0.881081759929657,
0.5497219562530518,
-0.08493923395872116,
-0.30838853120803833,
-0.026667026802897453,
0.0658695325255394,
-0.9822391867637634,
0.3779597878456116,
0.10901722311973572,
-0.1577909141778946,
-0.1547231376171112,
-0.6122375726699829,
-0.8575732707977295,
0.8487937450408936,
0.8170438408851624,
-0.6887902021408081,
0.029978064820170403,
0.5379945039749146,
0.5871398448944092,
-0.020328057929873466,
0.025535237044095993,
0.7423718571662903,
0.387483686208725,
-0.03331410884857178,
-0.8692763447761536,
0.16430343687534332,
-0.11796581000089645,
0.059931591153144836,
0.49154943227767944,
-1.037318468093872,
0.7119293808937073,
0.44800105690956116,
-0.13491100072860718,
-0.07210209220647812,
0.20483489334583282,
0.5634084343910217,
0.13325603306293488,
0.4721817076206207,
0.6465341448783875,
0.6076130270957947,
0.030115757137537003,
1.3427516222000122,
-0.3643980026245117,
0.031934045255184174,
0.8837264180183411,
-0.42618390917778015,
0.7946927547454834,
0.4984440505504608,
-0.11112947762012482,
0.023889321833848953,
0.5249832272529602,
0.0943351611495018,
0.7329524159431458,
0.5089223980903625,
-0.42461588978767395,
-0.06348851323127747,
-0.19172516465187073,
-0.4858296811580658,
0.1328127533197403,
0.6083611249923706,
-0.004168836399912834,
-0.3524712920188904,
-0.22491207718849182,
0.3845707178115845,
-0.09575160592794418,
-0.5321616530418396,
0.5148046612739563,
0.290639191865921,
-0.5913519263267517,
0.8616786599159241,
0.16448959708213806,
0.844691276550293,
-0.806673526763916,
0.10784593969583511,
-0.42106369137763977,
-0.03322552889585495,
0.08198445290327072,
-0.6122488975524902,
0.08638843894004822,
0.1158503070473671,
0.30397406220436096,
0.01815575547516346,
0.8257706761360168,
-0.2808099091053009,
-0.3749268352985382,
0.556607723236084,
0.3067670166492462,
-0.03433353453874588,
-0.17344321310520172,
-0.7132089734077454,
0.38599511981010437,
0.05688232555985451,
-0.21733540296554565,
0.6567569375038147,
0.18896794319152832,
-0.1487843096256256,
0.9912822246551514,
0.7598451972007751,
0.5101070404052734,
0.2807220220565796,
-0.006282184738665819,
0.9610366821289062,
-0.4443386197090149,
-0.3397041857242584,
-1.0459847450256348,
0.12778425216674805,
-0.07398367673158646,
0.02458958327770233,
0.5417627692222595,
0.3601282835006714,
0.850574791431427,
0.20379777252674103,
0.6689815521240234,
0.3707757592201233,
0.2031627893447876,
-0.7467285990715027,
0.6123932600021362,
-0.5349032282829285,
0.8303043246269226,
-0.32034358382225037,
-0.919216513633728,
-0.46362608671188354,
0.14048010110855103,
-0.40290266275405884,
-0.3523963689804077,
0.4350838363170624,
1.281823992729187,
0.11665500700473785,
-0.23794019222259521,
0.14986401796340942,
0.31136569380760193,
0.971936047077179,
0.6375847458839417,
0.8984140157699585,
-0.09069395065307617,
0.8104726672172546,
-0.18428100645542145,
-0.19422774016857147,
-0.13953948020935059,
-0.9942798614501953,
-1.2247179746627808,
-0.14286305010318756,
-0.12171132117509842,
-0.3003883957862854,
0.47916650772094727,
0.587469220161438,
0.37357985973358154,
-0.497384637594223,
-0.1417679339647293,
-0.19568845629692078,
0.14542877674102783,
0.3086583614349365,
-0.17682483792304993,
0.4975156784057617,
-0.2569427788257599,
-0.5206032991409302,
0.6640153527259827,
0.15157563984394073,
0.06454242765903473,
-0.35395926237106323,
-0.16485758125782013,
-0.10175436735153198,
0.24396850168704987,
0.4013022482395172,
0.3160490393638611,
-0.7813623547554016,
-0.5151513814926147,
-0.22405995428562164,
0.11847315728664398,
-0.2322765290737152,
0.30799588561058044,
-0.5459128022193909,
0.5463842749595642,
0.2027546763420105,
0.9206162691116333,
0.5353416800498962,
0.0786222442984581,
0.46725189685821533,
-0.9064428806304932,
0.10553151369094849,
0.09256172925233841,
0.521621823310852,
0.11364742368459702,
-0.3116903305053711,
0.6132819652557373,
0.09483955055475235,
-0.45918259024620056,
-1.30387544631958,
0.2809498906135559,
-1.1401305198669434,
-0.38236650824546814,
1.3895903825759888,
0.10654640942811966,
-0.38984861969947815,
-0.037633251398801804,
-0.43266093730926514,
-0.09596443176269531,
-0.5741607546806335,
0.970159113407135,
0.5220739245414734,
0.16170601546764374,
0.04397140443325043,
-0.7466144561767578,
0.40811270475387573,
0.45427510142326355,
-0.7828627228736877,
0.07294204086065292,
0.49700573086738586,
0.215273916721344,
0.03979548439383507,
0.4148360788822174,
-0.11411599814891815,
0.17042909562587738,
-0.21594367921352386,
-0.3958415389060974,
-0.12431690096855164,
-0.17036616802215576,
-0.4352226257324219,
0.5255828499794006,
0.006464124657213688,
-0.1292140632867813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09668v1 | How to Train Data-Efficient LLMs | 2024-02-15T02:27:57 | 2024-02-15T02:27:57 | Noveen Sachdeva, Benjamin Coleman, Wang-Cheng Kang, Jianmo Ni, Lichan Hong, Ed H. Chi, James Caverlee, Julian McAuley, Derek Zhiyuan Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The training of large language models (LLMs) is expensive. In this paper, we
study data-efficient approaches for pre-training LLMs, i.e., techniques that
aim to optimize the Pareto frontier of model quality and training resource/data
consumption. We seek to understand the tradeoffs associated with data selection
routines based on (i) expensive-to-compute data-quality estimates, and (ii)
maximization of coverage and diversity-based measures in the feature space. Our
first technique, Ask-LLM, leverages the zero-shot reasoning capabilities of
instruction-tuned LLMs to directly assess the quality of a training example. To
target coverage, we propose Density sampling, which models the data
distribution to select a diverse sample. In our comparison of 19 samplers,
involving hundreds of evaluation tasks and pre-training runs, we find that
Ask-LLM and Density are the best methods in their respective categories.
Coverage sampling can recover the performance of the full data, while models
trained on Ask-LLM data consistently outperform full-data training -- even when
we reject 90% of the original dataset, while converging up to 70% faster. | [
-0.5301872491836548,
-0.7364055514335632,
0.5373203158378601,
0.01130570936948061,
-0.2934543192386627,
0.15108215808868408,
-0.273470401763916,
-0.034481555223464966,
0.190929114818573,
0.7542032599449158,
-0.3622259497642517,
-0.5398333072662354,
-0.6448199152946472,
-0.21956324577331543,
-0.5994942784309387,
0.6221179962158203,
-0.0696338415145874,
0.1871977597475052,
-0.2547604739665985,
-0.10471025109291077,
-0.04074898734688759,
-0.5580263137817383,
-0.5920383334159851,
-0.018705762922763824,
0.6113945841789246,
0.5637040138244629,
0.6034151911735535,
0.9357142448425293,
0.3376253843307495,
0.26394814252853394,
-0.21476531028747559,
0.20065763592720032,
-0.9430325627326965,
-0.0348929837346077,
0.038442403078079224,
-0.6458085179328918,
-0.08991474658250809,
0.3738325238227844,
0.5839851498603821,
0.9756627082824707,
-0.22786466777324677,
0.21675650775432587,
-0.06427951157093048,
0.46815431118011475,
-0.654492974281311,
-0.19391083717346191,
-0.8920393586158752,
0.09658747166395187,
-0.21982915699481964,
-0.22856451570987701,
-0.21959812939167023,
-0.42927396297454834,
-0.15139923989772797,
-0.455211877822876,
0.16504909098148346,
-0.007460474036633968,
0.8122360110282898,
0.2633163332939148,
-0.2823646366596222,
-0.20472171902656555,
-0.7234769463539124,
1.1232126951217651,
-0.33484408259391785,
0.48315632343292236,
0.6653868556022644,
0.3162834644317627,
-0.06018659472465515,
-0.4188406467437744,
-0.39376309514045715,
-0.3062392771244049,
0.2547537088394165,
0.060106903314590454,
-0.09403195232152939,
-0.039361950010061264,
0.19559872150421143,
0.5280743837356567,
-0.47394120693206787,
0.44043731689453125,
-0.23662275075912476,
-0.12180626392364502,
0.7059116959571838,
0.08265461027622223,
0.11068451404571533,
0.16578541696071625,
-0.31969204545021057,
-0.23371833562850952,
-0.7896782755851746,
-0.0037797715049237013,
0.5133006572723389,
0.16265566647052765,
0.13233213126659393,
0.6673352718353271,
-0.26620081067085266,
0.9581281542778015,
-0.390434205532074,
-0.19322775304317474,
0.10393664240837097,
-0.45856985449790955,
-0.26037079095840454,
-0.46283960342407227,
0.4690851867198944,
0.07859349250793457,
0.4007962644100189,
-0.21180202066898346,
-0.4752459228038788,
-0.2441076636314392,
0.2558797597885132,
-0.6896345615386963,
-0.07937221974134445,
0.2820902168750763,
-0.2743273079395294,
-0.21104063093662262,
-0.35619091987609863,
-0.651141345500946,
-0.04022207483649254,
-0.5742182731628418,
0.5067887902259827,
-0.4262007474899292,
-0.03137095645070076,
0.2838335931301117,
0.07829935848712921,
0.24772299826145172,
0.4396131634712219,
-0.8487103581428528,
0.1317777782678604,
0.43605557084083557,
0.6525619626045227,
-0.029642725363373756,
-0.23617057502269745,
-0.5985868573188782,
-0.07974021881818771,
-0.6617265939712524,
0.8847209811210632,
-0.3811420202255249,
-0.39305511116981506,
-0.15414412319660187,
-0.4923458397388458,
-0.21080264449119568,
-0.806573212146759,
0.2876230478286743,
-0.5287520289421082,
-0.029908938333392143,
-0.4516538679599762,
-0.7422579526901245,
0.004653948824852705,
0.3685324192047119,
-0.7332245707511902,
0.9928712844848633,
0.4784168004989624,
-0.6484930515289307,
0.7142699956893921,
-0.1998652070760727,
-0.3185768127441406,
-0.021057257428765297,
-0.08737950772047043,
-0.468149334192276,
0.018286587670445442,
0.5390165448188782,
0.7677270770072937,
-0.24246536195278168,
0.0731629729270935,
-0.39892736077308655,
-0.5478502511978149,
0.3800334632396698,
-0.21676436066627502,
0.6437405347824097,
0.5313372611999512,
-0.08004115521907806,
-0.13513067364692688,
-0.6850096583366394,
0.08147802948951721,
0.24826118350028992,
-0.5358143448829651,
-0.23788024485111237,
0.06358550488948822,
-0.3274816870689392,
-0.14865192770957947,
0.07383596152067184,
-0.20641891658306122,
-0.03618186339735985,
-0.35392916202545166,
0.19475574791431427,
0.5972023606300354,
-0.2629063129425049,
0.5817264318466187,
-0.578869640827179,
0.6590749025344849,
-0.09212573617696762,
0.35254988074302673,
0.02585807628929615,
0.10434454679489136,
-0.9486189484596252,
-0.4148007333278656,
0.25520947575569153,
0.5613545775413513,
-0.9566964507102966,
0.5610064268112183,
-0.16677230596542358,
-0.6689337491989136,
-0.5720009207725525,
0.6158611178398132,
0.19906748831272125,
0.34997105598449707,
0.29604142904281616,
0.04170515388250351,
-0.1871299147605896,
-0.7123000025749207,
-0.148851677775383,
0.032554108649492264,
0.13573282957077026,
0.46071672439575195,
0.34359076619148254,
-0.03393782675266266,
0.9578580260276794,
-0.5043421983718872,
0.20522689819335938,
-0.7582604885101318,
-0.25146254897117615,
0.2597998082637787,
0.29503411054611206,
0.5851885676383972,
-0.6390910744667053,
-0.42781180143356323,
-0.326995849609375,
-0.45340290665626526,
-0.21449407935142517,
-0.03940625116229057,
-0.3737097978591919,
-0.03600475937128067,
0.40962329506874084,
-0.5355511903762817,
0.00715393153950572,
0.5334634184837341,
0.1000252217054367,
0.14761200547218323,
-0.10352075099945068,
0.11059824377298355,
-0.890133798122406,
-0.03433563932776451,
-0.07329250872135162,
-0.24144259095191956,
-0.7124438285827637,
-0.08238500356674194,
-0.05432496219873428,
-0.291089802980423,
-0.5305196046829224,
0.6798531413078308,
-0.5288875102996826,
-0.28834590315818787,
-0.08875768631696701,
-0.021090546622872353,
-0.07693653553724289,
0.38439080119132996,
-0.07175072282552719,
1.0565811395645142,
0.6792542338371277,
-0.6847423911094666,
0.10753916949033737,
0.10015196353197098,
-0.7062065601348877,
0.4092770516872406,
-0.41735175251960754,
0.026426222175359726,
-0.3869521915912628,
-0.15101483464241028,
-0.8942723274230957,
-0.08848167210817337,
0.08812883496284485,
-0.13143597543239594,
0.26214054226875305,
-0.08302359282970428,
-0.5337717533111572,
-0.23872794210910797,
-0.3326309323310852,
0.2049260139465332,
0.7258332967758179,
-0.9055656790733337,
0.21388377249240875,
0.5723072290420532,
-0.12231942266225815,
-0.583164632320404,
-0.6846051216125488,
-0.20181061327457428,
-0.4899681806564331,
-0.481052428483963,
0.019100122153759003,
0.08595730364322662,
-0.2324095070362091,
-0.25835075974464417,
-0.058211736381053925,
-0.28445547819137573,
0.46410733461380005,
-0.32436805963516235,
-0.10711490362882614,
0.1329485923051834,
0.025831768289208412,
0.059913069009780884,
-0.031708646565675735,
-0.13223378360271454,
-0.06263376027345657,
0.7781572341918945,
0.18051767349243164,
-0.590251624584198,
-0.008229898288846016,
0.22083230316638947,
0.02751224674284458,
-0.1873854249715805,
0.5819240808486938,
0.3124569356441498,
-0.015888091176748276,
-0.6440796256065369,
-0.8569336533546448,
-0.10343043506145477,
-0.4107201099395752,
0.4826856851577759,
-0.23820048570632935,
-0.870736837387085,
0.4075719118118286,
-0.004558749496936798,
0.15907235443592072,
0.05267078056931496,
0.45519888401031494,
-0.4175835847854614,
0.7409196496009827,
0.4226936995983124,
-0.15189479291439056,
0.6486488580703735,
-0.5280551910400391,
0.04077141731977463,
-0.3850117325782776,
-0.08431006968021393,
-0.527118980884552,
-0.2822968661785126,
-0.0896640419960022,
-0.8116748332977295,
0.39111003279685974,
0.4507320821285248,
-0.29583144187927246,
0.14798197150230408,
-0.23655687272548676,
0.6137270927429199,
0.7826063632965088,
0.2733621597290039,
0.06736177206039429,
0.44977205991744995,
0.3513225018978119,
0.023869866505265236,
-0.9499403834342957,
-0.4585682451725006,
1.4127132892608643,
0.39260974526405334,
0.9112324714660645,
-0.2548782527446747,
0.9405497908592224,
-0.2493872046470642,
0.11771134287118912,
-0.7191934585571289,
0.612125813961029,
-0.2761302590370178,
-0.32185661792755127,
-0.5184243321418762,
-0.9329569935798645,
-1.0963587760925293,
0.33584722876548767,
-0.1597861349582672,
-0.21569117903709412,
0.11560331284999847,
0.43194496631622314,
-0.27289241552352905,
0.5582778453826904,
-0.5530753135681152,
0.6250844597816467,
-0.6453852653503418,
0.02810566872358322,
-0.27873480319976807,
-0.33195558190345764,
0.3378179371356964,
-0.2635045349597931,
0.1611103117465973,
-0.4004363417625427,
-0.11787951737642288,
0.6386813521385193,
-0.278679758310318,
0.5172070264816284,
-0.28843581676483154,
0.19565963745117188,
0.3726324737071991,
-0.040592946112155914,
0.337704598903656,
-0.015687957406044006,
-0.1165647879242897,
0.3268797993659973,
-0.29590776562690735,
-0.7822205424308777,
-0.5313419103622437,
0.18571095168590546,
-0.9377456903457642,
-0.28617027401924133,
-0.022839918732643127,
-0.5815132856369019,
-0.4317697286605835,
-0.14233404397964478,
0.4328579008579254,
0.29449838399887085,
-0.21308186650276184,
0.19987821578979492,
0.9570103287696838,
-0.5368050932884216,
0.15035194158554077,
0.3138261139392853,
0.0050302655436098576,
-0.5148376226425171,
0.9533878564834595,
0.42400917410850525,
0.6029651761054993,
0.5036822557449341,
0.09505358338356018,
-0.29485324025154114,
-1.0238944292068481,
-0.27332043647766113,
0.13893894851207733,
-0.6820392608642578,
-0.19640247523784637,
-0.8141452670097351,
-0.2937031388282776,
-0.05139303579926491,
-0.2049114853143692,
-0.42957139015197754,
-0.16436299681663513,
-0.3941076695919037,
-0.11816509068012238,
0.42522668838500977,
0.1574917584657669,
0.10666929930448532,
0.7639800906181335,
-0.47261983156204224,
0.16962271928787231,
0.3905717432498932,
0.30573421716690063,
-0.37271514534950256,
-0.5039849281311035,
-0.30133289098739624,
0.019031144678592682,
-0.07481064647436142,
-0.5373528003692627,
0.4611600339412689,
0.09962859004735947,
0.9911932945251465,
0.1601676195859909,
-0.19059805572032928,
0.40658843517303467,
-0.19951488077640533,
0.539056122303009,
-0.06465089321136475,
-0.6688486933708191,
0.5370182991027832,
-0.1226806715130806,
0.08618012070655823,
0.9854611158370972,
0.6002660989761353,
-0.1354726403951645,
-0.4006973206996918,
-0.5015903115272522,
-0.854171633720398,
0.6256998777389526,
0.16086195409297943,
0.4217440187931061,
-0.033013567328453064,
0.4421691298484802,
0.13511666655540466,
0.35142451524734497,
-0.6503133773803711,
-0.12094917893409729,
-0.18169407546520233,
-0.22988533973693848,
-0.27638694643974304,
-0.3560182750225067,
-0.18585167825222015,
-0.2545592188835144,
0.4231664836406708,
-0.26251357793807983,
0.10347498953342438,
-0.07910976558923721,
-0.40536031126976013,
0.4614975154399872,
0.3828045129776001,
0.18744826316833496,
0.7781470417976379,
-0.2336854338645935,
0.13206282258033752,
0.34141600131988525,
-0.2871154248714447,
0.32781317830085754,
0.1225510835647583,
-0.17592257261276245,
-0.01821238175034523,
0.29656144976615906,
1.1448224782943726,
0.1030408963561058,
-0.8913167119026184,
0.5894086956977844,
0.09023360162973404,
-0.40566346049308777,
-0.12503767013549805,
0.42220914363861084,
0.1979985386133194,
0.22026757895946503,
-0.08013247698545456,
-0.5066665410995483,
0.03538268059492111,
-0.35845208168029785,
0.05263252556324005,
0.5886334776878357,
0.13502173125743866,
0.16710975766181946,
0.36086636781692505,
0.022805105894804,
0.07494471967220306,
0.8311586380004883,
-0.09542591869831085,
-0.29636144638061523,
0.711789071559906,
0.19800858199596405,
0.4791901111602783,
-0.2626659870147705,
0.3209424912929535,
0.1165783628821373,
0.3081871271133423,
-0.2531387209892273,
0.7418718338012695,
-0.002355852397158742,
-0.9374710321426392,
-0.4848427176475525,
-0.6917192935943604,
-0.5871766209602356,
0.23185887932777405,
-0.4728834629058838,
0.30671054124832153,
-0.5877692103385925,
0.019592810422182083,
-0.3936779201030731,
0.08365243673324585,
-0.8591744899749756,
0.33752384781837463,
-0.007809326518326998,
1.0739874839782715,
-0.8475682735443115,
0.7858758568763733,
0.41291943192481995,
-0.2089025378227234,
-0.9574040770530701,
-0.39254623651504517,
-0.35065773129463196,
-1.2894362211227417,
0.6209632158279419,
0.03612235188484192,
0.3365299701690674,
0.10524079203605652,
-0.5630674958229065,
-1.0888466835021973,
1.0369927883148193,
0.8063549995422363,
-0.8227299451828003,
0.26513493061065674,
0.2631588578224182,
0.19555042684078217,
-0.19598333537578583,
0.37475597858428955,
0.7691431045532227,
0.16863717138767242,
0.2522658705711365,
-0.4993428587913513,
-0.4752498269081116,
0.014640331268310547,
0.1276385337114334,
0.2568937838077545,
-0.5382720232009888,
0.933075487613678,
-0.08285734802484512,
-0.09360525012016296,
-0.20114703476428986,
0.4074220061302185,
0.4982633888721466,
0.11732356995344162,
0.8699239492416382,
0.7497034668922424,
0.8198886513710022,
-0.07290296256542206,
1.2683992385864258,
-0.42408469319343567,
0.3145481050014496,
0.7636679410934448,
-0.32039934396743774,
0.7106725573539734,
0.3514847457408905,
-0.3433555066585541,
-0.21305061876773834,
1.0100083351135254,
-0.294171005487442,
0.5113197565078735,
0.49250122904777527,
-0.26328715682029724,
-0.5143583416938782,
0.12142913788557053,
-0.16089749336242676,
0.4083845019340515,
0.20648828148841858,
-0.17283692955970764,
-0.45276933908462524,
0.10584625601768494,
0.01323819812387228,
0.012182824313640594,
-0.3711671829223633,
0.8782429099082947,
0.09854397177696228,
-0.3519768714904785,
0.6812031269073486,
-0.16974252462387085,
0.5834458470344543,
-0.660404622554779,
0.428369402885437,
-0.7626696228981018,
-0.13342684507369995,
0.06944248080253601,
-0.729997992515564,
0.3231074810028076,
-0.026931725442409515,
-0.09305880218744278,
-0.3248785734176636,
0.513445258140564,
-0.6477529406547546,
-0.5605356097221375,
0.24752771854400635,
0.8019689321517944,
0.5028139352798462,
-0.13320688903331757,
-0.7656378149986267,
0.032432686537504196,
-0.12222444266080856,
-0.5036935806274414,
0.5338646173477173,
0.08285845816135406,
0.00546928308904171,
0.7697724103927612,
0.6274753212928772,
0.6669385433197021,
0.11285177618265152,
0.20255519449710846,
0.8936603665351868,
-0.5875827670097351,
-0.48482948541641235,
-0.7576355338096619,
0.34584325551986694,
-0.19391198456287384,
-0.1988895833492279,
0.36584222316741943,
0.6070507764816284,
1.038096308708191,
0.23849652707576752,
0.7386314272880554,
0.3741782605648041,
0.8379484415054321,
-0.8992525935173035,
0.4952746629714966,
-0.6504964232444763,
0.4944060742855072,
0.14667342603206635,
-1.1015079021453857,
-0.11868646740913391,
0.633912980556488,
-0.4196527898311615,
0.2257874310016632,
0.2914181053638458,
0.9617362022399902,
-0.2747049331665039,
-0.17037512362003326,
0.46992918848991394,
-0.15626761317253113,
0.319889098405838,
0.6463465690612793,
1.0338020324707031,
-0.03476816415786743,
0.45327553153038025,
-0.4900384843349457,
-0.3118741512298584,
-0.054466549307107925,
-0.7113532423973083,
-0.9338105916976929,
-0.14415673911571503,
-0.0788905993103981,
-0.07358206808567047,
-0.044649384915828705,
0.92106693983078,
0.913445770740509,
-0.5866978168487549,
-0.451398640871048,
0.06487677246332169,
0.1604689508676529,
0.07625897973775864,
-0.1270560920238495,
0.3777686059474945,
-0.7433079481124878,
-0.7292563915252686,
0.5214110612869263,
0.06089431419968605,
0.24932026863098145,
-0.16023322939872742,
0.0931829959154129,
0.2238370180130005,
0.10817316174507141,
0.5177327990531921,
0.003936546854674816,
-0.3068206310272217,
0.15047432482242584,
0.006513137370347977,
-0.1995936632156372,
0.06568442285060883,
0.9294112324714661,
-0.47201940417289734,
0.3164932429790497,
0.43790969252586365,
1.2332032918930054,
0.5754562616348267,
0.05088453367352486,
0.49665242433547974,
-0.5978558659553528,
0.24908071756362915,
0.3755503296852112,
0.25419068336486816,
0.3407735824584961,
-0.3688390851020813,
0.5430470108985901,
0.11385085433721542,
-0.5520485639572144,
-0.8772000670433044,
0.1046156957745552,
-0.7686123847961426,
-0.5145102739334106,
1.2472659349441528,
-0.09667466580867767,
-0.0298968106508255,
-0.041404079645872116,
0.016296880319714546,
-0.03664868697524071,
0.01897144317626953,
0.6023042798042297,
0.5947464108467102,
-0.09200385212898254,
-0.38916438817977905,
-0.8543508648872375,
0.43323758244514465,
0.6390098333358765,
-1.1959607601165771,
-0.08903910219669342,
0.3485592305660248,
0.4436478018760681,
-0.41198140382766724,
0.8409802913665771,
0.031736575067043304,
-0.058780696243047714,
-0.12908975780010223,
0.07590650767087936,
-0.12518614530563354,
-0.3580329120159149,
-0.45059478282928467,
0.07817205041646957,
0.22098276019096375,
-0.19059936702251434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09666v1 | EntailE: Introducing Textual Entailment in Commonsense Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-02-15T02:27:23 | 2024-02-15T02:27:23 | Ying Su, Tianqing Fang, Huiru Xiao, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song, Tong Zhang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Commonsense knowledge graph completion is a new challenge for commonsense
knowledge graph construction and application. In contrast to factual knowledge
graphs such as Freebase and YAGO, commonsense knowledge graphs (CSKGs; e.g.,
ConceptNet) utilize free-form text to represent named entities, short phrases,
and events as their nodes. Such a loose structure results in large and sparse
CSKGs, which makes the semantic understanding of these nodes more critical for
learning rich commonsense knowledge graph embedding. While current methods
leverage semantic similarities to increase the graph density, the semantic
plausibility of the nodes and their relations are under-explored. Previous
works adopt conceptual abstraction to improve the consistency of modeling
(event) plausibility, but they are not scalable enough and still suffer from
data sparsity. In this paper, we propose to adopt textual entailment to find
implicit entailment relations between CSKG nodes, to effectively densify the
subgraph connecting nodes within the same conceptual class, which indicates a
similar level of plausibility. Each node in CSKG finds its top entailed nodes
using a finetuned transformer over natural language inference (NLI) tasks,
which sufficiently capture textual entailment signals. The entailment relation
between these nodes are further utilized to: 1) build new connections between
source triplets and entailed nodes to densify the sparse CSKGs; 2) enrich the
generalization ability of node representations by comparing the node embeddings
with a contrastive loss. Experiments on two standard CSKGs demonstrate that our
proposed framework EntailE can improve the performance of CSKG completion tasks
under both transductive and inductive settings. | [
-0.270712286233902,
-0.8992316126823425,
0.7340863943099976,
-0.02137550711631775,
-0.3052968680858612,
-0.10220497846603394,
-0.22551584243774414,
-0.32488149404525757,
0.4263332486152649,
0.6608607172966003,
-0.3775831460952759,
-0.7236812710762024,
-0.5661587715148926,
0.2308519184589386,
-0.47205111384391785,
0.7644921541213989,
-0.3630998432636261,
-0.5725230574607849,
-0.7282605767250061,
0.03026001900434494,
-0.3353198170661926,
0.09905263781547546,
-0.6513770222663879,
-0.3700200915336609,
0.32939666509628296,
0.33968713879585266,
0.7254850268363953,
0.5879585146903992,
0.21150456368923187,
0.32754385471343994,
-0.14274464547634125,
0.6506006717681885,
-0.6813518404960632,
0.24581776559352875,
0.02324187196791172,
-0.13210034370422363,
-0.19945868849754333,
-0.01067647710442543,
0.5638571381568909,
0.9634882211685181,
0.171803817152977,
-0.17664264142513275,
0.5192177295684814,
0.5067501664161682,
-0.6945506930351257,
0.2603287696838379,
-0.6633926033973694,
-0.04119383171200752,
-0.00973101332783699,
-0.07729445397853851,
-0.48125433921813965,
-0.44533950090408325,
0.3254666030406952,
-1.2703675031661987,
0.37765777111053467,
0.11547280102968216,
0.9637423753738403,
0.3381013572216034,
-0.6012963652610779,
-0.3678262233734131,
-0.10880287736654282,
0.3938570022583008,
-0.6430761814117432,
0.45539581775665283,
0.6167922616004944,
-0.0029036991763859987,
-0.16831910610198975,
-0.9546512365341187,
-0.7451605200767517,
-0.44848427176475525,
-0.6977922916412354,
0.29462918639183044,
-0.08734128624200821,
0.2855879068374634,
0.1957799792289734,
0.28698602318763733,
-0.45472201704978943,
-0.14218047261238098,
-0.019127899780869484,
-0.18623842298984528,
0.39053982496261597,
0.04181836545467377,
0.245609849691391,
-0.23327533900737762,
-0.2597353458404541,
0.33467164635658264,
-0.7028128504753113,
-0.3639698922634125,
0.4427902102470398,
0.08013875037431717,
-0.1561560034751892,
0.657021164894104,
-0.5274696350097656,
0.6971803307533264,
0.11979033052921295,
0.1454201191663742,
0.23574800789356232,
-0.6001301407814026,
-0.21468935906887054,
0.2357412576675415,
0.5560529828071594,
0.32706111669540405,
0.38925737142562866,
-0.6074233055114746,
0.37320128083229065,
0.06851392984390259,
-0.03129801154136658,
-0.7304651737213135,
-0.03801528364419937,
0.4332405626773834,
-0.26247942447662354,
-0.1800052523612976,
-0.06132637709379196,
-0.3385825753211975,
-0.5137231945991516,
-0.597929060459137,
0.40644964575767517,
-0.6881167888641357,
-0.44628533720970154,
0.32016417384147644,
-0.4086630344390869,
0.12434979528188705,
0.4172342121601105,
-0.4810939133167267,
0.45435959100723267,
0.922284722328186,
0.8382363319396973,
-0.025302540510892868,
-0.18173393607139587,
-0.27265051007270813,
0.6705986261367798,
-0.3859066963195801,
0.5731484293937683,
-0.6425126194953918,
-0.07949574291706085,
-0.028247594833374023,
0.15139935910701752,
-0.17671336233615875,
-0.3225246071815491,
0.6430028676986694,
-0.2672779858112335,
-0.009433536790311337,
-0.17586080729961395,
-0.9325196146965027,
-0.24496065080165863,
0.44450804591178894,
-0.5723717212677002,
1.0842537879943848,
-0.10999009758234024,
-1.0597256422042847,
0.28538233041763306,
-0.5172337293624878,
-0.5036906599998474,
0.1582479327917099,
0.10259763896465302,
-0.1986348181962967,
-0.2417934387922287,
0.0939583107829094,
0.6174618005752563,
-0.06849564611911774,
0.3299195468425751,
-0.3289547860622406,
-0.2734324634075165,
0.06874477118253708,
-0.0737084150314331,
0.6530328989028931,
-0.05221887305378914,
-0.07543326169252396,
-0.09374423325061798,
-0.6195842623710632,
-0.20146815478801727,
-0.10764957964420319,
0.017488468438386917,
-0.7333120703697205,
0.14012759923934937,
-0.26169249415397644,
-0.33427301049232483,
0.255104124546051,
-0.7788036465644836,
-0.29472532868385315,
-0.8767905235290527,
0.47216796875,
0.35779157280921936,
0.28904056549072266,
0.7296748161315918,
-0.17946860194206238,
-0.13429157435894012,
0.06289664655923843,
-0.0684637799859047,
-0.004030989482998848,
-0.5398204922676086,
-0.7366717457771301,
-0.23108050227165222,
0.2850024700164795,
0.4207456409931183,
-0.9650566577911377,
0.39310142397880554,
-0.3822835385799408,
-0.27252766489982605,
-0.33717063069343567,
0.0037925741635262966,
0.2368081510066986,
0.6375223398208618,
0.2921765446662903,
0.1664675921201706,
-0.46593815088272095,
-0.9122602343559265,
-0.32805564999580383,
0.1133139580488205,
-0.106584832072258,
0.092886783182621,
0.6241254210472107,
-0.006704377010464668,
0.9514148831367493,
-0.6122726798057556,
-0.2679636776447296,
-0.20130647718906403,
0.14017869532108307,
0.08776917308568954,
0.4928905963897705,
0.35754477977752686,
-0.7789050340652466,
-0.6196713447570801,
0.38810378313064575,
-0.7309551239013672,
0.006174852605909109,
0.06393782049417496,
-0.44387346506118774,
0.07527878135442734,
0.5316833853721619,
-0.507058322429657,
0.5630413889884949,
0.059728287160396576,
-0.42470353841781616,
0.11324011534452438,
-0.09023700654506683,
0.22007200121879578,
-0.9466565251350403,
-0.2812458574771881,
-0.10398835688829422,
-0.2523428797721863,
-0.5345073938369751,
0.16382743418216705,
0.021068627014756203,
0.03142734244465828,
-0.20726589858531952,
0.5184134244918823,
-0.28899556398391724,
0.1768716275691986,
-0.04949916899204254,
0.6540431380271912,
0.21529638767242432,
0.3835189938545227,
0.055734097957611084,
0.10540837794542313,
0.5375049710273743,
-0.7078644037246704,
0.29201483726501465,
0.28219830989837646,
0.03815429285168648,
0.5935297012329102,
-0.7200107574462891,
-0.14831030368804932,
-0.37297534942626953,
0.22304114699363708,
-0.9930126070976257,
-0.27895587682724,
0.36544743180274963,
-0.6364348530769348,
0.1848033368587494,
-0.267457515001297,
-0.6725676655769348,
0.06800317019224167,
-0.1829572170972824,
0.19657215476036072,
0.303617000579834,
-0.3595810830593109,
0.8041547536849976,
0.14353306591510773,
0.12265966832637787,
-0.5516757369041443,
-0.6799247860908508,
0.11956925690174103,
-0.010844362899661064,
-0.796889066696167,
0.4717825651168823,
0.326960951089859,
-0.24684542417526245,
0.5456981062889099,
-0.02706645056605339,
-0.17587131261825562,
0.14068537950515747,
0.1728593111038208,
-0.006176438648253679,
-0.2016327679157257,
0.4541464149951935,
0.36701589822769165,
-0.1611504852771759,
-0.11344413459300995,
-0.39195626974105835,
0.19737878441810608,
0.0015101141761988401,
-0.45234885811805725,
-0.29183363914489746,
0.46378597617149353,
0.0907963290810585,
-0.14671432971954346,
0.725675642490387,
0.4926196336746216,
-0.7080788612365723,
-0.1671810895204544,
-0.4201841354370117,
-0.23037080466747284,
-0.3922724425792694,
0.28159815073013306,
-0.20050866901874542,
-1.0987156629562378,
0.41870734095573425,
-0.13007938861846924,
0.11559884995222092,
0.5504024624824524,
-0.05068766698241234,
-0.1130058690905571,
0.47134771943092346,
0.2063378244638443,
0.5792907476425171,
-0.12678174674510956,
-0.27582287788391113,
0.09423694014549255,
-0.7265328168869019,
-0.3527182936668396,
-0.5124472975730896,
-0.22825613617897034,
-0.6899119019508362,
-0.4092908501625061,
0.35015177726745605,
0.15820695459842682,
-0.37986549735069275,
0.3318081498146057,
-0.47399845719337463,
0.6071040630340576,
0.1958332657814026,
0.2036323994398117,
0.5067279934883118,
0.05095980316400528,
-0.1907171905040741,
-0.08053214102983475,
-0.6470015048980713,
-0.3513270318508148,
0.7701851725578308,
0.1264406144618988,
0.3022505044937134,
0.1748216152191162,
0.8225808143615723,
0.021802134811878204,
0.2118116170167923,
-0.6648141145706177,
0.5360016822814941,
-0.3981016278266907,
-0.1784484088420868,
-0.5154493451118469,
-0.4182479679584503,
-1.0095957517623901,
0.23887299001216888,
-0.39351171255111694,
-0.5450734496116638,
0.1299399584531784,
0.06290031224489212,
0.18065990507602692,
0.15150904655456543,
-0.7346735000610352,
0.8078286647796631,
0.4585358798503876,
-0.47006431221961975,
-0.3791253864765167,
-0.36922577023506165,
0.40890777111053467,
0.30482950806617737,
0.11717244982719421,
-0.07593443244695663,
-0.25738438963890076,
0.6682801246643066,
-0.5539870858192444,
1.051534652709961,
-0.1058148667216301,
0.009984076023101807,
0.551154375076294,
0.17652732133865356,
0.6707888245582581,
0.21543729305267334,
0.09639699757099152,
-0.06935449689626694,
-0.13832224905490875,
-0.3103737235069275,
-0.8460564613342285,
0.7416637539863586,
-0.46602120995521545,
-0.404275119304657,
-0.01552110631018877,
-0.3474943935871124,
-0.22312000393867493,
0.19000576436519623,
-0.05962838977575302,
0.7621806263923645,
-0.1326906681060791,
0.28915759921073914,
1.0255893468856812,
-0.16680528223514557,
0.2234160453081131,
0.27944591641426086,
0.2288454920053482,
-0.31888070702552795,
0.9042290449142456,
0.1690455675125122,
0.25980639457702637,
0.5817830562591553,
0.2379772961139679,
-0.48422911763191223,
-0.480803906917572,
-0.29361793398857117,
0.2776906192302704,
-0.7784498333930969,
-0.28902551531791687,
-0.971940279006958,
-0.3247941732406616,
-0.5543447732925415,
-0.3095877766609192,
-0.061631105840206146,
-0.6037392020225525,
-0.14141011238098145,
-0.21971926093101501,
0.76849365234375,
0.6484573483467102,
0.1743323653936386,
0.1708572804927826,
-0.34568798542022705,
0.39244505763053894,
0.25037381052970886,
0.4365832805633545,
0.19666726887226105,
-0.3256901800632477,
-0.04187045618891716,
0.04536520689725876,
-0.1873617023229599,
-0.9795386791229248,
-0.07465485483407974,
0.2719704210758209,
0.7307088971138,
0.20834335684776306,
0.4358130991458893,
0.504301130771637,
-0.390661358833313,
0.47028908133506775,
0.14798517525196075,
-0.9553760886192322,
0.48755937814712524,
-0.39925312995910645,
-0.07231088727712631,
0.3313095271587372,
0.5251772403717041,
-0.6253884434700012,
-0.8394523859024048,
-0.7559583783149719,
-0.9314882755279541,
0.42815202474594116,
0.4706609845161438,
0.039568010717630386,
-0.3237852454185486,
0.41326773166656494,
0.05486098676919937,
-0.05085735395550728,
-0.5773407220840454,
-0.18121914565563202,
-0.5203925371170044,
-0.5792673230171204,
0.4353644847869873,
-0.13529209792613983,
-0.10950364172458649,
-0.07060185074806213,
0.6143566370010376,
-0.24646209180355072,
0.01536567322909832,
0.3500475287437439,
-0.08089037984609604,
0.4679344892501831,
0.3444429337978363,
0.12369302660226822,
0.49863970279693604,
0.0255768783390522,
0.5064405202865601,
0.4814832806587219,
-0.36872434616088867,
-0.23599913716316223,
0.09850016981363297,
-0.3904819190502167,
0.044016748666763306,
0.5859349966049194,
0.5520316362380981,
0.4806762635707855,
-0.3040928542613983,
0.6084199547767639,
0.28084924817085266,
-0.6053541898727417,
-0.1685606688261032,
-0.13976579904556274,
0.5883098244667053,
-0.16131068766117096,
0.11798609793186188,
-0.12066356092691422,
0.34552156925201416,
-0.16802585124969482,
0.21513958275318146,
0.2915363311767578,
-0.350068062543869,
0.21698692440986633,
0.3797799348831177,
0.3234029710292816,
0.3200671672821045,
0.34379449486732483,
-0.49156543612480164,
-0.3694862127304077,
0.8070343732833862,
0.49884068965911865,
0.7332753539085388,
0.3181006908416748,
0.4437146782875061,
0.7489820122718811,
0.4158347547054291,
-0.10293589532375336,
-0.0648784190416336,
-0.04358334094285965,
-0.8138318657875061,
-0.7611223459243774,
-0.49210745096206665,
-0.18442930281162262,
-0.252223402261734,
-0.336954265832901,
0.21505816280841827,
-0.2013287991285324,
0.35462918877601624,
0.012691187672317028,
-0.06279605627059937,
-0.533344030380249,
0.02027106285095215,
-0.2394595742225647,
0.8107241988182068,
-0.7461180686950684,
0.4195370078086853,
0.4134800136089325,
-0.38699159026145935,
-0.6839802861213684,
-0.12283559143543243,
-0.2923958897590637,
-0.5129728317260742,
0.5959571003913879,
-0.05695420503616333,
-0.12304546684026718,
0.17259904742240906,
-0.5752788186073303,
-0.7866201996803284,
1.1261465549468994,
0.20858176052570343,
-0.11228451132774353,
0.21312713623046875,
0.16111451387405396,
0.3097184896469116,
-0.27995985746383667,
0.20923198759555817,
0.36702585220336914,
0.6909843683242798,
0.4096944332122803,
-0.6605688333511353,
0.6003040671348572,
0.06362074613571167,
-0.14464062452316284,
0.3229566216468811,
-0.31437039375305176,
0.47334638237953186,
-0.15248197317123413,
-0.5702918171882629,
-0.20412510633468628,
0.8735840320587158,
0.1638137698173523,
0.6404461860656738,
0.4070158302783966,
0.8172151446342468,
0.7968051433563232,
-0.22713592648506165,
0.7653436660766602,
0.02871844172477722,
0.10075610131025314,
0.9945017099380493,
-0.12984704971313477,
0.7004632949829102,
0.20481078326702118,
-0.053929973393678665,
0.48714688420295715,
0.49302932620048523,
0.38586118817329407,
0.29335686564445496,
0.1315305382013321,
-0.18124501407146454,
-0.39631783962249756,
-0.36712807416915894,
-0.4283897876739502,
0.1623479127883911,
0.5858915448188782,
-0.037896279245615005,
-0.48082461953163147,
-0.14304697513580322,
0.14061923325061798,
0.4108469486236572,
-0.41463688015937805,
0.884698212146759,
-0.1325952708721161,
-0.540561318397522,
0.4528292417526245,
-0.07432015240192413,
0.569247305393219,
-0.6516393423080444,
-0.23299135267734528,
-0.12337690591812134,
-0.20846793055534363,
-0.403261661529541,
-0.8541529178619385,
0.6649631261825562,
-0.38122132420539856,
-0.03975505754351616,
-0.10148154199123383,
0.9988653063774109,
-0.7237114906311035,
-0.3669343888759613,
0.14041383564472198,
0.4024485647678375,
0.010388568043708801,
0.03188054636120796,
-0.22637657821178436,
-0.43359291553497314,
-0.2686779201030731,
0.1147652417421341,
0.12628446519374847,
0.9670416116714478,
-0.04008868336677551,
0.37864950299263,
0.47874417901039124,
-0.20052359998226166,
-0.1674593985080719,
0.03657785430550575,
0.8299515247344971,
-0.2672315835952759,
-0.5071102380752563,
-0.6878789663314819,
0.39518260955810547,
-0.511415958404541,
-0.06404626369476318,
0.8007293939590454,
0.7074127793312073,
0.783248782157898,
0.1424005776643753,
0.6850515007972717,
-0.23271498084068298,
0.4221929907798767,
-0.6445991396903992,
0.6787656545639038,
-0.37789008021354675,
-0.051892656832933426,
-0.20247682929039001,
-0.4316861033439636,
-0.18451237678527832,
0.42137959599494934,
-0.27771902084350586,
-0.30855220556259155,
0.9668528437614441,
0.8671364188194275,
-0.10377585887908936,
0.26773330569267273,
0.24449339509010315,
0.2212490439414978,
-0.23156651854515076,
0.5637050867080688,
0.7934644818305969,
-0.31188690662384033,
0.6125014424324036,
-0.0009976621950045228,
-0.1863545924425125,
0.2102358043193817,
-1.0005357265472412,
-0.9106512069702148,
-0.7707135081291199,
-0.6193736791610718,
-0.45529910922050476,
0.15678414702415466,
0.6374739408493042,
0.266711562871933,
-0.6102455854415894,
0.17497724294662476,
-0.28155839443206787,
0.5835545659065247,
-0.2154037207365036,
-0.3171136677265167,
0.6249106526374817,
-0.4701244831085205,
-0.6088091731071472,
-0.001989307813346386,
0.20182959735393524,
0.07117439061403275,
0.14058798551559448,
-0.14470171928405762,
-0.2476850003004074,
-0.07168097048997879,
0.5361596345901489,
-0.1317843496799469,
-0.841140866279602,
-0.43395036458969116,
-0.09152641147375107,
0.05260597914457321,
-0.47535109519958496,
0.9405484199523926,
-0.801672637462616,
0.19500161707401276,
0.7292335033416748,
0.860935628414154,
0.5267683267593384,
-0.2885863780975342,
0.3049456477165222,
-1.1080507040023804,
0.14408467710018158,
0.06137611344456673,
0.3586055636405945,
0.35578832030296326,
-0.4538326859474182,
0.6898103356361389,
0.4808439016342163,
-0.1197226271033287,
-0.5166243314743042,
0.43142980337142944,
-1.0235894918441772,
-0.48915982246398926,
1.2965049743652344,
-0.13974733650684357,
-0.1905537247657776,
-0.6978456974029541,
-0.09658675640821457,
0.42380622029304504,
-0.17895837128162384,
0.1700619012117386,
0.6066513061523438,
0.02807793766260147,
-0.10341358929872513,
-0.5525256395339966,
0.6768949627876282,
-0.02363135665655136,
-0.6674966216087341,
0.2591709792613983,
0.40623655915260315,
0.16776525974273682,
0.08141286671161652,
0.6624990701675415,
-0.06298233568668365,
0.12558723986148834,
0.2776671350002289,
-0.22524906694889069,
-0.4642147421836853,
0.14120052754878998,
0.5590061545372009,
0.2869102656841278,
-0.4027794301509857,
-0.07434099912643433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09664v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09664v4 | CodeMind: A Framework to Challenge Large Language Models for Code Reasoning | 2024-02-15T02:24:46 | 2024-04-03T06:23:48 | Changshu Liu, Shizhuo Dylan Zhang, Ali Reza Ibrahimzada, Reyhaneh Jabbarvand | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL | Solely relying on test passing to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) for
code synthesis may result in unfair assessment or promoting models with data
leakage. As an alternative, we introduce CodeMind, a framework designed to
gauge the code reasoning abilities of LLMs. CodeMind currently supports three
code reasoning tasks: Independent Execution Reasoning (IER), Dependent
Execution Reasoning (DER), and Specification Reasoning (SR). The first two
evaluate models to predict the execution output of an arbitrary code or code
the model could correctly synthesize. The third one evaluates the extent to
which LLMs implement the specified expected behavior.
Our extensive evaluation of nine LLMs across five benchmarks in two different
programming languages using CodeMind shows that LLMs fairly follow control flow
constructs and, in general, explain how inputs evolve to output, specifically
for simple programs and the ones they can correctly synthesize. However, their
performance drops for code with higher complexity, non-trivial logical and
arithmetic operators, non-primitive types, and API calls. Furthermore, we
observe that, while correlated, specification reasoning (essential for code
synthesis) does not imply execution reasoning (essential for broader
programming tasks such as testing and debugging): ranking LLMs based on test
passing can be different compared to code reasoning. | [
-0.17957665026187897,
-0.435472309589386,
0.8254783749580383,
0.33062803745269775,
0.12505052983760834,
0.2256217747926712,
-0.3616828918457031,
-0.3003447353839874,
-0.2743188738822937,
0.5089634656906128,
-0.5954053401947021,
-0.6116706728935242,
-0.486735075712204,
0.101691834628582,
-0.5526922345161438,
0.6938151717185974,
-0.32000938057899475,
0.1476653516292572,
-0.5707883238792419,
0.04470076039433479,
-0.7173536419868469,
-0.477578341960907,
-0.32464084029197693,
-0.5670561194419861,
0.39399978518486023,
0.27366766333580017,
0.5265712738037109,
0.5249951481819153,
0.6207809448242188,
0.21826612949371338,
0.09748289734125137,
-0.04849034547805786,
-0.5006300210952759,
0.2659097909927368,
-0.09571746736764908,
-0.9221789240837097,
-0.28739306330680847,
-0.11141679435968399,
0.3188757300376892,
0.6816797256469727,
-0.06744623929262161,
0.23432034254074097,
-0.13595236837863922,
0.6201021671295166,
-0.6524645090103149,
0.42503517866134644,
-0.7131208181381226,
-0.06283694505691528,
0.030876895412802696,
-0.12061720341444016,
-0.5657569766044617,
-0.5327884554862976,
-0.2947009801864624,
-0.12771421670913696,
-0.10317938774824142,
0.01605619303882122,
0.36374035477638245,
0.49955323338508606,
-0.08998315781354904,
-0.3875039219856262,
-0.5122689604759216,
0.6764046549797058,
-0.8031807541847229,
0.29761752486228943,
0.21328458189964294,
0.36454474925994873,
-0.1070089191198349,
-0.5260581374168396,
-0.6806380152702332,
-0.34391719102859497,
0.09136650711297989,
-0.019925657659769058,
-0.08264268189668655,
0.11857901513576508,
0.5607316493988037,
0.37373608350753784,
-0.7762424349784851,
-0.002654255134984851,
-0.290333092212677,
-0.2565094232559204,
0.6825913190841675,
0.354791522026062,
0.3152916431427002,
0.08061935007572174,
-0.1720699518918991,
-0.0036628723610192537,
-1.084362506866455,
0.06611920148134232,
0.34733209013938904,
0.12379559874534607,
0.013284113258123398,
0.6268212199211121,
-0.16440171003341675,
0.8418797254562378,
-0.43521416187286377,
0.04554625228047371,
0.13042335212230682,
0.12102270126342773,
-0.3485259413719177,
-0.16287289559841156,
0.6585832238197327,
0.27798789739608765,
0.4497126340866089,
-0.1459079086780548,
-0.4092205762863159,
0.4813723564147949,
0.3019644021987915,
-0.7564109563827515,
-0.3843759596347809,
0.3870447278022766,
-0.4602225422859192,
-0.3050186336040497,
0.07247204333543777,
-0.37730467319488525,
-0.44583258032798767,
-0.39861947298049927,
0.3528566062450409,
-0.4465583264827728,
-0.22745376825332642,
0.27248242497444153,
-0.22676809132099152,
0.4468434154987335,
0.35900628566741943,
-0.5782336592674255,
0.22750478982925415,
1.0706309080123901,
0.5742692947387695,
-0.5229524970054626,
-0.3320237696170807,
-0.22813180088996887,
-0.13785116374492645,
-0.6298872828483582,
0.7278507947921753,
-0.6998808979988098,
-0.18314552307128906,
-0.05688634514808655,
-0.28780606389045715,
-0.21553149819374084,
-0.7719202637672424,
0.15453512966632843,
-0.6458204984664917,
-0.2108858823776245,
-0.07335060834884644,
-0.8652865290641785,
-0.0938027873635292,
0.26619356870651245,
-0.42350199818611145,
0.737476646900177,
0.15454129874706268,
-0.49086058139801025,
0.3572578430175781,
-0.5482475757598877,
-0.6324363350868225,
0.2005467265844345,
-0.6868444085121155,
0.08958536386489868,
0.12773118913173676,
-0.1189141571521759,
0.41027453541755676,
-0.41272833943367004,
0.29616987705230713,
-0.6016154289245605,
-0.7974907755851746,
0.47811946272850037,
-0.2671210765838623,
0.7381914854049683,
0.3280497193336487,
-0.6076595783233643,
0.14421936869621277,
-0.5682151317596436,
0.6412159204483032,
0.09033861011266708,
-0.2709188461303711,
0.017471712082624435,
0.20264698565006256,
-0.3746362328529358,
0.06247902661561966,
-0.057583313435316086,
-0.17789660394191742,
0.32108256220817566,
-0.24883179366588593,
0.632084310054779,
0.8125957250595093,
-0.06442012637853622,
0.24159517884254456,
-0.5331898927688599,
0.765913188457489,
-0.22023038566112518,
0.11014324426651001,
-0.226180300116539,
-0.5939496159553528,
-0.7695266008377075,
-0.24189847707748413,
0.2413431853055954,
0.671226978302002,
-0.6386303305625916,
0.34838107228279114,
-0.3293415904045105,
-0.4161246120929718,
-0.2797551453113556,
0.2575165331363678,
0.6027863025665283,
-0.023949159309267998,
0.013768629170954227,
-0.1550525277853012,
-0.5347201228141785,
-0.8158340454101562,
-0.5876460075378418,
-0.5264053344726562,
-0.14710697531700134,
0.20890280604362488,
0.5464295744895935,
-0.1780865341424942,
0.6945427060127258,
-0.6870402097702026,
-0.03396163508296013,
-0.5067775845527649,
-0.09685318171977997,
0.4788382351398468,
0.4680754542350769,
0.16962236166000366,
-0.6705659627914429,
-0.17221559584140778,
-0.19897758960723877,
-0.743495762348175,
-0.2519650459289551,
0.009114144369959831,
0.07376924902200699,
0.18890628218650818,
0.649645984172821,
-0.4888693392276764,
0.37208324670791626,
0.731132984161377,
-0.28349369764328003,
0.6170084476470947,
0.11195214092731476,
0.10780607908964157,
-0.4977463483810425,
0.07303527742624283,
-0.4464695453643799,
-0.17604370415210724,
-0.2346116453409195,
0.6535860300064087,
0.23015767335891724,
-0.15559622645378113,
-0.21527598798274994,
0.36275410652160645,
-0.24508316814899445,
-0.16618669033050537,
-0.14128424227237701,
-0.33037853240966797,
-0.05201949551701546,
0.550072193145752,
-0.07582012563943863,
1.0379377603530884,
0.5974476337432861,
-0.586798369884491,
0.3023785650730133,
-0.12207368016242981,
-0.6812536120414734,
0.2280891090631485,
-0.7157881259918213,
0.36701667308807373,
0.3292084038257599,
0.07912151515483856,
-0.8374927043914795,
-0.25160276889801025,
-0.08486080914735794,
-0.6094415783882141,
0.20395413041114807,
-0.17435072362422943,
-0.6671053767204285,
-0.4405587315559387,
-0.1065535768866539,
0.30490192770957947,
0.8067731857299805,
-0.24122120440006256,
0.4513072669506073,
0.2827649414539337,
0.032747168093919754,
-0.3351791799068451,
-1.0077977180480957,
0.07461751252412796,
0.035660263150930405,
-0.5070155262947083,
0.1204138994216919,
-0.4260576367378235,
-0.5720427632331848,
-0.061206333339214325,
-0.334368497133255,
-0.2645542323589325,
0.1563723385334015,
0.4451799988746643,
0.2534922659397125,
-0.21720129251480103,
0.11812596768140793,
-0.1670536994934082,
0.12710340321063995,
0.5755707025527954,
-0.3857656717300415,
0.44560182094573975,
-0.16383767127990723,
-0.7739959359169006,
-0.010328403674066067,
0.24635063111782074,
0.6486217975616455,
-0.16840380430221558,
0.3907182514667511,
0.09110255539417267,
-0.28584131598472595,
-0.829502284526825,
-0.5517579913139343,
-0.017769141122698784,
-0.4556465148925781,
0.19090448319911957,
-0.7264385223388672,
-1.0293818712234497,
0.5432038307189941,
0.013723239302635193,
-0.04391387104988098,
0.24765536189079285,
0.8420762419700623,
0.09318447858095169,
1.167542576789856,
0.47170794010162354,
0.08950305730104446,
0.07740142196416855,
-0.2533467411994934,
0.4303602874279022,
-0.5276252627372742,
-0.20828793942928314,
-0.37334296107292175,
-0.10135282576084137,
-0.42897000908851624,
-0.6466361880302429,
0.15916398167610168,
0.13333062827587128,
-0.16613927483558655,
0.3954458236694336,
-0.5079182982444763,
0.6766110062599182,
0.39089423418045044,
0.09470256417989731,
0.274778813123703,
-0.3373360335826874,
-0.4076245129108429,
0.1733371615409851,
-0.7030799984931946,
-0.4099266827106476,
1.1561329364776611,
0.2559094727039337,
1.1735764741897583,
0.08475875109434128,
0.6678845882415771,
0.5010109543800354,
0.49391040205955505,
-0.8444910049438477,
0.63173907995224,
0.12209416925907135,
-0.6613898873329163,
-0.03087352029979229,
-0.7026198506355286,
-0.3405580222606659,
0.00821570586413145,
0.39821961522102356,
-0.6266727447509766,
-0.08495587855577469,
0.10407523810863495,
-0.2396826446056366,
0.18372328579425812,
-0.910931408405304,
0.8107199668884277,
-0.049268197268247604,
-0.21929126977920532,
-0.17973171174526215,
-0.2013436257839203,
0.7130942344665527,
-0.05933285877108574,
0.3057495355606079,
-0.12827803194522858,
0.12285026162862778,
0.48405805230140686,
-0.4958173632621765,
0.6933502554893494,
-0.015880271792411804,
-0.3163926303386688,
0.4309825301170349,
0.6388780474662781,
0.23952239751815796,
0.2144518494606018,
-0.15582245588302612,
0.1626814901828766,
0.10093031078577042,
-0.1950170397758484,
-0.8363300561904907,
0.7906182408332825,
-0.4894292652606964,
-0.8098060488700867,
-0.23170635104179382,
-0.6566433906555176,
-0.4301184415817261,
0.273093581199646,
0.201336070895195,
0.48900002241134644,
0.07461801916360855,
0.06130797043442726,
0.7287079095840454,
-0.18574440479278564,
0.1043437197804451,
0.19572316110134125,
-0.516646146774292,
-0.20248918235301971,
0.7811442017555237,
-0.1871793121099472,
0.5214748978614807,
0.2954692840576172,
-0.002240400295704603,
-0.16970688104629517,
-0.6421592831611633,
-0.31840407848358154,
-0.06271172314882278,
-1.0943864583969116,
-0.44881176948547363,
-0.48088574409484863,
-0.4144342541694641,
-0.3861692547798157,
-0.0821203663945198,
-0.29571738839149475,
-0.3168930411338806,
0.26468268036842346,
0.04699021950364113,
0.2390676587820053,
0.8900622129440308,
0.19463695585727692,
-0.33058837056159973,
-0.5178266763687134,
0.27998408675193787,
0.4220980405807495,
0.721288800239563,
-0.08520704507827759,
-0.4586256742477417,
0.016541970893740654,
-0.19484098255634308,
-0.0898635983467102,
-0.7836266756057739,
-0.04035648703575134,
-0.08675982803106308,
0.573021650314331,
0.20679526031017303,
0.14047342538833618,
0.5083739161491394,
-0.5237376689910889,
0.7075612545013428,
0.10201971232891083,
-1.27241051197052,
0.5213779807090759,
-0.23916973173618317,
0.4319523870944977,
0.5314924120903015,
-0.09890693426132202,
-0.25072377920150757,
-0.7367724776268005,
-0.28873705863952637,
-0.40801694989204407,
0.41998234391212463,
0.35858964920043945,
0.07181727886199951,
-0.022867146879434586,
0.3200059235095978,
-0.0021483127493411303,
0.17125646770000458,
-0.7779877781867981,
-0.2676369547843933,
0.16138477623462677,
-0.24549199640750885,
0.16583193838596344,
-0.040109071880578995,
-0.1389283537864685,
-0.2871254086494446,
0.2914230227470398,
-0.32624316215515137,
0.5495203137397766,
0.18621551990509033,
-0.2879560887813568,
0.07635463029146194,
0.21167804300785065,
0.5913708209991455,
1.0529789924621582,
-0.06650637090206146,
0.2521677613258362,
0.0073411655612289906,
-0.24843384325504303,
0.22223205864429474,
-0.16084493696689606,
-0.2126346379518509,
-0.07847674936056137,
0.7528672218322754,
0.5408514738082886,
0.21370694041252136,
-1.119824767112732,
0.7907344698905945,
-0.09255854040384293,
-0.5544718503952026,
-0.3950348496437073,
0.6284313797950745,
0.1850101351737976,
0.2007625848054886,
0.2544844448566437,
0.26098665595054626,
0.14516867697238922,
-0.48776426911354065,
0.3250975012779236,
0.24558313190937042,
-0.4439125061035156,
-0.10604989528656006,
0.6309963464736938,
-0.07423476129770279,
-0.3150031864643097,
0.48243391513824463,
-0.41667523980140686,
-0.8158835172653198,
0.9310898780822754,
0.49161139130592346,
0.9452744126319885,
0.1997826248407364,
-0.030054228380322456,
0.13811573386192322,
0.4990769326686859,
-0.10552164912223816,
0.6069242358207703,
-0.03399878740310669,
-0.6746423244476318,
-0.8658480644226074,
-0.427532821893692,
-0.5706382393836975,
-0.00310344947502017,
-0.601342499256134,
0.22151009738445282,
-0.6290937066078186,
0.08732222020626068,
-0.16058120131492615,
-0.19689641892910004,
-0.83650803565979,
0.04491521790623665,
0.32836952805519104,
1.3026889562606812,
-0.400124192237854,
0.8804871439933777,
0.6717158555984497,
-0.21403226256370544,
-1.0239273309707642,
0.08009452372789383,
0.08545798808336258,
-0.9929828643798828,
0.7910165190696716,
0.4022268056869507,
-0.2103217989206314,
-0.12134850025177002,
-0.6577479839324951,
-0.6534982919692993,
0.8745160698890686,
0.45775657892227173,
-0.49663397669792175,
0.022304005920886993,
-0.0006058901199139655,
0.4474579691886902,
-0.4918007552623749,
0.3507342040538788,
0.5137959718704224,
0.4596036672592163,
0.06911597400903702,
-0.7654166221618652,
0.23077741265296936,
-0.3579689860343933,
0.1660245656967163,
0.10664491355419159,
-0.4291292428970337,
0.8005515336990356,
-0.5762173533439636,
-0.26043322682380676,
0.14101840555667877,
0.20388883352279663,
0.5691413879394531,
0.07687722146511078,
0.5669515132904053,
0.5534110069274902,
0.5244469046592712,
-0.21252623200416565,
1.3006563186645508,
-0.3913171887397766,
0.20699149370193481,
1.0120965242385864,
-0.7498358488082886,
0.8665437698364258,
0.36142411828041077,
-0.5286692380905151,
0.5946229100227356,
0.3539711833000183,
-0.07632364332675934,
0.3775460422039032,
0.7827262878417969,
0.0981859341263771,
-0.4340471923351288,
0.27165672183036804,
-0.3563061058521271,
0.5802179574966431,
0.29533442854881287,
-0.20993508398532867,
0.09001743048429489,
-0.2951349914073944,
-0.09228932857513428,
0.14320412278175354,
-0.0982811227440834,
0.5524874329566956,
0.28784096240997314,
-1.0361604690551758,
0.75545734167099,
-0.06108587607741356,
0.4141586720943451,
-0.6017580628395081,
-0.27271178364753723,
-0.3208760619163513,
0.4591153860092163,
-0.14917729794979095,
-0.8024551868438721,
0.46132680773735046,
0.17766959965229034,
-0.2003345489501953,
-0.3867163062095642,
0.5633484721183777,
-0.147039994597435,
-0.3252768814563751,
0.5110446214675903,
0.5387250781059265,
0.10780932009220123,
-0.2656898498535156,
-0.7501654624938965,
0.4854109287261963,
0.08767654746770859,
-0.16763560473918915,
0.16045205295085907,
0.414249986410141,
0.15245626866817474,
0.9449153542518616,
0.6877238154411316,
0.2371298223733902,
0.03850198909640312,
0.28690996766090393,
0.8732157349586487,
-0.6828652024269104,
-0.43479520082473755,
-0.9979839324951172,
0.04684869945049286,
0.02139766700565815,
-0.25395482778549194,
0.6658482551574707,
0.5698801279067993,
0.9797165989875793,
-0.04718455672264099,
0.9159004092216492,
-0.1946938931941986,
0.3900478780269623,
-0.7812492251396179,
0.6852454543113708,
-0.3580736517906189,
0.5324043035507202,
-0.19533687829971313,
-0.9069017171859741,
-0.4801660180091858,
0.5410232543945312,
-0.2624932527542114,
0.08918355405330658,
1.0267407894134521,
0.8806837797164917,
0.21751469373703003,
0.022485895082354546,
0.47265246510505676,
0.13668985664844513,
0.39846405386924744,
1.0181894302368164,
1.1943752765655518,
-0.23658092319965363,
0.5929463505744934,
0.03294789418578148,
-0.27481359243392944,
0.08450142294168472,
-0.8146166205406189,
-1.0596016645431519,
-0.17830289900302887,
-0.28657111525535583,
-0.3857905864715576,
-0.08266256749629974,
0.7456973791122437,
0.7385434508323669,
-0.9853578805923462,
-0.4032208025455475,
-0.4990708827972412,
0.45713290572166443,
-0.4106229245662689,
-0.30391553044319153,
-0.012208376079797745,
-0.5880666971206665,
-0.3462880253791809,
0.4336424767971039,
0.43941742181777954,
-0.46762505173683167,
-0.5266254544258118,
-0.22436371445655823,
0.31046369671821594,
0.08456167578697205,
0.46587246656417847,
-0.007364266086369753,
-0.8812078237533569,
-0.2118324190378189,
0.16203895211219788,
-0.32599788904190063,
-0.10892344266176224,
1.2390458583831787,
-0.6873879432678223,
0.29861316084861755,
0.5698387622833252,
0.8719634413719177,
0.11070827394723892,
-0.49469664692878723,
0.8749784231185913,
-0.35511514544487,
-0.14437532424926758,
0.32612842321395874,
0.4492073059082031,
0.03002222254872322,
-0.18785721063613892,
0.618270218372345,
0.21393486857414246,
-0.5317772030830383,
-0.9367440342903137,
0.40504762530326843,
-0.5736083388328552,
-0.4963729679584503,
1.2560367584228516,
-0.303822785615921,
-0.23363305628299713,
0.013058728538453579,
0.18448084592819214,
-0.24098896980285645,
-0.1379086673259735,
0.5345355272293091,
0.7266300916671753,
-0.1452050805091858,
-0.26107585430145264,
-0.7486132383346558,
0.5135047435760498,
0.4355265498161316,
-0.8936493396759033,
0.13077020645141602,
0.39406758546829224,
0.3355996906757355,
0.0016947980038821697,
0.7237806916236877,
-0.22507202625274658,
0.3254255950450897,
0.08347423374652863,
0.15340349078178406,
-0.09744367003440857,
-0.24036523699760437,
-0.3820490837097168,
0.09805777668952942,
0.25617527961730957,
0.09682350605726242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09654v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09654v2 | GPT-4's assessment of its performance in a USMLE-based case study | 2024-02-15T01:38:50 | 2024-03-26T20:12:18 | Uttam Dhakal, Aniket Kumar Singh, Suman Devkota, Yogesh Sapkota, Bishal Lamichhane, Suprinsa Paudyal, Chandra Dhakal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MA, stat.ML | This study investigates GPT-4's assessment of its performance in healthcare
applications. A simple prompting technique was used to prompt the LLM with
questions taken from the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE)
questionnaire and it was tasked to evaluate its confidence score before posing
the question and after asking the question. The questionnaire was categorized
into two groups-questions with feedback (WF) and questions with no feedback(NF)
post-question. The model was asked to provide absolute and relative confidence
scores before and after each question. The experimental findings were analyzed
using statistical tools to study the variability of confidence in WF and NF
groups. Additionally, a sequential analysis was conducted to observe the
performance variation for the WF and NF groups. Results indicate that feedback
influences relative confidence but doesn't consistently increase or decrease
it. Understanding the performance of LLM is paramount in exploring its utility
in sensitive areas like healthcare. This study contributes to the ongoing
discourse on the reliability of AI, particularly of LLMs like GPT-4, within
healthcare, offering insights into how feedback mechanisms might be optimized
to enhance AI-assisted medical education and decision support. | [
-0.20039312541484833,
-0.6657120585441589,
0.933410108089447,
-0.0180821493268013,
-0.24028486013412476,
-0.046538203954696655,
0.181173175573349,
-0.5074336528778076,
-0.18332521617412567,
-0.08857887238264084,
-0.38722851872444153,
-0.6138725280761719,
-0.46886202692985535,
0.5463706851005554,
-0.050280604511499405,
0.8774476051330566,
-0.155411958694458,
0.49522295594215393,
-0.2938935160636902,
0.016709035262465477,
-0.568034827709198,
-0.7693616151809692,
-0.8428782820701599,
-0.39489856362342834,
0.5249447822570801,
0.22020943462848663,
0.3878539800643921,
0.05443562567234039,
0.8082184791564941,
0.32239478826522827,
0.3240642547607422,
-0.39321690797805786,
-0.3082827627658844,
0.03820343315601349,
0.026561686769127846,
-0.655546247959137,
-0.542218804359436,
0.5878186821937561,
0.5833304524421692,
0.2539040148258209,
-0.3413882553577423,
0.23453958332538605,
0.11634934693574905,
0.3970377743244171,
-0.29994747042655945,
0.08497529476881027,
-0.23926189541816711,
0.08165803551673889,
-0.06482313573360443,
-0.4587830603122711,
-0.21112962067127228,
-0.6849902868270874,
0.44397997856140137,
-0.34623274207115173,
0.23176975548267365,
-0.024205796420574188,
0.7991604208946228,
0.4858365058898926,
-0.1924116462469101,
-0.258832722902298,
-0.560411810874939,
0.44303664565086365,
-0.7452162504196167,
0.11273299902677536,
0.37146976590156555,
0.30218368768692017,
0.07298245280981064,
-0.8841423392295837,
-0.31743791699409485,
-0.6037611365318298,
0.15016505122184753,
0.4404487609863281,
0.14470288157463074,
0.2707471251487732,
0.23004963994026184,
0.4075705111026764,
-0.5425657629966736,
0.02160150371491909,
-0.3255378305912018,
-0.3228265345096588,
0.4890690743923187,
0.0971076637506485,
0.13150307536125183,
0.11913640797138214,
-0.4393780529499054,
0.06484976410865784,
-0.6471147537231445,
0.14112907648086548,
0.022595597431063652,
-0.20195633172988892,
0.14240612089633942,
0.4042757451534271,
0.04207028076052666,
0.39057326316833496,
0.0797266960144043,
-0.28053978085517883,
0.33203163743019104,
-0.4632841944694519,
-0.3719084858894348,
-0.14386600255966187,
0.7295960187911987,
0.6034883260726929,
-0.027584228664636612,
-0.08027275651693344,
-0.29704636335372925,
0.26486316323280334,
0.591830313205719,
-0.8230186104774475,
-0.07360552251338959,
0.24541783332824707,
-0.39029836654663086,
-0.33445197343826294,
0.22107163071632385,
-0.48243600130081177,
-0.05372124910354614,
-0.12667791545391083,
0.7189725041389465,
-0.3674740195274353,
-0.060923442244529724,
-0.24048183858394623,
-0.027573883533477783,
0.466524600982666,
0.35197028517723083,
-0.6346062421798706,
0.5770941972732544,
0.5078117847442627,
0.7704973220825195,
-0.6465162038803101,
-0.17843273282051086,
-0.29703694581985474,
-0.19760151207447052,
-0.42095261812210083,
0.596245527267456,
-0.22755929827690125,
-0.8296531438827515,
-0.2038634866476059,
0.053316380828619,
-0.14613406360149384,
-0.7473440766334534,
0.5153583884239197,
-0.41002607345581055,
0.3234502077102661,
-0.383071631193161,
-0.7462980151176453,
-0.23445133864879608,
0.5673720836639404,
-0.4233958125114441,
0.7810782194137573,
0.41296204924583435,
-0.6119338274002075,
0.6866441369056702,
-0.7748201489448547,
-0.10565793514251709,
0.21602143347263336,
-0.6982373595237732,
-0.5859622359275818,
0.1334414780139923,
-0.0011534050572663546,
0.38192257285118103,
-0.12952913343906403,
0.03022906742990017,
-0.03884221613407135,
-0.8747005462646484,
0.23847638070583344,
-0.7038142085075378,
0.228263720870018,
-0.20618648827075958,
-0.46046116948127747,
0.032220929861068726,
-0.5071941018104553,
0.25483912229537964,
-0.04790893942117691,
-0.4629865288734436,
0.04542750120162964,
-0.4519530236721039,
-0.45710375905036926,
0.08754503726959229,
0.27606216073036194,
-0.5063689351081848,
0.37307071685791016,
-0.09132754802703857,
0.12543557584285736,
0.6758367419242859,
0.5334801077842712,
0.18958918750286102,
-0.4559227228164673,
1.043241262435913,
-0.0896126925945282,
0.660785436630249,
0.3166402578353882,
-0.8926855325698853,
-0.24004396796226501,
0.18763360381126404,
0.5348424911499023,
0.5431397557258606,
-0.802675724029541,
-0.0856332778930664,
0.15042664110660553,
-0.08431560546159744,
-0.6812195181846619,
0.0734977051615715,
0.3490222990512848,
0.7192046046257019,
0.35340508818626404,
-0.6135814785957336,
-0.06013626605272293,
-0.7412864565849304,
0.08853407949209213,
-0.5380792021751404,
-0.09038841724395752,
0.44151759147644043,
0.3673587739467621,
-0.2463662326335907,
0.4865778386592865,
-0.2645963132381439,
-0.11582987010478973,
-0.11721333116292953,
0.21558605134487152,
0.21631108224391937,
0.13066081702709198,
0.5213592052459717,
-0.621376097202301,
-0.5138671398162842,
-0.3431777358055115,
-0.6130836606025696,
-0.0666458010673523,
0.0627252534031868,
0.12585939466953278,
0.3286210894584656,
0.12290195375680923,
-0.4660436809062958,
0.6713125109672546,
0.48259201645851135,
-0.18719203770160675,
0.7302837371826172,
-0.41463932394981384,
0.7093919515609741,
-0.5501899719238281,
0.09735007584095001,
-0.24465234577655792,
0.08314164727926254,
-0.49972984194755554,
-0.2653450667858124,
-0.03543145954608917,
0.3665953576564789,
-0.24710899591445923,
0.20819301903247833,
-0.3539755046367645,
-0.17852602899074554,
-0.12677940726280212,
-0.050068002194166183,
0.021461160853505135,
0.39386966824531555,
-0.2100931853055954,
1.0661557912826538,
0.46417537331581116,
-0.5356857776641846,
0.2602156102657318,
0.011013293638825417,
0.058446574956178665,
0.9638850688934326,
-0.7072371244430542,
0.4046957194805145,
0.37340715527534485,
-0.08084055781364441,
-0.8746788501739502,
-0.2875824272632599,
0.23082254827022552,
-0.4852120578289032,
0.6584314703941345,
-0.020974881947040558,
-0.21380041539669037,
-0.6646433472633362,
-0.4976576566696167,
0.0779072642326355,
0.39426347613334656,
-0.05107551068067551,
0.2975577414035797,
0.03230205550789833,
-0.19784140586853027,
-0.4575749337673187,
-0.6135294437408447,
-0.07093911617994308,
-0.2735532224178314,
-0.3692057132720947,
0.18867075443267822,
-0.373500257730484,
-0.25870993733406067,
-0.09207763522863388,
-0.31967607140541077,
-0.4107312858104706,
0.00885863695293665,
0.3699739873409271,
0.6205373406410217,
-0.1532876342535019,
0.039264190942049026,
-0.1650984138250351,
-0.13759206235408783,
0.2673267722129822,
0.041947461664676666,
0.10187830775976181,
-0.2729356586933136,
-0.6199935078620911,
-0.9514353275299072,
0.18696434795856476,
0.5294724106788635,
0.3483225107192993,
0.3855264186859131,
0.38603857159614563,
-0.009986131452023983,
0.37708932161331177,
-0.5656141638755798,
-0.5899006128311157,
-0.4478863775730133,
0.25687170028686523,
-0.26522985100746155,
-0.9100356101989746,
0.2083253711462021,
-0.042294979095458984,
0.06552126258611679,
0.4471626579761505,
0.7510647177696228,
-0.310919851064682,
0.7730184197425842,
0.4010675251483917,
-0.0981321632862091,
0.09814640134572983,
-0.19595089554786682,
-0.1356387585401535,
-0.5749987959861755,
-0.2721438407897949,
-0.2756226062774658,
-0.25301986932754517,
-0.5215299725532532,
-0.5041931867599487,
0.6823770999908447,
-0.1397714912891388,
-0.18499131500720978,
-0.36466243863105774,
-0.5639935731887817,
0.12746508419513702,
0.5547692775726318,
0.1263533979654312,
0.4776533544063568,
-0.3990233540534973,
-0.3741442561149597,
-0.04023510217666626,
-0.540749728679657,
-0.47631341218948364,
1.3534961938858032,
0.4383220970630646,
0.5363056063652039,
0.15700854361057281,
0.900836169719696,
0.20926538109779358,
0.7681758999824524,
-0.8052968382835388,
0.3331751525402069,
0.23153959214687347,
-0.4793202877044678,
-0.44946950674057007,
-0.513350784778595,
-0.902854859828949,
0.0016187407309189439,
-0.04367617890238762,
-0.4441407322883606,
-0.3596811592578888,
0.20776312053203583,
-0.6791173219680786,
-0.14381462335586548,
-0.8132458329200745,
0.5398269891738892,
-0.5324327945709229,
-0.3001260459423065,
0.1395103484392166,
-0.7382861971855164,
0.15159377455711365,
-0.37245431542396545,
-0.11692257225513458,
0.08487728983163834,
-0.2664746642112732,
0.5314661860466003,
-0.5700010657310486,
0.5673646926879883,
-0.3974815011024475,
0.07566116750240326,
0.42436838150024414,
-0.2927784025669098,
0.2437669336795807,
0.339817076921463,
-0.16153661906719208,
0.318385511636734,
0.17866215109825134,
-0.09702068567276001,
-0.8294164538383484,
0.6220451593399048,
-0.8298095464706421,
-0.780483067035675,
-0.5674570202827454,
-0.2675156593322754,
-0.6662281155586243,
0.058575503528118134,
0.5047567486763,
0.39452478289604187,
-0.234388530254364,
-0.08486025035381317,
0.4249802827835083,
-0.12217476218938828,
0.38072049617767334,
0.6819034218788147,
-0.026857491582632065,
-0.23583067953586578,
0.324093759059906,
0.3599495589733124,
0.27737388014793396,
0.09015214443206787,
0.24626608192920685,
-0.7476298213005066,
-0.7299140691757202,
-0.5786780118942261,
0.30487313866615295,
-0.345060795545578,
0.0035258259158581495,
-0.03499980643391609,
-0.3592468798160553,
-0.07838361710309982,
0.16585667431354523,
-0.1738082617521286,
-0.1803978830575943,
-0.23977874219417572,
-0.40230870246887207,
0.3856291174888611,
1.2479603290557861,
0.1263868361711502,
0.11099656671285629,
-0.5698264241218567,
-0.0775693953037262,
0.44653046131134033,
0.5855123996734619,
-0.4348990321159363,
-0.4435037076473236,
-0.026583101600408554,
-0.2944174110889435,
-0.5373595952987671,
-0.9552291631698608,
-0.15763993561267853,
0.01704118400812149,
0.7926063537597656,
0.3246634900569916,
-0.18402041494846344,
0.2986960709095001,
-0.5700525641441345,
1.2742210626602173,
0.22630606591701508,
-0.5026004314422607,
0.45688751339912415,
-0.1844460517168045,
0.21693934500217438,
0.7534241676330566,
0.5123096704483032,
0.10354674607515335,
-0.43761712312698364,
-0.7577778697013855,
-0.5871587991714478,
0.25541362166404724,
0.31416869163513184,
-0.1144515722990036,
0.07100962847471237,
0.942477285861969,
-0.09033583849668503,
0.32899582386016846,
-0.542144238948822,
-0.3937508165836334,
-0.21920736134052277,
0.01687631756067276,
0.029490076005458832,
-0.3417971730232239,
-0.2220124900341034,
-0.24529482424259186,
0.42915046215057373,
-0.001556388451717794,
0.4578440487384796,
0.42767757177352905,
0.29139429330825806,
0.18355311453342438,
0.27115920186042786,
0.7046060562133789,
0.8248082399368286,
-0.324322909116745,
-0.05242979899048805,
0.28766196966171265,
-0.9472730755805969,
0.38405337929725647,
-0.1265365481376648,
0.07439736276865005,
-0.01694449782371521,
0.2883969247341156,
0.3123241066932678,
-0.07982970029115677,
-0.1540461629629135,
0.7969779372215271,
-0.44202035665512085,
-0.5345759391784668,
-0.11200789362192154,
0.2366282045841217,
-0.12595361471176147,
0.009574387222528458,
0.32672786712646484,
-0.016957757994532585,
0.41129666566848755,
-0.3231576085090637,
0.6070988774299622,
0.18962959945201874,
-0.6782798767089844,
-0.375324010848999,
0.598177433013916,
0.1325918436050415,
-0.07107707113027573,
0.4973289966583252,
-0.036343976855278015,
-0.26999545097351074,
0.515842616558075,
0.44334161281585693,
0.5598687529563904,
-0.6170085668563843,
0.2934720814228058,
0.3088982403278351,
0.2199746072292328,
-0.16973428428173065,
0.5733959078788757,
0.15228138864040375,
-0.523252010345459,
-0.4611501097679138,
-0.22233961522579193,
-0.7218202948570251,
0.257933646440506,
-0.9543495774269104,
-0.24447044730186462,
-0.6688416004180908,
-0.7692690491676331,
-0.658524215221405,
0.33234894275665283,
-0.7073799967765808,
0.5571912527084351,
-0.17122919857501984,
0.6831467151641846,
-0.4284948706626892,
0.6763639450073242,
0.6002810597419739,
-0.6679074168205261,
-1.4894945621490479,
0.2634689509868622,
0.2634563446044922,
-0.9615837931632996,
0.23368854820728302,
0.20173396170139313,
-0.24731773138046265,
-0.12758204340934753,
-0.38200435042381287,
-0.547288715839386,
1.3961498737335205,
0.28442975878715515,
-0.36683622002601624,
0.27172377705574036,
0.09208964556455612,
0.7213535308837891,
-0.10477595031261444,
0.5367597341537476,
0.6593364477157593,
0.36607635021209717,
0.26136693358421326,
-1.112455129623413,
0.05468391627073288,
-0.2868020832538605,
0.005991453770548105,
-0.17553311586380005,
-0.6033506989479065,
0.6112785339355469,
-0.32566067576408386,
0.11978044360876083,
0.07488202303647995,
0.16319265961647034,
0.3778630197048187,
0.3800363838672638,
0.35660097002983093,
0.46942365169525146,
1.0436359643936157,
-0.13794031739234924,
1.3754857778549194,
-0.25974661111831665,
0.2418234795331955,
0.9107428789138794,
-0.3434203863143921,
0.8494126200675964,
0.5431264638900757,
-0.524590015411377,
0.4577803611755371,
0.7149953842163086,
0.0879392921924591,
0.4540741741657257,
0.23661121726036072,
-0.4544055759906769,
0.35139214992523193,
0.1790829449892044,
-0.48291391134262085,
0.42950063943862915,
0.2328062653541565,
-0.32641053199768066,
0.16174806654453278,
-0.29504498839378357,
-0.16114698350429535,
-0.44277700781822205,
-0.30397531390190125,
0.7955142855644226,
0.2731504440307617,
-0.7394391894340515,
0.4199337661266327,
-0.42722582817077637,
0.3794749081134796,
-0.6408538818359375,
-0.32531672716140747,
-0.3533470630645752,
-0.14509226381778717,
-0.20173989236354828,
-0.6441007256507874,
0.219953715801239,
-0.060754552483558655,
-0.13814041018486023,
0.033038366585969925,
0.27410072088241577,
0.05396168306469917,
-0.13634002208709717,
0.24976322054862976,
0.4942379295825958,
0.43431374430656433,
0.14406141638755798,
-0.7911155819892883,
-0.0924561619758606,
0.03639853745698929,
-0.35135772824287415,
0.2558634877204895,
0.356712281703949,
0.0824558436870575,
0.5509002804756165,
0.4703787565231323,
0.2710902690887451,
-0.04605022817850113,
0.39248791337013245,
0.5358256697654724,
-0.4285902678966522,
-0.273531049489975,
-0.8520443439483643,
0.2566089332103729,
-0.0460912324488163,
-0.28512027859687805,
0.7151347398757935,
0.25935423374176025,
0.2606469690799713,
0.138138547539711,
0.8619558811187744,
0.3883138597011566,
0.5822000503540039,
-0.560453474521637,
0.6652727723121643,
-0.5123202204704285,
0.45783478021621704,
-0.3481452763080597,
-0.6005656123161316,
-0.3679044842720032,
0.6610080003738403,
-0.2929309010505676,
0.46830618381500244,
0.8621701598167419,
0.6427702307701111,
0.5739678144454956,
0.16771481931209564,
0.6524733304977417,
0.432759165763855,
0.2611069977283478,
0.4446958601474762,
0.8456411361694336,
-0.16268542408943176,
0.3177585303783417,
0.01077598799020052,
-0.5409085154533386,
-0.022970762103796005,
-0.6374834775924683,
-0.6815251111984253,
-0.10257336497306824,
-0.2710893154144287,
-0.38312602043151855,
-0.06597194075584412,
0.4881787598133087,
0.5942195057868958,
-0.7214922904968262,
0.12878894805908203,
0.10630253702402115,
-0.2318737953901291,
-0.037119146436452866,
-0.1751660704612732,
0.5210989117622375,
-0.22321410477161407,
-0.45836400985717773,
0.3573855459690094,
0.5396762490272522,
0.303475946187973,
-0.20679326355457306,
-0.176507368683815,
0.2296600490808487,
-0.0644286498427391,
0.10519097000360489,
-0.022398382425308228,
-0.6662873029708862,
-0.44003763794898987,
0.17616425454616547,
-0.23638644814491272,
0.29403799772262573,
0.6000047922134399,
-0.48430103063583374,
0.42791616916656494,
-0.08417308330535889,
0.5290325880050659,
0.33981648087501526,
0.4341592788696289,
0.8248352408409119,
-0.6133032441139221,
-0.1672927439212799,
0.3229905962944031,
0.37974900007247925,
0.2741159498691559,
-0.7473562955856323,
0.556348443031311,
0.4266413748264313,
-0.9980155229568481,
-0.2078356295824051,
-0.162122443318367,
-0.7849369049072266,
0.07426249980926514,
1.0848807096481323,
-0.39484739303588867,
0.21479220688343048,
-0.4608887732028961,
-0.2565511465072632,
0.04298420995473862,
-0.4252883493900299,
0.6253840923309326,
0.7366229295730591,
-0.826828122138977,
-0.0876065269112587,
-0.9502409100532532,
0.7645856142044067,
0.3122429847717285,
-0.7442335486412048,
-0.7841377258300781,
0.4268181324005127,
0.7751457691192627,
0.1259513944387436,
1.3177344799041748,
-0.3170865774154663,
0.5134033560752869,
-0.07636167854070663,
-0.18452708423137665,
0.09572982043027878,
-0.088473841547966,
-0.5442447662353516,
0.3937670886516571,
0.4148756265640259,
-0.4352923631668091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09642v1 | Answer is All You Need: Instruction-following Text Embedding via Answering the Question | 2024-02-15T01:02:41 | 2024-02-15T01:02:41 | Letian Peng, Yuwei Zhang, Zilong Wang, Jayanth Srinivasa, Gaowen Liu, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work aims to build a text embedder that can capture characteristics of
texts specified by user instructions. Despite its tremendous potential to
deploy user-oriented embeddings, none of previous approaches provides a
concrete solution for it. This paper offers a new viewpoint, which treats the
instruction as a question about the input text and encodes the expected answers
to obtain the representation accordingly. Intuitively, texts with the same
(implicit) semantics would share similar answers following the instruction,
thus leading to more similar embeddings. Specifically, we propose InBedder that
instantiates this embed-via-answering idea by only fine-tuning language models
on abstractive question answering tasks. InBedder demonstrates significantly
improved instruction-following capabilities according to our proposed
instruction awareness tests and instruction robustness tests, when applied to
both large language models (LLMs) (e.g., llama-2-7b) and smaller encoder-based
LMs (e.g., roberta-large). Additionally, our qualitative analysis of clustering
outcomes, achieved by applying different instructions to the same corpus,
demonstrates a high degree of interpretability. | [
-0.2320287674665451,
-0.8669026494026184,
0.9441824555397034,
-0.06612882763147354,
-0.06300817430019379,
0.007455785758793354,
0.05387945473194122,
-0.2139730006456375,
0.02406073361635208,
0.622105062007904,
-0.4674048125743866,
-0.6435480117797852,
-0.7032735347747803,
-0.057634565979242325,
-0.5119511485099792,
0.9606844186782837,
-0.26713740825653076,
0.03440602123737335,
-0.6600258350372314,
0.048417653888463974,
-0.5377370119094849,
-0.3050572872161865,
-0.21711769700050354,
0.025039952248334885,
0.31504687666893005,
0.6605066061019897,
0.6772724390029907,
0.8505377769470215,
0.09354203939437866,
0.21074260771274567,
0.015082858502864838,
0.03056267835199833,
-0.22108253836631775,
0.14367622137069702,
0.008321401663124561,
-0.5267028212547302,
-0.017519842833280563,
-0.19729526340961456,
0.7006385326385498,
0.5462287664413452,
-0.004370309412479401,
0.11410319060087204,
0.4150547981262207,
0.06570781767368317,
-0.5337780714035034,
-0.053267378360033035,
-0.28603529930114746,
-0.11436523497104645,
0.26827773451805115,
-0.21076712012290955,
-0.5405027866363525,
-0.7670916318893433,
0.20865194499492645,
-0.32185348868370056,
-0.12364961951971054,
0.013409916311502457,
0.5377712845802307,
0.39378345012664795,
-0.2902919054031372,
-0.824245274066925,
-0.4192390441894531,
0.6365525126457214,
-0.6401829719543457,
0.3047999441623688,
0.5238798260688782,
0.33050474524497986,
0.10964807868003845,
-0.6293631792068481,
-0.46060070395469666,
0.07188841700553894,
-0.32593193650245667,
0.22767877578735352,
0.013279391452670097,
0.06002781167626381,
-0.05544739589095116,
0.19270014762878418,
-0.5297347903251648,
-0.08754100650548935,
-0.16241806745529175,
0.07279704511165619,
0.23009377717971802,
0.1608862429857254,
0.5158114433288574,
-0.03330812603235245,
-0.4452888071537018,
-0.037537507712841034,
-0.5484680533409119,
0.17198581993579865,
0.14222314953804016,
-0.10385122895240784,
-0.08103741705417633,
0.6872211694717407,
0.12972217798233032,
0.5848968625068665,
0.07126111537218094,
0.36506187915802,
-0.02389487810432911,
-0.18717148900032043,
0.06597206741571426,
0.2276018261909485,
0.46977296471595764,
0.22315344214439392,
0.1776927262544632,
-0.2893080413341522,
-0.16644683480262756,
-0.20994722843170166,
0.31675225496292114,
-1.1051479578018188,
-0.1835496574640274,
0.3087122440338135,
-0.3538852334022522,
-0.20902451872825623,
0.19104592502117157,
-0.7473446130752563,
-0.17996178567409515,
0.017740681767463684,
0.6469534039497375,
-0.5180550217628479,
0.2202020287513733,
0.11634043604135513,
-0.08142583072185516,
0.7042657136917114,
0.36618226766586304,
-1.1008434295654297,
0.5118762850761414,
0.8965086340904236,
0.6424973011016846,
-0.02441282570362091,
-0.12755125761032104,
-0.6371465921401978,
0.342296838760376,
-0.30377161502838135,
0.8040725588798523,
-1.0885558128356934,
-0.4963916540145874,
0.15627184510231018,
0.007986946031451225,
-0.09153632819652557,
-0.23767000436782837,
0.0026413165032863617,
-0.7344915866851807,
0.45485052466392517,
-0.26436132192611694,
-1.1886401176452637,
-0.2899168133735657,
0.42518672347068787,
-0.3009217381477356,
0.9096611142158508,
-0.08975385874509811,
-0.6957465410232544,
-0.1399589627981186,
-0.6248785257339478,
-0.14259938895702362,
-0.033246710896492004,
-0.3572317361831665,
-0.15817908942699432,
0.1705983430147171,
0.30359071493148804,
0.46101418137550354,
-0.01741473376750946,
-0.3733779788017273,
-0.1933538019657135,
-0.7263196706771851,
0.3194529414176941,
-0.41243255138397217,
0.6386182308197021,
-0.22499822080135345,
-0.1746387481689453,
0.0526137612760067,
-0.4688522219657898,
0.24362559616565704,
-0.0832880437374115,
-0.4273450970649719,
-0.4737548530101776,
0.0888277217745781,
-0.2993232011795044,
-0.1974010467529297,
0.6858515739440918,
-0.73332279920578,
0.1983739733695984,
-0.37304210662841797,
0.21460995078086853,
0.8424740433692932,
0.443729430437088,
0.6083623766899109,
-0.24807661771774292,
0.737756609916687,
-0.2579013705253601,
-0.06749199330806732,
-0.6183170080184937,
-0.6933887600898743,
-0.6377751231193542,
-0.11872148513793945,
0.22047661244869232,
0.8605355620384216,
-0.4716617166996002,
0.15987251698970795,
-0.14301010966300964,
-0.21709461510181427,
-0.888819694519043,
0.18121238052845,
0.7333124876022339,
0.5094902515411377,
0.5094572305679321,
0.05472196638584137,
-0.23597395420074463,
-0.6630792617797852,
-0.14516714215278625,
-0.1488759070634842,
-0.09706354141235352,
0.33284515142440796,
0.43170514702796936,
-0.24597163498401642,
0.6917543411254883,
-0.8243945240974426,
0.31337177753448486,
-0.1857973039150238,
-0.03986561670899391,
-0.09480202198028564,
0.48871904611587524,
0.3417789340019226,
-0.5712935328483582,
-0.8070644736289978,
0.21371294558048248,
-0.8880199790000916,
0.11574039608240128,
0.1739087551832199,
-0.30593937635421753,
-0.13340604305267334,
0.8210897445678711,
-0.31719762086868286,
0.4363899528980255,
0.47055596113204956,
-0.19577808678150177,
0.181674063205719,
-0.32857954502105713,
0.24699938297271729,
-1.287278413772583,
-0.38613343238830566,
-0.2922614812850952,
-0.20904819667339325,
-0.5516604781150818,
0.31679412722587585,
0.18626193702220917,
-0.13416144251823425,
-0.3735121488571167,
0.3988848030567169,
-0.36117592453956604,
-0.06860833615064621,
-0.261111319065094,
0.15666361153125763,
0.11424779891967773,
0.48905518651008606,
-0.07443614304065704,
1.0703495740890503,
0.45250895619392395,
-0.4917888343334198,
0.06378445029258728,
0.6432704925537109,
-0.23452454805374146,
0.33701831102371216,
-1.0021240711212158,
0.5338484644889832,
-0.49230533838272095,
-0.01989094354212284,
-1.3183053731918335,
-0.1746061146259308,
0.38844412565231323,
-0.47168806195259094,
0.24508431553840637,
-0.4094657301902771,
-0.5261887311935425,
-0.0313674733042717,
-0.4808935523033142,
0.21464765071868896,
0.8586536645889282,
-0.5667429566383362,
0.7294254302978516,
0.14376045763492584,
-0.3283414840698242,
-0.4875248074531555,
-0.6659896969795227,
-0.24141795933246613,
-0.10165947675704956,
-0.3582719564437866,
0.23781831562519073,
-0.3220665454864502,
0.05718216300010681,
0.390176922082901,
-0.05188341811299324,
-0.2918369174003601,
0.008589116856455803,
0.2543626129627228,
0.23186492919921875,
-0.3949337601661682,
0.239545077085495,
0.6178282499313354,
-0.14796672761440277,
0.1603810340166092,
-0.39846187829971313,
0.3370884358882904,
-0.07255244255065918,
-0.47316744923591614,
-0.5560166239738464,
0.8942416310310364,
0.1939706653356552,
-0.47296008467674255,
0.6543918251991272,
0.31501835584640503,
-0.3541845381259918,
-0.131468266248703,
-0.1750265657901764,
-0.27265679836273193,
-0.5087750554084778,
0.3125927448272705,
-0.30973780155181885,
-0.9490419626235962,
0.2602919638156891,
-0.0006182934157550335,
0.475063681602478,
-0.10769952833652496,
0.40104034543037415,
-0.7090660929679871,
1.201475977897644,
0.8181811571121216,
0.16742712259292603,
0.36088496446609497,
-0.0605044886469841,
0.0344739630818367,
-0.680689811706543,
-0.16427360475063324,
-0.5791996717453003,
-0.26583459973335266,
-0.5350648164749146,
-0.4379981458187103,
0.20702241361141205,
-0.046079251915216446,
-0.23230361938476562,
0.4353473484516144,
-0.5187221169471741,
0.7137664556503296,
0.4993652105331421,
0.13503563404083252,
-0.011904302053153515,
-0.10253730416297913,
0.023372327908873558,
0.03729045391082764,
-0.581194281578064,
-0.9471390247344971,
0.8988039493560791,
0.22363388538360596,
0.8445839285850525,
0.11743105202913284,
1.0846441984176636,
-0.009680863469839096,
0.5095335841178894,
-0.6151409149169922,
0.5170584321022034,
-0.2021697759628296,
-0.428750604391098,
-0.17799651622772217,
-0.15051890909671783,
-0.7321223616600037,
0.12607543170452118,
-0.09181439876556396,
-0.8924849629402161,
0.00024004734586924314,
0.3208360970020294,
-0.48469874262809753,
0.039639927446842194,
-1.0180256366729736,
0.9864616394042969,
-0.025666028261184692,
-0.06414023041725159,
-0.03863852471113205,
-0.5731119513511658,
-0.09246677160263062,
0.30273711681365967,
-0.02349792793393135,
0.34028711915016174,
-0.5284779071807861,
0.5345097780227661,
-0.1654510200023651,
1.0217708349227905,
-0.2069733440876007,
-0.0795292779803276,
0.5966252088546753,
-0.07822854816913605,
0.4194282591342926,
-0.05129975453019142,
-0.07307638972997665,
-0.45799559354782104,
0.17114129662513733,
-0.39798375964164734,
-1.1757515668869019,
0.9058235287666321,
-0.7193100452423096,
-0.7233725786209106,
0.011919044889509678,
-0.4916054904460907,
-0.2705807685852051,
0.11149165034294128,
0.08106318861246109,
0.817407488822937,
-0.2547379434108734,
0.15237049758434296,
1.27599036693573,
-0.233912393450737,
0.4534469544887543,
0.21282564103603363,
-0.2503589987754822,
-0.1921319216489792,
1.009701132774353,
-0.03801362216472626,
0.27421578764915466,
0.9467149376869202,
0.26933833956718445,
-0.48015540838241577,
-0.4514223635196686,
-0.8209061622619629,
0.1528293788433075,
-0.8894209265708923,
-0.05068182200193405,
-0.9464895129203796,
-0.1248144656419754,
-0.0160025954246521,
-0.5045817494392395,
-0.08718249946832657,
-0.1940975934267044,
-0.5768747329711914,
-0.2947802245616913,
0.43791061639785767,
0.9677531719207764,
0.6661561131477356,
0.4927516281604767,
-0.9538828730583191,
0.134559765458107,
0.6310462355613708,
0.2475244104862213,
0.07392480969429016,
-0.5346025824546814,
-0.1896970123052597,
0.1910608410835266,
-0.2583446502685547,
-1.2460469007492065,
-0.09373226761817932,
0.2074596881866455,
0.4629642069339752,
0.3199559450149536,
0.09034691751003265,
0.6333664655685425,
-0.7010698318481445,
0.5201541781425476,
-0.2673964202404022,
-0.8729797005653381,
0.6776551604270935,
0.013259983621537685,
0.33836856484413147,
0.657633364200592,
0.726555347442627,
-0.25636154413223267,
-0.578627347946167,
-0.38606002926826477,
-0.5031018257141113,
0.43873003125190735,
-0.019850153475999832,
0.7463115453720093,
-0.20252572000026703,
0.550360918045044,
0.1680467575788498,
0.07659558951854706,
-0.28118032217025757,
-0.13019797205924988,
-0.23517589271068573,
-0.720147967338562,
0.07514433562755585,
-0.3426349461078644,
0.03896946460008621,
0.019410543143749237,
0.3094526529312134,
-0.0678878203034401,
0.4214271605014801,
0.035136155784130096,
-0.27761244773864746,
0.3544749915599823,
0.37722668051719666,
0.19367581605911255,
0.33634576201438904,
-0.17357592284679413,
0.19236943125724792,
0.3651800751686096,
-0.44849953055381775,
0.09837613254785538,
0.028492746874690056,
-0.42684468626976013,
-0.12620054185390472,
0.3185514211654663,
0.46994227170944214,
0.5764522552490234,
-0.784010648727417,
0.7909643650054932,
-0.11396163702011108,
0.04792950674891472,
-0.30698686838150024,
0.2861538529396057,
0.4050427973270416,
0.05840663984417915,
0.10848431289196014,
-0.09234212338924408,
0.24660271406173706,
-0.5365975499153137,
0.36721351742744446,
0.18738339841365814,
-0.9916129112243652,
-0.3060324192047119,
0.5359857678413391,
0.1675712913274765,
-0.39365047216415405,
0.47197794914245605,
-0.27627718448638916,
-0.463502436876297,
0.5325466990470886,
0.7985162138938904,
0.6897506713867188,
-0.21575205028057098,
0.19714084267616272,
0.12712720036506653,
0.22015395760536194,
0.2805658280849457,
0.5268186330795288,
-0.22069035470485687,
-0.5637778043746948,
-0.42009449005126953,
-0.22533077001571655,
-0.6344401836395264,
-0.5744874477386475,
-0.857645571231842,
0.06772034615278244,
-0.6578295230865479,
0.480532705783844,
-0.14003662765026093,
-0.26907914876937866,
-0.49356016516685486,
-0.009548038244247437,
-0.07349264621734619,
0.9056025743484497,
-0.6218692064285278,
0.6703923344612122,
1.0984857082366943,
-0.35293903946876526,
-0.6134743094444275,
0.2634934186935425,
-0.0795498788356781,
-0.806346595287323,
-0.03636093810200691,
0.43816694617271423,
-0.22245728969573975,
0.3393992483615875,
-0.7353425621986389,
-0.4670671224594116,
1.20823335647583,
0.24512070417404175,
-0.14012925326824188,
-0.013310808688402176,
-0.19213663041591644,
0.3335772454738617,
-0.6147585511207581,
0.4087018668651581,
0.413678377866745,
0.12313761562108994,
0.09206181019544601,
-0.12006968259811401,
0.09071756154298782,
-0.2797260284423828,
-0.0793914720416069,
0.2632611393928528,
-0.21833935379981995,
0.4039173424243927,
-0.3805762231349945,
-0.3516404628753662,
0.19817504286766052,
0.9850490689277649,
-0.02806677669286728,
0.12494952231645584,
0.29182666540145874,
0.5001724362373352,
0.6386240720748901,
0.3174137473106384,
1.319620966911316,
-0.2371712327003479,
-0.12356984615325928,
1.147294044494629,
0.1760367453098297,
1.2082371711730957,
0.3428158164024353,
0.08836296945810318,
0.835911750793457,
0.1941191852092743,
0.311893492937088,
0.6722760200500488,
-0.04727420210838318,
-0.33848994970321655,
-0.20477373898029327,
-0.09014779329299927,
-0.23611615598201752,
0.39700084924697876,
0.4073117673397064,
-0.25189879536628723,
-0.26418113708496094,
-0.02960861101746559,
0.08631092309951782,
0.5803753137588501,
-0.25662440061569214,
0.9239690899848938,
-0.05563515052199364,
-0.3706551194190979,
0.2669849097728729,
-0.0706099346280098,
0.6043673753738403,
-0.5353325009346008,
-0.515234649181366,
-0.11463556438684464,
-0.1906234174966812,
-0.07382822036743164,
-1.1291897296905518,
0.3703039884567261,
0.33037787675857544,
-0.2460147589445114,
-0.40878626704216003,
0.45070815086364746,
-0.48440128564834595,
-0.4497376084327698,
0.09383329749107361,
0.5246596336364746,
0.23990464210510254,
0.21514742076396942,
-0.30136361718177795,
-0.03866822272539139,
0.11732923984527588,
-0.033114127814769745,
0.2836315631866455,
0.5652093291282654,
0.06028837710618973,
0.6150305867195129,
0.3873727023601532,
-0.5582382678985596,
0.2482987642288208,
-0.09785919636487961,
0.9120530486106873,
-0.5753229856491089,
-0.48674479126930237,
-0.6385630965232849,
0.6028946042060852,
0.0958806499838829,
-0.3593347668647766,
0.6974633932113647,
0.39420080184936523,
0.7586787939071655,
-0.018872728571295738,
0.7470203638076782,
0.07744084298610687,
0.5152708292007446,
-0.3992716073989868,
0.6053490042686462,
-0.36639344692230225,
0.21739840507507324,
-0.24543392658233643,
-0.7862611413002014,
-0.04929725080728531,
0.6064783930778503,
-0.27782201766967773,
-0.1966492235660553,
0.5494359731674194,
0.8554564714431763,
-0.16795487701892853,
0.28189852833747864,
0.1699550896883011,
0.03936150297522545,
0.021543260663747787,
0.615680456161499,
0.9456407427787781,
-0.4928669035434723,
0.7597724199295044,
0.023714106529951096,
-0.46984535455703735,
0.031147675588726997,
-0.5810225009918213,
-0.9471941590309143,
-0.49458491802215576,
-0.2953457832336426,
-0.05209924653172493,
0.23036576807498932,
0.8485822081565857,
0.3262045383453369,
-0.8108072280883789,
-0.012761959806084633,
-0.03356598690152168,
0.30287039279937744,
-0.2825236916542053,
-0.11688198149204254,
0.40589216351509094,
-0.3355266749858856,
-0.7815567255020142,
0.30034029483795166,
0.19504909217357635,
0.2654764652252197,
-0.09163063019514084,
-0.11051439493894577,
-0.039787497371435165,
0.3557150065898895,
0.503796398639679,
0.1434462070465088,
-0.4306259751319885,
-0.6742873787879944,
0.39626577496528625,
-0.320077508687973,
-0.09117600321769714,
0.5833455920219421,
-0.49924910068511963,
0.47545966506004333,
0.5180374979972839,
1.36020827293396,
0.46248412132263184,
0.09904203563928604,
0.5201255679130554,
-0.7276359796524048,
-0.21499231457710266,
0.2534083425998688,
0.04244057089090347,
0.2991175651550293,
-0.37067586183547974,
-0.07845496386289597,
-0.5254024267196655,
-0.3631868064403534,
-0.41423240303993225,
0.2475404441356659,
-0.7915199398994446,
-0.18985585868358612,
0.7796134948730469,
-0.5856159925460815,
-0.23582421243190765,
-0.2594779133796692,
-0.23165173828601837,
-0.02813931368291378,
-0.39415442943573,
0.5141494870185852,
0.5921539664268494,
-0.04895700514316559,
-0.5752661228179932,
-0.5929169654846191,
0.02624393254518509,
0.31995439529418945,
-0.8501091599464417,
-0.17046071588993073,
0.16973182559013367,
0.26796987652778625,
-0.0646655336022377,
0.5878586769104004,
-0.2073788046836853,
0.34609121084213257,
0.03677930682897568,
-0.15463046729564667,
-0.08675824850797653,
-0.32003653049468994,
-0.32787132263183594,
0.23188325762748718,
0.007312331814318895,
-0.6500650644302368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09631v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09631v5 | Representation Surgery: Theory and Practice of Affine Steering | 2024-02-15T00:20:30 | 2024-06-25T13:00:08 | Shashwat Singh, Shauli Ravfogel, Jonathan Herzig, Roee Aharoni, Ryan Cotterell, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY | Language models often exhibit undesirable behavior, e.g., generating toxic or
gender-biased text. In the case of neural language models, an encoding of the
undesirable behavior is often present in the model's representations. Thus, one
natural (and common) approach to prevent the model from exhibiting undesirable
behavior is to steer the model's representations in a manner that reduces the
probability of it generating undesirable text. This paper investigates the
formal and empirical properties of steering functions, i.e., transformation of
the neural language model's representations that alter its behavior. First, we
derive two optimal, in the least-squares sense, affine steering functions under
different constraints. Our theory provides justification for existing
approaches and offers a novel, improved steering approach. Second, we offer a
series of experiments that demonstrate the empirical effectiveness of the
methods in mitigating bias and reducing toxic generation. | [
-0.35381218791007996,
-0.7029412388801575,
0.5300861597061157,
0.15225760638713837,
0.007977579720318317,
-0.38112273812294006,
-0.3008700907230377,
-0.13927845656871796,
0.11271142214536667,
0.5139262080192566,
-0.5174033045768738,
-0.5271552205085754,
-0.6443802714347839,
-0.09628809243440628,
-0.8484545946121216,
0.9882931113243103,
0.1408180445432663,
0.472303181886673,
0.021772630512714386,
-0.3474556803703308,
-0.3615257740020752,
-0.5277280807495117,
-0.3706945776939392,
-0.5078643560409546,
0.39132460951805115,
0.23663605749607086,
1.1886948347091675,
1.0835061073303223,
0.11833526194095612,
0.3321031928062439,
-0.19147804379463196,
-0.18664167821407318,
-0.30785855650901794,
0.34957730770111084,
-0.3007633686065674,
-0.6628718376159668,
0.02397838421165943,
0.002892150776460767,
0.5361239910125732,
1.1120878458023071,
-0.6138079166412354,
-0.5909185409545898,
0.11084112524986267,
0.8502370715141296,
-0.47742000222206116,
-0.057949893176555634,
-0.6246994733810425,
0.10206370055675507,
0.008216127753257751,
-0.10286552459001541,
-0.36851581931114197,
-0.45301052927970886,
0.3112908899784088,
-0.717792272567749,
-0.02111712470650673,
0.07297167927026749,
0.6702746152877808,
0.315483033657074,
-0.7207151651382446,
-0.4743340015411377,
-0.9215698838233948,
0.5953809022903442,
-0.6384518146514893,
0.4691464900970459,
0.3209960460662842,
0.1392940878868103,
-0.22382819652557373,
-0.3445010185241699,
-0.2574723958969116,
-0.48448261618614197,
-0.12962885200977325,
-0.4491972327232361,
-0.5639133453369141,
0.5724018812179565,
0.31459203362464905,
-0.02316119894385338,
-0.24913404881954193,
0.07494407892227173,
-0.4823867976665497,
-0.2516927123069763,
0.7567816376686096,
0.1545335203409195,
0.4866183400154114,
-0.257178395986557,
-0.46381041407585144,
-0.1938205063343048,
-0.9731589555740356,
-0.1955670863389969,
0.5527772903442383,
0.3346465528011322,
0.12152636796236038,
0.5895742177963257,
-0.20082968473434448,
0.5840157270431519,
0.20705822110176086,
0.2613444924354553,
0.007517809513956308,
-0.005829992704093456,
-0.278346985578537,
0.05047690123319626,
0.6002757549285889,
0.5103815197944641,
0.41883155703544617,
-0.12404972314834595,
-0.2813376486301422,
0.2675042152404785,
0.7235952019691467,
-0.4440479874610901,
-0.2295796424150467,
0.007346585858613253,
-0.8784990310668945,
-0.6711519360542297,
-0.24533137679100037,
-0.7283720970153809,
-0.7066256999969482,
-0.48692256212234497,
0.21563144028186798,
-0.7330151796340942,
-0.3757160007953644,
0.11545325070619583,
-0.0793917253613472,
-0.09091652929782867,
0.1199994832277298,
-1.2725142240524292,
0.6566592454910278,
0.7100620865821838,
0.5818949937820435,
-0.19020166993141174,
-0.03315341845154762,
-0.16839729249477386,
0.19327819347381592,
-0.5789948105812073,
0.5376341938972473,
-0.578139066696167,
-0.5110946893692017,
0.4101414382457733,
-0.14269234240055084,
-0.08025526255369186,
-0.6635001301765442,
0.4952898323535919,
0.00872085988521576,
-0.20649859309196472,
-0.4078555703163147,
-0.39622262120246887,
-0.5022730827331543,
-0.10408012568950653,
-0.5313618183135986,
0.5283011794090271,
-0.11712261289358139,
-0.32154011726379395,
0.19312365353107452,
-0.7110643982887268,
-0.739795446395874,
-0.5520572662353516,
-0.23036839067935944,
-0.20603357255458832,
0.5195903778076172,
0.1255657970905304,
0.39584487676620483,
-0.006224678363651037,
0.39882543683052063,
-0.06817404180765152,
-0.07544004917144775,
0.26801902055740356,
-0.47278380393981934,
0.7594105005264282,
0.32739683985710144,
-0.3254212737083435,
0.5049980878829956,
-0.6056484580039978,
-0.40426358580589294,
-0.13341353833675385,
-0.009335181675851345,
-0.8861717581748962,
0.3790654242038727,
-0.005231967195868492,
0.10792513191699982,
-0.2635940611362457,
-0.731706440448761,
0.3101704716682434,
-0.5681321620941162,
0.6152809262275696,
0.7077687978744507,
0.24310632050037384,
1.1523487567901611,
-0.3422722816467285,
0.40354523062705994,
0.053284890949726105,
0.19632509350776672,
0.3955751657485962,
-0.4902273416519165,
-1.0844837427139282,
0.3544987738132477,
0.010138468816876411,
0.3738594353199005,
-0.9902457594871521,
-0.24917586147785187,
0.12873247265815735,
-0.38072672486305237,
-0.4754815697669983,
0.03664647415280342,
0.519832968711853,
0.41485917568206787,
0.27174270153045654,
0.025752101093530655,
-0.5810711979866028,
-1.1152458190917969,
-0.24709445238113403,
-0.3397822380065918,
0.1959175020456314,
0.09611375629901886,
0.2549517750740051,
-0.0349961556494236,
0.5639623403549194,
-0.39773112535476685,
-0.28204137086868286,
0.17389467358589172,
0.33368757367134094,
-0.11715003103017807,
0.752226710319519,
0.8927793502807617,
-0.8230048418045044,
-0.07977410405874252,
-0.017197249457240105,
-0.6622730493545532,
-0.30526813864707947,
-0.22560636699199677,
-0.28634944558143616,
0.6648968458175659,
0.7696406841278076,
-0.6792781352996826,
0.7698942422866821,
0.4889751970767975,
-0.3292684257030487,
0.46764257550239563,
-0.2802368998527527,
0.029504593461751938,
-0.3767359256744385,
0.10130717605352402,
0.2046145498752594,
-0.19150669872760773,
-0.9199695587158203,
0.1679587960243225,
0.12836261093616486,
-0.16442230343818665,
-0.2197304666042328,
0.3323736786842346,
-0.4648206830024719,
0.1974693387746811,
-0.3061848282814026,
-0.18182246387004852,
-0.4319007396697998,
0.4967260956764221,
0.22012554109096527,
0.4167551100254059,
0.4108119308948517,
-0.9119613170623779,
0.04736371710896492,
0.5617160797119141,
0.1797926127910614,
0.9256596565246582,
-0.5157548785209656,
-0.2241184115409851,
-0.4054220914840698,
-0.3622073233127594,
-1.1368343830108643,
0.42957478761672974,
0.4313253164291382,
-0.5548920035362244,
0.5884534120559692,
-0.30812445282936096,
0.15635767579078674,
-0.08214984834194183,
0.007098474074155092,
-0.22508305311203003,
0.5079652667045593,
-0.11298473924398422,
0.41274788975715637,
0.5082051753997803,
-0.34579145908355713,
-0.5139157772064209,
-0.8350183963775635,
-0.12907256186008453,
-0.210218146443367,
-0.45337343215942383,
0.5086049437522888,
0.18713979423046112,
-0.44531363248825073,
0.2491636872291565,
-0.36120620369911194,
0.022646209225058556,
-0.08713234961032867,
0.2019270658493042,
0.1676086187362671,
-0.1361677199602127,
0.1575545370578766,
0.5026670694351196,
-0.375461608171463,
0.23142237961292267,
-0.21008843183517456,
0.34635046124458313,
0.3405260145664215,
-0.31060823798179626,
-0.17735417187213898,
0.6760832667350769,
0.5865640640258789,
-0.00810200534760952,
0.5023991465568542,
0.22593137621879578,
-0.4789659380912781,
-0.1954190880060196,
-0.3600771725177765,
-0.4525761604309082,
-0.5212575793266296,
0.7354230880737305,
-0.05316005274653435,
-0.6030804514884949,
0.4307073950767517,
0.0725594162940979,
0.16511879861354828,
0.38051673769950867,
0.5066458582878113,
-0.1551353931427002,
1.5203111171722412,
0.6474478840827942,
-0.0025205600541085005,
0.5921635627746582,
-0.07906452566385269,
0.05869134142994881,
-0.7378000020980835,
-0.38449764251708984,
-0.7456727027893066,
-0.4069308042526245,
-0.6779374480247498,
-0.22458583116531372,
0.5418752431869507,
-0.2227891981601715,
-0.4693596363067627,
0.21577376127243042,
-0.6343181133270264,
0.020319372415542603,
0.5564743876457214,
-0.009646184742450714,
0.08860362321138382,
0.12802113592624664,
-0.5673495531082153,
-0.26191312074661255,
-0.8137544393539429,
-0.44671788811683655,
1.0336254835128784,
0.4923115670681,
0.9653382897377014,
-0.030256588011980057,
0.4709678590297699,
0.10040407627820969,
0.44618093967437744,
-0.8003571629524231,
0.5733835697174072,
-0.49163731932640076,
-0.7238340377807617,
-0.35182785987854004,
-0.2190018594264984,
-0.7728511095046997,
0.36009642481803894,
-0.42258018255233765,
-0.8002979755401611,
0.5113747715950012,
0.44465264678001404,
-0.10729453712701797,
0.539085865020752,
-0.455034464597702,
0.4526224434375763,
-0.2656322419643402,
-0.44845762848854065,
-0.3574483394622803,
-0.6215701103210449,
0.22146335244178772,
0.5021043419837952,
0.1548558473587036,
0.18082068860530853,
-0.193773552775383,
0.6484730243682861,
-0.47500303387641907,
0.8128894567489624,
-0.7322278022766113,
-0.15196524560451508,
-0.05292597785592079,
0.7030712366104126,
0.5642344951629639,
-0.3009222149848938,
-0.06707202643156052,
0.12099115550518036,
0.0742044746875763,
0.05212527886033058,
-0.8209609985351562,
0.6624636650085449,
-0.677203357219696,
-0.719870388507843,
-0.5522016286849976,
-0.6058773398399353,
-0.3185306489467621,
-0.03404638543725014,
0.18206843733787537,
0.21045145392417908,
-0.3821134567260742,
0.014671139419078827,
0.5954322218894958,
-0.255851686000824,
0.5268546938896179,
0.40564802289009094,
-0.32632842659950256,
-0.36683326959609985,
0.6648159027099609,
0.10525983572006226,
0.3288101255893707,
0.1530529409646988,
0.10371413826942444,
-0.4040447175502777,
-1.0398722887039185,
-0.3394452929496765,
0.11761298030614853,
-0.630323588848114,
-0.2338545173406601,
-0.38297685980796814,
-0.17692404985427856,
-0.2860027849674225,
-0.11260683834552765,
-0.4453458786010742,
-0.6697655916213989,
-0.2639906108379364,
-0.17103667557239532,
0.25913697481155396,
1.1562105417251587,
-0.3583472967147827,
0.6039324998855591,
-0.40180131793022156,
-0.033489786088466644,
0.0947103202342987,
0.34941521286964417,
0.2021951526403427,
-0.12557852268218994,
0.14359460771083832,
0.42052263021469116,
-0.47887444496154785,
-1.0845845937728882,
0.819135844707489,
0.06362932175397873,
0.8805702924728394,
0.6281931400299072,
-0.12270335108041763,
0.5505436062812805,
-0.6718461513519287,
0.3272331655025482,
0.2546825706958771,
-1.083420753479004,
0.30349645018577576,
-0.47271817922592163,
-0.1990618258714676,
0.3898709714412689,
0.599072277545929,
-0.9924944043159485,
-0.44716399908065796,
-0.3883330225944519,
-0.7257186770439148,
0.6099460124969482,
0.3476409614086151,
0.28374141454696655,
0.08157920837402344,
0.5771938562393188,
0.013771170750260353,
0.4689887464046478,
-0.43190059065818787,
-0.7151440978050232,
-0.4306912422180176,
-0.2574302852153778,
0.08391323685646057,
-0.43516743183135986,
-0.2882022261619568,
-0.29393723607063293,
0.778724730014801,
-0.10639278590679169,
0.5207386612892151,
0.16101562976837158,
-0.17951802909374237,
-0.16095824539661407,
0.09020127356052399,
1.0264778137207031,
0.29748836159706116,
0.017986731603741646,
0.08963041007518768,
-0.22942399978637695,
-0.5093302726745605,
0.4276246130466461,
0.0591764822602272,
-0.49609893560409546,
-0.028358954936265945,
0.0020619919523596764,
0.902055561542511,
0.43461695313453674,
-0.059326086193323135,
0.4947921335697174,
0.19302375614643097,
-0.3182061016559601,
-0.024644337594509125,
-0.05942754074931145,
0.03184721618890762,
0.11620594561100006,
0.5214990377426147,
0.6084572076797485,
0.4184337258338928,
-0.17152968049049377,
0.3536151051521301,
0.6976212859153748,
-0.660878598690033,
-0.2928335666656494,
0.7242528796195984,
0.5101099014282227,
-0.3207387328147888,
0.6022419929504395,
0.020491449162364006,
-0.5063532590866089,
0.4935070872306824,
0.6382406949996948,
0.6843822002410889,
-0.5077184438705444,
0.5438070893287659,
0.3246379494667053,
0.5753478407859802,
0.04039401933550835,
0.08628075569868088,
0.18808674812316895,
-0.9489039778709412,
-0.06767424941062927,
-0.3004639148712158,
-0.10569360852241516,
-0.1073315218091011,
-0.8028783798217773,
0.07336072623729706,
-0.605364203453064,
-0.24560286104679108,
0.2603898048400879,
-0.4855019450187683,
-0.10574043542146683,
-0.004406569991260767,
0.25272664427757263,
0.795005738735199,
-1.0564334392547607,
0.5069607496261597,
0.8425759673118591,
-0.391553670167923,
-0.5247824788093567,
-0.11488993465900421,
0.43055227398872375,
-1.0852434635162354,
0.37678107619285583,
-0.45047426223754883,
0.1614254117012024,
-0.22365635633468628,
-0.8224121928215027,
-0.8468026518821716,
0.4455164074897766,
0.6924112439155579,
-0.5788688659667969,
-0.3254036605358124,
0.2557293474674225,
0.413896381855011,
-0.32616740465164185,
-0.025021040812134743,
0.5657813549041748,
0.5446292161941528,
0.06770049780607224,
-0.9505743384361267,
0.2908642292022705,
-0.15430741012096405,
0.48004645109176636,
0.3438449203968048,
-0.23682664334774017,
0.750519335269928,
-0.24631690979003906,
-0.07028395682573318,
0.27988383173942566,
0.44032007455825806,
0.22734922170639038,
-0.14179103076457977,
0.5549325942993164,
0.09815611690282822,
0.6594353318214417,
-0.3058486878871918,
1.0430667400360107,
-0.28993862867355347,
0.25543808937072754,
0.3994968831539154,
-0.051703888922929764,
0.5677844285964966,
0.9735957980155945,
0.014339425601065159,
0.5651294589042664,
-0.0016874942230060697,
0.17680026590824127,
0.8259799480438232,
0.38480237126350403,
0.1847854107618332,
-0.16587436199188232,
-0.007420097477734089,
-0.10046277195215225,
0.7097973823547363,
0.46645355224609375,
-0.5617641806602478,
-0.3447313606739044,
0.4848614037036896,
0.38498979806900024,
0.5149375796318054,
-0.5090989470481873,
0.7283780574798584,
0.18555010855197906,
-0.7397481799125671,
0.6677977442741394,
0.24034053087234497,
0.8396984934806824,
-0.7390806674957275,
-0.28474485874176025,
-0.12853775918483734,
0.1663716435432434,
-0.2895749509334564,
-0.655363917350769,
0.7825082540512085,
-0.6136763095855713,
-0.056992825120687485,
-0.4981050491333008,
0.9295154213905334,
-0.6439306139945984,
-0.2593112885951996,
0.22960658371448517,
0.3053179681301117,
-0.31885653734207153,
0.08391496539115906,
-0.6741915941238403,
0.25436779856681824,
0.3412567973136902,
-0.14028429985046387,
0.1678561270236969,
0.1561560183763504,
-0.30705997347831726,
0.9571703672409058,
0.5522732138633728,
0.5511687397956848,
0.01890752650797367,
-0.3239718973636627,
0.7712647318840027,
-0.5790078043937683,
-0.6430726051330566,
-0.7751685976982117,
0.4786764085292816,
0.05560163035988808,
-0.25446823239326477,
0.3637964725494385,
0.2100597620010376,
0.5231903195381165,
-0.08454433083534241,
0.7269560098648071,
-0.14890754222869873,
0.12921848893165588,
-0.6795288920402527,
1.2722777128219604,
-0.43608829379081726,
0.0023288007359951735,
-0.5217558741569519,
-0.6476123929023743,
-0.32965049147605896,
1.158345341682434,
-0.31343910098075867,
0.10666613280773163,
0.9078422784805298,
0.7211868762969971,
0.16758525371551514,
0.27940747141838074,
0.37961214780807495,
0.4028083086013794,
0.09838711470365524,
0.5775672793388367,
0.7628843784332275,
-0.3141414225101471,
0.4019717872142792,
-0.6053114533424377,
-0.118508480489254,
0.0456668883562088,
-0.8923360109329224,
-0.558403730392456,
-0.9669902324676514,
-0.3922691345214844,
-0.3577026128768921,
0.2558380961418152,
0.8611641526222229,
1.1065763235092163,
-0.8202012181282043,
-0.5330463647842407,
-0.23793190717697144,
0.2379530966281891,
-0.2698098421096802,
-0.1384062021970749,
0.22868262231349945,
-0.09654846042394638,
-0.6971179246902466,
0.14065448939800262,
0.032739173620939255,
0.23613885045051575,
-0.4886474311351776,
-0.087832972407341,
-0.39037224650382996,
-0.14176765084266663,
0.3816220462322235,
0.40302079916000366,
-0.5346323251724243,
-0.3790046274662018,
0.17215114831924438,
-0.09273434430360794,
0.08443053066730499,
0.9396341443061829,
-0.6154748797416687,
0.33369511365890503,
0.41686785221099854,
0.22515130043029785,
0.3794037699699402,
-0.07190091907978058,
1.2461025714874268,
-0.7606260180473328,
0.41771814227104187,
0.4127707779407501,
0.33056706190109253,
0.34606510400772095,
-0.4390857517719269,
0.34961119294166565,
0.19549082219600677,
-0.24210913479328156,
-0.8251141905784607,
0.23301176726818085,
-0.5852859616279602,
-0.2543225884437561,
1.2795946598052979,
0.25591960549354553,
-0.36132746934890747,
-0.08737049251794815,
-0.367856502532959,
0.31126752495765686,
-0.6356465816497803,
0.5469223260879517,
0.5041236877441406,
-0.3270964026451111,
-0.1489059180021286,
-0.5544494986534119,
0.8431833982467651,
0.54404616355896,
-0.3657435178756714,
0.14365364611148834,
0.47531858086586,
0.5429826378822327,
0.11638390272855759,
0.3674909472465515,
-0.2831803262233734,
0.21273766458034515,
-0.09911434352397919,
0.25000154972076416,
-0.2511399984359741,
-0.3292263448238373,
-0.7908372282981873,
0.0006785416626371443,
0.041633591055870056,
-0.16704010963439941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09615v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09615v4 | API Pack: A Massive Multi-Programming Language Dataset for API Call Generation | 2024-02-14T23:09:15 | 2024-06-03T22:38:04 | Zhen Guo, Adriana Meza Soria, Wei Sun, Yikang Shen, Rameswar Panda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce API Pack, a massive multi-programming language dataset
containing more than 1 million instruction-API call pairs to improve the API
call generation capabilities of large language models. By fine-tuning
CodeLlama-13B on 20,000 Python instances from API Pack, we enable it to
outperform GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in generating unseen API calls. Fine-tuning on API
Pack also facilitates cross-programming language generalization by leveraging a
large amount of data in one language and small amounts of data from other
languages. Scaling the training data to 1 million instances further improves
the model's ability to generalize to new APIs not used in training. To
facilitate further research, we open-source the API Pack dataset, trained
model, and associated source code at https://github.com/zguo0525/API-Pack. | [
-0.5014594793319702,
-0.4812091886997223,
-0.06352614611387253,
0.3529917001724243,
-0.05168157443404198,
0.1193753257393837,
-0.3039190173149109,
-0.50432950258255,
-0.15549947321414948,
0.6464287042617798,
-0.8235074281692505,
-0.597997784614563,
-0.03192679211497307,
0.072843998670578,
-0.1091986671090126,
0.9465442895889282,
0.311974436044693,
-0.11552952975034714,
0.07188185304403305,
-0.09735668450593948,
-0.7429015040397644,
-0.30954697728157043,
-0.4542784094810486,
-0.26433780789375305,
0.6489426493644714,
0.41511270403862,
0.345025897026062,
0.70811527967453,
0.1958734691143036,
0.2528771758079529,
0.3511715531349182,
0.17540203034877777,
-0.33303579688072205,
0.06022714078426361,
0.09535787254571915,
-0.5537989139556885,
-0.6875365376472473,
-0.041529279202222824,
0.3509097695350647,
0.572216808795929,
0.0007361391908489168,
0.660914957523346,
-0.10536642372608185,
0.747187077999115,
-0.37007805705070496,
0.46734535694122314,
-0.8123801350593567,
-0.1756928265094757,
-0.17791976034641266,
-0.3818924129009247,
-0.4960087239742279,
-0.35456621646881104,
0.4032428562641144,
-0.5296575427055359,
0.2058044821023941,
0.12776055932044983,
0.4665030539035797,
0.1184697076678276,
-0.08894038200378418,
-0.47129538655281067,
-0.4965176582336426,
0.9108706712722778,
-0.5621114373207092,
-0.05041944980621338,
0.47354695200920105,
0.27159765362739563,
-0.11684004217386246,
-0.49458763003349304,
-0.16477195918560028,
-0.04217395558953285,
0.3893158733844757,
-0.2529224157333374,
-0.028025347739458084,
-0.01241870317608118,
0.14343827962875366,
0.3240813910961151,
-0.8455016613006592,
0.079844169318676,
-0.6168569326400757,
-0.014491288922727108,
0.6676965951919556,
0.021521680057048798,
0.5255654454231262,
0.2276594340801239,
-0.09190330654382706,
0.07084911316633224,
-1.12602961063385,
-0.01587683893740177,
0.7980104088783264,
0.8852412104606628,
-0.1013660654425621,
0.39236095547676086,
-0.23333579301834106,
1.0204534530639648,
-0.22497494518756866,
0.13987676799297333,
0.3550841510295868,
-0.010504977777600288,
-0.18760716915130615,
0.18172672390937805,
0.4429418742656708,
0.2715807259082794,
0.2920317053794861,
-0.16429880261421204,
-0.05032426863908768,
-0.08566369861364365,
0.4250410795211792,
-0.9111748933792114,
-0.326978474855423,
0.5643677115440369,
-0.5271875858306885,
-0.3057009279727936,
0.011490914970636368,
-0.666701078414917,
-0.13112324476242065,
-0.4482870101928711,
0.10035769641399384,
-0.4796932637691498,
-0.5847356915473938,
0.11224192380905151,
-0.09213950484991074,
0.34592580795288086,
-0.0803871899843216,
-1.0577137470245361,
0.0323745459318161,
0.8761551976203918,
0.7841022610664368,
0.21373935043811798,
-0.6783549189567566,
-0.4578666388988495,
0.062034379690885544,
-0.4297665059566498,
1.1308810710906982,
-0.7683600187301636,
-0.2595071792602539,
0.4596959352493286,
0.02527834102511406,
0.08730291575193405,
-0.8206281065940857,
0.09411463141441345,
-0.2912311851978302,
-0.30129703879356384,
-0.17251631617546082,
-0.6621325612068176,
-0.04150889068841934,
0.16348131000995636,
-0.577183723449707,
1.0577096939086914,
0.33203715085983276,
-0.16346827149391174,
0.44534075260162354,
-0.6925572156906128,
-0.2154293656349182,
0.6094405055046082,
0.0016549695283174515,
-0.20123550295829773,
0.15160152316093445,
0.07680260390043259,
0.2097981572151184,
-0.25575441122055054,
-0.051569614559412,
-0.4379202723503113,
-0.34875327348709106,
0.15948379039764404,
0.014348307624459267,
0.7409605979919434,
0.30259695649147034,
-0.16870932281017303,
0.08003364503383636,
-0.9210492968559265,
0.47052571177482605,
-0.1261325627565384,
-0.5516388416290283,
-0.4745416045188904,
-0.23459899425506592,
0.07954983413219452,
0.2179645150899887,
0.16139639914035797,
-0.4705989956855774,
0.7954965233802795,
-0.30799296498298645,
0.7456012964248657,
0.7712393999099731,
-0.3147825300693512,
0.3749140799045563,
-0.12322127819061279,
0.5613959431648254,
-0.3676004707813263,
0.1636180728673935,
-0.7795071601867676,
-0.6386393308639526,
-0.37772855162620544,
-0.11498330533504486,
0.4257586896419525,
0.33563414216041565,
-0.49929651618003845,
0.6581109762191772,
-0.22027820348739624,
-0.5912373065948486,
-0.7813694477081299,
0.38899990916252136,
0.559863269329071,
0.15499074757099152,
0.23471792042255402,
0.016031034290790558,
-0.5517557859420776,
-0.749516487121582,
-0.14835591614246368,
-0.15396279096603394,
-0.22750216722488403,
0.32845380902290344,
0.40695708990097046,
-0.2734798192977905,
0.8061964511871338,
-0.4099923372268677,
-0.15925385057926178,
-0.23588697612285614,
0.32539206743240356,
0.24774381518363953,
0.677073061466217,
0.692435085773468,
-0.5183373689651489,
-0.37343722581863403,
-0.1563558131456375,
-0.4131174683570862,
-0.36816027760505676,
0.030809329822659492,
-0.3383362293243408,
0.46346330642700195,
0.21840986609458923,
-0.36000871658325195,
0.11745081096887589,
0.8711243271827698,
-0.2605661153793335,
0.6807994246482849,
-0.38229045271873474,
-0.10087159276008606,
-1.046547293663025,
-0.015077345073223114,
-0.1362401247024536,
0.34203240275382996,
-0.4762606620788574,
0.21190695464611053,
0.30743250250816345,
-0.44419562816619873,
-0.6023582816123962,
0.47006428241729736,
-0.565803050994873,
-0.11223740875720978,
-0.41775935888290405,
-0.5623061060905457,
-0.24781052768230438,
0.4282078146934509,
-0.23885609209537506,
0.8205888271331787,
0.9911493062973022,
-0.6271695494651794,
0.5421131253242493,
0.16885381937026978,
-0.28077051043510437,
0.3782629370689392,
-0.5144289135932922,
0.37083005905151367,
0.3102421462535858,
0.48032042384147644,
-0.9532272219657898,
-0.2126283198595047,
-0.01101923268288374,
-0.23207220435142517,
0.12967172265052795,
-0.7228732109069824,
-0.6293488144874573,
-0.6970036029815674,
-0.44827625155448914,
0.530508279800415,
0.3451579511165619,
-0.7590010166168213,
0.30285343527793884,
0.4663529396057129,
-0.28720563650131226,
-0.4357995092868805,
-0.7952775955200195,
-0.10424914956092834,
-0.08368252962827682,
-0.48760491609573364,
-0.11117324978113174,
-0.38014715909957886,
0.15376406908035278,
0.047015175223350525,
-0.20744413137435913,
-0.24135807156562805,
-0.41272661089897156,
0.5265974402427673,
0.4227900803089142,
-0.28427451848983765,
0.41280651092529297,
-0.1648704558610916,
-0.34066861867904663,
-0.1034025028347969,
-0.9341790080070496,
1.210558295249939,
-0.2395714670419693,
-0.23106542229652405,
-0.09839687496423721,
0.4797900319099426,
0.4636860489845276,
-0.33511266112327576,
0.5647222399711609,
0.41761356592178345,
-0.16708213090896606,
-0.5238294005393982,
-0.3236001133918762,
0.14043764770030975,
-0.4987775981426239,
0.07152687758207321,
-0.43742847442626953,
-0.625034749507904,
0.7513502240180969,
-0.22987042367458344,
0.34835004806518555,
0.2447279393672943,
0.5217407941818237,
0.3498009443283081,
0.972544252872467,
0.5517044067382812,
-0.5081163644790649,
0.3143675923347473,
-0.5003980398178101,
0.22221344709396362,
-0.5103217959403992,
-0.19523996114730835,
-0.7298705577850342,
-0.33032578229904175,
-0.7422510981559753,
-0.3033584654331207,
-0.10874612629413605,
-0.060026057064533234,
-0.3410763740539551,
0.5161624550819397,
-0.8987570405006409,
0.8908612728118896,
0.8166680932044983,
0.011177261359989643,
-0.08279984444379807,
0.19435223937034607,
0.3021649718284607,
0.2473290115594864,
-0.5842999219894409,
-0.3541497588157654,
1.5885010957717896,
0.007132587023079395,
0.8755909204483032,
-0.15795224905014038,
0.5720465779304504,
0.1955932080745697,
0.12565109133720398,
-0.7219190001487732,
0.4452638626098633,
-0.022814784198999405,
-0.5813347697257996,
-0.04567939043045044,
-0.41406774520874023,
-1.0459550619125366,
-0.08645852655172348,
0.03865985572338104,
-0.6083183288574219,
-0.1949775367975235,
0.34258225560188293,
-0.48610809445381165,
0.15155914425849915,
-1.1286894083023071,
0.806800901889801,
-0.2533133029937744,
0.005128851160407066,
-0.13357806205749512,
-0.3716491162776947,
0.2827579081058502,
-0.03379964828491211,
-0.05329641327261925,
-0.2109777182340622,
0.02112640254199505,
0.4044851064682007,
-0.4078795909881592,
0.7280329465866089,
-0.25802814960479736,
-0.41206708550453186,
0.44761762022972107,
-0.018695920705795288,
0.29030677676200867,
0.09047684818506241,
0.03674968704581261,
0.48586949706077576,
-0.12739324569702148,
-0.6725884079933167,
-0.14812900125980377,
0.9715557098388672,
-0.6983515620231628,
0.023434355854988098,
-0.14578711986541748,
-0.9991955757141113,
0.06519041955471039,
0.2952486276626587,
0.3174130916595459,
0.854231059551239,
0.2101961076259613,
0.032476380467414856,
0.5586851835250854,
-0.7798527479171753,
0.4752410650253296,
0.6917119026184082,
-0.33779099583625793,
-0.26812857389450073,
1.2757861614227295,
0.4373641908168793,
0.12289852648973465,
0.04198100417852402,
0.010524294339120388,
-0.420497864484787,
-0.5012246370315552,
-0.45935505628585815,
0.08039698004722595,
-0.3170229196548462,
-0.41020241379737854,
-0.5190736651420593,
-0.03369632363319397,
-0.7205303907394409,
-0.039454489946365356,
-0.5790363550186157,
-0.28252482414245605,
0.33861950039863586,
0.09988139569759369,
0.44863054156303406,
0.7402216792106628,
0.012158489786088467,
0.3622277081012726,
-0.7909132242202759,
0.4133813679218292,
0.3388396203517914,
0.81099933385849,
-0.1888476461172104,
0.003670605132356286,
-0.38044777512550354,
-0.05183684080839157,
-0.15459184348583221,
-0.6528743505477905,
0.5239522457122803,
0.21125176548957825,
0.4883364737033844,
0.359584778547287,
0.06001142039895058,
0.7980709075927734,
-0.7331497073173523,
0.8287379145622253,
-0.11329425871372223,
-0.6961132287979126,
0.908202588558197,
-0.6212188601493835,
0.5843470096588135,
0.25022822618484497,
0.015122833661735058,
-0.2379472404718399,
-0.5627367496490479,
-0.7517643570899963,
-1.172963261604309,
0.8846819996833801,
0.013979323208332062,
0.2148270606994629,
0.17583444714546204,
0.32647639513015747,
0.5099608898162842,
0.2900213599205017,
-0.425853431224823,
-0.33065468072891235,
-0.07317192107439041,
0.0001346173812635243,
0.07791854441165924,
-0.05686011165380478,
-0.3484616279602051,
-0.2504342794418335,
0.5358346700668335,
-0.36386334896087646,
0.31839606165885925,
-0.3455643951892853,
-0.030357234179973602,
-0.33354073762893677,
0.2784891724586487,
0.6336698532104492,
0.9932462573051453,
-0.4646811783313751,
-0.02195640839636326,
-0.3046685457229614,
-0.5170559883117676,
-0.1358269453048706,
0.33502069115638733,
-0.1912059187889099,
-0.12840025126934052,
0.13678961992263794,
0.6382117867469788,
0.078089639544487,
-1.0192437171936035,
-0.04465378075838089,
-0.11159949749708176,
-0.07190436124801636,
-0.3405437767505646,
0.11790993064641953,
0.03495074063539505,
0.2180764228105545,
0.6562051773071289,
0.09969806671142578,
-0.022564871236681938,
-0.5328003168106079,
0.29379430413246155,
0.23664148151874542,
0.18006189167499542,
-0.4869592785835266,
0.3753640949726105,
0.3994118273258209,
-0.4125950038433075,
0.56053227186203,
-0.15956053137779236,
-0.2876338064670563,
0.7638046741485596,
0.7036526203155518,
0.8091369271278381,
-0.36086133122444153,
0.42960721254348755,
0.4742989242076874,
0.31716835498809814,
-0.13861294090747833,
0.1720980405807495,
-0.1261264830827713,
-0.4583474099636078,
-0.4339331090450287,
-0.6290761232376099,
-0.41223347187042236,
0.6428440809249878,
-0.666797399520874,
0.1056143119931221,
-0.17180737853050232,
0.2911977171897888,
0.015068115666508675,
0.2672574520111084,
-0.6157867312431335,
-0.35789498686790466,
0.26666978001594543,
1.1236687898635864,
-0.8750954866409302,
1.1015876531600952,
0.8307690620422363,
-0.42067426443099976,
-0.9744330644607544,
-0.09674005955457687,
0.1760706752538681,
-0.9003747701644897,
0.45403948426246643,
0.578328549861908,
0.27947768568992615,
0.059989817440509796,
-0.7214528322219849,
-0.4741668999195099,
0.868941068649292,
0.5278913378715515,
-0.5032427310943604,
0.2787471115589142,
0.512309193611145,
0.4196692407131195,
-0.7774732708930969,
0.15536008775234222,
0.7326914668083191,
0.2711203992366791,
-0.27530747652053833,
-0.8061344623565674,
-0.2915458381175995,
-0.4759798049926758,
0.19174836575984955,
0.12161370366811752,
-0.5593681931495667,
1.0136799812316895,
0.012220288626849651,
0.1716533750295639,
0.17861522734165192,
0.1103193387389183,
0.5653383731842041,
0.06407297402620316,
0.4193640649318695,
0.5423116683959961,
0.7607511281967163,
-0.03494742885231972,
1.2294687032699585,
-0.5250154733657837,
0.36777639389038086,
1.1096210479736328,
-0.2026478350162506,
0.6768847703933716,
0.3331737816333771,
0.07167573273181915,
0.08866595476865768,
0.8612216114997864,
-0.17854943871498108,
0.558125913143158,
0.2563573718070984,
-0.3640964925289154,
-0.11374934017658234,
0.04888603463768959,
-0.8059865832328796,
0.28356319665908813,
0.2865169942378998,
-0.11883155256509781,
-0.41353294253349304,
0.03459226340055466,
-0.3135885000228882,
-0.374284565448761,
-0.5106185078620911,
0.6809514760971069,
-0.31359121203422546,
-0.7490507364273071,
0.7646308541297913,
-0.5310543775558472,
0.6446093320846558,
-0.6430112719535828,
-0.25383806228637695,
-0.3130294978618622,
0.3828524649143219,
-0.09366769343614578,
-0.7317053079605103,
-0.0005803043022751808,
0.21851074695587158,
-0.2225182056427002,
-0.23753222823143005,
0.7942946553230286,
-0.6754435300827026,
-0.45827117562294006,
0.3389277756214142,
0.40088528394699097,
0.21507441997528076,
-0.34337419271469116,
-0.8402862548828125,
0.22412942349910736,
-0.07938753068447113,
-0.29343003034591675,
0.5167791247367859,
0.662932276725769,
0.2156534641981125,
0.7939114570617676,
0.851315438747406,
0.44052210450172424,
0.659296989440918,
0.23178334534168243,
0.7983517050743103,
-0.4518197178840637,
-0.6285838484764099,
-0.5864763259887695,
0.4744831919670105,
0.035688288509845734,
-0.5752962231636047,
0.5147337317466736,
0.9632097482681274,
0.9876807928085327,
-0.4548463821411133,
1.1507688760757446,
-0.3386664092540741,
0.2737828195095062,
-0.18007820844650269,
0.6126126050949097,
-0.2319144755601883,
0.32008373737335205,
-0.11097628623247147,
-1.0438685417175293,
-0.28830596804618835,
0.3399752378463745,
-0.032149769365787506,
-0.3661918342113495,
0.243104949593544,
0.9435621500015259,
-0.07863729447126389,
0.09009252488613129,
0.10375566780567169,
0.03582106530666351,
0.5015510320663452,
0.5730098485946655,
0.7682347893714905,
-0.48363959789276123,
1.0025126934051514,
-0.21510405838489532,
-0.41661521792411804,
-0.09100811183452606,
-0.567668616771698,
-0.7924596071243286,
-0.6649170517921448,
-0.16952413320541382,
-0.29747527837753296,
-0.06871140003204346,
1.0430089235305786,
1.0387715101242065,
-0.9246275424957275,
-0.354035884141922,
-0.3899047374725342,
-0.21296586096286774,
-0.5907970666885376,
-0.21024416387081146,
0.1902197301387787,
-0.9360803365707397,
-0.9683070182800293,
0.3802395164966583,
0.3983476459980011,
-0.2764449417591095,
-0.22009173035621643,
-0.2978116571903229,
0.04280358925461769,
-0.2370990663766861,
0.5658143758773804,
0.6088672280311584,
-0.4783719778060913,
-0.10537508875131607,
-0.3292597830295563,
0.07366427779197693,
0.048975083976984024,
1.1605526208877563,
-0.5730251669883728,
0.530621349811554,
0.3447744846343994,
0.6532306671142578,
0.10866700857877731,
-0.24918398261070251,
0.7169598937034607,
-1.1508225202560425,
0.6165754795074463,
-0.13772933185100555,
0.2274455577135086,
0.0035684090107679367,
-0.1474715620279312,
0.773358941078186,
-0.11210514605045319,
-0.7922190427780151,
-1.0169379711151123,
0.24067610502243042,
-1.1430941820144653,
-0.35686394572257996,
1.1725414991378784,
-0.28814879059791565,
-0.27507156133651733,
-0.2209472507238388,
-0.4523153007030487,
0.20072397589683533,
-0.7207742929458618,
0.882612943649292,
0.565775454044342,
-0.2569376826286316,
-0.18615524470806122,
-0.8832341432571411,
0.40764522552490234,
-0.11013565212488174,
-0.9920381307601929,
0.49380844831466675,
0.5131621956825256,
0.3115578591823578,
0.36220651865005493,
0.49306488037109375,
-0.054876748472452164,
0.21843257546424866,
0.21533791720867157,
0.2597135305404663,
-0.2063700258731842,
-0.38659602403640747,
-0.19271299242973328,
0.28616124391555786,
-0.19112907350063324,
-0.5142548680305481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09614v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09614v2 | Probabilistic Reasoning in Generative Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T23:05:44 | 2024-06-17T05:13:33 | Aliakbar Nafar, Kristen Brent Venable, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | This paper considers the challenges Large Language Models (LLMs) face when
reasoning over text that includes information involving uncertainty explicitly
quantified via probability values. This type of reasoning is relevant to a
variety of contexts ranging from everyday conversations to medical
decision-making. Despite improvements in the mathematical reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, they still exhibit significant difficulties when it comes
to probabilistic reasoning. To deal with this problem, we introduce the
Bayesian Linguistic Inference Dataset (BLInD), a new dataset specifically
designed to test the probabilistic reasoning capabilities of LLMs. We use BLInD
to find out the limitations of LLMs for tasks involving probabilistic
reasoning. In addition, we present several prompting strategies that map the
problem to different formal representations, including Python code,
probabilistic algorithms, and probabilistic logical programming. We conclude by
providing an evaluation of our methods on BLInD and an adaptation of a causal
reasoning question-answering dataset. Our empirical results highlight the
effectiveness of our proposed strategies for multiple LLMs. | [
0.08191952854394913,
-1.0356953144073486,
1.2171118259429932,
0.36543190479278564,
0.03662509843707085,
-0.31098976731300354,
-0.3550618886947632,
-0.07455959171056747,
-0.422417014837265,
0.6714155673980713,
-0.6316577196121216,
-0.5330345034599304,
-0.5377286672592163,
0.10610701143741608,
-0.17065127193927765,
0.5441446304321289,
-0.19184237718582153,
0.004293884616345167,
-0.1125035509467125,
0.16604116559028625,
-0.5261771082878113,
-0.37154510617256165,
-0.6524240970611572,
-0.057438284158706665,
0.5033977627754211,
0.44034984707832336,
1.0516605377197266,
0.04791327193379402,
0.5604462027549744,
0.24149395525455475,
0.12198662012815475,
0.09159597009420395,
-0.008769258856773376,
0.43367648124694824,
-0.35925573110580444,
-0.7435917854309082,
-0.04532048851251602,
-0.37164047360420227,
0.746025800704956,
1.0720711946487427,
-0.1264335662126541,
-0.20288825035095215,
-0.19702094793319702,
0.4080190062522888,
-0.7801604866981506,
0.40049776434898376,
-0.7243764400482178,
0.03763163089752197,
-0.20617146790027618,
0.041302140802145004,
-0.5686970949172974,
-0.33938345313072205,
-0.020863879472017288,
-0.4437900483608246,
0.17734821140766144,
-0.1168113648891449,
0.3755788207054138,
0.3417310118675232,
-0.3998693823814392,
-0.18304511904716492,
-0.9053080081939697,
0.8017632961273193,
-0.8765278458595276,
0.2699596881866455,
0.7194344401359558,
0.1982571929693222,
-0.6207541823387146,
-0.3172174394130707,
-0.745561957359314,
-0.3256283402442932,
0.3115651309490204,
0.041683539748191833,
-0.2930382788181305,
0.0724019780755043,
0.265768438577652,
0.1517331302165985,
-0.7008727788925171,
0.24854329228401184,
0.16094711422920227,
0.08869586139917374,
0.6639811396598816,
-0.048776302486658096,
-0.1792655885219574,
-0.12521569430828094,
0.12324640899896622,
-0.10519588738679886,
-0.756200909614563,
-0.4213419258594513,
0.3737581670284271,
0.12921658158302307,
-0.01767062582075596,
0.8309209942817688,
-0.24925300478935242,
1.1207971572875977,
-0.40974733233451843,
-0.04341331496834755,
0.004074917174875736,
0.05997457727789879,
-0.27124714851379395,
-0.22197739779949188,
0.8158981204032898,
0.14529047906398773,
0.5900102853775024,
0.14494839310646057,
-0.15591196715831757,
-0.04627702012658119,
-0.16074703633785248,
-0.2606399357318878,
-0.33440637588500977,
0.5973367094993591,
-0.15790671110153198,
0.01815143972635269,
-0.07700180262327194,
-0.549954891204834,
-0.5047095417976379,
-0.053487394005060196,
0.6362743377685547,
-0.5643740892410278,
-0.2406228631734848,
0.6043448448181152,
-0.06674259155988693,
0.006406486965715885,
0.5934195518493652,
-0.8898448348045349,
-0.1347537636756897,
0.5830305218696594,
0.40446627140045166,
0.2897127568721771,
0.05566003546118736,
-0.35569503903388977,
0.32312262058258057,
-0.6238859295845032,
0.6209146976470947,
-0.550063967704773,
-0.1566779613494873,
0.09805160760879517,
-0.0947481244802475,
0.015592720359563828,
-0.601784884929657,
0.6064074635505676,
-0.3876098096370697,
0.1016916036605835,
-0.13471975922584534,
-0.639289140701294,
-0.16219691932201385,
-0.07092369347810745,
-0.5168173313140869,
0.4975578486919403,
0.1859671026468277,
-0.9003214240074158,
0.3420724868774414,
-0.1617894172668457,
-0.47944045066833496,
0.28252938389778137,
-0.3946893513202667,
-0.4371420443058014,
0.21608634293079376,
0.3145473003387451,
0.7266933917999268,
-0.4436194896697998,
0.6729696393013,
-0.5834270119667053,
-0.018748052418231964,
0.793377161026001,
-0.8010476231575012,
0.7484028935432434,
0.22576819360256195,
-0.21321433782577515,
-0.00340661546215415,
-0.7475860714912415,
-0.06615571677684784,
0.15869879722595215,
-0.26963597536087036,
-0.19933757185935974,
0.5998513102531433,
-0.20203262567520142,
-0.04699969291687012,
0.027349110692739487,
-0.21795007586479187,
0.2691398859024048,
-0.3562839925289154,
0.5306820273399353,
0.7510640621185303,
0.061656396836042404,
0.19947102665901184,
-0.2078714221715927,
0.3230190575122833,
-0.016956651583313942,
0.23572702705860138,
0.0480620451271534,
-0.896024227142334,
-0.6229084730148315,
-0.20360945165157318,
0.3106531500816345,
0.7379454374313354,
-1.0877937078475952,
0.5541185736656189,
-0.06330720335245132,
-0.11732134968042374,
-0.5472110509872437,
-0.11766083538532257,
0.12495799362659454,
0.31575238704681396,
0.1226554661989212,
0.09706880152225494,
-0.2502586841583252,
-0.7130123972892761,
-0.11857353150844574,
-0.5140106678009033,
-0.3510938882827759,
0.1118980124592781,
0.5007644295692444,
-0.10311675071716309,
0.8251727223396301,
-0.4701074957847595,
0.007794220931828022,
-0.44941094517707825,
0.28713443875312805,
0.5255131721496582,
0.5187022686004639,
-0.060600075870752335,
-0.9240977168083191,
0.11616393178701401,
-0.25282755494117737,
-0.8548482656478882,
-0.25327351689338684,
-0.7109885215759277,
0.05885870382189751,
0.19857771694660187,
0.3577120900154114,
-0.9717782735824585,
0.4199149012565613,
0.6227940917015076,
-0.20361822843551636,
0.8262190818786621,
-0.38089364767074585,
0.06073946878314018,
-0.7369619011878967,
-0.25513264536857605,
0.1958077996969223,
-0.0044050621800124645,
-0.39200785756111145,
0.05195565149188042,
-0.15745952725410461,
0.03796054795384407,
-0.205062136054039,
0.5044000148773193,
-0.4665922522544861,
-0.10497060418128967,
-0.1530744433403015,
-0.027594195678830147,
-0.2507047653198242,
0.03864205256104469,
0.42028629779815674,
0.49090152978897095,
0.8247861862182617,
-0.5013555884361267,
0.6987337470054626,
0.25589823722839355,
-0.6812435388565063,
0.4845801591873169,
-0.5318542122840881,
-0.4177391231060028,
-0.3334311246871948,
0.30647343397140503,
-0.9742750525474548,
-0.46995243430137634,
0.38809388875961304,
-0.5388623476028442,
0.20654277503490448,
-0.05200182646512985,
-0.9928020238876343,
-0.5309484004974365,
0.13399697840213776,
0.21324673295021057,
0.3677079379558563,
-0.2506704330444336,
0.157968670129776,
0.014326524920761585,
-0.31860023736953735,
-0.5038658976554871,
-0.7372338175773621,
0.29821449518203735,
-0.19800707697868347,
-0.582598865032196,
0.16210098564624786,
-0.045641664415597916,
-0.6471149325370789,
-0.0004394873685669154,
-0.038573361933231354,
-0.0001557162031531334,
0.32166704535484314,
0.11975434422492981,
0.1735997200012207,
-0.21025973558425903,
0.4280976355075836,
0.1573602259159088,
-0.206881582736969,
0.13027673959732056,
-0.470497190952301,
0.2910704016685486,
0.1630306839942932,
-0.8570054173469543,
-0.38399142026901245,
0.4609697163105011,
-0.004746332298964262,
0.0457165390253067,
0.9678798913955688,
0.2769325375556946,
-0.5455441474914551,
-0.3598648011684418,
-0.5602667331695557,
-0.24684274196624756,
-0.3717825710773468,
0.28964999318122864,
-0.5862835049629211,
-1.0577495098114014,
0.3714390695095062,
-0.04020800441503525,
-0.3373882472515106,
0.41352468729019165,
0.8353477716445923,
-0.18695636093616486,
1.1255364418029785,
0.24579791724681854,
0.17929798364639282,
-0.0248107872903347,
0.08015406876802444,
0.3780266344547272,
-0.3721313178539276,
-0.23136571049690247,
-0.5741881728172302,
0.1941700577735901,
-0.6203261613845825,
-0.8089087009429932,
0.36810940504074097,
0.41798892617225647,
-0.3319598436355591,
0.09290491789579391,
-0.20937949419021606,
0.2722871005535126,
0.6597179174423218,
0.20562352240085602,
0.24505697190761566,
-0.23851606249809265,
0.06116912513971329,
0.0864618644118309,
-0.8566937446594238,
-0.4579319655895233,
0.9111294150352478,
0.32205453515052795,
1.089939832687378,
0.28499993681907654,
0.39886099100112915,
-0.043773800134658813,
0.20111976563930511,
-0.5082791447639465,
0.5640460848808289,
-0.01605156809091568,
-0.7311797738075256,
-0.5235881805419922,
-0.9207471609115601,
-1.0726335048675537,
0.17469125986099243,
-0.2618822455406189,
-0.9830596446990967,
0.27930742502212524,
-0.087675541639328,
-0.3496706783771515,
0.31778261065483093,
-0.5791609287261963,
0.9108681678771973,
-0.1652166247367859,
-0.37014055252075195,
0.08855387568473816,
-0.7685627341270447,
0.4649219512939453,
-0.27712106704711914,
0.47646576166152954,
-0.1502324789762497,
0.09376128017902374,
0.45436808466911316,
-0.304311066865921,
0.9078000783920288,
0.03951709717512131,
-0.3476729691028595,
0.4396308362483978,
0.18690234422683716,
0.49877095222473145,
0.40361422300338745,
-0.2110125571489334,
0.027975142002105713,
-0.11447905004024506,
-0.38116735219955444,
-0.4590800404548645,
0.39646440744400024,
-0.46022042632102966,
-0.9771687388420105,
-0.4965539872646332,
-0.7801427245140076,
-0.6069192290306091,
-0.0497756190598011,
0.21489186584949493,
0.026024335995316505,
0.16411565244197845,
0.12041734158992767,
0.8896746039390564,
-0.8286113739013672,
0.2409392148256302,
0.5067181587219238,
-0.03722856193780899,
-0.18899203836917877,
0.6728686690330505,
0.04481004551053047,
0.39675235748291016,
0.8796344995498657,
0.3476528823375702,
-0.3623138666152954,
-0.699613630771637,
-0.40457794070243835,
0.2572108209133148,
-0.6745364665985107,
-0.15089184045791626,
-0.42325884103775024,
-0.21441712975502014,
-0.5182960033416748,
-0.12130212038755417,
0.1174737736582756,
-0.44022583961486816,
-0.36412063241004944,
-0.08078420162200928,
0.27652302384376526,
0.24418723583221436,
-0.16766391694545746,
0.4132387638092041,
-0.7283139228820801,
0.4608100652694702,
0.49300679564476013,
0.17412421107292175,
-0.26509398221969604,
-0.4365023076534271,
0.20616936683654785,
-0.026502545922994614,
-0.08490753173828125,
-1.3459696769714355,
0.46760013699531555,
0.008436121046543121,
0.6973232626914978,
0.4623662233352661,
0.21951748430728912,
0.16431741416454315,
-0.39234259724617004,
0.5687776803970337,
0.12816238403320312,
-0.8057432174682617,
0.8236775994300842,
-0.6672607660293579,
0.389111191034317,
0.17218469083309174,
0.6241128444671631,
-0.22794762253761292,
-0.7271528840065002,
-0.6814315319061279,
-0.7143876552581787,
0.2876952886581421,
0.3684259355068207,
-0.04775334522128105,
-0.29451286792755127,
0.4089509844779968,
0.12401238083839417,
0.2782844603061676,
-0.6195988655090332,
0.091063492000103,
0.37994593381881714,
-0.423759788274765,
-0.37827372550964355,
-0.3022315204143524,
0.01936059445142746,
-0.16900549829006195,
0.49859949946403503,
-0.23460477590560913,
0.27577832341194153,
0.08323109894990921,
-0.028767935931682587,
-0.011012662202119827,
0.5059172511100769,
0.4038791358470917,
0.8237151503562927,
-0.23087629675865173,
0.4206593930721283,
0.002639888087287545,
-0.019155608490109444,
0.09446153789758682,
0.35337769985198975,
-0.18102115392684937,
-0.002160537987947464,
0.6504089832305908,
0.7793342471122742,
0.15772190690040588,
-0.9749356508255005,
0.5497372150421143,
0.24240508675575256,
-0.33483177423477173,
-0.3209008276462555,
-0.0433863066136837,
0.33837205171585083,
0.3593026399612427,
0.3936227560043335,
-0.23960600793361664,
0.023014891892671585,
-0.6578142046928406,
0.12305177748203278,
0.3943827748298645,
0.01993163861334324,
-0.00741360429674387,
0.8919926881790161,
-0.316093385219574,
-0.09244533628225327,
0.7378123998641968,
-0.2805548906326294,
-0.36948931217193604,
0.5366430878639221,
0.5359155535697937,
0.52302086353302,
-0.34606224298477173,
0.47254490852355957,
0.05386676266789436,
0.5209865570068359,
-0.47327324748039246,
0.5527132749557495,
0.09412968903779984,
-0.9480538368225098,
-0.9080228805541992,
-0.6368476152420044,
-0.5903394818305969,
0.07445438206195831,
-0.21082042157649994,
0.05043747276067734,
-0.33237868547439575,
-0.2032804787158966,
0.13470903038978577,
-0.2583400011062622,
-0.3418903648853302,
0.27550801634788513,
0.27787691354751587,
0.7755324840545654,
-0.9880390763282776,
0.7864288091659546,
0.3097105622291565,
-0.45731431245803833,
-0.5088791847229004,
0.05959787219762802,
-0.06125748157501221,
-0.7748537063598633,
0.6857756972312927,
0.022217832505702972,
0.4182002544403076,
-0.12655654549598694,
-0.7038962841033936,
-0.5761719346046448,
0.43265897035598755,
0.5721907019615173,
-0.91791170835495,
0.2823004722595215,
0.33695027232170105,
0.3181588351726532,
0.106170155107975,
-0.00047406702651642263,
0.5694417953491211,
0.6347578763961792,
0.05553169548511505,
-0.6599042415618896,
0.10774075239896774,
0.2950457036495209,
0.03058159165084362,
0.03119758702814579,
-0.30790528655052185,
0.9815598726272583,
-0.5789296627044678,
-0.02417980134487152,
0.1713789403438568,
0.7712056040763855,
0.5769163370132446,
0.19467560946941376,
0.40182775259017944,
0.7228586673736572,
0.7864987254142761,
-0.2817637026309967,
1.1852104663848877,
0.21167296171188354,
0.14456094801425934,
1.0134682655334473,
-0.49585825204849243,
0.9660971164703369,
0.42984771728515625,
-0.4930712580680847,
0.37418392300605774,
0.7801416516304016,
-0.07642779499292374,
0.3561914563179016,
0.691660463809967,
-0.7447932362556458,
-0.745566725730896,
0.1918848603963852,
-0.2696838676929474,
0.10911743342876434,
0.6312701106071472,
-0.16877806186676025,
-0.07489471882581711,
0.13418413698673248,
-0.08736420422792435,
-0.04319113492965698,
-0.12146560847759247,
0.541254997253418,
0.29240095615386963,
-0.6194082498550415,
0.3237045407295227,
0.33750423789024353,
0.3149099349975586,
-0.4648740291595459,
0.0010675907833501697,
-0.11865060031414032,
0.2908783555030823,
-0.09393078088760376,
-1.16359281539917,
0.25714823603630066,
-0.15013711154460907,
0.0373237170279026,
-0.09666729718446732,
0.617616593837738,
-0.3013797998428345,
-0.8174476027488708,
-0.04364921897649765,
0.6361907720565796,
0.32685092091560364,
-0.4032350182533264,
-0.6278530955314636,
0.06580068171024323,
-0.23167753219604492,
-0.3477512001991272,
0.3279447555541992,
0.974911630153656,
-0.4120959937572479,
1.0226538181304932,
0.5106315016746521,
0.36218973994255066,
-0.010446885600686073,
0.4592844843864441,
0.4608161151409149,
-0.5634873509407043,
-0.2951808273792267,
-0.9115169048309326,
0.22077292203903198,
0.22872643172740936,
-0.07809145748615265,
0.7627047300338745,
0.2006216198205948,
0.626952588558197,
-0.2097671926021576,
0.9217414259910583,
0.03170306980609894,
0.27158376574516296,
-0.8007891178131104,
0.28866419196128845,
-0.2795305550098419,
0.3705020248889923,
-0.2370898723602295,
-0.6778931021690369,
-0.7159299254417419,
1.0444797277450562,
-0.5531509518623352,
0.09774046391248703,
0.6045177578926086,
0.6851794719696045,
0.3115883469581604,
0.062483061105012894,
0.35273393988609314,
0.2795906960964203,
0.090263232588768,
1.0962685346603394,
1.0815351009368896,
-0.1867303103208542,
0.31029215455055237,
0.08491741865873337,
-0.45966240763664246,
-0.15237243473529816,
-0.9555389285087585,
-0.5891531109809875,
-0.6109665036201477,
-0.5995336174964905,
-0.31683775782585144,
0.3012080788612366,
0.3764447271823883,
0.4414512515068054,
-0.7937515377998352,
-0.024853667244315147,
-0.4951415956020355,
0.5085646510124207,
-0.3202645480632782,
-0.24878303706645966,
0.35095617175102234,
-0.2544420659542084,
-0.4272080361843109,
0.25684866309165955,
0.2343488335609436,
0.006699132267385721,
-0.2145824134349823,
0.14687813818454742,
-0.10347248613834381,
0.10514175146818161,
0.47785860300064087,
0.14509771764278412,
-0.6694714426994324,
-0.4733884632587433,
-0.42934149503707886,
0.16172422468662262,
-0.372260183095932,
0.5908681154251099,
-0.5537691116333008,
0.21069593727588654,
0.5819057822227478,
0.6319003105163574,
0.43465882539749146,
-0.31476065516471863,
0.6058703660964966,
-0.6182835102081299,
0.12541890144348145,
0.4293995201587677,
0.3792112469673157,
0.4225795269012451,
-0.05844617262482643,
0.3168392479419708,
0.36808133125305176,
-0.5767943263053894,
-0.7868154048919678,
0.47831428050994873,
-0.9428697824478149,
-0.7937875390052795,
1.428758978843689,
-0.24076199531555176,
0.05696897581219673,
-0.287643700838089,
0.062036946415901184,
0.09949483722448349,
0.05413035303354263,
0.6038582921028137,
0.8670445680618286,
-0.04807312786579132,
-0.5493882298469543,
-1.0253243446350098,
0.2597253620624542,
0.5138823986053467,
-0.9507810473442078,
0.21803341805934906,
0.7409717440605164,
0.10209400951862335,
-0.2615108788013458,
0.7044548988342285,
-0.04364398866891861,
0.08861494809389114,
0.23978553712368011,
-0.11449982970952988,
0.4790370464324951,
-0.3861411511898041,
-0.3087674677371979,
0.27553507685661316,
0.19363798201084137,
0.14626525342464447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09611v1 | Towards Privacy-Aware Sign Language Translation at Scale | 2024-02-14T22:57:03 | 2024-02-14T22:57:03 | Phillip Rust, Bowen Shi, Skyler Wang, Necati Cihan Camgöz, Jean Maillard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | A major impediment to the advancement of sign language translation (SLT) is
data scarcity. Much of the sign language data currently available on the web
cannot be used for training supervised models due to the lack of aligned
captions. Furthermore, scaling SLT using large-scale web-scraped datasets bears
privacy risks due to the presence of biometric information, which the
responsible development of SLT technologies should account for. In this work,
we propose a two-stage framework for privacy-aware SLT at scale that addresses
both of these issues. We introduce SSVP-SLT, which leverages self-supervised
video pretraining on anonymized and unannotated videos, followed by supervised
SLT finetuning on a curated parallel dataset. SSVP-SLT achieves
state-of-the-art finetuned and zero-shot gloss-free SLT performance on the
How2Sign dataset, outperforming the strongest respective baselines by over 3
BLEU-4. Based on controlled experiments, we further discuss the advantages and
limitations of self-supervised pretraining and anonymization via facial
obfuscation for SLT. | [
0.0755307674407959,
0.015095566399395466,
0.2631306052207947,
0.28667163848876953,
-0.36695849895477295,
0.13287055492401123,
0.027318524196743965,
-0.47335636615753174,
0.2572754919528961,
0.6613211631774902,
-0.4660368859767914,
-0.5798285007476807,
-0.8918136954307556,
-0.1132599338889122,
-0.5179323554039001,
1.154386043548584,
0.05939776450395584,
0.21223068237304688,
0.23515945672988892,
-0.25449249148368835,
0.13586460053920746,
-0.18919195234775543,
-0.4949129521846771,
0.25820213556289673,
0.1561758667230606,
0.29614609479904175,
0.7947235703468323,
1.0073926448822021,
0.5047877430915833,
0.2042980045080185,
0.0527108833193779,
-0.11128182709217072,
-0.3111758828163147,
0.19068774580955505,
-0.10754659026861191,
-0.13173700869083405,
-0.627759575843811,
0.054737187922000885,
0.8417675495147705,
0.39287930727005005,
0.12344560027122498,
0.5972301363945007,
-0.0889451876282692,
0.6953921914100647,
-0.4386196434497833,
0.2543084919452667,
-0.41455161571502686,
0.12108030915260315,
-0.41119617223739624,
0.3329441249370575,
-0.13076002895832062,
-0.413715660572052,
-0.10383901000022888,
-0.46853503584861755,
0.3993178904056549,
0.11642555892467499,
0.6223574876785278,
0.5411912798881531,
-0.4668106138706207,
0.1022651270031929,
-0.6628810167312622,
0.45826828479766846,
-0.7696858644485474,
0.6578973531723022,
0.5166416168212891,
0.253214567899704,
0.3279383182525635,
-0.6054158210754395,
-0.19222024083137512,
-0.09811091423034668,
-0.24131478369235992,
-0.022685633972287178,
0.21818913519382477,
0.1656128615140915,
0.3312082886695862,
0.546047568321228,
-0.8877727389335632,
0.32047924399375916,
-0.3919035494327545,
-0.556290328502655,
0.7835567593574524,
-0.028274593874812126,
0.1222769245505333,
-0.05378313362598419,
-0.5631438493728638,
-0.0221828892827034,
-0.43253830075263977,
-0.0647311732172966,
0.19412226974964142,
0.5832529664039612,
-0.45809000730514526,
0.546372652053833,
-0.31510257720947266,
0.5583710670471191,
0.20410658419132233,
-0.07472439110279083,
0.35783934593200684,
-0.4559514820575714,
0.07208404690027237,
0.009798547253012657,
0.9180134534835815,
0.15973123908042908,
0.14198383688926697,
-0.09624779224395752,
-0.14109429717063904,
-0.10362672060728073,
-0.09023057669401169,
-0.8958064317703247,
-0.016364051029086113,
0.30917516350746155,
-0.22086083889007568,
0.013282283209264278,
-0.0014299910981208086,
-0.5278002023696899,
-0.7031251788139343,
-0.24504713714122772,
0.37999093532562256,
-0.14640220999717712,
-0.48671865463256836,
0.11817783862352371,
0.16981056332588196,
0.22635714709758759,
0.18066002428531647,
-0.9331265091896057,
0.43255430459976196,
0.6234133243560791,
0.8903734683990479,
-0.38915255665779114,
-0.2326834797859192,
-0.6596709489822388,
0.17873439192771912,
-0.020350899547338486,
-0.11763114482164383,
-0.02912568300962448,
-0.04128064960241318,
-0.1547604650259018,
-0.04632177948951721,
0.01665894128382206,
-0.1848812848329544,
0.03500960022211075,
-0.2771223783493042,
-0.0148775614798069,
0.010320167988538742,
-0.39861953258514404,
0.38650110363960266,
-0.03357692435383797,
-0.5366056561470032,
0.7187525629997253,
0.23127326369285583,
-0.44683125615119934,
0.4298188090324402,
-0.4634443521499634,
-0.7750823497772217,
0.40414246916770935,
-0.084269218146801,
-0.7632148265838623,
0.051794085651636124,
0.16566160321235657,
0.5449298620223999,
0.2076113522052765,
0.03619033843278885,
-0.08941075205802917,
-0.13429297506809235,
-0.017380543053150177,
-0.1632494330406189,
0.6589544415473938,
0.5004566311836243,
-0.7051371335983276,
-0.10669486969709396,
-0.8305881023406982,
0.08037042617797852,
-0.10952555388212204,
0.17946965992450714,
-0.2825002670288086,
-0.48911646008491516,
-0.11279034614562988,
0.3040894865989685,
0.6344238519668579,
-0.8799947500228882,
-0.1970904916524887,
-0.30505114793777466,
0.47870510816574097,
0.5330095887184143,
-0.10965272784233093,
0.5854561924934387,
0.27907830476760864,
0.7474223971366882,
-0.11206889897584915,
0.7421221733093262,
-0.04128667339682579,
-0.49042171239852905,
-0.4686976671218872,
-0.24263259768486023,
0.15513408184051514,
0.38764017820358276,
-0.3807021379470825,
0.2772408425807953,
-0.27476683259010315,
-0.36375582218170166,
-0.8468283414840698,
0.23235400021076202,
0.9126102924346924,
0.2949966490268707,
0.312865674495697,
-0.7650590538978577,
-0.11925370246171951,
-0.6815179586410522,
-0.46017754077911377,
0.022739851847290993,
-0.09223992377519608,
0.050789572298526764,
0.17583738267421722,
0.33486995100975037,
0.7111152410507202,
-0.43322673439979553,
-0.8669594526290894,
0.2564064860343933,
-0.048478707671165466,
-0.1122598946094513,
0.7961415648460388,
0.09898644685745239,
-1.0312633514404297,
-0.7656040191650391,
0.14156529307365417,
-0.5649516582489014,
0.03474466875195503,
-0.23341795802116394,
0.19153203070163727,
-0.16683560609817505,
0.5109571218490601,
-0.35659900307655334,
0.4762009382247925,
0.900242030620575,
-0.4078245162963867,
0.21359440684318542,
-0.32464173436164856,
-0.0557207390666008,
-0.8807596564292908,
-0.05933791399002075,
-0.041342198848724365,
-0.6562503576278687,
-0.8610985279083252,
0.18284742534160614,
0.2764531970024109,
-0.49719613790512085,
-0.7048024535179138,
0.36265724897384644,
-0.7757203578948975,
-0.49990057945251465,
-0.012795381247997284,
0.1867256909608841,
-0.1461053341627121,
0.3045596480369568,
0.15825992822647095,
0.7221282720565796,
0.7001776099205017,
-0.2574871778488159,
-0.1510278731584549,
0.3488397002220154,
0.03212408348917961,
0.5532118082046509,
-0.34521088004112244,
0.14850029349327087,
-0.03486806899309158,
-0.05204113572835922,
-0.8440348505973816,
-0.14314919710159302,
0.2183205485343933,
-0.5363081097602844,
0.4869217574596405,
-0.20842140913009644,
-0.44902023673057556,
-0.2762131989002228,
-0.15014386177062988,
0.265889972448349,
0.44884398579597473,
-0.3414769768714905,
0.40210965275764465,
0.442270964384079,
-0.12907539308071136,
-0.4621504843235016,
-0.7711161375045776,
0.055154018104076385,
-0.1879277229309082,
-0.37835025787353516,
-0.1410590261220932,
0.026503130793571472,
0.11496567726135254,
-0.40732043981552124,
-0.399535596370697,
-0.15040217339992523,
-0.10152910649776459,
0.42411893606185913,
-0.1826750636100769,
0.05261347442865372,
-0.17968443036079407,
0.0459839291870594,
-0.41363781690597534,
0.022648653015494347,
-0.5418119430541992,
0.1855267882347107,
-0.5242719054222107,
-0.4894614815711975,
-0.7060986161231995,
0.1994175761938095,
0.5317344069480896,
-0.5239713191986084,
0.601527214050293,
0.7766809463500977,
-0.12100519239902496,
0.058516327291727066,
-0.4630718529224396,
-0.1258598417043686,
-0.4962141811847687,
0.023503564298152924,
-0.14169134199619293,
-1.251190423965454,
0.38638749718666077,
-0.035332754254341125,
0.3248538374900818,
0.04254697263240814,
0.37923479080200195,
-0.02465604618191719,
0.8214453458786011,
0.37209656834602356,
0.1955414116382599,
0.584966778755188,
-0.018773822113871574,
0.23893751204013824,
-0.6527725458145142,
-0.1533452570438385,
-0.18169166147708893,
-0.23665735125541687,
-0.7144235372543335,
-0.5631754994392395,
0.3323070704936981,
-0.22453060746192932,
-0.2126363068819046,
1.032730221748352,
-0.7524058222770691,
0.4575692415237427,
0.4126138687133789,
0.2786368727684021,
0.5337368249893188,
-0.1164969950914383,
0.47477516531944275,
-0.2565411925315857,
-0.24040600657463074,
-0.13730086386203766,
1.1613903045654297,
0.38486307859420776,
0.6574959754943848,
0.1832805573940277,
0.9683939218521118,
0.3460208773612976,
0.18866561353206635,
-0.2627529501914978,
0.6825776696205139,
-0.4691930115222931,
-0.8360227346420288,
-0.9138375520706177,
-0.35362544655799866,
-0.8213038444519043,
0.4902854561805725,
-0.0003978598688263446,
-0.5759503245353699,
0.09580732882022858,
0.6420282125473022,
-0.19142009317874908,
0.04027140140533447,
-0.8696262836456299,
0.8206815719604492,
-0.49226000905036926,
-0.6037594676017761,
-0.0014178757555782795,
-1.47408127784729,
0.32463639974594116,
-0.37874525785446167,
0.5175448060035706,
-0.19236677885055542,
-0.014535479247570038,
0.525684654712677,
-0.6304561495780945,
1.0807710886001587,
-0.42352357506752014,
-0.22923453152179718,
-0.061391521245241165,
0.2875830829143524,
0.5586612820625305,
-0.00008285573130706325,
0.1968177855014801,
0.2566448450088501,
0.08546262979507446,
-0.485395610332489,
-0.43616941571235657,
0.6084477305412292,
-0.46591565012931824,
-0.5167648196220398,
-0.3701591193675995,
-0.5264537334442139,
-0.2786608934402466,
0.422744482755661,
0.14000928401947021,
-0.0006892883102409542,
0.05152669548988342,
0.04776335135102272,
0.7833340764045715,
0.19108200073242188,
0.18239738047122955,
0.7525960803031921,
-0.08725769072771072,
-0.19804291427135468,
1.1440237760543823,
0.021879874169826508,
0.7328479290008545,
0.31393927335739136,
0.4110543131828308,
-0.5648707747459412,
-0.67533940076828,
-0.5389866232872009,
0.4451262652873993,
-0.4265931248664856,
-0.04087264463305473,
-0.3201335370540619,
-0.16600050032138824,
-0.900383472442627,
-0.07195731997489929,
-0.8042451739311218,
-0.7832584381103516,
-0.07881756126880646,
-0.2788337171077728,
0.43912333250045776,
0.4558468461036682,
-0.5438112616539001,
0.5274682641029358,
-0.37659358978271484,
0.4728631377220154,
0.22220560908317566,
0.5235409140586853,
-0.3525266647338867,
-0.47385352849960327,
-0.2921304702758789,
-0.08289208263158798,
0.1267901211977005,
-0.46352624893188477,
0.17403028905391693,
0.24310584366321564,
0.019103435799479485,
0.5371235609054565,
0.19269540905952454,
0.6996090412139893,
-0.5261622071266174,
0.8227902054786682,
0.4534676671028137,
-0.8750020265579224,
0.5896896123886108,
-0.4020814895629883,
0.3782196342945099,
0.8075225353240967,
0.2518381178379059,
-0.5279780626296997,
-0.7653307318687439,
-0.6550490856170654,
-0.8927106857299805,
0.6228526830673218,
0.4292770028114319,
0.1931048333644867,
0.3830772340297699,
0.2273777723312378,
0.2599126696586609,
0.4404617249965668,
-0.984848141670227,
-0.24793533980846405,
-0.6224473714828491,
-0.0035102323163300753,
-0.16211260855197906,
0.3729483485221863,
-0.0963483601808548,
-0.23224015533924103,
0.47191140055656433,
0.05883974954485893,
-0.4246136248111725,
-0.06218194216489792,
-0.24680283665657043,
-0.010060504078865051,
0.09394407272338867,
0.4476514756679535,
0.3295893669128418,
-0.06181555613875389,
0.10957703739404678,
-0.04337243735790253,
-0.8564105033874512,
0.19633789360523224,
0.07448164373636246,
-0.5732817053794861,
-0.1434621959924698,
0.10471908748149872,
0.8396015167236328,
0.08534368872642517,
-0.32441282272338867,
0.8625526428222656,
0.18641646206378937,
-0.2744612395763397,
-0.2465982288122177,
-0.11353856325149536,
-0.09041955322027206,
0.12210367619991302,
-0.12286379933357239,
-0.13564938306808472,
0.08288375288248062,
0.10557050257921219,
0.42540252208709717,
0.21705643832683563,
-0.5120449066162109,
-0.3686094880104065,
1.216284155845642,
0.13909034430980682,
-0.5740304589271545,
0.24837176501750946,
-0.10900988429784775,
-0.08458838611841202,
0.17465785145759583,
0.37055259943008423,
0.8025502562522888,
-0.6628074049949646,
0.6450661420822144,
0.33869609236717224,
0.44274836778640747,
-0.1706361621618271,
0.1384119987487793,
-0.3818707764148712,
-0.24337057769298553,
-0.1710100769996643,
-0.5286567807197571,
-0.3566409647464752,
0.1417205035686493,
-0.9549388289451599,
-0.12582750618457794,
-0.70888751745224,
-0.13009855151176453,
-0.4497971832752228,
-0.4122711718082428,
-0.7114929556846619,
0.3864971697330475,
0.2582475244998932,
0.3561462163925171,
-1.1467562913894653,
0.7279401421546936,
0.2359447181224823,
-0.3991991877555847,
-0.5933973789215088,
-0.18464313447475433,
0.1741304248571396,
-1.0975171327590942,
0.2529558837413788,
0.07796387374401093,
-0.22708047926425934,
0.38399219512939453,
-0.38425973057746887,
-1.1499484777450562,
1.0388832092285156,
0.3005658984184265,
-0.6819324493408203,
0.04138052463531494,
0.704630434513092,
0.7462177872657776,
-0.13022883236408234,
-0.46255165338516235,
0.5841503143310547,
0.45690682530403137,
0.15708352625370026,
-0.9633288979530334,
0.3441290259361267,
0.44320908188819885,
0.20267029106616974,
0.14229249954223633,
-0.9131657481193542,
0.3565822243690491,
-0.21702909469604492,
-0.23372220993041992,
-0.013874352909624577,
0.8108938932418823,
-0.05303606390953064,
0.20580673217773438,
0.459611713886261,
0.33765876293182373,
0.47610652446746826,
0.2851113975048065,
0.5279286503791809,
-0.33633390069007874,
0.27331921458244324,
1.2928409576416016,
-0.2596934735774994,
0.5568047165870667,
0.60666424036026,
-0.16890105605125427,
-0.1752396672964096,
0.3898943364620209,
0.021356062963604927,
0.5209830403327942,
0.37171095609664917,
-0.2589041292667389,
-0.28535300493240356,
-0.02346798963844776,
-0.2853301465511322,
0.39508119225502014,
0.2038509100675583,
-0.35226520895957947,
-0.37181779742240906,
0.2677876055240631,
0.1167326271533966,
0.3923318684101105,
-0.273081511259079,
0.6154559850692749,
0.3006322979927063,
-0.2793874740600586,
0.4040108919143677,
-0.30165737867355347,
0.37706536054611206,
-0.8321053385734558,
0.32733580470085144,
-0.2566264867782593,
0.13642776012420654,
-0.292543888092041,
-0.7356417775154114,
0.1841110736131668,
-0.03464433550834656,
0.3938271999359131,
-0.9934030175209045,
0.5073163509368896,
-0.5450436472892761,
-0.22569851577281952,
0.029155485332012177,
0.429624080657959,
0.8228799104690552,
0.08074600249528885,
-0.7733736634254456,
-0.06064631789922714,
0.024826103821396828,
-0.30884110927581787,
0.7964450716972351,
0.30098897218704224,
-0.2783617377281189,
0.594760000705719,
0.48321229219436646,
0.1672879159450531,
0.30380159616470337,
0.32769128680229187,
0.623266339302063,
-0.293518602848053,
-0.6572409868240356,
-0.43751242756843567,
0.5252367854118347,
-0.07120177894830704,
-0.44757840037345886,
1.0675017833709717,
0.8083663582801819,
0.7863227128982544,
-0.04495134577155113,
0.6488584876060486,
-0.06560155004262924,
0.49789750576019287,
-0.2521301507949829,
0.8497133851051331,
-0.39247462153434753,
-0.08286973088979721,
-0.27387329936027527,
-0.5651922821998596,
-0.599833071231842,
0.3341673016548157,
-0.08007007092237473,
-0.35442593693733215,
0.43895694613456726,
0.8057996034622192,
0.0522482767701149,
-0.09676993638277054,
0.5841701030731201,
0.13964146375656128,
0.143423929810524,
0.29587268829345703,
-0.004989113658666611,
-0.572154700756073,
0.6369727253913879,
-0.19622673094272614,
-0.45854756236076355,
0.1426890343427658,
-0.9190598130226135,
-0.7866209149360657,
-0.8218926191329956,
-0.6290207505226135,
-0.25894802808761597,
-0.13587909936904907,
0.3521935045719147,
0.7810633778572083,
-0.7386531829833984,
-0.23177948594093323,
-0.07294938713312149,
-0.1816117763519287,
-0.4369466304779053,
-0.1015402153134346,
0.48744839429855347,
0.09160210192203522,
-0.5589665174484253,
0.39771801233291626,
0.2811625599861145,
0.34318676590919495,
-0.4871383607387543,
-0.1100013330578804,
0.14364898204803467,
-0.34967532753944397,
0.45220914483070374,
0.8030053377151489,
-0.6116593480110168,
-0.33473294973373413,
-0.3097424805164337,
-0.0384071059525013,
0.05216853693127632,
0.7373461723327637,
-0.40963014960289,
0.6488375663757324,
0.08453026413917542,
0.48032525181770325,
1.2032058238983154,
0.39893996715545654,
0.2665015459060669,
-1.2400091886520386,
0.2500971853733063,
0.2604660391807556,
-0.2263597697019577,
0.46812885999679565,
-0.6002147793769836,
0.5640541911125183,
0.143891379237175,
-0.32672128081321716,
-0.6957488059997559,
0.546829879283905,
-1.0467575788497925,
0.09252138435840607,
1.1375362873077393,
-0.4047691524028778,
-0.13808158040046692,
-0.2589101791381836,
0.26726752519607544,
0.17406511306762695,
-0.3115217089653015,
0.586689293384552,
0.2682749629020691,
-0.28024083375930786,
-0.2628820836544037,
-0.3603494167327881,
0.6801726222038269,
0.2756747901439667,
-0.49040791392326355,
0.5836753845214844,
0.3770049214363098,
0.3347337245941162,
0.07253870368003845,
1.0189005136489868,
-0.37736383080482483,
0.09579259157180786,
-0.018471913412213326,
0.0788080170750618,
-0.3953869044780731,
-0.25130996108055115,
-0.3486737608909607,
0.0458885133266449,
-0.013678444549441338,
-0.5000104904174805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09609v1 | LogicPrpBank: A Corpus for Logical Implication and Equivalence | 2024-02-14T22:36:07 | 2024-02-14T22:36:07 | Zhexiong Liu, Jing Zhang, Jiaying Lu, Wenjing Ma, Joyce C Ho | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Logic reasoning has been critically needed in problem-solving and
decision-making. Although Language Models (LMs) have demonstrated capabilities
of handling multiple reasoning tasks (e.g., commonsense reasoning), their
ability to reason complex mathematical problems, specifically propositional
logic, remains largely underexplored. This lack of exploration can be
attributed to the limited availability of annotated corpora. Here, we present a
well-labeled propositional logic corpus, LogicPrpBank, containing 7093
Propositional Logic Statements (PLSs) across six mathematical subjects, to
study a brand-new task of reasoning logical implication and equivalence. We
benchmark LogicPrpBank with widely-used LMs to show that our corpus offers a
useful resource for this challenging task and there is ample room for model
improvement. | [
-0.3154571056365967,
-0.44339871406555176,
0.6436015963554382,
0.23170964419841766,
-0.06115278601646423,
-0.24046991765499115,
-0.22106444835662842,
-0.326315701007843,
-0.3509887754917145,
0.5562033653259277,
-0.27003568410873413,
-0.13991625607013702,
-0.6436972618103027,
0.37029120326042175,
-0.43906888365745544,
0.8825347423553467,
0.10031857341527939,
0.18472523987293243,
-0.5132355690002441,
-0.02318659983575344,
-0.3724624216556549,
-0.5673863887786865,
-0.4569568336009979,
-0.32615694403648376,
0.008107747882604599,
0.10062903165817261,
0.945759654045105,
0.256344199180603,
0.7794783711433411,
0.3633562922477722,
0.1389104425907135,
0.14737847447395325,
0.09422556310892105,
-0.045073311775922775,
-0.7734640836715698,
-0.38139766454696655,
-0.27106666564941406,
-0.15596312284469604,
0.44271084666252136,
0.9218565821647644,
0.12476997077465057,
0.4470592141151428,
-0.28045132756233215,
0.5104484558105469,
-0.7460725903511047,
0.2836490273475647,
-0.6062915325164795,
-0.1570608764886856,
-0.07442694902420044,
0.18359331786632538,
-0.539445161819458,
-0.3837236166000366,
0.41880670189857483,
-0.8765159249305725,
0.11272082477807999,
0.1705884337425232,
0.5296257734298706,
0.19640418887138367,
-0.2554222047328949,
-0.2610345780849457,
-0.4547806978225708,
0.7444587349891663,
-0.5587559342384338,
0.23365989327430725,
0.24301128089427948,
0.4397827684879303,
-0.1127176359295845,
-0.8032524585723877,
-0.7203294634819031,
0.09320312738418579,
-0.3301585018634796,
0.10585160553455353,
-0.4570569097995758,
-0.017997590824961662,
0.5065839886665344,
-0.028582094237208366,
-0.46300172805786133,
-0.3317459523677826,
-0.537788987159729,
-0.39312970638275146,
0.42786312103271484,
-0.20204061269760132,
0.17789757251739502,
-0.5991680026054382,
-0.3902932107448578,
0.03390054777264595,
-0.6593787670135498,
0.10568496584892273,
0.48761942982673645,
0.28851550817489624,
0.15480639040470123,
0.6455187201499939,
-0.0060613034293055534,
1.096009612083435,
-0.3732828199863434,
-0.25113582611083984,
0.21209487318992615,
-0.14573675394058228,
-0.13763484358787537,
0.36201515793800354,
0.27325522899627686,
0.28354236483573914,
0.4162430167198181,
0.4279637634754181,
-0.39431867003440857,
0.4872952103614807,
0.13069882988929749,
-0.4967834949493408,
-0.3298614025115967,
0.33793553709983826,
-0.3070208728313446,
0.2040705680847168,
0.1891680359840393,
-0.3982512354850769,
-0.45154568552970886,
-0.703499972820282,
0.4572085738182068,
-0.7226771712303162,
-0.2994954586029053,
0.7375744581222534,
-0.4378621280193329,
0.07857074588537216,
0.37175947427749634,
-0.6639436483383179,
0.42316192388534546,
1.1977523565292358,
0.29007717967033386,
-0.013813618570566177,
-0.1374337375164032,
-0.6575212478637695,
-0.019219016656279564,
-0.2864282727241516,
1.0790326595306396,
-0.8321634531021118,
-0.1824207752943039,
0.07259154319763184,
-0.30332186818122864,
-0.15753740072250366,
-0.7835597991943359,
1.40804922580719,
-0.30603018403053284,
0.1773500293493271,
-0.2285517305135727,
-1.0076512098312378,
-0.161899134516716,
0.1365455687046051,
-0.5254822969436646,
0.699312686920166,
0.11093838512897491,
-0.5492430925369263,
-0.12356185168027878,
-0.5357874035835266,
-0.31922468543052673,
0.25210103392601013,
-0.24026939272880554,
0.040193989872932434,
0.24718724191188812,
0.148217111825943,
0.1694926917552948,
-0.3087543845176697,
0.7129660248756409,
-0.21516172587871552,
-0.08263765275478363,
0.6346147060394287,
-0.2018682360649109,
0.8570001125335693,
0.349829763174057,
0.07282477617263794,
0.15272429585456848,
-0.7547022104263306,
-0.20124073326587677,
-0.07318982481956482,
0.17861291766166687,
-0.47522440552711487,
0.04882843419909477,
-0.14778932929039001,
0.42698633670806885,
0.47047215700149536,
-0.6923452019691467,
-0.039801448583602905,
-0.47852882742881775,
0.6202559471130371,
0.5238181352615356,
-0.3689781725406647,
0.08544330298900604,
-0.43921321630477905,
0.21802225708961487,
0.1361946016550064,
-0.061726704239845276,
-0.17295128107070923,
-0.5769369006156921,
-0.508991539478302,
-0.41713517904281616,
0.41518303751945496,
0.663497269153595,
-0.4267444312572479,
0.39919620752334595,
-0.07786045223474503,
-0.16923558712005615,
-0.6479817628860474,
-0.04347105324268341,
0.408480703830719,
1.097434163093567,
0.3933083117008209,
0.24730990827083588,
-0.6517987847328186,
-1.303431749343872,
-0.5663058161735535,
0.032193366438150406,
-0.2372109293937683,
0.0705847516655922,
0.555662989616394,
0.2829868793487549,
1.209505319595337,
-0.523607075214386,
-0.2339649647474289,
-0.2998693883419037,
0.017340997233986855,
0.5358090996742249,
0.4173303246498108,
0.3937130272388458,
-0.9448287487030029,
-0.10060779750347137,
-0.48494526743888855,
-0.6157469749450684,
-0.38268542289733887,
-0.14552591741085052,
-0.2593880891799927,
0.04914248362183571,
0.29503509402275085,
-0.7062745094299316,
0.3485977351665497,
0.27347490191459656,
-0.3499032258987427,
0.6334627866744995,
-0.3071209490299225,
-0.16512824594974518,
-0.6498209238052368,
0.07014026492834091,
0.2086951583623886,
-0.23844172060489655,
-0.477394700050354,
-0.09987509995698929,
0.2383703738451004,
-0.4587673246860504,
-0.5590223073959351,
0.6989174485206604,
-0.01044965349137783,
-0.31935155391693115,
-0.21158510446548462,
0.640758752822876,
0.1672499030828476,
0.28801456093788147,
0.4545213580131531,
0.605506181716919,
0.5774537324905396,
-0.26639074087142944,
0.4758617579936981,
0.5238739848136902,
-0.3611210286617279,
0.6639925241470337,
-0.48612740635871887,
-0.5306594371795654,
-0.244233638048172,
0.3625790476799011,
-0.9436328411102295,
0.006754780188202858,
0.18247349560260773,
-0.30043917894363403,
-0.3743151128292084,
0.04413604363799095,
-0.57359379529953,
-0.39056670665740967,
0.026709746569395065,
0.5634942650794983,
0.33328554034233093,
-0.685947060585022,
0.8084217309951782,
0.1890559196472168,
-0.270906925201416,
-0.4249984323978424,
-0.26601001620292664,
-0.22571109235286713,
-0.20245859026908875,
-0.4811787009239197,
0.3639277219772339,
0.26115015149116516,
-0.6841127872467041,
0.21335238218307495,
-0.316150426864624,
0.14909423887729645,
-0.05587632581591606,
0.16038042306900024,
0.7058857679367065,
-0.06541453301906586,
0.3975563943386078,
-0.14024485647678375,
-0.4095091223716736,
0.4028519093990326,
-0.6290956139564514,
0.2796342968940735,
-0.6060134172439575,
-0.3778949975967407,
-0.28859832882881165,
0.21603012084960938,
-0.0638674646615982,
-0.5154009461402893,
0.5729936957359314,
0.12669970095157623,
-0.7208119034767151,
-0.1654110848903656,
-0.30559542775154114,
-0.0012849324848502874,
-0.39517512917518616,
-0.08844032138586044,
-0.5882050395011902,
-0.7060413956642151,
0.25740063190460205,
-0.4399622082710266,
0.09740529209375381,
0.7246608138084412,
0.29852497577667236,
0.11715316772460938,
0.6283757090568542,
-0.08200380206108093,
0.5239927172660828,
-0.19830602407455444,
0.20991994440555573,
0.551030695438385,
-0.5691765546798706,
-0.11012248694896698,
-0.5913184881210327,
-0.0282784104347229,
-0.38443541526794434,
-0.3127186894416809,
0.19782638549804688,
0.3245607316493988,
-0.42788127064704895,
0.5321335792541504,
-0.5964012145996094,
0.5221560597419739,
0.5753312110900879,
-0.11018381267786026,
0.49102097749710083,
-0.2646816670894623,
-0.0341765359044075,
-0.28219830989837646,
-0.44045549631118774,
-0.6807727217674255,
1.035659909248352,
0.036444906145334244,
0.08826649934053421,
0.4005253314971924,
0.48667871952056885,
0.20642916858196259,
0.3604253828525543,
-0.3189495801925659,
0.6442340612411499,
-0.33468127250671387,
-0.9601935148239136,
-0.12626220285892487,
-0.2627694308757782,
-0.604155957698822,
0.43506935238838196,
-0.4871593117713928,
-0.8303486108779907,
-0.13854557275772095,
0.21643143892288208,
-0.7087858319282532,
0.11034148931503296,
-0.9152929186820984,
1.231140375137329,
-0.3213016986846924,
-0.3592292368412018,
-0.28749293088912964,
-0.6013455986976624,
0.7066596150398254,
-0.13416555523872375,
0.39051592350006104,
-0.4121871292591095,
-0.050018686801195145,
0.5550504922866821,
-0.466952919960022,
0.5829371809959412,
-0.036350008100271225,
-0.06292346119880676,
0.6615358591079712,
0.17261990904808044,
0.12200973927974701,
0.2642117738723755,
-0.16994374990463257,
-0.14980866014957428,
0.5131556391716003,
-0.4754751920700073,
-0.6797252297401428,
0.49772319197654724,
-0.5851391553878784,
-0.7911449670791626,
-0.6586209535598755,
-0.5904419422149658,
-0.3810095191001892,
0.30007216334342957,
-0.25370651483535767,
0.7611279487609863,
0.17508698999881744,
-0.009579738602042198,
0.6938811540603638,
-0.40311139822006226,
0.22341111302375793,
0.1529417484998703,
-0.524052083492279,
-0.20637716352939606,
0.9377362728118896,
-0.4193187654018402,
0.11090554296970367,
0.8252379298210144,
0.44421711564064026,
-0.7925950884819031,
-0.15714244544506073,
-0.20971766114234924,
0.20165503025054932,
-0.8471022248268127,
-0.3313577175140381,
-0.33363232016563416,
-0.09339150786399841,
-0.6475359201431274,
-0.12834568321704865,
-0.2961820065975189,
-0.976418137550354,
0.06800317019224167,
-0.14949408173561096,
0.3941607177257538,
0.1716228872537613,
-0.25182271003723145,
-0.01098645105957985,
-0.6404936909675598,
0.670839786529541,
0.18665209412574768,
0.27671852707862854,
-0.44216519594192505,
-0.3948022723197937,
0.6009441018104553,
-0.2757282853126526,
-0.17601308226585388,
-0.8122215867042542,
0.258506178855896,
0.07512430846691132,
0.4542654752731323,
0.3387751281261444,
0.4575289189815521,
0.34498172998428345,
-0.4678054451942444,
0.21402408182621002,
0.28793200850486755,
-1.2685054540634155,
0.5600681900978088,
-0.4020858108997345,
0.033546410501003265,
0.40993794798851013,
0.4864239990711212,
-0.4048452079296112,
0.17057748138904572,
-0.8456963300704956,
-0.43194013833999634,
0.30143114924430847,
0.2043905109167099,
-0.2633572220802307,
-0.22441454231739044,
0.19918349385261536,
0.3242989778518677,
0.4056726098060608,
-0.41610217094421387,
0.0008005952113308012,
-0.5214530229568481,
-0.4464394748210907,
0.13629856705665588,
0.05741462856531143,
-0.2185218632221222,
-0.3489757180213928,
0.5872805118560791,
-0.0956897959113121,
0.14898599684238434,
0.20864735543727875,
-0.08635343611240387,
0.4067852199077606,
0.5442848801612854,
0.6115479469299316,
0.9779782295227051,
-0.14300474524497986,
0.5029380321502686,
0.042613741010427475,
0.06831345707178116,
-0.17802858352661133,
0.6598643064498901,
-0.08808127045631409,
-0.09782610833644867,
0.39915189146995544,
0.5599184036254883,
0.34402766823768616,
-1.538150429725647,
0.6001101136207581,
0.23485246300697327,
-0.381343275308609,
-0.6402091383934021,
-0.13139888644218445,
0.6120553612709045,
0.22052548825740814,
0.39557352662086487,
0.16631415486335754,
0.14497311413288116,
-0.4991177022457123,
0.39935198426246643,
0.18693317472934723,
0.2474427968263626,
0.11699379980564117,
0.6510128378868103,
0.12691259384155273,
-0.39100706577301025,
0.6640657782554626,
-0.2343628853559494,
-0.5909548401832581,
0.36873480677604675,
0.5217905044555664,
0.18565715849399567,
0.23554003238677979,
0.23187196254730225,
0.4872936010360718,
-0.06468960642814636,
-0.20140783488750458,
0.1424102634191513,
0.09418024867773056,
-0.9119570255279541,
-0.42215394973754883,
-0.8640833497047424,
-0.6361055374145508,
-0.0121802669018507,
-0.5700541138648987,
0.14540962874889374,
-0.5434013605117798,
-0.04839472472667694,
0.3826617896556854,
-0.10908345133066177,
-0.5611186027526855,
0.1313292533159256,
0.2329651415348053,
1.1170506477355957,
-0.7855962514877319,
0.6668065786361694,
0.6849157214164734,
-0.3060305118560791,
-0.6806820034980774,
-0.6536543965339661,
-0.007892590016126633,
-0.6971490979194641,
0.7932238578796387,
0.16644501686096191,
-0.015134762972593307,
-0.2976280748844147,
-0.23950032889842987,
-0.5417472124099731,
0.4998719394207001,
0.4882259964942932,
-0.6415835618972778,
0.2909247577190399,
0.45985597372055054,
0.5428246855735779,
-0.4374251961708069,
-0.04254478961229324,
0.6636211276054382,
0.5882062911987305,
-0.05110246688127518,
-0.6463591456413269,
0.0028008848894387484,
-0.2548747658729553,
-0.19289487600326538,
0.18565011024475098,
-0.23942355811595917,
0.9811097979545593,
-0.039936259388923645,
0.01808873377740383,
-0.03192654997110367,
0.972079873085022,
0.8023865818977356,
0.1937669962644577,
0.5701888203620911,
0.6694327592849731,
0.728654146194458,
-0.2853792905807495,
0.8426761627197266,
-0.36800140142440796,
0.07530109584331512,
1.2832130193710327,
-0.6609955430030823,
1.0629302263259888,
0.3821961581707001,
-0.18312379717826843,
0.3278381824493408,
0.5255286693572998,
0.09824076294898987,
0.09414999932050705,
0.6271089911460876,
-0.45175692439079285,
-0.940180242061615,
-0.25684088468551636,
-0.1797809600830078,
0.3016205430030823,
0.6160942912101746,
-0.13578958809375763,
-0.48801931738853455,
-0.10337792336940765,
-0.3517824113368988,
0.8265330195426941,
-0.3276159167289734,
0.05045653507113457,
0.1739456057548523,
-1.0119056701660156,
0.07243576645851135,
0.15542031824588776,
0.2510283291339874,
-0.3881632387638092,
-0.0427452027797699,
0.042350128293037415,
0.5517154335975647,
-0.2520621716976166,
-0.994825541973114,
0.4133993983268738,
-0.0009958392474800348,
0.11734358966350555,
-0.4410841763019562,
0.8844121098518372,
-0.053098320960998535,
-0.6791413426399231,
0.14564937353134155,
0.6828109622001648,
0.11429838091135025,
0.06599598377943039,
-0.6367607712745667,
-0.015157779678702354,
-0.32285434007644653,
0.10667851567268372,
0.3200714886188507,
0.45396968722343445,
-0.31929826736450195,
0.6527212262153625,
0.5768671035766602,
-0.00702033331617713,
0.016513148322701454,
0.05293627083301544,
0.568988025188446,
-0.5972565412521362,
-0.2793551981449127,
-0.5864331722259521,
0.015914294868707657,
-0.16685552895069122,
-0.5570104122161865,
0.5453987717628479,
0.8518050909042358,
1.0114750862121582,
-0.03307829424738884,
0.8555010557174683,
-0.003180429805070162,
0.8215422034263611,
-0.36190709471702576,
-0.2862253189086914,
-0.2761775553226471,
0.2609497308731079,
-0.2533929646015167,
-0.6823233962059021,
-0.515635073184967,
1.017695665359497,
-0.8319242000579834,
-0.5549216270446777,
0.8157307505607605,
0.4211483597755432,
-0.1697489470243454,
0.6534334421157837,
-0.01928154192864895,
-0.2698154151439667,
-0.020698174834251404,
0.884441077709198,
0.8673672676086426,
-0.2166515737771988,
0.7293353080749512,
-0.21440072357654572,
-0.020843330770730972,
0.21631592512130737,
-1.0958659648895264,
-0.710254967212677,
-0.6156322360038757,
-0.33693575859069824,
-0.35351383686065674,
0.0343891903758049,
1.2488394975662231,
0.10685042291879654,
-0.8506268262863159,
-0.08220239728689194,
-0.08293736726045609,
0.14878682792186737,
-0.30938994884490967,
-0.11577383428812027,
0.5074273347854614,
-0.24856983125209808,
-0.5770267844200134,
0.12059462815523148,
0.2142677903175354,
-0.2844212055206299,
-0.034876611083745956,
0.19741645455360413,
-0.2552710473537445,
0.03905466943979263,
0.47990521788597107,
0.4486650228500366,
-0.7589981555938721,
-0.4222041368484497,
-0.22133809328079224,
-0.05042470991611481,
-0.1377614438533783,
0.9565065503120422,
-0.8014338612556458,
0.04276396706700325,
0.5996561646461487,
0.8866420388221741,
0.2728264331817627,
0.3309479057788849,
0.423292338848114,
-0.2728478014469147,
0.325361430644989,
0.3659072518348694,
0.6990261077880859,
0.3159416615962982,
0.2710168659687042,
0.45077240467071533,
0.38978275656700134,
-0.06911621987819672,
-0.6429303884506226,
0.5198253989219666,
-0.9563782215118408,
-0.7868394255638123,
0.9619423747062683,
-0.08575223386287689,
-0.2256128489971161,
-0.016876617446541786,
-0.21025261282920837,
-0.05696500465273857,
-0.383914053440094,
0.4363156855106354,
0.8273769021034241,
-0.4332643449306488,
-0.0849771797657013,
-0.7017879486083984,
0.5526005029678345,
0.6898135542869568,
-0.7932831048965454,
0.14856214821338654,
0.5921658873558044,
0.02043061889708042,
0.4670454263687134,
0.48655423521995544,
-0.0986049622297287,
0.23180046677589417,
0.07472217082977295,
-0.2833596169948578,
0.07051181048154831,
-0.24478526413440704,
-0.07380451261997223,
0.5007126331329346,
-0.13066324591636658,
0.16262051463127136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09588v2 | Emerging Opportunities of Using Large Language Models for Translation Between Drug Molecules and Indications | 2024-02-14T21:33:13 | 2024-02-16T20:55:08 | David Oniani, Jordan Hilsman, Chengxi Zang, Junmei Wang, Lianjin Cai, Jan Zawala, Yanshan Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | A drug molecule is a substance that changes the organism's mental or physical
state. Every approved drug has an indication, which refers to the therapeutic
use of that drug for treating a particular medical condition. While the Large
Language Model (LLM), a generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) technique, has
recently demonstrated effectiveness in translating between molecules and their
textual descriptions, there remains a gap in research regarding their
application in facilitating the translation between drug molecules and
indications, or vice versa, which could greatly benefit the drug discovery
process. The capability of generating a drug from a given indication would
allow for the discovery of drugs targeting specific diseases or targets and
ultimately provide patients with better treatments. In this paper, we first
propose a new task, which is the translation between drug molecules and
corresponding indications, and then test existing LLMs on this new task.
Specifically, we consider nine variations of the T5 LLM and evaluate them on
two public datasets obtained from ChEMBL and DrugBank. Our experiments show the
early results of using LLMs for this task and provide a perspective on the
state-of-the-art. We also emphasize the current limitations and discuss future
work that has the potential to improve the performance on this task. The
creation of molecules from indications, or vice versa, will allow for more
efficient targeting of diseases and significantly reduce the cost of drug
discovery, with the potential to revolutionize the field of drug discovery in
the era of generative AI. | [
0.05844225361943245,
-0.7550603151321411,
1.06549072265625,
-0.02554815635085106,
-0.08798601478338242,
0.051270175725221634,
-0.4998925030231476,
-0.5966600179672241,
0.13561834394931793,
0.4838819205760956,
-0.21870294213294983,
-0.7324197888374329,
-0.9372511506080627,
0.5099454522132874,
-0.5039390921592712,
0.9268720149993896,
-0.24400007724761963,
0.3795137107372284,
-0.2444671392440796,
-0.05102504417300224,
-0.35292989015579224,
-0.6258556246757507,
-0.532328188419342,
-0.644798219203949,
0.703953206539154,
0.02216222509741783,
0.27524450421333313,
0.5423448085784912,
0.9381009340286255,
0.370409220457077,
-0.08602822571992874,
0.01682872138917446,
-0.18662995100021362,
0.16114544868469238,
-0.3617199659347534,
-0.8077507615089417,
-0.48534858226776123,
-0.05409650504589081,
0.6931647658348083,
0.7622726559638977,
-0.18198071420192719,
-0.11998959630727768,
-0.31592610478401184,
0.5733146071434021,
-0.43002840876579285,
0.11126485466957092,
-0.4533747732639313,
0.3548075556755066,
-0.32945746183395386,
0.02595110610127449,
-0.18217575550079346,
-0.1095094233751297,
0.34702402353286743,
-0.47358763217926025,
0.2049579620361328,
0.09780693054199219,
0.9052509665489197,
0.24626751244068146,
-0.3462912440299988,
-0.6480661630630493,
-0.8106335997581482,
0.8438190817832947,
-0.9940367937088013,
0.4177160859107971,
-0.16370026767253876,
0.6298258900642395,
-0.7755025625228882,
-0.9303743839263916,
-0.40459415316581726,
-0.649968147277832,
0.01778254844248295,
-0.1296951025724411,
-0.20516200363636017,
0.10030744969844818,
0.18464802205562592,
0.4823949933052063,
-0.2933019995689392,
0.32987314462661743,
-0.3957078754901886,
-0.29943087697029114,
0.3928491175174713,
0.26024875044822693,
0.6337352991104126,
-0.1690329760313034,
-0.589547336101532,
0.24266859889030457,
-1.0208299160003662,
-0.27054354548454285,
-0.24676217138767242,
0.3858310580253601,
-0.06214352324604988,
0.8559796810150146,
-0.19755378365516663,
0.6634598970413208,
-0.0590161457657814,
-0.15278233587741852,
0.1035580188035965,
-0.42537087202072144,
-0.43489789962768555,
0.2925274968147278,
1.0002543926239014,
0.3694649934768677,
-0.042391471564769745,
-0.049358464777469635,
-0.4146369993686676,
-0.06521133333444595,
0.01646452024579048,
-0.9629160165786743,
-0.05021820589900017,
0.6562359929084778,
-0.567123532295227,
-0.38233187794685364,
-0.29861214756965637,
-0.7911558747291565,
-0.6166644096374512,
-0.13442261517047882,
0.3768855631351471,
-0.5549328327178955,
-0.0695013627409935,
0.22311970591545105,
-0.029407590627670288,
0.12747535109519958,
0.3420100212097168,
-0.970040500164032,
0.037917837500572205,
0.6490097045898438,
0.8428000211715698,
-0.4105595052242279,
-0.19543008506298065,
-0.4596165716648102,
0.46753963828086853,
-0.602952241897583,
0.9649169445037842,
-0.5330817699432373,
-0.517916202545166,
0.057741884142160416,
-0.17473427951335907,
0.08769958466291428,
-0.8515371084213257,
0.36406832933425903,
-0.26127541065216064,
0.022206367924809456,
-0.2745340168476105,
-0.6699315905570984,
-0.11210953444242477,
0.3977755010128021,
-0.7823917865753174,
0.3457706868648529,
0.11950072646141052,
-0.20153649151325226,
0.362962543964386,
-0.8904086351394653,
-0.38290777802467346,
0.12449966371059418,
-0.21600832045078278,
-0.24092818796634674,
0.39011621475219727,
0.10968063026666641,
0.368415892124176,
-0.611946702003479,
0.4940221309661865,
0.0369136743247509,
-0.16593199968338013,
0.8661553859710693,
-0.28258252143859863,
0.499424546957016,
0.37081387639045715,
-0.17197732627391815,
0.2730253040790558,
-0.36252346634864807,
-0.3083288073539734,
0.014927828684449196,
-0.6299428939819336,
-0.10368292033672333,
-0.026013169437646866,
0.02399132028222084,
0.2124961018562317,
0.5031317472457886,
-0.5112113356590271,
0.5201566815376282,
-0.39144691824913025,
0.7409080266952515,
0.5903627872467041,
0.111382856965065,
0.24708601832389832,
-0.018915319815278053,
0.6075509190559387,
0.23565062880516052,
0.01168886385858059,
-0.15775759518146515,
-0.5540367364883423,
-0.5706128478050232,
-0.29971227049827576,
0.6823385953903198,
0.44293197989463806,
-0.6223915815353394,
0.21833781898021698,
-0.37810298800468445,
-0.10418340563774109,
-0.48748940229415894,
0.24783708155155182,
0.3281678259372711,
0.12249387800693512,
0.3898680806159973,
-0.13242357969284058,
-0.3522580564022064,
-0.8581323027610779,
-0.30834224820137024,
-0.03616372123360634,
-0.07629375904798508,
0.24974611401557922,
0.5793666243553162,
-0.6367470622062683,
0.45350754261016846,
-0.5332542061805725,
-0.6333374977111816,
-0.5635865330696106,
-0.2495449036359787,
0.25965332984924316,
0.15088586509227753,
0.3512952923774719,
-0.7860904932022095,
-0.36371779441833496,
0.33498257398605347,
-0.8499025106430054,
-0.19618168473243713,
-0.07078182697296143,
-0.19668032228946686,
0.07581494748592377,
0.7372484803199768,
-0.8589761853218079,
0.0394488163292408,
0.513229250907898,
0.001771276816725731,
0.1001555398106575,
-0.43482887744903564,
0.056787434965372086,
-1.1959397792816162,
0.08802909404039383,
0.16391320526599884,
-0.0916818305850029,
-0.9235774874687195,
0.006539225112646818,
-0.14346493780612946,
-0.13344694674015045,
-0.5232112407684326,
0.6824852228164673,
-0.44402796030044556,
0.13353580236434937,
-0.31950414180755615,
0.09411878883838654,
-0.0664144903421402,
0.017072230577468872,
-0.06374946236610413,
0.5698598623275757,
0.4190937876701355,
-0.5330994129180908,
0.57967609167099,
0.15544453263282776,
-0.363717645406723,
0.3297361135482788,
-0.5275355577468872,
-0.19162417948246002,
0.10361260175704956,
0.3572596311569214,
-0.5840103030204773,
-0.6071234941482544,
0.6281847953796387,
-0.3447602689266205,
0.4276096522808075,
-0.002903801156207919,
-0.4673924148082733,
-0.3750652074813843,
0.11198815703392029,
0.37416431307792664,
0.5726411938667297,
-0.30890870094299316,
0.6008346676826477,
0.29167893528938293,
-0.11426694691181183,
-0.31802666187286377,
-0.7821429371833801,
0.3011569678783417,
-0.35981446504592896,
-0.25267651677131653,
0.4848670959472656,
0.26382535696029663,
-0.32477867603302,
0.11673717945814133,
0.04219050705432892,
0.1363544464111328,
-0.09597288072109222,
-0.06852121651172638,
0.3829652965068817,
-0.15815502405166626,
0.2522081136703491,
0.12524110078811646,
-0.2014954537153244,
0.11689788848161697,
-0.5190690755844116,
0.43306082487106323,
0.07281576097011566,
-0.17458723485469818,
-0.28901416063308716,
0.5862647294998169,
0.6637499332427979,
-0.36758852005004883,
0.5681899189949036,
0.2932516038417816,
-0.39006689190864563,
-0.2537941038608551,
-0.18928292393684387,
-0.03577937185764313,
-0.44595101475715637,
0.5236185193061829,
-0.30011534690856934,
-0.53022301197052,
0.2772671580314636,
-0.59649658203125,
-0.30440694093704224,
0.3031943440437317,
0.9875568747520447,
0.16839659214019775,
0.8284299969673157,
0.5054500102996826,
0.0734788328409195,
0.25666654109954834,
-0.22174464166164398,
0.588741660118103,
-0.9474002718925476,
-0.4645804762840271,
-0.29964643716812134,
-0.2659146189689636,
-0.7458529472351074,
-0.8391878604888916,
0.7309229969978333,
-0.12689509987831116,
0.09686526656150818,
0.17426951229572296,
-0.3446846306324005,
0.14754150807857513,
0.47225502133369446,
0.12056449800729752,
0.2418510764837265,
-0.04267575964331627,
-0.04083380475640297,
0.1890886127948761,
-0.6235014200210571,
-0.47138622403144836,
1.4184746742248535,
0.20690079033374786,
0.3895934224128723,
0.15354008972644806,
0.6409448981285095,
0.29732346534729004,
0.633644700050354,
-1.0007325410842896,
0.7368617653846741,
-0.36030828952789307,
-0.6006904244422913,
-0.15675291419029236,
-0.3192604184150696,
-1.0774600505828857,
-0.1295691430568695,
-0.39040490984916687,
-0.5189933180809021,
0.2663354277610779,
0.09020525217056274,
-0.22598379850387573,
0.23860949277877808,
-0.6283749341964722,
0.7701477408409119,
-0.6826512813568115,
-0.0915621966123581,
-0.21198928356170654,
-0.5229610204696655,
0.10635444521903992,
-0.29517513513565063,
0.040079861879348755,
-0.3407585620880127,
-0.08381770551204681,
0.38146623969078064,
-0.2642471492290497,
0.6105988621711731,
-0.09412103146314621,
-0.6320187449455261,
0.18031606078147888,
-0.3207421600818634,
0.39907601475715637,
-0.2679601311683655,
-0.12147149443626404,
0.37799307703971863,
-0.25232359766960144,
-0.3942469656467438,
-0.7607246041297913,
0.6482449769973755,
-0.43166112899780273,
-0.7250002026557922,
-0.4570339024066925,
-0.6739919781684875,
-0.08661478757858276,
0.43197062611579895,
0.3215290307998657,
0.23281006515026093,
-0.281371146440506,
-0.09127692133188248,
0.4491651654243469,
-0.6100221276283264,
0.02801344357430935,
0.6121765375137329,
-0.5057238340377808,
-0.20387889444828033,
0.987016499042511,
-0.1559896022081375,
0.4126087427139282,
0.8319870829582214,
0.30503055453300476,
-0.31602567434310913,
-1.1008058786392212,
-0.45732131600379944,
0.23902757465839386,
-0.5103821754455566,
-0.20225264132022858,
-0.20375663042068481,
-0.04598580300807953,
-0.43636494874954224,
-0.04465942829847336,
-0.36723974347114563,
-0.09636082500219345,
0.16946189105510712,
0.11557680368423462,
0.2833828330039978,
0.7330060005187988,
-0.07306569069623947,
-0.17541657388210297,
-0.8658295273780823,
0.5601297616958618,
-0.08334887772798538,
0.2653379440307617,
-0.25217360258102417,
-0.0072446558624506,
-0.4596326947212219,
0.36335501074790955,
-0.11181614547967911,
-0.7464526891708374,
0.394502729177475,
0.1826840043067932,
0.6448220014572144,
0.603179931640625,
-0.3260756731033325,
0.16227683424949646,
-0.717424750328064,
0.6067802309989929,
0.19923552870750427,
-0.7550305724143982,
0.7805027365684509,
-0.5159264802932739,
0.082347072660923,
0.15160784125328064,
0.40821436047554016,
-0.6858232021331787,
-0.342896968126297,
-0.2048163264989853,
-0.9121227264404297,
0.3295397460460663,
0.3344669044017792,
0.010661836713552475,
0.05494014546275139,
0.4999026656150818,
0.014388380572199821,
0.29738253355026245,
-0.37580448389053345,
-0.2276538759469986,
0.06635202467441559,
-0.24006906151771545,
-0.07413727790117264,
0.03327611833810806,
-0.4362383782863617,
0.09192995727062225,
0.41991138458251953,
0.02402641624212265,
0.6964349150657654,
0.21988753974437714,
0.04468446969985962,
0.04809650033712387,
0.5136198401451111,
0.5843347907066345,
0.38365933299064636,
-0.13350018858909607,
-0.14709536731243134,
-0.15708142518997192,
-0.642855703830719,
0.30176591873168945,
0.4081901013851166,
-0.4182969927787781,
-0.20577536523342133,
0.46981462836265564,
0.5999498963356018,
-0.3451811373233795,
-1.0918728113174438,
0.1568223387002945,
0.282715767621994,
0.0043977233581244946,
-0.2929413616657257,
0.162827268242836,
-0.059834349900484085,
0.5156204104423523,
0.13311396539211273,
-0.09637095779180527,
0.32161498069763184,
-0.8360011577606201,
-0.11837178468704224,
0.4652538299560547,
-0.22079668939113617,
-0.17862433195114136,
0.6309996247291565,
0.26092633605003357,
-0.49869945645332336,
0.6944263577461243,
-0.032614704221487045,
-0.5215514898300171,
0.6951675415039062,
0.6560981869697571,
0.8683998584747314,
-0.44163867831230164,
0.15235882997512817,
0.04659049212932587,
-0.060265496373176575,
0.024292508140206337,
-0.1427268385887146,
0.26769351959228516,
-0.8779683709144592,
-0.23546487092971802,
-0.5507652759552002,
-0.4615529477596283,
0.10858389735221863,
-0.2593008577823639,
0.3519054651260376,
-0.19857874512672424,
-0.18027454614639282,
0.4338306188583374,
-0.20340308547019958,
-0.25245630741119385,
0.14834566414356232,
0.28170591592788696,
0.5306794047355652,
-0.7774167656898499,
1.021718978881836,
1.0067310333251953,
-0.3640410602092743,
-0.608062207698822,
0.19190523028373718,
0.03606906533241272,
-0.5898116827011108,
0.6595789790153503,
-0.017540523782372475,
0.020441869273781776,
-0.2932140529155731,
-0.3646220862865448,
-0.9363785982131958,
1.2419638633728027,
0.20695267617702484,
-0.6518309712409973,
-0.1969950795173645,
0.617310106754303,
0.8600243926048279,
-0.679796040058136,
-0.19682976603507996,
0.8279178738594055,
0.6044400930404663,
0.09394415467977524,
-0.7357934713363647,
0.21709537506103516,
-0.3759494423866272,
0.1975669413805008,
0.447676420211792,
-0.4691791534423828,
0.8717340230941772,
-0.5061568021774292,
0.06469413638114929,
0.4862842559814453,
0.384438693523407,
0.3525497019290924,
0.35537126660346985,
0.09003940224647522,
0.349007785320282,
0.7075038552284241,
-0.2507261335849762,
1.2789925336837769,
-0.27906402945518494,
0.28335943818092346,
0.6555324792861938,
-0.5180809497833252,
0.7338032126426697,
0.5674693584442139,
-0.39437276124954224,
0.5332239866256714,
0.5627849102020264,
-0.5055279731750488,
0.5422202944755554,
0.4759233891963959,
-0.6075182557106018,
-0.12379825115203857,
-0.30215486884117126,
-0.22206047177314758,
0.3642657697200775,
0.9773266911506653,
-0.6026285290718079,
-0.04065992310643196,
0.31371620297431946,
-0.05227448791265488,
-0.062189046293497086,
-0.2720349431037903,
0.5924481749534607,
0.410165399312973,
-0.6578648090362549,
0.43693071603775024,
0.3579872250556946,
0.15526100993156433,
-0.6645287871360779,
-0.30622315406799316,
-0.1956409513950348,
0.3714386522769928,
-0.08325761556625366,
-0.38401561975479126,
-0.10849177092313766,
-0.07586728781461716,
0.02503349632024765,
0.131578728556633,
0.6702760457992554,
-0.5803727507591248,
-0.66716068983078,
0.31869038939476013,
0.2710484564304352,
0.26534751057624817,
0.27438318729400635,
-0.5791072249412537,
0.08110397309064865,
0.013120354153215885,
0.09163547307252884,
0.2737908959388733,
0.757064938545227,
-0.14389073848724365,
0.8924441933631897,
0.6189520359039307,
0.5519899129867554,
-0.14757685363292694,
-0.10919538140296936,
0.7490624785423279,
-0.6558523178100586,
0.06018733233213425,
-0.7922369837760925,
0.1653144359588623,
0.1186894103884697,
-0.02072524093091488,
0.6564800143241882,
0.582709014415741,
0.37455907464027405,
-0.20950742065906525,
0.9098082780838013,
-0.037552449852228165,
0.2865161597728729,
-0.867963969707489,
0.4603950083255768,
-0.5284891724586487,
0.5688629746437073,
-0.098817840218544,
-0.7955446243286133,
-0.44328269362449646,
0.28014475107192993,
-0.32984021306037903,
0.10000917315483093,
0.9115387797355652,
0.627677321434021,
0.17456699907779694,
-0.28317996859550476,
0.1467687487602234,
0.6319835782051086,
0.6211709380149841,
1.1047688722610474,
0.7635660767555237,
-0.3823736310005188,
0.37981751561164856,
-0.016383405774831772,
0.13378211855888367,
-0.37606072425842285,
-0.67964768409729,
-0.7966980338096619,
-0.26727986335754395,
-0.17964042723178864,
-0.5346805453300476,
0.23093652725219727,
1.0796849727630615,
0.34999096393585205,
-1.015598177909851,
-0.25214993953704834,
-0.27654731273651123,
0.02273796871304512,
-0.19726282358169556,
-0.08127108216285706,
0.4480735659599304,
-0.10592084378004074,
-1.0358023643493652,
0.40846478939056396,
0.4738541841506958,
0.30334746837615967,
-0.38122284412384033,
0.00676679378375411,
-0.19207456707954407,
-0.017801351845264435,
0.741723358631134,
0.25921398401260376,
-0.825773298740387,
-0.06389046460390091,
0.09132058918476105,
-0.1535460650920868,
0.09593304991722107,
1.1432887315750122,
-0.5967521071434021,
0.4021158814430237,
0.28731122612953186,
0.6258071660995483,
0.39603352546691895,
-0.09289848059415817,
1.1713347434997559,
0.01154208742082119,
0.014352666214108467,
0.3321478068828583,
0.277365505695343,
0.356781542301178,
-0.3486005365848541,
0.4569999575614929,
0.013285569846630096,
-0.4103550910949707,
-0.5795297622680664,
0.3323071002960205,
-0.859853982925415,
-0.4980926513671875,
1.3447107076644897,
-0.21862417459487915,
-0.28532901406288147,
-0.03923704847693443,
-0.12081822007894516,
0.19968979060649872,
-0.42914479970932007,
0.9262375235557556,
0.6055876016616821,
-0.33067870140075684,
0.1896287500858307,
-0.7806586027145386,
0.6084017753601074,
0.25712960958480835,
-0.9918967485427856,
-0.02300327457487583,
0.6038123965263367,
0.10097062587738037,
0.32427942752838135,
0.696282684803009,
-0.4388110637664795,
0.14878766238689423,
-0.25546035170555115,
0.03718001767992973,
0.23548206686973572,
-0.32663238048553467,
-0.2994465231895447,
-0.08702898770570755,
0.16041946411132812,
-0.0868765190243721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09573v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09573v2 | Changes by Butterflies: Farsighted Forecasting with Group Reservoir Transformer | 2024-02-14T20:48:58 | 2024-06-13T21:22:02 | Md Kowsher, Abdul Rafae Khan, Jia Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In Chaos, a minor divergence between two initial conditions exhibits
exponential amplification over time, leading to far-away outcomes, known as the
butterfly effect. Thus, the distant future is full of uncertainty and hard to
forecast. We introduce Group Reservoir Transformer to predict long-term events
more accurately and robustly by overcoming two challenges in Chaos: (1) the
extensive historical sequences and (2) the sensitivity to initial conditions. A
reservoir is attached to a Transformer to efficiently handle arbitrarily long
historical lengths, with an extension of a group of reservoirs to reduce the
sensitivity to the initialization variations. Our architecture consistently
outperforms state-of-the-art models in multivariate time series, including
TimeLLM, GPT2TS, PatchTST, DLinear, TimeNet, and the baseline Transformer, with
an error reduction of up to -59\% in various fields such as ETTh, ETTm, and air
quality, demonstrating that an ensemble of butterfly learning can improve the
adequacy and certainty of event prediction, despite of the traveling time to
the unknown future. | [
-0.524154543876648,
-0.13283073902130127,
0.3348867893218994,
0.4250606298446655,
-0.2771591246128082,
0.021406345069408417,
0.2837158143520355,
-0.5486356616020203,
0.45510339736938477,
0.39983969926834106,
-0.9911873936653137,
0.019978580996394157,
-0.7528907060623169,
0.07722987234592438,
-0.46200767159461975,
0.983630359172821,
0.0553017221391201,
-0.18434005975723267,
0.7718777060508728,
0.33511364459991455,
-0.06103266030550003,
-0.16885536909103394,
-0.5043998956680298,
-0.4169311225414276,
0.7481170296669006,
-0.22149725258350372,
0.8955849409103394,
0.555485725402832,
0.6326873302459717,
0.2824527621269226,
-0.12041232734918594,
0.10500692576169968,
-0.5796627998352051,
0.2587961256504059,
0.1221918836236,
-0.492693156003952,
0.06087120622396469,
-0.46051305532455444,
0.49187326431274414,
0.5791416764259338,
-0.23658351600170135,
-0.099188432097435,
0.02788613736629486,
0.8249820470809937,
-0.7507830858230591,
0.408610075712204,
-0.5685406923294067,
0.4917904734611511,
-0.10459725558757782,
-0.30520695447921753,
-0.33208948373794556,
-0.08714018762111664,
0.2998364269733429,
-0.8213171362876892,
0.41062983870506287,
-0.017347736284136772,
0.7105222940444946,
0.5309211015701294,
-0.592627763748169,
0.04712355509400368,
-1.1240822076797485,
0.8529229164123535,
-0.20644429326057434,
0.7923229336738586,
0.05283329635858536,
0.6264129877090454,
-0.3748314678668976,
-0.7650038003921509,
-0.41209709644317627,
0.38267892599105835,
0.2995799481868744,
0.6456124186515808,
-0.4615868330001831,
-0.22390548884868622,
0.01811389811336994,
0.21068990230560303,
-0.33137592673301697,
0.18453319370746613,
-0.6089064478874207,
-0.05887250602245331,
0.46753808856010437,
0.5144913792610168,
-0.3269210159778595,
-0.21901844441890717,
-0.38213974237442017,
-0.26898014545440674,
-0.5089197754859924,
0.3147297501564026,
0.3744320571422577,
0.6806634068489075,
-0.026110736653208733,
0.18713122606277466,
0.12453380227088928,
0.33880841732025146,
0.4801391363143921,
0.009892765432596207,
-0.17282046377658844,
0.37872689962387085,
-0.25142648816108704,
-0.15468578040599823,
0.42678701877593994,
0.5794433355331421,
-0.3166099786758423,
-0.550312876701355,
-0.0929839164018631,
-0.1315665990114212,
-0.01117004919797182,
-0.9942585229873657,
-0.3946385979652405,
-0.014708034694194794,
-0.43352994322776794,
-0.3107694387435913,
0.06092998385429382,
-1.4774091243743896,
-0.7838467955589294,
-0.17926080524921417,
0.28781914710998535,
-0.22464829683303833,
-0.23540672659873962,
-0.026511117815971375,
-0.3240739107131958,
0.1321469396352768,
0.37290191650390625,
-1.1374754905700684,
0.06885816156864166,
0.6772344708442688,
1.0203269720077515,
-0.19042827188968658,
-0.39188170433044434,
-0.20630401372909546,
0.5693817734718323,
-0.4409022033214569,
1.0270476341247559,
-0.12903372943401337,
-0.8340880870819092,
-0.0786907970905304,
-0.02208307757973671,
0.10986124724149704,
-0.47268834710121155,
0.11912186443805695,
-0.6286259293556213,
-0.0012216040631756186,
0.04893992468714714,
-0.15689048171043396,
-0.16372278332710266,
-0.15664705634117126,
-0.8852342367172241,
0.39218786358833313,
0.22446395456790924,
-0.361392617225647,
0.7795208692550659,
-0.6905612349510193,
-0.31525155901908875,
-0.4612784683704376,
0.3149106800556183,
-0.8171350955963135,
0.2965370714664459,
0.5436791777610779,
0.4649697542190552,
-0.008785479702055454,
0.2914075255393982,
-0.7031356692314148,
-0.3263612389564514,
0.2748069167137146,
-0.5924543142318726,
0.638032078742981,
0.20027576386928558,
0.20085547864437103,
0.059170544147491455,
-0.7447102665901184,
-0.296625018119812,
-0.2653672695159912,
0.06390026956796646,
-0.13540658354759216,
0.3404892385005951,
0.25803765654563904,
0.1168169304728508,
-0.4117746651172638,
-0.10079015791416168,
0.5554026961326599,
-0.4840173125267029,
0.6332648992538452,
1.301670789718628,
0.5065178275108337,
0.47239214181900024,
-0.3909991383552551,
0.4458448886871338,
0.51533043384552,
0.9212808609008789,
-0.20560158789157867,
-0.4133695960044861,
-0.6631513237953186,
-0.4016376733779907,
-0.2703024744987488,
0.3402289152145386,
-0.48525187373161316,
0.1817934662103653,
-0.4840295910835266,
-0.7516434788703918,
-0.11224713176488876,
-0.11184407770633698,
-0.6538670063018799,
0.09074759483337402,
0.615911602973938,
0.1816728115081787,
-0.8690019249916077,
-0.536965012550354,
-0.2093122899532318,
-0.08020160347223282,
-0.1084117665886879,
-0.23551245033740997,
0.3366066515445709,
-0.5522357225418091,
0.9563358426094055,
-0.8394527435302734,
-0.2321123480796814,
0.2991715371608734,
0.43196189403533936,
0.7352414727210999,
0.12420486658811569,
0.49255672097206116,
-0.9758150577545166,
-0.25747793912887573,
-0.13800261914730072,
-0.4333959221839905,
0.440159410238266,
-0.09397659450769424,
0.24251317977905273,
0.19931045174598694,
0.15343081951141357,
-0.5436874032020569,
0.4788168668746948,
0.7209908366203308,
0.09440770745277405,
0.25920215249061584,
0.2206227332353592,
0.22880464792251587,
-1.4443390369415283,
-0.38773953914642334,
-0.15545803308486938,
0.40230831503868103,
-0.5359159111976624,
-0.4458877444267273,
-0.020444344729185104,
-0.3194558620452881,
-0.23083674907684326,
0.21624362468719482,
-0.3534696102142334,
0.2205694168806076,
0.004068367183208466,
-0.719355046749115,
-0.43090394139289856,
0.17509636282920837,
-0.13780970871448517,
0.6677250862121582,
0.656010627746582,
-0.6999537348747253,
0.4069094657897949,
0.12752941250801086,
-0.24127833545207977,
0.027254750952124596,
-0.1520697921514511,
0.07614006847143173,
-0.18347908556461334,
0.33167657256126404,
-0.6583443284034729,
-0.15290480852127075,
0.08939988166093826,
-0.3034634590148926,
0.5510220527648926,
-0.11363597959280014,
-0.03412249684333801,
-0.8156757354736328,
-0.43515437841415405,
0.0048499805852770805,
0.42591774463653564,
-0.7321780323982239,
1.1979999542236328,
-0.18917642533779144,
-0.030489016324281693,
-0.9371888637542725,
-0.9313755631446838,
0.13491322100162506,
-0.45849665999412537,
-0.2840290069580078,
-0.039054565131664276,
0.053736038506031036,
-0.14750118553638458,
-0.11992073804140091,
-0.3474900722503662,
-0.6128243207931519,
0.07496973872184753,
0.8004724383354187,
0.31801605224609375,
-0.16382260620594025,
0.28855010867118835,
0.0770125612616539,
-0.36826273798942566,
-0.10150603950023651,
-0.5923384428024292,
0.2363852560520172,
0.15699777007102966,
-0.32569679617881775,
-0.22731395065784454,
0.4674805700778961,
0.6317948698997498,
0.09965742379426956,
0.8101955056190491,
0.3448152244091034,
-0.40613850951194763,
-0.29094600677490234,
-0.3165997266769409,
-0.514177680015564,
-0.5018010139465332,
0.571624755859375,
-0.3351821303367615,
-0.9908656477928162,
0.964107096195221,
-0.23393018543720245,
-0.1291724145412445,
0.6445070505142212,
0.27966365218162537,
-0.18832626938819885,
0.6498597264289856,
0.8156653046607971,
-0.5145295262336731,
0.5970587134361267,
-0.3860488533973694,
0.5033703446388245,
-0.5603948831558228,
-0.18497124314308167,
-0.38234999775886536,
-0.16943074762821198,
-0.7869896292686462,
-0.3333338797092438,
0.5169742703437805,
0.22467413544654846,
-0.41543343663215637,
0.15881288051605225,
-0.4330604374408722,
0.2725045382976532,
-0.03792790696024895,
0.2159944325685501,
0.23869188129901886,
-0.052405428141355515,
0.5934139490127563,
-0.327567458152771,
-0.3656681180000305,
0.05617712438106537,
1.3544721603393555,
-0.010319049470126629,
0.9942697286605835,
0.19682981073856354,
0.8721472024917603,
0.34342315793037415,
0.8545767664909363,
-0.5227128863334656,
-0.0017167867626994848,
-0.08559241890907288,
-0.7275348901748657,
-0.4209842085838318,
-0.27884441614151,
-1.0239143371582031,
0.1243986040353775,
-0.2214234471321106,
-0.8995963931083679,
0.557762861251831,
0.27065983414649963,
-0.705140233039856,
0.6361645460128784,
-0.25503721833229065,
0.34443163871765137,
-0.11906656622886658,
-0.252541720867157,
-0.10566908121109009,
-0.4916367530822754,
0.27818429470062256,
-0.6531140208244324,
0.06119156628847122,
0.12160767614841461,
-0.23372088372707367,
0.10583782941102982,
-0.03587121516466141,
0.8574556112289429,
-0.1215069591999054,
0.02454792521893978,
0.1537618190050125,
0.057371143251657486,
0.5766613483428955,
0.013208714313805103,
-0.3225416839122772,
0.22444406151771545,
-0.3609021008014679,
-0.14709512889385223,
-0.8819787502288818,
0.5734448432922363,
-1.1028608083724976,
-0.5155959129333496,
-0.5209004282951355,
-0.5959265232086182,
-0.097508005797863,
-0.010963809676468372,
0.6150151491165161,
0.19495560228824615,
-0.1985984891653061,
0.0006986754015088081,
0.3999856114387512,
0.2388172298669815,
0.7863351106643677,
0.49442410469055176,
-0.5708198547363281,
-0.7804786562919617,
0.6503888964653015,
0.38720718026161194,
0.016140766441822052,
0.9059086441993713,
0.06784657388925552,
-0.42547905445098877,
-0.5772307515144348,
-0.030311111360788345,
-0.19989994168281555,
-0.5734360814094543,
-0.3866005539894104,
-0.33494943380355835,
0.04522167891263962,
-0.5001575350761414,
-0.21974508464336395,
-0.30925846099853516,
-0.2148868590593338,
-0.4451885521411896,
-0.10539243370294571,
0.20864292979240417,
0.8303294777870178,
-0.3600102961063385,
0.619382917881012,
-0.8609810471534729,
0.04330121725797653,
0.456240177154541,
0.2936049997806549,
-0.1702764332294464,
-0.31596362590789795,
-0.22687584161758423,
-0.06637179106473923,
-0.8609787225723267,
-1.1232562065124512,
0.44199517369270325,
0.15927118062973022,
0.3442354202270508,
0.9764161109924316,
0.04975654184818268,
1.1550909280776978,
-0.45819851756095886,
0.7064752578735352,
0.6759535074234009,
-1.0981552600860596,
0.4948112964630127,
-0.5486260652542114,
-0.03326364979147911,
-0.08431655168533325,
0.2726942002773285,
-0.41416844725608826,
-0.26494312286376953,
-0.48879173398017883,
-0.7453922033309937,
0.3523312509059906,
0.10760415345430374,
-0.11063353717327118,
0.38494443893432617,
0.5553516149520874,
0.20981404185295105,
0.2207821160554886,
-0.7683427333831787,
-0.2638646364212036,
-0.6492171883583069,
0.35781872272491455,
-0.7838762402534485,
-0.013805363327264786,
0.18397106230258942,
-0.20594429969787598,
0.6504979133605957,
-0.11821042746305466,
0.5454955697059631,
0.02856941893696785,
0.4575681686401367,
-0.7289931774139404,
0.2809450924396515,
0.6666321158409119,
0.6823646426200867,
-0.3280770182609558,
-0.14019784331321716,
0.5383912920951843,
-0.18226870894432068,
0.24234922230243683,
0.6641258597373962,
-0.020803555846214294,
-0.06312362849712372,
0.6267129778862,
0.7133567333221436,
0.02374206855893135,
0.07184486091136932,
0.11592137813568115,
0.08781743049621582,
0.12998613715171814,
-0.38335663080215454,
-0.15013998746871948,
0.09419422596693039,
0.7423568367958069,
0.9526882171630859,
0.5502671003341675,
0.39621710777282715,
-0.3143463134765625,
0.006916852667927742,
0.042976364493370056,
-0.6061439514160156,
-0.49391645193099976,
0.7566695809364319,
0.07548674196004868,
-0.13495919108390808,
0.5589975118637085,
0.2262926697731018,
-0.4609090983867645,
0.6297463774681091,
0.6255117654800415,
1.0000771284103394,
-0.9849956631660461,
-0.2725204527378082,
0.0844356119632721,
0.5931194424629211,
0.11845827102661133,
0.02534624934196472,
0.02338257059454918,
-0.5077300667762756,
-0.4877166748046875,
-0.4875103831291199,
-0.37584516406059265,
0.38164305686950684,
-0.8057475686073303,
0.23526491224765778,
-0.31964927911758423,
-0.48981544375419617,
0.21863427758216858,
-0.11174280941486359,
-0.3045852482318878,
0.030161308124661446,
-0.041356056928634644,
0.8620688915252686,
-1.2750017642974854,
0.5460854172706604,
0.5615785121917725,
-0.22689904272556305,
-0.914623498916626,
0.1383674293756485,
0.03382938355207443,
-0.5619876384735107,
0.4664384424686432,
0.14475210011005402,
-0.16116149723529816,
-0.2604976296424866,
-0.29021817445755005,
-0.6842870116233826,
1.2117799520492554,
0.38484901189804077,
-0.9211592674255371,
0.03112957254052162,
0.18473465740680695,
0.6187284588813782,
0.1093553677201271,
0.05718254670500755,
-0.05055534839630127,
0.6781710386276245,
0.11560601741075516,
-0.6517627835273743,
-0.5338013768196106,
0.054241638630628586,
0.2692553400993347,
0.9675582647323608,
-0.7678861618041992,
1.07961905002594,
-0.5672910213470459,
-0.08975810557603836,
0.3026898503303528,
1.082942008972168,
-0.32356542348861694,
0.5493105053901672,
0.427097350358963,
0.2922922968864441,
0.7197079658508301,
-0.5573651194572449,
0.7976782917976379,
-0.31940096616744995,
0.836937665939331,
0.8674769401550293,
-0.3728890120983124,
0.6463825106620789,
0.8949481844902039,
-0.6191632151603699,
0.32554247975349426,
0.8101916909217834,
-0.2939838767051697,
0.8781899213790894,
0.16485446691513062,
-0.40567806363105774,
-0.34250131249427795,
0.24866312742233276,
-0.7878550291061401,
0.2497822642326355,
0.22672639787197113,
-0.18807750940322876,
-0.4384801983833313,
0.31352564692497253,
-0.270829439163208,
-0.14322614669799805,
-0.46160855889320374,
0.387160986661911,
0.13531991839408875,
-0.3873909115791321,
-0.0013531600125133991,
-0.5410199761390686,
0.4295493960380554,
-0.7252733111381531,
-0.07507937401533127,
-0.12394119799137115,
0.8918442130088806,
-0.1709151566028595,
-0.7331308126449585,
0.4220654368400574,
-0.633654773235321,
-0.591838002204895,
-0.049478039145469666,
0.46816736459732056,
-0.11779778450727463,
-0.47685107588768005,
0.591693103313446,
0.1579122543334961,
-0.23568959534168243,
-0.23675940930843353,
-0.3423987627029419,
-0.031731199473142624,
-0.11031470447778702,
-0.38631290197372437,
-0.026702195405960083,
0.5326203107833862,
0.2304970920085907,
1.0798841714859009,
0.4811232089996338,
0.0748862698674202,
0.27547067403793335,
-0.30971041321754456,
0.9298107624053955,
-0.6882696151733398,
-0.7309858798980713,
-0.6771188974380493,
0.04851233586668968,
0.21859636902809143,
-0.2602567970752716,
0.40816155076026917,
0.9223394393920898,
0.2395511418581009,
-0.4711487293243408,
0.8084775805473328,
0.3483083248138428,
0.3561796545982361,
-0.13971476256847382,
0.6670947074890137,
-0.34158656001091003,
-0.1270291656255722,
-0.21162089705467224,
-0.8243585228919983,
-0.4146362841129303,
0.26736050844192505,
-0.231211856007576,
-0.0023591883946210146,
0.40676000714302063,
0.540759265422821,
-0.05296526476740837,
0.6490228772163391,
0.34568190574645996,
0.45562538504600525,
0.6823994517326355,
0.8174459934234619,
1.1825262308120728,
-0.433901846408844,
0.4501931369304657,
-0.4828380346298218,
-0.12963812053203583,
-0.11064097285270691,
-0.9826682806015015,
-0.6866310834884644,
-0.7790817618370056,
0.03427094966173172,
-0.2514399588108063,
0.6462599039077759,
0.8773679137229919,
0.7123708724975586,
-1.0880721807479858,
-0.22883471846580505,
-0.0021161839831620455,
-0.1377844512462616,
-0.5435745120048523,
-0.20899035036563873,
0.45403844118118286,
0.08583447337150574,
-0.5150386691093445,
0.21831880509853363,
0.5109935998916626,
0.5642340779304504,
-0.23397277295589447,
-0.13949593901634216,
0.23705027997493744,
-0.18406453728675842,
0.33836203813552856,
0.2479391098022461,
-0.708507776260376,
-0.47910094261169434,
-0.10025662928819656,
0.26109328866004944,
-0.14652173221111298,
0.5827440023422241,
-0.5741381049156189,
0.470651775598526,
-0.1389763206243515,
0.18069986999034882,
0.8350160121917725,
-0.49673697352409363,
0.47153401374816895,
-0.07397298514842987,
0.24279096722602844,
0.2720661759376526,
0.29196134209632874,
-0.051824335008859634,
-0.4607108533382416,
0.4181114435195923,
0.4438323676586151,
-0.6732484102249146,
-0.7280798554420471,
0.03543270379304886,
-0.9724024534225464,
-0.05026823282241821,
0.2807871699333191,
-0.0974598079919815,
0.02564607746899128,
0.00348694808781147,
0.18499638140201569,
0.7257655262947083,
-0.4348243176937103,
1.3146865367889404,
0.7847396731376648,
-0.5384107828140259,
-0.34957608580589294,
-0.12714910507202148,
0.2460406869649887,
-0.06905163824558258,
-0.7246732711791992,
-0.09258700162172318,
0.268878698348999,
0.3518439531326294,
0.5807215571403503,
-0.1097293570637703,
0.2067156732082367,
0.27292996644973755,
0.08092116564512253,
-0.027906183153390884,
-0.27081096172332764,
-0.5535585880279541,
-0.3807676136493683,
0.1812833696603775,
-0.3974279463291168,
-0.03916757181286812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09552v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09552v2 | STEER: Assessing the Economic Rationality of Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T20:05:26 | 2024-05-28T16:27:56 | Narun Raman, Taylor Lundy, Samuel Amouyal, Yoav Levine, Kevin Leyton-Brown, Moshe Tennenholtz | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | There is increasing interest in using LLMs as decision-making "agents." Doing
so includes many degrees of freedom: which model should be used; how should it
be prompted; should it be asked to introspect, conduct chain-of-thought
reasoning, etc? Settling these questions -- and more broadly, determining
whether an LLM agent is reliable enough to be trusted -- requires a methodology
for assessing such an agent's economic rationality. In this paper, we provide
one. We begin by surveying the economic literature on rational decision making,
taxonomizing a large set of fine-grained "elements" that an agent should
exhibit, along with dependencies between them. We then propose a benchmark
distribution that quantitatively scores an LLMs performance on these elements
and, combined with a user-provided rubric, produces a "STEER report card."
Finally, we describe the results of a large-scale empirical experiment with 14
different LLMs, characterizing the both current state of the art and the impact
of different model sizes on models' ability to exhibit rational behavior. | [
-0.5394892692565918,
-0.7901037931442261,
0.7275091409683228,
0.4005557894706726,
-0.0114994952455163,
-0.09406169503927231,
-0.37752074003219604,
-0.49149173498153687,
0.13988861441612244,
0.4859481751918793,
-0.35219892859458923,
-0.34685710072517395,
-0.45581838488578796,
0.09671512991189957,
-0.37616240978240967,
0.6426183581352234,
0.2023744285106659,
0.13744790852069855,
-0.20176975429058075,
-0.3068046569824219,
-0.3154613971710205,
-0.3021274507045746,
-0.8278632164001465,
-0.6826091408729553,
0.6021578907966614,
0.2614603042602539,
1.1617780923843384,
0.8111973404884338,
0.41623997688293457,
0.330842524766922,
0.10520853102207184,
-0.21727143228054047,
-0.4059518575668335,
0.27955591678619385,
-0.6061760783195496,
-0.518253743648529,
-0.6602373123168945,
0.5282122492790222,
0.5750529766082764,
0.5967468619346619,
-0.2561015188694,
0.23385843634605408,
-0.18950806558132172,
0.5711062550544739,
-0.6130343079566956,
0.31359991431236267,
-0.782008945941925,
-0.30783772468566895,
0.06213841959834099,
-0.2035861313343048,
-0.8123161196708679,
-0.644460916519165,
0.27438414096832275,
-0.6274906992912292,
-0.5016977787017822,
0.5855632424354553,
0.6708325743675232,
0.1946440190076828,
-0.6021906137466431,
-0.5456061363220215,
-0.6685821413993835,
1.0687503814697266,
-0.4349105656147003,
0.39828458428382874,
0.7387090921401978,
0.26188939809799194,
-0.1092706024646759,
-0.6158624887466431,
-0.2886393368244171,
-0.6723841428756714,
0.10233023762702942,
0.30716779828071594,
-0.34392014145851135,
0.029969260096549988,
0.35165366530418396,
0.09014259278774261,
-0.1335052251815796,
0.20999297499656677,
-0.029259558767080307,
-0.0618581660091877,
0.7615022659301758,
0.1769508570432663,
0.011004213243722916,
0.10260678827762604,
-0.5956190824508667,
-0.32584843039512634,
-0.6615089774131775,
-0.08951213955879211,
0.5520644783973694,
0.05165529251098633,
0.10537245124578476,
0.8461611270904541,
-0.2877809703350067,
0.33405593037605286,
0.1149662509560585,
-0.3981602191925049,
-0.14938116073608398,
-0.250847190618515,
-0.46362465620040894,
0.19390623271465302,
0.5348612070083618,
0.7330892086029053,
0.5835573673248291,
0.03100435622036457,
-0.7221884727478027,
0.08473983407020569,
0.22437414526939392,
-0.6473726034164429,
-0.004811728838831186,
0.2833680510520935,
-0.582269549369812,
-0.2903405427932739,
-0.2522445321083069,
-0.5925817489624023,
-0.4743512272834778,
-0.6661128401756287,
0.4528675973415375,
-0.44568267464637756,
-0.2579784095287323,
-0.021906085312366486,
-0.14074335992336273,
0.7435654401779175,
0.23473775386810303,
-0.7335736155509949,
0.33614662289619446,
0.7934382557868958,
0.546934962272644,
-0.20252735912799835,
-0.44259539246559143,
-0.6313726305961609,
0.022967463359236717,
-0.6699524521827698,
0.981414794921875,
-0.5646912455558777,
-0.516228437423706,
0.15955063700675964,
-0.13503041863441467,
-0.03228481486439705,
-0.5488394498825073,
0.3912828862667084,
-0.7348607778549194,
-0.1371166855096817,
-0.5448408722877502,
-0.8151141405105591,
-0.20477889478206635,
0.6825217008590698,
-0.6936737298965454,
0.709272027015686,
0.22612565755844116,
-0.640856146812439,
0.6353155970573425,
-0.447136253118515,
-0.21177755296230316,
0.0034875646233558655,
-0.027260761708021164,
0.012547391466796398,
0.038923170417547226,
-0.2639068067073822,
0.40223267674446106,
-0.5448188185691833,
0.5498375296592712,
-0.501364529132843,
0.1049816757440567,
0.8898923993110657,
-0.8033643960952759,
0.6988264322280884,
0.15055833756923676,
-0.11931777745485306,
0.37546855211257935,
-0.6898184418678284,
0.007097355090081692,
-0.031109845265746117,
-0.12319748848676682,
-0.4363544285297394,
0.2059491127729416,
-0.021521173417568207,
-0.06928519159555435,
0.21366436779499054,
-0.21326394379138947,
0.08907274901866913,
-0.21004562079906464,
0.2863686680793762,
0.8847445249557495,
-0.05585114657878876,
0.6180399656295776,
-0.8307353854179382,
0.5983167886734009,
-0.39849525690078735,
0.19797606766223907,
0.14101079106330872,
-0.2310778647661209,
-0.9140114784240723,
-0.3043340742588043,
0.43831008672714233,
0.4033362567424774,
-0.5421139597892761,
0.3361148536205292,
0.08868418633937836,
-0.6058493256568909,
-0.09496304392814636,
-0.23790034651756287,
0.018701180815696716,
0.29251769185066223,
0.05731356143951416,
-0.11028143018484116,
-0.10929068177938461,
-1.0887922048568726,
-0.18732938170433044,
-0.4015131890773773,
0.15180523693561554,
0.144017294049263,
0.6883248090744019,
-0.32255491614341736,
1.1270334720611572,
-0.2972268760204315,
-0.003114239778369665,
-0.33251646161079407,
0.11589309573173523,
-0.12564721703529358,
0.4056953489780426,
0.47387605905532837,
-0.39977598190307617,
-0.22728419303894043,
0.14781060814857483,
-0.47748634219169617,
-0.15046802163124084,
-0.24332474172115326,
-0.41008010506629944,
0.36828553676605225,
0.27446579933166504,
-0.7382772564888,
0.2134087085723877,
0.47249317169189453,
-0.43017467856407166,
0.7654712200164795,
-0.5274644494056702,
-0.20549894869327545,
-0.6093940138816833,
0.15462057292461395,
0.30034324526786804,
-0.21490727365016937,
-0.2977374494075775,
-0.025477705523371696,
-0.08983951061964035,
0.536449670791626,
-0.25690722465515137,
0.6326587200164795,
-0.2038782835006714,
-0.41998353600502014,
-0.2694506049156189,
0.33065447211265564,
-0.1007399782538414,
0.04774262756109238,
-0.005148937460035086,
0.8628060221672058,
0.40564629435539246,
-0.5503419041633606,
0.3925207853317261,
-0.14329038560390472,
-0.4424085021018982,
0.988278329372406,
-0.7549018263816833,
-0.13905730843544006,
-0.07483600080013275,
0.000459048809716478,
-0.6713873744010925,
-0.3595500886440277,
0.11511744558811188,
-0.03743306174874306,
0.11461549252271652,
-0.051412433385849,
-0.33770251274108887,
0.26413169503211975,
-0.2506345808506012,
0.11508788168430328,
0.6556374430656433,
-0.3240365982055664,
0.8838949799537659,
0.5148072242736816,
-0.3652547597885132,
-0.31502899527549744,
-0.25975269079208374,
-0.1876428723335266,
-0.48167431354522705,
-0.6203033328056335,
-0.09408853203058243,
-0.1535429209470749,
-1.113147497177124,
-0.022833202034235,
-0.1044669821858406,
-0.0047315689735114574,
0.25318607687950134,
-0.03585348650813103,
0.3316047191619873,
-0.10549823194742203,
0.03016778454184532,
0.08471203595399857,
-0.4055548906326294,
0.6175535321235657,
-0.13642308115959167,
0.38334518671035767,
-0.33903831243515015,
-0.25767970085144043,
-0.0602436438202858,
0.03820110484957695,
0.853175163269043,
-0.40523356199264526,
0.47744205594062805,
-0.002302704146131873,
-0.23061072826385498,
-0.57295823097229,
-0.7002245783805847,
0.0514216274023056,
-0.46762213110923767,
0.10536585748195648,
-0.20868200063705444,
-0.44467613101005554,
0.49592867493629456,
-0.2862340211868286,
0.033698175102472305,
0.5004236698150635,
0.7635400295257568,
-0.020684482529759407,
1.0058215856552124,
0.48234325647354126,
0.06392382085323334,
0.1140475943684578,
-0.20135276019573212,
-0.0429203137755394,
-0.5573212504386902,
-0.5144549608230591,
-0.5825867056846619,
-0.14494146406650543,
-0.5162764191627502,
-0.5523755550384521,
0.1262761503458023,
-0.06257101148366928,
-0.4989863634109497,
-0.05351264029741287,
-0.032935626804828644,
0.5773860812187195,
0.6682400107383728,
-0.42036792635917664,
0.5187383890151978,
-0.312145471572876,
-0.19855064153671265,
0.272733598947525,
-0.3883804678916931,
-1.090239405632019,
0.9709025621414185,
0.5800865888595581,
1.0626888275146484,
0.014993051998317242,
0.3447866439819336,
0.37737035751342773,
0.840911865234375,
-1.2497360706329346,
0.7017185688018799,
0.30293792486190796,
-0.5114226937294006,
-0.418473482131958,
-0.26122117042541504,
-0.9960674047470093,
0.5274015665054321,
-0.35358285903930664,
-0.4499061107635498,
0.07421604543924332,
0.04771369695663452,
-0.14629733562469482,
0.016040025278925896,
-0.5343332290649414,
0.6994720101356506,
-0.727717399597168,
-0.3025023937225342,
-0.3406573534011841,
-0.3257844150066376,
0.49430733919143677,
-0.3154284358024597,
0.26508721709251404,
-0.4247613847255707,
-0.3598225712776184,
0.7954864501953125,
-0.21289151906967163,
0.5840036869049072,
0.00931631401181221,
-0.1865449696779251,
0.2547531723976135,
0.2814899981021881,
0.5579140186309814,
0.19789403676986694,
-0.23197829723358154,
-0.11944672465324402,
0.2678214907646179,
-0.12275059521198273,
-0.4476414918899536,
0.6019169092178345,
-0.7913588285446167,
-0.6056330800056458,
-0.6942389011383057,
-0.6859331727027893,
-0.44983789324760437,
0.3603774309158325,
-0.02015281282365322,
0.34089577198028564,
-0.5180923342704773,
0.40779614448547363,
0.5276968479156494,
-0.10596027225255966,
0.36539795994758606,
0.5499073266983032,
-0.6002259850502014,
-0.5761645436286926,
0.6223204135894775,
0.31064602732658386,
0.415772944688797,
-0.00850419607013464,
0.41423270106315613,
-0.663443386554718,
-0.49914899468421936,
-0.2550412118434906,
0.23217949271202087,
-0.7238172292709351,
-0.17679975926876068,
-0.2395469844341278,
0.05864620953798294,
0.14241698384284973,
-0.30188053846359253,
-0.5235204696655273,
-0.03777296096086502,
-0.16683250665664673,
-0.31654730439186096,
0.289750874042511,
1.0384286642074585,
0.22717402875423431,
0.2235378921031952,
-0.4336782991886139,
-0.1276092231273651,
0.5092371702194214,
0.3841400146484375,
0.12452720105648041,
-0.2253442406654358,
-0.0974002256989479,
0.18720468878746033,
-0.11217308044433594,
-0.6279186606407166,
0.5187864899635315,
-0.3699851930141449,
0.8001829981803894,
0.5893486738204956,
0.5335178375244141,
0.36728331446647644,
-0.23279665410518646,
0.4722348153591156,
0.21794748306274414,
-1.1464825868606567,
0.19061370193958282,
-0.4462033212184906,
-0.18799884617328644,
0.39170464873313904,
0.4104837477207184,
-0.2729782462120056,
-0.38637086749076843,
-0.5663408637046814,
-0.6822156310081482,
0.4846670627593994,
0.16330339014530182,
-0.12330195307731628,
-0.21163292229175568,
-0.03561792150139809,
0.184307262301445,
0.24708585441112518,
-0.5867783427238464,
-0.11193110048770905,
-0.06120136380195618,
-0.011534030549228191,
-0.08062689751386642,
-0.35242193937301636,
-0.24018023908138275,
0.0463259257376194,
0.5226515531539917,
-0.21993395686149597,
-0.20449812710285187,
0.18740659952163696,
-0.11207257956266403,
-0.014785127714276314,
0.3880993127822876,
0.49763184785842896,
1.0944173336029053,
-0.25874894857406616,
0.33017775416374207,
0.07142964750528336,
-0.06105796992778778,
0.29878532886505127,
-0.08822452276945114,
-0.20985086262226105,
-0.297283798456192,
0.2356773465871811,
0.489027202129364,
0.06326045095920563,
-0.9787749648094177,
0.3811987340450287,
0.10147219151258469,
-0.4910557270050049,
-0.5061602592468262,
-0.098723404109478,
0.22142323851585388,
0.5741654634475708,
0.14322438836097717,
0.07441389560699463,
0.034614793956279755,
-0.6306484937667847,
0.0014048786833882332,
0.5626130700111389,
-0.24038083851337433,
-0.2340051531791687,
0.43280357122421265,
0.46091538667678833,
-0.3226281404495239,
0.6999686360359192,
-0.32855263352394104,
-0.4029984474182129,
0.8041505217552185,
0.583347499370575,
0.9578135013580322,
0.09916428476572037,
0.25916165113449097,
-0.09502685070037842,
0.724679708480835,
-0.5885558128356934,
0.130256786942482,
0.34815412759780884,
-0.9472459554672241,
-0.49524858593940735,
-0.347244530916214,
-0.9005559086799622,
-0.00027076518745161593,
-0.8647133111953735,
-0.16763977706432343,
-0.455203115940094,
-0.5718106627464294,
-0.16686560213565826,
0.13358403742313385,
-0.5788331031799316,
0.19322995841503143,
0.07602415978908539,
1.2880216836929321,
-0.6251739859580994,
0.9165407419204712,
0.6423130631446838,
-0.31030911207199097,
-0.8221107125282288,
-0.04619026556611061,
-0.20601904392242432,
-0.8524602651596069,
0.8129588961601257,
0.12684722244739532,
-0.43731141090393066,
-0.1457710862159729,
-0.5137766599655151,
-0.9168957471847534,
1.249924659729004,
0.34634292125701904,
-0.5181575417518616,
0.4132247865200043,
-0.11580921709537506,
0.25982725620269775,
-0.5804989337921143,
0.38840967416763306,
0.9749189615249634,
0.8637070059776306,
0.05277935415506363,
-0.7752998471260071,
-0.05160656198859215,
0.11552975326776505,
0.03509999066591263,
0.05249365046620369,
-0.753770112991333,
0.8595143556594849,
-0.11959417909383774,
-0.13012677431106567,
0.16985857486724854,
0.4971386194229126,
0.5829036831855774,
0.6649761199951172,
0.6585080623626709,
0.27159619331359863,
1.0947200059890747,
-0.11793143302202225,
1.0627361536026,
-0.5509242415428162,
0.4828946590423584,
0.7678014039993286,
-0.8169939517974854,
1.0451605319976807,
0.44444379210472107,
-0.10985898226499557,
0.1834319680929184,
0.3700266480445862,
-0.03198174014687538,
0.2630535662174225,
0.3705371916294098,
-0.025451406836509705,
-0.5532634258270264,
-0.20982423424720764,
-0.048690315335989,
0.44195762276649475,
0.4428940713405609,
-0.26451393961906433,
0.03661954402923584,
-0.2003832757472992,
0.07398834079504013,
-0.057623133063316345,
-0.5056313276290894,
0.5155072808265686,
0.1780225932598114,
-0.8932940363883972,
0.11231464147567749,
0.11641427874565125,
0.44445595145225525,
-0.7066642642021179,
0.20780044794082642,
-0.42612209916114807,
0.20318815112113953,
0.06993325054645538,
-0.9040446281433105,
0.23407307267189026,
0.06237170472741127,
-0.11084412783384323,
-0.37048038840293884,
0.718641996383667,
-0.14208997786045074,
-0.4371885657310486,
0.443037211894989,
0.6897323727607727,
0.04307010769844055,
0.10697982460260391,
-0.49777156114578247,
0.45647796988487244,
-0.18021798133850098,
-0.5799857974052429,
0.46077781915664673,
0.5593936443328857,
-0.053187962621450424,
1.0640124082565308,
0.6380846500396729,
0.011949276551604271,
-0.18863706290721893,
-0.02521716244518757,
0.5147932767868042,
-0.9559813737869263,
-0.21538373827934265,
-0.7701153755187988,
0.24591244757175446,
-0.2247224599123001,
-0.3738962411880493,
0.9473664164543152,
0.4857144355773926,
0.8246473073959351,
0.08988688886165619,
0.883791983127594,
0.28945866227149963,
0.00017968508473131806,
-0.6946573257446289,
0.7267113327980042,
-0.21819594502449036,
0.3792552351951599,
0.09587002545595169,
-1.076198935508728,
-0.12664121389389038,
1.0342378616333008,
-0.46685051918029785,
0.06431803852319717,
0.7854709029197693,
0.6910443902015686,
0.31525030732154846,
0.16070556640625,
0.523910403251648,
0.2789372503757477,
0.08541295677423477,
0.018298456445336342,
1.47328519821167,
0.2478642463684082,
0.3012923002243042,
-0.23992785811424255,
-0.3034767806529999,
-0.21666757762432098,
-1.0554635524749756,
-0.9141907691955566,
-0.0039047731552273035,
-0.5152001976966858,
-0.3702259957790375,
-0.25108933448791504,
1.3240548372268677,
0.5725417137145996,
-0.4283945560455322,
-0.7946678996086121,
0.3467918038368225,
0.41384950280189514,
-0.1831057071685791,
-0.1455266773700714,
0.13827237486839294,
-0.4473426640033722,
-0.7518936395645142,
0.27875855565071106,
0.4635525345802307,
0.08076191693544388,
-0.4997217655181885,
-0.2448449283838272,
0.25955232977867126,
0.6823535561561584,
0.957663357257843,
-0.1018759086728096,
-0.7954131364822388,
-0.21435755491256714,
0.22155678272247314,
-0.1774846315383911,
-0.313714861869812,
0.7725298404693604,
-0.4895859658718109,
0.23194745182991028,
0.22303171455860138,
0.4688737094402313,
0.023219479247927666,
0.05028657987713814,
0.6125039458274841,
0.1086491048336029,
-0.15563607215881348,
0.2615814507007599,
0.5397716164588928,
-0.09018552303314209,
0.23204539716243744,
0.4363442361354828,
-0.0019431913970038295,
-0.9139559268951416,
-0.6126850843429565,
0.18574677407741547,
-1.3236929178237915,
-0.1680545210838318,
1.417685627937317,
0.03893008828163147,
-0.22612842917442322,
-0.1337178498506546,
-0.3880283534526825,
-0.30457189679145813,
-0.6682448983192444,
0.2827052175998688,
0.852508008480072,
0.0592636875808239,
0.09316789358854294,
-0.4942893385887146,
0.13771305978298187,
0.06387721002101898,
-0.7015199661254883,
0.26593729853630066,
0.7292344570159912,
0.3062666952610016,
-0.05591457709670067,
0.7081983685493469,
0.2609776258468628,
-0.06414864212274551,
0.32811471819877625,
-0.1832270473241806,
0.18146808445453644,
-0.23237398266792297,
-0.12943574786186218,
0.2628990411758423,
0.7775392532348633,
0.10005799680948257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09404v1 | AQA-Bench: An Interactive Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs' Sequential Reasoning Ability | 2024-02-14T18:59:33 | 2024-02-14T18:59:33 | Siwei Yang, Bingchen Zhao, Cihang Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces AQA-Bench, a novel benchmark to assess the sequential
reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in algorithmic contexts,
such as depth-first search (DFS). The key feature of our evaluation benchmark
lies in its interactive evaluation protocol -- for example, in DFS, the
availability of each node's connected edge is contingent upon the model's
traversal to that node, thereby necessitating the LLM's ability to effectively
remember visited nodes and strategize subsequent moves. We comprehensively
build AQA-Bench with three different algorithms, namely binary search,
depth-first search, and breadth-first search, and to evaluate the sequential
reasoning ability of 12 different LLMs. Our investigations reveal several
interesting findings: (1) Closed-source models like GPT-4 and Gemini generally
show strong sequential reasoning ability, significantly outperforming
open-source LLMs. (2) Naively providing interactive examples may inadvertently
hurt few-shot performance. (3) A very limited number of predecessor steps
following the optimal policy can substantially boost small models' performance.
(4) The scaling correlation between performance and model size is not always
significant, sometimes even showcasing an inverse trend. We hope our study can
catalyze future work on advancing the understanding and enhancement of LLMs'
capabilities in sequential reasoning. The code is available at
https://github.com/UCSC-VLAA/AQA-Bench. | [
-0.43724167346954346,
-0.6452040672302246,
1.158274531364441,
0.31007981300354004,
-0.10941151529550552,
0.27974411845207214,
-0.03868865966796875,
-0.1325785219669342,
-0.24966338276863098,
0.22377854585647583,
-0.6899645924568176,
-0.5140921473503113,
-0.4604776203632355,
0.06903145462274551,
-0.7069965600967407,
0.049934789538383484,
-0.16452378034591675,
0.14417040348052979,
-0.41118478775024414,
-0.16746723651885986,
-0.19975845515727997,
-0.16462399065494537,
-0.79232257604599,
-0.24890363216400146,
0.40680232644081116,
0.30951619148254395,
0.8845179080963135,
0.8386716246604919,
0.49797987937927246,
0.3346644639968872,
-0.07934065163135529,
-0.032467544078826904,
-0.378558486700058,
0.3181820511817932,
-0.41482874751091003,
-0.24661371111869812,
-0.26289230585098267,
-0.11014693975448608,
1.1735037565231323,
0.7786775231361389,
-0.07883257418870926,
0.22692139446735382,
-0.36096152663230896,
0.8225833773612976,
-0.6449198126792908,
0.016717737540602684,
-0.6481202244758606,
-0.042044129222631454,
-0.1644032895565033,
0.16769365966320038,
-0.3068966567516327,
-0.5171048641204834,
0.13752765953540802,
-0.5834224820137024,
-0.41438743472099304,
0.07426141202449799,
0.5043371319770813,
0.6962493062019348,
-0.48961976170539856,
-0.06018642336130142,
-0.4781859815120697,
0.609112560749054,
-0.7933953404426575,
0.5378373861312866,
0.0640818253159523,
0.5928987264633179,
-0.2268795520067215,
-1.1250348091125488,
-0.792527437210083,
-0.3836814761161804,
0.07369926571846008,
0.04373166710138321,
0.020853662863373756,
0.043875496834516525,
0.6414377689361572,
0.36159461736679077,
-0.4377426207065582,
0.20573951303958893,
0.016198083758354187,
0.12595641613006592,
0.677666425704956,
0.34345459938049316,
0.012743506580591202,
0.13809752464294434,
-0.4282781183719635,
-0.2414989173412323,
-0.7253639101982117,
0.29085785150527954,
0.13194020092487335,
-0.10163633525371552,
0.002461405470967293,
0.460033118724823,
-0.6133740544319153,
0.7380962371826172,
-0.23659534752368927,
0.0398685485124588,
0.24117013812065125,
-0.37110742926597595,
0.06815668195486069,
-0.2362658679485321,
0.8107075095176697,
-0.048016902059316635,
0.16125257313251495,
-0.01743466593325138,
-0.26856672763824463,
-0.2024938315153122,
0.10915308445692062,
-0.8349112272262573,
-0.21934084594249725,
0.35694649815559387,
-0.43273159861564636,
-0.004668382462114096,
0.0032873183954507113,
-0.45051059126853943,
-0.5886817574501038,
-0.2010498046875,
0.48422735929489136,
-0.2501472234725952,
-0.17659735679626465,
-0.023852357640862465,
-0.012716129422187805,
0.29574310779571533,
0.3902928829193115,
-0.48908600211143494,
0.7436776757240295,
0.8514834046363831,
0.7553908228874207,
-0.35336920619010925,
-0.5878189206123352,
-0.6360856294631958,
-0.18231932818889618,
-0.36705759167671204,
0.7884503602981567,
-0.6079468131065369,
-0.30462172627449036,
-0.12746816873550415,
-0.2837139070034027,
-0.10281549394130707,
-0.45028942823410034,
0.5891744494438171,
-0.578450083732605,
-0.32849007844924927,
-0.5222362279891968,
-0.49646657705307007,
-0.26973289251327515,
0.2570744454860687,
-0.7958519458770752,
1.1256585121154785,
0.061955589801073074,
-0.553511917591095,
0.3071914315223694,
-0.4919009506702423,
-0.2502014935016632,
0.14584960043430328,
-0.5760158896446228,
-0.10928294062614441,
-0.11208979785442352,
0.21088680624961853,
0.03887864947319031,
-0.5611653327941895,
0.28471118211746216,
-0.6308171153068542,
-0.7579975128173828,
0.4903584420681,
-0.2468520849943161,
0.6655014753341675,
-0.0586455799639225,
-0.3567303419113159,
0.2415001392364502,
-0.8615125417709351,
0.3760586678981781,
0.22579577565193176,
-0.08006101846694946,
-0.06705823540687561,
0.31163403391838074,
-0.566495418548584,
0.35975873470306396,
0.2796960175037384,
-0.3955293595790863,
0.3079449534416199,
-0.2957419157028198,
0.3675747215747833,
0.6811534762382507,
0.13207897543907166,
0.27853697538375854,
-0.43709802627563477,
0.3738613426685333,
-0.23543380200862885,
0.205091193318367,
-0.3732427656650543,
-0.3875080943107605,
-0.7090514898300171,
-0.4516524076461792,
0.6401177048683167,
0.6041997671127319,
-0.6997955441474915,
0.2193356454372406,
-0.26612207293510437,
-0.3684214651584625,
-0.5743579864501953,
0.10670477151870728,
0.40997716784477234,
0.2796570658683777,
0.24341067671775818,
-0.6358440518379211,
-0.4068659245967865,
-0.8774247765541077,
-0.18550847470760345,
-0.4275204539299011,
0.057118359953165054,
0.4282837510108948,
0.6370276808738708,
-0.0183392483741045,
0.9325402975082397,
-0.18724258244037628,
0.2193347066640854,
0.20688556134700775,
0.1730930507183075,
0.3148294687271118,
0.1916772425174713,
0.3663676679134369,
-0.5755939483642578,
-0.291684627532959,
-0.3860156536102295,
-0.7856983542442322,
-0.26047828793525696,
-0.017035504803061485,
-0.33231526613235474,
-0.1277482956647873,
0.3862551152706146,
-0.6603986620903015,
0.43591147661209106,
0.2793428301811218,
-0.23209543526172638,
0.4406052827835083,
-0.006865398958325386,
0.1152830719947815,
-0.2827003002166748,
0.17678202688694,
-0.3287031054496765,
-0.0004354534612502903,
-0.3616650402545929,
0.21431538462638855,
0.14146165549755096,
0.12952680885791779,
-0.39519456028938293,
1.0003420114517212,
-0.3757421374320984,
-0.5612900853157043,
-0.1964253932237625,
0.1550540179014206,
-0.12124330550432205,
0.4162557125091553,
0.1744420975446701,
0.7303739190101624,
0.5003929734230042,
-0.45970743894577026,
0.32122793793678284,
0.3534368574619293,
-0.6488379240036011,
0.22620528936386108,
-0.667216420173645,
0.3517392575740814,
0.278133749961853,
0.4125891625881195,
-1.1904841661453247,
0.11986520141363144,
-0.07383313030004501,
-0.23688967525959015,
0.0017969999462366104,
-0.14289940893650055,
-0.7712012529373169,
-0.49885115027427673,
-0.3436570167541504,
0.6933555006980896,
0.34865057468414307,
-0.7379149198532104,
0.5439419150352478,
0.12042630463838577,
-0.32501840591430664,
-0.49697616696357727,
-0.3971363604068756,
-0.008362026885151863,
0.05974844470620155,
-0.6954185366630554,
0.4155087172985077,
-0.236108660697937,
-0.4043072760105133,
0.08937803655862808,
-0.24379926919937134,
-0.05603627488017082,
0.31965404748916626,
0.1415284276008606,
-0.051291994750499725,
-0.12645159661769867,
0.08131889253854752,
-0.014735529199242592,
-0.04091896861791611,
0.24753154814243317,
-0.17227835953235626,
0.3155161738395691,
-0.3678458034992218,
-0.7176237106323242,
-0.1745803952217102,
0.25211450457572937,
0.6237975358963013,
-0.3711071312427521,
0.3749716579914093,
0.3760493993759155,
-0.355333536863327,
-0.2592564523220062,
-0.7153470516204834,
-0.11045629531145096,
-0.4468786418437958,
0.1531209647655487,
-0.545518696308136,
-0.7548025250434875,
0.5518490076065063,
-0.4213758409023285,
0.01487970631569624,
0.3563728928565979,
0.5644645690917969,
0.16968883574008942,
1.1205521821975708,
0.19168317317962646,
0.10362701863050461,
0.2768605649471283,
-0.18240012228488922,
-0.06668203324079514,
-0.8407177925109863,
-0.1781207174062729,
-0.3515762984752655,
-0.30044427514076233,
-0.543118417263031,
-0.509821355342865,
0.4912956953048706,
0.21834948658943176,
-0.755007266998291,
-0.13755443692207336,
-0.17445561289787292,
0.3681503236293793,
0.7074514031410217,
-0.026987353339791298,
0.5779139995574951,
-0.49812179803848267,
-0.5819869637489319,
0.14977514743804932,
-0.560318112373352,
-0.48639270663261414,
0.9939427971839905,
0.5040912628173828,
0.582740306854248,
0.27607959508895874,
0.7446700930595398,
0.21733953058719635,
0.20428305864334106,
-0.8090269565582275,
0.9070019721984863,
0.03796754032373428,
-0.3422718048095703,
-0.48487746715545654,
-0.4757799208164215,
-0.6089838743209839,
0.5341659188270569,
-0.23615142703056335,
-0.791536808013916,
0.21815001964569092,
-0.14597807824611664,
-0.41059163212776184,
0.06855011731386185,
-0.48267632722854614,
0.8231343030929565,
-0.6962302923202515,
-0.711685836315155,
-0.23368068039417267,
-0.46524369716644287,
0.6546251773834229,
-0.08174221962690353,
0.21358178555965424,
-0.32905685901641846,
-0.43810784816741943,
0.5233069062232971,
-0.40986666083335876,
0.5347653031349182,
-0.2887513041496277,
0.17315618693828583,
0.22688359022140503,
0.2967064380645752,
0.4984869658946991,
0.28976666927337646,
-0.2686656415462494,
0.12284713238477707,
0.14284655451774597,
-0.2683999240398407,
-0.7348077893257141,
0.6807964444160461,
-0.5586232542991638,
-0.7963054776191711,
-0.6153417229652405,
-0.43582531809806824,
-0.6482056975364685,
0.39670783281326294,
-0.45984983444213867,
0.21594156324863434,
-0.3662901222705841,
0.18477781116962433,
0.5103417038917542,
-0.15228095650672913,
0.3628768026828766,
0.8787262439727783,
-0.4057712256908417,
-0.3310742974281311,
0.4751213788986206,
0.0346028134226799,
0.003295352216809988,
0.36692893505096436,
0.23206903040409088,
-0.5497909188270569,
-0.937716543674469,
-0.4701625108718872,
0.1383436769247055,
-0.7995427846908569,
-0.029805446043610573,
-0.4677899181842804,
-0.4713144600391388,
0.0384724885225296,
0.2761003375053406,
-0.3749850392341614,
-0.7532290816307068,
0.3494431972503662,
0.11146049201488495,
0.2103055864572525,
0.8920100927352905,
-0.026961512863636017,
0.04161105304956436,
-0.52998286485672,
0.4008740782737732,
0.48926857113838196,
0.651521623134613,
0.2782340943813324,
-0.4280563294887543,
0.01695939712226391,
-0.26450732350349426,
-0.33102506399154663,
-0.7244347333908081,
-0.11806979030370712,
0.04758790135383606,
1.0301343202590942,
0.11825389415025711,
0.0281820110976696,
0.31469112634658813,
-0.5328171253204346,
0.6164742708206177,
-0.13964638113975525,
-0.9101628661155701,
0.3732295036315918,
-0.2909640073776245,
0.7673940062522888,
0.8652029037475586,
0.4997262954711914,
-0.08531828969717026,
-0.13962222635746002,
-0.4805678129196167,
-0.8275700807571411,
0.6004619598388672,
0.21793651580810547,
-0.4617595970630646,
-0.03223145008087158,
0.1974686235189438,
-0.015798574313521385,
0.29385074973106384,
-0.38792648911476135,
-0.17060598731040955,
0.06077195331454277,
-0.07120784372091293,
0.18310144543647766,
-0.24789726734161377,
-0.038172174245119095,
-0.3796774446964264,
0.5740118622779846,
-0.12886108458042145,
0.08566657453775406,
0.11953628808259964,
-0.043841954320669174,
0.09766890108585358,
0.15885594487190247,
0.28066450357437134,
0.9053104519844055,
-0.25904664397239685,
0.029622294008731842,
0.3413553535938263,
-0.1574261486530304,
0.07381218671798706,
0.5764790177345276,
-0.28961503505706787,
-0.25085100531578064,
0.2877580225467682,
0.6164724826812744,
0.5217653512954712,
-0.8807549476623535,
0.5276837348937988,
-0.3250778615474701,
-0.23232704401016235,
-0.34254875779151917,
-0.018861381337046623,
0.06626739352941513,
0.6178659796714783,
0.5436215400695801,
-0.2987363338470459,
0.37908458709716797,
-0.6016110181808472,
0.30807068943977356,
0.41938281059265137,
-0.05616828054189682,
0.08498270064592361,
0.4776343107223511,
0.18538014590740204,
-0.15104857087135315,
0.6821181178092957,
-0.36034637689590454,
-0.5578949451446533,
0.4809456467628479,
0.033292174339294434,
0.7886740565299988,
-0.19320771098136902,
0.024563424289226532,
0.5991594195365906,
0.30630162358283997,
-0.29394596815109253,
0.43274274468421936,
-0.3885660171508789,
-0.5906612277030945,
-0.43210217356681824,
-0.528619647026062,
-0.9686721563339233,
0.0633542388677597,
-0.5051981806755066,
0.13230392336845398,
-0.645780086517334,
-0.1236114352941513,
0.00040416119736619294,
0.3994872272014618,
-0.743276059627533,
0.07977954298257828,
0.2150067239999771,
1.3421683311462402,
-0.3611564636230469,
0.8324787020683289,
0.6068800091743469,
-0.2622724175453186,
-0.47938451170921326,
-0.006853426806628704,
0.21329927444458008,
-0.863020122051239,
0.43360739946365356,
0.06382539123296738,
-0.19109754264354706,
0.016699735075235367,
-0.39066317677497864,
-1.186550498008728,
1.339387059211731,
0.25163930654525757,
-0.605577290058136,
0.025151284411549568,
-0.08231350034475327,
0.4296323359012604,
-0.5002753734588623,
0.7221115827560425,
0.9511244297027588,
0.6203294992446899,
0.42745259404182434,
-1.011681079864502,
0.3784838914871216,
-0.46250593662261963,
0.040857963263988495,
0.01465414185076952,
-0.7643638849258423,
0.7648861408233643,
-0.30670809745788574,
-0.28776466846466064,
0.6080184578895569,
0.5414106845855713,
0.6798535585403442,
0.2801206707954407,
0.7183734774589539,
0.6041774749755859,
0.8424561619758606,
-0.22527644038200378,
1.1276870965957642,
-0.28054383397102356,
-0.2018784135580063,
1.3793449401855469,
-0.6466720700263977,
1.190381646156311,
0.22591161727905273,
-0.2698095440864563,
0.7143994569778442,
0.5863737463951111,
0.023908518254756927,
0.6424925923347473,
0.6599586606025696,
-0.19473879039287567,
-0.3507350981235504,
-0.034940291196107864,
-0.49708136916160583,
0.4267866313457489,
0.4373215138912201,
-0.1133057177066803,
-0.1337186098098755,
-0.44375336170196533,
-0.4062154293060303,
0.2232690155506134,
-0.3108893036842346,
0.7350958585739136,
0.2201685905456543,
-0.8317925930023193,
0.5787538886070251,
-0.030211595818400383,
0.16335070133209229,
-0.6509129405021667,
-0.22327709197998047,
-0.13347890973091125,
0.16583164036273956,
-0.10654370486736298,
-0.959708571434021,
-0.0899106040596962,
-0.15575946867465973,
0.06011442095041275,
-0.014787785708904266,
0.5678005218505859,
-0.1920703798532486,
-0.3321370482444763,
0.4013395607471466,
0.727179229259491,
0.03823109716176987,
0.03908475488424301,
-0.9317317008972168,
0.39290839433670044,
-0.4871421456336975,
-0.38848990201950073,
0.31432461738586426,
0.46339842677116394,
-0.21498987078666687,
0.7872045040130615,
0.45940226316452026,
-0.07171175628900528,
-0.010321448557078838,
0.4373549818992615,
0.9395543932914734,
-0.8106684684753418,
-0.3420580327510834,
-0.5626168251037598,
0.44016578793525696,
-0.15041100978851318,
-0.16565833985805511,
0.5464063882827759,
0.5605401396751404,
0.8142606616020203,
0.34538912773132324,
0.8057745099067688,
0.14664782583713531,
0.6396250128746033,
-0.6408398747444153,
0.3441832959651947,
-0.3833276629447937,
0.5257434248924255,
0.00862535834312439,
-0.8703338503837585,
0.03442404791712761,
0.6302138566970825,
-0.5639474391937256,
0.40918946266174316,
0.9505188465118408,
0.5782196521759033,
0.07094978541135788,
0.1493867039680481,
0.20811370015144348,
0.47891688346862793,
-0.10396037250757217,
0.7278068661689758,
1.3213355541229248,
-0.35584741830825806,
0.454514741897583,
-0.34686124324798584,
-0.4898258447647095,
0.10338228940963745,
-1.0722683668136597,
-0.8626066446304321,
-0.4064270555973053,
-0.2633046805858612,
-0.13029535114765167,
0.19361190497875214,
0.6619455814361572,
0.5756146311759949,
-0.5886368155479431,
-0.36576950550079346,
0.0025701315607875586,
0.2924489974975586,
-0.3433150053024292,
-0.13419440388679504,
0.1596529334783554,
-0.19158393144607544,
-0.45277512073516846,
0.7939562797546387,
0.16334468126296997,
-0.17816664278507233,
-0.48764362931251526,
-0.12612034380435944,
-0.3911592662334442,
0.13728228211402893,
0.48492687940597534,
0.46170803904533386,
-0.7618648409843445,
-0.15300798416137695,
-0.11799415200948715,
0.023107700049877167,
-0.23270003497600555,
0.8263522386550903,
-1.0945000648498535,
0.503939688205719,
0.5368183255195618,
0.7271050214767456,
0.8931739330291748,
0.108302041888237,
0.5925912857055664,
-0.4426995515823364,
-0.10750751942396164,
0.3200238347053528,
0.49724245071411133,
0.25664982199668884,
0.06717250496149063,
0.7995793223381042,
-0.020070649683475494,
-0.5158804059028625,
-0.9083618521690369,
0.17489252984523773,
-0.9611919522285461,
-0.14584733545780182,
1.0549771785736084,
-0.1878608912229538,
-0.10162802040576935,
0.0006734468624927104,
-0.003622720018029213,
-0.13082793354988098,
-0.32849639654159546,
0.594845175743103,
0.7205052971839905,
-0.0930834636092186,
-0.29065465927124023,
-0.6016882061958313,
0.4061560034751892,
0.398868203163147,
-0.6860591769218445,
-0.04565955698490143,
0.3285827934741974,
0.04559509828686714,
-0.0988316535949707,
0.992843747138977,
-0.203708216547966,
0.5700293183326721,
0.062151502817869186,
-0.26189032196998596,
-0.24175959825515747,
-0.47354575991630554,
-0.4096982479095459,
-0.003107248805463314,
0.4377365708351135,
0.12597492337226868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09401v1 | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback with Active Queries | 2024-02-14T18:58:40 | 2024-02-14T18:58:40 | Kaixuan Ji, Jiafan He, Quanquan Gu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC, stat.ML | Aligning large language models (LLM) with human preference plays a key role
in building modern generative models and can be achieved by reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF). Despite their superior performance,
current RLHF approaches often require a large amount of human-labelled
preference data, which is expensive to collect. In this paper, inspired by the
success of active learning, we address this problem by proposing
query-efficient RLHF methods. We first formalize the alignment problem as a
contextual dueling bandit problem and design an active-query-based proximal
policy optimization (APPO) algorithm with an $\tilde{O}(d^2/\Delta)$ regret
bound and an $\tilde{O}(d^2/\Delta^2)$ query complexity, where $d$ is the
dimension of feature space and $\Delta$ is the sub-optimality gap over all the
contexts. We then propose ADPO, a practical version of our algorithm based on
direct preference optimization (DPO) and apply it to fine-tuning LLMs. Our
experiments show that ADPO, while only making about half of queries for human
preference, matches the performance of the state-of-the-art DPO method. | [
-0.2968691289424896,
-0.8630130887031555,
0.445856511592865,
-0.1752370297908783,
-0.03693665564060211,
-0.045233141630887985,
-0.4733057916164398,
-0.2283409833908081,
0.16023460030555725,
0.6255335211753845,
-0.701602041721344,
-0.4169975817203522,
-0.007924694567918777,
-0.25816911458969116,
0.242365300655365,
0.6505889892578125,
-0.25584349036216736,
-0.06078534200787544,
0.04428941011428833,
-0.2682991325855255,
-0.24016985297203064,
-0.2913414239883423,
-0.7515074610710144,
-0.22039014101028442,
0.7014287710189819,
0.5482166409492493,
0.8565483093261719,
0.6710054874420166,
0.1058804914355278,
0.3104359209537506,
-0.16154997050762177,
0.7183144688606262,
-0.4887745678424835,
0.45324915647506714,
-0.21796850860118866,
-0.4635879695415497,
-0.26857471466064453,
0.032210130244493484,
0.4829779267311096,
0.42322903871536255,
-0.5785297155380249,
-0.3327274024486542,
-0.21966664493083954,
0.8908048868179321,
-0.8460001945495605,
0.08898632228374481,
-0.689168393611908,
0.1385284662246704,
-0.11681454628705978,
-0.05058056488633156,
-0.349689245223999,
-0.5088271498680115,
0.16848434507846832,
-0.9417775273323059,
0.003397205611690879,
0.3103582262992859,
0.8432742953300476,
0.31470292806625366,
-0.49627381563186646,
-0.2900943458080292,
-0.698594331741333,
0.8727139830589294,
-0.4564467668533325,
0.25560086965560913,
0.4745752215385437,
0.34597697854042053,
-0.44355395436286926,
-0.24480631947517395,
-0.6933503746986389,
-0.22459179162979126,
-0.10420633107423782,
0.15556305646896362,
0.01586838811635971,
0.2636357247829437,
0.05890561640262604,
0.1842479258775711,
-0.3793584704399109,
0.29148194193840027,
-0.02571205422282219,
-0.25181224942207336,
0.8842734694480896,
0.06035662442445755,
0.022710230201482773,
-0.04035637155175209,
-0.42380112409591675,
-0.32393091917037964,
-0.7382941842079163,
0.34118229150772095,
0.6297273635864258,
0.3081124424934387,
0.4113582670688629,
0.43759357929229736,
-0.22059431672096252,
1.1783249378204346,
0.18790918588638306,
-0.1132216826081276,
-0.10273299366235733,
-0.12941063940525055,
0.13053424656391144,
0.043429311364889145,
0.8786794543266296,
0.17107130587100983,
0.07507024705410004,
-0.21452967822551727,
-0.3001916706562042,
-0.08040869235992432,
0.4983178973197937,
-0.4029151201248169,
-0.12340816855430603,
0.11743186414241791,
-0.014507711865007877,
-0.31761112809181213,
-0.027796704322099686,
-0.5703243017196655,
-0.4452754557132721,
-0.3240489363670349,
0.5892952084541321,
-0.22981320321559906,
-0.02206011861562729,
0.05554722249507904,
0.30470284819602966,
0.30259495973587036,
0.3941044211387634,
-1.2026277780532837,
0.06632895767688751,
0.6642764210700989,
0.5659863948822021,
-0.21337437629699707,
-0.11581575870513916,
-0.8560693860054016,
0.17641039192676544,
-0.4242871105670929,
0.7373035550117493,
-0.5611429810523987,
-0.3795525133609772,
0.12931445240974426,
-0.03188876062631607,
-0.23245841264724731,
-0.785933792591095,
0.7393043041229248,
-0.9452450275421143,
0.299203485250473,
-0.29426637291908264,
-0.38127171993255615,
-0.12884803116321564,
0.26525282859802246,
-0.6166537404060364,
0.9889254570007324,
0.026384567841887474,
-0.44878989458084106,
0.41845715045928955,
-0.5516246557235718,
-0.5089259743690491,
-0.13985662162303925,
-0.19301365315914154,
-0.733868420124054,
-0.16533398628234863,
0.3622637093067169,
0.2090233862400055,
-0.03671024739742279,
0.31239885091781616,
-0.40302515029907227,
-0.49681776762008667,
0.21579670906066895,
-0.09573187679052353,
0.5187838673591614,
0.25015634298324585,
-0.4781297445297241,
0.5832961201667786,
-0.3911147713661194,
0.058611731976270676,
0.050147123634815216,
-0.6081613898277283,
-0.43701857328414917,
0.4129392206668854,
-0.35020411014556885,
-0.0337848924100399,
0.13919386267662048,
-0.3984901010990143,
0.6659898161888123,
-0.6089856624603271,
0.47192609310150146,
0.8896306753158569,
-0.1707097887992859,
0.6400481462478638,
-0.1406145989894867,
0.5381962060928345,
-0.2800922691822052,
0.22839999198913574,
0.12519367039203644,
-0.06679809838533401,
-0.5944512486457825,
-0.2712401747703552,
0.5148910880088806,
0.48309364914894104,
-0.8121823072433472,
0.714346706867218,
0.026782622560858727,
-0.1671377569437027,
-0.6648470759391785,
0.19187363982200623,
0.5182636380195618,
0.5515114665031433,
0.29372212290763855,
-0.20807190239429474,
-0.38054126501083374,
-1.0028458833694458,
-0.2937881350517273,
-0.40484562516212463,
0.04359576478600502,
0.8982431888580322,
-0.041752465069293976,
-0.06917612254619598,
0.9580301642417908,
-0.8595806360244751,
-0.28225046396255493,
-0.04696354642510414,
-0.021708030253648758,
0.04507523030042648,
0.20781096816062927,
0.35793042182922363,
-0.7911660671234131,
-0.6788898706436157,
-0.01273359451442957,
-0.33243536949157715,
0.026429418474435806,
0.11840278655290604,
-0.42491599917411804,
0.21843303740024567,
0.19667087495326996,
-0.5320227742195129,
-0.027836985886096954,
0.44319647550582886,
-0.32314300537109375,
0.23020808398723602,
-0.3267349302768707,
0.0299127995967865,
-0.7468980550765991,
-0.02618640474975109,
-0.10589819401502609,
-0.346327543258667,
-0.282367467880249,
-0.11559706926345825,
0.18259409070014954,
-0.15166768431663513,
-0.2910928726196289,
0.7645392417907715,
-0.4455455541610718,
-0.044170115143060684,
-0.24400973320007324,
0.1415846198797226,
-0.13274069130420685,
0.791927695274353,
0.23699046671390533,
0.8423277735710144,
0.45496025681495667,
-0.7200728058815002,
0.6013156771659851,
0.30449506640434265,
-0.22819295525550842,
0.4007258713245392,
-0.4731222987174988,
0.18021583557128906,
-0.11771059781312943,
0.3972194790840149,
-1.0233856439590454,
-0.2889884412288666,
0.29267963767051697,
-0.3473222851753235,
0.4295429289340973,
-0.25546184182167053,
-0.19714070856571198,
-0.10820432752370834,
-0.3884119987487793,
0.23935428261756897,
0.46713659167289734,
-0.8478480577468872,
0.4259118437767029,
0.7469642758369446,
0.10355875641107559,
-0.8548848032951355,
0.08089009672403336,
-0.2278992384672165,
-0.17622385919094086,
-0.4501488208770752,
0.5457950830459595,
0.3037281632423401,
-0.08817171305418015,
-0.015539086423814297,
-0.28829556703567505,
0.1272232085466385,
0.1071428433060646,
-0.04168182238936424,
0.2666270136833191,
0.2728651762008667,
0.11508114635944366,
-0.09801164269447327,
-0.1446305513381958,
-0.2455260008573532,
-0.35577237606048584,
0.3706796169281006,
-0.060913603752851486,
-0.39288467168807983,
-0.2544679641723633,
0.09507188946008682,
0.38864344358444214,
-0.30149978399276733,
0.5045499205589294,
0.425542414188385,
0.024908680468797684,
-0.5353934168815613,
-0.3743691146373749,
-0.2480950504541397,
-0.45204296708106995,
0.28973641991615295,
-0.1515074074268341,
-0.8474290370941162,
0.26416683197021484,
-0.13312244415283203,
0.29595932364463806,
0.19556310772895813,
0.44638413190841675,
-0.11204684525728226,
1.390954613685608,
0.3139799237251282,
-0.007294260896742344,
0.9652117490768433,
-0.2754378020763397,
-0.01570122130215168,
-0.6267213225364685,
-0.3500146269798279,
-0.34076622128486633,
-0.6365928053855896,
-0.5302300453186035,
-0.43442079424858093,
0.5243808031082153,
0.283446729183197,
-0.25147485733032227,
0.2609356641769409,
-0.3973560631275177,
0.3932259976863861,
0.7726943492889404,
0.343868225812912,
0.06404680013656616,
-0.017826439812779427,
-0.3387584090232849,
-0.051638778299093246,
-0.8643536567687988,
-0.2663794159889221,
0.983561635017395,
0.034897755831480026,
0.9784135818481445,
0.35022518038749695,
0.6545307040214539,
0.21409942209720612,
0.17052918672561646,
-1.1463605165481567,
0.5569237470626831,
-0.1312789022922516,
-0.49472594261169434,
-0.6685500741004944,
-0.6085274815559387,
-1.3282846212387085,
0.4249814450740814,
-0.3372713625431061,
-0.3323301374912262,
0.26277440786361694,
0.5319460034370422,
-0.5832239985466003,
0.22455687820911407,
-0.736156165599823,
0.8586919903755188,
-0.5893456339836121,
-0.9311148524284363,
-0.23727074265480042,
-0.6395412683486938,
0.2633036673069,
0.32895350456237793,
-0.06416182965040207,
-0.17714199423789978,
-0.31807631254196167,
0.7657193541526794,
-0.5171838402748108,
0.6269460916519165,
-0.5069892406463623,
-0.09493516385555267,
0.343962699174881,
-0.10203289240598679,
0.8970958590507507,
0.21774524450302124,
-0.02599288523197174,
-0.5088363885879517,
-0.26882097125053406,
-0.44192758202552795,
-0.6716902852058411,
0.7987352609634399,
-0.9970086216926575,
-0.6330655813217163,
-0.4544818699359894,
-0.14989188313484192,
-0.6243245601654053,
0.05968628078699112,
-0.25320756435394287,
0.2682666778564453,
-0.2509726285934448,
0.17804737389087677,
1.0690666437149048,
-0.28308001160621643,
0.3283872604370117,
0.8967269062995911,
-0.0366673618555069,
-0.47719132900238037,
0.7251450419425964,
-0.0741446316242218,
-0.02973390743136406,
0.5071563124656677,
0.37294408679008484,
-0.7012152075767517,
-0.3111603558063507,
-0.7071881294250488,
0.24620531499385834,
-0.17034953832626343,
-0.28844693303108215,
-0.4565373957157135,
0.12245690822601318,
-0.16894076764583588,
-0.041655026376247406,
-0.5690207481384277,
-0.2980120778083801,
-0.09632157534360886,
0.15996035933494568,
0.367721825838089,
0.25101912021636963,
0.07374310493469238,
0.16553330421447754,
-0.6067736148834229,
0.3441896140575409,
0.9082630276679993,
0.5505852699279785,
-0.034596849232912064,
-0.30064982175827026,
-0.17300322651863098,
-0.008466999046504498,
-0.5085000991821289,
-0.9084333181381226,
0.2851356565952301,
0.13403981924057007,
0.7892643213272095,
0.49364200234413147,
0.5255117416381836,
0.6365901827812195,
-0.3817705512046814,
0.5116803646087646,
0.020512918010354042,
-0.5632008910179138,
0.6780499815940857,
-0.4083186388015747,
0.05709819495677948,
0.7413008809089661,
0.5535928606987,
-0.4925670325756073,
0.2504904866218567,
-0.615328848361969,
-1.1246275901794434,
1.0644725561141968,
-0.05973393842577934,
-0.02567569725215435,
0.07840470224618912,
0.5838521718978882,
-0.12627846002578735,
0.04620260372757912,
-0.3036242425441742,
-0.13597068190574646,
0.09052853286266327,
-0.0448162779211998,
0.020915253087878227,
-0.05956092104315758,
-0.48599761724472046,
-0.1256229132413864,
0.8888529539108276,
-0.3212827146053314,
0.07183565199375153,
0.013707390986382961,
0.001307407976128161,
-0.28429603576660156,
0.44025880098342896,
0.3884964883327484,
0.553485631942749,
-0.28100109100341797,
0.029358165338635445,
-0.01969282142817974,
-0.09004689753055573,
0.2990008294582367,
0.14701497554779053,
-0.2840290367603302,
-0.267145037651062,
0.011662925593554974,
1.1183619499206543,
0.2683379650115967,
-0.954738974571228,
0.6247388124465942,
-0.21803097426891327,
-0.3036290407180786,
-0.1470799446105957,
0.5393891334533691,
0.020004311576485634,
0.19376306235790253,
0.24734804034233093,
-0.19404636323451996,
-0.093288354575634,
-0.6756578683853149,
0.15695710480213165,
0.6860738396644592,
-0.7496266961097717,
-0.21835510432720184,
0.6277892589569092,
0.491655170917511,
-0.34279167652130127,
0.607266902923584,
-0.23645998537540436,
-0.6240330338478088,
0.2719406485557556,
0.30664902925491333,
0.7616996169090271,
-0.11468259245157242,
0.23611336946487427,
0.45779022574424744,
-0.2593876123428345,
-0.34471943974494934,
0.25213950872421265,
-0.4278220534324646,
-0.7318302989006042,
-0.47993409633636475,
-0.6598338484764099,
-0.7026464939117432,
-0.018698016181588173,
-0.622092068195343,
0.355155885219574,
-0.3188747763633728,
-0.09918852895498276,
-0.14504985511302948,
0.37022876739501953,
-0.1465240716934204,
-0.045098911970853806,
-0.13205347955226898,
0.36390236020088196,
-0.604175329208374,
0.8688144683837891,
1.0888686180114746,
-0.1537974327802658,
-0.7470781207084656,
0.017318282276391983,
-0.10191676765680313,
-1.0821247100830078,
0.3746410608291626,
-0.19775158166885376,
-0.09173405915498734,
0.08442114293575287,
-0.457085520029068,
-0.6685289144515991,
0.9699887037277222,
0.28048375248908997,
-0.7133614420890808,
-0.022474288940429688,
-0.5862200260162354,
0.4609580338001251,
-0.1494290828704834,
0.13074955344200134,
0.4710026681423187,
0.4571230709552765,
0.37221065163612366,
-0.7395440340042114,
-0.02766341157257557,
0.07241146266460419,
-0.049937449395656586,
0.7234950661659241,
-1.0466948747634888,
0.33862361311912537,
-0.312455952167511,
-0.10428135097026825,
-0.3349595069885254,
0.5991543531417847,
0.4517793357372284,
0.01661931723356247,
0.9125388860702515,
0.6497872471809387,
0.6701727509498596,
-0.08711905032396317,
0.9133951663970947,
-0.20762741565704346,
0.3320717513561249,
0.8325054049491882,
-0.26359954476356506,
0.911935567855835,
0.3392047882080078,
-0.4593296945095062,
0.2946966290473938,
0.9223214387893677,
0.24212878942489624,
0.8366693258285522,
0.3648476004600525,
-0.44475650787353516,
-0.4917387068271637,
0.01772604137659073,
-0.09908175468444824,
0.466219961643219,
0.16815920174121857,
-0.09476643055677414,
-0.11927968263626099,
-0.3527650237083435,
0.08568260818719864,
0.3475622832775116,
-0.21945467591285706,
1.2968425750732422,
-0.31572425365448,
-1.3416345119476318,
0.7149986624717712,
0.18456478416919708,
0.803646981716156,
-0.7700804471969604,
0.0441187359392643,
-0.4163986146450043,
0.3604779839515686,
-0.11062648147344589,
-0.5272029638290405,
0.1518162190914154,
-0.20270468294620514,
-0.06531866639852524,
-0.3494356572628021,
0.4759301543235779,
-0.7166058421134949,
0.0989411473274231,
0.039909541606903076,
0.21592731773853302,
-0.21047064661979675,
0.0707775428891182,
-0.8357638716697693,
-0.23798665404319763,
0.16979660093784332,
-0.4306066036224365,
0.5832041501998901,
0.1496613770723343,
-0.33858829736709595,
0.45925769209861755,
0.6482537984848022,
0.17037297785282135,
-0.23657140135765076,
-0.11248946189880371,
0.8134517073631287,
-0.640501856803894,
-0.6156668663024902,
-0.6318678855895996,
0.15626779198646545,
-0.12047708034515381,
-0.20788541436195374,
0.49885112047195435,
0.5729727149009705,
0.7493259906768799,
0.2281903326511383,
0.7182271480560303,
-0.026799451559782028,
0.5266650319099426,
-0.5891989469528198,
0.3519097864627838,
-0.732265055179596,
0.4471297264099121,
0.18320970237255096,
-0.9607356786727905,
-0.09411436319351196,
0.7531053423881531,
-0.44804146885871887,
-0.07240265607833862,
0.24175436794757843,
0.9893584251403809,
-0.03714529797434807,
-0.32345297932624817,
0.1470242440700531,
-0.13506658375263214,
0.19276347756385803,
0.6191813349723816,
0.873660683631897,
-0.09630049765110016,
0.7290797829627991,
-0.15794815123081207,
-0.37242627143859863,
-0.4909478425979614,
-0.6840998530387878,
-0.5602391362190247,
-0.3652442395687103,
-0.18294814229011536,
-0.3954296112060547,
0.3308410048484802,
0.9916269183158875,
0.8176907300949097,
-0.7493097186088562,
-0.2251061052083969,
-0.05724111944437027,
0.4152274429798126,
-0.4967925548553467,
-0.20013666152954102,
0.6701827049255371,
-0.47701844573020935,
-0.9392113089561462,
0.417762815952301,
0.11757256090641022,
-0.05593854561448097,
-0.3400889039039612,
-0.44596630334854126,
-0.3806719481945038,
-0.047799985855817795,
0.38804447650909424,
0.6005575656890869,
-0.8016451597213745,
-0.06447471678256989,
0.13471834361553192,
-0.059879228472709656,
-0.0396701842546463,
1.060202717781067,
-0.7236863970756531,
0.8096847534179688,
0.702945351600647,
0.7123958468437195,
0.7372417449951172,
0.40509435534477234,
0.7665427327156067,
-0.8476694226264954,
0.014762310311198235,
0.411323606967926,
0.07140239328145981,
0.1926945596933365,
-0.29639533162117004,
0.4677620530128479,
0.19644050300121307,
-0.6398400068283081,
-0.714204728603363,
0.39268574118614197,
-0.8245931267738342,
-0.39625075459480286,
1.224874496459961,
-0.15294450521469116,
-0.23126091063022614,
-0.04991518333554268,
-0.43120336532592773,
0.14254745841026306,
-0.663986325263977,
0.9512961506843567,
0.3962061107158661,
-0.6346679329872131,
-0.06034424155950546,
-0.3390601873397827,
0.8909136056900024,
0.6233591437339783,
-0.5185068845748901,
0.29206380248069763,
0.6552318930625916,
-0.002515482483431697,
-0.20870757102966309,
0.687905490398407,
-0.08916734158992767,
0.19014452397823334,
-0.33554717898368835,
-0.029702121391892433,
-0.17356446385383606,
-0.22733795642852783,
-0.2055508941411972,
0.16728177666664124,
0.3151434361934662,
-0.25739338994026184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09394v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09394v2 | Long-form evaluation of model editing | 2024-02-14T18:45:14 | 2024-03-29T21:17:23 | Domenic Rosati, Robie Gonzales, Jinkun Chen, Xuemin Yu, Melis Erkan, Yahya Kayani, Satya Deepika Chavatapalli, Frank Rudzicz, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluations of model editing currently only use the `next few token'
completions after a prompt. As a result, the impact of these methods on longer
natural language generation is largely unknown. We introduce long-form
evaluation of model editing (LEME) a novel evaluation protocol that measures
the efficacy and impact of model editing in long-form generative settings. Our
protocol consists of a machine-rated survey and a classifier which correlates
well with human ratings. Importantly, we find that our protocol has very little
relationship with previous short-form metrics (despite being designed to extend
efficacy, generalization, locality, and portability into a long-form setting),
indicating that our method introduces a novel set of dimensions for
understanding model editing methods. Using this protocol, we benchmark a number
of model editing techniques and present several findings including that, while
some methods (ROME and MEMIT) perform well in making consistent edits within a
limited scope, they suffer much more from factual drift than other methods.
Finally, we present a qualitative analysis that illustrates common failure
modes in long-form generative settings including internal consistency, lexical
cohesion, and locality issues. | [
-0.2420470118522644,
-0.9348500370979309,
0.8060400485992432,
0.13013869524002075,
-0.10509316623210907,
0.03941742330789566,
-0.3442460298538208,
-0.49279505014419556,
0.14085714519023895,
0.19896431267261505,
-0.4870623052120209,
-0.39335620403289795,
-0.5087181925773621,
0.3430517911911011,
-0.3970426321029663,
0.753598153591156,
-0.10499395430088043,
0.04280520975589752,
-0.5289010405540466,
-0.09018829464912415,
-0.4860217869281769,
-0.48609963059425354,
-0.7564066052436829,
-0.2877216041088104,
0.553753674030304,
0.11565925925970078,
0.7917085289955139,
0.28257259726524353,
0.6343718767166138,
0.3152439296245575,
-0.5083200335502625,
0.1637570559978485,
-0.4773324429988861,
-0.14896860718727112,
-0.3311898112297058,
-0.44424188137054443,
-0.9885457158088684,
0.052844446152448654,
0.9483891129493713,
0.8069474697113037,
-0.014186267741024494,
0.17572416365146637,
0.15533919632434845,
0.7388460040092468,
-0.7612077593803406,
-0.34781232476234436,
-0.4901067614555359,
-0.056571830064058304,
-0.38301530480384827,
0.159963458776474,
-0.5695595145225525,
-0.16176831722259521,
-0.02152961865067482,
-0.34199294447898865,
0.18255703151226044,
-0.2172771841287613,
0.6488282680511475,
0.0905342549085617,
-0.27788153290748596,
-0.3100811839103699,
-0.7275631427764893,
0.6563560962677002,
-1.1621122360229492,
0.42774948477745056,
0.367198646068573,
0.30270516872406006,
-0.3209521472454071,
-0.6491568088531494,
-0.5230526328086853,
-0.6333617568016052,
0.021257096901535988,
0.17791609466075897,
-0.1728796362876892,
0.3054874837398529,
0.5448041558265686,
0.33776596188545227,
-0.36158815026283264,
0.46196895837783813,
-0.5021641254425049,
-0.23811817169189453,
0.6642187237739563,
0.15283507108688354,
0.24152815341949463,
-0.5131412148475647,
-0.10999808460474014,
0.1457240730524063,
-0.7119449973106384,
0.05495820194482803,
0.5349936485290527,
0.1342204213142395,
-0.026491964235901833,
0.7630422115325928,
-0.2332310527563095,
0.867781937122345,
0.057191651314496994,
-0.15738894045352936,
0.06569750607013702,
-0.34565529227256775,
-0.4935914874076843,
-0.19806210696697235,
0.9814290404319763,
0.7149163484573364,
-0.18395330011844635,
-0.0019655642099678516,
-0.38609862327575684,
-0.029951024800539017,
0.1068309098482132,
-0.7174432873725891,
0.23074346780776978,
0.04523390904068947,
-0.5529143214225769,
-0.4540168046951294,
-0.07607227563858032,
-0.5998336672782898,
-0.3462650775909424,
-0.22104081511497498,
0.5458260774612427,
-0.3166222870349884,
0.06801775842905045,
0.24657513201236725,
-0.15795257687568665,
-0.0637233555316925,
0.5503891706466675,
-0.6968784928321838,
0.3314104974269867,
0.7928000688552856,
1.0791374444961548,
-0.20598188042640686,
-0.40812593698501587,
-0.6330786347389221,
-0.054951298981904984,
-0.34332817792892456,
0.6323704719543457,
-0.4717009961605072,
-0.7092617154121399,
-0.2563864588737488,
0.09418725222349167,
-0.06602658331394196,
-0.4666437804698944,
0.620167076587677,
-0.26544302701950073,
0.3079131543636322,
-0.1272660195827484,
-0.8959512114524841,
0.12034381181001663,
0.07998407632112503,
-0.7636488080024719,
0.9753139615058899,
0.12849311530590057,
-0.4886544942855835,
0.4220016300678253,
-1.0539225339889526,
-0.2692789137363434,
-0.20601272583007812,
0.10978612303733826,
-0.5074661374092102,
0.4924941658973694,
0.13791993260383606,
0.4877733886241913,
-0.2603171169757843,
0.2556227445602417,
-0.32875004410743713,
-0.242421492934227,
0.22962649166584015,
-0.5544314384460449,
0.5778477787971497,
-0.06892362982034683,
-0.20824973285198212,
0.07767625898122787,
-0.9948363304138184,
-0.1729874610900879,
0.022423023357987404,
-0.25149956345558167,
-0.31481489539146423,
-0.13469237089157104,
-0.12382370978593826,
0.113179512321949,
0.12568889558315277,
-0.6515787839889526,
0.5686103701591492,
-0.30197104811668396,
0.6643917560577393,
0.8573144674301147,
0.19222019612789154,
0.49786993861198425,
-0.3934418857097626,
0.6692278385162354,
-0.4128238558769226,
0.2167995274066925,
-0.13181965053081512,
-0.3569003641605377,
-0.8920291662216187,
-0.087637759745121,
0.7169666290283203,
0.28518131375312805,
-0.25198617577552795,
0.2430662363767624,
-0.31299158930778503,
-0.6087601184844971,
-0.4747599959373474,
0.14866843819618225,
0.22925719618797302,
0.46779927611351013,
0.18757247924804688,
-0.4859032928943634,
-0.22289086878299713,
-0.975767970085144,
-0.19504289329051971,
0.1268237978219986,
0.024286765605211258,
0.08898796141147614,
0.7499464154243469,
-0.48052987456321716,
0.863452672958374,
-0.19599014520645142,
0.113526351749897,
-0.11203033477067947,
0.3857278823852539,
0.11875536292791367,
0.49922987818717957,
0.5970520377159119,
-0.1443796455860138,
-0.21182845532894135,
-0.2553015649318695,
-0.5860546827316284,
-0.11792115867137909,
-0.46350881457328796,
-0.18482252955436707,
0.2536830008029938,
0.5678187608718872,
-0.7776758670806885,
0.5836014747619629,
0.515198290348053,
-0.16577845811843872,
0.802413284778595,
-0.22681765258312225,
0.3424364924430847,
-1.0074440240859985,
-0.012292471714317799,
-0.2310078740119934,
-0.3180963695049286,
-0.5667135119438171,
-0.021770784631371498,
0.07416006177663803,
-0.11706209182739258,
-0.5452173352241516,
0.6337921023368835,
-0.46892833709716797,
-0.10006915032863617,
-0.08008512854576111,
0.2183191031217575,
0.27315637469291687,
-0.031942691653966904,
-0.16519734263420105,
0.5707530975341797,
0.09939876943826675,
-0.47209224104881287,
0.3070564866065979,
0.000022750227799406275,
-0.5106968283653259,
0.64696204662323,
-0.7740929126739502,
0.7553403377532959,
-0.20275311172008514,
0.2131333202123642,
-0.5152092576026917,
-0.22312043607234955,
-0.09528077393770218,
-0.3442770540714264,
0.2568246126174927,
0.02727353200316429,
-0.5118907690048218,
-0.2836090624332428,
-0.40294626355171204,
0.33328813314437866,
0.31695112586021423,
-0.3060413897037506,
0.46080100536346436,
-0.2798556387424469,
-0.15780137479305267,
-0.4060628116130829,
-0.5966394543647766,
0.31414055824279785,
-0.18629565834999084,
-0.8806730508804321,
0.30088722705841064,
-0.31659582257270813,
-0.416791707277298,
-0.1574188768863678,
0.07012268155813217,
0.2098706066608429,
0.29567065834999084,
0.1857345551252365,
0.02017718367278576,
-0.11689924448728561,
0.18674825131893158,
0.3410312533378601,
0.06276194751262665,
-0.07524482905864716,
0.46111369132995605,
0.34659355878829956,
0.025291427969932556,
-0.5783566832542419,
-0.7997744679450989,
0.43826159834861755,
0.7115239500999451,
-0.2319404035806656,
0.4637700319290161,
0.291606605052948,
-0.43362751603126526,
-0.12774257361888885,
-0.4346298575401306,
-0.03267304599285126,
-0.429708331823349,
0.576662003993988,
-0.5703660249710083,
-0.8207418918609619,
0.40503135323524475,
-0.27284494042396545,
0.20128558576107025,
0.7754560112953186,
0.36655193567276,
-0.17055004835128784,
0.94270259141922,
0.9000834226608276,
0.10453428328037262,
0.265903115272522,
-0.2609236240386963,
0.030457327142357826,
-0.8579341173171997,
0.08165726065635681,
-0.4883439242839813,
-0.24296928942203522,
-0.31128302216529846,
-0.5333133935928345,
0.2293258160352707,
0.6786524653434753,
-0.030330920591950417,
0.20565669238567352,
-0.22756022214889526,
0.40354934334754944,
0.3390921354293823,
-0.011949943378567696,
0.4019199311733246,
-0.2740650773048401,
-0.006828551180660725,
-0.2041560560464859,
-0.6194500923156738,
-0.6701815128326416,
1.0503461360931396,
0.5995783805847168,
0.5104484558105469,
0.11998318880796432,
0.9101216793060303,
0.5723636746406555,
0.48462432622909546,
-0.8654727339744568,
0.5029162168502808,
-0.08676739037036896,
-0.33514294028282166,
-0.5675960183143616,
-0.21211135387420654,
-0.7455312013626099,
-0.1391630321741104,
-0.2141382098197937,
-0.7524343132972717,
0.08653140813112259,
0.1421251744031906,
-0.573470950126648,
0.2865030765533447,
-0.5222865343093872,
0.9359282851219177,
-0.35692232847213745,
-0.27661630511283875,
-0.22324535250663757,
-0.4435669481754303,
0.3068009912967682,
-0.21462832391262054,
0.3774672746658325,
-0.018412986770272255,
0.08953595161437988,
0.7953331470489502,
-0.6414414048194885,
0.6489190459251404,
0.00684603676199913,
-0.14350351691246033,
0.1771641969680786,
0.19678671658039093,
0.5699557065963745,
0.15846243500709534,
-0.32773029804229736,
0.12466518580913544,
-0.14363674819469452,
-0.23271919786930084,
-1.037416696548462,
0.43909239768981934,
-0.5261198878288269,
-0.45745614171028137,
-0.2939406931400299,
-0.20728933811187744,
-0.272381067276001,
0.15490597486495972,
0.41313114762306213,
0.4740331768989563,
-0.5520728230476379,
0.16322530806064606,
0.16943715512752533,
-0.3095434904098511,
0.481179416179657,
0.23985005915164948,
-0.43413594365119934,
-0.5587527751922607,
0.5827996730804443,
0.1361723095178604,
0.8266536593437195,
0.16076429188251495,
0.27288466691970825,
0.17444059252738953,
-0.4526686370372772,
-0.6715192198753357,
0.11501169949769974,
-0.7430235147476196,
-0.058359503746032715,
-0.4375648498535156,
-0.2704853415489197,
-0.3770603537559509,
-0.37209951877593994,
-0.5149117708206177,
-0.5197312831878662,
-0.12401933968067169,
-0.1199524849653244,
0.049570851027965546,
1.022560715675354,
-0.2596554458141327,
0.44520506262779236,
-0.8343265652656555,
0.29023391008377075,
0.37627825140953064,
0.26700130105018616,
-0.08558803051710129,
-0.5400537848472595,
-0.2554989755153656,
0.19443970918655396,
-0.14897792041301727,
-1.0021787881851196,
0.04758079722523689,
0.3779033422470093,
0.40367189049720764,
0.21628497540950775,
-0.4389435946941376,
0.7653854489326477,
-0.5681380033493042,
1.0488922595977783,
0.23574689030647278,
-1.2215591669082642,
0.7108997106552124,
-0.30409035086631775,
0.5055245161056519,
0.5286023020744324,
0.10987211018800735,
-0.7074719071388245,
-0.3251871168613434,
-0.527547299861908,
-0.6444858312606812,
0.29266858100891113,
0.11475089192390442,
0.24217021465301514,
-0.09802359342575073,
0.572217583656311,
0.27904751896858215,
0.13653278350830078,
-0.6696988940238953,
-0.06004540994763374,
-0.01548751164227724,
0.22800639271736145,
-0.21467553079128265,
-0.716690719127655,
0.016114022582769394,
-0.36121025681495667,
0.7227513194084167,
0.08083419501781464,
0.16422566771507263,
0.23243768513202667,
-0.32014140486717224,
-0.07463784515857697,
0.6745461821556091,
1.0123945474624634,
1.025949239730835,
-0.4650692641735077,
-0.20676088333129883,
0.29757001996040344,
-0.18844074010849,
-0.09577807784080505,
-0.08980346471071243,
-0.47462835907936096,
0.3183062672615051,
0.6222493648529053,
1.0311630964279175,
0.09940822422504425,
-0.3893049657344818,
0.3934045732021332,
0.007153594400733709,
-0.29402053356170654,
-0.012214160524308681,
-0.16129830479621887,
0.007523104082792997,
-0.11136553436517715,
0.000036681372876046225,
0.17613893747329712,
0.374776154756546,
-0.6688973903656006,
-0.013065056875348091,
0.3273898661136627,
-0.38494929671287537,
-0.3881601393222809,
0.5060932040214539,
0.2611413896083832,
-0.5193657875061035,
0.5422855019569397,
-0.29612234234809875,
-0.23839209973812103,
0.5301797389984131,
0.4362223744392395,
1.0717381238937378,
-0.19062279164791107,
0.27803942561149597,
0.5086966156959534,
0.5388829112052917,
0.0018302206881344318,
0.027648624032735825,
0.1652209609746933,
-0.365998774766922,
-0.745898962020874,
-0.7927283644676208,
-0.4889635443687439,
0.4533730447292328,
-0.6066166162490845,
0.4366382658481598,
-0.3664199411869049,
-0.4725138247013092,
0.11726018786430359,
-0.3352399170398712,
-0.5956466794013977,
0.12940387427806854,
0.04685211181640625,
0.9756869673728943,
-0.7754124402999878,
0.4824388921260834,
0.6827730536460876,
-0.2522149682044983,
-0.5251553058624268,
-0.18484655022621155,
0.03039027936756611,
-0.24513550102710724,
0.47277262806892395,
0.34133002161979675,
-0.17439329624176025,
-0.32958975434303284,
-0.5128310322761536,
-0.7970542907714844,
0.9612017273902893,
0.37303516268730164,
-0.998346745967865,
-0.2692973017692566,
0.28545549511909485,
0.5769963264465332,
-0.2037755846977234,
0.21773572266101837,
0.5958300232887268,
0.488633394241333,
-0.32719019055366516,
-1.4115877151489258,
-0.12498364597558975,
-0.15833424031734467,
0.08351538330316544,
0.10979823023080826,
-0.577584981918335,
0.6441775560379028,
-0.2426237314939499,
-0.07688766717910767,
0.4761984646320343,
0.7061486840248108,
-0.09058378636837006,
0.3210827708244324,
0.5375874638557434,
0.7531969547271729,
0.7595205903053284,
0.20169074833393097,
0.9062846899032593,
-0.2085932493209839,
0.5328555107116699,
1.419503092765808,
-0.1329912543296814,
0.9402695298194885,
0.33685773611068726,
-0.22756724059581757,
0.5562236905097961,
0.5137049555778503,
0.06706952303647995,
0.21296267211437225,
0.4902978241443634,
-0.20905351638793945,
-0.2672189474105835,
0.0751708596944809,
-0.34930968284606934,
0.5640711188316345,
0.15505854785442352,
-0.4746180772781372,
-0.2269979566335678,
0.19529865682125092,
0.2262725532054901,
0.10750488191843033,
-0.33205026388168335,
0.6456764340400696,
0.2004208117723465,
-0.4762575924396515,
0.4543816149234772,
0.2549259662628174,
0.6333830952644348,
-0.3054335415363312,
-0.21158207952976227,
-0.15010200440883636,
-0.14598119258880615,
-0.1866273283958435,
-0.4496079385280609,
0.173785001039505,
0.03767797350883484,
-0.3502578139305115,
-0.087798111140728,
0.5723380446434021,
-0.08315306156873703,
-0.7565861344337463,
0.18514683842658997,
0.5457826256752014,
0.09048803150653839,
0.05885002389550209,
-0.6779574155807495,
0.11363505572080612,
-0.24918468296527863,
-0.4009104371070862,
0.10544924437999725,
0.16497774422168732,
-0.195962056517601,
0.3861047327518463,
0.5751807689666748,
0.1255897730588913,
-0.06188946217298508,
0.4938391447067261,
0.39667078852653503,
-0.7426590919494629,
-0.11131858080625534,
-0.9931309819221497,
0.706699788570404,
-0.2754441201686859,
-0.41017279028892517,
0.6387042999267578,
0.6958156824111938,
0.7138838171958923,
0.019293220713734627,
0.8743335008621216,
-0.02031203918159008,
0.3319401144981384,
-0.7367678880691528,
0.7103834748268127,
-0.4488741159439087,
0.18190984427928925,
-0.4106433093547821,
-1.1797195672988892,
-0.2710645794868469,
0.2312679886817932,
-0.3874678313732147,
0.012544607743620872,
0.7293387651443481,
0.6953418254852295,
-0.01577228493988514,
-0.34310296177864075,
0.4667234420776367,
0.3427650034427643,
0.2745591104030609,
0.36139291524887085,
0.9569979310035706,
-0.3816108703613281,
-0.13179145753383636,
-0.5571058988571167,
-0.18988701701164246,
-0.006369973532855511,
-1.1543502807617188,
-0.9913703203201294,
-0.3683164715766907,
-0.2944698929786682,
-0.3214312195777893,
0.4052903652191162,
0.8458408713340759,
0.46681469678878784,
-0.35100334882736206,
-0.08326742798089981,
0.09877585619688034,
-0.020602872595191002,
-0.02157638594508171,
-0.21902313828468323,
0.546644389629364,
-0.18846838176250458,
-0.8276378512382507,
0.5674371123313904,
0.46814072132110596,
-0.020355304703116417,
-0.29612842202186584,
-0.08215178549289703,
0.04642466455698013,
0.18171082437038422,
0.8542967438697815,
0.0634981244802475,
-0.7320182919502258,
-0.4900619387626648,
0.002798197790980339,
-0.022646911442279816,
0.05150294676423073,
0.5819137692451477,
-0.529492199420929,
0.8592125773429871,
0.41039130091667175,
0.31654396653175354,
0.22870460152626038,
0.02863047644495964,
0.658814013004303,
-0.46091896295547485,
-0.10166332870721817,
0.09637846797704697,
0.42506664991378784,
0.5126863718032837,
-0.22259463369846344,
0.398200660943985,
0.19506806135177612,
-0.7405369281768799,
-1.0411885976791382,
0.10916676372289658,
-0.9997469782829285,
0.01808934099972248,
1.2498314380645752,
-0.016472747549414635,
-0.20952662825584412,
0.4474705159664154,
-0.3221283257007599,
0.10255586355924606,
-0.18703800439834595,
0.6281646490097046,
0.9044304490089417,
-0.24564790725708008,
-0.025904294103384018,
-0.8299630880355835,
0.5255959033966064,
0.3979818820953369,
-0.8415179252624512,
-0.17638209462165833,
0.8178161382675171,
0.3262614607810974,
0.2192021608352661,
0.6771891117095947,
-0.01819545216858387,
0.5333613753318787,
-0.18859286606311798,
0.12171433120965958,
0.0056734769605100155,
-0.17066873610019684,
-0.5390328168869019,
-0.08040343970060349,
0.4173049032688141,
0.34512415528297424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09391v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09391v3 | LlaSMol: Advancing Large Language Models for Chemistry with a Large-Scale, Comprehensive, High-Quality Instruction Tuning Dataset | 2024-02-14T18:42:25 | 2024-04-01T17:28:16 | Botao Yu, Frazier N. Baker, Ziqi Chen, Xia Ning, Huan Sun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL | Chemistry plays a crucial role in many domains, such as drug discovery and
material science. While large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 exhibit
remarkable capabilities on natural language processing tasks, existing research
indicates that their performance on chemistry tasks is discouragingly low. In
this paper, however, we demonstrate that our developed LLMs can achieve very
strong results on a comprehensive set of chemistry tasks, outperforming the
most advanced GPT-4 and Claude 3 Opus by a substantial margin. To accomplish
this, we propose SMolInstruct, a large-scale, comprehensive, and high-quality
dataset for instruction tuning. It contains 14 selected chemistry tasks and
over three million samples, laying a solid foundation for training and
evaluating LLMs for chemistry. Using SMolInstruct, we fine-tune a set of
open-source LLMs, among which, we find that Mistral serves as the best base
model for chemistry tasks. Our analysis further demonstrates the critical role
of the proposed dataset in driving the performance improvements. | [
0.11560924351215363,
-0.5765641331672668,
0.7812856435775757,
-0.0778527557849884,
0.13189105689525604,
0.1867271065711975,
-0.4837833642959595,
0.05027294531464577,
-0.3228297829627991,
0.5433403849601746,
-0.5755035281181335,
-0.7490957379341125,
-0.586997389793396,
0.08624168485403061,
-0.1291666179895401,
1.1877845525741577,
-0.06949390470981598,
0.41760894656181335,
-0.30250513553619385,
0.2103446125984192,
-0.14251352846622467,
-0.18964891135692596,
-0.4591653048992157,
-0.4543161988258362,
0.5592242479324341,
0.4799645245075226,
0.3947039842605591,
0.8212783336639404,
0.6652217507362366,
0.3494170010089874,
0.011212735436856747,
0.2975066900253296,
-0.7303993701934814,
0.22365926206111908,
-0.43568646907806396,
-0.5223618745803833,
-0.7581468820571899,
0.06060953810811043,
0.5524758100509644,
0.5555654764175415,
-0.2875164747238159,
0.17934684455394745,
0.055882468819618225,
0.8335807919502258,
-0.5510767102241516,
0.4246174693107605,
-0.5753624439239502,
-0.1027241125702858,
-0.32963135838508606,
-0.011973857879638672,
-0.42507120966911316,
-0.19909709692001343,
0.03776824101805687,
-0.7157763242721558,
0.3379870355129242,
-0.1863769143819809,
0.619986355304718,
0.3534430265426636,
-0.6501687169075012,
-0.5622798204421997,
-0.5383195877075195,
0.9505680799484253,
-0.7320824861526489,
0.583709180355072,
0.1292562186717987,
0.33903032541275024,
-0.48843830823898315,
-1.1624268293380737,
-0.14300890266895294,
-0.42453470826148987,
0.25402989983558655,
0.05631373077630997,
0.21227063238620758,
0.3934316039085388,
0.259054034948349,
0.541983425617218,
-0.7511948347091675,
-0.2315240502357483,
-0.44478505849838257,
-0.3653321862220764,
0.15317901968955994,
0.3942773938179016,
0.12864789366722107,
0.23225055634975433,
-0.2828216850757599,
-0.02994743175804615,
-0.6693251729011536,
-0.21028877794742584,
0.12847377359867096,
0.4461711347103119,
0.3119531273841858,
0.5769460797309875,
-0.228323295712471,
0.6585492491722107,
-0.06758127361536026,
-0.08980100601911545,
0.0863037109375,
-0.29568392038345337,
-0.36149415373802185,
0.0634169802069664,
0.4376474618911743,
-0.015419437550008297,
0.22770453989505768,
-0.14676277339458466,
-0.11806178092956543,
0.2666926681995392,
0.28066638112068176,
-1.3249890804290771,
-0.7362082004547119,
0.2558234632015228,
0.09022877365350723,
-0.15372425317764282,
-0.13548246026039124,
-0.6290495991706848,
-0.41948217153549194,
-0.6456304788589478,
0.5006272196769714,
-0.4173019826412201,
0.15504257380962372,
0.027232419699430466,
-0.17779205739498138,
-0.2373654842376709,
0.3687295615673065,
-1.2458959817886353,
0.4981022775173187,
0.7991071343421936,
0.8916277289390564,
-0.37121009826660156,
-0.29235464334487915,
-0.5726212859153748,
0.3738918900489807,
-0.3478367030620575,
0.8983417749404907,
-0.705262303352356,
-0.25319617986679077,
-0.38434261083602905,
0.14475005865097046,
0.020046671852469444,
-0.8224537968635559,
0.5095487833023071,
-0.24620108306407928,
-0.008367395959794521,
-0.3610530495643616,
-0.7611322999000549,
0.22915644943714142,
0.019451826810836792,
-0.6466204524040222,
0.9574819207191467,
0.3834354281425476,
-0.29826992750167847,
0.2365831881761551,
-0.6050723791122437,
-0.3578733503818512,
0.007044768426567316,
-0.1232682541012764,
-0.24075427651405334,
0.2551569938659668,
0.23917631804943085,
0.3703525960445404,
-0.40666207671165466,
0.06407853960990906,
-0.15198512375354767,
-0.4176429212093353,
0.3416242301464081,
-0.29657554626464844,
0.5561968684196472,
0.22028519213199615,
-0.3259040415287018,
0.23177550733089447,
-0.6729657649993896,
0.1922285109758377,
-0.4742802381515503,
-0.5680713057518005,
0.04371687397360802,
-0.2662201225757599,
-0.006151619367301464,
0.2308053970336914,
0.4282229244709015,
-0.4346335828304291,
0.35366570949554443,
-0.25653785467147827,
0.5517844557762146,
1.2143890857696533,
-0.12773874402046204,
0.4888139069080353,
-0.06746578961610794,
0.5839191675186157,
-0.2391514927148819,
0.1634780466556549,
0.01494425255805254,
-0.23097911477088928,
-0.8018457889556885,
-0.656684935092926,
0.3359575867652893,
0.2709810137748718,
-0.5922538042068481,
0.006113267969340086,
-0.35090774297714233,
-0.5634763836860657,
-0.37052205204963684,
0.6977109313011169,
0.34383031725883484,
0.41488972306251526,
0.3345722258090973,
0.2008688598871231,
-0.36826905608177185,
-0.9602002501487732,
-0.4027871787548065,
0.27394190430641174,
0.03668774291872978,
0.35867011547088623,
0.5135683417320251,
-0.4091886281967163,
0.5562363266944885,
-0.737743616104126,
-0.3290356695652008,
-0.16430488228797913,
-0.1059049442410469,
0.40204551815986633,
0.12679414451122284,
0.19408220052719116,
-0.458548903465271,
-0.7218309640884399,
0.23979265987873077,
-0.5707119703292847,
-0.303379625082016,
0.4236335754394531,
-0.6512047052383423,
0.11698771268129349,
0.58382248878479,
-0.5336592197418213,
-0.19950787723064423,
0.7516306638717651,
-0.23185858130455017,
0.4527173638343811,
-0.1985468715429306,
0.24292440712451935,
-0.9832006096839905,
0.07150520384311676,
-0.0694790929555893,
-0.028862331062555313,
-0.7448303699493408,
-0.056747157126665115,
0.2782997190952301,
-0.259825199842453,
-0.6092613339424133,
0.6330834031105042,
-0.35675716400146484,
0.11249120533466339,
-0.40169399976730347,
-0.20822454988956451,
-0.059757109731435776,
0.4208228886127472,
-0.11161038279533386,
0.9404037594795227,
0.5170716047286987,
-0.5436627864837646,
0.44253894686698914,
-0.13107618689537048,
-0.2706746459007263,
0.45442435145378113,
-0.5587447881698608,
-0.06383351981639862,
0.26262563467025757,
0.3491244614124298,
-0.7656827569007874,
-0.6884183287620544,
-0.10380985587835312,
-0.13283567130565643,
0.3539521098136902,
-0.2582921087741852,
-0.5700202584266663,
-0.156662717461586,
-0.10393573343753815,
0.26552844047546387,
0.3282551169395447,
-0.5534531474113464,
0.7170073986053467,
0.1976890116930008,
-0.22758415341377258,
-0.46650969982147217,
-0.29982003569602966,
-0.17366279661655426,
-0.15245424211025238,
-0.579197883605957,
0.18708442151546478,
-0.3587365746498108,
0.06960893422365189,
-0.20742292702198029,
-0.5980561971664429,
-0.21284233033657074,
-0.21277107298374176,
0.4322032630443573,
0.2518932521343231,
-0.15569919347763062,
0.3197774291038513,
0.01385436486452818,
-0.2586650550365448,
-0.17397017776966095,
-0.45077553391456604,
0.5352461934089661,
-0.20378483831882477,
0.054327525198459625,
-0.3159331679344177,
-0.13740739226341248,
0.8675983548164368,
-0.21048511564731598,
0.5995813608169556,
0.39308062195777893,
-0.047026511281728745,
-0.6977386474609375,
-0.1583692729473114,
-0.28937843441963196,
-0.6253324747085571,
0.4518040120601654,
-0.21422792971134186,
-0.9772512912750244,
0.1606593281030655,
-0.39595624804496765,
-0.017765672877430916,
0.1939106285572052,
0.7752898335456848,
-0.07072453200817108,
0.8962236642837524,
0.3413373529911041,
0.07708664983510971,
0.41666585206985474,
-0.3000909686088562,
0.23268352448940277,
-0.6675070524215698,
-0.08320166915655136,
-0.29968175292015076,
-0.07133639603853226,
-0.3535092771053314,
-0.5833794474601746,
0.604918360710144,
-0.26511430740356445,
-0.3921668827533722,
0.2573927640914917,
-0.42852941155433655,
0.8724839687347412,
0.3283866047859192,
0.13753511011600494,
0.18567195534706116,
0.3251532316207886,
-0.12043115496635437,
-0.0965115949511528,
-0.4758428931236267,
-0.459119975566864,
1.400593638420105,
0.08020322024822235,
1.00223708152771,
0.18633097410202026,
0.5801018476486206,
0.16850164532661438,
0.25779905915260315,
-0.6065723896026611,
0.5722442865371704,
-0.4580563008785248,
-0.925116240978241,
-0.23972629010677338,
-0.6806229948997498,
-0.8470054864883423,
0.29169121384620667,
0.13273628056049347,
-0.3487577438354492,
-0.4126449525356293,
0.247995525598526,
0.0158203337341547,
-0.10286465287208557,
-0.7899907827377319,
1.0574625730514526,
-0.3730745315551758,
-0.6852872371673584,
-0.16412530839443207,
-0.20443153381347656,
0.3747931718826294,
-0.14467649161815643,
0.21044482290744781,
-0.2670936584472656,
0.055845607072114944,
0.44834715127944946,
-0.38824644684791565,
0.510659396648407,
-0.061431799083948135,
-0.3774864077568054,
0.07731945067644119,
0.12670473754405975,
0.31953275203704834,
-0.024062158539891243,
-0.18186743557453156,
-0.031864531338214874,
0.15009069442749023,
-0.5711473822593689,
-0.9171426892280579,
1.2982028722763062,
-0.553968608379364,
-0.4215103089809418,
-0.4248518645763397,
-0.7557564973831177,
-0.2643829584121704,
0.2630468010902405,
0.3131178021430969,
0.5147271156311035,
-0.02861686609685421,
0.11567070335149765,
0.7154501676559448,
0.0222312118858099,
0.06299225986003876,
0.48096656799316406,
-0.025486759841442108,
-0.48876240849494934,
1.3264693021774292,
0.19921107590198517,
0.46488067507743835,
0.23318757116794586,
0.08145511895418167,
-0.30883553624153137,
-0.27952441573143005,
-0.39844462275505066,
0.2632969915866852,
-0.8326660394668579,
-0.19628888368606567,
-0.3463188111782074,
-0.1742808222770691,
-0.5840215682983398,
-0.16992010176181793,
-0.5485782027244568,
-0.4828310012817383,
-0.13332650065422058,
-0.09467743337154388,
0.2641713321208954,
0.6925984621047974,
0.09990730881690979,
0.28878894448280334,
-0.6679547429084778,
0.4845833480358124,
0.36783310770988464,
0.5586000084877014,
-0.18015128374099731,
-0.4097743630409241,
-0.642562210559845,
0.09235121309757233,
-0.32047444581985474,
-0.4615684449672699,
0.1752028614282608,
0.4321380853652954,
0.7369447946548462,
0.16026253998279572,
-0.23134884238243103,
0.5977290272712708,
-0.6988500952720642,
0.6902271509170532,
-0.3373478055000305,
-0.8149868249893188,
0.6563346982002258,
-0.5705091953277588,
0.3683265745639801,
0.5459772944450378,
0.2739502787590027,
-0.16485905647277832,
-0.275579571723938,
-0.5043101906776428,
-0.8870038986206055,
0.6720225214958191,
0.38600680232048035,
-0.12919269502162933,
0.17195062339305878,
0.2200525403022766,
0.06632188707590103,
0.316697895526886,
-0.6951717138290405,
-0.18244391679763794,
-0.13876785337924957,
-0.5832985043525696,
-0.25331366062164307,
0.19584321975708008,
-0.2245432585477829,
-0.38273176550865173,
1.023683786392212,
-0.06821734458208084,
-0.030330592766404152,
-0.31215375661849976,
-0.26369017362594604,
0.029838483780622482,
0.3352636396884918,
0.7182179093360901,
0.5624614357948303,
-0.34859710931777954,
0.18047784268856049,
0.024281885474920273,
-0.8095458149909973,
0.354711651802063,
-0.046859260648489,
0.40234681963920593,
-0.375767320394516,
0.36229774355888367,
0.5362876057624817,
0.13377149403095245,
-1.0167790651321411,
0.322939395904541,
0.07749927043914795,
0.012288656085729599,
0.0405106320977211,
0.6787776350975037,
0.05304165929555893,
0.2858034670352936,
0.2265387326478958,
-0.1497262567281723,
0.309248149394989,
-0.689341127872467,
0.2350730150938034,
0.2637921869754791,
-0.1922425925731659,
-0.09928806871175766,
0.35085850954055786,
0.03754277154803276,
0.058055005967617035,
0.6036748290061951,
0.05096554756164551,
-0.4288851320743561,
0.6333959102630615,
0.5500523447990417,
0.5291051268577576,
-0.45364800095558167,
0.15038852393627167,
0.42165735363960266,
0.1378849446773529,
-0.23408879339694977,
0.11367297917604446,
-0.17849819362163544,
-0.24181725084781647,
-0.1356172114610672,
-0.8276450037956238,
-0.3314644694328308,
0.17062045633792877,
-0.4449211359024048,
0.22242827713489532,
-0.6913232803344727,
-0.06767547130584717,
0.11244591325521469,
0.24669180810451508,
-0.39216816425323486,
0.16804978251457214,
-0.1537190079689026,
0.5270006060600281,
-0.910676121711731,
0.8912899494171143,
0.6669397950172424,
-0.10411455482244492,
-0.5943102240562439,
-0.1968107968568802,
0.2670089602470398,
-0.39203575253486633,
0.796842634677887,
0.18764862418174744,
-0.24899201095104218,
0.1830795556306839,
-0.6900581121444702,
-1.0350197553634644,
1.1937668323516846,
0.5799813866615295,
-0.4799182116985321,
0.04097979515790939,
0.20606957376003265,
0.6750316023826599,
-0.244016632437706,
0.05602099373936653,
0.9606980681419373,
0.39955899119377136,
0.23624306917190552,
-0.7514276504516602,
-0.12797395884990692,
-0.3797478973865509,
-0.19159792363643646,
0.43680185079574585,
-0.5929126143455505,
1.05585515499115,
0.013138518668711185,
-0.06575639545917511,
0.2253578007221222,
0.36032670736312866,
0.6123345494270325,
0.1984289139509201,
-0.07898452132940292,
0.5328813791275024,
0.8106076717376709,
-0.21611784398555756,
0.901755690574646,
-0.27489975094795227,
0.27716949582099915,
1.0647788047790527,
-0.3371032178401947,
0.7426489591598511,
0.3410021960735321,
-0.19480615854263306,
0.42774465680122375,
0.5449718832969666,
-0.1964595466852188,
0.6756877899169922,
0.3506966531276703,
-0.48913633823394775,
-0.3427168130874634,
0.08094784617424011,
-0.18819113075733185,
0.2297150045633316,
0.8673242330551147,
-0.3233945071697235,
-0.2976694107055664,
0.03128657117486,
-0.2568855583667755,
-0.09489163011312485,
-0.3707593083381653,
0.4631221890449524,
-0.0499495230615139,
-0.4867378771305084,
0.6201457381248474,
-0.18125461041927338,
0.28142425417900085,
-0.6048497557640076,
-0.3397987186908722,
-0.28663334250450134,
0.4724932610988617,
-0.24960780143737793,
-0.5354501605033875,
-0.41681793332099915,
-0.10426005721092224,
-0.22098837792873383,
0.020698610693216324,
0.42647239565849304,
-0.6107595562934875,
-0.6011326313018799,
-0.05449654534459114,
0.08333709090948105,
0.12168861925601959,
0.11739663779735565,
-0.4883490204811096,
0.11254087090492249,
0.07409384101629257,
-0.04884038120508194,
0.37774986028671265,
0.572814404964447,
0.0536569282412529,
0.719174325466156,
0.8135732412338257,
0.2362934798002243,
0.18650497496128082,
-0.04781587794423103,
0.9353204369544983,
-0.5368969440460205,
-0.24119217693805695,
-0.7337085008621216,
0.489696204662323,
-0.03800360858440399,
-0.2635056674480438,
0.8334061503410339,
0.941737174987793,
0.6988705992698669,
-0.2730019688606262,
0.7660514712333679,
0.44570544362068176,
0.4363529086112976,
-0.8141435384750366,
0.5360385775566101,
-0.4108615219593048,
0.3772706389427185,
-0.2684890031814575,
-1.1620864868164062,
-0.1768299788236618,
0.6972892880439758,
-0.06730667501688004,
0.2355985939502716,
0.8137795925140381,
1.078789472579956,
-0.36359792947769165,
-0.1836583912372589,
0.2420012503862381,
0.4640992283821106,
0.6913831233978271,
0.5906502604484558,
0.7322617769241333,
-0.32874423265457153,
0.4352417588233948,
-0.132897287607193,
-0.12066271156072617,
-0.16473667323589325,
-0.5157425403594971,
-1.1507848501205444,
-0.512572705745697,
0.006134858354926109,
-0.30905285477638245,
0.18346673250198364,
0.9514211416244507,
0.6088676452636719,
-0.7746827602386475,
-0.5430267453193665,
-0.32128027081489563,
-0.3292752206325531,
0.032664332538843155,
-0.1870792657136917,
0.480328232049942,
-0.5820426940917969,
-0.8730310797691345,
0.6356876492500305,
0.39533641934394836,
0.018739651888608932,
-0.09252205491065979,
-0.19362251460552216,
0.13544629514217377,
0.20130689442157745,
0.5845004320144653,
0.10584608465433121,
-0.7105635404586792,
0.13199631869792938,
0.18714366853237152,
-0.33580195903778076,
0.003824960207566619,
0.9613627195358276,
-0.5289285182952881,
0.4894745647907257,
0.2769252061843872,
0.45628800988197327,
0.7254406809806824,
-0.12832897901535034,
0.653282105922699,
-0.6516798734664917,
-0.028209006413817406,
0.16435299813747406,
0.15335771441459656,
0.33248206973075867,
-0.2567327916622162,
0.6666341423988342,
-0.008569221012294292,
-0.9132482409477234,
-0.7751791477203369,
0.10509393364191055,
-0.9681780338287354,
-0.6033211350440979,
1.1708072423934937,
0.11928771436214447,
-0.35887575149536133,
0.20892414450645447,
-0.488200306892395,
0.26091107726097107,
-0.6604897975921631,
0.7539543509483337,
0.9730222225189209,
-0.5373391509056091,
-0.0995473638176918,
-0.761444628238678,
0.8332274556159973,
0.3484731912612915,
-0.9820913672447205,
0.4028429687023163,
0.8846014738082886,
0.5128962397575378,
-0.10703573375940323,
0.4025956988334656,
-0.01014727633446455,
0.4366151690483093,
-0.06383846700191498,
-0.17194966971874237,
-0.17163841426372528,
-0.7145464420318604,
-0.23861967027187347,
-0.06548705697059631,
0.20321033895015717,
0.2888699471950531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09390v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09390v2 | HGOT: Hierarchical Graph of Thoughts for Retrieval-Augmented In-Context Learning in Factuality Evaluation | 2024-02-14T18:41:19 | 2024-07-02T12:42:59 | Yihao Fang, Stephen W. Thomas, Xiaodan Zhu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | With the widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) in numerous
applications, the challenge of factuality and the propensity for hallucinations
has emerged as a significant concern. To address this issue, particularly in
retrieval-augmented in-context learning, we introduce the hierarchical graph of
thoughts (HGOT), a structured, multi-layered graph approach designed to enhance
the retrieval of pertinent passages during in-context learning. The framework
utilizes the emergent planning capabilities of LLMs, employing the
divide-and-conquer strategy to break down complex queries into manageable
sub-queries. It refines self-consistency majority voting for answer selection,
which incorporates the recently proposed citation recall and precision metrics
to assess the quality of thoughts, linking an answer's credibility
intrinsically to the thought's quality. This methodology introduces a weighted
system in majority voting, prioritizing answers based on the citation quality
of their thoughts. Additionally, we propose a scoring mechanism for evaluating
retrieved passages, considering factors such as citation frequency and quality,
self-consistency confidence, and the retrieval module's ranking. Experiments
indicate that HGOT excels as a versatile approach, outperforming competing
models in FEVER by up to $7\%$ and matching leading models such as
Retrieve-then-Read in Open-SQuAD, and DSP in HotPotQA, demonstrating its
efficacy in enhancing LLMs' factuality. | [
-0.38861432671546936,
-1.265320062637329,
0.8717538714408875,
0.03879399970173836,
-0.2705957591533661,
0.35576003789901733,
-0.18794432282447815,
-0.3496093153953552,
0.5434699654579163,
0.3768879473209381,
-0.36139556765556335,
-0.5574829578399658,
-0.5047965049743652,
-0.03231631591916084,
-0.24701976776123047,
1.1121586561203003,
0.1282843053340912,
-0.422902911901474,
-0.2190549522638321,
0.022925620898604393,
-0.4296106696128845,
-0.6632960438728333,
-0.37019094824790955,
-0.5001264214515686,
0.5869362950325012,
0.2771328091621399,
0.6385493874549866,
0.4669894576072693,
0.6420935392379761,
0.2260112464427948,
-0.08260346949100494,
0.2526308298110962,
-0.7183065414428711,
0.3407898247241974,
-0.41918015480041504,
0.06743599474430084,
-0.6674124002456665,
0.07425777614116669,
0.6549387574195862,
0.746947705745697,
-0.2867094874382019,
0.09352037310600281,
0.23820354044437408,
0.6960539221763611,
-0.7176752090454102,
0.2551320791244507,
-0.7780656218528748,
0.127811461687088,
0.04450475424528122,
-0.5240931510925293,
-0.5235182046890259,
-0.3446275293827057,
0.438071608543396,
-0.5130617618560791,
-0.011441786773502827,
0.32657331228256226,
0.6578059792518616,
0.19931912422180176,
-0.46015772223472595,
-0.3409675657749176,
-0.41640928387641907,
0.4928480386734009,
-0.3864065110683441,
0.4977346658706665,
0.25629696249961853,
0.153257817029953,
-0.15699179470539093,
-0.7869857549667358,
-0.4355732500553131,
-0.32890740036964417,
-0.11999015510082245,
0.39366620779037476,
0.12051775306463242,
0.08960531651973724,
0.2031196504831314,
0.3882521390914917,
-0.6343883275985718,
-0.5313190817832947,
0.0749492421746254,
-0.2033063918352127,
0.29223042726516724,
0.00334848091006279,
0.16505485773086548,
-0.6872093081474304,
-0.6464427709579468,
0.22387133538722992,
-0.5892309546470642,
-0.39136871695518494,
-0.0039572142995893955,
0.3626794219017029,
0.2538353502750397,
0.4809397757053375,
-0.24625399708747864,
0.49736055731773376,
0.2403499335050583,
-0.32926592230796814,
0.3381118178367615,
-0.22329102456569672,
-0.3079123795032501,
0.07223411649465561,
0.5772161483764648,
-0.0038725901395082474,
-0.19890420138835907,
-0.4238507151603699,
-0.27272844314575195,
-0.38719600439071655,
0.5399534702301025,
-0.8127264976501465,
-0.38636231422424316,
0.025381525978446007,
-0.4023192226886749,
-0.12176471203565598,
-0.02209906093776226,
-0.8273452520370483,
-0.32208842039108276,
-0.4632546007633209,
0.6993315815925598,
-0.6192761659622192,
-0.23212361335754395,
-0.0923195630311966,
0.031119242310523987,
-0.2091410756111145,
0.44585126638412476,
-0.801496148109436,
0.3915744125843048,
0.598548412322998,
0.866664469242096,
-0.36961179971694946,
-0.44912484288215637,
-0.47401678562164307,
0.14824463427066803,
-0.3103310763835907,
0.8252971172332764,
-0.5267441868782043,
-0.32047292590141296,
-0.08248645812273026,
-0.2593817114830017,
-0.3220738172531128,
-0.4898169934749603,
0.48775041103363037,
-0.8034818768501282,
0.09651745110750198,
-0.6652580499649048,
-0.6853366494178772,
-0.21303550899028778,
0.9412882924079895,
-0.5289818048477173,
1.127290964126587,
0.15473198890686035,
-1.0477317571640015,
0.3031408488750458,
-0.5706943869590759,
-0.32791972160339355,
0.3625037670135498,
-0.35892003774642944,
-0.14446479082107544,
-0.3203407824039459,
0.07763051986694336,
0.18078486621379852,
-0.016869552433490753,
0.2272481620311737,
-0.2217162400484085,
-0.39510440826416016,
-0.13585694134235382,
-0.27183517813682556,
0.6067879796028137,
0.07792561501264572,
-0.5275561809539795,
0.332884281873703,
-0.4353220462799072,
0.18126913905143738,
0.01497498806566,
-0.4863598048686981,
-0.31752318143844604,
0.03445586934685707,
-0.2652817368507385,
0.2012060433626175,
0.3024659752845764,
-0.4616183340549469,
0.19053666293621063,
-0.2785814702510834,
0.23975993692874908,
0.5471712946891785,
0.3569726347923279,
0.25440293550491333,
-0.13912370800971985,
0.23882153630256653,
-0.04100796580314636,
0.1792740672826767,
0.05317256972193718,
-0.5147072076797485,
-0.5775007605552673,
-0.21170680224895477,
0.057851020246744156,
0.521848738193512,
-0.8594618439674377,
0.5459364652633667,
-0.2745742201805115,
-0.30364853143692017,
-0.33375829458236694,
0.0895078107714653,
0.32742342352867126,
1.106850504875183,
0.4766395390033722,
-0.09394903481006622,
-0.3989713191986084,
-0.7930163145065308,
0.025340203195810318,
-0.45897817611694336,
0.35182875394821167,
0.32589417695999146,
1.0076192617416382,
-0.49023208022117615,
0.9347633123397827,
-0.6115997433662415,
-0.18738536536693573,
-0.06203741207718849,
0.26864874362945557,
0.03746531531214714,
0.27825742959976196,
0.23400147259235382,
-0.7930927872657776,
-0.31463056802749634,
0.0226602740585804,
-0.9756710529327393,
0.2386578768491745,
0.2103745937347412,
-0.5283955335617065,
-0.005284297280013561,
0.3181401789188385,
-0.5649770498275757,
0.22180607914924622,
0.09585247188806534,
-0.224288672208786,
0.7072979807853699,
-0.10502060502767563,
0.4302361309528351,
-1.0271035432815552,
0.10974673926830292,
-0.1887841522693634,
-0.27591919898986816,
-0.23222491145133972,
0.3678015172481537,
0.07671463489532471,
0.08831699937582016,
-0.09157327562570572,
0.2488103061914444,
-0.23766350746154785,
-0.006208141800016165,
-0.27766120433807373,
0.5102263689041138,
-0.02151567116379738,
0.5521159172058105,
-0.05324946343898773,
0.7753605246543884,
0.34229475259780884,
-0.20708507299423218,
0.21509602665901184,
0.281332790851593,
-0.43001317977905273,
0.5917189121246338,
-0.2555240988731384,
0.5209946036338806,
-0.10617297887802124,
0.3239651322364807,
-0.8853238224983215,
-0.2171424925327301,
0.1835835725069046,
-0.2255927324295044,
0.1364704817533493,
-0.2960411012172699,
-0.5382228493690491,
-0.23859909176826477,
-0.18193677067756653,
0.34582266211509705,
0.3258873522281647,
-0.7417686581611633,
0.4529876112937927,
0.6413500905036926,
-0.1258782148361206,
-0.845201849937439,
-0.2060849368572235,
0.28655773401260376,
-0.08908456563949585,
-0.3964765965938568,
0.38364365696907043,
-0.1740635633468628,
-0.2833941876888275,
0.108737051486969,
-0.1409120112657547,
0.07375175505876541,
-0.07510942965745926,
0.03361519053578377,
0.3349493741989136,
-0.13646718859672546,
0.22620245814323425,
0.0176860224455595,
0.19400566816329956,
0.13712678849697113,
-0.720767080783844,
0.47787368297576904,
-0.6140488982200623,
-0.33629995584487915,
0.1285841017961502,
0.2370111048221588,
0.33886420726776123,
-0.13853682577610016,
0.3694939613342285,
0.4444711208343506,
-0.6299747824668884,
-0.1969597190618515,
-0.5662598013877869,
-0.005284052807837725,
-0.3797154426574707,
0.31498482823371887,
-0.4832450747489929,
-1.0103708505630493,
0.4554935395717621,
-0.07388017326593399,
-0.14601139724254608,
0.4276300072669983,
0.839065670967102,
-0.3277280628681183,
0.827275812625885,
0.4120365083217621,
-0.11314707249403,
0.4449251592159271,
-0.44800519943237305,
0.2374773472547531,
-1.046247124671936,
-0.4854479432106018,
-0.11403153836727142,
-0.1152087077498436,
-0.4805484712123871,
-0.3417792320251465,
0.7024345993995667,
-0.1077403649687767,
-0.30469754338264465,
0.003803928615525365,
-0.4837011694908142,
0.5920659303665161,
0.30054381489753723,
0.4565163552761078,
0.43656158447265625,
0.10816516727209091,
-0.4129107594490051,
-0.009195921942591667,
-0.5762497782707214,
-0.475605845451355,
0.8318713307380676,
0.10448215901851654,
0.5095974802970886,
0.14357033371925354,
0.9086267352104187,
0.4979078471660614,
0.4614945352077484,
-1.0294185876846313,
0.5817171931266785,
0.3237434923648834,
-0.8736451864242554,
-0.5968121290206909,
-0.5707266926765442,
-0.7668799161911011,
0.7643426656723022,
-0.15629160404205322,
-0.8691717386245728,
0.11139465123414993,
-0.045891840010881424,
-0.28322267532348633,
0.4048316776752472,
-0.4241761863231659,
0.697424590587616,
-0.017016449943184853,
-0.5743502974510193,
-0.2967156767845154,
-0.622728705406189,
0.47730308771133423,
-0.02317516691982746,
0.10076834261417389,
0.15566584467887878,
0.23140095174312592,
0.8138795495033264,
-0.2427593320608139,
0.5486992001533508,
-0.06499067693948746,
-0.08536097407341003,
0.6722623705863953,
0.2907629609107971,
0.46609267592430115,
0.17656023800373077,
-0.11004867404699326,
-0.0902705043554306,
-0.03080204874277115,
-0.4206545352935791,
-0.7573047876358032,
0.7000230550765991,
-0.6358548402786255,
-0.7373679876327515,
-0.48825803399086,
-0.6935956478118896,
-0.3851534426212311,
0.5494285821914673,
0.24692218005657196,
0.4887641966342926,
-0.3875918388366699,
0.1068534106016159,
0.74003005027771,
0.2777425944805145,
0.19140903651714325,
0.07178406417369843,
-0.4332003891468048,
-0.659587562084198,
0.900575578212738,
0.40448233485221863,
0.30433428287506104,
0.4036604166030884,
0.3066038191318512,
-0.4459213316440582,
-0.6344444155693054,
-0.35513976216316223,
0.25871336460113525,
-1.1416454315185547,
-0.08383649587631226,
-0.6852178573608398,
-0.3835122287273407,
-0.31519991159439087,
0.1390293389558792,
-0.08571643382310867,
-0.27935922145843506,
0.25253140926361084,
-0.3923960328102112,
-0.011858255602419376,
0.7671678066253662,
0.16420574486255646,
0.10915371030569077,
-0.3343491554260254,
0.23476478457450867,
0.38100099563598633,
0.30848756432533264,
0.12362291663885117,
-0.5831761360168457,
-0.46622198820114136,
-0.1042291671037674,
-0.5753880739212036,
-0.9165419340133667,
0.3324030339717865,
-0.0946088656783104,
0.4367477595806122,
0.1622307300567627,
-0.04738740995526314,
0.8095170855522156,
-0.49738723039627075,
0.5728292465209961,
-0.02205587737262249,
-0.7900072932243347,
0.6236918568611145,
-0.45302483439445496,
-0.07060352712869644,
0.8159656524658203,
0.37284719944000244,
-0.2531808316707611,
-0.2781786024570465,
-0.692020833492279,
-0.6347488164901733,
0.19948212802410126,
0.2561381161212921,
-0.24748122692108154,
-0.2278895080089569,
0.5105607509613037,
0.0490243025124073,
0.38931480050086975,
-0.5684143900871277,
-0.038762886077165604,
-0.3756478726863861,
-0.02887667529284954,
0.19533303380012512,
-0.25267499685287476,
-0.3435206413269043,
-0.5731571316719055,
0.5439947247505188,
-0.42314133048057556,
0.23095043003559113,
0.5003315806388855,
-0.23105919361114502,
-0.16071690618991852,
0.34596067667007446,
0.07632576674222946,
0.8532416224479675,
-0.7350896000862122,
0.49151772260665894,
0.2160770446062088,
-0.6439803838729858,
0.05616040155291557,
-0.26375913619995117,
-0.32459455728530884,
-0.20765380561351776,
0.48483946919441223,
0.6145786643028259,
0.2870040237903595,
-0.3276813328266144,
0.3860680162906647,
0.2354743629693985,
-0.16202473640441895,
-0.08555791527032852,
-0.11845181882381439,
-0.014101996086537838,
0.1753627359867096,
0.3741894066333771,
0.12632593512535095,
0.6071559190750122,
-1.0139789581298828,
0.38323312997817993,
0.33778116106987,
-0.5202599167823792,
-0.20856165885925293,
0.39520519971847534,
0.09110977500677109,
-0.25653788447380066,
0.8910834193229675,
-0.47528550028800964,
-0.7845298647880554,
0.3101748824119568,
0.829096257686615,
0.9579757452011108,
0.1390933245420456,
0.269243985414505,
0.4721944332122803,
0.4197280704975128,
-0.022425176575779915,
0.3999536335468292,
-0.19135357439517975,
-0.7465510368347168,
-0.3134450316429138,
-0.5486658811569214,
-0.6501361131668091,
0.01898791640996933,
-0.5523994565010071,
-0.1945732831954956,
-0.4618628919124603,
-0.4592272937297821,
-0.29805129766464233,
0.4024020731449127,
-0.328674852848053,
0.3541925847530365,
0.21175552904605865,
0.7236925959587097,
-0.524111807346344,
1.0059152841567993,
0.5644002556800842,
-0.5142398476600647,
-0.642909586429596,
0.38320139050483704,
-0.013302809558808804,
-0.46399834752082825,
0.5339047908782959,
-0.030960746109485626,
-0.5297457575798035,
0.14737628400325775,
-0.34797903895378113,
-1.053816556930542,
1.1125621795654297,
0.39449670910835266,
-0.2947092354297638,
-0.23881731927394867,
-0.3035953938961029,
0.48913994431495667,
-0.5178034901618958,
0.27579131722450256,
0.7422752976417542,
0.4326109290122986,
0.3398872911930084,
-0.6422789096832275,
0.14796237647533417,
-0.20263417065143585,
-0.43879586458206177,
0.05188707634806633,
-0.6155936121940613,
0.8289806842803955,
-0.4284675717353821,
-0.23197726905345917,
-0.39890256524086,
0.733670175075531,
0.5651556849479675,
0.4029488265514374,
0.5999361276626587,
0.47596651315689087,
1.3583714962005615,
0.04830440878868103,
1.0562596321105957,
-0.10813768208026886,
0.5688282251358032,
1.0980621576309204,
-0.3633424937725067,
0.9680551290512085,
0.42692261934280396,
-0.0068155196495354176,
0.8134381175041199,
0.7294819951057434,
0.36385488510131836,
0.5539317727088928,
-0.015778329223394394,
-0.08375339955091476,
-0.327791690826416,
-0.04394836351275444,
-0.24831196665763855,
0.012915733270347118,
0.4075545370578766,
0.0649288222193718,
-0.18042263388633728,
-0.12513892352581024,
0.02350717969238758,
0.043819453567266464,
-0.09320949763059616,
0.571667492389679,
0.160302072763443,
-0.7166885733604431,
0.6994208693504333,
-0.4431026577949524,
0.38207197189331055,
-0.23385684192180634,
-0.025049110874533653,
-0.12802492082118988,
0.027546057477593422,
-0.3702522814273834,
-0.8352073431015015,
0.12086349725723267,
-0.0962454080581665,
-0.29138344526290894,
-0.10438444465398788,
0.6450456380844116,
-0.35935577750205994,
-0.4133404493331909,
0.48578038811683655,
0.7136380672454834,
0.08963627368211746,
-0.17185017466545105,
-0.8424180150032043,
-0.08612237870693207,
-0.301282674074173,
-0.45749780535697937,
0.274616003036499,
0.5778303146362305,
-0.04458335041999817,
0.6135453581809998,
0.3370707035064697,
0.10688970237970352,
-0.019830303266644478,
0.34088805317878723,
0.7717767357826233,
-0.5509555339813232,
-0.44388559460639954,
-0.8919284343719482,
0.11907632648944855,
-0.25797656178474426,
-0.20146521925926208,
0.9018492102622986,
0.7714005708694458,
0.7490838170051575,
0.2312508076429367,
0.7644580006599426,
-0.08615649491548538,
0.29344266653060913,
-0.542719841003418,
0.7877461314201355,
-0.4722050428390503,
0.15364722907543182,
-0.6078343391418457,
-0.8708527684211731,
-0.09225887060165405,
0.6647878885269165,
-0.5994502305984497,
0.09790889918804169,
1.214741587638855,
0.5617535710334778,
0.0017180893337354064,
0.05904605984687805,
0.34359875321388245,
0.2519058585166931,
0.42632707953453064,
0.35028696060180664,
1.0669106245040894,
-0.4201653301715851,
0.2941218912601471,
-0.21335235238075256,
-0.3992927372455597,
-0.23199839890003204,
-0.6169572472572327,
-0.8258385062217712,
-0.7293277382850647,
-0.3047626316547394,
-0.4618602693080902,
0.08687461167573929,
1.248831868171692,
0.8469322323799133,
-0.5146782994270325,
-0.383748859167099,
0.20996983349323273,
0.4133884608745575,
-0.23227116465568542,
-0.19940033555030823,
0.6850168108940125,
-0.69913649559021,
-0.4565708339214325,
0.5229042172431946,
0.49466148018836975,
-0.24832062423229218,
-0.16675692796707153,
-0.15991772711277008,
-0.44895628094673157,
0.22557534277439117,
1.0655888319015503,
-0.20024508237838745,
-0.7184515595436096,
-0.5795952081680298,
0.19331389665603638,
-0.32004448771476746,
0.32963863015174866,
0.7963197827339172,
-0.8879982233047485,
0.5726630687713623,
0.5498904585838318,
0.5504195094108582,
0.7113457918167114,
0.30821865797042847,
-0.011473355814814568,
-0.4177975356578827,
-0.1281754970550537,
0.46263402700424194,
0.4518175423145294,
0.24663245677947998,
-0.4929002523422241,
0.5795831680297852,
0.553101658821106,
-0.6456295847892761,
-0.7795902490615845,
0.12845176458358765,
-0.998278021812439,
-0.27593132853507996,
0.9748224020004272,
-0.021787630394101143,
-0.35055455565452576,
-0.15506954491138458,
-0.3530644476413727,
0.17108529806137085,
-0.21496441960334778,
1.1263235807418823,
0.8839776515960693,
-0.3556385338306427,
0.1941588670015335,
-0.6114618182182312,
0.44658994674682617,
0.1915905922651291,
-0.8774120807647705,
0.15154075622558594,
0.5281906127929688,
0.1871935874223709,
0.3554852306842804,
0.8748170137405396,
-0.1422143429517746,
-0.018722258508205414,
0.03413268178701401,
-0.17811109125614166,
0.13923953473567963,
-0.8389360308647156,
0.14076873660087585,
0.571905255317688,
0.007092503365129232,
0.16026932001113892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09371v1 | Transformers Can Achieve Length Generalization But Not Robustly | 2024-02-14T18:18:29 | 2024-02-14T18:18:29 | Yongchao Zhou, Uri Alon, Xinyun Chen, Xuezhi Wang, Rishabh Agarwal, Denny Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Length generalization, defined as the ability to extrapolate from shorter
training sequences to longer test ones, is a significant challenge for language
models. This issue persists even with large-scale Transformers handling
relatively straightforward tasks. In this paper, we test the Transformer's
ability of length generalization using the task of addition of two integers. We
show that the success of length generalization is intricately linked to the
data format and the type of position encoding. Using the right combination of
data format and position encodings, we show for the first time that standard
Transformers can extrapolate to a sequence length that is 2.5x the input
length. Nevertheless, unlike in-distribution generalization, length
generalization remains fragile, significantly influenced by factors like random
weight initialization and training data order, leading to large variances
across different random seeds. | [
-0.49313026666641235,
-0.47051769495010376,
0.5167639255523682,
0.5562695860862732,
-0.3195056617259979,
0.0811048224568367,
-0.5236414074897766,
-0.5451211333274841,
0.06563414633274078,
0.014125734567642212,
-0.07914700359106064,
-0.006351051852107048,
-0.9987236261367798,
0.2285350263118744,
-0.7478645443916321,
1.0174167156219482,
0.12975002825260162,
-0.29100844264030457,
0.17875820398330688,
-0.24178743362426758,
-0.37483057379722595,
-0.5686162710189819,
-0.3197638988494873,
-0.13183748722076416,
0.4575944244861603,
0.4507501721382141,
1.3690118789672852,
0.7233332991600037,
0.8515772819519043,
0.35287952423095703,
0.05656306818127632,
0.010270981118083,
-0.292208194732666,
0.08239593356847763,
0.12240330129861832,
-0.8794638514518738,
-0.22864697873592377,
-0.2036106437444687,
0.9863344430923462,
0.7830979824066162,
-0.10075468569993973,
0.136064812541008,
-0.2815052270889282,
0.8275898098945618,
-0.2200399935245514,
-0.03743629530072212,
-0.44636401534080505,
0.1409621685743332,
-0.16503889858722687,
-0.00561942346394062,
-0.4770392179489136,
-0.3248561918735504,
0.11376190930604935,
-0.39009764790534973,
0.5368467569351196,
-0.03483186289668083,
0.9089016914367676,
0.3449084758758545,
-0.39256590604782104,
-0.2352089285850525,
-1.5019675493240356,
0.8965278267860413,
-0.5264238715171814,
0.6260994076728821,
0.2279329150915146,
0.5570491552352905,
0.10768759995698929,
-0.5690274834632874,
-0.7060879468917847,
-0.1680251806974411,
-0.3240128457546234,
-0.10350214689970016,
-0.10972040891647339,
-0.08123117685317993,
0.7534654140472412,
0.426082581281662,
-0.5732476711273193,
0.16477470099925995,
-0.6831002831459045,
0.21136914193630219,
0.8191662430763245,
0.11691692471504211,
0.15597261488437653,
0.061956074088811874,
-0.03771509975194931,
-0.6897956728935242,
-0.3197529911994934,
0.45304471254348755,
0.8132763504981995,
0.012968387454748154,
-0.24598078429698944,
0.7524296045303345,
-0.045174483209848404,
0.5649954080581665,
0.24428585171699524,
0.13728860020637512,
0.22576913237571716,
-0.20739343762397766,
0.05962757021188736,
-0.22134695947170258,
0.7094732522964478,
0.4044313430786133,
0.46756839752197266,
-0.1783626228570938,
-0.04858847334980965,
0.016180353239178658,
0.2360505610704422,
-0.7396649122238159,
-0.08059274405241013,
0.1716577559709549,
-0.3392168879508972,
-0.10962669551372528,
0.44752055406570435,
-0.71021568775177,
-0.015567250549793243,
-0.07048846036195755,
0.29057082533836365,
-0.41484907269477844,
0.11675548553466797,
0.4284636378288269,
-0.4975927174091339,
0.6641640663146973,
-0.16691088676452637,
-1.4494972229003906,
0.44066354632377625,
0.7150737047195435,
0.7496589422225952,
-0.13249722123146057,
-0.2713839113712311,
-0.2775442898273468,
-0.08040294051170349,
-0.4904983341693878,
0.64322429895401,
-0.6733462810516357,
-0.5647667050361633,
-0.2507970929145813,
0.0474957637488842,
0.1434883326292038,
-0.3340972661972046,
0.4179174602031708,
-0.5542363524436951,
0.17305974662303925,
0.14166605472564697,
-0.347850501537323,
0.21734507381916046,
-0.11355660110712051,
-0.6201023459434509,
0.9507648348808289,
0.5545649528503418,
-0.5782527327537537,
0.5803435444831848,
-0.6085812449455261,
-0.6733965873718262,
-0.16196481883525848,
-0.33980420231819153,
-0.7065371870994568,
0.5096263885498047,
0.1533755660057068,
0.2636462152004242,
-0.223262220621109,
0.38656488060951233,
-0.20270945131778717,
-0.8349295854568481,
0.4412015378475189,
-0.7193864583969116,
0.4408843517303467,
-0.17886510491371155,
-0.37885230779647827,
-0.1290379911661148,
-0.8152251243591309,
-0.08989670127630234,
0.20750035345554352,
-0.48248112201690674,
-0.07904347032308578,
0.035693638026714325,
-0.21105808019638062,
0.08794521540403366,
0.008193565532565117,
-0.710368275642395,
0.6439272165298462,
-0.6198172569274902,
0.22603924572467804,
0.5091406106948853,
-0.34707343578338623,
0.7317097783088684,
-0.24790233373641968,
0.514836311340332,
-0.14108042418956757,
0.19754192233085632,
-0.02146524004638195,
-0.48469260334968567,
-0.9426185488700867,
0.05960940197110176,
0.5721486806869507,
0.5877643823623657,
-0.7123148441314697,
0.5137614011764526,
-0.9601467251777649,
-0.5934033393859863,
-0.1872907131910324,
-0.1680852323770523,
-0.03504238277673721,
0.019670862704515457,
0.5272095799446106,
-0.2569010257720947,
-0.5866583585739136,
-1.0669177770614624,
-0.2761876583099365,
-0.15921342372894287,
-0.7387067675590515,
-0.08328955620527267,
0.3625830411911011,
-0.30260252952575684,
1.0636565685272217,
-0.7065119743347168,
0.1125749796628952,
-0.2601364552974701,
0.09230918437242508,
0.5909364819526672,
0.42020970582962036,
0.47691017389297485,
-0.698447585105896,
-0.4003615975379944,
-0.09057559818029404,
-0.6919533014297485,
0.2967150807380676,
-0.16554568707942963,
0.5055066347122192,
-0.22144488990306854,
0.08486448228359222,
-0.6375724673271179,
0.558835506439209,
0.5907918810844421,
-0.24315056204795837,
0.4766096770763397,
-0.4416675865650177,
-0.11050672084093094,
-0.858540415763855,
-0.3229736387729645,
0.0018873496446758509,
-0.11790916323661804,
-0.788421630859375,
-0.12949422001838684,
0.12588825821876526,
-0.16053064167499542,
-0.24429449439048767,
0.023100197315216064,
-0.05361127853393555,
-0.22519126534461975,
-0.22980737686157227,
-0.4792792797088623,
0.02582911215722561,
0.4043920636177063,
-0.05475052073597908,
0.7040599584579468,
0.4217483401298523,
-0.6058601140975952,
0.5789929032325745,
0.14624768495559692,
-0.19878675043582916,
0.3242798447608948,
-0.9604987502098083,
0.1283140778541565,
-0.35491952300071716,
0.32742494344711304,
-0.8345856070518494,
-0.43420276045799255,
-0.1784970462322235,
-0.4804105758666992,
0.36252400279045105,
-0.1257621794939041,
-0.6374037265777588,
-0.6686013340950012,
-0.3029794692993164,
0.6361402273178101,
0.9061110019683838,
-0.4095008671283722,
0.51180499792099,
-0.16524888575077057,
-0.1185876801609993,
-0.6222818493843079,
-0.8549999594688416,
-0.05927153676748276,
-0.46311116218566895,
-0.8441256880760193,
0.32357943058013916,
-0.09300471097230911,
-0.16399776935577393,
-0.5338770151138306,
-0.06942376494407654,
-0.10417471826076508,
-0.13911482691764832,
0.041560765355825424,
-0.016540847718715668,
-0.14374403655529022,
0.16614289581775665,
0.2769729495048523,
-0.25885188579559326,
0.18829715251922607,
0.0030569329392164946,
0.5372700691223145,
-0.1001075878739357,
-0.5545245409011841,
-0.3576815128326416,
0.5363815426826477,
0.5685657262802124,
0.1360238790512085,
0.579447865486145,
0.659055769443512,
-0.3047473132610321,
-0.15850616991519928,
-0.3573587238788605,
-0.26666679978370667,
-0.5665596127510071,
0.4376937747001648,
-0.403010755777359,
-0.8085343837738037,
0.3566026985645294,
0.1846776157617569,
0.010054326616227627,
0.6018399596214294,
0.10781889408826828,
-0.08834483474493027,
1.2270896434783936,
0.7950381636619568,
0.2704031467437744,
0.16581320762634277,
-0.40852421522140503,
0.4403579533100128,
-0.5805803537368774,
-0.0923011377453804,
-0.486100435256958,
-0.620406985282898,
-0.7756744027137756,
-0.3487381637096405,
0.07279787957668304,
-0.026069913059473038,
-0.15397362411022186,
0.7780643701553345,
-0.5022079348564148,
0.5181858539581299,
0.5265052318572998,
-0.011615882627665997,
0.07233981788158417,
-0.07060917466878891,
0.2574954032897949,
-0.32316622138023376,
-0.38030552864074707,
-0.11192768812179565,
1.1068989038467407,
0.6439839005470276,
0.9425352215766907,
0.3490259051322937,
0.3821799159049988,
0.2568860352039337,
-0.025150630623102188,
-1.0728939771652222,
0.19961798191070557,
-0.5084530115127563,
-0.14150401949882507,
-0.7264591455459595,
-0.34312668442726135,
-0.8542643189430237,
-0.09284119307994843,
0.03896524757146835,
-0.4445755183696747,
0.6157621741294861,
-0.06342925876379013,
-0.3035255968570709,
0.2762840986251831,
-0.6297531723976135,
0.26660555601119995,
-0.37818264961242676,
0.2588486671447754,
0.1353674978017807,
-0.7932404279708862,
0.1556270718574524,
-0.2635345757007599,
0.22632688283920288,
0.003144301241263747,
0.058309074491262436,
0.8460323214530945,
-0.45063403248786926,
0.5094665288925171,
0.10525380074977875,
-0.08943568915128708,
0.16974496841430664,
-0.1183585524559021,
0.6433342695236206,
0.2782307267189026,
0.16999846696853638,
0.17928409576416016,
-0.26568126678466797,
-0.6821456551551819,
-1.0725542306900024,
0.2937624454498291,
-0.8405472040176392,
-0.7281265258789062,
-0.25010785460472107,
-0.6900947690010071,
-0.3794254660606384,
-0.054031290113925934,
0.5986626148223877,
0.3539094030857086,
0.10885564237833023,
0.6262907981872559,
0.6482351422309875,
-0.027883505448698997,
0.7986270785331726,
0.1598997563123703,
-0.07369624078273773,
-0.3609774708747864,
0.9427808523178101,
0.28525179624557495,
0.41080760955810547,
0.4568865895271301,
0.4309813380241394,
-0.4861607849597931,
-0.3918686807155609,
-0.5024114847183228,
-0.10168442875146866,
-0.5601502060890198,
0.12845344841480255,
-0.5259760618209839,
-0.3864101767539978,
-0.2944439947605133,
-0.2355354279279709,
-0.43612587451934814,
-0.7862938642501831,
0.13447952270507812,
-0.34659919142723083,
0.32588663697242737,
0.9825263619422913,
-0.23783186078071594,
0.5583315491676331,
-0.8284855484962463,
0.4063892662525177,
0.7385573387145996,
0.549994945526123,
-0.18111467361450195,
-0.7591379284858704,
-0.20354492962360382,
-0.012975785881280899,
-0.272644966840744,
-0.6011176705360413,
0.07628685235977173,
0.3210257589817047,
0.1226864904165268,
0.6480968594551086,
-0.26882636547088623,
0.5284228920936584,
-0.7223782539367676,
0.9005064964294434,
0.30174341797828674,
-0.6559138894081116,
0.2273772954940796,
-0.3050055205821991,
0.373384565114975,
0.2807808220386505,
0.4225783944129944,
-0.484223872423172,
-0.12575629353523254,
-0.7975998520851135,
-0.8555211424827576,
0.3727574050426483,
0.5226200819015503,
0.7550740242004395,
-0.13101637363433838,
0.16253535449504852,
0.25457456707954407,
-0.12330354005098343,
-0.3837149143218994,
-0.6180768609046936,
-0.46458256244659424,
-0.0811099112033844,
-0.2656603157520294,
-0.47112149000167847,
0.04574538394808769,
-0.2702122926712036,
0.2065528929233551,
-0.05228361487388611,
0.4937887489795685,
0.11307431012392044,
-0.041371505707502365,
0.2328801304101944,
0.6587129831314087,
0.7838588953018188,
0.7106001377105713,
-0.15965700149536133,
0.20403622090816498,
0.38032859563827515,
-0.6323525309562683,
0.5732329487800598,
0.1573776751756668,
0.08415018022060394,
0.3325044512748718,
0.39101865887641907,
0.628852903842926,
0.17190174758434296,
-0.3266058564186096,
0.6451818346977234,
-0.21329966187477112,
-0.08663106709718704,
-0.32226744294166565,
0.061179447919130325,
-0.0520654022693634,
-0.19844134151935577,
0.585497260093689,
0.05689215660095215,
0.0650569275021553,
-0.20168060064315796,
0.4731816053390503,
0.055999357253313065,
-0.5656030774116516,
-0.6921870112419128,
0.5033396482467651,
0.04950607940554619,
-0.5362235903739929,
0.7585088610649109,
-0.1461198776960373,
-0.28298619389533997,
0.8560773730278015,
0.5942677855491638,
0.6233552098274231,
-0.2680355906486511,
0.0581970177590847,
0.2915819585323334,
0.4886784255504608,
-0.3816015124320984,
0.09154894202947617,
0.17476557195186615,
-0.6055612564086914,
-0.5198554992675781,
-0.5065537095069885,
-0.2515445351600647,
-0.03050532005727291,
-0.7446433305740356,
0.3269858658313751,
-0.3977186381816864,
-0.36100631952285767,
-0.17840509116649628,
-0.4278722107410431,
-0.8817176222801208,
0.19582386314868927,
-0.0943712368607521,
0.9259433746337891,
-0.9502101540565491,
0.5095176100730896,
0.396893173456192,
-0.10124988853931427,
-0.7581234574317932,
-0.1253645271062851,
-0.5266644954681396,
-0.6682155728340149,
0.6090385317802429,
0.5288053154945374,
0.18778611719608307,
-0.15483899414539337,
-0.39761754870414734,
-0.9823562502861023,
0.9348133206367493,
0.2468186914920807,
-0.5274369120597839,
-0.3263663649559021,
0.9105138182640076,
0.7765063643455505,
-0.15795545279979706,
0.365807443857193,
0.6402997374534607,
0.4133119583129883,
-0.06762982904911041,
-0.8022813200950623,
-0.16070549190044403,
-0.04581649973988533,
0.44108328223228455,
0.3110695779323578,
-0.7054091095924377,
0.8477717041969299,
-0.2519494891166687,
-0.0959966704249382,
-0.023334933444857597,
0.8794894814491272,
-0.2208130657672882,
-0.1629687249660492,
0.5539034605026245,
0.8114856481552124,
0.4162904620170593,
-0.17917987704277039,
1.1261893510818481,
-0.17089132964611053,
0.5008271932601929,
1.0841542482376099,
0.1230086013674736,
0.5479153990745544,
0.23927636444568634,
-0.5884792804718018,
0.7618327736854553,
0.311407208442688,
-0.3686728775501251,
0.2062477469444275,
0.2725890278816223,
-0.10657185316085815,
-0.08353579789400101,
0.16958940029144287,
-0.520802915096283,
0.5473713874816895,
0.49887123703956604,
-0.6629874110221863,
-0.09311002492904663,
-0.027547141537070274,
-0.08458882570266724,
-0.004275310318917036,
0.009942830540239811,
0.5274559855461121,
0.019190555438399315,
-0.4637024998664856,
0.4142177700996399,
0.09329446405172348,
0.7652937769889832,
-0.6035119891166687,
-0.07903937995433807,
-0.07037615031003952,
0.06918853521347046,
-0.12615792453289032,
-0.9783492088317871,
0.5613601803779602,
-0.24584096670150757,
-0.39640045166015625,
-0.004174564033746719,
0.41420090198516846,
-0.051873475313186646,
-0.6454687118530273,
0.12871602177619934,
-0.004111702553927898,
-0.000858464976772666,
-0.02943466790020466,
-0.11444243043661118,
-0.22805261611938477,
-0.2718884348869324,
-0.21763285994529724,
0.16185395419597626,
0.17733627557754517,
-0.24011245369911194,
0.6422999501228333,
0.7080984711647034,
-0.3204338848590851,
0.3534948527812958,
-0.0338602215051651,
0.6354098320007324,
-0.6407784819602966,
-0.2689015865325928,
-1.097519874572754,
0.5010843873023987,
-0.06621602177619934,
-0.32807958126068115,
0.5124279856681824,
0.6049832701683044,
0.8662575483322144,
-0.3032347857952118,
0.7730626463890076,
-0.13294005393981934,
-0.06596804410219193,
-0.04163367673754692,
0.28645163774490356,
0.01595318131148815,
0.007117304485291243,
0.15087811648845673,
-1.233963966369629,
-0.32070571184158325,
0.2301415205001831,
-0.33668532967567444,
0.08674826472997665,
0.7652537226676941,
0.4198286235332489,
-0.10517944395542145,
-0.10706821829080582,
0.5115663409233093,
0.003952312283217907,
0.3977729082107544,
0.6236479878425598,
0.6988338232040405,
-0.7061797380447388,
0.8982582092285156,
-0.5828829407691956,
-0.2876999080181122,
0.034119099378585815,
-0.5675800442695618,
-0.9100570678710938,
-0.42428502440452576,
0.2340547740459442,
-0.17177528142929077,
-0.19264014065265656,
0.5351383090019226,
0.6779341697692871,
-0.7875418663024902,
0.05768590047955513,
-0.06651193648576736,
0.036263398826122284,
-0.23164139688014984,
-0.30270394682884216,
0.33843058347702026,
-0.03727016970515251,
-0.835014820098877,
0.37248122692108154,
0.258006751537323,
0.4475710988044739,
-0.2529388964176178,
0.10245164483785629,
0.23017646372318268,
0.12088619917631149,
0.45020928978919983,
0.3697745203971863,
-0.5295869708061218,
-0.792934000492096,
0.24966785311698914,
0.12619554996490479,
0.25595977902412415,
0.7647177577018738,
-0.47767361998558044,
0.36348965764045715,
0.5909639000892639,
0.5740162134170532,
0.21345631778240204,
0.26427868008613586,
0.8007039427757263,
-1.0528976917266846,
0.11083385348320007,
0.07690320163965225,
0.3693348467350006,
0.3133614957332611,
-0.4465380012989044,
0.45425692200660706,
0.09652996063232422,
-0.49751415848731995,
-0.40470072627067566,
0.6588417291641235,
-0.7438886165618896,
0.14950422942638397,
1.1321808099746704,
-0.0937749370932579,
0.1609470397233963,
0.029310403391718864,
0.07642205059528351,
0.14425510168075562,
-0.2621655762195587,
0.9101418256759644,
0.7311834096908569,
-0.16284969449043274,
0.18130667507648468,
-0.030463561415672302,
0.3829939365386963,
0.23844283819198608,
-0.4296506941318512,
-0.28675946593284607,
-0.3012593686580658,
0.4167863726615906,
0.6706253290176392,
0.09231758862733841,
0.0012052018428221345,
0.29713863134384155,
0.0722002238035202,
-0.40518245100975037,
0.06744718551635742,
-0.342184454202652,
-0.5274726152420044,
0.07227595895528793,
0.15582914650440216,
-0.01994861476123333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09369v1 | Massively Multi-Cultural Knowledge Acquisition & LM Benchmarking | 2024-02-14T18:16:54 | 2024-02-14T18:16:54 | Yi Fung, Ruining Zhao, Jae Doo, Chenkai Sun, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained large language models have revolutionized many applications but
still face challenges related to cultural bias and a lack of cultural
commonsense knowledge crucial for guiding cross-culture communication and
interactions. Recognizing the shortcomings of existing methods in capturing the
diverse and rich cultures across the world, this paper introduces a novel
approach for massively multicultural knowledge acquisition. Specifically, our
method strategically navigates from densely informative Wikipedia documents on
cultural topics to an extensive network of linked pages. Leveraging this
valuable source of data collection, we construct the CultureAtlas dataset,
which covers a wide range of sub-country level geographical regions and
ethnolinguistic groups, with data cleaning and preprocessing to ensure textual
assertion sentence self-containment, as well as fine-grained cultural profile
information extraction. Our dataset not only facilitates the evaluation of
language model performance in culturally diverse contexts but also serves as a
foundational tool for the development of culturally sensitive and aware
language models. Our work marks an important step towards deeper understanding
and bridging the gaps of cultural disparities in AI, to promote a more
inclusive and balanced representation of global cultures in the digital domain. | [
-0.6563079953193665,
-0.6089432835578918,
0.13034622371196747,
0.12180276215076447,
-0.027943255379796028,
0.3546839654445648,
-0.6364980936050415,
-0.6362543106079102,
0.2117885798215866,
0.1450526863336563,
-0.5106368660926819,
-0.5049619674682617,
-0.6308620572090149,
-0.0011592998635023832,
-0.039041902869939804,
0.9628345370292664,
0.08224081993103027,
0.03059222921729088,
-0.031569648534059525,
-0.4691261947154999,
-0.12676766514778137,
-0.2541729211807251,
-0.1514882594347,
-0.20476849377155304,
0.47401949763298035,
0.5609181523323059,
0.4504886865615845,
0.5962672233581543,
0.3138425648212433,
0.24424178898334503,
-0.09849445521831512,
0.48707690834999084,
-0.731002688407898,
0.13215065002441406,
-0.33934468030929565,
-0.23987996578216553,
-0.15964239835739136,
0.12920315563678741,
0.6592968106269836,
0.6708890199661255,
-0.021297002211213112,
0.6580066680908203,
-0.15069162845611572,
0.3850554823875427,
-0.7378861308097839,
0.2044702172279358,
-0.5867871046066284,
0.17500922083854675,
-0.3400888741016388,
0.10098280012607574,
-0.20371808111667633,
-0.3527945876121521,
0.13051290810108185,
-0.6899351477622986,
-0.15194568037986755,
-0.09730038791894913,
0.5065778493881226,
0.10062304139137268,
-0.81573086977005,
-0.21861104667186737,
-0.8965150117874146,
0.8157685995101929,
-0.13414523005485535,
0.5476820468902588,
0.3958858847618103,
0.5330082178115845,
0.20635218918323517,
-0.6434041261672974,
-0.6658522486686707,
-0.12298962473869324,
0.16825266182422638,
0.15255974233150482,
0.05899275094270706,
-0.5935436487197876,
0.3599647283554077,
0.443244993686676,
-0.4583779275417328,
0.22638319432735443,
-0.6379297375679016,
-0.29273635149002075,
0.6835293173789978,
0.025950362905859947,
0.3680759072303772,
-0.09827177971601486,
-0.2463505119085312,
-0.22072839736938477,
-0.740874707698822,
0.0005954942898824811,
0.2847171127796173,
0.37590646743774414,
-0.39148759841918945,
0.34207549691200256,
-0.48512595891952515,
0.4504139721393585,
-0.29963919520378113,
-0.34342506527900696,
0.5232667326927185,
-0.44331586360931396,
0.15560480952262878,
-0.13357694447040558,
0.6540324687957764,
0.25815603137016296,
0.7234394550323486,
-0.12599791586399078,
0.14514291286468506,
-0.04714604839682579,
-0.038863006979227066,
-0.8585159778594971,
-0.08097320795059204,
0.14300332963466644,
-0.39076563715934753,
0.010008747689425945,
-0.01395035907626152,
-0.8779039978981018,
-0.5639200806617737,
-0.3750153183937073,
-0.007264814339578152,
-0.27948325872421265,
-0.5295639634132385,
-0.17948080599308014,
-0.036717843264341354,
0.15967102348804474,
0.23699457943439484,
-0.8418976664543152,
-0.2583182752132416,
0.5662548542022705,
0.6675772070884705,
-0.06843897700309753,
-0.44858190417289734,
-0.1907026469707489,
0.3944947421550751,
-0.25107964873313904,
0.3458433151245117,
-0.6423572301864624,
-0.2510245740413666,
0.21673624217510223,
-0.12460578233003616,
0.22148582339286804,
-0.5805156230926514,
0.48951447010040283,
-0.6769050359725952,
0.13807542622089386,
-0.4351693093776703,
-0.2986658811569214,
-0.262634813785553,
0.5829442143440247,
-0.7146289944648743,
0.9628450870513916,
-0.07171711325645447,
-0.638911247253418,
0.5757453441619873,
-0.5540607571601868,
-0.45820000767707825,
0.12456583231687546,
-0.27369967103004456,
0.15295186638832092,
-0.02256949059665203,
0.40023383498191833,
0.515426754951477,
-0.3389372229576111,
0.2661423981189728,
-0.3666131794452667,
-0.17608535289764404,
-0.15858380496501923,
-0.2988443672657013,
0.9334951639175415,
0.536899209022522,
-0.2864001393318176,
-0.03180808946490288,
-0.8520074486732483,
-0.10066819936037064,
0.21108275651931763,
-0.3364231288433075,
-0.5700106620788574,
-0.2805836498737335,
0.14554136991500854,
0.6531403064727783,
0.509655237197876,
-0.4917936325073242,
0.24363607168197632,
0.14828428626060486,
0.30309000611305237,
0.6279305219650269,
-0.4719179570674896,
0.37810519337654114,
-0.20708833634853363,
0.41863909363746643,
0.23927956819534302,
0.18161310255527496,
-0.3067094683647156,
-0.08624443411827087,
-0.37424033880233765,
-0.4192512631416321,
0.10550829023122787,
0.6455656886100769,
-0.908708393573761,
0.3368282914161682,
-0.5812225937843323,
-0.8802435398101807,
-0.4624555706977844,
0.5233005881309509,
0.21817804872989655,
0.44304659962654114,
0.375772625207901,
-0.10353478044271469,
-0.29799073934555054,
-0.7251530289649963,
-0.11611654609441757,
-0.13209563493728638,
-0.08431292325258255,
0.2982342839241028,
0.36905404925346375,
-0.4079129695892334,
0.6632096767425537,
-0.2580322325229645,
-0.364151269197464,
-0.35987889766693115,
0.1635504812002182,
0.0987565889954567,
0.49629896879196167,
0.38485610485076904,
-0.9115194082260132,
-0.5514082312583923,
0.18116804957389832,
-1.1180845499038696,
0.06481495499610901,
0.1803097426891327,
-0.3678877353668213,
0.030286597087979317,
0.6935994029045105,
-0.49954724311828613,
-0.05754750221967697,
0.6976938247680664,
-0.06483805179595947,
0.3068345785140991,
-0.08191828429698944,
0.16691850125789642,
-1.3335174322128296,
0.32956355810165405,
0.0997367650270462,
0.04672651365399361,
-0.5412904620170593,
0.3300917446613312,
0.23079143464565277,
0.014558577910065651,
-0.4247570335865021,
0.619816243648529,
-0.47875460982322693,
0.10708516091108322,
0.08892909437417984,
0.1716804951429367,
-0.0858011320233345,
0.3585315942764282,
0.05546693876385689,
0.5787917971611023,
0.39894959330558777,
-0.2592034339904785,
0.3982921540737152,
0.2500879168510437,
-0.6153911352157593,
0.7322443723678589,
-0.2954373359680176,
-0.028870390728116035,
-0.2744464576244354,
0.5977012515068054,
-0.7171675562858582,
-0.21075816452503204,
-0.006933749653398991,
-0.08630090951919556,
0.10887695848941803,
-0.052515577524900436,
-0.5459476113319397,
-0.34099867939949036,
-0.06752319633960724,
0.9065331220626831,
0.44316110014915466,
-0.6289286017417908,
0.6713522672653198,
0.5773069262504578,
-0.22558589279651642,
-0.9040188789367676,
-0.3689672648906708,
0.04654425010085106,
-0.4912745952606201,
-0.6911507248878479,
0.010760278441011906,
-0.09907121956348419,
-0.3474365174770355,
-0.4706478714942932,
0.11236949265003204,
-0.06749585270881653,
0.21292251348495483,
0.021927200257778168,
0.11114007234573364,
-0.26905491948127747,
0.32333695888519287,
-0.23551714420318604,
0.09267517924308777,
-0.03239120915532112,
-0.5224126577377319,
0.6181767582893372,
-0.06032514572143555,
-0.39399707317352295,
-0.26003825664520264,
0.3736836314201355,
0.8388720750808716,
-0.6635072231292725,
0.7258468866348267,
0.9308642745018005,
-0.4025208055973053,
-0.198649063706398,
-0.8196278214454651,
-0.09935775399208069,
-0.3940039277076721,
0.5762773752212524,
-0.3861938714981079,
-0.8902002573013306,
0.7572683691978455,
-0.3448888063430786,
0.14534762501716614,
0.43146762251853943,
0.4214451014995575,
-0.042042650282382965,
0.6525095105171204,
0.7516375780105591,
-0.4688144028186798,
0.2953481376171112,
-0.24941685795783997,
0.08387520164251328,
-0.43111538887023926,
-0.33969900012016296,
-0.5234890580177307,
-0.33292195200920105,
-0.7205244898796082,
-0.6342519521713257,
0.35574692487716675,
-0.05943679437041283,
-0.417695552110672,
-0.03761078789830208,
0.008106393739581108,
0.6532118320465088,
0.5799347758293152,
-0.05066915974020958,
0.45353540778160095,
0.20298820734024048,
-0.21172897517681122,
-0.21555635333061218,
-0.6073246598243713,
-0.3209396302700043,
1.0565016269683838,
0.30470550060272217,
0.5841081142425537,
0.3320898413658142,
0.48390626907348633,
0.35373520851135254,
0.435199499130249,
-0.4777574837207794,
0.25482162833213806,
-0.29895225167274475,
-0.7951139807701111,
-0.4008415639400482,
-0.5788262486457825,
-0.6008595824241638,
0.2706683874130249,
-0.06995336711406708,
-0.7163882851600647,
0.061215948313474655,
-0.003502439009025693,
-0.19880101084709167,
0.26088008284568787,
-0.5861107110977173,
0.9836452007293701,
-0.3171284794807434,
-0.510586142539978,
-0.3631082773208618,
-0.7648979425430298,
0.5450387597084045,
-0.46770650148391724,
0.4562545716762543,
-0.28305357694625854,
0.17069068551063538,
0.5444209575653076,
0.2868897020816803,
0.7153490781784058,
-0.16215698421001434,
-0.2835024297237396,
-0.006401063874363899,
0.1942146271467209,
0.2554748058319092,
-0.08002208918333054,
-0.23263488709926605,
0.6465064287185669,
-0.023993585258722305,
-0.625338613986969,
-0.334909051656723,
0.5266066789627075,
-1.0337291955947876,
-0.2493024617433548,
-0.16929881274700165,
-0.8613220453262329,
-0.4744904339313507,
0.19649264216423035,
-0.05471634492278099,
0.3153643012046814,
-0.29576197266578674,
0.26253095269203186,
0.5444977283477783,
-0.42319563031196594,
0.2708992660045624,
0.7197326421737671,
-0.09265062212944031,
-0.15785178542137146,
1.0330809354782104,
0.12252753973007202,
0.2158934473991394,
0.4043637812137604,
-0.025460436940193176,
-0.36116713285446167,
-0.31809985637664795,
-0.4802402853965759,
0.18999701738357544,
-0.9563343524932861,
0.14074651896953583,
-0.6411445736885071,
-0.028249984607100487,
-0.36379745602607727,
0.017272843047976494,
-0.2676590383052826,
-0.19337457418441772,
0.29996296763420105,
-0.1437276303768158,
0.13683435320854187,
0.7304746508598328,
-0.2928755283355713,
0.23800644278526306,
-0.9177395701408386,
0.27778351306915283,
0.1700325310230255,
0.22172686457633972,
0.07942979782819748,
-0.3389366567134857,
-0.5343261361122131,
0.03984661027789116,
0.022220958024263382,
-0.4261387586593628,
0.25655147433280945,
0.21558170020580292,
0.8568308353424072,
0.5508984923362732,
0.12031447887420654,
0.7119635939598083,
-0.35785016417503357,
0.6348444819450378,
-0.059078365564346313,
-0.7210190892219543,
0.47512513399124146,
-0.48964041471481323,
0.6363715529441833,
0.7726343870162964,
0.9545601606369019,
-0.9572094678878784,
-0.2670457065105438,
-0.45965269207954407,
-0.8980938196182251,
0.5123420357704163,
-0.3714328110218048,
0.2849210798740387,
0.05778359994292259,
-0.06685229390859604,
0.25335824489593506,
0.1398153156042099,
-0.6782554984092712,
0.011791296303272247,
-0.11231624335050583,
-0.3134342133998871,
-0.42667609453201294,
-0.18951468169689178,
-0.44981008768081665,
-0.2586388885974884,
0.6600266098976135,
-0.40839144587516785,
-0.38515761494636536,
-0.1947384774684906,
-0.687216579914093,
0.11725261807441711,
-0.04912779480218887,
0.5051589012145996,
0.9596503376960754,
-0.12339023500680923,
0.11959400773048401,
0.157197967171669,
-0.5434843301773071,
0.021201584488153458,
0.18814177811145782,
-0.058657221496105194,
-0.3901503384113312,
0.36398082971572876,
0.3494107723236084,
-0.20880229771137238,
-0.8126903772354126,
0.28939443826675415,
-0.1964408904314041,
0.21410562098026276,
-0.36652007699012756,
-0.22231683135032654,
0.09452909976243973,
0.4053792357444763,
0.5393320918083191,
-0.39446863532066345,
-0.2699638903141022,
-0.5692421793937683,
0.38733163475990295,
0.3631560206413269,
-0.20723265409469604,
-0.13060782849788666,
0.5019086599349976,
0.41686514019966125,
0.18862174451351166,
0.8793875575065613,
0.06020794063806534,
-0.45093461871147156,
0.5185226202011108,
0.16457998752593994,
0.4470502734184265,
-0.21207481622695923,
0.3734644651412964,
0.5251697301864624,
0.3272668421268463,
0.08189474046230316,
0.0783013254404068,
-0.36999890208244324,
-0.9763598442077637,
-0.4503367245197296,
-0.711158037185669,
-0.31050872802734375,
0.03438451513648033,
-0.4983662962913513,
0.07581499218940735,
-0.3973793685436249,
0.25356778502464294,
-0.1062333956360817,
0.13831757009029388,
-0.8114315867424011,
0.430652916431427,
0.45594748854637146,
1.1077641248703003,
-1.2167402505874634,
0.8610079884529114,
0.49370598793029785,
-0.491372674703598,
-0.6716163158416748,
0.177180677652359,
0.1644441783428192,
-1.0528432130813599,
0.8316085934638977,
0.276024729013443,
0.1640186756849289,
-0.13814222812652588,
-0.204433873295784,
-0.8391495943069458,
0.9076314568519592,
0.2609163522720337,
-0.3286921977996826,
0.2297496348619461,
0.28831252455711365,
0.6106637716293335,
-0.36204782128334045,
0.4992358386516571,
0.5444602370262146,
0.45209965109825134,
0.16867369413375854,
-0.8637732863426208,
0.025684040039777756,
-0.4523088335990906,
-0.2720257043838501,
-0.1229095309972763,
-0.8640125393867493,
0.8157814145088196,
0.05572269856929779,
0.08977426588535309,
-0.1530415117740631,
0.7038216590881348,
0.290566086769104,
0.1312856823205948,
0.5298763513565063,
0.4180006682872772,
1.0289193391799927,
-0.09273780137300491,
0.8723830580711365,
-0.6275413036346436,
0.04845269024372101,
0.9871188998222351,
-0.43923264741897583,
0.7515949606895447,
0.3039534389972687,
0.07788806408643723,
0.3747168183326721,
0.66163170337677,
0.004617536440491676,
0.2184353470802307,
0.28521817922592163,
-0.34393414855003357,
-0.38417449593544006,
-0.6707026958465576,
-0.6002197265625,
0.9754214286804199,
0.459834486246109,
-0.17418058216571808,
-0.3463696539402008,
0.023586826398968697,
0.10017196834087372,
0.05421978607773781,
-0.2081264704465866,
0.6725476980209351,
-0.14231479167938232,
-0.7953172922134399,
0.41445192694664,
-0.2226399928331375,
0.8206113576889038,
-0.8041037321090698,
0.1366783231496811,
-0.5751696228981018,
0.19774171710014343,
0.008569193072617054,
-0.47958511114120483,
0.05924144759774208,
-0.11292702704668045,
-0.3159387409687042,
-0.34314948320388794,
0.5354341864585876,
-0.5401231646537781,
-0.5122193694114685,
0.4927257001399994,
0.9815236330032349,
0.1325325071811676,
0.1042778268456459,
-0.3096499741077423,
0.18725921213626862,
-0.09487948566675186,
0.0591774582862854,
0.27606865763664246,
0.6121402382850647,
-0.3627428710460663,
0.5672149062156677,
0.6536814570426941,
0.04726886376738548,
0.050921730697155,
0.22778823971748352,
0.47513243556022644,
-0.48128044605255127,
-0.6132687926292419,
-0.6867956519126892,
0.49408838152885437,
-0.4227510094642639,
-0.3650551736354828,
0.8725214600563049,
0.49961939454078674,
1.328856110572815,
0.08900996297597885,
0.991645872592926,
-0.13410407304763794,
0.3092021346092224,
-0.12404913455247879,
0.951657235622406,
-0.7321754693984985,
-0.0156309362500906,
-0.1905680000782013,
-0.9339921474456787,
-0.17391791939735413,
0.3243182599544525,
-0.32329022884368896,
0.17731116712093353,
0.27579963207244873,
0.6881913542747498,
-0.3046989142894745,
0.17169487476348877,
0.3240200877189636,
0.269722044467926,
0.30879026651382446,
0.4134023189544678,
1.0741522312164307,
0.013688870705664158,
0.5426618456840515,
-0.3413847088813782,
-0.2685425281524658,
0.01688787341117859,
-0.8821288347244263,
-0.6777524352073669,
-0.5533292889595032,
-0.16492262482643127,
-0.18074113130569458,
0.03138372674584389,
0.9731963872909546,
0.9189432263374329,
-0.8162059187889099,
-0.3756519854068756,
0.589850664138794,
0.1214805468916893,
-0.07027248293161392,
-0.1304243803024292,
0.16834405064582825,
-0.05556744709610939,
-0.8640651702880859,
0.3001043200492859,
-0.03611162677407265,
-0.09202643483877182,
-0.49448657035827637,
-0.006994502153247595,
-0.24849577248096466,
-0.17640048265457153,
0.5768383741378784,
0.47305867075920105,
-0.39733898639678955,
-0.029322432354092598,
-0.18895649909973145,
-0.1824653148651123,
-0.20890219509601593,
0.6567765474319458,
-0.5653611421585083,
0.42073723673820496,
0.48950648307800293,
0.8886231780052185,
0.4055634140968323,
-0.15115705132484436,
0.5780999660491943,
-0.9568068385124207,
0.5221966505050659,
-0.004497159738093615,
0.23484738171100616,
0.5296698808670044,
-0.10242075473070145,
0.42994368076324463,
0.23663944005966187,
-0.2979207932949066,
-0.6575061678886414,
0.19915713369846344,
-0.7746531963348389,
-0.32119929790496826,
1.1083272695541382,
-0.3360186815261841,
0.04223870858550072,
-0.10795241594314575,
0.09937579929828644,
0.3466344177722931,
-0.11475382000207901,
1.1480751037597656,
0.7340561151504517,
0.5685492157936096,
0.031734444200992584,
-0.652326762676239,
0.20731176435947418,
0.5008168816566467,
-0.7792909145355225,
0.04361046850681305,
0.7725219130516052,
0.22300994396209717,
0.415737509727478,
0.3556291460990906,
0.09467414021492004,
0.18163824081420898,
-0.1735117882490158,
0.07088465988636017,
-0.04703648388385773,
-0.5284967422485352,
-0.15260758996009827,
0.4643487334251404,
-0.2300461232662201,
0.0525083914399147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09363v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09363v2 | Copyright Traps for Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T18:09:53 | 2024-06-04T21:07:11 | Matthieu Meeus, Igor Shilov, Manuel Faysse, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Questions of fair use of copyright-protected content to train Large Language
Models (LLMs) are being actively debated. Document-level inference has been
proposed as a new task: inferring from black-box access to the trained model
whether a piece of content has been seen during training. SOTA methods however
rely on naturally occurring memorization of (part of) the content. While very
effective against models that memorize significantly, we hypothesize--and later
confirm--that they will not work against models that do not naturally memorize,
e.g. medium-size 1B models. We here propose to use copyright traps, the
inclusion of fictitious entries in original content, to detect the use of
copyrighted materials in LLMs with a focus on models where memorization does
not naturally occur. We carefully design a randomized controlled experimental
setup, inserting traps into original content (books) and train a 1.3B LLM from
scratch. We first validate that the use of content in our target model would be
undetectable using existing methods. We then show, contrary to intuition, that
even medium-length trap sentences repeated a significant number of times (100)
are not detectable using existing methods. However, we show that longer
sequences repeated a large number of times can be reliably detected (AUC=0.75)
and used as copyright traps. Beyond copyright applications, our findings
contribute to the study of LLM memorization: the randomized controlled setup
enables us to draw causal relationships between memorization and certain
sequence properties such as repetition in model training data and perplexity. | [
-0.15249979496002197,
-0.5109150409698486,
0.4357580840587616,
0.11428695172071457,
-0.46202677488327026,
-0.15051478147506714,
-0.24454250931739807,
-0.2512696385383606,
0.0037176304031163454,
0.774776816368103,
-0.3201706111431122,
-0.40351971983909607,
-0.7083753943443298,
0.2751002907752991,
-0.673948347568512,
0.8453927040100098,
0.0034450264647603035,
0.27219510078430176,
-0.1995905041694641,
-0.13363002240657806,
-0.5071024298667908,
-0.744006872177124,
-0.5824480652809143,
-0.23029206693172455,
0.47123491764068604,
0.10861216485500336,
0.2619415819644928,
0.7214744687080383,
0.14663776755332947,
0.14322850108146667,
-0.3432226777076721,
-0.08119313418865204,
-0.6486465334892273,
-0.0064538284204900265,
-0.2812289297580719,
-0.885337233543396,
-0.062125496566295624,
0.14578846096992493,
0.913388192653656,
0.11387304961681366,
-0.20629122853279114,
0.170969620347023,
0.04018819332122803,
0.5306631922721863,
-0.6849736571311951,
-0.0004899593768641353,
-0.7370635271072388,
0.2437376230955124,
-0.37037545442581177,
-0.4274715483188629,
-0.7894710898399353,
-0.23979447782039642,
-0.18466655910015106,
-0.5684441328048706,
0.4112014174461365,
0.1592606157064438,
0.8832709789276123,
0.1901371031999588,
-0.17309731245040894,
-0.6043416261672974,
-0.63779217004776,
0.9570359587669373,
-1.007362961769104,
0.28787973523139954,
0.5018755793571472,
0.16430656611919403,
-0.28980013728141785,
-0.575340747833252,
-0.9084458947181702,
-0.403882771730423,
0.13123759627342224,
0.00983373448252678,
-0.23619505763053894,
-0.21049904823303223,
0.8393889665603638,
0.27410322427749634,
-0.5322332382202148,
0.2424701303243637,
-0.32328087091445923,
-0.373546838760376,
0.6238588094711304,
0.02240089513361454,
0.3633979260921478,
-0.2489321082830429,
-0.5184227824211121,
-0.0035946955904364586,
-1.119240641593933,
-0.0673544704914093,
0.7217537760734558,
0.1251945048570633,
0.07248657196760178,
0.7624220848083496,
0.5258134007453918,
0.3512549102306366,
-0.020374666899442673,
-0.26311400532722473,
-0.0003835397947113961,
0.07019422948360443,
-0.21643811464309692,
0.14662547409534454,
0.6357555985450745,
0.038621772080659866,
0.7299174666404724,
-0.14924809336662292,
-0.4579223692417145,
-0.0871523916721344,
0.01752511039376259,
-0.6702038049697876,
-0.04292269051074982,
-0.02102111466228962,
-0.36216315627098083,
0.030634775757789612,
-0.008069890551269054,
-0.43965134024620056,
-0.5720692873001099,
-0.34291478991508484,
0.6607359647750854,
-0.3780073821544647,
-0.12170176953077316,
0.41324418783187866,
-0.4201087951660156,
0.15056321024894714,
0.0874362662434578,
-0.7370876669883728,
0.24012428522109985,
0.6444407105445862,
0.7708933353424072,
-0.11332341283559799,
-0.44161027669906616,
-0.6517693400382996,
0.39979517459869385,
-0.27506545186042786,
0.6036895513534546,
-0.33998486399650574,
-0.37493038177490234,
0.05822575092315674,
0.2523142397403717,
0.01657465472817421,
-0.7830854058265686,
0.19196327030658722,
-0.92804354429245,
0.11414121836423874,
-0.22211147844791412,
-0.9740185737609863,
-0.042534373700618744,
0.13869646191596985,
-1.077451467514038,
0.636137843132019,
-0.10471878200769424,
-0.9436721801757812,
0.36565619707107544,
-0.03784938529133797,
-0.4136403799057007,
-0.2753675878047943,
-0.33760952949523926,
-0.6624924540519714,
0.13331438601016998,
-0.15112875401973724,
0.3133295774459839,
-0.15330719947814941,
0.3181091248989105,
-0.18633809685707092,
-0.5938628315925598,
0.4900633692741394,
-0.42768484354019165,
0.9825753569602966,
0.2073240578174591,
-0.4319779574871063,
-0.3529640734195709,
-0.41787421703338623,
-0.5486592054367065,
0.4180434048175812,
-0.7209250330924988,
-0.5195484757423401,
-0.10274390131235123,
-0.1698339283466339,
0.03820742666721344,
0.08765237033367157,
-0.5758645534515381,
0.2495686262845993,
-0.1116681769490242,
0.17775897681713104,
0.7697135210037231,
0.07806628197431564,
0.5014218091964722,
-0.501393735408783,
0.7855530977249146,
0.09069842100143433,
-0.1362321972846985,
-0.2357597053050995,
-0.3596091866493225,
-0.5144082903862,
-0.4842338562011719,
0.5567287802696228,
0.44302549958229065,
-0.5762291550636292,
0.22427432239055634,
-0.2514439523220062,
0.013427791185677052,
-0.34247031807899475,
0.3338530659675598,
0.5547716021537781,
0.09515316039323807,
0.05289538577198982,
-0.5394464135169983,
-0.4459899067878723,
-0.6794753074645996,
-0.5829596519470215,
0.3266236484050751,
-0.25405552983283997,
0.38960394263267517,
0.6035532355308533,
0.18711961805820465,
0.9183294177055359,
-0.3394079804420471,
-0.4950733184814453,
-0.17119832336902618,
0.25462156534194946,
0.17036272585391998,
0.46707138419151306,
0.5196026563644409,
-0.7795855402946472,
-0.42632001638412476,
-0.4098760187625885,
-0.7223504185676575,
-0.15900348126888275,
-0.34242334961891174,
0.1679370105266571,
0.4342692494392395,
0.6990615725517273,
-0.6271119117736816,
0.5568045377731323,
0.34721624851226807,
-0.2055366188287735,
0.5899914503097534,
-0.21236100792884827,
-0.1187661737203598,
-0.8062381744384766,
0.22295565903186798,
-0.15479342639446259,
-0.13630245625972748,
-0.29922056198120117,
0.04545983672142029,
0.224111407995224,
-0.05049755424261093,
-0.46572211384773254,
0.7211270332336426,
-0.5875739455223083,
-0.16113926470279694,
-0.3122921586036682,
0.10546484589576721,
0.07570315152406693,
0.47136372327804565,
0.16915754973888397,
0.7992118000984192,
0.28763848543167114,
-0.48611539602279663,
-0.10026144981384277,
0.19710440933704376,
-0.664652943611145,
0.4931955337524414,
-0.38367947936058044,
0.2940593361854553,
-0.439503937959671,
0.3666425347328186,
-0.5939888954162598,
0.007523537613451481,
0.11238931119441986,
-0.4970952272415161,
0.5763531923294067,
-0.4990385174751282,
-0.8168533444404602,
-0.07324044406414032,
-0.32220458984375,
0.17061981558799744,
0.5844156742095947,
-0.4582136571407318,
0.5266497731208801,
0.36467862129211426,
0.09894973039627075,
-0.8959165811538696,
-0.9112061858177185,
-0.050789546221494675,
-0.35768255591392517,
-0.3694383203983307,
0.004892453085631132,
-0.16776850819587708,
-0.05813247710466385,
0.0032269961666315794,
-0.49185487627983093,
-0.09380555897951126,
0.16589473187923431,
0.30005747079849243,
0.032505687326192856,
-0.19805072247982025,
0.06795531511306763,
-0.03591508790850639,
0.035282306373119354,
0.10081767290830612,
-0.49412739276885986,
0.5808783173561096,
0.36945056915283203,
-0.3593524694442749,
-0.21634669601917267,
0.2688206434249878,
0.3853829503059387,
-0.21524924039840698,
0.7807786464691162,
0.2672276496887207,
-0.5859286785125732,
-0.6458308100700378,
-0.6988621950149536,
-0.13982732594013214,
-0.4543139636516571,
0.05501072481274605,
-0.18435591459274292,
-1.1080949306488037,
0.7276857495307922,
0.20853473246097565,
-0.02523438073694706,
0.0863342434167862,
0.41899263858795166,
-0.09751332551240921,
0.6057615280151367,
0.495105504989624,
-0.04487407207489014,
0.6040322780609131,
-0.5816090106964111,
0.23378387093544006,
-0.7697315812110901,
-0.21932843327522278,
-0.5015838146209717,
-0.32563117146492004,
-0.30759143829345703,
-0.46606922149658203,
0.08233051002025604,
0.2743827700614929,
-0.20492227375507355,
0.48414522409439087,
-0.08293397724628448,
0.8715465068817139,
0.7006544470787048,
0.13884982466697693,
0.6510491371154785,
0.1011369377374649,
-0.09931982308626175,
-0.022323625162243843,
-0.6228763461112976,
-0.5763363838195801,
1.2268986701965332,
0.3531866669654846,
0.9630478024482727,
0.08294817805290222,
0.911724865436554,
0.4471190571784973,
0.47974854707717896,
-0.8449245095252991,
0.5506371855735779,
-0.3042807877063751,
-1.2330647706985474,
-0.28801247477531433,
-0.48741504549980164,
-1.037705421447754,
-0.1309051215648651,
-0.034348610788583755,
-0.6560403108596802,
0.17219921946525574,
0.3037024736404419,
-0.24699535965919495,
0.5676906704902649,
-0.5836499333381653,
0.8326917886734009,
-0.10077933222055435,
-0.5635271072387695,
-0.19260062277317047,
-0.43982210755348206,
0.49319735169410706,
-0.42750346660614014,
0.28228259086608887,
-0.044014133512973785,
0.1433953046798706,
0.9387962222099304,
-0.12726503610610962,
0.9089515805244446,
-0.20277190208435059,
-0.25493815541267395,
0.5524978637695312,
0.48160654306411743,
0.5439460277557373,
0.029735468327999115,
-0.07014499604701996,
0.04594021663069725,
0.09286133199930191,
-0.38230574131011963,
-0.4037688076496124,
0.6524728536605835,
-0.4901809096336365,
-0.5803083777427673,
-0.4975632429122925,
-0.4966464042663574,
0.22263211011886597,
0.4892270267009735,
0.39532825350761414,
0.29294997453689575,
0.0015696333721280098,
0.23687544465065002,
0.8721045255661011,
-0.3662823736667633,
0.2325519323348999,
0.9010481834411621,
0.11999860405921936,
-0.12990468740463257,
0.9167158007621765,
0.278059184551239,
0.33976268768310547,
0.38887670636177063,
0.3654036819934845,
-0.3054024577140808,
-0.9253998398780823,
-0.19704647362232208,
0.3590618371963501,
-0.8983541131019592,
-0.16814981400966644,
-0.5396053194999695,
-0.21081943809986115,
-0.25240108370780945,
-0.017185160890221596,
-0.17812010645866394,
-0.25194987654685974,
-0.3133770823478699,
0.060491953045129776,
0.15615130960941315,
0.7077786922454834,
-0.14513668417930603,
0.3124615550041199,
-0.9017575979232788,
0.42838960886001587,
0.29216960072517395,
0.5225496888160706,
0.14280447363853455,
-0.9048187732696533,
-0.2683677673339844,
-0.11803875118494034,
-0.2069067358970642,
-0.8090429902076721,
0.40436285734176636,
-0.051803216338157654,
0.6175585389137268,
0.28553900122642517,
0.06163683533668518,
0.1990785449743271,
-0.6229058504104614,
0.6073193550109863,
-0.03676474839448929,
-0.9640015959739685,
0.17476703226566315,
-0.37778934836387634,
-0.12759242951869965,
0.3769122064113617,
0.5328603982925415,
-0.2701367437839508,
-0.46827924251556396,
-0.7792231440544128,
-0.46544867753982544,
0.6866264939308167,
0.0968117043375969,
0.3024263381958008,
-0.08120156824588776,
0.36846494674682617,
0.12325730919837952,
0.4711976647377014,
-1.1311522722244263,
0.0935894325375557,
0.1100844219326973,
-0.20881560444831848,
-0.059307076036930084,
-0.32072561979293823,
-0.04739701747894287,
0.13834704458713531,
0.4523408114910126,
0.1345728635787964,
0.01992783136665821,
0.11450698226690292,
-0.4763970673084259,
-0.1271490603685379,
0.15259595215320587,
0.30448493361473083,
0.5384925603866577,
-0.34134259819984436,
0.32934480905532837,
0.05902646481990814,
-0.6713282465934753,
0.18906095623970032,
-0.05962808057665825,
-0.35242268443107605,
-0.0014320679474622011,
0.34899720549583435,
0.29068195819854736,
0.18900616466999054,
-0.9431668519973755,
0.806403636932373,
0.08349829912185669,
-0.08690162003040314,
-0.5916052460670471,
0.047801077365875244,
0.27567392587661743,
0.289665549993515,
-0.049690909683704376,
-0.20212170481681824,
0.07677765190601349,
-0.5329790115356445,
0.3788813054561615,
0.43870848417282104,
-0.11852048337459564,
-0.19312891364097595,
0.6610167026519775,
-0.2011568695306778,
-0.4527021050453186,
0.5274385809898376,
-0.350178062915802,
-0.5779508352279663,
0.8644880056381226,
0.7154827117919922,
0.7189035415649414,
-0.22882869839668274,
-0.16766473650932312,
0.4578450322151184,
0.4834168255329132,
-0.46096113324165344,
0.24058274924755096,
0.05347253754734993,
-0.7058476805686951,
-0.3342033922672272,
-0.5921522378921509,
-0.330242782831192,
0.44858282804489136,
-0.5672789216041565,
0.45047667622566223,
-0.692966639995575,
0.02588423527777195,
-0.08228868246078491,
-0.049850329756736755,
-0.5420777201652527,
0.007691785227507353,
0.45499828457832336,
1.1598049402236938,
-0.9473568797111511,
0.9252840876579285,
0.14953291416168213,
-0.47043299674987793,
-0.9289392232894897,
0.03608817234635353,
0.07660277932882309,
-0.7408109307289124,
0.4561232924461365,
0.16564558446407318,
-0.044703561812639236,
0.11695962399244308,
-0.9834703207015991,
-0.42780429124832153,
0.9540951251983643,
0.5771573781967163,
-0.6296466588973999,
-0.014379119500517845,
-0.009645837359130383,
0.4036225974559784,
-0.07835811376571655,
-0.2775670289993286,
0.6362669467926025,
0.20236912369728088,
0.1477862149477005,
-0.640896737575531,
0.11944480240345001,
-0.13618481159210205,
-0.24957863986492157,
0.09127521514892578,
-0.3601936101913452,
0.9275521636009216,
-0.18806588649749756,
-0.506308913230896,
0.17004342377185822,
0.24240316450595856,
0.5994427800178528,
0.555392324924469,
0.519518256187439,
0.582856297492981,
0.5559300184249878,
0.26836371421813965,
1.0625303983688354,
0.02702081948518753,
0.5194609761238098,
1.242641806602478,
-0.3157605528831482,
0.781657338142395,
0.5727638006210327,
0.0175850261002779,
0.20324811339378357,
0.1899159550666809,
-0.38135769963264465,
0.4273267686367035,
0.8670389652252197,
-0.2905973792076111,
-0.16061778366565704,
-0.06721935421228409,
-0.14527136087417603,
0.09779149293899536,
0.3404048979282379,
-0.42402228713035583,
0.08563879132270813,
-0.09573650360107422,
0.3008376359939575,
0.2099958062171936,
-0.02610681764781475,
0.645395040512085,
0.5062703490257263,
-0.6335126161575317,
0.5864353179931641,
-0.02330869995057583,
0.6975396275520325,
-0.7232837080955505,
0.10054294764995575,
-0.45850884914398193,
0.20375065505504608,
-0.10825814306735992,
-0.7406438589096069,
0.13929396867752075,
0.3703530728816986,
-0.04582621157169342,
-0.13458451628684998,
0.5285851955413818,
-0.4927003085613251,
-0.11782043427228928,
0.3104020059108734,
0.1881725937128067,
0.20918117463588715,
-0.14471212029457092,
-0.2634556293487549,
0.08895724266767502,
-0.14347273111343384,
-0.394307404756546,
0.40144863724708557,
0.5143498182296753,
-0.19355908036231995,
0.6232051849365234,
0.6723279356956482,
0.18597960472106934,
0.24320919811725616,
0.03420514985918999,
0.7800535559654236,
-0.7027612924575806,
-0.561353862285614,
-0.8334826827049255,
0.27957457304000854,
-0.01656544953584671,
0.02308434061706066,
0.8086593747138977,
0.7986927628517151,
1.1412391662597656,
-0.4050489366054535,
0.9184806942939758,
0.12428708374500275,
0.3041595220565796,
-0.9139878749847412,
0.8486811518669128,
-0.7097383737564087,
0.5144327878952026,
-0.1464667022228241,
-0.8319269418716431,
-0.3225689232349396,
0.5592818260192871,
-0.23127979040145874,
-0.15148328244686127,
0.8049989342689514,
0.9143608808517456,
-0.4111359715461731,
-0.010755963623523712,
0.17433029413223267,
0.1725175827741623,
0.44186732172966003,
0.6979607343673706,
1.202575922012329,
-0.1796821802854538,
0.6653382182121277,
-0.1605122983455658,
-0.15629014372825623,
-0.24809630215168,
-1.170851469039917,
-1.1491400003433228,
-0.3258228600025177,
-0.08406317234039307,
-0.5588481426239014,
-0.05533171445131302,
0.8523181676864624,
0.42691919207572937,
-0.9112149477005005,
-0.314174085855484,
0.08122813701629639,
0.26459893584251404,
-0.011171907186508179,
-0.11394459009170532,
0.39255833625793457,
0.1328764706850052,
-0.6540870070457458,
0.1341279149055481,
0.039510443806648254,
0.40473249554634094,
-0.19364310801029205,
-0.07727502286434174,
-0.16434882581233978,
0.3615909516811371,
0.16220572590827942,
0.5651117563247681,
-0.6142296195030212,
-0.12906968593597412,
0.13247603178024292,
-0.23520947992801666,
-0.06223318725824356,
1.2217878103256226,
-0.39054521918296814,
0.49519452452659607,
0.5442059636116028,
0.5650696158409119,
0.7522452473640442,
-0.24871228635311127,
0.46175456047058105,
-0.8740503191947937,
0.33146747946739197,
0.5079845786094666,
0.41143301129341125,
0.2828647494316101,
-0.2453913688659668,
0.28071796894073486,
0.33828994631767273,
-0.3790005147457123,
-0.9631096124649048,
0.25458234548568726,
-0.9160456657409668,
-0.38220545649528503,
1.18331778049469,
-0.5823851823806763,
-0.24262961745262146,
-0.031188661232590675,
-0.131905660033226,
0.4225427508354187,
-0.10177905112504959,
0.9432501792907715,
0.78108149766922,
0.46998411417007446,
0.11346564441919327,
-0.9173231720924377,
0.5454985499382019,
0.3442036807537079,
-0.5266118049621582,
0.1600223332643509,
0.4408348500728607,
0.6330425143241882,
0.1030673235654831,
0.7101841568946838,
-0.31797486543655396,
0.28077560663223267,
-0.04741277918219566,
0.08119518309831619,
-0.22155670821666718,
-0.4671801030635834,
-0.6210840344429016,
-0.11780061572790146,
0.18651482462882996,
-0.031080186367034912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09353v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09353v5 | DoRA: Weight-Decomposed Low-Rank Adaptation | 2024-02-14T17:59:34 | 2024-06-03T07:27:15 | Shih-Yang Liu, Chien-Yi Wang, Hongxu Yin, Pavlo Molchanov, Yu-Chiang Frank Wang, Kwang-Ting Cheng, Min-Hung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Among the widely used parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods, LoRA
and its variants have gained considerable popularity because of avoiding
additional inference costs. However, there still often exists an accuracy gap
between these methods and full fine-tuning (FT). In this work, we first
introduce a novel weight decomposition analysis to investigate the inherent
differences between FT and LoRA. Aiming to resemble the learning capacity of FT
from the findings, we propose Weight-Decomposed Low-Rank Adaptation (DoRA).
DoRA decomposes the pre-trained weight into two components, magnitude and
direction, for fine-tuning, specifically employing LoRA for directional updates
to efficiently minimize the number of trainable parameters. By employing \ours,
we enhance both the learning capacity and training stability of LoRA while
avoiding any additional inference overhead. \ours~consistently outperforms LoRA
on fine-tuning LLaMA, LLaVA, and VL-BART on various downstream tasks, such as
commonsense reasoning, visual instruction tuning, and image/video-text
understanding. Code is available at https://github.com/NVlabs/DoRA. | [
-0.17907534539699554,
-0.7851491570472717,
0.3645753264427185,
0.23778672516345978,
-0.355840265750885,
0.05822433531284332,
-0.24276003241539001,
-0.24167916178703308,
0.13883572816848755,
0.21181201934814453,
-0.6417163014411926,
-0.4249289929866791,
-0.7692229151725769,
0.04097926244139671,
-0.22730301320552826,
1.068611741065979,
0.07191316038370132,
-0.042890697717666626,
0.057058580219745636,
-0.3803936243057251,
-0.5259432196617126,
-0.18161365389823914,
-0.9025486707687378,
-0.011051330715417862,
0.7888649106025696,
0.7522231340408325,
0.3053086996078491,
0.3251499831676483,
0.3710978031158447,
0.22880765795707703,
-0.11367403715848923,
0.3159314692020416,
-1.0902475118637085,
-0.0028549153357744217,
-0.06773809343576431,
-0.597990095615387,
-1.069421648979187,
-0.0057143159210681915,
0.6715436577796936,
0.6287882924079895,
-0.3231293559074402,
0.6799991726875305,
0.23837342858314514,
1.1788551807403564,
-1.072418212890625,
-0.011890063062310219,
-0.9225796461105347,
-0.11645960807800293,
-0.06715445965528488,
-0.2191818207502365,
-0.37278497219085693,
-0.1407724916934967,
-0.26253464818000793,
-0.865458607673645,
0.1025506928563118,
0.011953705921769142,
0.8527658581733704,
0.7757976055145264,
-0.3009786903858185,
0.09574343264102936,
-0.5151230692863464,
1.0019476413726807,
-0.3510662019252777,
0.22000285983085632,
0.5746688842773438,
0.39231592416763306,
0.08593299239873886,
-0.42936423420906067,
-0.14961707592010498,
0.3338533043861389,
0.5261828303337097,
-0.003022487973794341,
-0.26434624195098877,
-0.1818782091140747,
0.11457153409719467,
0.3915582299232483,
-0.1527864784002304,
0.348759263753891,
-0.5329644083976746,
0.3148352801799774,
0.6278464794158936,
-0.20675384998321533,
0.030022088438272476,
0.06380859017372131,
-0.48146358132362366,
-0.2694731056690216,
-1.0611985921859741,
0.13544701039791107,
0.36117589473724365,
0.48936110734939575,
-0.30567291378974915,
0.35521769523620605,
-0.32460466027259827,
0.6225718259811401,
0.4994906783103943,
-0.2465832382440567,
0.24087129533290863,
-0.0014959259424358606,
-0.5513158440589905,
0.33138635754585266,
0.383797824382782,
0.37524887919425964,
0.1081690788269043,
0.14454978704452515,
-0.10697942227125168,
-0.1397121697664261,
0.1040647029876709,
-0.8955921530723572,
-0.40609508752822876,
-0.14396175742149353,
-0.7402561902999878,
-0.5042278170585632,
-0.13813354074954987,
-0.6936396956443787,
-0.4790800213813782,
-0.16202573478221893,
0.9542829990386963,
-0.1615947186946869,
0.0873679369688034,
0.2963091731071472,
0.08718961477279663,
0.4816363751888275,
0.7898581027984619,
-0.9659914374351501,
0.5539626479148865,
0.6696978211402893,
0.6292204856872559,
-0.052658773958683014,
-0.016592932865023613,
-1.413107991218567,
-0.09029730409383774,
-0.2920294404029846,
0.6843058466911316,
-0.269034206867218,
-0.10394368320703506,
-0.4383324384689331,
0.06644552201032639,
-0.2856704890727997,
-0.34842267632484436,
0.7300906181335449,
-0.6683987975120544,
0.07069014757871628,
-0.47879618406295776,
0.005142074078321457,
-0.41622909903526306,
0.12348219007253647,
-0.6667693257331848,
0.8515592217445374,
0.35561230778694153,
-0.5123330950737,
0.5871636271476746,
-0.6380056738853455,
-0.5348376631736755,
-0.4658006727695465,
0.2947406470775604,
-0.670418381690979,
0.38096684217453003,
0.6443201899528503,
0.33047088980674744,
-0.35502734780311584,
-0.36728814244270325,
-0.310037761926651,
-0.744964599609375,
-0.283189982175827,
-0.29493921995162964,
0.7499650120735168,
0.18072694540023804,
-0.09435776621103287,
0.20731514692306519,
-0.9922067523002625,
-0.08605525642633438,
0.34574124217033386,
-0.6406678557395935,
-0.3901604413986206,
0.3296199440956116,
-0.14917534589767456,
-0.3002670109272003,
0.4032215178012848,
-0.4675246775150299,
0.2293315827846527,
-0.35729947686195374,
0.42767778038978577,
0.9107762575149536,
-0.06095804274082184,
0.5573623180389404,
-0.23225784301757812,
0.5167148113250732,
-0.11219854652881622,
0.30811557173728943,
0.2845855951309204,
-0.46178990602493286,
-0.78753662109375,
-0.2656082808971405,
0.6225205063819885,
0.24127358198165894,
-0.4707656502723694,
0.226517453789711,
-0.4037337601184845,
-0.22550071775913239,
-0.6376010179519653,
0.44773826003074646,
0.2600879371166229,
0.6921504139900208,
0.5664716958999634,
-0.07298833876848221,
-0.6380734443664551,
-0.4359024167060852,
-0.16499701142311096,
0.019555743783712387,
0.018610408529639244,
-0.0698959082365036,
0.2601540982723236,
-0.04940887540578842,
0.42466118931770325,
-0.4968130886554718,
-0.7031189203262329,
-0.2352907955646515,
0.036482688039541245,
0.22387272119522095,
0.42878925800323486,
0.9584845304489136,
-0.597290575504303,
-0.5642514228820801,
-0.10336245596408844,
-0.3560118079185486,
0.1715252846479416,
0.20466992259025574,
-0.15203967690467834,
0.18376001715660095,
0.29679256677627563,
-0.069524846971035,
0.47565025091171265,
0.851615309715271,
-0.33315059542655945,
0.08956214040517807,
-0.5029448866844177,
0.0645359456539154,
-0.6224774122238159,
-0.0876898318529129,
-0.20480976998806,
-0.2850707173347473,
-0.193639874458313,
0.10471221059560776,
-0.06843675673007965,
-0.17664077877998352,
-0.14886261522769928,
0.2703506648540497,
-0.40884628891944885,
-0.2570871114730835,
-0.08620887994766235,
0.10709911584854126,
0.08153536915779114,
0.5967573523521423,
-0.24982967972755432,
0.8802511096000671,
0.5912722945213318,
-0.6475921869277954,
-0.113681361079216,
0.3394893705844879,
-0.40611129999160767,
0.6255189180374146,
-0.8238780498504639,
0.057244233787059784,
-0.17934125661849976,
-0.06170804798603058,
-0.9499651789665222,
-0.12110186368227005,
0.17095108330249786,
-0.11861467361450195,
0.26331627368927,
-0.6344197392463684,
-0.2741229236125946,
0.08975587040185928,
-0.8407610058784485,
0.4841218590736389,
0.8855464458465576,
-0.6643348336219788,
0.41398119926452637,
0.34669068455696106,
-0.003923547919839621,
-0.5095598101615906,
-0.4307343661785126,
-0.3259834051132202,
-0.38645002245903015,
-0.2918190658092499,
0.27137479186058044,
-0.1798027902841568,
-0.05333130434155464,
-0.13727037608623505,
-0.362301766872406,
0.18215137720108032,
0.44902434945106506,
0.30643460154533386,
-0.1321215182542801,
-0.5540065169334412,
-0.05851488560438156,
0.44807082414627075,
-0.06680945307016373,
-0.23993705213069916,
0.15828253328800201,
0.32975783944129944,
-0.380150705575943,
-0.36491814255714417,
-0.29185229539871216,
-0.04174063727259636,
0.6224497556686401,
-0.20563316345214844,
0.9198482632637024,
0.8105584383010864,
-0.04064803943037987,
-0.4804728925228119,
-0.17129307985305786,
0.13932651281356812,
-0.49235430359840393,
0.2636655867099762,
-0.4794559180736542,
-0.27490904927253723,
0.42448970675468445,
-0.15812012553215027,
-0.07053709030151367,
0.4968571960926056,
0.1940741389989853,
-0.37853726744651794,
1.0765982866287231,
0.9549497961997986,
-0.03958879038691521,
0.6110150218009949,
-0.4221016764640808,
-0.0014928893651813269,
-1.1524959802627563,
-0.0706343799829483,
-0.5396350622177124,
-0.8663650155067444,
-0.4289569556713104,
-0.3904382884502411,
0.6515067219734192,
0.4131814241409302,
-0.5820896029472351,
0.13691450655460358,
-0.5093722343444824,
0.46386170387268066,
0.5484817028045654,
0.34096261858940125,
0.49323412775993347,
0.2887168824672699,
0.5618768930435181,
0.09809165447950363,
-0.7279608845710754,
-0.07524353265762329,
1.3614815473556519,
0.30317923426628113,
1.1326202154159546,
0.1487964540719986,
0.8177614808082581,
0.42412176728248596,
0.008853769861161709,
-0.9753311276435852,
0.43766605854034424,
-0.5537083745002747,
0.068393275141716,
-0.3812820017337799,
-0.2779688537120819,
-1.0584162473678589,
0.26500192284584045,
-0.28110694885253906,
-0.4852575659751892,
0.3911401331424713,
0.030673421919345856,
-0.43562033772468567,
0.32096531987190247,
-0.6836315989494324,
0.6585682034492493,
-0.3016022741794586,
-0.17570260167121887,
-0.4848165214061737,
-0.4367787837982178,
0.2885192632675171,
-0.14687839150428772,
0.0736822858452797,
-0.30383196473121643,
-0.1910039782524109,
1.1136338710784912,
-0.6467089653015137,
0.7453133463859558,
-0.4461514949798584,
-0.49023860692977905,
0.11150150746107101,
0.07364368438720703,
0.5599859952926636,
0.12431888282299042,
-0.3634144067764282,
0.029759058728814125,
0.29133841395378113,
-0.6164820194244385,
-0.5135154128074646,
0.722766637802124,
-1.0879817008972168,
-0.34190693497657776,
-0.27738475799560547,
-0.3536657392978668,
-0.3676956295967102,
0.13164691627025604,
0.06352563947439194,
0.2622547745704651,
-0.10091676563024521,
0.3212072253227234,
0.7120550870895386,
-0.08523347228765488,
0.2796856760978699,
0.3504524230957031,
-0.14056995511054993,
-0.3803962469100952,
0.970344066619873,
-0.09060823172330856,
-0.016088085249066353,
0.5770646929740906,
0.22716297209262848,
0.03827151283621788,
-0.8179752230644226,
-0.2938025891780853,
0.23371896147727966,
-0.5847682356834412,
-0.33887046575546265,
0.07602481544017792,
0.07890953123569489,
0.22231736779212952,
-0.33023133873939514,
-0.5047377943992615,
-0.5075804591178894,
-0.46493634581565857,
0.18557174503803253,
0.5018860101699829,
0.8205758929252625,
-0.060253605246543884,
0.49346163868904114,
-0.34991133213043213,
0.6683920621871948,
0.625757098197937,
0.24158599972724915,
0.006026156712323427,
-0.7003565430641174,
-0.13883987069129944,
0.2578071057796478,
-0.08896850794553757,
-0.5081707835197449,
-0.018123235553503036,
0.7732404470443726,
0.19081369042396545,
0.5469238758087158,
0.303471177816391,
1.0539747476577759,
-0.28021499514579773,
0.541244387626648,
0.06423478573560715,
-0.8775709867477417,
0.7744098901748657,
-0.20405055582523346,
-0.0034740986302495003,
0.7606315016746521,
0.04415806755423546,
0.19981536269187927,
0.2987625002861023,
-0.3216414749622345,
-0.5823422074317932,
0.7315500974655151,
-0.04924638941884041,
-0.07563864439725876,
0.4705063998699188,
0.1920093446969986,
0.25305670499801636,
0.062356434762477875,
-0.46771079301834106,
0.14969542622566223,
-0.10055568814277649,
-0.2613260746002197,
-0.18729718029499054,
-0.41191571950912476,
-0.26639702916145325,
-0.6966469883918762,
0.67173832654953,
-0.4559972584247589,
0.15326246619224548,
-0.08423522859811783,
-0.5561376810073853,
-0.4624665677547455,
0.007895483635365963,
0.6427182555198669,
0.807105302810669,
-0.5986151695251465,
0.08407117426395416,
0.32769352197647095,
-0.4702218174934387,
-0.02716376818716526,
-0.2003723382949829,
-0.11078245937824249,
-0.46867823600769043,
0.33820828795433044,
0.7036863565444946,
0.7183364629745483,
-0.565511167049408,
0.5291517376899719,
-0.08931837230920792,
-0.31183722615242004,
0.19040533900260925,
0.32659265398979187,
-0.20131471753120422,
0.2688203752040863,
0.5651558041572571,
0.3026154339313507,
-0.20195870101451874,
-0.59178626537323,
-0.21471959352493286,
0.41898292303085327,
-0.262879878282547,
-0.5506384372711182,
0.8054443597793579,
0.33401402831077576,
0.046348877251148224,
0.38531261682510376,
-0.2868129014968872,
-0.0832073912024498,
0.44893643260002136,
0.3388684391975403,
0.7099889516830444,
0.033503927290439606,
0.350202739238739,
0.3364144265651703,
0.09500492364168167,
0.03695918992161751,
0.5712828040122986,
-0.38901999592781067,
-0.3416191041469574,
-0.4429115653038025,
-0.9727686643600464,
-0.08751469105482101,
0.027740398421883583,
-0.838333785533905,
0.2779480814933777,
-0.776185154914856,
0.057809118181467056,
-0.2753361463546753,
0.30667683482170105,
-0.6287092566490173,
-0.15102431178092957,
0.08381414413452148,
0.8188251852989197,
-0.808577835559845,
0.811328649520874,
0.8303930759429932,
-0.37783053517341614,
-0.552337110042572,
0.07168789207935333,
-0.20200403034687042,
-1.1913467645645142,
0.9448069930076599,
-0.2540685534477234,
-0.6054490804672241,
0.1614183634519577,
-0.6501427888870239,
-0.9794575572013855,
1.3528039455413818,
0.5200842022895813,
-0.25462931394577026,
-0.14346928894519806,
-0.2740466594696045,
0.35078322887420654,
-0.24754519760608673,
-0.2985842227935791,
0.41878628730773926,
0.5009354948997498,
0.091497041285038,
-0.9286688566207886,
0.05128980800509453,
0.08945582807064056,
0.03429441154003143,
0.05003257095813751,
-0.8286157250404358,
1.1272679567337036,
-0.45205506682395935,
-0.05841582268476486,
0.34272968769073486,
0.5334460735321045,
0.0890980139374733,
0.20953334867954254,
0.563059389591217,
0.5110516548156738,
0.9329453706741333,
0.08946730941534042,
0.6498717069625854,
-0.09355227649211884,
0.444168359041214,
1.119075894355774,
-0.24549400806427002,
1.1341238021850586,
0.5124263167381287,
-0.4510391056537628,
0.918555498123169,
0.5537565350532532,
0.09714869409799576,
0.9584164023399353,
-0.2795497179031372,
0.1733151376247406,
-0.31173408031463623,
0.31197530031204224,
-0.4721510410308838,
0.7866060137748718,
0.36074385046958923,
-0.08785583078861237,
-0.5505642294883728,
0.10776501148939133,
-0.10587295889854431,
-0.10514606535434723,
-0.8483704924583435,
0.6766812205314636,
0.016602134332060814,
-0.3462490439414978,
1.2299983501434326,
0.08396653831005096,
0.62245112657547,
-0.5485875010490417,
-0.09555657207965851,
-0.17227508127689362,
0.3777771592140198,
-0.35084640979766846,
-0.4253164827823639,
-0.07213481515645981,
-0.02576291374862194,
-0.12192746996879578,
-0.15807613730430603,
0.7452641129493713,
-0.05934111773967743,
-0.40573832392692566,
0.009368772618472576,
0.44032689929008484,
-0.07065530866384506,
-0.25217825174331665,
-0.6221922039985657,
0.3532065749168396,
-0.22844748198986053,
-0.18735583126544952,
0.6307342052459717,
0.33681371808052063,
-0.010319245979189873,
0.6829103827476501,
0.5173234343528748,
0.19897820055484772,
-0.007177823223173618,
0.026057064533233643,
0.7368212938308716,
-0.38858574628829956,
-0.575977087020874,
-0.3638187050819397,
0.3894767165184021,
0.22281663119792938,
-0.18319271504878998,
0.7032207250595093,
0.355508953332901,
0.510261595249176,
-0.26380494236946106,
0.2791595458984375,
-0.20111706852912903,
0.2263375073671341,
-0.8198917508125305,
0.8761875629425049,
-0.9589658975601196,
0.34258726239204407,
-0.3165798783302307,
-0.8646854758262634,
-0.06951745599508286,
0.7254270315170288,
-0.391188383102417,
0.013792919926345348,
0.4851742386817932,
0.4048774242401123,
-0.5298178791999817,
-0.29072701930999756,
0.2329396903514862,
0.240705206990242,
-0.13276802003383636,
0.8003727197647095,
0.456822007894516,
-1.055768609046936,
0.4918372929096222,
-0.08195734024047852,
-0.11419875174760818,
-0.7671198844909668,
-0.9095032215118408,
-0.9522432684898376,
-0.5814728140830994,
-0.3926609754562378,
0.09796475619077682,
0.09641345590353012,
0.4523216784000397,
1.037277102470398,
-0.7842883467674255,
0.09599438309669495,
0.00980408675968647,
0.4741247296333313,
-0.7629457116127014,
-0.15219180285930634,
0.6699723601341248,
-0.334818035364151,
-0.6220468282699585,
0.6954545378684998,
0.05353832617402077,
-0.19206444919109344,
-0.058705054223537445,
-0.385701447725296,
-0.12722578644752502,
-0.11815591156482697,
1.0024081468582153,
0.4564611613750458,
-0.44790518283843994,
-0.41181549429893494,
-0.4393077492713928,
0.4216196835041046,
0.3293563425540924,
0.3580400347709656,
-1.1480381488800049,
0.246464341878891,
0.45814988017082214,
0.531293511390686,
0.6912577748298645,
0.3622409999370575,
0.24052290618419647,
-0.8544175624847412,
0.1301618367433548,
-0.15906186401844025,
0.23042818903923035,
0.09090922027826309,
-0.22595295310020447,
0.6238925457000732,
0.05952347442507744,
-0.32636842131614685,
-1.0703482627868652,
0.13279275596141815,
-1.4371209144592285,
-0.19608061015605927,
0.889914333820343,
0.1490187793970108,
-0.5467074513435364,
0.3417634665966034,
-0.3600669205188751,
0.03632137179374695,
-0.29985496401786804,
0.7148590683937073,
0.06054086610674858,
-0.19761575758457184,
-0.27194058895111084,
-0.3354038894176483,
0.6776549816131592,
0.35835644602775574,
-0.7067088484764099,
-0.13978615403175354,
0.13079747557640076,
0.6228998899459839,
-0.11101675778627396,
0.4079309403896332,
0.004177137743681669,
0.3898930251598358,
-0.1002003625035286,
-0.48567530512809753,
-0.2970370650291443,
-0.45848706364631653,
-0.5403702855110168,
0.37001803517341614,
0.5337815284729004,
-0.639758825302124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09344v1 | Generating Diverse Translation with Perturbed kNN-MT | 2024-02-14T17:46:46 | 2024-02-14T17:46:46 | Yuto Nishida, Makoto Morishita, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating multiple translation candidates would enable users to choose the
one that satisfies their needs. Although there has been work on diversified
generation, there exists room for improving the diversity mainly because the
previous methods do not address the overcorrection problem -- the model
underestimates a prediction that is largely different from the training data,
even if that prediction is likely. This paper proposes methods that generate
more diverse translations by introducing perturbed k-nearest neighbor machine
translation (kNN-MT). Our methods expand the search space of kNN-MT and help
incorporate diverse words into candidates by addressing the overcorrection
problem. Our experiments show that the proposed methods drastically improve
candidate diversity and control the degree of diversity by tuning the
perturbation's magnitude. | [
-0.824558436870575,
-0.5151514410972595,
0.307760626077652,
0.1552170217037201,
-0.6155405044555664,
0.4998113811016083,
-0.354734867811203,
-0.2603089511394501,
0.25241583585739136,
0.6930302977561951,
-0.5636966824531555,
-0.5042442679405212,
-0.9096460342407227,
0.3438926041126251,
-0.20924556255340576,
1.0488309860229492,
0.013648893684148788,
0.07398032397031784,
0.23745881021022797,
-0.21947067975997925,
-0.4885815382003784,
-0.6892414689064026,
-0.07454489171504974,
-0.2970186173915863,
0.8575211763381958,
0.8149588108062744,
0.9054586887359619,
0.5921658873558044,
0.6156648397445679,
0.29416391253471375,
-0.3706507384777069,
0.10946685820817947,
-0.718981921672821,
0.5144695043563843,
0.08909709751605988,
-0.7472866177558899,
-0.04972873255610466,
-0.17674577236175537,
1.0316028594970703,
0.6450875401496887,
-0.07951851934194565,
-0.028213050216436386,
-0.3519456088542938,
0.7542789578437805,
-0.5799228549003601,
-0.5269735455513,
-1.0806711912155151,
0.39260998368263245,
-0.6093798875808716,
-0.1669774353504181,
-0.005428907461464405,
-0.4727519452571869,
0.009049721993505955,
-0.3511418402194977,
0.17825941741466522,
-0.04745177924633026,
0.631243884563446,
0.023340240120887756,
-0.7290246486663818,
-0.14659355580806732,
-0.9953832030296326,
1.1753171682357788,
-0.7571923732757568,
0.5133458971977234,
0.33024266362190247,
0.6907516121864319,
-0.4221782684326172,
-0.37330523133277893,
-0.6243902444839478,
-0.21736198663711548,
0.3137940764427185,
0.4537399709224701,
0.22764720022678375,
-0.35436707735061646,
0.324185848236084,
0.5380754470825195,
-0.14770416915416718,
0.29147815704345703,
-0.3435872495174408,
-0.030100252479314804,
0.4742565155029297,
0.4949369728565216,
0.2993549406528473,
-0.14360365271568298,
-0.12132725119590759,
-0.49090293049812317,
-0.530266284942627,
-0.045254841446876526,
1.0597413778305054,
0.43195095658302307,
0.23386473953723907,
0.7349451780319214,
-0.32778409123420715,
0.5063507556915283,
-0.01709207519888878,
-0.0024647600948810577,
0.5207419991493225,
-0.41180136799812317,
0.06084307283163071,
0.11471088230609894,
0.6270012259483337,
0.34467366337776184,
-0.17782628536224365,
-0.18887080252170563,
-0.20846635103225708,
-0.08886867016553879,
0.31365031003952026,
-0.8697050213813782,
-0.18452072143554688,
0.054240304976701736,
-0.5015086531639099,
-0.5981268286705017,
0.16480442881584167,
-1.1611902713775635,
-0.22812731564044952,
-0.0869586393237114,
0.09127166867256165,
-0.3558487892150879,
-0.4495273232460022,
-0.13253405690193176,
-0.4286133944988251,
-0.15649864077568054,
0.16791893541812897,
-0.8739364147186279,
0.03190102428197861,
0.3103633522987366,
0.6433454155921936,
-0.25724339485168457,
-0.38715097308158875,
-0.3511754870414734,
-0.044556960463523865,
-0.3574046790599823,
0.49518102407455444,
-0.8255226016044617,
-0.7531918287277222,
-0.0196731798350811,
-0.5600681900978088,
0.3384206295013428,
-0.8087010383605957,
0.39688757061958313,
-0.5699540972709656,
0.3179028034210205,
-0.7521476745605469,
-0.2207350879907608,
-0.15943755209445953,
0.39747393131256104,
-0.5081683397293091,
0.8015206456184387,
0.43699344992637634,
-0.733954131603241,
0.6315526366233826,
-0.8090253472328186,
-0.5615400671958923,
-0.14329048991203308,
0.044635891914367676,
-0.7980074882507324,
0.4566996097564697,
0.5056765675544739,
0.08871689438819885,
-0.003925188910216093,
0.08870802819728851,
-0.30425330996513367,
0.024734167382121086,
0.6225458383560181,
-0.19026538729667664,
0.6118379235267639,
0.4525282382965088,
0.006553270388394594,
0.1750478893518448,
-0.8460366725921631,
-0.011545172892510891,
0.11771830916404724,
-0.6972798705101013,
-0.36966362595558167,
-0.1281105875968933,
0.07335200905799866,
0.3855700194835663,
-0.010104403831064701,
-0.7010997533798218,
0.31162527203559875,
-0.6955860257148743,
0.11234961450099945,
0.5366597771644592,
0.004115393850952387,
0.5165754556655884,
-0.42011067271232605,
0.8028189539909363,
0.3171634376049042,
0.06700113415718079,
-0.02911093458533287,
-0.7737540602684021,
-0.3954586982727051,
-0.1333615630865097,
0.5189530849456787,
0.3894370198249817,
-0.7822130918502808,
0.21827784180641174,
-0.24166011810302734,
-0.48253992199897766,
-0.8120213150978088,
0.34922030568122864,
0.1631896048784256,
0.3701139986515045,
0.48599839210510254,
-0.3320631980895996,
-0.8853336572647095,
-0.609513521194458,
-0.5164624452590942,
0.35003113746643066,
-0.0579744391143322,
0.4891699254512787,
0.3364272117614746,
-0.7213509678840637,
0.6785470843315125,
-0.3734343349933624,
-0.38167604804039,
-0.12910835444927216,
0.05763554945588112,
0.4486590623855591,
0.5494847297668457,
0.47565966844558716,
-1.1397987604141235,
-0.9477400779724121,
0.47754600644111633,
-0.1569977104663849,
-0.14932329952716827,
0.01605881378054619,
-0.3211318254470825,
-0.03550482541322708,
0.21874724328517914,
-0.2548930048942566,
0.039423540234565735,
0.6376273036003113,
0.10289681702852249,
0.44990065693855286,
-0.011304127983748913,
0.2333899885416031,
-1.4065219163894653,
-0.07602111250162125,
-0.6036986708641052,
-0.1985509693622589,
-0.638999879360199,
0.35571813583374023,
-0.21496039628982544,
-0.02463107742369175,
-0.2486843764781952,
0.20296718180179596,
-0.3819453716278076,
-0.0763411819934845,
-0.46092313528060913,
0.2604826092720032,
-0.5527414679527283,
0.10668377578258514,
-0.32080474495887756,
0.29517218470573425,
0.31364914774894714,
-0.5025616884231567,
0.3683512210845947,
0.5147154331207275,
-0.27084243297576904,
0.17107893526554108,
-0.1486232429742813,
0.15630565583705902,
-0.2304956614971161,
0.1804286390542984,
-1.0442339181900024,
-0.3633266091346741,
0.19900639355182648,
-0.5621452927589417,
0.32507163286209106,
-0.24221287667751312,
-0.5204120874404907,
-0.5821969509124756,
-0.21019679307937622,
0.524450421333313,
0.6660317182540894,
-0.6534417271614075,
0.4962262809276581,
0.1272568255662918,
-0.07767648249864578,
-0.5518568754196167,
-0.9192896485328674,
0.13853691518306732,
-0.41142159700393677,
-0.4369187355041504,
0.3464992344379425,
-0.14400438964366913,
0.14699964225292206,
-0.13875210285186768,
-0.21506382524967194,
0.14519670605659485,
0.15698041021823883,
-0.0020595246460288763,
-0.06501030921936035,
-0.32983317971229553,
-0.21251867711544037,
0.6124972105026245,
-0.13355596363544464,
-0.29475709795951843,
-0.5186145305633545,
0.744316577911377,
0.23781165480613708,
-0.2401508390903473,
0.09271031618118286,
0.6038700342178345,
0.41090843081474304,
-0.3351074755191803,
0.5741434693336487,
1.0497077703475952,
0.00878319051116705,
-0.004034814890474081,
-0.564845085144043,
-0.17050069570541382,
-0.532326877117157,
0.7290841341018677,
-0.5446725487709045,
-1.1914597749710083,
0.9535338282585144,
-0.424043744802475,
0.11732445657253265,
0.4508439898490906,
0.8453730344772339,
-0.16591545939445496,
1.4146183729171753,
0.36612647771835327,
0.16217932105064392,
0.7024105787277222,
-0.0983644500374794,
-0.10777455568313599,
-1.0191442966461182,
-0.10125121474266052,
-0.6217300295829773,
-1.0070990324020386,
-0.9471419453620911,
-0.16676224768161774,
0.3541814684867859,
0.24733954668045044,
-0.054340165108442307,
0.2556222677230835,
-0.5896557569503784,
0.4544493556022644,
0.7988882660865784,
-0.0052189575508236885,
0.1503133773803711,
0.43882280588150024,
-0.6188595294952393,
-0.5190388560295105,
-0.8253670334815979,
-0.030320223420858383,
1.3626632690429688,
0.08810978382825851,
0.3905240595340729,
0.3934135138988495,
1.1854795217514038,
-0.2725902199745178,
0.6810204386711121,
-0.38362061977386475,
0.29609784483909607,
-0.7061716318130493,
-0.7250065803527832,
-0.40650349855422974,
-0.9338159561157227,
-1.21113121509552,
0.382545530796051,
-0.581575870513916,
-0.56466144323349,
0.1445796936750412,
0.10966283082962036,
-0.026185769587755203,
0.4036899507045746,
-0.1629130244255066,
0.6694879531860352,
-0.2189243733882904,
0.5293418169021606,
-0.27058321237564087,
-0.8721312284469604,
0.41540858149528503,
-0.5422699451446533,
-0.03945459425449371,
0.09980462491512299,
0.05657614767551422,
0.3175431787967682,
-0.38454586267471313,
0.5680955648422241,
-0.11553121358156204,
0.029890749603509903,
0.08317120373249054,
0.18535423278808594,
0.5923675894737244,
-0.07150028645992279,
-0.17297516763210297,
0.1055668368935585,
-0.5528882145881653,
-0.4712750017642975,
-0.7760517001152039,
0.7467181086540222,
-0.9805899262428284,
-0.4539075791835785,
0.13684487342834473,
-0.7842214107513428,
-0.19387711584568024,
0.5737565755844116,
0.8245454430580139,
-0.06466817855834961,
0.11107181012630463,
0.47595804929733276,
0.35155823826789856,
-0.3335951864719391,
0.1291808933019638,
0.27870747447013855,
-0.6899105906486511,
-1.123227834701538,
1.0581721067428589,
0.3773318827152252,
0.4422662556171417,
0.47715049982070923,
0.7644081115722656,
-0.22861464321613312,
-0.8372716307640076,
-0.32999593019485474,
-0.17049676179885864,
-0.5584205389022827,
-0.187157541513443,
-0.7336317896842957,
0.1753961443901062,
-0.26264137029647827,
-0.19286850094795227,
-0.29818081855773926,
-0.5440918803215027,
-0.07945100963115692,
0.1238706111907959,
0.23320817947387695,
0.5905060768127441,
0.009578113444149494,
0.891578733921051,
-1.0721813440322876,
0.45529115200042725,
0.3240579068660736,
0.4575926959514618,
-0.07150385528802872,
-0.5993658900260925,
-0.2284415364265442,
0.13340388238430023,
-0.5610834360122681,
-1.0668585300445557,
0.3961285948753357,
0.07458341121673584,
0.723721981048584,
0.25861987471580505,
-0.05384939908981323,
0.687555730342865,
-0.4974202811717987,
0.6277595162391663,
0.5398537516593933,
-0.7049829959869385,
0.6974727511405945,
-0.5032490491867065,
0.8023637533187866,
0.5977909564971924,
0.4131137430667877,
-0.5264394283294678,
-0.9289886951446533,
-0.5766884088516235,
-1.0013962984085083,
0.6286177039146423,
0.5241762399673462,
0.37857720255851746,
0.050363022834062576,
0.19784487783908844,
0.4279535114765167,
0.39993223547935486,
-0.43783727288246155,
-0.23734523355960846,
-0.6589541435241699,
-0.00699149165302515,
-0.09596234560012817,
-0.2292582094669342,
0.14536534249782562,
-0.13918478786945343,
0.5869029760360718,
0.23817913234233856,
-0.00045051658526062965,
0.19145745038986206,
0.13727688789367676,
-0.598740816116333,
0.168659046292305,
0.7925509810447693,
0.2210729420185089,
-0.11839018762111664,
-0.12803517282009125,
0.40162572264671326,
-0.5887210369110107,
-0.017915770411491394,
-0.012892150320112705,
-0.4375758469104767,
0.19212254881858826,
-0.15932005643844604,
0.8045080304145813,
-0.23900780081748962,
-0.2413872927427292,
-0.03572389483451843,
0.08409492671489716,
-0.3960777521133423,
0.18052582442760468,
0.17872639000415802,
0.070477694272995,
0.26845690608024597,
0.30765867233276367,
0.5323792695999146,
0.059653401374816895,
-0.39515283703804016,
0.09883709251880646,
0.3333425223827362,
-0.18031181395053864,
-0.1643473207950592,
0.7920094132423401,
0.11849456280469894,
-0.6985780000686646,
0.9099345207214355,
-0.3288947641849518,
-0.9236569404602051,
0.5693996548652649,
0.9251945614814758,
0.9724621176719666,
-0.6298722624778748,
-0.17541612684726715,
0.3770712614059448,
0.39030420780181885,
-0.0788545235991478,
0.5133854150772095,
0.10115461051464081,
-0.8586593866348267,
-0.5271381139755249,
-0.3771442770957947,
-0.24475282430648804,
0.14327818155288696,
-0.46652644872665405,
0.12838760018348694,
-0.4240225553512573,
-0.8394370675086975,
-0.2185058295726776,
-0.05655907094478607,
-0.39034515619277954,
0.15342989563941956,
-0.06595580279827118,
0.37639421224594116,
-0.5282834768295288,
0.7595122456550598,
0.9838428497314453,
-0.42679619789123535,
-0.45650598406791687,
0.14129950106143951,
-0.41191941499710083,
-0.29164621233940125,
0.7495383620262146,
-0.12661273777484894,
0.28240105509757996,
-0.04654858261346817,
-0.5574820041656494,
-0.8528435826301575,
0.6724252104759216,
0.4147671163082123,
-0.587187647819519,
0.3792717754840851,
0.389838308095932,
0.46430328488349915,
-0.29134321212768555,
-0.21160681545734406,
0.031478434801101685,
0.7264585494995117,
0.11305223405361176,
-0.661599338054657,
-0.10265161097049713,
-0.1139117106795311,
0.35277464985847473,
0.6549661159515381,
-0.3958824574947357,
0.7735773324966431,
-0.14816351234912872,
0.006407466717064381,
0.22017446160316467,
0.6136545538902283,
0.26714053750038147,
0.10678160190582275,
0.5067474842071533,
0.432770311832428,
0.6474089026451111,
0.12300611287355423,
0.9751802086830139,
0.04924330115318298,
0.20612576603889465,
1.161360740661621,
0.023637140169739723,
0.6573522090911865,
0.5757507085800171,
-0.3181111812591553,
0.22186148166656494,
0.26446378231048584,
-0.36768627166748047,
0.4078011214733124,
0.35784071683883667,
-0.05074141547083855,
-0.4879933297634125,
0.2484140545129776,
-0.5012699365615845,
0.4478810727596283,
0.32769137620925903,
-0.44271454215049744,
-0.23386703431606293,
0.1280001848936081,
-0.42600706219673157,
0.389885812997818,
-0.11827008426189423,
0.4488052725791931,
0.20793560147285461,
-0.4590799808502197,
0.45275089144706726,
0.24481385946273804,
0.6880528330802917,
-0.6156492233276367,
0.02936537005007267,
-0.26517558097839355,
0.03207007423043251,
-0.2097044289112091,
-0.6643340587615967,
0.2818497121334076,
-0.3859453499317169,
-0.3435157239437103,
-0.21823149919509888,
0.8084440231323242,
-0.679611325263977,
-0.7166125774383545,
0.07266290485858917,
0.2390570044517517,
0.2335352897644043,
-0.025732364505529404,
-0.5337427258491516,
-0.11964055150747299,
0.34588783979415894,
0.027977734804153442,
0.541827380657196,
0.6070389747619629,
-0.05697443336248398,
0.603440523147583,
1.0325067043304443,
0.32824382185935974,
0.5115796327590942,
0.1382421851158142,
0.8471775650978088,
-0.5148783326148987,
-0.5607637763023376,
-0.8418017625808716,
0.46952229738235474,
-0.07791353017091751,
-0.5993905663490295,
0.9152851700782776,
0.4770156443119049,
0.9137063026428223,
-0.2766406834125519,
0.6233387589454651,
0.31906384229660034,
0.5484551191329956,
-0.15567190945148468,
0.7228295803070068,
-0.5768569111824036,
0.11500272899866104,
-0.6355206966400146,
-1.1888906955718994,
-0.7180904150009155,
0.5235368013381958,
-0.14923880994319916,
0.21804164350032806,
0.23350560665130615,
0.4174361824989319,
-0.2533416152000427,
-0.07832285016775131,
0.5149803757667542,
0.3193577229976654,
0.32209959626197815,
0.3289402723312378,
0.9537284970283508,
-0.46421709656715393,
1.004821538925171,
-0.22317995131015778,
0.08830992877483368,
-0.43961626291275024,
-0.9235543608665466,
-0.8291429877281189,
-0.2888681888580322,
-0.23159749805927277,
-0.3726901113986969,
-0.08176703751087189,
0.7852118015289307,
0.48310586810112,
-0.9235657453536987,
-0.025203503668308258,
-0.16844123601913452,
0.373505562543869,
-0.3219675123691559,
-0.14097094535827637,
-0.06482823193073273,
-0.39363643527030945,
-0.6297749876976013,
0.3604537546634674,
0.08307180553674698,
0.23436486721038818,
-0.053861115127801895,
-0.2019568681716919,
0.010259375907480717,
-0.2937946319580078,
0.5106075406074524,
0.05957954004406929,
-0.5493433475494385,
0.21267786622047424,
0.046426981687545776,
0.029744064435362816,
0.4187979996204376,
0.8151618838310242,
-0.4125124216079712,
0.8284820914268494,
0.6521291136741638,
0.9399399757385254,
0.6399039030075073,
0.06873922049999237,
0.8416547775268555,
-1.0237281322479248,
-0.08219029754400253,
0.41155943274497986,
-0.06047751009464264,
0.19296659529209137,
-0.36525505781173706,
0.0711091011762619,
0.17399238049983978,
-0.5296133756637573,
-0.812686562538147,
0.682580292224884,
-0.6397132873535156,
-0.2441685050725937,
1.0898395776748657,
0.175269216299057,
0.1555970013141632,
-0.11929967999458313,
-0.38865676522254944,
0.4407626688480377,
-0.4254360795021057,
0.8846551179885864,
0.6203115582466125,
0.30886325240135193,
0.24747999012470245,
-0.509718656539917,
0.24686038494110107,
0.8472601771354675,
-0.3204018771648407,
-0.29233458638191223,
0.17171786725521088,
0.19943858683109283,
0.31834861636161804,
0.20275625586509705,
-0.35824984312057495,
0.2525600492954254,
0.030805598944425583,
-0.14630542695522308,
-0.06542949378490448,
-0.017601951956748962,
-0.2161838859319687,
0.11075688898563385,
0.1927955150604248,
-0.19125095009803772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09320v1 | ICDPO: Effectively Borrowing Alignment Capability of Others via In-context Direct Preference Optimization | 2024-02-14T17:14:34 | 2024-02-14T17:14:34 | Feifan Song, Yuxuan Fan, Xin Zhang, Peiyi Wang, Houfeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) rely on Human Preference Alignment (HPA) to
ensure the generation of safe content. Due to the heavy cost associated with
fine-tuning, fine-tuning-free methods have emerged, typically modifying LLM
decoding with external auxiliary methods. However, these methods do not
essentially enhance the LLM itself. In this paper, we rethink the derivation
procedures of DPO, based on which we conversely build an instant scorer using
the states of the LLM before and after In-context Learning (ICL). Accordingly,
we propose a novel approach called In-Context Direct Preference Optimization
(ICDPO). It enables LLMs to borrow the HPA capabilities from superior LLMs with
ICL, generating well-aligned responses as estimated by the aforementioned
instant scorer, thereby enhancing the final performance. ICDPO can be further
enhanced with a two-stage retriever and an upgraded scorer, both offering
benefits. Extensive experiments show its effectiveness, particularly in
outperforming two fine-tuning-free baselines, and it exhibits competitiveness
with SFT + LoRA. We also conduct detailed analyses to offer comprehensive
insights into ICDPO. | [
-0.3040979206562042,
-0.297203004360199,
0.5140318274497986,
0.11297273635864258,
-0.4336717426776886,
0.1067882627248764,
-0.32711729407310486,
-0.5067888498306274,
-0.13599345088005066,
0.42704951763153076,
-0.2953275740146637,
-0.15297189354896545,
-0.4438762664794922,
0.1612774282693863,
0.1869799792766571,
0.7926768064498901,
-0.18118979036808014,
-0.07602157443761826,
-0.09329584240913391,
0.19633042812347412,
-0.46449607610702515,
-0.3483711779117584,
-0.49036845564842224,
-0.2684192657470703,
0.20508764684200287,
0.9933146238327026,
0.43488070368766785,
0.9824888110160828,
0.44861578941345215,
0.27116671204566956,
0.009947662241756916,
0.3729657530784607,
-0.45915743708610535,
-0.06530993431806564,
-0.16423602402210236,
-0.20805850625038147,
-0.6308949589729309,
0.1970183551311493,
0.7056987285614014,
0.4255644679069519,
-0.0828680470585823,
-0.14682774245738983,
0.43984365463256836,
0.8354028463363647,
-0.7857300043106079,
0.029084421694278717,
-1.1786009073257446,
0.004765683319419622,
-0.05951443687081337,
-0.4347260594367981,
-0.5896323919296265,
-0.4443388879299164,
0.4117647409439087,
-0.6257409453392029,
-0.31539174914360046,
-0.12650145590305328,
0.6699399352073669,
0.3038841187953949,
-0.4401349723339081,
-0.3787499666213989,
-0.567687451839447,
0.9319038391113281,
-0.5520670413970947,
0.1270381659269333,
0.28685253858566284,
0.23411661386489868,
-0.38721275329589844,
-0.14206050336360931,
-0.588994562625885,
-0.215681254863739,
0.09713345766067505,
-0.04780763387680054,
0.21594354510307312,
0.07028185576200485,
-0.11625941097736359,
0.25311073660850525,
-0.032998453825712204,
0.48504438996315,
0.22356267273426056,
0.004078968428075314,
0.6456275582313538,
-0.062375813722610474,
0.16339614987373352,
-0.17490187287330627,
-0.752071738243103,
-0.08096906542778015,
-0.8859592080116272,
0.34574025869369507,
0.37773820757865906,
0.46457770466804504,
0.021991614252328873,
0.5154760479927063,
-0.1171073466539383,
0.598153829574585,
0.706663191318512,
-0.521715521812439,
0.09673960506916046,
-0.17364637553691864,
-0.03900022432208061,
0.3874906003475189,
0.577978789806366,
0.3936169445514679,
0.13766345381736755,
-0.2472597360610962,
-0.23059074580669403,
-0.20135550200939178,
0.08504156023263931,
-0.7070755958557129,
0.2918517589569092,
-0.003477799240499735,
-0.30624547600746155,
-0.3073188066482544,
0.1256680190563202,
-0.8693625330924988,
-0.1397240310907364,
-0.7254080772399902,
0.25831836462020874,
-0.5134175419807434,
-0.0021778519731014967,
0.03791390731930733,
0.21347084641456604,
0.5127829313278198,
0.2505003809928894,
-1.1789737939834595,
0.11845642328262329,
0.9433947205543518,
0.5840030908584595,
-0.578829288482666,
-0.348014235496521,
-0.7474416494369507,
0.4750133752822876,
-0.17865802347660065,
0.6720309257507324,
-0.5480185151100159,
-0.443418949842453,
-0.14059507846832275,
-0.3583245873451233,
0.1541363149881363,
-0.4606313109397888,
0.7157776951789856,
-0.5587144494056702,
0.15789000689983368,
-0.2536250054836273,
-0.6508971452713013,
0.2771282196044922,
0.13479098677635193,
-0.21831358969211578,
0.8531373739242554,
0.05780739337205887,
-0.5923089981079102,
0.6686262488365173,
-0.45796817541122437,
-0.32667994499206543,
0.03344554081559181,
-0.20122385025024414,
-0.1665496528148651,
0.1307888776063919,
0.16678698360919952,
0.4358518421649933,
-0.29212167859077454,
0.34324705600738525,
-0.4755334258079529,
-0.4615338444709778,
0.267652302980423,
-0.39399462938308716,
0.6425272226333618,
0.16217586398124695,
-0.3181406855583191,
0.07760222256183624,
-0.8529080748558044,
-0.11639291048049927,
-0.22314853966236115,
-0.6420189738273621,
-0.6080335974693298,
0.07516111433506012,
-0.4385641813278198,
0.43286553025245667,
0.37593725323677063,
-0.5759601593017578,
0.2759971618652344,
-0.6319487690925598,
0.3697875440120697,
1.2616270780563354,
-0.2926395535469055,
0.9673166871070862,
-0.09195664525032043,
0.2761857807636261,
-0.2058359980583191,
0.24299772083759308,
0.30047109723091125,
-0.141880601644516,
-0.28100258111953735,
-0.7002946138381958,
-0.008020813576877117,
0.49083417654037476,
-0.6123233437538147,
0.9125461578369141,
-0.3103421926498413,
-0.1412399411201477,
-0.42530035972595215,
0.1482630968093872,
0.4884646236896515,
1.0437979698181152,
0.16803941130638123,
-0.20898683369159698,
-0.38342440128326416,
-0.9043340682983398,
-0.23030239343643188,
-0.0926332175731659,
0.17506025731563568,
0.4406188130378723,
-0.12244773656129837,
0.0014668937074020505,
1.1082334518432617,
-0.5699700117111206,
-0.25795063376426697,
-0.28406620025634766,
-0.3036520779132843,
0.22698412835597992,
0.5764064788818359,
0.6251057982444763,
-0.7574378252029419,
-0.9999258518218994,
0.20612716674804688,
-0.43964463472366333,
-0.19224309921264648,
0.17792950570583344,
-0.41954460740089417,
0.31762513518333435,
0.2936074137687683,
-0.44780686497688293,
0.08242445439100266,
0.3676515817642212,
-0.2856312096118927,
0.47208940982818604,
-0.292712926864624,
0.059106506407260895,
-1.1604702472686768,
0.0228608138859272,
-0.0940903052687645,
0.07907595485448837,
-0.4372006952762604,
0.06957987695932388,
0.17009933292865753,
-0.03392889350652695,
-0.555723249912262,
0.8060129880905151,
-0.4014753997325897,
0.05824916809797287,
-0.45770397782325745,
0.15809720754623413,
-0.1778247356414795,
0.4889020621776581,
-0.04019893333315849,
0.9038065671920776,
0.33303606510162354,
-0.6377940773963928,
-0.1533232480287552,
0.30001094937324524,
-0.34436798095703125,
0.5676469206809998,
-0.2618575692176819,
0.36474600434303284,
-0.1952047348022461,
0.17299863696098328,
-1.0254907608032227,
-0.19904214143753052,
0.11768919229507446,
-0.11016075313091278,
0.5617098212242126,
-0.17111381888389587,
-0.3336084187030792,
-0.03696882724761963,
-0.4795697033405304,
0.5309004783630371,
0.2760656177997589,
-0.9062559604644775,
0.2816135585308075,
0.5825706720352173,
-0.07097242027521133,
-0.9075763821601868,
-0.08123116940259933,
-0.00409121485427022,
-0.5088781118392944,
-0.27522948384284973,
0.7271630764007568,
-0.34178200364112854,
-0.3693781793117523,
-0.37176769971847534,
-0.059172485023736954,
0.15423226356506348,
0.23185878992080688,
-0.037110742181539536,
0.5201053619384766,
0.25212574005126953,
-0.019603725522756577,
0.31694290041923523,
-0.3972873091697693,
-0.29630905389785767,
-0.3013280928134918,
0.5511230826377869,
0.12068444490432739,
0.007911870256066322,
-0.6062195897102356,
0.3762836456298828,
0.5419696569442749,
-0.1270437091588974,
0.4528951346874237,
0.005054899957031012,
-0.10915827006101608,
-0.2745364010334015,
-0.37276703119277954,
-0.14803729951381683,
-0.5303723812103271,
0.14775313436985016,
-0.5525911450386047,
-0.6789385080337524,
0.0604967437684536,
-0.09092618525028229,
-0.08290175348520279,
0.10030920058488846,
0.4248325228691101,
-0.03051777370274067,
1.1342915296554565,
0.7357643842697144,
-0.2754858434200287,
0.8220950365066528,
0.07464424520730972,
0.0990556851029396,
-0.9400714039802551,
-0.048932455480098724,
-0.521257758140564,
-0.3133809566497803,
-0.6745228171348572,
0.00016299144772347063,
0.33404552936553955,
0.36762529611587524,
-0.20058533549308777,
0.4234340786933899,
-0.548769474029541,
0.7350214719772339,
0.5266929864883423,
0.14204515516757965,
0.40336379408836365,
0.1140231192111969,
-0.25324249267578125,
-0.2417948693037033,
-0.3331872820854187,
-0.56988924741745,
1.1872161626815796,
0.14456316828727722,
0.4320138990879059,
0.07755470275878906,
0.816636860370636,
0.06861372292041779,
0.3334827423095703,
-0.9556437730789185,
0.6117630004882812,
-0.40645962953567505,
-0.16481485962867737,
-0.21416760981082916,
-0.3064538538455963,
-0.4747123420238495,
0.2754844129085541,
-0.19622696936130524,
-0.9190285801887512,
0.3958575129508972,
0.19535011053085327,
-0.16177545487880707,
0.03219185397028923,
-0.6427628397941589,
0.5370184183120728,
-0.34594640135765076,
-0.5299257040023804,
-0.1878107637166977,
-0.6038610339164734,
0.2878396213054657,
-0.11048854142427444,
-0.07541927695274353,
-0.25185123085975647,
-0.18000493943691254,
0.27880164980888367,
-0.2156437188386917,
0.48577168583869934,
-0.12100622802972794,
-0.41316714882850647,
0.06206096336245537,
0.0070430501364171505,
0.6837878823280334,
0.19013310968875885,
-0.6154788136482239,
-0.19487647712230682,
-0.31387224793434143,
-0.24717696011066437,
-0.43984052538871765,
1.0541183948516846,
-0.82020103931427,
-0.6431884765625,
-0.22741739451885223,
-0.6017088890075684,
-0.37954720854759216,
0.34860363602638245,
0.24787820875644684,
0.3087438941001892,
-0.20301859080791473,
0.054310016334056854,
0.44416725635528564,
0.03498711809515953,
0.6819038391113281,
0.5841962695121765,
0.15843917429447174,
-0.6764257550239563,
0.7805613279342651,
-0.22209356725215912,
0.38041022419929504,
0.8506902456283569,
0.48455098271369934,
-0.3457469344139099,
-0.6851094961166382,
-0.3539924919605255,
0.2869222164154053,
-0.5734623670578003,
-0.21310770511627197,
-0.2928283214569092,
0.3363087773323059,
-0.27221307158470154,
-0.4787987470626831,
-0.26372355222702026,
-0.24363034963607788,
-0.5895607471466064,
-0.08159393072128296,
-0.10145416110754013,
0.09669647365808487,
-0.12626992166042328,
0.08840972185134888,
-0.6365224123001099,
0.20944270491600037,
0.3910723626613617,
0.3756171464920044,
-0.0023861113004386425,
-0.4113086462020874,
-0.11895151436328888,
0.018482360988855362,
-0.4749550521373749,
-0.6598570346832275,
0.36495012044906616,
0.17236605286598206,
0.4688725173473358,
0.62286376953125,
0.19722211360931396,
0.7915908098220825,
-0.5737153887748718,
0.33999815583229065,
0.04671165347099304,
-1.1685925722122192,
0.5332862734794617,
-0.30192890763282776,
0.02793874777853489,
0.8571103811264038,
0.3311912715435028,
-0.07196337729692459,
0.036824677139520645,
-0.14767158031463623,
-0.797911524772644,
0.8333549499511719,
-0.21391357481479645,
0.08206438273191452,
-0.17346520721912384,
0.8081380724906921,
0.45454293489456177,
0.05987834930419922,
-0.5173705220222473,
-0.051673583686351776,
0.11102045327425003,
-0.27322378754615784,
-0.07343519479036331,
-0.30985406041145325,
-0.2344592958688736,
-0.2610079050064087,
0.8363481760025024,
-0.5891897082328796,
-0.0039056928362697363,
0.1281091868877411,
-0.04819820448756218,
-0.29375508427619934,
0.3089134097099304,
0.3386683762073517,
0.7636243104934692,
-0.3802834749221802,
-0.07699362188577652,
-0.136361762881279,
-0.20500169694423676,
0.33386027812957764,
0.21100641787052155,
-0.3182488977909088,
-0.6202338337898254,
-0.005130516365170479,
0.6193557977676392,
0.29472339153289795,
-0.6945366263389587,
0.39750078320503235,
-0.09665084630250931,
0.13187475502490997,
-0.051769960671663284,
0.0021091108210384846,
-0.310815691947937,
0.1702687293291092,
0.37999626994132996,
-0.060448743402957916,
0.1968962401151657,
-0.610230028629303,
0.26158395409584045,
0.7794350385665894,
-0.5703455209732056,
-0.36429280042648315,
0.4407767951488495,
0.2041170448064804,
-0.3020872473716736,
0.4519805908203125,
-0.003953277133405209,
-0.24700556695461273,
0.4193773865699768,
0.9651969075202942,
0.9342185854911804,
-0.16401168704032898,
0.16517788171768188,
0.13227397203445435,
-0.282171368598938,
-0.029104670509696007,
0.10220849514007568,
-0.32781293988227844,
-1.0090618133544922,
-0.44948872923851013,
-0.611700177192688,
-0.3528250455856323,
-0.14966431260108948,
-0.6554504036903381,
0.3997274339199066,
-0.4520794749259949,
0.10241919755935669,
-0.20234309136867523,
0.15171663463115692,
-0.355525404214859,
0.04917502403259277,
0.1321161985397339,
0.7253662943840027,
-0.2504193186759949,
1.1438716650009155,
0.5709540843963623,
-0.0589599534869194,
-0.7772052884101868,
0.3926488161087036,
0.01451844535768032,
-0.7998149991035461,
0.6393992304801941,
0.15331043303012848,
-0.30451253056526184,
0.13014434278011322,
-0.3539041578769684,
-1.0427180528640747,
1.1332998275756836,
0.6293753981590271,
-0.5284343957901001,
-0.07191875576972961,
-0.04136419668793678,
0.4627988338470459,
-0.597212553024292,
-0.03992210328578949,
0.7102049589157104,
0.20271818339824677,
0.071108877658844,
-0.8069570660591125,
0.171298548579216,
0.21238063275814056,
0.03757317364215851,
0.3457135558128357,
-0.7115685939788818,
0.655007541179657,
-0.1942390501499176,
-0.2859552204608917,
0.22365982830524445,
0.4631669223308563,
0.45949786901474,
0.008073747158050537,
0.525669515132904,
0.517419159412384,
0.4960609972476959,
0.09945670515298843,
1.0446884632110596,
-0.39198070764541626,
0.22109468281269073,
1.1218544244766235,
-0.5782821178436279,
0.9841756224632263,
0.8271235823631287,
0.017162390053272247,
0.21946926414966583,
0.4131169319152832,
0.6371572613716125,
1.0152949094772339,
-0.02434368245303631,
-0.39488908648490906,
-0.10681596398353577,
-0.21313591301441193,
-0.14794909954071045,
0.8037121295928955,
0.14378292858600616,
-0.2674667537212372,
0.017666013911366463,
-0.18667888641357422,
0.022621430456638336,
0.3102554380893707,
-0.24341981112957,
1.0679348707199097,
0.0415654294192791,
-1.0516207218170166,
0.5446162223815918,
-0.22861333191394806,
0.7296037077903748,
-0.5763368010520935,
-0.03660790994763374,
-0.2819473445415497,
0.6130338311195374,
0.0777728483080864,
-0.6260238885879517,
0.06527160108089447,
-0.1918136477470398,
-0.2407556027173996,
-0.40506061911582947,
0.4695073366165161,
-0.49613651633262634,
-0.18755683302879333,
0.5843415856361389,
0.11427335441112518,
-0.3597578704357147,
0.1327185332775116,
-0.5680747032165527,
-0.1852867752313614,
0.055909354239702225,
0.08267999440431595,
0.7643349766731262,
0.32793012261390686,
-0.005744646769016981,
0.476534903049469,
0.5962120890617371,
0.04357701912522316,
-0.3314976096153259,
-0.19682443141937256,
0.7405597567558289,
-0.365955650806427,
-0.5580198764801025,
-1.0248610973358154,
0.2452670931816101,
0.014766490086913109,
-0.4214637875556946,
0.7196738719940186,
0.43304744362831116,
0.9522630572319031,
0.0015295656630769372,
0.6212133765220642,
0.04179378226399422,
0.3551866412162781,
-0.6484260559082031,
0.45943713188171387,
-0.614801824092865,
0.28613510727882385,
-0.624865710735321,
-1.1821485757827759,
-0.3104638159275055,
0.2536514103412628,
-0.3683672547340393,
-0.47495341300964355,
0.3584962487220764,
0.6196661591529846,
-0.04502630606293678,
-0.18041157722473145,
0.12124902009963989,
-0.06216947361826897,
0.5213868021965027,
0.6697311401367188,
0.7286977171897888,
-0.13036376237869263,
0.35186538100242615,
-0.46686670184135437,
-0.5976718664169312,
-0.2731688618659973,
-1.1823723316192627,
-0.44743242859840393,
-0.48831647634506226,
0.020917972549796104,
-0.1648033708333969,
-0.046953875571489334,
1.318969488143921,
0.5475443005561829,
-0.717393696308136,
-0.4498114585876465,
-0.06463724374771118,
0.32296431064605713,
-0.3195091784000397,
-0.22951659560203552,
0.4844803214073181,
-0.325107604265213,
-1.1018599271774292,
0.6701157689094543,
0.47123733162879944,
0.0829404667019844,
0.10559574514627457,
-0.2539558708667755,
-0.23519574105739594,
0.018053695559501648,
0.8330826163291931,
0.3006838858127594,
-0.6712616086006165,
-0.4929179251194,
-0.0678386464715004,
-0.07629025727510452,
0.35953113436698914,
0.9133309721946716,
-0.6122212409973145,
0.5607476234436035,
0.6679710745811462,
0.7026187777519226,
0.20256170630455017,
0.2824876606464386,
0.8575400710105896,
-0.6066272258758545,
0.20826610922813416,
0.1520525962114334,
0.43447452783584595,
0.2734214663505554,
-0.6615734696388245,
0.19599094986915588,
-0.07304605096578598,
-0.6354376673698425,
-0.7082805633544922,
0.34214910864830017,
-0.9987759590148926,
-0.2372252494096756,
1.115297555923462,
-0.01635291613638401,
0.037723738700151443,
0.17161038517951965,
-0.43919965624809265,
0.23672835528850555,
-0.8476072549819946,
1.1082360744476318,
0.3783471882343292,
-0.35976430773735046,
0.2099500149488449,
0.18648579716682434,
0.7954809069633484,
0.3237585127353668,
-0.9052138328552246,
0.04734181612730026,
0.41779443621635437,
0.32474789023399353,
-0.06886215507984161,
0.7230209708213806,
-0.2824108600616455,
-0.0073363566771149635,
-0.6426272988319397,
-0.19382886588573456,
0.0926099643111229,
-0.5133652687072754,
-0.3972932696342468,
0.23311921954154968,
0.2660798132419586,
-0.17485879361629486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09283v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09283v3 | Attacks, Defenses and Evaluations for LLM Conversation Safety: A Survey | 2024-02-14T16:14:03 | 2024-03-27T13:55:14 | Zhichen Dong, Zhanhui Zhou, Chao Yang, Jing Shao, Yu Qiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are now commonplace in conversation
applications. However, their risks of misuse for generating harmful responses
have raised serious societal concerns and spurred recent research on LLM
conversation safety. Therefore, in this survey, we provide a comprehensive
overview of recent studies, covering three critical aspects of LLM conversation
safety: attacks, defenses, and evaluations. Our goal is to provide a structured
summary that enhances understanding of LLM conversation safety and encourages
further investigation into this important subject. For easy reference, we have
categorized all the studies mentioned in this survey according to our taxonomy,
available at: https://github.com/niconi19/LLM-conversation-safety. | [
-0.35050147771835327,
-1.2852574586868286,
0.4445629119873047,
-0.001965857110917568,
0.02106613852083683,
0.12300007045269012,
-0.030952339991927147,
-0.788438081741333,
0.08068376779556274,
0.7907146215438843,
-0.14023950695991516,
-0.3594050705432892,
-0.7363032102584839,
-0.0902269035577774,
-0.6720811128616333,
0.9630597233772278,
0.25241631269454956,
0.26085877418518066,
-0.12146545201539993,
0.1002463549375534,
-0.40489745140075684,
-1.0967906713485718,
-0.893028199672699,
0.12813657522201538,
0.5172261595726013,
0.25396957993507385,
0.321734219789505,
-0.08261562883853912,
0.9724193811416626,
0.42053043842315674,
-0.35456612706184387,
-0.32525646686553955,
-0.7654663920402527,
0.4344871938228607,
0.023062098771333694,
-0.49344903230667114,
-0.7849150896072388,
-0.05258384346961975,
0.6113969087600708,
0.743354320526123,
-0.20079763233661652,
-0.06682928651571274,
0.09566714614629745,
0.5132304430007935,
-0.5884251594543457,
-0.3230246603488922,
-0.937504231929779,
0.10955021530389786,
-0.39749521017074585,
-0.13203111290931702,
-0.7476819157600403,
-0.5394391417503357,
0.26752424240112305,
0.17184582352638245,
-0.39160212874412537,
0.10724662989377975,
0.49758267402648926,
-0.3014790415763855,
-0.8478806018829346,
-0.4824758470058441,
-0.6402190923690796,
0.7812139987945557,
-0.6184173226356506,
0.13068121671676636,
0.40850383043289185,
0.4850425124168396,
-0.3124758303165436,
-0.510382890701294,
-0.10432712733745575,
-0.5141335725784302,
0.02902672067284584,
0.08441541343927383,
-0.6139742732048035,
0.4572329819202423,
0.3259499967098236,
0.39050063490867615,
-0.42132696509361267,
0.4674277603626251,
-0.46185192465782166,
-0.22028881311416626,
0.7959904074668884,
0.6598536372184753,
0.5947282314300537,
-0.12397335469722748,
-0.4098091423511505,
-0.012287376448512077,
-1.1431448459625244,
-0.07736704498529434,
0.42786896228790283,
-0.051483526825904846,
-0.2894245684146881,
0.5540493130683899,
0.0388372577726841,
0.7050393223762512,
-0.27457547187805176,
-0.4066174626350403,
-0.1241796612739563,
-0.5743789076805115,
-0.24438956379890442,
-0.15580995380878448,
1.1067453622817993,
0.8240373730659485,
0.30598184466362,
-0.16119937598705292,
-0.04851476103067398,
-0.13158302009105682,
0.4136974513530731,
-0.8365797996520996,
0.12823458015918732,
0.14093247056007385,
-0.4565076529979706,
-0.7239446640014648,
-0.056946221739053726,
-0.8922364115715027,
-0.5863444805145264,
0.3820970356464386,
-0.07468044012784958,
-0.22461539506912231,
-0.29697367548942566,
0.11365746706724167,
0.13069851696491241,
0.531112015247345,
0.21049626171588898,
-0.682069718837738,
0.5672497749328613,
0.6640539765357971,
0.5738826394081116,
-0.38568681478500366,
0.01712835393846035,
-0.31027865409851074,
0.03904949501156807,
-0.3175949156284332,
0.7356014847755432,
-0.27963119745254517,
-1.0829012393951416,
0.42609313130378723,
-0.06988012045621872,
-0.06723260879516602,
-0.37936753034591675,
0.6243472695350647,
-0.6905264854431152,
0.19243919849395752,
-0.08843448758125305,
-0.48562973737716675,
-0.09392060339450836,
0.7207556366920471,
-0.6535013318061829,
0.5038026571273804,
-0.31437236070632935,
-1.0886775255203247,
-0.30211886763572693,
-0.49241510033607483,
-0.5620529651641846,
-0.11285495012998581,
-0.07519859075546265,
-0.24618647992610931,
0.12963131070137024,
-0.25271353125572205,
0.6423708200454712,
-0.44684144854545593,
0.039564210921525955,
-0.3539189398288727,
-0.005779840052127838,
0.7828086018562317,
-0.6682613492012024,
0.7902196645736694,
0.3635682761669159,
-0.05958576500415802,
0.24432703852653503,
-0.5926764607429504,
-0.033166807144880295,
0.2031129151582718,
-0.34859028458595276,
-0.10804211348295212,
-0.011477630585432053,
-0.09112707525491714,
0.048037536442279816,
0.18903155624866486,
-0.6085769534111023,
-0.02169240452349186,
-0.5573397874832153,
0.46810945868492126,
0.5509361028671265,
0.5313180685043335,
0.3055967688560486,
-0.2833092510700226,
0.7333613038063049,
-0.21782834827899933,
0.393538236618042,
-0.0887584239244461,
-0.38388437032699585,
-0.6171081066131592,
0.11735135316848755,
0.16470611095428467,
0.7358903884887695,
-0.55010586977005,
0.3037453293800354,
-0.06246268004179001,
-0.7029353976249695,
0.20174530148506165,
-0.10770384222269058,
0.6359466314315796,
0.1773442029953003,
-0.2802141010761261,
-0.3159261643886566,
-0.6136450171470642,
-0.9827362895011902,
-0.23196081817150116,
-0.6016712188720703,
0.04772366210818291,
0.4089561700820923,
0.23901815712451935,
-0.27769118547439575,
0.59818035364151,
-0.6411128044128418,
0.14992661774158478,
-0.5476060509681702,
-0.17441800236701965,
-0.22554220259189606,
0.37710416316986084,
0.8754616975784302,
-0.4266503155231476,
-0.45327356457710266,
-0.24189318716526031,
-0.5543063879013062,
-0.09597959369421005,
0.1314268261194229,
-0.09009251743555069,
0.254425972700119,
0.7157443761825562,
-0.7546916007995605,
0.42347198724746704,
0.683257520198822,
-0.1741306334733963,
0.534771740436554,
0.39975452423095703,
0.18857739865779877,
-1.1338789463043213,
-0.20348133146762848,
0.09440121054649353,
-0.1746176928281784,
-1.1000900268554688,
0.20896266400814056,
-0.29947584867477417,
0.032603275030851364,
-0.8316388130187988,
0.2830171287059784,
-0.2819887399673462,
0.1632712334394455,
-0.29364338517189026,
0.1966768503189087,
-0.21122866868972778,
-0.11549487709999084,
-0.15590041875839233,
0.5432454347610474,
0.6608715653419495,
-0.5740495920181274,
0.4390575885772705,
0.15975935757160187,
-0.6368909478187561,
0.4756527245044708,
-0.912807822227478,
0.5290998220443726,
0.2860216200351715,
0.3323161005973816,
-0.9612467885017395,
-0.2904931306838989,
0.446444571018219,
-0.48566964268684387,
0.302598774433136,
-0.12892763316631317,
-0.4038430452346802,
-0.2203817367553711,
-0.5880277752876282,
0.294834703207016,
0.31873562932014465,
-0.07898063212633133,
0.3833859860897064,
0.8953168392181396,
-0.3638055920600891,
-0.5355705618858337,
-0.7844332456588745,
0.550971269607544,
-0.6456712484359741,
-0.6198042035102844,
-0.16696475446224213,
-0.4130820035934448,
-0.8519191145896912,
-0.5897225737571716,
0.1741083860397339,
-0.06655692309141159,
0.657405436038971,
0.3998487591743469,
0.3386273980140686,
0.1351623386144638,
-0.3032858669757843,
-0.6687343120574951,
0.10622476786375046,
0.5124282836914062,
0.5329163670539856,
0.7815927267074585,
-0.1521756947040558,
-0.6648592948913574,
-0.34816884994506836,
0.4714246988296509,
0.49765509366989136,
0.16104505956172943,
0.5634793639183044,
0.2147580236196518,
-0.18252964317798615,
0.24425314366817474,
-0.6752273440361023,
-0.31484416127204895,
-0.49976104497909546,
0.7293243408203125,
-0.18190304934978485,
-1.1631942987442017,
0.33959081768989563,
0.0031666785944253206,
0.30328333377838135,
0.19495874643325806,
0.6171748638153076,
-0.2621258795261383,
0.8990156054496765,
0.5615912675857544,
-0.3024732172489166,
0.5301265120506287,
0.21320316195487976,
0.42779800295829773,
-0.6934862732887268,
-0.23334845900535583,
-0.6689881086349487,
0.1051175445318222,
-0.5917690396308899,
-0.10732235759496689,
0.3528236746788025,
-0.15461045503616333,
-0.05732244253158569,
0.18507738411426544,
-0.09738979488611221,
0.32589155435562134,
0.03696683794260025,
-0.28147536516189575,
0.2758701741695404,
-0.11573027074337006,
0.188273623585701,
-0.031518079340457916,
-0.3749961256980896,
-0.8121066093444824,
1.1469483375549316,
0.9247033596038818,
1.1543710231781006,
0.6040604710578918,
0.5985932350158691,
0.16035039722919464,
0.3723841607570648,
-0.9152695536613464,
0.9687784910202026,
0.3190408945083618,
-0.9111524820327759,
-0.26201245188713074,
-0.5914379358291626,
-1.2477781772613525,
0.30395257472991943,
-0.17754949629306793,
-1.1355153322219849,
-0.4246726334095001,
-0.09266100823879242,
-0.22838430106639862,
0.3100675046443939,
-0.6524896025657654,
0.485478013753891,
-0.6288016438484192,
0.03876713663339615,
-0.23380739986896515,
-0.6504441499710083,
0.8416528105735779,
-0.1608656346797943,
0.185085728764534,
-0.022207677364349365,
0.1823004186153412,
0.8335846662521362,
-0.055945634841918945,
1.136255145072937,
0.04685730114579201,
-0.39354127645492554,
0.46611201763153076,
0.21880871057510376,
0.46323347091674805,
0.05541175976395607,
0.012035656720399857,
0.10626397281885147,
-0.00962287187576294,
-0.04936954379081726,
-0.2797684967517853,
0.7831017971038818,
-0.40984904766082764,
-1.033562183380127,
-0.4797992408275604,
-0.422355592250824,
-0.3959181606769562,
-0.05318332090973854,
-0.029659193009138107,
0.3082553446292877,
-0.78305983543396,
0.5461989045143127,
0.8476252555847168,
-0.44489115476608276,
0.5248960852622986,
0.6896981596946716,
-0.4779868423938751,
-0.5772300958633423,
0.550394594669342,
-0.036809585988521576,
0.6439744234085083,
0.1695232391357422,
-0.06827758252620697,
-0.18080861866474152,
-1.0270487070083618,
-0.052666548639535904,
-0.08887849748134613,
-0.7229185104370117,
-0.24547073245048523,
-0.8081463575363159,
-0.4216977059841156,
-0.4817203879356384,
0.16343730688095093,
-0.2136070430278778,
-0.3118641674518585,
-0.00014403181558009237,
-0.5206605195999146,
0.3544033169746399,
1.0684760808944702,
0.36055850982666016,
0.6396404504776001,
-0.747280478477478,
-0.014113126322627068,
0.336590975522995,
0.11698325723409653,
-0.03867727518081665,
-0.4128287434577942,
-0.10438892990350723,
-0.22768810391426086,
-0.562136709690094,
-1.1194171905517578,
0.09886183589696884,
-0.19599585235118866,
0.7177296876907349,
0.5680609941482544,
0.11741150170564651,
0.2871738076210022,
-0.5426440238952637,
1.1814972162246704,
0.5788455605506897,
-0.5448819398880005,
0.4650440216064453,
-0.3005475103855133,
-0.11344636231660843,
0.5340230464935303,
0.3732311427593231,
-0.5609341263771057,
-0.23707498610019684,
-0.613797664642334,
-0.7880170345306396,
0.3260959982872009,
0.2199910432100296,
0.5868801474571228,
-0.10547570884227753,
-0.027274666354060173,
-0.3031769096851349,
0.019991019740700722,
-0.8153983354568481,
-0.2634325921535492,
0.43243637681007385,
0.0777367502450943,
0.18228919804096222,
-0.7704119086265564,
-0.598312497138977,
0.05009564384818077,
0.4660778343677521,
0.26244449615478516,
0.014035427011549473,
-0.24384646117687225,
-0.16363538801670074,
0.19583351910114288,
0.5544708967208862,
0.6111137866973877,
0.4727247655391693,
-0.0494099035859108,
0.234134703874588,
0.6658497452735901,
-0.6447153091430664,
0.2581411898136139,
-0.19772425293922424,
0.10242301225662231,
-0.3156336843967438,
0.4408017098903656,
0.6692734360694885,
0.45717355608940125,
-0.7473490238189697,
0.6175119876861572,
-0.41619792580604553,
-0.14793133735656738,
-0.3804462254047394,
0.05067688599228859,
0.15671446919441223,
-0.0530129000544548,
-0.012273548170924187,
-0.25877484679222107,
0.12322968244552612,
-0.6003437042236328,
-0.0979415774345398,
0.8451544642448425,
-0.36849361658096313,
-0.2137242704629898,
0.1040838211774826,
0.45648232102394104,
-0.2405543476343155,
0.16855132579803467,
0.21532277762889862,
-0.4415595233440399,
0.4008955955505371,
0.6712093949317932,
0.8969960808753967,
-0.3470551073551178,
-0.19182343780994415,
0.11183172464370728,
0.4492325186729431,
0.27438512444496155,
0.09759123623371124,
0.224470317363739,
-0.6562832593917847,
-0.09536662697792053,
-0.4190385043621063,
-0.8601787090301514,
0.3524589538574219,
-0.4221675992012024,
0.0038380210753530264,
-0.676732063293457,
-0.5253983736038208,
-0.11787740886211395,
0.04352384805679321,
-0.16294939815998077,
-0.13239498436450958,
0.31254225969314575,
0.9910604357719421,
-0.5141435265541077,
0.5973412990570068,
0.6433620452880859,
-0.1422927975654602,
-0.3445609509944916,
-0.1445743590593338,
0.34924444556236267,
-0.5363305807113647,
0.49686673283576965,
-0.022966286167502403,
-0.42613163590431213,
-0.512188732624054,
-0.5948179960250854,
-0.718646228313446,
0.7154340147972107,
0.2973947525024414,
-0.6921852827072144,
0.15982377529144287,
0.4639645516872406,
0.3692326545715332,
-0.26548904180526733,
0.3997088074684143,
0.7044662237167358,
0.3706675171852112,
-0.08897507190704346,
-0.9664435982704163,
-0.20648519694805145,
-0.25279757380485535,
0.10818945616483688,
0.00994645431637764,
-0.8558678030967712,
0.3795633316040039,
0.12047568708658218,
-0.2891765236854553,
0.30228155851364136,
0.44019460678100586,
0.4842687249183655,
0.21118147671222687,
0.5573286414146423,
0.575876772403717,
0.364716500043869,
-0.1144067794084549,
1.2419708967208862,
-0.4087264835834503,
-0.07168658822774887,
1.0750781297683716,
-0.360202819108963,
0.8266305923461914,
0.32620835304260254,
-0.31941860914230347,
0.06510751694440842,
0.5635982155799866,
0.16563411056995392,
0.02556339092552662,
0.6534557342529297,
-0.27913886308670044,
0.05350090190768242,
-0.03849468752741814,
-0.4433352053165436,
0.48851099610328674,
0.5283457636833191,
-0.34199610352516174,
0.0012958740117028356,
-0.05808180198073387,
0.5481002926826477,
-0.15619270503520966,
-0.16752085089683533,
1.0311297178268433,
0.42993834614753723,
-0.4874551594257355,
0.3509562611579895,
0.08169692009687424,
0.8004868030548096,
-0.7183912992477417,
0.21041330695152283,
-0.2136819213628769,
-0.036189768463373184,
-0.18267512321472168,
-0.9677357077598572,
0.27116844058036804,
0.3283342123031616,
0.12797172367572784,
-0.18068915605545044,
0.9850048422813416,
-0.04602693021297455,
-0.19489026069641113,
0.2285229116678238,
0.4603058397769928,
0.2961399257183075,
0.1893240064382553,
-0.5085105299949646,
0.6418326497077942,
-0.11235307902097702,
-0.4851660430431366,
0.6089125275611877,
0.011834396049380302,
-0.040403079241514206,
0.7530736327171326,
0.4105493724346161,
0.03058379329741001,
0.17841465771198273,
0.34399619698524475,
0.8738027215003967,
-0.7724207043647766,
-0.06859254837036133,
-1.0723718404769897,
0.2482837289571762,
-0.3491447865962982,
-0.1429363638162613,
1.1697444915771484,
0.46526068449020386,
0.447400838136673,
0.18841512501239777,
0.8050412535667419,
0.17200767993927002,
0.37087950110435486,
-0.5644798874855042,
1.0362536907196045,
0.11155327409505844,
0.5456628203392029,
-0.5558468103408813,
-0.7131382822990417,
-0.271421879529953,
0.19530047476291656,
-0.4622242748737335,
0.04575350135564804,
0.4734541177749634,
0.8146977424621582,
0.37225937843322754,
0.15012750029563904,
0.4667029082775116,
0.3298565149307251,
0.6770508289337158,
0.5770617127418518,
1.5660656690597534,
-0.2917262315750122,
0.6945041418075562,
-0.05817241221666336,
-0.052791692316532135,
-0.2277533859014511,
-0.8800891637802124,
-1.1404566764831543,
-0.2301000952720642,
-0.3984420597553253,
-0.4533197581768036,
0.1192384660243988,
0.6029966473579407,
0.5802376866340637,
-0.7612966895103455,
-0.44572219252586365,
0.36087191104888916,
0.11795368790626526,
0.5396239757537842,
-0.14080160856246948,
-0.01864040642976761,
-0.23475989699363708,
-0.6805317997932434,
0.649378776550293,
0.1601281762123108,
0.3449440598487854,
-0.43334832787513733,
-0.00007492341683246195,
-0.045399535447359085,
0.23658005893230438,
0.9250345230102539,
0.37510085105895996,
-0.6929903626441956,
-0.31777504086494446,
-0.23535597324371338,
-0.39057326316833496,
-0.12203399091959,
0.702183187007904,
-0.14925098419189453,
0.09366261214017868,
0.5802202224731445,
0.786375105381012,
0.11108788102865219,
-0.18679821491241455,
0.5882722735404968,
-0.5399365425109863,
0.011267018504440784,
0.1731763631105423,
0.5882112979888916,
0.4311720132827759,
-0.3771316409111023,
0.5389668941497803,
-0.060165856033563614,
-0.6343404054641724,
-1.225750207901001,
0.5246647596359253,
-1.166151762008667,
-0.05882658436894417,
1.4575999975204468,
-0.12782947719097137,
-0.12635277211666107,
-0.10679107904434204,
-0.4306660294532776,
-0.22169823944568634,
-0.13502617180347443,
0.6635383367538452,
0.7854652404785156,
-0.009410270489752293,
-0.052159279584884644,
-0.8857094645500183,
0.4103815257549286,
0.18780013918876648,
-1.1500893831253052,
0.08923062682151794,
0.6059738993644714,
0.4033050537109375,
0.030124375596642494,
0.5807678699493408,
-0.5628100037574768,
0.043786730617284775,
-0.3281964361667633,
-0.1898423582315445,
0.3252665102481842,
-0.313114732503891,
-0.3617148995399475,
0.3982338309288025,
0.5330280065536499,
-0.0644959807395935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09282v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09282v4 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Enhanced NLP Task Performance through Knowledge Distillation and Optimized Training Strategies | 2024-02-14T16:10:45 | 2024-03-24T07:06:19 | Yining Huang, Keke Tang, Meilian Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emerging Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 have revolutionized Natural
Language Processing (NLP), showing potential in traditional tasks such as Named
Entity Recognition (NER). Our study explores a three-phase training strategy
that harnesses GPT-4's capabilities to enhance the BERT model's performance on
NER. Initially, GPT-4 annotates a subset of the CONLL2003 and additional BBC
dataset without fine-tuning. We then train BERT using a mix of original and
LLM-annotated data, analyzing the efficacy of LLM annotations against
traditional methods. The second phase involves comparative experiments with
different training regimens, assessing the synergy between distilled and
original data. We observe that sequential strategies, particularly a simple mix
of training first with distilled data followed by original data, significantly
boost performance. In the third phase, we investigate various data blending
techniques, including sigmoid and power decay functions, to optimize the
training process further. Our results indicate that a strategic mix of
distilled and original data markedly elevates the NER capabilities of BERT. Our
approach presents a scalable methodology that reduces manual annotation costs
and increases efficiency, making it especially pertinent in resource-limited
and closed-network environments. The study concludes that while the 'Simple
Mix' strategy yields the best results, understanding its underlying mechanisms
requires further research. Future work will also focus on refining prompt
designs and enhancing annotation selection processes, aiming to extend our
methodology to diverse NLP tasks. | [
-0.6072242856025696,
-0.5765908360481262,
0.5721222162246704,
0.1840820014476776,
-0.5051586031913757,
0.10114395618438721,
-0.48667672276496887,
-0.614023745059967,
0.01663767173886299,
0.3788878917694092,
-0.34165632724761963,
-0.2334093600511551,
-0.7869121432304382,
0.4299135208129883,
-0.31657254695892334,
1.2314940690994263,
0.07482733577489853,
0.07371643930673599,
0.2195676565170288,
0.06305426359176636,
-0.4650903642177582,
-0.7206616997718811,
-1.024094581604004,
-0.7202416658401489,
0.6527718305587769,
0.10852998495101929,
0.39192864298820496,
0.32655391097068787,
0.46984168887138367,
0.2654695212841034,
-0.20279420912265778,
0.19334104657173157,
-0.47739377617836,
0.3072967827320099,
-0.008759373798966408,
-0.35606834292411804,
-0.29657331109046936,
-0.041077978909015656,
0.6187775731086731,
0.6245003938674927,
-0.14790603518486023,
-0.06512289494276047,
0.4340888559818268,
0.6051449775695801,
-0.353760689496994,
0.3948361575603485,
-1.1070786714553833,
0.05771184712648392,
-0.4035566747188568,
-0.1450667679309845,
-0.2981272339820862,
-0.12452563643455505,
0.4668036997318268,
-0.5291695594787598,
0.33073875308036804,
-0.023041894659399986,
0.8532832264900208,
0.36828622221946716,
-0.09814770519733429,
-0.30452439188957214,
-0.828307569026947,
0.6295123100280762,
-0.9449081420898438,
0.29827916622161865,
0.2731463611125946,
0.1811058670282364,
-0.20512738823890686,
-0.811416745185852,
-0.784967839717865,
-0.10584504157304764,
-0.020744211971759796,
-0.16496537625789642,
-0.06870479881763458,
0.1842186003923416,
0.6151393055915833,
0.23123003542423248,
-0.23601152002811432,
0.1996641904115677,
-0.2549072802066803,
-0.07440932840108871,
0.4115452468395233,
-0.3020496964454651,
0.07059530913829803,
-0.08328526467084885,
-0.41940218210220337,
-0.040954794734716415,
-0.611415684223175,
-0.17578479647636414,
0.3019874691963196,
0.5374566316604614,
0.36372867226600647,
0.47286495566368103,
-0.1214287281036377,
0.7220670580863953,
0.277090847492218,
-0.3146747946739197,
0.4192849099636078,
-0.2785496711730957,
-0.21109886467456818,
0.23623162508010864,
0.6111644506454468,
0.04929152876138687,
0.15093927085399628,
-0.28520700335502625,
-0.5357767939567566,
-0.4102869927883148,
0.16438733041286469,
-0.8228374123573303,
-0.5490099787712097,
-0.06264813244342804,
-0.15572746098041534,
-0.1312587857246399,
-0.37767794728279114,
-0.6775537729263306,
-0.42650625109672546,
-0.6819701790809631,
0.5771334767341614,
-0.7288178205490112,
-0.26949289441108704,
-0.005541237536817789,
-0.27030906081199646,
0.14044427871704102,
0.4651157557964325,
-1.3050705194473267,
0.41696038842201233,
0.7349697351455688,
0.832037627696991,
-0.11559080332517624,
-0.11016757041215897,
-0.41160649061203003,
0.15335778892040253,
-0.07617723196744919,
0.48392000794410706,
-0.39328256249427795,
-0.04295389726758003,
-0.15975435078144073,
-0.303747296333313,
-0.05893920734524727,
-0.6281005144119263,
0.4984138011932373,
-0.741316020488739,
0.0035843891091644764,
-0.4148944020271301,
-0.660286009311676,
-0.3300046920776367,
0.25133541226387024,
-0.9714279174804688,
1.2240269184112549,
-0.04403231665492058,
-0.9905207753181458,
0.7348037958145142,
-0.6651027798652649,
-0.49093061685562134,
0.3170872926712036,
-0.1354002207517624,
-0.24274180829524994,
0.12123765051364899,
0.5036579370498657,
0.7497598528862,
-0.14549970626831055,
0.2548021376132965,
-0.1315261870622635,
-0.20615318417549133,
-0.08300308138132095,
-0.3703809976577759,
0.4859582483768463,
0.014065711759030819,
-0.6094077825546265,
-0.3213217556476593,
-0.7122548818588257,
-0.051670197397470474,
0.12171018123626709,
-0.5132816433906555,
-0.5981135964393616,
0.06402846425771713,
-0.11404852569103241,
0.1462569534778595,
0.2320612370967865,
-0.4626423120498657,
0.24310824275016785,
-0.40184393525123596,
0.5579294562339783,
0.5624219179153442,
0.10710429400205612,
0.3593915104866028,
-0.10357040166854858,
0.19732095301151276,
-0.12026660144329071,
-0.12607888877391815,
0.05670861527323723,
-0.5846431255340576,
-0.8273014426231384,
-0.3643352687358856,
0.5165440440177917,
0.38495925068855286,
-1.1212595701217651,
0.28163692355155945,
-0.3249310255050659,
-0.40440014004707336,
-0.46099212765693665,
0.27325189113616943,
0.11696892231702805,
0.5743796825408936,
0.5730375647544861,
-0.1484653353691101,
-0.5309058427810669,
-0.884816586971283,
0.011983118019998074,
-0.0596507303416729,
-0.08112824708223343,
0.03799227997660637,
0.4871519207954407,
-0.03008395805954933,
0.8819094300270081,
-0.25202512741088867,
-0.36404556035995483,
-0.5227670669555664,
0.4718208312988281,
0.41733071208000183,
0.2928512990474701,
0.44802775979042053,
-0.8837850093841553,
-0.3923295736312866,
-0.07224351167678833,
-0.46895018219947815,
-0.07591754198074341,
-0.2235540896654129,
0.11023437976837158,
0.16704732179641724,
0.3159272074699402,
-0.39942285418510437,
0.056090328842401505,
0.5675397515296936,
0.32562458515167236,
0.25083327293395996,
-0.19249674677848816,
0.027251381427049637,
-0.863689124584198,
-0.02056773565709591,
0.0950896143913269,
-0.17330309748649597,
-0.7843141555786133,
-0.24366673827171326,
-0.06786055862903595,
0.012909076176583767,
-0.2935304343700409,
0.28531450033187866,
-0.7815808057785034,
0.07281791418790817,
-0.36896809935569763,
0.2018653154373169,
-0.04798797518014908,
0.5148891806602478,
0.20113930106163025,
0.621540904045105,
0.3460531234741211,
-0.5631872415542603,
0.2816212475299835,
0.12185078859329224,
-0.35040518641471863,
0.3531440496444702,
-0.7048045992851257,
0.3463316261768341,
-0.18019376695156097,
0.21589328348636627,
-0.861671507358551,
-0.10375236719846725,
0.06363958865404129,
-0.11107060313224792,
0.7197242379188538,
-0.32406267523765564,
-0.791664183139801,
-0.32627636194229126,
-0.12435541301965714,
0.18321336805820465,
0.421705961227417,
-0.5576483607292175,
0.7905333638191223,
0.33510348200798035,
-0.36723873019218445,
-0.5695383548736572,
-0.6990242600440979,
0.2896880805492401,
-0.4448949694633484,
-0.3614187240600586,
0.6337776780128479,
0.24116137623786926,
0.060571908950805664,
-0.10519817471504211,
-0.2244226038455963,
-0.18070973455905914,
0.10946958512067795,
0.09014645963907242,
0.2316274493932724,
0.12291821837425232,
0.17054396867752075,
0.06007636711001396,
0.012373621575534344,
-0.02884172648191452,
-0.36602985858917236,
0.6198627352714539,
0.07276301085948944,
-0.16122104227542877,
-0.38507479429244995,
0.16756998002529144,
0.13902249932289124,
-0.19233568012714386,
0.6957627534866333,
0.7831031680107117,
-0.45702293515205383,
-0.3107091188430786,
-0.7932148575782776,
-0.3406837284564972,
-0.4456062614917755,
0.3738892376422882,
-0.3131669759750366,
-0.9728342294692993,
0.29390162229537964,
-0.22365669906139374,
0.33233001828193665,
0.2500080168247223,
0.5359760522842407,
-0.07004193216562271,
0.6284621953964233,
0.5519699454307556,
-0.28365060687065125,
0.6176578998565674,
-0.18863622844219208,
0.4459925591945648,
-0.9822751879692078,
-0.237581267952919,
-0.2916395962238312,
-0.5520696043968201,
-0.43160179257392883,
-0.5486157536506653,
0.374058336019516,
0.25000956654548645,
0.015009082853794098,
0.3974243700504303,
-0.4967881441116333,
0.39283668994903564,
0.6032667756080627,
0.16807611286640167,
0.28890952467918396,
0.042181357741355896,
-0.17486806213855743,
-0.13997328281402588,
-0.680334746837616,
-0.4393112361431122,
1.2606878280639648,
0.4040863513946533,
0.586810290813446,
-0.09065591543912888,
1.1185628175735474,
0.04480880871415138,
0.2617064416408539,
-0.6008994579315186,
0.6173257827758789,
0.029498910531401634,
-0.6652935147285461,
-0.4082867503166199,
-0.4443190395832062,
-0.8394245505332947,
0.3475773334503174,
-0.39001309871673584,
-0.6234987378120422,
-0.04526138678193092,
0.2554778754711151,
-0.3314957618713379,
0.2831836938858032,
-0.7747661471366882,
0.468397855758667,
-0.40501612424850464,
-0.14279165863990784,
0.016879314556717873,
-0.6218850016593933,
0.21898508071899414,
-0.4943158030509949,
0.013091569766402245,
-0.1656535267829895,
-0.023344919085502625,
0.7764143943786621,
-0.12985412776470184,
0.7283115386962891,
-0.441395103931427,
-0.15026572346687317,
0.0606919564306736,
-0.2890559732913971,
0.753839373588562,
0.09301726520061493,
-0.08800171315670013,
0.41118553280830383,
-0.30429184436798096,
-0.09066970646381378,
-0.5590003132820129,
0.6105627417564392,
-0.6003546118736267,
-0.5361525416374207,
-0.37956541776657104,
-0.46170321106910706,
-0.3357526361942291,
0.33694520592689514,
0.24580122530460358,
0.307595431804657,
0.01290389895439148,
0.21458393335342407,
0.8188880085945129,
0.023256363347172737,
0.6981425285339355,
0.2427576184272766,
0.008387558162212372,
-0.39724788069725037,
0.5519720315933228,
0.2497938573360443,
0.3405945301055908,
0.5116733908653259,
-0.07250049710273743,
-0.390205979347229,
-1.0978680849075317,
-0.14203357696533203,
0.14614859223365784,
-0.6123653054237366,
-0.18825185298919678,
-0.7732529640197754,
-0.2137085646390915,
-0.23321299254894257,
0.2221555858850479,
-0.24876192212104797,
-0.3212581276893616,
-0.24139483273029327,
0.012533754110336304,
0.3768570125102997,
0.6173558235168457,
-0.11064744740724564,
0.31425154209136963,
-0.5512896776199341,
0.33683180809020996,
0.39181652665138245,
0.17120672762393951,
-0.00167452497407794,
-0.3997845947742462,
-0.198106050491333,
0.05657248571515083,
-0.19081315398216248,
-0.8739002346992493,
0.3723345398902893,
0.4385756850242615,
0.6862493753433228,
0.025847189128398895,
-0.11414885520935059,
0.6750285029411316,
-0.8702818751335144,
0.6387647390365601,
0.1500403732061386,
-0.8771073818206787,
0.6043949723243713,
-0.3341290056705475,
0.07041441649198532,
0.751143217086792,
0.5770930051803589,
-0.25129279494285583,
-0.25502103567123413,
-0.4315817058086395,
-1.2418222427368164,
0.6361412405967712,
0.45295989513397217,
-0.00296962121501565,
0.028593959286808968,
0.41013187170028687,
0.10390453785657883,
0.4089782238006592,
-0.856067419052124,
-0.214115709066391,
0.08220794051885605,
-0.03816618397831917,
0.015508272685110569,
-0.17087271809577942,
-0.14779908955097198,
-0.2759259343147278,
0.8234587907791138,
-0.11339327692985535,
0.2174205183982849,
0.14736048877239227,
-0.07558976113796234,
0.42883339524269104,
0.16915789246559143,
0.10418245941400528,
0.555079996585846,
-0.2544572055339813,
0.043032124638557434,
0.3207322955131531,
-0.5910453200340271,
0.02985026128590107,
0.5965815782546997,
-0.11944036185741425,
0.23952695727348328,
0.3621531128883362,
0.9090985059738159,
0.31741389632225037,
-0.2510448396205902,
0.3190973997116089,
-0.09237299859523773,
-0.32059624791145325,
-0.16892141103744507,
0.1300850212574005,
0.13231472671031952,
0.5557467937469482,
0.6058623194694519,
-0.08956466615200043,
0.2881617546081543,
-0.24169203639030457,
0.1347883641719818,
0.33195438981056213,
0.1083453819155693,
-0.2188754826784134,
0.5367399454116821,
0.17207787930965424,
0.054346587508916855,
0.6125854849815369,
-0.3028711676597595,
-0.49064216017723083,
0.21368783712387085,
0.4325219988822937,
0.7679181694984436,
-0.11704219877719879,
0.06218908727169037,
0.27906590700149536,
0.36919763684272766,
-0.35900935530662537,
0.13558119535446167,
-0.12942978739738464,
-0.7301820516586304,
-0.6928955316543579,
-0.7705944180488586,
-0.325369656085968,
0.4205589294433594,
-0.6721577048301697,
0.3447191119194031,
-0.3951910436153412,
-0.437755286693573,
0.3284105658531189,
0.08544854074716568,
-1.015779972076416,
0.07130766659975052,
0.4848155081272125,
0.6549564003944397,
-0.6974786520004272,
0.9322887659072876,
0.5885202288627625,
-0.2745402455329895,
-1.0094468593597412,
0.1189911961555481,
-0.029749372974038124,
-0.6882696151733398,
0.9066498875617981,
0.235368013381958,
0.20115135610103607,
0.17799615859985352,
-0.23632767796516418,
-0.9773574471473694,
1.1424325704574585,
0.3775421977043152,
-0.9566892981529236,
-0.28757861256599426,
0.02727164328098297,
0.4922527074813843,
-0.26892122626304626,
0.12604458630084991,
0.769128680229187,
0.3949868083000183,
0.21189400553703308,
-1.1078473329544067,
-0.005787913221865892,
-0.048994727432727814,
0.3625539243221283,
0.4431864023208618,
-0.16156238317489624,
0.6587116718292236,
-0.11783624440431595,
-0.23295219242572784,
-0.2817095220088959,
0.6019756197929382,
0.2721554934978485,
0.05282330885529518,
0.707302451133728,
0.6727576851844788,
0.9497677087783813,
-0.268273264169693,
0.6830850839614868,
-0.18749526143074036,
0.3185988664627075,
1.3924288749694824,
-0.5564442873001099,
0.865605354309082,
0.6227391362190247,
-0.1882004290819168,
0.32982298731803894,
0.5648485422134399,
-0.10640232264995575,
0.8018038272857666,
0.3184881806373596,
-0.3439216613769531,
0.08042415976524353,
0.08448968827724457,
-0.270386278629303,
0.39088374376296997,
0.28904828429222107,
-0.4019157886505127,
-0.37437283992767334,
0.20971648395061493,
0.20525263249874115,
-0.316177099943161,
-0.12579086422920227,
1.0204496383666992,
0.007968291640281677,
-0.5372744202613831,
0.6137171387672424,
-0.246201753616333,
0.8376846313476562,
-0.7048336267471313,
-0.10822076350450516,
0.038580916821956635,
0.023079199716448784,
-0.03363975137472153,
-0.6690448522567749,
0.0711110457777977,
0.05536418408155441,
-0.1517624706029892,
-0.4128035008907318,
0.6392555236816406,
-0.5749143958091736,
-0.29418423771858215,
0.2942812144756317,
0.28950512409210205,
0.15811069309711456,
-0.22550764679908752,
-0.7119314074516296,
0.056372519582509995,
0.0534416101872921,
-0.2571222186088562,
0.38989531993865967,
0.7854036688804626,
0.24933505058288574,
0.38666942715644836,
0.6469391584396362,
0.44182872772216797,
0.057659000158309937,
0.22361572086811066,
1.1529947519302368,
-0.42144885659217834,
-0.1936294287443161,
-1.024034857749939,
0.3747512698173523,
-0.3249684274196625,
-0.137662872672081,
0.6541035175323486,
0.36378124356269836,
0.9398948550224304,
0.16044430434703827,
0.8749827742576599,
-0.12830527126789093,
0.4596344530582428,
-0.6429222822189331,
0.3985912501811981,
-0.20905262231826782,
0.36201849579811096,
-0.3996374011039734,
-1.1847889423370361,
-0.09208162128925323,
0.48712849617004395,
-0.36266347765922546,
0.1674736589193344,
0.6358444690704346,
0.409441739320755,
0.22062362730503082,
0.12320611625909805,
0.09464993327856064,
0.11972085386514664,
0.560034990310669,
0.6021976470947266,
0.5834120512008667,
-0.19196972250938416,
0.28945446014404297,
-0.4205261170864105,
-0.3045704662799835,
-0.05545734614133835,
-1.1550098657608032,
-0.9944847822189331,
-0.6259347200393677,
-0.22931469976902008,
-0.010944421403110027,
0.10648051649332047,
0.85914146900177,
0.7549652457237244,
-0.5748100876808167,
0.22705329954624176,
-0.10916367918252945,
-0.3475683331489563,
-0.14115428924560547,
-0.14591287076473236,
0.22635270655155182,
-0.6386933922767639,
-0.7859288454055786,
0.41825082898139954,
0.2304515838623047,
0.14895018935203552,
-0.1557130664587021,
0.303509920835495,
-0.32609400153160095,
-0.22257199883460999,
0.721703290939331,
-0.06928867101669312,
-0.7116115689277649,
-0.12686197459697723,
-0.28828075528144836,
0.12218238413333893,
-0.07237742096185684,
0.6844578981399536,
-0.7296109795570374,
0.5427303314208984,
0.33151307702064514,
0.9393754601478577,
0.6621012091636658,
-0.04466969519853592,
0.6113942265510559,
-0.9284660220146179,
0.09121400117874146,
0.5488974452018738,
0.42737895250320435,
0.573622465133667,
-0.4270784556865692,
0.5827866792678833,
0.0485197976231575,
-0.7080948352813721,
-0.6823031306266785,
-0.13052789866924286,
-0.9167355895042419,
-0.06059857830405235,
1.2800527811050415,
-0.14851492643356323,
0.1974787414073944,
-0.18059448897838593,
-0.19712838530540466,
0.2047770917415619,
-0.5434032082557678,
0.599963903427124,
0.8881614804267883,
-0.2637176215648651,
-0.04159891605377197,
-0.9627147912979126,
0.749298632144928,
0.18173182010650635,
-0.7048160433769226,
-0.03344431892037392,
0.4456455707550049,
0.36220577359199524,
0.17326296865940094,
0.6021581888198853,
0.05359424650669098,
-0.28293952345848083,
-0.2413296401500702,
0.0704084113240242,
-0.1171712800860405,
-0.32625216245651245,
-0.3067001700401306,
0.08620823919773102,
0.13781629502773285,
-0.14168255031108856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09269v1 | Personalized Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T15:55:30 | 2024-02-14T15:55:30 | Stanisław Woźniak, Bartłomiej Koptyra, Arkadiusz Janz, Przemysław Kazienko, Jan Kocoń | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks in recent years. However, their universal nature poses
limitations in scenarios requiring personalized responses, such as
recommendation systems and chatbots. This paper investigates methods to
personalize LLMs, comparing fine-tuning and zero-shot reasoning approaches on
subjective tasks. Results demonstrate that personalized fine-tuning improves
model reasoning compared to non-personalized models. Experiments on datasets
for emotion recognition and hate speech detection show consistent performance
gains with personalized methods across different LLM architectures. These
findings underscore the importance of personalization for enhancing LLM
capabilities in subjective text perception tasks. | [
-0.37642839550971985,
-0.8908620476722717,
0.8041443824768066,
-0.011082852259278297,
-0.06413626670837402,
0.007846550084650517,
-0.5976061224937439,
-0.48596617579460144,
-0.047479335218667984,
0.7812721133232117,
-0.3630240559577942,
-0.8152133822441101,
-0.41151732206344604,
0.1664014458656311,
-0.2665095031261444,
1.0063745975494385,
0.21212933957576752,
-0.0504147931933403,
-0.15222357213497162,
-0.14176926016807556,
-0.5610055923461914,
-0.6965984106063843,
-0.8380612730979919,
-0.5467872619628906,
0.8354226350784302,
0.5694128274917603,
0.6384260654449463,
0.4846689701080322,
0.5215827822685242,
0.3984912037849426,
-0.2806416451931,
0.08602242916822433,
-0.34603750705718994,
0.49298447370529175,
-0.49027252197265625,
-0.5237839221954346,
-0.360004723072052,
-0.2689869999885559,
0.3301331400871277,
0.6617925763130188,
-0.015760941430926323,
0.20205695927143097,
-0.18688923120498657,
0.6823680996894836,
-0.5185304284095764,
-0.017651397734880447,
-0.695149302482605,
0.074788898229599,
-0.20747196674346924,
-0.32372525334358215,
-0.508863091468811,
-0.17653843760490417,
0.295850932598114,
-0.4145217537879944,
0.15919192135334015,
0.19861851632595062,
0.4846334457397461,
0.3338492512702942,
-0.42394572496414185,
-0.38833087682724,
-1.169826865196228,
1.1122593879699707,
-1.1062943935394287,
0.22084611654281616,
0.255026638507843,
0.33620351552963257,
-0.13107509911060333,
-0.2279132455587387,
-0.38254305720329285,
-0.5343889594078064,
0.12524566054344177,
-0.18815487623214722,
-0.2816835045814514,
0.2466963678598404,
0.21311776340007782,
0.3964150547981262,
-0.4281669855117798,
0.5422755479812622,
0.028406059369444847,
-0.046454641968011856,
0.7856061458587646,
0.347655713558197,
0.2966499626636505,
-0.048276521265506744,
0.13782605528831482,
0.21193990111351013,
-0.4299405515193939,
0.03311190754175186,
0.5436473488807678,
0.45779508352279663,
-0.011486006900668144,
0.6999744176864624,
-0.801435112953186,
1.0458468198776245,
0.2356986403465271,
-0.3514155149459839,
0.12375462055206299,
-0.07326263189315796,
-0.525565505027771,
0.010046355426311493,
0.6756356954574585,
0.33307456970214844,
0.6262717843055725,
-0.3784210979938507,
-0.10011052340269089,
-0.22435739636421204,
0.11868637055158615,
-0.6213502883911133,
0.03759867325425148,
0.42543238401412964,
-0.460854172706604,
-0.4285016655921936,
-0.46850350499153137,
-0.38813307881355286,
-0.5642639398574829,
-0.7630086541175842,
0.2421148121356964,
-0.37373992800712585,
0.17923304438591003,
0.5164999961853027,
0.005423974711447954,
0.004819909110665321,
0.5689824819564819,
-1.0974650382995605,
0.19259925186634064,
0.6734009981155396,
0.6924648880958557,
-0.2124238908290863,
0.031122557818889618,
-0.4463760256767273,
0.14097173511981964,
-0.18701864778995514,
1.054492712020874,
-0.7841355204582214,
-0.1529611498117447,
0.08440996706485748,
-0.3015233874320984,
0.41691532731056213,
-0.7240634560585022,
0.7199653387069702,
-0.4409733712673187,
0.24169692397117615,
-0.3420620858669281,
-0.6394124627113342,
-0.2940291166305542,
0.4115607738494873,
-0.11233911663293839,
0.6383105516433716,
-0.0614955797791481,
-0.5703343749046326,
0.2620166838169098,
-0.6820088624954224,
-0.4535779654979706,
0.17552588880062103,
0.09977623075246811,
-0.22519393265247345,
0.4282515048980713,
0.17291587591171265,
0.943679690361023,
-0.31688663363456726,
0.43262043595314026,
-0.6933884024620056,
-0.32862725853919983,
0.2666127383708954,
-0.21313829720020294,
0.14078325033187866,
0.3908087909221649,
-0.19181613624095917,
0.476185142993927,
-0.9072897434234619,
0.006030709482729435,
0.12120334804058075,
-0.5562470555305481,
-0.49698910117149353,
0.33423635363578796,
0.10172530263662338,
0.07774294167757034,
0.47914668917655945,
-0.6299870610237122,
0.14070238173007965,
-0.8755428791046143,
0.4198001027107239,
0.8809292912483215,
-0.17041243612766266,
0.49825191497802734,
-0.3671591281890869,
0.1932363510131836,
0.17086675763130188,
-0.19026605784893036,
-0.2902810275554657,
-0.3036136329174042,
-1.0116013288497925,
-0.03767584264278412,
0.07780515402555466,
0.5826005935668945,
-0.2773042917251587,
0.5663159489631653,
0.05029183253645897,
-0.3190566301345825,
-0.09437201917171478,
0.34374451637268066,
0.3322267234325409,
0.348092645406723,
0.24039766192436218,
-0.09215396642684937,
-0.5010210871696472,
-1.114364504814148,
-0.6744620203971863,
0.07329203188419342,
-0.368053138256073,
0.7182592153549194,
0.1970028579235077,
-0.299153208732605,
0.882213830947876,
-0.7598623037338257,
-0.2614055573940277,
-0.26466622948646545,
-0.02082579955458641,
0.30132943391799927,
0.1267787367105484,
0.5105450749397278,
-0.5486608147621155,
-0.6709079742431641,
0.31846562027931213,
-0.6729847192764282,
-0.27459171414375305,
-0.17821073532104492,
0.13625843822956085,
0.0906062051653862,
0.29189997911453247,
-0.2478235363960266,
0.12102963030338287,
0.3897601366043091,
-0.5172300934791565,
0.34972989559173584,
-0.27235114574432373,
0.06266969442367554,
-0.9904946088790894,
-0.19116279482841492,
0.4621703028678894,
-0.6332617998123169,
-0.8930196166038513,
0.04403703659772873,
-0.4821249544620514,
0.0920843631029129,
-0.4920869767665863,
0.8934324383735657,
-0.18726599216461182,
-0.08003979176282883,
-0.5286771655082703,
0.22819174826145172,
-0.32876697182655334,
0.39559513330459595,
0.05870744213461876,
0.4094971716403961,
0.4622569978237152,
-0.6914052963256836,
0.4805244505405426,
0.24010048806667328,
-0.3442908525466919,
0.7456389665603638,
-0.8514658808708191,
0.39715269207954407,
-0.2343660295009613,
-0.10209658741950989,
-0.7875379920005798,
-0.38961634039878845,
-0.06214064359664917,
-0.20254935324192047,
0.1352132111787796,
0.19141487777233124,
-0.36633044481277466,
-0.0492367297410965,
-0.32352888584136963,
-0.010353527031838894,
0.35008537769317627,
-0.5057583451271057,
0.4732379913330078,
0.18342703580856323,
-0.20696595311164856,
-0.1392175704240799,
-0.5116490721702576,
0.3326728045940399,
-0.3273125886917114,
-0.5094460844993591,
0.2665310204029083,
-0.3938068449497223,
-0.5603963136672974,
-0.4778316617012024,
0.15743909776210785,
-0.0421595498919487,
0.239910289645195,
0.5125561952590942,
-0.03564014285802841,
-0.20272907614707947,
0.29413896799087524,
-0.044125817716121674,
-0.042940523475408554,
-0.3025495111942291,
0.0013319061836227775,
0.6573883891105652,
-0.21556907892227173,
-0.0438120998442173,
-0.6035071611404419,
0.24745076894760132,
0.34704557061195374,
-0.1289428025484085,
0.7189614176750183,
0.6234084367752075,
-0.23930591344833374,
-0.1935594379901886,
-0.9523393511772156,
0.030577756464481354,
-0.5392314791679382,
0.26355135440826416,
-0.4357966184616089,
-1.5220433473587036,
0.2711918354034424,
-0.08910039812326431,
0.05122492089867592,
0.17189078032970428,
1.170588731765747,
-0.2562120258808136,
1.2313979864120483,
0.6692067384719849,
-0.3341730535030365,
0.6192870736122131,
0.23224805295467377,
0.3977539539337158,
-0.8691921830177307,
-0.1542859971523285,
-0.6097404956817627,
-0.5279048681259155,
-0.48052531480789185,
-0.06746676564216614,
0.03253129497170448,
-0.05118237063288689,
-0.678602397441864,
0.04171004518866539,
-0.7343934178352356,
0.6541597843170166,
0.5839204788208008,
0.1193157285451889,
0.5474005937576294,
0.021886276081204414,
0.1821194589138031,
-0.0839230865240097,
-0.23301497101783752,
-0.8187986016273499,
1.0320322513580322,
0.5189129114151001,
0.7944222688674927,
0.12748728692531586,
0.621416449546814,
0.35240626335144043,
0.1734338402748108,
-1.0644958019256592,
0.5465547442436218,
-0.6040626168251038,
-0.7083826065063477,
-0.3461895287036896,
-0.35512682795524597,
-0.712983250617981,
0.15543833374977112,
-0.3336973190307617,
-1.0698634386062622,
-0.10760501772165298,
0.295660138130188,
-0.5301480889320374,
0.25722455978393555,
-0.7795376777648926,
0.42318350076675415,
-0.14406096935272217,
0.009356610476970673,
-0.3754156231880188,
-0.23724760115146637,
0.4211122393608093,
-0.15130747854709625,
0.16384902596473694,
-0.42375609278678894,
-0.15506470203399658,
0.4723929166793823,
-0.04653071612119675,
0.9567318558692932,
-0.0011815850157290697,
-0.01775546185672283,
-0.12557964026927948,
0.21141038835048676,
0.46217766404151917,
0.041416626423597336,
-0.36971771717071533,
0.05690883472561836,
-0.11987611651420593,
-0.19245633482933044,
-0.46864771842956543,
1.0858412981033325,
-0.7310137152671814,
-0.872575044631958,
-0.18075764179229736,
-0.6624753475189209,
-0.4387770891189575,
0.29548847675323486,
0.02390328422188759,
0.12974025309085846,
-0.29608651995658875,
0.4402918517589569,
0.6889423727989197,
-0.7682746052742004,
0.4671265780925751,
0.763031542301178,
-0.14581800997257233,
-0.14055098593235016,
0.6972169876098633,
-0.08879010379314423,
0.07597965747117996,
0.6047331094741821,
0.46176162362098694,
-0.03619344159960747,
-0.8333073854446411,
-0.02833665907382965,
0.1792808175086975,
-0.6229274272918701,
-0.22342562675476074,
-0.848721444606781,
0.08321482688188553,
-0.4346469044685364,
-0.3712405264377594,
-0.25355616211891174,
-0.23899932205677032,
-0.5535935759544373,
0.004051495343446732,
0.446705162525177,
0.6829633116722107,
0.2737465798854828,
0.5122049450874329,
-0.6312254071235657,
0.5904772877693176,
0.3492495119571686,
0.4494169056415558,
-0.1015031486749649,
-0.6829918026924133,
-0.10991831868886948,
-0.0330880768597126,
-0.3477291166782379,
-0.5566266179084778,
0.4571891129016876,
0.24429035186767578,
0.18161532282829285,
0.522233247756958,
-0.16171400249004364,
0.45836856961250305,
-0.7157249450683594,
0.7335172891616821,
0.20743942260742188,
-1.050585389137268,
0.6001547574996948,
-0.5862188935279846,
0.5499789118766785,
0.31755807995796204,
0.31417223811149597,
-0.6433675289154053,
-0.32230186462402344,
-0.2332921028137207,
-0.4834100008010864,
0.5635843873023987,
-0.001267573214136064,
0.5737746357917786,
0.1529233753681183,
0.842041552066803,
0.0023715628776699305,
0.20499210059642792,
-0.5764212012290955,
-0.1639520674943924,
0.2519339323043823,
-0.339195191860199,
-0.47344762086868286,
-0.42666807770729065,
0.11536415666341782,
-0.4509374499320984,
0.3611990213394165,
-0.3224611282348633,
0.008679525926709175,
0.09803962707519531,
0.15926489233970642,
-0.12051650136709213,
0.6020110249519348,
0.6459256410598755,
0.33086660504341125,
-0.3252565860748291,
-0.04491405934095383,
0.46471384167671204,
0.05355270206928253,
0.11760333925485611,
-0.3628431260585785,
-0.24309252202510834,
-0.0145860705524683,
0.40675219893455505,
1.0282797813415527,
0.3449583649635315,
-0.7358782291412354,
0.3471715748310089,
-0.03402957692742348,
-0.17750997841358185,
-0.23107045888900757,
0.38039523363113403,
0.3651755154132843,
0.4731115996837616,
-0.17278027534484863,
-0.0010709279449656606,
0.3612370491027832,
-0.6623477935791016,
-0.2907339632511139,
0.5995904207229614,
-0.2566399872303009,
-0.41949644684791565,
0.6600513458251953,
0.05007687583565712,
-0.5497174859046936,
0.16771864891052246,
0.1285620927810669,
-0.24987910687923431,
0.27824342250823975,
0.46582522988319397,
0.9799813032150269,
-0.19525651633739471,
0.4119793474674225,
0.22823414206504822,
-0.09928387403488159,
-0.07731103897094727,
0.052150025963783264,
-0.123663991689682,
-0.9825300574302673,
-0.3784342110157013,
-0.8830065131187439,
-0.6463783383369446,
0.2266613394021988,
-0.3356068432331085,
0.4376702308654785,
-0.7938775420188904,
-0.1958443820476532,
0.46709302067756653,
0.02931542880833149,
-0.7421277761459351,
0.6206774711608887,
0.4413343369960785,
0.5555294156074524,
-0.3691043555736542,
0.8048861026763916,
0.6592521667480469,
0.01888570562005043,
-0.4747394621372223,
-0.31852295994758606,
-0.03216657415032387,
-0.6272217631340027,
0.8084812760353088,
-0.17626091837882996,
-0.008297156542539597,
-0.21288762986660004,
-0.6678435802459717,
-0.649989902973175,
0.6995733380317688,
0.4872831404209137,
-1.0686943531036377,
-0.08597685396671295,
0.25710710883140564,
0.9623400568962097,
-0.3634987771511078,
0.27469781041145325,
0.7365692853927612,
0.4182966947555542,
0.12791754305362701,
-0.7762753963470459,
-0.2188270390033722,
0.2274075150489807,
0.2769486904144287,
0.05279335007071495,
-0.7094549536705017,
0.6523102521896362,
-0.24875877797603607,
0.16258829832077026,
-0.01994255930185318,
0.47762373089790344,
0.15642651915550232,
0.32370537519454956,
0.48019903898239136,
0.5512474775314331,
0.6349254846572876,
0.03297175094485283,
1.1864988803863525,
-0.22429734468460083,
0.20981447398662567,
1.3707596063613892,
-0.4897838234901428,
1.0048807859420776,
0.1994169056415558,
-0.12695454061031342,
0.3757258951663971,
0.5785616040229797,
-0.06387171894311905,
0.2748997211456299,
0.2438611090183258,
-0.3321867287158966,
-0.48755618929862976,
-0.18660672008991241,
-0.026605620980262756,
0.5196214914321899,
0.08252313733100891,
-0.42786693572998047,
-0.18052183091640472,
0.17642758786678314,
0.06706704944372177,
0.24505750834941864,
-0.3462160527706146,
1.0464328527450562,
0.19715891778469086,
-0.3997018337249756,
0.3368545174598694,
0.473549485206604,
1.1460728645324707,
-0.3230041265487671,
0.36184602975845337,
-0.203179731965065,
0.3444995880126953,
-0.45299091935157776,
-0.7520453929901123,
0.5007987022399902,
0.2580389976501465,
-0.4145458936691284,
-0.38828331232070923,
1.0544323921203613,
-0.21763908863067627,
-0.4427211880683899,
0.28845658898353577,
0.28524017333984375,
0.02369753085076809,
-0.4308808743953705,
-0.5521161556243896,
-0.01136461179703474,
0.11155036091804504,
-0.5764527916908264,
0.5207481384277344,
0.22957783937454224,
0.10681059956550598,
0.962753176689148,
0.7724248170852661,
0.2137432098388672,
-0.1373588591814041,
0.21493448317050934,
0.8184606432914734,
-0.9565395712852478,
-0.20897746086120605,
-1.1225037574768066,
0.1793813407421112,
0.13948698341846466,
-0.3929302394390106,
0.9030182361602783,
0.4561241567134857,
0.7989588379859924,
-0.31341972947120667,
0.756249725818634,
0.40762394666671753,
0.8246788382530212,
-0.4107888638973236,
0.38111552596092224,
-0.6240593194961548,
0.2806691527366638,
-0.24606342613697052,
-0.9494436979293823,
-0.5535122752189636,
0.4608062505722046,
-0.6762781739234924,
0.07945531606674194,
0.22795118391513824,
0.5938233733177185,
0.07603680342435837,
-0.05959407612681389,
0.821306586265564,
0.4007057249546051,
0.5909791588783264,
0.5513925552368164,
0.7359358668327332,
0.015548100695014,
0.010445661842823029,
-0.2723224461078644,
-0.06739453971385956,
-0.25681719183921814,
-0.7733085751533508,
-1.2925711870193481,
-0.3869418203830719,
-0.3918614983558655,
0.03970187529921532,
-0.06793263554573059,
0.9660354256629944,
0.7571515440940857,
-0.9390068650245667,
-0.22587145864963531,
0.03778519481420517,
0.1189940944314003,
0.4339938163757324,
-0.2481970638036728,
-0.2337048202753067,
-0.5034403800964355,
-0.837030827999115,
0.3940087556838989,
0.7336477637290955,
-0.0896359458565712,
-0.33139768242836,
0.010614684782922268,
0.030738329514861107,
0.5169999003410339,
1.0468651056289673,
0.1778353899717331,
-0.9187789559364319,
-0.5053145885467529,
-0.05489842966198921,
0.12380295991897583,
0.1407352238893509,
0.7661870718002319,
-0.6738944053649902,
0.41711363196372986,
0.6444348692893982,
0.42277371883392334,
0.5174310803413391,
-0.0037943567149341106,
0.5021702647209167,
-0.556385338306427,
0.22756242752075195,
0.31616106629371643,
0.2213858962059021,
0.41614630818367004,
-0.6457207202911377,
0.2856133282184601,
-0.1578996330499649,
-0.7990282773971558,
-0.8718539476394653,
0.2534879446029663,
-1.1057350635528564,
-0.383723646402359,
1.2941737174987793,
-0.08775704354047775,
0.04706063121557236,
-0.12310876697301865,
-0.4184470474720001,
-0.03015618585050106,
-0.4448884427547455,
0.7089068293571472,
0.9399769306182861,
-0.2927481234073639,
-0.14426492154598236,
-0.5791366696357727,
0.38596266508102417,
0.4413664937019348,
-1.0075663328170776,
-0.16300654411315918,
0.30613717436790466,
0.49739378690719604,
-0.013034017756581306,
0.493648886680603,
0.21376919746398926,
-0.2316654473543167,
-0.639732837677002,
0.03145015612244606,
-0.003993109334260225,
-0.09617124497890472,
-0.6066217422485352,
0.19955387711524963,
0.2828318774700165,
0.3005978763103485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09267v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09267v2 | Self-Alignment for Factuality: Mitigating Hallucinations in LLMs via Self-Evaluation | 2024-02-14T15:52:42 | 2024-06-11T12:22:14 | Xiaoying Zhang, Baolin Peng, Ye Tian, Jingyan Zhou, Lifeng Jin, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite showing increasingly human-like abilities, large language models
(LLMs) often struggle with factual inaccuracies, i.e. "hallucinations", even
when they hold relevant knowledge. To address these hallucinations, current
approaches typically necessitate high-quality human factuality annotations. In
this work, we explore Self-Alignment for Factuality, where we leverage the
self-evaluation capability of an LLM to provide training signals that steer the
model towards factuality. Specifically, we incorporate Self-Eval, a
self-evaluation component, to prompt an LLM to validate the factuality of its
own generated responses solely based on its internal knowledge. Additionally,
we design Self-Knowledge Tuning (SK-Tuning) to augment the LLM's
self-evaluation ability by improving the model's confidence estimation and
calibration. We then utilize these self-annotated responses to fine-tune the
model via Direct Preference Optimization algorithm. We show that the proposed
self-alignment approach substantially enhances factual accuracy over Llama
family models across three key knowledge-intensive tasks on TruthfulQA and
BioGEN. | [
-0.2233683168888092,
-0.5788546800613403,
0.8380559682846069,
0.2118133157491684,
-0.19973665475845337,
0.1818086951971054,
-0.24295976758003235,
-0.37558943033218384,
0.43146488070487976,
0.6794238686561584,
-0.6457793712615967,
-0.510154128074646,
-0.42684033513069153,
0.3503012955188751,
-0.1608799695968628,
1.2069931030273438,
0.1657203733921051,
0.023780418559908867,
-0.3673626184463501,
-0.1951865255832672,
-0.5927586555480957,
-0.6323841214179993,
-0.12307016551494598,
-0.26637715101242065,
0.6356114149093628,
0.40466344356536865,
0.8008927702903748,
1.0085347890853882,
0.5216154456138611,
0.24387484788894653,
0.28976282477378845,
0.4199168086051941,
-0.6316476464271545,
0.2936752140522003,
-0.3878646492958069,
-0.34544292092323303,
-0.4668417274951935,
0.02154788374900818,
0.28885626792907715,
0.3877120912075043,
-0.20317788422107697,
0.4375750422477722,
0.05251041799783707,
0.688347578048706,
-0.5581929087638855,
-0.1302577555179596,
-0.681790828704834,
0.2211785912513733,
0.07812351733446121,
-0.4361134469509125,
-0.21925117075443268,
-0.47466039657592773,
0.03878157585859299,
-0.49710461497306824,
0.3059374690055847,
0.260513037443161,
0.7628535628318787,
0.9725991487503052,
-0.2929346263408661,
-0.35314470529556274,
-0.7081231474876404,
0.5521867275238037,
-0.8443701863288879,
0.4464985728263855,
0.3097724914550781,
0.07491163164377213,
-0.19968266785144806,
-0.19700247049331665,
-0.7315817475318909,
-0.38042110204696655,
-0.1486385613679886,
0.10044574737548828,
0.16844876110553741,
0.10858996212482452,
0.29300791025161743,
0.2468259483575821,
-0.6216170191764832,
0.23305724561214447,
-0.29722440242767334,
-0.5714046955108643,
0.7247806787490845,
0.21761150658130646,
0.14762364327907562,
-0.35702577233314514,
-0.5472906827926636,
0.12417560070753098,
-0.5146416425704956,
-0.3157601058483124,
0.5096895098686218,
0.2968257963657379,
0.14798815548419952,
0.8458505272865295,
-0.35511815547943115,
0.605550229549408,
0.536519467830658,
-0.4625394344329834,
0.1939791589975357,
-0.25044405460357666,
-0.11812605708837509,
0.6120926737785339,
0.593355655670166,
0.5405585765838623,
0.08460221439599991,
-0.20690536499023438,
-0.2614229917526245,
0.2976694107055664,
0.6961467862129211,
-0.6316173076629639,
-0.16182100772857666,
0.31449639797210693,
-0.3348391652107239,
-0.5775309801101685,
-0.19709829986095428,
-0.873557984828949,
-0.6808701157569885,
-0.6390151977539062,
0.8231402635574341,
-0.28588175773620605,
-0.035268425941467285,
0.2344236820936203,
0.3203863799571991,
0.1302783340215683,
0.28510040044784546,
-1.1113699674606323,
0.08296012133359909,
0.5656709671020508,
0.6590607166290283,
-0.3050179183483124,
-0.24777072668075562,
-0.478450208902359,
0.34364110231399536,
-0.4304584562778473,
0.8330768942832947,
-0.27674391865730286,
-0.1335747241973877,
-0.27786341309547424,
-0.23758789896965027,
-0.08854609727859497,
-0.44749975204467773,
0.6564061045646667,
-0.2642216086387634,
0.17832091450691223,
-0.5222410559654236,
-0.5415759682655334,
-0.15260222554206848,
0.3503057062625885,
-0.3245902359485626,
0.9818229079246521,
-0.14358901977539062,
-0.7733981013298035,
0.353316068649292,
-0.43880221247673035,
-0.4360317885875702,
-0.09894448518753052,
-0.4551636576652527,
-0.3610709607601166,
0.29611966013908386,
0.33187609910964966,
0.4577052891254425,
0.12280325591564178,
0.37133729457855225,
-0.4167347848415375,
-0.3021753430366516,
0.2804182767868042,
-0.3886113464832306,
0.31517428159713745,
0.2215842306613922,
-0.6356465816497803,
0.24750567972660065,
-0.855326235294342,
-0.22550086677074432,
-0.02942197024822235,
-0.13575498759746552,
-0.14507587254047394,
-0.0401734784245491,
-0.6643017530441284,
0.25179553031921387,
0.5423542857170105,
-0.43571364879608154,
0.35569605231285095,
-0.46209579706192017,
-0.05923681706190109,
0.9578352570533752,
-0.09341215342283249,
0.08257168531417847,
-0.47346481680870056,
0.3432028293609619,
-0.01083436980843544,
0.2544058561325073,
0.18457670509815216,
-0.10319249331951141,
-0.9673101902008057,
-0.341549813747406,
0.3043545186519623,
0.474286824464798,
-0.4034341871738434,
0.9481396079063416,
-0.3084089159965515,
-0.34286245703697205,
-0.8913426995277405,
0.39049720764160156,
0.2057286947965622,
0.9894682168960571,
0.43935713171958923,
-0.20046202838420868,
-0.5878972411155701,
-1.0848021507263184,
-0.10925622284412384,
-0.2604750692844391,
0.3120000958442688,
0.0842062383890152,
0.3611046373844147,
-0.4463927447795868,
0.9748741984367371,
-0.5460589528083801,
-0.46835601329803467,
0.15746323764324188,
0.2596680819988251,
-0.0539858341217041,
0.40253281593322754,
0.26848116517066956,
-0.3873089849948883,
-0.04347243160009384,
0.0020343270152807236,
-0.9893774390220642,
-0.3221418559551239,
-0.25787678360939026,
-0.20575770735740662,
0.45721927285194397,
0.1753242313861847,
-0.6133593320846558,
0.4729861319065094,
0.41108304262161255,
-0.25905677676200867,
0.8196317553520203,
-0.3494996726512909,
0.26364728808403015,
-0.790402352809906,
-0.0904545783996582,
-0.22969262301921844,
-0.2553212642669678,
-0.3347059488296509,
-0.20708905160427094,
-0.04796858876943588,
0.33261120319366455,
0.058248668909072876,
0.3993460536003113,
-0.3472364544868469,
-0.1468980759382248,
-0.4533158540725708,
0.24735821783542633,
-0.015827864408493042,
0.4816010296344757,
0.08934184163808823,
0.8122389316558838,
0.4188278615474701,
-0.41239190101623535,
0.23556537926197052,
0.34460633993148804,
-0.30128756165504456,
0.43712273240089417,
-0.19968409836292267,
0.2960889935493469,
-0.08027363568544388,
-0.01917046122252941,
-0.8451569676399231,
-0.3377857506275177,
0.4264589250087738,
-0.2796201705932617,
0.3006422817707062,
0.0789204090833664,
-0.34606704115867615,
-0.20552277565002441,
-0.3275623023509979,
0.251778781414032,
0.35674673318862915,
-0.8287203907966614,
0.7844486236572266,
0.18153560161590576,
0.04658457264304161,
-0.7473392486572266,
-0.38905444741249084,
0.21645624935626984,
-0.35966917872428894,
-0.4926915466785431,
0.17324349284172058,
-0.30499839782714844,
-0.06038207188248634,
-0.1522790491580963,
-0.4632737338542938,
0.46008458733558655,
0.009806493297219276,
0.3219200670719147,
0.44171833992004395,
-0.21863491833209991,
0.3278622329235077,
0.10828980058431625,
-0.0489826425909996,
0.26734450459480286,
-0.22957928478717804,
0.4032854437828064,
-0.16096380352973938,
-0.4785122871398926,
-0.4263249933719635,
-0.11748813837766647,
0.45886361598968506,
-0.12393569201231003,
0.5837146639823914,
0.43267926573753357,
-0.3371172845363617,
-0.033754173666238785,
-1.23970627784729,
-0.37529054284095764,
-0.46832042932510376,
0.12809546291828156,
-0.3501811921596527,
-0.8708614110946655,
0.363811731338501,
-0.05160623416304588,
-0.2672237157821655,
0.5106379985809326,
0.8198490142822266,
-0.3128461241722107,
1.021767497062683,
0.5012946724891663,
-0.04879855737090111,
-0.08569170534610748,
0.14979904890060425,
0.36930549144744873,
-0.9016666412353516,
-0.32586607336997986,
-0.21083906292915344,
-0.17721650004386902,
-0.4634210467338562,
-0.3641600012779236,
0.4001026749610901,
-0.2594434916973114,
-0.1392880082130432,
0.08932889252901077,
-0.6634220480918884,
0.46903127431869507,
0.2709783613681793,
0.25453048944473267,
0.4713042378425598,
-0.002569566946476698,
-0.23699699342250824,
-0.2047702670097351,
-0.6138884425163269,
-0.8253669738769531,
1.0420628786087036,
0.3930123448371887,
0.8761341571807861,
-0.09448541700839996,
0.82016521692276,
0.3175760805606842,
0.29498302936553955,
-0.640143632888794,
0.4692555069923401,
0.08873938769102097,
-0.712395191192627,
-0.410999596118927,
-0.5154188871383667,
-0.4617859423160553,
0.09745646268129349,
-0.4977481961250305,
-0.7677174210548401,
0.27405789494514465,
0.30119600892066956,
-0.7491028308868408,
0.1270250678062439,
-0.4266011714935303,
0.7944795489311218,
-0.8431141376495361,
-0.3775051236152649,
-0.4344611167907715,
-0.7781025171279907,
0.5415582060813904,
-0.3740496337413788,
0.15935567021369934,
-0.36083275079727173,
0.09145477414131165,
0.4920384883880615,
-0.09820662438869476,
1.0445080995559692,
0.0907844752073288,
-0.3343130350112915,
-0.017707450315356255,
0.29499056935310364,
0.3183614909648895,
0.12567290663719177,
-0.03600151836872101,
0.2824663817882538,
0.1034465804696083,
-0.033086325973272324,
-0.8687388300895691,
0.7153674364089966,
-0.9095191359519958,
-1.107956886291504,
-0.6462149620056152,
-0.48416244983673096,
-0.3991067409515381,
0.010815689340233803,
0.1871425211429596,
0.1999332308769226,
-0.13938069343566895,
-0.13148796558380127,
0.8126291036605835,
-0.042871274054050446,
0.06252744793891907,
0.4862792193889618,
-0.42223286628723145,
-0.522013783454895,
1.080897569656372,
0.21764624118804932,
0.16914191842079163,
0.04703889042139053,
0.4445325434207916,
-0.6316620707511902,
-0.44682052731513977,
-0.4372302293777466,
0.5041984915733337,
-0.8094133138656616,
-0.4436863660812378,
-0.7308036684989929,
-0.3395136296749115,
-0.6354394555091858,
-0.05087267607450485,
-0.449817419052124,
-0.4547673463821411,
-0.445773720741272,
-0.31156039237976074,
0.19977450370788574,
0.7273386716842651,
-0.32113945484161377,
0.11486738175153732,
-0.41992634534835815,
0.5661665201187134,
0.5072461366653442,
0.4083130955696106,
-0.20831947028636932,
-0.8970522880554199,
-0.20473721623420715,
0.05740530788898468,
-0.3389105200767517,
-0.7878543138504028,
0.27029111981391907,
0.005423908121883869,
0.48454737663269043,
0.5964202880859375,
0.2098129689693451,
0.9415265917778015,
-0.37005260586738586,
0.447761207818985,
0.07751559466123581,
-0.9939571619033813,
0.612732470035553,
-0.09214185178279877,
-0.10515061020851135,
0.8341139554977417,
0.34545719623565674,
-0.2729155123233795,
-0.28293994069099426,
-0.39150184392929077,
-0.31597694754600525,
0.31628572940826416,
0.2349531203508377,
0.0673418939113617,
0.09286923706531525,
0.7617084383964539,
0.33799099922180176,
0.3051665127277374,
-0.8403741717338562,
-0.025293879210948944,
-0.5697200298309326,
-0.5421301126480103,
0.10988552868366241,
-0.45035162568092346,
-0.5343310832977295,
-0.42549464106559753,
0.9074999094009399,
-0.5174335837364197,
-0.10628002136945724,
0.5509190559387207,
-0.12514813244342804,
-0.32628968358039856,
0.046395350247621536,
0.6986650228500366,
0.6592386364936829,
-0.258165180683136,
0.2606745958328247,
0.3942581117153168,
-0.24851594865322113,
0.19631344079971313,
-0.12364625930786133,
-0.10363283008337021,
-0.4017426669597626,
0.274261474609375,
0.7233188152313232,
0.18101397156715393,
-0.4718396067619324,
0.4987228512763977,
-0.007366088218986988,
0.003908067941665649,
-0.1221541315317154,
0.3361574113368988,
-0.04329391568899155,
0.3643818199634552,
0.14665673673152924,
0.02137133479118347,
0.2639869749546051,
-0.44291970133781433,
0.011764016933739185,
0.5987985134124756,
-0.18707433342933655,
-0.3102010488510132,
0.6859803199768066,
0.07932599633932114,
-0.26601213216781616,
0.42109644412994385,
-0.12956535816192627,
-0.6699948906898499,
0.2850838303565979,
0.6888757944107056,
0.9729977250099182,
-0.2821963429450989,
0.23797301948070526,
0.3494991958141327,
0.4887548089027405,
-0.10343756526708603,
0.07047959417104721,
-0.0723784863948822,
-0.9635180234909058,
-0.43410810828208923,
-0.8994351029396057,
-0.44479185342788696,
0.018856016919016838,
-0.5496131181716919,
0.3311906158924103,
-0.4347671568393707,
-0.1976071447134018,
-0.22650958597660065,
0.00645388662815094,
-0.4520043730735779,
0.5514893531799316,
0.3055063784122467,
0.4618200659751892,
-0.6344067454338074,
0.7695057988166809,
0.27236488461494446,
-0.25344786047935486,
-0.7465699315071106,
0.243167445063591,
-0.04220547899603844,
-0.8761945962905884,
0.5756142139434814,
0.29287654161453247,
-0.5201901793479919,
-0.11448734998703003,
-0.6853903532028198,
-1.0562264919281006,
1.001094102859497,
0.6850704550743103,
-0.7988438010215759,
0.14975914359092712,
0.224342480301857,
0.6632910966873169,
-0.5591843724250793,
-0.039731673896312714,
0.8077340126037598,
0.558603823184967,
0.13654446601867676,
-0.6993551254272461,
0.22815123200416565,
0.15768110752105713,
-0.2746817469596863,
-0.24132119119167328,
-0.8092352747917175,
0.13747626543045044,
-0.44846072793006897,
-0.10825785994529724,
-0.08073323220014572,
1.011912226676941,
0.41152331233024597,
0.22915376722812653,
0.6760965585708618,
0.5821123719215393,
1.0439308881759644,
0.1288987100124359,
0.6240482330322266,
-0.6564162373542786,
0.21273435652256012,
1.342688798904419,
-0.5625377297401428,
0.4926723539829254,
0.5665349960327148,
0.1774088591337204,
0.5406808853149414,
0.5596586465835571,
-0.23946411907672882,
0.349630206823349,
0.06804762035608292,
-0.23902124166488647,
-0.5943443179130554,
-0.07628289610147476,
-0.2647600471973419,
0.6672091484069824,
0.17160624265670776,
-0.02436642535030842,
0.0901896134018898,
-0.14154508709907532,
-0.1417875736951828,
0.11475283652544022,
-0.04058369994163513,
0.8931676149368286,
-0.11573314666748047,
-0.771644651889801,
0.41916584968566895,
-0.25845006108283997,
0.5000766515731812,
-0.46059444546699524,
-0.04349001869559288,
-0.2746807932853699,
-0.22404272854328156,
-0.4621465504169464,
-0.520849883556366,
0.30966341495513916,
-0.06003745272755623,
-0.1702391803264618,
0.08842571824789047,
0.838983416557312,
-0.41022562980651855,
-0.589579701423645,
0.26911652088165283,
0.3346844017505646,
0.14161956310272217,
-0.0010998292127624154,
-0.5574576258659363,
0.15710920095443726,
-0.03534284234046936,
-0.09380078315734863,
0.19150596857070923,
0.43914473056793213,
0.179543137550354,
0.7496631145477295,
0.6362324357032776,
0.2431805282831192,
0.09425213187932968,
0.03500626981258392,
0.7466404438018799,
-0.8073937892913818,
-0.240667924284935,
-0.9815416932106018,
0.21226507425308228,
0.02383585274219513,
-0.29303380846977234,
0.761725902557373,
0.6126564741134644,
0.5621360540390015,
-0.10029654949903488,
0.7300147414207458,
0.2966606020927429,
0.43943488597869873,
-0.6319188475608826,
0.7409195303916931,
-0.4985116124153137,
0.30071181058883667,
-0.09942683577537537,
-0.906679630279541,
-0.21960772573947906,
0.9222854971885681,
-0.3158711791038513,
-0.0628700777888298,
0.5645663142204285,
0.9888202548027039,
0.13801658153533936,
0.11017420887947083,
0.5789783596992493,
0.5802161693572998,
0.01960611343383789,
-0.016346078366041183,
0.9680122137069702,
-0.03989998623728752,
0.281745046377182,
-0.4626009464263916,
-0.18142053484916687,
-0.1885773092508316,
-1.084622859954834,
-0.9974520206451416,
-0.3203619718551636,
-0.5290403962135315,
-0.37705138325691223,
0.13060715794563293,
1.2906675338745117,
0.6137666702270508,
-0.7470601201057434,
-0.21467499434947968,
0.3149396479129791,
0.15436656773090363,
0.06256286799907684,
-0.14188727736473083,
0.37536805868148804,
-0.7116551995277405,
-0.3114166259765625,
0.5493179559707642,
0.6550548076629639,
0.17935441434383392,
-0.6151212453842163,
-0.003412233665585518,
0.01749959960579872,
0.3822799623012543,
0.38054677844047546,
0.05142796039581299,
-0.9596816301345825,
-0.7889574766159058,
-0.018455855548381805,
-0.18806728720664978,
0.43177613615989685,
0.5776728987693787,
-0.8746470212936401,
0.6779490113258362,
-0.13885337114334106,
0.6363582611083984,
0.3328808844089508,
0.3180053234100342,
0.4176592230796814,
-0.5311569571495056,
-0.35610833764076233,
0.14075212180614471,
0.21247225999832153,
0.5609554648399353,
-0.9662684798240662,
0.5997039675712585,
0.2094414234161377,
-0.8557060956954956,
-0.889941394329071,
-0.031042270362377167,
-1.0553972721099854,
-0.03319716826081276,
1.0331778526306152,
0.29371699690818787,
-0.287262499332428,
-0.024980181828141212,
-0.4457591474056244,
0.4076436758041382,
-0.01918364129960537,
1.6330329179763794,
0.821914553642273,
-0.34799957275390625,
0.19268415868282318,
-0.37991490960121155,
0.688350260257721,
0.6707385778427124,
-0.8066684007644653,
0.175247460603714,
0.47832778096199036,
0.45276689529418945,
0.2642669677734375,
0.3037254214286804,
0.11867251247167587,
0.10944752395153046,
-0.41757503151893616,
0.4235977232456207,
0.08425731211900711,
-0.5911622047424316,
-0.527472972869873,
-0.06251996010541916,
0.0432136133313179,
0.10735183209180832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09259v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09259v2 | SyntaxShap: Syntax-aware Explainability Method for Text Generation | 2024-02-14T15:45:56 | 2024-06-03T10:30:00 | Kenza Amara, Rita Sevastjanova, Mennatallah El-Assady | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To harness the power of large language models in safety-critical domains, we
need to ensure the explainability of their predictions. However, despite the
significant attention to model interpretability, there remains an unexplored
domain in explaining sequence-to-sequence tasks using methods tailored for
textual data. This paper introduces SyntaxShap, a local, model-agnostic
explainability method for text generation that takes into consideration the
syntax in the text data. The presented work extends Shapley values to account
for parsing-based syntactic dependencies. Taking a game theoric approach,
SyntaxShap only considers coalitions constraint by the dependency tree. We
adopt a model-based evaluation to compare SyntaxShap and its weighted form to
state-of-the-art explainability methods adapted to text generation tasks, using
diverse metrics including faithfulness, coherency, and semantic alignment of
the explanations to the model. We show that our syntax-aware method produces
explanations that help build more faithful and coherent explanations for
predictions by autoregressive models. Confronted with the misalignment of human
and AI model reasoning, this paper also highlights the need for cautious
evaluation strategies in explainable AI. | [
-0.023081310093402863,
-0.7555115222930908,
0.6743901371955872,
0.5103511214256287,
-0.15482288599014282,
-0.010450907982885838,
-0.04586971923708916,
-0.24709907174110413,
-0.0028975962195545435,
0.46065983176231384,
-0.5060255527496338,
-0.47105902433395386,
-0.3484785258769989,
-0.04148994758725166,
-0.5948502421379089,
0.870918869972229,
-0.2952580153942108,
-0.25933414697647095,
-0.6166715025901794,
-0.028382577002048492,
-0.5112667083740234,
-0.7081334590911865,
-0.44747743010520935,
-0.2479798048734665,
-0.10817791521549225,
0.2921784818172455,
0.9867286682128906,
1.0418648719787598,
0.36646342277526855,
0.3781307339668274,
-0.015771623700857162,
-0.11792197078466415,
-0.21542954444885254,
0.4102981388568878,
-0.21269214153289795,
-0.4294717609882355,
-0.2970203161239624,
-0.28483274579048157,
0.4304213225841522,
0.6851862668991089,
-0.5997920036315918,
-0.08108720928430557,
-0.06017465889453888,
0.5527123212814331,
-0.5688060522079468,
0.2714734971523285,
-0.7714478373527527,
0.02990737371146679,
-0.040016740560531616,
-0.13255536556243896,
-0.4634321928024292,
-0.19268928468227386,
-0.06665835529565811,
-0.543515682220459,
0.46888017654418945,
0.11835180222988129,
0.8496299386024475,
0.2331879884004593,
-0.14521563053131104,
-0.08300817757844925,
-0.5630983114242554,
0.6285863518714905,
-0.709889829158783,
0.25619491934776306,
0.2843264937400818,
0.45859113335609436,
-0.05561280623078346,
-0.6605201959609985,
-0.7125157713890076,
-0.025742771103978157,
-0.033884916454553604,
0.13756272196769714,
-0.09598864614963531,
0.21249759197235107,
0.14483895897865295,
0.2897785007953644,
-0.6421657204627991,
-0.13373629748821259,
0.1737244874238968,
-0.12884382903575897,
0.7272583246231079,
0.3388913571834564,
0.47825005650520325,
-0.5850240588188171,
-0.6965269446372986,
0.13095618784427643,
-0.5940839052200317,
0.27516254782676697,
0.2776576578617096,
0.12301985919475555,
-0.30922842025756836,
0.3610575795173645,
-0.09061740338802338,
0.8524402976036072,
0.09912586212158203,
0.2688787579536438,
-0.3727252781391144,
-0.6477789282798767,
-0.3476376533508301,
-0.0498429536819458,
0.8180375099182129,
0.2658139169216156,
0.20578233897686005,
-0.37345629930496216,
0.020292852073907852,
0.012747760862112045,
0.2692156136035919,
-0.8547680974006653,
-0.275789350271225,
0.48422256112098694,
-0.7434180378913879,
-0.615617036819458,
-0.18452088534832,
-0.815967857837677,
-0.5416585803031921,
-0.0869099348783493,
0.29601556062698364,
-0.7302698493003845,
-0.36598002910614014,
0.17448274791240692,
-0.1971781998872757,
0.23861505091190338,
0.17833848297595978,
-1.2552731037139893,
0.2613135874271393,
0.6950520277023315,
0.8472732901573181,
-0.07147615402936935,
-0.4638996720314026,
-0.18560852110385895,
0.368602454662323,
-0.3391009271144867,
0.7447227835655212,
-0.35170963406562805,
-0.22937679290771484,
-0.08559942245483398,
-0.29338598251342773,
-0.22438505291938782,
-0.5226883888244629,
0.3017235994338989,
-0.10638546943664551,
0.1767706573009491,
-0.2907196581363678,
-0.6673784852027893,
-0.220750629901886,
-0.06940105557441711,
-0.4290374517440796,
0.5489267706871033,
0.1516530066728592,
-0.6697134971618652,
0.565542995929718,
-0.5243912935256958,
-0.6171762943267822,
0.15241003036499023,
-0.29439613223075867,
-0.43846195936203003,
0.06599733233451843,
0.30061814188957214,
0.49146854877471924,
-0.2818329334259033,
0.7963079214096069,
-0.3690464496612549,
-0.058852337300777435,
0.15819525718688965,
-0.4072332978248596,
0.9630544781684875,
0.16964754462242126,
-0.4084305763244629,
0.2978633642196655,
-0.5641021132469177,
0.28596076369285583,
0.3896828591823578,
0.08062440156936646,
-0.06424663960933685,
0.4540289342403412,
-0.0970001369714737,
0.23270322382450104,
0.19108301401138306,
-0.05466185882687569,
-0.07143910974264145,
-0.5223067998886108,
0.7218274474143982,
0.6961036324501038,
0.14632882177829742,
0.49661436676979065,
-0.3067655861377716,
0.7391693592071533,
-0.08943361043930054,
0.3473201394081116,
-0.45943355560302734,
-0.3944832980632782,
-0.6143136620521545,
-0.0808088555932045,
0.11330422013998032,
0.3915867805480957,
-0.6694621443748474,
0.5074850916862488,
-0.1338198482990265,
-0.34147727489471436,
-0.165281280875206,
-0.03674769401550293,
0.5577834844589233,
0.47763457894325256,
0.2525976896286011,
-0.13291330635547638,
-0.6333360075950623,
-0.9084279537200928,
-0.6345914602279663,
-0.5068098306655884,
0.3271328806877136,
0.2123846411705017,
0.3940366208553314,
0.16271699965000153,
1.0643264055252075,
-0.22956672310829163,
0.2735515236854553,
-0.48108285665512085,
0.15399858355522156,
-0.145955890417099,
0.38428348302841187,
0.5254709720611572,
-0.741463840007782,
-0.25908157229423523,
-0.31826111674308777,
-0.7575643062591553,
-0.13428907096385956,
-0.4156363308429718,
-0.28303128480911255,
0.0008475030190311372,
0.46512433886528015,
-0.6407060027122498,
0.13571694493293762,
0.5236303806304932,
-0.6586352586746216,
0.5498853921890259,
-0.0682319849729538,
0.09910635650157928,
-1.167140007019043,
0.02507174201309681,
-0.3653623163700104,
-0.5553182363510132,
-0.48730000853538513,
0.5353060364723206,
-0.13537883758544922,
-0.3492315411567688,
-0.1671282798051834,
0.4703613221645355,
-0.24653784930706024,
0.030061587691307068,
0.028913144022226334,
0.04756567254662514,
0.3518560826778412,
0.18462298810482025,
0.060017965734004974,
0.7263324856758118,
0.43582725524902344,
-0.3992287218570709,
0.21092653274536133,
0.4766843914985657,
-0.18796981871128082,
0.3735649883747101,
-0.7620645761489868,
-0.3338358998298645,
0.04819600656628609,
0.1788976490497589,
-0.8117635846138,
-0.33938267827033997,
0.012317730113863945,
-0.47962865233421326,
0.06324545294046402,
-0.37886130809783936,
-0.3893255591392517,
0.030070390552282333,
0.004129475448280573,
0.34968510270118713,
0.5784393548965454,
-0.6572152376174927,
0.3877706527709961,
0.3041040599346161,
-0.25114548206329346,
-0.3945975601673126,
-0.3565709590911865,
0.2218143790960312,
-0.4824683368206024,
-0.9411813020706177,
0.391571044921875,
0.031057678163051605,
-0.5320447087287903,
-0.21029525995254517,
-0.1226227656006813,
-0.42214465141296387,
0.4996365010738373,
0.4683551788330078,
0.07921040803194046,
-0.2559371292591095,
0.2102450728416443,
0.09140913188457489,
-0.09789331257343292,
0.5516732335090637,
-0.20150445401668549,
0.4557684659957886,
-0.14443868398666382,
-0.26115497946739197,
-0.05387759208679199,
0.3954881429672241,
0.17205920815467834,
-0.3118400275707245,
0.7066571116447449,
0.23963838815689087,
-0.29492855072021484,
-0.6000902652740479,
0.009131846018135548,
0.049503691494464874,
-0.4635836184024811,
0.30725905299186707,
-0.1757725030183792,
-0.42273539304733276,
0.5626167058944702,
-0.05789893865585327,
-0.1673683226108551,
0.6970135569572449,
0.4013749361038208,
-0.026558199897408485,
1.060241460800171,
0.5391556024551392,
0.18721291422843933,
0.38677436113357544,
-0.044582292437553406,
0.16107769310474396,
-0.11492736637592316,
-0.08852454274892807,
-0.5162999629974365,
0.18829010426998138,
-0.19881480932235718,
-0.4669148623943329,
0.03601055219769478,
0.4870510399341583,
-0.0897851288318634,
0.3812847435474396,
-0.4681730568408966,
0.6093680262565613,
0.2970525920391083,
-0.0811861976981163,
0.24366708099842072,
-0.15708911418914795,
0.03537610173225403,
-0.03541826084256172,
-0.9086333513259888,
-0.36536428332328796,
0.6768611073493958,
0.05466987565159798,
0.3859443664550781,
0.26626452803611755,
0.8951950073242188,
0.27222445607185364,
-0.1614302545785904,
-0.3897271752357483,
0.44626620411872864,
-0.10639389604330063,
-0.4618886411190033,
-0.3060985207557678,
-0.45614323019981384,
-0.8565031290054321,
0.13660115003585815,
-0.3317899703979492,
-0.7074633836746216,
-0.04334694519639015,
0.3671058118343353,
-0.48969078063964844,
0.022175725549459457,
-0.7932884693145752,
1.2653765678405762,
-0.3448432385921478,
-0.20534054934978485,
-0.2730179727077484,
-0.5487487316131592,
0.5557537078857422,
0.26646456122398376,
0.23492443561553955,
-0.06867772340774536,
0.10240817815065384,
0.7471171021461487,
-0.9258111119270325,
0.6971843242645264,
-0.2779504060745239,
-0.09256695210933685,
0.3309507966041565,
0.39778533577919006,
0.42562565207481384,
0.080268494784832,
0.06019827350974083,
0.17283137142658234,
0.21319450438022614,
-0.3574898838996887,
-0.7902199625968933,
0.6327413320541382,
-0.32648584246635437,
-0.5278319716453552,
-0.12958240509033203,
-0.5952382683753967,
-0.2526440918445587,
0.13324613869190216,
0.4416999816894531,
0.5346025824546814,
-0.22549869120121002,
-0.18207751214504242,
0.5395889282226562,
-0.35952383279800415,
0.4898884892463684,
0.16197825968265533,
-0.48992305994033813,
-0.20763415098190308,
1.0920631885528564,
-0.21710936725139618,
0.3610538840293884,
0.35860493779182434,
0.3171788454055786,
-0.24327506124973297,
-0.6877198815345764,
-0.6794812083244324,
-0.19925232231616974,
-0.6547510027885437,
-0.17524373531341553,
-0.3885451555252075,
-0.32200267910957336,
-0.11460801213979721,
-0.5935595035552979,
-0.21365250647068024,
-0.8803732991218567,
0.19190607964992523,
-0.08729995042085648,
0.42821094393730164,
0.6716844439506531,
0.16345538198947906,
0.41018185019493103,
-0.530073881149292,
0.4422104060649872,
0.1541460007429123,
0.4989587366580963,
0.02556736022233963,
-0.3009175658226013,
-0.19653978943824768,
-0.05855134502053261,
-0.21571795642375946,
-1.093318223953247,
0.2825722098350525,
0.23739111423492432,
0.34844648838043213,
0.3786959946155548,
0.011917315423488617,
0.6400609612464905,
-0.38489195704460144,
0.8803852796554565,
0.13252073526382446,
-1.4155083894729614,
0.7869398593902588,
-0.621936023235321,
0.12708333134651184,
0.4363854229450226,
-0.12585124373435974,
-0.2830493152141571,
-0.5345646739006042,
-1.0804288387298584,
-0.9430747628211975,
0.4086449146270752,
0.4210442006587982,
-0.0350397527217865,
-0.004978106822818518,
0.5022064447402954,
0.32600629329681396,
0.12983250617980957,
-0.7030766606330872,
-0.18112127482891083,
-0.27315014600753784,
-0.40212950110435486,
0.023358864709734917,
-0.20148974657058716,
-0.09207630157470703,
0.15450651943683624,
0.528598964214325,
-0.04565014690160751,
0.257121741771698,
0.012293464504182339,
-0.31101861596107483,
-0.06805973500013351,
0.3549681305885315,
0.45300039649009705,
0.8451815247535706,
0.004508877173066139,
0.11263594776391983,
-0.23624539375305176,
-0.2207406610250473,
0.11574476212263107,
0.41828614473342896,
-0.33377718925476074,
0.11627940088510513,
0.758599579334259,
0.5971514582633972,
0.13288025557994843,
-0.618326723575592,
0.8702040314674377,
-0.033460583537817,
-0.05964345484972,
-0.09899118542671204,
0.35101309418678284,
0.13662531971931458,
0.09986317902803421,
-0.08520220965147018,
0.17997783422470093,
0.3379228413105011,
-0.1983446329832077,
0.21703718602657318,
0.6163331270217896,
-0.32571539282798767,
-0.24469316005706787,
1.0377148389816284,
0.3999115824699402,
-0.18204660713672638,
0.16544751822948456,
-0.1619955152273178,
-0.378422349691391,
1.0316429138183594,
0.5965696573257446,
0.8854127526283264,
-0.14109459519386292,
0.548994779586792,
0.3366096615791321,
0.20814236998558044,
0.0878305733203888,
0.5369991660118103,
-0.27304351329803467,
-0.6148958206176758,
-0.48556646704673767,
-0.42804190516471863,
-0.3523101806640625,
-0.08093426376581192,
-0.6895210146903992,
0.0015884953318163753,
-0.6324619650840759,
0.1252552568912506,
0.3716546297073364,
-0.4107186198234558,
-0.33190616965293884,
0.11647243797779083,
-0.15498673915863037,
0.7412609457969666,
-0.8823971152305603,
0.3239196538925171,
0.29695016145706177,
-0.5781248807907104,
-0.7504944205284119,
0.2945363521575928,
-0.09172181785106659,
-1.0465540885925293,
0.05481597036123276,
0.11849850416183472,
0.04119102656841278,
-0.12832927703857422,
-0.6646488904953003,
-0.6187180876731873,
0.8332425951957703,
0.6792279481887817,
-0.32913312315940857,
-0.04581575468182564,
0.12273761630058289,
0.47119277715682983,
-0.02017505094408989,
0.03960632160305977,
0.3124232888221741,
0.3908017873764038,
-0.423568993806839,
-0.6440762281417847,
0.392976313829422,
-0.06923019886016846,
0.03598540276288986,
0.37190893292427063,
-0.43641334772109985,
0.4855579733848572,
-0.5708301663398743,
-0.27935782074928284,
0.28057485818862915,
0.5596249103546143,
0.217206671833992,
0.21588517725467682,
0.4609895348548889,
0.31303536891937256,
0.66515052318573,
-0.12120192497968674,
1.284995198249817,
-0.3812069594860077,
0.23771996796131134,
1.1925724744796753,
0.1006273403763771,
0.7592331171035767,
0.3901037871837616,
-0.2668776512145996,
0.876753032207489,
0.5315391421318054,
0.1001574918627739,
0.2793424129486084,
0.14952097833156586,
-0.12249218672513962,
-0.5718554258346558,
-0.054417286068201065,
-0.2895084619522095,
0.642449140548706,
0.061153046786785126,
-0.6543937921524048,
-0.3355070948600769,
-0.36789095401763916,
0.06938324123620987,
0.3938729763031006,
-0.1398620456457138,
0.7748715281486511,
-0.06268974393606186,
-0.7172561883926392,
0.5890776515007019,
0.17691421508789062,
-0.023441750556230545,
-0.5602391362190247,
-0.2254871279001236,
-0.09983862191438675,
0.08117655664682388,
-0.16082608699798584,
-0.8325605392456055,
0.3602454960346222,
-0.10496972501277924,
-0.5080835819244385,
-0.35757774114608765,
0.663912296295166,
-0.5239829421043396,
-0.2985983192920685,
0.04860737919807434,
0.5887966156005859,
-0.051787152886390686,
-0.1385517120361328,
-0.8562024235725403,
-0.38273513317108154,
0.040548067539930344,
0.10325105488300323,
0.18932898342609406,
0.4370381832122803,
-0.18285484611988068,
0.6924105882644653,
0.3412058651447296,
-0.05078372731804848,
-0.24801108241081238,
-0.043937768787145615,
0.3350863754749298,
-0.7032222747802734,
-0.7156240344047546,
-1.0201596021652222,
0.4734691381454468,
-0.0019832493271678686,
-0.25673121213912964,
0.7184158563613892,
0.4950815439224243,
0.19787150621414185,
0.08231929689645767,
0.9926857948303223,
-0.23605148494243622,
0.19731181859970093,
-0.7503753304481506,
0.8967151045799255,
-0.19353534281253815,
0.13814948499202728,
-0.17591631412506104,
-0.5345056056976318,
-0.02579999901354313,
0.5391306281089783,
0.04087704047560692,
0.1515820473432541,
0.7553814649581909,
0.34030935168266296,
-0.07644878327846527,
0.16333894431591034,
0.10482499748468399,
0.4190879166126251,
0.0960068553686142,
0.48556163907051086,
0.7404398918151855,
-0.15553969144821167,
0.5908884406089783,
-0.28147631883621216,
-0.07029587030410767,
0.10118411481380463,
-1.1621336936950684,
-0.6397431492805481,
-0.8073097467422485,
-0.2698042690753937,
-0.5699824094772339,
0.2048102468252182,
0.4026806056499481,
0.8071735501289368,
-0.6241270303726196,
-0.07603292167186737,
-0.6310098171234131,
0.45990848541259766,
-0.49821966886520386,
-0.30498185753822327,
0.308657169342041,
-0.4530414044857025,
-0.08017478883266449,
0.4274723529815674,
0.21372155845165253,
-0.0762789398431778,
-0.2590893805027008,
-0.08147627860307693,
0.16663464903831482,
0.22725927829742432,
0.23235061764717102,
0.26448750495910645,
-0.7782478928565979,
-0.20322997868061066,
-0.39450159668922424,
0.18340791761875153,
0.02140127308666706,
0.8278458118438721,
-0.7517741918563843,
0.6539626717567444,
0.41652342677116394,
0.3141462802886963,
0.12607625126838684,
0.21078699827194214,
1.1346449851989746,
-0.8257881999015808,
0.0058038546703755856,
0.02671290747821331,
0.5010611414909363,
0.44998490810394287,
-0.4847009479999542,
0.4149397015571594,
0.15026001632213593,
-0.4885307848453522,
-0.6616837382316589,
0.4459419846534729,
-0.8306242823600769,
-0.3064623475074768,
1.1016325950622559,
-0.2742384672164917,
-0.026427844539284706,
-0.15338227152824402,
-0.019502514973282814,
0.08892221003770828,
-0.16521675884723663,
0.7993255257606506,
0.610746443271637,
-0.14991655945777893,
-0.08804716914892197,
-0.3250510096549988,
0.9460318684577942,
0.5078933835029602,
-1.1802936792373657,
0.7024499773979187,
0.4880732595920563,
0.19395717978477478,
-0.2072976678609848,
0.5327017307281494,
0.07044418901205063,
0.5161679983139038,
0.29900142550468445,
0.11158451437950134,
-0.15470373630523682,
-0.21675676107406616,
-0.4416530430316925,
0.05303589254617691,
0.12723030149936676,
0.04107999801635742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09221v1 | Spectral Filters, Dark Signals, and Attention Sinks | 2024-02-14T15:01:07 | 2024-02-14T15:01:07 | Nicola Cancedda | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Projecting intermediate representations onto the vocabulary is an
increasingly popular interpretation tool for transformer-based LLMs, also known
as the logit lens. We propose a quantitative extension to this approach and
define spectral filters on intermediate representations based on partitioning
the singular vectors of the vocabulary embedding and unembedding matrices into
bands. We find that the signals exchanged in the tail end of the spectrum are
responsible for attention sinking (Xiao et al. 2023), of which we provide an
explanation. We find that the loss of pretrained models can be kept low despite
suppressing sizable parts of the embedding spectrum in a layer-dependent way,
as long as attention sinking is preserved. Finally, we discover that the
representation of tokens that draw attention from many tokens have large
projections on the tail end of the spectrum. | [
-0.700437068939209,
-0.23981371521949768,
0.6188283562660217,
-0.08869297802448273,
-0.5302019119262695,
0.2967331111431122,
-0.08712050318717957,
-0.4021194875240326,
0.5159925818443298,
0.852184534072876,
-0.5969133377075195,
-0.4778675436973572,
-0.6142473816871643,
-0.2970118522644043,
-0.8190754055976868,
1.103434681892395,
0.3343757092952728,
0.15472513437271118,
0.1535354107618332,
-0.03158300369977951,
-0.3052595555782318,
-0.27882540225982666,
-0.7139431834220886,
-0.38817721605300903,
1.0739282369613647,
0.2341216802597046,
0.8528348803520203,
0.3665612041950226,
0.8289496898651123,
0.16698653995990753,
-0.1592561900615692,
-0.09974478930234909,
-0.8770902752876282,
-0.07740870118141174,
-0.20695510506629944,
-1.042343020439148,
-0.12170565873384476,
0.013173876330256462,
0.8356574177742004,
1.0158402919769287,
0.014195083640515804,
0.3689509332180023,
0.27431628108024597,
0.7538395524024963,
-0.6182530522346497,
-0.1523706018924713,
-0.7663121819496155,
0.22279831767082214,
-0.32385700941085815,
-0.352286696434021,
-0.7501031160354614,
0.38726815581321716,
-0.013394216075539589,
-0.3625407814979553,
0.324294775724411,
0.15797095000743866,
1.0023759603500366,
0.6330278515815735,
-0.658187985420227,
0.055557359009981155,
-1.0174015760421753,
0.786384642124176,
-0.38128992915153503,
0.6346964836120605,
0.26791736483573914,
0.4178168475627899,
0.17495030164718628,
-0.9487869739532471,
-0.2414766550064087,
0.08977826684713364,
-0.3491596579551697,
0.5641489624977112,
-0.17747966945171356,
0.477463960647583,
-0.009089956060051918,
0.30184048414230347,
-0.23234818875789642,
0.042716071009635925,
-0.6982057690620422,
-0.17352735996246338,
0.3140481114387512,
0.229648157954216,
-0.07459151744842529,
-0.07235155254602432,
-0.4842106103897095,
0.12799182534217834,
-0.9211670160293579,
-0.4070557653903961,
0.42627865076065063,
-0.009207509458065033,
-0.02537512592971325,
0.6467083096504211,
0.4824688136577606,
0.7553916573524475,
0.3181043565273285,
0.3088570535182953,
-0.21116453409194946,
-0.042670950293540955,
-0.3899402320384979,
-0.03180209547281265,
0.18472857773303986,
0.5621684193611145,
0.13847750425338745,
-0.3388407230377197,
-0.2290520817041397,
0.410279780626297,
0.48752152919769287,
-0.4066821336746216,
-0.44879382848739624,
0.0739469900727272,
-0.5967106819152832,
-0.20989227294921875,
-0.22673235833644867,
-0.736400306224823,
-0.08641451597213745,
-0.387192040681839,
0.478322833776474,
0.027250388637185097,
-0.13952943682670593,
0.17141690850257874,
0.05431085079908371,
0.42729178071022034,
-0.04712323471903801,
-0.856941819190979,
0.4782096743583679,
0.603600025177002,
0.7379923462867737,
-0.19947437942028046,
0.15891721844673157,
-0.15343455970287323,
0.41225042939186096,
-0.4807979166507721,
0.8247058391571045,
-0.7228710651397705,
-0.3993402123451233,
0.08352693915367126,
0.046334411948919296,
-0.13235701620578766,
-0.49035754799842834,
0.6161893606185913,
-1.1267083883285522,
0.018328597769141197,
0.04799332097172737,
-0.546061098575592,
-0.3113940358161926,
-0.165290966629982,
-0.8053466081619263,
0.9729229211807251,
0.15933118760585785,
-0.5197581052780151,
0.16898129880428314,
-0.34034085273742676,
0.08976420015096664,
0.19495539367198944,
-0.21409855782985687,
-0.245841845870018,
0.3792232871055603,
-0.008991762064397335,
0.4438617527484894,
-0.12367835640907288,
-0.19299398362636566,
-0.36679187417030334,
-0.5496231317520142,
0.3264624774456024,
-0.1871684044599533,
0.47951605916023254,
0.25925570726394653,
-0.12389542162418365,
-0.036593370139598846,
-0.7679554224014282,
-0.34374716877937317,
-0.2492491900920868,
-0.149020716547966,
-0.34734082221984863,
0.2627709209918976,
0.24469242990016937,
-0.05389365553855896,
-0.09812361747026443,
-0.5705562829971313,
-0.30614548921585083,
-0.3849039375782013,
0.44297343492507935,
1.0780000686645508,
0.33468374609947205,
0.6693387627601624,
0.10281889885663986,
0.5217403173446655,
0.3991874158382416,
0.28036877512931824,
-0.2904241681098938,
-0.4322100877761841,
-1.342907428741455,
-0.08032997697591782,
0.1331915408372879,
0.08527948707342148,
-0.6079037189483643,
0.05085139349102974,
-0.36280402541160583,
-0.3309180736541748,
-0.5182892680168152,
-0.014492744579911232,
0.1490606814622879,
0.4346819818019867,
0.15656669437885284,
-0.23827748000621796,
-0.4675905406475067,
-1.2124454975128174,
-0.2544836103916168,
-0.1369173228740692,
0.09763094037771225,
0.14961376786231995,
0.2756343483924866,
-0.22815199196338654,
0.8577998280525208,
-0.8489086031913757,
-0.5483716726303101,
0.0997857004404068,
-0.32346898317337036,
0.6385984420776367,
0.3590371906757355,
0.6930732131004333,
-1.0766981840133667,
-0.327934205532074,
-0.2687093913555145,
-0.41647300124168396,
0.05033000186085701,
-0.20704038441181183,
-0.65891033411026,
-0.32415828108787537,
0.7372408509254456,
-0.5225440263748169,
0.25322583317756653,
0.5400784015655518,
-0.6973398923873901,
0.2570815086364746,
0.28033068776130676,
-0.336212158203125,
-0.694423258304596,
-0.07741781324148178,
0.14454346895217896,
-0.47308349609375,
-0.804529070854187,
0.21842075884342194,
-0.0503646619617939,
-0.024336235597729683,
-0.4912799894809723,
0.3571908473968506,
-0.5775835514068604,
-0.23911328613758087,
-0.12450329959392548,
0.3720710277557373,
0.05657142400741577,
0.7554657459259033,
-0.2520076632499695,
0.2089899629354477,
0.4084729254245758,
-0.6169817447662354,
0.2423439919948578,
-0.02183258719742298,
-0.21864821016788483,
0.6609675288200378,
-0.5374935269355774,
0.2478579878807068,
-0.4671827256679535,
0.06228642538189888,
-1.7086362838745117,
0.0663982629776001,
0.2727459967136383,
-0.3643311560153961,
0.5129814743995667,
-0.48367270827293396,
-0.2901389002799988,
-0.40625783801078796,
-0.2566158175468445,
0.3081303834915161,
0.712136447429657,
-0.5363266468048096,
0.8670939803123474,
0.4920690357685089,
0.20375315845012665,
-0.47321435809135437,
-1.186131477355957,
0.09430648386478424,
-0.48134106397628784,
-0.4850232005119324,
0.4209962487220764,
0.1917034536600113,
-0.22328977286815643,
0.520255982875824,
-0.07029334455728531,
0.08199609071016312,
-0.09854274988174438,
0.13760000467300415,
0.5960671305656433,
-0.38045668601989746,
0.22665780782699585,
0.023999545723199844,
-0.13848748803138733,
0.4277459383010864,
-0.6622924208641052,
0.38855862617492676,
0.3475548326969147,
-0.5958073735237122,
0.07752558588981628,
0.286944180727005,
0.5304928421974182,
-0.11164400726556778,
0.35992830991744995,
0.8079113960266113,
-0.20463316142559052,
-0.2874126732349396,
-0.6411210298538208,
-0.43209308385849,
-0.5331535935401917,
0.4144164025783539,
-0.2840593159198761,
-0.6919876933097839,
0.944125771522522,
0.18547244369983673,
0.08105320483446121,
0.6229668259620667,
0.4211861789226532,
-0.437610924243927,
0.9451155066490173,
0.6166117191314697,
0.2589460015296936,
0.7073156833648682,
-0.6082167625427246,
0.29464685916900635,
-1.2568403482437134,
-0.19520924985408783,
-0.2422422170639038,
-0.904335618019104,
-0.5297985076904297,
-0.4778243601322174,
0.4030880033969879,
-0.03249582648277283,
-0.2623217701911926,
-0.2780923545360565,
-0.7476342916488647,
0.6454470753669739,
0.3997412323951721,
0.5686447620391846,
0.107619509100914,
0.0900365337729454,
0.019514894112944603,
-0.26539722084999084,
-0.5496150255203247,
-0.26547086238861084,
1.2647442817687988,
0.534435510635376,
0.8451551198959351,
0.052544426172971725,
0.7320008873939514,
0.2845521867275238,
0.4619581699371338,
-0.8469855785369873,
0.7235696911811829,
-0.3354729115962982,
-0.9724852442741394,
-0.08238264918327332,
0.0772596225142479,
-0.8951286673545837,
0.5689301490783691,
0.3000865578651428,
-0.6950021982192993,
0.9167079925537109,
0.07231709361076355,
-0.2479284703731537,
0.3999459445476532,
-0.7242836952209473,
0.5094771981239319,
0.16157039999961853,
-0.49086445569992065,
-0.45023611187934875,
-0.6446343064308167,
0.5973233580589294,
-0.22437134385108948,
0.11297573894262314,
-0.2752966284751892,
-0.4820407032966614,
1.1365063190460205,
-0.24352221190929413,
1.3985366821289062,
-0.5472681522369385,
-0.08756736665964127,
0.5825400352478027,
0.03280598297715187,
0.5669621229171753,
-0.18234674632549286,
0.3576872646808624,
-0.11654645204544067,
-0.25454822182655334,
-0.5714616179466248,
-0.6549432873725891,
0.5620948672294617,
-0.6898661851882935,
-0.7723568081855774,
-0.15985998511314392,
-0.1864103227853775,
-0.21118074655532837,
-0.014436186291277409,
0.16274306178092957,
0.2629207372665405,
0.3696182370185852,
0.16958516836166382,
0.772271990776062,
0.34427642822265625,
0.5590285658836365,
0.3705608546733856,
-0.7297537326812744,
-0.2551654279232025,
0.8223364353179932,
0.4281870424747467,
0.4083593487739563,
0.20833313465118408,
-0.09289797395467758,
-0.3064374327659607,
-0.7807592153549194,
-0.235237255692482,
0.40190503001213074,
-1.2810100317001343,
-0.11522775143384933,
-0.34778618812561035,
-0.14123228192329407,
0.1981266736984253,
-0.05666997283697128,
-0.1622162163257599,
-0.41028329730033875,
-0.3400362432003021,
-0.24356397986412048,
0.3370991051197052,
0.6481415629386902,
-0.11656589806079865,
0.7470507621765137,
-0.500304639339447,
0.27524587512016296,
0.2450263351202011,
0.26848453283309937,
0.33025723695755005,
-0.8873500227928162,
-0.868689775466919,
-0.30590134859085083,
-0.10251616686582565,
-0.934248685836792,
0.2509942948818207,
0.468433678150177,
0.5634648203849792,
0.5920292139053345,
-0.04019546881318092,
0.786993145942688,
-0.4197671413421631,
0.8583372235298157,
0.42052313685417175,
-0.7796024084091187,
0.226870596408844,
-0.22449076175689697,
0.1498337686061859,
0.38891834020614624,
0.27850979566574097,
-0.6607319712638855,
-0.8112098574638367,
-0.4294340908527374,
-1.024949312210083,
0.8024587631225586,
-0.11036287993192673,
0.5623812675476074,
0.06490698456764221,
0.5207716226577759,
-0.10713662952184677,
-0.012633781880140305,
-0.7682068943977356,
-0.6063964366912842,
-0.22558467090129852,
-0.20619842410087585,
-0.3876650035381317,
-0.6137133836746216,
-0.2947997450828552,
-0.09748842567205429,
0.4053826630115509,
0.047557391226291656,
0.6326355934143066,
0.27740803360939026,
-0.16000624001026154,
-0.06933869421482086,
-0.23904500901699066,
0.17233015596866608,
0.26317334175109863,
-0.21612635254859924,
0.7019323706626892,
-0.01756918616592884,
-1.0048277378082275,
0.13699263334274292,
-0.324878990650177,
-0.3548029959201813,
0.38499897718429565,
0.3889424502849579,
0.8387295007705688,
0.6939257979393005,
-0.1781797856092453,
0.28242141008377075,
0.4363831579685211,
0.08891899883747101,
-0.40625548362731934,
-0.21217899024486542,
0.2705601751804352,
0.13462066650390625,
0.8720796704292297,
0.2893308103084564,
0.3219708800315857,
-0.4636116325855255,
0.2436130791902542,
0.13305220007896423,
-0.9014493823051453,
-0.46888652443885803,
0.860032856464386,
0.14301809668540955,
0.1431177705526352,
0.3192561864852905,
0.23609362542629242,
-0.44438183307647705,
0.5124307870864868,
0.37004128098487854,
0.9963674545288086,
-0.3837790787220001,
0.007636625319719315,
0.12314578145742416,
0.4513920843601227,
0.47722697257995605,
0.15421858429908752,
-0.16227728128433228,
-0.7097698450088501,
-0.7703835368156433,
-0.6106401681900024,
-0.05346250534057617,
-0.1536400318145752,
-0.701292097568512,
0.39832696318626404,
-0.20300917327404022,
-0.3979825973510742,
0.3040612041950226,
-0.3904026448726654,
-0.6855138540267944,
0.3077755570411682,
0.5225609540939331,
0.5950649380683899,
-0.9376965761184692,
0.779918372631073,
0.5737447142601013,
-0.43622586131095886,
-0.5621452927589417,
-0.13575394451618195,
-0.2943851351737976,
-1.248753547668457,
1.0632884502410889,
-0.15866418182849884,
-0.38185960054397583,
0.3111843466758728,
-0.5986902117729187,
-1.3280341625213623,
0.7645007967948914,
0.48940032720565796,
-0.6431344151496887,
-0.4201340973377228,
0.2705177664756775,
0.4463590979576111,
-0.3054138720035553,
0.2697919011116028,
0.4707520604133606,
0.5961037874221802,
0.2421698421239853,
-0.34359532594680786,
-0.12195132672786713,
-0.12761686742305756,
0.03777789697051048,
0.37353551387786865,
-0.7410550713539124,
0.7793709635734558,
0.013420648872852325,
-0.5914103984832764,
-0.4267898201942444,
0.5240775346755981,
-0.34746870398521423,
0.20941248536109924,
0.5294311046600342,
0.48194992542266846,
0.2444068193435669,
-0.2931998372077942,
0.864845871925354,
-0.44935840368270874,
0.45289021730422974,
0.9110837578773499,
0.03589923679828644,
0.899009108543396,
1.0119218826293945,
-0.46239209175109863,
0.5223226547241211,
1.0421223640441895,
-0.3574502170085907,
0.9546021819114685,
0.24563287198543549,
-0.25400510430336,
-0.11962210386991501,
-0.14125441014766693,
-0.13755826652050018,
0.2814145088195801,
0.5494250059127808,
-0.5645632743835449,
-0.11306540668010712,
0.3479304015636444,
-0.23945653438568115,
-0.23666034638881683,
-0.7802053093910217,
0.6929258108139038,
0.5039966702461243,
-0.5548644065856934,
0.7916072607040405,
-0.39997127652168274,
0.5093050599098206,
-0.4545431137084961,
0.16770592331886292,
-0.27294492721557617,
0.37456241250038147,
-0.6037210822105408,
-0.9509307146072388,
0.4827369451522827,
-0.4323352873325348,
-0.07635998725891113,
0.075982466340065,
0.789792537689209,
-0.49622097611427307,
-0.5252870917320251,
0.7551242709159851,
0.2746700942516327,
0.3487851321697235,
0.1057138741016388,
-0.32996538281440735,
0.13554991781711578,
0.1016201600432396,
-0.6204606294631958,
-0.02831786684691906,
0.24821195006370544,
0.3076278269290924,
0.49755576252937317,
0.4299103021621704,
0.08486573398113251,
0.8151553869247437,
0.20300404727458954,
0.9881212115287781,
-0.6534532904624939,
-0.614988386631012,
-0.9019378423690796,
0.6234695911407471,
0.08106563985347748,
0.13853223621845245,
0.7477590441703796,
0.7271724939346313,
0.6241306662559509,
-0.2035682052373886,
0.32804039120674133,
0.5356063842773438,
0.2647434175014496,
-0.7457593679428101,
0.6744664907455444,
-0.5342935919761658,
0.3855152726173401,
-0.020077254623174667,
-1.5037257671356201,
-0.41803380846977234,
0.059047047048807144,
-0.18888437747955322,
-0.0526740625500679,
0.7242094874382019,
0.6101934909820557,
-0.19242717325687408,
-0.19311212003231049,
0.6255705952644348,
0.43985554575920105,
0.08877959102392197,
0.5351982712745667,
1.055936336517334,
-0.44922083616256714,
0.7182031273841858,
-0.09840800613164902,
0.23781023919582367,
-0.36563679575920105,
-0.2669881284236908,
-0.7350917458534241,
-0.6802605986595154,
-0.3712202310562134,
-0.07374253123998642,
-0.12019675970077515,
0.05242463946342468,
0.9358839392662048,
-0.4916495978832245,
-0.22275494039058685,
0.010459769517183304,
-0.04906915873289108,
0.10235673934221268,
-0.20559810101985931,
0.6308566927909851,
-0.44645416736602783,
-0.7855883836746216,
0.03034611977636814,
0.42063796520233154,
0.177792027592659,
-1.0099799633026123,
0.07185175269842148,
-0.042397286742925644,
0.2178923338651657,
0.6908896565437317,
-0.3186436593532562,
-0.8172591328620911,
-0.4017128348350525,
0.01918414793908596,
0.07551826536655426,
0.1720716953277588,
0.5756773948669434,
-0.8819255232810974,
0.31346094608306885,
0.11579714715480804,
0.3504709303379059,
1.1724904775619507,
-0.5555014610290527,
0.29272642731666565,
-0.6882227063179016,
0.24905610084533691,
0.4406498372554779,
0.5736393928527832,
0.13990789651870728,
-0.21266324818134308,
0.7497126460075378,
0.27502667903900146,
-0.3259826898574829,
-1.23494553565979,
0.36688125133514404,
-1.0697320699691772,
-0.035375241190195084,
0.8519545793533325,
-0.07805886119604111,
-0.6651564836502075,
-0.24729909002780914,
-0.11731910705566406,
0.12952889502048492,
-0.12483608722686768,
0.3271370232105255,
0.796434223651886,
0.03046760894358158,
-0.585446834564209,
-0.5488265156745911,
0.2227254956960678,
0.5986127257347107,
-0.09290759265422821,
-0.04311404377222061,
0.20124812424182892,
-0.0177585631608963,
0.4867496192455292,
0.30515721440315247,
-0.2083638608455658,
0.15791602432727814,
0.21517249941825867,
-0.16314859688282013,
0.499423623085022,
-0.02797883190214634,
-0.45075753331184387,
0.2798568308353424,
0.09162449836730957,
-0.48140501976013184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09216v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09216v3 | AutoTutor meets Large Language Models: A Language Model Tutor with Rich Pedagogy and Guardrails | 2024-02-14T14:53:56 | 2024-04-25T13:15:55 | Sankalan Pal Chowdhury, Vilém Zouhar, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Large Language Models (LLMs) have found several use cases in education,
ranging from automatic question generation to essay evaluation. In this paper,
we explore the potential of using Large Language Models (LLMs) to author
Intelligent Tutoring Systems. A common pitfall of LLMs is their straying from
desired pedagogical strategies such as leaking the answer to the student, and
in general, providing no guarantees. We posit that while LLMs with certain
guardrails can take the place of subject experts, the overall pedagogical
design still needs to be handcrafted for the best learning results. Based on
this principle, we create a sample end-to-end tutoring system named MWPTutor,
which uses LLMs to fill in the state space of a pre-defined finite state
transducer. This approach retains the structure and the pedagogy of traditional
tutoring systems that has been developed over the years by learning scientists
but brings in additional flexibility of LLM-based approaches. Through a human
evaluation study on two datasets based on math word problems, we show that our
hybrid approach achieves a better overall tutoring score than an instructed,
but otherwise free-form, GPT-4. MWPTutor is completely modular and opens up the
scope for the community to improve its performance by improving individual
modules or using different teaching strategies that it can follow. | [
-0.39907872676849365,
-0.7763646841049194,
0.5966955423355103,
-0.10471974313259125,
-0.33956483006477356,
0.49261364340782166,
-0.37699949741363525,
-0.12861120700836182,
-0.02141856774687767,
0.28121280670166016,
-0.24492715299129486,
-0.18076089024543762,
-0.6274130344390869,
0.03790224343538284,
-0.6143492460250854,
0.835638165473938,
-0.20448549091815948,
0.25654101371765137,
-0.32152998447418213,
0.22689594328403473,
-0.38595059514045715,
-0.6602773070335388,
-0.49941208958625793,
-0.44523313641548157,
0.4291171729564667,
0.24278908967971802,
0.5246098637580872,
0.7553890943527222,
0.1040867492556572,
0.3753051161766052,
0.047736674547195435,
-0.05559738725423813,
-0.22135885059833527,
0.10206020623445511,
-0.3636332154273987,
-0.5276969075202942,
-0.21937191486358643,
-0.034107863903045654,
0.39185988903045654,
0.6841015815734863,
-0.20845457911491394,
-0.06723935902118683,
0.1752178966999054,
0.2416771501302719,
-0.42138561606407166,
0.2113446295261383,
-0.43262332677841187,
0.25423529744148254,
-0.1536470353603363,
0.01803436316549778,
-0.4135468304157257,
-0.39698153734207153,
0.3646996319293976,
-0.34534528851509094,
-0.04927167296409607,
-0.02623392455279827,
0.27582675218582153,
0.3493366539478302,
-0.5616195797920227,
-0.2331256866455078,
-0.8876928091049194,
0.7413628101348877,
-0.7539107799530029,
0.2362026423215866,
0.15530869364738464,
0.655632495880127,
-0.24655383825302124,
-0.36207616329193115,
-0.5534892678260803,
-0.12784011662006378,
0.03832973539829254,
0.18643683195114136,
-0.008681489154696465,
0.021417800337076187,
0.03742470219731331,
0.4736057221889496,
-0.5455899238586426,
0.4629290699958801,
-0.23641851544380188,
-0.47685495018959045,
0.5058940052986145,
0.2683495283126831,
0.2705540060997009,
-0.13368883728981018,
-0.19283510744571686,
-0.25854992866516113,
-0.7010890245437622,
-0.09443754702806473,
0.6415293216705322,
0.20001186430454254,
0.053848687559366226,
0.584945797920227,
0.26935383677482605,
0.9008499979972839,
-0.02552306279540062,
-0.19438794255256653,
-0.3039861023426056,
0.04988535866141319,
0.07461035996675491,
0.011227349750697613,
1.0516808032989502,
0.06524930149316788,
0.6670112609863281,
-0.11344808340072632,
-0.4213883578777313,
-0.061645012348890305,
-0.007717073895037174,
-0.7427968978881836,
-0.4405195116996765,
-0.060672011226415634,
-0.07255269587039948,
-0.27442577481269836,
0.06411473453044891,
-0.7661022543907166,
-0.3011340796947479,
-0.5725136995315552,
0.6226125955581665,
-0.6145000457763672,
-0.264289915561676,
0.10803082585334778,
0.20969851315021515,
0.2760320007801056,
0.23210059106349945,
-1.0039710998535156,
0.5635802745819092,
0.746837317943573,
0.802808403968811,
-0.3934822678565979,
-0.2351294606924057,
-0.2724921405315399,
0.16042734682559967,
-0.28829050064086914,
0.8225451111793518,
-0.5154492259025574,
-0.6682185530662537,
0.004653274081647396,
-0.11082381755113602,
0.03708687052130699,
-0.3773469924926758,
0.04507209360599518,
-0.45796555280685425,
0.7476627230644226,
0.1998663991689682,
-0.8765385746955872,
-0.16665105521678925,
0.1261555552482605,
-0.514801025390625,
0.8373113870620728,
0.08588675409555435,
-0.24240072071552277,
-0.039477504789829254,
-0.5771806836128235,
-0.5153859853744507,
0.15665556490421295,
-0.2383321076631546,
-0.23802286386489868,
0.07819866389036179,
0.12180124968290329,
0.47419095039367676,
-0.3593389391899109,
0.6339054703712463,
0.04780786857008934,
-0.2920493185520172,
0.2381230890750885,
-0.5921267867088318,
0.5525879859924316,
0.0990714505314827,
-0.3509637415409088,
0.23588529229164124,
-0.5205493569374084,
0.01613704301416874,
0.14009463787078857,
-0.43454688787460327,
-0.281594842672348,
0.10817573964595795,
0.05653087794780731,
0.17571210861206055,
0.34109389781951904,
-0.655825674533844,
0.13450835645198822,
-0.4006451666355133,
0.7399996519088745,
1.1278432607650757,
-0.21900686621665955,
0.33904826641082764,
-0.36132359504699707,
0.756506621837616,
-0.26812490820884705,
-0.054710809141397476,
-0.3268296420574188,
-0.27663499116897583,
-0.8371387720108032,
-0.1951276659965515,
0.4660608768463135,
0.48890170454978943,
-0.5292288064956665,
0.7116194367408752,
-0.16902433335781097,
-0.5036288499832153,
-0.2079087346792221,
0.15412522852420807,
0.3324487507343292,
0.2895733118057251,
0.1831451952457428,
0.002349862828850746,
-0.41741687059402466,
-0.8117687702178955,
-0.2311399132013321,
0.042345963418483734,
-0.1182456836104393,
-0.013010669499635696,
0.5046529173851013,
0.10459998995065689,
1.1146273612976074,
-0.45308250188827515,
-0.26500773429870605,
-0.43069571256637573,
-0.2756176292896271,
0.1441769152879715,
0.5778388977050781,
0.4699856638908386,
-0.39182227849960327,
-0.6483378410339355,
-0.23302501440048218,
-0.47017738223075867,
-0.08929570019245148,
0.024779748171567917,
-0.18327759206295013,
0.17633159458637238,
0.5320209860801697,
-0.565872073173523,
0.018049029633402824,
0.469471275806427,
-0.20720700919628143,
0.6235906481742859,
-0.23892010748386383,
-0.40276816487312317,
-1.4012677669525146,
-0.1263684779405594,
-0.1283261924982071,
-0.3931773602962494,
-0.24231715500354767,
-0.05549426004290581,
0.01542988233268261,
-0.33583539724349976,
-0.1664937436580658,
0.6651181578636169,
-0.4103957712650299,
-0.11565110832452774,
-0.4044536352157593,
0.20224368572235107,
-0.20743931829929352,
0.3841094374656677,
-0.22668595612049103,
0.8416996002197266,
0.4775364398956299,
-0.2183946669101715,
0.7658650279045105,
0.06776238232851028,
-0.3552621901035309,
0.47091615200042725,
-0.8363657593727112,
0.26504281163215637,
0.07468635588884354,
0.467281699180603,
-0.8935445547103882,
-0.27050596475601196,
-0.09289057552814484,
-0.1988629251718521,
0.37402722239494324,
-0.2411465048789978,
-0.762114405632019,
-0.577164888381958,
-0.1811620593070984,
0.015514921396970749,
0.6216707229614258,
-0.5846240520477295,
0.7078512907028198,
0.4199138581752777,
-0.3761008083820343,
-0.3103967308998108,
-0.4527782201766968,
0.37923526763916016,
-0.06433612108230591,
-0.297588050365448,
0.1565449982881546,
-0.29463088512420654,
-0.16628386080265045,
0.03345879539847374,
0.033300261944532394,
-0.0608372762799263,
0.12487660348415375,
0.08269906044006348,
0.5026683807373047,
-0.15626409649848938,
0.24501225352287292,
0.21698647737503052,
-0.30095088481903076,
0.2508142292499542,
-0.6083551049232483,
0.8225094676017761,
-0.10323835164308548,
-0.6465545296669006,
-0.28980642557144165,
0.3193889856338501,
0.7670350670814514,
-0.34185415506362915,
0.5255715250968933,
0.08149415254592896,
-0.2812664806842804,
-0.45197707414627075,
-0.48095613718032837,
-0.23755906522274017,
-0.5426599979400635,
0.42019861936569214,
-0.28347182273864746,
-0.9331751465797424,
0.35526755452156067,
0.012056032195687294,
0.3032148480415344,
0.18263506889343262,
0.5934717059135437,
0.08175582438707352,
1.048287272453308,
0.6851393580436707,
-0.3580171763896942,
0.6201711893081665,
-0.3354547619819641,
0.3116246461868286,
-0.6186577677726746,
-0.28123387694358826,
-0.17464733123779297,
-0.31281766295433044,
-0.3095499575138092,
-0.1344001591205597,
0.352744460105896,
-0.1909426599740982,
-0.28099215030670166,
0.3405638337135315,
-0.5396338105201721,
0.654773473739624,
0.5415178537368774,
-0.09775496274232864,
0.3003557324409485,
-0.016270628198981285,
-0.5174151062965393,
-0.0839681625366211,
-0.7051008343696594,
-0.6367232799530029,
1.1199454069137573,
0.15120238065719604,
0.8842769265174866,
0.25980812311172485,
0.5724043250083923,
0.08920536935329437,
0.3628341555595398,
-1.0230141878128052,
0.8059467077255249,
-0.11957190930843353,
-0.6542923450469971,
-0.3472074568271637,
-0.33771851658821106,
-0.7738625407218933,
0.4409756362438202,
-0.12485853582620621,
-0.4504542648792267,
-0.3837784230709076,
0.03332194313406944,
-0.4073307514190674,
0.449815958738327,
-0.6188516020774841,
0.6949360966682434,
-0.54660564661026,
-0.33407747745513916,
-0.10351008921861649,
-0.3831714391708374,
0.22119757533073425,
-0.3191704750061035,
0.11755471676588058,
0.17396768927574158,
-0.08716189116239548,
0.7759402394294739,
-0.7716689109802246,
0.9190524220466614,
-0.1948993057012558,
-0.32467105984687805,
0.16158629953861237,
0.33982256054878235,
0.3538641929626465,
-0.41144177317619324,
-0.08901049941778183,
-0.4349014461040497,
-0.05668945610523224,
-0.29218944907188416,
-0.7118399739265442,
0.8045231103897095,
-0.8461874723434448,
-0.8374251127243042,
-0.34925031661987305,
-0.768308162689209,
-0.3239414393901825,
0.33255842328071594,
0.052951082587242126,
0.7476974129676819,
0.055350884795188904,
0.08964399993419647,
0.6801967620849609,
-0.29428204894065857,
0.6752579212188721,
0.6590492129325867,
-0.2765125036239624,
-0.3997277021408081,
1.0258628129959106,
0.22786782681941986,
0.17786987125873566,
0.17519696056842804,
0.5809321999549866,
-0.4077320694923401,
-0.5356640815734863,
-0.7075000405311584,
0.3598361909389496,
-0.6867712140083313,
-0.1383054107427597,
-0.47089260816574097,
-0.3445173501968384,
-0.33193331956863403,
-0.3736536204814911,
-0.27379512786865234,
-0.4258458614349365,
-0.21612365543842316,
-0.2567037045955658,
0.46716150641441345,
0.9569658637046814,
-0.012418457306921482,
0.4033546447753906,
-0.5559635758399963,
-0.14362747967243195,
0.5526376962661743,
0.28060007095336914,
0.18593814969062805,
-0.7329689860343933,
-0.02504153922200203,
-0.18136589229106903,
-0.2663082182407379,
-0.44802790880203247,
0.4024490416049957,
0.18601927161216736,
0.6139416098594666,
0.36275896430015564,
0.01653209701180458,
0.5015342831611633,
-0.6920434236526489,
0.625579297542572,
0.10155550390481949,
-0.9133924245834351,
0.32032468914985657,
-0.4998353123664856,
0.3678751289844513,
0.1965452879667282,
0.3203180432319641,
-0.5061386823654175,
-0.5489108562469482,
-0.22243188321590424,
-0.7624332308769226,
0.43061843514442444,
-0.3589325547218323,
0.4541114568710327,
0.25013697147369385,
0.27131739258766174,
0.3406888544559479,
0.1481119692325592,
-0.6875027418136597,
-0.010668558068573475,
-0.32643720507621765,
-0.7550195455551147,
-0.18972523510456085,
-0.08824299275875092,
0.00329669495113194,
-0.18268337845802307,
0.5019855499267578,
-0.23533150553703308,
0.04738423973321915,
-0.1911587119102478,
-0.31584370136260986,
-0.08328981697559357,
0.28221508860588074,
0.4662160873413086,
0.6602936387062073,
0.2678602635860443,
0.2721051871776581,
0.08165457844734192,
-0.4177723228931427,
0.3335859775543213,
0.21160675585269928,
-0.16591514647006989,
-0.21371100842952728,
0.4537016749382019,
0.44973888993263245,
0.3999426066875458,
-0.6637424230575562,
0.5500069260597229,
0.19748467206954956,
-0.24086709320545197,
-0.6272566914558411,
0.2939195930957794,
0.2462102472782135,
0.03785642981529236,
0.5361629724502563,
-0.23906835913658142,
-0.245883047580719,
-0.3911704421043396,
0.03749290853738785,
0.4637923836708069,
-0.25036439299583435,
-0.46869218349456787,
0.6579447984695435,
0.36195337772369385,
-0.6243842244148254,
0.2595435678958893,
0.24543336033821106,
-0.879298210144043,
0.5310274362564087,
0.742672860622406,
0.7432467341423035,
-0.3893139958381653,
-0.0007287774933502078,
0.05704290792346001,
0.14703644812107086,
-0.07682779431343079,
0.026739830151200294,
-0.18377335369586945,
-0.5183064937591553,
-0.7618993520736694,
-0.5694007873535156,
-0.6775379776954651,
0.1457056850194931,
-0.4501698911190033,
0.23933908343315125,
-0.7248409390449524,
0.1464340090751648,
-0.14996106922626495,
-0.06018693000078201,
-0.28333693742752075,
-0.08237064629793167,
0.174516499042511,
0.9054934978485107,
-0.6585059762001038,
0.8428080081939697,
0.7677339911460876,
-0.001344216288998723,
-0.8284995555877686,
-0.2325965017080307,
0.13001225888729095,
-0.5899087190628052,
0.4465322494506836,
0.08663681894540787,
-0.1807957887649536,
0.2760741412639618,
-0.4010993540287018,
-0.7700493335723877,
0.9457680583000183,
0.42457982897758484,
-0.7554818987846375,
-0.1830786168575287,
0.3304118514060974,
0.6861633658409119,
-0.14215417206287384,
0.21017220616340637,
0.2094181925058365,
0.35726305842399597,
-0.06555823981761932,
-0.8464646935462952,
-0.0092619638890028,
-0.05616364628076553,
-0.0387263223528862,
0.26792532205581665,
-0.7207223773002625,
0.8301354646682739,
-0.03329450637102127,
0.015519163571298122,
0.21933668851852417,
0.46438315510749817,
-0.022869670763611794,
-0.25173062086105347,
0.5626750588417053,
0.48040711879730225,
0.5018975734710693,
-0.07786212116479874,
0.9738814830780029,
-0.40995922684669495,
0.26561930775642395,
1.0240010023117065,
-0.12190111726522446,
0.7188165783882141,
0.37554171681404114,
-0.3833552896976471,
0.5957973599433899,
0.5724380016326904,
-0.08741515129804611,
0.2858763337135315,
0.4354197084903717,
-0.29777026176452637,
-0.3463500738143921,
0.17715813219547272,
-0.02877260558307171,
0.48400652408599854,
0.23429739475250244,
-0.10347243398427963,
-0.4230971932411194,
0.3398853540420532,
0.12217259407043457,
0.3395327925682068,
-0.17926062643527985,
0.5976383686065674,
0.16406500339508057,
-0.5749353170394897,
0.2301550805568695,
-0.16246484220027924,
0.802910327911377,
-0.6309213638305664,
0.15244999527931213,
-0.20112815499305725,
0.30551713705062866,
0.042844053357839584,
-0.7540246248245239,
0.05947280302643776,
0.2093510627746582,
0.06491335481405258,
-0.47140347957611084,
0.38039320707321167,
-0.5265061259269714,
-0.6035486459732056,
0.24861761927604675,
0.5934628248214722,
0.10839654505252838,
0.40801283717155457,
-0.4728601574897766,
-0.23215414583683014,
-0.3306645154953003,
-0.291714072227478,
0.40964198112487793,
0.4181029200553894,
-0.00575817096978426,
0.9347453713417053,
0.7096382975578308,
0.10526978969573975,
-0.01513043325394392,
0.01748810149729252,
0.9239446520805359,
-0.5213260054588318,
-0.5076369047164917,
-1.0422202348709106,
0.20910677313804626,
0.054811760783195496,
-0.2555290758609772,
0.9833332300186157,
0.64690101146698,
0.7519215941429138,
0.04617688059806824,
0.9387770891189575,
0.06919771432876587,
0.6584726572036743,
-0.38198035955429077,
0.804152250289917,
-0.2064705193042755,
0.2345290184020996,
-0.14831310510635376,
-1.1338037252426147,
-0.23345322906970978,
0.6087803244590759,
-0.4353165626525879,
0.034567587077617645,
0.48120564222335815,
0.5128311514854431,
-0.11168836802244186,
0.03016558475792408,
0.46260106563568115,
0.15087901055812836,
0.5920473337173462,
0.6333706974983215,
1.1874241828918457,
-0.07486801594495773,
0.6976285576820374,
-0.13179723918437958,
-0.13966238498687744,
-0.19312164187431335,
-0.5636565685272217,
-1.1237473487854004,
-0.42598864436149597,
0.009894863702356815,
0.10398879647254944,
0.011152227409183979,
0.9084817171096802,
0.5802024006843567,
-0.6843276619911194,
-0.40829724073410034,
-0.15839703381061554,
-0.02235051803290844,
0.44938740134239197,
-0.2595583498477936,
0.25420427322387695,
-0.0748952105641365,
-0.871017336845398,
0.4364513158798218,
0.06601543724536896,
0.3680626153945923,
-0.933525562286377,
0.14751367270946503,
0.14572519063949585,
0.13463082909584045,
0.49380573630332947,
0.05903790146112442,
-0.6217966675758362,
-0.4260966181755066,
0.153734490275383,
-0.15175436437129974,
-0.3204578161239624,
0.8622015714645386,
-0.9836820960044861,
0.3595357835292816,
0.1784166544675827,
0.7980723977088928,
0.4118507504463196,
-0.30598947405815125,
0.9446819424629211,
-0.13722074031829834,
0.06491612643003464,
0.2526438534259796,
0.5083516836166382,
0.5322672724723816,
-0.16243447363376617,
0.18409663438796997,
0.11286686360836029,
-0.5240429043769836,
-0.719146728515625,
0.08936464786529541,
-0.4766359329223633,
-0.34884321689605713,
0.9958860874176025,
-0.18000374734401703,
-0.22629015147686005,
-0.16782614588737488,
-0.2686430513858795,
0.05150322988629341,
-0.2756944000720978,
0.7903428673744202,
0.9254390001296997,
-0.0031372508965432644,
-0.14263100922107697,
-0.4524748623371124,
0.05456472188234329,
0.5532480478286743,
-0.677464485168457,
-0.05233718827366829,
0.5083014965057373,
0.7084360718727112,
0.0035757955629378557,
0.08156929165124893,
-0.006482167635113001,
0.07091113179922104,
-0.2640896141529083,
-0.04571071267127991,
-0.4705263674259186,
-0.2434941828250885,
-0.37984180450439453,
-0.04478119686245918,
-0.032416775822639465,
0.00015081677702255547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09205v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09205v2 | Tell Me More! Towards Implicit User Intention Understanding of Language Model Driven Agents | 2024-02-14T14:36:30 | 2024-02-15T09:59:52 | Cheng Qian, Bingxiang He, Zhong Zhuang, Jia Deng, Yujia Qin, Xin Cong, Zhong Zhang, Jie Zhou, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Current language model-driven agents often lack mechanisms for effective user
participation, which is crucial given the vagueness commonly found in user
instructions. Although adept at devising strategies and performing tasks, these
agents struggle with seeking clarification and grasping precise user
intentions. To bridge this gap, we introduce Intention-in-Interaction (IN3), a
novel benchmark designed to inspect users' implicit intentions through explicit
queries. Next, we propose the incorporation of model experts as the upstream in
agent designs to enhance user-agent interaction. Employing IN3, we empirically
train Mistral-Interact, a powerful model that proactively assesses task
vagueness, inquires user intentions, and refines them into actionable goals
before starting downstream agent task execution. Integrating it into the XAgent
framework, we comprehensively evaluate the enhanced agent system regarding user
instruction understanding and execution, revealing that our approach notably
excels at identifying vague user tasks, recovering and summarizing critical
missing information, setting precise and necessary agent execution goals, and
minimizing redundant tool usage, thus boosting overall efficiency. All the data
and codes are released. | [
-0.37044599652290344,
-0.3698148727416992,
1.135874629020691,
-0.06695199757814407,
0.21370196342468262,
-0.2742592692375183,
0.04115942493081093,
-0.6764525175094604,
-0.18995676934719086,
0.44209668040275574,
-0.7539265155792236,
-0.43830105662345886,
-0.3317223787307739,
-0.15430711209774017,
-0.6005887389183044,
0.8859964609146118,
-0.09630466252565384,
-0.05515088513493538,
-0.254763662815094,
0.14621952176094055,
-0.43402528762817383,
-0.24533778429031372,
-0.8590525984764099,
-0.3136511743068695,
0.3456093370914459,
0.6295883059501648,
0.8361603617668152,
0.247170090675354,
0.10502597689628601,
0.4082399010658264,
0.29277923703193665,
0.16049878299236298,
-0.6260738968849182,
0.0005131024518050253,
-0.2268379032611847,
-0.5161356925964355,
-0.5589847564697266,
0.22083823382854462,
0.42422133684158325,
0.5898526906967163,
0.18188391625881195,
0.024736007675528526,
0.18317009508609772,
0.22670485079288483,
-0.6890588402748108,
0.2687859535217285,
-0.2383268177509308,
-0.17718225717544556,
0.009094477631151676,
-0.03403136506676674,
-0.521136999130249,
-0.15999332070350647,
0.10817467421293259,
-0.7966009974479675,
0.16802459955215454,
-0.2537609040737152,
0.5718947649002075,
0.3740370571613312,
-0.5070260167121887,
-0.30219462513923645,
-0.6092462539672852,
0.6797512769699097,
-0.8452214598655701,
0.5066977739334106,
0.3485811650753021,
0.25731781125068665,
-0.46001821756362915,
-0.9618847370147705,
-0.8635286092758179,
-0.3104410767555237,
-0.3667435050010681,
-0.016346076503396034,
-0.4348606765270233,
0.44033950567245483,
0.3534972071647644,
-0.06809087842702866,
-0.5227744579315186,
-0.09331155568361282,
0.14470724761486053,
0.11706600338220596,
0.7773988842964172,
0.3253980875015259,
0.26415640115737915,
0.21709056198596954,
-0.3441827893257141,
0.014443389140069485,
-0.5290815830230713,
0.36684533953666687,
0.4963178336620331,
0.13237729668617249,
-0.06390918791294098,
0.4537944495677948,
-0.3917158842086792,
0.692806601524353,
0.19644857943058014,
0.45239803194999695,
0.04632242023944855,
-0.2708207964897156,
-0.10647467523813248,
-0.1632094383239746,
0.7171662449836731,
0.2300047129392624,
0.3381764590740204,
-0.22108390927314758,
-0.4960809350013733,
-0.40195366740226746,
0.309209942817688,
-0.8537704348564148,
0.05120871961116791,
0.5585306882858276,
-0.30152538418769836,
-0.006028702482581139,
0.20966877043247223,
-0.33772775530815125,
-0.492110013961792,
-0.37310391664505005,
0.5041006207466125,
-0.4176195561885834,
-0.313018798828125,
0.24777112901210785,
-0.24714380502700806,
0.28060758113861084,
0.5073947310447693,
-0.8279597759246826,
0.6136141419410706,
0.9711522459983826,
0.5138342976570129,
0.25792670249938965,
-0.6147247552871704,
-0.6665642857551575,
0.4864041805267334,
-0.15432152152061462,
0.6537394523620605,
-0.8270540237426758,
-0.36935219168663025,
0.025930779054760933,
-0.3123285174369812,
-0.15312397480010986,
-0.03889371454715729,
0.49464285373687744,
-0.48314452171325684,
0.20564812421798706,
-0.31172052025794983,
-0.5191189050674438,
-0.48678159713745117,
0.09970447421073914,
-0.43654146790504456,
1.0964051485061646,
0.3197283148765564,
-0.19522926211357117,
0.5619311332702637,
-0.9824784398078918,
-0.23154985904693604,
0.2438531517982483,
-0.18668894469738007,
0.22874772548675537,
0.3906576633453369,
0.05039888992905617,
0.5732882022857666,
-0.2141496241092682,
0.15287992358207703,
-0.21731039881706238,
-0.6274431943893433,
0.49539196491241455,
-0.4448687434196472,
0.3053050637245178,
-0.011860746890306473,
-0.5809339284896851,
0.34495168924331665,
-0.4967951774597168,
0.2333248257637024,
-0.31607353687286377,
0.1135539785027504,
-0.4748989939689636,
0.11748315393924713,
0.026112666353583336,
0.5428295135498047,
0.522070050239563,
-0.4016616642475128,
0.07272867858409882,
-0.4241759479045868,
0.16434818506240845,
0.8529776334762573,
0.0029903147369623184,
0.5068674087524414,
-0.09225430339574814,
0.4158998131752014,
-0.5164265036582947,
0.7471578121185303,
0.007909141480922699,
-0.4984002709388733,
-0.7752941846847534,
-0.15384307503700256,
-0.2775020897388458,
-0.05431811884045601,
-0.4406883418560028,
0.12233743071556091,
-0.3326188921928406,
-0.3490583896636963,
-0.5356124639511108,
0.1717543751001358,
0.6921908259391785,
0.332054078578949,
0.053926967084407806,
-0.17897716164588928,
-0.08232519775629044,
-0.8318769335746765,
-0.4713928699493408,
-0.4528350532054901,
0.06252846866846085,
0.5171846151351929,
0.5451374650001526,
-0.3596075475215912,
1.2807821035385132,
-0.5173594951629639,
-0.06908760964870453,
-0.4488392472267151,
0.2778235673904419,
0.15040260553359985,
0.3370104134082794,
0.48929911851882935,
-0.9485965967178345,
-0.8371667861938477,
0.49442291259765625,
-0.8657097220420837,
-0.06841924786567688,
-0.06271115690469742,
-0.0925154834985733,
0.05500505864620209,
0.43778786063194275,
-0.6752655506134033,
0.4984213709831238,
0.17274554073810577,
-0.3223452866077423,
0.12678757309913635,
-0.17842023074626923,
0.2623830735683441,
-0.5597386360168457,
0.07001876085996628,
-0.051668573170900345,
-0.3200315833091736,
-1.119894027709961,
0.01263613160699606,
0.18636064231395721,
0.052299194037914276,
-0.706462025642395,
1.0572370290756226,
-0.6378390789031982,
-0.0189875066280365,
-0.5124873518943787,
0.10580843687057495,
-0.0017864468973129988,
0.5477374792098999,
0.12355140596628189,
0.87013840675354,
0.3866446614265442,
-0.5469970107078552,
-0.2829127609729767,
0.1948004812002182,
0.03718813136219978,
0.4279153645038605,
-0.7971935868263245,
0.40255141258239746,
-0.11930669099092484,
-0.1860784888267517,
-1.0366202592849731,
-0.522267758846283,
0.578560471534729,
-0.5192506909370422,
0.2756779193878174,
-0.3319605886936188,
-0.523234486579895,
-0.08863861858844757,
-0.23715464770793915,
0.35330888628959656,
0.35952287912368774,
-0.5519057512283325,
0.7962979674339294,
0.2398662269115448,
0.07372938841581345,
-0.617036759853363,
-0.4975685179233551,
0.032989852130413055,
0.011342081241309643,
-0.7330148816108704,
0.06599879264831543,
0.07054515182971954,
-0.359578400850296,
0.06635762006044388,
-0.12333047389984131,
-0.24088799953460693,
0.007876155897974968,
0.5400838851928711,
-0.1260516345500946,
0.03993091732263565,
0.016286561265587807,
0.21132251620292664,
-0.2452523410320282,
0.2230842560529709,
-0.20273280143737793,
0.3895871341228485,
-0.11175788938999176,
-0.6193908452987671,
-0.9513303637504578,
0.4782392382621765,
0.44325873255729675,
-0.08214858919382095,
0.45135417580604553,
0.486041396856308,
-0.23977667093276978,
-0.058022577315568924,
-0.5371019244194031,
-0.3786817193031311,
-0.5412874221801758,
0.29649218916893005,
-0.6576460003852844,
-0.5948598384857178,
0.3492121696472168,
-0.2289046049118042,
0.17305848002433777,
0.19767498970031738,
0.1416543573141098,
-0.1575496345758438,
1.5161064863204956,
0.8946685791015625,
0.07204757630825043,
0.5350239276885986,
-0.20808851718902588,
0.030713966116309166,
-0.5891409516334534,
-0.1828802227973938,
-0.3445996046066284,
-0.17938543856143951,
-0.19483107328414917,
-0.35630086064338684,
0.3994666635990143,
-0.16462789475917816,
-0.02997661754488945,
0.23281697928905487,
-0.2596817910671234,
0.37171271443367004,
0.21484817564487457,
-0.03773267939686775,
0.18860729038715363,
-0.37328457832336426,
0.48631832003593445,
0.09833036363124847,
-0.36010125279426575,
-0.7103024125099182,
0.8890531659126282,
0.2716282904148102,
0.6921682953834534,
0.14920634031295776,
0.6371526122093201,
0.4603457450866699,
0.41108238697052,
-0.5471236109733582,
0.6125527620315552,
0.4350232183933258,
-0.5754684209823608,
-0.44157540798187256,
-0.12487167119979858,
-1.003532886505127,
0.3909091353416443,
0.16457869112491608,
-1.0312178134918213,
0.48962071537971497,
0.24784554541110992,
-0.16133219003677368,
-0.25660526752471924,
-0.9863167405128479,
1.0799634456634521,
-0.3455056846141815,
-0.5632414221763611,
-0.45401111245155334,
-0.5454075336456299,
0.3977051377296448,
-0.00499715143814683,
0.08301327377557755,
-0.06625054031610489,
-0.530920147895813,
0.36278432607650757,
-0.6403881311416626,
1.0005584955215454,
-0.48304131627082825,
-0.0657280758023262,
0.1172483041882515,
-0.16201536357402802,
0.9845336079597473,
-0.01652245782315731,
-0.3576338589191437,
0.03764636814594269,
-0.40742242336273193,
-0.2991640269756317,
-1.0514390468597412,
0.6696274280548096,
-0.6027445793151855,
-0.6870073080062866,
-0.33455735445022583,
-0.6829039454460144,
-0.2180788367986679,
0.26803719997406006,
-0.1150037944316864,
0.4488075077533722,
-0.5129907131195068,
-0.5046931505203247,
0.6353724002838135,
0.36590513586997986,
0.44824132323265076,
1.003491759300232,
-0.014142980799078941,
0.11435862630605698,
0.8371212482452393,
-0.2692926228046417,
0.3620288670063019,
0.4890097975730896,
0.024547770619392395,
-0.4207366406917572,
-0.6760391592979431,
-0.3624172806739807,
0.13044770061969757,
-0.7393096685409546,
0.2684001326560974,
-0.8935456871986389,
0.16920484602451324,
-0.2876141369342804,
-0.3010208010673523,
-0.1470453143119812,
-0.10471393167972565,
-0.22099824249744415,
0.14069654047489166,
0.38427668809890747,
1.273721694946289,
0.02237997204065323,
0.9172390103340149,
-0.5916875004768372,
-0.05431368947029114,
0.10367666929960251,
0.1302807629108429,
0.04551442712545395,
-0.41475799679756165,
-0.4309205710887909,
0.07082835584878922,
-0.04002217575907707,
-0.9187124967575073,
0.2937140464782715,
0.10334593057632446,
0.9551005959510803,
0.9095948934555054,
-0.02105845883488655,
0.6736463308334351,
-0.08590605109930038,
0.46132320165634155,
-0.17035266757011414,
-1.1583141088485718,
0.44167834520339966,
-0.25647953152656555,
0.17585299909114838,
0.7101696133613586,
0.647520899772644,
-0.5624425411224365,
-0.5276845693588257,
-0.6108040809631348,
-0.6936240196228027,
1.122903823852539,
0.36398664116859436,
0.09359591454267502,
0.3122060000896454,
0.5778602957725525,
0.4321398437023163,
0.26883089542388916,
-0.5159881114959717,
-0.3121914565563202,
0.15290740132331848,
-0.10606700927019119,
-0.12427636981010437,
-0.16089260578155518,
-0.021636847406625748,
-0.05999975651502609,
0.695636510848999,
-0.27394479513168335,
-0.0046324776485562325,
-0.058802999556064606,
-0.35257279872894287,
0.07208238542079926,
0.194148987531662,
0.4937952160835266,
0.6442762017250061,
-0.19176849722862244,
-0.03481987863779068,
0.05750678852200508,
-0.5192480683326721,
0.12926332652568817,
0.33460626006126404,
-0.09189850091934204,
-0.11787324398756027,
0.21238677203655243,
0.563753604888916,
0.29957178235054016,
-0.7960154414176941,
0.6902380585670471,
-0.5473837852478027,
0.16911502182483673,
-0.3279569447040558,
0.34545832872390747,
-0.19757820665836334,
0.2608449459075928,
0.214679554104805,
0.028468826785683632,
0.6573169231414795,
-0.3977559506893158,
0.05430995672941208,
0.482757031917572,
-0.9582529067993164,
-0.5478082895278931,
0.4877227544784546,
0.2888512909412384,
-0.15617212653160095,
0.36900657415390015,
-0.45587635040283203,
-0.24801822006702423,
0.23589390516281128,
0.21729835867881775,
1.1976271867752075,
-0.07634232193231583,
0.2661166489124298,
-0.005522111896425486,
0.32511645555496216,
0.1308489441871643,
0.7101241946220398,
-0.524109423160553,
-0.46606388688087463,
-0.32569199800491333,
-0.039953455328941345,
-0.384900838136673,
-0.017156079411506653,
-0.3820536136627197,
0.20223566889762878,
0.030938593670725822,
-0.008263718336820602,
0.04737060144543648,
-0.06640258431434631,
-0.7130048871040344,
0.04512771964073181,
-0.4449929893016815,
0.6693683862686157,
-0.7926686406135559,
0.6928129196166992,
0.6919711232185364,
-0.639526903629303,
-0.6609366536140442,
0.22189508378505707,
0.11280570179224014,
-0.6682232022285461,
0.525932252407074,
0.2588280737400055,
-0.39715778827667236,
0.05716346204280853,
-0.6626439690589905,
-0.8482718467712402,
0.8090750575065613,
0.38702842593193054,
-0.2740601897239685,
0.19827887415885925,
0.44387087225914,
0.4094558656215668,
-0.23642879724502563,
0.8397074937820435,
0.713506281375885,
0.8259416222572327,
-0.05293971672654152,
-0.48024967312812805,
0.20801787078380585,
-0.5161752104759216,
-0.30726394057273865,
0.3894044756889343,
-0.43694207072257996,
0.5975873470306396,
-0.20241226255893707,
-0.36724725365638733,
0.0996856763958931,
0.7438100576400757,
-0.07136553525924683,
0.5762795805931091,
0.49762213230133057,
0.14531566202640533,
0.7138383388519287,
0.14538733661174774,
1.3300144672393799,
-0.21060319244861603,
-0.165207639336586,
1.120559811592102,
-0.5169872641563416,
0.5321661829948425,
0.48346200585365295,
0.07610518485307693,
0.25723931193351746,
0.4774746894836426,
0.584290623664856,
0.31868159770965576,
-0.14965780079364777,
-0.5855355262756348,
-0.24566838145256042,
-0.40083494782447815,
-0.18044617772102356,
0.46213480830192566,
0.46001672744750977,
-0.058007389307022095,
-0.16695421934127808,
0.009564494714140892,
0.21364335715770721,
0.0637783408164978,
-0.2964344322681427,
0.8569770455360413,
-0.164841890335083,
-0.6736475229263306,
0.21514342725276947,
-0.2510581910610199,
0.3485613167285919,
-0.6961574554443359,
-0.29154476523399353,
-0.031726762652397156,
0.270146906375885,
-0.4325644373893738,
-1.0674753189086914,
-0.20755869150161743,
-0.03592078387737274,
-0.31163522601127625,
-0.30156955122947693,
0.7493922114372253,
-0.18358229100704193,
-0.07360333949327469,
0.2844545543193817,
0.5752729177474976,
0.6342412233352661,
-0.42990443110466003,
-0.5693385004997253,
-0.06547552347183228,
-0.06497327238321304,
-0.21399220824241638,
0.3206612467765808,
0.5956591367721558,
-0.30401313304901123,
0.7642133235931396,
0.540538489818573,
-0.18877768516540527,
-0.10823503136634827,
0.28101086616516113,
0.9409972429275513,
-0.45603933930397034,
-0.2835049629211426,
-0.6539191007614136,
0.7294355630874634,
-0.2848043441772461,
-0.3276078402996063,
0.8858368396759033,
0.6887689828872681,
0.9267346262931824,
0.10623453557491302,
0.9927071928977966,
-0.006713801063597202,
-0.01050794217735529,
-0.23231419920921326,
0.5335439443588257,
-0.7070993781089783,
0.2180587649345398,
-0.22425433993339539,
-0.5602588653564453,
0.2761543095111847,
0.03622673451900482,
-0.4358818829059601,
0.4129796624183655,
0.387875497341156,
1.0242806673049927,
-0.1617654263973236,
0.009172127582132816,
0.5413920283317566,
-0.07422252744436264,
0.3482913672924042,
0.44194793701171875,
1.2959342002868652,
-0.2624721825122833,
0.47109144926071167,
-0.23398639261722565,
-0.47387510538101196,
-0.2646234929561615,
-0.49696022272109985,
-0.9331508278846741,
-0.7350256443023682,
-0.07736698538064957,
0.16558726131916046,
0.33107709884643555,
0.8681909441947937,
0.8507193922996521,
-0.4215054214000702,
-0.457527220249176,
-0.3150925934314728,
0.25116685032844543,
-0.5308473110198975,
-0.22677333652973175,
0.1494053155183792,
-0.6204090118408203,
-1.0453444719314575,
0.4960227906703949,
0.3452140986919403,
0.11496672034263611,
-0.24229313433170319,
-0.4735570251941681,
-0.038388486951589584,
0.16868773102760315,
0.4198664426803589,
0.5558122396469116,
-0.5710612535476685,
-0.1458447426557541,
-0.1323864459991455,
-0.21497441828250885,
-0.23321393132209778,
0.9566587209701538,
-0.7150837182998657,
0.526002824306488,
0.4881414771080017,
0.16897498071193695,
0.5379476547241211,
0.04375527799129486,
0.9280602931976318,
-0.6140989661216736,
0.014123683795332909,
0.20065957307815552,
0.1759551614522934,
-0.06602898985147476,
-0.8226680159568787,
0.4773580729961395,
-0.48214802145957947,
-0.549400269985199,
-0.7280264496803284,
0.13579010963439941,
-0.8531239628791809,
-0.26607364416122437,
1.0570909976959229,
-0.1162075623869896,
-0.3004228472709656,
-0.614238440990448,
-0.3627985417842865,
0.020495614036917686,
-0.9571318030357361,
0.3229939639568329,
0.11587392538785934,
-0.6375556588172913,
-0.032558418810367584,
-0.7469911575317383,
0.9111263751983643,
0.23187965154647827,
-0.9186100959777832,
0.17143724858760834,
0.5194602012634277,
-0.17760033905506134,
-0.2017958164215088,
0.8172773718833923,
0.20648112893104553,
0.6930911540985107,
-0.0031141110230237246,
0.52454674243927,
-0.11653124541044235,
-0.3588387370109558,
-0.33460888266563416,
0.012857184745371342,
0.3468327820301056,
-0.10116676986217499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09199v1 | Ten Words Only Still Help: Improving Black-Box AI-Generated Text Detection via Proxy-Guided Efficient Re-Sampling | 2024-02-14T14:32:16 | 2024-02-14T14:32:16 | Yuhui Shi, Qiang Sheng, Juan Cao, Hao Mi, Beizhe Hu, Danding Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the rapidly increasing application of large language models (LLMs),
their abuse has caused many undesirable societal problems such as fake news,
academic dishonesty, and information pollution. This makes AI-generated text
(AIGT) detection of great importance. Among existing methods, white-box methods
are generally superior to black-box methods in terms of performance and
generalizability, but they require access to LLMs' internal states and are not
applicable to black-box settings. In this paper, we propose to estimate word
generation probabilities as pseudo white-box features via multiple re-sampling
to help improve AIGT detection under the black-box setting. Specifically, we
design POGER, a proxy-guided efficient re-sampling method, which selects a
small subset of representative words (e.g., 10 words) for performing multiple
re-sampling in black-box AIGT detection. Experiments on datasets containing
texts from humans and seven LLMs show that POGER outperforms all baselines in
macro F1 under black-box, partial white-box, and out-of-distribution settings
and maintains lower re-sampling costs than its existing counterparts. | [
-0.5238592028617859,
-1.0429059267044067,
0.7313216328620911,
-0.07475639879703522,
-0.47331637144088745,
0.15292929112911224,
-0.019913602620363235,
-0.4025745391845703,
0.33649855852127075,
0.5310409665107727,
-0.3871040344238281,
-0.5212598443031311,
-0.6968699097633362,
0.28513914346694946,
-0.6612208485603333,
0.9889489412307739,
0.07294650375843048,
-0.31729114055633545,
0.07703455537557602,
0.042173970490694046,
-0.3372509181499481,
-0.40214911103248596,
-0.7128487229347229,
-0.08770593255758286,
0.2768520712852478,
0.24740485846996307,
0.4563297927379608,
0.4187321364879608,
0.11935730278491974,
0.32714948058128357,
-0.30246132612228394,
0.5352277159690857,
-0.49626195430755615,
-0.0981823205947876,
-0.00667315861210227,
-0.31442442536354065,
-0.2664785087108612,
0.14417824149131775,
0.5543272495269775,
0.108496755361557,
-0.21301788091659546,
0.2981466054916382,
-0.027017472311854362,
0.21034911274909973,
-0.7288809418678284,
-0.15493083000183105,
-0.7870410084724426,
-0.08531580865383148,
-0.4128924608230591,
0.0062429094687104225,
-0.3060087561607361,
-0.05911312624812126,
0.0485018752515316,
-0.5969964265823364,
0.5211440920829773,
0.2922024130821228,
0.8279626369476318,
0.19288435578346252,
-0.13300910592079163,
-0.21247000992298126,
-0.2860262989997864,
0.6138774156570435,
-0.7979415655136108,
0.19424021244049072,
0.5303810834884644,
0.24028386175632477,
-0.47110244631767273,
-0.9555984139442444,
-0.9812570214271545,
-0.38185131549835205,
-0.1330835521221161,
0.010977334342896938,
-0.40942853689193726,
-0.2889333665370941,
0.13155537843704224,
0.15455371141433716,
-0.28086036443710327,
-0.1749940663576126,
-0.3134295344352722,
-0.5989126563072205,
0.6823001503944397,
-0.02212921716272831,
0.4031444191932678,
-0.007619075942784548,
-0.1367930918931961,
-0.37722688913345337,
-0.7071288824081421,
-0.08461026847362518,
0.6986443400382996,
0.009741287678480148,
0.06413325667381287,
0.35627636313438416,
-0.08296588063240051,
0.7702821493148804,
0.08276797831058502,
-0.2543933689594269,
0.3562285304069519,
-0.30934861302375793,
-0.03189850598573685,
0.023148898035287857,
0.9278272986412048,
-0.012500579468905926,
0.33551064133644104,
-0.02868974767625332,
-0.2443925440311432,
0.2386465221643448,
0.6315352916717529,
-0.648636519908905,
-0.3609161376953125,
-0.08067288994789124,
-0.4625212550163269,
-0.4210669994354248,
0.19336648285388947,
-1.111380696296692,
-0.5389757752418518,
0.1411110758781433,
0.47564998269081116,
-0.18893444538116455,
-0.39730948209762573,
0.2079092562198639,
-0.39420777559280396,
0.023252049461007118,
0.21406714618206024,
-0.15641556680202484,
-0.1064034029841423,
0.3834392726421356,
0.7306760549545288,
0.011574146337807178,
-0.30171823501586914,
-0.970203697681427,
-0.04826758801937103,
-0.37677261233329773,
1.0697101354599,
-0.6157947778701782,
-0.4081009328365326,
0.1297781765460968,
0.20707201957702637,
0.5306927561759949,
-0.6749654412269592,
0.370182067155838,
-0.19707338511943817,
0.1912628412246704,
-0.08165299147367477,
-0.25422602891921997,
0.16844360530376434,
0.17303720116615295,
-0.6150603294372559,
1.0771710872650146,
-0.0891595259308815,
-0.7402348518371582,
0.438554048538208,
-0.29320093989372253,
-0.5391066074371338,
0.2579961121082306,
-0.31535860896110535,
-0.9378525614738464,
0.597693681716919,
0.34755197167396545,
0.26488974690437317,
-0.11577185243368149,
0.3882553279399872,
-0.3182404935359955,
-0.6124612092971802,
-0.021663786843419075,
-0.5161669254302979,
0.41056057810783386,
0.178239107131958,
-0.549584686756134,
0.021846218034625053,
-0.7164722681045532,
-0.1743890941143036,
0.23902824521064758,
-0.3010627031326294,
-0.391319215297699,
0.12971794605255127,
-0.17669014632701874,
-0.059852566570043564,
-0.10370045900344849,
-0.8369258046150208,
-0.04491778463125229,
-0.20985810458660126,
0.2914055585861206,
0.6190438866615295,
0.016978396102786064,
0.2677483558654785,
-0.27980878949165344,
0.7800055742263794,
-0.03523179888725281,
-0.24285870790481567,
-0.28175461292266846,
-0.7614087462425232,
-0.44270482659339905,
-0.44589054584503174,
0.22085386514663696,
0.45824873447418213,
-1.319289207458496,
0.5301995873451233,
0.003123460803180933,
-0.4237878620624542,
-0.8021548986434937,
0.23461151123046875,
0.5756632089614868,
0.3684665262699127,
0.38233354687690735,
-0.09528976678848267,
-0.001189816277474165,
-0.9704581499099731,
-0.5424765944480896,
-0.26599377393722534,
-0.2516344487667084,
0.11527654528617859,
0.4703964293003082,
-0.21662433445453644,
0.7848916053771973,
-0.8209205865859985,
-0.47195965051651,
-0.09658541530370712,
0.47550052404403687,
-0.27658504247665405,
0.00029716402059420943,
0.5018812417984009,
-0.7329637408256531,
-0.283088743686676,
-0.47037702798843384,
-0.4101930260658264,
-0.6023569703102112,
-0.06687914580106735,
-0.35123342275619507,
-0.06166389584541321,
0.8958706259727478,
-0.00046284738346002996,
0.7471777200698853,
0.5006529092788696,
-0.44186124205589294,
0.4333838224411011,
-0.3194904923439026,
-0.1694827526807785,
-0.8901419043540955,
-0.1447276473045349,
0.3289019763469696,
-0.25658759474754333,
-0.6338412761688232,
-0.08272239565849304,
0.28208982944488525,
-0.0829557329416275,
-0.5710698366165161,
1.0131031274795532,
-0.6557998657226562,
0.4280581772327423,
-0.722528338432312,
0.316407710313797,
-0.053197529166936874,
0.20385907590389252,
0.05274670198559761,
1.0313292741775513,
0.23969750106334686,
-0.4835168123245239,
0.1664896011352539,
0.24732603132724762,
-0.4665347635746002,
0.630591630935669,
-0.5091803669929504,
0.11562009155750275,
-0.5102757215499878,
0.43301868438720703,
-1.2142682075500488,
0.10644616931676865,
0.3354171812534332,
-0.5690089464187622,
0.2786670923233032,
0.33499401807785034,
-0.43778878450393677,
-0.3603055477142334,
-0.5507668256759644,
0.1723955124616623,
0.4991598427295685,
-0.6813593506813049,
0.3848613500595093,
0.6501728296279907,
0.12706425786018372,
-0.5308175086975098,
-0.6896547079086304,
0.2033778727054596,
-0.1331292688846588,
-0.26001763343811035,
0.42361176013946533,
0.24714358150959015,
-0.12620948255062103,
0.2577773630619049,
-0.2707666754722595,
0.2620466947555542,
0.13151809573173523,
-0.12790803611278534,
-0.06012457236647606,
0.18782927095890045,
0.20601233839988708,
0.026539335027337074,
-0.12680916488170624,
-0.09823237359523773,
-0.2802678942680359,
0.5745320916175842,
0.18761484324932098,
-0.16696599125862122,
-0.2589551508426666,
0.3445555567741394,
0.32834118604660034,
-0.3724253475666046,
0.8366153836250305,
1.0382508039474487,
-0.42401203513145447,
-0.6809249520301819,
-0.5216125845909119,
-0.3011365830898285,
-0.4766119718551636,
0.39664754271507263,
-0.35599085688591003,
-0.8380522131919861,
0.2971017360687256,
0.09281054139137268,
0.07917793095111847,
0.22321133315563202,
0.40601491928100586,
-0.06662525236606598,
0.7897526025772095,
0.5415933132171631,
-0.2293437123298645,
0.8185189366340637,
-0.12115217745304108,
0.5594012141227722,
-0.8277974128723145,
0.014485334046185017,
-0.439861536026001,
-0.45744678378105164,
-0.6289107203483582,
-0.02116449549794197,
0.5055060386657715,
0.04897557199001312,
0.006644976790994406,
0.3177168369293213,
-0.784325122833252,
0.19921572506427765,
0.8688867092132568,
0.3410789668560028,
0.054018598049879074,
0.38857460021972656,
-0.08484586328268051,
0.3190917670726776,
-0.4551261365413666,
-0.482209712266922,
1.0097765922546387,
0.11381237953901291,
0.7615079879760742,
0.0321786105632782,
0.8139858245849609,
0.46886926889419556,
0.8055047392845154,
-0.4020015597343445,
0.6265978813171387,
-0.4069700837135315,
-0.6187019348144531,
-0.2555445432662964,
-0.3916202187538147,
-0.9779688715934753,
0.21605126559734344,
-0.3600415587425232,
-0.7243403792381287,
-0.03791902959346771,
0.411772757768631,
-0.23632387816905975,
0.4367366433143616,
-0.6463726162910461,
0.5267212986946106,
-0.16575732827186584,
-0.4039902091026306,
0.10262984782457352,
-0.13226740062236786,
0.40156906843185425,
-0.42554864287376404,
0.1995551884174347,
-0.10037849843502045,
-0.231051966547966,
0.6458250284194946,
-0.44438058137893677,
0.7902170419692993,
-0.39682015776634216,
-0.2543155550956726,
0.6703431606292725,
-0.13643315434455872,
0.7393209338188171,
0.05533343926072121,
0.2433277666568756,
0.2630535066127777,
-0.21342064440250397,
-0.3228479325771332,
-0.22373518347740173,
0.47842881083488464,
-0.5672387480735779,
-0.8907673954963684,
-0.4334106743335724,
-0.16532301902770996,
0.006293454207479954,
-0.04266511648893356,
0.6127602458000183,
0.3472430109977722,
0.3159729838371277,
0.236058309674263,
0.3583301603794098,
-0.8645244836807251,
0.49229931831359863,
0.5061505436897278,
-0.04303191229701042,
-0.6241394281387329,
1.041861891746521,
0.019047537818551064,
0.08213091641664505,
0.3191694915294647,
0.36324259638786316,
-0.5299063920974731,
-0.582895040512085,
-0.5481328964233398,
0.3736205995082855,
-0.19114123284816742,
-0.42792683839797974,
-0.758050262928009,
-0.06803280115127563,
-0.36233407258987427,
-0.16960188746452332,
0.06734355539083481,
0.3023657202720642,
-0.2122318297624588,
-0.111258365213871,
0.3132516145706177,
0.36870649456977844,
0.21798144280910492,
0.8707907795906067,
-0.6526725888252258,
0.8252981901168823,
0.29885414242744446,
0.252404123544693,
-0.09108637273311615,
-0.6557073593139648,
0.06343695521354675,
-0.09216853231191635,
-0.38057005405426025,
-1.1348544359207153,
0.49251899123191833,
0.16605988144874573,
0.7280428409576416,
0.18922576308250427,
0.23597808182239532,
0.7479053139686584,
-0.5483452081680298,
0.827445387840271,
-0.010268205776810646,
-0.8174001574516296,
0.3525445759296417,
-0.009633520618081093,
0.4645940959453583,
0.4686531126499176,
0.023151487112045288,
-0.5528753399848938,
-0.8764963150024414,
-0.7986263632774353,
-0.8274849653244019,
0.718390166759491,
0.24393358826637268,
0.3793823719024658,
-0.40018197894096375,
0.5524128675460815,
-0.09919071197509766,
0.5971760153770447,
-0.7140629887580872,
-0.25470051169395447,
-0.20292139053344727,
-0.3982866406440735,
-0.1770559847354889,
-0.37116140127182007,
0.22339142858982086,
0.2925224304199219,
0.7565995454788208,
-0.21716605126857758,
0.5364939570426941,
0.19792841374874115,
-0.10473641753196716,
0.08540640026330948,
0.12985347211360931,
0.5754140615463257,
0.22604325413703918,
-0.047268886119127274,
0.3671046495437622,
0.14687496423721313,
-0.8149328827857971,
0.42082032561302185,
0.017860047519207,
-0.503512442111969,
0.1415654569864273,
0.5542016625404358,
0.5224747061729431,
-0.1280284970998764,
-0.7396852374076843,
0.5213626027107239,
-0.15178140997886658,
-0.20483683049678802,
-0.3088052570819855,
0.18550415337085724,
-0.003481720108538866,
0.11310586333274841,
0.399257630109787,
-0.5386224985122681,
-0.06076608970761299,
-0.5320749878883362,
0.4617440700531006,
0.7876669764518738,
-0.05598888546228409,
-0.04863616079092026,
0.8122432827949524,
0.15454606711864471,
-0.7408168315887451,
0.45765334367752075,
-0.7515437006950378,
-0.47116294503211975,
0.5954051613807678,
0.7181196808815002,
0.9436429738998413,
-0.023201974108815193,
0.3887035846710205,
0.22909240424633026,
0.32964521646499634,
-0.4329259693622589,
0.30967527627944946,
0.045076966285705566,
-1.0101927518844604,
-0.28302276134490967,
-0.8675565123558044,
-0.11551839858293533,
0.8342695832252502,
-0.30969250202178955,
0.35309696197509766,
-0.35640275478363037,
-0.42406120896339417,
0.047929245978593826,
0.014079893007874489,
-0.5163169503211975,
0.06695606559515,
0.2331227958202362,
0.8159435987472534,
-0.9786636233329773,
0.7261171340942383,
0.9874582886695862,
-0.17140087485313416,
-0.5654988884925842,
0.31861355900764465,
0.30473610758781433,
-0.804233193397522,
0.06318257749080658,
0.1177251935005188,
-0.2411097139120102,
0.1094970628619194,
-0.6617093086242676,
-0.5731901526451111,
0.8264467120170593,
0.16621941328048706,
-0.7206400036811829,
0.06508935987949371,
-0.2422388643026352,
0.5465344786643982,
-0.056431688368320465,
0.18266230821609497,
0.6967671513557434,
0.5705752372741699,
-0.18896935880184174,
-0.4404408037662506,
-0.14974381029605865,
-0.21843430399894714,
0.010758775286376476,
0.6050306558609009,
-0.5375272631645203,
0.5108410120010376,
0.2165503054857254,
-0.37270426750183105,
-0.05277365818619728,
0.5326731204986572,
0.6787054538726807,
0.3804888129234314,
0.777932345867157,
0.5964645743370056,
0.5944307446479797,
-0.07655351608991623,
1.002134084701538,
-0.3139066696166992,
-0.01088066678494215,
0.9193923473358154,
0.0004519826907198876,
0.5641912221908569,
0.16911262273788452,
-0.16069097816944122,
0.07961797714233398,
0.38147780299186707,
-0.16623356938362122,
0.500072717666626,
0.639691948890686,
-0.36279675364494324,
-0.07868405431509018,
-0.07366111129522324,
-0.03842436894774437,
0.4822518527507782,
0.21596887707710266,
-0.3369789123535156,
-0.28789883852005005,
0.12569929659366608,
0.3570598065853119,
0.3238615393638611,
-0.23643821477890015,
0.807677149772644,
0.046936750411987305,
-0.7346799373626709,
0.3299448788166046,
0.11496949195861816,
1.1596930027008057,
-0.4803909361362457,
-0.08556438237428665,
-0.41605445742607117,
0.2362338751554489,
0.030090853571891785,
-0.6601787805557251,
0.1562611311674118,
0.16576512157917023,
0.15868233144283295,
-0.15685036778450012,
0.9153795838356018,
-0.7395479679107666,
-0.7439208626747131,
0.26393193006515503,
0.7285277247428894,
0.16398783028125763,
-0.4170849323272705,
-0.28821656107902527,
-0.06005104258656502,
0.18198084831237793,
-0.14229190349578857,
0.32566383481025696,
0.5388988256454468,
-0.3674790561199188,
0.374506413936615,
0.7155585289001465,
0.6594309210777283,
0.16158676147460938,
-0.23537951707839966,
0.48543718457221985,
-0.7022184133529663,
-0.4986773729324341,
-0.9529604315757751,
0.2411440759897232,
-0.18130725622177124,
-0.31615936756134033,
0.4753504991531372,
0.12535524368286133,
1.138018012046814,
0.031774554401636124,
0.8859127759933472,
-0.036139559000730515,
0.30469176173210144,
-0.3248293697834015,
0.7287037968635559,
-0.7802945375442505,
0.12938719987869263,
-0.31142789125442505,
-0.9376973509788513,
-0.05918562784790993,
0.6701347827911377,
-0.28515711426734924,
-0.14417721331119537,
0.5200535655021667,
0.8979394435882568,
0.07755205780267715,
-0.23732782900333405,
0.44289055466651917,
-0.14804387092590332,
0.7996340990066528,
0.24833574891090393,
0.7520226836204529,
-0.1605905145406723,
0.7530298233032227,
-0.08453201502561569,
-0.26230329275131226,
-0.055713146924972534,
-0.9616187214851379,
-0.8012798428535461,
-0.4738253057003021,
-0.23949401080608368,
-0.19996459782123566,
-0.070765919983387,
0.41432061791419983,
0.6005045771598816,
-0.7597854137420654,
0.1608412116765976,
0.09815660864114761,
-0.0033816336654126644,
-0.25202399492263794,
-0.18918974697589874,
0.4189109802246094,
-0.24354809522628784,
-0.8269995450973511,
0.22383414208889008,
0.0885452851653099,
-0.05977146327495575,
-0.12883137166500092,
0.2385634183883667,
-0.10127659142017365,
0.019059164449572563,
0.4828123450279236,
0.05332154408097267,
-0.6230884790420532,
-0.4965053200721741,
-0.17129258811473846,
0.10987533628940582,
-0.30812928080558777,
0.730177104473114,
-0.98014897108078,
0.4825902581214905,
0.47727447748184204,
0.8766067028045654,
0.4007614850997925,
0.4305451512336731,
0.43776440620422363,
-0.9131450057029724,
0.2623116672039032,
-0.07903409004211426,
0.3928976058959961,
0.19218434393405914,
-0.3093825578689575,
0.4438599944114685,
0.3335304856300354,
-0.2982490360736847,
-0.8808538317680359,
0.19588106870651245,
-0.09646767377853394,
-0.5393533110618591,
1.2585500478744507,
-0.012036627158522606,
-0.2925798296928406,
-0.14860939979553223,
-0.324593186378479,
0.23040513694286346,
-0.6305992007255554,
0.9016560912132263,
0.8021713495254517,
0.07817956805229187,
-0.4256148636341095,
-0.5935711860656738,
0.6148114800453186,
0.10593993216753006,
-0.9295626282691956,
-0.20076067745685577,
0.6367737650871277,
0.16012124717235565,
0.3440224826335907,
0.7361211180686951,
0.04527701437473297,
-0.02477271668612957,
-0.05635394901037216,
-0.005360351875424385,
-0.3828860819339752,
-0.45203542709350586,
-0.2708316743373871,
0.28287768363952637,
-0.27671384811401367,
-0.5136115550994873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09193v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09193v2 | (Ir)rationality and Cognitive Biases in Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T14:17:21 | 2024-02-15T11:09:09 | Olivia Macmillan-Scott, Mirco Musolesi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Do large language models (LLMs) display rational reasoning? LLMs have been
shown to contain human biases due to the data they have been trained on;
whether this is reflected in rational reasoning remains less clear. In this
paper, we answer this question by evaluating seven language models using tasks
from the cognitive psychology literature. We find that, like humans, LLMs
display irrationality in these tasks. However, the way this irrationality is
displayed does not reflect that shown by humans. When incorrect answers are
given by LLMs to these tasks, they are often incorrect in ways that differ from
human-like biases. On top of this, the LLMs reveal an additional layer of
irrationality in the significant inconsistency of the responses. Aside from the
experimental results, this paper seeks to make a methodological contribution by
showing how we can assess and compare different capabilities of these types of
models, in this case with respect to rational reasoning. | [
-0.5310888290405273,
-0.7751959562301636,
0.9411617517471313,
0.17760679125785828,
0.1410771906375885,
-0.06762097775936127,
-0.6547827124595642,
-0.4963943064212799,
-0.07265593856573105,
0.4792425036430359,
-0.5857952237129211,
-0.03588135167956352,
-0.6679004430770874,
0.19247138500213623,
-0.011430763639509678,
0.5604941844940186,
0.048552244901657104,
0.5418601036071777,
-0.3911898732185364,
-0.3554581105709076,
-0.5387181043624878,
-0.8110925555229187,
-0.5127826929092407,
-0.6972383856773376,
0.34302157163619995,
0.4045797288417816,
0.8766284584999084,
0.3055942952632904,
0.34057801961898804,
0.3273254930973053,
0.06375803798437119,
-0.14129236340522766,
-0.4242427349090576,
0.16735342144966125,
-0.43262723088264465,
-0.6507159471511841,
-0.288812518119812,
0.35892459750175476,
0.3970930278301239,
0.7263889312744141,
0.2115246057510376,
0.08768210560083389,
-0.24191640317440033,
0.7230485081672668,
-0.4392625391483307,
0.16367372870445251,
-0.6787439584732056,
-0.10865280777215958,
0.08153924345970154,
0.0011677811853587627,
-0.7544805407524109,
-0.205253005027771,
0.22105731070041656,
-0.5042093992233276,
-0.06896773725748062,
0.31871297955513,
0.45854610204696655,
0.1252395063638687,
-0.6776223182678223,
-0.5101442337036133,
-0.8599385619163513,
1.2049280405044556,
-0.9039643406867981,
0.3121322989463806,
0.5495745539665222,
0.280205637216568,
-0.13229286670684814,
-0.11993584781885147,
-0.7677341103553772,
-0.9994339346885681,
0.029838066548109055,
-0.05658892169594765,
0.0021974837873131037,
0.027441387996077538,
0.8304039835929871,
0.20959314703941345,
-0.46138685941696167,
0.1416638344526291,
-0.12288696318864822,
-0.13949953019618988,
0.8100801706314087,
0.08516543358564377,
0.27284976840019226,
-0.01796787977218628,
-0.28075650334358215,
-0.2660728394985199,
-0.5452021360397339,
-0.07443782687187195,
0.5299127697944641,
-0.12702207267284393,
0.2248452603816986,
1.0696594715118408,
-0.2741687297821045,
0.528862714767456,
0.03925163671374321,
-0.25379323959350586,
-0.13963904976844788,
0.10740119963884354,
-0.23221196234226227,
-0.19153931736946106,
0.5185717344284058,
0.43666982650756836,
0.9116904139518738,
0.011503515765070915,
-0.4425782263278961,
0.5568194389343262,
0.11041469871997833,
-0.3270265460014343,
0.05956556275486946,
0.19399946928024292,
-0.4589998424053192,
-0.08393654972314835,
-0.2890036404132843,
-0.19800430536270142,
-0.6395776271820068,
-0.5988985300064087,
0.2234332114458084,
-0.4624328017234802,
-0.2479299008846283,
0.2443072646856308,
-0.11428245902061462,
0.2046772986650467,
0.48518839478492737,
-0.8232471346855164,
0.36059078574180603,
0.6913102269172668,
0.19366231560707092,
-0.09198608994483948,
-0.23679986596107483,
-0.12350942194461823,
-0.13069316744804382,
-0.33311665058135986,
0.8815191984176636,
-0.7384319305419922,
-0.23391111195087433,
-0.010827743448317051,
-0.11427517235279083,
-0.08666820824146271,
-0.7540750503540039,
0.7117995023727417,
-0.597987174987793,
0.21685713529586792,
-0.7260296940803528,
-0.7453262805938721,
-0.47165223956108093,
0.47225847840309143,
-0.5707228183746338,
0.6451987624168396,
0.13384908437728882,
-0.7444315552711487,
0.19915631413459778,
-0.43978258967399597,
-0.08657364547252655,
-0.14572949707508087,
-0.392928808927536,
0.12350495159626007,
0.142885223031044,
0.033315740525722504,
0.31037670373916626,
-0.6200478672981262,
0.3783571124076843,
-0.7903881072998047,
-0.20163896679878235,
1.0220896005630493,
-0.6486740708351135,
0.9240463972091675,
0.19124794006347656,
-0.4126709997653961,
0.18169644474983215,
-0.5139380097389221,
0.1239376813173294,
0.20541730523109436,
-0.37430712580680847,
-0.3367483615875244,
0.203351691365242,
0.04294446483254433,
0.47830456495285034,
0.18072816729545593,
-0.43846064805984497,
0.520996630191803,
-0.13660845160484314,
0.5885984301567078,
0.8065158128738403,
-0.35962560772895813,
0.5964648127555847,
-0.7889754772186279,
0.4887124300003052,
0.05024970322847366,
-0.00231815199367702,
0.22793595492839813,
-0.5728800296783447,
-0.885674238204956,
-0.19755896925926208,
0.0033193062990903854,
0.7386074066162109,
-0.38804107904434204,
0.26278752088546753,
-0.17105408012866974,
-0.41857969760894775,
-0.13991105556488037,
0.03905026987195015,
0.252590149641037,
0.4453314244747162,
0.07421877235174179,
-0.02987731620669365,
-0.3804132342338562,
-1.3221274614334106,
-0.5808249711990356,
-0.299899697303772,
-0.14231158792972565,
0.34563711285591125,
0.6013103723526001,
-0.3207957446575165,
0.7349106669425964,
-0.24913817644119263,
0.028918830677866936,
-0.2001451700925827,
0.18873190879821777,
-0.15994596481323242,
0.41748714447021484,
0.36601579189300537,
-0.3908703625202179,
-0.08958424627780914,
-0.0636998638510704,
-0.9377077221870422,
-0.13097421824932098,
-0.08592629432678223,
-0.007209863513708115,
0.6172289252281189,
0.2958197295665741,
-0.9826667308807373,
0.29421132802963257,
0.29406213760375977,
-0.492673397064209,
0.714719295501709,
-0.0804472491145134,
0.18910858035087585,
-0.4997507929801941,
-0.03722592070698738,
0.25708669424057007,
-0.0912836566567421,
-0.5149922966957092,
-0.24909774959087372,
-0.03974292427301407,
0.31992998719215393,
-0.10770527273416519,
0.5880521535873413,
-0.42375171184539795,
-0.3068140745162964,
-0.2366984486579895,
0.24548909068107605,
0.043806955218315125,
0.515691339969635,
0.0721796303987503,
0.46039047837257385,
0.3534367084503174,
-0.25221845507621765,
0.3637884855270386,
-0.38505998253822327,
-0.41075605154037476,
0.475980669260025,
-0.4487723708152771,
0.1874905228614807,
-0.360621839761734,
0.4510178864002228,
-0.8949734568595886,
-0.39690205454826355,
0.15677960216999054,
-0.43964052200317383,
-0.03603136166930199,
0.13491077721118927,
-0.5078273415565491,
-0.3477727770805359,
-0.25912046432495117,
0.5538612008094788,
0.6117557287216187,
-0.19956472516059875,
0.6050920486450195,
0.2627917230129242,
-0.07221728563308716,
-0.5603556036949158,
-0.7357916235923767,
-0.3013020157814026,
-0.31051507592201233,
-0.8923934698104858,
-0.15872222185134888,
-0.28476476669311523,
-1.0857689380645752,
-0.19985835254192352,
-0.04098701849579811,
-0.1522357016801834,
-0.034577593207359314,
0.1832226812839508,
0.4487188160419464,
-0.39331358671188354,
0.11431637406349182,
-0.2933567464351654,
0.25555485486984253,
0.42638352513313293,
-0.12329071760177612,
0.5886673927307129,
-0.36245328187942505,
-0.6228911876678467,
-0.46122097969055176,
0.34068089723587036,
0.9458755254745483,
0.010303759016096592,
0.6676986813545227,
0.09434731304645538,
-0.5176154971122742,
0.020615512505173683,
-1.0920352935791016,
-0.34591612219810486,
-0.37231341004371643,
0.18391990661621094,
-0.17803718149662018,
-0.995693027973175,
0.7296578884124756,
0.198265939950943,
-0.07984393835067749,
0.5847370028495789,
0.7892454862594604,
-0.030046051368117332,
1.4831438064575195,
0.15872563421726227,
0.11913342028856277,
0.22836782038211823,
-0.16853690147399902,
0.17427751421928406,
-0.8087368011474609,
-0.2718173861503601,
-0.4681256115436554,
-0.07401470094919205,
-0.5253987908363342,
-0.35190126299858093,
-0.06560555100440979,
0.18684564530849457,
-0.6611303687095642,
-0.2240930050611496,
-0.3281613290309906,
0.5607525110244751,
0.3130865693092346,
-0.13739603757858276,
0.40120652318000793,
-0.10821844637393951,
0.03802250325679779,
-0.1864989697933197,
-0.6633272767066956,
-1.0856842994689941,
0.9799833297729492,
0.500751256942749,
0.6816868185997009,
0.04333795607089996,
0.015116995200514793,
0.3642447888851166,
0.8974181413650513,
-0.8976117372512817,
0.6704867482185364,
0.3606405258178711,
-0.89432293176651,
-0.35478222370147705,
-0.43023285269737244,
-0.5859681367874146,
0.49959176778793335,
-0.4492679834365845,
-0.7630547881126404,
0.09606991708278656,
0.12128695100545883,
-0.005699194967746735,
0.24606719613075256,
-0.9394650459289551,
0.6330934762954712,
-0.3829291760921478,
-0.2030009925365448,
-0.4355242848396301,
-0.1902078539133072,
0.897646427154541,
0.0030088205821812153,
0.37092968821525574,
-0.3491586446762085,
-0.0038673141971230507,
0.750377893447876,
-0.12315140664577484,
0.6968225836753845,
-0.10000255703926086,
-0.19768312573432922,
0.2436724752187729,
0.21373777091503143,
0.49686697125434875,
0.2777158319950104,
-0.2113531231880188,
-0.028517847880721092,
-0.03423912078142166,
-0.6763094067573547,
-0.6504744291305542,
0.8636146187782288,
-0.8756939172744751,
-0.9416909217834473,
-0.6520348787307739,
-0.8295913934707642,
-0.42953088879585266,
0.29629698395729065,
0.1280931532382965,
0.38183140754699707,
-0.23419252038002014,
-0.11780717223882675,
0.6180161237716675,
-0.3459325134754181,
0.16764609515666962,
0.4338074326515198,
-0.31641194224357605,
-0.18610771000385284,
0.5288638472557068,
0.32097533345222473,
0.52711021900177,
-0.06780543923377991,
0.056050512939691544,
-0.3562459349632263,
-0.3655715584754944,
-0.25886401534080505,
0.4001665711402893,
-0.9992565512657166,
0.1964297741651535,
-0.33275774121284485,
0.0106658935546875,
-0.5400991439819336,
-0.27498987317085266,
-0.2262824922800064,
-0.43027493357658386,
-0.1333591490983963,
0.10639137029647827,
0.3284232020378113,
1.2449860572814941,
0.20880922675132751,
0.013654360547661781,
-0.31991705298423767,
0.14060862362384796,
0.407622367143631,
0.23711836338043213,
0.4076733887195587,
-0.528257429599762,
0.07048597931861877,
0.36396321654319763,
-0.14697138965129852,
-0.7779960036277771,
0.2529626786708832,
-0.5117050409317017,
0.4988386332988739,
0.5524472594261169,
0.08801945298910141,
0.40859174728393555,
-0.3711051940917969,
0.6626259684562683,
0.1321536749601364,
-0.9551749229431152,
0.11399815231561661,
-0.5811503529548645,
0.2793740928173065,
0.3310408294200897,
0.5233250856399536,
-0.4316740930080414,
-0.41461503505706787,
-0.6955251097679138,
-0.3967755436897278,
0.6678876280784607,
0.06015655770897865,
-0.07847139984369278,
-0.2388569861650467,
0.29965299367904663,
-0.04226594418287277,
-0.1922825425863266,
-0.9256733059883118,
-0.06029507890343666,
-0.05143536999821663,
-0.02750709466636181,
0.02386673167347908,
-0.4754193127155304,
-0.24983347952365875,
-0.15534047782421112,
0.6142465472221375,
-0.03194868192076683,
0.15290646255016327,
0.37579548358917236,
-0.183162659406662,
-0.13555006682872772,
0.49610060453414917,
0.9462704062461853,
0.924947202205658,
-0.15017136931419373,
0.15334771573543549,
0.4336308240890503,
-0.21556231379508972,
0.2298501431941986,
-0.3537304401397705,
0.05189412832260132,
-0.4404681921005249,
0.6560433506965637,
0.5963112711906433,
-0.05828913301229477,
-1.17583167552948,
0.5059653520584106,
-0.16301627457141876,
-0.13871851563453674,
-0.7444230318069458,
-0.03554731607437134,
0.335659384727478,
0.381041556596756,
0.2852698862552643,
0.36492300033569336,
-0.005378889851272106,
-0.8127567172050476,
-0.35971254110336304,
0.7060150504112244,
-0.06536306440830231,
-0.1680116057395935,
0.326320618391037,
-0.07606963813304901,
-0.42116016149520874,
0.7792349457740784,
-0.07405503839254379,
-0.515394389629364,
0.6144635677337646,
0.4540414810180664,
0.5746164321899414,
-0.011596583761274815,
-0.24079588055610657,
0.0880303829908371,
0.5924715995788574,
-0.38082945346832275,
0.1597636193037033,
0.24981415271759033,
-0.9759224653244019,
-0.7086151838302612,
-0.15578214824199677,
-0.4551513195037842,
0.30050739645957947,
-0.6896789073944092,
-0.08739742636680603,
-0.5141251683235168,
-0.3446641266345978,
0.1311730444431305,
-0.06434959918260574,
-0.46319955587387085,
0.20694410800933838,
0.34761443734169006,
0.9507036209106445,
-0.8110255002975464,
0.908013641834259,
0.709092915058136,
-0.3532197177410126,
-0.6600896120071411,
-0.05087108910083771,
-0.13126333057880402,
-0.744158923625946,
0.9327621459960938,
0.2382286638021469,
-0.10123288631439209,
-0.4082792401313782,
-0.7427295446395874,
-0.8543692231178284,
0.7296648621559143,
0.5600610971450806,
-0.3539603650569916,
0.13817906379699707,
0.2983551323413849,
0.5953716039657593,
-0.6375187039375305,
0.5026119351387024,
0.5529820919036865,
0.7788494229316711,
-0.18463492393493652,
-0.7819168567657471,
0.05730266496539116,
-0.10368373990058899,
0.15728627145290375,
-0.32562118768692017,
-0.5258159637451172,
0.9547555446624756,
-0.14556793868541718,
-0.1512666791677475,
-0.04055202007293701,
0.5372427701950073,
0.5574819445610046,
0.2647601068019867,
0.5837538838386536,
0.469651997089386,
0.7860544323921204,
-0.0878409594297409,
1.3146673440933228,
-0.08418899029493332,
0.15482893586158752,
0.785832405090332,
-0.6274052858352661,
0.7668651342391968,
0.49854862689971924,
-0.025251610204577446,
0.33616891503334045,
0.4978928864002228,
0.2599313259124756,
-0.051236484199762344,
0.5446730852127075,
-0.3449039161205292,
-0.5966132283210754,
-0.12213579565286636,
-0.06312859058380127,
0.16414032876491547,
0.5065065026283264,
-0.19701850414276123,
0.15594327449798584,
0.06525611132383347,
0.28318315744400024,
0.21152885258197784,
-0.4140721559524536,
0.4421820640563965,
0.14823484420776367,
-1.1869250535964966,
0.7159479856491089,
0.23819231986999512,
0.7063762545585632,
-0.29997873306274414,
0.1555645614862442,
-0.2042473554611206,
0.3119332790374756,
-0.255242258310318,
-0.8584698438644409,
0.38700562715530396,
0.0897509902715683,
-0.5517565011978149,
-0.13327589631080627,
0.6826953887939453,
-0.07255861163139343,
-0.4086516797542572,
0.349361777305603,
0.5402510166168213,
0.025237513706088066,
-0.18999460339546204,
-0.6624087691307068,
0.28261813521385193,
0.10653702914714813,
-0.5370875597000122,
0.33392226696014404,
0.48736461997032166,
-0.5790896415710449,
1.0586285591125488,
0.6274008750915527,
-0.08205495029687881,
0.17660295963287354,
0.01883096806704998,
0.73222815990448,
-0.9435536861419678,
0.2059018760919571,
-0.9259639978408813,
0.14888598024845123,
-0.09968171268701553,
-0.2671499252319336,
0.7804540395736694,
0.38200727105140686,
0.8792722225189209,
-0.2549442946910858,
0.8778074979782104,
0.1157459020614624,
0.40905851125717163,
-0.41340428590774536,
0.4596197009086609,
-0.1418611854314804,
0.47301286458969116,
0.05251986160874367,
-0.9326029419898987,
-0.19585606455802917,
0.9712576270103455,
-0.8561362624168396,
0.27341943979263306,
0.7586590051651001,
0.8118378520011902,
0.06886179745197296,
0.2836335301399231,
0.32688260078430176,
0.5153703689575195,
0.025701750069856644,
0.5112061500549316,
1.393965244293213,
0.004924547392874956,
0.015984173864126205,
-0.1087876632809639,
-0.34805601835250854,
-0.06702648103237152,
-0.6450332403182983,
-1.1581953763961792,
-0.32784852385520935,
-0.15853926539421082,
-0.3176000416278839,
-0.182259663939476,
1.1430031061172485,
0.43691331148147583,
-0.7823333740234375,
-0.450843870639801,
0.05669298395514488,
0.17653515934944153,
0.1321835070848465,
-0.26912492513656616,
-0.018835583701729774,
-0.1869667023420334,
-0.5682356953620911,
0.20644788444042206,
0.11872264742851257,
-0.0007980885566212237,
-0.6470423340797424,
-0.08741557598114014,
-0.1480652540922165,
0.5037809014320374,
0.7661730647087097,
0.1411767154932022,
-1.166533350944519,
-0.5696548223495483,
0.23286427557468414,
-0.25587403774261475,
-0.10014400631189346,
0.7805621027946472,
-0.6862121820449829,
-0.05143892392516136,
0.5911622047424316,
0.2265872210264206,
0.11306186765432358,
-0.2924084961414337,
0.6442281603813171,
0.08751846849918365,
0.18601693212985992,
0.48297199606895447,
0.6209964752197266,
0.3732217252254486,
-0.13590002059936523,
0.25079694390296936,
0.11597026884555817,
-0.8529447317123413,
-0.7911312580108643,
0.4135902523994446,
-1.2267863750457764,
-0.3372446894645691,
1.3273534774780273,
-0.022563906386494637,
-0.18372933566570282,
-0.1611357033252716,
-0.42011281847953796,
-0.016826337203383446,
-0.2570513188838959,
0.7503519654273987,
1.1928154230117798,
-0.3328058421611786,
0.23608098924160004,
-0.8583609461784363,
0.3910575807094574,
0.6810070872306824,
-0.5542420148849487,
0.2921742796897888,
0.7848575115203857,
0.3392561376094818,
0.12380342930555344,
0.6851938366889954,
-0.10769949853420258,
0.14099633693695068,
-0.14836767315864563,
-0.008976555429399014,
0.33502352237701416,
0.12059157341718674,
-0.4173125922679901,
-0.20046712458133698,
0.6227050423622131,
0.6714892983436584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09177v1 | Leveraging the Context through Multi-Round Interactions for Jailbreaking Attacks | 2024-02-14T13:45:19 | 2024-02-14T13:45:19 | Yixin Cheng, Markos Georgopoulos, Volkan Cevher, Grigorios G. Chrysos | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are susceptible to Jailbreaking attacks, which
aim to extract harmful information by subtly modifying the attack query. As
defense mechanisms evolve, directly obtaining harmful information becomes
increasingly challenging for Jailbreaking attacks. In this work, inspired by
human practices of indirect context to elicit harmful information, we focus on
a new attack form called Contextual Interaction Attack. The idea relies on the
autoregressive nature of the generation process in LLMs. We contend that the
prior context--the information preceding the attack query--plays a pivotal role
in enabling potent Jailbreaking attacks. Specifically, we propose an approach
that leverages preliminary question-answer pairs to interact with the LLM. By
doing so, we guide the responses of the model toward revealing the 'desired'
harmful information. We conduct experiments on four different LLMs and
demonstrate the efficacy of this attack, which is black-box and can also
transfer across LLMs. We believe this can lead to further developments and
understanding of the context vector in LLMs. | [
-0.5171610116958618,
-1.4471479654312134,
0.6173216104507446,
0.06916550546884537,
-0.2026580274105072,
-0.05718107521533966,
-0.23496848344802856,
-0.664025604724884,
0.34162741899490356,
0.8051038980484009,
-0.5499189496040344,
-0.04316878691315651,
-0.6003860831260681,
-0.06134282052516937,
-0.4559486210346222,
0.9512345194816589,
0.09612119197845459,
-0.32850438356399536,
0.08009639382362366,
-0.06739700585603714,
-0.8231816291809082,
-1.0164624452590942,
-0.45416173338890076,
0.14170552790164948,
0.5704658627510071,
0.23568736016750336,
0.4848615527153015,
0.16156619787216187,
0.46154752373695374,
0.32831963896751404,
0.10746905952692032,
-0.1459178477525711,
-0.521241307258606,
0.6386704444885254,
-0.16739831864833832,
-0.3925071060657501,
-0.30826494097709656,
0.14462824165821075,
0.3017473816871643,
0.4786902070045471,
-0.09786666929721832,
-0.11710555851459503,
-0.15521395206451416,
0.5766509175300598,
-0.8031152486801147,
-0.2590632438659668,
-0.9881375432014465,
-0.00831889919936657,
-0.4139631986618042,
-0.17685732245445251,
-0.6291612386703491,
0.08673802018165588,
-0.05831458792090416,
-0.1869507133960724,
-0.40745383501052856,
0.1452164500951767,
0.3972976505756378,
0.09961006790399551,
-0.4858997166156769,
-0.40773940086364746,
-0.4896646738052368,
0.38964173197746277,
-0.7494445443153381,
0.05620332807302475,
0.28853029012680054,
0.2713862657546997,
-0.506253182888031,
-0.5446972846984863,
-0.5673450231552124,
-0.4203401207923889,
-0.19438667595386505,
-0.28486689925193787,
-0.3386428952217102,
-0.000660098041407764,
0.37370455265045166,
0.01080505270510912,
-0.08436257392168045,
-0.09881750494241714,
-0.533000111579895,
0.006889000069350004,
0.5897857546806335,
0.13747479021549225,
0.6612157821655273,
-0.4631919860839844,
-0.6053993105888367,
0.08883549273014069,
-0.9281390905380249,
0.07584325969219208,
0.24721895158290863,
0.2547559440135956,
-0.22456872463226318,
0.674185037612915,
0.09420135617256165,
0.9716945886611938,
0.2822314500808716,
0.11383941024541855,
-0.10860185325145721,
-0.35471421480178833,
-0.25542956590652466,
0.18576577305793762,
0.9027969837188721,
0.4959465265274048,
0.07106520235538483,
-0.3231894373893738,
-0.07044167071580887,
-0.3797946274280548,
0.6148890852928162,
-1.0390957593917847,
-0.10124769061803818,
0.21986350417137146,
-0.022646430879831314,
-0.5856285095214844,
0.3348304331302643,
-0.8432360887527466,
-0.5851171612739563,
0.058123715221881866,
0.40413394570350647,
-0.34057673811912537,
-0.22085236012935638,
-0.1495915651321411,
-0.03632977977395058,
0.33942911028862,
0.10972172766923904,
-0.8671358227729797,
0.21270832419395447,
0.40553539991378784,
0.8301742076873779,
0.008206943050026894,
-0.24019241333007812,
-0.8897933959960938,
0.5901576280593872,
-0.1388254314661026,
0.6192877292633057,
-0.5354092121124268,
-0.570557177066803,
-0.22267776727676392,
-0.006382134277373552,
-0.02322613075375557,
-0.37143179774284363,
0.11278042197227478,
-0.8416290283203125,
-0.15336593985557556,
-0.24599827826023102,
-0.35898932814598083,
0.04640119522809982,
0.37082573771476746,
-0.8232133388519287,
0.6703475117683411,
-0.20546270906925201,
-1.030444622039795,
0.0785662829875946,
-0.7293269634246826,
-0.5715870261192322,
-0.030522288754582405,
-0.140128031373024,
-0.1728857308626175,
0.1645454317331314,
0.16994252800941467,
0.5688099265098572,
0.10549421608448029,
0.3977687358856201,
-0.62257981300354,
-0.044051751494407654,
0.524677038192749,
-0.23506514728069305,
0.660452127456665,
0.2914090156555176,
-0.4753861427307129,
0.12544207274913788,
-0.509455144405365,
-0.20918413996696472,
0.38024964928627014,
-0.056673794984817505,
-0.7879834771156311,
0.07041224092245102,
-0.24708887934684753,
0.2879641652107239,
0.2625277042388916,
-0.48136866092681885,
0.44093382358551025,
-0.42029300332069397,
0.7726964354515076,
0.7184059023857117,
0.36417073011398315,
0.5023757219314575,
-0.03298007324337959,
0.3477434515953064,
-0.006411697715520859,
0.13766437768936157,
-0.39627084136009216,
-0.17035633325576782,
-0.20401133596897125,
0.028948433697223663,
-0.12073779851198196,
0.5293176174163818,
-0.5839502811431885,
0.16399414837360382,
0.12061513215303421,
-0.34948596358299255,
-0.03153739124536514,
0.2614794671535492,
0.294663667678833,
0.6009390354156494,
0.41535356640815735,
-0.2788417935371399,
-0.6597435474395752,
-0.8079574108123779,
-0.4397584795951843,
-0.12750796973705292,
0.1812046766281128,
0.41821449995040894,
0.3665269613265991,
-0.22526510059833527,
1.056197166442871,
-0.6223896741867065,
-0.01424889825284481,
-0.30851802229881287,
-0.03243442252278328,
0.03302031382918358,
0.5494878888130188,
0.7678588032722473,
-0.7964210510253906,
-0.245575949549675,
-0.3557032644748688,
-0.9818115234375,
-0.17617671191692352,
-0.0557171069085598,
-0.16952800750732422,
-0.12156674265861511,
1.1339932680130005,
-0.43543049693107605,
0.4078977704048157,
0.38898393511772156,
-0.5754842162132263,
0.5926845669746399,
-0.013461047783493996,
0.20825383067131042,
-1.1006110906600952,
-0.13235293328762054,
-0.026470758020877838,
-0.23951531946659088,
-1.1047332286834717,
0.4007287621498108,
0.02327043004333973,
-0.0777159035205841,
-0.609275758266449,
0.7379493117332458,
-0.5229441523551941,
0.01689830608665943,
-0.33971792459487915,
0.2410726398229599,
-0.03573472425341606,
0.1495726853609085,
-0.19386981427669525,
0.9353333711624146,
0.15349015593528748,
-0.2673351466655731,
0.1772114634513855,
0.1269935667514801,
-0.23753103613853455,
0.5535837411880493,
-0.7600558996200562,
0.39577266573905945,
-0.10780038684606552,
0.32413050532341003,
-0.913743257522583,
-0.31668204069137573,
0.31263643503189087,
-0.339839369058609,
0.23110677301883698,
-0.21552440524101257,
-0.48620522022247314,
-0.0922204926609993,
-0.42665424942970276,
0.592490017414093,
0.13064736127853394,
-0.5863630771636963,
0.5157498717308044,
0.6865706443786621,
-0.30523353815078735,
-0.5142567753791809,
-0.6245118975639343,
0.5244584083557129,
-0.6827856302261353,
-0.8069022297859192,
0.19853085279464722,
-0.1615593433380127,
-0.6599404215812683,
-0.46968314051628113,
-0.05543652921915054,
-0.031818509101867676,
0.42678266763687134,
0.3172217309474945,
0.38305601477622986,
0.14370274543762207,
-0.27176350355148315,
-0.029769450426101685,
0.2798687219619751,
0.4067405164241791,
-0.006859702989459038,
0.5793067812919617,
-0.04473826289176941,
-0.1688058227300644,
-0.19698211550712585,
0.4147578775882721,
0.6616532802581787,
-0.258649080991745,
0.928762674331665,
0.10444488376379013,
-0.23355615139007568,
0.012147295288741589,
-0.6916107535362244,
-0.29260820150375366,
-0.561722457408905,
0.395629346370697,
-0.5421895980834961,
-1.0313416719436646,
0.4964321255683899,
-0.11051879823207855,
-0.17439547181129456,
-0.091529980301857,
0.48439130187034607,
0.11376461386680603,
0.8036410212516785,
0.659957766532898,
-0.4116607904434204,
0.7381287217140198,
0.05166415497660637,
0.22543710470199585,
-1.134443759918213,
-0.2108878791332245,
-0.1932593286037445,
0.10977697372436523,
-0.14209242165088654,
-0.22107577323913574,
0.31910136342048645,
0.7165952920913696,
-0.19872133433818817,
0.5785484910011292,
-0.2486116737127304,
0.45018282532691956,
0.08806802332401276,
0.21868087351322174,
0.20436735451221466,
-0.24159632623195648,
-0.3271999657154083,
0.16987328231334686,
-0.4795551896095276,
-0.4202480614185333,
1.1146774291992188,
0.23835469782352448,
0.7819364666938782,
0.33742040395736694,
0.6648501753807068,
0.33957639336586,
0.5245280265808105,
-0.33088430762290955,
0.418465256690979,
0.36119499802589417,
-0.7012282013893127,
-0.23394675552845,
-0.11585671454668045,
-0.9561936259269714,
0.4922972619533539,
-0.17101341485977173,
-1.3424924612045288,
-0.1611170917749405,
0.09394241869449615,
-0.4316386282444,
0.39615440368652344,
-0.8901038765907288,
0.905829906463623,
-0.316624253988266,
-0.6782062649726868,
-0.09518103301525116,
-0.9240168333053589,
0.7665639519691467,
-0.1708793193101883,
0.8464372754096985,
0.11523569375276566,
0.27496394515037537,
0.5718538761138916,
-0.633642852306366,
1.0590734481811523,
-0.3662320077419281,
-0.3319433033466339,
0.20425724983215332,
0.2631393074989319,
0.7357292175292969,
0.5220468044281006,
0.05049342289566994,
-0.11410722136497498,
-0.17352049052715302,
-0.22881343960762024,
-0.6545611023902893,
0.7760217189788818,
-0.5328025817871094,
-1.0709714889526367,
-0.24368488788604736,
-0.6010915040969849,
-0.13561442494392395,
0.25354063510894775,
-0.03705329820513725,
0.3715449571609497,
-0.23507237434387207,
-0.041939374059438705,
0.573257565498352,
-0.26249006390571594,
0.6153169870376587,
0.4803917407989502,
-0.3142308294773102,
-0.3263568580150604,
0.4696764647960663,
-0.1986510008573532,
0.5217357277870178,
0.05858788266777992,
0.0838877335190773,
0.0077100167982280254,
-0.5310525894165039,
-0.3020501434803009,
0.04318848252296448,
-0.5706323385238647,
-0.23008106648921967,
-0.6788994073867798,
-0.22785528004169464,
-0.38668006658554077,
-0.40727654099464417,
-0.07394462823867798,
-0.06515344977378845,
0.1307341605424881,
-0.2296808660030365,
0.36048173904418945,
0.7544650435447693,
-0.14864249527454376,
0.46525895595550537,
-0.8766573667526245,
0.3508132994174957,
0.496060311794281,
-0.028569167479872704,
0.10517196357250214,
-0.15487785637378693,
-0.026517421007156372,
-0.049020759761333466,
-0.24906475841999054,
-1.4972479343414307,
0.2806958854198456,
-0.23207636177539825,
0.4218916594982147,
0.2965274155139923,
0.1229388490319252,
0.633236825466156,
-0.876679539680481,
0.7225533127784729,
0.18244703114032745,
-0.9995402693748474,
0.8285238742828369,
-0.3948768079280853,
0.2209780365228653,
0.6685367226600647,
-0.03983166441321373,
-0.6276996731758118,
-0.7891175746917725,
-0.5339334607124329,
-1.1437326669692993,
0.6440553665161133,
0.1087249144911766,
0.39508917927742004,
-0.2027023881673813,
0.6722134947776794,
-0.19572971761226654,
0.39090272784233093,
-1.0201267004013062,
-0.3403606116771698,
-0.1736270636320114,
0.22138532996177673,
0.11042401939630508,
-0.32032310962677,
-0.335970938205719,
-0.2561909854412079,
0.2310333251953125,
0.20471371710300446,
-0.0057412413880229,
0.2742304801940918,
-0.5323680639266968,
0.11825381964445114,
0.4416210651397705,
0.6588700413703918,
0.45036375522613525,
-0.15923626720905304,
0.1986851543188095,
0.19527244567871094,
-0.5633791089057922,
0.2936886250972748,
0.037167131900787354,
-0.16160787642002106,
-0.4913349449634552,
0.29355353116989136,
0.8046481013298035,
0.3314650356769562,
-0.7088612914085388,
0.6458995342254639,
-0.22155064344406128,
0.19642464816570282,
-0.4737009108066559,
0.167022705078125,
-0.018540194258093834,
0.4220665991306305,
0.5541743040084839,
-0.17426344752311707,
0.03215475380420685,
-0.7292152047157288,
0.5024722814559937,
0.8259531855583191,
-0.4664408564567566,
-0.3250596523284912,
0.7683553099632263,
0.1758764684200287,
-0.234470397233963,
0.4277156889438629,
-0.05376366898417473,
-0.6561617851257324,
0.644706130027771,
0.7429036498069763,
0.6103774905204773,
-0.31992068886756897,
-0.13407067954540253,
0.21393674612045288,
0.4395524859428406,
0.343246728181839,
-0.12184859812259674,
-0.3197561800479889,
-0.6936647295951843,
-0.5415281653404236,
-0.4431590139865875,
-0.27556517720222473,
0.39279037714004517,
-0.7194387316703796,
0.11386274546384811,
-0.5342743396759033,
-0.026906991377472878,
-0.05872267484664917,
-0.3287888169288635,
-0.2027815729379654,
0.015971094369888306,
0.1791471689939499,
0.7308260798454285,
-0.582136332988739,
0.9802594780921936,
0.5826364755630493,
-0.28304240107536316,
-0.5987752676010132,
0.17930729687213898,
0.1801520586013794,
-0.631033718585968,
0.9563882946968079,
0.5465125441551208,
-0.07662574201822281,
-0.10183095186948776,
-0.7407901883125305,
-0.8644727468490601,
0.7743538022041321,
0.20962601900100708,
-0.6036884784698486,
-0.08610707521438599,
-0.09350438416004181,
0.15236249566078186,
-0.4506223797798157,
0.12079786509275436,
0.7527947425842285,
0.5654810667037964,
-0.05254887416958809,
-0.6140620112419128,
0.4923859238624573,
-0.36961543560028076,
-0.1467391848564148,
0.5577009916305542,
-0.5666603446006775,
0.6793045997619629,
-0.419830322265625,
-0.043000128120183945,
0.014916562475264072,
0.645006000995636,
0.42290008068084717,
0.041560057550668716,
0.6223224401473999,
0.4742625653743744,
0.3444114923477173,
0.12644271552562714,
1.0968607664108276,
-0.5629120469093323,
0.0980578139424324,
1.287683129310608,
-0.3792847692966461,
0.9545987844467163,
0.9256272315979004,
0.02207169122993946,
0.5130641460418701,
0.15626707673072815,
0.06453786045312881,
0.6737419962882996,
0.5843697190284729,
-0.3969019651412964,
0.11908066272735596,
0.34927868843078613,
-0.31344884634017944,
0.3706243634223938,
0.5029280185699463,
-0.042660605162382126,
-0.2745448350906372,
0.553331732749939,
0.5874426960945129,
0.020641393959522247,
-0.28171539306640625,
0.9436410665512085,
0.11070194840431213,
-0.5270448923110962,
0.42320823669433594,
0.28459158539772034,
0.8493937849998474,
-0.553152322769165,
0.11451788246631622,
-0.023705147206783295,
-0.17465314269065857,
-0.11541510373353958,
-0.5038719773292542,
0.42884907126426697,
0.13591016829013824,
-0.1235615462064743,
0.06734713166952133,
0.7809544205665588,
-0.22654573619365692,
-0.08248057216405869,
0.6082485318183899,
0.33832353353500366,
-0.1586751788854599,
0.0049424306489527225,
-0.4723478853702545,
0.18202978372573853,
-0.17486821115016937,
-0.5530253648757935,
0.7320267558097839,
0.14904488623142242,
0.026089364662766457,
0.48374056816101074,
0.6890980005264282,
0.042375486344099045,
0.24039773643016815,
-0.17095646262168884,
1.1665065288543701,
-0.8067524433135986,
-0.3831395208835602,
-1.3221315145492554,
0.42966458201408386,
-0.359468013048172,
0.024549515917897224,
0.8493741750717163,
0.2402937412261963,
0.7601712942123413,
0.4502313733100891,
0.9179219603538513,
-0.30155718326568604,
0.06712397187948227,
-0.739211916923523,
0.7500370144844055,
-0.2990579307079315,
0.6754903197288513,
-0.5289716124534607,
-0.6380009055137634,
-0.1317884922027588,
0.44754618406295776,
-0.5786629915237427,
-0.10373114794492722,
0.7084760069847107,
0.513745129108429,
0.058813754469156265,
-0.04112286493182182,
0.14966532588005066,
0.484063982963562,
0.5131288766860962,
0.5629059076309204,
0.8569040894508362,
-0.3050956130027771,
0.3943645656108856,
-0.20812579989433289,
-0.32051411271095276,
0.016042955219745636,
-0.9327602982521057,
-1.2910789251327515,
-0.42939066886901855,
0.14729684591293335,
-0.5034781694412231,
0.3569941520690918,
0.7514896988868713,
0.6247581243515015,
-0.5611420273780823,
-0.3125670552253723,
-0.10652168095111847,
-0.06222149729728699,
0.3634774386882782,
-0.29757991433143616,
0.11844965815544128,
-0.6094169020652771,
-0.35352057218551636,
0.748620867729187,
0.3490118980407715,
-0.000012132159099564888,
-0.35517415404319763,
0.1558687835931778,
-0.3791041672229767,
0.1661163866519928,
0.7060248255729675,
0.3180835545063019,
-0.5113617181777954,
-0.35780104994773865,
-0.30003106594085693,
-0.09269606322050095,
0.10038319230079651,
1.1251916885375977,
-0.7998998165130615,
0.2701926827430725,
0.01744597963988781,
0.6552092432975769,
0.4324338138103485,
0.11905446648597717,
0.868990421295166,
-0.838837742805481,
0.5372573137283325,
-0.20183612406253815,
0.41817575693130493,
0.2202649712562561,
-0.6560587882995605,
0.16181837022304535,
0.012779919430613518,
-0.40384477376937866,
-0.9109034538269043,
0.48237165808677673,
-0.5646439790725708,
-0.8564086556434631,
1.1353954076766968,
-0.13774365186691284,
-0.4304742217063904,
-0.08687734603881836,
-0.28432825207710266,
-0.12445873022079468,
-0.44335389137268066,
0.8254851698875427,
0.8545800447463989,
-0.05081766098737717,
0.022641927003860474,
-0.8362536430358887,
0.505189836025238,
0.26566338539123535,
-1.0572556257247925,
0.1578221619129181,
0.5632792115211487,
0.3500722050666809,
0.0860331580042839,
0.5824111700057983,
-0.34232091903686523,
0.11064733564853668,
-0.41519492864608765,
-0.2393088936805725,
-0.1693313717842102,
-0.3636664152145386,
-0.42143183946609497,
0.6067779660224915,
0.05508817732334137,
0.30856531858444214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09151v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09151v2 | Chinese MentalBERT: Domain-Adaptive Pre-training on Social Media for Chinese Mental Health Text Analysis | 2024-02-14T13:08:25 | 2024-06-12T16:03:31 | Wei Zhai, Hongzhi Qi, Qing Zhao, Jianqiang Li, Ziqi Wang, Han Wang, Bing Xiang Yang, Guanghui Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In the current environment, psychological issues are prevalent and
widespread, with social media serving as a key outlet for individuals to share
their feelings. This results in the generation of vast quantities of data
daily, where negative emotions have the potential to precipitate crisis
situations. There is a recognized need for models capable of efficient
analysis. While pre-trained language models have demonstrated their
effectiveness broadly, there's a noticeable gap in pre-trained models tailored
for specialized domains like psychology. To address this, we have collected a
huge dataset from Chinese social media platforms and enriched it with publicly
available datasets to create a comprehensive database encompassing 3.36 million
text entries. To enhance the model's applicability to psychological text
analysis, we integrated psychological lexicons into the pre-training masking
mechanism. Building on an existing Chinese language model, we performed
adaptive training to develop a model specialized for the psychological domain.
We evaluated our model's performance across six public datasets, where it
demonstrated improvements compared to eight other models. Additionally, in the
qualitative comparison experiment, our model provided psychologically relevant
predictions given the masked sentences. Due to concerns regarding data privacy,
the dataset will not be made publicly available. However, we have made the
pre-trained models and codes publicly accessible to the community via:
https://github.com/zwzzzQAQ/Chinese-MentalBERT. | [
-0.36541637778282166,
-0.6358514428138733,
0.4117196202278137,
0.8332943916320801,
-0.32529735565185547,
-0.08916092664003372,
-0.5398313999176025,
-0.4582681357860565,
0.28149616718292236,
0.33240553736686707,
-0.7303247451782227,
-0.646133303642273,
-0.8018497824668884,
-0.05260723456740379,
-0.18426227569580078,
1.2337576150894165,
0.02702689915895462,
0.3096441328525543,
0.11925648152828217,
-0.08214698731899261,
-0.2590411305427551,
-0.9250615239143372,
-0.6321020126342773,
-0.1832495480775833,
0.39339572191238403,
-0.02700212597846985,
0.4075912833213806,
0.028633376583456993,
0.5820855498313904,
0.21366356313228607,
0.2669636309146881,
0.09894835203886032,
-0.6509392857551575,
-0.28606700897216797,
-0.2989008128643036,
-0.21178780496120453,
-0.7683340311050415,
0.09947797656059265,
0.44871786236763,
0.36531972885131836,
-0.286205917596817,
0.19173406064510345,
0.23317620158195496,
0.6924489736557007,
-0.7050402164459229,
0.059196434915065765,
-0.6357855796813965,
0.2882938086986542,
-0.12374480813741684,
-0.2295224517583847,
-0.21615846455097198,
-0.5888469815254211,
0.2804866135120392,
-0.7800333499908447,
0.20981332659721375,
-0.3570755124092102,
0.7822858095169067,
0.17802490293979645,
-0.3216281533241272,
-0.056440964341163635,
-0.7683629989624023,
0.4444562494754791,
-0.6109219193458557,
0.120023213326931,
0.6791419982910156,
0.2495747208595276,
0.09781380742788315,
-0.9582328796386719,
-0.4906823933124542,
-0.07018125057220459,
0.043678540736436844,
0.39485040307044983,
-0.09198100119829178,
0.1107141450047493,
0.15435266494750977,
0.06622093915939331,
-0.7623809576034546,
-0.23059707880020142,
-0.3902674615383148,
-0.2171429991722107,
1.0128906965255737,
0.22100059688091278,
0.5373442769050598,
0.02351793274283409,
-0.20713916420936584,
0.12160996347665787,
-0.3077833950519562,
-0.09360026568174362,
0.0050317272543907166,
0.05054457113146782,
-0.3172745108604431,
0.17014971375465393,
-0.2098437398672104,
0.4153413772583008,
0.03696957975625992,
0.03961067274212837,
0.3462914824485779,
-0.20139285922050476,
-0.28288382291793823,
0.2147464156150818,
0.8771806359291077,
0.5032678842544556,
0.6165525913238525,
0.1318722367286682,
-0.2227923423051834,
0.19901598989963531,
0.48617079854011536,
-0.9029293060302734,
-0.779877245426178,
0.31708353757858276,
-0.6408812999725342,
-0.14171713590621948,
0.10440780967473984,
-0.535739541053772,
-0.7556925415992737,
-0.2836897671222687,
0.3385999798774719,
-0.533635139465332,
-0.40483778715133667,
0.3514428734779358,
0.0910332202911377,
-0.05173430219292641,
0.2896069884300232,
-0.6936112642288208,
0.4075363278388977,
0.41932007670402527,
1.0228912830352783,
-0.04164405167102814,
-0.38132134079933167,
-0.33326655626296997,
0.06095849350094795,
-0.33327433466911316,
0.6340449452400208,
-0.3936287462711334,
-0.20002992451190948,
0.30060189962387085,
0.14527039229869843,
-0.19839735329151154,
-0.35920989513397217,
0.5711901783943176,
-0.36845362186431885,
0.2715354561805725,
-0.3488251566886902,
-0.26098307967185974,
0.0698687806725502,
0.20976203680038452,
-0.39504677057266235,
0.8189169764518738,
0.07957664132118225,
-0.8862832188606262,
0.04521142691373825,
-0.8619624972343445,
-0.5745254158973694,
0.11335163563489914,
0.029677661135792732,
-0.28106778860092163,
-0.01618810184299946,
0.4340513050556183,
0.7226330041885376,
-0.15618793666362762,
0.20634262263774872,
-0.6102844476699829,
-0.4786135256290436,
0.4843129813671112,
-0.1148996651172638,
1.1792283058166504,
0.26776623725891113,
-0.15297861397266388,
0.4093613028526306,
-0.7417117953300476,
-0.02198551781475544,
0.23543065786361694,
0.11144457012414932,
-0.49776890873908997,
0.1316092163324356,
0.38971930742263794,
0.4402467906475067,
0.23537978529930115,
-0.39164283871650696,
-0.07716409116983414,
-0.319389283657074,
0.4186072051525116,
0.9098162055015564,
0.11579462140798569,
0.2012120634317398,
-0.2499481737613678,
0.5214895009994507,
-0.015914814546704292,
0.43496114015579224,
0.14891967177391052,
-0.19564607739448547,
-0.2639888525009155,
-0.37979453802108765,
-0.09397044777870178,
0.6785656809806824,
-0.7600512504577637,
0.5543347001075745,
-0.16292519867420197,
-0.7634721398353577,
-0.5250403881072998,
0.05680983141064644,
0.17512381076812744,
0.2492934912443161,
0.30452656745910645,
-0.3827972412109375,
-0.5270801782608032,
-0.48099637031555176,
-0.31598684191703796,
0.014585419557988644,
-0.34510987997055054,
0.15928484499454498,
0.39511221647262573,
-0.44677212834358215,
0.6087499856948853,
-0.8882459998130798,
-0.6066020131111145,
-0.2209075689315796,
0.1855185329914093,
-0.1083938255906105,
0.2718041241168976,
0.6296640038490295,
-0.8492461442947388,
-0.6636632084846497,
-0.12133388221263885,
-0.8843714594841003,
-0.2934083640575409,
-0.15032845735549927,
-0.3801742494106293,
0.0023672166280448437,
0.30081382393836975,
-0.5269513130187988,
0.31777891516685486,
0.5454818606376648,
-0.14160004258155823,
0.7804905772209167,
-0.15048854053020477,
0.056557752192020416,
-1.1418020725250244,
0.08587555587291718,
0.3366332948207855,
-0.05834908038377762,
-0.8754320740699768,
-0.1535370796918869,
0.10161090642213821,
-0.33385390043258667,
-0.4274408519268036,
0.33971527218818665,
-0.2609255611896515,
0.31940001249313354,
-0.4821435809135437,
0.4091931879520416,
-0.16210517287254333,
0.5958945155143738,
0.20439179241657257,
0.3794615864753723,
0.7683249711990356,
-0.6038084030151367,
0.4115847647190094,
0.11532258242368698,
-0.31638115644454956,
0.4487936198711395,
-0.5567693710327148,
0.17030100524425507,
-0.2084246426820755,
0.4219280481338501,
-0.7825945615768433,
-0.3857068419456482,
0.6217148900032043,
-0.5309891104698181,
-0.01920737512409687,
0.4566889703273773,
-0.26262038946151733,
-0.2840559780597687,
-0.5358120203018188,
0.2626478970050812,
0.22247759997844696,
-0.3696228563785553,
0.2699792981147766,
0.5637654662132263,
-0.22778789699077606,
-0.5226978659629822,
-0.5361751317977905,
0.017716359347105026,
-0.2308053970336914,
-0.4217676520347595,
0.5296112298965454,
-0.27080270648002625,
-0.015075872652232647,
0.0360507033765316,
0.09270098060369492,
-0.46044814586639404,
0.2029516100883484,
0.06664770096540451,
0.3406055271625519,
-0.23753969371318817,
0.41847532987594604,
-0.150438591837883,
0.06602158397436142,
0.417062908411026,
-0.16220685839653015,
0.6017641425132751,
-0.16986602544784546,
0.03275299817323685,
-0.606488823890686,
0.2141597419977188,
0.2270270138978958,
-0.4813278615474701,
0.9784822463989258,
0.8254140019416809,
-1.0351721048355103,
-0.15866169333457947,
-0.1932913064956665,
-0.06804382801055908,
-0.5005820989608765,
0.6080028414726257,
-0.03754573315382004,
-0.6397193670272827,
0.36838293075561523,
0.19252531230449677,
-0.16617172956466675,
0.16080176830291748,
0.6707049012184143,
-0.07277420163154602,
1.0852805376052856,
0.822388231754303,
-0.4371015131473541,
0.6626317501068115,
0.2251461148262024,
0.2762207090854645,
-0.43289175629615784,
0.15476538240909576,
-0.17671263217926025,
0.036558493971824646,
-0.5975887179374695,
-0.14591915905475616,
0.23080503940582275,
-0.10675607621669769,
-0.5306115746498108,
0.09226012974977493,
-0.7762242555618286,
0.13330617547035217,
0.2993086278438568,
0.4826643466949463,
0.06245771050453186,
-0.0870460793375969,
0.5608044266700745,
-0.2903232276439667,
-0.343307763338089,
-0.4072546064853668,
0.9196476340293884,
0.31717655062675476,
0.7354634404182434,
-0.08810482919216156,
0.518491268157959,
0.36729103326797485,
0.7945941090583801,
-0.6122530102729797,
0.4868747293949127,
-0.29570096731185913,
-0.6313743591308594,
-0.27800047397613525,
-0.30865612626075745,
-0.7581679224967957,
0.09997005760669708,
-0.26076382398605347,
-1.0120351314544678,
0.04414749890565872,
0.12520362436771393,
-0.4284215569496155,
0.04414800927042961,
-0.6729333400726318,
0.8809876441955566,
-0.49015429615974426,
-0.07579626142978668,
-0.26185134053230286,
-0.6167659759521484,
0.673237144947052,
-0.6142277717590332,
0.01918729580938816,
-0.12784337997436523,
0.29026222229003906,
0.988571047782898,
-0.1667776107788086,
0.9288948178291321,
-0.2953357994556427,
0.0030399721581488848,
0.1727038025856018,
-0.30709561705589294,
0.08458761125802994,
0.044331807643175125,
0.11095663160085678,
0.1569012850522995,
0.2990867495536804,
-0.5403704643249512,
-0.7401174902915955,
0.41151562333106995,
-1.1595510244369507,
-0.5719020366668701,
-0.43141263723373413,
-0.3218870460987091,
-0.3056067228317261,
0.35122671723365784,
0.3921782970428467,
0.14032810926437378,
-0.31619733572006226,
0.11569210141897202,
0.48646920919418335,
-0.592054009437561,
0.020571686327457428,
0.43066978454589844,
-0.24074652791023254,
-0.4095152020454407,
1.047258973121643,
0.2826637923717499,
-0.08895358443260193,
0.3237387239933014,
0.11746884882450104,
0.05552280694246292,
-0.31152787804603577,
0.3073546290397644,
0.2755667567253113,
-0.6201487183570862,
0.05759870633482933,
-0.5993824601173401,
-0.6900544762611389,
-0.6983791589736938,
-0.12146889418363571,
-0.3050411641597748,
0.06388114392757416,
-0.2433444857597351,
-0.16353973746299744,
0.2496073842048645,
0.5414950847625732,
-0.10229312628507614,
0.6062069535255432,
-0.8852461576461792,
0.4180041551589966,
-0.09364455193281174,
0.5570883750915527,
0.11286860704421997,
-0.2623676359653473,
-0.6371605396270752,
0.11535846441984177,
-0.4832795262336731,
-1.1255478858947754,
0.623947262763977,
0.10985302180051804,
0.2862353026866913,
0.6668925881385803,
0.5368358492851257,
0.7034456729888916,
-0.32986992597579956,
0.6779009699821472,
0.2797902822494507,
-0.9883767366409302,
0.6763123273849487,
-0.43348240852355957,
0.05259619653224945,
0.3962554335594177,
0.7086432576179504,
-0.8828698992729187,
-0.299405038356781,
-0.40613487362861633,
-0.7368686199188232,
0.8487948775291443,
0.16038213670253754,
0.33072131872177124,
0.11196204274892807,
0.4030551016330719,
-0.18638333678245544,
0.07026276737451553,
-0.9658468961715698,
-0.2378309965133667,
-0.719651460647583,
-0.5660147666931152,
-0.2859906256198883,
-0.07777337729930878,
-0.26800599694252014,
-0.3157559931278229,
0.7236450910568237,
-0.05169996619224548,
0.5360778570175171,
0.3752686381340027,
-0.2673385441303253,
-0.017918866127729416,
-0.04202937334775925,
0.5433487892150879,
0.6075659394264221,
-0.46987855434417725,
-0.05013694614171982,
0.11386251449584961,
-0.9024032354354858,
0.06655173003673553,
0.3902865946292877,
0.2529212236404419,
-0.20764587819576263,
0.3617609143257141,
0.6085379123687744,
-0.2008398473262787,
-0.7385727167129517,
0.6360639929771423,
-0.2529602646827698,
-0.3283679187297821,
-0.6567565202713013,
-0.013546369969844818,
0.15557390451431274,
0.3350491523742676,
0.3487330377101898,
-0.2511155605316162,
0.15507915616035461,
-0.395725280046463,
0.2972893714904785,
0.030762463808059692,
-0.6277562379837036,
-0.5547024607658386,
0.6884250640869141,
0.00954701192677021,
-0.4389086961746216,
0.656635582447052,
-0.028907369822263718,
-0.650104284286499,
0.3676433861255646,
0.4642944931983948,
1.0850898027420044,
-0.32911059260368347,
0.460171103477478,
0.24230769276618958,
0.44859579205513,
-0.026851367205381393,
0.2103579193353653,
0.056394074112176895,
-1.0237011909484863,
-0.209531769156456,
-0.20174333453178406,
-0.19077268242835999,
0.5103339552879333,
-0.8570175766944885,
0.1498909294605255,
-0.8130089044570923,
-0.30818310379981995,
-0.2724824845790863,
0.2271210253238678,
-0.6302053928375244,
0.6234068274497986,
0.40254834294319153,
0.8315324187278748,
-0.9584451913833618,
1.0606178045272827,
0.8034955263137817,
-0.40905359387397766,
-0.6726065874099731,
0.5363104939460754,
-0.04169493541121483,
-0.6705963015556335,
0.39046645164489746,
0.3927246928215027,
0.019539479166269302,
-0.18842369318008423,
-0.6551317572593689,
-0.531157910823822,
0.8974167108535767,
0.4381389915943146,
-0.2657178044319153,
0.044298168271780014,
0.13666069507598877,
0.9532119035720825,
-0.4403289258480072,
0.021987782791256905,
0.3261863589286804,
0.19528095424175262,
-0.5234887599945068,
-0.48313194513320923,
0.1882050484418869,
-0.5500257015228271,
-0.04808582365512848,
-0.3292672336101532,
-0.7424300312995911,
0.6592310667037964,
0.20875856280326843,
-0.377162903547287,
-0.2682165801525116,
0.8019970655441284,
0.42906710505485535,
0.5395458340644836,
0.36214596033096313,
-0.01961461268365383,
1.0420747995376587,
0.20795179903507233,
0.8691825866699219,
-0.5070092082023621,
0.37342116236686707,
1.2011433839797974,
-0.4690040349960327,
0.7360725998878479,
-0.04775504395365715,
-0.1384180337190628,
0.42169371247291565,
1.0321720838546753,
0.05798834562301636,
0.5766267776489258,
0.10606227070093155,
-0.3351306617259979,
-0.1273483783006668,
-0.21693091094493866,
-0.3729862868785858,
0.1313900202512741,
0.48302316665649414,
-0.3508857786655426,
0.1275802105665207,
0.18138502538204193,
-0.1578163057565689,
0.1791582852602005,
-0.3490828573703766,
0.4089168906211853,
0.27305424213409424,
-0.3446227014064789,
0.5333219766616821,
0.0889439731836319,
0.6417514681816101,
-0.6976441740989685,
0.29242458939552307,
-0.22876332700252533,
0.36476510763168335,
-0.314817875623703,
-0.49184319376945496,
0.34552305936813354,
0.023071827366948128,
-0.06253185123205185,
-0.08482687920331955,
1.1572816371917725,
-0.3691617548465729,
-0.4590330123901367,
0.6118453741073608,
0.49645671248435974,
0.10663355886936188,
-0.519870936870575,
-0.8406310081481934,
-0.26471200585365295,
-0.21210964024066925,
-0.41376450657844543,
0.47031161189079285,
0.5835790038108826,
-0.23280923068523407,
0.5367931127548218,
0.5346626043319702,
0.3156355321407318,
-0.19206902384757996,
0.29846835136413574,
0.8225602507591248,
-0.7926928400993347,
-0.6022449731826782,
-0.941903293132782,
0.34964343905448914,
-0.24274180829524994,
-0.38606804609298706,
0.5446361303329468,
0.14180926978588104,
0.8267242312431335,
-0.10751116275787354,
1.0338444709777832,
0.20566216111183167,
0.253299355506897,
-0.18490666151046753,
1.185784101486206,
-0.6231079697608948,
-0.0923449695110321,
-0.49725955724716187,
-0.8151856660842896,
-0.48221907019615173,
0.7961897253990173,
-0.5016828179359436,
0.02224225178360939,
0.6076251864433289,
0.80766761302948,
0.10445603728294373,
0.052924130111932755,
0.16753044724464417,
0.319125235080719,
0.3810926377773285,
0.6395467519760132,
0.8504493832588196,
-0.2086217850446701,
0.3382047712802887,
-0.3356998562812805,
-0.3654745817184448,
-0.015418671071529388,
-0.6491906642913818,
-1.0105599164962769,
-0.6854605078697205,
-0.294899046421051,
-0.36902937293052673,
0.18316732347011566,
1.1551845073699951,
0.5681390762329102,
-0.7207493185997009,
-0.16683079302310944,
0.15972165763378143,
-0.09879735112190247,
-0.2957216501235962,
-0.29254090785980225,
0.6289463639259338,
-0.15005844831466675,
-0.3769618570804596,
-0.32429754734039307,
0.15042510628700256,
-0.13778908550739288,
-0.15440446138381958,
-0.06740473210811615,
-0.1772546023130417,
0.27510151267051697,
0.7535656094551086,
0.10226039588451385,
-0.29904136061668396,
-0.2400267869234085,
0.09948825091123581,
-0.3339441120624542,
0.04227721691131592,
0.8989186882972717,
-0.3046817481517792,
0.35060104727745056,
0.26143932342529297,
0.7899622321128845,
0.2923128008842468,
0.01416196208447218,
0.6962804794311523,
-0.5659963488578796,
0.019626084715127945,
0.05082940310239792,
0.3259963095188141,
0.3551502227783203,
-0.6378048658370972,
0.39761781692504883,
0.3338111340999603,
-0.351214736700058,
-0.8398171663284302,
-0.10232940316200256,
-0.8072749376296997,
-0.614065945148468,
0.938951849937439,
-0.41339725255966187,
-0.13779042661190033,
0.013464068993926048,
-0.48366832733154297,
0.702232301235199,
-0.22300520539283752,
1.3152014017105103,
0.9628179669380188,
-0.091336689889431,
-0.18082265555858612,
-0.5412839651107788,
0.5559096932411194,
0.36171141266822815,
-0.8899357914924622,
0.17208583652973175,
0.1470513939857483,
0.16252253949642181,
-0.09026364982128143,
1.2077044248580933,
0.13641968369483948,
0.4496430456638336,
-0.26611417531967163,
0.266162633895874,
0.33619797229766846,
-0.15449507534503937,
-0.36082231998443604,
0.06884095817804337,
-0.1510293036699295,
-0.08968546241521835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09141v1 | Advancing NLP Models with Strategic Text Augmentation: A Comprehensive Study of Augmentation Methods and Curriculum Strategies | 2024-02-14T12:41:09 | 2024-02-14T12:41:09 | Himmet Toprak Kesgin, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study conducts a thorough evaluation of text augmentation techniques
across a variety of datasets and natural language processing (NLP) tasks to
address the lack of reliable, generalized evidence for these methods. It
examines the effectiveness of these techniques in augmenting training sets to
improve performance in tasks such as topic classification, sentiment analysis,
and offensive language detection. The research emphasizes not only the
augmentation methods, but also the strategic order in which real and augmented
instances are introduced during training. A major contribution is the
development and evaluation of Modified Cyclical Curriculum Learning (MCCL) for
augmented datasets, which represents a novel approach in the field. Results
show that specific augmentation methods, especially when integrated with MCCL,
significantly outperform traditional training approaches in NLP model
performance. These results underscore the need for careful selection of
augmentation techniques and sequencing strategies to optimize the balance
between speed and quality improvement in various NLP tasks. The study concludes
that the use of augmentation methods, especially in conjunction with MCCL,
leads to improved results in various classification tasks, providing a
foundation for future advances in text augmentation strategies in NLP. | [
-0.44664567708969116,
-0.798186182975769,
0.16923688352108002,
0.2577180564403534,
-0.055057987570762634,
0.5620185732841492,
-0.38797345757484436,
-0.6199868321418762,
-0.03229105845093727,
0.6108203530311584,
-0.6478778719902039,
-0.5256406664848328,
-0.6387909650802612,
0.35696884989738464,
-0.40551626682281494,
1.0380531549453735,
0.1810830682516098,
0.09672848880290985,
-0.30942463874816895,
-0.31029680371284485,
-0.7680575251579285,
-0.8158968687057495,
-0.7225786447525024,
-0.4659970998764038,
0.30709969997406006,
0.35289180278778076,
0.699748158454895,
0.6231335997581482,
0.8415855169296265,
0.2899933457374573,
-0.29053056240081787,
0.5292494893074036,
-0.31689462065696716,
0.11353379487991333,
-0.291290819644928,
-0.2892780900001526,
-0.485592246055603,
-0.018960246816277504,
0.7431821823120117,
0.8815751075744629,
-0.1659887284040451,
0.10501501709222794,
0.12307298928499222,
0.7279286980628967,
-0.7931610941886902,
-0.05406530946493149,
-0.48232561349868774,
0.15012897551059723,
-0.20742417871952057,
-0.3671322762966156,
-0.5035520792007446,
-0.24261978268623352,
0.4009426236152649,
-0.5104125738143921,
0.17435751855373383,
0.04298591613769531,
0.4342740476131439,
0.02743573859333992,
-0.41101300716400146,
-0.5598962306976318,
-0.7300590872764587,
1.072872519493103,
-0.9332522749900818,
0.20462960004806519,
0.27674400806427,
-0.08639600872993469,
0.05997296795248985,
-0.9067100882530212,
-0.35049811005592346,
-0.17862166464328766,
-0.07116376608610153,
0.20397646725177765,
0.18684755265712738,
0.4132569432258606,
0.489616721868515,
0.5950400829315186,
-0.5526577830314636,
0.2872624695301056,
-0.34033331274986267,
0.1420859396457672,
0.7163819670677185,
0.19774088263511658,
0.4511319398880005,
-0.11257126927375793,
-0.35888543725013733,
-0.2696588635444641,
-0.4042506515979767,
0.15205015242099762,
0.4832640588283539,
0.30222076177597046,
0.23925545811653137,
0.8467127084732056,
-0.21525342762470245,
0.8672448992729187,
-0.09187866747379303,
-0.0031453168485313654,
0.4049367308616638,
-0.7556681632995605,
-0.12244504690170288,
0.37389063835144043,
0.4747990071773529,
0.33840030431747437,
0.04236990213394165,
-0.10789670795202255,
-0.3437737822532654,
0.22382842004299164,
0.6855999231338501,
-0.5302065014839172,
-0.05442135035991669,
0.08234918117523193,
-0.38022148609161377,
-0.6515715718269348,
0.02078547328710556,
-0.7462445497512817,
-0.144413024187088,
-0.6434575915336609,
0.21838314831256866,
-0.7643068432807922,
-0.04911299794912338,
0.26573458313941956,
-0.23384356498718262,
0.22186873853206635,
0.09116820991039276,
-1.0736770629882812,
0.4091823399066925,
0.9740146994590759,
0.8231327533721924,
-0.49944376945495605,
-0.0018746721325442195,
-0.14038732647895813,
0.046804074198007584,
-0.43573519587516785,
0.7657000422477722,
-0.995460569858551,
-0.491120308637619,
0.3739667534828186,
-0.27549922466278076,
-0.08371667563915253,
-0.6002243757247925,
1.0870288610458374,
-0.6875843405723572,
0.4991438388824463,
-0.24483159184455872,
-0.7124816179275513,
-0.45019522309303284,
0.4315386414527893,
-0.7294008731842041,
1.3655118942260742,
-0.07122141867876053,
-0.6938508152961731,
0.31507447361946106,
-0.923861026763916,
-0.44409438967704773,
-0.0025882923509925604,
0.1850660741329193,
-0.3241969645023346,
-0.03269219398498535,
0.5880125164985657,
0.21929103136062622,
0.0024307994171977043,
0.28023073077201843,
-0.04844653606414795,
-0.4807644784450531,
0.14174778759479523,
-0.4890805780887604,
0.8519421219825745,
0.012814396061003208,
-0.18448863923549652,
0.13960979878902435,
-0.8768895268440247,
0.13653188943862915,
-0.1200585588812828,
-0.4692472815513611,
-0.4373874068260193,
0.20726542174816132,
0.07718406617641449,
0.18251612782478333,
0.1974084973335266,
-0.2586159110069275,
0.30176934599876404,
-0.9372868537902832,
0.07609913498163223,
0.5599323511123657,
0.21584491431713104,
0.6705792546272278,
-0.46225228905677795,
0.3796740472316742,
-0.13257327675819397,
0.026818808168172836,
-0.551292896270752,
-0.41454213857650757,
-0.8587764501571655,
0.07495027780532837,
0.3241829574108124,
0.7440056204795837,
-1.0012531280517578,
0.5786542296409607,
-0.1623745858669281,
-0.43808576464653015,
-0.331272155046463,
0.07411247491836548,
0.34567326307296753,
0.537995457649231,
0.6855864524841309,
-0.596550464630127,
-0.9229940176010132,
-0.5926561951637268,
-0.4894565939903259,
-0.1435367912054062,
0.10457783937454224,
-0.15431231260299683,
0.29331687092781067,
-0.17575478553771973,
0.9709440469741821,
-0.36113986372947693,
-0.08136514574289322,
-0.3827238976955414,
0.5289821028709412,
0.14036276936531067,
0.5975136756896973,
0.4137374758720398,
-0.8270161747932434,
-0.2533603012561798,
-0.029098698869347572,
-0.7506837844848633,
-0.1629566103219986,
-0.22598525881767273,
0.25965726375579834,
0.10889197885990143,
0.36191150546073914,
-0.027861207723617554,
0.31938937306404114,
0.40344491600990295,
-0.06475459039211273,
0.7937008738517761,
-0.06166037172079086,
0.32695135474205017,
-0.7988057732582092,
-0.3492491841316223,
0.1658821851015091,
-0.1487220972776413,
-0.928330659866333,
0.23613500595092773,
-0.13189001381397247,
-0.0005241434555500746,
-0.16043098270893097,
0.20158323645591736,
-0.38515326380729675,
0.14500129222869873,
-0.5533382296562195,
0.16584473848342896,
0.03388010337948799,
0.21711450815200806,
0.16215106844902039,
0.8805676102638245,
0.3726906478404999,
-0.5475636720657349,
0.3414740562438965,
0.23208023607730865,
-0.289842814207077,
0.4354523718357086,
-0.5835411548614502,
-0.00856948271393776,
-0.12705844640731812,
0.15434256196022034,
-0.8452025055885315,
0.1107279434800148,
0.15229913592338562,
-0.4126565456390381,
0.4649186134338379,
0.23309080302715302,
-0.437319815158844,
-0.30704963207244873,
-0.3555335998535156,
0.3072749078273773,
0.3478570282459259,
-0.4675816595554352,
0.32699134945869446,
0.24725563824176788,
-0.30442214012145996,
-0.8822743892669678,
-0.7177261710166931,
0.3461516499519348,
-0.23350417613983154,
-0.4964439570903778,
0.7265335917472839,
0.025861600413918495,
-0.23772621154785156,
-0.2806035280227661,
0.023836063221096992,
-0.25988560914993286,
-0.1035347729921341,
-0.13661599159240723,
0.40060558915138245,
-0.26044198870658875,
0.18097589910030365,
0.0818474218249321,
-0.04057367891073227,
0.15832524001598358,
-0.30593642592430115,
0.5560083389282227,
-0.05558325722813606,
-0.358070433139801,
-0.31618255376815796,
0.254562109708786,
-0.027643272653222084,
-0.35072317719459534,
0.938992440700531,
0.964015007019043,
-0.2754945755004883,
0.00787601713091135,
-0.8140966892242432,
-0.2940027713775635,
-0.5168172717094421,
0.4349750876426697,
0.06867486983537674,
-0.8549392223358154,
0.13125410676002502,
-0.21560940146446228,
0.2717362344264984,
0.349651038646698,
0.2754497528076172,
-0.04243010655045509,
1.0975172519683838,
0.7205774784088135,
0.12785601615905762,
0.6926975846290588,
-0.35751280188560486,
0.26505041122436523,
-1.0803167819976807,
-0.16436444222927094,
-0.459773451089859,
-0.20885518193244934,
-0.7287676334381104,
-0.5312944054603577,
0.005527672357857227,
-0.05388956144452095,
-0.06321308761835098,
0.3410435914993286,
-0.8083018064498901,
0.46622177958488464,
0.35723865032196045,
0.2872503399848938,
0.530167281627655,
0.12439411133527756,
-0.09796184301376343,
-0.4039100408554077,
-0.857871413230896,
-0.7018146514892578,
1.1657086610794067,
0.28013738989830017,
0.21244698762893677,
0.012364068999886513,
0.5427993535995483,
0.38583093881607056,
0.23952248692512512,
-0.6976878643035889,
0.5453987717628479,
-0.19838634133338928,
-0.5201850533485413,
-0.21770893037319183,
-0.2701527178287506,
-0.6850899457931519,
0.2198503613471985,
-0.6124508380889893,
-0.5972145795822144,
0.2138606160879135,
-0.146759495139122,
-0.1766553670167923,
0.25900161266326904,
-0.44972482323646545,
0.5004721879959106,
-0.1720597743988037,
-0.276836633682251,
-0.289430171251297,
-0.6039062142372131,
0.5102697014808655,
-0.13408678770065308,
0.13816344738006592,
0.20350830256938934,
-0.3648395240306854,
0.8780258297920227,
-0.11317233741283417,
0.6702777147293091,
0.1257810890674591,
0.04871547222137451,
0.3186556398868561,
-0.4809649586677551,
0.4242740869522095,
-0.10588262230157852,
-0.28509846329689026,
0.08666322380304337,
-0.050576645880937576,
-0.33930158615112305,
-0.6678051352500916,
0.4905722439289093,
-0.4798807203769684,
-0.5256391763687134,
-0.5875753164291382,
-0.7091670036315918,
-0.3688625693321228,
0.02354894019663334,
0.04691290110349655,
0.5281622409820557,
-0.2223346084356308,
0.39610812067985535,
0.8508808612823486,
-0.3649909496307373,
0.7170230150222778,
0.1808733195066452,
-0.009495138190686703,
-0.5457941889762878,
0.7922534346580505,
0.08738256990909576,
0.38143229484558105,
0.4263377785682678,
-0.022563302889466286,
-0.43341219425201416,
-0.8528236150741577,
-0.10871504247188568,
-0.1170390322804451,
-0.6972811222076416,
0.0195297934114933,
-0.7117857336997986,
-0.5115433931350708,
-0.5337481498718262,
-0.35282957553863525,
-0.16120557487010956,
-0.6125829815864563,
-0.3087134063243866,
-0.10864327847957611,
0.19151188433170319,
0.4657704532146454,
0.10518410801887512,
0.7252490520477295,
-0.8437305092811584,
0.18386498093605042,
-0.0009323431877419353,
-0.035227514803409576,
0.05613647773861885,
-0.6127299666404724,
-0.23093029856681824,
0.12074877321720123,
-0.6904637217521667,
-0.8979520201683044,
0.5214284062385559,
0.24344715476036072,
0.5485337376594543,
0.2453344166278839,
-0.020360460504889488,
0.8749879002571106,
-0.5454797148704529,
0.9576276540756226,
0.2746340334415436,
-0.8428788185119629,
0.5896466374397278,
-0.3643310070037842,
0.24170292913913727,
0.6442784667015076,
0.4086068868637085,
-0.42937329411506653,
-0.22000910341739655,
-0.7552861571311951,
-1.083165168762207,
0.628696620464325,
0.42045602202415466,
0.28964799642562866,
0.04006984457373619,
0.4029681086540222,
-0.24695812165737152,
0.43223267793655396,
-0.713168740272522,
-0.30426889657974243,
0.017434684559702873,
-0.23362015187740326,
0.04495621845126152,
-0.39319461584091187,
0.017860760912299156,
-0.3251020610332489,
0.854404628276825,
-0.013159999623894691,
0.052888523787260056,
0.15012817084789276,
-0.016966307535767555,
0.23464860022068024,
0.2816319167613983,
0.476370245218277,
0.8571981191635132,
-0.0902843326330185,
-0.31071561574935913,
0.4950219392776489,
-0.6593183875083923,
0.096818707883358,
0.03165927529335022,
-0.09289797395467758,
0.1564147025346756,
0.517665445804596,
0.6219888925552368,
0.3726920783519745,
-0.6413071751594543,
0.2934701144695282,
0.15333865582942963,
-0.037464436143636703,
-0.20084311068058014,
0.13577504456043243,
-0.37566834688186646,
0.2075611799955368,
0.45175424218177795,
0.21266083419322968,
0.5503969788551331,
-0.4573928117752075,
0.39453572034835815,
0.4281875491142273,
-0.5131442546844482,
0.08544767647981644,
0.17944607138633728,
-0.022105012089014053,
-0.28656721115112305,
0.47329747676849365,
-0.10783139616250992,
-0.5055757164955139,
0.5349830389022827,
0.6992641091346741,
0.6412094831466675,
-0.3701847493648529,
0.30894702672958374,
0.6177169680595398,
0.6004192233085632,
-0.2765233516693115,
-0.04588603228330612,
-0.04311603307723999,
-0.6468688249588013,
-0.879116952419281,
-0.5775706768035889,
-0.49980583786964417,
-0.15826669335365295,
-0.8684397339820862,
0.3962903320789337,
-0.29060134291648865,
-0.2542373239994049,
-0.11515187472105026,
0.22004523873329163,
-0.28622469305992126,
0.4556574523448944,
-0.0036587482318282127,
0.9620192646980286,
-0.5797877907752991,
0.5751146078109741,
0.7749410271644592,
-0.3058065176010132,
-0.42827826738357544,
-0.006527991965413094,
0.06928152590990067,
-0.44370803236961365,
0.5435060858726501,
0.2914939224720001,
0.16002169251441956,
0.03056342341005802,
-0.2993305027484894,
-0.7420393824577332,
0.8819100856781006,
-0.24919436872005463,
-0.502106785774231,
-0.2772207260131836,
0.44274967908859253,
0.6735491752624512,
-0.4100615680217743,
0.3633122742176056,
0.6244136691093445,
0.4274037778377533,
0.24147751927375793,
-0.501110315322876,
-0.23542346060276031,
-0.0674295648932457,
0.3152680993080139,
0.15718594193458557,
-0.22234319150447845,
0.3688470125198364,
0.08685895800590515,
-0.10807958245277405,
0.12611857056617737,
0.8968815803527832,
0.3626843988895416,
0.5118768811225891,
0.39956727623939514,
0.6703299880027771,
0.5601760745048523,
-0.33028239011764526,
0.872249960899353,
-0.21434184908866882,
0.33679258823394775,
1.1642332077026367,
-0.10222554951906204,
0.755457878112793,
0.3701896667480469,
-0.1351691037416458,
0.5924928188323975,
0.6637857556343079,
-0.10952300578355789,
0.43416088819503784,
-0.013948380015790462,
-0.4200930595397949,
0.025917207822203636,
-0.3930691182613373,
-0.3625641465187073,
0.41383007168769836,
0.6934939622879028,
-0.4720844328403473,
-0.18117547035217285,
0.2931062877178192,
-0.1200622096657753,
0.3524632453918457,
-0.3708808720111847,
0.9483218789100647,
0.006972704082727432,
-0.6427670121192932,
0.30602335929870605,
0.24160096049308777,
0.8285111784934998,
-0.5819193720817566,
-0.12802745401859283,
0.2860521376132965,
0.04022468999028206,
-0.265373557806015,
-0.8334385752677917,
0.74751877784729,
0.007366820238530636,
-0.15173108875751495,
-0.36956506967544556,
0.9410781860351562,
-0.35908856987953186,
-0.6704939007759094,
0.0716262087225914,
0.2974846363067627,
-0.32821783423423767,
0.11814607679843903,
-0.9042866230010986,
0.020910482853651047,
-0.14677709341049194,
-0.05596856027841568,
0.2459757924079895,
0.25363752245903015,
0.12851223349571228,
0.4682536721229553,
1.0440354347229004,
0.2343207448720932,
0.03819890320301056,
0.09799209237098694,
0.9066014885902405,
-0.4764256179332733,
-0.3064250946044922,
-0.8725230693817139,
0.651566743850708,
-0.559708297252655,
-0.16323211789131165,
0.929124116897583,
0.558501660823822,
0.9611351490020752,
0.13639302551746368,
0.5691790580749512,
0.17652323842048645,
0.49345946311950684,
-0.7014589309692383,
0.2524574398994446,
-0.2295209765434265,
0.49165263772010803,
-0.46004652976989746,
-1.1036103963851929,
-0.39253541827201843,
0.5841036438941956,
-0.6152514219284058,
0.10732316225767136,
0.7186707258224487,
0.5890913605690002,
0.13189992308616638,
0.4670526683330536,
0.16191905736923218,
-0.210757315158844,
0.299615740776062,
0.1262809783220291,
0.8531076908111572,
-0.65250563621521,
0.24921423196792603,
-0.6226216554641724,
-0.23130476474761963,
0.05705080181360245,
-0.9090558290481567,
-0.8149229884147644,
-0.47846972942352295,
-0.3119009733200073,
-0.20394952595233917,
0.3987767994403839,
0.9593650102615356,
0.5123193860054016,
-0.7585466504096985,
-0.26196983456611633,
-0.2187880128622055,
-0.019582511857151985,
-0.4448566138744354,
-0.35565894842147827,
0.12839406728744507,
-0.912530779838562,
-0.831443727016449,
0.4815013110637665,
0.4111067056655884,
-0.20568904280662537,
-0.086009681224823,
0.1846591979265213,
-0.6929076910018921,
0.21940726041793823,
0.9349112510681152,
0.08287432789802551,
-0.5407857298851013,
0.08548127859830856,
0.12842248380184174,
0.13249477744102478,
0.17152568697929382,
0.9036989808082581,
-0.7384663820266724,
0.6419963836669922,
0.4643675982952118,
0.9248824715614319,
0.205521360039711,
0.2695312798023224,
0.5807180404663086,
-0.9992526173591614,
0.11286754906177521,
0.5053264498710632,
0.08686228096485138,
0.46236443519592285,
-0.3092266619205475,
0.6993190050125122,
0.18384841084480286,
-0.6708702445030212,
-0.8650825023651123,
-0.014260228723287582,
-0.9097879528999329,
-0.16087035834789276,
0.9287250638008118,
0.07831033319234848,
0.10184074193239212,
-0.25612470507621765,
-0.348294198513031,
0.2819627821445465,
-0.1942249834537506,
0.7568893432617188,
0.9582883715629578,
-0.07672180980443954,
-0.16400927305221558,
-0.7498179078102112,
0.5019308924674988,
0.42541375756263733,
-0.9000054597854614,
-0.2570807635784149,
0.42057347297668457,
-0.34533289074897766,
0.41196879744529724,
0.14330673217773438,
-0.26696938276290894,
0.07520629465579987,
-0.3441905081272125,
-0.2060682624578476,
0.04056733474135399,
-0.2774721086025238,
-0.3360826373100281,
0.161363884806633,
-0.15587657690048218,
0.019803030416369438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09136v1 | DolphCoder: Echo-Locating Code Large Language Models with Diverse and Multi-Objective Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-14T12:34:58 | 2024-02-14T12:34:58 | Yejie Wang, Keqing He, Guanting Dong, Pei Wang, Weihao Zeng, Muxi Diao, Yutao Mou, Mengdi Zhang, Jingang Wang, Xunliang Cai, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Code Large Language Models (Code LLMs) have demonstrated outstanding
performance in code-related tasks. Several instruction tuning approaches have
been proposed to boost the code generation performance of pre-trained Code
LLMs. In this paper, we introduce a diverse instruction model (DolphCoder) with
self-evaluating for code generation. It learns diverse instruction targets and
combines a code evaluation objective to enhance its code generation ability.
Our model achieves superior performance on the HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks,
demonstrating new insights for future code instruction tuning work. Our key
findings are: (1) Augmenting more diverse responses with distinct reasoning
paths increases the code capability of LLMs. (2) Improving one's ability to
evaluate the correctness of code solutions also enhances their ability to
create it. | [
-0.46272987127304077,
-0.49753594398498535,
0.4297587275505066,
0.15103460848331451,
-0.1640651524066925,
0.2825463116168976,
-0.4440864622592926,
-0.4165267050266266,
-0.056294869631528854,
0.5647581219673157,
-0.5348489880561829,
-0.6517572402954102,
-0.5488083362579346,
0.05142289400100708,
0.10530365258455276,
0.9606289863586426,
0.16728585958480835,
0.2902905344963074,
0.3090593218803406,
-0.041986122727394104,
-0.5364214181900024,
-0.41667264699935913,
-0.10538483411073685,
0.03381211310625076,
0.42815813422203064,
0.7824039459228516,
0.38187500834465027,
0.9017302393913269,
0.7584117650985718,
0.3554634749889374,
0.16474086046218872,
0.43275710940361023,
-0.6501908302307129,
0.32444527745246887,
-0.13420067727565765,
-0.5022952556610107,
-0.5372399687767029,
-0.0675831139087677,
0.6845229268074036,
0.44208547472953796,
-0.1712460219860077,
0.35542577505111694,
-0.024328483268618584,
0.4757865369319916,
-0.8970539569854736,
-0.358426570892334,
-0.7675756216049194,
-0.0720987543463707,
-0.10263590514659882,
-0.49687620997428894,
-0.4029766917228699,
-0.394756942987442,
-0.35746341943740845,
-0.05838882550597191,
0.291560560464859,
0.20886024832725525,
0.2594344913959503,
0.39871320128440857,
-0.4216914474964142,
-0.6699391603469849,
-0.5530044436454773,
1.2307192087173462,
-0.6658439636230469,
0.37544578313827515,
-0.05321303382515907,
0.23561729490756989,
-0.06002556532621384,
-0.552579939365387,
-0.36404985189437866,
-0.2474706918001175,
0.36786383390426636,
0.16406697034835815,
-0.20612135529518127,
-0.007076383102685213,
0.16310769319534302,
0.8384228944778442,
-0.44690921902656555,
0.5381898283958435,
-0.2444492131471634,
-0.08165185898542404,
0.7089386582374573,
0.3266581892967224,
0.4099927246570587,
-0.06264811009168625,
-0.3398658335208893,
0.024229414761066437,
-0.526631236076355,
-0.27803510427474976,
0.6851224303245544,
0.43859437108039856,
-0.2639547288417816,
0.47559961676597595,
0.038739390671253204,
0.8338912129402161,
0.2906142771244049,
-0.22874580323696136,
0.3426990807056427,
-0.18292024731636047,
-0.12259339541196823,
0.2222626805305481,
0.4104786217212677,
0.31674230098724365,
-0.17430232465267181,
-0.04726819694042206,
-0.3490569293498993,
0.0086793452501297,
0.6372917890548706,
-0.7409756183624268,
-0.08752869814634323,
0.0775853842496872,
-0.8814765810966492,
-0.23253686726093292,
0.008424949832260609,
-0.7254329323768616,
0.0004546995915006846,
-0.36120638251304626,
0.13086670637130737,
-0.3722114562988281,
-0.3546363115310669,
0.2212112993001938,
-0.03164834529161453,
0.38714396953582764,
0.3161727488040924,
-1.0460602045059204,
0.1208406388759613,
0.6990863084793091,
0.4886808693408966,
-0.2523190975189209,
-0.6250014305114746,
-0.801490843296051,
0.1540774405002594,
-0.5711200833320618,
0.7263501286506653,
-1.0958131551742554,
-0.5491340160369873,
-0.13883577287197113,
-0.24369321763515472,
-0.04345892369747162,
-0.8323732018470764,
0.37956473231315613,
-0.3744219243526459,
0.20737224817276,
-0.18270403146743774,
-0.7149315476417542,
-0.067427858710289,
-0.014868797734379768,
-0.36068108677864075,
0.8321623802185059,
0.32498258352279663,
-0.7466160655021667,
0.21074801683425903,
-0.6967264413833618,
-0.4631006121635437,
0.19196434319019318,
-0.2365303933620453,
-0.3901093006134033,
0.5034322738647461,
0.22379793226718903,
0.34088972210884094,
-0.3813234269618988,
0.010071120224893093,
-0.39090439677238464,
-0.6234822273254395,
-0.0323009230196476,
-0.3364535868167877,
0.6178428530693054,
0.5212362408638,
-0.5590996742248535,
0.3474441468715668,
-0.637004017829895,
0.329563707113266,
0.00027141711325384676,
-0.4981941878795624,
-0.02715052291750908,
-0.29134324193000793,
-0.1371781975030899,
-0.03848547860980034,
0.3785511553287506,
-0.2923033833503723,
0.34891751408576965,
0.05709319934248924,
0.13146686553955078,
0.7674025893211365,
0.03441457450389862,
0.3234923481941223,
-0.5478842258453369,
0.7992710471153259,
-0.16387222707271576,
0.17313146591186523,
-0.4345688819885254,
-0.40191516280174255,
-0.7209722399711609,
-0.641791582107544,
-0.06969328969717026,
0.4671350121498108,
-0.2500101327896118,
0.6355699300765991,
0.19297665357589722,
-0.5661024451255798,
-0.8527199625968933,
0.21577176451683044,
0.6095277070999146,
0.3893773555755615,
0.45824742317199707,
-0.06642182916402817,
-0.6696570515632629,
-0.8321806788444519,
-0.19032061100006104,
0.11962056159973145,
-0.028712879866361618,
0.5531889796257019,
0.3536970913410187,
-0.6088496446609497,
0.19523976743221283,
-0.4133998453617096,
0.05444183573126793,
-0.41198185086250305,
0.08513958752155304,
0.5058707594871521,
0.572992205619812,
0.4890417158603668,
-0.42719513177871704,
-0.388979971408844,
-0.1499759703874588,
-0.5472858548164368,
-0.2530656158924103,
0.04065527766942978,
-0.21007521450519562,
0.15380899608135223,
0.141133114695549,
-0.1930529773235321,
0.03118911199271679,
0.8203322291374207,
0.11065784096717834,
0.49093568325042725,
-0.5072912573814392,
0.6043618321418762,
-1.0249269008636475,
-0.037230681627988815,
-0.3525330722332001,
-0.02232385240495205,
-0.27935487031936646,
0.6712192296981812,
0.14924359321594238,
-0.20308206975460052,
-0.1344316303730011,
0.28448307514190674,
-0.7267191410064697,
-0.24372197687625885,
-0.4361870586872101,
-0.24482561647891998,
-0.3124057948589325,
0.34668564796447754,
0.09644820541143417,
0.865017294883728,
0.841593325138092,
-0.6309398412704468,
0.17493565380573273,
-0.17498670518398285,
-0.5148223042488098,
0.42829573154449463,
-0.5674487352371216,
0.5367883443832397,
0.08708213269710541,
-0.14377956092357635,
-0.9323879480361938,
-0.2087613344192505,
0.0856335312128067,
-0.0962204560637474,
0.5566025376319885,
-0.15470513701438904,
-0.3504944443702698,
-0.4207158386707306,
-0.40468040108680725,
0.3887083828449249,
0.855440080165863,
-0.9054390788078308,
0.19912470877170563,
0.3495122790336609,
-0.003693075617775321,
-0.5951091051101685,
-0.22767217457294464,
-0.06830060482025146,
-0.31212010979652405,
-0.34872931241989136,
0.2786414325237274,
-0.26472583413124084,
-0.21078042685985565,
-0.3414784371852875,
-0.3128625452518463,
-0.00497595826163888,
0.16850580275058746,
0.09092072397470474,
0.1596052497625351,
-0.4311870038509369,
0.32732129096984863,
0.37347254157066345,
-0.09222715348005295,
-0.19618725776672363,
-0.311818391084671,
0.6112310886383057,
-0.4165094792842865,
-0.5064144730567932,
-0.1404494047164917,
0.5804708003997803,
0.28060856461524963,
-0.5438627004623413,
0.41229507327079773,
0.5159302353858948,
0.10697764903306961,
-0.5715802311897278,
-0.6942374110221863,
-0.1204003244638443,
-0.5103143453598022,
0.4802124500274658,
-0.270151823759079,
-1.1197822093963623,
0.32890522480010986,
-0.3173651695251465,
0.04930378496646881,
0.3426379859447479,
0.9337644577026367,
-0.24053485691547394,
0.8969129920005798,
0.6304630041122437,
0.13692016899585724,
0.2861267030239105,
-0.059715386480093,
0.19568556547164917,
-0.8681207299232483,
0.007828100584447384,
-0.5511738061904907,
-0.3966656029224396,
-0.8210147619247437,
-0.7679853439331055,
0.20782126486301422,
0.31685784459114075,
-0.3372761011123657,
-0.05115753039717674,
-0.9929020404815674,
0.5824426412582397,
0.6196013689041138,
0.13724537193775177,
0.22890739142894745,
-0.08467023819684982,
-0.05663849785923958,
0.011843066662549973,
-0.8130438923835754,
-0.651370644569397,
1.157703161239624,
0.4635741412639618,
1.005142331123352,
0.08306680619716644,
1.3157213926315308,
0.20850567519664764,
0.33656278252601624,
-0.38288384675979614,
0.3340013921260834,
-0.3108615577220917,
-0.6507337689399719,
-0.12356726825237274,
-0.6368316411972046,
-0.8310901522636414,
0.05688850209116936,
-0.06602321565151215,
-0.5982640385627747,
-0.03450772911310196,
0.23707756400108337,
-0.052310001105070114,
0.36505746841430664,
-0.5732186436653137,
0.7055110931396484,
-0.6930972337722778,
-0.3409141004085541,
-0.559017539024353,
-0.33512595295906067,
0.24694013595581055,
-0.08693359792232513,
0.18064984679222107,
-0.2897006869316101,
-0.27586156129837036,
0.202636256814003,
-0.24918650090694427,
0.7491037845611572,
-0.12319786846637726,
-0.4645220935344696,
0.31330960988998413,
0.16384971141815186,
0.038154952228069305,
0.1447935700416565,
-0.26212823390960693,
0.3625917434692383,
-0.4110369086265564,
-0.3447047770023346,
-0.36965346336364746,
1.0100218057632446,
-0.8191999793052673,
-0.7654393911361694,
0.0755431279540062,
-0.7035786509513855,
0.04541398212313652,
0.3457823097705841,
0.46265411376953125,
0.3580329418182373,
0.1038968563079834,
0.18745504319667816,
0.5874401330947876,
-0.3836406171321869,
0.48001787066459656,
0.61666339635849,
-0.28048092126846313,
-0.36003729701042175,
0.8058352470397949,
-0.18528984487056732,
-0.04074127972126007,
0.4712091386318207,
0.22935056686401367,
-0.17895495891571045,
-0.6114064455032349,
-0.3413015902042389,
0.07442101091146469,
-0.6163484454154968,
-0.33131539821624756,
-0.2740413248538971,
0.011851317249238491,
-0.22773660719394684,
-0.3059251010417938,
-0.5165702104568481,
-0.07323744893074036,
-0.14304688572883606,
0.15290415287017822,
0.09224659204483032,
0.8567604422569275,
-0.3091045916080475,
0.21566946804523468,
-1.0452336072921753,
0.4981634020805359,
0.4382003843784332,
0.6741859316825867,
0.03703117370605469,
-0.5487061738967896,
-0.2864299416542053,
0.03944479301571846,
-0.327882319688797,
-0.8979187607765198,
0.0729178786277771,
0.17880254983901978,
1.07742178440094,
0.019935045391321182,
0.022725006565451622,
0.546288251876831,
-0.4975050985813141,
0.35026681423187256,
0.2843763530254364,
-1.1972604990005493,
0.8176735043525696,
-0.5013704299926758,
0.680526614189148,
0.41745367646217346,
0.4195708930492401,
0.011322878301143646,
-0.4784587323665619,
-0.3182213008403778,
-0.4393060803413391,
0.5691069960594177,
0.05084354802966118,
0.3168098032474518,
-0.42766231298446655,
0.44076424837112427,
0.4301450550556183,
0.19654279947280884,
-0.5921623110771179,
-0.1120636910200119,
-0.11357749998569489,
-0.25358089804649353,
0.17773312330245972,
-0.27132701873779297,
-0.0998801738023758,
-0.1174863800406456,
0.2563939392566681,
-0.23070983588695526,
0.3602759838104248,
0.022614827379584312,
-0.08114930242300034,
-0.3480587303638458,
0.3515859842300415,
0.5561703443527222,
0.9195708632469177,
-0.19488541781902313,
0.012544985860586166,
0.13919740915298462,
-0.1804315745830536,
0.07802285999059677,
-0.17045150697231293,
0.319675475358963,
-0.25312477350234985,
0.82927006483078,
0.8247880935668945,
0.345588356256485,
-0.5860133171081543,
0.2526560425758362,
-0.1356966346502304,
-0.03445545583963394,
0.10408682376146317,
0.7184762358665466,
0.02558373101055622,
0.45817604660987854,
0.39920198917388916,
0.14673826098442078,
0.270373672246933,
-0.5574449300765991,
0.31543266773223877,
0.2578919231891632,
-0.08155962079763412,
0.08257570117712021,
0.6112076640129089,
0.4131259322166443,
-0.6053035259246826,
0.9564757347106934,
-0.14482389390468597,
-0.37486377358436584,
0.6520618200302124,
0.8710007667541504,
0.9504971504211426,
-0.6266757249832153,
-0.03876854479312897,
0.38137778639793396,
0.20344285666942596,
0.3388722240924835,
0.6987630724906921,
-0.3819967806339264,
-0.6359087228775024,
-0.4350524842739105,
-0.5483942031860352,
-0.27556973695755005,
-0.31659626960754395,
-0.9799566864967346,
0.27838653326034546,
-0.6195087432861328,
-0.11850622296333313,
-0.3223389983177185,
-0.12281151860952377,
-0.6699763536453247,
0.17370109260082245,
0.4920070767402649,
0.6352972388267517,
-0.3854432702064514,
0.914197564125061,
0.714053213596344,
0.016514722257852554,
-0.7383977770805359,
0.3044743537902832,
-0.2554798126220703,
-1.0570696592330933,
0.781535804271698,
0.4567207992076874,
-0.46704843640327454,
-0.004879877902567387,
-0.4963298738002777,
-0.6758000254631042,
0.8200424313545227,
0.6267915368080139,
-1.0939379930496216,
0.1844830960035324,
-0.251530259847641,
0.5361142754554749,
-0.7121415138244629,
0.35714900493621826,
0.2744946777820587,
0.10032358020544052,
-0.03472231701016426,
-0.8635022640228271,
-0.19786715507507324,
-0.2590387761592865,
0.07019978016614914,
0.3241511285305023,
-0.8214948773384094,
0.820850133895874,
-0.6932522058486938,
0.03969612717628479,
0.035750191658735275,
0.19661672413349152,
0.6898449659347534,
0.055339518934488297,
0.37598520517349243,
0.5082629323005676,
0.8716304302215576,
0.22784316539764404,
1.2262732982635498,
-0.7274701595306396,
0.3747800886631012,
1.323655366897583,
-0.3126489222049713,
0.7629504203796387,
0.20021803677082062,
-0.044684141874313354,
0.5267500281333923,
0.5172643661499023,
-0.21558834612369537,
0.5980867147445679,
0.3189884126186371,
0.03797544911503792,
-0.5843546986579895,
0.1500568836927414,
-0.7390483021736145,
0.8073989748954773,
0.07547444850206375,
-0.4324907064437866,
0.06641191989183426,
-0.2450929433107376,
-0.20980946719646454,
0.1760866791009903,
-0.4316158890724182,
0.6315016150474548,
-0.06090669706463814,
-0.5701470971107483,
0.6560497283935547,
0.050926439464092255,
0.5938930511474609,
-0.5502712726593018,
-0.3375275433063507,
-0.39356884360313416,
0.288875550031662,
-0.16932253539562225,
-0.6355331540107727,
0.15438728034496307,
0.008959139697253704,
-0.2881753444671631,
-0.24513931572437286,
0.48899707198143005,
-0.23644952476024628,
-0.715938925743103,
0.6032795310020447,
0.3941223621368408,
0.04788075014948845,
0.37374454736709595,
-0.7623686790466309,
0.4025258421897888,
0.24404381215572357,
-0.10980016738176346,
0.21130670607089996,
0.41475892066955566,
0.4290101230144501,
0.5754546523094177,
0.4137573540210724,
-0.07769433408975601,
0.21008093655109406,
0.10661952197551727,
0.8215674161911011,
-0.6583342552185059,
-0.39021703600883484,
-0.7981189489364624,
0.4210742115974426,
0.008471840061247349,
-0.5425949692726135,
0.899502158164978,
0.6997352242469788,
0.8159464001655579,
-0.24805527925491333,
0.6412301659584045,
0.2187613993883133,
0.6284696459770203,
-0.5763680338859558,
0.32643166184425354,
-0.6300704479217529,
0.5417794585227966,
-0.36078548431396484,
-1.3997176885604858,
-0.25544285774230957,
0.8025640845298767,
-0.3471250832080841,
0.40261831879615784,
0.4298174977302551,
0.6474831104278564,
-0.14047248661518097,
-0.03686973452568054,
0.35967233777046204,
-0.0652301236987114,
0.06970325857400894,
0.6912360191345215,
1.250209093093872,
-0.09939903020858765,
0.23253312706947327,
-0.263713002204895,
-0.37712621688842773,
-0.28725987672805786,
-0.8545321226119995,
-0.8814385533332825,
-0.13343459367752075,
-0.3598010838031769,
0.20769496262073517,
0.0812128558754921,
0.8740144371986389,
0.8376851081848145,
-0.7423796653747559,
-0.5688723921775818,
0.0269154142588377,
0.21054603159427643,
-0.1711905300617218,
-0.12488259375095367,
0.08597902953624725,
-0.9624992609024048,
-0.8092207908630371,
0.5287213325500488,
0.6739036440849304,
-0.18749839067459106,
-0.0974959060549736,
-0.38717538118362427,
0.17282940447330475,
-0.0327446311712265,
0.2071489542722702,
-0.13260459899902344,
-0.684303343296051,
-0.1797591596841812,
0.11034300178289413,
-0.09710469841957092,
0.29344791173934937,
0.9944393634796143,
-0.2985682189464569,
0.6231566667556763,
0.27230411767959595,
0.5045939683914185,
0.37025174498558044,
-0.12684501707553864,
0.7094998359680176,
-0.5113276839256287,
0.12477689236402512,
0.4394350051879883,
0.3681785762310028,
0.08110593259334564,
-0.49181079864501953,
0.39237818121910095,
-0.35729843378067017,
-0.8076649904251099,
-0.7831569910049438,
0.290828138589859,
-0.5663149952888489,
-0.5256547331809998,
0.744898796081543,
-0.25687649846076965,
0.06578059494495392,
0.2652549147605896,
-0.27544569969177246,
0.20964524149894714,
-0.14745664596557617,
0.9440449476242065,
0.12619251012802124,
-0.37050628662109375,
-0.4602811932563782,
-0.06665435433387756,
0.0916573628783226,
0.5129681825637817,
-0.8254768252372742,
-0.09337017685174942,
0.6580489277839661,
0.2721100151538849,
0.028001783415675163,
0.4476156532764435,
-0.060385562479496,
0.5255955457687378,
0.2280605286359787,
0.19330783188343048,
-0.05668805167078972,
-0.5482364892959595,
-0.33765992522239685,
0.23110514879226685,
0.4480123817920685,
-0.3144180476665497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09126v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09126v2 | MPIrigen: MPI Code Generation through Domain-Specific Language Models | 2024-02-14T12:24:21 | 2024-04-23T16:59:46 | Nadav Schneider, Niranjan Hasabnis, Vy A. Vo, Tal Kadosh, Neva Krien, Mihai Capotă, Guy Tamir, Ted Willke, Nesreen Ahmed, Yuval Pinter, Timothy Mattson, Gal Oren | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | The imperative need to scale computation across numerous nodes highlights the
significance of efficient parallel computing, particularly in the realm of
Message Passing Interface (MPI) integration. The challenging parallel
programming task of generating MPI-based parallel programs has remained
unexplored. This study first investigates the performance of state-of-the-art
language models in generating MPI-based parallel programs. Findings reveal that
widely used models such as GPT-3.5 and PolyCoder (specialized multi-lingual
code models) exhibit notable performance degradation, when generating MPI-based
programs compared to general-purpose programs. In contrast, domain-specific
models such as MonoCoder, which are pretrained on MPI-related programming
languages of C and C++, outperform larger models. Subsequently, we introduce a
dedicated downstream task of MPI-based program generation by fine-tuning
MonoCoder on HPCorpusMPI. We call the resulting model as MPIrigen. We propose
an innovative preprocessing for completion only after observing the whole code,
thus enabling better completion with a wider context. Comparative analysis
against GPT-3.5 zero-shot performance, using a novel HPC-oriented evaluation
method, demonstrates that MPIrigen excels in generating accurate MPI functions
up to 0.8 accuracy in location and function predictions, and with more than 0.9
accuracy for argument predictions. The success of this tailored solution
underscores the importance of domain-specific fine-tuning in optimizing
language models for parallel computing code generation, paving the way for a
new generation of automatic parallelization tools. The sources of this work are
available at our GitHub MPIrigen repository:
https://github.com/Scientific-Computing-Lab-NRCN/MPI-rigen | [
-0.6290661692619324,
-0.08670113980770111,
0.5688349008560181,
0.3757747709751129,
0.0160949919372797,
-0.08278941363096237,
-0.10774052143096924,
-0.08302236348390579,
-0.015350398607552052,
0.4399598240852356,
-0.4768272340297699,
-0.5067044496536255,
-0.7279245257377625,
0.07102271914482117,
-0.09399310499429703,
0.754163920879364,
-0.2541232109069824,
0.036760374903678894,
-0.4393353760242462,
-0.15966486930847168,
0.04057293012738228,
-0.8003533482551575,
-0.4367360472679138,
-0.5266278386116028,
0.5196934342384338,
0.3833094835281372,
0.2803209125995636,
0.9541893601417542,
0.6629921793937683,
0.16524899005889893,
0.2899492383003235,
0.033838409930467606,
-0.3799339830875397,
-0.3323988914489746,
-0.07820670306682587,
-0.3350740075111389,
-0.49078643321990967,
0.026886669918894768,
0.7935970425605774,
0.659827709197998,
-0.23399856686592102,
0.39742615818977356,
0.05861566588282585,
0.46205273270606995,
-0.8599086403846741,
0.13444556295871735,
-0.5397495627403259,
-0.052065614610910416,
-0.3822159469127655,
-0.4160976707935333,
-0.4377163052558899,
-0.2051011472940445,
-0.3775387704372406,
-0.15846900641918182,
0.07121890038251877,
-0.24346362054347992,
0.5662664175033569,
0.3258168399333954,
-0.16719086468219757,
-0.12666194140911102,
-0.7039546966552734,
0.9317799806594849,
-0.9059550762176514,
0.0852503851056099,
-0.08407476544380188,
0.23642177879810333,
-0.07738078385591507,
-1.0401420593261719,
-0.5314183831214905,
-0.13275916874408722,
0.01272193156182766,
-0.07006523013114929,
-0.09625940024852753,
0.18466117978096008,
0.5361413955688477,
0.25349774956703186,
-0.6947985887527466,
0.0323086753487587,
-0.3575862646102905,
0.09740525484085083,
0.47841066122055054,
0.24723853170871735,
0.37386441230773926,
0.08122316747903824,
0.00228329049423337,
-0.025961309671401978,
-0.9237916469573975,
-0.03543013706803322,
0.4695553481578827,
0.17127567529678345,
-0.07372488081455231,
0.533517062664032,
-0.1828940063714981,
0.7479174137115479,
-0.24945476651191711,
-0.2860225737094879,
0.1499192714691162,
-0.16457770764827728,
-0.2612311840057373,
0.07275467365980148,
0.7130249738693237,
0.24635322391986847,
0.48642581701278687,
-0.0024692765437066555,
-0.07684070616960526,
0.2608902156352997,
0.11211700737476349,
-1.2017192840576172,
-0.1991720348596573,
0.3633788228034973,
-0.5962105393409729,
-0.3499867618083954,
-0.023280203342437744,
-0.44330278038978577,
-0.10207527875900269,
-0.4862612783908844,
0.028770476579666138,
-0.2674658000469208,
-0.26776090264320374,
0.017138352617621422,
0.07118020951747894,
0.1858251839876175,
-0.2945176064968109,
-0.6240078806877136,
0.2434561550617218,
0.6858701705932617,
0.6924457550048828,
-0.3421705663204193,
-0.7323814630508423,
-0.6296761631965637,
0.33400291204452515,
-0.028738223016262054,
0.5467288494110107,
-0.8866077661514282,
-0.5012907981872559,
-0.16357867419719696,
-0.0998007282614708,
-0.4284023940563202,
-0.6123962998390198,
0.4527963399887085,
-0.056161943823099136,
-0.26392436027526855,
-0.11753815412521362,
-0.45365163683891296,
0.30728667974472046,
-0.15016336739063263,
-0.11759527772665024,
0.4787965714931488,
-0.11917493492364883,
-1.1015805006027222,
0.11330857127904892,
-0.7366819381713867,
-0.5388998985290527,
-0.0019136749906465411,
-0.2729688584804535,
-0.3932958245277405,
0.2541891038417816,
0.24006204307079315,
0.29776731133461,
-0.547553300857544,
0.323689728975296,
-0.2398446500301361,
-0.5172111988067627,
-0.019836250692605972,
-0.10739711672067642,
0.44644537568092346,
0.48181670904159546,
-0.4501078128814697,
0.13837870955467224,
-0.719356119632721,
0.33124956488609314,
0.03310035914182663,
-0.2715553343296051,
0.24335455894470215,
0.14263653755187988,
-0.09057297557592392,
0.11682768911123276,
0.30732545256614685,
-0.6775724291801453,
0.20843535661697388,
0.054181057959795,
0.3321073055267334,
0.4268551170825958,
-0.07705747336149216,
0.20665039122104645,
-0.26733407378196716,
0.6107732057571411,
0.045214809477329254,
0.30819085240364075,
-0.5049465298652649,
-0.44020047783851624,
-0.6388633251190186,
-0.29678910970687866,
0.500378429889679,
0.6701374650001526,
-0.7452552914619446,
-0.08567413687705994,
-0.30755919218063354,
-0.626528263092041,
-0.2881409227848053,
-0.0580151304602623,
0.5324972867965698,
0.2225216180086136,
0.006869885139167309,
-0.2285826951265335,
-0.5837206244468689,
-1.0834816694259644,
-0.22928817570209503,
-0.11389830708503723,
-0.007378578186035156,
0.5223133563995361,
0.19545409083366394,
-0.5436958074569702,
0.47611111402511597,
-0.6660051345825195,
0.3056377172470093,
-0.34865421056747437,
0.534197986125946,
0.11499863117933273,
0.7189381122589111,
0.6295430660247803,
-0.7353667616844177,
-0.5739366412162781,
0.16587786376476288,
-0.6205027103424072,
-0.39930886030197144,
0.0845835879445076,
-0.08771520853042603,
-0.15556758642196655,
0.4496876895427704,
-0.5498545169830322,
0.2570086121559143,
0.6806371808052063,
0.18036596477031708,
0.6109928488731384,
-0.35716724395751953,
0.39531460404396057,
-0.9329186677932739,
0.5460677742958069,
-0.07328440248966217,
-0.07727105915546417,
-0.78523188829422,
0.4228193461894989,
-0.10084749758243561,
-0.541684627532959,
-0.5020738244056702,
0.18883255124092102,
-0.26939657330513,
-0.016782062128186226,
-0.5469552874565125,
-0.39771851897239685,
-0.31891968846321106,
0.49814075231552124,
0.11717215180397034,
1.144325852394104,
0.8029679656028748,
-0.5871875286102295,
0.03089369647204876,
-0.4594162702560425,
-0.1433742791414261,
-0.052669912576675415,
-0.8048161864280701,
0.1689492017030716,
-0.12076667696237564,
-0.10748090595006943,
-0.39443713426589966,
-0.4209635555744171,
0.04466850310564041,
-0.37922143936157227,
0.34135398268699646,
-0.3454316258430481,
-0.5382234454154968,
-0.33464282751083374,
0.1590910702943802,
0.7271291017532349,
0.7834518551826477,
-0.47807079553604126,
0.44325339794158936,
0.4063775837421417,
-0.3288441300392151,
-0.42343848943710327,
-0.586914598941803,
-0.06189480051398277,
0.00428790831938386,
-0.5297175645828247,
0.2398860901594162,
-0.1482708901166916,
-0.13374647498130798,
-0.2973432242870331,
0.10839353501796722,
-0.11854854971170425,
-0.23155653476715088,
0.3468874394893646,
-0.0884086936712265,
-0.2772439122200012,
-0.36577197909355164,
0.17632080614566803,
-0.22392599284648895,
-0.13006144762039185,
-0.5990169048309326,
0.6795427799224854,
-0.23606273531913757,
-0.5835646986961365,
-0.42780059576034546,
0.6779435873031616,
1.032812476158142,
-0.6998174786567688,
0.8341099619865417,
0.5856412053108215,
-0.24434685707092285,
-0.049416281282901764,
-0.4369993209838867,
0.1283842772245407,
-0.4101984202861786,
0.041026826947927475,
-0.7804833054542542,
-0.7890287041664124,
0.3708723485469818,
-0.4657534062862396,
-0.19625724852085114,
0.15597917139530182,
0.5527856945991516,
0.40511637926101685,
1.4917677640914917,
0.9988671541213989,
0.03474581986665726,
0.20102640986442566,
-0.09419874846935272,
0.3948732018470764,
-0.553549587726593,
-0.000011627821550064255,
-0.5342953205108643,
-0.1578155755996704,
-0.7007788419723511,
-0.4052716791629791,
0.38272327184677124,
0.11977463215589523,
-0.07799284905195236,
0.46272337436676025,
-0.6493918895721436,
0.6008222699165344,
0.5757911801338196,
-0.35469549894332886,
-0.036732017993927,
0.14054779708385468,
-0.35484305024147034,
-0.011821727268397808,
-0.8177615404129028,
-0.5053991079330444,
0.9145625829696655,
0.26535630226135254,
0.5011271834373474,
-0.16634228825569153,
0.9092835187911987,
0.09967511147260666,
0.5467449426651001,
-0.012145018205046654,
0.5001041293144226,
-0.48776671290397644,
-0.07520455121994019,
0.29035577178001404,
-0.8089069724082947,
-0.3746330738067627,
-0.08828267455101013,
0.3466966450214386,
-0.8227930068969727,
0.36949992179870605,
0.07120196521282196,
-0.24350988864898682,
0.41830578446388245,
-1.019316554069519,
1.06987726688385,
0.0932227075099945,
-0.3796645402908325,
-0.19417493045330048,
-0.26370111107826233,
0.41414445638656616,
-0.10657992959022522,
-0.09430454671382904,
-0.15310727059841156,
0.2339933067560196,
0.17306166887283325,
-0.4077923893928528,
0.3985847532749176,
-0.3985000252723694,
0.10168825089931488,
0.4244867265224457,
-0.0871942937374115,
0.3811458349227905,
0.06564870476722717,
-0.23651430010795593,
0.1598992794752121,
0.15679050981998444,
-0.5478290915489197,
-0.40553849935531616,
1.1471550464630127,
-0.4932723641395569,
-0.46839842200279236,
-0.007380431517958641,
-0.595217764377594,
0.04440135881304741,
0.2970442771911621,
0.49711450934410095,
0.7519226670265198,
0.10196734219789505,
-0.12161332368850708,
0.6489640474319458,
-0.40874308347702026,
0.2907496988773346,
0.2332182377576828,
-0.3747323751449585,
-0.15962328016757965,
1.3688255548477173,
-0.17235615849494934,
0.06968242675065994,
0.2899092733860016,
-0.364210844039917,
0.23057973384857178,
-0.70304274559021,
-0.43670129776000977,
0.38016605377197266,
-0.30442014336586,
-0.16123108565807343,
-0.6962282061576843,
-0.37204888463020325,
-0.5210740566253662,
-0.14730769395828247,
-0.4412049353122711,
-0.28002485632896423,
-0.01443009078502655,
0.39820295572280884,
-0.315091073513031,
0.6269611716270447,
-0.13056540489196777,
0.37175458669662476,
-0.8156821131706238,
0.12121973186731339,
0.15827518701553345,
0.4777348041534424,
-0.18874216079711914,
0.1752137988805771,
-0.1919119954109192,
-0.001994979102164507,
-0.11677413433790207,
-0.5421904921531677,
0.31726258993148804,
0.15161389112472534,
0.4569244086742401,
0.20012900233268738,
-0.11649281531572342,
0.4317023754119873,
-0.6235342025756836,
0.584925651550293,
0.060328494757413864,
-0.8565657138824463,
0.6305903196334839,
-0.40185993909835815,
0.6873296499252319,
0.38740789890289307,
0.4563894271850586,
-0.23077572882175446,
-0.2576408088207245,
-0.35603299736976624,
-0.4025636613368988,
0.6651731729507446,
0.5482726097106934,
-0.11926102638244629,
-0.14001978933811188,
0.6129471063613892,
-0.11487659811973572,
0.28923267126083374,
-0.4011002480983734,
-0.2812679708003998,
-0.06364565342664719,
-0.29297757148742676,
-0.15465183556079865,
-0.37435585260391235,
0.14769385755062103,
-0.19036297500133514,
0.587857186794281,
-0.3132779896259308,
0.43067118525505066,
0.2526945471763611,
0.13186196982860565,
0.008274538442492485,
0.18864239752292633,
0.7294161915779114,
0.9616125226020813,
-0.15719012916088104,
-0.056368447840213776,
-0.14362084865570068,
-0.4203796684741974,
-0.033130958676338196,
0.41329681873321533,
-0.08562827110290527,
-0.03539680317044258,
0.08253820985555649,
0.6923736333847046,
-0.43233782052993774,
-0.9280024170875549,
0.5743383169174194,
-0.3245968818664551,
-0.03472709283232689,
-0.21240608394145966,
0.22045141458511353,
-0.0029157460667192936,
0.14017096161842346,
0.09265749156475067,
0.34174010157585144,
0.2460152506828308,
-0.2293214350938797,
0.3871326148509979,
0.1847776174545288,
-0.15859726071357727,
-0.24125534296035767,
0.7871686220169067,
0.045382313430309296,
-0.03331892192363739,
0.4827355444431305,
-0.44427523016929626,
-0.3687187731266022,
0.7092067003250122,
0.46073174476623535,
0.8761382699012756,
-0.17797169089317322,
0.09276844561100006,
0.5194193124771118,
0.24965542554855347,
0.22080761194229126,
0.26448628306388855,
-0.25625520944595337,
-0.4718913435935974,
-0.757077693939209,
-1.0074872970581055,
-0.1746470332145691,
-0.038320351392030716,
-0.3909711241722107,
0.05771009251475334,
-0.565222442150116,
-0.307175874710083,
0.05158941447734833,
-0.2739827632904053,
-0.4096628427505493,
0.13790756464004517,
0.49451470375061035,
0.967319905757904,
-0.5631158351898193,
1.211290955543518,
0.9504969716072083,
-0.046442098915576935,
-0.6778295636177063,
0.2710460126399994,
-0.21330375969409943,
-0.2154819518327713,
0.5104250907897949,
0.17547859251499176,
-0.22817304730415344,
0.1173369437456131,
-0.3485892415046692,
-0.5585052371025085,
0.8193132281303406,
0.5447725057601929,
-0.46863123774528503,
-0.05759812891483307,
0.6256527304649353,
0.4073971211910248,
-0.9437041878700256,
0.1806728094816208,
0.6796103119850159,
0.23932376503944397,
0.07422083616256714,
-0.8895376324653625,
-0.2706952691078186,
-0.5579735040664673,
0.3949853181838989,
0.36605769395828247,
-0.5961434841156006,
0.7953919172286987,
-0.1432127058506012,
-0.11862631142139435,
0.3719748258590698,
0.40079569816589355,
0.31540629267692566,
0.21582190692424774,
0.010854789055883884,
0.6003327369689941,
0.4058518409729004,
-0.20844249427318573,
1.5128145217895508,
-0.9481832981109619,
0.10741762071847916,
0.8583657145500183,
-0.3261904716491699,
0.6423699259757996,
0.2891470789909363,
0.12172462046146393,
0.397060364484787,
0.2777942419052124,
0.08873383700847626,
0.41567349433898926,
0.1950322985649109,
-0.6125946640968323,
-0.27481821179389954,
-0.40041178464889526,
-0.29017674922943115,
0.3205651640892029,
0.2616748511791229,
-0.49101826548576355,
-0.03931408002972603,
0.14182844758033752,
-0.11924130469560623,
-0.049388736486434937,
-0.27438536286354065,
0.36799266934394836,
0.04491788148880005,
-0.9392720460891724,
0.683521568775177,
0.3342616558074951,
0.4476304054260254,
-0.5697599053382874,
-0.04680117964744568,
-0.25027909874916077,
0.6163391470909119,
-0.021010462194681168,
-0.3371131420135498,
0.5121491551399231,
0.1459500938653946,
-0.45432010293006897,
-0.06553392112255096,
0.8042778968811035,
-0.3770004212856293,
-0.5167267918586731,
0.20466288924217224,
0.35158488154411316,
0.22585105895996094,
-0.07843395322561264,
-0.5610578060150146,
0.39821845293045044,
0.3250354826450348,
0.19082267582416534,
0.35738277435302734,
0.01648835837841034,
0.33216020464897156,
0.5869757533073425,
0.6068309545516968,
0.10986644774675369,
0.1973084956407547,
0.19071067869663239,
0.7472726106643677,
-0.2554936707019806,
-0.04426313191652298,
-0.562920868396759,
0.3509009778499603,
-0.05281446501612663,
-0.15298660099506378,
0.5115839838981628,
0.6943231225013733,
0.7563959360122681,
-0.2696778476238251,
0.7711661458015442,
-0.19648951292037964,
0.4002940058708191,
-0.21250636875629425,
0.7051165103912354,
-0.5130041241645813,
0.18338866531848907,
-0.08103080093860626,
-1.0390909910202026,
-0.25663578510284424,
-0.08251829445362091,
-0.4054526388645172,
0.008938096463680267,
0.444852352142334,
1.063422441482544,
-0.31855452060699463,
-0.12594351172447205,
0.33963459730148315,
-0.008005991578102112,
0.27754053473472595,
0.7438101172447205,
0.5144508481025696,
-0.30007100105285645,
0.515686571598053,
-0.431931734085083,
-0.43836700916290283,
0.2573164403438568,
-0.6241176724433899,
-0.7445842027664185,
-0.40782707929611206,
-0.5611183047294617,
0.08426260948181152,
0.2056588977575302,
0.4403578042984009,
0.8638670444488525,
-0.87437504529953,
-0.42718419432640076,
-0.4225596487522125,
-0.2055748850107193,
0.04635811969637871,
-0.20833995938301086,
0.04470592364668846,
-0.5986959934234619,
-0.9128430485725403,
0.27272549271583557,
0.4462949335575104,
-0.0708773285150528,
0.01352316327393055,
-0.2302369922399521,
0.02272200398147106,
0.2460518330335617,
0.3883717358112335,
0.5125247836112976,
-0.44043371081352234,
0.2296513468027115,
-0.18795765936374664,
-0.1074611097574234,
-0.013164302334189415,
1.2884037494659424,
-0.5392996668815613,
0.21400396525859833,
0.42398205399513245,
0.5755563974380493,
0.5243319869041443,
0.07332950085401535,
0.8290382623672485,
-0.7611654996871948,
0.31410181522369385,
-0.041117388755083084,
0.4138588607311249,
0.24531559646129608,
-0.22418645024299622,
0.3134824335575104,
0.18073709309101105,
-0.6782765984535217,
-0.7986577749252319,
0.472576767206192,
-0.2894878685474396,
-0.25432088971138,
0.8950081467628479,
-0.3011946976184845,
-0.35719165205955505,
0.5012345314025879,
-0.17030826210975647,
0.1393318474292755,
0.14374692738056183,
0.15848670899868011,
0.3405996859073639,
-0.36567947268486023,
-0.4498869776725769,
-0.3576793074607849,
0.5295463800430298,
0.4271297752857208,
-0.5972534418106079,
0.0825432613492012,
0.15851789712905884,
0.14210879802703857,
0.32982707023620605,
0.4456239342689514,
-0.32461458444595337,
0.33686742186546326,
0.3854002058506012,
0.3743264079093933,
-0.1379842609167099,
-0.48947134613990784,
-0.06345438957214355,
0.43827730417251587,
0.2208034098148346,
0.011952604167163372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09025v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09025v4 | SLEB: Streamlining LLMs through Redundancy Verification and Elimination of Transformer Blocks | 2024-02-14T09:01:13 | 2024-06-12T01:40:12 | Jiwon Song, Kyungseok Oh, Taesu Kim, Hyungjun Kim, Yulhwa Kim, Jae-Joon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have proven to be highly effective across
various natural language processing tasks. However, their large number of
parameters poses significant challenges for practical deployment. Pruning, a
technique aimed at reducing the size and complexity of LLMs, offers a potential
solution by removing redundant components from the network. Despite the promise
of pruning, existing methods often struggle to achieve substantial end-to-end
LLM inference speedup. In this paper, we introduce SLEB, a novel approach
designed to streamline LLMs by eliminating redundant transformer blocks. We
choose the transformer block as the fundamental unit for pruning, because LLMs
exhibit block-level redundancy with high similarity between the outputs of
neighboring blocks. This choice allows us to effectively enhance the processing
speed of LLMs. Our experimental results demonstrate that SLEB outperforms
previous LLM pruning methods in accelerating LLM inference while also
maintaining superior perplexity and accuracy, making SLEB as a promising
technique for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs. The code is available at:
https://github.com/jiwonsong-dev/SLEB. | [
-0.4860903024673462,
-0.9021704792976379,
0.39810317754745483,
0.39990004897117615,
-0.5941333174705505,
0.255465567111969,
-0.47526103258132935,
-0.31772300601005554,
0.22022999823093414,
0.5851854085922241,
-0.6530624628067017,
-0.547890305519104,
-0.42960378527641296,
0.1572997123003006,
-0.7255259156227112,
0.7445256114006042,
0.009712956845760345,
-0.23244549334049225,
-0.16678737103939056,
0.036783818155527115,
-0.5117794871330261,
-0.12491107732057571,
-0.5681167244911194,
-0.5471562147140503,
0.3118683099746704,
0.3709360659122467,
0.49853959679603577,
0.6561760902404785,
0.46226561069488525,
0.4425904154777527,
-0.5230393409729004,
0.4492088258266449,
-0.7032106518745422,
0.4088343381881714,
-0.09727773815393448,
-0.4568121135234833,
-0.48494571447372437,
-0.49045422673225403,
0.7378280162811279,
0.5757623314857483,
-0.21346528828144073,
0.3276095688343048,
-0.07974782586097717,
0.6681639552116394,
-0.4744362533092499,
-0.0846780315041542,
-0.8126320242881775,
-0.20854227244853973,
-0.34573066234588623,
-0.05835353210568428,
-0.600684404373169,
-0.5324878096580505,
-0.0787854716181755,
-0.10335025936365128,
0.466653972864151,
0.17737187445163727,
1.1421867609024048,
0.31901583075523376,
-0.36855849623680115,
0.14414082467556,
-0.79849773645401,
0.7410937547683716,
-0.7391798496246338,
0.3243168294429779,
0.04532352089881897,
0.15609826147556305,
-0.17560900747776031,
-0.8952736258506775,
-0.40111520886421204,
0.010779760777950287,
-0.3911377191543579,
-0.11526692658662796,
-0.03436990827322006,
0.25480917096138,
0.22513152658939362,
0.3785775601863861,
-0.6005749106407166,
0.11666776239871979,
-0.6000040769577026,
-0.40713492035865784,
0.6522955894470215,
0.003835056908428669,
-0.020102106034755707,
-0.13052920997142792,
-0.3779219090938568,
0.29577192664146423,
-0.9271700978279114,
-0.20749616622924805,
0.43263447284698486,
-0.03492036834359169,
0.41685932874679565,
0.46555095911026,
-0.02537006326019764,
0.7373573184013367,
-0.19037170708179474,
-0.27458903193473816,
0.20793417096138,
-0.22241105139255524,
-0.35921838879585266,
0.06006504222750664,
0.5218636989593506,
0.2333909273147583,
0.23284946382045746,
-0.16587676107883453,
-0.37834370136260986,
0.1250644326210022,
0.4150891602039337,
-0.7812298536300659,
-0.15309610962867737,
0.39227548241615295,
-0.3003007173538208,
-0.2476956993341446,
-0.13262884318828583,
-0.5462669134140015,
-0.2717878818511963,
-0.22696486115455627,
-0.062367308884859085,
-0.41056063771247864,
-0.4006827175617218,
0.048265691846609116,
0.0947493463754654,
0.33902421593666077,
0.3198561668395996,
-0.5415295958518982,
0.2589168846607208,
1.057315707206726,
0.6990899443626404,
-0.29126131534576416,
-0.2626936733722687,
-0.2973089814186096,
0.058214638382196426,
-0.26027917861938477,
0.8234483599662781,
-0.25724655389785767,
-0.14777548611164093,
-0.1905490756034851,
-0.00546907028183341,
0.24723610281944275,
-0.7615951895713806,
0.6174328327178955,
-0.6397307515144348,
-0.36133113503456116,
0.12646636366844177,
-0.5937532186508179,
-0.26462987065315247,
0.3001490533351898,
-0.6642277836799622,
1.0828527212142944,
-0.08620118349790573,
-0.49875345826148987,
0.006356074474751949,
-0.3137952983379364,
-0.9437305927276611,
0.38162145018577576,
0.057643331587314606,
-0.7104431390762329,
0.3790559768676758,
0.06162325665354729,
0.3433792293071747,
-0.36971041560173035,
0.7797365784645081,
-0.15578396618366241,
-0.6943219304084778,
-0.052265942096710205,
-0.3356408178806305,
0.7061823010444641,
0.1289430558681488,
-0.22201527655124664,
0.3363291025161743,
-0.9075261354446411,
0.22127266228199005,
0.22051185369491577,
-0.25311899185180664,
-0.24586786329746246,
0.05205446481704712,
-0.25892016291618347,
-0.1800469011068344,
0.15903529524803162,
-0.5317423939704895,
0.09828951954841614,
-0.4355335533618927,
0.569420576095581,
0.9237804412841797,
-0.010952115058898926,
0.42766696214675903,
-0.2125525325536728,
0.3264921009540558,
-0.14014612138271332,
-0.04847094044089317,
-0.28414732217788696,
-0.20431220531463623,
-1.0353693962097168,
-0.561102032661438,
0.4606175720691681,
0.46528998017311096,
-0.48109593987464905,
0.6521232724189758,
-0.3144587278366089,
-0.475930392742157,
-0.8249324560165405,
0.2365674376487732,
0.16375641524791718,
0.379364550113678,
0.33327892422676086,
-0.015521209686994553,
-0.9891021251678467,
-1.1158415079116821,
-0.26324230432510376,
-0.07032757997512817,
-0.12258356809616089,
-0.009752637706696987,
0.3864765465259552,
-0.26629260182380676,
1.1000032424926758,
-0.37508440017700195,
-0.019671836867928505,
-0.6763322949409485,
0.025682242587208748,
0.2944243848323822,
0.3262578845024109,
-0.21781788766384125,
-0.7609415650367737,
-0.27201858162879944,
-0.08786128461360931,
-0.522131085395813,
-0.5133877396583557,
-0.3814621567726135,
-0.02970808371901512,
0.07258028537034988,
0.5589945912361145,
-0.5324702262878418,
0.44490957260131836,
0.5084925293922424,
-0.07824062556028366,
0.7344940900802612,
-0.026185352355241776,
-0.24139852821826935,
-0.44450700283050537,
-0.0924549326300621,
-0.031769800931215286,
-0.7096129655838013,
-0.8049800395965576,
0.09571564197540283,
0.2714889645576477,
0.08005152642726898,
-0.4820818305015564,
0.39672917127609253,
-0.7351968288421631,
-0.14190340042114258,
-0.33980032801628113,
0.439703106880188,
0.19112999737262726,
0.51004558801651,
-0.10825435817241669,
0.7424018383026123,
0.26814085245132446,
-0.650407612323761,
0.5358449816703796,
-0.012161815539002419,
-0.3467196822166443,
0.2318033128976822,
-0.6706641912460327,
-0.03740426152944565,
-0.4565516710281372,
0.26177915930747986,
-0.8562328815460205,
0.21803787350654602,
-0.11627744138240814,
0.04059145972132683,
0.25628963112831116,
0.005946184508502483,
-0.4824497699737549,
-0.5261625647544861,
-0.25453847646713257,
0.1939500868320465,
0.6390044093132019,
-0.5620858669281006,
0.790268063545227,
0.2868216931819916,
-0.1707371473312378,
-0.416960209608078,
-0.7166346311569214,
0.07960528135299683,
-0.2503372132778168,
-0.7177581787109375,
0.5085155367851257,
0.06468251347541809,
-0.26485639810562134,
-0.07302610576152802,
-0.5183404684066772,
-0.04634736105799675,
0.3394479751586914,
0.14401262998580933,
0.3963470458984375,
-0.1722666472196579,
0.1884629875421524,
-0.0628185123205185,
-0.25300586223602295,
-0.02415488474071026,
-0.07752764225006104,
0.7109227776527405,
-0.28124338388442993,
-0.5886412858963013,
-0.4839598834514618,
0.1334736943244934,
0.5281669497489929,
-0.24142703413963318,
0.5008328557014465,
0.5526149868965149,
-0.24007776379585266,
-0.5170264840126038,
-0.9027639627456665,
-0.300425261259079,
-0.5100398063659668,
0.5322619676589966,
-0.25835421681404114,
-0.966859757900238,
0.3374970555305481,
-0.5120549201965332,
0.3394521176815033,
-0.02614525891840458,
0.3820261061191559,
-0.020591212436556816,
0.44213545322418213,
0.5215402841567993,
-0.037108417600393295,
0.3136475086212158,
-0.1308128982782364,
0.7320864796638489,
-0.9225246906280518,
-0.13257449865341187,
-0.421976774930954,
-0.628889799118042,
-0.33179721236228943,
-0.49080801010131836,
-0.05166437476873398,
0.26702144742012024,
-0.08967332541942596,
0.514497697353363,
-0.5577396750450134,
0.750507652759552,
0.43582016229629517,
0.06748923659324646,
0.5500023365020752,
-0.11542137712240219,
0.029820626601576805,
-0.07991186529397964,
-0.4947665333747864,
-0.488626092672348,
0.5905209183692932,
0.47818660736083984,
0.6975111961364746,
-0.03072536550462246,
0.8111190795898438,
0.027804479002952576,
0.5842598676681519,
-0.6299793124198914,
1.0772590637207031,
0.13329963386058807,
-0.555287778377533,
-0.45352908968925476,
-0.4585103988647461,
-0.726771891117096,
0.6752086877822876,
-0.001239622593857348,
-0.6779949069023132,
-0.2728816866874695,
0.25757071375846863,
-0.08320289105176926,
0.5193096995353699,
-0.8254373669624329,
0.5560268759727478,
-0.2916848957538605,
-0.44301900267601013,
-0.23485836386680603,
-0.5216917991638184,
0.5653974413871765,
-0.0748172178864479,
0.1646394580602646,
-0.18680688738822937,
0.04753094166517258,
0.4884834289550781,
-0.5693615078926086,
0.8280629515647888,
-0.011443689465522766,
-0.04352697730064392,
0.3653479218482971,
0.15236319601535797,
0.9515067338943481,
-0.014158586040139198,
0.03127945587038994,
0.16726644337177277,
-0.587669312953949,
-0.28730371594429016,
-0.4634109139442444,
0.6229451298713684,
-0.2255011796951294,
-0.7385007739067078,
-0.026941578835248947,
-0.5202715396881104,
-0.11562864482402802,
0.32751789689064026,
-0.07357913255691528,
0.1603773683309555,
0.10512785613536835,
0.36608409881591797,
0.6864911913871765,
-0.1292611062526703,
0.5128065943717957,
0.3353467583656311,
-0.3286932408809662,
-0.2727207541465759,
0.9172772169113159,
-0.12671421468257904,
0.2878227233886719,
0.24213390052318573,
-0.03026430308818817,
-0.18812885880470276,
-0.9791615009307861,
0.06522452086210251,
0.5991994738578796,
-0.630829393863678,
-0.4355201721191406,
-0.3995300531387329,
-0.4240366816520691,
-0.16514942049980164,
-0.20487436652183533,
-0.5081420540809631,
-0.08711657673120499,
0.03447496518492699,
-0.332830548286438,
0.05470757558941841,
0.5870614051818848,
0.4482896029949188,
0.5633634328842163,
-0.8261359930038452,
0.2872329652309418,
0.03670790046453476,
0.4865127503871918,
-0.0036404479760676622,
-0.31477612257003784,
0.004652590956538916,
-0.31771212816238403,
-0.2081342488527298,
-0.7592666149139404,
0.3985144793987274,
-0.1305982619524002,
0.5524110794067383,
0.31455403566360474,
0.12801268696784973,
1.0597050189971924,
-0.5827416181564331,
0.6069028973579407,
0.17742829024791718,
-1.0202556848526,
0.2567712068557739,
0.20677413046360016,
0.32374563813209534,
0.43369704484939575,
-0.01431227196007967,
-0.5304141044616699,
-0.7599722743034363,
-0.7258269190788269,
-1.286316156387329,
0.43666189908981323,
0.240530326962471,
-0.3427910804748535,
0.09144924581050873,
0.2175694853067398,
-0.05859173461794853,
0.43165111541748047,
-0.871810257434845,
-0.4480740427970886,
0.17693664133548737,
-0.11364375799894333,
0.21072937548160553,
-0.5108514428138733,
0.0070487093180418015,
-0.07814890146255493,
0.9651178121566772,
0.08766268193721771,
-0.039765335619449615,
0.1685951054096222,
-0.6695569157600403,
0.19959315657615662,
0.4352949559688568,
0.5475947856903076,
0.7053800821304321,
0.026135489344596863,
0.2950107753276825,
0.5420923829078674,
-0.35156458616256714,
0.21621067821979523,
-0.3521600067615509,
-0.5145346522331238,
0.28252890706062317,
0.4421093761920929,
0.8499724864959717,
0.29007288813591003,
-0.7764182090759277,
0.2970324158668518,
-0.06480192393064499,
-0.14401660859584808,
-0.18139730393886566,
-0.14692920446395874,
0.3475515842437744,
0.2671811580657959,
0.37732577323913574,
0.03149404004216194,
-0.1955629140138626,
0.06456193327903748,
0.21629473567008972,
0.350472092628479,
0.04948324337601662,
-0.1104726791381836,
0.18073061108589172,
0.3367263674736023,
-0.5524582266807556,
0.6617400646209717,
-0.29384344816207886,
-0.5631985664367676,
0.574129045009613,
0.728823184967041,
0.74178147315979,
0.004384192172437906,
0.09225944429636002,
0.32854509353637695,
0.6713114976882935,
-0.22571511566638947,
-0.10784163326025009,
-0.0535658597946167,
-0.5946860909461975,
-0.8126838207244873,
-0.7757677435874939,
-0.2675569951534271,
0.31205570697784424,
-0.43234458565711975,
0.4749204218387604,
-0.40129196643829346,
0.022075582295656204,
-0.37195730209350586,
-0.12611044943332672,
-0.2605816721916199,
-0.13662874698638916,
0.17934750020503998,
1.0618407726287842,
-0.6907131671905518,
0.8214118480682373,
0.4820469617843628,
0.19508565962314606,
-0.7263903617858887,
-0.1680092066526413,
-0.016743287444114685,
-0.591733455657959,
0.5004935264587402,
0.3273438513278961,
-0.11780605465173721,
0.023468000814318657,
-0.30018261075019836,
-0.6411007046699524,
1.2002464532852173,
0.38116493821144104,
-1.0178557634353638,
-0.19612175226211548,
-0.10257658362388611,
0.35757726430892944,
-0.10096219927072525,
0.2955404818058014,
0.8801770806312561,
0.7438838481903076,
0.1774962842464447,
-0.5805355906486511,
0.1868886798620224,
0.02206999994814396,
0.17075660824775696,
0.6260538697242737,
-0.3850926160812378,
0.5877984762191772,
-0.23135513067245483,
-0.37508997321128845,
-0.1285734325647354,
0.9450396299362183,
0.487017422914505,
0.10385571420192719,
0.776762843132019,
0.500135600566864,
1.0163118839263916,
-0.2886415123939514,
0.4434434175491333,
-0.27869880199432373,
0.5182588696479797,
1.1833889484405518,
-0.520383358001709,
0.6173722147941589,
0.715860903263092,
-0.31272801756858826,
0.4321383535861969,
0.29594072699546814,
-0.07105156779289246,
0.19507478177547455,
0.4720776379108429,
-0.3010328412055969,
-0.30163148045539856,
0.18912266194820404,
0.0746149942278862,
0.09508437663316727,
0.276951402425766,
0.0264388807117939,
-0.549109697341919,
-0.1630270779132843,
0.12711447477340698,
0.0826444998383522,
-0.2141098827123642,
0.5541338920593262,
-0.013588806614279747,
-0.7100201845169067,
0.5853719711303711,
0.023684436455368996,
0.9002841114997864,
-0.8289211392402649,
0.188905730843544,
-0.28199028968811035,
0.3465559184551239,
-0.35318291187286377,
-0.49412044882774353,
0.561434268951416,
-0.17279548943042755,
0.014589115977287292,
-0.6225010752677917,
1.0141119956970215,
-0.46685418486595154,
-0.26764625310897827,
0.4133356809616089,
0.30649444460868835,
0.15013976395130157,
0.05653592571616173,
-0.3135358691215515,
0.40556755661964417,
0.380719393491745,
-0.4203564524650574,
0.1927267462015152,
0.3793492019176483,
-0.05860928073525429,
0.935545027256012,
0.7556787133216858,
0.5597390532493591,
0.1376577764749527,
0.06320016086101532,
0.7686490416526794,
-0.8091292977333069,
-0.2526422441005707,
-1.1310126781463623,
0.6127839088439941,
-0.42199453711509705,
0.09721878170967102,
0.6003620028495789,
0.5909263491630554,
0.748552143573761,
0.07411680370569229,
0.543209433555603,
0.012457674369215965,
0.4228428602218628,
-0.16218475997447968,
0.45011475682258606,
-0.24293388426303864,
0.7431814074516296,
0.22643311321735382,
-0.7642821073532104,
-0.39561226963996887,
0.6850171089172363,
-0.14027833938598633,
-0.28501951694488525,
0.971079409122467,
1.09099280834198,
0.06693976372480392,
0.09854848682880402,
0.3319312036037445,
0.46576517820358276,
0.5066458582878113,
0.28183090686798096,
0.5185609459877014,
-0.25807011127471924,
0.8851706385612488,
-0.3581162393093109,
-0.1498616337776184,
-0.2092529982328415,
-1.0396887063980103,
-0.8651014566421509,
-0.23395320773124695,
-0.286250501871109,
-0.28261369466781616,
-0.011790478602051735,
0.7560542225837708,
0.5316749215126038,
-0.6523028016090393,
-0.30829131603240967,
-0.32300710678100586,
0.6484994888305664,
-0.41104286909103394,
-0.23394718766212463,
0.016259051859378815,
-0.4513028562068939,
-0.6341810822486877,
0.4045507311820984,
0.4689615070819855,
-0.14811104536056519,
-0.4041633605957031,
0.047137655317783356,
-0.351570188999176,
-0.10896947234869003,
0.5347836017608643,
0.04192069172859192,
-0.8386619091033936,
0.02679496631026268,
-0.2678031921386719,
-0.12407058477401733,
0.0740835890173912,
0.9701823592185974,
-0.8906677961349487,
-0.16339431703090668,
0.6650633811950684,
0.7719890475273132,
0.5627511143684387,
0.22801771759986877,
0.4907449185848236,
-0.9983683228492737,
0.1893685758113861,
0.3811548948287964,
0.5637264847755432,
0.23201029002666473,
-0.09092321991920471,
0.4540106952190399,
0.2456945925951004,
-0.5096789002418518,
-1.305885672569275,
0.39429670572280884,
-0.7513882517814636,
-0.3516875207424164,
1.2219467163085938,
-0.1281120926141739,
-0.6456379890441895,
-0.09949570149183273,
-0.3204440474510193,
0.11420515924692154,
-0.29710692167282104,
0.4488813877105713,
0.6382814049720764,
0.20388786494731903,
-0.33763498067855835,
-0.34992220997810364,
0.03828691691160202,
0.5721549391746521,
-0.8329517245292664,
0.4916878342628479,
0.30692625045776367,
0.3386784493923187,
0.22414030134677887,
0.5452879071235657,
0.05147024616599083,
-0.06613133102655411,
-0.2950572073459625,
0.3218112289905548,
-0.3541319966316223,
-0.40715301036834717,
-0.33704185485839844,
0.5480487942695618,
-0.1150238886475563,
-0.006344734691083431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09015v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09015v3 | Towards better Human-Agent Alignment: Assessing Task Utility in LLM-Powered Applications | 2024-02-14T08:46:15 | 2024-02-22T23:49:10 | Negar Arabzadeh, Julia Kiseleva, Qingyun Wu, Chi Wang, Ahmed Awadallah, Victor Dibia, Adam Fourney, Charles Clarke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid development in the field of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to
a surge in applications that facilitate collaboration among multiple agents to
assist humans in their daily tasks. However, a significant gap remains in
assessing whether LLM-powered applications genuinely enhance user experience
and task execution efficiency. This highlights the pressing need for methods to
verify utility of LLM-powered applications, particularly by ensuring alignment
between the application's functionality and end-user needs. We introduce
AgentEval provides an implementation for the math problems, a novel framework
designed to simplify the utility verification process by automatically
proposing a set of criteria tailored to the unique purpose of any given
application. This allows for a comprehensive assessment, quantifying the
utility of an application against the suggested criteria. We present a
comprehensive analysis of the robustness of quantifier's work. | [
-0.17802634835243225,
-0.5063764452934265,
0.46215903759002686,
0.22399815917015076,
0.1934913694858551,
0.4309896230697632,
-0.17682009935379028,
-0.4404420256614685,
0.026828106492757797,
0.5294113755226135,
-0.42586928606033325,
-0.4480828642845154,
-0.4256829023361206,
0.032350122928619385,
-0.2583770453929901,
0.5937909483909607,
-0.2006436288356781,
-0.010294800624251366,
-0.8862820863723755,
-0.31520015001296997,
-0.6920021772384644,
-0.4267396330833435,
-0.4469815492630005,
-0.7180285453796387,
0.054659586399793625,
0.4879874289035797,
1.1830005645751953,
0.5319828391075134,
0.948145866394043,
0.5379112958908081,
0.47559574246406555,
0.17337971925735474,
-0.27144190669059753,
0.43556803464889526,
-0.13043081760406494,
-0.34378868341445923,
-1.0965728759765625,
-0.039207495748996735,
0.38819825649261475,
0.6458435654640198,
-0.4608665406703949,
0.3281305432319641,
0.1515720635652542,
0.5963274240493774,
-0.8325155973434448,
0.029012011364102364,
-0.5047388076782227,
-0.286725789308548,
-0.06731097400188446,
-0.27757352590560913,
-0.26328617334365845,
-0.41346311569213867,
-0.13579069077968597,
-0.6002402901649475,
-0.04068998619914055,
0.08836384117603302,
0.7969094514846802,
0.7382380366325378,
-0.6584237217903137,
-0.17038196325302124,
-0.6662185192108154,
0.9485403299331665,
-0.4405636191368103,
0.37101995944976807,
0.4733286499977112,
0.6665816307067871,
-0.2924148440361023,
-0.5383338928222656,
-0.6004858016967773,
-0.4177553653717041,
-0.12238695472478867,
-0.08292078971862793,
-0.34032928943634033,
0.19342033565044403,
0.2823221981525421,
0.13555066287517548,
-0.6966965198516846,
0.07109232991933823,
0.23964129388332367,
-0.468380331993103,
0.7777406573295593,
0.47465968132019043,
0.4967348575592041,
0.08114971220493317,
-0.2670270502567291,
-0.14909054338932037,
-0.6128516793251038,
0.22888264060020447,
0.411044180393219,
0.20371410250663757,
0.036958903074264526,
0.7763638496398926,
-0.00018007414473686367,
0.5939757227897644,
-0.13708040118217468,
-0.18655599653720856,
0.13909611105918884,
-0.4008721113204956,
-0.2054775357246399,
0.07916527986526489,
0.482460618019104,
0.4538784623146057,
0.342316210269928,
-0.1330188512802124,
-0.28896522521972656,
0.1829220950603485,
0.455810546875,
-0.684390664100647,
0.26621174812316895,
0.5016223788261414,
-0.12432340532541275,
-0.27963122725486755,
-0.08631376922130585,
-0.26981300115585327,
-0.6560406684875488,
-0.4923047721385956,
0.3237378001213074,
-0.24707292020320892,
-0.21987096965312958,
0.1674765795469284,
0.1758735328912735,
0.3581998348236084,
0.2525741159915924,
-0.9107118844985962,
0.5116947293281555,
1.2182433605194092,
0.6349896192550659,
-0.2409832626581192,
-0.3664449453353882,
-0.8877760171890259,
0.018161704763770103,
-0.20533734560012817,
0.7698414921760559,
-0.26984256505966187,
-0.15022291243076324,
0.05324019491672516,
-0.13924618065357208,
-0.04134676605463028,
-0.5125739574432373,
0.687339723110199,
-0.5758222937583923,
-0.11669211089611053,
-0.1997765451669693,
-0.5930346250534058,
0.30790281295776367,
0.45512983202934265,
-0.6068965196609497,
1.1097874641418457,
0.3225281834602356,
-0.48150622844696045,
0.3211047947406769,
-0.7569716572761536,
-0.4446001946926117,
0.16479256749153137,
-0.12939739227294922,
-0.6074683666229248,
0.0172658022493124,
-0.009843969717621803,
0.1798090636730194,
-0.48774442076683044,
0.33289453387260437,
-0.22630053758621216,
-0.20161205530166626,
0.5079457759857178,
-0.3874049484729767,
0.9348059892654419,
0.26231738924980164,
-0.3987700343132019,
0.35870757699012756,
-0.7382461428642273,
0.2121107280254364,
-0.08937351405620575,
0.05799616128206253,
-0.4530317485332489,
0.14412735402584076,
0.08943961560726166,
-0.01671392284333706,
0.6583849787712097,
-0.48593682050704956,
0.13695602118968964,
-0.32827073335647583,
0.17418795824050903,
0.7059608101844788,
-0.47539737820625305,
0.5611693263053894,
-0.46135371923446655,
0.9548079967498779,
-0.522772490978241,
0.3623341917991638,
0.11854177713394165,
-0.1684202253818512,
-0.4190179705619812,
-0.3716248869895935,
0.36455613374710083,
0.7501312494277954,
-0.683910608291626,
0.7493005394935608,
-0.3058071732521057,
-0.4869135022163391,
-0.422396183013916,
0.264139860868454,
0.35729578137397766,
0.46346887946128845,
0.03003113530576229,
-0.008367989212274551,
-0.3175872564315796,
-0.7971280813217163,
-0.39981719851493835,
-0.3229254484176636,
-0.2628241777420044,
0.37482449412345886,
0.19864937663078308,
-0.24755561351776123,
1.3410356044769287,
-0.29724112153053284,
-0.19237422943115234,
-0.16925108432769775,
-0.16517899930477142,
-0.010388256050646305,
0.3376232385635376,
0.4482278525829315,
-0.8225855231285095,
-0.6199010014533997,
0.28953707218170166,
-0.7638559341430664,
-0.7252723574638367,
0.06468167155981064,
-0.23602841794490814,
0.12874536216259003,
0.21709761023521423,
-0.6220489740371704,
0.4474138021469116,
0.5860272645950317,
-0.6044292449951172,
0.44645431637763977,
-0.2911757528781891,
0.2729661464691162,
-1.0015870332717896,
0.31805434823036194,
-0.08690628409385681,
-0.5127921104431152,
-0.57474285364151,
0.1193479523062706,
0.20207206904888153,
-0.01758044771850109,
-0.2508571445941925,
0.5803706049919128,
-0.49060699343681335,
-0.26491400599479675,
-0.5048747062683105,
0.17663505673408508,
0.07749353349208832,
0.020874693989753723,
-0.40563929080963135,
1.0586833953857422,
0.4705747961997986,
-0.3056797385215759,
0.5316066145896912,
0.09929832816123962,
-0.010024718940258026,
0.8928577899932861,
-0.7283524870872498,
0.1347566395998001,
0.17292624711990356,
-0.12852489948272705,
-1.0540270805358887,
-0.24666009843349457,
-0.1263393759727478,
-0.4205794036388397,
0.06042429432272911,
0.2446601539850235,
-0.503846287727356,
-0.13176243007183075,
-0.365981787443161,
0.6522459387779236,
0.4916316568851471,
-0.3925878405570984,
1.1363048553466797,
0.5041103959083557,
0.026035545393824577,
-0.7816339731216431,
-0.19282737374305725,
0.16923737525939941,
-0.2841774821281433,
-1.050252079963684,
0.3709897994995117,
0.05657615885138512,
-0.6996318697929382,
-0.048811979591846466,
-0.12548260390758514,
0.11400210857391357,
0.4283161461353302,
0.40541544556617737,
0.4464191198348999,
0.042832955718040466,
0.04995127022266388,
-0.06267024576663971,
-0.3918325901031494,
-0.018069999292492867,
-0.1066352128982544,
0.2905510663986206,
-0.2825392484664917,
-0.7681704759597778,
-0.27895814180374146,
0.081380195915699,
0.5950511693954468,
-0.250447154045105,
0.3393578827381134,
0.39007773995399475,
-0.36260131001472473,
0.07042140513658524,
-0.6295241713523865,
0.08340257406234741,
-0.5806690454483032,
0.23382209241390228,
-0.1629190742969513,
-0.8048486709594727,
0.7310786247253418,
-0.2495194673538208,
0.20676791667938232,
0.26469749212265015,
0.6652864217758179,
0.16709962487220764,
1.302701711654663,
0.7703226804733276,
0.020728735253214836,
0.4529767632484436,
-0.030360842123627663,
0.003385914722457528,
-0.587956428527832,
-0.168436199426651,
-0.6784868836402893,
-0.29595476388931274,
-0.4931904971599579,
-0.17249058187007904,
0.5506897568702698,
-0.24254898726940155,
-0.09442556649446487,
0.5224155783653259,
-0.43390214443206787,
0.6331768035888672,
0.18008358776569366,
-0.3235478103160858,
0.3444414436817169,
0.04061835631728172,
-0.006548276171088219,
0.03819853812456131,
-0.3479892909526825,
-0.8028407692909241,
0.9304256439208984,
0.3040095567703247,
0.8677331805229187,
0.44944193959236145,
0.5922024250030518,
0.48491817712783813,
0.4681450128555298,
-0.9791175723075867,
0.6215705871582031,
-0.08169107884168625,
-0.4388333261013031,
-0.6233562231063843,
-0.32248571515083313,
-1.4410006999969482,
0.2738953232765198,
-0.04121912270784378,
-0.8985109925270081,
-0.03304154425859451,
0.2710549235343933,
-0.467365562915802,
-0.11775549501180649,
-0.7216194868087769,
0.9615554213523865,
-0.6037793159484863,
-0.7915719747543335,
-0.29460811614990234,
-0.45069608092308044,
0.051678914576768875,
-0.009739204309880733,
0.1833009272813797,
-0.40166500210762024,
-0.30085811018943787,
0.39788326621055603,
-0.8955641388893127,
0.5705176591873169,
-0.026240747421979904,
-0.4484562575817108,
0.1860860139131546,
0.04985930025577545,
0.489942729473114,
-0.17356768250465393,
-0.24547500908374786,
0.012964433059096336,
0.18044357001781464,
-0.5199355483055115,
-0.9215479493141174,
0.6620883345603943,
-0.6440799832344055,
-0.6581124663352966,
-0.5841010212898254,
-0.6122162938117981,
-0.4004867672920227,
0.19435067474842072,
-0.20741896331310272,
0.34101614356040955,
-0.2993496060371399,
0.05396305024623871,
0.27142325043678284,
0.2743184566497803,
0.3944392502307892,
0.538543701171875,
-0.3432866930961609,
-0.3486432731151581,
0.7963624000549316,
-0.22254762053489685,
0.21658176183700562,
0.4154406785964966,
0.20099128782749176,
-0.49431347846984863,
-0.2630326747894287,
-0.4048590362071991,
-0.11333926022052765,
-0.4396446943283081,
-0.34370720386505127,
-0.09717311710119247,
0.004574960097670555,
-0.3517444431781769,
-0.2517370879650116,
-0.41607406735420227,
-0.32256823778152466,
-0.1775166392326355,
0.23241059482097626,
0.13196223974227905,
0.4889795184135437,
0.03650497645139694,
0.35931074619293213,
-0.750316321849823,
0.20917242765426636,
0.43139439821243286,
0.29357457160949707,
-0.16244767606258392,
-0.1814626306295395,
-0.3750329315662384,
-0.12213340401649475,
-0.6223902106285095,
-0.6902515888214111,
0.33833619952201843,
0.16093413531780243,
0.6317563056945801,
0.44223752617836,
0.17853569984436035,
0.4508141279220581,
-0.36927103996276855,
0.7428431510925293,
0.23052847385406494,
-1.1866168975830078,
0.36202675104141235,
-0.03946606442332268,
0.14622603356838226,
0.6096253395080566,
0.07558224350214005,
-0.3569101393222809,
-0.23396000266075134,
-0.5315982699394226,
-0.7341554164886475,
0.3702233135700226,
0.505649209022522,
-0.02343844622373581,
0.26497870683670044,
0.3303641676902771,
-0.04324507713317871,
0.09088575094938278,
-0.23908039927482605,
-0.1543048918247223,
-0.09362675994634628,
-0.4505743086338043,
-0.12008602172136307,
-0.041620370000600815,
-0.14945200085639954,
-0.09056996554136276,
0.45974594354629517,
-0.368243545293808,
-0.07634291052818298,
-0.03861352428793907,
-0.18607711791992188,
-0.2545648515224457,
0.33930328488349915,
0.6553595662117004,
0.8648779988288879,
-0.1599551886320114,
0.42149797081947327,
0.0873224139213562,
-0.645677387714386,
0.5401280522346497,
0.3214569091796875,
0.062060341238975525,
-0.3186700642108917,
0.5253125429153442,
0.4527502655982971,
0.043104272335767746,
-0.8740107417106628,
0.762298047542572,
-0.29429277777671814,
-0.02902042120695114,
-0.2853551506996155,
0.3813858926296234,
-0.18290618062019348,
0.4106685221195221,
0.46353262662887573,
-0.11614744365215302,
0.19720208644866943,
-0.27196741104125977,
0.16337373852729797,
0.9202238321304321,
-0.18718279898166656,
-0.239263117313385,
0.45197251439094543,
0.28656336665153503,
-0.9318255186080933,
0.2644251883029938,
-0.1271878331899643,
-0.48789191246032715,
0.8372944593429565,
0.4099419414997101,
1.1512343883514404,
-0.3791393041610718,
0.04269268363714218,
-0.11621381342411041,
0.3043254017829895,
0.16651129722595215,
0.3750196695327759,
-0.22293399274349213,
-0.7278321385383606,
-0.667834997177124,
-0.40921375155448914,
-0.5898792147636414,
-0.37266623973846436,
-0.5723544955253601,
0.20850315690040588,
0.0702342838048935,
-0.6538974642753601,
0.09840130805969238,
0.25426796078681946,
-0.6161364316940308,
-0.3143532872200012,
-0.2484266757965088,
0.7350423336029053,
-0.6958429217338562,
0.8010059595108032,
0.9551486968994141,
-0.014593588188290596,
-0.7275025844573975,
0.011609354987740517,
-0.020121486857533455,
-0.9662156105041504,
0.5940755009651184,
-0.04616154730319977,
-0.4762938916683197,
-0.0898885652422905,
-0.4490728974342346,
-0.7390387654304504,
1.3621994256973267,
0.9157630801200867,
-0.4849187731742859,
0.36301732063293457,
0.5526783466339111,
0.6517882943153381,
-0.2588734030723572,
0.4022350013256073,
0.5355732440948486,
0.5731386542320251,
0.2187192738056183,
-1.25334894657135,
0.11156834661960602,
-0.2872806191444397,
0.05932600051164627,
0.3812922239303589,
-0.3972814679145813,
0.3938325047492981,
-0.1463679075241089,
-0.11508326232433319,
0.10795316845178604,
0.5828486680984497,
0.28972646594047546,
0.7265071272850037,
0.5888451337814331,
0.3182448148727417,
1.0184067487716675,
0.15694434940814972,
1.0533286333084106,
-0.5279315114021301,
0.4901820719242096,
0.7579997777938843,
-0.726110577583313,
0.5641754865646362,
0.5169065594673157,
-0.481599360704422,
0.3100852966308594,
0.3054579198360443,
0.3294665217399597,
0.17002904415130615,
0.277925580739975,
-0.37400341033935547,
-0.49482646584510803,
-0.26527154445648193,
-0.26155781745910645,
0.5571033954620361,
0.06758031994104385,
0.22937443852424622,
-0.3295830488204956,
-0.015880664810538292,
-0.24545173346996307,
0.34006327390670776,
-0.10496384650468826,
0.7303318977355957,
0.041546404361724854,
-0.7953240275382996,
0.4538317024707794,
-0.03507763892412186,
0.36471784114837646,
-0.49911126494407654,
-0.09027820825576782,
-0.11034324020147324,
0.30560368299484253,
-0.38473257422447205,
-0.6151722073554993,
0.29634296894073486,
-0.08477848768234253,
0.018106799572706223,
-0.15033124387264252,
1.0340989828109741,
-0.21492743492126465,
-0.3460000157356262,
0.006398632191121578,
0.6512795090675354,
0.08876506984233856,
-0.009420821443200111,
-0.6812990307807922,
0.16506792604923248,
-0.42352065443992615,
0.0864029973745346,
0.4250432550907135,
0.3484967350959778,
-0.15340055525302887,
0.9204007983207703,
0.5494998097419739,
-0.039133090525865555,
-0.2897413372993469,
0.13692238926887512,
0.5819811820983887,
-0.35999608039855957,
-0.4499105215072632,
-1.194211721420288,
0.4384794235229492,
-0.22833168506622314,
-0.010723737068474293,
1.0274319648742676,
0.5907857418060303,
0.19236785173416138,
0.28108474612236023,
0.4292990565299988,
0.09616241604089737,
0.08976703137159348,
-0.35262802243232727,
0.5959751009941101,
-0.5864094495773315,
0.6195802092552185,
-0.2029278427362442,
-0.799815833568573,
-0.3907150328159332,
0.6061281561851501,
-0.3871169686317444,
0.1516939252614975,
0.6132896542549133,
0.8725855350494385,
0.011013471521437168,
-0.10688971728086472,
0.5126244425773621,
-0.43501511216163635,
0.4410013258457184,
0.5644839406013489,
1.0809499025344849,
-0.24499750137329102,
0.35266953706741333,
-0.04345147684216499,
-0.48727676272392273,
-0.2835102677345276,
-1.328262209892273,
-0.7423186898231506,
-0.4922395646572113,
-0.4301537275314331,
-0.5979270339012146,
-0.0916578620672226,
1.2625600099563599,
0.6718311905860901,
-0.7437425851821899,
-0.6758860349655151,
-0.1913531869649887,
0.44134247303009033,
-0.4734867513179779,
-0.16385486721992493,
0.49951228499412537,
-0.29363197088241577,
-0.5585547685623169,
0.021083341911435127,
0.3613860011100769,
-0.08272828161716461,
-0.531710684299469,
-0.4013725519180298,
0.34315407276153564,
0.1787702739238739,
0.5586422681808472,
0.27161985635757446,
-0.5770615935325623,
-0.20263954997062683,
0.26140329241752625,
-0.34959840774536133,
-0.05094442516565323,
1.0567291975021362,
-0.6472715735435486,
0.2855159342288971,
0.3900251090526581,
0.8240822553634644,
-0.03261984884738922,
0.31661906838417053,
0.4579642117023468,
-0.693953275680542,
-0.2143978327512741,
0.1611817479133606,
0.34674230217933655,
0.31628021597862244,
-0.510847270488739,
0.5066400766372681,
-0.06532496213912964,
-0.9084327220916748,
-0.8997408747673035,
0.19573365151882172,
-1.241662859916687,
0.09652293473482132,
1.0481293201446533,
0.06675894558429718,
-0.3113662898540497,
-0.21667292714118958,
-0.34287843108177185,
0.0526377409696579,
-0.4050286114215851,
0.8575069904327393,
0.6723613142967224,
-0.5300597548484802,
0.10996360331773758,
-0.3609982430934906,
0.44290903210639954,
0.5238897204399109,
-0.9559749364852905,
0.20258942246437073,
0.46597713232040405,
0.14182895421981812,
0.33058810234069824,
0.6094031929969788,
0.15191592276096344,
0.2373182475566864,
-0.30511027574539185,
0.20624659955501556,
-0.21094785630702972,
0.09135724604129791,
-0.3495139479637146,
0.35300618410110474,
0.37574049830436707,
-0.12314825505018234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09008v1 | Multi-Query Focused Disaster Summarization via Instruction-Based Prompting | 2024-02-14T08:22:58 | 2024-02-14T08:22:58 | Philipp Seeberger, Korbinian Riedhammer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic summarization of mass-emergency events plays a critical role in
disaster management. The second edition of CrisisFACTS aims to advance disaster
summarization based on multi-stream fact-finding with a focus on web sources
such as Twitter, Reddit, Facebook, and Webnews. Here, participants are asked to
develop systems that can extract key facts from several disaster-related
events, which ultimately serve as a summary. This paper describes our method to
tackle this challenging task. We follow previous work and propose to use a
combination of retrieval, reranking, and an embarrassingly simple
instruction-following summarization. The two-stage retrieval pipeline relies on
BM25 and MonoT5, while the summarizer module is based on the open-source Large
Language Model (LLM) LLaMA-13b. For summarization, we explore a Question
Answering (QA)-motivated prompting approach and find the evidence useful for
extracting query-relevant facts. The automatic metrics and human evaluation
show strong results but also highlight the gap between open-source and
proprietary systems. | [
-0.3158682584762573,
-0.7524948120117188,
0.5948296785354614,
0.5192477703094482,
-0.3706176280975342,
0.12615297734737396,
0.03954024240374565,
-0.04341646283864975,
0.38380056619644165,
0.2928618788719177,
-0.5997116565704346,
-0.3910408616065979,
-0.4587530195713043,
0.24430008232593536,
-0.648959755897522,
1.0868033170700073,
0.11765927821397781,
-0.16025832295417786,
-0.01780344732105732,
0.04954926669597626,
-0.37908926606178284,
-0.33739733695983887,
-0.5592471957206726,
0.06701144576072693,
0.7213279008865356,
1.0844289064407349,
0.38588932156562805,
0.29751625657081604,
0.4977869987487793,
0.21737901866436005,
-0.047939732670784,
0.24982275068759918,
-0.6527808904647827,
0.17006513476371765,
0.0428745374083519,
-0.2435934990644455,
-0.13859930634498596,
-0.14926965534687042,
0.4216548800468445,
0.29737037420272827,
-0.3983687162399292,
0.30772504210472107,
0.18031975626945496,
0.604738712310791,
-0.8060614466667175,
0.2417556196451187,
-0.37575235962867737,
-0.053412776440382004,
0.15147225558757782,
-0.5319488644599915,
-0.43884047865867615,
-0.6406955718994141,
0.13887976109981537,
-0.3639346659183502,
0.5126046538352966,
-0.05407407134771347,
0.385203093290329,
0.3590642511844635,
-0.6733701229095459,
-0.45155400037765503,
-0.41222792863845825,
0.5532906651496887,
-0.3011503517627716,
0.23409441113471985,
0.24031658470630646,
0.19829308986663818,
0.05574183911085129,
-0.8242095708847046,
-0.23351742327213287,
0.2495618611574173,
0.020845836028456688,
0.3014812171459198,
0.19893482327461243,
-0.07471749931573868,
0.04576443135738373,
0.25722047686576843,
-0.5211567878723145,
-0.10459204763174057,
-0.4484439790248871,
-0.23180662095546722,
0.6522011160850525,
0.3740078806877136,
0.09677736461162567,
-0.5667566657066345,
-0.479404091835022,
-0.1643286645412445,
-0.8516488075256348,
-0.0861644446849823,
0.007021711673587561,
0.33478352427482605,
-0.17350345849990845,
0.5853458046913147,
-0.36119189858436584,
0.31220710277557373,
-0.1851455122232437,
-0.25162309408187866,
0.02068614587187767,
-0.498834490776062,
-0.10634609311819077,
0.11658469587564468,
0.6593311429023743,
0.7994709014892578,
0.04039595276117325,
-0.05520482733845711,
0.002815475920215249,
-0.5819337368011475,
0.20219561457633972,
-0.9089652895927429,
-0.24480998516082764,
0.19778208434581757,
-0.502805233001709,
-0.27990368008613586,
0.018362578004598618,
-1.1205235719680786,
-0.5786532759666443,
-0.0322275310754776,
0.580207884311676,
-0.0013157649664208293,
-0.06849928945302963,
-0.13682934641838074,
-0.4800716042518616,
0.03804030269384384,
0.603011965751648,
-0.5873220562934875,
-0.10086366534233093,
0.4211370050907135,
1.0127801895141602,
0.16137677431106567,
-0.10370254516601562,
-0.5487038493156433,
0.1229693815112114,
-0.031241506338119507,
1.186591386795044,
-0.2979070246219635,
-0.5798784494400024,
0.0876118615269661,
0.0690927803516388,
0.16187028586864471,
-0.5187748670578003,
0.6326521635055542,
-0.5305582284927368,
0.21813182532787323,
-0.6286605000495911,
-0.305259644985199,
-0.37937748432159424,
0.13228866457939148,
-0.4571472406387329,
0.908332347869873,
-0.3622046709060669,
-0.8618203997612,
0.23253010213375092,
-0.44431057572364807,
-0.5737027525901794,
-0.20113003253936768,
0.0028790945652872324,
-0.3471421003341675,
0.1752302497625351,
0.3833295404911041,
0.360592246055603,
-0.38528889417648315,
0.2037077248096466,
-0.17575521767139435,
-0.2930017411708832,
-0.30220678448677063,
-0.5521381497383118,
0.6683613657951355,
-0.08409393578767776,
-0.14106321334838867,
0.09447480738162994,
-0.5047930479049683,
-0.06912517547607422,
0.12416376918554306,
-0.750660240650177,
-0.2566886246204376,
0.2276443988084793,
-0.06548116356134415,
0.06987562030553818,
0.244979128241539,
-0.1251603662967682,
0.26057684421539307,
0.028069520369172096,
-0.011674029752612114,
0.43067467212677,
0.5685949921607971,
0.1499289870262146,
-0.3649007976055145,
0.36223629117012024,
-0.09303499013185501,
0.22051645815372467,
-0.6572259664535522,
-0.5436093211174011,
-0.7041218876838684,
-0.12985043227672577,
-0.16749374568462372,
0.9292677640914917,
-0.6315341591835022,
0.029757043346762657,
0.05020252242684364,
-0.444595068693161,
-0.21441929042339325,
-0.03509160131216049,
0.19254891574382782,
0.7203519940376282,
0.7670907378196716,
0.025626907125115395,
-0.8145231604576111,
-0.6751973032951355,
-0.2344016432762146,
-0.2278210073709488,
-0.08274801820516586,
0.15303607285022736,
0.1987912505865097,
0.24482257664203644,
0.7403431534767151,
-0.962211549282074,
-0.039884984493255615,
-0.4111892879009247,
0.4506814181804657,
0.048355583101511,
0.10201107710599899,
0.4167368710041046,
-0.7176294326782227,
-0.24114084243774414,
-0.5286027193069458,
-0.7282534241676331,
-0.12493221461772919,
-0.0509636290371418,
0.08567468076944351,
-0.0755435973405838,
0.4118610918521881,
-0.44772762060165405,
0.4003344476222992,
-0.14197923243045807,
-0.20944324135780334,
0.685243546962738,
-0.11256230622529984,
0.41587716341018677,
-1.2105499505996704,
-0.10691573470830917,
-0.11576387286186218,
-0.004311458207666874,
-0.513942539691925,
0.15324123203754425,
0.15618371963500977,
-0.17562705278396606,
-0.3886156976222992,
0.30815479159355164,
-0.5808066129684448,
-0.07164391875267029,
-0.3349073529243469,
0.4344448447227478,
-0.14224103093147278,
0.14925512671470642,
0.019902408123016357,
0.7356356382369995,
0.30872249603271484,
-0.6911978721618652,
0.5581641793251038,
0.38015422224998474,
-0.05140955373644829,
0.3032214641571045,
-0.5821335911750793,
-0.03177030012011528,
-0.3960438072681427,
0.4466286599636078,
-1.0584012269973755,
-0.5545761585235596,
0.15239575505256653,
-0.19344279170036316,
-0.008870387449860573,
-0.3529038429260254,
-0.3504157066345215,
-0.4859926104545593,
-0.6818186640739441,
-0.01897691935300827,
0.3081720173358917,
-0.4209735691547394,
0.49869242310523987,
0.5564732551574707,
-0.7186353802680969,
-0.7687370181083679,
-0.4564678370952606,
0.36208224296569824,
-0.2436307817697525,
-0.3785858154296875,
-0.08657748997211456,
-0.17143984138965607,
-0.10049450397491455,
-0.07444120198488235,
-0.3195241689682007,
-0.4137648344039917,
0.2751307487487793,
0.23198281228542328,
0.17478610575199127,
-0.28106042742729187,
0.119746632874012,
0.17165546119213104,
0.03555356711149216,
0.23149698972702026,
0.05181771144270897,
0.31447651982307434,
0.03735587000846863,
-0.23551802337169647,
-0.5385189652442932,
0.7947851419448853,
0.49312373995780945,
-0.15589940547943115,
0.6622718572616577,
0.23423197865486145,
-0.39817744493484497,
0.1756063550710678,
-0.6328370571136475,
-0.5727410912513733,
-0.35603436827659607,
0.2554309368133545,
0.08039572089910507,
-0.6615445613861084,
0.624616801738739,
-0.24924243986606598,
0.4325385093688965,
0.43514126539230347,
0.5302013158798218,
-0.07037848979234695,
0.7800772786140442,
0.47600942850112915,
-0.20431192219257355,
0.3825382888317108,
-0.1369527131319046,
0.015889199450612068,
-0.3704392611980438,
-0.4982548654079437,
-0.6488341689109802,
-0.17022934556007385,
0.028776369988918304,
-0.29897019267082214,
0.6596094369888306,
0.09458489716053009,
0.17358480393886566,
0.046403802931308746,
-0.11421506851911545,
0.6544712781906128,
0.4215506613254547,
0.13820582628250122,
0.5009382963180542,
0.012177253141999245,
0.2097802460193634,
0.36559683084487915,
-0.6867821216583252,
-0.36199629306793213,
0.816368043422699,
-0.08133076876401901,
0.6516343951225281,
0.41011086106300354,
1.0397748947143555,
0.23296695947647095,
0.47473764419555664,
-0.6829113960266113,
0.547142744064331,
0.18437623977661133,
-0.7015657424926758,
-0.426419734954834,
-0.5007430911064148,
-0.6994439363479614,
0.2613051235675812,
-0.1921217292547226,
-0.45198148488998413,
0.13758143782615662,
0.16873975098133087,
-0.729611337184906,
-0.15306146442890167,
-1.0008777379989624,
0.5208377838134766,
0.0749744176864624,
0.15121755003929138,
-0.7473950982093811,
-0.7132618427276611,
0.5792160034179688,
0.13714253902435303,
0.525161623954773,
0.05119091272354126,
-0.19655995070934296,
0.4159635007381439,
-0.4118172526359558,
0.8054759502410889,
-0.24018172919750214,
-0.07157168537378311,
0.7011852860450745,
-0.0005249864188954234,
0.44394469261169434,
0.4337884485721588,
0.06743326783180237,
-0.5063292980194092,
-0.1680351346731186,
-0.3431335985660553,
-0.689969539642334,
0.5236506462097168,
-0.3786044120788574,
-0.7556818723678589,
-0.12850335240364075,
-0.3870736062526703,
-0.0429866798222065,
0.2554769515991211,
0.12218966335058212,
0.9350284337997437,
-0.20755843818187714,
0.12319686263799667,
0.6377890706062317,
0.00003548880704329349,
0.7968478202819824,
0.6778817772865295,
-0.047254353761672974,
-0.42526718974113464,
0.9195249676704407,
0.3535403609275818,
-0.11975757032632828,
0.5476074814796448,
0.2709532082080841,
-0.310710608959198,
-0.35438403487205505,
-0.5935103893280029,
0.15145117044448853,
-0.7633305191993713,
-0.5685752630233765,
-0.7806403040885925,
-0.036745585501194,
-0.31447964906692505,
-0.08514057844877243,
-0.07087314128875732,
-0.6844608187675476,
-0.34038639068603516,
-0.4261400103569031,
0.20924341678619385,
0.8039005994796753,
-0.18995608389377594,
-0.039655573666095734,
-1.0789998769760132,
0.46220195293426514,
0.35690340399742126,
0.06267794221639633,
0.1470772624015808,
-0.29300013184547424,
-0.2633272707462311,
-0.24706719815731049,
-0.4453466832637787,
-1.4384145736694336,
-0.0291141290217638,
0.38954222202301025,
0.2841430604457855,
0.6691018342971802,
0.5279459953308105,
0.6204894185066223,
-0.458628386259079,
0.7140657305717468,
0.09539972990751266,
-0.5846114158630371,
0.7301990389823914,
-0.17569521069526672,
0.041128963232040405,
0.5403788685798645,
0.5836331844329834,
-0.4865468442440033,
-0.46371373534202576,
-0.47228267788887024,
-0.9220383167266846,
0.6956735253334045,
0.008332124911248684,
0.062009651213884354,
-0.24417108297348022,
0.20973923802375793,
0.0037585736718028784,
0.1363154947757721,
-0.044086623936891556,
-0.4690456688404083,
-0.38926810026168823,
-0.2320958822965622,
0.09251837432384491,
-0.6555225849151611,
-0.2679308354854584,
0.11450686305761337,
0.6462993621826172,
-0.1511845588684082,
-0.1669987142086029,
0.2306946963071823,
-0.2712201178073883,
0.2506309747695923,
0.335334837436676,
0.8555519580841064,
0.5861567258834839,
-0.13526809215545654,
0.2965831160545349,
0.4180949032306671,
-0.6470909714698792,
0.23494918644428253,
0.2202579230070114,
-0.25572600960731506,
0.08324020355939865,
0.4580698311328888,
0.16253791749477386,
0.7084928750991821,
-0.6882983446121216,
0.4505373537540436,
-0.2890605330467224,
0.1206546425819397,
0.010615825653076172,
0.10670463740825653,
0.12581250071525574,
0.385662317276001,
0.9090731739997864,
-0.25140827894210815,
0.730955183506012,
-0.4670600891113281,
0.34530583024024963,
-0.001497045042924583,
0.24871273338794708,
-0.35677218437194824,
0.36519792675971985,
0.5303604602813721,
-0.03461531177163124,
0.4724482595920563,
-0.18907971680164337,
-0.2806350290775299,
0.605918288230896,
0.3316235840320587,
0.7001315355300903,
-0.5058572888374329,
0.4308331608772278,
0.6280198097229004,
0.31008902192115784,
-0.35475897789001465,
0.6930586099624634,
-0.13901513814926147,
-0.27098068594932556,
-0.5126395225524902,
-0.1268274337053299,
-0.4890080690383911,
-0.05192055553197861,
-0.7266786098480225,
0.3295506536960602,
-0.41330185532569885,
-0.06904224306344986,
-0.17474152147769928,
-0.25354695320129395,
-0.11253699660301208,
0.10093110799789429,
-0.19566750526428223,
1.1137441396713257,
-0.7031446695327759,
-0.07984722405672073,
0.7640095949172974,
-0.45039066672325134,
-0.8450883030891418,
0.22577647864818573,
0.34629663825035095,
-0.5102896690368652,
0.1607944369316101,
0.11104606837034225,
0.15393683314323425,
0.17311473190784454,
-0.3903403580188751,
-0.8626406192779541,
0.9007627964019775,
0.4673389792442322,
-0.3353128433227539,
-0.318398654460907,
-0.3087616264820099,
0.11962895095348358,
0.07111818343400955,
0.5605222582817078,
0.3899695873260498,
0.5304543375968933,
0.038803838193416595,
-0.6570780873298645,
0.06218191608786583,
0.05818535387516022,
-0.7036295533180237,
0.23556990921497345,
-1.0419429540634155,
0.3709980547428131,
-0.7906087040901184,
-0.42658355832099915,
-0.24111387133598328,
0.8856319189071655,
0.06769106537103653,
0.6316004991531372,
0.35710692405700684,
0.4507650136947632,
0.8686486482620239,
0.028467293828725815,
0.8691831827163696,
-0.27153024077415466,
0.560636579990387,
1.0602283477783203,
0.31917259097099304,
0.7728316783905029,
0.05951366946101189,
-0.06438804417848587,
0.41882088780403137,
0.7168501019477844,
0.44501012563705444,
0.6351960897445679,
-0.27124887704849243,
-0.36379989981651306,
-0.2556578814983368,
-0.12450447678565979,
-0.34120386838912964,
0.35505884885787964,
0.37926584482192993,
-0.08022209256887436,
-0.8852046728134155,
-0.240118145942688,
0.1402358114719391,
-0.5631533265113831,
-0.24377577006816864,
0.9091904759407043,
0.22387968003749847,
-0.6112199425697327,
0.32769036293029785,
0.004096037242561579,
0.05583250895142555,
-0.17080609500408173,
-0.09299563616514206,
-0.5102480053901672,
-0.32630017399787903,
-0.27179208397865295,
-0.839821994304657,
0.5319125652313232,
0.23482681810855865,
-0.5288178324699402,
0.1112150251865387,
0.4788106679916382,
-0.3940795063972473,
-0.26566872000694275,
-0.15231704711914062,
0.627667248249054,
0.2983652353286743,
-0.20754604041576385,
-0.3408694565296173,
-0.044703200459480286,
-0.15807828307151794,
-0.33403265476226807,
0.15971536934375763,
0.5696150064468384,
-0.030492257326841354,
0.7929902672767639,
0.33260250091552734,
-0.32218137383461,
0.05210733786225319,
0.3288958966732025,
0.8760954737663269,
-0.7133291959762573,
-0.5425594449043274,
-0.7933864593505859,
0.436185747385025,
-0.09866701066493988,
-0.2071809321641922,
0.636732280254364,
0.7189266085624695,
0.15834106504917145,
-0.006607925985008478,
0.7603293657302856,
-0.11484482884407043,
0.635533332824707,
-0.3763563334941864,
0.4782908856868744,
-0.5038627982139587,
0.01011674664914608,
-0.10455627739429474,
-0.7284713387489319,
-0.1622401922941208,
0.18752121925354004,
0.19609855115413666,
-0.23898018896579742,
0.5367438197135925,
0.5600069761276245,
0.069760762155056,
0.19446732103824615,
-0.17984598875045776,
0.25366267561912537,
0.16991466283798218,
0.29214343428611755,
0.6538553833961487,
-0.05571194738149643,
0.8811243772506714,
0.03749047964811325,
-0.4601801931858063,
-0.869254469871521,
-0.827577531337738,
-0.6925912499427795,
-0.6226391792297363,
-0.27159303426742554,
-0.0825486108660698,
0.030916443094611168,
0.8186368942260742,
0.40291765332221985,
-0.7759859561920166,
0.15101319551467896,
0.1800832599401474,
0.7478456497192383,
-0.003930138889700174,
-0.22740285098552704,
0.4042857587337494,
-0.2809000015258789,
-0.3869515657424927,
0.7880094051361084,
0.4643666744232178,
0.03473414108157158,
-0.06363817304372787,
0.2451913207769394,
0.008944869972765446,
0.16912925243377686,
0.6713454127311707,
0.30408889055252075,
-0.3893605172634125,
-0.3675646483898163,
-0.09115185588598251,
0.05810103565454483,
-0.25250428915023804,
0.9172919988632202,
-0.7258955240249634,
0.05546500161290169,
0.6305225491523743,
0.6479431986808777,
0.07370880991220474,
0.4374721944332123,
0.3119387626647949,
-0.7933907508850098,
-0.03311418741941452,
-0.032797377556562424,
0.16996510326862335,
0.39056700468063354,
-0.47653433680534363,
0.4249468445777893,
0.46643829345703125,
-0.3974802494049072,
-0.8843605518341064,
0.1663907915353775,
-0.4123888909816742,
-0.1415603756904602,
0.915208637714386,
-0.08065368235111237,
0.21091721951961517,
-0.35014379024505615,
-0.2586873173713684,
0.3446069061756134,
-0.687879741191864,
1.1420692205429077,
0.5935251712799072,
-0.309303343296051,
-0.47339004278182983,
-0.27535727620124817,
0.3097286522388458,
0.023442134261131287,
-0.9547755718231201,
0.1000925824046135,
0.7545114755630493,
0.3656015992164612,
0.12883351743221283,
0.5303032398223877,
0.23657017946243286,
0.4183028042316437,
-0.15576376020908356,
-0.09726527333259583,
-0.06533127278089523,
-0.7811832427978516,
-0.07570622116327286,
0.6112284660339355,
-0.365650475025177,
0.049784377217292786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08983v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08983v3 | SafeDecoding: Defending against Jailbreak Attacks via Safety-Aware Decoding | 2024-02-14T06:54:31 | 2024-06-07T17:25:04 | Zhangchen Xu, Fengqing Jiang, Luyao Niu, Jinyuan Jia, Bill Yuchen Lin, Radha Poovendran | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into
real-world applications such as code generation and chatbot assistance,
extensive efforts have been made to align LLM behavior with human values,
including safety. Jailbreak attacks, aiming to provoke unintended and unsafe
behaviors from LLMs, remain a significant/leading LLM safety threat. In this
paper, we aim to defend LLMs against jailbreak attacks by introducing
SafeDecoding, a safety-aware decoding strategy for LLMs to generate helpful and
harmless responses to user queries. Our insight in developing SafeDecoding is
based on the observation that, even though probabilities of tokens representing
harmful contents outweigh those representing harmless responses, safety
disclaimers still appear among the top tokens after sorting tokens by
probability in descending order. This allows us to mitigate jailbreak attacks
by identifying safety disclaimers and amplifying their token probabilities,
while simultaneously attenuating the probabilities of token sequences that are
aligned with the objectives of jailbreak attacks. We perform extensive
experiments on five LLMs using six state-of-the-art jailbreak attacks and four
benchmark datasets. Our results show that SafeDecoding significantly reduces
the attack success rate and harmfulness of jailbreak attacks without
compromising the helpfulness of responses to benign user queries. SafeDecoding
outperforms six defense methods. | [
-0.19176076352596283,
-0.8192058801651001,
0.26713138818740845,
0.1012144684791565,
-0.44329988956451416,
0.40365731716156006,
-0.03722335770726204,
-0.5229907631874084,
0.1440483033657074,
0.8249728679656982,
-0.06967449933290482,
-0.8810099959373474,
-0.6161834001541138,
0.012968926690518856,
-0.45502325892448425,
0.9487309455871582,
0.20529285073280334,
-0.22386711835861206,
0.039913326501846313,
0.049751367419958115,
-0.6938241720199585,
-0.8579007983207703,
-0.7227095365524292,
0.36652299761772156,
0.3547229468822479,
0.4115685224533081,
0.6145667433738708,
0.5878929495811462,
0.460165798664093,
0.257497638463974,
-0.19337843358516693,
0.21518920361995697,
-0.5196623802185059,
0.5767225623130798,
0.02010377123951912,
-0.48178181052207947,
-0.5010390877723694,
-0.14076557755470276,
-0.1601792871952057,
0.056688420474529266,
-0.27951738238334656,
-0.2996334135532379,
0.019460799172520638,
0.6944525241851807,
-1.0043376684188843,
-0.040682531893253326,
-0.7683671116828918,
-0.026453068479895592,
-0.1891561597585678,
-0.24898405373096466,
-0.7880515456199646,
-0.667119562625885,
-0.4338301718235016,
-0.10138749331235886,
-0.01571398228406906,
0.16379767656326294,
0.1748921275138855,
0.03232487663626671,
-0.4258175194263458,
-0.3294934332370758,
-0.22845622897148132,
0.5118874311447144,
-0.6901016235351562,
0.07015436887741089,
0.7456766963005066,
0.15499965846538544,
-0.5673239827156067,
-0.25326231122016907,
-0.08545219153165817,
-0.22626540064811707,
0.18946340680122375,
-0.25641193985939026,
-0.29767584800720215,
0.38575831055641174,
0.16203773021697998,
-0.08988989144563675,
-0.27142849564552307,
0.19132116436958313,
-0.1690967082977295,
-0.5055019855499268,
0.7263388633728027,
0.24248924851417542,
0.43393850326538086,
-0.313842236995697,
-0.49114522337913513,
-0.005421096459031105,
-0.8762000203132629,
0.05550886690616608,
0.48516198992729187,
0.2129184901714325,
-0.10447423160076141,
0.4904356598854065,
-0.08628316223621368,
0.46945667266845703,
-0.04195375740528107,
-0.23972012102603912,
-0.04798267036676407,
-0.3483552932739258,
-0.005709036719053984,
0.5044664144515991,
0.9168994426727295,
0.8496394157409668,
0.5544757843017578,
-0.5000309944152832,
-0.11729717999696732,
-0.054196104407310486,
0.4628092646598816,
-0.9194056391716003,
-0.2434568554162979,
0.23682095110416412,
-0.4163081645965576,
-1.034325361251831,
0.21193906664848328,
-0.6282479763031006,
-0.8349618315696716,
0.6195399165153503,
0.0996994897723198,
-0.45682260394096375,
-0.18440645933151245,
0.30804944038391113,
0.06292087584733963,
0.038238525390625,
-0.05640264227986336,
-1.0772594213485718,
0.4367147386074066,
0.804821252822876,
0.6737300157546997,
-0.04077962785959244,
0.04455875977873802,
-0.7120077610015869,
0.41166335344314575,
-0.4383717477321625,
0.5175179243087769,
0.030130483210086823,
-0.753122091293335,
-0.16223308444023132,
-0.04940886050462723,
-0.004367327783256769,
-0.5481635332107544,
0.8188618421554565,
-0.758497953414917,
-0.7441239953041077,
-0.08881238847970963,
-0.494121253490448,
-0.026291731745004654,
0.22428904473781586,
-0.7916707396507263,
0.36987391114234924,
-0.40212446451187134,
-1.1556600332260132,
0.16791030764579773,
-0.29165714979171753,
-0.7103457450866699,
-0.0663728266954422,
0.21438275277614594,
-0.33948972821235657,
0.15962472558021545,
0.32679301500320435,
0.5276278257369995,
0.0666898563504219,
0.18814101815223694,
-0.4551057517528534,
-0.2922744154930115,
0.5056466460227966,
-0.45758628845214844,
0.7768553495407104,
0.5785120129585266,
-0.34918665885925293,
0.1224181056022644,
-0.5768461227416992,
0.12926755845546722,
0.2926943600177765,
-0.2527288496494293,
-0.8268532156944275,
0.27618885040283203,
-0.1670190542936325,
-0.07216056436300278,
0.12888213992118835,
-0.8911136984825134,
-0.01291482150554657,
-0.45353057980537415,
0.6533928513526917,
0.8179975152015686,
0.16995351016521454,
0.3247720003128052,
0.023693960160017014,
0.39374881982803345,
0.05789051577448845,
0.3803821802139282,
-0.20168155431747437,
-0.29929113388061523,
-0.10240880399942398,
-0.26259157061576843,
0.2271130084991455,
0.8852498531341553,
-0.29155439138412476,
0.540564775466919,
0.09775783866643906,
-0.2740640640258789,
-0.3385361135005951,
0.33196404576301575,
0.5363166332244873,
0.567122220993042,
0.1866796314716339,
-0.3160501718521118,
-0.7063690423965454,
-0.6945782899856567,
-0.4270038306713104,
-0.2809400260448456,
0.32340842485427856,
0.0029171472415328026,
-0.05035519599914551,
-0.330104261636734,
0.7276649475097656,
-0.49397167563438416,
0.07942800223827362,
-0.523835301399231,
-0.29168811440467834,
-0.06531976163387299,
0.6536893844604492,
0.707216739654541,
-0.4789406955242157,
-0.16512414813041687,
-0.36393827199935913,
-0.7228178381919861,
-0.06269361823797226,
-0.04704376682639122,
-0.17110386490821838,
0.29734528064727783,
0.6785516142845154,
-0.7177573442459106,
0.474835067987442,
0.30256494879722595,
-0.6360886096954346,
0.38914966583251953,
-0.23807016015052795,
0.10120049864053726,
-1.1382710933685303,
-0.3280411660671234,
-0.2379164844751358,
-0.36390382051467896,
-0.5965138077735901,
0.27367186546325684,
0.23688629269599915,
0.05565850809216499,
-0.5629242062568665,
0.23122167587280273,
-0.13844908773899078,
0.25067174434661865,
-0.23623058199882507,
-0.03247324004769325,
-0.08153948932886124,
-0.1858753263950348,
-0.2698381841182709,
0.8014715909957886,
0.47157710790634155,
-0.14746849238872528,
0.3170635402202606,
0.21423852443695068,
-0.5835611820220947,
0.05164361745119095,
-0.6892725825309753,
0.35904109477996826,
-0.06482477486133575,
0.08738680183887482,
-0.8404511213302612,
-0.07701868563890457,
0.32825151085853577,
-0.2624780237674713,
0.15026994049549103,
-0.483928382396698,
-0.6936920881271362,
-0.39888104796409607,
-0.6544271111488342,
0.23454730212688446,
0.43957364559173584,
-0.4486398994922638,
0.04924016818404198,
0.6084811687469482,
-0.24111197888851166,
-0.7803666591644287,
-0.6120558977127075,
0.3788505792617798,
-0.49654874205589294,
-0.6298571825027466,
-0.010126269422471523,
-0.23735474050045013,
-0.407996267080307,
-0.3529965281486511,
-0.3912425935268402,
-0.04908530041575432,
0.8256027698516846,
0.5163040161132812,
0.42396897077560425,
0.40529489517211914,
-0.43476545810699463,
0.09180714190006256,
-0.45443838834762573,
0.5007466077804565,
0.019507845863699913,
0.469268262386322,
-0.15910567343235016,
-0.2553761899471283,
-0.33271196484565735,
0.5308766961097717,
0.6191057562828064,
-0.22818388044834137,
0.796836793422699,
0.13631312549114227,
-0.14690224826335907,
-0.019335703924298286,
-0.4243893623352051,
-0.24989385902881622,
-0.560354471206665,
0.18519102036952972,
-0.24808134138584137,
-0.9871687293052673,
0.4749601185321808,
0.07452694326639175,
0.044983599334955215,
-0.20228330790996552,
0.25657913088798523,
-0.3215404450893402,
1.2144989967346191,
0.5934172868728638,
-0.3920725882053375,
0.30937573313713074,
-0.01145289558917284,
0.46243247389793396,
-0.4212757349014282,
-0.3851093351840973,
-0.5399488806724548,
-0.030546760186553,
-0.704720675945282,
-0.07792956382036209,
-0.0436679907143116,
0.5047959685325623,
-0.21324515342712402,
0.5587277412414551,
-0.4393698275089264,
0.8751596212387085,
0.316212922334671,
0.23114676773548126,
0.3502688705921173,
-0.1087266355752945,
-0.3020291328430176,
0.03674427047371864,
-0.49351248145103455,
-0.47623270750045776,
1.195594310760498,
0.3090353012084961,
1.4400631189346313,
0.24863217771053314,
1.1958131790161133,
0.4518798887729645,
0.014160370454192162,
-0.7069531083106995,
0.7271569967269897,
-0.12609687447547913,
-0.5985351204872131,
0.11533282697200775,
-0.4545131027698517,
-0.879785418510437,
0.005739586427807808,
-0.16205862164497375,
-0.8464478850364685,
-0.03726305812597275,
0.18405839800834656,
-0.40845704078674316,
0.5472171306610107,
-0.7440747022628784,
0.7779380679130554,
-0.6093679070472717,
-0.28661173582077026,
-0.21145492792129517,
-0.8305972218513489,
0.506149172782898,
-0.050674427300691605,
0.5268306136131287,
-0.16680140793323517,
0.23591259121894836,
0.6614680886268616,
-0.45656895637512207,
0.8777105212211609,
-0.39204293489456177,
-0.03962831199169159,
0.4001591205596924,
0.5790442228317261,
0.6538100242614746,
0.3473553955554962,
-0.02530074119567871,
-0.17442500591278076,
0.15274322032928467,
-0.16958725452423096,
-0.18074168264865875,
0.8798809051513672,
-0.5414637327194214,
-0.8668851256370544,
-0.24672386050224304,
-0.6086173057556152,
-0.022253282368183136,
0.46113258600234985,
0.11104004830121994,
0.3156347870826721,
-0.03916158527135849,
0.18731866776943207,
1.0059477090835571,
-0.27904757857322693,
0.6309855580329895,
0.17288482189178467,
-0.10222679376602173,
-0.5437113046646118,
0.5810563564300537,
-0.2178872525691986,
0.10226745903491974,
0.11456689983606339,
0.06538721174001694,
-0.47121357917785645,
-0.968546986579895,
-0.18682803213596344,
-0.06165821850299835,
-0.8053362965583801,
-0.6065785884857178,
-0.6302789449691772,
-0.1424238383769989,
-0.3900735676288605,
-0.30664166808128357,
-0.2626005709171295,
-0.41116300225257874,
0.05744944140315056,
-0.7427561283111572,
0.7631584405899048,
0.4839816391468048,
-0.24917441606521606,
-0.07934972643852234,
-1.1412806510925293,
0.3633551597595215,
0.22573859989643097,
0.39188846945762634,
-0.16213904321193695,
0.09744717180728912,
-0.23934195935726166,
-0.07686691731214523,
-0.04057827219367027,
-1.0413670539855957,
0.39135852456092834,
-0.11629033833742142,
0.5775966644287109,
0.43760600686073303,
0.8361893892288208,
0.34709981083869934,
-0.4510114789009094,
0.4311518371105194,
0.23423893749713898,
-0.8198928833007812,
0.7704436779022217,
-0.2896992564201355,
-0.1902015656232834,
0.9740216135978699,
-0.06341876834630966,
-0.3146989345550537,
-0.5448307991027832,
-0.3073364794254303,
-1.1298763751983643,
0.40233761072158813,
0.0804157480597496,
0.4426766037940979,
-0.5873869061470032,
0.31685519218444824,
-0.002399842254817486,
0.18436302244663239,
-0.6267756223678589,
-0.16814590990543365,
-0.37233150005340576,
-0.23108996450901031,
0.12464825063943863,
-0.5178588032722473,
-0.3899245262145996,
-0.0445551760494709,
0.15995515882968903,
0.1857033222913742,
0.18396860361099243,
-0.17385360598564148,
-0.2685416638851166,
0.2791815996170044,
0.6914042234420776,
0.3724464774131775,
-0.14944767951965332,
-0.45845189690589905,
0.3974784016609192,
-0.10964015126228333,
-0.8033263087272644,
0.3809519112110138,
0.11455433070659637,
-0.2099902182817459,
-0.32883456349372864,
0.10108496993780136,
0.5996198058128357,
0.13245759904384613,
-0.7839144468307495,
0.5456605553627014,
-0.3904924988746643,
0.031298503279685974,
-0.0433291532099247,
0.5871861577033997,
0.04905681312084198,
0.03259158506989479,
0.20279644429683685,
0.19454510509967804,
0.09098859131336212,
-0.24408774077892303,
0.2238776683807373,
0.49687546491622925,
-0.1769620031118393,
-0.03920670226216316,
0.8616752624511719,
0.47904953360557556,
-0.25435590744018555,
0.5969425439834595,
0.11525731533765793,
-0.43053939938545227,
0.8232229351997375,
0.9029977321624756,
1.0627020597457886,
-0.12964485585689545,
-0.08694972097873688,
0.19120338559150696,
0.6104257106781006,
0.006886892486363649,
0.3272636830806732,
-0.22035019099712372,
-0.7044543027877808,
-0.11689203232526779,
-0.38757315278053284,
-0.2508845925331116,
-0.21307094395160675,
-0.7849007844924927,
-0.03325334191322327,
-0.7724837064743042,
-0.30822595953941345,
-0.48459136486053467,
-0.3252897560596466,
-0.1571924388408661,
-0.018954187631607056,
0.15430597960948944,
1.391640543937683,
-0.4867312014102936,
0.9409487843513489,
0.41116535663604736,
0.07016601413488388,
-0.7325037717819214,
-0.11791286617517471,
0.10675352066755295,
-0.34499698877334595,
0.3951258957386017,
0.49850666522979736,
-0.4315239191055298,
0.04492482170462608,
-0.44210928678512573,
-0.5679483413696289,
0.9049043655395508,
0.37830662727355957,
-0.712053120136261,
0.09832999110221863,
0.06295379251241684,
0.014948052354156971,
-0.1785549372434616,
-0.20554594695568085,
0.6287544369697571,
0.17960673570632935,
-0.289015531539917,
-0.5639998912811279,
0.3421386182308197,
-0.2678636312484741,
0.0317036435008049,
0.39061638712882996,
-0.22357892990112305,
0.3242373466491699,
-0.7895300984382629,
-0.14531151950359344,
0.3579237759113312,
0.2330629676580429,
0.5790762901306152,
0.32081350684165955,
0.47792133688926697,
0.6081700921058655,
0.4631597697734833,
-0.19260001182556152,
1.0691248178482056,
-0.5304902791976929,
0.12923568487167358,
0.7567040324211121,
-0.14652039110660553,
0.7699344158172607,
0.42039385437965393,
0.28403639793395996,
0.26816874742507935,
0.4791634976863861,
0.2460625171661377,
1.251951813697815,
0.2624368965625763,
-0.587153971195221,
-0.22849129140377045,
0.2834821343421936,
-0.33016327023506165,
0.3178633451461792,
0.4916605055332184,
-0.22476550936698914,
-0.25876516103744507,
0.3770347237586975,
0.5276327729225159,
0.0823712944984436,
-0.3568996787071228,
0.8152992725372314,
0.07647353410720825,
-0.23274308443069458,
0.7201500535011292,
0.2910824120044708,
0.8628334999084473,
-0.5885086059570312,
0.49217870831489563,
-0.4195072650909424,
0.19961513578891754,
-0.2647883892059326,
-0.9359641075134277,
0.36480313539505005,
0.3638025224208832,
-0.07718788087368011,
-0.09182951599359512,
0.9335756301879883,
0.06807664781808853,
0.08213324099779129,
0.51195228099823,
-0.04891452193260193,
-0.01644672267138958,
0.26195457577705383,
-0.534386157989502,
0.4185681641101837,
0.014375478960573673,
-0.18716518580913544,
0.5327462553977966,
-0.09255889803171158,
-0.09215109050273895,
0.8014369010925293,
0.6561208963394165,
-0.16434085369110107,
0.1158791109919548,
0.04621736705303192,
0.8240243196487427,
-0.7169181704521179,
-0.6444156169891357,
-1.027668833732605,
0.49824070930480957,
0.025784021243453026,
0.3973850607872009,
0.7638481259346008,
0.3118674159049988,
0.5719096660614014,
-0.0373166985809803,
0.9331928491592407,
-0.11688481271266937,
0.15395380556583405,
-0.591971755027771,
1.1893802881240845,
0.21421776711940765,
0.6388336420059204,
-0.39083221554756165,
-0.4983999729156494,
-0.5366939306259155,
0.6111971735954285,
-0.2509767711162567,
-0.2845085859298706,
0.2112710326910019,
0.7695690393447876,
0.32048091292381287,
0.06286250054836273,
0.07047422230243683,
0.11086934059858322,
0.5835888981819153,
0.5260200500488281,
0.7923304438591003,
-0.2236911952495575,
0.7003628611564636,
-0.32662704586982727,
-0.15827010571956635,
-0.12999796867370605,
-1.0981320142745972,
-0.9344950914382935,
0.11200755089521408,
0.023831821978092194,
-0.5834262371063232,
0.41566726565361023,
0.7464602589607239,
0.5767354369163513,
-0.856976330280304,
-0.12740878760814667,
-0.2598309814929962,
0.3065871596336365,
-0.06961023807525635,
-0.1778702586889267,
0.02274879813194275,
-0.1414531171321869,
-0.29622289538383484,
0.7436623573303223,
0.1562979817390442,
0.16932180523872375,
0.23312023282051086,
-0.13746114075183868,
0.2333890199661255,
0.10311299562454224,
0.5727880597114563,
0.4965870976448059,
-0.48411449790000916,
-0.3260372579097748,
-0.0424978993833065,
-0.42430055141448975,
-0.1381254345178604,
0.6352819204330444,
-0.7475693225860596,
0.43787044286727905,
0.33150240778923035,
0.7528066039085388,
0.13506178557872772,
0.05539340525865555,
0.3606354594230652,
-0.7010623216629028,
0.41688549518585205,
0.12515787780284882,
0.3256436288356781,
0.3299087584018707,
-0.520715057849884,
0.3073076009750366,
0.009228648617863655,
-0.4689252972602844,
-0.9587807059288025,
0.3672228753566742,
-0.9424927830696106,
-0.30201637744903564,
0.8060898184776306,
-0.3175509572029114,
-0.13110609352588654,
-0.3109242916107178,
-0.35391151905059814,
-0.05762438848614693,
-0.5339001417160034,
0.8547646403312683,
0.2779485881328583,
0.057667672634124756,
-0.24515537917613983,
-0.4024159908294678,
0.4669804871082306,
0.03680919110774994,
-0.7820559144020081,
0.49052703380584717,
0.36842918395996094,
0.6642260551452637,
-0.12581604719161987,
0.48534953594207764,
-0.4595680832862854,
0.4388343095779419,
-0.21329963207244873,
-0.18113064765930176,
-0.45898059010505676,
-0.44499608874320984,
-0.11354482173919678,
0.37545081973075867,
0.469611257314682,
-0.4137636721134186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08971v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08971v2 | Structured Language Generation Model for Robust Structure Prediction | 2024-02-14T06:33:22 | 2024-02-19T00:06:41 | Minho Lee, Junghyun Min, Woochul Lee, Yeonsoo Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous work in structured prediction (e.g. NER, information extraction)
using single model make use of explicit dataset information, which helps boost
in-distribution performance but is orthogonal to robust generalization in
real-world situations. To overcome this limitation, we propose the Structured
Language Generation Model (SLGM), a framework that reduces sequence-to-sequence
problems to classification problems via methodologies in loss calibration and
decoding method. Our experimental results show that SLGM is able to maintain
performance without explicit dataset information, follow and potentially
replace dataset-specific fine-tuning. | [
-0.05513777583837509,
-0.8770506381988525,
0.13204282522201538,
-0.008968669921159744,
-0.3138396143913269,
-0.05258120596408844,
-0.11767027527093887,
-0.3234897255897522,
-0.3415461480617523,
0.5921316742897034,
-0.5264274477958679,
-0.45009127259254456,
-0.43368616700172424,
-0.10849334299564362,
-0.5067269206047058,
1.0750517845153809,
0.25512951612472534,
0.125471830368042,
-0.07917514443397522,
0.18765290081501007,
-0.47164320945739746,
-0.45705264806747437,
-0.38189902901649475,
-0.4198022484779358,
-0.010014316067099571,
0.14776955544948578,
0.8255628347396851,
1.2074495553970337,
0.2910248637199402,
0.2877556383609772,
-0.26106229424476624,
0.12009540945291519,
-0.42545488476753235,
0.2282993048429489,
0.13769543170928955,
-0.4157619774341583,
-0.5776585340499878,
-0.34770816564559937,
1.0099581480026245,
0.9694168567657471,
-0.4192844331264496,
0.11172028630971909,
0.3425289988517761,
0.45532405376434326,
-0.38775163888931274,
0.3311536908149719,
-0.809641420841217,
0.2518601417541504,
-0.1580238789319992,
-0.40455108880996704,
-0.6232579350471497,
-0.3320833146572113,
-0.024001795798540115,
-0.2936388850212097,
0.6319671869277954,
0.12169364094734192,
0.6359429955482483,
0.3846064805984497,
-0.11198519170284271,
-0.12432137876749039,
-0.6979514360427856,
0.5909064412117004,
-0.9802299737930298,
0.22874721884727478,
0.47523126006126404,
0.19913768768310547,
-0.4368281066417694,
-0.5449065566062927,
-0.04296960309147835,
-0.17847226560115814,
-0.06570205837488174,
-0.13496558368206024,
0.31108951568603516,
0.2628617584705353,
0.33657127618789673,
0.3117685914039612,
-0.6814547777175903,
-0.03879811614751816,
-0.4058854281902313,
-0.2173091471195221,
0.7262635827064514,
0.19985811412334442,
0.10445868223905563,
-0.24771685898303986,
-0.2962769567966461,
0.10539751499891281,
-0.8677178621292114,
-0.005102694034576416,
0.4994336664676666,
0.802207350730896,
0.03741784766316414,
0.47206059098243713,
0.022867772728204727,
0.842693030834198,
0.09964108467102051,
-0.42908158898353577,
0.26598963141441345,
-0.3718043565750122,
-0.4050430655479431,
0.26669248938560486,
0.4091850519180298,
-0.14502093195915222,
0.30738043785095215,
-0.10961350053548813,
-0.3742695450782776,
0.09331423789262772,
0.08772193640470505,
-0.9431343078613281,
-0.375323623418808,
-0.042180031538009644,
-0.5712366104125977,
-0.6155989766120911,
0.10242103785276413,
-0.6440424919128418,
-0.085303395986557,
-0.030592408031225204,
-0.002804136835038662,
-0.23257070779800415,
-0.17569398880004883,
0.0516207292675972,
-0.05884901434183121,
-0.03293103352189064,
-0.006067999638617039,
-0.773400068283081,
0.3238232135772705,
0.43204447627067566,
0.7582089304924011,
-0.12187627702951431,
-0.0003449020441621542,
-0.6491261720657349,
0.46308907866477966,
-0.2682928740978241,
0.6797941327095032,
-0.4298878014087677,
-0.3676883280277252,
0.03980988636612892,
-0.23069164156913757,
-0.016973858699202538,
-0.4362325072288513,
0.4918834865093231,
-0.06640007346868515,
0.1751583367586136,
0.3318396508693695,
-0.6128342151641846,
0.10556677728891373,
0.22857321798801422,
-0.6845486164093018,
1.0207655429840088,
0.2102234810590744,
-0.9326899647712708,
0.5464456081390381,
-0.32729023694992065,
-0.6245177984237671,
0.5578787326812744,
-0.29345834255218506,
-0.6327758431434631,
0.21580195426940918,
0.11337000876665115,
0.3712940514087677,
-0.07414893805980682,
0.7916789054870605,
-0.4781739413738251,
-0.3878304958343506,
-0.14007772505283356,
-0.2994030714035034,
0.22047020494937897,
0.3840252459049225,
-0.18645282089710236,
0.045545000582933426,
-1.2798179388046265,
0.4602336287498474,
0.11414114385843277,
-0.6986244320869446,
-0.3199344575405121,
0.6391801238059998,
0.086266428232193,
0.21669720113277435,
0.08542947471141815,
-0.2561655044555664,
0.22890280187129974,
-0.8035008311271667,
0.5039925575256348,
0.752798855304718,
-0.06257308274507523,
0.6421669721603394,
-0.13429391384124756,
0.6473051905632019,
0.017830075696110725,
-0.02898930385708809,
-0.34057772159576416,
-0.39954376220703125,
-0.3695548176765442,
-0.0601692721247673,
0.30200672149658203,
0.5419989228248596,
-0.4977269172668457,
0.4078243374824524,
-0.15045487880706787,
-0.10948077589273453,
-0.23339132964611053,
0.22255608439445496,
0.5633023381233215,
0.9028478860855103,
0.052403565496206284,
-0.039256948977708817,
-0.8747037053108215,
-0.730503499507904,
-0.058567773550748825,
-0.186320498585701,
-0.030698753893375397,
0.04869266226887703,
0.0317571684718132,
-0.28848573565483093,
0.8531584739685059,
-0.6043992042541504,
0.052802346646785736,
-0.524113655090332,
0.037744391709566116,
0.32250577211380005,
0.5448485612869263,
0.178123340010643,
-0.9647760987281799,
-0.15249599516391754,
-0.07391252368688583,
-0.6775631904602051,
-0.19413380324840546,
0.17407037317752838,
0.15718533098697662,
0.09143076837062836,
0.41827183961868286,
-0.041876476258039474,
0.5588794946670532,
0.6392666697502136,
-0.2127232402563095,
0.5421830415725708,
-0.15134093165397644,
-0.5536306500434875,
-1.3135910034179688,
0.181715726852417,
0.02646096795797348,
-0.3100159764289856,
-0.872418224811554,
-0.045522477477788925,
-0.001059944392181933,
-0.34758448600769043,
-0.22533142566680908,
0.4182489812374115,
-0.3884124755859375,
-0.22417418658733368,
-0.19959479570388794,
-0.17227241396903992,
0.032831575721502304,
0.4354436993598938,
0.10169009119272232,
0.7599804997444153,
0.5837405920028687,
-0.7913614511489868,
-0.1887488216161728,
0.4186651110649109,
-0.4423713982105255,
0.16402661800384521,
-0.8218790292739868,
-0.026797307655215263,
-0.415881872177124,
0.10518503189086914,
-0.71565181016922,
-0.3607749044895172,
0.053920891135931015,
-0.31919944286346436,
0.5939465761184692,
-0.2749522030353546,
-0.316791296005249,
-0.26661190390586853,
-0.15993519127368927,
0.28833454847335815,
0.22502583265304565,
-0.15217629075050354,
0.12500476837158203,
0.3316040337085724,
-0.3255493938922882,
-0.5867589712142944,
-0.7788349390029907,
-0.21404820680618286,
-0.26402726769447327,
-0.7432214021682739,
0.26700469851493835,
-0.30047303438186646,
-0.00926436297595501,
-0.20361250638961792,
-0.05763183534145355,
-0.19068223237991333,
0.23973575234413147,
0.43505749106407166,
0.2706056833267212,
-0.2633894383907318,
0.4347114562988281,
-0.005571374669671059,
-0.00370652973651886,
-0.13870778679847717,
-0.22612586617469788,
0.5175421237945557,
-0.2304118275642395,
-0.06978683918714523,
0.1034335047006607,
0.4280499219894409,
0.086078941822052,
-0.15139096975326538,
0.6414747834205627,
0.26775363087654114,
-0.509735107421875,
-0.6833897829055786,
-0.07747865468263626,
0.004826453980058432,
-0.515618622303009,
0.5665099024772644,
-0.41808250546455383,
-0.7067875266075134,
0.5129381418228149,
-0.1676272451877594,
-0.16211937367916107,
0.22549153864383698,
0.3085690140724182,
0.015427214093506336,
1.512588381767273,
0.893065333366394,
0.046701110899448395,
0.6007019281387329,
-0.2016543596982956,
0.2254471331834793,
-0.5145764946937561,
-0.3667231500148773,
-0.6082960963249207,
-0.11955972015857697,
-0.5018562078475952,
0.108863964676857,
0.26770904660224915,
0.48730117082595825,
-0.32820701599121094,
0.44006797671318054,
-0.6366085410118103,
0.17048579454421997,
0.25238651037216187,
-0.07463696599006653,
0.28835973143577576,
0.1583467274904251,
-0.20695523917675018,
0.06126837804913521,
-0.9691422581672668,
-0.6177781820297241,
0.844612717628479,
0.3740317225456238,
1.046973466873169,
-0.22715342044830322,
0.5720966458320618,
0.27053093910217285,
0.17858944833278656,
-0.6395530700683594,
0.45713672041893005,
-0.0033185710199177265,
-0.2219342738389969,
-0.25702014565467834,
-0.8185913562774658,
-0.8337565064430237,
-0.10493696480989456,
-0.1664976179599762,
-0.5199398994445801,
0.2344842553138733,
0.3317593038082123,
-0.038928523659706116,
0.11844811588525772,
-0.4435317814350128,
0.5698431730270386,
-0.05696650221943855,
-0.012324029579758644,
0.4399324953556061,
-0.6767159700393677,
0.41235846281051636,
-0.23567840456962585,
0.421235054731369,
-0.05207257717847824,
0.22634068131446838,
0.4211632013320923,
-0.5033823251724243,
0.620685338973999,
-0.25041669607162476,
-0.03300906717777252,
0.17229770123958588,
0.09935613721609116,
0.6939453482627869,
0.11460180580615997,
-0.5060034394264221,
-0.0823177769780159,
-0.12563219666481018,
-0.2437862604856491,
-0.5114965438842773,
0.42725107073783875,
-0.4574293792247772,
-0.2344166785478592,
-0.06336580216884613,
-0.8135396838188171,
-0.2563101649284363,
0.22427193820476532,
0.7386022210121155,
0.7983885407447815,
-0.20167627930641174,
0.19842049479484558,
0.602636992931366,
0.05277187377214432,
0.5252582430839539,
0.0006968927336856723,
-0.0026120981201529503,
-0.5538854002952576,
0.5650043487548828,
0.08244283497333527,
0.3225668668746948,
0.3627692759037018,
0.34810250997543335,
-0.33762434124946594,
-0.8810620903968811,
-0.436096727848053,
-0.10253327339887619,
-0.5591292977333069,
-0.5952931046485901,
-0.27796241641044617,
-0.4872734546661377,
-0.5245745182037354,
-0.09894302487373352,
-0.12000767141580582,
-0.41615355014801025,
-0.23656553030014038,
-0.375851035118103,
-0.149175226688385,
0.8766933083534241,
0.23109641671180725,
0.45920345187187195,
-0.7926042079925537,
-0.014481625519692898,
-0.16020573675632477,
0.5967510938644409,
-0.2785702347755432,
-0.4663229286670685,
-0.3645344078540802,
0.13350847363471985,
-0.2691882848739624,
-0.8518907427787781,
0.728948175907135,
0.8445571660995483,
0.6138603687286377,
0.5820100903511047,
-0.026838131248950958,
0.8520100116729736,
-0.5378779172897339,
0.41406694054603577,
0.08756551891565323,
-0.7891038656234741,
0.9239017963409424,
-0.47835516929626465,
0.3463296890258789,
0.38433441519737244,
-0.14738236367702484,
-0.03053027205169201,
-0.34279000759124756,
-0.4358663260936737,
-0.7512869238853455,
0.7282427549362183,
0.12130230665206909,
-0.003751159179955721,
-0.02486412413418293,
0.4772011637687683,
0.12497274577617645,
0.49414587020874023,
-0.9004780650138855,
-0.13062894344329834,
-0.323286771774292,
-0.2345532476902008,
-0.12854218482971191,
-0.23985175788402557,
0.1473129242658615,
-0.05658019706606865,
0.4855741262435913,
-0.44505932927131653,
0.11176106333732605,
0.12020464241504669,
-0.0804842859506607,
-0.5212752223014832,
0.3332814574241638,
0.5490038394927979,
0.7063244581222534,
-0.3709600269794464,
0.048942141234874725,
-0.020221784710884094,
-0.4146883487701416,
0.1097947210073471,
0.060698408633470535,
-0.6258175373077393,
-0.0045560626313090324,
0.39486977458000183,
0.9197515249252319,
0.3493344485759735,
-0.6647723317146301,
0.3593043088912964,
0.2101573944091797,
-0.1878407597541809,
-0.14281557500362396,
0.09024420380592346,
-0.35057881474494934,
0.05592350289225578,
0.48584023118019104,
0.18935909867286682,
0.28433898091316223,
-0.5191234946250916,
0.4444458782672882,
0.351516991853714,
-0.241720512509346,
-0.4043528735637665,
0.706246554851532,
-0.11106569319963455,
-0.35879096388816833,
0.5680705308914185,
-0.12952002882957458,
-0.49446436762809753,
0.5443102717399597,
1.0643129348754883,
0.7246847152709961,
-0.38328230381011963,
0.2585761845111847,
0.41882577538490295,
0.1445973962545395,
-0.477012038230896,
0.30450114607810974,
-0.07469760626554489,
-0.6279798746109009,
-0.5085919499397278,
-0.9847468137741089,
-0.07420483231544495,
0.0597088560461998,
-0.6588777303695679,
0.28012290596961975,
-0.6029061079025269,
-0.08405846357345581,
-0.33050018548965454,
0.01368500292301178,
-0.4127785563468933,
0.2296598106622696,
0.2607184052467346,
0.962117612361908,
-0.7392886281013489,
1.105331540107727,
0.5226983428001404,
-0.08287470042705536,
-0.8962671756744385,
-0.2736819088459015,
-0.29370245337486267,
-0.4780917465686798,
0.47414860129356384,
0.307678759098053,
0.04526875168085098,
-0.14736908674240112,
-0.7996528148651123,
-0.9853478074073792,
1.0695710182189941,
0.6301449537277222,
-0.4410557448863983,
-0.5195723176002502,
0.1527431756258011,
0.5302091240882874,
-0.618854284286499,
-0.34573569893836975,
0.1975419819355011,
0.3490411937236786,
0.3976150453090668,
-0.7147842049598694,
-0.08747109770774841,
-0.48384472727775574,
0.485725998878479,
0.5141585469245911,
-0.05240686237812042,
0.92356938123703,
-0.22257192432880402,
-0.48952728509902954,
0.24367760121822357,
0.5576593279838562,
0.3114872872829437,
0.3658292293548584,
0.24564725160598755,
0.41631680727005005,
0.7596299052238464,
-0.04615965113043785,
0.920028030872345,
-0.2740086615085602,
0.4205806255340576,
1.2084784507751465,
-0.19636699557304382,
0.8525749444961548,
0.10126308351755142,
0.12202651798725128,
0.438586562871933,
0.4781728982925415,
-0.07779712229967117,
0.7924901247024536,
0.2438838630914688,
-0.020402515307068825,
-0.19623488187789917,
0.10180240124464035,
-0.5186951756477356,
0.5379352569580078,
0.5040276646614075,
-0.508055567741394,
-0.23599529266357422,
-0.16528987884521484,
-0.23494796454906464,
0.17175588011741638,
-0.4968093931674957,
0.6676073670387268,
-0.09807556122541428,
-0.6400659084320068,
0.5454347133636475,
0.09196530282497406,
0.6228613257408142,
-0.7695474028587341,
-0.1592068076133728,
-0.17616316676139832,
0.2973828911781311,
-0.33862820267677307,
-0.4235309064388275,
0.6149255037307739,
-0.3379441499710083,
-0.33965548872947693,
-0.29248127341270447,
1.2106999158859253,
-0.6519888043403625,
-0.6291660666465759,
0.07002796232700348,
0.2928963303565979,
0.027318330481648445,
0.1172511950135231,
-0.6098677515983582,
-0.14158129692077637,
-0.11434512585401535,
-0.1491551548242569,
0.4158967435359955,
0.17513534426689148,
-0.1751626580953598,
0.7290850281715393,
0.6399540901184082,
0.25066444277763367,
0.25533851981163025,
-0.18083132803440094,
0.7679415345191956,
-0.5331875681877136,
-0.5962696075439453,
-0.6817527413368225,
0.2652522325515747,
0.06686095893383026,
-0.11087355017662048,
0.602631151676178,
0.5583134889602661,
0.6914060711860657,
-0.000050718546845018864,
0.8196269869804382,
0.08713913708925247,
0.4287499189376831,
-0.2871505618095398,
0.5918545126914978,
-0.24801181256771088,
0.25578227639198303,
-0.4784272015094757,
-0.9950753450393677,
-0.4203755557537079,
0.577042281627655,
0.15418100357055664,
-0.03275098651647568,
0.24614273011684418,
0.78654944896698,
0.07684408128261566,
-0.016160117462277412,
0.5361120104789734,
0.17511501908302307,
0.20736084878444672,
0.5121198296546936,
0.5274176597595215,
-0.4599423110485077,
0.6081197261810303,
-0.06525896489620209,
-0.02301519177854061,
-0.13758479058742523,
-1.0325300693511963,
-0.7150583267211914,
-0.5992673635482788,
-0.11562028527259827,
-0.3230810761451721,
-0.00010736843978520483,
0.6216561794281006,
0.855391263961792,
-0.7567152976989746,
-0.1285860687494278,
-0.43099457025527954,
0.0337616428732872,
-0.0931389182806015,
-0.19880297780036926,
0.21680983901023865,
-0.32031866908073425,
-0.5218510627746582,
0.7667117714881897,
0.3430245816707611,
0.14087319374084473,
-0.20583651959896088,
-0.34186431765556335,
0.050513625144958496,
-0.0061498223803937435,
0.5113077163696289,
0.31124576926231384,
-0.42083021998405457,
-0.21593669056892395,
-0.1544836461544037,
-0.10593105107545853,
0.1499326527118683,
0.714361846446991,
-0.8220025300979614,
0.30954238772392273,
0.5612406134605408,
0.37367352843284607,
0.2753809094429016,
0.3527323305606842,
0.8443706631660461,
-1.3060542345046997,
0.2837415933609009,
0.3065585196018219,
0.4892894923686981,
0.29281339049339294,
-0.5686929821968079,
0.5936151146888733,
0.1453918218612671,
-0.5415916442871094,
-1.082877278327942,
0.3812101483345032,
-0.7590741515159607,
-0.062133461236953735,
1.1346875429153442,
-0.1568749099969864,
-0.1995866596698761,
-0.20559360086917877,
-0.00962225254625082,
0.31347793340682983,
-0.28511056303977966,
0.3645178973674774,
0.3801921010017395,
0.09660471230745316,
-0.13857392966747284,
-0.32090675830841064,
0.5830098986625671,
0.07940074056386948,
-0.7926813960075378,
-0.049201566725969315,
0.5832006335258484,
0.32531923055648804,
0.06548396497964859,
0.419657438993454,
-0.10876984149217606,
-0.023402774706482887,
-0.11999557912349701,
-0.09970416128635406,
-0.3828621506690979,
-0.5773758292198181,
-0.4565418064594269,
0.611016571521759,
0.12911728024482727,
0.027688713744282722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10965v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10965v2 | Generalization in Healthcare AI: Evaluation of a Clinical Large Language Model | 2024-02-14T06:24:52 | 2024-02-24T13:17:38 | Salman Rahman, Lavender Yao Jiang, Saadia Gabriel, Yindalon Aphinyanaphongs, Eric Karl Oermann, Rumi Chunara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Advances in large language models (LLMs) provide new opportunities in
healthcare for improved patient care, clinical decision-making, and enhancement
of physician and administrator workflows. However, the potential of these
models importantly depends on their ability to generalize effectively across
clinical environments and populations, a challenge often underestimated in
early development. To better understand reasons for these challenges and inform
mitigation approaches, we evaluated ClinicLLM, an LLM trained on [HOSPITAL]'s
clinical notes, analyzing its performance on 30-day all-cause readmission
prediction focusing on variability across hospitals and patient
characteristics. We found poorer generalization particularly in hospitals with
fewer samples, among patients with government and unspecified insurance, the
elderly, and those with high comorbidities. To understand reasons for lack of
generalization, we investigated sample sizes for fine-tuning, note content
(number of words per note), patient characteristics (comorbidity level, age,
insurance type, borough), and health system aspects (hospital, all-cause 30-day
readmission, and mortality rates). We used descriptive statistics and
supervised classification to identify features. We found that, along with
sample size, patient age, number of comorbidities, and the number of words in
notes are all important factors related to generalization. Finally, we compared
local fine-tuning (hospital specific), instance-based augmented fine-tuning and
cluster-based fine-tuning for improving generalization. Among these, local
fine-tuning proved most effective, increasing AUC by 0.25% to 11.74% (most
helpful in settings with limited data). Overall, this study provides new
insights for enhancing the deployment of large language models in the
societally important domain of healthcare, and improving their performance for
broader populations. | [
0.08077897131443024,
-0.7991656064987183,
0.892890453338623,
0.13680075109004974,
-0.1532139778137207,
-0.196271613240242,
-0.4143117666244507,
-0.5050641298294067,
0.05129401013255119,
0.649350106716156,
-0.11484885215759277,
-0.9258078336715698,
-0.735567033290863,
0.07872222363948822,
-0.27393898367881775,
1.1077678203582764,
-0.14925400912761688,
0.20391862094402313,
-0.15375111997127533,
-0.12319759279489517,
-0.3201095163822174,
-0.7038461565971375,
-0.8979543447494507,
-0.5472756028175354,
0.4324394464492798,
0.3822515904903412,
0.5967380404472351,
0.5015997290611267,
0.9435732364654541,
0.3287024199962616,
-0.08771982789039612,
0.0058698225766420364,
-0.37155091762542725,
-0.16294161975383759,
0.1350284069776535,
-0.5001123547554016,
-0.6688218116760254,
-0.3538833558559418,
0.7940303683280945,
1.0974088907241821,
-0.3547653257846832,
0.07360870391130447,
-0.17631250619888306,
0.8280671834945679,
-0.4764236807823181,
0.066033273935318,
-0.3604184091091156,
0.23997364938259125,
-0.04100001975893974,
0.060140397399663925,
-0.18075531721115112,
-0.4013088047504425,
0.4456040561199188,
-0.5252279043197632,
0.6211135387420654,
0.04631809890270233,
0.5928164124488831,
0.07392948120832443,
-0.5658822059631348,
-0.4032958447933197,
-0.9047057628631592,
0.7608137130737305,
-0.843977153301239,
0.26476889848709106,
0.37578901648521423,
0.3537687361240387,
-0.05848095938563347,
-0.6738619208335876,
-0.10184826701879501,
-0.5167188048362732,
-0.14878934621810913,
0.2537556290626526,
-0.3155052661895752,
0.41091275215148926,
0.30504104495048523,
0.6038935780525208,
-0.731696367263794,
0.4175155758857727,
-0.46197324991226196,
-0.1618449091911316,
0.6540130376815796,
0.5484837889671326,
0.34103667736053467,
0.16991975903511047,
-0.06956794112920761,
0.10435023903846741,
-0.5200705528259277,
-0.02864011749625206,
-0.146709606051445,
0.12022046744823456,
-0.4129485785961151,
0.46400201320648193,
-0.3081378638744354,
0.45463135838508606,
-0.2606774866580963,
-0.10596933215856552,
0.3125677704811096,
-0.3441891372203827,
-0.44281256198883057,
0.03889620304107666,
0.7262157201766968,
0.47005021572113037,
0.3072628080844879,
-0.4026564061641693,
-0.11326171457767487,
0.18385976552963257,
0.3024161458015442,
-0.6445906758308411,
-0.18221154808998108,
0.45332619547843933,
-0.7594565153121948,
-0.27370864152908325,
-0.13313692808151245,
-0.5775700211524963,
-0.4363272488117218,
-0.41061699390411377,
-0.23284007608890533,
-0.3454696238040924,
-0.0522921159863472,
0.12631112337112427,
0.09212028980255127,
0.13430359959602356,
0.6192782521247864,
-0.8854786157608032,
0.4351640045642853,
0.6482725143432617,
0.7956196069717407,
-0.36965280771255493,
-0.061264172196388245,
-0.4642236530780792,
0.17945538461208344,
-0.4979967176914215,
0.6286845207214355,
-0.3906063139438629,
-0.6668142080307007,
0.4436808228492737,
-0.0861678346991539,
-0.27996450662612915,
-1.0424392223358154,
0.7065253257751465,
-0.025885287672281265,
-0.08419040590524673,
0.21622183918952942,
-0.48473843932151794,
0.235642671585083,
0.16921187937259674,
-0.6041731238365173,
0.038816727697849274,
0.3843843638896942,
-0.3604602515697479,
0.5064299702644348,
-0.7268800139427185,
-0.5950012803077698,
0.1356368213891983,
-0.15948687493801117,
-0.6974326372146606,
0.6707693338394165,
0.3991481363773346,
0.46634748578071594,
-0.3044113516807556,
0.36626923084259033,
-0.1731942743062973,
-0.49293529987335205,
0.10134270787239075,
-0.24422718584537506,
0.2261561155319214,
0.4383477568626404,
0.09248650074005127,
0.25371256470680237,
-0.6773901581764221,
-0.12073355913162231,
-0.004411735106259584,
-0.5286408066749573,
-0.323620080947876,
-0.069765105843544,
0.2412007749080658,
-0.21630768477916718,
0.12888510525226593,
-0.2684885859489441,
0.28708434104919434,
-0.5789229869842529,
0.38343992829322815,
0.34573063254356384,
0.18713028728961945,
0.4754830300807953,
-0.5941761136054993,
0.6846179962158203,
0.19317667186260223,
0.45013004541397095,
-0.12933053076267242,
-0.4092547595500946,
-0.4753800332546234,
-0.4023020267486572,
0.21591399610042572,
0.46608731150627136,
-0.12954775989055634,
0.09906865656375885,
-0.24724018573760986,
-0.24198409914970398,
-0.6895365715026855,
0.05792984738945961,
0.35917046666145325,
0.36057963967323303,
0.29264888167381287,
-0.25093743205070496,
-0.4126911461353302,
-1.0463111400604248,
-0.0765833705663681,
-0.11462436616420746,
-0.14255398511886597,
0.44323664903640747,
0.3302082121372223,
-0.9134142398834229,
0.4449830949306488,
-0.4705143868923187,
-0.647933304309845,
-0.4371170699596405,
0.028154615312814713,
0.4401204586029053,
0.41319283843040466,
0.25155600905418396,
-0.5070482492446899,
-0.376545250415802,
0.4065781235694885,
-0.6473697423934937,
-0.11659897863864899,
-0.07747742533683777,
0.44191551208496094,
0.17087016999721527,
0.4043131470680237,
-0.48764488101005554,
0.6012426614761353,
0.5187248587608337,
0.003226582193747163,
0.3975110948085785,
-0.7093308568000793,
0.021826734766364098,
-0.8941102623939514,
0.19195832312107086,
0.13495729863643646,
-0.009116645902395248,
-0.8436837196350098,
-0.004107765853404999,
-0.03450145944952965,
-0.27778494358062744,
0.023770645260810852,
0.34273168444633484,
-0.41227689385414124,
0.18872418999671936,
-0.02486138790845871,
-0.03290734440088272,
-0.1234019324183464,
-0.02571028470993042,
-0.07214316725730896,
0.476750910282135,
0.37880629301071167,
-0.46943917870521545,
0.20400530099868774,
0.02977021038532257,
-0.3824635148048401,
0.34922879934310913,
-0.8453986048698425,
-0.004476597532629967,
-0.23602250218391418,
0.19429123401641846,
-0.8146111369132996,
-0.3457087576389313,
-0.13066595792770386,
-0.2051631510257721,
0.30760031938552856,
0.015421445481479168,
-0.3435935378074646,
-0.4436219036579132,
0.031692929565906525,
0.3617352843284607,
0.4433292746543884,
0.061735108494758606,
0.4557265639305115,
0.16303929686546326,
-0.18355056643486023,
-0.12300844490528107,
-0.7021321058273315,
0.1275692880153656,
-0.2635210454463959,
-0.39279815554618835,
0.2150229662656784,
-0.04203331470489502,
-0.5744773149490356,
-0.24085286259651184,
0.0254067312926054,
-0.13246488571166992,
0.1932697892189026,
0.24353158473968506,
0.15214784443378448,
-0.28688934445381165,
0.3303208649158478,
0.20276331901550293,
-0.009398875758051872,
0.14165423810482025,
-0.13548602163791656,
0.49897465109825134,
-0.26486122608184814,
-0.42459121346473694,
-0.627733588218689,
0.6031212210655212,
0.6015048623085022,
-0.0763818547129631,
0.60794597864151,
0.44176313281059265,
-0.4808456003665924,
-0.010225903242826462,
-0.7039702534675598,
-0.018007459118962288,
-0.334501713514328,
0.6936433911323547,
-0.0565267875790596,
-1.0207171440124512,
0.6335033178329468,
-0.34650591015815735,
0.1726783812046051,
0.5009422302246094,
0.6136395931243896,
-0.06000277400016785,
1.0037544965744019,
0.5111308097839355,
-0.3412262201309204,
0.13492877781391144,
-0.41231656074523926,
0.14072969555854797,
-0.8767052292823792,
-0.20992816984653473,
-0.610054075717926,
-0.0028223751578480005,
-0.9492185711860657,
-0.38865384459495544,
0.5139018297195435,
-0.008155460469424725,
-0.09240037947893143,
-0.3508506417274475,
-0.39512839913368225,
0.09152518957853317,
0.10654330998659134,
0.19569115340709686,
0.48230382800102234,
-0.07009116560220718,
-0.1780233085155487,
0.20277853310108185,
-0.5578321218490601,
-0.4012884497642517,
1.3076502084732056,
0.7221264243125916,
0.7765466570854187,
0.21915550529956818,
1.0514261722564697,
0.5733875632286072,
0.5335946083068848,
-0.7492920756340027,
0.17616981267929077,
-0.6411445140838623,
-0.2723710238933563,
-0.3705562651157379,
-0.5756862163543701,
-1.3002208471298218,
0.07791702449321747,
-0.18274454772472382,
-0.7108494639396667,
0.041976455599069595,
0.24281322956085205,
-0.477297306060791,
-0.04106609523296356,
-0.9217279553413391,
0.7398725152015686,
-0.12377885729074478,
0.18530461192131042,
-0.3436860144138336,
-0.457104355096817,
0.25113290548324585,
-0.3083031475543976,
0.5538908839225769,
0.13235992193222046,
-0.042087066918611526,
0.3805665075778961,
-0.34454289078712463,
0.8220836520195007,
0.08281401544809341,
-0.18648894131183624,
-0.14810293912887573,
-0.31335222721099854,
0.33487120270729065,
0.11754309386014938,
0.03581211343407631,
0.3434092700481415,
0.05688006430864334,
-0.35690227150917053,
-0.653310239315033,
0.7162067294120789,
-1.0350193977355957,
-0.7027377486228943,
-0.2117892950773239,
-0.4662475883960724,
-0.4582405984401703,
0.019030794501304626,
0.23922912776470184,
0.6609882116317749,
-0.5482369661331177,
0.10600115358829498,
0.620182991027832,
-0.3827822208404541,
-0.05172019451856613,
0.5332401394844055,
-0.3254794180393219,
-0.5118299126625061,
0.5730588436126709,
-0.17195609211921692,
0.3422459363937378,
0.615854799747467,
0.6126987338066101,
-0.10681449621915817,
-1.0490436553955078,
-0.32299715280532837,
0.35418999195098877,
-0.5158895254135132,
0.29088467359542847,
-0.5952551364898682,
-0.41314297914505005,
-0.6332533359527588,
-0.17670603096485138,
0.1709313839673996,
-0.20061391592025757,
-0.4190586805343628,
0.1036074310541153,
-0.06128721311688423,
0.9802407026290894,
0.33819353580474854,
0.547002375125885,
-0.7643953561782837,
0.26421570777893066,
0.06520558893680573,
0.24760931730270386,
0.09850369393825531,
-0.547850489616394,
-0.5756099820137024,
-0.16340695321559906,
-0.20535147190093994,
-0.6846963167190552,
0.235632061958313,
0.24156944453716278,
0.8066075444221497,
0.7144452333450317,
-0.28154149651527405,
0.545096755027771,
-0.6337326169013977,
0.5170674324035645,
0.36452215909957886,
-0.5612238049507141,
0.6673341393470764,
-0.3243837058544159,
0.5649857521057129,
0.5848863124847412,
0.12888716161251068,
-0.6502436399459839,
-0.40270882844924927,
-0.4448838531970978,
-0.9367765784263611,
0.288328617811203,
0.007111848331987858,
0.17112502455711365,
0.07002367824316025,
0.5098567605018616,
-0.08407571911811829,
0.15899845957756042,
-0.29711076617240906,
-0.22483046352863312,
0.18503792583942413,
-0.3805243968963623,
-0.49362197518348694,
-0.28825122117996216,
-0.2740819454193115,
-0.20039375126361847,
0.1594795137643814,
-0.12891605496406555,
0.21300271153450012,
0.45993009209632874,
-0.000501879258081317,
-0.31601250171661377,
0.6280041933059692,
0.8974209427833557,
0.9425930380821228,
-0.19485162198543549,
-0.0921049416065216,
0.27197936177253723,
-0.7523512244224548,
-0.14139917492866516,
0.29137948155403137,
-0.05242500081658363,
0.04251989722251892,
0.7683504819869995,
0.9571154713630676,
0.05956347659230232,
-0.6051305532455444,
0.31456029415130615,
-0.15319067239761353,
-0.1748192012310028,
-0.3084399998188019,
0.13237181305885315,
-0.0761863961815834,
0.14869140088558197,
0.13403315842151642,
-0.1731909215450287,
0.44224533438682556,
-0.5704033970832825,
-0.014604722149670124,
0.41833531856536865,
-0.4544356167316437,
-0.11926257610321045,
0.456870973110199,
0.08014897257089615,
-0.3080802261829376,
0.6077995896339417,
0.49437791109085083,
-0.08023684471845627,
0.8194257020950317,
0.616655170917511,
0.933014452457428,
-0.32151418924331665,
0.19045396149158478,
0.197974294424057,
0.3396546542644501,
0.024676166474819183,
-0.10783177614212036,
0.052884235978126526,
-0.5052210092544556,
-0.4026862382888794,
-0.5923513174057007,
-0.6753942370414734,
0.23016174137592316,
-0.7179152965545654,
0.061444029211997986,
-0.5678374767303467,
-0.38388994336128235,
-0.09495371580123901,
0.052342161536216736,
-0.8070727586746216,
0.350035697221756,
0.1969013512134552,
0.8182052373886108,
-0.6725859045982361,
0.6756988167762756,
1.0189274549484253,
-0.13994921743869781,
-0.7183914184570312,
0.17648252844810486,
-0.22403079271316528,
-0.8709357380867004,
0.32900458574295044,
0.1548188477754593,
0.40368276834487915,
-0.2693726122379303,
-0.20638498663902283,
-0.5069150924682617,
0.9953874349594116,
-0.08191770315170288,
-1.0041897296905518,
-0.19700010120868683,
0.515658438205719,
1.0721303224563599,
-0.6279380321502686,
0.23998621106147766,
0.6460272669792175,
0.1691625863313675,
-0.04265414923429489,
-1.1748614311218262,
-0.10888892412185669,
-0.10773143172264099,
0.2985166609287262,
0.1958358883857727,
-0.5970470309257507,
0.6450344324111938,
-0.5115078091621399,
0.23199892044067383,
0.05734645947813988,
0.32067152857780457,
0.22630538046360016,
0.7862310409545898,
0.3006022572517395,
0.7365431189537048,
0.8644731044769287,
0.007878906093537807,
1.131927251815796,
0.017486341297626495,
0.2923741340637207,
0.9044609069824219,
-0.45010146498680115,
0.5248425006866455,
0.36533284187316895,
-0.37967461347579956,
0.45757022500038147,
0.3118521571159363,
0.05647633224725723,
0.4960039258003235,
0.5472208261489868,
-0.4390530288219452,
-0.09397156536579132,
-0.05702214688062668,
-0.47493425011634827,
0.2688192129135132,
0.4867071807384491,
-0.7514157891273499,
-0.13739922642707825,
0.13570597767829895,
-0.03131747990846634,
0.05137253180146217,
-0.5495457053184509,
1.072508692741394,
0.3956887722015381,
-0.619943380355835,
0.6245729923248291,
-0.07348258048295975,
0.20093002915382385,
-0.7636628746986389,
0.004768273327499628,
-0.3820412755012512,
0.4658089578151703,
-0.2919294536113739,
-0.31716278195381165,
0.24129392206668854,
-0.02755868062376976,
-0.40572765469551086,
0.04216519370675087,
0.4884030520915985,
-0.2890152037143707,
-0.6236943602561951,
0.15498873591423035,
0.3970927894115448,
0.2454783320426941,
0.09765014052391052,
-0.5780514478683472,
0.14579711854457855,
-0.111434705555439,
0.0791204422712326,
0.5329405665397644,
0.4829763174057007,
-0.3337792158126831,
0.6345147490501404,
0.6604951620101929,
0.6938714385032654,
-0.28438517451286316,
0.6403259634971619,
0.731317937374115,
-0.4939897358417511,
-0.267385870218277,
-0.873184323310852,
0.22754980623722076,
0.0327538326382637,
-0.3523980379104614,
0.36347079277038574,
0.5543038845062256,
0.3500669002532959,
-0.08603276312351227,
0.9007391929626465,
0.4078812003135681,
0.51473069190979,
-0.526436448097229,
0.6639325618743896,
-0.6765947341918945,
0.2924852669239044,
-0.23049093782901764,
-0.5279963612556458,
-0.5419672131538391,
0.3717813193798065,
-0.5851930975914001,
0.0925796702504158,
0.5057073831558228,
0.36985138058662415,
0.2438674420118332,
-0.12087192386388779,
0.6618285775184631,
0.3195417523384094,
0.570464015007019,
0.642937421798706,
0.5858048796653748,
-0.15344159305095673,
0.18861332535743713,
-0.14449606835842133,
-0.4309213161468506,
-0.3775876760482788,
-0.5614739060401917,
-0.8894118666648865,
-0.17165488004684448,
-0.3175376057624817,
-0.20684976875782013,
0.3151814341545105,
0.7633644342422485,
0.485533207654953,
-1.1087080240249634,
-0.2858860194683075,
0.044358931481838226,
-0.05577806010842323,
-0.15452489256858826,
-0.16266478598117828,
0.47005653381347656,
-0.33388787508010864,
-0.41849979758262634,
0.001502854865975678,
0.38733839988708496,
0.05846906453371048,
-0.1423807293176651,
0.020595571026206017,
0.27535367012023926,
-0.14211630821228027,
0.5518496036529541,
-0.011749295517802238,
-0.796914279460907,
0.11382387578487396,
-0.008452084846794605,
-0.32606467604637146,
0.046677540987730026,
0.9690113663673401,
-0.22222988307476044,
0.5076504349708557,
0.05491117388010025,
0.46570274233818054,
0.29938405752182007,
0.14202524721622467,
0.4228399395942688,
-0.17180605232715607,
-0.09326429665088654,
0.3913000524044037,
0.5768917202949524,
0.20231930911540985,
-0.5127227902412415,
0.30647969245910645,
0.21673907339572906,
-0.8371825218200684,
-0.5462403893470764,
-0.008623163215816021,
-0.8550196886062622,
-0.017948593944311142,
1.168546199798584,
-0.1968645304441452,
0.014528146013617516,
-0.3628814220428467,
-0.2855693995952606,
0.10073967278003693,
-0.4106644093990326,
0.8778815269470215,
0.5031238198280334,
-0.3032263517379761,
-0.06425261497497559,
-0.8187490701675415,
0.3926496207714081,
0.3438696265220642,
-0.9437999725341797,
-0.009759852662682533,
0.6311371326446533,
0.3379765748977661,
0.08274190127849579,
1.0252740383148193,
-0.1569640040397644,
0.3672530949115753,
-0.5905594229698181,
-0.03305709362030029,
0.27983325719833374,
-0.06359034031629562,
-0.6139684319496155,
0.050915565341711044,
0.14896206557750702,
0.030576327815651894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08966v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08966v2 | Pretraining Vision-Language Model for Difference Visual Question Answering in Longitudinal Chest X-rays | 2024-02-14T06:20:48 | 2024-06-17T12:57:55 | Yeongjae Cho, Taehee Kim, Heejun Shin, Sungzoon Cho, Dongmyung Shin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Difference visual question answering (diff-VQA) is a challenging task that
requires answering complex questions based on differences between a pair of
images. This task is particularly important in reading chest X-ray images
because radiologists often compare multiple images of the same patient taken at
different times to track disease progression and changes in its severity in
their clinical practice. However, previous works focused on designing specific
network architectures for the diff-VQA task, missing opportunities to enhance
the model's performance using a pretrained vision-language model (VLM). Here,
we introduce a novel VLM called PLURAL, which is pretrained on natural and
longitudinal chest X-ray data for the diff-VQA task. The model is developed
using a step-by-step approach, starting with being pretrained on natural images
and texts, followed by being trained using longitudinal chest X-ray data. The
longitudinal data consist of pairs of X-ray images, along with question-answer
sets and radiologist's reports that describe the changes in lung abnormalities
and diseases over time. Our experimental results show that the PLURAL model
outperforms state-of-the-art methods not only in diff-VQA for longitudinal
X-rays but also in conventional VQA for a single X-ray image. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed VLM architecture
and pretraining method in improving the model's performance. | [
-0.4430789351463318,
-0.5576428174972534,
0.5352318286895752,
-0.04333397373557091,
-0.8048800230026245,
-0.04153641313314438,
0.41599681973457336,
-0.304244726896286,
0.08645151555538177,
0.5577094554901123,
-0.9363759160041809,
-0.4715597629547119,
-0.7630859017372131,
0.1062132716178894,
-0.5214568972587585,
0.6101967096328735,
-0.15045484900474548,
0.2568419575691223,
-0.2164362519979477,
-0.23054927587509155,
-0.5901267528533936,
-0.42796987295150757,
-0.39194172620773315,
-0.1096968948841095,
0.4376619756221771,
-0.18438801169395447,
0.6397887468338013,
0.22673724591732025,
0.674310028553009,
0.3174169063568115,
-0.16048654913902283,
0.13269250094890594,
-0.37533798813819885,
-0.16091689467430115,
0.16067320108413696,
-0.4924895763397217,
-0.2680179476737976,
-0.3185896575450897,
0.6969342231750488,
0.5281080603599548,
-0.19137515127658844,
0.09085848182439804,
-0.34596285223960876,
0.9624758362770081,
-0.4508374333381653,
-0.07823803275823593,
-0.5312941074371338,
0.27209344506263733,
-0.22225147485733032,
-0.2726549804210663,
-0.1923447847366333,
-0.14901220798492432,
0.49462082982063293,
-0.6702008247375488,
0.13328753411769867,
-0.19474241137504578,
1.0254756212234497,
0.39289140701293945,
-0.653394341468811,
0.011948254890739918,
-0.4463531970977783,
0.3915219008922577,
-0.5666016936302185,
0.7399338483810425,
0.16766583919525146,
0.48210546374320984,
0.35726678371429443,
-1.1321450471878052,
-0.5529351830482483,
-0.20526041090488434,
-0.2173890471458435,
0.38572925329208374,
-0.39657339453697205,
-0.039272136986255646,
0.024611132219433784,
0.2783467471599579,
-1.0457344055175781,
-0.022680869325995445,
-0.7256660461425781,
0.05368827283382416,
0.4836723804473877,
0.2783745527267456,
0.2970556616783142,
-0.20773330330848694,
-0.677768349647522,
-0.09152288734912872,
-0.5391883850097656,
-0.05758778005838394,
-0.18516327440738678,
-0.15526370704174042,
-0.06527388095855713,
0.35142943263053894,
-0.4862818717956543,
0.9525733590126038,
0.00978611595928669,
-0.08452129364013672,
0.6969231367111206,
-0.2313932180404663,
-0.6202773451805115,
-0.05479394644498825,
0.2680221199989319,
0.3258679509162903,
-0.14478223025798798,
0.1653408259153366,
-0.047866303473711014,
0.23754964768886566,
0.3539091944694519,
-0.6083201766014099,
-0.24775975942611694,
-0.015425609424710274,
-0.6970521807670593,
-0.3741336166858673,
0.024900369346141815,
-0.3792007863521576,
-0.07684949040412903,
-0.5181794166564941,
0.8025413751602173,
-0.24362152814865112,
-0.16021201014518738,
0.5557836294174194,
-0.21478942036628723,
0.12854118645191193,
0.4546913206577301,
-0.2051028609275818,
0.4089147448539734,
0.19373632967472076,
0.8167341947555542,
0.0767747238278389,
-0.27491647005081177,
-0.7648151516914368,
-0.3676924407482147,
-0.23390918970108032,
0.7304034233093262,
-0.3602612614631653,
-0.480533242225647,
-0.23537129163742065,
-0.04151943698525429,
-0.3155990540981293,
-0.7301692962646484,
0.13264892995357513,
-0.8803486227989197,
0.523504912853241,
-0.3273443579673767,
-0.35839611291885376,
-0.262686163187027,
0.47522473335266113,
-0.779619038105011,
0.9034342169761658,
0.17516374588012695,
-0.8070564866065979,
0.3441847264766693,
-0.4076046049594879,
-0.17710143327713013,
0.266196072101593,
-0.624189555644989,
-0.5667275786399841,
0.20890562236309052,
0.45703959465026855,
0.24247795343399048,
-0.13503606617450714,
0.05423584580421448,
-0.027484195306897163,
-0.2334194779396057,
0.37307366728782654,
-0.5025583505630493,
0.8190611004829407,
-0.1086408793926239,
-0.447511225938797,
-0.016006600111722946,
-0.8501480221748352,
0.17071519792079926,
0.10114963352680206,
-0.02178567461669445,
-0.36939549446105957,
0.024693820625543594,
-0.3389064371585846,
0.4348301887512207,
0.05341476574540138,
-0.45045438408851624,
0.2632830739021301,
-0.12281101942062378,
0.10037469118833542,
0.6260143518447876,
0.0857953131198883,
-0.17722152173519135,
-0.6027443408966064,
0.5189245939254761,
0.4155799150466919,
0.7439343929290771,
0.024705084040760994,
-0.6094722747802734,
-0.6093240976333618,
-0.3124620020389557,
-0.09075258672237396,
0.6124757528305054,
-1.0425596237182617,
-0.2582225799560547,
-0.029522689059376717,
-0.5211758613586426,
-0.5363066792488098,
0.10395165532827377,
0.7434383034706116,
0.8379490375518799,
0.7005956172943115,
-0.7228829860687256,
-0.6624959707260132,
-0.7786142826080322,
0.21397006511688232,
-0.3690723180770874,
0.302305668592453,
0.24450941383838654,
0.37316977977752686,
-0.4365232288837433,
0.4031369984149933,
-1.054120659828186,
-0.28593286871910095,
-0.026464510709047318,
0.2176671177148819,
0.12913328409194946,
0.048114243894815445,
0.483799010515213,
-1.4061704874038696,
-0.45714983344078064,
-0.07410481572151184,
-0.8283050060272217,
0.04308626800775528,
-0.08314088732004166,
-0.3101666271686554,
-0.09637873619794846,
0.9160208702087402,
-0.20987732708454132,
0.8012012839317322,
0.7179182767868042,
-0.2471913844347,
0.8642350435256958,
-0.16850920021533966,
0.20476140081882477,
-0.7336912751197815,
-0.10497688502073288,
-0.0699511393904686,
-0.32751840353012085,
-0.8324117660522461,
0.12020954489707947,
-0.06989533454179764,
0.10941241681575775,
-0.950517475605011,
0.6393113136291504,
-0.547823965549469,
0.08538512140512466,
0.025722358375787735,
-0.08495411276817322,
0.33269432187080383,
0.34068575501441956,
0.439430832862854,
0.24691453576087952,
0.8715516924858093,
-0.5204392671585083,
0.143190398812294,
0.5686406493186951,
-0.5082939863204956,
0.5531585216522217,
-0.934362530708313,
0.14072784781455994,
-0.4301096498966217,
0.059326354414224625,
-0.8879932165145874,
0.2869046926498413,
-0.03590637817978859,
-0.1717926412820816,
0.13082191348075867,
-0.23982758820056915,
-0.127890482544899,
-0.5757250785827637,
0.031975194811820984,
0.6842234134674072,
0.5168853998184204,
-0.5499005913734436,
0.48723578453063965,
-0.06892431527376175,
-0.12185593694448471,
-0.6395583152770996,
-0.7731710076332092,
-0.18609625101089478,
-0.06370756775140762,
-0.6103057861328125,
0.5822935700416565,
-0.2572277784347534,
-0.2872810959815979,
0.19457247853279114,
-0.15084749460220337,
-0.5969468951225281,
-0.013268944807350636,
0.31513381004333496,
0.5528515577316284,
-0.4748201370239258,
0.2340494841337204,
-0.015285525470972061,
-0.18368655443191528,
-0.38710740208625793,
-0.45665642619132996,
0.3741499185562134,
-0.2824028730392456,
-0.5702155828475952,
-0.45406287908554077,
0.46283969283103943,
0.4293922483921051,
-0.4558168649673462,
0.5139402747154236,
0.5574756860733032,
-0.27578163146972656,
0.26280495524406433,
-0.5838114023208618,
0.09173215925693512,
-0.4920499324798584,
0.516157329082489,
-0.29678523540496826,
-0.8520017266273499,
0.18780244886875153,
0.14304938912391663,
0.01791735738515854,
0.01776934042572975,
0.6396076083183289,
-0.42910298705101013,
0.7923703789710999,
0.5432673096656799,
0.38199159502983093,
0.48623326420783997,
-0.34862396121025085,
-0.11601840704679489,
-0.730657696723938,
-0.3251492381095886,
0.0019349869107827544,
-0.2575876712799072,
-0.04892563819885254,
-0.6574505567550659,
0.6509019136428833,
0.011338507756590843,
-0.15160372853279114,
-0.23374557495117188,
-0.39602020382881165,
0.44808274507522583,
0.4406675100326538,
0.5336538553237915,
0.4088895618915558,
-0.04251527786254883,
0.0001840804034145549,
-0.1795208901166916,
-0.7012670636177063,
-0.09510032832622528,
0.9394774436950684,
-0.1368551254272461,
0.4931682348251343,
0.28946515917778015,
0.8495521545410156,
0.2091839760541916,
0.08789438009262085,
-0.2894152104854584,
0.4550541043281555,
-0.7716315388679504,
-0.5354260802268982,
-0.23604197800159454,
-0.2922692894935608,
-1.17002534866333,
0.4614573121070862,
-0.16999100148677826,
-0.4498930871486664,
0.2517383098602295,
0.380471795797348,
-0.24383479356765747,
0.2629484236240387,
-0.49990805983543396,
0.9842633008956909,
-0.8119719624519348,
0.07434968650341034,
0.06682126969099045,
-0.8685390949249268,
0.3813337981700897,
-0.10320227593183517,
0.049266669899225235,
0.3552860915660858,
0.2241320013999939,
0.4466150403022766,
-0.5837811827659607,
0.8615838289260864,
-0.32083427906036377,
0.3274220824241638,
0.3032186031341553,
-0.13065217435359955,
0.050216250121593475,
0.17278002202510834,
0.1775391697883606,
0.22622118890285492,
0.25849130749702454,
-0.5490157008171082,
-0.753375232219696,
0.07922696322202682,
-0.9611101150512695,
-0.6265522241592407,
-0.2690398693084717,
-0.09722732752561569,
-0.09275107830762863,
0.327271968126297,
0.7269434332847595,
1.10038423538208,
-0.28707969188690186,
0.08291512727737427,
0.7723742723464966,
-0.2854371666908264,
0.015522648580372334,
0.6122907996177673,
-0.5247874855995178,
-0.062110595405101776,
0.5427121520042419,
0.2066573053598404,
0.4991009831428528,
0.9012337327003479,
0.22864070534706116,
-0.4988061785697937,
-0.6541272401809692,
-0.39661917090415955,
0.2559640109539032,
-0.7120339870452881,
0.0408526249229908,
-0.5527065396308899,
-0.2300330251455307,
-0.1579824835062027,
-0.1614522784948349,
-0.2031869739294052,
-0.040768589824438095,
-0.1908016800880432,
0.03182811662554741,
0.14276033639907837,
0.4882200062274933,
0.019190913066267967,
0.18683089315891266,
-0.8722999691963196,
0.6046282649040222,
0.8324546813964844,
0.07015959918498993,
-0.26578858494758606,
-0.7431567907333374,
-0.08611583709716797,
-0.17375534772872925,
0.016899285838007927,
-0.9345268607139587,
0.45069530606269836,
0.3056226074695587,
0.5843366980552673,
0.06645612418651581,
-0.03966483101248741,
0.955278217792511,
-0.41880151629447937,
0.693872332572937,
0.5286827683448792,
-0.8680447340011597,
0.470366895198822,
0.11938656121492386,
0.5217875838279724,
0.5878345370292664,
0.36460307240486145,
-0.5896512269973755,
0.08980581164360046,
-0.5444964170455933,
-0.8627599477767944,
0.2505485713481903,
0.2233687788248062,
-0.08484664559364319,
0.14731751382350922,
0.22872863709926605,
0.14148196578025818,
0.3091695308685303,
-0.695011556148529,
-0.29359960556030273,
-0.5504382252693176,
0.033928725868463516,
-0.12363491952419281,
0.021267861127853394,
-0.22119353711605072,
-0.3281936049461365,
0.5013262033462524,
-0.09371256083250046,
0.2557767629623413,
0.5238842964172363,
-0.5724630355834961,
0.4699682295322418,
0.05815194919705391,
0.539417028427124,
0.5361953377723694,
-0.10445169359445572,
0.20438703894615173,
0.156173974275589,
-0.5653122663497925,
0.19404223561286926,
-0.0022598884534090757,
-0.1456262618303299,
0.21221986413002014,
0.4347105622291565,
1.2994139194488525,
-0.007779912557452917,
-0.7547977566719055,
0.7777279019355774,
-0.7231569290161133,
-0.5665164589881897,
-0.23658354580402374,
-0.11748729646205902,
0.1128540188074112,
0.5531522035598755,
0.18005219101905823,
0.2143782079219818,
0.07005772739648819,
-0.2669079005718231,
0.4250853359699249,
-0.07106602936983109,
-0.5223644375801086,
-0.0964297354221344,
0.338128000497818,
0.02747800014913082,
-0.0318230502307415,
0.9902504086494446,
-0.12548691034317017,
-0.4898110628128052,
0.6632775664329529,
0.22823014855384827,
0.5129716992378235,
-0.06121406331658363,
0.637067973613739,
-0.035153698176145554,
0.33203646540641785,
0.0225953571498394,
0.5580074191093445,
0.055209603160619736,
-0.6699708700180054,
-0.1712471842765808,
-0.2689293622970581,
-0.10962264984846115,
0.19035932421684265,
-1.142870306968689,
0.3291771113872528,
-0.33457082509994507,
-0.1049419566988945,
-0.17928501963615417,
-0.09863825887441635,
-1.1246435642242432,
0.8343539834022522,
0.45357850193977356,
0.836578369140625,
-0.9151273369789124,
0.8249942064285278,
0.792590856552124,
-0.33094093203544617,
-0.9518270492553711,
-0.06526125222444534,
0.3287450075149536,
-1.0041861534118652,
0.9280036687850952,
0.07714778929948807,
-0.04834386333823204,
-0.026129567995667458,
0.0438251793384552,
-0.8586362600326538,
1.205795407295227,
0.15617699921131134,
-0.8495655655860901,
-0.08359986543655396,
-0.06313832849264145,
0.5885145664215088,
-0.15667131543159485,
0.1464560180902481,
0.08441539108753204,
0.15002290904521942,
0.13223473727703094,
-0.7862340211868286,
-0.18448826670646667,
-0.5490760207176208,
0.12020412087440491,
0.1243383064866066,
-0.5214424133300781,
1.0632421970367432,
-0.3449598550796509,
-0.18119016289710999,
0.001493551186285913,
0.42793896794319153,
0.357110857963562,
0.550778329372406,
0.790793240070343,
0.6325492262840271,
0.9302971959114075,
0.16238723695278168,
1.0263383388519287,
0.0011601918376982212,
0.15405409038066864,
1.3102840185165405,
-0.36370334029197693,
0.891667366027832,
0.4827457070350647,
-0.04331010952591896,
0.8280110955238342,
0.3797026574611664,
0.09404997527599335,
0.6246680617332458,
0.14763827621936798,
-0.2771678864955902,
-0.31382259726524353,
0.5130264759063721,
-0.767080545425415,
0.41385558247566223,
0.11190477758646011,
-0.3028014898300171,
-0.16324134171009064,
0.3080402910709381,
-0.37773481011390686,
-0.1472129225730896,
-0.30587321519851685,
0.6632384061813354,
0.08396375179290771,
-0.3775343894958496,
0.790766179561615,
-0.32042109966278076,
0.5384072661399841,
-0.813153088092804,
0.21181823313236237,
-0.2705303430557251,
0.1493874490261078,
-0.1620732694864273,
-0.6635355949401855,
0.3673481047153473,
-0.04572295397520065,
-0.35537463426589966,
0.06798415631055832,
0.37455296516418457,
-0.191371887922287,
-0.6755709052085876,
0.3718331456184387,
0.7172419428825378,
0.11758500337600708,
-0.03085293434560299,
-1.1342250108718872,
0.24142713844776154,
0.1242654025554657,
-0.13290467858314514,
0.3202597200870514,
0.26491159200668335,
-0.2945866286754608,
0.5065931677818298,
0.46610260009765625,
0.06748462468385696,
0.47111526131629944,
0.3044310510158539,
1.0060704946517944,
-0.28720447421073914,
-0.7030474543571472,
-0.5930231213569641,
0.7017426490783691,
0.01421720813959837,
-0.6570283770561218,
0.2698836326599121,
0.16335131227970123,
1.035198450088501,
-0.09177777916193008,
0.781662106513977,
0.1407635360956192,
0.21909771859645844,
-0.9464960694313049,
0.3023214638233185,
-1.1746987104415894,
0.19289125502109528,
-0.3785332441329956,
-0.3766113221645355,
-0.49771374464035034,
0.6288330554962158,
-0.35188543796539307,
-0.1318386048078537,
0.8482918739318848,
0.9305031299591064,
-0.10268457978963852,
-0.2957799732685089,
0.46874213218688965,
0.39386269450187683,
0.3787391781806946,
0.5706966519355774,
0.7012718915939331,
-0.48816996812820435,
0.5653097033500671,
-0.2923087477684021,
-0.2226291298866272,
-0.270385205745697,
-0.6293057799339294,
-0.674609899520874,
-0.8804888129234314,
-0.6953850984573364,
-0.1636660397052765,
0.514883279800415,
0.447173148393631,
1.0055514574050903,
-0.13987937569618225,
0.05258405953645706,
-0.007544971536844969,
-0.21610407531261444,
-0.41818350553512573,
-0.06373287737369537,
0.4742545485496521,
0.2371452897787094,
-0.16477787494659424,
0.24189911782741547,
0.4360333979129791,
0.2022145390510559,
-0.12285392731428146,
-0.10387825220823288,
-0.08058749884366989,
0.05058072879910469,
0.7447656393051147,
0.4360917806625366,
-0.5123216509819031,
0.011890836991369724,
0.14024144411087036,
-0.1104438528418541,
0.31901320815086365,
0.6476958394050598,
-0.9023814797401428,
0.9256636500358582,
0.529840350151062,
0.5763517022132874,
0.8210377097129822,
-0.014148401096463203,
0.08355899900197983,
-0.7592190504074097,
0.2688622772693634,
0.25025537610054016,
0.4521726369857788,
0.31670135259628296,
-0.27169620990753174,
0.010116477496922016,
0.40176817774772644,
-0.26756182312965393,
-0.8388949632644653,
0.5889874696731567,
-1.1227302551269531,
-0.561397910118103,
0.7298716902732849,
-0.1172032356262207,
-0.29096001386642456,
-0.1708008050918579,
-0.3846954107284546,
0.0018133122939616442,
0.3132910132408142,
0.7361775636672974,
0.15183213353157043,
-0.21768079698085785,
-0.5242710709571838,
-0.09398100525140762,
0.15620523691177368,
0.611877977848053,
-0.9664151072502136,
-0.588803768157959,
0.2913531959056854,
0.4588988423347473,
-0.11971766501665115,
1.1102344989776611,
-0.3663720488548279,
0.7033873200416565,
0.15314602851867676,
-0.24344804883003235,
-0.20585189759731293,
-0.34858712553977966,
-0.292534202337265,
0.011404705233871937,
-0.06269890815019608,
-0.43465638160705566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08957v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08957v3 | MUSTARD: Mastering Uniform Synthesis of Theorem and Proof Data | 2024-02-14T05:57:58 | 2024-05-23T03:13:23 | Yinya Huang, Xiaohan Lin, Zhengying Liu, Qingxing Cao, Huajian Xin, Haiming Wang, Zhenguo Li, Linqi Song, Xiaodan Liang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LG, cs.PL | Recent large language models (LLMs) have witnessed significant advancement in
various tasks, including mathematical reasoning and theorem proving. As these
two tasks require strict and formal multi-step inference, they are appealing
domains for exploring the reasoning ability of LLMs but still face important
challenges. Previous studies such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) have revealed the
effectiveness of intermediate steps guidance. However, such step-wise
annotation requires heavy labor, leading to insufficient training steps for
current benchmarks. To fill this gap, this work introduces MUSTARD, a data
generation framework that masters uniform synthesis of theorem and proof data
of high quality and diversity. MUSTARD synthesizes data in three stages: (1) It
samples a few mathematical concept seeds as the problem category. (2) Then, it
prompts a generative language model with the sampled concepts to obtain both
the problems and their step-wise formal solutions. (3) Lastly, the framework
utilizes a proof assistant (e.g., Lean Prover) to filter the valid proofs. With
the proposed MUSTARD, we present a theorem-and-proof benchmark MUSTARDSAUCE
with 5,866 valid data points. Each data point contains an informal statement,
an informal proof, and a translated formal proof that passes the prover
validation. We perform extensive analysis and demonstrate that MUSTARD
generates validated high-quality step-by-step data. We further apply the
MUSTARDSAUCE for fine-tuning smaller language models. The fine-tuned Llama 2-7B
achieves a 15.41% average relative performance gain in automated theorem
proving, and 8.18% in math word problems. Codes and data are available at
https://github.com/Eleanor-H/MUSTARD. | [
-0.4365995526313782,
-0.6367814540863037,
0.5355953574180603,
0.5183675289154053,
-0.09007050842046738,
0.04237790405750275,
-0.41758036613464355,
-0.15998612344264984,
-0.2144540548324585,
0.6796977519989014,
-0.3558809459209442,
-0.9407979846000671,
-0.4267204701900482,
0.20925703644752502,
-0.5206871628761292,
0.8301383256912231,
-0.21575254201889038,
0.05576225742697716,
0.01675943098962307,
-0.06478389352560043,
-0.3330947160720825,
-0.1836300939321518,
-0.441413938999176,
-0.3281337022781372,
0.14327482879161835,
0.6663581132888794,
0.5005338788032532,
1.1465177536010742,
0.2614922523498535,
0.2954350709915161,
0.14826451241970062,
0.34347355365753174,
-0.4436051845550537,
0.35806557536125183,
-0.22948850691318512,
-0.5845295190811157,
-0.3200778067111969,
-0.10018952935934067,
0.38836151361465454,
0.6606492400169373,
0.031950876116752625,
0.08436227589845657,
-0.09186962246894836,
0.6377182006835938,
-0.6150364875793457,
0.13092251121997833,
-0.8348434567451477,
-0.038045380264520645,
-0.3738548755645752,
0.046668265014886856,
-0.36876702308654785,
-0.5218697786331177,
-0.3167508542537689,
-0.7216658592224121,
0.29759711027145386,
-0.15557165443897247,
0.8016052842140198,
0.40095680952072144,
-0.2782778739929199,
-0.42857813835144043,
-0.7122379541397095,
0.8634845018386841,
-0.5329168438911438,
0.4117262065410614,
0.20278605818748474,
0.7780424356460571,
-0.5035704970359802,
-0.7232247591018677,
-0.6558035016059875,
-0.04534080997109413,
0.3575395941734314,
0.008633330464363098,
0.0610482431948185,
-0.2766396105289459,
0.23736786842346191,
0.3226265609264374,
-0.4267845153808594,
-0.07092088460922241,
-0.17174996435642242,
-0.09395188093185425,
0.7035778760910034,
0.07275775074958801,
0.0432649701833725,
-0.31310033798217773,
-0.15802353620529175,
-0.3641601800918579,
-0.7240399122238159,
-0.19388297200202942,
0.3479176461696625,
0.207469642162323,
-0.07089803367853165,
0.7634674906730652,
-0.34460604190826416,
0.6140910983085632,
-0.13867026567459106,
-0.2632276713848114,
-0.07042623311281204,
-0.44630950689315796,
-0.23944680392742157,
-0.1427040994167328,
0.766616702079773,
0.18235920369625092,
0.5800490975379944,
-0.04132753238081932,
-0.09974648803472519,
0.5476552844047546,
0.04821966961026192,
-0.7059937119483948,
-0.507330060005188,
0.48369497060775757,
0.02424999140202999,
-0.2912587821483612,
0.006177099421620369,
-0.8843342065811157,
-0.4826698303222656,
-0.3812657594680786,
0.00474232342094183,
-0.8007182478904724,
0.028503745794296265,
0.3198913335800171,
-0.24009642004966736,
0.07634851336479187,
0.28547850251197815,
-0.5689379572868347,
0.45749354362487793,
0.8907080888748169,
0.4696435034275055,
0.10984626412391663,
-0.2165580838918686,
-0.3740959167480469,
0.28984692692756653,
-0.786726713180542,
0.8514941334724426,
-0.4599609375,
-0.055981315672397614,
0.06421584635972977,
-0.3702054023742676,
0.1824706643819809,
-0.7893379330635071,
0.7194127440452576,
-0.2759822607040405,
-0.19595445692539215,
-0.22501878440380096,
-0.7432804703712463,
0.15369711816310883,
0.2750197649002075,
-0.4124489724636078,
1.172116756439209,
0.039747435599565506,
-0.6518821120262146,
0.482677698135376,
-0.369497686624527,
-0.3756653070449829,
-0.09592887759208679,
-0.4937931299209595,
-0.33899304270744324,
-0.13732826709747314,
0.4526624083518982,
0.4902617633342743,
-0.4863785207271576,
0.11307623237371445,
-0.2406764179468155,
-0.09142787009477615,
0.437907874584198,
0.006320946849882603,
0.6454882025718689,
0.253910630941391,
-0.49811214208602905,
0.05775298923254013,
-1.3630397319793701,
-0.026365432888269424,
0.33598577976226807,
-0.526780903339386,
-0.24869878590106964,
-0.13114666938781738,
-0.19283783435821533,
0.2118261307477951,
-0.01179046742618084,
-0.40222933888435364,
0.23000404238700867,
-0.23571661114692688,
0.028154242783784866,
0.8180698156356812,
0.08625917136669159,
0.33521556854248047,
-0.36226847767829895,
0.2838435471057892,
0.058667272329330444,
-0.01574314385652542,
-0.10288634896278381,
-0.4661969244480133,
-1.1712678670883179,
-0.5754830837249756,
0.5395534634590149,
0.44276514649391174,
-0.7373569011688232,
0.6051985025405884,
-0.18016815185546875,
-0.5453208684921265,
-0.6554080843925476,
0.5540866851806641,
0.34898290038108826,
0.3619658350944519,
0.38506290316581726,
-0.04566407948732376,
-0.9212911128997803,
-0.6932327747344971,
-0.3907816708087921,
0.09503263235092163,
-0.3691919445991516,
0.12143684178590775,
0.38718390464782715,
-0.5983972549438477,
1.0668376684188843,
-0.37663546204566956,
-0.22666561603546143,
-0.27277418971061707,
0.1400858610868454,
0.44035178422927856,
0.4513315260410309,
0.3212776780128479,
-0.4060216546058655,
-0.5226415395736694,
0.1817452758550644,
-0.7969370484352112,
-0.5216174721717834,
-0.14806289970874786,
-0.6241050958633423,
0.2275579422712326,
0.5765961408615112,
-0.269815057516098,
0.19571973383426666,
0.3346808850765228,
-0.12256406247615814,
0.5486181378364563,
0.030400920659303665,
0.027431244030594826,
-0.953169584274292,
-0.10431525856256485,
0.21705211699008942,
-0.3930390775203705,
-0.4310758709907532,
0.12100635468959808,
0.09456638991832733,
0.2218913584947586,
-0.18707053363323212,
0.4402277171611786,
-0.15410387516021729,
0.07754018157720566,
-0.20112094283103943,
-0.1444856971502304,
-0.058400146663188934,
0.2605014443397522,
-0.2374565303325653,
0.4993610382080078,
0.5694796442985535,
-0.9426181316375732,
0.4347670078277588,
-0.04891359806060791,
-0.20006583631038666,
0.5894435048103333,
-0.6074325442314148,
-0.12562160193920135,
0.1723032295703888,
0.19834114611148834,
-1.0623788833618164,
-0.43317168951034546,
0.295555979013443,
-0.28265273571014404,
0.04757146164774895,
-0.41334062814712524,
-0.7937896251678467,
-0.25932231545448303,
-0.2504585087299347,
0.15397903323173523,
0.7488682866096497,
-0.7136720418930054,
0.46008050441741943,
0.22841309010982513,
-0.0646614357829094,
-0.2562459111213684,
-0.4715367555618286,
-0.10053939372301102,
-0.10600370168685913,
-0.6557747721672058,
0.1832084357738495,
0.024197783321142197,
-0.5423667430877686,
-0.20041881501674652,
-0.17382287979125977,
-0.011965449899435043,
-0.1677398532629013,
0.07397662848234177,
-0.1316993236541748,
0.18254035711288452,
-0.16648167371749878,
0.11303161829710007,
-0.28767240047454834,
0.07958192378282547,
-0.4962445795536041,
0.6742814183235168,
0.2108021229505539,
-0.3222676217556,
0.0388278067111969,
0.12767598032951355,
0.37855264544487,
0.10083131492137909,
0.28852763772010803,
0.5850933790206909,
-0.4124913811683655,
-0.7654854655265808,
-0.4095272719860077,
0.1179175078868866,
-0.47980165481567383,
0.12306947261095047,
-0.505064070224762,
-0.2291644811630249,
0.39164021611213684,
-0.5111609101295471,
0.3965094983577728,
0.5390280485153198,
0.7703302502632141,
-0.10435588657855988,
0.6594717502593994,
0.3706204891204834,
0.2719838619232178,
0.18942230939865112,
-0.49740874767303467,
-0.1760435253381729,
-0.5915495157241821,
-0.17565342783927917,
-0.6679483652114868,
0.030777662992477417,
-0.545221209526062,
-0.914921224117279,
0.47496601939201355,
0.31871065497398376,
-0.3020094931125641,
0.3464062809944153,
-0.38455793261528015,
0.4923035800457001,
0.514009952545166,
0.045232828706502914,
0.2819356918334961,
0.037359822541475296,
-0.4287838637828827,
-0.18763096630573273,
-0.6418848037719727,
-0.5765888094902039,
1.4291044473648071,
0.3197459578514099,
0.892509937286377,
0.130513995885849,
1.080662727355957,
0.18051698803901672,
0.13591431081295013,
-0.5036526322364807,
0.7873852252960205,
-0.14757610857486725,
-0.39130911231040955,
-0.15230482816696167,
-0.7603216171264648,
-0.8755120635032654,
0.18157996237277985,
-0.042120981961488724,
-0.42069438099861145,
-0.1740289181470871,
0.14077875018119812,
0.2149723470211029,
-0.12242896854877472,
-0.5103254318237305,
0.5252715349197388,
-0.10344186425209045,
-0.4804441034793854,
-0.026822585612535477,
-0.4041776657104492,
0.6251477599143982,
-0.04470519721508026,
0.4963185489177704,
-0.1552252471446991,
0.18847446143627167,
0.854272723197937,
-0.7784388661384583,
0.6650279760360718,
-0.03193850442767143,
-0.4725518822669983,
0.24317459762096405,
0.37466996908187866,
0.6015600562095642,
0.22562620043754578,
0.0432685986161232,
-0.022712718695402145,
-0.3185676634311676,
-0.45043453574180603,
-0.5096583366394043,
0.640302836894989,
-0.5646094679832458,
-0.38857775926589966,
-0.40971627831459045,
-0.6625953912734985,
-0.29468223452568054,
0.28718268871307373,
0.3101573884487152,
-0.03182709589600563,
-0.056036874651908875,
-0.18118742108345032,
0.8564004302024841,
-0.10366026312112808,
0.14716893434524536,
0.0837143287062645,
-0.3277478516101837,
-0.7894628047943115,
0.9892335534095764,
0.08662114292383194,
0.2053035944700241,
0.23811252415180206,
0.19693513214588165,
-0.18244780600070953,
-0.35753902792930603,
-0.534581184387207,
0.2685403823852539,
-0.9665098190307617,
-0.19003212451934814,
-0.5456662178039551,
-0.04118494689464569,
-0.5797312259674072,
-0.28275322914123535,
-0.7151833772659302,
-0.6853454113006592,
0.21299390494823456,
0.31011223793029785,
0.5235138535499573,
0.6996119022369385,
-0.26399850845336914,
-0.028624963015317917,
-0.4089769124984741,
0.9679206013679504,
0.4120658040046692,
0.33608147501945496,
-0.26140260696411133,
-0.1762702316045761,
-0.23247596621513367,
0.01054284069687128,
-0.3640744686126709,
-0.7467180490493774,
0.24072448909282684,
0.001598017755895853,
0.3707839250564575,
0.338296115398407,
0.08817979693412781,
0.7123541235923767,
-0.6329056620597839,
0.497526079416275,
0.007377560716122389,
-1.0297924280166626,
0.6356281638145447,
-0.26482078433036804,
0.1104140505194664,
0.42000752687454224,
0.2699066400527954,
-0.26103708148002625,
-0.662224531173706,
-0.661575198173523,
-0.9644836187362671,
0.18453553318977356,
0.43163254857063293,
-0.5915708541870117,
0.15276190638542175,
0.07225728034973145,
0.3068130314350128,
0.05416499078273773,
-0.38877829909324646,
-0.3291877210140228,
-0.22374099493026733,
-0.5039723515510559,
0.08543676882982254,
-0.08414743840694427,
-0.440544992685318,
-0.34440305829048157,
0.7501311898231506,
-0.15793360769748688,
0.13159804046154022,
-0.05746741592884064,
-0.12379404902458191,
0.09109431505203247,
0.38158389925956726,
0.293326735496521,
0.661149263381958,
-0.16868501901626587,
0.34831416606903076,
-0.1215977668762207,
-0.382741242647171,
0.3639684319496155,
0.3123345971107483,
-0.14838813245296478,
0.3070720136165619,
0.45601826906204224,
0.19357940554618835,
0.09419792890548706,
-0.5988582372665405,
0.13722127676010132,
-0.1508430689573288,
-0.1505812108516693,
-0.18662236630916595,
0.4174758195877075,
0.02648690529167652,
0.20443397760391235,
0.23617778718471527,
-0.03844374045729637,
0.06809185445308685,
-0.35867470502853394,
0.3151313364505768,
0.1556577831506729,
0.37749308347702026,
-0.04349169135093689,
0.5567699670791626,
-0.010645300149917603,
0.08576471358537674,
0.1521233767271042,
-0.26044222712516785,
-0.4698368310928345,
0.6288202404975891,
0.6223413348197937,
0.6042309403419495,
0.0012298241490498185,
0.08614631742238998,
0.31768837571144104,
0.17021816968917847,
0.043203987181186676,
0.5111409425735474,
-0.15389752388000488,
-0.4781305491924286,
-0.1667289435863495,
-0.8122276663780212,
-0.5780176520347595,
-0.1145181804895401,
-0.3993277847766876,
0.30292004346847534,
-0.7037635445594788,
0.20300230383872986,
0.17562545835971832,
0.16625149548053741,
-0.8719983100891113,
0.2370043694972992,
-0.1167004257440567,
1.0089688301086426,
-0.7987082004547119,
0.7313030362129211,
0.562219500541687,
-0.14081257581710815,
-0.7514389157295227,
0.022982032969594002,
0.021155308932065964,
-0.6638171672821045,
0.4027002453804016,
-0.055794283747673035,
0.16447971761226654,
-0.22675791382789612,
-0.5394858121871948,
-0.619953453540802,
0.8650461435317993,
0.5485041737556458,
-0.6265445351600647,
0.5421871542930603,
0.5375031232833862,
0.40791550278663635,
-0.3015492260456085,
-0.11591028422117233,
0.9057642817497253,
0.5382004976272583,
0.4794663190841675,
-0.646903932094574,
0.08083181083202362,
-0.2221328169107437,
0.17870499193668365,
-0.08364076167345047,
-0.29649659991264343,
1.0413017272949219,
-0.03683580458164215,
-0.07688526809215546,
0.17798739671707153,
0.7041303515434265,
1.0143299102783203,
0.2622055411338806,
0.16069450974464417,
0.8988032341003418,
0.9394228458404541,
-0.19567114114761353,
1.2126742601394653,
-0.082143634557724,
0.09361454099416733,
1.020277976989746,
-0.4222720265388489,
0.5443540215492249,
0.442323237657547,
-0.2436407059431076,
0.5731542110443115,
0.5611402988433838,
0.11295876652002335,
0.35931387543678284,
0.6395198106765747,
-0.1786627471446991,
-0.18411734700202942,
-0.02212640829384327,
-0.4443477988243103,
0.2539045810699463,
0.4105647802352905,
-0.2687431871891022,
-0.15974287688732147,
-0.23679934442043304,
0.2445901334285736,
0.18288801610469818,
-0.1857679784297943,
0.8493092060089111,
-0.0933930054306984,
-0.5714488625526428,
1.0211858749389648,
0.2511856257915497,
0.4812264144420624,
-0.5278273820877075,
-0.22208136320114136,
-0.4169691503047943,
0.5947672724723816,
-0.15498510003089905,
-0.7223191261291504,
0.014834183268249035,
0.3611283600330353,
-0.14422529935836792,
0.10753444582223892,
0.4724692404270172,
-0.4052402675151825,
-0.7865746021270752,
0.05633517727255821,
0.2411399632692337,
0.15102870762348175,
0.28510457277297974,
-0.3794362246990204,
0.5392509698867798,
-0.1937067061662674,
-0.06100442633032799,
0.014102946035563946,
1.054544448852539,
-0.05177856609225273,
0.6483444571495056,
0.8032767176628113,
0.4336254596710205,
0.4091121256351471,
0.12406092137098312,
1.022820234298706,
-0.6150678396224976,
-0.49350693821907043,
-0.8554361462593079,
0.37470555305480957,
-0.2568867802619934,
-0.04958565533161163,
1.008776068687439,
0.45014524459838867,
1.031967043876648,
-0.09882400184869766,
1.0809524059295654,
-0.052631691098213196,
0.3293035328388214,
-0.7521244287490845,
0.4053225517272949,
-0.12509331107139587,
0.33945944905281067,
-0.5135043859481812,
-1.0459229946136475,
-0.5392746925354004,
0.6967103481292725,
0.0013126092962920666,
-0.022628838196396828,
0.5873497724533081,
0.6779623627662659,
-0.19311222434043884,
-0.3053776025772095,
0.07388528436422348,
0.3206965923309326,
0.8527817130088806,
0.6016589403152466,
0.5535264611244202,
-0.6506662368774414,
0.5360025763511658,
-0.3533792793750763,
-0.3951985538005829,
-0.11051520705223083,
-0.8059266805648804,
-0.9654226899147034,
-0.3038998544216156,
-0.39349567890167236,
-0.6428765654563904,
-0.033371955156326294,
0.9269600510597229,
0.7344980835914612,
-0.7873371243476868,
-0.44475358724594116,
-0.6848084926605225,
0.3149740993976593,
-0.33012935519218445,
-0.22207966446876526,
0.2529081106185913,
-0.5244923233985901,
-0.6513350009918213,
0.4114297926425934,
0.23104293644428253,
0.03311726450920105,
-0.2169087529182434,
-0.4057775139808655,
-0.19998006522655487,
0.4132741093635559,
0.33134952187538147,
0.380567342042923,
-0.5240345597267151,
0.0671355202794075,
-0.4047233760356903,
-0.13927119970321655,
-0.0869574099779129,
0.7483863234519958,
-0.7614163160324097,
0.511581301689148,
0.3041881024837494,
0.7163391709327698,
0.3918185830116272,
-0.15428048372268677,
0.6667434573173523,
-1.0868699550628662,
0.18576614558696747,
0.07376867532730103,
0.5868702530860901,
0.4390183091163635,
-0.12332919239997864,
0.6064412593841553,
0.2316928207874298,
-0.38447993993759155,
-0.8150773644447327,
0.3804849684238434,
-0.7633911371231079,
-0.2775057256221771,
1.4518043994903564,
-0.08973606675863266,
-0.5497170686721802,
-0.09322135895490646,
-0.2651633322238922,
0.4818347990512848,
-0.32294344902038574,
0.8175008893013,
0.4935641288757324,
-0.09071121364831924,
0.09554963558912277,
-0.19591660797595978,
0.5546743869781494,
0.2559533417224884,
-0.9710665345191956,
0.2721008062362671,
0.49972081184387207,
0.35505494475364685,
0.16255943477153778,
0.4675915241241455,
-0.13613347709178925,
0.27374520897865295,
0.25160256028175354,
0.0504247210919857,
-0.16315828263759613,
-0.781629741191864,
-0.038486503064632416,
0.19388538599014282,
0.0542895644903183,
-0.3009669780731201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08955v1 | Using Counterfactual Tasks to Evaluate the Generality of Analogical Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T05:52:23 | 2024-02-14T05:52:23 | Martha Lewis, Melanie Mitchell | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have performed well on several reasoning
benchmarks, including ones that test analogical reasoning abilities. However,
it has been debated whether they are actually performing humanlike abstract
reasoning or instead employing less general processes that rely on similarity
to what has been seen in their training data. Here we investigate the
generality of analogy-making abilities previously claimed for LLMs (Webb,
Holyoak, & Lu, 2023). We take one set of analogy problems used to evaluate LLMs
and create a set of "counterfactual" variants-versions that test the same
abstract reasoning abilities but that are likely dissimilar from any
pre-training data. We test humans and three GPT models on both the original and
counterfactual problems, and show that, while the performance of humans remains
high for all the problems, the GPT models' performance declines sharply on the
counterfactual set. This work provides evidence that, despite previously
reported successes of LLMs on analogical reasoning, these models lack the
robustness and generality of human analogy-making. | [
-0.5373614430427551,
-0.8506858944892883,
1.0219719409942627,
-0.37550246715545654,
-0.2624357342720032,
-0.2892778813838959,
-0.20495466887950897,
-0.6171355843544006,
0.18936218321323395,
0.26965147256851196,
-0.5733240246772766,
-0.06373298168182373,
-0.5647191405296326,
0.12249623239040375,
-0.4273815155029297,
0.9032294750213623,
-0.14243143796920776,
0.06037464737892151,
-0.39268213510513306,
-0.326834499835968,
-0.2319989949464798,
-0.7894760966300964,
-0.5137719511985779,
-0.7703733444213867,
0.3603232502937317,
-0.055739641189575195,
1.1110224723815918,
0.49187707901000977,
0.1932476907968521,
0.35089612007141113,
0.2841772437095642,
-0.1538858711719513,
-0.43826180696487427,
-0.0878170058131218,
-0.7415468692779541,
-0.5396386384963989,
-0.3372234106063843,
0.4826001524925232,
0.404019832611084,
0.8283117413520813,
0.006036895792931318,
0.1705930382013321,
0.043946441262960434,
0.3520987629890442,
-0.34117355942726135,
0.1285143792629242,
-0.99794602394104,
-0.2263815701007843,
0.25577834248542786,
0.04621860012412071,
-0.14428672194480896,
-0.2826352119445801,
0.42429953813552856,
-0.6851233839988708,
0.518604040145874,
0.20405827462673187,
0.8401567935943604,
0.0496809221804142,
-0.17859932780265808,
-0.3729104697704315,
-0.625337541103363,
0.9170328378677368,
-0.8575361967086792,
0.10107777267694473,
0.3529900908470154,
0.2063177078962326,
-0.211944580078125,
-0.5865769982337952,
-0.9148974418640137,
-0.629873514175415,
-0.19863706827163696,
-0.14725476503372192,
-0.5468108654022217,
-0.030332205817103386,
0.5821636319160461,
0.18774856626987457,
-0.8179174661636353,
0.15822185575962067,
-0.26124799251556396,
0.02128041349351406,
0.30155640840530396,
0.2730081379413605,
0.3719630539417267,
0.23703469336032867,
-0.26751837134361267,
-0.07746061682701111,
-1.0068403482437134,
-0.13957852125167847,
0.2614351511001587,
-0.0302717387676239,
-0.005887823645025492,
0.37560784816741943,
-0.26469460129737854,
0.5651514530181885,
0.008161102421581745,
0.16623809933662415,
0.0840601995587349,
-0.026832260191440582,
-0.34049227833747864,
-0.3087804615497589,
0.5056909322738647,
0.6528632640838623,
0.86002516746521,
-0.32920151948928833,
-0.24860885739326477,
0.5354909896850586,
0.21717078983783722,
-0.6305615901947021,
-0.299219012260437,
-0.0920497477054596,
-0.3786567747592926,
-0.014316515065729618,
0.028826287016272545,
-0.18739672005176544,
-0.033009521663188934,
-0.6751311421394348,
0.8566555976867676,
-0.22795702517032623,
-0.12282689660787582,
0.018850717693567276,
-0.22219382226467133,
0.1879003345966339,
0.320575088262558,
-0.8955903649330139,
0.5900411009788513,
0.7961723208427429,
0.6513862609863281,
-0.1470024436712265,
-0.7707329988479614,
-0.5432011485099792,
0.056131813675165176,
-0.5248621106147766,
0.8176915049552917,
-0.8179110884666443,
-0.3661404550075531,
-0.27464887499809265,
0.08285263925790787,
-0.3052598536014557,
-0.9726387858390808,
0.1349545121192932,
-0.2548110783100128,
0.16929294168949127,
-0.5933729410171509,
-0.5446056723594666,
-0.18218262493610382,
0.539991021156311,
-0.42693886160850525,
0.6025283336639404,
0.013599665835499763,
-0.5513281226158142,
0.32847878336906433,
-0.42366233468055725,
-0.2616131603717804,
-0.2000960111618042,
-0.5695717334747314,
-0.27732422947883606,
0.28155753016471863,
-0.02493816800415516,
0.25089383125305176,
-0.7120382189750671,
0.21666719019412994,
-0.6492921113967896,
-0.8493717312812805,
0.31421148777008057,
-0.4028608500957489,
0.5645773410797119,
-0.015949005261063576,
-0.46895816922187805,
-0.03066239133477211,
-0.3720880448818207,
0.06847944110631943,
0.2877083718776703,
0.05600503087043762,
-0.5123873353004456,
0.0452691987156868,
-0.4323703646659851,
0.4132494330406189,
-0.06795307993888855,
-0.6323686242103577,
0.28441861271858215,
-0.32888704538345337,
0.5250798463821411,
0.6530134081840515,
-0.20550724864006042,
0.15768052637577057,
-0.8302572965621948,
0.5068534016609192,
-0.11479932069778442,
-0.15135349333286285,
0.06484745442867279,
-0.7512578964233398,
-0.6611039042472839,
-0.10306774824857712,
0.02251724898815155,
0.5515508055686951,
-0.7269790172576904,
0.06881561875343323,
-0.5178588628768921,
-0.47416287660598755,
-0.16656646132469177,
0.03220251575112343,
0.5774950981140137,
0.6245793104171753,
0.39185094833374023,
-0.3815179467201233,
-0.4242538511753082,
-1.2697259187698364,
-0.6419106721878052,
-0.4244515597820282,
-0.43958041071891785,
0.13889890909194946,
0.8295947909355164,
-0.1808956116437912,
0.8984826803207397,
-0.42451992630958557,
0.045145127922296524,
-0.015282073989510536,
0.5423956513404846,
0.2801484167575836,
0.33281174302101135,
0.7259259223937988,
-0.6204507350921631,
-0.2524365186691284,
-0.1149139255285263,
-0.8962511420249939,
-0.3547648787498474,
-0.14741918444633484,
0.4381800889968872,
0.2467600405216217,
0.6958736777305603,
-0.8902400135993958,
0.4711531102657318,
0.4384740889072418,
-0.2337467074394226,
1.0106950998306274,
-0.3761206567287445,
0.3325587809085846,
-0.4705039858818054,
0.1845848560333252,
-0.08402293175458908,
-0.02110355719923973,
-0.6253431439399719,
0.1897255778312683,
-0.23807533085346222,
-0.015214783139526844,
-0.46976780891418457,
0.7556537985801697,
-0.30771109461784363,
-0.25095105171203613,
-0.27718812227249146,
0.04554993659257889,
-0.06697879731655121,
0.4548870921134949,
0.250976026058197,
0.8600366115570068,
0.38424956798553467,
-0.46058252453804016,
0.3478942811489105,
-0.3099275231361389,
-0.2359996736049652,
0.7666374444961548,
-1.0099618434906006,
0.22806009650230408,
-0.15308575332164764,
0.2732888460159302,
-0.9456542134284973,
0.02697853557765484,
0.12628820538520813,
-0.17993105947971344,
-0.1758967936038971,
-0.060217224061489105,
-0.6163387894630432,
-0.334096223115921,
-0.4127286970615387,
0.39880621433258057,
0.8715329170227051,
-0.3661080002784729,
0.5969126224517822,
-0.33059972524642944,
-0.20978407561779022,
-0.2965543866157532,
-0.8856150507926941,
0.17571966350078583,
-0.4062170684337616,
-0.3280436098575592,
0.22756953537464142,
-0.06711845844984055,
-0.5378578305244446,
0.27528566122055054,
-0.22014360129833221,
-0.10719973593950272,
-0.07959968596696854,
0.11651647090911865,
0.31230878829956055,
-0.28330060839653015,
0.035457804799079895,
-0.17533281445503235,
-0.14552241563796997,
0.27998214960098267,
-0.15909406542778015,
0.2289879024028778,
-0.2487223744392395,
-0.7301585078239441,
-0.040076520293951035,
0.29972752928733826,
0.4713798463344574,
0.1999853551387787,
0.6906599998474121,
0.27840369939804077,
-0.2746988832950592,
0.08687413483858109,
-0.7576854825019836,
-0.32992714643478394,
-0.41266700625419617,
0.48576828837394714,
-0.7070897221565247,
-0.7674084901809692,
0.6913577318191528,
0.06938422471284866,
0.08159700781106949,
0.4869093596935272,
0.47188934683799744,
-0.15092125535011292,
0.6321981549263,
-0.07702990621328354,
0.15822766721248627,
-0.015065369196236134,
-0.03898829594254494,
0.14509981870651245,
-0.5280545949935913,
0.13055716454982758,
-0.4135904610157013,
-0.15130889415740967,
-0.5543212294578552,
-0.3772661089897156,
0.16200372576713562,
-0.05524203181266785,
-0.5776809453964233,
0.3354809284210205,
-0.06321315467357635,
0.6305444240570068,
0.4453091025352478,
0.017785947769880295,
0.4658603072166443,
-0.018494663760066032,
-0.14355061948299408,
-0.19035710394382477,
-0.5709617137908936,
-0.6739179491996765,
1.0397454500198364,
0.08387445658445358,
0.627447247505188,
0.05149100348353386,
0.40763285756111145,
0.23528103530406952,
0.7445976734161377,
-0.3601342737674713,
0.7947027087211609,
-0.5059043169021606,
-0.6663864850997925,
-0.2187754511833191,
-0.3856952488422394,
-0.9917194247245789,
0.6095103621482849,
-0.2228250354528427,
-0.8890030384063721,
-0.0030334729235619307,
0.3933427929878235,
0.05147005617618561,
0.5366647839546204,
-0.8397290110588074,
0.777886688709259,
0.15948888659477234,
-0.12595625221729279,
-0.4268925189971924,
-0.5107837319374084,
0.41618576645851135,
-0.1874091625213623,
0.23774372041225433,
0.050387799739837646,
-0.014308439567685127,
0.5707384943962097,
-0.3531557023525238,
0.8645907044410706,
-0.08640935271978378,
-0.07492838054895401,
0.2324184775352478,
0.3668364882469177,
0.5537869334220886,
-0.34555742144584656,
-0.08483649790287018,
0.2681160271167755,
0.019142573699355125,
-0.55084228515625,
-0.9971371293067932,
0.8085122108459473,
-0.5799244046211243,
-1.181258201599121,
-0.39427393674850464,
-0.5691946744918823,
-0.3379206657409668,
0.11237850785255432,
0.15986570715904236,
0.4543408453464508,
-0.4752589762210846,
0.09657997637987137,
0.4751178026199341,
-0.11967101693153381,
0.28568634390830994,
0.5685811042785645,
-0.117915578186512,
-0.04564083740115166,
0.779876708984375,
0.17769336700439453,
0.7355942726135254,
0.2305159717798233,
0.22088974714279175,
-0.2884331941604614,
-0.5149487853050232,
-0.5046616792678833,
0.20352120697498322,
-0.7027133703231812,
0.32088708877563477,
-0.3587823510169983,
0.12408227473497391,
-0.09473764896392822,
-0.21451839804649353,
-0.17883537709712982,
-0.3289247155189514,
0.09701789170503616,
0.1721368134021759,
-0.15958842635154724,
0.8796510696411133,
-0.06994489580392838,
-0.10359024256467819,
-0.5201295018196106,
0.7536568641662598,
1.0240298509597778,
0.12957198917865753,
0.3274315595626831,
-0.6542127132415771,
0.09591825306415558,
0.1749473512172699,
-0.20965488255023956,
-0.5089710354804993,
-0.08553683757781982,
0.1564970314502716,
0.7024575471878052,
0.3026830852031708,
-0.10758301615715027,
0.576435387134552,
-0.7056902050971985,
0.7179854512214661,
0.29652535915374756,
-0.9508262276649475,
-0.0647965744137764,
-0.5599873065948486,
0.33787834644317627,
0.3605875074863434,
0.43723243474960327,
-0.38742947578430176,
-0.3858446478843689,
-0.578033983707428,
-0.31743159890174866,
0.37077081203460693,
0.3117803931236267,
0.21031253039836884,
-0.11250603199005127,
0.2599899172782898,
0.25788047909736633,
0.19659386575222015,
-0.7943875789642334,
-0.04702853038907051,
-0.24584700167179108,
0.03676723316311836,
-0.23113638162612915,
-0.1135765090584755,
-0.007881567813456059,
-0.21150554716587067,
0.32816725969314575,
0.020653439685702324,
0.06172841787338257,
0.2393198013305664,
-0.1039358451962471,
-0.13331378996372223,
0.5571113228797913,
0.6396916508674622,
0.9472761154174805,
-0.25830623507499695,
0.45614728331565857,
0.5654499530792236,
-0.17641352117061615,
0.4684154987335205,
0.12289298325777054,
-0.06401161849498749,
-0.18487970530986786,
0.7805899977684021,
0.5553209185600281,
0.3346094489097595,
-0.8448091149330139,
0.3384658694267273,
0.13086280226707458,
-0.48063477873802185,
-0.13200855255126953,
0.23621097207069397,
0.41666659712791443,
0.20282065868377686,
0.43353456258773804,
0.05372260883450508,
0.13059763610363007,
-1.1085882186889648,
-0.008983457460999489,
0.6424771547317505,
-0.04683789983391762,
-0.44917377829551697,
0.659958004951477,
-0.07781066745519638,
-0.43301305174827576,
0.5705001354217529,
-0.2778542637825012,
-0.5375236868858337,
0.7531691193580627,
0.5487725138664246,
0.7476066946983337,
-0.13481596112251282,
-0.12187804281711578,
0.08040511608123779,
0.43158578872680664,
-0.16708344221115112,
-0.0035934702027589083,
0.14455462992191315,
-0.7045796513557434,
-0.48779672384262085,
-0.19894950091838837,
-0.48285025358200073,
0.5200632810592651,
-0.4946300983428955,
-0.07904661446809769,
-0.29156258702278137,
0.011849108152091503,
0.045411281287670135,
-0.3567652702331543,
-0.8412780165672302,
0.42229562997817993,
-0.20797601342201233,
0.5476799011230469,
-1.1987097263336182,
0.8136606812477112,
0.9600986242294312,
-0.22683961689472198,
-0.33403435349464417,
0.20047058165073395,
-0.17101143300533295,
-0.7322480082511902,
0.9453519582748413,
0.18091075122356415,
-0.2915908098220825,
-0.43540847301483154,
-0.3938044607639313,
-0.43116167187690735,
0.7660661935806274,
0.7687132954597473,
-0.6302304267883301,
-0.22537225484848022,
0.41146981716156006,
0.9048952460289001,
-0.507146418094635,
0.26645535230636597,
0.6362366080284119,
0.4412415325641632,
-0.0534750260412693,
-1.4423238039016724,
0.33762049674987793,
-0.2378285825252533,
0.024857932701706886,
-0.12282953411340714,
-0.30972570180892944,
1.10341215133667,
-0.2851799726486206,
-0.0182708241045475,
0.23409809172153473,
0.21252955496311188,
0.5486012101173401,
0.31634268164634705,
0.7756180167198181,
0.8105364441871643,
0.11077959835529327,
0.10331769287586212,
1.172319769859314,
0.31611067056655884,
0.29201558232307434,
1.238707423210144,
-0.34074652194976807,
0.7065736651420593,
0.48661839962005615,
-0.4411157965660095,
0.490620881319046,
0.18912632763385773,
-0.030055828392505646,
0.3559817671775818,
0.42577308416366577,
-0.06998389214277267,
-0.6048353314399719,
0.18220023810863495,
-0.3973191976547241,
0.220152348279953,
0.10297948867082596,
-0.27562353014945984,
-0.4686761498451233,
-0.3434211015701294,
-0.010880507528781891,
0.341248095035553,
-0.19731353223323822,
0.4121238887310028,
0.19164659082889557,
-0.7953609824180603,
0.9321973919868469,
-0.1463150829076767,
0.5581552386283875,
-0.42221468687057495,
-0.37469857931137085,
0.004304585047066212,
-0.0004513549502007663,
0.16510868072509766,
-0.8122952580451965,
0.32889658212661743,
-0.17920538783073425,
-0.2272179126739502,
0.13303585350513458,
0.4179397523403168,
-0.22458785772323608,
-0.2586122155189514,
0.36677590012550354,
0.6212842464447021,
0.44059449434280396,
-0.13353167474269867,
-0.5921286344528198,
-0.15475600957870483,
-0.042688820511102676,
-0.12800033390522003,
0.5470477938652039,
0.2602044343948364,
-0.3151359260082245,
0.7949932813644409,
0.5112659931182861,
0.19605550169944763,
-0.2644064426422119,
-0.05150182545185089,
0.8427460193634033,
-0.7115324139595032,
-0.3865152597427368,
-1.0851558446884155,
-0.009770910255610943,
0.07418613880872726,
-0.30091989040374756,
0.49578964710235596,
0.28382372856140137,
0.9414017200469971,
-0.36772993206977844,
0.7439513802528381,
0.22910459339618683,
0.49601510167121887,
-0.5501314997673035,
0.4331783950328827,
-0.49200063943862915,
0.2614193558692932,
-0.4291910231113434,
-1.2069810628890991,
0.1153298020362854,
0.5319279432296753,
-0.7135825753211975,
0.38111695647239685,
0.8969807624816895,
0.7653310298919678,
-0.5522242784500122,
-0.02897406928241253,
0.6218624711036682,
0.3592391312122345,
0.3197653889656067,
0.8751423358917236,
0.828144371509552,
-0.19831973314285278,
0.3925943672657013,
0.21116547286510468,
-0.10280215740203857,
-0.01039191149175167,
-1.039610505104065,
-1.2373881340026855,
-0.4766559898853302,
-0.13753148913383484,
0.08546420186758041,
0.4593826234340668,
0.8859877586364746,
0.529329776763916,
-0.814126193523407,
0.015308216214179993,
-0.1276879459619522,
-0.09077336639165878,
-0.11824625730514526,
-0.12230587005615234,
0.39359018206596375,
0.07991833984851837,
-0.663571834564209,
0.20288428664207458,
0.013620964251458645,
0.1319166123867035,
-0.14081057906150818,
-0.11123678833246231,
-0.08752387017011642,
0.30867961049079895,
0.46298953890800476,
0.3702183663845062,
-1.1783860921859741,
-0.602749228477478,
-0.4519585371017456,
0.12862008810043335,
-0.1734449714422226,
0.7818059921264648,
-0.9270873665809631,
0.1942475438117981,
0.3091602623462677,
0.4121047556400299,
0.44963762164115906,
0.14979057013988495,
0.5411503314971924,
-0.2553187906742096,
0.28211167454719543,
-0.03560507670044899,
0.427000492811203,
0.19897466897964478,
0.19270698726177216,
0.3995530903339386,
0.41533344984054565,
-0.4429425597190857,
-0.6346248388290405,
0.43374359607696533,
-0.4889200031757355,
-0.57919842004776,
1.023390531539917,
-0.5839223861694336,
0.18734365701675415,
-0.3805001378059387,
-0.0423007570207119,
-0.047594957053661346,
-0.1227540448307991,
0.9132371544837952,
0.8619227409362793,
-0.2806917130947113,
0.10361780226230621,
-0.5967177152633667,
0.17248070240020752,
0.7704692482948303,
-0.6659177541732788,
-0.04160236567258835,
0.42141997814178467,
0.6746239066123962,
0.07646653056144714,
0.5281834602355957,
0.08618388324975967,
0.5783789753913879,
0.16172237694263458,
-0.19125965237617493,
-0.1804952472448349,
0.0880022644996643,
-0.16468356549739838,
0.07037536799907684,
0.2854706645011902,
0.1480029672384262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08939v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08939v3 | Premise Order Matters in Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T04:50:18 | 2024-05-28T04:32:09 | Xinyun Chen, Ryan A. Chi, Xuezhi Wang, Denny Zhou | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have accomplished remarkable reasoning
performance in various domains. However, in the domain of reasoning tasks, we
discover a frailty: LLMs are surprisingly brittle to the ordering of the
premises, despite the fact that such ordering does not alter the underlying
task. In particular, we observe that LLMs achieve the best performance when the
premise order aligns with the context required in intermediate reasoning steps.
For example, in deductive reasoning tasks, presenting the premises in the same
order as the ground truth proof in the prompt (as opposed to random ordering)
drastically increases the model's accuracy. We first examine the effect of
premise ordering on deductive reasoning on a variety of LLMs, and our
evaluation shows that permuting the premise order can cause a performance drop
of over 30%. In addition, we release the benchmark R-GSM, based on GSM8K, to
examine the ordering effect for mathematical problem-solving, and we again
observe a significant drop in accuracy, relative to the original GSM8K
benchmark. | [
0.08107811212539673,
-0.7022294998168945,
1.15664803981781,
0.5084338784217834,
-0.26140910387039185,
-0.13103991746902466,
-0.12123292684555054,
-0.5591795444488525,
-0.3080163598060608,
0.6938809156417847,
-0.0005040379473939538,
-0.5693820714950562,
-0.9489011764526367,
0.03114308789372444,
0.07505053281784058,
0.6307997703552246,
0.1214052066206932,
0.25442245602607727,
-0.5206446051597595,
-0.399809330701828,
-0.1396356076002121,
-0.7728608250617981,
-0.4533771872520447,
-0.8307915925979614,
0.3184259533882141,
0.3054097294807434,
1.0864713191986084,
0.8516423106193542,
0.6332626342773438,
0.3586116135120392,
-0.562543511390686,
0.11828205734491348,
-0.3924967050552368,
0.37408551573753357,
-0.3450489938259125,
-0.91911780834198,
-0.6238301396369934,
-0.06105779856443405,
0.38648638129234314,
0.9539992809295654,
-0.229711651802063,
0.03910232335329056,
-0.2772974669933319,
0.7464849352836609,
-0.5413930416107178,
0.2359643280506134,
-0.7361195683479309,
-0.28156495094299316,
-0.049132607877254486,
-0.27827388048171997,
-0.7137082815170288,
-0.33250683546066284,
0.31303805112838745,
-0.22277042269706726,
0.09520675241947174,
0.25495800375938416,
0.6743625998497009,
0.28334763646125793,
-0.2682906985282898,
-0.08257356286048889,
-0.9328362941741943,
0.87201988697052,
-0.7843819856643677,
0.3385046124458313,
0.19885344803333282,
-0.025969764217734337,
-0.5467166900634766,
-0.5346903800964355,
-0.2632462978363037,
-0.2659013271331787,
0.134617879986763,
-0.032403651624917984,
0.10692866146564484,
0.36388707160949707,
0.6414157748222351,
0.3015440106391907,
-0.44459429383277893,
0.18288756906986237,
-0.20884260535240173,
0.18728996813297272,
0.5544442534446716,
0.36620405316352844,
0.19271400570869446,
-0.22670885920524597,
-0.3088044226169586,
-0.0028654092457145452,
-1.22496497631073,
0.08499737828969955,
0.12035331130027771,
0.3442085385322571,
0.2600752115249634,
0.7948009371757507,
-0.2865143120288849,
0.7882322669029236,
0.1980719119310379,
-0.5046820044517517,
0.11856719106435776,
-0.05735134705901146,
-0.42707327008247375,
0.27060794830322266,
0.6822518706321716,
0.2391280233860016,
0.05813556909561157,
0.11561597138643265,
-0.28481781482696533,
-0.00434328755363822,
0.04504359886050224,
-0.7086644768714905,
-0.26698610186576843,
0.32895517349243164,
-0.35121825337409973,
0.10843288153409958,
-0.0034366229083389044,
-0.029283152893185616,
-0.45742306113243103,
-0.43468955159187317,
0.3431903123855591,
-0.36113885045051575,
-0.09445447474718094,
0.4178392291069031,
0.31568291783332825,
0.08620585501194,
0.5931054949760437,
-0.9427997469902039,
0.4405175745487213,
0.9696784615516663,
0.5104038119316101,
-0.01665446162223816,
-0.37804529070854187,
-0.37988755106925964,
0.1899484395980835,
-0.57423335313797,
0.8040322661399841,
-0.5291262865066528,
-0.14654695987701416,
-0.18966305255889893,
-0.1513637751340866,
-0.17990872263908386,
-0.9603996872901917,
0.9949612021446228,
-0.6538697481155396,
-0.11132197082042694,
-0.5486956238746643,
-0.5921799540519714,
-0.11148744076490402,
-0.19410869479179382,
-0.36429649591445923,
0.8830695152282715,
-0.41214093565940857,
-0.6536955833435059,
0.4734686017036438,
-0.09221892803907394,
-0.780362069606781,
-0.08264701813459396,
-0.25839927792549133,
-0.41920205950737,
0.46547994017601013,
-0.007075388450175524,
0.6363887190818787,
-0.2691873013973236,
0.2164539098739624,
-0.5586121082305908,
-0.4821888506412506,
0.3484245836734772,
-0.15894894301891327,
0.7252758145332336,
0.27912193536758423,
-0.4932731091976166,
-0.0808800458908081,
-0.5428879857063293,
0.26466137170791626,
0.4237244427204132,
-0.31897208094596863,
-0.5724079012870789,
0.5516453385353088,
-0.4146830141544342,
0.386397123336792,
0.04265199229121208,
-0.2405998557806015,
0.1859118491411209,
-0.6101261377334595,
0.5405575633049011,
0.6078773140907288,
-0.10528206825256348,
0.6962451338768005,
-0.187514528632164,
0.07909649610519409,
0.0021567444782704115,
0.1430072784423828,
0.15740056335926056,
-0.6882111430168152,
-0.4883514642715454,
-0.07209624350070953,
0.13360106945037842,
0.7104582786560059,
-0.13401906192302704,
0.05429869890213013,
-0.37993502616882324,
-0.2314491719007492,
-0.012658432126045227,
-0.05181720852851868,
0.373840868473053,
0.21142086386680603,
0.21750375628471375,
0.20392362773418427,
-0.11468647420406342,
-0.7883132696151733,
-0.3182445764541626,
-0.42185768485069275,
0.18869648873806,
0.20791949331760406,
0.29942286014556885,
0.15342415869235992,
0.7684733271598816,
-0.7484760284423828,
0.20862117409706116,
-0.4318864345550537,
0.18307511508464813,
0.5787035226821899,
0.22990168631076813,
0.43658682703971863,
-1.1079145669937134,
-0.09327548742294312,
-0.13899728655815125,
-0.6615238785743713,
-0.1934717446565628,
0.2009711116552353,
0.01032811775803566,
0.3552914559841156,
0.32804179191589355,
-1.1545066833496094,
0.21632729470729828,
0.19489870965480804,
-0.06579724699258804,
0.7091938257217407,
-0.34388071298599243,
0.16036856174468994,
-0.912625789642334,
-0.4270089864730835,
-0.20110870897769928,
-0.07686461508274078,
-0.4732545018196106,
-0.06455174833536148,
-0.025020262226462364,
-0.0928497463464737,
-0.16344675421714783,
0.2667679488658905,
-0.5113625526428223,
-0.21358491480350494,
-0.20924729108810425,
0.1477728635072708,
0.2094600647687912,
-0.0029694847762584686,
0.04663549363613129,
0.72483229637146,
0.2915858030319214,
-0.7182842493057251,
0.020220806822180748,
0.254429429769516,
-0.535426139831543,
0.2628338038921356,
-0.7474262118339539,
0.024159451946616173,
0.03197815269231796,
0.15679971873760223,
-1.0661548376083374,
-0.11562149971723557,
0.09173008054494858,
-0.38100501894950867,
0.49290651082992554,
-0.3783249258995056,
-0.7079925537109375,
-0.2548186182975769,
0.044557005167007446,
0.2508322596549988,
0.41620925068855286,
-0.36964064836502075,
0.3995121717453003,
0.11317039281129837,
-0.23799049854278564,
-0.8784841299057007,
-0.5615878105163574,
0.042025018483400345,
-0.28603076934814453,
-0.7687620520591736,
0.43299052119255066,
0.03664829954504967,
-0.8238703012466431,
0.001990792341530323,
-0.5217120051383972,
-0.011849521659314632,
0.2054891735315323,
0.31914985179901123,
0.11485844105482101,
-0.45285895466804504,
0.1962091624736786,
0.03288988769054413,
-0.12741266191005707,
0.3467823565006256,
-0.4365020990371704,
0.14505958557128906,
-0.11778514087200165,
-0.44468653202056885,
0.04763929918408394,
0.2050684690475464,
1.0611811876296997,
-0.14839157462120056,
1.0293595790863037,
-0.18990227580070496,
-0.30582553148269653,
-0.45057764649391174,
-0.6350234746932983,
0.10260600596666336,
-0.46420472860336304,
0.24799008667469025,
-0.812519371509552,
-0.6893442869186401,
0.5449604988098145,
-0.2947172522544861,
0.018019968643784523,
0.44339442253112793,
0.5088670253753662,
-0.22020652890205383,
1.15766179561615,
0.547091007232666,
0.03032328002154827,
0.32524237036705017,
-0.036398015916347504,
0.6057748198509216,
-0.5771315097808838,
-0.16559350490570068,
-0.6082045435905457,
0.20821423828601837,
-0.3546193242073059,
-0.3991031348705292,
0.16008201241493225,
0.5069810152053833,
-0.22296881675720215,
0.19844025373458862,
-0.29677069187164307,
0.7137780785560608,
0.08538326621055603,
0.16509674489498138,
0.547676146030426,
0.11399425566196442,
-0.2193434238433838,
-0.09578651189804077,
-0.7873343229293823,
-0.8106947541236877,
0.9376882910728455,
0.15043652057647705,
1.0129728317260742,
0.2370290607213974,
0.678736686706543,
0.013392064720392227,
0.1049303412437439,
-0.7398987412452698,
0.762962281703949,
-0.3640745282173157,
-0.5241439342498779,
-0.2543092966079712,
-0.6292463541030884,
-0.8557964563369751,
0.4122900366783142,
0.037727031856775284,
-0.7306089997291565,
0.08826451748609543,
-0.03724975511431694,
-0.4302452802658081,
0.20056703686714172,
-0.8751193284988403,
0.6539641618728638,
-0.37964189052581787,
-0.4681103825569153,
-0.31563690304756165,
-0.6987610459327698,
0.4077652096748352,
0.4224418103694916,
0.03818183392286301,
-0.434251993894577,
0.30073627829551697,
0.5722050666809082,
-0.6329649090766907,
0.5524099469184875,
0.021285496652126312,
-0.32714420557022095,
0.3545234799385071,
0.25608181953430176,
0.7432588338851929,
0.14227478206157684,
-0.21487604081630707,
-0.03332296386361122,
-0.18772020936012268,
-0.4748982787132263,
-0.7713804841041565,
0.7267832159996033,
-0.8282008767127991,
-1.1747019290924072,
-0.4537213444709778,
-0.43756136298179626,
-0.3114875257015228,
-0.02501930668950081,
0.5138452053070068,
0.8626617193222046,
0.10485068708658218,
-0.02946178801357746,
1.2081162929534912,
-0.022688500583171844,
-0.0374453105032444,
0.42770928144454956,
-0.03127015754580498,
-0.37625986337661743,
0.6912412643432617,
0.5333623886108398,
0.7715567350387573,
0.6691644191741943,
0.2074185162782669,
-0.44758880138397217,
-1.1236904859542847,
-0.3263532221317291,
0.36739128828048706,
-1.2625744342803955,
0.05932917073369026,
-0.8373118042945862,
-0.13527417182922363,
-0.4733285903930664,
-0.1252002716064453,
-0.37543171644210815,
-0.5431504845619202,
-0.085847869515419,
-0.009920584037899971,
0.18996170163154602,
0.8339191675186157,
0.4124797582626343,
0.03291027992963791,
-0.723034143447876,
0.32563644647598267,
0.20348520576953888,
0.19517236948013306,
-0.28763142228126526,
-0.6581507325172424,
0.05228116735816002,
-0.257526695728302,
-0.09100835025310516,
-0.5548852682113647,
-0.155767560005188,
-0.262864351272583,
0.7169899940490723,
0.47627386450767517,
0.1904837042093277,
0.7200764417648315,
-0.7624144554138184,
0.48446574807167053,
0.09033165872097015,
-0.7868546843528748,
0.3933084011077881,
-0.5566369891166687,
0.2698351740837097,
0.41265222430229187,
0.14506153762340546,
-0.1392049491405487,
-0.36590856313705444,
-0.6508493423461914,
-0.9304437041282654,
0.6717789173126221,
0.16671878099441528,
0.029051469638943672,
0.08058583736419678,
0.5297650694847107,
-0.048629265278577805,
0.10464104264974594,
-0.5653008222579956,
-0.3932727575302124,
0.17165690660476685,
-0.0771946981549263,
-0.0837550014257431,
-0.5842494964599609,
-0.16496090590953827,
-0.26607874035835266,
0.4750004708766937,
-0.009946046397089958,
0.4106454849243164,
0.3306034505367279,
-0.2312392145395279,
-0.1972207874059677,
0.39326393604278564,
0.9811262488365173,
1.254685878753662,
-0.2755908966064453,
0.4369059205055237,
0.09915012121200562,
-0.3119734227657318,
0.35067373514175415,
0.12584498524665833,
-0.10920937359333038,
-0.17143847048282623,
0.5207335352897644,
0.6319807767868042,
0.3832046091556549,
-0.49188315868377686,
0.39252111315727234,
0.19875246286392212,
-0.18255987763404846,
0.02770853415131569,
0.07355999946594238,
0.20004902780056,
0.42975860834121704,
0.5210798382759094,
0.19742070138454437,
0.025286588817834854,
-0.5151223540306091,
0.11714258790016174,
0.2890513837337494,
0.39294567704200745,
-0.22834539413452148,
0.6261208057403564,
-0.09926576167345047,
-0.26766762137413025,
0.45253798365592957,
-0.08915430307388306,
-0.9580483436584473,
0.758763313293457,
0.8284866213798523,
0.7403398752212524,
-0.20336854457855225,
0.2424987256526947,
0.09042008221149445,
0.5081836581230164,
-0.632506787776947,
0.09554598480463028,
0.02363184653222561,
-0.752765417098999,
-0.7749421000480652,
-0.5942468047142029,
-0.7767710089683533,
0.08511783182621002,
-0.3328166604042053,
-0.02167677693068981,
-0.6460791826248169,
-0.23804402351379395,
-0.11193280667066574,
0.1517581045627594,
-0.09609264880418777,
0.36157503724098206,
0.26039963960647583,
0.5478203296661377,
-0.8041329979896545,
0.468296617269516,
0.9028856158256531,
0.1255427449941635,
-0.8524104952812195,
0.20597289502620697,
-0.1507197916507721,
-0.4332593083381653,
0.9455639719963074,
0.1549002230167389,
-0.4984206557273865,
-0.3617400825023651,
-0.5293638706207275,
-1.2756115198135376,
0.7915272116661072,
0.5711051225662231,
-0.3895131051540375,
0.36328181624412537,
0.06520341336727142,
0.5612583756446838,
-0.3085169494152069,
0.11159354448318481,
0.10581045597791672,
0.21519753336906433,
0.3885194659233093,
-0.8169244527816772,
0.19671708345413208,
0.12318424135446548,
-0.046373400837183,
0.567298412322998,
-0.8788527250289917,
0.9038654565811157,
-0.5977463722229004,
-0.342110276222229,
0.0010075587779283524,
0.6252197027206421,
0.4494691789150238,
0.47936418652534485,
0.4092104732990265,
0.7543700933456421,
0.856839120388031,
-0.3073144555091858,
0.9813066720962524,
0.10237017273902893,
0.2470114380121231,
1.1784483194351196,
-0.888285756111145,
0.7760154008865356,
0.22429870069026947,
-0.49508702754974365,
0.41758912801742554,
0.8313585519790649,
0.32883355021476746,
0.3802857995033264,
0.2963526248931885,
-0.0798918679356575,
-0.5782978534698486,
0.28235486149787903,
-0.2883239686489105,
0.09402476996183395,
0.3781071901321411,
-0.2006223201751709,
-0.11199656128883362,
-0.23159624636173248,
0.1570790410041809,
0.040077175945043564,
-0.21905353665351868,
0.4451107978820801,
0.5028246641159058,
-0.623580276966095,
0.8564797639846802,
0.14364905655384064,
0.008274706080555916,
-0.4423823654651642,
0.10229630023241043,
-0.038038477301597595,
0.44916456937789917,
-0.3665464222431183,
-0.8580008149147034,
0.2195674031972885,
-0.33451902866363525,
-0.6166132688522339,
-0.33222758769989014,
0.7181618809700012,
-0.07930199801921844,
-0.2529517710208893,
0.5514184832572937,
0.548297107219696,
0.03030865080654621,
-0.03544339910149574,
-0.6846728920936584,
0.09662126004695892,
-0.5722126364707947,
-0.6489716172218323,
0.44686558842658997,
0.7406861186027527,
-0.27188587188720703,
0.822516918182373,
0.5543845891952515,
-0.12437572330236435,
0.15669392049312592,
0.11685118079185486,
0.8023131489753723,
-0.5152157545089722,
-0.2861330807209015,
-1.011860966682434,
0.0005293210269883275,
-0.03030712902545929,
-0.20296461880207062,
0.8539727926254272,
0.41550612449645996,
0.5328596234321594,
0.18048253655433655,
0.34099477529525757,
-0.036326952278614044,
0.05456841364502907,
-0.828472375869751,
0.3882002830505371,
-0.4699544608592987,
0.509068489074707,
-0.3442904055118561,
-1.2301307916641235,
-0.4825986623764038,
0.36049339175224304,
-0.9484213590621948,
-0.05237146466970444,
0.9581705331802368,
0.5407283902168274,
0.038676876574754715,
0.075406514108181,
0.5086401104927063,
0.5256713032722473,
-0.019277626648545265,
0.5062735080718994,
1.058098554611206,
-0.3342568874359131,
0.42718228697776794,
-0.15508855879306793,
0.006385697517544031,
-0.17426104843616486,
-0.6404010653495789,
-0.9159438610076904,
-0.21340982615947723,
-0.2973417639732361,
-0.6001090407371521,
0.20041850209236145,
1.0180703401565552,
0.5271596908569336,
-0.7024845480918884,
-0.16675439476966858,
-0.057199180126190186,
0.6097482442855835,
-0.42072489857673645,
-0.21392004191875458,
0.46283966302871704,
-0.37973418831825256,
-0.5472188591957092,
0.5115987658500671,
0.5483012795448303,
-0.09417639672756195,
0.3672966957092285,
0.03530459105968475,
-0.18511730432510376,
0.2236180603504181,
0.859316349029541,
-0.03207884356379509,
-1.0471316576004028,
-0.3740083575248718,
0.14704370498657227,
-0.4352167248725891,
0.4034917950630188,
0.9390797019004822,
-0.3860255479812622,
-0.013115908950567245,
0.7394582033157349,
0.5977749228477478,
0.3100373148918152,
0.2921343743801117,
0.4240542948246002,
-0.10484529286623001,
-0.08700257539749146,
0.19547559320926666,
0.4942740499973297,
0.14312365651130676,
-0.5270798206329346,
0.3306798040866852,
0.5167596936225891,
-0.8107953071594238,
-0.8885213732719421,
0.38242974877357483,
-1.0406980514526367,
-0.45185786485671997,
1.2254818677902222,
-0.19714215397834778,
-0.41588476300239563,
-0.29845693707466125,
0.04081881791353226,
-0.23096387088298798,
-0.2903531491756439,
0.594985842704773,
0.9350849390029907,
-0.2761513292789459,
-0.11604917049407959,
-0.4849143326282501,
0.355488121509552,
0.9206223487854004,
-0.4844585955142975,
0.38371387124061584,
0.3843441605567932,
0.5400097370147705,
0.31809207797050476,
0.6484153270721436,
-0.06464087218046188,
0.09734295308589935,
-0.1593274176120758,
-0.47659775614738464,
0.26657792925834656,
-0.526505172252655,
-0.2932842969894409,
0.45538249611854553,
0.39905238151550293,
0.20216229557991028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08925v1 | MaxMin-RLHF: Towards Equitable Alignment of Large Language Models with Diverse Human Preferences | 2024-02-14T03:56:27 | 2024-02-14T03:56:27 | Souradip Chakraborty, Jiahao Qiu, Hui Yuan, Alec Koppel, Furong Huang, Dinesh Manocha, Amrit Singh Bedi, Mengdi Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) aligns language models to
human preferences by employing a singular reward model derived from preference
data. However, such an approach overlooks the rich diversity of human
preferences inherent in data collected from multiple users. In this work, we
first derive an impossibility result of alignment with single reward RLHF,
thereby highlighting its insufficiency in representing diverse human
preferences. To provide an equitable solution to the problem, we learn a
mixture of preference distributions via an expectation-maximization algorithm
and propose a MaxMin alignment objective for policy learning inspired by the
Egalitarian principle in social choice theory to better represent diverse human
preferences. We elucidate the connection of our proposed approach to
distributionally robust optimization and general utility RL, thereby
highlighting the generality and robustness of our proposed solution. We present
comprehensive experimental results on small-scale (GPT-2) and large-scale
language models (with Tulu2-7B) and show the efficacy of the proposed approach
in the presence of diversity among human preferences. Our algorithm achieves an
average improvement of more than 16% in win-rates over conventional RLHF
algorithms and improves the win-rate (accuracy) for minority groups by over 33%
without compromising the performance of majority groups, showcasing the
robustness and fairness of our approach. We remark that our findings in this
work are not only limited to language models but also extend to reinforcement
learning in general. | [
-0.34967684745788574,
-0.665188729763031,
0.24813559651374817,
0.016268344596028328,
0.044709183275699615,
0.1719161570072174,
-0.5996367931365967,
-0.2898368835449219,
0.3493694067001343,
0.20857331156730652,
-0.5265755653381348,
-0.35888978838920593,
-0.6320248246192932,
-0.20228604972362518,
0.07941314578056335,
1.0377966165542603,
-0.01773274689912796,
-0.1692596673965454,
0.017924943938851357,
-0.6245108842849731,
-0.21999330818653107,
-0.6082510948181152,
-0.4638417959213257,
-0.5434134602546692,
0.7694741487503052,
0.5669811964035034,
1.0479671955108643,
1.106549620628357,
0.20871183276176453,
0.20991939306259155,
0.09027757495641708,
0.18297381699085236,
-0.8277563452720642,
0.23731981217861176,
-0.16310790181159973,
-0.30041876435279846,
-0.13651272654533386,
-0.16407154500484467,
0.644867479801178,
0.5409122109413147,
-0.7808544039726257,
0.025031760334968567,
0.10316205024719238,
0.7001439929008484,
-0.686335563659668,
-0.04542672261595726,
-0.3517366945743561,
0.39115628600120544,
-0.0042253099381923676,
0.013301555067300797,
-0.27783316373825073,
-0.5259077548980713,
0.2217862457036972,
-0.744156002998352,
-0.13704246282577515,
0.310195654630661,
1.0971393585205078,
0.24872718751430511,
-0.5796452760696411,
-0.02055123634636402,
-0.5347959995269775,
1.1079213619232178,
-0.43588191270828247,
0.42512309551239014,
0.25783246755599976,
0.4398694932460785,
-0.10158378630876541,
-0.01900707185268402,
-0.47244149446487427,
-0.13794095814228058,
0.1325627714395523,
0.23289786279201508,
0.09565524011850357,
0.23178385198116302,
0.18789197504520416,
0.09674795717000961,
-0.7189511060714722,
0.387580007314682,
0.006723153870552778,
-0.46351179480552673,
0.6717538833618164,
0.22616979479789734,
0.18603548407554626,
0.11483146250247955,
-0.47556549310684204,
-0.41406166553497314,
-0.5693609714508057,
0.21401596069335938,
0.835119903087616,
0.3999903202056885,
-0.27637678384780884,
0.5237709879875183,
-0.04540824145078659,
0.6998581290245056,
-0.02787768468260765,
-0.2727307081222534,
0.2632763385772705,
-0.13998639583587646,
-0.18066315352916718,
-0.15445856750011444,
0.7932257652282715,
0.3515203893184662,
0.28093066811561584,
0.09274102002382278,
-0.3329334855079651,
0.042933475226163864,
-0.07763034850358963,
-0.408221960067749,
0.020105447620153427,
0.05779607221484184,
-0.402357816696167,
-0.4553622603416443,
0.03468828275799751,
-0.8798771500587463,
-0.44136086106300354,
-0.39244481921195984,
0.21852493286132812,
0.028845222666859627,
-0.6170911192893982,
0.0331096276640892,
0.08846510201692581,
0.5022763609886169,
0.2618371248245239,
-1.299028992652893,
0.3134365975856781,
0.7452977299690247,
0.4442198872566223,
-0.46646180748939514,
-0.6434949040412903,
-0.5592716932296753,
0.1464722901582718,
-0.13336916267871857,
0.5968039035797119,
-0.5484905242919922,
-0.20963846147060394,
0.2861950993537903,
-0.21782825887203217,
-0.07009351998567581,
-0.610405445098877,
0.7105545401573181,
-0.39660629630088806,
0.2764609456062317,
-0.41233834624290466,
-0.509442150592804,
-0.048632409423589706,
0.17093732953071594,
-0.7733055353164673,
0.8307924866676331,
0.23615886270999908,
-0.6555835008621216,
0.6744592189788818,
-0.6080794334411621,
-0.4801667332649231,
-0.25200483202934265,
-0.21538648009300232,
-0.5205954313278198,
-0.11378327012062073,
0.15997357666492462,
0.050388846546411514,
-0.12131679058074951,
0.6579787135124207,
-0.7578655481338501,
-0.18251316249370575,
0.3571193218231201,
-0.5363278388977051,
0.7884318232536316,
0.46612346172332764,
-0.34097862243652344,
0.6087387204170227,
-0.33584660291671753,
-0.16884762048721313,
0.2312593311071396,
-0.4740923047065735,
-0.014165056869387627,
-0.08410283178091049,
0.3780262768268585,
0.2087598741054535,
0.19613958895206451,
-0.31841418147087097,
0.07910310477018356,
-0.21405386924743652,
0.17506830394268036,
1.458764672279358,
-0.5487528443336487,
0.6438251733779907,
-0.5999059081077576,
0.6916026473045349,
-0.08876779675483704,
0.45229771733283997,
0.37099167704582214,
-0.21706253290176392,
-0.40104591846466064,
-0.3695704936981201,
0.3742905557155609,
0.5260235667228699,
-0.08571130037307739,
0.5658427476882935,
-0.2025521993637085,
0.24145182967185974,
-0.5569007992744446,
0.31462541222572327,
0.3702457547187805,
0.40345415472984314,
0.0323786735534668,
-0.29951223731040955,
-0.6122124195098877,
-1.0338482856750488,
-0.3226795494556427,
-0.2628403306007385,
0.41565605998039246,
0.5578005909919739,
0.09753963351249695,
-0.2434185892343521,
0.7324357032775879,
-0.289204478263855,
0.006076376419514418,
-0.3698212802410126,
-0.3258800208568573,
0.24039804935455322,
0.31582361459732056,
0.14968734979629517,
-0.8760663270950317,
-0.5626921653747559,
0.20439809560775757,
-0.5568788051605225,
-0.11333741992712021,
0.1409161537885666,
-0.5583999156951904,
0.3037325441837311,
-0.13245585560798645,
-0.24161826074123383,
0.005436267238110304,
0.7162889242172241,
-0.29681938886642456,
0.4080886244773865,
-0.26024356484413147,
0.02982083149254322,
-0.9285733103752136,
-0.06760172545909882,
0.20871305465698242,
-0.6133110523223877,
-0.40702030062675476,
0.18645870685577393,
0.16567115485668182,
0.12459675222635269,
-0.2883942127227783,
0.6200493574142456,
-0.0841427817940712,
-0.2079516500234604,
-0.2043217271566391,
0.25686952471733093,
-0.2922484278678894,
0.769959032535553,
-0.06113376095890999,
0.4734610915184021,
0.3836725354194641,
-0.5903424620628357,
0.4819370210170746,
0.07852654159069061,
0.09149695932865143,
0.7509037256240845,
-0.4547925293445587,
-0.08622855693101883,
-0.28788095712661743,
0.1292029619216919,
-0.7636210322380066,
-0.6276811361312866,
0.35459625720977783,
-0.4145076274871826,
0.3633931577205658,
0.1562371850013733,
-0.1805015206336975,
-0.03249165043234825,
-0.3635423183441162,
0.39761897921562195,
0.5175023674964905,
-0.735342800617218,
0.5479603409767151,
0.8722440004348755,
-0.01870729960501194,
-1.1160975694656372,
-0.40848803520202637,
-0.2257581651210785,
-0.4329463243484497,
-0.5521330237388611,
0.10144313424825668,
-0.0548061728477478,
-0.17057089507579803,
0.03735046461224556,
-0.09260835498571396,
0.1081073060631752,
0.21716085076332092,
0.04142533242702484,
0.5184534788131714,
0.10829109698534012,
0.09898778796195984,
0.10820971429347992,
-0.18710888922214508,
-0.46975114941596985,
-0.5170466303825378,
0.5275852680206299,
-0.17396672070026398,
-0.5087185502052307,
-0.16331356763839722,
0.36698347330093384,
0.3001559376716614,
-0.06755547225475311,
0.5463874936103821,
0.6128207445144653,
-0.23089757561683655,
-0.14291618764400482,
-0.4761086106300354,
0.011650612577795982,
-0.4011894166469574,
0.6089792251586914,
-0.1261502355337143,
-1.2458884716033936,
0.48703187704086304,
0.17307926714420319,
0.5106114745140076,
0.42393365502357483,
0.621487557888031,
0.04329334571957588,
1.2313114404678345,
0.8784432411193848,
-0.40915706753730774,
0.6669538021087646,
0.23900945484638214,
-0.06306183338165283,
-0.6331433653831482,
-0.07373063266277313,
-0.4036661684513092,
-0.45946204662323,
-0.5591063499450684,
0.05348607152700424,
0.2034182846546173,
-0.023457342758774757,
-0.6498058438301086,
0.14056292176246643,
-0.3952135145664215,
0.44009026885032654,
0.5483142137527466,
0.12653543055057526,
0.1274416148662567,
0.2637263536453247,
-0.3787316679954529,
-0.10952922701835632,
-0.8496981263160706,
-0.19482140243053436,
1.3106226921081543,
0.4300057590007782,
0.9181653261184692,
0.4672749936580658,
0.982644259929657,
0.4380182921886444,
0.4693070352077484,
-0.7248942255973816,
0.09294208884239197,
0.14240474998950958,
-0.4474565088748932,
-0.7978586554527283,
-0.7451669573783875,
-1.117666244506836,
0.6394707560539246,
-0.22661232948303223,
-0.5951889753341675,
0.13279297947883606,
0.3130249083042145,
-0.21405450999736786,
0.12291019409894943,
-0.600842297077179,
0.9521794319152832,
-0.42135515809059143,
-0.42500337958335876,
-0.30035459995269775,
-0.7356972098350525,
0.562322199344635,
0.15183395147323608,
0.5276449918746948,
-0.1688062846660614,
-0.10173813998699188,
0.7321858406066895,
-0.26002228260040283,
0.5222371220588684,
-0.2351333498954773,
-0.23161038756370544,
-0.2307431548833847,
-0.22493809461593628,
0.6843788027763367,
-0.08247458189725876,
0.006356301251798868,
-0.37937742471694946,
-0.20326538383960724,
-0.8164442777633667,
-0.48311352729797363,
0.6380279660224915,
-1.1319254636764526,
-0.47284772992134094,
-0.45691728591918945,
-0.6415935158729553,
-0.11528508365154266,
0.021790826693177223,
0.025669250637292862,
0.27678489685058594,
-0.21832004189491272,
-0.07341253012418747,
0.9058417081832886,
-0.37640923261642456,
0.21883830428123474,
0.1614370048046112,
-0.6169047355651855,
-0.8739867806434631,
1.0694342851638794,
-0.2628108263015747,
0.5576254725456238,
0.4490906596183777,
0.4067768156528473,
-0.7045016884803772,
-0.153425931930542,
-0.5681679248809814,
0.28011777997016907,
-0.8093229532241821,
0.08999622613191605,
-0.5568604469299316,
0.17476384341716766,
-0.41327035427093506,
-0.14784584939479828,
-0.12800095975399017,
-0.3140396177768707,
0.021557817235589027,
-0.18551228940486908,
-0.09686872363090515,
0.44534239172935486,
-0.4149700701236725,
0.0700594112277031,
-0.5244260430335999,
0.26219984889030457,
0.47904229164123535,
0.35211870074272156,
-0.027345793321728706,
-0.6126090884208679,
-0.25313305854797363,
0.002449873136356473,
-0.2456245869398117,
-0.7833172678947449,
0.2591377794742584,
0.2484457641839981,
1.001628041267395,
0.4131282866001129,
0.029797082766890526,
0.5022940635681152,
-0.05040936544537544,
0.4519781470298767,
0.6285184025764465,
-0.7596815824508667,
0.09589489549398422,
-0.2360488325357437,
0.0995907336473465,
0.6027783751487732,
0.14538869261741638,
-0.8557630181312561,
-0.27529171109199524,
-0.5144456624984741,
-0.8132749199867249,
0.546542763710022,
-0.23749221861362457,
0.0886957049369812,
0.2885668873786926,
-0.12610499560832977,
0.30061009526252747,
0.11967938393354416,
-0.8801358342170715,
-0.4322901666164398,
-0.24076148867607117,
-0.5608736872673035,
0.04216606169939041,
-0.049266424030065536,
-0.5279039740562439,
-0.012002612464129925,
0.7175565958023071,
-0.2728642225265503,
0.12331148982048035,
-0.0822523757815361,
-0.3438631594181061,
-0.3854030668735504,
0.5055862069129944,
0.8205777406692505,
0.7449238300323486,
-0.00310610793530941,
0.045199088752269745,
0.039788682013750076,
-0.24689385294914246,
0.5091114044189453,
0.09219487756490707,
-0.2029741108417511,
-0.3972444534301758,
-0.021427525207400322,
0.9938836693763733,
0.10351767390966415,
-0.704230546951294,
0.6010939478874207,
-0.21889621019363403,
-0.45769989490509033,
-0.019466880708932877,
0.08813527226448059,
-0.014030109159648418,
0.25570303201675415,
0.2643188238143921,
-0.03953137621283531,
-0.12057442963123322,
-0.47709694504737854,
0.31499457359313965,
0.5646951198577881,
-0.583353579044342,
-0.04710932821035385,
0.5576971173286438,
-0.021038956940174103,
-0.31436094641685486,
0.2622993290424347,
-0.21258625388145447,
-0.6307699680328369,
0.5249671339988708,
0.5911046862602234,
0.8408780694007874,
-0.16357280313968658,
0.4619344472885132,
0.3098093569278717,
0.1817893087863922,
-0.3050691485404968,
0.192661851644516,
-0.14417147636413574,
-0.8957246541976929,
-0.4404345452785492,
-0.7039085030555725,
-0.5348934531211853,
-0.3550749719142914,
-0.5826817750930786,
-0.03268037736415863,
-0.5022080540657043,
-0.15737003087997437,
-0.45684489607810974,
-0.14026862382888794,
-0.6198657751083374,
-0.20840704441070557,
0.06142733246088028,
0.18877828121185303,
-0.8306373357772827,
0.7502120137214661,
0.5634661912918091,
-0.2654092013835907,
-1.0748670101165771,
-0.1403569132089615,
0.18400952219963074,
-0.8782353401184082,
0.39613163471221924,
-0.12378453463315964,
0.11170461773872375,
-0.11486225575208664,
-0.5613073110580444,
-0.8355953097343445,
0.9491044878959656,
0.5074382424354553,
-0.5503289699554443,
0.15226656198501587,
-0.0761076882481575,
0.05485919490456581,
-0.36616677045822144,
0.36117371916770935,
0.42788371443748474,
0.6203956604003906,
0.05994584411382675,
-0.9716611504554749,
0.021429840475320816,
-0.048639509826898575,
-0.018076494336128235,
0.4548875391483307,
-0.7561387419700623,
0.5420482754707336,
-0.26144644618034363,
-0.3117925822734833,
-0.21928824484348297,
0.7863613367080688,
0.6899137496948242,
0.04703827574849129,
0.696235179901123,
0.8319273591041565,
1.0716639757156372,
0.11743080615997314,
0.9206405282020569,
-0.07153954356908798,
0.7711716890335083,
0.9215164184570312,
-0.42502811551094055,
0.43019819259643555,
0.44979289174079895,
-0.5546782612800598,
0.12869364023208618,
0.7218765616416931,
0.3030463457107544,
0.5798360705375671,
0.35783153772354126,
-0.23205789923667908,
-0.3266070783138275,
-0.16996099054813385,
-0.34242016077041626,
-0.13557375967502594,
-0.027682805433869362,
-0.0898764580488205,
-0.253587543964386,
-0.04163332283496857,
-0.16599613428115845,
0.2337600141763687,
-0.08917215466499329,
0.7680625915527344,
0.00773216038942337,
-0.7266350984573364,
0.580474317073822,
-0.004644694272428751,
1.064661979675293,
-0.5004681944847107,
0.08129943907260895,
-0.2801676392555237,
0.05922848358750343,
-0.19704768061637878,
-0.6759129166603088,
-0.04407810419797897,
-0.29032760858535767,
-0.07656755298376083,
-0.07958293706178665,
0.46721217036247253,
-0.6287519931793213,
-0.027638670057058334,
0.33477866649627686,
0.4048599898815155,
-0.10585585981607437,
0.5461392402648926,
-0.8098316788673401,
0.017580736428499222,
0.2839418351650238,
-0.12895892560482025,
0.7307508587837219,
0.17659510672092438,
0.14411771297454834,
0.5877971053123474,
0.6695390939712524,
0.19120091199874878,
0.17575395107269287,
0.15097926557064056,
0.4277579188346863,
-0.6296642422676086,
-0.7172303199768066,
-0.9330602288246155,
0.25458723306655884,
-0.1763443797826767,
-0.33655938506126404,
0.3220843970775604,
0.38835999369621277,
0.9651586413383484,
0.22237136960029602,
1.023315668106079,
0.013432182371616364,
0.2703301012516022,
-0.3014785945415497,
0.3166625499725342,
-0.5421700477600098,
0.10292690992355347,
-0.16430313885211945,
-1.046051263809204,
-0.313793420791626,
0.5631914734840393,
0.08986649662256241,
-0.03846873342990875,
0.6208367943763733,
0.8729814887046814,
-0.11050232499837875,
-0.011301863938570023,
0.545187771320343,
-0.3651798665523529,
0.42934733629226685,
0.8445007801055908,
0.8972361087799072,
0.06477262824773788,
0.5331253409385681,
-0.08696439862251282,
-0.3917020559310913,
-0.22885696589946747,
-0.6911322474479675,
-0.4167953431606293,
-0.32515454292297363,
-0.0369468629360199,
-0.4663684368133545,
0.15180157124996185,
1.6146483421325684,
0.5790278911590576,
-0.75838303565979,
-0.542410135269165,
-0.0036077918484807014,
0.602713406085968,
-0.4064500629901886,
-0.22647607326507568,
0.3550349473953247,
-0.352995902299881,
-0.5279277563095093,
-0.15357597172260284,
0.33685147762298584,
-0.19565927982330322,
-0.2742157578468323,
-0.8663085103034973,
-0.09361128509044647,
-0.07312089949846268,
0.30561739206314087,
0.6795265078544617,
-0.7293757796287537,
-0.3007681667804718,
-0.012810470536351204,
-0.39846134185791016,
0.15676961839199066,
0.7799567580223083,
-0.16272518038749695,
0.3037690222263336,
0.4763299524784088,
1.1003375053405762,
0.24044370651245117,
0.025957243517041206,
0.710158109664917,
-0.2620256245136261,
-0.009229112416505814,
0.11997032165527344,
0.4488360583782196,
0.28268083930015564,
-0.2256537824869156,
0.2803099453449249,
0.2664296329021454,
-0.8407068252563477,
-0.780365526676178,
0.6817371249198914,
-0.8882003426551819,
0.03874268755316734,
1.2542121410369873,
-0.13367511332035065,
-0.30052822828292847,
-0.12181860208511353,
-0.1593114137649536,
0.4340967833995819,
-0.8721508383750916,
0.6416864395141602,
0.7302960157394409,
-0.02702816016972065,
-0.37159067392349243,
-0.46102091670036316,
0.29646018147468567,
0.7898330688476562,
-0.7408942580223083,
0.1697886437177658,
0.6524603366851807,
0.17544390261173248,
-0.3386198878288269,
0.687155544757843,
-0.13858382403850555,
0.38879790902137756,
-0.439585417509079,
0.04020142927765846,
0.05925139784812927,
-0.12769374251365662,
-0.7268737554550171,
0.23960672318935394,
0.44503217935562134,
0.08027515560388565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00774v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00774v2 | Regional inflation analysis using social network data | 2024-02-14T02:33:17 | 2024-03-14T11:34:28 | Vasilii Chsherbakov, Ilia Karpov | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.SI | Inflation is one of the most important macroeconomic indicators that have a
great impact on the population of any country and region. Inflation is
influenced by range of factors, one of which is inflation expectations. Many
central banks take this factor into consideration while implementing monetary
policy within the inflation targeting regime. Nowadays, a lot of people are
active users of the Internet, especially social networks. There is a hypothesis
that people search, read, and discuss mainly only those issues that are of
particular interest to them. It is logical to assume that the dynamics of
prices may also be in the focus of user discussions. So, such discussions could
be regarded as an alternative source of more rapid information about inflation
expectations. This study is based on unstructured data from Vkontakte social
network to analyze upward and downward inflationary trends (on the example of
the Omsk region). The sample of more than 8.5 million posts was collected
between January 2010 and May 2022. The authors used BERT neural networks to
solve the problem. These models demonstrated better results than the benchmarks
(e.g., logistic regression, decision tree classifier, etc.). It makes possible
to define pro-inflationary and disinflationary types of keywords in different
contexts and get their visualization with SHAP method. This analysis provides
additional operational information about inflationary processes at the regional
level The proposed approach can be scaled for other regions. At the same time
the limitation of the work is the time and power costs for the initial training
of similar models for all regions of Russia. | [
-0.615432620048523,
-0.8646761775016785,
0.24770772457122803,
0.40608182549476624,
-0.5047888159751892,
-0.3440658152103424,
-0.2455262541770935,
-0.30873602628707886,
0.591384768486023,
0.351331502199173,
-0.38273945450782776,
-0.40523239970207214,
-0.4627988934516907,
-0.3421083986759186,
-0.28117549419403076,
0.7443215250968933,
0.18437986075878143,
0.037234529852867126,
0.07695462554693222,
0.4631882309913635,
-0.034344468265771866,
-0.519690752029419,
-0.8322173357009888,
-0.2888602316379547,
0.46820947527885437,
0.38829541206359863,
0.22920596599578857,
0.5528210997581482,
0.3619112968444824,
0.43828409910202026,
-0.17306439578533173,
-0.11421583592891693,
-0.5483458638191223,
-0.062224891036748886,
0.22157607972621918,
-0.12156170606613159,
-0.12397927790880203,
-0.39868441224098206,
0.8038586378097534,
0.4542459547519684,
-0.00859765149652958,
0.3077284097671509,
0.19235455989837646,
0.8570694327354431,
-0.44290891289711,
0.05727876350283623,
-0.6061939001083374,
-0.16583247482776642,
-0.3513909578323364,
-0.36409279704093933,
0.22841845452785492,
-0.5879727005958557,
0.4457263648509979,
0.025019239634275436,
0.4005909562110901,
-0.2805815041065216,
0.9290181994438171,
-0.36129146814346313,
-0.40094685554504395,
-0.3607008159160614,
-0.7946127653121948,
0.6076059341430664,
-0.6455673575401306,
0.1947428435087204,
0.26125368475914,
0.3601095378398895,
-0.20672792196273804,
-0.6081311702728271,
-0.4782285988330841,
0.2645227909088135,
-0.1014009341597557,
0.13646931946277618,
-0.27701982855796814,
-0.29235538840293884,
-0.1979418843984604,
0.32047024369239807,
-0.11614049226045609,
-0.1231519877910614,
-0.4863734841346741,
-0.08538351953029633,
0.32461869716644287,
-0.09830458462238312,
-0.026455337181687355,
-0.6558569669723511,
-0.6479072570800781,
-0.18087708950042725,
-0.19042883813381195,
0.20185555517673492,
0.6534975171089172,
0.5893574357032776,
-0.25432679057121277,
0.45875516533851624,
-0.6020262837409973,
0.47035953402519226,
0.04218074679374695,
0.05357213318347931,
0.32588258385658264,
-0.3847542107105255,
0.07254620641469955,
0.0563880130648613,
0.39713147282600403,
0.3532782793045044,
0.019540680572390556,
0.3035084903240204,
-0.2114151120185852,
-0.3052147626876831,
0.1443382054567337,
-0.5424486398696899,
-0.005740826949477196,
0.12547098100185394,
-0.5820705890655518,
-0.40617987513542175,
0.21098248660564423,
-1.3769733905792236,
-0.42444291710853577,
-0.40755659341812134,
0.3698224723339081,
-0.04732675850391388,
-0.4015835225582123,
0.09979505836963654,
-0.04545355960726738,
-0.25310367345809937,
0.1646009385585785,
-0.7088529467582703,
0.2623049020767212,
0.7761094570159912,
0.9825872182846069,
0.2674735188484192,
-0.12123861163854599,
0.17911787331104279,
-0.31430885195732117,
-0.023690642789006233,
1.3557863235473633,
-0.15964573621749878,
-0.1286400407552719,
0.4970070719718933,
-0.0012222009245306253,
0.07533619552850723,
-0.21403327584266663,
0.6241943836212158,
-0.5794745683670044,
0.04949503019452095,
-0.50016850233078,
-0.3860401213169098,
-0.16888956725597382,
0.41201460361480713,
-0.5094640851020813,
1.0158562660217285,
0.1385691612958908,
-0.6772467494010925,
0.6588563919067383,
-0.6351544260978699,
-0.16780950129032135,
-0.00722128339111805,
0.17924921214580536,
-0.4228423833847046,
0.18121492862701416,
0.5427935123443604,
0.6204718947410583,
-0.2706311047077179,
0.24575136601924896,
-0.2565552592277527,
-0.06758394837379456,
0.240280881524086,
-0.28134068846702576,
0.5780113935470581,
0.2375158816576004,
-0.3294028043746948,
0.02599465101957321,
-0.6475630402565002,
-0.09233509749174118,
-0.10799809545278549,
-0.3127322494983673,
-0.5206823945045471,
0.08334217220544815,
0.2655162513256073,
0.21145708858966827,
0.33626168966293335,
-0.5711571574211121,
0.3531469702720642,
-0.323801726102829,
0.40205368399620056,
0.9667910933494568,
0.5868781805038452,
0.19517138600349426,
-0.3416839838027954,
0.1909509152173996,
0.1824478656053543,
0.5745221972465515,
0.3272859454154968,
-0.30356961488723755,
-0.5839933753013611,
-0.1143578588962555,
0.34342145919799805,
0.0471135750412941,
-0.6177892684936523,
0.19683367013931274,
-0.12424838542938232,
-0.6751023530960083,
-0.05480136722326279,
-0.2279553860425949,
-0.1205911710858345,
0.6440221667289734,
-0.1262914091348648,
0.33074966073036194,
-0.7025049328804016,
-0.6883522868156433,
0.004710972774773836,
-0.19216971099376678,
0.03858864679932594,
0.3149664103984833,
0.4548102915287018,
0.09280730783939362,
0.645317018032074,
-0.5798608660697937,
-0.3334941864013672,
-0.08039097487926483,
0.338243693113327,
0.5607779622077942,
0.4135666787624359,
0.4590897858142853,
-1.0618643760681152,
-0.588010311126709,
0.02256854437291622,
0.08409863710403442,
-0.22255223989486694,
-0.1432555913925171,
-0.35435062646865845,
0.38167688250541687,
0.1030425876379013,
-0.07926380634307861,
0.3774116337299347,
0.5911726355552673,
-0.4947276711463928,
0.3882529139518738,
-0.5103853344917297,
0.4015345573425293,
-1.1305932998657227,
0.10771232843399048,
0.43147221207618713,
0.10629290342330933,
-0.730739176273346,
-0.1828847974538803,
-0.1199440062046051,
-0.2146870195865631,
-0.4296014606952667,
0.5125129818916321,
-0.11117612570524216,
-0.19475285708904266,
-0.10715831071138382,
0.1694071888923645,
-0.26845329999923706,
0.46341919898986816,
0.17620110511779785,
0.542861819267273,
0.42027929425239563,
-0.41160500049591064,
0.38963794708251953,
-0.06725165992975235,
-0.7067160606384277,
0.16933639347553253,
-0.6246699094772339,
-0.14719600975513458,
-0.0884585976600647,
-0.046624667942523956,
-1.1242281198501587,
-0.0978783592581749,
0.09962998330593109,
-0.4273429214954376,
-0.038949158042669296,
-0.11313505470752716,
-0.5619511604309082,
-0.32642078399658203,
-0.23296889662742615,
-0.04186883941292763,
0.47104790806770325,
-0.3813919425010681,
0.40229180455207825,
0.45806047320365906,
-0.14117036759853363,
-0.5397709608078003,
-0.18322713673114777,
-0.2804665267467499,
-0.45030927658081055,
-0.7354239225387573,
0.06475026160478592,
0.27989116311073303,
-0.29916298389434814,
0.1835835874080658,
0.10373308509588242,
-0.2246599793434143,
-0.21903757750988007,
-0.09919627755880356,
0.1358889490365982,
-0.07137291878461838,
0.3119408190250397,
-0.21795745193958282,
-0.24897298216819763,
-0.21846294403076172,
-0.4063182771205902,
0.8777629733085632,
-0.3528347611427307,
0.1666567474603653,
-0.1863042265176773,
0.10486631840467453,
0.3237442672252655,
0.07278244942426682,
0.878995954990387,
0.5875076651573181,
-0.6064199209213257,
-0.010769671760499477,
-0.8211132884025574,
-0.1184270903468132,
-0.43380433320999146,
0.2448544204235077,
-0.02819102816283703,
-0.5537790656089783,
0.9413114190101624,
-0.2909780740737915,
-0.1866447776556015,
0.4736362397670746,
0.7263539433479309,
-0.08409551531076431,
0.7022016048431396,
0.6192187666893005,
-0.07166117429733276,
0.6454135775566101,
-0.2586204707622528,
0.013720165938138962,
-0.4470455050468445,
-0.351123183965683,
-0.8902840614318848,
-0.6159433722496033,
-0.578950822353363,
-0.1666986495256424,
0.7501747608184814,
0.10724598914384842,
-0.052732281386852264,
0.0737328827381134,
-0.3657216727733612,
0.43411803245544434,
0.46098828315734863,
0.21348530054092407,
-0.19772633910179138,
0.3748510777950287,
0.08307937532663345,
-0.05972977355122566,
-0.5706822872161865,
-0.14806310832500458,
0.8894186019897461,
0.2236160784959793,
0.28801771998405457,
0.11660663783550262,
0.46071845293045044,
0.656190812587738,
0.07035616040229797,
-0.419479101896286,
0.20656435191631317,
-0.3398040533065796,
-0.7532839775085449,
-0.49284854531288147,
-0.5204318165779114,
-0.907650887966156,
0.01891391910612583,
-0.6596168279647827,
-1.0195178985595703,
0.6225963234901428,
0.182824969291687,
-0.27943775057792664,
0.4739636480808258,
-0.4677548408508301,
0.7820389270782471,
-0.05581365525722504,
-0.21913278102874756,
-0.13104388117790222,
-0.3051093816757202,
0.2082863748073578,
-0.11584053933620453,
0.11556588858366013,
-0.26024457812309265,
0.06613646447658539,
0.5764623880386353,
-0.3926364779472351,
0.8176752328872681,
-0.42151108384132385,
0.37274622917175293,
0.37231385707855225,
-0.38997796177864075,
0.4694046676158905,
-0.16317430138587952,
-0.18577633798122406,
0.3747408092021942,
0.13303276896476746,
-0.7659875750541687,
-0.5645356178283691,
0.9380596876144409,
-1.1697441339492798,
-0.11099136620759964,
-0.3451739251613617,
-0.23856648802757263,
-0.06714142858982086,
0.19701643288135529,
0.31356358528137207,
0.8139029741287231,
-0.007930445484817028,
0.23482532799243927,
0.32983919978141785,
0.009262220934033394,
0.283248633146286,
0.3228328824043274,
-0.3826564848423004,
-0.5255640745162964,
0.8811892867088318,
0.4567588269710541,
0.08316601067781448,
0.34652256965637207,
1.093637228012085,
-0.48982304334640503,
-0.39253270626068115,
-0.15319274365901947,
0.3873419165611267,
-0.7581009268760681,
-0.06531760841608047,
-0.2697453796863556,
0.18897542357444763,
-0.8174237012863159,
-0.24651119112968445,
-0.17602194845676422,
-0.3112729489803314,
-0.14993250370025635,
0.028682712465524673,
0.3220677375793457,
0.6943802833557129,
-0.49675145745277405,
0.5278131365776062,
-0.585220217704773,
0.017627958208322525,
0.1395246535539627,
0.3247852623462677,
0.13291265070438385,
-0.1552703082561493,
-0.38877516984939575,
-0.013598699122667313,
-0.03570723906159401,
-0.8403382301330566,
0.42172732949256897,
-0.05963604152202606,
0.32983601093292236,
0.7991167306900024,
0.2830153703689575,
1.0308282375335693,
-0.02578834258019924,
0.6415854692459106,
0.0034969511907547712,
-0.8251703977584839,
0.21098409593105316,
-0.46826526522636414,
0.23818399012088776,
0.46688833832740784,
0.491900771856308,
-1.1214892864227295,
0.10927091538906097,
-0.7596031427383423,
-0.9828454852104187,
0.6592907309532166,
0.12633727490901947,
0.15782642364501953,
-0.04086785390973091,
0.6828063130378723,
0.05283842980861664,
0.2630423307418823,
-0.4829826056957245,
-0.138519749045372,
-0.18024753034114838,
0.021938636898994446,
-0.046911321580410004,
-0.6392295360565186,
0.13353656232357025,
-0.16844989359378815,
0.823726236820221,
0.13426826894283295,
0.48281484842300415,
0.40681102871894836,
0.5843369364738464,
-0.3769976496696472,
-0.015504051931202412,
1.068284511566162,
0.8052670359611511,
-0.2933284640312195,
0.06308680772781372,
-0.13766399025917053,
-0.431860089302063,
-0.26585283875465393,
-0.10303479433059692,
-0.24605023860931396,
-0.036877136677503586,
0.21848388016223907,
0.566859781742096,
0.0766901820898056,
-0.4044708013534546,
0.3951130509376526,
-0.2210734486579895,
-0.2284681648015976,
-0.96063232421875,
-0.5173729062080383,
0.07522695511579514,
0.49589940905570984,
0.3741784393787384,
0.14918044209480286,
-0.0033291527070105076,
-0.5307665467262268,
0.05912782624363899,
0.19684460759162903,
-0.5838225483894348,
-0.41342419385910034,
0.12320923060178757,
0.30257725715637207,
-0.28458717465400696,
0.5516116619110107,
0.12052558362483978,
-0.7663405537605286,
0.7669432163238525,
0.49614131450653076,
0.7299246191978455,
-0.10007458180189133,
0.39074093103408813,
0.33903422951698303,
0.43647700548171997,
0.013683068566024303,
0.5543031692504883,
0.1131705641746521,
-0.7273316383361816,
-0.28639712929725647,
-0.5669569373130798,
0.11492600291967392,
0.49781545996665955,
-0.5747158527374268,
0.5452615022659302,
-0.32064536213874817,
-0.31686532497406006,
-0.09906656295061111,
0.3780714273452759,
-0.5785813927650452,
0.11298330873250961,
0.16379530727863312,
0.7376835942268372,
-1.1063604354858398,
0.47334665060043335,
0.7671900987625122,
0.06490892171859741,
-0.4920476973056793,
0.026078516617417336,
0.024863628670573235,
-0.8202393651008606,
0.6493115425109863,
-0.14831657707691193,
0.2143058031797409,
-0.26207417249679565,
-0.3028446137905121,
-1.0319865942001343,
0.6860308647155762,
-0.21952323615550995,
-0.17712512612342834,
0.16598351299762726,
0.24056850373744965,
0.6800751686096191,
-0.3600064516067505,
0.14477208256721497,
0.32771459221839905,
0.6328641772270203,
0.16062600910663605,
-0.41582176089286804,
-0.3017144203186035,
-0.30658799409866333,
0.07165679335594177,
0.6836817860603333,
-0.7377902269363403,
1.1604738235473633,
0.48637571930885315,
-0.23370575904846191,
-0.2340136170387268,
0.54779052734375,
-0.37598559260368347,
0.4436216652393341,
0.6554685235023499,
0.2566101551055908,
0.35112354159355164,
-0.010622906498610973,
0.8138707876205444,
-0.47832679748535156,
0.7411383986473083,
0.26821988821029663,
0.13091836869716644,
1.015325665473938,
0.5060300230979919,
-0.24815471470355988,
0.19346164166927338,
0.8131746649742126,
0.08296076953411102,
0.5005261301994324,
0.14315098524093628,
-0.3106028437614441,
-0.2861962914466858,
-0.1670539677143097,
-0.2827778458595276,
0.32038193941116333,
0.36530041694641113,
-0.04368152841925621,
-0.4405824542045593,
0.05350629985332489,
0.13915187120437622,
0.15779012441635132,
-0.6388117074966431,
0.6721053123474121,
-0.4054480791091919,
-0.19095292687416077,
0.19834542274475098,
-0.03594803065061569,
0.4254358112812042,
-0.7046766877174377,
-0.02721690759062767,
-0.18041923642158508,
0.33374810218811035,
-0.09445881098508835,
-0.35784733295440674,
0.3984130620956421,
0.0030984815675765276,
-0.130442813038826,
0.04275692254304886,
1.0974808931350708,
-0.2908816933631897,
-0.9263067245483398,
-0.030415859073400497,
0.458924800157547,
0.30611151456832886,
0.034117650240659714,
-0.7274996638298035,
0.005171305034309626,
0.020985692739486694,
-0.47541913390159607,
0.303877592086792,
0.5413036942481995,
0.06283541023731232,
0.2285751849412918,
0.7338033318519592,
0.3904939591884613,
0.023458682000637054,
-0.2428296059370041,
0.7793524861335754,
-0.30463242530822754,
-0.7631087899208069,
-0.6347568035125732,
0.40742650628089905,
-0.40609538555145264,
-0.5292592644691467,
0.7395395636558533,
0.18093536794185638,
0.7799103856086731,
0.045495979487895966,
0.5768990516662598,
-0.05865127593278885,
0.8981735110282898,
-0.5035268664360046,
0.8662276268005371,
-0.7115201950073242,
-0.0927496924996376,
-0.4050162732601166,
-1.0294729471206665,
-0.23533134162425995,
0.4663325548171997,
-0.6847469210624695,
0.03765326738357544,
0.4275692105293274,
0.19820937514305115,
0.03794192522764206,
0.13477414846420288,
0.26699966192245483,
0.13627509772777557,
0.19380336999893188,
-0.10777004063129425,
0.46944278478622437,
-0.1281234174966812,
0.2448204606771469,
-1.1070114374160767,
-0.21099217236042023,
-0.5655173063278198,
-1.1740517616271973,
-0.7957132458686829,
-0.7972468137741089,
-0.12078588455915451,
-0.23463882505893707,
-0.16467821598052979,
1.1804977655410767,
0.5103740692138672,
-0.6811256408691406,
-0.47193393111228943,
0.21366111934185028,
0.022694284096360207,
-0.43457555770874023,
-0.26369208097457886,
0.9391855597496033,
-0.0724092423915863,
-0.6503784656524658,
-0.14331378042697906,
0.0490739531815052,
0.006462549325078726,
-0.35762467980384827,
0.41671597957611084,
-0.2688485383987427,
0.1657833755016327,
0.32259777188301086,
0.21148337423801422,
-0.31793588399887085,
-0.3268454074859619,
0.03136860579252243,
0.14242751896381378,
-0.03441954404115677,
1.0049047470092773,
-0.3277997672557831,
0.7523534297943115,
0.8839648365974426,
0.3867911994457245,
0.5664716362953186,
0.4195278286933899,
0.08155691623687744,
-0.7015823125839233,
0.20546631515026093,
0.008483084850013256,
0.32421478629112244,
-0.05492914840579033,
-0.537274956703186,
0.023635316640138626,
0.4501412510871887,
-0.9805026650428772,
-0.4631279706954956,
-0.021174196153879166,
-0.6645522117614746,
-0.2897518277168274,
0.9175336360931396,
-0.023887155577540398,
-0.5414109230041504,
-0.13192203640937805,
-0.1949162781238556,
-0.004720847122371197,
-0.751410961151123,
1.320682406425476,
0.9282642006874084,
-0.37213030457496643,
-0.09939099848270416,
-0.5512716174125671,
0.08405902236700058,
-0.05448193475604057,
-0.566814661026001,
-0.0015246151015162468,
0.33009010553359985,
-0.021994035691022873,
0.21799814701080322,
0.6195631623268127,
0.10269154608249664,
-0.0400504507124424,
0.25848403573036194,
0.1298857182264328,
-0.08390606939792633,
-0.24946828186511993,
-0.3971239924430847,
0.274848073720932,
-0.24671447277069092,
0.0028395112603902817
] |
Subsets and Splits